id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11215v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11215v1
|
MemeMQA: Multimodal Question Answering for Memes via Rationale-Based Inferencing
| 2024-05-18T07:44:41 | 2024-05-18T07:44:41 |
Siddhant Agarwal, Shivam Sharma, Preslav Nakov, Tanmoy Chakraborty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Memes have evolved as a prevalent medium for diverse communication, ranging
from humour to propaganda. With the rising popularity of image-focused content,
there is a growing need to explore its potential harm from different aspects.
Previous studies have analyzed memes in closed settings - detecting harm,
applying semantic labels, and offering natural language explanations. To extend
this research, we introduce MemeMQA, a multimodal question-answering framework
aiming to solicit accurate responses to structured questions while providing
coherent explanations. We curate MemeMQACorpus, a new dataset featuring 1,880
questions related to 1,122 memes with corresponding answer-explanation pairs.
We further propose ARSENAL, a novel two-stage multimodal framework that
leverages the reasoning capabilities of LLMs to address MemeMQA. We benchmark
MemeMQA using competitive baselines and demonstrate its superiority - ~18%
enhanced answer prediction accuracy and distinct text generation lead across
various metrics measuring lexical and semantic alignment over the best
baseline. We analyze ARSENAL's robustness through diversification of
question-set, confounder-based evaluation regarding MemeMQA's generalizability,
and modality-specific assessment, enhancing our understanding of meme
interpretation in the multimodal communication landscape.
|
[
-0.5507334470748901,
-1.0496454238891602,
0.4659775197505951,
0.34581905603408813,
-0.13547810912132263,
0.20661701261997223,
0.28430473804473877,
-0.45206418633461,
0.1178819090127945,
0.2747364342212677,
-1.2105293273925781,
-0.17874711751937866,
-0.6107009053230286,
0.16497832536697388,
-0.1409478634595871,
0.6406615972518921,
-0.22195850312709808,
0.08402272313833237,
-0.520524799823761,
-0.3593311607837677,
-0.5969186425209045,
-0.31074532866477966,
-0.5224120616912842,
0.04594440013170242,
0.7945525646209717,
0.8279537558555603,
0.7963640689849854,
0.2860538065433502,
0.47527527809143066,
0.3223854899406433,
0.22783179581165314,
0.18801091611385345,
-0.14421208202838898,
0.2474755346775055,
-0.35152536630630493,
-0.33155351877212524,
-0.10550571233034134,
0.2127503901720047,
0.21209776401519775,
0.3900749981403351,
0.23211103677749634,
0.1736273318529129,
-0.1353437602519989,
0.2890914976596832,
-0.6921313405036926,
-0.6000117659568787,
-0.612802267074585,
0.026216967031359673,
-0.03946908935904503,
-0.48541533946990967,
-0.27431944012641907,
-0.08973035216331482,
0.07175793498754501,
-0.412582129240036,
-0.26353374123573303,
0.038690291345119476,
0.6794962882995605,
0.368214875459671,
-0.754478931427002,
-0.4919470250606537,
-0.4387405216693878,
0.9284297227859497,
-0.45850038528442383,
0.2889288365840912,
0.13852491974830627,
0.5899524688720703,
-0.12121258676052094,
-0.6705499887466431,
-0.6807690262794495,
0.03138237074017525,
0.1324777454137802,
0.28997427225112915,
-0.2135678380727768,
-0.04323717951774597,
0.02329719439148903,
0.2793194353580475,
-0.9603426456451416,
-0.10095508396625519,
-0.16136381030082703,
-0.6274701356887817,
0.2599482238292694,
0.1212296411395073,
0.5598931908607483,
-0.3575756847858429,
-0.8999963998794556,
-0.20173533260822296,
-0.3966444432735443,
0.3398408889770508,
0.2642483413219452,
-0.5740428566932678,
0.07240007072687149,
0.731427788734436,
-0.24613356590270996,
0.3388829529285431,
-0.017490621656179428,
-0.2649576663970947,
-0.022477759048342705,
-0.5412423014640808,
-0.09952781349420547,
-0.23882535099983215,
0.6090058088302612,
0.6846323609352112,
0.06961503624916077,
-0.08554401993751526,
0.14803636074066162,
0.07323387265205383,
0.24935391545295715,
-0.9090708494186401,
0.06370733678340912,
0.5445643067359924,
-0.46983733773231506,
-0.1043514758348465,
-0.13763047754764557,
-0.9920819997787476,
-0.28063204884529114,
0.09632395207881927,
0.5954358577728271,
-0.4029805362224579,
-0.3354114592075348,
0.17641037702560425,
-0.3470156490802765,
0.31885942816734314,
0.3411007523536682,
-0.6383427381515503,
-0.1586875468492508,
0.29773619771003723,
0.5672091841697693,
0.17061208188533783,
-0.048762038350105286,
-0.31920814514160156,
0.2507008910179138,
-0.1539599597454071,
0.9405167102813721,
-0.6268757581710815,
0.05481337010860443,
-0.303108274936676,
0.07116058468818665,
-0.010420833714306355,
-0.44346967339515686,
0.6962996125221252,
-0.5536724328994751,
0.33902427554130554,
-0.33156925439834595,
-0.4184130132198334,
-0.5055460929870605,
0.6411479711532593,
-0.5747962594032288,
0.5083727836608887,
-0.037377823144197464,
-0.6937684416770935,
0.288333922624588,
-0.7930450439453125,
-0.10647477209568024,
-0.16156867146492004,
-0.04954948648810387,
-0.06508726626634598,
-0.18350590765476227,
0.4224863052368164,
0.7215721607208252,
-0.2605532109737396,
0.07525329291820526,
-0.4572230577468872,
0.03362288698554039,
0.6723283529281616,
-0.8896307945251465,
0.4022487998008728,
0.5846472978591919,
-0.12464777380228043,
0.1864413470029831,
-0.4101577401161194,
0.18506281077861786,
0.08262528479099274,
-0.25058045983314514,
-0.14755888283252716,
-0.06250731647014618,
-0.1163678914308548,
0.5814111232757568,
0.2882947325706482,
-0.7627753615379333,
-0.24432533979415894,
-0.03271489217877388,
0.515912652015686,
0.509490430355072,
0.12246397882699966,
0.5999208092689514,
-0.6174346804618835,
0.5452067852020264,
0.1766422837972641,
0.5383682250976562,
-0.4271356761455536,
-0.5016618967056274,
0.01597064919769764,
-0.44083577394485474,
-0.09287095069885254,
0.6146913170814514,
-1.2143670320510864,
-0.34742212295532227,
0.10601579397916794,
-0.4898875653743744,
-0.32027217745780945,
0.09696997702121735,
0.24229696393013,
0.5275750756263733,
0.4644000232219696,
-0.07140535116195679,
-0.40964916348457336,
-1.1736924648284912,
-0.2618676722049713,
0.0000234472918236861,
-0.058669667690992355,
0.5124258399009705,
0.3363029658794403,
-0.42365050315856934,
0.5429548621177673,
-0.11636578291654587,
0.19982914626598358,
-0.11654629558324814,
0.27574729919433594,
-0.009382973425090313,
0.481781542301178,
0.60189288854599,
-0.9390238523483276,
-0.09842053055763245,
-0.36946991086006165,
-0.7277790904045105,
-0.16849538683891296,
-0.46541863679885864,
-0.3171440660953522,
-0.3110716938972473,
0.42510002851486206,
-0.4196942150592804,
0.10234979540109634,
0.8555573225021362,
-0.4763970673084259,
0.7237062454223633,
0.22756245732307434,
0.6861922740936279,
-1.2207049131393433,
-0.23657889664173126,
-0.18366800248622894,
-0.26680561900138855,
-0.55894535779953,
-0.05941809341311455,
0.06594151258468628,
0.011361375451087952,
-0.696208655834198,
0.5998314619064331,
-0.11464617401361465,
0.2425963431596756,
-0.11923757940530777,
0.09807425737380981,
0.46146485209465027,
0.44141706824302673,
-0.47203928232192993,
0.8192217946052551,
0.30114972591400146,
-0.3503085970878601,
0.40529531240463257,
0.2693878710269928,
-0.15374363958835602,
0.7656821012496948,
-0.5039132237434387,
0.10652387142181396,
-0.23560680449008942,
0.17066021263599396,
-1.4446951150894165,
-0.4620356559753418,
0.5651260018348694,
-0.5919459462165833,
0.14402763545513153,
0.17357490956783295,
-0.4238244593143463,
-0.3967726528644562,
-0.5140051245689392,
1.0096074342727661,
-0.10544273257255554,
-0.5845068693161011,
0.6281158328056335,
0.21740572154521942,
-0.20163053274154663,
-0.9231928586959839,
-0.531014084815979,
0.19956199824810028,
-0.380405992269516,
-1.0400084257125854,
-0.01504585426300764,
-0.5127002000808716,
-0.3242499530315399,
-0.08434659987688065,
-0.3623524606227875,
-0.3336312174797058,
0.3182288110256195,
0.15185962617397308,
-0.06319355964660645,
-0.3229299485683441,
0.3722541034221649,
0.35695573687553406,
-0.0009198528714478016,
0.02457571215927601,
-0.05054241418838501,
0.3212495744228363,
-0.08903491497039795,
-0.5144007205963135,
-0.2431972324848175,
0.7898665070533752,
0.7228058576583862,
-0.24623817205429077,
0.43643665313720703,
0.5456003546714783,
-0.30326011776924133,
0.015687039121985435,
-0.6510843634605408,
-0.3486623764038086,
-0.49496981501579285,
0.2733788788318634,
-0.47153741121292114,
-1.0556797981262207,
0.383825421333313,
-0.3150959014892578,
0.15915733575820923,
0.36158448457717896,
0.6649603247642517,
-0.5051262974739075,
1.1744071245193481,
0.17936186492443085,
0.29315608739852905,
0.32918962836265564,
0.1243339478969574,
-0.044904958456754684,
-0.4060962498188019,
-0.44804298877716064,
-0.25256773829460144,
-0.6351075768470764,
-0.1916280835866928,
-0.6597514152526855,
0.4053497910499573,
-0.026429690420627594,
-0.010630837641656399,
0.05263514444231987,
-0.3203876316547394,
0.4766686260700226,
0.432366281747818,
0.2079581469297409,
0.19027405977249146,
-0.08662392944097519,
-0.21045953035354614,
-0.11382225155830383,
-0.6148189902305603,
-0.6682382225990295,
0.8196272850036621,
0.596071720123291,
1.088340163230896,
0.41436532139778137,
0.10135915875434875,
0.27793487906455994,
0.31470802426338196,
-0.6596119403839111,
0.257640540599823,
0.11055069416761398,
-1.1949807405471802,
-0.2486116886138916,
-0.2594744563102722,
-0.8656324744224548,
0.3289490342140198,
-0.43042564392089844,
-0.44593045115470886,
-0.002631646580994129,
0.20987336337566376,
-0.1951751708984375,
0.21548980474472046,
-0.6376661658287048,
1.054526448249817,
-0.5661269426345825,
-0.347239226102829,
-0.4029739797115326,
-0.8137189149856567,
0.4118957221508026,
0.15175017714500427,
0.3672015368938446,
-0.4284795820713043,
-0.1758688986301422,
0.6014493703842163,
-0.1201166883111,
0.567223846912384,
-0.05489407852292061,
-0.09295570105314255,
0.5667473077774048,
0.10344311594963074,
-0.09318280220031738,
0.38198035955429077,
-0.021587323397397995,
0.11655193567276001,
0.521752119064331,
-0.6779447197914124,
-0.8535909652709961,
0.6576893329620361,
-0.4386376738548279,
-0.3821186423301697,
-0.13672040402889252,
-0.926760196685791,
-0.32573169469833374,
0.03563932329416275,
0.19643934071063995,
0.7737827897071838,
-0.04236116632819176,
0.5186359286308289,
0.8175421953201294,
-0.43835580348968506,
0.47631004452705383,
0.14107634127140045,
0.12261390686035156,
-0.5098642706871033,
0.7830939292907715,
-0.18444450199604034,
0.2727823257446289,
0.42871853709220886,
0.1424717754125595,
-0.6871386766433716,
-0.3234657049179077,
-0.8937505483627319,
-0.03947358578443527,
-0.9076336026191711,
-0.2086787223815918,
-0.6047043800354004,
0.18481792509555817,
0.09692497551441193,
-0.16187205910682678,
-0.17362092435359955,
-0.421560674905777,
-0.1100212037563324,
0.006654064636677504,
0.03561143949627876,
0.4585518538951874,
0.07631076127290726,
0.2809610068798065,
-0.829045295715332,
0.2927926182746887,
0.573034405708313,
0.28095677495002747,
-0.3459935784339905,
-0.30913254618644714,
0.10678445547819138,
0.41142672300338745,
-0.5922465920448303,
-1.3458707332611084,
-0.14499197900295258,
0.23968103528022766,
0.5853782892227173,
0.5529959797859192,
0.12033497542142868,
0.4609684944152832,
-0.34813567996025085,
0.5984324812889099,
0.2965228855609894,
-0.6266161203384399,
0.30326756834983826,
-0.28110429644584656,
0.2051987648010254,
0.538724958896637,
0.43387284874916077,
-0.5584800839424133,
-0.31729453802108765,
-0.4286637604236603,
-0.4650416970252991,
0.15060405433177948,
0.16156825423240662,
0.4893559217453003,
-0.13054704666137695,
0.43089690804481506,
0.27714774012565613,
0.27501943707466125,
-0.694482684135437,
-0.12393379211425781,
-0.5278360843658447,
-0.4170069694519043,
0.054464347660541534,
-0.5282848477363586,
-0.27037280797958374,
-0.07842370122671127,
0.38922199606895447,
-0.2775162160396576,
0.29493141174316406,
0.24168148636817932,
-0.4496273398399353,
-0.16884730756282806,
0.4882478713989258,
0.7040607333183289,
0.5829671025276184,
-0.10462980717420578,
0.5196231007575989,
0.1473289132118225,
-0.3132031559944153,
0.3697872459888458,
-0.19693271815776825,
0.19793406128883362,
-0.08308228850364685,
0.09653790295124054,
0.25752517580986023,
0.1503428816795349,
-1.0995042324066162,
0.6657930612564087,
-0.19115467369556427,
-0.4900757670402527,
0.11249425262212753,
-0.20524398982524872,
0.11464150995016098,
0.6845952868461609,
0.36004966497421265,
0.10419317334890366,
0.4820103049278259,
-0.5040737986564636,
0.6396011710166931,
0.8348727822303772,
-0.36847981810569763,
-0.22967231273651123,
0.7193567156791687,
0.13012906908988953,
0.26443156599998474,
-0.03699878603219986,
0.09339892864227295,
-0.3107173442840576,
0.6672697067260742,
0.40641361474990845,
0.6195310354232788,
-0.11595762521028519,
0.43049654364585876,
0.1805262565612793,
0.5127949118614197,
0.5039189457893372,
0.5274044871330261,
-0.024715568870306015,
-0.7133370041847229,
-0.5572790503501892,
-0.4582345485687256,
-0.5702212452888489,
0.24029193818569183,
-0.2053002417087555,
-0.1477750688791275,
-0.5503418445587158,
-0.03791669383645058,
0.1780763864517212,
-0.31930309534072876,
-0.2839694619178772,
0.46113520860671997,
0.22765597701072693,
1.0648798942565918,
-0.6964837908744812,
0.1574191004037857,
0.8610372543334961,
-0.39159801602363586,
-0.6583327054977417,
0.06476276367902756,
0.11286117881536484,
-0.666598916053772,
-0.08087492734193802,
0.42630735039711,
-0.11394413560628891,
0.002088438021019101,
-1.050195574760437,
-0.7907766699790955,
1.148541808128357,
0.5082690715789795,
0.006278707645833492,
0.5040338039398193,
0.11698674410581589,
0.19028019905090332,
-0.23853810131549835,
0.4307113289833069,
0.11980188637971878,
0.4730777442455292,
0.5747209191322327,
-0.41659218072891235,
0.05142753943800926,
-0.32090499997138977,
-0.5942832827568054,
0.04593763127923012,
-0.4240977168083191,
0.7207722067832947,
-0.11479721963405609,
-0.0678248330950737,
0.12019079178571701,
0.6025883555412292,
-0.07354811578989029,
0.6663768291473389,
0.4635286331176758,
0.2530212104320526,
0.5832504630088806,
-0.0687040314078331,
0.9636936187744141,
-0.04412463307380676,
0.0033098040148615837,
0.7512790560722351,
0.4091544449329376,
0.6002558469772339,
0.6279022693634033,
0.22731941938400269,
0.6832566857337952,
0.9537981152534485,
0.17769762873649597,
0.47766903042793274,
0.060037922114133835,
-0.4441327750682831,
-0.40157797932624817,
-0.18661023676395416,
-0.1504315435886383,
0.46946582198143005,
0.3129778504371643,
-0.11416744440793991,
-0.5271105766296387,
0.3435683846473694,
0.04257935658097267,
0.021656647324562073,
-0.28330036997795105,
0.7328101992607117,
-0.09434778243303299,
-0.5738025307655334,
0.5185136198997498,
0.11190805584192276,
0.5258257985115051,
-0.490790456533432,
0.005300232209265232,
-0.15232917666435242,
0.09208715707063675,
-0.14820237457752228,
-0.9154919981956482,
0.3779263496398926,
-0.2589733600616455,
-0.38472816348075867,
-0.09635887295007706,
0.8745748400688171,
-0.44168952107429504,
-0.2174680531024933,
0.0814346894621849,
0.8707054853439331,
0.25076985359191895,
-0.32309114933013916,
-1.0065029859542847,
-0.25228527188301086,
-0.2697305381298065,
-0.08268976956605911,
0.2049008011817932,
0.5300723314285278,
-0.2995895743370056,
0.8797082901000977,
0.5366949439048767,
-0.72943115234375,
0.3796868324279785,
-0.23888859152793884,
0.789751410484314,
-0.13916566967964172,
-0.06643987447023392,
-0.9180916547775269,
0.7986540794372559,
0.0026618444826453924,
-0.23645438253879547,
0.7140836715698242,
0.2017175555229187,
0.4407462477684021,
-0.13193050026893616,
0.6877583265304565,
-0.11122029274702072,
0.2815607488155365,
-0.3854793906211853,
0.41909322142601013,
-1.0014402866363525,
-0.07833255082368851,
-0.28590384125709534,
-0.6333916783332825,
-0.14731791615486145,
0.4329749047756195,
-0.0971861407160759,
-0.18459217250347137,
0.6027451157569885,
0.932027280330658,
-0.14891910552978516,
0.12058867514133453,
0.38030150532722473,
0.10102465748786926,
0.1615351289510727,
0.6606205701828003,
1.36196768283844,
-0.3014880120754242,
0.8148885369300842,
-0.21943548321723938,
-0.44653087854385376,
-0.20215940475463867,
-0.7817718386650085,
-0.8765652179718018,
-0.47375085949897766,
-0.04482010751962662,
-0.2602878510951996,
-0.1823999583721161,
0.8736380934715271,
0.5723443627357483,
-0.8344958424568176,
0.1847463995218277,
0.45933178067207336,
0.3460080325603485,
-0.11002962291240692,
-0.1498122662305832,
-0.03310377895832062,
-0.25984424352645874,
-0.5602688193321228,
0.3533211648464203,
0.5504786372184753,
-0.015230145305395126,
-0.1997511386871338,
-0.11667107790708542,
-0.4899568259716034,
0.5253952741622925,
0.6626521944999695,
0.12398460507392883,
-0.6336846351623535,
-0.4831241965293884,
0.40945449471473694,
-0.05695786327123642,
0.03274008259177208,
0.5583329796791077,
-0.2374662458896637,
0.713918924331665,
0.3730517327785492,
0.8339649438858032,
-0.07517784088850021,
0.2655240297317505,
0.42463234066963196,
-0.8777826428413391,
0.13821493089199066,
0.21813257038593292,
0.25642845034599304,
0.2665444016456604,
-0.42807266116142273,
0.2560942471027374,
0.17419536411762238,
-0.39217743277549744,
-0.3778393566608429,
0.44230350852012634,
-0.9861454367637634,
-0.5341212749481201,
1.1538935899734497,
0.025950388982892036,
-0.037688858807086945,
-0.4461730122566223,
-0.5744304656982422,
0.07746613025665283,
-0.1672726422548294,
0.44711947441101074,
0.7987985014915466,
0.009491211734712124,
-0.47946515679359436,
-0.7590078115463257,
0.3781394958496094,
0.6274967193603516,
-0.9532420039176941,
-0.5071680545806885,
0.6885414719581604,
0.37975504994392395,
0.10322409868240356,
0.37847232818603516,
-0.0429803766310215,
0.6152319312095642,
-0.23082739114761353,
-0.06604927033185959,
0.11714381724596024,
-0.4813617765903473,
0.06825795769691467,
0.40969353914260864,
-0.1037939190864563,
-0.49536052346229553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11212v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11212v1
|
Automated Text Identification Using CNN and Training Dynamics
| 2024-05-18T07:37:17 | 2024-05-18T07:37:17 |
Claudiu Creanga, Liviu Petrisor Dinu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We used Data Maps to model and characterize the AuTexTification dataset. This
provides insights about the behaviour of individual samples during training
across epochs (training dynamics). We characterized the samples across 3
dimensions: confidence, variability and correctness. This shows the presence of
3 regions: easy-to-learn, ambiguous and hard-to-learn examples. We used a
classic CNN architecture and found out that training the model only on a subset
of ambiguous examples improves the model's out-of-distribution generalization.
|
[
-0.14861701428890228,
-1.049176812171936,
0.5794863104820251,
0.0235965084284544,
-0.3229803442955017,
0.11734353005886078,
-0.11466086655855179,
-0.657242476940155,
-0.20034460723400116,
0.4612693786621094,
-0.4720408320426941,
-0.6485709547996521,
-0.6287950277328491,
0.46026259660720825,
-0.9231264591217041,
1.1625828742980957,
-0.5180887579917908,
-0.12438514828681946,
0.08428531885147095,
-0.2445058375597,
-0.1400158554315567,
-0.488353431224823,
-0.6023967266082764,
-0.36780160665512085,
0.42862486839294434,
0.4601357579231262,
0.5591469407081604,
1.1540650129318237,
0.6857035756111145,
0.4703647792339325,
-0.2322903722524643,
0.31190282106399536,
-0.3259456157684326,
0.03170640394091606,
0.09929325431585312,
-0.3757602870464325,
0.041434936225414276,
0.3755062222480774,
0.6747520565986633,
0.44123679399490356,
-0.02100038155913353,
-0.05889143794775009,
0.021138163283467293,
0.6156587600708008,
-0.3575717508792877,
0.14115625619888306,
-0.4144548773765564,
0.3354446291923523,
-0.20749573409557343,
-0.5640652775764465,
-0.31539636850357056,
-0.2570253312587738,
0.46972328424453735,
-0.8416176438331604,
0.5498953461647034,
0.07138945907354355,
1.1922889947891235,
0.1538931131362915,
-0.8385913372039795,
-0.8149700164794922,
-1.0179798603057861,
0.7981514930725098,
-0.2502754032611847,
0.08011309057474136,
0.5043985843658447,
0.2968553900718689,
0.08078600466251373,
-0.6649082899093628,
-0.5084643363952637,
0.1442810297012329,
-0.3418036997318268,
0.14549587666988373,
0.1564330756664276,
-0.0641917809844017,
0.012389196082949638,
0.5070141553878784,
-0.3647245168685913,
0.15722359716892242,
-0.5983757376670837,
-0.23410607874393463,
0.7590610384941101,
0.13412591814994812,
0.378116637468338,
-0.025134360417723656,
-0.38352322578430176,
-0.14213794469833374,
-0.07005973905324936,
0.027174094691872597,
0.6126458048820496,
0.3450775444507599,
-0.2230530083179474,
0.5526926517486572,
-0.018658485263586044,
0.6338151693344116,
0.012544484809041023,
-0.2699085772037506,
0.6499837636947632,
-0.16370387375354767,
-0.35483479499816895,
0.06587866693735123,
1.0213737487792969,
0.03232130780816078,
0.3683808445930481,
-0.24160441756248474,
-0.36128467321395874,
-0.4930962920188904,
0.3347282409667969,
-0.5955769419670105,
0.01898355595767498,
0.13363538682460785,
-0.7391697764396667,
-0.5308452844619751,
0.25848469138145447,
-0.6790037751197815,
-0.5046955347061157,
-0.50691157579422,
0.5194970965385437,
-0.6182823777198792,
-0.10324835032224655,
0.010492810979485512,
-0.3733890950679779,
0.13573269546031952,
0.43618714809417725,
-1.0567545890808105,
0.28823837637901306,
0.2581527531147003,
0.757084310054779,
-0.44102030992507935,
-0.3181804418563843,
0.030285486951470375,
-0.07271628826856613,
-0.4137427508831024,
0.7849071025848389,
-0.5977338552474976,
-0.18535153567790985,
-0.03910151496529579,
0.19045522809028625,
-0.1552840620279312,
-0.38113924860954285,
0.4679987132549286,
-0.6355231404304504,
0.4336830973625183,
0.12656360864639282,
-0.5596809983253479,
-0.6035637259483337,
0.14305156469345093,
-1.0146247148513794,
1.152606725692749,
0.3161693811416626,
-0.8066325783729553,
0.4132586121559143,
-0.5925822854042053,
-0.27644044160842896,
-0.016790764406323433,
-0.21536453068256378,
-0.790596067905426,
0.16544736921787262,
0.2552758753299713,
0.44468891620635986,
-0.1114538386464119,
0.014760127291083336,
0.2317347675561905,
-0.51659095287323,
0.3483579456806183,
-0.820885181427002,
0.7913206219673157,
0.37281787395477295,
-0.3834746181964874,
-0.08476900309324265,
-1.0839719772338867,
-0.1439988762140274,
0.11170103400945663,
-0.5783666372299194,
-0.30143603682518005,
-0.04946955665946007,
0.4428275227546692,
-0.23261432349681854,
0.03355030342936516,
-0.3301089107990265,
0.2668224275112152,
-0.5267812013626099,
0.3645005524158478,
0.32444339990615845,
0.4671213626861572,
0.6663476228713989,
-0.17062115669250488,
0.5493051409721375,
0.43212106823921204,
-0.13555341958999634,
-0.41943246126174927,
-0.6302646994590759,
-0.7320142984390259,
-0.3358016908168793,
0.60039222240448,
1.0105448961257935,
-0.6770268678665161,
0.16511546075344086,
-0.17956285178661346,
-0.48947155475616455,
-0.2871951758861542,
0.37479010224342346,
0.17730256915092468,
0.3620959222316742,
0.354515016078949,
-0.16357927024364471,
-0.29207295179367065,
-0.8615818023681641,
-0.11424051225185394,
-0.10072031617164612,
-0.07662273943424225,
0.3201819956302643,
0.5727256536483765,
-0.25356364250183105,
1.0783429145812988,
-0.021591022610664368,
-0.3504456877708435,
-0.04155055433511734,
0.6760176420211792,
-0.05843108892440796,
0.47679799795150757,
0.6325271725654602,
-1.2802531719207764,
-0.308185875415802,
0.10634971410036087,
-0.6573424935340881,
-0.049484286457300186,
-0.5389865040779114,
0.0415034219622612,
0.20119807124137878,
0.7365528345108032,
-0.1222236230969429,
0.7896241545677185,
0.3536616265773773,
-0.1833021193742752,
-0.08524680137634277,
-0.5380666851997375,
0.2888945937156677,
-0.9981610774993896,
-0.0025585743132978678,
0.3094838559627533,
-0.1925462931394577,
-0.6502021551132202,
-0.1636050045490265,
0.20574243366718292,
-0.10079077631235123,
-0.2247239202260971,
0.2857072055339813,
-0.726193368434906,
0.2233995795249939,
-0.16236594319343567,
0.19843260943889618,
0.11870887130498886,
0.5122320055961609,
0.16771087050437927,
0.6399729251861572,
0.32664546370506287,
-0.5810281038284302,
0.39913880825042725,
0.13207806646823883,
-0.41967853903770447,
0.21379414200782776,
-0.5245977640151978,
0.13293325901031494,
-0.4347197711467743,
0.152563214302063,
-1.2114977836608887,
-0.32096102833747864,
0.2706924378871918,
-0.3658432364463806,
0.20836789906024933,
0.1299448013305664,
-0.46994081139564514,
-0.07758858054876328,
0.21371904015541077,
0.6845192909240723,
0.19824673235416412,
-0.4607917070388794,
1.0157263278961182,
0.38146722316741943,
-0.0617888867855072,
-0.4206920266151428,
-0.858331024646759,
-0.07637697458267212,
-0.48481816053390503,
0.14656926691532135,
0.524178147315979,
0.07821931689977646,
-0.20896629989147186,
-0.21583126485347748,
0.2692740857601166,
-0.6757786273956299,
0.29116904735565186,
0.37370622158050537,
0.12614606320858002,
-0.14222174882888794,
0.41864120960235596,
0.0945427268743515,
-0.1336827576160431,
-0.21648728847503662,
-0.11364636570215225,
0.12074200809001923,
-0.05862756818532944,
-0.1940486878156662,
-0.8177175521850586,
0.41786015033721924,
0.49063435196876526,
-0.2428392916917801,
0.5630735158920288,
0.8608699440956116,
-0.3768630623817444,
-0.08414100110530853,
-0.05502508953213692,
0.198821559548378,
-0.5104733109474182,
0.3226574659347534,
-0.26335424184799194,
-0.6644176840782166,
0.41259369254112244,
-0.16467902064323425,
-0.000627898785751313,
0.6636372208595276,
0.5067490935325623,
-0.13315385580062866,
1.1176490783691406,
0.9782907366752625,
-0.1643112599849701,
0.5241276621818542,
-0.2473784238100052,
0.15228043496608734,
-0.26944905519485474,
-0.3379155695438385,
-0.6627026796340942,
-0.46324607729911804,
-0.6717360615730286,
-0.10321100056171417,
0.08220148831605911,
0.1668049693107605,
-0.07787624001502991,
0.2614506781101227,
-0.7373058795928955,
0.6324135661125183,
0.6037284731864929,
0.3301877975463867,
0.1286005824804306,
0.08233972638845444,
-0.18374362587928772,
0.029561838135123253,
-0.2727760970592499,
-0.6736255288124084,
0.9020158052444458,
0.49863988161087036,
0.5026209354400635,
0.07594447582960129,
0.6090090274810791,
0.3268360495567322,
0.5428416728973389,
-0.9015379548072815,
0.19784192740917206,
0.05196922644972801,
-0.718054473400116,
-0.34180012345314026,
-0.4915798008441925,
-1.0872772932052612,
-0.264055460691452,
-0.5861163139343262,
-0.7397624254226685,
0.44750770926475525,
0.07657477259635925,
-0.44394323229789734,
0.20499511063098907,
-0.8368967175483704,
0.5879682302474976,
-0.10213976353406906,
0.29159045219421387,
0.2943381667137146,
-0.6327000260353088,
-0.023547416552901268,
-0.4485902488231659,
0.38850274682044983,
0.18022751808166504,
-0.18512339890003204,
0.735816240310669,
-0.08897960931062698,
1.0002161264419556,
0.13114392757415771,
-0.2530440390110016,
0.4857093095779419,
-0.10288722068071365,
0.26231691241264343,
-0.07190501689910889,
-0.12958496809005737,
0.11861133575439453,
-0.18491166830062866,
-0.1775159239768982,
-0.7160962224006653,
0.27447742223739624,
-1.0983753204345703,
-0.2279151827096939,
-0.30101779103279114,
-0.6951794624328613,
-0.02032341994345188,
0.34993776679039,
0.4657963216304779,
0.7937996983528137,
-0.139938086271286,
0.2248448133468628,
0.5245093107223511,
-0.3350106179714203,
0.7017870545387268,
0.4189309775829315,
-0.043430645018815994,
-0.3947995603084564,
0.8856267929077148,
-0.05363844335079193,
-0.07752139866352081,
0.5787957310676575,
0.06996563822031021,
-0.09949130564928055,
-0.7350718379020691,
-0.46663808822631836,
-0.10700653493404388,
-0.7724964618682861,
-0.0797438994050026,
-0.6442212462425232,
-0.5554937124252319,
-0.09686247259378433,
-0.039447903633117676,
0.012853201478719711,
-0.42604148387908936,
-0.8668153285980225,
-0.2353883683681488,
0.4592651426792145,
0.9845450520515442,
0.21682065725326538,
0.5998040437698364,
-0.7601345181465149,
0.4735972285270691,
0.2610800564289093,
0.21976560354232788,
-0.36272796988487244,
-0.5836214423179626,
-0.3876291513442993,
-0.1291622370481491,
-0.3199740946292877,
-1.0737963914871216,
0.49546894431114197,
0.5961185097694397,
0.4667937457561493,
0.6259100437164307,
-0.04953593388199806,
0.17023707926273346,
-0.6808814406394958,
0.7827048301696777,
-0.2876330614089966,
-0.874856173992157,
0.45831140875816345,
-0.2820768654346466,
0.16451837122440338,
0.4983329176902771,
0.5926277041435242,
-0.12968017160892487,
-0.48637521266937256,
-0.6616336703300476,
-0.783115565776825,
0.5786553025245667,
0.44040074944496155,
0.20133709907531738,
0.11812866479158401,
0.9928427338600159,
0.09072031825780869,
0.09842196851968765,
-0.7291140556335449,
-0.6037845611572266,
-0.22733642160892487,
-0.8438593149185181,
-0.3104855418205261,
-0.14797958731651306,
-0.12709984183311462,
-0.24553735554218292,
0.5181272625923157,
-0.16055408120155334,
0.310324490070343,
0.28615602850914,
-0.16422824561595917,
-0.09002619236707687,
-0.06666503101587296,
0.7140178084373474,
0.44646042585372925,
0.06147528812289238,
0.08541988581418991,
0.1716371476650238,
-0.7614315152168274,
0.43593543767929077,
0.13440285623073578,
-0.08350809663534164,
0.15534742176532745,
0.5351122617721558,
0.8535855412483215,
-0.16432063281536102,
-0.47953736782073975,
0.5977138876914978,
-0.3111284375190735,
-0.446018248796463,
-0.27245548367500305,
0.2235996574163437,
-0.40850013494491577,
0.2183516025543213,
0.5845716595649719,
0.2947971820831299,
0.3427397906780243,
-0.27123138308525085,
0.20215879380702972,
0.10848823189735413,
-0.7674694657325745,
-0.09482339769601822,
0.45249253511428833,
0.08695033937692642,
-0.7353493571281433,
0.8163278698921204,
0.0492887981235981,
-0.6226861476898193,
1.0136276483535767,
0.3829890191555023,
0.7438748478889465,
-0.14552485942840576,
0.35966283082962036,
0.25609898567199707,
0.4399164021015167,
0.06424668431282043,
0.008014434948563576,
-0.22391806542873383,
-0.9514535665512085,
0.07028227299451828,
-0.3271675407886505,
-0.33144888281822205,
0.18043792247772217,
-0.9093394875526428,
0.34005630016326904,
-0.3222636282444,
-0.14619357883930206,
0.397707462310791,
0.08161882311105728,
-0.677725076675415,
0.7453352212905884,
0.21845659613609314,
1.0181533098220825,
-1.1204687356948853,
0.763871431350708,
0.642335057258606,
-0.2000606209039688,
-0.7615327835083008,
-0.015053202398121357,
0.47247231006622314,
-0.5117325186729431,
0.675677478313446,
0.35489797592163086,
0.06500755250453949,
0.1829945594072342,
-0.7651311159133911,
-0.8410507440567017,
1.1958668231964111,
-0.07092557847499847,
-0.1818830370903015,
0.04713724926114082,
0.16198816895484924,
0.6815497279167175,
-0.5829367637634277,
0.5190137624740601,
0.5861340761184692,
0.36618223786354065,
-0.061738528311252594,
-0.6360819935798645,
-0.3716873228549957,
-0.5803568363189697,
0.03555262088775635,
0.10421675443649292,
-0.3667294681072235,
0.7034419178962708,
-0.03703681379556656,
-0.4403301477432251,
0.3748209476470947,
0.7422291040420532,
-0.20118926465511322,
0.09850390255451202,
0.7869183421134949,
0.27720874547958374,
0.925452470779419,
-0.28470706939697266,
0.898555338382721,
-0.36838969588279724,
0.43464627861976624,
0.9026968479156494,
0.2124989628791809,
0.6005128026008606,
0.19942057132720947,
0.34271863102912903,
0.7269390225410461,
0.9938244819641113,
-0.18687234818935394,
0.5129522085189819,
0.025830542668700218,
-0.16490919888019562,
-0.05693526938557625,
0.2452222853899002,
-0.03470548242330551,
0.6420745849609375,
0.5468602776527405,
-0.7629126310348511,
-0.20774421095848083,
0.320435106754303,
-0.21215765178203583,
0.016849836334586143,
0.02310045063495636,
0.985398530960083,
-0.294890433549881,
-0.3547610640525818,
0.18056520819664001,
0.320295512676239,
0.2735574245452881,
-0.5091829299926758,
-0.11518318951129913,
-0.03486489877104759,
0.1590501219034195,
-0.03804691880941391,
-0.6941487193107605,
0.1607227921485901,
-0.13371333479881287,
-0.3146972358226776,
-0.39542365074157715,
0.4571453034877777,
-0.6263430118560791,
-0.5633726716041565,
-0.04433131963014603,
0.1997719407081604,
0.17144553363323212,
0.32608968019485474,
-0.7613410353660583,
0.05662257969379425,
-0.04061923176050186,
-0.48650163412094116,
-0.15896400809288025,
1.108193278312683,
-0.09414488077163696,
0.6197726130485535,
0.19815634191036224,
-0.1369742900133133,
-0.18158134818077087,
0.03638194128870964,
0.5343160629272461,
-0.663219690322876,
-0.44258981943130493,
-0.9223638772964478,
0.31759580969810486,
-0.20481722056865692,
-0.688193678855896,
0.7572475075721741,
0.5678484439849854,
0.45743298530578613,
0.1386621743440628,
0.6703125834465027,
0.30940115451812744,
0.5722788572311401,
-0.4574073255062103,
0.8356071710586548,
-0.6559576988220215,
0.1931447684764862,
-0.4718305468559265,
-0.6404479742050171,
-0.4975084066390991,
0.7114899754524231,
0.0005935297813266516,
0.19187197089195251,
0.7979609370231628,
0.6210784316062927,
-0.1034775823354721,
0.27612441778182983,
0.02966536208987236,
0.08852972090244293,
0.11211860179901123,
0.11207572370767593,
0.6355118751525879,
-0.7617019414901733,
0.5247430801391602,
-0.2873600125312805,
-0.31286588311195374,
-0.049740154296159744,
-0.9887416958808899,
-0.9546059966087341,
-0.974463164806366,
-0.45838505029678345,
-0.22561001777648926,
-0.3076459765434265,
0.6479629874229431,
0.8112929463386536,
-0.8948009014129639,
0.09504639357328415,
-0.2046242356300354,
0.02827274426817894,
-0.25050991773605347,
-0.23815050721168518,
0.4755901098251343,
-0.23837685585021973,
-0.9563549160957336,
0.17349135875701904,
0.1924404501914978,
0.6669214963912964,
-0.19136998057365417,
0.36290091276168823,
-0.0911005437374115,
0.3472922444343567,
0.09096892923116684,
0.2905118763446808,
-0.30621588230133057,
-0.420876145362854,
-0.28267014026641846,
-0.44318145513534546,
0.17093248665332794,
0.8476712703704834,
-0.7948809862136841,
0.43272435665130615,
0.3427385091781616,
0.769197404384613,
0.29314109683036804,
0.2655026912689209,
0.5568198561668396,
-0.8591124415397644,
0.4465982913970947,
-0.04558537155389786,
0.13226771354675293,
0.40357348322868347,
-0.6893458962440491,
0.2328934371471405,
0.1573226898908615,
-0.6024351716041565,
-0.5536739230155945,
-0.05597834289073944,
-0.8249325156211853,
-0.1891457438468933,
0.960571825504303,
-0.12570030987262726,
-0.5572498440742493,
-0.43658775091171265,
-0.29560616612434387,
0.26989874243736267,
0.0216758344322443,
0.8770448565483093,
0.7940658330917358,
0.21946297585964203,
-0.40432208776474,
-0.43530961871147156,
0.6796056628227234,
-0.04548186436295509,
-0.7861913442611694,
-0.3329463303089142,
0.22730648517608643,
0.14022807776927948,
0.3996584117412567,
0.46779507398605347,
-0.06162140145897865,
-0.09015045315027237,
-0.046854905784130096,
-0.17711251974105835,
0.1751958578824997,
-0.5307549238204956,
-0.4409042000770569,
0.2531507611274719,
-0.5235599875450134,
-0.175774484872818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11200v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11200v1
|
LexGen: Domain-aware Multilingual Lexicon Generation
| 2024-05-18T07:02:43 | 2024-05-18T07:02:43 |
Karthika NJ, Ayush Maheshwari, Atul Kumar Singh, Preethi Jyothi, Ganesh Ramakrishnan, Krishnakant Bhatt
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Lexicon or dictionary generation across domains is of significant societal
importance, as it can potentially enhance information accessibility for a
diverse user base while preserving language identity. Prior work in the field
primarily focuses on bilingual lexical induction, which deals with word
alignments using mapping-based or corpora-based approaches. Though initiated by
researchers, the research associated with lexicon generation is limited, even
more so with domain-specific lexicons. This task becomes particularly important
in atypical medical, engineering, and other technical domains, owing to the
highly infrequent usage of the terms and negligibly low data availability of
technical terms in many low-resource languages. Owing to the research gap in
lexicon generation, especially with a limited focus on the domain-specific
area, we propose a new model to generate dictionary words for 6 Indian
languages in the multi-domain setting. Our model consists of domain-specific
and domain-generic layers that encode information, and these layers are invoked
via a learnable routing technique. Further, we propose an approach to
explicitly leverage the relatedness between these Indian languages toward
coherent translation. We also release a new benchmark dataset across 6 Indian
languages that span 8 diverse domains that can propel further research in
domain-specific lexicon induction. We conduct both zero-shot and few-shot
experiments across multiple domains to show the efficacy of our proposed model
in generalizing to unseen domains and unseen languages.
|
[
-0.47349175810813904,
-0.4758153259754181,
0.35623660683631897,
0.132482647895813,
-0.10996741056442261,
0.2508469521999359,
-0.31361961364746094,
-0.40689367055892944,
0.20728354156017303,
0.08635425567626953,
-0.6135098934173584,
-0.4360179901123047,
-0.3516562581062317,
0.2704169750213623,
-0.4210129678249359,
0.7308611869812012,
-0.0060616545379161835,
-0.12713412940502167,
-0.156328484416008,
-0.2558577060699463,
-0.4033719599246979,
-0.6650044918060303,
-0.4398106038570404,
-0.2501075267791748,
0.23468713462352753,
0.2506721615791321,
0.7843846678733826,
0.5897268652915955,
0.15576623380184174,
0.2881477177143097,
-0.08817646652460098,
0.5568476319313049,
-0.1521073430776596,
0.22032085061073303,
-0.3137446939945221,
-0.08886879682540894,
-0.40028879046440125,
-0.5069102644920349,
0.7015938758850098,
0.9873340725898743,
-0.2960508465766907,
-0.10715405642986298,
0.002305278554558754,
0.3335624635219574,
-0.6868653893470764,
-0.18757645785808563,
-0.9607576131820679,
-0.26137351989746094,
-0.5353894233703613,
0.007774081081151962,
-0.15021269023418427,
-0.1383020430803299,
-0.22911743819713593,
-0.8274320363998413,
0.6897599697113037,
0.0681542381644249,
0.8327579498291016,
-0.21422617137432098,
-0.10601701587438583,
-0.3529839813709259,
-0.6077860593795776,
0.6642323136329651,
-0.5424830317497253,
0.5932417511940002,
0.026235561817884445,
0.2991481423377991,
0.06360558420419693,
-0.7969933748245239,
-0.6182969808578491,
0.25492793321609497,
0.30263352394104004,
0.26803991198539734,
0.2675105035305023,
-0.19046366214752197,
0.07493415474891663,
0.29045557975769043,
-0.5133625864982605,
-0.19163161516189575,
-0.24185048043727875,
-0.1595238894224167,
0.42347821593284607,
0.203986257314682,
0.5510831475257874,
-0.32125863432884216,
-0.43811026215553284,
-0.08900821208953857,
-0.9272693991661072,
-0.33302342891693115,
0.4301731288433075,
0.8227847218513489,
-0.1465986669063568,
0.44417551159858704,
-0.24060364067554474,
0.7669897675514221,
-0.11136534065008163,
-0.06532251089811325,
0.5034703612327576,
-0.9573108553886414,
0.04946018382906914,
0.2991853356361389,
0.5943668484687805,
-0.009731086902320385,
0.33460360765457153,
-0.2618802487850189,
-0.2767183780670166,
0.18687860667705536,
0.22691400349140167,
-0.7143139839172363,
0.2231360524892807,
0.1294744312763214,
-0.33127012848854065,
-0.14986830949783325,
-0.11327704787254333,
-0.9131371378898621,
-0.402773380279541,
-0.14798900485038757,
0.11397399753332138,
-0.7247000336647034,
-0.8308364152908325,
0.167671337723732,
-0.1876724660396576,
0.17481106519699097,
-0.15351100265979767,
-1.195449948310852,
0.36059072613716125,
0.5867857336997986,
0.900588870048523,
-0.3391309082508087,
-0.49944034218788147,
-0.20735745131969452,
0.2705133855342865,
-0.43809229135513306,
0.7230110764503479,
-0.6761747002601624,
-0.7099130749702454,
0.6817243695259094,
-0.16186709702014923,
-0.23904836177825928,
-0.6058794856071472,
0.42203226685523987,
-0.48722919821739197,
-0.22007590532302856,
-0.14664188027381897,
-0.6461901664733887,
0.12238985300064087,
0.08246053010225296,
-0.37835514545440674,
0.7087982296943665,
0.09940706938505173,
-0.8316560387611389,
0.48318997025489807,
-0.47237277030944824,
-0.6428401470184326,
0.4244615137577057,
-0.45190370082855225,
-0.20390832424163818,
0.3490159809589386,
0.1289139986038208,
0.26209989190101624,
-0.37965553998947144,
0.3188244104385376,
-0.15461964905261993,
0.15805697441101074,
-0.12521985173225403,
-0.09315277636051178,
0.7061097025871277,
0.4120214879512787,
-0.2607876658439636,
-0.05784311890602112,
-0.8224412798881531,
0.1575607806444168,
0.23065431416034698,
-0.07318870723247528,
-0.6458849310874939,
-0.01953881047666073,
0.17489995062351227,
0.23985826969146729,
0.13541430234909058,
-0.8085729479789734,
-0.03519820049405098,
-0.6611353158950806,
0.17796756327152252,
0.3646913468837738,
0.09682624042034149,
0.5453683733940125,
-0.24008482694625854,
0.47542673349380493,
0.19480592012405396,
0.09901244193315506,
-0.07113393396139145,
-0.6180692315101624,
-0.5590500831604004,
-0.055587466806173325,
0.40808066725730896,
0.3459165692329407,
-1.0200438499450684,
0.009095786139369011,
-0.5326768159866333,
-0.35997825860977173,
-0.375949501991272,
0.33849993348121643,
0.472322553396225,
0.5218246579170227,
0.3234013617038727,
-0.2504483163356781,
-0.2936954200267792,
-0.6861444115638733,
-0.21423688530921936,
0.09446132928133011,
0.33190402388572693,
0.11145210266113281,
0.1116531640291214,
-0.34170085191726685,
0.7379211783409119,
-0.46133702993392944,
-0.18189473450183868,
-0.5183773040771484,
0.1203572228550911,
-0.14438895881175995,
0.32726484537124634,
0.456367552280426,
-0.8838131427764893,
-0.5782893300056458,
0.07994315773248672,
-0.739474356174469,
-0.10516681522130966,
-0.14154379069805145,
-0.37041452527046204,
0.24024318158626556,
0.6314689517021179,
-0.40938302874565125,
0.2262139618396759,
0.5541131496429443,
-0.2012101709842682,
0.340292364358902,
-0.23532313108444214,
-0.1385360211133957,
-1.4429066181182861,
-0.02366916462779045,
-0.1574186235666275,
-0.05707203596830368,
-0.8369578123092651,
0.17444643378257751,
0.3392294943332672,
-0.3761484920978546,
-0.6373338103294373,
0.7321228384971619,
-0.46442243456840515,
0.1311556100845337,
-0.25049665570259094,
0.30019450187683105,
-0.11740750819444656,
0.3271724581718445,
0.29775047302246094,
0.9321846961975098,
0.7529396414756775,
-0.8233774304389954,
0.007922696880996227,
0.49538350105285645,
-0.2960920035839081,
0.40070733428001404,
-0.3494867980480194,
-0.3328312933444977,
0.08512753993272781,
-0.41364794969558716,
-0.6055852174758911,
-0.2438536137342453,
-0.17875327169895172,
-0.5569548606872559,
0.36755862832069397,
0.2954160273075104,
-0.5583063364028931,
0.011197849176824093,
-0.08395679295063019,
0.7112875580787659,
0.5441280007362366,
-0.7235772609710693,
0.5790895819664001,
0.45688241720199585,
-0.23542290925979614,
-0.2679760754108429,
-0.6302167773246765,
0.05011139437556267,
-0.03014020249247551,
-0.796716034412384,
0.6103384494781494,
-0.215239480137825,
-0.3679755926132202,
-0.01232787687331438,
0.038474131375551224,
-0.04968436807394028,
-0.15979234874248505,
0.30018720030784607,
0.20483402907848358,
-0.07859189063310623,
0.3370763957500458,
0.2580019533634186,
0.1794508397579193,
-0.18450547754764557,
-0.2132803499698639,
0.5636041760444641,
-0.08511880785226822,
-0.4079347550868988,
0.014282245188951492,
0.7169548869132996,
0.41675901412963867,
-0.4403121769428253,
0.7551115155220032,
0.5736538171768188,
-0.5694935321807861,
-0.6218665242195129,
-0.26980289816856384,
-0.008479327894747257,
-0.4834868907928467,
0.16943439841270447,
-0.6734153628349304,
-0.5499883890151978,
0.5579121708869934,
-0.5971952676773071,
0.0008326125680468976,
0.7199723124504089,
0.8626222014427185,
0.593734085559845,
0.9927369952201843,
0.7848333716392517,
0.22799305617809296,
0.11882064491510391,
0.012650891207158566,
0.5045235753059387,
-0.7303531169891357,
-0.1714628040790558,
-0.36789852380752563,
0.4215225279331207,
-0.6668105125427246,
-0.17093738913536072,
0.3662431538105011,
-0.0712386816740036,
0.09329615533351898,
0.36204472184181213,
-0.4896547496318817,
0.0520373098552227,
0.5486615896224976,
-0.27504557371139526,
0.1585366576910019,
0.2856813073158264,
-0.8605626821517944,
0.12234780937433243,
-0.9868044853210449,
-0.09183456003665924,
1.0655354261398315,
-0.1390785425901413,
0.6092000007629395,
0.26607534289360046,
0.908301591873169,
0.12975524365901947,
0.044769689440727234,
-0.5354548096656799,
0.30039501190185547,
-0.33029067516326904,
-0.8421004414558411,
-0.12691731750965118,
-0.22128717601299286,
-0.768738329410553,
-0.11303949356079102,
-0.24428176879882812,
-0.018227940425276756,
0.2733055651187897,
-0.04225994274020195,
-0.5573767423629761,
0.36106938123703003,
-0.6787164211273193,
0.5457078814506531,
-0.22473400831222534,
-0.4802829921245575,
-0.06081264838576317,
-0.4927685856819153,
0.4322143495082855,
-0.4782200753688812,
0.6211259961128235,
-0.150239497423172,
-0.031173724681138992,
0.41773778200149536,
-0.6761021614074707,
0.6036880612373352,
-0.1857779175043106,
-0.14088907837867737,
0.4460606873035431,
0.12035515159368515,
-0.07967928051948547,
0.17648665606975555,
-0.06468204408884048,
0.39951053261756897,
-0.11602915078401566,
-0.22400379180908203,
-0.046508051455020905,
0.8867731690406799,
-0.7056365609169006,
-0.2949041724205017,
-0.30971959233283997,
-0.5821118354797363,
-0.5976959466934204,
0.33337080478668213,
0.5246769785881042,
0.7438638806343079,
-0.1963377743959427,
-0.3140510618686676,
0.7080429196357727,
-0.4859403371810913,
0.5463807582855225,
0.3158128261566162,
-0.10470689088106155,
-0.31026691198349,
1.2090022563934326,
-0.08200044184923172,
0.43464866280555725,
0.23669764399528503,
0.002695293864235282,
-0.23406469821929932,
-0.4105699956417084,
-0.6490877866744995,
0.4103970527648926,
-0.6598575115203857,
-0.4479692280292511,
-0.32413578033447266,
-0.6341612935066223,
-0.7608966827392578,
-0.3993043601512909,
-0.5584719181060791,
-0.3585326671600342,
-0.05587663874030113,
0.16468445956707,
0.07200199365615845,
0.7372174263000488,
-0.35247302055358887,
0.32957181334495544,
-0.7731077075004578,
0.6408459544181824,
0.4033816456794739,
0.4757746756076813,
-0.08488509804010391,
-0.2956447899341583,
-0.2595509886741638,
-0.0570986345410347,
-0.1831797957420349,
-0.5386109352111816,
0.605484664440155,
0.7080573439598083,
0.5709279775619507,
0.35311251878738403,
-0.1529126614332199,
0.5100773572921753,
-1.037489891052246,
0.9726690053939819,
0.4801492691040039,
-0.9851517081260681,
0.5505248308181763,
-0.19835060834884644,
0.4216618835926056,
0.39658570289611816,
0.3959490656852722,
-0.6117134690284729,
-0.41668805480003357,
-0.6549352407455444,
-0.9180546998977661,
0.2960033118724823,
0.17119309306144714,
0.36445799469947815,
-0.4282327890396118,
0.3456597328186035,
0.39252611994743347,
0.07330217212438583,
-0.1235160306096077,
-0.24321629106998444,
-0.4205547571182251,
-0.20448601245880127,
0.07910847663879395,
-0.20676545798778534,
-0.13443566858768463,
-0.04361841455101967,
0.7630316019058228,
-0.04424576833844185,
0.2314346730709076,
0.2850992679595947,
-0.10088697075843811,
0.00945714395493269,
0.2262008786201477,
0.7792434096336365,
0.7838625907897949,
0.04636409133672714,
0.29067519307136536,
-0.0061361161060631275,
-0.4641057550907135,
-0.009987416677176952,
0.1439102739095688,
-0.09930375218391418,
0.4911767542362213,
0.18435989320278168,
0.6107014417648315,
-0.08180626481771469,
-0.6370987892150879,
0.6429747939109802,
-0.20572178065776825,
-0.54630446434021,
-0.39185065031051636,
-0.03588605672121048,
0.07913274317979813,
-0.08671803027391434,
0.06360429525375366,
0.14818808436393738,
-0.10341035574674606,
-0.22751009464263916,
0.34173423051834106,
0.46473297476768494,
-0.04343210533261299,
-0.3497072160243988,
1.0608247518539429,
0.31915155053138733,
-0.05922982096672058,
0.5173649191856384,
-0.44268283247947693,
-0.29429033398628235,
0.3899546265602112,
0.6933514475822449,
0.8186647891998291,
-0.38436082005500793,
0.05350898578763008,
0.6695419549942017,
0.026338906958699226,
-0.05951711907982826,
0.37368661165237427,
0.027152782306075096,
-1.141131043434143,
-0.08277007937431335,
-0.9653887748718262,
-0.17805013060569763,
-0.024188179522752762,
-0.41308367252349854,
0.21523834764957428,
-0.30636361241340637,
-0.32206353545188904,
0.012499119155108929,
-0.27625614404678345,
-0.604134738445282,
0.1284569948911667,
0.5915942192077637,
1.060563325881958,
-0.8792771697044373,
1.0278141498565674,
0.5461660623550415,
-0.49188143014907837,
-0.6352531909942627,
-0.1986367404460907,
-0.060946885496377945,
-1.0833477973937988,
0.6710222363471985,
-0.19067038595676422,
-0.4280487895011902,
-0.02396279014647007,
-0.25361114740371704,
-0.8656608462333679,
0.9025221467018127,
-0.09901998192071915,
-0.4829355478286743,
-0.04085656255483627,
0.40645214915275574,
0.4305385649204254,
-0.49339258670806885,
-0.39520975947380066,
0.30108943581581116,
0.17200832068920135,
-0.003930097911506891,
-0.6832827925682068,
-0.026925062760710716,
-0.4475521743297577,
0.537234902381897,
0.1671319305896759,
-0.4782241880893707,
0.8404329419136047,
0.003823054488748312,
-0.3770638406276703,
0.14092963933944702,
0.619996964931488,
0.279323935508728,
-0.12088003754615784,
0.45493146777153015,
0.4820025563240051,
0.5620681047439575,
0.1771596223115921,
1.1162774562835693,
-1.047401785850525,
-0.027886293828487396,
0.9683941006660461,
-0.5164122581481934,
0.6644108891487122,
0.37185025215148926,
0.2981802225112915,
0.5018325448036194,
0.4341086745262146,
0.219605952501297,
0.768247127532959,
0.10333816707134247,
-0.6635594964027405,
-0.34443944692611694,
-0.48720842599868774,
-0.5375707745552063,
0.4238344132900238,
0.8013551235198975,
-0.34466198086738586,
-0.3565467894077301,
0.07359042018651962,
0.0402817539870739,
0.3163503408432007,
-0.4248257577419281,
0.5374682545661926,
0.00875631719827652,
-0.724963366985321,
0.7916515469551086,
0.218602254986763,
0.7326407432556152,
-0.8821877837181091,
0.08953139185905457,
-0.33984553813934326,
0.20619983971118927,
-0.12450481951236725,
-0.3307661712169647,
0.37369850277900696,
0.10396144539117813,
0.007869544439017773,
-0.3560639023780823,
0.9110892415046692,
-0.5709115862846375,
-0.611312210559845,
0.42554906010627747,
1.025473713874817,
-0.05811135470867157,
0.14219540357589722,
-0.520759105682373,
0.14988698065280914,
-0.17218813300132751,
0.1383177638053894,
0.27139347791671753,
0.38754889369010925,
0.009112454019486904,
0.2956556975841522,
0.3544785976409912,
0.4946618974208832,
0.5528664588928223,
0.49792686104774475,
0.6902459859848022,
-0.4054202437400818,
-0.14447058737277985,
-0.47073259949684143,
0.15908874571323395,
-0.10771637409925461,
-0.44431400299072266,
0.6761520504951477,
0.6100767850875854,
0.9850070476531982,
-0.11003842949867249,
1.1649354696273804,
-0.17478503286838531,
0.6380813717842102,
-0.30554214119911194,
0.7042439579963684,
-0.8583735227584839,
-0.123759925365448,
0.16756680607795715,
-0.6774771809577942,
-0.4161766469478607,
0.11999060958623886,
0.28391870856285095,
0.018869753926992416,
0.9316396117210388,
0.7375292778015137,
-0.07428726553916931,
-0.10774625092744827,
0.4499151408672333,
-0.16014474630355835,
0.16871148347854614,
0.4039989113807678,
0.4395318925380707,
-0.398247629404068,
0.4588070809841156,
-0.4578510522842407,
-0.12542948126792908,
0.20600385963916779,
-0.5712989568710327,
-0.7786425948143005,
-0.9424968361854553,
-0.1397077590227127,
-0.23778760433197021,
-0.0370878241956234,
0.5912142395973206,
0.6632432341575623,
-0.8308773040771484,
-0.4304242432117462,
-0.4807189702987671,
-0.10081273317337036,
-0.1314384490251541,
-0.17881666123867035,
0.3288632333278656,
-1.0399540662765503,
-0.8317738771438599,
0.38607802987098694,
0.178694948554039,
-0.10690756887197495,
-0.1963309645652771,
0.08884578943252563,
-0.4241497218608856,
0.2732008397579193,
0.6613116264343262,
0.3335708677768707,
-0.40685200691223145,
-0.0673285648226738,
-0.02442205883562565,
-0.2107260823249817,
0.009914284572005272,
0.9110707640647888,
-0.6344856023788452,
0.6599567532539368,
0.43445372581481934,
0.9177149534225464,
0.04153202101588249,
-0.08803796023130417,
0.5153891444206238,
-1.0236834287643433,
0.15257520973682404,
-0.08606011420488358,
0.46196305751800537,
0.5908559560775757,
-0.2243540734052658,
0.4639858305454254,
0.5267123579978943,
-0.3470778167247772,
-0.39836621284484863,
0.4028138518333435,
-0.7224367260932922,
-0.5242383480072021,
1.4670135974884033,
0.2972642481327057,
-0.27037209272384644,
-0.10967756807804108,
0.21013370156288147,
0.47206249833106995,
-0.11753527820110321,
0.4879094064235687,
0.4798203408718109,
-0.1322164535522461,
0.36424851417541504,
-0.5033159852027893,
0.9162977933883667,
0.3804331123828888,
-0.8096705079078674,
0.1805364489555359,
0.3369934856891632,
0.20203906297683716,
0.46877384185791016,
0.5618345141410828,
-0.2504834234714508,
-0.01236817054450512,
0.3437756896018982,
0.46984732151031494,
0.030720146372914314,
-0.41703280806541443,
-0.266970694065094,
0.3081054389476776,
0.13775058090686798,
-0.2772183418273926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11197v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11197v1
|
Designing NLP Systems That Adapt to Diverse Worldviews
| 2024-05-18T06:48:09 | 2024-05-18T06:48:09 |
Claudiu Creanga, Liviu P. Dinu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Natural Language Inference (NLI) is foundational for evaluating language
understanding in AI. However, progress has plateaued, with models failing on
ambiguous examples and exhibiting poor generalization. We argue that this stems
from disregarding the subjective nature of meaning, which is intrinsically tied
to an individual's \textit{weltanschauung} (which roughly translates to
worldview). Existing NLP datasets often obscure this by aggregating labels or
filtering out disagreement. We propose a perspectivist approach: building
datasets that capture annotator demographics, values, and justifications for
their labels. Such datasets would explicitly model diverse worldviews. Our
initial experiments with a subset of the SBIC dataset demonstrate that even
limited annotator metadata can improve model performance.
|
[
-0.49991628527641296,
-0.37125977873802185,
0.25393036007881165,
0.28422093391418457,
-0.13902920484542847,
-0.016875792294740677,
-0.3034411370754242,
-0.615949809551239,
0.0263934675604105,
0.47184106707572937,
-0.5654492974281311,
-0.44507843255996704,
-0.7794060111045837,
0.203402578830719,
-0.07824545353651047,
1.2827048301696777,
0.24977944791316986,
-0.27721258997917175,
-0.012433190830051899,
-0.46451568603515625,
-0.16049887239933014,
-0.335769921541214,
-0.41056784987449646,
-0.6468607187271118,
0.42872166633605957,
0.25933369994163513,
0.8587206602096558,
0.30879440903663635,
0.39173996448516846,
0.2347773313522339,
-0.2352922558784485,
0.18485330045223236,
-0.18541719019412994,
0.2706092894077301,
-0.35009443759918213,
-0.6432235836982727,
0.018959520384669304,
-0.05735477805137634,
0.4289480149745941,
1.2343745231628418,
0.11406474560499191,
0.23009614646434784,
-0.07001391053199768,
0.4868532717227936,
-0.690918505191803,
0.10934785008430481,
-0.7422401905059814,
0.513832688331604,
0.09299952536821365,
0.22434818744659424,
-0.45955488085746765,
-0.10496223717927933,
0.5778531432151794,
-0.8944674730300903,
0.21317604184150696,
0.025259969756007195,
0.9486744403839111,
0.7019565105438232,
-0.3916740119457245,
-0.17726582288742065,
-0.9901751279830933,
0.9433189034461975,
-0.8164575695991516,
0.3170575499534607,
0.37566128373146057,
0.24328500032424927,
0.008223193697631359,
-0.364106684923172,
-0.5277158617973328,
0.06600704044103622,
-0.10656985640525818,
0.11476291716098785,
-0.21773609519004822,
-0.05782072991132736,
0.2687159776687622,
0.2107391506433487,
-0.39969971776008606,
0.29486557841300964,
-0.2105226069688797,
0.0033727309200912714,
0.7158206701278687,
0.06372403353452682,
0.3334196209907532,
-0.2364589273929596,
-0.2155570536851883,
0.10916992276906967,
-0.3848434090614319,
-0.07937348634004593,
0.4741089344024658,
0.4689181447029114,
-0.13412204384803772,
0.33505865931510925,
-0.22098104655742645,
0.8824906349182129,
0.04173425957560539,
-0.11245009303092957,
0.28768303990364075,
-0.2480783462524414,
-0.40974146127700806,
-0.19344410300254822,
0.6594517230987549,
0.282879501581192,
0.44196808338165283,
-0.47556155920028687,
-0.011870897375047207,
0.19332921504974365,
0.35056182742118835,
-0.37116730213165283,
-0.17780889570713043,
0.2912391722202301,
-0.32914215326309204,
-0.14470796287059784,
0.18810974061489105,
-0.6739066243171692,
-0.5375691652297974,
-0.4340444505214691,
0.038248348981142044,
-0.43496468663215637,
-0.36995062232017517,
-0.07067283242940903,
-0.3553912937641144,
0.21418580412864685,
0.3285731077194214,
-1.1919608116149902,
0.23224730789661407,
0.733582079410553,
0.6109834909439087,
0.05608071759343147,
-0.3888355493545532,
0.05882931873202324,
0.14125382900238037,
-0.35389024019241333,
0.8112548589706421,
-0.7190393805503845,
-0.1484001874923706,
-0.220838263630867,
-0.36377471685409546,
0.11309702694416046,
-0.4919918179512024,
0.5112069249153137,
-0.31282150745391846,
0.2847394049167633,
-0.34677547216415405,
-0.4254872500896454,
-0.11063449084758759,
0.18078018724918365,
-0.5494309067726135,
0.7523970007896423,
-0.09082424640655518,
-1.0737006664276123,
0.8538928031921387,
-0.7875136733055115,
-0.26716649532318115,
0.22962430119514465,
-0.24067048728466034,
-0.14463217556476593,
0.46118786931037903,
0.3387579619884491,
0.33657681941986084,
-0.06307966262102127,
0.8256437182426453,
-0.2038612961769104,
-0.5251246690750122,
0.20214596390724182,
-0.42298126220703125,
0.7953264713287354,
0.2996304929256439,
-0.204429492354393,
0.030920615419745445,
-0.8873193860054016,
-0.3275337815284729,
-0.1355448216199875,
-0.23916074633598328,
-0.7181905508041382,
0.319649875164032,
0.25579771399497986,
0.09370174258947372,
-0.1584755927324295,
-0.6045711040496826,
0.09364065527915955,
-0.6220940351486206,
0.3166828453540802,
0.8728711009025574,
-0.2111133337020874,
0.6245759725570679,
-0.11326956003904343,
0.37046846747398376,
0.004536445718258619,
-0.026817860081791878,
0.09171352535486221,
-0.5800434947013855,
-0.7716630697250366,
-0.19768325984477997,
0.1749933511018753,
0.5382127165794373,
-0.719777524471283,
0.6236770749092102,
-0.37448766827583313,
-0.3746676743030548,
-0.5770136713981628,
0.06993208080530167,
0.09561377763748169,
0.33989933133125305,
0.19403399527072906,
-0.27089691162109375,
-0.7997527718544006,
-1.07461416721344,
-0.5692312717437744,
-0.3427560329437256,
-0.5255668759346008,
0.28642913699150085,
0.5153374671936035,
-0.18849816918373108,
1.1974639892578125,
-0.2994651794433594,
-0.005438821855932474,
-0.34848639369010925,
0.2065683901309967,
0.3936282992362976,
0.3313146233558655,
0.4554291069507599,
-1.1683526039123535,
-0.20053115487098694,
0.03951319307088852,
-1.044837474822998,
-0.20222115516662598,
-0.37296047806739807,
-0.010655095800757408,
-0.06416814774274826,
0.00020486382709350437,
-0.29272791743278503,
0.5084213018417358,
0.5823156833648682,
-0.5575228929519653,
0.1797470897436142,
0.08612264692783356,
-0.16507555544376373,
-0.9648374319076538,
0.07480736076831818,
0.39692047238349915,
0.054327789694070816,
-0.707202136516571,
0.12131620943546295,
-0.56199711561203,
0.04408556595444679,
-0.22724325954914093,
0.5545220375061035,
-0.13126571476459503,
-0.09889323264360428,
-0.19212676584720612,
0.27288031578063965,
0.007045745849609375,
0.28800660371780396,
0.1606198251247406,
0.48427614569664,
0.1908971071243286,
-0.5669006109237671,
0.21355868875980377,
0.417134165763855,
-0.19668257236480713,
0.7131412029266357,
-0.5878498554229736,
-0.09227012097835541,
-0.5746422410011292,
0.42312124371528625,
-0.8274604082107544,
-0.4343529939651489,
0.25753816962242126,
-0.3458699584007263,
-0.07311838120222092,
-0.2681271731853485,
-0.19991004467010498,
-0.09899688512086868,
0.013806072995066643,
0.14677377045154572,
0.1111336275935173,
-0.5807821750640869,
0.8692243099212646,
0.4028305411338806,
0.02905525639653206,
-0.7837748527526855,
-1.0502800941467285,
0.41344720125198364,
-0.3511545956134796,
-0.4246518015861511,
0.3415476679801941,
0.18321068584918976,
-0.7000404000282288,
0.007584061473608017,
-0.17748549580574036,
-0.3104120194911957,
0.27261656522750854,
0.5201563835144043,
0.20617815852165222,
-0.28039002418518066,
0.30811190605163574,
0.08156143128871918,
-0.10711588710546494,
-0.06642570346593857,
-0.5006463527679443,
0.29512789845466614,
-0.2257845550775528,
-0.2506425380706787,
-0.4000183939933777,
0.3561653792858124,
0.26145631074905396,
-0.16209381818771362,
0.8717833757400513,
0.5547026991844177,
-0.3953438401222229,
-0.22216688096523285,
-0.5494070649147034,
0.14966623485088348,
-0.3768400549888611,
0.3860189914703369,
-0.4649762213230133,
-0.9399592876434326,
0.4456616938114166,
0.09359321743249893,
0.41774505376815796,
0.3490404188632965,
0.4016580879688263,
-0.01992521621286869,
0.5447888970375061,
0.7283666133880615,
-0.08633949607610703,
0.4567459225654602,
-0.16242384910583496,
0.4623498022556305,
-0.859168291091919,
0.02746320515871048,
-0.4312211275100708,
-0.41085565090179443,
-0.7866414785385132,
-0.13714149594306946,
0.043653398752212524,
-0.11991153657436371,
-0.3219447731971741,
0.05185479298233986,
-0.7094257473945618,
0.49449533224105835,
0.4493919312953949,
-0.11483744531869888,
0.3946768343448639,
-0.09144280105829239,
0.12541207671165466,
-0.26508334279060364,
-0.5935559272766113,
-0.9643806219100952,
1.0597981214523315,
0.3028765320777893,
0.6261371374130249,
0.16440905630588531,
0.6531140208244324,
0.11372115463018417,
0.6888272166252136,
-0.5183141827583313,
0.35140907764434814,
-0.38281089067459106,
-0.8753830790519714,
-0.2169472873210907,
-0.3792179822921753,
-0.8156660795211792,
0.7741817831993103,
-0.29900264739990234,
-0.9939016699790955,
0.3508933484554291,
0.1207558736205101,
-0.3029039204120636,
0.515350878238678,
-0.7239023447036743,
0.7749552130699158,
-0.0072196596302092075,
-0.13016782701015472,
0.10716494917869568,
-0.8783478736877441,
0.5327671766281128,
0.008634783327579498,
0.32206040620803833,
-0.4435950815677643,
-0.056936316192150116,
0.5563485622406006,
-0.061566077172756195,
1.1283358335494995,
-0.38691580295562744,
0.05511379614472389,
0.12677045166492462,
-0.32610324025154114,
-0.19960685074329376,
0.1574980467557907,
-0.4432457387447357,
0.1853102594614029,
-0.046587683260440826,
-0.5236518383026123,
-0.61323481798172,
0.4302311837673187,
-0.9242920875549316,
-0.4445502758026123,
-0.22027765214443207,
-0.6375773549079895,
-0.2509111762046814,
-0.1664099544286728,
0.20582275092601776,
0.02533826045691967,
-0.3973469138145447,
-0.058112382888793945,
0.45255130529403687,
-0.39351239800453186,
0.3051530122756958,
0.19632115960121155,
-0.1929776966571808,
-0.1723831593990326,
0.6637513041496277,
-0.01097432617098093,
0.22358261048793793,
0.3536624014377594,
0.2679580748081207,
0.07055564224720001,
-0.4139343798160553,
-0.45137161016464233,
0.03284740075469017,
-0.8900636434555054,
0.07772743701934814,
-0.7452856302261353,
0.04498913884162903,
-0.17199371755123138,
-0.18547840416431427,
-0.09074865281581879,
-0.4601631760597229,
-0.2388940453529358,
-0.2163068652153015,
0.2617969810962677,
0.8794194459915161,
-0.0014251430984586477,
0.3063820004463196,
-0.46890172362327576,
0.3227989077568054,
0.19686920940876007,
0.2711862027645111,
0.04015693813562393,
-0.5104447603225708,
0.009385320357978344,
0.06612029671669006,
-0.16296806931495667,
-0.6091114282608032,
0.2910124361515045,
0.3979165256023407,
0.5885439515113831,
0.23209773004055023,
-0.032354336231946945,
0.5805947780609131,
-0.39116114377975464,
0.8377336859703064,
-0.06817980110645294,
-1.0468827486038208,
0.6986373662948608,
-0.16575245559215546,
0.4169151186943054,
0.7848990559577942,
0.3658062815666199,
-0.9267534613609314,
-0.7144047617912292,
-0.49463027715682983,
-1.0196975469589233,
0.5128375291824341,
0.030160440132021904,
0.2931221127510071,
0.2769865393638611,
0.5979934930801392,
0.3625660538673401,
0.1852395087480545,
-1.005949854850769,
-0.13301950693130493,
-0.5271379351615906,
-0.5570175647735596,
0.09700912237167358,
0.1443665474653244,
0.06091587617993355,
-0.13853833079338074,
0.39529886841773987,
-0.4838204085826874,
0.042839810252189636,
0.2562810182571411,
-0.19196750223636627,
0.1847854107618332,
0.4492054581642151,
0.24652133882045746,
0.8753424882888794,
-0.056266240775585175,
0.36255505681037903,
0.2192634493112564,
-0.24605609476566315,
0.18701983988285065,
0.13111695647239685,
-0.4790939688682556,
-0.022430047392845154,
0.5939069390296936,
0.9110074043273926,
-0.022849641740322113,
-0.6434189677238464,
0.13881337642669678,
-0.23256568610668182,
0.16731849312782288,
-0.16651448607444763,
0.04547123238444328,
0.12193755805492401,
0.12515878677368164,
0.5453212261199951,
0.2805047333240509,
0.18151289224624634,
-0.5004664063453674,
0.11641326546669006,
0.27936455607414246,
-0.5511086583137512,
-0.4767448306083679,
0.6631200313568115,
0.11325392127037048,
-0.33663323521614075,
0.5564043521881104,
-0.06660249829292297,
-0.4430448114871979,
0.5766103267669678,
0.4197947382926941,
0.7545779943466187,
-0.17858333885669708,
0.1830965131521225,
0.22699713706970215,
0.4394954442977905,
0.15261034667491913,
-0.07821434736251831,
-0.13004812598228455,
-1.1633490324020386,
-0.731747567653656,
-0.8049782514572144,
-0.558365523815155,
-0.14950555562973022,
-0.6929874420166016,
-0.11037004739046097,
-0.6074178218841553,
-0.0747518241405487,
0.2691328227519989,
-0.27581489086151123,
-0.7459012866020203,
0.5230830907821655,
0.33414167165756226,
0.7081760168075562,
-1.3978228569030762,
0.6016452312469482,
0.7953690886497498,
-0.4667511284351349,
-0.4019625782966614,
0.41140085458755493,
-0.015998560935258865,
-0.5163295865058899,
0.9471073150634766,
0.1541799157857895,
0.0769311860203743,
-0.466630220413208,
-0.6480973958969116,
-0.785024881362915,
0.5329011678695679,
0.27763909101486206,
-0.33088698983192444,
-0.09134166687726974,
0.137276291847229,
0.9273074865341187,
-0.47782155871391296,
0.18438299000263214,
0.7103376984596252,
0.5439811944961548,
-0.19848021864891052,
-0.6696580648422241,
-0.14713558554649353,
-0.21604318916797638,
0.2129940241575241,
0.05640401691198349,
-0.4568394124507904,
0.45264890789985657,
-0.14297419786453247,
0.0072096954099833965,
-0.2942948639392853,
0.6158832907676697,
0.24534007906913757,
0.25658339262008667,
0.6455188393592834,
0.5436732172966003,
0.6138525009155273,
-0.09942080080509186,
1.0069479942321777,
0.22580906748771667,
0.20186695456504822,
1.2074496746063232,
-0.28423500061035156,
0.7270219922065735,
0.6143226623535156,
-0.35347235202789307,
0.48123276233673096,
0.649283230304718,
-0.13022421300411224,
0.3111981451511383,
0.24476730823516846,
-0.2395492047071457,
-0.29027774930000305,
-0.3902997076511383,
0.2076663374900818,
0.7928629517555237,
0.4242931306362152,
-0.17226417362689972,
-0.1201723963022232,
0.026781471446156502,
-0.11937369406223297,
0.32214757800102234,
0.23062318563461304,
0.8206014037132263,
0.02309013344347477,
-0.631952702999115,
0.3324250876903534,
-0.19921450316905975,
0.9823423624038696,
-0.3651895225048065,
-0.01554176677018404,
-0.16665180027484894,
0.007153261452913284,
-0.46142783761024475,
-0.7006965279579163,
0.7474653124809265,
0.05840916186571121,
-0.2639457583427429,
-0.19801661372184753,
0.43560078740119934,
-0.17678497731685638,
-0.6351252794265747,
0.2795160412788391,
0.3388412892818451,
0.045093003660440445,
0.3153017461299896,
-0.6156346797943115,
0.15350474417209625,
0.2533985674381256,
-0.1409928798675537,
0.10949923098087311,
0.4125608801841736,
-0.010607021860778332,
0.6972853541374207,
0.3704413175582886,
0.05846710875630379,
-0.10052698850631714,
0.1730670928955078,
0.7421873211860657,
-0.5843012928962708,
-0.18918699026107788,
-0.9425475001335144,
0.4972427487373352,
-0.17831021547317505,
-0.6599796414375305,
0.5857357978820801,
0.4548792839050293,
0.9130460619926453,
0.224091038107872,
1.127679467201233,
-0.1397762894630432,
0.40603360533714294,
-0.21799765527248383,
0.48355016112327576,
-0.5082124471664429,
0.3701355457305908,
-0.43056586384773254,
-0.8202575445175171,
-0.764008104801178,
0.9640519022941589,
-0.3734874129295349,
-0.16407141089439392,
0.16751283407211304,
0.21953484416007996,
-0.09813561290502548,
0.4456005394458771,
0.20431271195411682,
0.1829739362001419,
0.4997558295726776,
0.5469323992729187,
1.0083757638931274,
-0.3689154386520386,
0.27263692021369934,
-0.17731371521949768,
-0.28445595502853394,
0.09511172771453857,
-0.8328952789306641,
-0.7939755916595459,
-0.3558422029018402,
-0.21205395460128784,
-0.08303753286600113,
0.06814757734537125,
1.0152667760849,
0.7057467103004456,
-0.8848055005073547,
-0.16169440746307373,
-0.08408670127391815,
0.3624655306339264,
-0.13625378906726837,
-0.21203282475471497,
0.09206071496009827,
-0.3478057086467743,
-0.8019797205924988,
0.16648070514202118,
0.48184630274772644,
-0.18623791635036469,
-0.44367167353630066,
0.2674795985221863,
-0.16154047846794128,
0.027372024953365326,
0.4401266574859619,
0.11765899509191513,
-1.2060164213180542,
-0.42320793867111206,
-0.31839093565940857,
0.25663772225379944,
0.32221949100494385,
0.5865505933761597,
-0.7265621423721313,
0.41476014256477356,
0.1763947606086731,
0.7863268256187439,
0.3960297107696533,
-0.06682687252759933,
0.5754756927490234,
-0.7521508932113647,
0.48801520466804504,
0.5417966246604919,
0.22687950730323792,
0.7054668664932251,
-0.19584666192531586,
0.6421123147010803,
0.17936325073242188,
-0.43410730361938477,
-0.7366160154342651,
0.5343592762947083,
-0.49972593784332275,
-0.42369478940963745,
0.8021337389945984,
-0.23743276298046112,
-0.21118393540382385,
-0.5027582049369812,
0.07492824643850327,
-0.02025848999619484,
-0.27163201570510864,
0.7100369930267334,
0.7847672700881958,
-0.27790310978889465,
0.018456844612956047,
-0.5439153909683228,
0.2274145632982254,
0.42735329270362854,
-0.8271290063858032,
0.18037790060043335,
0.4640273153781891,
0.3122321367263794,
0.46122294664382935,
0.5042665004730225,
0.22156088054180145,
-0.183077871799469,
0.1722126454114914,
0.21693770587444305,
0.5747735500335693,
-0.07641036063432693,
-0.32202377915382385,
0.14325809478759766,
0.1957184076309204,
0.06719116121530533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11192v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11192v1
|
BrainStorm @ iREL at SMM4H 2024: Leveraging Translation and Topical Embeddings for Annotation Detection in Tweets
| 2024-05-18T06:08:07 | 2024-05-18T06:08:07 |
Manav Chaudhary, Harshit Gupta, Vasudeva Varma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
The proliferation of LLMs in various NLP tasks has sparked debates regarding
their reliability, particularly in annotation tasks where biases and
hallucinations may arise. In this shared task, we address the challenge of
distinguishing annotations made by LLMs from those made by human domain experts
in the context of COVID-19 symptom detection from tweets in Latin American
Spanish. This paper presents BrainStorm @ iREL's approach to the SMM4H 2024
Shared Task, leveraging the inherent topical information in tweets, we propose
a novel approach to identify and classify annotations, aiming to enhance the
trustworthiness of annotated data.
|
[
-0.404367059469223,
-0.4022018611431122,
0.6228466033935547,
0.4760531485080719,
-0.41841697692871094,
0.3887706696987152,
-0.260084331035614,
-0.7927394509315491,
0.676249086856842,
0.4361644685268402,
-0.6979823708534241,
-0.6840998530387878,
-0.9047891497612,
0.2860190272331238,
-0.4967615306377411,
1.0704416036605835,
-0.22807562351226807,
-0.342227578163147,
-0.5839878916740417,
-0.2687886953353882,
-0.0880882740020752,
-0.48327216506004333,
-0.5981603860855103,
-0.3678748607635498,
0.5499456524848938,
0.49415063858032227,
0.4630364179611206,
0.15563420951366425,
0.9088874459266663,
0.1624917834997177,
0.17929591238498688,
0.3274390399456024,
-0.2943197786808014,
0.2995983362197876,
-0.3096790015697479,
-0.2641569972038269,
-0.28234416246414185,
0.14183956384658813,
0.07935013622045517,
0.004502895288169384,
0.03802337870001793,
0.3127748668193817,
-0.05708794295787811,
0.04796057939529419,
-0.14926040172576904,
0.1257980763912201,
-0.9107075333595276,
0.2367725819349289,
-0.49452173709869385,
-0.5610265135765076,
-0.20784635841846466,
-0.13769333064556122,
0.08734823763370514,
-0.3574810326099396,
0.3491131365299225,
0.14096646010875702,
0.9660119414329529,
0.530649721622467,
-0.15494370460510254,
-0.24048247933387756,
-0.30867892503738403,
0.8194950819015503,
-0.48677656054496765,
-0.009105678647756577,
0.45392510294914246,
0.1677584946155548,
-0.02880849316716194,
-0.8484378457069397,
-0.3038806915283203,
0.10570918768644333,
0.02069188468158245,
-0.21825309097766876,
-0.1894587129354477,
-0.31789669394493103,
-0.01590878702700138,
0.017807982861995697,
-0.3165619373321533,
0.07820696383714676,
-0.26229727268218994,
-0.4767574369907379,
0.6122309565544128,
-0.35756832361221313,
0.4147052466869354,
-0.2112671434879303,
-0.5635605454444885,
0.6073831915855408,
-0.5022651553153992,
-0.4829467833042145,
-0.26974552869796753,
0.01679757609963417,
-0.1581128090620041,
0.27616360783576965,
0.11671504378318787,
-0.02921910025179386,
-0.08491257578134537,
-0.14726151525974274,
0.46622005105018616,
-0.24690064787864685,
-0.18619917333126068,
-0.14371787011623383,
0.8879866600036621,
0.36845865845680237,
0.4171236753463745,
-0.42657753825187683,
-0.19486494362354279,
-0.1739397644996643,
0.40579378604888916,
-0.653758704662323,
-0.32853415608406067,
0.24943505227565765,
-0.18227995932102203,
-0.5065208077430725,
0.12466514855623245,
-0.6565397381782532,
-0.5872634053230286,
-0.13231076300144196,
0.25980865955352783,
-0.18399497866630554,
-0.18179059028625488,
-0.3367907404899597,
-0.19440679252147675,
-0.15693055093288422,
0.51424640417099,
-0.6279211640357971,
0.23095375299453735,
0.8587340712547302,
0.8944931626319885,
-0.5053959488868713,
-0.14766855537891388,
-0.3198434114456177,
0.34924066066741943,
-0.20966003835201263,
0.9341942667961121,
-0.35878777503967285,
0.10284914821386337,
-0.09540986269712448,
0.0020128609612584114,
-0.027840394526720047,
-0.5900389552116394,
0.6584837436676025,
-0.25058430433273315,
0.03913860023021698,
-0.4837367534637451,
-0.3201706111431122,
-0.048752374947071075,
0.456063836812973,
-0.5928274393081665,
1.0285683870315552,
0.13610196113586426,
-1.148600697517395,
0.43000781536102295,
-0.6858019828796387,
-0.27072590589523315,
0.5081678628921509,
-0.6100270748138428,
-0.5379816293716431,
0.026943810284137726,
0.4407818019390106,
0.9257462024688721,
-0.21770405769348145,
0.5030759572982788,
-0.3440685570240021,
-0.3251875936985016,
0.3814661204814911,
-0.1798049658536911,
0.444904625415802,
0.07746437191963196,
-0.5371695756912231,
0.33361920714378357,
-0.3184693455696106,
-0.23023729026317596,
0.14502090215682983,
0.33744537830352783,
-0.36079537868499756,
-0.23847824335098267,
0.1626998484134674,
0.3447182774543762,
0.4522787630558014,
-0.4313015639781952,
-0.1426686942577362,
0.03686134144663811,
0.5910922884941101,
0.7674302458763123,
0.5349204540252686,
0.3276505470275879,
-0.36201414465904236,
0.6645291447639465,
0.11887545883655548,
0.13104820251464844,
0.09559978544712067,
-0.8123912215232849,
-0.5155101418495178,
-0.5168687105178833,
-0.14303117990493774,
0.5275758504867554,
-0.8981419205665588,
0.2361786812543869,
-0.29859426617622375,
-0.3741479814052582,
-0.40139663219451904,
0.07885916531085968,
0.0011282964842393994,
0.22222374379634857,
0.5960264801979065,
0.07670854032039642,
-0.799994170665741,
-0.8980505466461182,
-0.2665700912475586,
0.12330891191959381,
0.15202687680721283,
0.25640374422073364,
0.8371445536613464,
-0.6584029197692871,
0.6781058311462402,
-0.21640890836715698,
-0.3154739439487457,
-0.08048169314861298,
0.38740742206573486,
-0.22622458636760712,
0.45976921916007996,
0.681431233882904,
-0.8393508791923523,
-0.5142079591751099,
-0.06335114687681198,
-0.8926606178283691,
-0.36150065064430237,
-0.11529656499624252,
-0.11398528516292572,
0.03191164508461952,
0.7989892959594727,
-0.31165605783462524,
0.4170016944408417,
0.5225388407707214,
-0.3747827410697937,
0.039015576243400574,
0.2353399246931076,
0.31551340222358704,
-1.3093974590301514,
-0.06972736865282059,
0.18995076417922974,
-0.5535006523132324,
-0.41265058517456055,
0.02023286744952202,
-0.1570950597524643,
0.23439371585845947,
-0.27207884192466736,
0.6041807532310486,
-0.11668886244297028,
0.11248854547739029,
-0.15757417678833008,
0.08683960884809494,
-0.0028366681654006243,
0.07367293536663055,
-0.07637465000152588,
0.7403748631477356,
0.1942788064479828,
-0.14261935651302338,
0.2092810720205307,
0.05445191636681557,
-0.13338185846805573,
0.5544522404670715,
-0.5496653318405151,
0.2966157793998718,
-0.01639128476381302,
0.24816416203975677,
-0.8283661007881165,
-0.3338143527507782,
0.6470049023628235,
-0.5155242085456848,
-0.04232630506157875,
0.056059565395116806,
-0.6709464192390442,
-0.3552848696708679,
-0.4638471305370331,
0.2931597828865051,
0.1872226744890213,
-0.5399072766304016,
0.30018940567970276,
0.6839582920074463,
-0.18540619313716888,
-0.5671235918998718,
-0.9359508156776428,
0.4183959662914276,
-0.48008280992507935,
-0.6136513352394104,
0.6826229691505432,
0.15300683677196503,
-0.3882826864719391,
0.1311328411102295,
-0.26471298933029175,
-0.2833099365234375,
0.45320022106170654,
0.5282959342002869,
-0.008108722046017647,
0.10497577488422394,
0.03935052081942558,
0.0681990534067154,
0.06131692975759506,
0.09259942173957825,
-0.3502914309501648,
0.4464666247367859,
-0.20323391258716583,
-0.14386649429798126,
-0.482570618391037,
0.35860249400138855,
0.3932349979877472,
-0.1145482063293457,
0.7290074825286865,
1.293960690498352,
-0.6861346960067749,
-0.21503180265426636,
-0.663689136505127,
-0.15245015919208527,
-0.45171213150024414,
0.10228618234395981,
-0.26866474747657776,
-1.1883296966552734,
0.5542123317718506,
-0.18545466661453247,
-0.09172917157411575,
0.5284032821655273,
0.5113857984542847,
-0.27814772725105286,
0.32242172956466675,
0.6584516167640686,
-0.13144850730895996,
0.3294142484664917,
-0.2693755328655243,
0.21166014671325684,
-0.557039737701416,
-0.5680447220802307,
-0.4249831736087799,
-0.21635478734970093,
-0.5073824524879456,
-1.0208057165145874,
0.12636655569076538,
-0.39549127221107483,
0.09970548748970032,
0.25184983015060425,
-0.5478074550628662,
0.3277587294578552,
0.4807305932044983,
0.1117536872625351,
-0.001328703947365284,
-0.02274531126022339,
-0.07207372784614563,
-0.3171674609184265,
-0.40883299708366394,
-0.6772491931915283,
0.7315772771835327,
0.5601961612701416,
0.31666967272758484,
-0.1701495498418808,
1.1267178058624268,
0.6666696071624756,
0.5260935425758362,
-0.5481165647506714,
0.6747201085090637,
-0.03793898597359657,
-0.4273906946182251,
-0.06512206792831421,
-0.18686194717884064,
-0.6424398422241211,
-0.03260624408721924,
-0.22648726403713226,
-0.8414115309715271,
0.011554311960935593,
-0.25085434317588806,
-0.1366450935602188,
0.15340253710746765,
-0.24831268191337585,
0.8427425622940063,
0.07097673416137695,
-0.12723340094089508,
-0.1562056690454483,
-0.4392900764942169,
0.170378178358078,
-0.2347213625907898,
0.4494049549102783,
-0.6032429337501526,
-0.4154602885246277,
1.1254292726516724,
-0.04741910472512245,
0.8164454698562622,
-0.12584351003170013,
0.07466506212949753,
0.32113105058670044,
-0.2405783236026764,
0.26932984590530396,
0.30243292450904846,
0.07152292132377625,
0.42730358242988586,
-0.09303160756826401,
-0.44887036085128784,
-0.22277310490608215,
0.7399219870567322,
-0.6900133490562439,
-0.49285396933555603,
-0.6406887173652649,
-0.5700455904006958,
-0.0951651781797409,
0.08749599009752274,
0.2773228883743286,
0.057600464671850204,
-0.23416343331336975,
0.23801100254058838,
0.371648371219635,
0.06559228897094727,
0.36602187156677246,
-0.08305854350328445,
-0.08768381923437119,
-0.5127727389335632,
0.7551072835922241,
0.01538316160440445,
-0.3019630014896393,
0.5149187445640564,
0.16876792907714844,
0.11272896081209183,
-0.7480541467666626,
-0.013556151650846004,
0.2431948482990265,
-0.7816898226737976,
-0.23076973855495453,
-0.7472245693206787,
-0.31201571226119995,
-0.4241154193878174,
-0.32472938299179077,
-0.19072245061397552,
-0.4624560475349426,
-0.6437715291976929,
-0.37479230761528015,
0.6357648372650146,
0.9271681308746338,
-0.07972636818885803,
0.25863784551620483,
-0.600985586643219,
0.25360846519470215,
0.020872775465250015,
-0.13399694859981537,
-0.26366135478019714,
-0.41372933983802795,
-0.496707022190094,
-0.17213180661201477,
-0.10099197179079056,
-0.7059934139251709,
0.5664843320846558,
0.09813962876796722,
0.5117654800415039,
0.39795583486557007,
0.026923203840851784,
0.5077918171882629,
-0.43882524967193604,
0.8828490376472473,
-0.0122843561694026,
-0.9735671877861023,
0.6223638653755188,
-0.3789781630039215,
0.08479119092226028,
0.7640392184257507,
0.7426989078521729,
-0.48771241307258606,
-0.779087483882904,
-0.7521031498908997,
-0.8477420210838318,
0.2822599709033966,
0.23808979988098145,
-0.039972178637981415,
-0.21876753866672516,
0.5831122398376465,
0.20922864973545074,
0.3803318738937378,
-0.7068670392036438,
-0.12700685858726501,
0.04949040338397026,
-0.41229450702667236,
0.08372750133275986,
-0.48285239934921265,
-0.24669097363948822,
-0.2884616553783417,
0.43810805678367615,
-0.026427926495671272,
0.4232359528541565,
0.08856844902038574,
-0.09088902175426483,
-0.12714068591594696,
-0.01428662333637476,
0.6918237805366516,
0.8383424282073975,
-0.3781973421573639,
0.5504161715507507,
-0.018661055713891983,
-0.5470895767211914,
-0.13867563009262085,
-0.008226589299738407,
-0.18007653951644897,
0.26293957233428955,
0.6734665036201477,
0.6785162687301636,
0.1937696784734726,
-0.2929704189300537,
0.6595775485038757,
-0.11479584872722626,
-0.2069583684206009,
-0.7230150103569031,
-0.05474283918738365,
0.1642562597990036,
0.4259909391403198,
0.5648301839828491,
0.5251275897026062,
0.059845779091119766,
-0.5312705636024475,
0.7554221749305725,
0.30056893825531006,
-0.46282249689102173,
-0.61226487159729,
0.626552164554596,
0.28847768902778625,
-0.33289992809295654,
0.02482263743877411,
-0.4145238697528839,
-0.9020024538040161,
0.5408013463020325,
0.28361639380455017,
0.930927038192749,
-0.11871226131916046,
0.3478695750236511,
0.09266982972621918,
0.4686416685581207,
-0.06862238794565201,
0.48591139912605286,
0.14446157217025757,
-0.7298530340194702,
-0.3885558843612671,
-0.2633358836174011,
-0.4817878007888794,
0.028596287593245506,
-0.6886937618255615,
0.2611789107322693,
-0.4160156548023224,
-0.4043246805667877,
0.08885884284973145,
0.02639075182378292,
-0.8142105937004089,
0.2949686348438263,
0.34252288937568665,
0.6550919413566589,
-1.0801663398742676,
0.9741805195808411,
0.735955536365509,
-0.21840694546699524,
-0.24853043258190155,
0.5048420429229736,
0.01962769776582718,
-0.9077735543251038,
0.7197771072387695,
0.4542320966720581,
0.16073359549045563,
-0.2215465009212494,
-0.7489454746246338,
-0.6220843195915222,
1.4034332036972046,
0.17046691477298737,
-0.14887458086013794,
0.08682573586702347,
0.09721314907073975,
0.477450966835022,
-0.6416663527488708,
0.03722790628671646,
0.42456942796707153,
0.4603871703147888,
0.23261074721813202,
-0.9573018550872803,
0.26120755076408386,
-0.12036198377609253,
-0.30400151014328003,
-0.12046149373054504,
-0.4120562672615051,
0.6429012417793274,
-0.16249319911003113,
-0.07189114391803741,
-0.243477001786232,
0.8686652779579163,
0.24021907150745392,
0.8422974944114685,
0.28512412309646606,
0.5282643437385559,
1.0670783519744873,
-0.06368277966976166,
0.7586584091186523,
-0.16374261677265167,
0.3080189824104309,
1.1945538520812988,
0.07385537028312683,
0.9318936467170715,
0.7583568692207336,
0.02059830166399479,
0.5227574110031128,
0.597790002822876,
-0.0531219057738781,
0.6124491095542908,
0.09707267582416534,
-0.4112899601459503,
-0.004851252306252718,
-0.5861659646034241,
-0.2206660658121109,
0.22924265265464783,
0.7162681221961975,
-0.38778388500213623,
0.02950916439294815,
0.15920916199684143,
0.36431026458740234,
0.17230109870433807,
-0.20842552185058594,
0.5424461960792542,
0.4869658052921295,
-0.4605305790901184,
0.25203508138656616,
0.07298307865858078,
1.0406246185302734,
-0.05693904310464859,
0.17852190136909485,
0.1389026641845703,
-0.007001025602221489,
-0.3613103926181793,
-0.8407569527626038,
0.8116459250450134,
-0.0800878033041954,
0.0020508503075689077,
-0.388989120721817,
0.9285786747932434,
-0.4993787407875061,
-0.3626307249069214,
0.43411755561828613,
0.4924812614917755,
0.20405514538288116,
-0.40974265336990356,
-0.8988468050956726,
0.30590564012527466,
0.09657878428697586,
0.05664313584566116,
0.12537023425102234,
0.7424156069755554,
-0.1228780448436737,
0.644344687461853,
0.2528589069843292,
0.04861586540937424,
-0.0532650388777256,
0.1385948210954666,
0.6048407554626465,
-0.5681986212730408,
-0.2373455911874771,
-1.0491876602172852,
0.1600741297006607,
-0.37034013867378235,
-0.019440848380327225,
0.8804665207862854,
0.20866449177265167,
0.5754764676094055,
-0.13006043434143066,
0.9482777714729309,
0.033001549541950226,
0.5364302396774292,
-0.06948591768741608,
0.5919479727745056,
-0.42945972084999084,
0.2596491575241089,
-0.19570831954479218,
-0.4329144358634949,
-0.5134423971176147,
0.7514548897743225,
-0.42339804768562317,
-0.13201682269573212,
0.9107012152671814,
0.45061948895454407,
0.08289502561092377,
0.05403777211904526,
0.1746819168329239,
0.05206865072250366,
0.47958576679229736,
0.34582099318504333,
0.716944694519043,
-0.37997201085090637,
0.2186117321252823,
-0.5053398609161377,
0.027790062129497528,
-0.5143188834190369,
-1.1701725721359253,
-1.3271867036819458,
-0.7888522744178772,
-0.6953123211860657,
-0.4297577142715454,
0.08542633801698685,
1.3654547929763794,
0.5806025862693787,
-1.0583462715148926,
0.09555041790008545,
-0.13661418855190277,
0.2894056439399719,
0.0924338549375534,
-0.2644614279270172,
0.3360866904258728,
-0.14982572197914124,
-0.4868285655975342,
0.10331299155950546,
0.577375054359436,
0.06714646518230438,
-0.1956550031900406,
0.21533234417438507,
-0.3610580563545227,
0.09433351457118988,
0.5211260318756104,
-0.1719803661108017,
-0.8342793583869934,
-0.4606892764568329,
0.0027280920185148716,
-0.28270789980888367,
-0.002772377571091056,
0.6060490608215332,
-0.5911996364593506,
-0.02638799138367176,
0.46630996465682983,
0.750950813293457,
0.404387503862381,
-0.05868154391646385,
0.44975098967552185,
-0.8870179057121277,
0.19764631986618042,
0.6246340870857239,
0.3011409640312195,
0.6184015274047852,
-0.46743619441986084,
0.8252139687538147,
0.4867364168167114,
-0.5506297945976257,
-0.8009861707687378,
-0.1389985829591751,
-1.2484534978866577,
-0.010480265133082867,
1.224273443222046,
-0.36065617203712463,
-0.22521497309207916,
-0.42955687642097473,
-0.012504206039011478,
0.05423958972096443,
-0.544265866279602,
0.7232789397239685,
0.6746480464935303,
0.030333884060382843,
-0.27945974469184875,
-0.6747268438339233,
0.7420921921730042,
0.06263551861047745,
-0.8119087219238281,
-0.502887487411499,
-0.2002568393945694,
0.22814851999282837,
0.20795895159244537,
0.9426535964012146,
0.11892430484294891,
0.19124817848205566,
-0.3049389123916626,
0.07002956420183182,
-0.07103662937879562,
-0.34898561239242554,
0.07766003161668777,
0.11387273669242859,
0.1915285438299179,
-0.14655107259750366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11181v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11181v1
|
Towards Knowledge-Infused Automated Disease Diagnosis Assistant
| 2024-05-18T05:18:50 | 2024-05-18T05:18:50 |
Mohit Tomar, Abhisek Tiwari, Sriparna Saha
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With the advancement of internet communication and telemedicine, people are
increasingly turning to the web for various healthcare activities. With an
ever-increasing number of diseases and symptoms, diagnosing patients becomes
challenging. In this work, we build a diagnosis assistant to assist doctors,
which identifies diseases based on patient-doctor interaction. During
diagnosis, doctors utilize both symptomatology knowledge and diagnostic
experience to identify diseases accurately and efficiently. Inspired by this,
we investigate the role of medical knowledge in disease diagnosis through
doctor-patient interaction. We propose a two-channel, knowledge-infused,
discourse-aware disease diagnosis model (KI-DDI), where the first channel
encodes patient-doctor communication using a transformer-based encoder, while
the other creates an embedding of symptom-disease using a graph attention
network (GAT). In the next stage, the conversation and knowledge graph
embeddings are infused together and fed to a deep neural network for disease
identification. Furthermore, we first develop an empathetic conversational
medical corpus comprising conversations between patients and doctors, annotated
with intent and symptoms information. The proposed model demonstrates a
significant improvement over the existing state-of-the-art models, establishing
the crucial roles of (a) a doctor's effort for additional symptom extraction
(in addition to patient self-report) and (b) infusing medical knowledge in
identifying diseases effectively. Many times, patients also show their medical
conditions, which acts as crucial evidence in diagnosis. Therefore, integrating
visual sensory information would represent an effective avenue for enhancing
the capabilities of diagnostic assistants.
|
[
-0.3190869688987732,
-0.8440855741500854,
1.0498969554901123,
-0.12839606404304504,
-0.33750587701797485,
-0.12371706962585449,
0.04645988345146179,
-0.7815060019493103,
0.6395254731178284,
0.3137967586517334,
-0.09168744832277298,
-0.47366493940353394,
-0.8445897698402405,
-0.0513131357729435,
-0.3081120550632477,
0.6059675216674805,
0.05412043258547783,
0.228558748960495,
-0.5692138671875,
0.13679201900959015,
-0.5680218935012817,
0.059850063174963,
-1.3870738744735718,
-0.38502034544944763,
0.38838618993759155,
0.23000562191009521,
0.673233151435852,
0.6238803267478943,
0.43758171796798706,
0.2926110029220581,
0.1451389491558075,
0.6190131902694702,
0.15534916520118713,
0.2341366708278656,
0.09429801255464554,
-0.18225249648094177,
-0.6702787280082703,
-0.017092622816562653,
-0.09663546830415726,
0.7443951964378357,
0.041398972272872925,
-0.19721391797065735,
0.05271453410387039,
0.33222994208335876,
-0.12105050683021545,
0.3476127088069916,
0.1482212245464325,
0.3385503888130188,
-0.009627480059862137,
-0.17762650549411774,
-0.28998279571533203,
-0.0812392607331276,
0.14541378617286682,
-1.0298526287078857,
-0.08337748795747757,
-0.10375135391950607,
0.8204005360603333,
0.5286600589752197,
-0.5559933185577393,
-0.44738128781318665,
-0.6751553416252136,
0.16090287268161774,
-0.40805375576019287,
0.4437299072742462,
0.5029606819152832,
0.5530616044998169,
0.09665518254041672,
-0.638290524482727,
-0.5580844879150391,
-0.17419230937957764,
-0.4140304625034332,
0.37722840905189514,
-0.3373393416404724,
0.0728020891547203,
-0.047547776252031326,
0.3381647765636444,
-0.6009517908096313,
0.15121757984161377,
-0.11991137266159058,
-0.0715264305472374,
0.5336704850196838,
0.2586425244808197,
0.6842271685600281,
-0.33036500215530396,
-0.20661714673042297,
0.44904735684394836,
-0.15611284971237183,
-0.24570190906524658,
-0.20568524301052094,
-0.20537643134593964,
-0.3368699550628662,
0.17316067218780518,
-0.09972603619098663,
0.8621719479560852,
0.39688819646835327,
-0.4094610810279846,
0.045312728732824326,
-0.13711236417293549,
-0.2202395647764206,
0.12356092780828476,
0.7862275838851929,
0.41245749592781067,
-0.005212431773543358,
-0.24708189070224762,
0.06314770132303238,
0.12131830304861069,
0.3993101716041565,
-0.5548992156982422,
-0.8503320813179016,
0.4014168679714203,
-0.6453329920768738,
-0.42652466893196106,
-0.5080602169036865,
-0.7464467883110046,
-1.0818642377853394,
-0.3373278081417084,
0.5483313798904419,
-0.5468776822090149,
-0.46130621433258057,
0.06212550774216652,
-0.3117431402206421,
-0.32246923446655273,
0.6293351054191589,
-0.6806563138961792,
0.5056681632995605,
0.3802429735660553,
0.4740701913833618,
0.028049824759364128,
0.37158170342445374,
-0.41847488284111023,
0.36486363410949707,
-0.15926899015903473,
0.720777153968811,
-0.6353579163551331,
-0.46272772550582886,
-0.45877107977867126,
-0.13137809932231903,
-0.19045116007328033,
-0.5483754873275757,
0.0032761713955551386,
-0.3354562819004059,
0.03900375962257385,
-0.20087866485118866,
-0.486341267824173,
-0.15320785343647003,
0.36229100823402405,
-0.616510808467865,
0.5308409929275513,
0.47283199429512024,
-0.49419155716896057,
0.4170055091381073,
-0.8612006902694702,
-0.3666825294494629,
0.5020427107810974,
-0.3520113229751587,
-0.2324274182319641,
-0.30281326174736023,
0.2583772838115692,
0.5444358587265015,
-0.6061952710151672,
0.5156237483024597,
-0.1767772138118744,
0.13905580341815948,
0.049257852137088776,
-0.2966761291027069,
0.7420210242271423,
0.1619996279478073,
-0.051049284636974335,
-0.20872944593429565,
-0.6639321446418762,
-0.17393909394741058,
0.10283824801445007,
0.12667754292488098,
-0.5514750480651855,
-0.03163902461528778,
-0.5244206190109253,
-0.10412853211164474,
0.22716088593006134,
-0.5027036070823669,
0.2661679983139038,
-0.6899538040161133,
0.13157624006271362,
0.38394784927368164,
0.37774017453193665,
0.17121781408786774,
-0.31935110688209534,
0.6646298766136169,
0.6114339232444763,
0.5140597224235535,
-0.07074043899774551,
-0.9999817609786987,
-0.6393920183181763,
-0.45264577865600586,
0.39189180731773376,
0.734290599822998,
-0.5226134061813354,
0.4759323000907898,
-0.1404792070388794,
-0.4545831084251404,
-0.8311166167259216,
-0.09970571100711823,
0.3365616500377655,
0.9771334528923035,
0.3993729054927826,
-0.18946313858032227,
-0.21297584474086761,
-0.6217730641365051,
0.07982563972473145,
0.021232249215245247,
-0.06310325860977173,
0.8567487001419067,
0.06023748591542244,
-0.4148503839969635,
0.6756484508514404,
-0.71605384349823,
-0.537621259689331,
-0.18651074171066284,
-0.06807536631822586,
-0.013556334190070629,
0.43513649702072144,
0.4989735186100006,
-0.7560915946960449,
-0.5943698287010193,
0.6467787027359009,
-1.044560194015503,
-0.1257661134004593,
0.11457279324531555,
0.1917986273765564,
-0.15658076107501984,
0.18608252704143524,
-0.4923768937587738,
0.7999557256698608,
0.39178282022476196,
-0.6942868232727051,
0.030911467969417572,
-0.526591420173645,
0.36551526188850403,
-1.3600207567214966,
0.0003779285179916769,
0.05580594763159752,
-0.38732200860977173,
-0.44568517804145813,
-0.2569079101085663,
-0.05276498198509216,
-0.2902621030807495,
0.23443208634853363,
0.7017401456832886,
-0.16451644897460938,
0.21934279799461365,
-0.051179077476263046,
0.2025943249464035,
0.5827462673187256,
0.061573486775159836,
-0.06861194968223572,
0.2262357622385025,
0.7860276103019714,
-0.814470112323761,
0.49608027935028076,
0.34892722964286804,
0.0757528617978096,
0.7640992999076843,
-0.6708805561065674,
-0.0017786446260288358,
0.013207634910941124,
-0.04202811419963837,
-0.9502245783805847,
-0.3407542407512665,
0.7273491621017456,
-0.7108243107795715,
0.6473598480224609,
-0.10144198685884476,
-0.38266584277153015,
-0.30543142557144165,
0.43659523129463196,
0.613749623298645,
0.4388591945171356,
-0.4504430294036865,
0.94580078125,
0.4614278972148895,
-0.16381436586380005,
-0.07807400077581406,
-0.7030408978462219,
-0.0457674041390419,
-0.1149483397603035,
-0.7410415410995483,
0.43112316727638245,
0.29402852058410645,
-0.2863815128803253,
0.04972487688064575,
0.29726099967956543,
-0.3629569709300995,
0.2748640775680542,
0.3526330292224884,
0.263915091753006,
-0.06499862670898438,
0.6544988751411438,
0.3191095292568207,
-0.26480069756507874,
0.08697347342967987,
-0.13901622593402863,
0.4505787491798401,
0.2902233898639679,
-0.7455296516418457,
-0.7745614647865295,
0.6960242986679077,
0.5816906094551086,
-0.2784963846206665,
0.32937997579574585,
0.38423672318458557,
-0.4494990110397339,
0.2852330207824707,
-0.47245824337005615,
-0.1925981342792511,
-0.4225987493991852,
0.05145926773548126,
-0.3728068768978119,
-0.2426871359348297,
0.649882435798645,
-0.41817978024482727,
-0.5461831092834473,
0.39595332741737366,
0.27103716135025024,
-0.22437681257724762,
1.3854215145111084,
0.5925759077072144,
0.05365174636244774,
-0.19262433052062988,
-0.2464008629322052,
0.5662259459495544,
-0.8282603621482849,
-0.47382211685180664,
-0.25815069675445557,
-0.05667869746685028,
-0.3764917850494385,
-0.2546147108078003,
1.0889744758605957,
-0.07993889600038528,
0.0017168935155496001,
-0.05982016399502754,
-0.8014482259750366,
-0.06042657792568207,
0.25652340054512024,
0.7230096459388733,
0.2779567539691925,
-0.44499829411506653,
-0.26199066638946533,
0.008472439832985401,
-0.848341166973114,
-0.1533808559179306,
1.0921145677566528,
0.3174956440925598,
0.4685041606426239,
0.06152336299419403,
0.8371586799621582,
0.516106128692627,
0.08487966656684875,
-1.0476655960083008,
0.1218615174293518,
-0.2607121467590332,
0.01639900542795658,
-0.1024765893816948,
-0.19194146990776062,
-0.9923620820045471,
-0.3507234454154968,
0.06541965156793594,
-0.6333336234092712,
0.4714057147502899,
0.4889686107635498,
-0.7378402948379517,
0.02113833650946617,
-0.9838741421699524,
1.099326491355896,
-0.1340429037809372,
-0.006726621184498072,
-0.4011157751083374,
-0.6104461550712585,
0.2568439841270447,
0.18787188827991486,
0.163356751203537,
0.24572941660881042,
0.13924814760684967,
0.906423032283783,
-0.14454662799835205,
0.8906487822532654,
-0.46804922819137573,
-0.04424275830388069,
-0.12881503999233246,
0.07539777457714081,
0.21110884845256805,
0.4091747999191284,
0.17279182374477386,
-0.0889093279838562,
-0.11191997677087784,
-0.0711500272154808,
-0.8841938972473145,
0.48095834255218506,
-0.7116926908493042,
-0.6631945371627808,
-0.15476678311824799,
-0.4021996855735779,
-0.5353646874427795,
0.18292054533958435,
-0.024143829941749573,
0.7645506262779236,
-0.046459443867206573,
-0.4606377184391022,
0.9598749279975891,
-0.2451339215040207,
-0.04764225333929062,
0.5374987721443176,
-0.062242843210697174,
-0.03121301159262657,
0.9557051658630371,
-0.050158966332674026,
0.13439054787158966,
0.25159528851509094,
0.4956985414028168,
0.07802943140268326,
-0.15935149788856506,
-0.6061328649520874,
0.2772795259952545,
-0.6963669657707214,
-0.3259291648864746,
-1.057552695274353,
-0.2820235788822174,
-0.5376089811325073,
-0.0793488621711731,
-0.1136086955666542,
-0.16814956068992615,
-0.6538568139076233,
0.1681315004825592,
0.7503365874290466,
0.8503061532974243,
-0.0625547543168068,
0.13053904473781586,
-0.6310307383537292,
0.700485110282898,
0.4500690698623657,
0.15535560250282288,
0.22441846132278442,
-0.4009944200515747,
-0.16153855621814728,
0.17031872272491455,
-0.15530478954315186,
-0.9931739568710327,
0.5228579640388489,
0.09753812849521637,
0.4986199736595154,
0.9420169591903687,
-0.0005784202949143946,
0.6771095991134644,
-0.17249345779418945,
0.6028028726577759,
0.2683984637260437,
-0.7386015057563782,
0.8134937882423401,
-0.04359636455774307,
0.11608389765024185,
0.13105696439743042,
0.5843862891197205,
-0.6853951215744019,
-0.4708136022090912,
-0.7497606873512268,
-0.3086816966533661,
0.34199443459510803,
-0.49116793274879456,
-0.3000575006008148,
-0.32715579867362976,
0.1032676249742508,
0.15969611704349518,
-0.22193974256515503,
-0.13769419491291046,
-0.25505509972572327,
-0.27960553765296936,
-0.5725857615470886,
0.23197734355926514,
-0.14469797909259796,
-0.46779462695121765,
-0.8341942429542542,
0.3036295175552368,
-0.260556161403656,
0.740060567855835,
0.5101876854896545,
-0.0364544652402401,
0.07322582602500916,
0.047799739986658096,
0.22058172523975372,
0.41553249955177307,
0.3915557265281677,
0.003027103142812848,
-0.13577966392040253,
-0.4242877662181854,
-0.21439586579799652,
0.36876747012138367,
0.08578020334243774,
0.00018636969616636634,
0.0956323966383934,
0.621819019317627,
0.08469156175851822,
-0.4839194715023041,
0.8170377612113953,
0.15461452305316925,
-0.06361342966556549,
-0.3136838674545288,
0.10131748765707016,
0.23462818562984467,
0.3210318088531494,
0.03176309913396835,
0.36769789457321167,
0.5659540295600891,
-0.20784775912761688,
0.18797463178634644,
0.4784729778766632,
-0.5149396061897278,
-0.2813574969768524,
0.6359922289848328,
0.42944303154945374,
-0.42063379287719727,
0.7194880247116089,
-0.5394033193588257,
-0.5144554376602173,
0.7597482800483704,
0.37452074885368347,
0.41949185729026794,
-0.32213905453681946,
0.3179742395877838,
-0.023241441696882248,
-0.10310617089271545,
0.3794369101524353,
0.2793424129486084,
-0.3328483998775482,
-0.7247603535652161,
-0.18022935092449188,
-0.35271310806274414,
-0.035968322306871414,
0.015212269499897957,
-0.5412344336509705,
0.22961655259132385,
-0.2434525489807129,
-0.09881578385829926,
0.5234973430633545,
0.005808077286928892,
-0.4805157482624054,
0.5512955784797668,
0.13102483749389648,
0.5571824312210083,
-0.9896776080131531,
0.8206897377967834,
0.3749687969684601,
-0.3020752966403961,
-0.973687469959259,
-0.16088402271270752,
0.019415948539972305,
-1.0669625997543335,
0.480263352394104,
0.06642477214336395,
0.2910647690296173,
0.13011434674263,
-0.15385811030864716,
-0.5383329391479492,
1.2431730031967163,
0.1254366934299469,
-0.21338455379009247,
-0.06425522267818451,
-0.06407296657562256,
0.4809322655200958,
-0.46867620944976807,
0.43199387192726135,
0.42249494791030884,
0.6828736662864685,
0.04320025071501732,
-1.3182471990585327,
0.18711037933826447,
-0.4190639853477478,
-0.33910754323005676,
0.4060113728046417,
-0.2837105393409729,
0.743516206741333,
-0.2693423628807068,
-0.0663503110408783,
-0.06592701375484467,
0.1316368132829666,
-0.13230988383293152,
0.48348546028137207,
0.3986489772796631,
0.9520983695983887,
1.1053041219711304,
0.15274342894554138,
1.1214730739593506,
-0.5776479244232178,
-0.35418155789375305,
0.5170359015464783,
-0.08296384662389755,
0.22526319324970245,
0.17561034858226776,
-0.1932184100151062,
0.5312175154685974,
0.45840612053871155,
0.12161725014448166,
0.2844627797603607,
-0.19133785367012024,
-0.5876966118812561,
-0.37350642681121826,
-0.4374389052391052,
-0.5436831116676331,
0.5826436877250671,
0.7152711749076843,
-0.7897412180900574,
-0.30201616883277893,
0.3994911313056946,
-0.01700931414961815,
-0.0632241740822792,
-0.2338992804288864,
1.1491777896881104,
-0.17657886445522308,
-0.4817679822444916,
0.4844597280025482,
-0.18579313158988953,
0.204910010099411,
-0.42104679346084595,
-0.3596212565898895,
0.12479795515537262,
-0.08791270852088928,
-0.1596795916557312,
-0.600135326385498,
0.32386085391044617,
-0.33933526277542114,
-0.4365346431732178,
-0.058629658073186874,
0.944092333316803,
-0.43911775946617126,
-0.412704199552536,
0.17222967743873596,
0.5894766449928284,
0.45645302534103394,
-0.09204505383968353,
-0.33793577551841736,
-0.36820363998413086,
-0.2897301912307739,
0.25631776452064514,
0.27758267521858215,
0.5491886138916016,
-0.015611443668603897,
0.7146956324577332,
0.2437179535627365,
0.15154536068439484,
-0.4478375017642975,
0.14525607228279114,
0.867197573184967,
-0.11634811013936996,
-0.3682873845100403,
-0.4755493998527527,
0.34373360872268677,
-0.26930877566337585,
-0.19028088450431824,
0.16146305203437805,
0.22201839089393616,
-0.0009821064304560423,
-0.09788894653320312,
0.7343515753746033,
-0.21295051276683807,
0.5198984146118164,
-0.208714097738266,
1.1444536447525024,
-0.6875198483467102,
-0.01320804562419653,
0.0027446409221738577,
0.42138829827308655,
-0.06501170992851257,
0.26604384183883667,
-0.16292493045330048,
0.1646347939968109,
0.5776357054710388,
0.6878737211227417,
-0.07603441923856735,
0.060314614325761795,
0.4155275821685791,
0.23473504185676575,
0.14123278856277466,
0.6974228024482727,
0.26910799741744995,
-0.2100210338830948,
0.08614882826805115,
-0.3191142678260803,
-0.5129510164260864,
-0.314506858587265,
-0.3631057143211365,
-0.6600075960159302,
-0.5850022435188293,
-0.45840978622436523,
0.011514987796545029,
0.21907496452331543,
0.6251686811447144,
0.9587345719337463,
-0.3920966684818268,
0.45930829644203186,
-0.19887790083885193,
0.11660183221101761,
-0.438326895236969,
-0.2420874387025833,
0.3823927342891693,
-0.024025967344641685,
-0.4719436764717102,
0.5374186635017395,
0.3042113780975342,
0.024722907692193985,
-0.30509018898010254,
0.13656114041805267,
0.05306384712457657,
-0.4038698971271515,
0.45156338810920715,
0.1407516747713089,
-0.6863990426063538,
-0.023967193439602852,
-0.08867735415697098,
-0.005501155275851488,
0.12402121722698212,
0.4164471924304962,
-1.2783578634262085,
0.7588105797767639,
-0.059870652854442596,
0.733600914478302,
0.10450046509504318,
-0.005179504863917828,
0.6187005639076233,
-0.2764088809490204,
0.003718600608408451,
0.6383898854255676,
0.12887971103191376,
0.13774153590202332,
-1.1781578063964844,
0.02568221464753151,
0.4164496064186096,
-0.43848279118537903,
-0.4533032178878784,
0.16553263366222382,
-1.2013087272644043,
-0.07352785021066666,
0.91197669506073,
-0.3328663110733032,
-0.20473206043243408,
-0.6955932378768921,
-0.11291854083538055,
0.4141256511211395,
-0.24620702862739563,
0.8997868299484253,
0.10992806404829025,
-0.7209390997886658,
-0.18047921359539032,
-0.2851097583770752,
0.6019468903541565,
0.20952455699443817,
-0.8816826939582825,
-0.3004297912120819,
0.16792607307434082,
0.3454492390155792,
0.11017453670501709,
0.7937573790550232,
-0.14583320915699005,
0.6987679600715637,
0.0806746557354927,
-0.08644665032625198,
-0.44461753964424133,
-0.3114796578884125,
0.24535910785198212,
-0.014612593688070774,
0.004052493255585432,
-0.4008740484714508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11178v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11178v1
|
Automating PTSD Diagnostics in Clinical Interviews: Leveraging Large Language Models for Trauma Assessments
| 2024-05-18T05:04:18 | 2024-05-18T05:04:18 |
Sichang Tu, Abigail Powers, Natalie Merrill, Negar Fani, Sierra Carter, Stephen Doogan, Jinho D. Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The shortage of clinical workforce presents significant challenges in mental
healthcare, limiting access to formal diagnostics and services. We aim to
tackle this shortage by integrating a customized large language model (LLM)
into the workflow, thus promoting equity in mental healthcare for the general
population. Although LLMs have showcased their capability in clinical
decision-making, their adaptation to severe conditions like Post-traumatic
Stress Disorder (PTSD) remains largely unexplored. Therefore, we collect 411
clinician-administered diagnostic interviews and devise a novel approach to
obtain high-quality data. Moreover, we build a comprehensive framework to
automate PTSD diagnostic assessments based on interview contents by leveraging
two state-of-the-art LLMs, GPT-4 and Llama-2, with potential for broader
clinical diagnoses. Our results illustrate strong promise for LLMs, tested on
our dataset, to aid clinicians in diagnostic validation. To the best of our
knowledge, this is the first AI system that fully automates assessments for
mental illness based on clinician-administered interviews.
|
[
-0.4079281687736511,
-0.8780929446220398,
0.9888499975204468,
0.297120600938797,
-0.2545909285545349,
0.2691301703453064,
0.05537455901503563,
-0.7101035714149475,
0.19356504082679749,
0.31110236048698425,
-0.5609261393547058,
-0.5763984322547913,
-1.0044000148773193,
0.21694409847259521,
-0.38339608907699585,
0.8650259971618652,
-0.3024773597717285,
0.16077472269535065,
-0.104273721575737,
-0.008266210556030273,
-0.44720062613487244,
-0.8561121821403503,
-0.9050759673118591,
-0.16225583851337433,
0.3331739604473114,
0.09234315901994705,
0.7604791522026062,
0.7757006883621216,
0.7952452301979065,
0.2942587733268738,
0.06272593885660172,
-0.06752364337444305,
-0.20313629508018494,
0.27211707830429077,
-0.15779303014278412,
0.06777919828891754,
-0.6011033654212952,
-0.15886160731315613,
0.3281475901603699,
0.8317319750785828,
-0.22062940895557404,
0.26655149459838867,
-0.27670010924339294,
-0.2138512283563614,
-0.3866384029388428,
0.002706813160330057,
-0.2226242870092392,
0.3686528205871582,
-0.05462849885225296,
-0.01903030276298523,
-0.06377451866865158,
-0.4267464876174927,
0.15906353294849396,
-0.3922501802444458,
0.37747761607170105,
-0.39222216606140137,
0.31844866275787354,
0.4663931131362915,
-0.668991208076477,
-0.037933770567178726,
-0.8911396265029907,
0.21886858344078064,
-0.6271809339523315,
0.3435947000980377,
0.5970398783683777,
0.3544493615627289,
-0.04728790000081062,
-0.8467580080032349,
-0.40016189217567444,
-0.046881053596735,
0.16223764419555664,
0.03423520550131798,
-0.16247130930423737,
0.23197047412395477,
0.31429845094680786,
0.5778800845146179,
-0.8905487656593323,
0.5539036393165588,
-0.22935903072357178,
-0.23623345792293549,
0.6851412057876587,
0.719491183757782,
0.5588944554328918,
0.37218916416168213,
-0.22496166825294495,
-0.014742599800229073,
-0.29519128799438477,
-0.27232879400253296,
-0.3659064471721649,
-0.10647285729646683,
-0.033105019479990005,
0.536220908164978,
-0.2201048880815506,
0.5163289904594421,
-0.10816111415624619,
-0.2920916676521301,
0.06338593363761902,
-0.12390173226594925,
-0.43661895394325256,
0.09674378484487534,
0.9022202491760254,
0.5283070802688599,
-0.1155012771487236,
-0.18217912316322327,
-0.40831562876701355,
0.3160265386104584,
0.3752407431602478,
-0.5393595695495605,
-0.15003763139247894,
0.40280959010124207,
-0.37211179733276367,
-0.2562575340270996,
-0.4912481904029846,
-0.8736521005630493,
-0.895026683807373,
-0.3893466591835022,
0.2838141918182373,
-0.39718666672706604,
-0.5137788653373718,
0.3384705185890198,
-0.08034461736679077,
0.2212817370891571,
0.3632644712924957,
-0.6033477187156677,
0.37519076466560364,
0.7532973289489746,
0.730697751045227,
-0.18533191084861755,
-0.10619482398033142,
-0.568811297416687,
0.027876906096935272,
-0.6690168380737305,
0.8507936000823975,
-0.6663792729377747,
-0.4193606376647949,
0.2208297997713089,
-0.029526712372899055,
-0.062172215431928635,
-0.6787310838699341,
0.6050525903701782,
-0.16814972460269928,
0.04127829149365425,
-0.017911113798618317,
-0.3843887448310852,
0.09851928055286407,
0.5109323263168335,
-0.23325085639953613,
1.187821865081787,
0.5623146295547485,
-0.3937799334526062,
0.3039553463459015,
-0.5095078945159912,
-0.2935267388820648,
0.15247488021850586,
-0.20101216435432434,
-0.15379199385643005,
0.257847398519516,
0.42244163155555725,
0.4556145668029785,
-0.703396737575531,
0.5062986016273499,
-0.6493735909461975,
-0.26925787329673767,
0.09733599424362183,
-0.10906714200973511,
0.7213805317878723,
0.2815921902656555,
-0.12424225360155106,
0.013420782051980495,
-0.5654422640800476,
-0.17659828066825867,
0.22617526352405548,
-0.0789632573723793,
-0.10861313343048096,
-0.1253378689289093,
0.2553402781486511,
0.2995798587799072,
-0.10240229219198227,
-0.4662315547466278,
0.23800982534885406,
-0.32554951310157776,
0.12453611195087433,
0.5758976936340332,
0.3419279158115387,
-0.08420121669769287,
-0.5200201272964478,
1.1225520372390747,
0.1616234928369522,
0.2806537449359894,
-0.14730733633041382,
-0.3264542818069458,
-0.29415905475616455,
-0.6537391543388367,
-0.15474089980125427,
0.886214017868042,
-0.38627931475639343,
0.5885684490203857,
-0.013294992968440056,
-0.6050586104393005,
-0.4624232053756714,
-0.11523453891277313,
0.19262103736400604,
0.6950139999389648,
0.2104651927947998,
-0.5321980714797974,
-0.8513385653495789,
-0.7698119878768921,
0.08868250250816345,
-0.1519194394350052,
-0.056942664086818695,
-0.05179547518491745,
0.2851695418357849,
-0.6959031224250793,
0.7909364104270935,
-0.5026335716247559,
-0.558947741985321,
-0.27943184971809387,
0.024849655106663704,
0.12943802773952484,
0.39142894744873047,
0.6263462901115417,
-0.20513851940631866,
-0.22053726017475128,
0.08996694535017014,
-1.094315767288208,
-0.41880273818969727,
-0.0038048550486564636,
0.06818805634975433,
-0.11607815325260162,
0.6201984286308289,
-0.713744580745697,
0.2928912937641144,
0.4628271758556366,
-0.5461688041687012,
0.6054234504699707,
-0.24053573608398438,
0.023259302601218224,
-0.9954212307929993,
-0.009973139502108097,
-0.0615101084113121,
-0.3654782474040985,
-0.4080422520637512,
-0.01408160850405693,
-0.3864341080188751,
-0.5807237029075623,
-0.19876156747341156,
0.44317710399627686,
-0.15284959971904755,
-0.2074819803237915,
-0.08021418750286102,
0.10739068686962128,
-0.10465095192193985,
0.1425151377916336,
0.025293976068496704,
0.5081127882003784,
0.7321082949638367,
-0.43525925278663635,
0.4856473505496979,
0.31082165241241455,
-0.2256404012441635,
0.8378487825393677,
-0.5125631093978882,
0.19365359842777252,
-0.10742700099945068,
0.5074472427368164,
-0.9753116369247437,
-0.3481879234313965,
0.19815684854984283,
-0.04651455953717232,
0.05435382202267647,
-0.07110738009214401,
-0.6822970509529114,
-0.4328550100326538,
0.05463525652885437,
0.6457821726799011,
0.47809016704559326,
-0.20754988491535187,
0.37229105830192566,
0.6976919770240784,
-0.6388441324234009,
-0.15355294942855835,
-0.4554901123046875,
0.33912393450737,
-0.3632248044013977,
-0.3810734748840332,
0.17761383950710297,
-0.2614869177341461,
-0.385129451751709,
-0.48394978046417236,
0.07570871710777283,
-0.4902387261390686,
0.2528474032878876,
0.13647542893886566,
0.34732210636138916,
-0.5275569558143616,
0.2532198429107666,
0.12266019731760025,
-0.2176707237958908,
0.38148587942123413,
-0.270259290933609,
0.5515857338905334,
-0.07362917810678482,
-0.5813479423522949,
-0.634852945804596,
0.6170139908790588,
0.9195389151573181,
-0.18389439582824707,
0.37537822127342224,
0.7034623026847839,
-0.770060122013092,
0.2662952244281769,
-0.7918378710746765,
-0.10632815957069397,
-0.3421093821525574,
0.4632233679294586,
-0.13676586747169495,
-0.7759577631950378,
0.5939038991928101,
-0.2815171778202057,
-0.24558772146701813,
0.42041465640068054,
0.7194888591766357,
-0.18520957231521606,
1.3422316312789917,
0.4780375063419342,
-0.12834468483924866,
0.11913322657346725,
0.05972567945718765,
0.26685288548469543,
-0.5861610770225525,
-0.013997466303408146,
-0.37937259674072266,
-0.044953927397727966,
-0.3117603063583374,
-0.3842567205429077,
0.6979246735572815,
-0.11192788928747177,
-0.48220303654670715,
-0.3807927966117859,
-0.5561845898628235,
0.31815606355667114,
0.06770186871290207,
0.1482122540473938,
0.36724036931991577,
-0.2656293213367462,
0.07080195099115372,
-0.21152067184448242,
-0.47142937779426575,
-0.5583336353302002,
1.0721890926361084,
0.46226149797439575,
0.3386208117008209,
0.06265632063150406,
0.6726356744766235,
0.47343483567237854,
0.538054347038269,
-0.7121500968933105,
0.291294664144516,
0.15177246928215027,
-0.3359774947166443,
-0.09533630311489105,
-0.01228043157607317,
-0.7567551732063293,
0.2647506594657898,
0.05673288553953171,
-0.6944968104362488,
0.2769138514995575,
-0.12437453120946884,
-0.654428243637085,
0.10391661524772644,
-0.5831782817840576,
0.9391075968742371,
-0.37936830520629883,
0.32623490691185,
-0.1581374555826187,
-0.4910884201526642,
0.5773190855979919,
-0.6436452269554138,
0.2958596348762512,
-0.22827106714248657,
-0.12360537797212601,
0.8759914636611938,
-0.5621402859687805,
0.8811970949172974,
-0.24576149880886078,
-0.2584238648414612,
-0.08522746711969376,
0.2574519217014313,
0.2719040811061859,
0.30211547017097473,
-0.09030066430568695,
0.045033663511276245,
0.5308272242546082,
-0.2690977454185486,
-0.6530165076255798,
0.3705308139324188,
-0.9013410210609436,
-0.5724925398826599,
-0.6337515115737915,
-0.6315292119979858,
-0.7339478135108948,
0.2052868902683258,
0.08661938458681107,
0.5371755957603455,
-0.5797194242477417,
-0.23266439139842987,
0.4801313579082489,
-0.4356076419353485,
0.23354728519916534,
0.6259787678718567,
-0.2906869053840637,
-0.46962103247642517,
0.39435631036758423,
-0.12076272070407867,
-0.1266828328371048,
-0.061184052377939224,
0.183302104473114,
-0.22087334096431732,
-0.7048320174217224,
-0.24971668422222137,
0.43810737133026123,
-0.6445093154907227,
-0.32434380054473877,
-0.6510860323905945,
-0.10084281861782074,
-0.7028939127922058,
-0.29478228092193604,
-0.3957173526287079,
-0.1335289478302002,
-0.09448682516813278,
-0.48543959856033325,
0.3660901188850403,
0.8439844846725464,
-0.09976767748594284,
0.16470417380332947,
-0.7218263745307922,
0.49927619099617004,
0.06308799237012863,
0.3527337610721588,
-0.1877565085887909,
-0.5048085451126099,
-0.13656093180179596,
-0.03297419473528862,
-0.21464677155017853,
-0.8328396677970886,
0.6338656544685364,
0.19329741597175598,
0.25676989555358887,
0.6551199555397034,
0.473307341337204,
0.8613846898078918,
-0.33864521980285645,
0.7678160667419434,
0.2679927349090576,
-0.7478584051132202,
0.6293911933898926,
-0.45644426345825195,
0.12876538932323456,
0.5903863906860352,
0.573522686958313,
-0.7252752184867859,
-0.6732783317565918,
-0.6040843725204468,
-0.6447359323501587,
0.7065712213516235,
-0.33147719502449036,
-0.030425308272242546,
-0.39681825041770935,
0.22689777612686157,
0.01783551648259163,
-0.2655715346336365,
-0.22763486206531525,
-0.017409738153219223,
-0.060398876667022705,
-0.5305739045143127,
-0.4438793957233429,
-0.48495447635650635,
-0.7237328290939331,
-0.573492169380188,
0.23988774418830872,
-0.008533637970685959,
0.643543004989624,
0.5072743892669678,
-0.1808093786239624,
-0.12051156163215637,
0.058441124856472015,
0.6557687520980835,
0.7396560311317444,
-0.17314819991588593,
0.2125532329082489,
0.39086204767227173,
-0.5287564992904663,
0.44202157855033875,
0.3005770742893219,
0.4622749984264374,
0.14606058597564697,
0.28427717089653015,
0.6258849501609802,
0.10324899107217789,
-1.0346698760986328,
0.64223313331604,
-0.1427759975194931,
-0.321611225605011,
-0.7133616805076599,
-0.16324445605278015,
-0.07715561240911484,
0.5899066925048828,
0.21475404500961304,
-0.19024166464805603,
0.036279357969760895,
-0.26974841952323914,
0.29849132895469666,
0.2147296965122223,
-0.31832438707351685,
-0.41273653507232666,
0.4375840127468109,
-0.13432267308235168,
-0.6854258179664612,
0.9058836102485657,
0.025841007009148598,
-0.27246350049972534,
0.6573486924171448,
0.8149780631065369,
0.9062759280204773,
-0.37871110439300537,
0.2446485012769699,
0.04243114963173866,
0.33846721053123474,
-0.2587549090385437,
0.2877862751483917,
0.1600702702999115,
-0.550087034702301,
-0.3858099579811096,
-0.47626522183418274,
-0.6062513589859009,
0.5233379602432251,
-0.9065890908241272,
0.1362457573413849,
-0.8644827008247375,
-0.3351368010044098,
-0.45030519366264343,
-0.27558034658432007,
-0.6733934879302979,
0.5182545185089111,
0.41145312786102295,
0.875465452671051,
-0.8918591141700745,
0.7340090870857239,
0.6302292346954346,
-0.35510459542274475,
-0.4112418293952942,
-0.1398448944091797,
0.12735402584075928,
-0.6638700366020203,
0.3021274209022522,
-0.00390948262065649,
0.3214346766471863,
0.0016308346530422568,
-0.15298639237880707,
-0.8482723832130432,
1.0109167098999023,
0.7468788623809814,
-0.15368619561195374,
-0.08355769515037537,
0.3730860650539398,
0.9278985857963562,
-0.4930908679962158,
0.4751910865306854,
0.74893718957901,
0.4593822956085205,
-0.05245668441057205,
-1.198957920074463,
0.08549317717552185,
-0.35329675674438477,
-0.008707692846655846,
-0.05474419519305229,
0.004641996696591377,
0.34674572944641113,
-0.21475516259670258,
-0.11685976386070251,
-0.16237899661064148,
0.23028476536273956,
0.20708180963993073,
0.586094856262207,
0.3124904930591583,
0.7348969578742981,
1.0226328372955322,
0.04701036587357521,
1.3754069805145264,
-0.44757190346717834,
0.193137988448143,
0.9126744866371155,
-0.5310795903205872,
0.824507474899292,
0.015715597197413445,
-0.2654057443141937,
0.24563387036323547,
1.029552936553955,
0.09773655235767365,
0.029751645401120186,
-0.046982213854789734,
-0.5926898717880249,
-0.31661704182624817,
-0.28046563267707825,
-0.5703511238098145,
0.5362865328788757,
0.47083592414855957,
-0.4355194866657257,
-0.38611268997192383,
0.3986562490463257,
-0.03661982715129852,
-0.23990808427333832,
-0.04391440749168396,
0.8803717494010925,
0.17350628972053528,
-0.535392701625824,
0.8579197525978088,
-0.02107756957411766,
0.16779543459415436,
-0.3773086369037628,
0.33423563838005066,
-0.4410088360309601,
0.22798365354537964,
-0.05264030769467354,
-0.5457841753959656,
0.7437405586242676,
0.11530076712369919,
-0.23645788431167603,
-0.5220558643341064,
0.3962363302707672,
-0.25129351019859314,
-0.5669527649879456,
0.2504919469356537,
0.6685414910316467,
0.18965373933315277,
-0.2880527079105377,
-0.6314809322357178,
0.2878990173339844,
-0.5071623921394348,
0.10112756490707397,
0.7018254995346069,
0.5437301397323608,
-0.18086479604244232,
0.6061726212501526,
0.5215209722518921,
0.13955102860927582,
-0.17437520623207092,
0.05566262826323509,
0.5603119730949402,
-0.7427607178688049,
-0.5253316760063171,
-0.8405267000198364,
0.20405951142311096,
0.2478664368391037,
-0.3873230516910553,
0.09346987307071686,
0.5200554132461548,
0.4355604946613312,
-0.11323684453964233,
0.8571351766586304,
0.26722392439842224,
0.6044397950172424,
-0.12419254332780838,
0.6586362719535828,
-0.49158337712287903,
0.0067879133857786655,
-0.4051370918750763,
-0.4700941741466522,
-0.5097637176513672,
0.48701393604278564,
-0.24498125910758972,
-0.11742320656776428,
0.8492471575737,
0.784422755241394,
-0.026874059811234474,
-0.189361110329628,
0.3321223556995392,
0.2833091616630554,
0.5377996563911438,
0.5593085885047913,
0.8186962604522705,
-0.2623613774776459,
0.36005154252052307,
-0.07599624991416931,
-0.24022626876831055,
-0.051406774669885635,
-0.6409276723861694,
-0.4687207043170929,
-0.680905282497406,
-0.611920177936554,
-0.21059514582157135,
0.13506393134593964,
0.9642630219459534,
0.5395023822784424,
-0.4965851604938507,
-0.22577473521232605,
0.20312990248203278,
-0.0404914952814579,
-0.3847512900829315,
-0.2661254405975342,
0.271574467420578,
-0.2338884025812149,
-0.49139365553855896,
0.5832852125167847,
0.487699955701828,
0.14729861915111542,
-0.16374889016151428,
0.15374605357646942,
0.0699077621102333,
-0.11676498502492905,
0.7960788011550903,
0.2618522047996521,
-0.7379993200302124,
-0.10073645412921906,
-0.2498454451560974,
-0.41544651985168457,
0.11649886518716812,
0.9303244948387146,
-1.0842828750610352,
0.3541242480278015,
0.13886192440986633,
1.1200517416000366,
0.1631338894367218,
-0.09833700954914093,
1.021758794784546,
-0.1936497986316681,
0.10801933705806732,
0.4565277397632599,
0.31880855560302734,
0.22761456668376923,
-0.4794304668903351,
0.42928847670555115,
0.44913962483406067,
-0.27853134274482727,
-1.3324060440063477,
0.022431815043091774,
-0.9142258167266846,
0.022816015407443047,
1.0301038026809692,
-0.11033343523740768,
0.26754480600357056,
-0.6464266777038574,
-0.3230123221874237,
0.20075774192810059,
0.05956769362092018,
0.9174483418464661,
0.4698082506656647,
-0.3496091961860657,
-0.38055843114852905,
-0.4330205023288727,
0.5339365601539612,
0.2949000895023346,
-0.7926384210586548,
-0.16825450956821442,
0.45970118045806885,
0.33206626772880554,
-0.44615688920021057,
1.1980191469192505,
-0.07585476338863373,
0.5993112325668335,
-0.23409296572208405,
0.035327088087797165,
-0.1219801977276802,
0.19328735768795013,
-0.5087968707084656,
0.21006420254707336,
0.08862728625535965,
0.05386028438806534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11162v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11162v1
|
LG AI Research & KAIST at EHRSQL 2024: Self-Training Large Language Models with Pseudo-Labeled Unanswerable Questions for a Reliable Text-to-SQL System on EHRs
| 2024-05-18T03:25:44 | 2024-05-18T03:25:44 |
Yongrae Jo, Seongyun Lee, Minju Seo, Sung Ju Hwang, Moontae Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text-to-SQL models are pivotal for making Electronic Health Records (EHRs)
accessible to healthcare professionals without SQL knowledge. With the
advancements in large language models, these systems have become more adept at
translating complex questions into SQL queries. Nonetheless, the critical need
for reliability in healthcare necessitates these models to accurately identify
unanswerable questions or uncertain predictions, preventing misinformation. To
address this problem, we present a self-training strategy using pseudo-labeled
unanswerable questions to enhance the reliability of text-to-SQL models for
EHRs. This approach includes a two-stage training process followed by a
filtering method based on the token entropy and query execution. Our
methodology's effectiveness is validated by our top performance in the EHRSQL
2024 shared task, showcasing the potential to improve healthcare
decision-making through more reliable text-to-SQL systems.
|
[
-0.04682912677526474,
-0.8035632371902466,
0.7752953171730042,
-0.39271077513694763,
-0.4208517372608185,
-0.1850997507572174,
0.21775272488594055,
-0.448334276676178,
0.1476295441389084,
0.6508681178092957,
-0.5308892726898193,
-0.32984277606010437,
-0.2796722650527954,
0.19773438572883606,
-0.4532621204853058,
1.30665922164917,
0.03315097466111183,
0.2694064974784851,
-0.6055917143821716,
-0.2897857427597046,
-0.29424339532852173,
-0.9415084719657898,
-0.4987144470214844,
-0.4753437340259552,
0.20299935340881348,
0.11709003150463104,
0.4046710431575775,
0.6370364427566528,
0.4072549343109131,
0.2543655037879944,
0.09722067415714264,
0.11798401176929474,
-0.3238726854324341,
0.12913094460964203,
-0.04359610378742218,
-0.5018020868301392,
-0.49982231855392456,
-0.6180920600891113,
0.4197187125682831,
0.15698495507240295,
-0.4921490252017975,
0.30559128522872925,
-0.013722318224608898,
0.743333637714386,
-0.4050091803073883,
0.00540851429104805,
-0.725916862487793,
0.28232407569885254,
-0.1708834320306778,
-0.31969159841537476,
-0.38232550024986267,
-0.2042902708053589,
-0.019607054069638252,
-0.1911626011133194,
0.0014780380297452211,
0.20216606557369232,
0.7118083238601685,
0.5356572270393372,
-0.4998365342617035,
-0.15461939573287964,
-0.73700350522995,
0.45810484886169434,
-0.7114241123199463,
0.6534621119499207,
0.6449424624443054,
0.17612433433532715,
-0.001325485180132091,
-1.0144312381744385,
-0.4160636067390442,
-0.10940458625555038,
-0.26634764671325684,
0.14229588210582733,
0.10898789763450623,
0.24248963594436646,
-0.03575201332569122,
0.08280041068792343,
-0.7988599538803101,
0.08048828691244125,
-0.21262681484222412,
-0.1821824163198471,
0.4832877814769745,
0.12650048732757568,
0.4504609704017639,
-0.12246290594339371,
-0.3260551393032074,
0.27044135332107544,
-0.41688668727874756,
-0.25819510221481323,
-0.25336411595344543,
0.16372080147266388,
0.18331414461135864,
0.5862532258033752,
-0.15773111581802368,
0.7742816805839539,
0.4692862629890442,
-0.06836678832769394,
0.32695770263671875,
-0.2672728896141052,
-0.17072615027427673,
0.361437052488327,
0.7430561184883118,
-0.14194895327091217,
-0.2188020646572113,
-0.40259799361228943,
-0.5558725595474243,
-0.35141316056251526,
0.6510054469108582,
-0.5560244917869568,
-0.589313268661499,
0.6893868446350098,
-0.6088885068893433,
-0.11845385283231735,
-0.31322747468948364,
-0.6958819031715393,
-0.1926591545343399,
-0.2838684320449829,
0.8687025308609009,
-0.23675212264060974,
-0.14956770837306976,
-0.13628724217414856,
0.16197364032268524,
0.08431357890367508,
0.20381882786750793,
-0.9687795042991638,
0.15481331944465637,
0.4144417643547058,
0.46862104535102844,
-0.14061957597732544,
-0.1497514843940735,
-0.4773657023906708,
0.14352823793888092,
-0.37777307629585266,
0.7921711206436157,
-0.032318685203790665,
-0.2433285117149353,
-0.028093811124563217,
-0.07110992074012756,
-0.22845987975597382,
-0.435967355966568,
0.28310129046440125,
-0.9329907894134521,
0.34549665451049805,
-0.11503461003303528,
-0.8410137891769409,
0.2576393485069275,
0.6253654360771179,
-0.40379342436790466,
1.0427303314208984,
0.02168939635157585,
-0.8143309950828552,
0.1881626546382904,
-0.49510154128074646,
-0.269041508436203,
0.3661963939666748,
-0.5030173659324646,
-1.0301673412322998,
-0.1434202790260315,
0.30081260204315186,
0.4072589576244354,
-0.2502744197845459,
0.3404328525066376,
-0.21950091421604156,
-0.21440190076828003,
0.05117199569940567,
-0.3483698070049286,
0.5103894472122192,
0.15811870992183685,
-0.3302379846572876,
0.2021724283695221,
-0.7533989548683167,
0.6732340455055237,
0.26307910680770874,
-0.4427448511123657,
-0.21385949850082397,
0.019228966906666756,
-0.1257135570049286,
0.27239829301834106,
0.42835545539855957,
-0.3412737250328064,
-0.11317889392375946,
-0.5354070663452148,
0.32333192229270935,
0.504891574382782,
0.20512014627456665,
0.30580276250839233,
-0.28554394841194153,
0.4344555139541626,
0.02394968830049038,
0.3405795395374298,
0.0056040920317173,
-0.4128949046134949,
-0.6662458181381226,
0.027873598039150238,
0.20725898444652557,
0.8051656484603882,
-1.0618523359298706,
0.7611613869667053,
-0.05651126056909561,
-0.6274943947792053,
-0.5339829921722412,
0.16529551148414612,
0.48755064606666565,
0.8588567972183228,
0.8187975287437439,
-0.16510945558547974,
-0.39845576882362366,
-0.5822935104370117,
-0.2980039119720459,
-0.552770733833313,
0.01901770941913128,
0.09971974045038223,
0.6482365727424622,
-0.2512243390083313,
0.9303916692733765,
-0.3282390832901001,
-0.4122399389743805,
-0.2925625741481781,
0.20778779685497284,
-0.12200254946947098,
0.39157000184059143,
0.20118549466133118,
-0.7537170648574829,
-0.2817607820034027,
-0.12606315314769745,
-1.056850552558899,
0.463360071182251,
-0.03688798472285271,
0.14559714496135712,
0.2131248414516449,
0.6940544247627258,
-0.45561814308166504,
0.4308985471725464,
0.41243553161621094,
-0.1664847433567047,
0.452475905418396,
-0.698695182800293,
0.1361495852470398,
-0.8991708159446716,
0.1642652153968811,
-0.117237888276577,
-0.27335843443870544,
-0.7735957503318787,
-0.2902304232120514,
0.3007999360561371,
-0.24205932021141052,
-0.42913758754730225,
0.5248400568962097,
-0.5862498879432678,
0.13046608865261078,
-0.04186778888106346,
-0.4556328058242798,
-0.14501452445983887,
0.32211214303970337,
0.06204754486680031,
0.697388231754303,
0.3944481909275055,
-0.6383782029151917,
0.2896665036678314,
0.6231376528739929,
-0.37548619508743286,
0.7120106816291809,
-0.7906391620635986,
0.5380721688270569,
-0.38592660427093506,
0.3311346769332886,
-0.8280913829803467,
-0.23545801639556885,
0.27650824189186096,
-0.36389508843421936,
0.32755687832832336,
-0.2881922125816345,
-0.31044337153434753,
-0.6589692234992981,
0.20292696356773376,
0.5166897773742676,
0.5844176411628723,
-0.5460370779037476,
0.7367810606956482,
0.5115553736686707,
0.03458590433001518,
-0.5600517988204956,
-0.8801453113555908,
-0.049600496888160706,
-0.18944577872753143,
-0.18178656697273254,
0.26131224632263184,
-0.027691995725035667,
0.14525797963142395,
0.14203035831451416,
-0.1181296855211258,
-0.5783478617668152,
-0.06250538676977158,
0.0886375680565834,
0.3438470661640167,
-0.11176151782274246,
0.5536642074584961,
-0.038874417543411255,
-0.07970287650823593,
0.27751386165618896,
-0.6508057713508606,
0.28385129570961,
0.08045370876789093,
-0.6249428987503052,
-0.7389916777610779,
0.24823981523513794,
0.29491132497787476,
-0.5707685947418213,
1.045788288116455,
0.33768516778945923,
-0.46458321809768677,
-0.12308937311172485,
-0.5124481916427612,
-0.5338253378868103,
-0.45683419704437256,
0.5925484299659729,
-0.11044760793447495,
-0.9436196684837341,
0.1482287496328354,
-0.12206416577100754,
0.036534421145915985,
0.544571578502655,
0.5138786435127258,
-0.407006174325943,
1.020739197731018,
0.46595215797424316,
-0.004644414875656366,
0.1265355944633484,
0.19917988777160645,
0.31332558393478394,
-0.3488254249095917,
-0.7256813049316406,
-0.6121928691864014,
0.29048261046409607,
-0.3069382905960083,
-0.41856488585472107,
0.8395046591758728,
-0.2518758475780487,
-0.35268834233283997,
-0.022481873631477356,
-0.6582381725311279,
0.3194483816623688,
0.37922877073287964,
0.45234936475753784,
0.12030529230833054,
-0.07960472255945206,
-0.047515057027339935,
0.0640140026807785,
-0.8961547613143921,
-0.12897846102714539,
1.0080866813659668,
0.32353174686431885,
0.6697547435760498,
-0.23207364976406097,
0.9515330195426941,
0.3943043649196625,
0.17556029558181763,
-0.4229568541049957,
0.3466114103794098,
0.029701391234993935,
-0.9960550665855408,
-0.703861653804779,
-0.6010656356811523,
-0.8687989115715027,
0.04264335334300995,
-0.3559425175189972,
-0.5724685788154602,
-0.06875063478946686,
0.694551944732666,
-0.4578375816345215,
0.5405768752098083,
-0.5479936599731445,
1.0914859771728516,
-0.7764610648155212,
-0.052872005850076675,
0.10353939980268478,
-1.016065001487732,
0.07234819233417511,
-0.48969700932502747,
0.27136000990867615,
0.27325254678726196,
0.16285350918769836,
0.8458853363990784,
-0.5525071620941162,
0.717333972454071,
-0.11909876018762589,
0.056711915880441666,
0.5557748079299927,
-0.25041696429252625,
0.6958150267601013,
-0.1957927793264389,
-0.22916243970394135,
0.2605060338973999,
0.3400380611419678,
-0.3863615095615387,
-0.4782393276691437,
0.3666859269142151,
-0.7320315837860107,
-0.4220709800720215,
-0.6840137839317322,
0.02212299033999443,
-0.5169926285743713,
0.3875729441642761,
0.41172537207603455,
0.38586845993995667,
-0.22688674926757812,
-0.01575419120490551,
0.8837785720825195,
-0.17998209595680237,
0.038302674889564514,
0.27302229404449463,
0.13039246201515198,
-0.3855101466178894,
0.7341436147689819,
0.36997678875923157,
0.17085622251033783,
0.5452993512153625,
-0.012913575395941734,
-0.886014997959137,
-0.6521503925323486,
-0.6514523029327393,
0.28371724486351013,
-0.6952165365219116,
-0.27531003952026367,
-0.8618355989456177,
-0.5794214010238647,
-0.4188336133956909,
0.29825085401535034,
-0.47876203060150146,
-0.06248101592063904,
-0.7054961919784546,
-0.17580172419548035,
0.4305623471736908,
0.6379005312919617,
0.19885534048080444,
0.22929705679416656,
-1.077573299407959,
0.3344772160053253,
0.550665020942688,
0.41405534744262695,
-0.06428691744804382,
-0.9583799839019775,
-0.3447985053062439,
-0.0029477914795279503,
-0.015305337496101856,
-0.9615876078605652,
0.21008488535881042,
0.17431612312793732,
0.48426875472068787,
0.21950429677963257,
0.3879888355731964,
0.644501268863678,
-0.9632955193519592,
0.6792078018188477,
0.4502066969871521,
-0.76658695936203,
0.7264249324798584,
-0.17761658132076263,
0.1878015398979187,
1.0045719146728516,
0.5799987316131592,
-0.17347273230552673,
0.024820992723107338,
-0.672421395778656,
-0.8723142147064209,
0.5131257176399231,
-0.10117590427398682,
0.18424269556999207,
-0.03379436209797859,
0.6728119850158691,
-0.3258950412273407,
0.3067678213119507,
-0.7213144898414612,
-0.5918817520141602,
-0.3480266034603119,
-0.39526480436325073,
0.011510525830090046,
-0.5125473737716675,
-0.009149458259344101,
-0.23856166005134583,
0.787462055683136,
-0.04605650156736374,
0.38449332118034363,
0.18362584710121155,
0.06443803012371063,
-0.23672525584697723,
0.40973058342933655,
0.013739322312176228,
0.6362209916114807,
-0.27342063188552856,
0.11269310116767883,
0.42590445280075073,
-0.2405373752117157,
0.2031872272491455,
0.08471832424402237,
-0.20343157649040222,
-0.056841205805540085,
0.028658708557486534,
0.7329979538917542,
-0.13403211534023285,
-0.5055130124092102,
0.4315379858016968,
-0.001658322406001389,
-0.2140672653913498,
-0.4826672077178955,
-0.11173009872436523,
0.0015129584353417158,
-0.13922373950481415,
0.20280008018016815,
-0.19091784954071045,
0.1255236715078354,
-0.41764524579048157,
0.6884967088699341,
0.29115739464759827,
-0.8012794256210327,
-0.0648312047123909,
0.9413334131240845,
0.06229137256741524,
-0.317941278219223,
0.8532041311264038,
-0.03706447035074234,
-0.5270448327064514,
0.45294538140296936,
0.7079402804374695,
0.43551355600357056,
-0.6417937874794006,
0.31010857224464417,
0.48123660683631897,
0.31562086939811707,
-0.5307188630104065,
0.3471391797065735,
0.19038435816764832,
-0.41815727949142456,
-0.22785505652427673,
-0.4002961814403534,
-0.40126803517341614,
0.22851556539535522,
-0.6891335844993591,
0.17247341573238373,
-0.3277244567871094,
-0.25531643629074097,
-0.2170943319797516,
-0.4354057013988495,
-0.487263560295105,
0.9423669576644897,
-0.19267062842845917,
0.4094029664993286,
-0.8503299355506897,
0.8026416301727295,
0.7722936868667603,
-0.3665524125099182,
-1.0463087558746338,
0.08774544298648834,
-0.04140615835785866,
-0.9133508205413818,
0.3031070828437805,
-0.18105463683605194,
0.28508567810058594,
0.20595699548721313,
-0.3777391314506531,
-0.750967264175415,
0.9490498304367065,
0.1627589613199234,
-0.6186550855636597,
-0.15061424672603607,
0.24582943320274353,
0.7509965300559998,
0.21595720946788788,
0.3790297508239746,
0.386599600315094,
0.2866056263446808,
0.13711729645729065,
-0.941893458366394,
-0.06403552740812302,
-0.07435905933380127,
-0.3460269272327423,
0.4075069725513458,
-0.4681885242462158,
0.5146406888961792,
-0.3295027017593384,
0.13099488615989685,
0.00515405461192131,
0.8845576047897339,
0.2310878187417984,
0.5277471542358398,
0.5881065130233765,
0.5293481349945068,
1.04811429977417,
0.039283160120248795,
1.140446662902832,
-0.28084421157836914,
0.3921545743942261,
1.379575252532959,
-0.23205377161502838,
0.9618926644325256,
0.44927167892456055,
-0.11634153872728348,
0.332232803106308,
0.5819602608680725,
-0.02547650970518589,
0.6192959547042847,
0.1035948395729065,
-0.281566321849823,
-0.5245512127876282,
-0.08912929892539978,
-0.612365186214447,
0.3127639591693878,
0.23024989664554596,
-0.30190467834472656,
-0.11565876752138138,
0.06589508801698685,
-0.06774402409791946,
-0.044193562120199203,
-0.20858611166477203,
1.0344061851501465,
0.2493574619293213,
-0.602116048336029,
0.4441370964050293,
-0.05067838728427887,
0.32212743163108826,
-0.7039595246315002,
0.07760962098836899,
-0.05447365343570709,
0.08784022927284241,
-0.2450345903635025,
-0.5739740133285522,
0.1893853098154068,
0.04994743689894676,
-0.03495439514517784,
-0.12781959772109985,
0.9508083462715149,
-0.4944378435611725,
-0.47179681062698364,
0.004424001555889845,
0.6970945596694946,
0.23579201102256775,
-0.14025957882404327,
-1.019824743270874,
-0.468722403049469,
0.013473205268383026,
0.06853736937046051,
0.544970691204071,
0.5361598134040833,
0.15894584357738495,
0.8197968006134033,
0.48459163308143616,
0.13038872182369232,
-0.11510669440031052,
-0.1045624166727066,
0.6722584962844849,
-0.386229008436203,
-0.7492560744285583,
-0.7238119840621948,
0.5120282173156738,
0.20735937356948853,
-0.1636250764131546,
0.5807632803916931,
0.4125250577926636,
0.4682285785675049,
-0.07670862972736359,
0.6996980905532837,
0.1830066740512848,
0.6878383755683899,
-0.47867459058761597,
1.080317735671997,
-0.8954024314880371,
0.20694737136363983,
0.01629849709570408,
-0.35045140981674194,
-0.22888125479221344,
0.4267156422138214,
-0.2830180823802948,
0.3948012888431549,
0.6433115601539612,
0.4607747793197632,
0.2804511785507202,
-0.2031140774488449,
0.43670353293418884,
0.13896770775318146,
0.1855778843164444,
0.29373693466186523,
0.6304304003715515,
-0.4842912554740906,
0.6731377243995667,
-0.18914298713207245,
-0.017768550664186478,
-0.12546686828136444,
-0.656112790107727,
-0.9794420003890991,
-0.5241953134536743,
-0.4656412899494171,
-0.6281694173812866,
0.5001793503761292,
0.8783462643623352,
0.662125289440155,
-0.9519382119178772,
0.13678885996341705,
-0.02313581481575966,
-0.08241769671440125,
0.08225102722644806,
-0.08376999944448471,
0.7136213183403015,
-0.2533056437969208,
-0.00529350433498621,
0.2518174946308136,
0.26960667967796326,
0.2365386039018631,
-0.02791932038962841,
0.10036254674196243,
-0.10117633640766144,
0.10140182822942734,
0.22164350748062134,
0.5905778408050537,
-0.35261714458465576,
-0.019853608682751656,
-0.07116418331861496,
-0.18389829993247986,
0.2458033263683319,
0.44829264283180237,
-0.6907742619514465,
0.5958983302116394,
0.2337428480386734,
0.912354052066803,
0.35903462767601013,
0.30057284235954285,
0.08974611014127731,
-0.5687751173973083,
-0.21777315437793732,
0.5720263123512268,
0.07775571942329407,
0.3236132860183716,
-0.707819938659668,
0.057469237595796585,
0.018455585464835167,
-0.8649415969848633,
-0.7454906105995178,
-0.062093861401081085,
-0.5216490030288696,
-0.18920771777629852,
0.9653781652450562,
-0.09940598905086517,
-0.11572109162807465,
-0.6306538581848145,
0.1909724920988083,
0.3452746272087097,
-0.1476600021123886,
1.052195429801941,
0.2400064915418625,
-0.33837443590164185,
-0.1828024685382843,
-0.5638993978500366,
0.7429513931274414,
0.8816071152687073,
-1.3347804546356201,
-0.28335288166999817,
0.30479156970977783,
0.3478121757507324,
-0.16888763010501862,
1.0970330238342285,
-0.22185783088207245,
0.23555223643779755,
-0.3765113651752472,
-0.030170733109116554,
0.12513136863708496,
-0.383352667093277,
-0.3688288927078247,
0.13284803926944733,
0.17967313528060913,
-0.28159502148628235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11157v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11157v1
|
Towards Modular LLMs by Building and Reusing a Library of LoRAs
| 2024-05-18T03:02:23 | 2024-05-18T03:02:23 |
Oleksiy Ostapenko, Zhan Su, Edoardo Maria Ponti, Laurent Charlin, Nicolas Le Roux, Matheus Pereira, Lucas Caccia, Alessandro Sordoni
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
The growing number of parameter-efficient adaptations of a base large
language model (LLM) calls for studying whether we can reuse such trained
adapters to improve performance for new tasks. We study how to best build a
library of adapters given multi-task data and devise techniques for both
zero-shot and supervised task generalization through routing in such library.
We benchmark existing approaches to build this library and introduce
model-based clustering, MBC, a method that groups tasks based on the similarity
of their adapter parameters, indirectly optimizing for transfer across the
multi-task dataset. To re-use the library, we present a novel zero-shot routing
mechanism, Arrow, which enables dynamic selection of the most relevant adapters
for new inputs without the need for retraining. We experiment with several
LLMs, such as Phi-2 and Mistral, on a wide array of held-out tasks, verifying
that MBC-based adapters and Arrow routing lead to superior generalization to
new tasks. We make steps towards creating modular, adaptable LLMs that can
match or outperform traditional joint training.
|
[
-0.08017950505018234,
-0.7241012454032898,
0.6115148663520813,
-0.2737874984741211,
-0.24123384058475494,
-0.0850449949502945,
-0.2024330198764801,
-0.10079621523618698,
0.30565324425697327,
0.49940308928489685,
-0.5264266729354858,
-0.612130343914032,
-0.502783477306366,
-0.14677445590496063,
-0.4340583384037018,
0.594794750213623,
0.023022139444947243,
-0.05629759654402733,
-0.13422632217407227,
-0.3649088740348816,
-0.6094065308570862,
-0.5545340776443481,
-0.6801703572273254,
-0.5820922255516052,
1.1720432043075562,
0.5544229745864868,
0.3108239769935608,
0.6525635123252869,
0.3930431604385376,
0.28589123487472534,
0.015002816915512085,
0.05583023652434349,
-0.47890016436576843,
0.34388962388038635,
-0.4689069986343384,
-0.786258339881897,
-0.6773749589920044,
-0.6541186571121216,
0.6171339154243469,
0.666530191898346,
-0.14920678734779358,
0.45311129093170166,
-0.18886858224868774,
0.8053018450737,
-0.7006136178970337,
0.08396384865045547,
-0.8612905144691467,
0.05285436287522316,
-0.28246787190437317,
0.029902217909693718,
-0.46242621541023254,
0.004499257542192936,
-0.12241555750370026,
-0.4839322566986084,
0.15754780173301697,
0.1637008637189865,
0.1421269178390503,
0.21721087396144867,
-0.4942079782485962,
-0.09620776772499084,
-0.6045576333999634,
1.0601400136947632,
-0.7176402807235718,
0.1474362015724182,
0.21723122894763947,
0.5648968815803528,
-0.32499366998672485,
-0.6343419551849365,
-0.2228553742170334,
0.18421238660812378,
0.10971403867006302,
-0.14501327276229858,
-0.2834790349006653,
0.003899468807503581,
-0.025458574295043945,
0.1926116645336151,
-0.5074208974838257,
0.2796969711780548,
-0.20887412130832672,
0.12975376844406128,
0.41161471605300903,
0.22295917570590973,
0.14252595603466034,
0.031227244064211845,
0.21647682785987854,
0.2402755320072174,
-0.868354082107544,
0.00878141913563013,
0.24431367218494415,
0.4585739076137543,
0.20516784489154816,
0.6329510807991028,
-0.3429073691368103,
1.036436915397644,
0.3839716613292694,
-0.31239748001098633,
0.2159363180398941,
-0.058800097554922104,
-0.22573037445545197,
-0.14513744413852692,
0.4098162055015564,
0.052855342626571655,
0.06159747391939163,
-0.3591967225074768,
-0.15289923548698425,
-0.06267006695270538,
0.5249804258346558,
-0.5715202689170837,
-0.01912318542599678,
0.2947515547275543,
-0.5682722330093384,
-0.22381870448589325,
-0.367998331785202,
-0.2887687087059021,
-0.07791163772344589,
-0.48957157135009766,
0.4892793595790863,
-0.2558436095714569,
-0.048279162496328354,
0.1999102085828781,
-0.014537577517330647,
0.3656255900859833,
0.3536292612552643,
-0.9711811542510986,
0.3665092885494232,
0.8578822612762451,
0.9534029960632324,
-0.48497965931892395,
-0.4075990319252014,
-0.6389630436897278,
0.5094109773635864,
-0.21334993839263916,
1.087782621383667,
-0.49241283535957336,
-0.33308908343315125,
0.20767782628536224,
0.38455167412757874,
-0.21613037586212158,
-0.760915219783783,
0.40551427006721497,
-0.42139071226119995,
-0.09185001999139786,
-0.28803324699401855,
-0.550311803817749,
-0.47778183221817017,
0.36176350712776184,
-0.5070363879203796,
0.8475639820098877,
0.12714388966560364,
-0.3493003845214844,
0.06529266387224197,
-0.6445118188858032,
-0.6810628771781921,
-0.11046717315912247,
-0.04764339327812195,
-0.30950459837913513,
0.5403494238853455,
0.16361461579799652,
0.7287037968635559,
-0.22673174738883972,
0.13073445856571198,
-0.5054608583450317,
-0.4937940239906311,
-0.04564685747027397,
0.05135399103164673,
0.49772652983665466,
0.09455950558185577,
-0.10675127059221268,
0.3900050222873688,
-0.6453331708908081,
-0.10789715498685837,
-0.27773982286453247,
-0.643724262714386,
-0.252422958612442,
0.43210145831108093,
-0.19936503469944,
0.07951219379901886,
0.2053799331188202,
-0.5173917412757874,
0.4286700487136841,
-0.08585270494222641,
0.41931337118148804,
0.7652727365493774,
-0.3092747628688812,
0.557451069355011,
-0.7865682244300842,
0.3771362006664276,
0.08389593660831451,
0.09605138748884201,
-0.38995361328125,
-0.40387943387031555,
-1.0784519910812378,
-0.3637423813343048,
-0.15636204183101654,
0.5368258357048035,
-0.6665090918540955,
0.4978976249694824,
-0.166908398270607,
-0.7622959017753601,
-0.42959389090538025,
0.18312354385852814,
0.06450730562210083,
0.35353997349739075,
0.2710602283477783,
-0.39936313033103943,
-0.4599857032299042,
-0.8850992918014526,
-0.0023676936980336905,
0.015951771289110184,
0.1261196881532669,
0.18530616164207458,
0.3254804015159607,
-0.3775799572467804,
0.8294932246208191,
-0.5626780390739441,
-0.18532292544841766,
-0.43148118257522583,
-0.03502640128135681,
0.5250727534294128,
0.36971306800842285,
0.5010906457901001,
-0.2650647759437561,
-0.5201111435890198,
0.2412792146205902,
-0.8521029949188232,
0.006166466046124697,
0.127170592546463,
-0.17345860600471497,
0.06077273562550545,
0.5243784785270691,
-0.39322614669799805,
0.13662411272525787,
0.6215441823005676,
-0.1059715673327446,
0.611163318157196,
-0.13221003115177155,
0.06739968806505203,
-1.211534857749939,
0.10539901256561279,
-0.2576828896999359,
-0.5024423003196716,
-0.8933386206626892,
0.1912737339735031,
-0.09935778379440308,
-0.10846558213233948,
-0.5594126582145691,
0.7149844765663147,
-0.5247334241867065,
-0.29257142543792725,
-0.698850691318512,
-0.1608506590127945,
-0.28793275356292725,
0.7735117077827454,
-0.20603853464126587,
0.37196609377861023,
1.1938389539718628,
-0.4269172251224518,
0.611323356628418,
-0.0910000205039978,
-0.27993395924568176,
0.9324933290481567,
-0.6051427125930786,
0.24627098441123962,
-0.33112743496894836,
0.3183733820915222,
-0.8985281586647034,
-0.0028667740989476442,
0.165223628282547,
-0.12117575109004974,
0.16597087681293488,
-0.506747305393219,
-0.5696507096290588,
-0.09770052880048752,
-0.3233957886695862,
0.5761342644691467,
0.6622404456138611,
-0.3553750514984131,
1.0090428590774536,
0.2595398426055908,
-0.20331022143363953,
-0.45921167731285095,
-0.7366345524787903,
-0.08132843673229218,
-0.39939945936203003,
-0.5888964533805847,
0.2197331339120865,
-0.24968691170215607,
0.04522758722305298,
0.1340213119983673,
-0.2489347904920578,
-0.24896754324436188,
0.010828124359250069,
0.4749622941017151,
0.0646020844578743,
-0.33182668685913086,
0.019833944737911224,
0.19456809759140015,
-0.1690000295639038,
-0.23566539585590363,
-0.5624232888221741,
0.5170167684555054,
0.16224390268325806,
-0.905134379863739,
-0.27745068073272705,
0.41355761885643005,
0.7059341669082642,
0.07775215059518814,
0.6195347905158997,
0.6464552879333496,
-0.22950932383537292,
-0.24058687686920166,
-0.7917028665542603,
-0.035156525671482086,
-0.4895957410335541,
0.601717472076416,
-0.26265084743499756,
-1.3489551544189453,
0.47530385851860046,
-0.2575261890888214,
0.41645920276641846,
-0.0173637755215168,
0.8438317775726318,
-0.11017242074012756,
0.3346620500087738,
0.6332592368125916,
-0.4130825996398926,
0.7270449995994568,
-0.07404814660549164,
0.12821955978870392,
-0.9713650941848755,
-0.012211674824357033,
-0.3102167546749115,
-0.7742752432823181,
-0.10524459928274155,
-0.9401726722717285,
0.24382026493549347,
0.10979285091161728,
-0.03158435970544815,
0.5266953110694885,
-0.11498219519853592,
0.42302483320236206,
0.5573436617851257,
-0.02196783758699894,
0.4111841917037964,
0.16118520498275757,
0.23165367543697357,
0.44368964433670044,
-0.9080595970153809,
-0.2452041059732437,
1.3469607830047607,
0.0900348499417305,
0.8139824867248535,
0.2394513636827469,
0.7800799012184143,
0.2834405303001404,
0.3371691405773163,
-0.9874749183654785,
0.7968206405639648,
-0.5124087929725647,
-0.48720815777778625,
-0.2152344137430191,
-0.16616640985012054,
-1.1314055919647217,
0.5062764883041382,
-0.11956150084733963,
-0.7530888915061951,
0.12302321940660477,
0.3441222310066223,
-0.18775248527526855,
0.5573265552520752,
-0.34676650166511536,
0.4763304591178894,
-0.07096666097640991,
-0.24215665459632874,
-0.5877432227134705,
-0.3048609793186188,
0.24270182847976685,
-0.3321942985057831,
0.24813374876976013,
-0.22592180967330933,
-0.13628555834293365,
0.516298234462738,
-0.1986531913280487,
1.0347038507461548,
-0.08899117261171341,
0.05523497238755226,
0.348304808139801,
0.07831185311079025,
0.44104471802711487,
-0.43661531805992126,
-0.3919532597064972,
0.13998335599899292,
-0.14417392015457153,
-0.6300688982009888,
-0.6493548154830933,
0.9198439717292786,
-0.7533547878265381,
-0.5702377557754517,
-0.0989273190498352,
-0.904564380645752,
-0.08398082852363586,
0.2448767125606537,
-0.2513076066970825,
0.710271418094635,
-0.11557913571596146,
0.26952871680259705,
0.5898436307907104,
-0.006234501488506794,
0.5673104524612427,
0.7608373761177063,
-0.34156426787376404,
-0.3151925504207611,
0.8650854229927063,
0.1342003047466278,
0.34875261783599854,
0.7110642790794373,
0.10595113784074783,
0.14886589348316193,
-0.8735564947128296,
-0.31088709831237793,
0.28918707370758057,
-0.5955763459205627,
-0.1477595716714859,
-0.2995138466358185,
-0.008858094923198223,
-0.33522289991378784,
-0.49101021885871887,
-0.2539404034614563,
-0.4792346656322479,
-0.3882777988910675,
-0.004101351834833622,
0.31615549325942993,
0.8296109437942505,
-0.13698145747184753,
0.603726863861084,
-0.6899316906929016,
0.2367081344127655,
0.5473859310150146,
0.14822226762771606,
0.34482282400131226,
-0.6516733169555664,
-0.46806684136390686,
-0.4015411138534546,
-0.2720825672149658,
-0.6231793761253357,
-0.011889215558767319,
0.15369494259357452,
0.8621332049369812,
0.23895278573036194,
-0.26121824979782104,
0.6126657128334045,
-0.899569571018219,
0.5673700571060181,
0.2592982053756714,
-0.674946665763855,
0.341678261756897,
-0.7121734023094177,
0.5566648840904236,
0.4017828702926636,
0.2252015620470047,
-0.4908328354358673,
-0.14404313266277313,
-0.07866613566875458,
-0.8591763973236084,
0.5522862672805786,
-0.052950065582990646,
0.07096084952354431,
0.15718558430671692,
0.6203879117965698,
0.07289572805166245,
0.19252216815948486,
-0.6938875913619995,
-0.383015900850296,
0.09492053836584091,
-0.20319536328315735,
-0.05241825431585312,
-0.22644250094890594,
-0.07591573148965836,
-0.18673619627952576,
0.542322039604187,
-0.3471972346305847,
0.28309550881385803,
-0.2018541693687439,
-0.2860635817050934,
0.005089033395051956,
0.4014756381511688,
0.2667697072029114,
0.7612056732177734,
-0.055564217269420624,
0.21377108991146088,
0.38201969861984253,
-0.035201236605644226,
0.40584659576416016,
-0.24195021390914917,
-0.15964652597904205,
-0.03089080937206745,
0.4470613896846771,
0.7684068083763123,
0.47424420714378357,
-0.6456711888313293,
0.1461050808429718,
0.24879410862922668,
-0.28402280807495117,
-0.10657094419002533,
0.2897598445415497,
0.4327377378940582,
0.46733155846595764,
0.08576508611440659,
0.06214764341711998,
-0.027581483125686646,
-0.759219765663147,
0.2174690216779709,
0.44010767340660095,
-0.36061954498291016,
-0.5142832398414612,
0.0644194632768631,
0.21102260053157806,
-0.6141893267631531,
0.13723136484622955,
-0.05241677910089493,
-0.03183354064822197,
0.15667763352394104,
0.6515517830848694,
0.8973388671875,
-0.33650821447372437,
0.14558716118335724,
0.32216575741767883,
0.15943999588489532,
-0.34777960181236267,
0.28000539541244507,
0.03651611506938934,
-0.525206983089447,
-0.6385131478309631,
-0.4866524934768677,
-0.2434624433517456,
-0.27184438705444336,
-0.7219973802566528,
0.3012724220752716,
-0.4639532268047333,
-0.08268863707780838,
-0.5059694647789001,
-0.5480580925941467,
-0.474142462015152,
-0.23499912023544312,
0.09932050108909607,
0.8033336997032166,
-0.7008203268051147,
1.1800731420516968,
0.924293041229248,
0.15543179214000702,
-0.41620635986328125,
-0.23679134249687195,
0.18330109119415283,
-1.0840915441513062,
0.4073255956172943,
-0.13759291172027588,
-0.18661150336265564,
-0.03634536266326904,
-0.1744271218776703,
-1.014738917350769,
1.4819153547286987,
0.21646955609321594,
-0.8485722541809082,
-0.25297218561172485,
0.14240673184394836,
0.30097633600234985,
-0.35269030928611755,
0.053984131664037704,
0.3301043212413788,
0.10919995605945587,
0.24858713150024414,
-0.8368030190467834,
-0.06967650353908539,
0.06929898262023926,
-0.02707553841173649,
0.2955983579158783,
-0.6484887599945068,
0.9548770189285278,
0.09435318410396576,
0.20414729416370392,
0.3017340898513794,
0.46541130542755127,
0.41805216670036316,
0.07075892388820648,
0.5763733983039856,
0.7725529074668884,
0.6042369604110718,
0.3066439926624298,
0.5999763011932373,
-0.2163301706314087,
0.27756786346435547,
1.2962121963500977,
-0.35382550954818726,
1.174181580543518,
0.513816237449646,
-0.025333346799016,
0.7818804979324341,
0.16685646772384644,
0.027341166511178017,
0.5250095725059509,
0.5349676609039307,
-0.5056729316711426,
-0.3191119134426117,
-0.009196020662784576,
-0.04056331515312195,
0.08597232401371002,
0.22922340035438538,
-0.02355993539094925,
-0.4894668161869049,
-0.0063772485591471195,
0.1465141475200653,
-0.2433631867170334,
-0.5953637957572937,
0.7279096245765686,
0.29829251766204834,
-0.6119168400764465,
0.19351045787334442,
0.12460964173078537,
0.9810540080070496,
-0.984813392162323,
0.32638001441955566,
-0.3309344947338104,
0.277837872505188,
-0.30268487334251404,
-0.4933323562145233,
0.5223421454429626,
-0.05878324434161186,
-0.5396367311477661,
-0.07415754348039627,
0.8232508301734924,
-0.35660478472709656,
-0.8425301313400269,
0.3047473132610321,
0.7420961856842041,
0.1554856151342392,
0.04342926666140556,
-0.5296806693077087,
0.12806519865989685,
-0.0888170525431633,
-0.026895010843873024,
0.8536500930786133,
0.338204950094223,
0.07612374424934387,
0.8282501697540283,
0.6654170155525208,
0.1010422483086586,
0.20976825058460236,
-0.009468828327953815,
0.9021854400634766,
-0.770479142665863,
-0.17765186727046967,
-0.867456316947937,
0.6171998381614685,
0.31470543146133423,
0.015418251045048237,
0.7301667332649231,
0.43941089510917664,
0.5838006734848022,
-0.10628079622983932,
0.7591166496276855,
-0.08631733059883118,
0.4547533392906189,
-0.4416273236274719,
0.4042598307132721,
-0.7012292146682739,
0.25642991065979004,
-0.15783432126045227,
-0.9933542013168335,
-0.2898068130016327,
0.507422149181366,
-0.1596910059452057,
-0.1962873935699463,
0.7133522629737854,
1.0263237953186035,
-0.43118929862976074,
-0.4430558979511261,
0.5979068875312805,
0.0746455043554306,
0.491389662027359,
0.766075074672699,
0.5162671804428101,
-0.13647986948490143,
0.4642869234085083,
0.13218918442726135,
-0.2461612969636917,
-0.183968648314476,
-1.0721745491027832,
-1.2294927835464478,
-0.417780339717865,
-0.3884636461734772,
0.13964058458805084,
0.1818150132894516,
0.733851432800293,
1.1632863283157349,
-0.7436479926109314,
-0.9360893964767456,
0.12563513219356537,
0.19987985491752625,
-0.21800683438777924,
-0.09786972403526306,
0.19002708792686462,
-0.4299010932445526,
-0.49308523535728455,
0.6509588360786438,
0.5284658074378967,
-0.28807103633880615,
-0.3484533131122589,
0.06299816071987152,
-0.2241441309452057,
0.001957522239536047,
0.9283600449562073,
0.24177700281143188,
-0.8523510694503784,
-0.2882493734359741,
0.034280721098184586,
0.35430440306663513,
-0.022702928632497787,
1.079393744468689,
-0.7031172513961792,
0.16107088327407837,
0.42099353671073914,
0.8535056114196777,
0.5005422234535217,
-0.2857944965362549,
0.6221638321876526,
-0.5037320256233215,
0.06259477883577347,
-0.21789933741092682,
0.6198006272315979,
0.18579234182834625,
0.1980903446674347,
0.3142884075641632,
0.21681447327136993,
-0.7869065403938293,
-0.6244645118713379,
0.5217921733856201,
-1.1797024011611938,
-0.41514939069747925,
1.1774749755859375,
-0.4020785689353943,
-0.18487337231636047,
-0.3193315267562866,
-0.1869277060031891,
-0.13446904718875885,
-0.28210100531578064,
0.5397794246673584,
0.5770407915115356,
-0.4528874158859253,
-0.15561024844646454,
-0.3469216525554657,
-0.14480632543563843,
0.30691468715667725,
-0.989166796207428,
-0.04955032095313072,
0.43059173226356506,
0.6644995808601379,
-0.017484428361058235,
0.8005285263061523,
0.26317548751831055,
-0.030475690960884094,
-0.282134473323822,
-0.0667356327176094,
-0.21146619319915771,
-0.3213469684123993,
-0.3789282739162445,
0.16862909495830536,
0.3327036499977112,
-0.1654120683670044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11125v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11125v1
|
A Reproducibility Study on Quantifying Language Similarity: The Impact of Missing Values in the URIEL Knowledge Base
| 2024-05-17T23:53:48 | 2024-05-17T23:53:48 |
Hasti Toossi, Guo Qing Huai, Jinyu Liu, Eric Khiu, A. Seza Doğruöz, En-Shiun Annie Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the pursuit of supporting more languages around the world, tools that
characterize properties of languages play a key role in expanding the existing
multilingual NLP research. In this study, we focus on a widely used typological
knowledge base, URIEL, which aggregates linguistic information into numeric
vectors. Specifically, we delve into the soundness and reproducibility of the
approach taken by URIEL in quantifying language similarity. Our analysis
reveals URIEL's ambiguity in calculating language distances and in handling
missing values. Moreover, we find that URIEL does not provide any information
about typological features for 31\% of the languages it represents, undermining
the reliabilility of the database, particularly on low-resource languages. Our
literature review suggests URIEL and lang2vec are used in papers on diverse NLP
tasks, which motivates us to rigorously verify the database as the
effectiveness of these works depends on the reliability of the information the
tool provides.
|
[
-0.3400160074234009,
-0.018718205392360687,
0.393893837928772,
0.5048638582229614,
-0.0005433973856270313,
-0.039927925914525986,
-0.10808335989713669,
-0.5596349835395813,
0.4052996337413788,
0.4088687598705292,
-0.12869927287101746,
-0.5858616828918457,
-0.416003555059433,
0.21149387955665588,
-0.5657177567481995,
0.8999223113059998,
-0.11226483434438705,
-0.2426362782716751,
-0.11537583917379379,
-0.7995541095733643,
-0.14377275109291077,
-0.6398413181304932,
-0.2205614149570465,
-0.32679688930511475,
0.560628354549408,
0.2315865457057953,
0.7185764312744141,
0.6371389031410217,
0.43677690625190735,
0.27544888854026794,
-0.08628585189580917,
0.002368429908528924,
-0.4848718047142029,
0.18340007960796356,
-0.24500098824501038,
-0.35359087586402893,
-0.36446326971054077,
-0.0383840836584568,
0.9776550531387329,
1.0120495557785034,
-0.3184393644332886,
0.3656485974788666,
0.358470618724823,
0.8632724285125732,
-0.512920081615448,
0.11369844526052475,
-0.4112817943096161,
0.20953308045864105,
-0.31020447611808777,
-0.16143712401390076,
-0.12236002087593079,
-0.5962547063827515,
0.24126264452934265,
-0.5056161880493164,
0.25083139538764954,
0.03506447747349739,
0.8997639417648315,
0.281623512506485,
-0.01956695318222046,
-0.18740269541740417,
-0.7550035119056702,
1.092757225036621,
-0.6224675178527832,
0.6079860925674438,
0.38957783579826355,
-0.006006291136145592,
-0.407827764749527,
-0.5677112340927124,
-0.2814355790615082,
-0.28318706154823303,
-0.22104515135288239,
-0.11588437110185623,
-0.3093589246273041,
-0.23319117724895477,
0.12623372673988342,
0.2766830027103424,
-0.5821965932846069,
-0.2420428842306137,
-0.22295120358467102,
-0.11765604466199875,
0.22518005967140198,
-0.010521326214075089,
0.39750054478645325,
-0.07607811689376831,
0.07297992706298828,
-0.15260444581508636,
-0.5356895923614502,
0.034586407244205475,
0.54622882604599,
0.18144643306732178,
-0.008368578739464283,
0.5744978785514832,
-0.2402990758419037,
0.5202950835227966,
-0.5795440077781677,
-0.40429800748825073,
0.5429654717445374,
-0.2855342924594879,
-0.09542014449834824,
-0.32272621989250183,
0.6464384198188782,
0.21125851571559906,
0.5491782426834106,
-0.5179944634437561,
0.07441505789756775,
-0.4342738091945648,
0.17268793284893036,
-0.19139933586120605,
-0.25487643480300903,
0.11423801630735397,
-0.35341060161590576,
-0.35950949788093567,
-0.022363224998116493,
-0.8554551601409912,
-0.0028823106549680233,
0.09817349910736084,
0.016371795907616615,
-0.4610103666782379,
-0.43942126631736755,
-0.19504646956920624,
-0.4008500874042511,
0.05870223790407181,
0.07722070068120956,
-0.9405171275138855,
0.3140689730644226,
0.6558724641799927,
0.8335608243942261,
-0.1263781636953354,
-0.85984867811203,
-0.09993612766265869,
-0.12691150605678558,
-0.3994048535823822,
0.8939803242683411,
-0.4153083264827728,
-0.23616831004619598,
-0.13552047312259674,
0.03890226036310196,
0.06041572988033295,
-0.7841832637786865,
0.32493674755096436,
-0.36065638065338135,
0.08659260720014572,
-0.38649630546569824,
-0.4648222029209137,
-0.22873109579086304,
0.11586927622556686,
-1.0168975591659546,
1.2103351354599,
0.5098575949668884,
-0.9258520603179932,
0.3610093593597412,
-0.07934697717428207,
-0.20232689380645752,
0.10393756628036499,
-0.2571616768836975,
-0.27072107791900635,
0.3034842312335968,
-0.3592625856399536,
-0.2560124695301056,
-0.10582524538040161,
-0.02083127200603485,
-0.39079025387763977,
-0.4718664288520813,
0.34275397658348083,
-0.5747305154800415,
0.7786936163902283,
-0.03914063051342964,
-0.40151286125183105,
-0.593961775302887,
-0.8932718634605408,
0.4499572515487671,
-0.03397907689213753,
-0.6502017378807068,
-0.4878784120082855,
-0.19183537364006042,
0.13183166086673737,
0.040885988622903824,
0.1812949776649475,
-0.3534626364707947,
0.02969437837600708,
-0.43331485986709595,
-0.014329463243484497,
0.38483282923698425,
-0.016904687508940697,
0.31840768456459045,
-0.356338232755661,
0.4122621715068817,
-0.49658074975013733,
-0.1998179703950882,
0.42199793457984924,
-0.6852964162826538,
-0.5430166721343994,
0.016402283683419228,
0.7712374329566956,
0.6405220627784729,
-0.3013443350791931,
-0.0007368046208284795,
-0.2834537625312805,
-0.4402064383029938,
-0.5941138863563538,
0.3204556703567505,
0.6405346393585205,
0.27969974279403687,
0.13305258750915527,
-0.1982862949371338,
-0.6527450084686279,
-0.962302565574646,
-0.4476204514503479,
-0.5080579519271851,
-0.18701867759227753,
0.13204564154148102,
0.4436923861503601,
-0.019799141213297844,
0.8094929456710815,
0.03224394470453262,
-0.024925922974944115,
-0.20574802160263062,
0.3760802447795868,
0.029167141765356064,
0.40401673316955566,
0.7983505129814148,
-0.37128746509552,
-0.2800545394420624,
0.022823244333267212,
-1.0527522563934326,
-0.3945747911930084,
0.38181158900260925,
0.12238764017820358,
0.6099810600280762,
0.21855896711349487,
-0.1721830517053604,
0.41634249687194824,
0.7904252409934998,
-0.03242717310786247,
0.5260456800460815,
-0.3796371519565582,
0.5350439548492432,
-0.8101605772972107,
0.400063693523407,
-0.18655800819396973,
0.014884154312312603,
-0.5018610954284668,
0.009486406110227108,
0.019299330189824104,
0.2422543615102768,
-0.3489496409893036,
0.4670664370059967,
-0.009352878667414188,
-0.45263728499412537,
-0.2425876259803772,
0.19550593197345734,
0.040217138826847076,
0.3884679079055786,
0.07787930220365524,
0.8832502365112305,
-0.022204231470823288,
-0.34442517161369324,
0.3882432281970978,
0.14496344327926636,
-0.45177552103996277,
0.7808788418769836,
-0.6637614369392395,
-0.2872030735015869,
0.015918711200356483,
-0.1858542412519455,
-0.831099808216095,
-0.06615358591079712,
0.3067692518234253,
-0.6489227414131165,
-0.025136305019259453,
-0.6802678108215332,
-0.4891502857208252,
0.04749589040875435,
-0.20911432802677155,
0.6543203592300415,
0.5613902807235718,
-0.35957011580467224,
0.2915409803390503,
0.4168212115764618,
-0.34070637822151184,
-1.0173249244689941,
-0.8404674530029297,
0.08360432833433151,
-0.3635267913341522,
-0.6257373690605164,
0.047406237572431564,
0.2747662365436554,
-0.6119095087051392,
0.4276094138622284,
-0.11861376464366913,
-0.23598703742027283,
0.05394915118813515,
0.33865171670913696,
-0.13553963601589203,
-0.2825039327144623,
0.4171050786972046,
-0.24821805953979492,
-0.25218144059181213,
0.06047578901052475,
-0.4391939043998718,
0.24971462786197662,
-0.32544538378715515,
-0.47940748929977417,
-0.3458176851272583,
0.37957650423049927,
0.5451978445053101,
0.10528263449668884,
0.700701117515564,
0.3836904466152191,
-0.4298713803291321,
-0.11987680196762085,
-0.5157529711723328,
0.25832563638687134,
-0.3486388027667999,
0.3713529407978058,
-0.3797980546951294,
-0.7418546080589294,
0.7590380907058716,
0.09608914703130722,
0.1798635721206665,
0.5958113074302673,
0.20907260477542877,
-0.3392782211303711,
0.4485264718532562,
0.8084710240364075,
-0.1681065559387207,
0.17085760831832886,
-0.030961785465478897,
0.10072091221809387,
-0.5283912420272827,
-0.44337892532348633,
-0.8715137839317322,
-0.12120581418275833,
-0.8080751895904541,
-0.095330148935318,
0.08615004271268845,
0.11397876590490341,
0.02844243124127388,
0.659967303276062,
0.11757206171751022,
0.45207005739212036,
0.7915168404579163,
-0.4276202619075775,
0.5390801429748535,
0.4923739433288574,
-0.22047601640224457,
-0.34588122367858887,
-0.6435064673423767,
-0.5362974405288696,
1.0462181568145752,
0.15059909224510193,
0.835293710231781,
0.20684075355529785,
0.7626347541809082,
0.5229578614234924,
-0.08115990459918976,
-0.4368012845516205,
0.235450878739357,
-0.07360241562128067,
-0.32742467522621155,
-0.672191858291626,
-0.6235513687133789,
-0.9899035692214966,
0.28826114535331726,
-0.10148158669471741,
-0.9328509569168091,
0.12716995179653168,
0.07734957337379456,
-0.1973918080329895,
0.4156215190887451,
-0.397516131401062,
0.9406104683876038,
-0.0005953651270829141,
-0.141191765666008,
-0.1376764476299286,
-0.3750953674316406,
-0.0410979725420475,
-0.14328765869140625,
0.22487293183803558,
-0.1424061506986618,
0.19567319750785828,
1.0646882057189941,
-0.4387664198875427,
0.47779417037963867,
0.31734341382980347,
-0.3648390769958496,
0.18637241423130035,
0.2590799033641815,
0.1589367389678955,
0.18047964572906494,
0.02669696882367134,
0.4466746151447296,
0.3139764666557312,
-0.6773877143859863,
-0.7425718903541565,
0.995708167552948,
-0.7375848889350891,
-0.26979613304138184,
-0.4319272041320801,
-0.5472472310066223,
-0.1825220137834549,
0.17059461772441864,
0.21158653497695923,
0.5128415822982788,
-0.37440580129623413,
-0.06611926108598709,
0.5298461318016052,
-0.24181389808654785,
0.2600339949131012,
0.469684898853302,
-0.06418115645647049,
-0.33624881505966187,
1.106277346611023,
0.28567585349082947,
0.19319573044776917,
0.26560303568840027,
-0.21494130790233612,
-0.2102586179971695,
-0.3481716513633728,
-0.36523541808128357,
0.3335258364677429,
-0.7102825045585632,
0.10091962665319443,
-0.6271013617515564,
-0.21850092709064484,
-0.34642869234085083,
-0.010793326422572136,
-0.6630832552909851,
-0.712797999382019,
0.06743113696575165,
-0.11157967150211334,
0.30220308899879456,
1.0931801795959473,
-0.34430500864982605,
0.008501640520989895,
-0.8592803478240967,
0.0912044495344162,
0.3744741678237915,
0.5893914699554443,
-0.06734281033277512,
-0.621344804763794,
-0.270859032869339,
0.04518163949251175,
0.2934770882129669,
-0.820332407951355,
0.39460325241088867,
-0.02706027589738369,
0.7624519467353821,
-0.010100483894348145,
-0.19261077046394348,
0.45559611916542053,
-0.16947832703590393,
0.5626049637794495,
-0.25618863105773926,
-0.8005678057670593,
0.25064364075660706,
-0.046425867825746536,
-0.0038002682849764824,
0.7420209050178528,
0.1757914274930954,
-0.7402961850166321,
-0.5641301870346069,
-0.8784832954406738,
-0.7265080809593201,
0.4557437300682068,
0.505666971206665,
-0.17905955016613007,
0.168391615152359,
0.230064257979393,
-0.011343519203364849,
0.2180982083082199,
-0.3917189836502075,
-0.42696458101272583,
0.00036157204885967076,
-0.1686042845249176,
0.14950911700725555,
-0.5471832752227783,
-0.04404022544622421,
0.15147708356380463,
0.5698972344398499,
0.21294823288917542,
0.10134368389844894,
0.0009364182478748262,
-0.2350005805492401,
-0.10359729081392288,
0.48947566747665405,
0.5827459692955017,
0.9437301754951477,
-0.5653645992279053,
0.4190995693206787,
0.353136271238327,
-0.4636785686016083,
0.18842779099941254,
-0.017877677455544472,
-0.10455185174942017,
0.4029697775840759,
0.5763936638832092,
0.19397442042827606,
0.23670169711112976,
-0.7304683923721313,
0.24923257529735565,
-0.07324180752038956,
-0.2648187279701233,
-0.5173811316490173,
-0.21796327829360962,
0.05330750718712807,
0.35556256771087646,
0.19495521485805511,
0.07577451318502426,
0.055349189788103104,
-0.23525682091712952,
0.48845022916793823,
0.21937577426433563,
-0.44369539618492126,
-0.2716689705848694,
0.10940610617399216,
-0.019130676984786987,
-0.20843687653541565,
0.8696167469024658,
-0.2956157326698303,
-0.2771875858306885,
0.7865275740623474,
0.3231445550918579,
0.5193529725074768,
0.05671568214893341,
0.4315842390060425,
0.27828675508499146,
0.5730394721031189,
-0.3455061614513397,
0.13792014122009277,
0.37371769547462463,
-0.6516046524047852,
-0.38272327184677124,
-0.5151018500328064,
-0.430891752243042,
0.2539333701133728,
-0.6801535487174988,
-0.17139552533626556,
-0.16105973720550537,
-0.006653811316937208,
0.03803297132253647,
-0.027113420888781548,
-0.39677008986473083,
-0.1860082894563675,
-0.12468446046113968,
0.7882667779922485,
-1.0775600671768188,
0.7901331186294556,
0.5538637638092041,
-0.3891119658946991,
-0.8067150115966797,
-0.07640054821968079,
0.0645405501127243,
-0.941011905670166,
0.6812623143196106,
-0.2653699815273285,
-0.25293034315109253,
-0.13719302415847778,
-0.12980525195598602,
-0.9219397902488708,
0.9438638687133789,
0.41376352310180664,
-0.1282719373703003,
0.14881688356399536,
0.5029187202453613,
0.7501603960990906,
-0.1628277599811554,
0.07056701183319092,
0.6740438342094421,
0.4031655788421631,
-0.0740470364689827,
-1.068399429321289,
-0.0734306201338768,
-0.30538511276245117,
0.13658304512500763,
0.2768837511539459,
-0.2914719879627228,
0.514780580997467,
-0.40064099431037903,
-0.22320233285427094,
0.2668227553367615,
0.5349991321563721,
0.1859102100133896,
0.08448832482099533,
0.14467883110046387,
1.0181341171264648,
0.8610752820968628,
0.04690919443964958,
0.7347719073295593,
-0.24022126197814941,
0.7080876231193542,
1.162883996963501,
0.022728152573108673,
0.7266240119934082,
0.595909059047699,
-0.40880176424980164,
0.49033161997795105,
0.15702904760837555,
-0.21533793210983276,
0.3023003935813904,
0.09301730245351791,
-0.21176883578300476,
0.010194787755608559,
-0.2927474081516266,
-0.5406413078308105,
0.1914544254541397,
0.1615951806306839,
-0.46351900696754456,
-0.561717689037323,
-0.28933221101760864,
0.1355975866317749,
-0.008038160391151905,
0.16481103003025055,
0.5466486215591431,
-0.02440890297293663,
-0.3889143168926239,
0.69679856300354,
-0.008060396648943424,
0.15902911126613617,
-0.37066617608070374,
-0.28091225028038025,
-0.7626722455024719,
-0.05528051778674126,
-0.17629040777683258,
-0.995014488697052,
0.4740375578403473,
-0.12470505386590958,
-0.22097863256931305,
0.03364267945289612,
0.43560636043548584,
-0.42423519492149353,
-0.34904903173446655,
0.3293764591217041,
0.973987877368927,
0.43890607357025146,
-0.03455145284533501,
-0.3420122563838959,
-0.059960752725601196,
0.029862171038985252,
-0.02540775202214718,
0.3535974323749542,
0.6252361536026001,
-0.016289688646793365,
0.9622652530670166,
0.17961959540843964,
0.14851604402065277,
0.07150842994451523,
0.23103390634059906,
0.4277162253856659,
-0.8746600151062012,
0.019002726301550865,
-0.8393159508705139,
-0.04278668761253357,
0.0689270868897438,
-0.38851138949394226,
0.8456633687019348,
0.4578951597213745,
1.0583521127700806,
-0.08083654195070267,
1.0179945230484009,
-0.13526229560375214,
0.4943828284740448,
-0.18959863483905792,
0.6351398229598999,
-0.4246685206890106,
0.30670079588890076,
-0.25016504526138306,
-0.9751142263412476,
-0.4051680266857147,
0.5149165391921997,
0.20793473720550537,
-0.0431726910173893,
0.9562217593193054,
0.8329838514328003,
0.009362626820802689,
-0.2243233323097229,
0.42306628823280334,
-0.12374044209718704,
-0.14979059994220734,
0.5273393392562866,
0.7356826066970825,
-0.3863966464996338,
1.0252764225006104,
-0.4278978705406189,
-0.2721156179904938,
-0.11847774684429169,
-0.6909124851226807,
-0.8141126036643982,
-0.6316646337509155,
-0.17943239212036133,
-0.7505640387535095,
0.39876943826675415,
0.8387420773506165,
0.3270472586154938,
-1.082473635673523,
-0.3813484311103821,
0.025428682565689087,
0.5767378211021423,
-0.3198634386062622,
-0.19464509189128876,
0.41622430086135864,
-0.3440812826156616,
-0.5752967596054077,
0.03937531262636185,
0.40046223998069763,
0.31852781772613525,
-0.1594475954771042,
0.05399928614497185,
0.167405366897583,
-0.3549271821975708,
0.11712020635604858,
0.8888410329818726,
-0.7882810235023499,
-0.3350335955619812,
0.06003102660179138,
-0.3453810513019562,
-0.012492123991250992,
0.7290735840797424,
-0.7048115730285645,
-0.006590279284864664,
0.7238451242446899,
0.6137447357177734,
-0.14993925392627716,
-0.11529222875833511,
0.6748234033584595,
-0.6140981912612915,
0.05813281983137131,
-0.17657379806041718,
0.5124308466911316,
0.1792892962694168,
0.18894009292125702,
0.7585052251815796,
0.5080329179763794,
-0.5038961172103882,
-0.4845719039440155,
0.3496433198451996,
-0.9123284816741943,
-0.02209511026740074,
1.1486767530441284,
-0.4697210192680359,
-0.16984429955482483,
-0.543660044670105,
-0.00017410775762982666,
-0.061361655592918396,
-0.4625663757324219,
0.918799877166748,
0.7937150597572327,
0.09086617827415466,
-0.20930281281471252,
-0.5700069665908813,
0.6031166911125183,
0.2961222529411316,
-0.4980263411998749,
0.10856862366199493,
0.2385026216506958,
0.6495671272277832,
0.41580504179000854,
0.5967664122581482,
-0.24479180574417114,
0.051339782774448395,
0.25872087478637695,
0.2220153957605362,
0.1905403435230255,
-0.3022279739379883,
-0.14619609713554382,
0.32892361283302307,
0.4158321022987366,
0.006030702497810125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11117v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11117v2
|
Dynamic Embeddings with Task-Oriented prompting
| 2024-05-17T23:18:15 | 2024-06-21T20:51:59 |
Allmin Balloccu, Jack Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces Dynamic Embeddings with Task-Oriented prompting
(DETOT), a novel approach aimed at improving the adaptability and efficiency of
machine learning models by implementing a flexible embedding layer. Unlike
traditional static embeddings [14], DETOT dynamically adjusts embeddings based
on task-specific requirements and performance feedback, optimizing input data
representation for individual tasks [4]. This method enhances both accuracy and
computational performance by tailoring the representation layer to meet the
unique needs of each task. The structure of DETOT is detailed, highlighting its
task-specific adaptation, continuous feedback loop, and mechanisms for
preventing overfitting. Empirical evaluations demonstrate its superiority over
existing methods.
|
[
-0.17596419155597687,
-1.0789101123809814,
0.43961381912231445,
0.11791060119867325,
-0.3071272671222687,
0.4776010513305664,
-0.05043698102235794,
-0.11345640569925308,
0.12688544392585754,
0.2307901382446289,
-0.9520447850227356,
-0.4392785429954529,
-0.6030985116958618,
-0.02182631567120552,
-0.2510627210140228,
0.8198915719985962,
-0.32499802112579346,
-0.17996832728385925,
-0.39754438400268555,
-0.10556621849536896,
-1.2124593257904053,
-0.26802492141723633,
-0.5685998201370239,
-0.17252574861049652,
0.519967794418335,
0.44782203435897827,
0.4538388252258301,
0.5935457348823547,
0.366554319858551,
0.2945113778114319,
0.28570014238357544,
0.20342306792736053,
-0.3017362356185913,
0.9647575616836548,
-0.2139030396938324,
-0.6783705949783325,
-0.13351304829120636,
-0.1419135183095932,
0.7590048313140869,
0.5347439050674438,
-0.2699695825576782,
0.11462726444005966,
0.28281983733177185,
0.8160182237625122,
-0.772702157497406,
0.25833141803741455,
-0.5338799357414246,
0.32314684987068176,
-0.02219177596271038,
-0.5050355792045593,
-0.6249128580093384,
-0.44044867157936096,
0.24569472670555115,
-0.5205112099647522,
0.12997670471668243,
-0.2982679605484009,
0.3250378966331482,
0.9412482380867004,
-0.38626450300216675,
-0.30158692598342896,
-0.733603298664093,
0.7394097447395325,
-0.18620853126049042,
0.4509766101837158,
0.23128385841846466,
0.5184764862060547,
-0.11885391175746918,
-0.7509320378303528,
-0.04389713332056999,
-0.31500130891799927,
0.26241499185562134,
0.07473845779895782,
0.01588553749024868,
-0.09687570482492447,
0.3296668827533722,
-0.12174924463033676,
-0.22556009888648987,
0.12133204936981201,
-0.05921361595392227,
0.2435884028673172,
0.5007656812667847,
0.22869090735912323,
0.2953261435031891,
0.19769062101840973,
-0.4586888253688812,
-0.10634718835353851,
-0.5983193516731262,
0.13217845559120178,
0.3809361457824707,
0.46763429045677185,
-0.0762629359960556,
0.3899315297603607,
0.03697852045297623,
0.6859402656555176,
0.6602321267127991,
0.2225583791732788,
0.45840898156166077,
0.11950311809778214,
-0.13972273468971252,
0.2858467996120453,
0.16092759370803833,
0.023923372849822044,
0.1582365781068802,
0.059393592178821564,
-0.1431366205215454,
-0.30561479926109314,
0.6970128417015076,
-0.7023018598556519,
-0.35048070549964905,
0.609287440776825,
-0.5247973203659058,
-0.5520898103713989,
0.0954621210694313,
-0.9019279479980469,
-0.5875133275985718,
-0.4430444836616516,
0.2917558550834656,
-0.7402628660202026,
-0.21698924899101257,
-0.08270566165447235,
-0.3026520609855652,
-0.24701213836669922,
0.8019628524780273,
-0.6649742126464844,
-0.016774555668234825,
0.3838230073451996,
0.9455893635749817,
-0.47330641746520996,
-0.19836020469665527,
-0.8316484689712524,
0.24285566806793213,
-0.1726701259613037,
0.6396452784538269,
-1.052367925643921,
-0.40294188261032104,
0.26274076104164124,
-0.07090730965137482,
-0.3033495545387268,
-0.5669282674789429,
0.21133749186992645,
-0.4365348219871521,
0.012305399402976036,
-0.5511974096298218,
-0.5841291546821594,
-0.5375469923019409,
0.2619278132915497,
-0.7499433755874634,
1.385032057762146,
0.3242345452308655,
-0.7824676632881165,
0.5657781958580017,
-1.1905232667922974,
-0.2005525827407837,
0.3002307415008545,
-0.11836568266153336,
-0.2985561788082123,
0.33920788764953613,
0.19720809161663055,
0.6097645163536072,
0.19607648253440857,
0.38531893491744995,
-0.24258053302764893,
-0.30877989530563354,
0.31273403763771057,
-0.49848198890686035,
0.8286647796630859,
0.15054190158843994,
-0.5729731321334839,
0.48882532119750977,
-0.744059681892395,
-0.041842635720968246,
0.22612690925598145,
-0.3128719925880432,
-0.43000802397727966,
0.3167911469936371,
-0.22973573207855225,
0.053932834416627884,
0.2993471324443817,
-0.30019015073776245,
0.6531935930252075,
0.22006972134113312,
0.4050704538822174,
1.0638298988342285,
0.037605736404657364,
0.0893971174955368,
-0.32347673177719116,
0.8128949403762817,
0.1936923712491989,
-0.12043698877096176,
-0.2797161340713501,
-0.31922203302383423,
-0.3408512473106384,
-0.6871359348297119,
0.4369460940361023,
0.8031718134880066,
-0.8618062734603882,
0.4612751007080078,
0.24049925804138184,
-0.3233371078968048,
-0.46551594138145447,
0.13796785473823547,
0.009770741686224937,
0.28416168689727783,
0.317582905292511,
-0.1651274859905243,
-0.5259575843811035,
-0.44852128624916077,
0.03147836774587631,
-0.03070111572742462,
0.08339639008045197,
-0.0037996023893356323,
0.4747513234615326,
-0.16920894384384155,
0.7249244451522827,
-0.3715265393257141,
0.13110727071762085,
-0.21038174629211426,
0.3068483769893646,
0.06596086174249649,
0.7114461660385132,
0.8180111646652222,
-0.5663169026374817,
-0.7307303547859192,
-0.35230761766433716,
-0.7833539843559265,
-0.10244151204824448,
-0.4036242961883545,
-0.15852424502372742,
-0.021434083580970764,
0.5050378441810608,
-0.6092665195465088,
0.4728699326515198,
0.3548716902732849,
-0.4259219765663147,
0.8542996644973755,
-0.3702283501625061,
0.10248110443353653,
-0.6956393122673035,
0.029636478051543236,
-0.3969734311103821,
-0.31640130281448364,
-0.6765866279602051,
0.19356027245521545,
0.15587535500526428,
-0.09371988475322723,
-0.5193014144897461,
0.31740134954452515,
-0.4960397779941559,
0.3403785228729248,
-0.23761329054832458,
-0.02832081913948059,
-0.2575359642505646,
0.30870577692985535,
-0.07206754386425018,
0.6218897104263306,
0.9021526575088501,
-0.7638112306594849,
0.6235952973365784,
0.24871096014976501,
-0.22010910511016846,
0.9553940892219543,
-0.7235830426216125,
0.2525736093521118,
-0.22909493744373322,
0.4496873915195465,
-1.0069040060043335,
-0.2261034995317459,
0.34292739629745483,
-0.13400302827358246,
0.6488999128341675,
-0.07936100661754608,
-0.4534526467323303,
-0.5245702862739563,
-0.6243536472320557,
0.40430745482444763,
0.5016025304794312,
-0.728524386882782,
0.5576254725456238,
0.012482298538088799,
-0.11826958507299423,
-0.59229576587677,
-0.5899685621261597,
-0.346204549074173,
-0.2683461308479309,
-0.24693584442138672,
0.5233751535415649,
-0.2102493941783905,
0.20428366959095,
0.1435776650905609,
0.08789203315973282,
0.06949110329151154,
0.29096001386642456,
0.526355504989624,
0.13592158257961273,
-0.09022057056427002,
0.3031291365623474,
0.4718025326728821,
-0.07200458645820618,
0.07145552337169647,
-0.3656005263328552,
0.6403999328613281,
0.18000797927379608,
-0.7806993722915649,
-0.8288013339042664,
0.4706994593143463,
0.5650743842124939,
-0.23015610873699188,
0.658211886882782,
0.8869102597236633,
-0.3960534930229187,
-0.5395447611808777,
-0.1902988851070404,
-0.34225839376449585,
-0.5985864996910095,
0.40044277906417847,
-0.5372716188430786,
-0.8123670816421509,
0.49828553199768066,
-0.29889801144599915,
0.33608299493789673,
0.2530701756477356,
0.8931638598442078,
-0.3714628219604492,
1.17560875415802,
0.67698073387146,
0.27607962489128113,
0.9405819773674011,
-0.2199035882949829,
-0.15654681622982025,
-0.7522481679916382,
-0.48496952652931213,
-0.3590843975543976,
-0.9487293362617493,
-0.6060132384300232,
-0.5693501234054565,
-0.022420678287744522,
0.02954205311834812,
-0.44882693886756897,
0.05221853777766228,
-1.0130364894866943,
0.10800938308238983,
0.8755210638046265,
0.26980799436569214,
-0.3276992440223694,
0.048618994653224945,
-0.32234615087509155,
-0.01885681040585041,
-0.6929208040237427,
-0.23052939772605896,
0.8268095850944519,
0.5089160799980164,
0.8797948956489563,
0.10075907409191132,
0.6725459098815918,
0.6243290901184082,
-0.08945746719837189,
-0.8410170674324036,
0.5185493230819702,
-0.02825818955898285,
-0.5265952944755554,
-0.23029053211212158,
-0.11326257884502411,
-1.167960524559021,
-0.17153754830360413,
-0.11624588817358017,
-1.0926904678344727,
0.4684785008430481,
0.4175252318382263,
-0.44153618812561035,
0.47569188475608826,
-0.6721755266189575,
0.5954465270042419,
-0.31129157543182373,
-0.3481373190879822,
-0.17429396510124207,
-0.3863176703453064,
-0.15703007578849792,
0.015880612656474113,
-0.48230910301208496,
-0.24106928706169128,
-0.3100051283836365,
0.7401955723762512,
-0.36425575613975525,
1.1917269229888916,
-0.8376134634017944,
0.16102257370948792,
0.6632651090621948,
0.44125503301620483,
0.9099169969558716,
-0.13891957700252533,
-0.2883674204349518,
-0.21531942486763,
0.07433006912469864,
-0.47453197836875916,
-0.9993433952331543,
0.6051562428474426,
-0.6956359148025513,
-0.7145839333534241,
-0.4095698297023773,
-1.0959956645965576,
-0.2878740727901459,
0.09711575508117676,
-0.2001844346523285,
0.382548987865448,
0.20470885932445526,
0.47700023651123047,
0.695266604423523,
-0.342189222574234,
0.46516647934913635,
0.11383775621652603,
-0.08272138237953186,
-0.12698981165885925,
0.9321423768997192,
0.15902334451675415,
-0.015672054141759872,
0.4517151415348053,
0.2676721215248108,
-0.357316792011261,
-0.4553486406803131,
-0.4865654408931732,
0.037537746131420135,
-0.6481491327285767,
-0.09618068486452103,
-0.6397913694381714,
-0.05588192865252495,
-0.19193005561828613,
-0.5552112460136414,
-0.32262036204338074,
-0.5636658072471619,
-0.4487377107143402,
-0.38430291414260864,
0.7912679314613342,
0.8762351870536804,
0.0026537850499153137,
0.18331342935562134,
-0.7723795175552368,
-0.13447508215904236,
0.21397647261619568,
0.364402711391449,
0.14828665554523468,
-0.3865397572517395,
-0.16999772191047668,
-0.20544293522834778,
-0.5083742141723633,
-1.1524615287780762,
0.1838328093290329,
0.042674727737903595,
0.9804109334945679,
0.5767771601676941,
0.32363423705101013,
0.6929264068603516,
-0.641997218132019,
0.8826678991317749,
0.16806599497795105,
-0.9057146906852722,
0.8366438150405884,
-0.3146301209926605,
0.5104389786720276,
0.5809034705162048,
0.7058937549591064,
-0.07743047922849655,
-0.2528094947338104,
-0.5346421003341675,
-0.7667029500007629,
0.5884459018707275,
-0.16879777610301971,
0.25561290979385376,
0.18372613191604614,
0.3567616641521454,
0.528407871723175,
0.3997020125389099,
0.049736835062503815,
-0.23760215938091278,
-0.3589549660682678,
-0.5735346674919128,
0.5838896036148071,
-0.2319445163011551,
-0.12688151001930237,
-0.3612130284309387,
0.4665977358818054,
-0.1536208987236023,
0.9574910402297974,
-0.12473072856664658,
-0.04776600003242493,
0.0028833418618887663,
-0.22718076407909393,
0.5730987191200256,
0.7964884042739868,
-0.46463117003440857,
0.32880085706710815,
0.2437354326248169,
-0.7170373797416687,
0.28964510560035706,
0.07490783929824829,
-0.2898987829685211,
0.13016411662101746,
0.2170364409685135,
1.0200397968292236,
0.0826195627450943,
-0.6121891736984253,
0.10070937871932983,
0.20162463188171387,
-0.27638038992881775,
0.04829444736242294,
0.4718337059020996,
-0.2276383638381958,
0.4354027807712555,
0.5096991658210754,
0.05901552364230156,
-0.08751223236322403,
-0.4484063982963562,
0.47754746675491333,
0.23876953125,
-0.6607753038406372,
-0.40260225534439087,
0.7422383427619934,
0.34298643469810486,
-0.40416455268859863,
0.6734657883644104,
0.017074596136808395,
-0.542333722114563,
0.5302900075912476,
0.701539933681488,
1.021510362625122,
-0.7188233137130737,
0.5048202276229858,
0.34168750047683716,
0.07735800743103027,
0.2589647173881531,
0.5851532816886902,
-0.2338576316833496,
-0.33780956268310547,
-0.3611079752445221,
-0.1940220296382904,
-0.5529974102973938,
-0.13739179074764252,
-0.6892109513282776,
0.30054140090942383,
-0.7672244906425476,
-0.23278434574604034,
-0.18657413125038147,
0.07897499203681946,
-0.8685773015022278,
0.11684383451938629,
-0.20728859305381775,
1.0959123373031616,
-0.6286522746086121,
0.9213218688964844,
0.9479094743728638,
-0.204977348446846,
-0.4281883239746094,
-0.07953766733407974,
0.3207395076751709,
-0.7674572467803955,
0.774316668510437,
0.26572999358177185,
0.1360926479101181,
-0.06187070533633232,
-0.49374908208847046,
-0.9847065806388855,
1.1296555995941162,
0.49997010827064514,
-0.39912086725234985,
0.003641995834186673,
-0.19719836115837097,
0.22519607841968536,
-0.41133618354797363,
0.25006619095802307,
0.06060675531625748,
0.5752202272415161,
0.07506008446216583,
-0.41093260049819946,
0.5076438784599304,
-0.224058598279953,
-0.04642808809876442,
0.0852566808462143,
-0.45890337228775024,
0.7266408205032349,
-0.14051267504692078,
-0.05425560474395752,
-0.33334147930145264,
0.697921633720398,
0.4744577407836914,
0.24268019199371338,
0.7169457674026489,
0.1338638812303543,
1.1891849040985107,
-0.20616695284843445,
1.0049878358840942,
-0.3789590895175934,
0.0525827631354332,
1.3294603824615479,
-0.23186132311820984,
0.8641217947006226,
0.3966740667819977,
-0.3305026590824127,
0.983747124671936,
0.9064542055130005,
-0.17139826714992523,
0.8106933832168579,
0.1176789179444313,
-0.15773522853851318,
-0.1028551310300827,
-0.00882055051624775,
-0.42602354288101196,
0.22853605449199677,
0.5509453415870667,
-0.311913400888443,
-0.1492234766483307,
0.35308408737182617,
-0.10581201314926147,
-0.30459219217300415,
-0.01968868263065815,
0.2560851275920868,
-0.13571371138095856,
-0.5419472455978394,
0.45756760239601135,
-0.17529653012752533,
0.4766313433647156,
-0.6503840684890747,
-0.2554311156272888,
0.16778649389743805,
0.09946217387914658,
-0.2556101083755493,
-0.8414891362190247,
0.42902517318725586,
-0.10933329164981842,
-0.26922839879989624,
-0.37972694635391235,
0.7386918067932129,
-0.3222145438194275,
-0.4568818509578705,
0.1609281599521637,
0.45842552185058594,
0.0005748778348788619,
0.18229849636554718,
-1.2333141565322876,
0.24045328795909882,
-0.016955208033323288,
-0.5722535848617554,
0.3505404591560364,
0.7751232385635376,
-0.16064777970314026,
0.8571503758430481,
0.7909904718399048,
-0.18876370787620544,
0.17705857753753662,
0.06428655982017517,
0.7602555155754089,
-0.6237202882766724,
-0.5460341572761536,
-0.7650953531265259,
0.8953453898429871,
-0.01860855147242546,
0.052790604531764984,
0.7035535573959351,
0.09884149581193924,
0.4818804860115051,
-0.1825605183839798,
0.8320803642272949,
-0.27548080682754517,
0.3073907494544983,
-0.32527345418930054,
0.38365644216537476,
-0.5198336243629456,
0.007650344632565975,
-0.12037216126918793,
-0.7496321797370911,
-0.47564196586608887,
0.7539466619491577,
-0.30774396657943726,
0.32858771085739136,
0.789731502532959,
0.4308730661869049,
-0.04584271460771561,
-0.0007062234217301011,
0.3389003872871399,
0.12185029685497284,
0.3480803370475769,
0.3773370385169983,
0.8139182925224304,
0.13896343111991882,
0.05450177937746048,
-0.14254412055015564,
-0.1732291430234909,
-0.6445543766021729,
-1.0569289922714233,
-0.9469836950302124,
-0.7298810482025146,
-0.7934512495994568,
-0.24650827050209045,
0.2365618646144867,
1.0185056924819946,
0.8561016917228699,
-0.9479178190231323,
0.16935808956623077,
-0.03346582129597664,
0.24736161530017853,
-0.8830434679985046,
-0.27208489179611206,
0.7072504162788391,
-0.5297076106071472,
-0.8669129610061646,
0.3708260953426361,
0.18419890105724335,
-0.021949583664536476,
-0.3904598355293274,
0.07818103581666946,
-0.38719233870506287,
0.1172565445303917,
0.702635645866394,
0.07103709876537323,
-0.41168755292892456,
-0.44477635622024536,
-0.18285605311393738,
0.2242734134197235,
-0.06631042063236237,
0.8876711130142212,
-0.9336649775505066,
0.632048487663269,
0.8469358682632446,
0.999690055847168,
0.41107377409935,
-0.008519810624420643,
0.4993559718132019,
-0.871841311454773,
0.2788950800895691,
0.14045047760009766,
0.06777217984199524,
0.12522096931934357,
-0.6433973908424377,
0.4635584354400635,
0.35393136739730835,
-0.4351687431335449,
-1.0209051370620728,
0.09927588701248169,
-1.0888583660125732,
-0.3942769467830658,
0.7678119540214539,
-0.4023262858390808,
-0.2767027020454407,
-0.23217110335826874,
-0.2062314748764038,
0.3124021589756012,
-0.6770996451377869,
0.6851603388786316,
0.5089884996414185,
-0.4390052855014801,
-0.27383166551589966,
-0.8822636604309082,
0.29157114028930664,
0.38240042328834534,
-0.7667458653450012,
-0.04822877049446106,
0.301896870136261,
0.19102877378463745,
0.05657351016998291,
0.24801823496818542,
0.08755359053611755,
0.306953102350235,
0.10357465595006943,
-0.24757103621959686,
-0.5271088480949402,
-0.6005634069442749,
-0.0779050886631012,
0.48358649015426636,
-0.026935432106256485,
-0.7001827359199524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11109v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11109v2
|
Watermarking Language Models for Many Adaptive Users
| 2024-05-17T22:15:30 | 2024-06-28T22:15:59 |
Aloni Cohen, Alexander Hoover, Gabe Schoenbach
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We study watermarking schemes for language models with provable guarantees.
As we show, prior works offer no robustness guarantees against adaptive
prompting: when a user queries a language model more than once, as even benign
users do. And with just a single exception (Christ and Gunn, 2024), prior works
are restricted to zero-bit watermarking: machine-generated text can be detected
as such, but no additional information can be extracted from the watermark.
Unfortunately, merely detecting AI-generated text may not prevent future
abuses.
We introduce multi-user watermarks, which allow tracing model-generated text
to individual users or to groups of colluding users, even in the face of
adaptive prompting. We construct multi-user watermarking schemes from
undetectable, adaptively robust, zero-bit watermarking schemes (and prove that
the undetectable zero-bit scheme of Christ, Gunn, and Zamir (2024) is
adaptively robust). Importantly, our scheme provides both zero-bit and
multi-user assurances at the same time. It detects shorter snippets just as
well as the original scheme, and traces longer excerpts to individuals.
The main technical component is a construction of message-embedding
watermarks from zero-bit watermarks. Ours is the first generic reduction
between watermarking schemes for language models. A challenge for such
reductions is the lack of a unified abstraction for robustness -- that marked
text is detectable even after edits. We introduce a new unifying abstraction
called AEB-robustness. AEB-robustness provides that the watermark is detectable
whenever the edited text "approximates enough blocks" of model-generated
output.
|
[
-0.31095466017723083,
-0.7970089316368103,
0.43065574765205383,
0.2418447583913803,
-0.16145379841327667,
0.1208965927362442,
-0.09824622422456741,
-0.5475590229034424,
0.0064790938049554825,
0.7374996542930603,
-0.3168356716632843,
-0.266930490732193,
-0.6856982707977295,
0.09125401824712753,
-0.5777526497840881,
0.8127738237380981,
0.0606573186814785,
-0.42410987615585327,
0.026257259771227837,
-0.5441210269927979,
-0.3624833822250366,
-0.5560495257377625,
-0.5658628940582275,
-0.23507453501224518,
0.40010714530944824,
0.14971090853214264,
0.7919679880142212,
0.8017255067825317,
0.21440547704696655,
0.3214645981788635,
-0.19507504999637604,
0.09024880081415176,
-0.15374603867530823,
0.6035014390945435,
-0.2828223407268524,
-0.3143899440765381,
-0.2920743525028229,
-0.31587958335876465,
0.6260697245597839,
0.22820256650447845,
0.12232774496078491,
-0.1320401430130005,
0.189507395029068,
0.5144883394241333,
-1.043068528175354,
0.03944464400410652,
-0.8329223990440369,
-0.36586007475852966,
-0.4656122326850891,
-0.09844201803207397,
-0.6042512059211731,
-0.07537657022476196,
-0.1838098168373108,
-0.5003510117530823,
0.11655015498399734,
0.2034521847963333,
0.7926113605499268,
0.041501037776470184,
-0.2047353833913803,
-0.4557238221168518,
-0.7829173803329468,
0.8299990296363831,
-0.7613619565963745,
0.29633164405822754,
0.500905454158783,
0.09056892991065979,
-0.16190007328987122,
-0.8044509887695312,
-0.6311633586883545,
-0.06853275746107101,
0.3711739182472229,
0.22198301553726196,
-0.6276353597640991,
-0.04032779112458229,
0.12472784519195557,
0.1608581691980362,
-0.09930604696273804,
0.0560290664434433,
-0.07991890609264374,
-0.43865999579429626,
0.4360669255256653,
0.04918467998504639,
0.3658049702644348,
0.2579892873764038,
-0.4009018540382385,
-0.12969501316547394,
-0.7669407725334167,
0.048766229301691055,
0.5768032073974609,
0.3706294596195221,
0.005433944519609213,
0.16739419102668762,
-0.0902358666062355,
0.6073698997497559,
-0.24707011878490448,
0.042193952947854996,
-0.23743116855621338,
-0.12091416865587234,
0.09747038781642914,
-0.17911145091056824,
0.9424546957015991,
0.02628709375858307,
0.6113209128379822,
-0.07722308486700058,
-0.34059658646583557,
0.07480327785015106,
0.14638115465641022,
-0.7801190614700317,
-0.47036466002464294,
-0.11607317626476288,
-0.3274558484554291,
-0.30499327182769775,
-0.07187845557928085,
-0.5378175973892212,
-0.6993966102600098,
0.1341976672410965,
0.6317639946937561,
-0.33725452423095703,
-0.36037135124206543,
0.26215609908103943,
0.0660974457859993,
-0.23703612387180328,
0.3185073733329773,
-0.9956998825073242,
0.3622884750366211,
0.45659980177879333,
0.6612716317176819,
0.0538199283182621,
-0.4806244373321533,
-0.35229530930519104,
0.44163501262664795,
-0.3236859142780304,
0.9501633644104004,
-0.7214644551277161,
-0.2517620325088501,
0.03247355669736862,
-0.17775435745716095,
0.15718960762023926,
-0.3252347409725189,
0.3410455882549286,
-0.629620373249054,
0.22421757876873016,
-0.334449827671051,
-0.7043097019195557,
-0.11809247732162476,
-0.09477797895669937,
-0.7487074732780457,
0.6577678322792053,
0.02898424305021763,
-0.9201569557189941,
0.2851567268371582,
-0.6541759371757507,
-0.222341388463974,
0.06386639177799225,
0.0821886733174324,
-0.5570402145385742,
0.14755509793758392,
0.2647125720977783,
0.2117556780576706,
0.015553268603980541,
0.08143818378448486,
-0.6868085861206055,
-0.1993681788444519,
0.27224719524383545,
-0.6924546360969543,
0.8881182074546814,
0.05730133131146431,
-0.0721869170665741,
0.13597922027111053,
-0.6263602375984192,
0.03572411090135574,
0.22621648013591766,
-0.531398594379425,
-0.438802033662796,
0.12363792210817337,
0.18061955273151398,
-0.06193607673048973,
0.35844627022743225,
-0.45548200607299805,
0.11220653355121613,
-0.0601157546043396,
0.6222400069236755,
1.022027850151062,
0.03306858614087105,
0.226551815867424,
-0.38242560625076294,
0.5859302878379822,
-0.023366160690784454,
0.12440864741802216,
-0.7526556253433228,
-0.6069141030311584,
-0.6274711489677429,
-0.42481377720832825,
0.44242408871650696,
0.4309403896331787,
-0.6753299832344055,
0.08721796423196793,
0.0097777945920825,
-0.2151952087879181,
-0.530754029750824,
0.3301719129085541,
0.5520132780075073,
0.2361878603696823,
0.4262385368347168,
-0.41268622875213623,
-0.17478080093860626,
-0.764604389667511,
-0.6251339912414551,
-0.5868101716041565,
-0.07849819213151932,
0.34757861495018005,
0.3065634071826935,
-0.0004955375916324556,
0.8021363019943237,
-0.237071692943573,
-0.07329077273607254,
-0.14820456504821777,
0.2545369863510132,
-0.3161798119544983,
0.44608813524246216,
0.722955048084259,
-0.6869154572486877,
-0.6062448620796204,
-0.06258857995271683,
-0.3857567012310028,
-0.42734459042549133,
-0.09174656122922897,
0.08675025403499603,
0.23574793338775635,
0.476128488779068,
-0.3161085247993469,
0.5030333995819092,
0.7419562935829163,
-0.5453457832336426,
0.4106520414352417,
-0.4765399992465973,
-0.02440391667187214,
-1.0329214334487915,
0.026875033974647522,
-0.21441252529621124,
-0.5193866491317749,
-0.6493857502937317,
0.14811423420906067,
0.21017403900623322,
0.0969662070274353,
-0.21643014252185822,
0.8957171440124512,
-0.47743716835975647,
0.29216039180755615,
-0.6959224939346313,
-0.23337846994400024,
0.10866086184978485,
0.3758918046951294,
-0.0912545770406723,
0.7327241897583008,
0.8340388536453247,
-0.48361268639564514,
0.13170093297958374,
0.13945282995700836,
-0.09903234988451004,
0.6973807215690613,
-0.7106388211250305,
0.48375949263572693,
-0.23341262340545654,
-0.05586889013648033,
-0.9945741891860962,
0.027885815128684044,
0.34960368275642395,
-0.43609926104545593,
0.27466580271720886,
-0.4001268148422241,
-0.3608388900756836,
0.1371108442544937,
-0.30274370312690735,
0.27004894614219666,
0.4281429648399353,
-0.3790837228298187,
0.5684974193572998,
0.2054760754108429,
-0.4223409593105316,
-0.4784209728240967,
-0.5212495923042297,
0.3677603006362915,
-0.15602704882621765,
-0.4215039014816284,
0.45073312520980835,
-0.2788673937320709,
-0.09844262152910233,
0.3377701938152313,
-0.28871336579322815,
-0.5235545039176941,
0.4342615604400635,
0.3177288770675659,
0.13593411445617676,
-0.20680810511112213,
-0.16451016068458557,
0.17783845961093903,
-0.31175100803375244,
-0.23940764367580414,
-0.25352248549461365,
0.2169470191001892,
-0.14128278195858002,
-0.5918847918510437,
-0.5182206034660339,
0.6783055663108826,
0.5338729023933411,
-0.45045366883277893,
0.8067083954811096,
0.584662914276123,
-0.6890515089035034,
-0.06570401042699814,
-0.47313016653060913,
-0.1852116882801056,
-0.505578339099884,
0.07943997532129288,
-0.23790930211544037,
-1.215954303741455,
0.7783198356628418,
0.03560449928045273,
0.44522085785865784,
0.3753080368041992,
0.4714109003543854,
-0.06137359142303467,
0.9369235038757324,
0.9254355430603027,
-0.2114715576171875,
0.6969301700592041,
0.42230406403541565,
0.13623270392417908,
-0.5425152778625488,
0.15981507301330566,
-0.8742582201957703,
-0.0033223701175302267,
-0.3921153247356415,
0.16527797281742096,
-0.09586147218942642,
0.6272883415222168,
-0.21043036878108978,
0.5500475168228149,
-0.34603989124298096,
0.6797516345977783,
0.6104034185409546,
-0.0005583214806392789,
0.2730902433395386,
-0.03044550120830536,
-0.05267297849059105,
-0.12517346441745758,
-0.3939160108566284,
-0.6024652123451233,
0.9886667132377625,
0.11200732737779617,
0.7430397272109985,
0.24516157805919647,
0.7639642953872681,
0.6704940795898438,
0.5693358778953552,
-0.2823295295238495,
0.22658680379390717,
0.03032442182302475,
-0.8724653720855713,
-0.23050695657730103,
-0.40315309166908264,
-1.0788259506225586,
0.19867052137851715,
-0.327536404132843,
-1.0587550401687622,
0.01753370650112629,
0.4801096022129059,
-0.3562299311161041,
0.44430768489837646,
-0.6199120283126831,
0.7113897204399109,
-0.049739770591259,
-0.5030295848846436,
-0.031139710918068886,
-0.4683868885040283,
-0.07065077871084213,
-0.4108317196369171,
0.42094752192497253,
-0.31671974062919617,
-0.16800227761268616,
0.617516040802002,
-0.0742277279496193,
0.7805199027061462,
-0.4118572175502777,
-0.007402088958770037,
0.27423912286758423,
0.4882502555847168,
0.42481791973114014,
0.03032969869673252,
-0.012307842262089252,
-0.09387243539094925,
0.1491074115037918,
-0.613684892654419,
-0.4218745231628418,
0.4487420618534088,
-0.3043387234210968,
-0.6689781546592712,
-0.2600889205932617,
-0.45468568801879883,
-0.004167009145021439,
0.7050064206123352,
0.07049863040447235,
0.41839396953582764,
0.12430501729249954,
0.3050471842288971,
0.4421999454498291,
-0.24245180189609528,
0.813686728477478,
0.5944797396659851,
-0.1579568237066269,
-0.448481947183609,
0.8653655052185059,
-0.15294313430786133,
0.30930212140083313,
0.23280805349349976,
0.3318033218383789,
-0.3371618688106537,
-0.9884475469589233,
-0.5151177644729614,
-0.013776405714452267,
-0.7489354014396667,
-0.2571330964565277,
-0.4367567300796509,
-0.05813734605908394,
-0.15145498514175415,
-0.22083503007888794,
-0.5005648732185364,
-0.35815009474754333,
-0.24357624351978302,
0.32979118824005127,
0.3730418384075165,
0.8166194558143616,
-0.05034054070711136,
0.4165601134300232,
-0.7986406683921814,
0.4113610088825226,
0.36471012234687805,
0.4357813596725464,
-0.12628817558288574,
-0.7413755655288696,
-0.018467171117663383,
0.0809435024857521,
-0.5474069714546204,
-0.936174213886261,
0.23447470366954803,
0.5466943979263306,
0.48037195205688477,
0.5017009377479553,
0.2878061830997467,
0.5656535625457764,
-0.45609092712402344,
0.6238173246383667,
0.1987549066543579,
-1.277695894241333,
0.28008121252059937,
-0.1869126409292221,
0.21219871938228607,
0.49563366174697876,
0.07338006049394608,
-0.5505052208900452,
-0.6178499460220337,
-0.4860081672668457,
-0.8592303395271301,
0.5539741516113281,
0.2528853714466095,
0.6762720346450806,
0.19160403311252594,
0.4277983605861664,
0.13863727450370789,
0.13596267998218536,
-0.9396155476570129,
-0.29904890060424805,
-0.3431254029273987,
-0.17407143115997314,
0.3156776428222656,
-0.43679770827293396,
0.04712085425853729,
0.10789106041193008,
0.6734569072723389,
-0.3112437427043915,
0.08811766654253006,
0.029108084738254547,
-0.04310733452439308,
-0.10430053621530533,
0.5520786046981812,
0.5172964930534363,
0.7770678997039795,
0.11779526621103287,
0.277889609336853,
-0.04079914838075638,
-0.2418796718120575,
0.1480463147163391,
0.026499761268496513,
-0.4250553846359253,
-0.11694463342428207,
0.7162399888038635,
0.7907528281211853,
0.053324613720178604,
-0.43535134196281433,
0.5128083229064941,
-0.2953859865665436,
-0.04710426181554794,
-0.0013286654138937593,
0.20643535256385803,
0.3587973117828369,
0.13747023046016693,
0.24334271252155304,
0.3224929869174957,
-0.11680098623037338,
-0.3080175220966339,
0.1733906865119934,
0.37097471952438354,
-0.4461866319179535,
-0.6518949866294861,
1.0302095413208008,
-0.03028162382543087,
-0.5911151170730591,
0.37134844064712524,
-0.16399803757667542,
-0.5626890063285828,
0.15644192695617676,
0.7136732339859009,
0.8410914540290833,
-0.6111660003662109,
0.006185163743793964,
0.04155287891626358,
0.3347524106502533,
-0.20163589715957642,
0.47345787286758423,
-0.14362311363220215,
-1.0359523296356201,
-0.1140623614192009,
-0.5163756012916565,
-0.6626608371734619,
0.19285577535629272,
-0.6967155933380127,
-0.03681734949350357,
-0.6644524335861206,
-0.21037814021110535,
0.4612172544002533,
-0.4251762926578522,
-0.3615180253982544,
-0.1568586528301239,
0.060272037982940674,
0.6720271110534668,
-0.8806265592575073,
0.8416219353675842,
0.7492884993553162,
-0.042012229561805725,
-0.3402571976184845,
-0.052576422691345215,
0.07071913778781891,
-0.8146578073501587,
-0.2620043456554413,
0.17802679538726807,
-0.13411714136600494,
0.06266139447689056,
-0.7452373504638672,
-0.5463804006576538,
0.6733140349388123,
0.9355867505073547,
-0.3143121004104614,
0.37809863686561584,
0.010815995745360851,
0.5269676446914673,
-0.10662137717008591,
-0.07875671982765198,
0.17174692451953888,
0.5009934902191162,
-0.29804983735084534,
-0.7343381643295288,
0.11257017403841019,
-0.32635053992271423,
-0.04125184938311577,
0.13833342492580414,
-0.4891117811203003,
0.8357764482498169,
-0.14397430419921875,
-0.42291995882987976,
0.21156680583953857,
0.5457302927970886,
0.18185001611709595,
0.22289663553237915,
0.5410138964653015,
0.30604153871536255,
0.6067468523979187,
-0.057567574083805084,
0.9511113166809082,
-0.41195914149284363,
0.2868128716945648,
0.9825190901756287,
-0.3581143915653229,
0.8249520063400269,
0.4267721176147461,
-0.21807917952537537,
0.3852645754814148,
0.2552705407142639,
0.15534274280071259,
0.4707922041416168,
0.06103606894612312,
-0.5197954177856445,
-0.5696206092834473,
-0.30319252610206604,
-0.21422335505485535,
0.2759823203086853,
0.15463057160377502,
-0.3060990571975708,
-0.0962609127163887,
-0.3306826949119568,
0.20064739882946014,
0.3551780879497528,
0.009433877654373646,
0.7516691088676453,
0.14604732394218445,
-0.35833409428596497,
0.4993775486946106,
0.38198086619377136,
0.6882859468460083,
-0.5654789805412292,
0.07755707204341888,
-0.2802375257015228,
0.20354503393173218,
-0.046558186411857605,
-0.7806883454322815,
0.1769281029701233,
0.09420885890722275,
-0.14366558194160461,
-0.388816773891449,
1.036008358001709,
-0.45501434803009033,
-0.38568583130836487,
0.32195454835891724,
0.5091109871864319,
0.06590806692838669,
-0.19267882406711578,
-0.7549967169761658,
0.1213744580745697,
0.07035364955663681,
-0.34129300713539124,
0.23612350225448608,
0.29789552092552185,
-0.26416927576065063,
0.968573272228241,
0.6496608257293701,
0.178740993142128,
0.20922616124153137,
0.1732151359319687,
0.6636383533477783,
-0.5142458081245422,
-0.4894159436225891,
-1.137266755104065,
0.23906435072422028,
0.10780367255210876,
-0.2696729600429535,
0.6150299310684204,
0.26038962602615356,
0.8363133072853088,
0.14265307784080505,
0.9588854312896729,
0.08695785701274872,
0.08607097715139389,
-0.38496553897857666,
0.9257526397705078,
-0.5575248003005981,
0.0959886685013771,
-0.48503491282463074,
-0.8372581601142883,
-0.5353207588195801,
0.40195390582084656,
0.3779871463775635,
0.1591658741235733,
0.2883458137512207,
0.7609816789627075,
-0.1653045117855072,
0.12843798100948334,
0.301891565322876,
-0.26578450202941895,
0.4970540404319763,
0.5015444755554199,
0.88774174451828,
-0.24832096695899963,
0.5322798490524292,
-0.20759019255638123,
-0.15633481740951538,
0.13351880013942719,
-1.1528301239013672,
-0.7365202903747559,
-0.6744828820228577,
-0.47590968012809753,
-0.2013685554265976,
0.08562099933624268,
0.5250363945960999,
0.7607179880142212,
-1.2463041543960571,
0.04654666408896446,
-0.05841055512428284,
0.15204760432243347,
-0.31589803099632263,
-0.1230660006403923,
0.4435962736606598,
0.15680985152721405,
-0.5408467054367065,
0.37179872393608093,
0.4995388686656952,
0.526404619216919,
-0.1942080408334732,
-0.22015906870365143,
0.21093463897705078,
0.35584941506385803,
0.11550930887460709,
0.5999471545219421,
-0.524739146232605,
-0.499072790145874,
-0.2425878793001175,
0.1594950407743454,
0.05329079553484917,
0.7290334105491638,
-0.2461032271385193,
0.6989720463752747,
0.30450499057769775,
0.7110095620155334,
0.24836848676204681,
-0.04496685788035393,
0.23230881989002228,
-0.7404981851577759,
0.06922156363725662,
0.11995719373226166,
0.5223926901817322,
0.5349794626235962,
0.019936619326472282,
0.027253611013293266,
0.300534725189209,
-0.4227323830127716,
-0.8823202848434448,
0.26213473081588745,
-0.6181230545043945,
-0.22845883667469025,
0.7973306775093079,
-0.8005053400993347,
0.026831766590476036,
-0.37684908509254456,
-0.11847661435604095,
0.03857247158885002,
-0.41895076632499695,
0.9147453904151917,
0.9505719542503357,
0.1520116776227951,
-0.25042909383773804,
-0.26666921377182007,
0.3233393728733063,
0.431898295879364,
-0.8612074255943298,
0.4488649368286133,
0.33703041076660156,
0.5571591854095459,
0.09990379214286804,
0.7302170395851135,
-0.14235273003578186,
0.19482257962226868,
0.12362398952245712,
0.07619837671518326,
-0.45709389448165894,
-0.5761868357658386,
-0.3821347653865814,
0.2088903784751892,
0.353742390871048,
-0.07508088648319244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11106v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11106v1
|
LLM-based Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning: Current and Future Directions
| 2024-05-17T22:10:23 | 2024-05-17T22:10:23 |
Chuanneng Sun, Songjun Huang, Dario Pompili
|
cs.MA
|
cs.MA, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.RO
|
In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown great abilities in
various tasks, including question answering, arithmetic problem solving, and
poem writing, among others. Although research on LLM-as-an-agent has shown that
LLM can be applied to Reinforcement Learning (RL) and achieve decent results,
the extension of LLM-based RL to Multi-Agent System (MAS) is not trivial, as
many aspects, such as coordination and communication between agents, are not
considered in the RL frameworks of a single agent. To inspire more research on
LLM-based MARL, in this letter, we survey the existing LLM-based single-agent
and multi-agent RL frameworks and provide potential research directions for
future research. In particular, we focus on the cooperative tasks of multiple
agents with a common goal and communication among them. We also consider
human-in/on-the-loop scenarios enabled by the language component in the
framework.
|
[
-0.4546275734901428,
-0.7859019637107849,
0.6073768138885498,
0.3309321701526642,
0.21303141117095947,
0.4825567901134491,
-0.22467917203903198,
-0.588462233543396,
0.30197733640670776,
0.49148476123809814,
-0.8491939902305603,
-0.40174174308776855,
-0.41519320011138916,
0.24355117976665497,
-0.009210173971951008,
0.7589823603630066,
-0.07343961298465729,
0.22768059372901917,
-0.5326744914054871,
-0.37422022223472595,
-0.40785592794418335,
-0.8496885895729065,
-0.9803488254547119,
-0.7576237320899963,
0.8166539072990417,
0.6041415333747864,
0.33572056889533997,
0.25132259726524353,
0.3418939411640167,
0.4430578947067261,
0.0929272472858429,
0.33597686886787415,
-0.35402417182922363,
0.5262321829795837,
-0.2429904192686081,
-0.5384873151779175,
-0.42438656091690063,
0.27533185482025146,
0.9890807271003723,
0.42963701486587524,
-0.12758804857730865,
-0.07359576970338821,
0.011808001436293125,
0.6935849785804749,
-0.49837881326675415,
0.40725696086883545,
-0.20864152908325195,
0.1979050636291504,
0.336490660905838,
-0.14161616563796997,
-0.3805215358734131,
-0.189594104886055,
0.02090347744524479,
-0.6357288360595703,
-0.2413693070411682,
0.18667875230312347,
0.32204219698905945,
0.10320249944925308,
-0.580233633518219,
-0.5990639328956604,
-0.685625433921814,
1.0829408168792725,
-0.598796010017395,
0.385206937789917,
0.2803691625595093,
0.35729900002479553,
-0.4096628725528717,
-0.4845382273197174,
-0.36748310923576355,
-0.6617124080657959,
0.09091044962406158,
0.25864377617836,
0.1671593338251114,
0.19626878201961517,
0.01794196479022503,
-0.09877663850784302,
-0.25158143043518066,
0.33831214904785156,
-0.0018485598266124725,
-0.02933201752603054,
0.7303282618522644,
0.3918546140193939,
0.03767403960227966,
0.31008684635162354,
-0.8098613619804382,
-0.12256091833114624,
-0.817802369594574,
0.1845170110464096,
0.2329959124326706,
0.2705223262310028,
-0.11235041171312332,
0.45892202854156494,
-0.24029268324375153,
0.3816923201084137,
-0.1591653823852539,
-0.304940789937973,
-0.01307294238358736,
-0.38532328605651855,
-0.09326796978712082,
-0.20768555998802185,
0.6158985495567322,
0.036607544869184494,
0.2586267292499542,
-0.29830402135849,
-0.5041678547859192,
0.13348843157291412,
0.019448790699243546,
-0.3393828570842743,
0.2729746997356415,
0.020773334428668022,
-0.35014423727989197,
-0.30640700459480286,
0.08569080382585526,
-0.6225157380104065,
-0.45246559381484985,
-0.33163395524024963,
0.44272005558013916,
-0.20461827516555786,
-0.4534485340118408,
0.03334473446011543,
0.09407497942447662,
0.518004298210144,
0.3168282210826874,
-0.6461765766143799,
0.6590461134910583,
0.8219224214553833,
0.5923008322715759,
-0.3631259799003601,
-1.038826823234558,
-0.7702457308769226,
0.10792731493711472,
-0.25859561562538147,
0.8343864679336548,
-0.5617678761482239,
-0.35136476159095764,
0.15713053941726685,
-0.05446619540452957,
-0.2737811803817749,
-0.28652215003967285,
0.0741802528500557,
-0.6855289340019226,
0.08528141677379608,
-0.40201935172080994,
-0.6566875576972961,
-0.2997642457485199,
0.649840772151947,
-0.7018317580223083,
0.5807711482048035,
-0.256011426448822,
-0.399783730506897,
-0.060561083257198334,
-0.8360185027122498,
-0.526611328125,
-0.20195992290973663,
-0.27188026905059814,
-0.4935489892959595,
-0.15413978695869446,
-0.05608048290014267,
0.5103891491889954,
-0.3936391770839691,
0.21941769123077393,
-0.4042338728904724,
-0.4523831605911255,
0.7245657444000244,
-0.6122812628746033,
0.46228814125061035,
0.25749343633651733,
-0.033579807728528976,
0.3998267650604248,
-0.4209926724433899,
-0.0695127323269844,
0.12633109092712402,
-0.510528028011322,
0.14397041499614716,
0.2152394950389862,
-0.16299866139888763,
0.5253798961639404,
0.41665366291999817,
-0.3721618056297302,
0.31246644258499146,
-0.13751055300235748,
0.24069248139858246,
0.7768078446388245,
0.15649010241031647,
0.586622953414917,
-0.8703446388244629,
0.7774530053138733,
-0.1537299007177353,
0.2639603614807129,
-0.08561530709266663,
-0.33536389470100403,
-0.646264374256134,
-0.22993268072605133,
0.074428029358387,
0.5109924077987671,
-0.8167495131492615,
-0.05884643271565437,
0.25959277153015137,
-0.12505459785461426,
-0.2026258260011673,
0.002897554310038686,
0.6328340172767639,
-0.041345007717609406,
0.23665237426757812,
-0.29348281025886536,
-0.39122605323791504,
-0.3828018307685852,
-0.22622977197170258,
-0.3297746181488037,
0.5980119109153748,
0.33875980973243713,
0.5285165309906006,
-0.06979544460773468,
0.878831148147583,
-0.30596014857292175,
-0.18696877360343933,
-0.6298003792762756,
-0.10397995263338089,
-0.19464436173439026,
0.24149291217327118,
0.2919757068157196,
-0.9046365022659302,
-0.4466378688812256,
-0.13579170405864716,
-0.7250551581382751,
0.0410526804625988,
-0.060929153114557266,
0.24808691442012787,
0.22126257419586182,
0.6733115315437317,
-0.5903642177581787,
0.18719342350959778,
0.6788300275802612,
-0.25750651955604553,
0.7867192029953003,
-0.46266791224479675,
0.1312040239572525,
-0.921333372592926,
-0.19458472728729248,
-0.10270264744758606,
-0.3185499906539917,
-0.8450636267662048,
0.139065682888031,
-0.2824263274669647,
0.20162345468997955,
-0.6153609156608582,
0.7371730208396912,
-0.5639392137527466,
-0.5574024319648743,
-0.6494596004486084,
0.2334582656621933,
-0.28204426169395447,
0.7595719695091248,
0.12745656073093414,
0.7856387495994568,
0.6158343553543091,
-0.7461838126182556,
0.5739821195602417,
-0.08901244401931763,
0.22119566798210144,
0.5865424275398254,
-0.2880760729312897,
0.06144947186112404,
-0.04155530035495758,
0.3118717670440674,
-0.5974205136299133,
0.07362894713878632,
0.42402052879333496,
-0.3890939950942993,
0.01578584685921669,
0.15163695812225342,
-0.3626067638397217,
-0.11048909276723862,
-0.38592907786369324,
0.3648422956466675,
0.2368258833885193,
-0.39447885751724243,
0.633979082107544,
0.23249788582324982,
0.0015749854501336813,
-0.871579110622406,
-0.3153785169124603,
-0.08433827757835388,
-0.24741563200950623,
-0.2809237539768219,
0.12741714715957642,
-0.22354744374752045,
-0.44290998578071594,
0.07555528730154037,
0.10712721943855286,
-0.11753413081169128,
0.30517518520355225,
0.3594987094402313,
0.11501306295394897,
-0.0644402951002121,
0.43442901968955994,
-0.3446754813194275,
-0.26140567660331726,
-0.07758933305740356,
-0.3481065034866333,
0.5776606798171997,
-0.42564865946769714,
-0.6926077604293823,
0.010112238116562366,
0.38547036051750183,
0.5211891531944275,
-0.5445723533630371,
0.8454394340515137,
0.3678845167160034,
-0.08587029576301575,
-0.41901135444641113,
-0.3938882350921631,
-0.21074944734573364,
-0.4449552595615387,
0.4021427631378174,
-0.3561248481273651,
-1.181340217590332,
0.4563104212284088,
-0.5253676176071167,
0.020226309075951576,
0.09525502473115921,
0.6166805028915405,
-0.22059157490730286,
0.6822311282157898,
0.8205896019935608,
-0.2178920954465866,
0.7066657543182373,
-0.25476935505867004,
-0.22885429859161377,
-0.6948742270469666,
-0.25032028555870056,
-0.2918422818183899,
-0.15831534564495087,
-0.5329235792160034,
-0.3887409269809723,
0.1648712158203125,
-0.08107317239046097,
-0.33616194128990173,
0.08903694897890091,
0.14651788771152496,
0.4270089566707611,
0.6095436811447144,
-0.178395077586174,
0.522045373916626,
-0.3102523386478424,
-0.29344239830970764,
0.643276572227478,
-0.763206422328949,
-0.37257087230682373,
1.0078134536743164,
0.2876555621623993,
0.6903429627418518,
0.1908615231513977,
0.7579149603843689,
0.36693018674850464,
0.20687811076641083,
-0.6376720666885376,
0.7984364628791809,
0.230820432305336,
-0.44745686650276184,
-0.627240002155304,
-0.33596646785736084,
-1.1354825496673584,
0.60944664478302,
-0.3661598563194275,
-0.41573309898376465,
-0.1648622453212738,
-0.10509579628705978,
0.030007746070623398,
0.36496174335479736,
-0.39938774704933167,
0.5303789973258972,
-0.3635352849960327,
-0.3018980026245117,
-0.5662717223167419,
-0.6667068600654602,
0.2620304822921753,
-0.04284879192709923,
0.3672727942466736,
-0.2246440052986145,
-0.2919802963733673,
0.534961462020874,
-0.08647598326206207,
0.901958703994751,
-0.1368541717529297,
-0.1885834038257599,
0.3642902076244354,
-0.3372202217578888,
0.694707453250885,
-0.036890480667352676,
-0.13032285869121552,
-0.2750155031681061,
-0.052642304450273514,
-0.34493812918663025,
-0.5337247848510742,
0.651218056678772,
-0.8188340067863464,
-0.4540560245513916,
-0.6157492995262146,
-0.6398234963417053,
-0.4052618145942688,
-0.0016586174024268985,
-0.24245941638946533,
0.3449917435646057,
-0.4661940038204193,
-0.14772078394889832,
0.6384774446487427,
-0.24629804491996765,
0.6871787309646606,
0.8681408166885376,
-0.4723978340625763,
-0.48307281732559204,
1.050013542175293,
-0.14390385150909424,
0.40186938643455505,
0.49330779910087585,
0.0016850406536832452,
-0.42852628231048584,
-0.5228989720344543,
-0.04922167584300041,
0.3938289284706116,
-0.6082372069358826,
-0.07799840718507767,
-0.36074697971343994,
-0.23331806063652039,
-0.1467483937740326,
-0.28747987747192383,
-0.4583679735660553,
-0.09216096997261047,
-0.2865157127380371,
0.18698559701442719,
0.21439199149608612,
1.1362230777740479,
-0.24153396487236023,
0.24280688166618347,
-0.5859269499778748,
0.3225778043270111,
0.36518150568008423,
0.4582042098045349,
0.1576298028230667,
-0.06292302161455154,
-0.5277146100997925,
0.08887313306331635,
-0.28469574451446533,
-0.7945117354393005,
0.32894691824913025,
-0.0018775648204609752,
0.7978275418281555,
0.13036631047725677,
0.02112012729048729,
0.10580522567033768,
-0.3556169271469116,
0.5415010452270508,
0.28378233313560486,
-0.6567745804786682,
0.09610956907272339,
-0.04838655889034271,
0.02578354813158512,
0.1856493055820465,
0.20128200948238373,
-0.9041643738746643,
-0.4844989478588104,
-0.4618605077266693,
-0.25825726985931396,
0.7735211253166199,
-0.017214639112353325,
-0.32978904247283936,
0.24309219419956207,
0.2348473221063614,
0.04484521597623825,
0.20822325348854065,
-0.8480488657951355,
-0.43027663230895996,
0.2785399556159973,
-0.036123864352703094,
-0.46711647510528564,
0.025500677525997162,
0.06319481134414673,
0.031554002314805984,
0.6406263709068298,
-0.1691015362739563,
0.46622711420059204,
-0.054236363619565964,
-0.22548551857471466,
-0.12013094872236252,
0.716419517993927,
0.7641460299491882,
0.30640333890914917,
0.08286264538764954,
0.09841659665107727,
0.45777568221092224,
-0.08775687962770462,
0.7234747409820557,
-0.03416533023118973,
0.1190933883190155,
-0.6251606345176697,
0.38900360465049744,
0.728670597076416,
0.28481507301330566,
-0.7324069738388062,
0.5088933706283569,
-0.013857955113053322,
-0.38434162735939026,
-0.4457179605960846,
0.22359588742256165,
0.09623046964406967,
0.9456009864807129,
0.18270482122898102,
0.018582699820399284,
-0.2886461019515991,
-0.7689297199249268,
0.24211128056049347,
0.7108201384544373,
-0.32342714071273804,
-0.2822890281677246,
0.17179067432880402,
0.12078820914030075,
-0.47628310322761536,
0.2477584183216095,
-0.34284675121307373,
-0.6412064433097839,
0.7304567694664001,
0.724737823009491,
0.8807244896888733,
-0.13980047404766083,
0.3077905774116516,
-0.16002912819385529,
0.19350136816501617,
-0.21243661642074585,
0.3516119420528412,
-0.0664239302277565,
-0.9036997556686401,
-0.6548119783401489,
-0.41413575410842896,
-0.8726058006286621,
-0.1486741453409195,
-0.2651059329509735,
0.03494526445865631,
-0.3369268774986267,
0.07247068732976913,
-0.4795432686805725,
0.42109084129333496,
-0.4562418460845947,
0.04533345252275467,
0.28870564699172974,
0.4204644560813904,
-0.738824725151062,
1.113389015197754,
1.103433609008789,
-0.5506389737129211,
-0.6572036147117615,
-0.0922873467206955,
-0.10072880238294601,
-0.6587182283401489,
0.5797099471092224,
-0.08059687912464142,
-0.5803913474082947,
0.13982780277729034,
-0.5056077241897583,
-0.8375838398933411,
1.4060790538787842,
0.14202912151813507,
-0.29630520939826965,
-0.20051738619804382,
0.23675543069839478,
0.4728049635887146,
-0.6948065757751465,
0.14176146686077118,
0.2700973451137543,
0.48481228947639465,
0.18727520108222961,
-0.8323422074317932,
-0.18885338306427002,
0.09701128304004669,
-0.2249852418899536,
0.10333676636219025,
-1.140944242477417,
1.1202895641326904,
-0.23747991025447845,
-0.048726167529821396,
0.13132601976394653,
0.7804765105247498,
0.5392782688140869,
0.5577412843704224,
0.35050734877586365,
0.2173944115638733,
0.6937428712844849,
0.26931068301200867,
0.7865596413612366,
-0.1633511632680893,
0.47595158219337463,
0.9389463067054749,
-0.5537343621253967,
0.7011001706123352,
0.2803684175014496,
-0.16062627732753754,
0.41879820823669434,
0.3132082223892212,
0.1997610330581665,
0.4823467433452606,
0.3268842101097107,
-0.6415629386901855,
-0.3521369695663452,
-0.06836459040641785,
-0.13240770995616913,
0.37111949920654297,
0.4560011029243469,
0.06373663991689682,
-0.22582079470157623,
0.3136928975582123,
-0.3175209164619446,
0.08359707146883011,
-0.44602513313293457,
0.9191413521766663,
0.21069428324699402,
-0.5870266556739807,
-0.03920307755470276,
0.21069982647895813,
0.8308247327804565,
-0.6646168231964111,
-0.1876353621482849,
-0.20539481937885284,
0.2150532454252243,
0.17297029495239258,
-0.6498221158981323,
-0.0007581102545373142,
-0.15720483660697937,
0.0047370316460728645,
-0.3016407787799835,
1.097785234451294,
-0.5957394242286682,
0.024173347279429436,
0.5360055565834045,
0.9438538551330566,
0.12492381036281586,
0.1664217710494995,
-0.8232718706130981,
0.048485055565834045,
-0.3236101567745209,
-0.24736076593399048,
0.6306723356246948,
0.39606162905693054,
0.0644177719950676,
1.1867088079452515,
0.47112441062927246,
0.1795940101146698,
0.07517468184232712,
-0.2650275230407715,
0.779388427734375,
-0.918907105922699,
-0.4484945237636566,
-0.6547554731369019,
0.12858504056930542,
0.2930721640586853,
0.13661326467990875,
0.7102726101875305,
0.2715233564376831,
0.7276591658592224,
0.0755191370844841,
0.8477345705032349,
0.20297200977802277,
0.3196738660335541,
-0.6694324016571045,
0.39270755648612976,
-0.5817137360572815,
0.20311681926250458,
-0.07883010804653168,
-0.8404651284217834,
-0.16901932656764984,
0.48113808035850525,
-0.16473506391048431,
0.28546518087387085,
0.870033323764801,
0.6354047060012817,
0.32937929034233093,
0.11894799768924713,
0.7115790247917175,
-0.17670504748821259,
0.3837578296661377,
0.7267417907714844,
1.3573554754257202,
-0.006435354705899954,
0.38517317175865173,
0.06748495995998383,
0.18507012724876404,
-0.36548396944999695,
-0.6840113997459412,
-0.8258615136146545,
-0.6534797549247742,
-0.06130267679691315,
-0.047000423073768616,
0.3140658736228943,
1.34511137008667,
0.29216110706329346,
-0.5476853251457214,
-0.579851508140564,
-0.20836012065410614,
0.6314482688903809,
-0.5321581363677979,
-0.06625954061746597,
0.07848388701677322,
-0.49864670634269714,
-0.5444767475128174,
0.5790325999259949,
0.3837759494781494,
-0.009869527071714401,
-0.5649332404136658,
-0.8962568640708923,
-0.49872472882270813,
0.2614966034889221,
0.7724941372871399,
0.6377262473106384,
-0.6774098873138428,
-0.1541738212108612,
-0.11398211121559143,
-0.26352712512016296,
0.04123261570930481,
0.8523772954940796,
-0.7196263074874878,
0.07447190582752228,
0.13279564678668976,
0.5762305855751038,
0.47414013743400574,
-0.06718161702156067,
0.4272991418838501,
-0.6352725625038147,
0.0012460969155654311,
0.20099800825119019,
0.12459702789783478,
0.01694147102534771,
0.09031568467617035,
0.4625760316848755,
0.3015187978744507,
-0.7798444032669067,
-0.3427745997905731,
0.4803045392036438,
-0.8435900211334229,
-0.4080963134765625,
1.3334875106811523,
-0.20949259400367737,
-0.1702084243297577,
-0.42504212260246277,
-0.14519347250461578,
0.44412320852279663,
-0.4172949492931366,
0.11373121291399002,
0.7129521369934082,
-0.3425764739513397,
-0.42518290877342224,
-0.41625961661338806,
0.38039907813072205,
0.30611592531204224,
-1.0544321537017822,
0.06342727690935135,
0.5940821170806885,
0.13225725293159485,
-0.18860472738742828,
0.9287569522857666,
0.2756696045398712,
0.3086998462677002,
0.0167562086135149,
0.327898770570755,
-0.36534401774406433,
-0.6591516137123108,
-0.47094205021858215,
0.27676862478256226,
0.5431259870529175,
-0.20062363147735596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11100v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11100v1
|
Are Large Language Models Moral Hypocrites? A Study Based on Moral Foundations
| 2024-05-17T21:27:32 | 2024-05-17T21:27:32 |
José Luiz Nunes, Guilherme F. C. F. Almeida, Marcelo de Araujo, Simone D. J. Barbosa
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have taken centre stage in debates on Artificial
Intelligence. Yet there remains a gap in how to assess LLMs' conformity to
important human values. In this paper, we investigate whether state-of-the-art
LLMs, GPT-4 and Claude 2.1 (Gemini Pro and LLAMA 2 did not generate valid
results) are moral hypocrites. We employ two research instruments based on the
Moral Foundations Theory: (i) the Moral Foundations Questionnaire (MFQ), which
investigates which values are considered morally relevant in abstract moral
judgements; and (ii) the Moral Foundations Vignettes (MFVs), which evaluate
moral cognition in concrete scenarios related to each moral foundation. We
characterise conflicts in values between these different abstractions of moral
evaluation as hypocrisy. We found that both models displayed reasonable
consistency within each instrument compared to humans, but they displayed
contradictory and hypocritical behaviour when we compared the abstract values
present in the MFQ to the evaluation of concrete moral violations of the MFV.
|
[
-0.25130826234817505,
-0.6596351861953735,
0.8753246665000916,
0.23021794855594635,
-0.17442451417446136,
0.05592161789536476,
-0.15973709523677826,
-0.5271074175834656,
-0.0467623770236969,
0.6332627534866333,
-0.2790008783340454,
-0.03447428345680237,
-0.8524949550628662,
0.26236215233802795,
-0.4344691336154938,
0.8296180367469788,
0.008169470354914665,
-0.12557150423526764,
-0.4405798017978668,
-0.4123672842979431,
-0.017451755702495575,
-0.7792226076126099,
-0.48821327090263367,
-0.5327937602996826,
0.5539886951446533,
0.2029024064540863,
0.9019010663032532,
0.538968026638031,
0.5171642303466797,
0.3699265122413635,
-0.03077644109725952,
-0.27803847193717957,
-0.7765107750892639,
0.014199194498360157,
-0.47569894790649414,
-0.2669883668422699,
-0.410942018032074,
0.5733148455619812,
0.1936495155096054,
0.23479773104190826,
-0.06072554737329483,
0.370043009519577,
-0.049135416746139526,
0.5423571467399597,
-0.7127816081047058,
0.13830727338790894,
-0.5584221482276917,
-0.0377621166408062,
0.08023694902658463,
0.06620395928621292,
-0.2627919912338257,
-0.4633313715457916,
0.17806555330753326,
-0.5462116599082947,
-0.10847809165716171,
0.007966062054038048,
0.8951618075370789,
0.43609145283699036,
-0.3421359062194824,
-0.7851478457450867,
-0.3961230218410492,
1.1531912088394165,
-0.9512463212013245,
-0.016430912539362907,
0.8023123145103455,
-0.03891588747501373,
-0.04719170182943344,
-0.5867196321487427,
-0.9177364706993103,
-0.47231170535087585,
-0.0593058317899704,
0.04998362064361572,
-0.07725463062524796,
-0.13159845769405365,
0.34321340918540955,
0.2087542861700058,
-0.05027887597680092,
0.37473392486572266,
-0.433845192193985,
-0.25201985239982605,
0.7078538537025452,
0.009144552052021027,
-0.13958068192005157,
-0.4231637120246887,
-0.3403814136981964,
-0.12158128619194031,
-0.7211751937866211,
0.2635892629623413,
0.596428394317627,
-0.06251050531864166,
-0.2506333291530609,
0.6665470600128174,
0.34699517488479614,
0.23839233815670013,
0.24009229242801666,
-0.4736858904361725,
0.10922005772590637,
-0.09884849190711975,
-0.17546765506267548,
0.12182717025279999,
1.0377753973007202,
0.5805666446685791,
1.0844842195510864,
0.346357136964798,
-0.23317386209964752,
0.31254100799560547,
0.42215582728385925,
-0.7677907943725586,
-0.04792766645550728,
0.2405204176902771,
-0.31633156538009644,
-0.6831675171852112,
-0.057979222387075424,
-0.23399017751216888,
-0.5289592146873474,
-0.2253955900669098,
0.35054686665534973,
-0.1315813958644867,
-0.19896705448627472,
0.12434694916009903,
-0.09885933250188828,
0.43208956718444824,
0.3924816846847534,
-0.7694660425186157,
-0.012637895531952381,
0.8071115612983704,
0.42028775811195374,
0.09286325424909592,
-0.29718446731567383,
-0.419737309217453,
0.09924181550741196,
-0.4366753399372101,
0.2903296947479248,
-0.7430558204650879,
-0.5995798110961914,
-0.0667518675327301,
0.12110615521669388,
0.20104382932186127,
-0.3199474513530731,
0.7303277254104614,
-0.27309685945510864,
0.12802264094352722,
-0.5911835432052612,
-0.41087818145751953,
-0.25689417123794556,
0.5161130428314209,
-0.5209311246871948,
0.7660069465637207,
0.1342388540506363,
-0.80345618724823,
0.13682813942432404,
-0.3150901198387146,
-0.22338621318340302,
-0.1517784744501114,
-0.5753598809242249,
-0.46676090359687805,
-0.165674090385437,
-0.1682802140712738,
0.3951994478702545,
-0.3705674409866333,
0.6336973309516907,
-0.5886026620864868,
-0.6113141775131226,
0.6297391057014465,
-0.6263753175735474,
0.8068114519119263,
-0.04428507387638092,
-0.5138362050056458,
-0.13310497999191284,
-0.3269280195236206,
-0.1274423599243164,
0.20612744987010956,
-0.36368194222450256,
-0.2807784080505371,
0.29808875918388367,
-0.26968929171562195,
0.5919656753540039,
0.2913781404495239,
-0.6388279795646667,
-0.110203318297863,
-0.035445962101221085,
0.844811737537384,
1.1897472143173218,
-0.24808558821678162,
0.044179294258356094,
-0.5935760736465454,
0.14291056990623474,
-0.15936295688152313,
0.2409733533859253,
0.3549831509590149,
-0.7358700633049011,
-0.7347955107688904,
-0.18341048061847687,
-0.21610823273658752,
0.45548978447914124,
-0.2508569657802582,
0.42170536518096924,
-0.17470408976078033,
-0.27879685163497925,
-0.33122625946998596,
-0.08598187565803528,
0.49789586663246155,
0.5970406532287598,
0.12305286526679993,
-0.17874892055988312,
-0.15971466898918152,
-1.1705230474472046,
-0.32029905915260315,
-0.690729022026062,
0.09714876860380173,
0.49226388335227966,
0.9514338374137878,
-0.23881477117538452,
0.8376824259757996,
0.09537515789270401,
0.12592904269695282,
0.30048617720603943,
0.1474524289369583,
0.025535985827445984,
0.4751066267490387,
0.6809360384941101,
-0.8302376866340637,
-0.02631159871816635,
-0.318390816450119,
-0.8937516808509827,
0.18978482484817505,
0.3581486642360687,
0.12284823507070541,
0.15941178798675537,
0.23378919064998627,
-0.7463959455490112,
0.43411996960639954,
0.6955459117889404,
-0.40741023421287537,
0.7101845145225525,
-0.029184380546212196,
0.3234928250312805,
-0.6476778984069824,
-0.023348160088062286,
-0.09749574959278107,
-0.07207041233778,
-0.33219143748283386,
-0.13944120705127716,
0.1516658365726471,
0.3502749502658844,
-0.6873444318771362,
0.3430827260017395,
0.13392381370067596,
-0.14797301590442657,
-0.1847086250782013,
0.2901138365268707,
0.18529866635799408,
0.1952795684337616,
-0.2245330661535263,
0.7207381725311279,
0.25576624274253845,
-0.7203903198242188,
0.41569578647613525,
0.35232093930244446,
-0.11754026263952255,
0.6129006147384644,
-0.7688644528388977,
0.24191364645957947,
-0.24770459532737732,
0.22307687997817993,
-0.6528223752975464,
-0.40046805143356323,
0.2952500581741333,
-0.4175385534763336,
-0.24343805015087128,
-0.16360025107860565,
-0.49909085035324097,
-0.43725264072418213,
-0.5803350210189819,
0.535090446472168,
0.7389312386512756,
-0.2816452980041504,
0.17476974427700043,
0.32100409269332886,
-0.1127963736653328,
-0.9804642200469971,
-0.9561073184013367,
-0.022709988057613373,
-0.11264953762292862,
-0.7054659724235535,
0.07285250723361969,
0.05284940451383591,
-0.7005603909492493,
0.06601399928331375,
-0.12411732971668243,
0.16098688542842865,
-0.07062374800443649,
0.18913301825523376,
0.13917268812656403,
-0.30272287130355835,
0.08301369100809097,
-0.21654728055000305,
0.15559926629066467,
0.29786014556884766,
-0.1557682901620865,
0.3283986747264862,
-0.7121301889419556,
-0.4820142984390259,
-0.4106527268886566,
-0.13680829107761383,
1.0296176671981812,
-0.2767733633518219,
0.541834831237793,
0.375470370054245,
-0.37837937474250793,
0.3255329728126526,
-0.7235369086265564,
-0.13433678448200226,
-0.5526607036590576,
0.1799289733171463,
-0.07010047882795334,
-1.323143482208252,
0.2840360403060913,
0.33532145619392395,
0.09675224125385284,
0.6149404048919678,
0.8537132143974304,
-0.46137720346450806,
0.591033935546875,
0.5038084387779236,
-0.013485806994140148,
0.04856671020388603,
-0.3189627230167389,
0.1999424695968628,
-0.7191686034202576,
-0.03420634940266609,
-0.591715931892395,
-0.2781771123409271,
-0.9968258738517761,
-0.41559675335884094,
0.03972144424915314,
0.076607845723629,
-0.9358548521995544,
0.1858004331588745,
-0.19549652934074402,
0.4529058635234833,
0.08219414949417114,
-0.33943670988082886,
0.33927443623542786,
-0.03320735692977905,
-0.11018463224172592,
0.10278355330228806,
-0.4181272089481354,
-1.154222846031189,
1.14536714553833,
0.4021384119987488,
0.8280477523803711,
0.21364343166351318,
0.3851044774055481,
0.4656277298927307,
0.7936595678329468,
-0.8992477655410767,
0.41222983598709106,
-0.20223738253116608,
-0.825089693069458,
-0.3585008382797241,
-0.4361533224582672,
-0.7164236903190613,
0.3988862931728363,
-0.25932958722114563,
-0.9056494832038879,
0.5711602568626404,
0.029023604467511177,
-0.23745596408843994,
0.37077653408050537,
-0.3777688145637512,
0.6020291447639465,
-0.467916876077652,
-0.5762819051742554,
-0.3520071506500244,
-0.5749962329864502,
0.7458702325820923,
-0.19060294330120087,
0.4775318503379822,
-0.5355081558227539,
-0.035657625645399094,
0.6762269735336304,
-0.2891307771205902,
0.8613631129264832,
0.017656784504652023,
-0.45972558856010437,
0.45138612389564514,
0.09359681606292725,
0.5970346331596375,
0.32010045647621155,
-0.43329042196273804,
0.10711695998907089,
0.05440157651901245,
-0.6585870981216431,
-0.23659402132034302,
0.8928267955780029,
-1.0532530546188354,
-0.8394505381584167,
-0.5675255656242371,
-0.40755680203437805,
-0.0707460343837738,
0.10407916456460953,
0.094912089407444,
0.31461602449417114,
-0.22950325906276703,
0.2998104989528656,
0.6314030885696411,
-0.3300841748714447,
0.49496006965637207,
0.5236201882362366,
0.00972668919712305,
-0.3632182776927948,
0.5400234460830688,
-0.18358194828033447,
0.505223274230957,
-0.049547694623470306,
0.36121371388435364,
-0.260718435049057,
-0.24012123048305511,
-0.5475584268569946,
0.5803758502006531,
-0.6501528024673462,
0.07606207579374313,
-0.26417234539985657,
0.01603965274989605,
-0.20126719772815704,
-0.33236637711524963,
-0.5556544661521912,
-0.23373576998710632,
-0.04483611509203911,
0.06425200402736664,
0.30250757932662964,
0.9286969900131226,
0.37633994221687317,
0.13169008493423462,
-0.7888767719268799,
0.29148662090301514,
0.3480825126171112,
0.200252965092659,
-0.367995023727417,
-0.6045796275138855,
0.08755555748939514,
0.19942507147789001,
-0.3801632225513458,
-0.7175354957580566,
-0.16312579810619354,
-0.14733676612377167,
0.4316459000110626,
0.6201269030570984,
0.11659714579582214,
0.4386434257030487,
-0.179410919547081,
0.7175548076629639,
0.1326986849308014,
-1.0491182804107666,
0.050996240228414536,
-0.49359816312789917,
-0.15225251019001007,
0.5212289094924927,
0.40234601497650146,
-0.49384599924087524,
-0.42422595620155334,
-0.7114376425743103,
-0.3562451899051666,
0.6293648481369019,
0.5371250510215759,
0.1893201470375061,
0.04363470897078514,
0.6847745776176453,
0.038477350026369095,
0.5870699286460876,
-0.9067745804786682,
-0.00961641687899828,
-0.3960801661014557,
-0.26145562529563904,
-0.19248804450035095,
-0.19756416976451874,
-0.35181140899658203,
-0.16665223240852356,
0.2783192992210388,
-0.14701266586780548,
0.005807979963719845,
0.33298513293266296,
-0.10509733110666275,
-0.45379823446273804,
0.27039751410484314,
0.6414269208908081,
1.0992380380630493,
-0.12143826484680176,
-0.0418146550655365,
-0.019060250371694565,
-0.6117523908615112,
0.5946387648582458,
-0.3235478699207306,
-0.24185819923877716,
-0.3939492702484131,
0.4044072926044464,
0.5396730303764343,
0.10836343467235565,
-0.7904902696609497,
0.9323382377624512,
0.054745085537433624,
-0.48410481214523315,
-0.67695552110672,
0.054007865488529205,
0.3392747640609741,
0.20401057600975037,
-0.13035933673381805,
0.25734004378318787,
-0.15882767736911774,
-0.938319981098175,
0.004803984891623259,
0.34217068552970886,
-0.32483527064323425,
-0.23024006187915802,
0.4401388168334961,
0.24986092746257782,
-0.21674668788909912,
0.8957672715187073,
-0.2530369162559509,
-0.5912997722625732,
0.7135602831840515,
0.16368865966796875,
0.6225113272666931,
-0.27581629157066345,
0.3163905739784241,
0.16304311156272888,
0.8982572555541992,
-0.28743189573287964,
0.28068625926971436,
0.17338250577449799,
-1.037572979927063,
-0.7280880808830261,
-0.6172369122505188,
-0.6276406645774841,
0.21042585372924805,
-0.5864490270614624,
0.06244789808988571,
-0.5718304514884949,
-0.3923310339450836,
-0.3591151535511017,
-0.12252829968929291,
-0.3783484399318695,
0.14764975011348724,
0.20652709901332855,
0.632744550704956,
-0.48776549100875854,
0.8121684193611145,
0.6362850666046143,
-0.33717644214630127,
-0.3572404682636261,
0.14484234154224396,
-0.02206873707473278,
-0.7237561941146851,
0.40916118025779724,
0.3035220205783844,
-0.5278489589691162,
-0.32745128870010376,
-0.6948208212852478,
-0.8371077179908752,
1.0924240350723267,
0.6577479243278503,
-0.5727331638336182,
-0.13868582248687744,
0.3632512390613556,
0.4113495349884033,
-0.35186266899108887,
-0.11664257943630219,
0.7721144556999207,
0.9548370838165283,
-0.10252231359481812,
-0.9962284564971924,
0.20733006298542023,
-0.10346292704343796,
-0.3291512429714203,
0.05318687856197357,
-1.0412681102752686,
1.2067818641662598,
-0.4967063069343567,
0.06904859840869904,
0.06759108603000641,
0.2416202276945114,
0.6155825257301331,
0.3514329791069031,
0.5298658609390259,
0.5283442735671997,
0.7526872754096985,
-0.15037235617637634,
1.054953932762146,
-0.09898499399423599,
0.5271230936050415,
0.4983484745025635,
-0.44945624470710754,
0.7615029811859131,
0.5678734183311462,
-0.1485624611377716,
0.5540100336074829,
0.4285585582256317,
-0.07858727872371674,
0.08868218213319778,
0.47875750064849854,
0.1181904524564743,
-0.3459804952144623,
0.1932808756828308,
-0.12935185432434082,
0.6501823663711548,
0.7690278887748718,
-0.25186148285865784,
0.09989012777805328,
-0.3363947570323944,
0.3881365954875946,
-0.023792246356606483,
-0.27689996361732483,
0.349548876285553,
0.539634108543396,
-0.5696954727172852,
0.8715342879295349,
0.3823203146457672,
0.6569034457206726,
-0.4134860634803772,
0.28077155351638794,
0.11963213980197906,
0.23854583501815796,
-0.2965027093887329,
-0.8421823382377625,
0.13626661896705627,
0.357462614774704,
0.11357663571834564,
0.0028526526875793934,
0.4561077356338501,
0.028685957193374634,
-0.32821306586265564,
0.3620496690273285,
0.6077855825424194,
0.17406073212623596,
-0.1005072295665741,
-0.7428515553474426,
-0.019986502826213837,
-0.18459810316562653,
-0.3387424945831299,
0.07969417423009872,
0.25238412618637085,
-0.30659663677215576,
0.8755413889884949,
0.607611358165741,
-0.3054625988006592,
-0.14049875736236572,
-0.11947290599346161,
0.752106785774231,
-1.0421431064605713,
-0.22048406302928925,
-0.9984111785888672,
0.16740551590919495,
-0.016063136979937553,
-0.5737262964248657,
0.476618230342865,
0.21891359984874725,
0.6852589249610901,
0.18677227199077606,
0.8845629692077637,
0.049959924072027206,
0.0018674199236556888,
-0.6076543927192688,
0.8537164330482483,
-0.36046352982521057,
0.32043734192848206,
-0.26728811860084534,
-0.8905500173568726,
0.2402118742465973,
0.7755871415138245,
-0.4713701903820038,
0.3643595576286316,
0.734086275100708,
0.5607627630233765,
0.10080134868621826,
0.32373353838920593,
0.3812929689884186,
0.612296462059021,
0.36269599199295044,
0.4436718821525574,
1.2645916938781738,
-0.23567688465118408,
0.4253900349140167,
-0.020167239010334015,
-0.116055928170681,
-0.36795300245285034,
-0.8681779503822327,
-0.9661109447479248,
-0.09038800746202469,
-0.10208775848150253,
-0.30792781710624695,
0.24297669529914856,
0.8628206253051758,
0.3908785879611969,
-0.6668307781219482,
-0.48872140049934387,
0.009142652153968811,
0.07459992170333862,
0.10526535660028458,
-0.18596918880939484,
0.37439924478530884,
0.03921522572636604,
-0.613621711730957,
0.10355331748723984,
0.3453190326690674,
-0.011896182782948017,
-0.5341569185256958,
-0.3948902487754822,
0.04920065030455589,
0.4434647560119629,
0.8402577638626099,
0.03369702026247978,
-1.128013014793396,
-0.7408958673477173,
-0.08658885210752487,
-0.41160109639167786,
0.04136907309293747,
0.7559561729431152,
-0.6648456454277039,
-0.12208262830972672,
0.3245129883289337,
0.2947791516780853,
0.2944847643375397,
0.1971522569656372,
0.49311792850494385,
-0.1687822788953781,
0.11282731592655182,
0.504937469959259,
0.48647215962409973,
0.47936707735061646,
-0.15221592783927917,
0.11808692663908005,
0.40527108311653137,
-0.6579826474189758,
-0.481036901473999,
0.47015348076820374,
-0.8117883205413818,
-0.03617161884903908,
1.0846601724624634,
-0.19034069776535034,
-0.29480817914009094,
-0.09738440066576004,
0.010228244587779045,
-0.11679181456565857,
-0.36714592576026917,
0.7653406858444214,
0.9184072017669678,
-0.1525646299123764,
0.2121007889509201,
-0.8880807161331177,
0.5003765821456909,
0.19047942757606506,
-0.5079646706581116,
-0.061729107052087784,
0.5294371843338013,
0.3973131477832794,
0.27399230003356934,
0.4054681658744812,
-0.38333961367607117,
0.37369272112846375,
-0.056014444679021835,
-0.06682328134775162,
0.01301591470837593,
0.06743896007537842,
0.02420997805893421,
-0.06574511528015137,
0.18962162733078003,
0.31090593338012695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11093v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11093v2
|
AudioSetMix: Enhancing Audio-Language Datasets with LLM-Assisted Augmentations
| 2024-05-17T21:08:58 | 2024-06-07T16:15:26 |
David Xu
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.MM, cs.SD
|
Multi-modal learning in the audio-language domain has seen significant
advancements in recent years. However, audio-language learning faces challenges
due to limited and lower-quality data compared to image-language tasks.
Existing audio-language datasets are notably smaller, and manual labeling is
hindered by the need to listen to entire audio clips for accurate labeling.
Our method systematically generates audio-caption pairs by augmenting audio
clips with natural language labels and corresponding audio signal processing
operations. Leveraging a Large Language Model, we generate descriptions of
augmented audio clips with a prompt template. This scalable method produces
AudioSetMix, a high-quality training dataset for text-and-audio related models.
Integration of our dataset improves models performance on benchmarks by
providing diversified and better-aligned examples. Notably, our dataset
addresses the absence of modifiers (adjectives and adverbs) in existing
datasets. By enabling models to learn these concepts, and generating hard
negative examples during training, we achieve state-of-the-art performance on
multiple benchmarks.
|
[
-0.5917960405349731,
-0.6326059103012085,
0.2500123083591461,
0.08929158747196198,
-0.2958860993385315,
0.1315714567899704,
-0.405103474855423,
-0.43202489614486694,
0.16979382932186127,
0.44900456070899963,
-0.8147508502006531,
-0.4882010817527771,
-0.45536988973617554,
0.28154364228248596,
-0.18366841971874237,
0.7702834606170654,
0.14937379956245422,
0.3252949118614197,
-0.43791142106056213,
-0.394547700881958,
-0.6923970580101013,
-0.44354623556137085,
-0.49977800250053406,
-0.2036563754081726,
0.3036386966705322,
0.5948694348335266,
0.6808962225914001,
0.9067853093147278,
0.3806680738925934,
0.23433613777160645,
0.1694456934928894,
0.5799455046653748,
-0.2190551608800888,
0.3673684000968933,
0.35929444432258606,
-0.24072539806365967,
-0.5572372674942017,
0.10855846852064133,
0.7161473035812378,
0.8136420249938965,
0.07196542620658875,
0.15523852407932281,
-0.13172808289527893,
0.27206069231033325,
-0.47666579484939575,
0.2167198359966278,
-0.5134477019309998,
0.04133518412709236,
0.0171059537678957,
-0.482859343290329,
-0.10443077236413956,
-0.08643750846385956,
-0.12523478269577026,
-0.8572434782981873,
0.10834438353776932,
0.23439672589302063,
0.4825352728366852,
0.5432624220848083,
-0.42249560356140137,
-0.25231942534446716,
-0.6533718705177307,
0.94664067029953,
-0.6799439191818237,
0.7122153043746948,
0.6129591464996338,
0.28141623735427856,
0.0904967412352562,
-0.4207738935947418,
-0.5447055101394653,
-0.11861077696084976,
0.27042195200920105,
0.08266054838895798,
0.2146776020526886,
0.06427356600761414,
0.42696020007133484,
0.7839199900627136,
-0.31916823983192444,
0.22934970259666443,
-0.27545708417892456,
-0.16871142387390137,
0.611409604549408,
0.16981661319732666,
0.42810121178627014,
0.027534320950508118,
-0.4187706708908081,
-0.23836076259613037,
-0.8355101346969604,
-0.06869228929281235,
0.48771217465400696,
0.43422508239746094,
-0.19625775516033173,
0.7157392501831055,
0.0682278499007225,
0.8522037267684937,
-0.05834490805864334,
-0.4994579255580902,
0.6483429670333862,
-0.538590669631958,
-0.1085003986954689,
0.36753299832344055,
0.7040959596633911,
0.3062925636768341,
-0.06619221717119217,
-0.1938653439283371,
-0.6366221308708191,
-0.025087349116802216,
-0.2558339238166809,
-0.599414587020874,
-0.13492055237293243,
0.21987009048461914,
0.009519336745142937,
-0.11349371075630188,
-0.03667859733104706,
-0.38185280561447144,
-0.3984890282154083,
-0.8842174410820007,
0.6791042685508728,
-0.41913852095603943,
-0.15181532502174377,
0.20372885465621948,
-0.1443859189748764,
0.002919982187449932,
0.19537724554538727,
-0.8736165165901184,
0.2857401967048645,
0.5661472678184509,
0.5983592867851257,
-0.2772786319255829,
-0.18607883155345917,
-1.0075348615646362,
0.33660751581192017,
-0.28203922510147095,
0.6913766860961914,
-0.8076514601707458,
-0.3776452839374542,
0.034002020955085754,
-0.06717440485954285,
0.2044527232646942,
-0.8162129521369934,
0.613281786441803,
-0.20806419849395752,
0.36157897114753723,
-0.028267772868275642,
-0.756869912147522,
-0.1417984813451767,
0.023651205003261566,
-0.7702541351318359,
1.1914353370666504,
-0.03203709051012993,
-0.43064084649086,
0.439164936542511,
-0.5655578374862671,
-0.6317669153213501,
-0.04670577868819237,
-0.22170564532279968,
-0.3702470362186432,
-0.020561393350362778,
0.7077135443687439,
0.6089975237846375,
-0.3244120478630066,
0.2577376067638397,
-0.18351022899150848,
-0.34682920575141907,
0.3926849067211151,
-0.6234567761421204,
0.3993784487247467,
0.07803555577993393,
0.13823574781417847,
0.03600812330842018,
-1.0615979433059692,
-0.429864764213562,
-0.23753291368484497,
-0.39448675513267517,
-0.3852621018886566,
-0.13911037147045135,
0.3139829933643341,
0.2289993017911911,
0.02253701351583004,
-0.6025335192680359,
0.12222490459680557,
-0.42859822511672974,
0.3356124758720398,
0.4875370264053345,
0.1514194756746292,
0.5087987184524536,
-0.41643232107162476,
0.5377501249313354,
-0.007022873032838106,
-0.04467252269387245,
-0.8313855528831482,
-0.09167313575744629,
-0.5572089552879333,
-0.6502156853675842,
0.3319065570831299,
0.594628632068634,
-0.8601232171058655,
0.5428370833396912,
-0.32382991909980774,
-0.04407919570803642,
-0.8231607675552368,
0.49370893836021423,
0.24037306010723114,
0.5929521918296814,
0.5660643577575684,
-0.24917204678058624,
-0.6504483222961426,
-0.9562129974365234,
0.19965095818042755,
0.36582034826278687,
-0.2988117039203644,
0.48922890424728394,
-0.11643151193857193,
-0.28979039192199707,
0.85223788022995,
-0.25713050365448,
-0.3695683479309082,
-0.18611998856067657,
0.22075706720352173,
0.3146457076072693,
0.5515826344490051,
0.34994950890541077,
-0.7351547479629517,
-0.05769185721874237,
-0.14739255607128143,
-0.5246680378913879,
-0.24850276112556458,
-0.2316778004169464,
0.1914527267217636,
-0.03676038235425949,
0.5873584151268005,
-0.20425499975681305,
-0.2990286648273468,
0.4608229696750641,
0.01735556311905384,
0.48146429657936096,
-0.006674096919596195,
0.33061861991882324,
-1.3043543100357056,
-0.3077711760997772,
0.06467431038618088,
-0.3976080119609833,
-0.5461301803588867,
-0.47726067900657654,
-0.20257659256458282,
-0.1955866664648056,
-0.6027926802635193,
0.495659738779068,
-0.5503040552139282,
-0.214762344956398,
-0.47061029076576233,
0.3054688274860382,
0.08226249366998672,
0.5161392688751221,
0.115716852247715,
1.1019420623779297,
0.830169141292572,
-0.6551241874694824,
0.6209135055541992,
0.4014286696910858,
-0.46021369099617004,
0.551215410232544,
-0.26376837491989136,
0.09537849575281143,
-0.018705740571022034,
-0.034819673746824265,
-0.7918408513069153,
-0.40411487221717834,
0.03594253212213516,
-0.4183881878852844,
0.5778897404670715,
-0.06515227258205414,
-0.6914929151535034,
0.03439955785870552,
-0.299046128988266,
0.6313336491584778,
0.22771979868412018,
-0.7903215885162354,
0.5795617699623108,
0.6756035089492798,
-0.3973395526409149,
-0.6052460670471191,
-0.6407603025436401,
0.24319538474082947,
-0.29624494910240173,
-0.3787863254547119,
0.21916534006595612,
-0.2495255321264267,
-0.1926923394203186,
-0.19573958218097687,
-0.23896662890911102,
-0.19097645580768585,
-0.10701879113912582,
0.23982340097427368,
0.3974955976009369,
-0.2079019397497177,
0.52606600522995,
0.14825128018856049,
-0.06118825823068619,
-0.023656051605939865,
-0.019221017137169838,
0.2292524129152298,
0.06458722800016403,
-0.2310267984867096,
-0.3352748453617096,
0.39339515566825867,
0.4549306333065033,
-0.23604051768779755,
0.2992206811904907,
0.6876934766769409,
-0.18247100710868835,
-0.130841925740242,
-0.649989664554596,
-0.4159901738166809,
-0.43256691098213196,
0.4368407428264618,
-0.31574738025665283,
-1.0062206983566284,
0.19090723991394043,
0.012710532173514366,
0.19008110463619232,
0.03823060169816017,
0.3956541121006012,
-0.148285374045372,
1.1302918195724487,
0.4438859522342682,
-0.08853960782289505,
0.6926577091217041,
-0.17421960830688477,
-0.01100193988531828,
-0.9550901651382446,
-0.09682796150445938,
-0.12292362749576569,
-0.11667441576719284,
-0.2749997079372406,
-0.530316174030304,
0.41076532006263733,
-0.18582965433597565,
-0.07589250802993774,
0.40743082761764526,
-0.25339964032173157,
0.582372784614563,
0.647884726524353,
0.17921413481235504,
0.4447157382965088,
0.24226781725883484,
0.03154856339097023,
-0.12173625081777573,
-0.6605227589607239,
-0.24270205199718475,
1.1219077110290527,
0.3936350643634796,
0.9106593728065491,
0.07148516178131104,
0.4636498689651489,
0.5356384515762329,
0.0597795732319355,
-1.0627321004867554,
0.28624409437179565,
-0.05803874507546425,
-0.3591073751449585,
-0.19687265157699585,
-0.4031183421611786,
-0.5247340798377991,
0.16357070207595825,
-0.5857422351837158,
-0.29228925704956055,
0.16724595427513123,
0.21738429367542267,
-0.29367753863334656,
0.10137314349412918,
-0.5931307673454285,
0.4402381181716919,
-0.3976714611053467,
-0.4692889153957367,
-0.07660423219203949,
-0.5625855326652527,
0.41390132904052734,
-0.1557246893644333,
0.4956958293914795,
-0.2841716706752777,
-0.2454065978527069,
0.5835011005401611,
-0.20440563559532166,
0.6121940016746521,
0.04159866273403168,
-0.2620699107646942,
0.18332117795944214,
-0.08335216343402863,
0.13443224132061005,
0.20694878697395325,
0.17419180274009705,
0.044354889541864395,
-0.03845180198550224,
-0.16308431327342987,
-0.5032544732093811,
0.6741036772727966,
-0.6829658150672913,
-0.36473965644836426,
-0.02402384579181671,
-0.9729164242744446,
-0.6475329399108887,
-0.08235282450914383,
-0.08148231357336044,
1.073353886604309,
0.180385559797287,
0.2428930550813675,
0.8574276566505432,
-0.4263738691806793,
0.4417867362499237,
0.3457649052143097,
-0.14742307364940643,
-0.9250639081001282,
1.0901296138763428,
-0.2018192857503891,
0.22259891033172607,
0.5009067058563232,
0.02418425865471363,
-0.48006752133369446,
-0.4243013262748718,
-0.40114066004753113,
0.2807301878929138,
-0.6588432788848877,
-0.3013335168361664,
-0.45197200775146484,
0.11530891805887222,
-0.3195471167564392,
0.14292854070663452,
-0.43067166209220886,
-0.7701765894889832,
-0.256274551153183,
-0.3375679850578308,
0.4102919399738312,
0.36233383417129517,
-0.34398984909057617,
0.4011875092983246,
-0.9677397608757019,
0.6033198833465576,
0.4147528409957886,
0.3068169355392456,
-0.43050292134284973,
-0.6130465865135193,
-0.5222415328025818,
0.005715524312108755,
0.02207055315375328,
-0.7408051490783691,
0.35189715027809143,
0.5081943273544312,
0.6235995292663574,
0.5067235827445984,
-0.10408975183963776,
0.442737340927124,
-0.445389062166214,
0.7583298683166504,
0.3044719099998474,
-0.7445282340049744,
0.5236509442329407,
-0.522129237651825,
0.21132588386535645,
0.40526071190834045,
0.15388116240501404,
-0.5050802826881409,
-0.3287913501262665,
-0.3866669535636902,
-1.0278575420379639,
0.6637835502624512,
0.14501209557056427,
0.24107252061367035,
0.07585921883583069,
0.1365317702293396,
0.4066708981990814,
0.39532774686813354,
-0.7486386895179749,
-0.4738117754459381,
-0.35922443866729736,
-0.3549991846084595,
-0.23213765025138855,
-0.20132187008857727,
-0.2670511305332184,
-0.48232391476631165,
0.9927800893783569,
-0.2378264218568802,
0.12015476822853088,
-0.0036900630220770836,
-0.4018149971961975,
0.08253929018974304,
0.3433123826980591,
0.7897272109985352,
0.36047375202178955,
-0.2140524536371231,
0.21267496049404144,
0.10225614905357361,
-0.3005445599555969,
0.22159017622470856,
0.3105279803276062,
0.20675107836723328,
-0.011174994520843029,
0.40374088287353516,
1.1230131387710571,
0.4585895538330078,
-1.0338624715805054,
0.40757644176483154,
0.0225044097751379,
-0.16267052292823792,
-0.3240096867084503,
0.009853753261268139,
-0.061365608125925064,
0.030121630057692528,
0.393375962972641,
0.04608108103275299,
0.4092634320259094,
-0.273523211479187,
0.434842586517334,
0.27551960945129395,
-0.5731890797615051,
-0.17428290843963623,
0.645738959312439,
0.278353214263916,
-0.09863119572401047,
0.38004130125045776,
0.1078079342842102,
-0.10620367527008057,
0.4321915805339813,
0.3992786407470703,
0.7303218841552734,
-0.1099434569478035,
-0.08793972432613373,
0.4259757101535797,
0.1803722232580185,
0.07533206790685654,
0.11263598501682281,
-0.5939148664474487,
-0.6926959156990051,
-0.6915531754493713,
-0.5943153500556946,
-0.5569227933883667,
0.36378413438796997,
-0.6092393398284912,
0.44371268153190613,
-0.23369769752025604,
-0.09126013517379761,
-0.2581319212913513,
-0.3377326428890228,
-0.5337603688240051,
0.20208783447742462,
0.4273444414138794,
0.7775359153747559,
-1.0974220037460327,
0.6535891890525818,
0.7286016345024109,
-0.5337672829627991,
-0.7270653247833252,
-0.32410764694213867,
-0.16570815443992615,
-0.5443943738937378,
0.3893052935600281,
0.1914280503988266,
-0.13777080178260803,
-0.010186303406953812,
-0.5480144619941711,
-0.7459530234336853,
0.8668439984321594,
0.4368695616722107,
-0.5479035377502441,
0.35480618476867676,
0.2995518445968628,
0.2526942789554596,
-0.568821132183075,
0.08311496675014496,
0.5276472568511963,
0.47281867265701294,
0.22354242205619812,
-0.6597050428390503,
-0.4123097062110901,
-0.25314974784851074,
-0.2627618908882141,
0.08778049796819687,
-0.1321643888950348,
0.5087288618087769,
0.02094641700387001,
0.014461127109825611,
-0.24031545221805573,
0.6980509757995605,
0.1616150587797165,
0.27462509274482727,
0.6178225874900818,
0.5329920649528503,
0.47325050830841064,
-0.18820391595363617,
0.9352445006370544,
-0.3749409317970276,
0.04207809269428253,
1.3906834125518799,
-0.0012243484379723668,
0.6891130805015564,
0.5870299339294434,
0.013621676713228226,
0.11255402863025665,
0.8106201887130737,
-0.18037962913513184,
0.49416622519493103,
-0.11976911127567291,
-0.6020436882972717,
-0.7647774815559387,
-0.49861252307891846,
-0.16055943071842194,
0.5031850934028625,
0.46522578597068787,
-0.2817896604537964,
-0.053923025727272034,
0.5093662142753601,
-0.23298746347427368,
0.19189859926700592,
-0.3956373929977417,
0.8590308427810669,
0.10666322708129883,
-0.2703053057193756,
0.3690136969089508,
-0.3571215569972992,
0.8684889078140259,
-0.4127379059791565,
-0.2762664258480072,
-0.08743276447057724,
-0.14950057864189148,
-0.17734679579734802,
-0.5843753814697266,
0.0709061473608017,
-0.17666864395141602,
-0.33681541681289673,
-0.1576121300458908,
0.4252336025238037,
-1.0123354196548462,
-0.5780782103538513,
-0.03199835866689682,
0.4757740795612335,
0.05670390650629997,
0.25563734769821167,
-0.4836043119430542,
0.08639214932918549,
-0.285722017288208,
0.0605253130197525,
0.03074692003428936,
0.1219407394528389,
0.22458171844482422,
0.5749549865722656,
0.6669874787330627,
0.20155394077301025,
0.10374216735363007,
0.45751938223838806,
0.7062837481498718,
-0.22662964463233948,
-0.3669551908969879,
-0.45020171999931335,
0.3477097153663635,
-0.052956994622945786,
0.2012263685464859,
0.6161542534828186,
0.9455825090408325,
0.7723459601402283,
-0.2602504789829254,
0.9352333545684814,
0.25922879576683044,
0.7862900495529175,
-0.8381026387214661,
0.2241450548171997,
-0.7069078087806702,
0.6533863544464111,
-0.04623283073306084,
-1.006914734840393,
-0.4206630289554596,
0.2897115647792816,
-0.13593488931655884,
0.019161131232976913,
0.4124230444431305,
0.9226260781288147,
-0.39213743805885315,
-0.07531564682722092,
0.4642230272293091,
0.0007745626498945057,
0.2462795376777649,
0.3653155267238617,
0.889650285243988,
-0.5549415349960327,
0.5320619344711304,
-0.44496971368789673,
-0.044120725244283676,
0.06879307329654694,
-0.8304646015167236,
-0.9380310773849487,
-0.6878341436386108,
-0.5847868323326111,
-0.03994284197688103,
-0.03251604363322258,
1.3008383512496948,
0.7772814035415649,
-0.8345205783843994,
-0.24473737180233002,
0.19874167442321777,
0.17763355374336243,
-0.3434789478778839,
-0.25229591131210327,
0.2620479464530945,
-0.43693020939826965,
-1.1374694108963013,
0.9776099324226379,
0.29764324426651,
0.1578865647315979,
-0.245878204703331,
-0.16611383855342865,
-0.1367773413658142,
0.09897242486476898,
0.5611686110496521,
0.3049647808074951,
-0.5177104473114014,
-0.1826532632112503,
-0.2253502458333969,
0.14749765396118164,
0.44335541129112244,
0.8730655908584595,
-0.7975760102272034,
0.6891573667526245,
0.32510754466056824,
0.7816509008407593,
0.25347888469696045,
0.012063656002283096,
0.7479481101036072,
-1.1445366144180298,
0.18628564476966858,
0.15449026226997375,
0.41089576482772827,
0.8728586435317993,
-0.07319723814725876,
0.33654269576072693,
0.21457761526107788,
-0.35448384284973145,
-0.8782203793525696,
0.11810784786939621,
-1.1658884286880493,
-0.07246597856283188,
1.3443044424057007,
0.3056793212890625,
-0.02217988669872284,
-0.1831849217414856,
-0.39590373635292053,
0.3232644200325012,
-0.5885224938392639,
0.4600415527820587,
0.46209418773651123,
-0.06919034570455551,
-0.4710555076599121,
-0.6075746417045593,
0.5675918459892273,
0.10567876696586609,
-0.5758118629455566,
0.0388932004570961,
0.9526781439781189,
0.19833175837993622,
0.014695174992084503,
0.1685759425163269,
-0.10963475704193115,
0.4141065180301666,
-0.15319909155368805,
0.31018751859664917,
-0.766953706741333,
-0.3249948024749756,
-0.5634748339653015,
0.016881193965673447,
0.07197936624288559,
-0.5214044451713562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11086v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11086v1
|
Multilingual Substitution-based Word Sense Induction
| 2024-05-17T20:38:56 | 2024-05-17T20:38:56 |
Denis Kokosinskii, Nikolay Arefyev
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Word Sense Induction (WSI) is the task of discovering senses of an ambiguous
word by grouping usages of this word into clusters corresponding to these
senses. Many approaches were proposed to solve WSI in English and a few other
languages, but these approaches are not easily adaptable to new languages. We
present multilingual substitution-based WSI methods that support any of 100
languages covered by the underlying multilingual language model with minimal to
no adaptation required. Despite the multilingual capabilities, our methods
perform on par with the existing monolingual approaches on popular English WSI
datasets. At the same time, they will be most useful for lower-resourced
languages which miss lexical resources available for English, thus, have higher
demand for unsupervised methods like WSI.
|
[
-0.4642902910709381,
-0.046354740858078,
0.6291662454605103,
0.18155482411384583,
-0.00022285798331722617,
-0.2569800019264221,
-0.15639016032218933,
-0.5802450776100159,
0.3279891610145569,
-0.295541375875473,
-0.896994948387146,
-0.23136112093925476,
-0.4994697868824005,
0.5720369815826416,
0.05157668516039848,
0.37004512548446655,
-0.32170626521110535,
0.3651055693626404,
-0.10869788378477097,
-0.7724106907844543,
-0.4697774648666382,
-0.2621280550956726,
-0.40229925513267517,
-0.4186129570007324,
0.7918993234634399,
0.6062365174293518,
0.27041420340538025,
0.16728746891021729,
0.12842057645320892,
0.3216225206851959,
-0.10623249411582947,
0.4535757005214691,
0.1181149035692215,
-0.13308390974998474,
-0.6317098140716553,
-0.40229788422584534,
-0.06569451093673706,
0.18342171609401703,
0.3358069360256195,
1.2598165273666382,
-0.4514371454715729,
-0.07660158723592758,
0.12313927710056305,
0.4886532723903656,
-1.029887080192566,
-0.035997174680233,
-0.6650652289390564,
0.10033165663480759,
-0.13588304817676544,
-0.09378870576620102,
-0.5671281814575195,
0.10254549980163574,
0.06027752161026001,
-1.033074140548706,
0.06193430721759796,
0.06539712101221085,
0.5150200128555298,
-0.0671105906367302,
-0.3738090693950653,
-0.35234761238098145,
-0.6064627170562744,
1.1428234577178955,
-0.6316395401954651,
0.9142442941665649,
0.3456551134586334,
0.07031897455453873,
-0.2997531592845917,
-0.29637113213539124,
-1.1100841760635376,
0.03500713035464287,
-0.29126372933387756,
0.3150295317173004,
0.11876474320888519,
0.04175980016589165,
0.2968360185623169,
0.14084933698177338,
-0.6594313383102417,
0.04908785969018936,
-0.1354019045829773,
-0.18259210884571075,
0.39918580651283264,
0.09818705171346664,
0.4032232463359833,
-0.15076477825641632,
-0.20923615992069244,
-0.2144649773836136,
-0.5760805010795593,
0.007090212311595678,
0.16932907700538635,
0.4500105679035187,
0.01626315899193287,
0.5990098118782043,
-0.26076772809028625,
0.9201400876045227,
-0.19921590387821198,
-0.5991445779800415,
0.5726197957992554,
-0.5012181997299194,
-0.1987760215997696,
0.15373218059539795,
0.5646522045135498,
0.10713805258274078,
0.18581247329711914,
-0.019326040521264076,
-0.23672255873680115,
0.5582021474838257,
-0.3672206699848175,
-0.34555432200431824,
0.23131971061229706,
0.0692543312907219,
-0.4249386787414551,
-0.013405769132077694,
0.16752412915229797,
-0.45861825346946716,
-0.31827542185783386,
-0.3112429082393646,
0.36266300082206726,
-0.6790907979011536,
-0.545613706111908,
0.23355861008167267,
-0.895530104637146,
0.21286286413669586,
0.03817863017320633,
-0.8186875581741333,
0.027716532349586487,
0.183172807097435,
0.6256343126296997,
-0.10135363042354584,
-1.134743094444275,
-0.280468612909317,
0.44949862360954285,
-0.49897968769073486,
0.9415809512138367,
-0.7426572442054749,
-0.6081206798553467,
0.11811984330415726,
0.3594764769077301,
-0.2407671958208084,
-0.48067739605903625,
0.24548569321632385,
-0.17424818873405457,
0.6827602386474609,
-0.6764252781867981,
-0.49802592396736145,
-0.3079952299594879,
0.28936967253685,
-0.5282544493675232,
1.1102674007415771,
0.3051123321056366,
-0.7849676012992859,
0.8230584859848022,
-1.170689582824707,
-0.7350080013275146,
0.11808463931083679,
0.06270602345466614,
0.30722576379776,
0.24898189306259155,
0.26037123799324036,
0.035791900008916855,
0.2315293848514557,
0.028109969571232796,
-0.24281974136829376,
-0.3739481270313263,
0.12875542044639587,
-0.6310553550720215,
0.6429798603057861,
0.22693462669849396,
-0.08338037133216858,
-0.08430549502372742,
-0.8197462558746338,
0.03214002028107643,
0.227889284491539,
0.1343030035495758,
-1.0012375116348267,
0.17014838755130768,
-0.042908236384391785,
0.15813907980918884,
0.22727404534816742,
-0.8130537867546082,
0.19494584202766418,
-0.5134695172309875,
0.33761486411094666,
0.6074913144111633,
0.05881281569600105,
0.46566662192344666,
-0.19377528131008148,
0.5088824033737183,
0.5050784945487976,
0.2340075522661209,
-0.291182279586792,
-0.6369768977165222,
-0.6885780692100525,
-0.15039485692977905,
0.18786942958831787,
0.7987995743751526,
-1.2619088888168335,
0.21793094277381897,
0.08693871647119522,
-0.32711899280548096,
-0.6355041861534119,
0.1143694669008255,
0.18966570496559143,
0.3181578814983368,
0.42122751474380493,
0.056393034756183624,
-0.6621677875518799,
-0.8394757509231567,
-0.3515183925628662,
-0.17569030821323395,
-0.009792684577405453,
-0.019205735996365547,
0.2885773181915283,
-0.41642460227012634,
0.7127179503440857,
-0.40431177616119385,
-0.4041309654712677,
-0.34459152817726135,
0.09305253624916077,
0.2656192481517792,
0.16453933715820312,
0.3040729761123657,
-0.7978276610374451,
-0.35801658034324646,
0.3384353518486023,
-0.8039498925209045,
-0.0029092179611325264,
0.0018476282712072134,
0.012073775753378868,
0.35233598947525024,
0.5752084255218506,
-0.33434534072875977,
0.3975643217563629,
0.8819116353988647,
-0.35211509466171265,
0.6365545392036438,
-0.10242611169815063,
0.22347594797611237,
-1.504250407218933,
-0.004189704079180956,
0.05279381200671196,
-0.028473056852817535,
-0.6385205388069153,
0.1220419779419899,
0.18899361789226532,
-0.11671321094036102,
-0.7327907681465149,
0.7428109645843506,
-0.712207555770874,
-0.02051652781665325,
-0.11657921969890594,
0.062069665640592575,
0.3106932044029236,
0.3983668088912964,
0.10301487147808075,
1.20892333984375,
0.719161868095398,
-0.9957047700881958,
0.2875159978866577,
0.4294562041759491,
-0.4247296154499054,
0.6866592764854431,
-0.2583686411380768,
-0.31845539808273315,
-0.290812224149704,
-0.18652679026126862,
-0.7621064186096191,
-0.22417935729026794,
0.18447352945804596,
-0.36393409967422485,
0.11386705189943314,
0.06549514830112457,
0.01825878769159317,
-0.5417119860649109,
-0.31249621510505676,
0.7347365021705627,
0.1133037731051445,
-1.0708125829696655,
0.5295393466949463,
0.18852657079696655,
-0.011068953201174736,
-0.7363958954811096,
-0.8216846585273743,
-0.03048081137239933,
-0.19448424875736237,
-0.17188970744609833,
0.4042552411556244,
-0.2476911097764969,
-0.3052963316440582,
0.16884605586528778,
0.008336381055414677,
-0.04805976152420044,
-0.030706997960805893,
-0.17883893847465515,
0.06126272678375244,
-0.1947994828224182,
0.14707593619823456,
0.3471432626247406,
-0.21153925359249115,
-0.4813149869441986,
-0.5462678074836731,
0.3600916266441345,
0.022198885679244995,
-0.7890542149543762,
-0.6075200438499451,
1.0946904420852661,
0.8537581562995911,
-0.26537540555000305,
0.5930993556976318,
0.4076941907405853,
-0.6359679698944092,
-0.26307016611099243,
-0.3614656627178192,
-0.07351076602935791,
-0.5118402242660522,
0.24385805428028107,
-0.8458800315856934,
-0.6434574723243713,
0.42320582270622253,
-0.11651977151632309,
0.0242648646235466,
0.3588675856590271,
0.28235235810279846,
-0.024965230375528336,
1.263190507888794,
0.7341950535774231,
-0.18264760076999664,
0.4991167485713959,
0.2221912145614624,
0.6875443458557129,
-0.5636240839958191,
-0.1702030748128891,
-0.4387805163860321,
-0.2744738757610321,
-0.717511773109436,
-0.08162520825862885,
0.48694875836372375,
0.036360003054142,
0.27630534768104553,
0.3528982698917389,
-0.49601301550865173,
0.6452856063842773,
0.5786009430885315,
-0.19838306307792664,
0.2874898910522461,
0.12453385442495346,
-0.3939741253852844,
-0.0590963140130043,
-0.8715470433235168,
-0.07646454125642776,
0.4413684606552124,
-0.04512587934732437,
0.623390793800354,
0.33504411578178406,
0.7541655898094177,
0.2009231299161911,
0.06290421634912491,
-1.287826418876648,
0.5740253925323486,
-0.15014035999774933,
0.00796348787844181,
-0.45612332224845886,
-0.21656492352485657,
-1.1811710596084595,
0.4007987380027771,
-0.07271461933851242,
-0.6198084950447083,
0.40375223755836487,
-0.006848110817372799,
-0.10881748050451279,
0.23235675692558289,
-1.180298089981079,
0.6540253758430481,
0.2117093950510025,
0.07991735637187958,
-0.21829724311828613,
0.10240471363067627,
0.16875484585762024,
0.2024494707584381,
0.4605250656604767,
0.06963461637496948,
0.10953700542449951,
0.7345062494277954,
-0.4967495799064636,
0.6375818848609924,
-0.5948313474655151,
-0.389483243227005,
0.1950019896030426,
0.04243254289031029,
0.426466703414917,
-0.01681412383913994,
-0.18309196829795837,
0.3314829170703888,
0.3790709674358368,
-0.5522106885910034,
-0.6289357542991638,
0.6822365522384644,
-0.4155077338218689,
-0.5462101697921753,
-0.6530691385269165,
-0.5336251258850098,
-0.662787139415741,
0.3294145166873932,
0.5584744215011597,
0.34669890999794006,
-0.27934032678604126,
-0.6400291919708252,
0.43538838624954224,
-0.12589403986930847,
0.8494688868522644,
0.5874919891357422,
0.06162871792912483,
-0.0562635101377964,
1.0779004096984863,
0.021022731438279152,
-0.15499578416347504,
0.2039443850517273,
0.3656471371650696,
-0.4655206799507141,
-0.3034050464630127,
-0.6869197487831116,
0.21015240252017975,
-0.4824194610118866,
-0.1530148684978485,
-0.3905450105667114,
-0.024542154744267464,
-0.5457756519317627,
-0.3048192262649536,
-0.18626955151557922,
-0.23965632915496826,
0.08209165930747986,
-0.17232830822467804,
0.3513038456439972,
0.7474471926689148,
-0.25117242336273193,
-0.014222318306565285,
-0.7733831405639648,
0.24084357917308807,
0.34884974360466003,
0.6152172088623047,
-0.214207261800766,
-0.3243024945259094,
-0.1687764823436737,
0.282253235578537,
0.05615062266588211,
-1.1582249402999878,
0.2917276620864868,
0.4763977825641632,
0.775736927986145,
0.7396570444107056,
-0.08509480208158493,
0.987707793712616,
-0.6801288723945618,
0.9400133490562439,
0.5645752549171448,
-1.1953774690628052,
0.507358193397522,
-0.0752803236246109,
0.295858234167099,
0.5135353207588196,
0.5447879433631897,
-1.0901116132736206,
-0.2891020178794861,
-0.42079371213912964,
-0.5386162996292114,
0.40665069222450256,
-0.4644472301006317,
0.01279766671359539,
-0.33508551120758057,
-0.017572849988937378,
0.4241034984588623,
-0.09215405583381653,
-0.6087625622749329,
0.03499707207083702,
-0.0970785990357399,
-0.34297990798950195,
-0.06373792141675949,
-0.18238604068756104,
-0.05452728644013405,
-0.4627150297164917,
0.912900447845459,
-0.5414294004440308,
0.35666897892951965,
0.36602890491485596,
-0.30144503712654114,
-0.002920701401308179,
0.47235026955604553,
0.7437641024589539,
0.7747025489807129,
0.41608068346977234,
0.33392322063446045,
0.6667386293411255,
-0.1907305121421814,
0.3040362298488617,
-0.2992396056652069,
-0.060905054211616516,
0.37948453426361084,
0.2086755335330963,
0.6797815561294556,
0.06625852733850479,
-0.709800660610199,
0.5134996771812439,
-0.16855043172836304,
-0.3719908893108368,
-0.561482846736908,
-0.09881532192230225,
-0.10952085256576538,
0.0059006717056035995,
0.4243212640285492,
0.09098700433969498,
0.24900822341442108,
-0.4809742867946625,
0.27446451783180237,
0.5671273469924927,
-0.2762902081012726,
-0.3951248526573181,
0.11259882897138596,
-0.12445447593927383,
-0.07090628892183304,
0.3314231336116791,
-0.8409313559532166,
-0.46380576491355896,
0.16276556253433228,
0.6775764226913452,
0.5848763585090637,
-0.7689362168312073,
0.2482142150402069,
0.46276986598968506,
0.3570519685745239,
-0.0727531686425209,
0.6376950144767761,
0.11479184031486511,
-1.3456178903579712,
-0.696144163608551,
-0.43761271238327026,
-0.41347751021385193,
0.22897206246852875,
-0.9583304524421692,
0.26555266976356506,
-0.06573642045259476,
0.27925291657447815,
0.06470943987369537,
-0.520592212677002,
-0.5624523162841797,
0.14152029156684875,
0.24663828313350677,
1.2176766395568848,
-1.3946783542633057,
0.9204904437065125,
1.1839802265167236,
-0.11710546165704727,
-0.7655321359634399,
0.19181232154369354,
-0.12090471386909485,
-0.8795812726020813,
0.036322515457868576,
0.07832672446966171,
-0.14297914505004883,
-0.12111620604991913,
-0.35242554545402527,
-0.6804381608963013,
0.676385760307312,
-0.10855059325695038,
-0.34136971831321716,
0.19421608746051788,
0.13407623767852783,
0.22377808392047882,
-0.06372423470020294,
0.07287640869617462,
0.6264640092849731,
0.8159516453742981,
-0.11264731734991074,
-0.7280772924423218,
-0.11189286410808563,
-0.42114120721817017,
0.28414106369018555,
0.38761231303215027,
-0.24757519364356995,
0.4187222421169281,
-0.2647513747215271,
-0.3607235252857208,
-0.049175191670656204,
0.7782383561134338,
0.22518318891525269,
0.5232250094413757,
0.857085645198822,
0.7320215106010437,
1.1708675622940063,
0.014137465506792068,
0.7093716263771057,
-0.32336723804473877,
0.03798229247331619,
0.6888293027877808,
-0.7423680424690247,
0.9471365213394165,
1.1394516229629517,
-0.2833479642868042,
0.7585318088531494,
0.5871346592903137,
0.0822749137878418,
0.6090275049209595,
-0.30899327993392944,
-0.6197138428688049,
-0.0674123615026474,
-0.4301205575466156,
-0.3482690453529358,
0.5992864966392517,
0.6542910933494568,
0.25403907895088196,
-0.31882134079933167,
0.5499743223190308,
-0.09203102439641953,
0.12700015306472778,
-0.24996942281723022,
0.9910058975219727,
-0.10516343265771866,
-0.9526234865188599,
0.6831655502319336,
0.37466222047805786,
1.0263091325759888,
-0.820888102054596,
-0.09480606764554977,
-0.5397000312805176,
0.01736171916127205,
-0.27362683415412903,
-0.4730720818042755,
0.5205612778663635,
-0.201975017786026,
-0.5301990509033203,
-0.11557800322771072,
0.6026185154914856,
-0.5944837927818298,
-0.6393073797225952,
0.4774024784564972,
0.7840605974197388,
-0.06866249442100525,
0.13281108438968658,
-0.3642832040786743,
-0.3162585496902466,
-0.020458050072193146,
-0.07800410687923431,
0.400272399187088,
0.7090656757354736,
-0.3382682502269745,
0.36174872517585754,
0.7613450288772583,
0.18023036420345306,
0.004480714909732342,
0.2956450283527374,
0.48181384801864624,
-0.8259928226470947,
-0.6197417974472046,
-0.5221061110496521,
0.25239166617393494,
-0.005265906453132629,
-0.3366086483001709,
0.6693583726882935,
0.32290205359458923,
1.153191328048706,
-0.2675193250179291,
1.3033229112625122,
-0.07089995592832565,
0.43961694836616516,
-0.5925605893135071,
0.36347463726997375,
-0.9248586893081665,
-0.306644469499588,
-0.24355196952819824,
-0.7191231846809387,
-0.10280110687017441,
0.7410897612571716,
0.24695254862308502,
-0.21984398365020752,
1.2063181400299072,
1.093277931213379,
-0.28186166286468506,
0.26367923617362976,
0.7047504782676697,
-0.10605881363153458,
-0.12123585492372513,
0.6029990911483765,
0.8984266519546509,
-0.35342302918434143,
0.21626880764961243,
-0.16893863677978516,
-0.6195757985115051,
0.3173517882823944,
-0.8487092852592468,
-0.518995463848114,
-0.9726207852363586,
-0.30349278450012207,
-0.30562737584114075,
-0.1582334041595459,
0.8817141056060791,
0.7576355934143066,
-1.2204293012619019,
-0.11400233954191208,
-0.1811670958995819,
0.31936606764793396,
-0.8952614665031433,
-0.27298837900161743,
0.005947093944996595,
-0.6911448836326599,
-1.025590181350708,
1.218300700187683,
0.20507541298866272,
-0.0386359877884388,
-0.28587955236434937,
-0.12337223440408707,
-0.19083137810230255,
0.1580629199743271,
0.9120001196861267,
0.5087843537330627,
-0.6820144653320312,
-0.34186801314353943,
0.08569188416004181,
0.10470308363437653,
-0.09847497940063477,
1.0020333528518677,
-0.5572183132171631,
0.23570431768894196,
0.40744778513908386,
0.43997082114219666,
-0.13544157147407532,
-0.4659675657749176,
0.32364925742149353,
-1.089892029762268,
0.9555290341377258,
-0.1706886738538742,
0.8889250159263611,
0.29287010431289673,
-0.24033139646053314,
0.29266583919525146,
0.7841339707374573,
0.25577354431152344,
-0.7467939853668213,
0.6640797853469849,
-0.7765177488327026,
-0.5536654591560364,
1.2840726375579834,
0.13943296670913696,
-0.33245259523391724,
-0.3515878915786743,
-0.11376548558473587,
-0.05965401977300644,
-0.05438585206866264,
0.4960537850856781,
0.7782604098320007,
0.13696859776973724,
-0.11576781421899796,
-0.10320503264665604,
0.3707418739795685,
0.7247481942176819,
-0.5176767110824585,
-0.1315649449825287,
0.287177711725235,
0.2549116015434265,
0.2595410943031311,
0.5096781253814697,
-0.06597522646188736,
0.17904411256313324,
0.02339244820177555,
0.6112294793128967,
0.07331870496273041,
-0.49620139598846436,
-0.24861089885234833,
-0.031234901398420334,
0.3067225515842438,
-0.5178960561752319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11083v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11083v1
|
Prompt Exploration with Prompt Regression
| 2024-05-17T20:30:49 | 2024-05-17T20:30:49 |
Michael Feffer, Ronald Xu, Yuekai Sun, Mikhail Yurochkin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In the advent of democratized usage of large language models (LLMs), there is
a growing desire to systematize LLM prompt creation and selection processes
beyond iterative trial-and-error. Prior works majorly focus on searching the
space of prompts without accounting for relations between prompt variations.
Here we propose a framework, Prompt Exploration with Prompt Regression
(PEPR), to predict the effect of prompt combinations given results for
individual prompt elements as well as a simple method to select an effective
prompt for a given use-case. We evaluate our approach with open-source LLMs of
different sizes on several different tasks.
|
[
-0.27003422379493713,
-0.6809012293815613,
1.0522950887680054,
0.452020525932312,
0.10683736950159073,
-0.07549432665109634,
-0.3986431658267975,
-0.061449628323316574,
0.4419748783111572,
0.2967655658721924,
-0.8114919662475586,
-0.3580684959888458,
-0.4325686991214752,
0.367045134305954,
0.09866722673177719,
0.6783045530319214,
0.028989017009735107,
0.33601701259613037,
-0.2481107860803604,
0.3175365626811981,
-0.7840509414672852,
-0.38279685378074646,
-0.4805501103401184,
-0.3608151376247406,
0.9849648475646973,
0.613050103187561,
0.3878900408744812,
0.350361168384552,
0.48450207710266113,
0.20471873879432678,
-0.35539644956588745,
0.020137153565883636,
-0.3717133700847626,
0.47653084993362427,
-0.050522901117801666,
-0.2787024974822998,
-0.05142424255609512,
0.0098529988899827,
0.6906101703643799,
0.48892882466316223,
0.03180375322699547,
0.0437733419239521,
0.12435320764780045,
0.41206446290016174,
-0.5514552593231201,
0.16503024101257324,
-0.27468302845954895,
-0.12469954788684845,
0.09208044409751892,
-0.22490422427654266,
-0.35751456022262573,
-0.6012701988220215,
0.2760712206363678,
-0.481720894575119,
0.08452483266592026,
0.13258899748325348,
0.13147012889385223,
0.1263362616300583,
-0.11394056677818298,
-0.40983590483665466,
-0.7550882697105408,
0.9005152583122253,
-0.35061514377593994,
0.3703474700450897,
0.3358641564846039,
0.5690048336982727,
-0.5972175002098083,
-0.7275650501251221,
-0.2608662545681,
-0.4219827651977539,
-0.0693884789943695,
-0.08848472684621811,
-0.16802184283733368,
0.07849223166704178,
0.18454261124134064,
-0.01914392039179802,
-0.5019263029098511,
0.1868436634540558,
-0.3164461851119995,
-0.29882943630218506,
0.49751412868499756,
0.34443920850753784,
0.31933048367500305,
-0.29900920391082764,
-0.490449994802475,
0.010167249478399754,
-0.8271012902259827,
0.39119967818260193,
0.2916446328163147,
0.7624370455741882,
0.08475365489721298,
0.8210676908493042,
-0.18787242472171783,
0.757403552532196,
-0.23769895732402802,
-0.29095226526260376,
-0.09757911413908005,
-0.40963014960289,
-0.10654774308204651,
-0.08431944251060486,
0.8203560709953308,
0.18243755400180817,
0.1935608983039856,
-0.11909642815589905,
-0.5096145272254944,
-0.1750572770833969,
-0.20581364631652832,
-0.8587337136268616,
0.009130083955824375,
0.20789264142513275,
-0.43062523007392883,
-0.06982254981994629,
0.14661805331707,
-0.8955826163291931,
-0.7915376424789429,
-0.2894328534603119,
0.27610209584236145,
-0.2933487594127655,
0.13475251197814941,
0.05083639919757843,
-0.3577916622161865,
-0.019149834290146828,
0.5512747764587402,
-0.5681499242782593,
0.10047254711389542,
0.6610698699951172,
0.940373420715332,
-0.10961596667766571,
-0.23397818207740784,
-1.1126421689987183,
-0.3490539491176605,
-0.24962522089481354,
0.8339556455612183,
-0.9296849966049194,
-0.9080497026443481,
0.21492069959640503,
-0.08392759412527084,
0.1616712063550949,
-0.4459265172481537,
0.45453697443008423,
-0.6103864312171936,
0.4703163206577301,
-0.41048434376716614,
-0.5851090550422668,
-0.0029903596732765436,
0.1212218850851059,
-0.6731523871421814,
0.8590685129165649,
0.1889657825231552,
-0.5525150299072266,
0.2611619234085083,
-0.8460584878921509,
-0.07348442077636719,
0.25928905606269836,
-0.42124420404434204,
-0.003303681267425418,
0.13199155032634735,
0.4468814730644226,
0.392612099647522,
-0.4390328526496887,
0.5604207515716553,
-0.15058282017707825,
-0.5566692352294922,
0.44885149598121643,
0.08587470650672913,
0.8398135900497437,
0.21386121213436127,
-0.0485142320394516,
0.43887659907341003,
-0.33901503682136536,
-0.320008248090744,
0.001433627330698073,
-0.39925605058670044,
-0.37725889682769775,
0.008130878210067749,
0.029904693365097046,
-0.10910269618034363,
0.42531493306159973,
-0.5852165222167969,
0.5836556553840637,
-0.07859165966510773,
0.04636615142226219,
0.8138396143913269,
0.15252970159053802,
0.5925061702728271,
-0.43929925560951233,
1.1573470830917358,
-0.34382471442222595,
0.12804117798805237,
-0.7214585542678833,
-0.5810024738311768,
-0.16231633722782135,
-0.6214900016784668,
0.37416785955429077,
0.5049412250518799,
-0.5810933113098145,
0.3843732476234436,
0.020347628742456436,
-0.35826078057289124,
-0.35344254970550537,
-0.004776169545948505,
-0.045161742717027664,
0.35363224148750305,
0.09803032875061035,
0.3810132145881653,
-0.6831845045089722,
-0.7034969925880432,
-0.16970862448215485,
-0.29757022857666016,
-0.3553236424922943,
0.5573709607124329,
0.10408011823892593,
-0.342282235622406,
1.3059202432632446,
-0.5757903456687927,
-0.3512146770954132,
-0.4115709960460663,
0.008226674050092697,
0.48588594794273376,
0.15711461007595062,
0.39979609847068787,
-0.6280428171157837,
-0.4341645836830139,
-0.3317982852458954,
-0.3453880250453949,
-0.5229886770248413,
-0.08463365584611893,
0.23871691524982452,
-0.1597689688205719,
0.7103691697120667,
-0.2606320083141327,
0.1752411127090454,
0.5358410477638245,
-0.4046576917171478,
0.6085848808288574,
-0.031541213393211365,
0.04793532192707062,
-0.9446306824684143,
-0.004602829925715923,
0.33892273902893066,
-0.13536188006401062,
-0.47889065742492676,
-0.03887990862131119,
0.2616455554962158,
-0.25905925035476685,
-0.3714698255062103,
1.103644847869873,
-0.5685575604438782,
0.011942445300519466,
-0.28876638412475586,
0.07698625326156616,
-0.253845751285553,
-0.12886103987693787,
0.006129991728812456,
1.2712076902389526,
0.5885544419288635,
-0.3688654899597168,
0.23230652511119843,
0.24553270637989044,
-0.3554646074771881,
0.0020828719716519117,
-0.737028181552887,
0.041623905301094055,
-0.35455837845802307,
0.26036691665649414,
-1.2530577182769775,
-0.30134543776512146,
0.10902570188045502,
-0.44314149022102356,
-0.08065905421972275,
-0.13717834651470184,
-0.6108766198158264,
-0.32734861969947815,
-0.5618898272514343,
0.1682005673646927,
0.7655565142631531,
-0.7688633799552917,
0.5821876525878906,
0.08288867771625519,
-0.6375525593757629,
-0.5921058654785156,
-0.09514573216438293,
-0.04227929562330246,
-0.47788095474243164,
-0.7073021531105042,
0.11454892158508301,
-0.2845362722873688,
-0.5852475762367249,
-0.2901449501514435,
0.14348392188549042,
0.28638771176338196,
0.149886816740036,
0.24860535562038422,
0.5283414721488953,
-0.1722506880760193,
0.16621433198451996,
-0.1952800303697586,
0.06845302879810333,
0.028608663007616997,
-0.2005394548177719,
0.7671380043029785,
0.10991160571575165,
-0.013372838497161865,
-0.29705217480659485,
0.37639984488487244,
0.2706966996192932,
-0.15552391111850739,
0.43188104033470154,
0.2809441089630127,
-0.23473963141441345,
-0.2541516423225403,
-0.6218605637550354,
-0.37678369879722595,
-0.5610671639442444,
0.011797107756137848,
-0.18946625292301178,
-1.111010193824768,
0.649649977684021,
-0.2779102623462677,
-0.17882733047008514,
0.026507364585995674,
0.3618506193161011,
0.0401637889444828,
0.9283662438392639,
0.9167896509170532,
0.025345366448163986,
0.9305036664009094,
0.09098529815673828,
0.03921119496226311,
-0.882615864276886,
-0.3578665852546692,
-0.6379812359809875,
-0.35657453536987305,
-0.6572645902633667,
-0.5245587825775146,
0.6486397385597229,
0.20592960715293884,
-0.11959294974803925,
0.0074302200227975845,
-0.26904913783073425,
0.6659915447235107,
0.7146859169006348,
-0.024500632658600807,
0.2797088921070099,
-0.05740036070346832,
-0.12572209537029266,
-0.12370267510414124,
-0.687176525592804,
-0.55693519115448,
1.0758107900619507,
0.20733705163002014,
0.9665066003799438,
-0.05379549413919449,
0.8686902523040771,
0.2592255771160126,
0.26515135169029236,
-0.992551863193512,
0.6299647092819214,
0.12386498600244522,
-0.2612040042877197,
-0.4704366624355316,
-0.3460022807121277,
-1.2375520467758179,
0.07325535267591476,
0.008259925991296768,
-1.0571335554122925,
0.3012736439704895,
-0.12494249641895294,
-0.6196355223655701,
-0.015731679275631905,
-0.5199944376945496,
0.45440351963043213,
-0.08495133370161057,
-0.1573229879140854,
0.1959236115217209,
-0.41916516423225403,
0.20228888094425201,
-0.2022956907749176,
0.21920321881771088,
0.009752091951668262,
-0.3447780907154083,
0.6619250178337097,
-0.21413949131965637,
0.8993112444877625,
-0.3168991208076477,
0.03257070481777191,
0.36384984850883484,
0.19494158029556274,
0.7995600700378418,
0.15052878856658936,
-0.2659328877925873,
-0.20845746994018555,
-0.5756049156188965,
-0.10784439742565155,
-0.5714017748832703,
0.716699481010437,
-0.5628834962844849,
-0.8456326723098755,
-0.35635438561439514,
-0.631535530090332,
-0.13239209353923798,
0.09484119713306427,
0.17883414030075073,
0.26542043685913086,
-0.4382963478565216,
-0.06724047660827637,
0.516247570514679,
-0.37744343280792236,
0.7039029002189636,
0.43669408559799194,
-0.7592736482620239,
-0.44375133514404297,
0.4346730411052704,
0.03662259504199028,
-0.12332385033369064,
0.19503331184387207,
0.7732294797897339,
-0.49340733885765076,
-0.4969671368598938,
-0.3077540695667267,
0.3050224483013153,
-0.3889152407646179,
-0.29469478130340576,
-0.6759415864944458,
0.2001093626022339,
-0.5090682506561279,
-0.361968994140625,
0.21305058896541595,
-0.2415139526128769,
-0.6272590160369873,
0.0343501903116703,
0.6088988780975342,
0.8360472321510315,
-0.1379595398902893,
0.6771277189254761,
-0.6989336013793945,
-0.023797236382961273,
0.2059263437986374,
0.2586453855037689,
-0.32106995582580566,
-0.3565705716609955,
0.05927590653300285,
-0.18211133778095245,
-0.09586938470602036,
-1.0185457468032837,
0.5634422898292542,
-0.18480882048606873,
0.6121597290039062,
0.31080588698387146,
0.07649508863687515,
0.19944588840007782,
-0.5975322723388672,
0.9812578558921814,
0.4541023373603821,
-0.6682516932487488,
0.7372081279754639,
-0.6426543593406677,
0.32980892062187195,
0.2907102108001709,
0.6336446404457092,
-0.6393915414810181,
-0.12128526717424393,
-0.4175451397895813,
-0.756130039691925,
0.6168515682220459,
-0.16495679318904877,
-0.005192791577428579,
-0.029827279970049858,
0.14335446059703827,
0.3614449203014374,
0.1348724365234375,
-0.43392741680145264,
0.05403520539402962,
0.3334522545337677,
0.08120894432067871,
-0.3303963840007782,
-0.3757380247116089,
-0.1304713934659958,
-0.031096842139959335,
0.4433501362800598,
-0.20123839378356934,
0.29861342906951904,
0.42040714621543884,
0.1933019757270813,
-0.2636120617389679,
0.409005731344223,
0.2622361183166504,
0.637442409992218,
-0.21995332837104797,
-0.025471912696957588,
-0.23061354458332062,
-0.17265640199184418,
0.17600014805793762,
0.3789793848991394,
-0.3018046021461487,
0.1054348573088646,
0.14445489645004272,
0.6777309775352478,
-0.2402878999710083,
-0.9385002851486206,
0.5697537660598755,
-0.07166838645935059,
0.11156154423952103,
-0.44071710109710693,
0.17671823501586914,
0.06275929510593414,
0.6901059150695801,
0.5142925381660461,
-0.30338603258132935,
0.3226650357246399,
-0.47254249453544617,
0.0622226856648922,
0.43252578377723694,
-0.3963107466697693,
-0.11220002919435501,
0.45322057604789734,
0.18132399022579193,
-0.8835933208465576,
0.6052541136741638,
-0.3208381235599518,
-0.42368197441101074,
0.5626888275146484,
0.6322344541549683,
0.9986026883125305,
-0.4380819499492645,
0.4287666082382202,
0.21684995293617249,
0.22751863300800323,
-0.2307242751121521,
0.5639402866363525,
0.29928627610206604,
-0.5446093678474426,
-0.6825827956199646,
-0.4181104600429535,
-0.4463704526424408,
0.2900083363056183,
-0.2913942337036133,
0.6710611581802368,
-0.2820415198802948,
-0.28234779834747314,
-0.19179099798202515,
-0.09450479596853256,
-0.653293251991272,
-0.23735053837299347,
0.08393848687410355,
1.1724908351898193,
-0.6787106394767761,
0.4773995280265808,
0.9420065879821777,
-0.2745119631290436,
-0.7542343139648438,
0.20533530414104462,
0.11240439862012863,
-0.6845322847366333,
0.7662931680679321,
0.20053544640541077,
0.032567594200372696,
-0.18855448067188263,
-0.6048030853271484,
-0.9425349831581116,
1.0670502185821533,
0.24160365760326385,
-0.7403943538665771,
-0.056768905371427536,
-0.1910456269979477,
0.3379991352558136,
-0.7568215727806091,
0.2600606381893158,
0.46127578616142273,
0.6067194938659668,
0.155333012342453,
-0.8129804730415344,
0.022663703188300133,
0.07922352105379105,
0.1672816276550293,
0.22404535114765167,
-0.4803876280784607,
1.0104453563690186,
-0.5486763119697571,
-0.2311370074748993,
0.3200626075267792,
0.5560010075569153,
0.5829499363899231,
0.42993590235710144,
0.5031734704971313,
-0.27741363644599915,
0.923294723033905,
0.01663549803197384,
1.1752586364746094,
0.009214714169502258,
0.19922983646392822,
1.009830117225647,
-0.3883604109287262,
0.5622482895851135,
0.7344192266464233,
-0.03501910716295242,
0.3047886788845062,
0.8325800895690918,
0.12263962626457214,
0.6027113795280457,
0.4996460974216461,
-0.4186188280582428,
-0.17809122800827026,
-0.38777467608451843,
-0.126997709274292,
0.13146942853927612,
0.3107103407382965,
-0.4402536153793335,
-0.20634911954402924,
0.18338853120803833,
0.05044883117079735,
0.11890065670013428,
-0.36046960949897766,
0.78600013256073,
-0.06428415328264236,
-0.7933170795440674,
0.10287962108850479,
-0.16347235441207886,
0.808857262134552,
-0.505324125289917,
-0.11366292834281921,
-0.37224504351615906,
-0.22716586291790009,
0.1698962301015854,
-0.7329822182655334,
-0.2770836651325226,
0.11258159577846527,
-0.14591512084007263,
-0.3141686022281647,
0.9954902529716492,
-0.2578302025794983,
-0.5298073887825012,
0.45302119851112366,
1.0445871353149414,
0.004813060164451599,
-0.09228034317493439,
-0.17457623779773712,
0.12443933635950089,
0.175213024020195,
-0.5441208481788635,
0.19727332890033722,
0.42080938816070557,
-0.043022990226745605,
0.6126039028167725,
0.5885645151138306,
0.18961668014526367,
-0.14751045405864716,
-0.11042332649230957,
1.0034033060073853,
-0.7653372883796692,
-0.5853164792060852,
-0.897155225276947,
0.4608755111694336,
-0.00845856498926878,
-0.08472825586795807,
0.5026265978813171,
0.5805838108062744,
0.4096124768257141,
-0.03730214759707451,
1.0740009546279907,
0.08950250595808029,
0.614255428314209,
-0.4650689661502838,
0.23355598747730255,
-0.4079737365245819,
0.5110434293746948,
-0.1432187557220459,
-1.191775918006897,
-0.3162764608860016,
0.45776382088661194,
-0.5028896331787109,
-0.06745457649230957,
0.44925302267074585,
0.9571666717529297,
-0.0001952621532836929,
0.20402073860168457,
0.23614028096199036,
-0.08814436942338943,
0.2903840243816376,
0.03675021603703499,
1.3359413146972656,
0.3182790279388428,
0.3015991151332855,
0.04591304063796997,
-0.6147004961967468,
-0.5499630570411682,
-1.0964945554733276,
-0.8197152018547058,
-0.5075527429580688,
0.03300726041197777,
-0.30960986018180847,
0.07957794517278671,
1.3994920253753662,
0.37484243512153625,
-0.40247660875320435,
-0.48849526047706604,
0.10572584718465805,
0.2099888175725937,
-0.06928377598524094,
-0.216615229845047,
0.17621223628520966,
-0.6225766539573669,
-0.8161215782165527,
0.8955950736999512,
-0.1415759176015854,
0.2136698216199875,
-0.42926159501075745,
-0.10589491575956345,
0.108461894094944,
0.27034538984298706,
0.4546770751476288,
0.0810343399643898,
-0.5902400016784668,
-0.2368651181459427,
0.6589349508285522,
0.09490042924880981,
0.06501216441392899,
1.255702257156372,
-1.0429770946502686,
0.4769175946712494,
0.7566983699798584,
0.6311197280883789,
0.25469598174095154,
-0.08546407520771027,
0.8549253344535828,
-0.751000702381134,
-0.0979388952255249,
0.35641923546791077,
0.5863776206970215,
0.37873098254203796,
-0.4667668044567108,
0.6835585236549377,
-0.1638285368680954,
-0.7084939479827881,
-0.7772418260574341,
0.26462751626968384,
-0.8785079717636108,
-0.5151877403259277,
1.697777271270752,
0.023241128772497177,
-0.060738444328308105,
0.22221894562244415,
-0.4933343529701233,
-0.04291008040308952,
-0.9466184377670288,
0.7971349358558655,
0.6991764903068542,
-0.5032268762588501,
-0.027321595698595047,
-0.32023853063583374,
0.3276815116405487,
0.12606404721736908,
-0.5272027254104614,
0.18803688883781433,
0.8677346706390381,
0.14869530498981476,
0.3233359754085541,
0.6798468828201294,
0.14262884855270386,
0.04308013245463371,
-0.3408704102039337,
-0.06769995391368866,
-0.08754096180200577,
-0.5777961611747742,
-0.7260234951972961,
0.17155490815639496,
0.1483430415391922,
0.01168921310454607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11070v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11070v1
|
Jill Watson: A Virtual Teaching Assistant powered by ChatGPT
| 2024-05-17T19:55:57 | 2024-05-17T19:55:57 |
Karan Taneja, Pratyusha Maiti, Sandeep Kakar, Pranav Guruprasad, Sanjeev Rao, Ashok K. Goel
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Conversational AI agents often require extensive datasets for training that
are not publicly released, are limited to social chit-chat or handling a
specific domain, and may not be easily extended to accommodate the latest
advances in AI technologies. This paper introduces Jill Watson, a
conversational Virtual Teaching Assistant (VTA) leveraging the capabilities of
ChatGPT. Jill Watson based on ChatGPT requires no prior training and uses a
modular design to allow the integration of new APIs using a skill-based
architecture inspired by XiaoIce. Jill Watson is also well-suited for
intelligent textbooks as it can process and converse using multiple large
documents. We exclusively utilize publicly available resources for
reproducibility and extensibility. Comparative analysis shows that our system
outperforms the legacy knowledge-based Jill Watson as well as the OpenAI
Assistants service. We employ many safety measures that reduce instances of
hallucinations and toxicity. The paper also includes real-world examples from a
classroom setting that demonstrate different features of Jill Watson and its
effectiveness.
|
[
-0.041124116629362106,
-0.9800447821617126,
0.3615097105503082,
0.1489599198102951,
-0.138860285282135,
0.23028641939163208,
0.06421688199043274,
-0.4002244770526886,
0.2025788128376007,
0.5445553660392761,
-0.08413375914096832,
-0.40361836552619934,
-0.592828631401062,
-0.08733177185058594,
-0.6847220063209534,
0.9106183648109436,
0.48548397421836853,
0.29569393396377563,
-0.42444413900375366,
0.018736835569143295,
-0.8465417623519897,
-0.5009298324584961,
-0.9240968823432922,
-0.19555149972438812,
0.06876228749752045,
0.44919195771217346,
0.9862030148506165,
0.3296293318271637,
0.3368973731994629,
0.37714970111846924,
0.039083752781152725,
0.39896902441978455,
-0.42333903908729553,
-0.12632803618907928,
0.045129936188459396,
-0.5703606605529785,
-0.6264568567276001,
-0.2682400941848755,
0.5375837683677673,
0.441536545753479,
-0.10736123472452164,
-0.29968956112861633,
0.12094015628099442,
0.2452130764722824,
-0.412311315536499,
0.4887293875217438,
-0.4679490029811859,
0.18721520900726318,
0.3429788053035736,
-0.050004445016384125,
-0.6271128058433533,
-0.6045312881469727,
0.6313736438751221,
-1.1470204591751099,
-0.016821444034576416,
-0.3277961015701294,
0.755399763584137,
0.3596503734588623,
-0.38988569378852844,
-0.31653088331222534,
-0.7885158061981201,
0.8189043402671814,
-0.15365737676620483,
0.501918613910675,
0.30501532554626465,
0.5234361886978149,
-0.0173849705606699,
-0.6588148474693298,
-0.6743156313896179,
-0.6435856223106384,
0.12583443522453308,
0.21637022495269775,
-0.03061816468834877,
0.11613322049379349,
-0.02445254474878311,
0.02040775865316391,
-0.4961060881614685,
-0.23459038138389587,
-0.47467708587646484,
0.06041082739830017,
0.17557188868522644,
0.08865746855735779,
0.6156476140022278,
0.1466851681470871,
-0.32515648007392883,
-0.27577394247055054,
-0.4152123034000397,
-0.07585788518190384,
0.19947366416454315,
0.15699057281017303,
-0.3111896216869354,
0.4992920756340027,
-0.014499800279736519,
0.5811363458633423,
-0.45623451471328735,
-0.13114269077777863,
0.005437977146357298,
0.24875907599925995,
-0.18028587102890015,
0.21627800166606903,
0.6357986330986023,
0.12249729782342911,
0.5410692691802979,
-0.34427422285079956,
0.44365692138671875,
-0.00959880743175745,
0.4576597809791565,
-0.7975308299064636,
-0.7577511072158813,
0.15366558730602264,
-0.055827829986810684,
-0.5406245589256287,
-0.07609398663043976,
-0.8802060484886169,
-0.7355762124061584,
-0.5509294867515564,
0.39246779680252075,
-0.7207974791526794,
-0.34923645853996277,
-0.15739451348781586,
-0.2066154181957245,
0.2206069529056549,
0.60951828956604,
-0.9410834312438965,
0.35947704315185547,
0.7703598737716675,
0.9194079041481018,
-0.08854715526103973,
-0.44761088490486145,
-0.6199125647544861,
0.15528719127178192,
-0.5518723130226135,
0.5882901549339294,
-0.88527512550354,
-0.8694291710853577,
0.23457172513008118,
-0.13553474843502045,
0.27283555269241333,
-0.40218600630760193,
0.3322868049144745,
-0.29911574721336365,
0.3711581826210022,
-0.08378534764051437,
-0.21621501445770264,
-0.005620850250124931,
0.5253288149833679,
-0.1335473209619522,
0.8350595235824585,
0.08063456416130066,
-0.33584028482437134,
0.17944550514221191,
-0.6897671222686768,
-0.34344571828842163,
0.17037411034107208,
-0.31847497820854187,
-0.4983219504356384,
-0.5180088877677917,
0.2959550619125366,
0.18712325394153595,
-0.028044814243912697,
0.0019220761023461819,
-0.37662625312805176,
-0.5102156400680542,
0.4099595248699188,
-0.5201964378356934,
1.1664626598358154,
-0.04770054295659065,
-0.03808167949318886,
0.14121495187282562,
-0.8438277840614319,
0.01107077207416296,
0.2193187177181244,
-0.27718764543533325,
-0.44014477729797363,
-0.18601098656654358,
-0.04419570788741112,
-0.3789154887199402,
0.05311792716383934,
-0.3315539062023163,
0.4123985767364502,
-0.23193833231925964,
0.38827770948410034,
0.8100678324699402,
-0.314790815114975,
0.4203604757785797,
-0.42570996284484863,
0.4164874851703644,
-0.1170990988612175,
0.45771291851997375,
-0.23974213004112244,
-0.8571463823318481,
-0.897924542427063,
-0.39264699816703796,
0.14232678711414337,
0.8218516707420349,
-0.8720065355300903,
0.16447031497955322,
-0.44947925209999084,
-0.5889897346496582,
-0.6960744261741638,
-0.04197302088141441,
0.39875173568725586,
0.4469239413738251,
0.48347580432891846,
-0.49375808238983154,
-0.20632000267505646,
-0.31502676010131836,
0.1465955227613449,
-0.37292367219924927,
-0.15584330260753632,
0.33623450994491577,
0.02254420705139637,
-0.11018768697977066,
0.9233375191688538,
-0.4324662983417511,
-0.45389312505722046,
-0.09626888483762741,
-0.03117999993264675,
-0.35623833537101746,
0.5367042422294617,
0.4894506335258484,
-0.6969430446624756,
-0.6049926280975342,
0.2729624807834625,
-1.0360291004180908,
0.1785147488117218,
-0.2389817237854004,
-0.3705819547176361,
0.16515858471393585,
0.16486042737960815,
-0.8901298642158508,
0.30165034532546997,
0.19312995672225952,
-0.12396116554737091,
0.3576047122478485,
-0.4214780926704407,
0.15809254348278046,
-1.2352628707885742,
-0.27038076519966125,
-0.33835625648498535,
-0.1719604730606079,
-0.5446925163269043,
-0.05238912254571915,
-0.19199047982692719,
-0.669869065284729,
-0.34035584330558777,
0.551593005657196,
-0.26455560326576233,
-0.1674678772687912,
-0.3249968886375427,
0.45142075419425964,
-0.08983869105577469,
0.46609094738960266,
0.2886601388454437,
0.7471649050712585,
0.7138015031814575,
-0.48756328225135803,
0.5616254806518555,
0.7990316152572632,
0.17927812039852142,
0.7631787657737732,
-0.7062628865242004,
0.39021602272987366,
0.08263799548149109,
0.13451653718948364,
-0.6674078702926636,
0.03953676298260689,
0.6104977130889893,
-0.6624000072479248,
0.38332459330558777,
-0.3242311477661133,
-0.23516687750816345,
0.002813936909660697,
-0.18584875762462616,
-0.04797511547803879,
0.6968442797660828,
-0.8250914812088013,
0.7201321721076965,
0.43563637137413025,
-0.09806458652019501,
-0.8179075717926025,
-0.41849401593208313,
0.2730351984500885,
-0.01604718714952469,
-0.5141972303390503,
0.024788521230220795,
-0.16213864088058472,
-0.20411445200443268,
0.030642831698060036,
0.4447360038757324,
-0.37207409739494324,
-0.005312174092978239,
0.5225532650947571,
0.46700218319892883,
-0.18901106715202332,
0.35230812430381775,
0.09637623280286789,
-0.28200763463974,
0.10365808010101318,
-0.20328767597675323,
0.37456879019737244,
-0.097052201628685,
-0.47178640961647034,
-0.6515476107597351,
0.2873828709125519,
0.575761616230011,
-0.14743636548519135,
0.7586767077445984,
0.7103081941604614,
-0.16590657830238342,
-0.34833285212516785,
-0.259971559047699,
-0.3084649443626404,
-0.4717649519443512,
0.3613489270210266,
-0.18670442700386047,
-0.3924558460712433,
0.0977596789598465,
0.18626999855041504,
0.2295025885105133,
-0.4206203818321228,
0.468474805355072,
0.2130756378173828,
0.7130922079086304,
0.5851706266403198,
-0.2540592849254608,
0.8919506072998047,
-0.2774806618690491,
0.5180675983428955,
-0.28150033950805664,
-0.26113688945770264,
-0.514333963394165,
0.43080583214759827,
-0.6450190544128418,
-0.38479912281036377,
0.46528559923171997,
-0.6122011542320251,
-0.3982856571674347,
0.11495169997215271,
-0.9250928163528442,
0.6400623917579651,
1.199294924736023,
0.34435489773750305,
0.428941547870636,
-0.06726650893688202,
0.6851978898048401,
0.3178453743457794,
-0.4773794710636139,
-0.6308038234710693,
1.355289340019226,
0.1860015094280243,
0.5171592831611633,
0.4106388986110687,
0.45051881670951843,
0.4757741391658783,
0.3194659948348999,
-0.6679372787475586,
0.8257942795753479,
0.27069559693336487,
-0.6708666086196899,
-0.556408166885376,
-0.13087601959705353,
-0.964606761932373,
0.32704049348831177,
-0.3928687572479248,
-0.6471151113510132,
-0.30609309673309326,
0.13052377104759216,
-0.1842094212770462,
0.17305070161819458,
-1.186257243156433,
0.8575342297554016,
0.09465241432189941,
-0.6681813597679138,
-0.22200371325016022,
-0.49559059739112854,
0.41325879096984863,
0.25498124957084656,
-0.27832382917404175,
0.14689916372299194,
0.16693980991840363,
0.38224053382873535,
-0.4751645624637604,
0.9036833643913269,
-0.11380903422832489,
0.38601407408714294,
0.6757575273513794,
0.10857849568128586,
0.4157544672489166,
0.06568862497806549,
0.2855047583580017,
0.14336365461349487,
0.3940909802913666,
-0.7670584917068481,
-0.5759284496307373,
0.7210042476654053,
-1.2749652862548828,
-0.6282501816749573,
-0.5117738842964172,
-0.35688987374305725,
-0.3835129141807556,
0.08247842639684677,
-0.20460589230060577,
0.2045600414276123,
-0.27497854828834534,
0.13056564331054688,
0.8336934447288513,
-0.4359450042247772,
0.01735880598425865,
0.3827308714389801,
-0.1717512160539627,
-0.11140435934066772,
1.5269784927368164,
0.18290238082408905,
0.06889990717172623,
0.4521600306034088,
0.14180102944374084,
-0.0865321010351181,
-0.35387033224105835,
-0.6030337810516357,
0.04119995981454849,
-0.7662244439125061,
0.17175157368183136,
-0.8738892674446106,
-0.4230687916278839,
-0.8497359156608582,
-0.49020838737487793,
-0.24055343866348267,
-0.2566434442996979,
-0.4191906452178955,
-0.22604335844516754,
0.2363201379776001,
0.683869481086731,
0.16709855198860168,
0.6341677308082581,
-0.7408576011657715,
0.17291632294654846,
1.0107356309890747,
-0.003108077682554722,
-0.09214728325605392,
-0.13861925899982452,
-0.054220810532569885,
-0.15502114593982697,
-0.8180121183395386,
-1.0011935234069824,
0.4319673180580139,
0.023858705535531044,
0.37990903854370117,
0.5189939141273499,
0.11248757690191269,
0.3602182865142822,
0.010601210407912731,
1.0321904420852661,
-0.06537432968616486,
-0.807218611240387,
0.4156949818134308,
-0.5004200339317322,
-0.1894766092300415,
-0.04181002825498581,
0.29048630595207214,
-0.3205687999725342,
-0.4368351101875305,
-0.5806645750999451,
-0.5333049893379211,
0.6448334455490112,
0.301323801279068,
0.5813676714897156,
0.24900373816490173,
-0.06931808590888977,
0.0759178176522255,
0.1532234400510788,
-0.7828804850578308,
0.06102193892002106,
-0.5804217457771301,
-0.3361988365650177,
0.19943632185459137,
-0.2341087907552719,
-0.20406977832317352,
-0.006590777542442083,
1.0678588151931763,
-0.10011346638202667,
0.3667526841163635,
0.030460702255368233,
0.06652688980102539,
0.2996467053890228,
0.02573283389210701,
0.2930721044540405,
0.5938256978988647,
-0.07110463082790375,
-0.14059267938137054,
0.5184800028800964,
-0.7969567775726318,
-0.1815023273229599,
0.2737100422382355,
-0.011927261017262936,
-0.038436900824308395,
0.39335325360298157,
0.473793625831604,
-0.0031151589937508106,
-0.9175671935081482,
0.6438052654266357,
-0.2724674940109253,
0.08891469240188599,
-0.8457756638526917,
0.5335756540298462,
-0.06491164118051529,
0.3460597097873688,
-0.15496200323104858,
-0.38124585151672363,
0.13343676924705505,
-0.3907223641872406,
-0.10158666968345642,
0.3598122000694275,
-0.5255680084228516,
-0.1564205288887024,
0.6702739000320435,
0.46405187249183655,
-0.5254133343696594,
1.0259207487106323,
0.057892970740795135,
-0.04761635884642601,
0.6755767464637756,
0.4331655204296112,
0.708519697189331,
-0.37757784128189087,
0.5951213240623474,
0.12020199745893478,
0.2632477283477783,
0.40007492899894714,
0.12355613708496094,
-0.5273470878601074,
-0.5605837106704712,
0.29015830159187317,
-0.16782400012016296,
-1.1917979717254639,
-0.014873694628477097,
-0.09747269749641418,
0.6127843856811523,
-0.5995710492134094,
0.19246041774749756,
0.07410839945077896,
-0.16510529816150665,
-0.3921163082122803,
0.02891978621482849,
0.0676083117723465,
0.32737475633621216,
-0.7226625084877014,
0.9681181311607361,
0.664555013179779,
-0.5979348421096802,
-0.6028494834899902,
-0.3225367069244385,
-0.010502893477678299,
-1.029160499572754,
0.14178307354450226,
-0.08456049859523773,
0.1303701549768448,
-0.09652084857225418,
-0.3225998878479004,
-0.3590136766433716,
1.1240736246109009,
0.4872279763221741,
-0.051816921681165695,
-0.1856914907693863,
0.5171583294868469,
0.7133545875549316,
0.07237768918275833,
0.8108857870101929,
0.27681657671928406,
0.12202630937099457,
0.13975784182548523,
-0.6482529640197754,
-0.37147730588912964,
-0.19227631390094757,
-0.2047131508588791,
-0.24256204068660736,
-0.8755017518997192,
0.49729716777801514,
-0.19985979795455933,
0.27082377672195435,
0.06043880805373192,
0.7201251983642578,
0.11613182723522186,
0.7527509331703186,
0.24087437987327576,
0.32856476306915283,
0.8598405122756958,
-0.027430295944213867,
0.8290398120880127,
-0.36784639954566956,
-0.025890247896313667,
1.2272562980651855,
0.016314931213855743,
0.5421766042709351,
0.18477654457092285,
-0.4165886342525482,
0.2874647378921509,
0.4731842279434204,
0.2091394066810608,
0.31819280982017517,
-0.1215507909655571,
-0.638912558555603,
-0.2041267603635788,
-0.42331963777542114,
-0.4532790184020996,
0.30993953347206116,
0.298633337020874,
-0.23857058584690094,
0.11883573234081268,
0.1691981852054596,
0.1435222625732422,
-0.007527410052716732,
0.06403355300426483,
0.8256980180740356,
0.1296820193529129,
-0.6134304404258728,
0.1918611377477646,
-0.5369526743888855,
-0.043540146201848984,
-0.5606470108032227,
-0.47865355014801025,
-0.14909867942333221,
0.20650801062583923,
0.06611998379230499,
-0.6170576810836792,
0.042320869863033295,
-0.06618064641952515,
0.40638020634651184,
-0.127452552318573,
0.7341123223304749,
-0.39827656745910645,
-0.1547151356935501,
0.05650084465742111,
0.3046282231807709,
0.430788516998291,
-0.025871209800243378,
-0.4608064591884613,
-0.11563589423894882,
-0.19352394342422485,
-0.002977152122184634,
0.3765639662742615,
0.7412647008895874,
0.12536396086215973,
0.922971785068512,
0.7040379047393799,
-0.29028618335723877,
0.15622109174728394,
-0.22616390883922577,
0.8784966468811035,
-0.2283661812543869,
-0.6570018529891968,
-0.3488427996635437,
0.5845734477043152,
-0.2779087424278259,
-0.5590305328369141,
0.5763719081878662,
0.466158926486969,
0.7572298645973206,
-0.03009282425045967,
0.9961778521537781,
0.2650091052055359,
0.5068771243095398,
-0.272123247385025,
0.6966416835784912,
-0.31577280163764954,
0.1686946302652359,
-0.24244479835033417,
-0.7766163945198059,
0.04375006631016731,
0.555374026298523,
-0.4290601909160614,
0.06490427255630493,
0.3925473392009735,
0.8787025213241577,
-0.1539267599582672,
0.49026158452033997,
0.7178340554237366,
0.1606058031320572,
0.7647099494934082,
0.4070642292499542,
0.9184089303016663,
-0.20886380970478058,
0.9140764474868774,
-0.3561733067035675,
-0.3049221932888031,
-0.40867191553115845,
-0.23612043261528015,
-1.3116793632507324,
-0.8104851245880127,
-0.4266361594200134,
-0.4563933312892914,
0.581728458404541,
0.9481504559516907,
1.0442570447921753,
-0.4848320484161377,
0.0439680851995945,
-0.1784527599811554,
0.4253336787223816,
-0.10027650743722916,
-0.2673426568508148,
0.4093668460845947,
-0.33261555433273315,
-1.294756531715393,
0.2853921353816986,
-0.05932280048727989,
0.29693737626075745,
-0.3805631697177887,
-0.06881502270698547,
0.40201854705810547,
0.2644626498222351,
0.6503154039382935,
0.36283227801322937,
-0.29503005743026733,
-0.39105308055877686,
-0.2524345815181732,
-0.2257746160030365,
0.010017869994044304,
0.30392947793006897,
-0.844505250453949,
0.8240190148353577,
0.31630781292915344,
0.9599543213844299,
0.3636859655380249,
-0.12448584288358688,
0.28753146529197693,
-0.2844026982784271,
0.2847108542919159,
0.317939817905426,
-0.005216654855757952,
0.3288925588130951,
-0.4086637794971466,
0.5419677495956421,
0.3487560451030731,
-0.6141089200973511,
-0.8933163285255432,
-0.22490201890468597,
-1.3675795793533325,
-0.13430124521255493,
0.8657596111297607,
-0.35666874051094055,
-0.25793078541755676,
-0.2666804790496826,
-0.754169762134552,
0.32376429438591003,
-0.624967634677887,
1.3422783613204956,
0.5957117676734924,
0.053865522146224976,
-0.29585713148117065,
-0.6495232582092285,
0.32711315155029297,
0.3758237361907959,
-1.0415512323379517,
-0.16536898910999298,
0.3394260108470917,
0.05203616991639137,
0.18749909102916718,
0.6979018449783325,
0.21959371864795685,
0.29066094756126404,
0.549144446849823,
0.09157563745975494,
-0.32402703166007996,
-0.5133470892906189,
0.0732012540102005,
0.44668465852737427,
0.10695952922105789,
-0.7889741659164429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11055v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11055v2
|
Leveraging Discourse Structure for Extractive Meeting Summarization
| 2024-05-17T19:06:20 | 2024-05-21T14:23:02 |
Virgile Rennard, Guokan Shang, Michalis Vazirgiannis, Julie Hunter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce an extractive summarization system for meetings that leverages
discourse structure to better identify salient information from complex
multi-party discussions. Using discourse graphs to represent semantic relations
between the contents of utterances in a meeting, we train a GNN-based node
classification model to select the most important utterances, which are then
combined to create an extractive summary. Experimental results on AMI and ICSI
demonstrate that our approach surpasses existing text-based and graph-based
extractive summarization systems, as measured by both classification and
summarization metrics. Additionally, we conduct ablation studies on discourse
structure and relation type to provide insights for future NLP applications
leveraging discourse analysis theory.
|
[
-0.3276835083961487,
-0.57755047082901,
0.4460456073284149,
0.09987380355596542,
-0.41224849224090576,
0.3822718560695648,
0.12578651309013367,
-0.7204838395118713,
0.7284939289093018,
0.28703299164772034,
-0.19851458072662354,
-0.46083322167396545,
-0.7045077681541443,
0.04052456468343735,
-0.40566709637641907,
1.1106618642807007,
0.515223503112793,
-0.029928654432296753,
-0.24123892188072205,
-0.09393245726823807,
-0.1825508326292038,
-0.6702836155891418,
-0.6435993909835815,
-0.5334227681159973,
0.6643072962760925,
0.49460577964782715,
0.556963324546814,
0.5375547409057617,
0.5025666356086731,
0.34675657749176025,
-0.5438653826713562,
0.262689471244812,
-0.3416019380092621,
0.17001040279865265,
-0.0442616231739521,
-0.19912023842334747,
-0.6489967703819275,
-0.05699175223708153,
0.7461320161819458,
1.0972189903259277,
-0.20696868002414703,
0.12798938155174255,
0.22115661203861237,
0.45079126954078674,
-0.473916620016098,
0.5701606273651123,
-0.6657171249389648,
0.02092703990638256,
-0.17959915101528168,
-0.3321344554424286,
-0.4217468202114105,
-0.4913729131221771,
0.13891248404979706,
-0.08495472371578217,
-0.07877041399478912,
0.22625182569026947,
1.0484009981155396,
-0.19253821671009064,
-0.5989707112312317,
-0.2315748929977417,
-0.6388375163078308,
0.4688388705253601,
-0.6197837591171265,
0.16894324123859406,
0.043408188968896866,
0.1930490881204605,
0.036126233637332916,
-0.8831893801689148,
-0.10019253939390182,
0.0695289820432663,
-0.4365446865558624,
0.3409108519554138,
-0.11712136119604111,
0.3727853000164032,
0.2728179693222046,
0.6131101250648499,
-0.31020453572273254,
0.1338104009628296,
-0.5238256454467773,
0.05499222129583359,
0.5168467164039612,
0.11890047043561935,
0.42277348041534424,
-0.5558807253837585,
-0.26940006017684937,
0.2693823575973511,
-0.687728226184845,
-0.17372632026672363,
0.09647668153047562,
0.5459729433059692,
-0.08567259460687637,
0.6554277539253235,
-0.10223495215177536,
0.38742348551750183,
-0.1287488341331482,
-0.0608028843998909,
0.19943071901798248,
-0.5867055058479309,
-0.22323858737945557,
0.30957016348838806,
0.8517364859580994,
0.6116679906845093,
0.004375898744910955,
-0.32247790694236755,
0.1239599958062172,
-0.2940313518047333,
0.02591582015156746,
-0.9397640228271484,
-0.3975472152233124,
0.14502935111522675,
-0.7057234644889832,
-0.36771416664123535,
0.1565839797258377,
-0.9738538265228271,
-0.061787672340869904,
-0.38622215390205383,
-0.3113168776035309,
-0.3268847167491913,
-0.3664923310279846,
-0.45205017924308777,
-0.6753074526786804,
0.3249877691268921,
0.3709457814693451,
-0.8885772824287415,
0.6380283236503601,
0.7613588571548462,
1.238340139389038,
-0.3836904764175415,
0.027751006186008453,
-0.5242891907691956,
0.44151774048805237,
-0.1082267016172409,
0.992328405380249,
-0.4317023456096649,
-0.5401250123977661,
-0.06210407242178917,
-0.06922005861997604,
0.03904065117239952,
-0.4476581811904907,
0.5094069838523865,
-0.4048517644405365,
0.3530271351337433,
-0.30228403210639954,
-0.6477102041244507,
-0.0627182349562645,
0.3193841874599457,
-0.6948693990707397,
0.7984908819198608,
0.024659166112542152,
-0.9455863833427429,
0.3215576112270355,
-0.9119735956192017,
-0.4326961934566498,
0.23067089915275574,
-0.32572653889656067,
-0.4883020520210266,
0.22261598706245422,
0.22831383347511292,
0.28226637840270996,
0.04828615114092827,
0.21714462339878082,
-0.11131442338228226,
-0.11648041754961014,
0.2790743112564087,
0.04055456072092056,
0.9466597437858582,
0.15115241706371307,
0.10084456950426102,
0.44577643275260925,
-0.790299654006958,
0.02304767817258835,
-0.04618415609002113,
-0.28274938464164734,
-0.631604015827179,
0.26760780811309814,
-0.1397067755460739,
0.2659090757369995,
0.06530354171991348,
-0.5095862746238708,
-0.00901744980365038,
-0.8734267950057983,
0.36736106872558594,
0.5651679635047913,
0.5697896480560303,
0.4754129946231842,
-0.08520213514566422,
0.34890609979629517,
-0.12856042385101318,
-0.1577800065279007,
-0.5090842843055725,
-0.48552605509757996,
-0.6148110032081604,
-0.39840948581695557,
0.33336448669433594,
0.5032519698143005,
-0.6029667854309082,
0.46185532212257385,
-0.4331890940666199,
-0.40461596846580505,
-0.2915685474872589,
-0.5149725079536438,
0.5903297662734985,
0.6028841733932495,
0.1334144026041031,
-0.39570772647857666,
-0.6201705932617188,
-0.8353503942489624,
-0.22681885957717896,
-0.507902204990387,
-0.13674518465995789,
0.2263830602169037,
0.36329737305641174,
0.6451123952865601,
0.870614230632782,
-0.761120080947876,
-0.014304989948868752,
-0.5464189648628235,
0.45308437943458557,
0.09669214487075806,
0.18663734197616577,
0.45121902227401733,
-0.7526008486747742,
-0.40413182973861694,
0.22606539726257324,
-0.6850115656852722,
-0.10661336779594421,
0.10338276624679565,
-0.0208584014326334,
-0.054697372019290924,
0.6256871819496155,
-0.43321311473846436,
0.33704376220703125,
0.13733182847499847,
-0.28733178973197937,
0.6683930158615112,
0.20881783962249756,
0.12700502574443817,
-1.362182378768921,
0.21833346784114838,
-0.3493838906288147,
-0.619995653629303,
-0.61219722032547,
-0.0643099769949913,
-0.34442800283432007,
-0.2652645707130432,
-0.37479302287101746,
0.20503562688827515,
-0.6325165033340454,
-0.6433647871017456,
-0.33164313435554504,
0.29645389318466187,
0.16569869220256805,
0.7078424096107483,
-0.006599488668143749,
0.637201726436615,
0.14984415471553802,
-0.5444291830062866,
0.026966659352183342,
0.6100335717201233,
-0.220015749335289,
0.5838449001312256,
-0.827960729598999,
0.09879346191883087,
-0.09764272719621658,
0.10406430810689926,
-1.0361469984054565,
-0.4054212272167206,
0.3537925183773041,
-0.4463699758052826,
0.27151015400886536,
-0.27145180106163025,
-0.24932417273521423,
-0.2001112550497055,
-0.35542672872543335,
0.07606658339500427,
0.07800688594579697,
-0.19084665179252625,
0.6163690686225891,
1.0128998756408691,
-0.7503148317337036,
-0.48835235834121704,
-0.46886780858039856,
0.40999481081962585,
-0.2902328670024872,
-0.1893344670534134,
0.5014414191246033,
0.20412349700927734,
-0.49118149280548096,
0.10694020241498947,
0.08079221844673157,
-0.23950067162513733,
0.18253149092197418,
0.5393484234809875,
0.2921482026576996,
-0.017646819353103638,
0.14252883195877075,
0.2052866667509079,
-0.1696280688047409,
0.2729659378528595,
-0.1729339212179184,
0.6131294965744019,
-0.2521073520183563,
-0.2514575123786926,
-0.6680680513381958,
1.0080609321594238,
0.4995560944080353,
-0.28182393312454224,
0.5978061556816101,
0.18966901302337646,
-0.36955946683883667,
0.31379014253616333,
-0.13939236104488373,
-0.08178368210792542,
-0.3798672556877136,
0.6152587532997131,
-0.25966086983680725,
-0.9391589164733887,
0.7028888463973999,
-0.48038536310195923,
0.4579051434993744,
0.5270609259605408,
0.48656535148620605,
-0.11292332410812378,
1.1335296630859375,
0.7010605335235596,
-0.19952042400836945,
0.6391389966011047,
0.08195959776639938,
0.08601512014865875,
-0.8267597556114197,
-0.43426206707954407,
-0.8636118173599243,
-0.38954371213912964,
-0.27393701672554016,
0.09973770380020142,
0.31197768449783325,
-0.12152275443077087,
0.189373180270195,
0.2964267134666443,
-0.6333178281784058,
0.7322839498519897,
0.3565075695514679,
-0.2553311288356781,
0.5274350047111511,
0.09643333405256271,
0.06529568135738373,
-0.20310066640377045,
-0.4567047357559204,
-0.5373601913452148,
0.41464751958847046,
0.0447387769818306,
0.1363305300474167,
0.12838959693908691,
0.6551730632781982,
0.015633514150977135,
0.4142734408378601,
-0.8887378573417664,
0.7137067317962646,
0.04382152110338211,
-0.2833133041858673,
-0.3269660472869873,
-0.7834884524345398,
-1.0549259185791016,
0.6385781764984131,
-0.13431517779827118,
-0.9870274066925049,
0.25834596157073975,
-0.14902375638484955,
-0.10481784492731094,
0.25690123438835144,
-0.6911048889160156,
0.5785602927207947,
0.07992065697908401,
0.37725645303726196,
-0.023586926981806755,
-0.8494148850440979,
0.472053587436676,
0.46852782368659973,
0.2842543423175812,
-0.2514732778072357,
0.11176059395074844,
0.8675880432128906,
-0.25310930609703064,
0.7769218683242798,
-0.07357703149318695,
0.1782124936580658,
0.27775898575782776,
-0.07364653795957565,
0.07293972373008728,
0.04615383222699165,
-0.15331605076789856,
0.22911006212234497,
-0.2745990753173828,
-0.05158668011426926,
-0.6861629486083984,
0.27741119265556335,
-0.6637722849845886,
-0.28612181544303894,
-0.34438103437423706,
-0.3425164520740509,
0.03259812667965889,
0.3067571222782135,
0.27660614252090454,
0.7167454361915588,
-0.5882130265235901,
-0.005057245492935181,
0.21037358045578003,
0.31002217531204224,
0.683363139629364,
0.045047275722026825,
-0.36410659551620483,
-0.7020391821861267,
0.8684183955192566,
0.17662166059017181,
0.36666592955589294,
0.44358184933662415,
0.2128807157278061,
-0.0669696107506752,
-0.7602344155311584,
-0.04895886033773422,
0.19600369036197662,
-0.6051324605941772,
-0.3282070755958557,
-0.9410945773124695,
-0.5742068290710449,
-0.39623820781707764,
-0.04462392255663872,
-0.2982209324836731,
-0.966762363910675,
-0.2782548666000366,
-0.4536322355270386,
-0.19919636845588684,
0.5842601656913757,
0.15042874217033386,
0.5144878625869751,
-0.8008244633674622,
0.06532782316207886,
0.19426041841506958,
-0.07814701646566391,
-0.07555423676967621,
-0.08102840185165405,
-0.10037346184253693,
-0.30078932642936707,
-0.6046273708343506,
-1.2312531471252441,
0.56095951795578,
0.5184401869773865,
0.420736700296402,
0.5211837887763977,
-0.06844478845596313,
0.7485820055007935,
-0.4633273482322693,
0.9040440917015076,
0.5721713304519653,
-0.8576353192329407,
0.8977919816970825,
-0.2933574914932251,
0.3588588833808899,
0.6081787943840027,
0.2953313887119293,
-0.5249281525611877,
-0.7540907263755798,
-0.7905084490776062,
-1.162536859512329,
0.7606584429740906,
0.3395368456840515,
-0.20113492012023926,
-0.07718002796173096,
0.519952654838562,
-0.0281200110912323,
0.4047461450099945,
-0.7424015998840332,
-0.2037738710641861,
0.07765475660562515,
0.040237389504909515,
0.26418977975845337,
-0.47950196266174316,
-0.5000072121620178,
-0.03753572702407837,
0.44298484921455383,
-0.18884015083312988,
0.2969830632209778,
0.09535925835371017,
0.13801325857639313,
0.14674846827983856,
0.3847234547138214,
0.3240704834461212,
0.7873899340629578,
-0.0753156915307045,
0.48077887296676636,
0.2527577877044678,
-0.28868481516838074,
-0.24505573511123657,
0.04261685162782669,
-0.1333625614643097,
0.23342764377593994,
0.49585792422294617,
0.6196548342704773,
0.3524881601333618,
-0.18674392998218536,
0.5390706658363342,
-0.44611573219299316,
-0.2861100733280182,
-0.02402731031179428,
0.03195521607995033,
0.14814966917037964,
0.1634330302476883,
0.17546992003917694,
0.06975744664669037,
0.6671819090843201,
-0.6513671278953552,
0.3973099887371063,
0.45171356201171875,
-0.7089139819145203,
-0.5633429288864136,
0.394922137260437,
0.281461626291275,
-0.5175775289535522,
0.5423985719680786,
-0.27020132541656494,
-0.42428573966026306,
0.4636005461215973,
0.4917561113834381,
0.9150199294090271,
-0.31467360258102417,
0.35541626811027527,
0.4275025725364685,
0.09526172280311584,
0.5582939982414246,
0.2670169174671173,
-0.14918415248394012,
-0.2864486277103424,
-0.7597189545631409,
-0.4652343690395355,
-0.8458758592605591,
-0.13227981328964233,
-0.6266583204269409,
0.2424025535583496,
-0.18951556086540222,
-0.0876896008849144,
0.3619539439678192,
0.017410224303603172,
0.20311813056468964,
-0.33514222502708435,
0.009787887334823608,
0.31404075026512146,
-0.661085307598114,
0.2901223301887512,
0.3709466755390167,
-0.2215084582567215,
-0.6462545394897461,
-0.39115431904792786,
-0.050054989755153656,
-0.17336398363113403,
0.141123965382576,
0.14816001057624817,
-0.13670815527439117,
-0.22097867727279663,
-0.6830495595932007,
-0.7621534466743469,
1.01642906665802,
0.5613968968391418,
-0.19148728251457214,
-0.3567284643650055,
-0.04448337480425835,
0.3156905174255371,
-0.5475524663925171,
0.30862465500831604,
0.30558207631111145,
0.13470272719860077,
0.6564964056015015,
-0.8305978178977966,
-0.08486458659172058,
-0.2941732704639435,
-0.27064332365989685,
0.43325984477996826,
-0.3874911069869995,
0.753351628780365,
0.09012065827846527,
-0.652119517326355,
-0.30981677770614624,
1.0947682857513428,
0.05903523415327072,
0.3846425712108612,
0.5076451301574707,
0.13593314588069916,
1.1116646528244019,
-0.15242230892181396,
0.7591632604598999,
-0.16966664791107178,
0.05302605777978897,
1.526692509651184,
-0.23290731012821198,
0.676488995552063,
0.33657076954841614,
0.10945449769496918,
0.6478047370910645,
0.49787193536758423,
0.30607888102531433,
0.3523397743701935,
0.04859429970383644,
-0.14591264724731445,
0.061424314975738525,
-0.5292493104934692,
-0.3663720488548279,
0.7467407584190369,
0.6374171376228333,
-0.230227530002594,
-0.45687633752822876,
-0.29674193263053894,
0.31631526350975037,
-0.0724436342716217,
-0.363267719745636,
1.3838317394256592,
0.390554279088974,
-0.7243925929069519,
-0.015278632752597332,
-0.08616676926612854,
-0.07669369131326675,
-0.5613794922828674,
-0.13817699253559113,
0.2430863082408905,
-0.11058588325977325,
-0.2682524621486664,
-0.6675277948379517,
0.8835901021957397,
-0.14209894835948944,
0.01162212248891592,
-0.2819749116897583,
1.0974115133285522,
-0.5566574931144714,
-0.2740577757358551,
0.1400139182806015,
0.6618323922157288,
0.26410025358200073,
-0.06741016358137131,
-0.29932159185409546,
-0.15950597822666168,
-0.2709121108055115,
-0.06323710829019547,
0.36481398344039917,
0.5586304068565369,
0.15179169178009033,
0.18658943474292755,
0.5296048521995544,
0.19305291771888733,
-0.3357956111431122,
0.2620928883552551,
1.2477314472198486,
-0.6140543222427368,
-0.9608222246170044,
-1.095373272895813,
0.5096473693847656,
-0.9276530146598816,
-0.36026933789253235,
0.6522406339645386,
0.7840240597724915,
0.021764840930700302,
0.4621792435646057,
0.5182748436927795,
-0.008420259691774845,
0.4649961292743683,
-0.4189938008785248,
0.5657140016555786,
-0.195230171084404,
-0.03274727612733841,
-0.5120298266410828,
-0.8704103827476501,
-0.5110625624656677,
0.334245502948761,
-0.020125770941376686,
-0.4559880495071411,
0.7473862767219543,
0.25828638672828674,
0.18607346713542938,
0.4562728703022003,
0.0005194292170926929,
0.09089105576276779,
0.6382584571838379,
0.29738590121269226,
0.8731799125671387,
-0.048170022666454315,
0.6364662647247314,
0.18071043491363525,
-0.4813503623008728,
-0.12677091360092163,
-0.8643770813941956,
-0.8494181036949158,
-0.7065708041191101,
-0.6114287972450256,
-0.1986784189939499,
0.0597149021923542,
0.6775122880935669,
0.7135475277900696,
-0.5822933912277222,
-0.3902096748352051,
-0.044314492493867874,
0.5001623630523682,
-0.2723028063774109,
-0.27510184049606323,
0.6175642013549805,
-0.438620924949646,
-0.7860495448112488,
0.4129001200199127,
0.7820326685905457,
0.032707564532756805,
0.09749715030193329,
0.45491936802864075,
-0.44750282168388367,
-0.04208426550030708,
0.7682804465293884,
0.30689579248428345,
-0.17885459959506989,
-0.4250587522983551,
-0.14231672883033752,
-0.028188416734337807,
0.340350478887558,
0.8779438734054565,
-0.3602476716041565,
0.09574814140796661,
0.5044986009597778,
0.2966160476207733,
0.6409182548522949,
0.2185124158859253,
0.5700669288635254,
-1.1883994340896606,
0.024433208629488945,
0.4054643511772156,
0.2673147916793823,
0.1931600570678711,
-0.2792581617832184,
0.5355986952781677,
-0.02773718349635601,
-0.6837044954299927,
-0.7561255097389221,
0.4244200587272644,
-1.1591367721557617,
-0.2307465374469757,
0.8229561448097229,
-0.2159474641084671,
-0.4210844933986664,
-0.5592371225357056,
-0.3306914269924164,
0.36046329140663147,
-0.4658701717853546,
0.6944215297698975,
0.6783956289291382,
-0.4105237126350403,
-0.0691785216331482,
-0.07361631840467453,
0.5601686239242554,
-0.08619081974029541,
-1.2551497220993042,
0.22493940591812134,
0.49366623163223267,
-0.35661178827285767,
0.6238799095153809,
1.1099177598953247,
-0.4348447322845459,
-0.09356922656297684,
-0.18796415627002716,
-0.1165735274553299,
0.06325332075357437,
-0.5598320364952087,
-0.06216375529766083,
0.99200838804245,
-0.21326616406440735,
-0.20647118985652924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11040v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11040v1
|
From Generalist to Specialist: Improving Large Language Models for Medical Physics Using ARCoT
| 2024-05-17T18:31:38 | 2024-05-17T18:31:38 |
Jace Grandinetti, Rafe McBeth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, physics.med-ph
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable progress, yet their
application in specialized fields, such as medical physics, remains challenging
due to the need for domain-specific knowledge. This study introduces ARCoT
(Adaptable Retrieval-based Chain of Thought), a framework designed to enhance
the domain-specific accuracy of LLMs without requiring fine-tuning or extensive
retraining. ARCoT integrates a retrieval mechanism to access relevant
domain-specific information and employs step-back and chain-of-thought
prompting techniques to guide the LLM's reasoning process, ensuring more
accurate and context-aware responses. Benchmarking on a medical physics
multiple-choice exam, our model outperformed standard LLMs and reported average
human performance, demonstrating improvements of up to 68% and achieving a high
score of 90%. This method reduces hallucinations and increases domain-specific
performance. The versatility and model-agnostic nature of ARCoT make it easily
adaptable to various domains, showcasing its significant potential for
enhancing the accuracy and reliability of LLMs in specialized fields.
|
[
-0.13548725843429565,
-0.8132528066635132,
0.7479683756828308,
-0.20120516419410706,
-0.16427172720432281,
0.3730773627758026,
-0.33111366629600525,
-0.5986096858978271,
0.45444387197494507,
0.7099143266677856,
-0.2590670585632324,
-0.5343495607376099,
-0.5833700895309448,
0.1323738694190979,
-0.6824982762336731,
0.6511164903640747,
-0.18037095665931702,
0.0767083615064621,
-0.05339805409312248,
-0.06189246475696564,
-0.2908616364002228,
-0.6377198100090027,
-0.5617662668228149,
-0.751092255115509,
0.36474156379699707,
0.09693226963281631,
0.6384375095367432,
0.2985544502735138,
1.0875853300094604,
0.1821942925453186,
-0.1710416078567505,
0.08066095411777496,
-0.24576453864574432,
0.2183745950460434,
-0.7623637914657593,
-0.39147815108299255,
-0.9384800791740417,
-0.3915412724018097,
0.5787036418914795,
1.0370001792907715,
-0.649527907371521,
-0.1917165070772171,
-0.324386864900589,
0.8210765719413757,
-0.3718425929546356,
-0.1020694449543953,
-0.707714319229126,
0.04094672575592995,
0.0318865068256855,
-0.365373820066452,
-0.5141322016716003,
-0.07474971562623978,
0.49950969219207764,
-0.6666823029518127,
0.2332805097103119,
0.3732992708683014,
0.47258397936820984,
0.11808022111654282,
-0.3520410656929016,
-0.2782154381275177,
-0.7777684330940247,
0.6252080202102661,
-0.561310887336731,
0.5738998651504517,
0.2201640009880066,
0.2151528000831604,
-0.2799571454524994,
-0.9481909871101379,
-0.20196682214736938,
-0.18236523866653442,
0.2498425543308258,
-0.016633953899145126,
-0.26739439368247986,
0.39365220069885254,
0.08429402858018875,
0.3054819703102112,
-0.6371898651123047,
0.13512744009494781,
-0.21835845708847046,
0.010287401266396046,
0.5173606276512146,
0.23204071819782257,
0.3467845022678375,
0.17858241498470306,
0.09480205178260803,
-0.020751839503645897,
-0.8654604554176331,
-0.34519508481025696,
-0.21986427903175354,
0.06984454393386841,
0.23970501124858856,
0.8130422830581665,
-0.4569735527038574,
0.6956486701965332,
0.20334544777870178,
-0.003039549570530653,
0.25820982456207275,
0.0016781010199338198,
-0.28816670179367065,
-0.051172249019145966,
0.498478502035141,
0.09456151723861694,
0.33275312185287476,
-0.11309465765953064,
0.04614861682057381,
-0.19944195449352264,
0.4581761360168457,
-0.7160652875900269,
-0.35526448488235474,
0.34988468885421753,
-0.18795359134674072,
-0.12924878299236298,
-0.19182616472244263,
-0.58073490858078,
-0.461498498916626,
-0.23816141486167908,
0.09535270184278488,
-0.6318838000297546,
-0.39690738916397095,
0.6363662481307983,
0.20996713638305664,
-0.014668646268546581,
0.6350260972976685,
-0.9180007576942444,
0.42226162552833557,
0.6907540559768677,
0.8745417594909668,
-0.3474193811416626,
-0.31522244215011597,
-0.09655115008354187,
0.3227720260620117,
-0.46940064430236816,
1.1290926933288574,
-0.8308283090591431,
-0.41199812293052673,
-0.34297695755958557,
-0.2972469925880432,
-0.009586899541318417,
-0.7175312638282776,
0.35218390822410583,
-0.41032838821411133,
-0.016188565641641617,
0.1134786307811737,
-0.6818682551383972,
-0.2830035984516144,
0.16543953120708466,
-0.48803815245628357,
0.7673311233520508,
0.029735442250967026,
-0.6265571117401123,
0.037428002804517746,
-0.8400877118110657,
-0.6668769717216492,
0.10983666032552719,
-0.19063618779182434,
-0.22185640037059784,
0.43656888604164124,
0.29904603958129883,
0.423237144947052,
-0.5565693378448486,
0.45567578077316284,
-0.09756024926900864,
-0.2082764059305191,
0.16833652555942535,
-0.11348491162061691,
0.28762227296829224,
-0.10089655965566635,
-0.007262337952852249,
-0.00852370448410511,
-0.7370069026947021,
0.15516166388988495,
0.05433594435453415,
-0.05030038580298424,
-0.4776500165462494,
0.30826035141944885,
-0.3720219135284424,
0.05251171812415123,
-0.10903717577457428,
-0.3183186650276184,
0.3674088418483734,
-0.8567413687705994,
0.45738670229911804,
0.616815984249115,
0.13885115087032318,
0.32572120428085327,
-0.28881606459617615,
0.4617355763912201,
-0.12571294605731964,
-0.16748443245887756,
0.12514428794384003,
-0.6768287420272827,
-0.45337560772895813,
-0.23204770684242249,
0.05062443017959595,
0.42073187232017517,
-0.7709485292434692,
0.4778028726577759,
-0.2795068025588989,
-0.6645743250846863,
-0.5510420799255371,
0.0004649366019293666,
0.12409887462854385,
0.7332221865653992,
0.5317617058753967,
-0.5253177881240845,
-0.4702416956424713,
-0.6059854626655579,
-0.4399821162223816,
-0.34295526146888733,
-0.08660192787647247,
0.3289608955383301,
0.6829242706298828,
-0.512758731842041,
0.84516441822052,
-0.7552879452705383,
0.02558829076588154,
-0.20084626972675323,
-0.07595743983983994,
0.44635796546936035,
0.38204798102378845,
0.11525896191596985,
-0.4604741930961609,
-0.2786007523536682,
0.602203905582428,
-0.8655087351799011,
-0.01382878702133894,
0.17513884603977203,
-0.19113655388355255,
-0.2639418840408325,
0.16338671743869781,
-0.6581348776817322,
0.26662421226501465,
0.5606749057769775,
-0.4159764051437378,
0.8835307955741882,
-0.2815588712692261,
0.304599791765213,
-0.7989607453346252,
0.23191966116428375,
-0.10806062817573547,
-0.22926394641399384,
-0.8814030289649963,
0.2581515908241272,
-0.04087042063474655,
-0.0698988065123558,
-0.5909803509712219,
0.8616968989372253,
-0.29733461141586304,
0.0511477068066597,
-0.502067506313324,
0.1782749742269516,
0.13820181787014008,
0.03873657435178757,
0.382427841424942,
0.6667348742485046,
1.0290535688400269,
-0.6686885952949524,
0.4216073751449585,
0.15225353837013245,
-0.30053168535232544,
0.8201648592948914,
-0.7357682585716248,
0.2763630747795105,
0.009335790760815144,
0.3432382643222809,
-0.49065232276916504,
-0.3998561501502991,
-0.039960794150829315,
-0.15992030501365662,
0.18015499413013458,
0.2382165938615799,
-0.5761595368385315,
-0.6167552471160889,
0.03436507657170296,
0.4742705225944519,
0.5388291478157043,
-0.48832157254219055,
0.8739365935325623,
0.37621667981147766,
-0.3526226878166199,
-0.5236271023750305,
-0.6031948924064636,
0.07355878502130508,
0.04811691865324974,
-0.49821561574935913,
0.24462735652923584,
-0.12510377168655396,
-0.2819880545139313,
-0.2884717583656311,
-0.29088208079338074,
-0.2579377591609955,
0.022147754207253456,
-0.12236898392438889,
0.27603980898857117,
-0.1422378569841385,
0.5156950950622559,
0.4007951021194458,
-0.1182970479130745,
0.027534978464245796,
-0.35994473099708557,
0.6659069657325745,
-0.20290398597717285,
-0.6957217454910278,
-0.4549221992492676,
0.34247490763664246,
0.45204657316207886,
-0.10124107450246811,
0.3550695776939392,
0.009849625639617443,
-0.5211300253868103,
-0.2806650996208191,
-0.6263605356216431,
-0.46768730878829956,
-0.46710002422332764,
0.8388972878456116,
-0.35647648572921753,
-1.0285639762878418,
0.389764666557312,
-0.5204314589500427,
-0.07831908762454987,
0.43430641293525696,
0.7232589721679688,
-0.2101028859615326,
1.0522493124008179,
0.4858669340610504,
0.12443020194768906,
0.18566924333572388,
-0.027389224618673325,
0.23928628861904144,
-1.1581183671951294,
-0.11062324792146683,
-0.36602503061294556,
-0.08189106732606888,
0.010146616026759148,
-0.6078169345855713,
0.3426925837993622,
0.031219296157360077,
-0.32687076926231384,
0.11316397786140442,
-0.9361307621002197,
0.6572050452232361,
0.040065739303827286,
0.2996928095817566,
0.7029224634170532,
0.04966089501976967,
-0.10539290308952332,
0.10815086215734482,
-0.610933244228363,
-0.3121936619281769,
1.3300411701202393,
0.3207705616950989,
1.2325595617294312,
-0.003070597071200609,
0.47488006949424744,
0.012689403258264065,
0.3818425238132477,
-0.7441224455833435,
0.6041730046272278,
-0.10122717916965485,
-0.7019091844558716,
-0.19837002456188202,
-0.36445608735084534,
-0.8659366965293884,
0.46997731924057007,
0.05440506339073181,
-0.9332323670387268,
-0.12206822633743286,
0.07838243246078491,
-0.2422657012939453,
0.5864747166633606,
-0.5719487071037292,
0.2278854101896286,
-0.34544914960861206,
-0.004841271322220564,
-0.5489940643310547,
-0.3645284175872803,
0.3507150411605835,
-0.4771021604537964,
0.17644916474819183,
-0.27958908677101135,
-0.18233874440193176,
0.6735739707946777,
-0.22145405411720276,
0.8968166708946228,
0.3383965790271759,
-0.020794091746211052,
0.30226919054985046,
0.21080361306667328,
0.4337082803249359,
-0.03487073630094528,
-0.29111623764038086,
0.3355119526386261,
-0.15315772593021393,
-0.2589327096939087,
-0.6576729416847229,
0.7761045098304749,
-0.7537002563476562,
-0.82371586561203,
-0.5169732570648193,
-0.9069195985794067,
-0.4447213411331177,
0.34296321868896484,
0.059368181973695755,
0.24451614916324615,
-0.25589096546173096,
0.06959348171949387,
0.8578304648399353,
-0.3042018413543701,
0.06595218926668167,
0.5551268458366394,
-0.4709911048412323,
-0.26014870405197144,
0.5701640844345093,
-0.061357419937849045,
0.44716158509254456,
0.5369908809661865,
0.36679306626319885,
-0.31346622109413147,
-0.6022565960884094,
-0.1252102553844452,
0.6508539915084839,
-0.8723229169845581,
-0.17696751654148102,
-0.7037146091461182,
-0.32524582743644714,
-0.2886105179786682,
-0.49720826745033264,
-0.5566343665122986,
-0.4535793364048004,
-0.22587884962558746,
-0.2537012994289398,
0.5355109572410583,
0.7528561949729919,
0.23233124613761902,
0.1695098876953125,
-0.4091652035713196,
0.2510095536708832,
0.1865154355764389,
0.6439006328582764,
0.12200811505317688,
-0.6429638862609863,
-0.2327067106962204,
-0.1662394404411316,
-0.30305999517440796,
-0.5855712890625,
0.2685481309890747,
0.25137731432914734,
0.5210050344467163,
0.04493188485503197,
-0.15011730790138245,
0.7007554769515991,
-0.7738201022148132,
0.5692529082298279,
0.5921120643615723,
-1.0832364559173584,
0.9068652391433716,
-0.08064912259578705,
0.4039376676082611,
0.31441038846969604,
0.1479497104883194,
-0.3881235420703888,
-0.6305282711982727,
-0.603073000907898,
-0.7483384013175964,
0.22483520209789276,
0.004991383757442236,
0.06362107396125793,
0.01735098287463188,
0.7309550046920776,
0.1901591569185257,
0.20913395285606384,
-0.5501917004585266,
-0.08688554912805557,
0.0878390297293663,
-0.24011115729808807,
0.17973102629184723,
0.22636963427066803,
-0.24824336171150208,
-0.5214905738830566,
0.5966789126396179,
-0.3051132261753082,
0.4352518618106842,
0.4759940207004547,
-0.12475138157606125,
-0.211935892701149,
0.3464278280735016,
0.5176147818565369,
1.1215736865997314,
-0.1463451236486435,
0.2145526260137558,
0.433932900428772,
-0.8948903679847717,
0.3336549997329712,
-0.12846091389656067,
0.1465451717376709,
-0.033110931515693665,
0.4329115152359009,
0.4261069893836975,
0.1352798342704773,
-1.0709656476974487,
0.2650781571865082,
0.15717920660972595,
-0.22581960260868073,
0.09698943048715591,
0.22537189722061157,
0.14436809718608856,
0.23751994967460632,
0.4202905297279358,
0.18714700639247894,
0.18281568586826324,
-0.31099027395248413,
0.4373381733894348,
0.18871155381202698,
-0.2666456997394562,
-0.42050406336784363,
0.7332265377044678,
0.21679121255874634,
-0.40555909276008606,
0.2648348808288574,
0.32021793723106384,
-0.15980938076972961,
0.41385161876678467,
0.7143723964691162,
0.805182933807373,
-0.5689539909362793,
0.06377872079610825,
0.24790073931217194,
0.1795479655265808,
-0.5444404482841492,
0.17298556864261627,
0.522886335849762,
-0.6289771199226379,
-0.717166006565094,
-0.2670307457447052,
-0.8669944405555725,
-0.43379074335098267,
-0.7058744430541992,
0.27097582817077637,
-0.7413438558578491,
-0.3618299961090088,
-0.1358865201473236,
-0.051849983632564545,
-0.6100665330886841,
0.2613195776939392,
-0.05172787234187126,
1.0166689157485962,
-0.48035117983818054,
1.2582319974899292,
0.7130321264266968,
-0.11633578687906265,
-0.5838650465011597,
-0.1959276795387268,
-0.19243191182613373,
-1.0232073068618774,
0.44372114539146423,
-0.10496647655963898,
-0.39375802874565125,
0.2362106293439865,
-0.43184515833854675,
-1.0473898649215698,
1.2727164030075073,
0.4175301790237427,
-1.0181803703308105,
-0.3000912070274353,
0.06291259080171585,
0.8631250858306885,
-0.4718802571296692,
0.366487979888916,
0.6782520413398743,
0.042354948818683624,
0.21328821778297424,
-1.104079008102417,
0.018013587221503258,
0.019951149821281433,
-0.03989248722791672,
0.18972726166248322,
-0.49131137132644653,
0.662116527557373,
-0.3995538353919983,
0.07898510247468948,
-0.006289507728070021,
0.44032102823257446,
0.6416383385658264,
0.23962585628032684,
0.07792447507381439,
0.4056980013847351,
1.2361905574798584,
-0.09780915081501007,
1.281132698059082,
-0.3919033706188202,
0.6073991656303406,
0.9602509140968323,
-0.7452859282493591,
0.9870526790618896,
0.5480772852897644,
-0.16142712533473969,
0.7514843940734863,
0.1641474962234497,
0.13040362298488617,
0.44648244976997375,
0.19991301000118256,
-0.24051529169082642,
-0.24572260677814484,
0.04846779629588127,
-0.6328941583633423,
0.030216781422495842,
0.6353452205657959,
-0.2509736120700836,
-0.020204711705446243,
0.2752068042755127,
-0.04163209721446037,
-0.021805258467793465,
-0.5844081044197083,
0.46519750356674194,
0.47768425941467285,
-0.4271787106990814,
0.49135643243789673,
-0.26133838295936584,
0.5000621676445007,
-0.6104233860969543,
0.13684481382369995,
0.037350207567214966,
0.31475791335105896,
-0.24293074011802673,
-1.0389636754989624,
0.3221699297428131,
0.04131067171692848,
-0.16829073429107666,
0.0702817440032959,
0.8164975047111511,
-0.19831117987632751,
-0.7791037559509277,
0.3525523841381073,
0.6366850137710571,
0.06999840587377548,
0.02647213079035282,
-0.8194573521614075,
-0.018732398748397827,
-0.2147514820098877,
-0.3635302782058716,
0.2668401598930359,
0.27963003516197205,
0.059900861233472824,
1.0668020248413086,
0.467562198638916,
0.40518641471862793,
-0.2438458800315857,
0.2439820021390915,
0.9863932728767395,
-0.9640535712242126,
-0.34531083703041077,
-0.7410770654678345,
0.4117582142353058,
-0.027489755302667618,
-0.2645809054374695,
0.3095402121543884,
0.31340503692626953,
0.6417288780212402,
0.14826428890228271,
0.7962062954902649,
0.1972936987876892,
0.7892797589302063,
-0.522719144821167,
0.5785706639289856,
-0.4367237687110901,
0.48297199606895447,
-0.45848289132118225,
-0.716965913772583,
-0.9533373713493347,
0.8370736241340637,
-0.6085584163665771,
-0.04222065955400467,
1.2171311378479004,
0.4917965531349182,
0.003504144726321101,
0.022206246852874756,
0.4338158071041107,
0.32584109902381897,
0.7372270822525024,
0.7328587770462036,
0.734224259853363,
-0.32548952102661133,
0.279841810464859,
0.02225138247013092,
-0.23986279964447021,
-0.21028301119804382,
-0.6964858770370483,
-1.0518025159835815,
-0.1509818434715271,
-0.4536899924278259,
-0.22097575664520264,
0.1651660054922104,
0.9533282518386841,
0.7450978755950928,
-0.7745092511177063,
-0.357626736164093,
-0.10049466043710709,
0.16753338277339935,
-0.4154748320579529,
-0.1409398466348648,
0.49581772089004517,
0.05883922427892685,
-0.4401654601097107,
0.4459920823574066,
0.63921719789505,
-0.09907104820013046,
-0.05516837537288666,
-0.14124855399131775,
-0.20163071155548096,
0.2606605589389801,
0.7306745052337646,
0.24308879673480988,
-1.0434435606002808,
-0.6211873292922974,
0.199091836810112,
-0.07083641737699509,
0.3607499599456787,
0.8109954595565796,
-0.6109939813613892,
0.6497313380241394,
0.1898898035287857,
0.7087997794151306,
0.3955787122249603,
-0.008940924890339375,
0.5862921476364136,
-0.43768206238746643,
0.15747885406017303,
0.6547417640686035,
0.4641527235507965,
0.2568647861480713,
-0.28002700209617615,
0.5948355793952942,
0.4175014793872833,
-0.6530333161354065,
-0.8789485096931458,
0.22756820917129517,
-1.0841407775878906,
-0.4617375433444977,
1.095911979675293,
0.13781048357486725,
-0.1127454861998558,
-0.15531915426254272,
-0.21218572556972504,
-0.16018609702587128,
-0.30739936232566833,
0.7383349537849426,
0.7393376231193542,
-0.5296310782432556,
-0.23438699543476105,
-0.38635241985321045,
0.050362326204776764,
0.5375100374221802,
-0.9720944166183472,
-0.0648307353258133,
0.10760241746902466,
0.4107132852077484,
0.07394383102655411,
0.9115058183670044,
0.0051077078096568584,
0.36815518140792847,
-0.23437725007534027,
0.35547950863838196,
0.25227057933807373,
-0.31201937794685364,
-0.2832218408584595,
0.09519094228744507,
0.30421364307403564,
0.48246631026268005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11039v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11039v2
|
CC-GPX: Extracting High-Quality Annotated Geospatial Data from Common Crawl
| 2024-05-17T18:31:26 | 2024-05-29T09:16:28 |
Ilya Ilyankou, Meihui Wang, James Haworth, Stefano Cavazzi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Common Crawl (CC) corpus is the largest open web crawl dataset containing
9.5+ petabytes of data captured since 2008. The dataset is instrumental in
training large language models, and as such it has been studied for
(un)desirable content, and distilled for smaller, domain-specific datasets.
However, to our knowledge, no research has been dedicated to using CC as a
source of annotated geospatial data. In this paper, we introduce an efficient
pipeline to extract annotated user-generated tracks from GPX files found in CC,
and the resulting multimodal dataset with 1,416 pairings of human-written
descriptions and MultiLineString vector data from the 6 most recent CC
releases. The dataset can be used to study people's outdoor activity patterns,
the way people talk about their outdoor experiences, and for developing
trajectory generation or track annotation models. Our reproducible code is
available on GitHub: https://github.com/ilyankou/cc-gpx
|
[
-0.5603604912757874,
-0.3082329034805298,
0.8414435386657715,
-0.024441402405500412,
-0.30824074149131775,
-0.02875930443406105,
-0.46225211024284363,
-0.47212663292884827,
0.36650216579437256,
0.36665958166122437,
-0.5846075415611267,
-1.2422964572906494,
-0.48906993865966797,
-0.08954031765460968,
-0.6546383500099182,
0.9677666425704956,
0.18852582573890686,
-0.42399200797080994,
-0.08637351542711258,
-0.2688632309436798,
-0.09373852610588074,
-0.8798138499259949,
-0.38130924105644226,
0.2584798038005829,
0.6956103444099426,
0.18418589234352112,
0.6610555648803711,
0.598796010017395,
0.21445193886756897,
0.15594026446342468,
-0.03863222524523735,
0.532811164855957,
-0.4985796809196472,
-0.033105168491601944,
-0.12547138333320618,
0.13746249675750732,
-0.09355420619249344,
0.23763664066791534,
0.6664685606956482,
0.5101492404937744,
-0.1809195578098297,
0.29094311594963074,
-0.19841338694095612,
0.15573327243328094,
-0.8737279772758484,
0.15093055367469788,
-0.5345522165298462,
-0.3144654333591461,
-0.6576241254806519,
-0.09063275158405304,
-0.04371599107980728,
-0.11219221353530884,
0.10880891978740692,
-1.0710912942886353,
0.4638437032699585,
0.2871539294719696,
0.5422834753990173,
-0.031548045575618744,
-0.018758825957775116,
-0.44693851470947266,
-0.03331393003463745,
0.6444247961044312,
-0.5320242047309875,
0.21297167241573334,
0.5904030799865723,
0.25445351004600525,
-0.027721961960196495,
-0.8548951745033264,
-0.7988642454147339,
0.0035373845603317022,
-0.15048876404762268,
0.04680253565311432,
0.18201397359371185,
-0.2621822953224182,
0.3882789611816406,
0.36385586857795715,
-0.6627238988876343,
-0.10388147830963135,
-0.24763734638690948,
-0.33985671401023865,
0.9135593771934509,
0.39368873834609985,
0.6233811974525452,
-0.22137857973575592,
-0.2708347737789154,
-0.2760741412639618,
-0.46717604994773865,
0.2926730215549469,
0.6175113320350647,
0.7954538464546204,
-0.29585644602775574,
0.7007181644439697,
-0.6028162240982056,
0.5436015129089355,
-0.4154798090457916,
-0.019346587359905243,
0.43392589688301086,
-0.5016979575157166,
0.250240683555603,
-0.16960389912128448,
0.8898816108703613,
0.5072624683380127,
0.17406415939331055,
-0.5124778747558594,
-0.1449090540409088,
0.07251473516225815,
0.010043718852102757,
-0.43320029973983765,
-0.6597719788551331,
0.21438667178153992,
-0.11925598978996277,
0.030655737966299057,
0.7019162178039551,
-1.139032244682312,
-0.3247319757938385,
-0.6046674847602844,
-0.029478488489985466,
-0.23295655846595764,
-0.2681543827056885,
0.12070560455322266,
-0.4360112249851227,
0.09089253842830658,
0.426232248544693,
-0.6269841194152832,
0.3540235757827759,
0.8753562569618225,
1.1766167879104614,
-0.49334463477134705,
-0.4414187967777252,
-0.8797107338905334,
-0.05916935205459595,
-0.04426740109920502,
0.6291694045066833,
-0.7290880084037781,
-0.4033365547657013,
0.10351377725601196,
0.48553577065467834,
0.000299748353427276,
-0.32730889320373535,
0.6265015602111816,
-0.22403401136398315,
0.053957968950271606,
-0.5660436153411865,
0.005827085580676794,
-0.32381319999694824,
0.19812746345996857,
-0.749634861946106,
1.4187084436416626,
0.23243151605129242,
-0.8430420756340027,
0.38112083077430725,
-0.6034329533576965,
-0.27969470620155334,
0.35585129261016846,
0.07719874382019043,
-0.3481028079986572,
0.014384986832737923,
0.7163824439048767,
0.2223287969827652,
-0.0972994714975357,
0.030446957796812057,
-0.4151701331138611,
-0.5452105402946472,
0.08976778388023376,
0.0990646705031395,
0.7590115070343018,
0.31770721077919006,
-0.19248543679714203,
-0.2717300355434418,
-1.0353397130966187,
0.09253446757793427,
0.15914443135261536,
-0.35734865069389343,
-0.44993385672569275,
0.3190319836139679,
0.4799145758152008,
0.29993101954460144,
0.18023844063282013,
-0.7973114252090454,
0.37773817777633667,
-0.012796753086149693,
0.37891706824302673,
0.6143636107444763,
-0.15286654233932495,
0.24443627893924713,
-0.11465263366699219,
0.38115695118904114,
-0.12985992431640625,
0.044427238404750824,
-0.4846324026584625,
-0.4408707320690155,
-0.2553103566169739,
-0.4739077091217041,
0.03360584005713463,
0.12053611129522324,
-0.4485064744949341,
-0.017877303063869476,
-0.6052519679069519,
-0.5960059762001038,
-0.4216098189353943,
0.10604587942361832,
-0.05680925399065018,
0.17116856575012207,
0.7661574482917786,
-0.6655145287513733,
-0.224956676363945,
-0.11164210736751556,
0.1779378354549408,
0.20924414694309235,
-0.08048152923583984,
0.6324218511581421,
0.41784778237342834,
-0.4275236427783966,
1.3001071214675903,
-0.8094349503517151,
-0.035895634442567825,
-0.05141829326748848,
0.45790156722068787,
0.0193600095808506,
0.22975574433803558,
0.6470721960067749,
-0.7545132040977478,
-0.4044492840766907,
0.010388989001512527,
-0.32898983359336853,
-0.24390535056591034,
-0.17042791843414307,
-0.23403756320476532,
-0.1632639765739441,
-0.00013946954277344048,
-0.6380550861358643,
0.5000157952308655,
0.6629238724708557,
-0.2956794798374176,
0.643013596534729,
0.08618656545877457,
0.27909818291664124,
-0.6570338010787964,
0.38540923595428467,
0.11388929188251495,
-0.43755578994750977,
-0.06628704816102982,
0.14719007909297943,
-0.23738981783390045,
-0.41629743576049805,
-0.4943961799144745,
0.30210375785827637,
-0.572629988193512,
-0.33845603466033936,
-0.24720238149166107,
0.4982561469078064,
-0.27308419346809387,
0.41417649388313293,
0.4324170649051666,
0.75577312707901,
0.8220720887184143,
-0.4981057047843933,
0.6365379691123962,
0.3340013921260834,
-0.3213774263858795,
0.017926359549164772,
-0.35062816739082336,
0.7263359427452087,
-0.23540464043617249,
0.13370560109615326,
-0.7682946920394897,
-0.49509331583976746,
0.17490921914577484,
-0.6282333731651306,
-0.33911222219467163,
-0.49038997292518616,
-0.6517724394798279,
-0.28829193115234375,
-0.38378286361694336,
0.13999377191066742,
0.10772272199392319,
-0.9115127921104431,
0.26357463002204895,
0.5499306917190552,
-0.025351375341415405,
-0.36751243472099304,
-0.4165354371070862,
0.31744158267974854,
-0.2258252054452896,
-0.31244003772735596,
0.036291394382715225,
-0.15441623330116272,
-0.11643851548433304,
-0.10638343542814255,
0.04915979877114296,
-0.35420894622802734,
0.11348807066679001,
0.5476364493370056,
0.08076252788305283,
0.16532231867313385,
-0.0828331857919693,
-0.3721161186695099,
-0.25438717007637024,
0.09984008967876434,
-0.29646235704421997,
0.5911503434181213,
0.3587501049041748,
-0.25056642293930054,
-0.2980354428291321,
0.5367003083229065,
0.4270678460597992,
-0.4357117712497711,
0.555629551410675,
0.7817752361297607,
-0.23316620290279388,
-0.3719490170478821,
0.015520088374614716,
0.2360786646604538,
-0.39669108390808105,
0.0959760919213295,
-0.047456514090299606,
-1.0321656465530396,
0.22494013607501984,
-0.32660752534866333,
0.011748034507036209,
0.3787370026111603,
0.20753219723701477,
-0.11013539880514145,
0.85701584815979,
0.38761597871780396,
-0.34713634848594666,
0.05004154145717621,
-0.20752787590026855,
0.14681775867938995,
-0.697638988494873,
-0.1313149631023407,
-0.7217875123023987,
-0.07301127165555954,
-0.8331753611564636,
-0.4624921381473541,
0.1234770193696022,
-0.07262155413627625,
-0.151450976729393,
0.6431319117546082,
-0.723155677318573,
0.32462796568870544,
0.7653670310974121,
0.09062456339597702,
0.09223587810993195,
0.04033032804727554,
-0.04525456205010414,
-0.1259903758764267,
-0.2638329267501831,
-0.32081228494644165,
1.1291550397872925,
-0.12195660173892975,
0.7058756351470947,
0.24388475716114044,
0.4868638515472412,
0.3010590076446533,
0.05826523154973984,
-0.47702735662460327,
0.49225762486457825,
-0.06093732267618179,
-0.5551060438156128,
-0.0718083307147026,
-0.31701475381851196,
-0.7144325971603394,
-0.21439243853092194,
-0.6002683043479919,
-0.903116762638092,
-0.13079088926315308,
0.08462612330913544,
-0.43757444620132446,
0.2262505441904068,
-0.3944143056869507,
0.6796454191207886,
-0.2749750018119812,
-0.4444642961025238,
0.18518120050430298,
-0.8551732301712036,
0.11613218486309052,
-0.13061976432800293,
0.44412580132484436,
-0.20806176960468292,
0.0961880162358284,
0.44372084736824036,
-0.5079687237739563,
0.6260875463485718,
-0.36761271953582764,
0.2666378617286682,
0.7855849266052246,
-0.09596758335828781,
0.7214028239250183,
0.3520204722881317,
0.41595667600631714,
0.5094536542892456,
-0.11328424513339996,
-0.058885760605335236,
-0.2926699221134186,
0.741902768611908,
-0.7207854390144348,
-0.05373518913984299,
-0.591198742389679,
-0.24658191204071045,
0.2309659868478775,
-0.006462314166128635,
0.2070932537317276,
0.5455767512321472,
0.1598883420228958,
-0.014508775435388088,
0.21045677363872528,
-0.3244861960411072,
0.7293068766593933,
0.2943665087223053,
-0.05104856565594673,
-0.7329774498939514,
1.0191680192947388,
-0.11362151056528091,
-0.18311111629009247,
0.29701223969459534,
-0.05297363921999931,
-0.49635177850723267,
-0.7431620955467224,
-0.1024908721446991,
0.10919790714979172,
-0.509799063205719,
-0.0404336117208004,
-0.7769708037376404,
0.21704721450805664,
-0.5697943568229675,
-0.23002564907073975,
-0.27593010663986206,
-0.30477094650268555,
-0.2912612855434418,
-0.1661442220211029,
0.26860299706459045,
0.6526652574539185,
-0.19484230875968933,
0.566782534122467,
-0.7848835587501526,
0.25742971897125244,
0.15855146944522858,
0.004365466069430113,
-0.3921370506286621,
0.19397900998592377,
-0.4475119411945343,
0.026955127716064453,
-0.19611790776252747,
-0.5777822136878967,
0.7756282091140747,
0.027101535350084305,
0.45877450704574585,
0.2584419846534729,
0.03327310085296631,
0.930289089679718,
-0.1878330558538437,
1.333834171295166,
0.16676363348960876,
-0.9272637367248535,
0.47845277190208435,
-0.5480594038963318,
0.16133549809455872,
0.5810457468032837,
0.6423041224479675,
-0.7497467398643494,
0.06412237882614136,
-0.359036922454834,
-1.0665696859359741,
0.45635750889778137,
0.0899219810962677,
-0.06832427531480789,
-0.264579176902771,
0.528454065322876,
0.2526432275772095,
-0.007701284717768431,
-0.8339054584503174,
-0.10192999243736267,
-0.3428150415420532,
-0.30868902802467346,
-0.4990689754486084,
-0.16706393659114838,
-0.03784490004181862,
-0.004407930187880993,
0.4295004904270172,
-0.5216931104660034,
0.018595103174448013,
0.4624364674091339,
-0.4242020845413208,
0.126830592751503,
0.004736646078526974,
0.1886068433523178,
0.7831453084945679,
-0.20721064507961273,
0.3797769248485565,
0.11043892800807953,
-0.786109983921051,
-0.20202142000198364,
0.23226214945316315,
-0.09638698399066925,
0.009835347533226013,
0.3795594274997711,
0.13333067297935486,
-0.093390092253685,
-0.9653851389884949,
0.8020447492599487,
0.012701831758022308,
0.14052535593509674,
-0.627467930316925,
0.1588752567768097,
0.0628635436296463,
-0.00867236964404583,
0.27534472942352295,
-0.021344326436519623,
0.3876628577709198,
-0.29716166853904724,
0.3368584215641022,
0.3054004907608032,
-0.38754329085350037,
-0.5669735074043274,
0.9182064533233643,
0.15890318155288696,
0.030007563531398773,
1.0358855724334717,
-0.2791314125061035,
-0.2853259742259979,
0.12323183566331863,
0.08740828186273575,
0.7146769762039185,
0.33440330624580383,
-0.07698129117488861,
0.9532322287559509,
0.18549510836601257,
-0.031135892495512962,
-0.05406470596790314,
-0.4563438296318054,
-0.44895073771476746,
-0.6780540943145752,
-0.764178454875946,
-0.33637917041778564,
-0.12467729300260544,
-0.6307056546211243,
0.5981974601745605,
-0.21145890653133392,
-0.09002450108528137,
-0.2366386353969574,
0.07876335084438324,
-0.7189493775367737,
0.3401717245578766,
0.5078150033950806,
0.9872084259986877,
-0.7549228072166443,
0.648099422454834,
0.6370497941970825,
-0.3247600197792053,
-0.4613761007785797,
-0.010818500071763992,
0.18791520595550537,
-0.5461805462837219,
0.3825463056564331,
0.5274506211280823,
-0.07984817028045654,
-0.09305091202259064,
-1.2269482612609863,
-0.8428440093994141,
1.2836220264434814,
-0.2089107483625412,
-0.8327292799949646,
0.12430611252784729,
0.3615279793739319,
0.22281403839588165,
-0.38520267605781555,
0.24593377113342285,
0.27430278062820435,
0.4862954616546631,
-0.011145132593810558,
-0.6230684518814087,
-0.06869491934776306,
0.012770471163094044,
-0.23909007012844086,
0.13076581060886383,
-0.639471173286438,
0.866617739200592,
-0.2799113094806671,
-0.5519120693206787,
0.3154495656490326,
0.38791561126708984,
0.25599831342697144,
0.6034448742866516,
0.5379692912101746,
1.093961477279663,
0.7104262113571167,
-0.39972880482673645,
0.9238341450691223,
-0.10954738408327103,
0.7278629541397095,
1.3171535730361938,
-0.12007435411214828,
0.7079516053199768,
-0.05403565987944603,
-0.08402898907661438,
0.42045873403549194,
0.659643828868866,
0.14032568037509918,
0.7090503573417664,
0.3539024293422699,
-0.4859830141067505,
-0.5009738802909851,
0.2265576720237732,
0.031795352697372437,
0.7169000506401062,
0.26347094774246216,
-0.12843191623687744,
-0.28878071904182434,
-0.5206869840621948,
0.23003427684307098,
0.07226531207561493,
-0.3055674731731415,
0.69095778465271,
-0.27325910329818726,
-0.5710351467132568,
-0.06541775912046432,
-0.1849803775548935,
0.6330153346061707,
-0.6562354564666748,
-0.32481828331947327,
0.05128127709031105,
-0.23758922517299652,
-0.34066644310951233,
-0.7887393236160278,
0.25597822666168213,
0.1088726669549942,
0.11333257704973221,
0.10091666132211685,
0.48667848110198975,
-0.38720962405204773,
-0.19125592708587646,
0.3424476683139801,
0.1276085525751114,
0.3485877811908722,
-0.45592793822288513,
-0.4027792513370514,
0.13028639554977417,
0.0529279001057148,
-0.011195874772965908,
0.034732330590486526,
0.4009914696216583,
0.050933171063661575,
0.4090161621570587,
1.2031642198562622,
0.2425626516342163,
0.19657906889915466,
-0.2546062171459198,
1.0989024639129639,
-1.0898677110671997,
-0.44792211055755615,
-0.5994765162467957,
0.9093220233917236,
-0.34469732642173767,
-0.5031756162643433,
0.8105316162109375,
0.8913446664810181,
0.909804105758667,
0.332991361618042,
1.1137752532958984,
-0.25917762517929077,
0.6952203512191772,
-0.4210693836212158,
0.44798848032951355,
-0.2184797078371048,
-0.12867529690265656,
-0.18720367550849915,
-0.9210373759269714,
-0.2931775748729706,
0.3432478606700897,
0.027996696531772614,
-0.25984564423561096,
0.5480898022651672,
0.7730019092559814,
-0.25813496112823486,
0.09282327443361282,
-0.057620786130428314,
-0.1562168151140213,
0.5665545463562012,
0.5824510455131531,
0.8615255355834961,
-0.18955107033252716,
0.3799041509628296,
-0.37605011463165283,
-0.31190025806427,
0.2839494049549103,
-1.1263872385025024,
-0.7623314261436462,
-0.6635156869888306,
-0.27988532185554504,
-0.14578314125537872,
0.09671735018491745,
0.7693362236022949,
1.018513560295105,
-0.7834976315498352,
0.17560681700706482,
-0.24894532561302185,
-0.3367552161216736,
-0.14012621343135834,
-0.2531983256340027,
0.4324493706226349,
-0.3161502182483673,
-0.8706837892532349,
0.4641983211040497,
0.21788734197616577,
-0.15589596331119537,
0.10130204260349274,
-0.1274397224187851,
-0.14935293793678284,
-0.5953678488731384,
0.41012176871299744,
0.2795860767364502,
-0.21840545535087585,
-0.5418522357940674,
-0.19351285696029663,
0.2883155643939972,
-0.010253886692225933,
0.8933929800987244,
-0.677679181098938,
0.7232511639595032,
0.2795349359512329,
0.40686845779418945,
0.7646474242210388,
0.5085648894309998,
0.10518354177474976,
-0.8235850930213928,
0.051755089312791824,
-0.07486659288406372,
0.4202791750431061,
0.4903634488582611,
-0.3655625283718109,
0.7076082825660706,
0.6855973601341248,
-0.7017998099327087,
-0.3116641044616699,
-0.2480466514825821,
-1.5170642137527466,
0.035272885113954544,
1.468605875968933,
-0.4776774048805237,
-0.10820682346820831,
-0.139469176530838,
-0.35140126943588257,
-0.07147186994552612,
-0.438050776720047,
0.49527493119239807,
0.6855864524841309,
0.10916712880134583,
-0.18362507224082947,
-0.651703953742981,
0.35976192355155945,
-0.61822909116745,
-0.7077347636222839,
0.30825075507164,
0.8612043261528015,
0.5577444434165955,
0.34748804569244385,
0.48597151041030884,
-0.12912318110466003,
0.1010616198182106,
0.04731106013059616,
0.27840372920036316,
-0.33239951729774475,
-0.30721917748451233,
0.11930043995380402,
0.4577200412750244,
-0.27893128991127014,
-0.3374863266944885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11030v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11030v1
|
The Unappreciated Role of Intent in Algorithmic Moderation of Social Media Content
| 2024-05-17T18:05:13 | 2024-05-17T18:05:13 |
Xinyu Wang, Sai Koneru, Pranav Narayanan Venkit, Brett Frischmann, Sarah Rajtmajer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As social media has become a predominant mode of communication globally, the
rise of abusive content threatens to undermine civil discourse. Recognizing the
critical nature of this issue, a significant body of research has been
dedicated to developing language models that can detect various types of online
abuse, e.g., hate speech, cyberbullying. However, there exists a notable
disconnect between platform policies, which often consider the author's
intention as a criterion for content moderation, and the current capabilities
of detection models, which typically lack efforts to capture intent. This paper
examines the role of intent in content moderation systems. We review state of
the art detection models and benchmark training datasets for online abuse to
assess their awareness and ability to capture intent. We propose strategic
changes to the design and development of automated detection and moderation
systems to improve alignment with ethical and policy conceptualizations of
abuse.
|
[
-0.16365814208984375,
-0.7822240591049194,
0.9409984350204468,
0.2471998929977417,
-0.30916205048561096,
-0.4339081645011902,
-0.013249947689473629,
-0.28828495740890503,
0.2233210951089859,
0.6151005029678345,
-0.26937854290008545,
-0.15049304068088531,
-1.15605890750885,
-0.04006749764084816,
-0.6676244139671326,
0.9648837447166443,
-0.2338378131389618,
-0.049743615090847015,
0.048951245844364166,
-0.20822103321552277,
-0.5343144536018372,
-0.11753714829683304,
-0.8773137927055359,
-0.12137670814990997,
0.46051642298698425,
0.02415139600634575,
0.5713457465171814,
0.4347771108150482,
0.7050721049308777,
0.3645915687084198,
0.2175850123167038,
0.3218310475349426,
-0.9803965091705322,
0.2448333352804184,
-0.22409018874168396,
-0.2723349928855896,
-0.4520869851112366,
0.17402377724647522,
0.33710208535194397,
0.29866257309913635,
0.04657253250479698,
0.1489025354385376,
0.08524255454540253,
0.4679088294506073,
-0.7040303945541382,
-0.0650118812918663,
-0.5730966329574585,
-0.27821728587150574,
0.1380346715450287,
-0.6528264880180359,
-0.5189169645309448,
-0.22379739582538605,
-0.28293171525001526,
-0.7140752673149109,
-0.2654656171798706,
-0.07571298629045486,
0.16146713495254517,
0.2898021936416626,
-0.38351115584373474,
-0.9219529628753662,
-0.9923645257949829,
0.8512535095214844,
-0.3757433593273163,
0.4119267761707306,
0.6111047863960266,
-0.12163743376731873,
-0.34684380888938904,
-0.5910442471504211,
-0.35569366812705994,
0.2492934763431549,
-0.057126253843307495,
-0.29166287183761597,
-0.2353350818157196,
0.23566041886806488,
0.1365155428647995,
0.10675538331270218,
-0.10972660779953003,
-0.062064338475465775,
-0.5051143765449524,
-0.021440014243125916,
0.8856037855148315,
0.167401522397995,
0.6759235858917236,
-0.21507757902145386,
-0.2916434407234192,
0.4410458505153656,
-0.3604119122028351,
0.44180062413215637,
0.671500027179718,
0.2873445451259613,
0.12190738320350647,
0.5942201018333435,
0.02048959955573082,
0.3757697641849518,
0.1976882964372635,
-0.06784888356924057,
-0.41527050733566284,
-0.1939321756362915,
-0.04554535076022148,
0.4579944908618927,
0.7063838839530945,
0.7271211743354797,
0.14900000393390656,
0.14657191932201385,
-0.4446902871131897,
0.25738954544067383,
0.8049696087837219,
-0.7574172019958496,
0.01169347669929266,
0.5105218887329102,
-0.6815012097358704,
-0.5498479604721069,
0.34525126218795776,
-0.11455688625574112,
-0.7398535013198853,
-0.36493006348609924,
0.5272338390350342,
-0.1445101797580719,
-0.4682735800743103,
0.2754959464073181,
-0.24581274390220642,
0.23644645512104034,
0.40106526017189026,
-0.7029576301574707,
0.34471312165260315,
0.9530532360076904,
0.5981886386871338,
-0.26133474707603455,
0.09878932684659958,
-0.4667659103870392,
0.193491131067276,
-0.4574359059333801,
0.36649131774902344,
-0.6928790807723999,
-0.22738483548164368,
0.22618919610977173,
0.13991326093673706,
0.18367260694503784,
0.079218290746212,
0.970354437828064,
-0.8021963238716125,
0.01676742546260357,
-0.4096781015396118,
-0.4404239356517792,
-0.5793392062187195,
0.12662793695926666,
-0.6070553064346313,
0.5786376595497131,
0.01891089230775833,
-0.47050684690475464,
0.6602287292480469,
-1.155301809310913,
-0.5453985333442688,
0.22225695848464966,
-0.06021960824728012,
-0.23866325616836548,
0.22169864177703857,
0.01863163895905018,
0.3782833516597748,
0.25491219758987427,
0.6147146821022034,
-0.4144423305988312,
-0.7637084126472473,
0.40628647804260254,
-0.6529075503349304,
0.9716182947158813,
0.0318584106862545,
-0.6062043905258179,
0.13352088630199432,
-0.029620887711644173,
-0.1190648302435875,
0.009972290135920048,
-0.3009234666824341,
-0.6794013977050781,
0.5638361573219299,
0.12602531909942627,
0.11304289102554321,
0.012356874532997608,
-0.5810944437980652,
-0.31591683626174927,
0.07727210968732834,
0.5745017528533936,
0.9215954542160034,
0.18937888741493225,
0.5081156492233276,
-0.5321199893951416,
0.4150480329990387,
-0.2901245951652527,
0.6934574246406555,
0.2117408812046051,
-0.5497205257415771,
-0.4348590075969696,
-0.08215576410293579,
-0.21598763763904572,
0.08161477744579315,
-0.38341009616851807,
0.46045345067977905,
-0.3111982047557831,
-0.25359588861465454,
-0.5266830325126648,
0.4196850657463074,
0.25325652956962585,
-0.125387042760849,
0.16202959418296814,
-0.5208291411399841,
-0.47651588916778564,
-0.5754868984222412,
-0.40201500058174133,
-0.3587198257446289,
0.30552399158477783,
0.48021647334098816,
0.2064865678548813,
-0.14305180311203003,
0.8829113841056824,
-0.033788200467824936,
-0.41887515783309937,
-0.46354222297668457,
0.06978745758533478,
-0.2520776093006134,
0.2790501117706299,
0.5850726962089539,
-1.3214311599731445,
-0.5741113424301147,
-0.20345397293567657,
-1.0226831436157227,
-0.2902239263057709,
0.05298618972301483,
-0.13086242973804474,
-0.03049441985785961,
0.6219744682312012,
-0.31217992305755615,
0.5383415818214417,
0.36785221099853516,
-0.3303227126598358,
0.037444066256284714,
0.2439916729927063,
0.7654323577880859,
-0.4595733880996704,
0.07119709253311157,
-0.16027088463306427,
-0.19616679847240448,
-0.9088912010192871,
-0.07345125079154968,
-0.1742345243692398,
0.10395104438066483,
-0.7999926209449768,
0.3295765221118927,
-0.32933738827705383,
0.18480820953845978,
-0.47651252150535583,
0.20498600602149963,
0.15886615216732025,
0.08219166100025177,
-0.15803134441375732,
0.39396095275878906,
0.21272245049476624,
-0.7672677636146545,
0.17830534279346466,
0.12406840175390244,
-0.23111172020435333,
0.7492986917495728,
-0.5255699753761292,
0.10913757234811783,
-0.4799271523952484,
0.1710136979818344,
-0.9485059976577759,
-0.3464455306529999,
0.5204220414161682,
-0.4978404641151428,
0.06763549149036407,
-0.3325919210910797,
-0.06310740113258362,
-0.11150359362363815,
-0.5729815363883972,
0.5538828372955322,
0.18491211533546448,
-0.11785905808210373,
0.6759156584739685,
0.8602820634841919,
-0.04020985588431358,
-0.5704686641693115,
-0.5567717552185059,
-0.05347488820552826,
-0.42366302013397217,
-0.4963494837284088,
0.13234315812587738,
0.10701537132263184,
-0.46935397386550903,
-0.027586545795202255,
0.07287091016769409,
-0.1367422640323639,
0.15862582623958588,
0.5157236456871033,
-0.020495813339948654,
0.08529927581548691,
-0.03208579868078232,
0.10319031029939651,
0.19330349564552307,
0.4131506681442261,
0.043413370847702026,
0.5819211602210999,
0.17373931407928467,
-0.3357992172241211,
-0.6505852341651917,
0.5167047381401062,
0.6477028727531433,
-0.1177048459649086,
0.3956236243247986,
0.4926908612251282,
-0.23797732591629028,
-0.15187744796276093,
-0.47255343198776245,
-0.29690322279930115,
-0.5495772361755371,
0.10890711098909378,
0.2500036954879761,
-0.5739105343818665,
0.29542744159698486,
0.12040741741657257,
0.08705812692642212,
0.053522609174251556,
0.25629299879074097,
-0.023312458768486977,
1.1679080724716187,
0.7045732140541077,
0.06385248899459839,
0.6881575584411621,
-0.13614529371261597,
0.5261238217353821,
-0.7701341509819031,
0.06682863086462021,
-0.017141863703727722,
-0.5066012144088745,
-0.7902608513832092,
-0.06256523728370667,
0.3117053508758545,
-0.32171136140823364,
0.045244473963975906,
0.32269084453582764,
-0.6920312643051147,
0.4147827923297882,
-0.09536681324243546,
0.4107314646244049,
0.31682467460632324,
-0.1102689728140831,
0.7100589275360107,
-0.023211002349853516,
-0.43630120158195496,
-0.8159139156341553,
1.2037521600723267,
0.41338130831718445,
0.6771697998046875,
0.10570627450942993,
0.4379483461380005,
0.9009750485420227,
0.5136186480522156,
-0.8485980033874512,
0.4716699719429016,
0.03506482020020485,
-0.8477012515068054,
-0.3921584188938141,
0.156203493475914,
-0.923515796661377,
-0.08109361678361893,
0.166716530919075,
-0.5650296807289124,
0.3740365505218506,
0.1278720498085022,
-0.3503457009792328,
0.37504056096076965,
-0.5738570094108582,
0.7195701599121094,
-0.32882705330848694,
-0.4867161810398102,
-0.3315446376800537,
-0.2639079988002777,
0.534772515296936,
-0.05816669762134552,
0.5531724691390991,
-0.16848985850811005,
-0.21593423187732697,
0.8559030890464783,
-0.057098206132650375,
0.8861274123191833,
-0.4514937996864319,
-0.08330711722373962,
0.6442647576332092,
0.2952103912830353,
0.42387667298316956,
-0.05029044300317764,
0.03179182857275009,
-0.09695214033126831,
-0.2734698951244354,
-0.13926216959953308,
-0.18885360658168793,
0.6105408072471619,
-0.49420058727264404,
-0.39279234409332275,
-0.008034570142626762,
-0.38954299688339233,
0.05134640261530876,
0.32458195090293884,
0.07217082381248474,
0.5252338647842407,
-0.4883388578891754,
0.5561680197715759,
0.9466301202774048,
0.13224761188030243,
0.4211827516555786,
0.37400105595588684,
-0.3157094120979309,
0.09939152002334595,
0.9992440938949585,
-0.07722409069538116,
0.2551761567592621,
-0.021554570645093918,
0.13898645341396332,
-0.23452289402484894,
-0.5334076881408691,
-0.20536981523036957,
-0.11186879873275757,
-0.7853829264640808,
-0.040205489844083786,
-0.8346816301345825,
-0.09683337807655334,
-0.3908284902572632,
-0.6671618819236755,
-0.16489414870738983,
0.028820479288697243,
-0.00006830096390331164,
0.18530961871147156,
0.23512275516986847,
0.9519255757331848,
-0.06317932903766632,
0.6507010459899902,
-0.3448377549648285,
0.41500359773635864,
0.23194476962089539,
0.33255255222320557,
-0.33635973930358887,
-0.6298520565032959,
0.26917141675949097,
0.1091800183057785,
-0.24747076630592346,
-0.7594039440155029,
0.06094130501151085,
0.018186714500188828,
0.4376283884048462,
0.793363094329834,
0.1677420437335968,
0.21550942957401276,
-0.01254277303814888,
0.5584216117858887,
-0.2207908183336258,
-0.5071172714233398,
0.6886709332466125,
-0.6078733205795288,
-0.2706412076950073,
0.7997753620147705,
0.8442447781562805,
-0.9208377599716187,
-0.5002933740615845,
-0.6138831377029419,
-0.40463924407958984,
0.8671521544456482,
0.10303078591823578,
0.5670173764228821,
0.05828896909952164,
0.07583345472812653,
0.1092807799577713,
0.5290289521217346,
-0.9375744462013245,
-0.010520415380597115,
-0.08866654336452484,
-0.1252177655696869,
0.3805028796195984,
-0.3140120208263397,
-0.24982194602489471,
-0.03298405557870865,
0.6549565196037292,
0.1380494087934494,
0.3114981949329376,
0.002134033478796482,
-0.2790755033493042,
-0.4752912223339081,
0.1607189178466797,
0.496667742729187,
0.6974095106124878,
0.029906833544373512,
-0.0678706243634224,
-0.5411884188652039,
-0.8464111089706421,
0.06442046910524368,
-0.3536335229873657,
-0.8039566874504089,
-0.14520855247974396,
-0.06805947422981262,
0.4076913595199585,
0.48743340373039246,
-0.5563458204269409,
1.095973253250122,
0.009805150330066681,
0.009578597731888294,
-0.4122998118400574,
0.31707295775413513,
-0.2696317434310913,
-0.13029277324676514,
0.046990856528282166,
-0.12568603456020355,
0.5220573544502258,
-0.7445107102394104,
0.15581034123897552,
0.5818900465965271,
-0.815081000328064,
-0.09854117035865784,
0.4911988377571106,
0.20948587357997894,
-0.45310673117637634,
0.24816131591796875,
-0.45001956820487976,
-0.7930047512054443,
0.4690028727054596,
0.2150820940732956,
0.8196120262145996,
-0.3943385183811188,
0.5159509181976318,
0.07409517467021942,
0.6723479628562927,
0.056762274354696274,
0.626327633857727,
-0.01967868208885193,
-0.9136511087417603,
-0.08583679050207138,
-0.4870331883430481,
-0.07420115172863007,
0.2508329153060913,
-0.23260866105556488,
0.6312276124954224,
-0.6374770998954773,
-0.033787403255701065,
0.24143943190574646,
-0.13721632957458496,
-0.3562033772468567,
-0.0998135581612587,
-0.11220727115869522,
0.2311016470193863,
-1.082443356513977,
0.181285098195076,
0.41205736994743347,
-0.26997140049934387,
-0.6580685973167419,
-0.17263269424438477,
0.26699137687683105,
-0.8853674530982971,
0.327078640460968,
0.4315023422241211,
-0.14839313924312592,
-0.025578821077942848,
-0.9302089214324951,
-0.5304998159408569,
0.7576583623886108,
-0.07998800277709961,
0.26577919721603394,
0.08153698593378067,
0.33168742060661316,
0.3208334743976593,
-0.5567266941070557,
0.07811090350151062,
0.45655879378318787,
0.6913545727729797,
-0.2274473011493683,
-0.5558758974075317,
0.1592281013727188,
-0.13249599933624268,
-0.18678916990756989,
0.5848278999328613,
-0.3275226652622223,
0.4652268886566162,
0.19006073474884033,
-0.5361257791519165,
-0.6022012233734131,
-0.03671431168913841,
-0.10889125615358353,
0.44244059920310974,
0.5092755556106567,
0.19273176789283752,
0.031093044206500053,
-0.01112916599959135,
0.6846651434898376,
-0.1581708788871765,
-0.12106667459011078,
0.5467095375061035,
-0.02310284785926342,
0.47929856181144714,
0.432987242937088,
0.015613078139722347,
0.4585934579372406,
0.3147881329059601,
0.058946505188941956,
0.383958101272583,
-0.31869766116142273,
-0.3791694641113281,
-0.4123074412345886,
-0.7863234877586365,
0.07610864192247391,
0.8867831230163574,
0.9098854064941406,
-0.6832563877105713,
-0.2791437804698944,
-0.04283289611339569,
0.1572406142950058,
0.36382851004600525,
-0.7168834805488586,
0.7056004405021667,
-0.14210480451583862,
-0.8001229763031006,
0.016083156690001488,
0.1204221323132515,
0.5892529487609863,
-0.45650604367256165,
0.03675542771816254,
0.4242413341999054,
-0.08659172803163528,
-0.5695481300354004,
-0.8561676144599915,
0.3251197040081024,
-0.24981914460659027,
-0.0042211078107357025,
-0.5394871830940247,
1.2793234586715698,
-0.1846223622560501,
-0.19086551666259766,
0.33663618564605713,
0.3701525926589966,
0.15770214796066284,
-0.37139856815338135,
-0.5848321318626404,
0.6057837009429932,
-0.30168187618255615,
0.03424656018614769,
0.03693903982639313,
0.279155433177948,
-0.22936363518238068,
0.33596861362457275,
0.7610300183296204,
-0.05941321328282356,
0.1279798299074173,
-0.2449312061071396,
0.7914005517959595,
0.012950451113283634,
-0.5218875408172607,
-0.6093811392784119,
0.274206280708313,
-0.2091417908668518,
-0.0973379835486412,
0.32394707202911377,
0.33899906277656555,
0.872707188129425,
0.4881983995437622,
0.7527996897697449,
-0.5555254220962524,
0.223394513130188,
-0.0801306664943695,
0.6739580035209656,
-0.3270987272262573,
0.006715103983879089,
-0.23939663171768188,
-0.7615020275115967,
0.14172707498073578,
0.3573319911956787,
-0.6327048540115356,
0.27278682589530945,
0.354322612285614,
0.6944283843040466,
-0.25197306275367737,
0.35039669275283813,
0.23686666786670685,
-0.13154351711273193,
0.3253728151321411,
0.1559959053993225,
0.6149091124534607,
-0.5785548686981201,
0.4671987295150757,
-0.30793824791908264,
-0.371871680021286,
-0.48390743136405945,
-0.7022353410720825,
-0.7750284671783447,
-0.5925360918045044,
0.1613718867301941,
-0.06536979973316193,
0.0680733174085617,
0.8089853525161743,
0.41462936997413635,
-0.6635620594024658,
-0.12200623750686646,
-0.10210750252008438,
0.22545352578163147,
-0.13612385094165802,
-0.28184089064598083,
-0.04756911098957062,
-0.3043152689933777,
-0.5604332089424133,
0.13998788595199585,
0.5978278517723083,
-0.3059268891811371,
-0.5431737303733826,
-0.08329589664936066,
-0.4976237416267395,
0.2703135907649994,
0.9495514631271362,
0.3277515172958374,
-0.694424033164978,
-0.35431402921676636,
0.24825552105903625,
-0.37766799330711365,
0.007000212091952562,
1.1228216886520386,
-0.08523184806108475,
0.5267289876937866,
0.5935776233673096,
0.6195222735404968,
-0.18461215496063232,
0.3249499499797821,
0.4234645366668701,
-0.33646246790885925,
-0.28372639417648315,
0.44727838039398193,
0.14155152440071106,
0.3238787055015564,
-0.7102588415145874,
0.15593542158603668,
0.1417921930551529,
-0.6997337937355042,
-0.7735036611557007,
0.1495441198348999,
-0.7358323931694031,
-0.36717960238456726,
1.2231827974319458,
0.16974475979804993,
-0.3359609842300415,
-0.738633930683136,
-0.31736424565315247,
0.09035150706768036,
-0.49351224303245544,
0.9855157732963562,
0.6664215922355652,
-0.07411254197359085,
0.08928601443767548,
-0.984651505947113,
0.8034974932670593,
0.12342710793018341,
-0.6210268139839172,
0.2527879476547241,
0.5974050760269165,
0.08020159602165222,
0.14264650642871857,
0.9665402770042419,
-0.2682788670063019,
0.5160167217254639,
-0.3601299226284027,
-0.20645497739315033,
0.2522159814834595,
-0.4537191689014435,
-0.07528842240571976,
0.22685986757278442,
-0.08015306293964386,
0.13438713550567627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11029v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11029v1
|
Generative Artificial Intelligence: A Systematic Review and Applications
| 2024-05-17T18:03:59 | 2024-05-17T18:03:59 |
Sandeep Singh Sengar, Affan Bin Hasan, Sanjay Kumar, Fiona Carroll
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
In recent years, the study of artificial intelligence (AI) has undergone a
paradigm shift. This has been propelled by the groundbreaking capabilities of
generative models both in supervised and unsupervised learning scenarios.
Generative AI has shown state-of-the-art performance in solving perplexing
real-world conundrums in fields such as image translation, medical diagnostics,
textual imagery fusion, natural language processing, and beyond. This paper
documents the systematic review and analysis of recent advancements and
techniques in Generative AI with a detailed discussion of their applications
including application-specific models. Indeed, the major impact that generative
AI has made to date, has been in language generation with the development of
large language models, in the field of image translation and several other
interdisciplinary applications of generative AI. Moreover, the primary
contribution of this paper lies in its coherent synthesis of the latest
advancements in these areas, seamlessly weaving together contemporary
breakthroughs in the field. Particularly, how it shares an exploration of the
future trajectory for generative AI. In conclusion, the paper ends with a
discussion of Responsible AI principles, and the necessary ethical
considerations for the sustainability and growth of these generative models.
|
[
-0.20830248296260834,
-0.8797132968902588,
0.5730820298194885,
0.16247858107089996,
-0.0454116016626358,
0.15491937100887299,
-0.13627496361732483,
-0.5488581657409668,
-0.18323466181755066,
0.3581857979297638,
-0.3446054458618164,
-0.4353853762149811,
-0.6087010502815247,
0.3039340078830719,
-0.8311068415641785,
0.7105700373649597,
-0.0785374641418457,
0.34890466928482056,
-0.5387787222862244,
-0.2676054835319519,
-0.4457519054412842,
-0.34442251920700073,
-0.764837920665741,
-0.45180022716522217,
0.15396474301815033,
0.05598798394203186,
0.6368284821510315,
0.5032100081443787,
0.7752493023872375,
0.41352578997612,
0.11026576161384583,
0.11084874719381332,
0.00196372764185071,
0.193862184882164,
-0.10577374696731567,
-0.40902289748191833,
-0.31353825330734253,
0.002641626400873065,
0.6586122512817383,
0.7135531902313232,
-0.2712230980396271,
-0.07112234085798264,
-0.20184741914272308,
0.6129525899887085,
-0.4418521225452423,
0.2031668871641159,
-0.26544877886772156,
0.21825452148914337,
-0.28318682312965393,
0.07426174730062485,
-0.27845892310142517,
-0.37674903869628906,
0.0555892288684845,
-0.7412168979644775,
0.38080278038978577,
-0.24437125027179718,
0.4869902431964874,
0.5566001534461975,
-0.0649426281452179,
-0.3898399770259857,
-1.1376924514770508,
0.8514575958251953,
-0.5634471774101257,
0.24666672945022583,
-0.08777274936437607,
0.4455389082431793,
-0.16035138070583344,
-0.9485843777656555,
-0.7114085555076599,
-0.3723852336406708,
0.24826255440711975,
0.32415226101875305,
-0.3760372996330261,
0.19858120381832123,
0.08783581107854843,
0.6294488906860352,
-0.43542972207069397,
0.3405657708644867,
-0.4010348618030548,
-0.009004645049571991,
0.9038187861442566,
0.2751675546169281,
0.6134412884712219,
0.21888501942157745,
-0.082671158015728,
-0.12106586247682571,
-0.616604745388031,
-0.1841021627187729,
0.05781693011522293,
-0.07817842811346054,
-0.09764468669891357,
0.6443747878074646,
-0.3814101815223694,
0.6410821676254272,
-0.10300450026988983,
-0.10538150370121002,
0.19551873207092285,
-0.615563154220581,
-0.036181796342134476,
-0.20741766691207886,
0.9488052129745483,
0.20368237793445587,
0.2871173322200775,
-0.14551636576652527,
-0.14380203187465668,
0.40598323941230774,
0.4121505916118622,
-0.42529892921447754,
-0.11888773739337921,
0.3833993971347809,
-0.5759135484695435,
-0.4930655062198639,
-0.05557331070303917,
-0.5724278092384338,
-0.3701848089694977,
-0.34910085797309875,
-0.08430163562297821,
-0.4145069420337677,
-0.2918242812156677,
0.0781804770231247,
-0.17100001871585846,
0.47388896346092224,
0.4988836348056793,
-0.7046287655830383,
-0.022390808910131454,
0.7232323288917542,
0.5353312492370605,
-0.15564961731433868,
-0.29486051201820374,
0.0924394279718399,
0.09061958640813828,
-0.6418158411979675,
0.8709539175033569,
-0.46855834126472473,
-0.47513547539711,
0.2583655118942261,
-0.4767087697982788,
0.0555557943880558,
-0.694596529006958,
0.4872649013996124,
-0.4483506679534912,
0.09003353863954544,
0.18020078539848328,
-0.3273656666278839,
-0.32422035932540894,
0.17282874882221222,
-0.532218873500824,
0.43472176790237427,
0.07669536024332047,
-0.4139379560947418,
0.34985920786857605,
-1.0889869928359985,
-0.6522897481918335,
0.523173451423645,
-0.32037466764450073,
-0.538462221622467,
0.2627616822719574,
0.23626114428043365,
0.21326026320457458,
-0.5670343637466431,
0.5565441250801086,
0.007828805595636368,
-0.09915972501039505,
0.29571741819381714,
-0.3511239290237427,
0.9023689031600952,
0.41790449619293213,
-0.36558815836906433,
0.49611619114875793,
-0.473265677690506,
0.034536149352788925,
0.1470191925764084,
-0.0023809955455362797,
-0.1293870508670807,
0.33844009041786194,
0.10603728890419006,
0.041452955454587936,
0.21449555456638336,
-0.30791381001472473,
0.04078612104058266,
-0.22549711167812347,
0.7118365168571472,
0.5869621634483337,
0.0553022101521492,
0.5792319178581238,
-0.3528115749359131,
0.5295724272727966,
0.09894534200429916,
0.6231051087379456,
-0.21440312266349792,
-0.5537137389183044,
-0.718062162399292,
-0.27252769470214844,
0.421080619096756,
0.6213194727897644,
-0.869435727596283,
0.6109248995780945,
-0.22364801168441772,
-0.45754504203796387,
-0.8114708662033081,
-0.05875714495778084,
0.22970856726169586,
0.3664996027946472,
0.36490771174430847,
-0.4966661036014557,
-0.29967063665390015,
-0.9960371851921082,
-0.07108250260353088,
-0.48605799674987793,
-0.07224009186029434,
0.1993384063243866,
0.35310447216033936,
-0.7289130091667175,
0.7511159777641296,
-0.16197821497917175,
-0.19201725721359253,
-0.386950820684433,
0.31836745142936707,
-0.33346784114837646,
0.6573788523674011,
0.34677860140800476,
-0.9987013936042786,
-0.11535133421421051,
0.1847156435251236,
-1.309983730316162,
0.14094968140125275,
-0.5043492913246155,
-0.038798995316028595,
0.03385898098349571,
0.46640101075172424,
-0.7232314348220825,
0.41990160942077637,
0.18120160698890686,
0.02603565901517868,
0.3083580434322357,
-0.11335309594869614,
0.2730245888233185,
-0.8995152115821838,
0.16858187317848206,
0.0733352079987526,
0.0465458519756794,
-0.6479645371437073,
0.46979913115501404,
-0.18784624338150024,
-0.017127223312854767,
-0.04658051207661629,
0.30191919207572937,
-0.2999174892902374,
-0.047075528651475906,
-0.27830997109413147,
-0.18482348322868347,
-0.32161572575569153,
-0.138627827167511,
-0.013950533233582973,
0.636267900466919,
0.8848716020584106,
-0.5821971893310547,
0.6357962489128113,
0.4463627338409424,
-0.24247446656227112,
0.4219181537628174,
-0.5769625306129456,
0.09186182916164398,
-0.1839868277311325,
0.18966203927993774,
-0.45865005254745483,
-0.169983372092247,
0.36983203887939453,
-0.41639596223831177,
0.1280713826417923,
0.4159128963947296,
-0.590628981590271,
-0.4144885838031769,
-0.11270062625408173,
0.6944091320037842,
0.8292443156242371,
-0.24114125967025757,
0.590014636516571,
0.4119895100593567,
-0.30634862184524536,
-0.18205596506595612,
-0.5693202614784241,
0.3479612171649933,
-0.13489487767219543,
-0.46967199444770813,
0.5332865118980408,
-0.047824449837207794,
-0.6944449543952942,
0.10784823447465897,
0.3035043478012085,
0.07027682662010193,
0.269673228263855,
0.09044758975505829,
0.20197822153568268,
-0.12721629440784454,
-0.0888604149222374,
0.11140225827693939,
-0.17984697222709656,
0.1531136929988861,
-0.12482044845819473,
0.2489730566740036,
-0.06253217905759811,
-0.3479226529598236,
-0.46970170736312866,
0.640159010887146,
0.5720211267471313,
-0.4216115474700928,
0.43873390555381775,
0.4694691002368927,
-0.37890753149986267,
-0.08328153192996979,
-0.3544813096523285,
-0.06826208531856537,
-0.3702295124530792,
0.454249769449234,
0.13462616503238678,
-0.55733722448349,
0.3189373314380646,
-0.2842795252799988,
0.16563402116298676,
0.6346670389175415,
0.6310845613479614,
-0.29692789912223816,
1.0996376276016235,
0.8772163391113281,
-0.13486184179782867,
0.5864232182502747,
-0.32269084453582764,
0.5787293910980225,
-0.7707785964012146,
-0.3426172733306885,
-0.3739319145679474,
-0.08426815271377563,
-0.8355799317359924,
-0.18627554178237915,
0.6106725335121155,
-0.009328953921794891,
0.004467945545911789,
-0.18671445548534393,
-0.6751118898391724,
0.21583291888237,
0.6676008701324463,
-0.15309537947177887,
0.3588792085647583,
-0.1126064583659172,
0.23173807561397552,
0.32643023133277893,
-0.7710896730422974,
-0.5283510684967041,
0.9912561178207397,
0.16099871695041656,
0.5887935757637024,
-0.12216509133577347,
0.4918639361858368,
0.6607940196990967,
0.7291369438171387,
-0.6762839555740356,
0.5589736700057983,
-0.14835886657238007,
-0.4570969045162201,
-0.39340734481811523,
-0.27657076716423035,
-0.9770128130912781,
-0.0021277053747326136,
-0.17720073461532593,
-0.08091495931148529,
-0.03308601304888725,
0.12175365537405014,
-0.14917020499706268,
0.1592397540807724,
-0.43696221709251404,
0.6542353630065918,
-0.4858103394508362,
-0.12895430624485016,
-0.6163873672485352,
-0.6753171682357788,
0.46606212854385376,
0.08378729969263077,
-0.022573526948690414,
0.16425994038581848,
0.21425898373126984,
0.5398833155632019,
-0.01778879202902317,
0.7444822788238525,
-0.033375952392816544,
-0.08314979076385498,
0.41949647665023804,
-0.3870620131492615,
0.012268551625311375,
-0.0047882902435958385,
0.14838069677352905,
0.5582929849624634,
-0.3170167803764343,
-0.38671308755874634,
-0.4811885356903076,
0.4721936285495758,
-0.5729652047157288,
-0.7860760688781738,
-0.6371870636940002,
-0.5381737351417542,
-0.1309279203414917,
0.23686133325099945,
0.3581545650959015,
0.1612805724143982,
-0.5613204836845398,
-0.11481973528862,
0.5557281970977783,
-0.31003499031066895,
0.3059241771697998,
0.08410193026065826,
0.04287485033273697,
-0.30203840136528015,
0.9071981310844421,
-0.12496773898601532,
-0.0189055148512125,
0.24515174329280853,
-0.10150513797998428,
-0.2730007469654083,
-1.0392725467681885,
-0.704251229763031,
0.11008831113576889,
-0.6191527843475342,
-0.16777558624744415,
-0.28920096158981323,
-0.4125458598136902,
-0.4669688642024994,
-0.33356839418411255,
-0.1621761918067932,
-0.20488674938678741,
-0.3213035762310028,
0.13975471258163452,
0.17948348820209503,
0.9158939719200134,
0.120517298579216,
-0.1739659309387207,
-0.5031901001930237,
0.5430853366851807,
0.24439497292041779,
0.04726821929216385,
-0.042369294911623,
0.05609959363937378,
0.02062869817018509,
0.17982561886310577,
-0.5059062242507935,
-0.5007911920547485,
0.16944128274917603,
0.14951957762241364,
0.7915032505989075,
0.4454613924026489,
-0.0036310830619186163,
0.49431338906288147,
-0.4311883747577667,
0.9099949598312378,
0.26360437273979187,
-0.6691330075263977,
0.736685574054718,
-0.23442238569259644,
0.2535901963710785,
0.3782614469528198,
0.25593098998069763,
-0.4651656448841095,
-0.4207477569580078,
-0.5837774872779846,
-0.8914783000946045,
0.16315089166164398,
0.2933221161365509,
0.2396954596042633,
0.1256282925605774,
0.39888134598731995,
0.09918191283941269,
0.209242045879364,
-0.34358879923820496,
-0.21205462515354156,
-0.21943874657154083,
-0.4290980100631714,
-0.061232518404722214,
0.13137607276439667,
-0.28746846318244934,
-0.3476130962371826,
0.5594131350517273,
-0.1186022236943245,
0.4305455982685089,
0.07918062806129456,
-0.04362602159380913,
-0.022002240642905235,
0.26093894243240356,
0.48250964283943176,
0.547060489654541,
0.44810205698013306,
-0.26868051290512085,
-0.18931259214878082,
-0.35061880946159363,
0.11764977872371674,
0.36339741945266724,
-0.7302039861679077,
-0.18539690971374512,
0.5596559643745422,
0.4932284951210022,
-0.245570108294487,
-0.8749634623527527,
0.2731409966945648,
-0.019020525738596916,
-0.1917378455400467,
-0.6152075529098511,
0.17433328926563263,
-0.3006427586078644,
0.2676682770252228,
0.2784017324447632,
0.44976863265037537,
0.47831276059150696,
-0.6274334788322449,
-0.11838752031326294,
0.6360697746276855,
-0.055174749344587326,
-0.310414582490921,
0.6199248433113098,
0.41306638717651367,
-0.24066846072673798,
1.069270133972168,
-0.0642976462841034,
-0.2577797472476959,
0.6667584776878357,
0.4183734357357025,
1.0745972394943237,
-0.17966057360172272,
0.35427939891815186,
0.07018562406301498,
0.14449502527713776,
-0.05616619065403938,
0.10080420970916748,
-0.3533695638179779,
-0.9001695513725281,
-0.05794065073132515,
-0.45341625809669495,
-0.4791889786720276,
0.08265570551156998,
-0.5485396981239319,
-0.17632487416267395,
-0.3240959346294403,
-0.13006936013698578,
0.2473377138376236,
-0.3213459551334381,
-0.39885544776916504,
0.13733069598674774,
0.061062656342983246,
0.6357221603393555,
-0.6109434962272644,
0.5348505973815918,
0.8948489427566528,
-0.49656474590301514,
-0.03209065645933151,
0.18745160102844238,
-0.1473930925130844,
-0.5865783095359802,
0.2600765824317932,
-0.06689051538705826,
-0.14702412486076355,
0.08667438477277756,
-0.7926662564277649,
-0.5040209293365479,
1.0179616212844849,
0.11569563299417496,
-0.14975395798683167,
-0.021458998322486877,
0.1675533801317215,
0.8330262303352356,
-0.3178426921367645,
-0.0914686843752861,
0.48951396346092224,
0.41069960594177246,
-0.04129216820001602,
-0.5972791314125061,
-0.24571780860424042,
-0.5977133512496948,
0.3571423590183258,
0.04099249094724655,
-0.6042786836624146,
0.614228367805481,
-0.3027782440185547,
-0.3911498785018921,
0.5579614639282227,
0.7505621314048767,
0.26095420122146606,
0.45398327708244324,
0.1266847401857376,
0.4178633689880371,
0.4325368106365204,
-0.23014262318611145,
1.254306674003601,
-0.22384683787822723,
-0.09644360840320587,
0.30179721117019653,
-0.41858041286468506,
0.4613116681575775,
0.290950745344162,
-0.07199585437774658,
0.4316701889038086,
0.5568113327026367,
-0.18810833990573883,
0.534186840057373,
0.14856436848640442,
-0.5268138647079468,
-0.11736880987882614,
-0.38462188839912415,
-0.296195924282074,
0.41932639479637146,
0.49243009090423584,
-0.49283215403556824,
-0.05816514417529106,
0.27214163541793823,
-0.4491300582885742,
0.2990778982639313,
-0.44084954261779785,
0.981634795665741,
-0.002883604494854808,
-0.8760074973106384,
0.2819046378135681,
0.2934349477291107,
0.5750725865364075,
-0.36199742555618286,
-0.5297185778617859,
-0.12157749384641647,
0.20221729576587677,
0.01324915885925293,
-0.6390351057052612,
0.38709476590156555,
0.14178282022476196,
-0.18348829448223114,
-0.5424850583076477,
0.5940447449684143,
-0.08856190741062164,
-0.6403388381004333,
-0.0036552147939801216,
0.5783506631851196,
-0.05717417970299721,
0.2833055555820465,
-0.8343814611434937,
0.015547149814665318,
-0.17352311313152313,
0.30623018741607666,
0.007701505441218615,
0.16848626732826233,
-0.4541594982147217,
0.724608838558197,
0.7002565860748291,
0.05428609251976013,
-0.00941639207303524,
0.11422241479158401,
0.7519569993019104,
-0.6853718161582947,
-0.35879436135292053,
-0.5285074710845947,
0.3754090368747711,
0.024682389572262764,
-0.440219521522522,
0.4412958025932312,
0.3955632746219635,
0.9762313961982727,
-0.08419771492481232,
1.148659348487854,
-0.2856312394142151,
-0.101455457508564,
-0.5833672881126404,
0.7035971283912659,
-0.33485743403434753,
-0.055513784289360046,
-0.07470756024122238,
-0.5160165429115295,
-0.6128228902816772,
0.7273852229118347,
-0.2981765568256378,
0.32440081238746643,
0.27645912766456604,
0.4318673610687256,
0.3144153952598572,
0.17660632729530334,
0.2871873378753662,
0.09338388592004776,
0.28264960646629333,
0.09209135174751282,
1.0141905546188354,
-0.38337695598602295,
-0.13017570972442627,
-0.19161280989646912,
-0.27754244208335876,
-0.16914743185043335,
-0.3993152379989624,
-0.45903193950653076,
-0.8753430843353271,
-0.5745143890380859,
0.13955309987068176,
0.15843422710895538,
0.4040782153606415,
0.6605220437049866,
-0.8707987666130066,
-0.08717939257621765,
-0.7339285612106323,
0.05015973746776581,
-0.6677254438400269,
-0.21588827669620514,
0.1279553472995758,
-0.3364373743534088,
-0.8040046691894531,
0.3783726096153259,
0.4131370782852173,
0.20470590889453888,
-0.5248415470123291,
-0.07542583346366882,
-0.024191254749894142,
-0.028886200860142708,
0.7003169655799866,
0.5245168805122375,
-0.948495090007782,
0.04985186830163002,
-0.14895367622375488,
-0.10124608129262924,
-0.014945518225431442,
0.8642802834510803,
-0.7120279669761658,
0.4122116267681122,
0.41826432943344116,
0.7629565000534058,
0.10367550700902939,
0.18289078772068024,
0.7534977793693542,
-0.15944577753543854,
-0.044677481055259705,
0.7443366050720215,
0.19960364699363708,
0.5766441226005554,
-0.46259361505508423,
0.5646455883979797,
0.23473383486270905,
-0.396787166595459,
-0.7446136474609375,
0.44644638895988464,
-0.7444180250167847,
-0.26369157433509827,
0.622308075428009,
0.06375770270824432,
-0.04209507629275322,
-0.13585753738880157,
0.05235004052519798,
0.3653745651245117,
-0.14692921936511993,
1.1753262281417847,
0.3645215630531311,
-0.5787346959114075,
-0.28853529691696167,
-0.447022944688797,
0.3915610611438751,
0.45557501912117004,
-1.1558572053909302,
-0.21245168149471283,
0.5898630619049072,
-0.2623307704925537,
0.34784746170043945,
0.43178802728652954,
-0.45121103525161743,
0.4695752263069153,
0.06134562939405441,
0.23843365907669067,
0.1710810512304306,
-0.4336930215358734,
-0.5303314924240112,
-0.020461905747652054,
0.2204509973526001,
-0.2389983981847763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10938v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10938v2
|
Observational Scaling Laws and the Predictability of Language Model Performance
| 2024-05-17T17:49:44 | 2024-07-02T14:16:42 |
Yangjun Ruan, Chris J. Maddison, Tatsunori Hashimoto
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Understanding how language model performance varies with scale is critical to
benchmark and algorithm development. Scaling laws are one approach to building
this understanding, but the requirement of training models across many
different scales has limited their use. We propose an alternative,
observational approach that bypasses model training and instead builds scaling
laws from ~80 publically available models. Building a single scaling law from
multiple model families is challenging due to large variations in their
training compute efficiencies and capabilities. However, we show that these
variations are consistent with a simple, generalized scaling law where language
model performance is a function of a low-dimensional capability space, and
model families only vary in their efficiency in converting training compute to
capabilities. Using this approach, we show the surprising predictability of
complex scaling phenomena: we show that several emergent phenomena follow a
smooth, sigmoidal behavior and are predictable from small models; we show that
the agent performance of models such as GPT-4 can be precisely predicted from
simpler non-agentic benchmarks; and we show how to predict the impact of
post-training interventions like Chain-of-Thought and Self-Consistency as
language model capabilities continue to improve.
|
[
-0.16357067227363586,
-0.5383171439170837,
0.7660804390907288,
0.18288454413414001,
0.2553476095199585,
-0.09539685398340225,
-0.3215407431125641,
-0.636393666267395,
0.09292827546596527,
0.5801896452903748,
-0.3874266743659973,
0.1732887476682663,
-0.7596182227134705,
-0.17379750311374664,
-0.22682741284370422,
0.8441709280014038,
-0.020681696012616158,
0.20053939521312714,
-0.048682644963264465,
-0.12335763871669769,
0.07340395450592041,
-0.4688592255115509,
-0.48876455426216125,
-0.5354499220848083,
0.19114574790000916,
0.21573805809020996,
0.7814769744873047,
1.1503809690475464,
0.5600343346595764,
0.2642521262168884,
-0.01688622683286667,
-0.19761934876441956,
-0.5088863372802734,
-0.13177131116390228,
0.0025447802618145943,
-0.6482114195823669,
-0.45159149169921875,
0.12884719669818878,
0.8459780216217041,
0.8136339783668518,
-0.4030979573726654,
-0.03444744646549225,
0.1773887723684311,
0.4848480820655823,
-0.2587902247905731,
0.5003666877746582,
-0.6401782035827637,
-0.19712558388710022,
-0.024702733382582664,
-0.053411953151226044,
-0.44711875915527344,
-0.31939923763275146,
0.08608992397785187,
-0.6275866031646729,
0.27144289016723633,
0.10609947890043259,
0.5334764719009399,
0.141398623585701,
-0.3642435073852539,
-0.3559721112251282,
-0.8799083232879639,
0.7354686856269836,
-0.9476085305213928,
0.3364705443382263,
0.4358465075492859,
0.5119541883468628,
-0.12685859203338623,
-0.7949547171592712,
-0.371071457862854,
-0.5975359082221985,
0.019530272111296654,
-0.23694700002670288,
-0.2596108317375183,
0.11052291840314865,
0.35231804847717285,
0.18211796879768372,
-0.43808695673942566,
0.18173497915267944,
-0.24134869873523712,
-0.004321668297052383,
0.45018017292022705,
0.27023616433143616,
0.2741384208202362,
0.287336140871048,
0.08762458711862564,
-0.09490060806274414,
-0.7110702991485596,
0.10465016961097717,
0.3805876672267914,
0.701716959476471,
-0.27825507521629333,
0.4084380269050598,
-0.25913822650909424,
0.32397252321243286,
0.0812060534954071,
-0.2711693346500397,
0.2664991617202759,
-0.27460432052612305,
0.044512566179037094,
-0.07162972539663315,
0.585837185382843,
0.07482708245515823,
0.35272273421287537,
-0.22717256844043732,
-0.1731441617012024,
-0.11646728217601776,
0.1945957988500595,
-1.0375096797943115,
-0.31816115975379944,
-0.1794825792312622,
-0.2730410099029541,
-0.3786385953426361,
-0.2560136914253235,
-0.553479790687561,
-0.511979341506958,
-0.27908867597579956,
0.4244652986526489,
-0.19939571619033813,
-0.6097357869148254,
-0.05532630905508995,
0.2603142559528351,
0.11400125175714493,
0.2531212866306305,
-1.3523260354995728,
0.6048198938369751,
0.7988860011100769,
0.8565893769264221,
0.35854634642601013,
-0.6168553233146667,
-0.480143278837204,
-0.11997795850038528,
-0.5761728286743164,
0.3600040674209595,
-0.6004652380943298,
-0.11541114002466202,
-0.013427685014903545,
-0.10031962394714355,
-0.1944650113582611,
-0.5177615880966187,
0.10490664839744568,
-0.3562779128551483,
-0.42266660928726196,
-0.055466581135988235,
-0.6485568881034851,
0.05907320976257324,
0.05994819104671478,
-0.6243419051170349,
0.5942016839981079,
0.11573861539363861,
-0.49750789999961853,
0.565025269985199,
-0.5332215428352356,
-0.43807440996170044,
0.027531104162335396,
-0.21676133573055267,
-0.5681178569793701,
0.38148438930511475,
-0.039360541850328445,
0.3169267177581787,
-0.34767937660217285,
0.13399484753608704,
-0.6233603358268738,
-0.20874476432800293,
-0.12849649786949158,
-0.39055725932121277,
0.45742201805114746,
0.253730446100235,
-0.45454132556915283,
0.02642483450472355,
-0.9464057683944702,
0.2641012370586395,
0.11870501190423965,
-0.38627034425735474,
-0.15046223998069763,
0.335479199886322,
-0.2380061149597168,
0.053693726658821106,
0.18433989584445953,
-0.4273134469985962,
0.1939476877450943,
-0.2521716058254242,
0.46264079213142395,
0.6678627729415894,
0.006133232265710831,
0.6352716684341431,
0.0042683943174779415,
0.646382212638855,
-0.17636971175670624,
0.15674741566181183,
-0.017614107578992844,
-0.39918243885040283,
-0.41315948963165283,
-0.1795176863670349,
0.10437355935573578,
0.10780290514230728,
-0.4414674937725067,
-0.18685011565685272,
-0.4965229034423828,
-0.7133943438529968,
-0.3392641544342041,
0.1042419895529747,
0.43652305006980896,
0.2361951619386673,
0.1285833716392517,
-0.13024231791496277,
-0.5174640417098999,
-0.8384057879447937,
-0.6191176772117615,
-0.33761513233184814,
-0.04605194553732872,
0.36271926760673523,
0.464981347322464,
-0.053415197879076004,
0.6967555284500122,
-0.4363548755645752,
0.18933135271072388,
-0.38746458292007446,
0.4243089556694031,
0.2805173099040985,
0.5200943946838379,
0.6233514547348022,
-0.5577656030654907,
-0.5148717164993286,
0.5092117786407471,
-0.5984223484992981,
0.0069093662314116955,
0.1754678338766098,
0.4942951500415802,
-0.06563188135623932,
0.7403249740600586,
-0.12123745679855347,
0.1561470329761505,
0.6831992864608765,
-0.3172822594642639,
0.7095195055007935,
-0.6310377717018127,
-0.12415231764316559,
-0.7709428668022156,
-0.24661774933338165,
0.13043034076690674,
-0.24825075268745422,
-1.0447007417678833,
0.2030833214521408,
0.31284672021865845,
0.17135506868362427,
-0.23182396590709686,
0.38158276677131653,
-0.40013185143470764,
-0.3557168245315552,
-0.39099588990211487,
-0.47424980998039246,
-0.4528590440750122,
0.4328339993953705,
0.03339453414082527,
0.7984057664871216,
0.7004019618034363,
-0.5511171817779541,
-0.11568496376276016,
-0.3881114423274994,
-0.4042368531227112,
0.2606077492237091,
-0.780989944934845,
-0.1790352463722229,
0.10615890473127365,
-0.12086491286754608,
-0.5983661413192749,
-0.3215878903865814,
-0.3402373790740967,
-0.3190756142139435,
0.3306628465652466,
-0.30194419622421265,
-0.5546010136604309,
-0.11325246840715408,
0.044153060764074326,
0.28993189334869385,
0.5196018218994141,
-0.6013994216918945,
0.7414534091949463,
0.22271104156970978,
0.02688520774245262,
-0.33856871724128723,
-0.4585631191730499,
-0.17310023307800293,
-0.20565874874591827,
-0.3211687207221985,
-0.2411130666732788,
-0.20858989655971527,
-0.43347325921058655,
-0.2138880044221878,
-0.05298635736107826,
-0.18699738383293152,
0.3333253264427185,
0.3141895830631256,
-0.08141440153121948,
-0.5400792956352234,
-0.030426062643527985,
-0.22773988544940948,
0.2748910188674927,
0.34740468859672546,
-0.43416908383369446,
0.5217516422271729,
-0.7335842847824097,
-0.20808355510234833,
-0.18116767704486847,
-0.14789947867393494,
0.8026348352432251,
-0.09317343682050705,
0.8065019845962524,
0.2599714994430542,
-0.3808384835720062,
-0.1023620143532753,
-0.3363271653652191,
-0.20591716468334198,
-0.44248828291893005,
0.5641797780990601,
-0.6083766222000122,
-0.6154209971427917,
0.7082292437553406,
-0.14302057027816772,
-0.09610316902399063,
0.3922772705554962,
0.5898331999778748,
0.1970767080783844,
1.2028008699417114,
0.971757709980011,
-0.016028793528676033,
0.6224647760391235,
-0.13344697654247284,
0.07834675163030624,
-0.603148341178894,
0.10727088153362274,
-0.5258066654205322,
0.025302575901150703,
-1.2357431650161743,
-0.3027908504009247,
0.31635576486587524,
-0.02298586629331112,
-0.3243861496448517,
0.45187288522720337,
0.021868061274290085,
0.6709550619125366,
0.4470784664154053,
-0.002376530785113573,
0.36657610535621643,
-0.06152170151472092,
-0.10517798364162445,
0.05672377347946167,
-0.5493226647377014,
-0.43867865204811096,
1.3380389213562012,
0.37652790546417236,
0.8756330013275146,
0.18329910933971405,
0.6281735897064209,
0.1278194785118103,
0.6473142504692078,
-0.6141151189804077,
0.2900558114051819,
0.06845690310001373,
-0.6156325340270996,
-0.6509054899215698,
-0.7450566291809082,
-0.842552125453949,
0.5168967247009277,
0.0029023955576121807,
-0.9405422210693359,
0.14379334449768066,
0.12606562674045563,
-0.05048542842268944,
0.5232858657836914,
-0.806167483329773,
0.7061320543289185,
0.05133073031902313,
-0.22630789875984192,
-0.3288237154483795,
-0.6493618488311768,
0.007802493870258331,
-0.30935490131378174,
0.42595160007476807,
-0.04270419478416443,
0.024595757946372032,
0.4816579222679138,
-0.6837716102600098,
0.8937568664550781,
-0.14525966346263885,
0.03935979679226875,
0.2502097189426422,
0.2765871286392212,
0.6274313926696777,
-0.13830013573169708,
0.05106465518474579,
-0.004545335192233324,
-0.005279568023979664,
-0.5243126749992371,
-0.6549006104469299,
0.5793433785438538,
-1.0863240957260132,
-0.5057337880134583,
-0.15729941427707672,
-0.6328344941139221,
-0.32198241353034973,
0.4349033236503601,
0.2758220434188843,
0.46684765815734863,
-0.2688327133655548,
0.09262537956237793,
0.5377920269966125,
0.45684364438056946,
0.4446602463722229,
0.7026451230049133,
-0.2645711600780487,
-0.04170283302664757,
1.005650281906128,
0.39966726303100586,
0.5954070687294006,
0.33894607424736023,
0.5843126773834229,
-0.10038147866725922,
-0.711831271648407,
-0.16359218955039978,
0.17920690774917603,
-0.4823617935180664,
0.34310218691825867,
-0.46985235810279846,
-0.13837537169456482,
-0.46121761202812195,
-0.1415596455335617,
-0.6311275959014893,
-0.44070887565612793,
0.03986334428191185,
-0.12214331328868866,
0.05042967572808266,
1.1451261043548584,
-0.3392859995365143,
0.2858382761478424,
-0.27938076853752136,
-0.17289529740810394,
0.38146623969078064,
0.5896599888801575,
0.15220491588115692,
-0.6743219494819641,
-0.5011256337165833,
-0.058304496109485626,
-0.1697232723236084,
-0.427216112613678,
0.30751535296440125,
0.24513767659664154,
0.500938892364502,
0.5340149998664856,
-0.2665248215198517,
0.399758905172348,
-0.7189103364944458,
0.36087608337402344,
0.3467000126838684,
-0.9050541520118713,
0.4217960238456726,
-0.5562400817871094,
0.23755376040935516,
0.23271724581718445,
0.16581709682941437,
-0.24128901958465576,
-0.6352716684341431,
-0.9082642793655396,
-0.5359824299812317,
0.7606489658355713,
0.19427728652954102,
0.20074251294136047,
0.3330494463443756,
0.5358811020851135,
0.1920543760061264,
0.27384111285209656,
-0.7720786929130554,
-0.007038653362542391,
-0.2752572000026703,
0.03566444665193558,
-0.5449737310409546,
-0.11754316091537476,
0.11756136268377304,
-0.17042973637580872,
0.4410139322280884,
-0.2546912431716919,
-0.03632061928510666,
-0.1414724439382553,
0.12443377822637558,
-0.31343770027160645,
0.19963505864143372,
0.8003970384597778,
0.8942999839782715,
-0.33393171429634094,
0.09502345323562622,
0.05994471162557602,
-0.7267013192176819,
0.24904099106788635,
-0.0298150647431612,
-0.07719617336988449,
-0.347059965133667,
0.5462136268615723,
0.8197776675224304,
0.1760655641555786,
-0.5453395247459412,
0.31983837485313416,
-0.06294447183609009,
-0.44210341572761536,
-0.414950966835022,
0.11460660398006439,
0.15296083688735962,
0.49171024560928345,
0.12327427417039871,
0.12998250126838684,
0.06384971737861633,
-0.6358919739723206,
0.1527824103832245,
0.198140949010849,
-0.5618399381637573,
-0.6281368136405945,
0.8533743619918823,
-0.19451799988746643,
-0.27145177125930786,
0.4302217364311218,
-0.2132708728313446,
-0.21178381145000458,
0.9115303754806519,
0.5360426902770996,
0.6410202980041504,
-0.4223402738571167,
0.0679386630654335,
0.4080335199832916,
0.6493710875511169,
-0.4244576096534729,
-0.037425681948661804,
0.1678147166967392,
-0.8743702173233032,
-0.27174273133277893,
-0.2757419943809509,
-0.5311500430107117,
0.14074642956256866,
-0.84732985496521,
-0.07590333372354507,
-0.7499842047691345,
-0.05500590801239014,
0.24469485878944397,
0.13550858199596405,
-0.6249871253967285,
0.1999189555644989,
0.018694033846259117,
0.6572842001914978,
-1.0215924978256226,
0.8598312735557556,
0.5216065049171448,
-0.35055866837501526,
-1.0112807750701904,
0.17029552161693573,
0.18205200135707855,
-0.9305884838104248,
0.30879348516464233,
0.03603166714310646,
-0.19388222694396973,
-0.028049254789948463,
-0.4669462740421295,
-0.992826521396637,
0.932345986366272,
0.559844434261322,
-0.3344166874885559,
0.05094173923134804,
0.08887200802564621,
0.9382686018943787,
-0.632999062538147,
0.3710620701313019,
0.7682384848594666,
0.23622958362102509,
0.08401602506637573,
-1.0516197681427002,
0.009827203117311,
-0.06993433833122253,
0.13536673784255981,
0.28983327746391296,
-0.5866081118583679,
1.063882827758789,
-0.625683069229126,
0.024146415293216705,
0.014278310351073742,
0.6650823354721069,
0.004342968575656414,
0.300149530172348,
0.3929804563522339,
0.429254412651062,
0.796053946018219,
0.05151047185063362,
1.404946208000183,
-0.33811303973197937,
0.6165594458580017,
1.2883024215698242,
-0.2992824614048004,
0.8913604021072388,
0.41362932324409485,
-0.35522517561912537,
0.40662682056427,
0.43816983699798584,
0.05725739151239395,
0.550990104675293,
0.3013812005519867,
-0.06157319247722626,
-0.18571725487709045,
0.035888150334358215,
-0.11352421343326569,
0.42603257298469543,
0.16707710921764374,
-0.3738270699977875,
-0.0901387631893158,
-0.08089358359575272,
0.20309098064899445,
0.15425370633602142,
-0.5501433610916138,
0.6044487953186035,
-0.16415846347808838,
-0.45061928033828735,
0.6097182035446167,
-0.22597259283065796,
0.31813380122184753,
-0.6055519580841064,
0.16984300315380096,
-0.0218560378998518,
0.3854897916316986,
0.0621209517121315,
-0.5745659470558167,
-0.01752740517258644,
-0.3465535640716553,
-0.3072013556957245,
-0.13993558287620544,
0.263116717338562,
-0.220118910074234,
-0.5683965682983398,
0.2892425060272217,
0.6749924421310425,
0.32296252250671387,
0.09098503738641739,
-0.25680655241012573,
-0.2613147497177124,
0.026979006826877594,
-0.4768689274787903,
0.6916919946670532,
0.4171469211578369,
-0.02235645428299904,
0.8617318868637085,
0.2871820330619812,
0.3749415874481201,
0.35627472400665283,
0.021775217726826668,
0.6358981728553772,
-0.3161553144454956,
-0.5764578580856323,
-0.7609720826148987,
-0.05940406024456024,
0.03216072544455528,
-0.1226448267698288,
0.5937640070915222,
0.4462219774723053,
0.7521219253540039,
-0.019365305081009865,
0.7532944679260254,
0.09059087187051773,
0.3372516334056854,
-0.26033660769462585,
0.6012426614761353,
-0.5051923990249634,
0.16910111904144287,
0.004494804423302412,
-0.6264601945877075,
-0.07485798746347427,
0.18295302987098694,
-0.546951949596405,
0.20169658958911896,
0.6796373724937439,
0.7462068200111389,
-0.08591636270284653,
0.1384187936782837,
0.6197722554206848,
0.4672476351261139,
0.5435155630111694,
0.20884969830513,
0.325462281703949,
-0.047005534172058105,
0.5296750664710999,
-0.2002091109752655,
-0.4360121190547943,
-0.2959711253643036,
-0.6924821734428406,
-0.6447025537490845,
-0.6434766054153442,
-0.22974765300750732,
-0.2509616017341614,
-0.17535753548145294,
0.6457204818725586,
0.8817108273506165,
-0.7184619307518005,
-0.5509002208709717,
-0.45483338832855225,
-0.056087713688611984,
-0.6950762867927551,
-0.18640899658203125,
0.19758687913417816,
-0.4893700182437897,
-0.6473879814147949,
0.34276947379112244,
-0.013797303661704063,
0.28199636936187744,
-0.2347588986158371,
-0.20619966089725494,
0.16512656211853027,
0.3895421326160431,
0.42324596643447876,
0.6242871880531311,
-0.6636182069778442,
-0.15387699007987976,
-0.44576025009155273,
-0.21090632677078247,
0.15111909806728363,
1.0009703636169434,
-0.2884978950023651,
0.6224369406700134,
0.22544227540493011,
0.4948034882545471,
0.741230309009552,
-0.44401222467422485,
0.6715167760848999,
-0.6128313541412354,
0.0597967803478241,
0.02983846329152584,
0.5135255455970764,
0.05151199549436569,
-0.3847472667694092,
0.7148329615592957,
0.05825808644294739,
-0.6519407033920288,
-0.7624156475067139,
0.4028196334838867,
-0.45131716132164,
-0.13793635368347168,
0.8814375400543213,
-0.3882805407047272,
-0.1860811710357666,
0.12305557727813721,
0.2801019847393036,
-0.06395742297172546,
-0.2936643660068512,
0.7096662521362305,
0.833264172077179,
-0.49332666397094727,
-0.27114588022232056,
-0.9825213551521301,
0.40039095282554626,
0.2578277587890625,
-0.6413242220878601,
0.33846554160118103,
0.11760126054286957,
0.5257142782211304,
0.20476658642292023,
0.5858994722366333,
-0.11752690374851227,
0.12828245759010315,
0.46285977959632874,
0.050493836402893066,
0.1562589555978775,
-0.3001704812049866,
-0.5048241019248962,
0.18707193434238434,
0.5036113262176514,
0.21061493456363678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10936v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10936v1
|
A Survey on Large Language Models with Multilingualism: Recent Advances and New Frontiers
| 2024-05-17T17:47:39 | 2024-05-17T17:47:39 |
Kaiyu Huang, Fengran Mo, Hongliang Li, You Li, Yuanchi Zhang, Weijian Yi, Yulong Mao, Jinchen Liu, Yuzhuang Xu, Jinan Xu, Jian-Yun Nie, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid development of Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrates remarkable
multilingual capabilities in natural language processing, attracting global
attention in both academia and industry. To mitigate potential discrimination
and enhance the overall usability and accessibility for diverse language user
groups, it is important for the development of language-fair technology.
Despite the breakthroughs of LLMs, the investigation into the multilingual
scenario remains insufficient, where a comprehensive survey to summarize recent
approaches, developments, limitations, and potential solutions is desirable. To
this end, we provide a survey with multiple perspectives on the utilization of
LLMs in the multilingual scenario. We first rethink the transitions between
previous and current research on pre-trained language models. Then we introduce
several perspectives on the multilingualism of LLMs, including training and
inference methods, model security, multi-domain with language culture, and
usage of datasets. We also discuss the major challenges that arise in these
aspects, along with possible solutions. Besides, we highlight future research
directions that aim at further enhancing LLMs with multilingualism. The survey
aims to help the research community address multilingual problems and provide a
comprehensive understanding of the core concepts, key techniques, and latest
developments in multilingual natural language processing based on LLMs.
|
[
-0.6411457061767578,
-0.6905112266540527,
0.565310001373291,
0.22707735002040863,
0.06892471015453339,
0.25454649329185486,
-0.5582702159881592,
-0.6995405554771423,
0.23051978647708893,
0.43801194429397583,
-0.4210678040981293,
-0.34930214285850525,
-0.7901217937469482,
0.38639628887176514,
-0.172713965177536,
0.5825560688972473,
-0.009600347839295864,
0.4622238576412201,
-0.0682932510972023,
-0.2040962278842926,
-0.2770894467830658,
-0.9884849786758423,
-0.4381846487522125,
-0.3389318287372589,
0.5950315594673157,
0.1988655924797058,
0.4365253448486328,
0.12117283791303635,
0.3556244373321533,
0.3774363696575165,
-0.3317197561264038,
-0.0031970557756721973,
-0.1930132657289505,
0.19680027663707733,
0.0006699935183860362,
-0.5578981637954712,
-0.6063166856765747,
0.11304022371768951,
0.9738767147064209,
0.9522825479507446,
-0.20474879443645477,
0.1266702562570572,
0.06538890302181244,
0.3639097213745117,
-0.5341971516609192,
0.07485563308000565,
-0.5787708759307861,
0.2053520530462265,
-0.5378563404083252,
0.0869351178407669,
-0.3949950635433197,
-0.18291500210762024,
-0.027125949040055275,
-0.235280379652977,
-0.016588566824793816,
-0.03136543557047844,
0.1776534616947174,
-0.38128846883773804,
-0.8353492617607117,
-0.2950989603996277,
-0.6657499670982361,
1.0695501565933228,
-0.7117371559143066,
0.923700213432312,
0.24522560834884644,
0.4897110164165497,
-0.06291396170854568,
-0.5972999334335327,
-0.46305352449417114,
-0.13931187987327576,
0.25187015533447266,
-0.23575057089328766,
0.04761230945587158,
-0.3106532394886017,
0.08925923705101013,
0.32439345121383667,
-0.5205692052841187,
0.7181472778320312,
-0.03306916356086731,
-0.34730949997901917,
0.4793466031551361,
0.1646200567483902,
0.16179755330085754,
0.07548616826534271,
-0.19657652080059052,
0.1272994577884674,
-0.9302718043327332,
0.03303385153412819,
0.45884573459625244,
0.47872793674468994,
-0.1312071979045868,
0.3156646490097046,
-0.22812595963478088,
0.7519906759262085,
-0.6750513911247253,
-0.3544814884662628,
0.5088050961494446,
-0.5344929695129395,
-0.01774253137409687,
-0.4129837453365326,
0.6643972396850586,
0.2116239219903946,
0.28988099098205566,
-0.059513743966817856,
-0.15350832045078278,
-0.27607646584510803,
-0.31635600328445435,
-0.8333027362823486,
0.3602510690689087,
0.035654596984386444,
-0.5054751634597778,
0.11692272126674652,
-0.2331169843673706,
-1.0316197872161865,
-0.4987563192844391,
-0.42970532178878784,
-0.36015331745147705,
0.07158654928207397,
-0.7506664395332336,
0.2632805109024048,
0.28110113739967346,
0.16498267650604248,
0.5252421498298645,
-0.8545538187026978,
0.08310550451278687,
0.677242636680603,
0.721855103969574,
-0.13126252591609955,
-0.636128306388855,
-0.24122054874897003,
0.016408367082476616,
-0.19632269442081451,
0.7271831035614014,
-0.5313940644264221,
-0.39815497398376465,
0.4695238471031189,
0.167416051030159,
0.028585005551576614,
-0.4013565480709076,
0.29645442962646484,
-0.6766144037246704,
0.1481991708278656,
-0.33502525091171265,
-0.29418110847473145,
-0.16286858916282654,
0.7640649080276489,
-0.7349268198013306,
0.5195556879043579,
-0.4672909677028656,
-0.6874752044677734,
0.2705731689929962,
-0.5492556095123291,
-0.35138821601867676,
0.03714512288570404,
-0.2200184315443039,
-0.14630171656608582,
0.19608163833618164,
0.11248208582401276,
0.5640855431556702,
-0.4830898940563202,
0.5003789067268372,
-0.532680332660675,
0.02737458236515522,
0.51323002576828,
-0.6718069911003113,
0.8282716870307922,
0.4165927767753601,
0.08038300275802612,
0.06531588733196259,
-0.6051540970802307,
-0.027896994724869728,
0.2638821005821228,
-0.3341538906097412,
-0.13084322214126587,
-0.017614644020795822,
0.2741292715072632,
0.43901121616363525,
0.4492616057395935,
-0.5936830639839172,
0.20779241621494293,
-0.17803911864757538,
0.38468214869499207,
0.6323752403259277,
-0.30260956287384033,
0.4742313325405121,
-0.006422267761081457,
0.6566647291183472,
-0.16753309965133667,
0.2378300279378891,
-0.2678390443325043,
-0.4707048535346985,
-0.3334016799926758,
-0.13396097719669342,
0.3199739456176758,
0.492625892162323,
-0.607491135597229,
-0.20097114145755768,
-0.150078684091568,
-0.2909911274909973,
-0.2800358235836029,
0.32363274693489075,
0.17974813282489777,
-0.05223756283521652,
0.09988655894994736,
-0.01810571551322937,
-0.5038388967514038,
-0.9581429362297058,
-0.3343870937824249,
0.051700398325920105,
0.2128935307264328,
0.2029029279947281,
0.45112401247024536,
-0.31901752948760986,
0.5952565670013428,
-0.3611797094345093,
-0.19861070811748505,
-0.5171457529067993,
-0.12437392771244049,
0.14932851493358612,
0.2287711650133133,
0.5328782200813293,
-1.0125409364700317,
-0.46679356694221497,
0.17490404844284058,
-0.7153165936470032,
0.19548895955085754,
0.3759590685367584,
0.2412765622138977,
0.3696756064891815,
0.5297954082489014,
-0.606546938419342,
-0.07939868420362473,
0.8651363253593445,
-0.0473790280520916,
0.5855817794799805,
-0.12989355623722076,
0.2083403468132019,
-1.0877532958984375,
0.037257347255945206,
0.0494086891412735,
-0.07639505714178085,
-0.8173678517341614,
0.26406916975975037,
0.05757356807589531,
-0.001464914996176958,
-0.5892850160598755,
0.799424409866333,
-0.7933704853057861,
-0.1802637130022049,
-0.37424036860466003,
0.16643622517585754,
-0.22893930971622467,
0.08627498894929886,
0.14819832146167755,
0.5786212682723999,
0.6490122079849243,
-0.4712589681148529,
0.41428375244140625,
0.20301127433776855,
-0.35499829053878784,
0.4711291193962097,
-0.28069719672203064,
-0.012289907783269882,
-0.2665282189846039,
0.3314256966114044,
-0.6331002712249756,
-0.24251797795295715,
0.11446231603622437,
-0.33810532093048096,
0.4159693121910095,
-0.1687353402376175,
-0.726985514163971,
-0.4130910336971283,
-0.34005287289619446,
0.6490537524223328,
0.27687808871269226,
-0.3438093364238739,
0.34372761845588684,
0.6356022953987122,
-0.5428905487060547,
-0.7783195376396179,
-0.8551706671714783,
0.35978224873542786,
-0.23979048430919647,
-0.5877882838249207,
-0.05638401210308075,
-0.25844255089759827,
-0.6121816039085388,
-0.43145105242729187,
0.27910473942756653,
-0.16345852613449097,
0.25182268023490906,
-0.30709245800971985,
0.11546830832958221,
-0.19248846173286438,
0.11440296471118927,
-0.12928737699985504,
0.08472622185945511,
0.13544008135795593,
-0.10663948953151703,
0.7028589248657227,
-0.1688469797372818,
-0.3418145179748535,
-0.1946503221988678,
0.6593850255012512,
0.4612794816493988,
-0.5519899725914001,
0.7484893202781677,
0.5709074139595032,
-0.47372159361839294,
-0.07526867836713791,
-0.7412889003753662,
-0.08776882290840149,
-0.42041346430778503,
0.6034494042396545,
-0.3760867118835449,
-1.3670904636383057,
0.6077050566673279,
-0.22592391073703766,
0.31134361028671265,
0.24007388949394226,
0.8739650249481201,
0.23452481627464294,
0.8688652515411377,
0.7872210144996643,
-0.07681088149547577,
0.4647167921066284,
0.09930302202701569,
0.28389298915863037,
-0.6628218293190002,
-0.40258732438087463,
-0.8074917793273926,
0.08307122439146042,
-0.680869460105896,
-0.3407723009586334,
0.15846839547157288,
-0.1434984654188156,
0.024226322770118713,
-0.07672474533319473,
0.0321316197514534,
0.1973777711391449,
0.13590647280216217,
-0.5376067161560059,
0.5523224472999573,
0.0658445805311203,
-0.13743029534816742,
-0.11780641973018646,
-0.5269516110420227,
-0.5581559538841248,
1.0953383445739746,
0.520386278629303,
0.7229602336883545,
0.4363812506198883,
0.4670492708683014,
0.018068503588438034,
0.46126115322113037,
-0.5887084007263184,
0.42037031054496765,
-0.08715660125017166,
-0.950826108455658,
-0.3077619671821594,
-0.4894503057003021,
-0.954678475856781,
0.7452466487884521,
-0.10982135683298111,
-0.787047266960144,
0.005938740447163582,
0.08589377999305725,
0.015374132432043552,
0.4920715093612671,
-0.46249377727508545,
0.8074876070022583,
-0.38272523880004883,
-0.26331496238708496,
-0.1495397537946701,
-0.6079922318458557,
0.6222894787788391,
-0.37473633885383606,
0.828394889831543,
-0.25289422273635864,
-0.02328255958855152,
0.6811791062355042,
-0.041395436972379684,
0.8370593786239624,
-0.30356812477111816,
-0.7331773042678833,
0.14516355097293854,
-0.26915210485458374,
0.39559057354927063,
0.18057934939861298,
-0.217046320438385,
0.4133768677711487,
-0.03323596343398094,
-0.2888852655887604,
-0.15105493366718292,
0.9095941781997681,
-0.5587776303291321,
-0.6054397821426392,
-0.5329240560531616,
-0.676653265953064,
-0.5853275060653687,
0.41109371185302734,
0.1268942803144455,
0.34545716643333435,
-0.36386245489120483,
0.05610935017466545,
0.5402207374572754,
-0.4439117908477783,
0.5922940373420715,
0.6861484050750732,
-0.7214596271514893,
-0.3045051097869873,
0.8312574028968811,
0.23162882030010223,
0.23796378076076508,
0.35986465215682983,
-0.0782037228345871,
-0.6119338274002075,
-0.878546953201294,
-0.3647938668727875,
0.3910941481590271,
-0.7017949223518372,
0.03206958621740341,
-0.708962082862854,
0.04225846007466316,
-0.7019504308700562,
0.1627897173166275,
-0.46852317452430725,
-0.11675208061933517,
-0.07373087108135223,
0.0445370189845562,
-0.05116487294435501,
0.7773513197898865,
0.06815291196107864,
0.30828896164894104,
-0.7753437757492065,
0.17796051502227783,
0.15285508334636688,
0.48656412959098816,
0.0651361346244812,
-0.21999594569206238,
-0.35164597630500793,
0.10557767003774643,
-0.1015271544456482,
-0.5811703205108643,
0.2727394104003906,
-0.03868917375802994,
0.8676806092262268,
0.22411085665225983,
-0.28836947679519653,
0.3355114459991455,
-0.6423835754394531,
0.7114822864532471,
0.35830920934677124,
-0.6916519403457642,
-0.01293309684842825,
-0.36984938383102417,
0.23616375029087067,
0.32277625799179077,
0.5101245641708374,
-0.8871253728866577,
-0.23380716145038605,
-0.11784681677818298,
-0.70954829454422,
0.588109016418457,
-0.1820003241300583,
0.25309136509895325,
0.19514574110507965,
-0.04828286170959473,
0.2492305189371109,
0.41983526945114136,
-0.9753942489624023,
-0.17312902212142944,
0.14583219587802887,
0.1696125715970993,
-0.4367029368877411,
-0.3003990650177002,
0.021346120163798332,
-0.023218126967549324,
0.42463842034339905,
-0.1968938261270523,
0.06295210123062134,
-0.3503739535808563,
-0.3910999894142151,
0.2192574292421341,
0.7374706268310547,
0.6216027736663818,
0.8729327917098999,
0.04668308421969414,
0.19312483072280884,
0.2580573558807373,
-0.3184420168399811,
0.31994596123695374,
0.26480451226234436,
0.055110443383455276,
-0.0744057223200798,
0.3555968105792999,
0.5523346662521362,
0.02301020175218582,
-0.701696515083313,
0.49612319469451904,
-0.2810647785663605,
-0.16348689794540405,
-0.4467829167842865,
-0.5082248449325562,
0.31438836455345154,
0.3141078054904938,
0.3015023171901703,
-0.03884969651699066,
0.06670183688402176,
-0.5704513788223267,
-0.16022396087646484,
0.716230571269989,
-0.08358767628669739,
-0.4386546313762665,
0.4667440950870514,
0.15837392210960388,
-0.11028627306222916,
0.45453283190727234,
-0.2045726180076599,
-0.40171897411346436,
0.39358845353126526,
0.5735237002372742,
0.5206437706947327,
-0.40245911478996277,
0.04211720451712608,
0.0879940465092659,
0.3850431740283966,
-0.14458075165748596,
0.2774141728878021,
0.07796952873468399,
-0.8658445477485657,
-0.6072182059288025,
-0.8029269576072693,
-0.40103620290756226,
0.12412899732589722,
-0.47384294867515564,
0.1380850076675415,
-0.22218303382396698,
-0.2699987292289734,
-0.170236736536026,
0.0001631922204978764,
-0.547511100769043,
-0.04345621168613434,
0.5650030970573425,
0.9762265682220459,
-0.7302820682525635,
0.933085024356842,
0.7856402397155762,
-0.04456896334886551,
-0.27427488565444946,
-0.20155926048755646,
0.1026669591665268,
-0.6079262495040894,
0.407563716173172,
0.2946448028087616,
-0.08938369154930115,
-0.207992285490036,
-0.24382346868515015,
-0.692154586315155,
0.6909583210945129,
0.5120136737823486,
-0.5825340747833252,
-0.10086417943239212,
0.42375367879867554,
0.41193002462387085,
-0.12006652355194092,
0.12902341783046722,
0.483124703168869,
0.6358545422554016,
-0.1803842931985855,
-0.9320143461227417,
-0.3402602970600128,
-0.3505431115627289,
0.021728044375777245,
0.28172293305397034,
-0.7390084862709045,
1.0853357315063477,
0.06338450312614441,
-0.017431601881980896,
0.18029752373695374,
0.5928093791007996,
0.3732239603996277,
0.3650627136230469,
0.4129481613636017,
0.19981622695922852,
0.6599107384681702,
0.035534657537937164,
1.0183560848236084,
-0.24255123734474182,
0.3844591975212097,
0.8435056209564209,
-0.7178268432617188,
0.6893136501312256,
0.4935782253742218,
-0.4030723571777344,
0.09235160797834396,
0.5756325721740723,
0.16441556811332703,
0.10087843984365463,
0.285665363073349,
-0.4305225610733032,
-0.3566977381706238,
-0.3288388252258301,
-0.6204203963279724,
0.48255476355552673,
0.3592749834060669,
-0.019418055191636086,
-0.40205568075180054,
0.32817262411117554,
0.20545688271522522,
0.08991370350122452,
-0.3209242522716522,
0.4842010736465454,
0.2975986897945404,
-0.49103933572769165,
0.23302248120307922,
0.44055047631263733,
1.0491881370544434,
-0.8191173076629639,
0.180806964635849,
-0.27985191345214844,
0.06109889969229698,
-0.09188861399888992,
-0.7011697888374329,
0.136895552277565,
0.192930206656456,
-0.1406540423631668,
-0.5894667506217957,
0.5284897089004517,
-0.4533597230911255,
-0.5279640555381775,
0.48884424567222595,
0.9654176235198975,
0.1249171793460846,
-0.11553246527910233,
-0.45789438486099243,
0.44707557559013367,
-0.18385650217533112,
-0.25988587737083435,
0.5984189510345459,
0.4113173484802246,
-0.20164097845554352,
0.705926239490509,
0.5242789387702942,
0.15965348482131958,
0.37337756156921387,
0.3213578760623932,
0.6071210503578186,
-0.7827641367912292,
-0.47392234206199646,
-0.7723423838615417,
0.17342914640903473,
0.0611875057220459,
-0.313022643327713,
0.9477493166923523,
0.6101281046867371,
0.9901466369628906,
0.023521270602941513,
0.8719369769096375,
0.170206218957901,
0.5347723960876465,
-0.570534348487854,
0.7500239014625549,
-0.781845211982727,
0.19392117857933044,
-0.28341144323349,
-0.8822633028030396,
-0.5256549715995789,
0.19183234870433807,
-0.183759406208992,
0.3655402660369873,
0.47800931334495544,
0.55595862865448,
0.06392993777990341,
0.10831157118082047,
0.4032515287399292,
0.0992322564125061,
0.49079421162605286,
0.42926284670829773,
1.175783395767212,
0.07871197164058685,
0.2544514834880829,
-0.02268841117620468,
-0.11860024183988571,
-0.14470796287059784,
-0.7952089309692383,
-0.7096323370933533,
-0.4321252107620239,
-0.06519357115030289,
0.15680654346942902,
-0.23913997411727905,
0.8484306335449219,
0.5394725203514099,
-0.7617056369781494,
-0.6087953448295593,
0.3328578472137451,
0.20594801008701324,
0.22254297137260437,
-0.10448482632637024,
-0.013361809775233269,
-0.32404711842536926,
-1.0258111953735352,
0.43593519926071167,
0.10616031289100647,
0.09045947343111038,
-0.5782553553581238,
-0.15897499024868011,
-0.37472519278526306,
-0.26589757204055786,
0.9593951106071472,
0.3158019781112671,
-0.747859001159668,
0.1426699012517929,
0.043624863028526306,
-0.06996449083089828,
-0.054140396416187286,
0.8984911441802979,
-0.3221691846847534,
0.23635362088680267,
0.36951518058776855,
0.6268705129623413,
0.351408451795578,
-0.5830410122871399,
0.3769294321537018,
-0.43511244654655457,
0.38864022493362427,
0.21839337050914764,
0.6080856323242188,
0.5829241871833801,
0.03491044417023659,
0.1323099583387375,
0.19956833124160767,
-0.3825894296169281,
-1.0368655920028687,
0.5251443386077881,
-0.6615781784057617,
-0.4246634840965271,
1.0249297618865967,
-0.06129385158419609,
0.09714129567146301,
-0.14921912550926208,
0.10360698401927948,
0.11531580239534378,
-0.13972941040992737,
0.18953508138656616,
0.8501522541046143,
0.004724979400634766,
-0.2751408517360687,
-0.7679585218429565,
0.15635466575622559,
0.30359500646591187,
-0.9406931400299072,
0.1841241419315338,
0.6290711760520935,
0.26519647240638733,
-0.008070188574492931,
0.6962066292762756,
-0.2758322060108185,
-0.10843075811862946,
-0.2662217915058136,
0.09961775690317154,
0.10889281332492828,
-0.5165746808052063,
-0.691297173500061,
0.4092712700366974,
0.5308300852775574,
0.2691383361816406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11014v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11014v1
|
The Arabic Noun System Generation
| 2024-05-17T17:33:10 | 2024-05-17T17:33:10 |
Abdelhadi Soudi, Violetta Cavalli-Sforza, Abderrahim Jamari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we show that the multiple-stem approach to nouns with a broken
plural pattern allows for greater generalizations to be stated in the
morphological system. Such an approach dispenses with truncating/deleting rules
and other complex rules that are required to account for the highly allomorphic
broken plural system. The generation of inflected sound nouns necessitates a
pre-specification of the affixes denoting the sound plural masculine and the
sound plural feminine, namely uwna and aAt, in the lexicon. The first
subsection of section one provides an evaluation of some of the previous
analyses of the Arabic broken plural. We provide both linguistic and
statistical evidence against deriving broken plurals from the singular or the
root. In subsection two, we propose a multiple stem approach to the Arabic Noun
Plural System within the Lexeme-based Morphology framework. In section two, we
look at the noun inflection of Arabic. Section three provides an implementation
of the Arabic Noun system in MORPHE. In this context, we show how the
generalizations discussed in the linguistic analysis section are captured in
Morphe using the equivalencing nodes.
|
[
-0.3032451570034027,
-0.7353764772415161,
0.2821240723133087,
0.18973584473133087,
-0.4499303698539734,
0.1115325391292572,
0.35582399368286133,
-0.3321213126182556,
0.2901102304458618,
0.2738901674747467,
-0.6425918340682983,
-0.5201170444488525,
-0.6091383695602417,
0.40648865699768066,
-0.4139012098312378,
0.7996387481689453,
0.0315396785736084,
-0.050029456615448,
0.34633663296699524,
-0.20261654257774353,
-0.7097060084342957,
-0.7219321727752686,
-0.39070987701416016,
-0.17886140942573547,
0.45498359203338623,
0.5266496539115906,
1.2107356786727905,
0.5618293881416321,
0.3464047312736511,
0.355532169342041,
-0.30560502409935,
0.4228915870189667,
0.06149023771286011,
0.26041150093078613,
0.041433047503232956,
0.039368078112602234,
-0.31676962971687317,
-0.291647344827652,
0.7571981549263,
0.8885661959648132,
-0.020154889672994614,
-0.2999478578567505,
-0.2971605062484741,
0.6614030003547668,
-0.5036289095878601,
-0.1358039230108261,
-0.536615252494812,
0.0022856921423226595,
-0.3097125291824341,
0.2687705457210541,
-0.034063540399074554,
-0.3183688521385193,
-0.19227150082588196,
-0.030010893940925598,
0.09331304579973221,
-0.2541009783744812,
0.9107595682144165,
-0.1682104915380478,
-0.5384287238121033,
-0.6180581450462341,
-0.7277231216430664,
0.767510712146759,
-0.7339519262313843,
0.2997085452079773,
0.07345626503229141,
0.07456039637327194,
-0.6093584895133972,
-0.37784624099731445,
-0.3500595688819885,
-0.2115298956632614,
0.04259654879570007,
0.02545974776148796,
-0.3607895076274872,
0.13082154095172882,
-0.04683632403612137,
0.45204320549964905,
-0.41760683059692383,
-0.00990929827094078,
-0.34187495708465576,
-0.1737259328365326,
0.5703075528144836,
-0.2852656841278076,
0.9829987287521362,
-0.3890380561351776,
-0.24975983798503876,
0.21361210942268372,
-0.8596580028533936,
-0.345370352268219,
0.7681483030319214,
0.6715067028999329,
0.08254757523536682,
0.8433318138122559,
0.23700882494449615,
0.2177191972732544,
-0.06969825178384781,
-0.2935750186443329,
0.47268179059028625,
-0.6610467433929443,
-0.1475384682416916,
0.13828903436660767,
0.4624863862991333,
-0.10762891918420792,
0.23792673647403717,
-0.2791544795036316,
-0.36207517981529236,
0.15231619775295258,
0.22434571385383606,
-0.6272861361503601,
0.2002970576286316,
0.21478892862796783,
-0.4456632137298584,
0.008238786831498146,
0.40253686904907227,
-0.3568633794784546,
0.23194769024848938,
-0.2776203155517578,
0.2421960085630417,
-0.7197936773300171,
-0.6199600100517273,
0.14119242131710052,
-0.3692993223667145,
0.052569713443517685,
-0.024168532341718674,
-0.9168539643287659,
0.6011121869087219,
0.6358951926231384,
1.0393047332763672,
-0.055810146033763885,
-0.27346962690353394,
-0.06900157034397125,
0.05820833519101143,
-0.25932684540748596,
0.7538641691207886,
-0.5072531700134277,
-0.9399462342262268,
0.17861635982990265,
-0.1965162605047226,
-0.07436606287956238,
-0.7118391394615173,
0.6597179174423218,
-0.30735674500465393,
0.01466043945401907,
0.12904666364192963,
-0.6728680729866028,
-0.35096490383148193,
-0.28169873356819153,
-0.559106707572937,
0.6645041704177856,
0.11376364529132843,
-0.3192022442817688,
0.21272994577884674,
-0.9835492968559265,
-0.4924909770488739,
-0.11086178570985794,
-0.26256322860717773,
-0.4281008839607239,
0.3599262833595276,
0.15713441371917725,
0.0410778783261776,
0.2318674772977829,
0.04659439995884895,
0.2225174605846405,
-0.15231460332870483,
-0.10422582924365997,
-0.30945247411727905,
1.092848300933838,
0.1698935627937317,
-0.31239053606987,
0.2248487025499344,
-0.5314100980758667,
0.024670030921697617,
0.04896516352891922,
-0.24130919575691223,
-0.34956005215644836,
0.028626274317502975,
0.3432018458843231,
-0.06026920676231384,
-0.1842791885137558,
-0.5260424613952637,
0.4584158658981323,
-0.6516607999801636,
0.24971377849578857,
0.6230961084365845,
0.24754580855369568,
0.33998364210128784,
-0.1780601292848587,
0.3601214587688446,
0.4488877058029175,
-0.05464230850338936,
-0.23782046139240265,
-0.5379014015197754,
-0.35330045223236084,
-0.5820473432540894,
0.32428407669067383,
0.24216733872890472,
-0.26567479968070984,
0.2849951982498169,
0.24554327130317688,
-0.4659923315048218,
-0.1577320545911789,
0.09061644971370697,
0.6339214444160461,
-0.06939511001110077,
0.5575382709503174,
-0.35162314772605896,
-0.9588649868965149,
-1.023595929145813,
-0.14474429190158844,
-0.39974740147590637,
0.35780414938926697,
-0.043344080448150635,
0.8488969802856445,
-0.46081364154815674,
0.9313611388206482,
-0.21103104948997498,
-0.157378152012825,
-0.31613078713417053,
0.35798898339271545,
0.2900339663028717,
0.563510000705719,
0.9199318289756775,
-0.8003239035606384,
0.14006537199020386,
-0.2377626597881317,
-0.4628000855445862,
-0.14264990389347076,
0.18043482303619385,
-0.3850480616092682,
0.30932968854904175,
0.36740854382514954,
-0.7886327505111694,
0.7151120901107788,
0.2800740599632263,
-0.8275703191757202,
1.147972583770752,
0.07505080103874207,
-0.026654671877622604,
-0.9833296537399292,
-0.39866432547569275,
-0.12104251235723495,
0.06296465545892715,
-0.7521876692771912,
0.1047302708029747,
-0.26139920949935913,
0.25774523615837097,
-0.5437201857566833,
0.4550184905529022,
-0.7153428792953491,
-0.15476207435131073,
-0.59378582239151,
-0.2764155864715576,
-0.2658298909664154,
0.09499730914831161,
-0.31722456216812134,
0.5733988881111145,
0.33583134412765503,
-0.8775266408920288,
0.42583316564559937,
0.27068403363227844,
-0.11471711099147797,
0.36002466082572937,
-0.7676228880882263,
0.1375768631696701,
-0.22063684463500977,
0.02422860823571682,
-0.97993403673172,
-0.10448017716407776,
0.45493850111961365,
-0.36526525020599365,
0.03333137929439545,
-0.09758738428354263,
-0.5931178331375122,
-0.12443127483129501,
-0.007244250737130642,
0.8386316299438477,
0.24246665835380554,
-0.42400023341178894,
0.42654430866241455,
0.46887001395225525,
-0.24291253089904785,
-0.5450721979141235,
-0.16611643135547638,
0.13959462940692902,
-0.17874620854854584,
-0.5915648341178894,
0.5996763110160828,
-0.018171092495322227,
-1.0016767978668213,
0.12733903527259827,
-0.12403616309165955,
-0.2625240981578827,
0.09226053953170776,
0.6152554154396057,
0.3201901316642761,
-0.3777672350406647,
0.47587716579437256,
0.42365676164627075,
0.16425396502017975,
-0.0919816792011261,
-0.13165324926376343,
0.655451238155365,
-0.23195718228816986,
-0.5794084668159485,
-0.4514991343021393,
0.7745655179023743,
0.7646490931510925,
0.03687556833028793,
0.5786839723587036,
0.009295616298913956,
-0.585277795791626,
0.1467437893152237,
-0.2325754463672638,
-0.039096467196941376,
-0.4070083200931549,
0.3900872468948364,
-0.7874398827552795,
-0.44700169563293457,
0.3577735126018524,
-0.07053280621767044,
0.4606345295906067,
0.9399362206459045,
0.49641844630241394,
-0.08666033297777176,
1.0753307342529297,
0.5418224930763245,
-0.08166169375181198,
0.08122582733631134,
0.021332204341888428,
-0.039788734167814255,
-0.4564412832260132,
-0.23569060862064362,
-0.8371964693069458,
-0.46081963181495667,
-0.2866264879703522,
-0.08898957818746567,
0.05650719627737999,
0.41009801626205444,
-0.5522615313529968,
0.17766404151916504,
-0.15312373638153076,
0.5224825739860535,
0.4326261281967163,
-0.36524489521980286,
0.45204848051071167,
0.351541131734848,
-0.4104653000831604,
-0.13381920754909515,
-0.36445558071136475,
-0.8255435228347778,
0.6044412851333618,
0.18999317288398743,
0.2989833354949951,
0.8093433976173401,
0.7381847500801086,
0.5509578585624695,
0.10793095827102661,
-0.9341838955879211,
0.34238556027412415,
-0.23688305914402008,
-0.48345640301704407,
-0.3243533968925476,
-0.22412364184856415,
-1.2209656238555908,
0.4822344183921814,
0.16006439924240112,
-0.31401556730270386,
0.2937552332878113,
-0.37638020515441895,
-0.0656006783246994,
0.4167814552783966,
-0.5049276947975159,
0.3323736786842346,
-0.24580281972885132,
0.425666868686676,
-0.036772195249795914,
-0.23315095901489258,
0.3734860122203827,
0.22036582231521606,
0.4744865596294403,
-0.2809513807296753,
-0.13604150712490082,
0.8644801378250122,
-0.9701945781707764,
0.8776478171348572,
-0.18948429822921753,
-0.25864169001579285,
0.40832576155662537,
0.18674632906913757,
-0.128379225730896,
-0.015889229252934456,
-0.0012846500612795353,
0.31803181767463684,
-0.05533350631594658,
-0.572105884552002,
-0.5072339773178101,
0.488914430141449,
-1.2033908367156982,
-0.48378095030784607,
-0.6718267798423767,
-0.5748587250709534,
-0.2507524788379669,
0.0865766778588295,
0.22342707216739655,
0.5975743532180786,
-0.4063415229320526,
-0.1971449851989746,
-0.032940544188022614,
0.294175922870636,
0.6356028914451599,
0.1094999834895134,
-0.5810242891311646,
-0.3509332835674286,
0.3314080238342285,
0.32663342356681824,
-0.0705714225769043,
-0.1474146842956543,
0.0465133972465992,
-0.3959949314594269,
-0.5726742744445801,
-0.7171853184700012,
0.4137669801712036,
-0.43064191937446594,
-0.14163701236248016,
-0.23675133287906647,
-0.5037974715232849,
-0.5492842793464661,
-0.03565734252333641,
-0.3503623902797699,
-0.5384001135826111,
-0.32868167757987976,
-0.19623227417469025,
0.476340115070343,
1.2048031091690063,
-0.20395396649837494,
0.3087053596973419,
-0.8557158708572388,
0.3941761255264282,
0.20988674461841583,
-0.24771080911159515,
-0.09816104173660278,
-0.737178385257721,
0.09892615675926208,
0.2539912462234497,
-0.2823816239833832,
-1.3035029172897339,
0.245454803109169,
0.5011808276176453,
0.5906562805175781,
0.5556110143661499,
-0.3800206482410431,
0.802438497543335,
-0.7287931442260742,
0.6632833480834961,
0.5830942988395691,
-1.0904444456100464,
0.7609535455703735,
-0.22560806572437286,
0.3030140697956085,
0.054154038429260254,
0.27086248993873596,
-0.7175219655036926,
-0.41455405950546265,
-0.7078616619110107,
-1.1464170217514038,
0.17700211703777313,
0.42933890223503113,
0.5242708921432495,
-0.35733723640441895,
0.5668354034423828,
0.539279580116272,
0.12275876849889755,
-0.15310367941856384,
-0.7229785323143005,
-0.3527600169181824,
-0.12147395312786102,
0.289933443069458,
-0.5474278926849365,
0.05690232291817665,
-0.3222946524620056,
0.7736371755599976,
0.1775365024805069,
0.10702361911535263,
-0.03266414627432823,
-0.3360690176486969,
0.044848088175058365,
0.51331627368927,
0.7851349711418152,
0.8659544587135315,
0.05562082305550575,
0.3229999244213104,
-0.3553648293018341,
-0.7985237836837769,
0.676750123500824,
-0.39284151792526245,
-0.5020765662193298,
0.7687546014785767,
0.3188551068305969,
0.5739065408706665,
0.2695017457008362,
-0.3944251239299774,
-0.00662626139819622,
0.2477244883775711,
-0.5698243975639343,
-0.27522003650665283,
-0.05153544619679451,
-0.0594048947095871,
-0.016385048627853394,
0.7227973937988281,
0.2854122221469879,
-0.11663719266653061,
-0.9216094017028809,
0.418212890625,
0.38091468811035156,
-0.19318890571594238,
-0.4943072497844696,
-0.09961443394422531,
-0.001913966378197074,
-0.5163245797157288,
0.7158181667327881,
-0.162965327501297,
-0.508908748626709,
0.7905240058898926,
0.897042989730835,
0.7148674726486206,
-0.4875512421131134,
0.5454204678535461,
0.45721179246902466,
0.19787652790546417,
-0.002594455610960722,
0.6747807860374451,
0.38149720430374146,
-1.070380449295044,
-0.1865602433681488,
-0.5926976203918457,
-0.33008337020874023,
-0.028462449088692665,
-0.34484490752220154,
-0.08508025854825974,
-0.5181722640991211,
-0.3085273802280426,
0.043002013117074966,
-0.27973759174346924,
-0.19840623438358307,
0.210682213306427,
0.16466321051120758,
0.44746527075767517,
-0.6733564734458923,
0.37122413516044617,
0.9555165767669678,
-0.6817022562026978,
-0.6660688519477844,
-0.14162074029445648,
0.23391254246234894,
-0.5251685976982117,
1.0685279369354248,
-0.03933635354042053,
-0.7026640176773071,
-0.16173261404037476,
-0.43494415283203125,
-0.9770777225494385,
0.5105791091918945,
0.29439783096313477,
-0.12596748769283295,
-0.03488021343946457,
-0.0003277001087553799,
0.20582561194896698,
-0.4746455252170563,
0.2757805287837982,
0.4454761743545532,
0.6889861226081848,
0.17945213615894318,
-0.7996507287025452,
-0.14213599264621735,
-0.39173704385757446,
0.0445915088057518,
0.3061479330062866,
-0.2642715275287628,
1.138235092163086,
-0.5040662288665771,
-0.6994848251342773,
0.3290940523147583,
0.9527248740196228,
0.30819806456565857,
-0.12378250807523727,
0.5804644823074341,
0.5595964193344116,
0.916097104549408,
-0.19968055188655853,
0.5744075179100037,
0.1993887722492218,
-0.10645163804292679,
0.8592446446418762,
-0.018682150170207024,
0.7754695415496826,
0.5001468062400818,
-0.433636337518692,
0.9871554374694824,
0.5203724503517151,
0.11939115822315216,
0.29032307863235474,
0.3992537260055542,
-0.38877129554748535,
-0.009744510985910892,
-0.28115612268447876,
-0.6132251024246216,
0.9141795039176941,
0.2922266721725464,
-0.22769363224506378,
-0.4547976851463318,
0.02409239299595356,
0.325053334236145,
0.08872150629758835,
-0.7366083860397339,
0.5690802931785583,
0.11393377184867859,
-0.25773996114730835,
0.4828528165817261,
0.41471007466316223,
0.5955116748809814,
-0.44043079018592834,
-0.16316691040992737,
-0.26734787225723267,
-0.03759068623185158,
-0.47042015194892883,
-0.32120344042778015,
0.5148921012878418,
0.12030768394470215,
-0.42581355571746826,
0.015812912955880165,
0.6619331240653992,
-0.06291469186544418,
-0.8904807567596436,
0.1336585134267807,
1.0182881355285645,
0.42020726203918457,
-0.09604739397764206,
-0.4340553879737854,
-0.12939830124378204,
-0.16211670637130737,
-0.07751470804214478,
0.10197031497955322,
0.25460362434387207,
-0.235508531332016,
0.24079443514347076,
0.6442888379096985,
0.18741552531719208,
0.2696472704410553,
0.5737289786338806,
0.38525745272636414,
-0.9407944679260254,
-0.26086416840553284,
-1.233042597770691,
0.3248606026172638,
0.29557332396507263,
-0.3914276957511902,
0.7306596636772156,
0.5688464045524597,
0.4374834895133972,
0.01430604699999094,
0.7999197244644165,
0.1464320421218872,
0.4162432551383972,
-0.38732802867889404,
0.6296772956848145,
-0.5555868744850159,
-0.0014283331111073494,
-0.2529699206352234,
-1.0191707611083984,
-0.4705880284309387,
0.5072765350341797,
0.09285899251699448,
0.2947235405445099,
0.7690749168395996,
0.4580264687538147,
0.03565729036927223,
0.21306313574314117,
0.3231778144836426,
0.3386967182159424,
0.11374948918819427,
-0.04962687939405441,
0.9356867074966431,
-0.5346072316169739,
0.3239789307117462,
-0.023486267775297165,
0.031262803822755814,
-0.08029215037822723,
-0.24307532608509064,
-0.3697309195995331,
-0.4568248987197876,
-0.42840132117271423,
-0.2663078010082245,
0.3453601002693176,
1.0490466356277466,
0.4475218653678894,
-0.9827702641487122,
-0.6969155073165894,
-0.10186794400215149,
0.4319157898426056,
-0.5454903244972229,
-0.1573149412870407,
0.5959193706512451,
-0.5179988145828247,
-0.8972960114479065,
0.6161921620368958,
0.43497422337532043,
0.34093719720840454,
-0.07721129059791565,
-0.03956463187932968,
-0.5107536911964417,
0.12340471148490906,
0.7388668656349182,
0.433452308177948,
-0.8188867568969727,
-0.3183128237724304,
-0.22198356688022614,
-0.13397721946239471,
0.28960588574409485,
0.7643706202507019,
-0.6270804405212402,
-0.1073291227221489,
0.2765883505344391,
0.15743529796600342,
-0.2094123214483261,
0.15219169855117798,
0.42820507287979126,
-0.663810670375824,
0.07179462164640427,
0.2679797410964966,
0.5517193675041199,
0.05856792628765106,
0.04997120052576065,
0.3377148509025574,
0.49012163281440735,
-0.18599987030029297,
-0.6439809203147888,
0.7935922741889954,
-0.5710651874542236,
-0.5628774762153625,
1.1401731967926025,
0.1783534735441208,
-0.07277889549732208,
-0.7761934995651245,
-0.5319650769233704,
0.3751659393310547,
-0.4993290603160858,
0.6068351864814758,
0.7317707538604736,
-0.28866222500801086,
0.05584761127829552,
-0.08939586579799652,
0.2276444137096405,
0.4806293845176697,
-0.5310131311416626,
-0.5197471380233765,
0.7304235100746155,
-0.05159548670053482,
0.33770278096199036,
0.34122276306152344,
-0.3544290065765381,
0.3380228281021118,
0.11033856868743896,
0.25313496589660645,
0.0765683725476265,
-0.34886178374290466,
0.005686781369149685,
0.6203542947769165,
0.11186474561691284,
-0.28585296869277954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10918v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10918v1
|
GenToC: Leveraging Partially-Labeled Data for Product Attribute-Value Identification
| 2024-05-17T17:09:45 | 2024-05-17T17:09:45 |
D. Subhalingam, Keshav Kolluru, Mausam, Saurabh Singal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
In the e-commerce domain, the accurate extraction of attribute-value pairs
from product listings (e.g., Brand: Apple) is crucial for enhancing search and
recommendation systems. The automation of this extraction process is
challenging due to the vast diversity of product categories and their
respective attributes, compounded by the lack of extensive, accurately
annotated training datasets and the demand for low latency to meet the
real-time needs of e-commerce platforms. To address these challenges, we
introduce GenToC, a novel two-stage model for extracting attribute-value pairs
from product titles. GenToC is designed to train with partially-labeled data,
leveraging incomplete attribute-value pairs and obviating the need for a fully
annotated dataset. Moreover, we introduce a bootstrapping method that enables
GenToC to progressively refine and expand its training dataset. This
enhancement substantially improves the quality of data available for training
other neural network models that are typically faster but are inherently less
capable than GenToC in terms of their capacity to handle partially-labeled
data. By supplying an enriched dataset for training, GenToC significantly
advances the performance of these alternative models, making them more suitable
for real-time deployment. Our results highlight the unique capability of GenToC
to learn from a limited set of labeled data and to contribute to the training
of more efficient models, marking a significant leap forward in the automated
extraction of attribute-value pairs from product titles. GenToC has been
successfully integrated into India's largest B2B e-commerce platform,
IndiaMART.com, achieving a significant increase of 21.1% in recall over the
existing deployed system while maintaining a high precision of 89.5% in this
challenging task.
|
[
-0.23474201560020447,
-0.5678790211677551,
0.09351051598787308,
0.037374209612607956,
-0.2542284429073334,
0.6472407579421997,
-0.004940565675497055,
-0.75433349609375,
0.021793561056256294,
0.10025838017463684,
-0.6466293334960938,
-0.43088871240615845,
-0.3813263773918152,
0.004608240444213152,
-0.5255959630012512,
1.0543997287750244,
0.34710806608200073,
-0.2936527729034424,
-0.4265170693397522,
-0.22052286565303802,
-0.3434555232524872,
-0.3515520989894867,
-0.8361883759498596,
-0.21106389164924622,
0.5487107634544373,
0.410105437040329,
0.702130913734436,
0.5213417410850525,
0.41979658603668213,
0.24299317598342896,
0.012960430234670639,
0.24056747555732727,
-0.2563977837562561,
0.22785106301307678,
0.03723596781492233,
-0.38312676548957825,
-0.6317150592803955,
0.4495503902435303,
0.18317706882953644,
0.6811087727546692,
-0.2595426142215729,
0.39841428399086,
0.03589896112680435,
0.6476161479949951,
-0.6508873701095581,
0.2934769093990326,
-0.4632798433303833,
0.3546935021877289,
0.09427379071712494,
0.049700457602739334,
-0.5188798904418945,
-0.39070114493370056,
0.09161468595266342,
-0.8691767454147339,
0.3458671271800995,
0.16262194514274597,
1.3372396230697632,
0.1338196098804474,
-0.24217960238456726,
-0.14499501883983612,
-0.8823117017745972,
0.7331134080886841,
-0.5025129914283752,
0.468962699174881,
0.654615044593811,
0.30431824922561646,
0.19473615288734436,
-0.9298005700111389,
-0.44376397132873535,
-0.11621248722076416,
-0.13761776685714722,
0.1998092532157898,
0.15996038913726807,
-0.1815418154001236,
0.26801198720932007,
0.6232122778892517,
-0.2834906578063965,
0.2231023609638214,
-0.3850138783454895,
-0.14560380578041077,
0.6216995120048523,
-0.09112007170915604,
0.24055282771587372,
-0.0684630498290062,
-0.5465177297592163,
-0.1440913826227188,
-0.6218754649162292,
0.1476086676120758,
0.4724935293197632,
0.31770437955856323,
-0.001681772293522954,
0.5464137196540833,
-0.5120551586151123,
0.6721266508102417,
0.18356266617774963,
-0.1930234432220459,
0.5248482823371887,
-0.6807736158370972,
-0.2531282901763916,
0.1990431696176529,
0.7050244212150574,
-0.02518412470817566,
-0.13843610882759094,
-0.31408512592315674,
-0.25917690992355347,
-0.49404987692832947,
0.2972044050693512,
-0.7141809463500977,
-0.423897385597229,
0.1854962706565857,
-0.629981517791748,
-0.6819108128547668,
0.21352605521678925,
-1.0074454545974731,
-0.5276453495025635,
-0.21831534802913666,
0.5765759944915771,
-0.012612269259989262,
-0.058275334537029266,
-0.23801970481872559,
-0.15319904685020447,
0.615308940410614,
0.18928365409374237,
-0.782951831817627,
0.17537550628185272,
0.7136210799217224,
0.9910317063331604,
0.023181524127721786,
0.2534909248352051,
-0.5593070983886719,
0.10631757974624634,
-0.31458181142807007,
0.643963634967804,
-0.7406116127967834,
-0.08541657775640488,
-0.16451886296272278,
0.3295513987541199,
0.29593542218208313,
-0.582010805606842,
0.24895071983337402,
-0.9242228269577026,
-0.02686389721930027,
-0.03759259358048439,
-0.4511908292770386,
0.04973798617720604,
0.27028778195381165,
-0.8697386384010315,
1.1074484586715698,
0.18323896825313568,
-0.5731687545776367,
0.5977607369422913,
-0.20614415407180786,
-0.9023876786231995,
0.5324174165725708,
-0.10049421340227127,
-1.0180786848068237,
-0.13302268087863922,
0.1262183040380478,
0.4683477580547333,
-0.6769124269485474,
0.11153948307037354,
-0.3633314073085785,
-0.07392392307519913,
0.1875378042459488,
-0.17068907618522644,
0.6927129626274109,
0.49313485622406006,
-0.39447760581970215,
-0.33330482244491577,
-1.0491105318069458,
0.060158032923936844,
0.3096427619457245,
-0.17199601233005524,
-0.3772415518760681,
-0.022805405780673027,
-0.2086210697889328,
0.1607987880706787,
0.34070226550102234,
-0.6759040951728821,
0.2899561822414398,
-0.18709483742713928,
0.40767043828964233,
0.7405778765678406,
-0.08732350170612335,
0.48658591508865356,
0.10118207335472107,
0.6611605286598206,
-0.2498544156551361,
0.5094268918037415,
0.024151895195245743,
-0.8112772703170776,
-0.7982186079025269,
-0.29174724221229553,
0.92137211561203,
0.610078752040863,
-0.7684857845306396,
0.6080172061920166,
-0.1032925397157669,
-0.5952547192573547,
-0.5386132597923279,
0.18010671436786652,
0.2766220271587372,
0.6419849991798401,
0.3721352517604828,
-0.4190945625305176,
-0.3263261318206787,
-1.158156156539917,
0.12477213144302368,
-0.09843221306800842,
-0.2635803520679474,
0.280366450548172,
0.19503308832645416,
0.20771196484565735,
1.0302445888519287,
-0.5773036479949951,
-0.37650904059410095,
-0.4711359739303589,
0.5826035141944885,
0.26175209879875183,
0.4060768485069275,
0.017249813303351402,
-0.9832436442375183,
-0.42404013872146606,
0.15552586317062378,
-0.6432793140411377,
-0.27534836530685425,
-0.4040977656841278,
-0.12225572764873505,
-0.08305855840444565,
0.23650285601615906,
-0.055798277258872986,
0.660610556602478,
0.4028960168361664,
-0.11275290697813034,
0.2798665463924408,
-0.35200732946395874,
0.2728720009326935,
-1.2091381549835205,
0.0911344587802887,
0.28235769271850586,
-0.2026541531085968,
-0.4791960120201111,
-0.29727721214294434,
0.24578934907913208,
-0.05193740874528885,
-0.456390380859375,
0.08484555035829544,
-0.3939898610115051,
-0.2951489984989166,
0.02159087173640728,
-0.26606741547584534,
0.26657572388648987,
0.30874142050743103,
0.058250878006219864,
0.9941204786300659,
0.1568823903799057,
-0.6397756934165955,
0.6854256391525269,
0.37551164627075195,
-0.4019085466861725,
0.6820530891418457,
-0.4287017583847046,
0.0594201497733593,
0.03976757451891899,
0.13186153769493103,
-0.8281537890434265,
-0.07755837589502335,
0.3610386848449707,
-0.34711477160453796,
0.5230481028556824,
-0.4422062039375305,
-0.7802999019622803,
-0.4444742798805237,
-0.13735368847846985,
0.6040859818458557,
0.7715864181518555,
-0.6422778367996216,
0.5813044905662537,
0.42513757944107056,
-0.17041127383708954,
-0.251497745513916,
-0.8134094476699829,
0.06771639734506607,
0.0124669773504138,
-0.22279849648475647,
0.2549566328525543,
0.11145802587270737,
0.3700251877307892,
-0.039679404348134995,
-0.039299268275499344,
-0.15443158149719238,
0.14197836816310883,
0.28952327370643616,
0.44470733404159546,
0.10950641334056854,
0.490690678358078,
0.1936742067337036,
-0.44603389501571655,
-0.21705099940299988,
-0.48032334446907043,
0.20501364767551422,
0.35604962706565857,
-0.17221054434776306,
-0.6693487763404846,
0.08305539190769196,
0.10312545299530029,
-0.427331805229187,
0.9483195543289185,
0.41843685507774353,
-0.39733707904815674,
-0.30655646324157715,
-0.42113664746284485,
-0.0742746889591217,
-0.45095276832580566,
0.16083088517189026,
-0.37048470973968506,
-0.3314462900161743,
0.3105792701244354,
-0.3243235945701599,
-0.3765482008457184,
0.5165776014328003,
0.3780663311481476,
-0.2532915771007538,
1.091737151145935,
0.5903909206390381,
0.0574893094599247,
0.397743821144104,
-0.35449305176734924,
0.7430639266967773,
-0.7524363994598389,
-0.9869344234466553,
-0.5734559297561646,
-0.5365759134292603,
-0.5611737370491028,
-0.3570410907268524,
0.18506678938865662,
-0.1754043996334076,
-0.23045146465301514,
0.4839874804019928,
-0.7934404015541077,
0.3988574743270874,
0.8585537672042847,
0.4966581165790558,
0.2644939422607422,
0.2829696238040924,
-0.017740990966558456,
0.26931998133659363,
-0.4914741814136505,
-0.08086027204990387,
1.253981113433838,
0.3093104362487793,
0.673790693283081,
-0.2658684253692627,
0.25271403789520264,
0.44150421023368835,
0.1640067994594574,
-0.8054839372634888,
0.41129279136657715,
-0.2934066355228424,
-0.7635616660118103,
0.11158417910337448,
-0.5143906474113464,
-0.5449072122573853,
-0.27625495195388794,
-0.15745572745800018,
-0.6462045907974243,
0.6403378248214722,
0.05751219019293785,
-0.7895562052726746,
0.54132479429245,
-0.6535788178443909,
0.8125234842300415,
-0.7129774689674377,
-0.6926188468933105,
0.0827760398387909,
-0.8939785957336426,
-0.02625986374914646,
-0.28918561339378357,
0.17061907052993774,
-0.20051293075084686,
-0.13590818643569946,
1.056976318359375,
-0.572437584400177,
0.550639271736145,
-0.036716096103191376,
0.043090976774692535,
0.2198611944913864,
-0.14341841638088226,
0.4885607063770294,
-0.012222541496157646,
0.1904395967721939,
0.08013837039470673,
-0.1587885618209839,
-0.5868827104568481,
-0.42461976408958435,
0.4572684168815613,
-0.6364578604698181,
-0.15533305704593658,
-0.6094506978988647,
-0.11113136261701584,
-0.43407586216926575,
-0.051543738692998886,
0.054831281304359436,
0.19955602288246155,
0.14926303923130035,
0.36291876435279846,
0.8117887377738953,
-0.6061840653419495,
0.2707090973854065,
0.05704431235790253,
0.15119655430316925,
-0.5855852365493774,
1.120191216468811,
-0.058061134070158005,
0.5282312035560608,
0.4304922819137573,
0.011781209148466587,
-0.2712618112564087,
-0.23046773672103882,
-0.2806766927242279,
-0.02634045109152794,
-0.4908898174762726,
-0.6470345258712769,
-0.6141623854637146,
-0.4149797856807709,
-0.21335500478744507,
0.07967220991849899,
-0.5916203856468201,
-0.48547881841659546,
-0.2818247079849243,
-0.3702438771724701,
0.5195875763893127,
0.6952078938484192,
-0.2486264407634735,
0.5008099675178528,
-0.7099090814590454,
0.4751448929309845,
0.758914053440094,
0.4782172739505768,
-0.037643834948539734,
-0.30713215470314026,
-0.4128914773464203,
0.1703750342130661,
-0.13901333510875702,
-0.8973202705383301,
0.21280312538146973,
0.28524619340896606,
0.2229868322610855,
0.6212959289550781,
0.014039969071745872,
0.6417060494422913,
-0.12284631282091141,
0.7738838791847229,
0.18535155057907104,
-0.5638189315795898,
0.5823240280151367,
0.23161129653453827,
-0.021706098690629005,
0.7561421394348145,
0.5021763443946838,
-0.2961764633655548,
0.002585512585937977,
-0.46523651480674744,
-1.0799909830093384,
1.0273375511169434,
0.438374787569046,
-0.09264638274908066,
0.34537044167518616,
0.28949350118637085,
0.469362735748291,
0.4193832576274872,
-0.5050978064537048,
-0.2352021336555481,
-0.18858128786087036,
-0.32822296023368835,
0.11157653480768204,
-0.5238052010536194,
0.043694667518138885,
-0.6269919872283936,
0.8048083782196045,
0.1249944195151329,
0.23572596907615662,
0.0432053841650486,
-0.11648640781641006,
0.14515678584575653,
0.11108473688364029,
-0.04974618926644325,
0.29774734377861023,
-0.38942793011665344,
0.09663542360067368,
-0.1702139973640442,
-0.4255874454975128,
0.29330331087112427,
0.40447402000427246,
-0.2923208773136139,
-0.45624297857284546,
0.09642884880304337,
0.576377809047699,
0.03433065861463547,
-0.3808205723762512,
0.5863049626350403,
-0.0015591750852763653,
0.10316035151481628,
-0.10129550099372864,
-0.48110437393188477,
-0.10556475818157196,
0.09795690327882767,
0.6022238731384277,
-0.08139090985059738,
0.3206585943698883,
-0.48662981390953064,
0.5093954205513,
0.28050464391708374,
-0.33439937233924866,
-0.26156529784202576,
0.8783930540084839,
0.2730259597301483,
-0.07445291429758072,
1.1448898315429688,
-0.409942626953125,
-0.5550323128700256,
1.026674509048462,
0.321148157119751,
1.0129557847976685,
-0.0537307932972908,
0.6615847945213318,
0.44590532779693604,
0.45098069310188293,
0.04724597930908203,
-0.18309339880943298,
-0.46827372908592224,
-0.4913879632949829,
-0.1820996105670929,
-0.8744143843650818,
-0.04433082416653633,
-0.04259224608540535,
-0.6564423441886902,
0.22335998713970184,
-0.513580858707428,
-0.2408796101808548,
-0.03418459743261337,
-0.04236701875925064,
-0.8646257519721985,
0.3874984085559845,
0.4249696433544159,
0.5698087811470032,
-1.1550676822662354,
0.6834350824356079,
0.2692197859287262,
-0.9065086841583252,
-0.9393177628517151,
-0.43110084533691406,
-0.14338558912277222,
-0.6996822953224182,
0.5559762120246887,
0.22989852726459503,
0.22594092786312103,
-0.12452685832977295,
-0.48785197734832764,
-0.5075228214263916,
1.2617300748825073,
-0.08635545521974564,
-0.7068526744842529,
-0.04590974003076553,
0.5720760822296143,
0.40088027715682983,
-0.39372262358665466,
0.5372841954231262,
0.6034281253814697,
0.5325548648834229,
0.6080752611160278,
-0.6243730783462524,
0.06457506120204926,
-0.22889702022075653,
0.03883323445916176,
0.12708726525306702,
-0.531441330909729,
0.453990638256073,
0.06605886667966843,
-0.2659594714641571,
0.3076780438423157,
0.32497256994247437,
-0.12830348312854767,
0.44723793864250183,
0.4372212886810303,
0.8983856439590454,
0.609291136264801,
-0.2465079426765442,
1.0018563270568848,
-0.037002258002758026,
0.6000574231147766,
1.0875126123428345,
-0.28830090165138245,
0.7035499811172485,
0.23761846125125885,
-0.4225672483444214,
0.4197317063808441,
1.022101879119873,
-0.4164290726184845,
0.7578868269920349,
-0.1598404198884964,
-0.18864895403385162,
-0.5631487965583801,
-0.22032080590724945,
-0.34397628903388977,
0.011919379234313965,
0.1279120147228241,
-0.6274111866950989,
0.038885392248630524,
0.14967124164104462,
-0.10474149882793427,
-0.42702558636665344,
-0.1236785501241684,
1.0437313318252563,
-0.12772412598133087,
-0.09087523818016052,
0.22581063210964203,
-0.22258774936199188,
0.30961915850639343,
-0.548738420009613,
-0.20789475739002228,
-0.4160889983177185,
-0.021449018269777298,
-0.405360609292984,
-0.45221713185310364,
-0.23398740589618683,
-0.02973346970975399,
0.12486833333969116,
-0.32748478651046753,
0.6017441153526306,
-0.38196268677711487,
-1.0476418733596802,
0.2442329078912735,
0.2493184208869934,
-0.1862286925315857,
0.07337357848882675,
-0.625885009765625,
-0.14708222448825836,
-0.0960000604391098,
-0.149470716714859,
0.2723560929298401,
0.15369711816310883,
0.2878592610359192,
0.5771077871322632,
0.6217390894889832,
0.11835956573486328,
0.2379489243030548,
-0.08854322880506516,
0.6990391612052917,
-0.558840811252594,
-0.1745849996805191,
-0.40771761536598206,
0.6319599151611328,
-0.6035117506980896,
0.14218761026859283,
0.34762707352638245,
1.0140995979309082,
0.9055889248847961,
0.07189293950796127,
0.6963229775428772,
-0.43814435601234436,
0.21574127674102783,
-0.21767301857471466,
0.845413863658905,
-0.8599001169204712,
0.4837927222251892,
0.11913370341062546,
-0.8707764744758606,
-0.32611119747161865,
0.32829007506370544,
-0.13067083060741425,
0.15082864463329315,
0.7206465005874634,
0.8109176158905029,
-0.22863084077835083,
0.07472243905067444,
0.183981791138649,
0.23046228289604187,
0.19651001691818237,
0.5118362903594971,
0.7976460456848145,
-0.6282870769500732,
0.5998587012290955,
-0.7548484206199646,
-0.4933721721172333,
-0.017323488369584084,
-0.7100450992584229,
-0.4452098309993744,
-0.6277686357498169,
-0.7167800068855286,
-0.2808719873428345,
0.26802292466163635,
0.6960600018501282,
0.8719733357429504,
-1.052363634109497,
0.00782536156475544,
-0.016015073284506798,
0.07429321110248566,
-0.41237109899520874,
-0.2098819613456726,
0.35255399346351624,
-0.302825391292572,
-0.5762186050415039,
0.2035122513771057,
0.39757558703422546,
-0.07276421040296555,
0.014818797819316387,
0.20465585589408875,
-0.49636268615722656,
-0.0059885624796152115,
0.4303193688392639,
0.36423176527023315,
-0.393085241317749,
-0.19424086809158325,
-0.282357782125473,
0.18348170816898346,
0.3434705138206482,
0.8719401955604553,
-1.156568169593811,
0.8378344774246216,
0.49620872735977173,
0.787533700466156,
0.48854559659957886,
0.22228644788265228,
0.4424108862876892,
-0.7618773579597473,
0.172773540019989,
0.16304342448711395,
0.013462139293551445,
0.2677063047885895,
-0.32772019505500793,
0.4944441020488739,
0.38617148995399475,
-0.3070053160190582,
-0.6754900217056274,
0.132600799202919,
-0.9228695631027222,
-0.25655514001846313,
0.9979757070541382,
-0.029744122177362442,
-0.332216739654541,
0.09522870928049088,
0.1021372377872467,
0.5329899787902832,
-0.4050377309322357,
0.6912398934364319,
0.24105754494667053,
0.20114824175834656,
-0.057645540684461594,
-0.4168955683708191,
0.2707204520702362,
0.10405942052602768,
-0.9223479628562927,
-0.28828445076942444,
0.2749479115009308,
0.15656785666942596,
-0.01463414542376995,
0.04089435935020447,
-0.08017425984144211,
0.006054332945495844,
-0.13218249380588531,
0.1378832310438156,
-0.1015673503279686,
-0.5023224949836731,
-0.16478420794010162,
0.4951874017715454,
-0.04287222772836685,
-0.6337873935699463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10893v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10893v1
|
COGNET-MD, an evaluation framework and dataset for Large Language Model benchmarks in the medical domain
| 2024-05-17T16:31:56 | 2024-05-17T16:31:56 |
Dimitrios P. Panagoulias, Persephone Papatheodosiou, Anastasios P. Palamidas, Mattheos Sanoudos, Evridiki Tsoureli-Nikita, Maria Virvou, George A. Tsihrintzis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) constitute a breakthrough state-of-the-art
Artificial Intelligence (AI) technology which is rapidly evolving and promises
to aid in medical diagnosis either by assisting doctors or by simulating a
doctor's workflow in more advanced and complex implementations. In this
technical paper, we outline Cognitive Network Evaluation Toolkit for Medical
Domains (COGNET-MD), which constitutes a novel benchmark for LLM evaluation in
the medical domain. Specifically, we propose a scoring-framework with increased
difficulty to assess the ability of LLMs in interpreting medical text. The
proposed framework is accompanied with a database of Multiple Choice Quizzes
(MCQs). To ensure alignment with current medical trends and enhance safety,
usefulness, and applicability, these MCQs have been constructed in
collaboration with several associated medical experts in various medical
domains and are characterized by varying degrees of difficulty. The current
(first) version of the database includes the medical domains of Psychiatry,
Dentistry, Pulmonology, Dermatology and Endocrinology, but it will be
continuously extended and expanded to include additional medical domains.
|
[
-0.43668806552886963,
-1.0489901304244995,
0.8521519303321838,
0.09853910654783249,
-0.168520987033844,
0.09856720268726349,
-0.5861753225326538,
-0.21204012632369995,
0.15037018060684204,
0.4490073621273041,
-0.8545835018157959,
-0.7347899675369263,
-0.7578721642494202,
0.1520760953426361,
-0.1598319262266159,
0.7218742370605469,
-0.1673021912574768,
0.5433452129364014,
-0.6665363907814026,
-0.2214294970035553,
-0.48671212792396545,
-0.5989306569099426,
-1.1243036985397339,
-0.5422316789627075,
0.4266555905342102,
0.16765858232975006,
0.6270880103111267,
0.18678924441337585,
1.158821940422058,
0.2700960338115692,
0.17450734972953796,
0.27440300583839417,
-0.22928403317928314,
0.2669975459575653,
-0.6099880337715149,
-0.11717746406793594,
-0.8880010843276978,
0.11714958399534225,
0.0977092981338501,
0.9889776706695557,
-0.22869670391082764,
0.11925327032804489,
-0.21092979609966278,
0.608285665512085,
-0.2810380756855011,
0.20044802129268646,
-0.30846989154815674,
-0.010653847828507423,
-0.03207273408770561,
-0.31496185064315796,
-0.3221578896045685,
-0.13521328568458557,
0.4252995550632477,
-0.46537405252456665,
0.041292931884527206,
0.3555283546447754,
0.7096274495124817,
0.3868110775947571,
-0.5570349097251892,
-0.5841568112373352,
-0.2735587954521179,
0.7711785435676575,
-0.2899182140827179,
0.333801805973053,
0.3375176787376404,
0.6635113954544067,
-0.33038797974586487,
-0.826370120048523,
-0.5791141390800476,
-0.4096533954143524,
0.1925506442785263,
0.3145664632320404,
0.010993522591888905,
0.12318816781044006,
-0.0938287302851677,
0.4792007505893707,
-0.7349159717559814,
0.25329670310020447,
-0.27756544947624207,
-0.08236142247915268,
0.7700575590133667,
0.6985682845115662,
0.5439967513084412,
-0.07834802567958832,
-0.29680463671684265,
0.03940296173095703,
-0.689059853553772,
-0.45205947756767273,
-0.25254026055336,
-0.09265872091054916,
-0.1969791054725647,
0.7126708626747131,
-0.13369111716747284,
0.8700271248817444,
0.015010572969913483,
-0.08447587490081787,
0.41151726245880127,
-0.2588275074958801,
-0.44125908613204956,
-0.24027927219867706,
1.0945518016815186,
0.5808278918266296,
0.17610520124435425,
-0.2196565568447113,
0.07503814250230789,
0.21608880162239075,
0.38391947746276855,
-0.5884796977043152,
-0.37520894408226013,
0.6099177598953247,
-0.4267559349536896,
-0.3058515191078186,
-0.3962593376636505,
-0.6004310846328735,
-0.6589101552963257,
-0.3756479024887085,
0.2688967287540436,
-0.5832000374794006,
-0.13806138932704926,
0.39850109815597534,
0.05127648636698723,
-0.14240586757659912,
0.46494871377944946,
-0.5784980654716492,
0.6655527353286743,
0.7740944623947144,
0.725083589553833,
-0.847728431224823,
-0.1728001981973648,
-0.17681758105754852,
-0.30696019530296326,
-0.1546335071325302,
0.7584113478660583,
-0.5774886012077332,
-0.16764532029628754,
-0.32587340474128723,
0.056161150336265564,
-0.5310142040252686,
-0.7961055040359497,
0.6017124056816101,
-0.6084973216056824,
0.2119605541229248,
-0.020508989691734314,
-0.6647094488143921,
-0.23779980838298798,
0.705100417137146,
-0.7159520983695984,
0.770761251449585,
0.41801440715789795,
-0.4397798776626587,
0.22253000736236572,
-0.857402503490448,
-0.4327879846096039,
0.2227211445569992,
-0.36050501465797424,
-0.38670244812965393,
-0.14598532021045685,
0.27735477685928345,
0.6743736267089844,
-1.082587480545044,
0.7503191232681274,
-0.3409945070743561,
-0.2039339542388916,
0.3864523768424988,
-0.48836424946784973,
0.9566271901130676,
0.10137805342674255,
-0.11287900060415268,
-0.01389817800372839,
-0.8841255903244019,
0.2806016504764557,
0.09210261702537537,
-0.3580276370048523,
-0.2889454960823059,
-0.09052306413650513,
-0.04874180257320404,
0.48011282086372375,
0.13120470941066742,
-0.32428961992263794,
-0.04418262839317322,
-0.3110795021057129,
0.40306028723716736,
0.401921808719635,
0.40491804480552673,
0.09354657679796219,
-0.4485180974006653,
0.8329068422317505,
0.1083001121878624,
0.1817678064107895,
0.1771365851163864,
-0.5759000778198242,
-0.5069195032119751,
-0.6953122019767761,
0.25569429993629456,
0.7227177023887634,
-0.8183587789535522,
0.6424496173858643,
-0.5738282799720764,
-0.6630799174308777,
-0.5852681398391724,
0.02231770195066929,
0.3836264908313751,
0.5557152628898621,
0.39351949095726013,
-0.4669634997844696,
-0.3642817735671997,
-0.7931832671165466,
-0.21619237959384918,
0.15099748969078064,
0.13889478147029877,
0.6729332208633423,
0.6370139718055725,
-0.4528895318508148,
0.6039502024650574,
-0.4053795039653778,
-0.38275694847106934,
-0.046024736016988754,
-0.27006131410598755,
0.4055500626564026,
0.3827996551990509,
0.17273807525634766,
-0.6186666488647461,
-0.3979630172252655,
0.000804198149126023,
-1.0129733085632324,
-0.041719287633895874,
0.1944855898618698,
0.07127512991428375,
-0.22459159791469574,
0.43321505188941956,
-0.6106222867965698,
0.07095540314912796,
0.9309200644493103,
-0.35395047068595886,
0.47526460886001587,
-0.20137877762317657,
0.3230602443218231,
-1.0939875841140747,
0.04818534851074219,
-0.13883033394813538,
-0.20851418375968933,
-0.4002654254436493,
0.23029473423957825,
-0.05680607259273529,
-0.03093794547021389,
-0.3717332184314728,
0.7278270125389099,
-0.28664666414260864,
0.2437266707420349,
0.1760939657688141,
0.5226058959960938,
0.053285304456949234,
0.30385345220565796,
-0.1665193885564804,
0.6664849519729614,
0.4983381927013397,
-0.5924215316772461,
0.7664763331413269,
0.21004082262516022,
-0.5972341299057007,
1.2378109693527222,
-0.5400539040565491,
0.28403618931770325,
0.2873512804508209,
0.02358432486653328,
-0.7420690655708313,
-0.2132217437028885,
0.13607706129550934,
-0.3321807086467743,
0.20789630711078644,
0.010248578153550625,
-0.5920162796974182,
-0.46006500720977783,
0.02415657415986061,
0.5379534363746643,
0.20134209096431732,
-0.39631593227386475,
0.35999569296836853,
0.5825850367546082,
-0.20484086871147156,
-0.3548488914966583,
-0.5913434624671936,
0.32957983016967773,
0.010430330410599709,
-1.0091623067855835,
0.19757819175720215,
-0.20391254127025604,
-0.350380539894104,
-0.05935503542423248,
0.21262438595294952,
-0.19888357818126678,
0.27134472131729126,
0.3473062813282013,
0.38017094135284424,
-0.43421393632888794,
0.315334677696228,
0.2773597538471222,
-0.12501108646392822,
0.15123476088047028,
-0.21059457957744598,
0.7694970369338989,
-0.18664665520191193,
-0.6148033142089844,
-0.2189694494009018,
0.19378229975700378,
0.490060031414032,
-0.36254656314849854,
0.5112685561180115,
0.33416593074798584,
-0.42645758390426636,
-0.06754180788993835,
-0.3624670207500458,
0.028614725917577744,
-0.4123043715953827,
0.7368144392967224,
-0.5156232714653015,
-1.0434927940368652,
0.26537543535232544,
-0.493917852640152,
-0.44898998737335205,
0.6763464212417603,
1.078396201133728,
-0.07591050118207932,
0.8627577424049377,
0.07859358191490173,
0.4098300039768219,
-0.21986539661884308,
-0.24713633954524994,
0.1591501533985138,
-1.1687389612197876,
-0.29292091727256775,
-0.21674852073192596,
0.024191079661250114,
-0.35519731044769287,
-0.6920813918113708,
0.5792106986045837,
-0.32632315158843994,
-0.1894204467535019,
0.1480374038219452,
-0.4595181941986084,
0.22753068804740906,
0.009418590925633907,
0.23910003900527954,
0.4057004153728485,
0.019796615466475487,
-0.7533590793609619,
-0.12582805752754211,
-0.6154762506484985,
-0.44588208198547363,
1.3657972812652588,
0.23701688647270203,
0.6317367553710938,
0.18709494173526764,
0.6451815366744995,
0.32705849409103394,
0.6607478857040405,
-0.9994562864303589,
0.527975857257843,
-0.3944253623485565,
-1.0280946493148804,
-0.21774041652679443,
-0.4071360230445862,
-0.9623223543167114,
0.2070767730474472,
-0.26688459515571594,
-0.6968520879745483,
-0.03818623349070549,
-0.18701697885990143,
-0.35514432191848755,
-0.049127720296382904,
-0.6710906624794006,
0.8613683581352234,
-0.23879295587539673,
-0.2917155623435974,
-0.31154724955558777,
-0.2614602744579315,
0.41237637400627136,
-0.32925114035606384,
0.21148592233657837,
-0.35531705617904663,
-0.18728448450565338,
0.7300137281417847,
-0.3437526524066925,
0.5181127190589905,
0.023711757734417915,
0.15405622124671936,
0.08260001987218857,
0.15870113670825958,
0.003703536232933402,
0.23451070487499237,
-0.35280632972717285,
0.2746889889240265,
0.21279796957969666,
-0.10797766596078873,
-0.6340545415878296,
0.7774266600608826,
-0.5982561111450195,
-0.4740590453147888,
-0.5416404008865356,
-0.6742942333221436,
-0.6072021722793579,
0.43599867820739746,
0.016136646270751953,
0.5247479677200317,
-0.5977703928947449,
0.0980975404381752,
0.5939809083938599,
-0.3698481321334839,
-0.06647133082151413,
0.5142940282821655,
-0.26641255617141724,
-0.5901324152946472,
0.7669920921325684,
0.012729203328490257,
0.18586212396621704,
0.18436317145824432,
0.05906179919838905,
-0.16012752056121826,
-0.7802066206932068,
-0.47180742025375366,
0.2541939914226532,
-0.9324100017547607,
-0.12331420183181763,
-0.6791775226593018,
-0.4064353406429291,
-0.044097159057855606,
-0.06561051309108734,
-0.25168314576148987,
-0.3427283465862274,
0.02808203734457493,
0.12594230473041534,
0.2977737784385681,
0.7451032400131226,
0.504973828792572,
0.3201278746128082,
-0.5840902328491211,
0.22333253920078278,
-0.06475221365690231,
0.7454246878623962,
-0.1733705848455429,
-0.20418664813041687,
-0.2629559338092804,
-0.24910444021224976,
-0.1676524132490158,
-0.562020480632782,
0.3084507882595062,
0.12047575414180756,
0.6398226618766785,
0.07890469580888748,
-0.12290799617767334,
0.5690836310386658,
-0.5595420598983765,
0.6416002511978149,
0.35449856519699097,
-0.6890149712562561,
0.07649033516645432,
-0.1893608123064041,
0.14102664589881897,
0.8054891228675842,
0.31670743227005005,
-0.7459608316421509,
-0.17918998003005981,
-0.48646047711372375,
-0.6859298348426819,
0.3434004485607147,
0.04808158427476883,
-0.01709417998790741,
-0.3387247622013092,
0.38930365443229675,
0.13953998684883118,
0.14525476098060608,
-0.056656625121831894,
-0.28751230239868164,
0.37659454345703125,
-0.9137873649597168,
-0.28965210914611816,
0.07788016647100449,
-0.4026457667350769,
-0.3166101276874542,
0.48134350776672363,
-0.22146788239479065,
0.4980428218841553,
0.3732590079307556,
-0.4977648854255676,
0.08293205499649048,
0.30189335346221924,
0.5595372319221497,
0.8594918251037598,
-0.2420397251844406,
0.09156952053308487,
0.2727392911911011,
-0.9927526116371155,
0.22449728846549988,
0.10042901337146759,
0.1855510175228119,
-0.28608837723731995,
0.40286582708358765,
0.4792306423187256,
0.03754625841975212,
-0.8425408601760864,
0.7471354007720947,
-0.3026135265827179,
-0.2838897407054901,
-0.4528985619544983,
0.11676903069019318,
0.3212130665779114,
0.0865306630730629,
0.0378839448094368,
0.31601330637931824,
0.21460941433906555,
-0.33304160833358765,
0.3734079599380493,
0.3770766258239746,
-0.7714847922325134,
-0.042600587010383606,
0.43972116708755493,
0.15271955728530884,
-0.4186097979545593,
0.6239281296730042,
-0.22697505354881287,
-0.4431951642036438,
0.6051045060157776,
0.3583126962184906,
0.6469369530677795,
-0.11207251995801926,
-0.14284202456474304,
0.2190219908952713,
0.3350297212600708,
0.08863140642642975,
0.566676914691925,
0.4359017610549927,
-0.624419629573822,
-0.31449538469314575,
-0.4142249524593353,
-0.48810651898384094,
0.07813579589128494,
-0.6097684502601624,
0.4200502932071686,
-0.7567295432090759,
-0.5597336292266846,
0.18078936636447906,
0.2793479859828949,
-1.123939871788025,
0.8119277358055115,
-0.11225223541259766,
1.0957188606262207,
-0.2952079176902771,
0.9907827973365784,
0.7154136300086975,
-0.2369057834148407,
-0.4060382544994354,
-0.2782014012336731,
0.19589181244373322,
-1.1314806938171387,
0.4678419232368469,
-0.03294533118605614,
-0.11708632111549377,
-0.13827301561832428,
-0.31043827533721924,
-0.6805201172828674,
1.3530203104019165,
0.2773692309856415,
-0.6148774027824402,
0.043012771755456924,
0.1211293488740921,
0.7788136601448059,
-0.8572485446929932,
0.37940070033073425,
0.6662579774856567,
0.2646787762641907,
-0.21074278652668,
-1.045951008796692,
0.427890419960022,
-0.3375244736671448,
-0.3324511647224426,
-0.031384121626615524,
-0.5748609304428101,
0.8163414001464844,
-0.18910527229309082,
0.009135122410953045,
0.055732376873493195,
0.018897121772170067,
0.31249308586120605,
0.5317243933677673,
0.3929007351398468,
0.5832014679908752,
1.0381487607955933,
-0.20956459641456604,
1.346068263053894,
-0.5191758275032043,
0.4508689343929291,
1.151671290397644,
-0.4014091193675995,
0.7817887663841248,
0.49866819381713867,
-0.28480395674705505,
0.4747892916202545,
0.6333741545677185,
-0.20130543410778046,
0.28237593173980713,
0.4707964360713959,
-0.09310901910066605,
-0.32999077439308167,
0.12345298379659653,
-0.23995402455329895,
0.46852102875709534,
0.7617542743682861,
-0.6004958748817444,
0.06260676681995392,
-0.12257887423038483,
0.17750325798988342,
-0.08700210601091385,
-0.14344555139541626,
0.57413649559021,
0.4936507046222687,
-0.6878855228424072,
0.5949239730834961,
0.12574228644371033,
0.3528593182563782,
-0.3756003677845001,
0.1694008857011795,
0.14629288017749786,
0.4210602641105652,
-0.18887262046337128,
-0.7061476707458496,
0.2532709836959839,
-0.21915346384048462,
-0.15923553705215454,
0.32083359360694885,
0.5591139793395996,
-0.13946174085140228,
-0.5342008471488953,
0.5448482632637024,
0.7935262322425842,
0.2837136685848236,
-0.01438006293028593,
-1.0367016792297363,
-0.014167563058435917,
-0.6128281950950623,
-0.20003736019134521,
0.19792310893535614,
0.20404888689517975,
-0.31218111515045166,
0.786827802658081,
0.6109552383422852,
0.08598130941390991,
-0.13825024664402008,
0.3222310543060303,
0.7702049612998962,
-0.6159239411354065,
-0.21075470745563507,
-0.9807530045509338,
0.11797118932008743,
-0.23706983029842377,
-0.34081631898880005,
0.5299775004386902,
0.5676360130310059,
0.468020498752594,
0.07764944434165955,
0.857064962387085,
0.0187063068151474,
0.5522525310516357,
-0.4789307117462158,
1.085153341293335,
-0.5540674328804016,
0.38214731216430664,
-0.14376550912857056,
-0.5238630175590515,
-0.5959395170211792,
0.34845393896102905,
-0.7198719382286072,
0.3032142221927643,
1.2923967838287354,
0.7102246284484863,
-0.053341783583164215,
0.006063055247068405,
0.542497992515564,
0.2347533255815506,
0.210379496216774,
0.8177852034568787,
0.7045711278915405,
-0.507387101650238,
0.15312136709690094,
-0.02808372862637043,
-0.19092313945293427,
-0.24075236916542053,
-0.6339165568351746,
-1.309818983078003,
-0.47379884123802185,
-0.3631707429885864,
-0.6432814598083496,
0.1817752867937088,
1.2773854732513428,
0.8119691610336304,
-0.8397883176803589,
-0.15725481510162354,
0.4081995487213135,
0.038959942758083344,
-0.3791898190975189,
-0.16472174227237701,
0.7284567356109619,
-0.06509596854448318,
-0.4115651845932007,
0.4222389757633209,
0.6348289847373962,
-0.3427909016609192,
-0.35171759128570557,
-0.30982646346092224,
-0.16677066683769226,
0.24755969643592834,
0.6585289835929871,
-0.38358041644096375,
-0.4658258259296417,
-0.0479586161673069,
0.31107866764068604,
-0.4923327565193176,
0.24208270013332367,
0.7215368151664734,
-0.5759195685386658,
0.6445919275283813,
0.15107843279838562,
0.679799497127533,
0.26269295811653137,
-0.5000469088554382,
0.64283287525177,
-0.14587704837322235,
-0.3023165464401245,
0.30567416548728943,
0.3620415925979614,
0.43659356236457825,
-0.36532050371170044,
0.50440514087677,
0.3889828324317932,
-0.36375463008880615,
-0.6104392409324646,
0.08579149842262268,
-1.2062400579452515,
-0.07991135865449905,
1.042077898979187,
-0.3686473071575165,
-0.478925496339798,
-0.6018916368484497,
-0.10969096422195435,
0.11526550352573395,
0.002161250216886401,
0.6229557991027832,
0.787227988243103,
-0.12408159673213959,
-0.11536893993616104,
-0.8520063757896423,
0.4441656470298767,
0.3334752023220062,
-0.9606768488883972,
-0.4515399932861328,
0.059499938040971756,
0.7364405989646912,
-0.0022637147922068834,
0.9753211736679077,
-0.5551227927207947,
0.5150196552276611,
-0.07328879088163376,
-0.030943311750888824,
-0.13880588114261627,
0.02101736329495907,
-0.48224759101867676,
0.12045443803071976,
0.06256607919931412,
0.22223739326000214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10861v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10861v1
|
Tailoring Vaccine Messaging with Common-Ground Opinions
| 2024-05-17T15:48:30 | 2024-05-17T15:48:30 |
Rickard Stureborg, Sanxing Chen, Ruoyu Xie, Aayushi Patel, Christopher Li, Chloe Qinyu Zhu, Tingnan Hu, Jun Yang, Bhuwan Dhingra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, 68T50 (Primary) 68T01, 68T37, 91F20 (Secondary), I.2; I.2.7; I.7
|
One way to personalize chatbot interactions is by establishing common ground
with the intended reader. A domain where establishing mutual understanding
could be particularly impactful is vaccine concerns and misinformation. Vaccine
interventions are forms of messaging which aim to answer concerns expressed
about vaccination. Tailoring responses in this domain is difficult, since
opinions often have seemingly little ideological overlap. We define the task of
tailoring vaccine interventions to a Common-Ground Opinion (CGO). Tailoring
responses to a CGO involves meaningfully improving the answer by relating it to
an opinion or belief the reader holds. In this paper we introduce TAILOR-CGO, a
dataset for evaluating how well responses are tailored to provided CGOs. We
benchmark several major LLMs on this task; finding GPT-4-Turbo performs
significantly better than others. We also build automatic evaluation metrics,
including an efficient and accurate BERT model that outperforms finetuned LLMs,
investigate how to successfully tailor vaccine messaging to CGOs, and provide
actionable recommendations from this investigation.
Code and model weights: https://github.com/rickardstureborg/tailor-cgo
Dataset: https://huggingface.co/datasets/DukeNLP/tailor-cgo
|
[
-0.32231760025024414,
-0.9187637567520142,
0.305100679397583,
0.007376747205853462,
-0.30952832102775574,
-0.04633393883705139,
-0.14701735973358154,
-0.2533540427684784,
0.290018767118454,
0.18525923788547516,
-0.43973982334136963,
-0.5915755033493042,
-0.6943452954292297,
-0.00968348141759634,
-0.01692790910601616,
1.0956279039382935,
0.4764968156814575,
0.11914714425802231,
-0.33537358045578003,
0.03792521730065346,
-0.6834747195243835,
-0.6452019214630127,
-0.4140539765357971,
-0.5187891125679016,
0.5546095967292786,
0.6546972393989563,
0.5211182832717896,
0.3320870101451874,
0.29834288358688354,
0.22592350840568542,
-0.3181571662425995,
0.19627007842063904,
-0.8236276507377625,
0.011741720139980316,
-0.3993998169898987,
-0.5075917840003967,
-0.48907628655433655,
0.34968534111976624,
0.20218199491500854,
0.4840286374092102,
-0.4122442305088043,
0.1665329933166504,
0.2184344083070755,
0.43149515986442566,
-0.6668614745140076,
-0.2791975736618042,
-0.9098513126373291,
-0.009319166652858257,
0.004629706498235464,
-0.14870962500572205,
-0.300947904586792,
-0.08512789011001587,
0.22733190655708313,
-0.6471475958824158,
0.39142417907714844,
0.14306999742984772,
0.7057303786277771,
-0.05467376112937927,
-0.45913687348365784,
-0.4067104756832123,
-0.5234074592590332,
0.6613190770149231,
-0.8562329411506653,
0.11189227551221848,
0.3330673277378082,
0.2188391536474228,
-0.5038732886314392,
-0.4853496551513672,
-0.3287197947502136,
-0.018935291096568108,
-0.05465998873114586,
0.5047630667686462,
-0.5129143595695496,
0.2528495192527771,
0.048930421471595764,
0.19327731430530548,
-0.732663094997406,
0.07520350813865662,
-0.4061732292175293,
-0.34409353137016296,
0.5747358798980713,
0.3123565912246704,
0.04821687564253807,
-0.17607317864894867,
-0.09727595001459122,
0.10726015269756317,
-0.432879239320755,
0.27126431465148926,
0.4500451385974884,
0.02370266430079937,
-0.21535193920135498,
0.3144555687904358,
-0.39243751764297485,
1.1039457321166992,
0.5439303517341614,
-0.008956088684499264,
-0.05110246315598488,
-0.355098158121109,
-0.4095672070980072,
-0.34392860531806946,
0.6138949394226074,
0.8032293915748596,
0.10780352354049683,
0.007944749668240547,
0.12217702716588974,
-0.1657741218805313,
0.5859000086784363,
-0.8387297987937927,
-0.041118115186691284,
0.20679213106632233,
-0.6519578099250793,
-0.3798883259296417,
0.04058602452278137,
-0.9430997371673584,
-0.37976759672164917,
-0.2165154218673706,
0.3322301506996155,
-0.2753062844276428,
0.17511755228042603,
0.4308233857154846,
-0.714692234992981,
0.15329928696155548,
0.5178903341293335,
-1.00577712059021,
0.09802717715501785,
0.9633505344390869,
0.7917022109031677,
-0.13017253577709198,
0.07127422839403152,
-0.5773776769638062,
0.3825583755970001,
0.06744993478059769,
1.2203410863876343,
-0.8199096918106079,
-0.5293779373168945,
-0.0063005052506923676,
-0.04651150107383728,
-0.12971952557563782,
-0.3062940537929535,
0.3960629105567932,
-0.21369418501853943,
0.45990484952926636,
-0.2521574795246124,
-0.7156643867492676,
-0.17489571869373322,
0.8366018533706665,
0.008862527087330818,
0.285660982131958,
0.019655250012874603,
-1.001634955406189,
0.4683336317539215,
-0.4627635180950165,
-0.36853060126304626,
0.008869863115251064,
-0.1514185667037964,
-0.45839208364486694,
0.3811393976211548,
0.6621780395507812,
0.5234819054603577,
-0.28518784046173096,
0.13621090352535248,
-0.8458855748176575,
-0.36959245800971985,
0.07206865400075912,
-0.2950116991996765,
0.3604660928249359,
0.06882311403751373,
0.014244185760617256,
0.3645542860031128,
-0.5275254249572754,
0.022063275799155235,
-0.018523668870329857,
-0.11338219046592712,
-0.26725131273269653,
-0.04189838469028473,
-0.16768021881580353,
-0.31682834029197693,
0.22062918543815613,
-0.3701913356781006,
0.4725044369697571,
-0.6998738050460815,
0.6132400631904602,
0.8283959627151489,
0.4326431453227997,
0.41449522972106934,
-0.7283709049224854,
0.7366056442260742,
-0.13487470149993896,
0.7460450530052185,
0.10549524426460266,
-0.8240472674369812,
-0.36134105920791626,
-0.29892292618751526,
-0.01751728355884552,
0.4667198657989502,
-0.3053528070449829,
0.33095288276672363,
-0.08789591491222382,
-0.7517160177230835,
-0.2776728868484497,
-0.12212740629911423,
0.18947717547416687,
0.6974737048149109,
0.16633988916873932,
-0.4123653769493103,
-0.29100117087364197,
-1.2074780464172363,
-0.5875201225280762,
-0.3920440971851349,
-0.1111171618103981,
0.49140286445617676,
0.32617831230163574,
-0.2304728478193283,
0.8240349888801575,
-0.6330363154411316,
0.09767955541610718,
-0.06797380745410919,
0.13886737823486328,
0.598950982093811,
0.09374494850635529,
0.7091343998908997,
-0.47102659940719604,
-0.4130851626396179,
0.15700681507587433,
-0.259164422750473,
-0.24903790652751923,
-0.05339086055755615,
0.10181519389152527,
-0.3426160216331482,
-0.03275846689939499,
-0.39885151386260986,
0.6509804725646973,
0.6494203805923462,
0.006086135748773813,
0.2888038158416748,
-0.3745879530906677,
0.594210684299469,
-1.1341898441314697,
0.04879417642951012,
-0.028948500752449036,
-0.2317265272140503,
-0.7633466124534607,
-0.1597612500190735,
-0.31742584705352783,
0.12478315085172653,
-0.5351352095603943,
0.6560811996459961,
-0.04195574298501015,
-0.007887492887675762,
-0.24537156522274017,
-0.014576324261724949,
0.13846883177757263,
0.23492684960365295,
-0.20948444306850433,
0.7909038066864014,
0.3932005763053894,
-0.5559301972389221,
0.39335665106773376,
0.48126882314682007,
-0.09761931002140045,
0.8591985702514648,
-0.9191670417785645,
0.4847171902656555,
-0.1287650167942047,
0.4915948212146759,
-0.6360901594161987,
-0.604131817817688,
0.7174763679504395,
-0.6275820732116699,
-0.1482037603855133,
-0.44641998410224915,
-0.06880722939968109,
-0.3481763005256653,
-0.3614189624786377,
0.15882457792758942,
0.43998706340789795,
-0.3219446837902069,
0.3393215835094452,
0.7228888869285583,
-0.1186424270272255,
-0.4905129075050354,
-0.607550323009491,
0.0181206576526165,
-0.49521636962890625,
-0.6349313855171204,
0.24438771605491638,
-0.3060605525970459,
0.028361091390252113,
-0.37675467133522034,
-0.10098781436681747,
-0.17069073021411896,
-0.033938534557819366,
0.22932618856430054,
-0.26186108589172363,
-0.021296007558703423,
0.23385055363178253,
0.10688561201095581,
0.07647576928138733,
-0.21876800060272217,
-0.22474618256092072,
0.39003053307533264,
-0.024447187781333923,
-0.5470628142356873,
-0.29642927646636963,
0.6108078956604004,
0.23555374145507812,
0.1338702291250229,
0.3221278190612793,
0.4172509014606476,
-0.24033695459365845,
-0.08428463339805603,
-0.29449760913848877,
-0.16920620203018188,
-0.46893247961997986,
0.2391846925020218,
-0.12138442695140839,
-0.8498271107673645,
0.22079485654830933,
0.05751458927989006,
0.061238743364810944,
0.17968881130218506,
1.0176740884780884,
-0.39635634422302246,
0.9417261481285095,
0.5209410190582275,
-0.23263126611709595,
0.6359841227531433,
0.20259974896907806,
0.12217183411121368,
-0.6434940099716187,
-0.23773880302906036,
-0.5041647553443909,
-0.2610902190208435,
-0.3133423626422882,
-0.4536941945552826,
0.4273138642311096,
0.2321711629629135,
-0.2528459429740906,
0.23083870112895966,
-0.961840808391571,
0.24106867611408234,
0.7426944375038147,
0.38619527220726013,
-0.00026895367773249745,
0.005967411678284407,
-0.03249939903616905,
0.13236460089683533,
-1.2494771480560303,
-0.6054845452308655,
1.0297620296478271,
0.17895850539207458,
0.8088082671165466,
-0.057189613580703735,
0.5771824717521667,
0.3994866907596588,
0.6065494418144226,
-0.8226243257522583,
0.2493920922279358,
-0.04953392595052719,
-0.6188439726829529,
0.036526504904031754,
-0.2496870756149292,
-1.3357107639312744,
0.09642694890499115,
-0.21769613027572632,
-1.0549180507659912,
0.17768678069114685,
0.4657410681247711,
-0.22575809061527252,
-0.11869364976882935,
-0.836726188659668,
0.7180914282798767,
-0.05373461917042732,
-0.0010321175213903189,
-0.5248854160308838,
-0.6147736310958862,
0.03434404358267784,
-0.004931421019136906,
0.17092914879322052,
-0.35226237773895264,
0.1326872706413269,
0.42537638545036316,
-0.4108540415763855,
0.9817295074462891,
-0.028969500213861465,
0.17713765799999237,
0.2277156114578247,
-0.4964723587036133,
0.20226800441741943,
0.55936199426651,
-0.21184007823467255,
0.29934313893318176,
0.2026660144329071,
-0.5112204551696777,
-0.4806976318359375,
0.4524049758911133,
-0.6582776308059692,
-1.1914736032485962,
-0.4385274052619934,
-0.46732327342033386,
-0.4061734974384308,
-0.0463114008307457,
0.3465670049190521,
0.19521014392375946,
-0.6715796589851379,
0.1142815575003624,
0.3007000982761383,
-0.4911784529685974,
0.059379156678915024,
0.6149454712867737,
0.20453941822052002,
-0.6925150156021118,
0.26421698927879333,
-0.11784661561250687,
0.10298539698123932,
0.4292800724506378,
0.6056479215621948,
-0.021849919110536575,
-0.513443112373352,
-0.2826036512851715,
-0.0661504864692688,
-0.7222859263420105,
-0.4433634281158447,
-0.5013670921325684,
-0.05771435797214508,
-0.7044868469238281,
-0.36432337760925293,
0.014617681503295898,
-0.02218697965145111,
-0.28078222274780273,
0.20439857244491577,
0.5133421421051025,
0.6991650462150574,
-0.32485130429267883,
0.6192546486854553,
-1.0221433639526367,
0.40310585498809814,
0.4022389352321625,
0.26385894417762756,
-0.2550213634967804,
-0.6744731068611145,
-0.18017879128456116,
0.6014021635055542,
-0.489118754863739,
-1.0471110343933105,
0.10883118212223053,
0.20389242470264435,
0.6817692518234253,
0.2685248851776123,
-0.15154893696308136,
0.9665943384170532,
-0.5924217700958252,
0.7653546333312988,
0.3076532781124115,
-1.0411089658737183,
0.9937100410461426,
-0.4746277332305908,
0.42689967155456543,
0.30325835943222046,
0.19186003506183624,
-0.7435591220855713,
-0.48571524024009705,
-0.6179633736610413,
-0.4077307879924774,
0.46981802582740784,
0.2965414226055145,
0.20211653411388397,
-0.06645478308200836,
0.35650864243507385,
0.21274161338806152,
0.05338484048843384,
-0.16204455494880676,
0.09029347449541092,
-0.17666980624198914,
-0.1145322248339653,
-0.05398290976881981,
-0.004970225505530834,
-0.6498260498046875,
-0.15942955017089844,
0.4363081455230713,
-0.20835812389850616,
0.25291505455970764,
0.15126600861549377,
0.07919186353683472,
0.15001799166202545,
0.23352208733558655,
0.8180136680603027,
0.7269598245620728,
-0.22310414910316467,
-0.2806311547756195,
0.18090999126434326,
-0.44957685470581055,
0.05914907529950142,
0.02347550354897976,
-0.007462597917765379,
0.05870015546679497,
0.6766408085823059,
0.666368842124939,
-0.12385071069002151,
-0.3095073103904724,
0.6262568831443787,
-0.2744627296924591,
-0.1117967888712883,
0.35435861349105835,
0.2919478118419647,
0.07913706451654434,
0.1778780221939087,
-0.09644784033298492,
-0.03103666752576828,
0.337864488363266,
-0.3893749713897705,
0.48569488525390625,
0.5741708874702454,
-0.282577782869339,
-0.4870951175689697,
0.4215119779109955,
0.4949350953102112,
-0.5188404321670532,
0.30069711804389954,
0.47537505626678467,
-0.36977002024650574,
0.7514955401420593,
0.4681815207004547,
0.6298221945762634,
-0.29299190640449524,
0.352031946182251,
0.3753921687602997,
0.22713980078697205,
0.18975317478179932,
-0.014356694184243679,
0.1801055371761322,
-0.6460737586021423,
-0.18618229031562805,
-0.22118116915225983,
-0.6889835000038147,
0.15533937513828278,
-0.6540064811706543,
0.41184568405151367,
-0.4684707820415497,
-0.38804808259010315,
0.24391908943653107,
-0.1196933463215828,
-0.8924945592880249,
0.20476679503917694,
-0.04051210731267929,
0.8841738700866699,
-0.879218578338623,
0.6552318334579468,
0.8107339143753052,
-0.3313288390636444,
-0.40139690041542053,
0.2980315685272217,
0.03440364450216293,
-1.1578108072280884,
0.010565620847046375,
0.23078681528568268,
0.05776182934641838,
-0.43513160943984985,
-0.7748487591743469,
-0.5942901968955994,
0.9283502101898193,
0.4034869074821472,
-0.8573060035705566,
0.2696566879749298,
0.19807371497154236,
0.4857999086380005,
-0.4329708218574524,
0.379477322101593,
0.27611905336380005,
0.4522494673728943,
-0.01828707754611969,
-0.8248950242996216,
-0.18580053746700287,
0.13993306457996368,
-0.08150148391723633,
-0.06198885291814804,
-0.7711763978004456,
0.019980860874056816,
0.045387886464595795,
-0.004273433703929186,
0.03915584832429886,
0.36155933141708374,
0.3352469503879547,
0.7367491126060486,
0.5133461356163025,
0.30401790142059326,
0.8560932874679565,
0.08128851652145386,
0.8764805197715759,
-0.42992082238197327,
0.3543200194835663,
1.1528884172439575,
0.014550963416695595,
0.48111286759376526,
0.6155418157577515,
-0.05458073690533638,
-0.07471553981304169,
0.9555086493492126,
-0.012604884803295135,
0.5093997716903687,
0.5555574297904968,
0.00626659020781517,
-0.18843123316764832,
-0.07245909422636032,
-0.4313986301422119,
0.5144347548484802,
0.5391226410865784,
0.08472862094640732,
-0.16785919666290283,
-0.10334569215774536,
-0.1763862669467926,
0.023218074813485146,
-0.16732195019721985,
1.001587986946106,
-0.007047813385725021,
-0.6553714275360107,
0.38976120948791504,
-0.08191477507352829,
0.4662379324436188,
-0.48138460516929626,
-0.2183721363544464,
-0.4600958824157715,
-0.0032886371482163668,
-0.032345835119485855,
-0.8843183517456055,
0.4199850559234619,
0.15064634382724762,
-0.40257740020751953,
-0.1134851723909378,
0.8474230766296387,
-0.25644451379776,
-0.3537074625492096,
0.06945264339447021,
0.41530823707580566,
0.00457000033929944,
0.14869412779808044,
-1.1269934177398682,
0.2728176414966583,
0.028154615312814713,
-0.3030543923377991,
0.11602672189474106,
0.43492817878723145,
0.05331520363688469,
0.5449466705322266,
0.7342110872268677,
0.23104684054851532,
-0.30600830912590027,
0.10418097674846649,
0.6958715915679932,
-0.49921295046806335,
-0.29778116941452026,
-0.717536449432373,
0.5807032585144043,
-0.47088685631752014,
-0.5800264477729797,
0.5694159269332886,
0.44097185134887695,
0.6103266477584839,
-0.17673875391483307,
0.8133701086044312,
0.06355570256710052,
0.3978065550327301,
-0.311056911945343,
0.6785776615142822,
-0.45555663108825684,
0.036571577191352844,
-0.021848013624548912,
-0.7449867129325867,
-0.44727370142936707,
0.4981945753097534,
-0.1889222413301468,
-0.06893238425254822,
0.18353833258152008,
0.9737476110458374,
-0.07856334745883942,
-0.1782875508069992,
0.47994911670684814,
0.10689928382635117,
0.5838988423347473,
0.5980677604675293,
0.9826318025588989,
-0.22715742886066437,
0.31071901321411133,
0.1387525200843811,
-0.5006626844406128,
-0.5711641907691956,
-1.085634708404541,
-1.0336885452270508,
-0.3162131607532501,
-0.2605292797088623,
-0.2820384204387665,
0.6768524050712585,
0.9029508233070374,
1.1771754026412964,
-0.691600501537323,
0.052264194935560226,
-0.08307081460952759,
0.11572830379009247,
-0.041658151894807816,
-0.16181069612503052,
0.11831910163164139,
-0.26324400305747986,
-0.7535786628723145,
0.2198432981967926,
0.5089333057403564,
-0.14704090356826782,
0.2690477967262268,
0.049248386174440384,
0.07625196874141693,
0.4299355149269104,
0.33463379740715027,
0.24420954287052155,
-0.7852692008018494,
-0.7300484776496887,
-0.09520844370126724,
-0.18720699846744537,
0.21396403014659882,
0.6725565791130066,
-0.6082372665405273,
0.7487637400627136,
0.5569361448287964,
0.7773146033287048,
0.43737050890922546,
-0.017976636067032814,
1.095104455947876,
-0.6182625889778137,
0.18165019154548645,
0.3553456664085388,
0.22102931141853333,
0.2453872114419937,
-0.4028472602367401,
0.4264838695526123,
0.17488132417201996,
-0.6611267924308777,
-0.45196661353111267,
0.44932228326797485,
-1.0987675189971924,
-0.22981223464012146,
1.4568381309509277,
-0.16438612341880798,
-0.02954939939081669,
0.010168799199163914,
-0.318053662776947,
0.16192591190338135,
-0.525793194770813,
0.8645829558372498,
0.9444651007652283,
-0.12724974751472473,
0.08908095955848694,
-0.24322277307510376,
0.25897806882858276,
0.30050867795944214,
-0.9400014281272888,
-0.24047543108463287,
0.3491518199443817,
0.5052556395530701,
-0.5075369477272034,
0.8381991386413574,
0.39565831422805786,
0.3009319603443146,
-0.152141734957695,
-0.17751917243003845,
0.31252312660217285,
0.008060569874942303,
-0.4092423617839813,
-0.04741794615983963,
-0.10628816485404968,
-0.2786731719970703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10860v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10860v2
|
ECR-Chain: Advancing Generative Language Models to Better Emotion-Cause Reasoners through Reasoning Chains
| 2024-05-17T15:45:08 | 2024-05-21T06:40:20 |
Zhaopei Huang, Jinming Zhao, Qin Jin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Understanding the process of emotion generation is crucial for analyzing the
causes behind emotions. Causal Emotion Entailment (CEE), an
emotion-understanding task, aims to identify the causal utterances in a
conversation that stimulate the emotions expressed in a target utterance.
However, current works in CEE mainly focus on modeling semantic and emotional
interactions in conversations, neglecting the exploration of the
emotion-generation process. This hinders the models from deeply understanding
emotions, restricting their ability to produce explainable predictions. In this
work, inspired by the emotion generation process of
"stimulus-appraisal-emotion" in the cognitive appraisal theory, we introduce a
step-by-step reasoning method, Emotion-Cause Reasoning Chain (ECR-Chain), to
infer the stimulus from the target emotional expressions in conversations.
Specifically, we first introduce the ECR-Chain to ChatGPT via few-shot
prompting, which significantly improves its performance on the CEE task. We
further propose an automated construction process to utilize ChatGPT in
building an ECR-Chain set, which can enhance the reasoning abilities of smaller
models through supervised training and assist the Vicuna-7B model in achieving
state-of-the-art CEE performance. Moreover, our methods can enable these
generative language models to effectively perform emotion-cause reasoning in an
explainable manner. Our code, data and more details are at
https://github.com/hzp3517/ECR-Chain.
|
[
-0.5916684865951538,
-0.9636942744255066,
0.5728742480278015,
-0.07328186184167862,
-0.052954141050577164,
-0.1964425891637802,
-0.2343597412109375,
-0.539919912815094,
0.03906868398189545,
0.5219154953956604,
-0.5166676640510559,
-0.26891252398490906,
-0.385501891374588,
0.17214208841323853,
-0.43381038308143616,
0.9692980051040649,
-0.10181496292352676,
-0.19153772294521332,
-0.05889461934566498,
0.11176956444978714,
-0.3486170172691345,
-0.5602564215660095,
-1.060211181640625,
-0.383949875831604,
0.8163065314292908,
0.570202112197876,
0.45079073309898376,
0.4570890963077545,
0.42451614141464233,
0.30637648701667786,
0.07211682945489883,
0.10956227034330368,
-0.42320603132247925,
0.2705279290676117,
-0.2730114459991455,
-0.386640340089798,
-0.5150638222694397,
-0.5151876211166382,
0.02994110807776451,
0.2934773862361908,
-0.48417869210243225,
-0.0435907356441021,
-0.08974414318799973,
0.9655376076698303,
-0.8347665071487427,
-0.022423483431339264,
-0.6481482982635498,
-0.17726100981235504,
-0.06561098992824554,
-0.3870415985584259,
-0.6161288619041443,
-0.3470707833766937,
0.229091078042984,
-0.4960513412952423,
0.26535719633102417,
0.32945987582206726,
0.7689037919044495,
-0.01465749554336071,
-0.48079654574394226,
-0.5363616347312927,
-0.7663289904594421,
0.21059922873973846,
-0.5644450783729553,
0.3390335738658905,
0.2948141396045685,
0.19738301634788513,
-0.22050057351589203,
-0.6596644520759583,
-0.8568413853645325,
-0.15710629522800446,
0.23687386512756348,
0.45880165696144104,
-0.39040783047676086,
0.38528573513031006,
0.25812432169914246,
0.5047399401664734,
-0.5968278050422668,
-0.15481509268283844,
-0.1498229205608368,
0.1641089767217636,
0.4502463638782501,
0.20481900870800018,
0.4076045751571655,
-0.024811653420329094,
-0.14074821770191193,
-0.3745396137237549,
-0.8065940737724304,
-0.20417095720767975,
0.48453208804130554,
0.050625648349523544,
-0.11099842190742493,
0.528895914554596,
-0.23595382273197174,
0.5011857748031616,
0.2648622393608093,
0.5321911573410034,
-0.2361684888601303,
-0.008358662948012352,
-0.3445173501968384,
0.37920036911964417,
0.8174517154693604,
0.22095395624637604,
0.30201852321624756,
0.09232494235038757,
0.12227077037096024,
0.6076459884643555,
0.2990671992301941,
-0.8055216073989868,
-0.3839099109172821,
0.44525834918022156,
-0.3045874238014221,
-0.27448034286499023,
-0.0605773851275444,
-0.8016316890716553,
-0.22956864535808563,
-0.31193625926971436,
0.2888878285884857,
-0.3815172612667084,
-0.3812538683414459,
0.29169872403144836,
-0.1632295548915863,
0.12189099937677383,
0.1984320729970932,
-0.8478734493255615,
0.4871506989002228,
0.4731115698814392,
0.41175270080566406,
0.29400634765625,
-0.060784779489040375,
-0.44472265243530273,
0.2021462619304657,
-0.33091506361961365,
1.0452827215194702,
-0.5046275854110718,
-0.18042942881584167,
0.12683497369289398,
0.033005520701408386,
-0.06054280325770378,
-0.4058597683906555,
0.7786862254142761,
-0.5403537154197693,
0.14834226667881012,
-0.20415136218070984,
-0.6643677949905396,
-0.23959535360336304,
0.3049755394458771,
-0.3955009877681732,
0.8286831378936768,
-0.2674975097179413,
-0.7463278770446777,
0.13020393252372742,
-0.491103857755661,
-0.4019959270954132,
-0.07839985191822052,
0.022020045667886734,
-0.31319716572761536,
0.2899287939071655,
0.22815069556236267,
0.33205410838127136,
-0.6652003526687622,
0.35235169529914856,
-0.4142489433288574,
0.05742737650871277,
0.11078229546546936,
-0.4338820278644562,
0.27988192439079285,
0.29368162155151367,
-0.3204555809497833,
0.15758396685123444,
-0.811608076095581,
-0.09929019212722778,
-0.00009869651694316417,
-0.009921899996697903,
-0.4571273922920227,
0.3587965667247772,
-0.07236915826797485,
0.5030489563941956,
-0.14852893352508545,
-0.28260037302970886,
-0.011845288798213005,
-0.4119267463684082,
0.1875886768102646,
0.7833467125892639,
0.38308626413345337,
0.3883665204048157,
-0.03958870470523834,
0.5396245121955872,
0.19486147165298462,
0.33858466148376465,
-0.4274809658527374,
-0.3380934000015259,
-1.0661159753799438,
0.328329473733902,
-0.13076940178871155,
0.503605842590332,
-0.779874324798584,
0.355298787355423,
0.10959407687187195,
-0.39342811703681946,
-0.29800060391426086,
-0.20160995423793793,
0.45563408732414246,
0.6002504825592041,
0.35884878039360046,
-0.1992407888174057,
-0.7331580519676208,
-0.6958158612251282,
-0.3072423040866852,
-0.5144599080085754,
-0.027494968846440315,
0.1323051154613495,
0.49808329343795776,
-0.051539987325668335,
0.5972723364830017,
-0.5227739810943604,
0.19678862392902374,
-0.1463034749031067,
0.3311990201473236,
0.12815463542938232,
0.3962697684764862,
-0.09257731586694717,
-0.5503581166267395,
-0.3014303147792816,
0.27600762248039246,
-0.7787573933601379,
-0.16667313873767853,
-0.23411977291107178,
-0.5976404547691345,
0.031382910907268524,
0.25550758838653564,
-0.359983891248703,
0.3736596703529358,
0.4670283794403076,
-0.5238744616508484,
0.5291882157325745,
-0.265231728553772,
0.2747896611690521,
-0.8181815147399902,
-0.1271342933177948,
0.2567487359046936,
0.10414402186870575,
-0.5819648504257202,
-0.09467405080795288,
-0.15758338570594788,
-0.017184261232614517,
-0.3131106495857239,
0.2004007250070572,
-0.3951092064380646,
0.18020851910114288,
-0.2649458050727844,
0.234945148229599,
0.13479360938072205,
0.5879720449447632,
0.19737474620342255,
0.17798778414726257,
0.6715253591537476,
-0.8400298357009888,
0.24313564598560333,
0.28109246492385864,
-0.12860830128192902,
0.8140179514884949,
-0.6552398800849915,
0.2168145477771759,
-0.20158828794956207,
0.18591882288455963,
-0.6270578503608704,
-0.2752518355846405,
0.29850926995277405,
-0.31280940771102905,
0.10478448122739792,
-0.11005982011556625,
-0.5174132585525513,
-0.5287176966667175,
0.06609342247247696,
0.21993575990200043,
0.5374302864074707,
-0.7465672492980957,
0.6267171502113342,
0.14108064770698547,
0.15811994671821594,
-0.03115914948284626,
-0.38726305961608887,
0.05848265439271927,
-0.39848262071609497,
-0.7239354848861694,
0.2525366544723511,
-0.1632525622844696,
-0.333980530500412,
-0.09560435265302658,
-0.1171199381351471,
-0.023026395589113235,
-0.11827091127634048,
0.05203958973288536,
0.16159303486347198,
-0.12261876463890076,
0.33722954988479614,
0.1348140686750412,
-0.22348035871982574,
0.31111225485801697,
-0.1974675953388214,
0.370257705450058,
-0.31221622228622437,
-0.4090854525566101,
-0.35271167755126953,
0.23973582684993744,
0.41529229283332825,
-0.10769101232290268,
0.7735778093338013,
0.36672452092170715,
-0.3610084056854248,
-0.16507861018180847,
-0.5766375064849854,
-0.40958133339881897,
-0.38866743445396423,
0.16813449561595917,
-0.41575342416763306,
-0.7791128158569336,
0.6161400079727173,
-0.3372958302497864,
-0.3901749849319458,
0.5137249827384949,
0.6148363947868347,
-0.026018112897872925,
1.317478060722351,
0.40710529685020447,
0.014828196726739407,
0.4353654682636261,
-0.08987385034561157,
0.5061892867088318,
-0.9309391975402832,
-0.2515697181224823,
-0.4406062960624695,
0.15613815188407898,
-0.7303535342216492,
-0.11677337437868118,
0.4162071943283081,
0.5255707502365112,
-0.5239577293395996,
0.2778829038143158,
-0.5913873314857483,
0.3735882043838501,
0.0561220645904541,
0.19158998131752014,
0.30763474106788635,
-0.14676010608673096,
0.06631860136985779,
0.36711594462394714,
-0.9026244282722473,
-0.4890461564064026,
0.4914858639240265,
0.266692191362381,
0.8064722418785095,
0.0008476994698867202,
0.5629611015319824,
0.09648055583238602,
0.4317558705806732,
-0.6759073734283447,
0.42351776361465454,
0.1630830317735672,
-0.4658079147338867,
-0.00994384940713644,
-0.3545234799385071,
-0.7794539928436279,
0.38359978795051575,
-0.10453857481479645,
-0.9731258749961853,
0.4919331669807434,
0.5348535776138306,
-0.01614220440387726,
0.1463998258113861,
-0.6978350281715393,
0.897640585899353,
-0.2300361692905426,
-0.6473764777183533,
-0.4043828547000885,
-0.552945613861084,
0.6515256762504578,
0.26497524976730347,
0.3293986916542053,
0.016925755888223648,
0.5329551696777344,
0.5595732927322388,
-1.0172451734542847,
0.7793410420417786,
0.053887635469436646,
-0.25388744473457336,
0.7304527163505554,
0.2273988276720047,
0.934749960899353,
-0.13013918697834015,
0.007068135309964418,
-0.12881839275360107,
-0.3363371789455414,
0.009368534199893475,
-0.6928788423538208,
0.48114800453186035,
-0.28218233585357666,
-0.4187238812446594,
-0.20091000199317932,
-0.060451433062553406,
-0.0019010971300303936,
-0.2437027543783188,
0.3344375193119049,
0.4135199785232544,
-0.20033404231071472,
-0.13710297644138336,
0.6145814061164856,
-0.29561692476272583,
0.31281960010528564,
0.37168124318122864,
-0.050719548016786575,
-0.36003389954566956,
0.8069818615913391,
-0.4192276895046234,
0.37821948528289795,
0.4423155188560486,
0.42491233348846436,
-0.16261699795722961,
0.07348654419183731,
-0.12745510041713715,
-0.09597082436084747,
-0.6419130563735962,
-0.24867971241474152,
-0.6122624278068542,
0.0629272311925888,
0.024022839963436127,
-0.3465748429298401,
-0.5347192883491516,
-0.19879060983657837,
0.050533466041088104,
-0.22504769265651703,
0.7434367537498474,
0.6553934812545776,
-0.18606030941009521,
0.3907047212123871,
-0.7092183828353882,
0.2400793582201004,
0.322381854057312,
0.21214905381202698,
0.4345158636569977,
-0.24060992896556854,
-0.3836667239665985,
-0.057148829102516174,
-0.621813178062439,
-1.0529676675796509,
0.4467603862285614,
0.0888584554195404,
0.13134552538394928,
0.6359035968780518,
0.21968451142311096,
0.9354705810546875,
-0.5609214901924133,
0.5827707052230835,
0.561205267906189,
-1.2435719966888428,
0.9981160759925842,
-0.47620266675949097,
0.024608513340353966,
0.13614416122436523,
0.08890718221664429,
-0.7396606206893921,
-0.644226610660553,
-0.9579786062240601,
-1.2109144926071167,
0.46652793884277344,
0.5264154672622681,
-0.20027829706668854,
-0.7569944262504578,
0.14327190816402435,
-0.20015326142311096,
-0.0852014347910881,
-0.5319525003433228,
-0.2466849833726883,
0.02425437793135643,
-0.3145730197429657,
0.3487851321697235,
-0.26171019673347473,
0.20034649968147278,
-0.03680172935128212,
0.8271546363830566,
-0.14985667169094086,
0.3740408420562744,
0.39574021100997925,
-0.02050687000155449,
-0.42016685009002686,
0.5540565252304077,
0.21786043047904968,
0.4050559401512146,
-0.1384219527244568,
0.20245955884456635,
0.19014813005924225,
0.0023462437093257904,
0.15340988337993622,
-0.076659195125103,
0.18918097019195557,
-0.3144465982913971,
0.2601844370365143,
0.9317569136619568,
0.2373594343662262,
-0.546943724155426,
0.3952954411506653,
-0.03684061020612717,
-0.014913707040250301,
-0.3001888394355774,
-0.046626850962638855,
0.01330247987061739,
0.31587013602256775,
-0.011190439574420452,
-0.032754309475421906,
0.4659755229949951,
-0.575387179851532,
0.1165340319275856,
0.08136448264122009,
-0.37119871377944946,
-0.5312516689300537,
0.7599159479141235,
0.17296116054058075,
0.0037090720143169165,
0.6829982399940491,
-0.049205102026462555,
-0.5507267117500305,
0.8754411935806274,
0.7003109455108643,
1.089449167251587,
-0.3718174993991852,
0.28326982259750366,
0.6919925212860107,
0.15097418427467346,
-0.4439862072467804,
0.361621230840683,
-0.10887426882982254,
-0.9771474599838257,
-0.46407225728034973,
-0.32395654916763306,
-0.5502794981002808,
-0.298880934715271,
-0.9988060593605042,
0.2649560570716858,
-0.04695882275700569,
0.011453190818428993,
-0.305984765291214,
-0.6814462542533875,
-0.7831031084060669,
0.33889901638031006,
0.15564711391925812,
0.5799134373664856,
-0.8763331174850464,
0.5020583271980286,
0.33407071232795715,
-0.712553083896637,
-0.8731305599212646,
-0.12658461928367615,
-0.13240736722946167,
-0.4536941945552826,
0.7279353141784668,
0.04910594969987869,
-0.14017875492572784,
0.1430761069059372,
-0.47285938262939453,
-0.43030089139938354,
0.825641393661499,
-0.020900627598166466,
-0.9010804295539856,
0.25594890117645264,
-0.2607165277004242,
0.6853259205818176,
-0.4088823199272156,
0.6902334690093994,
0.5434871912002563,
0.34264492988586426,
0.2275630086660385,
-0.3632602095603943,
0.19864881038665771,
-0.23748241364955902,
0.15705552697181702,
0.37532785534858704,
-0.513203501701355,
0.39627689123153687,
-0.34280964732170105,
-0.18746612966060638,
-0.1554393619298935,
0.5472177863121033,
0.7227604985237122,
0.40014803409576416,
0.43597182631492615,
0.6403490304946899,
0.7182044982910156,
-0.11641409993171692,
1.3530040979385376,
-0.4561259150505066,
0.3702934682369232,
1.1677120923995972,
-0.3781948983669281,
1.0037970542907715,
0.5729191303253174,
-0.17856931686401367,
0.9234777092933655,
0.6528225541114807,
0.27093711495399475,
0.468124121427536,
0.5068978071212769,
-0.509515106678009,
-0.34504956007003784,
-0.21653635799884796,
-0.20027075707912445,
0.2625110447406769,
0.516446053981781,
-0.3228972852230072,
0.011074289679527283,
-0.0741049200296402,
-0.0011939681135118008,
-0.10473012924194336,
-0.3876194655895233,
0.8294659852981567,
0.3365199565887451,
-0.6338014602661133,
0.26808562874794006,
-0.2819634675979614,
0.2652300000190735,
-0.5084953308105469,
-0.172653928399086,
-0.1755378544330597,
0.20358042418956757,
-0.18338893353939056,
-0.48839202523231506,
0.3370856046676636,
0.21364933252334595,
-0.19466613233089447,
-0.07915626466274261,
0.8048582673072815,
-0.5370342135429382,
-0.36189180612564087,
0.4052494168281555,
0.47589921951293945,
0.038178589195013046,
-0.09418842941522598,
-0.41189026832580566,
-0.005795452278107405,
-0.2917080223560333,
-0.4720615744590759,
0.1001780778169632,
0.8756752014160156,
-0.10081201046705246,
0.5217386484146118,
0.7139139771461487,
-0.20879937708377838,
-0.18131911754608154,
0.5865069627761841,
0.8078241348266602,
-0.7670433521270752,
-0.5277160406112671,
-1.1833007335662842,
0.8752986192703247,
-0.03276593238115311,
-0.04630552604794502,
0.4235343337059021,
0.37161269783973694,
0.6548627614974976,
-0.14588883519172668,
0.7224546074867249,
-0.26834020018577576,
-0.02958562783896923,
-0.6113508939743042,
0.2561883330345154,
-0.3322550356388092,
0.25172102451324463,
-0.5867787599563599,
-0.752561628818512,
-0.11351371556520462,
0.6575824022293091,
-0.30023327469825745,
-0.0445384681224823,
1.1104382276535034,
0.7199177145957947,
0.30739399790763855,
0.2777974009513855,
0.27310410141944885,
0.3960878252983093,
0.34158286452293396,
0.9405118823051453,
1.1077513694763184,
-0.6320584416389465,
0.4821659028530121,
-0.12473022937774658,
-0.13399562239646912,
0.09292837977409363,
-1.1062315702438354,
-0.7098910808563232,
-0.44673943519592285,
-0.6891919374465942,
-0.3749072253704071,
0.16431283950805664,
0.7675634026527405,
0.39996179938316345,
-0.7164077758789062,
-0.2707689702510834,
-1.0433275699615479,
0.31484684348106384,
-0.3626929819583893,
-0.28148192167282104,
0.292987585067749,
-0.3405677378177643,
-0.4076352119445801,
0.17371709644794464,
0.4058750867843628,
-0.17257066071033478,
0.18312978744506836,
-0.32375091314315796,
-0.13263894617557526,
0.1546986699104309,
0.7854251265525818,
0.343471884727478,
-0.7498129606246948,
-0.24117325246334076,
-0.3979865610599518,
0.32518771290779114,
-0.055069684982299805,
0.9221378564834595,
-0.5584014058113098,
0.6177313923835754,
0.4924762547016144,
0.31984150409698486,
0.6254752278327942,
-0.22732412815093994,
0.8815035223960876,
-0.44557198882102966,
-0.19865332543849945,
-0.2044122815132141,
0.5756590962409973,
0.14655353128910065,
-0.5204330682754517,
0.6270393133163452,
0.13712036609649658,
-0.7229962944984436,
-0.42340710759162903,
0.3693470060825348,
-0.9621747732162476,
0.053412385284900665,
0.8217849135398865,
0.016328776255249977,
-0.25311771035194397,
0.15731023252010345,
-0.23889733850955963,
0.6255289912223816,
-0.46531036496162415,
0.764062225818634,
0.5540120005607605,
-0.45723387598991394,
-0.4863737225532532,
-0.38780030608177185,
0.21443356573581696,
0.2173304408788681,
-1.3184489011764526,
0.24291229248046875,
0.5735465288162231,
-0.10109025985002518,
-0.16527657210826874,
0.615573525428772,
-0.12354414165019989,
0.20137730240821838,
0.07803630828857422,
0.5650849342346191,
0.34257030487060547,
-0.1811758279800415,
-0.12130718678236008,
-0.004691936541348696,
-0.07428532838821411,
-0.02277356944978237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13041v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13041v3
|
Assessing Political Bias in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-17T15:30:18 | 2024-06-05T05:48:27 |
Luca Rettenberger, Markus Reischl, Mark Schutera
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The assessment of bias within Large Language Models (LLMs) has emerged as a
critical concern in the contemporary discourse surrounding Artificial
Intelligence (AI) in the context of their potential impact on societal
dynamics. Recognizing and considering political bias within LLM applications is
especially important when closing in on the tipping point toward performative
prediction. Then, being educated about potential effects and the societal
behavior LLMs can drive at scale due to their interplay with human operators.
In this way, the upcoming elections of the European Parliament will not remain
unaffected by LLMs. We evaluate the political bias of the currently most
popular open-source LLMs (instruct or assistant models) concerning political
issues within the European Union (EU) from a German voter's perspective. To do
so, we use the "Wahl-O-Mat," a voting advice application used in Germany. From
the voting advice of the "Wahl-O-Mat" we quantize the degree of alignment of
LLMs with German political parties. We show that larger models, such as
Llama3-70B, tend to align more closely with left-leaning political parties,
while smaller models often remain neutral, particularly when prompted in
English. The central finding is that LLMs are similarly biased, with low
variances in the alignment concerning a specific party. Our findings underline
the importance of rigorously assessing and making bias transparent in LLMs to
safeguard the integrity and trustworthiness of applications that employ the
capabilities of performative prediction and the invisible hand of machine
learning prediction and language generation.
|
[
-0.5038949251174927,
-0.7248446941375732,
0.7577415108680725,
0.0603005476295948,
-0.09387435764074326,
0.051351726055145264,
-0.4755215346813202,
-0.18182678520679474,
0.029545653611421585,
0.5687240362167358,
-0.5560989379882812,
-0.5100567936897278,
-0.6888826489448547,
-0.1301906853914261,
-0.31394535303115845,
0.7329297065734863,
0.0822363942861557,
0.6378718018531799,
-0.45185187458992004,
-0.17279237508773804,
-0.12345540523529053,
-0.6727656722068787,
-0.2541576325893402,
-0.9879611134529114,
0.2108752727508545,
0.30275318026542664,
0.8091880083084106,
0.6727184653282166,
0.3460451662540436,
0.3312644362449646,
-0.1343943327665329,
-0.14650915563106537,
-0.5240107774734497,
-0.15276449918746948,
-0.3021743893623352,
-0.5864656567573547,
-0.40705156326293945,
0.3003235161304474,
0.5140823721885681,
0.6215128302574158,
-0.032359469681978226,
0.22834064066410065,
0.09156637638807297,
0.838521420955658,
-0.5681217312812805,
0.3453669846057892,
-0.9139623045921326,
-0.05095496028661728,
-0.36326977610588074,
0.051694680005311966,
-0.375776469707489,
-0.4624948501586914,
0.0711410641670227,
0.03839687630534172,
-0.11321411281824112,
-0.09397048503160477,
0.5430922508239746,
0.33405858278274536,
-0.4165835976600647,
-0.27849647402763367,
-0.663914144039154,
0.828994631767273,
-0.8278921246528625,
0.49181222915649414,
0.19007615745067596,
0.18723642826080322,
-0.43044137954711914,
-0.10832861065864563,
-0.596265435218811,
-0.20640407502651215,
0.3007911145687103,
0.01051091868430376,
-0.18642039597034454,
0.01431459654122591,
0.01473214477300644,
-0.005394740030169487,
-0.07946249842643738,
0.4264434576034546,
-0.1881287395954132,
-0.17633956670761108,
0.6753193736076355,
0.025877736508846283,
-0.009018928743898869,
-0.1326690912246704,
-0.32923179864883423,
-0.02047877199947834,
-0.8785686492919922,
-0.2418113797903061,
0.8668957948684692,
0.36305809020996094,
-0.17336183786392212,
0.5176251530647278,
0.1285971701145172,
0.49796897172927856,
0.3392038643360138,
0.1869170218706131,
0.23384767770767212,
-0.1434866338968277,
-0.1021074578166008,
0.011331362649798393,
1.0051051378250122,
0.44535738229751587,
0.6900307536125183,
0.18690982460975647,
-0.03494207561016083,
0.38743647933006287,
0.10447799414396286,
-0.5770329236984253,
0.06847524642944336,
0.30642595887184143,
-0.3818410634994507,
-0.3787427246570587,
0.33477911353111267,
-0.8793521523475647,
-0.8452317118644714,
-0.4598604738712311,
-0.05237893387675285,
-0.019770024344325066,
-0.20289793610572815,
-0.023838600143790245,
0.20530644059181213,
0.2455846220254898,
0.3712156414985657,
-0.4311528503894806,
0.05249178782105446,
1.0366525650024414,
0.3445989787578583,
-0.44347745180130005,
-0.1440698206424713,
-0.4114721119403839,
-0.083454929292202,
-0.6231918334960938,
0.6609259843826294,
-0.7862069010734558,
-0.24177652597427368,
0.3222375810146332,
0.015256399288773537,
0.2145434021949768,
-0.61868816614151,
0.6332182288169861,
-0.5066900253295898,
0.41812849044799805,
-0.13084155321121216,
-0.7096028923988342,
-0.17202112078666687,
0.07451935112476349,
-0.6903220415115356,
0.8596936464309692,
-0.20139212906360626,
-0.7008538246154785,
0.5306742191314697,
-0.7458779215812683,
-0.11978260427713394,
-0.3238273859024048,
-0.6948856115341187,
-0.45197057723999023,
0.03753292188048363,
0.22837045788764954,
0.5398327112197876,
-0.18538160622119904,
0.5198657512664795,
-0.5943558216094971,
-0.2939286231994629,
0.42400407791137695,
-0.38477423787117004,
0.7777715921401978,
-0.1453709751367569,
-0.6311731934547424,
0.3864392638206482,
-0.5463160872459412,
-0.19571301341056824,
-0.01697203889489174,
-0.23053520917892456,
-0.20915639400482178,
0.27829593420028687,
-0.072455033659935,
0.27474090456962585,
0.22658342123031616,
-0.6367162466049194,
0.02676529996097088,
-0.40522500872612,
0.47620224952697754,
1.3514609336853027,
-0.26586002111434937,
0.6354497075080872,
-0.14268167316913605,
0.5255589485168457,
-0.08293797820806503,
0.04998301342129707,
0.29449132084846497,
-0.4195665717124939,
-0.5504555106163025,
0.03857804462313652,
0.45441630482673645,
0.5785724520683289,
-0.30723750591278076,
0.6495832204818726,
-0.28164753317832947,
-0.5767839550971985,
-0.4688026010990143,
0.14612790942192078,
0.08379293978214264,
0.13810355961322784,
-0.3040195107460022,
0.0575559027493,
-0.3898356556892395,
-1.0247702598571777,
-0.4917980134487152,
-0.4274086356163025,
-0.1642364114522934,
0.6214360594749451,
0.7184122204780579,
-0.350282222032547,
0.7372166514396667,
0.0794086903333664,
-0.3664754331111908,
-0.0018584062345325947,
-0.18533039093017578,
0.316747784614563,
0.14391323924064636,
0.287276029586792,
-0.5337210297584534,
-0.34382715821266174,
0.11807018518447876,
-0.42313435673713684,
-0.29487165808677673,
0.1721101552248001,
-0.12611126899719238,
0.536246120929718,
0.26337185502052307,
-0.47473135590553284,
0.15534134209156036,
0.8344044089317322,
-0.5627694725990295,
0.11930981278419495,
0.08255163580179214,
0.03892441838979721,
-0.662975549697876,
-0.018215646967291832,
0.02387409657239914,
-0.4072914719581604,
-0.4102565348148346,
-0.08340929448604584,
0.001042124698869884,
0.4053247570991516,
-0.5967798233032227,
0.5389426350593567,
-0.2212800234556198,
-0.16935472190380096,
-0.28547441959381104,
0.21285560727119446,
-0.29970991611480713,
0.09706815332174301,
-0.0751374289393425,
0.8442480564117432,
0.2881639897823334,
-0.2015271931886673,
0.04463467374444008,
-0.06893900036811829,
-0.48047274351119995,
0.6112033128738403,
-0.274301141500473,
0.5187495350837708,
-0.11035299301147461,
0.21880678832530975,
-0.7905482053756714,
-0.1290435492992401,
0.16653236746788025,
-0.34227684140205383,
0.10292733460664749,
0.09450379014015198,
-0.4556019604206085,
-0.250414103269577,
-0.26660290360450745,
0.035532910376787186,
0.5428452491760254,
-0.4990633428096771,
0.7408183813095093,
0.8141889572143555,
0.07237795740365982,
-0.6416562795639038,
-0.48260676860809326,
-0.028900614008307457,
-0.34910786151885986,
-0.5557419657707214,
-0.04306851699948311,
0.28542011976242065,
-0.8083330392837524,
-0.046983134001493454,
-0.011316503398120403,
0.17051240801811218,
0.011704705655574799,
0.3320083022117615,
0.25215598940849304,
-0.008712414652109146,
-0.038161154836416245,
-0.26012319326400757,
0.04708587005734444,
0.29422059655189514,
-0.1470785290002823,
0.6052554249763489,
-0.209427610039711,
-0.5969522595405579,
-0.3036371171474457,
0.13168108463287354,
0.7622053027153015,
0.1033378392457962,
0.4835878014564514,
0.3374260365962982,
-0.2971237897872925,
-0.15822814404964447,
-0.735032856464386,
-0.20393921434879303,
-0.45745158195495605,
0.5641348958015442,
0.16071917116641998,
-0.8067983388900757,
0.5980343818664551,
-0.14326003193855286,
0.12854322791099548,
0.5871298909187317,
1.097320556640625,
-0.01137471478432417,
1.2197779417037964,
0.663543164730072,
-0.4604073166847229,
0.3490009307861328,
-0.008926755748689175,
0.06412118673324585,
-0.4265178442001343,
-0.18684907257556915,
-0.7125180959701538,
-0.2634943723678589,
-0.7684800028800964,
-0.6272774934768677,
0.1992367058992386,
-0.3556331992149353,
-0.5338482856750488,
-0.2977171838283539,
-0.42560985684394836,
0.5558778047561646,
0.606219470500946,
-0.0599166639149189,
0.03169902414083481,
0.08066866546869278,
0.08707665652036667,
-0.13711969554424286,
-0.5984045267105103,
-0.9006215929985046,
1.1669219732284546,
0.6588670015335083,
0.8390716314315796,
-0.3428196310997009,
0.5713173747062683,
0.5215005874633789,
0.4534241557121277,
-0.6518218517303467,
0.5217111706733704,
-0.19463911652565002,
-0.6202037930488586,
-0.36808347702026367,
-0.3080882728099823,
-0.6229746341705322,
0.31381869316101074,
-0.0918060913681984,
-0.6530399918556213,
0.2187548279762268,
-0.01237413939088583,
0.09278236329555511,
0.5533691048622131,
-0.32620957493782043,
0.619111180305481,
-0.38057225942611694,
-0.39515402913093567,
-0.30540287494659424,
-0.42361539602279663,
0.2125360518693924,
-0.20560723543167114,
0.5660268068313599,
-0.42421314120292664,
-0.4017030596733093,
1.0289056301116943,
-0.21383216977119446,
0.9266842603683472,
-0.3411678373813629,
-0.4042886793613434,
-0.06842543184757233,
-0.12855269014835358,
0.6268519759178162,
-0.3660958409309387,
-0.4714907109737396,
0.7439026236534119,
-0.012532580643892288,
-0.26623260974884033,
-0.2718557119369507,
0.6860327124595642,
-0.9806526899337769,
-0.7965385317802429,
-0.44290441274642944,
-0.524535059928894,
-0.1844681352376938,
0.03775002434849739,
0.00292704114690423,
-0.267814964056015,
-0.47563523054122925,
0.13060753047466278,
0.3533088266849518,
-0.057542189955711365,
0.15369975566864014,
0.46120572090148926,
-0.41081303358078003,
-0.27189192175865173,
0.59902423620224,
0.18394482135772705,
0.20198416709899902,
-0.27252495288848877,
0.4631810188293457,
-0.28189191222190857,
-0.32424724102020264,
-0.6634171605110168,
0.21957743167877197,
-0.6400852203369141,
-0.06309990584850311,
-0.18293315172195435,
0.007460706867277622,
0.09071388095617294,
-0.10573935508728027,
-0.4295240044593811,
-0.2846512794494629,
-0.3104375898838043,
-0.18726660311222076,
0.24053969979286194,
0.9836300611495972,
0.05893172323703766,
0.16999801993370056,
-0.12872865796089172,
-0.01379024051129818,
-0.22543349862098694,
0.42266684770584106,
-0.248749777674675,
-0.382946252822876,
0.06635349988937378,
0.09816019237041473,
-0.2924695312976837,
-1.119158387184143,
-0.015843309462070465,
0.07986951619386673,
0.5773827433586121,
0.7228174805641174,
0.15081903338432312,
0.2686014473438263,
-0.7307695746421814,
1.0343204736709595,
-0.026154950261116028,
-0.8421221375465393,
0.3240688741207123,
-0.41717544198036194,
0.1134089007973671,
0.45611372590065,
0.2635040879249573,
-0.14876893162727356,
-0.8986281156539917,
-0.6306151747703552,
-0.6103934049606323,
0.7395473718643188,
-0.10222296416759491,
0.497763067483902,
0.07518567889928818,
0.18263573944568634,
0.28520748019218445,
0.37110668420791626,
-0.7556933164596558,
-0.37930285930633545,
0.1683068424463272,
-0.09890278428792953,
0.01039647776633501,
-0.2574147880077362,
-0.40737128257751465,
-0.13667374849319458,
0.8083372712135315,
-0.14938977360725403,
0.10768052935600281,
-0.019449718296527863,
0.41099539399147034,
-0.3851720690727234,
0.4222778081893921,
0.5462467670440674,
0.9910978674888611,
-0.07633306086063385,
0.01663089729845524,
0.27584847807884216,
-0.1905793845653534,
0.3099539279937744,
-0.09402763098478317,
-0.42937171459198,
0.1253783255815506,
0.3561866581439972,
0.6505023837089539,
-0.288492888212204,
-0.5394330620765686,
0.5714073181152344,
0.2571566700935364,
-0.3462775945663452,
-0.4695269763469696,
-0.04775398224592209,
0.18622474372386932,
0.37025877833366394,
0.2439114898443222,
-0.02518472634255886,
-0.09714198857545853,
-0.7140107750892639,
0.08111448585987091,
1.0031726360321045,
-0.5571336150169373,
-0.18886391818523407,
0.5504700541496277,
0.3495810925960541,
-0.5299468636512756,
0.16029278934001923,
0.18851971626281738,
-0.9196648597717285,
0.6664906144142151,
0.1697981059551239,
0.7351401448249817,
-0.3813931941986084,
-0.012978468090295792,
-0.0909757986664772,
0.5089945197105408,
0.2034691572189331,
0.3780759572982788,
0.3254481554031372,
-0.7177342176437378,
-0.38529276847839355,
-0.2799493670463562,
-0.5456581115722656,
0.2538987100124359,
-0.4417629837989807,
0.282086044549942,
-0.34173324704170227,
-0.46877989172935486,
-0.14363473653793335,
0.18532823026180267,
-0.5532737374305725,
-0.24477019906044006,
0.3583994209766388,
0.9402515888214111,
-1.074735164642334,
0.6512705087661743,
0.5672469139099121,
0.2966741621494293,
-0.35487061738967896,
0.14295756816864014,
0.3421283960342407,
-0.9966048002243042,
0.51542067527771,
0.06404134631156921,
-0.0942932516336441,
-0.6623226404190063,
-0.5519833564758301,
-0.6038299798965454,
0.5773752331733704,
0.8045274019241333,
-0.7038095593452454,
-0.039448332041502,
0.48462411761283875,
0.45701920986175537,
-0.48416152596473694,
0.2632376551628113,
0.6639190316200256,
0.7283968329429626,
-0.2956281900405884,
-0.8941788673400879,
-0.048758476972579956,
0.09970872104167938,
-0.206497922539711,
0.2519320249557495,
-0.6937544941902161,
0.705698549747467,
0.0845266655087471,
-0.13271605968475342,
-0.33210527896881104,
0.5114596486091614,
0.09843268990516663,
0.2835969030857086,
0.6734843850135803,
0.1347758024930954,
0.8671914935112,
-0.1694321483373642,
0.9916130900382996,
-0.6412789821624756,
0.08026334643363953,
0.8767349720001221,
-0.5509956479072571,
0.9021756052970886,
0.7633482217788696,
-0.28354889154434204,
0.5210170149803162,
0.49198785424232483,
-0.025968274101614952,
0.2241699993610382,
0.43899136781692505,
0.0413140170276165,
-0.24657563865184784,
-0.1847803294658661,
-0.2502470910549164,
0.5477409362792969,
0.32615411281585693,
-0.5115119814872742,
-0.19046558439731598,
-0.16587787866592407,
0.30627524852752686,
0.4097400903701782,
-0.42666134238243103,
0.7898899912834167,
0.07794388383626938,
-0.7089285850524902,
0.19540612399578094,
-0.12907114624977112,
0.6152260899543762,
-0.3368261158466339,
-0.023940948769450188,
0.033587466925382614,
0.3110361099243164,
-0.21923646330833435,
-1.0069185495376587,
0.17943191528320312,
0.14492157101631165,
-0.13051018118858337,
-0.03598178178071976,
0.49100831151008606,
-0.26482176780700684,
-0.7605831027030945,
0.6334139704704285,
0.733634352684021,
0.12170515954494476,
0.10920245945453644,
-0.8708590865135193,
0.49692824482917786,
0.07858636230230331,
-0.3222353160381317,
0.25262850522994995,
0.3009716868400574,
-0.10944288223981857,
0.6736451387405396,
0.4463908076286316,
0.4281744956970215,
-0.11604373157024384,
-0.016606630757451057,
0.7314121127128601,
-0.13930478692054749,
-0.23153743147850037,
-1.192291498184204,
0.2123001515865326,
-0.09449844807386398,
0.16756851971149445,
0.8582245111465454,
0.4241556227207184,
0.8165234923362732,
0.20466391742229462,
0.9235671162605286,
0.2887144386768341,
0.4526709318161011,
-0.3901109993457794,
0.8732635378837585,
-0.3088906705379486,
0.20899908244609833,
-0.2514484226703644,
-0.8645676374435425,
-0.010918576270341873,
0.6947177052497864,
-0.6590436100959778,
0.19173501431941986,
0.17821791768074036,
0.705531120300293,
0.012010646983981133,
-0.0829843282699585,
0.19651301205158234,
0.3416769206523895,
0.13718152046203613,
0.25968894362449646,
0.9061855673789978,
0.061767205595970154,
0.28879648447036743,
-0.25655877590179443,
-0.3147996962070465,
-0.06411469727754593,
-1.0301684141159058,
-1.0983200073242188,
-0.36302536725997925,
-0.22212958335876465,
-0.4764255881309509,
0.14038291573524475,
0.9694369435310364,
0.756886899471283,
-0.8913801908493042,
-0.578333854675293,
0.1666833907365799,
0.2842319905757904,
0.21422259509563446,
-0.22011156380176544,
0.5666617155075073,
0.04328536242246628,
-0.9211457967758179,
-0.0352315716445446,
0.1145583763718605,
-0.41501498222351074,
-0.8258228302001953,
-0.16894909739494324,
-0.10724060237407684,
0.5127738118171692,
0.3621426224708557,
-0.06895846873521805,
-1.2275172472000122,
-0.47192850708961487,
-0.15937410295009613,
-0.018821099773049355,
0.2264966517686844,
0.45441579818725586,
-0.6528980135917664,
0.29364657402038574,
0.2991904318332672,
0.5401589274406433,
0.029792631044983864,
0.05916491895914078,
0.8456394076347351,
-0.30618220567703247,
0.09288014471530914,
0.2840394377708435,
0.3465110957622528,
0.4129454791545868,
-0.25705525279045105,
0.5428256988525391,
-0.3318360149860382,
-0.7097733020782471,
-0.9348980188369751,
0.1345967799425125,
-0.5801934003829956,
-0.09523935616016388,
1.3690072298049927,
0.12564578652381897,
-0.3213467597961426,
0.17956557869911194,
-0.3591424226760864,
0.008288365788757801,
-0.5437823534011841,
0.7108909487724304,
0.9423086047172546,
-0.09663834422826767,
0.021789636462926865,
-0.7790908217430115,
0.43172961473464966,
0.3584497570991516,
-0.5950794219970703,
0.3168397843837738,
0.5242699980735779,
0.051284968852996826,
0.10834410786628723,
0.42967623472213745,
-0.18579119443893433,
0.19803486764431,
-0.3745093047618866,
-0.025234784930944443,
0.10385706275701523,
0.011089950799942017,
-0.6172863245010376,
0.04210896044969559,
0.19476188719272614,
0.032823242247104645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10808v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10808v1
|
ActiveLLM: Large Language Model-based Active Learning for Textual Few-Shot Scenarios
| 2024-05-17T14:23:54 | 2024-05-17T14:23:54 |
Markus Bayer, Christian Reuter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Active learning is designed to minimize annotation efforts by prioritizing
instances that most enhance learning. However, many active learning strategies
struggle with a 'cold start' problem, needing substantial initial data to be
effective. This limitation often reduces their utility for pre-trained models,
which already perform well in few-shot scenarios. To address this, we introduce
ActiveLLM, a novel active learning approach that leverages large language
models such as GPT-4, Llama 3, and Mistral Large for selecting instances. We
demonstrate that ActiveLLM significantly enhances the classification
performance of BERT classifiers in few-shot scenarios, outperforming both
traditional active learning methods and the few-shot learning method SetFit.
Additionally, ActiveLLM can be extended to non-few-shot scenarios, allowing for
iterative selections. In this way, ActiveLLM can even help other active
learning strategies to overcome their cold start problem. Our results suggest
that ActiveLLM offers a promising solution for improving model performance
across various learning setups.
|
[
-0.018193505704402924,
-1.1228256225585938,
0.43566828966140747,
-0.0742454007267952,
-0.2767502963542938,
0.01838906668126583,
-0.515012264251709,
-0.549667239189148,
-0.25026804208755493,
0.2950499951839447,
-0.2198656052350998,
-0.6504639387130737,
-0.37728971242904663,
-0.1945132166147232,
-0.2885017693042755,
0.9520649313926697,
-0.20239344239234924,
-0.02173571102321148,
0.17303507030010223,
-0.14489015936851501,
-0.14167925715446472,
-0.36612668633461,
-0.753919243812561,
-0.3542332649230957,
0.7776323556900024,
0.36938199400901794,
0.687350869178772,
0.3526507318019867,
0.4880874454975128,
0.22412589192390442,
-0.08895067870616913,
0.2772970497608185,
-0.462201863527298,
0.4388525187969208,
0.37743186950683594,
-0.6061035394668579,
-0.3238624036312103,
0.12221165746450424,
0.8819352388381958,
0.5802565813064575,
0.015850897878408432,
-0.027094073593616486,
-0.18355561792850494,
0.1729768067598343,
-0.6908019781112671,
0.12237376719713211,
-0.9430115818977356,
0.24053452908992767,
-0.12776856124401093,
0.2673814594745636,
-0.41304662823677063,
-0.14912885427474976,
0.38175660371780396,
-0.48344606161117554,
0.4231778085231781,
-0.02732084132730961,
0.9391056895256042,
0.15516313910484314,
-0.28262001276016235,
0.06431309878826141,
-0.8153139352798462,
0.9696985483169556,
-0.7147471904754639,
0.18364855647087097,
0.535454511642456,
0.24638421833515167,
0.1518269181251526,
-0.6754831671714783,
-0.5164397358894348,
-0.03592951223254204,
0.11250296235084534,
0.18199345469474792,
-0.12915921211242676,
0.014691858552396297,
0.18310949206352234,
0.08188600093126297,
-0.4993551969528198,
0.4660654664039612,
-0.26901882886886597,
-0.06888782978057861,
0.3766327202320099,
0.003342068986967206,
0.1732395887374878,
0.2549707293510437,
-0.550491452217102,
0.07015982270240784,
-0.8244184255599976,
-0.1696096509695053,
0.2246917337179184,
0.8464398384094238,
0.1063132956624031,
0.34762752056121826,
0.34297677874565125,
0.9270133376121521,
-0.2402493804693222,
0.01651407591998577,
0.040156491100788116,
0.08023184537887573,
-0.48205453157424927,
0.1581626534461975,
0.454807847738266,
-0.390124648809433,
-0.2713674306869507,
-0.10748004168272018,
-0.3739195764064789,
-0.20941126346588135,
0.13326044380664825,
-0.8458700180053711,
-0.4326162040233612,
0.17036442458629608,
-0.2861041724681854,
-0.39148327708244324,
-0.04513091221451759,
-0.19008496403694153,
-0.16691510379314423,
-0.09850925952196121,
0.8412046432495117,
-0.43089812994003296,
-0.3330896198749542,
-0.2277888059616089,
0.24185407161712646,
0.4384716749191284,
0.7725039124488831,
-0.6631841063499451,
0.21938779950141907,
0.45651257038116455,
1.0191415548324585,
-0.5434752702713013,
-0.3001052439212799,
-0.772128164768219,
0.29447391629219055,
-0.3772597014904022,
0.8247230052947998,
-0.5552049875259399,
-0.15353494882583618,
0.2083347737789154,
-0.20387141406536102,
-0.04521676525473595,
-0.40245625376701355,
0.24028076231479645,
-0.6260309815406799,
0.3626875877380371,
0.16785503923892975,
-0.5532094836235046,
-0.3298826813697815,
0.4743542969226837,
-0.7597123384475708,
1.2062069177627563,
-0.21446993947029114,
-0.4050500988960266,
0.5789405703544617,
-0.5451159477233887,
-0.7404014468193054,
0.332060307264328,
-0.08000845462083817,
-0.8983818888664246,
-0.03088391199707985,
-0.17584474384784698,
0.9609091877937317,
0.18756002187728882,
-0.1424638330936432,
-0.3229108154773712,
-0.3299071490764618,
0.11981765925884247,
-0.2926293611526489,
0.5060240030288696,
0.14268061518669128,
-0.2788892686367035,
0.2615642547607422,
-0.5000724792480469,
0.16264678537845612,
0.18634678423404694,
-0.6367310881614685,
-0.39369356632232666,
-0.20573246479034424,
0.34168440103530884,
0.13262730836868286,
0.17051932215690613,
-0.35302552580833435,
0.464780330657959,
-0.32242435216903687,
0.10350566357374191,
0.7356992363929749,
-0.17298029363155365,
0.5882466435432434,
-0.2780698835849762,
0.448752224445343,
-0.028934424743056297,
-0.09606806188821793,
-0.4143187999725342,
-0.5251576900482178,
-0.9185650944709778,
-0.7337524890899658,
0.5162257552146912,
0.5286564230918884,
-0.6821164488792419,
0.1879943162202835,
0.3041645288467407,
-0.4258350133895874,
-0.2917194962501526,
0.6630173921585083,
0.31269559264183044,
0.11445051431655884,
0.40735048055648804,
0.1221974641084671,
-0.306404173374176,
-0.5571856498718262,
0.08698828518390656,
-0.44418367743492126,
0.25507333874702454,
0.41278618574142456,
0.21812410652637482,
-0.12783832848072052,
0.8842382431030273,
-0.6218554973602295,
-0.6230818629264832,
-0.6856847405433655,
0.3762645721435547,
0.29802876710891724,
0.28355202078819275,
0.6066048741340637,
-0.7383036017417908,
-0.66595458984375,
-0.08759032934904099,
-0.7731603384017944,
-0.01213274709880352,
-0.16814164817333221,
-0.04896774888038635,
0.19915130734443665,
0.23222818970680237,
-0.47036683559417725,
0.14281176030635834,
0.46003255248069763,
-0.18091313540935516,
0.020339233800768852,
-0.17462995648384094,
-0.24664847552776337,
-0.8524971008300781,
-0.06053222715854645,
0.040193475782871246,
-0.34786051511764526,
-0.6992846727371216,
-0.03772452473640442,
0.21093428134918213,
-0.38223564624786377,
-0.837984025478363,
0.8564018607139587,
-0.630394697189331,
0.16855743527412415,
-0.4816221296787262,
-0.08183249086141586,
-0.25105559825897217,
0.3066575229167938,
0.45443227887153625,
0.3741580545902252,
0.8649704456329346,
-0.573554515838623,
0.2187955230474472,
0.22614693641662598,
-0.2452123910188675,
-0.08614267408847809,
-0.3077240586280823,
0.2881058156490326,
-0.050778478384017944,
0.17134709656238556,
-0.9314712882041931,
-0.08102108538150787,
-0.22036387026309967,
-0.1542106419801712,
0.7379453182220459,
-0.3352362811565399,
-0.5399613976478577,
-0.0458407960832119,
-0.27480003237724304,
0.29650774598121643,
0.6109955310821533,
-0.5673329830169678,
0.6546491384506226,
0.1591617465019226,
-0.12420938163995743,
-0.399410218000412,
-0.5423849821090698,
0.10489602386951447,
-0.22197797894477844,
-0.23596978187561035,
0.101563461124897,
0.05619834363460541,
-0.23085357248783112,
-0.06097005307674408,
0.017575809732079506,
-0.27452462911605835,
0.48008885979652405,
0.2013295590877533,
0.4018164277076721,
-0.1101241260766983,
0.41199105978012085,
-0.1210399940609932,
-0.013021686114370823,
-0.5189430713653564,
-0.19057424366474152,
0.22890061140060425,
0.03463370352983475,
-0.24767395853996277,
-0.12025636434555054,
0.1956162005662918,
0.1425439417362213,
-0.27595314383506775,
0.7320475578308105,
0.8495311141014099,
-0.6849125027656555,
-0.7456334829330444,
-0.6054273247718811,
-0.43001341819763184,
-0.38009101152420044,
0.3444613218307495,
-0.1391260325908661,
-0.9546019434928894,
0.3024309277534485,
-0.036886442452669144,
0.600944995880127,
0.20532454550266266,
0.693000078201294,
-0.13899056613445282,
0.9761512875556946,
0.7262890338897705,
0.038286589086055756,
0.9091812968254089,
-0.37432482838630676,
0.05313684791326523,
-0.2573392391204834,
-0.12488576024770737,
-0.3102380633354187,
-0.5051489472389221,
0.1599711924791336,
-0.6282669901847839,
0.24509364366531372,
0.18626384437084198,
-0.1157006174325943,
0.12368515133857727,
-0.0932222306728363,
0.5306453704833984,
0.3544636368751526,
0.2516552805900574,
0.19327634572982788,
0.03228985145688057,
-0.2156037986278534,
-0.007570814806967974,
-1.0453779697418213,
-0.5345103144645691,
1.036501169204712,
0.43899717926979065,
1.0190144777297974,
0.372433602809906,
0.7725368142127991,
0.20519481599330902,
0.6288608312606812,
-1.167913794517517,
0.5665804743766785,
-0.2010374218225479,
-0.8564959764480591,
-0.36224833130836487,
-0.3291701376438141,
-1.0863280296325684,
0.11239131540060043,
-0.5350305438041687,
-0.2532190680503845,
-0.24665823578834534,
0.15007352828979492,
-0.582105278968811,
0.4661838114261627,
-0.7215766906738281,
0.6396375298500061,
-0.66988605260849,
-0.7372213006019592,
0.037277866154909134,
-0.4518906772136688,
0.25836294889450073,
-0.4191422760486603,
-0.0932137593626976,
-0.43135184049606323,
-0.3823706805706024,
0.8384943008422852,
-0.22580058872699738,
1.2197673320770264,
-0.4217183291912079,
-0.11247177422046661,
0.35558706521987915,
0.14320003986358643,
0.576010525226593,
0.1081201508641243,
-0.16280989348888397,
0.13203193247318268,
-0.5751546621322632,
-0.4288278818130493,
-0.29380857944488525,
0.8472843766212463,
-0.861602246761322,
-0.41619569063186646,
-0.6323035955429077,
-0.32329919934272766,
-0.286607563495636,
0.3721481263637543,
-0.1521652191877365,
0.24722963571548462,
-0.3179067373275757,
0.2434878647327423,
1.001306414604187,
-0.17433078587055206,
0.7344944477081299,
0.931677520275116,
-0.08191192150115967,
-0.08725064992904663,
0.620914876461029,
0.17732028663158417,
0.11210547387599945,
0.26021525263786316,
0.1340276449918747,
-0.15082110464572906,
-0.971327543258667,
-0.3437332808971405,
0.1365693360567093,
-0.6979852914810181,
-0.6757883429527283,
-0.7276270389556885,
-0.16224871575832367,
-0.03438306972384453,
-0.2717304825782776,
-0.262949138879776,
-0.4162781834602356,
-0.47702640295028687,
-0.24959078431129456,
0.44349032640457153,
0.4447862505912781,
0.18475496768951416,
0.35464510321617126,
-0.6791353821754456,
0.2646782398223877,
0.694837212562561,
0.16782213747501373,
-0.10548965632915497,
-0.581052839756012,
-0.4193243086338043,
-0.39933550357818604,
-0.30114293098449707,
-0.5807167291641235,
0.3320561945438385,
0.8304747939109802,
0.8854305148124695,
0.6856560111045837,
0.08828680962324142,
0.45513051748275757,
-0.5806290507316589,
0.7517286539077759,
0.35705268383026123,
-0.6731999516487122,
0.8804052472114563,
-0.33158162236213684,
0.525327205657959,
0.5088797807693481,
0.5509056448936462,
-0.06487780064344406,
-0.47226473689079285,
-0.581506073474884,
-0.9939170479774475,
0.7902353405952454,
0.2522510588169098,
0.2483094334602356,
-0.01885596103966236,
0.29086580872535706,
0.34961608052253723,
-0.19386230409145355,
-0.8527818918228149,
-0.06696099042892456,
0.027831649407744408,
-0.24432122707366943,
-0.0378282330930233,
-0.036838121712207794,
-0.15167111158370972,
-0.07944285869598389,
0.8804097771644592,
-0.3936428129673004,
0.251145601272583,
-0.10040328651666641,
-0.45216044783592224,
-0.34507840871810913,
0.0545014813542366,
0.29584357142448425,
0.558843731880188,
-0.24055461585521698,
0.3650412857532501,
0.5054499506950378,
-0.4427218735218048,
0.09030997008085251,
0.10568398237228394,
-0.27340903878211975,
0.087607242166996,
0.7115682363510132,
0.9243308901786804,
0.48009610176086426,
-0.7158386707305908,
0.5280116200447083,
-0.07418423891067505,
-0.0953378975391388,
-0.24635981023311615,
0.3171153962612152,
-0.33485186100006104,
0.29862985014915466,
0.8797605037689209,
-0.19524948298931122,
-0.2806878983974457,
-0.7400162816047668,
0.25672447681427,
0.5735576152801514,
-0.6299059391021729,
-0.3763134479522705,
0.5958529114723206,
0.38898253440856934,
-0.09044159203767776,
0.5417731404304504,
0.048620324581861496,
-0.735927939414978,
0.5125057697296143,
0.6648944616317749,
0.9730978012084961,
-0.33501747250556946,
0.0515618771314621,
0.22764933109283447,
0.23490047454833984,
-0.3878856301307678,
0.2819453179836273,
-0.045291900634765625,
-1.0347678661346436,
-0.3830565810203552,
-0.6474941372871399,
-0.49115848541259766,
0.1898268461227417,
-0.3966696858406067,
0.7553989887237549,
-0.6752442717552185,
-0.21225495636463165,
-0.044524695724248886,
0.31718909740448,
-0.7363226413726807,
0.07729031145572662,
0.5366615653038025,
0.6951496005058289,
-1.056542158126831,
1.1950581073760986,
1.3038794994354248,
-0.16380172967910767,
-0.4795072674751282,
-0.05520495027303696,
-0.006171769928187132,
-0.7399162650108337,
0.6659694910049438,
0.2500031590461731,
0.1369776725769043,
0.19382773339748383,
-0.6392191052436829,
-0.40190330147743225,
1.093291163444519,
0.03056144341826439,
-0.48445186018943787,
0.07367056608200073,
-0.4976150691509247,
0.36739346385002136,
-0.3499697148799896,
0.1806446611881256,
0.058261971920728683,
0.3933335542678833,
0.2870127558708191,
-0.7703202962875366,
-0.21820582449436188,
-0.06094041094183922,
-0.1829073429107666,
0.4546237885951996,
-0.7464728951454163,
0.5379698276519775,
-0.47130832076072693,
-0.026194849982857704,
-0.07082114368677139,
0.6753777861595154,
0.25361141562461853,
0.35677990317344666,
0.6546072959899902,
0.4246569275856018,
0.7123558521270752,
-0.16825784742832184,
0.5216550827026367,
0.07414930313825607,
0.3852153420448303,
0.7948320508003235,
-0.6979297399520874,
1.1737146377563477,
0.22446724772453308,
-0.13848520815372467,
0.021473011001944542,
0.819310188293457,
-0.14941774308681488,
0.6608285903930664,
-0.08054604381322861,
-0.6497586965560913,
-0.6923285722732544,
0.2283206284046173,
-0.11104337126016617,
0.5783324837684631,
0.4377513825893402,
-0.2773902714252472,
-0.28066545724868774,
0.41819101572036743,
0.1480126529932022,
-0.1700601577758789,
-0.5023536086082458,
1.0705806016921997,
0.10256422311067581,
-0.18947724997997284,
0.4836660325527191,
0.007182576227933168,
0.7974038124084473,
-0.8832375407218933,
-0.12124298512935638,
-0.16610033810138702,
0.21594774723052979,
-0.19600319862365723,
-0.48569995164871216,
-0.06928712129592896,
0.22927720844745636,
-0.120487280189991,
-0.4583825469017029,
0.979170560836792,
-0.6594515442848206,
-0.6836163997650146,
0.07188299298286438,
0.7421298623085022,
0.08564569801092148,
0.16336339712142944,
-0.8902058005332947,
0.021459773182868958,
-0.2361529916524887,
-0.3428660035133362,
0.4243643879890442,
0.4609183967113495,
-0.14381363987922668,
0.4942246675491333,
0.6875023245811462,
0.17595721781253815,
0.019024232402443886,
-0.01865830272436142,
0.8633123636245728,
-0.6463701725006104,
-0.2434324473142624,
-0.7317928671836853,
0.20796234905719757,
0.14981569349765778,
-0.05143563076853752,
0.8552948236465454,
0.8021026253700256,
0.47665855288505554,
0.05941487476229668,
0.888710081577301,
-0.013285232707858086,
0.4122970700263977,
-0.6469939947128296,
0.7181075215339661,
-0.4331085681915283,
0.40560734272003174,
-0.09041835367679596,
-1.2521260976791382,
-0.8108081221580505,
0.9319868087768555,
-0.2744509279727936,
0.05459343641996384,
0.6065745949745178,
0.3333236277103424,
-0.2415800541639328,
-0.3028746247291565,
0.6313469409942627,
0.3361204266548157,
0.21337082982063293,
0.40846940875053406,
0.8540690541267395,
-0.18591740727424622,
0.6276886463165283,
-0.06301435828208923,
-0.33811238408088684,
-0.3264089822769165,
-0.8991144299507141,
-1.2793476581573486,
-0.3204810917377472,
-0.6293523907661438,
-0.10855408757925034,
0.08126410096883774,
1.0258902311325073,
0.880980908870697,
-0.8281306624412537,
-0.05502181872725487,
0.39213746786117554,
0.011663375422358513,
-0.25365763902664185,
-0.14924848079681396,
0.3982354700565338,
-0.6046727895736694,
-0.8565794229507446,
0.6158956289291382,
0.20788733661174774,
0.25531667470932007,
-0.25696617364883423,
-0.08161873370409012,
-0.5079104900360107,
-0.10796166211366653,
0.7370603680610657,
0.3296879827976227,
-0.5203449130058289,
-0.053193043917417526,
-0.11332090198993683,
-0.0628446713089943,
-0.1141010969877243,
0.8614146709442139,
-1.0210078954696655,
0.4466823935508728,
0.4436560869216919,
0.7001322507858276,
0.9484032988548279,
-0.23701991140842438,
0.4165996015071869,
-1.025437831878662,
0.47825074195861816,
0.6710011959075928,
0.25623491406440735,
0.2698011100292206,
-0.19278788566589355,
0.4549228549003601,
0.08842229098081589,
-0.3085436522960663,
-1.0270047187805176,
-0.07585256546735764,
-1.0480138063430786,
-0.49404022097587585,
1.5294400453567505,
-0.42739057540893555,
0.021509643644094467,
-0.30519309639930725,
-0.21445459127426147,
0.11739302426576614,
-0.3791927099227905,
0.73082035779953,
0.6205952763557434,
-0.05778650566935539,
-0.4178897440433502,
-0.6409358978271484,
0.42994359135627747,
0.45427632331848145,
-0.7960724830627441,
-0.08073408901691437,
0.5316326022148132,
0.17142990231513977,
-0.1687881201505661,
0.20675069093704224,
0.17873446643352509,
0.2733692228794098,
-0.5674998164176941,
-0.06655615568161011,
-0.2148914933204651,
-0.4389335811138153,
-0.44468992948532104,
0.29549726843833923,
0.4745190739631653,
-0.033948153257369995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.11009v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.11009v1
|
Petri nets in modelling glucose regulating processes in the liver
| 2024-05-17T13:15:01 | 2024-05-17T13:15:01 |
Kamila Barylska, Anna Gogolińska
|
q-bio.OT
|
q-bio.OT, cs.CL, 68, F.1.1
|
Diabetes is a chronic condition, considered one of the civilization diseases,
that is characterized by sustained high blood sugar levels. There is no doubt
that more and more people is going to suffer from diabetes, hence it is crucial
to understand better its biological foundations. The essential processes
related to the control of glucose levels in the blood are: glycolysis (process
of breaking down of glucose) and glucose synthesis, both taking place in the
liver. The glycolysis occurs during feeding and it is stimulated by insulin. On
the other hand, the glucose synthesis arises during fasting and it is
stimulated by glucagon. In the paper we present a Petri net model of glycolysis
and glucose synthesis in the liver. The model is created based on medical
literature. Standard Petri nets techniques are used to analyse the properties
of the model: traps, reachability graphs, tokens dynamics, deadlocks analysis.
The results are described in the paper. Our analysis shows that the model
captures the interactions between different enzymes and substances, which is
consistent with the biological processes occurring during fasting and feeding.
The model constitutes the first element of our long-time goal to create the
whole body model of the glucose regulation in a healthy human and a person with
diabetes.
|
[
-0.15680085122585297,
-0.6987173557281494,
0.5552878379821777,
-0.11135932058095932,
-0.11901702731847763,
-0.175289124250412,
0.09808552265167236,
-0.5084546208381653,
0.380388081073761,
0.8187294006347656,
-0.11572398245334625,
0.029845325276255608,
-0.2175431102514267,
0.3748139441013336,
-0.3759760558605194,
1.1663928031921387,
-0.3855355381965637,
0.8225996494293213,
-0.01330834161490202,
0.26843905448913574,
-0.07817374914884567,
-0.5489992499351501,
-0.6526679396629333,
-0.42864757776260376,
0.39012622833251953,
0.008414574898779392,
0.4337860941886902,
0.7131204605102539,
0.540311336517334,
0.3086719810962677,
-0.40267932415008545,
-0.3859333097934723,
-0.41911906003952026,
0.33062273263931274,
-0.08424555510282516,
-0.3767034709453583,
-0.5670763850212097,
-0.003922538366168737,
0.4216533303260803,
0.7033287286758423,
-0.06307455897331238,
0.1577511727809906,
0.19008080661296844,
0.7227029800415039,
-0.2683176100254059,
0.07668811082839966,
-0.01647583395242691,
0.30866149067878723,
-0.2792455852031708,
-0.18791459500789642,
-0.0962238535284996,
-0.38018468022346497,
-0.24207322299480438,
-0.23709973692893982,
0.36225199699401855,
-0.04591178894042969,
0.5849113464355469,
0.44925832748413086,
-0.17432144284248352,
-0.35317835211753845,
-0.6107050776481628,
0.20173029601573944,
-0.7557824850082397,
-0.14538727700710297,
0.2252856343984604,
0.6518089175224304,
-0.44546589255332947,
-0.8166298866271973,
-0.12308058887720108,
-0.696315586566925,
-0.383733332157135,
0.08625495433807373,
0.7561295628547668,
0.21312205493450165,
0.27459514141082764,
0.43353646993637085,
-0.6857936382293701,
-0.26727378368377686,
-0.8361441493034363,
0.2661714553833008,
0.2737598717212677,
0.6211681365966797,
0.12597133219242096,
-0.1263817995786667,
-0.8681613206863403,
0.3157351315021515,
-0.4094350039958954,
0.2025851309299469,
0.0449797660112381,
0.2945217490196228,
-0.10288283228874207,
0.3301820158958435,
-0.15172141790390015,
0.5872129201889038,
0.010988348163664341,
0.011171157471835613,
-0.016778692603111267,
-0.7801384925842285,
-0.5834497809410095,
0.18853804469108582,
0.3440226912498474,
0.3362392783164978,
0.09921453148126602,
0.22434912621974945,
-0.25787967443466187,
0.2960624396800995,
0.44676142930984497,
-0.9957607984542847,
-0.10401065647602081,
0.7243612408638,
-0.782620370388031,
-0.2505281865596771,
0.004499409813433886,
-0.6397614479064941,
-0.3483617305755615,
-0.05473526194691658,
0.15183500945568085,
0.12349525839090347,
-0.23263107240200043,
0.3904906213283539,
-0.007468738593161106,
-0.19347089529037476,
0.33255666494369507,
-0.9062109589576721,
0.6755735278129578,
0.6820318102836609,
0.7377138733863831,
-0.18092143535614014,
-0.16180068254470825,
-0.43943727016448975,
0.229525625705719,
-0.17069204151630402,
0.311372309923172,
-0.2821580469608307,
-0.22223012149333954,
-0.41921713948249817,
0.3273787498474121,
-0.08082538843154907,
-0.5983770489692688,
0.3509281873703003,
-0.41714078187942505,
-0.47107237577438354,
-0.29873159527778625,
-0.8308634757995605,
-0.12131224572658539,
0.004335287492722273,
-0.9306070804595947,
0.5432888269424438,
-0.26048746705055237,
-0.68538898229599,
0.15520700812339783,
-1.001281499862671,
-0.09262833744287491,
0.3133409321308136,
0.29265496134757996,
-0.5028194189071655,
0.2758502662181854,
-0.5857166647911072,
0.4783724248409271,
-0.2602272629737854,
0.7167021632194519,
-0.27460670471191406,
-0.15864111483097076,
0.09543481469154358,
0.0441092811524868,
0.5413293242454529,
0.5391620397567749,
-0.0532861091196537,
0.3102736473083496,
-0.6222971081733704,
-0.06462322175502777,
-0.25223565101623535,
-0.34436914324760437,
-0.3420552909374237,
0.3045797646045685,
0.23785527050495148,
0.2649730145931244,
0.25534147024154663,
-0.658592164516449,
0.5260328054428101,
-0.2544275224208832,
0.6882101893424988,
0.3114625811576843,
0.47448471188545227,
0.09042147547006607,
-0.13604523241519928,
0.15722979605197906,
0.1250821053981781,
0.8089799880981445,
0.042733535170555115,
-0.46875837445259094,
-0.3883969485759735,
0.4420287609100342,
0.295829713344574,
0.6005356311798096,
-0.13749544322490692,
0.3574680984020233,
0.2948131561279297,
-0.32883015275001526,
-0.012921430170536041,
-0.32481035590171814,
0.2983551323413849,
0.660517692565918,
0.07413819432258606,
-0.7282354235649109,
-0.24818171560764313,
-0.8005759716033936,
0.5883510112762451,
-0.20589493215084076,
0.07852999120950699,
-0.04180361330509186,
0.8860335350036621,
0.17309796810150146,
0.5067572593688965,
-0.27390533685684204,
-0.17677654325962067,
0.1896422952413559,
0.10552703589200974,
0.6892227530479431,
0.8980377316474915,
0.6485439538955688,
-0.9043360948562622,
-0.6234338879585266,
0.2233315259218216,
-0.7297644019126892,
-0.22826619446277618,
-0.18265073001384735,
-0.17848119139671326,
-0.09279781579971313,
0.5950788259506226,
-0.19032129645347595,
0.8527010679244995,
0.31711727380752563,
-0.6585435271263123,
0.9942509531974792,
-0.43718358874320984,
0.06020813807845116,
-0.863452136516571,
0.7752630114555359,
-0.28900277614593506,
-0.6428346633911133,
-1.183637261390686,
0.1641206294298172,
-0.09499175101518631,
-0.19711080193519592,
-0.6532991528511047,
0.30163297057151794,
-0.5492354035377502,
-0.20882189273834229,
-0.5932018160820007,
-0.5632652640342712,
0.02982025220990181,
0.3277416527271271,
0.19992797076702118,
0.9465155601501465,
0.7846091985702515,
-0.5246385931968689,
0.45452097058296204,
0.26704952120780945,
-0.5507966876029968,
0.2677271366119385,
-1.027588963508606,
-0.57768714427948,
0.013681072741746902,
0.24653783440589905,
-0.9364064335823059,
-0.06731517612934113,
0.662674605846405,
-0.3720495402812958,
0.2124599814414978,
-0.2328198403120041,
-0.2548118531703949,
-0.3962627053260803,
-0.025493130087852478,
-0.12591660022735596,
0.24825866520404816,
-0.060694459825754166,
0.2912834584712982,
0.3540841341018677,
-0.1602081060409546,
-0.11257342994213104,
-0.5212545990943909,
0.14011479914188385,
-0.1211797371506691,
-0.4082050621509552,
0.4088854193687439,
-0.22964395582675934,
-0.22788093984127045,
0.04286627098917961,
-0.06390714645385742,
-0.30308854579925537,
0.37450993061065674,
0.35516709089279175,
0.22705969214439392,
0.07040334492921829,
-0.054552435874938965,
-0.3924578130245209,
-0.4301243722438812,
0.15831314027309418,
0.07595393061637878,
0.25953373312950134,
0.07478214055299759,
-0.11431321501731873,
-0.5578530430793762,
0.6885578036308289,
0.8865187764167786,
0.044854748994112015,
0.6280538439750671,
0.2783685326576233,
-0.20074257254600525,
0.24863335490226746,
-0.059038158506155014,
-0.2934090793132782,
-0.4559394419193268,
-0.010903263464570045,
-0.3588784337043762,
-0.49941107630729675,
0.9798606634140015,
-0.03019389696419239,
-0.008907652460038662,
-0.002842050278559327,
0.7867507338523865,
0.17696863412857056,
0.8559399247169495,
0.49148041009902954,
0.3560785949230194,
0.21625718474388123,
-0.06514746695756912,
-0.20125314593315125,
-0.9266932606697083,
-0.026952223852276802,
-0.689257025718689,
-0.36920464038848877,
-0.6078033447265625,
-0.345831960439682,
1.051171898841858,
0.31081798672676086,
-0.27035990357398987,
-0.04161355644464493,
-0.432775616645813,
0.7005958557128906,
0.26588553190231323,
0.09760835021734238,
-0.04164190962910652,
-0.21001765131950378,
-0.5048831701278687,
0.49592235684394836,
-0.4929963946342468,
-0.5240938663482666,
0.6402889490127563,
0.35008367896080017,
0.7641994953155518,
-0.3201073706150055,
0.3743435740470886,
0.3045484125614166,
0.45006227493286133,
-0.27711114287376404,
0.1626664102077484,
-0.2526378035545349,
-1.0641028881072998,
-0.21630483865737915,
-0.2332484871149063,
-0.7536580562591553,
0.0493028350174427,
-0.10692627727985382,
-0.8086650967597961,
0.013544848188757896,
0.17302753031253815,
-0.5802304744720459,
0.49845167994499207,
-0.7662794589996338,
1.039158821105957,
-0.5344241857528687,
-0.9507997632026672,
0.029838979244232178,
-1.3867384195327759,
0.12465474009513855,
-0.04922827333211899,
0.01853514276444912,
0.21329839527606964,
0.0752883031964302,
0.4902592897415161,
-0.9052677154541016,
1.2131248712539673,
-0.4454318583011627,
0.22700433433055878,
0.16265758872032166,
0.2211061269044876,
0.3837352395057678,
-0.09117714315652847,
-0.09356938302516937,
0.007396754343062639,
0.19624322652816772,
-0.5038170218467712,
-0.26602134108543396,
0.28931963443756104,
-0.469823956489563,
-0.5597757697105408,
-0.4115602970123291,
0.2688731551170349,
0.18929538130760193,
0.006637544836848974,
-0.00583690358325839,
0.16607452929019928,
-0.2191433310508728,
-0.160501167178154,
0.15508900582790375,
-0.05186855047941208,
0.5928133130073547,
0.28476524353027344,
-0.33203792572021484,
-0.2934700548648834,
0.34450504183769226,
-0.008324326016008854,
0.4836585819721222,
0.1098356544971466,
0.343241423368454,
-0.04332391917705536,
-0.5489968657493591,
-0.40944111347198486,
0.17053790390491486,
-0.1790764033794403,
-0.012888621538877487,
-0.1974661946296692,
-0.3339753746986389,
0.019295688718557358,
-0.3162682354450226,
-0.24043788015842438,
-0.13434042036533356,
-0.45688778162002563,
0.16231076419353485,
0.26801326870918274,
0.785211980342865,
-0.5160598158836365,
0.05131958797574043,
-1.0613332986831665,
0.2600976228713989,
0.11653783172369003,
0.6751484870910645,
0.36945223808288574,
0.22689098119735718,
-0.4680849611759186,
-0.2979101538658142,
-0.08064432442188263,
-1.1927990913391113,
0.5680002570152283,
0.07712080329656601,
0.4040096700191498,
0.33273130655288696,
-0.44974634051322937,
0.4705377221107483,
-0.6383852958679199,
0.8060557842254639,
0.39641764760017395,
-0.951876699924469,
0.2322380542755127,
-0.25330618023872375,
0.18541160225868225,
0.498702734708786,
0.4164694845676422,
-1.0111830234527588,
-0.03231396526098251,
-0.2582726776599884,
-0.8333005309104919,
0.39972227811813354,
0.06529850512742996,
-0.27260446548461914,
0.21627384424209595,
0.7063403725624084,
0.5104337930679321,
0.279544860124588,
-0.4644750952720642,
-0.21728470921516418,
-0.006810135208070278,
0.5173535346984863,
0.30997124314308167,
-0.14476917684078217,
-0.005803395062685013,
-0.31253352761268616,
0.5751784443855286,
-0.07449690252542496,
0.028086477890610695,
0.366291344165802,
0.3876066207885742,
-0.4037720859050751,
0.04436355456709862,
0.4076544940471649,
0.7339386940002441,
-0.4268548786640167,
-0.16477183997631073,
-0.3644478917121887,
-0.6307416558265686,
0.23419012129306793,
-0.29280251264572144,
-0.43329957127571106,
-0.2681261897087097,
-0.07348717004060745,
0.798539936542511,
-0.193001389503479,
-0.209987074136734,
0.0964415892958641,
-0.20645153522491455,
-0.23912785947322845,
-0.42409253120422363,
0.3737008571624756,
0.11121135950088501,
0.2590699791908264,
0.22457163035869598,
0.26058146357536316,
0.2959459125995636,
-0.30238333344459534,
0.4501582980155945,
0.08607251197099686,
-0.03777935355901718,
-0.37192001938819885,
1.164048433303833,
0.508039653301239,
-0.08188216388225555,
0.457375705242157,
-0.2590688467025757,
-0.49603044986724854,
1.0961265563964844,
0.5843948125839233,
0.7736144065856934,
-0.425337016582489,
0.30646559596061707,
0.6090127825737,
-0.04420710355043411,
-0.24362006783485413,
0.38698142766952515,
-0.3769790232181549,
-0.30002301931381226,
-0.6365357637405396,
-0.9972324967384338,
-0.5766220688819885,
0.36709079146385193,
-0.5333133935928345,
0.10929445922374725,
-0.25279632210731506,
-0.20225048065185547,
0.6115621328353882,
-0.05333298444747925,
-0.01566079817712307,
0.08070362359285355,
0.3512592315673828,
0.7274174690246582,
-1.2559019327163696,
0.8940526843070984,
0.5161061882972717,
-0.32303041219711304,
-0.24110208451747894,
-0.23708705604076385,
-0.2564328610897064,
-0.3026248812675476,
0.6418936848640442,
-0.06497959792613983,
0.4557965397834778,
-0.22166889905929565,
-0.5397865772247314,
-0.9038316607475281,
0.49523451924324036,
-0.2017437070608139,
-0.6958820223808289,
0.1053287535905838,
0.26077914237976074,
0.9037192463874817,
-0.2707296907901764,
0.38432762026786804,
0.3228113353252411,
0.8751698732376099,
0.28350499272346497,
-1.219973087310791,
0.09182038903236389,
-0.5442134737968445,
0.18627490103244781,
0.2817975878715515,
-0.7021315097808838,
1.298374056816101,
-0.010327130556106567,
-0.06028080731630325,
0.32881468534469604,
-0.03565226495265961,
-0.04057017341256142,
0.11927621811628342,
0.2560116648674011,
0.34126996994018555,
0.3906821012496948,
0.03622017055749893,
0.9689424633979797,
-0.4898652732372284,
0.47245869040489197,
0.5110045671463013,
-0.5947259664535522,
0.481559693813324,
0.6227636933326721,
-0.30770066380500793,
-0.1003447100520134,
0.773158848285675,
-0.22801128029823303,
0.40047088265419006,
0.8308899402618408,
-0.08865988999605179,
-0.3471537232398987,
0.0462556853890419,
-0.41637617349624634,
0.19472000002861023,
0.4515845477581024,
-0.6385626792907715,
-0.5664867162704468,
-0.059251755475997925,
0.14405648410320282,
-0.26501721143722534,
-0.6340020895004272,
0.5223414897918701,
-0.10808591544628143,
-0.6280888319015503,
1.1499323844909668,
-0.08364428579807281,
0.14487670361995697,
-0.6994644403457642,
-0.1906328797340393,
-0.10291014611721039,
0.010771302506327629,
-0.08837375044822693,
-0.7429429888725281,
0.7508711218833923,
0.015833230689167976,
-0.31204235553741455,
-0.37688809633255005,
0.7866270542144775,
-0.20874622464179993,
-0.42069175839424133,
0.4389054477214813,
0.6443119645118713,
0.4393002688884735,
0.5628058314323425,
-0.7077438235282898,
0.045800041407346725,
-0.11688761413097382,
-0.3712902069091797,
0.35074254870414734,
0.016317376866936684,
-0.06641900539398193,
0.2941540777683258,
0.6461942791938782,
0.3988812565803528,
-0.23934100568294525,
-0.07166403532028198,
0.8660366535186768,
-0.6594941020011902,
-0.6941676139831543,
-0.7677337527275085,
0.268135666847229,
0.10766785591840744,
-0.26041531562805176,
0.16817109286785126,
0.3558763861656189,
0.4427720308303833,
-0.479542076587677,
0.6717129945755005,
-0.18581151962280273,
0.30598536133766174,
-0.6423391103744507,
0.9894120693206787,
-0.726038932800293,
-0.2008470892906189,
0.016725225374102592,
-0.6059532165527344,
-0.49231261014938354,
0.3392752707004547,
-0.10718902200460434,
-0.11753857880830765,
0.8634836077690125,
0.7024707794189453,
-0.15559105575084686,
0.2576245963573456,
0.18767614662647247,
0.6209030151367188,
0.18631915748119354,
0.7568022608757019,
0.2760341465473175,
0.09815853834152222,
-0.33090776205062866,
0.06399042159318924,
-0.20560476183891296,
-0.3714701235294342,
-0.9090251326560974,
-0.4771483242511749,
-0.7067233920097351,
-0.0021027291659265757,
-0.2609364688396454,
0.3637242019176483,
0.6168445944786072,
0.746812105178833,
-1.130071997642517,
-0.8787067532539368,
-0.39859968423843384,
-0.14629268646240234,
-0.49768438935279846,
-0.09251696616411209,
0.3250938057899475,
0.002129341010004282,
-0.32434746623039246,
0.21670696139335632,
0.4505513608455658,
0.22784486413002014,
-0.5643457770347595,
0.1888056993484497,
-0.5680658221244812,
-0.1889263093471527,
0.05216915160417557,
0.5320141911506653,
-0.10720118880271912,
-0.11253407597541809,
-0.2902217209339142,
-0.18415036797523499,
0.32140034437179565,
0.7910556793212891,
-0.6741883158683777,
0.5000981688499451,
0.8876387476921082,
0.2432219386100769,
0.7777218222618103,
0.1936623752117157,
0.28427770733833313,
-0.4430723488330841,
-0.08910906314849854,
0.04329155758023262,
0.2941955327987671,
0.17854732275009155,
-0.4637373685836792,
0.7035385370254517,
0.27549904584884644,
-0.9869433641433716,
-0.48988077044487,
0.06284667551517487,
-0.8000406622886658,
-0.5072658061981201,
0.5607188940048218,
-0.042289070785045624,
-0.9085196256637573,
-0.1980874240398407,
-0.12417405098676682,
0.3573359549045563,
-0.13301779329776764,
1.0768218040466309,
0.4720945954322815,
-0.6640717387199402,
0.5858312249183655,
-0.6975067257881165,
0.5525436997413635,
0.11642561107873917,
-1.0724306106567383,
0.2983354926109314,
0.6778917908668518,
0.35552605986595154,
0.26801809668540955,
0.5888220071792603,
-0.10404084622859955,
0.1572198122739792,
-0.09374178200960159,
0.11423010379076004,
-0.019451532512903214,
-0.3527427911758423,
-0.0682399645447731,
0.42155012488365173,
-0.6438246965408325,
-0.12649518251419067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10745v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10745v1
|
Empowering Small-Scale Knowledge Graphs: A Strategy of Leveraging General-Purpose Knowledge Graphs for Enriched Embeddings
| 2024-05-17T12:46:23 | 2024-05-17T12:46:23 |
Albert Sawczyn, Jakub Binkowski, Piotr Bielak, Tomasz Kajdanowicz
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Knowledge-intensive tasks pose a significant challenge for Machine Learning
(ML) techniques. Commonly adopted methods, such as Large Language Models
(LLMs), often exhibit limitations when applied to such tasks. Nevertheless,
there have been notable endeavours to mitigate these challenges, with a
significant emphasis on augmenting LLMs through Knowledge Graphs (KGs). While
KGs provide many advantages for representing knowledge, their development costs
can deter extensive research and applications. Addressing this limitation, we
introduce a framework for enriching embeddings of small-scale domain-specific
Knowledge Graphs with well-established general-purpose KGs. Adopting our
method, a modest domain-specific KG can benefit from a performance boost in
downstream tasks when linked to a substantial general-purpose KG. Experimental
evaluations demonstrate a notable enhancement, with up to a 44% increase
observed in the Hits@10 metric. This relatively unexplored research direction
can catalyze more frequent incorporation of KGs in knowledge-intensive tasks,
resulting in more robust, reliable ML implementations, which hallucinates less
than prevalent LLM solutions.
Keywords: knowledge graph, knowledge graph completion, entity alignment,
representation learning, machine learning
|
[
-0.37875834107398987,
-0.7577432990074158,
0.5787083506584167,
-0.11473763734102249,
-0.10104593634605408,
0.23598039150238037,
-0.3116070032119751,
-0.36146560311317444,
0.38763147592544556,
0.4785271883010864,
-0.10665468871593475,
-0.4591694176197052,
-0.8370589017868042,
0.027667813003063202,
-0.002173585584387183,
0.6896874308586121,
-0.24884644150733948,
-0.06120237335562706,
-0.6903813481330872,
-0.2854357659816742,
-0.5005935430526733,
-0.22079850733280182,
-0.5508224368095398,
-0.3510649800300598,
0.7445573806762695,
0.42322784662246704,
0.7662581205368042,
0.8447772264480591,
0.2278091162443161,
0.1693330556154251,
0.16929811239242554,
0.8256769180297852,
-0.5662955641746521,
0.208130344748497,
-0.07830539345741272,
-0.26209402084350586,
-0.4947969317436218,
-0.26589488983154297,
0.4837927520275116,
1.221818447113037,
0.21914134919643402,
0.06915585696697235,
0.43909594416618347,
0.5963534712791443,
-0.7462470531463623,
0.5193290114402771,
-0.48522698879241943,
0.07035449147224426,
-0.20891040563583374,
0.042488254606723785,
-0.39359307289123535,
-0.1649707853794098,
0.21499088406562805,
-0.706485390663147,
-0.22869528830051422,
0.26391151547431946,
0.5189451575279236,
0.4214492440223694,
-0.5128138661384583,
-0.409748911857605,
-0.43695470690727234,
0.6326152086257935,
-0.21823251247406006,
0.5304059982299805,
0.3451184034347534,
0.3544318675994873,
-0.1208999827504158,
-0.90739905834198,
-0.20290686190128326,
0.02364949695765972,
-0.41764381527900696,
-0.3352660834789276,
-0.39654839038848877,
0.07716839015483856,
0.23436199128627777,
0.05675816908478737,
-0.23301593959331512,
0.1806771606206894,
-0.0727832242846489,
-0.15619297325611115,
0.27089688181877136,
0.18551361560821533,
0.2869446575641632,
0.025066042318940163,
0.034206606447696686,
0.09966585785150528,
-1.0710796117782593,
-0.021491842344403267,
0.3364584147930145,
0.6086264252662659,
0.12958374619483948,
0.8945824503898621,
-0.3458840250968933,
0.9250738024711609,
-0.1651342362165451,
0.04785717651247978,
0.13552291691303253,
-0.05365820601582527,
-0.2149830013513565,
-0.08730792254209518,
0.5876660346984863,
0.11490810662508011,
0.31277430057525635,
-0.7124906182289124,
-0.0184433963149786,
-0.2658470869064331,
0.2998652458190918,
-0.9939002394676208,
-0.4550396203994751,
0.013864872977137566,
-0.14802302420139313,
-0.25347891449928284,
-0.23110103607177734,
-0.44278648495674133,
-0.6659497618675232,
-0.3947176933288574,
0.5388185381889343,
-0.40076375007629395,
0.01106119342148304,
-0.1353839933872223,
-0.40759992599487305,
-0.25631412863731384,
0.32145583629608154,
-0.7445147037506104,
0.08999668806791306,
0.6557638049125671,
0.6577422618865967,
0.11292099952697754,
-0.005207311827689409,
-0.32524269819259644,
0.6644708514213562,
-0.3681769073009491,
0.5409862995147705,
-0.8064995408058167,
-0.46314066648483276,
-0.08997804671525955,
0.030750209465622902,
0.0835508331656456,
-0.6598395109176636,
0.30577966570854187,
-0.692382276058197,
-0.16121846437454224,
-0.4190148413181305,
-0.7924830913543701,
-0.1382695585489273,
0.29956185817718506,
-0.611171305179596,
0.9321460723876953,
0.4297279417514801,
-0.8268188238143921,
0.4622785449028015,
-0.5756651163101196,
-0.6903650760650635,
0.07388146966695786,
-0.509225606918335,
-0.33894193172454834,
-0.10580025613307953,
0.3352847695350647,
0.7267112731933594,
-0.3638564348220825,
-0.2018677145242691,
-0.596710205078125,
-0.16951312124729156,
-0.14357344806194305,
0.13625404238700867,
0.4458301365375519,
0.129682257771492,
-0.08006110042333603,
-0.16226977109909058,
-0.34672439098358154,
0.18546336889266968,
0.2639106810092926,
-0.2641790211200714,
-0.703112006187439,
-0.11449082940816879,
-0.6778080463409424,
-0.2080712616443634,
0.3671952486038208,
-0.226975679397583,
0.4099915027618408,
-0.21175415813922882,
0.45972520112991333,
0.6246950626373291,
0.16593265533447266,
0.7508885860443115,
-0.19195765256881714,
0.3767632842063904,
0.0998452827334404,
-0.20520617067813873,
0.18273265659809113,
-0.6551432013511658,
-0.47454795241355896,
-0.540265679359436,
0.5592722296714783,
0.2677220404148102,
-1.0509493350982666,
0.36530736088752747,
-0.6815623044967651,
-0.5874103903770447,
-0.6204924583435059,
0.5234018564224243,
0.018905159085989,
0.6527377367019653,
0.4346419870853424,
-0.20026874542236328,
-0.4824669063091278,
-0.83563232421875,
-0.37005072832107544,
0.21651683747768402,
-0.32661640644073486,
0.8301329016685486,
0.3417923152446747,
-0.5449573993682861,
1.2533478736877441,
-0.71190345287323,
-0.45671042799949646,
-0.22405025362968445,
-0.11104068160057068,
-0.06911390274763107,
0.38810357451438904,
0.4332294762134552,
-0.778001606464386,
-0.7691060900688171,
0.2526058554649353,
-1.0109223127365112,
0.15059959888458252,
0.3894611597061157,
-0.08957973122596741,
-0.2328438013792038,
0.3472370505332947,
-0.4458470642566681,
0.14740398526191711,
0.23637089133262634,
-0.20573055744171143,
0.207046240568161,
-0.1265544295310974,
0.04505505785346031,
-0.7089842557907104,
-0.03964437171816826,
-0.12852485477924347,
-0.473449170589447,
-0.5044735074043274,
-0.10307635366916656,
0.11140916496515274,
-0.24022911489009857,
-0.030134057626128197,
0.5674847960472107,
-0.3166360557079315,
-0.09022462368011475,
-0.18715542554855347,
0.5254849791526794,
0.15833142399787903,
0.3179709315299988,
-0.14961987733840942,
0.5711445808410645,
0.4354404807090759,
-0.6143075227737427,
0.28679537773132324,
0.2940675914287567,
-0.1820826232433319,
0.3823757469654083,
-0.5209553241729736,
0.1673569679260254,
-0.05082728713750839,
0.14583997428417206,
-0.5627989172935486,
-0.4136720895767212,
0.40902289748191833,
-0.4118556082248688,
0.5895731449127197,
-0.44638440012931824,
-0.5452144145965576,
-0.40120017528533936,
-0.1508868783712387,
0.3376072943210602,
0.5637603402137756,
-0.6626208424568176,
0.8390318155288696,
0.6269413232803345,
-0.04233062267303467,
-0.5788633823394775,
-0.5686324834823608,
-0.017347704619169235,
-0.1732814610004425,
-0.8275274634361267,
0.2803248167037964,
0.4753062129020691,
-0.05462652072310448,
0.5146105289459229,
-0.03259168937802315,
0.17908723652362823,
0.20029321312904358,
0.28971460461616516,
-0.1424998641014099,
-0.07729547470808029,
0.36270323395729065,
0.2092830389738083,
0.0190797820687294,
-0.13133752346038818,
-0.910602331161499,
0.3706645369529724,
0.13853174448013306,
-0.44863161444664,
0.10032566636800766,
0.17353013157844543,
0.18152713775634766,
-0.002283171284943819,
0.8509128093719482,
0.668302059173584,
-0.5745570063591003,
-0.48159515857696533,
-0.203622967004776,
-0.20333582162857056,
-0.48892486095428467,
0.40796154737472534,
-0.5009759664535522,
-1.347108006477356,
0.2529914081096649,
-0.6764526963233948,
-0.2823135256767273,
0.520546019077301,
0.3742308020591736,
-0.14626730978488922,
1.0429900884628296,
0.7340403199195862,
-0.2874358296394348,
0.23294903337955475,
-0.3553029000759125,
0.4630289673805237,
-0.9242188930511475,
-0.14377716183662415,
-0.512618899345398,
-0.46873974800109863,
-0.5170817971229553,
-0.7611492872238159,
0.32567980885505676,
0.365601509809494,
-0.36136379837989807,
0.28879013657569885,
-0.45909273624420166,
0.46386024355888367,
0.27052539587020874,
0.2341010719537735,
0.2321813702583313,
0.1120416447520256,
-0.285994291305542,
-0.015024540945887566,
-1.0445832014083862,
-0.41445764899253845,
1.374930500984192,
0.3136637806892395,
0.7346014976501465,
0.04345042631030083,
0.71959388256073,
0.6869940757751465,
0.5256849527359009,
-0.7768001556396484,
0.3347186744213104,
-0.28591322898864746,
-0.26917552947998047,
-0.45398563146591187,
-0.8269581198692322,
-0.8300442695617676,
0.035141631960868835,
-0.05079453065991402,
-0.7692885994911194,
0.09401911497116089,
0.24473854899406433,
-0.06635250151157379,
0.4877922832965851,
-0.7103126645088196,
0.957718014717102,
0.034338559955358505,
-0.2727883756160736,
-0.16652077436447144,
-0.260560542345047,
0.15753020346164703,
-0.08750513195991516,
0.2349105030298233,
0.1698552817106247,
-0.2026013433933258,
0.6497015357017517,
-0.45738258957862854,
0.9602120518684387,
-0.5605862736701965,
0.0023904480040073395,
0.44493892788887024,
-0.06297717988491058,
1.049277901649475,
-0.11103534698486328,
0.1683899313211441,
-0.19008736312389374,
-0.5379570722579956,
-0.588213324546814,
-0.8824092745780945,
0.7585095763206482,
-0.7609989047050476,
-0.639121949672699,
0.33293893933296204,
-0.5692131519317627,
-0.6119579076766968,
0.24583902955055237,
-0.17013761401176453,
0.3565441370010376,
0.022636277601122856,
0.415569007396698,
0.7146598696708679,
-0.0333610363304615,
-0.24528728425502777,
-0.03829250857234001,
-0.19301418960094452,
-0.562350332736969,
1.22111976146698,
0.33486390113830566,
0.23212528228759766,
0.42670875787734985,
0.06769748777151108,
-0.24724628031253815,
-0.3868127763271332,
-0.5722155570983887,
0.03127102553844452,
-1.0384215116500854,
-0.3737647831439972,
-1.0121920108795166,
0.09969954937696457,
-0.633213222026825,
-0.2723028361797333,
-0.059535913169384,
-0.6742014288902283,
-0.18990132212638855,
-0.18311361968517303,
0.5563541650772095,
0.715242862701416,
-0.05017116293311119,
0.22099117934703827,
-0.6144623756408691,
0.18248194456100464,
0.5771294236183167,
0.2210332155227661,
0.3776944577693939,
-0.21943721175193787,
-0.6499152779579163,
0.030877895653247833,
-0.15834999084472656,
-0.5977358222007751,
0.02224063128232956,
0.15921521186828613,
0.6253091096878052,
0.5617128014564514,
0.14442919194698334,
0.671716570854187,
-0.42893466353416443,
0.5743300914764404,
0.02278372459113598,
-0.623232364654541,
0.41744905710220337,
-0.2973134517669678,
-0.2730454206466675,
0.3536674380302429,
0.6815273761749268,
-0.28484365344047546,
-0.35757702589035034,
-0.5452244877815247,
-0.9444933533668518,
0.28144001960754395,
-0.05680419132113457,
0.07679804414510727,
0.024956142529845238,
0.33117687702178955,
-0.055775076150894165,
0.40820711851119995,
-0.2729089856147766,
-0.26615846157073975,
-0.11591052263975143,
-0.43805211782455444,
0.03245725855231285,
-0.07018928974866867,
-0.45876553654670715,
-0.21138425171375275,
0.7166358828544617,
-0.5263397097587585,
0.38028061389923096,
0.025693504139780998,
-0.404534250497818,
0.11055310070514679,
-0.02019832842051983,
-0.030916182324290276,
0.28533124923706055,
-0.01772613823413849,
0.38038721680641174,
0.3509920537471771,
-0.26682326197624207,
-0.004932135809212923,
0.19007530808448792,
-0.26146259903907776,
-0.31031402945518494,
0.2142069935798645,
0.5641914010047913,
0.327136367559433,
-0.38946449756622314,
0.3818943500518799,
0.27267614006996155,
0.1157238706946373,
0.1521918773651123,
0.07840711623430252,
0.42334291338920593,
0.3918638229370117,
0.3352552652359009,
0.01764502003788948,
-0.048297952860593796,
-0.31746798753738403,
0.19089224934577942,
0.5480196475982666,
-0.5092409253120422,
0.11421084403991699,
0.5685670375823975,
0.2824932634830475,
0.0368628054857254,
0.465914785861969,
-0.5041714906692505,
-0.5717638731002808,
0.3947101831436157,
0.39700207114219666,
0.6144680380821228,
0.3622773289680481,
-0.004660801496356726,
0.059428147971630096,
0.25058841705322266,
0.17601436376571655,
-0.0269856508821249,
-0.24942056834697723,
-0.7847321033477783,
-0.36092591285705566,
-0.5251054763793945,
-0.5363101363182068,
-0.4271593391895294,
-0.33006876707077026,
0.03594307228922844,
-0.30715128779411316,
-0.22541479766368866,
-0.17432014644145966,
0.24940820038318634,
-0.9348700046539307,
0.0846058800816536,
-0.038671813905239105,
1.0074635744094849,
-0.6390419602394104,
0.9630153179168701,
0.6981800198554993,
-0.3149372935295105,
-0.7632499933242798,
-0.30540576577186584,
-0.2184528410434723,
-0.847409188747406,
0.6249599456787109,
0.01799553446471691,
-0.00030078424606472254,
0.2170751690864563,
-0.35676077008247375,
-0.4925609827041626,
1.4989451169967651,
0.19819507002830505,
-0.3149566650390625,
-0.0056798625737428665,
0.6159423589706421,
0.2281850427389145,
-0.7025995850563049,
-0.2219296395778656,
0.4341568052768707,
0.668508768081665,
-0.15274085104465485,
-0.32812193036079407,
0.33991149067878723,
0.14832966029644012,
-0.09943780303001404,
0.22984999418258667,
-0.44780027866363525,
0.44020169973373413,
-0.27467936277389526,
-0.08692517876625061,
-0.17440055310726166,
0.8590208292007446,
0.16783487796783447,
0.2284228801727295,
0.5344562530517578,
0.959530234336853,
1.253700852394104,
-0.21079257130622864,
1.1235073804855347,
-0.32496607303619385,
0.16972684860229492,
0.9923841953277588,
-0.12021538615226746,
0.4905513823032379,
0.4204273223876953,
-0.3813875615596771,
0.41602084040641785,
0.4987840950489044,
-0.055100373923778534,
0.6698803305625916,
0.20007489621639252,
-0.3105272352695465,
-0.346445769071579,
-0.37782976031303406,
-0.379319429397583,
-0.0002431382890790701,
0.5796765089035034,
-0.5226994156837463,
-0.13327373564243317,
0.05854927748441696,
0.15525226294994354,
-0.17505593597888947,
-0.4504145085811615,
0.5859640836715698,
0.31232789158821106,
-0.1758650690317154,
0.014439644291996956,
-0.13881121575832367,
0.4806448221206665,
-0.6236898899078369,
0.13600148260593414,
0.046099703758955,
0.10221116244792938,
-0.23731935024261475,
-0.6160220503807068,
0.19927255809307098,
-0.1033247783780098,
-0.3134293854236603,
-0.2556123733520508,
1.2445130348205566,
-0.3819234073162079,
-0.17777475714683533,
0.5392481088638306,
0.747673511505127,
-0.23482128977775574,
-0.06859716773033142,
-0.1833743453025818,
-0.17360882461071014,
-0.01861279271543026,
-0.09896395355463028,
0.6219789385795593,
0.8505474925041199,
0.17644266784191132,
0.6673681735992432,
0.3965349495410919,
0.01717078499495983,
-0.11270343512296677,
0.03225516155362129,
1.1469697952270508,
-0.30788561701774597,
-0.2745007574558258,
-0.6214615106582642,
0.46844109892845154,
-0.244905024766922,
0.19312410056591034,
0.834629476070404,
0.5423619747161865,
0.8180625438690186,
-0.09540946781635284,
1.070050597190857,
-0.3389025330543518,
0.23255066573619843,
-0.2914546728134155,
0.838779866695404,
-0.5765202641487122,
0.10141290724277496,
-0.06988309323787689,
-0.6620051860809326,
-0.2533968687057495,
0.1183541864156723,
-0.5016771554946899,
0.020654132589697838,
0.31099480390548706,
0.686686098575592,
0.018522894009947777,
-0.04227987676858902,
0.3685801327228546,
-0.013387740589678288,
0.2649736702442169,
0.34822046756744385,
0.6369706392288208,
-0.12453806400299072,
0.702752947807312,
-0.3433140218257904,
-0.14004653692245483,
-0.1711750328540802,
-0.7262237071990967,
-0.8664727210998535,
-0.3231108486652374,
-0.3224855661392212,
-0.27633869647979736,
0.023240800946950912,
0.766895055770874,
0.5710809826850891,
-0.5640144944190979,
0.2623522877693176,
0.18450838327407837,
0.5268862247467041,
-0.14606469869613647,
-0.18938139081001282,
0.5140072107315063,
-0.5294041633605957,
-0.5797602534294128,
0.3927280902862549,
0.20151254534721375,
0.05695902183651924,
-0.1801929920911789,
-0.23764291405677795,
0.31990960240364075,
-0.22849223017692566,
0.6301578283309937,
0.2485203593969345,
-0.2389904260635376,
-0.6080994009971619,
-0.07740473747253418,
-0.08014978468418121,
-0.1702258139848709,
0.9351358413696289,
-0.896432638168335,
0.2817297577857971,
0.3702149987220764,
1.2347214221954346,
0.42552533745765686,
-0.18095403909683228,
0.49936991930007935,
-1.244827389717102,
-0.054918766021728516,
0.12595242261886597,
0.5760676860809326,
0.4050866663455963,
-0.30486613512039185,
0.7352635264396667,
0.370144248008728,
-0.5277440547943115,
-0.7464275360107422,
0.18746820092201233,
-0.7398567199707031,
-0.2527359426021576,
0.9694697260856628,
-0.3572688102722168,
-0.1535017043352127,
-0.032329387962818146,
0.18691697716712952,
0.37333375215530396,
-0.1833290457725525,
0.5415796637535095,
0.540492832660675,
-0.12581738829612732,
0.26242178678512573,
-0.409869909286499,
0.6224629878997803,
0.014115392230451107,
-0.675859272480011,
0.08285339921712875,
0.19540604948997498,
0.10491865873336792,
0.25275230407714844,
0.3196576237678528,
-0.03514380380511284,
-0.17696085572242737,
0.09614817053079605,
-0.3290430009365082,
-0.44991186261177063,
-0.3633418083190918,
0.15894557535648346,
0.48223763704299927,
0.20871855318546295,
0.026870451867580414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10741v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10741v1
|
SBAAM! Eliminating Transcript Dependency in Automatic Subtitling
| 2024-05-17T12:42:56 | 2024-05-17T12:42:56 |
Marco Gaido, Sara Papi, Matteo Negri, Mauro Cettolo, Luisa Bentivogli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Subtitling plays a crucial role in enhancing the accessibility of audiovisual
content and encompasses three primary subtasks: translating spoken dialogue,
segmenting translations into concise textual units, and estimating timestamps
that govern their on-screen duration. Past attempts to automate this process
rely, to varying degrees, on automatic transcripts, employed diversely for the
three subtasks. In response to the acknowledged limitations associated with
this reliance on transcripts, recent research has shifted towards
transcription-free solutions for translation and segmentation, leaving the
direct generation of timestamps as uncharted territory. To fill this gap, we
introduce the first direct model capable of producing automatic subtitles,
entirely eliminating any dependence on intermediate transcripts also for
timestamp prediction. Experimental results, backed by manual evaluation,
showcase our solution's new state-of-the-art performance across multiple
language pairs and diverse conditions.
|
[
-0.5495494604110718,
-0.6425564289093018,
0.587274432182312,
0.2725149989128113,
-0.7190952897071838,
0.07741270214319229,
0.1536012589931488,
-0.5748139023780823,
0.27134978771209717,
0.5347149968147278,
-0.9497823119163513,
-0.5756211876869202,
-0.7847709059715271,
0.26182135939598083,
-0.5783686637878418,
1.1395069360733032,
-0.07683511078357697,
-0.051240891218185425,
-0.2573619484901428,
-0.1614203304052353,
-0.5367582440376282,
-0.3531801700592041,
-0.36760956048965454,
-0.09366486221551895,
0.3089083731174469,
0.4123418927192688,
0.7053988575935364,
1.1550425291061401,
0.4282793402671814,
0.12327113747596741,
-0.0917491465806961,
0.3753930628299713,
0.21649476885795593,
0.4403058886528015,
-0.020276017487049103,
-0.09250825643539429,
-0.4562356173992157,
0.0959576815366745,
0.7297777533531189,
0.7410682439804077,
-0.020917456597089767,
0.38746848702430725,
-0.20890536904335022,
0.6898781657218933,
-0.4311552047729492,
0.20193225145339966,
-0.5982216000556946,
0.24880890548229218,
-0.29244473576545715,
-0.36192622780799866,
-0.4206644296646118,
-0.18341556191444397,
0.16874052584171295,
-0.41017821431159973,
0.45245933532714844,
-0.01643560640513897,
0.9442095756530762,
0.8492246866226196,
-0.4892338514328003,
0.07836303114891052,
-0.8180007934570312,
0.6666404008865356,
-0.722826361656189,
0.30270618200302124,
0.3887779712677002,
0.3977685570716858,
0.0882384181022644,
-0.49991416931152344,
-0.1810356080532074,
-0.12536737322807312,
0.09144888073205948,
-0.09559796005487442,
-0.5080788135528564,
0.11075993627309799,
0.1836765855550766,
0.35633987188339233,
-0.4809090793132782,
0.12268512696027756,
-0.18799465894699097,
-0.29974886775016785,
0.3695024847984314,
0.366687536239624,
0.5595470666885376,
-0.35145509243011475,
-0.3528153896331787,
0.46101096272468567,
-0.6092979907989502,
-0.2700820863246918,
0.12789958715438843,
0.24732117354869843,
0.10855796188116074,
0.7165802121162415,
-0.30834949016571045,
0.32045912742614746,
0.19440717995166779,
0.008360323496162891,
0.13292661309242249,
-0.6580516695976257,
-0.27100831270217896,
0.22316965460777283,
0.43803730607032776,
0.1721942126750946,
0.031194064766168594,
-0.06760478019714355,
0.029134519398212433,
-0.1104913055896759,
0.25435441732406616,
-0.5872840285301208,
-0.022521639242768288,
0.2484593540430069,
-0.2096196562051773,
-0.002352098235860467,
-0.033803120255470276,
-0.27498432993888855,
-0.3167630136013031,
-0.4547218382358551,
0.3469782769680023,
-0.2936941981315613,
0.12928229570388794,
-0.3706289529800415,
0.0011443832190707326,
0.2085086852312088,
0.4076792597770691,
-0.8545395731925964,
0.43916720151901245,
0.35407328605651855,
0.9580137133598328,
-0.470330148935318,
-0.21177147328853607,
-0.9323803186416626,
0.594714343547821,
-0.47165143489837646,
0.7910576462745667,
-0.21370476484298706,
-0.44401854276657104,
-0.413443922996521,
-0.06528086215257645,
0.5133508443832397,
-0.5738663673400879,
0.22051319479942322,
-0.2664889693260193,
0.002571839140728116,
0.15080787241458893,
-0.4955199956893921,
-0.18792589008808136,
-0.32192307710647583,
-0.7031229138374329,
0.6503385305404663,
0.09639705717563629,
-0.327785849571228,
0.2747330963611603,
-0.6002792119979858,
-0.6114864349365234,
0.10191228985786438,
0.012556341476738453,
-0.2921060621738434,
0.11001870781183243,
0.755638062953949,
0.09098055213689804,
-0.43840092420578003,
0.441841721534729,
0.11286040395498276,
-0.1369638592004776,
-0.0038118353113532066,
-0.749454140663147,
0.4352877736091614,
0.0325729101896286,
-0.5871532559394836,
0.4252709150314331,
-0.6740043759346008,
-0.16858144104480743,
-0.15807895362377167,
-0.01517454069107771,
-0.14971813559532166,
-0.00466966675594449,
-0.15108898282051086,
0.11340564489364624,
0.1232634037733078,
-0.4341502785682678,
0.062057748436927795,
-0.26211369037628174,
0.19572238624095917,
0.8912275433540344,
0.23383474349975586,
0.6776485443115234,
-0.06004287675023079,
0.7319908738136292,
0.20421037077903748,
0.40596631169319153,
-0.5657132863998413,
-0.40170788764953613,
-0.8654696941375732,
-0.5179339051246643,
0.3179425597190857,
0.4327816069126129,
-0.5597471594810486,
0.14017055928707123,
-0.09807178378105164,
-0.4537036120891571,
-0.6194316744804382,
0.05766445770859718,
0.4448840022087097,
0.5218095183372498,
0.7453093528747559,
-0.4930684566497803,
-0.6714223623275757,
-1.2337405681610107,
-0.20059223473072052,
-0.013833819888532162,
-0.18757784366607666,
0.130689337849617,
0.17924654483795166,
-0.443424791097641,
1.035828948020935,
-0.6383453607559204,
-0.6210706233978271,
-0.22060994803905487,
0.4315639138221741,
-0.010542677715420723,
0.5814467072486877,
0.3324261009693146,
-0.7012345194816589,
-0.5412490963935852,
-0.2493937909603119,
-0.5621454119682312,
-0.6976261138916016,
0.0061281584203243256,
0.02274056151509285,
0.6230979561805725,
0.5627986192703247,
-0.587772011756897,
0.8585021495819092,
0.27753642201423645,
-0.1364528089761734,
0.6975122094154358,
0.06577158719301224,
0.18201178312301636,
-0.5394922494888306,
-0.07722916454076767,
-0.11467067897319794,
-0.46248772740364075,
-0.4757113754749298,
-0.2992952764034271,
-0.09487626701593399,
-0.388624906539917,
-0.765291690826416,
0.5862813591957092,
-0.5559114217758179,
-0.36949610710144043,
-0.35008537769317627,
-0.1463567316532135,
0.06432764232158661,
0.578565776348114,
0.2221013456583023,
0.6454393267631531,
0.31074845790863037,
-0.5519358515739441,
0.26043206453323364,
0.4095440208911896,
-0.4069836735725403,
0.1517602503299713,
-0.7356095910072327,
0.06338988989591599,
-0.21584707498550415,
0.4146122336387634,
-0.9697532653808594,
-0.3743659555912018,
0.5182737112045288,
-0.606204628944397,
0.19384637475013733,
-0.4753623604774475,
-0.1542491465806961,
0.14889848232269287,
0.16729533672332764,
0.4043833613395691,
0.548349916934967,
-0.2043803334236145,
0.695728600025177,
0.521943211555481,
-0.7139533162117004,
-0.4442470669746399,
-0.7386327981948853,
0.21593187749385834,
0.01771809160709381,
-0.4216729402542114,
0.39179444313049316,
0.06269533932209015,
-0.16074052453041077,
0.10726179927587509,
-0.747536838054657,
-0.39936909079551697,
-0.13266314566135406,
0.3870842456817627,
0.3603009879589081,
-0.02405928075313568,
-0.239982008934021,
0.48253872990608215,
-0.4849132299423218,
-0.2461765706539154,
-0.43804123997688293,
0.22132383286952972,
0.214307963848114,
-0.40546754002571106,
-0.7596449851989746,
0.9860831499099731,
0.7836647629737854,
-0.6340484023094177,
0.4524063766002655,
0.5982151627540588,
-0.38082993030548096,
-0.3283190131187439,
-0.5016713738441467,
0.12998729944229126,
-0.42477625608444214,
0.3290080726146698,
-0.11384235322475433,
-0.8009355068206787,
0.30639031529426575,
0.22609108686447144,
0.15030188858509064,
0.26677405834198,
0.1176401674747467,
0.000040779112168820575,
1.3364590406417847,
0.4396589696407318,
0.3624882996082306,
0.6308128237724304,
0.007524995133280754,
-0.023714907467365265,
-0.7317484021186829,
-0.16523641347885132,
-0.3617282509803772,
-0.13247105479240417,
-0.16484956443309784,
-0.5582729578018188,
0.5539687275886536,
-0.39449524879455566,
0.031101007014513016,
0.5522257089614868,
-0.3316369354724884,
0.5941625833511353,
0.6301639080047607,
-0.015657726675271988,
0.3439112603664398,
-0.14698469638824463,
0.12682242691516876,
-0.18190674483776093,
-0.44614875316619873,
-0.44432199001312256,
0.7123780250549316,
0.285541832447052,
0.6242271661758423,
0.11896859109401703,
0.6687820553779602,
0.7885782718658447,
0.14543478190898895,
-0.8816594481468201,
0.7435393333435059,
-0.3583914041519165,
-0.5221161842346191,
-0.43081995844841003,
-0.37532997131347656,
-0.5528943538665771,
0.23338864743709564,
0.15431950986385345,
-0.42303043603897095,
-0.02893935516476631,
0.14899732172489166,
-0.34466588497161865,
0.1155867949128151,
-0.6059091091156006,
0.8177574276924133,
-0.11306283622980118,
-0.0791374146938324,
-0.03592560067772865,
-0.9601852297782898,
0.025908229872584343,
-0.015335249714553356,
0.28727203607559204,
-0.5260908007621765,
-0.18602336943149567,
0.7892576456069946,
-0.43845272064208984,
0.6793197393417358,
-0.27457207441329956,
0.007631816901266575,
0.48942309617996216,
0.4126395285129547,
0.06072769686579704,
-0.09833135455846786,
0.3619866967201233,
0.18814781308174133,
0.07729256898164749,
-0.38774314522743225,
-0.40172287821769714,
0.31261304020881653,
-0.3327453136444092,
-0.9061390161514282,
-0.544877827167511,
-0.5082011222839355,
-0.2328859120607376,
0.4116400182247162,
0.004200323019176722,
0.6799812912940979,
-0.2871133089065552,
0.22363267838954926,
0.529374897480011,
-0.30333778262138367,
0.47651293873786926,
0.7786451578140259,
-0.21780958771705627,
-0.6618406772613525,
0.6313572525978088,
0.03125675022602081,
0.3574167490005493,
0.45236822962760925,
-0.017151478677988052,
-0.5519741773605347,
-0.7746874094009399,
-0.4911602735519409,
0.07016824185848236,
-0.8160683512687683,
-0.23502527177333832,
-0.6319989562034607,
-0.10203664004802704,
-0.6803886890411377,
0.02707882598042488,
-0.4976236820220947,
-0.7022273540496826,
-0.4922141134738922,
-0.4515831470489502,
-0.07868313044309616,
0.45847758650779724,
-0.2349638044834137,
0.16566358506679535,
-1.3000938892364502,
0.7872757911682129,
0.3083242177963257,
-0.002652804832905531,
-0.1324874460697174,
-0.7419875860214233,
-0.44401949644088745,
-0.09709825366735458,
-0.2726373076438904,
-0.7088795304298401,
0.5986085534095764,
0.30989596247673035,
0.5546866655349731,
0.16687864065170288,
0.16492146253585815,
0.6859777569770813,
-0.9112091064453125,
0.9925177693367004,
0.1463795304298401,
-1.2838085889816284,
0.856259822845459,
-0.2687968313694,
0.6351956725120544,
0.3587673604488373,
0.3473550081253052,
-0.5513720512390137,
-0.546307384967804,
-0.3645119369029999,
-1.1814416646957397,
0.7766236662864685,
0.29018881916999817,
-0.1537545919418335,
-0.11623269319534302,
-0.03405601903796196,
0.5172376036643982,
0.24280232191085815,
-0.33679285645484924,
-0.06219102814793587,
-0.2704724669456482,
0.007190255913883448,
-0.19484645128250122,
-0.0828118547797203,
0.05255119502544403,
-0.2838209271430969,
0.7618157267570496,
0.11973104625940323,
-0.008195377886295319,
0.5060071349143982,
-0.4395790100097656,
-0.20702926814556122,
0.3210543096065521,
0.5302597284317017,
0.7005226016044617,
-0.2779673933982849,
0.12949274480342865,
-0.23286226391792297,
-0.23699873685836792,
0.5553390383720398,
-0.04667174816131592,
-0.4140795171260834,
0.5632786154747009,
0.3203383684158325,
0.9722300171852112,
0.184306338429451,
-0.5436261296272278,
0.14998792111873627,
0.13805711269378662,
0.09451964497566223,
-0.5037581324577332,
-0.021579647436738014,
-0.2541821300983429,
0.046846240758895874,
0.7125309705734253,
0.24642831087112427,
0.24317626655101776,
-0.529535710811615,
0.5645366907119751,
0.019869469106197357,
-0.5875417590141296,
-0.19040736556053162,
1.117012619972229,
0.5151220560073853,
-0.4576703906059265,
0.5086838006973267,
0.38689181208610535,
-0.25223198533058167,
0.7426822185516357,
0.3315095603466034,
1.2743639945983887,
-0.35494735836982727,
0.4057524800300598,
0.047853387892246246,
0.3183755874633789,
0.052558690309524536,
-0.2857629656791687,
-0.2723385691642761,
-0.23036549985408783,
-0.3202083110809326,
-0.6466115713119507,
-0.7332201600074768,
-0.16240528225898743,
-0.8199971914291382,
0.07051172852516174,
-0.4964029788970947,
-0.32884156703948975,
0.2644299566745758,
-0.48646092414855957,
-0.33543747663497925,
0.42707493901252747,
0.38769450783729553,
0.9116592407226562,
-0.8444837331771851,
0.7947521209716797,
0.4108460247516632,
-0.6600374579429626,
-0.4277156889438629,
0.04617508873343468,
0.18895168602466583,
-0.299182653427124,
0.467871755361557,
0.252667099237442,
-0.3630704879760742,
0.1382608562707901,
-0.5611171126365662,
-0.7618566155433655,
0.829825758934021,
0.25394460558891296,
-0.17323455214500427,
-0.30898016691207886,
0.12130014598369598,
0.3041090965270996,
-0.3347523808479309,
-0.1887790709733963,
0.7092998623847961,
0.4002993404865265,
0.05682229623198509,
-0.9300413727760315,
0.009685526601970196,
-0.21422220766544342,
-0.08772563189268112,
0.381682425737381,
-0.4165205657482147,
0.5017550587654114,
-0.11095782369375229,
-0.39974740147590637,
0.25635790824890137,
0.9466999769210815,
-0.08250603079795837,
0.29279592633247375,
0.34956780076026917,
0.15531986951828003,
0.2737956941127777,
-0.06258758902549744,
0.7952703833580017,
0.22104714810848236,
-0.06835553795099258,
1.431302547454834,
-0.16270554065704346,
0.388158917427063,
0.6586592197418213,
-0.1688719540834427,
0.38325899839401245,
0.6107729077339172,
0.16477571427822113,
0.7655726671218872,
-0.04537885636091232,
-0.28763869404792786,
-0.4402640461921692,
-0.4211799204349518,
-0.22342677414417267,
0.546866238117218,
0.20517262816429138,
-0.22997869551181793,
-0.1717824786901474,
0.034472305327653885,
-0.2970551550388336,
0.04867042228579521,
-0.28966787457466125,
0.8166730403900146,
0.1543920934200287,
-0.8407552242279053,
0.410635769367218,
-0.06105763092637062,
0.4390171766281128,
-1.0413432121276855,
-0.05489155277609825,
-0.479667067527771,
-0.2486525923013687,
-0.18739545345306396,
-0.5447494387626648,
0.6656460762023926,
0.2689864933490753,
-0.4625280797481537,
-0.3764576017856598,
0.4166123569011688,
-0.6030696630477905,
-0.09905988723039627,
0.18067467212677002,
0.33185479044914246,
0.3720729351043701,
-0.027211183682084084,
-0.2944469153881073,
0.0005593609530478716,
0.07073439657688141,
-0.12583079934120178,
0.2096058428287506,
0.3017788827419281,
-0.09860070049762726,
0.8045707941055298,
0.5416173934936523,
-0.0378740131855011,
0.18386542797088623,
0.12395167350769043,
0.3328106999397278,
-0.7521659731864929,
-0.6168285608291626,
-0.828737199306488,
0.4929080605506897,
0.3602661192417145,
-0.0141964852809906,
0.7397039532661438,
0.514757513999939,
0.5920447707176208,
-0.3648900091648102,
0.9542620778083801,
0.02099713310599327,
0.41746193170547485,
-0.46165743470191956,
0.6245173215866089,
-0.6254767775535583,
0.26091817021369934,
-0.5973177552223206,
-0.9553528428077698,
-0.36614498496055603,
0.055115003138780594,
-0.08028974384069443,
-0.4987800121307373,
0.7123342752456665,
0.41227662563323975,
0.023654239252209663,
-0.14684021472930908,
0.18509073555469513,
-0.12317758798599243,
0.431549608707428,
0.3545721471309662,
0.6982077956199646,
-0.23103556036949158,
0.9287698864936829,
-0.2701939046382904,
-0.28045862913131714,
-0.12036671489477158,
-1.0189030170440674,
-0.6073110103607178,
-0.5586029887199402,
-0.5487493872642517,
-0.016464758664369583,
-0.08824226260185242,
0.9489095211029053,
0.6158725619316101,
-1.02423095703125,
-0.06157628446817398,
0.13861313462257385,
0.23837970197200775,
-0.44338759779930115,
-0.21245549619197845,
0.24822670221328735,
0.03777916729450226,
-0.9559604525566101,
0.8218727111816406,
0.6216292381286621,
0.5326716899871826,
-0.0033005813602358103,
0.05900052189826965,
-0.20166946947574615,
0.43176552653312683,
0.49671557545661926,
0.43894141912460327,
-0.8952029943466187,
-0.3825240433216095,
-0.05866457149386406,
0.0772237703204155,
0.23820239305496216,
0.6295192837715149,
-0.5333093404769897,
0.4313075542449951,
0.4745578467845917,
0.5783095359802246,
0.5782489776611328,
0.5266640186309814,
0.8209280371665955,
-0.9078425765037537,
0.23242343962192535,
0.3704690933227539,
0.10783206671476364,
0.39540112018585205,
-0.19540315866470337,
0.588860273361206,
0.26769784092903137,
-0.3898901045322418,
-0.991187334060669,
0.4722825586795807,
-1.0246437788009644,
-0.28529196977615356,
0.9229695200920105,
-0.1811046451330185,
-0.1313183754682541,
-0.22484950721263885,
-0.40051764249801636,
0.6809133291244507,
-0.4022350013256073,
0.5087092518806458,
0.7197554707527161,
-0.3570803701877594,
-0.19097033143043518,
-0.23043471574783325,
0.5006533265113831,
0.4154149889945984,
-0.6246257424354553,
0.2399146407842636,
0.9045522809028625,
0.31394970417022705,
-0.045777931809425354,
0.8451265096664429,
-0.19073443114757538,
0.4689561724662781,
-0.03766082227230072,
-0.08374493569135666,
-0.5226840376853943,
-0.8044057488441467,
-0.2987755239009857,
0.04629070311784744,
-0.32087022066116333,
-0.5044117569923401
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10738v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10738v2
|
Feature-Adaptive and Data-Scalable In-Context Learning
| 2024-05-17T12:32:53 | 2024-06-03T06:42:32 |
Jiahao Li, Quan Wang, Licheng Zhang, Guoqing Jin, Zhendong Mao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In-context learning (ICL), which promotes inference with several
demonstrations, has become a widespread paradigm to stimulate LLM capabilities
for downstream tasks. Due to context length constraints, it cannot be further
improved in spite of more training data, and general features directly from
LLMs in ICL are not adaptive to the specific downstream task. In this paper, we
propose a feature-adaptive and data-scalable in-context learning framework
(FADS-ICL), which can leverage task-adaptive features to promote inference on
the downstream task, with the supervision of beyond-context samples.
Specifically, it first extracts general features of beyond-context samples via
the LLM with ICL input form one by one, and introduces a task-specific
modulator to perform feature refinement and prediction after fitting a specific
downstream task. We conduct extensive experiments on FADS-ICL under varying
data settings (4$\sim$128 shots) and LLM scale (0.8$\sim$70B) settings.
Experimental results show that FADS-ICL consistently outperforms previous
state-of-the-art methods by a significant margin under all settings, verifying
the effectiveness and superiority of FADS-ICL. For example, under the 1.5B and
32 shots setting, FADS-ICL can achieve \textbf{+14.3} average accuracy from
feature adaptation over vanilla ICL on 10 datasets, with \textbf{+6.2} average
accuracy over the previous state-of-the-art method, and the performance can
further improve with increasing training data. Code and data are publicly
available at \url{https://github.com/jiahaozhenbang/FADS-ICL}.
|
[
-0.5265765190124512,
-0.46945375204086304,
0.36607635021209717,
0.14325812458992004,
-0.2878500819206238,
-0.06477447599172592,
-0.1557914912700653,
-0.4212892949581146,
-0.024122117087244987,
0.46214401721954346,
-0.533577561378479,
-0.3437355160713196,
-0.5890775918960571,
0.003972151782363653,
-0.32771632075309753,
1.1717714071273804,
-0.07788227498531342,
0.05131891742348671,
-0.4372960031032562,
-0.3767949044704437,
-0.4361109137535095,
-0.40883690118789673,
-0.5114417672157288,
0.029282554984092712,
0.3077162206172943,
0.6737747192382812,
0.1702173352241516,
0.6066139936447144,
-0.0007455821032635868,
0.2320246398448944,
0.0269563440233469,
0.533519983291626,
-0.4242560863494873,
0.1799522489309311,
-0.2616236209869385,
-0.2835948169231415,
-0.5126013159751892,
-0.21099022030830383,
0.5846853256225586,
0.6031442880630493,
0.21917724609375,
0.15318608283996582,
0.5586792826652527,
0.6845345497131348,
-0.7871458530426025,
0.30532148480415344,
-0.79180908203125,
-0.0583709292113781,
-0.1840881109237671,
-0.2492499053478241,
-0.3481144309043884,
0.05647489055991173,
0.4740476608276367,
-0.6064673066139221,
0.38298818469047546,
0.08448298275470734,
0.6577738523483276,
0.5162279009819031,
-0.3602532148361206,
-0.46213677525520325,
-0.3369798958301544,
0.6619663834571838,
-0.5192914605140686,
0.43951669335365295,
0.3092510402202606,
0.1777850240468979,
-0.05560648813843727,
-0.6017270684242249,
-0.14879179000854492,
-0.21037425100803375,
-0.05670281872153282,
0.007927142083644867,
0.21137776970863342,
-0.29785728454589844,
0.3632347881793976,
0.29177409410476685,
-0.21741215884685516,
0.17412778735160828,
0.02784883975982666,
0.09636671096086502,
0.6853476762771606,
0.15021488070487976,
-0.3205794394016266,
0.4124751687049866,
-0.7267396450042725,
0.04079948738217354,
-0.694869875907898,
0.4342665374279022,
-0.2878754436969757,
0.36093565821647644,
-0.401246577501297,
-0.12296940386295319,
-0.382831335067749,
0.5446572303771973,
0.8183166980743408,
-0.2783645689487457,
0.47425177693367004,
0.03804568201303482,
-0.5015901923179626,
-0.038285911083221436,
0.0978405624628067,
-0.05796489864587784,
-0.26240694522857666,
-0.2011377364397049,
-0.4810188412666321,
-0.5191203355789185,
0.17642992734909058,
-0.8095558881759644,
-0.07560225576162338,
0.15863469243049622,
-0.1684068888425827,
0.02335883118212223,
0.09044914692640305,
-0.5879759788513184,
-0.469777375459671,
-0.4360998570919037,
0.5399680733680725,
-0.48413771390914917,
0.008874175138771534,
-0.153477743268013,
0.0666518285870552,
0.17494091391563416,
0.6247122287750244,
-0.853352963924408,
0.14719344675540924,
0.5895751118659973,
1.0537539720535278,
-0.38371044397354126,
-0.2686562240123749,
-0.814763069152832,
0.24144843220710754,
-0.3621037006378174,
0.6770583391189575,
-0.36763474345207214,
-0.3194785714149475,
-0.2542210519313812,
0.07228118926286697,
-0.074714295566082,
-0.584248423576355,
0.24486291408538818,
-0.6249404549598694,
-0.20371778309345245,
-0.37635770440101624,
-0.8422893285751343,
-0.4052795171737671,
0.12317923456430435,
-0.5257800817489624,
0.8126354217529297,
0.22541767358779907,
-0.6617195010185242,
1.093349814414978,
-1.0155198574066162,
-0.40418556332588196,
0.040209848433732986,
-0.12910161912441254,
-0.5651530027389526,
0.036702852696180344,
0.36342188715934753,
0.8585308194160461,
-0.2092037796974182,
0.34659457206726074,
-0.7874590158462524,
-0.5859413743019104,
0.13115203380584717,
-0.4646507501602173,
0.5790766477584839,
0.0721040815114975,
-0.6390926837921143,
0.4291887581348419,
-0.5792925953865051,
-0.24171346426010132,
-0.4268896281719208,
-0.4459351599216461,
0.1146075576543808,
0.12444022297859192,
0.08800721913576126,
0.12341403216123581,
-0.13480374217033386,
-0.48832598328590393,
-0.017054731026291847,
-0.29900801181793213,
0.3557324707508087,
0.8889198899269104,
-0.0806986540555954,
0.6182382106781006,
-0.6094677448272705,
0.2547139525413513,
0.17219805717468262,
0.09852847456932068,
-0.2085525244474411,
-0.2057557851076126,
-0.652491569519043,
-0.8681069016456604,
0.15195368230342865,
0.3978152275085449,
-0.9198909401893616,
0.5793545842170715,
-0.3988601863384247,
-0.27862250804901123,
-0.0794805958867073,
0.4005134105682373,
0.3295382261276245,
0.7899960875511169,
0.6133819818496704,
-0.11946102231740952,
-0.22778138518333435,
-0.4286283254623413,
0.022679917514324188,
0.2073015570640564,
-0.37236347794532776,
0.5891054272651672,
0.47660303115844727,
-0.008449292741715908,
1.0925354957580566,
-0.2893475890159607,
-0.625906229019165,
-0.12800346314907074,
-0.004059797618538141,
-0.04949682950973511,
0.47526317834854126,
0.7467148900032043,
-0.9074336886405945,
-0.5693280696868896,
0.09753300249576569,
-0.5343620777130127,
-0.1317618489265442,
-0.19715780019760132,
0.17315571010112762,
0.3567323684692383,
0.600327730178833,
0.022942660376429558,
0.4384244680404663,
0.4223690927028656,
-0.4693961441516876,
0.3260098397731781,
-0.15390503406524658,
0.0848938450217247,
-1.0268909931182861,
-0.07671047002077103,
0.21218793094158173,
-0.24891376495361328,
-0.40942028164863586,
-0.17771336436271667,
0.24508757889270782,
0.1521756798028946,
-0.5008646249771118,
0.6646026968955994,
-0.32416725158691406,
-0.3262749910354614,
-0.5447606444358826,
-0.15899232029914856,
-0.004887665156275034,
0.5398295521736145,
0.12323208153247833,
0.9016035795211792,
0.9280587434768677,
-0.8177556395530701,
0.18992452323436737,
0.03154347091913223,
-0.4227094054222107,
0.612460732460022,
-0.06835372745990753,
-0.13352172076702118,
-0.08230538666248322,
0.6365737318992615,
-0.8962634801864624,
-0.4900190532207489,
0.05210418626666069,
-0.14962460100650787,
0.4191606342792511,
-0.15289324522018433,
-0.11455825716257095,
0.0067707994021475315,
-0.18672627210617065,
0.23646758496761322,
0.4034751057624817,
-0.9362849593162537,
0.7963043451309204,
0.20912912487983704,
0.11705610156059265,
-0.5543730854988098,
-0.7141301035881042,
-0.07652309536933899,
-0.6017235517501831,
-0.45489582419395447,
0.4983832538127899,
-0.17361876368522644,
0.1174057349562645,
-0.2377607822418213,
-0.18061864376068115,
-0.27940207719802856,
0.35750195384025574,
0.5507789254188538,
0.12917378544807434,
-0.270261287689209,
0.2572939097881317,
0.2606377601623535,
-0.003055079374462366,
-0.031899791210889816,
-0.3694087266921997,
0.073251873254776,
-0.10811729729175568,
-0.3580588698387146,
-0.5917887687683105,
0.0605512373149395,
0.7450080513954163,
0.1176287978887558,
0.17249695956707,
0.6076340675354004,
-0.26052504777908325,
-0.7034790515899658,
-0.38851138949394226,
-0.28258252143859863,
-0.5079817175865173,
0.5063056349754333,
-0.5108569860458374,
-1.1525570154190063,
0.32599276304244995,
-0.3401499390602112,
0.16442520916461945,
0.14999353885650635,
0.4137566387653351,
-0.2739890515804291,
0.5808210968971252,
0.6998628973960876,
-0.2714916169643402,
0.575262725353241,
-0.4149237871170044,
-0.23727570474147797,
-0.9876015186309814,
-0.042326126247644424,
0.013426302932202816,
-0.5320325493812561,
-0.23982685804367065,
-0.5232784748077393,
0.46607452630996704,
0.2288571149110794,
-0.418556809425354,
0.087545245885849,
-0.027953971177339554,
0.21545295417308807,
0.35033535957336426,
0.6602468490600586,
-0.06681744009256363,
-0.1089199110865593,
0.045612890273332596,
0.0241826344281435,
-0.591174840927124,
-0.18212883174419403,
1.0276365280151367,
0.3225471079349518,
0.6499518752098083,
-0.07702607661485672,
0.272424578666687,
0.676011860370636,
0.7479810118675232,
-0.7125563025474548,
0.3798930048942566,
-0.4426548182964325,
-0.4417968690395355,
-0.3367290794849396,
-0.07249890267848969,
-0.14881329238414764,
0.19514219462871552,
-0.3017956018447876,
-0.5786122679710388,
0.4872033894062042,
0.5203313827514648,
-0.5246317982673645,
0.4811660349369049,
-0.6261839866638184,
0.4165298342704773,
-0.40540412068367004,
-0.52912837266922,
-0.02505413629114628,
-0.5166054964065552,
0.2223576009273529,
-0.3997218608856201,
-0.07263028621673584,
-0.08144337683916092,
-0.4325620234012604,
0.25788959860801697,
-0.3661026358604431,
1.1764365434646606,
-0.4840826392173767,
0.04206620529294014,
0.075285404920578,
-0.09043566137552261,
0.3865037262439728,
0.316061407327652,
-0.24461548030376434,
0.1010511964559555,
-0.4431518316268921,
-0.43706831336021423,
-0.6425448060035706,
0.8204862475395203,
-0.5602318644523621,
-0.7083542346954346,
-0.11645630747079849,
-1.0060793161392212,
-0.5703508257865906,
-0.10332134366035461,
0.2476826161146164,
0.6686657667160034,
0.1293371170759201,
0.4708346128463745,
0.772294819355011,
-0.0025293261278420687,
0.7522523403167725,
0.4093053936958313,
0.16980622708797455,
-0.3866676688194275,
0.9284732341766357,
0.15004123747348785,
0.37712472677230835,
0.4510582685470581,
0.03373352810740471,
-0.2895345091819763,
-0.815742015838623,
-0.7658166289329529,
-0.37681108713150024,
-0.6934022307395935,
-0.34143996238708496,
-0.567809522151947,
-0.10554056614637375,
-0.17760375142097473,
-0.7498269081115723,
-0.08919000625610352,
0.1900223046541214,
-0.6029648780822754,
0.1044331043958664,
0.6077116131782532,
0.3754074275493622,
0.06095561757683754,
0.2143433839082718,
-0.48561230301856995,
0.05708612501621246,
0.4533364772796631,
0.2740727365016937,
0.03297700732946396,
-0.9186440706253052,
-0.35917311906814575,
0.018480410799384117,
-0.18775194883346558,
-0.23024636507034302,
0.2264055609703064,
0.5462133884429932,
0.2444329708814621,
0.7192594408988953,
0.04050762206315994,
1.0386064052581787,
-0.27801191806793213,
0.6361356973648071,
-0.07554999738931656,
-1.065504550933838,
0.28292056918144226,
-0.1612410694360733,
0.22293557226657867,
0.4803581237792969,
0.5041496157646179,
0.019134894013404846,
-0.13423578441143036,
-0.32630839943885803,
-0.6074997186660767,
0.8772642612457275,
-0.2329670637845993,
0.08778369426727295,
0.23567698895931244,
0.6232929229736328,
0.3575214743614197,
-0.03248484805226326,
-0.379043847322464,
-0.07779500633478165,
-0.17467562854290009,
-0.20557411015033722,
0.06475982069969177,
-0.04600803181529045,
0.05735006183385849,
-0.34497585892677307,
0.7486827373504639,
-0.7840791940689087,
-0.0009365736041218042,
0.3174205422401428,
-0.24952898919582367,
0.10739199817180634,
-0.02166438288986683,
0.5589323043823242,
0.8674411177635193,
-0.21423737704753876,
-0.12940803170204163,
0.7378019094467163,
-0.49872517585754395,
0.1754496842622757,
0.22503331303596497,
-0.29212915897369385,
-0.31241804361343384,
0.33715924620628357,
0.9659135341644287,
0.5348672866821289,
-0.6813058257102966,
0.6362470388412476,
0.24862752854824066,
-0.3118797838687897,
-0.1599940061569214,
0.46245577931404114,
-0.13170897960662842,
0.7915165424346924,
0.7581399083137512,
0.37198469042778015,
0.164757639169693,
-0.2991142272949219,
0.685448169708252,
0.4281648099422455,
-0.7001886963844299,
-0.22921374440193176,
0.6560792922973633,
0.24356240034103394,
0.1715323030948639,
0.2008674591779709,
-0.13059188425540924,
-0.08803527802228928,
0.7729343771934509,
0.49390390515327454,
1.0064043998718262,
-0.017064841464161873,
0.047663670033216476,
0.1387374848127365,
-0.395774781703949,
0.15647396445274353,
0.2272176891565323,
-0.4479636549949646,
-0.8019547462463379,
-0.45525091886520386,
-0.522387683391571,
-0.22247691452503204,
0.32653534412384033,
-0.5460153818130493,
0.3966650366783142,
-0.6441073417663574,
0.038018252700567245,
0.03325453773140907,
-0.1265590488910675,
-0.5175648927688599,
0.41568851470947266,
0.1748552769422531,
1.1055833101272583,
-0.6952532529830933,
1.2928591966629028,
0.6979244351387024,
-0.030194168910384178,
-0.43112167716026306,
0.4994916021823883,
0.20167674124240875,
-0.5321547985076904,
0.8793473243713379,
0.23157723248004913,
-0.2378915399312973,
0.18227623403072357,
-0.3829617202281952,
-1.0055497884750366,
1.638284683227539,
0.5370250940322876,
-0.3795974552631378,
0.23300467431545258,
-0.15123917162418365,
0.25806453824043274,
-1.0897130966186523,
0.08849412202835083,
0.3341052234172821,
0.10364359617233276,
0.2543821632862091,
-0.7548438310623169,
0.15028445422649384,
0.19242772459983826,
0.14051897823810577,
-0.04483506456017494,
-0.6224916577339172,
0.7510702013969421,
-0.39060071110725403,
-0.0912538394331932,
0.004347512032836676,
0.9502587914466858,
0.3382358253002167,
0.45710957050323486,
0.8675500154495239,
0.36483651399612427,
0.4366445541381836,
-0.05487958341836929,
0.7431383728981018,
-0.12020133435726166,
0.3389218747615814,
1.2885631322860718,
-0.4122615456581116,
0.7840259075164795,
0.2540521025657654,
0.05952073633670807,
0.39527401328086853,
0.7912129759788513,
-0.011223241686820984,
0.7782179117202759,
-0.1452426016330719,
-0.4079415798187256,
-0.30279016494750977,
-0.006606771145015955,
0.04037260264158249,
0.5588573217391968,
0.6508841514587402,
-0.4677276611328125,
-0.2531045079231262,
0.4783639907836914,
-0.20151221752166748,
-0.16054914891719818,
-0.6079320311546326,
0.7299377918243408,
-0.22291941940784454,
-0.20477677881717682,
0.4622381925582886,
-0.2777961790561676,
0.9972598552703857,
-0.48721304535865784,
-0.24610403180122375,
-0.2967282235622406,
0.219627246260643,
-0.24914436042308807,
-0.6609635949134827,
0.20018677413463593,
-0.09355585277080536,
-0.4777872562408447,
-0.2151460200548172,
0.6169163584709167,
-0.31045904755592346,
-0.21547475457191467,
0.2825840711593628,
0.21405327320098877,
-0.27785131335258484,
-0.08211443573236465,
-0.7707765698432922,
0.03478237986564636,
-0.011449778452515602,
-0.05673668533563614,
0.577168881893158,
0.4305616319179535,
-0.3677581250667572,
0.7838215231895447,
0.56767338514328,
-0.08724465221166611,
-0.0870237648487091,
-0.266887366771698,
1.0199589729309082,
-0.41206395626068115,
-0.6304885149002075,
-0.5587046146392822,
0.5937675833702087,
-0.010573425330221653,
-0.5675405263900757,
0.47379985451698303,
0.40002989768981934,
1.2274795770645142,
-0.1464514583349228,
0.758192777633667,
-0.29543402791023254,
0.41949912905693054,
-0.6599789261817932,
0.5370232462882996,
-0.5848483443260193,
0.2694198787212372,
-0.042766023427248,
-0.5258966088294983,
-0.2169366180896759,
0.23012125492095947,
-0.2814602553844452,
0.2087288796901703,
0.39568957686424255,
0.7750484347343445,
-0.3849891424179077,
0.012987042777240276,
0.4525893032550812,
0.217392697930336,
0.212871715426445,
0.5034234523773193,
0.4218235909938812,
-0.21237273514270782,
0.11492066085338593,
-0.41770151257514954,
-0.32781457901000977,
-0.3211662769317627,
-0.8578670024871826,
-0.7391440868377686,
-0.8499488234519958,
-0.3788747191429138,
-0.044401608407497406,
0.017285345122218132,
1.0109885931015015,
1.1510382890701294,
-0.979048490524292,
-0.20007629692554474,
-0.08481769263744354,
-0.055204059928655624,
-0.6026113033294678,
-0.2641121745109558,
0.5489163398742676,
-0.6124194264411926,
-0.7357675433158875,
0.5810891389846802,
0.5204192996025085,
-0.22461523115634918,
-0.12635600566864014,
-0.20358553528785706,
-0.15540046989917755,
-0.2646946310997009,
0.7801907658576965,
0.11716601997613907,
-0.9269746541976929,
-0.5782988667488098,
-0.33444151282310486,
0.15137994289398193,
0.09606178849935532,
0.9270933270454407,
-0.9553465247154236,
0.42711544036865234,
0.2342945635318756,
1.026465654373169,
0.37229123711586,
0.11330180615186691,
0.3206873834133148,
-0.8751099109649658,
0.17098085582256317,
0.09244666248559952,
0.3046559989452362,
0.1511925458908081,
-0.6468634605407715,
0.3895256817340851,
0.311740517616272,
-0.47629514336586,
-0.4527217447757721,
0.003242658684030175,
-0.8509553074836731,
-0.43876075744628906,
0.890473484992981,
-0.4913650155067444,
0.024456540122628212,
-0.4318098723888397,
0.020048225298523903,
-0.04209766909480095,
-0.47449761629104614,
0.7868559956550598,
0.2816396951675415,
-0.5461016893386841,
-0.21369096636772156,
-0.4834636151790619,
0.8307133316993713,
0.09573109447956085,
-0.8157265782356262,
0.16865013539791107,
0.5280176997184753,
0.5906643271446228,
-0.20788194239139557,
0.2693370282649994,
0.10101976990699768,
0.47877079248428345,
-0.3751411437988281,
-0.2782337963581085,
-0.19440725445747375,
-0.40899041295051575,
-0.46654364466667175,
0.2549458146095276,
-0.029985828325152397,
-0.17643983662128448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10725v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10725v2
|
INDUS: Effective and Efficient Language Models for Scientific Applications
| 2024-05-17T12:15:07 | 2024-05-20T23:49:12 |
Bishwaranjan Bhattacharjee, Aashka Trivedi, Masayasu Muraoka, Muthukumaran Ramasubramanian, Takuma Udagawa, Iksha Gurung, Rong Zhang, Bharath Dandala, Rahul Ramachandran, Manil Maskey, Kaylin Bugbee, Mike Little, Elizabeth Fancher, Lauren Sanders, Sylvain Costes, Sergi Blanco-Cuaresma, Kelly Lockhart, Thomas Allen, Felix Grezes, Megan Ansdell, Alberto Accomazzi, Yousef El-Kurdi, Davis Wertheimer, Birgit Pfitzmann, Cesar Berrospi Ramis, Michele Dolfi, Rafael Teixeira de Lima, Panagiotis Vagenas, S. Karthik Mukkavilli, Peter Staar, Sanaz Vahidinia, Ryan McGranaghan, Armin Mehrabian, Tsendgar Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Large language models (LLMs) trained on general domain corpora showed
remarkable results on natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However,
previous research demonstrated LLMs trained using domain-focused corpora
perform better on specialized tasks. Inspired by this pivotal insight, we
developed INDUS, a comprehensive suite of LLMs tailored for the Earth science,
biology, physics, heliophysics, planetary sciences and astrophysics domains and
trained using curated scientific corpora drawn from diverse data sources. The
suite of models include: (1) an encoder model trained using domain-specific
vocabulary and corpora to address natural language understanding tasks, (2) a
contrastive-learning-based general text embedding model trained using a diverse
set of datasets drawn from multiple sources to address information retrieval
tasks and (3) smaller versions of these models created using knowledge
distillation techniques to address applications which have latency or resource
constraints. We also created three new scientific benchmark datasets namely,
CLIMATE-CHANGE-NER (entity-recognition), NASA-QA (extractive QA) and NASA-IR
(IR) to accelerate research in these multi-disciplinary fields. Finally, we
show that our models outperform both general-purpose encoders (RoBERTa) and
existing domain-specific encoders (SciBERT) on these new tasks as well as
existing benchmark tasks in the domains of interest.
|
[
-0.06116170063614845,
-0.40455660223960876,
0.6356874704360962,
0.31141287088394165,
-0.07661013305187225,
0.4100518524646759,
-0.41444164514541626,
-0.609960675239563,
-0.16154152154922485,
0.2994508743286133,
-0.1391334980726242,
-0.7361024022102356,
-0.7528700232505798,
0.4236275255680084,
-0.5757150053977966,
0.6133354902267456,
-0.02123030088841915,
0.1786797046661377,
-0.45858311653137207,
-0.049173273146152496,
0.1496681272983551,
-0.449553519487381,
-0.33061227202415466,
-0.3827746510505676,
0.46453502774238586,
0.22826389968395233,
0.3757025897502899,
0.7985659241676331,
0.9928375482559204,
0.24218623340129852,
-0.21494297683238983,
0.49631449580192566,
-0.302255243062973,
0.063382089138031,
-0.37908288836479187,
-0.3916006088256836,
-0.17784665524959564,
0.1185116097331047,
0.5973533391952515,
1.007243037223816,
-0.13447441160678864,
0.29879069328308105,
0.004931161645799875,
0.4555342495441437,
-0.6080839037895203,
0.280683696269989,
-0.6879392862319946,
-0.10104906558990479,
-0.22819280624389648,
-0.2891577184200287,
-0.40579721331596375,
-0.1636250913143158,
0.10475794225931168,
-0.7686744332313538,
0.19005078077316284,
0.43509405851364136,
0.6123331785202026,
0.6013126373291016,
-0.27682510018348694,
-0.4465019702911377,
-0.864696741104126,
1.0220909118652344,
-0.757880449295044,
0.7299532294273376,
0.2570909559726715,
0.17179670929908752,
-0.13264630734920502,
-0.8175209760665894,
-0.5485296249389648,
-0.15726925432682037,
0.1170632541179657,
0.12963281571865082,
-0.15169763565063477,
-0.0100748585537076,
-0.05900643765926361,
0.4668527841567993,
-0.7391262054443359,
0.3069041669368744,
-0.6631131172180176,
0.072066530585289,
0.3531394600868225,
0.18753889203071594,
0.040536150336265564,
-0.0828159973025322,
-0.3076930344104767,
-0.11795163154602051,
-0.8425914645195007,
-0.012800761498510838,
0.04512600228190422,
0.38225358724594116,
-0.04034765809774399,
0.6983703374862671,
-0.24970825016498566,
0.7839754223823547,
-0.1975320726633072,
-0.12367613613605499,
0.045264776796102524,
-0.33950015902519226,
-0.3625841736793518,
-0.2646320164203644,
0.6273286938667297,
0.06324943155050278,
-0.15997128188610077,
-0.5191836357116699,
0.012725728563964367,
0.3874961733818054,
-0.015320380218327045,
-0.7163434028625488,
-0.1925729364156723,
0.3517143130302429,
-0.2688356041908264,
-0.06125066056847572,
-0.2040143609046936,
-0.6454892158508301,
-0.47062474489212036,
-0.5667111277580261,
-0.09072566032409668,
-0.4433903396129608,
-0.1591852754354477,
0.37866082787513733,
-0.06455680727958679,
0.0744854211807251,
0.18010208010673523,
-0.8867886066436768,
0.47374266386032104,
0.8462578058242798,
0.9010929465293884,
-0.30319133400917053,
-0.24952392280101776,
-0.4485875368118286,
0.2195936143398285,
-0.1480417400598526,
0.8680468797683716,
-0.9413877129554749,
-0.25628772377967834,
-0.12197228521108627,
-0.20297729969024658,
-0.10984517633914948,
-0.7497040033340454,
0.6689296364784241,
-0.6947154998779297,
0.011125970631837845,
-0.07497736066579819,
-0.604352593421936,
-0.44438186287879944,
0.12212862819433212,
-0.5771450996398926,
1.084797739982605,
0.04080621898174286,
-0.636939525604248,
0.24302850663661957,
-0.8490409255027771,
-0.08175335079431534,
0.187296062707901,
-0.07769647240638733,
-0.07414647191762924,
-0.014567166566848755,
0.037116169929504395,
0.5731397271156311,
-0.8568113446235657,
0.2968244254589081,
-0.2085685431957245,
-0.13861611485481262,
0.03776533156633377,
-0.06039388105273247,
0.46634069085121155,
0.4186612069606781,
-0.06926562637090683,
0.2252437323331833,
-0.9118207693099976,
-0.14898435771465302,
-0.18123812973499298,
-0.30531713366508484,
-0.7319514751434326,
0.17315925657749176,
0.130934476852417,
0.161056250333786,
0.30063313245773315,
-0.7376773357391357,
0.12303409725427628,
-0.3230779767036438,
0.7044937014579773,
0.40902164578437805,
-0.36514100432395935,
0.5184997916221619,
0.004008253570646048,
0.22112838923931122,
-0.10502307116985321,
-0.005983176175504923,
0.0859999731183052,
-0.34282174706459045,
-0.5463692545890808,
-0.5063754320144653,
0.15687458217144012,
0.6107748746871948,
-0.6283721327781677,
0.2308238446712494,
-0.3514803647994995,
-0.8619190454483032,
-0.7465569376945496,
0.29235023260116577,
0.27832576632499695,
0.5551939010620117,
0.5031090974807739,
0.009855101816356182,
-0.637137234210968,
-0.7938122153282166,
-0.26793816685676575,
-0.1467583030462265,
-0.22813375294208527,
0.22701403498649597,
0.6264074444770813,
-0.5233001112937927,
1.0224008560180664,
-0.5168492197990417,
0.1557566225528717,
0.03293175995349884,
0.13275550305843353,
0.2150564044713974,
0.20660924911499023,
0.25998830795288086,
-1.233041763305664,
-0.4034150540828705,
0.22209589183330536,
-1.049575924873352,
-0.17633946239948273,
0.3694322407245636,
-0.08701808005571365,
0.05234277620911598,
0.4595392942428589,
-0.504612922668457,
0.046362318098545074,
0.7901578545570374,
-0.2693662643432617,
0.4985191226005554,
-0.02532656118273735,
0.286022424697876,
-0.9702646136283875,
0.3585132956504822,
0.196000337600708,
-0.22363799810409546,
-0.662606954574585,
0.14965298771858215,
0.06288762390613556,
-0.035340894013643265,
-0.6655732989311218,
0.6292711496353149,
-0.45236948132514954,
-0.025456082075834274,
-0.4163670539855957,
0.15012839436531067,
0.08213075250387192,
0.2558272182941437,
0.28868797421455383,
0.9048300981521606,
0.6345099806785583,
-0.9524343013763428,
0.4351716637611389,
0.3879753053188324,
-0.3959697186946869,
0.1543913334608078,
-0.7729329466819763,
0.12691792845726013,
-0.09669976681470871,
-0.10333690792322159,
-0.44911208748817444,
-0.0980556458234787,
0.0732981488108635,
-0.1538163125514984,
0.03873741626739502,
0.18500131368637085,
-0.5353095531463623,
-0.3817957937717438,
-0.13876217603683472,
0.3677537441253662,
0.5024111270904541,
-0.7112903594970703,
0.6358997821807861,
0.38299426436424255,
-0.3725067675113678,
-0.43072429299354553,
-0.5496718287467957,
-0.0018255519680678844,
-0.42034149169921875,
-0.5565743446350098,
0.5708866119384766,
-0.22844350337982178,
-0.5660627484321594,
0.316053569316864,
-0.06263023614883423,
-0.10722264647483826,
0.0918518453836441,
0.283342570066452,
0.3931177258491516,
-0.22938768565654755,
0.05851390212774277,
-0.17785558104515076,
-0.02413921244442463,
-0.0007342561148107052,
-0.40901076793670654,
0.5586016774177551,
-0.24319253861904144,
-0.2653788924217224,
-0.20071449875831604,
0.40854552388191223,
0.6084417700767517,
-0.24186472594738007,
0.9561214447021484,
0.4001753330230713,
-0.46844446659088135,
-0.08108697831630707,
-0.4604441225528717,
-0.10498508810997009,
-0.4642525613307953,
0.462037056684494,
-0.09278396517038345,
-1.148929238319397,
0.5209903717041016,
-0.5773570537567139,
0.1636822521686554,
0.4648468494415283,
0.49782994389533997,
0.18508300185203552,
0.6584513187408447,
1.0627520084381104,
-0.27949652075767517,
0.17132145166397095,
-0.1635872721672058,
0.3152814507484436,
-1.1455979347229004,
-0.34846872091293335,
-0.6709944605827332,
0.2432558238506317,
-0.4224490523338318,
-0.6965343952178955,
0.2976224720478058,
0.03926725685596466,
-0.37083590030670166,
0.25797849893569946,
-0.746045708656311,
0.3231675624847412,
0.5873399376869202,
-0.29284733533859253,
0.4263603389263153,
0.13906311988830566,
0.15709689259529114,
0.01540732104331255,
-0.787155270576477,
-0.9586194753646851,
1.089124321937561,
0.22081483900547028,
0.8459231853485107,
-0.06754881888628006,
0.3355298340320587,
0.22705978155136108,
0.42120811343193054,
-0.38852837681770325,
0.3735434412956238,
-0.4691981077194214,
-0.41121214628219604,
-0.13021360337734222,
-0.5082427859306335,
-0.6821021437644958,
0.1784670054912567,
-0.11996191740036011,
-0.4769040048122406,
0.21042513847351074,
-0.15470033884048462,
-0.4019257128238678,
0.4194936156272888,
-0.4763452708721161,
0.45436298847198486,
-0.24773213267326355,
-0.37840506434440613,
-0.2470863312482834,
-0.45299285650253296,
0.3422183394432068,
-0.2464774250984192,
0.45289748907089233,
-0.21252447366714478,
-0.0783529058098793,
0.7545667290687561,
0.050107382237911224,
0.7380615472793579,
0.03944821655750275,
0.00258521712385118,
0.2530125379562378,
-0.25540891289711,
0.151706263422966,
0.07414009422063828,
-0.489472359418869,
0.37135690450668335,
-0.1835532784461975,
-0.27376532554626465,
-0.369262158870697,
0.7107150554656982,
-0.8317427635192871,
-0.5211396217346191,
-0.5417490601539612,
-0.6106321215629578,
-0.0490708164870739,
0.010240699164569378,
0.13962623476982117,
0.24673797190189362,
-0.1760507971048355,
0.2499212622642517,
0.6037511229515076,
-0.41801217198371887,
0.15768472850322723,
0.7184996008872986,
-0.0764123797416687,
-0.23333880305290222,
0.8483170866966248,
-0.2902454137802124,
0.32256627082824707,
0.47015437483787537,
-0.15432731807231903,
-0.21138782799243927,
-0.6726586222648621,
-0.20811650156974792,
0.2699803113937378,
-0.559494137763977,
-0.44548940658569336,
-0.8465973138809204,
-0.31949079036712646,
-0.39714741706848145,
-0.13963645696640015,
-0.4362776279449463,
-0.32681435346603394,
-0.29859408736228943,
0.07215078175067902,
0.5418038368225098,
0.9979678392410278,
-0.19085030257701874,
0.16755245625972748,
-0.8970961570739746,
0.38058629631996155,
-0.15162402391433716,
0.3040442168712616,
-0.24589577317237854,
-0.4083733558654785,
-0.5210952162742615,
0.12706489861011505,
-0.08211559057235718,
-0.3638215661048889,
0.7440445423126221,
0.4753687083721161,
0.49495071172714233,
0.0830029621720314,
-0.12036019563674927,
0.45491424202919006,
-0.7408320903778076,
0.8738964796066284,
-0.03417757526040077,
-0.7761446237564087,
0.4418996572494507,
-0.17803050577640533,
0.061361223459243774,
0.4276833236217499,
0.6573886871337891,
-0.5516886115074158,
-0.3450785279273987,
-0.2142031043767929,
-1.086896300315857,
0.34546929597854614,
0.043918121606111526,
-0.2613671123981476,
0.09568165987730026,
0.5109197497367859,
0.4894532859325409,
0.3893350064754486,
-0.4043007791042328,
-0.23774220049381256,
-0.04597693309187889,
-0.30863144993782043,
-0.13150329887866974,
-0.0319942869246006,
-0.20351135730743408,
-0.09613732993602753,
0.8152151703834534,
-0.07973837852478027,
0.17190635204315186,
0.28274327516555786,
-0.06056666001677513,
0.13565586507320404,
0.35825976729393005,
0.4630216062068939,
0.4442700147628784,
-0.25549834966659546,
0.22026023268699646,
-0.054082565009593964,
-0.6391724944114685,
-0.004176188725978136,
0.4169965982437134,
-0.0654631108045578,
-0.10508668422698975,
0.22057335078716278,
0.5990567803382874,
0.16246703267097473,
-0.8585487008094788,
-0.2168186753988266,
-0.062147993594408035,
0.0876409262418747,
-0.231609046459198,
-0.01656379923224449,
0.20314987003803253,
0.41525015234947205,
0.626092791557312,
0.18730634450912476,
0.47015711665153503,
-0.3721403479576111,
-0.06188909709453583,
0.1742548942565918,
0.06934142112731934,
-0.45586735010147095,
0.8935173749923706,
0.1674138456583023,
0.0030137524008750916,
0.6323338150978088,
-0.3024405241012573,
-0.6168540716171265,
0.5148271918296814,
0.5287248492240906,
0.5467233061790466,
-0.08974684029817581,
0.09615527838468552,
0.2784281373023987,
0.23739810287952423,
-0.2715953588485718,
0.19680063426494598,
0.19292289018630981,
-0.6297857761383057,
-0.5228959918022156,
-0.928675651550293,
-0.865007221698761,
0.036227136850357056,
-0.5101098418235779,
0.10258258134126663,
-0.25608953833580017,
0.008165433071553707,
0.07052357494831085,
0.11004913598299026,
-0.8309277296066284,
0.14269012212753296,
0.17735478281974792,
1.0646584033966064,
-0.7762311697006226,
0.6033889055252075,
0.7668233513832092,
-0.20319785177707672,
-0.6603166460990906,
-0.5523810386657715,
-0.05584337189793587,
-0.4466969668865204,
1.1201972961425781,
-0.008586534298956394,
-0.34139955043792725,
-0.03189576417207718,
-0.8248041868209839,
-1.1993941068649292,
1.1390193700790405,
0.43515074253082275,
-0.7066802978515625,
0.17762218415737152,
0.33459967374801636,
0.6962223649024963,
-0.5440225005149841,
0.06525631994009018,
0.47219112515449524,
0.3936736583709717,
-0.02228970266878605,
-0.8903330564498901,
-0.14920443296432495,
-0.6114876866340637,
-0.25290292501449585,
-0.10406491905450821,
-0.6625645756721497,
1.0004569292068481,
0.1300498992204666,
-0.19032888114452362,
0.13617795705795288,
0.9292664527893066,
0.5995395183563232,
0.5251337885856628,
0.1594548523426056,
0.3648782968521118,
1.1327543258666992,
-0.11946231871843338,
1.2078487873077393,
-0.6875349879264832,
0.07140769064426422,
0.7516650557518005,
-0.7305126190185547,
0.9165485501289368,
0.5000432729721069,
-0.044339414685964584,
0.5590345859527588,
0.7788947820663452,
-0.027576077729463577,
0.6808527708053589,
0.1592869758605957,
-0.40423840284347534,
-0.12673529982566833,
-0.5417929887771606,
-0.36198052763938904,
0.4021364748477936,
0.6715492010116577,
-0.01274901069700718,
0.031144017353653908,
0.16779808700084686,
-0.22155167162418365,
0.34169700741767883,
-0.3203265368938446,
0.35209664702415466,
0.3144339919090271,
-0.3752296566963196,
0.4124794602394104,
0.16627229750156403,
1.1033800840377808,
-0.6609094738960266,
-0.060770437121391296,
0.05019518733024597,
0.17679421603679657,
-0.29504573345184326,
-0.5137555599212646,
0.41260793805122375,
0.27319589257240295,
-0.3355836868286133,
-0.1536700278520584,
0.6143019199371338,
-0.5717288851737976,
-0.5173637866973877,
0.4487411081790924,
0.38592517375946045,
0.24802309274673462,
0.07025590538978577,
-0.2461763471364975,
0.19318699836730957,
-0.24412281811237335,
-0.23919764161109924,
0.0851062685251236,
0.34510543942451477,
0.01907208189368248,
0.9202043414115906,
0.757035493850708,
0.30799031257629395,
0.21297606825828552,
0.0451212003827095,
1.0511982440948486,
-0.7738634347915649,
-0.13354243338108063,
-0.6338328719139099,
0.23509038984775543,
-0.1640220731496811,
-0.16573883593082428,
0.7151250243186951,
0.8156769871711731,
0.5806448459625244,
-0.10817927122116089,
1.0215873718261719,
0.054995402693748474,
0.6992095708847046,
-0.5187896490097046,
0.5207003355026245,
-0.46542662382125854,
0.3882417380809784,
0.10035011917352676,
-0.8990893363952637,
-0.515971839427948,
0.4699016213417053,
-0.3312660753726959,
-0.1239076629281044,
0.6506429314613342,
0.5593565106391907,
-0.07263961434364319,
0.17087231576442719,
0.0057770926505327225,
0.15962348878383636,
0.47562265396118164,
0.5350443720817566,
0.7842956781387329,
-0.2488388568162918,
0.1364259421825409,
-0.05567671358585358,
-0.22347645461559296,
0.028060561046004295,
-0.8682821393013,
-0.7314158082008362,
-0.6862761974334717,
-0.29122239351272583,
0.17159205675125122,
0.21605157852172852,
1.0254541635513306,
0.6982179284095764,
-0.7249498963356018,
-0.18761500716209412,
-0.04895367473363876,
-0.23519594967365265,
0.009846028871834278,
-0.16722062230110168,
0.5173760056495667,
-0.21868623793125153,
-0.916077196598053,
0.8568015694618225,
0.4713044762611389,
-0.25113382935523987,
-0.2730834484100342,
-0.09733928740024567,
-0.2784227132797241,
0.11103329807519913,
0.6397449970245361,
0.41330820322036743,
-0.5542765855789185,
-0.24143992364406586,
0.5403066277503967,
-0.24787971377372742,
-0.16171884536743164,
0.6193661689758301,
-0.8329096436500549,
-0.02765757218003273,
0.2917475402355194,
0.8762109279632568,
0.2246297150850296,
-0.14357663691043854,
0.6094970107078552,
-0.47853362560272217,
0.2504573166370392,
0.4125557243824005,
0.2943979799747467,
0.9109644293785095,
-0.3336958587169647,
0.9390352368354797,
0.0455067902803421,
-0.7827799320220947,
-0.9111019968986511,
-0.04158502072095871,
-0.9143984913825989,
-0.27375057339668274,
1.2707751989364624,
-0.018000606447458267,
-0.448935329914093,
-0.16717778146266937,
0.12686151266098022,
0.30122944712638855,
-0.22739680111408234,
0.8961682915687561,
0.651888370513916,
-0.24388176202774048,
0.19991183280944824,
-0.6145382523536682,
0.4731602966785431,
0.420645147562027,
-0.8743672966957092,
0.1359301507472992,
0.22453157603740692,
0.1837417334318161,
0.48335036635398865,
0.2363310307264328,
-0.10038357973098755,
0.012461954727768898,
-0.07070400565862656,
0.35296866297721863,
-0.2723710238933563,
-0.38644126057624817,
-0.22158114612102509,
0.10391926765441895,
0.05860783904790878,
0.08563718944787979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10718v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10718v1
|
SignLLM: Sign Languages Production Large Language Models
| 2024-05-17T12:01:43 | 2024-05-17T12:01:43 |
Sen Fang, Lei Wang, Ce Zheng, Yapeng Tian, Chen Chen
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce the first comprehensive multilingual sign
language dataset named Prompt2Sign, which builds from public data including
American Sign Language (ASL) and seven others. Our dataset transforms a vast
array of videos into a streamlined, model-friendly format, optimized for
training with translation models like seq2seq and text2text. Building on this
new dataset, we propose SignLLM, the first multilingual Sign Language
Production (SLP) model, which includes two novel multilingual SLP modes that
allow for the generation of sign language gestures from input text or prompt.
Both of the modes can use a new loss and a module based on reinforcement
learning, which accelerates the training by enhancing the model's capability to
autonomously sample high-quality data. We present benchmark results of SignLLM,
which demonstrate that our model achieves state-of-the-art performance on SLP
tasks across eight sign languages.
|
[
0.024618227034807205,
-0.2306128740310669,
0.27725014090538025,
0.31726551055908203,
-0.10730335861444473,
0.031389541923999786,
-0.12147597968578339,
-0.44859644770622253,
-0.03855622559785843,
0.5578565001487732,
-0.741382896900177,
-0.7098325490951538,
-0.8873591423034668,
0.043430864810943604,
-0.3082495927810669,
0.8701996207237244,
-0.1972823292016983,
0.47451141476631165,
0.22260649502277374,
-0.3030965030193329,
-0.30050572752952576,
-0.3590835928916931,
-1.039496898651123,
-0.19636578857898712,
0.13045711815357208,
0.3303375244140625,
0.724918782711029,
0.354726105928421,
0.21048571169376373,
0.17613527178764343,
0.08097565174102783,
0.2689104676246643,
-0.23743189871311188,
0.12006875872612,
0.18587814271450043,
-0.04011424630880356,
-0.3511609733104706,
0.13729098439216614,
0.9577623009681702,
0.7349759936332703,
0.18594375252723694,
0.28556326031684875,
-0.22556713223457336,
0.38221868872642517,
-0.2725791335105896,
0.26781749725341797,
-0.37156736850738525,
0.19800299406051636,
-0.02450857311487198,
0.20518776774406433,
-0.7531911134719849,
-0.40616559982299805,
-0.37528401613235474,
-0.4878079295158386,
-0.05896736681461334,
0.13789929449558258,
0.4570462107658386,
0.27459853887557983,
-0.7327331900596619,
-0.36272746324539185,
-0.6749203205108643,
0.706817626953125,
-0.9113289713859558,
0.8121625185012817,
0.24491609632968903,
0.2562032639980316,
-0.03965479135513306,
-0.5253899097442627,
-0.2776009440422058,
-0.34228214621543884,
0.06929001957178116,
-0.10831150412559509,
0.1870129257440567,
0.07794906944036484,
0.44130533933639526,
-0.0024260017089545727,
-1.0146088600158691,
0.37342414259910583,
-0.4520402252674103,
-0.3577047288417816,
0.8548077940940857,
0.2155127227306366,
0.4716675579547882,
0.07758113741874695,
-0.7147480845451355,
-0.2261878401041031,
-0.8516073226928711,
0.09494722634553909,
0.23844918608665466,
0.6315175294876099,
-0.15983010828495026,
0.528153121471405,
0.06181459501385689,
0.8199434280395508,
-0.42693573236465454,
-0.24129076302051544,
-0.1038069948554039,
-0.3513999283313751,
-0.05509839579463005,
0.09050017595291138,
0.8177569508552551,
0.2235475480556488,
0.01570441946387291,
0.211620032787323,
-0.42380914092063904,
0.01959705352783203,
-0.5626348853111267,
-0.8100758790969849,
-0.1635582596063614,
0.13699820637702942,
-0.23697823286056519,
0.24131955206394196,
-0.01564694568514824,
-0.13534827530384064,
-0.7112994194030762,
-0.48458775877952576,
0.28816336393356323,
-0.4026166498661041,
-0.5227086544036865,
0.36246687173843384,
0.1253916174173355,
0.4276043474674225,
0.48369088768959045,
-0.6487290859222412,
0.3694043457508087,
0.7050281167030334,
0.8804957270622253,
-0.5509595274925232,
-0.4167526066303253,
-0.9234724640846252,
-0.04313790053129196,
-0.39696383476257324,
0.22035029530525208,
-0.2012922614812851,
-0.251798152923584,
0.23382611572742462,
-0.009317264892160892,
-0.21427057683467865,
-0.452918142080307,
0.26546359062194824,
-0.5049080848693848,
0.2699780762195587,
0.11523260176181793,
-0.5945129990577698,
-0.20551607012748718,
0.16871361434459686,
-0.7734881043434143,
0.9575073719024658,
-0.06163078546524048,
-0.03299819305539131,
0.5677170157432556,
-0.5468277931213379,
-0.7918767929077148,
0.09432516247034073,
-0.13156402111053467,
-0.3575460612773895,
-0.08526130765676498,
-0.1866624504327774,
0.5823273658752441,
-0.23773421347141266,
0.3070000410079956,
0.00846739299595356,
0.1385534554719925,
0.2674412131309509,
-0.13382087647914886,
0.8641260862350464,
0.3802662193775177,
-0.2157992571592331,
0.22186267375946045,
-0.6883427500724792,
0.025978343561291695,
-0.03148477524518967,
-0.4347164034843445,
-0.04214191436767578,
-0.23028388619422913,
0.4332740902900696,
0.8375954627990723,
0.25920817255973816,
-0.4252917766571045,
-0.005002185236662626,
-0.21477080881595612,
0.2426280528306961,
0.4386468827724457,
-0.2118198424577713,
0.2956848740577698,
0.09266234934329987,
0.7968193888664246,
0.12111177295446396,
0.2115437388420105,
-0.6008967161178589,
-0.6933093667030334,
-0.6453686952590942,
-0.025139901787042618,
-0.19788514077663422,
0.35954317450523376,
-0.4907122254371643,
0.06441955268383026,
0.18016904592514038,
-0.16731245815753937,
-0.4165983498096466,
0.268942266702652,
0.7631373405456543,
0.20710813999176025,
0.2386636883020401,
-0.2517855763435364,
-0.45523056387901306,
-0.6844916343688965,
-0.19157886505126953,
-0.18028907477855682,
0.22195951640605927,
-0.2008042335510254,
0.2231249362230301,
0.26795467734336853,
0.4211629331111908,
-0.4700165390968323,
-0.3723403215408325,
-0.4099286198616028,
0.1769150197505951,
0.44974765181541443,
0.5233427286148071,
0.24460409581661224,
-0.7588076591491699,
-0.6129571795463562,
-0.09352441132068634,
-0.5727517008781433,
0.04094590246677399,
-0.3500730097293854,
0.12054412066936493,
0.32878178358078003,
0.7680160999298096,
-0.6511066555976868,
-0.1647641509771347,
0.9062541127204895,
-0.9525337219238281,
0.7812916040420532,
-0.10658822953701019,
0.17249484360218048,
-1.2338640689849854,
0.012780515477061272,
0.1775059700012207,
-0.48936232924461365,
-0.9382960796356201,
0.1370498389005661,
0.11074987798929214,
-0.7846503257751465,
-0.8628221154212952,
0.8822659850120544,
-0.9320504665374756,
-0.556837797164917,
-0.16160018742084503,
0.12437509745359421,
0.011783357709646225,
0.3674635589122772,
0.40099993348121643,
0.5877647399902344,
0.5991135239601135,
-0.6290929913520813,
0.2908841669559479,
0.3674250543117523,
-0.34636548161506653,
0.47299546003341675,
-0.5174693465232849,
0.04205833747982979,
-0.14405034482479095,
-0.0699080228805542,
-1.2153329849243164,
-0.2603793740272522,
0.12748029828071594,
-0.44500428438186646,
0.6160897016525269,
-0.09367244690656662,
-0.3662698268890381,
-0.39812782406806946,
-0.02768522873520851,
0.15810006856918335,
0.647098183631897,
-0.5208637714385986,
0.32306548953056335,
0.352010577917099,
-0.12876808643341064,
-0.2663816213607788,
-0.4609021842479706,
0.15600340068340302,
-0.19321905076503754,
-0.6870706081390381,
-0.2042807936668396,
-0.182062566280365,
-0.12907347083091736,
-0.65769362449646,
0.09332364797592163,
-0.03346017748117447,
0.08950480073690414,
0.24753473699092865,
0.10537060350179672,
-0.26313644647598267,
0.11186607927083969,
-0.1583646684885025,
-0.27449843287467957,
0.09278841316699982,
-0.236970916390419,
0.5436024069786072,
0.09791881591081619,
-0.6741940379142761,
-0.5936654210090637,
0.21800552308559418,
0.46360883116722107,
-0.2958313822746277,
0.40407028794288635,
0.6318256855010986,
-0.4689825773239136,
-0.32919538021087646,
-0.1482354998588562,
-0.2828124463558197,
-0.4124778211116791,
0.5633206367492676,
-0.33336272835731506,
-0.8195503950119019,
0.24065543711185455,
-0.23574136197566986,
0.539219081401825,
0.12288576364517212,
0.5012686848640442,
0.2940639853477478,
1.3980131149291992,
0.26999449729919434,
0.1421077996492386,
0.4357571303844452,
-0.09372931718826294,
-0.0851769894361496,
-0.3714748024940491,
-0.3713327646255493,
-0.48311468958854675,
-0.22457948327064514,
0.09173616021871567,
-0.8780232667922974,
0.24906738102436066,
0.1527993083000183,
-0.3644861578941345,
0.6532542109489441,
-0.3082631826400757,
0.1928541213274002,
0.3748030364513397,
-0.19122713804244995,
0.5565121173858643,
-0.15006618201732635,
0.1784350574016571,
-0.187830850481987,
-0.5659980177879333,
-0.6436436772346497,
0.8385270237922668,
0.4607332944869995,
0.7533699870109558,
0.263266921043396,
0.44691765308380127,
0.2930721640586853,
0.13912399113178253,
-0.662178635597229,
0.7736263275146484,
-0.29046669602394104,
-0.5080922842025757,
-0.39842554926872253,
-0.2079412192106247,
-0.8032450675964355,
0.08811508864164352,
-0.2481490969657898,
-0.3165651559829712,
-0.4024336636066437,
0.38778939843177795,
0.024979092180728912,
0.12243038415908813,
-0.7931180000305176,
1.0157513618469238,
-0.5877600908279419,
-0.14099429547786713,
-0.021541548892855644,
-0.7276322841644287,
0.7328945994377136,
0.021781276911497116,
0.25509336590766907,
-0.4881228506565094,
-0.033411189913749695,
0.7600924968719482,
-0.2502621114253998,
0.8948392868041992,
-0.4837641417980194,
-0.3794304132461548,
0.12455306202173233,
0.3421798348426819,
0.6965732574462891,
0.06563223153352737,
-0.10684185475111008,
-0.0785532146692276,
-0.24070757627487183,
-0.16685569286346436,
-0.24329045414924622,
0.6047360897064209,
-0.7618858218193054,
-0.21472465991973877,
-0.30758944153785706,
-0.4596497714519501,
-0.1889980137348175,
0.22313663363456726,
0.04615665599703789,
0.5668078064918518,
-0.4398542642593384,
-0.28958290815353394,
0.7655125260353088,
-0.24566084146499634,
0.5063048601150513,
0.759524941444397,
-0.516707718372345,
-0.33476686477661133,
0.6600066423416138,
-0.20121340453624725,
0.529769241809845,
0.3450104594230652,
-0.04048272967338562,
-0.7969474792480469,
-0.5907690525054932,
-0.7927685976028442,
0.36342835426330566,
-0.6996687054634094,
-0.152184396982193,
-0.3705296516418457,
0.0005220150924287736,
-0.6666398644447327,
0.028144067153334618,
-0.3910955488681793,
-0.5447179675102234,
-0.19858390092849731,
-0.1485333889722824,
0.26164793968200684,
0.853992760181427,
-0.02235482446849346,
0.264112651348114,
-0.6169154047966003,
0.34719330072402954,
0.2910524606704712,
0.1744641810655594,
-0.3823205232620239,
-0.5005828142166138,
-0.23646438121795654,
-0.07440486550331116,
-0.11882112175226212,
-0.8804440498352051,
0.3271279036998749,
0.6750913858413696,
0.48301491141319275,
0.5805566906929016,
-0.019528931006789207,
0.15968072414398193,
-0.42086878418922424,
0.9977517127990723,
0.941676676273346,
-0.7335124015808105,
0.5008331537246704,
-0.36517709493637085,
0.6086007952690125,
0.1700664609670639,
0.5855781435966492,
-1.065487265586853,
-0.335613489151001,
-0.36320677399635315,
-0.7031831741333008,
0.9644705057144165,
-0.08958152681589127,
-0.036375027149915695,
0.039641354233026505,
0.00277412380091846,
0.4125773012638092,
0.17249545454978943,
-0.7725954651832581,
-0.18049685657024384,
-0.07137104868888855,
-0.34017214179039,
-0.41474220156669617,
-0.022595928981900215,
-0.07814840227365494,
0.09532292932271957,
0.865730345249176,
-0.3494497537612915,
-0.11430469155311584,
-0.29013508558273315,
-0.5686577558517456,
0.021964792162179947,
0.022823158651590347,
0.826454222202301,
0.5829944610595703,
0.34282469749450684,
0.3456372320652008,
0.03597259148955345,
-0.39108091592788696,
0.47048673033714294,
0.03197199106216431,
-0.40030139684677124,
0.24300427734851837,
0.34493646025657654,
1.3038647174835205,
0.3417605459690094,
-0.8629716038703918,
0.529339075088501,
0.3005622625350952,
-0.18982839584350586,
-0.452360063791275,
0.059907861053943634,
0.1520690619945526,
0.29318156838417053,
0.29447585344314575,
-0.24288436770439148,
0.10289320349693298,
-0.2796914279460907,
0.34610143303871155,
0.4465673863887787,
-0.5886797904968262,
-0.59809410572052,
1.1672635078430176,
0.10675886273384094,
-0.3983471393585205,
0.46184980869293213,
-0.20644335448741913,
-0.28492307662963867,
0.6349825859069824,
0.7494942545890808,
0.7608278393745422,
-0.45687705278396606,
0.6629977226257324,
0.7849376797676086,
0.278537780046463,
-0.2886626422405243,
0.49387240409851074,
0.18778935074806213,
-0.6428991556167603,
-0.5489104390144348,
-0.6830347776412964,
-0.3320794701576233,
0.13694272935390472,
-0.41911134123802185,
0.6424683928489685,
-0.682374894618988,
-0.1408826857805252,
-0.3319954574108124,
-0.08175723999738693,
-0.5742143392562866,
0.3664996027946472,
0.5895897746086121,
0.9884885549545288,
-1.398790717124939,
0.6069987416267395,
0.9180358648300171,
-0.36547836661338806,
-0.6541299819946289,
-0.6778837442398071,
0.16343030333518982,
-1.0706547498703003,
0.7311510443687439,
0.26634302735328674,
-0.03702874854207039,
0.2954523265361786,
-0.34119364619255066,
-0.8695645332336426,
0.8786630630493164,
0.42606186866760254,
-0.4348602890968323,
0.10388479381799698,
0.46021097898483276,
0.22979174554347992,
-0.43512606620788574,
0.045963820070028305,
0.5517966747283936,
0.5382135510444641,
0.27893969416618347,
-0.6637980937957764,
0.19395822286605835,
0.023860378190875053,
0.15323424339294434,
0.376651793718338,
-0.5902953147888184,
0.6451457142829895,
-0.43845102190971375,
-0.39307788014411926,
0.051367007195949554,
0.8219944834709167,
0.6979983448982239,
0.3680373728275299,
0.31606587767601013,
0.3977835178375244,
0.6371732354164124,
-0.2154848724603653,
0.4256236255168915,
-0.47465410828590393,
0.17369459569454193,
1.2598505020141602,
-0.5417470335960388,
0.7173088788986206,
0.3928236961364746,
-0.30904632806777954,
-0.039453331381082535,
0.7577770352363586,
0.1296280026435852,
0.1449839323759079,
0.3290463387966156,
-0.237314373254776,
-0.39059221744537354,
-0.1869564652442932,
-0.11012275516986847,
0.23036813735961914,
0.30080699920654297,
-0.3783297836780548,
-0.2550661861896515,
0.2320544421672821,
0.28213655948638916,
0.2991483807563782,
-0.4883348047733307,
0.6976306438446045,
0.2666928172111511,
-0.554402768611908,
0.4721807837486267,
0.05667085945606232,
0.6395590305328369,
-0.9392430186271667,
0.11077326536178589,
-0.35577234625816345,
0.03486637398600578,
-0.10539986938238144,
-0.7908048629760742,
0.13967691361904144,
-0.3140661120414734,
-0.016900941729545593,
-0.7608131766319275,
0.6677042841911316,
-0.9509095549583435,
-0.48678165674209595,
0.22716397047042847,
0.4114958643913269,
0.6392073035240173,
0.20818941295146942,
-0.8536924123764038,
0.17604473233222961,
-0.10025228559970856,
-0.19358119368553162,
0.26475590467453003,
0.16143976151943207,
-0.1693350076675415,
0.5452766418457031,
0.5843969583511353,
0.12976714968681335,
0.40037697553634644,
0.3166497051715851,
0.3930816054344177,
-0.6421893239021301,
-0.5136516690254211,
-0.45033562183380127,
0.6752888560295105,
-0.08275651931762695,
-0.5676627159118652,
0.8361265659332275,
0.8776974678039551,
0.6674249768257141,
-0.3693128824234009,
0.7148728966712952,
0.0675015076994896,
0.408849835395813,
-0.8031010627746582,
0.55995112657547,
-0.42221564054489136,
-0.25341179966926575,
-0.10614905506372452,
-0.8652775287628174,
-0.424736350774765,
0.14499524235725403,
0.09426423162221909,
0.014077968895435333,
0.43402084708213806,
0.7901672720909119,
0.05021336302161217,
-0.2218974083662033,
0.6727781891822815,
0.02001096121966839,
0.2326613962650299,
0.8828568458557129,
0.6609554290771484,
-0.6538881659507751,
0.5084486603736877,
0.28789976239204407,
-0.062219083309173584,
-0.2106040120124817,
-0.8480115532875061,
-0.797922670841217,
-0.892326295375824,
-0.6086603403091431,
-0.2943279445171356,
-0.23487262427806854,
0.9848306179046631,
0.8511633276939392,
-0.9914014935493469,
-0.6043551564216614,
0.13261620700359344,
0.06622056663036346,
-0.3612979054450989,
-0.11865945160388947,
0.2496504783630371,
-0.34075480699539185,
-0.8957478404045105,
0.7763505578041077,
0.1780519187450409,
0.31875303387641907,
-0.6223630309104919,
-0.7478682994842529,
-0.1883772909641266,
-0.3328644335269928,
0.7999604940414429,
0.5923475623130798,
-0.42248299717903137,
0.02375400811433792,
0.07174300402402878,
-0.15965919196605682,
-0.15331318974494934,
0.9520564079284668,
-0.2974114418029785,
0.43749141693115234,
0.5158448219299316,
0.3315533697605133,
0.5794442296028137,
-0.17520847916603088,
0.7256614565849304,
-0.9262557625770569,
0.3238156735897064,
0.08339767158031464,
0.3432088792324066,
0.6236564517021179,
-0.17916782200336456,
0.32477235794067383,
0.09873457998037338,
-0.22995659708976746,
-0.617388129234314,
0.7477871179580688,
-0.7532736659049988,
-0.179534450173378,
1.4418907165527344,
-0.16578830778598785,
0.044683173298835754,
-0.299836665391922,
-0.12235157936811447,
0.28941023349761963,
-0.4332524836063385,
0.1298753321170807,
0.3829546272754669,
-0.05939644202589989,
-0.5011587142944336,
-0.3330911695957184,
0.8436839580535889,
0.1172238439321518,
-0.7157267332077026,
0.2049722820520401,
0.9815495610237122,
0.1876656413078308,
0.003245243337005377,
0.8290725946426392,
-0.09367550909519196,
0.3271268606185913,
-0.2058539241552353,
0.41739293932914734,
-0.31356942653656006,
-0.5212612748146057,
-0.5909312963485718,
0.13265028595924377,
0.6886600852012634,
-0.02793385274708271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10714v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10714v1
|
Persian Pronoun Resolution: Leveraging Neural Networks and Language Models
| 2024-05-17T11:56:00 | 2024-05-17T11:56:00 |
Hassan Haji Mohammadi, Alireza Talebpour, Ahmad Mahmoudi Aznaveh, Samaneh Yazdani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Coreference resolution, critical for identifying textual entities referencing
the same entity, faces challenges in pronoun resolution, particularly
identifying pronoun antecedents. Existing methods often treat pronoun
resolution as a separate task from mention detection, potentially missing
valuable information. This study proposes the first end-to-end neural network
system for Persian pronoun resolution, leveraging pre-trained Transformer
models like ParsBERT. Our system jointly optimizes both mention detection and
antecedent linking, achieving a 3.37 F1 score improvement over the previous
state-of-the-art system (which relied on rule-based and statistical methods) on
the Mehr corpus. This significant improvement demonstrates the effectiveness of
combining neural networks with linguistic models, potentially marking a
significant advancement in Persian pronoun resolution and paving the way for
further research in this under-explored area.
|
[
-0.5309438109397888,
-0.5396291017532349,
0.3735150694847107,
-0.20431888103485107,
-0.6476255655288696,
0.24356162548065186,
-0.7762806415557861,
-0.5224222540855408,
0.32680538296699524,
0.3870679438114166,
-0.2848462760448456,
-0.25013333559036255,
-0.7208116054534912,
0.3223521113395691,
-0.5824970602989197,
0.7595065236091614,
0.3225187063217163,
-0.01818363182246685,
-0.04551566019654274,
-0.015676768496632576,
-0.24507799744606018,
-0.7275312542915344,
-0.6516784429550171,
-0.37559425830841064,
0.48884686827659607,
0.5786219239234924,
0.9264522194862366,
0.5370036959648132,
0.7058795094490051,
0.40657901763916016,
-0.396828830242157,
0.239087775349617,
0.034776471555233,
0.21464139223098755,
-0.5841847658157349,
-0.2301231473684311,
-0.30573466420173645,
0.010543763637542725,
0.6235972046852112,
0.6340855956077576,
0.026863591745495796,
0.41516852378845215,
-0.1626386046409607,
0.533263623714447,
-0.5332865118980408,
-0.26796236634254456,
-0.38799968361854553,
-0.07919164001941681,
-0.6563910245895386,
0.00252544810064137,
-0.47206494212150574,
-0.22252143919467926,
-0.08155626803636551,
-0.29281240701675415,
0.4577549993991852,
0.21499697864055634,
1.1200300455093384,
0.176457017660141,
-0.15467871725559235,
0.03341306746006012,
-0.9637464880943298,
0.6327378153800964,
-0.6260069012641907,
0.2672152817249298,
0.1597229391336441,
0.35640403628349304,
-0.0662815198302269,
-0.5212525129318237,
-0.640350878238678,
-0.4484162926673889,
-0.12402836978435516,
-0.048235610127449036,
-0.4109831750392914,
-0.10697382688522339,
0.06056210398674011,
0.41293954849243164,
-0.5281282663345337,
0.004335624165832996,
-0.4697774648666382,
-0.2129128873348236,
0.24290716648101807,
-0.2927713990211487,
0.13791321218013763,
-0.23908191919326782,
-0.0510469414293766,
0.14395081996917725,
-0.6236818432807922,
-0.018915485590696335,
0.2487579733133316,
0.44117996096611023,
0.4816757142543793,
0.42315977811813354,
-0.2313707321882248,
0.4185040593147278,
0.6078936457633972,
0.297143816947937,
0.09080313891172409,
-0.216439351439476,
-0.013836351223289967,
0.3982985317707062,
0.8693125247955322,
-0.052781738340854645,
0.33284297585487366,
-0.2904679775238037,
0.12338468432426453,
0.026106197386980057,
0.3010055422782898,
-0.5069885849952698,
-0.3948200047016144,
-0.10328962653875351,
-0.3834971487522125,
0.010185263119637966,
-0.04613069072365761,
-0.20421284437179565,
-0.3550702929496765,
-0.48399990797042847,
0.3904433250427246,
-0.5846099853515625,
-0.702903687953949,
-0.21273840963840485,
0.06599821150302887,
0.22074533998966217,
0.29143446683883667,
-0.6081123352050781,
0.5762479901313782,
0.5248139500617981,
0.683727502822876,
0.35533058643341064,
-0.17396129667758942,
-0.13500159978866577,
-0.11453410983085632,
-0.5107590556144714,
1.0839213132858276,
-0.6514677405357361,
-0.38752782344818115,
-0.5147960186004639,
-0.13029372692108154,
0.02607608214020729,
-0.9046968817710876,
0.8660403490066528,
-0.40067803859710693,
0.11204714328050613,
-0.04266446828842163,
-0.5471016764640808,
-0.3642466366291046,
0.09252580255270004,
-0.8071320056915283,
0.963417112827301,
-0.004678814206272364,
-0.540688157081604,
-0.36533719301223755,
-0.20599333941936493,
-0.24264326691627502,
0.11972589790821075,
0.011495993472635746,
-0.25931623578071594,
0.41979560256004333,
0.21941551566123962,
0.603026270866394,
-0.9283565282821655,
0.610852837562561,
0.5370663404464722,
-0.23582957684993744,
0.21432501077651978,
-0.015758614987134933,
0.38078194856643677,
-0.19236420094966888,
-0.13204102218151093,
0.4879554510116577,
-0.6573631763458252,
-0.17367716133594513,
0.014780763536691666,
0.11910442262887955,
-0.4311160445213318,
-0.025163181126117706,
-0.22149614989757538,
0.28285250067710876,
0.37811940908432007,
-0.7306455969810486,
-0.3838318884372711,
-0.18299797177314758,
0.17361584305763245,
0.5198299288749695,
-0.174222931265831,
0.4243680536746979,
-0.1902589648962021,
0.3317157030105591,
0.1764429360628128,
0.061664581298828125,
-0.16042596101760864,
-0.2933472692966461,
-0.8307359218597412,
0.02006874606013298,
0.6756359338760376,
0.3984833061695099,
-0.42252466082572937,
0.5099166035652161,
-0.32740169763565063,
-0.7921547889709473,
-0.33611181378364563,
-0.07670023292303085,
0.8222430348396301,
0.7227399945259094,
0.6312615871429443,
-0.12758387625217438,
-0.8068539500236511,
-1.1608117818832397,
-0.5266165733337402,
-0.3711411654949188,
0.1096368357539177,
0.2558269798755646,
0.4098953306674957,
0.43414995074272156,
0.7486496567726135,
0.021866094321012497,
-0.4984775483608246,
-0.3228866755962372,
0.06817281246185303,
0.7417110204696655,
0.6335741281509399,
0.20371215045452118,
-0.8841257095336914,
-0.5189504027366638,
0.2095838040113449,
-0.46563154458999634,
0.03995879366993904,
0.14222554862499237,
-0.2147991955280304,
-0.31826815009117126,
0.6024695038795471,
-0.36920979619026184,
0.14009973406791687,
0.36633405089378357,
-0.42932021617889404,
1.1518268585205078,
0.07590878009796143,
0.0963514968752861,
-1.1196491718292236,
0.25627031922340393,
0.27864518761634827,
-0.5535242557525635,
-0.6981865763664246,
-0.1392536461353302,
0.12463176995515823,
-0.11224142462015152,
-0.3786119818687439,
0.32179540395736694,
-0.5427306294441223,
0.21055325865745544,
-0.3053049147129059,
0.020685967057943344,
-0.1229148581624031,
0.4812588393688202,
0.21145911514759064,
0.9940500855445862,
0.28622424602508545,
-0.7422052621841431,
0.7958866953849792,
0.34257081151008606,
-0.12089688330888748,
0.6200886964797974,
-0.7592210173606873,
-0.07401175051927567,
-0.09442561119794846,
-0.016413351520895958,
-0.7096869349479675,
-0.07142778486013412,
0.2939677834510803,
-0.7833890914916992,
0.4340490698814392,
0.15414825081825256,
-0.37715885043144226,
-0.19298337399959564,
0.04708012938499451,
0.5686646103858948,
0.40400803089141846,
-0.4997318983078003,
0.7291661500930786,
0.29217416048049927,
-0.42340782284736633,
-0.4625193476676941,
-0.07299239188432693,
0.32822659611701965,
-0.08263731002807617,
-0.2751757502555847,
0.7773622274398804,
0.49163031578063965,
-0.2423064112663269,
0.18805031478405,
-0.24383150041103363,
-0.03406020253896713,
-0.14142413437366486,
0.09056190401315689,
0.25169724225997925,
-0.3499586880207062,
0.3313155472278595,
-0.070491261780262,
-0.5374573469161987,
0.1372450441122055,
-0.10759221762418747,
0.4459642469882965,
-0.24018706381320953,
-0.09474822133779526,
-0.5401850938796997,
0.4780214726924896,
0.09819187223911285,
-0.7319298386573792,
0.8053638339042664,
0.27080830931663513,
-0.6375250220298767,
0.15776139497756958,
-0.773010790348053,
-0.050094399601221085,
-0.34335875511169434,
0.3466165363788605,
-0.5272454023361206,
-0.7554903030395508,
0.6045767068862915,
-0.8292436003684998,
-0.4450252950191498,
0.6500684022903442,
0.4633805751800537,
-0.08981810510158539,
0.5471353530883789,
0.5221223831176758,
0.07209531962871552,
0.3877590596675873,
0.1314764767885208,
0.5157427191734314,
-1.4274699687957764,
-0.1398201435804367,
-0.9161717295646667,
-0.31603097915649414,
-0.022891009226441383,
-0.6812499165534973,
0.1508878916501999,
0.5210830569267273,
-0.441098690032959,
0.8275942206382751,
-0.6305869817733765,
0.673803985118866,
0.7650390863418579,
0.5742191672325134,
0.29917487502098083,
-0.33203479647636414,
-0.4261951148509979,
-0.07984926551580429,
-0.16568678617477417,
-0.44329211115837097,
0.5798328518867493,
0.09454582631587982,
0.18830570578575134,
0.38312870264053345,
0.5558003783226013,
0.334860622882843,
0.04769587516784668,
-0.554898738861084,
0.7307767868041992,
-0.4047638773918152,
-0.5538470149040222,
-0.3242863416671753,
-0.07527761161327362,
-0.3246828615665436,
0.21216529607772827,
-0.025761159136891365,
-0.6870482563972473,
0.5467720031738281,
-0.06527533382177353,
-0.5116709470748901,
0.25896838307380676,
-0.031848274171352386,
0.6957636475563049,
0.06202508509159088,
-0.5701167583465576,
-0.2349054366350174,
-0.7646618485450745,
0.25938546657562256,
0.027508582919836044,
0.08124846965074539,
-0.6327806115150452,
0.22337521612644196,
0.9551049470901489,
-0.4694894254207611,
0.6890113949775696,
0.049391742795705795,
0.211958646774292,
0.35479703545570374,
0.18604294955730438,
0.2805830240249634,
-0.17888285219669342,
-0.3009227216243744,
0.23659199476242065,
-0.37310531735420227,
-0.2035331130027771,
-0.35985448956489563,
0.6311963200569153,
-0.670653760433197,
-0.6980932950973511,
-0.4782920181751251,
-0.11120045185089111,
-0.04693982005119324,
0.15355616807937622,
0.29093512892723083,
0.3674156665802002,
-0.3354155421257019,
0.21179361641407013,
0.7635349631309509,
-0.014019559137523174,
0.4171023964881897,
0.4372379779815674,
-0.09298650175333023,
-0.48594003915786743,
0.6443923115730286,
-0.1142779216170311,
-0.2027827501296997,
0.38975757360458374,
0.24544042348861694,
-0.41651543974876404,
-0.19847141206264496,
-0.6775571703910828,
0.46014878153800964,
-0.707629382610321,
-0.7473205924034119,
-0.17939601838588715,
-0.5890958905220032,
-0.20382368564605713,
0.09582097083330154,
-0.652323842048645,
-0.4439506232738495,
-0.46828141808509827,
0.008381268940865993,
0.3129836618900299,
0.39696791768074036,
-0.22535340487957,
0.6082174777984619,
-0.9199199676513672,
0.34588149189949036,
-0.026375707238912582,
0.15858305990695953,
0.02291686087846756,
-0.9229877591133118,
-0.4882308542728424,
-0.2755221128463745,
-0.0985565260052681,
-1.1413331031799316,
0.3050035834312439,
0.6267949342727661,
0.48128247261047363,
0.33475854992866516,
0.21915189921855927,
0.7519827485084534,
-0.7933063507080078,
0.7370687127113342,
0.28593525290489197,
-1.4332776069641113,
0.8426112532615662,
-0.1454789787530899,
0.10373741388320923,
0.40250152349472046,
0.4488232731819153,
-0.7309720516204834,
-0.15402302145957947,
-0.5574175715446472,
-0.7581183314323425,
0.5112863183021545,
0.15994152426719666,
0.13030540943145752,
-0.3768647611141205,
0.7006304860115051,
0.010027531534433365,
0.09097545593976974,
-0.40244200825691223,
-0.21533092856407166,
0.21135178208351135,
-0.005598005373030901,
-0.08073288202285767,
-0.47534817457199097,
0.30385011434555054,
-0.4134266674518585,
1.0968745946884155,
0.05495721474289894,
0.30692505836486816,
0.36237549781799316,
-0.47203460335731506,
-0.15345463156700134,
0.4545723795890808,
0.3837760388851166,
0.4582458436489105,
0.07799673080444336,
0.3504050374031067,
-0.026236308738589287,
-0.3663027584552765,
0.3513329327106476,
-0.02734994702041149,
0.12216061353683472,
0.42394140362739563,
0.3233344256877899,
0.5278445482254028,
0.4869527816772461,
-0.43814119696617126,
0.32693928480148315,
0.07357919216156006,
-0.1162947490811348,
-0.5171687006950378,
-0.08292495459318161,
0.21730676293373108,
0.3831128776073456,
0.5870330929756165,
0.37817782163619995,
0.23702503740787506,
-0.18318124115467072,
0.2742549777030945,
0.16674494743347168,
-0.38473406434059143,
-0.4547736942768097,
0.5904437899589539,
0.23550695180892944,
-0.38899850845336914,
0.6853954195976257,
-0.028651883825659752,
-0.8974235653877258,
0.6511523127555847,
0.7516545057296753,
0.6401980519294739,
-1.102497935295105,
0.2271813452243805,
0.8011794686317444,
0.020079338923096657,
-0.20683316886425018,
0.2715064585208893,
-0.19991746544837952,
-0.8806058168411255,
-0.594222903251648,
-0.7343907952308655,
-0.5959776043891907,
-0.40180039405822754,
-0.8802382946014404,
0.2356172502040863,
-0.5900639295578003,
-0.47798529267311096,
0.06925710290670395,
0.06608187407255173,
-0.37683379650115967,
0.28167811036109924,
0.24138425290584564,
0.7931718826293945,
-0.7500070929527283,
0.7630802989006042,
0.9829990863800049,
-0.48658502101898193,
-0.7581859230995178,
-0.5508860945701599,
-0.2664005160331726,
-0.18597529828548431,
0.669888436794281,
0.19786490499973297,
-0.24954353272914886,
0.45599913597106934,
-0.22566890716552734,
-0.8618185520172119,
0.8533156514167786,
0.21513330936431885,
-0.8146005868911743,
-0.0013508490519598126,
0.04127408191561699,
0.429540753364563,
-0.18047718703746796,
0.5607595443725586,
0.6929296255111694,
0.2159697413444519,
-0.026198886334896088,
-1.3513516187667847,
0.36081311106681824,
-0.6222632527351379,
0.26313820481300354,
0.5727864503860474,
-0.5234360098838806,
1.1254605054855347,
-0.12144660949707031,
-0.30254483222961426,
0.21213647723197937,
0.9635810852050781,
-0.09704966098070145,
-0.30057451128959656,
0.4353967607021332,
0.7073847651481628,
0.6473469734191895,
-0.06319426000118256,
0.3715926706790924,
-0.45170044898986816,
0.22088606655597687,
1.3482416868209839,
-0.25682955980300903,
1.1744672060012817,
0.3522825539112091,
-0.3815789222717285,
0.6502843499183655,
0.6237682700157166,
0.22794567048549652,
0.36438408493995667,
0.4290916919708252,
-0.7252406477928162,
-0.5156325697898865,
-0.8057413697242737,
-0.3273562490940094,
0.40084564685821533,
0.6048370003700256,
-0.5389039516448975,
-0.4217239320278168,
0.16654133796691895,
-0.07485675811767578,
0.5528894662857056,
-0.5332920551300049,
0.9488939046859741,
-0.11060105264186859,
-0.4984177052974701,
0.38220226764678955,
0.08226741850376129,
0.3927519917488098,
-0.17672155797481537,
-0.037741754204034805,
-0.022655658423900604,
0.32408562302589417,
-0.23180270195007324,
-0.38930174708366394,
0.5299438238143921,
0.012450323440134525,
-0.5357025861740112,
0.034477874636650085,
1.024351954460144,
-0.2911010682582855,
-0.5525997281074524,
0.3730872571468353,
0.8130087852478027,
0.30575159192085266,
-0.5950207710266113,
-0.33815932273864746,
-0.286230206489563,
-0.22026777267456055,
-0.049341704696416855,
0.007180233485996723,
0.3550088405609131,
-0.22828027606010437,
0.3343980312347412,
0.7555068135261536,
0.08462096750736237,
0.21609976887702942,
0.11345746368169785,
1.1089578866958618,
-0.9755629897117615,
-0.12860864400863647,
-0.9786813259124756,
0.3434017300605774,
-0.11133356392383575,
-0.3004380166530609,
0.45355433225631714,
0.47581756114959717,
0.606347382068634,
0.06338627636432648,
0.4807443618774414,
-0.005090269725769758,
1.081917643547058,
-0.01620456762611866,
0.41652730107307434,
-0.17472204566001892,
0.13998372852802277,
0.03523820638656616,
-0.8869978785514832,
-0.5545195937156677,
0.8539400696754456,
-0.18729500472545624,
-0.2485375702381134,
0.7736766338348389,
0.5551316738128662,
-0.02286977879703045,
0.19697308540344238,
0.35577064752578735,
0.08375602215528488,
0.027284059673547745,
0.5538226366043091,
0.8788071274757385,
-0.6825106739997864,
0.2949732840061188,
-0.6620856523513794,
-0.16989251971244812,
-0.2769864797592163,
-0.7253804802894592,
-0.6604987978935242,
-0.7297133803367615,
-0.42262980341911316,
-0.22374418377876282,
0.37622690200805664,
1.073945164680481,
0.41024917364120483,
-0.8963427543640137,
-0.12854242324829102,
0.04031715914607048,
-0.14807137846946716,
-0.4032851755619049,
-0.06527489423751831,
0.5903431177139282,
-0.29223936796188354,
-0.6824263334274292,
0.2951374053955078,
0.14075779914855957,
-0.4637382924556732,
-0.07504528760910034,
0.05297284200787544,
-0.6094372868537903,
-0.21487757563591003,
0.3027721345424652,
0.2087736278772354,
-0.8601389527320862,
-0.17984236776828766,
0.1278015524148941,
-0.013981116004288197,
0.1847638487815857,
0.7727054953575134,
-1.1717629432678223,
0.09645650535821915,
0.348542183637619,
0.5320976972579956,
-0.09631583094596863,
0.3631521165370941,
0.4920896887779236,
-0.7442799806594849,
0.0678335577249527,
0.5352591872215271,
0.43910250067710876,
0.32587721943855286,
-0.4868370294570923,
0.3675093650817871,
0.050658755004405975,
-0.5450083017349243,
-0.3747946321964264,
0.2156549096107483,
-0.5861499905586243,
-0.20332759618759155,
0.5071495771408081,
-0.3756285011768341,
-0.4368303418159485,
-0.1888715922832489,
-0.3129270672798157,
0.7310532331466675,
-0.26726022362709045,
0.2543972432613373,
0.7335425615310669,
-0.30910512804985046,
-0.8257013559341431,
-0.16170664131641388,
0.24251951277256012,
0.628429651260376,
-0.38094642758369446,
-0.0030979071743786335,
0.38312602043151855,
-0.07793989032506943,
0.5973904132843018,
0.40985944867134094,
-0.0850791335105896,
0.45318806171417236,
-0.12768930196762085,
0.42514568567276,
-0.17569728195667267,
-0.6545554399490356,
-0.24788197875022888,
-0.033916302025318146,
0.1617611199617386,
-0.19895437359809875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10702v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10702v1
|
Empowering Prior to Court Legal Analysis: A Transparent and Accessible Dataset for Defensive Statement Classification and Interpretation
| 2024-05-17T11:22:27 | 2024-05-17T11:22:27 |
Yannis Spyridis, Jean-Paul, Haneen Deeb, Vasileios Argyriou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
The classification of statements provided by individuals during police
interviews is a complex and significant task within the domain of natural
language processing (NLP) and legal informatics. The lack of extensive
domain-specific datasets raises challenges to the advancement of NLP methods in
the field. This paper aims to address some of the present challenges by
introducing a novel dataset tailored for classification of statements made
during police interviews, prior to court proceedings. Utilising the curated
dataset for training and evaluation, we introduce a fine-tuned DistilBERT model
that achieves state-of-the-art performance in distinguishing truthful from
deceptive statements. To enhance interpretability, we employ explainable
artificial intelligence (XAI) methods to offer explainability through saliency
maps, that interpret the model's decision-making process. Lastly, we present an
XAI interface that empowers both legal professionals and non-specialists to
interact with and benefit from our system. Our model achieves an accuracy of
86%, and is shown to outperform a custom transformer architecture in a
comparative study. This holistic approach advances the accessibility,
transparency, and effectiveness of statement analysis, with promising
implications for both legal practice and research.
|
[
-0.2847292423248291,
-0.34968453645706177,
0.5875126719474792,
-0.0974591001868248,
-0.17325261235237122,
0.37752869725227356,
-0.1418248862028122,
-0.5762466192245483,
-0.01267162337899208,
0.30259886384010315,
-0.440012127161026,
-0.43667250871658325,
-0.8890725374221802,
-0.014574456959962845,
-0.6124710440635681,
0.8727078437805176,
0.26243358850479126,
0.23913756012916565,
0.017383500933647156,
-0.3016561269760132,
-0.4806753993034363,
-0.5969519019126892,
-0.25018310546875,
-0.09313928335905075,
0.04542159661650658,
0.059061381965875626,
0.7519581913948059,
0.4680623710155487,
0.6004300713539124,
0.398627370595932,
0.1208035945892334,
-0.1771128922700882,
-0.2974545955657959,
0.03440796211361885,
-0.40808165073394775,
-0.7462396621704102,
-0.25144216418266296,
0.11076239496469498,
0.1401662528514862,
0.5693085193634033,
-0.24382217228412628,
-0.007115961518138647,
-0.25125470757484436,
0.5072838068008423,
-0.8275641202926636,
0.22767169773578644,
-0.7793881893157959,
0.3918101489543915,
-0.2758938670158386,
-0.12246181070804596,
-0.36906546354293823,
-0.31678634881973267,
0.35462865233421326,
-0.646508514881134,
0.2869487702846527,
0.040652137249708176,
0.6503909826278687,
0.5564300417900085,
-0.2856636345386505,
-0.32786136865615845,
-0.7507187724113464,
0.48683398962020874,
-0.5358185172080994,
0.21907101571559906,
0.35144153237342834,
0.7480925917625427,
0.11673542112112045,
-0.8753394484519958,
-0.8822398781776428,
-0.2216220200061798,
-0.4189145267009735,
0.24279813468456268,
-0.6062642931938171,
0.23738180100917816,
0.3428835868835449,
0.1989620476961136,
-0.41869157552719116,
0.263386994600296,
-0.4387400150299072,
0.050816044211387634,
0.865893542766571,
0.04859370365738869,
0.0005443893605843186,
0.0771411657333374,
-0.12035521864891052,
-0.2505891025066376,
-0.37732255458831787,
0.16978514194488525,
0.4139135479927063,
0.41177013516426086,
-0.1517758071422577,
0.37379780411720276,
-0.3107702434062958,
0.508758544921875,
0.4310903549194336,
-0.20989951491355896,
0.2903538942337036,
-0.03462642803788185,
-0.3446548879146576,
0.5518059134483337,
0.7940892577171326,
0.5240773558616638,
0.18059903383255005,
0.029999984428286552,
-0.2862243950366974,
0.02481519989669323,
0.57328200340271,
-0.6444225311279297,
-0.2079111486673355,
0.389382541179657,
-0.4949435591697693,
-0.6333224773406982,
0.455923855304718,
-0.8610416650772095,
-0.8508891463279724,
-0.5599636435508728,
-0.0344163179397583,
-0.1918623000383377,
-0.24533188343048096,
0.12860530614852905,
-0.14800997078418732,
0.10672704130411148,
0.302167683839798,
-0.6848962903022766,
0.4226092994213104,
0.5685927867889404,
0.5313053727149963,
0.0872257649898529,
0.3259251117706299,
-0.34688639640808105,
0.1488708108663559,
-0.14117427170276642,
0.33215898275375366,
-0.7226500511169434,
-0.17551830410957336,
0.08609561622142792,
0.016664188355207443,
0.219404399394989,
-0.49746039509773254,
0.8446841835975647,
-0.5817978978157043,
0.06710582971572876,
0.20373070240020752,
-0.25824862718582153,
-0.3351186513900757,
0.21470367908477783,
-0.6208267211914062,
0.4118059277534485,
0.27757006883621216,
-0.6775633096694946,
0.9092749357223511,
-0.8908026814460754,
-0.6716201305389404,
0.35116666555404663,
-0.6272810697555542,
-0.514678955078125,
0.27277711033821106,
0.13987022638320923,
0.3949161469936371,
-0.1500670313835144,
0.5833473205566406,
-0.2635931372642517,
-0.0736626535654068,
0.2566792964935303,
-0.42294904589653015,
1.1231141090393066,
0.4520139694213867,
-0.7222471833229065,
0.11070039868354797,
-0.8861244916915894,
-0.2190883457660675,
0.04627985507249832,
0.04014673829078674,
-0.3373776078224182,
0.031193917617201805,
-0.40902549028396606,
0.2232012003660202,
-0.03766114264726639,
-0.5652236342430115,
-0.1239551305770874,
-0.21935445070266724,
0.27938738465309143,
0.7186375856399536,
-0.4537467360496521,
0.2821747660636902,
-0.017187146469950676,
0.6514341235160828,
0.04307255148887634,
0.34455907344818115,
0.19885453581809998,
-0.2252759337425232,
-0.24768395721912384,
-0.20584742724895477,
0.4034520983695984,
0.8927397131919861,
-0.5410898923873901,
0.6806761622428894,
-0.5214908123016357,
-0.238672137260437,
-0.7515047192573547,
-0.10409028083086014,
0.11806038022041321,
0.8340813517570496,
0.25697779655456543,
-0.010519363917410374,
-0.7996271252632141,
-1.0128326416015625,
-0.07633116841316223,
-0.2586820125579834,
-0.063266821205616,
0.12234848737716675,
0.3853692412376404,
-0.08469779789447784,
1.1481225490570068,
-0.37337368726730347,
-0.3488720655441284,
-0.48097723722457886,
0.1948447972536087,
0.31030189990997314,
0.28399857878685,
0.7639684081077576,
-1.37822687625885,
-0.4236104190349579,
0.12100167572498322,
-0.870020866394043,
-0.3416951298713684,
-0.3856458067893982,
0.0006558538298122585,
-0.29391247034072876,
0.26231518387794495,
-0.3084557354450226,
0.8885363340377808,
-0.012838670052587986,
-0.4803663492202759,
0.5648232102394104,
0.17000505328178406,
0.32410502433776855,
-0.5535438060760498,
-0.18261176347732544,
0.07965269684791565,
-0.5188875794410706,
-0.8313965797424316,
0.11113601922988892,
-0.14509901404380798,
0.025429481640458107,
-0.4592263996601105,
0.05045914649963379,
-0.19870968163013458,
0.07403179258108139,
-0.26060402393341064,
0.10255720466375351,
0.0063070193864405155,
0.43914198875427246,
0.20875586569309235,
0.42132940888404846,
0.6728253364562988,
-0.5651063323020935,
0.4060981869697571,
0.539363443851471,
-0.5634384751319885,
0.7339186668395996,
-0.5571079254150391,
-0.13522323966026306,
-0.17461374402046204,
0.02583317644894123,
-0.6397302150726318,
-0.22524286806583405,
0.3848295211791992,
-0.14688019454479218,
0.5692338943481445,
-0.35027027130126953,
-0.2924042046070099,
-0.4537982940673828,
-0.21092793345451355,
0.30353397130966187,
0.37141138315200806,
-0.5984069108963013,
0.6894402503967285,
0.6115837097167969,
-0.3348677456378937,
-0.696840226650238,
-0.9081924557685852,
0.08437329530715942,
-0.5343002080917358,
-0.3274911344051361,
0.3779730200767517,
0.15798325836658478,
-0.8290697336196899,
-0.154901385307312,
-0.05243859812617302,
-0.44927847385406494,
0.37436529994010925,
0.5524215698242188,
0.431696355342865,
-0.01208365149796009,
0.07954573631286621,
0.22078341245651245,
0.18151873350143433,
0.4310736060142517,
0.14104343950748444,
0.22416667640209198,
-0.05889701098203659,
-0.3839339017868042,
-0.8251264691352844,
0.36936452984809875,
0.34759846329689026,
-0.05448604002594948,
0.5705051422119141,
0.20993949472904205,
-0.0610572025179863,
0.04414188861846924,
-0.24018266797065735,
0.10046099126338959,
-0.503537654876709,
0.17391040921211243,
-0.4165771007537842,
-0.7484864592552185,
0.02402912825345993,
-0.15270087122917175,
0.21312931180000305,
0.45117419958114624,
0.385801762342453,
-0.01667104661464691,
0.8672537207603455,
0.5729556679725647,
-0.23946280777454376,
0.49187159538269043,
0.050099972635507584,
0.4242260754108429,
-0.17284448444843292,
-0.19428648054599762,
-0.3863029479980469,
-0.3069312274456024,
-0.5852975249290466,
0.16619005799293518,
0.36816340684890747,
-0.06407225131988525,
-0.030269520357251167,
0.11504440754652023,
-0.9089279770851135,
0.41460737586021423,
0.3921199440956116,
0.1601109802722931,
0.23123730719089508,
-0.12691418826580048,
0.15435414016246796,
0.11563920974731445,
-0.3102989196777344,
-0.5967865586280823,
1.2180521488189697,
0.28308138251304626,
0.49381202459335327,
0.4350860118865967,
0.4617787003517151,
0.6403802633285522,
0.26465922594070435,
-0.6645049452781677,
0.50070720911026,
-0.19764530658721924,
-0.6863408088684082,
-0.2640285789966583,
-0.32618629932403564,
-0.7105152010917664,
0.2252548635005951,
-0.4369567036628723,
-0.7519452571868896,
0.4542122185230255,
-0.2384919822216034,
-0.9321604371070862,
0.13083308935165405,
-0.719188392162323,
0.41339612007141113,
-0.5294151306152344,
-0.3081468939781189,
-0.33379215002059937,
-0.8674933314323425,
0.575688898563385,
-0.25429508090019226,
0.26649409532546997,
-0.10541468113660812,
0.287271648645401,
0.5723473429679871,
-0.7029627561569214,
0.8419721722602844,
-0.5065383911132812,
0.051401834934949875,
0.4607761800289154,
-0.33677318692207336,
0.18767789006233215,
0.0688481256365776,
-0.10468693822622299,
-0.030490349978208542,
0.18989616632461548,
0.04656487703323364,
-1.018254041671753,
0.1298714131116867,
-0.37961602210998535,
-0.8110789656639099,
-0.3306542634963989,
-0.42771151661872864,
-0.095109723508358,
0.12819649279117584,
-0.11589858680963516,
0.4342306852340698,
-0.2598961293697357,
0.2185060828924179,
0.5707893967628479,
-0.056815456598997116,
0.2108583003282547,
0.6096957325935364,
0.06044138967990875,
0.1341441422700882,
0.5441809892654419,
0.10244406759738922,
-0.14119583368301392,
0.4944589138031006,
0.2941681742668152,
-0.7059578895568848,
-0.8116581439971924,
-0.10811072587966919,
-0.2606355845928192,
-0.7120945453643799,
-0.2195415198802948,
-0.43061235547065735,
0.03592568263411522,
-0.7215071320533752,
0.02891889400780201,
0.1143636703491211,
-0.8694602847099304,
0.16019819676876068,
-0.3591965138912201,
0.41407203674316406,
0.7198718786239624,
-0.2552056312561035,
0.48280227184295654,
-0.3507869839668274,
0.5526166558265686,
0.22225242853164673,
0.1464235633611679,
-0.4620397090911865,
-0.6446802020072937,
-0.056868184357881546,
0.05640121176838875,
-0.3296578526496887,
-0.8429465889930725,
0.29401421546936035,
0.013698496855795383,
0.6205669045448303,
0.7231218218803406,
0.3951199948787689,
0.4660889804363251,
-0.39067214727401733,
0.5461175441741943,
0.16693423688411713,
-0.768546998500824,
0.9229043126106262,
0.05191325768828392,
-0.23027512431144714,
1.0202146768569946,
0.6042046546936035,
0.2560010850429535,
-0.2613946795463562,
-0.6747403740882874,
-0.5675106644630432,
0.6391162872314453,
0.27778545022010803,
-0.14156068861484528,
0.23425264656543732,
0.2119603157043457,
0.19984130561351776,
0.5023025870323181,
-0.5161596536636353,
-0.11193916946649551,
-0.48542389273643494,
-0.4323651194572449,
0.11533215641975403,
0.05384572967886925,
-0.5362002849578857,
-0.4745866656303406,
0.5763626098632812,
-0.06832415610551834,
0.05626180022954941,
0.13542184233665466,
-0.2301100790500641,
0.6198059916496277,
0.4624999761581421,
0.3632637858390808,
0.6259769797325134,
-0.15335313975811005,
0.053560514003038406,
0.2501644790172577,
-0.4971184730529785,
0.2246752381324768,
0.4161253273487091,
-0.009575341828167439,
0.1791302114725113,
0.32045236229896545,
0.7151011824607849,
-0.2648376524448395,
-0.8322197794914246,
0.765017032623291,
-0.4593410789966583,
-0.24584314227104187,
-0.5877067446708679,
0.10526452958583832,
-0.6724846363067627,
0.37925615906715393,
0.39761456847190857,
0.07618320733308792,
0.4969516396522522,
-0.6558458805084229,
0.33823615312576294,
0.1836220622062683,
-0.4402145445346832,
-0.011931833811104298,
0.7123132944107056,
0.04711361601948738,
0.01209287066012621,
0.47545111179351807,
-0.32031384110450745,
-0.5033941268920898,
0.22814133763313293,
-0.05760077014565468,
0.8091855049133301,
-0.11938054114580154,
0.1650860458612442,
-0.02499454654753208,
0.12719659507274628,
-0.05176275968551636,
0.009431307204067707,
-0.47121021151542664,
-0.7171357274055481,
-0.08891500532627106,
-0.3724105656147003,
-0.26026424765586853,
0.13405992090702057,
-1.0428321361541748,
-0.05722557753324509,
-0.8887096047401428,
-0.3433535695075989,
0.05918994918465614,
-0.10032138973474503,
-0.6129624843597412,
0.5230977535247803,
0.0267340037971735,
0.8670607209205627,
-0.701034426689148,
0.6544970273971558,
0.1550990790128708,
-0.4538930654525757,
-0.5830113291740417,
-0.2753142714500427,
0.3352317810058594,
-0.6789371967315674,
0.8195227980613708,
0.1700473576784134,
-0.13634955883026123,
-0.608284056186676,
-0.7943719625473022,
-0.035486750304698944,
1.029801368713379,
0.3120601177215576,
-0.9653980731964111,
0.04238797724246979,
0.4611131548881531,
0.5991034507751465,
-0.47340527176856995,
0.22133539617061615,
1.1799174547195435,
0.46091362833976746,
0.21993094682693481,
-0.5689061284065247,
0.15667864680290222,
-0.4125603437423706,
-0.4552345871925354,
-0.10537237673997879,
-0.27495720982551575,
0.432755708694458,
-0.0959862545132637,
-0.39593467116355896,
-0.1592644602060318,
0.6397731304168701,
0.030550435185432434,
0.31556540727615356,
0.6562259793281555,
0.5242872834205627,
1.2104841470718384,
-0.4584200084209442,
1.3980820178985596,
-0.22813600301742554,
-0.2135637253522873,
1.5810699462890625,
-0.3970116972923279,
0.48352962732315063,
0.3330554664134979,
-0.2641270160675049,
0.5350937843322754,
0.25758495926856995,
-0.32940399646759033,
0.8529550433158875,
0.3552085757255554,
-0.41622716188430786,
-0.12902209162712097,
-0.2913564443588257,
0.04847854748368263,
0.7367039322853088,
0.3611212968826294,
-0.5282449722290039,
-0.012074255384504795,
-0.08004527539014816,
-0.3262885808944702,
0.21887357532978058,
-0.5020081400871277,
0.7672022581100464,
-0.09470777958631516,
-0.27762937545776367,
0.18360349535942078,
-0.17421823740005493,
0.6013472676277161,
-0.4751140773296356,
-0.018654929473996162,
0.10424450039863586,
0.16404542326927185,
-0.5254024863243103,
-1.1099375486373901,
0.6464633345603943,
0.2555483877658844,
-0.16544561088085175,
-0.4797135293483734,
0.6577891707420349,
0.029679514467716217,
-0.4083419740200043,
0.05699703097343445,
0.20370164513587952,
0.22592926025390625,
-0.13907140493392944,
-0.9499885439872742,
-0.11430297791957855,
0.06984174996614456,
-0.02662106603384018,
0.09818114340305328,
0.6351333856582642,
-0.19986961781978607,
0.6512471437454224,
0.315876841545105,
0.11235471069812775,
0.0899471789598465,
0.46560341119766235,
0.8784649968147278,
-0.3734282851219177,
-0.6441618800163269,
-0.7840816974639893,
0.7593804001808167,
-0.6048062443733215,
-0.22020132839679718,
0.3900628983974457,
0.5200149416923523,
0.6478396058082581,
0.2006780207157135,
1.1923630237579346,
-0.19230441749095917,
0.7322766780853271,
-0.6303572654724121,
0.7273566722869873,
-0.09948309510946274,
0.2593882977962494,
-0.25681838393211365,
-0.22155791521072388,
-0.12321533262729645,
0.6920800805091858,
-0.4044686257839203,
-0.21283268928527832,
0.2799833118915558,
0.7460968494415283,
-0.18962863087654114,
0.3760412931442261,
0.4353518486022949,
0.07745382189750671,
0.3962553143501282,
0.3976098299026489,
1.0053863525390625,
-0.25759321451187134,
0.5812388062477112,
-0.1572699248790741,
-0.31254276633262634,
0.08821515738964081,
-0.5477882623672485,
-0.9126405119895935,
-0.35729920864105225,
-0.35500162839889526,
-0.03333205729722977,
-0.05874031037092209,
0.6070294380187988,
0.9240061640739441,
-0.9713746309280396,
0.09539379924535751,
-0.09946703910827637,
-0.12336057424545288,
-0.03404676914215088,
-0.27302467823028564,
0.013160448521375656,
-0.10794807970523834,
-0.5044377446174622,
0.6615872979164124,
0.03385923430323601,
0.3423401117324829,
0.03745082765817642,
0.003182600485160947,
-0.06612192839384079,
-0.07948681712150574,
0.5054369568824768,
0.3371559977531433,
-0.42357203364372253,
-0.13019157946109772,
-0.723358154296875,
0.1943410336971283,
0.26918816566467285,
0.8991693258285522,
-0.7456561326980591,
0.39714133739471436,
0.016510343179106712,
0.8928589820861816,
0.3659067153930664,
0.1351400762796402,
0.8401321172714233,
-0.7843354344367981,
0.3787517845630646,
0.30773550271987915,
0.556524932384491,
0.16274841129779816,
-0.5256837010383606,
0.816818356513977,
-0.10348976403474808,
-0.04715641215443611,
-0.6596307754516602,
0.2082139402627945,
-0.8234766721725464,
-0.4809432923793793,
0.49766087532043457,
-0.3621419370174408,
-0.145513117313385,
-0.5053768754005432,
-0.1270838975906372,
0.1846179962158203,
-0.43518808484077454,
1.0099681615829468,
0.5823537707328796,
-0.09876023977994919,
-0.2089402973651886,
-0.43189242482185364,
0.6157577037811279,
0.04279569908976555,
-0.9487795829772949,
0.019302234053611755,
0.5135825276374817,
-0.015005769208073616,
0.5189558863639832,
0.25580939650535583,
-0.2527396082878113,
0.14980369806289673,
-0.013394180685281754,
-0.2877177894115448,
-0.17315693199634552,
-0.2975047826766968,
-0.5758361220359802,
0.39370307326316833,
-0.36745336651802063,
-0.2223612517118454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10700v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10700v1
|
SynDy: Synthetic Dynamic Dataset Generation Framework for Misinformation Tasks
| 2024-05-17T11:14:55 | 2024-05-17T11:14:55 |
Michael Shliselberg, Ashkan Kazemi, Scott A. Hale, Shiri Dori-Hacohen
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Diaspora communities are disproportionately impacted by off-the-radar
misinformation and often neglected by mainstream fact-checking efforts,
creating a critical need to scale-up efforts of nascent fact-checking
initiatives. In this paper we present SynDy, a framework for Synthetic Dynamic
Dataset Generation to leverage the capabilities of the largest frontier Large
Language Models (LLMs) to train local, specialized language models. To the best
of our knowledge, SynDy is the first paper utilizing LLMs to create
fine-grained synthetic labels for tasks of direct relevance to misinformation
mitigation, namely Claim Matching, Topical Clustering, and Claim Relationship
Classification. SynDy utilizes LLMs and social media queries to automatically
generate distantly-supervised, topically-focused datasets with synthetic labels
on these three tasks, providing essential tools to scale up human-led
fact-checking at a fraction of the cost of human-annotated data. Training on
SynDy's generated labels shows improvement over a standard baseline and is not
significantly worse compared to training on human labels (which may be
infeasible to acquire). SynDy is being integrated into Meedan's chatbot
tiplines that are used by over 50 organizations, serve over 230K users
annually, and automatically distribute human-written fact-checks via messaging
apps such as WhatsApp. SynDy will also be integrated into our deployed
Co-Insights toolkit, enabling low-resource organizations to launch tiplines for
their communities. Finally, we envision SynDy enabling additional fact-checking
tools such as matching new misinformation claims to high-quality explainers on
common misinformation topics.
|
[
-0.3760712742805481,
-0.6899381875991821,
0.19945776462554932,
0.037912044674158096,
-0.08873853832483292,
0.4366973042488098,
-0.40902116894721985,
-0.49669724702835083,
0.868882954120636,
0.5536710619926453,
-0.7914199829101562,
-0.549403727054596,
-0.5191615223884583,
0.23141168057918549,
-0.48481518030166626,
1.1478666067123413,
0.22314700484275818,
-0.27456918358802795,
-0.14103052020072937,
-0.16675813496112823,
-0.11331649869680405,
-0.4205862879753113,
-0.319425493478775,
0.1851881444454193,
0.581963300704956,
0.920683741569519,
0.7272510528564453,
0.4738444983959198,
0.4213312268257141,
0.3271603286266327,
-0.03542674705386162,
0.6288220882415771,
-0.7207438349723816,
0.4802735447883606,
-0.31116634607315063,
-0.5887959599494934,
-0.3807185888290405,
0.20950493216514587,
0.5153629779815674,
0.7314102649688721,
-0.23136742413043976,
0.7747367024421692,
-0.15305587649345398,
0.3245622515678406,
-0.768398642539978,
-0.03797420114278793,
-0.7497293949127197,
-0.05536428466439247,
-0.7458256483078003,
0.07067271322011948,
-0.037081390619277954,
-0.33616700768470764,
-0.23122964799404144,
-0.6312105655670166,
0.5000593066215515,
0.23223994672298431,
0.4735642075538635,
0.13532179594039917,
-0.5180920362472534,
-0.33297470211982727,
-0.8449252247810364,
0.5819106101989746,
-0.5612368583679199,
0.43052804470062256,
0.15331625938415527,
0.3923209607601166,
-0.4463109076023102,
-1.0034242868423462,
-1.0430361032485962,
0.006558669731020927,
0.032679472118616104,
0.23245422542095184,
0.02624829113483429,
-0.07646896690130234,
0.5203415155410767,
0.19135694205760956,
-0.38570326566696167,
-0.05473656579852104,
-0.6007053256034851,
-0.3940877914428711,
0.6575722098350525,
0.32233741879463196,
0.18894727528095245,
-0.23041144013404846,
-0.09741028398275375,
-0.0911182090640068,
-0.8133882880210876,
-0.20863668620586395,
0.6199836730957031,
0.46534454822540283,
-0.33527126908302307,
0.6262954473495483,
-0.5525719523429871,
0.6822121739387512,
0.2908099293708801,
-0.5302117466926575,
0.23462232947349548,
-0.7313851118087769,
0.004764131270349026,
0.3771202564239502,
0.6882588863372803,
0.363238126039505,
-0.16366718709468842,
0.027393462136387825,
-0.18278856575489044,
0.35297146439552307,
0.13334675133228302,
-0.8304618000984192,
-0.15242092311382294,
-0.015559567138552666,
-0.4567427337169647,
-0.5048904418945312,
-0.020034391433000565,
-0.9234187006950378,
-0.800101637840271,
-0.36381298303604126,
-0.1631864756345749,
0.04411926493048668,
-0.49928170442581177,
-0.08235549181699753,
-0.20021416246891022,
-0.43151140213012695,
0.5165496468544006,
-0.7997220754623413,
0.1270487904548645,
0.5474228858947754,
0.7306652069091797,
-0.002739840652793646,
-0.08692002296447754,
-0.5912672281265259,
0.14993704855442047,
-0.43513014912605286,
0.5357712507247925,
-0.541450023651123,
-0.03188496083021164,
0.03483705595135689,
0.00024793954798951745,
0.0567704513669014,
-0.5634638071060181,
0.6740954518318176,
-0.47593486309051514,
-0.031697828322649,
-0.39724108576774597,
-0.3461424708366394,
0.10711472481489182,
0.46604377031326294,
-0.7588183283805847,
0.7956880331039429,
0.17783068120479584,
-1.0967189073562622,
0.3661789894104004,
-0.32708126306533813,
-0.40115609765052795,
0.14111508429050446,
-0.32817521691322327,
-0.19996273517608643,
-0.0582430325448513,
-0.025708213448524475,
0.15500524640083313,
-0.5255803465843201,
0.4575558602809906,
-0.5073372721672058,
0.005197243764996529,
0.26516076922416687,
-0.4882783591747284,
0.6520393490791321,
0.2968922555446625,
-0.25513944029808044,
0.08554520457983017,
-1.0074621438980103,
-0.36369478702545166,
-0.09410000592470169,
-0.39922764897346497,
-0.2733612656593323,
-0.1168816089630127,
-0.05610397830605507,
0.34445425868034363,
0.30277249217033386,
-1.0066193342208862,
0.09523110836744308,
-0.2901923358440399,
-0.010168319568037987,
0.26972419023513794,
0.11389973759651184,
0.18202272057533264,
-0.2732856273651123,
0.5360105037689209,
0.14336493611335754,
0.29638928174972534,
-0.07104206085205078,
-0.3755885660648346,
-0.808397114276886,
0.14707182347774506,
0.29566460847854614,
0.5253591537475586,
-0.9489789605140686,
0.3493385314941406,
-0.4299623370170593,
-0.5657373666763306,
-0.32507213950157166,
0.29197758436203003,
-0.05416250228881836,
0.624241828918457,
0.1608741283416748,
-0.03317165747284889,
-0.8502664566040039,
-0.9482901096343994,
-0.3905038833618164,
-0.10652289539575577,
0.28401416540145874,
-0.06734210252761841,
0.2249833196401596,
-0.2223474383354187,
1.0868760347366333,
-0.13544197380542755,
-0.13711494207382202,
-0.5004745721817017,
0.17402209341526031,
0.36162686347961426,
0.16516630351543427,
0.3365418314933777,
-0.8671196699142456,
-0.37858426570892334,
-0.09118975698947906,
-0.5277120471000671,
-0.11686019599437714,
-0.2779599130153656,
0.03144792467355728,
0.10858100652694702,
0.3899548649787903,
-0.9599922299385071,
0.3075813055038452,
0.6548900604248047,
-0.3341550827026367,
0.7342996597290039,
-0.02104240097105503,
0.19480040669441223,
-1.2760963439941406,
0.1478748619556427,
-0.05738028883934021,
-0.3858846426010132,
-0.6926840543746948,
-0.25168469548225403,
-0.0645626038312912,
-0.22910888493061066,
-0.3245333433151245,
0.42287030816078186,
-0.31431615352630615,
0.08655493706464767,
-0.3349364399909973,
0.30270200967788696,
-0.28604739904403687,
0.035622887313365936,
-0.3323071599006653,
0.562340497970581,
0.19421342015266418,
-0.4507724642753601,
0.8761659860610962,
0.26998987793922424,
-0.4787518084049225,
0.44838595390319824,
-0.17019766569137573,
-0.238857701420784,
-0.06648071110248566,
0.6425935626029968,
-0.7155546545982361,
-0.5171750783920288,
0.5027768611907959,
-0.36169472336769104,
0.22613254189491272,
-0.32843440771102905,
-0.7313082814216614,
-0.6427497267723083,
-0.04038010537624359,
0.30476096272468567,
0.2446887493133545,
-0.567852258682251,
0.4482816159725189,
0.6255720853805542,
-0.30350613594055176,
-0.7776913046836853,
-0.5612374544143677,
0.5051743984222412,
-0.17314757406711578,
-0.6537157893180847,
0.1394403874874115,
0.3319914937019348,
-0.4759402871131897,
-0.04780372604727745,
-0.28455430269241333,
0.3026648163795471,
0.007447727490216494,
0.3361617922782898,
0.07048968970775604,
-0.09398797154426575,
0.231628879904747,
0.14253373444080353,
-0.014893137849867344,
0.0947379618883133,
-0.26949459314346313,
0.4281598925590515,
0.17683212459087372,
-0.37778130173683167,
-0.3128739297389984,
0.045709799975156784,
0.5030491352081299,
-0.17475764453411102,
0.8859996199607849,
0.8166554570198059,
-0.2530441880226135,
-0.46275320649147034,
-0.7204874753952026,
-0.45930784940719604,
-0.4804302155971527,
0.3987957537174225,
-0.1625446230173111,
-0.7437973618507385,
0.4343359172344208,
-0.4857740104198456,
0.08606316149234772,
0.49090778827667236,
0.5037161111831665,
-0.07562732696533203,
0.5093622803688049,
0.4653961658477783,
-0.0980108380317688,
0.3339940905570984,
-0.14928209781646729,
0.37630242109298706,
-0.19566376507282257,
-0.1754680871963501,
-0.35513022541999817,
-0.5528742671012878,
-0.8342113494873047,
-0.7223900556564331,
0.5796818137168884,
-0.10517581552267075,
0.09366613626480103,
0.03277157247066498,
-0.06717976927757263,
0.2981792986392975,
0.5459744334220886,
-0.22334612905979156,
0.21884028613567352,
0.1761622428894043,
0.113154336810112,
0.055890925228595734,
-0.8542270064353943,
-0.25782790780067444,
1.0321074724197388,
0.17164544761180878,
1.0028232336044312,
0.09132621437311172,
0.6575722694396973,
0.6861566305160522,
0.38324815034866333,
-0.2873671054840088,
0.6111047267913818,
-0.15459893643856049,
-0.6859692335128784,
-0.2518775165081024,
-0.5119531154632568,
-0.7325328588485718,
0.027541207149624825,
-0.5352541208267212,
-0.530746340751648,
0.29273927211761475,
0.34698158502578735,
-0.2843582034111023,
0.5381474494934082,
-0.21591535210609436,
0.559869110584259,
-0.13493171334266663,
-0.3681745231151581,
-0.6810056567192078,
-0.7713518738746643,
0.5994637608528137,
-0.20998777449131012,
0.26028189063072205,
-0.336750328540802,
0.10697468370199203,
0.8315927386283875,
-0.5189177393913269,
1.2782518863677979,
-0.3688963055610657,
-0.1653020828962326,
0.4127504825592041,
0.19977478682994843,
0.6893847584724426,
0.17908410727977753,
-0.06603210419416428,
0.15727759897708893,
-0.12615424394607544,
0.07615934312343597,
-0.5577979683876038,
0.7232691049575806,
-0.5746818780899048,
-0.6563131213188171,
-0.14580577611923218,
-0.6647597551345825,
-0.12299302965402603,
0.2225257158279419,
0.020327990874648094,
0.5765870213508606,
-0.1489797681570053,
0.11775535345077515,
0.6078061461448669,
-0.2765258848667145,
0.017358221113681793,
0.4550790786743164,
-0.06055635213851929,
-0.4391241669654846,
0.9496842622756958,
0.23473700881004333,
0.06807775050401688,
0.27872171998023987,
-0.008868868462741375,
-0.21408642828464508,
-0.24482379853725433,
-0.6460028290748596,
0.2846423387527466,
-0.7806541323661804,
-0.4298543930053711,
-0.5958300828933716,
-0.210830420255661,
-0.5724256634712219,
0.2668057978153229,
-0.6949657201766968,
-0.9120325446128845,
0.14337603747844696,
-0.11447378247976303,
0.2835177481174469,
0.8488852977752686,
-0.3060761094093323,
0.21747128665447235,
-0.7099586129188538,
0.48293906450271606,
-0.1215270608663559,
0.10665486007928848,
-0.35268110036849976,
-0.34832650423049927,
-0.5801874399185181,
0.4495241641998291,
-0.3772304654121399,
-0.8313226103782654,
0.24332663416862488,
0.1434749960899353,
0.47388511896133423,
0.3931441605091095,
0.5081762075424194,
0.5806966423988342,
-0.18437568843364716,
0.6518628597259521,
0.27833524346351624,
-0.4998417794704437,
0.668732762336731,
-0.34571871161460876,
-0.19019189476966858,
0.4590356647968292,
0.367250919342041,
-0.9822342991828918,
-0.767171323299408,
-0.7262681126594543,
-0.686822235584259,
0.9245134592056274,
0.10158564150333405,
0.12759622931480408,
-0.015647830441594124,
0.32121214270591736,
0.3634176254272461,
0.24935008585453033,
-0.3163352608680725,
-0.4734811782836914,
0.03540452942252159,
-0.487824022769928,
-0.0012194958981126547,
-0.3697036802768707,
-0.40672898292541504,
-0.109871044754982,
0.6762633919715881,
-0.21488036215305328,
0.0220799557864666,
0.05895639955997467,
-0.1880740523338318,
-0.33927470445632935,
0.07516715675592422,
0.5344058275222778,
0.7098464369773865,
-0.046469591557979584,
0.26617729663848877,
0.1133144348859787,
-0.5998693704605103,
0.09422941505908966,
0.23645780980587006,
-0.3437434136867523,
0.2615310549736023,
0.3248845040798187,
0.7783424854278564,
-0.14348721504211426,
-0.5793959498405457,
0.502736508846283,
0.022386088967323303,
-0.15500810742378235,
-0.36898282170295715,
0.250261515378952,
0.1432226151227951,
0.27878907322883606,
0.20971599221229553,
0.2897551655769348,
0.007107558660209179,
-0.38313060998916626,
0.1904265284538269,
0.2922302186489105,
0.19592121243476868,
-0.549089252948761,
0.46904465556144714,
0.45299020409584045,
0.07329946756362915,
0.701919674873352,
-0.24716858565807343,
-0.3998155891895294,
0.5099331140518188,
0.5695134401321411,
0.4381910562515259,
-0.2007082849740982,
0.4048371911048889,
0.5677410364151001,
0.3000655174255371,
0.05009860172867775,
0.1379578709602356,
-0.32641175389289856,
-0.9784629940986633,
-0.27474164962768555,
-0.6554054021835327,
-0.3803980350494385,
0.18884199857711792,
-0.2408236414194107,
0.306287556886673,
-0.40236690640449524,
-0.41585031151771545,
0.019001472741365433,
0.2167344093322754,
-0.6370900869369507,
0.17398476600646973,
0.43411338329315186,
1.0275949239730835,
-0.9201565980911255,
0.653888463973999,
0.7594007849693298,
-0.1357623040676117,
-0.5309377908706665,
0.18993030488491058,
0.2812208831310272,
-0.4928804039955139,
0.8924593329429626,
0.10187923908233643,
-0.11563578993082047,
-0.21230322122573853,
-0.47418224811553955,
-1.1929408311843872,
0.9555534720420837,
0.5510451197624207,
-0.9141174554824829,
0.20748575031757355,
0.5728145241737366,
0.4373641014099121,
-0.20832251012325287,
0.06776119023561478,
0.4849598705768585,
0.5192869305610657,
0.1803971529006958,
-0.8886176347732544,
0.11620116233825684,
-0.20231281220912933,
-0.4120469093322754,
0.11594598740339279,
-0.7923427820205688,
0.6355809569358826,
-0.3192896544933319,
-0.32691359519958496,
-0.20107726752758026,
0.6809252500534058,
0.12177793681621552,
0.42453423142433167,
0.657458484172821,
0.4706220030784607,
1.0038317441940308,
0.09699500352144241,
0.8024749159812927,
-0.5813571214675903,
0.12416452914476395,
1.1897450685501099,
-0.26060977578163147,
0.32119059562683105,
0.34609901905059814,
-0.06869959086179733,
0.6128844022750854,
0.6316775679588318,
-0.022936396300792694,
0.1920774281024933,
0.3340489864349365,
-0.3658921718597412,
-0.24819089472293854,
-0.4117729961872101,
-0.12386439740657806,
0.5265352725982666,
0.7872229814529419,
-0.18238405883312225,
-0.33619165420532227,
0.029749922454357147,
-0.12941193580627441,
-0.014163308776915073,
0.015009768307209015,
0.5074592232704163,
-0.1421220898628235,
-0.5917888879776001,
0.5697003602981567,
0.305244117975235,
0.5350582003593445,
-0.4745713770389557,
0.06875566393136978,
-0.4877645671367645,
0.2738485634326935,
-0.29249057173728943,
-0.6300811171531677,
0.33645910024642944,
-0.011926346458494663,
-0.19303320348262787,
-0.0037756164092570543,
1.1543476581573486,
-0.8038074374198914,
-0.4880215525627136,
-0.015106681734323502,
0.5303090214729309,
0.010569341480731964,
0.20316173136234283,
-0.5921392440795898,
0.26941826939582825,
-0.03296850621700287,
-0.11283085495233536,
-0.018520623445510864,
0.5791144967079163,
-0.361383855342865,
0.7598258256912231,
0.6543223261833191,
0.5415804386138916,
0.042729754000902176,
0.2943539023399353,
0.9475896954536438,
-0.41598793864250183,
-0.5982148051261902,
-0.5977339148521423,
0.14191937446594238,
-0.44023948907852173,
0.030975304543972015,
0.9722668528556824,
0.6799963116645813,
0.7698180079460144,
0.07169913500547409,
0.9681439995765686,
-0.4308977723121643,
0.7437009215354919,
-0.20049194991588593,
0.7806088924407959,
-0.44051143527030945,
0.16595901548862457,
0.14725667238235474,
-0.8258802890777588,
-0.0809854194521904,
0.04490099474787712,
-0.13492080569267273,
-0.09372265636920929,
0.2847394049167633,
1.0461132526397705,
-0.40336355566978455,
0.2385450154542923,
0.15536314249038696,
0.5310667753219604,
0.3234538435935974,
0.02401280403137207,
0.9986457824707031,
-0.09023740887641907,
0.4558149576187134,
-0.33843928575515747,
-0.05652979388833046,
-0.30261942744255066,
-0.5299319624900818,
-0.8094558119773865,
-0.5173130631446838,
-0.36994582414627075,
-0.519753098487854,
0.19910219311714172,
1.1152745485305786,
0.765289306640625,
-0.7808256149291992,
-0.08148738741874695,
0.0005705205257982016,
0.16391688585281372,
0.23378673195838928,
-0.21868295967578888,
0.11869506537914276,
-0.4496619999408722,
-0.47105225920677185,
0.3737207353115082,
0.09403223544359207,
-0.11035770177841187,
-0.3186492323875427,
0.0297890305519104,
-0.005578913260251284,
-0.10620805621147156,
0.2860052287578583,
0.2569591999053955,
-0.509933352470398,
0.05641237273812294,
-0.44610995054244995,
-0.05512178689241409,
-0.2667851746082306,
1.049330472946167,
-0.8255375027656555,
0.48148471117019653,
0.3834783732891083,
0.7444975972175598,
0.38447508215904236,
0.09633146971464157,
0.43181633949279785,
-1.0601608753204346,
0.1947660893201828,
0.0939524844288826,
0.12316080182790756,
0.4459635019302368,
-0.43400412797927856,
0.22732338309288025,
0.7107210755348206,
-0.2522699534893036,
-0.7354000806808472,
0.11652656644582748,
-0.675849974155426,
-0.00021410119370557368,
1.174934983253479,
0.13564598560333252,
-0.30276283621788025,
-0.25683194398880005,
-0.02326110377907753,
0.47526487708091736,
-0.3199743330478668,
0.9480888247489929,
0.40180259943008423,
0.1308431774377823,
0.1015668734908104,
-0.3776286840438843,
0.7239203453063965,
0.13247069716453552,
-0.7745834589004517,
0.5186919569969177,
0.6220968961715698,
0.4452374577522278,
0.34961920976638794,
0.512080729007721,
0.23854872584342957,
0.2238754779100418,
0.30530959367752075,
0.17932087182998657,
-0.12215208262205124,
-0.47695428133010864,
0.21106083691120148,
-0.025731021538376808,
-0.31445300579071045,
-0.1490844190120697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10689v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10689v1
|
Revolutionizing Process Mining: A Novel Architecture for ChatGPT Integration and Enhanced User Experience through Optimized Prompt Engineering
| 2024-05-17T10:48:14 | 2024-05-17T10:48:14 |
Mehrdad Agha Mohammad Ali Kermani, Hamid Reza Seddighi, Mehrdad Maghsoudi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the rapidly evolving field of business process management, there is a
growing need for analytical tools that can transform complex data into
actionable insights. This research introduces a novel approach by integrating
Large Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, into process mining tools,
making process analytics more accessible to a wider audience. The study aims to
investigate how ChatGPT enhances analytical capabilities, improves user
experience, increases accessibility, and optimizes the architectural frameworks
of process mining tools. The key innovation of this research lies in developing
a tailored prompt engineering strategy for each process mining submodule,
ensuring that the AI-generated outputs are accurate and relevant to the
context. The integration architecture follows an Extract, Transform, Load (ETL)
process, which includes various process mining engine modules and utilizes
zero-shot and optimized prompt engineering techniques. ChatGPT is connected via
APIs and receives structured outputs from the process mining modules, enabling
conversational interactions. To validate the effectiveness of this approach,
the researchers used data from 17 companies that employ BehfaLab's Process
Mining Tool. The results showed significant improvements in user experience,
with an expert panel rating 72% of the results as "Good". This research
contributes to the advancement of business process analysis methodologies by
combining process mining with artificial intelligence. Future research
directions include further optimization of prompt engineering, exploration of
integration with other AI technologies, and assessment of scalability across
various business environments. This study paves the way for continuous
innovation at the intersection of process mining and artificial intelligence,
promising to revolutionize the way businesses analyze and optimize their
processes.
|
[
-0.49998679757118225,
-0.9039102792739868,
0.6344565153121948,
0.3458541929721832,
-0.1257629245519638,
0.3382493257522583,
-0.08720023185014725,
-0.5691587328910828,
-0.0812234953045845,
0.4530172049999237,
-0.9913052320480347,
-0.5077400803565979,
-0.3954564929008484,
-0.026663903146982193,
-0.04383327066898346,
0.7930011749267578,
-0.049270618706941605,
-0.016819648444652557,
0.16334062814712524,
0.18595314025878906,
-0.6243442893028259,
-0.7491750717163086,
-0.9737639427185059,
-0.26453325152397156,
0.04372139647603035,
0.3723054528236389,
0.709020733833313,
0.17268644273281097,
0.25945669412612915,
0.2979549169540405,
-0.05712505802512169,
0.15262319147586823,
-0.27997860312461853,
0.3655218482017517,
-0.0056462958455085754,
-0.3449608087539673,
-0.6088812947273254,
0.06052868068218231,
0.21555568277835846,
0.6500526070594788,
-0.2597957253456116,
0.1939784437417984,
0.3352898061275482,
0.463742196559906,
-0.18896982073783875,
0.6652953028678894,
-0.47948768734931946,
0.21513502299785614,
-0.2324998825788498,
-0.4842137396335602,
-0.453935444355011,
-0.119111567735672,
0.15513430535793304,
-0.1461269110441208,
0.0767228826880455,
0.4724601209163666,
0.6094325184822083,
0.3179301619529724,
0.04080984741449356,
-0.41467610001564026,
-0.6534568071365356,
0.566372811794281,
-0.8199899196624756,
0.07429993897676468,
-0.20921236276626587,
0.5979669094085693,
-0.4175296425819397,
-0.6889584064483643,
-0.32137829065322876,
-0.16433118283748627,
-0.07343921065330505,
0.15715335309505463,
-0.3335656523704529,
0.14645059406757355,
0.44850921630859375,
0.23961296677589417,
-0.6481311917304993,
0.2685328722000122,
-0.1116785854101181,
-0.15541580319404602,
0.41747692227363586,
0.3610929548740387,
0.5215702056884766,
0.03243669867515564,
-0.3457341194152832,
0.25177910923957825,
-0.24930836260318756,
0.21862319111824036,
0.2579376697540283,
0.5079280138015747,
0.14772658050060272,
0.48291122913360596,
-0.5042141079902649,
0.19789426028728485,
-0.20673169195652008,
0.4503309726715088,
0.20323997735977173,
-0.13811860978603363,
-0.3679487109184265,
0.2685125470161438,
0.7837015986442566,
0.1737959235906601,
0.09811726957559586,
-0.15181539952754974,
-0.2773717939853668,
-0.0937867984175682,
0.18047532439231873,
-1.0886231660842896,
-0.11172042787075043,
0.20466558635234833,
-0.47756674885749817,
-0.22233827412128448,
0.02156916819512844,
-0.8199034929275513,
-0.5595503449440002,
-0.3660304844379425,
0.15680497884750366,
-0.41956278681755066,
-0.21776145696640015,
-0.12915083765983582,
-0.32739362120628357,
0.6623527407646179,
0.32551220059394836,
-0.807253360748291,
0.26537150144577026,
1.1490243673324585,
1.0015039443969727,
-0.20405827462673187,
0.09113505482673645,
-0.7022274136543274,
-0.34014463424682617,
-0.23763695359230042,
1.0262306928634644,
-0.7569984793663025,
-0.6168642044067383,
0.24460740387439728,
-0.05820634216070175,
0.12319586426019669,
-0.6680978536605835,
0.9038074612617493,
-0.6610324382781982,
0.10880208760499954,
-0.009443623013794422,
-0.4807649552822113,
-0.34918567538261414,
0.45279011130332947,
-0.46576404571533203,
1.0829663276672363,
-0.14475329220294952,
-0.32900822162628174,
0.4239203631877899,
-1.0448933839797974,
-0.04620634391903877,
0.39479854702949524,
-0.23855558037757874,
-0.3512765169143677,
0.17289209365844727,
0.20679081976413727,
0.5276016592979431,
-0.33576419949531555,
0.010697852820158005,
-0.34976959228515625,
-0.08520370721817017,
0.4783439636230469,
-0.397100031375885,
0.6916282176971436,
0.6027615070343018,
-0.22148020565509796,
0.3416593670845032,
-0.7124150395393372,
0.0631401315331459,
-0.16944977641105652,
-0.04991663247346878,
0.15206480026245117,
0.031555626541376114,
0.1355188637971878,
0.18546153604984283,
0.24976710975170135,
-0.4272891581058502,
0.11740738898515701,
-0.4169565737247467,
0.5680809617042542,
0.703427255153656,
0.36476409435272217,
0.36755234003067017,
-0.1778077930212021,
0.590456485748291,
-0.18201138079166412,
0.2245652675628662,
-0.6053037047386169,
-0.556150496006012,
-0.5018482804298401,
-0.4299447536468506,
-0.06604550778865814,
0.7597875595092773,
-0.21909834444522858,
0.45831942558288574,
-0.18642626702785492,
-0.5861284136772156,
-0.3154721260070801,
0.014615415595471859,
-0.35931283235549927,
0.5736489295959473,
0.03377251699566841,
-0.5398455858230591,
-0.5666684508323669,
-0.6987332701683044,
-0.26993775367736816,
-0.11944809556007385,
-0.2959420382976532,
0.17671777307987213,
-0.06096237525343895,
-0.3985900580883026,
1.1515766382217407,
-0.4619165062904358,
0.050765328109264374,
-0.34626761078834534,
0.32494983077049255,
1.0233601331710815,
0.31257230043411255,
0.14941786229610443,
-0.524430513381958,
-0.6440587639808655,
0.16682478785514832,
-0.6735165119171143,
-0.31179356575012207,
-0.18909971415996552,
-0.35601696372032166,
0.26630744338035583,
0.3374813497066498,
-0.5888696312904358,
0.4046960473060608,
-0.0022565005347132683,
-0.35125231742858887,
0.754616379737854,
-0.1780572086572647,
0.3435169458389282,
-0.7595275044441223,
0.22812648117542267,
0.013851149939000607,
-0.17950616776943207,
-0.7918637990951538,
-0.07052747160196304,
-0.11626503616571426,
-0.753567636013031,
-0.1824198067188263,
0.3448259234428406,
-0.41225042939186096,
-0.062089577317237854,
-0.6022443175315857,
-0.17547382414340973,
-0.19420060515403748,
0.6842188239097595,
-0.06766578555107117,
0.8384633660316467,
0.6924229264259338,
-0.4613339304924011,
0.4104135036468506,
0.2009253352880478,
-0.3627419173717499,
0.6639609932899475,
-0.5498626232147217,
0.2003343552350998,
0.14171673357486725,
-0.1477803885936737,
-1.261549472808838,
-0.11227822303771973,
0.43889978528022766,
-0.6472374796867371,
0.22674226760864258,
-0.35591626167297363,
-0.5665819644927979,
-0.025645410642027855,
-0.30247142910957336,
-0.38532471656799316,
1.0676878690719604,
-0.42890000343322754,
0.9625168442726135,
0.24484826624393463,
-0.6977783441543579,
-0.07294628769159317,
-0.4818195104598999,
0.3453100919723511,
-0.45753851532936096,
-0.8675656318664551,
0.12096419185400009,
-0.047021135687828064,
-0.1444394439458847,
-0.21758809685707092,
-0.453486829996109,
-0.25053179264068604,
0.20686295628547668,
0.33784520626068115,
0.5909865498542786,
0.006316319108009338,
-0.24787795543670654,
-0.10207968950271606,
-0.41540467739105225,
0.4754996597766876,
-0.20560915768146515,
0.8485845327377319,
0.11442465335130692,
-0.31192660331726074,
-0.7773569226264954,
0.29174959659576416,
0.5898674130439758,
-0.20889703929424286,
0.5536141395568848,
0.6172248721122742,
-0.3704063296318054,
-0.20810991525650024,
-0.5079572796821594,
-0.11942679435014725,
-0.5474108457565308,
0.24789270758628845,
-0.3350050747394562,
-0.6132596731185913,
0.749075710773468,
-0.721932053565979,
0.4431762993335724,
0.19369298219680786,
0.6034694910049438,
-0.09371590614318848,
1.149390459060669,
0.6856143474578857,
-0.010303138755261898,
0.5138508081436157,
-0.009082869626581669,
0.5574741959571838,
-0.7011628150939941,
-0.33527716994285583,
-0.768945574760437,
-0.21667882800102234,
-0.6792415380477905,
-0.19732961058616638,
0.4780266582965851,
-0.1134520024061203,
-0.24958008527755737,
-0.19114656746387482,
-0.34732457995414734,
0.18696358799934387,
0.6339151859283447,
-0.11416303366422653,
0.21252132952213287,
0.044119153171777725,
0.1982404887676239,
0.043172601610422134,
-0.5578963756561279,
-0.8618727922439575,
0.7785128355026245,
0.44704458117485046,
0.7444829940795898,
-0.1537763923406601,
0.5983613729476929,
0.5741598606109619,
0.08797185868024826,
-0.9346675276756287,
0.6006849408149719,
0.359358012676239,
-0.23751884698867798,
-0.18644274771213531,
-0.11884423345327377,
-0.7542644143104553,
0.07724037766456604,
-0.06266181915998459,
-0.7803180813789368,
0.009436998516321182,
0.13984434306621552,
-0.3887809216976166,
0.02460210956633091,
-0.9703969359397888,
0.8083873391151428,
-0.17446079850196838,
-0.4123622477054596,
-0.2731612026691437,
-0.29882189631462097,
0.06268812716007233,
0.08502879738807678,
0.32594409584999084,
-0.13655441999435425,
0.036897867918014526,
0.5579171180725098,
-0.70335853099823,
0.805511474609375,
-0.3760012984275818,
0.02979484386742115,
0.2282942235469818,
-0.007218513637781143,
0.8306306004524231,
0.036965999752283096,
-0.213655486702919,
0.33174777030944824,
-0.16474992036819458,
-0.35365429520606995,
-0.7920123934745789,
0.5503212809562683,
-0.34546026587486267,
-0.6084840297698975,
-0.4784659147262573,
-0.12450939416885376,
-0.27488765120506287,
0.03114224784076214,
-0.18900197744369507,
0.1100744754076004,
-0.33371400833129883,
-0.16146275401115417,
0.7278886437416077,
-0.25276339054107666,
0.6197623014450073,
0.3336951732635498,
-0.06144392862915993,
-0.14717717468738556,
0.5667078495025635,
0.019723843783140182,
-0.14718616008758545,
0.22109833359718323,
0.07044089585542679,
-0.39174166321754456,
-0.57830810546875,
-0.31603357195854187,
-0.17079152166843414,
-0.5413877367973328,
0.03857940435409546,
-0.735567569732666,
-0.29250895977020264,
-0.45059117674827576,
-0.12202035635709763,
-0.1312170773744583,
-0.10752270370721817,
-0.08639120310544968,
0.019996458664536476,
0.19298848509788513,
0.008066858164966106,
0.11746710538864136,
0.5393506288528442,
-0.813503623008728,
0.007787215057760477,
0.2963337004184723,
0.3591626286506653,
0.08990611135959625,
-0.24857774376869202,
-0.14827919006347656,
-0.22894136607646942,
-0.3621281087398529,
-0.9220618605613708,
0.5133422613143921,
0.010016397573053837,
0.808219850063324,
0.508693516254425,
-0.1582944393157959,
0.42808985710144043,
-0.6380675435066223,
0.777222216129303,
-0.06460817158222198,
-0.8239151239395142,
0.6096946001052856,
-0.0989588275551796,
0.12374992668628693,
0.21498338878154755,
0.33794233202934265,
-0.9129204750061035,
0.043089546263217926,
-0.6630646586418152,
-1.1739734411239624,
0.8071038722991943,
0.09953838586807251,
0.07173314690589905,
0.18509380519390106,
0.3932456076145172,
0.4082312285900116,
0.11455409228801727,
-0.11627864837646484,
-0.18866777420043945,
0.1351182907819748,
-0.15804128348827362,
0.2325304001569748,
-0.32480937242507935,
0.22237245738506317,
0.35510608553886414,
0.9673720002174377,
0.0788189247250557,
0.2779799997806549,
-0.03994032368063927,
-0.14477212727069855,
0.3813369870185852,
0.4350127875804901,
-0.20119433104991913,
0.5747882723808289,
-0.07755980640649796,
-0.15178881585597992,
0.2518436908721924,
-0.360642671585083,
-0.27763819694519043,
0.2968937158584595,
-0.12373621761798859,
-0.004348903428763151,
0.15046007931232452,
0.812933087348938,
-0.17595864832401276,
-0.8206560611724854,
-0.06659380346536636,
0.011033095419406891,
0.19428718090057373,
-0.4343166649341583,
0.41705647110939026,
-0.18006792664527893,
0.7567864060401917,
0.5684166550636292,
0.11713214218616486,
0.6838067173957825,
-0.7309473156929016,
0.00843933504074812,
0.5827165246009827,
-0.2957795262336731,
-0.2342199683189392,
0.44629788398742676,
0.26269736886024475,
-0.6179899573326111,
0.7197601795196533,
-0.09397688508033752,
-0.40404558181762695,
0.2967020869255066,
0.06366846710443497,
1.0560499429702759,
-0.19834421575069427,
0.0089885788038373,
0.24677981436252594,
0.2546972632408142,
0.17124734818935394,
0.1854199469089508,
-0.3122241795063019,
-0.4865090548992157,
-0.5401341915130615,
-0.5648926496505737,
-0.7890942096710205,
-0.11576567590236664,
-0.255459189414978,
0.5923892855644226,
-0.4503744840621948,
-0.053337596356868744,
-0.032548099756240845,
0.22423523664474487,
-0.7445682883262634,
-0.10840977728366852,
0.22767750918865204,
0.8560488224029541,
-0.6788058280944824,
0.25668811798095703,
0.5060352087020874,
-0.33433276414871216,
-0.413396418094635,
-0.2776482105255127,
0.05024944245815277,
-1.0974935293197632,
0.4245585799217224,
0.47066596150398254,
0.13794569671154022,
0.02668140083551407,
-0.5120188593864441,
-0.39185968041419983,
0.9492026567459106,
-0.03857506439089775,
-0.5249392986297607,
0.28713932633399963,
0.2591443657875061,
0.3889519274234772,
-0.23425282537937164,
0.5863602757453918,
0.8760386109352112,
0.35979992151260376,
0.422193706035614,
-0.5764831900596619,
0.1574232280254364,
-0.46453729271888733,
0.09989754855632782,
0.18382126092910767,
-0.3218475878238678,
0.1233576312661171,
0.23082298040390015,
-0.5633491277694702,
-0.2024448961019516,
0.7362398505210876,
0.3179364502429962,
0.5568204522132874,
0.28760361671447754,
0.3049897849559784,
0.8451932668685913,
-0.014133526012301445,
0.653314471244812,
-0.2647624611854553,
0.03475514426827431,
0.9372914433479309,
-0.41347160935401917,
0.538360059261322,
0.3965485095977783,
-0.19578184187412262,
0.35903769731521606,
0.7706226706504822,
-0.017714841291308403,
0.2386517971754074,
0.10698039829730988,
-0.4751223027706146,
-0.18052271008491516,
-0.16358453035354614,
-0.024185150861740112,
0.09003888070583344,
0.36091798543930054,
-0.13382488489151,
-0.3265490233898163,
-0.07053237408399582,
0.1770620495080948,
-0.18649356067180634,
-0.3049152195453644,
0.8647645115852356,
-0.08384352922439575,
-0.5015624165534973,
0.01085235271602869,
-0.023227665573358536,
0.6839154958724976,
-0.7406735420227051,
-0.055196087807416916,
-0.39261969923973083,
-0.004043182823807001,
-0.21696780622005463,
-0.7452985644340515,
0.4426252245903015,
0.26704975962638855,
0.0922580435872078,
-0.46147099137306213,
0.7184139490127563,
0.15677829086780548,
-0.19816897809505463,
-0.1998426616191864,
0.5971629023551941,
0.3864113390445709,
-0.478664368391037,
-0.5779381394386292,
0.18031594157218933,
-0.003486168570816517,
-0.2865348756313324,
0.14406198263168335,
0.8905342817306519,
-0.04096635431051254,
0.657494306564331,
0.9469843506813049,
0.02154208905994892,
0.06301376968622208,
0.0685291439294815,
0.7618055939674377,
-0.8892369866371155,
-0.6889528632164001,
-1.2133839130401611,
0.7601758241653442,
-0.41565731167793274,
0.18138298392295837,
0.5297501087188721,
0.826454758644104,
0.2932750880718231,
0.09128692001104355,
0.9887263178825378,
-0.17067405581474304,
0.3678101897239685,
-0.4957108199596405,
0.4972112476825714,
0.13945189118385315,
0.40865403413772583,
-0.14262163639068604,
-1.0388859510421753,
-0.100560262799263,
0.20397700369358063,
-0.36703914403915405,
-0.14552900195121765,
0.43367451429367065,
0.9177685976028442,
0.031668346375226974,
0.24399763345718384,
0.13757246732711792,
0.2614860236644745,
0.9275742173194885,
0.3409343957901001,
0.7283748388290405,
-0.1927541196346283,
0.5588610768318176,
0.1363166719675064,
-0.8441251516342163,
-0.20729421079158783,
-0.9153798222541809,
-0.7483587265014648,
-0.30008670687675476,
-0.3068603277206421,
0.011608402244746685,
-0.2300771176815033,
0.9477245211601257,
0.41623061895370483,
-0.6474677324295044,
-0.3076920211315155,
-0.12202246487140656,
-0.18367861211299896,
-0.2658264935016632,
-0.26359882950782776,
0.22227129340171814,
-1.0082752704620361,
-0.9031305313110352,
0.34850743412971497,
0.7401517629623413,
-0.13727658987045288,
-0.15798206627368927,
0.039495550096035004,
0.23208940029144287,
0.06943173706531525,
0.5844416618347168,
0.28204867243766785,
-0.14425000548362732,
0.1361905038356781,
0.18575550615787506,
0.48224881291389465,
0.2554474472999573,
0.7566463947296143,
-0.6013393998146057,
0.2830454707145691,
0.7788230180740356,
0.9497418403625488,
0.7180400490760803,
-0.10000964254140854,
0.55549556016922,
-0.45012325048446655,
-0.011850292794406414,
0.09421301633119583,
0.3978940546512604,
0.1286669373512268,
-0.6065448522567749,
0.5879641175270081,
0.11183680593967438,
-0.6707042455673218,
-0.5962633490562439,
0.19992880523204803,
-1.2235468626022339,
-0.07397837191820145,
0.7287987470626831,
0.026398127898573875,
-0.33815816044807434,
-0.18427270650863647,
-0.6537299156188965,
0.3615480065345764,
-0.7146160006523132,
1.0139963626861572,
0.8443130254745483,
-0.7538994550704956,
-0.05121174827218056,
-0.773279070854187,
0.2923278510570526,
0.25357505679130554,
-0.9539211988449097,
0.2312728315591812,
0.5479792952537537,
0.07127445191144943,
-0.0642726793885231,
0.45804768800735474,
-0.09654054045677185,
0.06531403213739395,
-0.25757595896720886,
0.06823283433914185,
-0.19526509940624237,
0.23165716230869293,
-0.3927112817764282,
0.32292497158050537,
0.20370855927467346,
-0.2029317170381546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10659v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10659v2
|
Realistic Evaluation of Toxicity in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-17T09:42:59 | 2024-05-20T14:27:37 |
Tinh Son Luong, Thanh-Thien Le, Linh Ngo Van, Thien Huu Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have become integral to our professional
workflows and daily lives. Nevertheless, these machine companions of ours have
a critical flaw: the huge amount of data which endows them with vast and
diverse knowledge, also exposes them to the inevitable toxicity and bias. While
most LLMs incorporate defense mechanisms to prevent the generation of harmful
content, these safeguards can be easily bypassed with minimal prompt
engineering. In this paper, we introduce the new Thoroughly Engineered Toxicity
(TET) dataset, comprising manually crafted prompts designed to nullify the
protective layers of such models. Through extensive evaluations, we demonstrate
the pivotal role of TET in providing a rigorous benchmark for evaluation of
toxicity awareness in several popular LLMs: it highlights the toxicity in the
LLMs that might remain hidden when using normal prompts, thus revealing subtler
issues in their behavior.
|
[
-0.045407503843307495,
-0.8406203985214233,
0.8820725083351135,
0.2649063766002655,
-0.04268379881978035,
0.07782135903835297,
-0.1788865625858307,
-0.3814222514629364,
-0.2845957279205322,
0.4434346854686737,
-0.5190973281860352,
-0.7370136380195618,
-0.3849320113658905,
0.08434039354324341,
-0.2421111911535263,
1.0385005474090576,
0.08601830899715424,
-0.21875768899917603,
0.018951566889882088,
-0.006185953039675951,
-0.6832540035247803,
-0.37785911560058594,
-0.644281804561615,
-0.24577072262763977,
0.9742248058319092,
0.2844717502593994,
0.6922268867492676,
0.48628905415534973,
0.26034367084503174,
0.30030372738838196,
-0.4736223816871643,
-0.08747221529483795,
-0.7070043087005615,
0.35464853048324585,
-0.35252267122268677,
-0.16769643127918243,
-0.2862977385520935,
-0.04228922724723816,
0.482263445854187,
0.7580104470252991,
0.18352529406547546,
0.13172319531440735,
0.19863253831863403,
0.5322201251983643,
-0.6983310580253601,
0.1407855898141861,
-0.7325337529182434,
0.1687278151512146,
-0.20479069650173187,
-0.028996603563427925,
-0.8748337030410767,
-0.3515847623348236,
0.286083459854126,
-0.4648560583591461,
-0.5308078527450562,
-0.03129053860902786,
0.6560214757919312,
0.3223129212856293,
-0.6992365121841431,
-0.3233996629714966,
-0.7780107855796814,
0.8021805882453918,
-0.5129039287567139,
0.2552652955055237,
0.0014690021052956581,
0.4437674880027771,
-0.3269079923629761,
-0.5251286029815674,
-0.18124644458293915,
-0.633948802947998,
0.0190745759755373,
0.1179693266749382,
-0.2775512933731079,
0.28572675585746765,
0.34687498211860657,
0.06409014761447906,
-0.6025714874267578,
0.3224063515663147,
-0.19632957875728607,
-0.34093785285949707,
0.4724029004573822,
0.43914759159088135,
0.6352900862693787,
-0.1800929754972458,
-0.46306756138801575,
0.11284751445055008,
-0.9511606097221375,
-0.3714359700679779,
0.21073752641677856,
0.23249441385269165,
0.0012204035883769393,
0.5018371343612671,
-0.0019734918605536222,
0.491896390914917,
-0.46188727021217346,
0.27291035652160645,
0.07824969291687012,
-0.15128014981746674,
-0.2337484061717987,
-0.09458882361650467,
1.0264437198638916,
0.4395599365234375,
0.5507246851921082,
-0.17368082702159882,
-0.23941317200660706,
0.05705922842025757,
0.28754928708076477,
-0.7186998128890991,
0.013132690452039242,
0.37423306703567505,
-0.06126486882567406,
-0.5363626480102539,
-0.4012540578842163,
-0.7225340008735657,
-0.9008573889732361,
0.13326488435268402,
0.4905606508255005,
-0.4148464798927307,
-0.20566117763519287,
0.12742988765239716,
-0.07856202870607376,
-0.13101595640182495,
0.12924093008041382,
-0.3657614588737488,
-0.015397148206830025,
0.6869449615478516,
0.8307994604110718,
-0.09938082844018936,
-0.10772552341222763,
-0.5063117742538452,
0.12493064254522324,
-0.5271896719932556,
0.8835539817810059,
-0.6855254769325256,
-0.5297896862030029,
-0.06137550622224808,
-0.2444421648979187,
0.19959160685539246,
-0.6659837961196899,
1.0548843145370483,
-0.5035018920898438,
0.04649687930941582,
-0.7067617177963257,
-0.33199599385261536,
-0.11796911805868149,
0.37821629643440247,
-0.6582175493240356,
0.6951959729194641,
0.22609035670757294,
-0.8606823682785034,
0.25068899989128113,
-0.7967244386672974,
-0.28828150033950806,
0.1570875197649002,
0.23541966080665588,
-0.11160770058631897,
-0.04386525973677635,
-0.2062254548072815,
0.2930980324745178,
-0.39012065529823303,
0.4008985757827759,
-0.5807325839996338,
-0.5037689208984375,
0.33812934160232544,
-0.6953280568122864,
0.9993886947631836,
0.4952705204486847,
-0.10319682955741882,
0.3346664309501648,
-0.563342809677124,
-0.1828344613313675,
-0.0511990524828434,
-0.3300101161003113,
-0.4651434123516083,
-0.10584605485200882,
-0.10209997743368149,
0.40885868668556213,
0.05230658873915672,
-0.537116289138794,
-0.21335624158382416,
-0.3665776252746582,
0.5671767592430115,
1.0124096870422363,
0.2441851794719696,
0.19228264689445496,
-0.45816174149513245,
0.47367626428604126,
-0.02253764495253563,
0.38878118991851807,
-0.08994106203317642,
-0.24747106432914734,
-0.48666912317276,
-0.0972975566983223,
0.009716418571770191,
0.4729999005794525,
-0.6863100528717041,
0.470409631729126,
-0.41201484203338623,
-0.7643446326255798,
-0.1319754719734192,
-0.013503382913768291,
0.3797946870326996,
0.6871959567070007,
0.10833699256181717,
0.10807144641876221,
-0.34963279962539673,
-1.0686964988708496,
-0.4536520838737488,
-0.20525068044662476,
-0.3048543334007263,
0.4089570939540863,
0.3012767434120178,
-0.3330415189266205,
0.6436886191368103,
-0.3649282157421112,
0.11968740075826645,
-0.040230195969343185,
-0.08212865144014359,
0.1627289205789566,
0.20151585340499878,
0.476583868265152,
-0.12116678804159164,
-0.5876220464706421,
-0.07767146080732346,
-0.9650825262069702,
-0.6058220267295837,
-0.12460052967071533,
-0.333725243806839,
-0.1913888156414032,
0.39866065979003906,
-0.613770604133606,
-0.07803821563720703,
0.38231736421585083,
-0.3720293641090393,
0.7322642207145691,
0.011730942875146866,
0.06368625909090042,
-0.6815433502197266,
0.19666479527950287,
0.29727455973625183,
-0.09860710054636002,
-0.7439584732055664,
0.09195967018604279,
0.04726063087582588,
-0.06496002525091171,
-0.7804569602012634,
0.802828311920166,
-0.3861839175224304,
0.30810701847076416,
0.021907862275838852,
0.07956153154373169,
0.16042089462280273,
0.10024412721395493,
-0.10213615000247955,
0.7979462146759033,
0.4155297875404358,
-0.5938557386398315,
0.3904109597206116,
0.1428459733724594,
-0.3420013189315796,
0.5281778573989868,
-0.7749470472335815,
0.08579854667186737,
-0.0043360041454434395,
0.23634089529514313,
-0.7910574674606323,
-0.2631756663322449,
0.1276097595691681,
-0.1275392770767212,
0.1690945327281952,
-0.13973715901374817,
-0.6976760625839233,
-0.49649885296821594,
-0.4365459978580475,
0.4081296920776367,
0.6693188548088074,
-0.35311609506607056,
0.26979944109916687,
0.456676721572876,
-0.29483380913734436,
-0.3968350291252136,
-0.5650776624679565,
0.34193819761276245,
-0.5724896788597107,
-0.6849768161773682,
-0.16240274906158447,
-0.31096088886260986,
-0.44967758655548096,
-0.2714066505432129,
-0.10464834421873093,
0.06868167966604233,
0.30734384059906006,
0.29938364028930664,
0.258195161819458,
-0.1462634950876236,
0.3149344027042389,
0.14413942396640778,
-0.09641709923744202,
0.5080916881561279,
0.0852418914437294,
0.49444887042045593,
-0.10446324199438095,
-0.42756810784339905,
-0.29035109281539917,
0.16322541236877441,
0.7589873671531677,
-0.06475137174129486,
0.5554988384246826,
0.08690226823091507,
-0.4441014230251312,
-0.3927345871925354,
-0.47169727087020874,
0.017198888584971428,
-0.5870193243026733,
0.6461576223373413,
-0.09158457815647125,
-0.571168065071106,
0.6464994549751282,
-0.1642317771911621,
0.1572602391242981,
0.4764530062675476,
0.4703975319862366,
0.06697308272123337,
0.9830021858215332,
0.20992079377174377,
-0.008150885812938213,
0.37759530544281006,
0.23781783878803253,
0.03252138942480087,
-0.7281970381736755,
-0.18556703627109528,
-0.44999057054519653,
-0.009291848167777061,
-0.362382173538208,
-0.18016910552978516,
0.8002674579620361,
-0.35641127824783325,
-0.930351734161377,
-0.014737416058778763,
-0.464168906211853,
0.8341377973556519,
0.1718188375234604,
0.32672247290611267,
0.3622865378856659,
-0.1443071961402893,
-0.15526872873306274,
-0.06613435596227646,
-0.4980694651603699,
-0.9174922108650208,
0.890613317489624,
0.8343464136123657,
0.7869910597801208,
-0.08277053385972977,
0.45672687888145447,
0.23364949226379395,
0.6454414129257202,
-0.7487126588821411,
0.6295744776725769,
-0.04921739920973778,
-0.8964470028877258,
-0.18133726716041565,
-0.6625235676765442,
-0.6121952533721924,
0.04755837097764015,
0.019786454737186432,
-0.7069396376609802,
-0.11348102241754532,
0.014868594706058502,
-0.5990060567855835,
0.3744548559188843,
-1.0629370212554932,
0.8768889904022217,
-0.3097323477268219,
-0.6493702530860901,
0.14063549041748047,
-0.5327544808387756,
0.777209997177124,
-0.4179600179195404,
0.3651246130466461,
-0.1555718332529068,
-0.13945432007312775,
0.6106393933296204,
-0.38339561223983765,
0.9123973250389099,
-0.1163739562034607,
-0.4153296649456024,
0.4070681035518646,
0.6185628771781921,
0.5151591300964355,
0.04618468135595322,
-0.5149545073509216,
-0.08062770217657089,
-0.16091179847717285,
-0.34775498509407043,
-0.18429091572761536,
0.8526726961135864,
-0.4515732526779175,
-0.6358034014701843,
-0.31487295031547546,
-0.6882383227348328,
-0.5380250215530396,
0.35118648409843445,
0.19781360030174255,
0.10725264996290207,
-0.3777615427970886,
-0.030570626258850098,
0.9122044444084167,
-1.0587756633758545,
0.23898884654045105,
0.48152679204940796,
0.01720876805484295,
-0.05313161388039589,
0.9957315921783447,
0.05765540152788162,
0.5976157188415527,
-0.026976725086569786,
0.45032498240470886,
-0.3719955384731293,
-0.5951357483863831,
-0.32398179173469543,
0.25587156414985657,
-0.9346509575843811,
-0.2956148386001587,
-0.7580387592315674,
-0.3780793845653534,
-0.03138316050171852,
-0.0893457904458046,
-0.3632039725780487,
0.1411590427160263,
-0.121375672519207,
-0.42703235149383545,
0.3238210082054138,
1.1005247831344604,
0.12894275784492493,
0.16392162442207336,
-1.106010913848877,
-0.17842145264148712,
0.2643088400363922,
0.7188817262649536,
-0.0028836249839514494,
-0.4770076274871826,
0.11354532092809677,
0.21768881380558014,
-0.2983349859714508,
-1.069826602935791,
0.2195294201374054,
-0.08654345571994781,
0.5755141377449036,
0.3477625250816345,
0.4086405336856842,
0.18280036747455597,
-0.4586735963821411,
0.8036810159683228,
-0.17737331986427307,
-0.9433901906013489,
0.36063918471336365,
-0.7982272505760193,
0.1304924637079239,
0.5301424860954285,
0.4337151348590851,
-0.8024947047233582,
-0.5123310685157776,
-0.38901472091674805,
-0.7876183986663818,
0.46644163131713867,
0.06623613834381104,
0.49498552083969116,
-0.3364666998386383,
0.17192696034908295,
0.30040326714515686,
-0.11504577845335007,
-0.7924134135246277,
0.026989810168743134,
0.0927293673157692,
-0.23409201204776764,
0.2289944440126419,
-0.6256776452064514,
-0.06707261502742767,
0.06119607388973236,
0.5810819864273071,
0.3568691611289978,
-0.12447891384363174,
-0.1470666527748108,
-0.3280321955680847,
-0.1800386905670166,
0.5629184246063232,
0.40077000856399536,
0.2545888125896454,
-0.2745886743068695,
0.2508827745914459,
0.4172089397907257,
-0.37638890743255615,
0.2019372433423996,
-0.32026928663253784,
-0.27902358770370483,
-0.27616527676582336,
0.4868393838405609,
0.487516850233078,
0.12434589862823486,
-0.9549528956413269,
0.38814011216163635,
0.20736776292324066,
0.04649591073393822,
0.027017267420887947,
0.06950980424880981,
0.21384385228157043,
-0.03553032502532005,
-0.04637574777007103,
-0.1251930445432663,
0.32136622071266174,
-0.6602767109870911,
0.2919871211051941,
0.3457161784172058,
-0.6710077524185181,
-0.3395096957683563,
0.5544357299804688,
0.44229549169540405,
0.09290540963411331,
0.5475565195083618,
-0.19171036779880524,
-0.5840508937835693,
0.5048115253448486,
0.2818615734577179,
0.9537250995635986,
-0.2746311128139496,
0.23128846287727356,
0.409260630607605,
0.6084038615226746,
0.22497320175170898,
0.10293890535831451,
0.5941832065582275,
-0.5353550910949707,
-0.34467577934265137,
-0.6476231813430786,
-0.21286751329898834,
0.44544902443885803,
-0.2180611938238144,
0.30477777123451233,
-0.6469936370849609,
0.012636354193091393,
0.04442084580659866,
-0.25052788853645325,
-0.4212791323661804,
-0.0483536496758461,
0.20153355598449707,
1.1670944690704346,
-1.2219250202178955,
0.3911915421485901,
0.4122522175312042,
-0.3799411654472351,
-0.6549596786499023,
-0.07521094381809235,
0.1645180881023407,
-0.742189347743988,
0.5650352239608765,
0.21129122376441956,
0.02925635129213333,
-0.17629016935825348,
-0.4232271909713745,
-0.37081027030944824,
0.7026221752166748,
0.62525874376297,
-0.5857376456260681,
-0.07162605226039886,
0.3599776327610016,
0.7309564352035522,
0.08452252298593521,
0.7315207719802856,
0.6370657086372375,
0.7346240282058716,
0.12074924260377884,
-0.8301220536231995,
0.5068089365959167,
-0.3850441575050354,
-0.03604264557361603,
-0.11361871659755707,
-0.6508488655090332,
0.655829668045044,
-0.19855250418186188,
-0.5284304022789001,
-0.24178491532802582,
0.12396790087223053,
0.32326123118400574,
0.1982949823141098,
0.5872930884361267,
0.20420634746551514,
0.5856806039810181,
-0.06756395101547241,
1.0360443592071533,
0.064764104783535,
0.006261508911848068,
1.0575640201568604,
-0.6367517709732056,
0.3933650851249695,
0.16568998992443085,
-0.049094438552856445,
0.12441380321979523,
0.8478468656539917,
0.06713540852069855,
0.2760942876338959,
0.6169349551200867,
-0.4498313367366791,
-0.3428858816623688,
-0.5460063219070435,
-0.3127683401107788,
0.013894042931497097,
0.4595690667629242,
-0.36115527153015137,
-0.5376794338226318,
-0.04811643809080124,
0.21086359024047852,
0.16451409459114075,
-0.09864035993814468,
0.8239734768867493,
0.16962870955467224,
-0.3617459833621979,
0.5936269164085388,
-0.2941841185092926,
0.6749234199523926,
-0.30935510993003845,
0.02788091078400612,
-0.323885053396225,
-0.16911470890045166,
-0.23005180060863495,
-1.1566179990768433,
0.4258556365966797,
0.30005010962486267,
0.3047480583190918,
-0.13355091214179993,
0.6416434049606323,
-0.04128820821642876,
-0.30933648347854614,
0.4436606466770172,
0.41011491417884827,
0.035513218492269516,
-0.4505078196525574,
-0.5178977251052856,
0.18654510378837585,
-0.1697092056274414,
-0.5546082854270935,
0.10135224461555481,
0.7579427361488342,
-0.2703319787979126,
0.9916830062866211,
0.4908168315887451,
0.10739018768072128,
0.060297880321741104,
0.19245147705078125,
1.1480722427368164,
-0.665407657623291,
-0.11888203024864197,
-1.0114812850952148,
0.619293212890625,
-0.025614436715841293,
-0.08788587898015976,
0.44925564527511597,
0.5471124649047852,
0.3607426583766937,
0.09275054931640625,
0.942976176738739,
0.2723405957221985,
0.36798495054244995,
-0.34513232111930847,
1.0997892618179321,
-0.280981183052063,
0.8043363690376282,
-0.41533493995666504,
-0.8695527911186218,
-0.3892737925052643,
0.09618093073368073,
-0.4215807318687439,
0.33810222148895264,
0.6584787964820862,
0.9023757576942444,
0.008194326423108578,
-0.007221807725727558,
0.4266304075717926,
0.798733651638031,
0.48233726620674133,
0.8936783671379089,
1.330190658569336,
-0.1474572718143463,
0.6030336022377014,
-0.2370050549507141,
-0.36947694420814514,
-0.017261574044823647,
-1.1413825750350952,
-0.9880998730659485,
-0.36935317516326904,
-0.14647728204727173,
-0.5047326683998108,
0.19149090349674225,
0.951341986656189,
0.267939031124115,
-0.6560803055763245,
0.14493528008460999,
0.011481249704957008,
0.3089021146297455,
0.283678263425827,
-0.18357107043266296,
0.15576913952827454,
-0.20728956162929535,
-0.5463387966156006,
0.2729755640029907,
0.26504671573638916,
0.16116461157798767,
-0.16720327734947205,
-0.03513660654425621,
0.18100212514400482,
0.25213491916656494,
0.7906054854393005,
0.09925314784049988,
-0.4141661822795868,
-0.5957088470458984,
0.0940067246556282,
-0.3993377387523651,
-0.20074352622032166,
0.3667227625846863,
-0.5312722325325012,
0.3419951796531677,
0.7616305351257324,
0.4527648985385895,
-0.2473665177822113,
-0.3300516605377197,
0.8109328150749207,
-0.5891722440719604,
-0.18289095163345337,
0.5559172630310059,
0.30936872959136963,
0.3079807758331299,
-0.6014941930770874,
0.42229321599006653,
-0.11573172360658646,
-0.4490657448768616,
-1.146317720413208,
0.2738516926765442,
-0.9466738104820251,
-0.24626602232456207,
1.4833881855010986,
-0.10175685584545135,
-0.26013481616973877,
-0.26809418201446533,
-0.3402961790561676,
0.25169894099235535,
-0.3701916038990021,
0.8622551560401917,
0.8058966398239136,
0.4107859432697296,
0.058492399752140045,
-0.9640188217163086,
0.4897456765174866,
0.2824135720729828,
-1.0396976470947266,
0.5654580593109131,
0.6356891989707947,
0.6849376559257507,
-0.0901951938867569,
0.3142867684364319,
-0.4639721214771271,
0.13605400919914246,
-0.09299272298812866,
0.0009913807734847069,
-0.16391538083553314,
-0.19117456674575806,
-0.20184530317783356,
-0.043356020003557205,
0.391093909740448,
0.2713738977909088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10650v7
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10650v7
|
SPOR: A Comprehensive and Practical Evaluation Method for Compositional Generalization in Data-to-Text Generation
| 2024-05-17T09:25:30 | 2024-06-19T18:09:32 |
Ziyao Xu, Houfeng Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Compositional generalization is an important ability of language models and
has many different manifestations. For data-to-text generation, previous
research on this ability is limited to a single manifestation called
Systematicity and lacks consideration of large language models (LLMs), which
cannot fully cover practical application scenarios. In this work, we propose
SPOR, a comprehensive and practical evaluation method for compositional
generalization in data-to-text generation. SPOR includes four aspects of
manifestations (Systematicity, Productivity, Order invariance, and Rule
learnability) and allows high-quality evaluation without additional manual
annotations based on existing datasets. We demonstrate SPOR on two different
datasets and evaluate some existing language models including LLMs. We find
that the models are deficient in various aspects of the evaluation and need
further improvement. Our work shows the necessity for comprehensive research on
different manifestations of compositional generalization in data-to-text
generation and provides a framework for evaluation.
|
[
-0.1441061943769455,
-0.7986707091331482,
0.37695083022117615,
0.6941142678260803,
-0.40470537543296814,
-0.11063047498464584,
-0.6864433288574219,
-0.08821236342191696,
0.1281338483095169,
0.4992295801639557,
-0.22102901339530945,
-0.7839691638946533,
-0.7294745445251465,
0.17446163296699524,
-0.8750872015953064,
1.5257394313812256,
-0.18122433125972748,
-0.15549468994140625,
-0.670404851436615,
-0.07760581374168396,
-0.5429139733314514,
-0.3774036765098572,
-0.06543038785457611,
-0.1358933448791504,
0.4150884747505188,
0.5430421233177185,
0.2120911031961441,
0.8198555111885071,
0.7878156900405884,
0.26279202103614807,
0.09281747788190842,
0.2328091412782669,
-0.741326093673706,
0.27193930745124817,
-0.15179283916950226,
-0.19693350791931152,
-0.4335901141166687,
-0.30006924271583557,
0.9754490256309509,
0.9413989186286926,
-0.2668846845626831,
0.36917367577552795,
-0.08097352832555771,
0.6211168169975281,
-0.5694323182106018,
0.20087336003780365,
-0.5873053073883057,
0.04312855005264282,
-0.15472298860549927,
-0.15624214708805084,
-0.7123560905456543,
-0.6008132696151733,
0.25291964411735535,
-0.5073863863945007,
0.3113994300365448,
-0.08421383053064346,
0.5356374382972717,
0.20192906260490417,
-0.5466427803039551,
-0.7959194183349609,
-1.1115425825119019,
0.8557602167129517,
-0.48964443802833557,
0.3145536780357361,
-0.10446517914533615,
0.49537909030914307,
0.11701720952987671,
-1.2194159030914307,
-0.6960517168045044,
-0.6585052609443665,
-0.09425690770149231,
0.4361410439014435,
0.066070556640625,
0.04211009293794632,
0.07872537523508072,
0.7194786667823792,
-0.5102429986000061,
-0.5614075660705566,
-0.3594682514667511,
-0.04088471829891205,
0.8241109251976013,
0.12402453273534775,
0.32346466183662415,
0.1112951710820198,
-0.422543466091156,
-0.08780203014612198,
-0.38071760535240173,
-0.3661792576313019,
0.4193909466266632,
0.37392932176589966,
-0.04415882006287575,
0.7154844403266907,
-0.1288108378648758,
0.7991685271263123,
0.06866364181041718,
-0.27488771080970764,
0.06262481957674026,
-0.575954258441925,
-0.1715518683195114,
-0.3291924297809601,
0.6931099891662598,
0.30849501490592957,
0.05726383998990059,
-0.5921056270599365,
-0.34169498085975647,
0.44909268617630005,
0.21179965138435364,
-0.9274188280105591,
0.04007932171225548,
0.18264789879322052,
-0.47716259956359863,
-0.41557666659355164,
0.3384750783443451,
-0.8689362406730652,
-0.11610216647386551,
-0.29942232370376587,
0.4111182689666748,
-0.29721713066101074,
-0.3229660987854004,
0.24968263506889343,
-0.10655207186937332,
-0.0034015292767435312,
0.02629978582262993,
-0.7125188708305359,
0.501747190952301,
0.8570775985717773,
0.4902196526527405,
-0.5829980373382568,
-0.5136849284172058,
-0.3130987584590912,
0.16407957673072815,
-0.3070808947086334,
0.8813440203666687,
-0.6518081426620483,
-0.6208431720733643,
0.054112114012241364,
-0.4012328088283539,
-0.3052183985710144,
-0.5765595436096191,
0.8089986443519592,
-0.1687331646680832,
0.29335102438926697,
0.08841781318187714,
-0.8538312315940857,
-0.0822649821639061,
0.1361193060874939,
-0.5037407875061035,
1.1568280458450317,
0.12453026324510574,
-0.8297592401504517,
0.7609580755233765,
-0.5887195467948914,
-0.8741601705551147,
0.052934594452381134,
-0.39214083552360535,
-0.5870935916900635,
0.3886026442050934,
-0.25651052594184875,
0.6280556917190552,
-0.4662993848323822,
0.8947671055793762,
-0.009242519736289978,
-0.2683919668197632,
0.3286929726600647,
-0.17940641939640045,
0.10242792963981628,
0.2671210765838623,
-0.3466213345527649,
0.354500949382782,
-1.0456035137176514,
-0.1662362515926361,
0.15507912635803223,
-0.44906535744667053,
0.019531821832060814,
0.27037370204925537,
0.07299593091011047,
-0.0078093307092785835,
0.5329074859619141,
-0.3247886002063751,
0.13053345680236816,
-0.524799108505249,
-0.14409245550632477,
0.49900367856025696,
0.0010932167060673237,
0.6397518515586853,
-0.3500284254550934,
0.48511818051338196,
-0.01455854345113039,
0.12582959234714508,
-0.22461427748203278,
-0.28181061148643494,
-1.162402629852295,
-0.6134997010231018,
0.17259888350963593,
0.33002787828445435,
-0.5868918299674988,
0.6946637034416199,
-0.5120870471000671,
-0.8282662034034729,
0.052939269691705704,
0.04212513938546181,
0.3705908954143524,
0.45453912019729614,
0.17551074922084808,
-0.4484652280807495,
-0.4761536121368408,
-0.8408558964729309,
-0.16876594722270966,
0.21728289127349854,
0.028576241806149483,
0.2015381157398224,
0.4481319785118103,
-0.3766644299030304,
1.1308680772781372,
-0.43059754371643066,
0.12882839143276215,
-0.7136504650115967,
0.07442371547222137,
0.06029914692044258,
0.2925337255001068,
0.40930789709091187,
-0.40813788771629333,
-0.5352264642715454,
0.27850791811943054,
-0.7497872710227966,
-0.3051459491252899,
-0.021096518263220787,
-0.10104045271873474,
-0.11204149574041367,
0.10601094365119934,
-0.265077143907547,
0.4078608751296997,
0.5519604086875916,
-0.32223010063171387,
0.45067188143730164,
-0.2509099245071411,
-0.16373103857040405,
-1.1452367305755615,
0.5274578928947449,
0.07861542701721191,
-0.07261499762535095,
-1.0775294303894043,
0.5118554830551147,
-0.06692501902580261,
-0.34070268273353577,
-0.045525483787059784,
0.5035057067871094,
-0.08714324980974197,
-0.08435654640197754,
-0.33877259492874146,
-0.018021855503320694,
0.016091126948595047,
0.03414851799607277,
0.11268722265958786,
0.6567043662071228,
0.7482089400291443,
-0.780792236328125,
0.3076021075248718,
-0.09995070844888687,
-0.15846692025661469,
0.4292674958705902,
-0.745612382888794,
0.2479032427072525,
-0.547866940498352,
0.4527662396430969,
-0.8578476905822754,
-0.20889481902122498,
0.3037661612033844,
-0.11425799131393433,
0.2709839642047882,
0.1473122388124466,
-0.5128231644630432,
-0.11422740668058395,
-0.127507746219635,
0.29026299715042114,
-0.0332573726773262,
-0.15958891808986664,
0.8961028456687927,
0.13628390431404114,
-0.14895135164260864,
-0.39103999733924866,
-0.43743112683296204,
-0.13299083709716797,
-0.5180081725120544,
-0.7573980689048767,
0.22156833112239838,
-0.36691731214523315,
-0.06828202307224274,
-0.5704103708267212,
-0.3169876039028168,
-0.050205688923597336,
-0.09003029018640518,
0.13734452426433563,
0.23143424093723297,
0.037796519696712494,
-0.1548837423324585,
0.14488084614276886,
-0.22468186914920807,
-0.13098907470703125,
-0.011777211911976337,
0.6166318655014038,
0.13395105302333832,
-0.3365517854690552,
-0.3378279209136963,
0.43225595355033875,
0.4515374004840851,
-0.3357457220554352,
0.40281128883361816,
0.3705748915672302,
-0.2675378620624542,
-0.6005767583847046,
-0.481935977935791,
-0.19801528751850128,
-0.3934854567050934,
0.5340952277183533,
-0.31561198830604553,
-0.5219454765319824,
0.5191383957862854,
-0.2783825397491455,
0.11129767447710037,
0.44159135222435,
0.6520215272903442,
0.47645822167396545,
0.8339741826057434,
0.6369673609733582,
0.170466348528862,
0.4669647812843323,
-0.346341609954834,
0.24209189414978027,
-0.28036636114120483,
-0.3696763515472412,
-0.5372107028961182,
0.08350171893835068,
-0.46267011761665344,
-0.5189581513404846,
0.16308945417404175,
-0.0942596048116684,
-0.10529032349586487,
0.3507973253726959,
-0.7705925107002258,
0.2724558413028717,
0.07853430509567261,
-0.012815234251320362,
0.3895357549190521,
0.3006243109703064,
-0.13511300086975098,
-0.05535334348678589,
-0.6102448105812073,
-0.7858438491821289,
1.3160676956176758,
0.4442104697227478,
0.4945492744445801,
-0.15486346185207367,
0.8062266111373901,
0.21226367354393005,
0.771577775478363,
-0.9387658834457397,
0.7173182368278503,
-0.5512579679489136,
-0.6829249262809753,
0.022912276908755302,
-0.614162266254425,
-0.5938665270805359,
0.10787064582109451,
-0.02275804989039898,
-0.46491190791130066,
0.026893682777881622,
-0.11378797888755798,
0.03136105462908745,
-0.2352755218744278,
-0.7980283498764038,
0.7135122418403625,
-0.20185263454914093,
-0.29382455348968506,
-0.033637382090091705,
-0.49309900403022766,
0.3482533097267151,
-0.15765249729156494,
0.10149835050106049,
0.05560620129108429,
0.11962024867534637,
0.803021252155304,
-0.42274343967437744,
0.6363091468811035,
-0.3067788779735565,
-0.22011546790599823,
0.3679223954677582,
0.012430397793650627,
0.6672757863998413,
0.11399729549884796,
-0.32013896107673645,
-0.018958769738674164,
-0.033561039716005325,
-0.22204910218715668,
-0.6253883838653564,
0.43526485562324524,
-0.6089764833450317,
-0.03487330675125122,
-0.32651981711387634,
-0.5508603453636169,
-0.15186792612075806,
0.14307944476604462,
0.20068509876728058,
0.3114280104637146,
-0.3874777853488922,
0.051629163324832916,
0.3256548345088959,
-0.2161206156015396,
0.08919499069452286,
0.40051397681236267,
-0.5205668210983276,
-0.6217426061630249,
1.3571021556854248,
-0.018579132854938507,
0.13410744071006775,
0.2301737517118454,
0.40922844409942627,
-0.21731513738632202,
-0.6624475717544556,
-0.5259391665458679,
0.1603274941444397,
-0.6961395740509033,
-0.1467578113079071,
-0.5012034177780151,
0.008995350450277328,
-0.11317221075296402,
-0.07357180118560791,
-0.5320650339126587,
-0.44861096143722534,
-0.22935603559017181,
-0.08506344258785248,
0.13830462098121643,
0.8661070466041565,
0.181435227394104,
0.5792276859283447,
-0.2960782051086426,
0.3590667247772217,
0.2792150378227234,
0.29553961753845215,
-0.01252567395567894,
-0.44928833842277527,
-0.22245417535305023,
-0.13529172539710999,
-0.35552558302879333,
-0.7658849954605103,
0.06921963393688202,
0.47389107942581177,
0.5924568176269531,
0.589272141456604,
-0.24543629586696625,
0.7361648082733154,
-0.35695981979370117,
0.4614102840423584,
0.16498138010501862,
-1.1923298835754395,
0.4956679344177246,
-0.32756492495536804,
-0.3107531666755676,
0.7023048400878906,
-0.033369630575180054,
-0.5414044260978699,
-0.3202848434448242,
-0.4276917576789856,
-1.0902208089828491,
0.5270810127258301,
0.33509090542793274,
0.20575854182243347,
0.007867624051868916,
0.43252116441726685,
0.5351153016090393,
0.4544041156768799,
-0.8554579615592957,
-0.5764988660812378,
-0.3491479754447937,
-0.34228596091270447,
0.12319247424602509,
-0.2093869298696518,
-0.2317899465560913,
-0.11067080497741699,
0.39099013805389404,
-0.03072551265358925,
0.33266356587409973,
0.0073632593266665936,
-0.12446071207523346,
0.1312756985425949,
0.3643837571144104,
0.7277879118919373,
0.915208101272583,
-0.1014862209558487,
-0.11100323498249054,
0.2850225269794464,
-0.37653473019599915,
0.10248201340436935,
0.27666857838630676,
-0.3214551508426666,
0.050608519464731216,
0.3602275550365448,
0.7475804090499878,
-0.07248850166797638,
-0.45139452815055847,
0.7629397511482239,
-0.0843256488442421,
-0.004266735166311264,
-0.05807947739958763,
-0.009068001993000507,
-0.2234696000814438,
-0.19566042721271515,
0.4942103624343872,
-0.034861017018556595,
0.28063786029815674,
-0.6122961640357971,
0.33402448892593384,
0.0684317871928215,
-0.14823323488235474,
-0.4164178669452667,
0.3538335859775543,
0.19840598106384277,
0.19131383299827576,
-0.004441685974597931,
-0.3194885849952698,
-0.3313465118408203,
0.569367527961731,
0.8446749448776245,
0.7221781015396118,
-0.15749509632587433,
0.2734297513961792,
0.24415676295757294,
0.09550487995147705,
-0.13448786735534668,
0.27665573358535767,
-0.1710304319858551,
-0.6659229397773743,
-0.5780952572822571,
-0.7663944363594055,
-0.3469681143760681,
-0.1727224737405777,
-0.6302110552787781,
0.3293343484401703,
-0.5388452410697937,
-0.011710891500115395,
-0.0732450783252716,
-0.013714120723307133,
-0.6796016693115234,
0.5255154371261597,
-0.09660094231367111,
0.6585249304771423,
-0.9809067249298096,
0.5416267514228821,
0.8965854048728943,
-0.41620421409606934,
-0.7149192094802856,
0.21262118220329285,
-0.6511825919151306,
-0.5534911155700684,
0.6423938274383545,
0.19642217457294464,
0.01432293001562357,
-0.0777936801314354,
-0.389434278011322,
-0.394661009311676,
1.047616958618164,
0.5157859921455383,
-0.5173400044441223,
0.14423853158950806,
0.5031279921531677,
0.7082205414772034,
-0.6979669332504272,
0.4893905520439148,
0.6505468487739563,
0.6949891448020935,
0.2212803214788437,
-0.6159796118736267,
0.07488597929477692,
-0.12650740146636963,
0.21912284195423126,
-0.043304309248924255,
-0.6799418330192566,
0.4072591960430145,
0.25564420223236084,
-0.5426080226898193,
0.15905646979808807,
0.7522028088569641,
0.5437385439872742,
0.838616132736206,
0.2650727927684784,
0.6370247602462769,
0.6157709360122681,
-0.10054196417331696,
0.9115822911262512,
-0.6099645495414734,
0.6737590432167053,
1.0084706544876099,
-0.6204347014427185,
0.5277453660964966,
0.4402577579021454,
-0.19778567552566528,
0.2360992133617401,
0.07557258009910583,
0.09127097576856613,
0.49999314546585083,
0.7036260962486267,
-0.7039124965667725,
0.04093995317816734,
-0.15068289637565613,
-0.4296317994594574,
0.6243357062339783,
0.33450326323509216,
-0.4191250503063202,
-0.2475486397743225,
-0.07364191859960556,
0.11880549788475037,
0.3329280912876129,
-0.05261560529470444,
0.9082010388374329,
-0.3071814775466919,
-0.5421974658966064,
0.2461816817522049,
0.22239835560321808,
0.7867551445960999,
-0.6068480014801025,
0.2503000795841217,
-0.45244935154914856,
0.10260484367609024,
-0.36130645871162415,
-0.3272934854030609,
0.5713762044906616,
0.2478971928358078,
-0.23934361338615417,
-0.0980176106095314,
0.8862053155899048,
-0.41929104924201965,
-0.988602876663208,
0.34313225746154785,
0.45890167355537415,
0.057531118392944336,
0.03883408010005951,
-0.30536118149757385,
0.23998160660266876,
0.027505483478307724,
-0.09744750708341599,
-0.07047723978757858,
0.5318043231964111,
0.1903448849916458,
0.5133971571922302,
0.5895746946334839,
0.31071576476097107,
0.06744467467069626,
0.27761051058769226,
1.0154767036437988,
-0.5488695502281189,
-0.14412380754947662,
-0.6802532076835632,
0.655859112739563,
0.03795827925205231,
-0.15394873917102814,
0.7575688362121582,
0.9651665687561035,
0.7486799955368042,
-0.11478011310100555,
1.0783569812774658,
-0.3326381742954254,
0.47717708349227905,
-0.07521205395460129,
0.6280688047409058,
-0.2853241562843323,
0.12907171249389648,
-0.4309113323688507,
-1.3361443281173706,
-0.6516675353050232,
0.6886557936668396,
-0.4524464011192322,
0.2616806626319885,
0.7728689312934875,
0.8515254855155945,
-0.3018184006214142,
-0.05432737246155739,
0.43391674757003784,
-0.06265558302402496,
0.16223257780075073,
0.052882738411426544,
0.9603099226951599,
-0.5772836804389954,
0.5942811965942383,
-0.30651426315307617,
-0.2967042326927185,
-0.11233299225568771,
-0.8500320911407471,
-0.7904546856880188,
-0.562684178352356,
-0.24442483484745026,
-0.22537744045257568,
0.21633188426494598,
0.7780698537826538,
0.6704093813896179,
-0.7577571868896484,
-0.48956528306007385,
-0.48538896441459656,
-0.23893766105175018,
0.02984163723886013,
-0.2462557852268219,
0.2189999371767044,
-0.23523320257663727,
-0.7482423782348633,
0.4856298267841339,
0.3541068434715271,
-0.2074146419763565,
-0.29326334595680237,
-0.11490323394536972,
0.18140362203121185,
0.19685578346252441,
0.8187218308448792,
-0.07492466270923615,
-0.31343719363212585,
-0.07962612062692642,
-0.19224785268306732,
0.0831780955195427,
0.05650368705391884,
1.097725749015808,
-0.25290656089782715,
0.6036606431007385,
0.62434983253479,
0.4360453188419342,
0.566883385181427,
0.08758220076560974,
0.6360735297203064,
-0.9672802090644836,
0.24073590338230133,
0.23467816412448883,
0.21318556368350983,
0.38122671842575073,
0.021452423185110092,
0.2668735980987549,
0.13233977556228638,
-0.6886507272720337,
-0.7608906626701355,
0.38901153206825256,
-1.0314630270004272,
0.2751365303993225,
1.1832823753356934,
-0.20892652869224548,
0.07063519209623337,
0.25324440002441406,
-0.29639843106269836,
0.7135664820671082,
-0.5182415843009949,
0.7561869025230408,
0.5308157205581665,
0.19065295159816742,
0.2792193293571472,
-0.38254162669181824,
0.07304156571626663,
0.47630929946899414,
-1.0287939310073853,
0.1988937258720398,
0.46080297231674194,
0.2684929072856903,
0.11299377679824829,
0.29419049620628357,
0.02360251359641552,
-0.08285073190927505,
-0.022227350622415543,
0.19537462294101715,
0.15456657111644745,
-0.5297767519950867,
-0.26322534680366516,
0.23955848813056946,
0.17243598401546478,
0.012335860170423985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10637v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10637v2
|
Layer-Condensed KV Cache for Efficient Inference of Large Language Models
| 2024-05-17T08:59:46 | 2024-06-04T00:08:10 |
Haoyi Wu, Kewei Tu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Huge memory consumption has been a major bottleneck for deploying
high-throughput large language models in real-world applications. In addition
to the large number of parameters, the key-value (KV) cache for the attention
mechanism in the transformer architecture consumes a significant amount of
memory, especially when the number of layers is large for deep language models.
In this paper, we propose a novel method that only computes and caches the KVs
of a small number of layers, thus significantly saving memory consumption and
improving inference throughput. Our experiments on large language models show
that our method achieves up to 26$\times$ higher throughput than standard
transformers and competitive performance in language modeling and downstream
tasks. In addition, our method is orthogonal to existing transformer
memory-saving techniques, so it is straightforward to integrate them with our
model, achieving further improvement in inference efficiency. Our code is
available at https://github.com/whyNLP/LCKV.
|
[
-0.2587638795375824,
-0.5453914999961853,
0.5363576412200928,
0.30053019523620605,
-0.1351144164800644,
-0.24129781126976013,
-0.481960654258728,
-0.22987081110477448,
-0.0363403744995594,
0.8277126550674438,
-0.24758093059062958,
-0.4384761154651642,
-0.2112758308649063,
-0.6530677080154419,
-0.1408105045557022,
0.3778289258480072,
0.122726209461689,
-0.12028022855520248,
-0.3552109897136688,
-0.004426705185323954,
-0.3720552623271942,
-0.19415272772312164,
-0.44214051961898804,
-0.3527117073535919,
0.437505841255188,
0.5867031812667847,
0.29782676696777344,
0.5039188265800476,
0.3382636308670044,
0.3262403607368469,
-0.22332961857318878,
0.053836461156606674,
-0.5206950306892395,
0.45036715269088745,
-0.034068960696458817,
-0.6946341395378113,
-0.342957079410553,
-0.31718501448631287,
0.7636321187019348,
0.44892799854278564,
-0.1051672101020813,
0.24475529789924622,
-0.1380944401025772,
0.8988712430000305,
-1.2997080087661743,
0.3570433259010315,
-0.7471595406532288,
0.09165147691965103,
-0.14344826340675354,
0.07060651481151581,
-1.0851210355758667,
0.06331045180559158,
0.3153506815433502,
-0.4670819044113159,
0.3952634036540985,
-0.30926570296287537,
0.607536256313324,
0.3740609884262085,
-0.15993426740169525,
0.2867572605609894,
-1.057323694229126,
1.0450738668441772,
-0.6763794422149658,
0.8434211015701294,
0.33528953790664673,
0.5383665561676025,
0.21272417902946472,
-1.0052727460861206,
-0.557845413684845,
-0.35442832112312317,
-0.022641848772764206,
0.3846907317638397,
-0.035759732127189636,
0.17029953002929688,
0.2543599605560303,
0.23768675327301025,
-0.24657976627349854,
-0.07033858448266983,
-0.1769116073846817,
-0.23771432042121887,
0.23470991849899292,
0.14214499294757843,
-0.09901929646730423,
-0.2063867598772049,
-0.11374480277299881,
-0.3864300549030304,
-0.6350237727165222,
0.07363146543502808,
0.10545101761817932,
0.4067535698413849,
-0.08145245164632797,
0.29266297817230225,
-0.4477183520793915,
0.3593555986881256,
0.01817840151488781,
-0.10274279862642288,
0.05834367498755455,
-0.060105498880147934,
-0.35593700408935547,
0.14004041254520416,
0.5030518770217896,
0.20861594378948212,
0.33159270882606506,
-0.41960594058036804,
0.09547141939401627,
0.22337669134140015,
0.5185924172401428,
-1.0641528367996216,
-0.6545860171318054,
0.2459842562675476,
-0.24512235820293427,
-0.14006008207798004,
-0.23142623901367188,
-0.8890267014503479,
-0.14250507950782776,
-0.016668595373630524,
0.23200921714305878,
-0.14934614300727844,
-0.09492301195859909,
0.22720758616924286,
-0.045089658349752426,
0.28892701864242554,
0.2565881013870239,
-0.7942905426025391,
0.36513057351112366,
0.4183700978755951,
0.5218015909194946,
-0.023898353800177574,
0.01880386844277382,
-0.7343323230743408,
0.2550753951072693,
-0.14395029842853546,
0.6077603697776794,
-0.7352750301361084,
-0.15462616086006165,
-0.1001933142542839,
-0.1475720852613449,
-0.015918374061584473,
-0.527500331401825,
0.6863404512405396,
-0.9621460437774658,
-0.24923375248908997,
-0.46060505509376526,
-0.3964797854423523,
-0.05467212200164795,
0.1578458845615387,
-1.049644112586975,
1.3252476453781128,
-0.07032494992017746,
-0.600052535533905,
0.08791851252317429,
-0.22481049597263336,
-0.47271397709846497,
-0.09391746670007706,
0.021272895857691765,
-0.5825875997543335,
0.14313896000385284,
0.45764392614364624,
0.4882829189300537,
-0.4917971193790436,
0.20110370218753815,
-0.18683268129825592,
-0.2494409680366516,
0.05579135939478874,
-0.5041698813438416,
0.48643773794174194,
0.09526807814836502,
-0.4444694519042969,
-0.054825879633426666,
-0.7602746486663818,
0.030181029811501503,
0.07488200068473816,
-0.3160461187362671,
-0.4285890460014343,
0.10894886404275894,
-0.036854397505521774,
0.2275521159172058,
0.19238263368606567,
-0.6032981872558594,
0.19324301183223724,
-0.26351305842399597,
0.4254409968852997,
0.6209250688552856,
-0.15718208253383636,
0.8259567022323608,
0.1822458952665329,
0.43609729409217834,
0.4678163528442383,
0.13080242276191711,
-0.36131271719932556,
-0.3363940417766571,
-1.2503561973571777,
-0.25447940826416016,
0.5001935958862305,
0.31063568592071533,
-0.7702953219413757,
0.321639746427536,
-0.42783433198928833,
-0.6220093369483948,
-0.7046492695808411,
-0.08795695751905441,
0.5318320989608765,
0.6125383973121643,
0.44498908519744873,
-0.09038778394460678,
-0.43376031517982483,
-1.1081514358520508,
-0.13058234751224518,
-0.14452390372753143,
0.03200748935341835,
0.7081031203269958,
0.3529199957847595,
0.10125813633203506,
0.884453535079956,
-0.641287624835968,
0.05363721773028374,
-0.20157453417778015,
-0.026548495516180992,
-0.07904525846242905,
0.5581145882606506,
0.160212442278862,
-0.5841752290725708,
-0.6417255997657776,
0.04809435084462166,
-0.264117956161499,
-0.18016207218170166,
-0.17033788561820984,
-0.4418507218360901,
0.10821107029914856,
0.5559040904045105,
-0.9588243961334229,
0.1321701556444168,
0.5421615839004517,
0.054392699152231216,
0.6137728691101074,
-0.1636480987071991,
-0.028186706826090813,
-0.8920084834098816,
0.31334784626960754,
-0.1550816297531128,
-0.18212735652923584,
-0.6501728296279907,
0.22187818586826324,
0.54341059923172,
0.17900393903255463,
-0.5635321140289307,
0.6616436839103699,
-0.5001161098480225,
0.12835274636745453,
-0.04905632510781288,
0.11317294090986252,
0.22412319481372833,
0.7071954011917114,
-0.08751286566257477,
0.7334247827529907,
0.5968999266624451,
-0.6208203434944153,
0.09526394307613373,
-0.008282101713120937,
-0.3113915026187897,
0.10313002020120621,
-0.45773831009864807,
0.37874647974967957,
-0.16162888705730438,
0.5274474620819092,
-0.9891964197158813,
0.06994130462408066,
-0.04530782252550125,
-0.13456860184669495,
0.36462363600730896,
-0.277863472700119,
-0.5893619060516357,
-0.40053099393844604,
-0.18900497257709503,
0.607876181602478,
0.6543068885803223,
-0.6634137034416199,
0.9961483478546143,
0.4224092662334442,
0.28184401988983154,
-0.6706534624099731,
-0.785389244556427,
-0.12643392384052277,
0.0011372924782335758,
-0.6613379120826721,
0.443425714969635,
0.04855074733495712,
0.1219097226858139,
-0.06186938285827637,
-0.361344575881958,
-0.1182456687092781,
-0.18714983761310577,
-0.0378974974155426,
0.02447546273469925,
-0.66041499376297,
0.16359233856201172,
0.06327153742313385,
-0.34615790843963623,
-0.005035892594605684,
-0.49090856313705444,
0.8259194493293762,
-0.1321377456188202,
-0.3711896240711212,
-0.420570433139801,
0.23390275239944458,
0.8162540793418884,
-0.44656941294670105,
0.8154579401016235,
0.4277285039424896,
-0.2716635465621948,
-0.6027195453643799,
-0.8957251310348511,
-0.25336310267448425,
-0.5102423429489136,
0.376788467168808,
-0.40122851729393005,
-0.8761870861053467,
0.9517037272453308,
0.019985143095254898,
-0.205991730093956,
0.421572744846344,
0.5282624959945679,
0.23726056516170502,
1.024459719657898,
0.25167450308799744,
-0.43556419014930725,
0.4116213619709015,
-0.4301081895828247,
0.38231542706489563,
-0.843127965927124,
-0.14104585349559784,
-0.6634406447410583,
-0.3775881230831146,
-0.519831120967865,
-0.8520840406417847,
0.22490528225898743,
0.0538465641438961,
-0.2924199104309082,
0.27039074897766113,
-0.3683614730834961,
0.7242411375045776,
0.5705596208572388,
0.27357956767082214,
0.39397430419921875,
-0.16263559460639954,
-0.370218962430954,
-0.15463781356811523,
-0.7354465126991272,
-0.10975439101457596,
0.841507077217102,
0.310788094997406,
0.897762656211853,
-0.1475508064031601,
0.30599477887153625,
-0.24797621369361877,
0.16107000410556793,
-0.7671459913253784,
0.621634304523468,
-0.259461373090744,
-0.5689536929130554,
-0.18138925731182098,
-0.5115076303482056,
-0.5957198143005371,
0.35103872418403625,
0.26388686895370483,
-0.9141642451286316,
0.1060953289270401,
0.5097925662994385,
-0.25634998083114624,
0.39546090364456177,
-0.8602970242500305,
0.8829196095466614,
0.25882744789123535,
-0.48539453744888306,
-0.3811957836151123,
-0.7647837996482849,
0.45513784885406494,
0.16131973266601562,
-0.5213695168495178,
0.3031524419784546,
0.15652808547019958,
0.47576433420181274,
-0.25559771060943604,
0.8955642580986023,
-0.31216520071029663,
-0.0271755438297987,
0.34123075008392334,
-0.006057569291442633,
1.0301252603530884,
0.025148116052150726,
-0.11516115069389343,
-0.08099846541881561,
-0.5265669226646423,
-0.4198473393917084,
-0.7471604347229004,
0.7826966047286987,
-0.6392384767532349,
-0.3498480021953583,
0.19408854842185974,
-0.6372010707855225,
-0.24936066567897797,
0.271348237991333,
0.09461990743875504,
0.34156686067581177,
-0.028554368764162064,
0.602085530757904,
1.1400526762008667,
-0.41924628615379333,
0.3511110842227936,
0.5270541906356812,
0.0855136290192604,
-0.0845189243555069,
0.8199238777160645,
0.22033612430095673,
0.591404378414154,
0.8542799353599548,
0.32096466422080994,
-0.19250857830047607,
-0.3693995773792267,
-0.3061562180519104,
0.17593879997730255,
-0.8356381058692932,
-0.18155577778816223,
-1.114659070968628,
-0.4344766438007355,
-0.24689708650112152,
-0.12628427147865295,
-1.1011126041412354,
-0.387440949678421,
0.07382828742265701,
0.14284513890743256,
0.3582611680030823,
0.03519541770219803,
0.5128817558288574,
0.5730445384979248,
-0.8393812775611877,
0.44732844829559326,
0.47617876529693604,
0.5788662433624268,
0.6316367983818054,
-0.30457720160484314,
-0.4545033276081085,
-0.16405142843723297,
-0.22772811353206635,
-0.3306720554828644,
0.18921709060668945,
0.029795965179800987,
0.5027784109115601,
0.3783379793167114,
0.28979939222335815,
0.8918678164482117,
-0.596994936466217,
0.7234607338905334,
-0.23604749143123627,
-1.0367697477340698,
0.18676522374153137,
-0.16168689727783203,
0.8022294640541077,
0.6279205083847046,
-0.23507724702358246,
-0.4604071378707886,
-0.5793332457542419,
-0.6623014807701111,
-1.1409687995910645,
0.7117154598236084,
0.3477441370487213,
0.21973930299282074,
0.02580852061510086,
0.08976337313652039,
-0.2595939636230469,
-0.0721387043595314,
-0.4582502245903015,
-0.343798965215683,
0.1114041730761528,
-0.03367404639720917,
0.13786087930202484,
-0.3189840018749237,
0.3184960186481476,
-0.4602224826812744,
0.7165052890777588,
-0.04076661169528961,
0.3594529330730438,
0.04310312122106552,
-0.38389912247657776,
-0.24539296329021454,
0.18581122159957886,
0.6669912934303284,
0.32637515664100647,
-0.16790466010570526,
0.4654844403266907,
0.3398968279361725,
-0.7914367914199829,
-0.11115795373916626,
-0.1375412940979004,
-0.1889742612838745,
-0.07250038534402847,
0.048424214124679565,
0.964780867099762,
0.5448311567306519,
-0.6742500066757202,
0.3298978805541992,
-0.21782292425632477,
-0.0016576868947595358,
-0.09437406808137894,
0.06486822664737701,
0.5948193073272705,
0.440760999917984,
0.16360868513584137,
0.022894397377967834,
0.003958874847739935,
0.06693366169929504,
0.255148708820343,
0.3270208537578583,
-0.28348278999328613,
-0.27010712027549744,
0.6050417423248291,
0.13949131965637207,
0.054637107998132706,
0.7289507985115051,
0.17401123046875,
-0.5911058783531189,
0.6096569895744324,
0.5641946196556091,
1.225610375404358,
-0.3062620759010315,
0.023930402472615242,
0.3063053786754608,
0.35261300206184387,
-0.1787893921136856,
0.08191332966089249,
-0.4465029239654541,
-0.7496463656425476,
-0.7046722173690796,
-0.7685639262199402,
-0.28026336431503296,
0.4693918824195862,
-0.5511888265609741,
0.06579875200986862,
-0.06576491892337799,
0.20226982235908508,
0.10308495908975601,
-0.07182810455560684,
-0.719054639339447,
0.11737838387489319,
0.14451421797275543,
1.0396467447280884,
-0.8461552262306213,
1.2284834384918213,
0.16540294885635376,
-0.04131574183702469,
-0.7732070684432983,
0.12896016240119934,
-0.4835461378097534,
-0.6171332001686096,
0.6410224437713623,
0.2969188094139099,
-0.30951324105262756,
0.10685320198535919,
-0.430001825094223,
-0.900810182094574,
0.8162312507629395,
0.5094643831253052,
-0.5888925194740295,
-0.06992407143115997,
0.2064334899187088,
0.47361502051353455,
-0.17173783481121063,
0.22130881249904633,
0.7844905853271484,
0.6155816316604614,
0.12347641587257385,
-0.5632971525192261,
0.06574494391679764,
-0.3520953357219696,
0.3369024395942688,
0.5880302786827087,
-0.6042277812957764,
0.7474257349967957,
0.00287890643812716,
-0.08072074502706528,
-0.12222500890493393,
0.9224522709846497,
0.2469172328710556,
-0.22484026849269867,
0.5072959065437317,
0.8729218244552612,
0.49924907088279724,
0.1408330351114273,
0.9652159214019775,
-0.41286128759384155,
0.5065022706985474,
1.0906943082809448,
-0.24531537294387817,
0.8712672591209412,
0.5165795087814331,
-0.05440770089626312,
0.17219007015228271,
0.08258356153964996,
0.26337289810180664,
0.6965416073799133,
0.15596145391464233,
-0.40858137607574463,
-0.4297446608543396,
0.06364108622074127,
-0.17253249883651733,
0.4217343032360077,
0.20949460566043854,
-0.4663158059120178,
-0.31398189067840576,
-0.2128322869539261,
-0.06090303137898445,
-0.41241708397865295,
-0.11016412079334259,
0.5936663150787354,
0.037718892097473145,
-0.9446723461151123,
0.5375790596008301,
-0.13002216815948486,
0.31071266531944275,
-0.4802398085594177,
-0.07683625817298889,
-0.0425906665623188,
0.6840681433677673,
0.15718285739421844,
-0.4164844751358032,
0.054096005856990814,
-0.1287553906440735,
-0.5346468091011047,
-0.25069597363471985,
0.7233152985572815,
-0.6540859937667847,
-0.5366166234016418,
0.33390599489212036,
0.15947102010250092,
-0.21565409004688263,
-0.24297639727592468,
-0.2101069837808609,
0.007938205264508724,
-0.3125564455986023,
-0.5952829718589783,
0.3036588132381439,
0.3896770775318146,
-0.0459887720644474,
0.5028897523880005,
0.543164849281311,
-0.06572073698043823,
0.38061848282814026,
0.3617705702781677,
1.1170674562454224,
-0.5948610901832581,
-0.8054737448692322,
-0.8923733830451965,
0.9375101923942566,
-0.10363250970840454,
-0.15043535828590393,
0.5637925267219543,
0.6308582425117493,
0.6666631102561951,
-0.2489783614873886,
0.6634777188301086,
0.19470332562923431,
0.09738387912511826,
-0.6931723356246948,
0.908831775188446,
-0.2730930745601654,
0.24394972622394562,
-0.3595674932003021,
-0.9222429990768433,
-0.26469430327415466,
0.41984647512435913,
-0.18572357296943665,
0.10009155422449112,
0.7147460579872131,
0.9672411680221558,
-0.4330524802207947,
0.024724777787923813,
0.32295629382133484,
0.5362094640731812,
0.41934770345687866,
0.5168519020080566,
0.5261797308921814,
-0.5036389231681824,
0.5066257119178772,
-0.652838408946991,
-0.07792721688747406,
-0.395303875207901,
-0.9836853742599487,
-0.8131133913993835,
-0.5043622255325317,
-0.10613015294075012,
-0.33854013681411743,
-0.1291043609380722,
0.40334734320640564,
0.9618023037910461,
-0.8811299800872803,
-0.08615970611572266,
-0.338971346616745,
-0.06482017785310745,
-0.24611160159111023,
-0.2675197124481201,
0.471663236618042,
-0.41898104548454285,
-0.5407233238220215,
0.24526217579841614,
0.31735357642173767,
-0.45459645986557007,
-0.5289037227630615,
-0.026205921545624733,
-0.0892450362443924,
0.1741100698709488,
0.7786672115325928,
-0.03682669624686241,
-0.8539238572120667,
-0.3301845192909241,
0.30728408694267273,
-0.22007018327713013,
0.3169052004814148,
1.0306750535964966,
-0.9011154174804688,
0.7412665486335754,
0.8335570693016052,
0.9660385847091675,
1.1591931581497192,
-0.3309389650821686,
0.6051070690155029,
-1.0457632541656494,
0.2625473439693451,
0.3374159336090088,
0.2946431338787079,
0.11419472098350525,
-0.3906690180301666,
-0.024575762450695038,
0.051823001354932785,
-0.5159530639648438,
-0.7935376763343811,
0.21004782617092133,
-1.3233095407485962,
-0.1237562969326973,
0.9234747290611267,
0.0498381145298481,
-0.4928339421749115,
0.11378222703933716,
-0.06696079671382904,
0.46653029322624207,
-0.6702110171318054,
0.8044594526290894,
0.52693110704422,
0.41183140873908997,
-0.479439377784729,
-0.775561511516571,
0.36863383650779724,
0.4923545718193054,
-0.6082093715667725,
0.5088016986846924,
0.13530667126178741,
-0.11715946346521378,
0.28428414463996887,
0.4023688733577728,
0.054048214107751846,
0.29621899127960205,
0.09431381523609161,
0.16681526601314545,
0.256921648979187,
-0.6555587649345398,
0.009150332771241665,
0.22946752607822418,
-0.31199660897254944,
-0.07669252157211304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10630v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10630v1
|
Medical Dialogue: A Survey of Categories, Methods, Evaluation and Challenges
| 2024-05-17T08:46:15 | 2024-05-17T08:46:15 |
Xiaoming Shi, Zeming Liu, Li Du, Yuxuan Wang, Hongru Wang, Yuhang Guo, Tong Ruan, Jie Xu, Shaoting Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper surveys and organizes research works on medical dialog systems,
which is an important yet challenging task. Although these systems have been
surveyed in the medical community from an application perspective, a systematic
review from a rigorous technical perspective has to date remained noticeably
absent. As a result, an overview of the categories, methods, and evaluation of
medical dialogue systems remain limited and underspecified, hindering the
further improvement of this area. To fill this gap, we investigate an initial
pool of 325 papers from well-known computer science, and natural language
processing conferences and journals, and make an overview. Recently, large
language models have shown strong model capacity on downstream tasks, which
also reshaped medical dialog systems' foundation. Despite the alluring
practical application value, current medical dialogue systems still suffer from
problems. To this end, this paper lists the grand challenges of medical dialog
systems, especially of large language models.
|
[
-0.34738388657569885,
-0.5179468393325806,
0.9818732738494873,
0.02469560317695141,
-0.09006646275520325,
0.39771655201911926,
0.004434443544596434,
-0.5519716739654541,
0.0986284464597702,
0.47133177518844604,
-0.7061604261398315,
-0.16920159757137299,
-0.7888414859771729,
0.42561379075050354,
-0.16957205533981323,
0.9996804594993591,
0.009414266794919968,
0.5023038983345032,
-0.21918262541294098,
-0.24358396232128143,
-0.5945507884025574,
-0.6684058904647827,
-0.5638762712478638,
-0.2339397817850113,
0.2327641248703003,
0.09737872332334518,
0.4614700973033905,
-0.0714004784822464,
0.9177260398864746,
0.40042123198509216,
-0.315736323595047,
0.25508570671081543,
-0.21475306153297424,
0.4658913314342499,
-0.07692798227071762,
-0.231491357088089,
-0.24801458418369293,
-0.20375320315361023,
0.6322140097618103,
1.134137749671936,
-0.2253233790397644,
0.06547913700342178,
-0.1188277080655098,
0.6202734708786011,
-0.3170199692249298,
0.13420705497264862,
-0.25224292278289795,
0.03269046172499657,
-0.08714500069618225,
-0.18078945577144623,
-0.2840403616428375,
-0.33020949363708496,
0.647274911403656,
-0.330228716135025,
0.010817646980285645,
0.025801993906497955,
0.5888513326644897,
0.02998407371342182,
-0.4964347183704376,
-0.5872854590415955,
-0.9269277453422546,
0.782941997051239,
-0.7515357732772827,
0.08809815347194672,
0.19294658303260803,
0.36314666271209717,
-0.23670148849487305,
-0.5591219663619995,
-0.14697052538394928,
-0.29053357243537903,
0.26991498470306396,
-0.002492757048457861,
-0.3389164209365845,
0.244490846991539,
0.18348941206932068,
0.5906455516815186,
-0.3049387037754059,
0.058798518031835556,
-0.6935941576957703,
-0.0458807572722435,
0.3800399899482727,
0.7479071021080017,
0.44379836320877075,
-0.09037676453590393,
0.06299681216478348,
0.2885221540927887,
-0.5560559630393982,
-0.2294582575559616,
-0.19057218730449677,
-0.14552931487560272,
0.03692023828625679,
0.5830231308937073,
-0.18821829557418823,
0.7840017676353455,
-0.15193355083465576,
-0.3542536795139313,
0.07641404122114182,
-0.6794872283935547,
-0.33795061707496643,
-0.5711780786514282,
0.9352651834487915,
0.5442347526550293,
-0.2068033218383789,
0.21897123754024506,
-0.06136030703783035,
-0.0649489089846611,
0.35506778955459595,
-0.4017663896083832,
0.17967447638511658,
0.424102246761322,
-0.620983898639679,
-0.2023959755897522,
-0.41781556606292725,
-0.4664067029953003,
-0.591659426689148,
-0.09267271310091019,
-0.03428882732987404,
-0.2904914319515228,
-0.16444367170333862,
0.28149622678756714,
-0.05294074863195419,
-0.15917687118053436,
0.828419029712677,
-0.6427338123321533,
0.41558894515037537,
0.6306617259979248,
0.6869893670082092,
0.038597702980041504,
0.4701806306838989,
-0.04216867312788963,
-0.3110955059528351,
-0.1994348168373108,
0.7757434248924255,
-0.7626467943191528,
-0.7313613891601562,
0.10339561104774475,
0.133014515042305,
-0.2420782595872879,
-0.9483064413070679,
0.47140270471572876,
-0.047385092824697495,
0.44218909740448,
-0.26800641417503357,
-0.5710418820381165,
-0.0008038135129027069,
0.31951844692230225,
-0.29392537474632263,
0.3554885983467102,
0.041082996875047684,
-0.627271294593811,
-0.019385498017072678,
-0.7378291487693787,
-0.20327617228031158,
0.29238978028297424,
-0.37673598527908325,
-0.09797579795122147,
0.4111954867839813,
0.09335672110319138,
0.17549127340316772,
-0.9954236745834351,
0.6287692785263062,
-0.07471328973770142,
-0.21192525327205658,
0.4166748821735382,
-0.2037212997674942,
0.8404520153999329,
0.6152856349945068,
-0.04652847722172737,
0.22424720227718353,
-0.6306912302970886,
-0.09141244739294052,
-0.033495694398880005,
-0.18172965943813324,
-0.20866085588932037,
0.07573218643665314,
-0.04247809574007988,
0.1778775453567505,
0.03813043236732483,
-0.6332818269729614,
0.49569782614707947,
-0.34818390011787415,
0.7196531891822815,
0.33310356736183167,
0.21895438432693481,
0.10232694447040558,
-0.4037081003189087,
0.8142876625061035,
0.05320758745074272,
0.3844984173774719,
-0.37195202708244324,
-0.7615535259246826,
-0.6293169260025024,
-0.09658215194940567,
0.3789558708667755,
0.659227192401886,
-0.8541876077651978,
0.3680858910083771,
-0.05518611520528793,
-0.47698330879211426,
-0.6507164239883423,
-0.17322735488414764,
0.44347140192985535,
0.34523478150367737,
-0.041953254491090775,
-0.5739461779594421,
-0.3634423017501831,
-1.016318917274475,
0.01931842975318432,
-0.487859845161438,
-0.14867471158504486,
0.5226031541824341,
0.3252941966056824,
-0.3539830446243286,
0.5284437537193298,
-0.43260207772254944,
-0.0816340520977974,
-0.22099821269512177,
0.06713414192199707,
0.10069629549980164,
0.37693142890930176,
0.14560292661190033,
-0.3829973340034485,
-0.2442622035741806,
0.07943583279848099,
-0.6981241106987,
-0.271604061126709,
-0.041266970336437225,
0.4040875732898712,
0.09003442525863647,
0.45888984203338623,
-0.4764264225959778,
0.28291887044906616,
0.5552066564559937,
-0.1603611707687378,
0.5280781984329224,
0.04090794548392296,
0.38127171993255615,
-0.8377682566642761,
0.17383167147636414,
0.073483407497406,
-0.012811150401830673,
-0.696541965007782,
-0.07387752830982208,
-0.3663410246372223,
-0.3377283215522766,
-0.14910423755645752,
0.451186865568161,
-0.3460276424884796,
0.23520798981189728,
-0.22512415051460266,
-0.013720483519136906,
-0.06881445646286011,
0.05113285034894943,
-0.10566766560077667,
0.40913471579551697,
0.5298498868942261,
-0.3561001121997833,
0.6076688170433044,
0.3689868152141571,
-0.476228266954422,
0.822110652923584,
-0.6560922265052795,
-0.06821892410516739,
-0.06396316736936569,
0.618726909160614,
-0.9377436637878418,
-0.20758956670761108,
0.4283117353916168,
-0.3725990355014801,
0.2599705755710602,
-0.06649477034807205,
-0.23727357387542725,
-0.5476017594337463,
-0.005207553040236235,
0.5997752547264099,
0.46708470582962036,
0.19496360421180725,
0.09320595860481262,
0.6426828503608704,
-0.7531529068946838,
-0.39223015308380127,
-0.21005237102508545,
0.5028789043426514,
0.05008677393198013,
-0.455149382352829,
-0.2665075957775116,
-0.0030090510845184326,
-0.6112258434295654,
-0.2570072114467621,
-0.2859072983264923,
-0.11970934271812439,
-0.06663796305656433,
0.2501641511917114,
0.4130818843841553,
-0.034564703702926636,
0.33043965697288513,
-0.08424654603004456,
-0.1029098704457283,
0.13400396704673767,
-0.07018160820007324,
0.3486708700656891,
-0.10634279996156693,
-0.6423972845077515,
-0.6154442429542542,
0.6841487884521484,
0.7175131440162659,
0.10120561718940735,
0.33665817975997925,
0.0003128099488094449,
-0.3191288113594055,
0.4419844150543213,
-0.8721635937690735,
0.02640693634748459,
-0.3838396370410919,
0.5168147087097168,
-0.0858558863401413,
-1.2266162633895874,
0.37104833126068115,
-0.2145647257566452,
0.24093909561634064,
0.5905423760414124,
0.5586062073707581,
-0.16933146119117737,
1.1555606126785278,
0.26340848207473755,
0.09757713973522186,
0.03325964882969856,
0.23570865392684937,
0.2734906077384949,
-0.7973375916481018,
-0.4450303614139557,
-0.925869882106781,
-0.016671674326062202,
-0.637442409992218,
-0.4027257561683655,
0.7646034955978394,
-0.3537251949310303,
0.013650137931108475,
0.10232581943273544,
-0.7125889658927917,
-0.07285958528518677,
0.28996601700782776,
0.03970532491803169,
0.5630313754081726,
-0.17570745944976807,
-0.13161885738372803,
-0.19132551550865173,
-0.6517125964164734,
-0.5823206901550293,
0.8060932755470276,
0.7132921814918518,
0.9117015600204468,
-0.11788052320480347,
0.600670576095581,
-0.07888712733983994,
0.4195255637168884,
-0.8758936524391174,
0.6103520393371582,
-0.07643501460552216,
-0.8909863233566284,
-0.3019104301929474,
-0.6669818758964539,
-0.9447881579399109,
0.28013598918914795,
-0.04155557602643967,
-0.9166284799575806,
0.20350416004657745,
-0.16547803580760956,
-0.5730509161949158,
0.21831898391246796,
-0.6859217882156372,
0.4404269754886627,
0.18757373094558716,
-0.04824415594339371,
-0.1266433745622635,
-0.8778326511383057,
0.4673720598220825,
-0.009057965129613876,
0.38492125272750854,
-0.19603227078914642,
0.196110337972641,
0.6509072184562683,
-0.768906831741333,
0.7727176547050476,
-0.05409100651741028,
-0.34669700264930725,
0.4477555453777313,
-0.05156685411930084,
0.02608506940305233,
0.01458923239260912,
0.3081551492214203,
-0.055491749197244644,
0.5403875708580017,
-0.1930074542760849,
-0.40652206540107727,
0.3701401948928833,
-0.27096566557884216,
-0.8695703148841858,
-0.5730676054954529,
-0.312771201133728,
-0.7134053111076355,
-0.033260833472013474,
0.2063608020544052,
0.7426300644874573,
-0.39312878251075745,
0.18331030011177063,
0.4400762915611267,
-0.718626081943512,
0.13989673554897308,
0.13852326571941376,
-0.4110684096813202,
-0.45854538679122925,
0.546618640422821,
0.07135690003633499,
0.4046608805656433,
0.015060584992170334,
-0.19182676076889038,
-0.033301085233688354,
-0.6805128455162048,
-0.49104052782058716,
0.2739591598510742,
-0.46906521916389465,
-0.17717629671096802,
-0.8128622174263,
-0.43511033058166504,
-0.4062306582927704,
0.14494551718235016,
-0.24745295941829681,
-0.5326958298683167,
-0.1292501837015152,
0.4289068579673767,
-0.08921241015195847,
1.2697629928588867,
0.3419254422187805,
0.16521333158016205,
-1.156334638595581,
0.2620248794555664,
0.28575804829597473,
0.6320385336875916,
0.0693153664469719,
-0.13109330832958221,
-0.06964011490345001,
-0.07328757643699646,
-0.4607752561569214,
-0.6861791014671326,
0.1673472821712494,
-0.3795745372772217,
0.2512853145599365,
0.4177285432815552,
-0.12712207436561584,
0.6255350708961487,
-0.5908277034759521,
0.9242080450057983,
0.6392282247543335,
-0.6627907752990723,
0.36445748805999756,
-0.40679290890693665,
0.4527846574783325,
0.7155338525772095,
0.2498193234205246,
-0.8595638871192932,
-0.5640537738800049,
-0.6373474597930908,
-0.6411339044570923,
0.5279994606971741,
0.2518094778060913,
0.01937352865934372,
-0.07877959311008453,
-0.026098743081092834,
-0.07783021777868271,
0.2103232741355896,
-0.19564533233642578,
0.06398004293441772,
0.37544381618499756,
-0.13282886147499084,
0.046615324914455414,
-0.22532957792282104,
-0.44854098558425903,
-0.2649044990539551,
0.3783005475997925,
0.11502546072006226,
0.29543575644493103,
0.40942904353141785,
0.2593025267124176,
-0.15282942354679108,
0.7781802415847778,
0.74910569190979,
0.6452263593673706,
-0.11166736483573914,
-0.27542227506637573,
0.03424037992954254,
-0.5734501481056213,
0.34507161378860474,
0.04384179413318634,
0.08019637316465378,
0.18223777413368225,
0.29668375849723816,
0.7102668881416321,
0.15905095636844635,
-0.9556902050971985,
0.43672898411750793,
-0.2275373786687851,
-0.43652355670928955,
-0.02074120007455349,
-0.08866862952709198,
0.07070186734199524,
0.18306289613246918,
0.4140692949295044,
0.1032901406288147,
0.46405720710754395,
-0.8162688612937927,
-0.2123468816280365,
0.5814003944396973,
-0.7417599558830261,
-0.015657031908631325,
0.2867625057697296,
0.4742169678211212,
-0.28125351667404175,
0.37161263823509216,
0.23528072237968445,
-0.32459622621536255,
0.5185646414756775,
0.28217896819114685,
0.8045406341552734,
-0.1682577133178711,
0.13691163063049316,
0.183292955160141,
0.20617537200450897,
-0.13994213938713074,
0.1884997934103012,
0.13585208356380463,
-0.32343295216560364,
-0.5650732517242432,
-0.37711384892463684,
-0.968635618686676,
0.2928202152252197,
-0.38090750575065613,
-0.10779829323291779,
-0.4549840986728668,
-0.7565789818763733,
0.28238368034362793,
-0.08177778124809265,
-0.3846830129623413,
0.06657786667346954,
0.024502824991941452,
0.9321552515029907,
-0.3989405930042267,
0.23640689253807068,
0.7865654826164246,
-0.02881721220910549,
-0.3790102005004883,
-0.31125181913375854,
0.2898470163345337,
-0.5456588864326477,
0.4379177987575531,
-0.1284034103155136,
-0.14184165000915527,
-0.526292622089386,
-0.6551665663719177,
-0.4646320343017578,
0.3053848147392273,
-0.01602214388549328,
-0.6296029686927795,
-0.39513394236564636,
-0.08659406006336212,
0.7841839790344238,
-0.4683566689491272,
0.3643978536128998,
0.4548111855983734,
0.4502893090248108,
0.1358671635389328,
-1.6660252809524536,
0.01126955822110176,
-0.5511223077774048,
0.05931072682142258,
0.08459578454494476,
-0.6296434998512268,
0.3741895258426666,
0.0019168639555573463,
-0.3061414361000061,
0.5477524399757385,
-0.09926491975784302,
0.25704967975616455,
0.31364068388938904,
0.4134918451309204,
0.26191389560699463,
0.30387964844703674,
-0.31888988614082336,
0.9098639488220215,
0.06100529804825783,
0.22405685484409332,
0.7090238928794861,
-0.6763902902603149,
0.35270264744758606,
0.42588645219802856,
-0.5256142616271973,
0.25107836723327637,
0.44208312034606934,
0.07498329132795334,
-0.09753069281578064,
0.6640186309814453,
-0.6034573316574097,
-0.259973406791687,
-0.36275333166122437,
-0.702064037322998,
0.30626198649406433,
0.7615644335746765,
-0.43436217308044434,
-0.19325238466262817,
0.10325690358877182,
-0.19608888030052185,
-0.23472577333450317,
-0.2531869411468506,
1.1303366422653198,
0.20948833227157593,
-0.931317925453186,
0.6651510000228882,
-0.07356126606464386,
0.39161360263824463,
-0.5562800168991089,
-0.24065105617046356,
0.05584072694182396,
-0.09086132049560547,
-0.23850932717323303,
-0.36363518238067627,
0.016956418752670288,
0.060013651847839355,
0.13479048013687134,
-0.25241875648498535,
0.742526113986969,
-0.06379019469022751,
-0.3562118411064148,
-0.22714777290821075,
0.5953110456466675,
0.2169874608516693,
0.2765601873397827,
-0.42271125316619873,
0.3119114637374878,
0.1546279639005661,
-0.09863100945949554,
0.2368553727865219,
0.3718015253543854,
-0.03213387355208397,
0.8625927567481995,
0.3838067650794983,
0.2477307915687561,
-0.1788082867860794,
0.11805393546819687,
0.8675599098205566,
-0.9153386950492859,
-0.24324803054332733,
-0.5599721670150757,
0.4177447557449341,
-0.17480537295341492,
-0.26886364817619324,
0.3647547960281372,
0.3421253263950348,
0.2982916533946991,
-0.1164267510175705,
0.9446839690208435,
0.04125627875328064,
0.8295601606369019,
-0.2169441282749176,
0.5799936652183533,
-0.28535452485084534,
0.23720824718475342,
-0.6077226996421814,
-0.5422324538230896,
-0.50068199634552,
0.43745124340057373,
-0.1646289974451065,
0.13296739757061005,
0.9162566661834717,
0.2852588891983032,
0.34057021141052246,
0.40370264649391174,
0.32838931679725647,
0.14818641543388367,
0.12772516906261444,
0.5528877377510071,
1.1856987476348877,
-0.2906609773635864,
0.24247339367866516,
0.19270148873329163,
-0.4232522249221802,
-0.33754244446754456,
-0.3770618438720703,
-0.6064918041229248,
-0.6844408512115479,
-0.39872732758522034,
-0.4519727826118469,
0.1121983751654625,
0.8897860646247864,
0.7397644519805908,
-0.8070704936981201,
-0.29146280884742737,
0.29460373520851135,
-0.04505465179681778,
0.12862932682037354,
-0.16884095966815948,
-0.1117132380604744,
-0.36177223920822144,
-0.6654374599456787,
0.35952678322792053,
0.6856147050857544,
0.153086856007576,
-0.2596679925918579,
0.43770354986190796,
-0.03649388253688812,
0.09304339438676834,
0.5452013611793518,
0.5411237478256226,
-0.7278619408607483,
-0.0944795161485672,
0.09944329410791397,
-0.29531875252723694,
0.13229697942733765,
1.220426082611084,
-0.41727733612060547,
0.6332224011421204,
0.3335716128349304,
0.7551013231277466,
0.1869652420282364,
-0.1776321977376938,
0.7246036529541016,
-0.11955731362104416,
-0.21953657269477844,
0.42871466279029846,
0.45227184891700745,
0.1285574734210968,
0.044409219175577164,
0.49611756205558777,
0.26532164216041565,
-0.6289362907409668,
-1.080383539199829,
0.4326893985271454,
-0.9915550351142883,
-0.3360489010810852,
0.8224162459373474,
-0.007218793500214815,
0.16394037008285522,
-0.66904616355896,
-0.6477532982826233,
0.03834916651248932,
-0.152566060423851,
0.5931058526039124,
1.062009572982788,
-0.40423470735549927,
-0.022952668368816376,
-0.7141368389129639,
0.4736972451210022,
0.5382539629936218,
-0.8216506242752075,
0.07469918578863144,
0.8629865050315857,
0.16065795719623566,
0.320526123046875,
1.1551494598388672,
-0.7389991879463196,
0.1234239935874939,
-0.18801914155483246,
-0.1385541409254074,
0.5081033110618591,
-0.1987043172121048,
-0.5304524898529053,
0.15421272814273834,
0.24699829518795013,
0.14402364194393158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10629v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10629v1
|
DeepPavlov at SemEval-2024 Task 8: Leveraging Transfer Learning for Detecting Boundaries of Machine-Generated Texts
| 2024-05-17T08:44:48 | 2024-05-17T08:44:48 |
Anastasia Voznyuk, Vasily Konovalov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The Multigenerator, Multidomain, and Multilingual Black-Box Machine-Generated
Text Detection shared task in the SemEval-2024 competition aims to tackle the
problem of misusing collaborative human-AI writing. Although there are a lot of
existing detectors of AI content, they are often designed to give a binary
answer and thus may not be suitable for more nuanced problem of finding the
boundaries between human-written and machine-generated texts, while hybrid
human-AI writing becomes more and more popular. In this paper, we address the
boundary detection problem. Particularly, we present a pipeline for augmenting
data for supervised fine-tuning of DeBERTaV3. We receive new best MAE score,
according to the leaderboard of the competition, with this pipeline.
|
[
-0.6401899456977844,
-0.676587700843811,
0.6528716683387756,
0.12348403036594391,
-0.16646552085876465,
0.17535744607448578,
-0.04025612026453018,
-0.6016632914543152,
-0.18221333622932434,
0.9060112237930298,
-0.667719304561615,
-0.7184632420539856,
-0.8960974812507629,
0.13192301988601685,
-0.035185620188713074,
0.9441593885421753,
-0.3375285565853119,
-0.42922258377075195,
-0.13274769484996796,
-0.07618443667888641,
-0.7701701521873474,
-0.3937309682369232,
-0.3227652907371521,
-0.4352695345878601,
0.26943954825401306,
0.6504281163215637,
0.1993904560804367,
0.5438089966773987,
0.44855648279190063,
0.2861073613166809,
0.16041773557662964,
0.6365861892700195,
-0.29595527052879333,
0.3489321768283844,
-0.24019820988178253,
-0.2545454204082489,
-0.6135124564170837,
-0.12463743984699249,
0.6097602248191833,
0.3450741469860077,
0.4908820688724518,
0.13991716504096985,
0.23929181694984436,
0.6427953839302063,
-0.6879312992095947,
0.09607213735580444,
-0.6960415244102478,
0.11066030710935593,
-0.17284438014030457,
-0.500822126865387,
-0.42449113726615906,
-0.23285585641860962,
0.02322634682059288,
-0.4877503514289856,
0.06650456041097641,
-0.2798883020877838,
0.745508074760437,
0.5936809182167053,
-0.5208214521408081,
-0.17458710074424744,
-0.6197179555892944,
0.6360820531845093,
-0.2448158711194992,
0.22680531442165375,
0.48197633028030396,
0.145846888422966,
-0.15332449972629547,
-0.6038562059402466,
-0.5675826668739319,
0.16330654919147491,
0.18714658915996552,
0.02665727026760578,
-0.4067106544971466,
-0.19853825867176056,
0.11895706504583359,
0.08116842806339264,
-0.6034928560256958,
0.36319512128829956,
-0.6430901288986206,
-0.49466028809547424,
0.8074177503585815,
0.25699540972709656,
0.22358658909797668,
0.21675702929496765,
-0.26058074831962585,
-0.0853300467133522,
-0.49251100420951843,
-0.0030137046705931425,
0.610309362411499,
0.1652449071407318,
0.09562835097312927,
0.2039903700351715,
-0.1967771053314209,
0.6799054741859436,
0.2186078280210495,
0.49121183156967163,
0.6570994853973389,
-0.2143220156431198,
-0.1302047073841095,
0.16657398641109467,
0.8373472094535828,
0.516201376914978,
0.11211134493350983,
0.08460237830877304,
0.07780897617340088,
0.10307085514068604,
0.23695161938667297,
-0.8781788349151611,
-0.5736840963363647,
0.011843026615679264,
-0.2574072480201721,
-0.43397489190101624,
-0.08237139880657196,
-0.5636206269264221,
-0.4624752998352051,
-0.41992881894111633,
0.4790129065513611,
-0.4929874837398529,
-0.08655500411987305,
0.234648659825325,
-0.007642623037099838,
0.27694252133369446,
0.4767953157424927,
-0.7283251285552979,
0.06734103709459305,
0.5425950884819031,
0.6264343857765198,
-0.39750078320503235,
-0.6577125191688538,
-1.0620821714401245,
-0.11405083537101746,
-0.1263420283794403,
0.9444730281829834,
-0.6780561208724976,
-0.07104083150625229,
-0.2548508048057556,
0.33692625164985657,
0.19536429643630981,
-0.476040244102478,
0.7739827632904053,
-0.2725394368171692,
0.16481047868728638,
-0.014227733016014099,
-0.3795371353626251,
-0.18695880472660065,
0.38534441590309143,
-0.5764880180358887,
1.0196565389633179,
0.06754074990749359,
-0.5356360673904419,
0.3845766484737396,
-0.5309586524963379,
-0.47926005721092224,
0.21021701395511627,
0.18194317817687988,
-0.6130927205085754,
-0.2627776265144348,
0.65162593126297,
0.7876960039138794,
0.08744253218173981,
0.23701930046081543,
-0.18959005177021027,
-0.4625016450881958,
0.04216122254729271,
-0.3443351089954376,
0.7354677319526672,
0.2617452144622803,
-0.5956509113311768,
0.01245732232928276,
-0.7868013381958008,
-0.042539291083812714,
-0.34519127011299133,
-0.29228365421295166,
-0.33197349309921265,
-0.5555369853973389,
-0.11150268465280533,
0.2727716565132141,
0.2396145612001419,
-0.5408591032028198,
0.3337287902832031,
-0.19432750344276428,
0.19419686496257782,
0.7889105081558228,
0.14394570887088776,
0.6870294213294983,
-0.3046949505805969,
0.58244788646698,
0.19881701469421387,
-0.04839570075273514,
-0.17947286367416382,
-0.33891892433166504,
-0.7041015028953552,
-0.2861463129520416,
0.43135949969291687,
0.4534496068954468,
-0.8495532274246216,
0.8457029461860657,
0.13858696818351746,
-0.5778329968452454,
-0.8888439536094666,
0.2176063060760498,
0.020352713763713837,
0.35053855180740356,
0.4728672206401825,
-0.22705680131912231,
-0.6797539591789246,
-1.0769027471542358,
-0.27586299180984497,
0.24503950774669647,
0.24566321074962616,
0.17723038792610168,
0.66693115234375,
-0.7470127940177917,
0.3680911660194397,
-0.5700395703315735,
-0.6350809335708618,
-0.0007307589403353631,
0.3324531614780426,
-0.00844124797731638,
0.7290228009223938,
0.5013353228569031,
-0.6405899524688721,
-0.8147218823432922,
0.17823781073093414,
-0.671782374382019,
-0.519686758518219,
-0.050992630422115326,
-0.5033038854598999,
0.09606397897005081,
0.5705293416976929,
-0.06379532068967819,
0.22278381884098053,
0.6795661449432373,
-0.3928382098674774,
0.25447791814804077,
-0.22551526129245758,
0.4694119691848755,
-1.107291340827942,
0.02655896730720997,
0.07966269552707672,
-0.3721155524253845,
-0.5784012079238892,
-0.0879138708114624,
0.07782306522130966,
0.16385981440544128,
-0.5050904750823975,
0.3783237040042877,
-0.3449278771877289,
0.3425845801830292,
-0.43972858786582947,
0.06237989664077759,
0.2846800684928894,
0.4884004294872284,
-0.10624078661203384,
0.6060876846313477,
0.6374229788780212,
-0.4883650839328766,
0.42177876830101013,
0.29000210762023926,
-0.03971745818853378,
0.701619029045105,
-0.3778040409088135,
0.40165024995803833,
-0.2930457890033722,
0.3839431405067444,
-0.8555458784103394,
0.043293267488479614,
0.3395659923553467,
-0.672915518283844,
0.16743381321430206,
-0.3951553702354431,
-0.23185701668262482,
-0.14384233951568604,
-0.5127363204956055,
0.41911137104034424,
0.48191431164741516,
-0.547581136226654,
0.41137033700942993,
0.5251184701919556,
-0.017792679369449615,
-0.4536254107952118,
-0.8276560306549072,
0.13648946583271027,
-0.325685977935791,
-0.7213371992111206,
0.4826267659664154,
-0.0988541767001152,
0.07476375997066498,
0.04613782837986946,
0.39006614685058594,
-0.273978054523468,
0.3767940104007721,
0.2748011648654938,
0.10909267514944077,
0.03896167501807213,
-0.05228421092033386,
0.5183589458465576,
-0.13163959980010986,
0.057109422981739044,
-0.4334561824798584,
0.4720105230808258,
-0.222171351313591,
-0.10536304116249084,
-0.38946568965911865,
0.2825990915298462,
0.6811720132827759,
-0.49144721031188965,
0.444964200258255,
1.1741093397140503,
-0.5326728224754333,
-0.4558936655521393,
-0.31734341382980347,
-0.028224805369973183,
-0.42895522713661194,
0.05829503759741783,
-0.6916250586509705,
-1.2336902618408203,
0.48925283551216125,
-0.25173521041870117,
-0.2525666058063507,
0.9146032333374023,
0.8433749675750732,
0.1226426362991333,
0.9718542098999023,
0.5920770764350891,
0.15430259704589844,
0.21401602029800415,
-0.5537271499633789,
-0.1473790407180786,
-1.2302888631820679,
-0.3842333257198334,
-0.41592398285865784,
-0.4774007499217987,
-0.7484712600708008,
-0.3862846791744232,
0.1940259337425232,
-0.19372500479221344,
-0.19952145218849182,
0.7090645432472229,
-1.0521005392074585,
0.6652640700340271,
0.6693716645240784,
0.18664640188217163,
0.44135576486587524,
-0.07991571724414825,
0.016795571893453598,
-0.3339215815067291,
-0.21380215883255005,
-0.362883061170578,
0.9598580002784729,
0.5040660500526428,
0.6908899545669556,
0.0240621380507946,
1.0166288614273071,
0.819360613822937,
-0.18939241766929626,
-0.4304163455963135,
0.23395641148090363,
-0.19053956866264343,
-0.3298732340335846,
-0.2260655164718628,
-0.24171701073646545,
-1.1804311275482178,
0.3230856657028198,
-0.2488625943660736,
-0.9087864756584167,
0.2758421301841736,
-0.05763533338904381,
-0.3982525169849396,
0.1627723127603531,
-0.5090321898460388,
0.9846819639205933,
-0.18288841843605042,
-0.6448571681976318,
0.08513136208057404,
-0.545184314250946,
0.2202230542898178,
-0.19514156877994537,
-0.15625514090061188,
-0.3051505982875824,
0.2069045752286911,
0.5652033090591431,
-0.12666812539100647,
0.7529895901679993,
-0.19379989802837372,
-0.3365216553211212,
0.5138806700706482,
0.35988664627075195,
0.4433309733867645,
0.08665814250707626,
-0.08013929426670074,
0.01752931997179985,
-0.14477425813674927,
-0.23591220378875732,
-0.27538251876831055,
0.9652042984962463,
-0.8835575580596924,
-0.2340242564678192,
-0.40702641010284424,
-0.3445354998111725,
-0.013368477113544941,
0.24937723577022552,
0.4433963894844055,
0.2702542245388031,
-0.12227558344602585,
0.1703091263771057,
0.46409323811531067,
-0.1512415111064911,
0.12016946822404861,
0.2919299006462097,
0.150125652551651,
-0.3946998417377472,
0.9943390488624573,
-0.11006751656532288,
-0.37026160955429077,
0.26090022921562195,
0.1155691146850586,
-0.35360410809516907,
-0.6794387102127075,
-0.6722457408905029,
-0.09708047658205032,
-0.6663256883621216,
-0.35268908739089966,
-0.9230109453201294,
-0.375950425863266,
-0.4461916387081146,
-0.31603285670280457,
-0.23410066962242126,
-0.25752681493759155,
-0.6352693438529968,
0.04209807515144348,
0.2825978994369507,
0.6909235715866089,
-0.30569976568222046,
0.17151528596878052,
-1.0945671796798706,
-0.013377269729971886,
0.23544815182685852,
0.19696250557899475,
-0.30238085985183716,
-0.793739914894104,
-0.11506066471338272,
-0.05465995892882347,
-0.5738947987556458,
-0.48163625597953796,
0.4595125615596771,
0.0644737184047699,
0.4691990315914154,
-0.24177947640419006,
0.15005996823310852,
0.31812262535095215,
-0.4083045721054077,
0.6392040848731995,
-0.046487487852573395,
-1.0579291582107544,
0.9015629291534424,
-0.40343159437179565,
0.4880615770816803,
0.8558042049407959,
0.35926637053489685,
-0.30949994921684265,
-0.380683571100235,
-0.6250625252723694,
-0.690632164478302,
0.5555508136749268,
0.4441147744655609,
0.1382834017276764,
0.3750832676887512,
0.12301848828792572,
0.5894432663917542,
0.08679187297821045,
-0.5811806321144104,
0.1445477455854416,
0.16325892508029938,
-0.3640655279159546,
0.1731300950050354,
0.09679670631885529,
0.09694453328847885,
-0.4302152395248413,
0.7393786907196045,
-0.37849733233451843,
0.06636227667331696,
0.266277015209198,
-0.358209490776062,
-0.07732595503330231,
0.17939534783363342,
0.6714075207710266,
0.4752870500087738,
-0.140397846698761,
0.3070683479309082,
0.37087419629096985,
-0.3178010582923889,
0.32287514209747314,
0.571182370185852,
-0.10858156532049179,
-0.25548049807548523,
0.47529634833335876,
1.0339100360870361,
-0.5483168959617615,
-0.47546693682670593,
0.5517089366912842,
-0.09629712998867035,
-0.8060494065284729,
-0.2412380874156952,
0.13701197504997253,
-0.4214876592159271,
0.6912426948547363,
0.29199859499931335,
0.296897828578949,
0.6751530170440674,
-0.33110448718070984,
0.6184563040733337,
0.19469226896762848,
-0.6935085654258728,
-0.4653751254081726,
0.6446778178215027,
0.6358471512794495,
-0.24780765175819397,
0.22711379826068878,
-0.40178096294403076,
-1.0997580289840698,
0.6210645437240601,
0.30415111780166626,
0.8825958967208862,
0.0600215308368206,
0.21108923852443695,
0.3198346495628357,
0.31432220339775085,
0.17496030032634735,
0.1965685486793518,
-0.06005077064037323,
-0.7417711019515991,
-0.6881332993507385,
-0.4126790761947632,
-0.26380205154418945,
0.46422624588012695,
-0.2813345789909363,
0.6018482446670532,
-0.20107029378414154,
0.0147602129727602,
0.2853982746601105,
0.20292852818965912,
-0.9187978506088257,
-0.008455486968159676,
0.5758386850357056,
0.4898150563240051,
-1.0221937894821167,
0.522865355014801,
0.787843644618988,
-0.0917048528790474,
-0.3919524848461151,
-0.16730307042598724,
-0.16100096702575684,
-0.5543175935745239,
0.7272799611091614,
0.4530732035636902,
-0.29811328649520874,
0.06109710410237312,
-0.5690208077430725,
-0.5135197043418884,
1.0072702169418335,
0.3961451053619385,
-0.4861571192741394,
0.22179846465587616,
-0.13421426713466644,
0.627393901348114,
-0.3620389699935913,
-0.01819869503378868,
0.8233016133308411,
0.5355426073074341,
0.003925289027392864,
-0.8177433609962463,
0.044679444283246994,
-0.2438189685344696,
-0.48512399196624756,
0.39490756392478943,
-0.7188569903373718,
0.7660908699035645,
0.09097778052091599,
0.09051838517189026,
-0.13914145529270172,
0.41305622458457947,
0.021743489429354668,
0.5107239484786987,
0.3593987822532654,
0.8661209940910339,
0.7877030968666077,
0.010042854584753513,
0.5512478351593018,
-0.10333381593227386,
0.364214152097702,
1.0130552053451538,
-0.33836400508880615,
0.33562174439430237,
0.10603156685829163,
0.13142751157283783,
0.5289061069488525,
0.6503922343254089,
-0.4136732816696167,
0.5778663158416748,
0.2641090750694275,
-0.22953127324581146,
-0.34726524353027344,
-0.298750102519989,
-0.37215229868888855,
0.8639925718307495,
0.2951298952102661,
-0.4775743782520294,
-0.1199081689119339,
0.2584313154220581,
-0.10283779352903366,
0.2591659128665924,
-0.20632009208202362,
0.790230393409729,
-0.11131050437688828,
-0.872161865234375,
0.5622588396072388,
-0.000830708013381809,
0.7518723607063293,
0.06977016478776932,
-0.40044838190078735,
-0.09825238585472107,
0.5457670092582703,
-0.2513752579689026,
-1.274514079093933,
0.20279189944267273,
-0.12542350590229034,
0.1371874064207077,
-0.15350429713726044,
1.287381887435913,
-0.8350309729576111,
-0.42219048738479614,
0.2274845987558365,
0.6718273162841797,
0.12550486624240875,
-0.13038820028305054,
-0.5631956458091736,
0.3476962745189667,
0.03244400769472122,
0.14144276082515717,
0.036840181797742844,
0.8370612859725952,
0.03938787430524826,
0.4207119345664978,
0.5502007007598877,
-0.030208203941583633,
-0.1900426596403122,
0.05319355055689812,
0.9391024112701416,
-0.3745236396789551,
-0.48558154702186584,
-1.2075544595718384,
0.5636709928512573,
-0.3204473555088043,
-0.43646958470344543,
0.601641058921814,
0.5935198068618774,
0.8577383160591125,
-0.13775092363357544,
1.1077998876571655,
0.1636715978384018,
0.044425833970308304,
-0.49578484892845154,
0.5189248919487,
-0.49284785985946655,
-0.07659273594617844,
-0.38000553846359253,
-1.0581114292144775,
-0.4676724672317505,
0.46447402238845825,
-0.10815726220607758,
-0.3549954891204834,
0.549172580242157,
0.4771917164325714,
-0.22352290153503418,
-0.3152067959308624,
0.3325415551662445,
-0.31474369764328003,
0.4091304540634155,
1.082058310508728,
1.019755244255066,
-0.7205801606178284,
0.6559083461761475,
-0.10182367265224457,
-0.239225834608078,
-0.3329968750476837,
-0.8173794150352478,
-1.2115585803985596,
-0.8568789958953857,
-0.5039739608764648,
-0.42898398637771606,
0.09779829531908035,
0.762292742729187,
0.6088384389877319,
-0.692908763885498,
0.3179706931114197,
-0.04881007596850395,
0.08257955312728882,
0.1519099622964859,
-0.19229722023010254,
0.3420586585998535,
-0.02167254313826561,
-0.9450402855873108,
0.22811922430992126,
0.3209722638130188,
0.21453268826007843,
-0.32420313358306885,
-0.14171230792999268,
-0.2825371026992798,
-0.25546371936798096,
0.6125693917274475,
-0.06916719675064087,
-0.20293179154396057,
-0.4820626378059387,
0.02276967465877533,
-0.05668000131845474,
0.09349452704191208,
0.6643213629722595,
-0.7992215156555176,
0.5054160356521606,
0.7102084755897522,
1.09605872631073,
0.7551238536834717,
0.04665174335241318,
0.6457830667495728,
-0.8473358154296875,
0.012727639637887478,
0.39936646819114685,
0.21095724403858185,
0.5612766146659851,
-0.6888872385025024,
0.6395331025123596,
0.1815520077943802,
-0.8319648504257202,
-0.6080830097198486,
0.17439667880535126,
-0.7079779505729675,
-0.244570791721344,
1.1102168560028076,
0.14381466805934906,
-0.10375762730836868,
-0.12022256851196289,
-0.5350242257118225,
0.19516171514987946,
-0.5377313494682312,
0.49935275316238403,
0.7397175431251526,
-0.21095092594623566,
-0.3158777058124542,
-0.3157840073108673,
0.5367985963821411,
0.1576438695192337,
-0.985271692276001,
-0.12818923592567444,
0.48586228489875793,
0.07219605892896652,
0.1507648527622223,
0.7165291905403137,
0.16194647550582886,
0.2949092388153076,
-0.15281769633293152,
0.024704700335860252,
-0.23991398513317108,
-0.5666435956954956,
-0.38481131196022034,
-0.011453568004071712,
-0.03433798626065254,
-0.4890051484107971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10626v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10626v1
|
Dynamic data sampler for cross-language transfer learning in large language models
| 2024-05-17T08:40:51 | 2024-05-17T08:40:51 |
Yudong Li, Yuhao Feng, Wen Zhou, Zhe Zhao, Linlin Shen, Cheng Hou, Xianxu Hou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have gained significant attention in the field
of natural language processing (NLP) due to their wide range of applications.
However, training LLMs for languages other than English poses significant
challenges, due to the difficulty in acquiring large-scale corpus and the
requisite computing resources. In this paper, we propose ChatFlow, a
cross-language transfer-based LLM, to address these challenges and train large
Chinese language models in a cost-effective manner. We employ a mix of Chinese,
English, and parallel corpus to continuously train the LLaMA2 model, aiming to
align cross-language representations and facilitate the knowledge transfer
specifically to the Chinese language model. In addition, we use a dynamic data
sampler to progressively transition the model from unsupervised pre-training to
supervised fine-tuning. Experimental results demonstrate that our approach
accelerates model convergence and achieves superior performance. We evaluate
ChatFlow on popular Chinese and English benchmarks, the results indicate that
it outperforms other Chinese models post-trained on LLaMA-2-7B.
|
[
0.07004258781671524,
-0.5535786747932434,
0.3113411068916321,
0.3041101098060608,
-0.3122299015522003,
0.5123813152313232,
-0.572823166847229,
-0.6247260570526123,
-0.11102352291345596,
0.5062878727912903,
-0.39347150921821594,
-0.3624114394187927,
-0.615526556968689,
-0.09590107202529907,
-0.5534788370132446,
0.8325986266136169,
-0.3390321731567383,
0.11633525788784027,
-0.00286891614086926,
0.030269354581832886,
-0.4384489059448242,
-0.3160451352596283,
-0.9358689188957214,
-0.41348353028297424,
0.5195291042327881,
0.37538525462150574,
0.5937397480010986,
0.41139495372772217,
0.3795557916164398,
0.23846979439258575,
-0.000015217699910863303,
0.37150466442108154,
-0.6582532525062561,
0.11460964381694794,
-0.12767325341701508,
-0.7563467621803284,
-0.1874522566795349,
-0.18573638796806335,
0.8098281621932983,
0.6713343262672424,
-0.3058936893939972,
0.1844904124736786,
0.1754813939332962,
0.3837919235229492,
-0.3687814474105835,
0.39868271350860596,
-0.9209085702896118,
0.15270555019378662,
-0.36835768818855286,
-0.0451427586376667,
-0.38933271169662476,
-0.42283838987350464,
0.154882550239563,
-0.5427091121673584,
-0.0642743781208992,
-0.02507747709751129,
0.7712050676345825,
0.2485644519329071,
-0.4639362692832947,
-0.16871221363544464,
-0.8874019980430603,
0.7965166568756104,
-0.6643602252006531,
0.47566473484039307,
0.0973362922668457,
0.7106564044952393,
-0.1378672868013382,
-0.9670240879058838,
-0.6461113691329956,
-0.2896459102630615,
0.10812270641326904,
-0.06724172085523605,
-0.0782167986035347,
-0.3056488633155823,
-0.03503557667136192,
0.2736329436302185,
-0.5120422840118408,
0.5131757855415344,
-0.2928714156150818,
-0.07818424701690674,
0.7533149719238281,
0.21004758775234222,
0.382262259721756,
0.4008883237838745,
-0.37669193744659424,
-0.30525854229927063,
-0.7323359251022339,
0.14740753173828125,
0.12841209769248962,
0.5237822532653809,
-0.4252830743789673,
0.1516016572713852,
-0.05180003121495247,
0.4661625623703003,
-0.03919995576143265,
-0.17387866973876953,
0.3460973799228668,
-0.1719588041305542,
-0.029676072299480438,
0.1060856431722641,
0.7275552153587341,
0.09214938431978226,
0.44714540243148804,
-0.1736697554588318,
-0.2068668007850647,
-0.3084110915660858,
-0.1644858866930008,
-0.9967715740203857,
-0.36410248279571533,
0.20286591351032257,
-0.23049062490463257,
-0.21155132353305817,
-0.13889290392398834,
-0.7120094895362854,
-0.3960835635662079,
-0.30763453245162964,
0.06695031374692917,
-0.29886510968208313,
-0.36066749691963196,
0.009616207331418991,
0.24916450679302216,
0.3591042160987854,
0.5019509792327881,
-0.8592255711555481,
0.18515034019947052,
0.5385287404060364,
0.9027762413024902,
-0.6984459161758423,
-0.38748493790626526,
-0.7725883722305298,
0.2449699193239212,
-0.3377753794193268,
0.8952462673187256,
-0.661491870880127,
-0.12236297130584717,
0.36463019251823425,
0.1648523062467575,
-0.29320135712623596,
-0.7755557894706726,
0.24211834371089935,
-0.5487304329872131,
-0.02290383167564869,
0.07460175454616547,
-0.48844653367996216,
-0.16256585717201233,
0.3319314122200012,
-0.5839976072311401,
1.09239661693573,
-0.06584420055150986,
-0.5531829595565796,
0.02903876081109047,
-0.29863911867141724,
-0.5371688604354858,
0.20633119344711304,
-0.1995135098695755,
-0.3111478388309479,
-0.3132009208202362,
0.2075575292110443,
0.4657757878303528,
-0.4055841863155365,
0.32120829820632935,
-0.467930406332016,
-0.3756215572357178,
0.30122387409210205,
-0.5958863496780396,
0.6775446534156799,
0.33508962392807007,
-0.13936978578567505,
0.13638687133789062,
-0.8303418159484863,
-0.08233019709587097,
0.16606201231479645,
-0.4458189010620117,
-0.17502714693546295,
-0.08520355820655823,
0.34136056900024414,
0.21381142735481262,
0.33299121260643005,
-0.5256988406181335,
0.20256094634532928,
-0.20335249602794647,
0.30432119965553284,
0.4235629737377167,
-0.345918208360672,
0.4127689003944397,
-0.3740543723106384,
0.6395857930183411,
0.07175292819738388,
-0.14416418969631195,
-0.1949111521244049,
-0.31764891743659973,
-0.87123042345047,
-0.19015249609947205,
0.4869430363178253,
0.8690215945243835,
-0.8982804417610168,
0.39132872223854065,
-0.30724436044692993,
-0.7203198075294495,
-0.6209009289741516,
0.4397895038127899,
-0.036163412034511566,
0.15146273374557495,
0.31540781259536743,
-0.11926194280385971,
-0.3285701274871826,
-0.44292330741882324,
-0.13508474826812744,
-0.15022024512290955,
-0.14139023423194885,
0.17044071853160858,
0.10835348814725876,
-0.19285564124584198,
0.6514961123466492,
-0.27882087230682373,
-0.455294668674469,
-0.7255529761314392,
0.033410537987947464,
0.1897803097963333,
0.4154561460018158,
0.4711027443408966,
-0.5362021327018738,
-0.723138153553009,
0.29773956537246704,
-0.40656983852386475,
-0.41073402762413025,
-0.4296409487724304,
-0.27522775530815125,
0.1826716959476471,
0.6684843897819519,
-0.45157599449157715,
0.08190824836492538,
1.0689144134521484,
0.148152694106102,
0.298336923122406,
-0.2512848973274231,
-0.22463466227054596,
-1.2935700416564941,
0.04760851338505745,
-0.2235543131828308,
-0.3696304261684418,
-0.4894108772277832,
-0.19529849290847778,
0.04242747649550438,
-0.02751271240413189,
-0.749804675579071,
0.7874288558959961,
-0.6092437505722046,
0.10394599288702011,
-0.5829896926879883,
0.2704355716705322,
-0.20986074209213257,
0.42458784580230713,
0.32736432552337646,
0.5877479314804077,
0.5976628661155701,
-0.5753787159919739,
0.682142436504364,
0.11511292308568954,
-0.49089112877845764,
0.23673860728740692,
-0.43056830763816833,
0.14087052643299103,
0.1825384646654129,
0.5152463912963867,
-0.965495228767395,
0.08609451353549957,
0.15659405291080475,
-0.11327104270458221,
0.33448439836502075,
-0.12760883569717407,
-0.4542887210845947,
-0.14981882274150848,
0.019633496180176735,
0.3161861002445221,
0.5890098810195923,
-0.83212810754776,
0.5371158123016357,
0.39759647846221924,
-0.2045043408870697,
-0.3366716802120209,
-0.9229040741920471,
0.01804724521934986,
-0.16199366748332977,
-0.5003281235694885,
0.4593225121498108,
0.052051618695259094,
0.027231190353631973,
-0.17185485363006592,
0.18049167096614838,
-0.29558515548706055,
0.02596896141767502,
-0.03283413499593735,
0.17833347618579865,
-0.12627016007900238,
0.11324585229158401,
-0.0027839771937578917,
0.10291291773319244,
0.04292021319270134,
-0.1687304824590683,
0.8157786726951599,
0.23712722957134247,
-0.5271762013435364,
-0.4188043475151062,
-0.05502493679523468,
0.34106630086898804,
-0.39199796319007874,
0.7444918751716614,
0.6506479978561401,
-0.3182896375656128,
-0.6176981925964355,
-0.34737494587898254,
-0.014820261858403683,
-0.45275360345840454,
0.6019306778907776,
-0.23258906602859497,
-0.8466833233833313,
0.6817372441291809,
-0.230118989944458,
0.3799360990524292,
0.06726833432912827,
0.8502297401428223,
0.0877452939748764,
0.705410897731781,
0.7607575058937073,
-0.4026302397251129,
0.753714382648468,
-0.045773930847644806,
0.09502296149730682,
-0.472078800201416,
-0.17780701816082,
-0.3209114372730255,
-0.41113731265068054,
-0.6625910997390747,
-0.8680863976478577,
0.07036962360143661,
-0.213449165225029,
-0.04492661729454994,
0.2079484909772873,
0.1542719602584839,
0.37544846534729004,
0.4467809200286865,
-0.023330161347985268,
0.41760778427124023,
0.10032999515533447,
0.0011487331939861178,
0.21567806601524353,
-0.8664886951446533,
-0.3538931906223297,
0.8645862340927124,
0.44871416687965393,
0.9404307007789612,
0.07976531237363815,
0.3842124342918396,
0.016087975353002548,
0.26356902718544006,
-0.7534351944923401,
0.49719059467315674,
-0.4073706865310669,
-0.21544072031974792,
-0.2748318612575531,
-0.42209166288375854,
-1.1617388725280762,
0.3780592381954193,
-0.29601824283599854,
-0.5336212515830994,
-0.08040999621152878,
0.031073100864887238,
-0.19912569224834442,
0.6489904522895813,
-0.25307637453079224,
0.6300788521766663,
-0.4826735854148865,
-0.37309256196022034,
-0.21206802129745483,
-0.4499201774597168,
0.5864298939704895,
-0.5545922517776489,
0.16584233939647675,
-0.3146180212497711,
0.13617785274982452,
0.5113866329193115,
-0.2812226414680481,
0.8434462547302246,
0.021572448313236237,
-0.4278978407382965,
0.15026380121707916,
0.05967571586370468,
0.6271735429763794,
0.019173404201865196,
0.020528225228190422,
0.3847009837627411,
-0.0025158782955259085,
-0.28069210052490234,
-0.5107183456420898,
0.48843806982040405,
-0.7945764660835266,
-0.49482741951942444,
-0.33986055850982666,
-0.8319969177246094,
-0.322855681180954,
0.07237990200519562,
-0.12326160818338394,
-0.17148815095424652,
-0.06949896365404129,
0.2082284539937973,
0.48647189140319824,
-0.5679145455360413,
0.4127255976200104,
0.7204439640045166,
-0.5057819485664368,
-0.015799105167388916,
0.734908938407898,
0.10216964036226273,
0.46503517031669617,
0.5517817139625549,
0.1457722783088684,
-0.1957460641860962,
-0.5292850136756897,
-0.7062519192695618,
0.2490091472864151,
-0.25936415791511536,
-0.03286057338118553,
-0.5363320112228394,
-0.6283871531486511,
-0.31992486119270325,
0.2231028527021408,
-0.7860233187675476,
-0.029766879975795746,
-0.23002693057060242,
0.21243616938591003,
0.40717536211013794,
0.20087791979312897,
0.05851658061146736,
0.3597499430179596,
-1.231829285621643,
0.08241748064756393,
0.28956422209739685,
0.2957313060760498,
0.10272663086652756,
-0.9590986967086792,
-0.3732607364654541,
0.1199430599808693,
-0.15204018354415894,
-0.5086052417755127,
0.618960440158844,
0.217734694480896,
0.6644320487976074,
0.39870837330818176,
0.25696974992752075,
0.7294226288795471,
-0.5927661061286926,
0.6007128357887268,
-0.0666033998131752,
-0.6871048212051392,
0.22119726240634918,
-0.05782344564795494,
0.42002683877944946,
0.48365098237991333,
0.35566607117652893,
-0.940551221370697,
-0.47520461678504944,
-0.10082082450389862,
-0.7248453497886658,
0.7489640712738037,
0.08409935235977173,
0.2780819833278656,
0.32732370495796204,
0.11421383917331696,
0.1740945279598236,
-0.07746574282646179,
-0.5938026309013367,
-0.05184570699930191,
0.2971658408641815,
-0.27149954438209534,
0.04120783880352974,
0.21558710932731628,
0.2709232270717621,
-0.11166466772556305,
0.6440922617912292,
-0.32748088240623474,
-0.06752626597881317,
-0.2349541038274765,
-0.3248325288295746,
0.021586040034890175,
0.04434727504849434,
0.12811018526554108,
0.44015735387802124,
-0.09339087456464767,
0.023458294570446014,
0.5740994811058044,
-0.48747503757476807,
0.04010216146707535,
0.4426623582839966,
-0.10673526674509048,
-0.07589268684387207,
0.35981717705726624,
0.9024925827980042,
0.15448196232318878,
-1.0825492143630981,
0.4565376043319702,
-0.10043013840913773,
-0.07752926647663116,
-0.41423898935317993,
0.2028474062681198,
0.3258059322834015,
0.6697095036506653,
0.1511993259191513,
-0.5053626894950867,
-0.13558785617351532,
-0.526732861995697,
0.108743816614151,
0.4161248505115509,
-0.22943951189517975,
-0.30408045649528503,
0.707486629486084,
0.29175376892089844,
-0.0844326987862587,
0.8216489553451538,
0.2532130181789398,
-0.6128432750701904,
0.5731164813041687,
0.5586966276168823,
0.6806432604789734,
-0.2937852442264557,
0.057059984654188156,
0.12696564197540283,
0.16013319790363312,
-0.20107075572013855,
0.10682949423789978,
-0.06071186810731888,
-0.97218257188797,
-0.5637446045875549,
-0.5897548198699951,
-0.8634887933731079,
0.22696813941001892,
-0.4922538697719574,
0.6031183004379272,
-0.19028720259666443,
0.32039302587509155,
-0.3326742649078369,
0.11584391444921494,
-0.6564477682113647,
0.049106139689683914,
0.8058603405952454,
1.035353183746338,
-0.8399832248687744,
1.5024781227111816,
0.6361348628997803,
-0.11816705763339996,
-0.8408210277557373,
0.03973940759897232,
-0.16829703748226166,
-1.0003485679626465,
0.6611023545265198,
0.11766976118087769,
-0.057560376822948456,
-0.1125323474407196,
-0.39577624201774597,
-1.1439976692199707,
1.0547200441360474,
0.5700535774230957,
-0.9944277405738831,
0.042061541229486465,
0.5293076038360596,
0.6763209104537964,
-0.3081369996070862,
0.38908806443214417,
0.5207006931304932,
0.23022404313087463,
0.4764087200164795,
-1.0479356050491333,
-0.018768327310681343,
-0.18579810857772827,
0.08985468000173569,
-0.11884471774101257,
-0.9999107122421265,
0.7320485711097717,
-0.07756500691175461,
-0.25777482986450195,
0.0469985157251358,
1.0265541076660156,
0.5870146155357361,
0.06715011596679688,
0.7488427758216858,
0.1266026645898819,
0.91770339012146,
0.19010424613952637,
0.6366656422615051,
-0.5670697689056396,
0.07038363069295883,
1.2087492942810059,
-0.7772669792175293,
1.1852766275405884,
0.38690119981765747,
-0.2231496125459671,
0.4984475076198578,
0.6879680156707764,
-0.1333223581314087,
0.3960631787776947,
0.4708823263645172,
-0.11816141754388809,
-0.26285994052886963,
-0.11517215520143509,
-0.343762069940567,
0.5862612724304199,
0.2854378819465637,
-0.16687536239624023,
-0.33842024207115173,
-0.06651041656732559,
0.058735452592372894,
-0.09996861964464188,
-0.05615498870611191,
0.5479747653007507,
0.19636252522468567,
-0.5877179503440857,
0.518445611000061,
0.052150364965200424,
0.9059353470802307,
-0.7360518574714661,
-0.06755733489990234,
-0.5870789289474487,
0.48927533626556396,
-0.03815111890435219,
-0.7954855561256409,
0.3214203715324402,
0.1361733227968216,
0.2371869832277298,
-0.27258870005607605,
0.604902446269989,
-0.9938595294952393,
-0.5812670588493347,
0.480976402759552,
0.5264465808868408,
0.3916764557361603,
0.09012304991483688,
-0.6659044623374939,
0.047233957797288895,
0.01587645523250103,
-0.2070944756269455,
0.548670768737793,
0.5602092146873474,
-0.2702546715736389,
0.8497283458709717,
0.8292602300643921,
0.4335668087005615,
0.2645321488380432,
0.2384513020515442,
0.7562508583068848,
-0.5114094614982605,
-0.47671934962272644,
-0.6995461583137512,
0.1554725617170334,
0.02452683635056019,
-0.15539568662643433,
0.5449537634849548,
0.5583779215812683,
1.1137182712554932,
0.2556983530521393,
0.8729483485221863,
0.3003217577934265,
0.6500650644302368,
-0.4916539192199707,
0.877044677734375,
-0.6110421419143677,
0.4715789556503296,
0.09218766540288925,
-0.9616539478302002,
-0.3429020941257477,
0.44716477394104004,
-0.042478322982788086,
-0.18182817101478577,
0.4142756164073944,
0.6612359881401062,
-0.1067361906170845,
-0.025709467008709908,
0.28715038299560547,
0.15959365665912628,
0.6272525191307068,
1.0054110288619995,
0.8480035066604614,
-0.18435366451740265,
0.9092453122138977,
-0.2468399554491043,
-0.13723969459533691,
-0.10452917218208313,
-0.9016128778457642,
-1.0425418615341187,
-0.2822937071323395,
-0.34540513157844543,
-0.12612271308898926,
0.04832109063863754,
1.0784423351287842,
0.6691133379936218,
-0.9233951568603516,
-0.6600077152252197,
0.18616019189357758,
-0.1121586412191391,
-0.16961705684661865,
-0.1305617243051529,
0.4148699939250946,
-0.5601715445518494,
-1.2094786167144775,
0.3031904399394989,
-0.09941975027322769,
-0.03939569368958473,
-0.43361231684684753,
0.05289579927921295,
-0.1609184443950653,
0.01362280361354351,
0.5174782276153564,
0.3068317472934723,
-0.4202214479446411,
-0.030111530795693398,
-0.11954627186059952,
-0.2694970965385437,
0.0239431019872427,
0.5249521732330322,
-0.7819409370422363,
0.13191968202590942,
0.5903701186180115,
1.285415768623352,
0.7707173228263855,
-0.30414432287216187,
0.8209826946258545,
-0.44921189546585083,
0.2218315154314041,
-0.09355855733156204,
0.33769696950912476,
0.37284907698631287,
-0.1977219134569168,
0.3948071002960205,
0.16900788247585297,
-0.37884414196014404,
-0.7492681741714478,
-0.07627581804990768,
-0.952489972114563,
-0.31375205516815186,
1.4090038537979126,
-0.252165287733078,
-0.24981074035167694,
0.017884785309433937,
-0.17890553176403046,
0.6111864447593689,
-0.29601603746414185,
0.7753331661224365,
0.5474157929420471,
0.06364942342042923,
-0.38156118988990784,
-0.6498203277587891,
0.21594084799289703,
0.4852772057056427,
-1.038888692855835,
0.26671937108039856,
0.08601778000593185,
0.25419142842292786,
-0.3409692049026489,
0.2829899489879608,
0.08976327627897263,
-0.024794433265924454,
-0.18203389644622803,
0.26889070868492126,
0.08449696004390717,
-0.09293662756681442,
-0.19788441061973572,
-0.04609929770231247,
-0.07344967126846313,
-0.33417701721191406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10625v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10625v1
|
Specialising and Analysing Instruction-Tuned and Byte-Level Language Models for Organic Reaction Prediction
| 2024-05-17T08:39:56 | 2024-05-17T08:39:56 |
Jiayun Pang, Ivan Vulić
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, q-bio.BM
|
Transformer-based encoder-decoder models have demonstrated impressive results
in chemical reaction prediction tasks. However, these models typically rely on
pretraining using tens of millions of unlabelled molecules, which can be
time-consuming and GPU-intensive. One of the central questions we aim to answer
in this work is: Can FlanT5 and ByT5, the encode-decoder models pretrained
solely on language data, be effectively specialised for organic reaction
prediction through task-specific fine-tuning? We conduct a systematic empirical
study on several key issues of the process, including tokenisation, the impact
of (SMILES-oriented) pretraining, fine-tuning sample efficiency, and decoding
algorithms at inference. Our key findings indicate that although being
pretrained only on language tasks, FlanT5 and ByT5 provide a solid foundation
to fine-tune for reaction prediction, and thus become `chemistry domain
compatible' in the process. This suggests that GPU-intensive and expensive
pretraining on a large dataset of unlabelled molecules may be useful yet not
essential to leverage the power of language models for chemistry. All our
models achieve comparable Top-1 and Top-5 accuracy although some variation
across different models does exist. Notably, tokenisation and vocabulary
trimming slightly affect final performance but can speed up training and
inference; The most efficient greedy decoding strategy is very competitive
while only marginal gains can be achieved from more sophisticated decoding
algorithms. In summary, we evaluate FlanT5 and ByT5 across several dimensions
and benchmark their impact on organic reaction prediction, which may guide more
effective use of these state-of-the-art language models for chemistry-related
tasks in the future.
|
[
-0.3181932866573334,
-0.3521316349506378,
0.5803369283676147,
-0.1986258625984192,
0.08979010581970215,
0.12772314250469208,
-0.34928619861602783,
-0.5924338698387146,
-0.3457660377025604,
0.44076991081237793,
-0.5526021122932434,
-0.30920931696891785,
-0.7354331612586975,
0.3972839117050171,
-0.35812368988990784,
0.7143524289131165,
0.11527060717344284,
0.4038039743900299,
-0.16393086314201355,
0.14090465009212494,
-0.1933138221502304,
-0.5547741055488586,
-0.37538886070251465,
-0.27613314986228943,
0.5070902705192566,
0.4346136748790741,
0.2778818905353546,
0.5516197681427002,
0.7525695562362671,
0.30199912190437317,
-0.06999430060386658,
-0.0849224105477333,
-0.6352590322494507,
-0.12110035121440887,
-0.376190721988678,
-0.8254871368408203,
-0.41425055265426636,
0.21909213066101074,
0.043962616473436356,
0.6502447724342346,
-0.09162610024213791,
0.07607326656579971,
-0.12089429795742035,
0.5159913301467896,
-0.6296948790550232,
0.23998196423053741,
-0.7841166853904724,
0.17083589732646942,
-0.02392534725368023,
0.06293527781963348,
-0.520501971244812,
0.10750897228717804,
-0.04901175573468208,
-0.5166773796081543,
0.45459210872650146,
0.1282777190208435,
0.5867277383804321,
0.3897135555744171,
-0.23316967487335205,
-0.19302929937839508,
-0.8122345805168152,
0.8623522520065308,
-0.7623501420021057,
0.578921914100647,
-0.005520360078662634,
0.36455294489860535,
-0.3385244905948639,
-0.9628746509552002,
-0.6780732870101929,
-0.13114699721336365,
-0.045815836638212204,
0.30955934524536133,
0.08954118937253952,
0.6118902564048767,
0.29236096143722534,
0.5762940049171448,
-0.4294363260269165,
-0.2555272877216339,
-0.5056085586547852,
-0.04302358627319336,
0.30863431096076965,
0.046273887157440186,
0.23231086134910583,
-0.004980339203029871,
-0.5282245874404907,
-0.04849107936024666,
-0.4787292778491974,
-0.005201974418014288,
0.11394086480140686,
0.5445984601974487,
0.2898697257041931,
0.49624118208885193,
-0.1475265622138977,
0.4643956422805786,
0.2701337933540344,
0.26279258728027344,
-0.07246576994657516,
-0.5369811654090881,
-0.4126303195953369,
0.3374651372432709,
0.693361759185791,
-0.00019236459047533572,
0.4812674820423126,
-0.3297370374202728,
-0.4641605317592621,
0.7006716132164001,
0.4544084668159485,
-1.2389445304870605,
-0.5386372208595276,
0.5897233486175537,
-0.07944605499505997,
-0.14891718327999115,
0.03784579783678055,
-0.45641574263572693,
-0.012391706928610802,
-0.34113287925720215,
0.5283145308494568,
-0.5369533896446228,
-0.04244545102119446,
0.41051918268203735,
-0.2028648555278778,
-0.12073083221912384,
0.14988723397254944,
-1.0596632957458496,
0.4834771454334259,
0.6658294200897217,
0.5052590370178223,
-0.419200599193573,
-0.15655763447284698,
-0.4109874367713928,
-0.06932597607374191,
-0.1483249068260193,
0.7466379404067993,
-0.9816240668296814,
-0.20083904266357422,
-0.2968286871910095,
0.09191856533288956,
-0.11750195175409317,
-0.660598635673523,
0.2188018262386322,
-0.4844282269477844,
-0.03793700411915779,
-0.2677764594554901,
-0.7933884263038635,
0.13984563946723938,
-0.08375173062086105,
-0.8067404627799988,
0.5678593516349792,
0.10966953635215759,
-0.41063523292541504,
0.7605867981910706,
-0.6837391257286072,
-0.3596879839897156,
-0.2536485195159912,
-0.011417871341109276,
-0.2711070477962494,
0.3099372982978821,
0.14744947850704193,
0.3559873700141907,
-0.38944897055625916,
0.13263334333896637,
-0.18459072709083557,
-0.33426713943481445,
0.26355627179145813,
-0.18056319653987885,
0.21025924384593964,
0.3536677956581116,
-0.4273286461830139,
0.38460785150527954,
-1.0142349004745483,
-0.05634351074695587,
-0.35647475719451904,
-0.506310224533081,
0.3420644700527191,
-0.08206842094659805,
0.1734681874513626,
0.3151794970035553,
0.06003160402178764,
-0.7409871816635132,
0.08425012975931168,
-0.452792763710022,
0.4351309835910797,
0.6546215415000916,
0.028804048895835876,
0.4666993319988251,
0.14986513555049896,
0.6414775848388672,
0.3743310272693634,
0.02111705020070076,
-0.1499195396900177,
-0.3776583671569824,
-0.6258294582366943,
0.00023282249458134174,
0.31903576850891113,
0.2792845368385315,
-0.6382908821105957,
0.12635350227355957,
-0.3781796991825104,
-0.49101030826568604,
-0.4335121810436249,
0.14402572810649872,
0.5062670707702637,
0.33451321721076965,
0.5522972345352173,
-0.3281926214694977,
-0.5043334364891052,
-0.45546719431877136,
-0.8506645560264587,
0.11656037718057632,
0.1402379721403122,
0.03180694207549095,
0.6273338794708252,
-0.13517601788043976,
0.7914888262748718,
-0.28244635462760925,
-0.3695913255214691,
-0.46462512016296387,
-0.008778993971645832,
0.23730981349945068,
0.53998863697052,
0.39832714200019836,
-0.7517294883728027,
-0.6418880820274353,
0.2461269199848175,
-0.32942304015159607,
0.18139947950839996,
0.1779785305261612,
0.0458734929561615,
0.3086604177951813,
0.3742215931415558,
-0.7084279656410217,
0.2313336730003357,
0.48062124848365784,
-0.17354454100131989,
0.3191216289997101,
-0.1117093488574028,
0.14326006174087524,
-0.8349976539611816,
0.13807636499404907,
0.01597377471625805,
-0.22907912731170654,
-0.8777256608009338,
-0.04127369448542595,
-0.06720484048128128,
-0.38157176971435547,
-0.8212815523147583,
0.41120463609695435,
-0.6365257501602173,
0.0714937224984169,
-0.07933341711759567,
-0.5220604538917542,
-0.1755019873380661,
0.5925365090370178,
0.3176077902317047,
0.9416280388832092,
0.5024656057357788,
-0.5456411242485046,
-0.08248712867498398,
0.05649843066930771,
-0.2862824499607086,
-0.0012877301778644323,
-0.5207503437995911,
0.17314472794532776,
0.10408664494752884,
0.010769522748887539,
-1.1048166751861572,
-0.43416133522987366,
-0.012824395671486855,
-0.5318639874458313,
0.45174741744995117,
-0.1755986213684082,
-0.3768642544746399,
-0.2026594579219818,
-0.1197386384010315,
0.40290236473083496,
0.5266085267066956,
-0.3796949088573456,
0.8678041696548462,
0.0998573824763298,
0.35383304953575134,
-0.5327714085578918,
-0.6483420133590698,
-0.360256552696228,
-0.3115849196910858,
-0.24105720221996307,
0.10568040609359741,
-0.005188979208469391,
0.29151177406311035,
-0.24242374300956726,
-0.6607770323753357,
-0.003956677857786417,
-0.21484413743019104,
0.17505116760730743,
-0.2718602120876312,
-0.19650323688983917,
-0.2798306941986084,
-0.29194629192352295,
-0.377970814704895,
0.1524958461523056,
-0.5519846081733704,
0.423799991607666,
-0.16042475402355194,
-0.012671802192926407,
-0.2383514791727066,
0.03230724111199379,
0.829126238822937,
-0.4807456433773041,
0.8261932730674744,
0.6457298398017883,
-0.39935755729675293,
-0.14928770065307617,
-0.1794220358133316,
-0.6293111443519592,
-0.5583251714706421,
0.3407294452190399,
-0.4205629527568817,
-0.6673763990402222,
0.5406241416931152,
-0.243662029504776,
-0.22479058802127838,
0.13072438538074493,
0.41138607263565063,
-0.034745462238788605,
1.0008203983306885,
0.6715620756149292,
0.14671608805656433,
0.4845119118690491,
-0.36300092935562134,
0.5718478560447693,
-0.3620644807815552,
-0.08759615570306778,
-0.32652950286865234,
-0.3617478907108307,
-0.4744998514652252,
-0.5355728268623352,
0.5537665486335754,
-0.17652514576911926,
-0.20746824145317078,
0.4796612560749054,
-0.546254575252533,
0.5611888766288757,
0.28851965069770813,
0.07871946692466736,
0.1274116486310959,
0.49131569266319275,
-0.09017777442932129,
-0.02997683174908161,
-0.8118455410003662,
-0.14818644523620605,
1.326295256614685,
0.11192979663610458,
0.9926708340644836,
-0.047185953706502914,
0.5770208239555359,
-0.0341801643371582,
0.22322796285152435,
-0.6606642603874207,
0.5010811686515808,
-0.36893317103385925,
-0.8376214504241943,
-0.2521837651729584,
-0.30632996559143066,
-1.0314873456954956,
0.0661848932504654,
-0.21294642984867096,
-0.609451174736023,
0.22667953372001648,
0.39037472009658813,
-0.17808212339878082,
0.18908584117889404,
-0.9135482907295227,
1.2650233507156372,
-0.23349933326244354,
-0.5861143469810486,
-0.30281341075897217,
-0.8050472140312195,
0.061363108456134796,
-0.07820966094732285,
0.07816056907176971,
0.048130303621292114,
0.21769945323467255,
0.4898437261581421,
-0.5903846025466919,
0.7330173254013062,
-0.17571187019348145,
-0.08268432319164276,
0.25989359617233276,
0.001889527658931911,
0.16338182985782623,
-0.3844197690486908,
0.006737804040312767,
-0.04609459266066551,
0.21868999302387238,
-0.5379793047904968,
-0.6873469948768616,
0.5692336559295654,
-0.6529198288917542,
-0.6122953295707703,
-0.3129172921180725,
-0.30451396107673645,
-0.30798035860061646,
0.4353766441345215,
0.521174967288971,
0.3159407675266266,
-0.07946856319904327,
0.08713047206401825,
0.762066125869751,
0.1102847084403038,
0.30950024724006653,
0.3587658405303955,
-0.18936043977737427,
-0.23819640278816223,
1.1761475801467896,
0.11997852474451065,
0.5234255194664001,
0.7865487933158875,
0.032350923866033554,
-0.27284252643585205,
-0.6330483555793762,
-0.18580128252506256,
-0.04083772376179695,
-0.9201920628547668,
-0.1958329677581787,
-0.5916234254837036,
0.17353080213069916,
-0.32290664315223694,
-0.08117527514696121,
-0.6976831555366516,
-0.3307853043079376,
-0.3108566701412201,
-0.2948191463947296,
0.2846888303756714,
0.7507709860801697,
0.14262805879116058,
0.27033206820487976,
-0.7274864315986633,
0.49498021602630615,
-0.1064169853925705,
0.47395089268684387,
-0.1874079555273056,
-0.017935242503881454,
-0.28189921379089355,
0.051943812519311905,
-0.03277573361992836,
-0.938720703125,
0.194899320602417,
0.4338762164115906,
0.2785746157169342,
0.32181480526924133,
0.017591742798686028,
0.5249886512756348,
-0.3942682445049286,
0.6845835447311401,
-0.04737841710448265,
-0.8812190294265747,
0.5463767051696777,
-0.36181291937828064,
0.2999534606933594,
0.5099173188209534,
0.5062358975410461,
-0.14546319842338562,
-0.2325417399406433,
-0.5965074896812439,
-0.9230333566665649,
0.8455392122268677,
0.15939484536647797,
-0.10435030609369278,
-0.11179433763027191,
0.2518749535083771,
0.15622586011886597,
0.3507038652896881,
-0.5266286134719849,
-0.11937623471021652,
-0.3149091303348541,
-0.4290948212146759,
-0.16228105127811432,
0.12902936339378357,
0.3101683259010315,
-0.47749990224838257,
0.6872072219848633,
-0.02873735874891281,
0.23111574351787567,
0.012422888539731503,
-0.4173913896083832,
-0.16525526344776154,
0.2679939866065979,
0.3117840588092804,
0.48178786039352417,
-0.4009822607040405,
0.052480414509773254,
0.20107267796993256,
-0.6801177263259888,
0.32297372817993164,
-0.25487270951271057,
0.4870370626449585,
-0.17259596288204193,
0.2501455247402191,
0.7848620414733887,
0.1687510758638382,
-0.842383861541748,
0.28595200181007385,
-0.10200703144073486,
0.10391715168952942,
0.014666622504591942,
0.5473527908325195,
0.12082858383655548,
0.014433356933295727,
0.2594301402568817,
0.4212976396083832,
0.2773088812828064,
-0.816275954246521,
0.2106034755706787,
0.29884931445121765,
-0.42528560757637024,
-0.5223994255065918,
1.0620774030685425,
0.18545646965503693,
0.1127413734793663,
0.38283395767211914,
-0.0004869728290941566,
-0.48499757051467896,
0.6538481712341309,
0.38975024223327637,
0.6216861009597778,
-0.3831748366355896,
-0.33567649126052856,
0.3333708643913269,
0.09818683564662933,
0.006463788449764252,
0.6583998799324036,
-0.09691087156534195,
-0.6127206087112427,
-0.01514245755970478,
-0.7753235101699829,
-0.13223914802074432,
0.1118706539273262,
-0.49585890769958496,
0.14032067358493805,
-0.5994508862495422,
-0.270488440990448,
0.23238065838813782,
0.10270043462514877,
-0.8294234275817871,
0.5461499691009521,
0.052851602435112,
0.966132640838623,
-0.8291632533073425,
0.8125374913215637,
0.9239413142204285,
-0.40047264099121094,
-0.8614582419395447,
-0.030504334717988968,
-0.15547266602516174,
-0.2601810395717621,
0.5648824572563171,
0.372219443321228,
-0.34659963846206665,
0.26240772008895874,
-0.47666728496551514,
-0.7814779281616211,
0.8666166067123413,
0.5231731534004211,
-0.58927983045578,
-0.09977105259895325,
0.6185084581375122,
0.7322770357131958,
-0.32959651947021484,
0.29178935289382935,
1.1124275922775269,
0.5419111847877502,
0.007497432641685009,
-0.8238115906715393,
0.09654276818037033,
-0.31606781482696533,
0.006845817901194096,
-0.014529098756611347,
-0.48873794078826904,
0.8101356029510498,
-0.18156427145004272,
-0.46076804399490356,
-0.09673510491847992,
0.7553626894950867,
-0.11597412079572678,
-0.09100650250911713,
0.009725683368742466,
0.3449136018753052,
0.45763659477233887,
-0.26302576065063477,
1.2862484455108643,
-0.8419187664985657,
0.334250807762146,
0.5668726563453674,
-0.09307810664176941,
0.925580620765686,
0.4959444999694824,
-0.4465847313404083,
0.11596141010522842,
0.6443464159965515,
0.07439957559108734,
0.6788375377655029,
0.10312073677778244,
-0.3099919557571411,
-0.31411778926849365,
0.16751141846179962,
-0.0408032163977623,
0.3127460181713104,
0.7186993956565857,
-0.23504169285297394,
-0.06713403016328812,
0.06536541879177094,
-0.15007992088794708,
-0.05434460937976837,
-0.38907837867736816,
0.6784696578979492,
0.04354123771190643,
-0.9046464562416077,
0.8543182015419006,
-0.008362340740859509,
0.6608209609985352,
-0.5045601725578308,
0.02434617094695568,
-0.25929364562034607,
0.7427107691764832,
-0.3565274775028229,
-0.643980085849762,
0.053239673376083374,
-0.18897724151611328,
-0.12029082328081131,
-0.07401666045188904,
0.9112585783004761,
-0.768401026725769,
-0.49437448382377625,
0.20896734297275543,
0.23491765558719635,
0.06436324864625931,
-0.21051350235939026,
-0.47351396083831787,
-0.023585040122270584,
0.13197582960128784,
-0.1619458794593811,
0.33511561155319214,
0.33491817116737366,
-0.07215623557567596,
0.6474298238754272,
0.6913748979568481,
-0.08514093607664108,
0.20981867611408234,
-0.02700895629823208,
0.9162780046463013,
-0.5344436764717102,
-0.43308401107788086,
-0.6158588528633118,
0.5529784560203552,
0.5759705305099487,
0.042363811284303665,
0.5087565779685974,
0.7251638770103455,
1.0040050745010376,
-0.7750819325447083,
0.8518343567848206,
0.31539103388786316,
0.02534734457731247,
-0.7144859433174133,
0.6710801720619202,
-0.45444321632385254,
0.15530578792095184,
-0.1558557003736496,
-0.9502114057540894,
-0.09509110450744629,
0.42404985427856445,
-0.20494437217712402,
0.4351138174533844,
0.8654622435569763,
0.8332026600837708,
-0.5298019051551819,
-0.12565207481384277,
0.20474191009998322,
0.3229193389415741,
0.5108075737953186,
0.6768092513084412,
0.45568493008613586,
-0.37205156683921814,
0.20403032004833221,
-0.15138477087020874,
0.31021320819854736,
-0.17320315539836884,
-0.619465172290802,
-1.0547633171081543,
-0.46108129620552063,
-0.1722634881734848,
-0.1134069412946701,
0.3904958963394165,
0.8957423567771912,
0.5702710151672363,
-1.1145808696746826,
-0.3681337833404541,
-0.4935793876647949,
-0.36081463098526,
-0.1341036707162857,
-0.13887786865234375,
0.0895533412694931,
-0.48182162642478943,
-0.8224203586578369,
0.28985652327537537,
0.26076990365982056,
0.15527451038360596,
-0.21201768517494202,
0.06318292021751404,
-0.0653090849518776,
0.20697568356990814,
0.4673815667629242,
0.22159458696842194,
-0.8405256867408752,
-0.14527910947799683,
0.14190112054347992,
0.13734370470046997,
0.4972456395626068,
0.9823313355445862,
-0.8857985138893127,
0.4857877790927887,
0.4865246117115021,
0.4927268326282501,
0.699333667755127,
0.16845771670341492,
0.9441461563110352,
-0.8795936107635498,
0.03924323990941048,
0.0671439841389656,
0.3013007342815399,
0.34811466932296753,
-0.3859104812145233,
0.41380059719085693,
0.193773090839386,
-0.19106251001358032,
-0.6064153909683228,
0.10809975862503052,
-0.8372971415519714,
-0.3998878598213196,
0.9234485626220703,
-0.18451009690761566,
-0.6086592078208923,
0.19971151649951935,
-0.005413217470049858,
0.4708150029182434,
-0.473613977432251,
0.39650848507881165,
0.6592592597007751,
-0.392656147480011,
-0.2945801913738251,
-0.3926973044872284,
1.092189073562622,
0.6437497735023499,
-0.7054663896560669,
0.3002609610557556,
0.42348939180374146,
0.4524417221546173,
0.21748724579811096,
0.2712447941303253,
0.11280398815870285,
0.41961538791656494,
0.15649180114269257,
0.022213341668248177,
-0.06613297760486603,
-0.7415575981140137,
-0.16945193707942963,
-0.08358239382505417,
0.053227175027132034,
0.12317363172769547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10620v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10620v1
|
MC-GPT: Empowering Vision-and-Language Navigation with Memory Map and Reasoning Chains
| 2024-05-17T08:33:27 | 2024-05-17T08:33:27 |
Zhaohuan Zhan, Lisha Yu, Sijie Yu, Guang Tan
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
In the Vision-and-Language Navigation (VLN) task, the agent is required to
navigate to a destination following a natural language instruction. While
learning-based approaches have been a major solution to the task, they suffer
from high training costs and lack of interpretability. Recently, Large Language
Models (LLMs) have emerged as a promising tool for VLN due to their strong
generalization capabilities. However, existing LLM-based methods face
limitations in memory construction and diversity of navigation strategies. To
address these challenges, we propose a suite of techniques. Firstly, we
introduce a method to maintain a topological map that stores navigation
history, retaining information about viewpoints, objects, and their spatial
relationships. This map also serves as a global action space. Additionally, we
present a Navigation Chain of Thoughts module, leveraging human navigation
examples to enrich navigation strategy diversity. Finally, we establish a
pipeline that integrates navigational memory and strategies with perception and
action prediction modules. Experimental results on the REVERIE and R2R datasets
show that our method effectively enhances the navigation ability of the LLM and
improves the interpretability of navigation reasoning.
|
[
-0.45699214935302734,
-0.7171895503997803,
0.978993833065033,
-0.2560747265815735,
-0.25125157833099365,
0.19511203467845917,
-0.31137728691101074,
-0.2598324716091156,
0.2823382616043091,
0.7076418995857239,
-0.3370117247104645,
-0.6267938613891602,
-0.3771530091762543,
-0.417929083108902,
-0.013892273418605328,
0.7980355024337769,
-0.13855606317520142,
-0.10189785808324814,
-0.09091345965862274,
-0.09456003457307816,
-0.5003478527069092,
-0.6691662669181824,
-0.7768921852111816,
-0.2860415279865265,
0.7214927673339844,
0.34536704421043396,
0.7227583527565002,
0.5133660435676575,
0.6001938581466675,
0.24224340915679932,
0.01644292287528515,
0.44516703486442566,
-0.4910431504249573,
0.07278826087713242,
-0.6530616879463196,
-0.31388407945632935,
-0.5169397592544556,
-0.42865726351737976,
0.6435866951942444,
0.4811451733112335,
-0.33529314398765564,
-0.1348991096019745,
-0.2189927101135254,
0.639787495136261,
-0.6534631848335266,
0.3902563452720642,
-0.6208322644233704,
0.14614912867546082,
0.09488987922668457,
-0.2085399329662323,
-0.3055436611175537,
-0.1101919561624527,
0.3657298982143402,
-0.5831307172775269,
-0.22675402462482452,
0.3686366081237793,
0.5487822890281677,
0.2803845703601837,
-0.6428647041320801,
-0.32428550720214844,
-0.8209243416786194,
0.8174628615379333,
-0.18726572394371033,
0.460016131401062,
0.19733001291751862,
0.6440741419792175,
-0.20227158069610596,
-0.6493324041366577,
-0.40294113755226135,
-0.24312448501586914,
0.15278631448745728,
0.3191286325454712,
0.12445890158414841,
0.07695524394512177,
0.07563810050487518,
0.0666898638010025,
-0.6522604823112488,
-0.12697306275367737,
-0.3747829496860504,
-0.15680064260959625,
0.44907689094543457,
0.26851433515548706,
0.551142692565918,
0.15169429779052734,
-0.5727962255477905,
-0.1018633022904396,
-0.737561821937561,
-0.2517976760864258,
-0.13153187930583954,
0.3958984315395355,
-0.006694340612739325,
0.5818911194801331,
-0.2146281599998474,
0.8789146542549133,
-0.36443454027175903,
-0.14868207275867462,
-0.02502277120947838,
-0.23025085031986237,
-0.2428567260503769,
-0.10600745677947998,
0.5811098217964172,
0.49221885204315186,
0.7120973467826843,
-0.4416179955005646,
-0.02678866684436798,
-0.011116391979157925,
0.6567614674568176,
-0.44853705167770386,
-0.4583039879798889,
-0.11875679343938828,
0.032419752329587936,
0.12011655420064926,
-0.023863008245825768,
-0.8111861944198608,
-0.3413884937763214,
-0.4837304949760437,
0.377463161945343,
-0.3931255042552948,
-0.460796594619751,
0.3200390338897705,
-0.16903305053710938,
0.5229198932647705,
0.5713794827461243,
-0.8173000812530518,
0.3474246859550476,
0.5796979069709778,
0.8063875436782837,
-0.30712857842445374,
-0.3453589081764221,
-0.28635701537132263,
0.5484201312065125,
-0.1461271345615387,
0.5989510416984558,
-0.7150434851646423,
-0.4997386336326599,
-0.05494346842169762,
-0.05499787628650665,
-0.22847825288772583,
-0.4291064143180847,
0.2353031039237976,
-0.3826133608818054,
0.02090064063668251,
-0.642445981502533,
-0.16606763005256653,
-0.6363067626953125,
0.7596036791801453,
-0.4725118577480316,
0.6264795660972595,
0.027640245854854584,
-0.34188759326934814,
0.16967038810253143,
-0.5345781445503235,
-0.4057154357433319,
0.0071557736955583096,
-0.5348052382469177,
-0.08036433905363083,
0.2080230712890625,
0.4252626597881317,
0.34674009680747986,
-0.2182266116142273,
0.14225749671459198,
-0.012181012891232967,
-0.42074453830718994,
-0.1095074936747551,
-0.1825752556324005,
0.38687074184417725,
-0.08939366787672043,
-0.33342084288597107,
-0.036430682986974716,
-0.2867330014705658,
0.0379800982773304,
0.2037043273448944,
-0.5191104412078857,
-0.35806962847709656,
0.2568611800670624,
-0.2043292075395584,
0.3246338665485382,
0.18958140909671783,
-0.09947192668914795,
0.6586960554122925,
-0.1544267237186432,
0.049133069813251495,
0.708265483379364,
0.051947254687547684,
0.4923883080482483,
-0.21048498153686523,
0.6261933445930481,
0.22143712639808655,
0.20204557478427887,
-0.12028343230485916,
-0.7927490472793579,
-0.9267370700836182,
-0.03980129957199097,
-0.2856023609638214,
0.7015787363052368,
-1.2614588737487793,
-0.03261891007423401,
-0.6624829173088074,
-0.29940763115882874,
-0.0335310697555542,
0.03455176576972008,
0.328727662563324,
0.4361949563026428,
0.5752149820327759,
-0.447113573551178,
-0.3900328576564789,
-0.43079692125320435,
-0.15041537582874298,
-0.3624727725982666,
0.17336462438106537,
0.5768106579780579,
0.40664857625961304,
-0.5358541011810303,
0.8769020438194275,
-0.47307685017585754,
-0.1696702241897583,
-0.41678228974342346,
-0.35911092162132263,
-0.020378366112709045,
0.4360528886318207,
0.2680429220199585,
-0.9887746572494507,
-0.14647334814071655,
0.22158080339431763,
-0.7779478430747986,
0.2916410267353058,
-0.33283406496047974,
-0.3777306079864502,
0.06604135781526566,
0.4924450218677521,
-0.5254453420639038,
0.5081430077552795,
0.3050372302532196,
-0.4493538737297058,
0.36075544357299805,
-0.20245705544948578,
0.13218319416046143,
-0.8478038311004639,
-0.22354984283447266,
-0.014757145196199417,
-0.28921014070510864,
-0.5509149432182312,
0.4869483709335327,
-0.10577088594436646,
-0.027871837839484215,
-0.6513863801956177,
0.8737366199493408,
-0.6542485952377319,
-0.2526794373989105,
-0.20274941623210907,
0.321103036403656,
-0.23179298639297485,
0.9235166311264038,
0.3812831938266754,
0.5464282035827637,
0.6865766644477844,
-0.6649670004844666,
0.3098992705345154,
0.05153448134660721,
-0.023365816101431847,
0.469170480966568,
-0.24984528124332428,
0.2377663552761078,
-0.14078156650066376,
0.15586833655834198,
-0.9295102953910828,
0.14194847643375397,
0.5046598315238953,
-0.07782431691884995,
0.3851318657398224,
-0.40197107195854187,
-0.3858417868614197,
-0.2671467959880829,
0.05720765143632889,
0.4456109404563904,
0.634418785572052,
-0.5996978282928467,
0.9776953458786011,
0.41454288363456726,
-0.014562172815203667,
-0.35447433590888977,
-0.76463782787323,
0.30949845910072327,
-0.1983637511730194,
-0.4193272590637207,
-0.015586461871862411,
-0.04283953830599785,
-0.10004084557294846,
-0.19229699671268463,
-0.18026979267597198,
0.12548725306987762,
-0.12435393780469894,
0.38874536752700806,
0.45509082078933716,
-0.13389459252357483,
0.21540877223014832,
-0.18003423511981964,
-0.19455251097679138,
-0.036000944674015045,
-1.016026496887207,
0.5825828909873962,
-0.4453543424606323,
-0.6364431381225586,
0.22340071201324463,
0.22921644151210785,
0.5442588925361633,
-0.30040213465690613,
0.6052005887031555,
0.6051496267318726,
-0.1714426577091217,
-0.023650936782360077,
-0.5249856114387512,
-0.05921655520796776,
-0.4691120386123657,
0.33666980266571045,
-0.37721532583236694,
-1.0822895765304565,
0.355136513710022,
-0.63783860206604,
-0.07120522856712341,
0.0829898789525032,
0.6580794453620911,
-0.016944942995905876,
0.5082992315292358,
0.6541851758956909,
-0.11546909064054489,
0.2863474488258362,
-0.3827817738056183,
0.3970728814601898,
-1.0562859773635864,
-0.40768781304359436,
0.12760034203529358,
-0.6731405258178711,
-0.48490872979164124,
-0.9920576810836792,
0.45096635818481445,
-0.029879948124289513,
-0.3368147909641266,
0.1348113715648651,
-0.45094555616378784,
0.7082567811012268,
0.46611878275871277,
0.027351049706339836,
0.24694857001304626,
0.21000295877456665,
-0.6351249814033508,
-0.021926045417785645,
-0.8507545590400696,
-0.36167117953300476,
1.200831413269043,
-0.016652947291731834,
0.7656553983688354,
0.3108491003513336,
0.7608775496482849,
-0.030906129628419876,
0.14646649360656738,
-0.7915346026420593,
1.0095837116241455,
0.009824948385357857,
-0.3215859830379486,
-0.3208272159099579,
-0.4751856029033661,
-0.736964762210846,
0.5314193964004517,
-0.09425830096006393,
-1.0550823211669922,
0.09855084866285324,
0.11583951860666275,
-0.2684420645236969,
0.6567066311836243,
-0.6232628226280212,
0.7276967763900757,
-0.48590829968452454,
-0.44735950231552124,
-0.06885936856269836,
-0.57686448097229,
0.3038144111633301,
0.17314811050891876,
0.10444654524326324,
0.34075531363487244,
-0.31851187348365784,
0.21412746608257294,
-0.08273658901453018,
0.7716757655143738,
-0.15349890291690826,
0.06732267886400223,
0.37181857228279114,
0.12490130960941315,
0.616692304611206,
-0.14460541307926178,
0.2633673846721649,
0.09650710970163345,
-0.6630712151527405,
-0.2786523103713989,
-0.6266197562217712,
0.7518919706344604,
-0.37233465909957886,
-0.6520841121673584,
-0.400767982006073,
-0.4767010807991028,
-0.2265164703130722,
0.017448194324970245,
-0.1556457132101059,
0.43205782771110535,
-0.17807653546333313,
-0.09977003931999207,
0.8366830945014954,
-0.49071457982063293,
0.4221307337284088,
0.43354150652885437,
-0.6334502696990967,
-0.2208850383758545,
1.1670241355895996,
0.08583903312683105,
0.37355396151542664,
0.5892618298530579,
0.08981817960739136,
-0.3250848948955536,
-0.6587168574333191,
-0.3935491442680359,
0.20861348509788513,
-0.6652166247367859,
0.2365257292985916,
-0.6204005479812622,
-0.2580254375934601,
0.017601298168301582,
-0.2924302816390991,
-0.27869275212287903,
-0.46846258640289307,
0.08500079065561295,
-0.1510651707649231,
0.21664674580097198,
0.5323455333709717,
-0.12372391670942307,
0.24178588390350342,
-0.3852173984050751,
0.4581010043621063,
0.6319150328636169,
0.10553952306509018,
0.11707545816898346,
-0.13977135717868805,
-0.37300094962120056,
-0.014934300445020199,
-0.23200534284114838,
-0.6264727711677551,
0.358791708946228,
-0.0457751601934433,
0.5130856037139893,
0.266784131526947,
-0.2780792713165283,
0.7056480050086975,
-0.6509919762611389,
0.7492334842681885,
0.2248253971338272,
-0.4948969781398773,
0.7540594339370728,
-0.41450515389442444,
0.612542450428009,
0.2996951937675476,
0.2439270168542862,
-0.5109549760818481,
-0.42054757475852966,
-0.5199693441390991,
-0.9410132169723511,
0.11828688532114029,
0.12608972191810608,
-0.3587535619735718,
-0.02173011377453804,
0.4675898253917694,
-0.4792881906032562,
0.22770461440086365,
-0.5288833975791931,
-0.026587536558508873,
-0.07966697216033936,
-0.09130409359931946,
-0.32250216603279114,
-0.04908633232116699,
-0.022571783512830734,
-0.28245893120765686,
0.3440597951412201,
-0.2815474271774292,
0.2816475033760071,
0.23789268732070923,
-0.12371180951595306,
0.2459019422531128,
0.1805589646100998,
0.6494143009185791,
0.6840300559997559,
-0.12469851970672607,
0.25387606024742126,
0.3338391184806824,
-0.8026630282402039,
0.21043314039707184,
-0.39468058943748474,
-0.15550409257411957,
-0.22973360121250153,
0.22836686670780182,
0.6826599836349487,
0.25598031282424927,
-0.7598116993904114,
0.17545238137245178,
-0.04412200301885605,
0.0427541546523571,
-0.27345991134643555,
0.44867032766342163,
0.27602145075798035,
0.4462517499923706,
0.015382332727313042,
0.12215559184551239,
0.16366323828697205,
-0.721217691898346,
0.08629439026117325,
0.38113656640052795,
-0.6609293222427368,
-0.061615001410245895,
0.48570483922958374,
0.05692485347390175,
-0.24915637075901031,
0.7656905055046082,
-0.27627992630004883,
-0.6908491849899292,
0.44891685247421265,
0.21724748611450195,
0.9536939263343811,
-0.20014351606369019,
0.13513557612895966,
0.2215258777141571,
0.7609802484512329,
-0.22867318987846375,
0.539354681968689,
-0.2230973243713379,
-0.6816209554672241,
-0.277937650680542,
-0.47519850730895996,
-0.4447858929634094,
-0.3954715430736542,
-0.4843628704547882,
-0.22041429579257965,
-0.5730421543121338,
-0.21768981218338013,
-0.8678929805755615,
-0.006850820500403643,
-0.8629963994026184,
0.3714599907398224,
0.34572404623031616,
0.707589864730835,
-0.43629854917526245,
1.0658286809921265,
0.8284680843353271,
-0.2398851364850998,
-0.6544224619865417,
0.07701610028743744,
0.2525092661380768,
-0.9689950346946716,
0.5735477805137634,
-0.028004741296172142,
-0.4069681465625763,
-0.03258036449551582,
-0.3001039922237396,
-0.7078525424003601,
1.3314173221588135,
0.11659983545541763,
-0.902838408946991,
-0.12999171018600464,
0.1752166748046875,
0.35784101486206055,
-0.4852176904678345,
0.00031270281760953367,
0.5726848244667053,
0.4342520833015442,
0.4521581828594208,
-0.6471550464630127,
0.01924290880560875,
-0.06725799292325974,
0.16250380873680115,
0.4629145860671997,
-0.6910443902015686,
0.7197496294975281,
-0.6334942579269409,
-0.1510009616613388,
-0.1273289918899536,
0.37611666321754456,
0.5583897829055786,
0.20205380022525787,
0.39986100792884827,
0.8754944801330566,
0.852105975151062,
-0.2636949419975281,
1.2158606052398682,
0.024105867370963097,
0.13360661268234253,
1.3686540126800537,
-0.24806736409664154,
0.92375248670578,
0.6751784682273865,
0.26757314801216125,
0.5122658610343933,
0.20666642487049103,
0.22477643191814423,
0.7224523425102234,
0.5274128317832947,
-0.21608641743659973,
-0.4711024761199951,
0.08318613469600677,
-0.3182061016559601,
0.35730284452438354,
0.6331515312194824,
-0.24078084528446198,
-0.19606810808181763,
0.009702435694634914,
-0.04440569877624512,
-0.24740739166736603,
-0.5132614970207214,
0.7382113337516785,
0.29590556025505066,
-0.4596690535545349,
0.2508871853351593,
-0.3558015823364258,
0.30833521485328674,
-0.646758496761322,
-0.10929166525602341,
-0.20130655169487,
0.2681933343410492,
0.26466983556747437,
-0.7550197243690491,
0.20990093052387238,
-0.15135107934474945,
0.0935676172375679,
-0.19508928060531616,
0.8168074488639832,
-0.5762898921966553,
-0.5651692152023315,
0.35908326506614685,
0.7723301649093628,
0.1917257457971573,
-0.16957403719425201,
-0.4842599332332611,
0.09694740176200867,
0.025837181136012077,
-0.170860156416893,
0.37942469120025635,
0.5989794731140137,
-0.03694356232881546,
1.1751360893249512,
0.4480690360069275,
0.23654675483703613,
0.14430248737335205,
0.055951282382011414,
0.8005213737487793,
-1.0518077611923218,
-0.49489331245422363,
-0.9511929750442505,
0.6588104367256165,
-0.05520317703485489,
-0.14541801810264587,
0.593332052230835,
0.5363733172416687,
0.6738350987434387,
-0.07105467468500137,
0.685025691986084,
0.39344048500061035,
-0.03561105206608772,
-0.9480394124984741,
0.6219990253448486,
-0.5316557884216309,
0.2494872808456421,
-0.2742217779159546,
-0.9048265218734741,
-0.24278533458709717,
0.6166296601295471,
-0.3452499210834503,
0.11974387615919113,
0.7461293935775757,
0.7275342345237732,
-0.2653558850288391,
-0.12528756260871887,
0.39624008536338806,
0.04087378457188606,
0.4876954257488251,
1.279557466506958,
0.8885583281517029,
-0.21362757682800293,
0.42698290944099426,
0.287479043006897,
-0.11627339571714401,
-0.14730750024318695,
-0.7881414890289307,
-1.0471526384353638,
-0.4560171365737915,
-0.4136554002761841,
0.04066476970911026,
0.36114582419395447,
0.45423680543899536,
0.7873058319091797,
-0.3336258828639984,
-0.39609047770500183,
-0.1559983491897583,
0.33262795209884644,
-0.272148072719574,
-0.11068494617938995,
0.17966516315937042,
-0.07582404464483261,
-0.3783186972141266,
0.44154855608940125,
0.889371931552887,
0.3277890980243683,
-0.4691685140132904,
-0.4434468746185303,
-0.21060660481452942,
-0.004499182105064392,
0.6258413791656494,
0.3736080229282379,
-0.8322663307189941,
-0.30703458189964294,
-0.14627088606357574,
0.10839250683784485,
-0.10214212536811829,
0.7131664752960205,
-1.0998860597610474,
0.6879077553749084,
0.15410394966602325,
0.7124166488647461,
0.7147746682167053,
-0.22059208154678345,
0.807997465133667,
-0.3934118151664734,
0.19749611616134644,
0.16816166043281555,
0.4895033538341522,
0.26128527522087097,
-0.1529705971479416,
0.8261156678199768,
0.146811842918396,
-0.3990550637245178,
-0.2807222306728363,
0.3705732822418213,
-1.3681143522262573,
-0.20047920942306519,
1.1214483976364136,
-0.04084354266524315,
-0.30023133754730225,
-0.11707738041877747,
-0.37518730759620667,
-0.059190209954977036,
-0.20980526506900787,
0.5471437573432922,
0.6964049339294434,
0.1037660762667656,
-0.37799715995788574,
-0.6970118880271912,
0.2760757505893707,
-0.025903193280100822,
-0.8353546261787415,
-0.26301640272140503,
0.4187901020050049,
-0.04843660444021225,
0.20661157369613647,
0.6885586977005005,
0.07844143360853195,
0.2395433485507965,
-0.09715710580348969,
-0.09507042914628983,
-0.10828093439340591,
-0.8946560025215149,
-0.04256463423371315,
0.08187418431043625,
-0.24139606952667236,
-0.2766651213169098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10616v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10616v1
|
Feature-based Low-Rank Compression of Large Language Models via Bayesian Optimization
| 2024-05-17T08:27:12 | 2024-05-17T08:27:12 |
Yixin Ji, Yang Xiang, Juntao Li, Wei Chen, Zhongyi Liu, Kehai Chen, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have driven advances in natural
language processing. Still, their growing scale has increased the computational
burden, necessitating a balance between efficiency and performance. Low-rank
compression, a promising technique, reduces non-essential parameters by
decomposing weight matrices into products of two low-rank matrices. Yet, its
application in LLMs has not been extensively studied. The key to low-rank
compression lies in low-rank factorization and low-rank dimensions allocation.
To address the challenges of low-rank compression in LLMs, we conduct empirical
research on the low-rank characteristics of large models. We propose a low-rank
compression method suitable for LLMs. This approach involves precise estimation
of feature distributions through pooled covariance matrices and a Bayesian
optimization strategy for allocating low-rank dimensions. Experiments on the
LLaMA-2 models demonstrate that our method outperforms existing strong
structured pruning and low-rank compression techniques in maintaining model
performance at the same compression ratio.
|
[
-0.47163617610931396,
-0.7558199763298035,
0.6534804701805115,
0.08922241628170013,
-0.38373345136642456,
0.20530752837657928,
-0.3458267152309418,
-0.3445393443107605,
0.4011007249355316,
0.7097494602203369,
-0.5725685358047485,
-0.5436180830001831,
-0.7310122847557068,
-0.010178005322813988,
-0.3229554295539856,
0.6867354512214661,
0.29039493203163147,
-0.19732213020324707,
-0.21873430907726288,
0.04729809612035751,
-0.3701231777667999,
-0.6530612111091614,
-0.5489590764045715,
-0.10603222250938416,
0.5387527346611023,
0.49770480394363403,
0.6947911381721497,
0.6082075834274292,
0.635711133480072,
0.26298052072525024,
-0.4179452955722809,
0.2080797404050827,
-0.6818053722381592,
0.26658546924591064,
0.1029566153883934,
-0.4853250980377197,
-0.6580343842506409,
-0.07236539572477341,
0.8826623558998108,
1.172014832496643,
-0.11605296283960342,
0.3085785508155823,
0.31961143016815186,
0.4772644639015198,
-0.6937524676322937,
0.13108918070793152,
-0.5156078934669495,
-0.15874706208705902,
-0.21363304555416107,
-0.23208115994930267,
-0.27031242847442627,
-0.47298121452331543,
-0.23484790325164795,
-0.1700553596019745,
0.3584006428718567,
0.13405634462833405,
0.6522170901298523,
0.48371338844299316,
-0.18481342494487762,
0.17791949212551117,
-0.8072792291641235,
0.906970202922821,
-0.8061700463294983,
0.12470914423465729,
0.4273882508277893,
0.11982022970914841,
-0.2966056764125824,
-0.05943288281559944,
-0.4052060544490814,
-0.136957049369812,
0.006722467951476574,
-0.3014167845249176,
-0.1712009757757187,
0.12625855207443237,
0.20200325548648834,
0.4280816912651062,
-0.7028893828392029,
0.6762547492980957,
-0.3229067623615265,
-0.06632447987794876,
0.7145040035247803,
-0.09704113751649857,
-0.01310360711067915,
-0.1474875956773758,
-0.16787877678871155,
-0.32190099358558655,
-1.0037450790405273,
-0.050084568560123444,
0.47225266695022583,
0.5509707927703857,
-0.07518848776817322,
0.7547405958175659,
-0.3472222089767456,
0.6105396151542664,
-0.13566596806049347,
-0.5278719067573547,
-0.04922058433294296,
0.12446079403162003,
-0.19241786003112793,
0.08425582945346832,
0.5670137405395508,
0.032271094620227814,
-0.02763100154697895,
-0.09069442749023438,
-0.22308848798274994,
0.277269572019577,
-0.0521576926112175,
-0.912129819393158,
-0.23293912410736084,
0.23572970926761627,
-0.6693071126937866,
-0.5653542280197144,
-0.23952922224998474,
-0.9095707535743713,
-0.45048317313194275,
-0.09441670030355453,
0.5477309226989746,
0.005891692824661732,
-0.1318211406469345,
0.08269540220499039,
0.022301964461803436,
-0.15456227958202362,
0.36802616715431213,
-1.055597186088562,
0.4040055572986603,
0.8301224112510681,
0.8451850414276123,
-0.12777698040008545,
0.027117816731333733,
-0.8411305546760559,
0.16095656156539917,
-0.2300165891647339,
0.7293859124183655,
-0.7295638918876648,
-0.278453528881073,
-0.06403832137584686,
-0.2443222552537918,
0.2588478922843933,
-0.7157608270645142,
0.45976290106773376,
-0.14186051487922668,
-0.15023618936538696,
-0.10028868168592453,
-0.38543838262557983,
-0.002164853736758232,
0.1068197712302208,
-0.6441718339920044,
1.0582835674285889,
0.18090416491031647,
-0.5408310294151306,
0.1163734644651413,
-0.2946777045726776,
-0.3668273985385895,
-0.012827130034565926,
-0.14821527898311615,
-0.4860762655735016,
0.6883408427238464,
0.4337020516395569,
0.6187765598297119,
-0.6990158557891846,
0.12258005142211914,
-0.6184093952178955,
-0.5181727409362793,
0.19841711223125458,
-0.48409658670425415,
0.498159259557724,
0.1801271289587021,
0.09279022365808487,
-0.10175643116235733,
-0.7002742290496826,
-0.11682320386171341,
0.21071825921535492,
-0.4182589054107666,
-0.36140450835227966,
0.20982444286346436,
-0.20706665515899658,
0.0183575376868248,
0.43254581093788147,
-0.41414475440979004,
0.646773099899292,
-0.38954782485961914,
0.37382933497428894,
0.44517695903778076,
0.0732354074716568,
0.6066845655441284,
-0.2502056360244751,
0.4352022409439087,
-0.041958533227443695,
0.14328181743621826,
0.2887631952762604,
-0.4467158019542694,
-0.8150426149368286,
-0.6504690647125244,
0.36311885714530945,
0.40558457374572754,
-0.5556204915046692,
0.758783221244812,
-0.6628787517547607,
-0.4586414098739624,
-0.5885321497917175,
0.2264474332332611,
0.16525030136108398,
0.12948907911777496,
0.48800837993621826,
-0.44604676961898804,
-0.07982999086380005,
-1.1336270570755005,
0.09035594761371613,
-0.33221670985221863,
-0.318649023771286,
0.13539545238018036,
0.185601145029068,
-0.0664542093873024,
0.8240112662315369,
-0.7103549242019653,
-0.10109291970729828,
-0.5249035358428955,
0.5628597140312195,
0.2701515853404999,
0.6575421094894409,
0.4760180711746216,
-0.38450416922569275,
-0.0014776495518162847,
-0.31913551688194275,
-0.1754043996334076,
-0.4811583161354065,
0.09532447904348373,
-0.00957682728767395,
0.25172632932662964,
0.2500306963920593,
-0.7401924729347229,
0.4386400878429413,
0.9253844618797302,
0.03293163329362869,
0.18113580346107483,
-0.23539388179779053,
-0.07672012597322464,
-0.8998622298240662,
-0.07721425592899323,
0.012402121908962727,
-0.20539945363998413,
-0.4863578677177429,
-0.04868055507540703,
-0.14990437030792236,
-0.3805356025695801,
-0.0694240853190422,
0.41531533002853394,
-0.4298159182071686,
-0.43202412128448486,
-0.422240674495697,
-0.029806524515151978,
0.003151852637529373,
0.6425339579582214,
0.1629030853509903,
0.545376181602478,
0.2975124418735504,
-0.5015833377838135,
-0.007398894056677818,
0.1402064561843872,
-0.48597636818885803,
0.4270235300064087,
-0.33146247267723083,
0.06070045754313469,
-0.24817973375320435,
0.17503957450389862,
-0.9337626099586487,
0.002906492678448558,
0.15399746596813202,
-0.12420434504747391,
0.5310028195381165,
-0.5086578726768494,
-0.7375037670135498,
-0.11386465281248093,
-0.5402160882949829,
0.3979334235191345,
0.7548165917396545,
-0.4642758071422577,
0.0749860554933548,
0.569072425365448,
-0.6865459680557251,
-0.29730793833732605,
-0.6814095973968506,
0.20729470252990723,
-0.4388391375541687,
-0.4500284492969513,
0.6095538139343262,
-0.033768780529499054,
-0.07140888273715973,
-0.17969854176044464,
-0.09244824200868607,
0.08415074646472931,
0.3438098132610321,
0.08845390379428864,
0.17885494232177734,
-0.15508557856082916,
-0.013923434540629387,
0.38148027658462524,
-0.09103618562221527,
-0.2292921096086502,
-0.07266848534345627,
0.6830279231071472,
0.24265097081661224,
-0.34344637393951416,
-0.325052946805954,
0.5681880712509155,
0.2583661377429962,
-0.03557993099093437,
0.7394220232963562,
0.45963385701179504,
-0.41138899326324463,
-0.4718347191810608,
-0.6760904788970947,
-0.2670058310031891,
-0.4425555467605591,
0.32628682255744934,
-0.13064546883106232,
-1.2912176847457886,
0.28159740567207336,
-0.48096415400505066,
-0.26058048009872437,
0.33203285932540894,
0.5005383491516113,
-0.03881504014134407,
1.0560967922210693,
0.9308512806892395,
-0.2885822653770447,
0.2710759937763214,
-0.1369088739156723,
0.46114838123321533,
-0.6980597972869873,
0.18795906007289886,
-0.9162010550498962,
-0.6408464312553406,
-0.9226073026657104,
-0.699564516544342,
0.46608448028564453,
0.5599527955055237,
-0.27714553475379944,
0.19217881560325623,
-0.46544772386550903,
0.21493959426879883,
0.47749003767967224,
-0.09809602051973343,
0.2514358460903168,
0.3423234522342682,
0.1258581131696701,
-0.03824855387210846,
-0.6547135710716248,
-0.4577575922012329,
0.7134732007980347,
0.5058708190917969,
1.0436686277389526,
0.48189395666122437,
0.9257844090461731,
0.22310611605644226,
0.17621567845344543,
-0.8751457929611206,
0.6072283983230591,
-0.3410642445087433,
-0.043176475912332535,
-0.39598292112350464,
-0.6480549573898315,
-0.8015711307525635,
0.1767522692680359,
-0.4166921079158783,
-1.1205401420593262,
0.5097739696502686,
-0.019480839371681213,
-0.36606308817863464,
0.0607014074921608,
-0.43486684560775757,
0.5844763517379761,
-0.11169495433568954,
-0.15512970089912415,
-0.3657230734825134,
-0.3218398988246918,
0.36296382546424866,
-0.0929236188530922,
0.13826598227024078,
-0.2533697783946991,
-0.14195019006729126,
0.6347487568855286,
-0.6502610445022583,
0.8576800227165222,
-0.12277088314294815,
-0.14686879515647888,
-0.06963307410478592,
0.24756447970867157,
0.6727728247642517,
0.1511492282152176,
0.025853833183646202,
0.23202010989189148,
0.041365060955286026,
-0.4221740663051605,
-0.7097326517105103,
0.6997498273849487,
-0.7499631643295288,
-0.6284979581832886,
-0.18395143747329712,
-0.37356969714164734,
-0.363287091255188,
-0.17317365109920502,
0.1213231012225151,
0.3822975754737854,
-0.016515709459781647,
0.21578897535800934,
0.5338125228881836,
-0.44025883078575134,
0.43298137187957764,
0.25106558203697205,
-0.24151615798473358,
-0.3760475516319275,
0.9372259378433228,
0.20280446112155914,
0.15831483900547028,
0.7193286418914795,
0.20731589198112488,
0.040224459022283554,
-1.0414063930511475,
-0.1413429230451584,
0.25333264470100403,
-0.43016812205314636,
-0.41920438408851624,
-0.36665454506874084,
-0.25273850560188293,
-0.3693235516548157,
-0.20581714808940887,
-0.573966920375824,
-0.7098091840744019,
-0.04786376655101776,
0.25765177607536316,
0.1125330924987793,
0.6486914157867432,
-0.014213964343070984,
0.5300300717353821,
-0.8494795560836792,
0.28215858340263367,
0.2646944522857666,
0.11093786358833313,
-0.1048026755452156,
-0.4487125277519226,
-0.2960447072982788,
-0.09438645094633102,
-0.19889579713344574,
-0.7638369798660278,
0.7280114889144897,
0.1624181568622589,
0.4185049533843994,
0.3576795160770416,
0.18246771395206451,
0.57635498046875,
-0.24854637682437897,
0.7789366841316223,
-0.0801723524928093,
-0.7337413430213928,
0.4875187277793884,
-0.14439384639263153,
0.1739887148141861,
0.44618508219718933,
0.1735580712556839,
-0.2673424184322357,
-0.41283056139945984,
-0.4532448947429657,
-0.8040117025375366,
0.5080723166465759,
0.27939140796661377,
0.005886455997824669,
0.026031136512756348,
0.4888390004634857,
0.02631833776831627,
0.36736002564430237,
-0.5902206301689148,
-0.06696952879428864,
0.23251965641975403,
-0.38633912801742554,
-0.3020455241203308,
-0.669568657875061,
-0.06870236992835999,
-0.159310445189476,
0.42956867814064026,
-0.3444010317325592,
0.5596740245819092,
-0.09010787308216095,
-0.41992244124412537,
0.012130183167755604,
0.42458808422088623,
0.6539463996887207,
0.3547119200229645,
-0.501151442527771,
0.21711786091327667,
0.08686927706003189,
-0.4305005967617035,
0.15859390795230865,
0.21411411464214325,
-0.05112849548459053,
-0.17487598955631256,
0.36381667852401733,
0.7158462405204773,
0.38237905502319336,
-0.27363789081573486,
0.48673391342163086,
0.12983494997024536,
0.07534072548151016,
0.007848091423511505,
0.048392027616500854,
0.03287671133875847,
0.4015950560569763,
0.36934342980384827,
-0.07863138616085052,
0.0914846807718277,
-0.5045309066772461,
-0.3466319143772125,
0.4931476414203644,
0.006590644828975201,
-0.21395601332187653,
0.333415150642395,
0.054107777774333954,
-0.06838348507881165,
0.49524375796318054,
-0.08198583126068115,
-0.3263762295246124,
0.4114571809768677,
0.3389604091644287,
0.8002814054489136,
-0.06016971170902252,
0.17555873095989227,
0.32528477907180786,
0.38264361023902893,
-0.36678341031074524,
0.13086764514446259,
-0.18762385845184326,
-0.63700932264328,
-0.6004839539527893,
-1.0770552158355713,
-0.5223906636238098,
0.3108953535556793,
-0.46627622842788696,
0.36223480105400085,
-0.526573121547699,
-0.13956217467784882,
-0.10170841962099075,
0.3532838225364685,
-0.5525911450386047,
-0.04630310460925102,
0.5545291900634766,
0.7432431578636169,
-0.6786502003669739,
1.069806694984436,
0.24921709299087524,
-0.3028125464916229,
-0.49817416071891785,
0.10141777992248535,
0.04106256365776062,
-0.4859828054904938,
0.6469663381576538,
0.019900020211935043,
-0.05498192459344864,
0.06493628025054932,
-0.49735361337661743,
-1.1562687158584595,
1.0432852506637573,
0.7431363463401794,
-0.5942132472991943,
0.036522168666124344,
0.3943023085594177,
0.37235191464424133,
-0.4877924621105194,
-0.00320129725150764,
0.49018341302871704,
0.35655900835990906,
0.052753984928131104,
-0.8173903226852417,
0.07210133969783783,
-0.049010880291461945,
0.43507447838783264,
0.27611416578292847,
-0.5483939051628113,
0.8645865321159363,
0.14791594445705414,
-0.1210096925497055,
0.257648766040802,
0.6261961460113525,
0.3929317891597748,
-0.2551442086696625,
0.44915372133255005,
0.6173230409622192,
0.8318062424659729,
0.1267046183347702,
0.9095024466514587,
-0.2726476788520813,
0.4853830337524414,
0.8243896961212158,
-0.2833702862262726,
1.271649718284607,
0.42199158668518066,
-0.2899513840675354,
0.4674387276172638,
0.6138706207275391,
-0.08847392350435257,
0.5600184798240662,
0.35953420400619507,
-0.2466745525598526,
-0.3920987546443939,
-0.11342524737119675,
-0.17539145052433014,
0.5398119688034058,
0.44213876128196716,
-0.21052144467830658,
-0.18652456998825073,
-0.30681219696998596,
0.041460879147052765,
-0.18864849209785461,
-0.37331444025039673,
0.6467423439025879,
0.07119059562683105,
-0.5154768228530884,
0.7229951620101929,
0.2529696226119995,
0.8295949697494507,
-0.319692999124527,
-0.056739915162324905,
-0.4102018177509308,
-0.06275653839111328,
-0.004082950297743082,
-0.3950188159942627,
0.12706799805164337,
0.14147426187992096,
-0.28529900312423706,
-0.27845463156700134,
0.8177327513694763,
-0.5466897487640381,
-0.6704275608062744,
0.12499670684337616,
0.5329415798187256,
0.24716036021709442,
-0.17114637792110443,
-0.31663572788238525,
0.288381963968277,
-0.5643895864486694,
-0.3731164336204529,
0.7297712564468384,
0.0379716157913208,
-0.17920097708702087,
0.5702905654907227,
0.6298349499702454,
0.5499131679534912,
-0.30321359634399414,
0.12629495561122894,
0.8223243355751038,
-0.5603981614112854,
-0.4816061556339264,
-0.6846392154693604,
0.20553632080554962,
-0.1510302573442459,
0.08414768427610397,
0.2817090153694153,
0.4147127866744995,
0.5517547130584717,
0.14940060675144196,
0.6036009192466736,
0.18026506900787354,
0.5967944264411926,
-0.6698203086853027,
0.8014158010482788,
-0.6560792922973633,
0.4808832108974457,
-0.12917672097682953,
-1.2509962320327759,
-0.40750008821487427,
0.6152238249778748,
-0.2721160650253296,
-0.01380977500230074,
0.5886087417602539,
0.9527677893638611,
-0.06890088319778442,
-0.3375017046928406,
0.39145901799201965,
0.1365758329629898,
0.22106648981571198,
0.5909979343414307,
0.5545568466186523,
-0.13969051837921143,
0.37994471192359924,
-0.4022256135940552,
-0.18792451918125153,
-0.520642876625061,
-1.0140941143035889,
-0.8591867089271545,
-0.44935256242752075,
-0.4577353298664093,
-0.02218163199722767,
-0.1325969398021698,
0.9508990049362183,
0.74201899766922,
-0.600097119808197,
-0.310071736574173,
0.26478302478790283,
0.21033687889575958,
-0.17816565930843353,
-0.16411340236663818,
0.42939916253089905,
-0.13576065003871918,
-0.8198855519294739,
0.6160510778427124,
0.5440046191215515,
-0.03923459351062775,
-0.6575182676315308,
-0.05050204321742058,
-0.06526719033718109,
0.08193804323673248,
0.7039772272109985,
0.1161615177989006,
-0.6436667442321777,
-0.4570362865924835,
-0.44901391863822937,
-0.22910438477993011,
-0.07358834892511368,
0.6617043614387512,
-0.8571435809135437,
-0.1276928335428238,
0.8395892977714539,
0.5927003026008606,
0.5257057547569275,
0.06510123610496521,
0.5453212857246399,
-0.967792809009552,
0.40580272674560547,
0.14425569772720337,
0.416465699672699,
0.48393985629081726,
-0.3208540380001068,
0.49948057532310486,
0.2231997549533844,
-0.47673648595809937,
-1.0620603561401367,
0.1673372983932495,
-1.2327653169631958,
-0.3805831968784332,
1.2175383567810059,
0.023314546793699265,
-0.2640012502670288,
0.18700815737247467,
0.09580633789300919,
0.20544639229774475,
-0.2652131915092468,
0.7856090664863586,
0.563152015209198,
-0.06421174108982086,
-0.5932095646858215,
-0.6963351368904114,
0.5721056461334229,
0.3295108377933502,
-0.724133312702179,
0.01127527840435505,
0.5226133465766907,
0.03729161247611046,
0.08585857599973679,
0.27713876962661743,
0.09440218657255173,
-0.14596661925315857,
-0.07594850659370422,
0.11431535333395004,
0.09338654577732086,
-0.3011821508407593,
-0.5564479231834412,
0.41822001338005066,
0.45351964235305786,
0.19820137321949005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10597v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10597v1
|
UniCL: A Universal Contrastive Learning Framework for Large Time Series Models
| 2024-05-17T07:47:11 | 2024-05-17T07:47:11 |
Jiawei Li, Jingshu Peng, Haoyang Li, Lei Chen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Time-series analysis plays a pivotal role across a range of critical
applications, from finance to healthcare, which involves various tasks, such as
forecasting and classification. To handle the inherent complexities of
time-series data, such as high dimensionality and noise, traditional supervised
learning methods first annotate extensive labels for time-series data in each
task, which is very costly and impractical in real-world applications. In
contrast, pre-trained foundation models offer a promising alternative by
leveraging unlabeled data to capture general time series patterns, which can
then be fine-tuned for specific tasks. However, existing approaches to
pre-training such models typically suffer from high-bias and low-generality
issues due to the use of predefined and rigid augmentation operations and
domain-specific data training. To overcome these limitations, this paper
introduces UniCL, a universal and scalable contrastive learning framework
designed for pretraining time-series foundation models across cross-domain
datasets. Specifically, we propose a unified and trainable time-series
augmentation operation to generate pattern-preserved, diverse, and low-bias
time-series data by leveraging spectral information. Besides, we introduce a
scalable augmentation algorithm capable of handling datasets with varying
lengths, facilitating cross-domain pretraining. Extensive experiments on two
benchmark datasets across eleven domains validate the effectiveness of UniCL,
demonstrating its high generalization on time-series analysis across various
fields.
|
[
-0.3347269594669342,
-0.1610942929983139,
0.0040025776252150536,
0.018055591732263565,
-0.5837205648422241,
0.4126697778701782,
0.023666802793741226,
-0.5819522142410278,
0.12232501059770584,
0.6463508605957031,
-0.7277746796607971,
-0.6018529534339905,
-0.2892710864543915,
-0.2091171145439148,
-0.48724740743637085,
1.2969294786453247,
-0.0029192876536399126,
0.08395851403474808,
0.12567362189292908,
-0.26745158433914185,
0.06874214112758636,
-0.5920419096946716,
-0.30958291888237,
-0.45692387223243713,
0.1299346536397934,
0.05416382849216461,
0.5269188284873962,
0.29488542675971985,
0.3530469834804535,
0.2534393072128296,
0.33964458107948303,
0.48623138666152954,
-0.4358838200569153,
-0.10629020631313324,
-0.05792667344212532,
-0.047207336872816086,
-0.2508644759654999,
0.0014430503360927105,
0.5474380850791931,
1.3383015394210815,
-0.212137371301651,
0.408951073884964,
0.3473125994205475,
0.7257764339447021,
-0.8056935667991638,
0.12572719156742096,
-0.38608765602111816,
0.40555334091186523,
-0.17256543040275574,
-0.32141080498695374,
-0.1463015228509903,
0.020566964522004128,
0.2882254719734192,
-0.9435395002365112,
0.5255619287490845,
0.08704008162021637,
0.6493935585021973,
0.5576283931732178,
-0.5962616801261902,
0.46994370222091675,
-1.0401794910430908,
0.9205288290977478,
-0.5332165956497192,
0.24928057193756104,
-0.241001158952713,
0.39073553681373596,
0.28888991475105286,
-0.9357821941375732,
-0.05312652140855789,
0.29487794637680054,
-0.19324013590812683,
0.1200898140668869,
-0.14839719235897064,
0.012464197352528572,
0.19527828693389893,
0.3964303731918335,
-0.5822288393974304,
0.11445394158363342,
-0.12857142090797424,
0.03617562726140022,
0.3629940152168274,
0.2778737246990204,
-0.12009425461292267,
0.3877444267272949,
-0.6125770807266235,
-0.13886100053787231,
-0.6224542260169983,
0.1102553978562355,
0.01209958828985691,
0.5112454891204834,
-0.3225231170654297,
-0.08434328436851501,
-0.16573473811149597,
0.45812398195266724,
0.13457685708999634,
0.29149818420410156,
0.4081096053123474,
0.02353837341070175,
-0.6883306503295898,
0.02597731351852417,
0.4829339385032654,
0.058998096734285355,
0.2745206654071808,
-0.33089545369148254,
-0.14832650125026703,
0.10169316828250885,
0.08559204638004303,
-1.0540119409561157,
-0.3752681314945221,
0.04984259605407715,
-0.23304912447929382,
-0.39702296257019043,
0.19225704669952393,
-0.814407467842102,
-0.20395712554454803,
-0.7675721645355225,
0.2063269317150116,
0.16704998910427094,
-0.19475871324539185,
0.021570660173892975,
0.34857288002967834,
0.044752877205610275,
0.20993509888648987,
-0.7749061584472656,
0.46250349283218384,
0.29834339022636414,
0.3180614709854126,
-0.33382025361061096,
-0.17754270136356354,
-0.6303049921989441,
0.2792070209980011,
-0.5452598929405212,
0.5434885025024414,
-0.6480589509010315,
-0.45976579189300537,
-0.0679144635796547,
-0.016960471868515015,
0.14574018120765686,
-0.5178720951080322,
0.19986015558242798,
-0.7183000445365906,
-0.06060188263654709,
-0.017933815717697144,
-0.18213124573230743,
-0.06870117038488388,
-0.05612097308039665,
-0.5957618951797485,
0.8854677081108093,
0.23429274559020996,
-0.7790677547454834,
0.6421061754226685,
-0.7735380530357361,
-0.5041853189468384,
-0.1849702000617981,
-0.3503172695636749,
-0.6426076889038086,
-0.10718078911304474,
0.5736109018325806,
0.6739184856414795,
-0.5671021342277527,
0.36814960837364197,
-0.49362799525260925,
-0.34539106488227844,
-0.021733898669481277,
-0.7514119148254395,
0.6328965425491333,
0.3177727460861206,
-0.45983371138572693,
0.2744029462337494,
-0.9254646301269531,
0.05027586594223976,
-0.026836663484573364,
0.08299161493778229,
-0.3848036229610443,
-0.28650009632110596,
0.42994049191474915,
-0.012013018131256104,
-0.13221944868564606,
-0.6040349006652832,
0.0435868576169014,
-0.48823392391204834,
0.35447460412979126,
0.7565293312072754,
-0.021320480853319168,
0.13557147979736328,
-0.18582947552204132,
0.33978089690208435,
0.3224412500858307,
0.4238542318344116,
-0.29345065355300903,
0.20476047694683075,
-0.380721777677536,
-0.26260989904403687,
0.3461877107620239,
0.42986631393432617,
-0.46834808588027954,
0.3319771885871887,
-0.2322418987751007,
-0.20465226471424103,
-0.10002913326025009,
0.361357718706131,
0.4955350160598755,
0.6934118270874023,
0.7011326551437378,
-0.3486679494380951,
-0.7380077242851257,
-0.510297954082489,
0.008713491261005402,
0.4920874238014221,
-0.1244390532374382,
0.23579514026641846,
0.23769038915634155,
-0.40859878063201904,
0.7857917547225952,
-0.6880934834480286,
-0.2518872022628784,
0.04860749468207359,
0.34841641783714294,
0.2641125023365021,
0.5200929045677185,
0.5857368111610413,
-1.1683933734893799,
-0.42794832587242126,
0.13401904702186584,
-0.8902326822280884,
0.129978209733963,
-0.043402403593063354,
0.0345606654882431,
-0.0037543377839028835,
0.6059386134147644,
-0.21006782352924347,
0.7264382243156433,
0.3866172432899475,
-0.4298543632030487,
0.351192444562912,
-0.26930153369903564,
0.20849695801734924,
-1.3378734588623047,
0.3985164165496826,
0.10100454837083817,
-0.1288774013519287,
-0.49458032846450806,
-0.23282070457935333,
-0.14105387032032013,
-0.4287657141685486,
-0.3396821618080139,
0.530331015586853,
-0.5058985352516174,
-0.3895695209503174,
-0.0022425358183681965,
-0.32061445713043213,
0.13918592035770416,
0.6047679781913757,
-0.005713383201509714,
0.5281782746315002,
0.5939221382141113,
-0.6872448325157166,
0.312559574842453,
-0.004037067294120789,
-0.4281792640686035,
0.34430038928985596,
-0.584730327129364,
-0.1453332155942917,
-0.007048317231237888,
0.1179196909070015,
-0.9852713346481323,
-0.1027727797627449,
-0.13800378143787384,
-0.1770772635936737,
0.7274386882781982,
0.013239860534667969,
0.0850033164024353,
-0.2610815167427063,
-0.12907859683036804,
0.7150511145591736,
0.388012558221817,
-1.285460114479065,
0.8436968922615051,
0.0721510723233223,
0.1591036319732666,
-1.2871851921081543,
-0.644297182559967,
-0.5120552182197571,
-0.2777355909347534,
-0.16324667632579803,
0.51936274766922,
-0.3975089192390442,
-0.3036853075027466,
-0.011972406879067421,
-0.4335384666919708,
-0.26958948373794556,
0.2836375832557678,
0.4889768958091736,
0.7098175883293152,
-0.3453667163848877,
0.033541660755872726,
-0.043541837483644485,
-0.3072493076324463,
-0.12227163463830948,
-0.5951233506202698,
0.3449937701225281,
-0.07881337404251099,
-0.515507698059082,
-0.3288198411464691,
0.234562948346138,
0.5306460857391357,
-0.2781223952770233,
0.11208470165729523,
0.6343929171562195,
-0.2683919072151184,
-0.6979320645332336,
-0.4096553325653076,
-0.03086838684976101,
-0.506606936454773,
0.2577989399433136,
-0.08773732930421829,
-0.7785170078277588,
0.35127994418144226,
-0.2935669422149658,
0.3808108866214752,
0.46148017048835754,
0.11329304426908493,
0.08231913298368454,
0.9319666028022766,
0.5863932967185974,
-0.44898948073387146,
0.3860003650188446,
-0.5231204628944397,
0.020424513146281242,
-0.649746835231781,
-0.12598100304603577,
-0.25442469120025635,
-0.28851884603500366,
-0.26434972882270813,
-0.1273658126592636,
0.29771888256073,
0.02095375768840313,
-0.7522812485694885,
-0.25046229362487793,
-0.6147662401199341,
0.7496777176856995,
0.033793747425079346,
-0.02319038286805153,
0.30134615302085876,
0.3853547275066376,
-0.0018490282818675041,
0.024600941687822342,
-0.1785980761051178,
0.15888427197933197,
1.5735220909118652,
-0.1875150203704834,
1.0731555223464966,
-0.18830043077468872,
0.41351252794265747,
0.9006625413894653,
0.5378187894821167,
-0.12026675790548325,
0.07390017807483673,
-0.8141365051269531,
-0.28861528635025024,
-0.3497386574745178,
-0.33607378602027893,
-1.1075971126556396,
0.20547129213809967,
-0.3191145360469818,
-0.35443025827407837,
0.4940624535083771,
0.5333400964736938,
-0.6303064823150635,
0.781132161617279,
-0.3657171428203583,
0.8924741148948669,
-0.34004685282707214,
-0.2466323971748352,
-0.1292436122894287,
-0.746811032295227,
0.22096067667007446,
-0.16754794120788574,
-0.035048749297857285,
0.08003776520490646,
0.01791892945766449,
0.46511125564575195,
-0.3127234876155853,
1.0841140747070312,
-0.11887761950492859,
0.24489055573940277,
0.1878959983587265,
-0.04395653307437897,
0.23821713030338287,
0.05183461681008339,
0.26444894075393677,
0.21851316094398499,
-0.11138023436069489,
-0.7101781368255615,
-0.5573115944862366,
0.7485771775245667,
-0.9977067112922668,
-0.17239436507225037,
-0.36697590351104736,
-0.4017832577228546,
-0.5295790433883667,
0.06859727203845978,
0.22509051859378815,
0.9951088428497314,
-0.4983427822589874,
0.26994094252586365,
0.7872340679168701,
0.2993610203266144,
0.6728411912918091,
0.7784299254417419,
-0.05466665327548981,
-0.3335568904876709,
0.9718565344810486,
-0.1907179206609726,
0.10000487416982651,
0.6410344839096069,
-0.04511105269193649,
-0.3716943562030792,
-0.5689425468444824,
-0.2766215205192566,
0.03390488773584366,
-0.5739406943321228,
-0.06661079078912735,
-0.195491760969162,
-0.1877852976322174,
-0.39013972878456116,
-0.40196430683135986,
-0.2922917604446411,
-0.24394062161445618,
-0.550457239151001,
-0.10287262499332428,
0.046909820288419724,
0.6224645972251892,
-0.12077236920595169,
0.2306332290172577,
-0.6609811782836914,
0.5051024556159973,
0.525199294090271,
0.3423607349395752,
-0.01250806450843811,
-0.45507657527923584,
-0.061595380306243896,
-0.29343587160110474,
-0.29334816336631775,
-0.07247304171323776,
0.581803560256958,
0.2966269850730896,
0.5087419152259827,
0.8464081883430481,
0.1725190281867981,
0.6462938785552979,
-0.19972580671310425,
0.6138516068458557,
0.46278244256973267,
-0.8875654935836792,
0.31933507323265076,
-0.11727919429540634,
-0.07152065634727478,
0.43581900000572205,
0.5726751685142517,
-0.2590027451515198,
0.40565580129623413,
-0.8511726260185242,
-0.9529188871383667,
0.5275139212608337,
-0.3320915400981903,
-0.146572083234787,
0.34763023257255554,
0.5536679029464722,
0.24139101803302765,
0.4957302510738373,
-0.4952448308467865,
-0.4761638641357422,
-0.5934372544288635,
-0.22539353370666504,
-0.5494200587272644,
0.22217300534248352,
-0.1441473513841629,
-0.1352372169494629,
0.5813433527946472,
-0.42011719942092896,
-0.23714376986026764,
0.19632543623447418,
-0.16735056042671204,
-0.23330537974834442,
0.3375296890735626,
0.12197933346033096,
0.7443361878395081,
-0.3293621838092804,
-0.23073236644268036,
0.06957633048295975,
-0.30834874510765076,
-0.0068566990084946156,
0.5894870162010193,
-0.01771201379597187,
-0.3087325692176819,
0.29810503125190735,
0.7706778049468994,
0.3314555287361145,
-0.6287376284599304,
0.4522325396537781,
0.17934565246105194,
-0.0611572191119194,
-0.5176212191581726,
-0.03270731493830681,
-0.44253548979759216,
0.424594521522522,
0.4378417730331421,
0.3222087323665619,
0.21805572509765625,
-0.4839535653591156,
0.3159264326095581,
0.46033287048339844,
-0.4943362772464752,
-0.3964517414569855,
0.8649938106536865,
0.38454169034957886,
0.26244816184043884,
0.6782927513122559,
0.08046804368495941,
-0.16048865020275116,
0.731045663356781,
0.4119132459163666,
0.8365155458450317,
-0.5192546844482422,
0.106142558157444,
0.10010620206594467,
-0.09420401602983475,
0.10121718794107437,
0.07886165380477905,
-0.40035220980644226,
-0.6875958442687988,
-0.5314672589302063,
-0.6158472299575806,
-0.447165846824646,
0.4272262454032898,
-0.9124826788902283,
-0.11971987038850784,
-0.8988934755325317,
0.17066451907157898,
0.14109396934509277,
0.18867021799087524,
-0.7756786942481995,
0.6127018332481384,
0.13484418392181396,
0.7181128263473511,
-1.115775227546692,
0.822533369064331,
0.5127469897270203,
-0.2426912933588028,
-0.6872655749320984,
-0.13431860506534576,
-0.044332027435302734,
-0.8689526319503784,
0.8447203636169434,
0.14712390303611755,
-0.23132389783859253,
0.04845012351870537,
-0.6330999135971069,
-0.5128990411758423,
1.2509863376617432,
0.3166525363922119,
-0.623221755027771,
-0.11885236948728561,
0.1781880259513855,
0.5162777304649353,
-0.8527154922485352,
0.12177188694477081,
0.592686116695404,
0.1330914944410324,
0.1949073225259781,
-0.3895717263221741,
-0.12396097183227539,
-0.4566729962825775,
-0.23186525702476501,
0.6367978453636169,
-0.6682376861572266,
1.0317020416259766,
-0.5126004219055176,
-0.00537357572466135,
0.03741854056715965,
0.7593121528625488,
-0.27359047532081604,
0.5709852576255798,
0.5655703544616699,
0.5896108150482178,
0.8301237225532532,
-0.043026696890592575,
0.8301665782928467,
-0.4342121183872223,
0.3909080922603607,
1.2432050704956055,
-0.4443556070327759,
0.4925435483455658,
0.0761893019080162,
-0.22606630623340607,
0.4883732199668884,
0.6813309788703918,
-0.28082528710365295,
0.48862433433532715,
0.03648471459746361,
-0.32596495747566223,
-0.7817491888999939,
-0.15064547955989838,
-0.4147741496562958,
-0.0059132142923772335,
0.47081729769706726,
-0.24171783030033112,
-0.26394888758659363,
-0.05521560087800026,
-0.37160030007362366,
0.13734817504882812,
-0.6674486994743347,
0.32874929904937744,
0.03107510879635811,
-0.26382309198379517,
0.4423427879810333,
-0.4619391858577728,
0.6864394545555115,
-1.018898844718933,
-0.2704433500766754,
-0.3317921757698059,
0.3485735356807709,
-0.31257709860801697,
-0.3703542947769165,
0.12289582937955856,
-0.16663634777069092,
-0.3080935478210449,
0.16253365576267242,
0.44791707396507263,
-0.19920837879180908,
-0.35041511058807373,
0.4779333472251892,
0.18817631900310516,
-0.0654844120144844,
0.0330422967672348,
-0.737831175327301,
-0.391996830701828,
0.06870376318693161,
-0.21217034757137299,
0.47347620129585266,
0.18091455101966858,
-0.10427427291870117,
0.6253599524497986,
0.9990292191505432,
-0.0007338406867347658,
-0.310672402381897,
0.41527557373046875,
0.9071527123451233,
-0.696800708770752,
-0.744001567363739,
-0.4022189974784851,
0.5326325297355652,
-0.07277218252420425,
-0.4689227044582367,
0.21844364702701569,
0.6162232756614685,
0.8765462636947632,
0.14364087581634521,
0.7908661365509033,
0.6336735486984253,
0.8043535947799683,
-0.49845048785209656,
0.279482901096344,
-0.7757967114448547,
0.556991457939148,
-0.05193006619811058,
-0.8360633254051208,
-0.5148112177848816,
0.06786990165710449,
-0.17555996775627136,
0.24354098737239838,
0.41124284267425537,
0.3285738229751587,
-0.4914133846759796,
0.15925192832946777,
0.4406399428844452,
0.33795467019081116,
0.0969914048910141,
0.5908759236335754,
0.5386003255844116,
-0.11526229232549667,
0.749829888343811,
-0.2875373065471649,
-0.22430291771888733,
-0.0404241569340229,
-0.808383047580719,
-1.1612080335617065,
-0.2823828160762787,
-0.23782750964164734,
-0.3479278087615967,
0.1923677772283554,
1.1289124488830566,
0.8241913318634033,
-1.2180687189102173,
-0.157780259847641,
0.1441892385482788,
-0.3627544939517975,
-0.2029927670955658,
-0.13978752493858337,
0.8841982483863831,
-0.15139250457286835,
-0.575066864490509,
0.43607550859451294,
0.12248186767101288,
0.2460387498140335,
-0.21054400503635406,
-0.046543918550014496,
0.4180775284767151,
-0.028555389493703842,
0.3826054334640503,
0.8912824392318726,
-0.37726065516471863,
0.030650097876787186,
-0.34930893778800964,
0.4112773835659027,
0.26582762598991394,
1.122063398361206,
-0.962764322757721,
0.3439536392688751,
0.037748485803604126,
0.8561877012252808,
0.6743941307067871,
0.19652505218982697,
0.15366798639297485,
-0.8182896375656128,
0.17747044563293457,
0.1059284433722496,
0.557755708694458,
0.46154549717903137,
-0.4499620199203491,
0.6186449527740479,
0.4914837181568146,
-0.4825609028339386,
-0.629883348941803,
0.08226737380027771,
-0.9956292510032654,
-0.5811363458633423,
0.5589768290519714,
-0.09518559277057648,
-0.006847585551440716,
-0.28424838185310364,
0.20547574758529663,
0.26697367429733276,
-0.3914514482021332,
0.6227967143058777,
0.045300085097551346,
-0.3164297938346863,
0.296003133058548,
-0.14324763417243958,
0.5365952849388123,
0.34360677003860474,
-0.8480132818222046,
0.34773969650268555,
0.308287113904953,
0.5629240870475769,
0.04722855985164642,
0.2736128866672516,
-0.09283847361803055,
0.3594183027744293,
-0.12542983889579773,
0.060608599334955215,
-0.360485702753067,
-0.6096103191375732,
-0.5180933475494385,
0.2529858350753784,
-0.1933794617652893,
-0.09269039332866669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13039v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13039v1
|
Surgical Feature-Space Decomposition of LLMs: Why, When and How?
| 2024-05-17T07:34:03 | 2024-05-17T07:34:03 |
Arnav Chavan, Nahush Lele, Deepak Gupta
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Low-rank approximations, of the weight and feature space can enhance the
performance of deep learning models, whether in terms of improving
generalization or reducing the latency of inference. However, there is no clear
consensus yet on \emph{how}, \emph{when} and \emph{why} these approximations
are helpful for large language models (LLMs). In this work, we empirically
study the efficacy of weight and feature space decomposition in
transformer-based LLMs. We demonstrate that surgical decomposition not only
provides critical insights into the trade-off between compression and language
modelling performance, but also sometimes enhances commonsense reasoning
performance of LLMs. Our empirical analysis identifies specific network
segments that intrinsically exhibit a low-rank structure. Furthermore, we
extend our investigation to the implications of low-rank approximations on
model bias. Overall, our findings offer a novel perspective on optimizing LLMs,
presenting the low-rank approximation not only as a tool for performance
enhancements, but also as a means to potentially rectify biases within these
models. Our code is available at
\href{https://github.com/nyunAI/SFSD-LLM}{GitHub}.
|
[
-0.479952871799469,
-0.5975719690322876,
0.6572393774986267,
-0.10364313423633575,
-0.10485625267028809,
0.13209521770477295,
-0.32070791721343994,
-0.2748916447162628,
0.4447096288204193,
0.5057390332221985,
-0.6133476495742798,
-0.39710870385169983,
-0.5398407578468323,
-0.08005216717720032,
-0.5159754753112793,
0.7333875894546509,
0.3632727265357971,
0.31026530265808105,
-0.28145623207092285,
-0.154362291097641,
-0.16445192694664001,
-0.6892876029014587,
-0.43477916717529297,
-0.4075370728969574,
0.5703673362731934,
0.10608960688114166,
0.7057044506072998,
0.8304830193519592,
0.7362929582595825,
0.3352791666984558,
-0.5806095600128174,
0.025515520945191383,
-0.5459558963775635,
0.05014375224709511,
0.11990080028772354,
-0.622031033039093,
-0.46341562271118164,
0.021256163716316223,
0.7929691672325134,
1.4075326919555664,
-0.22446896135807037,
-0.03118751384317875,
0.1652110069990158,
0.7813915610313416,
-0.5552456974983215,
-0.3113759458065033,
-0.5584502220153809,
0.2566086947917938,
-0.024491170421242714,
0.015731437131762505,
-0.29579734802246094,
-0.36904844641685486,
0.18816202878952026,
-0.4101681113243103,
0.4538372755050659,
-0.11467120051383972,
0.6527462601661682,
0.6564285159111023,
-0.057898975908756256,
-0.025534747168421745,
-0.6791724562644958,
0.7062230110168457,
-0.6545666456222534,
0.5152573585510254,
0.00944259949028492,
0.2854903042316437,
-0.2050706148147583,
-0.7261955738067627,
-0.19053222239017487,
-0.3019406795501709,
-0.15910165011882782,
-0.1471012830734253,
-0.25385403633117676,
0.2726772129535675,
0.5504082441329956,
0.5984620451927185,
-0.24649950861930847,
0.5488073229789734,
-0.5321956872940063,
-0.1949617862701416,
0.3995007276535034,
0.019257796928286552,
0.2050037831068039,
-0.25695592164993286,
-0.4376087188720703,
-0.1280711144208908,
-1.0870323181152344,
-0.03282156586647034,
0.4261077344417572,
0.2371441274881363,
0.07117763161659241,
0.6252268552780151,
-0.0077279615215957165,
0.5862725377082825,
-0.07562368363142014,
-0.09453543275594711,
0.14752672612667084,
-0.05274181813001633,
-0.34368404746055603,
-0.12906937301158905,
0.6996840238571167,
0.285337895154953,
0.10168672353029251,
-0.2931572198867798,
-0.23008771240711212,
0.20233574509620667,
0.35615700483322144,
-0.897526204586029,
-0.18673479557037354,
-0.10703027993440628,
-0.8036504983901978,
-0.4747530519962311,
-0.2639096677303314,
-0.48238405585289,
-0.526369571685791,
-0.19940325617790222,
0.06765709072351456,
-0.12413902580738068,
-0.08412022143602371,
0.08022084087133408,
-0.23505030572414398,
0.22830355167388916,
0.595683753490448,
-0.7874317765235901,
0.6179825663566589,
0.8244863748550415,
0.7666341066360474,
-0.37307509779930115,
-0.0007301121950149536,
-0.45712777972221375,
-0.37250709533691406,
-0.45928728580474854,
0.5799550414085388,
-0.5057873725891113,
-0.3425421118736267,
-0.2125179022550583,
-0.058918945491313934,
-0.14603400230407715,
-1.0526771545410156,
0.5722764134407043,
-0.34389346837997437,
-0.03428555279970169,
-0.21866890788078308,
-0.4319026470184326,
-0.06638164818286896,
0.06282908469438553,
-0.9036868810653687,
1.0758683681488037,
0.038228753954172134,
-0.4266466796398163,
0.29511967301368713,
-0.6702226400375366,
-0.5291945338249207,
-0.201727032661438,
-0.10880471020936966,
-0.41499388217926025,
0.5786493420600891,
0.4005802571773529,
0.7229904532432556,
-0.34506097435951233,
0.20314210653305054,
-0.7302660942077637,
-0.49131685495376587,
0.3522956371307373,
-0.473799467086792,
0.4799419343471527,
0.32591891288757324,
0.021665045991539955,
-0.14616425335407257,
-0.5013524293899536,
-0.1677313596010208,
0.20948177576065063,
-0.24384234845638275,
-0.3550274670124054,
0.2436153143644333,
-0.2167547345161438,
-0.0561242438852787,
-0.0999942496418953,
-0.36364811658859253,
0.47134119272232056,
-0.7451494932174683,
0.7235905528068542,
0.5756826400756836,
-0.04968128353357315,
0.7969139814376831,
-0.0896860882639885,
0.5466970205307007,
-0.21239708364009857,
0.04131618142127991,
0.1162264496088028,
-0.300606369972229,
-0.6735247373580933,
-0.36335399746894836,
0.44615742564201355,
0.3428833484649658,
-0.5233989357948303,
0.11641409993171692,
-0.4124974012374878,
-0.43992894887924194,
-0.7890390753746033,
0.1638721376657486,
0.32036876678466797,
0.48952555656433105,
0.3348362445831299,
-0.31755945086479187,
-0.4333207309246063,
-1.138717770576477,
-0.3240318298339844,
-0.05465332046151161,
-0.30133742094039917,
0.39396151900291443,
0.32853126525878906,
-0.025469668209552765,
0.8061447739601135,
-0.6629588603973389,
-0.18503840267658234,
-0.37271642684936523,
-0.22755113244056702,
0.3425443768501282,
0.32183176279067993,
0.6845724582672119,
-0.6132890582084656,
0.06990335881710052,
-0.29986241459846497,
-0.5756710767745972,
-0.16077111661434174,
0.09601316601037979,
0.14499665796756744,
0.1005941703915596,
0.5615607500076294,
-0.5772796273231506,
0.42048245668411255,
0.5930309295654297,
0.15302184224128723,
0.31732553243637085,
0.045077480375766754,
-0.04663490876555443,
-0.8239921927452087,
0.05378255248069763,
0.23064686357975006,
-0.2477887123823166,
-0.6173300743103027,
0.050432611256837845,
-0.32913723587989807,
-0.29364100098609924,
-0.5034380555152893,
0.47091636061668396,
-0.4364525377750397,
-0.5466037392616272,
-0.138645201921463,
0.24097751080989838,
-0.10130144655704498,
0.5554851293563843,
0.07569637149572372,
0.8536429405212402,
0.3905724883079529,
-0.3686530590057373,
-0.1406935304403305,
0.05437874421477318,
-0.4528847336769104,
0.2840951979160309,
-0.6692420244216919,
-0.05418705940246582,
-0.004235314205288887,
0.17240822315216064,
-0.9913878440856934,
-0.005394002888351679,
0.14709466695785522,
-0.37793436646461487,
0.43688514828681946,
-0.6171897053718567,
-0.30865639448165894,
-0.28982341289520264,
-0.5152111053466797,
0.33998236060142517,
0.7969459295272827,
-0.5173135995864868,
0.47687339782714844,
0.7178406715393066,
-0.11863555759191513,
-0.679705023765564,
-0.8066706657409668,
0.026734383776783943,
-0.41556477546691895,
-0.5396278500556946,
0.37580418586730957,
0.005547888111323118,
-0.46212515234947205,
0.038758937269449234,
-0.23168262839317322,
0.11967423558235168,
0.4820650815963745,
0.21964427828788757,
0.11847838014364243,
-0.3234638273715973,
-0.17594631016254425,
0.14689552783966064,
-0.10087725520133972,
0.06960494816303253,
-0.04591891169548035,
0.5450211763381958,
-0.15771633386611938,
-0.4910762310028076,
-0.189935564994812,
0.05941398814320564,
0.595562219619751,
0.19154876470565796,
0.49550628662109375,
0.5147879123687744,
-0.38659003376960754,
-0.414732962846756,
-0.7795198559761047,
-0.32184773683547974,
-0.49212905764579773,
0.44402721524238586,
-0.16499538719654083,
-1.1475286483764648,
0.5966818332672119,
-0.46558845043182373,
-0.1915026754140854,
0.6379309892654419,
0.7392334938049316,
-0.4132462739944458,
0.9150858521461487,
0.595300555229187,
-0.24801845848560333,
0.2995435893535614,
-0.4751828610897064,
0.24475879967212677,
-1.2888692617416382,
-0.1819370836019516,
-0.5826625227928162,
-0.5728884935379028,
-0.7745153307914734,
-0.5791447162628174,
0.5049301385879517,
0.13928671181201935,
0.2453051209449768,
0.2060936838388443,
-0.6588295698165894,
0.4032280445098877,
0.32188916206359863,
0.17388679087162018,
-0.0019799775909632444,
0.2319398671388626,
-0.15666347742080688,
-0.11574758589267731,
-0.9435598850250244,
-0.29699867963790894,
0.7931244373321533,
0.679953932762146,
1.0025765895843506,
-0.2073206752538681,
0.77852463722229,
0.2811073958873749,
0.3700789213180542,
-1.2085126638412476,
0.5902060866355896,
-0.48129063844680786,
-0.15028075873851776,
-0.40829724073410034,
-0.584047257900238,
-0.9987509250640869,
0.4499519467353821,
-0.022267475724220276,
-0.6659247279167175,
0.1515895128250122,
0.1353725641965866,
-0.278164267539978,
0.3315662443637848,
-0.7602487206459045,
0.6287481784820557,
-0.05444798618555069,
-0.17247126996517181,
-0.2441650778055191,
-0.6107982397079468,
0.2943882644176483,
0.2488948106765747,
0.136180579662323,
-0.04772572964429855,
-0.06006848067045212,
1.0268906354904175,
-0.7539451718330383,
0.956866443157196,
-0.4216836988925934,
-0.04298100993037224,
-0.019168412312865257,
0.17178259789943695,
0.2871636748313904,
-0.07343526929616928,
-0.09172508120536804,
0.4280700981616974,
-0.17568901181221008,
0.032805465161800385,
-0.9113613963127136,
0.708199143409729,
-0.861284077167511,
-0.6825624704360962,
-0.03990507125854492,
-0.4492432177066803,
-0.1690862774848938,
-0.028388669714331627,
-0.050864096730947495,
0.384132981300354,
-0.13750721514225006,
0.4493194818496704,
0.8650055527687073,
-0.25542348623275757,
0.6002594232559204,
-0.04818059131503105,
-0.05712321773171425,
-0.46792712807655334,
0.5371603965759277,
0.2665533721446991,
0.1735009402036667,
0.5492541790008545,
0.20395731925964355,
-0.1662510633468628,
-1.0083868503570557,
-0.35136353969573975,
0.38695818185806274,
-0.8530920147895813,
-0.137368842959404,
-0.6077984571456909,
-0.3566770851612091,
-0.11083166301250458,
-0.4526073932647705,
-0.5324137806892395,
-0.7554093599319458,
-0.13702496886253357,
-0.07897669821977615,
-0.0026350985281169415,
0.779815673828125,
0.2528425455093384,
0.3567419648170471,
-0.435547411441803,
0.32944315671920776,
0.12303045392036438,
0.35915181040763855,
-0.03752534091472626,
-0.44372695684432983,
-0.17724300920963287,
-0.20971715450286865,
0.07699493318796158,
-0.5808678269386292,
0.2965264320373535,
0.07266411185264587,
0.8183188438415527,
0.12097320705652237,
-0.3350427746772766,
0.6330695748329163,
-0.47614917159080505,
0.8506144881248474,
0.0690329298377037,
-0.7138485908508301,
0.3497422933578491,
-0.0876179039478302,
0.1973477602005005,
0.4929887056350708,
0.18458957970142365,
-0.39987847208976746,
-0.3796977698802948,
-0.4851641356945038,
-0.9009913206100464,
0.6851677894592285,
0.1396210491657257,
0.06989888101816177,
0.25046995282173157,
0.4827039837837219,
-0.05554792657494545,
0.30291810631752014,
-0.7078933715820312,
-0.3734504282474518,
0.09874740988016129,
-0.012494795024394989,
0.03178591653704643,
-0.5356516242027283,
-0.2713859975337982,
-0.2320762723684311,
0.3325946629047394,
-0.38255366683006287,
0.5699905157089233,
-0.05227426439523697,
-0.48780518770217896,
0.11500872671604156,
0.15911169350147247,
0.8111931681632996,
0.6416900753974915,
-0.04106422886252403,
0.061991237103939056,
0.49602195620536804,
-0.41398003697395325,
-0.027725161984562874,
-0.08003883808851242,
-0.003555202390998602,
-0.10533753782510757,
0.6317765116691589,
0.779574453830719,
0.4886338412761688,
-0.2908434569835663,
0.6508607864379883,
-0.04817260429263115,
-0.3089386820793152,
-0.04471133276820183,
0.11564388126134872,
0.141269251704216,
0.31047311425209045,
0.4622690975666046,
0.49122849106788635,
0.3254547715187073,
-0.17683658003807068,
0.10599412024021149,
0.5981706976890564,
-0.2863703668117523,
-0.2701009213924408,
0.5194858908653259,
0.1683242917060852,
-0.2434862107038498,
0.58213871717453,
0.24112729728221893,
-0.6792812347412109,
0.6584081649780273,
0.1735045611858368,
1.0158271789550781,
0.018762163817882538,
0.003528798231855035,
0.09792261570692062,
0.4723016023635864,
-0.039823438972234726,
-0.030850788578391075,
-0.14157824218273163,
-0.728594958782196,
-0.7860074043273926,
-0.8650689125061035,
-0.2580212354660034,
-0.025685129687190056,
-0.588196337223053,
0.18879815936088562,
-0.680689811706543,
-0.059790533035993576,
0.028544288128614426,
-0.04784780740737915,
-0.7400155067443848,
0.09223522245883942,
0.4546060264110565,
0.9424348473548889,
-0.7491112351417542,
0.8126369714736938,
0.43513453006744385,
-0.1446126401424408,
-0.9051007032394409,
-0.07012813538312912,
0.07802923768758774,
-1.2362785339355469,
0.7458302974700928,
-0.05914578586816788,
-0.32993316650390625,
-0.3187040090560913,
-0.37577953934669495,
-0.9029294848442078,
0.8787754774093628,
0.7560197710990906,
-0.5311110615730286,
-0.26616033911705017,
0.2016899287700653,
0.6145173907279968,
-0.3153581917285919,
0.30612805485725403,
0.4766124188899994,
0.3568718731403351,
0.3236423134803772,
-0.9986680150032043,
0.0900176465511322,
-0.13044986128807068,
0.3224676251411438,
0.37183573842048645,
-0.4947621524333954,
0.5728583335876465,
-0.2283957153558731,
0.028690576553344727,
-0.05883713439106941,
0.37179461121559143,
0.1261996030807495,
-0.11490553617477417,
0.5996062159538269,
0.8640150427818298,
0.5678456425666809,
-0.34924015402793884,
1.1180561780929565,
-0.27526798844337463,
0.41967371106147766,
0.602130115032196,
-0.1412130445241928,
0.7087993621826172,
0.6123287081718445,
-0.2952711582183838,
0.4828451871871948,
0.5879876613616943,
-0.25156232714653015,
0.58721524477005,
0.2910804748535156,
0.3648626506328583,
-0.15046431124210358,
-0.045273393392562866,
-0.29220202565193176,
0.5504326224327087,
0.40775758028030396,
-0.5002985596656799,
-0.2807125151157379,
-0.013326246291399002,
0.281505823135376,
-0.30390608310699463,
-0.43378520011901855,
0.9661317467689514,
0.20014408230781555,
-0.6235610842704773,
0.7870428562164307,
-0.04974612221121788,
0.6981531381607056,
-0.4795018434524536,
-0.042799074202775955,
-0.33379340171813965,
0.1285097301006317,
-0.31042906641960144,
-0.7833595275878906,
0.33971619606018066,
-0.2794290781021118,
-0.1766238659620285,
-0.5555939674377441,
0.8531602621078491,
-0.3620710074901581,
-0.35588622093200684,
0.2953714430332184,
0.5015861392021179,
0.035388749092817307,
0.09363037347793579,
-0.7346477508544922,
0.39096924662590027,
-0.23339462280273438,
-0.49314039945602417,
0.5126258730888367,
0.22965195775032043,
0.008540559560060501,
0.865171492099762,
0.5429404377937317,
0.38159528374671936,
-0.2236539125442505,
0.32641738653182983,
1.0997177362442017,
-0.35121995210647583,
-0.30243754386901855,
-0.9264584183692932,
0.4571090638637543,
-0.07343953847885132,
0.06693204492330551,
0.641184389591217,
0.5952218770980835,
0.858422577381134,
-0.019305123016238213,
0.581098198890686,
0.05209669470787048,
0.4009310007095337,
-0.7521476745605469,
0.8196333646774292,
-0.8420664072036743,
0.5416980981826782,
-0.42247432470321655,
-0.9617680907249451,
-0.4336352050304413,
0.4678643047809601,
-0.42834240198135376,
0.2576017677783966,
0.8438162803649902,
0.9016484618186951,
-0.07153631001710892,
-0.39274975657463074,
0.46139106154441833,
0.0733841136097908,
0.12261992692947388,
0.32066938281059265,
0.9192513227462769,
-0.22632519900798798,
0.41755619645118713,
-0.2230120599269867,
0.0040391129441559315,
-0.36343619227409363,
-0.797493040561676,
-0.7674779295921326,
-0.37798431515693665,
-0.2341887503862381,
-0.13377249240875244,
-0.18564407527446747,
0.8242350220680237,
0.9426331520080566,
-0.4606401324272156,
-0.3065168261528015,
0.3832915723323822,
0.41921553015708923,
-0.2281428426504135,
-0.18166083097457886,
0.5052298903465271,
-0.19811426103115082,
-0.5544165968894958,
0.6210100054740906,
0.4052947163581848,
-0.24982579052448273,
-0.37102246284484863,
-0.0508582666516304,
0.13475285470485687,
-0.12359385192394257,
0.5884343981742859,
-0.004598887637257576,
-0.9309006333351135,
-0.2247239053249359,
0.2770451009273529,
-0.06447911262512207,
0.2136784791946411,
1.17317533493042,
-1.0169553756713867,
0.1588091403245926,
0.3915117084980011,
0.8832322359085083,
0.5902579426765442,
-0.17387431859970093,
0.46315449476242065,
-0.8830403685569763,
0.1514396369457245,
0.34072694182395935,
0.6240642666816711,
0.29845449328422546,
-0.49578824639320374,
0.754010796546936,
0.4118645191192627,
-0.37260934710502625,
-1.1329436302185059,
0.14366161823272705,
-0.990338921546936,
-0.3426468074321747,
1.0381993055343628,
0.08357828855514526,
-0.49846240878105164,
0.4083935618400574,
0.14642514288425446,
0.04738858714699745,
-0.15340794622898102,
0.6486890912055969,
0.4558440148830414,
-0.22617462277412415,
-0.3821250796318054,
-0.41900399327278137,
0.6562078595161438,
0.5590950846672058,
-0.6222156286239624,
0.06467299908399582,
0.4581185579299927,
0.43014606833457947,
0.0845848023891449,
0.4501286447048187,
-0.11245464533567429,
0.17186102271080017,
-0.2543978691101074,
-0.12205732613801956,
-0.10148066282272339,
-0.4114029109477997,
-0.49228644371032715,
0.5025790929794312,
0.16229261457920074,
0.1328181028366089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10587v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10587v2
|
RDRec: Rationale Distillation for LLM-based Recommendation
| 2024-05-17T07:22:02 | 2024-06-14T05:07:32 |
Xinfeng Wang, Jin Cui, Yoshimi Suzuki, Fumiyo Fukumoto
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Large language model (LLM)-based recommender models that bridge users and
items through textual prompts for effective semantic reasoning have gained
considerable attention. However, few methods consider the underlying rationales
behind interactions, such as user preferences and item attributes, limiting the
reasoning capability of LLMs for recommendations. This paper proposes a
rationale distillation recommender (RDRec), a compact model designed to learn
rationales generated by a larger language model (LM). By leveraging rationales
from reviews related to users and items, RDRec remarkably specifies their
profiles for recommendations. Experiments show that RDRec achieves
state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance in both top-N and sequential
recommendations. Our source code is released at
https://github.com/WangXFng/RDRec.
|
[
-0.488998681306839,
-0.7380443215370178,
0.9937979578971863,
0.21211561560630798,
-0.29799872636795044,
-0.22370284795761108,
-0.18948234617710114,
-0.18802647292613983,
0.21555766463279724,
0.5372855067253113,
-0.9907788038253784,
-0.500088095664978,
-0.5546610355377197,
0.2599886953830719,
-0.2778005003929138,
1.1685596704483032,
-0.056432947516441345,
-0.014995221979916096,
-0.2484634816646576,
-0.2455918937921524,
-0.8691740036010742,
-0.4623889923095703,
-0.4456665813922882,
-0.6730741858482361,
1.0556285381317139,
0.6011192202568054,
0.3259942829608917,
0.23421907424926758,
0.3339412808418274,
0.23413953185081482,
-0.08698923140764236,
0.4797663390636444,
-0.7657365798950195,
0.6779406666755676,
-0.5467689633369446,
-0.2596726417541504,
-0.1678873896598816,
0.042927663773298264,
0.13060586154460907,
0.24907326698303223,
-0.3746137320995331,
0.041389599442481995,
0.08322547376155853,
1.0037884712219238,
-0.6784191727638245,
-0.08279222995042801,
-0.5220063924789429,
-0.3479517102241516,
0.11724821478128433,
-0.36713600158691406,
-0.8448256850242615,
-0.5510958433151245,
0.5709971189498901,
-0.5765774846076965,
-0.15716888010501862,
0.3486887812614441,
0.6924015283584595,
0.16121850907802582,
-0.38074392080307007,
-0.49948906898498535,
-1.047262191772461,
1.0546380281448364,
-0.5299443602561951,
0.3772229552268982,
0.7669261693954468,
0.6714388728141785,
-0.2531183362007141,
-0.8805769681930542,
-0.4229932129383087,
-0.5260908007621765,
-0.14090341329574585,
-0.21558354794979095,
-0.16760170459747314,
-0.16470323503017426,
0.38410577178001404,
0.26025092601776123,
-0.39590221643447876,
-0.18832622468471527,
-0.026800228282809258,
0.30622467398643494,
0.3917560577392578,
0.13399147987365723,
0.05679474025964737,
0.08796679973602295,
-0.6359483599662781,
0.07962780445814133,
-0.6931860446929932,
-0.39174050092697144,
0.05394170805811882,
0.032408181577920914,
0.24030351638793945,
0.645037829875946,
-0.24604995548725128,
0.6282540559768677,
0.35129430890083313,
-0.2027798742055893,
-0.20864588022232056,
-0.5752891302108765,
-0.12722280621528625,
0.06379173696041107,
0.6277649998664856,
0.5188061594963074,
0.43765750527381897,
0.04005338251590729,
-0.26578307151794434,
-0.1692657470703125,
0.14294281601905823,
-1.1113446950912476,
-0.2916715443134308,
0.06009982153773308,
-0.42278793454170227,
-0.09068144857883453,
0.11755847185850143,
-0.4434756636619568,
-0.593488872051239,
-0.49845924973487854,
0.1907532811164856,
-0.43887612223625183,
0.08207233995199203,
0.28424394130706787,
-0.2776298224925995,
-0.044788658618927,
0.6352862119674683,
-0.9923802614212036,
0.22987531125545502,
0.4471162259578705,
0.8704249262809753,
-0.10617246478796005,
-0.2526158094406128,
-0.47158798575401306,
0.13811224699020386,
0.22347654402256012,
1.2687911987304688,
-0.6766406297683716,
-0.47948479652404785,
-0.16314604878425598,
-0.10134831070899963,
0.1566413938999176,
-0.5806304216384888,
0.6132115721702576,
-0.747465193271637,
0.09787439554929733,
-0.605168342590332,
-0.5433887839317322,
-0.411088764667511,
0.32347753643989563,
-0.8499865531921387,
0.8419278264045715,
-0.001072781509719789,
-0.8197399973869324,
0.6363544464111328,
-0.4430069923400879,
-0.27381184697151184,
0.08900812268257141,
0.08793424069881439,
-0.13467398285865784,
-0.04087876155972481,
0.24275390803813934,
0.3683166205883026,
-0.7660181522369385,
0.6001721024513245,
-0.607054591178894,
-0.19503189623355865,
0.4553067684173584,
-0.45612889528274536,
0.6047760844230652,
0.5650384426116943,
0.055592481046915054,
0.5803656578063965,
-0.5213792324066162,
-0.23161767423152924,
-0.034468427300453186,
-0.2106715440750122,
-0.6719995737075806,
0.033197544515132904,
0.24487391114234924,
0.02145795337855816,
0.2691275179386139,
-0.07510209828615189,
0.23288558423519135,
0.07171515375375748,
0.7985988259315491,
0.6576579809188843,
0.16775177419185638,
0.5083577632904053,
-0.5177292227745056,
0.24903815984725952,
-0.26406168937683105,
-0.11627340316772461,
-0.2521304786205292,
-0.26603496074676514,
-0.5425707697868347,
-0.5111435651779175,
0.43197277188301086,
0.3665708005428314,
-0.5164728164672852,
0.8199547529220581,
0.152496337890625,
-0.36937257647514343,
-0.048792555928230286,
0.22603407502174377,
-0.06669644266366959,
0.23473148047924042,
0.3132317066192627,
0.05491337552666664,
-0.892756462097168,
-0.6442434787750244,
-0.13413119316101074,
-0.29994553327560425,
-0.0714263916015625,
0.39218688011169434,
0.27452391386032104,
-0.5412580370903015,
1.0230014324188232,
-0.6157620549201965,
-0.4867238998413086,
-0.8212331533432007,
0.04334724321961403,
0.28400954604148865,
-0.008815011009573936,
0.4431934356689453,
-0.45449668169021606,
-0.6490974426269531,
-0.1270315796136856,
-0.5205362439155579,
-0.44181519746780396,
-0.13603538274765015,
-0.3523728847503662,
-0.039527926594018936,
0.29417163133621216,
-0.43777722120285034,
0.2866225838661194,
0.3606704771518707,
-0.4919145107269287,
0.47499099373817444,
-0.40603893995285034,
0.1943521797657013,
-1.1295918226242065,
0.09269223362207413,
0.5502134561538696,
-0.31402409076690674,
-0.2981674075126648,
-0.3045113980770111,
-0.314529150724411,
0.3290010094642639,
-0.09939537197351456,
0.5771595239639282,
-0.1546074002981186,
0.4681580364704132,
-0.48765313625335693,
0.38540753722190857,
0.431017130613327,
0.24729132652282715,
0.14391489326953888,
0.45138704776763916,
0.05480649322271347,
-0.45872193574905396,
0.34246957302093506,
0.1995784491300583,
-0.5458707809448242,
0.7001873254776001,
-0.792877197265625,
-0.004397810436785221,
0.13350476324558258,
0.5672374367713928,
-0.9504995942115784,
0.015635795891284943,
-0.10068070888519287,
0.1510360687971115,
-0.024104585871100426,
-0.28894883394241333,
-0.2516387104988098,
0.07084383815526962,
-0.33607420325279236,
0.5079806447029114,
0.3971659541130066,
-0.7485319375991821,
0.7078186273574829,
0.46469464898109436,
0.0010393285192549229,
-0.4436429440975189,
-0.38709256052970886,
-0.14148470759391785,
-0.3944583237171173,
-0.5871590971946716,
0.1469711810350418,
-0.4032500982284546,
-0.5181869268417358,
-0.09313260018825531,
-0.055837955325841904,
-0.17735300958156586,
-0.03307091072201729,
0.298406183719635,
0.5700799226760864,
0.03312687203288078,
-0.11440518498420715,
-0.15419046580791473,
-0.3116545081138611,
-0.13522322475910187,
-0.4369770884513855,
0.4818932116031647,
-0.14846685528755188,
-0.007962987758219242,
-0.48817598819732666,
0.1386360079050064,
0.7134526968002319,
0.12006565183401108,
0.6700388193130493,
0.24870136380195618,
-0.10667193681001663,
-0.5659375786781311,
-0.7685094475746155,
-0.5591368079185486,
-0.44603753089904785,
0.3268684148788452,
-0.4377003312110901,
-1.0911781787872314,
0.39910170435905457,
-0.30208253860473633,
-0.119862399995327,
0.35426944494247437,
0.8804295063018799,
0.03627754747867584,
0.7629469037055969,
0.357572078704834,
-0.07336995005607605,
0.7517841458320618,
-0.2524164021015167,
0.4052823781967163,
-0.5915179252624512,
-0.29746660590171814,
-0.5022287368774414,
-0.32991528511047363,
-0.29937994480133057,
-0.38401466608047485,
-0.010274218395352364,
0.35344916582107544,
-0.14428892731666565,
0.438465416431427,
-0.3846449553966522,
0.7146381139755249,
0.5324354767799377,
-0.11116943508386612,
0.5994657874107361,
-0.10412392765283585,
-0.2586510479450226,
0.0361294187605381,
-0.5878961086273193,
-0.6151276230812073,
0.7112281322479248,
0.5186637043952942,
1.2030822038650513,
-0.05742838978767395,
0.47506123781204224,
0.43280401825904846,
0.09196317195892334,
-1.041580319404602,
0.4739862084388733,
-0.12291744351387024,
-0.5728106498718262,
-0.30035966634750366,
-0.31908395886421204,
-0.5827546715736389,
0.10881120711565018,
-0.295370876789093,
-0.5241138339042664,
0.28898879885673523,
0.07154357433319092,
-0.3876102566719055,
0.11452917754650116,
-0.6099464893341064,
0.8082341551780701,
-0.16257061064243317,
-0.40711599588394165,
-0.5770944952964783,
-0.20662975311279297,
0.35700085759162903,
0.01570143923163414,
-0.10643996298313141,
-0.3413001000881195,
0.42065781354904175,
0.5321958661079407,
-0.6661949157714844,
0.5487143397331238,
-0.2299690693616867,
-0.025056354701519012,
0.521554172039032,
0.36736997961997986,
0.6903108358383179,
0.4937356412410736,
-0.0976613461971283,
0.2632273733615875,
0.20444414019584656,
0.16648787260055542,
-0.8370482921600342,
1.0537083148956299,
-0.5153974294662476,
-0.7656860947608948,
-0.4579017460346222,
-0.38909855484962463,
0.008363286033272743,
0.26626160740852356,
-0.1627914160490036,
0.2191009670495987,
-0.3108775019645691,
0.4737226366996765,
0.6051923036575317,
0.054818443953990936,
-0.03179822489619255,
0.6100497245788574,
-0.4784942865371704,
-0.6471949219703674,
0.6226522922515869,
-0.01832442544400692,
-0.03131547197699547,
0.4354468882083893,
0.5332770347595215,
-0.605742871761322,
-0.582824170589447,
-0.44449448585510254,
0.2106870859861374,
-0.5420921444892883,
-0.12629789113998413,
-0.5070385336875916,
-0.07988180965185165,
0.13108301162719727,
-0.060842569917440414,
-0.13864554464817047,
-0.4642500877380371,
-0.30050066113471985,
-0.27662166953086853,
0.8746708035469055,
1.0296249389648438,
0.18677407503128052,
0.14731217920780182,
-0.5719321966171265,
0.2652001976966858,
0.37487637996673584,
0.34285399317741394,
0.0075908382423222065,
-0.6950303316116333,
-0.31672218441963196,
-0.11318165063858032,
-0.1979965716600418,
-0.4097975492477417,
0.37673163414001465,
0.00525242555886507,
0.395635187625885,
0.6389865279197693,
0.47379595041275024,
0.5405771732330322,
-0.6879924535751343,
0.45824819803237915,
0.28406715393066406,
-0.5740455985069275,
0.5122725367546082,
-0.1931326538324356,
0.20846469700336456,
0.8694919943809509,
0.42932233214378357,
-0.44569510221481323,
0.03736632689833641,
-0.0015706453705206513,
-0.8166365027427673,
0.6389918923377991,
-0.024170711636543274,
-0.35219842195510864,
0.00414661830291152,
0.31847378611564636,
0.36881139874458313,
-0.06581427156925201,
-0.45812350511550903,
-0.19120343029499054,
-0.09975765645503998,
-0.14449535310268402,
0.03099149651825428,
-0.9010382294654846,
-0.18882040679454803,
-0.07778162509202957,
0.7459507584571838,
0.03434024751186371,
-0.38007527589797974,
0.22126026451587677,
0.06086770445108414,
-0.07023938745260239,
0.26939359307289124,
0.6508841514587402,
0.5870264768600464,
-0.4859262704849243,
0.10324987769126892,
0.09044855087995529,
-0.2544659376144409,
0.17433863878250122,
-0.1605425924062729,
-0.0869329571723938,
-0.23334379494190216,
0.13970817625522614,
0.9753162264823914,
0.13631528615951538,
-0.6537864208221436,
0.29262858629226685,
-0.47899308800697327,
-0.37819069623947144,
-0.2825697958469391,
-0.007424347568303347,
0.21661530435085297,
0.23160119354724884,
0.14185260236263275,
0.183945894241333,
0.20155949890613556,
-0.5521096587181091,
0.32859501242637634,
0.3129063546657562,
-0.447006493806839,
-0.18796275556087494,
0.4503531754016876,
0.45572224259376526,
-0.03202230483293533,
0.5700089335441589,
0.23110249638557434,
-0.1283327341079712,
-0.05565609410405159,
0.45175406336784363,
1.2585387229919434,
0.13177376985549927,
0.04793250933289528,
0.4556867480278015,
-0.06126212701201439,
-0.46666717529296875,
-0.08863452076911926,
-0.36045965552330017,
-0.7398005723953247,
-0.5617434978485107,
-0.7402638792991638,
-0.4098801910877228,
-0.07923782616853714,
-0.5226917266845703,
0.544677734375,
-0.6450300812721252,
-0.3772028684616089,
-0.023955119773745537,
-0.045037802308797836,
-0.204216867685318,
-0.2730388641357422,
-0.10421565175056458,
1.01248300075531,
-0.5721649527549744,
1.1664361953735352,
0.360053151845932,
-0.5147098302841187,
-0.851987361907959,
-0.07923451066017151,
-0.0879262387752533,
-0.40720805525779724,
0.8708822131156921,
0.02376030571758747,
-0.5898975729942322,
-0.2741655111312866,
-0.16310745477676392,
-0.5131057500839233,
1.1575294733047485,
0.4527222514152527,
-0.8245555758476257,
0.17906451225280762,
-0.2741578221321106,
0.5351903438568115,
-0.6889869570732117,
0.7112883925437927,
0.549725353717804,
0.685655951499939,
0.6942721605300903,
-0.7993422150611877,
0.10872875154018402,
-0.11838062107563019,
0.19005908071994781,
-0.08344856649637222,
-0.5014292001724243,
0.5005009174346924,
-0.46929803490638733,
-0.20883867144584656,
0.15132932364940643,
0.4924982190132141,
0.8726071715354919,
0.3473108410835266,
0.5420742630958557,
0.5062066316604614,
0.614298403263092,
0.02648399956524372,
0.9813432693481445,
-0.20400401949882507,
0.2442760318517685,
1.3845767974853516,
-0.9112604856491089,
0.8614070415496826,
0.6224992871284485,
-0.14497247338294983,
1.0933051109313965,
0.532904326915741,
0.05255229398608208,
0.7907930612564087,
0.18932722508907318,
-0.2976418435573578,
-0.33430007100105286,
-0.30899518728256226,
-0.036390140652656555,
-0.050406940281391144,
0.14607657492160797,
-0.3676159083843231,
-0.06765172630548477,
-0.28337761759757996,
-0.30574995279312134,
0.3024371266365051,
0.02901412732899189,
1.0663375854492188,
0.40209272503852844,
-0.7291979789733887,
0.7150654196739197,
0.024585597217082977,
0.596631646156311,
-0.8598841428756714,
-0.39024636149406433,
-0.05813969299197197,
0.3890013098716736,
-0.24637335538864136,
-0.66306471824646,
0.144305020570755,
-0.03569770231842995,
-0.8561710715293884,
-0.36955076456069946,
0.647874653339386,
-0.501301646232605,
-0.32258257269859314,
0.5208132863044739,
0.26367831230163574,
-0.10541455447673798,
0.09735707938671112,
-0.490486741065979,
0.02868170104920864,
0.2587789297103882,
-0.32750388979911804,
0.45693206787109375,
0.7878684997558594,
-0.1517266482114792,
0.9584941864013672,
0.7599377036094666,
0.09355377405881882,
-0.38252609968185425,
0.5169453024864197,
0.7583634257316589,
-0.7097514867782593,
-0.41905784606933594,
-1.1203619241714478,
0.2898726463317871,
0.08911117911338806,
0.028710035607218742,
0.872704803943634,
0.3930988013744354,
0.7582875490188599,
-0.2016707956790924,
0.7513155341148376,
0.01689562387764454,
0.44534990191459656,
-0.5760688185691833,
0.6445647478103638,
-0.25796160101890564,
0.9267406463623047,
0.10573113709688187,
-1.1722168922424316,
-0.29376932978630066,
0.9499288201332092,
-0.4349559247493744,
0.33728286623954773,
1.0378323793411255,
0.784066379070282,
0.22682160139083862,
0.2149498015642166,
0.42583438754081726,
0.18768399953842163,
0.24172861874103546,
0.34988436102867126,
1.1424592733383179,
-0.0273456871509552,
0.32598063349723816,
0.0041672782972455025,
-0.19251492619514465,
-0.5251103639602661,
-1.03477144241333,
-1.1471861600875854,
-0.41452881693840027,
-0.2274569422006607,
-0.5719693303108215,
-0.06833822280168533,
1.3222681283950806,
0.6129161715507507,
-1.0663599967956543,
-0.5037240982055664,
-0.22584490478038788,
0.34206175804138184,
-0.15599733591079712,
-0.20708446204662323,
0.10187720507383347,
-0.052766136825084686,
-0.5777781009674072,
0.5037845373153687,
0.38077595829963684,
-0.29791784286499023,
-0.5366253852844238,
-0.42076611518859863,
-0.31600654125213623,
0.12870338559150696,
0.5879874229431152,
-0.09626185148954391,
-0.9157048463821411,
-0.11790575087070465,
-0.14325255155563354,
-0.03537851944565773,
-0.18760892748832703,
1.3623428344726562,
-0.7726565003395081,
0.4250771105289459,
0.6852455139160156,
0.15096057951450348,
0.4795108735561371,
0.1259123682975769,
0.8696646094322205,
-0.26519688963890076,
-0.04608817398548126,
0.04861969128251076,
0.5913916230201721,
-0.034416958689689636,
-0.27076879143714905,
0.36103612184524536,
0.12249848991632462,
-0.8723862171173096,
-0.8287113308906555,
0.22436554729938507,
-1.175858497619629,
-0.32807648181915283,
1.375339388847351,
-0.31516045331954956,
-0.16722139716148376,
-0.19568747282028198,
-0.7286002039909363,
-0.2641477584838867,
-0.861253023147583,
0.7431637644767761,
0.7123373746871948,
0.04549210146069527,
0.0009661900694482028,
-0.18117447197437286,
0.4200778901576996,
0.1171254962682724,
-0.30100521445274353,
0.5980395674705505,
0.6816244721412659,
0.42049723863601685,
-0.13291436433792114,
0.5219889879226685,
0.06208644434809685,
-0.007245685905218124,
-0.215485617518425,
-0.07412482798099518,
-0.2155941128730774,
-0.6004829406738281,
-0.1994350254535675,
0.15857040882110596,
0.7337291836738586,
0.31888556480407715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10584v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10584v1
|
A Hybrid Deep Learning Framework for Stock Price Prediction Considering the Investor Sentiment of Online Forum Enhanced by Popularity
| 2024-05-17T07:18:08 | 2024-05-17T07:18:08 |
Huiyu Li, Junhua Hu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, q-fin.ST
|
Stock price prediction has always been a difficult task for forecasters.
Using cutting-edge deep learning techniques, stock price prediction based on
investor sentiment extracted from online forums has become feasible. We propose
a novel hybrid deep learning framework for predicting stock prices. The
framework leverages the XLNET model to analyze the sentiment conveyed in user
posts on online forums, combines these sentiments with the post popularity
factor to compute daily group sentiments, and integrates this information with
stock technical indicators into an improved BiLSTM-highway model for stock
price prediction. Through a series of comparative experiments involving four
stocks on the Chinese stock market, it is demonstrated that the hybrid
framework effectively predicts stock prices. This study reveals the necessity
of analyzing investors' textual views for stock price prediction.
|
[
-0.25636082887649536,
-0.36544734239578247,
0.13322627544403076,
0.2435852289199829,
-0.4059053957462311,
0.6259870529174805,
-0.25376808643341064,
-0.4834206998348236,
0.6238566637039185,
0.14762598276138306,
-0.5710437893867493,
-0.44118499755859375,
-0.44814783334732056,
-0.337992399930954,
-0.268344908952713,
0.8405505418777466,
0.12726354598999023,
0.5500838160514832,
0.245099738240242,
0.007834351621568203,
-0.02389093115925789,
-0.6916686296463013,
-0.6469526886940002,
0.051752910017967224,
0.44301795959472656,
-0.15408934652805328,
0.5885204672813416,
0.3278089165687561,
0.4111420512199402,
0.3145544230937958,
0.023233048617839813,
0.34909382462501526,
-0.43378332257270813,
-0.026738200336694717,
0.3812573552131653,
-0.20522063970565796,
-0.38233238458633423,
0.00855328980833292,
0.3546196222305298,
0.761206865310669,
-0.13418489694595337,
-0.19856342673301697,
0.3454049825668335,
0.3754913806915283,
-0.5389236807823181,
0.1276100128889084,
-0.6454305648803711,
0.4609295725822449,
-0.14593954384326935,
-0.3294229805469513,
-0.26726293563842773,
-0.24751101434230804,
0.05555443465709686,
-0.5972816944122314,
0.10736338794231415,
0.2506866753101349,
0.7837068438529968,
-0.19196005165576935,
-0.385760635137558,
0.015011650510132313,
-0.7195687294006348,
0.8826445937156677,
-0.6185788512229919,
0.3067026436328888,
0.05533217266201973,
0.3444186747074127,
0.23201152682304382,
-0.5475490689277649,
-0.4318816065788269,
-0.03630942851305008,
-0.023520953953266144,
0.2782706916332245,
0.032061122357845306,
-0.12745915353298187,
-0.18402771651744843,
0.662244439125061,
-0.45792731642723083,
0.151900514960289,
-0.7269027829170227,
0.2316017597913742,
0.6696962118148804,
0.2525845766067505,
0.013900277204811573,
-0.18904705345630646,
-0.681712806224823,
0.04472269490361214,
-0.3880322575569153,
0.04203715920448303,
0.41947829723358154,
0.5620459914207458,
0.13949079811573029,
-0.009819124825298786,
-0.051098719239234924,
0.2983402907848358,
0.308920294046402,
0.15673314034938812,
0.6999833583831787,
0.01728559285402298,
-0.4311715364456177,
0.3389950096607208,
0.8750430941581726,
0.6019648909568787,
0.11444036662578583,
-0.10093852877616882,
-0.09383299201726913,
-0.13931652903556824,
0.23161256313323975,
-0.549100399017334,
-0.2259783148765564,
0.21340474486351013,
-0.941073477268219,
-0.6063605546951294,
0.5647247433662415,
-0.9243140816688538,
-0.6023392081260681,
-0.17660117149353027,
0.3304920196533203,
-0.02720632031559944,
-0.8152874112129211,
0.20503099262714386,
-0.3066442310810089,
0.16458483040332794,
0.4074888825416565,
-0.543041467666626,
0.24733266234397888,
0.8942495584487915,
0.8713313341140747,
-0.20753006637096405,
-0.3180161714553833,
-0.621028482913971,
0.1312098503112793,
-0.41738054156303406,
0.9030587673187256,
-0.436214804649353,
-0.4701458215713501,
-0.09822963923215866,
-0.21498699486255646,
-0.04294053092598915,
-0.5224885940551758,
-0.07658793032169342,
-0.7052627801895142,
0.2524685561656952,
-0.19636331498622894,
-0.8084343075752258,
-0.25340068340301514,
0.3215019404888153,
-0.8412619233131409,
0.7571923732757568,
-0.24561460316181183,
-0.790868878364563,
0.4856487214565277,
-0.8044629693031311,
-0.48518726229667664,
0.3975813090801239,
-0.15032657980918884,
-0.163102924823761,
-0.16644415259361267,
0.287409245967865,
0.7445342540740967,
-0.021160464733839035,
0.23420065641403198,
-0.7031514048576355,
-0.36598819494247437,
0.49633079767227173,
0.01951644942164421,
0.6682710647583008,
0.33536264300346375,
-0.6800477504730225,
-0.024422697722911835,
-0.5467180013656616,
-0.15628238022327423,
-0.10696341097354889,
-0.03316763788461685,
-0.5706531405448914,
0.12239445000886917,
0.06243835389614105,
0.17383171617984772,
0.18772025406360626,
-0.46089088916778564,
0.10934316366910934,
-0.6808558702468872,
0.3816962242126465,
1.2488585710525513,
0.06308162212371826,
0.32673656940460205,
0.23987716436386108,
0.5216826796531677,
0.4716750681400299,
0.27714043855667114,
0.29238393902778625,
-0.3730176091194153,
-0.5036346912384033,
0.16278207302093506,
0.15436744689941406,
0.5166729092597961,
-0.24093614518642426,
0.42591074109077454,
0.01104490552097559,
-0.5140942931175232,
-0.41602033376693726,
0.35801640152931213,
-0.031231660395860672,
0.1572369933128357,
0.287872850894928,
-0.10302899777889252,
-0.7374424338340759,
-0.7090533971786499,
-0.3725932836532593,
0.09354400634765625,
0.1164388433098793,
0.2894807755947113,
-0.06627942621707916,
-0.5023548007011414,
0.5090514421463013,
-0.657393217086792,
-0.2541104853153229,
-0.45317405462265015,
0.6511469483375549,
0.35349443554878235,
0.12654103338718414,
0.3130931854248047,
-1.0795577764511108,
-0.5297603607177734,
0.4309171736240387,
-0.5805462002754211,
0.7509142756462097,
-0.06558532267808914,
0.013818501494824886,
0.15210667252540588,
0.5173842906951904,
-0.43027788400650024,
0.47107917070388794,
0.5412128567695618,
-0.0857962816953659,
0.09485029429197311,
0.16096286475658417,
-0.10377271473407745,
-1.4456827640533447,
-0.19545342028141022,
0.7398807406425476,
-0.14834479987621307,
-0.183854877948761,
-0.12286994606256485,
-0.23788748681545258,
-0.07678600400686264,
-0.33815109729766846,
0.33318689465522766,
-0.04249183088541031,
-0.23599453270435333,
-0.5909984707832336,
-0.07271599769592285,
-0.0006618860061280429,
0.29329705238342285,
0.1092526763677597,
0.5422742366790771,
0.634401261806488,
-0.5314356088638306,
0.7454460263252258,
-0.15877580642700195,
-0.5357629060745239,
-0.08872514218091965,
-0.4940112829208374,
-0.08613750338554382,
0.07733063399791718,
0.218727707862854,
-1.2078405618667603,
0.11474809050559998,
0.14036500453948975,
-0.49046117067337036,
0.17790775001049042,
0.28637394309043884,
-0.2936874330043793,
-0.29776978492736816,
-0.5994938015937805,
0.04161616414785385,
0.21845369040966034,
-0.3974411189556122,
0.6584007143974304,
0.3137228190898895,
-0.07495401054620743,
-0.6232390999794006,
-0.8111650347709656,
0.06566348671913147,
0.02807305008172989,
-0.47991761565208435,
0.23849160969257355,
-0.11138048768043518,
-0.46902140974998474,
0.03370854631066322,
0.3842202126979828,
0.1079128161072731,
0.11466122418642044,
0.14112593233585358,
0.5156729817390442,
-0.4756747782230377,
0.16149133443832397,
-0.14464262127876282,
-0.4929955005645752,
0.08823812007904053,
-0.462338387966156,
0.5144959092140198,
-0.42205810546875,
0.1317814290523529,
-0.2651556432247162,
0.3663034737110138,
0.14814138412475586,
0.03022378869354725,
0.8989428281784058,
0.42355427145957947,
-0.5033804774284363,
-0.35551905632019043,
-0.3960879147052765,
-0.27581843733787537,
-0.5846604108810425,
0.44920092821121216,
0.05356012284755707,
-0.7848836183547974,
0.15698258578777313,
-0.1629197597503662,
-0.08048616349697113,
0.6406650543212891,
0.6363860964775085,
-0.36124205589294434,
1.3388561010360718,
0.6435966491699219,
-0.27309682965278625,
0.178290456533432,
-0.24649938941001892,
0.7013186812400818,
-0.18259310722351074,
-0.05812698230147362,
0.049985621124506,
-0.9572319984436035,
-0.6642483472824097,
-0.05441014841198921,
0.24061574041843414,
-0.1993151754140854,
-0.3303143382072449,
0.28013336658477783,
-0.4061581492424011,
0.15028584003448486,
0.7281320095062256,
0.1717683970928192,
0.07033832371234894,
0.18820640444755554,
-0.2913825809955597,
-0.17135024070739746,
-0.26099497079849243,
-0.007527614943683147,
1.0477465391159058,
0.3699702024459839,
0.5829980373382568,
-0.29515373706817627,
0.29167819023132324,
0.6598432064056396,
0.35608139634132385,
-0.6475209593772888,
0.4071843922138214,
-0.540681004524231,
-0.6309483051300049,
0.023228557780385017,
-0.6925568580627441,
-0.30872493982315063,
-0.170741006731987,
-0.09852144122123718,
-0.30827975273132324,
0.47882550954818726,
-0.038528550416231155,
-0.9218301177024841,
0.6864457130432129,
-0.58319491147995,
0.9515588283538818,
-0.7107614874839783,
-0.10002565383911133,
-0.37957021594047546,
-0.47596123814582825,
0.2341669201850891,
-0.054416000843048096,
0.18196237087249756,
0.017522035166621208,
-0.14610527455806732,
0.6655840873718262,
-0.4140574336051941,
1.0675616264343262,
-0.1254013180732727,
0.3047972023487091,
-0.0909072756767273,
-0.10646920651197433,
0.33703187108039856,
-0.04750467836856842,
-0.27200132608413696,
0.05849388614296913,
-0.37803298234939575,
-0.3635776937007904,
-0.4375806748867035,
0.9632837772369385,
-1.097954273223877,
-0.2569303512573242,
-0.45988139510154724,
0.038931768387556076,
-0.2813892662525177,
-0.18850408494472504,
0.4519062340259552,
0.2715705931186676,
0.009913645684719086,
0.3157922029495239,
0.30646154284477234,
-0.08214457333087921,
0.3723597824573517,
-0.004074870143085718,
-0.38342827558517456,
-0.6736365556716919,
1.214287281036377,
0.13505145907402039,
-0.042694032192230225,
0.5460684895515442,
0.5305648446083069,
-0.29735472798347473,
-0.35461708903312683,
-0.2203269749879837,
-0.09004554152488708,
-0.7511476874351501,
-0.18201233446598053,
-0.6442450881004333,
-0.5518161654472351,
-0.5242342352867126,
-0.36647912859916687,
-0.4628029763698578,
-0.11119415611028671,
-0.5046566128730774,
-0.8562369346618652,
0.5304965972900391,
0.8442279100418091,
-0.008481064811348915,
0.021119078621268272,
-0.8553057909011841,
0.21215079724788666,
0.621788501739502,
0.437837153673172,
0.2556630074977875,
-0.17589129507541656,
-0.240044504404068,
0.09143306314945221,
-0.42099907994270325,
-0.3395892083644867,
0.7168855667114258,
0.02119622752070427,
0.36533012986183167,
0.9509644508361816,
0.22864240407943726,
0.5896663069725037,
0.30843859910964966,
0.6670364737510681,
0.5483742952346802,
-0.7149218916893005,
0.6189569234848022,
-0.11353467404842377,
-0.3819962441921234,
0.2714187800884247,
0.7224098443984985,
-0.4896758794784546,
-0.16067245602607727,
-0.46367552876472473,
-0.8451068997383118,
0.4049951732158661,
-0.2748942971229553,
0.334346741437912,
-0.015167499892413616,
0.3202417492866516,
0.4419952630996704,
0.3755696713924408,
-1.0668830871582031,
-0.38348469138145447,
-0.6523537039756775,
-0.4246734380722046,
-0.051845651119947433,
-0.19926151633262634,
0.2409822791814804,
-0.5819897055625916,
0.6513386368751526,
-0.12131091952323914,
0.06060195341706276,
-0.2561238706111908,
0.39566028118133545,
-0.3817444145679474,
-0.24297422170639038,
0.12551547586917877,
0.5773983597755432,
-0.39541882276535034,
-0.11937068402767181,
0.11648797243833542,
0.08184231072664261,
-0.20127831399440765,
0.3046022653579712,
-0.32353198528289795,
-0.1673411726951599,
-0.028027700260281563,
0.884316086769104,
0.348857045173645,
-0.7409289479255676,
0.6971924304962158,
-0.1543458253145218,
-0.4783117175102234,
-0.7648300528526306,
-0.019974835216999054,
0.24892202019691467,
0.35968831181526184,
0.7681321501731873,
0.40545928478240967,
0.34828945994377136,
-0.6724563837051392,
0.1065639927983284,
0.3210582435131073,
-0.7106932997703552,
-0.30181506276130676,
0.6154739260673523,
0.39998164772987366,
0.10282798111438751,
0.3842127025127411,
-0.11007221043109894,
-0.8643983602523804,
0.5031151175498962,
-0.0907670184969902,
1.204394817352295,
-0.0026260176673531532,
0.23267275094985962,
0.3873215913772583,
-0.16361503303050995,
-0.12662240862846375,
0.38224494457244873,
0.28477829694747925,
-0.8450774550437927,
-0.4282678961753845,
-0.5630475282669067,
-0.487239807844162,
0.10984974354505539,
-0.29303422570228577,
0.5579954981803894,
-0.9472627639770508,
-0.15765295922756195,
0.3952583968639374,
0.32418540120124817,
-0.23908400535583496,
0.5785418748855591,
0.5785700678825378,
0.6301075220108032,
-0.28488948941230774,
0.631572961807251,
0.6660138368606567,
-0.28590208292007446,
-0.6422663927078247,
0.012355080805718899,
-0.08217749744653702,
-0.6320359110832214,
0.7308518290519714,
0.5932050943374634,
-0.14754217863082886,
-0.34822291135787964,
-0.6785839796066284,
-0.461995005607605,
0.8311248421669006,
-0.19340279698371887,
-0.7916775941848755,
0.15067312121391296,
0.08187010884284973,
0.3465486466884613,
-0.6655768156051636,
0.004646632354706526,
-0.12468515336513519,
0.4000224769115448,
0.23205481469631195,
-0.29009369015693665,
-0.18624937534332275,
-0.6044809818267822,
-0.2588464617729187,
0.2192094922065735,
-0.7682191729545593,
1.2330154180526733,
0.2726229429244995,
-0.026766488328576088,
-0.2259698063135147,
0.8227035999298096,
-0.04612140730023384,
0.6846719980239868,
0.6039474606513977,
0.3894854187965393,
0.554563581943512,
0.3062267005443573,
0.8420090079307556,
-0.5597237944602966,
0.3130934536457062,
0.6622384190559387,
-0.6406527757644653,
1.2881616353988647,
0.06290220469236374,
-0.08747360110282898,
0.7289806008338928,
0.6127046346664429,
-0.32530418038368225,
0.5907596349716187,
-0.09878955036401749,
-0.33245137333869934,
-0.7841326594352722,
0.23711614310741425,
-0.6588339805603027,
0.32525524497032166,
0.3113786578178406,
-0.6706401109695435,
0.1916419416666031,
0.009037709794938564,
-0.36025649309158325,
0.07955311238765717,
-0.48658353090286255,
0.6631996631622314,
0.22624486684799194,
-0.26813918352127075,
0.04774891957640648,
0.22861474752426147,
0.9440062642097473,
-0.45879289507865906,
0.47806867957115173,
-0.3354451060295105,
0.7311670780181885,
0.05717634782195091,
-0.6641785502433777,
0.30937081575393677,
-0.21511958539485931,
-0.02589327283203602,
-0.31022873520851135,
0.7796415090560913,
-0.05236260965466499,
-1.082442045211792,
0.7328285574913025,
0.29583293199539185,
-0.33073678612709045,
-0.4189952611923218,
-0.8184744119644165,
-0.41380345821380615,
0.12464706599712372,
-0.4469348192214966,
0.3544652462005615,
0.22596469521522522,
0.40432441234588623,
0.4500043988227844,
0.86190265417099,
-0.25138717889785767,
-0.09122445434331894,
-0.11415547132492065,
1.1977473497390747,
-1.09725821018219,
-0.8524621725082397,
-0.8248082399368286,
0.22656820714473724,
-0.4912016689777374,
-0.3237777054309845,
0.5858519077301025,
0.5901846289634705,
0.5899157524108887,
0.027708088979125023,
1.2321127653121948,
0.6043351292610168,
1.0386719703674316,
-0.21337606012821198,
0.7648777365684509,
-0.7993370890617371,
0.23244312405586243,
0.004969178233295679,
-0.576580286026001,
-0.18707288801670074,
0.4538494348526001,
-0.5676445960998535,
0.14519385993480682,
0.35230329632759094,
0.7628023624420166,
-0.34704360365867615,
0.7031326293945312,
0.13459767401218414,
0.3090047538280487,
-0.24463476240634918,
0.44094178080558777,
0.917594850063324,
-0.4511677026748657,
0.7063495516777039,
-0.8596687316894531,
0.11148347705602646,
-0.6517342925071716,
-0.8808560967445374,
-0.9057115316390991,
-0.18539738655090332,
-0.5284393429756165,
-0.37150096893310547,
-0.09427390247583389,
1.2689290046691895,
0.6050723791122437,
-1.054151177406311,
-0.4587266743183136,
0.0668458640575409,
-0.25989973545074463,
-0.4810789227485657,
-0.3782551884651184,
0.35810762643814087,
-0.02783343754708767,
-0.22165928781032562,
0.2061249017715454,
0.6695764064788818,
-0.21084094047546387,
-0.6396578550338745,
-0.3322555720806122,
0.031987130641937256,
0.0454937107861042,
0.5036962032318115,
0.18551398813724518,
-0.3159555494785309,
0.16112230718135834,
0.20707833766937256,
-0.3929867446422577,
0.13325315713882446,
0.7509685754776001,
-0.6386842727661133,
0.03623511269688606,
0.36609283089637756,
0.6395198702812195,
0.3534232974052429,
-0.03684308007359505,
0.881132185459137,
-0.5353872776031494,
0.07013530284166336,
0.3346486985683441,
0.5354945063591003,
0.28161540627479553,
-0.5586070418357849,
-0.10272715985774994,
0.6989087462425232,
-0.19566458463668823,
-0.3250778019428253,
-0.34529250860214233,
-0.8624576330184937,
-0.6981715559959412,
0.9410126209259033,
0.1442653089761734,
-0.4397839307785034,
0.019713781774044037,
-0.08265641331672668,
-0.2331991046667099,
-0.4969983696937561,
0.9412856698036194,
0.3431147038936615,
0.3302673101425171,
-0.5978652834892273,
-0.24735601246356964,
0.11508028209209442,
0.2217450737953186,
-0.40585729479789734,
-0.08788906782865524,
0.07817050069570541,
-0.041896216571331024,
-0.1361069679260254,
0.3808807134628296,
0.3720429241657257,
0.3716237246990204,
-0.09982586652040482,
-0.218697652220726,
-0.08078017085790634,
-0.005774604622274637,
0.12548017501831055,
0.6185814142227173,
-0.20473672449588776,
-0.316173255443573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10579v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10579v1
|
A Hard Nut to Crack: Idiom Detection with Conversational Large Language Models
| 2024-05-17T07:08:13 | 2024-05-17T07:08:13 |
Francesca De Luca Fornaciari, Begoña Altuna, Itziar Gonzalez-Dios, Maite Melero
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this work, we explore idiomatic language processing with Large Language
Models (LLMs). We introduce the Idiomatic language Test Suite IdioTS, a new
dataset of difficult examples specifically designed by language experts to
assess the capabilities of LLMs to process figurative language at sentence
level. We propose a comprehensive evaluation methodology based on an idiom
detection task, where LLMs are prompted with detecting an idiomatic expression
in a given English sentence. We present a thorough automatic and manual
evaluation of the results and an extensive error analysis.
|
[
-0.19203443825244904,
-1.021327018737793,
0.6309569478034973,
0.532652735710144,
-0.5033957362174988,
0.4382094442844391,
-0.3329769968986511,
-0.40103042125701904,
-0.1776408702135086,
0.47056806087493896,
-0.47053807973861694,
-0.4846077263355255,
-0.7170255780220032,
0.5568926930427551,
-0.6930213570594788,
0.6649683713912964,
-0.05680641159415245,
-0.14379778504371643,
-0.39556756615638733,
0.07550077140331268,
-0.435794860124588,
-0.22573745250701904,
-0.44741034507751465,
-0.5072269439697266,
-0.09586189687252045,
0.538840651512146,
0.8139709234237671,
0.4112327992916107,
0.6588671207427979,
0.325087308883667,
-0.1747369021177292,
0.010150996968150139,
-0.285011351108551,
0.20014320313930511,
-0.1725439876317978,
-0.452839732170105,
-0.11893921345472336,
-0.0794120505452156,
0.4551369249820709,
0.5643714070320129,
-0.11999046802520752,
-0.056622471660375595,
-0.31356722116470337,
0.5227606296539307,
-0.14588616788387299,
0.6429338455200195,
-1.1524299383163452,
0.007674711290746927,
-0.47588348388671875,
-0.28075116872787476,
-0.5449031591415405,
-0.2506900429725647,
-0.25214219093322754,
0.09122627973556519,
-0.24920734763145447,
0.2210501730442047,
0.616676390171051,
0.33852487802505493,
-0.3961409628391266,
-0.6980342864990234,
-0.3367655873298645,
0.7375110983848572,
-0.9758985638618469,
0.04331223666667938,
0.3828970193862915,
0.24228383600711823,
-0.6576119661331177,
-0.38297027349472046,
-0.8518202900886536,
-0.567280113697052,
-0.022694837301969528,
-0.49707409739494324,
-0.22621095180511475,
0.06121880188584328,
0.223942831158638,
0.5193231105804443,
-0.6376981139183044,
0.34224358201026917,
-0.40219900012016296,
0.18246105313301086,
1.0231130123138428,
0.35997509956359863,
0.2656809985637665,
-0.41016748547554016,
-0.17877206206321716,
0.2738025486469269,
-0.6611613631248474,
-0.13045528531074524,
0.40563544631004333,
0.3758196532726288,
-0.18320444226264954,
0.6358416676521301,
-0.3722406327724457,
0.8063990473747253,
-0.2967289984226227,
-0.4041481614112854,
0.41025620698928833,
0.058506645262241364,
-0.1791037917137146,
0.12461958825588226,
0.7172454595565796,
0.11534105241298676,
0.6985063552856445,
-0.21396374702453613,
-0.4178328514099121,
0.18075935542583466,
-0.2442513257265091,
-0.7088969945907593,
-0.3457355201244354,
0.4542054533958435,
-0.09011857211589813,
-0.4648159146308899,
-0.22598502039909363,
-0.3542554974555969,
-0.5722611546516418,
-0.2929750680923462,
-0.053696997463703156,
-0.6290490031242371,
-0.32068735361099243,
0.5350465178489685,
-0.07583105564117432,
0.4334163963794708,
0.22539417445659637,
-0.4965929388999939,
0.2545247972011566,
0.9657668471336365,
0.8065555691719055,
-0.006430419627577066,
-0.17476023733615875,
-0.5897558331489563,
-0.017295269295573235,
-0.25482165813446045,
1.1710319519042969,
-0.6317465305328369,
-0.17813971638679504,
0.061677947640419006,
0.024836139753460884,
0.030435020104050636,
-1.0159144401550293,
0.5649726986885071,
-0.40222474932670593,
-0.019592180848121643,
0.21470186114311218,
-0.7970661520957947,
-0.2894377112388611,
0.5988748073577881,
-0.3632429242134094,
1.016129970550537,
0.3709923326969147,
-0.6220236420631409,
0.050320785492658615,
-0.7334281206130981,
-0.6477082967758179,
0.4139849543571472,
-0.4673493206501007,
-0.1887461394071579,
0.22475838661193848,
0.08003583550453186,
0.7182125449180603,
-0.7168551683425903,
0.369222491979599,
-0.6402871012687683,
-0.5731247663497925,
0.6886849999427795,
-0.4027409851551056,
0.9257967472076416,
0.1527165025472641,
-0.44196808338165283,
-0.06953588873147964,
-0.42272263765335083,
0.11599693447351456,
0.3476255536079407,
-0.42690154910087585,
-0.33472302556037903,
0.15700262784957886,
0.1209530234336853,
0.5664012432098389,
0.020702973008155823,
-0.32496947050094604,
0.40941664576530457,
-0.5408994555473328,
0.4875462055206299,
0.8483176231384277,
-0.18116675317287445,
-0.3212355971336365,
-0.03591954708099365,
0.6707282066345215,
0.3091794550418854,
-0.2694389820098877,
-0.19020190834999084,
-0.41581130027770996,
-0.6085036396980286,
-0.4134655296802521,
0.11325990408658981,
0.7681030035018921,
-0.7002750039100647,
0.7033635973930359,
-0.21456530690193176,
-0.37687987089157104,
-0.4611088037490845,
0.5633338093757629,
0.31342315673828125,
0.1373123675584793,
-0.12187664210796356,
-0.19280889630317688,
-0.10066146403551102,
-1.2313035726547241,
-0.4650760591030121,
-0.4670877456665039,
-0.0624026358127594,
-0.04298869147896767,
0.7216330766677856,
-0.0024533995892852545,
0.7805336117744446,
-0.648765504360199,
-0.24923817813396454,
-0.24786849319934845,
0.4158134162425995,
0.4437639117240906,
0.16111408174037933,
0.49787092208862305,
-0.6742978096008301,
-0.35330525040626526,
-0.06632386893033981,
-0.8149349689483643,
-0.055730126798152924,
0.2553289532661438,
0.39898255467414856,
0.21784065663814545,
1.0834119319915771,
-0.6840144395828247,
0.3406049907207489,
0.28488507866859436,
-0.4499579966068268,
0.5728193521499634,
0.10407586395740509,
0.06875061988830566,
-0.6587629318237305,
-0.2155413180589676,
-0.06930960714817047,
-0.36775004863739014,
-0.12891627848148346,
0.3381432592868805,
-0.05938703566789627,
0.059980813413858414,
-0.6475119590759277,
0.4464055597782135,
-0.4885711967945099,
-0.09482067823410034,
-0.31630176305770874,
0.19879797101020813,
-0.4381018280982971,
0.21198248863220215,
-0.27154403924942017,
0.6681936383247375,
0.4779606759548187,
-0.3194769620895386,
0.7637266516685486,
0.010111124254763126,
-0.9395057559013367,
0.846975564956665,
-0.6168712973594666,
0.3485243320465088,
-0.38729405403137207,
-0.03160659223794937,
-1.4193130731582642,
-0.5089969038963318,
0.2862052917480469,
-0.08931649476289749,
0.09352006018161774,
0.12870271503925323,
-1.1011028289794922,
-0.6750060319900513,
-0.1946343630552292,
0.2527971565723419,
0.25090619921684265,
-0.43171408772468567,
0.11683434247970581,
0.41841021180152893,
-0.3147119879722595,
-0.37371891736984253,
-0.5859359502792358,
0.44406604766845703,
-0.5116288065910339,
-0.7022303342819214,
-0.12654313445091248,
-0.3898569643497467,
-0.8987443447113037,
-0.05386507511138916,
0.3016654849052429,
-0.20472906529903412,
0.3730337917804718,
0.10325261205434799,
-0.04101579636335373,
-0.2522231638431549,
0.4941483438014984,
0.07180870324373245,
0.15866637229919434,
0.16979555785655975,
0.1918029934167862,
0.6742404699325562,
-0.5564594864845276,
-0.4400559663772583,
-0.32394784688949585,
0.44109848141670227,
0.9154085516929626,
-0.16703875362873077,
0.24746106564998627,
0.2864828109741211,
-0.6427276730537415,
-0.3245397210121155,
-0.4008914828300476,
-0.06771429628133774,
-0.5139521956443787,
0.5947510004043579,
-0.4727555811405182,
-0.5431349873542786,
0.15962715446949005,
-0.023081477731466293,
-0.020647335797548294,
0.02925160527229309,
0.741769015789032,
0.12432950735092163,
1.2062687873840332,
0.29632753133773804,
-0.3516445755958557,
-0.11132362484931946,
0.14401614665985107,
0.6246421337127686,
-0.22273404896259308,
0.0865406021475792,
-0.4712264835834503,
-0.3419959843158722,
-0.04551151767373085,
-0.5598077178001404,
0.2855309247970581,
0.03215388208627701,
-0.23747433722019196,
0.08678655326366425,
-0.3207504153251648,
0.7875894904136658,
0.1053583100438118,
0.03738194704055786,
0.7943042516708374,
-0.06296370178461075,
0.26746466755867004,
0.0043725986033678055,
-0.362797349691391,
-0.6697401404380798,
0.6449233293533325,
0.5056712627410889,
0.7558748722076416,
0.20229864120483398,
0.2679036557674408,
0.5171744227409363,
0.7150483727455139,
-1.463274359703064,
0.9105603694915771,
-0.2701724171638489,
-0.7623906135559082,
-0.04369794577360153,
-0.03304469212889671,
-0.6471141576766968,
0.019233103841543198,
0.10947488248348236,
-0.8314964771270752,
-0.417518675327301,
-0.13610945641994476,
-0.06813357770442963,
0.35429441928863525,
-0.5076814889907837,
0.7878926992416382,
-0.40186330676078796,
0.2551054060459137,
-0.25769639015197754,
-0.2629436254501343,
0.9477236270904541,
-0.05542904883623123,
0.34295544028282166,
-0.7201207876205444,
0.07139210402965546,
0.4619339108467102,
-0.16045910120010376,
0.6701297760009766,
0.18536150455474854,
-0.17861801385879517,
0.2317212074995041,
0.4538089334964752,
0.5047072768211365,
0.09524296224117279,
-0.389430969953537,
-0.021699318662285805,
-0.09733881056308746,
-0.4694488048553467,
-0.41745665669441223,
0.7265884876251221,
-0.16944679617881775,
-0.7562570571899414,
-0.6532483696937561,
-1.0573786497116089,
-0.22707568109035492,
-0.14739692211151123,
-0.051937535405159,
0.0334150567650795,
-0.0723297968506813,
0.2594062089920044,
0.3056008815765381,
0.01561067160218954,
0.3834956884384155,
0.5133237242698669,
-0.4092353880405426,
0.28344306349754333,
0.45884284377098083,
-0.00852524396032095,
0.12854281067848206,
0.028116237372159958,
0.008420728147029877,
-0.16972289979457855,
-0.831938624382019,
-0.43682152032852173,
0.45075368881225586,
-0.8850256204605103,
-0.20275485515594482,
-0.45362335443496704,
-0.07936801761388779,
-0.405435174703598,
-0.0815390944480896,
-0.31537100672721863,
-0.005587404128164053,
-0.15177026391029358,
-0.08460937440395355,
0.7905016541481018,
0.8079774379730225,
0.30927398800849915,
0.30646461248397827,
-0.5982300043106079,
0.09183742851018906,
0.19378989934921265,
0.1479433923959732,
-0.2194480299949646,
-0.4889160990715027,
0.011164248920977116,
-0.2346557378768921,
-0.13106778264045715,
-0.9084360003471375,
0.5011550188064575,
0.1705583930015564,
0.196868896484375,
0.5791101455688477,
0.258518248796463,
0.4805315434932709,
-0.2850804328918457,
0.47506478428840637,
0.09835585206747055,
-0.8992992043495178,
0.3337979316711426,
-0.4198185205459595,
0.3210030794143677,
0.5464369654655457,
0.32857638597488403,
-0.5799111127853394,
-0.5577452778816223,
-0.34368470311164856,
-0.8167442083358765,
0.5452456474304199,
-0.24340270459651947,
0.26454636454582214,
-0.41898125410079956,
0.2219492793083191,
0.05953078344464302,
0.3703635632991791,
-0.7771266102790833,
0.04217521846294403,
0.5926114320755005,
-0.4667205214500427,
-0.13100078701972961,
-0.05663558095693588,
-0.263103723526001,
-0.29471972584724426,
0.4888666272163391,
-0.4391150176525116,
-0.03627229109406471,
-0.1378624141216278,
-0.24814920127391815,
-0.005837198346853256,
0.4295106530189514,
0.3098719120025635,
0.7231237292289734,
-0.31127917766571045,
0.1488056182861328,
0.0405864343047142,
-0.0033502825535833836,
0.27327293157577515,
0.2536783814430237,
0.013076473027467728,
0.20533007383346558,
0.2611796259880066,
0.5174793004989624,
0.21443094313144684,
-1.4320824146270752,
0.7764126062393188,
0.12200144678354263,
-0.03254159912467003,
-0.8528573513031006,
-0.007101598661392927,
0.32290831208229065,
0.2818906009197235,
0.2694675922393799,
-0.3803320527076721,
0.15204262733459473,
-0.8091316819190979,
0.34758391976356506,
0.5607077479362488,
-0.47503626346588135,
-0.23954059183597565,
0.2486787736415863,
-0.04337232559919357,
-0.54166179895401,
0.8841956257820129,
-0.7708553075790405,
-0.5826152563095093,
0.5697697997093201,
0.6486272215843201,
0.7478715777397156,
-0.18141812086105347,
0.2846088111400604,
-0.17163144052028656,
0.5233963131904602,
-0.040207214653491974,
0.4403832256793976,
0.27100005745887756,
-0.62235027551651,
-0.40305498242378235,
-0.41466692090034485,
-0.4462348520755768,
0.5308714509010315,
-0.26378658413887024,
0.7544490694999695,
-0.4519073963165283,
0.4782165288925171,
0.2172262817621231,
-0.3111596703529358,
-0.8308741450309753,
0.017946159467101097,
0.13729660212993622,
1.0606387853622437,
-0.9320983290672302,
0.8156949877738953,
0.8621553778648376,
-0.19026786088943481,
-0.5470348000526428,
0.04423796012997627,
0.293852299451828,
-0.9003522992134094,
0.8537036776542664,
0.3245899975299835,
0.07785583287477493,
-0.2849214971065521,
-0.7045157551765442,
-0.3844242990016937,
0.6215290427207947,
0.6107028126716614,
-0.4594997465610504,
-0.09021438658237457,
0.15981823205947876,
0.31456074118614197,
-0.46696412563323975,
0.225258931517601,
1.1306322813034058,
0.5009797215461731,
-0.0393734946846962,
-0.8828301429748535,
0.2007637619972229,
-0.1767127960920334,
-0.4571375250816345,
0.2419186532497406,
-0.3456873595714569,
1.1788265705108643,
-0.085133858025074,
-0.05481677129864693,
0.14301244914531708,
0.690873920917511,
0.41453662514686584,
0.44534480571746826,
0.9742743968963623,
0.44948121905326843,
0.6611682772636414,
-0.04995705187320709,
1.1341581344604492,
-0.2856677770614624,
0.2884022891521454,
1.0950136184692383,
-0.4974408745765686,
1.0599570274353027,
0.5686228275299072,
-0.3838910460472107,
0.5627246499061584,
0.6448039412498474,
0.3643130958080292,
0.01012363936752081,
0.7630026340484619,
-0.6142227053642273,
-0.3591236174106598,
-0.19520385563373566,
-0.24251960217952728,
0.9280235767364502,
0.7583152651786804,
-0.36754074692726135,
-0.5093291997909546,
0.050748877227306366,
0.43271082639694214,
0.229389488697052,
-0.12541022896766663,
0.3101929724216461,
0.20484206080436707,
-0.5920551419258118,
0.6688363552093506,
0.12313620746135712,
0.860494077205658,
-0.4335917532444,
0.001280335709452629,
-0.008159950375556946,
0.4010988473892212,
-0.15229222178459167,
-0.8662492036819458,
0.43423643708229065,
0.025111153721809387,
0.1396275907754898,
0.2983067035675049,
0.8524875640869141,
-0.5461460947990417,
-0.6809026002883911,
0.40983113646507263,
0.5096085071563721,
0.6409896016120911,
-0.4226306080818176,
-0.8497555255889893,
0.11083311587572098,
-0.16922369599342346,
-0.2765054702758789,
0.15829871594905853,
0.42553749680519104,
-0.038703806698322296,
0.6429160237312317,
0.3446089029312134,
-0.16173943877220154,
-0.2538483738899231,
-0.2916313707828522,
0.7418367862701416,
-0.9336445331573486,
-0.4344814121723175,
-0.8522793054580688,
0.30521854758262634,
-0.19455726444721222,
-0.3713625371456146,
0.5884173512458801,
0.4761451482772827,
0.779770016670227,
-0.24156533181667328,
0.8005026578903198,
-0.04033024236559868,
0.6025668978691101,
-0.3667353093624115,
0.4206846058368683,
-0.5896982550621033,
0.4764930307865143,
-0.2964273691177368,
-0.6533617973327637,
-0.4223971962928772,
0.49004316329956055,
-0.5798286199569702,
-0.2873212397098541,
0.6126323938369751,
0.9847566485404968,
-0.17514875531196594,
0.1130860224366188,
0.3368176221847534,
0.6161556839942932,
0.44053739309310913,
0.6333389282226562,
1.0177847146987915,
-0.3542444407939911,
0.5576756000518799,
-0.21294286847114563,
-0.29563599824905396,
-0.36412549018859863,
-1.2123578786849976,
-0.8581887483596802,
-0.4791715741157532,
-0.5837461352348328,
-0.626215398311615,
-0.1563064008951187,
1.3010094165802002,
0.4933725595474243,
-0.781558096408844,
-0.6116414070129395,
-0.003950769547373056,
0.4886005222797394,
-0.09978941828012466,
-0.36583206057548523,
0.08116691559553146,
-0.379535973072052,
-1.0765652656555176,
0.7688857913017273,
0.619164228439331,
-0.26946672797203064,
-0.4347674548625946,
0.134446382522583,
-0.44725537300109863,
0.3183518648147583,
0.886448860168457,
0.2919979393482208,
-0.7035923600196838,
-0.5552809238433838,
-0.1992446333169937,
0.04148088023066521,
0.02532997354865074,
0.720230758190155,
-0.6796234846115112,
0.2922065556049347,
0.4881645441055298,
0.6243135929107666,
0.028201553970575333,
-0.3612958490848541,
0.3592245280742645,
-0.5305553674697876,
0.4557952880859375,
0.45184919238090515,
0.43533921241760254,
0.5796734094619751,
-0.25203919410705566,
0.5440002679824829,
0.35191231966018677,
-0.38005387783050537,
-1.3224923610687256,
0.312303751707077,
-0.8657573461532593,
-0.5784485936164856,
1.168565273284912,
-0.17597129940986633,
-0.39719927310943604,
-0.5567101836204529,
-0.22239752113819122,
-0.32246747612953186,
-0.14580397307872772,
0.9526448249816895,
0.9295775294303894,
-0.2610458433628082,
0.0707501545548439,
-0.5035767555236816,
0.3029002547264099,
0.3961663842201233,
-0.9113101363182068,
0.06494423002004623,
0.27577605843544006,
0.3472093343734741,
-0.022637657821178436,
0.7233954668045044,
-0.25669533014297485,
0.11628071963787079,
-0.2704804539680481,
-0.032758574932813644,
0.03611543029546738,
0.014475971460342407,
-0.4556403160095215,
0.22816361486911774,
0.45423424243927,
0.06462930142879486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13037v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13037v1
|
Enhancing Dialogue State Tracking Models through LLM-backed User-Agents Simulation
| 2024-05-17T07:00:05 | 2024-05-17T07:00:05 |
Cheng Niu, Xingguang Wang, Xuxin Cheng, Juntong Song, Tong Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Dialogue State Tracking (DST) is designed to monitor the evolving dialogue
state in the conversations and plays a pivotal role in developing task-oriented
dialogue systems. However, obtaining the annotated data for the DST task is
usually a costly endeavor. In this paper, we focus on employing LLMs to
generate dialogue data to reduce dialogue collection and annotation costs.
Specifically, GPT-4 is used to simulate the user and agent interaction,
generating thousands of dialogues annotated with DST labels. Then a two-stage
fine-tuning on LLaMA 2 is performed on the generated data and the real data for
the DST prediction. Experimental results on two public DST benchmarks show that
with the generated dialogue data, our model performs better than the baseline
trained solely on real data. In addition, our approach is also capable of
adapting to the dynamic demands in real-world scenarios, generating dialogues
in new domains swiftly. After replacing dialogue segments in any domain with
the corresponding generated ones, the model achieves comparable performance to
the model trained on real data.
|
[
-0.38906848430633545,
-0.5627813935279846,
0.8234033584594727,
-0.25184959173202515,
-0.43475621938705444,
0.23208071291446686,
0.08187537640333176,
-0.5041577219963074,
0.1425090879201889,
0.7287178635597229,
-0.9332143068313599,
-0.4254155158996582,
-0.20429842174053192,
0.15303100645542145,
-0.04684457555413246,
1.2172324657440186,
0.11412308365106583,
-0.2052195519208908,
-0.05290333926677704,
0.2759818732738495,
-0.29607057571411133,
-0.6675056219100952,
-0.7556867599487305,
-0.36582934856414795,
0.33285030722618103,
0.10809195786714554,
0.6073020696640015,
0.33508843183517456,
0.14689135551452637,
0.2721996605396271,
-0.10201927274465561,
0.4694424271583557,
-0.7096470594406128,
0.46629759669303894,
-0.03413020446896553,
-0.527912437915802,
-0.6313177347183228,
0.11371766030788422,
0.5367114543914795,
0.02486114576458931,
-0.28444904088974,
0.02683684043586254,
-0.041606757789850235,
0.07630216330289841,
-0.1323612928390503,
0.5091683864593506,
-0.6281102299690247,
-0.13365009427070618,
-0.05632339417934418,
-0.4381149709224701,
-0.106827512383461,
-0.4011109471321106,
0.2662617862224579,
-0.7189125418663025,
0.12599430978298187,
-0.058440666645765305,
0.6321457624435425,
0.3892102539539337,
-0.48762932419776917,
-0.19021743535995483,
-0.7739942669868469,
0.6036098003387451,
-0.9962959885597229,
-0.01000284031033516,
0.37715497612953186,
0.3058322072029114,
-0.5254642367362976,
-0.6690112352371216,
-0.6548583507537842,
-0.363901287317276,
0.12003946304321289,
0.23130972683429718,
-0.11044801026582718,
0.28113147616386414,
0.5115265250205994,
-0.00575350783765316,
-0.07891835272312164,
-0.05360475182533264,
-0.227264866232872,
-0.3061245381832123,
0.7067251205444336,
0.7078596353530884,
0.0720326155424118,
-0.19827939569950104,
-0.38968324661254883,
0.16037359833717346,
-0.8660266995429993,
-0.08293318748474121,
0.4774321913719177,
0.42403528094291687,
-0.08081202208995819,
0.45347559452056885,
-0.38906991481781006,
0.3869042694568634,
0.02951611392199993,
-0.5311785340309143,
-0.0026107330340892076,
-0.680897057056427,
-0.05701659619808197,
-0.14857958257198334,
0.5856462717056274,
0.6681718230247498,
0.19346675276756287,
0.04277675971388817,
-0.49702271819114685,
0.17495031654834747,
0.31698474287986755,
-1.078441858291626,
-0.20674020051956177,
-0.007653067819774151,
0.04770054295659065,
-0.3866102397441864,
-0.6018092036247253,
-0.49370482563972473,
-0.497747004032135,
-0.5626856088638306,
0.2600788474082947,
-0.2963680028915405,
-0.31312888860702515,
-0.12461136281490326,
0.42358362674713135,
0.004667378030717373,
0.9505327939987183,
-0.8236945271492004,
0.41845282912254333,
0.6559401154518127,
0.9167317748069763,
-0.17928563058376312,
0.03874383494257927,
-0.5491312146186829,
0.1913524717092514,
-0.43408453464508057,
0.882412850856781,
-0.4287712275981903,
-0.480618417263031,
-0.17157556116580963,
-0.23259903490543365,
-0.05914023146033287,
-0.4682443141937256,
0.21750828623771667,
-0.3639194071292877,
0.0013389741070568562,
-0.4147029519081116,
-0.626753032207489,
-0.09121331572532654,
0.5685418248176575,
-0.4226347506046295,
1.0234713554382324,
0.12208624929189682,
-0.5459770560264587,
0.1710161715745926,
-0.6080609560012817,
-0.06005961075425148,
0.15247438848018646,
-0.3940325081348419,
-0.43656206130981445,
0.011806932277977467,
0.26735684275627136,
0.39634695649147034,
-0.4355165958404541,
0.3831479847431183,
-0.1604551523923874,
-0.5814107060432434,
0.20371663570404053,
-0.5026150941848755,
0.19610759615898132,
0.3211127817630768,
-0.19677820801734924,
-0.13586600124835968,
-0.6611171960830688,
-0.26197659969329834,
-0.03690701350569725,
-0.3765731155872345,
0.019491046667099,
0.3077722489833832,
-0.21779634058475494,
0.21363377571105957,
0.027804339304566383,
-0.7425452470779419,
0.4768597185611725,
-0.3007759749889374,
0.22124169766902924,
0.7936243414878845,
0.48064330220222473,
0.029987819492816925,
-0.3368208706378937,
0.8202475905418396,
0.14399942755699158,
-0.1016935184597969,
-0.4076763689517975,
-0.6538782119750977,
-0.6174036860466003,
-0.43417593836784363,
-0.0693093091249466,
0.47041037678718567,
-0.7898575663566589,
-0.11830499023199081,
-0.1989988386631012,
-0.34503990411758423,
-0.5457362532615662,
-0.11886724084615707,
0.26158037781715393,
0.5384923219680786,
0.10031936317682266,
-0.3342273235321045,
-0.3521117866039276,
-0.6065757870674133,
0.04392947629094124,
-0.38810625672340393,
-0.12687619030475616,
0.4435267448425293,
0.40008482336997986,
-0.2786085903644562,
1.2168177366256714,
-0.5385276079177856,
-0.21047067642211914,
-0.24510414898395538,
0.14550158381462097,
-0.2186180055141449,
0.29134634137153625,
0.33172082901000977,
-0.37737342715263367,
-0.3134686350822449,
-0.12217538803815842,
-0.601349949836731,
-0.32865196466445923,
-0.22245024144649506,
0.07480345666408539,
0.3482676148414612,
0.15965905785560608,
-0.6507977843284607,
0.793176531791687,
0.4326011836528778,
-0.052914686501026154,
0.4994129538536072,
-0.025929264724254608,
0.29768407344818115,
-1.3208438158035278,
-0.23785808682441711,
-0.056119970977306366,
-0.4302988350391388,
-0.7486187815666199,
-0.5832933187484741,
-0.318802148103714,
-0.38261502981185913,
-0.4310176372528076,
0.46626871824264526,
-0.3872862458229065,
-0.37645629048347473,
-0.4184454679489136,
0.27272042632102966,
-0.07311129570007324,
0.7923120260238647,
0.06827081739902496,
1.2721887826919556,
0.2399860918521881,
-0.45302191376686096,
0.3838338553905487,
0.30099421739578247,
-0.277791827917099,
0.571208655834198,
-0.41117146611213684,
0.3889819085597992,
0.2044711709022522,
0.6694328188896179,
-1.0666178464889526,
-0.07296048849821091,
0.3464246392250061,
-0.1764659285545349,
0.07280334830284119,
-0.5592367053031921,
-0.6411054730415344,
0.0018683207454159856,
-0.16580775380134583,
0.17465482652187347,
0.606076717376709,
-0.46324917674064636,
0.6460593342781067,
0.3852834701538086,
-0.4001188278198242,
-0.08641975373029709,
-0.3134852945804596,
0.18273092806339264,
-0.3216208815574646,
-0.5497108101844788,
0.01696365512907505,
0.021410491317510605,
-0.014049547724425793,
-0.3246947228908539,
-0.3290746212005615,
0.3364701271057129,
0.20230209827423096,
0.3134755790233612,
0.17906630039215088,
0.0045257071033120155,
0.04171415790915489,
0.13491633534431458,
-0.26682624220848083,
0.025642607361078262,
-0.3012017011642456,
0.42105600237846375,
-0.011318009346723557,
-0.5126253962516785,
-1.0525882244110107,
0.1958714872598648,
0.41973644495010376,
-0.0037090869154781103,
0.3077782988548279,
0.431082546710968,
-0.16001363098621368,
-0.16836217045783997,
-0.586760938167572,
-0.44239652156829834,
-0.49470189213752747,
0.2596052587032318,
-0.584427535533905,
-0.8494037389755249,
0.5514302849769592,
-0.4077250063419342,
0.3238791227340698,
-0.03095008060336113,
0.6897716522216797,
-0.23299434781074524,
1.2163969278335571,
0.3758259415626526,
-0.06189704313874245,
0.5772045850753784,
-0.07745183259248734,
0.13695907592773438,
-0.946171224117279,
-0.13073764741420746,
-0.19895322620868683,
-0.055070847272872925,
-0.6078096032142639,
-0.6804280281066895,
0.5157344937324524,
-0.09562359750270844,
-0.041219793260097504,
0.3412177562713623,
-0.18187285959720612,
0.20270280539989471,
0.4937368333339691,
-0.0057447380386292934,
0.49093112349510193,
0.16602665185928345,
0.08765386790037155,
-0.12044335901737213,
-0.3431393504142761,
-0.916682243347168,
1.0655136108398438,
0.31182676553726196,
1.001020073890686,
0.09273736923933029,
0.7852824926376343,
0.4697609543800354,
0.24790333211421967,
-0.518207311630249,
0.7804372310638428,
0.37945106625556946,
-0.29981374740600586,
-0.1400999277830124,
-0.4696686565876007,
-0.7449042201042175,
0.4724768400192261,
0.06015791743993759,
-1.0841903686523438,
-0.24865303933620453,
0.43331798911094666,
-0.3655877709388733,
0.25425127148628235,
-0.5174695253372192,
0.3464471101760864,
0.003954361658543348,
-0.2850832939147949,
-0.39346781373023987,
-0.4574984908103943,
0.2287900447845459,
-0.23006480932235718,
-0.32414668798446655,
-0.6829106211662292,
0.09147606790065765,
0.6730139255523682,
-0.6254719495773315,
1.2954057455062866,
-0.37645968794822693,
-0.5166133642196655,
0.7161511778831482,
0.18568018078804016,
0.9440358281135559,
0.2639539837837219,
-0.028117947280406952,
0.035492729395627975,
0.060018159449100494,
-0.24955715239048004,
-0.5609685778617859,
0.5307130813598633,
-0.7763802409172058,
-0.8342083692550659,
-0.3787258267402649,
-0.753873348236084,
-0.3614981174468994,
-0.25175243616104126,
-0.13398516178131104,
0.5981005430221558,
-0.13606730103492737,
-0.4884340763092041,
0.3888877034187317,
-0.03742419555783272,
0.16699814796447754,
0.8577197194099426,
-0.059914715588092804,
-0.31552183628082275,
0.754825234413147,
0.09115967154502869,
0.4859018623828888,
0.06616298109292984,
-0.08836416155099869,
-0.39249780774116516,
-0.5390871167182922,
-0.5346845388412476,
0.2766890823841095,
-0.4613568186759949,
-0.3380501866340637,
-0.6408629417419434,
-0.11690886318683624,
-0.3286057710647583,
0.10151265561580658,
-0.36150062084198,
-0.4749370217323303,
-0.3334302604198456,
-0.33086225390434265,
0.6976594924926758,
0.9512877464294434,
0.017509952187538147,
0.6692160964012146,
-0.49874407052993774,
0.22035034000873566,
0.29784128069877625,
0.25272509455680847,
-0.2421644926071167,
-0.4940835237503052,
-0.3421165645122528,
0.317423939704895,
-0.6404033899307251,
-0.6907106637954712,
0.27976396679878235,
-0.05345778167247772,
0.37237995862960815,
0.09152530133724213,
0.06494785845279694,
0.8158380389213562,
-0.47435879707336426,
1.0394368171691895,
-0.0010360298911109567,
-0.7915198802947998,
0.6492851376533508,
-0.6517981290817261,
0.29421883821487427,
0.35342276096343994,
-0.11134292930364609,
-0.4798794984817505,
-0.5866830945014954,
-0.3820315897464752,
-0.5536057949066162,
1.193189024925232,
0.41042178869247437,
0.19017837941646576,
0.01857357658445835,
0.3717193305492401,
-0.05231839790940285,
0.20016147196292877,
-0.2299492359161377,
0.14474041759967804,
-0.13444064557552338,
-0.17232061922550201,
-0.06742539256811142,
-0.32262104749679565,
-0.17462818324565887,
0.15385198593139648,
0.7352999448776245,
-0.2887212336063385,
0.27979880571365356,
0.07103333622217178,
-0.015154621563851833,
-0.09634917974472046,
0.06339286267757416,
0.7870698571205139,
0.30896422266960144,
-0.2567178010940552,
-0.2492370307445526,
0.3734123408794403,
-0.4207516312599182,
0.26260221004486084,
0.11778203397989273,
-0.3705591559410095,
-0.1069113165140152,
-0.12478779256343842,
1.1659327745437622,
0.09920617192983627,
-0.6817946434020996,
0.3981490433216095,
-0.13276562094688416,
-0.0953340008854866,
-0.3464460074901581,
0.27299055457115173,
0.20026369392871857,
0.652551531791687,
0.1296403408050537,
-0.12238156050443649,
0.17793956398963928,
-0.25379183888435364,
0.25118008255958557,
0.3453427255153656,
-0.11447720229625702,
-0.6803299784660339,
0.6490561962127686,
0.505251944065094,
-0.38968604803085327,
0.6383739709854126,
-0.08701226860284805,
-0.5735058188438416,
0.44123169779777527,
0.6887826919555664,
0.6850944757461548,
-0.2364114671945572,
0.08159898221492767,
0.16875207424163818,
0.04119254648685455,
-0.035388968884944916,
0.23101598024368286,
-0.4278607666492462,
-0.5892152786254883,
-0.41814008355140686,
-0.5746743083000183,
-0.911840558052063,
0.1746763437986374,
-0.518497884273529,
0.27545586228370667,
-0.17235654592514038,
-0.5041651129722595,
-0.5040275454521179,
0.2961902618408203,
-0.6735602021217346,
0.13033808767795563,
0.4777384102344513,
0.5654535293579102,
-0.8164271116256714,
0.9852671027183533,
0.280349463224411,
-0.33802568912506104,
-0.7754876613616943,
0.12324699014425278,
0.442766934633255,
-0.8302893042564392,
0.3119352459907532,
0.17208755016326904,
-0.5973734855651855,
0.17261303961277008,
-0.4152623414993286,
-0.9060419201850891,
1.3000880479812622,
0.3439941704273224,
-0.6668400168418884,
0.020527547225356102,
0.27849653363227844,
0.7365552186965942,
-0.43265336751937866,
0.40828612446784973,
0.7858173251152039,
0.09041742235422134,
0.2020222693681717,
-0.932031512260437,
0.022539276629686356,
-0.03843206912279129,
0.2649866044521332,
0.2202392816543579,
-0.6430103182792664,
0.6318695545196533,
-0.20735813677310944,
-0.36207640171051025,
0.3293064534664154,
0.6525849103927612,
0.5439826250076294,
0.3875041604042053,
0.5035602450370789,
0.43270206451416016,
0.7161890268325806,
-0.050658561289310455,
0.8426336050033569,
-0.2543349862098694,
0.410680890083313,
1.1565803289413452,
-0.8402008414268494,
0.4593951106071472,
0.2835924029350281,
-0.024980712682008743,
0.27245867252349854,
0.7277305722236633,
-0.06980959326028824,
0.5457417964935303,
0.4138015806674957,
-0.5528916716575623,
-0.14544136822223663,
-0.19267942011356354,
-0.18045343458652496,
0.3079218566417694,
0.5313516855239868,
0.043509453535079956,
-0.19523818790912628,
-0.10594628751277924,
0.30194225907325745,
-0.16526460647583008,
-0.01196107268333435,
1.1979708671569824,
0.09029947221279144,
-0.8309001922607422,
0.6284458041191101,
-0.21932078897953033,
0.39825350046157837,
-0.714311420917511,
-0.1500314325094223,
-0.5852928161621094,
0.07465849816799164,
0.05360017344355583,
-0.5243998169898987,
-0.056070681661367416,
0.49110469222068787,
0.27995914220809937,
-0.18920376896858215,
0.5032655000686646,
-0.6132473349571228,
-0.24276092648506165,
0.25807109475135803,
0.40264081954956055,
0.5588464140892029,
0.1592172384262085,
-0.36561015248298645,
0.1289987564086914,
0.30191272497177124,
-0.6690975427627563,
0.48146703839302063,
0.32075294852256775,
-0.2948220670223236,
0.7959134578704834,
0.651863157749176,
0.06461738049983978,
-0.0310088898986578,
0.2369164377450943,
1.096105694770813,
-0.6260564923286438,
-0.4937743842601776,
-0.5656595230102539,
0.40131938457489014,
-0.03870964050292969,
-0.233079195022583,
0.40662500262260437,
0.4410122036933899,
0.5987680554389954,
0.21712347865104675,
0.9375225901603699,
0.2650022804737091,
0.7954080700874329,
-0.5191184282302856,
0.41859400272369385,
-0.4415103495121002,
0.6002318263053894,
-0.11511075496673584,
-0.7664331197738647,
0.1758643090724945,
0.31570976972579956,
-0.244463711977005,
-0.03176087141036987,
0.18250149488449097,
1.1719220876693726,
-0.07804903388023376,
0.29216495156288147,
0.4442440867424011,
0.088747039437294,
0.7538059949874878,
0.42964985966682434,
1.1378953456878662,
-0.2045699954032898,
0.4994458556175232,
-0.11398378759622574,
-0.014318806119263172,
-0.23568594455718994,
-0.643283486366272,
-1.0233417749404907,
-0.4558855891227722,
-0.26330986618995667,
-0.2263479381799698,
0.16100428998470306,
0.9986405968666077,
0.7793457508087158,
-0.5357676148414612,
-0.24789859354496002,
0.1091303825378418,
-0.41534170508384705,
0.017006216570734978,
-0.14515450596809387,
0.11996332556009293,
-0.47120538353919983,
-0.9010750651359558,
0.7086732387542725,
0.16998624801635742,
0.32102012634277344,
-0.1588616520166397,
-0.2496543675661087,
0.1296083629131317,
0.39439475536346436,
0.40810567140579224,
0.08834461867809296,
-0.9505122303962708,
-0.4652312099933624,
-0.40848296880722046,
-0.19368976354599,
0.1487531065940857,
0.8270969390869141,
-0.893688976764679,
0.5216392874717712,
0.11781839281320572,
0.5129795074462891,
1.1074258089065552,
0.5074605345726013,
0.819299042224884,
-0.7777951955795288,
-0.023619938641786575,
0.21320867538452148,
0.16645891964435577,
0.4572894871234894,
-0.4016071856021881,
0.6159549951553345,
0.17806242406368256,
-0.5755536556243896,
-0.8662329316139221,
0.4930150806903839,
-0.8961423635482788,
0.23211801052093506,
1.0916428565979004,
-0.3114190101623535,
0.3080786168575287,
-0.1221415102481842,
-0.3612153232097626,
0.3358117938041687,
-0.8024677038192749,
0.6436884999275208,
0.32826676964759827,
-0.441558301448822,
-0.11667905747890472,
-0.5745025873184204,
0.7345860600471497,
0.26898202300071716,
-0.9921143054962158,
0.2587410509586334,
0.6392866969108582,
0.47501102089881897,
-0.08857053518295288,
1.0578231811523438,
0.19473910331726074,
0.007218055427074432,
0.006039317697286606,
-0.010157331824302673,
-0.10697908699512482,
-0.16260208189487457,
-0.23426993191242218,
-0.26440128684043884,
-0.03265204280614853,
-0.2861728072166443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10548v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10548v3
|
Language Models can Exploit Cross-Task In-context Learning for Data-Scarce Novel Tasks
| 2024-05-17T05:20:49 | 2024-06-12T08:00:19 |
Anwoy Chatterjee, Eshaan Tanwar, Subhabrata Dutta, Tanmoy Chakraborty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have transformed NLP with their remarkable
In-context Learning (ICL) capabilities. Automated assistants based on LLMs are
gaining popularity; however, adapting them to novel tasks is still challenging.
While colossal models excel in zero-shot performance, their computational
demands limit widespread use, and smaller language models struggle without
context. This paper investigates whether LLMs can generalize from labeled
examples of predefined tasks to novel tasks. Drawing inspiration from
biological neurons and the mechanistic interpretation of the Transformer
architecture, we explore the potential for information sharing across tasks. We
design a cross-task prompting setup with three LLMs and show that LLMs achieve
significant performance improvements despite no examples from the target task
in the context. Cross-task prompting leads to a remarkable performance boost of
107% for LLaMA-2 7B, 18.6% for LLaMA-2 13B, and 3.2% for GPT 3.5 on average
over zero-shot prompting, and performs comparable to standard in-context
learning. The effectiveness of generating pseudo-labels for in-task examples is
demonstrated, and our analyses reveal a strong correlation between the effect
of cross-task examples and model activation similarities in source and target
input tokens. This paper offers a first-of-its-kind exploration of LLMs'
ability to solve novel tasks based on contextual signals from different task
examples.
|
[
-0.14282502233982086,
-0.8171152472496033,
0.6262147426605225,
0.23270724713802338,
-0.0662996768951416,
-0.07466131448745728,
-0.32686325907707214,
-0.5542482137680054,
-0.09487947076559067,
0.30520591139793396,
-0.6020902395248413,
-0.2538868188858032,
-0.7707962393760681,
0.31928178668022156,
-0.506072461605072,
0.908798098564148,
-0.009633964858949184,
-0.14215895533561707,
-0.30955594778060913,
-0.06262729316949844,
-0.7496651411056519,
-0.5130025148391724,
-0.6444804072380066,
-0.5524635314941406,
0.7263783812522888,
0.39878156781196594,
0.4033157527446747,
0.33580076694488525,
0.05798422917723656,
0.29271388053894043,
0.07531783729791641,
0.1731211245059967,
-0.32786646485328674,
0.16513477265834808,
-0.5070251226425171,
-0.6152427792549133,
-0.2247406393289566,
-0.1698646992444992,
0.6223568916320801,
0.9235749244689941,
0.20586252212524414,
0.07133935391902924,
0.4247632622718811,
0.2553727328777313,
-0.5223129391670227,
0.34346288442611694,
-0.7977540493011475,
0.03731472045183182,
-0.052969712764024734,
-0.43562501668930054,
-0.5799652934074402,
0.3282599449157715,
0.1784711331129074,
-0.631145179271698,
0.15511347353458405,
-0.09143545478582382,
0.6569749712944031,
0.44945764541625977,
-0.3006640374660492,
-0.509158730506897,
-0.7307621836662292,
0.8501505255699158,
-0.5347501635551453,
0.2198045551776886,
0.22721928358078003,
0.09501588344573975,
-0.20073315501213074,
-0.6157194375991821,
-0.5902958512306213,
-0.24017812311649323,
-0.2523151934146881,
-0.30313241481781006,
-0.5233606100082397,
-0.1509387493133545,
0.3578138053417206,
0.06811641156673431,
-0.385082483291626,
0.23954707384109497,
-0.13601964712142944,
0.1481395661830902,
0.3339681625366211,
0.224861741065979,
0.41953417658805847,
0.0028102537617087364,
-0.28906863927841187,
-0.15255391597747803,
-0.713357150554657,
0.27450594305992126,
-0.045503322035074234,
0.4411345422267914,
-0.2511299252510071,
0.46816104650497437,
-0.13794849812984467,
0.9332093596458435,
0.3302587568759918,
0.07995327562093735,
0.29199373722076416,
-0.3108614981174469,
-0.31933143734931946,
-0.2742500901222229,
0.6781641244888306,
-0.015781406313180923,
0.004949826747179031,
-0.47359341382980347,
-0.30085256695747375,
-0.27570533752441406,
0.2855214476585388,
-0.34005895256996155,
0.024519307538866997,
-0.016017155721783638,
-0.31673431396484375,
0.030943620949983597,
-0.3971916437149048,
-0.336549311876297,
-0.18311196565628052,
-0.5140918493270874,
0.8063440918922424,
-0.24772851169109344,
-0.039176709949970245,
-0.033316582441329956,
-0.05754522606730461,
0.27820998430252075,
0.28018027544021606,
-0.9475441575050354,
0.3110353350639343,
0.6476353406906128,
0.795512855052948,
-0.4867125451564789,
-0.5858131647109985,
-0.6064790487289429,
0.18896527588367462,
-0.18762856721878052,
0.6802382469177246,
-0.681857168674469,
-0.24562908709049225,
-0.13943059742450714,
0.20467180013656616,
-0.29772230982780457,
-0.62208092212677,
0.0865059569478035,
-0.4748249053955078,
-0.030884088948369026,
-0.3750208616256714,
-0.4058084785938263,
-0.1492374837398529,
0.20002058148384094,
-0.6368940472602844,
0.8989351391792297,
0.12791486084461212,
-0.560849130153656,
0.44283998012542725,
-0.8782361745834351,
-0.5549101233482361,
0.11608076095581055,
-0.3544568717479706,
-0.06692103296518326,
0.19405971467494965,
0.19967752695083618,
0.8789209127426147,
-0.4323571026325226,
0.5026697516441345,
-0.03551192581653595,
-0.3742087185382843,
0.16551457345485687,
-0.2910202145576477,
0.7395135164260864,
-0.08361245691776276,
-0.520588755607605,
0.261033833026886,
-0.30495038628578186,
-0.24193283915519714,
0.16155697405338287,
-0.2602667808532715,
-0.4185483753681183,
-0.2599828839302063,
-0.09290313720703125,
0.3426307737827301,
0.26984283328056335,
-0.4693610370159149,
0.24062252044677734,
-0.14298033714294434,
0.36642056703567505,
0.504181981086731,
-0.18954749405384064,
0.5327062606811523,
-0.4482041001319885,
0.6374479532241821,
-0.0637776181101799,
-0.11196351051330566,
-0.3572205603122711,
-0.5981297492980957,
-0.5718134641647339,
-0.26048213243484497,
-0.012620726600289345,
0.6013161540031433,
-0.9459278583526611,
0.2894839942455292,
-0.20929937064647675,
-0.41044142842292786,
-0.2576453685760498,
0.23896175622940063,
0.5110176205635071,
0.6542015075683594,
0.5779786109924316,
-0.11111903935670853,
-0.42883580923080444,
-0.8609828352928162,
-0.4512174427509308,
0.2177353948354721,
-0.33042842149734497,
0.5806822180747986,
0.49711689352989197,
-0.20692884922027588,
0.9244112372398376,
-0.09816303104162216,
-0.2965843677520752,
-0.5859947204589844,
0.2810076177120209,
0.3563285171985626,
0.4822632968425751,
0.4075735807418823,
-0.7188552618026733,
-0.4358678162097931,
-0.01628948003053665,
-0.8121548891067505,
-0.17187850177288055,
-0.3813934624195099,
0.21879617869853973,
0.003464823355898261,
0.6148709654808044,
-0.5329827070236206,
0.20819635689258575,
0.6776875853538513,
-0.15584394335746765,
0.3158988356590271,
-0.44260382652282715,
-0.12943997979164124,
-1.0800715684890747,
0.11807379126548767,
0.09110686182975769,
-0.08552326261997223,
-0.8084680438041687,
-0.08226674795150757,
-0.05380500853061676,
0.007701873779296875,
-0.5270947217941284,
0.8271899223327637,
-0.553069531917572,
-0.24911069869995117,
-0.586885929107666,
-0.08436250686645508,
-0.21532100439071655,
0.7531985640525818,
0.21534740924835205,
0.6240135431289673,
0.813226044178009,
-0.737433135509491,
0.15017981827259064,
0.1786225289106369,
-0.2258094847202301,
0.3907993733882904,
-0.7788882851600647,
0.1564110964536667,
-0.21189174056053162,
0.5127474665641785,
-0.8087546825408936,
-0.18384873867034912,
0.1743711531162262,
-0.26926156878471375,
0.3839205205440521,
0.13775859773159027,
-0.48642346262931824,
-0.05760620906949043,
0.11337950080633163,
0.7082017660140991,
0.41501763463020325,
-0.7021931409835815,
0.7042922377586365,
0.37448036670684814,
-0.17168255150318146,
-0.6360145211219788,
-0.8219114542007446,
0.2595374584197998,
-0.08823904395103455,
-0.23233406245708466,
0.6215016841888428,
0.06579527258872986,
0.05327928438782692,
0.0634877011179924,
0.05499635264277458,
-0.035476721823215485,
-0.012256346642971039,
0.4708152115345001,
0.1589123010635376,
0.015193209983408451,
0.22934718430042267,
0.05295565351843834,
0.03872610256075859,
-0.043666791170835495,
-0.3527517318725586,
0.539076030254364,
-0.057301390916109085,
-0.4251343607902527,
-0.47375693917274475,
0.48359501361846924,
0.2730751037597656,
-0.032451268285512924,
0.6254586577415466,
0.4263935089111328,
-0.4552387297153473,
-0.4554913640022278,
-0.2845996022224426,
-0.3932334780693054,
-0.47366103529930115,
0.5234473943710327,
-0.5899888873100281,
-1.0397734642028809,
0.27072879672050476,
-0.10471044480800629,
0.14544999599456787,
0.2656831741333008,
0.7397196292877197,
-0.009004016406834126,
0.7160612344741821,
0.8671064972877502,
-0.21234630048274994,
0.5914964079856873,
-0.30082517862319946,
0.18804949522018433,
-0.877524197101593,
-0.36567962169647217,
-0.4016818404197693,
-0.5622117519378662,
-0.275591105222702,
-0.7270495295524597,
0.3203461170196533,
-0.09015969932079315,
0.07844392955303192,
0.6763673424720764,
-0.41380563378334045,
0.5854185819625854,
0.5929000377655029,
0.07512235641479492,
0.2151762992143631,
-0.041030850261449814,
-0.13781647384166718,
0.30061984062194824,
-1.0162514448165894,
-0.36764058470726013,
1.0656050443649292,
0.1905117779970169,
0.6666816473007202,
-0.41283512115478516,
0.5437852740287781,
0.33385613560676575,
0.3624451756477356,
-0.7294481992721558,
0.5686106085777283,
-0.22661884129047394,
-0.47644126415252686,
-0.4422832727432251,
-0.22335179150104523,
-1.1390715837478638,
0.23215803503990173,
-0.09635094553232193,
-0.9247767925262451,
0.32630378007888794,
0.2208409458398819,
-0.2934514284133911,
0.2982754409313202,
-0.5230268836021423,
0.8139081001281738,
-0.05411563068628311,
-0.359415203332901,
-0.2525881826877594,
-0.6140751242637634,
0.2752644121646881,
-0.13270126283168793,
0.18442191183567047,
0.04486678168177605,
-0.18976211547851562,
0.5848175883293152,
0.08155932277441025,
1.2478848695755005,
-0.15884922444820404,
-0.26041388511657715,
0.13326427340507507,
0.03053477220237255,
0.5704443454742432,
-0.14769545197486877,
-0.08747494220733643,
0.24763084948062897,
-0.3037048280239105,
-0.34463316202163696,
-0.6989036202430725,
0.7271692752838135,
-0.5497142672538757,
-0.6507673859596252,
-0.11512237787246704,
-1.143660068511963,
-0.35044029355049133,
-0.022008871659636497,
0.29367440938949585,
0.4556864798069,
0.15071211755275726,
0.3048555254936218,
0.516189694404602,
-0.28109297156333923,
0.5722185969352722,
0.42203742265701294,
0.2754986882209778,
0.1706399768590927,
0.8510502576828003,
-0.12079034745693207,
0.28720003366470337,
0.7939066886901855,
0.1393546462059021,
-0.23160357773303986,
-0.3987150490283966,
-0.3790600597858429,
0.14603811502456665,
-0.7969295382499695,
-0.009783854708075523,
-0.9157335162162781,
0.06684113293886185,
-0.18732337653636932,
-0.36492714285850525,
-0.12023188918828964,
-0.20587268471717834,
-0.3109920620918274,
0.10536006838083267,
0.08874879032373428,
0.9169294834136963,
-0.10287166386842728,
0.28443482518196106,
-0.7499099373817444,
0.38293692469596863,
0.4573519825935364,
-0.01576237380504608,
0.3110123574733734,
-0.5925294160842896,
-0.24172236025333405,
0.006272639147937298,
-0.1602189838886261,
-0.8945660591125488,
0.3084624409675598,
0.21796105802059174,
0.8117319941520691,
0.02941426821053028,
-0.08563362061977386,
0.5380216836929321,
-0.5170137286186218,
0.7346652746200562,
-0.03397858142852783,
-1.1499783992767334,
0.21995089948177338,
-0.2593093812465668,
0.5523076057434082,
0.20753426849842072,
0.6609034538269043,
-0.5137032866477966,
-0.4621529281139374,
-0.4188193380832672,
-0.6791960597038269,
0.9265174865722656,
0.002486724406480789,
0.28909921646118164,
0.08843226730823517,
0.27771493792533875,
0.27345725893974304,
0.14342308044433594,
-0.9864848256111145,
-0.13055916130542755,
0.10374242067337036,
-0.1267523616552353,
-0.20507343113422394,
0.08133013546466827,
-0.043089598417282104,
-0.30631300806999207,
0.35956817865371704,
-0.4039897918701172,
0.3355419337749481,
0.21567364037036896,
-0.2872990369796753,
0.0415247417986393,
0.2582748234272003,
0.5368176102638245,
0.48993703722953796,
0.34864193201065063,
0.15403546392917633,
0.5033665895462036,
0.0397392176091671,
0.10922855883836746,
-0.049349136650562286,
-0.10748151689767838,
-0.014040379785001278,
0.5281835198402405,
0.9268752932548523,
0.48847344517707825,
-0.7033522129058838,
0.5035099387168884,
0.06122675910592079,
-0.09752394258975983,
0.05876526981592178,
0.12046043574810028,
0.14155521988868713,
0.5366083979606628,
0.5345085263252258,
0.00789068453013897,
0.11749904602766037,
-0.7304585576057434,
0.28738486766815186,
0.6681543588638306,
-0.3417847454547882,
-0.48633435368537903,
0.5554929971694946,
-0.030775560066103935,
-0.4413622319698334,
0.02906559407711029,
-0.22922416031360626,
-0.33245155215263367,
0.6492257118225098,
0.8571183681488037,
0.838300347328186,
-0.20207780599594116,
0.16796284914016724,
0.12554386258125305,
0.09838873147964478,
-0.061526909470558167,
0.0987088605761528,
-0.7321153283119202,
-0.6437675356864929,
-0.6122670769691467,
-0.4493620991706848,
-0.4569833278656006,
0.2569214701652527,
-0.32859882712364197,
0.190423846244812,
-0.18566541373729706,
0.08377692103385925,
-0.015811048448085785,
-0.4484056532382965,
-0.7383877635002136,
0.20917944610118866,
0.08082053065299988,
0.5717921853065491,
-0.8743986487388611,
1.0071805715560913,
0.7447925209999084,
-0.058279238641262054,
-0.8617282509803772,
0.11238008737564087,
-0.29563358426094055,
-0.8089858889579773,
0.9667521715164185,
0.15036170184612274,
-0.06686577200889587,
-0.1310207098722458,
-0.3654502332210541,
-0.8013826608657837,
1.0315688848495483,
0.3843543529510498,
-0.5457875728607178,
-0.5378847122192383,
0.37611624598503113,
0.5153464078903198,
-0.6044122576713562,
0.252013236284256,
0.3435027301311493,
0.2627486288547516,
0.07288499921560287,
-1.1752594709396362,
0.34706562757492065,
-0.16995586454868317,
-0.105648934841156,
-0.05285213887691498,
-0.35246971249580383,
1.1452834606170654,
-0.231331467628479,
-0.04736030101776123,
-0.12642915546894073,
0.4322282373905182,
0.25908321142196655,
0.25994208455085754,
0.7093461751937866,
0.16959324479103088,
0.4519219398498535,
0.272161066532135,
0.9680663347244263,
-0.26303109526634216,
0.006677383091300726,
1.3157448768615723,
-0.22459636628627777,
0.7324296832084656,
0.608274519443512,
0.16299839317798615,
0.5705006122589111,
0.25609061121940613,
0.02113242633640766,
0.4322218596935272,
0.1341131180524826,
-0.24406228959560394,
-0.21560539305210114,
-0.3059864044189453,
-0.10781572014093399,
0.4395981431007385,
0.5536195039749146,
-0.42868855595588684,
-0.41419634222984314,
0.4121662676334381,
-0.2185460478067398,
-0.10970000922679901,
-0.23865772783756256,
0.6905412077903748,
0.23753683269023895,
-0.7680433392524719,
0.6529436707496643,
-0.1867627054452896,
0.935526430606842,
-0.5333462357521057,
-0.16044805943965912,
0.11488160490989685,
0.0872415080666542,
-0.1454329937696457,
-0.6086925268173218,
0.3971432149410248,
0.030798425897955894,
-0.18826861679553986,
-0.559079647064209,
0.6300205588340759,
-0.5344207286834717,
-0.22215041518211365,
0.5194416046142578,
0.4640047252178192,
0.06640373170375824,
-0.15326102077960968,
-0.5084193348884583,
-0.008573909290134907,
-0.143588587641716,
-0.15775972604751587,
0.4302804470062256,
0.3675827980041504,
-0.20383739471435547,
0.741924524307251,
0.5536234378814697,
0.04928876459598541,
0.16826297342777252,
-0.22331252694129944,
0.7994431853294373,
-0.5234240293502808,
-0.3635346293449402,
-0.749640703201294,
0.28820091485977173,
0.11060551553964615,
-0.2562668025493622,
0.771633505821228,
0.29367145895957947,
1.1347970962524414,
-0.28172364830970764,
0.769751250743866,
-0.06321761012077332,
0.3850788176059723,
-0.37298405170440674,
0.4503646492958069,
-0.8125114440917969,
0.16120950877666473,
-0.24777907133102417,
-0.7139081954956055,
-0.2491132766008377,
0.24160921573638916,
-0.3861807882785797,
-0.02578006684780121,
0.7135890126228333,
0.7602884769439697,
-0.1617872714996338,
-0.03999264910817146,
0.5541245937347412,
-0.0683361068367958,
0.2622748911380768,
1.0039255619049072,
0.7193467020988464,
-0.16845639050006866,
0.49469029903411865,
-0.19301600754261017,
-0.24233993887901306,
-0.19596773386001587,
-0.7906057834625244,
-1.0353626012802124,
-0.9245368838310242,
-0.12680062651634216,
0.11417770385742188,
0.029864968731999397,
0.9376013278961182,
0.9225647449493408,
-0.7115128636360168,
-0.359553724527359,
-0.19429117441177368,
0.014795277267694473,
-0.2920040190219879,
-0.16219982504844666,
0.15510666370391846,
-0.5725340843200684,
-0.9464801549911499,
0.8323512077331543,
0.2361469715833664,
-0.03941147401928902,
-0.13606128096580505,
0.07194942981004715,
-0.21951794624328613,
-0.016231529414653778,
0.594525158405304,
0.5037447810173035,
-0.7691706418991089,
-0.01154282782226801,
0.08072508126497269,
-0.058030348271131516,
-0.12434892356395721,
1.086390495300293,
-1.0177390575408936,
0.08636798709630966,
0.5247361660003662,
1.0621023178100586,
0.5157860517501831,
-0.2627103328704834,
0.6653607487678528,
-0.7971079349517822,
0.2299288809299469,
0.3261987864971161,
0.3934527635574341,
0.2779839336872101,
-0.4114694893360138,
0.06503163278102875,
0.011044812388718128,
-0.4818013608455658,
-0.7513972520828247,
0.28423550724983215,
-0.7631537318229675,
-0.40653929114341736,
1.1422921419143677,
-0.23660293221473694,
-0.2682372033596039,
-0.19671685993671417,
-0.05064889043569565,
0.31044769287109375,
-0.3107413649559021,
0.7297598719596863,
0.5301754474639893,
-0.3550138771533966,
-0.0550132654607296,
-0.518146812915802,
0.5407246351242065,
0.811835765838623,
-0.8760305047035217,
0.06657373160123825,
0.11061058938503265,
0.24173644185066223,
0.20120149850845337,
0.502151608467102,
0.20335188508033752,
0.23545485734939575,
-0.23691122233867645,
-0.12892353534698486,
-0.14116045832633972,
-0.5525354743003845,
-0.4935155510902405,
0.2762305438518524,
-0.18169230222702026,
-0.180160254240036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10542v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10542v1
|
Benchmarking Large Language Models on CFLUE -- A Chinese Financial Language Understanding Evaluation Dataset
| 2024-05-17T05:03:40 | 2024-05-17T05:03:40 |
Jie Zhu, Junhui Li, Yalong Wen, Lifan Guo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In light of recent breakthroughs in large language models (LLMs) that have
revolutionized natural language processing (NLP), there is an urgent need for
new benchmarks to keep pace with the fast development of LLMs. In this paper,
we propose CFLUE, the Chinese Financial Language Understanding Evaluation
benchmark, designed to assess the capability of LLMs across various dimensions.
Specifically, CFLUE provides datasets tailored for both knowledge assessment
and application assessment. In knowledge assessment, it consists of 38K+
multiple-choice questions with associated solution explanations. These
questions serve dual purposes: answer prediction and question reasoning. In
application assessment, CFLUE features 16K+ test instances across distinct
groups of NLP tasks such as text classification, machine translation, relation
extraction, reading comprehension, and text generation. Upon CFLUE, we conduct
a thorough evaluation of representative LLMs. The results reveal that only
GPT-4 and GPT-4-turbo achieve an accuracy exceeding 60\% in answer prediction
for knowledge assessment, suggesting that there is still substantial room for
improvement in current LLMs. In application assessment, although GPT-4 and
GPT-4-turbo are the top two performers, their considerable advantage over
lightweight LLMs is noticeably diminished. The datasets and scripts associated
with CFLUE are openly accessible at https://github.com/aliyun/cflue.
|
[
-0.2543642520904541,
-0.5146995186805725,
0.22438304126262665,
0.6540436148643494,
0.05221574008464813,
0.3351954519748688,
-0.571081817150116,
-0.615858256816864,
-0.3205184042453766,
0.4247736632823944,
-0.21013180911540985,
-0.49475613236427307,
-0.4015267491340637,
0.03592349961400032,
-0.5126317739486694,
0.9140142798423767,
-0.044450994580984116,
0.08613813668489456,
-0.03960992023348808,
-0.20970554649829865,
-0.3863123655319214,
-0.3459120988845825,
-1.0472701787948608,
-0.2726951837539673,
0.3369481861591339,
0.32092511653900146,
0.7847984433174133,
0.5200049877166748,
0.4373037815093994,
0.2863789498806,
0.02319663017988205,
-0.16219817101955414,
-0.5374929904937744,
-0.34661585092544556,
-0.0742478221654892,
-0.1924993246793747,
-0.46319594979286194,
-0.07370614260435104,
0.80855792760849,
0.7777469754219055,
-0.28297969698905945,
0.1354353129863739,
0.15591473877429962,
0.6934302449226379,
-0.620566725730896,
0.4416167140007019,
-0.5895292162895203,
0.09778309613466263,
-0.15665124356746674,
0.0012055413099005818,
-0.3256866931915283,
-0.50538170337677,
0.3864143490791321,
-0.6505635976791382,
0.10617955774068832,
0.08761893957853317,
0.7089681029319763,
-0.006303905975073576,
-0.6151140332221985,
-0.11361357569694519,
-0.370978444814682,
0.9139052033424377,
-0.8092162013053894,
0.5662493705749512,
0.12376885116100311,
0.48865658044815063,
0.03671622648835182,
-0.7465958595275879,
-0.3532223105430603,
-0.37578314542770386,
-0.07052891701459885,
0.1292496919631958,
-0.1563941389322281,
0.10266111046075821,
0.27264711260795593,
0.551063597202301,
-0.7676990032196045,
0.23005470633506775,
-0.06531035900115967,
-0.4370149075984955,
0.677005410194397,
-0.049128010869026184,
0.09094304591417313,
0.1090332567691803,
-0.6407588124275208,
-0.21247868239879608,
-0.5760327577590942,
-0.04074958711862564,
0.13117998838424683,
0.22754237055778503,
-0.13060496747493744,
0.17377561330795288,
-0.28513646125793457,
0.6966066360473633,
-0.2795698642730713,
-0.067195363342762,
0.37956079840660095,
-0.43902358412742615,
-0.4652993977069855,
-0.008826389908790588,
0.8524292707443237,
0.23671244084835052,
0.4566636383533478,
-0.24297687411308289,
-0.5703079700469971,
-0.37453943490982056,
-0.23759020864963531,
-0.8305273056030273,
-0.3181276023387909,
0.29252609610557556,
-0.2804901897907257,
-0.1856859177350998,
0.09433969855308533,
-0.8397719264030457,
-0.36771538853645325,
-0.24466948211193085,
0.20008763670921326,
-0.3989121615886688,
-0.39228785037994385,
0.32552003860473633,
-0.1763613075017929,
0.5962297320365906,
0.27976757287979126,
-1.1264774799346924,
0.5738940834999084,
1.0282256603240967,
0.7469756603240967,
-0.20060919225215912,
-0.30468758940696716,
-0.7011284232139587,
-0.0441177673637867,
-0.31340375542640686,
0.8094841837882996,
-0.42065998911857605,
-0.34156563878059387,
0.19429603219032288,
-0.4124656617641449,
-0.16991101205348969,
-0.7705284953117371,
0.7556516528129578,
-0.5994197726249695,
-0.12258389592170715,
-0.4909122586250305,
-0.6122680902481079,
-0.2508891224861145,
0.43378251791000366,
-0.7811984419822693,
1.126647710800171,
0.2525831460952759,
-0.767867386341095,
0.3842868506908417,
-0.7901561260223389,
-0.37360453605651855,
0.1535259485244751,
-0.2084571272134781,
-0.036377646028995514,
-0.32288360595703125,
0.32262763381004333,
0.4300275444984436,
-0.7595211863517761,
0.407665878534317,
-0.385644793510437,
-0.43728017807006836,
0.3415082097053528,
-0.6724414229393005,
0.8756027221679688,
0.21313491463661194,
-0.39617350697517395,
0.05015797168016434,
-0.7100914120674133,
0.05379500985145569,
0.17273519933223724,
-0.10677361488342285,
-0.23872722685337067,
-0.14868420362472534,
0.4514389932155609,
0.01748594641685486,
0.4902478754520416,
-0.32648929953575134,
0.09661095589399338,
-0.47892796993255615,
0.4968826472759247,
0.8889026045799255,
-0.2146969437599182,
0.2612411379814148,
-0.31711989641189575,
0.6167810559272766,
-0.07429714500904083,
0.18217076361179352,
0.08881835639476776,
-0.23824343085289001,
-0.5399632453918457,
0.07638474553823471,
0.6036331653594971,
0.4956541359424591,
-0.7446550726890564,
0.14613190293312073,
-0.15530593693256378,
-0.44854265451431274,
-0.027674803510308266,
0.2956258952617645,
0.1933538019657135,
0.4072909355163574,
0.2889712452888489,
0.01404875610023737,
-0.24327252805233002,
-0.9256551861763,
-0.31631243228912354,
-0.32315975427627563,
-0.19439707696437836,
0.22530899941921234,
0.47809699177742004,
-0.11228154599666595,
0.7324347496032715,
-0.6052270531654358,
-0.09340175241231918,
-0.2651643455028534,
0.2600591480731964,
0.3665906488895416,
0.20514480769634247,
0.9480454921722412,
-0.9441914558410645,
-0.3917953372001648,
0.3025680482387543,
-0.48883935809135437,
-0.21558906137943268,
-0.40173041820526123,
-0.12426645308732986,
-0.005305361934006214,
0.2805488109588623,
-0.34355664253234863,
-0.09613350033760071,
0.7937697768211365,
-0.19931380450725555,
0.887626051902771,
-0.014650354161858559,
0.03926293924450874,
-0.6848182082176208,
0.24817214906215668,
0.2683820128440857,
-0.17240644991397858,
-0.47508329153060913,
0.12570761144161224,
0.1926473081111908,
0.22506771981716156,
-0.2740854322910309,
0.7520129680633545,
-0.36828312277793884,
-0.4424678087234497,
-0.010619009844958782,
0.6040194630622864,
-0.05130397155880928,
0.44015422463417053,
0.0360860712826252,
0.8370451927185059,
0.5837885737419128,
-0.341220885515213,
0.4292752146720886,
0.026164308190345764,
-0.6415746808052063,
0.15698085725307465,
-0.6421857476234436,
0.029027482494711876,
0.5611422061920166,
0.10538222640752792,
-0.8845635056495667,
0.18002907931804657,
-0.03586785867810249,
-0.10102313756942749,
0.11316417157649994,
0.2541039288043976,
-0.5996924042701721,
-0.276140421628952,
-0.4823073148727417,
0.40689507126808167,
-0.00007799492595950142,
-0.683152973651886,
0.5620918869972229,
0.20078736543655396,
-0.24601510167121887,
-1.0392206907272339,
-0.48129627108573914,
0.1747562289237976,
-0.18581002950668335,
-0.6508970260620117,
0.3163772225379944,
-0.2412426769733429,
-0.3940301537513733,
-0.1684962660074234,
-0.09004265069961548,
-0.2943490445613861,
0.39047887921333313,
-0.3881514370441437,
0.4328913390636444,
-0.4957257807254791,
0.20358231663703918,
-0.09732308238744736,
-0.033568400889635086,
0.26272448897361755,
-0.2778920531272888,
0.3551904261112213,
-0.3957287073135376,
-0.05732845887541771,
0.06677345931529999,
-0.27707988023757935,
0.31393730640411377,
-0.32639655470848083,
0.474858820438385,
0.6493930816650391,
-0.4067993760108948,
-0.4362627863883972,
-0.48695632815361023,
0.13268236815929413,
-0.5264924764633179,
0.3527820408344269,
-0.25550180673599243,
-1.0614664554595947,
0.5928146243095398,
-0.13827849924564362,
0.5228639245033264,
0.7197091579437256,
0.5654800534248352,
0.36075183749198914,
0.5403998494148254,
0.5596773028373718,
-0.7047132253646851,
0.3087168037891388,
-0.1588660478591919,
0.10854852199554443,
-0.44324687123298645,
0.2980283200740814,
-0.5786610841751099,
-0.012831867672502995,
-0.48651888966560364,
-0.43886178731918335,
0.08241143077611923,
0.14798131585121155,
-0.3811686038970947,
0.3431204855442047,
-0.16658350825309753,
0.42274409532546997,
0.1193385049700737,
-0.36250126361846924,
0.5354593992233276,
-0.42430579662323,
-0.22929732501506805,
0.12308278679847717,
-0.5927568078041077,
-0.36837539076805115,
1.1463134288787842,
0.6032517552375793,
0.6397308707237244,
0.07192649692296982,
0.31915032863616943,
0.3132357597351074,
0.6656915545463562,
-0.7487497329711914,
0.5115824937820435,
-0.15774568915367126,
-0.3949695825576782,
-0.3619614839553833,
-0.8279392719268799,
-0.5327150821685791,
0.3169594407081604,
-0.08799190819263458,
-0.6215072870254517,
-0.05981076881289482,
0.019381284713745117,
-0.4420977532863617,
0.125276580452919,
-0.7150025367736816,
1.1334364414215088,
-0.5795616507530212,
-0.07624014467000961,
-0.11164918541908264,
-0.21079736948013306,
0.8164795637130737,
-0.5852348208427429,
0.21157744526863098,
0.0004231116909068078,
-0.11518817394971848,
0.8374984860420227,
-0.384312242269516,
0.5185340642929077,
-0.1318778544664383,
-0.5079635977745056,
0.21666809916496277,
-0.1690720170736313,
0.29593056440353394,
0.3307594954967499,
-0.44337862730026245,
0.41687580943107605,
0.30590859055519104,
-0.3729434311389923,
-0.6340134739875793,
0.7558069825172424,
-0.6494550108909607,
-0.37714439630508423,
-0.5371251702308655,
-0.39602935314178467,
-0.42624631524086,
0.1788591891527176,
-0.14540408551692963,
0.3471490442752838,
-0.5144679546356201,
0.18670649826526642,
0.26850205659866333,
-0.42218509316444397,
0.3561614453792572,
0.6318152546882629,
-0.4989921748638153,
-0.23255297541618347,
0.8137692213058472,
-0.0024408448953181505,
0.21176092326641083,
0.6438693404197693,
0.34378042817115784,
-0.5412202477455139,
-0.6633535623550415,
-0.3076493740081787,
0.2506830394268036,
-0.7443394064903259,
-0.2469586431980133,
-0.28660303354263306,
-0.2633441984653473,
-0.46898582577705383,
-0.07509535551071167,
-0.3365519046783447,
-0.1684899479150772,
-0.07881738990545273,
-0.2926306426525116,
0.3513462245464325,
0.69492506980896,
-0.1329261213541031,
-0.03428949415683746,
-0.8184996247291565,
0.27096736431121826,
0.3275756537914276,
0.5614210367202759,
0.35880813002586365,
-0.426052063703537,
-0.44121724367141724,
0.003430540906265378,
-0.2266083061695099,
-0.4000001549720764,
0.22005830705165863,
0.2087807059288025,
0.5344945192337036,
0.8433189392089844,
0.09760846942663193,
0.6682761907577515,
-0.23092766106128693,
0.6533083915710449,
-0.006155611481517553,
-1.1482354402542114,
0.051953718066215515,
-0.37896785140037537,
0.31482061743736267,
0.5826937556266785,
0.22000457346439362,
-0.8158295154571533,
-0.3581365942955017,
-0.323940634727478,
-0.671290934085846,
0.48399752378463745,
0.036672696471214294,
-0.1887720376253128,
0.06826892495155334,
0.4285476803779602,
0.08983267843723297,
0.19370432198047638,
-0.8230258822441101,
-0.24967016279697418,
-0.006040113512426615,
0.021421359851956367,
-0.18434791266918182,
-0.1046212911605835,
0.049346234649419785,
-0.11020325124263763,
0.6711384057998657,
-0.34596723318099976,
0.026216622442007065,
-0.16145388782024384,
0.05939817428588867,
0.05874123051762581,
0.18448784947395325,
0.41054049134254456,
0.8627068996429443,
-0.233076274394989,
-0.17537708580493927,
0.44474688172340393,
-0.574865460395813,
-0.37433838844299316,
0.47853219509124756,
0.20082980394363403,
-0.20062996447086334,
0.5813065767288208,
0.2679012715816498,
0.5092342495918274,
-1.1034572124481201,
0.6173136234283447,
-0.3566976487636566,
-0.38144177198410034,
-0.5997096300125122,
-0.017484420910477638,
0.23204129934310913,
0.21776941418647766,
0.5154253244400024,
-0.2155221402645111,
0.24389177560806274,
-0.4545668661594391,
0.3534024953842163,
0.3006369173526764,
-0.23885783553123474,
-0.17501385509967804,
0.6325546503067017,
0.18692277371883392,
0.3634951710700989,
0.6777822971343994,
-0.08644205331802368,
-0.6532600522041321,
0.7015799880027771,
0.24038508534431458,
0.8897090554237366,
-0.0680403932929039,
0.2128920555114746,
0.3831802010536194,
0.37568655610084534,
-0.20390138030052185,
0.2278924137353897,
-0.12201441824436188,
-1.0162889957427979,
-0.6924380660057068,
-0.7432266473770142,
-0.7641148567199707,
0.2505478858947754,
-0.6446309685707092,
0.3134647011756897,
-0.5640382766723633,
0.2139454036951065,
0.17401279509067535,
0.3123159408569336,
-0.6053929328918457,
0.23625053465366364,
0.2024255245923996,
1.3900243043899536,
-0.5828666090965271,
1.054548978805542,
0.23883149027824402,
-0.11648686975240707,
-0.8796616792678833,
0.07669270783662796,
-0.005654372740536928,
-0.7751858830451965,
0.7095667123794556,
0.24911977350711823,
-0.16201303899288177,
-0.262076199054718,
-0.3222464621067047,
-0.6566609144210815,
1.0180974006652832,
0.47535374760627747,
-0.8950467705726624,
0.154531791806221,
0.17044681310653687,
0.5561823844909668,
-0.19963040947914124,
0.5090262293815613,
0.9868718385696411,
0.799933910369873,
-0.09150738269090652,
-0.940484344959259,
-0.10249824821949005,
-0.22028210759162903,
-0.13958220183849335,
0.17421461641788483,
-0.8299993276596069,
0.7869385480880737,
-0.059140488505363464,
-0.2638646960258484,
0.044021401554346085,
0.8182361125946045,
0.22744858264923096,
0.3090917766094208,
0.7544971108436584,
0.2625393867492676,
0.8078143000602722,
-0.29398196935653687,
0.9643765091896057,
-0.42501530051231384,
0.5404130220413208,
1.0544335842132568,
-0.5640753507614136,
1.061390995979309,
-0.004234693944454193,
-0.3877072334289551,
0.2871140241622925,
0.7380036115646362,
-0.10764417797327042,
0.1005832701921463,
0.3759671747684479,
-0.3383236229419708,
-0.16277967393398285,
0.03852732852101326,
-0.3006977140903473,
0.48976555466651917,
0.3004417419433594,
-0.06973829865455627,
-0.13796865940093994,
-0.2676853835582733,
-0.0971207544207573,
0.017054736614227295,
-0.18782123923301697,
0.44505348801612854,
0.2614805996417999,
-0.44201961159706116,
0.5026214122772217,
0.11701486259698868,
0.6992082595825195,
-0.7648256421089172,
-0.0420120544731617,
-0.2760135233402252,
0.08560910075902939,
-0.09814050048589706,
-0.7851920127868652,
0.1542079597711563,
0.07566311955451965,
0.2903973460197449,
-0.20938776433467865,
0.5717062950134277,
-0.3275879919528961,
-0.46650031208992004,
0.7098622918128967,
0.28245824575424194,
0.037452466785907745,
-0.16901740431785583,
-0.9897107481956482,
-0.07191634178161621,
0.05412861704826355,
-0.40182194113731384,
0.4131735563278198,
0.5897700786590576,
0.08741416037082672,
0.6453078389167786,
0.6204326748847961,
0.02418978326022625,
-0.3756873607635498,
0.4813626706600189,
0.8262274861335754,
-0.8841484785079956,
-0.4325411915779114,
-0.722909152507782,
-0.005654600914567709,
-0.02707470767199993,
-0.5025181770324707,
0.6457358002662659,
0.8783298134803772,
0.8945379257202148,
0.2516777813434601,
0.7896127700805664,
0.2766859829425812,
0.4054179787635803,
-0.591759443283081,
0.7231788635253906,
-0.4952143430709839,
0.5265769362449646,
-0.42334744334220886,
-1.059744954109192,
-0.3494781255722046,
0.48376908898353577,
-0.5157783031463623,
0.16743247210979462,
0.6533051133155823,
0.5659568905830383,
0.1636047065258026,
0.49320438504219055,
0.4873967468738556,
0.3299747407436371,
0.3493419587612152,
0.8784101605415344,
0.707902729511261,
-0.4371768534183502,
0.7225585579872131,
-0.27533087134361267,
-0.23181389272212982,
-0.0775628611445427,
-1.048130989074707,
-0.7643539905548096,
-0.3694191575050354,
-0.29565000534057617,
0.11819194257259369,
-0.23792409896850586,
0.7879852652549744,
0.2669838070869446,
-0.8845803141593933,
-0.6317642331123352,
0.15549322962760925,
0.16358834505081177,
-0.5912838578224182,
-0.27913230657577515,
0.5179643630981445,
-0.22610971331596375,
-0.6789785027503967,
0.40575385093688965,
0.45098766684532166,
-0.21191340684890747,
-0.5645093321800232,
-0.05785351246595383,
-0.07552226632833481,
-0.24887114763259888,
0.6834962964057922,
0.2934055030345917,
-0.4629574716091156,
-0.3857129216194153,
0.026315754279494286,
-0.013412747532129288,
-0.02419898472726345,
0.8655905723571777,
-0.47915664315223694,
0.28454914689064026,
0.3479227125644684,
0.8749917149543762,
0.4149491786956787,
-0.08203617483377457,
0.7520642280578613,
-0.4425737261772156,
-0.057767488062381744,
0.1845836490392685,
0.5874305963516235,
0.20333044230937958,
-0.2781391441822052,
0.6579083800315857,
0.028726380318403244,
-0.6544519066810608,
-0.4744862914085388,
-0.3456248939037323,
-1.0943868160247803,
-0.27137312293052673,
1.0154569149017334,
-0.2202204167842865,
-0.0803368017077446,
-0.140515998005867,
-0.09607084095478058,
-0.058190006762742996,
-0.5404544472694397,
0.428506463766098,
0.8984563946723938,
0.12598659098148346,
-0.16634231805801392,
-1.0574660301208496,
0.4093208312988281,
0.4625656306743622,
-0.7787498831748962,
0.5647761821746826,
0.35438477993011475,
0.155608132481575,
-0.14415639638900757,
0.7542933225631714,
0.012037910521030426,
0.4425109326839447,
-0.052345018833875656,
-0.06616964191198349,
0.301236093044281,
-0.0187983475625515,
-0.3070997893810272,
0.12263254821300507,
0.32509496808052063,
0.24813739955425262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10523v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10523v1
|
Smart Expert System: Large Language Models as Text Classifiers
| 2024-05-17T04:05:05 | 2024-05-17T04:05:05 |
Zhiqiang Wang, Yiran Pang, Yanbin Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text classification is a fundamental task in Natural Language Processing
(NLP), and the advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) has revolutionized the
field. This paper introduces the Smart Expert System, a novel approach that
leverages LLMs as text classifiers. The system simplifies the traditional text
classification workflow, eliminating the need for extensive preprocessing and
domain expertise. The performance of several LLMs, machine learning (ML)
algorithms, and neural network (NN) based structures is evaluated on four
datasets. Results demonstrate that certain LLMs surpass traditional methods in
sentiment analysis, spam SMS detection and multi-label classification.
Furthermore, it is shown that the system's performance can be further enhanced
through few-shot or fine-tuning strategies, making the fine-tuned model the top
performer across all datasets. Source code and datasets are available in this
GitHub repository: https://github.com/yeyimilk/llm-zero-shot-classifiers.
|
[
-0.21910494565963745,
-0.7286756038665771,
0.4904398024082184,
-0.027617910876870155,
-0.16126695275306702,
0.2609107196331024,
-0.45407435297966003,
-0.5975437164306641,
0.1606421321630478,
0.6635735630989075,
-0.255933940410614,
-0.5574992895126343,
-0.8069300055503845,
0.36724361777305603,
-0.5041661262512207,
1.146426796913147,
0.3951627314090729,
0.002107037231326103,
0.12528708577156067,
0.07624302804470062,
-0.28334495425224304,
-0.5508691668510437,
-0.5056546330451965,
-0.4728254973888397,
0.5678833723068237,
0.5980212092399597,
0.6874884366989136,
0.5462696552276611,
0.5752254128456116,
0.5047370195388794,
0.02984536997973919,
0.3104252219200134,
-0.11594641208648682,
0.20703771710395813,
-0.2988238036632538,
-0.5897989273071289,
-0.5950124859809875,
-0.16928747296333313,
0.2778994143009186,
0.2937140166759491,
0.1997542381286621,
0.006443318910896778,
-0.14342327415943146,
0.45565980672836304,
-0.48449334502220154,
0.14624111354351044,
-0.835544228553772,
-0.0282815583050251,
-0.4945022761821747,
-0.44936951994895935,
-0.450355589389801,
-0.3726097047328949,
0.19188590347766876,
-0.20058323442935944,
0.07884559035301208,
0.005470650270581245,
0.3965296745300293,
0.42575404047966003,
-0.417770653963089,
-0.2339896410703659,
-0.7652264833450317,
1.0243624448776245,
-0.8938122987747192,
0.13019995391368866,
0.08705199509859085,
0.3848098814487457,
-0.1701747179031372,
-0.45575013756752014,
-0.7017836570739746,
0.07712949812412262,
0.14942266047000885,
-0.07831782102584839,
0.1552996188402176,
0.0770384669303894,
-0.0727883130311966,
0.1336054503917694,
-0.4520849287509918,
0.5926346778869629,
0.015617976896464825,
-0.1658276468515396,
0.8889040946960449,
0.20502309501171112,
0.1191820427775383,
-0.30936574935913086,
-0.17089499533176422,
0.35350820422172546,
-0.24899429082870483,
-0.25917983055114746,
0.19070902466773987,
0.5743657350540161,
0.24539537727832794,
0.5111256241798401,
-0.40317657589912415,
0.9052992463111877,
-0.14184468984603882,
-0.7060657739639282,
0.22774824500083923,
-0.03352515771985054,
-0.3544616103172302,
0.17026084661483765,
1.0612165927886963,
0.13422855734825134,
0.6897114515304565,
-0.2118721753358841,
-0.49093523621559143,
0.007958227768540382,
0.08672985434532166,
-0.6880512833595276,
-0.22474022209644318,
0.08262412250041962,
-0.22447673976421356,
-0.5591508150100708,
-0.17262114584445953,
-0.5977810621261597,
-0.5885124206542969,
-0.33275106549263,
0.32294416427612305,
-0.22046764194965363,
-0.06529506295919418,
0.3194008469581604,
0.1353929191827774,
0.0598360039293766,
0.4764936864376068,
-0.9133479595184326,
0.4564203917980194,
0.818014919757843,
0.6091177463531494,
-0.15736161172389984,
-0.2007652372121811,
-0.31812945008277893,
0.0414668433368206,
-0.27924853563308716,
1.2044320106506348,
-0.4693527817726135,
0.04726048931479454,
-0.0037308100145310163,
-0.3747662305831909,
-0.004327111877501011,
-0.5210651159286499,
0.6898869872093201,
-0.817784309387207,
0.25924938917160034,
0.26391157507896423,
-0.7274417281150818,
-0.24100928008556366,
0.38778233528137207,
-0.4172375798225403,
0.9632741212844849,
-0.2941974103450775,
-0.7082650065422058,
0.10504575073719025,
-0.6693258285522461,
-0.4235556125640869,
0.5230175256729126,
-0.04717972129583359,
-0.2695213556289673,
-0.012464901432394981,
-0.038979921489953995,
1.1355513334274292,
-0.29671037197113037,
0.3271022140979767,
-0.3809903562068939,
-0.34107306599617004,
0.2928312122821808,
-0.3485633134841919,
0.44741591811180115,
0.1820143461227417,
-0.21220077574253082,
0.11849936097860336,
-0.8853626847267151,
0.1722482144832611,
0.10474129766225815,
-0.5709565877914429,
-0.5072038769721985,
0.030652429908514023,
0.30759963393211365,
0.28043872117996216,
0.4581303298473358,
-0.4727333188056946,
0.34487292170524597,
-0.4124384820461273,
0.36005061864852905,
0.6325426697731018,
-0.22394952178001404,
0.40853267908096313,
-0.0052487230859696865,
0.12120679765939713,
-0.21504627168178558,
-0.11048658192157745,
-0.1727914661169052,
-0.6143108010292053,
-0.8851718306541443,
-0.3501575291156769,
0.6393888592720032,
1.0801728963851929,
-0.7632021307945251,
0.8494746088981628,
-0.41914016008377075,
-0.40502822399139404,
-0.2874471843242645,
0.4400046169757843,
0.36584630608558655,
0.3015291690826416,
0.2345624715089798,
0.04529373720288277,
-0.3797719478607178,
-0.9009531736373901,
-0.42840105295181274,
-0.11905810981988907,
-0.024142753332853317,
0.013149493373930454,
0.4888184070587158,
-0.43496814370155334,
0.9760951399803162,
-0.5271168351173401,
-0.3000391125679016,
-0.49384722113609314,
0.14642389118671417,
0.2845582365989685,
0.20640972256660461,
0.4527667164802551,
-0.696251392364502,
-0.49609658122062683,
0.12437765300273895,
-0.7331644296646118,
-0.214300736784935,
0.17744700610637665,
0.3050725758075714,
0.3514139652252197,
0.5362427234649658,
-0.5758988261222839,
0.26314279437065125,
0.23994891345500946,
-0.27032268047332764,
0.49463096261024475,
-0.07563981413841248,
-0.16482755541801453,
-1.0925767421722412,
-0.09105710685253143,
0.3359040319919586,
-0.5709643959999084,
-0.8826634883880615,
-0.06137363985180855,
0.014097216539084911,
0.23973946273326874,
-0.26811882853507996,
0.4644685685634613,
-0.03817437216639519,
0.017770741134881973,
-0.7028157114982605,
0.12579721212387085,
-0.16119270026683807,
0.4545831084251404,
0.14473621547222137,
0.24910086393356323,
0.3834720849990845,
-0.6409744620323181,
0.6832240223884583,
0.01771889254450798,
-0.34800079464912415,
0.5332891345024109,
-0.47233840823173523,
0.2434588223695755,
-0.08574112504720688,
0.09792619198560715,
-0.5685336589813232,
-0.3763554096221924,
0.19118890166282654,
-0.4151715934276581,
0.41921937465667725,
0.1188158243894577,
-0.9014306664466858,
-0.3069588541984558,
-0.19267679750919342,
-0.050041913986206055,
0.13923616707324982,
-0.24978876113891602,
0.49451982975006104,
0.36457309126853943,
-0.5126894116401672,
-0.5556383728981018,
-0.5972195267677307,
0.5411778688430786,
-0.05057910457253456,
-0.2644909620285034,
0.23262694478034973,
-0.06848232448101044,
-0.332048624753952,
-0.040314141660928726,
0.24857506155967712,
-0.29629406332969666,
0.23321814835071564,
-0.0675995796918869,
0.16087064146995544,
0.0259218942373991,
0.6064656972885132,
-0.04058019816875458,
-0.34836021065711975,
-0.20358853042125702,
-0.3566291928291321,
0.40352708101272583,
-0.2591104507446289,
0.02525818534195423,
-0.6807741522789001,
0.26554355025291443,
0.6378619074821472,
-0.31162741780281067,
0.6195377707481384,
0.43206533789634705,
-0.4555509090423584,
-0.4798696041107178,
-0.6236493587493896,
-0.19089104235172272,
-0.48161470890045166,
0.5256990194320679,
-0.19809837639331818,
-0.7489599585533142,
0.22948560118675232,
-0.06860602647066116,
0.18540489673614502,
0.406392902135849,
0.503687858581543,
0.022614985704421997,
1.0918718576431274,
1.0189985036849976,
-0.47774824500083923,
0.39857742190361023,
0.0255719106644392,
0.5217183232307434,
-0.12073872983455658,
-0.41596272587776184,
-0.7257480025291443,
-0.26301348209381104,
-0.5291928052902222,
-0.21535785496234894,
0.04824033007025719,
0.03858087211847305,
-0.32179075479507446,
0.11389964073896408,
-0.4099867343902588,
0.46325764060020447,
0.4854554533958435,
-0.030377967283129692,
0.5459359288215637,
-0.11017054319381714,
0.07417696714401245,
0.08405862748622894,
-0.7544108033180237,
-0.9997512698173523,
0.9049299955368042,
0.633327066898346,
0.6816696524620056,
-0.018107140436768532,
0.6138232350349426,
0.38599735498428345,
0.4936045706272125,
-1.2936198711395264,
0.9938318729400635,
-0.4010747969150543,
-0.4538576602935791,
-0.26320114731788635,
-0.35812801122665405,
-0.5127938389778137,
0.08086971193552017,
-0.5694532990455627,
-0.4737088680267334,
-0.15141093730926514,
-0.14550982415676117,
-0.4560472369194031,
0.4380199611186981,
-0.7965901494026184,
0.35992416739463806,
-0.4380682706832886,
-0.069942906498909,
-0.0497455932199955,
-0.49233198165893555,
0.28514721989631653,
-0.5468859672546387,
0.27958282828330994,
-0.018924659118056297,
-0.34770968556404114,
0.9520866870880127,
-0.42686372995376587,
0.8064492344856262,
-0.05643002688884735,
-0.08612257987260818,
0.09564698487520218,
-0.12554456293582916,
0.4542364478111267,
-0.13304468989372253,
-0.29593852162361145,
0.08875167369842529,
-0.319102019071579,
-0.32845449447631836,
-0.681754469871521,
0.8336342573165894,
-0.6941745281219482,
-0.4488134980201721,
-0.4515256881713867,
-0.589326024055481,
-0.293422132730484,
0.5600913763046265,
0.00789402425289154,
0.30948272347450256,
0.2205350548028946,
0.1440889537334442,
0.991100013256073,
-0.14613355696201324,
0.658096194267273,
0.7415656447410583,
-0.20085512101650238,
-0.20556063950061798,
0.8258741497993469,
0.3983999788761139,
-0.1802484393119812,
0.5503630638122559,
0.1957002580165863,
-0.18261970579624176,
-1.051352858543396,
-0.32862234115600586,
-0.0140904001891613,
-0.6603795289993286,
-0.5651765465736389,
-0.903113067150116,
-0.222305566072464,
-0.4727378487586975,
-0.06763427704572678,
-0.3704312741756439,
-0.3658491373062134,
-0.37899354100227356,
-0.1722104549407959,
0.517797589302063,
1.074333906173706,
0.4133729338645935,
0.3524908721446991,
-0.9275718331336975,
0.24250224232673645,
0.5399376749992371,
0.5665958523750305,
-0.1480400115251541,
-0.3679877817630768,
-0.3784881830215454,
-0.3551081418991089,
-0.18036866188049316,
-0.7887651920318604,
0.5300195217132568,
0.2013426125049591,
0.5407759547233582,
0.5955129861831665,
0.09718863666057587,
0.10832714289426804,
-0.4615694284439087,
0.47579532861709595,
0.07650840282440186,
-0.9159078001976013,
0.2850647270679474,
-0.48978400230407715,
0.33824583888053894,
0.5640535950660706,
0.40820279717445374,
-0.2759387195110321,
-0.316494345664978,
-0.2775021493434906,
-0.6836553812026978,
0.48649245500564575,
-0.2306777536869049,
-0.09990783035755157,
0.16593213379383087,
0.47217288613319397,
0.10400344431400299,
0.2750762701034546,
-0.739518940448761,
-0.11359795182943344,
0.016925908625125885,
-0.6129512786865234,
-0.36421898007392883,
-0.14656822383403778,
0.2392507940530777,
-0.1401054561138153,
0.6982772946357727,
-0.39961758255958557,
0.14308884739875793,
0.013250662013888359,
-0.14328214526176453,
0.044157542288303375,
0.5416595339775085,
0.4034292995929718,
0.2990863025188446,
-0.14763636887073517,
0.17946317791938782,
0.37671035528182983,
-0.3600611388683319,
-0.052833687514066696,
0.04309260845184326,
-0.21027125418186188,
-0.004071046598255634,
0.5183578133583069,
0.4276106357574463,
0.3208308219909668,
-0.6256752610206604,
0.4223858714103699,
-0.05169105529785156,
-0.18846480548381805,
-0.07098691165447235,
0.21380829811096191,
-0.03247661888599396,
0.31693536043167114,
0.6535704731941223,
0.3428482115268707,
0.1851091831922531,
-0.41715478897094727,
-0.0174156054854393,
0.3754737675189972,
-0.34004348516464233,
-0.29003143310546875,
0.09048673510551453,
0.36331140995025635,
-0.6993906497955322,
0.14701053500175476,
-0.11616995930671692,
-0.8414278030395508,
0.35693061351776123,
0.325777143239975,
0.8115931153297424,
-0.276785671710968,
0.1986335963010788,
-0.20766697824001312,
0.27591243386268616,
-0.22535917162895203,
0.28928813338279724,
0.19449347257614136,
-0.8261221051216125,
-0.6863256692886353,
-0.5953524708747864,
-0.4506952464580536,
0.2688136100769043,
-0.23040825128555298,
0.32596689462661743,
-0.6714826226234436,
-0.16540461778640747,
0.2069225013256073,
0.38203269243240356,
-0.6711658239364624,
0.36375558376312256,
0.3219015300273895,
1.0891079902648926,
-0.7292579412460327,
1.034867763519287,
0.9243727326393127,
0.34068986773490906,
-0.4754464328289032,
-0.0530780628323555,
-0.05010680854320526,
-0.2826441526412964,
0.7258909940719604,
0.3407588601112366,
-0.2982245087623596,
-0.00852056872099638,
-0.7237734794616699,
-0.41547685861587524,
0.6934526562690735,
0.12685224413871765,
-0.7534613013267517,
0.23613399267196655,
0.17214231193065643,
0.9231613278388977,
-0.38294920325279236,
0.2973330318927765,
0.47324663400650024,
0.6083269119262695,
-0.3604983389377594,
-1.0899906158447266,
-0.3063199520111084,
-0.34453439712524414,
-0.19290463626384735,
0.22125568985939026,
-0.6064185500144958,
0.5878229141235352,
-0.21272426843643188,
0.09256553649902344,
-0.05284256115555763,
0.6222810745239258,
-0.01655219867825508,
0.3925185203552246,
0.5050021409988403,
0.6052427291870117,
0.8285000920295715,
-0.07082190364599228,
0.8545926213264465,
-0.2067965567111969,
0.17607109248638153,
0.7355552315711975,
-0.35282760858535767,
1.0954198837280273,
0.20121361315250397,
0.03410132974386215,
0.6044974327087402,
0.49285101890563965,
0.13042783737182617,
0.46485644578933716,
0.12219487875699997,
-0.38009247183799744,
-0.4211193919181824,
-0.14381568133831024,
-0.04204874113202095,
0.653315544128418,
0.4244109094142914,
-0.09976940602064133,
-0.1731741577386856,
0.0586039237678051,
0.011401652358472347,
0.264102578163147,
-0.6005736589431763,
0.9472407698631287,
0.05632387846708298,
-0.3835940957069397,
0.19387243688106537,
0.5494325160980225,
1.3544373512268066,
-0.5398846864700317,
0.23035193979740143,
0.1870276778936386,
0.43069902062416077,
-0.4915585517883301,
-0.7487845420837402,
0.10117482393980026,
0.16910074651241302,
-0.33007630705833435,
-0.3014832139015198,
1.219875693321228,
-0.2173711508512497,
-0.5449151396751404,
0.2320004254579544,
0.4518316388130188,
0.09636656939983368,
-0.029709815979003906,
-0.7454080581665039,
-0.276456743478775,
-0.299611359834671,
-0.4223096966743469,
0.3968525230884552,
0.5886828899383545,
-0.12171489745378494,
0.8841127753257751,
0.4817408621311188,
-0.010768388397991657,
-0.04455935209989548,
-0.0757647305727005,
0.7463663220405579,
-0.8291336894035339,
-0.4438062012195587,
-0.8101786971092224,
0.1651938408613205,
-0.07401557266712189,
-0.2112947553396225,
0.9046001434326172,
0.4017217755317688,
0.6963037252426147,
-0.016178175806999207,
0.9835010170936584,
0.2903599143028259,
0.7959388494491577,
-0.25177401304244995,
0.6713970303535461,
-0.2771887183189392,
0.3601989150047302,
-0.3072868287563324,
-0.8274011611938477,
-0.6844506859779358,
0.47938889265060425,
-0.5168995261192322,
0.12307132035493851,
0.36234432458877563,
0.6355564594268799,
0.14847896993160248,
0.10528215020895004,
0.3504883050918579,
0.06485812366008759,
0.3122277557849884,
0.36981338262557983,
0.6637327671051025,
-0.2802235782146454,
0.37832558155059814,
-0.1253923624753952,
-0.36861908435821533,
-0.5085898637771606,
-1.0023658275604248,
-1.058632731437683,
-0.1530686467885971,
-0.2603701651096344,
0.01679590530693531,
0.028414852917194366,
1.0755013227462769,
0.7550374865531921,
-0.8688238263130188,
0.01595996879041195,
0.03634980320930481,
0.3356958329677582,
0.08638793975114822,
-0.279703289270401,
0.03237142041325569,
-0.314690500497818,
-0.9286856651306152,
0.4848945140838623,
0.4362720251083374,
0.017182614654302597,
-0.45157837867736816,
0.03978457301855087,
-0.2467430830001831,
0.19254998862743378,
0.8941144347190857,
0.16244164109230042,
-0.29036396741867065,
-0.1221005916595459,
0.039055436849594116,
-0.280413419008255,
-0.31856289505958557,
0.6529653668403625,
-0.9649525880813599,
0.1230081170797348,
0.7913682460784912,
0.7389404773712158,
-0.16521528363227844,
-0.3777235448360443,
0.23292283713817596,
-0.4614342451095581,
0.0012473539682105184,
0.436884343624115,
0.18115860223770142,
0.37572139501571655,
-0.39539894461631775,
0.0950736254453659,
0.16377408802509308,
-0.7138258218765259,
-0.8107143044471741,
0.044854536652565,
-0.7898251414299011,
-0.4881384074687958,
1.0154294967651367,
0.03620856627821922,
-0.04542064294219017,
-0.7055940628051758,
-0.07393400371074677,
-0.0018317935755476356,
-0.48511838912963867,
0.8596949577331543,
0.5227057337760925,
-0.001723122433759272,
-0.11378222703933716,
-0.6392325758934021,
0.25026288628578186,
0.35118675231933594,
-0.9781184196472168,
-0.3220394253730774,
0.24671128392219543,
0.4133017361164093,
0.3611212372779846,
0.4989880323410034,
0.13271738588809967,
-0.13425201177597046,
-0.5894100666046143,
0.2104179412126541,
-0.15647734701633453,
-0.6169747710227966,
-0.4162426292896271,
0.41605129837989807,
0.014735435135662556,
0.2014760971069336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10517v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10517v2
|
Towards Better Question Generation in QA-based Event Extraction
| 2024-05-17T03:52:01 | 2024-06-06T13:40:00 |
Zijin Hong, Jian Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Event Extraction (EE) is an essential information extraction task that aims
to extract event-related information from unstructured texts. The paradigm of
this task has shifted from conventional classification-based methods to more
contemporary question-answering-based (QA-based) approaches. However, in
QA-based EE, the quality of the questions dramatically affects the extraction
accuracy, and how to generate high-quality questions for QA-based EE remains a
challenge. In this work, to tackle this challenge, we suggest four criteria to
evaluate the quality of a question and propose a reinforcement learning method,
RLQG, for QA-based EE that can generate generalizable, high-quality, and
context-dependent questions and provides clear guidance to QA models. The
extensive experiments conducted on ACE and RAMS datasets have strongly
validated our approach's effectiveness, which also demonstrates its robustness
in scenarios with limited training data. The corresponding code of RLQG is
released for further research.
|
[
-0.538995623588562,
-1.0307328701019287,
0.5990161895751953,
-0.09299084544181824,
-0.2734338641166687,
-0.18589727580547333,
0.061104096472263336,
-0.5597306489944458,
-0.06588555127382278,
0.28609809279441833,
-0.6152413487434387,
-0.44563189148902893,
-0.19730058312416077,
0.18562249839305878,
-0.23458051681518555,
1.0450682640075684,
-0.19152258336544037,
-0.2623703181743622,
-0.2916204631328583,
-0.12865905463695526,
-0.4153952896595001,
-0.4632519781589508,
-1.2624845504760742,
-0.18734079599380493,
0.41183099150657654,
0.225046768784523,
0.4019286334514618,
0.25619766116142273,
0.04597986862063408,
0.16384701430797577,
0.030072392895817757,
0.5300515294075012,
-0.336977481842041,
0.4748117923736572,
-0.19131334125995636,
-0.48928579688072205,
0.08021431416273117,
0.0011377388145774603,
0.3214724063873291,
0.15925663709640503,
-0.5271400809288025,
0.4714047908782959,
-0.1582280844449997,
0.27906548976898193,
-0.5173710584640503,
0.1835062950849533,
-0.5105608105659485,
0.3908732831478119,
0.32918620109558105,
-0.5469751954078674,
-0.43136849999427795,
-0.5707091093063354,
-0.07819493860006332,
-0.8348349332809448,
0.2585267722606659,
0.20014311373233795,
1.1724706888198853,
-0.03805064782500267,
-0.5494125485420227,
-0.14264456927776337,
-0.6758384108543396,
0.7227222919464111,
-0.5703384876251221,
0.29608649015426636,
0.25391262769699097,
0.28710442781448364,
-0.29591166973114014,
-0.71174156665802,
-0.639885663986206,
0.15252628922462463,
0.19448715448379517,
0.3366515338420868,
0.05506604537367821,
-0.21562252938747406,
0.3686840534210205,
-0.07828179746866226,
-0.7238494753837585,
-0.003548487089574337,
-0.26964956521987915,
0.056435540318489075,
0.9224446415901184,
0.34608834981918335,
0.28619861602783203,
-0.5468295812606812,
-0.27667340636253357,
-0.32761576771736145,
-0.5632583498954773,
0.48954299092292786,
0.13034600019454956,
0.038201406598091125,
0.4282064735889435,
0.06766301393508911,
-0.3947347402572632,
0.348726361989975,
0.48174670338630676,
-0.07091826945543289,
-0.011931083165109158,
-0.33304816484451294,
-0.012672888115048409,
-0.23322053253650665,
0.5804111361503601,
0.34671658277511597,
-0.041980840265750885,
-0.2008691430091858,
-0.18655964732170105,
-0.507900595664978,
0.3636528253555298,
-0.8199368715286255,
-0.18626773357391357,
0.6847167015075684,
-0.5395200252532959,
-0.2143033742904663,
-0.006287573836743832,
-0.8544705510139465,
-0.08450419455766678,
-0.12048788368701935,
0.5782378911972046,
-0.33685246109962463,
-0.4885120093822479,
-0.13983923196792603,
-0.07392682880163193,
0.7878891229629517,
0.5097386837005615,
-0.45578378438949585,
-0.15578772127628326,
0.3650839626789093,
-0.010651308111846447,
-0.5198825597763062,
-0.0915994942188263,
-1.1066144704818726,
-0.01422866340726614,
-0.47889018058776855,
0.8586876392364502,
-0.3856924772262573,
-0.38444843888282776,
0.017153192311525345,
0.0024454351514577866,
-0.046772852540016174,
-0.7606583833694458,
0.3619089722633362,
-1.172756552696228,
0.7237227559089661,
-0.27091795206069946,
-0.6312983632087708,
-0.29305407404899597,
0.5103021860122681,
-0.4135904014110565,
1.0758171081542969,
-0.08837153017520905,
-0.2845543622970581,
0.5475532412528992,
-0.22818805277347565,
-0.21796290576457977,
0.40089619159698486,
-0.6308403015136719,
-0.6977060437202454,
-0.16822858154773712,
0.6501385569572449,
0.4101247489452362,
0.00010034345905296504,
0.4034637212753296,
-0.08263006806373596,
-0.0441230833530426,
0.2642056941986084,
-0.18628215789794922,
0.49887707829475403,
0.31113401055336,
-0.18970339000225067,
0.1433863639831543,
-0.925357460975647,
0.7659051418304443,
0.1734565645456314,
-0.6616438031196594,
0.013793423771858215,
0.362990140914917,
-0.1822744458913803,
0.35206669569015503,
-0.03457034379243851,
-0.4474199414253235,
0.09109687805175781,
-0.3312106728553772,
-0.16841919720172882,
0.4729090631008148,
0.885086178779602,
0.1274767816066742,
-0.2198166847229004,
0.9294105768203735,
0.08426529169082642,
0.31466028094291687,
0.1363331824541092,
-0.4421786963939667,
-0.2540605068206787,
0.23175173997879028,
0.32415270805358887,
0.7675378918647766,
-1.2833759784698486,
0.1949407309293747,
0.34471073746681213,
-0.21175885200500488,
-0.2147943675518036,
-0.10459038615226746,
0.4465273916721344,
0.5028828382492065,
0.5175643563270569,
-0.07262523472309113,
-0.5559883713722229,
-0.3358326554298401,
-0.08622176200151443,
-0.5552161931991577,
-0.02023276500403881,
0.48571619391441345,
0.2785293757915497,
0.339342325925827,
0.985253095626831,
-0.609373152256012,
0.18105950951576233,
-0.4834268391132355,
0.532042384147644,
0.025145595893263817,
0.4697122275829315,
0.19222491979599,
-1.0389305353164673,
-0.17628522217273712,
-0.04499806836247444,
-0.8079634308815002,
0.08583029359579086,
-0.4225189983844757,
-0.07441424578428268,
0.20939511060714722,
0.6139273643493652,
-0.3626922070980072,
0.424603134393692,
0.18428713083267212,
-0.39837130904197693,
0.8567296862602234,
0.008243017829954624,
0.5656644701957703,
-1.0287021398544312,
-0.15745718777179718,
-0.21006058156490326,
-0.259473979473114,
-0.5386590361595154,
0.3069729208946228,
0.13436421751976013,
-0.29508134722709656,
-0.6963704228401184,
0.5341684818267822,
-0.08245140314102173,
0.046355098485946655,
-0.17970792949199677,
0.24650222063064575,
0.2128065973520279,
0.811848521232605,
0.11342871189117432,
0.6297102570533752,
0.006077213678508997,
-1.0348531007766724,
0.48180919885635376,
0.531599760055542,
-0.2008778303861618,
0.37273919582366943,
-0.6095219850540161,
0.13603927195072174,
-0.3023107945919037,
0.08543330430984497,
-0.6208433508872986,
0.06460805982351303,
0.15397197008132935,
-0.7363964319229126,
0.1563674658536911,
-0.13860180974006653,
-0.317564994096756,
-0.06906192749738693,
-0.16645628213882446,
0.4294721186161041,
0.7692825794219971,
-0.703242838382721,
0.5575027465820312,
0.22622354328632355,
-0.32302215695381165,
-0.38329535722732544,
-0.049685053527355194,
-0.31123703718185425,
-0.3083336353302002,
-0.42478105425834656,
0.016755033284425735,
0.10449011623859406,
-0.05850588157773018,
0.1442766636610031,
-0.1715172678232193,
-0.26065048575401306,
0.1328004002571106,
-0.08310440182685852,
0.09057774394750595,
-0.2892804443836212,
0.44900742173194885,
0.11168787628412247,
0.16150696575641632,
0.29657894372940063,
-0.19658495485782623,
0.20968127250671387,
0.19539573788642883,
-0.3215368688106537,
-0.4682498574256897,
0.6349980235099792,
-0.17751635611057281,
-0.5186867713928223,
0.48418575525283813,
0.675054669380188,
-0.21644850075244904,
-0.6395589113235474,
-0.38062235713005066,
-0.3977389931678772,
-0.3912118971347809,
0.6260764598846436,
-0.25024089217185974,
-0.890262246131897,
0.5007680058479309,
-0.15392138063907623,
0.15274010598659515,
0.45775094628334045,
0.23142582178115845,
-0.31382012367248535,
1.321575403213501,
0.23873978853225708,
0.27577152848243713,
0.5233421325683594,
-0.024462075904011726,
0.04260728880763054,
-0.5904287695884705,
-0.4185970425605774,
-0.5075501799583435,
0.005969678051769733,
-0.4038811922073364,
-0.34304216504096985,
0.5300450325012207,
0.4975280165672302,
-0.04881489276885986,
-0.061410702764987946,
-0.1537739336490631,
0.34230124950408936,
0.3994295001029968,
0.0931837186217308,
0.16949231922626495,
-0.2603203058242798,
0.03961724415421486,
0.25170984864234924,
-0.9607641696929932,
-0.3327341377735138,
0.9458409547805786,
0.23712939023971558,
0.34585586190223694,
-0.01952298730611801,
1.0107412338256836,
0.13335612416267395,
-0.08147966861724854,
-0.29938170313835144,
0.4970032572746277,
0.5594606995582581,
-0.5876186490058899,
-0.9518333673477173,
-0.6218395829200745,
-1.2961992025375366,
0.5027080774307251,
-0.2326800376176834,
-0.568487823009491,
0.43675002455711365,
0.03680814057588577,
-0.6911417245864868,
0.1918981522321701,
-0.4137163758277893,
0.733434796333313,
-0.09504929184913635,
-0.09553264826536179,
-0.08087995648384094,
-0.40643757581710815,
0.2466827780008316,
0.2187483161687851,
0.20951013267040253,
-0.041593533009290695,
0.18211479485034943,
1.0375866889953613,
-0.09841962903738022,
0.38100332021713257,
-0.22324007749557495,
-0.06099784001708031,
0.9250534176826477,
0.11101645231246948,
0.8957353830337524,
0.553420901298523,
0.11919134110212326,
-0.5171737670898438,
0.43313559889793396,
-0.4792408049106598,
-0.8235418200492859,
0.02479933761060238,
-0.7358742952346802,
-0.5201625823974609,
-0.15881650149822235,
-0.18679779767990112,
-0.4995265603065491,
-0.264985054731369,
0.07493151724338531,
0.6738250851631165,
-0.11704311519861221,
-0.027462132275104523,
1.1353025436401367,
-0.7186446785926819,
0.4678429067134857,
0.6393659710884094,
-0.5150326490402222,
-0.394687682390213,
0.855240523815155,
-0.21282906830310822,
0.11282315850257874,
0.42853787541389465,
-0.0052168043330311775,
-0.2632104754447937,
-0.6031494140625,
-0.6035878658294678,
-0.052824657410383224,
-0.6110833287239075,
-0.4005105197429657,
-0.6862683892250061,
-0.2875351309776306,
-0.2973226010799408,
0.26260891556739807,
-0.11338117718696594,
-0.2634625732898712,
-0.4760088622570038,
-0.3368658721446991,
0.10911736637353897,
0.25936609506607056,
0.11620716750621796,
-0.20302091538906097,
-1.0667636394500732,
0.5129815340042114,
0.7816405892372131,
0.045202817767858505,
0.06837523728609085,
-0.3437826633453369,
-0.19186829030513763,
-0.35472577810287476,
-0.6653920412063599,
-1.0249813795089722,
0.43721863627433777,
0.18511249125003815,
0.7081988453865051,
0.3089146018028259,
0.33172130584716797,
0.4087013304233551,
-0.24155974388122559,
0.9680037498474121,
0.02685236558318138,
-0.5117933750152588,
0.8575228452682495,
-0.21966545283794403,
0.11530888825654984,
0.6345670223236084,
0.48942962288856506,
-0.5227267146110535,
-0.5205519199371338,
-1.070405125617981,
-0.9436010122299194,
0.5761285424232483,
0.08450072258710861,
-0.17858152091503143,
-0.3618662655353546,
0.6752960085868835,
0.2684919536113739,
0.22816632688045502,
-0.7912128567695618,
-0.048569455742836,
0.09363365173339844,
0.03737698495388031,
0.23235589265823364,
-0.1766682118177414,
0.14786981046199799,
0.08244402706623077,
0.7026157379150391,
-0.11923658847808838,
0.16176018118858337,
0.48214584589004517,
-0.1932476907968521,
-0.28584057092666626,
0.5429686903953552,
0.2913685739040375,
0.775397777557373,
-0.13976579904556274,
-0.09394970536231995,
0.6266054511070251,
-0.08221355825662613,
0.10964095592498779,
-0.05598701909184456,
-0.4381752610206604,
-0.17004215717315674,
0.25855255126953125,
0.6686932444572449,
-0.1893758475780487,
-0.8758780360221863,
0.4546542465686798,
-0.29515910148620605,
-0.4921630024909973,
-0.15451914072036743,
0.24542547762393951,
-0.3500213027000427,
0.594050407409668,
0.5344284176826477,
-0.7883550524711609,
0.1665969043970108,
-0.5472117066383362,
0.6045132279396057,
0.2916458547115326,
-0.34442126750946045,
0.0018979195738211274,
0.42614513635635376,
0.2086533010005951,
-0.1590195745229721,
0.7411777973175049,
-0.6924192905426025,
-0.5968428254127502,
0.8304744958877563,
0.28403428196907043,
0.5915480256080627,
-0.09587522596120834,
0.5787198543548584,
0.7247771620750427,
0.12804336845874786,
0.01538580097258091,
0.9155175089836121,
-0.06788605451583862,
-0.6700409650802612,
-0.7753104567527771,
-0.7147616147994995,
-0.5369287729263306,
0.4300321638584137,
-0.8379294276237488,
-0.14642813801765442,
-0.18495631217956543,
0.11767475306987762,
-0.5816228985786438,
0.22776034474372864,
-0.5616133809089661,
0.5117586255073547,
-0.09565620869398117,
0.5323853492736816,
-0.5543639063835144,
0.4000675678253174,
0.7360547780990601,
-0.7443637251853943,
-1.233189344406128,
-0.08056547492742538,
-0.6424345970153809,
-0.46643170714378357,
0.6629419326782227,
-0.2988303303718567,
0.6441811323165894,
0.08046362549066544,
-0.5899859070777893,
-0.9182730913162231,
1.1127235889434814,
-0.3182991147041321,
-0.27912959456443787,
-0.12124639004468918,
-0.05138406902551651,
0.3600481152534485,
-0.09943266957998276,
0.15536367893218994,
0.24563246965408325,
0.27415332198143005,
-0.005925590172410011,
-0.550929605960846,
0.12093354016542435,
-0.051133956760168076,
-0.19925563037395477,
0.44637274742126465,
-0.35942238569259644,
0.6126552224159241,
-0.07616336643695831,
-0.3950902223587036,
-0.2142174243927002,
1.1019011735916138,
0.4312838315963745,
0.5950126051902771,
0.3193623125553131,
0.43335139751434326,
0.8464601039886475,
-0.015033925883471966,
1.009690761566162,
0.1528100073337555,
0.4121335744857788,
0.9676244854927063,
-0.16892138123512268,
0.8604207038879395,
0.323485404253006,
-0.21702155470848083,
0.4875335693359375,
0.8147972822189331,
0.05604272335767746,
0.5295557379722595,
0.39616140723228455,
-0.11159244924783707,
-0.5482916831970215,
0.24017733335494995,
-0.33630645275115967,
0.2575515806674957,
0.006132425740361214,
0.10076289623975754,
-0.4047800898551941,
0.16102999448776245,
-0.17122669517993927,
0.021087653934955597,
-0.3864215910434723,
1.3090087175369263,
-0.12535469233989716,
-0.9058699607849121,
0.4058116674423218,
0.05076593533158302,
0.25356346368789673,
-0.5157116055488586,
-0.2706376314163208,
-0.4869363605976105,
-0.2908189594745636,
-0.04275716096162796,
-0.5534541010856628,
0.11303534358739853,
-0.1446247398853302,
-0.10511389374732971,
-0.05307549238204956,
0.5796544551849365,
-0.4858885705471039,
-0.03141076862812042,
-0.11840503662824631,
0.8865825533866882,
0.23010306060314178,
-0.10207013785839081,
-0.6414376497268677,
-0.24699793756008148,
0.035108789801597595,
-0.6740235090255737,
0.635804295539856,
0.7478294372558594,
-0.14481553435325623,
0.5377358794212341,
0.5200287699699402,
0.09675299376249313,
0.16777603328227997,
-0.22478260099887848,
0.437391996383667,
-0.8696074485778809,
-0.7963071465492249,
-0.26165851950645447,
0.4659068286418915,
-0.1688043624162674,
-0.5141661763191223,
0.4466467797756195,
0.35478296875953674,
0.7487202286720276,
0.1293468326330185,
0.7841240763664246,
0.010512515902519226,
0.5828258395195007,
-0.6792916059494019,
0.31471994519233704,
-0.4916970431804657,
0.05098634585738182,
0.06992113590240479,
-0.44481247663497925,
0.1639445275068283,
0.35277223587036133,
-0.19425667822360992,
0.028377912938594818,
0.9663470983505249,
0.5065874457359314,
0.5559115409851074,
0.1472514420747757,
0.41687995195388794,
-0.3476138710975647,
0.6622411608695984,
0.8175709843635559,
1.136826992034912,
-0.6284275054931641,
0.7805303335189819,
0.06812534481287003,
-0.1739308387041092,
-0.1963406503200531,
-0.7749398350715637,
-0.6468690633773804,
-0.8313880562782288,
-0.6206266283988953,
-0.3922754228115082,
0.1554645299911499,
0.9846034646034241,
0.4918688237667084,
-0.9044799208641052,
0.12658600509166718,
-0.022617263719439507,
0.3425736725330353,
-0.5165178775787354,
-0.28297749161720276,
0.5211932063102722,
-0.7409777641296387,
-0.3170618414878845,
0.3407513201236725,
-0.10469187796115875,
-0.12273231148719788,
0.21861810982227325,
0.01941433735191822,
-0.24816793203353882,
0.2597599923610687,
0.5999777913093567,
0.7379505038261414,
-0.2956652343273163,
-0.6132996678352356,
-0.29916125535964966,
0.07986514270305634,
-0.08778830617666245,
0.4969005286693573,
-0.9099081158638,
-0.10675911605358124,
0.38668355345726013,
1.023927092552185,
0.6062507033348083,
0.33681604266166687,
0.41713249683380127,
-0.9532079100608826,
-0.48099008202552795,
0.5121947526931763,
-0.16788354516029358,
-0.26850566267967224,
-0.5344109535217285,
0.3477380871772766,
0.050778403878211975,
-0.7265245914459229,
-0.7270879745483398,
0.49618929624557495,
-0.7380138635635376,
-0.513573169708252,
1.4530051946640015,
0.025704870000481606,
-0.18521855771541595,
-0.26729056239128113,
-0.2814086675643921,
0.2805679142475128,
-0.24818280339241028,
0.9809613823890686,
0.3654334545135498,
-0.7125624418258667,
-0.521748423576355,
-0.5530950427055359,
0.860497772693634,
0.4036467969417572,
-1.3047276735305786,
-0.23966090381145477,
0.4846988320350647,
0.2436334639787674,
-0.2014952301979065,
0.45269447565078735,
-0.21393509209156036,
0.7316781282424927,
-0.35956647992134094,
0.4151449501514435,
-0.12341761589050293,
-0.14616462588310242,
-0.1387016773223877,
0.9140638113021851,
0.16772764921188354,
-0.3242373466491699
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10516v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10516v1
|
Language Models can Evaluate Themselves via Probability Discrepancy
| 2024-05-17T03:50:28 | 2024-05-17T03:50:28 |
Tingyu Xia, Bowen Yu, Yuan Wu, Yi Chang, Chang Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this paper, we initiate our discussion by demonstrating how Large Language
Models (LLMs), when tasked with responding to queries, display a more even
probability distribution in their answers if they are more adept, as opposed to
their less skilled counterparts. Expanding on this foundational insight, we
propose a new self-evaluation method ProbDiff for assessing the efficacy of
various LLMs. This approach obviates the necessity for an additional evaluation
model or the dependence on external, proprietary models like GPT-4 for
judgment. It uniquely utilizes the LLMs being tested to compute the probability
discrepancy between the initial response and its revised versions. A higher
discrepancy for a given query between two LLMs indicates a relatively weaker
capability. Our findings reveal that ProbDiff achieves results on par with
those obtained from evaluations based on GPT-4, spanning a range of scenarios
that include natural language generation (NLG) tasks such as translation,
summarization, and our proposed Xiaohongshu blog writing task, and benchmarks
for LLM evaluation like AlignBench, MT-Bench, and AlpacaEval, across LLMs of
varying magnitudes.
|
[
-0.18134507536888123,
-0.7616870999336243,
0.8173825740814209,
0.636517345905304,
-0.08637427538633347,
0.07150111347436905,
-0.22551319003105164,
-0.24275903403759003,
0.008994165807962418,
0.24437828361988068,
-0.5134927034378052,
-0.40882885456085205,
-0.6618884801864624,
0.31386977434158325,
-0.4159071743488312,
0.7937940955162048,
0.021566716954112053,
0.12580080330371857,
-0.3548567593097687,
0.019830886274576187,
-0.5954237580299377,
-0.3305307924747467,
-0.5179562568664551,
-0.40307295322418213,
0.21698005497455597,
0.04997900873422623,
0.6478312611579895,
0.22687651216983795,
0.9573768973350525,
0.3254343867301941,
0.3707564175128937,
0.0036486752796918154,
-0.22457651793956757,
0.04893678426742554,
-0.2514740824699402,
-0.44319385290145874,
-0.3318149447441101,
0.10188286751508713,
0.6550124287605286,
0.5932759046554565,
-0.34049278497695923,
0.015565972775220871,
0.23603157699108124,
0.670417070388794,
-0.6209059357643127,
0.07146541774272919,
-0.5369378328323364,
-0.11013370752334595,
-0.2660164535045624,
0.0739077478647232,
-0.5227142572402954,
-0.4890231788158417,
-0.02186366356909275,
-0.18349193036556244,
0.23634794354438782,
-0.11071527004241943,
0.5150960087776184,
0.26395562291145325,
-0.3471822440624237,
-0.377041757106781,
-0.7355286478996277,
0.6488912105560303,
-1.0360703468322754,
0.2698523700237274,
0.3097659647464752,
0.3970402777194977,
-0.29514744877815247,
-0.6586260795593262,
-0.7297750115394592,
-0.5648388862609863,
0.1841059923171997,
0.2570413053035736,
-0.28579819202423096,
-0.04571208730340004,
0.0477990098297596,
0.4762767255306244,
-0.6713762283325195,
0.20431175827980042,
0.07471999526023865,
-0.09443333745002747,
0.776742696762085,
0.21842242777347565,
0.05759130045771599,
-0.36526766419410706,
-0.13821622729301453,
-0.15926118195056915,
-0.6811631321907043,
-0.18886709213256836,
0.6933783292770386,
0.013282005675137043,
0.16306062042713165,
0.5322248339653015,
-0.11081846803426743,
0.8943929672241211,
0.17103299498558044,
-0.17791037261486053,
0.24791400134563446,
-0.35723885893821716,
-0.22879162430763245,
-0.2163330316543579,
1.004927158355713,
0.5134811997413635,
0.2471284121274948,
0.05153363198041916,
-0.320808470249176,
-0.09180571138858795,
0.16508062183856964,
-0.6166386604309082,
-0.470506489276886,
0.19817012548446655,
-0.40555116534233093,
-0.14872920513153076,
0.023277735337615013,
-0.4917738437652588,
-0.5068751573562622,
0.22339636087417603,
0.6012006998062134,
-0.3533359467983246,
-0.46971943974494934,
0.2667505443096161,
0.11450585722923279,
-0.23148761689662933,
0.19264163076877594,
-0.836392879486084,
0.3835792541503906,
0.6209742426872253,
0.6972530484199524,
-0.4074520468711853,
-0.27138447761535645,
-0.3594737648963928,
-0.08577354997396469,
-0.5988974571228027,
0.8989408016204834,
-0.4074195921421051,
-0.47182372212409973,
-0.18772318959236145,
-0.319345086812973,
-0.07135602086782455,
-0.7071143388748169,
0.7558435797691345,
-0.3464440703392029,
0.0868452936410904,
-0.32128164172172546,
-0.6863149404525757,
0.025523245334625244,
0.04548089578747749,
-0.6865377426147461,
0.879793107509613,
0.2614329755306244,
-0.9966486096382141,
0.4215362071990967,
-0.25701209902763367,
-0.26558589935302734,
0.17514127492904663,
-0.31034716963768005,
-0.33970120549201965,
0.1888149231672287,
-0.054401639848947525,
0.4726203978061676,
-0.39014774560928345,
0.3746611773967743,
-0.4367699921131134,
-0.22603824734687805,
0.3935917019844055,
-0.5522709488868713,
0.6933830380439758,
0.2940700352191925,
-0.25439175963401794,
-0.09296336024999619,
-0.7440690994262695,
0.14845289289951324,
0.10274283587932587,
-0.4322473406791687,
-0.4367060959339142,
0.034510537981987,
-0.40976712107658386,
0.12875407934188843,
0.30274564027786255,
-0.5244487524032593,
0.11538470536470413,
-0.6846591234207153,
0.08368787169456482,
0.6947745084762573,
-0.020385460928082466,
0.3287140429019928,
-0.38552427291870117,
0.6761125326156616,
-0.24466250836849213,
0.025638006627559662,
0.011943980120122433,
-0.576858401298523,
-0.5174053311347961,
-0.25216788053512573,
0.46910279989242554,
0.3570263087749481,
-0.6244384050369263,
0.4433734118938446,
-0.13247863948345184,
-0.6602656245231628,
-0.7376225590705872,
0.2610085606575012,
0.45878198742866516,
0.38725098967552185,
0.16602590680122375,
-0.5540052056312561,
-0.6191681623458862,
-1.0021156072616577,
-0.4649186432361603,
-0.458827942609787,
0.02787892147898674,
-0.030046604573726654,
0.47386276721954346,
0.0975358635187149,
1.0151100158691406,
-0.37879690527915955,
-0.1995953470468521,
-0.5190034508705139,
0.2603816092014313,
0.4149605929851532,
0.27363601326942444,
0.49275797605514526,
-0.3762055039405823,
-0.4309483468532562,
-0.3015080690383911,
-0.8058650493621826,
-0.4427521228790283,
-0.17456179857254028,
0.1740543395280838,
0.3162793815135956,
0.15232476592063904,
-0.8031119704246521,
0.20489147305488586,
0.660466194152832,
-0.10344608128070831,
0.9437443614006042,
-0.4360765218734741,
0.21188341081142426,
-0.6699739098548889,
-0.2770143151283264,
0.11645527929067612,
-0.23646441102027893,
-0.35673433542251587,
0.09807455539703369,
0.284740149974823,
0.5081418752670288,
-0.22180978953838348,
0.6688199639320374,
-0.4880029857158661,
-0.2324291467666626,
-0.3238520622253418,
0.3131222128868103,
-0.056019991636276245,
-0.05225272476673126,
-0.21641959249973297,
0.6684701442718506,
0.37551188468933105,
-0.5695021152496338,
0.4072211980819702,
0.08954876661300659,
-0.7154269814491272,
0.4229312837123871,
-0.6453876495361328,
0.01755746826529503,
0.05659593641757965,
0.24716882407665253,
-1.1333887577056885,
-0.1337926834821701,
0.07532939314842224,
-0.4075911343097687,
0.1592220515012741,
0.13951484858989716,
-0.7239448428153992,
-0.883794903755188,
-0.3603852689266205,
0.0782243087887764,
0.40450575947761536,
-0.32303541898727417,
0.33518534898757935,
0.17080172896385193,
-0.20959293842315674,
-0.6445638537406921,
-0.6437000036239624,
0.027957739308476448,
-0.1718701720237732,
-0.6703068614006042,
0.09299494326114655,
-0.3750506341457367,
-0.5626799464225769,
-0.11560586839914322,
-0.24966448545455933,
0.19941097497940063,
0.28257113695144653,
0.10426993668079376,
0.004240778274834156,
-0.021658096462488174,
0.21549031138420105,
-0.10570323467254639,
0.1115218847990036,
0.19830982387065887,
-0.05879349634051323,
0.5640867352485657,
-0.14568844437599182,
-0.8359265923500061,
-0.1606743484735489,
0.020705854520201683,
-0.1879865676164627,
-0.15639978647232056,
0.4296182096004486,
0.3566097319126129,
-0.07851193845272064,
-0.20678427815437317,
-0.7451804280281067,
-0.18012841045856476,
-0.4609617590904236,
0.47376617789268494,
-0.6324166655540466,
-0.6955416798591614,
0.4504583775997162,
0.16864080727100372,
-0.018537450581789017,
0.6598422527313232,
0.8677418828010559,
-0.14842359721660614,
1.024172067642212,
0.6251912713050842,
0.40266790986061096,
0.13574348390102386,
-0.051807794719934464,
0.5217262506484985,
-0.6612826585769653,
-0.01770724728703499,
-0.42914170026779175,
-0.013027684763073921,
-0.7191439867019653,
-0.3340887129306793,
0.16099697351455688,
0.27685537934303284,
-0.11954174935817719,
0.35988786816596985,
-0.28194132447242737,
0.5032796859741211,
0.5515646934509277,
-0.16478335857391357,
0.5270988345146179,
-0.2649543881416321,
-0.25315359234809875,
-0.27471044659614563,
-0.7519972324371338,
-0.6346131563186646,
1.293423056602478,
0.3367920517921448,
0.9021590948104858,
0.3000582456588745,
0.874194324016571,
0.3868505656719208,
0.6150651574134827,
-0.4341842830181122,
0.6507801413536072,
-0.15406225621700287,
-0.650039553642273,
-0.30522024631500244,
-0.5042669177055359,
-0.8677427172660828,
0.3424277603626251,
0.018284233286976814,
-0.7481493353843689,
0.08722298592329025,
0.05594655126333237,
-0.3760949671268463,
0.048998624086380005,
-0.8363693356513977,
0.9023940563201904,
-0.41888973116874695,
-0.2525428533554077,
-0.17324720323085785,
-0.324097216129303,
0.6734652519226074,
-0.4756019413471222,
0.31853267550468445,
-0.32468098402023315,
0.2926400601863861,
0.766867995262146,
-0.14366966485977173,
0.6312559247016907,
-0.09360717236995697,
-0.3796374201774597,
0.3999524712562561,
0.6472521424293518,
0.2927091121673584,
0.0942651629447937,
-0.4240227937698364,
0.0632103830575943,
-0.0363827645778656,
-0.06246316432952881,
-0.709467351436615,
0.7204318046569824,
-0.5458512306213379,
-1.1264317035675049,
-0.5053746104240417,
-0.534247636795044,
-0.15972018241882324,
0.16825075447559357,
0.19072306156158447,
0.2855152487754822,
-0.36538922786712646,
-0.0517762117087841,
0.16123299300670624,
-0.3116873800754547,
0.5989012122154236,
0.8012288808822632,
-0.3814431428909302,
-0.09768732637166977,
0.649236798286438,
0.18227705359458923,
0.38219553232192993,
0.26129886507987976,
0.25387606024742126,
-0.5141134262084961,
-0.6301831007003784,
-0.2541101276874542,
0.329113245010376,
-0.912120521068573,
-0.31083959341049194,
-0.6684814095497131,
-0.06459421664476395,
-0.5681678056716919,
0.26686379313468933,
-0.34210965037345886,
-0.4827008843421936,
0.14511477947235107,
-0.1563056856393814,
0.04485788941383362,
0.9324247241020203,
-0.42095640301704407,
0.4945058524608612,
-0.5023255944252014,
0.11587905138731003,
0.16616187989711761,
0.2770504951477051,
-0.04471511393785477,
-0.6851739883422852,
-0.14871294796466827,
-0.019144445657730103,
-0.7401776313781738,
-1.083200454711914,
0.5308066010475159,
0.18698838353157043,
0.9293038249015808,
0.22133517265319824,
0.022950155660510063,
0.44457247853279114,
-0.5869715213775635,
0.7351523637771606,
0.34921762347221375,
-0.8750351667404175,
0.4465334415435791,
-0.21513719856739044,
0.24780476093292236,
0.3474067449569702,
0.4683930277824402,
-0.24158024787902832,
-0.7512644529342651,
-0.7463870048522949,
-0.6345898509025574,
0.5418753027915955,
0.1847037374973297,
0.2525074779987335,
-0.5122270584106445,
0.1836596578359604,
0.23247124254703522,
0.3009664714336395,
-0.9351208806037903,
-0.0977572575211525,
-0.012439905665814877,
-0.3791944980621338,
-0.17432430386543274,
-0.414397656917572,
-0.04495231807231903,
0.04244617745280266,
0.621860146522522,
-0.07326246052980423,
0.3575116693973541,
0.24092085659503937,
-0.2348610907793045,
-0.0034546838141977787,
0.3135436773300171,
0.2830260694026947,
1.0668883323669434,
-0.362909734249115,
0.31482863426208496,
0.11586497724056244,
-0.18061839044094086,
0.18808645009994507,
0.15588146448135376,
0.11559852212667465,
0.07159207761287689,
0.6182156205177307,
0.6599729657173157,
0.11468378454446793,
-0.5827359557151794,
0.7708722949028015,
-0.1076725572347641,
-0.19018051028251648,
-0.055571652948856354,
0.13138748705387115,
0.3393442928791046,
0.2389201819896698,
0.5024170875549316,
-0.15362103283405304,
0.30222180485725403,
-0.571079671382904,
0.30399608612060547,
0.4221312403678894,
0.1032642126083374,
-0.23922021687030792,
0.6403990983963013,
0.14586004614830017,
-0.4687502682209015,
0.3483235239982605,
-0.5741298794746399,
-0.31463706493377686,
0.5887250304222107,
0.7448202967643738,
0.7285187840461731,
-0.6120232939720154,
0.4200479984283447,
0.1931503415107727,
0.3552549481391907,
-0.350507915019989,
0.1813461035490036,
0.20734916627407074,
-0.7886257767677307,
-0.7274274230003357,
-0.794898509979248,
-0.25759685039520264,
0.08522980660200119,
-0.2602893114089966,
0.13213956356048584,
-0.268653929233551,
-0.36228734254837036,
0.014250177890062332,
0.08868171274662018,
-0.5299256443977356,
0.09913105517625809,
-0.18251484632492065,
0.8629786968231201,
-0.7405800819396973,
0.7258102297782898,
0.4144182503223419,
-0.439372718334198,
-0.6038414835929871,
0.19940917193889618,
-0.2790660262107849,
-0.7710393667221069,
0.9851827621459961,
0.1561710089445114,
-0.06575925648212433,
0.02733604423701763,
-0.07699909806251526,
-0.7532534599304199,
0.7260114550590515,
0.6015942096710205,
-0.850161612033844,
0.15561267733573914,
0.08315248787403107,
0.7229384779930115,
-0.35953986644744873,
0.5913832187652588,
0.7894849181175232,
0.3341664671897888,
-0.26654252409935,
-1.1509511470794678,
-0.0019265817245468497,
0.07637418806552887,
0.09862768650054932,
-0.10388056933879852,
-0.47102436423301697,
0.8747153878211975,
-0.48471564054489136,
-0.19949758052825928,
0.04288436099886894,
0.676225483417511,
0.47099122405052185,
0.08730164170265198,
0.4483603239059448,
0.46254605054855347,
0.7067863941192627,
-0.16670279204845428,
1.3480725288391113,
-0.22522783279418945,
0.5242071747779846,
1.3000165224075317,
-0.5872672200202942,
0.8165966868400574,
0.2597079277038574,
-0.5127639174461365,
0.4303395748138428,
0.7133844494819641,
0.009999070316553116,
0.678419291973114,
0.5002403855323792,
-0.2064870446920395,
-0.39068499207496643,
0.2874525189399719,
-0.24832160770893097,
0.29550009965896606,
0.009863538667559624,
-0.12419378012418747,
-0.4573042690753937,
-0.009244833141565323,
-0.12499096244573593,
0.3903502821922302,
0.05255556106567383,
0.5572195649147034,
0.30891385674476624,
-0.8216255307197571,
0.575013279914856,
0.31665316224098206,
0.5922117233276367,
-0.413817435503006,
0.006377155892550945,
-0.4246799051761627,
0.33893609046936035,
-0.15401756763458252,
-1.2507151365280151,
0.37894511222839355,
-0.01161244697868824,
0.06643307209014893,
-0.11117717623710632,
0.6655694246292114,
-0.09889651834964752,
-0.639289379119873,
0.435951292514801,
0.7379573583602905,
0.31566083431243896,
-0.10687766224145889,
-0.7739512324333191,
0.02098570019006729,
0.007197157479822636,
-0.43310996890068054,
0.2424578070640564,
0.4535844326019287,
-0.14694517850875854,
0.9588192701339722,
0.30658331513404846,
0.23514877259731293,
0.0496704988181591,
0.4000433683395386,
0.37561139464378357,
-0.21957051753997803,
-0.37541329860687256,
-1.1480233669281006,
0.16517354547977448,
-0.002839011838659644,
-0.18878783285617828,
1.1064320802688599,
0.40546175837516785,
0.8025612235069275,
-0.09672408550977707,
0.8515137434005737,
-0.16369998455047607,
0.5282225012779236,
-0.3902425765991211,
0.3897845447063446,
-0.3054112493991852,
0.560448408126831,
-0.38339656591415405,
-0.9425716400146484,
-0.1768902689218521,
0.9002105593681335,
-0.7630378603935242,
0.3212784230709076,
0.9240527153015137,
0.6908497214317322,
0.16742375493049622,
-0.2431052029132843,
0.5213569402694702,
0.43336620926856995,
0.35390937328338623,
0.49333456158638,
0.9287288188934326,
-0.3390926718711853,
0.48650267720222473,
-0.08601675182580948,
-0.3170405626296997,
-0.13905270397663116,
-1.0161398649215698,
-0.7675091624259949,
-0.611212432384491,
-0.2716715633869171,
-0.27423420548439026,
0.35346147418022156,
0.5512145161628723,
0.4460572600364685,
-0.4946357309818268,
-0.3871399760246277,
-0.1171918585896492,
0.22978301346302032,
-0.23471678793430328,
-0.17942827939987183,
0.3059955835342407,
-0.30409330129623413,
-0.626445472240448,
0.3184134364128113,
0.13978683948516846,
-0.07891473174095154,
-0.5427505373954773,
-0.10423161834478378,
-0.12248469889163971,
0.1406271606683731,
0.30555859208106995,
-0.21975672245025635,
-0.6064876914024353,
-0.24619509279727936,
-0.22361555695533752,
-0.03601736202836037,
0.09930221736431122,
0.5189219117164612,
-0.7224043607711792,
0.32729676365852356,
0.3736747205257416,
0.5004905462265015,
0.3635471761226654,
-0.08022763580083847,
0.7249359488487244,
-0.7090699076652527,
-0.2050151377916336,
0.11730658262968063,
0.33821946382522583,
0.6315461993217468,
-0.30500340461730957,
0.5716280937194824,
0.16068153083324432,
-0.654983401298523,
-0.8649680614471436,
0.35574576258659363,
-0.6385500431060791,
-0.3561880886554718,
1.2642267942428589,
-0.2783922851085663,
-0.062198456376791,
0.15657804906368256,
-0.05765474587678909,
0.10091985017061234,
-0.18696346879005432,
0.9131749272346497,
1.1094833612442017,
-0.21764713525772095,
-0.13622088730335236,
-0.9441598057746887,
0.45506131649017334,
0.5383341908454895,
-0.6538379788398743,
0.1631295382976532,
0.34546607732772827,
0.5921653509140015,
0.046415794640779495,
1.1054555177688599,
-0.1295604109764099,
0.28772443532943726,
-0.1372106671333313,
0.16832561790943146,
0.21766053140163422,
-0.1820424199104309,
-0.32770588994026184,
-0.05209977552294731,
0.5190858840942383,
0.22207818925380707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10492v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10492v2
|
Automatic News Generation and Fact-Checking System Based on Language Processing
| 2024-05-17T01:58:23 | 2024-05-21T01:18:22 |
Xirui Peng, Qiming Xu, Zheng Feng, Haopeng Zhao, Lianghao Tan, Yan Zhou, Zecheng Zhang, Chenwei Gong, Yingqiao Zheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, I.5; H.4
|
This paper explores an automatic news generation and fact-checking system
based on language processing, aimed at enhancing the efficiency and quality of
news production while ensuring the authenticity and reliability of the news
content. With the rapid development of Natural Language Processing (NLP) and
deep learning technologies, automatic news generation systems are capable of
extracting key information from massive data and generating well-structured,
fluent news articles. Meanwhile, by integrating fact-checking technology, the
system can effectively prevent the spread of false news and improve the
accuracy and credibility of news. This study details the key technologies
involved in automatic news generation and factchecking, including text
generation, information extraction, and the application of knowledge graphs,
and validates the effectiveness of these technologies through experiments.
Additionally, the paper discusses the future development directions of
automatic news generation and fact-checking systems, emphasizing the importance
of further integration and innovation of technologies. The results show that
with continuous technological optimization and practical application, these
systems will play an increasingly important role in the future news industry,
providing more efficient and reliable news services.
|
[
-0.49226611852645874,
-1.0513161420822144,
0.7270498871803284,
0.1538207083940506,
-0.23977486789226532,
0.450448602437973,
-0.12504440546035767,
-0.5921437740325928,
0.11185450106859207,
0.5015071630477905,
-0.321513295173645,
-0.3056429624557495,
-0.5249468088150024,
0.2572981119155884,
-0.7778477668762207,
0.8094704151153564,
-0.08791855722665787,
-0.11973103135824203,
0.15784430503845215,
0.058911725878715515,
-0.3259269893169403,
-0.3173700273036957,
-0.6821869611740112,
-0.2737075984477997,
-0.07638654112815857,
0.46329787373542786,
0.9118344187736511,
0.7752400636672974,
0.5312145948410034,
0.3615497350692749,
0.34140560030937195,
0.40557754039764404,
0.1444907933473587,
0.24604226648807526,
-0.08095219731330872,
-0.17180892825126648,
-0.3839862644672394,
-0.005186660680919886,
0.6168603301048279,
0.15466119349002838,
0.14929445087909698,
0.261891633272171,
0.0023075751960277557,
0.8461349606513977,
-0.3320367932319641,
0.28045031428337097,
-0.3692818880081177,
0.06952087581157684,
-0.198781356215477,
-0.38677284121513367,
-0.1356230080127716,
-0.9697037935256958,
-0.2820607125759125,
-0.1760484129190445,
0.2676981985569,
0.10142742097377777,
1.020262360572815,
0.14872023463249207,
-0.4019463062286377,
-0.5828478932380676,
-0.7907484769821167,
0.4057585597038269,
-0.8087172508239746,
0.45387762784957886,
0.09154274314641953,
0.3974454402923584,
-0.24502862989902496,
-0.5302773714065552,
-0.8874090313911438,
-0.2461700439453125,
-0.11720473319292068,
-0.0129992151632905,
0.053855691105127335,
-0.28995561599731445,
0.1080184131860733,
0.3900359869003296,
-0.6412254571914673,
-0.09442809969186783,
-0.4015533924102783,
-0.23439167439937592,
0.7106408476829529,
-0.2542608976364136,
0.43866902589797974,
-0.30915191769599915,
-0.04415549710392952,
0.038673073053359985,
-0.4857347905635834,
-0.19448824226856232,
0.4289768636226654,
0.12527483701705933,
0.09379639476537704,
0.6143450736999512,
-0.7888352870941162,
0.6980012059211731,
-0.0707588642835617,
-0.5126737952232361,
0.2666122615337372,
-0.530855119228363,
-0.42579615116119385,
0.2908615171909332,
0.8333082795143127,
0.28802376985549927,
0.07410413771867752,
-0.02731393277645111,
-0.3094814419746399,
0.338027685880661,
-0.055390939116477966,
-0.5014570355415344,
0.11863800138235092,
0.2973461151123047,
-0.3068239986896515,
-0.6944231986999512,
0.12226143479347229,
-0.6749067902565002,
-0.07353521138429642,
-0.3909423351287842,
0.33342090249061584,
-0.3819894790649414,
-0.38030120730400085,
0.36671000719070435,
-0.36227789521217346,
-0.13796468079090118,
0.28993722796440125,
-0.5206469297409058,
0.15233241021633148,
0.4804287552833557,
0.8197235465049744,
-0.13201244175434113,
0.10720042884349823,
-0.4537144601345062,
0.18361546099185944,
-0.43275031447410583,
0.9125432372093201,
-0.06787063926458359,
0.36344340443611145,
0.13251826167106628,
-0.21395817399024963,
0.36779531836509705,
-0.39085468649864197,
0.6400546431541443,
-0.8348010778427124,
0.33114737272262573,
-0.0908789411187172,
-0.6280945539474487,
-0.18270623683929443,
0.39682909846305847,
-0.7757980823516846,
0.8004698157310486,
-0.23082464933395386,
-0.6387118697166443,
0.5411320328712463,
-0.6932300329208374,
-0.7544593811035156,
0.2052069455385208,
-0.08463423699140549,
-0.46441805362701416,
-0.1254502832889557,
0.40766641497612,
0.32717984914779663,
-0.15220995247364044,
0.6583812832832336,
0.24317637085914612,
-0.063091941177845,
0.2015513926744461,
-0.25968411564826965,
0.7334389686584473,
0.4698363244533539,
-0.6497634649276733,
-0.3128832280635834,
-0.9789059162139893,
0.14359496533870697,
0.08493250608444214,
-0.7947791814804077,
0.11880987137556076,
0.06953345984220505,
-0.18745975196361542,
0.37597107887268066,
0.3723571300506592,
-0.7298469543457031,
0.03467274829745293,
-0.21602968871593475,
0.2569773197174072,
0.12571968138217926,
0.25615832209587097,
0.2938542068004608,
-0.2372366338968277,
0.012548288330435753,
0.02693769708275795,
0.22609128057956696,
-0.523379385471344,
-0.33227017521858215,
-1.0171623229980469,
0.250531405210495,
0.4851841330528259,
0.7733979225158691,
-0.965166449546814,
0.9191682934761047,
0.12616902589797974,
-0.47822079062461853,
-0.15117043256759644,
0.03831537440419197,
0.06320572644472122,
0.6619501113891602,
0.24811355769634247,
-0.19493131339550018,
-0.9425644278526306,
-0.6128568053245544,
-0.4770507216453552,
-0.057307805866003036,
0.32888373732566833,
-0.43343135714530945,
0.21299195289611816,
0.003812373848631978,
1.2299509048461914,
-0.31340357661247253,
0.07927988469600677,
-0.23065011203289032,
0.3133051097393036,
0.25018951296806335,
0.5498538613319397,
0.30510228872299194,
-1.0854265689849854,
-0.26881200075149536,
-0.05305406451225281,
-1.017723798751831,
-0.1111544743180275,
-0.03640865534543991,
0.2735448181629181,
0.7252985835075378,
0.5575964450836182,
-0.4801532030105591,
0.3290312886238098,
0.5978326201438904,
-0.2623450756072998,
0.6278602480888367,
-0.050163403153419495,
0.4614299535751343,
-0.7863754034042358,
-0.05881500989198685,
0.001584250247105956,
-0.5789054036140442,
-0.5507910251617432,
0.010253455489873886,
-0.033357322216033936,
-0.30371683835983276,
-0.3635682165622711,
0.435211718082428,
-0.4297766387462616,
-0.2576598823070526,
-0.5763640999794006,
0.1922500878572464,
0.15942485630512238,
0.14124608039855957,
0.09084101021289825,
0.5136328339576721,
0.5002921223640442,
-0.8467447757720947,
0.8716649413108826,
-0.2841532826423645,
-0.7317169904708862,
0.06202685087919235,
-0.22815139591693878,
-0.09273470193147659,
-0.008274590596556664,
0.29221871495246887,
-0.6830270290374756,
-0.2128300964832306,
0.15079617500305176,
-0.5516339540481567,
-0.0030479126144200563,
0.28960150480270386,
-0.9451810717582703,
-0.5865654349327087,
-0.016956789419054985,
-0.37526535987854004,
0.5784857869148254,
-0.2370043843984604,
0.05277550593018532,
0.4689365029335022,
-0.47395893931388855,
-0.5682507753372192,
-0.6397457718849182,
0.4897473454475403,
0.1733752340078354,
-0.6763598918914795,
-0.025253791362047195,
0.20078140497207642,
-0.34852105379104614,
0.3434195816516876,
-0.010618885979056358,
-0.15982118248939514,
-0.10506615042686462,
-0.2582457661628723,
0.11402881145477295,
-0.40485861897468567,
0.37597349286079407,
0.2721061110496521,
-0.13166911900043488,
-0.11434675753116608,
-0.5527930855751038,
0.44918012619018555,
-0.20811006426811218,
-0.28110387921333313,
-0.6874145865440369,
0.24573148787021637,
0.5100985765457153,
-0.24582964181900024,
0.6589199900627136,
0.732279360294342,
-0.3209846317768097,
-0.0020287593360990286,
-0.9712059497833252,
-0.24840010702610016,
-0.43242016434669495,
0.21827761828899384,
0.018758824095129967,
-0.7458460927009583,
0.07359684258699417,
-0.3399721384048462,
0.2586231231689453,
0.800603985786438,
0.5003060698509216,
0.0631694421172142,
1.1759321689605713,
0.7640790343284607,
0.016544101759791374,
0.3211810886859894,
0.03622040897607803,
0.2764589786529541,
0.04940655454993248,
0.05588805302977562,
-0.6290093064308167,
-0.0670652911067009,
-0.5052956938743591,
-0.010117582976818085,
0.2922065854072571,
-0.08968058973550797,
-0.2424726039171219,
0.1286803036928177,
-0.5428255200386047,
0.35861262679100037,
0.6970412731170654,
-0.301317423582077,
0.8484143614768982,
0.1478685587644577,
0.08324050158262253,
0.24221907556056976,
-0.5408087968826294,
-0.7088960409164429,
0.7891033887863159,
0.27502280473709106,
0.6280582547187805,
-0.3134496510028839,
0.5134001970291138,
0.7049760222434998,
0.12856091558933258,
-0.48114824295043945,
0.4895992577075958,
-0.1409807950258255,
-0.5520231127738953,
-0.4946330487728119,
-0.35101133584976196,
-0.2818704843521118,
-0.13790912926197052,
-0.3463323712348938,
-0.12654663622379303,
0.20317275822162628,
-0.0014924146234989166,
-0.233744278550148,
0.27998584508895874,
-0.7352944016456604,
0.2096477597951889,
-0.37023481726646423,
0.06910344958305359,
-0.37981221079826355,
-0.3434024453163147,
0.6397570371627808,
-0.08073852211236954,
0.5017403364181519,
-0.048453520983457565,
0.19843609631061554,
0.6421337127685547,
-0.2166515737771988,
0.6021343469619751,
-0.12508933246135712,
-0.1867244690656662,
0.5668081045150757,
0.08623946458101273,
0.49821338057518005,
0.1846112161874771,
-0.31060367822647095,
0.014178191311657429,
-0.4480281472206116,
0.08353716135025024,
-0.3543647527694702,
0.5699308514595032,
-0.5018866062164307,
-0.5962091684341431,
-0.4457651972770691,
-0.5122756361961365,
-0.016594568267464638,
0.6778954267501831,
0.07758115977048874,
0.31470391154289246,
-0.2172810435295105,
0.13211455941200256,
0.5947849750518799,
-0.14042799174785614,
0.6113051772117615,
0.6938266754150391,
-0.32500118017196655,
-0.3754490613937378,
0.9800533056259155,
0.3090241849422455,
-0.14230948686599731,
0.3898784816265106,
0.14739076793193817,
-0.07255302369594574,
-0.4638582766056061,
-0.8535769581794739,
0.043387237936258316,
-0.43031787872314453,
-0.30967456102371216,
-0.8198704719543457,
-0.42911496758461,
-0.73870450258255,
-0.0557590126991272,
-0.38836851716041565,
-0.7270472645759583,
0.15831995010375977,
-0.032831836491823196,
0.18996411561965942,
0.8052853345870972,
-0.2353493571281433,
0.06814653426408768,
-0.8875716924667358,
0.7973423004150391,
0.4614481031894684,
0.3113345205783844,
-0.4536665380001068,
0.07712527364492416,
-0.6033634543418884,
0.052618902176618576,
-0.5434186458587646,
-0.7289208769798279,
0.34324344992637634,
-0.035464685410261154,
0.24788179993629456,
0.13467192649841309,
-0.08721469342708588,
0.021002132445573807,
-0.49634888768196106,
0.7043177485466003,
0.17605404555797577,
-1.016124963760376,
0.7218512296676636,
-0.1991732120513916,
0.19992122054100037,
0.2743423283100128,
-0.047519560903310776,
-0.5059349536895752,
-0.8448618650436401,
-0.6836839318275452,
-0.3922857344150543,
0.7009961605072021,
0.0931483805179596,
-0.23478615283966064,
0.18899904191493988,
0.23906978964805603,
0.20847180485725403,
0.46324825286865234,
-0.6670584082603455,
-0.05439642816781998,
-0.5181335806846619,
-0.18134376406669617,
0.16079659759998322,
-0.18705667555332184,
-0.05827641114592552,
-0.005022069439291954,
1.0239603519439697,
-0.14279060065746307,
-0.017388399690389633,
0.26457130908966064,
-0.09466048330068588,
-0.3748670518398285,
0.5131867527961731,
0.5558944344520569,
0.6355028748512268,
-0.006549390032887459,
0.1038917526602745,
-0.1301097571849823,
-0.4134654700756073,
0.3491174876689911,
0.044251699000597,
-0.6068173050880432,
0.37896519899368286,
0.0008810285944491625,
0.6037895679473877,
-0.45321547985076904,
-0.43255382776260376,
0.35982924699783325,
0.010583450086414814,
-0.22826853394508362,
-0.43923407793045044,
0.43898439407348633,
0.17568232119083405,
0.3645727336406708,
0.6976109147071838,
0.3373758792877197,
0.23435945808887482,
-0.8189293742179871,
0.37561798095703125,
0.23545940220355988,
0.042343687266111374,
0.02215912938117981,
0.3782299757003784,
0.2878057658672333,
-0.2461971491575241,
0.27953675389289856,
-0.421892911195755,
-0.3631075620651245,
0.7841066122055054,
0.5981947183609009,
0.5974295735359192,
-0.1473330855369568,
0.4096496105194092,
0.3202505111694336,
0.46076467633247375,
-0.461971253156662,
0.3634624481201172,
0.054945651441812515,
-0.7759256362915039,
-0.7899629473686218,
-0.6917452216148376,
-0.38287317752838135,
0.265572726726532,
-0.09374531358480453,
0.49291297793388367,
-0.2826788127422333,
-0.2952733337879181,
-0.10589932650327682,
0.34920260310173035,
-0.40229448676109314,
0.7521567344665527,
0.26942330598831177,
0.9990831017494202,
-0.8495845794677734,
0.6846620440483093,
0.6197748780250549,
-0.1438334733247757,
-0.45854029059410095,
0.16115766763687134,
-0.004657464101910591,
-0.5653817653656006,
0.8887966275215149,
-0.03728191927075386,
-0.2784816324710846,
-0.02406344562768936,
-0.4998567998409271,
-0.8829092979431152,
0.7384898066520691,
0.5707327127456665,
-0.5313408970832825,
-0.023531030863523483,
0.17587651312351227,
0.4320518970489502,
-0.22885912656784058,
-0.26026451587677,
0.5799144506454468,
0.9426665306091309,
-0.20100650191307068,
-0.7325924038887024,
0.1564589887857437,
-0.060001831501722336,
-0.357046902179718,
0.0726483166217804,
-0.7134144902229309,
0.7278361916542053,
0.015898004174232483,
-0.49924707412719727,
-0.22917738556861877,
0.7400708794593811,
0.010036868043243885,
0.3726607859134674,
0.4703414738178253,
0.5374898314476013,
0.5419375896453857,
-0.11573020368814468,
0.7060394287109375,
-0.4441523849964142,
0.22880007326602936,
0.6073389649391174,
-0.061828624457120895,
0.2640109062194824,
0.06932303309440613,
0.19226138293743134,
0.8322684168815613,
0.10113898664712906,
-0.1348131000995636,
0.1352306455373764,
-0.2644098103046417,
-0.2830798029899597,
-0.008283506147563457,
-0.17383618652820587,
-0.29889553785324097,
0.43169158697128296,
0.4832877218723297,
-0.3685552775859833,
-0.3974567651748657,
0.11508549749851227,
0.19574379920959473,
-0.01062422152608633,
-0.042357832193374634,
0.7792210578918457,
-0.2505537271499634,
-0.9596062302589417,
0.2724900543689728,
0.3346492052078247,
0.6260756850242615,
-0.5672555565834045,
-0.04370659217238426,
0.002914934419095516,
-0.13012002408504486,
-0.41973716020584106,
-0.9501974582672119,
0.3723389506340027,
0.3633253872394562,
-0.28105852007865906,
-0.28383901715278625,
1.3251314163208008,
-0.33215469121932983,
-0.47730326652526855,
-0.09997638314962387,
0.7635788917541504,
-0.13676773011684418,
-0.06150469928979874,
-0.455933153629303,
0.2124634087085724,
-0.03282792121171951,
-0.5288479924201965,
-0.02827855758368969,
0.48009270429611206,
0.13920089602470398,
0.4512574076652527,
0.7624951601028442,
0.5333932042121887,
-0.029992109164595604,
0.038047026842832565,
0.6074104309082031,
-0.7526691555976868,
-0.755115807056427,
-0.8411779999732971,
0.10161733627319336,
-0.4121396839618683,
0.12688195705413818,
0.8260061144828796,
0.5638223886489868,
0.5783702731132507,
0.1265803873538971,
1.2344077825546265,
-0.4393823742866516,
0.6292433738708496,
-0.49664315581321716,
0.9163462519645691,
-0.19243484735488892,
-0.21122010052204132,
-0.04489196836948395,
-0.806839644908905,
-0.4046398997306824,
0.1450713574886322,
0.10038401186466217,
-0.06688399612903595,
0.8121695518493652,
0.5364691615104675,
0.17822887003421783,
0.263217031955719,
0.05530185252428055,
0.14799971878528595,
0.4042029082775116,
0.04421508312225342,
0.4471399486064911,
-0.4469713866710663,
0.5597074627876282,
-0.3723016083240509,
-0.32007932662963867,
-0.39447781443595886,
-0.9212973117828369,
-0.30769333243370056,
-0.5749586224555969,
-0.2587722837924957,
-0.1265861690044403,
0.18301312625408173,
0.31508567929267883,
0.7202762365341187,
-0.7840290665626526,
-0.12155447900295258,
-0.41179579496383667,
0.4804551601409912,
-0.3507666289806366,
-0.36706995964050293,
0.4895876348018646,
-0.8299235105514526,
-0.792376697063446,
0.3906724452972412,
0.6073966026306152,
-0.02613907866179943,
-0.5088686943054199,
0.2327204942703247,
-0.23991507291793823,
0.021504681557416916,
0.6099498867988586,
0.4291629493236542,
-0.23999416828155518,
-0.2923690974712372,
-0.11822225153446198,
-0.2831383943557739,
0.03711322322487831,
0.9559128284454346,
-1.1267317533493042,
0.31978335976600647,
0.6026410460472107,
0.5553381443023682,
0.11539266258478165,
0.0006971213733777404,
0.6070724725723267,
-0.5795929431915283,
0.09168140590190887,
0.05522533878684044,
0.17361687123775482,
0.5529344081878662,
-0.6056787371635437,
0.2969241440296173,
0.30771034955978394,
-0.6447001099586487,
-0.5844491720199585,
0.25151118636131287,
-0.4172899127006531,
-0.2056904137134552,
0.9169639348983765,
0.4529057443141937,
-0.33253607153892517,
-0.5746868848800659,
-0.17323443293571472,
0.8455870747566223,
-0.4935376048088074,
0.9153684973716736,
0.6939217448234558,
-0.31770768761634827,
-0.08326486498117447,
-0.6708357930183411,
0.7680266499519348,
0.11096009612083435,
-1.0155835151672363,
-0.10505882650613785,
0.37955859303474426,
0.061365704983472824,
0.608433723449707,
0.5575590133666992,
-0.25495997071266174,
0.39419984817504883,
0.029150554910302162,
0.14828930795192719,
-0.18477296829223633,
-0.2813180983066559,
0.06482093781232834,
0.3333143889904022,
-0.21371130645275116,
-0.05162516236305237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10485v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10485v1
|
CNER: A tool Classifier of Named-Entity Relationships
| 2024-05-17T01:16:58 | 2024-05-17T01:16:58 |
Jefferson A. Peña Torres, Raúl E. Gutiérrez De Piñerez
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
We introduce CNER, an ensemble of capable tools for extraction of semantic
relationships between named entities in Spanish language. Built upon a
container-based architecture, CNER integrates different Named entity
recognition and relation extraction tools with a user-friendly interface that
allows users to input free text or files effortlessly, facilitating streamlined
analysis. Developed as a prototype version for the Natural Language Processing
(NLP) Group at Universidad del Valle, CNER serves as a practical educational
resource, illustrating how machine learning techniques can effectively tackle
diverse NLP tasks in Spanish. Our preliminary results reveal the promising
potential of CNER in advancing the understanding and development of NLP tools,
particularly within Spanish-language contexts.
|
[
-0.6151406764984131,
-0.4877847731113434,
0.5109052062034607,
0.42778319120407104,
-0.1476897895336151,
0.21084125339984894,
-0.2363312542438507,
-0.8735377788543701,
0.37645816802978516,
0.5569155216217041,
-0.5497912764549255,
-0.42955198884010315,
-0.6283944249153137,
0.2614075839519501,
-0.6402877569198608,
0.9512529373168945,
0.16284385323524475,
0.1758280247449875,
-0.03010631911456585,
-0.00412746099755168,
-0.5219929814338684,
-0.31034043431282043,
-1.2583340406417847,
-0.31105101108551025,
1.1986641883850098,
0.2402033805847168,
0.5855122804641724,
0.6934818029403687,
0.7640334367752075,
0.39791780710220337,
0.2946021556854248,
-0.24311266839504242,
-0.1510741263628006,
0.43036335706710815,
-0.4506942331790924,
-0.5028524994850159,
-0.37523022294044495,
-0.34044718742370605,
0.2660875618457794,
0.683993935585022,
0.13361088931560516,
0.19542208313941956,
-0.11971814185380936,
0.5085360407829285,
-0.5204393267631531,
0.565829336643219,
-0.8183766603469849,
0.062193166464567184,
-0.326212078332901,
-0.28185757994651794,
-0.3556141257286072,
-0.3283247649669647,
0.6094188690185547,
-0.458790123462677,
0.4367203414440155,
0.10005073249340057,
0.9647831320762634,
0.5650071501731873,
-0.390929251909256,
-0.5421507358551025,
-0.5854304432868958,
0.7264569401741028,
-0.1338886320590973,
0.8052292466163635,
-0.02294113300740719,
0.5627491474151611,
-0.4344320297241211,
-1.0275784730911255,
-0.5822415351867676,
-0.17274124920368195,
-0.0577675960958004,
0.007869351655244827,
-0.29339727759361267,
0.21045102179050446,
-0.03589355945587158,
0.4803897738456726,
-0.1730937510728836,
0.29312270879745483,
-0.5263938307762146,
-0.15405665338039398,
0.3435910940170288,
-0.159189373254776,
0.6980919241905212,
-0.16629232466220856,
-0.29751673340797424,
-0.2949582636356354,
-0.49757736921310425,
-0.13022710382938385,
0.29243871569633484,
0.46316641569137573,
0.10160159319639206,
0.525530219078064,
0.2055629938840866,
0.575101912021637,
-0.002447085687890649,
-0.11781703680753708,
0.012117340229451656,
0.36300185322761536,
-0.4501722753047943,
0.3671073615550995,
1.0804038047790527,
0.2964261472225189,
0.3833951950073242,
-0.8695175051689148,
0.10238303989171982,
0.42213040590286255,
0.027334315702319145,
-0.6986613869667053,
-0.6201314926147461,
0.10425711423158646,
-0.13481460511684418,
-0.5175197124481201,
0.5233299732208252,
-0.8089891672134399,
-0.05398799851536751,
-0.4469916820526123,
-0.22128713130950928,
0.0400717593729496,
-0.1898372322320938,
-0.14684800803661346,
-0.4857442080974579,
0.4283609986305237,
0.1387115865945816,
-0.5140292644500732,
0.8980076313018799,
0.5629109144210815,
0.5856790542602539,
-0.7572967410087585,
-0.08104131370782852,
-0.534491240978241,
0.19937902688980103,
0.10996107757091522,
0.9277355670928955,
-0.3828074038028717,
-0.500849187374115,
-0.38813671469688416,
0.46886637806892395,
-0.027954813092947006,
-0.45811477303504944,
0.5068260431289673,
-0.7318170666694641,
0.6043456792831421,
-0.13226573169231415,
-0.3281637132167816,
-0.17631028592586517,
0.2320701628923416,
-1.2276496887207031,
1.1718815565109253,
0.18776285648345947,
-1.0552886724472046,
0.24856506288051605,
-0.7436189651489258,
-0.2712080180644989,
0.2636134624481201,
-0.31815531849861145,
-0.06705750524997711,
-0.1933009773492813,
-0.0086606340482831,
0.4537406861782074,
-0.5776477456092834,
0.655175507068634,
-0.21183280646800995,
0.12361173331737518,
0.133895143866539,
-0.24988123774528503,
0.8124045133590698,
-0.0034996250178664923,
-0.16839343309402466,
0.09301602840423584,
-1.0692811012268066,
-0.07139831781387329,
0.05475195497274399,
-0.27909600734710693,
-0.5320029854774475,
0.039933376014232635,
0.5000482797622681,
0.6519705653190613,
0.37557029724121094,
-0.6624996662139893,
-0.08354835212230682,
-0.6385358572006226,
0.2383003979921341,
0.2292308360338211,
0.294540673494339,
0.6468167304992676,
0.2160620391368866,
0.6177107691764832,
-0.16977907717227936,
-0.25550636649131775,
0.2255791276693344,
-0.2566183805465698,
-1.2123808860778809,
0.05092834681272507,
0.6761811375617981,
0.9574649333953857,
-0.8070072531700134,
0.5552751421928406,
-0.2544122636318207,
-0.5850265026092529,
-0.24124020338058472,
-0.07555470615625381,
0.3406889736652374,
0.7608993649482727,
0.643353283405304,
-0.2765636146068573,
-0.8990560173988342,
-0.8739225268363953,
-0.08359336107969284,
-0.08473169803619385,
-0.21162272989749908,
0.2172877937555313,
0.3756289780139923,
-0.2268042266368866,
1.0769143104553223,
-0.4082657992839813,
-0.4036792814731598,
-0.33263900876045227,
-0.05399202182888985,
0.06236434355378151,
0.3416188657283783,
0.5558232069015503,
-0.8885047435760498,
-0.4207572340965271,
0.37977808713912964,
-0.7384016513824463,
-0.056777942925691605,
0.18924465775489807,
-0.19971340894699097,
-0.1280374526977539,
0.8026279211044312,
-0.39948418736457825,
0.248792365193367,
0.462801069021225,
-0.10805609077215195,
0.2669053375720978,
0.05330445244908333,
-0.3008692264556885,
-1.3039575815200806,
0.015927499160170555,
0.25663667917251587,
-0.20376519858837128,
-0.542999267578125,
-0.03435668349266052,
-0.07561448216438293,
0.2833101153373718,
-0.8209781646728516,
0.7459844946861267,
-0.5786139965057373,
0.010847113095223904,
-0.2637474536895752,
0.34785327315330505,
-0.04411737620830536,
0.31804701685905457,
0.4879341125488281,
0.4888911545276642,
0.5338984131813049,
-0.8523030877113342,
0.4278523623943329,
0.17926812171936035,
0.2051728367805481,
0.6809369325637817,
-1.043675184249878,
0.08917926996946335,
-0.1134936511516571,
-0.06686685979366302,
-0.39303627610206604,
-0.2904227674007416,
0.29770928621292114,
-0.4079831838607788,
0.2552712857723236,
-0.41482430696487427,
-0.47069039940834045,
-0.44623398780822754,
-0.028542427346110344,
0.07249540835618973,
-0.17461615800857544,
-0.5779628157615662,
0.6842862963676453,
0.6559206247329712,
-0.1338743269443512,
-0.7887015342712402,
-0.8223483562469482,
0.14083926379680634,
-0.40185195207595825,
-0.34971749782562256,
0.41181495785713196,
0.2930543124675751,
-0.42611995339393616,
0.2310411036014557,
-0.4283912777900696,
-0.6688588857650757,
0.18684399127960205,
0.612767219543457,
0.6080108880996704,
-0.2634804844856262,
0.3935988247394562,
0.158443883061409,
-0.16259263455867767,
0.31352174282073975,
-0.08227875083684921,
0.6671093106269836,
-0.1399277299642563,
0.055497393012046814,
-0.26309508085250854,
-0.014681914821267128,
0.4666816294193268,
-0.18619345128536224,
0.773256242275238,
0.36422041058540344,
-0.6101306080818176,
-0.08780615031719208,
-0.5177041292190552,
0.043925829231739044,
-0.4378996789455414,
0.30728793144226074,
-0.7039158344268799,
-0.7771739959716797,
0.6512376666069031,
-0.1129644513130188,
0.00008167704072548077,
0.6505595445632935,
0.15386418998241425,
0.07950977981090546,
0.42873167991638184,
1.174092173576355,
-0.30793553590774536,
0.526506245136261,
-0.2730679214000702,
0.39810171723365784,
-0.7563016414642334,
-0.5793145895004272,
-0.8637422919273376,
-0.2979983985424042,
-0.8018984198570251,
-0.08192092180252075,
-0.21623370051383972,
-0.014668125659227371,
-0.05444296449422836,
1.2201508283615112,
-0.5800029039382935,
0.5926855802536011,
0.33130741119384766,
-0.22864502668380737,
0.41633567214012146,
-0.5173585414886475,
-0.05118681862950325,
-0.07995086163282394,
-0.42618733644485474,
-0.7546887993812561,
0.5878931879997253,
0.24405378103256226,
0.401672899723053,
-0.12253086268901825,
0.9760763645172119,
-0.06304418295621872,
0.3883945643901825,
-1.33670973777771,
0.4504285752773285,
0.09297143667936325,
-0.3389900326728821,
-0.1394638568162918,
-0.20937199890613556,
-1.3697471618652344,
0.1278316229581833,
-0.22438260912895203,
-1.046321988105774,
0.5635272860527039,
-0.11036455631256104,
0.04035163298249245,
0.18506643176078796,
-0.645821213722229,
1.1384793519973755,
-0.33372801542282104,
-0.0192244965583086,
0.23101796209812164,
-0.6974172592163086,
0.21803218126296997,
-0.018911905586719513,
-0.02672683633863926,
-0.06066453456878662,
-0.272981196641922,
0.7443310022354126,
-0.2713741362094879,
0.33247488737106323,
-0.014074095524847507,
-0.019513580948114395,
0.054086361080408096,
0.3685039281845093,
0.1308751106262207,
0.23317307233810425,
-0.044114451855421066,
-0.008541579358279705,
0.24704505503177643,
0.11757419258356094,
-0.5989195704460144,
0.9644241333007812,
-0.4559098184108734,
-0.02208661660552025,
-0.5350080132484436,
-0.4885648488998413,
-0.04264727607369423,
0.6466081738471985,
0.06603370606899261,
0.15530405938625336,
-0.6289704442024231,
0.18658936023712158,
0.5800231099128723,
-0.17316000163555145,
0.6641988158226013,
0.38485515117645264,
-0.35338589549064636,
-0.29061415791511536,
0.7271859645843506,
-0.040537964552640915,
-0.11606127768754959,
0.77322918176651,
-0.19297045469284058,
-0.4300668239593506,
-0.34398484230041504,
-0.11316782981157303,
0.2800271213054657,
-0.5185337662696838,
-0.37009724974632263,
-1.0807907581329346,
-0.26721277832984924,
0.13454113900661469,
-0.13093644380569458,
-0.42585718631744385,
-0.5854795575141907,
-0.3144596219062805,
-0.2517656683921814,
0.15571868419647217,
0.61805260181427,
0.5942110419273376,
0.537187933921814,
-0.6460534334182739,
0.4225108325481415,
0.2209445685148239,
0.16890670359134674,
-0.13666409254074097,
0.22516664862632751,
0.35003480315208435,
-0.46717149019241333,
-0.23188777267932892,
-1.069758653640747,
0.6063364744186401,
0.10102182626724243,
0.47024428844451904,
0.4236161410808563,
0.04518182575702667,
0.6454477310180664,
-0.2540590167045593,
0.32795900106430054,
0.22731101512908936,
-0.6546643972396851,
0.7906391620635986,
-0.14394718408584595,
-0.17662110924720764,
0.8099060654640198,
0.39379584789276123,
-0.5722247362136841,
-0.549258291721344,
-1.0204845666885376,
-0.8920238018035889,
0.5055252313613892,
0.11511323601007462,
-0.19305294752120972,
-0.5029511451721191,
0.013197798281908035,
-0.07574154436588287,
0.3291620910167694,
-1.0161421298980713,
-0.4511958360671997,
0.11821424216032028,
-0.41802749037742615,
0.2939707040786743,
0.1282871514558792,
0.4290628135204315,
-0.11698921024799347,
0.6489711999893188,
0.07975569367408752,
0.019156277179718018,
0.2516203820705414,
-0.40040621161460876,
0.15281134843826294,
0.43495360016822815,
-0.31995517015457153,
0.44009751081466675,
-0.16944241523742676,
0.2733059227466583,
0.19736641645431519,
-0.32264891266822815,
-0.19117645919322968,
0.3661426901817322,
0.047347236424684525,
0.14590473473072052,
-0.018157701939344406,
0.35554811358451843,
0.6288261413574219,
-0.5375816822052002,
0.44676482677459717,
-0.3920034170150757,
0.04847211763262749,
-0.7569699287414551,
0.1771116703748703,
0.2522386312484741,
0.09606962651014328,
0.11669494956731796,
0.3389965295791626,
0.4882638156414032,
-0.4486157298088074,
0.2886809706687927,
0.32023584842681885,
-0.7704528570175171,
-0.23803134262561798,
0.7487221360206604,
0.10265763849020004,
-0.5638383030891418,
0.49722492694854736,
-0.16107331216335297,
-0.39996659755706787,
0.8173890113830566,
0.46240469813346863,
0.781777024269104,
0.12999339401721954,
0.21842311322689056,
0.43310192227363586,
0.1183713749051094,
-0.4469585120677948,
-0.07181756943464279,
-0.31635794043540955,
-0.8340171575546265,
-0.4171907901763916,
-0.4996749460697174,
-0.40886446833610535,
0.1289122849702835,
-0.9299277663230896,
0.8643388152122498,
-0.3789195120334625,
-0.12354052066802979,
0.43143340945243835,
0.01388769131153822,
-1.068014144897461,
-0.0020303153432905674,
-0.08120214194059372,
1.060235857963562,
-0.5925225615501404,
1.1136388778686523,
0.7210556864738464,
-0.6067506670951843,
-0.9047657251358032,
-0.24637573957443237,
-0.17135103046894073,
-0.40842804312705994,
0.7849485278129578,
0.3253510594367981,
-0.4665980637073517,
0.15454821288585663,
-0.22109100222587585,
-0.8968377709388733,
1.0806578397750854,
0.3739786446094513,
-0.7030095458030701,
-0.33514404296875,
-0.13078399002552032,
0.8259451985359192,
-0.26891839504241943,
0.2765943706035614,
0.832658052444458,
0.603001058101654,
-0.15959709882736206,
-0.9444693922996521,
-0.08568605035543442,
-0.4089474678039551,
-0.073947474360466,
0.7123138308525085,
-0.2072976529598236,
0.3141638934612274,
0.1315411925315857,
-0.5707674026489258,
0.04708356037735939,
0.7990350127220154,
-0.06594930589199066,
0.34267497062683105,
0.44579121470451355,
0.4837639331817627,
0.8717154860496521,
-0.38709715008735657,
0.7761781811714172,
-0.31101134419441223,
0.04874715209007263,
1.5294532775878906,
-0.03794167935848236,
0.8290219306945801,
0.895332932472229,
-0.10901321470737457,
0.8510794043540955,
0.3585642874240875,
-0.22780677676200867,
0.2476218193769455,
0.1706821173429489,
-0.21678049862384796,
0.236517533659935,
-0.2766207456588745,
-0.04459846764802933,
0.48481202125549316,
0.45000967383384705,
-0.6147147417068481,
-0.2476292997598648,
-0.20346342027187347,
0.1684741973876953,
0.23843318223953247,
-0.17361420392990112,
0.7939398288726807,
0.14153838157653809,
-0.6338683366775513,
-0.20173874497413635,
-0.11177545040845871,
0.7530034184455872,
-0.13240601122379303,
0.0008322906214743853,
0.3678959608078003,
0.037071023136377335,
-0.4035065472126007,
-0.702843427658081,
0.4264110028743744,
0.011054374277591705,
-0.3602261245250702,
0.17215633392333984,
0.8874141573905945,
-0.46866321563720703,
-0.49187612533569336,
0.7082226276397705,
1.0490769147872925,
0.31415843963623047,
-0.03519773855805397,
-0.5675740838050842,
-0.323280930519104,
-0.20246993005275726,
0.07330989837646484,
0.08687587827444077,
0.5757156610488892,
-0.26209354400634766,
0.740049421787262,
0.59566330909729,
0.20968738198280334,
0.18455924093723297,
0.4413433372974396,
0.7602093815803528,
-0.7106029987335205,
-0.06707669794559479,
-0.7748189568519592,
0.38166454434394836,
-0.387491375207901,
-0.1945590227842331,
0.5824976563453674,
0.6685658097267151,
1.0287986993789673,
-0.11088039726018906,
0.6478574872016907,
-0.5544047951698303,
0.42538177967071533,
0.08782288432121277,
0.2810591757297516,
0.2045627385377884,
0.28194987773895264,
-0.4588966369628906,
-1.3195189237594604,
-0.7157540321350098,
0.5735591053962708,
-0.27177754044532776,
-0.5222700834274292,
0.8014922738075256,
0.6046726703643799,
-0.23170669376850128,
-0.1497899293899536,
-0.03971050679683685,
-0.29721659421920776,
0.2879890203475952,
0.4326426684856415,
0.6955132484436035,
-0.7000415921211243,
0.6122533679008484,
-0.5839758515357971,
0.11401059478521347,
0.3453737795352936,
-0.9593923091888428,
-1.2430719137191772,
-0.49561578035354614,
-0.36129191517829895,
0.07782263308763504,
-0.006830740720033646,
1.2304434776306152,
0.3813140392303467,
-1.0073814392089844,
-0.1981469690799713,
-0.6694133281707764,
0.3387143611907959,
0.08421748131513596,
-0.37640994787216187,
0.34863296151161194,
-0.291000634431839,
-1.013861060142517,
0.42086663842201233,
0.17125099897384644,
0.19922009110450745,
-0.1944097876548767,
0.0025110619608312845,
0.008898396044969559,
-0.4126039445400238,
0.5011935234069824,
0.6069450378417969,
-0.6234201788902283,
-0.09017310291528702,
0.14961940050125122,
0.04331609234213829,
0.04188822954893112,
0.6236064434051514,
-1.0605428218841553,
0.2698066830635071,
0.3867321312427521,
0.6284851431846619,
0.40780869126319885,
-0.22452174127101898,
0.6411718726158142,
-0.7251349091529846,
0.34684380888938904,
0.24412935972213745,
0.540564239025116,
0.2727775573730469,
-0.459392249584198,
0.674390971660614,
-0.18107429146766663,
-0.4414076805114746,
-0.7769520282745361,
0.05638096481561661,
-1.621707797050476,
0.19508470594882965,
0.683925986289978,
0.1727152168750763,
-0.3286624252796173,
-0.43583565950393677,
-0.4374855160713196,
0.6347686648368835,
-0.5969642400741577,
0.625780463218689,
0.3881019055843353,
-0.09596104919910431,
-0.35030126571655273,
-0.7975943684577942,
0.4083164632320404,
-0.5598080158233643,
-0.9937703609466553,
-0.49299442768096924,
0.11057758331298828,
0.4279218018054962,
0.3917955160140991,
0.17930994927883148,
-0.4216243326663971,
0.20061300694942474,
-0.37470513582229614,
0.3428916335105896,
0.17695939540863037,
-0.41276460886001587,
0.24516436457633972,
0.22958913445472717,
0.13892413675785065,
-0.19569604098796844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10474v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10474v1
|
Rethinking ChatGPT's Success: Usability and Cognitive Behaviors Enabled by Auto-regressive LLMs' Prompting
| 2024-05-17T00:19:41 | 2024-05-17T00:19:41 |
Xinzhe Li, Ming Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Over the last decade, a wide range of training and deployment strategies for
Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged. Among these, the prompting paradigms
of Auto-regressive LLMs (AR-LLMs) have catalyzed a significant surge in
Artificial Intelligence (AI). This paper aims to emphasize the significance of
utilizing free-form modalities (forms of input and output) and verbal free-form
contexts as user-directed channels (methods for transforming modalities) for
downstream deployment. Specifically, we analyze the structure of modalities
within both two types of LLMs and six task-specific channels during deployment.
From the perspective of users, our analysis introduces and applies the
analytical metrics of task customizability, transparency, and complexity to
gauge their usability, highlighting the superior nature of AR-LLMs' prompting
paradigms. Moreover, we examine the stimulation of diverse cognitive behaviors
in LLMs through the adoption of free-form text and verbal contexts, mirroring
human linguistic expressions of such behaviors. We then detail four common
cognitive behaviors to underscore how AR-LLMs' prompting successfully imitate
human-like behaviors using this free-form modality and channel. Lastly, the
potential for improving LLM deployment, both as autonomous agents and within
multi-agent systems, is identified via cognitive behavior concepts and
principles.
|
[
-0.480378657579422,
-1.0070239305496216,
0.5620619654655457,
0.36571332812309265,
-0.16377593576908112,
0.34268295764923096,
-0.5283966064453125,
-0.18358947336673737,
-0.07462575286626816,
0.3682172894477844,
-0.7262060046195984,
-0.1958950012922287,
-0.4548530578613281,
0.010994031094014645,
-0.5259870290756226,
1.1425535678863525,
0.12405043840408325,
-0.33702999353408813,
-0.14797735214233398,
0.18098200857639313,
-0.808491051197052,
-0.5070148706436157,
-0.7665484547615051,
-0.5841716527938843,
0.7030382752418518,
0.4851714074611664,
0.9562442302703857,
0.49374133348464966,
0.25871431827545166,
0.27086177468299866,
0.16417022049427032,
0.010770373046398163,
-0.4140816032886505,
0.3265392780303955,
0.24908047914505005,
-0.6790105104446411,
-0.18954715132713318,
0.18343013525009155,
0.4944489598274231,
0.4846382737159729,
-0.5657093524932861,
-0.13356252014636993,
0.4603474736213684,
0.5225757360458374,
-0.3211287558078766,
0.21724434196949005,
-0.5832942724227905,
-0.0850638672709465,
-0.015115135349333286,
-0.2556743025779724,
-0.5181335806846619,
-0.15681906044483185,
0.07487411797046661,
-0.7683656811714172,
0.035720329731702805,
0.17919297516345978,
0.48631712794303894,
0.3446696698665619,
-0.6974833607673645,
-0.6129274368286133,
-0.9393079876899719,
0.6599437594413757,
-0.3958096206188202,
0.5870513916015625,
0.36775344610214233,
0.1591719090938568,
-0.5240880846977234,
-0.439007967710495,
-0.5148681402206421,
-0.6931031942367554,
0.05003973841667175,
0.006743907928466797,
-0.38705527782440186,
0.05407554283738136,
-0.1340387910604477,
0.1499442160129547,
-0.5604591369628906,
0.19231180846691132,
-0.07492953538894653,
-0.16995228826999664,
0.5589035153388977,
0.16886775195598602,
0.5491101741790771,
-0.07733243703842163,
-0.5606050491333008,
-0.15377400815486908,
-0.6389726996421814,
0.21009814739227295,
0.23907822370529175,
0.3123328387737274,
-0.24707859754562378,
0.5418046116828918,
-0.14847233891487122,
0.40261730551719666,
0.12389645725488663,
0.1499321311712265,
0.013230440206825733,
-0.34343263506889343,
-0.2857660949230194,
-0.2991011440753937,
1.0156587362289429,
0.13672083616256714,
0.5265584588050842,
-0.13996551930904388,
-0.25913935899734497,
-0.07573921978473663,
0.7327713966369629,
-0.11520220339298248,
-0.31974661350250244,
0.07676775008440018,
-0.45362332463264465,
-0.3018592894077301,
-0.4300508499145508,
-0.5531900525093079,
-0.31189626455307007,
-0.3877010941505432,
0.528658390045166,
-0.6317534446716309,
-0.25782454013824463,
-0.09002294391393661,
0.05751406401395798,
0.4246838092803955,
0.4760152995586395,
-1.0375609397888184,
0.2790030837059021,
0.7200643420219421,
0.7098208665847778,
-0.2824389636516571,
-0.34209755063056946,
-0.0702340304851532,
0.10024891793727875,
-0.39039966464042664,
0.9365538358688354,
-0.3219647705554962,
-0.7412813901901245,
0.11837183684110641,
-0.23969587683677673,
-0.44442227482795715,
-0.393159955739975,
0.35074952244758606,
-0.5783659815788269,
0.34556037187576294,
-0.248249351978302,
-0.31921902298927307,
-0.237815260887146,
0.38790008425712585,
-0.19808296859264374,
0.8898828625679016,
0.016984451562166214,
-0.12931297719478607,
0.42287641763687134,
-0.8502312898635864,
-0.33634668588638306,
0.20700055360794067,
-0.304292768239975,
-0.024238351732492447,
0.11285286396741867,
0.02731597051024437,
0.3836422562599182,
-0.1478220671415329,
0.10387704521417618,
0.1898120492696762,
-0.1646323800086975,
0.33412376046180725,
-0.8137945532798767,
0.7820715308189392,
0.4051453471183777,
-0.44997525215148926,
0.2001965045928955,
-0.3149825632572174,
0.15807689726352692,
0.038740113377571106,
-0.5285139083862305,
-0.09838034957647324,
0.40050703287124634,
-0.15240378677845,
0.11036095768213272,
-0.028690673410892487,
-0.12389948219060898,
0.30280327796936035,
-0.1632312387228012,
0.607548713684082,
0.7342188954353333,
0.21472012996673584,
0.633112370967865,
-0.4407753646373749,
0.649921715259552,
-0.2360454648733139,
0.5372524261474609,
-0.1564047634601593,
-0.6417126655578613,
-0.5442111492156982,
-0.517819881439209,
-0.370915025472641,
0.6756536364555359,
-0.4434387683868408,
0.0976041853427887,
-0.014672648161649704,
-0.6604982614517212,
-0.12358089536428452,
0.38138097524642944,
0.21573308110237122,
0.3618582487106323,
0.08339234441518784,
-0.4195443391799927,
-0.17464005947113037,
-0.7408459186553955,
-0.13309098780155182,
-0.5964550971984863,
0.05961287021636963,
0.2980615198612213,
0.12309305369853973,
-0.5996858477592468,
0.8212268352508545,
0.00148014014121145,
-0.132238507270813,
-0.33659881353378296,
0.37923550605773926,
-0.1459542214870453,
0.42731034755706787,
0.26826024055480957,
-0.537375271320343,
-0.23796282708644867,
-0.40258097648620605,
-0.60317063331604,
-0.15618310868740082,
-0.19371631741523743,
-0.044722359627485275,
0.30242758989334106,
0.5734618306159973,
-0.8027030825614929,
0.4172304570674896,
0.4490131139755249,
-0.2586108446121216,
0.5381115078926086,
-0.3246726095676422,
0.2964017689228058,
-0.8031446933746338,
-0.23386184871196747,
-0.3319014608860016,
0.08857861906290054,
-0.5253629088401794,
-0.12328553199768066,
-0.1797429621219635,
-0.11692896485328674,
-0.38070517778396606,
0.3220820724964142,
-0.5773158073425293,
-0.02093147300183773,
-0.2063363790512085,
0.2213723063468933,
-0.19299304485321045,
0.48300692439079285,
-0.3543892502784729,
0.9992502927780151,
0.3704812526702881,
-0.8953315615653992,
0.3920881450176239,
0.35456791520118713,
0.010056443512439728,
0.6635915637016296,
-0.7359880208969116,
0.07946478575468063,
-0.1273965686559677,
0.3105681836605072,
-1.497472882270813,
-0.23286478221416473,
0.2703690528869629,
-0.40995216369628906,
0.023842640221118927,
-0.027315964922308922,
-0.40838104486465454,
-0.06930697709321976,
-0.20054522156715393,
0.40829578042030334,
0.8034685850143433,
-0.23402976989746094,
0.5250581502914429,
0.16049805283546448,
-0.19491223990917206,
-0.18263153731822968,
-0.6747995615005493,
0.4471783936023712,
-0.22112934291362762,
-0.6048819422721863,
0.027572089806199074,
-0.2712787687778473,
-0.2079840898513794,
-0.2519780099391937,
0.2675572335720062,
0.18236076831817627,
0.3949776589870453,
0.3332621157169342,
0.39897656440734863,
-0.18461787700653076,
0.058848243206739426,
-0.290351003408432,
-0.13393187522888184,
0.1849256306886673,
-0.2309103012084961,
0.616317868232727,
-0.22638852894306183,
-0.6581184267997742,
-0.5542698502540588,
0.3992060720920563,
0.4792022705078125,
-0.1523052304983139,
0.43094056844711304,
0.6144660711288452,
0.09219730645418167,
-0.06440305709838867,
-0.5917062163352966,
-0.2580701410770416,
-0.47528597712516785,
0.06657082587480545,
0.06517918407917023,
-0.9600040316581726,
0.3574579358100891,
-0.10374993085861206,
0.4029604196548462,
0.12674763798713684,
0.7259788513183594,
-0.451202392578125,
1.1584601402282715,
0.7658033967018127,
0.12039928883314133,
0.7857493162155151,
-0.09194822609424591,
0.348862886428833,
-0.7811635732650757,
-0.5175098776817322,
-0.41955289244651794,
-0.08537464588880539,
-0.7554317712783813,
-0.30381497740745544,
0.43148091435432434,
0.04565834254026413,
-0.4180498719215393,
0.16351456940174103,
-0.4204248785972595,
0.021080104634165764,
0.7559473514556885,
-0.2039157897233963,
0.38659006357192993,
0.12162914872169495,
-0.14209656417369843,
0.22374562919139862,
-0.7708871960639954,
-0.7707574963569641,
0.912559986114502,
0.28447702527046204,
1.0035444498062134,
0.29816901683807373,
0.7080762982368469,
0.6314354538917542,
0.3595495820045471,
-1.0844511985778809,
0.6937736868858337,
0.2042752504348755,
-0.3534148037433624,
-0.3327464163303375,
0.05094904452562332,
-1.3602242469787598,
0.06848210096359253,
-0.22688694298267365,
-0.8807980418205261,
0.11521196365356445,
0.3116745352745056,
-0.30129027366638184,
-0.15083321928977966,
-1.0201765298843384,
0.673422634601593,
-0.316026896238327,
-0.025132540613412857,
-0.4096028804779053,
-0.4038379490375519,
0.15496210753917694,
0.21409207582473755,
0.4466403126716614,
-0.16404177248477936,
-0.4333908259868622,
0.4905264973640442,
-0.11115297675132751,
1.0818239450454712,
-0.029257601127028465,
-0.2573032081127167,
0.38572683930397034,
0.40784573554992676,
0.638927698135376,
-0.12924230098724365,
0.360023558139801,
-0.07622040808200836,
-0.21803471446037292,
-0.3434571325778961,
-0.7935120463371277,
0.5916083455085754,
-0.9349061846733093,
-0.7494882345199585,
-0.17413266003131866,
-0.4542114734649658,
-0.4898819029331207,
0.06612802296876907,
0.18069472908973694,
0.377058207988739,
-0.3011596202850342,
0.012288212776184082,
0.8597961068153381,
-0.06438768655061722,
0.6962199211120605,
0.43986549973487854,
-0.16124305129051208,
-0.39664357900619507,
0.6952997446060181,
-0.053100284188985825,
0.4447159469127655,
-0.0419815294444561,
-0.00012949187657795846,
-0.36142516136169434,
-0.5952561497688293,
-0.3847651183605194,
0.15430793166160583,
-0.4237918257713318,
0.10014404356479645,
-0.47294390201568604,
-0.1563291847705841,
-0.3129519522190094,
-0.4106847047805786,
-0.28997406363487244,
-0.14034946262836456,
-0.31364166736602783,
0.14795364439487457,
0.26919469237327576,
1.11134934425354,
-0.13264136016368866,
0.5388135313987732,
-0.6896716356277466,
0.03875061869621277,
0.466869592666626,
0.30416324734687805,
0.21434001624584198,
-0.4639497995376587,
-0.09153129905462265,
0.18984179198741913,
-0.4555661976337433,
-0.7544992566108704,
0.2465648353099823,
0.1988859921693802,
0.8522400259971619,
0.054709646850824356,
-0.16305632889270782,
0.3665979504585266,
-0.4647316038608551,
1.1690304279327393,
-0.05898893624544144,
-0.5567581057548523,
0.5782414078712463,
-0.6920111775398254,
0.2753904163837433,
0.26952895522117615,
0.41796934604644775,
-0.8818626403808594,
-0.5020087361335754,
-0.6382880210876465,
-0.9299819469451904,
0.5090932250022888,
0.16265307366847992,
0.5241849422454834,
-0.21241217851638794,
0.34279027581214905,
-0.0748506709933281,
0.2256404459476471,
-0.4984172582626343,
-0.31024348735809326,
-0.4029829502105713,
-0.200419619679451,
-0.18679356575012207,
-0.2249280959367752,
-0.1310538351535797,
0.2264450192451477,
0.6317150592803955,
-0.12252532690763474,
0.7394375801086426,
0.2765624523162842,
-0.16232509911060333,
0.11083690822124481,
0.547419548034668,
0.6419937610626221,
0.245291605591774,
0.26464852690696716,
-0.024284765124320984,
-0.29629650712013245,
-0.3437751829624176,
0.3389970362186432,
-0.2524145245552063,
-0.225316122174263,
-0.42971017956733704,
0.16224218904972076,
0.6371989846229553,
0.26506462693214417,
-0.5597365498542786,
0.28503939509391785,
-0.04639122262597084,
-0.27016520500183105,
-0.4578166902065277,
0.41405531764030457,
-0.07071393728256226,
0.4197615385055542,
0.5724179744720459,
0.03347126767039299,
-0.041019175201654434,
-0.6877459287643433,
0.1601332128047943,
0.6571752429008484,
-0.43805599212646484,
-0.3556046783924103,
0.7087842226028442,
0.24776604771614075,
-0.7225620150566101,
0.8078194856643677,
-0.10910628736019135,
-0.21087796986103058,
0.280585378408432,
0.46836230158805847,
0.9702228903770447,
-0.13727541267871857,
0.4635104238986969,
-0.04556173086166382,
0.45251980423927307,
-0.03306129574775696,
0.1584361046552658,
-0.32512059807777405,
-0.778937578201294,
-0.40037670731544495,
-0.032552946358919144,
-0.39821428060531616,
-0.056852053850889206,
-0.3776266276836395,
-0.006898475345224142,
-0.44116657972335815,
-0.31088438630104065,
-0.27226561307907104,
-0.26231107115745544,
-0.6809650659561157,
0.025282271206378937,
0.2846853733062744,
0.8522933125495911,
-0.5878049731254578,
0.37249475717544556,
0.7631011009216309,
-0.4582391083240509,
-1.0194953680038452,
0.04512676224112511,
0.35324057936668396,
-1.1841260194778442,
0.5395357012748718,
-0.30073750019073486,
-0.08781740814447403,
0.12955060601234436,
-0.5371198654174805,
-0.9337676167488098,
1.1100465059280396,
0.25108227133750916,
-0.1264549046754837,
-0.08301124721765518,
0.10078182816505432,
0.528639554977417,
-0.34805557131767273,
0.39071059226989746,
0.2331046611070633,
0.338114470243454,
-0.036609917879104614,
-1.1294786930084229,
0.06368785351514816,
0.02877797931432724,
0.1727616786956787,
0.15876328945159912,
-0.9366393089294434,
0.4184912145137787,
-0.18936888873577118,
-0.23260025680065155,
-0.13581621646881104,
0.5413069725036621,
0.07486292719841003,
0.05380202457308769,
0.7070747017860413,
0.026290027424693108,
0.7032997012138367,
0.05816056951880455,
0.9101006388664246,
-0.16593052446842194,
-0.05447402596473694,
0.6293707489967346,
0.06916003674268723,
0.9223408102989197,
0.6201707720756531,
-0.09606528282165527,
0.9571455717086792,
0.465778112411499,
0.22002576291561127,
0.39245370030403137,
0.10527155548334122,
-0.3428707718849182,
-0.1620718091726303,
-0.20242856442928314,
0.07747659832239151,
0.6272013783454895,
0.5151006579399109,
-0.09163887053728104,
-0.4131443202495575,
0.3882707953453064,
0.08052952587604523,
-0.10873209685087204,
-0.11339552700519562,
0.9951123595237732,
0.05863126367330551,
-0.9805837869644165,
0.6762473583221436,
-0.3443719148635864,
0.7152355909347534,
-0.7529861330986023,
0.13697755336761475,
-0.17922405898571014,
-0.27325692772865295,
-0.19098640978336334,
-0.8382936120033264,
0.33140498399734497,
-0.1311805248260498,
-0.19196870923042297,
-0.5932630300521851,
0.5850244164466858,
-0.26258721947669983,
0.10738148540258408,
0.0939464271068573,
0.9539329409599304,
0.13271881639957428,
-0.03771546483039856,
-0.7592884302139282,
0.08670594543218613,
0.024829089641571045,
-0.48267194628715515,
0.45121875405311584,
0.3910937011241913,
-0.3890988528728485,
1.1835322380065918,
0.7845902442932129,
-0.11686649918556213,
0.19141457974910736,
0.10304728150367737,
0.5668907761573792,
-0.6722415685653687,
-0.2647072672843933,
-0.8533643484115601,
0.48550915718078613,
0.4354601502418518,
-0.1530953049659729,
0.734731912612915,
0.10889309644699097,
0.6396253705024719,
0.21855369210243225,
0.779778003692627,
-0.26786401867866516,
0.10721492767333984,
-0.26618802547454834,
0.520293653011322,
-0.3360038697719574,
0.42741718888282776,
-0.01249617338180542,
-0.5761639475822449,
0.06749039888381958,
0.31384122371673584,
-0.16652525961399078,
0.20135465264320374,
0.2929304540157318,
0.8609138131141663,
0.2675052583217621,
0.11249270290136337,
0.3161241114139557,
0.06631644070148468,
0.5057905316352844,
0.3814750909805298,
1.0969889163970947,
-0.050701480358839035,
0.8327730298042297,
-0.08991992473602295,
-0.44655072689056396,
-0.23871880769729614,
-0.9306572079658508,
-0.5656586289405823,
-0.750423789024353,
-0.23619478940963745,
-0.11865086108446121,
0.11201119422912598,
1.1408027410507202,
0.671567976474762,
-0.3420834243297577,
-0.42566218972206116,
-0.29840031266212463,
0.02642691135406494,
-0.1130286380648613,
-0.31002184748649597,
-0.2152509242296219,
-0.916731595993042,
-0.3677367568016052,
0.5201287269592285,
0.27312934398651123,
0.40520262718200684,
-0.5159062743186951,
0.028222139924764633,
-0.18959112465381622,
0.22916966676712036,
0.6431953310966492,
0.5236269235610962,
-0.8413669466972351,
-0.4583975672721863,
0.2521932125091553,
-0.26619404554367065,
0.019555358216166496,
0.860096275806427,
-0.9509221911430359,
0.21822352707386017,
0.31545332074165344,
0.49489980936050415,
0.0007434753933921456,
-0.09343850612640381,
0.9959536194801331,
-0.43602171540260315,
-0.1951678991317749,
0.15835487842559814,
-0.07355175167322159,
0.25902464985847473,
-0.37913498282432556,
0.35338160395622253,
0.20045900344848633,
-0.8970853686332703,
-0.5262362360954285,
0.2863903045654297,
-0.8576322793960571,
0.08601798862218857,
1.1981312036514282,
0.11889591068029404,
-0.14376430213451385,
-0.4665977954864502,
-0.4925878942012787,
0.04503219202160835,
-0.7736800909042358,
0.908236026763916,
0.7118772268295288,
-0.7563068270683289,
-0.31552574038505554,
-0.7076917886734009,
0.6469629406929016,
0.6566704511642456,
-0.5028617978096008,
0.25007113814353943,
0.3766961991786957,
0.3470529019832611,
0.09992817789316177,
0.9058472514152527,
0.11315762251615524,
0.24708105623722076,
-0.17211249470710754,
-0.057345446199178696,
-0.14715947210788727,
-0.01691991090774536,
-0.2568921148777008,
-0.19716784358024597,
0.4570992588996887,
-0.1739315688610077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13036v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13036v1
|
Can formal argumentative reasoning enhance LLMs performances?
| 2024-05-16T22:09:31 | 2024-05-16T22:09:31 |
Federico Castagna, Isabel Sassoon, Simon Parsons
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent years witnessed significant performance advancements in
deep-learning-driven natural language models, with a strong focus on the
development and release of Large Language Models (LLMs). These improvements
resulted in better quality AI-generated output but rely on resource-expensive
training and upgrading of models. Although different studies have proposed a
range of techniques to enhance LLMs without retraining, none have considered
computational argumentation as an option. This is a missed opportunity since
computational argumentation is an intuitive mechanism that formally captures
agents' interactions and the information conflict that may arise during such
interplays, and so it seems well-suited for boosting the reasoning and
conversational abilities of LLMs in a seamless manner. In this paper, we
present a pipeline (MQArgEng) and preliminary study to evaluate the effect of
introducing computational argumentation semantics on the performance of LLMs.
Our experiment's goal was to provide a proof-of-concept and a feasibility
analysis in order to foster (or deter) future research towards a fully-fledged
argumentation engine plugin for LLMs. Exploratory results using the MT-Bench
indicate that MQArgEng provides a moderate performance gain in most of the
examined topical categories and, as such, show promise and warrant further
research.
|
[
-0.4183608293533325,
-0.7373847365379333,
0.746107816696167,
-0.20279724895954132,
-0.46243414282798767,
0.3458990156650543,
-0.16423986852169037,
-0.46197980642318726,
0.061037056148052216,
0.31164059042930603,
-0.5853371620178223,
-0.5025457143783569,
-0.35898637771606445,
0.28806832432746887,
-0.3341931998729706,
0.6410539150238037,
-0.00537880277261138,
0.09722332656383514,
-0.7016497254371643,
0.17134803533554077,
-0.21187114715576172,
-0.7992399334907532,
-0.83744215965271,
-0.38689011335372925,
0.7005347609519958,
0.4113888442516327,
0.6345537304878235,
0.7828889489173889,
0.2071940302848816,
0.4619351625442505,
0.09007254987955093,
0.586289644241333,
-0.16469506919384003,
0.4862682819366455,
-0.2156457155942917,
-0.47233137488365173,
-0.19125862419605255,
-0.1536329984664917,
0.6438949108123779,
0.3500477373600006,
-0.11117924004793167,
-0.09804778546094894,
-0.05060761794447899,
0.6067301034927368,
-0.699832022190094,
0.13937969505786896,
-0.8277446031570435,
0.1256115585565567,
-0.26784446835517883,
-0.5059486627578735,
-0.3648742139339447,
-0.21219943463802338,
0.13800352811813354,
-0.5010995268821716,
-0.24699446558952332,
0.11424177139997482,
0.9272476434707642,
0.3725620210170746,
-0.1482032984495163,
-0.29824915528297424,
-0.5709636807441711,
0.5643107295036316,
-1.174015998840332,
0.23149563372135162,
-0.20868486166000366,
0.1924775242805481,
-0.25594618916511536,
-0.9133322238922119,
-0.5293137431144714,
-0.3262666165828705,
0.12892158329486847,
0.18357081711292267,
-0.2605074644088745,
0.34493041038513184,
0.385731041431427,
0.2944856286048889,
-0.3012170195579529,
0.3764156997203827,
-0.13031841814517975,
-0.27252504229545593,
0.5769636034965515,
0.39312243461608887,
0.014723596163094044,
-0.12289917469024658,
-0.2030872404575348,
0.12489365041255951,
-0.5321646928787231,
0.07331939786672592,
0.4432080388069153,
0.17555709183216095,
-0.043034300208091736,
0.44890907406806946,
-0.12642361223697662,
0.6099777817726135,
0.022643743082880974,
0.10284701734781265,
-0.15509696304798126,
-0.13624630868434906,
-0.2859862446784973,
0.05257948115468025,
0.9435503482818604,
0.11083655059337616,
0.23574687540531158,
-0.15904127061367035,
0.1072121411561966,
0.23959702253341675,
0.38315287232398987,
-0.9542255401611328,
-0.2023259997367859,
0.3458322286605835,
-0.1374979168176651,
-0.5596181750297546,
-0.20822688937187195,
-0.550525426864624,
-0.5623315572738647,
-0.5532567501068115,
-0.11963735520839691,
-0.32171159982681274,
-0.20460687577724457,
0.21196836233139038,
-0.2128247767686844,
0.37516945600509644,
0.4386143684387207,
-0.7355565428733826,
0.28004932403564453,
1.064925193786621,
0.7770971059799194,
-0.3120310306549072,
-0.13720759749412537,
-0.5734689831733704,
-0.08898080885410309,
-0.6187371611595154,
1.2971603870391846,
-0.7385892271995544,
-0.12637750804424286,
0.21985511481761932,
-0.16506971418857574,
-0.020384548231959343,
-0.6470522880554199,
1.0347973108291626,
-0.5771685242652893,
0.20783095061779022,
-0.34332597255706787,
-0.6939868927001953,
0.05812849476933479,
0.4392038583755493,
-0.31565234065055847,
0.7974840998649597,
-0.283193439245224,
-0.5235927700996399,
0.44160178303718567,
-0.6270648837089539,
-0.38606026768684387,
0.2797011733055115,
-0.42071354389190674,
-0.22124402225017548,
0.013712398707866669,
0.21748051047325134,
0.47566553950309753,
-0.5588765144348145,
0.314161092042923,
-0.4909721314907074,
-0.4015563130378723,
0.4476848840713501,
-0.4727315306663513,
0.381351500749588,
0.2218945473432541,
-0.3961431682109833,
0.09250005334615707,
-0.5166530013084412,
0.2512863874435425,
0.01272979099303484,
-0.43918928503990173,
0.09952406585216522,
0.3486863076686859,
-0.5659947991371155,
0.4756569266319275,
-0.09336712211370468,
-0.39432692527770996,
0.11140735447406769,
-0.7384253144264221,
0.5073708891868591,
0.8623319864273071,
-0.10062357783317566,
0.1930866241455078,
-0.3164305090904236,
0.6820709109306335,
0.015001293271780014,
-0.3312441408634186,
-0.23114101588726044,
-0.38506004214286804,
-0.8945361971855164,
-0.34869176149368286,
0.5122859477996826,
0.48872679471969604,
-0.8259327411651611,
0.21563954651355743,
-0.1565670520067215,
-0.245165154337883,
-0.5113967657089233,
0.02087572030723095,
0.2240058332681656,
0.38517099618911743,
-0.056263674050569534,
-0.06700064986944199,
-0.7608053684234619,
-0.9012231230735779,
-0.39096519351005554,
-0.27745670080184937,
-0.061416033655405045,
0.7536932229995728,
0.22824285924434662,
-0.07672158628702164,
0.8512665629386902,
-0.1816868633031845,
0.3893059194087982,
-0.14103998243808746,
0.16019050776958466,
0.02361913211643696,
0.10167916864156723,
0.23812967538833618,
-0.18835966289043427,
-0.11357402056455612,
0.02037401869893074,
-0.9363223314285278,
-0.5278928279876709,
-0.3175452649593353,
-0.41973793506622314,
0.36888086795806885,
0.48836013674736023,
-0.7850993275642395,
0.08679349720478058,
0.32497265934944153,
-0.0749470666050911,
0.9953929781913757,
0.05134645849466324,
0.19786834716796875,
-0.7487290501594543,
-0.17337322235107422,
-0.07427432388067245,
-0.3524465560913086,
-0.5540074110031128,
0.032354891300201416,
-0.47254154086112976,
-0.2017873376607895,
-0.6519901752471924,
0.555480420589447,
-0.054893214255571365,
0.228075310587883,
-0.5465725064277649,
0.5018793344497681,
0.18192416429519653,
0.35949233174324036,
0.31440767645835876,
0.6948544979095459,
0.6652360558509827,
-0.619417130947113,
0.38795533776283264,
-0.2871081531047821,
-0.11566051840782166,
0.5922603607177734,
-0.7908798456192017,
0.32021307945251465,
0.10702795535326004,
0.2761775553226471,
-0.9736920595169067,
-0.1870923489332199,
0.27092719078063965,
-0.3472020626068115,
0.12089983373880386,
-0.3083553910255432,
-0.329324334859848,
-0.20179933309555054,
-0.40990930795669556,
0.17099514603614807,
0.2147607058286667,
-0.6148885488510132,
0.7511093020439148,
0.1482047438621521,
-0.0720280334353447,
-0.5211987495422363,
-0.48754939436912537,
0.5188128352165222,
-0.5667318105697632,
-0.9346247911453247,
0.26645299792289734,
0.15629887580871582,
-0.4564647674560547,
-0.3117305040359497,
0.05765000730752945,
0.15018244087696075,
0.07941906154155731,
0.16892613470554352,
0.19703912734985352,
-0.39451974630355835,
0.3298902213573456,
0.15166714787483215,
-0.2321091741323471,
0.6157766580581665,
-0.3808991014957428,
0.3441537618637085,
-0.35096392035484314,
-0.4252774715423584,
-0.31100496649742126,
0.35630255937576294,
0.5455086827278137,
0.018491582944989204,
0.5469041466712952,
0.36230388283729553,
-0.20809511840343475,
-0.32917389273643494,
-0.6757190227508545,
-0.19802521169185638,
-0.5477185845375061,
0.09029361605644226,
-0.32587099075317383,
-1.0520387887954712,
0.31277215480804443,
-0.8426088094711304,
0.1667509377002716,
0.4003194570541382,
0.5873321294784546,
-0.2740177810192108,
0.9464653134346008,
-0.2637885510921478,
0.1685229241847992,
0.22776798903942108,
-0.1750289499759674,
0.33632519841194153,
-0.7049756646156311,
-0.07854489982128143,
-0.5408535599708557,
-0.12897057831287384,
-0.4915558695793152,
-0.56552654504776,
0.035676825791597366,
-0.001671994337812066,
-0.277472585439682,
-0.26336848735809326,
-0.451208233833313,
0.43537771701812744,
0.1444517821073532,
-0.2832203507423401,
0.11336155235767365,
0.18108557164669037,
-0.4683270752429962,
-0.25981011986732483,
-0.9374008774757385,
-0.9673148989677429,
0.5844793915748596,
0.402597576379776,
0.47313591837882996,
-0.03255259245634079,
0.6915839314460754,
0.5089317560195923,
0.2535684108734131,
-0.9564101099967957,
0.7829059958457947,
-0.055096015334129333,
-0.2434907704591751,
-0.01436676923185587,
-0.3462708592414856,
-0.9736872911453247,
0.5950527787208557,
-0.4826594889163971,
-0.6672469973564148,
0.14480654895305634,
0.16443316638469696,
-0.21020585298538208,
0.36515793204307556,
-0.5324488282203674,
0.8098294734954834,
-0.5077884793281555,
-0.8311527967453003,
-0.22039759159088135,
-0.21922039985656738,
0.5193862915039062,
0.09918896108865738,
0.1787748485803604,
-0.10476663708686829,
0.1598919928073883,
0.8184159398078918,
-0.5953719615936279,
0.6810758709907532,
-0.052847158163785934,
-0.21202406287193298,
0.6599982976913452,
0.08614656329154968,
0.583407998085022,
-0.008463051170110703,
-0.2574033737182617,
0.18983304500579834,
-0.05953821912407875,
-0.1855853646993637,
-0.9219569563865662,
0.7792177200317383,
-0.44486838579177856,
-1.0134612321853638,
-0.47998344898223877,
-0.3832046687602997,
-0.30360835790634155,
-0.023075994104146957,
-0.2498864382505417,
0.30635109543800354,
-0.01584542542695999,
0.18889284133911133,
0.4595436751842499,
-0.10518046468496323,
0.30895867943763733,
0.37888312339782715,
0.05870695412158966,
-0.3946972191333771,
0.8771804571151733,
-0.24371416866779327,
0.21871542930603027,
0.007572522386908531,
0.6242305040359497,
-0.5542086362838745,
-0.6627015471458435,
-0.6241693496704102,
0.17622920870780945,
-0.788561224937439,
-0.1903991401195526,
-0.602023184299469,
-0.09486699849367142,
0.025211647152900696,
-0.2643775939941406,
-0.2901226580142975,
-0.6886696815490723,
-0.16515493392944336,
0.006313845049589872,
0.19008506834506989,
0.4845276474952698,
0.08842106908559799,
0.014603235758841038,
-0.5824307799339294,
-0.05439871549606323,
0.33425062894821167,
0.26351022720336914,
0.14755363762378693,
-0.5257051587104797,
-0.18905210494995117,
0.17758558690547943,
-0.5136735439300537,
-0.6007272005081177,
0.10436584055423737,
0.15133632719516754,
0.561615526676178,
0.5692743062973022,
-0.024669766426086426,
0.9415559768676758,
-0.43519261479377747,
1.033244013786316,
-0.004504192154854536,
-0.9209900498390198,
0.47437041997909546,
-0.49172237515449524,
0.20179930329322815,
0.34180793166160583,
0.0652676373720169,
-0.24321195483207703,
-0.41139060258865356,
-0.5193483829498291,
-0.8006178140640259,
0.539776086807251,
0.14971840381622314,
0.02844432182610035,
-0.18523558974266052,
0.6130579710006714,
-0.25981247425079346,
0.11872382462024689,
-0.5278807878494263,
-0.008147817105054855,
-0.016784802079200745,
0.22074252367019653,
0.3775280714035034,
-0.2080635279417038,
-0.266888290643692,
-0.3537200093269348,
0.596837043762207,
-0.2757689654827118,
0.1346767097711563,
0.07737042009830475,
0.22755339741706848,
0.12801392376422882,
0.5988064408302307,
0.6562044024467468,
0.4471299648284912,
0.08985526114702225,
0.2645190358161926,
0.4616205096244812,
0.08555229008197784,
0.22340674698352814,
0.10304943472146988,
0.18162234127521515,
-0.08842752128839493,
0.4439152181148529,
0.6225627660751343,
0.12706713378429413,
-0.8550782203674316,
0.2229885309934616,
-0.041524264961481094,
-0.6627516150474548,
-0.052469003945589066,
0.21848240494728088,
0.4012170135974884,
0.5200005769729614,
-0.009365616366267204,
-0.06227194890379906,
0.21787427365779877,
-0.5154507160186768,
0.021036792546510696,
0.7432740330696106,
-0.14668354392051697,
0.1683351695537567,
0.4749051332473755,
0.17943722009658813,
-0.45650964975357056,
0.3565909266471863,
-0.1302061527967453,
-0.5465449094772339,
0.459785521030426,
0.49271953105926514,
0.9076619744300842,
0.20760396122932434,
0.04106117784976959,
0.07983797043561935,
0.11892279237508774,
0.19866260886192322,
0.049117568880319595,
-0.2925642728805542,
-0.6426631212234497,
-0.6782844662666321,
-0.4088982045650482,
-0.6039865016937256,
0.06432084739208221,
-0.027157777920365334,
0.15908850729465485,
-0.48906388878822327,
-0.23202626407146454,
0.03545810654759407,
0.05810471996665001,
-0.39649561047554016,
0.07194454222917557,
0.5297309756278992,
0.7050532102584839,
-0.5921974182128906,
0.38828858733177185,
0.6761752367019653,
0.0855880081653595,
-0.6611035466194153,
-0.17696309089660645,
-0.06997591257095337,
-0.3175777494907379,
0.4903869032859802,
0.024921411648392677,
-0.8830928206443787,
-0.5832647681236267,
-0.5879814028739929,
-0.5206534266471863,
0.9335709810256958,
0.8103218078613281,
-0.45135754346847534,
0.3317665159702301,
0.42183634638786316,
0.8293669819831848,
-0.7546699047088623,
0.4561789929866791,
0.5357739925384521,
0.4842584431171417,
0.43689465522766113,
-0.45773205161094666,
0.10906568914651871,
-0.43119126558303833,
-0.1319127231836319,
-0.11357174068689346,
-0.400385320186615,
0.4096733033657074,
-0.2084253579378128,
-0.4169950485229492,
-0.18380357325077057,
0.6799425482749939,
0.6688446402549744,
0.43987786769866943,
0.37850531935691833,
0.5294845700263977,
0.8785498738288879,
-0.2631334662437439,
1.2475323677062988,
-0.4029141664505005,
-0.14583225548267365,
0.985234797000885,
-0.5395578145980835,
0.730782151222229,
0.33508455753326416,
-0.1847459375858307,
0.9928363561630249,
0.7348211407661438,
0.24257966876029968,
0.06592358648777008,
0.7055305242538452,
-0.5009974241256714,
-0.7266307473182678,
-0.3679882287979126,
-0.26770541071891785,
0.4821358323097229,
0.4552704393863678,
-0.2922792136669159,
-0.028280097991228104,
-0.5773760676383972,
0.16016699373722076,
0.19277916848659515,
-0.06826494634151459,
0.7590506672859192,
0.1292930245399475,
-0.7742396593093872,
0.7827745079994202,
0.08559854328632355,
0.5585496425628662,
-0.4313755929470062,
-0.31767234206199646,
0.14662234485149384,
-0.019421106204390526,
-0.42239388823509216,
-0.6013134121894836,
0.130104199051857,
0.08617991954088211,
0.14105908572673798,
-0.04063773900270462,
1.0690312385559082,
-0.16337615251541138,
-0.4167909622192383,
0.1838487982749939,
0.6314359903335571,
0.23544281721115112,
0.09867864847183228,
-0.8734126091003418,
0.1131085753440857,
-0.37090492248535156,
0.016815122216939926,
0.24540239572525024,
0.5908564329147339,
-0.016416849568486214,
0.8142729997634888,
0.930685818195343,
0.10381723195314407,
-0.11263035982847214,
0.30516958236694336,
1.199467420578003,
-0.307799369096756,
-0.2607745826244354,
-1.2150217294692993,
0.6649183630943298,
-0.32827049493789673,
0.13283434510231018,
0.645297646522522,
0.6239711046218872,
0.2700944244861603,
0.18005311489105225,
0.7262915968894958,
0.32939988374710083,
0.09703149646520615,
-0.5054798126220703,
0.19264712929725647,
-0.24399395287036896,
0.5175749063491821,
-0.41541871428489685,
-0.5954738259315491,
-0.23977139592170715,
0.6178105473518372,
-0.44971659779548645,
0.049332454800605774,
0.7027342915534973,
0.7161721587181091,
0.0217362642288208,
0.25260186195373535,
0.22066143155097961,
0.028444336727261543,
0.6022754311561584,
0.5806109309196472,
1.3650494813919067,
-0.08801098167896271,
0.39643773436546326,
0.08293333649635315,
-0.09783168137073517,
0.15086747705936432,
-1.3338627815246582,
-1.0130494832992554,
-0.07091788202524185,
-0.5228954553604126,
-0.45893949270248413,
0.4881296753883362,
0.945839524269104,
0.704079270362854,
-0.5069471597671509,
-0.24026495218276978,
-0.08300241827964783,
0.2916257977485657,
-0.07056478410959244,
-0.25265273451805115,
0.1368831843137741,
-0.6625353097915649,
-0.32698047161102295,
0.6642003655433655,
0.32344815135002136,
-0.4212071895599365,
-0.33246126770973206,
-0.3615117371082306,
-0.2882877588272095,
0.6819093227386475,
0.8423517942428589,
0.3197338283061981,
-0.8620118498802185,
-0.1357078105211258,
-0.2253236621618271,
0.3211715817451477,
0.19578692317008972,
1.0711078643798828,
-0.9074132442474365,
0.48463788628578186,
0.3479726314544678,
0.8062066435813904,
0.4055638313293457,
0.25143054127693176,
0.6764028668403625,
-0.6323674917221069,
-0.1098160669207573,
0.14225049316883087,
0.45277485251426697,
0.23760147392749786,
-0.34784647822380066,
0.22340981662273407,
0.0834609791636467,
-0.7054388523101807,
-0.7495558261871338,
0.05489498749375343,
-0.716355562210083,
-0.03873905912041664,
1.23080313205719,
-0.16060426831245422,
0.0418352447450161,
-0.12547841668128967,
-0.36315083503723145,
0.0734502524137497,
-0.5493676066398621,
0.7777825593948364,
1.0615811347961426,
-0.4634874761104584,
-0.37613344192504883,
-0.47338011860847473,
0.6253036260604858,
0.550971269607544,
-1.1863683462142944,
0.31326064467430115,
0.6717378497123718,
-0.07026498764753342,
0.14853082597255707,
0.40954160690307617,
-0.1769062727689743,
0.3905694782733917,
-0.182432159781456,
-0.4678024351596832,
-0.28498804569244385,
-0.16167286038398743,
-0.379761666059494,
0.2881530225276947,
0.3598985970020294,
0.04506333917379379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10457v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10457v1
|
Participle-Prepended Nominals Have Lower Entropy Than Nominals Appended After the Participle
| 2024-05-16T22:05:45 | 2024-05-16T22:05:45 |
Kristie Denlinger, Stephen Wechsler, Kyle Mahowald
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
English allows for both compounds (e.g., London-made) and phrasal paraphrases
(e.g., made in London). While these constructions have roughly the same
truth-conditional meaning, we hypothesize that the compound allows less freedom
to express the nature of the semantic relationship between the participle and
the pre-participle nominal. We thus predict that the pre-participle slot is
more constrained than the equivalent position in the phrasal construction. We
test this prediction in a large corpus by measuring the entropy of
corresponding nominal slots, conditional on the participle used. That is, we
compare the entropy of $\alpha$ in compound construction slots like
$\alpha$-[V]ed to the entropy of $\alpha$ in phrasal constructions like [V]ed
by $\alpha$ for a given verb V. As predicted, there is significantly lower
entropy in the compound construction than in the phrasal construction. We
consider how these predictions follow from more general grammatical properties
and processing factors.
|
[
-0.2190951704978943,
-0.5652920603752136,
0.7915517091751099,
-0.049878377467393875,
-0.5334361791610718,
-0.011230596341192722,
-0.1718290001153946,
-0.3416811227798462,
0.36295002698898315,
0.010885428637266159,
-0.32980212569236755,
-0.06159201264381409,
-0.48435983061790466,
0.3254182040691376,
-0.21661940217018127,
0.6691821217536926,
-0.05797761306166649,
-0.07830356061458588,
-0.45470476150512695,
0.20553138852119446,
-0.1869908720254898,
-1.0658795833587646,
-0.13150447607040405,
-0.23310299217700958,
0.8837722539901733,
0.14124774932861328,
1.0869207382202148,
0.6163996458053589,
0.40177515149116516,
0.4906723201274872,
0.10621543228626251,
-0.1884198635816574,
0.044120777398347855,
0.1291700303554535,
-0.26701706647872925,
-0.6612672209739685,
-0.2936437129974365,
0.27277886867523193,
0.5164324641227722,
0.7860645651817322,
-0.12663286924362183,
-0.1480948030948639,
0.09268175810575485,
0.29211726784706116,
-0.7562698721885681,
0.01894284039735794,
-0.8963477611541748,
-0.2235603630542755,
-0.5276427268981934,
-0.5117052793502808,
-0.212448388338089,
-0.278835654258728,
0.1263890564441681,
-0.6704666018486023,
0.3775159418582916,
0.25121238827705383,
1.209453821182251,
0.1940845102071762,
-0.04332371801137924,
-0.19361881911754608,
-0.588982105255127,
0.5621793270111084,
-0.6396154761314392,
0.5220608115196228,
0.560377299785614,
-0.24018213152885437,
-0.2573224902153015,
-0.9221991300582886,
-1.0617005825042725,
-0.2584443986415863,
-0.38053834438323975,
0.07703360915184021,
0.23040521144866943,
0.3419751524925232,
0.03540040925145149,
0.5743054747581482,
-0.7709201574325562,
-0.013753484934568405,
-0.578661322593689,
-0.23745499551296234,
0.2847018837928772,
-0.03652046248316765,
0.3182797133922577,
-0.5661556124687195,
-0.44332683086395264,
-0.1456296443939209,
-0.7300519943237305,
0.011564583517611027,
0.5436983108520508,
0.4298155605792999,
0.10957331955432892,
0.8230721950531006,
0.3204926550388336,
0.30218204855918884,
0.1698630303144455,
-0.31191569566726685,
0.4502224326133728,
-0.6228095889091492,
-0.31727856397628784,
0.2565464377403259,
0.6431010365486145,
0.23117727041244507,
0.13272912800312042,
-0.06825198978185654,
0.12443922460079193,
0.21758849918842316,
-0.021955888718366623,
-0.6144740581512451,
-0.5989058613777161,
0.23916545510292053,
-0.12444289028644562,
0.22423359751701355,
0.5906582474708557,
-0.002703872974961996,
-0.020500585436820984,
-0.5715569853782654,
0.40608254075050354,
-0.5922530293464661,
0.013531209900975227,
0.37854817509651184,
-0.5177700519561768,
0.3062022924423218,
0.20358295738697052,
-0.4873879551887512,
0.04996014013886452,
1.1481516361236572,
0.8041507601737976,
-0.04272233694791794,
-0.8392053842544556,
-0.2154756635427475,
0.10056012123823166,
-0.14251022040843964,
1.0309096574783325,
-0.6962650418281555,
-0.39111706614494324,
-0.24978730082511902,
0.31947290897369385,
-0.2555205821990967,
-0.6339573264122009,
0.4406849145889282,
-0.3013337254524231,
0.8415375351905823,
-0.41449296474456787,
-0.5518910884857178,
-0.08948438614606857,
-0.07148168981075287,
-0.4553435146808624,
0.4901524484157562,
0.10481766611337662,
-0.7137435078620911,
0.6771143078804016,
0.16790688037872314,
-0.6931811571121216,
0.0843789130449295,
-0.25916317105293274,
-0.11031942069530487,
0.3182930648326874,
-0.3989573121070862,
0.1265297681093216,
-0.24317246675491333,
0.21359878778457642,
-0.5139205455780029,
-0.21938389539718628,
0.5929578542709351,
-0.2530612051486969,
0.2716841399669647,
0.14282134175300598,
0.0976414754986763,
-0.2231828272342682,
-0.5262706279754639,
-0.2848271429538727,
-0.3378587067127228,
-0.46428054571151733,
-0.6847470998764038,
0.2202007919549942,
-0.39967286586761475,
0.22739319503307343,
0.26121652126312256,
-0.8458932638168335,
0.2161751687526703,
-0.6671321988105774,
0.37903374433517456,
1.0219783782958984,
0.1951688677072525,
0.6659112572669983,
-0.4932475686073303,
0.6036415100097656,
0.10624478757381439,
0.10859058052301407,
0.18701399862766266,
-0.19826963543891907,
-0.44514355063438416,
-0.46287956833839417,
0.5029112100601196,
0.7158899307250977,
-0.8477153182029724,
0.4283166229724884,
-0.25177499651908875,
-0.3778954744338989,
-0.28220856189727783,
0.1576896607875824,
0.4231858551502228,
0.2749845087528229,
-0.14654949307441711,
-0.331892728805542,
-0.6152051687240601,
-0.7661091685295105,
-0.28014230728149414,
-0.6071789860725403,
-0.03091387264430523,
-0.23695668578147888,
0.3763866424560547,
0.48608338832855225,
0.6280101537704468,
-0.6356320381164551,
-0.044464174658060074,
-0.08483551442623138,
0.05374341830611229,
0.46621620655059814,
0.6888271570205688,
0.603598952293396,
-0.7052557468414307,
-0.43479642271995544,
-0.33704689145088196,
-0.33132821321487427,
0.11255290359258652,
-0.16757570207118988,
-0.2269151359796524,
0.03742978721857071,
0.4939229190349579,
-1.1364284753799438,
0.5315346121788025,
0.08130146563053131,
-0.7296596169471741,
0.6043376326560974,
-0.17516516149044037,
0.006782176438719034,
-1.095497727394104,
-0.30041468143463135,
-0.273441344499588,
-0.03991984575986862,
-0.3421207666397095,
-0.21789580583572388,
-0.2861781418323517,
-0.09757480770349503,
-0.8209081292152405,
0.19734422862529755,
-0.5306961536407471,
-0.07097683101892471,
-0.08151169121265411,
-0.27624011039733887,
0.4021568298339844,
0.517448902130127,
0.11633414030075073,
1.0244512557983398,
0.5182484984397888,
-0.9039551615715027,
0.24088427424430847,
-0.0011924289865419269,
-0.3916289508342743,
0.3963342308998108,
-0.8651313781738281,
-0.14915642142295837,
-0.42206189036369324,
0.17353695631027222,
-0.9106404781341553,
-0.28689879179000854,
-0.08921878039836884,
-0.6218980550765991,
0.34738484025001526,
0.23488815128803253,
-0.6589190363883972,
-0.2084452509880066,
-0.5495837330818176,
0.6164666414260864,
0.3949998617172241,
-0.1675494760274887,
0.20246511697769165,
0.19614297151565552,
-0.3582742214202881,
-0.20318934321403503,
-0.8556240200996399,
-0.2274036854505539,
-0.5312767028808594,
-0.5333494544029236,
0.825230598449707,
-0.23023712635040283,
-0.5685480833053589,
0.18584832549095154,
-0.22430945932865143,
-0.07575947791337967,
0.08682391047477722,
0.17967301607131958,
0.3078821301460266,
-0.1579522341489792,
0.28675270080566406,
-0.21805691719055176,
0.01296482514590025,
-0.028981946408748627,
-0.11021998524665833,
0.6335168480873108,
0.1127443015575409,
-0.25846144556999207,
-0.3259497880935669,
0.22093108296394348,
0.5901936888694763,
0.04758276045322418,
0.9450845718383789,
0.2830874025821686,
-0.298074871301651,
0.1332308053970337,
-0.18278159201145172,
-0.17583678662776947,
-0.5728034973144531,
-0.15748640894889832,
-0.6706148386001587,
-0.7303630113601685,
0.5254588723182678,
0.5525089502334595,
-0.18121886253356934,
0.5543602108955383,
0.41095101833343506,
-0.32022321224212646,
0.5240033864974976,
0.14454768598079681,
0.5128490328788757,
0.46463942527770996,
0.10889282822608948,
0.36949822306632996,
-0.6527777910232544,
-0.17777866125106812,
-0.5899311304092407,
-0.313311368227005,
-0.9560049176216125,
-0.5127332806587219,
0.5667475461959839,
0.13497623801231384,
-0.09963074326515198,
0.4875852167606354,
-0.3490515649318695,
0.5007737278938293,
0.9874163866043091,
0.07760398834943771,
-0.13258932530879974,
-0.16804061830043793,
-0.04393744841217995,
-0.1573307365179062,
-0.7232227921485901,
-0.1293984353542328,
0.6169611215591431,
-0.13120438158512115,
0.4541008770465851,
0.33519247174263,
0.6753593683242798,
0.37787842750549316,
-0.3077794015407562,
-0.6631800532341003,
0.4820896089076996,
-0.09827897697687149,
-0.6881235837936401,
-0.11265748739242554,
-0.08519937098026276,
-1.2199623584747314,
0.10634896904230118,
-0.1190524697303772,
-0.5003386735916138,
0.567847490310669,
-0.050404131412506104,
-0.6995025873184204,
0.22564862668514252,
-0.8778318166732788,
0.5648974776268005,
-0.12651023268699646,
-0.4511256814002991,
-0.039041388779878616,
-0.5193160772323608,
0.20263339579105377,
0.02459690347313881,
0.23865848779678345,
-0.2156943678855896,
-0.03501284867525101,
0.5095416903495789,
-1.3915375471115112,
0.595706582069397,
-0.11257802695035934,
0.06749608367681503,
0.48436856269836426,
0.16062502562999725,
0.1724441647529602,
-0.09603743255138397,
-0.12478560209274292,
-0.170909583568573,
0.32356205582618713,
-0.6361760497093201,
-0.7798126935958862,
0.4654002785682678,
-0.6687129139900208,
-0.8908113241195679,
-0.9005826711654663,
-0.1218523383140564,
-0.06089485436677933,
-0.26816466450691223,
0.8138262033462524,
0.631438672542572,
0.08846990764141083,
0.2798745036125183,
0.18166428804397583,
-0.4170500338077545,
0.4736923277378082,
0.30783769488334656,
0.0211850106716156,
-0.2853081226348877,
0.7082648873329163,
0.6549654006958008,
0.16403348743915558,
0.6913290619850159,
0.3533303439617157,
-0.18473103642463684,
-0.465318888425827,
0.2614489197731018,
0.35313495993614197,
-0.295389860868454,
-0.2506422698497772,
-0.1451738178730011,
-0.21408678591251373,
-0.7108374834060669,
-0.3617134690284729,
-0.12762920558452606,
-0.8993850350379944,
-0.17725861072540283,
-0.5231267809867859,
0.5051172971725464,
0.292461633682251,
-0.5968964099884033,
0.18861375749111176,
-0.6512746810913086,
0.18941840529441833,
0.486593633890152,
0.25064942240715027,
-0.4033133089542389,
-0.6662605404853821,
-0.015976501628756523,
-0.36262592673301697,
0.02227814868092537,
-0.7855212688446045,
0.13535001873970032,
0.5549705624580383,
0.30209916830062866,
0.4292316734790802,
0.33151334524154663,
0.8858344554901123,
-0.6468526721000671,
1.1563485860824585,
0.2832714915275574,
-0.8304290175437927,
0.3494628071784973,
-0.2880127727985382,
0.23479260504245758,
0.755369246006012,
0.09363701194524765,
-0.004875069949775934,
-0.5438864827156067,
-1.0017518997192383,
-1.0610092878341675,
0.06938810646533966,
0.31098756194114685,
0.28471383452415466,
-0.42669111490249634,
0.48955437541007996,
0.4592987895011902,
0.42638668417930603,
-0.6377673149108887,
-0.1257951557636261,
-0.04308342561125755,
0.25747498869895935,
-0.17354193329811096,
-0.3412936329841614,
0.5109123587608337,
-0.6180368661880493,
0.602780818939209,
0.704548716545105,
0.531410276889801,
0.5048848986625671,
0.038116615265607834,
0.21909640729427338,
0.332393616437912,
0.7307174801826477,
0.750133752822876,
-0.5552296042442322,
0.6286141872406006,
-0.006024688947945833,
-0.46896645426750183,
0.09591072052717209,
0.08929286897182465,
-0.10095611214637756,
0.40902814269065857,
0.7479586005210876,
0.7650002241134644,
0.1572287380695343,
-0.368074506521225,
0.4581613838672638,
0.1150146946310997,
-0.11771614104509354,
-0.8484185934066772,
0.10057874023914337,
-0.3766149580478668,
0.07588997483253479,
0.11721836775541306,
0.04681013897061348,
0.12240242213010788,
-1.2210005521774292,
0.27350863814353943,
0.2001892626285553,
0.1464952677488327,
-1.0233893394470215,
0.5097205638885498,
-0.10004287958145142,
-0.4332053065299988,
0.2301931530237198,
-0.5308244228363037,
-0.722195029258728,
0.07596909254789352,
0.3353150486946106,
0.734754204750061,
-0.37602025270462036,
0.08465395867824554,
0.3198928236961365,
0.3365916311740875,
0.3038577139377594,
0.7059987187385559,
-0.10295293480157852,
-0.8127860426902771,
-0.512475311756134,
-0.6685190796852112,
-0.13658036291599274,
0.1290232241153717,
-0.5035526156425476,
0.10525136440992355,
-0.45538583397865295,
-0.4548322558403015,
-0.01177314855158329,
-0.29179608821868896,
-0.6896882653236389,
0.22340410947799683,
0.0014033669140189886,
0.6016974449157715,
-0.8170808553695679,
0.9053687453269958,
0.7475926876068115,
-0.5701963901519775,
-1.0317689180374146,
0.16304419934749603,
-0.24086526036262512,
-0.3869357705116272,
0.31056487560272217,
-0.24741579592227936,
0.019439697265625,
-0.43456152081489563,
-0.2146751880645752,
-1.0065617561340332,
0.8570712208747864,
0.4786495268344879,
-0.15994082391262054,
-0.5178031325340271,
0.20975199341773987,
0.4884188771247864,
0.18863557279109955,
-0.2980964183807373,
0.4084230363368988,
0.52902752161026,
0.24677830934524536,
-1.0475804805755615,
-0.07247570902109146,
-0.2655966877937317,
-0.34712812304496765,
0.3745635151863098,
-0.5412011742591858,
1.379467487335205,
0.15323297679424286,
-0.5123634338378906,
-0.06698065251111984,
0.7811421751976013,
0.1655827909708023,
0.32078489661216736,
0.5524121522903442,
0.7328702807426453,
0.806670606136322,
-0.08222761005163193,
1.2085015773773193,
-0.4145105183124542,
-0.21939001977443695,
1.1467264890670776,
-0.2642146348953247,
0.9412446618080139,
0.796545147895813,
-0.5602531433105469,
0.9158030152320862,
0.6610103845596313,
0.5630333423614502,
0.8432255387306213,
0.2351425737142563,
-0.2351856380701065,
-0.12454728037118912,
-0.2624605596065521,
-0.3891184329986572,
0.7408263683319092,
0.4719473719596863,
-0.21431221067905426,
0.11698503792285919,
0.09709122031927109,
0.43802958726882935,
0.1284264475107193,
-0.25925418734550476,
0.7616962790489197,
0.3351813554763794,
-1.122990369796753,
0.6358518004417419,
-0.0641319528222084,
0.4450530707836151,
-0.48269250988960266,
0.5170628428459167,
-0.12651577591896057,
0.16128908097743988,
-0.14372462034225464,
-0.891829252243042,
0.6162562966346741,
-0.17327776551246643,
-0.008551136590540409,
-0.25278007984161377,
0.7338561415672302,
-0.3006913363933563,
-0.4425162672996521,
-0.18316209316253662,
0.665744960308075,
0.19643019139766693,
-0.05401652306318283,
-0.3670032322406769,
-0.2610839009284973,
-0.13646116852760315,
-0.29983580112457275,
0.3076392114162445,
0.7778486013412476,
0.4043165445327759,
-0.017780868336558342,
0.5337997674942017,
0.3536454439163208,
0.26088541746139526,
-0.1644635647535324,
0.6777365803718567,
-0.5584005117416382,
-0.5626274347305298,
-1.083918571472168,
0.4908781349658966,
0.15183842182159424,
-0.4338270127773285,
0.9976281523704529,
0.6803154349327087,
0.9340547919273376,
-0.007011732552200556,
0.6089017391204834,
-0.09925677627325058,
0.4156700372695923,
-0.8594918251037598,
0.026432378217577934,
-0.4446609616279602,
0.09996810555458069,
-0.37049856781959534,
-0.9559785723686218,
-0.07007980346679688,
0.5360564589500427,
-0.39275628328323364,
-0.4334288239479065,
1.0767266750335693,
0.7296796441078186,
-0.24569237232208252,
-0.3688034117221832,
0.2498401254415512,
0.14150360226631165,
-0.16574807465076447,
0.4631097912788391,
0.8257384896278381,
-0.14811953902244568,
0.023540187627077103,
-0.3872593641281128,
0.22674117982387543,
0.2263847142457962,
-0.9048607349395752,
-0.5792187452316284,
-1.108381748199463,
-0.4730900824069977,
-0.5820127129554749,
-0.1795080155134201,
1.0071450471878052,
0.4724788963794708,
-0.679225742816925,
-0.07255442440509796,
-0.2322600930929184,
0.14268876612186432,
0.08445750921964645,
-0.21956130862236023,
0.5158044099807739,
0.026890994980931282,
-0.5949805974960327,
0.36255908012390137,
0.16696372628211975,
0.18033061921596527,
-0.055426500737667084,
0.08367881178855896,
-0.33323249220848083,
0.6085368990898132,
0.6504259705543518,
0.3062267601490021,
-0.5821968913078308,
-0.5487614274024963,
-0.04876940697431564,
0.13479475677013397,
0.23049595952033997,
0.7746209502220154,
-0.7249106764793396,
0.0718299150466919,
1.0658060312271118,
-0.0027942301239818335,
0.23649132251739502,
0.4916996359825134,
0.869918704032898,
-1.084614634513855,
0.6100443601608276,
0.15764035284519196,
0.7149606347084045,
0.30704382061958313,
-0.28525981307029724,
0.18355868756771088,
0.5530124306678772,
-0.4151930809020996,
-0.9426150321960449,
0.6071863770484924,
-0.7417092323303223,
-0.7002685070037842,
1.195639729499817,
-0.05356362462043762,
-0.4833107590675354,
0.07476379722356796,
0.06518144905567169,
0.3681373596191406,
-0.2691977322101593,
0.5209469795227051,
0.8874377608299255,
-0.12062321603298187,
0.014279202558100224,
-0.07456673681735992,
0.6168230772018433,
0.39647287130355835,
-0.38339942693710327,
-0.29764243960380554,
0.5738030672073364,
0.07542169839143753,
0.15131862461566925,
0.5875368714332581,
0.22498200833797455,
0.19105593860149384,
-0.022350210696458817,
-0.18518604338169098,
0.14894811809062958,
-0.3795381486415863,
0.12153566628694534,
0.4399717450141907,
0.5323740243911743,
-0.40114960074424744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10452v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10452v1
|
Navigating Public Sentiment in the Circular Economy through Topic Modelling and Hyperparameter Optimisation
| 2024-05-16T21:38:21 | 2024-05-16T21:38:21 |
Junhao Song, Yingfang Yuan, Kaiwen Chang, Bing Xu, Jin Xuan, Wei Pang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
To advance the circular economy (CE), it is crucial to gain insights into the
evolution of public sentiments, cognitive pathways of the masses concerning
circular products and digital technology, and recognise the primary concerns.
To achieve this, we collected data related to the CE from diverse platforms
including Twitter, Reddit, and The Guardian. This comprehensive data collection
spanned across three distinct strata of the public: the general public,
professionals, and official sources. Subsequently, we utilised three topic
models on the collected data. Topic modelling represents a type of data-driven
and machine learning approach for text mining, capable of automatically
categorising a large number of documents into distinct semantic groups.
Simultaneously, these groups are described by topics, and these topics can aid
in understanding the semantic content of documents at a high level. However,
the performance of topic modelling may vary depending on different
hyperparameter values. Therefore, in this study, we proposed a framework for
topic modelling with hyperparameter optimisation for CE and conducted a series
of systematic experiments to ensure that topic models are set with appropriate
hyperparameters and to gain insights into the correlations between the CE and
public opinion based on well-established models. The results of this study
indicate that concerns about sustainability and economic impact persist across
all three datasets. Official sources demonstrate a higher level of engagement
with the application and regulation of CE. To the best of our knowledge, this
study is pioneering in investigating various levels of public opinions
concerning CE through topic modelling with the exploration of hyperparameter
optimisation.
|
[
-0.947952151298523,
-0.7055262923240662,
0.887138307094574,
-0.06570760905742645,
-0.4826110303401947,
-0.24408960342407227,
-0.12425868958234787,
-0.38589417934417725,
0.609447181224823,
0.8738250136375427,
-0.5058087706565857,
-0.6447188258171082,
-0.5534278750419617,
0.15120618045330048,
-0.5515375137329102,
1.1780762672424316,
0.21146559715270996,
-0.124017134308815,
-0.20609553158283234,
0.04319039732217789,
-0.03651493415236473,
-0.7423455119132996,
-0.2433033436536789,
-0.1017855852842331,
0.8167900443077087,
0.35829392075538635,
0.6995571255683899,
0.5621388554573059,
0.20861931145191193,
0.27252164483070374,
-0.5740392208099365,
0.14260262250900269,
-0.5710088610649109,
-0.2247304618358612,
-0.8783131241798401,
-0.00029078475199639797,
-0.07221385836601257,
0.3174758553504944,
0.3116469085216522,
0.5745972990989685,
-0.14369142055511475,
0.5004345774650574,
0.24317441880702972,
0.5701643228530884,
-0.8911356329917908,
0.22900040447711945,
-0.7598856091499329,
-0.32598379254341125,
0.026915229856967926,
-0.05411839857697487,
-0.008839266374707222,
-0.16804994642734528,
0.03606093302369118,
-0.6339987516403198,
0.17014414072036743,
0.10665731132030487,
0.9180275797843933,
0.03604713827371597,
-0.410031795501709,
-0.6336320638656616,
-0.8998730182647705,
1.142906904220581,
-0.42721474170684814,
0.32443493604660034,
0.2591228485107422,
0.12716296315193176,
0.12684951722621918,
-0.7148850560188293,
-0.973226010799408,
0.3129538893699646,
0.24983751773834229,
0.28910350799560547,
-0.22051484882831573,
-0.1280328929424286,
-0.05678126588463783,
0.14959780871868134,
-0.2112906277179718,
-0.3326948583126068,
-0.6388501524925232,
-0.032135698944330215,
0.5558153390884399,
0.26938632130622864,
-0.18230202794075012,
-0.4200696051120758,
-0.6397950053215027,
-0.06815450638532639,
-0.26431843638420105,
-0.2735922038555145,
0.6701904535293579,
0.37317022681236267,
-0.08143849670886993,
0.6985421180725098,
-0.4539100229740143,
0.656307578086853,
0.21178334951400757,
0.08685547858476639,
-0.059486813843250275,
-0.4503082036972046,
0.1588921993970871,
0.12928764522075653,
0.2580511271953583,
0.6343973278999329,
-0.18196187913417816,
0.29179826378822327,
-0.30783671140670776,
0.27968183159828186,
0.3795068860054016,
-0.5187103748321533,
-0.06463978439569473,
0.25909993052482605,
-0.5130810737609863,
-0.3513021469116211,
0.4360804855823517,
-1.1198234558105469,
-0.4535796046257019,
-0.8636754155158997,
0.05827667936682701,
0.7070381045341492,
-0.5028290748596191,
0.5807616114616394,
-0.027920115739107132,
0.12974941730499268,
0.44995278120040894,
-0.5201849341392517,
0.2554948925971985,
1.0979762077331543,
0.7467125058174133,
-0.09481538832187653,
0.06163385882973671,
-0.07529251277446747,
0.3840542435646057,
-0.1864011287689209,
1.1033140420913696,
-0.6599264740943909,
-0.36794981360435486,
-0.17881089448928833,
0.31438279151916504,
0.02726256102323532,
-0.3364380896091461,
0.6188313364982605,
-0.5269635319709778,
0.32304373383522034,
-0.6555699110031128,
-0.26270902156829834,
-0.5498015880584717,
0.492733895778656,
-0.6989511251449585,
0.7773845195770264,
-0.2085673063993454,
-1.2328646183013916,
0.3738572895526886,
-0.7898649573326111,
0.08600213378667831,
-0.22169460356235504,
0.057491790503263474,
-0.370619535446167,
0.23456227779388428,
0.21886354684829712,
0.36751365661621094,
-0.7444038987159729,
0.3445441424846649,
-0.7705650925636292,
-0.083283931016922,
-0.10916810482740402,
-0.5053756833076477,
0.45990049839019775,
0.34908512234687805,
-0.055443547666072845,
0.11902173608541489,
-0.4766891896724701,
-0.36710458993911743,
-0.47561731934547424,
0.052970387041568756,
-0.23863369226455688,
0.11725820600986481,
0.7355456948280334,
0.8273078203201294,
0.320322722196579,
-0.7870549559593201,
0.03689303249120712,
-0.19679993391036987,
0.9469459056854248,
0.7384868264198303,
0.8711327910423279,
-0.041259001940488815,
-0.4438965618610382,
0.24634535610675812,
0.15099163353443146,
0.3407036364078522,
0.26993420720100403,
-0.639285147190094,
-0.32838186621665955,
0.06142891198396683,
0.06147514656186104,
0.3849817216396332,
-0.22558607161045074,
0.44613713026046753,
0.2169451266527176,
-0.5718662142753601,
-0.1757456660270691,
-0.1777084469795227,
-0.0575336255133152,
0.7253518104553223,
0.12988391518592834,
-0.232728511095047,
-0.06421922892332077,
-0.7243986129760742,
-0.1323566883802414,
-0.4967188537120819,
0.1035856381058693,
0.27028757333755493,
0.635650634765625,
-0.4792743921279907,
1.0273598432540894,
-0.7761635780334473,
0.18808773159980774,
-0.10876259952783585,
0.36248958110809326,
0.5042116045951843,
0.2876545786857605,
-0.14483654499053955,
-1.2863969802856445,
-0.011065837927162647,
0.23468807339668274,
-0.26741132140159607,
0.18003936111927032,
-0.24809008836746216,
-0.32639381289482117,
0.04521995410323143,
0.10145795345306396,
-0.7730537056922913,
0.33274737000465393,
0.2549154758453369,
-0.312828004360199,
0.8635256886482239,
-0.20329856872558594,
0.27084672451019287,
-0.9601704478263855,
0.31036898493766785,
0.46015068888664246,
0.14352399110794067,
-0.34119197726249695,
-0.029405193403363228,
-0.1681947410106659,
-0.7170217633247375,
-0.8865071535110474,
0.6490819454193115,
0.05307961255311966,
-0.24625414609909058,
-0.5711194276809692,
0.03770516812801361,
0.43228209018707275,
0.42140835523605347,
0.41222286224365234,
0.6310485601425171,
0.4521811604499817,
-0.709834098815918,
0.26683369278907776,
0.13705560564994812,
-0.19817762076854706,
0.3252785801887512,
-0.7142148613929749,
0.21067282557487488,
-0.09671466052532196,
-0.02198604866862297,
-0.7259496450424194,
-0.2292899340391159,
0.2892933487892151,
-0.17204098403453827,
-0.11741980910301208,
0.10301896929740906,
-0.5182052254676819,
-0.5246042609214783,
-0.1622975617647171,
-0.05410902947187424,
0.07846023142337799,
-0.38267284631729126,
0.5099424123764038,
0.4219916760921478,
-0.25759536027908325,
-0.24502788484096527,
-0.08465883135795593,
0.07561177760362625,
-0.8138814568519592,
-0.7812144160270691,
0.12476347386837006,
0.14875559508800507,
-0.38116657733917236,
-0.06900037080049515,
-0.5324347615242004,
0.02545664831995964,
-0.010171648114919662,
0.0286855585873127,
-0.11054889857769012,
0.22058668732643127,
-0.02916010655462742,
-0.03006778098642826,
-0.6037740111351013,
0.22113633155822754,
-0.5330862998962402,
0.5199151635169983,
-0.2461492121219635,
-0.2813059389591217,
-0.7379159331321716,
0.23366516828536987,
0.9238045811653137,
-0.24227316677570343,
0.6353655457496643,
0.3221721947193146,
-0.4532201290130615,
0.17879194021224976,
-0.46598586440086365,
-0.2681715786457062,
-0.4655686914920807,
0.3102499842643738,
-0.09403427690267563,
-0.4238277077674866,
0.5173087120056152,
-0.33510321378707886,
-0.05156996473670006,
0.4731382131576538,
0.7046852707862854,
0.09898301213979721,
1.0665162801742554,
0.6355544328689575,
-0.2333919256925583,
0.06707780808210373,
-0.15653420984745026,
0.1994284987449646,
-0.6529003381729126,
-0.13387608528137207,
-0.7855129241943359,
0.35698720812797546,
-0.7438049912452698,
-0.37158337235450745,
0.2800585627555847,
0.3576204776763916,
-0.5605944991111755,
0.08806893974542618,
-0.5572656393051147,
0.31691446900367737,
0.28486913442611694,
0.5069970488548279,
0.33304333686828613,
0.022300921380519867,
0.32611629366874695,
0.32639119029045105,
-0.41661325097084045,
-1.3167643547058105,
0.7588979601860046,
0.37451058626174927,
0.5090852975845337,
-0.43376296758651733,
0.6734364628791809,
0.5498886108398438,
0.01716427132487297,
-0.4356965720653534,
0.4377407133579254,
0.12202496826648712,
-0.8181749582290649,
-0.39012545347213745,
-0.16203159093856812,
-0.5921202898025513,
0.1328563690185547,
-0.29614412784576416,
-0.3846912682056427,
0.6117172837257385,
0.11840160191059113,
-0.28834736347198486,
0.5568398237228394,
-0.3761579394340515,
0.8702678680419922,
0.14680829644203186,
-0.8152751922607422,
-0.5058432817459106,
-0.19833531975746155,
0.16250544786453247,
-0.2549498379230499,
0.5445224642753601,
0.017562342807650566,
-0.09718567878007889,
0.7689398527145386,
-0.5740073323249817,
0.7914353609085083,
-0.19593258202075958,
-0.14794133603572845,
0.7027638554573059,
-0.40265530347824097,
0.6244567036628723,
0.4728446304798126,
-0.3256702423095703,
0.21019373834133148,
-0.16956613957881927,
-0.8469017148017883,
-0.4041651785373688,
0.7187121510505676,
-0.8714964389801025,
-0.9824436902999878,
-0.2581782639026642,
-0.13172884285449982,
0.0031836999114602804,
-0.06550867855548859,
0.18086658418178558,
0.19227835536003113,
-0.010581823997199535,
-0.13185414671897888,
0.6978297233581543,
-0.24040529131889343,
0.3802219033241272,
-0.008671987801790237,
0.11240650713443756,
-0.4161747694015503,
0.9426264762878418,
-0.023657193407416344,
0.13387039303779602,
0.22339023649692535,
0.6704047918319702,
-0.44954219460487366,
-0.4343164563179016,
-0.16000545024871826,
0.17235536873340607,
-0.6698947548866272,
0.052312955260276794,
-0.7845026254653931,
0.4890269935131073,
-0.19484804570674896,
-0.41961926221847534,
-0.4746926724910736,
-0.3766500651836395,
-0.3628169000148773,
-0.36124277114868164,
0.32017186284065247,
0.7448849678039551,
-0.06735967844724655,
0.19917438924312592,
-0.5710060000419617,
0.22311891615390778,
0.35842612385749817,
0.16682550311088562,
-0.01553521677851677,
0.18485988676548004,
-0.3234582245349884,
0.12959237396717072,
-0.7364429831504822,
-0.8265974521636963,
0.5816425681114197,
-0.5716471076011658,
0.30450138449668884,
0.8673298358917236,
0.3428492546081543,
0.44122347235679626,
0.17086128890514374,
0.8254068493843079,
0.3755360543727875,
-1.067529320716858,
0.3588332235813141,
-0.575356662273407,
-0.16069716215133667,
0.37725189328193665,
0.5985936522483826,
-0.5427411198616028,
-0.3393958508968353,
-0.6040366888046265,
-0.9844745993614197,
0.5521347522735596,
0.23029136657714844,
0.03761957958340645,
-0.4097529351711273,
0.10522589087486267,
0.33082279562950134,
0.38132983446121216,
-0.5580530762672424,
0.07015356421470642,
-0.35338929295539856,
0.17092180252075195,
-0.09407325088977814,
-0.07082374393939972,
-0.061341121792793274,
-0.062442515045404434,
0.7621336579322815,
0.2685765326023102,
0.15066877007484436,
0.21713529527187347,
0.21812297403812408,
-0.18806897103786469,
0.2188231348991394,
0.41377538442611694,
0.9868013858795166,
-0.1766033172607422,
-0.16233357787132263,
-0.11783276498317719,
-0.4683098793029785,
0.010668328031897545,
-0.129075288772583,
-0.34565117955207825,
-0.10140158236026764,
0.1028575524687767,
0.4716850817203522,
-0.07294997572898865,
-0.33344918489456177,
0.10939731448888779,
0.286393940448761,
-0.3852848708629608,
-0.19941110908985138,
-0.3340010941028595,
0.3242217004299164,
0.2774714231491089,
0.30811619758605957,
0.15900592505931854,
0.41277453303337097,
-0.5379819869995117,
0.13298596441745758,
-0.11940041184425354,
-0.6199601292610168,
-0.33562415838241577,
0.9081939458847046,
0.27991122007369995,
-0.04553184285759926,
0.5601730346679688,
-0.003729376243427396,
-0.4792068898677826,
0.8061264753341675,
0.16619816422462463,
0.764381468296051,
0.3123047649860382,
0.2636362910270691,
0.31996238231658936,
0.0491107739508152,
-0.4559507668018341,
0.33189883828163147,
-0.07518915832042694,
-0.49230480194091797,
-0.29096218943595886,
-0.6867021322250366,
-0.6602407693862915,
-0.07355321198701859,
-0.980547308921814,
0.6364094018936157,
-0.28398773074150085,
-0.3460349142551422,
-0.051447562873363495,
0.5382735729217529,
-0.46207064390182495,
0.348701536655426,
0.10757408291101456,
0.7438022494316101,
-1.2382127046585083,
0.6034725308418274,
0.8102002739906311,
-0.3585805892944336,
-0.3359583020210266,
0.19676928222179413,
-0.19487127661705017,
-0.19859638810157776,
0.4868955910205841,
0.2175118327140808,
-0.1905178427696228,
-0.15147234499454498,
-0.5121061205863953,
-0.7990257740020752,
0.8611873388290405,
-0.2716442942619324,
-0.8490428328514099,
0.0024419575929641724,
0.13572648167610168,
0.1926051676273346,
-0.4417511224746704,
0.035732049494981766,
0.28682729601860046,
0.8006467819213867,
0.0528935045003891,
-0.25092220306396484,
-0.15241044759750366,
-0.13911236822605133,
0.12855742871761322,
0.4866553544998169,
-0.7934296131134033,
0.7673157453536987,
0.2718615233898163,
-0.13314571976661682,
-0.3831752836704254,
0.6797171831130981,
0.5149025917053223,
1.1229538917541504,
0.609853208065033,
0.45758697390556335,
0.6530628800392151,
0.19561904668807983,
1.0189659595489502,
-0.7224373817443848,
0.664635181427002,
0.5044539570808411,
-0.5615871548652649,
0.5238754749298096,
0.5515686869621277,
0.06705059856176376,
0.11961324512958527,
0.8394474983215332,
0.05223531275987625,
0.7711989283561707,
0.3343616724014282,
-0.22432206571102142,
-0.40059828758239746,
-0.06955776363611221,
-0.2864603102207184,
0.17438474297523499,
0.4492441415786743,
-0.09411931782960892,
-0.2920859754085541,
0.23443351686000824,
-0.14492298662662506,
0.43001481890678406,
-0.8185884952545166,
0.5675367116928101,
-0.20587359368801117,
-0.2501087784767151,
0.12704455852508545,
0.2615567743778229,
0.5878683924674988,
-0.002952306531369686,
0.0031356632243841887,
-0.25931674242019653,
-0.12632696330547333,
-0.13190586864948273,
-0.6004816293716431,
0.6383587121963501,
-0.03605359047651291,
-0.42296427488327026,
-0.21587878465652466,
0.6459444165229797,
0.011263866908848286,
-0.7824032306671143,
0.16121116280555725,
0.37695518136024475,
0.225630983710289,
-0.5090970396995544,
-0.8203324675559998,
0.18545697629451752,
0.013300941325724125,
-0.5359832048416138,
0.2466925084590912,
0.6680029630661011,
-0.3832915127277374,
0.3453565835952759,
0.5898097157478333,
-0.14669479429721832,
-0.4283936321735382,
-0.32336270809173584,
1.1355246305465698,
-1.0523186922073364,
-0.9330829381942749,
-0.5173224210739136,
0.31711405515670776,
-0.12511242926120758,
-0.521407425403595,
0.5097995400428772,
0.763340413570404,
1.0122178792953491,
-0.04412389174103737,
0.638013482093811,
0.3459886312484741,
0.6887328624725342,
-0.23111861944198608,
0.5495363473892212,
-0.20446662604808807,
0.441910058259964,
-0.6107931733131409,
-1.171607494354248,
0.2815481722354889,
0.37871596217155457,
-0.731906533241272,
-0.21458041667938232,
0.1841418743133545,
0.9782766103744507,
-0.05807334557175636,
0.5469134449958801,
0.16304126381874084,
-0.23517729341983795,
0.027672644704580307,
0.14335867762565613,
0.8561803698539734,
0.20754869282245636,
0.25710856914520264,
-0.4852157533168793,
-0.0018599885515868664,
-0.07117394357919693,
-0.7313372492790222,
-0.5737807154655457,
-0.5003691911697388,
-0.5504000186920166,
-0.2390030175447464,
0.3115609586238861,
0.8328019976615906,
0.8598026037216187,
-0.7199555039405823,
-0.3766331970691681,
-0.40903717279434204,
0.2906719744205475,
-0.30450835824012756,
-0.25150808691978455,
0.6317684650421143,
-0.02498718909919262,
-0.6454019546508789,
-0.3607487380504608,
0.2518555819988251,
-0.3668532371520996,
-0.29734572768211365,
0.10493268817663193,
-0.1999034285545349,
0.34342148900032043,
0.6202514171600342,
0.23151850700378418,
-0.5666581988334656,
-0.11179479211568832,
-0.17761337757110596,
0.2677306532859802,
-0.0856073647737503,
0.8451818227767944,
-0.49226370453834534,
0.07050073146820068,
0.22035494446754456,
0.2781909108161926,
0.9162973165512085,
0.44557711482048035,
0.31304630637168884,
0.11121410876512527,
0.005820294376462698,
0.21351051330566406,
0.019669312983751297,
0.1765350103378296,
-0.4620889127254486,
0.15478819608688354,
0.332122266292572,
-0.6679975390434265,
-0.6511942744255066,
0.28776317834854126,
-0.8125331997871399,
-0.6458821296691895,
0.8480488657951355,
0.019662639126181602,
-0.41311460733413696,
-0.5529746413230896,
-0.12732842564582825,
0.10882096737623215,
-0.6548172235488892,
1.126880168914795,
0.6986726522445679,
-0.08550062030553818,
0.1736505925655365,
-0.3993739187717438,
-0.13222679495811462,
-0.11842744052410126,
-0.45103707909584045,
0.47175946831703186,
0.4984376132488251,
0.044992029666900635,
0.21604837477207184,
0.11309679597616196,
-0.24937975406646729,
-0.019025547429919243,
-0.051346614956855774,
0.14728541672229767,
-0.020481353625655174,
-0.5967951416969299,
-0.18829947710037231,
0.6495267748832703,
-0.22186985611915588,
0.004670143127441406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10999v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10999v1
|
Large Language Models for Tuning Evolution Strategies
| 2024-05-16T21:14:32 | 2024-05-16T21:14:32 |
Oliver Kramer
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.NE
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit world knowledge and inference
capabilities, making them powerful tools for various applications. This paper
proposes a feedback loop mechanism that leverages these capabilities to tune
Evolution Strategies (ES) parameters effectively. The mechanism involves a
structured process of providing programming instructions, executing the
corresponding code, and conducting thorough analysis. This process is
specifically designed for the optimization of ES parameters. The method
operates through an iterative cycle, ensuring continuous refinement of the ES
parameters. First, LLMs process the instructions to generate or modify the
code. The code is then executed, and the results are meticulously logged.
Subsequent analysis of these results provides insights that drive further
improvements. An experiment on tuning the learning rates of ES using the LLaMA3
model demonstrate the feasibility of this approach. This research illustrates
how LLMs can be harnessed to improve ES algorithms' performance and suggests
broader applications for similar feedback loop mechanisms in various domains.
|
[
-0.4126741886138916,
-0.7673228979110718,
0.6124314069747925,
0.1030767485499382,
-0.5918874144554138,
0.12540875375270844,
-0.6639555096626282,
-0.24984754621982574,
0.18118655681610107,
0.6638907790184021,
-0.856837272644043,
-0.3770795464515686,
-0.33753693103790283,
0.4174264371395111,
-0.1513841152191162,
0.9796434640884399,
0.026750653982162476,
0.029590802267193794,
0.03178004175424576,
0.1028413325548172,
-0.15887048840522766,
0.01286294125020504,
-0.9311850070953369,
-0.47002309560775757,
0.4978732764720917,
0.48426294326782227,
0.36422204971313477,
0.876091480255127,
0.3464495837688446,
0.3536737561225891,
-0.4146069884300232,
0.4220895767211914,
-0.826253354549408,
0.6068902611732483,
-0.1334114819765091,
-0.6279517412185669,
-0.2986736595630646,
-0.42513853311538696,
0.690216600894928,
0.3010956943035126,
-0.48092713952064514,
0.26074734330177307,
0.01384200993925333,
0.5040256977081299,
-0.4207823872566223,
-0.03587568178772926,
-1.0221959352493286,
-0.19366206228733063,
-0.1857980489730835,
-0.8137747049331665,
-0.4137625992298126,
-0.4578644633293152,
0.004990713205188513,
-0.5038594603538513,
-0.06237952783703804,
0.13467542827129364,
0.5895729660987854,
0.18124309182167053,
0.23243705928325653,
-0.5576289892196655,
-0.700537383556366,
0.8391485214233398,
-1.0290666818618774,
0.21702688932418823,
-0.04765773564577103,
0.038703273981809616,
-0.4042518734931946,
-0.5755571126937866,
-0.3449273109436035,
-0.4732714593410492,
0.374477356672287,
-0.11087141185998917,
-0.06447968631982803,
0.029331691563129425,
0.33487749099731445,
0.3441636562347412,
-0.1540059894323349,
0.501778781414032,
-0.4076331853866577,
0.06803824752569199,
0.6551017165184021,
0.19742687046527863,
0.14646445214748383,
0.2002323865890503,
-0.052896127104759216,
-0.0738256499171257,
-0.9049152135848999,
-0.10816983133554459,
0.720766007900238,
0.48988500237464905,
0.018379349261522293,
0.4614851176738739,
-0.17088457942008972,
0.7723349928855896,
0.03278667852282524,
-0.4656960070133209,
0.07456496357917786,
-0.11801431328058243,
0.03403865545988083,
-0.18866293132305145,
0.3558664917945862,
0.24680563807487488,
0.3029385209083557,
-0.19593633711338043,
-0.5118115544319153,
-0.08202013373374939,
0.4589587450027466,
-0.7963483333587646,
0.07272478193044662,
0.04643615707755089,
-0.3998028039932251,
-0.37724846601486206,
-0.3375262916088104,
-1.143999695777893,
-0.27114203572273254,
-0.42660748958587646,
0.3556576073169708,
-0.30291926860809326,
-0.23204903304576874,
0.4030517041683197,
-0.1528281569480896,
0.3515300452709198,
0.16315363347530365,
-1.0227280855178833,
0.16166582703590393,
0.6536287069320679,
0.9009535312652588,
-0.16813324391841888,
-0.25008174777030945,
-0.6248413920402527,
0.3334619402885437,
-0.18983985483646393,
0.7697288990020752,
-0.9310423731803894,
-0.6086976528167725,
0.08126787096261978,
-0.1480642408132553,
0.0140367541462183,
-0.5735881924629211,
0.39907437562942505,
-0.8218568563461304,
-0.15274269878864288,
-0.053233060985803604,
-0.5534307956695557,
-0.09041138738393784,
0.11915259063243866,
-0.546726644039154,
0.860026478767395,
-0.10804175585508347,
-0.390170693397522,
0.22149528563022614,
-1.0893502235412598,
-0.5606504082679749,
0.07146061211824417,
0.28124794363975525,
-0.6656668186187744,
0.29115399718284607,
0.41603192687034607,
0.34593144059181213,
-0.39762264490127563,
-0.15280039608478546,
-0.6256932616233826,
-0.41887161135673523,
0.010231049731373787,
-0.07983756810426712,
0.5588662028312683,
0.34003400802612305,
-0.4283531606197357,
0.07885642349720001,
-0.8895182013511658,
0.26392263174057007,
0.1651538461446762,
-0.7100517153739929,
-0.14330929517745972,
0.42805638909339905,
-0.5026577115058899,
-0.0957052931189537,
0.036740995943546295,
-0.209546759724617,
0.5677769780158997,
-0.5323078632354736,
0.936127781867981,
0.7574005126953125,
0.3703468441963196,
0.27290812134742737,
-0.19155967235565186,
0.7917702198028564,
-0.3391764163970947,
0.18813127279281616,
-0.33235204219818115,
-0.34825000166893005,
-0.9543417692184448,
-0.0755160003900528,
0.0930662602186203,
0.2714478671550751,
-0.49922192096710205,
0.4322206377983093,
-0.2973294258117676,
-0.4934760630130768,
-0.6425605416297913,
0.4952007234096527,
0.12376782298088074,
0.07419892400503159,
0.2737923860549927,
0.14147792756557465,
-0.5904641151428223,
-0.6015278697013855,
-0.26638922095298767,
-0.16605806350708008,
0.03882776200771332,
0.2858197093009949,
0.48330676555633545,
-0.4303645193576813,
0.6301419734954834,
-0.323519229888916,
0.4133828580379486,
-0.348738431930542,
0.12896473705768585,
0.2476234883069992,
0.19829297065734863,
0.4390028417110443,
-0.33776894211769104,
-0.013336434960365295,
0.136042520403862,
-0.2824631631374359,
-0.6043646335601807,
-0.04406450688838959,
-0.15720416605472565,
0.1111229807138443,
0.7097043395042419,
-0.10791781544685364,
-0.08965384215116501,
0.725879967212677,
0.16430340707302094,
0.4460560083389282,
-0.11290984600782394,
-0.05456412956118584,
-0.8694921731948853,
-0.012582738883793354,
-0.03732188045978546,
-0.11128228902816772,
-0.3032473027706146,
0.47108498215675354,
-0.10938431322574615,
0.07060550898313522,
-0.1971408724784851,
0.26807308197021484,
-0.7020453810691833,
-0.08916394412517548,
-0.304373174905777,
0.3379029631614685,
-0.1392485350370407,
0.31900152564048767,
-0.033450715243816376,
0.8596106767654419,
0.6306514739990234,
-0.9310954809188843,
0.4515914022922516,
-0.034827060997486115,
-0.381074458360672,
0.32807207107543945,
-0.6378278136253357,
0.44330793619155884,
-0.08642376959323883,
0.14737741649150848,
-0.694662868976593,
0.06256698817014694,
-0.1534131020307541,
-0.12167878448963165,
0.29388049244880676,
-0.08025599271059036,
-0.37652355432510376,
-0.6232643723487854,
-0.5545496940612793,
-0.1935102343559265,
0.43113353848457336,
-0.6742817163467407,
0.4855155050754547,
0.020665820688009262,
-0.1323552131652832,
-0.28130561113357544,
-0.18618111312389374,
0.0918383002281189,
-0.5603271126747131,
-0.6438726782798767,
0.16149567067623138,
-0.2903468906879425,
-0.19021059572696686,
-0.3108287751674652,
0.0635516345500946,
0.6640017032623291,
0.28395068645477295,
-0.15042252838611603,
-0.028251416981220245,
-0.4269190728664398,
0.11440189182758331,
0.19109784066677094,
-0.08082791417837143,
-0.025615962222218513,
-0.5802606344223022,
0.7623828053474426,
0.09841906279325485,
-0.2304026335477829,
-0.25444552302360535,
0.15638579428195953,
0.9020038843154907,
-0.28526026010513306,
0.736668050289154,
0.31720584630966187,
0.14572708308696747,
-0.7693295478820801,
-0.605274498462677,
-0.33043786883354187,
-0.5569862723350525,
0.452133446931839,
-0.43736156821250916,
-0.9222229719161987,
0.5943194031715393,
-0.7254912853240967,
0.30436816811561584,
0.25498321652412415,
0.9518178105354309,
0.2077244222164154,
1.1720600128173828,
0.6767054200172424,
-0.17154665291309357,
0.5592119097709656,
-0.3715762197971344,
0.23563402891159058,
-1.1052610874176025,
-0.10567724704742432,
-0.7422930598258972,
-0.33523744344711304,
-0.5549203753471375,
-0.24004460871219635,
0.40538719296455383,
0.4962325394153595,
-0.33117058873176575,
0.20739267766475677,
-0.33746665716171265,
0.7197214961051941,
0.3811861276626587,
0.19016793370246887,
0.3041332960128784,
0.02665305696427822,
-0.2509250342845917,
0.22250182926654816,
-0.6840399503707886,
-0.6283263564109802,
1.163228988647461,
0.5050943493843079,
1.1671415567398071,
0.16203516721725464,
0.6596282124519348,
0.19046179950237274,
0.4216548204421997,
-0.7607843279838562,
0.4792097210884094,
0.13159625232219696,
-0.20785461366176605,
-0.34053561091423035,
-0.3671584129333496,
-0.7244535684585571,
0.15450546145439148,
-0.08035411685705185,
-0.8466588854789734,
-0.1714334785938263,
0.15129390358924866,
-0.18883714079856873,
0.4155707061290741,
-0.6194165349006653,
0.3174915015697479,
-0.29045096039772034,
-0.4794081449508667,
-0.4615665078163147,
-0.33705389499664307,
0.19095741212368011,
-0.31768736243247986,
0.021153002977371216,
0.04573752358555794,
-0.2539233863353729,
0.5532631278038025,
-0.41034838557243347,
0.6846760511398315,
-0.09606022387742996,
-0.49665647745132446,
0.15008483827114105,
-0.11547426134347916,
0.9711856245994568,
0.2156614512205124,
-0.5881957411766052,
-0.16615816950798035,
-0.39995360374450684,
-0.2712090313434601,
-0.4849819540977478,
0.7980644106864929,
-0.7593081593513489,
-0.8704447150230408,
0.25606676936149597,
-0.26805973052978516,
-0.49123477935791016,
0.00048698679893277586,
0.27487626671791077,
0.29276126623153687,
0.13555459678173065,
0.2891545593738556,
0.5594485402107239,
-0.22751736640930176,
0.6279606819152832,
0.7894207835197449,
-0.22568249702453613,
-0.2669566869735718,
0.6411938667297363,
-0.29433438181877136,
0.6654919981956482,
0.10901369899511337,
0.42639264464378357,
-0.33314234018325806,
-1.0982388257980347,
-0.40656158328056335,
0.38444334268569946,
-0.6496430039405823,
-0.44602522253990173,
-0.3590439260005951,
-0.09160935133695602,
-0.17220042645931244,
-0.289279580116272,
-0.1302945464849472,
0.16561885178089142,
-0.2406100630760193,
-0.16979794204235077,
0.6494269371032715,
0.8337210416793823,
0.038596510887145996,
0.5635074377059937,
-0.5815756916999817,
0.022633669897913933,
0.3813830614089966,
0.5988895893096924,
0.23202645778656006,
-0.5416530966758728,
-0.2185417115688324,
0.04723894223570824,
-0.5255835652351379,
-0.8444705009460449,
0.2769915461540222,
0.4990839958190918,
0.653719961643219,
0.5952659249305725,
-0.32057416439056396,
0.862847626209259,
-0.5393279194831848,
0.7661459445953369,
-0.1958257555961609,
-1.1074745655059814,
0.8258072137832642,
-0.5773195624351501,
0.16074073314666748,
0.20545552670955658,
0.0987689197063446,
-0.2463623732328415,
-0.6131476759910583,
-0.22080682218074799,
-0.7534353137016296,
0.8293467164039612,
-0.0754602923989296,
0.3083862364292145,
0.04824414476752281,
0.7763140201568604,
0.075825996696949,
0.1120355874300003,
-0.7219970226287842,
-0.016795983538031578,
0.26555973291397095,
0.12301076203584671,
0.09610958397388458,
-0.19122891128063202,
-0.12951543927192688,
-0.3210203945636749,
0.943665087223053,
-0.27853068709373474,
-0.037581801414489746,
-0.249174565076828,
-0.10816832631826401,
-0.5981566905975342,
0.24873627722263336,
0.9704824686050415,
1.0001264810562134,
0.12964782118797302,
-0.336589515209198,
0.42404961585998535,
-0.3152112364768982,
0.08298080414533615,
-0.3731938898563385,
-0.19906938076019287,
-0.26286089420318604,
0.2895260155200958,
1.0294417142868042,
0.2631557285785675,
-0.6312223672866821,
0.03385003283619881,
0.1012965589761734,
-0.25345054268836975,
0.08651596307754517,
0.4573524296283722,
0.20525822043418884,
0.574532687664032,
0.21239452064037323,
-0.29394257068634033,
-0.1384759247303009,
-0.4439578652381897,
0.11630334705114365,
0.4276597499847412,
0.1479569673538208,
-0.24732400476932526,
0.4610484838485718,
0.4328434467315674,
-0.6013647317886353,
0.3848143219947815,
-0.024908527731895447,
-0.6920453310012817,
0.5160934925079346,
1.0347347259521484,
0.7457791566848755,
-0.3617103397846222,
0.20856447517871857,
0.3258461356163025,
0.33158785104751587,
-0.2895491421222687,
0.24707582592964172,
0.0034402795135974884,
-0.5602511763572693,
-0.7546518445014954,
-1.064937710762024,
-0.4295303523540497,
0.4203784465789795,
-0.5877065658569336,
0.5608587861061096,
-0.3459591269493103,
0.04211168736219406,
-0.04511206969618797,
-0.1488923728466034,
-0.43605533242225647,
-0.10168006271123886,
0.29945865273475647,
0.9770554900169373,
-0.6335225105285645,
0.7250753045082092,
0.5804973244667053,
-0.11225472390651703,
-0.6189886331558228,
0.07350646704435349,
-0.06605443358421326,
-1.203104019165039,
0.5299793481826782,
-0.16429738700389862,
-0.5455803871154785,
0.2511318325996399,
-0.7957209348678589,
-1.0697176456451416,
0.8808806538581848,
0.4157736301422119,
-1.018934965133667,
0.1812758445739746,
-0.16545255482196808,
0.657842218875885,
-0.6375291347503662,
0.07332543283700943,
0.8200629353523254,
0.5872113108634949,
0.058564651757478714,
-0.5336591005325317,
-0.13765430450439453,
-0.11751268059015274,
0.38543426990509033,
0.5170447826385498,
-0.5767593383789062,
0.518925666809082,
-0.5082242488861084,
-0.1236785352230072,
0.25476372241973877,
0.4772546589374542,
0.22116371989250183,
-0.22780123353004456,
0.5259106159210205,
0.7322777509689331,
0.6220482587814331,
0.04721628874540329,
1.0049774646759033,
-0.5773777961730957,
0.49659469723701477,
0.6002846360206604,
-0.3215456008911133,
0.9739353060722351,
0.46946755051612854,
-0.3230535089969635,
0.770237386226654,
0.6356593370437622,
-0.15494032204151154,
0.5036197900772095,
0.8031790256500244,
-0.15318706631660461,
-0.18449729681015015,
0.2806850075721741,
-0.23573577404022217,
0.45861607789993286,
0.6772298216819763,
-0.3992459177970886,
-0.21429285407066345,
-0.017840981483459473,
0.25450965762138367,
-0.061230529099702835,
-0.6084368228912354,
1.0091969966888428,
-0.12612299621105194,
-0.8724767565727234,
0.7224396467208862,
0.04716572165489197,
0.6636947393417358,
-0.7857276201248169,
0.0002858825318980962,
-0.22193719446659088,
0.20622248947620392,
-0.1677020937204361,
-0.33575376868247986,
0.0476839579641819,
0.09114184230566025,
-0.09029597789049149,
-0.017172832041978836,
0.2872491180896759,
-0.35527870059013367,
-0.39327913522720337,
0.41767042875289917,
0.08385845273733139,
-0.2411968857049942,
0.31997403502464294,
-0.6554988026618958,
0.3307730257511139,
0.09158460795879364,
-0.3109819293022156,
0.01979655958712101,
0.3776608407497406,
0.22426265478134155,
0.8028751611709595,
0.6508949995040894,
0.44616222381591797,
0.1702585071325302,
0.3556954860687256,
0.8811244964599609,
-0.5044676065444946,
-0.4691532552242279,
-1.1699403524398804,
0.3051534593105316,
-0.18364548683166504,
-0.4941386282444,
0.677058219909668,
0.22294151782989502,
0.6564173698425293,
0.05704266205430031,
0.728110134601593,
0.3448026776313782,
0.46776387095451355,
-0.933186948299408,
0.28659671545028687,
-0.5462837815284729,
0.7305735349655151,
-0.16403889656066895,
-1.2715705633163452,
-0.05403151735663414,
0.38218793272972107,
-0.13855375349521637,
0.22248174250125885,
0.6722186207771301,
0.9737001061439514,
0.14384648203849792,
0.2507624328136444,
0.02034072019159794,
0.3893447518348694,
0.39885103702545166,
0.41787904500961304,
0.8348965048789978,
-0.03194205090403557,
0.5040363073348999,
0.1370333880186081,
-0.17941665649414062,
-0.3973981440067291,
-1.025622010231018,
-0.8707369565963745,
-0.28496381640434265,
-0.2679101526737213,
-0.30489927530288696,
0.28293469548225403,
0.7459385991096497,
0.7149704694747925,
-0.5822595357894897,
-0.2866055965423584,
-0.21439039707183838,
-0.008402043022215366,
-0.23754099011421204,
-0.17715886235237122,
0.0328170545399189,
-0.772670567035675,
-0.5970261096954346,
0.4490034282207489,
0.6143612265586853,
-0.3190626800060272,
-0.6282989978790283,
-0.23151510953903198,
0.031045658513903618,
0.37736257910728455,
0.5908949971199036,
0.2891148030757904,
-0.8962427973747253,
-0.3569951355457306,
-0.0933813601732254,
0.3066974878311157,
-0.03833954781293869,
1.127305507659912,
-0.4382460117340088,
0.49963444471359253,
0.32741162180900574,
0.6653090715408325,
0.6174845695495605,
-0.17952781915664673,
0.8581346273422241,
-0.6943938732147217,
-0.22774937748908997,
0.11895810067653656,
0.3285711705684662,
0.2591269910335541,
-0.23328642547130585,
0.458892285823822,
-0.058573078364133835,
-0.6863282322883606,
-0.8747095465660095,
0.2743188738822937,
-0.6216548681259155,
-0.2544385492801666,
1.4579757452011108,
0.13230712711811066,
-0.17259086668491364,
0.14629802107810974,
-0.11785095930099487,
-0.007518644444644451,
-0.3749420940876007,
1.0609420537948608,
0.6936647295951843,
-0.07211793959140778,
-0.23582418262958527,
-0.39820876717567444,
0.6166095733642578,
0.24251024425029755,
-0.9749711751937866,
0.08803384006023407,
0.20618772506713867,
0.40600642561912537,
0.13291901350021362,
0.0693974643945694,
-0.12024930864572525,
0.09431210160255432,
-0.1706537902355194,
-0.3078888952732086,
0.14704060554504395,
-0.18047446012496948,
-0.46136242151260376,
0.016619972884655,
0.40304288268089294,
0.08595164865255356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10443v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10443v2
|
Simultaneous Masking, Not Prompting Optimization: A Paradigm Shift in Fine-tuning LLMs for Simultaneous Translation
| 2024-05-16T21:07:42 | 2024-06-26T20:22:31 |
Matthew Raffel, Victor Agostinelli, Lizhong Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved state-of-the-art performance in
various language processing tasks, motivating their adoption in simultaneous
translation. Current fine-tuning methods to adapt LLMs for simultaneous
translation focus on prompting optimization strategies using either data
augmentation or prompt structure modifications. However, these methods suffer
from several issues, such as unnecessarily expanded training sets,
computational inefficiency from dumping the key and value cache, increased
prompt sizes, or restriction to a single decision policy. To eliminate these
issues, in this work, we propose SimulMask, a new paradigm for fine-tuning LLMs
for simultaneous translation. It utilizes a novel attention mask approach that
models simultaneous translation during fine-tuning by masking attention for a
desired decision policy. Applying the proposed SimulMask on a Falcon LLM for
the IWSLT 2017 dataset, we have observed a significant translation quality
improvement compared to state-of-the-art prompting optimization strategies on
five language pairs while reducing the computational cost.
|
[
-0.5410637259483337,
-0.656850278377533,
0.22436991333961487,
0.6395670771598816,
-0.6406185626983643,
0.3352707326412201,
-0.5510725378990173,
-0.3079510033130646,
0.14761611819267273,
0.5247572064399719,
-0.9990538358688354,
-0.42043817043304443,
-0.7748886346817017,
0.3888971209526062,
-0.013066623359918594,
0.7920470237731934,
-0.17003515362739563,
0.06114767864346504,
-0.26380854845046997,
-0.06352777779102325,
-0.5725772976875305,
0.02131459303200245,
-0.999999463558197,
-0.17358645796775818,
0.3574305474758148,
0.3782798647880554,
0.6223025321960449,
0.8186226487159729,
0.48556962609291077,
0.2640590965747833,
-0.15736350417137146,
0.8124463558197021,
-0.38129910826683044,
0.16176772117614746,
0.015524747781455517,
-0.1965046525001526,
-0.31125307083129883,
-0.10883711278438568,
0.9166040420532227,
0.7493575811386108,
0.19234316051006317,
0.2716166377067566,
0.2874709367752075,
0.7701478004455566,
-0.6714403629302979,
0.24129879474639893,
-0.6228036880493164,
0.1324201226234436,
-0.2567056715488434,
-0.45933908224105835,
-0.30162277817726135,
-0.07989344745874405,
-0.32475027441978455,
-0.7023804187774658,
0.14034053683280945,
0.30701956152915955,
0.570076584815979,
0.8418421149253845,
-0.0690707266330719,
0.056077856570482254,
-0.3748423457145691,
0.9823766350746155,
-0.7117229104042053,
0.3426998555660248,
0.2067684382200241,
0.12147142738103867,
-0.2204199880361557,
-0.3307971954345703,
-0.27483248710632324,
-0.10892893373966217,
-0.016762124374508858,
0.1562681347131729,
-0.09792466461658478,
0.2693757116794586,
0.4157252311706543,
0.14025531709194183,
-0.4612588584423065,
0.259776771068573,
-0.13706529140472412,
-0.2651497423648834,
0.6429915428161621,
0.21519099175930023,
0.17179730534553528,
0.23760321736335754,
-0.5619743466377258,
0.01587003841996193,
-0.6893028020858765,
0.2338256984949112,
0.25774112343788147,
0.4386526942253113,
0.023002542555332184,
0.2464650422334671,
-0.5649195313453674,
0.7221768498420715,
0.17709065973758698,
-0.28567537665367126,
0.08313248306512833,
-0.31903529167175293,
-0.3075713813304901,
0.2107781618833542,
0.6263025999069214,
0.43900296092033386,
0.22792814671993256,
-0.323842853307724,
-0.22307103872299194,
0.12640593945980072,
0.17067791521549225,
-0.6286115646362305,
0.25615495443344116,
0.28531646728515625,
-0.20167876780033112,
-0.41980189085006714,
0.2147703468799591,
-0.6957842111587524,
-0.28091442584991455,
-0.5259068608283997,
0.32121747732162476,
0.05898217111825943,
-0.031825631856918335,
0.5974916815757751,
0.20438435673713684,
0.05436377972364426,
0.46761125326156616,
-0.7436887621879578,
0.4549178183078766,
0.871178388595581,
0.8442533612251282,
-0.5934246778488159,
-0.4057656526565552,
-0.860571563243866,
0.1784132570028305,
-0.40658077597618103,
0.5709846615791321,
-0.36691322922706604,
-0.21061858534812927,
0.008323857560753822,
0.005959104746580124,
-0.1640968769788742,
-0.6458762288093567,
0.5209155678749084,
-0.33800607919692993,
-0.33981648087501526,
-0.3114500045776367,
-0.19946855306625366,
-0.13179974257946014,
0.1678507924079895,
-0.48796316981315613,
1.0235059261322021,
-0.20164456963539124,
-0.47053104639053345,
0.25350886583328247,
-0.6778576374053955,
-0.638698160648346,
0.23075169324874878,
-0.1420530080795288,
-0.4698519706726074,
0.12115815281867981,
0.5340927243232727,
0.37211158871650696,
-0.526116132736206,
0.4897579848766327,
-0.23309306800365448,
-0.5520939826965332,
0.2032202184200287,
-0.100091353058815,
0.6154840588569641,
0.29024606943130493,
-0.3330554962158203,
0.1760942041873932,
-0.41796672344207764,
0.006135983392596245,
-0.03336259350180626,
-0.33117491006851196,
-0.040297333151102066,
-0.147883340716362,
-0.20019219815731049,
0.41832366585731506,
0.3267087936401367,
-0.5067850947380066,
0.47209370136260986,
-0.26545044779777527,
0.32057732343673706,
0.7227841019630432,
0.08023001253604889,
0.5050197243690491,
-0.506578266620636,
0.7540811896324158,
0.07193092256784439,
0.187513068318367,
-0.1570102572441101,
-0.46622976660728455,
-1.001278042793274,
-0.37427353858947754,
0.16811366379261017,
0.44142505526542664,
-0.5551848411560059,
0.0654311552643776,
-0.2169187068939209,
0.010258123278617859,
-0.8885380029678345,
0.30379539728164673,
0.38172993063926697,
0.2536562383174896,
0.3580428957939148,
-0.17842884361743927,
-0.6049274802207947,
-0.9181669354438782,
-0.665481448173523,
0.2567327916622162,
0.40093109011650085,
0.03673473000526428,
0.04411788284778595,
0.051007892936468124,
0.5115891695022583,
-0.4475374221801758,
-0.4731954038143158,
-0.22611205279827118,
0.08444496244192123,
0.17163501679897308,
0.5494014024734497,
0.11019837856292725,
-0.6766809821128845,
-0.5731624960899353,
0.00026118397363461554,
-0.5329400897026062,
-0.5511773228645325,
-0.4425719976425171,
-0.05298762768507004,
0.23782743513584137,
1.121686339378357,
-0.5720834136009216,
0.36301884055137634,
0.423162043094635,
0.23872672021389008,
0.2069869041442871,
-0.04133737087249756,
0.03543754667043686,
-0.7963073253631592,
-0.11222628504037857,
-0.26123008131980896,
-0.27757301926612854,
-0.5175426006317139,
0.3257470726966858,
0.297151654958725,
0.06508719176054001,
-0.5031135678291321,
0.747312605381012,
-0.680437445640564,
0.03561079129576683,
-0.2134135365486145,
-0.1842244565486908,
0.020489444956183434,
0.516078531742096,
-0.14315608143806458,
0.8876252174377441,
0.5971569418907166,
-0.5695169568061829,
0.03655499964952469,
0.14418771862983704,
-0.33647552132606506,
0.3109552562236786,
-0.2637750208377838,
0.2434992641210556,
-0.18726526200771332,
0.2239759862422943,
-0.9143156409263611,
-0.2395567148923874,
0.5379075407981873,
-0.22803200781345367,
0.61724454164505,
-0.09510502964258194,
-0.5651598572731018,
-0.3093746602535248,
-0.5959662199020386,
0.5400470495223999,
0.43970397114753723,
-0.4620247185230255,
0.19982580840587616,
0.049288321286439896,
-0.2621477544307709,
-0.7407729625701904,
-0.6535311937332153,
0.2473592609167099,
-0.2750135064125061,
-0.7645542621612549,
0.3526739478111267,
-0.333336740732193,
-0.08322396874427795,
-0.18770891427993774,
-0.5187810659408569,
0.24081280827522278,
0.14585617184638977,
0.14282943308353424,
0.07426130026578903,
-0.32330843806266785,
0.09374748170375824,
0.3931696116924286,
-0.45495811104774475,
-0.30335766077041626,
-0.6027625203132629,
0.29645365476608276,
0.07528270035982132,
-0.2619971036911011,
-0.5093495845794678,
0.5857874155044556,
0.5932824611663818,
-0.5591985583305359,
0.7681609988212585,
0.5349992513656616,
-0.18500599265098572,
-0.4715757966041565,
-0.8823722004890442,
-0.25774237513542175,
-0.5027042627334595,
0.30588170886039734,
-0.5241847634315491,
-1.208061695098877,
0.3449319899082184,
-0.5916680693626404,
0.08014379441738129,
0.09199235588312149,
0.6213023066520691,
-0.07389084249734879,
1.0999066829681396,
0.39883673191070557,
0.16810543835163116,
0.4104866683483124,
0.11521223932504654,
0.28642234206199646,
-1.032942771911621,
-0.17586810886859894,
-0.3482948839664459,
-0.576808512210846,
-0.3789801001548767,
-0.4372653365135193,
0.5171599984169006,
0.30300843715667725,
0.08756444603204727,
0.09464556723833084,
-0.3435313403606415,
0.6794895529747009,
0.410709410905838,
-0.11464381963014603,
0.6207787394523621,
0.2146574854850769,
-0.1522282510995865,
-0.11598257720470428,
-0.7738423347473145,
-0.1813114583492279,
0.8427809476852417,
0.0539887472987175,
0.6715860366821289,
-0.11184176057577133,
0.9047860503196716,
-0.10753066092729568,
-0.1784859150648117,
-0.7511887550354004,
0.7441260814666748,
-0.3196658790111542,
-0.20990543067455292,
-0.2298966497182846,
-0.3559727668762207,
-0.9571531414985657,
0.5071980953216553,
-0.009155393578112125,
-0.5894919633865356,
0.10752934217453003,
0.04140627384185791,
-0.40808239579200745,
0.20245446264743805,
-0.4540432095527649,
0.6756654381752014,
-0.05676522105932236,
-0.36515289545059204,
-0.09246271848678589,
-0.6780930161476135,
0.37823307514190674,
-0.4722190797328949,
0.33032646775245667,
-0.4151974022388458,
-0.34286555647850037,
0.5128527283668518,
-0.12198571115732193,
0.7669832110404968,
0.15718206763267517,
0.09246324002742767,
-0.07775009423494339,
0.21864673495292664,
0.7976559996604919,
0.21694912016391754,
0.04558713361620903,
0.21353031694889069,
-0.1904309093952179,
-0.3374367952346802,
-0.529118001461029,
0.847184419631958,
-0.5529595613479614,
-0.8426035046577454,
-0.35839471220970154,
-0.9954059720039368,
-0.30127087235450745,
0.24279730021953583,
0.27045977115631104,
0.08032327145338058,
0.08777529746294022,
0.08025575429201126,
0.6522173285484314,
-0.10295982658863068,
0.3877553939819336,
0.6706852316856384,
-0.04943069815635681,
-0.27039510011672974,
0.8436006307601929,
0.24222254753112793,
0.5240439176559448,
0.2314775437116623,
0.1945616602897644,
-0.13058850169181824,
-0.8634752035140991,
-0.3258998394012451,
0.414321631193161,
-0.4367879033088684,
-0.36270564794540405,
-0.7815523147583008,
-0.2799060344696045,
-0.4950312674045563,
-0.16417713463306427,
-0.30997440218925476,
-0.4585569202899933,
-0.1398608535528183,
0.3190386891365051,
0.08780787885189056,
0.43904832005500793,
-0.12384067475795746,
0.35726168751716614,
-0.6266214847564697,
0.5254783034324646,
0.1204979419708252,
0.3153477609157562,
-0.31277188658714294,
-0.4015611708164215,
-0.3819074034690857,
-0.07281690835952759,
-0.16139216721057892,
-0.4775600731372833,
0.17655228078365326,
0.1533721685409546,
0.4269535541534424,
0.09366800636053085,
0.3149411380290985,
0.8523401618003845,
-0.38427355885505676,
0.3333956301212311,
-0.022299380972981453,
-0.9084590673446655,
0.36118537187576294,
-0.3258596658706665,
0.803213357925415,
0.5701348781585693,
-0.13717669248580933,
-0.7331448793411255,
-0.5828171968460083,
-0.32297226786613464,
-0.6653371453285217,
1.2812906503677368,
0.15997527539730072,
0.07607834786176682,
0.20387347042560577,
0.21879981458187103,
0.25172945857048035,
0.440445214509964,
-0.3989224433898926,
-0.23543621599674225,
0.2534739077091217,
0.04554415121674538,
-0.10969037562608719,
-0.11789219826459885,
-0.1381331980228424,
-0.46337559819221497,
0.9093570113182068,
-0.20361517369747162,
-0.09576714783906937,
-0.052257027477025986,
-0.2889038324356079,
-0.4398488402366638,
0.2832227945327759,
0.7854363918304443,
0.25869885087013245,
-0.1701945662498474,
0.07306820899248123,
0.198403462767601,
-0.3250671625137329,
0.054486896842718124,
0.11213424801826477,
-0.436353862285614,
-0.07945042103528976,
0.24066781997680664,
0.9752187728881836,
0.41489171981811523,
-0.2136680632829666,
0.40475982427597046,
0.20393554866313934,
-0.32306531071662903,
0.21246840059757233,
0.03478487208485603,
0.04933108389377594,
0.2557104825973511,
0.07570405304431915,
0.4700106978416443,
-0.007790903095155954,
0.06692317128181458,
-0.04262816533446312,
0.45827823877334595,
-0.05319306254386902,
0.01668669283390045,
0.5402170419692993,
0.1425723284482956,
-0.25178587436676025,
0.23707230389118195,
-0.20923268795013428,
-0.32698854804039,
0.49896982312202454,
0.6020830273628235,
1.0419771671295166,
-0.4228111505508423,
0.2259846031665802,
0.40234285593032837,
0.6681197881698608,
-0.39317646622657776,
-0.005945204757153988,
-0.24390625953674316,
-0.5998698472976685,
-0.6388124227523804,
-0.6503437161445618,
-0.2481929212808609,
0.24195632338523865,
-0.6336833834648132,
0.49006250500679016,
-0.5099401473999023,
0.15944749116897583,
-0.07587097585201263,
-0.024716563522815704,
-0.6048166751861572,
-0.06670644879341125,
0.14753635227680206,
0.7975684404373169,
-0.6505109667778015,
0.9257034063339233,
0.7349486351013184,
-0.1927444338798523,
-0.462350070476532,
0.10349350422620773,
0.2684943377971649,
-0.9624412059783936,
0.334976464509964,
0.253793865442276,
-0.2705036401748657,
0.3187520205974579,
-0.6505275368690491,
-0.9180171489715576,
0.822199285030365,
0.7059168219566345,
-0.7039126753807068,
0.07530136406421661,
0.3822569251060486,
0.07082339376211166,
-0.36667633056640625,
-0.3931397795677185,
0.675048291683197,
0.7050918340682983,
0.11721595376729965,
-0.8705083131790161,
0.1510968655347824,
0.02820531651377678,
0.12315542250871658,
0.4978850781917572,
-0.9611631631851196,
0.6782945990562439,
-0.09329155087471008,
-0.45341336727142334,
0.060542576014995575,
0.2357853353023529,
0.0003212408919353038,
0.15277191996574402,
0.4556848406791687,
0.4632931053638458,
0.6143696308135986,
-0.057719647884368896,
0.9545586705207825,
-0.06369122862815857,
0.35445070266723633,
1.2579208612442017,
-0.21894420683383942,
0.5349348187446594,
0.8586653470993042,
-0.07775212824344635,
-0.281863272190094,
0.5318732261657715,
0.11793223023414612,
0.5684622526168823,
0.12467411160469055,
-0.29336240887641907,
-0.7769677639007568,
-0.28152644634246826,
-0.47535330057144165,
0.27042263746261597,
0.31621742248535156,
-0.022926194593310356,
-0.5200937390327454,
0.1257820874452591,
0.04466434195637703,
-0.03426017612218857,
-0.11595615744590759,
0.8440660834312439,
0.34689661860466003,
-0.8976309895515442,
0.7925807237625122,
0.11289934813976288,
0.6137901544570923,
-0.6295078992843628,
0.16053059697151184,
-0.40933889150619507,
0.13077637553215027,
-0.1900816261768341,
-0.43994247913360596,
0.22489185631275177,
-0.3080420196056366,
-0.12266108393669128,
-0.5525201559066772,
0.47343647480010986,
-0.7255638837814331,
-0.5131927132606506,
0.2312416285276413,
0.45750391483306885,
0.009889406152069569,
-0.22806528210639954,
-0.7765054106712341,
0.6222611665725708,
0.1276767998933792,
-0.06715095043182373,
0.4272790551185608,
0.2215985804796219,
-0.3421604335308075,
0.6008888483047485,
0.8435770273208618,
0.13777276873588562,
0.3878217339515686,
0.12476326525211334,
0.7312480807304382,
-0.3644380569458008,
-0.5965827107429504,
-0.8415435552597046,
0.41278111934661865,
0.03407582268118858,
-0.11590919643640518,
0.6195530295372009,
0.38211023807525635,
0.7999465465545654,
-0.15809229016304016,
0.630729615688324,
0.5056526064872742,
0.2735763490200043,
-0.7528814077377319,
0.5428590178489685,
-0.7251195907592773,
0.4020080268383026,
-0.22602978348731995,
-1.0872262716293335,
-0.6693564653396606,
0.4529329538345337,
-0.08665920794010162,
-0.23754966259002686,
0.9910996556282043,
1.0183359384536743,
-0.22870369255542755,
0.020267527550458908,
0.4904564321041107,
0.2894948720932007,
0.08868195861577988,
0.5985878705978394,
0.8024706244468689,
-0.363594114780426,
0.47361335158348083,
-0.194696307182312,
-0.18583741784095764,
-0.34315767884254456,
-0.8978245854377747,
-0.839094340801239,
-0.5013375878334045,
-0.7325937747955322,
-0.018012333661317825,
0.1986982375383377,
0.9896109104156494,
0.6619441509246826,
-0.7849633693695068,
-0.21340373158454895,
-0.10439077764749527,
0.0809381902217865,
-0.42636188864707947,
-0.1269155740737915,
0.1880365014076233,
-0.914428174495697,
-0.6806967258453369,
0.640727698802948,
0.7028957009315491,
-0.08668645471334457,
-0.08225388824939728,
-0.1896706372499466,
-0.21804793179035187,
0.12693333625793457,
0.30693820118904114,
0.1927221119403839,
-1.1769260168075562,
-0.012999261729419231,
-0.06425873935222626,
-0.14858178794384003,
0.2466602772474289,
0.8181132674217224,
-0.6525909304618835,
0.8758317232131958,
0.33387669920921326,
0.9836543202400208,
0.6855408549308777,
-0.1740073561668396,
0.3251035213470459,
-0.927247166633606,
0.44820544123649597,
0.0005146730691194534,
0.06491205841302872,
0.23843500018119812,
-0.36547619104385376,
0.4609836935997009,
0.06418436765670776,
-0.31487828493118286,
-0.8286902904510498,
0.25446832180023193,
-1.145047664642334,
-0.09074641764163971,
1.094470500946045,
0.05277488753199577,
-0.10890801250934601,
-0.17983447015285492,
-0.5690282583236694,
0.23858383297920227,
-0.47938740253448486,
0.49352532625198364,
0.920653223991394,
0.025558190420269966,
-0.33353814482688904,
-0.6899136900901794,
0.6771281361579895,
0.9429076313972473,
-0.6672214865684509,
0.049051012843847275,
0.11527403444051743,
0.12101497501134872,
-0.16756495833396912,
0.44678300619125366,
-0.0839359238743782,
0.3231482207775116,
-0.2702806293964386,
-0.3035990595817566,
-0.5162597894668579,
-0.36588752269744873,
-0.6101524233818054,
-0.029111584648489952,
-0.010302991606295109,
-0.44209834933280945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10440v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10440v1
|
Retrieving and Refining: A Hybrid Framework with Large Language Models for Rare Disease Identification
| 2024-05-16T20:59:28 | 2024-05-16T20:59:28 |
Jinge Wu, Hang Dong, Zexi Li, Arijit Patra, Honghan Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The infrequency and heterogeneity of clinical presentations in rare diseases
often lead to underdiagnosis and their exclusion from structured datasets. This
necessitates the utilization of unstructured text data for comprehensive
analysis. However, the manual identification from clinical reports is an
arduous and intrinsically subjective task. This study proposes a novel hybrid
approach that synergistically combines a traditional dictionary-based natural
language processing (NLP) tool with the powerful capabilities of large language
models (LLMs) to enhance the identification of rare diseases from unstructured
clinical notes. We comprehensively evaluate various prompting strategies on six
large language models (LLMs) of varying sizes and domains (general and
medical). This evaluation encompasses zero-shot, few-shot, and
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) techniques to enhance the LLMs' ability to
reason about and understand contextual information in patient reports. The
results demonstrate effectiveness in rare disease identification, highlighting
the potential for identifying underdiagnosed patients from clinical notes.
|
[
0.03559856489300728,
-0.907274067401886,
0.7680890560150146,
0.06684083491563797,
-0.43204060196876526,
0.3511482775211334,
-0.45297276973724365,
-0.6960062384605408,
0.6608672738075256,
0.6513664722442627,
-0.5205680131912231,
-0.5919042825698853,
-0.396426260471344,
0.23131896555423737,
-0.4777916967868805,
1.0912503004074097,
0.009123817086219788,
0.3160351812839508,
-0.09861283004283905,
-0.2373669296503067,
-0.5203915238380432,
-0.3091040849685669,
-0.4131079316139221,
-0.34428671002388,
0.6111783385276794,
0.5303010940551758,
0.3803711235523224,
0.3515841066837311,
0.5036540031433105,
0.26415136456489563,
-0.1595698893070221,
0.40432804822921753,
-0.4812973737716675,
0.19437755644321442,
-0.15970870852470398,
-0.27644678950309753,
-0.5036166906356812,
-0.03442015126347542,
0.4417775571346283,
1.1406843662261963,
-0.09713903814554214,
0.04935874789953232,
0.1192631646990776,
0.3668888509273529,
-0.4638354480266571,
-0.2909107506275177,
-0.523816704750061,
0.32902246713638306,
-0.4865812063217163,
-0.5668767690658569,
-0.3572174906730652,
-0.010351658798754215,
0.2706546187400818,
-0.701453685760498,
0.4814290702342987,
-0.2948814034461975,
0.8443862199783325,
-0.14404386281967163,
-0.3712459206581116,
-0.4421897530555725,
-0.6522878408432007,
0.7440205812454224,
-0.624614953994751,
0.11073888093233109,
0.32928580045700073,
0.39418792724609375,
-0.037206582725048065,
-0.8060171008110046,
-0.3779274821281433,
-0.5512653589248657,
-0.17055103182792664,
0.08168450742959976,
-0.07088186591863632,
-0.10815928131341934,
0.21468810737133026,
0.6810229420661926,
-0.6225268244743347,
0.4917987287044525,
-0.37827202677726746,
-0.35902896523475647,
0.5112910866737366,
0.34243547916412354,
0.41788366436958313,
-0.3183521330356598,
-0.2389642298221588,
0.5077146887779236,
-0.5655726194381714,
-0.3248977065086365,
-0.08751223236322403,
0.5184425115585327,
-0.15485993027687073,
0.702539324760437,
-0.37926846742630005,
0.9266976118087769,
0.16767169535160065,
-0.33786246180534363,
0.5680158138275146,
-0.1627584844827652,
-0.012786788865923882,
-0.23534801602363586,
0.6464958786964417,
0.4268694818019867,
-0.002795339561998844,
-0.505048930644989,
-0.33585670590400696,
-0.21332553029060364,
0.13282550871372223,
-0.3559473156929016,
-0.0958937332034111,
0.39489877223968506,
-0.8628426790237427,
-0.3341948091983795,
-0.24290287494659424,
-1.1339218616485596,
-0.7880061864852905,
-0.2591736614704132,
0.4261387288570404,
-0.3333304524421692,
-0.3437594473361969,
-0.08389663696289062,
-0.3232189118862152,
-0.024826014414429665,
0.44526001811027527,
-0.9202003479003906,
0.19377796351909637,
0.43114984035491943,
0.5623327493667603,
-0.41697314381599426,
0.1591457724571228,
-0.9100902676582336,
0.3374078571796417,
0.0033649387769401073,
0.8950979113578796,
-0.818178117275238,
-0.5184668302536011,
-0.060655899345874786,
0.18240700662136078,
-0.07995226234197617,
-0.9211955070495605,
0.5012816190719604,
-0.28291434049606323,
0.07728933542966843,
-0.16074076294898987,
-0.29991039633750916,
0.11661405116319656,
0.07791972160339355,
-0.8549513220787048,
0.7784910202026367,
0.45107796788215637,
-0.7681203484535217,
0.5511602163314819,
-0.22342325747013092,
-0.4722680151462555,
0.6535654664039612,
-0.29043933749198914,
-0.2304525077342987,
0.4318431615829468,
0.20327641069889069,
0.4344475269317627,
-0.5281796455383301,
0.32110726833343506,
-0.2767800986766815,
-0.17582838237285614,
0.01449053455144167,
-0.39638274908065796,
0.46707284450531006,
0.3447328507900238,
0.14827083051204681,
0.0018720508087426424,
-1.01032555103302,
0.22877900302410126,
0.2553069293498993,
-0.49619925022125244,
-0.44074320793151855,
-0.13779322803020477,
0.09455444663763046,
-0.0678551122546196,
0.4178784191608429,
-0.4922280013561249,
0.3496830463409424,
-0.5820438861846924,
0.1620125025510788,
0.2287987619638443,
0.15076416730880737,
0.16368041932582855,
-0.6496031880378723,
0.6389145255088806,
0.11543410271406174,
-0.0013763473834842443,
-0.16386517882347107,
-0.388411283493042,
-0.3987753391265869,
-0.4213167130947113,
0.4955294728279114,
0.6931591629981995,
-0.6571566462516785,
0.2920114994049072,
-0.27374234795570374,
-0.28269433975219727,
-0.6628800630569458,
0.27098044753074646,
0.23449218273162842,
0.7075761556625366,
0.37633755803108215,
-0.21449875831604004,
-0.6243334412574768,
-0.6378322243690491,
-0.33464574813842773,
0.3317652642726898,
-0.17994314432144165,
0.5792924165725708,
0.1397934854030609,
-0.38110533356666565,
0.7559969425201416,
-0.188585102558136,
-0.30458158254623413,
-0.7629329562187195,
0.1238802969455719,
0.36323389410972595,
0.2680826783180237,
0.3132132589817047,
-0.6406515836715698,
-0.524298369884491,
0.3921866714954376,
-0.7751498818397522,
-0.3839258551597595,
-0.07907848805189133,
0.4478495419025421,
-0.013671129941940308,
0.537903904914856,
-0.4294579029083252,
0.5354894399642944,
0.3258141279220581,
0.07672514766454697,
0.24693194031715393,
-0.46761637926101685,
-0.0508095808327198,
-0.7815916538238525,
0.36817318201065063,
0.05017109587788582,
-0.2594887316226959,
-0.38627567887306213,
-0.003454080317169428,
-0.018809719011187553,
-0.1840171366930008,
-0.09843737632036209,
0.44900068640708923,
-0.6663432717323303,
0.2590484321117401,
-0.1953119933605194,
0.1413062959909439,
-0.0010867490200325847,
-0.010022112168371677,
0.16827057301998138,
0.16893629729747772,
0.5998609662055969,
-0.4293953478336334,
0.34385812282562256,
-0.2113238275051117,
-0.14346401393413544,
0.4515618085861206,
-0.7159998416900635,
-0.07439611107110977,
-0.21572765707969666,
0.30343616008758545,
-0.7391820549964905,
-0.26509907841682434,
0.1476251184940338,
-0.3248373866081238,
0.5472155213356018,
-0.3750532269477844,
-0.4744585454463959,
-0.7145586013793945,
0.0503513440489769,
0.3320905268192291,
0.23996663093566895,
-0.42619845271110535,
0.7421838045120239,
0.45469024777412415,
-0.3096134066581726,
-0.4405296742916107,
-0.5135581493377686,
-0.02462237887084484,
-0.22151531279087067,
-0.32973188161849976,
0.29994118213653564,
0.12171213328838348,
-0.2848857343196869,
-0.15682382881641388,
-0.12098641693592072,
-0.2810900807380676,
0.11718633770942688,
0.16620725393295288,
0.5084030628204346,
-0.42661401629447937,
0.1664505898952484,
0.0014069471508264542,
-0.23519296944141388,
-0.38306066393852234,
0.03186291083693504,
0.5251153111457825,
0.13812242448329926,
-0.45466431975364685,
-0.42144688963890076,
0.8114734888076782,
0.42150214314460754,
-0.13332189619541168,
0.3840595781803131,
0.29523882269859314,
-0.32411840558052063,
-0.3539165258407593,
-0.5111953020095825,
-0.1395375281572342,
-0.41979822516441345,
0.26600489020347595,
-0.2421465665102005,
-0.7788211703300476,
0.4482690989971161,
-0.3616082966327667,
-0.20112034678459167,
0.48777535557746887,
0.6577441096305847,
0.04164569452404976,
0.9406571388244629,
0.6537094712257385,
-0.12240846455097198,
-0.11407388001680374,
-0.025531021878123283,
0.31031572818756104,
-0.5950305461883545,
-0.279241681098938,
-0.543548583984375,
-0.08707072585821152,
-0.5180768370628357,
-0.3478062152862549,
0.5773354768753052,
0.0931084007024765,
0.6470103859901428,
-0.19116565585136414,
-0.5555800199508667,
0.6794757843017578,
0.15964142978191376,
0.27243396639823914,
0.5160455703735352,
-0.01979493908584118,
-0.40479758381843567,
-0.25808021426200867,
-0.6946985125541687,
-0.5134775638580322,
1.4974154233932495,
0.264468789100647,
0.6525737047195435,
0.0034861296880990267,
0.7646254897117615,
0.345681369304657,
0.5887331366539001,
-0.8944275975227356,
0.3082332909107208,
-0.295680969953537,
-0.5406681299209595,
-0.08785320818424225,
-0.4594442546367645,
-1.1199634075164795,
0.12175871431827545,
-0.396278440952301,
-0.9992115497589111,
-0.016545284539461136,
0.09442511945962906,
-0.9091919660568237,
0.021454257890582085,
-0.7642701268196106,
0.713391900062561,
-0.1882767677307129,
0.0024488710332661867,
-0.22847208380699158,
-0.6487603187561035,
0.475745290517807,
-0.25822150707244873,
0.23536664247512817,
0.10523873567581177,
-0.040251173079013824,
0.6029518246650696,
-0.5891315340995789,
0.8735986948013306,
0.022246092557907104,
-0.07311363518238068,
-0.0639960914850235,
-0.0398121178150177,
0.40334680676460266,
0.17903749644756317,
-0.02775220386683941,
-0.03708658739924431,
0.12457466125488281,
-0.23795662820339203,
-0.5411015152931213,
0.8621135950088501,
-0.4273543953895569,
-0.5159472227096558,
-0.26090535521507263,
-0.4359988570213318,
-0.5752198696136475,
0.2739254832267761,
0.3375793993473053,
0.7010601162910461,
-0.27799466252326965,
-0.003341825446113944,
0.6101381778717041,
-0.3995210826396942,
0.21854069828987122,
0.9751490950584412,
0.0761459618806839,
-0.09388536959886551,
0.9542163610458374,
0.013294758275151253,
0.24079319834709167,
0.43130308389663696,
0.25994259119033813,
-0.052975427359342575,
-0.8096461296081543,
-0.2881391644477844,
0.5386677980422974,
-0.604412317276001,
0.006323856767266989,
-0.8499080538749695,
-0.23093679547309875,
-0.41393837332725525,
-0.05384928360581398,
-0.04073423147201538,
-0.42296478152275085,
-0.5976445078849792,
0.1105777695775032,
0.36009716987609863,
0.7491697072982788,
-0.1652427315711975,
0.14534209668636322,
-0.9644309282302856,
0.7282410264015198,
0.14965833723545074,
0.23422224819660187,
0.230366051197052,
-0.5966730117797852,
-0.11690668016672134,
-0.13448674976825714,
-0.062466852366924286,
-0.9016279578208923,
0.578510046005249,
0.043212465941905975,
0.8252720832824707,
0.535224199295044,
0.01840139739215374,
0.6452349424362183,
-0.35883307456970215,
0.4056815803050995,
0.17678388953208923,
-0.5918074250221252,
0.5799192190170288,
-0.35474979877471924,
-0.12686514854431152,
0.704096257686615,
0.5744450092315674,
-0.6274311542510986,
-0.3503707945346832,
-0.8589798808097839,
-1.0009859800338745,
0.6124823093414307,
-0.40074974298477173,
-0.25081679224967957,
0.0013626943109557033,
0.1404532492160797,
0.19812823832035065,
0.04193612188100815,
-0.6101235151290894,
-0.1174272671341896,
0.2939888834953308,
-0.1557035595178604,
-0.1563919186592102,
-0.285600483417511,
-0.41742902994155884,
-0.38240405917167664,
0.26544609665870667,
-0.18433710932731628,
-0.013264424167573452,
0.3053963780403137,
-0.24834905564785004,
-0.3083055913448334,
0.2767561972141266,
0.3661865293979645,
0.594168484210968,
-0.13232798874378204,
-0.06075182184576988,
0.0776728019118309,
-0.33765897154808044,
-0.2984195649623871,
0.2320665866136551,
0.059654124081134796,
0.3377974331378937,
0.5397359132766724,
0.39175254106521606,
0.12391094863414764,
-0.9922821521759033,
0.7234517335891724,
0.11281031370162964,
0.030301250517368317,
-0.23980489373207092,
-0.1325741708278656,
-0.13034461438655853,
0.04415550455451012,
0.3778720498085022,
-0.2712475061416626,
0.20029683411121368,
-0.4243243932723999,
0.33106836676597595,
0.7480553388595581,
-0.31267890334129333,
-0.1746169924736023,
0.4182368218898773,
0.416395902633667,
-0.25362372398376465,
0.651800274848938,
-0.00921352207660675,
-0.08874285221099854,
0.5226365923881531,
0.5775806307792664,
0.5241798758506775,
0.2368352711200714,
0.3244064152240753,
0.0849137231707573,
0.10377561300992966,
-0.027496397495269775,
0.24028033018112183,
-0.18369890749454498,
-0.5068172812461853,
-0.5444372892379761,
-0.6176500916481018,
-0.056753356009721756,
0.5836246609687805,
-0.6589135527610779,
0.2626573443412781,
-0.48069053888320923,
-0.025034062564373016,
0.5795088410377502,
0.11046310514211655,
-0.2290734201669693,
-0.0021919396240264177,
0.3138231635093689,
0.8200024962425232,
-1.0097529888153076,
0.7458908557891846,
0.3409454822540283,
-0.41679924726486206,
-0.8719044923782349,
0.09498724341392517,
0.3348824083805084,
-0.8555912971496582,
0.6371648907661438,
0.03484034165740013,
0.4712403416633606,
-0.11913114041090012,
-0.4365743398666382,
-0.6203212738037109,
0.6493476033210754,
-0.06398371607065201,
-0.6857508420944214,
-0.02615852653980255,
0.039200205355882645,
0.7297328114509583,
-0.31630998849868774,
0.359393835067749,
0.7012046575546265,
0.5511425137519836,
0.4581807255744934,
-1.4273755550384521,
0.01787143014371395,
-0.4076234698295593,
-0.3656473159790039,
0.3179244101047516,
-0.190998837351799,
0.6599547266960144,
-0.5436772704124451,
-0.23707489669322968,
0.5353108048439026,
0.29074832797050476,
0.42846131324768066,
0.5054334998130798,
0.25500816106796265,
0.6425745487213135,
1.0864332914352417,
0.13942094147205353,
1.0177383422851562,
0.03895508870482445,
0.003514200681820512,
0.8040871620178223,
-0.522360622882843,
0.5520009398460388,
0.3979858160018921,
0.11289093643426895,
0.2869788706302643,
0.29820170998573303,
-0.07471521198749542,
0.43356621265411377,
0.19414305686950684,
-0.37153545022010803,
-0.3531399369239807,
-0.13882555067539215,
-0.4607563316822052,
0.18948568403720856,
0.6266807913780212,
-0.5636877417564392,
-0.641601026058197,
0.1230136975646019,
-0.08358277380466461,
-0.008730803616344929,
-0.2854691743850708,
0.77613365650177,
0.016075024381279945,
-0.6678938269615173,
0.8929265737533569,
-0.0175276231020689,
0.5263738632202148,
-0.618549108505249,
-0.08871090412139893,
-0.10517160594463348,
0.1689441204071045,
-0.239327073097229,
-0.4397547245025635,
0.18373622000217438,
-0.022893939167261124,
-0.3993583023548126,
0.06336985528469086,
0.5175684094429016,
-0.39389726519584656,
-0.5601892471313477,
0.08942683041095734,
0.6035698056221008,
0.14831481873989105,
0.17633455991744995,
-0.6588736772537231,
-0.0008790326537564397,
0.024251358583569527,
0.23934923112392426,
0.4074600636959076,
0.7753850221633911,
-0.461065411567688,
0.5939213633537292,
0.6812121868133545,
0.4659495949745178,
-0.37707531452178955,
0.40056514739990234,
0.7800461649894714,
-0.6540701985359192,
-0.1687629073858261,
-0.48563140630722046,
0.23007000982761383,
-0.2191617786884308,
-0.42582815885543823,
0.7464145421981812,
0.3932952284812927,
0.2633668780326843,
0.02005775272846222,
0.6679967641830444,
-0.04094806686043739,
1.1652828454971313,
-0.4807317554950714,
0.6215617060661316,
-0.7473442554473877,
0.43903034925460815,
-0.33824560046195984,
-0.07772824913263321,
-0.41185399889945984,
0.24391494691371918,
-0.30462825298309326,
0.05552619695663452,
0.7182628512382507,
0.8140262365341187,
-0.12350237369537354,
-0.02973776124417782,
0.1003696471452713,
0.36075374484062195,
0.06706377118825912,
0.7239248156547546,
0.8638420104980469,
0.13169972598552704,
0.21520066261291504,
0.07849405705928802,
-0.42512813210487366,
-0.4641251564025879,
-0.6366420388221741,
-0.8150454163551331,
-0.29326826333999634,
-0.38852134346961975,
-0.4060841202735901,
0.008601929992437363,
0.743351399898529,
0.6096943020820618,
-0.7040987014770508,
0.1531165987253189,
0.18272779881954193,
-0.0025993450544774532,
-0.19911837577819824,
-0.21694430708885193,
0.180073544383049,
0.005120266228914261,
-0.4188278019428253,
0.7768213748931885,
0.4414779841899872,
0.10055112093687057,
-0.02617640793323517,
0.29153215885162354,
0.039206378161907196,
-0.3322871923446655,
0.28719475865364075,
0.7923492789268494,
-0.69744873046875,
0.3169185221195221,
-0.30956366658210754,
-0.1489132046699524,
-0.14143329858779907,
1.1553623676300049,
-1.2332128286361694,
0.34359627962112427,
0.3387684226036072,
0.4009072184562683,
0.20369799435138702,
-0.019747255370020866,
0.5567818284034729,
-0.45556551218032837,
0.35408154129981995,
0.8535125255584717,
0.15445247292518616,
0.15431740880012512,
-0.44247904419898987,
0.08390292525291443,
0.5742504596710205,
-0.21048708260059357,
-1.0243324041366577,
-0.10655481368303299,
-1.2022435665130615,
-0.4255770444869995,
1.2116369009017944,
0.18510755896568298,
-0.2510349452495575,
-0.7149567604064941,
-0.09609314799308777,
-0.2087392956018448,
-0.19297361373901367,
0.692314863204956,
0.2977350950241089,
-0.14964161813259125,
0.05085648223757744,
-0.4658087491989136,
0.4922005832195282,
0.4416733384132385,
-0.4503019452095032,
0.07579734176397324,
0.5751562118530273,
0.3952197730541229,
-0.0556812547147274,
0.9076926708221436,
-0.4042293131351471,
0.4262838065624237,
-0.4211517572402954,
-0.3843800127506256,
0.30387216806411743,
-0.2709710896015167,
-0.3911064863204956,
0.19734205305576324,
-0.19735272228717804,
0.3039853274822235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10431v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10431v1
|
Thinking Fair and Slow: On the Efficacy of Structured Prompts for Debiasing Language Models
| 2024-05-16T20:27:58 | 2024-05-16T20:27:58 |
Shaz Furniturewala, Surgan Jandial, Abhinav Java, Pragyan Banerjee, Simra Shahid, Sumit Bhatia, Kokil Jaidka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Existing debiasing techniques are typically training-based or require access
to the model's internals and output distributions, so they are inaccessible to
end-users looking to adapt LLM outputs for their particular needs. In this
study, we examine whether structured prompting techniques can offer
opportunities for fair text generation. We evaluate a comprehensive
end-user-focused iterative framework of debiasing that applies System 2
thinking processes for prompts to induce logical, reflective, and critical text
generation, with single, multi-step, instruction, and role-based variants. By
systematically evaluating many LLMs across many datasets and different
prompting strategies, we show that the more complex System 2-based Implicative
Prompts significantly improve over other techniques demonstrating lower mean
bias in the outputs with competitive performance on the downstream tasks. Our
work offers research directions for the design and the potential of
end-user-focused evaluative frameworks for LLM use.
|
[
0.002972878748551011,
-1.0167655944824219,
0.7759600281715393,
0.4703196883201599,
-0.23211559653282166,
-0.2149929404258728,
-0.23720180988311768,
-0.0973694771528244,
-0.2406454235315323,
0.12687921524047852,
-0.5808127522468567,
-0.31754979491233826,
-0.44207605719566345,
0.3655785024166107,
-0.3426972031593323,
1.099273920059204,
-0.033586543053388596,
0.28600502014160156,
-0.1401015967130661,
0.18104441463947296,
-0.7848781943321228,
-0.22941887378692627,
-0.8218846321105957,
-0.3797571659088135,
0.42232629656791687,
0.8130534887313843,
0.773675799369812,
0.20038390159606934,
0.17311103641986847,
0.20937755703926086,
-0.1149912029504776,
-0.2200503945350647,
-0.5718330144882202,
0.7016780376434326,
-0.396968275308609,
-0.5717777609825134,
-0.190248042345047,
0.44915884733200073,
0.376020610332489,
0.6186542510986328,
-0.28642144799232483,
0.24478086829185486,
0.3382917046546936,
0.6630876064300537,
-0.7257477045059204,
-0.14333978295326233,
-0.6792670488357544,
0.12219328433275223,
-0.14043407142162323,
-0.2437470257282257,
-0.7064663767814636,
-0.6062071919441223,
-0.007620675954967737,
-0.5251718759536743,
-0.0749707818031311,
0.06890539079904556,
0.3618864417076111,
0.511003315448761,
-0.22304466366767883,
-0.6747645735740662,
-0.5583420395851135,
0.9197505116462708,
-0.7705974578857422,
0.06723548471927643,
0.2812623381614685,
0.4164629280567169,
-0.26175984740257263,
-0.5550334453582764,
-0.6502640843391418,
-0.16292588412761688,
0.0714796781539917,
0.32725998759269714,
-0.14672133326530457,
0.022135192528367043,
0.43166011571884155,
-0.006692528259009123,
-0.4021153748035431,
0.29317551851272583,
-0.2722746431827545,
0.0788346529006958,
0.4679664373397827,
0.2830861210823059,
0.0380173996090889,
-0.32652992010116577,
-0.5628268718719482,
0.07304632663726807,
-0.7040450572967529,
0.3555281162261963,
0.6990523338317871,
0.37566137313842773,
-0.14437128603458405,
0.5565743446350098,
-0.3489505350589752,
0.5038995146751404,
0.22474390268325806,
-0.08716046065092087,
0.26704493165016174,
-0.17429815232753754,
-0.41215628385543823,
0.007893280126154423,
0.777131199836731,
0.8386526107788086,
0.5223931670188904,
0.13067620992660522,
-0.6287675499916077,
0.2711729109287262,
-0.026350179687142372,
-0.9482259750366211,
0.14128176867961884,
0.38796883821487427,
-0.569367527961731,
-0.418403297662735,
-0.2242567390203476,
-0.7439899444580078,
-0.45951560139656067,
-0.41112226247787476,
0.26368674635887146,
-0.22556722164154053,
0.08478060364723206,
0.23988576233386993,
-0.342224657535553,
-0.03118314780294895,
0.3850698471069336,
-0.8457851409912109,
0.35978153347969055,
0.36094629764556885,
0.6403049230575562,
-0.1493329256772995,
0.12118814140558243,
-0.8312103748321533,
-0.012986992485821247,
-0.32048529386520386,
0.7541772127151489,
-0.8079419136047363,
-0.4637441635131836,
0.009338947013020515,
-0.4173693060874939,
0.13440074026584625,
-0.5503079295158386,
0.6098036766052246,
-0.2948435842990875,
0.5988774299621582,
-0.3940012454986572,
-0.18759283423423767,
0.14346715807914734,
0.27760130167007446,
-0.5548398494720459,
1.3183751106262207,
0.19204838573932648,
-0.8797532916069031,
0.5889131426811218,
-0.3560219407081604,
-0.3966330289840698,
-0.031198976561427116,
-0.5015317797660828,
-0.0910930186510086,
0.20073112845420837,
0.20101520419120789,
0.32838988304138184,
-0.5736308693885803,
0.6903718113899231,
-0.2683509886264801,
-0.5973796248435974,
0.2944440245628357,
-0.6653985977172852,
0.7341160774230957,
0.4770810902118683,
-0.6891316771507263,
0.1768725961446762,
-0.556059718132019,
0.158156156539917,
-0.07476578652858734,
-0.5129956603050232,
-0.28663188219070435,
0.022632284089922905,
-0.015718845650553703,
0.2885049879550934,
-0.09076350182294846,
-0.32141271233558655,
0.010007276199758053,
-0.4342016279697418,
0.28155580163002014,
1.0675630569458008,
-0.1148056834936142,
0.6051291227340698,
-0.33754727244377136,
0.6661540269851685,
0.14760372042655945,
0.2573902904987335,
-0.3224436640739441,
-0.3892124891281128,
-0.4865652918815613,
-0.2039753496646881,
0.06685951352119446,
0.7533072233200073,
-0.8116512894630432,
0.03397735208272934,
0.17989419400691986,
-0.12268751859664917,
-0.5000353455543518,
-0.016355620697140694,
0.6458301544189453,
0.786000669002533,
0.09823386371135712,
-0.1760360598564148,
-0.2887667715549469,
-1.023422360420227,
-0.3983409106731415,
-0.07219824194908142,
0.06791429221630096,
0.2620813846588135,
0.34241706132888794,
0.11606979370117188,
0.9238212704658508,
-0.33893248438835144,
0.05662503093481064,
-0.24970421195030212,
-0.07448626309633255,
0.3767473101615906,
0.23607926070690155,
0.5663040280342102,
-0.5907580256462097,
-0.7182949781417847,
-0.6789575219154358,
-0.65333092212677,
-0.49765291810035706,
-0.1553739458322525,
-0.007853149436414242,
0.2841418981552124,
0.4390292465686798,
-0.22485192120075226,
0.5158365368843079,
0.08299332857131958,
-0.4841676354408264,
0.4988209903240204,
-0.0659443661570549,
0.22223474085330963,
-0.774372398853302,
0.11348148435354233,
-0.20453786849975586,
-0.21105092763900757,
-0.4622955620288849,
-0.19409812986850739,
-0.29589396715164185,
0.0013637053780257702,
-0.39499375224113464,
0.7339490652084351,
-0.3380396366119385,
0.05998464673757553,
-0.3370037376880646,
0.46792417764663696,
0.12219870090484619,
0.26775404810905457,
-0.30807819962501526,
0.9282525777816772,
0.4531746506690979,
-0.6843644380569458,
-0.14057336747646332,
0.2932060658931732,
-0.4482337236404419,
0.6765642762184143,
-0.800904393196106,
0.2948300838470459,
-0.4802103638648987,
0.2877640128135681,
-1.0265302658081055,
-0.027305694296956062,
0.5970763564109802,
-0.18300123512744904,
0.04913318157196045,
0.06436898559331894,
-0.4012710154056549,
-0.1996922641992569,
-0.7178357839584351,
0.32415148615837097,
0.7144913673400879,
-0.31158366799354553,
-0.05700531229376793,
0.1669619381427765,
-0.5295709371566772,
-0.8774935007095337,
-0.8598552346229553,
0.03466117009520531,
-0.23595069348812103,
-0.44819337129592896,
0.27084827423095703,
-0.4525318741798401,
-0.7663071155548096,
-0.10257411748170853,
-0.007622226607054472,
0.1863948106765747,
0.5133366584777832,
0.26462268829345703,
0.09947231411933899,
0.17692430317401886,
-0.11481114476919174,
0.5314364433288574,
-0.2226434350013733,
0.00351983611471951,
-0.3156004846096039,
0.2123887836933136,
0.17402537167072296,
-0.2849390506744385,
-0.5215764045715332,
0.6604216694831848,
0.1484948694705963,
0.10912065953016281,
0.21301211416721344,
0.11756197363138199,
-0.3162517845630646,
-0.6493129730224609,
-0.2887294590473175,
-0.31430479884147644,
-0.4895975589752197,
-0.024563197046518326,
-0.3312872350215912,
-0.8975710272789001,
0.36910280585289,
0.12685613334178925,
0.19018486142158508,
-0.043415095657110214,
0.9312911033630371,
0.031139066442847252,
1.03512704372406,
0.49333637952804565,
0.41577595472335815,
0.478184312582016,
0.1500973403453827,
0.3759760558605194,
-0.42363160848617554,
-0.31882888078689575,
-0.7179243564605713,
-0.6134348511695862,
-0.2925024628639221,
-0.46198776364326477,
0.18773074448108673,
0.48943132162094116,
-0.2105204313993454,
-0.30027568340301514,
-0.6964507699012756,
0.5183337926864624,
0.7007431387901306,
0.02508828602731228,
0.3384251594543457,
0.0010501275537535548,
-0.5080606341362,
-0.04135314002633095,
-0.6373207569122314,
-1.0003070831298828,
0.8622826933860779,
0.19768507778644562,
0.8922527432441711,
-0.0649181455373764,
0.5569148063659668,
0.5308921933174133,
0.46649783849716187,
-0.8039669990539551,
0.536797821521759,
-0.003419493092224002,
-0.5609206557273865,
-0.274912565946579,
-0.17581704258918762,
-0.5267626643180847,
-0.02804805152118206,
0.014919963665306568,
-0.5540339350700378,
0.2702067792415619,
0.2725466191768646,
-0.6067461967468262,
-0.21358732879161835,
-0.6445176601409912,
0.4937736988067627,
0.01213656086474657,
-0.45888200402259827,
-0.10057726502418518,
-0.6649762988090515,
0.22598153352737427,
0.08962737768888474,
0.43945586681365967,
-0.29261502623558044,
-0.09028655290603638,
0.6710009574890137,
-0.21401560306549072,
0.9217052459716797,
-0.6365137100219727,
-0.28400918841362,
0.8166401386260986,
0.3477638065814972,
0.4740599989891052,
0.3904959559440613,
-0.6519759297370911,
-0.25504499673843384,
-0.3557632267475128,
-0.018266184255480766,
-0.60800701379776,
0.5562642216682434,
-0.27620360255241394,
-0.7159185409545898,
-0.1556187868118286,
-0.4502096176147461,
-0.11502362042665482,
0.12147940695285797,
0.30648112297058105,
0.45842111110687256,
-0.07208660989999771,
-0.09537611156702042,
0.5135670900344849,
-0.16167034208774567,
0.7000308632850647,
0.40289774537086487,
-0.046863853931427,
-0.4345124661922455,
0.34574997425079346,
-0.11315426230430603,
0.18868033587932587,
0.16853128373622894,
0.30546894669532776,
-0.21976953744888306,
-0.6760589480400085,
-0.5890979766845703,
-0.4478923976421356,
-0.803403377532959,
-0.44635531306266785,
-0.467386394739151,
0.3670499920845032,
-0.4097312092781067,
-0.32106927037239075,
0.06369613856077194,
-0.8352344632148743,
-0.2846510112285614,
-0.34782904386520386,
0.13483227789402008,
0.8141008615493774,
-0.026549044996500015,
0.4891403317451477,
-0.4194731116294861,
0.07982978969812393,
-0.0026718536391854286,
0.36886873841285706,
-0.02400425635278225,
-0.3571127951145172,
-0.026652706786990166,
0.003187144873663783,
-0.44034895300865173,
-0.9381392002105713,
0.0702563226222992,
-0.028558053076267242,
0.5599115490913391,
0.3386974334716797,
0.23518319427967072,
0.23515547811985016,
-0.6426721215248108,
0.9695998430252075,
0.324534147977829,
-1.0166176557540894,
0.5848212242126465,
-0.24147477746009827,
-0.08545058220624924,
0.8633748292922974,
0.24880647659301758,
-0.4148724377155304,
-0.5538451671600342,
-0.1795421689748764,
-0.7484602928161621,
0.8920766115188599,
0.07019876688718796,
0.23080459237098694,
-0.39832544326782227,
0.5047164559364319,
0.5687379240989685,
0.4300578832626343,
-0.7049528956413269,
-0.10699425637722015,
-0.17370560765266418,
-0.5207932591438293,
0.3274061381816864,
-0.5015401840209961,
-0.0645437017083168,
0.21538162231445312,
0.5814364552497864,
-0.4636721909046173,
-0.056686535477638245,
0.4983374774456024,
-0.10389990359544754,
-0.1631186604499817,
0.6757298111915588,
0.46825340390205383,
0.4912341833114624,
0.13554559648036957,
0.14920909702777863,
-0.019312994554638863,
-0.12291598320007324,
0.2918548285961151,
-0.14272034168243408,
-0.8132642507553101,
-0.056757502257823944,
-0.0112442122772336,
0.8100563287734985,
0.26675286889076233,
-0.8074629902839661,
0.6158040165901184,
0.021980730816721916,
-0.3105740249156952,
0.1389886885881424,
0.2582683563232422,
-0.18432645499706268,
0.4124043881893158,
0.24279385805130005,
-0.1660993993282318,
0.4527224600315094,
-0.5081446766853333,
0.1469854861497879,
0.3539060652256012,
-0.5449550747871399,
-0.3319454789161682,
0.9658442735671997,
0.44738131761550903,
-0.2658590078353882,
0.5115418434143066,
-0.5033413767814636,
-0.3961617648601532,
0.39665788412094116,
0.6675626635551453,
1.054858684539795,
-0.1627436876296997,
0.3093718886375427,
0.26860201358795166,
0.26507315039634705,
-0.12815935909748077,
0.8762685656547546,
-0.13952040672302246,
-0.4847010374069214,
-0.4742050766944885,
-0.5214597582817078,
-0.33800551295280457,
-0.10935378074645996,
-0.4836648106575012,
0.5979124903678894,
-0.5062927603721619,
-0.32081249356269836,
-0.3761567175388336,
-0.13175781071186066,
-0.48762211203575134,
0.18388448655605316,
0.21823205053806305,
1.17166268825531,
-0.715084969997406,
0.2947287857532501,
0.5277988910675049,
-0.3474682569503784,
-0.8214444518089294,
-0.04540843144059181,
0.08221516013145447,
-0.5343552231788635,
0.7821081876754761,
0.3634009063243866,
-0.23547907173633575,
-0.2441859245300293,
-0.7782156467437744,
-0.37028950452804565,
1.0185208320617676,
0.4980636537075043,
-0.7015174031257629,
-0.2879379093647003,
-0.01581188477575779,
0.19344787299633026,
-0.4314706027507782,
0.6599801778793335,
0.3247799873352051,
0.6576530933380127,
-0.11079087853431702,
-0.7740079164505005,
0.4627443253993988,
-0.22380560636520386,
-0.10358263552188873,
-0.14092078804969788,
-0.6488837599754333,
0.920624852180481,
-0.6025851964950562,
-0.4850330054759979,
0.010507084429264069,
0.3851703107357025,
0.31728988885879517,
0.6454434990882874,
0.6931213736534119,
0.42881569266319275,
0.8963640928268433,
0.2053002417087555,
0.7450612187385559,
-0.17441405355930328,
0.014888576231896877,
1.3165074586868286,
-0.7914751172065735,
0.4550302028656006,
0.5898301005363464,
0.20941264927387238,
0.7436913251876831,
0.496295690536499,
0.1484546661376953,
0.5932102799415588,
0.47155749797821045,
-0.061659783124923706,
-0.1258639395236969,
-0.3428999185562134,
-0.12561775743961334,
0.15621532499790192,
0.21800214052200317,
-0.30700576305389404,
-0.45823705196380615,
0.06500616669654846,
0.26813456416130066,
0.4831874668598175,
0.01343453861773014,
0.6941661238670349,
0.3640536963939667,
-0.9535417556762695,
0.2466922104358673,
0.1863606870174408,
0.7748544216156006,
-0.3709079623222351,
-0.09519793093204498,
-0.3311098515987396,
-0.032173607498407364,
-0.23122674226760864,
-0.8500433564186096,
0.1795622706413269,
0.41180941462516785,
-0.4718666970729828,
-0.8331855535507202,
0.7385956048965454,
-0.21563442051410675,
-0.07939471304416656,
0.2786157429218292,
0.756630003452301,
0.12414301931858063,
0.12636534869670868,
-0.6754215359687805,
-0.05828552693128586,
0.16799026727676392,
-0.7662845253944397,
-0.09952741116285324,
0.5157995223999023,
-0.40052157640457153,
0.5311607718467712,
0.4706483781337738,
-0.18690478801727295,
-0.2024860680103302,
0.47313764691352844,
0.8143689036369324,
-0.7396530508995056,
-0.4553941786289215,
-0.9621710777282715,
0.6815483570098877,
0.06370225548744202,
-0.3216533064842224,
0.5867727994918823,
0.6457205414772034,
0.7890127301216125,
0.1923712193965912,
0.9885407090187073,
-0.13772250711917877,
0.4439542293548584,
-0.5888491272926331,
0.4945407509803772,
-0.23172664642333984,
0.4009762108325958,
-0.11646164208650589,
-0.8458998203277588,
0.005106837954372168,
0.3425147235393524,
-0.18082663416862488,
0.06555644422769547,
0.7359069585800171,
0.7319095730781555,
0.28581953048706055,
0.1608293652534485,
0.056116774678230286,
0.05685071274638176,
0.4151321351528168,
0.6334536075592041,
1.0345884561538696,
-0.10357008874416351,
0.44677481055259705,
0.03186642751097679,
-0.5682619214057922,
-0.10264304280281067,
-0.9992090463638306,
-0.9729485511779785,
-0.3361888825893402,
-0.04730626940727234,
-0.525379478931427,
0.18021097779273987,
1.0674738883972168,
0.26492345333099365,
-0.4304942488670349,
-0.031835418194532394,
-0.10259266942739487,
0.2176811546087265,
0.06938392668962479,
-0.22864530980587006,
0.062027521431446075,
-0.6435335874557495,
-0.9410558938980103,
0.5590465068817139,
0.2592133581638336,
-0.029452990740537643,
-0.20571710169315338,
0.019391557201743126,
0.20616604387760162,
0.394826740026474,
0.4766886234283447,
-0.4214511811733246,
-0.3737896978855133,
-0.23621506989002228,
0.16741842031478882,
-0.35272249579429626,
-0.10390029102563858,
1.0334539413452148,
-1.188877820968628,
0.25963878631591797,
0.7244419455528259,
0.22488489747047424,
-0.05897701531648636,
-0.039413031190633774,
0.6998035907745361,
-0.6159992814064026,
0.26752567291259766,
0.45789721608161926,
0.14733758568763733,
0.4155208468437195,
-0.4463155269622803,
0.4589120149612427,
0.07831201702356339,
-0.38148292899131775,
-0.9605932235717773,
0.43089476227760315,
-0.665876567363739,
-0.38115033507347107,
1.2265928983688354,
0.02884487807750702,
-0.11623603105545044,
-0.10727442800998688,
-0.29221388697624207,
0.13338148593902588,
-0.7546833753585815,
0.6510850787162781,
0.5244022607803345,
-0.08576598018407822,
0.48131048679351807,
-0.48885059356689453,
0.5526047945022583,
0.6365355849266052,
-0.8010783195495605,
0.3438026010990143,
0.6963204741477966,
0.2503304183483124,
-0.24983909726142883,
1.1620843410491943,
-0.1909729540348053,
0.10312113910913467,
-0.018725061789155006,
-0.18911698460578918,
-0.12502281367778778,
-0.48145073652267456,
-0.39229652285575867,
0.08051037043333054,
-0.010053887963294983,
0.2520548701286316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10426v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10426v1
|
Memory-efficient Energy-adaptive Inference of Pre-Trained Models on Batteryless Embedded Systems
| 2024-05-16T20:16:45 | 2024-05-16T20:16:45 |
Pietro Farina, Subrata Biswas, Eren Yıldız, Khakim Akhunov, Saad Ahmed, Bashima Islam, Kasım Sinan Yıldırım
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Batteryless systems frequently face power failures, requiring extra runtime
buffers to maintain inference progress and leaving only a memory space for
storing ultra-tiny deep neural networks (DNNs). Besides, making these models
responsive to stochastic energy harvesting dynamics during inference requires a
balance between inference accuracy, latency, and energy overhead. Recent works
on compression mostly focus on time and memory, but often ignore energy
dynamics or significantly reduce the accuracy of pre-trained DNNs. Existing
energy-adaptive inference works modify the architecture of pre-trained models
and have significant memory overhead. Thus, energy-adaptive and accurate
inference of pre-trained DNNs on batteryless devices with extreme memory
constraints is more challenging than traditional microcontrollers. We combat
these issues by proposing FreeML, a framework to optimize pre-trained DNN
models for memory-efficient and energy-adaptive inference on batteryless
systems. FreeML comprises (1) a novel compression technique to reduce the model
footprint and runtime memory requirements simultaneously, making them
executable on extremely memory-constrained batteryless platforms; and (2) the
first early exit mechanism that uses a single exit branch for all exit points
to terminate inference at any time, making models energy-adaptive with minimal
memory overhead. Our experiments showed that FreeML reduces the model sizes by
up to $95 \times$, supports adaptive inference with a $2.03-19.65 \times$ less
memory overhead, and provides significant time and energy benefits with only a
negligible accuracy drop compared to the state-of-the-art.
|
[
0.006400395650416613,
-0.10337995737791061,
0.7520608305931091,
-0.19830583035945892,
-0.5336986184120178,
0.09706297516822815,
-0.22501854598522186,
-0.26585838198661804,
0.16328556835651398,
0.21141155064105988,
-0.44027039408683777,
-0.2871355712413788,
-0.10323919355869293,
-0.3472670614719391,
-0.1725301295518875,
0.5353240966796875,
0.045799437910318375,
0.04603574052453041,
-0.5210666060447693,
-0.17577329277992249,
-0.18558578193187714,
-0.10218948125839233,
-0.12445113062858582,
-0.33786430954933167,
0.2301381677389145,
0.19431394338607788,
0.4977213144302368,
0.5093512535095215,
0.302031934261322,
0.10958878695964813,
-0.07185237854719162,
0.13656702637672424,
-0.2518725097179413,
-0.005672507919371128,
0.13239499926567078,
-0.29964497685432434,
-0.4278506934642792,
0.10431680828332901,
0.3252324163913727,
0.5787471532821655,
-0.4093588590621948,
0.35323479771614075,
-0.192190021276474,
0.701865017414093,
-1.1610921621322632,
-0.19200611114501953,
-0.8433585166931152,
0.36514022946357727,
0.20708604156970978,
-0.21696044504642487,
-0.6192060112953186,
-0.057544637471437454,
-0.20363877713680267,
-0.8387772440910339,
0.3702680766582489,
0.0031383901368826628,
0.48740366101264954,
0.653718888759613,
-0.21177782118320465,
0.18737024068832397,
-0.8849064111709595,
0.808807373046875,
-0.6817043423652649,
0.3361434042453766,
0.22849448025226593,
0.2645588517189026,
0.1958143711090088,
-0.6488286256790161,
-0.6175405979156494,
-0.09145449846982956,
0.07003795355558395,
0.5683421492576599,
-0.3142329454421997,
0.3767486810684204,
0.16409550607204437,
0.4007705748081207,
-0.4918130934238434,
0.2023964524269104,
0.12522666156291962,
0.18663953244686127,
0.4917040467262268,
0.1407824456691742,
-0.16459761559963226,
-0.044380445033311844,
-0.48040124773979187,
0.056110966950654984,
-1.0189357995986938,
-0.20894497632980347,
0.4256363809108734,
0.3515525162220001,
-0.2618559002876282,
-0.07451075315475464,
0.01092078909277916,
0.7006365060806274,
0.011030858382582664,
0.4336169362068176,
0.027903325855731964,
-0.1582643985748291,
-0.5572822690010071,
0.4216625690460205,
0.6968003511428833,
0.6261320114135742,
0.051894571632146835,
-0.16305600106716156,
-0.3905899226665497,
-0.23021528124809265,
0.29771119356155396,
-1.1254321336746216,
-0.8436040878295898,
0.5614943504333496,
-0.7934186458587646,
-0.31806090474128723,
-0.3175596594810486,
-0.7814731001853943,
-0.21975623071193695,
0.22382435202598572,
0.6106715202331543,
-0.142913356423378,
-0.5750673413276672,
0.3086809515953064,
-0.20761682093143463,
-0.11019942909479141,
0.4315735101699829,
-1.1121349334716797,
0.27807968854904175,
0.4039238691329956,
1.080893635749817,
0.17620247602462769,
0.23588329553604126,
-0.5553394556045532,
0.18797773122787476,
-0.34847500920295715,
0.5117015242576599,
-0.29944977164268494,
-0.45875200629234314,
-0.4030722975730896,
-0.1935921162366867,
-0.19994916021823883,
-0.5662691593170166,
0.0009099001181311905,
-0.6540162563323975,
-0.18896201252937317,
0.12217449396848679,
-0.7966444492340088,
-0.024762555956840515,
-0.2745833396911621,
-0.7321521043777466,
0.772195041179657,
-0.05265837535262108,
-0.402424693107605,
0.24326270818710327,
-0.8317210674285889,
-0.09834614396095276,
-0.09018617123365402,
0.1439448893070221,
-0.44040215015411377,
0.5394360423088074,
-0.074552521109581,
0.44282451272010803,
-0.4873805046081543,
-0.09430995583534241,
-0.30383676290512085,
-0.3775220811367035,
-0.19812524318695068,
-0.5354245901107788,
0.5749306678771973,
0.3048197329044342,
-0.43975594639778137,
0.3584029972553253,
-1.085778832435608,
0.2612481713294983,
0.2598094046115875,
0.030698580667376518,
-0.5206426382064819,
0.20394785702228546,
-0.15313820540905,
-0.12700572609901428,
0.08666224032640457,
-0.7451124787330627,
0.16737134754657745,
-0.11265884339809418,
0.31684473156929016,
0.9437724351882935,
-0.12887048721313477,
0.57094806432724,
-0.24050042033195496,
0.3354857265949249,
-0.12086796015501022,
0.4141457676887512,
-0.01576046086847782,
-0.13467949628829956,
-0.6856819987297058,
-0.24046353995800018,
0.3023686110973358,
0.5490118265151978,
-0.6365289688110352,
0.49869346618652344,
-0.3573048710823059,
-0.893589198589325,
-0.38270828127861023,
-0.014156079851090908,
0.25102224946022034,
0.49885934591293335,
0.8159870505332947,
-0.06023760139942169,
-0.3475903868675232,
-0.6019172072410583,
-0.11678123474121094,
-0.09824927151203156,
-0.274011492729187,
0.5289208889007568,
0.49448949098587036,
0.1975216269493103,
0.7436456680297852,
-0.39395007491111755,
0.3323521614074707,
-0.008527073077857494,
-0.14307048916816711,
0.32539239525794983,
0.9838261008262634,
0.537865936756134,
-0.8058577179908752,
-0.10885483026504517,
-0.2718481719493866,
-0.5343639254570007,
0.06090856343507767,
-0.3628828823566437,
0.10018961131572723,
-0.15737658739089966,
0.0009974666172638535,
-1.1215249300003052,
0.4930061101913452,
0.5716466903686523,
-0.18192332983016968,
0.8687392473220825,
-0.3861457407474518,
-0.18590471148490906,
-0.938811182975769,
0.1479436159133911,
-0.42664456367492676,
-0.1350099742412567,
-0.6082678437232971,
-0.24150633811950684,
0.3764136731624603,
0.000084833794971928,
-0.515407383441925,
0.6763294339179993,
-0.7321769595146179,
-0.08298756182193756,
-0.32945823669433594,
-0.2764144837856293,
0.1753515750169754,
0.11968512088060379,
0.053363699465990067,
0.8804395198822021,
0.3340366780757904,
-0.9410862326622009,
0.30663686990737915,
-0.14712148904800415,
-0.5284329056739807,
-0.17747990787029266,
-0.3843318223953247,
0.3376223146915436,
0.1517307311296463,
0.07167281210422516,
-0.5532549619674683,
0.10819441825151443,
-0.005451503675431013,
-0.21490806341171265,
0.464796781539917,
-0.053185902535915375,
-0.29074543714523315,
-0.1959865242242813,
-0.42038029432296753,
0.5597347021102905,
0.6151161193847656,
-0.8498454689979553,
0.6320727467536926,
-0.019387438893318176,
0.6705676317214966,
-0.5104858875274658,
-0.6392466425895691,
-0.18543408811092377,
-0.005415754858404398,
-0.1583811193704605,
0.5623677372932434,
-0.24457527697086334,
-0.2866891920566559,
0.2309255301952362,
-0.483402818441391,
-0.16371560096740723,
0.5092493295669556,
0.24107490479946136,
0.38784080743789673,
-0.47577378153800964,
0.3970813453197479,
0.08884811401367188,
-0.17116177082061768,
-0.17340993881225586,
-0.8414611220359802,
0.4742409288883209,
0.004824860021471977,
-0.42512306571006775,
-0.6529338955879211,
0.37585020065307617,
0.6443386673927307,
0.15988779067993164,
0.781268835067749,
0.26623332500457764,
-0.48555999994277954,
-0.19205260276794434,
-0.2745310366153717,
-0.1967805176973343,
-0.4789007902145386,
-0.019395597279071808,
-0.29228323698043823,
-0.8329835534095764,
0.1977849304676056,
-0.19263266026973724,
0.15028263628482819,
0.4635816514492035,
0.33138149976730347,
-0.00021637810277752578,
0.6269228458404541,
0.5519667267799377,
0.29201245307922363,
0.6108006238937378,
-0.18717454373836517,
0.10818052291870117,
-0.8678242564201355,
0.053717758506536484,
-0.24224665760993958,
-0.5239551663398743,
-0.3559015095233917,
-0.5619746446609497,
0.04606655612587929,
0.3011947572231293,
-0.38231566548347473,
0.2188069373369217,
-0.7872154116630554,
0.5174259543418884,
0.37775754928588867,
-0.016521289944648743,
-0.002896215533837676,
0.019976258277893066,
-0.23926998674869537,
0.17366042733192444,
-0.8939071297645569,
-0.351175457239151,
0.9035253524780273,
-0.17791128158569336,
0.9250497221946716,
0.13716548681259155,
0.46234309673309326,
0.179303839802742,
0.3077293634414673,
-0.6441291570663452,
0.4529811441898346,
-0.06825635582208633,
-0.5492826700210571,
0.00922926515340805,
-0.6609493494033813,
-0.8700445294380188,
0.12625154852867126,
-0.05429232120513916,
-1.0341922044754028,
0.28558945655822754,
0.5874510407447815,
-0.9716450572013855,
1.1816402673721313,
-0.8175764679908752,
0.7058646082878113,
-0.3460726737976074,
-0.5373169779777527,
-0.4979805648326874,
-0.6589280366897583,
0.16070842742919922,
0.118484728038311,
-0.299970418214798,
-0.31440791487693787,
-0.3071880340576172,
0.7337499260902405,
-0.7044724822044373,
0.6648250222206116,
-0.7585216164588928,
0.19448211789131165,
0.3935815989971161,
0.034924350678920746,
0.386434942483902,
-0.09360699355602264,
-0.3374077379703522,
0.33162596821784973,
0.03086000308394432,
-0.6408200860023499,
-0.6734684705734253,
0.463580846786499,
-0.5338063836097717,
-0.5726971626281738,
-0.14374388754367828,
-0.47705721855163574,
-0.2638319432735443,
0.28488242626190186,
0.26736679673194885,
0.12003355473279953,
-0.15174907445907593,
0.2673916816711426,
0.7110130190849304,
-0.4348958432674408,
0.8152103424072266,
0.4185470640659332,
0.016049642115831375,
-0.29826679825782776,
0.7908964157104492,
0.05784086138010025,
0.5774620771408081,
0.6529659628868103,
0.15884441137313843,
-0.1976996511220932,
-0.7792273759841919,
-0.9160321950912476,
-0.2198738008737564,
-0.20141959190368652,
-0.5872977375984192,
-0.6408653259277344,
-0.10630808025598526,
-0.276752769947052,
-0.2408757358789444,
-0.9457988142967224,
-0.7518349885940552,
-0.6237239837646484,
-0.30791112780570984,
0.6908039450645447,
0.4731174111366272,
-0.5040042996406555,
0.5701878070831299,
-0.9671643972396851,
0.12987180054187775,
0.2230740636587143,
0.3164750635623932,
0.3498995900154114,
-0.14334970712661743,
-0.2829263508319855,
-0.1551033854484558,
-0.15255573391914368,
-0.6976640224456787,
0.11644240468740463,
0.4542810022830963,
0.23812885582447052,
0.4922886788845062,
0.16003237664699554,
0.6442174315452576,
-0.3173307776451111,
0.9384642243385315,
0.632967472076416,
-0.8866136074066162,
0.5096265077590942,
-0.055555086582899094,
0.4240826666355133,
0.42576009035110474,
0.3239321708679199,
-0.23272229731082916,
0.6232100129127502,
-0.5393718481063843,
-0.9018393158912659,
0.20402105152606964,
-0.056348007172346115,
0.31403252482414246,
0.10216488689184189,
0.5630696415901184,
0.1701095700263977,
0.4205362796783447,
-0.2928624153137207,
-0.17433497309684753,
-0.3647954761981964,
-0.2663496732711792,
0.019924912601709366,
-0.21169522404670715,
0.08900440484285355,
-0.3132222592830658,
0.6842581629753113,
-0.3062773048877716,
0.676781952381134,
0.27551475167274475,
-0.11857706308364868,
-0.02809031493961811,
0.12897735834121704,
0.5473268032073975,
0.318990558385849,
-0.5691678524017334,
0.3637275993824005,
0.2276710867881775,
-0.6510916352272034,
0.6568315029144287,
0.10521648079156876,
-0.2876451909542084,
0.11083993315696716,
0.03501353785395622,
0.973232090473175,
0.2065107524394989,
-0.6011203527450562,
0.4136311411857605,
-0.5416178107261658,
-0.11183003336191177,
-0.18567149341106415,
0.33810535073280334,
0.19139964878559113,
0.1388246715068817,
0.4047328531742096,
0.3747282922267914,
-0.2424587458372116,
0.03747870773077011,
0.22581830620765686,
0.4136556088924408,
-0.5879953503608704,
-0.41964173316955566,
0.6974464058876038,
0.1984274536371231,
-0.1431325376033783,
0.5776318907737732,
-0.2762749195098877,
-0.035840295255184174,
0.5838054418563843,
0.5677475333213806,
1.0990946292877197,
-0.3676636517047882,
-0.208455890417099,
0.31459441781044006,
0.32145294547080994,
0.1448628157377243,
0.36248064041137695,
-0.7138040661811829,
-0.7690249681472778,
-0.4090108573436737,
-0.907560408115387,
-0.4508565366268158,
0.0989803597331047,
-0.7499805688858032,
-0.34555694460868835,
-0.9808401465415955,
-0.0231720469892025,
-0.3113516867160797,
-0.04926644265651703,
-0.5011341571807861,
0.3737429678440094,
0.12436076253652573,
1.5388798713684082,
-0.4474497139453888,
0.9342271089553833,
0.2654549777507782,
0.2594512701034546,
-0.8110792636871338,
-0.055929530411958694,
-0.03430077061057091,
-0.5238121151924133,
0.2535649240016937,
0.39535799622535706,
-0.45034268498420715,
0.21239131689071655,
-0.5253295302391052,
-0.8258756399154663,
1.1563431024551392,
0.4840993285179138,
-0.6817479729652405,
0.025366267189383507,
-0.5465863943099976,
0.09056664258241653,
-0.32018133997917175,
0.37447449564933777,
0.16354762017726898,
0.31884974241256714,
-0.2623489797115326,
-0.7983788251876831,
0.1707904040813446,
-0.5199013352394104,
-0.14623917639255524,
0.35669252276420593,
-0.9583193063735962,
0.8751595616340637,
-0.40360403060913086,
-0.2614012062549591,
0.5514806509017944,
0.6638516783714294,
0.021032586693763733,
0.4051789343357086,
0.7234266400337219,
0.7386468052864075,
1.21830415725708,
0.18014545738697052,
0.9668313264846802,
-0.59002286195755,
0.40607500076293945,
1.0776865482330322,
-0.43444082140922546,
0.7711041569709778,
0.4128406047821045,
-0.03499181196093559,
0.4344784915447235,
0.7873099446296692,
-0.015515162609517574,
0.8564323782920837,
0.3031880259513855,
-0.892741858959198,
-0.5498701333999634,
-0.07172412425279617,
-0.6176215410232544,
0.4274543225765228,
0.33593329787254333,
-0.37578392028808594,
-0.04154304042458534,
-0.07551644742488861,
-0.2575567960739136,
-0.5898647904396057,
-0.4425090253353119,
0.4844781458377838,
0.18975862860679626,
-0.370311439037323,
0.6115503907203674,
-0.24798230826854706,
0.6721550226211548,
-0.5323372483253479,
-0.0003598600742407143,
0.0946168527007103,
0.37218841910362244,
-0.2341219186782837,
-0.22238948941230774,
0.25361472368240356,
0.06708772480487823,
-0.49274829030036926,
-0.3427903652191162,
1.035779356956482,
0.23729760944843292,
-0.24091514945030212,
0.5247510671615601,
0.5377904176712036,
0.3994458317756653,
-0.19505010545253754,
-0.5259412527084351,
-0.28943929076194763,
-0.02489023096859455,
-0.5412499308586121,
0.43387332558631897,
0.003251962596550584,
0.530223548412323,
0.4702434837818146,
0.8558855652809143,
0.18747949600219727,
0.005636894144117832,
-0.22703883051872253,
0.8880407214164734,
-0.796867847442627,
-0.3308209776878357,
-0.8794755339622498,
0.2254808247089386,
-0.05122887343168259,
-0.30135542154312134,
0.5249030590057373,
0.6172693371772766,
0.6739635467529297,
0.05540135130286217,
0.5977732539176941,
0.03409961238503456,
0.19102874398231506,
-0.814869225025177,
1.0936827659606934,
-0.9405564069747925,
-0.08967071771621704,
0.05156971141695976,
-0.5139945149421692,
-0.2787199020385742,
0.5689922571182251,
-0.2461671680212021,
0.17249175906181335,
0.5034278035163879,
0.7999944090843201,
-0.318293958902359,
0.30535298585891724,
0.551584005355835,
0.08996527642011642,
0.25506842136383057,
0.7810878753662109,
0.7220701575279236,
-0.31849709153175354,
0.3031967878341675,
-0.2919633984565735,
-0.17157012224197388,
-0.085577093064785,
-1.113321304321289,
-0.260256290435791,
-0.012934337370097637,
-0.19984690845012665,
-0.3067895174026489,
0.026001296937465668,
1.0555477142333984,
1.108129620552063,
-0.8199999928474426,
0.04991860315203667,
-0.3178505599498749,
0.14944027364253998,
-0.2634064853191376,
-0.11938866972923279,
0.3525058329105377,
0.05582357197999954,
-0.3595498204231262,
0.8900201916694641,
0.6964415907859802,
0.06932339817285538,
-0.027378015220165253,
-0.20906060934066772,
-0.23694740235805511,
0.11824379116296768,
0.41796624660491943,
0.3266584277153015,
-0.14529737830162048,
-0.42794808745384216,
-0.1675989180803299,
0.16261069476604462,
0.27618104219436646,
0.993629515171051,
-0.815848171710968,
0.512814462184906,
0.08423253893852234,
0.7811288237571716,
0.5062781572341919,
-0.18988920748233795,
0.1371983289718628,
-0.7205259203910828,
0.48988771438598633,
0.5562535524368286,
0.3626864552497864,
0.31957700848579407,
-0.41658467054367065,
0.23258137702941895,
0.6717069745063782,
-0.6237236857414246,
-0.7837498784065247,
0.2640381157398224,
-0.8264332413673401,
-0.48542001843452454,
0.7923789024353027,
-0.26568880677223206,
-0.6309948563575745,
0.20501340925693512,
0.6328874826431274,
0.45776301622390747,
-0.19719941914081573,
0.5747200846672058,
0.2696473300457001,
-0.5936374664306641,
-0.33873194456100464,
-0.7570891976356506,
0.4869133234024048,
0.8017891049385071,
-0.5746920108795166,
0.3105962574481964,
0.3739112615585327,
0.18184708058834076,
0.23810715973377228,
0.7777419090270996,
0.3897211253643036,
0.516581118106842,
0.5006920099258423,
0.2250986397266388,
-0.008654773235321045,
-0.3532712161540985,
-0.3528689444065094,
0.1536128968000412,
-0.2964172065258026,
-0.6414666771888733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10385v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10385v2
|
AmazUtah_NLP at SemEval-2024 Task 9: A MultiChoice Question Answering System for Commonsense Defying Reasoning
| 2024-05-16T18:26:38 | 2024-05-20T05:21:13 |
Mina Ghashami, Soumya Smruti Mishra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
The SemEval 2024 BRAINTEASER task represents a pioneering venture in Natural
Language Processing (NLP) by focusing on lateral thinking, a dimension of
cognitive reasoning that is often overlooked in traditional linguistic
analyses. This challenge comprises of Sentence Puzzle and Word Puzzle subtasks
and aims to test language models' capacity for divergent thinking.
In this paper, we present our approach to the BRAINTEASER task. We employ a
holistic strategy by leveraging cutting-edge pre-trained models in multiple
choice architecture, and diversify the training data with Sentence and Word
Puzzle datasets. To gain further improvement, we fine-tuned the model with
synthetic humor or jokes dataset and the RiddleSense dataset which helped
augmenting the model's lateral thinking abilities. Empirical results show that
our approach achieve 92.5% accuracy in Sentence Puzzle subtask and 80.2%
accuracy in Word Puzzle subtask.
|
[
-0.50248783826828,
-0.8646138906478882,
0.4676317870616913,
0.35684096813201904,
-0.33692896366119385,
-0.005164177156984806,
0.10198093950748444,
-0.3654964566230774,
0.22555860877037048,
0.6648393273353577,
-0.9663088917732239,
-0.30528852343559265,
-0.4623897075653076,
0.3085717260837555,
0.11011626571416855,
0.8501653671264648,
0.0900261253118515,
0.06387478858232498,
-0.2743885815143585,
-0.4523738622665405,
-1.0308712720870972,
-0.300898939371109,
-0.8173568844795227,
-0.37935978174209595,
0.3181462287902832,
0.3155423104763031,
0.5010471343994141,
0.1832198202610016,
0.25292953848838806,
0.2699127197265625,
0.0353427529335022,
0.185556560754776,
-0.14303751289844513,
0.09390823543071747,
-0.6945401430130005,
-0.47079840302467346,
-0.4766156077384949,
-0.06981728971004486,
0.024251313880085945,
0.5921030640602112,
-0.1753423660993576,
0.005783230531960726,
-0.15014858543872833,
0.6445282697677612,
-0.3927018642425537,
-0.10411848872900009,
-0.7877479791641235,
0.046567413955926895,
-0.15857745707035065,
-0.1804763376712799,
-0.2472526580095291,
-0.12357394397258759,
0.000028269399990676902,
-0.37007975578308105,
-0.08160277456045151,
0.01687253639101982,
0.5866108536720276,
0.6053581237792969,
-0.5413614511489868,
-0.14926376938819885,
-0.1448756456375122,
0.7596756219863892,
-0.7325871586799622,
0.5053833723068237,
0.4039722681045532,
0.3943760395050049,
0.23970314860343933,
-0.5091094970703125,
-0.4073513150215149,
0.1669592559337616,
0.3579246401786804,
0.22612932324409485,
-0.17413274943828583,
-0.2819070518016815,
0.06765817850828171,
-0.0703735500574112,
-0.7744789719581604,
-0.020948540419340134,
-0.405705064535141,
-0.2146444320678711,
0.743262767791748,
0.3793887197971344,
0.3197157680988312,
-0.1846742182970047,
-0.46374213695526123,
0.16147126257419586,
-0.3053204417228699,
0.177291139960289,
0.203184574842453,
-0.022906145080924034,
0.22805798053741455,
0.6448508501052856,
-0.5505920648574829,
0.4627041816711426,
0.06984409689903259,
0.38510754704475403,
0.42618435621261597,
-0.5522807240486145,
-0.13205279409885406,
-0.06389334052801132,
0.4397805333137512,
0.2928644120693207,
0.18219870328903198,
-0.08590137958526611,
-0.176697239279747,
0.2798902094364166,
0.5103750824928284,
-0.3897635340690613,
-0.31932660937309265,
0.6329417824745178,
-0.13941539824008942,
-0.17355899512767792,
-0.6159316301345825,
-0.7410285472869873,
-0.30918049812316895,
-0.2917526364326477,
0.5095610618591309,
-0.9215010404586792,
-0.030220424756407738,
0.5129778981208801,
-0.32450470328330994,
0.24701900780200958,
0.32321611046791077,
-0.7061029076576233,
0.11814497411251068,
0.5703970789909363,
0.41880396008491516,
-0.19124402105808258,
-0.4978082776069641,
-0.5890964865684509,
-0.011353474110364914,
-0.13004498183727264,
1.1826112270355225,
-0.6346251964569092,
0.116425059735775,
-0.48548755049705505,
-0.013795364648103714,
-0.09128212183713913,
-0.3355165719985962,
0.7968522310256958,
-0.6309328675270081,
0.14354076981544495,
-0.5023043155670166,
-0.535552442073822,
-0.47314512729644775,
0.6563544273376465,
-0.5832827687263489,
0.7188572287559509,
-0.2272525280714035,
-0.9269161820411682,
0.238210529088974,
-0.9260109066963196,
-0.4799194931983948,
0.3411490321159363,
-0.00028465932700783014,
-0.06850701570510864,
-0.1245560422539711,
0.8287249207496643,
0.3627784252166748,
-0.12737934291362762,
0.4275474548339844,
-0.3748152554035187,
-0.014967598952353,
0.1413661539554596,
-0.48989278078079224,
1.278686285018921,
0.10813522338867188,
-0.3760310113430023,
0.011171041056513786,
-0.5026214718818665,
0.20039178431034088,
0.21550050377845764,
-0.2294309288263321,
-0.4407300651073456,
-0.22874173521995544,
-0.21494418382644653,
0.43158045411109924,
0.28515830636024475,
-0.5548436045646667,
0.16026638448238373,
-0.7059107422828674,
0.4893794357776642,
0.5779162049293518,
0.19918063282966614,
0.3174844980239868,
-0.2529836893081665,
0.7186596989631653,
0.27248746156692505,
0.11419598758220673,
-0.11033099889755249,
-0.7837227582931519,
-0.6550294756889343,
0.004513120744377375,
0.17276035249233246,
0.9512192010879517,
-1.1606909036636353,
0.2504892945289612,
-0.12616613507270813,
-0.4852881133556366,
-0.6299017667770386,
-0.1279343068599701,
0.08420202136039734,
0.4119429290294647,
0.7669973969459534,
-0.17052681744098663,
-0.5242090225219727,
-1.10805344581604,
-0.7364959120750427,
0.21536317467689514,
0.2748340666294098,
0.021748274564743042,
0.7959336042404175,
-0.2752420902252197,
0.6144875884056091,
-0.5034000873565674,
-0.10206791013479233,
-0.38385701179504395,
0.3682929277420044,
0.11577976495027542,
0.30684542655944824,
0.111887626349926,
-0.7227668762207031,
-0.05013296753168106,
-0.29742351174354553,
-0.6142328381538391,
-0.25447723269462585,
-0.06780475378036499,
-0.163564532995224,
0.12470782548189163,
0.4525092840194702,
-0.5525180101394653,
0.31022968888282776,
0.31138086318969727,
-0.4771346151828766,
0.5267334580421448,
0.014630165882408619,
0.1312757134437561,
-0.9802643656730652,
-0.08631683886051178,
-0.3286925256252289,
-0.022090109065175056,
-0.7137826681137085,
0.22176696360111237,
0.046820227056741714,
0.06095725670456886,
-0.43872910737991333,
0.4391511380672455,
-0.3801269233226776,
0.23066815733909607,
-0.21584992110729218,
-0.004836383741348982,
0.08296184241771698,
0.5755137205123901,
0.039025112986564636,
0.5693279504776001,
0.3438320755958557,
-0.47180140018463135,
0.32429733872413635,
0.30561545491218567,
-0.21160219609737396,
0.7380796074867249,
-0.6718555092811584,
0.4289373457431793,
-0.3861263394355774,
0.09818515181541443,
-0.9527423977851868,
0.02184789441525936,
-0.07326246798038483,
-0.3998218774795532,
-0.23043318092823029,
0.31044378876686096,
-0.23875954747200012,
-0.5072405934333801,
-0.192413330078125,
0.4788391590118408,
0.06088097393512726,
-0.4250011444091797,
0.7556014060974121,
0.7081795334815979,
-0.5034657716751099,
-0.8241190314292908,
-0.8615122437477112,
0.1782604604959488,
-0.47002848982810974,
-0.7925812005996704,
0.22183182835578918,
-0.17757682502269745,
-0.05906979367136955,
-0.09783565998077393,
-0.0013394117122516036,
-0.1460488885641098,
0.08660901337862015,
-0.09490956366062164,
0.18469324707984924,
-0.055951908230781555,
0.14473895728588104,
0.305368572473526,
-0.06683405488729477,
0.30642205476760864,
-0.21298807859420776,
0.6911308765411377,
-0.477903813123703,
-0.31586238741874695,
0.023687636479735374,
0.3905446231365204,
0.10967424511909485,
-0.5880123972892761,
0.33114856481552124,
0.5606729388237,
-0.3496384918689728,
-0.41837120056152344,
-0.7042667865753174,
-0.10943742096424103,
-0.41976800560951233,
0.47818776965141296,
-0.5990890264511108,
-0.9847896099090576,
0.4380313754081726,
0.068814218044281,
0.21550679206848145,
0.3950231075286865,
0.6175969243049622,
0.05250954255461693,
1.0241426229476929,
0.2604953348636627,
0.15847089886665344,
-0.29964888095855713,
-0.10764282941818237,
0.30421555042266846,
-0.8601536154747009,
-0.30168768763542175,
-0.1577853113412857,
-0.4072819650173187,
-0.13222873210906982,
-0.6569268703460693,
0.3168909549713135,
-0.14468955993652344,
-0.18662428855895996,
0.49790894985198975,
-0.4786450266838074,
0.5825948119163513,
0.5102744102478027,
-0.00006266940908972174,
0.20698876678943634,
-0.3177497088909149,
-0.49178817868232727,
-0.08879067003726959,
-0.6630866527557373,
-0.3400968611240387,
0.8778423070907593,
0.2865716516971588,
0.4115619361400604,
0.16290253400802612,
0.6508147716522217,
-0.06116573140025139,
-0.16237525641918182,
-0.5797122120857239,
0.8345794081687927,
0.03872201219201088,
-0.9038631319999695,
-0.44127053022384644,
-0.15980133414268494,
-0.9682739973068237,
0.5510561466217041,
0.01011692639440298,
-0.6131423711776733,
0.13004609942436218,
-0.1766463816165924,
-0.5202900171279907,
0.010353956371545792,
-0.4744893014431,
1.0538352727890015,
-0.2877555191516876,
-0.2672368288040161,
-0.38137224316596985,
-0.7276987433433533,
0.5338873267173767,
-0.04819931462407112,
0.2500240206718445,
-0.07775617390871048,
-0.17789998650550842,
0.7240312695503235,
0.09464553743600845,
0.5695710182189941,
-0.07941902428865433,
-0.03767424076795578,
0.4060107469558716,
0.1823197454214096,
0.21954506635665894,
0.19777171313762665,
-0.03648883476853371,
0.13612426817417145,
0.1804119348526001,
-0.3264995515346527,
-0.4954802393913269,
0.41688159108161926,
-0.46870672702789307,
-0.8276227116584778,
-0.38676562905311584,
-0.7916383147239685,
-0.6090049743652344,
0.3357507884502411,
0.1115674376487732,
0.24477888643741608,
-0.28169697523117065,
0.17548033595085144,
0.5754233002662659,
-0.291614830493927,
0.4210323691368103,
0.3492686152458191,
0.016143573448061943,
-0.590851366519928,
0.5370076894760132,
0.17131781578063965,
-0.06217924878001213,
0.2848043441772461,
0.1461549997329712,
-0.6029888987541199,
-0.44454455375671387,
-0.3106321096420288,
0.07424623519182205,
-0.8992750644683838,
-0.14716070890426636,
-1.0346193313598633,
-0.3703738749027252,
-0.425839364528656,
-0.0903998538851738,
-0.32119259238243103,
-0.49956852197647095,
0.10162021964788437,
-0.08849412202835083,
-0.056465279310941696,
0.3287148177623749,
0.012915232218801975,
-0.2272695153951645,
-0.7183202505111694,
0.267424613237381,
0.48069867491722107,
-0.05436680093407631,
-0.19323782622814178,
-0.5938559770584106,
0.00965025182813406,
0.1724540740251541,
-0.4322037696838379,
-1.0577350854873657,
0.5451603531837463,
-0.1802784502506256,
0.5698244571685791,
0.04372352734208107,
-0.007446977309882641,
0.5867480039596558,
-0.6804283857345581,
0.7254891395568848,
-0.021495848894119263,
-0.8302395939826965,
0.8629277348518372,
-0.3289470970630646,
0.8630725741386414,
0.7835480570793152,
0.46148765087127686,
-0.3889056444168091,
-0.4199771583080292,
-0.8426827192306519,
-0.6052204370498657,
0.42809557914733887,
0.11380162835121155,
0.01768600568175316,
-0.09078904241323471,
-0.024485141038894653,
0.24309493601322174,
0.20328670740127563,
-0.6374717950820923,
0.18775096535682678,
-0.318113774061203,
-0.16248343884944916,
-0.06286311894655228,
0.16599051654338837,
-0.05259634181857109,
-0.4151783287525177,
0.7190164923667908,
-0.23744650185108185,
0.05882001668214798,
0.06639455258846283,
-0.16045254468917847,
0.2756534516811371,
0.6450369358062744,
0.4500892162322998,
0.5433564186096191,
0.030234890058636665,
0.2672993540763855,
0.6696188449859619,
-0.3355245292186737,
0.09343072026968002,
0.12473390251398087,
-0.02689773216843605,
-0.2491683065891266,
0.25832921266555786,
0.7029100060462952,
-0.033407267183065414,
-0.7412016987800598,
0.549649178981781,
0.09501853585243225,
-0.35648518800735474,
-0.20704308152198792,
0.021939199417829514,
0.6555801630020142,
0.43907347321510315,
0.02741507813334465,
0.42843177914619446,
0.6156277060508728,
-0.4930720925331116,
0.3161332607269287,
0.49024346470832825,
-0.23500697314739227,
-0.38038551807403564,
0.7286192178726196,
0.06347008794546127,
-0.07730506360530853,
0.5818567276000977,
-0.3248734176158905,
-0.808205783367157,
0.6260640025138855,
0.5076026916503906,
0.8460859060287476,
-0.35209107398986816,
0.25734591484069824,
0.31389957666397095,
0.5942837595939636,
0.15079279243946075,
0.6998249888420105,
0.15492267906665802,
-1.037018060684204,
-0.5586033463478088,
-0.4397522807121277,
-0.12656165659427643,
0.3833913505077362,
-0.2785910665988922,
0.3592495322227478,
-0.26298144459724426,
-0.20500798523426056,
0.245930477976799,
0.0296392273157835,
-0.7693753838539124,
0.2986759543418884,
0.2093871384859085,
0.9912464618682861,
-0.7879805564880371,
0.7192215919494629,
0.9325348138809204,
-0.47406530380249023,
-0.7107459306716919,
-0.16582125425338745,
-0.001262787263840437,
-0.7604586482048035,
0.8076759576797485,
0.275696724653244,
-0.07326057553291321,
0.08040180802345276,
-0.4478193521499634,
-0.6750745177268982,
0.8605996966362,
0.09885723888874054,
-0.19251470267772675,
-0.09993702173233032,
0.0918644368648529,
0.3996523320674896,
-0.37673965096473694,
0.2703142762184143,
0.5739344358444214,
0.4581742584705353,
0.21907736361026764,
-0.6714381575584412,
0.15185555815696716,
-0.3856640160083771,
-0.13677561283111572,
0.035390984266996384,
-0.5830178260803223,
0.8776274919509888,
-0.26683613657951355,
-0.14563316106796265,
-0.333249032497406,
0.7328271269798279,
0.5186411738395691,
0.277423620223999,
0.6730723977088928,
0.9785455465316772,
0.6826412677764893,
0.22345629334449768,
0.597237765789032,
0.03391202166676521,
-0.04065829887986183,
1.343008041381836,
-0.47092944383621216,
1.005664348602295,
0.5760393738746643,
0.00918410625308752,
0.4890657663345337,
0.42205268144607544,
0.016513023525476456,
0.6024888753890991,
0.06026427447795868,
0.04789376258850098,
-0.46385037899017334,
0.06406283378601074,
-0.034992314875125885,
0.7414225935935974,
0.3682229518890381,
0.33026689291000366,
-0.3934989869594574,
0.3336467146873474,
-0.2546965479850769,
0.03639066591858864,
-0.1575508415699005,
0.5885577201843262,
0.15443101525306702,
-1.0564789772033691,
0.44053399562835693,
0.16028618812561035,
0.6661092042922974,
-0.25139710307121277,
0.030824193730950356,
-0.14710703492164612,
0.15157724916934967,
0.0680965855717659,
-0.9786387085914612,
0.674430787563324,
-0.22727365791797638,
0.28561490774154663,
-0.17676743865013123,
0.9227080345153809,
-0.31711745262145996,
-0.4000316858291626,
0.08324992656707764,
0.7417874336242676,
0.16192203760147095,
-0.21051181852817535,
-1.1026082038879395,
-0.2571602463722229,
0.08772240579128265,
-0.1664661020040512,
-0.051315974444150925,
0.7446249127388,
-0.1840674728155136,
0.7622395753860474,
0.4675777852535248,
-0.0816190168261528,
0.08619476109743118,
0.06127568706870079,
0.7411292791366577,
-0.743726372718811,
-0.9010812044143677,
-0.8106398582458496,
0.5673325061798096,
-0.2489115297794342,
-0.5687939524650574,
0.7242367267608643,
0.6130550503730774,
0.6568222045898438,
-0.2240060567855835,
0.5401220321655273,
0.10163798183202744,
0.5019484758377075,
-0.49855485558509827,
0.4677684009075165,
-0.5503711104393005,
0.1538867950439453,
-0.1017308384180069,
-0.6544411182403564,
-0.07913265377283096,
0.6605340838432312,
-0.7506273984909058,
0.0685337632894516,
1.1034647226333618,
0.6867740154266357,
-0.10900227725505829,
0.6821122169494629,
0.2853362262248993,
0.12089826911687851,
-0.025743640959262848,
0.9919706583023071,
1.0146249532699585,
-0.440733939409256,
0.29350507259368896,
-0.2116895467042923,
-0.08997798711061478,
0.060345496982336044,
-0.636013388633728,
-1.1531566381454468,
-0.6385683417320251,
-0.2735741436481476,
-0.051108986139297485,
-0.06740377843379974,
0.7640759348869324,
0.35106322169303894,
-0.7360709309577942,
-0.06916721165180206,
-0.33551764488220215,
-0.23004497587680817,
-0.33062177896499634,
-0.2812863886356354,
0.027469951659440994,
-0.5396571755409241,
-0.47069889307022095,
0.5537087917327881,
0.5139498710632324,
-0.39581188559532166,
-0.1780044585466385,
0.2707822024822235,
-0.8230642676353455,
0.49887359142303467,
0.6530696749687195,
-0.26594623923301697,
-0.7111669182777405,
-0.2976340651512146,
0.240946963429451,
0.11400242894887924,
0.0003190728893969208,
0.40542787313461304,
-0.7696472406387329,
0.24292930960655212,
0.6244653463363647,
1.1076911687850952,
0.42843160033226013,
0.02434503473341465,
0.3972682058811188,
-0.2818011939525604,
-0.04697464033961296,
0.7505944967269897,
0.27824050188064575,
0.35054177045822144,
-0.37652215361595154,
0.6988398432731628,
0.20804762840270996,
-0.5225903987884521,
-0.44613003730773926,
0.31230273842811584,
-0.7714765667915344,
-0.7682451009750366,
0.8803020119667053,
0.19928085803985596,
-0.4267912805080414,
-0.4847930073738098,
-0.2139214724302292,
0.05079459026455879,
-0.06606688350439072,
0.5535761713981628,
1.0081826448440552,
-0.22399701178073883,
-0.33607521653175354,
-0.7117787599563599,
0.2815112769603729,
1.0042216777801514,
-1.0650839805603027,
-0.14951211214065552,
0.3872390389442444,
0.3077089488506317,
0.28867751359939575,
0.8250858783721924,
-0.0968291386961937,
0.27224332094192505,
0.08795346319675446,
-0.01938977651298046,
0.07428157329559326,
-0.3271637260913849,
-0.3527233600616455,
0.345819890499115,
-0.4411909282207489,
0.013992613181471825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10313v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10313v1
|
How Far Are We From AGI
| 2024-05-16T17:59:02 | 2024-05-16T17:59:02 |
Tao Feng, Chuanyang Jin, Jingyu Liu, Kunlun Zhu, Haoqin Tu, Zirui Cheng, Guanyu Lin, Jiaxuan You
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
The evolution of artificial intelligence (AI) has profoundly impacted human
society, driving significant advancements in multiple sectors. Yet, the
escalating demands on AI have highlighted the limitations of AI's current
offerings, catalyzing a movement towards Artificial General Intelligence (AGI).
AGI, distinguished by its ability to execute diverse real-world tasks with
efficiency and effectiveness comparable to human intelligence, reflects a
paramount milestone in AI evolution. While existing works have summarized
specific recent advancements of AI, they lack a comprehensive discussion of
AGI's definitions, goals, and developmental trajectories. Different from
existing survey papers, this paper delves into the pivotal questions of our
proximity to AGI and the strategies necessary for its realization through
extensive surveys, discussions, and original perspectives. We start by
articulating the requisite capability frameworks for AGI, integrating the
internal, interface, and system dimensions. As the realization of AGI requires
more advanced capabilities and adherence to stringent constraints, we further
discuss necessary AGI alignment technologies to harmonize these factors.
Notably, we emphasize the importance of approaching AGI responsibly by first
defining the key levels of AGI progression, followed by the evaluation
framework that situates the status-quo, and finally giving our roadmap of how
to reach the pinnacle of AGI. Moreover, to give tangible insights into the
ubiquitous impact of the integration of AI, we outline existing challenges and
potential pathways toward AGI in multiple domains. In sum, serving as a
pioneering exploration into the current state and future trajectory of AGI,
this paper aims to foster a collective comprehension and catalyze broader
public discussions among researchers and practitioners on AGI.
|
[
-0.6805956363677979,
-0.6854687929153442,
0.748746931552887,
-0.332454115152359,
0.4086913764476776,
0.4838981032371521,
0.09215512871742249,
-0.8999724388122559,
0.0428294911980629,
-0.1316850632429123,
-0.7389033436775208,
0.025966035202145576,
-0.5952889919281006,
0.038766875863075256,
-0.41455069184303284,
0.7640124559402466,
0.1523105502128601,
-0.4470365345478058,
-0.5197343230247498,
-0.3132418394088745,
-0.3960202634334564,
-0.517450213432312,
-0.44173750281333923,
-0.4082634150981903,
0.3857058882713318,
0.4109240174293518,
0.5302973985671997,
0.6384221911430359,
0.42146027088165283,
0.39173033833503723,
0.011918225325644016,
0.0036923117004334927,
-0.30846843123435974,
-0.44247907400131226,
0.07453888654708862,
-0.3952082097530365,
-0.5104621648788452,
0.38140565156936646,
0.6892334222793579,
0.9970685839653015,
0.13283012807369232,
0.1699664294719696,
-0.039824750274419785,
0.7261821627616882,
-0.6188458800315857,
-0.12944217026233673,
-0.22337093949317932,
0.07934712618589401,
-0.13986939191818237,
0.2293105572462082,
0.1660485565662384,
-0.19862182438373566,
0.2596766948699951,
-0.40394508838653564,
-0.010435501113533974,
-0.2228080928325653,
0.8091301918029785,
0.40250372886657715,
-0.638497531414032,
-0.18593952059745789,
-1.2512187957763672,
0.9730883836746216,
-0.17096154391765594,
0.17087367177009583,
0.22491639852523804,
0.49617987871170044,
-0.09075313806533813,
-0.8621915578842163,
-0.4732084274291992,
-0.22779200971126556,
0.29393118619918823,
0.2154945284128189,
-0.38054347038269043,
-0.20944717526435852,
-0.09791473299264908,
0.27605730295181274,
-0.2058345377445221,
-0.07445606589317322,
-0.6533504724502563,
0.02602577954530716,
0.9760132431983948,
0.06557315587997437,
0.23085951805114746,
0.6312934756278992,
-0.07014144957065582,
0.1754864752292633,
-0.49933621287345886,
0.30076298117637634,
0.4290158152580261,
0.0278608500957489,
-0.018302297219634056,
0.18135271966457367,
-0.32754066586494446,
0.33652132749557495,
0.20816920697689056,
0.3236372172832489,
0.18859493732452393,
-0.8203996419906616,
0.21048612892627716,
-0.20682145655155182,
0.6188516616821289,
0.24519063532352448,
0.10506847500801086,
-0.6013253331184387,
0.1548607349395752,
0.23588255047798157,
0.897026538848877,
-0.2271725833415985,
0.2820412516593933,
0.2850407660007477,
-0.2613826096057892,
-0.06983990967273712,
0.5506497025489807,
-0.6770418882369995,
-0.36955466866493225,
-0.400176465511322,
0.08155279606580734,
-0.1481837034225464,
-0.02019403874874115,
-0.6408538818359375,
-0.16650579869747162,
0.6633464097976685,
0.10821016132831573,
-0.9404359459877014,
0.35288840532302856,
1.1283808946609497,
0.8122532367706299,
-0.11734572798013687,
-0.5140128135681152,
-0.15075509250164032,
0.40666303038597107,
-0.42405369877815247,
0.7589103579521179,
-0.5983375310897827,
-0.5765839219093323,
-0.18809138238430023,
-0.1761964112520218,
-0.19140468537807465,
-0.3700215518474579,
0.20061975717544556,
-0.271717369556427,
-0.026531681418418884,
-0.17475588619709015,
-0.25442278385162354,
-0.6272217631340027,
0.49525773525238037,
-0.3111118972301483,
0.2666548192501068,
0.1616288423538208,
-0.2740618884563446,
0.3028656542301178,
-0.9898865818977356,
-0.6350455284118652,
0.13903585076332092,
-0.280113160610199,
-0.05020452290773392,
0.2179044485092163,
0.06372486799955368,
0.1155477911233902,
-0.24645791947841644,
0.4437268376350403,
-0.3434043228626251,
-0.4328460395336151,
-0.10480574518442154,
-0.45914512872695923,
0.45450490713119507,
0.1589130014181137,
-0.5144818425178528,
0.2494668811559677,
-0.5990286469459534,
0.1754300743341446,
-0.18577054142951965,
0.18744497001171112,
0.062431905418634415,
0.1434992402791977,
-0.5079474449157715,
-0.09860224276781082,
0.4481869339942932,
-0.28809383511543274,
0.18148396909236908,
-0.3731459081172943,
1.087853193283081,
0.7532172203063965,
-0.03772275149822235,
0.9615194797515869,
-0.4630846083164215,
0.5617125630378723,
-0.34516555070877075,
0.8615210652351379,
0.1768091917037964,
-0.5930699110031128,
-0.3135639727115631,
0.10287940502166748,
0.19710347056388855,
0.7863108515739441,
-0.06290445476770401,
0.7090766429901123,
-0.5239326357841492,
-0.7062133550643921,
-0.46247854828834534,
-0.1237429529428482,
0.0773807242512703,
0.4858517050743103,
0.24153926968574524,
-0.4051710069179535,
-0.023923607543110847,
-0.813980758190155,
-0.06781645864248276,
-0.42703917622566223,
-0.11021840572357178,
0.539669930934906,
0.5740650296211243,
-0.6747866868972778,
1.1943844556808472,
-0.314515084028244,
-0.4021521210670471,
-0.30090704560279846,
0.14584074914455414,
-0.031520403921604156,
0.44429975748062134,
0.44002753496170044,
-1.0242984294891357,
-0.18630008399486542,
0.447754830121994,
-0.9004359245300293,
0.05304309353232384,
-0.14477942883968353,
-0.23685228824615479,
-0.31751713156700134,
0.45973044633865356,
-0.543119490146637,
0.5883206725120544,
0.18571648001670837,
-0.24643343687057495,
0.332868754863739,
-0.08338118344545364,
0.3238261938095093,
-0.7511956691741943,
0.6633090376853943,
-0.10803914070129395,
0.3547113239765167,
-1.1594133377075195,
0.18870526552200317,
-0.5590576529502869,
-0.06683441251516342,
-0.11812449246644974,
0.6491141319274902,
-0.2926516532897949,
-0.12895111739635468,
-0.16338129341602325,
-0.01844829134643078,
-0.23414844274520874,
0.1166830062866211,
-0.5407314300537109,
1.0556349754333496,
0.6337791681289673,
-0.7089343667030334,
0.2780749201774597,
0.3977988362312317,
0.2994508147239685,
0.512995183467865,
-0.6232665181159973,
0.2749250829219818,
-0.0686103105545044,
0.19456182420253754,
-0.536087155342102,
-0.2681131064891815,
0.5878068804740906,
-0.509943425655365,
0.22636227309703827,
0.2668152153491974,
0.3242412805557251,
-0.6249845027923584,
-0.3047012388706207,
0.7208167910575867,
0.5681920647621155,
-0.20058491826057434,
1.1944897174835205,
0.5914183259010315,
-0.277384489774704,
-0.47107434272766113,
-0.5250413417816162,
0.4017747938632965,
-0.3939599394798279,
-0.8097005486488342,
0.1787874549627304,
-0.031058790162205696,
-0.6325639486312866,
-0.11490825563669205,
-0.21632502973079681,
-0.1539148986339569,
0.3441072404384613,
0.44980400800704956,
0.013459010049700737,
-0.06312143057584763,
-0.11495156586170197,
-0.08711349964141846,
-0.3238258957862854,
0.11080095916986465,
-0.2820180356502533,
0.12842269241809845,
-0.4222421646118164,
-0.46303683519363403,
-0.45698559284210205,
0.8492120504379272,
0.5175508260726929,
-0.3828713297843933,
0.29325631260871887,
0.47924795746803284,
-0.1534259021282196,
0.30069732666015625,
-0.4142872393131256,
0.27248266339302063,
-0.3900509178638458,
0.26812276244163513,
-0.22504161298274994,
-0.7678292989730835,
0.5956109166145325,
-0.5372967720031738,
0.2243659794330597,
0.5823591947555542,
0.00928510632365942,
0.03196960315108299,
1.1048698425292969,
1.1308844089508057,
-0.49658137559890747,
0.3031889796257019,
-0.43832096457481384,
0.4250316023826599,
-0.8074197173118591,
-0.2943693995475769,
-0.5132852792739868,
-0.5069404244422913,
-0.31885531544685364,
-0.08649778366088867,
0.3654943108558655,
-0.04766104370355606,
-0.2813309133052826,
-0.30437594652175903,
-0.6262730360031128,
0.433281272649765,
0.8926257491111755,
-0.2997726798057556,
0.0018929565558210015,
-0.2865435481071472,
0.6399927735328674,
0.42551136016845703,
-0.6160552501678467,
-0.6151893734931946,
0.6558403372764587,
0.3207368552684784,
0.13373082876205444,
-0.07912033051252365,
0.537925660610199,
0.6244531273841858,
0.36230766773223877,
-0.5741749405860901,
0.47758856415748596,
-0.10063756257295609,
-0.3656032681465149,
-0.49355632066726685,
-0.2274373173713684,
-0.8704836368560791,
-0.29330262541770935,
0.0711662620306015,
-0.6982353925704956,
0.32798320055007935,
-0.183332160115242,
-0.5822159647941589,
0.08375035971403122,
-0.9765522480010986,
0.883739173412323,
-0.33001047372817993,
-0.21167100965976715,
-0.3284038007259369,
-1.1835676431655884,
0.14335350692272186,
0.1032666340470314,
0.4412711262702942,
-0.11809072643518448,
-0.053929947316646576,
0.5483194589614868,
-0.207085981965065,
0.6654638051986694,
0.02380349300801754,
-0.023076049983501434,
0.6862931847572327,
-0.6527895927429199,
0.020066017284989357,
-0.09218195080757141,
0.15762534737586975,
0.5321572422981262,
-0.3291047215461731,
-0.4054616391658783,
-0.43545445799827576,
0.5716302990913391,
-0.99249267578125,
-0.7752416133880615,
-0.4925926625728607,
-0.2617599070072174,
-0.22190159559249878,
0.15576234459877014,
0.135177880525589,
0.1668231189250946,
-0.6204559206962585,
-0.5394986867904663,
0.3018870949745178,
0.2740578353404999,
0.6753852367401123,
-0.3894989788532257,
0.3900607228279114,
-0.31854987144470215,
1.3307267427444458,
0.014311959967017174,
-0.023955320939421654,
0.05619340389966965,
0.10291534662246704,
-0.3580102026462555,
-0.5851540565490723,
-0.4302389919757843,
0.2452559918165207,
-0.5487768054008484,
0.09823247790336609,
-0.3197862207889557,
-0.34998181462287903,
-0.575503945350647,
-0.4875122308731079,
-0.12062457203865051,
-0.01885991171002388,
-0.6041375994682312,
0.2727106511592865,
-0.050522517412900925,
1.2802534103393555,
-0.09013301879167557,
0.04060517996549606,
-0.8232750296592712,
0.23566748201847076,
0.7036409974098206,
0.2838059961795807,
0.27532637119293213,
-0.09834916889667511,
-0.08884284645318985,
0.2841714918613434,
-0.4568929076194763,
-0.4580933153629303,
0.034809261560440063,
0.5628690123558044,
0.6935076117515564,
0.8484398722648621,
-0.0702996551990509,
1.079353928565979,
-0.6848462820053101,
1.0864250659942627,
0.08805020153522491,
-0.8808502554893494,
0.5060974359512329,
0.028595129027962685,
0.23221825063228607,
0.7875407338142395,
0.45944467186927795,
-0.23776130378246307,
-0.22926613688468933,
-0.5811685919761658,
-0.9831711649894714,
0.41176554560661316,
-0.02528068609535694,
0.2268245369195938,
0.10706866532564163,
0.4671812653541565,
0.2023041546344757,
0.15546654164791107,
-0.347862184047699,
-0.0015486746560782194,
-0.09237901121377945,
-0.0008955355151556432,
-0.2209743857383728,
0.27180203795433044,
-0.3691631853580475,
-0.35784992575645447,
0.6494145393371582,
-0.2871265113353729,
0.34590065479278564,
0.13017717003822327,
0.35113248229026794,
-0.15060852468013763,
0.40227553248405457,
0.44120314717292786,
0.9311968684196472,
0.30859100818634033,
-0.31026092171669006,
0.15314270555973053,
-0.6942263245582581,
0.3639552891254425,
0.2918791174888611,
-0.46992889046669006,
-0.6376844644546509,
0.37339505553245544,
0.64464271068573,
-0.6471110582351685,
-0.6600031852722168,
0.343607097864151,
-0.059872716665267944,
-0.4217725694179535,
-0.49951988458633423,
0.2931135296821594,
-0.3591553866863251,
0.7635539770126343,
0.6499922275543213,
0.1148798018693924,
0.2482970952987671,
-0.9074590802192688,
0.09385716915130615,
0.7426135540008545,
-0.5536149144172668,
-0.4245663583278656,
1.0233594179153442,
0.3077291250228882,
-0.3990791141986847,
0.7186246514320374,
-0.2164772003889084,
-0.39094144105911255,
0.5995141267776489,
0.024748049676418304,
0.9481032490730286,
0.006647675298154354,
0.14500421285629272,
-0.18492217361927032,
0.23769377171993256,
0.23557674884796143,
-0.05870358645915985,
-0.2976011335849762,
-0.28262433409690857,
-0.37673696875572205,
-0.4353845417499542,
-0.20446977019309998,
-0.21714867651462555,
-0.27662718296051025,
-0.16160091757774353,
-0.4339662790298462,
-0.32821664214134216,
-0.12914495170116425,
0.13041894137859344,
-0.24178336560726166,
0.22041812539100647,
0.3850451409816742,
0.7084500193595886,
-0.7390580177307129,
0.04566863179206848,
0.9766282439231873,
-0.22783727943897247,
-0.35360297560691833,
0.34240013360977173,
-0.19189344346523285,
-0.42989546060562134,
0.04210794344544411,
0.4884308874607086,
-0.24540193378925323,
-0.0721743032336235,
-0.8659442663192749,
-0.9293336272239685,
1.2491563558578491,
-0.3326996862888336,
-0.19735664129257202,
-0.29796522855758667,
0.16572166979312897,
0.5882003307342529,
-0.38928571343421936,
0.18204538524150848,
0.85520339012146,
0.7053061127662659,
0.17657427489757538,
-0.5447503924369812,
-0.2882438004016876,
-0.4202340841293335,
0.08389796316623688,
0.21011883020401,
-0.9166540503501892,
0.4063960611820221,
-0.2720864713191986,
-0.3826618194580078,
0.3297797441482544,
0.9958778023719788,
-0.2801583707332611,
0.8433520793914795,
0.308993935585022,
0.4799503982067108,
0.5620439648628235,
-0.1581486314535141,
0.8514299988746643,
-0.09967543929815292,
-0.2765596807003021,
0.4296188950538635,
-0.5090954303741455,
0.3686552047729492,
0.5207112431526184,
-0.3000923991203308,
0.24867583811283112,
0.4512145519256592,
-0.3651143014431,
0.40567564964294434,
0.10948257148265839,
-0.4890863001346588,
0.034675031900405884,
-0.3499344289302826,
-0.35709643363952637,
0.602246880531311,
0.1812659204006195,
0.21579548716545105,
-0.003768084105104208,
0.10179690271615982,
-0.6360204219818115,
0.2164883017539978,
-0.47883158922195435,
0.9821754693984985,
-0.32290929555892944,
-0.7597107887268066,
-0.012047232128679752,
-0.2569044828414917,
0.42946839332580566,
-0.6274205446243286,
-0.26783186197280884,
-0.14223991334438324,
-0.05305445194244385,
0.10918440669775009,
-0.5679590106010437,
0.5775893926620483,
-0.0845819041132927,
-0.25920870900154114,
0.052847880870103836,
0.5523881912231445,
0.08509404957294464,
-0.14077411592006683,
0.13521477580070496,
0.741709291934967,
0.10953932255506516,
0.12658831477165222,
-0.5499626398086548,
-0.06849123537540436,
-0.13164766132831573,
0.18463000655174255,
0.44781598448753357,
0.4590298533439636,
-0.13435956835746765,
0.7758590579032898,
0.5117538571357727,
-0.10319888591766357,
-0.02833383157849312,
-0.1349972039461136,
0.7856526970863342,
-0.6043327450752258,
-0.6587697267532349,
-0.6958005428314209,
0.3272083103656769,
-0.05747976154088974,
-0.5048791766166687,
0.27561935782432556,
0.2243616282939911,
0.6011764407157898,
0.20931106805801392,
1.022783637046814,
-0.569885790348053,
0.03127956762909889,
0.19417643547058105,
0.6904524564743042,
-0.6733430027961731,
-0.11732349544763565,
-0.02046642079949379,
-0.8016253113746643,
-0.27294838428497314,
0.252583384513855,
-0.24054054915905,
0.2740146517753601,
0.11718741059303284,
0.10728639364242554,
0.12343132495880127,
0.040245890617370605,
0.16405558586120605,
0.013218005187809467,
0.2193627655506134,
0.4012504518032074,
0.9560451507568359,
-0.19173157215118408,
0.5675992965698242,
0.11215781420469284,
-0.41788336634635925,
0.23289300501346588,
-0.3845757246017456,
-0.39199167490005493,
-0.44771620631217957,
-0.37349334359169006,
0.3493763506412506,
0.21691004931926727,
0.3621036410331726,
0.6197438836097717,
-0.706572413444519,
-0.18806684017181396,
-0.4738629460334778,
0.13639366626739502,
-0.4987547695636749,
-0.21282465755939484,
0.02274673618376255,
-0.16737335920333862,
-0.6987048387527466,
0.38676944375038147,
0.40788733959198,
0.1478763073682785,
-0.16169744729995728,
-0.05546503886580467,
-0.47391003370285034,
0.037766605615615845,
0.415057897567749,
0.9755322337150574,
-0.6489480137825012,
-0.585610568523407,
-0.09126996994018555,
0.3061080276966095,
0.27391955256462097,
0.346648633480072,
-0.6745368242263794,
0.0024540647864341736,
0.06226436421275139,
0.9448647499084473,
-0.3217618465423584,
0.4684920310974121,
0.5416808724403381,
-0.5879673957824707,
-0.22109763324260712,
0.4000331461429596,
-0.24237288534641266,
0.10436490923166275,
-0.5105665922164917,
0.794912576675415,
0.30702024698257446,
-0.9460033774375916,
-0.5385351181030273,
0.43419355154037476,
-0.6381312608718872,
-0.23821760714054108,
0.599513828754425,
0.11395111680030823,
-0.4567805826663971,
-0.202327698469162,
0.00424385629594326,
0.3289601504802704,
-0.2461402714252472,
0.9454569220542908,
0.6657068133354187,
-0.6716902256011963,
-0.06265916675329208,
-0.3069494664669037,
0.10921560972929001,
0.13687774538993835,
-0.855897068977356,
-0.11896289885044098,
0.5447149872779846,
-0.39781931042671204,
0.7184849977493286,
0.45317673683166504,
0.04928320273756981,
0.14019764959812164,
0.21510949730873108,
-0.17080838978290558,
0.19057440757751465,
-0.78459632396698,
-0.4989393651485443,
0.2961958944797516,
-0.08431879431009293,
-0.22853288054466248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10292v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10292v2
|
Fine-Tuning Large Vision-Language Models as Decision-Making Agents via Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-05-16T17:50:19 | 2024-05-17T03:45:09 |
Yuexiang Zhai, Hao Bai, Zipeng Lin, Jiayi Pan, Shengbang Tong, Yifei Zhou, Alane Suhr, Saining Xie, Yann LeCun, Yi Ma, Sergey Levine
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Large vision-language models (VLMs) fine-tuned on specialized visual
instruction-following data have exhibited impressive language reasoning
capabilities across various scenarios. However, this fine-tuning paradigm may
not be able to efficiently learn optimal decision-making agents in multi-step
goal-directed tasks from interactive environments. To address this challenge,
we propose an algorithmic framework that fine-tunes VLMs with reinforcement
learning (RL). Specifically, our framework provides a task description and then
prompts the VLM to generate chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning, enabling the VLM
to efficiently explore intermediate reasoning steps that lead to the final
text-based action. Next, the open-ended text output is parsed into an
executable action to interact with the environment to obtain goal-directed task
rewards. Finally, our framework uses these task rewards to fine-tune the entire
VLM with RL. Empirically, we demonstrate that our proposed framework enhances
the decision-making capabilities of VLM agents across various tasks, enabling
7b models to outperform commercial models such as GPT4-V or Gemini.
Furthermore, we find that CoT reasoning is a crucial component for performance
improvement, as removing the CoT reasoning results in a significant decrease in
the overall performance of our method.
|
[
-0.467451810836792,
-0.7070564031600952,
0.8795830607414246,
-0.07656831294298172,
-0.22859780490398407,
0.12961173057556152,
-0.49995797872543335,
-0.34909379482269287,
-0.14537420868873596,
0.8166760206222534,
-0.6867175102233887,
-0.5372419357299805,
-0.4297696650028229,
0.03313655033707619,
0.09855332970619202,
0.9631898999214172,
-0.22503991425037384,
-0.2044067680835724,
-0.03285709768533707,
0.031062200665473938,
-0.5624265670776367,
-0.14218150079250336,
-1.020857810974121,
-0.33939462900161743,
0.753469705581665,
0.36455219984054565,
0.6431525945663452,
0.6860870122909546,
0.3897086977958679,
0.34519627690315247,
-0.016828544437885284,
0.8984858393669128,
-0.660822868347168,
0.11212848871946335,
-0.758602499961853,
-0.30375486612319946,
-0.25785890221595764,
-0.32159310579299927,
0.4180629849433899,
0.1847376525402069,
-0.09170357882976532,
0.08837568759918213,
-0.05658319965004921,
0.7663106918334961,
-0.8316593170166016,
0.5351303219795227,
-0.6167572736740112,
0.14886243641376495,
0.2796895205974579,
-0.4696708619594574,
-0.6654660701751709,
0.05586109682917595,
0.06243168190121651,
-0.7245658040046692,
-0.08693984150886536,
0.39013999700546265,
0.7810275554656982,
0.5704513192176819,
-0.14437617361545563,
-0.10806336253881454,
-0.7614639401435852,
0.7334516048431396,
-0.36761847138404846,
0.2755531966686249,
0.16908793151378632,
0.3515753149986267,
-0.32425814867019653,
-0.5655660629272461,
-0.47595101594924927,
-0.33924901485443115,
0.020687611773610115,
0.021070381626486778,
0.03562614694237709,
0.4668246805667877,
0.47409868240356445,
-0.08140693604946136,
-0.3244953751564026,
0.11279735714197159,
-0.4197585880756378,
0.05656687170267105,
0.6241985559463501,
0.40362629294395447,
-0.1011321172118187,
0.18704475462436676,
-0.3656611144542694,
-0.36819928884506226,
-0.4073966443538666,
0.40807485580444336,
-0.04514817148447037,
0.5260106325149536,
0.1332501620054245,
0.46665850281715393,
-0.5787901282310486,
0.9399341940879822,
0.1636631041765213,
0.06697345525026321,
0.06785274296998978,
-0.21885065734386444,
-0.5584664344787598,
-0.05847888067364693,
0.43266093730926514,
0.4040694534778595,
0.4526371657848358,
-0.03418492525815964,
-0.5925304889678955,
0.09026157855987549,
0.5655546188354492,
-0.6105545163154602,
-0.3468175232410431,
0.10244211554527283,
-0.24575696885585785,
-0.26219290494918823,
-0.10714507848024368,
-0.3545750379562378,
-0.43867576122283936,
-0.89211106300354,
0.535410463809967,
-0.36594095826148987,
-0.05616842582821846,
0.250881165266037,
-0.17350029945373535,
0.221451535820961,
0.7664105892181396,
-0.7624193429946899,
0.18830163776874542,
0.6879929900169373,
0.5249840617179871,
-0.25723978877067566,
-0.47492170333862305,
-1.0323327779769897,
0.0918113961815834,
-0.6691645383834839,
0.7417771220207214,
-0.7436463832855225,
-0.09681744128465652,
0.020288430154323578,
-0.02120015025138855,
-0.20932967960834503,
-0.651648998260498,
0.12712450325489044,
-0.35274216532707214,
-0.25125551223754883,
-0.37674951553344727,
-0.26809829473495483,
-0.11332105100154877,
0.6335725784301758,
-0.5397825241088867,
0.7131314873695374,
0.0029178389813750982,
-0.1872674971818924,
0.6818504333496094,
-0.6183578372001648,
-0.3492298722267151,
0.015292938798666,
-0.331752747297287,
-0.35742902755737305,
0.15554437041282654,
0.36436471343040466,
0.5449897646903992,
-0.14168255031108856,
0.11287272721529007,
-0.2347654402256012,
-0.38558998703956604,
-0.0008684669155627489,
-0.2828688621520996,
0.31180882453918457,
0.128371000289917,
-0.4518178701400757,
0.7741175889968872,
-0.5827634930610657,
0.2548689842224121,
0.0029827766120433807,
-0.34800249338150024,
-0.165726438164711,
0.22342410683631897,
-0.12154477089643478,
0.4364049434661865,
0.0801977589726448,
-0.3006325960159302,
0.32046422362327576,
-0.34129154682159424,
0.2873450815677643,
0.9840715527534485,
-0.04846317321062088,
0.3434904217720032,
-0.2836569845676422,
0.3827900290489197,
0.12697413563728333,
0.5193173885345459,
-0.005326633807271719,
-0.1790645569562912,
-0.8789733648300171,
-0.27004361152648926,
-0.09873881191015244,
0.32858020067214966,
-1.2636514902114868,
-0.04753470793366432,
0.02419423498213291,
-0.30232834815979004,
-0.36684080958366394,
0.1260053962469101,
0.750273585319519,
0.3467648923397064,
0.5123295783996582,
-0.23571385443210602,
-0.3269136846065521,
-0.6841272115707397,
-0.25930655002593994,
-0.0656355619430542,
0.4127950668334961,
0.4105122685432434,
0.5565778613090515,
-0.19565153121948242,
0.7053982019424438,
-0.49779582023620605,
-0.22808076441287994,
-0.3171979486942291,
0.016744667664170265,
0.000536744948476553,
0.4291723668575287,
0.15262162685394287,
-0.9716200828552246,
-0.29302024841308594,
0.3495410978794098,
-0.5727026462554932,
0.18751133978366852,
-0.292890340089798,
-0.2296769767999649,
0.30697715282440186,
0.7144302129745483,
-0.5028143525123596,
0.49945831298828125,
0.19908295571804047,
-0.6032693982124329,
0.8108179569244385,
-0.6918967962265015,
0.16035902500152588,
-0.36622729897499084,
-0.2746937572956085,
0.114314503967762,
-0.4085659980773926,
-0.37716910243034363,
0.24097982048988342,
-0.07161769270896912,
0.15403075516223907,
-0.5650351643562317,
0.6341636180877686,
-0.2251792699098587,
-0.23187772929668427,
-0.5230405330657959,
0.06557789444923401,
-0.05189596489071846,
1.0170894861221313,
0.34500375390052795,
0.6986621022224426,
0.5334857106208801,
-0.9183840155601501,
0.32141193747520447,
0.20083560049533844,
-0.21571362018585205,
0.4948112964630127,
-0.43587347865104675,
-0.1764732152223587,
-0.2888062000274658,
0.17586277425289154,
-0.43116194009780884,
-0.022595282644033432,
0.237709179520607,
-0.20112121105194092,
-0.005564526189118624,
0.023226339370012283,
-0.34808143973350525,
-0.21240994334220886,
-0.08408677577972412,
0.24712039530277252,
0.35964298248291016,
-0.6402982473373413,
0.755948007106781,
-0.005808782298117876,
0.18574826419353485,
-0.5674943327903748,
-0.2539452016353607,
-0.04145646095275879,
0.03602741286158562,
-0.15091508626937866,
0.3032853603363037,
-0.006778854876756668,
-0.2260456383228302,
0.059008095413446426,
-0.11876285076141357,
0.23884713649749756,
0.052111100405454636,
0.28894904255867004,
0.21431826055049896,
0.08085048198699951,
0.18644297122955322,
-0.014838937669992447,
-0.19507655501365662,
-0.09951947629451752,
-0.6723624467849731,
0.4928409457206726,
-0.41126275062561035,
-0.38259392976760864,
-0.023892827332019806,
-0.04901045933365822,
0.5898720622062683,
-0.7665153741836548,
0.5915906429290771,
0.6732855439186096,
-0.10827996581792831,
-0.7217934131622314,
-0.2670041620731354,
-0.04732900857925415,
-0.45074763894081116,
0.4659188389778137,
-0.5022566914558411,
-0.9111615419387817,
0.18044978380203247,
-0.3313502371311188,
0.32636165618896484,
0.15472689270973206,
0.6911142468452454,
-0.06800837814807892,
1.2980356216430664,
0.6671571135520935,
0.32654333114624023,
0.8068997263908386,
-0.3722761869430542,
0.21273194253444672,
-0.7904443144798279,
-0.464498907327652,
-0.06829638034105301,
-0.27837616205215454,
-0.4888046383857727,
-0.6034834980964661,
0.4289768636226654,
-0.10412298887968063,
-0.5410925149917603,
0.2528500258922577,
-0.5227313041687012,
0.5776819586753845,
0.7094199657440186,
0.4182901084423065,
0.1728375107049942,
-0.15608294308185577,
-0.21247337758541107,
0.4964257776737213,
-0.6541013717651367,
-0.3588487207889557,
0.7033014893531799,
0.07793822139501572,
0.6652517318725586,
-0.17121082544326782,
0.7076177597045898,
0.391002893447876,
-0.10348162800073624,
-0.598841667175293,
0.6942046880722046,
-0.07627168297767639,
-0.15422432124614716,
-0.6395754814147949,
-0.38946065306663513,
-0.8730565309524536,
0.5085983872413635,
-0.4372851550579071,
-0.802162766456604,
0.18293242156505585,
0.49020254611968994,
-0.4282335340976715,
0.2293921262025833,
-0.4950862228870392,
1.028728723526001,
-0.4021599590778351,
-0.7488221526145935,
-0.6984717845916748,
-0.45054301619529724,
0.18657584488391876,
0.2589603066444397,
0.020244404673576355,
-0.15348544716835022,
0.021137582138180733,
0.2511124908924103,
-0.3035832643508911,
0.7272513508796692,
-0.29593202471733093,
-0.08638925105333328,
0.18685367703437805,
0.05011018365621567,
0.7598900198936462,
-0.15773312747478485,
0.1822984218597412,
-0.32153430581092834,
-0.0360124297440052,
-0.4211065471172333,
-0.6628908514976501,
0.44652560353279114,
-0.4720039963722229,
-0.4982674717903137,
-0.23375415802001953,
-0.5586501359939575,
-0.3613361120223999,
0.09183146804571152,
-0.08774086087942123,
0.5594620704650879,
-0.026366043835878372,
-0.014060965739190578,
0.8071867823600769,
-0.33962222933769226,
0.3032359480857849,
0.45320677757263184,
-0.45321282744407654,
-0.20096971094608307,
1.1417230367660522,
-0.20100341737270355,
0.48189300298690796,
0.4589441120624542,
-0.00012839521514251828,
-0.21562516689300537,
-0.6666176915168762,
-0.5393405556678772,
-0.09339728206396103,
-0.7053610682487488,
-0.011551223695278168,
-0.28645724058151245,
-0.08381378650665283,
0.06205351650714874,
-0.3465273380279541,
-0.3811788260936737,
0.18422356247901917,
0.015028798952698708,
-0.0955989882349968,
0.19838248193264008,
0.5937222242355347,
0.06034332513809204,
0.07486303895711899,
-0.42347365617752075,
0.4931849241256714,
0.38539767265319824,
0.3601977229118347,
0.0700419545173645,
-0.13451124727725983,
-0.5074502825737,
0.06584398448467255,
-0.24135422706604004,
-0.21908754110336304,
0.3731844127178192,
-0.009344184771180153,
0.47425565123558044,
0.1683386117219925,
0.11666307598352432,
0.7880486249923706,
-0.5113046765327454,
0.4570406377315521,
0.25605759024620056,
-0.7898051142692566,
0.6171838641166687,
-0.26254647970199585,
0.35536301136016846,
0.4395054280757904,
-0.23813405632972717,
-0.24169738590717316,
-0.5032855868339539,
-0.5383212566375732,
-0.7714862823486328,
0.8124585747718811,
0.168091282248497,
-0.3085084557533264,
-0.027813831344246864,
0.11913386732339859,
-0.09987571090459824,
0.33823442459106445,
-0.4767986238002777,
0.18676871061325073,
0.10616718977689743,
-0.23770003020763397,
-0.3396879732608795,
0.31678664684295654,
-0.009071869775652885,
-0.38479745388031006,
0.688599705696106,
-0.4812735319137573,
-0.0404416099190712,
0.33176448941230774,
-0.2478771209716797,
-0.13630013167858124,
0.13274048268795013,
0.6781155467033386,
0.699195146560669,
0.049150362610816956,
0.07286176085472107,
0.27015289664268494,
-0.0689997524023056,
0.05754651874303818,
-0.09087173640727997,
-0.12386883050203323,
-0.4808303415775299,
0.27245092391967773,
1.4465162754058838,
0.3398800492286682,
-1.2642003297805786,
0.2877078950405121,
-0.1331796497106552,
-0.20893824100494385,
-0.22728897631168365,
0.6697065234184265,
-0.27039313316345215,
0.8559442162513733,
0.027712075039744377,
0.4041259288787842,
0.09816069155931473,
-0.6958327889442444,
0.15364086627960205,
0.421455979347229,
-0.5588355660438538,
0.13722577691078186,
0.49879249930381775,
0.20753197371959686,
-0.33056405186653137,
0.42401766777038574,
-0.22039149701595306,
-0.5631067156791687,
0.8876912593841553,
0.2348594069480896,
0.7503095269203186,
0.2711807191371918,
0.41148310899734497,
0.1796235889196396,
0.2665194272994995,
-0.3679683804512024,
0.22948777675628662,
-0.28467661142349243,
-0.6580517888069153,
-0.6396238803863525,
-0.7106524109840393,
-0.5327515602111816,
-0.12649832665920258,
-0.4679635167121887,
0.22271355986595154,
-0.6092576384544373,
-0.03083503618836403,
-0.10137118399143219,
-0.07273471355438232,
-0.8918372392654419,
0.5453208684921265,
0.41703733801841736,
0.6984347701072693,
-0.43386533856391907,
0.7292515635490417,
0.626884400844574,
-0.4032175838947296,
-0.946652889251709,
-0.10518237948417664,
-0.3335947096347809,
-0.7045623660087585,
0.6367402076721191,
0.15472720563411713,
-0.5500746369361877,
-0.017447853460907936,
-0.5188901424407959,
-0.6154123544692993,
0.9588996767997742,
0.32826563715934753,
-0.8549566268920898,
-0.04879562184214592,
-0.2470993846654892,
0.6420292258262634,
-0.4933023750782013,
0.042865827679634094,
0.6281817555427551,
0.5065999031066895,
0.053966086357831955,
-1.0346429347991943,
-0.015316418372094631,
-0.06686482578516006,
0.05919651314616203,
0.5142802596092224,
-0.5977691411972046,
0.7353050112724304,
-0.5678218007087708,
0.12547455728054047,
-0.15484492480754852,
0.5814694166183472,
0.44512414932250977,
0.3915853202342987,
0.6504665017127991,
0.4737931787967682,
0.6653076410293579,
0.03175289183855057,
1.0265434980392456,
-0.03431761637330055,
0.2704738676548004,
1.0317926406860352,
-0.20200808346271515,
0.9278641939163208,
0.4069494903087616,
0.18983194231987,
0.502845823764801,
0.506394624710083,
0.005245450418442488,
0.7236385941505432,
0.236160546541214,
-0.06703593581914902,
-0.7296000719070435,
-0.02299571968615055,
0.25719791650772095,
0.539642870426178,
0.37493371963500977,
-0.39511367678642273,
-0.12161532789468765,
0.401288777589798,
-0.4010520875453949,
0.24437549710273743,
-0.9090143442153931,
0.9645158052444458,
-0.06161585450172424,
-1.143319010734558,
0.6143055558204651,
-0.09002470970153809,
0.4137190282344818,
-0.433936208486557,
-0.3070056140422821,
0.27187272906303406,
0.5640547871589661,
-0.07408138364553452,
-0.8389871120452881,
0.04549899324774742,
-0.002503525698557496,
-0.1564674973487854,
-0.3599507510662079,
0.6698134541511536,
-0.5729124546051025,
-0.14044980704784393,
0.3843245506286621,
0.40049654245376587,
-0.11918145418167114,
-0.16548968851566315,
-0.7162402272224426,
0.16551713645458221,
0.06983653455972672,
-0.1850837767124176,
0.3958578109741211,
0.4387570917606354,
-0.2864939272403717,
0.9675586223602295,
0.5643380880355835,
0.17136293649673462,
-0.18062712252140045,
0.04353395849466324,
0.860660195350647,
-0.6548357009887695,
-0.678127646446228,
-0.8407499194145203,
0.4680601954460144,
-0.26876166462898254,
-0.32443538308143616,
0.2585669457912445,
0.4155416190624237,
1.111153244972229,
-0.17250101268291473,
0.7794266939163208,
0.05499808490276337,
0.007864505983889103,
-0.9160054922103882,
0.2522936761379242,
-0.626795768737793,
0.04354441910982132,
-0.1355109065771103,
-0.7662862539291382,
-0.03579461947083473,
0.6075924634933472,
-0.5681657195091248,
-0.06130671501159668,
0.6520854234695435,
0.7241938710212708,
-0.029558958485722542,
-0.267273485660553,
0.5232864618301392,
0.07663437724113464,
0.4511566162109375,
0.8278401494026184,
0.6680014729499817,
0.09573925286531448,
0.570679247379303,
-0.011210189200937748,
-0.08274153620004654,
-0.28210508823394775,
-0.7447958588600159,
-0.9395779371261597,
-0.6037566661834717,
-0.3491208553314209,
-0.17358572781085968,
0.5591159462928772,
1.2992240190505981,
0.6522696018218994,
-0.6144475936889648,
-0.036022063344717026,
-0.5373914837837219,
0.17276807129383087,
-0.8205030560493469,
-0.1229543387889862,
0.14014966785907745,
-0.673243522644043,
-0.6463424563407898,
0.32755401730537415,
0.6195006966590881,
-0.28350329399108887,
-0.2364850789308548,
-0.5477436184883118,
0.10542510449886322,
0.24416136741638184,
0.9018029570579529,
0.38715681433677673,
-0.9661509990692139,
-0.44169142842292786,
-0.33948197960853577,
-0.11455389112234116,
-0.09301222115755081,
0.7141258716583252,
-1.0179975032806396,
0.6090842485427856,
0.28667545318603516,
0.6091029644012451,
0.6612299084663391,
-0.08812633156776428,
0.6838193535804749,
-0.4520951211452484,
0.013603883795440197,
0.321857213973999,
0.33184733986854553,
0.11708767712116241,
-0.17389161884784698,
0.39380770921707153,
-0.11701559275388718,
-0.5252034068107605,
-0.628367006778717,
0.4190467298030853,
-1.097253441810608,
-0.5495725274085999,
1.138816237449646,
-0.01734881103038788,
-0.4710647463798523,
0.028512420132756233,
-0.7959582209587097,
0.13321395218372345,
-0.4469873309135437,
0.6915573477745056,
0.37092891335487366,
-0.2660689055919647,
-0.444100558757782,
-0.4426768720149994,
0.8330289125442505,
0.2964150309562683,
-0.9616991281509399,
0.3387592136859894,
0.6607515811920166,
-0.0443856306374073,
-0.13130713999271393,
0.42405039072036743,
0.30707916617393494,
0.582278311252594,
-0.13428790867328644,
-0.03923572227358818,
-0.40682685375213623,
-0.795965313911438,
-0.044916365295648575,
0.04351469874382019,
0.24811126291751862,
-0.2984978258609772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10288v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10288v3
|
Timeline-based Sentence Decomposition with In-Context Learning for Temporal Fact Extraction
| 2024-05-16T17:48:21 | 2024-06-18T08:22:29 |
Jianhao Chen, Haoyuan Ouyang, Junyang Ren, Wentao Ding, Wei Hu, Yuzhong Qu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Facts extraction is pivotal for constructing knowledge graphs. Recently, the
increasing demand for temporal facts in downstream tasks has led to the
emergence of the task of temporal fact extraction. In this paper, we
specifically address the extraction of temporal facts from natural language
text. Previous studies fail to handle the challenge of establishing
time-to-fact correspondences in complex sentences. To overcome this hurdle, we
propose a timeline-based sentence decomposition strategy using large language
models (LLMs) with in-context learning, ensuring a fine-grained understanding
of the timeline associated with various facts. In addition, we evaluate the
performance of LLMs for direct temporal fact extraction and get unsatisfactory
results. To this end, we introduce TSDRE, a method that incorporates the
decomposition capabilities of LLMs into the traditional fine-tuning of smaller
pre-trained language models (PLMs). To support the evaluation, we construct
ComplexTRED, a complex temporal fact extraction dataset. Our experiments show
that TSDRE achieves state-of-the-art results on both HyperRED-Temporal and
ComplexTRED datasets.
|
[
-0.19140464067459106,
-1.166198968887329,
0.8893032670021057,
0.12656396627426147,
-0.4419849216938019,
0.1925700604915619,
-0.2000604271888733,
-0.4103485941886902,
-0.08410477638244629,
0.5326551795005798,
-0.9196573495864868,
-0.6262755990028381,
-0.4309624135494232,
-0.08156779408454895,
-0.3176262378692627,
1.0186196565628052,
-0.05836540460586548,
-0.3201960623264313,
-0.0025143958628177643,
-0.06368961185216904,
-0.08723370730876923,
-0.5268989205360413,
-0.5432271957397461,
-0.2105804979801178,
0.3845069706439972,
0.5294117331504822,
0.14166204631328583,
0.879406750202179,
0.2221205234527588,
0.1482580304145813,
-0.3019641041755676,
0.6377374529838562,
-0.3238259553909302,
0.38300639390945435,
-0.13534973561763763,
-0.04167032614350319,
-0.37615522742271423,
0.08896132558584213,
0.7023460268974304,
0.7459522485733032,
0.012393329292535782,
0.4003572463989258,
-0.1553994119167328,
0.3512631952762604,
-0.5850028395652771,
0.666476309299469,
-0.3060455918312073,
0.25210946798324585,
-0.47396209836006165,
-0.5735577940940857,
-0.2577773332595825,
-0.6541047096252441,
0.5079964995384216,
-0.30948907136917114,
0.3120793402194977,
0.08306770771741867,
0.9561513662338257,
0.08997639268636703,
-0.8015657067298889,
-0.33240437507629395,
-0.8515699505805969,
0.6869596242904663,
-0.6221676468849182,
0.48272567987442017,
-0.09401781111955643,
0.12427913397550583,
-0.2779943346977234,
-0.851060152053833,
-0.6826711893081665,
-0.16066895425319672,
-0.08584219962358475,
-0.09874583035707474,
-0.20031803846359253,
-0.13509459793567657,
0.5990862250328064,
0.0548904687166214,
-0.5591670274734497,
0.05186857655644417,
-0.1814524084329605,
-0.25415194034576416,
0.11398005485534668,
0.34784162044525146,
0.4803297519683838,
-0.648891270160675,
-0.5985816121101379,
0.18493379652500153,
-0.8398482799530029,
0.042140401899814606,
-0.10422181338071823,
0.3198930025100708,
-0.05823921039700508,
0.8381249904632568,
-0.1250767856836319,
0.41476812958717346,
-0.31015804409980774,
-0.5052330493927002,
0.012347422540187836,
-0.36625936627388,
-0.2933615744113922,
0.20632119476795197,
0.8524097800254822,
0.25223830342292786,
0.1966206431388855,
-0.7496538162231445,
0.03933127224445343,
0.2715260088443756,
-0.5015559196472168,
-1.0073906183242798,
0.1075812429189682,
-0.021168861538171768,
-0.22560431063175201,
-0.10005391389131546,
-0.08268135786056519,
-0.784912645816803,
-0.014904439449310303,
-0.36299505829811096,
0.11141927540302277,
-0.4584202766418457,
0.3283263146877289,
-0.16936372220516205,
-0.3805329501628876,
0.20255662500858307,
0.23526714742183685,
-0.24918517470359802,
0.25097036361694336,
0.671051561832428,
1.073564052581787,
0.004741075914353132,
0.0644792914390564,
-1.0322628021240234,
0.4787738025188446,
-0.13431644439697266,
0.4859076142311096,
-0.33189430832862854,
-0.08287528157234192,
-0.14191961288452148,
-0.011754285544157028,
0.0016413393896073103,
-0.37534239888191223,
0.8445314168930054,
-0.7222493886947632,
0.45559728145599365,
-0.09289445728063583,
-0.7314200401306152,
0.039723340421915054,
0.32702428102493286,
-0.5950973033905029,
0.8327017426490784,
-0.098234161734581,
-0.8343963027000427,
0.3161490857601166,
-0.895153284072876,
-0.8628743290901184,
-0.15829212963581085,
0.002854578197002411,
-0.4833064079284668,
-0.16944453120231628,
0.5301660299301147,
0.7448928356170654,
-0.5121431946754456,
0.7536655068397522,
-0.4126681089401245,
0.009988486766815186,
0.23897859454154968,
-0.521224856376648,
0.9617429375648499,
0.39402830600738525,
-0.31733691692352295,
-0.22253724932670593,
-0.7592422366142273,
-0.21092712879180908,
-0.03918777406215668,
-0.3845280408859253,
-0.09914903342723846,
0.23652507364749908,
0.09604526311159134,
0.34338852763175964,
0.09220781177282333,
-0.9178008437156677,
0.21917439997196198,
-0.48698416352272034,
0.7835438251495361,
0.529810905456543,
0.5776841640472412,
0.41871967911720276,
-0.1843140572309494,
0.2370263934135437,
0.06388455629348755,
-0.013171055354177952,
0.03481350094079971,
0.14669491350650787,
-0.7358095049858093,
-0.2936496436595917,
0.004097445402294397,
0.34829041361808777,
-0.9065305590629578,
0.38510650396347046,
-0.5959253311157227,
-0.3439413011074066,
0.14885711669921875,
-0.1767769753932953,
0.39314910769462585,
1.0633350610733032,
0.33534207940101624,
0.10861875861883163,
-0.8089657425880432,
-0.6262327432632446,
-0.4694880545139313,
0.06633343547582626,
-0.006308916490525007,
0.05001656711101532,
0.291626900434494,
-0.3059036135673523,
1.280710220336914,
-0.9255943298339844,
-0.2870381474494934,
-0.27344605326652527,
0.49547749757766724,
0.04853404685854912,
0.07659474015235901,
0.586704671382904,
-0.6450105905532837,
0.059366852045059204,
-0.16520120203495026,
-0.6814228892326355,
-0.12848976254463196,
0.13769343495368958,
0.0560951866209507,
0.11170916259288788,
0.811121940612793,
-0.7188906073570251,
0.41390499472618103,
0.22958827018737793,
-0.3092647194862366,
0.5096486806869507,
0.15692442655563354,
0.028753217309713364,
-1.0515118837356567,
0.09650249779224396,
0.2023012489080429,
-0.6649978160858154,
-0.36859822273254395,
-0.2628248631954193,
-0.0760236456990242,
-0.23872417211532593,
-0.36014214158058167,
0.7140371799468994,
-0.3433554172515869,
-0.05133378133177757,
0.09862621873617172,
0.3040691912174225,
-0.13588014245033264,
0.5424844622612,
0.03718424215912819,
0.32580628991127014,
0.045985300093889236,
-0.9501686096191406,
0.15835300087928772,
0.1565643697977066,
-0.6173148155212402,
-0.051024582237005234,
-0.47080808877944946,
-0.13722792267799377,
-0.3009400963783264,
0.28286078572273254,
-0.5618003010749817,
-0.20626607537269592,
0.28122633695602417,
-0.05903756245970726,
0.02704017050564289,
-0.33575189113616943,
-0.5969536304473877,
0.05494247004389763,
-0.016673853620886803,
0.14662030339241028,
0.2250787317752838,
-0.42635154724121094,
0.7198653817176819,
0.5978401899337769,
-0.2932514548301697,
-0.4326392114162445,
-0.583071768283844,
0.14030779898166656,
-0.30979645252227783,
-0.3701772689819336,
0.5912025570869446,
0.006024632137268782,
-0.5290781855583191,
0.22137565910816193,
-0.4369218647480011,
-0.03871985897421837,
0.07618091255426407,
0.36508145928382874,
0.17931678891181946,
-0.27435216307640076,
0.20581109821796417,
0.1477123349905014,
-0.19023703038692474,
0.0834905356168747,
-0.2662450671195984,
0.5704695582389832,
0.11743597686290741,
0.02680533193051815,
-0.315289705991745,
0.16310210525989532,
0.7978072762489319,
-0.33069801330566406,
0.6741846203804016,
0.8057892322540283,
-0.5261313915252686,
-0.38470903038978577,
-0.4278309941291809,
0.025987591594457626,
-0.30623143911361694,
0.22150900959968567,
-0.011800517328083515,
-0.9924734234809875,
0.2280961126089096,
-0.41110673546791077,
0.3282715082168579,
0.6679770946502686,
0.18161554634571075,
-0.3901473879814148,
0.611649215221405,
0.5471704006195068,
0.027628786861896515,
0.7895327806472778,
-0.34761783480644226,
0.15642127394676208,
-0.7674710154533386,
-0.32686957716941833,
-0.5597628951072693,
-0.08274379372596741,
-0.3540591597557068,
-0.08105690777301788,
0.5192686319351196,
-0.23671633005142212,
-0.6864545345306396,
0.2002185881137848,
0.40056467056274414,
0.19591650366783142,
0.3436979055404663,
0.4968838095664978,
0.37837764620780945,
0.06649741530418396,
0.12976166605949402,
-0.13648071885108948,
-0.680335521697998,
-0.5261465907096863,
0.7029334902763367,
0.1858547180891037,
0.28075110912323,
0.21165357530117035,
0.5215749144554138,
0.3696724474430084,
0.09150582551956177,
-0.7463406324386597,
0.6718491315841675,
-0.546973466873169,
-0.2855205237865448,
-0.2749917805194855,
-0.967201292514801,
-0.6282582879066467,
-0.2250075340270996,
-0.22762173414230347,
-0.6737610101699829,
0.023653654381632805,
-0.34459543228149414,
-0.38530048727989197,
0.1717972308397293,
-0.6121475696563721,
0.652949869632721,
-0.23789642751216888,
-0.08980941772460938,
-0.197187140583992,
-0.7960618138313293,
0.20911726355552673,
0.23270609974861145,
0.3787524104118347,
-0.46486562490463257,
0.2165686935186386,
1.0681602954864502,
-0.7867932915687561,
0.7995175123214722,
-0.16514253616333008,
0.33690524101257324,
0.05557459965348244,
0.3685397505760193,
0.577885627746582,
0.3573088049888611,
0.046915676444768906,
-0.19418609142303467,
0.005216829013079405,
-0.1856670081615448,
-0.6532135009765625,
0.5648651123046875,
-0.6262658834457397,
-0.27400243282318115,
-0.4422748386859894,
-0.5916006565093994,
-0.28597527742385864,
0.1746426820755005,
0.214874267578125,
1.331766128540039,
-0.4408417046070099,
0.19886735081672668,
0.7009832262992859,
-0.004241573624312878,
1.0357263088226318,
0.43513521552085876,
-0.03487672284245491,
-0.2408938854932785,
0.3592664301395416,
0.19744837284088135,
-0.030720794573426247,
0.7886595726013184,
0.32119303941726685,
-0.32809093594551086,
-0.27817654609680176,
-0.0072194915264844894,
0.24829570949077606,
-0.6148871183395386,
-0.1937061995267868,
-1.0335510969161987,
-0.2678210735321045,
-0.3092048466205597,
0.15092772245407104,
-0.0666373148560524,
-0.5782023668289185,
-0.3870442807674408,
-0.23275595903396606,
0.3483949303627014,
0.5797365307807922,
0.39198967814445496,
0.2556280791759491,
-0.9575751423835754,
0.6383962035179138,
0.1266910433769226,
-0.016119161620736122,
-0.2651590406894684,
-0.2239408642053604,
0.012085792608559132,
-0.09439463168382645,
0.04729120060801506,
-0.6809821128845215,
0.4863288700580597,
0.43968796730041504,
0.3863917589187622,
0.2445903718471527,
0.34862077236175537,
0.9267461895942688,
-0.3675638735294342,
0.6698079705238342,
-0.10172239691019058,
-0.9628268480300903,
0.5082141160964966,
-0.22416463494300842,
0.31925585865974426,
-0.017622068524360657,
0.3228568434715271,
-0.5964379906654358,
-0.20577743649482727,
-0.6980584859848022,
-0.9269608855247498,
0.7218254208564758,
0.07648755609989166,
-0.2630774974822998,
-0.0014700780156999826,
0.4640170931816101,
0.0031043437775224447,
0.1236235648393631,
-0.6362570524215698,
-0.1585249900817871,
0.38920384645462036,
-0.1914054900407791,
-0.28262433409690857,
-0.5150485634803772,
-0.19005964696407318,
-0.07146206498146057,
0.41689714789390564,
0.13119111955165863,
0.020169349387288094,
0.24208031594753265,
-0.7286964058876038,
0.1573440134525299,
0.4940032362937927,
0.39048877358436584,
0.7205570340156555,
-0.292893648147583,
0.2605036199092865,
0.11501498520374298,
-0.26788175106048584,
-0.0728946179151535,
0.028510848060250282,
-0.2792991101741791,
-0.06351050734519958,
0.855162501335144,
0.628614604473114,
0.4778495132923126,
-0.5252481698989868,
0.4541469216346741,
-0.2526845932006836,
0.24477404356002808,
-0.2935486137866974,
-0.056730788201093674,
-0.11026591807603836,
0.5698944330215454,
0.5294701457023621,
0.3857079744338989,
-0.10392074286937714,
-0.8457670211791992,
0.4751381278038025,
-0.0464731901884079,
-0.32334819436073303,
-0.415134459733963,
0.46851301193237305,
0.06518765538930893,
-0.012749789282679558,
0.7958609461784363,
-0.3779619038105011,
-0.7325451970100403,
0.5284267067909241,
0.5438494086265564,
0.9659252166748047,
0.2936694025993347,
0.316854327917099,
0.35293614864349365,
0.05861836299300194,
-0.04034719243645668,
0.2110809087753296,
0.020681047812104225,
-0.6012610793113708,
-0.663707971572876,
-0.6454331874847412,
0.09648916125297546,
0.06902261078357697,
-0.37122878432273865,
0.22567862272262573,
-0.5655253529548645,
-0.21004793047904968,
0.02776223234832287,
0.2977462410926819,
-1.007312297821045,
0.10314328968524933,
-0.0986933708190918,
0.6899964809417725,
-0.9572294354438782,
0.7157135605812073,
0.21139971911907196,
-0.3274562358856201,
-0.7403555512428284,
0.40763694047927856,
0.04433586820960045,
-0.12595218420028687,
1.092413067817688,
-0.12694020569324493,
-0.37657755613327026,
0.08880975842475891,
-0.5575239062309265,
-0.5250279307365417,
1.0929995775222778,
0.8378945589065552,
-0.4168816804885864,
-0.3527851700782776,
-0.3188762962818146,
0.36436501145362854,
-0.47570309042930603,
0.023886404931545258,
0.40616580843925476,
0.44643330574035645,
0.11135707795619965,
-0.6059154868125916,
0.11216332763433456,
0.13631872832775116,
-0.29939043521881104,
0.24734297394752502,
-0.2755931317806244,
0.882403552532196,
-0.16627107560634613,
-0.8819379210472107,
-0.1558859646320343,
0.7683004140853882,
-0.11870820820331573,
0.5031749606132507,
0.4551267623901367,
0.3507383465766907,
0.8587506413459778,
-0.24969342350959778,
0.7846451997756958,
0.008840452879667282,
0.33250153064727783,
1.2067604064941406,
-0.1346721351146698,
0.649516224861145,
0.3875342905521393,
0.1891578733921051,
0.7292622327804565,
0.38732945919036865,
0.47055888175964355,
0.493550181388855,
-0.3159336447715759,
-0.05777707323431969,
-0.3533177077770233,
-0.3210256099700928,
0.1071544736623764,
0.5688676238059998,
0.42817434668540955,
-0.06248009204864502,
-0.7861139178276062,
0.05245247110724449,
0.4803156852722168,
-0.14454282820224762,
-0.33957013487815857,
0.6976516842842102,
-0.0037518958561122417,
-0.6215280890464783,
-0.11211588978767395,
-0.012186429463326931,
0.058838553726673126,
-0.5333567261695862,
-0.122750423848629,
-0.057784706354141235,
0.2595089077949524,
-0.2037867158651352,
-0.8090792298316956,
0.3108915388584137,
0.24999062716960907,
-0.2572895884513855,
-0.26698893308639526,
0.496002197265625,
-0.5801465511322021,
-0.17684805393218994,
0.18555140495300293,
0.5091306567192078,
-0.3371780216693878,
-0.05060786381363869,
-0.19691486656665802,
-0.06451854854822159,
-0.10564898699522018,
-0.10373436659574509,
-0.09354854375123978,
0.8392621278762817,
-0.21807636320590973,
0.8504247665405273,
0.6353534460067749,
0.04039296880364418,
-0.20045530796051025,
-0.023496761918067932,
0.8147433996200562,
-0.7811235785484314,
-0.5553173422813416,
-1.1225241422653198,
0.35482051968574524,
-0.15668825805187225,
-0.333146870136261,
0.806572675704956,
0.6077060103416443,
0.4413721561431885,
0.17866703867912292,
0.6803780198097229,
-0.22929763793945312,
0.6925433278083801,
-0.8667215704917908,
0.3597026467323303,
-0.28056561946868896,
0.4414847493171692,
-0.34412968158721924,
-0.8534522652626038,
-0.36797285079956055,
-0.04025176912546158,
-0.31115201115608215,
-0.2738349735736847,
0.777772843837738,
0.5099284052848816,
-0.13278178870677948,
0.008384604007005692,
-0.2711239755153656,
0.38239994645118713,
0.6892930269241333,
0.4167855679988861,
0.8071543574333191,
-0.21962006390094757,
0.6571325659751892,
-0.24639222025871277,
-0.1464294195175171,
-0.3936055898666382,
-1.2423888444900513,
-0.8056177496910095,
-0.9127534627914429,
-0.3802959620952606,
-0.2354211062192917,
0.140675351023674,
1.2304298877716064,
0.42155152559280396,
-0.528878927230835,
-0.043744124472141266,
0.17548754811286926,
0.17074361443519592,
-0.21714308857917786,
-0.2094155251979828,
0.7726861834526062,
-0.16275398433208466,
-0.38366425037384033,
0.6263294816017151,
0.3921988904476166,
-0.08444923162460327,
0.30180972814559937,
0.1399107128381729,
-0.2848045825958252,
-0.1564445048570633,
0.9060482382774353,
0.2482019066810608,
-0.36719322204589844,
-0.6830273866653442,
0.2175203263759613,
-0.18713289499282837,
-0.12778545916080475,
1.1133735179901123,
-0.8215405344963074,
0.3701261579990387,
0.8164247870445251,
0.41727304458618164,
0.9497621655464172,
0.09286864846944809,
0.7472289800643921,
-1.1355878114700317,
0.05108615756034851,
0.27022677659988403,
0.47965237498283386,
0.08087452501058578,
-0.1988184005022049,
0.40271133184432983,
0.34584808349609375,
-0.31545716524124146,
-0.7350202798843384,
0.35882893204689026,
-1.1322338581085205,
-0.42046940326690674,
1.132598638534546,
-0.07090654224157333,
-0.4681618809700012,
-0.3078635036945343,
0.022804224863648415,
0.8413947820663452,
-0.1487293690443039,
0.6148194670677185,
0.4615030288696289,
-0.06611579656600952,
0.09921035170555115,
-0.33632829785346985,
0.5565744042396545,
-0.21269699931144714,
-0.6574879884719849,
0.18609900772571564,
0.603191614151001,
0.461673378944397,
-0.08366856724023819,
0.35565635561943054,
-0.24263806641101837,
0.11718247085809708,
-0.38363730907440186,
-0.15897998213768005,
-0.3200037479400635,
-0.5391637086868286,
0.17444567382335663,
0.4539606273174286,
-0.25075188279151917,
-0.026147115975618362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10276v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10276v1
|
Revisiting OPRO: The Limitations of Small-Scale LLMs as Optimizers
| 2024-05-16T17:33:50 | 2024-05-16T17:33:50 |
Tuo Zhang, Jinyue Yuan, Salman Avestimehr
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Numerous recent works aim to enhance the efficacy of Large Language Models
(LLMs) through strategic prompting. In particular, the Optimization by
PROmpting (OPRO) approach provides state-of-the-art performance by leveraging
LLMs as optimizers where the optimization task is to find instructions that
maximize the task accuracy. In this paper, we revisit OPRO for automated
prompting with relatively small-scale LLMs, such as LLaMa-2 family and Mistral
7B. Our investigation reveals that OPRO shows limited effectiveness in
small-scale LLMs, with limited inference capabilities constraining optimization
ability. We suggest future automatic prompting engineering to consider both
model capabilities and computational costs. Additionally, for small-scale LLMs,
we recommend direct instructions that clearly outline objectives and
methodologies as robust prompt baselines, ensuring efficient and effective
prompt engineering in ongoing research.
|
[
-0.38843411207199097,
-0.8085716366767883,
0.7819427251815796,
0.2355584055185318,
-0.2342343032360077,
-0.19702096283435822,
-0.412352591753006,
-0.2148377001285553,
-0.1756117045879364,
0.27347657084465027,
-0.7607722282409668,
-0.08891896158456802,
-0.39605841040611267,
0.48974671959877014,
0.15705345571041107,
0.5453804135322571,
-0.38886913657188416,
0.003994173835963011,
0.04324420541524887,
0.06974348425865173,
-0.5971946120262146,
0.05652013421058655,
-0.9081924557685852,
-0.12035305798053741,
0.7127153277397156,
0.9697151184082031,
0.5870519876480103,
0.615418553352356,
0.23587222397327423,
0.26579952239990234,
-0.30567091703414917,
0.4780423641204834,
-0.6318972706794739,
0.2757031321525574,
0.052336618304252625,
-0.46825602650642395,
-0.28016772866249084,
-0.12120233476161957,
0.6476230025291443,
0.7518439888954163,
-0.20133088529109955,
0.3328060507774353,
0.2174680233001709,
0.727331817150116,
-0.9157024025917053,
-0.1324670910835266,
-0.7486576437950134,
0.020810944959521294,
0.16853687167167664,
-0.0873943641781807,
-0.560989260673523,
-0.3749040365219116,
0.05509229004383087,
-0.6393398642539978,
-0.14144794642925262,
0.4839813709259033,
0.5546363592147827,
0.7192225456237793,
0.07388926297426224,
-0.6407299637794495,
-0.7130642533302307,
0.9603301286697388,
-0.621355414390564,
0.031076829880475998,
0.3656215965747833,
0.28857603669166565,
-0.31385260820388794,
-0.5140756368637085,
-0.34131938219070435,
-0.5231207013130188,
-0.02683902345597744,
-0.11647237092256546,
-0.645999550819397,
0.14607977867126465,
0.2986445426940918,
0.19154979288578033,
-0.387026846408844,
0.494283527135849,
-0.5949003100395203,
-0.038093168288469315,
0.2788480818271637,
0.245557963848114,
-0.02488511987030506,
-0.04933841526508331,
-0.3978307247161865,
0.040786124765872955,
-0.9649187326431274,
0.16865767538547516,
0.3518052399158478,
0.3638412654399872,
0.13481581211090088,
0.540951132774353,
-0.18717797100543976,
0.7834658026695251,
0.3244157135486603,
-0.09562338888645172,
-0.1997142881155014,
-0.2326430082321167,
-0.1725461333990097,
0.09308019280433655,
1.0706539154052734,
0.08260396867990494,
0.23465551435947418,
0.3648753762245178,
-0.3533000946044922,
-0.13802310824394226,
0.21703311800956726,
-0.6007791757583618,
0.0049850838258862495,
0.3095611333847046,
-0.3615565896034241,
-0.410386323928833,
-0.1438443958759308,
-0.9727576971054077,
-0.30747154355049133,
-0.1379663050174713,
0.6675555109977722,
-0.1875929981470108,
0.06688706576824188,
0.14533460140228271,
-0.04796590283513069,
0.1239633858203888,
0.36126407980918884,
-0.9627498984336853,
0.1604919731616974,
0.6082106828689575,
0.9577738642692566,
0.0736575797200203,
-0.2428906261920929,
-0.873502254486084,
-0.021124577149748802,
-0.6219931244850159,
0.6242188215255737,
-0.6023913621902466,
-0.749700665473938,
-0.12885628640651703,
-0.3665173053741455,
-0.10750574618577957,
-0.7237797379493713,
0.3994893431663513,
-0.4181760549545288,
0.0632355660200119,
-0.436005175113678,
0.07506261765956879,
0.09402250498533249,
-0.0987900048494339,
-0.6391319632530212,
1.2269102334976196,
0.26293492317199707,
-0.3674578368663788,
0.2370469570159912,
-0.6758370399475098,
-0.27904585003852844,
-0.04464712738990784,
-0.32126858830451965,
-0.151347354054451,
0.4467190206050873,
0.48785486817359924,
0.05361589044332504,
-0.7496888041496277,
0.2068149447441101,
-0.06976114213466644,
-0.2765839993953705,
-0.16678689420223236,
-0.3101317286491394,
0.6173396110534668,
0.45291998982429504,
-0.3716966211795807,
0.31204691529273987,
-0.5100197196006775,
-0.11296295374631882,
0.08575287461280823,
-0.3203801214694977,
-0.21895134449005127,
-0.02159162424504757,
-0.6804984211921692,
-0.11151377111673355,
0.4923368990421295,
-0.2713029980659485,
0.4931887090206146,
-0.37019816040992737,
0.7484080791473389,
0.9373644590377808,
-0.046358127146959305,
0.7252118587493896,
-0.1672189086675644,
1.1386557817459106,
-0.4823160767555237,
0.4354795813560486,
-0.1705549955368042,
-0.5563639998435974,
-0.5903781056404114,
-0.4573979377746582,
0.12549278140068054,
0.5458027124404907,
-0.7470694780349731,
0.24114984273910522,
0.04671594873070717,
-0.4246204197406769,
-0.7438425421714783,
0.33416417241096497,
0.2530743181705475,
0.7260562181472778,
0.2289806455373764,
0.06583715230226517,
-0.5741685628890991,
-1.0552667379379272,
-0.14440375566482544,
-0.280365526676178,
0.14313378930091858,
0.3514811396598816,
0.29919689893722534,
-0.21123898029327393,
1.1186939477920532,
-0.3991997241973877,
-0.11598549783229828,
-0.5127203464508057,
0.22342120110988617,
0.27842825651168823,
0.16293002665042877,
0.5660293102264404,
-0.513228178024292,
-0.7231041193008423,
-0.025379186496138573,
-0.45241597294807434,
-0.6568100452423096,
0.02790689654648304,
0.0064919209107756615,
0.12119990587234497,
0.8130404949188232,
-0.4552541971206665,
0.2221582531929016,
0.5743500590324402,
0.33328184485435486,
0.5724887251853943,
-0.2196476012468338,
0.02315223030745983,
-0.5550302863121033,
0.12630480527877808,
-0.3775048851966858,
0.18106764554977417,
-0.4560980498790741,
-0.27459046244621277,
-0.03565360978245735,
-0.23167504370212555,
-0.4082478880882263,
0.749724268913269,
-0.8161666393280029,
0.14883100986480713,
-0.4890937805175781,
0.09569815546274185,
-0.16424159705638885,
0.22534775733947754,
-0.09950081259012222,
1.1638942956924438,
0.6545652151107788,
-0.700175404548645,
0.08302313089370728,
0.2567570209503174,
-0.21496953070163727,
0.48715123534202576,
-1.0271741151809692,
0.08268740028142929,
-0.17065033316612244,
0.09193199872970581,
-1.1264654397964478,
-0.3730125427246094,
0.5050129890441895,
-0.23793946206569672,
0.2154504805803299,
-0.19287097454071045,
-0.3843139410018921,
-0.662015974521637,
-0.5955645442008972,
0.37746620178222656,
0.9539616703987122,
-0.7632142901420593,
0.6868606805801392,
-0.04312565550208092,
-0.32894811034202576,
-0.6098811030387878,
-0.24320773780345917,
-0.09151563793420792,
-0.35911381244659424,
-0.5887001156806946,
-0.08932847529649734,
0.1140294149518013,
-0.4554123878479004,
-0.07753428816795349,
-0.031947579234838486,
0.28998029232025146,
-0.037560466676950455,
0.19556072354316711,
0.2170785814523697,
-0.2773812413215637,
-0.148533895611763,
0.35374727845191956,
-0.0794937014579773,
0.12952081859111786,
-0.34547263383865356,
0.5584920644760132,
-0.08992829918861389,
-0.26275351643562317,
-0.45497146248817444,
0.3894122242927551,
0.3104604184627533,
-0.24359376728534698,
0.7506453990936279,
0.3051265478134155,
-0.08199207484722137,
-0.4449240267276764,
-0.48766466975212097,
-0.3824419379234314,
-0.6387456655502319,
-0.043626416474580765,
-0.42066487669944763,
-1.049443244934082,
0.3305557668209076,
-0.38282543420791626,
-0.0791405588388443,
0.39037781953811646,
0.4181687533855438,
0.07799431681632996,
1.0102288722991943,
0.5352920889854431,
-0.10576105117797852,
0.5870895385742188,
-0.025037232786417007,
0.1315293312072754,
-0.9570047855377197,
0.11194580793380737,
-0.6951014399528503,
-0.3073384463787079,
-0.2743440270423889,
-0.35752081871032715,
0.7738535404205322,
0.2838670313358307,
-0.10367889702320099,
0.2287600189447403,
-0.6979047656059265,
0.5806599259376526,
0.682979166507721,
-0.029161492362618446,
0.1153494268655777,
0.06102892756462097,
-0.1484956294298172,
0.21341641247272491,
-1.2501378059387207,
-0.8144457936286926,
0.6808451414108276,
0.22868290543556213,
1.1632410287857056,
-0.19801966845989227,
0.6677914261817932,
-0.004550767596811056,
0.22055073082447052,
-1.0353269577026367,
0.6260671615600586,
0.3785695731639862,
-0.3737018406391144,
-0.4404653012752533,
-0.4283742308616638,
-1.3148407936096191,
0.12641389667987823,
0.1390741467475891,
-0.7703415751457214,
0.42579978704452515,
0.5862662196159363,
-0.7186618447303772,
-0.08787734061479568,
-0.748216450214386,
0.7792521119117737,
-0.21634508669376373,
-0.14062784612178802,
-0.05970636010169983,
-0.6423246264457703,
0.17193126678466797,
-0.22845794260501862,
0.39200618863105774,
0.24475738406181335,
-0.5949552655220032,
0.479623407125473,
-0.721808910369873,
1.0370292663574219,
-0.11143198609352112,
-0.3968723714351654,
0.6856879591941833,
0.09439239650964737,
0.8389253616333008,
-0.261330783367157,
-0.21087998151779175,
-0.287118136882782,
-0.3684677481651306,
-0.151602104306221,
-0.40869152545928955,
0.7576663494110107,
-0.47490057349205017,
-0.8720176815986633,
-0.16108153760433197,
-0.23293401300907135,
-0.2854533791542053,
0.17462286353111267,
0.5877097249031067,
0.31230974197387695,
0.06492482125759125,
0.04200911149382591,
0.6232561469078064,
-0.40688639879226685,
0.5581717491149902,
0.4686207175254822,
0.09246407449245453,
-0.6623875498771667,
0.7262491583824158,
0.00565358204767108,
0.6319887042045593,
0.18073107302188873,
0.8180394172668457,
-0.07593943923711777,
-0.7979406118392944,
-0.5605815052986145,
0.43710416555404663,
-0.6143664717674255,
-0.14891010522842407,
-0.34578293561935425,
0.4378499686717987,
-0.2391849309206009,
-0.45058101415634155,
-0.314154714345932,
-0.2457478791475296,
-0.5023643970489502,
0.10480672121047974,
0.44814884662628174,
1.0944100618362427,
-0.36813291907310486,
0.5032652020454407,
-0.6167171597480774,
0.16139717400074005,
0.2216978669166565,
0.013778039254248142,
0.290772020816803,
-0.5777198076248169,
-0.10030298680067062,
-0.18641529977321625,
-0.08733758330345154,
-0.9036557078361511,
0.17569591104984283,
0.12288771569728851,
0.5999814867973328,
0.4159362316131592,
0.29282069206237793,
0.5495776534080505,
-0.8409988284111023,
0.8018243908882141,
-0.012524851597845554,
-0.881648063659668,
0.9669011831283569,
-0.4706244170665741,
0.4319668114185333,
0.7385901808738708,
0.5790475606918335,
-0.1419215053319931,
-0.24873442947864532,
-0.5038756728172302,
-0.9569755792617798,
0.9611623883247375,
-0.1262304186820984,
-0.04353724792599678,
-0.09971528500318527,
0.4236007630825043,
0.25414833426475525,
0.47702714800834656,
-0.331518292427063,
-0.028328508138656616,
0.40531450510025024,
-0.20018556714057922,
0.2333553284406662,
-0.3976812958717346,
-0.12989483773708344,
0.01671529747545719,
0.6448267698287964,
-0.21380756795406342,
0.20788398385047913,
0.33536240458488464,
0.1387285590171814,
-0.5229424834251404,
0.1349714696407318,
0.8838950991630554,
0.584363579750061,
0.2255043089389801,
-0.16210950911045074,
0.4097532033920288,
-0.34616661071777344,
0.04012861102819443,
-0.2008458971977234,
-0.3000759780406952,
-0.09611073136329651,
0.3124685287475586,
0.7734799385070801,
0.19267407059669495,
-0.6486185193061829,
0.1863481104373932,
0.27061352133750916,
-0.10956542193889618,
-0.17160426080226898,
0.33908867835998535,
-0.18842440843582153,
0.19333475828170776,
0.508673906326294,
-0.03370130434632301,
0.02660997584462166,
-0.41127437353134155,
-0.3817788362503052,
0.5939257740974426,
-0.30807724595069885,
-0.09429964423179626,
0.7545821666717529,
0.18278658390045166,
-0.49539828300476074,
0.1558641642332077,
-0.25450339913368225,
-0.6008622050285339,
0.5490062236785889,
0.06854968518018723,
0.638267993927002,
-0.40214717388153076,
-0.014623578637838364,
0.4402642548084259,
0.690456211566925,
-0.4997137784957886,
0.39839452505111694,
-0.15657372772693634,
-0.2276683896780014,
-0.5359330177307129,
-0.3506675660610199,
-0.7485682368278503,
-0.014999918639659882,
-0.6163308620452881,
0.40148621797561646,
-0.6116210222244263,
-0.060683708637952805,
-0.25330764055252075,
-0.38171327114105225,
-0.24174219369888306,
-0.12065932899713516,
-0.053467150777578354,
0.9888719916343689,
-0.4271583557128906,
0.3484480381011963,
0.5987986922264099,
-0.25774556398391724,
-1.1554999351501465,
-0.31887972354888916,
0.1760396808385849,
-1.0106581449508667,
0.6598471999168396,
0.04866250231862068,
-0.6244462728500366,
0.1048656776547432,
-0.7949552536010742,
-0.6744268536567688,
1.0094016790390015,
0.34446296095848083,
-0.6950312256813049,
-0.06954515725374222,
0.012669145129621029,
0.4399780333042145,
-0.35723167657852173,
0.04506487399339676,
0.37123996019363403,
0.6846888661384583,
0.17419639229774475,
-1.180978536605835,
0.1143476739525795,
0.12729835510253906,
-0.0351613387465477,
0.4610683023929596,
-0.7721573710441589,
0.8322888016700745,
-0.46750983595848083,
-0.13867446780204773,
0.42634838819503784,
0.6453225016593933,
0.2357548624277115,
0.19677409529685974,
0.6204133629798889,
0.04546128585934639,
0.7649673223495483,
0.09586018323898315,
1.11589777469635,
-0.04320632666349411,
0.09320976585149765,
0.9503116011619568,
-0.3460136651992798,
0.9872353076934814,
0.7576825022697449,
-0.1783904880285263,
0.270065575838089,
0.6917441487312317,
0.0957612469792366,
0.4090811610221863,
0.015145642682909966,
-0.21284353733062744,
-0.017069846391677856,
-0.14719723165035248,
-0.3276260495185852,
0.2077348828315735,
0.45196622610092163,
-0.43337973952293396,
-0.0957825630903244,
0.06460697948932648,
0.06428921967744827,
-0.04430529102683067,
-0.44541284441947937,
0.7530465126037598,
0.20252691209316254,
-0.9575207233428955,
0.8026812672615051,
-0.3028401732444763,
0.5688682794570923,
-0.6519623398780823,
0.22837944328784943,
-0.1287325918674469,
0.031062612310051918,
-0.018391171470284462,
-0.3635358214378357,
0.03648785129189491,
0.03917048126459122,
-0.040857698768377304,
-0.3704066872596741,
0.7339146733283997,
-0.24076974391937256,
-0.2668103873729706,
0.12927109003067017,
0.5705418586730957,
0.03894713148474693,
-0.09411077201366425,
-0.5025266408920288,
0.34478604793548584,
-0.0046548135578632355,
-0.4506080150604248,
-0.0009354115463793278,
0.6614834666252136,
-0.1049250066280365,
0.7430115342140198,
0.5171506404876709,
0.21747387945652008,
-0.09244924038648605,
-0.04353220760822296,
0.8514125347137451,
-0.4576708674430847,
-0.291949063539505,
-1.0096228122711182,
0.21222983300685883,
0.18373847007751465,
-0.372762531042099,
0.8100300431251526,
0.2632853090763092,
0.5405110120773315,
-0.29140177369117737,
0.7179207801818848,
-0.04306584596633911,
0.39258065819740295,
-0.61478590965271,
0.23730377852916718,
-0.5663402080535889,
0.313994437456131,
-0.09083083271980286,
-0.8649892807006836,
0.10748748481273651,
0.6274341940879822,
-0.7056252360343933,
0.17417658865451813,
0.7876836657524109,
1.0185844898223877,
0.10245124995708466,
0.1413678377866745,
0.07839100062847137,
0.10026717931032181,
0.01648680865764618,
0.5159949660301208,
1.2475569248199463,
0.05535144731402397,
0.7419123649597168,
-0.04101609066128731,
-0.47576379776000977,
-0.5329951047897339,
-0.9606881141662598,
-1.102871298789978,
-0.2796356678009033,
-0.145603746175766,
0.1156625971198082,
-0.083077073097229,
1.0981974601745605,
0.4497872292995453,
-0.5292012691497803,
-0.22076281905174255,
-0.16280202567577362,
-0.0126480832695961,
-0.12325219810009003,
-0.15162990987300873,
-0.0009867907501757145,
-0.45399022102355957,
-0.7083916068077087,
0.7701866030693054,
0.3314564824104309,
0.13134820759296417,
-0.42427244782447815,
-0.05195034295320511,
0.17196732759475708,
0.22212155163288116,
0.5118923187255859,
0.5200287699699402,
-0.809328556060791,
-0.11204557865858078,
0.245589941740036,
-0.1441151201725006,
-0.021308137103915215,
0.9911132454872131,
-0.6714940071105957,
0.19008469581604004,
0.4826388955116272,
0.48913976550102234,
0.03721312806010246,
0.1335417479276657,
0.8897323608398438,
-0.40818291902542114,
0.06360290199518204,
0.28567811846733093,
0.23975498974323273,
0.2525584101676941,
-0.3529503345489502,
0.6525790691375732,
-0.2532447278499603,
-0.5974376201629639,
-0.8938427567481995,
0.3284037411212921,
-0.7536023855209351,
-0.2608955204486847,
1.4434300661087036,
0.3038908541202545,
-0.4694359004497528,
0.08000422269105911,
-0.9424831867218018,
-0.27954620122909546,
-0.7520200610160828,
0.37137192487716675,
0.6253914833068848,
-0.396194189786911,
-0.27749699354171753,
-0.6900006532669067,
0.6621515154838562,
0.6522021293640137,
-0.6406469941139221,
0.04774286225438118,
0.5535278916358948,
-0.21059633791446686,
0.18138904869556427,
0.5363186597824097,
0.19662751257419586,
0.3663530945777893,
0.12237542867660522,
-0.4770553410053253,
-0.22780220210552216,
-0.4063582122325897,
-0.5448279976844788,
0.1303030252456665,
0.38863319158554077,
0.011596650816500187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10266v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10266v1
|
A Tale of Two Languages: Large-Vocabulary Continuous Sign Language Recognition from Spoken Language Supervision
| 2024-05-16T17:19:06 | 2024-05-16T17:19:06 |
Charles Raude, K R Prajwal, Liliane Momeni, Hannah Bull, Samuel Albanie, Andrew Zisserman, Gül Varol
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
In this work, our goals are two fold: large-vocabulary continuous sign
language recognition (CSLR), and sign language retrieval. To this end, we
introduce a multi-task Transformer model, CSLR2, that is able to ingest a
signing sequence and output in a joint embedding space between signed language
and spoken language text. To enable CSLR evaluation in the large-vocabulary
setting, we introduce new dataset annotations that have been manually
collected. These provide continuous sign-level annotations for six hours of
test videos, and will be made publicly available. We demonstrate that by a
careful choice of loss functions, training the model for both the CSLR and
retrieval tasks is mutually beneficial in terms of performance -- retrieval
improves CSLR performance by providing context, while CSLR improves retrieval
with more fine-grained supervision. We further show the benefits of leveraging
weak and noisy supervision from large-vocabulary datasets such as BOBSL, namely
sign-level pseudo-labels, and English subtitles. Our model significantly
outperforms the previous state of the art on both tasks.
|
[
0.2700449526309967,
-0.2345711588859558,
0.30338698625564575,
0.16182996332645416,
-0.31049540638923645,
0.30811306834220886,
-0.40367409586906433,
-0.7757724523544312,
0.031578171998262405,
0.5344458222389221,
-0.11819182336330414,
-0.11643435060977936,
-0.9565204977989197,
-0.043816693127155304,
-0.6533240079879761,
1.0032743215560913,
-0.12662054598331451,
0.330336332321167,
0.11631862074136734,
0.06514237821102142,
-0.25363266468048096,
-0.35265326499938965,
-0.9356478452682495,
-0.38386136293411255,
0.4337155818939209,
0.2204180806875229,
0.6810513138771057,
0.39818274974823,
0.5464028120040894,
0.17121899127960205,
-0.16214722394943237,
0.16159969568252563,
-0.4596503674983978,
0.11163438856601715,
0.010511969216167927,
-0.3085545599460602,
-0.14072470366954803,
-0.1006527990102768,
0.7487131357192993,
0.8045116662979126,
0.11980064958333969,
0.18380577862262726,
0.13255304098129272,
0.4397011399269104,
-0.4966962933540344,
0.2707253694534302,
-0.3201497495174408,
0.21905551850795746,
-0.28397423028945923,
0.2010052651166916,
-0.5991290211677551,
-0.19885443150997162,
0.13862751424312592,
-0.4988914430141449,
0.22569119930267334,
0.05477043613791466,
0.8293411731719971,
-0.010300980880856514,
-0.5827922224998474,
-0.4408210217952728,
-0.8414378762245178,
0.9606215357780457,
-0.3522163927555084,
0.7074205875396729,
0.44742339849472046,
0.46088773012161255,
0.33541029691696167,
-0.8082770109176636,
-0.5703875422477722,
-0.4382123649120331,
-0.28746235370635986,
0.11941337585449219,
-0.20111559331417084,
-0.13887083530426025,
0.2871367633342743,
0.39243176579475403,
-0.5633874535560608,
0.26231443881988525,
-0.760844349861145,
-0.5204014778137207,
0.6022115349769592,
0.036637160927057266,
0.18168772757053375,
0.08178021013736725,
-0.4615785479545593,
-0.3838227689266205,
-0.5595706701278687,
0.16853797435760498,
0.10563366860151291,
0.6776416897773743,
-0.345774382352829,
0.45225536823272705,
0.1855335682630539,
0.6299976110458374,
-0.14541742205619812,
-0.32055291533470154,
0.24664688110351562,
-0.21992084383964539,
0.2445223182439804,
0.017442308366298676,
0.7442862391471863,
0.2685394287109375,
0.4386577010154724,
-0.234023317694664,
-0.19080302119255066,
0.13986088335514069,
-0.18545404076576233,
-0.5577338337898254,
-0.15184740722179413,
-0.08385690301656723,
-0.4515267014503479,
-0.10440681874752045,
0.2960801124572754,
-0.465254545211792,
-0.7850545048713684,
-0.5835753679275513,
0.2894964814186096,
-0.23610030114650726,
-0.5317268967628479,
0.1735471934080124,
-0.4198891818523407,
0.368360310792923,
0.36136406660079956,
-0.6913118362426758,
0.4501488208770752,
0.790698766708374,
0.9468150734901428,
-0.38357552886009216,
0.06474471837282181,
-0.8021969199180603,
0.08993896842002869,
-0.23864775896072388,
0.2565666437149048,
-0.5609192848205566,
-0.2425202578306198,
0.17563560605049133,
0.04535298049449921,
0.016678765416145325,
-0.16821865737438202,
0.40056657791137695,
-0.5059301257133484,
-0.010800466872751713,
-0.14651237428188324,
-0.16979795694351196,
-0.017444415017962456,
0.00622554263100028,
-0.7158724665641785,
1.1647236347198486,
0.08601676672697067,
-0.36457398533821106,
0.38915783166885376,
-0.35632559657096863,
-1.0023434162139893,
0.13972774147987366,
-0.1543838530778885,
-0.4204499423503876,
-0.09488661587238312,
-0.16878274083137512,
0.5887590050697327,
-0.2481786012649536,
-0.11822623014450073,
0.09586729854345322,
-0.34250080585479736,
0.22660470008850098,
-0.39590105414390564,
0.7992492318153381,
0.19052638113498688,
-0.31654223799705505,
-0.2960708439350128,
-0.7073200345039368,
-0.22739607095718384,
0.03786708042025566,
-0.41504186391830444,
-0.4855002164840698,
0.04227347671985626,
0.4286799728870392,
0.45074790716171265,
0.4671041965484619,
-0.8235673308372498,
-0.08739007264375687,
-0.3400290906429291,
0.45890724658966064,
0.22065743803977966,
-0.2149958461523056,
0.3499264717102051,
0.16298151016235352,
0.5084670186042786,
0.19892743229866028,
0.20335975289344788,
-0.20003101229667664,
-0.3152822256088257,
-0.852854311466217,
0.060297224670648575,
0.08914807438850403,
0.45402637124061584,
-0.5011091232299805,
0.21176987886428833,
-0.19507287442684174,
-0.426094114780426,
-0.49839848279953003,
0.25108036398887634,
1.0213645696640015,
0.2516672909259796,
0.49114975333213806,
-0.595596432685852,
-0.6260302662849426,
-0.6604118943214417,
0.006350889801979065,
-0.143347829580307,
0.005921749398112297,
-0.014881760813295841,
0.3339940309524536,
0.30519625544548035,
0.5165442824363708,
-0.5362381935119629,
-0.8037434220314026,
-0.4812045097351074,
0.11798303574323654,
0.2914654016494751,
0.39405038952827454,
0.3512860834598541,
-0.9611707329750061,
-0.7502596378326416,
0.44126424193382263,
-0.5159907937049866,
0.233355313539505,
-0.33586785197257996,
0.24143792688846588,
0.10746809840202332,
0.783040463924408,
-0.3276216387748718,
0.31089478731155396,
0.6943177580833435,
-0.4341278672218323,
0.6289349794387817,
-0.05110466107726097,
-0.050325166434049606,
-0.9708260297775269,
-0.01372190099209547,
-0.06963540613651276,
-0.2783081531524658,
-0.690843403339386,
-0.14533193409442902,
0.21715047955513,
-0.19531813263893127,
-0.37344110012054443,
0.5023834705352783,
-0.8852173686027527,
-0.33820703625679016,
-0.3346610963344574,
0.31948578357696533,
-0.007605775259435177,
0.2315618246793747,
0.3544822037220001,
0.7931485176086426,
0.9283540844917297,
-0.5123480558395386,
0.08605316281318665,
0.33085858821868896,
-0.2620558738708496,
0.48343366384506226,
-0.5867519378662109,
0.16831853985786438,
-0.13526204228401184,
0.08970948308706284,
-1.198129415512085,
-0.028056683018803596,
0.06993158161640167,
-0.4422904849052429,
0.7390041947364807,
-0.13598288595676422,
-0.45002445578575134,
-0.6304087042808533,
-0.021031301468610764,
0.011916158720850945,
0.5845073461532593,
-0.6551874279975891,
0.7038545608520508,
0.41664454340934753,
0.02988099679350853,
-0.6326954960823059,
-0.9681115746498108,
0.22184351086616516,
0.09718367457389832,
-0.20708529651165009,
-0.02955945022404194,
0.3005828559398651,
-0.11893665045499802,
-0.39917469024658203,
-0.07721838355064392,
-0.19798147678375244,
-0.0728166252374649,
0.4341338276863098,
0.070349782705307,
-0.1788778454065323,
0.11004424840211868,
0.08154968917369843,
-0.24806931614875793,
-0.006202578544616699,
-0.29991254210472107,
0.31236863136291504,
-0.019037039950489998,
-0.3906179666519165,
-0.46270039677619934,
0.40327170491218567,
0.5750920176506042,
-0.5148184895515442,
0.5316833853721619,
0.7500626444816589,
-0.2110070139169693,
0.0019592680037021637,
-0.5051161050796509,
-0.049406491219997406,
-0.42982763051986694,
0.4994094967842102,
-0.428173303604126,
-1.1516082286834717,
0.2982017695903778,
0.04127427935600281,
0.3064369857311249,
0.20838245749473572,
0.42859241366386414,
-0.13380075991153717,
0.8859695196151733,
0.6840490102767944,
-0.11098047345876694,
0.5960087180137634,
-0.07403183728456497,
0.2391567826271057,
-0.7226121425628662,
-0.24624526500701904,
-0.45366376638412476,
-0.15226608514785767,
0.026666656136512756,
-0.538038969039917,
0.512989342212677,
0.1862519085407257,
-0.05735425278544426,
1.0087159872055054,
-0.5677358508110046,
0.44638076424598694,
0.35369327664375305,
0.22881056368350983,
0.5174907445907593,
-0.09671475738286972,
0.07732982188463211,
-0.09023763984441757,
-0.2781450152397156,
-0.6386542916297913,
1.0084102153778076,
0.3754967749118805,
0.5169091820716858,
0.3557416796684265,
0.3958260118961334,
0.292424738407135,
0.15857160091400146,
-0.7795063853263855,
0.478865385055542,
-0.4818466901779175,
-0.5401362180709839,
-0.3531566262245178,
-0.09322022646665573,
-1.1230156421661377,
0.4290783107280731,
-0.21400366723537445,
-0.6429189443588257,
0.021555274724960327,
0.37830623984336853,
-0.17544446885585785,
0.16099108755588531,
-0.6917222738265991,
0.6871048808097839,
-0.3307552933692932,
-0.1605599969625473,
-0.5273035168647766,
-1.0584856271743774,
0.4895479381084442,
-0.295649915933609,
0.3074807822704315,
0.12562088668346405,
0.1628073900938034,
0.7044143676757812,
-0.24360260367393494,
1.1337984800338745,
-0.23377807438373566,
-0.19701211154460907,
0.2437240332365036,
0.17390261590480804,
0.5859781503677368,
-0.22835074365139008,
-0.07381952553987503,
0.08099315315485,
0.05992996320128441,
-0.10444873571395874,
-0.2969754934310913,
0.2891445457935333,
-0.5580237507820129,
-0.190922811627388,
-0.521891713142395,
-0.3345145285129547,
-0.10916287451982498,
0.2262948602437973,
-0.010418473742902279,
0.47257259488105774,
-0.13311971724033356,
0.1833713799715042,
0.47467803955078125,
0.01116587221622467,
0.5784916281700134,
0.6745371222496033,
-0.02728685550391674,
0.04293641075491905,
0.7318888306617737,
-0.099110908806324,
0.5308412313461304,
0.6007256507873535,
0.23388530313968658,
-0.3543461263179779,
-0.40096399188041687,
-0.28180843591690063,
0.25952810049057007,
-0.6649457812309265,
-0.17955021560192108,
-0.4849969446659088,
-0.03413659334182739,
-0.40005141496658325,
-0.012758373282849789,
-0.3639550805091858,
-0.5493813157081604,
-0.25233927369117737,
-0.21952885389328003,
0.521150529384613,
0.5954197645187378,
-0.3209013342857361,
0.3871164917945862,
-0.6006510853767395,
0.2908433675765991,
0.10356659442186356,
0.09188465029001236,
0.18578475713729858,
-0.6247496604919434,
-0.4685133099555969,
-0.10728493332862854,
-0.2283727377653122,
-0.651043176651001,
-0.09544709324836731,
0.5124847888946533,
0.22597894072532654,
0.6067854762077332,
-0.012073289602994919,
0.560014009475708,
-0.6166663765907288,
0.8321689367294312,
0.8568001985549927,
-0.8602580428123474,
0.2858645021915436,
-0.13485386967658997,
0.08264957368373871,
0.413383424282074,
0.35757601261138916,
-0.8712050914764404,
-0.4641467034816742,
-0.05153373256325722,
-0.7973874807357788,
0.6727361679077148,
0.04569970443844795,
0.387736976146698,
-0.06312607228755951,
-0.038457270711660385,
0.12556125223636627,
-0.17408387362957,
-0.8575966358184814,
-0.15455582737922668,
-0.1564439982175827,
-0.0791408121585846,
-0.07683965563774109,
0.00025696566444821656,
-0.009626946412026882,
-0.29590922594070435,
0.515211820602417,
-0.0720229297876358,
0.07805585116147995,
-0.004207967780530453,
-0.34815168380737305,
-0.1843750923871994,
0.12111162394285202,
0.3151376247406006,
0.45758652687072754,
0.4075971841812134,
0.23271775245666504,
0.21496939659118652,
-0.8977266550064087,
-0.11939352005720139,
0.014567358419299126,
-0.01679340749979019,
0.16044224798679352,
0.6781238317489624,
0.9064599871635437,
0.45371946692466736,
-0.692213773727417,
0.8486828804016113,
0.3472985327243805,
-0.1915425956249237,
-0.6597414016723633,
-0.09306185692548752,
0.07058532536029816,
0.3335665166378021,
0.5071012377738953,
-0.11412865668535233,
0.031011322513222694,
-0.3614996075630188,
0.3247862458229065,
0.3234510123729706,
-0.547213613986969,
-0.4077063202857971,
0.833802342414856,
-0.05107440799474716,
-0.23708891868591309,
0.5037094354629517,
-0.17458318173885345,
-0.6242009997367859,
0.44525980949401855,
0.5992302894592285,
0.5161387920379639,
-0.23734283447265625,
0.2690877318382263,
0.5958669185638428,
0.17478901147842407,
-0.3277851939201355,
0.29973074793815613,
-0.2982492446899414,
-0.5152589678764343,
-0.6222724318504333,
-0.6929067373275757,
-0.4775333106517792,
-0.31542322039604187,
-0.9141324162483215,
0.3910365104675293,
-0.2814648151397705,
0.048732489347457886,
0.09802528470754623,
-0.2581905126571655,
-0.5549331903457642,
0.2884306311607361,
0.3297542333602905,
0.6122862696647644,
-1.0966342687606812,
0.8512224555015564,
0.4149264097213745,
-0.632481038570404,
-0.8583517670631409,
-0.17220674455165863,
-0.0017224171897396445,
-0.8149969577789307,
0.8984817862510681,
0.09338899701833725,
-0.3036721646785736,
0.06137597933411598,
-0.21383702754974365,
-1.0077604055404663,
1.0379480123519897,
-0.028078174218535423,
-0.9532788395881653,
0.05184568092226982,
0.32328709959983826,
0.7773529887199402,
-0.000015072221685841214,
0.04517753794789314,
0.6397002339363098,
0.5253613591194153,
0.22237135469913483,
-1.1790989637374878,
0.11627039313316345,
0.19024021923542023,
-0.11801193654537201,
0.4066718816757202,
-0.5441626906394958,
0.5524305105209351,
-0.32946038246154785,
-0.3414227366447449,
0.1428513526916504,
0.8365645408630371,
0.12094506621360779,
0.197342649102211,
0.5879582166671753,
0.12459210306406021,
0.6324946284294128,
-0.1308315545320511,
0.8266575932502747,
-0.19870977103710175,
0.3198046386241913,
1.0052791833877563,
-0.3323148787021637,
1.054711937904358,
0.6336778402328491,
-0.4764861762523651,
0.3982298970222473,
0.10799766331911087,
-0.08712401986122131,
0.3209863603115082,
0.3105352818965912,
-0.2634586989879608,
-0.31818464398384094,
-0.13690349459648132,
-0.01987127959728241,
0.38695117831230164,
0.41453924775123596,
-0.5144093036651611,
-0.26541319489479065,
0.36576926708221436,
0.17150186002254486,
0.48005974292755127,
-0.30924341082572937,
0.515637218952179,
0.4087102711200714,
-0.48426273465156555,
0.36845457553863525,
-0.1812540888786316,
0.6440430283546448,
-0.7678267955780029,
-0.04384024441242218,
0.15734851360321045,
0.29464492201805115,
-0.2143993079662323,
-0.8346545696258545,
0.4266930818557739,
-0.018466368317604065,
-0.06744656711816788,
-0.540820837020874,
0.6814470291137695,
-0.6569110751152039,
-0.4683005213737488,
0.5073333978652954,
0.1605033427476883,
0.589189350605011,
0.21430784463882446,
-0.5937806367874146,
0.1627023071050644,
-0.2918998897075653,
-0.11582452058792114,
0.2822541892528534,
0.10191445052623749,
-0.35300782322883606,
0.3897113502025604,
0.6514315009117126,
0.028267625719308853,
0.07334502786397934,
0.5143804550170898,
0.6593109369277954,
-0.382295161485672,
-0.5197367668151855,
-0.4293069839477539,
0.5827652215957642,
-0.12512801587581635,
-0.5583727359771729,
0.7557520270347595,
0.7806901931762695,
0.6961712837219238,
-0.34440672397613525,
0.7946322560310364,
-0.3311980664730072,
0.7913355827331543,
-0.4518299698829651,
0.681215226650238,
-0.42243775725364685,
-0.23448996245861053,
-0.41599148511886597,
-0.6858795881271362,
-0.6967848539352417,
0.6128764152526855,
-0.1844395399093628,
-0.17894326150417328,
0.7034785747528076,
0.8187124133110046,
-0.17406557500362396,
-0.22016113996505737,
0.37382879853248596,
-0.015247221104800701,
0.07460803538560867,
0.7801968455314636,
0.6148225665092468,
-0.6414580941200256,
0.9296815395355225,
0.04104626551270485,
-0.06018924340605736,
0.04199304059147835,
-0.780371904373169,
-1.0077588558197021,
-0.8956741690635681,
-0.5687440037727356,
-0.42924854159355164,
-0.01229286752641201,
0.7035389542579651,
0.7549902200698853,
-0.9840343594551086,
-0.4302879571914673,
0.0798986628651619,
-0.2911778390407562,
-0.5614872574806213,
-0.2105283886194229,
0.5704851746559143,
-0.22332985699176788,
-0.7270892858505249,
0.6460132002830505,
0.06751258671283722,
-0.0340002216398716,
-0.30213284492492676,
-0.3691762387752533,
-0.01370814349502325,
-0.5148379802703857,
0.7124607563018799,
0.5501679182052612,
-0.7489954829216003,
-0.36604785919189453,
-0.2351008802652359,
-0.1761125922203064,
-0.1825466901063919,
0.85930997133255,
-0.37281110882759094,
0.29077231884002686,
0.2723698616027832,
0.42524755001068115,
0.8973107933998108,
-0.07765014469623566,
0.3989837169647217,
-1.0523310899734497,
0.06532158702611923,
0.1961691677570343,
0.315049409866333,
0.4005911946296692,
-0.421521931886673,
0.5135783553123474,
0.05119895562529564,
-0.029516205191612244,
-0.7533063292503357,
0.5024861693382263,
-1.2800617218017578,
-0.17042414844036102,
1.3703420162200928,
-0.17326126992702484,
0.16176073253154755,
-0.4872472584247589,
-0.26480814814567566,
0.39678651094436646,
-0.23054131865501404,
0.3023272752761841,
0.49810659885406494,
-0.0011971205240115523,
-0.355385422706604,
-0.4435166120529175,
0.44835755228996277,
0.2554601728916168,
-0.21537527441978455,
0.3931351900100708,
0.46909233927726746,
0.2794181704521179,
0.47708573937416077,
0.45648571848869324,
-0.38499903678894043,
0.41378694772720337,
-0.1326524168252945,
0.2747240960597992,
-0.2730305790901184,
-0.3141694962978363,
-0.3784072697162628,
0.1321432888507843,
0.15388615429401398,
-0.29308220744132996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10260v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10260v1
|
Keep It Private: Unsupervised Privatization of Online Text
| 2024-05-16T17:12:18 | 2024-05-16T17:12:18 |
Calvin Bao, Marine Carpuat
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Authorship obfuscation techniques hold the promise of helping people protect
their privacy in online communications by automatically rewriting text to hide
the identity of the original author. However, obfuscation has been evaluated in
narrow settings in the NLP literature and has primarily been addressed with
superficial edit operations that can lead to unnatural outputs. In this work,
we introduce an automatic text privatization framework that fine-tunes a large
language model via reinforcement learning to produce rewrites that balance
soundness, sense, and privacy. We evaluate it extensively on a large-scale test
set of English Reddit posts by 68k authors composed of short-medium length
texts. We study how the performance changes among evaluative conditions
including authorial profile length and authorship detection strategy. Our
method maintains high text quality according to both automated metrics and
human evaluation, and successfully evades several automated authorship attacks.
|
[
-0.2851465046405792,
-0.8479079604148865,
0.6427481770515442,
0.27770906686782837,
-0.15103968977928162,
0.13866505026817322,
-0.5721883773803711,
-0.4805034101009369,
0.26490017771720886,
1.110598087310791,
-0.22183826565742493,
-0.4812648296356201,
-0.6455866098403931,
0.32201477885246277,
-0.2957836091518402,
1.2363510131835938,
0.03943463787436485,
-0.5180624723434448,
-0.09737974405288696,
0.08618612587451935,
0.20314067602157593,
-0.20135287940502167,
-0.5309682488441467,
0.03933500126004219,
0.6000337600708008,
0.21733959019184113,
0.6836942434310913,
1.0819287300109863,
0.3506849706172943,
0.44481876492500305,
-0.08402930945158005,
0.20753933489322662,
-0.5894200205802917,
0.1841418445110321,
-0.3370726406574249,
-0.2177686244249344,
-0.11230781674385071,
0.03050118312239647,
0.8081445693969727,
0.43968695402145386,
-0.24445520341396332,
0.1288958638906479,
0.2708081603050232,
0.6353045701980591,
-1.0920405387878418,
0.16758042573928833,
-0.4420022666454315,
-0.02633189596235752,
0.10727372765541077,
-0.17931604385375977,
-0.6993241310119629,
-0.7515619993209839,
0.06902221590280533,
-0.6976595520973206,
-0.020988745614886284,
0.13749712705612183,
0.8031234741210938,
0.3196088969707489,
-0.16463615000247955,
-0.05861543491482735,
-0.846422553062439,
0.8266262412071228,
-0.4920141100883484,
0.17471878230571747,
0.7358352541923523,
0.06266499310731888,
0.018879607319831848,
-0.7923054695129395,
-0.24001023173332214,
-0.16713516414165497,
-0.46463102102279663,
-0.026495423167943954,
-0.41542676091194153,
0.33548295497894287,
-0.006334280129522085,
0.47928333282470703,
-0.25155335664749146,
0.15108151733875275,
-0.547122061252594,
-0.1002793163061142,
0.940335750579834,
-0.20904548466205597,
0.23689530789852142,
-0.11186590790748596,
-0.39222824573516846,
-0.006622975692152977,
-0.4501444697380066,
0.17490489780902863,
1.1443554162979126,
-0.10086369514465332,
0.35839834809303284,
0.6005412936210632,
-0.163207545876503,
0.3908435106277466,
0.21636241674423218,
0.12870702147483826,
0.020864006131887436,
-0.13275253772735596,
-0.324331670999527,
0.07892409712076187,
1.0357491970062256,
0.018245717510581017,
0.25561532378196716,
-0.29999709129333496,
-0.25983160734176636,
-0.32974258065223694,
0.5284577012062073,
-0.5824077129364014,
-0.3240320384502411,
0.3833272159099579,
-0.5592495799064636,
-0.6198024153709412,
0.31070420145988464,
-0.5703479051589966,
-0.6163032650947571,
-0.35508036613464355,
0.600060760974884,
-0.32169288396835327,
-0.2952597141265869,
0.4932812750339508,
-0.2981832027435303,
-0.33904510736465454,
0.089361771941185,
-0.9373513460159302,
0.6805387139320374,
0.8161962628364563,
0.48711472749710083,
-0.23262491822242737,
-0.4909626245498657,
-0.7675624489784241,
0.18632905185222626,
-0.33925846219062805,
0.342732310295105,
-0.4030819535255432,
-0.11597885191440582,
0.295646607875824,
0.11594492942094803,
0.07781609892845154,
-0.4087594151496887,
0.17319446802139282,
-0.572847843170166,
0.5771657228469849,
0.3053818643093109,
-0.5948607325553894,
-0.00027978670550510287,
0.010864551179111004,
-0.7204432487487793,
0.4234255850315094,
-0.15042103826999664,
-0.5784215331077576,
0.17377835512161255,
-0.8001937866210938,
-0.16865256428718567,
-0.10498251765966415,
0.17127558588981628,
-0.7991601824760437,
0.22407619655132294,
0.2543448209762573,
0.2759232223033905,
0.34187793731689453,
0.22213596105575562,
0.038898102939128876,
-0.2771610915660858,
0.4444931149482727,
-0.19144010543823242,
0.9714419841766357,
0.07502955198287964,
-0.30769068002700806,
0.3589096963405609,
-0.6764512658119202,
0.06526503711938858,
-0.20624777674674988,
-0.3084232807159424,
-0.48081180453300476,
-0.174555242061615,
-0.0629424974322319,
-0.2477140724658966,
0.386038213968277,
-0.7950692176818848,
0.16363459825515747,
-0.781438410282135,
0.5405798554420471,
0.9502725005149841,
0.4362511932849884,
0.8484423756599426,
-0.40131446719169617,
0.5288796424865723,
-0.4112692177295685,
0.6105024814605713,
-0.13212889432907104,
-0.5024911761283875,
-0.47460442781448364,
-0.6988418698310852,
0.6387873291969299,
0.25805315375328064,
-0.34374019503593445,
0.5427756905555725,
-0.07364493608474731,
-0.3347485065460205,
-0.8437474370002747,
0.2922302782535553,
0.6402699947357178,
-0.20107464492321014,
0.0770287737250328,
-0.10046172142028809,
-0.36592918634414673,
-1.0743613243103027,
-0.8091607093811035,
0.07361939549446106,
-0.11250828951597214,
0.019836770370602608,
0.339616984128952,
-0.1611839234828949,
0.9554223418235779,
-0.7746355533599854,
-0.7599884271621704,
-0.01362522505223751,
0.4726364016532898,
-0.23221389949321747,
0.6148380637168884,
0.003698622575029731,
-0.7132572531700134,
-0.5304061770439148,
-0.17205791175365448,
-0.43390148878097534,
-0.1609390527009964,
-0.14946869015693665,
-0.21242788434028625,
0.24121908843517303,
0.7592544555664062,
-0.3687470555305481,
0.5723378658294678,
0.4961183965206146,
-0.44214656949043274,
0.367887943983078,
-0.6242125034332275,
0.11366649717092514,
-0.7269131541252136,
-0.04592345282435417,
-0.1800546944141388,
-0.498048335313797,
-0.2252180576324463,
0.3102835714817047,
-0.09209828823804855,
-0.21144773066043854,
-0.4126676023006439,
0.41073471307754517,
-0.7205672264099121,
0.082209013402462,
-0.30715039372444153,
0.0679977685213089,
0.05424421280622482,
0.5609192848205566,
0.0021070153452455997,
0.2931571304798126,
0.11544467508792877,
-0.43495994806289673,
-0.08283837139606476,
0.26359620690345764,
-0.5853708386421204,
0.05752994120121002,
-0.5677456259727478,
0.20996254682540894,
-0.3246955871582031,
0.10048191994428635,
-0.999474287033081,
-0.1930379569530487,
0.2423710823059082,
-0.454848974943161,
0.10248468071222305,
-0.1606048345565796,
-0.7144445180892944,
0.37786170840263367,
-0.646202564239502,
0.11211860924959183,
0.5071292519569397,
-0.46155881881713867,
0.5397382378578186,
0.4479093551635742,
-0.20930153131484985,
-0.6288729906082153,
-0.6094175577163696,
0.11823903024196625,
-0.04434968903660774,
-0.3964760899543762,
0.5898834466934204,
0.06855783611536026,
-0.3118142783641815,
0.48071250319480896,
0.41362088918685913,
-0.5411985516548157,
0.34228551387786865,
0.3740915060043335,
-0.16393929719924927,
0.2413109838962555,
-0.03667754307389259,
0.32315102219581604,
-0.26494646072387695,
0.13269726932048798,
-0.26658499240875244,
0.09508883953094482,
0.10615231096744537,
-0.019656891003251076,
-0.7442641258239746,
0.5315232276916504,
0.27601853013038635,
-0.41819506883621216,
1.0549935102462769,
0.3686026334762573,
-0.2603953182697296,
-0.6238358616828918,
-0.27262598276138306,
-0.39335504174232483,
-0.4977669417858124,
0.06241743639111519,
0.18323957920074463,
-1.0867384672164917,
0.35238516330718994,
-0.04133641719818115,
0.4298982620239258,
0.23103220760822296,
0.21147212386131287,
0.10541120171546936,
0.6292300820350647,
1.035598874092102,
0.1386503279209137,
0.5291262865066528,
-0.1931518167257309,
0.4829108417034149,
-0.47828617691993713,
-0.06703735888004303,
-0.40891262888908386,
-0.31664735078811646,
-1.0621027946472168,
-0.2356603592634201,
0.21983638405799866,
-0.06621282547712326,
-0.242660254240036,
0.308584064245224,
-0.7806015610694885,
0.9033207297325134,
0.7870883345603943,
0.28354722261428833,
0.6036527156829834,
-0.0693625807762146,
0.29420846700668335,
-0.2515527904033661,
-0.26772305369377136,
-0.5070917010307312,
1.0590769052505493,
0.34318599104881287,
0.6249162554740906,
0.41840723156929016,
1.112201452255249,
0.6077127456665039,
0.24130366742610931,
-0.36010825634002686,
0.3378243148326874,
0.06534257531166077,
-0.6602189540863037,
-0.7613077163696289,
-0.22444570064544678,
-0.9600707292556763,
0.35794422030448914,
-0.17180286347866058,
-0.8289098739624023,
0.1544557362794876,
0.1975386142730713,
-0.4139516055583954,
0.3394426703453064,
-0.6442208290100098,
0.6866438388824463,
0.15055282413959503,
-0.6489356756210327,
-0.0731467604637146,
-0.4958079159259796,
0.4658871293067932,
-0.14089998602867126,
0.1774330735206604,
0.30033522844314575,
-0.35215166211128235,
0.6211320757865906,
-0.376950204372406,
0.9608756899833679,
0.07516729086637497,
0.006389159243553877,
-0.13653028011322021,
0.35414502024650574,
0.6066507697105408,
0.15471205115318298,
0.15191465616226196,
0.08527681231498718,
-0.22825057804584503,
-0.2558233141899109,
-0.5198482871055603,
0.8698700666427612,
-0.770840585231781,
-0.4643511176109314,
-0.3500995934009552,
0.0044814967550337315,
0.04939547926187515,
0.3390258848667145,
0.4721834659576416,
0.14347703754901886,
-0.2178872525691986,
0.6931633949279785,
0.8160833120346069,
-0.4215377867221832,
0.5149821043014526,
0.40545037388801575,
-0.2392694354057312,
-0.7006039023399353,
0.7301289439201355,
-0.043063972145318985,
0.06880761682987213,
0.48824796080589294,
0.570191502571106,
-0.5258461236953735,
-0.33713844418525696,
-0.30518487095832825,
0.3346181809902191,
-0.4061027467250824,
0.04215311259031296,
-0.9381919503211975,
-0.19696559011936188,
-0.4581015408039093,
-0.48722195625305176,
-0.5474424958229065,
-0.4143769145011902,
-0.1438586562871933,
-0.16972245275974274,
0.18872623145580292,
0.8319054245948792,
-0.2575913369655609,
0.2575724422931671,
-0.3699020743370056,
0.42130225896835327,
0.3616699278354645,
0.5509586334228516,
-0.1085779070854187,
-0.3830803334712982,
-0.22873593866825104,
-0.3804696798324585,
-0.31382909417152405,
-0.6672958731651306,
0.3840602934360504,
0.12928862869739532,
0.23983173072338104,
0.40431591868400574,
0.5857657194137573,
0.07366123050451279,
-0.5406581163406372,
0.7723159193992615,
0.030660955235362053,
-1.1141023635864258,
0.3060847520828247,
-0.48752522468566895,
-0.026712749153375626,
0.6793892979621887,
0.17970554530620575,
-0.276607871055603,
-0.9423052072525024,
-0.8197535276412964,
-1.0588500499725342,
0.6190788149833679,
0.6423613429069519,
0.24238701164722443,
0.3174888789653778,
0.13390956819057465,
0.22437575459480286,
0.6930007338523865,
-1.0985121726989746,
-0.24033720791339874,
0.014277666807174683,
-0.07364360988140106,
-0.11875294893980026,
-0.5425484776496887,
-0.2840326130390167,
-0.1665334701538086,
0.6282088160514832,
0.28142452239990234,
0.1734957993030548,
0.202416330575943,
-0.042090196162462234,
0.1309535801410675,
0.2938901484012604,
0.5678466558456421,
0.7039647698402405,
-0.032060153782367706,
-0.040550339967012405,
-0.6169322729110718,
-0.27039530873298645,
0.13144338130950928,
0.015250300988554955,
-0.4090719223022461,
0.022433027625083923,
0.3670080900192261,
0.5552634596824646,
0.4625234007835388,
-0.42890897393226624,
0.766111433506012,
-0.006996064446866512,
-0.5174119472503662,
-0.5638914704322815,
0.15076974034309387,
-0.015073881484568119,
0.05473244935274124,
-0.005942693445831537,
-0.11974713206291199,
0.3216112554073334,
-0.24118295311927795,
0.23962047696113586,
0.04843480885028839,
-0.3161478638648987,
-0.19879475235939026,
0.8294613361358643,
0.23399969935417175,
-0.5570254921913147,
0.3191056251525879,
-0.2015829235315323,
-0.2563534080982208,
0.2973848581314087,
0.15182049572467804,
1.20480477809906,
-0.30492985248565674,
0.5301898121833801,
0.14860045909881592,
0.623445451259613,
-0.19690480828285217,
-0.05365452915430069,
-0.336711049079895,
-0.32638195157051086,
-0.4293895661830902,
-0.42333483695983887,
-0.522527813911438,
0.2892739176750183,
-0.6151509881019592,
0.014518022537231445,
-0.8773375749588013,
0.12778788805007935,
0.1757991462945938,
0.04843772202730179,
-0.1103140190243721,
-0.05043124780058861,
-0.31158044934272766,
0.216746523976326,
-0.7448678016662598,
0.4353584349155426,
0.2877029776573181,
-0.18575328588485718,
-0.35926857590675354,
0.20590412616729736,
-0.0342685803771019,
-0.17640097439289093,
0.3904540240764618,
0.005782865919172764,
-0.22179023921489716,
0.1520034223794937,
-0.6116495132446289,
-0.4389756917953491,
0.4996231496334076,
0.46994006633758545,
-0.3628857731819153,
0.2939397990703583,
0.08246270567178726,
0.7077338695526123,
-0.0026237033307552338,
-0.21320974826812744,
0.021410701796412468,
0.5392966866493225,
-0.8321592807769775,
-0.6097082495689392,
-0.12264858186244965,
0.032827228307724,
-0.17721141874790192,
0.43017521500587463,
-0.5799846649169922,
0.7661274075508118,
0.058381661772727966,
-0.18212388455867767,
-0.015141602605581284,
0.44019651412963867,
-0.23131608963012695,
0.14107130467891693,
0.5073899626731873,
0.42373496294021606,
0.6730915307998657,
0.20676325261592865,
1.028111457824707,
-0.06941279023885727,
0.4492087662220001,
1.1154208183288574,
-0.02208166942000389,
0.7252210974693298,
0.37172067165374756,
0.27416184544563293,
0.5273014903068542,
0.12779656052589417,
0.09591279178857803,
0.8086774349212646,
0.5523025393486023,
-0.3361137807369232,
-0.10389730334281921,
-0.016220685094594955,
-0.007883898913860321,
0.5163429379463196,
-0.26806285977363586,
-0.7920351624488831,
0.055720921605825424,
0.20132814347743988,
0.3993017077445984,
0.8876410126686096,
0.031076524406671524,
0.9832484126091003,
-0.13313572108745575,
-0.8030800819396973,
0.04924006760120392,
0.4171276390552521,
0.5956982970237732,
-0.5760458111763,
0.05194544419646263,
-0.058192670345306396,
0.47400963306427,
-0.15426109731197357,
-0.5948693752288818,
0.45545291900634766,
-0.004419906530529261,
-0.3145619034767151,
-0.8214290142059326,
0.45621365308761597,
-0.5827897787094116,
-0.21081408858299255,
0.2526196539402008,
0.22072024643421173,
0.0259396955370903,
-0.3384319245815277,
-0.5145301818847656,
-0.03181919455528259,
0.029034143313765526,
-0.42040151357650757,
0.3686276376247406,
0.4107629060745239,
0.1423698514699936,
0.45508959889411926,
0.7655317783355713,
0.13500095903873444,
-0.16036014258861542,
-0.26890653371810913,
0.6131635308265686,
-0.49501150846481323,
-0.9835584759712219,
-0.9841419458389282,
0.3670835793018341,
-0.4471639394760132,
-0.5256063938140869,
0.9794731736183167,
0.7130240797996521,
0.894935667514801,
-0.22631461918354034,
0.6360073089599609,
0.33481258153915405,
0.5437057614326477,
-0.42975613474845886,
1.2602216005325317,
-0.5171356797218323,
0.12802287936210632,
-0.30366790294647217,
-0.6930338144302368,
-0.28077730536460876,
0.43413546681404114,
-0.22964361310005188,
-0.4148062467575073,
0.6613906621932983,
0.587382972240448,
0.027468204498291016,
-0.1496274769306183,
0.5193867087364197,
0.08080753684043884,
0.35458892583847046,
0.15111859142780304,
0.6473572254180908,
-0.39758917689323425,
0.420083612203598,
-0.5667997598648071,
-0.11620206385850906,
-0.26410001516342163,
-0.9998037219047546,
-0.9074658751487732,
-0.7614032030105591,
-0.6598281264305115,
-0.3918360769748688,
0.1236683577299118,
0.48486271500587463,
0.6548240184783936,
-0.3609350621700287,
-0.08901641517877579,
-0.0777333602309227,
0.3378051221370697,
-0.47991400957107544,
-0.2600029706954956,
0.43552398681640625,
0.039962287992239,
-0.8714026808738708,
0.1948419064283371,
0.4242100715637207,
-0.3582468032836914,
-0.5937439203262329,
0.17328961193561554,
-0.029210969805717468,
0.3609055280685425,
0.2666732668876648,
0.2005564421415329,
-0.6147448420524597,
-0.06242277845740318,
-0.21370753645896912,
-0.1782619059085846,
-0.21464748680591583,
1.005689263343811,
-0.44304633140563965,
0.7428507804870605,
0.4923540949821472,
0.7339884638786316,
0.2774040400981903,
0.3924392759799957,
0.5269341468811035,
-0.8479444980621338,
0.16574808955192566,
0.5042711496353149,
-0.07361502200365067,
0.168645977973938,
-0.7309901714324951,
0.21872664988040924,
-0.008817282505333424,
-0.7796199321746826,
-0.8781197667121887,
-0.009950488805770874,
-0.5940960645675659,
-0.6308174729347229,
1.0812640190124512,
-0.3281351923942566,
-0.4813198149204254,
-0.26069679856300354,
-0.19661210477352142,
-0.05444765463471413,
-0.5833131074905396,
1.1019591093063354,
0.5130473375320435,
0.3148256540298462,
-0.21503910422325134,
-0.43172165751457214,
0.9170693755149841,
0.004846752155572176,
-0.7239354252815247,
0.19666092097759247,
0.41249486804008484,
0.28279605507850647,
0.07223720103502274,
0.799896776676178,
-0.10942535102367401,
0.17410314083099365,
-0.21615098416805267,
-0.016583045944571495,
-0.473183810710907,
-0.4999074935913086,
-0.42652973532676697,
0.5578487515449524,
-0.23588359355926514,
-0.6537507176399231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10251v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10251v1
|
A Systematic Evaluation of Large Language Models for Natural Language Generation Tasks
| 2024-05-16T16:56:54 | 2024-05-16T16:56:54 |
Xuanfan Ni, Piji Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent efforts have evaluated large language models (LLMs) in areas such as
commonsense reasoning, mathematical reasoning, and code generation. However, to
the best of our knowledge, no work has specifically investigated the
performance of LLMs in natural language generation (NLG) tasks, a pivotal
criterion for determining model excellence. Thus, this paper conducts a
comprehensive evaluation of well-known and high-performing LLMs, namely
ChatGPT, ChatGLM, T5-based models, LLaMA-based models, and Pythia-based models,
in the context of NLG tasks. We select English and Chinese datasets
encompassing Dialogue Generation and Text Summarization. Moreover, we propose a
common evaluation setting that incorporates input templates and post-processing
strategies. Our study reports both automatic results, accompanied by a detailed
analysis.
|
[
-0.2578573226928711,
-0.835694432258606,
0.47306063771247864,
0.3690935969352722,
-0.24977195262908936,
0.05181916430592537,
-0.5171488523483276,
-0.23696522414684296,
-0.24029727280139923,
0.48522329330444336,
-0.46285852789878845,
-0.7635167837142944,
-0.4211850166320801,
0.5294004082679749,
-0.4825935959815979,
0.9237824082374573,
0.20381833612918854,
0.03059859573841095,
-0.1829686164855957,
0.3440404534339905,
-0.5469413995742798,
-0.35137230157852173,
-0.6618413925170898,
-0.6331433057785034,
0.3083619475364685,
0.10540560632944107,
0.7475017309188843,
0.36548206210136414,
0.6487430334091187,
0.25979185104370117,
-0.20843014121055603,
0.49696505069732666,
-0.5486629605293274,
0.2019803822040558,
-0.07366421073675156,
-0.12694697082042694,
-0.47573980689048767,
-0.21119195222854614,
0.7230411171913147,
0.6128674149513245,
-0.12149059027433395,
0.29294583201408386,
0.0025245908182114363,
0.3152729272842407,
-0.38725781440734863,
0.00007908982661319897,
-0.812702476978302,
0.09308163821697235,
-0.07206004112958908,
-0.11034570634365082,
-0.5586585998535156,
-0.7839285135269165,
0.3063637912273407,
-0.3135239779949188,
0.21854537725448608,
0.1084958165884018,
0.794941782951355,
0.02591170370578766,
-0.45306476950645447,
-0.6867882013320923,
-0.5736289024353027,
1.0361518859863281,
-1.2981940507888794,
-0.024401161819696426,
-0.0025204576086252928,
0.19484937191009521,
-0.5289382338523865,
-0.7501736283302307,
-0.529640793800354,
-0.6211907267570496,
0.005716162268072367,
0.24502071738243103,
-0.24762925505638123,
0.1540072113275528,
0.31468895077705383,
0.7471798062324524,
-0.698248565196991,
0.23837916553020477,
-0.25257426500320435,
0.017451835796236992,
0.8372200131416321,
0.25669607520103455,
0.40946075320243835,
-0.6339094042778015,
-0.15134337544441223,
0.13609236478805542,
-0.7305563688278198,
-0.3181118369102478,
0.3169040083885193,
0.2650739252567291,
-0.09285210072994232,
0.6558144688606262,
-0.177476704120636,
0.7951194643974304,
-0.19539234042167664,
-0.40012210607528687,
-0.09502951055765152,
-0.681278645992279,
-0.4088837802410126,
-0.194637730717659,
1.1382126808166504,
0.3963089883327484,
0.37811940908432007,
-0.28024518489837646,
-0.4418374001979828,
0.06117938086390495,
0.182463601231575,
-0.7434285283088684,
-0.1324830800294876,
0.08732254058122635,
-0.44317492842674255,
-0.5021731853485107,
-0.2195645123720169,
-0.49365851283073425,
-0.3194168508052826,
-0.33939293026924133,
0.2051316350698471,
-0.22459499537944794,
-0.28711003065109253,
0.10490092635154724,
-0.04539835825562477,
0.30529287457466125,
0.2507310211658478,
-0.6667492389678955,
0.1767902672290802,
0.7445029020309448,
0.7794281840324402,
-0.38166069984436035,
-0.07902494817972183,
-0.3510923981666565,
0.026005646213889122,
-0.5832971334457397,
0.7780059576034546,
-0.26782649755477905,
-0.2624719440937042,
0.23799185454845428,
-0.4106590747833252,
0.03309796378016472,
-0.7197302579879761,
0.7704808115959167,
-0.2847175598144531,
0.403439998626709,
-0.27671024203300476,
-0.6554881930351257,
-0.21683387458324432,
0.2869583070278168,
-0.6220024824142456,
1.0503653287887573,
-0.0987291932106018,
-0.7363085150718689,
0.45703792572021484,
-0.6002563238143921,
-0.6280555725097656,
0.2582779824733734,
-0.02887185662984848,
-0.25352057814598083,
0.22372384369373322,
0.3011828064918518,
0.6985202431678772,
-0.9152678847312927,
0.7870657444000244,
0.10494300723075867,
-0.16807617247104645,
0.15643450617790222,
-0.444080650806427,
0.5565891265869141,
0.14764107763767242,
-0.2901287078857422,
0.39054492115974426,
-0.6630021929740906,
0.03606129437685013,
0.2822173237800598,
-0.5436027646064758,
0.15747089684009552,
0.06774559617042542,
0.08939691632986069,
0.18361270427703857,
0.2570013999938965,
-0.3032393455505371,
0.13295143842697144,
-0.39322587847709656,
0.6309021711349487,
0.4585842192173004,
0.18922559916973114,
0.013067817315459251,
-0.40956541895866394,
0.3951680362224579,
-0.2650059163570404,
-0.2156773805618286,
-0.3676051199436188,
-0.48438453674316406,
-0.9654622077941895,
0.04221096634864807,
0.2609626352787018,
0.3941243588924408,
-0.6898730993270874,
0.5810600519180298,
-0.31216150522232056,
-0.8828176856040955,
-0.21390077471733093,
0.2939572036266327,
0.44565197825431824,
0.2602458894252777,
0.01265799906104803,
-0.2807362377643585,
-0.4283740222454071,
-1.0039066076278687,
-0.22587041556835175,
-0.14711891114711761,
-0.2013758271932602,
0.21607981622219086,
0.41022270917892456,
-0.03809664025902748,
0.7350139617919922,
-0.26133060455322266,
0.23474068939685822,
-0.7197073101997375,
0.4433758556842804,
0.3433121144771576,
0.11074009537696838,
0.38108325004577637,
-0.27348625659942627,
-0.18456339836120605,
-0.04277673363685608,
-0.8140016198158264,
-0.3076394200325012,
-0.311571329832077,
-0.1418074667453766,
0.2166239470243454,
0.2933691143989563,
-0.6348804235458374,
0.08316881954669952,
0.6567182540893555,
0.024468975141644478,
0.8195646405220032,
-0.02244015783071518,
0.11779215931892395,
-1.112051010131836,
0.18892307579517365,
0.18710894882678986,
-0.2565293610095978,
-0.8617167472839355,
0.08236734569072723,
-0.21407076716423035,
-0.12486596405506134,
-0.32852703332901,
0.495950847864151,
-0.420442670583725,
-0.33303144574165344,
-0.19913287460803986,
0.4886645972728729,
-0.18162280321121216,
0.391303151845932,
0.12128331512212753,
0.5775986313819885,
0.3492761552333832,
-0.7272769808769226,
0.6183416247367859,
0.08346095681190491,
-0.6196694374084473,
-0.002553708618506789,
-0.9442541599273682,
0.21780404448509216,
0.07556603848934174,
0.04553178325295448,
-0.9608157873153687,
-0.4190846383571625,
-0.13484255969524384,
-0.37448838353157043,
-0.03687875345349312,
0.13472004234790802,
-0.8533307909965515,
-0.42006805539131165,
-0.10151900351047516,
0.07771355658769608,
0.565838098526001,
-0.4853076934814453,
0.18848906457424164,
0.08223031461238861,
-0.30399763584136963,
-0.1564716249704361,
-0.35980862379074097,
0.3597700595855713,
-0.35103294253349304,
-0.8403810858726501,
0.006975115276873112,
0.144721120595932,
-0.41925668716430664,
-0.33765560388565063,
0.17291955649852753,
0.21449749171733856,
0.14327451586723328,
-0.10272499173879623,
0.21562770009040833,
-0.34313714504241943,
0.07537450641393661,
-0.1318061202764511,
0.15138854086399078,
0.163897305727005,
0.09009134024381638,
0.7346621751785278,
-0.07148705422878265,
-0.25077202916145325,
-0.00012669016723521054,
0.10935742408037186,
0.35843947529792786,
-0.4176517426967621,
0.43471986055374146,
0.41003185510635376,
-0.4045076072216034,
-0.4312540590763092,
-0.545634925365448,
0.022658562287688255,
-0.4029129147529602,
0.4737986922264099,
0.03603512793779373,
-0.6624043583869934,
0.23075193166732788,
-0.03538323566317558,
0.736650824546814,
0.5059501528739929,
0.9874568581581116,
0.25077927112579346,
0.9913228154182434,
0.18572889268398285,
0.13950341939926147,
0.2599259316921234,
0.09037278592586517,
0.5190391540527344,
-0.5821902751922607,
0.0674857646226883,
-0.37621286511421204,
0.07365917414426804,
-0.5130762457847595,
-0.42087316513061523,
0.337367445230484,
0.2586883306503296,
-0.07744857668876648,
0.2733565866947174,
-0.4114100933074951,
0.261637806892395,
0.393917441368103,
-0.33544841408729553,
0.4998249113559723,
0.055495355278253555,
0.026651544496417046,
0.15646663308143616,
-0.9194479584693909,
-1.162249207496643,
1.2273962497711182,
0.3111741840839386,
0.3983219861984253,
0.07668402045965195,
0.5048428773880005,
0.2209261953830719,
0.566627562046051,
-0.6754850149154663,
0.7246918678283691,
-0.2645646035671234,
-0.3835475444793701,
-0.33802807331085205,
-0.5488293766975403,
-0.9485594630241394,
0.1641465127468109,
-0.2725669741630554,
-0.5202572345733643,
-0.7643851041793823,
-0.12420724332332611,
-0.40746819972991943,
0.12028724700212479,
-0.5438405275344849,
0.6862186193466187,
-0.31651538610458374,
-0.2487468272447586,
-0.2791627049446106,
-0.17000868916511536,
0.9952675104141235,
-0.006525831762701273,
0.04563122242689133,
-0.2041541337966919,
0.32510384917259216,
0.798468828201294,
-0.015951184555888176,
0.4935058355331421,
0.11995375901460648,
-0.38034874200820923,
0.49727389216423035,
0.13801194727420807,
0.23568584024906158,
0.047174375504255295,
-0.1781354397535324,
0.13078205287456512,
-0.3458985984325409,
-0.07037816196680069,
-0.3654233515262604,
0.5658431649208069,
-0.42877164483070374,
-0.49463266134262085,
-0.1351875513792038,
-0.5728009939193726,
-0.23949044942855835,
0.17030510306358337,
0.32866963744163513,
0.5102957487106323,
-0.43319034576416016,
0.14230626821517944,
0.4209890365600586,
-0.7276906371116638,
0.5773352384567261,
0.13416056334972382,
-0.4236603081226349,
-0.47266092896461487,
0.8020844459533691,
-0.0516296923160553,
0.5655471086502075,
0.09506405144929886,
0.16094642877578735,
-0.17573781311511993,
-0.6719216704368591,
-0.5868620872497559,
0.3524074852466583,
-0.5810695290565491,
-0.12394095212221146,
-0.3369358479976654,
-0.5093442797660828,
-0.4324344992637634,
-0.06862736493349075,
-0.19170260429382324,
-0.19319875538349152,
-0.01432083174586296,
-0.006152342073619366,
-0.011362552642822266,
1.151179552078247,
0.28674519062042236,
0.3687879145145416,
-0.8243368268013,
0.42930957674980164,
0.2151368409395218,
0.09842021018266678,
0.2843932807445526,
-0.2090597152709961,
-0.15212486684322357,
-0.042543426156044006,
-0.6238905787467957,
-0.6907966136932373,
0.45664486289024353,
0.08675394207239151,
0.5932959318161011,
0.3061017096042633,
-0.20246991515159607,
0.40918710827827454,
-0.39938196539878845,
1.1943094730377197,
0.27960148453712463,
-0.9454318284988403,
0.5713725686073303,
-0.6979658007621765,
0.46000611782073975,
0.1023474633693695,
0.06171659380197525,
-0.6774290204048157,
-0.5222232937812805,
-0.5342292189598083,
-0.9730257391929626,
0.4632839858531952,
0.5718614459037781,
0.10371694713830948,
-0.2030901461839676,
0.04883018881082535,
0.1527346521615982,
0.31779977679252625,
-0.90362149477005,
0.013731737621128559,
0.10775186866521835,
-0.1240098848938942,
0.06271722912788391,
-0.1472446471452713,
0.040043123066425323,
0.2516486942768097,
0.6596516966819763,
-0.05326239392161369,
0.008500978350639343,
0.07760658860206604,
-0.1786232590675354,
0.10219521820545197,
0.39883002638816833,
0.6303879618644714,
0.7806826829910278,
0.07634957134723663,
-0.22246192395687103,
0.2863362729549408,
-0.09619290381669998,
-0.11681776493787766,
-0.2657433748245239,
-0.23030826449394226,
0.2063898742198944,
0.8005068302154541,
0.7836073637008667,
0.26314061880111694,
-0.889580488204956,
0.2905559539794922,
-0.1423262059688568,
-0.31851470470428467,
-0.17608077824115753,
0.22657714784145355,
0.2420411854982376,
-0.09842896461486816,
0.33211469650268555,
-0.386728435754776,
0.14883272349834442,
-0.5096718072891235,
-0.04632739722728729,
0.39465805888175964,
0.20664255321025848,
-0.1431407630443573,
0.3167310059070587,
0.4122459590435028,
-0.22325913608074188,
0.6744865775108337,
-0.3992688059806824,
-0.5431705117225647,
0.690302848815918,
0.5365151166915894,
0.9279371500015259,
-0.004336288198828697,
0.08240723609924316,
0.7620890736579895,
0.40601852536201477,
-0.17535169422626495,
0.11443256586790085,
-0.0008120699785649776,
-0.5965964198112488,
-0.7416444420814514,
-0.8310034871101379,
-0.44538891315460205,
0.33431246876716614,
-0.4082571864128113,
0.3150636553764343,
-0.41318461298942566,
-0.16927403211593628,
-0.11235542595386505,
0.06181745603680611,
-0.5947397351264954,
0.22924020886421204,
0.43503299355506897,
0.6930635571479797,
-0.6127244830131531,
0.29148104786872864,
0.5967118740081787,
-0.04600757732987404,
-0.8264102339744568,
0.0667252391576767,
-0.2920486032962799,
-0.49368786811828613,
0.5542181730270386,
0.14497356116771698,
0.007696713320910931,
-0.1771678626537323,
-0.3469252586364746,
-0.7054014205932617,
0.9954292178153992,
0.30981898307800293,
-0.6934136748313904,
-0.2940770387649536,
0.41244128346443176,
0.671909511089325,
-0.2772473096847534,
0.5376864075660706,
0.8706470727920532,
0.42660531401634216,
0.1270155906677246,
-1.2631782293319702,
-0.062476977705955505,
-0.1629188358783722,
0.20843805372714996,
-0.004040487576276064,
-0.7025823593139648,
0.5962888598442078,
-0.0684666633605957,
-0.4786130487918854,
0.2786695659160614,
0.6800740361213684,
0.7401699423789978,
-0.02355067990720272,
0.30170291662216187,
0.3182559311389923,
0.7536917924880981,
-0.33831214904785156,
1.0666556358337402,
-0.3605297803878784,
0.13425016403198242,
0.9512941241264343,
-0.30255162715911865,
0.6615833640098572,
0.02044733241200447,
-0.0848507359623909,
0.171390101313591,
0.5384451746940613,
-0.1237107664346695,
0.11134231835603714,
0.6954683065414429,
-0.1619289070367813,
-0.3605663478374481,
-0.2807407081127167,
-0.13369230926036835,
0.5065116882324219,
0.1782304048538208,
-0.44848161935806274,
-0.3989451229572296,
-0.3918541669845581,
0.07113007456064224,
-0.017656324431300163,
-0.4185238182544708,
1.013014316558838,
0.14816612005233765,
-1.1871017217636108,
0.6233072280883789,
0.3096597492694855,
0.6826413869857788,
-0.44042736291885376,
-0.03768293187022209,
-0.2537461221218109,
-0.14353901147842407,
-0.2669190466403961,
-0.7758613228797913,
0.19999605417251587,
0.5675026178359985,
0.11982539296150208,
-0.09590943902730942,
0.7271295785903931,
-0.3466089069843292,
-0.6469653248786926,
0.07878552377223969,
0.47002702951431274,
0.23747394979000092,
0.22097280621528625,
-0.3605596721172333,
-0.08277885615825653,
0.07339857518672943,
-0.5340011715888977,
0.037930428981781006,
0.4633908271789551,
-0.07805745303630829,
0.6486871242523193,
0.7011072635650635,
0.2044585645198822,
0.2546917796134949,
0.32465773820877075,
0.5585830211639404,
-0.6854118704795837,
-0.16526424884796143,
-0.8759136199951172,
0.44453343749046326,
-0.09531056880950928,
-0.5520452260971069,
0.9234094023704529,
0.6071454882621765,
0.5538724660873413,
0.08596070855855942,
1.0793684720993042,
0.017550017684698105,
0.3724556565284729,
-0.6954209208488464,
0.5657030344009399,
-0.14191271364688873,
0.23436130583286285,
-0.5075004696846008,
-1.2014511823654175,
-0.19568100571632385,
0.5225359201431274,
-0.3602157235145569,
0.04341096803545952,
0.5326024293899536,
0.6218915581703186,
0.19615289568901062,
0.1590169370174408,
0.37205880880355835,
0.1512187421321869,
0.6593518853187561,
0.8006846308708191,
1.1168802976608276,
-0.36808475852012634,
0.42100220918655396,
0.04075801745057106,
0.04259185120463371,
0.07179004698991776,
-1.0959066152572632,
-1.268085241317749,
-0.18287979066371918,
-0.1953824758529663,
-0.026861388236284256,
-0.17130255699157715,
0.8743301033973694,
0.5115538239479065,
-0.5429330468177795,
-0.43267449736595154,
-0.22214291989803314,
-0.0545429103076458,
0.19666582345962524,
-0.22625857591629028,
0.27314507961273193,
-0.43407851457595825,
-0.8529186844825745,
0.45053207874298096,
0.2491724044084549,
-0.24233904480934143,
-0.5339142084121704,
-0.07586701959371567,
0.06075199320912361,
0.29232579469680786,
0.7059167623519897,
-0.22011488676071167,
-0.9225497245788574,
0.0026549554895609617,
-0.07743001729249954,
-0.26985764503479004,
-0.11107896268367767,
0.7611138820648193,
-0.5192445516586304,
0.07625634223222733,
0.5688537955284119,
0.4579470157623291,
0.13400469720363617,
0.08908331394195557,
0.9865384101867676,
-0.5725576877593994,
-0.2985503375530243,
0.2999512851238251,
0.3550567328929901,
0.6129952073097229,
0.05779361352324486,
0.4937693178653717,
-0.18707521259784698,
-0.7284391522407532,
-0.9278531670570374,
0.10507400333881378,
-0.6409949660301208,
-0.004045027308166027,
1.4266767501831055,
-0.13952778279781342,
0.03359498828649521,
0.1463123857975006,
-0.32983583211898804,
0.47022563219070435,
-0.3045383393764496,
0.6931942105293274,
1.0558794736862183,
0.04178845137357712,
-0.023831557482481003,
-0.7551372647285461,
0.5092375874519348,
0.4677918255329132,
-1.1100995540618896,
0.3421190679073334,
0.6472918391227722,
0.06855545192956924,
0.11421255022287369,
0.2823108732700348,
-0.040234584361314774,
0.33264267444610596,
-0.1177268847823143,
0.1492234766483307,
0.06434658169746399,
-0.08719184994697571,
-0.2332639992237091,
0.15259695053100586,
0.36726558208465576,
0.4842863380908966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10213v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10213v1
|
Words as Trigger Points in Social Media Discussions
| 2024-05-16T16:02:42 | 2024-05-16T16:02:42 |
Dimosthenis Antypas, Christian Arnold, Jose Camacho-Collados, Nedjma Ousidhoum, Carla Perez Almendros
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Trigger points are a concept introduced by Mau, Lux, and Westheuser (2023) to
study qualitative focus group interviews and understand polarisation in
Germany. When people communicate, trigger points represent moments when
individuals feel that their understanding of what is fair, normal, or
appropriate in society is questioned. In the original studies, individuals
react affectively to such triggers and show strong and negative emotional
responses. In this paper, we introduce the first systematic study of the
large-scale effect of individual words as trigger points by analysing a large
amount of social media posts. We examine online deliberations on Reddit between
2020 and 2022 and collect >100 million posts from subreddits related to a set
of words identified as trigger points in UK politics. We find that such trigger
words affect user engagement and have noticeable consequences on animosity in
online discussions. We share empirical evidence of trigger words causing
animosity, and how they provide incentives for hate speech, adversarial
debates, and disagreements. Our work is the first to introduce trigger points
to computational studies of online communication. Our findings are relevant to
researchers interested in online harms and who examine how citizens debate
politics and society in light of affective polarisation.
|
[
-0.937544584274292,
-0.9829620122909546,
0.41934409737586975,
0.19563885033130646,
-0.5305531024932861,
-0.24980193376541138,
-0.2343369871377945,
-0.39597880840301514,
0.5316692590713501,
0.08498172461986542,
-0.6081175804138184,
-0.35641345381736755,
-0.9790604114532471,
0.20696118474006653,
-0.7791987061500549,
0.621989369392395,
0.21424829959869385,
-0.16058704257011414,
0.32295382022857666,
-0.5086315870285034,
-0.17100901901721954,
-0.6873689889907837,
-0.4068376421928406,
-0.05681181326508522,
1.267989158630371,
0.047035932540893555,
0.38312777876853943,
0.2973892390727997,
0.6330823302268982,
0.24315133690834045,
-0.33976563811302185,
-0.4753088355064392,
-0.9091969728469849,
0.17154252529144287,
-0.3068290948867798,
-0.5118257403373718,
0.18714158236980438,
0.042240019887685776,
0.3340963125228882,
0.271710604429245,
0.07556433230638504,
0.27048811316490173,
0.14171576499938965,
0.7134871482849121,
-0.7641950845718384,
-0.22183571755886078,
-0.7195916175842285,
0.16560837626457214,
-0.2944414019584656,
-0.5634037256240845,
0.00666129682213068,
-0.6165209412574768,
-0.15810970962047577,
-0.23708505928516388,
0.12544623017311096,
-0.5457227826118469,
0.8305431008338928,
0.02331453748047352,
-0.696047306060791,
-0.6009054183959961,
-0.4605979323387146,
0.5708462595939636,
-0.4671812355518341,
0.08865347504615784,
0.006042880937457085,
0.039535678923130035,
-0.06196359172463417,
-0.2337884157896042,
-0.8239530324935913,
0.4880177676677704,
-0.07262030988931656,
-0.018739623948931694,
-0.4009127616882324,
-0.061606794595718384,
0.46677276492118835,
-0.08937615901231766,
-0.04260430112481117,
-0.1969590187072754,
-0.4161979556083679,
0.04208602011203766,
0.7799698710441589,
0.07788795232772827,
0.1352384388446808,
-0.2354070395231247,
-0.20652298629283905,
0.20460079610347748,
-0.6797327995300293,
0.1355523020029068,
0.5840016603469849,
0.5310361385345459,
-0.10084567964076996,
0.4645662009716034,
0.13663849234580994,
0.6234575510025024,
0.4747765362262726,
0.25685223937034607,
-0.3468514680862427,
-0.17217420041561127,
0.30235573649406433,
0.10960235446691513,
0.9286106824874878,
0.7513412237167358,
0.5991673469543457,
0.5433492660522461,
0.3173590302467346,
0.5991963148117065,
0.35979729890823364,
-0.7233572602272034,
-0.064146988093853,
0.16983959078788757,
-0.39962607622146606,
-0.2550751268863678,
0.1094096228480339,
-0.6800957322120667,
-1.0529526472091675,
0.007643151096999645,
0.1749514788389206,
0.05321316421031952,
-0.45189812779426575,
-0.15214157104492188,
-0.2195882648229599,
0.2881636619567871,
0.3502151072025299,
-0.6071348786354065,
-0.02960294485092163,
0.7150654196739197,
0.7712311744689941,
-0.04293293133378029,
-0.1550525724887848,
-0.18212895095348358,
-0.0932115837931633,
-0.3623603880405426,
1.1024881601333618,
-0.5743021368980408,
-0.5613718032836914,
0.6277803778648376,
-0.022887594997882843,
0.2976861298084259,
-0.3811340034008026,
0.4569685757160187,
-0.5813454389572144,
0.3783715069293976,
-0.7860755324363708,
-0.623127818107605,
-0.35846421122550964,
0.27634894847869873,
-0.32070931792259216,
0.6541666984558105,
-0.5025871992111206,
-0.8629065155982971,
0.7262880802154541,
-0.817496657371521,
-0.673232913017273,
0.16651427745819092,
-0.26835647225379944,
0.07581693679094315,
0.2222656011581421,
-0.20240724086761475,
0.37409189343452454,
-0.13665857911109924,
0.0295936930924654,
-0.43883419036865234,
-0.09039649367332458,
0.5033686757087708,
0.1917453110218048,
0.5577554702758789,
-0.17804494500160217,
-0.6346690058708191,
0.32789334654808044,
-0.3023596405982971,
-0.3074008524417877,
-0.07787477970123291,
-0.294931560754776,
-0.44897451996803284,
0.18952026963233948,
-0.1320149451494217,
0.6910203695297241,
-0.16302257776260376,
-0.5306808948516846,
-0.17850828170776367,
0.08727537095546722,
0.6978738903999329,
0.6912803649902344,
0.4097422957420349,
0.04438738524913788,
-0.28840968012809753,
0.31266671419143677,
0.22875480353832245,
0.20575913786888123,
0.18373943865299225,
-0.8573683500289917,
-0.38385769724845886,
0.12945708632469177,
-0.07990206778049469,
0.35669389367103577,
-0.1486477106809616,
0.3923771381378174,
0.19367344677448273,
-0.47178953886032104,
-0.3141942024230957,
-0.012891733087599277,
0.030053984373807907,
0.15808722376823425,
0.03134016692638397,
-0.07588235288858414,
-0.35764676332473755,
-0.7195663452148438,
-0.662652313709259,
-0.4339591860771179,
-0.048080988228321075,
0.4107913374900818,
0.2167253941297531,
0.11737089604139328,
0.9324950575828552,
-0.3865451216697693,
-0.36401814222335815,
-0.014860192313790321,
0.7689890265464783,
-0.1274891346693039,
-0.34081968665122986,
0.29338642954826355,
-1.1403847932815552,
-0.6880953311920166,
-0.5149839520454407,
-0.6999754905700684,
-0.2521544396877289,
-0.05261577293276787,
-0.2920365035533905,
0.002917367033660412,
0.3410002589225769,
-0.3716253340244293,
0.22800318896770477,
0.6568199396133423,
-0.5486485958099365,
-0.06654109060764313,
0.44646623730659485,
0.9622136950492859,
-0.959415078163147,
0.041634250432252884,
0.19164086878299713,
0.2806609570980072,
-0.7407054901123047,
-0.364338219165802,
0.0748828798532486,
-0.0740794986486435,
-1.07965886592865,
0.5087676048278809,
-0.09685403108596802,
0.22782151401042938,
-0.41448578238487244,
0.27135396003723145,
-0.1914137899875641,
-0.16065619885921478,
-0.1056160032749176,
0.42590269446372986,
0.18650740385055542,
-0.4911658465862274,
0.2074878066778183,
0.34507593512535095,
-0.22649474442005157,
0.8360801935195923,
-0.25823312997817993,
0.219032421708107,
-0.1975255161523819,
-0.17410516738891602,
-1.052451252937317,
-0.37536177039146423,
0.011835016310214996,
-0.5234538316726685,
-0.259170264005661,
0.0733722448348999,
-0.09294743090867996,
-0.5298881530761719,
-0.41657447814941406,
0.28280144929885864,
0.11446692794561386,
-0.231109157204628,
0.25006166100502014,
1.0548391342163086,
-0.1642938107252121,
-0.19569317996501923,
-0.4137282073497772,
0.21723249554634094,
-0.527969479560852,
-0.6537067294120789,
0.023345939815044403,
0.2672915756702423,
-0.714381992816925,
0.1373687982559204,
0.41651204228401184,
0.12576192617416382,
-0.12469059973955154,
0.5182723999023438,
-0.37951093912124634,
0.24457073211669922,
0.5505254864692688,
-0.18474534153938293,
-0.08501722663640976,
0.18118594586849213,
0.3059322237968445,
0.6265954971313477,
-0.01860899291932583,
-0.0308501198887825,
-0.22920134663581848,
0.8004686832427979,
0.527997612953186,
0.09468255192041397,
0.7475245594978333,
0.2463371306657791,
-0.45652323961257935,
0.07917395979166031,
-0.7386483550071716,
-0.6491245627403259,
-0.45431146025657654,
0.10719502717256546,
0.03024899773299694,
-1.2401738166809082,
0.7915991544723511,
-0.13133946061134338,
0.02188747003674507,
0.5919314622879028,
0.7189470529556274,
-0.23000302910804749,
1.0407363176345825,
0.7547429800033569,
0.004664373584091663,
0.7110431790351868,
0.32041603326797485,
0.45979636907577515,
-0.1575520932674408,
0.06402038037776947,
-0.48726940155029297,
-0.6654650568962097,
-0.3939272165298462,
-0.35876280069351196,
0.32732293009757996,
0.10992886871099472,
-0.07292458415031433,
0.248308926820755,
-0.5206766128540039,
0.23376242816448212,
0.30730265378952026,
-0.2797752022743225,
-0.02194368466734886,
-0.2160428762435913,
0.34039995074272156,
-0.2436673790216446,
-0.5819042921066284,
-0.3913845419883728,
0.4045386016368866,
0.035330306738615036,
0.5783320069313049,
0.023435112088918686,
0.47655951976776123,
0.6674584746360779,
0.4838818609714508,
-0.789905846118927,
0.6640608906745911,
0.16273680329322815,
-1.065252661705017,
-0.3582046329975128,
-0.07392314076423645,
-0.864878237247467,
-0.19614240527153015,
-0.6788207292556763,
-0.7163898348808289,
0.5101600289344788,
0.2566164433956146,
-0.22833310067653656,
0.4209248125553131,
-0.33784323930740356,
0.7039651870727539,
-0.20481640100479126,
-0.5294809341430664,
-0.4213772118091583,
-0.6106808185577393,
0.3337991535663605,
-0.06261385977268219,
0.39600175619125366,
-0.4493361711502075,
0.16750101745128632,
1.0227640867233276,
-0.02246221899986267,
0.8336792588233948,
-0.27515295147895813,
-0.21849551796913147,
0.5377917289733887,
-0.17235536873340607,
0.400666743516922,
-0.4718298017978668,
-0.1665649116039276,
0.6636701226234436,
-0.10884659737348557,
-0.16714908182621002,
-0.29229867458343506,
0.6994753479957581,
-0.4329386055469513,
-0.3447997570037842,
-0.15548156201839447,
-0.23218587040901184,
0.24615417420864105,
-0.021851638332009315,
0.48545098304748535,
0.16914045810699463,
-0.08789660036563873,
0.025356996804475784,
0.21416573226451874,
-0.11911928653717041,
0.3582817018032074,
0.6316959857940674,
0.06711810827255249,
-0.25373491644859314,
0.6766708493232727,
0.4138655662536621,
0.19832859933376312,
-0.061620332300662994,
0.4076218605041504,
-0.35045111179351807,
-0.05353666841983795,
-0.15399551391601562,
0.3315967917442322,
-0.6850703358650208,
-0.24118201434612274,
-0.5073351263999939,
0.1936124563217163,
-0.3114679455757141,
-0.7770334482192993,
-0.32255756855010986,
-0.1710222214460373,
-0.15039825439453125,
-0.005362386349588633,
0.5194613337516785,
1.024835467338562,
-0.39731141924858093,
0.29053083062171936,
-0.7562242150306702,
0.16007103025913239,
0.37491944432258606,
0.31595417857170105,
-0.41782432794570923,
-0.1664668619632721,
-0.257549911737442,
-0.30729761719703674,
-0.28695452213287354,
-1.5756258964538574,
0.23387372493743896,
0.06486528366804123,
0.1535269170999527,
0.8983928561210632,
0.29801326990127563,
0.44217807054519653,
-0.2582666277885437,
0.9810561537742615,
0.363040030002594,
-0.6744484901428223,
0.7034346461296082,
-0.6171212792396545,
0.29751381278038025,
0.514773428440094,
0.9617520570755005,
-1.0420641899108887,
-0.6640284657478333,
-0.596580445766449,
-0.8248947262763977,
0.191706582903862,
-0.379539430141449,
0.2781312167644501,
-0.4556955397129059,
0.2687893807888031,
0.10711611062288284,
0.36922135949134827,
-0.46851786971092224,
-0.4383389949798584,
0.21764566004276276,
0.13806486129760742,
0.03295154124498367,
-0.7313461899757385,
-0.670555055141449,
-0.038883890956640244,
0.4799950420856476,
0.07388848066329956,
0.24305027723312378,
-0.1956801414489746,
0.0674554780125618,
-0.8067836761474609,
0.4158380627632141,
0.48431265354156494,
0.6650631427764893,
-0.08732450753450394,
0.30700650811195374,
0.061685554683208466,
-0.2589796483516693,
0.258620023727417,
-0.21852414309978485,
-0.41806334257125854,
-0.1333281695842743,
0.13510000705718994,
0.3515646159648895,
0.3474375605583191,
-0.23705898225307465,
0.5284459590911865,
-0.12158678472042084,
-0.47395211458206177,
0.03451474383473396,
-0.33632710576057434,
0.2526579201221466,
0.33458587527275085,
0.4362841844558716,
-0.4787684679031372,
0.03532904013991356,
-0.8457606434822083,
0.37975752353668213,
0.45755764842033386,
-0.6590920090675354,
-0.39881619811058044,
0.33961859345436096,
0.5111950039863586,
-0.6089086532592773,
-0.007894325070083141,
-0.3227614760398865,
-0.747442901134491,
0.012746408581733704,
0.25987735390663147,
0.7359057068824768,
-0.3021407127380371,
0.329900324344635,
0.4944310784339905,
0.15820440649986267,
0.3236503005027771,
0.42854973673820496,
0.10467154532670975,
-0.8583924174308777,
-0.048483386635780334,
-0.6352654099464417,
-0.4817558526992798,
0.03652103617787361,
-0.46424463391304016,
0.5320766568183899,
-0.4667131006717682,
-0.6859133243560791,
0.1007881835103035,
0.06496315449476242,
-0.2963746190071106,
-0.0752309113740921,
0.39435040950775146,
0.545123815536499,
-1.2625213861465454,
0.09131493419408798,
0.7036384344100952,
0.07585053145885468,
-0.4787783920764923,
0.04963376745581627,
0.6589905619621277,
-0.32638439536094666,
0.44325071573257446,
0.29939183592796326,
-0.1569262444972992,
-0.00422411086037755,
-0.46442776918411255,
-0.619917631149292,
0.38716474175453186,
0.11292053014039993,
-0.3600319027900696,
0.2782265245914459,
0.5061219930648804,
0.4102780520915985,
-0.19617889821529388,
0.18700292706489563,
0.42372962832450867,
0.5907783508300781,
0.2595363259315491,
-0.4122074544429779,
0.3506613075733185,
-0.4073316752910614,
-0.566350519657135,
0.6482882499694824,
-0.45917728543281555,
0.8501421809196472,
-0.026970375329256058,
-0.755213737487793,
-0.7434924244880676,
0.1410641074180603,
-0.3239908516407013,
0.005959397181868553,
0.6478700637817383,
0.21178634464740753,
0.3741724193096161,
-0.2054911106824875,
0.7075971364974976,
-0.7248133420944214,
0.2798188030719757,
0.568695068359375,
-0.27273088693618774,
1.0622694492340088,
0.48823171854019165,
-0.1010364294052124,
0.4832187592983246,
0.3632904589176178,
0.21376515924930573,
0.24902614951133728,
0.28579214215278625,
-0.6513338088989258,
-0.3383265435695648,
-0.37599262595176697,
-0.29451149702072144,
0.38973599672317505,
0.6406378746032715,
-0.1858038604259491,
-0.41972705721855164,
0.09903304278850555,
-0.0015461217844858766,
0.2551039755344391,
-0.25229617953300476,
1.1070365905761719,
0.17505641281604767,
-0.42693713307380676,
0.25255078077316284,
-0.18769319355487823,
0.7485052347183228,
-0.5234124064445496,
0.25106704235076904,
-0.09621183574199677,
0.07841304689645767,
-0.2618091404438019,
-1.0683953762054443,
0.5451288819313049,
0.1756565421819687,
0.04394776001572609,
-0.20846927165985107,
0.99677574634552,
-0.3677966892719269,
-0.26300758123397827,
0.7593314051628113,
0.3750329315662384,
0.1750469207763672,
-0.3462379276752472,
-0.7465757131576538,
0.2227603644132614,
-0.4678102135658264,
-0.42515119910240173,
0.43141621351242065,
0.5113345384597778,
0.16917544603347778,
0.12860991060733795,
0.6306983828544617,
0.07582678645849228,
0.205183207988739,
-0.05021194741129875,
0.9857720732688904,
-0.8945215344429016,
-0.390575110912323,
-0.6944124102592468,
0.7750409245491028,
-0.2651633024215698,
-0.5610576272010803,
0.7662026882171631,
0.1767096072435379,
0.6952970027923584,
0.38812828063964844,
0.7250422835350037,
-0.4568793475627899,
0.7027884125709534,
0.12727515399456024,
0.8836982250213623,
-0.44508597254753113,
-0.2984730005264282,
-0.336660236120224,
-0.6329568028450012,
-0.4881114959716797,
0.6415113806724548,
-0.7252727746963501,
-0.2710501551628113,
0.39799994230270386,
0.9384806752204895,
0.4029470682144165,
0.20997010171413422,
0.5513970255851746,
0.44547542929649353,
0.26947247982025146,
0.2977502942085266,
1.1181598901748657,
0.09464936703443527,
0.29083120822906494,
-0.445358544588089,
-0.2656051516532898,
-0.5000420808792114,
-0.8405187726020813,
-0.9571699500083923,
-0.7416011095046997,
-0.4598529040813446,
-0.4323822557926178,
0.16305482387542725,
0.7999203205108643,
0.08995344489812851,
-0.8526703119277954,
-0.3073129653930664,
0.033625952899456024,
0.3321702480316162,
0.18319976329803467,
-0.23974324762821198,
0.07186439633369446,
-0.14485661685466766,
-0.3138190507888794,
-0.046808965504169464,
0.5361272096633911,
-0.3164697289466858,
-0.16429337859153748,
0.20781059563159943,
-0.686528205871582,
0.2753928303718567,
0.806633472442627,
0.7097427248954773,
-0.5145670771598816,
-0.688917338848114,
-0.12005201727151871,
-0.01792163774371147,
0.021871857345104218,
0.9184096455574036,
-0.31497085094451904,
0.32175004482269287,
0.7024641036987305,
-0.08689849823713303,
0.15146636962890625,
0.38142815232276917,
0.5000309348106384,
-0.30017951130867004,
0.21575644612312317,
0.2419826090335846,
-0.010980487801134586,
0.40781375765800476,
-0.14685137569904327,
0.10088283568620682,
0.3373247981071472,
-0.4704147279262543,
-0.6165603399276733,
0.34741175174713135,
-0.5649238228797913,
-0.09556978195905685,
1.3332312107086182,
-0.038097772747278214,
0.04639454931020737,
-0.030245253816246986,
-0.09108786284923553,
0.49480217695236206,
-0.3911817669868469,
1.3421598672866821,
0.8519087433815002,
0.0003162112843710929,
-0.22712945938110352,
-0.250010222196579,
0.6835775971412659,
0.13791610300540924,
-0.850226640701294,
0.2716032564640045,
0.46376436948776245,
-0.32330355048179626,
0.378593772649765,
0.46325182914733887,
-0.023903656750917435,
0.12178168445825577,
0.0807034969329834,
0.13765259087085724,
0.4371063709259033,
-0.169819638133049,
-0.446871817111969,
0.6005622148513794,
-0.21106810867786407,
0.18100526928901672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10212v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10212v2
|
CPsyExam: A Chinese Benchmark for Evaluating Psychology using Examinations
| 2024-05-16T16:02:18 | 2024-05-18T07:55:58 |
Jiahao Zhao, Jingwei Zhu, Minghuan Tan, Min Yang, Di Yang, Chenhao Zhang, Guancheng Ye, Chengming Li, Xiping Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce a novel psychological benchmark, CPsyExam,
constructed from questions sourced from Chinese language examinations. CPsyExam
is designed to prioritize psychological knowledge and case analysis separately,
recognizing the significance of applying psychological knowledge to real-world
scenarios. From the pool of 22k questions, we utilize 4k to create the
benchmark that offers balanced coverage of subjects and incorporates a diverse
range of case analysis techniques.Furthermore, we evaluate a range of existing
large language models~(LLMs), spanning from open-sourced to API-based models.
Our experiments and analysis demonstrate that CPsyExam serves as an effective
benchmark for enhancing the understanding of psychology within LLMs and enables
the comparison of LLMs across various granularities.
|
[
-0.16645264625549316,
-0.3582427501678467,
0.6754463911056519,
0.9628341794013977,
-0.054646119475364685,
-0.14228643476963043,
-0.6176254153251648,
-0.4462171196937561,
-0.1939176470041275,
0.11970319598913193,
-0.7062907218933105,
-0.3924633860588074,
-0.40064460039138794,
0.010223890654742718,
0.05174221470952034,
0.6262995004653931,
-0.21350842714309692,
0.5162861943244934,
-0.1933722347021103,
-0.2354588359594345,
-0.159759521484375,
-0.7969472408294678,
-0.8910280466079712,
-0.2019772231578827,
0.03768359497189522,
-0.21173639595508575,
0.4100734293460846,
0.06572285294532776,
0.7455770969390869,
0.1894548386335373,
0.12830832600593567,
-0.11224760860204697,
-0.38568851351737976,
-0.2079816460609436,
-0.23900249600410461,
-0.6524907946586609,
-0.4794048070907593,
0.41691792011260986,
0.5832938551902771,
0.9777116179466248,
-0.15974892675876617,
0.4626995325088501,
0.09107790142297745,
0.2997707426548004,
-1.0580939054489136,
0.15149889886379242,
-0.3714207410812378,
0.3111935257911682,
-0.016108952462673187,
0.06440980732440948,
-0.4867786467075348,
-0.4046527147293091,
0.14701080322265625,
-0.524515688419342,
-0.05833223834633827,
-0.2906014621257782,
0.5595303177833557,
-0.1490178257226944,
-0.4714649021625519,
-0.024526765570044518,
-0.2671537697315216,
1.1023699045181274,
-0.4126262962818146,
0.4242992699146271,
0.35990285873413086,
0.49135759472846985,
0.09911328554153442,
-0.8821588754653931,
-0.34490343928337097,
-0.26248955726623535,
0.1135554313659668,
0.3687196671962738,
0.004055102355778217,
-0.05211896076798439,
0.277641624212265,
0.31941351294517517,
-0.632189154624939,
-0.18965008854866028,
-0.2732202410697937,
-0.4167419373989105,
0.8031051754951477,
0.6032031178474426,
0.6392441391944885,
0.11692396551370621,
-0.3685045540332794,
-0.1095622181892395,
-0.48773056268692017,
0.1526029109954834,
0.23864193260669708,
0.16895551979541779,
-0.10643839091062546,
0.1607825756072998,
0.014386608265340328,
0.4038488566875458,
-0.12824910879135132,
-0.20466437935829163,
0.13455453515052795,
-0.4141368865966797,
-0.323648065328598,
0.032844237983226776,
0.7684236764907837,
0.7248522043228149,
0.13369853794574738,
0.011350858025252819,
-0.03348700702190399,
0.3913498818874359,
0.18071375787258148,
-0.8973141312599182,
-0.6127806305885315,
0.31319567561149597,
-0.9817329049110413,
0.21675917506217957,
-0.06861906498670578,
-0.8349026441574097,
-0.44860294461250305,
-0.389779657125473,
0.13885994255542755,
-0.4166373312473297,
-0.6384283304214478,
0.14751066267490387,
-0.011351359076797962,
0.5755444169044495,
0.30142632126808167,
-0.6189966201782227,
0.6223238110542297,
1.0161347389221191,
0.7372581362724304,
-0.5262136459350586,
-0.4670942425727844,
-0.29644691944122314,
-0.2556470036506653,
-0.49969562888145447,
0.6890373826026917,
-0.5648971199989319,
-0.30646416544914246,
0.06774435192346573,
0.08569920063018799,
-0.26211369037628174,
-0.5390335321426392,
0.7047083377838135,
-0.04911356791853905,
0.41847363114356995,
-0.4970736801624298,
-0.6030699610710144,
0.09091959148645401,
0.4903150200843811,
-0.3071543276309967,
1.0644623041152954,
0.2169760763645172,
-0.40471386909484863,
0.5071366429328918,
-0.34934473037719727,
-0.10878308862447739,
0.21202974021434784,
-0.3859899342060089,
-0.006533699110150337,
0.03798627480864525,
0.05124308168888092,
0.284678190946579,
-0.21995997428894043,
0.11228136718273163,
-0.5056317448616028,
-0.7172245383262634,
0.44308674335479736,
-0.27569514513015747,
1.1498997211456299,
0.4021477699279785,
0.04526561126112938,
-0.24306033551692963,
-0.775457501411438,
0.41495493054389954,
0.013435114175081253,
-0.24583783745765686,
-0.5660478472709656,
-0.05834262818098068,
0.20291177928447723,
0.42196762561798096,
0.599206805229187,
-0.7386548519134521,
-0.03315071016550064,
-0.13396751880645752,
0.20577967166900635,
0.699878454208374,
-0.26139965653419495,
0.08805809170007706,
-0.15155364573001862,
0.5851147770881653,
-0.1974676102399826,
0.4062589704990387,
-0.17552416026592255,
-0.2424183487892151,
-0.4395255744457245,
-0.48159080743789673,
-0.1369839757680893,
0.48311176896095276,
0.09965711086988449,
0.2944994866847992,
0.2688392400741577,
-0.7546248435974121,
-0.6123020052909851,
0.2679316997528076,
0.4268866181373596,
0.17906537652015686,
0.1695159375667572,
-0.2934859097003937,
-0.6733276844024658,
-0.7052741646766663,
-0.6261569261550903,
-0.22483575344085693,
-0.21799786388874054,
0.25233733654022217,
0.201400488615036,
0.08399252593517303,
0.39903050661087036,
-0.709589421749115,
-0.2253815233707428,
-0.41516950726509094,
0.041109297424554825,
0.32670608162879944,
0.28387412428855896,
0.7612408399581909,
-0.43889710307121277,
-0.58798748254776,
-0.4064037799835205,
-0.7901886105537415,
-0.3722526729106903,
-0.3013876974582672,
-0.3863304853439331,
0.1481034755706787,
0.3709292709827423,
-0.42326515913009644,
0.16900953650474548,
0.3454982042312622,
-0.47047340869903564,
1.0028603076934814,
-0.04088694974780083,
0.19814063608646393,
-0.8785037398338318,
0.14663420617580414,
0.24724851548671722,
0.07146875560283661,
-0.44621542096138,
0.37392932176589966,
0.5313208103179932,
-0.29299262166023254,
-0.6017106771469116,
0.48316293954849243,
-0.403273344039917,
0.0942288190126419,
-0.2316754162311554,
0.47885438799858093,
-0.1471228450536728,
0.6340758204460144,
0.24904732406139374,
0.5657575726509094,
0.5758747458457947,
-0.391875296831131,
0.16511821746826172,
0.12450066208839417,
-0.41876518726348877,
1.0056926012039185,
-0.31460174918174744,
-0.03982800245285034,
0.21673020720481873,
0.07018611580133438,
-1.223061442375183,
0.2740308940410614,
-0.08928769081830978,
-0.20717869699001312,
-0.11595197021961212,
0.22987161576747894,
-0.5248842239379883,
-0.40065449476242065,
-0.5537691712379456,
0.5189448595046997,
0.5147484540939331,
-0.607991099357605,
0.2856159508228302,
0.14374929666519165,
-0.0818728357553482,
-0.44686225056648254,
-0.6162346601486206,
-0.010134353302419186,
-0.29189321398735046,
-0.442552387714386,
0.2288639098405838,
-0.45489609241485596,
-0.48684921860694885,
-0.3289250135421753,
-0.30926114320755005,
-0.09046048671007156,
0.13090096414089203,
0.12944386899471283,
0.49732688069343567,
-0.49507033824920654,
-0.10542453825473785,
-0.2331855744123459,
-0.057755425572395325,
0.7733458876609802,
0.08062179386615753,
0.5509443283081055,
-0.1898145228624344,
-0.4628373980522156,
-0.5743674635887146,
0.1815691441297531,
0.35863807797431946,
-0.0453154481947422,
0.48907771706581116,
0.31341925263404846,
-0.5303077101707458,
-0.3171643018722534,
-0.4813181459903717,
-0.10591839998960495,
-0.487484335899353,
0.46855688095092773,
-0.5060366988182068,
-0.5244556665420532,
0.5109512209892273,
-0.2268957495689392,
-0.11910049617290497,
0.06397464871406555,
0.5860089659690857,
0.03355021774768829,
1.3056771755218506,
0.5877131819725037,
-0.4105593264102936,
0.30301859974861145,
0.10992009192705154,
0.35145241022109985,
-0.8082784414291382,
-0.007644265424460173,
-0.3489960730075836,
-0.2781457006931305,
-0.5011497139930725,
-0.2007884979248047,
0.005334798246622086,
-0.03062732331454754,
-0.5419681668281555,
0.35114774107933044,
-0.47665295004844666,
0.3828135132789612,
0.2212008386850357,
0.0777897760272026,
0.26105406880378723,
-0.3380339741706848,
-0.2283191829919815,
-0.49433469772338867,
-0.17418530583381653,
-0.4869627356529236,
1.3149224519729614,
0.2603171467781067,
0.6123864650726318,
0.035793934017419815,
0.27382564544677734,
0.06152913346886635,
0.6159157156944275,
-0.5245468616485596,
0.8101167678833008,
-0.05804361402988434,
-0.49075424671173096,
0.11256975680589676,
-0.18016201257705688,
-0.734555721282959,
0.6670401096343994,
0.11215807497501373,
-1.1566582918167114,
-0.07850202172994614,
-0.33037954568862915,
-0.35883137583732605,
0.14785932004451752,
-0.6218218803405762,
0.8789710998535156,
-0.5504952073097229,
-0.5193114280700684,
-0.2629115581512451,
-0.2682751417160034,
0.837649941444397,
-0.14146222174167633,
-0.2551056742668152,
-0.32313281297683716,
-0.15165916085243225,
0.9305356740951538,
-0.39016178250312805,
0.5919877886772156,
-0.2351084202528,
-0.10789699107408524,
0.18245172500610352,
0.21875035762786865,
-0.07109000533819199,
0.15518741309642792,
-0.4028129279613495,
0.051073383539915085,
0.8159704208374023,
-0.4990687370300293,
-0.6451736092567444,
0.7720180153846741,
-0.9364179372787476,
-0.519007682800293,
-0.6874772906303406,
-0.5528350472450256,
-0.47070369124412537,
0.1872115284204483,
-0.07032296061515808,
0.14274364709854126,
-0.3524598181247711,
-0.016782449558377266,
0.37133046984672546,
-0.6709375381469727,
0.2190656214952469,
1.1781020164489746,
-0.21457472443580627,
-0.37002626061439514,
0.6915825605392456,
-0.01044144481420517,
0.026753883808851242,
0.24899770319461823,
0.12374097108840942,
-0.3660097122192383,
-0.21361850202083588,
0.2625645697116852,
0.4916044771671295,
-0.7498868107795715,
0.15706224739551544,
-0.555652379989624,
-0.24385176599025726,
-0.7009395956993103,
-0.12143884599208832,
-0.527518093585968,
-0.027241593226790428,
0.15416204929351807,
-0.19958147406578064,
-0.1752946525812149,
0.14783737063407898,
0.08667458593845367,
0.08762011677026749,
-0.3403467833995819,
0.1833678036928177,
-0.017338713631033897,
0.631720781326294,
0.1094367653131485,
-0.1969555765390396,
-0.00454477034509182,
-0.19417625665664673,
-0.6895521283149719,
-0.8401131629943848,
0.37249457836151123,
-0.09944839030504227,
0.9455211758613586,
0.7999873757362366,
0.22533293068408966,
0.9628503322601318,
-0.026283172890543938,
1.1248109340667725,
0.29757043719291687,
-1.0743894577026367,
0.7720262408256531,
-0.17612940073013306,
0.20933669805526733,
0.8253728151321411,
0.4875427186489105,
-0.7375208735466003,
-0.3335513174533844,
-0.4118671715259552,
-0.5804503560066223,
0.8318386673927307,
0.06240297481417656,
0.18061968684196472,
-0.15664562582969666,
0.37527501583099365,
0.12773628532886505,
0.017641806975007057,
-0.7717152237892151,
-0.15322336554527283,
-0.05825664848089218,
-0.41392064094543457,
-0.06654305756092072,
-0.20687365531921387,
-0.09890060871839523,
-0.44056838750839233,
0.3049200177192688,
-0.08905749768018723,
0.44841745495796204,
0.1094006597995758,
-0.16505010426044464,
-0.05758398771286011,
-0.024197055026888847,
0.4093427360057831,
0.8954732418060303,
-0.4195387661457062,
0.13455721735954285,
0.41250017285346985,
-0.7287251949310303,
0.0036921503487974405,
0.006623405497521162,
0.38103339076042175,
-0.3867965042591095,
0.3922317326068878,
0.21738409996032715,
0.0630280077457428,
-1.3375599384307861,
0.7087048888206482,
-0.3746257722377777,
-0.290614515542984,
-0.557986319065094,
0.061963364481925964,
0.10226638615131378,
0.09239014238119125,
0.3825833201408386,
-0.54582279920578,
0.04845636337995529,
-0.7403872609138489,
0.23817561566829681,
0.3389286994934082,
-0.40160998702049255,
-0.3976544737815857,
0.7099138498306274,
-0.015747807919979095,
-0.1818917840719223,
0.9282768368721008,
-0.010075961239635944,
-0.38840776681900024,
0.7161781191825867,
0.7738598585128784,
0.6887671947479248,
-0.37156543135643005,
0.0919579491019249,
0.4420474171638489,
0.41172143816947937,
-0.12757256627082825,
0.8911588788032532,
-0.3867717683315277,
-0.6982225775718689,
-0.12724970281124115,
-0.4975830912590027,
-0.6580461263656616,
0.6328510046005249,
-0.9026358723640442,
0.34526824951171875,
-0.7474175095558167,
0.06739448755979538,
-0.5427486300468445,
0.6095584034919739,
-0.6118192076683044,
0.31559017300605774,
0.25817355513572693,
1.4252324104309082,
-0.9615789651870728,
0.827852725982666,
0.778478741645813,
-0.3717556595802307,
-0.7512696981430054,
0.11402473598718643,
-0.10420234501361847,
-0.8078858256340027,
0.5105279684066772,
0.44512704014778137,
0.3901180028915405,
-0.7403174638748169,
-0.29817020893096924,
-0.6096324324607849,
1.1727569103240967,
0.5111948847770691,
-0.26832467317581177,
0.417491614818573,
0.44874608516693115,
0.9893969297409058,
-0.3667905032634735,
0.7165394425392151,
0.877164363861084,
0.5150405168533325,
-0.5103020071983337,
-0.6707470417022705,
0.2557257413864136,
-0.8125820755958557,
-0.17748847603797913,
-0.08050181716680527,
-1.0680241584777832,
0.9040380120277405,
0.02655915357172489,
-0.24392278492450714,
0.26478204131126404,
0.593490481376648,
0.9916929006576538,
0.7199593186378479,
0.34432512521743774,
0.27865639328956604,
0.8162267804145813,
-0.04491395503282547,
0.8696675896644592,
-0.764255940914154,
0.1438855230808258,
1.2558138370513916,
-0.7718209624290466,
0.9531399011611938,
0.47437968850135803,
-0.6250135898590088,
0.33939269185066223,
1.0095409154891968,
-0.20772238075733185,
0.34178972244262695,
0.48197048902511597,
-0.1318436563014984,
-0.32601773738861084,
0.029422475025057793,
-0.3757801353931427,
0.40347370505332947,
0.4635502099990845,
-0.3656216263771057,
-0.16064000129699707,
0.06615262478590012,
0.042112622410058975,
0.47401872277259827,
-0.3925958275794983,
0.3978096842765808,
0.30621859431266785,
-0.9162099957466125,
0.3542906939983368,
-0.057327743619680405,
0.6454919576644897,
-0.7547996640205383,
0.19203771650791168,
-0.572729229927063,
0.5983647704124451,
-0.04306633025407791,
-0.8243889808654785,
0.22524920105934143,
-0.009124810807406902,
0.35048654675483704,
-0.24825146794319153,
0.746304988861084,
-0.32026195526123047,
-0.5495527386665344,
0.6474270224571228,
0.39156243205070496,
0.3999212980270386,
-0.25968146324157715,
-0.8542826175689697,
0.06001734361052513,
-0.37247297167778015,
-0.25091150403022766,
0.6716384291648865,
0.33170202374458313,
-0.022223811596632004,
0.7435799837112427,
0.34320977330207825,
0.38860005140304565,
-0.1329043060541153,
0.12275087088346481,
0.45036715269088745,
-0.7650406360626221,
-0.8305563926696777,
-0.8486906290054321,
-0.039238594472408295,
-0.17944438755512238,
-0.4315766990184784,
1.0828251838684082,
0.7465032339096069,
0.8290780782699585,
-0.015218047425150871,
0.9279370903968811,
0.2381141632795334,
0.2007715106010437,
0.004406854044646025,
0.8328762650489807,
-0.5822566151618958,
0.16823986172676086,
-0.5705128312110901,
-0.8576211929321289,
-0.2780933380126953,
0.6120941638946533,
-0.47941917181015015,
-0.0017478521913290024,
0.9409704208374023,
0.7499620914459229,
-0.0457509346306324,
0.3741982877254486,
0.4740281105041504,
-0.030357331037521362,
0.2408883273601532,
1.145707130432129,
1.0378217697143555,
-0.4010242223739624,
0.544337272644043,
-0.49557849764823914,
-0.299258828163147,
0.15694965422153473,
-0.8069775700569153,
-1.166545033454895,
-0.53154057264328,
-0.48105165362358093,
-0.144563227891922,
-0.07687123119831085,
0.9577589631080627,
0.5932993292808533,
-0.8063403367996216,
-0.5548815131187439,
0.293423056602478,
-0.21787098050117493,
-0.8693912625312805,
-0.31156837940216064,
0.5864148736000061,
-0.3387870490550995,
-0.7204821109771729,
0.22990277409553528,
0.14894999563694,
-0.413501113653183,
-0.49521321058273315,
-0.1304241269826889,
0.11114580929279327,
0.30198216438293457,
0.6801270842552185,
-0.029619641602039337,
-0.5562220811843872,
-0.18770350515842438,
0.11585694551467896,
-0.3170299232006073,
-0.13173049688339233,
1.1149109601974487,
-0.6051580905914307,
0.2926121652126312,
0.7200689315795898,
0.5247824192047119,
0.10550840198993683,
-0.20624665915966034,
0.7676175832748413,
-0.4235050678253174,
0.08910936862230301,
-0.15482990443706512,
0.6687852740287781,
0.06807900220155716,
-0.6205196976661682,
0.6917338967323303,
0.3233262002468109,
-0.2513463497161865,
-1.135842204093933,
-0.20929095149040222,
-1.1019748449325562,
-0.5852811336517334,
0.9471037983894348,
-0.5095987319946289,
-0.22704382240772247,
-0.004123192746192217,
-0.3385174870491028,
0.05634075030684471,
-0.14316578209400177,
1.089966893196106,
0.9736379384994507,
-0.4922567903995514,
-0.4356912076473236,
-0.35661494731903076,
0.33404961228370667,
0.7722185850143433,
-0.695284366607666,
0.2384864240884781,
-0.018678681924939156,
0.5149304866790771,
-0.034043002873659134,
0.885144054889679,
-0.4049849510192871,
0.6406190395355225,
0.0420089028775692,
0.04934399202466011,
0.34246236085891724,
0.14967289566993713,
-0.14972953498363495,
0.5087100863456726,
-0.18805581331253052,
-0.078553207218647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10211v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10211v1
|
Building a Luganda Text-to-Speech Model From Crowdsourced Data
| 2024-05-16T16:00:47 | 2024-05-16T16:00:47 |
Sulaiman Kagumire, Andrew Katumba, Joyce Nakatumba-Nabende, John Quinn
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Text-to-speech (TTS) development for African languages such as Luganda is
still limited, primarily due to the scarcity of high-quality, single-speaker
recordings essential for training TTS models. Prior work has focused on
utilizing the Luganda Common Voice recordings of multiple speakers aged between
20-49. Although the generated speech is intelligible, it is still of lower
quality than the model trained on studio-grade recordings. This is due to the
insufficient data preprocessing methods applied to improve the quality of the
Common Voice recordings. Furthermore, speech convergence is more difficult to
achieve due to varying intonations, as well as background noise. In this paper,
we show that the quality of Luganda TTS from Common Voice can improve by
training on multiple speakers of close intonation in addition to further
preprocessing of the training data. Specifically, we selected six female
speakers with close intonation determined by subjectively listening and
comparing their voice recordings. In addition to trimming out silent portions
from the beginning and end of the recordings, we applied a pre-trained speech
enhancement model to reduce background noise and enhance audio quality. We also
utilized a pre-trained, non-intrusive, self-supervised Mean Opinion Score (MOS)
estimation model to filter recordings with an estimated MOS over 3.5,
indicating high perceived quality. Subjective MOS evaluations from nine native
Luganda speakers demonstrate that our TTS model achieves a significantly better
MOS of 3.55 compared to the reported 2.5 MOS of the existing model. Moreover,
for a fair comparison, our model trained on six speakers outperforms models
trained on a single-speaker (3.13 MOS) or two speakers (3.22 MOS). This
showcases the effectiveness of compensating for the lack of data from one
speaker with data from multiple speakers of close intonation to improve TTS
quality.
|
[
-0.3804864287376404,
-0.5215096473693848,
0.2969604730606079,
-0.026520175859332085,
-0.4077304005622864,
0.07442093640565872,
-0.5271111130714417,
-0.5304679870605469,
0.520210862159729,
0.6059610247612,
-0.4277571141719818,
-0.6664192080497742,
-0.5014294385910034,
0.18325550854206085,
-0.4919200539588928,
0.9919275045394897,
0.5076016187667847,
0.1451158970594406,
0.1554240882396698,
-0.17853018641471863,
-0.3443850576877594,
-0.7446655631065369,
-0.4369601309299469,
-0.1411305069923401,
0.44980859756469727,
0.6195940375328064,
0.7019721269607544,
0.16154275834560394,
-0.14346517622470856,
0.22859114408493042,
-0.2664824426174164,
0.44540777802467346,
-0.5932732820510864,
-0.10427777469158173,
0.08516579866409302,
-0.38427263498306274,
-0.37347567081451416,
0.2115420699119568,
0.46245482563972473,
0.6986610889434814,
-0.4195253551006317,
0.1711948812007904,
0.2794276475906372,
0.5151723027229309,
-0.2756226360797882,
-0.19481025636196136,
-0.6835345029830933,
-0.1549191176891327,
-0.53974449634552,
0.029167775064706802,
-0.31362810730934143,
-0.413944810628891,
0.21214136481285095,
-0.6103451251983643,
0.31211498379707336,
-0.6064826250076294,
0.7864617705345154,
0.2282220721244812,
0.02545042708516121,
-0.3003670275211334,
-0.8534629940986633,
0.6332463622093201,
-1.0961627960205078,
0.32434502243995667,
0.6177949905395508,
0.23301874101161957,
0.09175944328308105,
-0.47748708724975586,
-0.6579862833023071,
-0.33698880672454834,
0.009266996756196022,
0.08481242507696152,
-0.06489018350839615,
-0.008701453916728497,
0.22778700292110443,
0.16240710020065308,
-0.46736598014831543,
0.18940211832523346,
-0.5678792595863342,
-0.0924578532576561,
0.7190396189689636,
-0.22783522307872772,
0.0903015285730362,
-0.30596768856048584,
-0.18625493347644806,
0.0759182795882225,
-0.5111492276191711,
0.2013351172208786,
0.7666147351264954,
0.6315323710441589,
-0.0864124596118927,
0.37927281856536865,
-0.31236404180526733,
0.818120539188385,
-0.003075931454077363,
-0.45214205980300903,
0.44066154956817627,
-0.39921239018440247,
-0.03389856219291687,
0.088873490691185,
0.7088662981987,
0.17989780008792877,
0.48186445236206055,
-0.15643662214279175,
-0.20152711868286133,
0.13955208659172058,
0.19380813837051392,
-0.6150717735290527,
-0.04836641624569893,
0.055757053196430206,
-0.6347171068191528,
-0.14232715964317322,
0.12514783442020416,
-1.041795253753662,
-0.11353655904531479,
-0.6975324749946594,
0.4859089255332947,
-0.41153499484062195,
-0.4547770321369171,
0.04235989227890968,
0.23832367360591888,
-0.293937623500824,
0.4122416079044342,
-0.9238243699073792,
0.3821168541908264,
0.350681334733963,
1.1157654523849487,
-0.06838683038949966,
-0.16496728360652924,
-0.5464168190956116,
0.06435355544090271,
-0.15766970813274384,
0.6224508285522461,
-0.42218121886253357,
-0.6501672267913818,
-0.12089379876852036,
-0.405939519405365,
0.03936133533716202,
-0.5767652988433838,
0.538488507270813,
-0.15381339192390442,
0.024685632437467575,
-0.30531880259513855,
-0.4804123640060425,
-0.07287698984146118,
-0.28506022691726685,
-0.560956597328186,
0.8344227075576782,
0.11418620496988297,
-0.3845663070678711,
0.32400190830230713,
-0.6242505311965942,
-0.3427366614341736,
-0.11662933975458145,
-0.36637431383132935,
-0.30328115820884705,
0.20007231831550598,
0.5319716334342957,
0.41618412733078003,
-0.18286262452602386,
0.5368452072143555,
-0.12465304881334305,
-0.5115160942077637,
0.20661145448684692,
-0.538100004196167,
0.6572467684745789,
0.3293745219707489,
-0.400460422039032,
-0.04862559586763382,
-0.9732649326324463,
0.03240256756544113,
-0.14713357388973236,
-0.1418929398059845,
-0.1896475851535797,
-0.08802623301744461,
0.09389244019985199,
0.08769358694553375,
-0.10873387008905411,
-0.4997677206993103,
0.13553458452224731,
-0.5589680075645447,
0.5859009623527527,
0.6461622714996338,
-0.13271579146385193,
0.1985798329114914,
-0.34634917974472046,
0.44247716665267944,
-0.12505964934825897,
0.16736002266407013,
-0.13062646985054016,
-0.6445308923721313,
-0.7688535451889038,
-0.18506371974945068,
0.42314937710762024,
0.23543018102645874,
-0.6349112391471863,
0.4856562912464142,
-0.4588634967803955,
-0.6902843117713928,
-0.9930806756019592,
0.2078724056482315,
0.19010262191295624,
0.7733150124549866,
0.5062353014945984,
-0.48502957820892334,
-0.4548789858818054,
-0.7565970420837402,
-0.023226585239171982,
-0.058737244457006454,
-0.07830091565847397,
0.08691325038671494,
0.2785256803035736,
-0.04826076701283455,
1.24777352809906,
-0.21698777377605438,
-0.27923110127449036,
0.06679394841194153,
0.18091753125190735,
0.5741866230964661,
0.4091237485408783,
0.7186963558197021,
-0.6045649647712708,
-0.27219435572624207,
-0.1847442090511322,
-0.4559970200061798,
-0.11769871413707733,
0.21743036806583405,
0.056617263704538345,
-0.10664410889148712,
0.3398336172103882,
-0.3038388788700104,
0.7450942397117615,
0.8018478155136108,
-0.14735394716262817,
0.5280407667160034,
-0.022836990654468536,
0.28711819648742676,
-1.1551297903060913,
0.06291639804840088,
-0.16970545053482056,
-0.23285214602947235,
-0.8607143759727478,
-0.4082559049129486,
-0.46846163272857666,
-0.5923461318016052,
-0.13207794725894928,
0.14327795803546906,
-0.3414281904697418,
-0.3833381235599518,
-0.43281933665275574,
0.37647703289985657,
-0.10361974686384201,
0.42344731092453003,
0.13253851234912872,
1.1403676271438599,
0.38367676734924316,
-0.6757196187973022,
0.3722658157348633,
0.3394337594509125,
-0.7350884079933167,
0.6748231053352356,
-0.8580697178840637,
0.544202983379364,
-0.013865486718714237,
0.1258872002363205,
-0.9135581254959106,
-0.2202294021844864,
-0.05288634076714516,
-0.7927519083023071,
0.16977666318416595,
-0.1635226160287857,
-0.41044074296951294,
-0.24592334032058716,
0.12431245297193527,
0.22014500200748444,
0.39816024899482727,
-0.9519703984260559,
0.44905349612236023,
0.4596192240715027,
-0.4684487283229828,
-0.4141937792301178,
-0.7569969296455383,
0.24096958339214325,
-0.159671813249588,
-0.8049005270004272,
0.34118032455444336,
-0.03661378100514412,
-0.17440015077590942,
-0.20346933603286743,
0.19369325041770935,
-0.19034524261951447,
-0.14829567074775696,
0.11699303984642029,
-0.04507873207330704,
-0.17962703108787537,
0.6615033149719238,
-0.1313149780035019,
-0.08695003390312195,
-0.07664002478122711,
-0.3219037353992462,
0.6359079480171204,
0.20860262215137482,
-0.39195239543914795,
-0.6343547701835632,
0.5112297534942627,
0.2607775032520294,
-0.36205458641052246,
0.69395512342453,
0.5899441242218018,
-0.3244279623031616,
-0.007129383739084005,
-0.7549232840538025,
-0.18546940386295319,
-0.42910295724868774,
0.40214595198631287,
-0.25168484449386597,
-0.7153307795524597,
0.4040323793888092,
0.05927296727895737,
-0.06244727224111557,
0.1959104835987091,
0.27488866448402405,
-0.1718621850013733,
0.6308596134185791,
0.5149294137954712,
-0.46474334597587585,
0.658541202545166,
-0.14241915941238403,
-0.1272462159395218,
-0.5560399889945984,
-0.3171810507774353,
-0.8758817911148071,
-0.17314405739307404,
-0.3688293397426605,
-0.45241519808769226,
0.5236082077026367,
0.019230831414461136,
0.029703129082918167,
0.23592358827590942,
-0.6965439915657043,
0.21769744157791138,
0.6817538738250732,
0.6386878490447998,
0.375471293926239,
0.34412363171577454,
0.25168144702911377,
-0.31482699513435364,
-0.5092563629150391,
-0.7717883586883545,
1.3056116104125977,
0.18392275273799896,
0.5652498006820679,
0.22798992693424225,
0.7395999431610107,
0.25540226697921753,
0.3873833417892456,
-0.4044061303138733,
0.3163550794124603,
-0.3551647663116455,
-0.4647665321826935,
-0.4965740740299225,
-0.6190782785415649,
-0.7814145088195801,
0.026080012321472168,
-0.19393961131572723,
-0.8204392790794373,
0.21775558590888977,
0.15736882388591766,
-0.5720410346984863,
0.27534210681915283,
-0.7823238372802734,
0.3955976366996765,
-0.17918674647808075,
-0.1291409730911255,
-0.37578335404396057,
-0.6800957918167114,
0.36721011996269226,
-0.1573595255613327,
0.35092246532440186,
-0.20948883891105652,
0.25385528802871704,
1.1276274919509888,
-0.7875807881355286,
0.9011998772621155,
-0.35803690552711487,
-0.44685786962509155,
0.44236260652542114,
-0.5329964756965637,
0.4119987189769745,
0.2918577194213867,
-0.47394630312919617,
0.3114686608314514,
-0.36198803782463074,
-0.48868951201438904,
-0.6193278431892395,
0.6129428148269653,
-1.1352742910385132,
-0.420733243227005,
0.04269746318459511,
-0.2069464921951294,
-0.5102965235710144,
-0.13287235796451569,
0.6240726113319397,
0.6711297631263733,
-0.178163543343544,
0.13132911920547485,
0.576901912689209,
-0.15417681634426117,
0.5457744002342224,
0.34599724411964417,
-0.1105872318148613,
-0.8658773899078369,
0.7172665596008301,
0.42203226685523987,
0.5128244757652283,
0.1362307369709015,
0.12582360208034515,
-0.29347532987594604,
-0.5785971283912659,
-0.2250373512506485,
0.15350152552127838,
-0.653490424156189,
-0.15353870391845703,
-0.41258928179740906,
-0.23122446238994598,
-0.5518715977668762,
0.20070680975914001,
-0.4739852845668793,
-0.3314164876937866,
-0.5579153895378113,
-0.2165922075510025,
0.5972212553024292,
0.7203325629234314,
-0.24600712954998016,
0.7576082944869995,
-0.741051435470581,
0.4663351774215698,
0.6668711304664612,
0.1578652709722519,
0.03306637331843376,
-1.0002954006195068,
-0.2758895456790924,
0.3812195360660553,
0.026998335495591164,
-1.0454226732254028,
0.3945006728172302,
0.19084230065345764,
0.3991991877555847,
0.320652037858963,
-0.17758235335350037,
1.011000156402588,
-0.1524776965379715,
0.889926016330719,
0.3856014013290405,
-1.2471134662628174,
0.9733362793922424,
-0.3763745427131653,
0.18288613855838776,
0.8210585117340088,
0.035281915217638016,
-0.39906126260757446,
0.0036639245226979256,
-0.6039750576019287,
-0.519480288028717,
0.5736779570579529,
0.5740136504173279,
0.21590164303779602,
0.30136945843696594,
0.3719617426395416,
0.3811357915401459,
0.3484690487384796,
-0.7502793073654175,
-0.3012459874153137,
-0.551668107509613,
-0.032443203032016754,
-0.5995440483093262,
-0.17868274450302124,
-0.008488462306559086,
-0.46724608540534973,
0.5097883343696594,
-0.018000300973653793,
0.18380402028560638,
0.2446068972349167,
-0.007842402905225754,
0.0418386235833168,
0.308755487203598,
0.7571962475776672,
0.6031728982925415,
-0.1840929090976715,
-0.10071905702352524,
0.10967352241277695,
-0.5956336259841919,
0.3257896602153778,
0.31011322140693665,
-0.34627798199653625,
0.632091224193573,
0.38698050379753113,
1.1029990911483765,
0.020797042176127434,
-0.34783774614334106,
0.33868831396102905,
0.1232764944434166,
0.005438950844109058,
-0.21363882720470428,
-0.09540393948554993,
-0.011210747994482517,
-0.029444647952914238,
0.4269317090511322,
0.25515061616897583,
-0.14482605457305908,
-0.3755985498428345,
0.16976220905780792,
0.05916716903448105,
-0.3654371500015259,
-0.3980973958969116,
0.634087324142456,
0.7741528153419495,
-0.47798094153404236,
0.5836935639381409,
0.03949437662959099,
-0.13855218887329102,
0.40300577878952026,
0.2690081000328064,
0.6645967960357666,
-0.6624665856361389,
0.24624250829219818,
0.5399926900863647,
0.3807700276374817,
-0.12693630158901215,
0.39439356327056885,
-0.05047617480158806,
-0.7223978042602539,
-0.45685097575187683,
-0.4411187767982483,
-0.35456693172454834,
0.3231242597103119,
-0.793235719203949,
0.2806589901447296,
-0.09067126363515854,
-0.6216863989830017,
-0.19172829389572144,
-0.020253080874681473,
-0.5564331412315369,
0.4134939908981323,
0.05387057363986969,
0.4847525954246521,
-0.7359945178031921,
0.9400650858879089,
0.08092951774597168,
-0.5430428981781006,
-0.9312993288040161,
0.11483367532491684,
-0.24465130269527435,
-0.5704144239425659,
0.31746724247932434,
0.2711625397205353,
-0.23633967339992523,
0.05182720348238945,
-0.7530088424682617,
-0.960411012172699,
0.841494619846344,
0.695742666721344,
-1.102853775024414,
0.09912269562482834,
0.047513198107481,
0.3957694172859192,
-0.2355630099773407,
0.20868192613124847,
0.5691321492195129,
0.41960471868515015,
-0.21350359916687012,
-1.1357660293579102,
-0.35413116216659546,
-0.18048080801963806,
-0.11218180507421494,
-0.00514937611296773,
-0.6181854605674744,
0.866460382938385,
-0.19685332477092743,
-0.03614383563399315,
0.35040831565856934,
1.0039461851119995,
0.31883490085601807,
0.2448388785123825,
0.7778545618057251,
0.3765355050563812,
1.1563405990600586,
-0.1083548441529274,
0.6496226787567139,
-0.01585724577307701,
0.11488817632198334,
1.2755215167999268,
-0.17334355413913727,
0.7530202269554138,
0.3619377315044403,
-0.362324595451355,
0.3298853039741516,
0.5125283598899841,
0.18460285663604736,
0.5433676242828369,
0.2896806001663208,
-0.3445006310939789,
-0.17549841105937958,
-0.35319554805755615,
-0.735465943813324,
0.536065936088562,
0.36124250292778015,
-0.3602088391780853,
0.14170894026756287,
0.25824517011642456,
-0.14906227588653564,
0.5515664219856262,
-0.25499361753463745,
0.44275227189064026,
0.02326064370572567,
-0.4923754036426544,
0.5542082786560059,
-0.2987360656261444,
0.9715642333030701,
-0.6274637579917908,
0.09251177310943604,
-0.27104565501213074,
-0.20624685287475586,
-0.22484612464904785,
-0.4777279198169708,
0.10709113627672195,
0.33256950974464417,
-0.28822916746139526,
-0.17554643750190735,
0.41017091274261475,
-0.6710520386695862,
-0.3841419816017151,
0.37929415702819824,
0.3995567858219147,
0.2699487805366516,
-0.12067082524299622,
-0.2516869008541107,
-0.02207772433757782,
0.11124308407306671,
0.0729336366057396,
0.05062822997570038,
0.24625352025032043,
0.35795319080352783,
0.33525365591049194,
0.8046989440917969,
0.43977680802345276,
-0.07527400553226471,
0.66551274061203,
0.8556394577026367,
-0.5349208116531372,
-0.6265583038330078,
-0.6342025995254517,
0.2822970747947693,
-0.3232537508010864,
-0.6155582070350647,
0.526124119758606,
0.4629251956939697,
0.8231896758079529,
-0.015408170409500599,
0.7995333671569824,
0.3149296045303345,
1.0559428930282593,
-0.8719370365142822,
0.6771044135093689,
-0.30975836515426636,
0.1417275369167328,
-0.6230579614639282,
-0.7929419279098511,
0.2563202977180481,
0.6857957243919373,
0.0040976484306156635,
0.26598119735717773,
0.2271060049533844,
0.829231321811676,
0.10516847670078278,
0.18799737095832825,
0.5037330389022827,
0.009888971224427223,
0.314969003200531,
0.3975112736225128,
0.9467231631278992,
-0.3048611879348755,
0.7826758027076721,
-0.3354206681251526,
-0.10069101303815842,
0.057909004390239716,
-0.4781058430671692,
-0.924121081829071,
-0.5404554009437561,
-0.12652696669101715,
-0.2638099491596222,
0.19762684404850006,
0.9166907072067261,
1.0074588060379028,
-0.7080598473548889,
-0.41050466895103455,
0.10822701454162598,
-0.27675002813339233,
-0.1791134476661682,
-0.1656753271818161,
0.2368086725473404,
-0.055316261947155,
-0.7605607509613037,
0.7949159145355225,
0.016023928299546242,
0.3072796165943146,
-0.14689485728740692,
-0.1773049235343933,
-0.16559089720249176,
-0.10188695788383484,
0.3726308345794678,
0.1991465985774994,
-0.6690132021903992,
-0.19164006412029266,
-0.2035398632287979,
-0.03488445654511452,
0.1790364533662796,
0.7283384799957275,
-0.7735131978988647,
0.5665260553359985,
0.12490911781787872,
0.2640966475009918,
0.6991294026374817,
0.20973901450634003,
0.6804301142692566,
-1.1159528493881226,
0.5203918814659119,
0.3844880163669586,
0.22709932923316956,
0.46383002400398254,
-0.1370326727628708,
0.6539720296859741,
0.2205466479063034,
-0.4314574599266052,
-0.7615696787834167,
-0.014825263060629368,
-0.7974047064781189,
0.020234018564224243,
1.0694329738616943,
-0.10895657539367676,
0.2054857760667801,
-0.17935825884342194,
-0.34042882919311523,
0.49019840359687805,
-0.7432750463485718,
0.7750300168991089,
0.6104925274848938,
0.14377042651176453,
0.07399242371320724,
-0.5687218904495239,
0.5718555450439453,
0.4804517924785614,
-1.059975266456604,
-0.09826112538576126,
0.20732122659683228,
-0.006996111012995243,
0.31056270003318787,
0.7783019542694092,
0.19387267529964447,
0.21282826364040375,
-0.16054825484752655,
0.09336177259683609,
0.0005347371916286647,
-0.2525325119495392,
-0.47234609723091125,
0.043581608682870865,
-0.15406732261180878,
-0.36788681149482727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10202v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10202v1
|
Hierarchical Attention Graph for Scientific Document Summarization in Global and Local Level
| 2024-05-16T15:46:30 | 2024-05-16T15:46:30 |
Chenlong Zhao, Xiwen Zhou, Xiaopeng Xie, Yong Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Scientific document summarization has been a challenging task due to the long
structure of the input text. The long input hinders the simultaneous effective
modeling of both global high-order relations between sentences and local
intra-sentence relations which is the most critical step in extractive
summarization. However, existing methods mostly focus on one type of relation,
neglecting the simultaneous effective modeling of both relations, which can
lead to insufficient learning of semantic representations. In this paper, we
propose HAESum, a novel approach utilizing graph neural networks to locally and
globally model documents based on their hierarchical discourse structure.
First, intra-sentence relations are learned using a local heterogeneous graph.
Subsequently, a novel hypergraph self-attention layer is introduced to further
enhance the characterization of high-order inter-sentence relations. We
validate our approach on two benchmark datasets, and the experimental results
demonstrate the effectiveness of HAESum and the importance of considering
hierarchical structures in modeling long scientific documents. Our code will be
available at \url{https://github.com/MoLICHENXI/HAESum}
|
[
-0.16303454339504242,
-0.7508120536804199,
0.44131898880004883,
0.3008077144622803,
-0.16817589104175568,
0.15959537029266357,
-0.012074870988726616,
-0.48869189620018005,
0.5985591411590576,
0.45414963364601135,
-0.26300281286239624,
-0.6986615657806396,
-0.5778170824050903,
0.21270185708999634,
-0.1575440615415573,
1.213985800743103,
-0.053493794053792953,
-0.349542498588562,
-0.6254058480262756,
-0.2804906666278839,
0.13674186170101166,
-0.46440398693084717,
-0.49176734685897827,
-0.4798465073108673,
0.7864468097686768,
0.25196415185928345,
0.7023102641105652,
0.9179476499557495,
0.8390612006187439,
0.36808106303215027,
-0.44617095589637756,
0.20430932939052582,
-0.5797186493873596,
0.020864203572273254,
-0.14640763401985168,
0.005200875923037529,
-0.9139474630355835,
-0.1903005689382553,
1.155679702758789,
0.8861398696899414,
0.251559317111969,
0.2761390507221222,
0.2303236573934555,
0.5668317675590515,
-0.42868417501449585,
0.5795921087265015,
-0.18464680016040802,
0.3606731593608856,
-0.06699609011411667,
-0.33575567603111267,
-0.17483769357204437,
-0.14364749193191528,
0.26941782236099243,
-0.867231547832489,
0.1765126883983612,
0.12003911286592484,
0.9995682239532471,
0.15637344121932983,
-0.391149640083313,
0.02419285476207733,
-0.41251319646835327,
0.4332352876663208,
-0.8397142887115479,
0.008518129587173462,
0.3813070058822632,
-0.021768487989902496,
-0.07924027740955353,
-1.0738344192504883,
-0.0574733205139637,
-0.23361627757549286,
-0.4263259470462799,
0.6354790329933167,
-0.1638052761554718,
0.0003851471992675215,
0.031162071973085403,
0.36995750665664673,
-0.5176060795783997,
-0.007909939624369144,
-0.2710433304309845,
-0.0659063309431076,
0.17139530181884766,
0.1560646891593933,
0.06371935456991196,
-0.6991287469863892,
-0.4485297203063965,
0.24277561902999878,
-0.39033594727516174,
-0.352884978055954,
0.15701597929000854,
0.38736024498939514,
-0.31961801648139954,
0.4729005694389343,
-0.1983129233121872,
0.4534474313259125,
-0.03517575189471245,
-0.0965624526143074,
0.4327385127544403,
-0.5268897414207458,
-0.13900043070316315,
0.09291151911020279,
0.9295588135719299,
0.18245342373847961,
0.22602957487106323,
-0.11067500710487366,
0.2519835829734802,
-0.11884058266878128,
0.22383606433868408,
-0.8313892483711243,
0.016546284779906273,
0.05703841522336006,
-0.6461358070373535,
-0.32507389783859253,
-0.23125603795051575,
-0.9537644386291504,
-0.12602262198925018,
-0.12127931416034698,
0.08291149884462357,
-0.21724846959114075,
-0.049510691314935684,
-0.15989235043525696,
0.15483084321022034,
-0.47013598680496216,
0.24379026889801025,
-0.775448739528656,
0.6039274334907532,
0.4460812509059906,
1.2395857572555542,
-0.2386484146118164,
-0.7341119647026062,
-0.5259010791778564,
0.6253606081008911,
0.16244597733020782,
0.7631157636642456,
-0.24674436450004578,
-0.2825503647327423,
-0.25876954197883606,
-0.16121451556682587,
-0.19859980046749115,
-0.28844690322875977,
0.3868328034877777,
-0.3950952887535095,
0.28830617666244507,
0.10062002390623093,
-0.4902495741844177,
0.06397297233343124,
0.3864605724811554,
-0.5966677069664001,
1.1133226156234741,
0.3091391324996948,
-1.3969062566757202,
-0.2912774682044983,
-0.8992117643356323,
-0.756371021270752,
0.08629798889160156,
-0.273084431886673,
-0.774960458278656,
-0.2527827024459839,
0.4973008632659912,
0.5137916207313538,
0.09214095771312714,
0.23556098341941833,
-0.335505872964859,
-0.06266314536333084,
-0.20651128888130188,
0.07231825590133667,
0.6836771965026855,
0.056775253266096115,
-0.13859225809574127,
0.467602014541626,
-0.7389802932739258,
-0.17369197309017181,
0.1752784103155136,
-0.19082748889923096,
-0.34822431206703186,
-0.00031244437559507787,
-0.3049502670764923,
0.2986854612827301,
0.28748273849487305,
-0.5659350752830505,
0.015526018105447292,
-0.5600194931030273,
0.506261944770813,
0.3350384533405304,
0.580021321773529,
0.45825427770614624,
-0.09835391491651535,
0.4153761863708496,
-0.03398759290575981,
-0.0028070518746972084,
-0.3358501195907593,
-0.30457887053489685,
-0.48624852299690247,
-0.2953590154647827,
0.2607266306877136,
0.3024795353412628,
-0.26585638523101807,
0.5662574172019958,
-0.47494810819625854,
-0.29233160614967346,
-0.16099460422992706,
-0.03133537992835045,
0.3842335641384125,
0.9359706044197083,
0.2892032265663147,
-0.22705620527267456,
-0.451266348361969,
-0.7765975594520569,
0.04434125870466232,
-0.3294885456562042,
0.06170131266117096,
0.4090893864631653,
0.8110277652740479,
-0.12664224207401276,
1.044183373451233,
-0.765784740447998,
-0.5696482062339783,
-0.1544279158115387,
0.6284064650535583,
0.19139191508293152,
0.28489014506340027,
0.5744362473487854,
-0.5053377151489258,
-0.30461403727531433,
0.24967226386070251,
-1.2503430843353271,
0.12156832963228226,
-0.08157620579004288,
-0.3463285565376282,
-0.1303737312555313,
0.6081812977790833,
-0.7509933710098267,
0.40055394172668457,
0.24883899092674255,
-0.18456454575061798,
0.42914462089538574,
-0.6122701168060303,
0.06068555638194084,
-1.2778984308242798,
0.23713956773281097,
0.3160474896430969,
-0.36041727662086487,
-0.22279208898544312,
0.22261495888233185,
0.1791265457868576,
-0.47485706210136414,
-0.39542070031166077,
0.3677443861961365,
-0.9177687764167786,
-0.33749476075172424,
-0.2584192752838135,
0.3805181384086609,
0.15141995251178741,
0.704355776309967,
0.1720072478055954,
0.32023388147354126,
0.4260779023170471,
-0.3538801968097687,
0.233367457985878,
0.4756900668144226,
-0.1909003108739853,
0.39341288805007935,
-0.8962656259536743,
-0.24585291743278503,
-0.2858145833015442,
0.443208783864975,
-0.8775763511657715,
-0.4411791265010834,
0.17503301799297333,
-0.5216652750968933,
0.3058423697948456,
0.002680048579350114,
-0.46727481484413147,
-0.6990156173706055,
-0.20916296541690826,
0.37627044320106506,
0.12617585062980652,
-0.3464972674846649,
0.6134748458862305,
0.5266199707984924,
-0.5429638624191284,
-0.51350998878479,
-0.4380696713924408,
0.28388506174087524,
-0.13617879152297974,
-0.6876529455184937,
0.5415933132171631,
0.13223780691623688,
-0.08536308258771896,
0.168158158659935,
-0.09149489551782608,
0.1967059224843979,
0.0535476915538311,
0.32968446612358093,
0.3073092997074127,
-0.2177952229976654,
0.036893315613269806,
0.002141664968803525,
-0.2250818908214569,
0.2387647032737732,
-0.3232710659503937,
0.2132805436849594,
-0.1703745424747467,
0.08086059242486954,
-0.40565845370292664,
0.6604918837547302,
0.815788209438324,
-0.6064683198928833,
0.35219231247901917,
0.25912365317344666,
-0.7409888505935669,
0.07431983947753906,
0.16038671135902405,
-0.006718628574162722,
-0.3749018907546997,
0.877573549747467,
-0.19071900844573975,
-0.6048855185508728,
0.7342389822006226,
0.034042492508888245,
-0.06891574710607529,
0.47807949781417847,
0.6846839189529419,
-0.30182433128356934,
0.8976523280143738,
0.5618113279342651,
-0.5282809138298035,
0.3740755319595337,
-0.40776005387306213,
0.2535048723220825,
-0.7753279805183411,
-0.13527275621891022,
-0.6292504072189331,
0.03514570742845535,
-0.10877449810504913,
-0.052245430648326874,
0.6966361403465271,
-0.1713145226240158,
-0.17416390776634216,
0.16134701669216156,
-0.43425819277763367,
0.6125373244285583,
0.30012717843055725,
0.08501024544239044,
0.3660581707954407,
0.3409467935562134,
-0.09944542497396469,
0.0478266105055809,
-0.8776440620422363,
-0.2730303108692169,
0.5012078881263733,
0.634484052658081,
0.8252233862876892,
-0.3074078857898712,
0.9358242154121399,
0.27416616678237915,
0.28060591220855713,
-0.7679529190063477,
0.5010423064231873,
0.08356547355651855,
-0.21390707790851593,
-0.6314764618873596,
-0.6786535382270813,
-1.1608304977416992,
0.5165688991546631,
0.04588274657726288,
-0.8268107175827026,
0.020470140501856804,
0.01262443047016859,
-0.44077014923095703,
0.15643493831157684,
-0.6142833828926086,
0.9476969242095947,
-0.13318589329719543,
-0.5251020193099976,
-0.017115021124482155,
-1.0637681484222412,
0.07231885939836502,
0.18733005225658417,
0.4081178605556488,
0.038492877036333084,
0.3302416503429413,
0.979435920715332,
-0.36067742109298706,
0.9606581926345825,
0.06805066764354706,
-0.10969888418912888,
0.21241556107997894,
-0.08852849155664444,
0.5480234622955322,
0.14926275610923767,
-0.007208915892988443,
0.064039446413517,
-0.348086416721344,
-0.4100344479084015,
-0.42971882224082947,
0.917719841003418,
-0.8303077816963196,
-0.401856005191803,
-0.6505271792411804,
-1.0324822664260864,
-0.16452831029891968,
0.6473484635353088,
0.337003618478775,
0.5944936275482178,
-0.29027336835861206,
-0.17829445004463196,
0.3291676342487335,
0.46457639336586,
0.5179401636123657,
0.13324275612831116,
-0.1957063227891922,
-0.6276037096977234,
0.8084712028503418,
0.44893553853034973,
0.08531929552555084,
0.22224514186382294,
0.21696099638938904,
0.010823533870279789,
-0.5034164190292358,
-0.20213349163532257,
0.6825778484344482,
-0.7965953946113586,
-0.3256593346595764,
-1.037108063697815,
-0.409456342458725,
-0.9071281552314758,
-0.1630532592535019,
-0.09383825957775116,
-0.420490026473999,
-0.4969031810760498,
-0.1234673485159874,
-0.002912455005571246,
0.8119932413101196,
0.2028115689754486,
0.28515392541885376,
-0.8149473071098328,
0.6484569907188416,
-0.03717125579714775,
0.20027926564216614,
0.17855623364448547,
-0.4554179310798645,
-0.6380031108856201,
-0.30130788683891296,
-0.2763306200504303,
-0.83366858959198,
0.6126569509506226,
0.1633831411600113,
0.5290799140930176,
0.24779176712036133,
-0.07674676179885864,
0.4873082637786865,
-0.4525507092475891,
0.3767979145050049,
0.2011031210422516,
-0.5803516507148743,
0.6430099606513977,
-0.8017257452011108,
0.8484615683555603,
0.4168213903903961,
0.5363715887069702,
-0.43834978342056274,
-0.6785396933555603,
-0.5945374369621277,
-0.9746375679969788,
0.7286133170127869,
0.26805153489112854,
-0.2264350950717926,
-0.10370936244726181,
0.29106372594833374,
-0.13870008289813995,
0.07239733636379242,
-0.7877954244613647,
-0.1239238977432251,
-0.22050054371356964,
-0.33035340905189514,
-0.05243478715419769,
-0.1037636399269104,
-0.25037911534309387,
-0.3570808470249176,
0.7967886328697205,
-0.3165871500968933,
0.14019876718521118,
0.4217063784599304,
-0.1615041196346283,
-0.28666210174560547,
0.09583132714033127,
0.11708683520555496,
0.7944679260253906,
-0.47715839743614197,
0.3936464488506317,
-0.1536143571138382,
-0.45905065536499023,
-0.19392749667167664,
0.3476305902004242,
-0.3024396300315857,
-0.045631375163793564,
0.6492770314216614,
0.5839354991912842,
0.4936656355857849,
0.12772570550441742,
0.3116295337677002,
0.03879080340266228,
-0.35344842076301575,
0.17658820748329163,
-0.43860557675361633,
0.4285469949245453,
-0.0001797564182197675,
0.2710188627243042,
-0.030494332313537598,
0.248788982629776,
-0.5956814885139465,
0.06450238823890686,
0.02136274427175522,
-0.2292081117630005,
-0.1885463297367096,
0.612027108669281,
0.3482254445552826,
-0.18309076130390167,
0.4347454011440277,
-0.08042094856500626,
-0.6693713068962097,
0.8550439476966858,
1.0396450757980347,
0.6225326657295227,
0.08725092560052872,
0.45786717534065247,
0.5125200748443604,
0.1037251204252243,
0.30532366037368774,
-0.014222828671336174,
-0.20557422935962677,
-0.2833569347858429,
-0.24695801734924316,
-0.3803566098213196,
-0.5296607613563538,
-0.11675621569156647,
-0.616545557975769,
-0.1966969221830368,
-0.2319713681936264,
-0.22998395562171936,
0.5203430652618408,
0.06789935380220413,
0.009716551750898361,
0.13488903641700745,
0.06294853985309601,
0.677360475063324,
-0.739711582660675,
0.6940169930458069,
0.6330729722976685,
-0.4147157669067383,
-0.26016905903816223,
-0.012207451276481152,
-0.23897790908813477,
-0.2173207849264145,
0.513867974281311,
0.16663286089897156,
-0.3372589945793152,
0.20488138496875763,
-0.348370224237442,
-1.203369379043579,
0.8950931429862976,
0.32848915457725525,
-0.29991480708122253,
-0.551417887210846,
-0.10378380864858627,
0.6327234506607056,
-0.543074905872345,
0.09287906438112259,
0.2991187572479248,
0.38114336133003235,
-0.0512440949678421,
-0.46991780400276184,
-0.08207248896360397,
-0.6326212882995605,
-0.08513694256544113,
0.277228444814682,
-0.7250424027442932,
0.7375718355178833,
-0.3594326972961426,
-0.32042959332466125,
-0.05228360369801521,
1.1757917404174805,
0.06156843528151512,
0.5015798807144165,
0.21645991504192352,
0.5548999905586243,
0.8953670859336853,
0.06984352320432663,
1.0132721662521362,
-0.24047733843326569,
0.6357259154319763,
1.4381214380264282,
-0.6798292398452759,
0.4665463864803314,
0.46811941266059875,
0.03786899894475937,
0.3987082839012146,
0.6187081336975098,
-0.019670706242322922,
0.40979063510894775,
0.16868947446346283,
0.0008974240627139807,
-0.03554612398147583,
-0.25624993443489075,
-0.4684096574783325,
0.19598476588726044,
0.2617186903953552,
-0.286472350358963,
-0.6394675970077515,
0.08920309692621231,
0.1936311274766922,
0.21545545756816864,
-0.5013405680656433,
0.6861022710800171,
0.04580388590693474,
-0.7402081489562988,
0.5051624774932861,
-0.11039944738149643,
0.2267393320798874,
-0.6539620757102966,
0.08711288124322891,
-0.14296425879001617,
0.2096502184867859,
-0.35250163078308105,
-0.6673796772956848,
0.08763578534126282,
-0.04669187590479851,
-0.38834747672080994,
0.06363055109977722,
0.8562579154968262,
-0.43411174416542053,
-0.5695163011550903,
0.4946719706058502,
0.4156341552734375,
-0.061920005828142166,
0.22770054638385773,
-0.4933200776576996,
-0.3720596730709076,
-0.4375869929790497,
-0.46579477190971375,
0.20420826971530914,
0.37725263833999634,
-0.32280850410461426,
0.451375812292099,
0.27135512232780457,
0.10163629800081253,
-0.15292447805404663,
0.33607450127601624,
0.828732967376709,
-0.4632658064365387,
-1.1910165548324585,
-0.623759925365448,
0.05771002918481827,
-0.47310298681259155,
-0.316861093044281,
0.9989845752716064,
0.7556372284889221,
0.4032924771308899,
0.08064552396535873,
0.7408120036125183,
0.3471408486366272,
0.35801056027412415,
-0.27166128158569336,
0.8715333938598633,
-0.3212178349494934,
-0.30762505531311035,
-0.3875947892665863,
-0.8742020726203918,
-0.7249926328659058,
0.534282386302948,
-0.2692529261112213,
-0.0023898526560515165,
1.1636815071105957,
0.4750206768512726,
-0.18213202059268951,
0.10221116989850998,
-0.019685937091708183,
0.5377874374389648,
0.060241926461458206,
0.4489842653274536,
0.5687147378921509,
-0.13559596240520477,
0.3366873264312744,
-0.20298470556735992,
-0.419103741645813,
-0.12988165020942688,
-0.9406574368476868,
-0.9631077647209167,
-0.22828978300094604,
-0.5484187006950378,
-0.4106895923614502,
0.2231743186712265,
0.5672634243965149,
0.751945436000824,
-0.4079379737377167,
-0.2823018431663513,
-0.02092762663960457,
0.08675570040941238,
-0.08761735260486603,
-0.18477487564086914,
0.8956318497657776,
-0.2676335871219635,
-0.43832114338874817,
0.32756155729293823,
0.6599857807159424,
0.11148343235254288,
-0.1597624570131302,
-0.04150432348251343,
-0.6219087839126587,
0.01830555498600006,
0.6630644798278809,
0.4356839954853058,
-0.16102105379104614,
-0.18035361170768738,
-0.11371199786663055,
-0.41343316435813904,
0.46898767352104187,
0.8387608528137207,
-0.712074339389801,
0.2445916384458542,
0.626526951789856,
0.41901499032974243,
1.0915875434875488,
0.006647564470767975,
0.18852275609970093,
-0.8704934120178223,
-0.09005046635866165,
0.18501435220241547,
0.6572753190994263,
0.31090766191482544,
-0.7062782049179077,
0.6041014790534973,
0.27517053484916687,
-0.667686402797699,
-0.6137016415596008,
-0.046118445694446564,
-1.2022782564163208,
-0.26032981276512146,
0.8839523196220398,
-0.36262521147727966,
-0.8021661639213562,
0.05934872850775719,
-0.3251101076602936,
0.6775301098823547,
-0.30631178617477417,
0.8376170992851257,
0.5846271514892578,
-0.23848587274551392,
0.17478950321674347,
-0.052087366580963135,
-0.1043149009346962,
0.44923561811447144,
-1.389485478401184,
0.4378790855407715,
0.6250273585319519,
-0.15081918239593506,
0.5487073659896851,
0.839874804019928,
-0.4454854130744934,
0.4130803346633911,
-0.14834196865558624,
-0.08987854421138763,
-0.3438565731048584,
-0.730925440788269,
-0.24265040457248688,
0.5974878072738647,
-0.39536869525909424,
0.011926727369427681
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10166v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10166v1
|
LFED: A Literary Fiction Evaluation Dataset for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-16T15:02:24 | 2024-05-16T15:02:24 |
Linhao Yu, Qun Liu, Deyi Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.PF
|
The rapid evolution of large language models (LLMs) has ushered in the need
for comprehensive assessments of their performance across various dimensions.
In this paper, we propose LFED, a Literary Fiction Evaluation Dataset, which
aims to evaluate the capability of LLMs on the long fiction comprehension and
reasoning. We collect 95 literary fictions that are either originally written
in Chinese or translated into Chinese, covering a wide range of topics across
several centuries. We define a question taxonomy with 8 question categories to
guide the creation of 1,304 questions. Additionally, we conduct an in-depth
analysis to ascertain how specific attributes of literary fictions (e.g., novel
types, character numbers, the year of publication) impact LLM performance in
evaluations. Through a series of experiments with various state-of-the-art
LLMs, we demonstrate that these models face considerable challenges in
effectively addressing questions related to literary fictions, with ChatGPT
reaching only 57.08% under the zero-shot setting. The dataset will be publicly
available at https://github.com/tjunlp-lab/LFED.git
|
[
-0.0548323392868042,
-1.0487538576126099,
0.752042293548584,
0.19142872095108032,
-0.18023599684238434,
0.1528528332710266,
-0.4921838343143463,
-0.5369982719421387,
-0.010557536035776138,
0.6717463135719299,
-0.6256521940231323,
-0.38110509514808655,
-0.2509835362434387,
0.2793113887310028,
-0.5350803136825562,
0.8814963698387146,
-0.11437756568193436,
-0.1654331088066101,
-0.5927565693855286,
-0.07952602207660675,
-0.18668387830257416,
-0.2633409798145294,
-0.31170400977134705,
-0.4797615706920624,
0.9082518815994263,
0.015710046514868736,
0.7533894181251526,
0.42551684379577637,
0.5281121730804443,
0.28110429644584656,
0.05030067265033722,
0.31703975796699524,
-1.000105857849121,
0.0810517892241478,
-0.23892641067504883,
-0.2979046702384949,
-0.19923371076583862,
-0.03612639009952545,
0.8140398263931274,
0.6269064545631409,
0.16022852063179016,
0.18410056829452515,
-0.14667490124702454,
0.5003181099891663,
-0.35188716650009155,
0.1370927393436432,
-0.3530186712741852,
-0.021385006606578827,
-0.4227719008922577,
-0.21325555443763733,
-0.5684118866920471,
-0.5050703883171082,
0.0889190062880516,
-0.44325485825538635,
0.04347729682922363,
0.29246634244918823,
0.6602831482887268,
-0.05277968943119049,
-0.6964033842086792,
-0.15856976807117462,
-0.4344485402107239,
0.6455628871917725,
-0.6570203900337219,
0.20672693848609924,
0.1791055053472519,
0.026051675900816917,
-0.43283775448799133,
-0.7694208025932312,
-0.6418578624725342,
-0.549884021282196,
-0.24881267547607422,
0.12716452777385712,
-0.05596769228577614,
0.08132904767990112,
0.11296890676021576,
0.7391927242279053,
-0.7605096101760864,
0.2483520209789276,
-0.20686393976211548,
-0.23908324539661407,
0.8774169087409973,
0.5570507645606995,
0.21865350008010864,
-0.20877490937709808,
-0.47963541746139526,
0.2211599051952362,
-0.5807632207870483,
0.1620885282754898,
0.45438152551651,
0.1671692281961441,
-0.008820688351988792,
0.7019355893135071,
-0.09531273692846298,
0.7020092010498047,
-0.24128210544586182,
-0.3726999759674072,
0.2226385623216629,
-0.36001357436180115,
-0.3203006386756897,
-0.21542760729789734,
1.0276436805725098,
0.5574016571044922,
0.4654410779476166,
-0.2540818154811859,
-0.41286158561706543,
-0.03940358757972717,
0.02838917449116707,
-0.9161205887794495,
0.22094935178756714,
0.5021310448646545,
-0.19889017939567566,
-0.4440259337425232,
-0.30831587314605713,
-0.43040168285369873,
-1.1333643198013306,
-0.19046323001384735,
0.3883896470069885,
-0.3849153220653534,
-0.3573416769504547,
0.502055823802948,
-0.2589288353919983,
0.46923941373825073,
0.2632008194923401,
-0.7904258966445923,
-0.022720959037542343,
0.7339476346969604,
0.5842121839523315,
-0.558764636516571,
-0.5010762810707092,
-0.28062188625335693,
-0.059325072914361954,
-0.4698065221309662,
0.8679774403572083,
-0.2063317745923996,
-0.27584806084632874,
0.17795421183109283,
0.14488588273525238,
-0.2275395691394806,
-0.20818281173706055,
0.7312759757041931,
-0.5851069688796997,
0.0723404660820961,
-0.1251523345708847,
-0.8107407689094543,
-0.038229621946811676,
0.4900738000869751,
-0.9646741151809692,
0.8779126405715942,
0.25211629271507263,
-0.6768322587013245,
0.10715724527835846,
-0.2864013910293579,
-0.48281925916671753,
0.21112482249736786,
-0.22187450528144836,
-0.0896887332201004,
0.04778434708714485,
0.1967260241508484,
0.6109102368354797,
-0.8597049117088318,
0.6413382291793823,
-0.3585151135921478,
-0.6900252103805542,
0.5270739793777466,
-0.5208333134651184,
0.9192447662353516,
0.1918477863073349,
-0.10343971848487854,
0.21955260634422302,
-0.6714583039283752,
0.08237951248884201,
0.45597371459007263,
-0.193780317902565,
-0.12497109174728394,
-0.31717580556869507,
0.3715249300003052,
-0.4309960901737213,
0.43314671516418457,
-0.6554991006851196,
0.30578863620758057,
-0.331643670797348,
0.2961791753768921,
0.5760136842727661,
0.04407613351941109,
0.14712026715278625,
-0.6200927495956421,
0.6900023818016052,
-0.41451066732406616,
-0.2231743484735489,
-0.29099100828170776,
-0.12660594284534454,
-0.6569178104400635,
-0.3387743830680847,
0.32135021686553955,
0.4200246036052704,
-0.8844168186187744,
0.36937883496284485,
-0.2872924506664276,
-0.9073025584220886,
-0.20271433889865875,
0.06124461442232132,
0.15785224735736847,
0.22528620064258575,
-0.17223618924617767,
0.20550669729709625,
-0.019533369690179825,
-0.699409008026123,
-0.27457669377326965,
-0.4740334451198578,
0.09013877063989639,
0.10214138776063919,
0.4954882860183716,
-0.0715721920132637,
0.9892765879631042,
-0.42192378640174866,
-0.19950436055660248,
-0.7211098074913025,
-0.20444218814373016,
0.41827642917633057,
0.06258739531040192,
0.7123588919639587,
-0.4541264474391937,
-0.017226258292794228,
0.0798211470246315,
-0.9842678308486938,
-0.28160563111305237,
-0.318829208612442,
-0.1936608999967575,
0.020755285397171974,
0.4747370183467865,
-0.6304180026054382,
0.02081940323114395,
0.44474902749061584,
-0.6440659165382385,
0.9735906720161438,
0.16869400441646576,
0.26846063137054443,
-0.6581557393074036,
-0.02112875133752823,
-0.06537329405546188,
-0.2940720319747925,
-0.42564132809638977,
0.5592971444129944,
0.17181946337223053,
0.045872073620557785,
-0.5112680792808533,
0.908263623714447,
-0.30241015553474426,
0.24044692516326904,
0.00040467517101205885,
0.4607169032096863,
0.34667688608169556,
0.3565719723701477,
0.03289288654923439,
0.5954004526138306,
0.15291430056095123,
-0.17463256418704987,
0.8791413307189941,
0.006412621587514877,
-0.9674028158187866,
0.45747965574264526,
-0.533125102519989,
0.1371295005083084,
-0.09072582423686981,
0.31143611669540405,
-0.9116528034210205,
-0.30750206112861633,
-0.10512129217386246,
-0.06597790867090225,
0.20421260595321655,
0.20684830844402313,
-0.653382420539856,
-0.20088589191436768,
-0.31967228651046753,
0.4731636941432953,
0.0256766676902771,
-0.45763295888900757,
0.6751230955123901,
0.08638148754835129,
-0.04053899645805359,
-0.6558657288551331,
-0.5917337536811829,
-0.030498115345835686,
-0.35485661029815674,
-0.8905089497566223,
-0.03474656119942665,
-0.4146048128604889,
-0.45875856280326843,
-0.11386378109455109,
0.2557816207408905,
0.15213556587696075,
0.03912177309393883,
-0.15167933702468872,
0.3441624045372009,
-0.415777325630188,
0.35618260502815247,
-0.07571563869714737,
0.3562124967575073,
0.1567765176296234,
0.07829736173152924,
0.5010363459587097,
-0.22360272705554962,
-0.19315481185913086,
0.12320362031459808,
0.07450523227453232,
0.49503904581069946,
-0.277864009141922,
0.5250638127326965,
0.6152165532112122,
-0.2527522146701813,
-0.5533815026283264,
-0.520282506942749,
0.33282017707824707,
-0.44880667328834534,
0.6143079400062561,
-0.4347873628139496,
-1.0489318370819092,
0.4863932132720947,
0.16993649303913116,
0.20375347137451172,
0.6738594770431519,
0.8579067587852478,
-0.03998209908604622,
-0.024528715759515762,
0.445160448551178,
-0.06751354783773422,
0.22315457463264465,
-0.30809223651885986,
-0.005005552899092436,
-0.33237287402153015,
-0.12010769546031952,
-0.2513076663017273,
-0.13569115102291107,
-0.15768739581108093,
-0.5196195244789124,
0.11256097257137299,
-0.14886373281478882,
-0.21871553361415863,
0.1817513406276703,
0.1315227597951889,
0.7922194004058838,
-0.029841287061572075,
-0.07167582958936691,
0.7910468578338623,
-0.1226106807589531,
-0.1026308462023735,
0.14540253579616547,
-0.37435129284858704,
-0.49830782413482666,
1.1094121932983398,
0.6908951997756958,
0.9719331860542297,
0.24855729937553406,
0.5243492126464844,
0.6241595149040222,
0.2635355293750763,
-1.1296323537826538,
0.5483495593070984,
0.08128547668457031,
-1.017918586730957,
-0.5809215903282166,
-0.48973333835601807,
-0.7744958996772766,
0.3912074565887451,
-0.09539399296045303,
-0.585547685623169,
0.15044668316841125,
-0.5442866086959839,
-0.4432445466518402,
0.18926924467086792,
-0.5353459119796753,
0.9039112329483032,
-0.5558769702911377,
-0.4394691288471222,
-0.03229296952486038,
-0.15486782789230347,
0.745903491973877,
-0.5229175090789795,
0.22307828068733215,
-0.30708712339401245,
-0.031011052429676056,
0.7722136974334717,
-0.13426893949508667,
0.6616111993789673,
0.23967579007148743,
-0.5609679222106934,
0.602460503578186,
0.2266606241464615,
0.2702658772468567,
0.19669465720653534,
-0.6244977712631226,
0.14849789440631866,
0.5128024816513062,
-0.2705255448818207,
-0.5578434467315674,
0.6765159368515015,
-0.6198292970657349,
-0.5049425363540649,
-0.6844215393066406,
-0.9509590268135071,
-0.5087537169456482,
0.2768135070800781,
0.12667812407016754,
0.6513841152191162,
-0.7494109869003296,
0.36253705620765686,
0.2727406620979309,
-0.32665741443634033,
0.47378429770469666,
0.5551643967628479,
-0.9130265116691589,
-0.24918708205223083,
0.6567396521568298,
-0.058388035744428635,
0.4859376847743988,
0.18411141633987427,
0.11265543848276138,
-0.4412800669670105,
-0.691825270652771,
-0.68812096118927,
0.3845956027507782,
-0.8814422488212585,
-0.142039492726326,
-0.27809131145477295,
-0.3601757287979126,
-0.07461590319871902,
-0.13091471791267395,
-0.04439156502485275,
-0.1453920155763626,
-0.18480248749256134,
-0.37231212854385376,
0.4140630066394806,
0.8303987979888916,
0.47640642523765564,
0.28816890716552734,
-0.5039323568344116,
0.2845075726509094,
-0.2138863056898117,
0.6078163385391235,
-0.13140256702899933,
-0.7705135941505432,
-0.3924381136894226,
-0.2574792504310608,
-0.15118308365345,
-0.547391414642334,
0.18126897513866425,
0.1981332004070282,
0.4230174720287323,
0.31639936566352844,
0.47338172793388367,
0.45884570479393005,
-0.3673914074897766,
0.8718845248222351,
0.11366816610097885,
-0.679065465927124,
-0.0652243047952652,
-0.7164097428321838,
0.31872767210006714,
0.5726231932640076,
0.2612145245075226,
-0.382354199886322,
-0.41174378991127014,
-0.2182515263557434,
-0.438003271818161,
0.4793299734592438,
0.1477225124835968,
0.3142852485179901,
0.08789294958114624,
0.09792391955852509,
0.2847725450992584,
0.030111655592918396,
-1.0038734674453735,
-0.181650772690773,
0.313907653093338,
-0.26127129793167114,
-0.458898663520813,
-0.30124589800834656,
-0.12041625380516052,
-0.22586610913276672,
0.47023797035217285,
-0.23362357914447784,
-0.060614608228206635,
0.08222254365682602,
-0.3369540572166443,
-0.056149158626794815,
0.2808346152305603,
0.23389621078968048,
0.8669896721839905,
-0.37401777505874634,
-0.2626440227031708,
0.0813305601477623,
-0.4699481129646301,
0.1136375367641449,
0.1807604730129242,
-0.18084755539894104,
-0.1567816287279129,
0.9189687967300415,
0.8233077526092529,
-0.1391047239303589,
-1.0998183488845825,
0.6122289896011353,
-0.13312825560569763,
-0.23518826067447662,
-0.6834133863449097,
0.044003646820783615,
0.29018840193748474,
0.5399341583251953,
0.303291916847229,
-0.5864492058753967,
-0.02409585379064083,
-0.7708351016044617,
-0.01387045532464981,
0.3389877676963806,
-0.11307604610919952,
0.24914149940013885,
0.2268635481595993,
0.27846622467041016,
0.13439401984214783,
0.3841494917869568,
-0.1752440333366394,
-0.2866889536380768,
0.673850953578949,
0.6021059155464172,
0.6597915887832642,
0.36511144042015076,
0.2663675546646118,
0.15819424390792847,
0.6786219477653503,
0.1437481790781021,
0.08900584280490875,
0.2682396471500397,
-0.7918838262557983,
-0.4012492597103119,
-1.122828722000122,
-0.3762573003768921,
0.4902251958847046,
-0.16075639426708221,
0.5853920578956604,
-0.5061161518096924,
0.015566323883831501,
-0.13536472618579865,
0.2465847134590149,
-0.4723231792449951,
0.21316584944725037,
0.33125126361846924,
1.130369782447815,
-0.5393139719963074,
0.6991518139839172,
0.23566721379756927,
-0.44835180044174194,
-0.5187349915504456,
0.007565612439066172,
-0.04056912288069725,
-0.5270317196846008,
0.08906729519367218,
0.18023142218589783,
-0.13573896884918213,
0.0034613641910254955,
-0.4050162732601166,
-0.8279189467430115,
1.248995304107666,
0.6219860315322876,
-0.6990078091621399,
-0.011608739383518696,
0.37625277042388916,
0.7199198007583618,
-0.6212167143821716,
0.5128071308135986,
1.0267338752746582,
0.5494693517684937,
0.08534735441207886,
-0.9549899101257324,
-0.010129923932254314,
-0.3092958331108093,
-0.43150603771209717,
-0.06834778934717178,
-0.7867965698242188,
0.5355327725410461,
-0.3423597812652588,
-0.19702795147895813,
0.5126173496246338,
0.7638201117515564,
0.3288712799549103,
0.600147008895874,
0.5523017048835754,
0.25734609365463257,
0.8793643116950989,
-0.3183653950691223,
1.3185323476791382,
0.16164545714855194,
0.33118757605552673,
0.8518887758255005,
-0.4100974500179291,
0.7082546949386597,
0.12551529705524445,
-0.23643086850643158,
0.3832888901233673,
0.836197555065155,
-0.21199451386928558,
0.12150311470031738,
0.5813916921615601,
-0.25364235043525696,
-0.40247389674186707,
-0.17582179605960846,
-0.40945884585380554,
0.5710447430610657,
0.22543267905712128,
-0.41474324464797974,
-0.041871778666973114,
0.06237765774130821,
0.07791999727487564,
0.1705867350101471,
-0.37792274355888367,
0.5645865201950073,
0.18568558990955353,
-0.6038922071456909,
0.7457225918769836,
0.09162011742591858,
0.6011376976966858,
-0.6923134922981262,
0.36397168040275574,
-0.4481690227985382,
0.1912260204553604,
-0.27030012011528015,
-1.0012729167938232,
-0.08867577463388443,
0.11159076541662216,
-0.16261015832424164,
0.16968294978141785,
0.5970003604888916,
-0.4942462146282196,
-0.8908070921897888,
0.42310988903045654,
0.5306451916694641,
0.3105751872062683,
0.06000503897666931,
-0.2664003074169159,
0.4537942111492157,
0.025615276768803596,
-0.550855815410614,
0.2381644994020462,
0.6342800855636597,
-0.08657138794660568,
0.5800244212150574,
0.5514744520187378,
0.05426029860973358,
-0.2793063521385193,
0.27241405844688416,
0.7040069103240967,
-0.8700135350227356,
-0.35782188177108765,
-0.7162225246429443,
0.47827810049057007,
0.08478942513465881,
-0.40908437967300415,
0.465023934841156,
0.5175223350524902,
0.4582464396953583,
-0.16871537268161774,
0.8645850419998169,
-0.1340971291065216,
0.30395352840423584,
-0.6094579100608826,
1.0758565664291382,
-0.6701262593269348,
0.4246217906475067,
-0.3377237319946289,
-0.9807536005973816,
-0.10221050679683685,
0.1438368856906891,
-0.3978039622306824,
0.029033780097961426,
0.9726539850234985,
0.7169934511184692,
0.15056847035884857,
0.28548958897590637,
0.6947163343429565,
0.31149590015411377,
0.26311609148979187,
0.6521662473678589,
1.1692792177200317,
-0.3844999372959137,
0.4859154224395752,
0.002910515060648322,
-0.13096554577350616,
0.09864658117294312,
-1.1362535953521729,
-1.246217131614685,
-0.43509939312934875,
-0.09738756716251373,
-0.30794277787208557,
-0.14739738404750824,
0.7542724013328552,
-0.0911388248205185,
-0.5504730939865112,
-0.48643356561660767,
0.6768351793289185,
0.1865823119878769,
0.16504071652889252,
-0.19917190074920654,
0.45006176829338074,
-0.2984318137168884,
-0.7846776247024536,
0.5662931203842163,
-0.08137442916631699,
-0.49250105023384094,
-0.570241391658783,
-0.1328577697277069,
-0.17783650755882263,
0.44875848293304443,
0.7671085596084595,
-0.19132216274738312,
-0.8345968723297119,
-0.2136484533548355,
-0.0262741856276989,
-0.25036317110061646,
-0.350635826587677,
0.7686886787414551,
-0.6702040433883667,
0.353053480386734,
0.36793336272239685,
0.8015841245651245,
0.4035843312740326,
-0.1320262849330902,
0.6110977530479431,
-0.4114497900009155,
-0.0346798337996006,
0.2470485270023346,
0.6105439066886902,
0.33982810378074646,
-0.4987030029296875,
0.713421642780304,
0.36128732562065125,
-0.6356139779090881,
-0.9312419891357422,
0.007212615571916103,
-1.2186965942382812,
-0.21024902164936066,
1.511836290359497,
-0.22734934091567993,
-0.25275060534477234,
-0.013617333956062794,
-0.4030577540397644,
-0.20114390552043915,
-0.14229640364646912,
0.2549372613430023,
1.1714961528778076,
0.07408612966537476,
-0.24876084923744202,
-0.5369956493377686,
0.2795497179031372,
0.209889218211174,
-0.8003009557723999,
0.4901227653026581,
0.9298650622367859,
0.3083353638648987,
-0.11127179861068726,
0.6625626087188721,
-0.15185193717479706,
0.17682474851608276,
-0.16390611231327057,
-0.04436279088258743,
-0.3350335657596588,
-0.17979326844215393,
-0.24670065939426422,
0.39251840114593506,
0.10670816153287888,
0.5199199318885803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10150v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10150v2
|
Speaker Verification in Agent-Generated Conversations
| 2024-05-16T14:46:18 | 2024-06-06T03:36:16 |
Yizhe Yang, Palakorn Achananuparp, Heyan Huang, Jing Jiang, Ee-Peng Lim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The recent success of large language models (LLMs) has attracted widespread
interest to develop role-playing conversational agents personalized to the
characteristics and styles of different speakers to enhance their abilities to
perform both general and special purpose dialogue tasks. However, the ability
to personalize the generated utterances to speakers, whether conducted by human
or LLM, has not been well studied. To bridge this gap, our study introduces a
novel evaluation challenge: speaker verification in agent-generated
conversations, which aimed to verify whether two sets of utterances originate
from the same speaker. To this end, we assemble a large dataset collection
encompassing thousands of speakers and their utterances. We also develop and
evaluate speaker verification models under experiment setups. We further
utilize the speaker verification models to evaluate the personalization
abilities of LLM-based role-playing models. Comprehensive experiments suggest
that the current role-playing models fail in accurately mimicking speakers,
primarily due to their inherent linguistic characteristics.
|
[
-0.2892603576183319,
-0.8784896731376648,
0.6420320272445679,
0.037801433354616165,
0.07138443738222122,
0.2699989080429077,
-0.24417728185653687,
-0.5494644641876221,
0.18357791006565094,
0.9316623210906982,
-0.7101014852523804,
-0.344875305891037,
-0.31682538986206055,
0.35607489943504333,
-0.3065425455570221,
0.6855149269104004,
0.5762677192687988,
0.020128250122070312,
-0.49393031001091003,
0.04243023693561554,
-0.7590165138244629,
-0.37047427892684937,
-0.6465100049972534,
-0.7825401425361633,
0.25279656052589417,
0.3588632047176361,
0.6664836406707764,
0.3554648160934448,
0.10665903240442276,
0.48411864042282104,
-0.17918814718723297,
0.6606784462928772,
-0.5056425333023071,
0.411329060792923,
-0.26849931478500366,
-0.20398454368114471,
-0.4815394878387451,
0.05740106478333473,
0.7157337665557861,
0.505292534828186,
-0.16823872923851013,
-0.060443539172410965,
-0.0920751616358757,
0.052686888724565506,
-0.17918136715888977,
0.21449914574623108,
-0.9726405143737793,
-0.1046653538942337,
0.024974696338176727,
-0.5554729700088501,
-0.799734354019165,
-0.34169453382492065,
0.2042255997657776,
-0.3472292721271515,
0.36886951327323914,
-0.14980575442314148,
0.7265035510063171,
-0.1580859273672104,
-0.7304901480674744,
-0.4381059408187866,
-1.2142246961593628,
0.4551975131034851,
-0.682826578617096,
0.12133673578500748,
0.3747183382511139,
0.5416640043258667,
-0.4317515194416046,
-0.34873420000076294,
-0.6108922958374023,
-0.7588373422622681,
-0.03002520464360714,
-0.1699206531047821,
0.05969839543104172,
0.045750461518764496,
0.28084811568260193,
0.28502199053764343,
-0.4380485415458679,
0.17071813344955444,
-0.013265050947666168,
-0.14929503202438354,
0.8468288779258728,
0.2542206943035126,
0.3685642182826996,
-0.051908597350120544,
-0.3467269539833069,
-0.2828808128833771,
-0.5842432975769043,
0.06686893850564957,
0.7689385414123535,
0.5241909623146057,
0.05603596568107605,
0.4787706136703491,
-0.34202736616134644,
0.4387575387954712,
0.15045419335365295,
-0.20590201020240784,
0.1491800844669342,
-0.4078395366668701,
0.05248809978365898,
0.17103736102581024,
0.6189237833023071,
0.25721409916877747,
0.5605517029762268,
-0.2404477745294571,
-0.20045074820518494,
-0.2966427505016327,
0.1846306025981903,
-0.5232760310173035,
0.0496072880923748,
0.2217503935098648,
-0.21374604105949402,
-0.4135602116584778,
0.11124750971794128,
-0.45340004563331604,
-0.7984179258346558,
-0.025283223018050194,
0.44206106662750244,
-0.10748489946126938,
-0.3812277019023895,
-0.06871998310089111,
-0.012335048988461494,
0.2887742817401886,
0.3109743595123291,
-0.8849515318870544,
0.4041292667388916,
0.8942875862121582,
0.24120043218135834,
-0.02618076279759407,
-0.4139712154865265,
-0.7413477897644043,
0.09488007426261902,
-0.49804648756980896,
0.8228362798690796,
-0.6447047591209412,
-0.5770305395126343,
0.2393728345632553,
-0.03756531700491905,
0.08910050988197327,
-0.7215458154678345,
0.3438348174095154,
-0.482866108417511,
-0.03940136358141899,
-0.5299568772315979,
-0.6604936718940735,
0.28700101375579834,
0.40382716059684753,
-0.32655999064445496,
0.5991109609603882,
0.07270641624927521,
-0.38675132393836975,
0.25496694445610046,
-0.3321700692176819,
-0.30255335569381714,
0.5642802715301514,
-0.613002359867096,
-0.2977590560913086,
-0.019584141671657562,
-0.05746714770793915,
0.46159517765045166,
-0.40858033299446106,
0.27215078473091125,
-0.1655617654323578,
-0.4656463861465454,
0.8108873963356018,
-0.4135702848434448,
0.44810178875923157,
-0.05051983892917633,
-0.29377317428588867,
0.10313934832811356,
-0.813849925994873,
-0.09818366169929504,
0.45785704255104065,
-0.13472352921962738,
-0.04989010840654373,
0.21803073585033417,
-0.07738279551267624,
-0.09214136004447937,
0.15942032635211945,
-0.8045364022254944,
0.00007604495476698503,
-0.5520506501197815,
0.1615392565727234,
0.9515031576156616,
0.36951056122779846,
0.14938749372959137,
-0.48199546337127686,
0.509030282497406,
-0.16981922090053558,
-0.06968788802623749,
-0.4535326659679413,
-0.466228723526001,
-0.5418785810470581,
-0.13573484122753143,
0.10617481917142868,
0.45904722809791565,
-0.6392612457275391,
0.5911672115325928,
-0.2564922273159027,
-0.5162898302078247,
-0.12030859291553497,
-0.03279399499297142,
0.6340545415878296,
0.31355470418930054,
-0.122588612139225,
-0.39089301228523254,
-0.31382647156715393,
-1.10897696018219,
-0.2656329274177551,
-0.5916403532028198,
-0.15910132229328156,
0.9428674578666687,
0.2086288183927536,
-0.3550272285938263,
1.1449023485183716,
-0.3393532633781433,
0.004154591355472803,
-0.2583398222923279,
-0.11603265255689621,
0.0019122298108413815,
0.40306562185287476,
0.5399091243743896,
-0.583806574344635,
-0.5145899653434753,
0.18373386561870575,
-0.5222488641738892,
-0.35663506388664246,
-0.3836091458797455,
0.24018990993499756,
-0.04449709504842758,
0.3356035649776459,
-0.6240025162696838,
0.2800622880458832,
0.44876110553741455,
-0.6376915574073792,
0.7038562893867493,
-0.2767433524131775,
0.3263075649738312,
-0.9042065739631653,
-0.057747747749090195,
-0.16620533168315887,
-0.46084627509117126,
-0.8044874668121338,
-0.21108290553092957,
-0.4798000454902649,
-0.1958472728729248,
-0.2730065584182739,
0.8487844467163086,
-0.3939168155193329,
-0.36769115924835205,
-0.4604596197605133,
0.40516161918640137,
-0.03807403892278671,
0.34914931654930115,
-0.15008355677127838,
0.7466197609901428,
0.37019121646881104,
-0.5224931240081787,
0.6300861835479736,
0.534878671169281,
-0.5868449211120605,
0.7070936560630798,
-0.7845629453659058,
0.5692525506019592,
-0.02844638004899025,
0.32011473178863525,
-1.1981143951416016,
-0.25808870792388916,
0.23775015771389008,
-0.33168312907218933,
0.2523203194141388,
-0.18966853618621826,
-0.5758434534072876,
-0.07649394869804382,
0.17780999839305878,
0.32096579670906067,
0.4894276559352875,
-0.5681746006011963,
0.6138914227485657,
0.2506203055381775,
-0.4689876437187195,
-0.37226954102516174,
-0.3214423358440399,
0.19522735476493835,
0.004812766797840595,
-0.8286870718002319,
0.2157294601202011,
-0.32626473903656006,
-0.4900904595851898,
-0.5221367478370667,
0.029934829100966454,
0.2317630648612976,
0.143980011343956,
0.33897945284843445,
-0.07112640887498856,
-0.02707703411579132,
0.1256662905216217,
-0.12007402628660202,
0.02347840927541256,
0.034109294414520264,
0.2071017324924469,
0.6658665537834167,
0.04498136788606644,
-0.8339800834655762,
-0.5096070766448975,
0.49553704261779785,
0.3025219440460205,
-0.2924228608608246,
0.5272538661956787,
0.4476470947265625,
-0.0791233479976654,
-0.4511832594871521,
-0.9937736392021179,
-0.4690849483013153,
-0.5578612089157104,
0.49432116746902466,
-0.5297704339027405,
-0.8945385217666626,
0.7283316850662231,
0.03613543137907982,
0.001219172147102654,
0.045995671302080154,
0.5654045939445496,
0.19605648517608643,
1.0250574350357056,
0.348875492811203,
0.27595263719558716,
0.43999454379081726,
0.17729038000106812,
0.08257123827934265,
-0.47417208552360535,
-0.46703463792800903,
-0.6326886415481567,
0.012949848547577858,
-0.8457948565483093,
-0.3295890986919403,
0.045081302523612976,
-0.5694186091423035,
0.0864652544260025,
0.20613840222358704,
-0.27316123247146606,
0.6967597603797913,
0.3929010033607483,
0.1545209139585495,
0.22512055933475494,
0.03573038801550865,
-0.014673346653580666,
0.33172693848609924,
-0.1540759652853012,
-0.9327875375747681,
0.826097846031189,
0.5376313328742981,
0.43315789103507996,
0.217269629240036,
0.7489580512046814,
0.6973246932029724,
-0.0931142121553421,
-0.6322323679924011,
1.0172146558761597,
0.14643342792987823,
-0.5718279480934143,
-0.5825080275535583,
-0.6197981834411621,
-1.0121824741363525,
0.3725932836532593,
-0.17525139451026917,
-1.0478436946868896,
0.18839207291603088,
0.10386764258146286,
-0.11973454058170319,
-0.03185132518410683,
-0.48827922344207764,
0.6911556720733643,
-0.09750913828611374,
0.011572877876460552,
-0.30304181575775146,
-0.4134645164012909,
0.1384614259004593,
0.046254511922597885,
0.014855077490210533,
-0.44580700993537903,
0.282186895608902,
0.38441821932792664,
-0.3159913420677185,
0.8230891227722168,
-0.19304504990577698,
-0.30203741788864136,
0.34755897521972656,
0.2826685309410095,
0.7859334945678711,
0.2424786388874054,
-0.2209547609090805,
-0.0748039111495018,
-0.043710894882678986,
-0.3417975604534149,
-0.5005478858947754,
0.6815133690834045,
-0.8957769274711609,
-1.0091618299484253,
-0.13942980766296387,
-0.3367778956890106,
-0.5023756623268127,
-0.011199290864169598,
0.05043536052107811,
0.501454770565033,
-1.0333467721939087,
0.16737999022006989,
0.6199929118156433,
-0.33680295944213867,
0.3286227881908417,
0.7609859704971313,
-0.15096116065979004,
-0.3237178921699524,
0.8678862452507019,
-0.29171493649482727,
0.3174370527267456,
0.2642348110675812,
0.2279646396636963,
-0.02249513566493988,
-0.6086668372154236,
-0.23121124505996704,
0.3645492196083069,
-0.6865066885948181,
0.1863575428724289,
-0.4089856743812561,
-0.27724894881248474,
-0.5438169240951538,
0.18635323643684387,
-0.4809143841266632,
-0.09208859503269196,
-0.23447901010513306,
-0.09839940816164017,
-0.08121300488710403,
0.9926315546035767,
0.22562000155448914,
0.5101644396781921,
-0.7174181938171387,
0.15023815631866455,
0.8608459830284119,
0.16689170897006989,
-0.1275283247232437,
-0.6938209533691406,
-0.08528367429971695,
0.18678641319274902,
-0.3848418891429901,
-0.9771596789360046,
0.25337257981300354,
0.3247026205062866,
0.917506992816925,
0.6404796242713928,
-0.10868249088525772,
0.19703611731529236,
-0.5582984089851379,
1.008437991142273,
-0.11004513502120972,
-0.8834413290023804,
0.5198544263839722,
-0.5496010780334473,
0.1597926914691925,
0.30863437056541443,
-0.2722274959087372,
-0.5875621438026428,
-0.4390009343624115,
-0.7825603485107422,
-0.4836401045322418,
0.9317538142204285,
0.5782063603401184,
0.5483396649360657,
-0.11690358072519302,
0.29714059829711914,
0.1961701512336731,
0.14922074973583221,
-0.4238482713699341,
-0.20579233765602112,
0.08538234233856201,
0.3134910762310028,
-0.6634443402290344,
-0.6905457377433777,
-0.3288287818431854,
0.348215788602829,
0.5331873893737793,
-0.2083628922700882,
0.22947239875793457,
0.15938539803028107,
0.11012796312570572,
-0.15831147134304047,
0.468784362077713,
0.9725512266159058,
0.6136966347694397,
-0.2785762548446655,
0.06665264815092087,
0.14504091441631317,
0.04148421809077263,
0.15533946454524994,
0.008793478831648827,
0.0336931087076664,
0.1893858164548874,
0.4164448380470276,
0.8983229994773865,
-0.039017777889966965,
-0.783568263053894,
0.7023354768753052,
-0.1843782216310501,
-0.07582517713308334,
-0.486614853143692,
0.16461318731307983,
0.10312248766422272,
0.5189599990844727,
0.3837771415710449,
-0.11150472611188889,
0.05708342418074608,
-0.6485733985900879,
0.11472136527299881,
0.5609448552131653,
-0.11765184253454208,
-0.5767338275909424,
0.2981559634208679,
0.4380299746990204,
-1.0111013650894165,
0.5502669811248779,
-0.2519943118095398,
-0.3287479877471924,
0.8462815284729004,
0.5245031714439392,
1.1614688634872437,
-0.5522125363349915,
0.3802366852760315,
0.0016907094977796078,
0.1143018901348114,
0.14264822006225586,
0.030678516253829002,
-0.30454021692276,
-1.1121808290481567,
-0.05782106891274452,
-0.31982046365737915,
-0.8121662735939026,
0.05486150085926056,
-0.38605231046676636,
0.1774778664112091,
-0.1912177950143814,
-0.3982808589935303,
0.02084181271493435,
0.06382672488689423,
-0.572364091873169,
-0.07439421117305756,
0.41206321120262146,
0.5097719430923462,
-1.0744832754135132,
0.6333731412887573,
0.5992447137832642,
0.00789529550820589,
-0.4993164837360382,
-0.05073849856853485,
-0.15170618891716003,
-0.6059815883636475,
0.5053138732910156,
0.11642520874738693,
-0.15484565496444702,
-0.235816091299057,
-0.4548419415950775,
-0.43712055683135986,
1.0569400787353516,
0.4622516334056854,
-0.4058874845504761,
0.035921093076467514,
0.5531661510467529,
0.6833491325378418,
-0.7050793766975403,
0.5692347884178162,
0.4063703119754791,
0.2564937472343445,
0.49843326210975647,
-1.239290475845337,
-0.1444580852985382,
-0.2256142795085907,
0.28921225666999817,
-0.37644079327583313,
-0.7235012650489807,
0.6847612261772156,
-0.06504176557064056,
-0.027887435629963875,
0.25834929943084717,
0.7785512208938599,
0.7013142108917236,
0.3028215765953064,
0.7896588444709778,
-0.08982432633638382,
0.7682733535766602,
0.14590542018413544,
0.8441459536552429,
-0.2170841544866562,
0.030210532248020172,
1.4225456714630127,
-0.7016843557357788,
0.47747355699539185,
0.2505425214767456,
0.019542081281542778,
0.3727070093154907,
0.4484744369983673,
-0.10720238834619522,
0.17874640226364136,
0.3351973593235016,
-0.3583196997642517,
-0.5628376603126526,
-0.37990105152130127,
-0.24966108798980713,
0.8597861528396606,
0.14879798889160156,
-0.45074784755706787,
0.09450971335172653,
-0.05647435039281845,
-0.3412225544452667,
0.3734358251094818,
0.04990529268980026,
0.8933183550834656,
-0.04449257254600525,
-0.794636607170105,
0.17980501055717468,
0.03962693363428116,
0.2708035111427307,
-0.5663679242134094,
-0.20788735151290894,
-0.3261539340019226,
0.24628396332263947,
0.012056484818458557,
-0.3842989206314087,
-0.16030611097812653,
-0.11436855047941208,
0.02272803522646427,
-0.4404854476451874,
0.7485605478286743,
-0.4653984308242798,
-0.08015310019254684,
0.19728723168373108,
0.5612599849700928,
0.3458307981491089,
0.01664735935628414,
-0.23046337068080902,
0.13330453634262085,
0.02601712942123413,
-0.3601346015930176,
0.25274595618247986,
0.2355595976114273,
0.019140426069498062,
0.8529665470123291,
0.4420386254787445,
0.31142547726631165,
-0.05179455876350403,
0.4034893214702606,
0.617946207523346,
-0.39614009857177734,
-0.4618750810623169,
-0.8301878571510315,
0.34666013717651367,
-0.13989193737506866,
-0.19253785908222198,
0.7712145447731018,
0.5144622325897217,
0.704153299331665,
-0.38657161593437195,
0.5733851790428162,
0.3294496238231659,
0.591516375541687,
-0.17373864352703094,
0.590857207775116,
-0.17125220596790314,
0.6096899509429932,
-0.4027908742427826,
-0.9038218259811401,
0.38328269124031067,
0.34820371866226196,
-0.1384126991033554,
0.36144956946372986,
0.26600325107574463,
1.1342896223068237,
0.11748126894235611,
0.03028234653174877,
0.763594388961792,
0.15273235738277435,
0.6451355218887329,
0.2836788594722748,
1.3166447877883911,
-0.29665130376815796,
0.4580821990966797,
0.06988592445850372,
-0.06954595446586609,
-0.4279090166091919,
-0.7829310297966003,
-1.0835322141647339,
-0.616746187210083,
-0.5738216042518616,
-0.3945859968662262,
0.09476754069328308,
1.0721005201339722,
0.6336859464645386,
-0.6836051940917969,
-0.5927799940109253,
0.18926399946212769,
0.16763879358768463,
-0.1814470887184143,
-0.16326016187667847,
-0.06719616055488586,
0.00700808223336935,
-0.8947120308876038,
0.9208835363388062,
0.05405692011117935,
0.1732110232114792,
-0.38079187273979187,
-0.2299637496471405,
0.08996159583330154,
0.7322115302085876,
0.4228450357913971,
0.41061484813690186,
-0.9816833734512329,
-0.5354098081588745,
-0.18860362470149994,
-0.34180206060409546,
0.013227398507297039,
0.7665068507194519,
-0.5893860459327698,
0.5937369465827942,
0.5212891101837158,
0.3767436742782593,
0.4191032350063324,
0.16422557830810547,
0.7606200575828552,
-0.977811336517334,
0.009348963387310505,
0.23447804152965546,
0.16927191615104675,
0.36877551674842834,
-0.4097502529621124,
0.2645535171031952,
0.12007609009742737,
-0.80326908826828,
-1.179940938949585,
0.46094128489494324,
-1.1796404123306274,
0.14040140807628632,
1.4073139429092407,
-0.31630390882492065,
0.20209439098834991,
0.05146097391843796,
-0.3391803205013275,
0.23568955063819885,
-0.3975324332714081,
0.6582712531089783,
0.577861487865448,
-0.12915170192718506,
-0.23255176842212677,
-0.15184436738491058,
0.47603821754455566,
0.3110150992870331,
-0.7323564291000366,
0.09548501670360565,
0.3734326958656311,
0.27511802315711975,
0.224837526679039,
0.7314520478248596,
0.26041126251220703,
0.1934967190027237,
0.05897658318281174,
0.19992296397686005,
-0.2925734221935272,
-0.258800208568573,
-0.23145179450511932,
0.2626076638698578,
0.5297948718070984,
-0.08194791525602341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10138v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10138v1
|
PL-MTEB: Polish Massive Text Embedding Benchmark
| 2024-05-16T14:33:39 | 2024-05-16T14:33:39 |
Rafał Poświata, Sławomir Dadas, Michał Perełkiewicz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce the Polish Massive Text Embedding Benchmark
(PL-MTEB), a comprehensive benchmark for text embeddings in Polish. The PL-MTEB
consists of 28 diverse NLP tasks from 5 task types. We adapted the tasks based
on previously used datasets by the Polish NLP community. In addition, we
created a new PLSC (Polish Library of Science Corpus) dataset consisting of
titles and abstracts of scientific publications in Polish, which was used as
the basis for two novel clustering tasks. We evaluated 15 publicly available
models for text embedding, including Polish and multilingual ones, and
collected detailed results for individual tasks and aggregated results for each
task type and the entire benchmark. PL-MTEB comes with open-source code at
https://github.com/rafalposwiata/pl-mteb.
|
[
-0.4282219409942627,
-0.6895454525947571,
0.6967175006866455,
0.5165396928787231,
-0.46789121627807617,
0.16253681480884552,
-0.32689622044563293,
-0.22229956090450287,
0.3183732330799103,
0.507182776927948,
-0.43564945459365845,
-1.0382330417633057,
-0.6145533919334412,
0.3827473521232605,
-0.3785833716392517,
0.7248241901397705,
-0.25728416442871094,
0.20157568156719208,
-0.460687518119812,
-0.21033039689064026,
-0.41360801458358765,
-0.585258960723877,
0.03850296884775162,
0.18832813203334808,
0.4050748944282532,
0.2776159346103668,
0.282905250787735,
0.5078079104423523,
0.8277523517608643,
0.23964598774909973,
0.08646683394908905,
0.3081623911857605,
-0.34993302822113037,
0.08383116126060486,
-0.2942347228527069,
-0.2981013357639313,
-0.35103753209114075,
-0.08315461874008179,
1.0374138355255127,
0.7127574682235718,
-0.19121260941028595,
0.4739670753479004,
0.03493688255548477,
0.6807180643081665,
-0.6346879601478577,
0.12239562720060349,
-0.46202144026756287,
0.176978200674057,
-0.6079114675521851,
-0.0689578503370285,
-0.8277847170829773,
-0.28103458881378174,
-0.07565504312515259,
-0.43586304783821106,
0.05387641116976738,
0.4319821000099182,
0.45456141233444214,
0.09163351356983185,
-0.4569934904575348,
-0.3865877389907837,
-0.3390945494174957,
1.0166370868682861,
-0.6223551630973816,
0.37157025933265686,
0.2201346606016159,
0.06409333646297455,
-0.0029387797694653273,
-0.7673361897468567,
-0.28404882550239563,
-0.10277307778596878,
0.005404569208621979,
0.05812377855181694,
0.03878956660628319,
-0.15702269971370697,
0.335196852684021,
0.34053096175193787,
-0.7419131994247437,
-0.13944034278392792,
-0.29805490374565125,
-0.06692308932542801,
0.41380447149276733,
0.21881455183029175,
0.35387206077575684,
-0.03615371137857437,
-0.41612061858177185,
-0.10187090188264847,
-0.7665400505065918,
-0.31951144337654114,
0.48794904351234436,
0.3144170641899109,
-0.2338307648897171,
0.7865738272666931,
-0.0576624721288681,
0.6249972581863403,
-0.4191521108150482,
0.06284162402153015,
0.9730586409568787,
-0.40244340896606445,
0.0110387047752738,
0.11051470786333084,
0.8648130893707275,
0.3082994222640991,
-0.017728757113218307,
-0.2848391830921173,
0.05682426691055298,
0.1936984807252884,
0.28818947076797485,
-0.5598129034042358,
-0.049497008323669434,
0.16099762916564941,
-0.5026848912239075,
-0.10445159673690796,
0.2640722990036011,
-0.7758493423461914,
-0.3233582079410553,
-0.019600747153162956,
0.27030763030052185,
-0.420663446187973,
-0.14625680446624756,
0.0677105039358139,
-0.2868979275226593,
-0.036583587527275085,
0.08997216820716858,
-0.5998803973197937,
0.33953142166137695,
0.780866265296936,
0.867421567440033,
-0.43511414527893066,
-0.449783056974411,
-0.46470215916633606,
0.2474561482667923,
-0.3109479546546936,
0.959761381149292,
-0.584399402141571,
-0.33226022124290466,
0.02306123822927475,
0.1721753031015396,
-0.29427582025527954,
-0.5647933483123779,
0.7520483732223511,
-0.174723282456398,
0.22497257590293884,
-0.5521493554115295,
-0.5678815841674805,
-0.3030830919742584,
0.1449492871761322,
-0.7914999127388,
1.472769856452942,
0.19419336318969727,
-0.875338613986969,
0.20896850526332855,
-0.7589585185050964,
-0.4292495548725128,
0.10402369499206543,
0.1965569257736206,
-0.22732140123844147,
0.2132696956396103,
0.05800812691450119,
0.3019021153450012,
-0.32930421829223633,
0.34586507081985474,
-0.5622588992118835,
-0.20825937390327454,
0.1678672432899475,
0.04538742080330849,
0.7903977036476135,
-0.036518558859825134,
-0.1694369614124298,
0.24858278036117554,
-0.7734857201576233,
0.07229369878768921,
-0.12568390369415283,
-0.10255729407072067,
-0.7266646027565002,
0.24348321557044983,
0.2795742452144623,
0.39828500151634216,
0.6280838251113892,
-1.0532441139221191,
0.1946946382522583,
-0.36747515201568604,
0.5131217837333679,
0.5436083674430847,
-0.24397335946559906,
0.15642514824867249,
-0.1808333694934845,
-0.02511066570878029,
-0.08521245419979095,
0.12077000737190247,
0.0901152566075325,
-0.7486820220947266,
-0.24303783476352692,
-0.3147459030151367,
0.7198916077613831,
0.6948946118354797,
-0.7409202456474304,
0.6970881223678589,
-0.2557573914527893,
-0.5614005923271179,
-0.7497695088386536,
0.2467835545539856,
0.3257450461387634,
0.4479254186153412,
0.4133944511413574,
-0.10606521368026733,
-0.635453999042511,
-1.0764796733856201,
-0.07229934632778168,
0.19295968115329742,
-0.2650028169155121,
0.11544380336999893,
0.9735167026519775,
0.06670652329921722,
0.6279968619346619,
-0.3216548562049866,
-0.4177209138870239,
-0.3934330344200134,
0.2650604844093323,
0.2153732031583786,
0.5004332065582275,
0.5959539413452148,
-0.8278218507766724,
-0.943103015422821,
-0.18031847476959229,
-0.9182013869285583,
-0.2360856831073761,
0.1358160674571991,
-0.07557187974452972,
0.14176945388317108,
0.35063713788986206,
-0.40829068422317505,
-0.019007433205842972,
1.045499324798584,
-0.6919576525688171,
0.581452488899231,
-0.45180001854896545,
0.26795098185539246,
-1.0459376573562622,
0.2698839008808136,
-0.3586581349372864,
-0.3257654011249542,
-0.5110896825790405,
0.3166907727718353,
0.4724661111831665,
0.011900792829692364,
-0.711398720741272,
0.3689870238304138,
-0.4628312587738037,
-0.4301283359527588,
-0.012120714411139488,
0.6162737011909485,
-0.07375521957874298,
0.42485877871513367,
-0.22902297973632812,
0.9181541800498962,
0.5554520487785339,
-0.2919629216194153,
0.2592507600784302,
0.5354140400886536,
-0.6959851980209351,
0.4505409002304077,
-0.7322593331336975,
-0.05946166068315506,
0.1675696074962616,
0.07804029434919357,
-0.9148629903793335,
0.2143256515264511,
-0.055416371673345566,
-0.2231244444847107,
-0.027183882892131805,
0.13947740197181702,
-1.1894603967666626,
-0.5675981044769287,
-0.6404904127120972,
0.23981402814388275,
0.47770771384239197,
-0.3278120458126068,
0.6903913021087646,
0.5055475234985352,
-0.36396661400794983,
-0.47361114621162415,
-0.8217958211898804,
0.17214061319828033,
-0.023496078327298164,
-0.6449950337409973,
0.6836523413658142,
-0.3673707842826843,
-0.07493727654218674,
0.28105732798576355,
0.028575429692864418,
0.0927104651927948,
-0.10096506774425507,
0.3256778419017792,
0.20741166174411774,
-0.27054402232170105,
-0.17825868725776672,
0.22511257231235504,
-0.17928031086921692,
-0.12842419743537903,
0.13227228820323944,
0.9364091753959656,
-0.2786808907985687,
-0.4222683906555176,
-0.3321797549724579,
0.5786646604537964,
0.5617179274559021,
-0.28850221633911133,
1.0447967052459717,
0.6187353134155273,
-0.010839457623660564,
-0.05922522395849228,
-0.6474010944366455,
0.1791922003030777,
-0.43375322222709656,
0.18658876419067383,
-0.10919871181249619,
-0.809514045715332,
0.6423645615577698,
-0.2141224890947342,
0.21402181684970856,
0.6259397864341736,
0.7106469869613647,
-0.24775591492652893,
1.0070065259933472,
0.6670435667037964,
0.06438495218753815,
0.23738887906074524,
-0.02495519444346428,
-0.09260226786136627,
-1.0428354740142822,
-0.17227214574813843,
-0.5719178915023804,
-0.4531402885913849,
-0.5107597708702087,
-0.6871501207351685,
0.1685996651649475,
-0.19509154558181763,
-0.17391760647296906,
0.43986281752586365,
-0.3251790404319763,
0.18913975358009338,
0.7147364020347595,
0.11467345058917999,
0.20560787618160248,
-0.07120586931705475,
-0.24081243574619293,
-0.2576826810836792,
-0.5196765065193176,
-0.47596317529678345,
1.2578771114349365,
0.09433471411466599,
0.06296630948781967,
-0.03510293364524841,
0.5744988322257996,
0.4046560227870941,
0.43791159987449646,
-0.34080955386161804,
0.6785328984260559,
-0.7030563950538635,
-0.7147942185401917,
-0.08836162090301514,
-0.4073519706726074,
-0.7339290976524353,
0.4944559633731842,
-0.4384763240814209,
-0.6366285085678101,
0.07212501019239426,
-0.11160394549369812,
0.016414310783147812,
0.5298429727554321,
-0.5383151173591614,
1.1430249214172363,
0.021334275603294373,
-0.0762561485171318,
-0.41685158014297485,
-0.5669064521789551,
0.14968349039554596,
-0.13553528487682343,
0.5768105983734131,
-0.4052203297615051,
-0.35490038990974426,
1.0815181732177734,
-0.117508664727211,
0.7302142381668091,
-0.39478710293769836,
0.16012006998062134,
0.16673696041107178,
-0.20526723563671112,
0.6769388914108276,
-0.24220404028892517,
-0.3135213255882263,
0.369973748922348,
0.02490604668855667,
-0.5361019968986511,
-0.04535472393035889,
0.7136301398277283,
-0.4470687806606293,
-0.08016347140073776,
-0.2804824709892273,
-0.6031898856163025,
-0.3441856801509857,
0.48075905442237854,
0.11040107160806656,
0.5821304321289062,
-0.33525726199150085,
0.7943835258483887,
0.8406340479850769,
-0.6133807897567749,
0.4690166413784027,
0.7531558275222778,
-0.053331222385168076,
-0.6485706567764282,
0.7608199119567871,
-0.04782060906291008,
0.05387818068265915,
0.6021050810813904,
0.024939129129052162,
-0.24292488396167755,
-0.7515636682510376,
-0.28055471181869507,
0.49275022745132446,
-0.5757908225059509,
-0.23005682229995728,
-0.7108102440834045,
0.2270737886428833,
-0.27214932441711426,
-0.2840310037136078,
-0.5896493196487427,
-0.2566709518432617,
-0.0384707897901535,
-0.1511716991662979,
0.11620724201202393,
0.6694245338439941,
0.11038165539503098,
0.3800469636917114,
-0.8364096283912659,
0.46494197845458984,
-0.29754021763801575,
0.6557984948158264,
-0.34277594089508057,
-0.17040801048278809,
-0.18050257861614227,
-0.08338730037212372,
-0.11741278320550919,
-0.7977216243743896,
0.5656114220619202,
0.0736553743481636,
0.719760537147522,
0.07489599287509918,
0.33133813738822937,
0.2878083884716034,
-0.8836291432380676,
0.9967648386955261,
0.08450590074062347,
-0.9373828172683716,
0.32569119334220886,
-0.396192342042923,
0.23036865890026093,
0.8134868144989014,
0.37358176708221436,
-0.3094770610332489,
-0.6280640959739685,
-0.5079419612884521,
-1.0754923820495605,
0.44545021653175354,
0.12234356254339218,
0.03689562901854515,
-0.11031465977430344,
-0.17114870250225067,
0.38657012581825256,
0.616287112236023,
-0.7401807308197021,
-0.46764570474624634,
0.055351875722408295,
-0.34098079800605774,
-0.12566272914409637,
-0.640363872051239,
-0.18387316167354584,
-0.07343769818544388,
0.5497334599494934,
0.20400625467300415,
0.27186793088912964,
0.039836034178733826,
-0.5237388014793396,
0.07849563658237457,
0.2886227071285248,
0.8654700517654419,
0.6188486814498901,
-0.4475366175174713,
0.10112228989601135,
0.2587827444076538,
-0.6563420295715332,
-0.2643688917160034,
-0.04128768667578697,
-0.2004077434539795,
0.28901028633117676,
0.2814421057701111,
0.7516762018203735,
0.6040664315223694,
-1.0454111099243164,
0.5326729416847229,
0.14392852783203125,
-0.6610649228096008,
-0.27701395750045776,
-0.38629281520843506,
0.15987181663513184,
0.0020786612294614315,
0.5070009231567383,
-0.11406068503856659,
0.22545568645000458,
-0.4406237006187439,
0.19810788333415985,
0.314696341753006,
-0.11984885483980179,
-0.23513388633728027,
0.5199949145317078,
0.11563380062580109,
0.08332358300685883,
0.5107983946800232,
-0.1795952469110489,
-0.40252938866615295,
0.49623343348503113,
0.592446506023407,
0.5936552286148071,
-0.11330989748239517,
0.33835867047309875,
0.29128363728523254,
0.5348073840141296,
-0.33306801319122314,
0.5644439458847046,
0.2739710211753845,
-0.3389275074005127,
-0.6571480631828308,
-0.6715491414070129,
-0.5344076156616211,
-0.29738476872444153,
-0.630121648311615,
0.16055411100387573,
-0.22228573262691498,
-0.061464376747608185,
-0.16029393672943115,
0.11947935074567795,
-0.4532221555709839,
-0.23873665928840637,
0.11801407486200333,
1.150291919708252,
-0.9879311323165894,
0.9196519255638123,
0.6327188611030579,
0.03394010290503502,
-0.1306239813566208,
-0.5853002071380615,
-0.15997344255447388,
-0.6397473812103271,
0.6139287948608398,
0.13456936180591583,
0.25267717242240906,
-0.037607867270708084,
-0.27776363492012024,
-1.1925714015960693,
0.9987170696258545,
0.2538769543170929,
-0.6210750341415405,
0.05459096282720566,
0.18173809349536896,
0.5944620370864868,
-0.3814157247543335,
-0.17533555626869202,
0.09399527311325073,
0.8308498859405518,
-0.49283260107040405,
-0.9629868865013123,
0.08744356781244278,
-0.4155527651309967,
-0.15666478872299194,
0.5205176472663879,
-0.5004794001579285,
0.9404186010360718,
0.35120847821235657,
-0.18033628165721893,
0.1605122685432434,
0.5144097208976746,
0.1962375044822693,
0.3895028829574585,
0.3233751356601715,
0.8270910978317261,
0.6429451704025269,
-0.3638538420200348,
1.087465763092041,
-0.6519519090652466,
0.38003668189048767,
0.9651521444320679,
-0.44258856773376465,
1.2399183511734009,
0.41169360280036926,
-0.29743921756744385,
0.8299040198326111,
0.26610419154167175,
-0.6412972807884216,
0.7331873178482056,
-0.2894037365913391,
0.03853806480765343,
-0.08686213940382004,
0.10964767634868622,
-0.6634511947631836,
0.0568600594997406,
0.6672420501708984,
-0.295040488243103,
-0.3945210576057434,
0.39842987060546875,
-0.2424900382757187,
0.010493624024093151,
-0.3513685464859009,
0.6551708579063416,
-0.08922898024320602,
-0.34520605206489563,
0.2703979015350342,
0.0026453190948814154,
0.8614968061447144,
-0.8687419295310974,
0.2559630572795868,
0.2392837554216385,
0.0792360007762909,
-0.10624676197767258,
-0.9443380236625671,
0.5214874148368835,
-0.06859780848026276,
-0.26073169708251953,
-0.4943985641002655,
0.47867822647094727,
-0.38903507590293884,
-0.42461517453193665,
0.31150510907173157,
0.4834018647670746,
0.178535595536232,
-0.1552741974592209,
-0.7227798104286194,
0.22680649161338806,
-0.09479134529829025,
-0.36329326033592224,
0.6925367712974548,
0.3792603015899658,
0.043574463576078415,
0.5647611618041992,
0.7115749716758728,
0.18308885395526886,
0.06317772716283798,
0.036501195281744,
0.5847948789596558,
-0.7421985268592834,
-0.6121460795402527,
-0.8139510154724121,
0.4814053177833557,
-0.35898318886756897,
-0.19039075076580048,
1.0833351612091064,
0.9406594634056091,
0.6425660848617554,
-0.4735448956489563,
0.726884126663208,
-0.3189592957496643,
0.8083387613296509,
-0.3142816424369812,
0.5905566811561584,
-0.45482733845710754,
-0.04718353599309921,
-0.3892480731010437,
-0.9579475522041321,
-0.44002169370651245,
0.3657545745372772,
-0.4650523066520691,
-0.486075222492218,
1.1392097473144531,
0.38817012310028076,
0.1285160779953003,
-0.03591878339648247,
0.371234655380249,
0.26490291953086853,
-0.08890126645565033,
0.38978511095046997,
0.3637000620365143,
-0.2848699688911438,
0.5597791075706482,
-0.5070574879646301,
-0.14925411343574524,
-0.2665821313858032,
-1.125234603881836,
-0.9669938683509827,
-0.5759572982788086,
-0.27096813917160034,
-0.041787873953580856,
0.025133982300758362,
0.8558753728866577,
0.30999651551246643,
-1.1932507753372192,
-0.17218612134456635,
0.10221584141254425,
0.0489841103553772,
-0.5220667123794556,
-0.21077963709831238,
0.5613679885864258,
-0.3882896900177002,
-0.5726426243782043,
0.41273656487464905,
0.47447603940963745,
-0.2607658803462982,
0.09292449802160263,
0.38076385855674744,
-0.3069041073322296,
-0.19152340292930603,
0.9216288924217224,
0.04082765057682991,
-0.5305256843566895,
0.015118488110601902,
-0.0013240292901173234,
-0.21903064846992493,
0.0987522229552269,
0.9138779044151306,
-0.4488886594772339,
0.11920834332704544,
0.6866431832313538,
0.4472447633743286,
0.4064977765083313,
-0.1348336637020111,
0.5317444205284119,
-0.9223305583000183,
0.22888092696666718,
0.13524271547794342,
0.6036165952682495,
0.28313153982162476,
0.11263871192932129,
0.608180820941925,
0.38584160804748535,
-0.4789724051952362,
-1.3208810091018677,
-0.282453715801239,
-1.3534032106399536,
-0.47608789801597595,
0.9358699321746826,
-0.174353688955307,
-0.2714535892009735,
-0.22376462817192078,
-0.24523888528347015,
-0.021944984793663025,
-0.4235133230686188,
0.6281883120536804,
0.8407022953033447,
0.10268649458885193,
-0.032421745359897614,
-1.0355503559112549,
0.2746792435646057,
0.22228321433067322,
-0.8596773743629456,
0.3286740779876709,
0.27782994508743286,
0.3232930600643158,
0.32309064269065857,
0.3398262560367584,
-0.33202067017555237,
0.2193486988544464,
0.3283751606941223,
0.24234752357006073,
-0.2611851394176483,
-0.32035714387893677,
0.2194148600101471,
0.7123017311096191,
-0.3271165192127228,
0.1828535497188568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10133v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10133v1
|
Turkronicles: Diachronic Resources for the Fast Evolving Turkish Language
| 2024-05-16T14:31:07 | 2024-05-16T14:31:07 |
Togay Yazar, Mucahid Kutlu, İsa Kerem Bayırlı
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Over the past century, the Turkish language has undergone substantial
changes, primarily driven by governmental interventions. In this work, our goal
is to investigate the evolution of the Turkish language since the establishment
of T\"urkiye in 1923. Thus, we first introduce Turkronicles which is a
diachronic corpus for Turkish derived from the Official Gazette of T\"urkiye.
Turkronicles contains 45,375 documents, detailing governmental actions, making
it a pivotal resource for analyzing the linguistic evolution influenced by the
state policies. In addition, we expand an existing diachronic Turkish corpus
which consists of the records of the Grand National Assembly of T\"urkiye by
covering additional years. Next, combining these two diachronic corpora, we
seek answers for two main research questions: How have the Turkish vocabulary
and the writing conventions changed since the 1920s? Our analysis reveals that
the vocabularies of two different time periods diverge more as the time between
them increases, and newly coined Turkish words take the place of their old
counterparts. We also observe changes in writing conventions. In particular,
the use of circumflex noticeably decreases and words ending with the letters
"-b" and "-d" are successively replaced with "-p" and "-t" letters,
respectively. Overall, this study quantitatively highlights the dramatic
changes in Turkish from various aspects of the language in a diachronic
perspective.
|
[
-0.4752301275730133,
-1.06591796875,
0.37053146958351135,
0.05352433770895004,
-0.34018072485923767,
0.1204652339220047,
-0.4882093667984009,
-0.45503562688827515,
0.19651973247528076,
0.538712203502655,
-0.43339210748672485,
-0.4336211383342743,
-0.5430295467376709,
0.528175413608551,
-0.31321972608566284,
1.0698810815811157,
-0.012787737883627415,
-0.20136210322380066,
0.336307168006897,
-0.24197910726070404,
-0.20469194650650024,
-0.42043840885162354,
-0.48399412631988525,
-0.2636609375476837,
0.5497390031814575,
0.4814036190509796,
0.6756975650787354,
0.7248280048370361,
0.3669894337654114,
0.3321988880634308,
-0.4191316068172455,
0.034352850168943405,
0.058427177369594574,
0.21228066086769104,
-0.12555564939975739,
-0.25272223353385925,
-0.215692937374115,
-0.06514780223369598,
0.930496871471405,
0.7580179572105408,
-0.17646466195583344,
0.5100948810577393,
0.02463756501674652,
1.1611677408218384,
-0.8169546127319336,
-0.01081565860658884,
-0.1654205024242401,
-0.02869407646358013,
-0.8979106545448303,
-0.3497219383716583,
-0.03713211789727211,
-0.36972546577453613,
0.22300466895103455,
-0.6474041938781738,
0.17519277334213257,
-0.12363500148057938,
0.5056394934654236,
-0.20238745212554932,
-0.29337945580482483,
-0.6037224531173706,
-1.0943694114685059,
0.904556155204773,
-0.39747917652130127,
0.7497554421424866,
0.5388678908348083,
0.2520028054714203,
-0.6774503588676453,
-1.061651587486267,
-0.29274359345436096,
-0.7319015860557556,
0.177873432636261,
0.03540005907416344,
-0.06420627236366272,
-0.19609904289245605,
-0.019461046904325485,
0.46923068165779114,
-0.4914538860321045,
-0.18186739087104797,
-0.6541107892990112,
-0.09442174434661865,
0.47456786036491394,
0.31527936458587646,
0.3153340816497803,
-0.14861692488193512,
0.25948047637939453,
0.043372612446546555,
-0.5820769667625427,
0.1394304782152176,
0.674845814704895,
0.17316831648349762,
0.04464232176542282,
0.7648369073867798,
-0.37608665227890015,
0.651138186454773,
0.27572980523109436,
-0.1915750652551651,
-0.1461573839187622,
-0.662585973739624,
-0.2254832237958908,
0.21862782537937164,
0.7793644666671753,
-0.023385802283883095,
0.11812343448400497,
-0.15354931354522705,
0.40438413619995117,
-0.11042933911085129,
0.412671834230423,
-0.36193913221359253,
-0.2885628938674927,
0.24391712248325348,
-0.3809961676597595,
-0.6943960785865784,
0.06812815368175507,
-0.712859034538269,
-0.6053606271743774,
0.025245962664484978,
-0.10447700321674347,
-0.3964223265647888,
-0.31535428762435913,
0.15027770400047302,
-0.20807529985904694,
0.05288933590054512,
0.33012160658836365,
-1.245176076889038,
0.5810276865959167,
0.7974991202354431,
0.5747098922729492,
0.3038662374019623,
-0.24201396107673645,
-0.020191658288240433,
-0.11880984902381897,
-0.8685489296913147,
0.8550055623054504,
-0.5732253789901733,
-0.4414304494857788,
0.3375149965286255,
0.16817332804203033,
0.07166631519794464,
-0.6061333417892456,
0.6003907322883606,
-0.43841031193733215,
0.6677586436271667,
-0.0872340202331543,
-0.32724612951278687,
-0.28563275933265686,
0.06709747016429901,
-0.8290120959281921,
1.0402806997299194,
0.048796072602272034,
-1.03281831741333,
0.4165535569190979,
-0.3911179304122925,
-0.2773997485637665,
0.2914438247680664,
-0.23363347351551056,
-0.5229798555374146,
0.4451499879360199,
-0.14027948677539825,
0.010749592445790768,
-0.3190517723560333,
-0.191363126039505,
-0.09829545021057129,
-0.5170785784721375,
0.41550853848457336,
-0.051522694528102875,
0.9197288751602173,
0.06105310842394829,
-0.29797467589378357,
-0.36330971121788025,
-0.6290993690490723,
-0.3681392967700958,
-0.04202894866466522,
-0.8104697465896606,
-0.5241929292678833,
0.15703967213630676,
0.008773635141551495,
-0.13055852055549622,
0.4104425609111786,
-0.6375213861465454,
0.18426504731178284,
-0.3289417028427124,
0.3045694828033447,
0.4132178723812103,
0.27382031083106995,
0.49051228165626526,
-0.47850194573402405,
0.367510586977005,
-0.1387813538312912,
0.30124950408935547,
0.15546071529388428,
-0.423902302980423,
-0.7897353768348694,
-0.06105456128716469,
0.15370479226112366,
0.3658147156238556,
-0.09147901833057404,
0.17631475627422333,
-0.0028137448243796825,
-0.5484877824783325,
-0.33012479543685913,
-0.009391878731548786,
-0.09431561827659607,
0.15866871178150177,
0.18145515024662018,
-0.1926712840795517,
-0.7736213207244873,
-0.6284133791923523,
-0.28543809056282043,
-0.5937540531158447,
0.2944507598876953,
0.16982628405094147,
0.14135053753852844,
0.20644842088222504,
0.4930632710456848,
0.10516758263111115,
-0.07773163169622421,
-0.31234467029571533,
0.13438661396503448,
0.3046385943889618,
0.1997913420200348,
0.41701990365982056,
-0.4442516565322876,
-0.35646992921829224,
0.15167810022830963,
-0.2663719952106476,
-0.1850038319826126,
-0.11328278481960297,
-0.09831339865922928,
0.7677116990089417,
0.6964607238769531,
-0.5143635869026184,
0.28970301151275635,
0.6804152131080627,
-0.7755286693572998,
1.1998378038406372,
-0.1675741821527481,
0.4094944894313812,
-1.098482608795166,
0.27968931198120117,
-0.3112834095954895,
0.03290199115872383,
-0.8296282887458801,
-0.17726677656173706,
-0.10463272780179977,
0.3542587459087372,
-0.5218232274055481,
0.49573490023612976,
-0.321209579706192,
0.26543891429901123,
-0.2979178726673126,
0.18737375736236572,
-0.2277304083108902,
-0.03887036442756653,
-0.11344820261001587,
0.5899766087532043,
0.3628943860530853,
-0.9011750817298889,
0.6146916151046753,
0.2956831455230713,
-0.5580025315284729,
0.29537689685821533,
-0.10042434930801392,
0.03763941675424576,
-0.1733851283788681,
0.05913535878062248,
-0.5977237820625305,
0.08147785067558289,
0.5709618926048279,
-0.3494427800178528,
0.311394602060318,
-0.19435524940490723,
-0.32308337092399597,
-0.26645249128341675,
-0.4861114025115967,
0.3697037696838379,
0.28951001167297363,
-0.036659397184848785,
0.18150556087493896,
0.17874962091445923,
-0.4350505471229553,
-0.8125703930854797,
-0.48069140315055847,
0.36678487062454224,
-0.47485068440437317,
-0.33119693398475647,
0.30776387453079224,
-0.023865478113293648,
-0.8333753943443298,
0.20974208414554596,
-0.3587324917316437,
-0.2042865753173828,
0.06616407632827759,
-0.09251491725444794,
0.3067750632762909,
-0.3012637794017792,
0.23877321183681488,
0.08592066913843155,
0.1625106781721115,
-0.06776260584592819,
-0.680365800857544,
0.6905521750450134,
-0.06568361073732376,
0.36330705881118774,
-0.8499796986579895,
0.04998384043574333,
0.6274843811988831,
-0.09236350655555725,
0.8793436288833618,
0.5404905676841736,
-0.07101809978485107,
0.3264983296394348,
-0.8044731020927429,
-0.009033393114805222,
-0.4478825628757477,
0.4981839656829834,
-0.3371054232120514,
-0.8410730957984924,
0.2758888304233551,
-0.025476327165961266,
0.3803901970386505,
0.6917089819908142,
0.8803836703300476,
-0.4386979341506958,
0.1887417733669281,
0.6531171202659607,
0.11271677166223526,
0.8370618224143982,
-0.023648496717214584,
-0.23624584078788757,
-1.0291943550109863,
-0.5312408804893494,
-0.6993427872657776,
0.17990224063396454,
-1.0766448974609375,
0.0044463640078902245,
-0.03450679033994675,
0.24537329375743866,
-0.23170968890190125,
0.543390154838562,
-0.0045775072649121284,
0.177856907248497,
0.13971182703971863,
-0.19041214883327484,
0.3566077649593353,
0.25952544808387756,
-0.015334764495491982,
-0.06784402579069138,
-0.4689602851867676,
-0.7704210877418518,
1.2300771474838257,
0.14457650482654572,
0.5681627988815308,
0.4551449418067932,
0.7206034660339355,
0.6723958253860474,
-0.03096495196223259,
-0.5628358125686646,
0.3650722801685333,
-0.35461413860321045,
-0.6505905985832214,
-0.45441409945487976,
-0.10578859597444534,
-1.3474373817443848,
0.0878528505563736,
-0.37127578258514404,
-0.8642637729644775,
0.1083628311753273,
-0.0527614951133728,
-0.2531963884830475,
0.10971255600452423,
0.01526113785803318,
0.8058030605316162,
0.20891627669334412,
-0.37729912996292114,
-0.6561086773872375,
-0.1963537335395813,
0.28575900197029114,
-0.12020617723464966,
0.21655553579330444,
-0.2524586319923401,
-0.19105760753154755,
1.0987248420715332,
-0.3772532343864441,
0.37233486771583557,
0.40883713960647583,
-0.04471001774072647,
0.5826125741004944,
0.38654711842536926,
-0.003955096006393433,
0.24007758498191833,
-0.05123326554894447,
0.031435731798410416,
0.40039971470832825,
-0.542271077632904,
-0.49386969208717346,
0.5197633504867554,
-0.8344390988349915,
-0.6437979340553284,
-0.6760289669036865,
-0.3842334747314453,
0.27930569648742676,
-0.003557229647412896,
0.057639457285404205,
0.8745216131210327,
-0.7485805749893188,
-0.05137671157717705,
0.191913440823555,
-0.17456349730491638,
0.7031739354133606,
0.40348371863365173,
-0.14368264377117157,
-0.6395648717880249,
0.38623857498168945,
0.044606659561395645,
-0.08193284273147583,
0.40547657012939453,
0.5486549735069275,
-0.4212847054004669,
-0.3606247007846832,
-0.5427916049957275,
0.6711645722389221,
-0.23288442194461823,
0.49499404430389404,
-0.3746470510959625,
0.0656665563583374,
-0.5983692407608032,
-0.02897009812295437,
-0.45164939761161804,
-0.8690129518508911,
-0.264169842004776,
0.44464409351348877,
0.3111644387245178,
1.0282866954803467,
-0.2230643630027771,
-0.05539748817682266,
-0.7450088262557983,
-0.1518000215291977,
0.20339705049991608,
0.03672005236148834,
-0.2570062279701233,
-0.7117756009101868,
-0.4642665684223175,
-0.2954891324043274,
-0.14891336858272552,
-1.015538215637207,
0.002727228682488203,
0.270888090133667,
0.37800952792167664,
0.41502925753593445,
-0.09810201823711395,
0.3692803680896759,
-0.5346144437789917,
0.8123306632041931,
-0.12684249877929688,
-0.6275727152824402,
0.1903057098388672,
-0.3101130425930023,
0.5445187091827393,
0.40022793412208557,
0.11609748005867004,
-1.2920889854431152,
-0.6529066562652588,
-0.6283754110336304,
-0.49123507738113403,
0.761383056640625,
0.4399782121181488,
0.17962060868740082,
0.10443750768899918,
0.6103014945983887,
0.2156127542257309,
0.16837768256664276,
0.09783576428890228,
-0.2885459065437317,
-0.19174335896968842,
-0.1521030068397522,
-0.020220167934894562,
-0.35888391733169556,
-0.052548594772815704,
-0.20454201102256775,
0.5951495170593262,
0.35880106687545776,
0.22509709000587463,
0.10067572444677353,
-0.15973979234695435,
-0.07932773977518082,
0.7300479412078857,
0.9802958369255066,
1.0125668048858643,
-0.11473242938518524,
0.45646145939826965,
0.21071480214595795,
-1.3099218606948853,
0.09892701357603073,
0.2360849380493164,
0.02067856676876545,
0.09189003705978394,
0.5211707949638367,
0.453559011220932,
-0.13012894988059998,
-0.49623197317123413,
-0.02451467514038086,
-0.15429559350013733,
-0.17247800529003143,
-0.8423414826393127,
-0.18210452795028687,
-0.04376060515642166,
0.5118610858917236,
0.4328668713569641,
-0.48924073576927185,
0.018729517236351967,
-0.7632575631141663,
0.23395249247550964,
-0.039162810891866684,
-0.20033426582813263,
-0.5239242315292358,
0.30058911442756653,
-0.07635249942541122,
-0.3375115990638733,
0.7499074935913086,
0.04339149221777916,
-0.2990153431892395,
0.37842145562171936,
0.5107395648956299,
0.8628089427947998,
-0.5809614658355713,
0.7089932560920715,
0.41676923632621765,
0.3159935772418976,
0.23958605527877808,
0.21808092296123505,
-0.38094231486320496,
-0.4387797713279724,
-0.21489115059375763,
-0.8628655672073364,
-0.2300628274679184,
0.569165050983429,
-0.4255329370498657,
0.22699816524982452,
-0.6418536305427551,
-0.5589312314987183,
0.051062848418951035,
0.6927601099014282,
-0.4121887683868408,
0.07640407234430313,
0.3165012300014496,
0.7972460985183716,
-0.627582311630249,
0.5779158473014832,
1.3091609477996826,
-0.23048272728919983,
0.014922711998224258,
0.06367231905460358,
0.03668874502182007,
-0.28248175978660583,
0.7490338683128357,
-0.22273269295692444,
0.029742268845438957,
0.06490862369537354,
-0.13108891248703003,
-0.9699150919914246,
0.8107098937034607,
-0.20395618677139282,
-0.2297336310148239,
0.1990700662136078,
0.4022361636161804,
0.6844733953475952,
-0.0716714859008789,
0.03413974493741989,
0.8690911531448364,
0.4130829870700836,
-0.38877594470977783,
-0.9346155524253845,
0.15488913655281067,
0.008959447965025902,
-0.06660608947277069,
0.48842957615852356,
-0.40500879287719727,
0.7011363506317139,
-0.06525460630655289,
-0.5139172673225403,
0.39858630299568176,
0.7274972796440125,
0.14949989318847656,
0.0725959986448288,
0.2174610048532486,
0.4031037986278534,
0.5013017058372498,
0.0702718049287796,
0.7305722236633301,
-0.3375980854034424,
0.040077224373817444,
0.4719960391521454,
0.39248642325401306,
0.6414951682090759,
0.6499740481376648,
-0.2830337584018707,
0.9163963794708252,
0.8366820812225342,
0.04012063145637512,
0.47109711170196533,
0.024316195398569107,
-0.6848059296607971,
-0.13064469397068024,
-0.2659411132335663,
-0.15595297515392303,
0.5659247636795044,
0.38927048444747925,
-0.263685405254364,
-0.4781835079193115,
-0.2902459502220154,
0.5649446249008179,
-0.17747145891189575,
-0.14661270380020142,
0.6448705196380615,
0.06996222585439682,
-0.42387548089027405,
0.5387629866600037,
0.1768445372581482,
-0.12976673245429993,
-0.4542744755744934,
0.07808847725391388,
-0.339476078748703,
0.22030961513519287,
-0.08266206830739975,
-0.6176487803459167,
0.40234115719795227,
-0.12213341146707535,
0.15875084698200226,
0.414008229970932,
0.31285619735717773,
-0.4918433725833893,
-0.39529502391815186,
-0.20813193917274475,
0.5321410894393921,
0.31030213832855225,
0.30924075841903687,
-0.5174106359481812,
0.24897265434265137,
-0.46972039341926575,
-0.3293851613998413,
-0.015678904950618744,
0.18836936354637146,
-0.3941723108291626,
0.26687055826187134,
0.3895917236804962,
0.18591222167015076,
0.2448376715183258,
-0.09643030911684036,
0.5638275146484375,
-0.7955288887023926,
-0.37703752517700195,
-0.9684664011001587,
0.13181766867637634,
0.04937061667442322,
-0.45415642857551575,
0.6679476499557495,
0.3914299011230469,
0.730079174041748,
0.03023594059050083,
0.8054126501083374,
-0.43015310168266296,
0.04623064771294594,
-0.39086073637008667,
0.8982305526733398,
-0.5736132860183716,
-0.38386642932891846,
-0.24654395878314972,
-1.1682603359222412,
-0.34880977869033813,
0.45712730288505554,
-0.1098879724740982,
-0.18355238437652588,
1.1512260437011719,
0.4252472519874573,
0.261918842792511,
-0.03829808905720711,
0.15066088736057281,
0.2948083281517029,
0.0564444363117218,
0.12365096062421799,
0.862277090549469,
-0.37704694271087646,
0.6295046210289001,
-0.32247135043144226,
-0.31423094868659973,
-0.35484498739242554,
-0.5149567723274231,
-0.903654932975769,
-0.9345824718475342,
-0.45505669713020325,
-0.4445854127407074,
0.677749514579773,
0.9912543296813965,
0.08336076140403748,
-0.8211818337440491,
-0.6067707538604736,
-0.20221276581287384,
-0.07518624514341354,
-0.45426464080810547,
-0.1368366777896881,
0.7400481104850769,
-0.40451580286026,
-0.7130447626113892,
0.484468013048172,
0.15999732911586761,
0.2374447137117386,
-0.14724388718605042,
0.04557148367166519,
-0.07485385239124298,
0.37488994002342224,
0.5680479407310486,
0.8336554765701294,
-0.6074292063713074,
-0.18699446320533752,
0.011822989210486412,
-0.24879008531570435,
-0.09106463938951492,
0.9837421774864197,
-0.5196876525878906,
0.4968157112598419,
0.7864664196968079,
0.07898665219545364,
0.42713403701782227,
-0.10771390050649643,
0.48227983713150024,
-0.13204796612262726,
0.27927926182746887,
-0.13794025778770447,
0.016256533563137054,
0.35563111305236816,
0.07765709608793259,
0.11998384445905685,
0.5809918642044067,
-0.6097594499588013,
-0.4402516782283783,
0.3279170095920563,
-0.5652612447738647,
-0.21550720930099487,
0.9334118962287903,
0.2884269654750824,
-0.411847859621048,
-0.6197591423988342,
-0.06795264780521393,
0.5681232810020447,
-0.3228643834590912,
1.5173968076705933,
0.814627468585968,
-0.25645026564598083,
-0.35487350821495056,
-0.5217325091362,
0.9732245802879333,
0.2111223191022873,
-0.4964129626750946,
0.10893931239843369,
0.36562579870224,
0.4194164574146271,
0.20898893475532532,
0.7420135736465454,
-0.42874106764793396,
0.48773762583732605,
0.04886569082736969,
-0.013196791522204876,
-0.073311947286129,
-0.468107134103775,
-0.2343689650297165,
-0.09518863260746002,
0.26763877272605896,
-0.3413037061691284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10129v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10129v1
|
StyloAI: Distinguishing AI-Generated Content with Stylometric Analysis
| 2024-05-16T14:28:01 | 2024-05-16T14:28:01 |
Chidimma Opara
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
The emergence of large language models (LLMs) capable of generating realistic
texts and images has sparked ethical concerns across various sectors. In
response, researchers in academia and industry are actively exploring methods
to distinguish AI-generated content from human-authored material. However, a
crucial question remains: What are the unique characteristics of AI-generated
text? Addressing this gap, this study proposes StyloAI, a data-driven model
that uses 31 stylometric features to identify AI-generated texts by applying a
Random Forest classifier on two multi-domain datasets. StyloAI achieves
accuracy rates of 81% and 98% on the test set of the AuTextification dataset
and the Education dataset, respectively. This approach surpasses the
performance of existing state-of-the-art models and provides valuable insights
into the differences between AI-generated and human-authored texts.
|
[
-0.11846926808357239,
-1.0440738201141357,
0.31362542510032654,
0.08421928435564041,
-0.2878900170326233,
0.30618816614151,
-0.20716193318367004,
-1.1788647174835205,
0.3534514307975769,
0.4880276620388031,
-0.6664210557937622,
-0.5423739552497864,
-0.6110498309135437,
0.33806148171424866,
-0.4745386242866516,
1.0947613716125488,
-0.21292155981063843,
-0.05807948857545853,
-0.43810415267944336,
-0.2782464921474457,
-0.0188862606883049,
-0.37735357880592346,
-0.8484615087509155,
0.06262357532978058,
0.49620646238327026,
0.10041413456201553,
0.6576240658760071,
1.232346534729004,
0.5594992637634277,
0.2973395586013794,
0.0830923542380333,
0.33104947209358215,
-0.42543119192123413,
-0.06447234004735947,
0.28202906250953674,
-0.2900983691215515,
-0.14720283448696136,
0.07793819904327393,
0.6331047415733337,
0.21607282757759094,
-0.038309160619974136,
0.3393241763114929,
0.13087055087089539,
0.30593162775039673,
-0.15800741314888,
-0.06825903058052063,
-0.33905866742134094,
0.07154328376054764,
-0.6113044619560242,
-0.3772525191307068,
-0.4537733495235443,
-0.549063503742218,
0.2539016902446747,
-0.6513968706130981,
0.34431928396224976,
0.1732344627380371,
1.1378772258758545,
0.2048223465681076,
-0.32246702909469604,
-0.7238755822181702,
-0.7178123593330383,
0.9423325657844543,
-0.8025364875793457,
0.30768945813179016,
0.09329860657453537,
0.08155825734138489,
-0.08913484960794449,
-0.7146410942077637,
-0.8314463496208191,
-0.2083463966846466,
0.0013173873303458095,
-0.13710951805114746,
0.06715133786201477,
-0.20194849371910095,
-0.08139774948358536,
0.4321284294128418,
-0.6625859141349792,
0.3769417107105255,
-0.4079152047634125,
-0.17743399739265442,
1.143667221069336,
-0.00856704730540514,
0.8136475682258606,
-0.15589134395122528,
-0.3478657603263855,
-0.3107262849807739,
-0.6663087010383606,
0.19916045665740967,
0.7802112698554993,
0.23867349326610565,
-0.2751936912536621,
0.49538347125053406,
0.4373520314693451,
0.38034141063690186,
-0.4993115961551666,
-0.45641764998435974,
0.1160646304488182,
-0.32905563712120056,
-0.2759335935115814,
0.06276146322488785,
1.1466728448867798,
0.07627137750387192,
0.6247825026512146,
0.04370926693081856,
-0.11212355643510818,
0.1695321649312973,
0.25295984745025635,
-0.7121097445487976,
-0.29000574350357056,
0.18893906474113464,
-0.7326578497886658,
-0.7885572910308838,
-0.07782979309558868,
-0.7234684228897095,
-0.6096641421318054,
-0.34709039330482483,
-0.06074809655547142,
-0.40656882524490356,
-0.3256179690361023,
-0.44469699263572693,
-0.12609001994132996,
0.009580587036907673,
0.331099271774292,
-0.7537004947662354,
0.02178545854985714,
0.6476624608039856,
0.6534165143966675,
-0.5333383679389954,
-0.5356345772743225,
-0.04431970790028572,
-0.02000548131763935,
-0.7085721492767334,
0.713937520980835,
-0.9001349806785583,
-0.22824867069721222,
0.023868611082434654,
-0.2493136078119278,
0.03154819831252098,
-0.41731977462768555,
0.245247021317482,
-0.49659961462020874,
0.14868099987506866,
0.14240658283233643,
-0.648440420627594,
-0.16182874143123627,
-0.13753284513950348,
-0.8041518330574036,
1.2065831422805786,
0.04003682732582092,
-0.7272714376449585,
0.6749396920204163,
-0.43475618958473206,
-0.46877041459083557,
0.2012185901403427,
-0.6173889636993408,
-0.6000757217407227,
0.04213281720876694,
-0.13899827003479004,
0.025587428361177444,
-0.4920222759246826,
0.6140742897987366,
-0.302059531211853,
-0.2491462230682373,
0.39512941241264343,
-0.7200769782066345,
0.9027709364891052,
0.31993964314460754,
-0.21613414585590363,
0.430193156003952,
-0.767025351524353,
0.07196113467216492,
0.3733380138874054,
-0.4828309416770935,
-0.3801867663860321,
0.00483078183606267,
0.553672730922699,
-0.1812209188938141,
0.31187182664871216,
-0.46556660532951355,
0.12827123701572418,
-0.2631423771381378,
0.3457026481628418,
0.9431257843971252,
-0.011718926951289177,
0.1861753612756729,
-0.4898432791233063,
0.4582766890525818,
-0.17727285623550415,
-0.021291939541697502,
-0.00040911664837040007,
-0.7306383848190308,
-0.5590936541557312,
-0.5691653490066528,
0.393849641084671,
0.45436567068099976,
-0.7143245935440063,
0.30073994398117065,
-0.40007269382476807,
-0.7911106944084167,
-0.809703528881073,
0.19115810096263885,
0.5129544734954834,
0.1432608664035797,
0.11659058928489685,
-0.36233022809028625,
-0.30809226632118225,
-0.8772460222244263,
-0.31521716713905334,
-0.293069988489151,
-0.28148382902145386,
0.7489874362945557,
0.6135035157203674,
-0.3241790533065796,
0.7411400675773621,
-0.17761512100696564,
-0.0022701958660036325,
-0.09334301948547363,
0.6119225025177002,
-0.21583805978298187,
0.4496994912624359,
0.9543194770812988,
-0.853110134601593,
-0.3462047874927521,
-0.003947895485907793,
-1.078444480895996,
-0.19127963483333588,
-0.28776848316192627,
-0.1575910449028015,
0.20375704765319824,
0.05954046547412872,
-0.6288610696792603,
0.7613772749900818,
0.2387622445821762,
-0.2633325755596161,
0.41563084721565247,
-0.04731981083750725,
0.5358743667602539,
-1.002531886100769,
0.2887108623981476,
0.22881224751472473,
0.1866166591644287,
-0.6570000052452087,
0.35420840978622437,
-0.3604874908924103,
-0.25555554032325745,
-0.43770575523376465,
0.6429215669631958,
-0.08329389244318008,
-0.039239585399627686,
-0.05036352947354317,
0.014248337596654892,
0.0458592064678669,
0.42992544174194336,
0.26413747668266296,
0.8240024447441101,
0.26190701127052307,
-0.517998993396759,
0.3711831569671631,
0.34849604964256287,
-0.40166333317756653,
0.32454758882522583,
-0.6679264903068542,
0.3150085210800171,
-0.16901932656764984,
0.04668944329023361,
-1.127407431602478,
-0.3890763521194458,
0.3543143570423126,
-0.45273393392562866,
0.14410720765590668,
-0.05258121341466904,
-0.4780530333518982,
-0.1906619668006897,
-0.40353134274482727,
0.6659398078918457,
0.10880735516548157,
-0.42916420102119446,
0.7827893495559692,
0.6641850471496582,
-0.5853956937789917,
-0.4691866338253021,
-0.6140872836112976,
0.09088779240846634,
-0.38648608326911926,
-0.6864261031150818,
0.23734919726848602,
-0.11992385238409042,
-0.3168206810951233,
-0.008291007950901985,
0.13059712946414948,
-0.2501336634159088,
0.3010294437408447,
0.24540597200393677,
0.6576516032218933,
-0.4313468039035797,
-0.058873049914836884,
0.05823696404695511,
0.18047037720680237,
-0.07260843366384506,
-0.16215331852436066,
0.3639906048774719,
0.2721042335033417,
-0.26173970103263855,
-0.9171482920646667,
0.40599384903907776,
0.6736458539962769,
-0.307576060295105,
0.518912672996521,
0.5027614235877991,
-0.48310935497283936,
-0.41035446524620056,
-0.08887332677841187,
-0.12594300508499146,
-0.46007105708122253,
0.15281403064727783,
-0.24329473078250885,
-0.6190154552459717,
0.24070793390274048,
0.32141998410224915,
0.41329479217529297,
0.42858070135116577,
0.1403977870941162,
-0.1336689591407776,
0.9077998995780945,
0.7837716937065125,
-0.22823208570480347,
0.5631656050682068,
-0.09242235124111176,
0.26229965686798096,
-0.3377705216407776,
-0.1189277172088623,
-0.6701293587684631,
-0.5372346639633179,
-0.8566148281097412,
-0.12793247401714325,
-0.050866466015577316,
-0.20630809664726257,
-0.12642519176006317,
0.177414208650589,
-0.8098387122154236,
0.38499215245246887,
0.7749640941619873,
-0.08035724610090256,
0.12254942953586578,
0.48229339718818665,
0.22056210041046143,
-0.15073731541633606,
-0.33473220467567444,
-0.9705184698104858,
1.1513445377349854,
0.48211735486984253,
0.46002987027168274,
0.20635920763015747,
0.5230305194854736,
0.8716999888420105,
0.7637186050415039,
-0.7725504636764526,
0.5651495456695557,
-0.3781674802303314,
-0.4695452153682709,
-0.3274911046028137,
-0.7241097688674927,
-0.8335627317428589,
0.03298709914088249,
-0.542271077632904,
-0.8612199425697327,
0.08218370378017426,
-0.14332500100135803,
-0.21632267534732819,
0.27489686012268066,
-0.4302806556224823,
0.8138263821601868,
-0.614725649356842,
-0.3425534963607788,
-0.1953725665807724,
-0.38965457677841187,
0.10097403824329376,
-0.12005430459976196,
0.3022799491882324,
-0.2373393326997757,
0.18035756051540375,
1.2418957948684692,
-0.17094334959983826,
0.7346504330635071,
-0.036338187754154205,
-0.27367135882377625,
0.6524908542633057,
0.2869134247303009,
0.36504927277565,
-0.17664086818695068,
-0.09528111666440964,
0.4820190966129303,
0.06753496080636978,
-0.19384849071502686,
-0.21113979816436768,
0.5852578282356262,
-0.919475257396698,
-0.38909319043159485,
-0.49816587567329407,
-0.46175289154052734,
0.10332708805799484,
0.45023515820503235,
0.24677644670009613,
0.4878917634487152,
-0.38408544659614563,
-0.03263217210769653,
0.34370580315589905,
-0.3264234960079193,
0.387249618768692,
0.2181023806333542,
-0.15770792961120605,
-0.5071778893470764,
1.1955381631851196,
0.03561928868293762,
-0.2970665395259857,
0.13798518478870392,
0.03680380806326866,
-0.31692934036254883,
-0.7846096158027649,
-1.1161020994186401,
0.4040897786617279,
-0.5275128483772278,
0.02729632332921028,
-0.23079870641231537,
-0.42165613174438477,
-0.22952164709568024,
-0.2629919648170471,
-0.07346700876951218,
-0.07534442096948624,
-0.5744333267211914,
-0.2584689259529114,
0.3832475244998932,
1.1414740085601807,
0.48542481660842896,
0.23887117207050323,
-0.7372086644172668,
0.2646905183792114,
0.05443496257066727,
-0.040728550404310226,
0.006994703784584999,
-0.34734341502189636,
0.11252608150243759,
0.21494433283805847,
-0.0667312741279602,
-0.6545631289482117,
0.6494503617286682,
0.47233450412750244,
0.4036005139350891,
0.6809036731719971,
-0.08314833790063858,
0.7183912396430969,
-0.2947341203689575,
0.7427900433540344,
-0.04663161188364029,
-0.7811081409454346,
0.5021867752075195,
-0.3020993173122406,
-0.38859817385673523,
0.42740291357040405,
0.41163623332977295,
-0.2700596749782562,
-0.5429487824440002,
-0.6986918449401855,
-0.8953965902328491,
0.679453432559967,
0.35561999678611755,
0.0877465307712555,
0.302388995885849,
0.4391595125198364,
0.2632197439670563,
0.4661414325237274,
-0.4949890673160553,
-0.11375118046998978,
0.11518074572086334,
-0.9768557548522949,
-0.014209340326488018,
-0.2180890291929245,
-0.2569519281387329,
0.37456271052360535,
0.3324955999851227,
-0.08527371287345886,
0.10064657032489777,
-0.0624951496720314,
-0.13476550579071045,
-0.20980355143547058,
0.018200499936938286,
0.4262438714504242,
0.5782604813575745,
0.08567764610052109,
0.1191655620932579,
-0.02322545275092125,
-0.6440915465354919,
0.16847367584705353,
0.13263607025146484,
-0.5038864612579346,
-0.06761889904737473,
0.8064424991607666,
0.6735060811042786,
-0.10853765159845352,
-0.9258535504341125,
0.41557005047798157,
-0.2029935121536255,
0.04508177563548088,
-0.35739344358444214,
0.21706435084342957,
-0.3762466311454773,
0.10868068039417267,
0.426100492477417,
0.31878790259361267,
0.17339999973773956,
-0.5208545923233032,
0.39950406551361084,
0.2755527198314667,
-0.05914178863167763,
-0.4057426452636719,
0.810964822769165,
0.3443710505962372,
-0.4665336310863495,
0.7839878797531128,
0.12878911197185516,
-0.010433598421514034,
1.0241471529006958,
0.47420454025268555,
0.6605001091957092,
-0.15030348300933838,
0.34917354583740234,
0.10574468225240707,
0.05663434416055679,
0.29308757185935974,
0.17513641715049744,
-0.09643561393022537,
-0.8434016108512878,
0.19454950094223022,
-0.9944407343864441,
-0.23797351121902466,
0.16790823638439178,
-0.612449049949646,
0.10143410414457321,
-0.8042692542076111,
-0.05869969353079796,
0.5491976141929626,
-0.040435802191495895,
-0.5504814982414246,
0.5823391079902649,
0.35500824451446533,
0.6513866186141968,
-1.0912773609161377,
0.6719951629638672,
0.6325101256370544,
-0.3858596086502075,
-0.5921425223350525,
-0.013523894362151623,
0.327866792678833,
-0.7904710173606873,
0.30218306183815,
0.3797306418418884,
-0.3907094895839691,
0.1594455987215042,
-0.5677235722541809,
-0.6599263548851013,
1.0099986791610718,
0.2871062457561493,
-0.2913714349269867,
0.048754382878541946,
0.30446097254753113,
0.7563936114311218,
-0.6997709274291992,
0.26439645886421204,
0.41960105299949646,
0.31212177872657776,
-0.00784711167216301,
-0.665594756603241,
-0.1812204271554947,
-0.6663225889205933,
0.16508102416992188,
-0.10301941633224487,
-0.4264698922634125,
0.6477997303009033,
-0.029768159613013268,
-0.8958447575569153,
0.25624534487724304,
0.7352244257926941,
0.46309807896614075,
0.5755270719528198,
0.3736785352230072,
0.5032033324241638,
1.1973023414611816,
-0.038082022219896317,
1.053715705871582,
-0.3764737546443939,
0.007180335465818644,
0.7603060603141785,
-0.2500535249710083,
1.0028295516967773,
0.23165379464626312,
-0.03826696425676346,
0.5359774231910706,
0.9523070454597473,
-0.31668394804000854,
0.19210998713970184,
0.13499613106250763,
-0.2963998317718506,
0.0355181060731411,
-0.5990426540374756,
-0.1398080736398697,
0.5217117667198181,
0.2646327614784241,
-0.4475700557231903,
0.4805648624897003,
0.019146032631397247,
0.150984987616539,
0.12966413795948029,
-0.002539888257160783,
0.9798167943954468,
-0.033475544303655624,
-0.6366113424301147,
0.31270384788513184,
0.20354172587394714,
0.5539848804473877,
-0.5706852078437805,
-0.1314602643251419,
0.058464743196964264,
0.11285993456840515,
-0.2203379124403,
-0.850308358669281,
0.24168503284454346,
0.34986671805381775,
-0.006244956981390715,
-0.1949823945760727,
0.5928855538368225,
-0.41082343459129333,
-0.6863592863082886,
0.25113892555236816,
0.35734763741493225,
0.2282344400882721,
0.5867192149162292,
-0.4675339162349701,
0.3167731761932373,
0.1124764159321785,
-0.18097665905952454,
-0.034299515187740326,
0.38680675625801086,
-0.20663972198963165,
0.7206426858901978,
0.9425910115242004,
0.1706509292125702,
-0.21757233142852783,
-0.034415800124406815,
0.5657861232757568,
-0.6218677163124084,
-0.49795421957969666,
-0.8627861738204956,
0.3218773305416107,
-0.11926595866680145,
-0.6671743392944336,
0.6658758521080017,
0.5454930663108826,
0.74163818359375,
-0.17391906678676605,
1.1461181640625,
-0.13245977461338043,
0.09720061719417572,
-0.5222005844116211,
1.0275787115097046,
-0.6346948146820068,
0.20728960633277893,
-0.06291770190000534,
-0.6597177386283875,
-0.15043237805366516,
0.607751727104187,
-0.20303787291049957,
0.14906032383441925,
0.3991794288158417,
0.7438046336174011,
-0.0033714415039867163,
0.21392793953418732,
-0.2362753301858902,
-0.05738901346921921,
0.3142286539077759,
0.2768781781196594,
0.9685408473014832,
-0.3061451017856598,
0.3581029772758484,
0.020293649286031723,
-0.3043713867664337,
-0.17582516372203827,
-0.5083693861961365,
-0.9038814902305603,
-0.502131462097168,
-0.48054468631744385,
-0.07627293467521667,
-0.11651518940925598,
0.7493189573287964,
0.7547886371612549,
-1.0974111557006836,
-0.2756006717681885,
-0.1726699024438858,
0.15846656262874603,
-0.20465075969696045,
-0.2502724528312683,
0.49595507979393005,
0.27704334259033203,
-0.8650164604187012,
0.46327248215675354,
0.23763583600521088,
0.2445646971464157,
-0.2156670093536377,
-0.02185657247900963,
0.02518635243177414,
0.5788607597351074,
0.12748639285564423,
0.16911178827285767,
-0.6993513703346252,
-0.46339520812034607,
-0.21369902789592743,
-0.3983718454837799,
0.11611901223659515,
0.7513493895530701,
-0.16705380380153656,
0.2994619607925415,
0.5694705843925476,
0.6333227157592773,
0.11481042951345444,
0.19283221662044525,
0.40608540177345276,
-0.7359193563461304,
0.08547171205282211,
0.23152023553848267,
0.23033453524112701,
0.42608746886253357,
-0.5706297159194946,
0.4475730061531067,
0.4806481599807739,
-0.43837568163871765,
-0.8372113108634949,
0.23795831203460693,
-0.5771540999412537,
-0.21110831201076508,
0.7566906213760376,
-0.25722888112068176,
-0.6363502144813538,
-0.022839300334453583,
-0.228814959526062,
0.32899805903434753,
-0.2905551493167877,
1.0347086191177368,
0.4930938184261322,
0.007566818501800299,
-0.3057774603366852,
-0.3179321587085724,
0.7530859708786011,
-0.016673512756824493,
-1.015717625617981,
0.05407268926501274,
0.6487196087837219,
0.1867617666721344,
0.5210595726966858,
0.540642499923706,
0.04936791583895683,
0.1107960194349289,
0.28989335894584656,
0.0997265875339508,
-0.07198008894920349,
-0.7522467374801636,
0.20577533543109894,
0.3001139760017395,
0.14845384657382965,
-0.0855715274810791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10128v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10128v2
|
Red Teaming Language Models for Contradictory Dialogues
| 2024-05-16T14:27:32 | 2024-05-17T01:12:27 |
Xiaofei Wen, Bangzheng Li, Tenghao Huang, Muhao Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Most language models currently available are prone to self-contradiction
during dialogues. To mitigate this issue, this study explores a novel
contradictory dialogue processing task that aims to detect and modify
contradictory statements in a conversation. This task is inspired by research
on context faithfulness and dialogue comprehension, which have demonstrated
that the detection and understanding of contradictions often necessitate
detailed explanations. We develop a dataset comprising contradictory dialogues,
in which one side of the conversation contradicts itself. Each dialogue is
accompanied by an explanatory label that highlights the location and details of
the contradiction. With this dataset, we present a Red Teaming framework for
contradictory dialogue processing. The framework detects and attempts to
explain the dialogue, then modifies the existing contradictory content using
the explanation. Our experiments demonstrate that the framework improves the
ability to detect contradictory dialogues and provides valid explanations.
Additionally, it showcases distinct capabilities for modifying such dialogues.
Our study highlights the importance of the logical inconsistency problem in
conversational AI.
|
[
-0.19018249213695526,
-0.7197716236114502,
0.5121584534645081,
0.29251059889793396,
0.15236234664916992,
0.21118725836277008,
0.04096093773841858,
-0.7719063758850098,
0.16191160678863525,
0.6499667167663574,
-1.2915037870407104,
-0.07625886797904968,
-0.39002546668052673,
0.5095916986465454,
-0.3299423158168793,
1.1032617092132568,
-0.14163656532764435,
0.03435736522078514,
-0.24023106694221497,
-0.7612529397010803,
-0.9850476384162903,
-0.2596195638179779,
-0.5004956126213074,
-0.614460825920105,
0.10192504525184631,
0.5816207528114319,
0.9257707595825195,
0.4314228296279907,
0.28814810514450073,
0.5119220018386841,
0.24635249376296997,
-0.05700971931219101,
-0.4821176528930664,
0.632850706577301,
-0.4938903748989105,
-0.6456623077392578,
-0.12954829633235931,
-0.02830769494175911,
0.3706592619419098,
0.4560568928718567,
0.0058845882304012775,
-0.220681831240654,
-0.2449951022863388,
0.5710482001304626,
-0.31847476959228516,
0.07028371095657349,
-1.0083991289138794,
0.23005397617816925,
0.19984984397888184,
-0.07075150310993195,
-0.2552345395088196,
0.14257624745368958,
0.2555479407310486,
-0.5262492299079895,
0.4591370224952698,
0.00040670050657354295,
0.8539273142814636,
0.8619260787963867,
-0.012934260070323944,
-0.2558367848396301,
-0.8498574495315552,
0.6909278631210327,
-0.7108380794525146,
-0.014613539911806583,
0.31041988730430603,
0.40754735469818115,
0.011620644479990005,
-0.29695072770118713,
-1.0336793661117554,
-0.17316851019859314,
-0.3168463110923767,
0.34701356291770935,
-0.41987913846969604,
0.05842787027359009,
0.17802521586418152,
0.19339118897914886,
-0.5341208577156067,
0.05328397825360298,
-0.09564473479986191,
-0.029128314927220345,
0.49700212478637695,
0.468109130859375,
0.613781750202179,
-0.095279760658741,
-0.44356533885002136,
-0.1356111317873001,
-0.3691558241844177,
-0.3043471872806549,
0.4281274080276489,
0.19277970492839813,
-0.24577754735946655,
0.5821611881256104,
-0.38406050205230713,
0.6744730472564697,
0.10168486833572388,
0.37561294436454773,
0.1383185088634491,
-0.47662487626075745,
-0.4189108610153198,
0.013480018824338913,
0.6263998746871948,
0.2819850444793701,
-0.23027290403842926,
0.009866899810731411,
-0.4780442416667938,
0.22912254929542542,
0.14143376052379608,
-0.30669718980789185,
-0.4632498621940613,
0.5825814604759216,
-0.0642147958278656,
-0.08369001001119614,
-0.1985401213169098,
-0.5732234120368958,
-0.4774113595485687,
-0.19805027544498444,
0.4266693890094757,
-0.2812328040599823,
-0.34784045815467834,
-0.027249304577708244,
-0.3061542809009552,
0.04790457710623741,
0.46038347482681274,
-0.8060939311981201,
0.2130763977766037,
0.4506184756755829,
0.4232221245765686,
-0.008429638110101223,
-0.49775412678718567,
-0.5124436020851135,
0.03435060754418373,
0.06536656618118286,
0.8461589813232422,
-0.6382611989974976,
-0.19740840792655945,
-0.3330098092556,
-0.06578683853149414,
-0.11310624331235886,
-0.6656732559204102,
0.32974129915237427,
-0.13978737592697144,
0.7264807820320129,
-0.1586017906665802,
-0.42896851897239685,
-0.17834556102752686,
0.3444974720478058,
-0.5134111046791077,
0.47455960512161255,
0.0873112753033638,
-0.7938202619552612,
0.08847501128911972,
-0.7797061800956726,
-0.22869637608528137,
0.33504951000213623,
-0.435234397649765,
-0.5548518896102905,
-0.19164617359638214,
-0.09887519478797913,
0.03449365124106407,
-0.24129675328731537,
0.2406274825334549,
-0.2699897885322571,
-0.33186718821525574,
0.2849104702472687,
-0.34507226943969727,
1.0598751306533813,
0.16149838268756866,
-0.6444213390350342,
0.518071174621582,
-0.4038822650909424,
0.03731562942266464,
0.21813589334487915,
0.052535492926836014,
-0.17434674501419067,
0.14298874139785767,
-0.23467078804969788,
0.17370133101940155,
0.18936458230018616,
-0.47704628109931946,
-0.09452009946107864,
-0.4034181237220764,
0.604587197303772,
0.6866551637649536,
-0.1778089553117752,
0.35185423493385315,
-0.5528336763381958,
0.5227953791618347,
0.12274686992168427,
0.20842760801315308,
-0.13363765180110931,
-0.47856876254081726,
-0.8416101336479187,
-0.18391793966293335,
-0.09705934673547745,
0.8171213269233704,
-0.9186792969703674,
0.19444070756435394,
0.050002697855234146,
-0.144107386469841,
-0.8070117235183716,
0.06404222548007965,
0.49110540747642517,
0.759070634841919,
0.5093756318092346,
0.17390161752700806,
-0.8884933590888977,
-1.236356496810913,
-0.5422735214233398,
-0.5252382755279541,
0.1545703411102295,
0.3906784653663635,
0.645268440246582,
-0.5225462913513184,
1.2006038427352905,
-0.14455394446849823,
-0.243327796459198,
-0.2765204906463623,
0.4368940591812134,
0.26392877101898193,
0.7030045390129089,
0.13709592819213867,
-1.3318326473236084,
-0.5367331504821777,
-0.15110984444618225,
-0.7727220058441162,
-0.3535897433757782,
-0.5834837555885315,
0.19353599846363068,
0.546576201915741,
0.6796267628669739,
-0.3369115889072418,
0.5380357503890991,
0.968021810054779,
-0.26275214552879333,
0.6515098214149475,
-0.10016229003667831,
0.16900202631950378,
-0.6429407596588135,
-0.09725379198789597,
-0.12074436992406845,
-0.4157065749168396,
-0.7110782265663147,
0.07796680182218552,
-0.30266985297203064,
0.06841452419757843,
-0.3766826093196869,
0.4294712543487549,
-0.291807621717453,
0.19030240178108215,
-0.2671513259410858,
0.36939752101898193,
-0.03867911547422409,
0.6350468993186951,
0.1435634344816208,
0.8562792539596558,
0.12842871248722076,
-0.3503609299659729,
0.4868781566619873,
0.5772547125816345,
-0.22439317405223846,
0.6341123580932617,
-0.9314582347869873,
0.11754391342401505,
-0.17034994065761566,
0.49236246943473816,
-1.3308764696121216,
-0.2584005892276764,
0.5317809581756592,
-0.39813151955604553,
-0.038408443331718445,
-0.27827414870262146,
-0.2523004114627838,
-0.12582765519618988,
0.0986282229423523,
0.6745433211326599,
0.0835118219256401,
-0.4804755747318268,
0.6411551237106323,
0.29466429352760315,
-0.1597469002008438,
-0.6022898554801941,
-0.8713244199752808,
0.024971021339297295,
-0.22553817927837372,
-0.6427907347679138,
0.3920782506465912,
-0.364584743976593,
-0.48881813883781433,
0.11264632642269135,
-0.15913091599941254,
-0.36957594752311707,
0.14717693626880646,
0.4090603291988373,
0.45641210675239563,
-0.13750915229320526,
0.09230315685272217,
-0.22446556389331818,
-0.057283297181129456,
-0.03383742272853851,
-0.13639816641807556,
0.2961176931858063,
-0.4221423864364624,
-0.44946855306625366,
-0.8049631714820862,
0.5698773264884949,
0.6152281761169434,
0.09788188338279724,
0.795121431350708,
0.3173759877681732,
-0.16937504708766937,
-0.040661707520484924,
-0.5886138677597046,
-0.1328897327184677,
-0.4848391115665436,
0.2674485146999359,
-0.4130151569843292,
-0.9208055734634399,
0.5654924511909485,
0.13596349954605103,
-0.028487659990787506,
0.4054361581802368,
0.5141389966011047,
-0.2323843240737915,
1.0428417921066284,
0.45305636525154114,
-0.015737023204565048,
0.3809845447540283,
0.1818162500858307,
0.36820679903030396,
-0.588310182094574,
-0.2096066176891327,
-0.5262916088104248,
-0.2525515556335449,
-0.6406283974647522,
0.015879327431321144,
0.32052478194236755,
-0.06876631081104279,
-0.3128010332584381,
0.5796043872833252,
-0.45564234256744385,
0.8290911912918091,
0.3213731646537781,
-0.0538964681327343,
0.205325648188591,
-0.3635604977607727,
-0.0842512771487236,
-0.029124392196536064,
-0.8912482857704163,
-0.3464830219745636,
0.31456902623176575,
0.1946580410003662,
0.4960380494594574,
0.4556331932544708,
0.43528249859809875,
0.378359317779541,
0.19728733599185944,
-0.3865489363670349,
0.5698807239532471,
0.1433885097503662,
-0.7636979818344116,
-0.4785860776901245,
-0.6251969337463379,
-0.805338442325592,
0.2689429223537445,
-0.5478060841560364,
-0.809576690196991,
-0.2424687147140503,
0.16645856201648712,
-0.2022033929824829,
0.03481655195355415,
-1.1853891611099243,
1.166115641593933,
-0.056871745735406876,
-0.38590988516807556,
-0.22802455723285675,
-0.7786245346069336,
0.4474615454673767,
0.12901033461093903,
-0.04144471138715744,
-0.022299151867628098,
0.4268103837966919,
0.26663753390312195,
-0.5250499248504639,
1.1064711809158325,
0.013180033303797245,
-0.10440503805875778,
0.060814306139945984,
0.4632510542869568,
0.5733174085617065,
0.19036422669887543,
-0.04485765099525452,
0.01699976623058319,
-0.11202351748943329,
-0.5527546405792236,
-0.7618950009346008,
0.5916359424591064,
-0.6692973375320435,
-1.2444524765014648,
-0.27831506729125977,
-0.8593776822090149,
-0.2888379395008087,
0.10875215381383896,
0.1850912868976593,
0.017766715958714485,
-0.175197035074234,
-0.16715790331363678,
0.35634511709213257,
-0.32225501537323,
0.09124961495399475,
0.5193610787391663,
0.1125001609325409,
-0.11089465767145157,
0.858967661857605,
-0.5220451951026917,
0.6261407732963562,
0.5794103145599365,
0.11979620903730392,
-0.47865110635757446,
-0.48131731152534485,
-0.4510195553302765,
0.2596088647842407,
-0.6317834258079529,
-0.12091675400733948,
-0.44091325998306274,
-0.07793711125850677,
-0.3640386164188385,
0.06825713813304901,
-0.2625003755092621,
-0.5533345341682434,
-0.26759421825408936,
0.29473134875297546,
-0.04631248116493225,
0.8731013536453247,
-0.028794575482606888,
-0.1394241750240326,
-0.5765063166618347,
0.31735625863075256,
0.5654980540275574,
0.03772434592247009,
-0.23459403216838837,
-0.39163753390312195,
0.18060119450092316,
0.5406571626663208,
-0.31679025292396545,
-0.8472859263420105,
0.17987310886383057,
-0.11257794499397278,
0.45157790184020996,
0.0311460942029953,
0.37734079360961914,
0.7186506986618042,
-0.40695300698280334,
0.631280779838562,
0.4487510919570923,
-1.384118676185608,
0.7961055040359497,
-0.48032572865486145,
0.2888486087322235,
0.6494517922401428,
0.02122451551258564,
-0.6621465086936951,
-0.7301857471466064,
-0.8202450275421143,
-0.5968220829963684,
0.9919445514678955,
0.5609924793243408,
-0.18026001751422882,
0.1708364188671112,
0.1013459637761116,
0.027005113661289215,
0.19670984148979187,
-0.9733567237854004,
-0.32494300603866577,
-0.3904668390750885,
-0.17637933790683746,
0.13152219355106354,
0.1097543016076088,
-0.6829239130020142,
0.0020946692675352097,
0.5515192747116089,
-0.15022064745426178,
0.2172812521457672,
0.5460240840911865,
0.044237170368433,
-0.22443035244941711,
0.25850558280944824,
1.0038890838623047,
0.6249171495437622,
0.027988402172923088,
0.013859894126653671,
0.4014207422733307,
0.36097630858421326,
0.033960070461034775,
-0.0983421802520752,
-0.03974759578704834,
0.02198871225118637,
0.46109190583229065,
0.7560110092163086,
-0.006219097413122654,
-0.9327211380004883,
0.6471630334854126,
-0.21103402972221375,
-0.21494360268115997,
-0.18801899254322052,
0.30392733216285706,
-0.15126781165599823,
0.5505504012107849,
-0.02375722862780094,
0.6522805094718933,
-0.07992849498987198,
-0.8135606050491333,
0.10724826157093048,
0.5897067189216614,
-0.48121172189712524,
-0.17965807020664215,
0.6005855798721313,
0.35524463653564453,
-0.6785841584205627,
0.7109063863754272,
-0.1947689652442932,
-0.8706284165382385,
0.5248470902442932,
0.5382885932922363,
0.8297083377838135,
-0.1109434962272644,
0.3787020742893219,
0.0017407095292583108,
0.1110273078083992,
0.023972375318408012,
-0.11659770458936691,
-0.29938608407974243,
-1.208568811416626,
-0.22502350807189941,
0.11407163739204407,
-0.9187070727348328,
0.2963014245033264,
-0.580906867980957,
0.03201967105269432,
-0.2889033555984497,
0.2935957610607147,
-0.009581477381289005,
-0.329900860786438,
-0.4531286954879761,
0.08985265344381332,
-0.1684625893831253,
0.578464925289154,
-0.6211699843406677,
0.6394887566566467,
0.5279439091682434,
-0.35449182987213135,
-0.4993041157722473,
0.23196977376937866,
0.23734313249588013,
-0.8533803224563599,
0.7564818859100342,
-0.04887152463197708,
-0.5193301439285278,
-0.43185704946517944,
-0.6319006085395813,
-0.08358556032180786,
0.7042630314826965,
0.5151395201683044,
-0.4320056736469269,
0.22290082275867462,
0.08230201154947281,
0.6280478239059448,
-0.48607656359672546,
0.3152528703212738,
0.2874790132045746,
0.551086962223053,
0.19911876320838928,
-0.9570900201797485,
0.19298411905765533,
-0.2372080683708191,
-0.29695701599121094,
0.03010028600692749,
-0.7696605920791626,
0.8573859930038452,
-0.28648707270622253,
-0.5162855386734009,
0.380979061126709,
0.40071403980255127,
0.1682794988155365,
0.32389089465141296,
0.8365123867988586,
0.3968464136123657,
0.7673436999320984,
-0.02197292260825634,
0.739121675491333,
0.0002096570678986609,
0.293844997882843,
1.555177927017212,
-0.5923966765403748,
0.6776902079582214,
0.5425435304641724,
0.2030462771654129,
0.741675615310669,
0.07967516034841537,
-0.030283920466899872,
0.18615968525409698,
0.07521001249551773,
-0.47654813528060913,
-0.6299325823783875,
-0.07639404386281967,
-0.17484907805919647,
0.6976609230041504,
0.24227043986320496,
-0.05349879339337349,
-0.2451307773590088,
-0.30143240094184875,
-0.35052305459976196,
0.4505378007888794,
0.2589509189128876,
0.6591302752494812,
-0.33196699619293213,
-1.1941051483154297,
0.8606134057044983,
0.05771690979599953,
0.24990767240524292,
-0.4238860607147217,
-0.2890336215496063,
-0.21238815784454346,
0.3172376751899719,
-0.290005624294281,
-0.8649453520774841,
0.621362566947937,
-0.02923683449625969,
-0.2273906171321869,
-0.6114630103111267,
0.35123056173324585,
-0.47946760058403015,
0.1948002725839615,
0.26513516902923584,
0.5795469284057617,
-0.050130125135183334,
-0.011546891182661057,
-1.3353947401046753,
0.2708268463611603,
0.5653475522994995,
0.513046383857727,
0.00932453852146864,
0.5850788950920105,
0.3274819850921631,
0.9452003240585327,
0.4133472740650177,
-0.25362318754196167,
-0.4065524637699127,
0.05890245363116264,
0.7732092142105103,
-0.5814095735549927,
-0.521641194820404,
-0.8064325451850891,
0.26672855019569397,
-0.0940285250544548,
-0.41079699993133545,
0.6702103614807129,
0.3095245957374573,
0.8889518976211548,
0.03088723123073578,
0.8074499368667603,
0.08735732734203339,
0.5361502170562744,
-0.6454920172691345,
0.4963259994983673,
-0.606468677520752,
0.6390708088874817,
-0.2738330066204071,
-0.5492722392082214,
-0.20727048814296722,
0.8582492470741272,
-0.21196556091308594,
-0.16238471865653992,
0.8553472757339478,
0.8966193199157715,
-0.02567840926349163,
0.7745145559310913,
0.31571218371391296,
0.7744449973106384,
0.3488192558288574,
0.8014907240867615,
1.1963050365447998,
-0.5557091236114502,
0.7690851092338562,
0.25109604001045227,
0.04837840422987938,
-0.06450137495994568,
-0.8246247172355652,
-0.8832234740257263,
-0.938175618648529,
-0.508668065071106,
-0.4972444772720337,
0.2839130759239197,
0.8838752508163452,
0.7891526818275452,
-0.8162474632263184,
-0.21378710865974426,
-0.8847237825393677,
0.5103884935379028,
-0.15625163912773132,
-0.3021335303783417,
-0.4491371214389801,
-0.39920905232429504,
-0.8963301777839661,
0.6990781426429749,
0.4860060513019562,
0.2708348333835602,
-0.18240049481391907,
-0.2052670270204544,
-0.25412458181381226,
-0.16033901274204254,
0.011161678470671177,
0.7401944994926453,
-0.898913562297821,
-0.6153551936149597,
-0.3529451787471771,
-0.014649013988673687,
0.14349834620952606,
0.9173070788383484,
-0.8973850607872009,
0.48708680272102356,
0.36434492468833923,
0.7313727140426636,
0.3313940763473511,
-0.05718380957841873,
0.7825546860694885,
-0.6571252942085266,
0.07392816990613937,
0.4836258888244629,
0.21511408686637878,
0.5104770064353943,
-0.3454058766365051,
0.5061280131340027,
0.4798104465007782,
-0.5508765578269958,
-0.7095025777816772,
0.6406852602958679,
-1.0485970973968506,
-0.48960480093955994,
0.9518892765045166,
-0.20699813961982727,
0.03887477144598961,
-0.5125445127487183,
-0.256816029548645,
0.00883471593260765,
-0.24623320996761322,
0.9259001016616821,
0.8377044200897217,
-0.5570477247238159,
0.04240753874182701,
-0.11221030354499817,
0.46109509468078613,
1.0420597791671753,
-0.6347832679748535,
0.22153978049755096,
0.34165385365486145,
0.19734786450862885,
0.2440693974494934,
0.6706442832946777,
0.3221432566642761,
0.28507232666015625,
0.03276631608605385,
-0.5296663045883179,
0.16960489749908447,
-0.19034184515476227,
-0.27228569984436035,
0.0049607520923018456,
-0.5156137943267822,
-0.14359238743782043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10121v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10121v1
|
Distilling Implicit Multimodal Knowledge into LLMs for Zero-Resource Dialogue Generation
| 2024-05-16T14:21:33 | 2024-05-16T14:21:33 |
Bo Zhang, Hui Ma, Jian Ding, Jian Wang, Bo Xu, Hongfei Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Integrating multimodal knowledge into large language models (LLMs) represents
a significant advancement in dialogue generation capabilities. However, the
effective incorporation of such knowledge in zero-resource scenarios remains a
substantial challenge due to the scarcity of diverse, high-quality dialogue
datasets. To address this, we propose the Visual Implicit Knowledge
Distillation Framework (VIKDF), an innovative approach aimed at enhancing LLMs
for enriched dialogue generation in zero-resource contexts by leveraging
implicit multimodal knowledge. VIKDF comprises two main stages: knowledge
distillation, using an Implicit Query Transformer to extract and encode visual
implicit knowledge from image-text pairs into knowledge vectors; and knowledge
integration, employing a novel Bidirectional Variational Information Fusion
technique to seamlessly integrate these distilled vectors into LLMs. This
enables the LLMs to generate dialogues that are not only coherent and engaging
but also exhibit a deep understanding of the context through implicit
multimodal cues, effectively overcoming the limitations of zero-resource
scenarios. Our extensive experimentation across two dialogue datasets shows
that VIKDF outperforms existing state-of-the-art models in generating
high-quality dialogues. The code will be publicly available following
acceptance.
|
[
-0.4783797562122345,
-0.6736723780632019,
0.905714213848114,
0.27742117643356323,
-0.5041186213493347,
0.2398211658000946,
-0.18733422458171844,
-0.22086966037750244,
-0.17121154069900513,
0.46576225757598877,
-0.8133618831634521,
-0.635452926158905,
-0.43284013867378235,
0.020855166018009186,
-0.3283204734325409,
0.9973246455192566,
0.05138586461544037,
0.21586348116397858,
-0.6259857416152954,
-0.331295371055603,
-0.4071064889431,
-0.2162231057882309,
-0.1353634148836136,
-0.3132731020450592,
0.5468699336051941,
0.5312830209732056,
0.3021031320095062,
0.3014252781867981,
-0.004835142754018307,
0.345773845911026,
-0.07521756738424301,
0.4019497036933899,
-0.8374581336975098,
0.5612284541130066,
-0.053850095719099045,
-0.3156411945819855,
-0.07774610072374344,
-0.15609227120876312,
0.52913898229599,
0.5191888809204102,
-0.1974402368068695,
-0.003789772279560566,
0.24866721034049988,
0.5450313091278076,
-0.7325282096862793,
0.49595779180526733,
-0.6493386626243591,
0.12959149479866028,
0.16454879939556122,
-0.21427254378795624,
-0.17345456779003143,
-0.20570024847984314,
0.3757292926311493,
-0.6695821285247803,
0.24837073683738708,
-0.18810416758060455,
0.5571940541267395,
0.6046743988990784,
-0.529746413230896,
-0.14115792512893677,
-1.0202027559280396,
0.6266157031059265,
-0.5342987775802612,
0.29099521040916443,
0.05297687649726868,
0.39146688580513,
-0.042355459183454514,
-0.8297852277755737,
-1.0496242046356201,
-0.16441649198532104,
-0.00907989777624607,
0.33834710717201233,
-0.18660849332809448,
0.2060738056898117,
0.2653648555278778,
0.32340866327285767,
-0.2964695990085602,
-0.25643688440322876,
-0.409386545419693,
0.014269704930484295,
0.30235815048217773,
0.21724514663219452,
-0.0035725992638617754,
-0.4269084632396698,
-0.5714414119720459,
-0.2116103619337082,
-0.4753749668598175,
-0.08024708181619644,
0.0854441225528717,
0.2138364613056183,
-0.24177990853786469,
0.5318351984024048,
-0.5255144238471985,
0.5198307633399963,
0.1042538434267044,
-0.3833523094654083,
0.1429980844259262,
-0.6919284462928772,
-0.37024781107902527,
0.26999518275260925,
0.7511930465698242,
0.5783136487007141,
-0.00021631212439388037,
0.20178352296352386,
0.02148742415010929,
-0.12478287518024445,
0.0292191319167614,
-1.074121356010437,
-0.06659816950559616,
0.12868620455265045,
-0.11744853109121323,
-0.3906075358390808,
-0.23685961961746216,
-0.9356234073638916,
-0.5290248990058899,
-0.35139620304107666,
0.06008436903357506,
-0.40343931317329407,
-0.4935569763183594,
-0.08365579694509506,
-0.32504573464393616,
0.16086886823177338,
0.584921658039093,
-0.6405537128448486,
-0.1565021425485611,
0.28691232204437256,
0.7198158502578735,
0.3046494424343109,
0.07903517037630081,
-0.5046520233154297,
0.490291029214859,
-0.09294039011001587,
0.5827888250350952,
-0.5724809169769287,
-0.8027669191360474,
0.12288026511669159,
-0.20417168736457825,
0.22145651280879974,
-0.27051305770874023,
0.44643089175224304,
-0.1635141670703888,
0.10722051560878754,
-0.30854132771492004,
-0.038328029215335846,
-0.17388343811035156,
0.2964497208595276,
-0.6432442665100098,
0.8035343289375305,
0.0794450119137764,
-0.5327515602111816,
0.5267513394355774,
-0.5697466731071472,
-0.20651210844516754,
0.28747010231018066,
-0.6000149250030518,
-0.041107866913080215,
0.23473607003688812,
0.36158931255340576,
0.29946956038475037,
-0.5267531275749207,
0.335879921913147,
-0.44923943281173706,
-0.01117978896945715,
0.2763025164604187,
-0.9448152184486389,
0.22339877486228943,
0.354548841714859,
-0.26953911781311035,
-0.190888911485672,
-0.7267972826957703,
0.006386333145201206,
-0.0037878653965890408,
-0.16473183035850525,
-0.37635180354118347,
-0.16814327239990234,
-0.1303282231092453,
0.46095582842826843,
0.15877382457256317,
-0.5876073837280273,
0.2367755025625229,
-0.2323889583349228,
0.36199191212654114,
0.7993807792663574,
0.18910525739192963,
0.552817165851593,
0.08656811714172363,
0.28216639161109924,
0.4521920382976532,
0.3403662443161011,
-0.4382225275039673,
-0.42888468503952026,
-0.9880427718162537,
-0.44082537293434143,
-0.02318079210817814,
0.29100891947746277,
-1.343375325202942,
-0.21704955399036407,
-0.403286337852478,
-0.213252991437912,
-0.5391870737075806,
0.42531511187553406,
0.47269484400749207,
0.7250404953956604,
0.2582358717918396,
-0.03600780665874481,
-0.2765984833240509,
-0.9050647616386414,
0.28047364950180054,
-0.367533802986145,
0.12039000540971756,
0.730661928653717,
0.2203795313835144,
-0.17570199072360992,
1.032792091369629,
-0.695638120174408,
-0.3068368136882782,
-0.33649975061416626,
0.5368145108222961,
0.12015914916992188,
0.34005028009414673,
0.46159297227859497,
-0.9982147812843323,
-0.5325520634651184,
0.07261954247951508,
-0.9482468366622925,
-0.0910588726401329,
0.0967421680688858,
-0.3562263548374176,
0.22465834021568298,
0.44673964381217957,
-0.6471500992774963,
0.32968229055404663,
0.4706294536590576,
-0.1996239721775055,
0.170954629778862,
-0.2259746491909027,
0.3490985631942749,
-1.2695926427841187,
-0.013062018901109695,
0.0955478772521019,
-0.09508910775184631,
-0.49526065587997437,
-0.426518976688385,
-0.21841412782669067,
-0.22194869816303253,
-0.6281242370605469,
0.4826057255268097,
-0.48557743430137634,
0.2896946966648102,
0.03269874304533005,
0.1141844391822815,
0.19715897738933563,
0.8156988024711609,
0.07502694427967072,
0.4811859130859375,
0.290984570980072,
-0.41339030861854553,
0.6666080355644226,
0.3030390739440918,
-0.3821639120578766,
0.8400382399559021,
-0.5154494047164917,
0.05390038713812828,
-0.45939958095550537,
0.134439617395401,
-1.3060721158981323,
-0.2547518014907837,
0.23311340808868408,
-0.152413472533226,
0.3920183777809143,
-0.6335891485214233,
-0.23943400382995605,
-0.07392239570617676,
-0.14123228192329407,
0.49607759714126587,
0.5501269698143005,
-0.4702652394771576,
0.9085813164710999,
0.10267769545316696,
-0.5575298070907593,
-0.9277013540267944,
-0.5516200065612793,
-0.04654040187597275,
-0.050149958580732346,
-0.6829351186752319,
0.1079370453953743,
-0.1677311509847641,
-0.12325795739889145,
0.24963627755641937,
-0.3122265040874481,
-0.17395155131816864,
-0.3248477876186371,
0.5157603621482849,
0.3121078610420227,
-0.1607731580734253,
-0.06494800746440887,
0.4058462381362915,
-0.02034430392086506,
-0.18156512081623077,
-0.40509647130966187,
0.3530253469944,
0.08146610110998154,
-0.6933486461639404,
-0.23019273579120636,
0.47326263785362244,
0.974682092666626,
-0.01833239011466503,
0.607835590839386,
0.6782518029212952,
0.017411069944500923,
-0.23290161788463593,
-0.8182719349861145,
-0.0012977885780856013,
-0.475842148065567,
0.41082096099853516,
-0.21610011160373688,
-1.0554189682006836,
0.20559382438659668,
-0.4314735531806946,
-0.010239562951028347,
0.0805283784866333,
0.6032097935676575,
-0.2461763620376587,
1.0976736545562744,
0.7744912505149841,
0.22006872296333313,
0.5027512907981873,
-0.3715568482875824,
0.24505728483200073,
-0.658424437046051,
-0.6345810294151306,
-0.18265169858932495,
-0.16512970626354218,
-0.4172604978084564,
-0.8167690634727478,
0.7207112312316895,
0.19956913590431213,
0.07594943046569824,
-0.2634667456150055,
-0.15829455852508545,
0.45003727078437805,
0.5470523238182068,
0.047012943774461746,
0.42315739393234253,
0.26751330494880676,
-0.4210290312767029,
-0.0999087542295456,
-0.6871089935302734,
-0.2994250953197479,
0.9751641154289246,
0.05968841165304184,
0.8721303939819336,
0.09941785037517548,
0.5387474894523621,
0.23647315800189972,
0.21752452850341797,
-0.49030959606170654,
0.5097488760948181,
-0.029748277738690376,
-0.2781478762626648,
-0.2973055839538574,
-0.45439741015434265,
-0.4001487195491791,
0.2381746917963028,
-0.4221177101135254,
-0.43426114320755005,
0.4414837956428528,
0.2746395170688629,
-0.43415796756744385,
-0.024855326861143112,
-0.7664266228675842,
0.6863069534301758,
-0.2478761076927185,
-0.6785351037979126,
-0.19389362633228302,
-0.466962069272995,
0.6271838545799255,
0.009692532941699028,
0.09971398860216141,
-0.2735632061958313,
0.3493078351020813,
0.16655026376247406,
-0.5030418634414673,
0.8500305414199829,
-0.43946224451065063,
-0.2902105152606964,
0.39366668462753296,
0.03157253563404083,
0.4129623770713806,
0.4823523163795471,
0.3558944761753082,
0.13764706254005432,
-0.10897626727819443,
-0.07984703034162521,
-0.7868599891662598,
0.810743510723114,
-0.6578997373580933,
-0.5288412570953369,
-0.2004709094762802,
-0.45289596915245056,
-0.28280654549598694,
0.12482781708240509,
0.0389544777572155,
0.5574283003807068,
-0.5150636434555054,
0.29869696497917175,
0.9280051589012146,
-0.304843932390213,
0.38639068603515625,
0.725879967212677,
-0.0908726155757904,
-0.5498186349868774,
1.0993777513504028,
-0.025680122897028923,
0.32530832290649414,
0.3816930055618286,
-0.19281859695911407,
-0.6861883401870728,
-0.2532975971698761,
-0.6151692271232605,
0.06946787983179092,
-0.8167505264282227,
-0.29480886459350586,
-0.7264201045036316,
-0.2401847392320633,
-0.2804706394672394,
0.1556873768568039,
-0.3622880280017853,
-0.3094637095928192,
-0.12198251485824585,
-0.13942644000053406,
0.4564327001571655,
0.7276380658149719,
-0.23683618009090424,
0.03091917745769024,
-0.8878117203712463,
0.5796206593513489,
0.7981702089309692,
0.36591988801956177,
-0.1257823407649994,
0.014720918610692024,
-0.23662230372428894,
0.4272285997867584,
-0.20101940631866455,
-0.6222862005233765,
0.40844351053237915,
0.20832253992557526,
0.658683180809021,
0.5227024555206299,
0.2303624302148819,
0.7584534287452698,
-0.5210996866226196,
0.9142560958862305,
0.6056967973709106,
-0.7145772576332092,
0.5036476850509644,
-0.1766638308763504,
0.3683267831802368,
0.5729272961616516,
0.3047841787338257,
-0.5368717312812805,
-0.45736372470855713,
-0.1483897715806961,
-0.9791622757911682,
0.8082318305969238,
0.3137836158275604,
0.27068591117858887,
0.16453348100185394,
0.030401311814785004,
0.10195621848106384,
0.46483027935028076,
-0.5007618069648743,
-0.27592933177948,
-0.6282030940055847,
-0.2871367335319519,
-0.05971537157893181,
-0.6284424066543579,
-0.48633596301078796,
-0.20333918929100037,
0.4149843156337738,
-0.2980118989944458,
0.1472328156232834,
0.2792210578918457,
-0.2967439293861389,
-0.015325226821005344,
0.3759285807609558,
0.6430556178092957,
0.42667055130004883,
-0.20922791957855225,
0.047886114567518234,
0.12316800653934479,
-0.4351426064968109,
0.2499300092458725,
0.16530868411064148,
0.041827090084552765,
0.05537773296236992,
0.10233581811189651,
1.0895870923995972,
0.2340664267539978,
-0.6310676336288452,
0.5769811272621155,
-0.5140523314476013,
-0.33351990580558777,
-0.1560209095478058,
0.18615207076072693,
0.11884421855211258,
0.7044561505317688,
0.4161020517349243,
-0.09765218198299408,
0.12182357907295227,
-0.25648996233940125,
0.0168969314545393,
0.4034866690635681,
-0.4247579574584961,
-0.0711519792675972,
0.5830521583557129,
0.651370108127594,
0.34764203429222107,
0.7598305344581604,
0.004323440138250589,
-0.13626313209533691,
0.14239419996738434,
0.07328661531209946,
1.05748450756073,
-0.04140876978635788,
0.42103174328804016,
0.22201810777187347,
0.004867897368967533,
0.2552569508552551,
0.13643015921115875,
-0.7575289607048035,
-0.6199604272842407,
-0.6133559346199036,
-1.0271410942077637,
-0.3502885401248932,
0.32069700956344604,
-0.5619703531265259,
0.14532721042633057,
-0.39116236567497253,
-0.05821865797042847,
-0.1714460849761963,
-0.39982473850250244,
-0.7595551013946533,
-0.14371396601200104,
0.6066054105758667,
0.4209102690219879,
-0.7185668349266052,
0.6606450080871582,
0.3217218816280365,
-0.5695168972015381,
-0.5195642709732056,
-0.044809725135564804,
0.06036684662103653,
-0.7331194281578064,
0.9952244162559509,
-0.13150551915168762,
-0.3713097870349884,
-0.09386540949344635,
-0.7552945017814636,
-0.6130787134170532,
1.397782802581787,
0.7636237144470215,
-0.6591455340385437,
0.024346426129341125,
0.5513434410095215,
0.3639543950557709,
-0.2998306155204773,
0.33045193552970886,
0.33385196328163147,
0.4343944191932678,
0.90333092212677,
-0.8270493745803833,
-0.11734309047460556,
-0.5571915507316589,
0.3861863315105438,
-0.12828464806079865,
-0.5016804337501526,
0.6461036205291748,
-0.17511002719402313,
-0.4239332675933838,
-0.12363278120756149,
0.6804931163787842,
0.07511620223522186,
0.16914144158363342,
0.44116097688674927,
0.5559557676315308,
0.3788849115371704,
-0.19981719553470612,
0.7035422325134277,
-0.48247382044792175,
0.10436411201953888,
1.1923257112503052,
-0.5067395567893982,
0.3297010064125061,
0.6190760731697083,
0.3083270192146301,
0.558094322681427,
0.11525195091962814,
0.22309288382530212,
0.9034312963485718,
-0.1558552384376526,
-0.9009547829627991,
-0.45565563440322876,
-0.4977465271949768,
-0.469599187374115,
0.5021563172340393,
0.44668927788734436,
-0.20275110006332397,
-0.5089659094810486,
0.09697942435741425,
-0.2829938530921936,
-0.1544017344713211,
0.006243614945560694,
1.2570650577545166,
0.0744454488158226,
-0.5707349181175232,
0.6673727631568909,
-0.2511935830116272,
0.40593674778938293,
-0.7142378091812134,
-0.6663707494735718,
-0.41295865178108215,
0.07294069975614548,
-0.009569988586008549,
-0.8335883617401123,
-0.16416029632091522,
0.21916934847831726,
-0.4484519958496094,
-0.5319055318832397,
0.6826452612876892,
-1.005872130393982,
-0.3666861057281494,
0.25222134590148926,
0.8075629472732544,
-0.13908211886882782,
0.0404253751039505,
-0.5071636438369751,
0.0779903456568718,
0.13054895401000977,
-0.0626547783613205,
0.27471113204956055,
0.900825023651123,
0.26244863867759705,
0.5690414905548096,
0.828711986541748,
-0.16886988282203674,
0.006597581785172224,
0.3151150941848755,
1.3440933227539062,
-0.37707850337028503,
-0.39269864559173584,
-0.8966099619865417,
0.8227963447570801,
-0.3648187816143036,
0.032460767775774,
0.5889178514480591,
0.2944624125957489,
0.7384197115898132,
-0.034128446131944656,
1.1298857927322388,
0.03690207004547119,
-0.07366060465574265,
-0.5601624250411987,
0.8633056282997131,
-0.62628173828125,
0.22454743087291718,
-0.4467393457889557,
-0.8750386834144592,
0.3516996502876282,
0.36808016896247864,
0.09352588653564453,
-0.14680476486682892,
0.40385568141937256,
0.8877705931663513,
-0.05735383555293083,
-0.06009827181696892,
0.5726392865180969,
0.4613274931907654,
0.4519276022911072,
0.5417925715446472,
1.154744029045105,
0.06093030050396919,
0.8938109278678894,
-0.2284286469221115,
-0.22489164769649506,
-0.10890781879425049,
-1.1092194318771362,
-0.8513832092285156,
-0.839305579662323,
-0.15427082777023315,
-0.23505385220050812,
0.032435283064842224,
0.7669187188148499,
0.7478882074356079,
-0.3658277690410614,
-0.019892411306500435,
-0.0784783735871315,
0.19706733524799347,
0.22239114344120026,
-0.22428609430789948,
-0.24072381854057312,
-0.2641168236732483,
-1.000096321105957,
0.43109479546546936,
0.6475298404693604,
0.24421949684619904,
-0.5083728432655334,
-0.23081395030021667,
-0.04649980738759041,
0.06483171880245209,
0.7710577249526978,
0.11693456768989563,
-0.6036360859870911,
-0.01900644227862358,
-0.21860858798027039,
-0.09331460297107697,
-0.15287308394908905,
0.7962625622749329,
-0.9043741226196289,
0.8801328539848328,
0.40334051847457886,
0.24628159403800964,
0.9244793653488159,
-0.1394069343805313,
0.9615517258644104,
-1.1035829782485962,
0.4213080108165741,
0.06394179910421371,
0.31483498215675354,
0.2637820541858673,
-0.30561912059783936,
0.25339654088020325,
0.41467389464378357,
-0.039852745831012726,
-0.9329923987388611,
0.2660474479198456,
-1.0016961097717285,
-0.21086890995502472,
1.1796773672103882,
-0.12617510557174683,
-0.15178963541984558,
-0.11477333307266235,
-0.39458218216896057,
0.3226146697998047,
-0.6217317581176758,
0.4679372012615204,
0.6387194991111755,
0.019932860508561134,
-0.2823767066001892,
-0.4108734726905823,
0.6804465651512146,
0.0732986256480217,
-0.5194668769836426,
0.1275821030139923,
0.8880855441093445,
0.18552035093307495,
0.17112423479557037,
0.7042641639709473,
-0.09564431756734848,
0.11396099627017975,
0.038615547120571136,
0.14933614432811737,
-0.4880775511264801,
-0.43871963024139404,
-0.06065281480550766,
0.1840362250804901,
-0.1787380576133728,
-0.009761752560734749
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13034v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13034v2
|
Autonomous Workflow for Multimodal Fine-Grained Training Assistants Towards Mixed Reality
| 2024-05-16T14:20:30 | 2024-06-05T21:47:37 |
Jiahuan Pei, Irene Viola, Haochen Huang, Junxiao Wang, Moonisa Ahsan, Fanghua Ye, Jiang Yiming, Yao Sai, Di Wang, Zhumin Chen, Pengjie Ren, Pablo Cesar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Autonomous artificial intelligence (AI) agents have emerged as promising
protocols for automatically understanding the language-based environment,
particularly with the exponential development of large language models (LLMs).
However, a fine-grained, comprehensive understanding of multimodal environments
remains under-explored. This work designs an autonomous workflow tailored for
integrating AI agents seamlessly into extended reality (XR) applications for
fine-grained training. We present a demonstration of a multimodal fine-grained
training assistant for LEGO brick assembly in a pilot XR environment.
Specifically, we design a cerebral language agent that integrates LLM with
memory, planning, and interaction with XR tools and a vision-language agent,
enabling agents to decide their actions based on past experiences. Furthermore,
we introduce LEGO-MRTA, a multimodal fine-grained assembly dialogue dataset
synthesized automatically in the workflow served by a commercial LLM. This
dataset comprises multimodal instruction manuals, conversations, XR responses,
and vision question answering. Last, we present several prevailing
open-resource LLMs as benchmarks, assessing their performance with and without
fine-tuning on the proposed dataset. We anticipate that the broader impact of
this workflow will advance the development of smarter assistants for seamless
user interaction in XR environments, fostering research in both AI and HCI
communities.
|
[
-0.50067538022995,
-0.8849836587905884,
0.5557396411895752,
0.034130699932575226,
0.016638532280921936,
0.312663733959198,
-0.36166200041770935,
-0.6307600736618042,
0.3341521620750427,
0.28875890374183655,
-0.5855153799057007,
-0.12804444134235382,
-0.23987111449241638,
-0.04781060293316841,
-0.0505693219602108,
0.5839506387710571,
-0.2730238735675812,
0.1005900576710701,
-0.374231219291687,
-0.158706396818161,
-0.5271010398864746,
-0.5057399868965149,
-0.4684276580810547,
-0.5829496383666992,
0.5935871601104736,
0.418965220451355,
1.0346497297286987,
0.8827513456344604,
0.3120594620704651,
0.4709218740463257,
0.16308383643627167,
0.5309193134307861,
-0.058994993567466736,
-0.030942313373088837,
-0.33906373381614685,
-0.23710881173610687,
-0.5917174816131592,
-0.2537877857685089,
0.29988786578178406,
0.565436840057373,
-0.16567744314670563,
0.05128728970885277,
0.07992404699325562,
0.3987389802932739,
-0.6535797119140625,
0.4947533905506134,
-0.0024408989120274782,
0.35953980684280396,
0.11096370965242386,
-0.2745623290538788,
-0.216421976685524,
0.025109605863690376,
-0.14909785985946655,
-0.5829017758369446,
-0.006442807149142027,
0.01645839586853981,
0.3340941369533539,
0.4754611551761627,
-0.13272741436958313,
-0.30412429571151733,
-0.978325605392456,
0.5688273906707764,
-0.3578161895275116,
0.5741556286811829,
0.1520666480064392,
0.5610015988349915,
-0.26856333017349243,
-0.5996531248092651,
-0.896390974521637,
-0.29774853587150574,
-0.09315697848796844,
0.12927433848381042,
0.19585461914539337,
0.31304818391799927,
-0.02170080691576004,
0.3551434576511383,
-0.6287394762039185,
0.15633803606033325,
-0.1244872510433197,
-0.04656820371747017,
0.4055146872997284,
0.5182415246963501,
0.007942813448607922,
0.00519712595269084,
-0.2936837077140808,
-0.4396809935569763,
-0.03049316070973873,
0.20211048424243927,
-0.046890854835510254,
0.5099319219589233,
-0.45474717020988464,
0.8645226955413818,
-0.5272209644317627,
0.7829139828681946,
-0.1812475025653839,
-0.2385127991437912,
0.2747136354446411,
-0.3903663456439972,
-0.3748951554298401,
-0.0503702312707901,
0.7325919270515442,
0.1669045239686966,
0.316707968711853,
-0.2229584902524948,
-0.3642689287662506,
0.12136223167181015,
0.3398146331310272,
-0.5486682653427124,
-0.22968356311321259,
0.13284504413604736,
-0.2275676280260086,
0.08246324956417084,
-0.3153857886791229,
-0.729060709476471,
-0.527450680732727,
-0.7307344675064087,
0.3989962637424469,
-0.35192105174064636,
-0.23330673575401306,
-0.005054071079939604,
0.062246084213256836,
0.11452337354421616,
0.6044722199440002,
-0.7424395680427551,
0.12521618604660034,
0.567104160785675,
0.6120015382766724,
-0.11438057571649551,
-0.6350656747817993,
-0.5388981699943542,
0.206202894449234,
-0.3141993284225464,
0.8442572355270386,
-0.8034948706626892,
-0.20610465109348297,
-0.00674102921038866,
0.004380849190056324,
-0.10632572323083878,
-0.5178877711296082,
-0.014375176280736923,
-0.44328323006629944,
-0.04064666107296944,
0.40468570590019226,
-0.08852877467870712,
-0.1161922737956047,
0.7323799729347229,
-0.4508051574230194,
0.5951594710350037,
0.10952559858560562,
-0.06296256929636002,
0.2741386890411377,
-0.8977326154708862,
-0.34301337599754333,
-0.0982997789978981,
-0.4705129861831665,
0.08849913626909256,
0.002897729864344001,
0.1538189947605133,
0.6082983613014221,
0.0005828707944601774,
0.14234153926372528,
-0.3844577670097351,
-0.1965351551771164,
0.18985146284103394,
-0.7227045297622681,
0.32160288095474243,
0.08979422599077225,
-0.2648075819015503,
0.3456721305847168,
-0.8980145454406738,
0.09009968489408493,
-0.1227034255862236,
-0.3520165979862213,
-0.10547608137130737,
-0.12214385718107224,
0.17660436034202576,
0.613775372505188,
0.3343358039855957,
-0.5654245018959045,
0.2080109864473343,
-0.06306920945644379,
-0.011314045637845993,
0.7260332107543945,
-0.2994246184825897,
0.4582097828388214,
-0.39513275027275085,
0.45709851384162903,
0.10390521585941315,
0.30448123812675476,
-0.20652182400226593,
-0.3486641049385071,
-0.7803570032119751,
-0.5132284760475159,
-0.18501527607440948,
0.5024389028549194,
-1.0317280292510986,
0.24960629642009735,
-0.33617106080055237,
-0.14312325417995453,
-0.4034351110458374,
0.23709602653980255,
0.5764210224151611,
0.30760371685028076,
0.31832486391067505,
-0.3968808352947235,
-0.362838476896286,
-0.765897810459137,
0.3609985411167145,
-0.011267796158790588,
0.07048792392015457,
0.6123124957084656,
0.48451218008995056,
-0.5005785226821899,
0.9528120160102844,
-0.23344947397708893,
-0.5231866836547852,
-0.06920311599969864,
0.2868926227092743,
-0.23318856954574585,
0.6173878908157349,
0.19634705781936646,
-0.745259165763855,
-0.22939665615558624,
0.45749810338020325,
-0.9118539094924927,
0.4254307448863983,
-0.3672434985637665,
0.060984767973423004,
0.2805488705635071,
0.46601369976997375,
-0.7389625906944275,
0.3504212200641632,
0.6355393528938293,
-0.3375478982925415,
0.3730579912662506,
-0.47428226470947266,
0.23310238122940063,
-0.9782785773277283,
-0.09530041366815567,
-0.13685935735702515,
-0.321860134601593,
-0.41088858246803284,
0.10808325558900833,
-0.25764766335487366,
-0.07163969427347183,
-0.738154947757721,
0.7791886329650879,
-0.4521757662296295,
-0.4427567720413208,
-0.40436118841171265,
0.07251676917076111,
0.0036443667486310005,
1.0285648107528687,
0.5123604536056519,
0.8167085647583008,
0.5977840423583984,
-0.451007217168808,
0.40069177746772766,
0.35548076033592224,
-0.24958708882331848,
0.5955946445465088,
-0.2816859185695648,
0.10672273486852646,
-0.02763589285314083,
0.04813922941684723,
-0.569664716720581,
-0.37151867151260376,
0.2899182140827179,
-0.2626256048679352,
0.1399451047182083,
0.13403522968292236,
-0.865027666091919,
-0.12966260313987732,
0.05715888366103172,
0.3787657618522644,
0.20456582307815552,
-0.5866235494613647,
1.125346064567566,
0.32436850666999817,
-0.05176105722784996,
-0.47025784850120544,
-0.6575270891189575,
0.21462056040763855,
0.28179576992988586,
-0.5247666835784912,
0.08320968598127365,
-0.36625921726226807,
-0.28968483209609985,
-0.020554833114147186,
0.057432662695646286,
-0.49720266461372375,
-0.2831919491291046,
0.4494636058807373,
0.07560096681118011,
-0.25436171889305115,
-0.4190206229686737,
-0.019263742491602898,
-0.08620759099721909,
0.009794414974749088,
0.2616159915924072,
0.630050539970398,
-0.3838595747947693,
-0.556671679019928,
-0.5146565437316895,
0.4087815582752228,
0.9138304591178894,
-0.20923516154289246,
0.6369531154632568,
0.8052070140838623,
-0.280788779258728,
0.015143693424761295,
-0.40430954098701477,
-0.034441377967596054,
-0.5150020718574524,
0.2858326733112335,
-0.4639672636985779,
-0.7629234790802002,
0.578037440776825,
-0.006454196292907,
0.08047109842300415,
-0.23590408265590668,
0.9304240345954895,
-0.1400659829378128,
1.134622573852539,
0.8157420754432678,
0.2552952468395233,
0.6249116063117981,
-0.2967401444911957,
-0.05582669377326965,
-0.7651514410972595,
-0.557473361492157,
0.056607428938150406,
-0.3925681412220001,
-0.29085880517959595,
-0.8440998196601868,
0.29085439443588257,
-0.3992888629436493,
-0.10210171341896057,
0.18762387335300446,
-0.28022831678390503,
0.5928009152412415,
0.6501397490501404,
0.16685427725315094,
0.370387464761734,
-0.24884912371635437,
0.04252723976969719,
0.40597379207611084,
-0.7168514132499695,
-0.45903369784355164,
0.5176205039024353,
0.29328781366348267,
0.9899759292602539,
-0.13497294485569,
0.4940335154533386,
0.25707218050956726,
0.0979558452963829,
-0.7652884721755981,
0.6469378471374512,
0.14455462992191315,
-0.4998023509979248,
-0.18680614233016968,
-0.16633503139019012,
-0.715857744216919,
0.17821931838989258,
-0.19764457643032074,
-0.4659821391105652,
0.46761468052864075,
0.2266843616962433,
-0.555099606513977,
0.2986840009689331,
-0.6939529776573181,
0.9193166494369507,
-0.39509710669517517,
-0.44233936071395874,
-0.4299893379211426,
-0.7603130340576172,
0.24920228123664856,
-0.0498979426920414,
0.20157106220722198,
0.008727791719138622,
0.07741409540176392,
0.32373782992362976,
-0.1909712851047516,
1.0015560388565063,
-0.24071800708770752,
-0.10932565480470657,
0.28142374753952026,
0.20903967320919037,
0.35797184705734253,
-0.02193683572113514,
0.2472110092639923,
0.15693718194961548,
-0.0861322209239006,
-0.2513378858566284,
-0.560015082359314,
0.6537559032440186,
-0.7496772408485413,
-0.08254300057888031,
-0.3893638551235199,
-1.1960976123809814,
-0.37173935770988464,
0.22231967747211456,
-0.4397391974925995,
0.5865982174873352,
-0.18213777244091034,
0.13793613016605377,
0.42150506377220154,
-0.18045224249362946,
0.616316556930542,
0.5748544931411743,
0.015105719678103924,
-0.3168286383152008,
0.9435343742370605,
-0.13662336766719818,
0.31589195132255554,
0.42923298478126526,
0.017300760373473167,
0.007261390332132578,
-0.5994626879692078,
-0.7840239405632019,
-0.2776905596256256,
-0.5721951127052307,
-0.09827393293380737,
-0.6394374966621399,
-0.12915484607219696,
-0.2695518136024475,
-0.41524893045425415,
-0.7251558303833008,
-0.21265187859535217,
-0.2920650243759155,
0.274978905916214,
0.1311180740594864,
0.7041709423065186,
-0.21792078018188477,
0.3879750669002533,
-0.8754451274871826,
0.597533106803894,
0.5790563225746155,
0.4519360065460205,
-0.06444244831800461,
-0.24484987556934357,
-0.6105442643165588,
0.2884407639503479,
0.03328888863325119,
-0.10176633298397064,
0.3374263346195221,
0.1210208311676979,
0.508488118648529,
0.3886911869049072,
-0.19158828258514404,
1.0433273315429688,
-0.6673988699913025,
0.6217235326766968,
-0.007531353738158941,
-0.37729504704475403,
0.10472668707370758,
-0.23518626391887665,
0.31918099522590637,
0.6662818789482117,
0.02231113240122795,
-0.22110269963741302,
-0.4911153316497803,
-0.25384366512298584,
-0.5130935907363892,
0.7596985697746277,
0.0367535725235939,
0.23720969259738922,
-0.0002518318360671401,
-0.010610025376081467,
0.1988334208726883,
0.2569206655025482,
-0.5674744844436646,
-0.2315232753753662,
-0.22510893642902374,
-0.22089612483978271,
-0.05522168427705765,
0.13804294168949127,
-0.35705721378326416,
-0.24525363743305206,
0.3840113878250122,
-0.4515525698661804,
0.4392502009868622,
0.021993307396769524,
-0.25869280099868774,
-0.12630540132522583,
0.032899875193834305,
0.7049863934516907,
0.5732045769691467,
-0.15816888213157654,
-0.0514349564909935,
-0.14189165830612183,
-0.36003386974334717,
0.13241054117679596,
0.3226691484451294,
0.3346977233886719,
-0.26861923933029175,
0.3608677387237549,
0.6285956501960754,
0.09600123763084412,
-1.1619006395339966,
0.45987647771835327,
-0.24327854812145233,
-0.06992603838443756,
-0.4311991035938263,
0.30515560507774353,
-0.22440463304519653,
0.9360766410827637,
-0.027844663709402084,
0.4030875861644745,
0.09478709846735,
-0.7054106593132019,
0.3021077513694763,
0.4635781943798065,
-0.3706061542034149,
-0.3385314345359802,
0.47335708141326904,
0.16213418543338776,
-0.4881080985069275,
0.36171796917915344,
-0.3431321084499359,
0.0013463521609082818,
0.5929502844810486,
0.39939597249031067,
0.7789720892906189,
0.07583893090486526,
0.15037809312343597,
-0.14378948509693146,
0.21026872098445892,
0.14452829957008362,
0.3637952506542206,
-0.3445355296134949,
-0.7430776357650757,
-0.5602954030036926,
-0.6402284502983093,
-0.7330539226531982,
-0.13055619597434998,
-0.5088205337524414,
-0.04945148527622223,
-0.515480101108551,
0.36749574542045593,
-0.11607815325260162,
-0.3741992712020874,
-0.8192703127861023,
0.4604288339614868,
0.6437721848487854,
0.7341786026954651,
-0.6828954815864563,
0.9607006311416626,
0.8950514793395996,
-0.4444575011730194,
-0.5227584838867188,
-0.18561047315597534,
-0.11135443300008774,
-0.9718101024627686,
0.38845962285995483,
-0.05119287595152855,
-0.3568010628223419,
-0.1995646357536316,
-0.15499068796634674,
-0.7521807551383972,
1.0822875499725342,
0.2541755139827728,
-0.35954105854034424,
-0.1470576524734497,
0.33091625571250916,
0.6541028618812561,
-0.4147073030471802,
0.34801989793777466,
0.5202199220657349,
0.3491133451461792,
0.12095177173614502,
-1.0703738927841187,
-0.33469176292419434,
-0.3250617980957031,
-0.1405607908964157,
0.11823098361492157,
-0.7514170408248901,
0.6251925230026245,
-0.13991086184978485,
0.3169080317020416,
0.18552762269973755,
0.8109074831008911,
0.15250913798809052,
0.4938892424106598,
0.48351234197616577,
0.45708632469177246,
0.2501896321773529,
0.29831331968307495,
0.8064926862716675,
-0.4230436682701111,
-0.025896118953824043,
1.3982274532318115,
-0.23937101662158966,
0.8663707971572876,
0.6188220977783203,
0.23815985023975372,
0.6267472505569458,
0.48985356092453003,
0.310203492641449,
0.6612286567687988,
-0.28789615631103516,
-0.4243313670158386,
-0.10725260525941849,
-0.34557878971099854,
0.037660133093595505,
0.8090842366218567,
0.31087765097618103,
-0.15658491849899292,
-0.31209859251976013,
0.7267851233482361,
-0.23537136614322662,
0.025291962549090385,
-0.36340034008026123,
1.0233416557312012,
-0.19649085402488708,
-0.5686531066894531,
0.38032206892967224,
-0.27038174867630005,
0.6085479855537415,
-0.5196566581726074,
-0.26306161284446716,
-0.2060484141111374,
0.45487749576568604,
-0.09307325631380081,
-1.1000807285308838,
0.3427189290523529,
-0.04814237356185913,
-0.11505664139986038,
-0.431941956281662,
0.32263773679733276,
-0.5736714601516724,
-0.25324633717536926,
0.16443294286727905,
0.7244358062744141,
0.2736820876598358,
0.0428820438683033,
-0.8233153223991394,
-0.008276695385575294,
-0.3302771747112274,
-0.2804694175720215,
0.5505178570747375,
0.5573818683624268,
-0.031444571912288666,
0.8341071605682373,
0.5153099298477173,
-0.16021636128425598,
0.15727832913398743,
-0.019785849377512932,
1.055713415145874,
-0.4487903118133545,
-0.3748716115951538,
-0.6348900198936462,
0.6217849254608154,
0.24741314351558685,
-0.19369126856327057,
0.5332702398300171,
0.6074210405349731,
0.9269813895225525,
-0.12179070711135864,
0.440605491399765,
-0.343904048204422,
-0.00912240706384182,
-0.5039829611778259,
0.5293856263160706,
-0.6585556864738464,
-0.2309144139289856,
-0.15958432853221893,
-0.7960057854652405,
-0.3036095201969147,
0.5773023962974548,
0.08184505254030228,
0.17951248586177826,
0.48560094833374023,
1.0367639064788818,
-0.49492400884628296,
-0.15910020470619202,
0.5472601056098938,
0.01905662566423416,
0.3867723047733307,
0.4148569703102112,
0.7834491729736328,
0.062384191900491714,
0.6593332290649414,
-0.7766796946525574,
-0.1807711124420166,
-0.07070525735616684,
-0.7815700769424438,
-0.9759472012519836,
-0.4009791314601898,
-0.20298847556114197,
-0.03326452523469925,
0.032675206661224365,
1.3087522983551025,
0.9493788480758667,
-0.5835084915161133,
-0.20605798065662384,
-0.1928875744342804,
-0.1966053545475006,
-0.3522671163082123,
-0.19878801703453064,
0.0021501476876437664,
-0.2081974446773529,
-0.9740129709243774,
0.8481263518333435,
0.40835240483283997,
0.07198142260313034,
-0.6018325686454773,
-0.3430820405483246,
-0.12230000644922256,
-0.02781405672430992,
0.8378425240516663,
0.49072137475013733,
-0.598250687122345,
-0.33653759956359863,
-0.059413447976112366,
-0.11712270230054855,
0.33289462327957153,
0.6389201283454895,
-1.0082764625549316,
0.8398468494415283,
0.2700003683567047,
0.7917200922966003,
0.1934487670660019,
-0.0507449246942997,
0.5383362770080566,
-0.7688210010528564,
0.4365999400615692,
0.3973996341228485,
0.23072730004787445,
0.23154275119304657,
-0.2501651346683502,
0.3894287943840027,
-0.13764166831970215,
-0.5393564105033875,
-0.7277769446372986,
-0.017277875915169716,
-1.090985894203186,
-0.13822078704833984,
0.9050353765487671,
0.022489050403237343,
-0.46613433957099915,
-0.2202184945344925,
-0.4149150252342224,
0.18271397054195404,
-0.4176199436187744,
0.7363153696060181,
0.2886987328529358,
-0.6415007710456848,
-0.25279319286346436,
-0.7432215213775635,
0.15141543745994568,
0.28557783365249634,
-1.114303708076477,
0.20123660564422607,
0.7738659977912903,
-0.32088637351989746,
0.4154333174228668,
0.46401700377464294,
0.10668475180864334,
0.4609781801700592,
0.1842106580734253,
0.3875800371170044,
-0.5721407532691956,
-0.8738425970077515,
-0.30940553545951843,
0.08007573336362839,
-0.1137184277176857,
-0.4934827387332916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00008v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00008v2
|
KnowledgeHub: An end-to-end Tool for Assisted Scientific Discovery
| 2024-05-16T13:17:14 | 2024-06-17T10:23:46 |
Shinnosuke Tanaka, James Barry, Vishnudev Kuruvanthodi, Movina Moses, Maxwell J. Giammona, Nathan Herr, Mohab Elkaref, Geeth De Mel
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DL
|
This paper describes the KnowledgeHub tool, a scientific literature
Information Extraction (IE) and Question Answering (QA) pipeline. This is
achieved by supporting the ingestion of PDF documents that are converted to
text and structured representations. An ontology can then be constructed where
a user defines the types of entities and relationships they want to capture. A
browser-based annotation tool enables annotating the contents of the PDF
documents according to the ontology. Named Entity Recognition (NER) and
Relation Classification (RC) models can be trained on the resulting annotations
and can be used to annotate the unannotated portion of the documents. A
knowledge graph is constructed from these entity and relation triples which can
be queried to obtain insights from the data. Furthermore, we integrate a suite
of Large Language Models (LLMs) that can be used for QA and summarisation that
is grounded in the included documents via a retrieval component. KnowledgeHub
is a unique tool that supports annotation, IE and QA, which gives the user full
insight into the knowledge discovery pipeline.
|
[
-0.3827078640460968,
-0.6679739356040955,
0.6967906951904297,
-0.004767970182001591,
-0.14668168127536774,
0.2501968443393707,
0.39645764231681824,
-0.684471070766449,
0.5112354755401611,
0.551711916923523,
-0.19717808067798615,
-0.6295652389526367,
-0.470418244600296,
0.3657692074775696,
-0.5853307247161865,
0.8744527101516724,
0.07291071861982346,
0.20685289800167084,
-0.9580963253974915,
-0.09217951446771622,
0.06388944387435913,
-0.12779885530471802,
-0.4209533929824829,
-0.2674959897994995,
0.6997223496437073,
0.5246710181236267,
0.7198273539543152,
0.5273355841636658,
0.747158408164978,
0.1868957132101059,
-0.13051378726959229,
0.10229192674160004,
-0.24323415756225586,
0.4011198878288269,
-0.4072379767894745,
-0.6334462761878967,
-0.3899365961551666,
-0.07247962057590485,
0.37069734930992126,
0.7366311550140381,
-0.000576471327804029,
0.4121305048465729,
-0.37920430302619934,
0.4742110073566437,
-0.5305286645889282,
0.460627019405365,
-0.2273676097393036,
-0.0462150014936924,
-0.38298505544662476,
-0.2647770941257477,
-0.16304443776607513,
-0.4572872817516327,
0.28313395380973816,
-1.1861740350723267,
0.1562424749135971,
0.5864419341087341,
0.6542420983314514,
0.24153025448322296,
-0.4388503134250641,
-0.47454559803009033,
-0.4079441428184509,
0.43126535415649414,
-0.6464634537696838,
0.4514608681201935,
0.38951411843299866,
0.6110126972198486,
-0.47519752383232117,
-1.0332367420196533,
-0.905799925327301,
0.04867686703801155,
-0.14210371673107147,
0.28159135580062866,
0.0578824058175087,
0.07604124397039413,
0.20877914130687714,
0.41666272282600403,
-0.5249148011207581,
-0.15119603276252747,
-0.5090442299842834,
-0.3680790662765503,
0.5077464580535889,
-0.04399120435118675,
0.36440151929855347,
-0.5551130771636963,
0.009116481058299541,
-0.13559745252132416,
-0.3976578116416931,
0.08466142416000366,
0.13654978573322296,
-0.007424324285238981,
0.38480687141418457,
1.060034155845642,
-0.26196861267089844,
0.5917080044746399,
-0.1875050663948059,
-0.07683883607387543,
0.018831891939044,
-0.21327921748161316,
-0.06716307252645493,
0.11704875528812408,
0.7120441198348999,
0.22257398068904877,
-0.27337750792503357,
-0.3924946188926697,
0.11046306043863297,
-0.3635663688182831,
-0.06847191601991653,
-0.7477334141731262,
-0.5292463302612305,
0.3464133143424988,
-0.11127623915672302,
-0.4297775626182556,
-0.05842568352818489,
-0.9578185081481934,
-0.7466400265693665,
0.03438033163547516,
0.2970326244831085,
-0.3438378870487213,
-0.39265838265419006,
-0.2653574049472809,
-0.7136669158935547,
0.28755712509155273,
0.39882293343544006,
-0.5209488272666931,
0.2669125497341156,
0.21948745846748352,
1.0514767169952393,
-0.1378171294927597,
0.03970691189169884,
-0.35277366638183594,
0.7240385413169861,
-0.15560787916183472,
1.1407994031906128,
-0.39697015285491943,
-0.4834860861301422,
-0.3007689416408539,
0.16379490494728088,
0.37467160820961,
-0.0723106637597084,
0.432320237159729,
-1.0558584928512573,
0.5264242887496948,
-0.570561408996582,
-0.5462412238121033,
-0.82431960105896,
0.3076445758342743,
-0.9383948445320129,
1.1447311639785767,
0.6028823256492615,
-1.3367283344268799,
0.3096884489059448,
-1.0531635284423828,
-0.3804806172847748,
0.462356299161911,
-0.2002716064453125,
-0.15378214418888092,
-0.4598980247974396,
0.15708230435848236,
0.3711337745189667,
-0.648703396320343,
0.4363621473312378,
-0.5792388319969177,
0.03286265209317207,
-0.23235395550727844,
0.36266499757766724,
1.003981351852417,
0.2593139111995697,
-0.04574581980705261,
0.22561794519424438,
-0.8971881866455078,
-0.14353717863559723,
0.23402534425258636,
-0.25947821140289307,
-0.6589932441711426,
-0.10048241168260574,
0.15921266376972198,
0.08506803959608078,
0.3911053240299225,
-0.9084102511405945,
0.5039575099945068,
-0.27306443452835083,
0.5667168498039246,
0.35395845770835876,
0.19318269193172455,
0.3588029742240906,
-0.1392294019460678,
0.4384520649909973,
-0.033395107835531235,
0.19038623571395874,
-0.21114031970500946,
-0.6823079586029053,
-0.5258657336235046,
-0.06107504665851593,
0.3507654666900635,
0.5991359949111938,
-0.540778398513794,
0.4526030123233795,
-0.2783564329147339,
-0.808005690574646,
-0.6475816965103149,
0.08797689527273178,
-0.2508271634578705,
0.8694524168968201,
0.5687658786773682,
-0.20790782570838928,
-0.5838433504104614,
-0.7119284868240356,
0.35057881474494934,
-0.27704140543937683,
-0.11653190851211548,
0.13857153058052063,
0.49726298451423645,
-0.3485777974128723,
1.4780248403549194,
-0.46302440762519836,
-0.3369443714618683,
-0.13878490030765533,
0.06262117624282837,
0.09513796120882034,
0.176838219165802,
0.24812106788158417,
-1.160417079925537,
-0.34591102600097656,
0.4137164354324341,
-1.2909516096115112,
-0.23851355910301208,
0.2538502812385559,
-0.15560446679592133,
0.030546993017196655,
0.5366194248199463,
-0.6353081464767456,
0.42327937483787537,
0.2330041080713272,
-0.3349718749523163,
0.646604597568512,
0.020357057452201843,
0.27098146080970764,
-1.2406891584396362,
0.608884871006012,
-0.3936556875705719,
-0.20467987656593323,
-0.2211706042289734,
0.053892359137535095,
0.13325351476669312,
-0.18386705219745636,
-0.1727670133113861,
0.5036646723747253,
-0.4979887306690216,
-0.3866563141345978,
-0.2692432999610901,
0.5258515477180481,
0.4950186610221863,
0.1123119592666626,
0.14891919493675232,
0.5771046280860901,
0.6191114187240601,
-0.4557027816772461,
0.6420078873634338,
0.7011314630508423,
0.06039145216345787,
0.16880443692207336,
-0.7001020908355713,
0.20263807475566864,
-0.14778368175029755,
0.2093113362789154,
-0.8374084830284119,
-0.41058969497680664,
0.2764008641242981,
-0.39769473671913147,
0.1398734301328659,
0.12463825941085815,
-0.7701736092567444,
-0.4395330846309662,
-0.23134541511535645,
0.12753620743751526,
0.0352051705121994,
-0.4113346338272095,
0.9763009548187256,
0.5211252570152283,
-0.4423838257789612,
-0.47220301628112793,
-0.28780800104141235,
0.1800893396139145,
0.01108505204319954,
-0.8744629621505737,
0.41804221272468567,
-0.03667189180850983,
-0.27777111530303955,
0.2628026008605957,
-0.12893013656139374,
0.006610483396798372,
-0.09762495756149292,
0.5830743908882141,
0.22025282680988312,
0.10300267487764359,
0.24411746859550476,
0.35951584577560425,
0.01682545803487301,
0.20197466015815735,
-0.33276310563087463,
0.27643272280693054,
-0.05201047286391258,
-0.3084731698036194,
-0.07977762073278427,
0.5012416243553162,
0.8386510610580444,
-0.19284255802631378,
0.7140330672264099,
0.6787999868392944,
-0.46799781918525696,
0.44505584239959717,
-0.5774344205856323,
-0.27862444519996643,
-0.4237337112426758,
0.11836308240890503,
-0.3541879951953888,
-0.7648647427558899,
0.8435475826263428,
-0.3681471347808838,
0.43925806879997253,
0.6845747828483582,
-0.08038880676031113,
-0.3050714433193207,
0.7664885520935059,
0.9824177026748657,
0.10528255999088287,
0.006674799136817455,
-0.22536081075668335,
0.5127304792404175,
-0.9722346067428589,
-0.7619467377662659,
-0.7532032132148743,
0.08669577538967133,
-0.11539661139249802,
-0.23104043304920197,
0.6366994380950928,
0.738462507724762,
-0.026530543342232704,
0.41446635127067566,
-0.6718875169754028,
0.10319041460752487,
0.9233373999595642,
-0.09689540416002274,
0.6490480303764343,
-0.2809142470359802,
-0.27266526222229004,
0.19265630841255188,
-0.8474616408348083,
-0.6231858134269714,
1.1570974588394165,
0.049727726727724075,
0.34626924991607666,
0.013561342842876911,
0.4780501127243042,
0.4137597382068634,
0.3298611640930176,
-0.6585499048233032,
0.5553073287010193,
0.6931914687156677,
-0.8282397985458374,
-0.6804743409156799,
0.03761120140552521,
-0.6220815777778625,
-0.07440287619829178,
-0.4035016894340515,
-0.48592257499694824,
0.15719449520111084,
-0.13269107043743134,
-0.15186749398708344,
0.3139304220676422,
-0.6281676292419434,
0.6903568506240845,
-0.19626547396183014,
-0.46563172340393066,
-0.2630484998226166,
-0.8378727436065674,
0.2861076593399048,
-0.3467332124710083,
0.5016615390777588,
0.36174383759498596,
0.26502788066864014,
1.1721009016036987,
-0.24394546449184418,
0.45439812541007996,
-0.12292833626270294,
0.2065599262714386,
0.5055803656578064,
0.236090749502182,
0.5855318307876587,
0.2781578004360199,
-0.19434413313865662,
0.08785627782344818,
0.6475161910057068,
-0.5902209877967834,
-0.589176595211029,
0.45095303654670715,
-0.6691804528236389,
-0.7796797752380371,
-0.5559173822402954,
-0.8848064541816711,
0.005495369900017977,
0.6936435103416443,
0.017865179106593132,
0.04677955061197281,
0.05482020601630211,
0.15691044926643372,
0.4356118440628052,
-0.22922426462173462,
0.23551765084266663,
0.8176079988479614,
-0.6949018836021423,
-0.21090945601463318,
0.5207436680793762,
0.17566896975040436,
-0.11786522716283798,
0.3959425687789917,
0.23300276696681976,
-0.5147832632064819,
-0.7974073886871338,
-0.1493760496377945,
0.17483316361904144,
-0.9054010510444641,
-0.4368358254432678,
-1.1198415756225586,
-0.023095468059182167,
-0.9228420257568359,
-0.05743740499019623,
0.06789710372686386,
-0.6133385300636292,
-0.23006272315979004,
-0.4802728593349457,
0.9138039946556091,
0.9677072167396545,
-0.23359879851341248,
0.1777820885181427,
-0.8623006939888,
0.3605898320674896,
0.11641886830329895,
0.06490025669336319,
-0.22236956655979156,
-0.10807842016220093,
-0.38609057664871216,
-0.17308643460273743,
-0.3746595084667206,
-1.2586700916290283,
0.23225688934326172,
0.04273605719208717,
0.4770946800708771,
0.5592350363731384,
0.3847868740558624,
0.32000619173049927,
0.06758928298950195,
0.75572270154953,
0.13748471438884735,
-0.6232553720474243,
0.8078265190124512,
-0.4298783838748932,
-0.06633033603429794,
0.35386091470718384,
0.8011071681976318,
-0.40779364109039307,
-0.2595953643321991,
-0.6070013642311096,
-0.9517711400985718,
0.2828858196735382,
-0.23778052628040314,
-0.6532992124557495,
-0.02867310121655464,
0.4111746847629547,
0.5228539109230042,
0.32807672023773193,
-0.6243278980255127,
0.0674646869301796,
-0.3778352439403534,
0.0475512370467186,
0.41723760962486267,
-0.08928052335977554,
-0.4720326066017151,
-0.23870283365249634,
0.8576388359069824,
-0.33789584040641785,
-0.0936635434627533,
0.5683010220527649,
-0.2526590824127197,
-0.2545788884162903,
0.05807862430810928,
-0.21658816933631897,
0.6872427463531494,
-0.49809038639068604,
0.06432946026325226,
0.004181348253041506,
-0.5557119250297546,
-0.4257388114929199,
0.4004305601119995,
-0.4009458124637604,
-0.12972553074359894,
0.4186125695705414,
0.24109086394309998,
-0.05423889309167862,
-0.8116016983985901,
0.33596310019493103,
0.1735306978225708,
-0.0841452106833458,
-0.4634898900985718,
-0.10308858007192612,
0.35679665207862854,
0.35237452387809753,
0.78349369764328,
-0.027479121461510658,
0.4808574318885803,
-0.3325009047985077,
0.2734304666519165,
0.5236604809761047,
-0.3015546202659607,
-0.18989266455173492,
0.7654855847358704,
0.06676048785448074,
-0.17612320184707642,
0.6078888177871704,
-0.3846278488636017,
-0.5064665675163269,
0.4469657838344574,
0.35892337560653687,
0.3568311035633087,
0.07997718453407288,
0.37899622321128845,
0.2636851668357849,
0.20369279384613037,
0.32822540402412415,
0.15687651932239532,
-0.343422532081604,
-0.5558768510818481,
-0.26454266905784607,
-0.7971776127815247,
-0.7474822998046875,
-0.18084968626499176,
-0.6583837866783142,
0.5291823744773865,
-0.24124185740947723,
0.0014247159706428647,
0.2745124101638794,
0.22831225395202637,
-0.6040454506874084,
0.07547501474618912,
-0.46446412801742554,
1.043771505355835,
-0.6678540706634521,
0.8914929032325745,
0.8953222632408142,
-0.8280069231987,
-0.7418168783187866,
-0.7320072054862976,
-0.07944366335868835,
-0.5569305419921875,
0.6738346815109253,
0.015097355470061302,
-0.020650425925850868,
0.5014521479606628,
-0.651975154876709,
-0.9637728929519653,
1.6623735427856445,
0.1005619689822197,
-0.5169760584831238,
-0.29356643557548523,
0.002284718444570899,
0.6054007411003113,
-0.15403051674365997,
0.7535051107406616,
0.34833455085754395,
0.8093684911727905,
0.22445367276668549,
-0.70489901304245,
0.16025033593177795,
-0.3999265730381012,
-0.779068112373352,
-0.0123590137809515,
-0.36808574199676514,
0.35417884588241577,
-0.5739148855209351,
-0.32643482089042664,
-0.3547162413597107,
0.7784647345542908,
0.2242407351732254,
0.6937026381492615,
0.3158320188522339,
0.5514642000198364,
0.9827841520309448,
0.07597611099481583,
0.726598858833313,
-0.30511707067489624,
0.08837903290987015,
0.6202942132949829,
-0.4147200584411621,
0.6633533239364624,
0.8932181596755981,
-0.2412744164466858,
0.6393746137619019,
0.8371250629425049,
-0.07167308032512665,
0.4981357157230377,
0.07384492456912994,
0.05205120891332626,
-0.0878068208694458,
-0.5329629182815552,
-0.3272671103477478,
-0.006539962720125914,
0.5176360011100769,
0.011530161835253239,
-0.2927078604698181,
0.20164361596107483,
-0.18653292953968048,
0.047789376229047775,
-0.07619874179363251,
0.7296834588050842,
0.02126099355518818,
-0.48547837138175964,
0.10875573009252548,
-0.22577029466629028,
0.39451301097869873,
-0.6594905257225037,
-0.2276487797498703,
0.00043391765211708844,
-0.5196729302406311,
-0.6355559229850769,
-0.969523549079895,
0.3030513823032379,
-0.5232269167900085,
-0.4537401795387268,
0.30311188101768494,
0.7306910157203674,
-0.06901829689741135,
-0.2867148220539093,
0.48469316959381104,
0.5200608968734741,
0.30982252955436707,
-0.16436922550201416,
-0.28456634283065796,
-0.36933934688568115,
-0.05058034881949425,
-0.5051354169845581,
0.2133098691701889,
0.3780773878097534,
-0.3742048144340515,
1.1260954141616821,
1.0763981342315674,
0.02574356086552143,
0.1097857728600502,
-0.13969358801841736,
1.015152096748352,
-0.7647266983985901,
-0.4814530313014984,
-0.06979990005493164,
0.32124581933021545,
-0.29451489448547363,
0.038269851356744766,
0.589776873588562,
0.7616312503814697,
0.5316057205200195,
0.08641697466373444,
1.1487290859222412,
-0.6380894184112549,
0.6673309206962585,
-0.030039377510547638,
0.7526297569274902,
-0.42436209321022034,
0.25848388671875,
-0.05231127142906189,
-0.9183651208877563,
-0.3178213834762573,
0.36258354783058167,
-0.1869833618402481,
-0.49612462520599365,
0.8891854882240295,
0.65367192029953,
0.13507886230945587,
0.44800636172294617,
0.0408860482275486,
0.1733245998620987,
0.7384657859802246,
0.08554165065288544,
0.3641296327114105,
-0.43991905450820923,
0.7132900357246399,
-0.23812010884284973,
-0.3858814537525177,
0.03182750940322876,
-0.9073156714439392,
-1.0008162260055542,
-0.8783846497535706,
-0.20490142703056335,
-0.1739712357521057,
-0.07155373692512512,
0.538206160068512,
0.509397029876709,
-0.9032875299453735,
0.23978187143802643,
-0.4260689318180084,
0.06932464987039566,
0.004951129667460918,
-0.3396196961402893,
0.7131146788597107,
-0.09498410671949387,
-0.4615550935268402,
0.46463537216186523,
0.44627857208251953,
-0.005164258182048798,
-0.5748055577278137,
0.08514785766601562,
-0.478767991065979,
-0.35290953516960144,
0.39405420422554016,
0.5044488906860352,
-0.42613470554351807,
-0.11882179975509644,
0.5197858810424805,
0.206949383020401,
-0.2993450164794922,
0.4429076015949249,
-0.9223433136940002,
0.6569201350212097,
0.6349970102310181,
0.7112493515014648,
0.7647202610969543,
-0.1630774438381195,
0.7301755547523499,
-0.23807455599308014,
-0.03436492010951042,
0.3443398177623749,
0.2209305763244629,
0.5958016514778137,
-0.5983547568321228,
0.6979957222938538,
0.3979949951171875,
-0.7238447666168213,
-0.9321524500846863,
-0.060196902602910995,
-1.4036744832992554,
-0.23696772754192352,
0.7498390674591064,
-0.1152934804558754,
-0.24258384108543396,
-0.6683148741722107,
-0.29724958539009094,
0.6281993985176086,
-0.4262559115886688,
1.00016450881958,
0.805590808391571,
-0.13622243702411652,
-0.11052487045526505,
-0.6289225220680237,
0.43676817417144775,
0.10931500047445297,
-0.986914336681366,
-0.12787200510501862,
0.3886374533176422,
0.23120582103729248,
0.6862598657608032,
0.32705870270729065,
-0.2825333774089813,
0.226822167634964,
-0.18347100913524628,
0.5094520449638367,
-0.6036404371261597,
-0.22238735854625702,
0.46708565950393677,
0.4526338577270508,
0.12695054709911346,
0.0952364057302475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10051v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10051v2
|
MarkLLM: An Open-Source Toolkit for LLM Watermarking
| 2024-05-16T12:40:01 | 2024-05-24T07:15:54 |
Leyi Pan, Aiwei Liu, Zhiwei He, Zitian Gao, Xuandong Zhao, Yijian Lu, Binglin Zhou, Shuliang Liu, Xuming Hu, Lijie Wen, Irwin King
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7
|
LLM watermarking, which embeds imperceptible yet algorithmically detectable
signals in model outputs to identify LLM-generated text, has become crucial in
mitigating the potential misuse of large language models. However, the
abundance of LLM watermarking algorithms, their intricate mechanisms, and the
complex evaluation procedures and perspectives pose challenges for researchers
and the community to easily experiment with, understand, and assess the latest
advancements. To address these issues, we introduce MarkLLM, an open-source
toolkit for LLM watermarking. MarkLLM offers a unified and extensible framework
for implementing LLM watermarking algorithms, while providing user-friendly
interfaces to ensure ease of access. Furthermore, it enhances understanding by
supporting automatic visualization of the underlying mechanisms of these
algorithms. For evaluation, MarkLLM offers a comprehensive suite of 12 tools
spanning three perspectives, along with two types of automated evaluation
pipelines. Through MarkLLM, we aim to support researchers while improving the
comprehension and involvement of the general public in LLM watermarking
technology, fostering consensus and driving further advancements in research
and application. Our code is available at https://github.com/THU-BPM/MarkLLM.
|
[
-0.3683317005634308,
-0.6100072860717773,
0.6536464095115662,
0.40892642736434937,
-0.5887547135353088,
0.1571068912744522,
-0.17953743040561676,
-0.5248048305511475,
-0.14129504561424255,
0.5926337838172913,
-0.4188465178012848,
-0.8506373763084412,
-0.833811342716217,
-0.03300977498292923,
-0.41473186016082764,
0.5536802411079407,
-0.2506515085697174,
0.22268471121788025,
-0.2504071891307831,
-0.169009730219841,
-0.4012777805328369,
-0.5227776765823364,
-0.6124365925788879,
-0.37762561440467834,
0.3915998637676239,
0.011827966198325157,
0.2891067564487457,
0.9426240921020508,
0.5499562621116638,
0.17328009009361267,
-0.11457737535238266,
0.21973475813865662,
-0.45650383830070496,
0.51389080286026,
-0.09106332063674927,
-0.2587563097476959,
-0.2999281883239746,
0.20198187232017517,
0.7018089294433594,
0.2651060223579407,
0.4065034091472626,
0.3657826781272888,
0.11930558830499649,
0.5948601961135864,
-0.8744384050369263,
0.48493924736976624,
-0.7391141057014465,
-0.03977556899189949,
-0.4078774154186249,
-0.478357195854187,
-0.5115984678268433,
-0.47282251715660095,
-0.3540424406528473,
-0.580254852771759,
-0.3148491382598877,
0.26164689660072327,
0.6438403725624084,
0.2412962019443512,
-0.06902093440294266,
-0.37437769770622253,
-0.6472901105880737,
0.9440828561782837,
-0.7951939105987549,
0.449550062417984,
0.2947026789188385,
0.3095960021018982,
-0.14813335239887238,
-0.6556859016418457,
-0.35485178232192993,
-0.02902827039361,
0.151593416929245,
0.1560935378074646,
-0.24803738296031952,
-0.19042718410491943,
0.2175637185573578,
0.4450472593307495,
-0.39144814014434814,
0.21004852652549744,
-0.059204231947660446,
-0.19071149826049805,
0.47536733746528625,
0.251745343208313,
0.38785091042518616,
0.39592915773391724,
-0.586988627910614,
-0.03540094569325447,
-0.9948551058769226,
-0.30982905626296997,
0.5623992681503296,
0.34934568405151367,
0.006378798745572567,
0.3795604705810547,
0.05670083686709404,
0.7013176083564758,
-0.39168429374694824,
0.08230528980493546,
-0.04995613545179367,
0.036344125866889954,
-0.2626653015613556,
0.07441085577011108,
0.7753975987434387,
0.36856892704963684,
0.1383393555879593,
0.1486002802848816,
-0.3770197331905365,
-0.31851837038993835,
-0.17545659840106964,
-0.9574698805809021,
-0.26233601570129395,
0.07695302367210388,
-0.3729926645755768,
-0.23536603152751923,
0.2658766806125641,
-0.6704711318016052,
-0.8607139587402344,
-0.3573436737060547,
0.5454466938972473,
-0.004989738576114178,
-0.25130850076675415,
0.14496414363384247,
-0.19093525409698486,
0.319413423538208,
0.6578245162963867,
-0.40598541498184204,
0.19877862930297852,
0.8934616446495056,
0.760388970375061,
-0.5717890858650208,
-0.04706805571913719,
-0.5992513298988342,
0.33460816740989685,
-0.15196160972118378,
0.755501925945282,
-0.5465145707130432,
-0.5502742528915405,
-0.07497482746839523,
0.05503921955823898,
-0.037373822182416916,
-0.7694910168647766,
0.31098610162734985,
-0.6871881484985352,
0.3827778697013855,
-0.04058093950152397,
-0.8850443959236145,
-0.21864363551139832,
0.2078595757484436,
-1.0008094310760498,
1.1015831232070923,
-0.07052642852067947,
-0.7401487827301025,
0.3227843642234802,
-0.8206406831741333,
-0.12815135717391968,
0.271879643201828,
0.012877078726887703,
-0.7629234790802002,
-0.039059750735759735,
-0.046339843422174454,
0.48856455087661743,
-0.5248478055000305,
0.09034350514411926,
-0.40110108256340027,
-0.4613185226917267,
0.5294026136398315,
-0.3347642123699188,
0.7888399362564087,
0.25564488768577576,
-0.4207991659641266,
0.33031970262527466,
-0.6275641322135925,
0.08220157772302628,
0.24078530073165894,
-0.5288792252540588,
-0.30416885018348694,
-0.12861298024654388,
0.33314192295074463,
-0.06393110752105713,
0.4953234791755676,
-0.409075528383255,
-0.08424883335828781,
0.003399299457669258,
0.3668568730354309,
0.8883554935455322,
0.08518002182245255,
0.232674241065979,
-0.28945550322532654,
0.5503650307655334,
-0.09770514070987701,
0.29610776901245117,
-0.5871214866638184,
-0.7542014718055725,
-0.705528199672699,
-0.5233463048934937,
0.20446105301380157,
0.504460334777832,
-0.11362800002098083,
0.15971770882606506,
0.044754281640052795,
-0.45244449377059937,
-0.6048489212989807,
0.4739786684513092,
0.4696853756904602,
0.38138240575790405,
0.4328901171684265,
-0.22331100702285767,
-0.5417732000350952,
-0.8285387754440308,
-0.454973429441452,
-0.19816412031650543,
-0.07433755695819855,
0.20761457085609436,
0.4946512281894684,
-0.06121000275015831,
1.0664076805114746,
-0.4754146337509155,
-0.3541785776615143,
-0.09440324455499649,
0.19650663435459137,
0.01754373125731945,
0.5472456812858582,
0.23982779681682587,
-0.6257367134094238,
-0.42695027589797974,
0.047080349177122116,
-0.6892286539077759,
-0.6610651612281799,
0.16536860167980194,
0.05072487145662308,
0.20830674469470978,
0.6292881965637207,
-0.10894513130187988,
0.3575953245162964,
0.563197910785675,
-0.21526464819908142,
0.6348047256469727,
0.06826981902122498,
0.1845160275697708,
-0.7649245262145996,
0.3560762405395508,
-0.33012938499450684,
-0.30016040802001953,
-0.34406712651252747,
0.2434810996055603,
0.1925586462020874,
-0.08520369976758957,
-0.5465537309646606,
1.023158311843872,
-0.6914379596710205,
0.004981463309377432,
-0.4173460900783539,
-0.010476180352270603,
0.1822485774755478,
0.05022255703806877,
-0.13909447193145752,
0.8406320214271545,
0.3080366849899292,
-0.13297148048877716,
0.18809247016906738,
-0.19859091937541962,
-0.2927546799182892,
0.5649204850196838,
-0.47971096634864807,
0.41013890504837036,
0.1960720419883728,
-0.30540263652801514,
-0.7805473804473877,
0.12935659289360046,
0.5826979875564575,
-0.16651779413223267,
0.3567478358745575,
-0.34508639574050903,
-0.6408542394638062,
0.0022291180212050676,
-0.6302734017372131,
0.19779999554157257,
0.4472168982028961,
-0.4569871127605438,
0.5627349019050598,
0.46265918016433716,
0.006164959166198969,
-0.34225285053253174,
-0.6985662579536438,
0.24881216883659363,
-0.29410237073898315,
-0.32577720284461975,
0.0434940829873085,
-0.45302698016166687,
-0.4990899860858917,
0.08251932263374329,
-0.14744293689727783,
-0.23434051871299744,
0.4665745496749878,
0.6874542832374573,
0.07869435846805573,
-0.13972727954387665,
-0.2377072423696518,
-0.19451804459095,
-0.38346734642982483,
0.12043794989585876,
-0.44715437293052673,
0.39387717843055725,
-0.04715226590633392,
-0.8516759872436523,
-0.3050137162208557,
0.15644261240959167,
0.3931933641433716,
-0.2625390291213989,
0.20823931694030762,
0.5434814691543579,
-0.4233212172985077,
-0.6150599718093872,
-0.624496579170227,
-0.05978165194392204,
-0.46875065565109253,
0.11247618496417999,
-0.08429460227489471,
-1.1880953311920166,
0.47645097970962524,
-0.32775846123695374,
-0.02405780367553234,
0.11557839810848236,
0.6359655857086182,
0.022434517741203308,
0.5599765777587891,
0.6341866850852966,
-0.03785493224859238,
0.42188912630081177,
0.09016452729701996,
0.11476824432611465,
-0.6678276658058167,
-0.3174433410167694,
-0.40973907709121704,
-0.1285681277513504,
0.0883932113647461,
-0.6829246282577515,
-0.03472154587507248,
0.35670924186706543,
-0.11849389225244522,
0.12400629371404648,
-0.5542359352111816,
0.7214658260345459,
0.5888335704803467,
-0.16061152517795563,
0.7681816816329956,
-0.14117871224880219,
-0.21476119756698608,
-0.18110068142414093,
-0.24744683504104614,
-0.9417255520820618,
0.9720515608787537,
0.2351609319448471,
0.9020302891731262,
-0.3077927231788635,
0.7897514700889587,
0.5932466387748718,
0.7716739773750305,
-0.7200071215629578,
0.739564061164856,
0.27510392665863037,
-0.5161699652671814,
-0.06092202663421631,
-0.0345432423055172,
-0.8734930753707886,
0.05752325430512428,
-0.053243763744831085,
-0.5727595686912537,
-0.25159952044487,
0.09572238475084305,
0.2067968249320984,
0.6928670406341553,
-0.47442156076431274,
0.8660171627998352,
-0.19542819261550903,
-0.47258898615837097,
0.04830975458025932,
-0.2738337218761444,
0.3031240403652191,
-0.40709489583969116,
0.37760594487190247,
-0.632905125617981,
-0.24352283775806427,
0.783130407333374,
-0.3118022382259369,
0.7550507187843323,
-0.2910875678062439,
-0.3820667564868927,
0.40674594044685364,
0.5043221712112427,
0.29985976219177246,
-0.04664050042629242,
-0.10644667595624924,
0.20946726202964783,
-0.22741840779781342,
-0.09342924505472183,
-0.43798115849494934,
0.8756610751152039,
-0.4190133512020111,
-0.6286217570304871,
-0.23976249992847443,
-0.552065908908844,
0.0756622776389122,
0.36530348658561707,
-0.3382391333580017,
0.08306068927049637,
-0.29466450214385986,
-0.20305028557777405,
0.5610697865486145,
-0.24966669082641602,
0.6086843013763428,
0.6883648037910461,
-0.6613938808441162,
-0.5779665112495422,
0.9750562906265259,
-0.17010489106178284,
0.08928048610687256,
0.4426359236240387,
0.03820471838116646,
-0.2811588943004608,
-1.0359165668487549,
-0.4255255460739136,
0.17559421062469482,
-1.116363286972046,
-0.34442582726478577,
-0.3115614056587219,
-0.07561880350112915,
0.2609153091907501,
-0.11239572614431381,
-0.11261238902807236,
-0.3862837255001068,
-0.49747470021247864,
-0.007841529324650764,
0.3834563195705414,
0.9644128680229187,
0.02437649294734001,
0.184005469083786,
-0.6072348356246948,
0.02261149138212204,
0.41682693362236023,
0.43660950660705566,
-0.08604932576417923,
-0.13379764556884766,
-0.312247633934021,
-0.21060238778591156,
-0.3441435694694519,
-0.7568441033363342,
0.13558894395828247,
0.08948659151792526,
0.5682684183120728,
0.5114110708236694,
-0.02039581909775734,
0.4249879717826843,
-0.47693318128585815,
0.707123339176178,
0.2318088710308075,
-1.1750521659851074,
0.5120667219161987,
-0.14112675189971924,
0.26496702432632446,
0.41340768337249756,
0.12573902308940887,
-0.3493015468120575,
-0.7436901330947876,
-0.03774048015475273,
-0.8807931542396545,
0.39427879452705383,
0.0418378971517086,
-0.05384872481226921,
0.06322520226240158,
-0.03242066875100136,
0.30248650908470154,
0.17965412139892578,
-0.7957485318183899,
-0.26921209692955017,
-0.09556859731674194,
-0.25845685601234436,
0.3050837218761444,
-0.3024977445602417,
-0.30104511976242065,
0.1220564916729927,
0.7240127921104431,
-0.13376635313034058,
0.042561475187540054,
0.09323793649673462,
-0.6077769994735718,
-0.11626621335744858,
0.3324163556098938,
0.5049458742141724,
0.7688692808151245,
-0.3292851150035858,
0.5005783438682556,
-0.010873236693441868,
-0.5036118030548096,
0.1710510402917862,
0.24009846150875092,
-0.4027750790119171,
0.06332337111234665,
0.5513680577278137,
0.6055147647857666,
0.2156517654657364,
-0.7869414687156677,
0.4814434051513672,
0.06925472617149353,
-0.1876804232597351,
-0.10156987607479095,
0.025557631626725197,
0.37807247042655945,
0.3226354718208313,
0.7499182224273682,
-0.3546997606754303,
-0.1489783078432083,
-0.03241130709648132,
0.18650539219379425,
0.5408779382705688,
-0.49446800351142883,
-0.3805643618106842,
1.0613486766815186,
0.13092634081840515,
-0.37775570154190063,
-0.06100672483444214,
-0.09512650221586227,
-0.5946041345596313,
0.4999423623085022,
0.4405522346496582,
1.128678560256958,
-0.12086793035268784,
-0.10417280346155167,
0.04682226479053497,
0.5062829852104187,
0.06527593731880188,
0.4189816415309906,
0.04300674796104431,
-0.563460111618042,
-0.4073519706726074,
-0.8310887217521667,
-0.7243379950523376,
0.16339412331581116,
-0.3479163646697998,
0.3821989595890045,
-0.7210214138031006,
-0.1374274343252182,
-0.13370859622955322,
-0.16568727791309357,
-0.5300230979919434,
-0.13408488035202026,
0.47885897755622864,
0.9389360547065735,
-0.6569607257843018,
0.8295802474021912,
0.7204174995422363,
-0.08933054655790329,
-0.3578653633594513,
-0.2980779707431793,
0.3432728350162506,
-1.1665196418762207,
0.8752524852752686,
0.3995470106601715,
-0.4225008189678192,
0.18722905218601227,
-0.6911349296569824,
-0.4779227077960968,
1.2260390520095825,
0.5044164061546326,
-0.47559627890586853,
0.6570703387260437,
0.36453700065612793,
0.19724994897842407,
-0.42859700322151184,
0.18152225017547607,
0.07793494313955307,
0.9257521629333496,
-0.336544394493103,
-0.7113195657730103,
0.5155884027481079,
-0.22118575870990753,
0.06233282387256622,
0.19448401033878326,
-0.28637173771858215,
0.505556046962738,
-0.020759211853146553,
-0.5215911865234375,
0.1274716556072235,
0.21088352799415588,
0.34987694025039673,
0.4586333632469177,
0.3248278796672821,
0.7145460844039917,
0.5992346405982971,
-0.3648850619792938,
0.6434147357940674,
-0.5939540863037109,
0.42845606803894043,
1.1285161972045898,
-0.49643880128860474,
0.6310609579086304,
0.6890328526496887,
-0.25365617871284485,
0.1567683219909668,
0.5431866645812988,
-0.4797767996788025,
0.3228343427181244,
0.6006197333335876,
-0.5566793084144592,
-0.2340720146894455,
-0.26560333371162415,
-0.35932573676109314,
-0.09432569146156311,
0.13877993822097778,
-0.4500385820865631,
-0.2685835063457489,
-0.1006639152765274,
0.1937372386455536,
0.1895664930343628,
-0.3699074685573578,
0.621613621711731,
0.3165072500705719,
0.15906363725662231,
0.4319622814655304,
0.06605502963066101,
0.7561506628990173,
-0.6184541583061218,
-0.18791308999061584,
-0.17419826984405518,
0.02198694832623005,
-0.18633049726486206,
-0.8724650144577026,
0.2738611102104187,
-0.03780260309576988,
-0.1344878077507019,
-0.7145821452140808,
1.104067087173462,
-0.4080961346626282,
-0.19228141009807587,
0.7637210488319397,
0.8851701021194458,
0.2582051753997803,
-0.2203986644744873,
-0.7785791754722595,
0.7416084408760071,
-0.15995435416698456,
-0.3473803997039795,
0.19038115441799164,
0.2650712728500366,
-0.040051188319921494,
0.8011274337768555,
0.9055770635604858,
0.1488087922334671,
0.18044528365135193,
0.1805407702922821,
0.7871863842010498,
-0.6751309037208557,
-0.012367790564894676,
-1.3457705974578857,
0.4739752411842346,
0.020147057250142097,
0.06355398893356323,
1.0239477157592773,
0.9598259329795837,
0.7990245223045349,
-0.27585452795028687,
0.8639271259307861,
0.3304334282875061,
0.13586799800395966,
-0.4577607810497284,
0.9936546683311462,
-0.3617376983165741,
0.39553380012512207,
-0.2568870186805725,
-1.0971144437789917,
-0.8591079711914062,
0.16510477662086487,
-0.018097206950187683,
-0.292584091424942,
0.5731090307235718,
0.8922629952430725,
0.0021363492123782635,
-0.022813525050878525,
0.3566943407058716,
0.025548720732331276,
0.3354317843914032,
0.31828373670578003,
1.1636472940444946,
-0.04903089255094528,
0.5599328875541687,
-0.07079961150884628,
-0.026499995961785316,
-0.150968536734581,
-1.3575400114059448,
-0.9766228795051575,
-0.49840083718299866,
-0.5286629796028137,
-0.06753917038440704,
0.1236322745680809,
0.7323342561721802,
0.7647908926010132,
-0.9634197354316711,
-0.41339343786239624,
0.13893285393714905,
0.48023173213005066,
0.03302404284477234,
-0.24335849285125732,
0.29055485129356384,
-0.0317540168762207,
-0.7943047285079956,
0.47614914178848267,
0.7843292951583862,
0.3425964117050171,
-0.32009753584861755,
-0.24647054076194763,
0.04512287676334381,
-0.02516670525074005,
0.3599354922771454,
0.263884574174881,
-0.5779664516448975,
-0.0700320228934288,
-0.2507084310054779,
-0.1400873214006424,
0.21606172621250153,
0.9113731980323792,
-0.43649253249168396,
0.5581013560295105,
0.38712263107299805,
0.6873691082000732,
0.5180501937866211,
-0.32553327083587646,
0.40449774265289307,
-0.5555895566940308,
0.07309676706790924,
0.14115269482135773,
0.42101192474365234,
0.6142890453338623,
0.02089790627360344,
0.6156134009361267,
0.47989383339881897,
-0.24740807712078094,
-1.083315134048462,
-0.013413598760962486,
-0.9183906316757202,
-0.32913053035736084,
0.9620215892791748,
-0.48754236102104187,
-0.1282404512166977,
-0.2025715559720993,
-0.2568867802619934,
0.062418755143880844,
-0.28332802653312683,
0.39219558238983154,
0.8058255910873413,
0.25573697686195374,
-0.22415731847286224,
-0.7011953592300415,
0.4464716613292694,
0.10391636937856674,
-0.9868830442428589,
0.15610578656196594,
0.3643419146537781,
0.5178648233413696,
-0.14938361942768097,
0.5717247724533081,
-0.37366411089897156,
-0.1063557043671608,
-0.3829568028450012,
0.4279710650444031,
-0.7748705744743347,
0.07772829383611679,
-0.5999226570129395,
0.22722227871418,
0.3517318665981293,
-0.10841155052185059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00007v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00007v1
|
PyTorch-IE: Fast and Reproducible Prototyping for Information Extraction
| 2024-05-16T12:23:37 | 2024-05-16T12:23:37 |
Arne Binder, Leonhard Hennig, Christoph Alt
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
The objective of Information Extraction (IE) is to derive structured
representations from unstructured or semi-structured documents. However,
developing IE models is complex due to the need of integrating several
subtasks. Additionally, representation of data among varied tasks and
transforming datasets into task-specific model inputs presents further
challenges. To streamline this undertaking for researchers, we introduce
PyTorch-IE, a deep-learning-based framework uniquely designed to enable swift,
reproducible, and reusable implementations of IE models. PyTorch-IE offers a
flexible data model capable of creating complex data structures by integrating
interdependent layers of annotations derived from various data types, like
plain text or semi-structured text, and even images. We propose task modules to
decouple the concerns of data representation and model-specific
representations, thereby fostering greater flexibility and reusability of code.
PyTorch-IE also extends support for widely used libraries such as
PyTorch-Lightning for training, HuggingFace datasets for dataset reading, and
Hydra for experiment configuration. Supplementary libraries and GitHub
templates for the easy setup of new projects are also provided. By ensuring
functionality and versatility, PyTorch-IE provides vital support to the
research community engaged in Information Extraction.
|
[
-0.03928472101688385,
-0.7742260694503784,
0.22876423597335815,
0.2083810418844223,
0.04485972970724106,
0.22635211050510406,
-0.30866432189941406,
-0.5235410332679749,
0.05854364112019539,
0.005377124063670635,
-0.07525984942913055,
-0.6151203513145447,
-0.469268262386322,
-0.09755905717611313,
-0.8834836483001709,
0.9377588629722595,
-0.3234081268310547,
-0.32236164808273315,
-0.08660845458507538,
0.16528892517089844,
-0.0819544792175293,
-0.27200934290885925,
-0.21567080914974213,
-0.4071245491504669,
0.9752681255340576,
0.7277748584747314,
0.28105518221855164,
0.6704442501068115,
0.6639959812164307,
0.15972690284252167,
0.3900498151779175,
-0.14065136015415192,
-0.29053252935409546,
0.4184558093547821,
-0.24697387218475342,
-0.3555751144886017,
-0.394483357667923,
0.25452300906181335,
0.38329800963401794,
0.7313130497932434,
-0.2527846097946167,
0.5849994421005249,
0.15150006115436554,
0.23118630051612854,
-0.8694241046905518,
0.3894195854663849,
-0.47342270612716675,
0.17586375772953033,
-0.07103446125984192,
-0.2324526011943817,
-0.4609099328517914,
0.05533415079116821,
0.4505416452884674,
-0.6611588001251221,
0.4360227584838867,
-0.15625548362731934,
0.8001925349235535,
-0.2662128806114197,
-0.10617079585790634,
-0.16225123405456543,
-0.6915534138679504,
0.4932142496109009,
-0.34466540813446045,
0.46744778752326965,
0.05225064605474472,
0.41822779178619385,
-0.06095520406961441,
-1.5652052164077759,
-0.42277294397354126,
-0.10931781679391861,
0.14266689121723175,
0.15956567227840424,
-0.27959224581718445,
0.04309804365038872,
0.26122528314590454,
0.4561671316623688,
-0.619484543800354,
0.10890007764101028,
-0.327774316072464,
-0.2114204466342926,
0.26794716715812683,
-0.11589767038822174,
0.1618179827928543,
-0.10542816668748856,
-0.12058088183403015,
-0.13856922090053558,
-0.49054911732673645,
-0.06331601738929749,
0.2955709397792816,
0.27505600452423096,
0.14345566928386688,
0.6864534616470337,
-0.34119290113449097,
0.3441362977027893,
-0.12566013634204865,
0.2991804778575897,
0.30485352873802185,
0.16463536024093628,
-0.3852885663509369,
0.027172358706593513,
0.6184436678886414,
0.15480047464370728,
0.05467762053012848,
-0.529012143611908,
-0.1800355613231659,
-0.0016689721960574389,
0.1078891009092331,
-1.0563116073608398,
-0.7468718886375427,
0.36483272910118103,
-0.6070998311042786,
-0.25333091616630554,
0.3363213539123535,
-0.9937480092048645,
-0.29278820753097534,
-0.22408050298690796,
0.4356868863105774,
-0.19646121561527252,
-0.5018082857131958,
0.0952959880232811,
-0.3595608174800873,
0.10568713396787643,
0.7136948704719543,
-0.4837602376937866,
0.07407426089048386,
0.5907790660858154,
0.980625569820404,
-0.267206609249115,
-0.3271736800670624,
-0.5842793583869934,
0.08616851270198822,
-0.007996687665581703,
0.5413259863853455,
-0.5061078071594238,
-0.11108599603176117,
-0.06024378538131714,
0.006313248537480831,
0.1711832731962204,
-0.45596903562545776,
0.3456478416919708,
-0.33343037962913513,
0.04359830915927887,
0.2818693518638611,
-0.5357387065887451,
-0.11602367460727692,
0.22168457508087158,
-0.7600144147872925,
1.0941884517669678,
0.33219531178474426,
-0.9575055241584778,
0.3742131292819977,
-0.5918376445770264,
-0.40032535791397095,
0.1385076344013214,
-0.17424219846725464,
-0.3606727421283722,
0.24119530618190765,
0.08194062858819962,
0.5980904698371887,
-0.43543338775634766,
0.08697057515382767,
-0.36577239632606506,
-0.23346270620822906,
-0.11515967547893524,
-0.2493240386247635,
0.41680559515953064,
0.2538759112358093,
-0.4856330156326294,
-0.008290427736938,
-0.794384777545929,
0.18401387333869934,
0.25621986389160156,
-0.5973575711250305,
0.10103224217891693,
-0.1353403478860855,
0.5356401801109314,
0.0927242636680603,
0.21441328525543213,
-0.6956349611282349,
0.45835793018341064,
-0.12899751961231232,
0.6628828644752502,
0.4716954231262207,
-0.33325812220573425,
0.43474695086479187,
0.04358861222863197,
0.4536149501800537,
0.012110975570976734,
-0.02237425372004509,
-0.28297001123428345,
-0.20263995230197906,
-0.6290979385375977,
-0.40976494550704956,
0.5492300391197205,
0.5564380884170532,
-0.5731421113014221,
0.23146238923072815,
-0.2694731056690216,
-0.6332117319107056,
-0.39527249336242676,
0.0975642204284668,
0.04939047619700432,
0.752510666847229,
0.2712336480617523,
-0.14832767844200134,
-0.767573893070221,
-0.9099830389022827,
-0.1607937514781952,
-0.14833126962184906,
-0.27324923872947693,
-0.10177689045667648,
0.7579065561294556,
-0.1945820301771164,
1.0956007242202759,
-0.18718694150447845,
-0.06719399988651276,
-0.5036221742630005,
0.6545060873031616,
0.3202945291996002,
0.601657509803772,
0.20925919711589813,
-0.8488354682922363,
-0.16431382298469543,
0.2581389844417572,
-0.7990303039550781,
0.05173496901988983,
0.09003061056137085,
0.028560901060700417,
-0.35496994853019714,
0.385391503572464,
-0.6842809915542603,
0.8185887336730957,
0.19018730521202087,
-0.06215926259756088,
0.5662665963172913,
-0.04379890859127045,
-0.03812595456838608,
-1.0542688369750977,
0.6395940184593201,
-0.02075795829296112,
-0.3034684658050537,
-0.42717891931533813,
0.04670890048146248,
0.22870223224163055,
-0.33135300874710083,
-0.40371960401535034,
0.4689583480358124,
-0.3301261365413666,
-0.1306559443473816,
-0.13450579345226288,
-0.0036741946823894978,
0.41249534487724304,
-0.032260991632938385,
0.1830054521560669,
0.687565267086029,
0.5382789969444275,
-0.3629013001918793,
0.534990668296814,
0.13535375893115997,
-0.31824547052383423,
0.24215663969516754,
-0.7656475305557251,
0.4184289872646332,
-0.06979795545339584,
0.1002359464764595,
-0.5046107172966003,
-0.4431315064430237,
0.1523338407278061,
-0.43295276165008545,
0.3123043179512024,
-0.37479889392852783,
-0.8330217003822327,
-0.4060315489768982,
-0.20619207620620728,
0.1833333522081375,
0.3240296542644501,
-0.5794039368629456,
0.7988751530647278,
0.24369795620441437,
-0.1353408694267273,
-0.6182140707969666,
-0.7292349934577942,
0.1677229255437851,
-0.09299707412719727,
-0.4971601963043213,
0.45844435691833496,
0.32586923241615295,
-0.13453041017055511,
0.09471112489700317,
-0.3152295649051666,
-0.25394612550735474,
0.18459558486938477,
0.32290470600128174,
-0.039919350296258926,
-0.24261179566383362,
0.22764140367507935,
-0.2327650934457779,
-0.23642654716968536,
-0.1343645602464676,
-0.5516756176948547,
0.3228195607662201,
-0.011605754494667053,
-0.18853189051151276,
-0.6868537068367004,
0.6333871483802795,
0.5943206548690796,
-0.37814977765083313,
0.27920106053352356,
0.7514421343803406,
-0.5557619333267212,
-0.40349116921424866,
-0.3262254297733307,
-0.26831695437431335,
-0.37322938442230225,
0.7157087922096252,
-0.47041910886764526,
-0.6389591693878174,
0.4281243681907654,
-0.5128868818283081,
0.3756435215473175,
0.33985501527786255,
0.2799644470214844,
-0.42322999238967896,
0.7603991627693176,
0.7890160083770752,
0.027822747826576233,
0.7273410558700562,
-0.5712882280349731,
0.16544540226459503,
-0.712673544883728,
-0.20857730507850647,
-0.5743668079376221,
-0.5743069648742676,
-0.14108730852603912,
-0.0766281858086586,
0.01816130056977272,
0.3727845549583435,
-0.1682053655385971,
0.28329625725746155,
-0.6696630716323853,
0.26561734080314636,
0.690054714679718,
0.09986366331577301,
-0.0939500629901886,
0.32443976402282715,
0.16918817162513733,
0.17617757618427277,
-0.7926533222198486,
-0.6011830568313599,
1.3256689310073853,
0.4017386734485626,
0.9832693934440613,
-0.1627163290977478,
0.7221522927284241,
0.29440367221832275,
0.2424422651529312,
-0.785011887550354,
0.22013026475906372,
0.016732461750507355,
-0.4019482731819153,
0.17706774175167084,
-0.282013863325119,
-1.0137685537338257,
-0.1807946264743805,
-0.03614717721939087,
-1.2083888053894043,
0.399305135011673,
0.10466046631336212,
-0.267061322927475,
0.30568525195121765,
-1.0379558801651,
1.033190131187439,
-0.013273991644382477,
-0.7331644296646118,
0.036713529378175735,
-0.5267598628997803,
-0.24134595692157745,
0.37905430793762207,
-0.13057444989681244,
0.029708020389080048,
0.2115475833415985,
0.867067813873291,
-0.003794444724917412,
0.6389564871788025,
-0.2998822033405304,
0.18372765183448792,
0.34310853481292725,
0.431217223405838,
0.6586306095123291,
0.342441201210022,
-0.12252726405858994,
-0.06304512917995453,
-0.010375600308179855,
-0.20570987462997437,
-0.7736724615097046,
0.4978504478931427,
-0.6266358494758606,
-0.3351438343524933,
-0.3495517671108246,
-0.6961016654968262,
0.13438411056995392,
0.2020360231399536,
0.11156383156776428,
0.4821664094924927,
0.1168118342757225,
0.6101884245872498,
0.264128178358078,
0.06243510544300079,
0.36822569370269775,
0.2247350513935089,
-0.23235581815242767,
-0.25348135828971863,
0.9905450344085693,
0.06009221449494362,
-0.19313667714595795,
0.4840501546859741,
0.05263688042759895,
-0.13714972138404846,
-0.6717338562011719,
-0.042134981602430344,
-0.3641994297504425,
-0.7839028835296631,
-0.25294649600982666,
-0.719006359577179,
-0.057740651071071625,
-0.23863735795021057,
-0.132968008518219,
-0.47146737575531006,
-0.534311830997467,
-0.4672890901565552,
-0.31840980052948,
0.3207900822162628,
0.6976115703582764,
-0.0767187774181366,
0.30147868394851685,
-0.4512781500816345,
0.2143477201461792,
0.07875459641218185,
0.10536368191242218,
-0.18394576013088226,
-0.07144905626773834,
-0.3156608045101166,
-0.20610825717449188,
-0.11796238273382187,
-0.7810075283050537,
0.25478801131248474,
0.1619894951581955,
0.32362353801727295,
0.183559387922287,
-0.18520383536815643,
0.6330411434173584,
-0.09269262850284576,
0.3876481354236603,
0.0014175595715641975,
-0.6166539788246155,
0.7567285895347595,
-0.2199239730834961,
-0.11222442239522934,
0.6423037052154541,
0.13075754046440125,
-0.26743751764297485,
-0.08891042321920395,
-0.7624086737632751,
-1.2365776300430298,
0.4944765865802765,
0.3086855709552765,
-0.2905096411705017,
0.32995492219924927,
0.6644617915153503,
0.42483577132225037,
0.5000043511390686,
-0.566230833530426,
0.11783046275377274,
-0.4572907090187073,
-0.5507749915122986,
0.14284548163414001,
-0.20169252157211304,
-0.058730028569698334,
-0.3550594449043274,
0.2656037509441376,
-0.16857345402240753,
0.4798043668270111,
0.5325080752372742,
-0.685363233089447,
0.3228304088115692,
0.011628887616097927,
-0.007259332109242678,
0.6695116758346558,
-0.394483357667923,
0.5700230002403259,
-0.4220356345176697,
-0.6568577289581299,
-0.04706511273980141,
0.35183003544807434,
-0.13083359599113464,
-0.009660309180617332,
0.5928741693496704,
0.39851510524749756,
-0.024977196007966995,
-0.5454318523406982,
0.3590434193611145,
0.01732635498046875,
-0.0019659469835460186,
-0.16678732633590698,
-0.08782271295785904,
-0.16181616485118866,
0.2761966288089752,
0.553256094455719,
-0.23678864538669586,
0.292072594165802,
-0.45895907282829285,
0.6844772100448608,
0.0025502254720777273,
-0.14711810648441315,
-0.42193952202796936,
0.45468729734420776,
0.25574392080307007,
-0.3308582603931427,
0.8502014875411987,
-0.09597433358430862,
-0.2034042924642563,
0.7100998759269714,
0.4479207992553711,
0.7898252010345459,
0.08979644626379013,
0.23899522423744202,
0.24704384803771973,
0.23276901245117188,
0.09682132303714752,
0.25117287039756775,
-0.22037756443023682,
-0.39535802602767944,
-0.16569098830223083,
-0.5015345215797424,
-0.1453937143087387,
0.13233382999897003,
-0.6462356448173523,
0.11703494191169739,
-0.5551158785820007,
-0.11505258828401566,
0.0876067727804184,
0.04180663079023361,
-0.9251372218132019,
0.1597852259874344,
-0.07984104752540588,
1.1575303077697754,
-0.532756507396698,
0.8599520921707153,
0.6008253693580627,
-0.6208840012550354,
-0.7489404678344727,
-0.21958467364311218,
-0.11783789098262787,
-0.5764439105987549,
0.9421445727348328,
0.4988844692707062,
0.14612747728824615,
0.3640685975551605,
-0.5518931746482849,
-0.40400001406669617,
1.3023260831832886,
0.6816092729568481,
-0.703478991985321,
-0.3487550914287567,
0.03586848825216293,
0.18742527067661285,
-0.5183016061782837,
0.5511896014213562,
0.4137958586215973,
0.4484197199344635,
-0.023169228807091713,
-0.6587932705879211,
-0.2589989900588989,
-0.4636807143688202,
-0.405967116355896,
-0.19079960882663727,
-0.15789912641048431,
0.9793204665184021,
0.03676868602633476,
-0.2922363579273224,
0.10602421313524246,
0.5104551315307617,
-0.2414758950471878,
0.09007541090250015,
0.08046276122331619,
0.5658350586891174,
0.8636118769645691,
-0.3600046634674072,
0.9104178547859192,
-0.1525091975927353,
0.49518221616744995,
1.3126121759414673,
-0.21590018272399902,
0.7904022336006165,
0.6896020174026489,
0.0634218081831932,
0.47859370708465576,
0.5388258695602417,
-0.19629697501659393,
0.30245500802993774,
0.16261467337608337,
-0.12825654447078705,
-0.17543837428092957,
-0.19025593996047974,
-0.21450912952423096,
0.5387505292892456,
0.4012434482574463,
-0.41471362113952637,
-0.5655055642127991,
0.02438717894256115,
-0.0966167226433754,
-0.4156912863254547,
-0.13410839438438416,
0.46060365438461304,
-0.19123922288417816,
-0.007784725166857243,
-0.06440779566764832,
-0.0634743943810463,
0.46093833446502686,
-0.561722457408905,
-0.3744741380214691,
-0.14099639654159546,
0.20992770791053772,
-0.37348929047584534,
-0.8958207964897156,
0.1328061819076538,
-0.08916015923023224,
-0.2824735641479492,
-0.21910502016544342,
0.9233052134513855,
-0.15657377243041992,
-0.38763973116874695,
0.30761241912841797,
0.4636595547199249,
0.010448066517710686,
-0.3171866536140442,
-0.624389111995697,
0.01972382701933384,
-0.26820728182792664,
-0.6194942593574524,
0.13199608027935028,
0.4566907584667206,
0.20197348296642303,
0.6366335153579712,
0.7379736304283142,
0.07687374949455261,
0.11544805020093918,
-0.047294702380895615,
0.7987129092216492,
-0.6712177395820618,
-0.3155592083930969,
-0.6014015078544617,
0.8600632548332214,
-0.19805409014225006,
-0.2497105598449707,
0.5244833827018738,
0.799878716468811,
0.5865270495414734,
0.0822075754404068,
0.9657647609710693,
-0.5076192021369934,
0.13883565366268158,
-0.20137542486190796,
0.6197934150695801,
-0.38688015937805176,
-0.17089296877384186,
-0.09559006989002228,
-0.8411953449249268,
-0.4167519509792328,
0.7689832448959351,
-0.009911622852087021,
-0.07943300157785416,
0.6413351893424988,
0.5190425515174866,
-0.3644867241382599,
-0.02940184809267521,
-0.10391142219305038,
0.23502644896507263,
0.7455206513404846,
0.5408462285995483,
0.8545811772346497,
-0.3381029963493347,
0.46532097458839417,
-0.2728891968727112,
-0.2837839424610138,
-0.18540407717227936,
-0.8888981342315674,
-0.7279558777809143,
-0.5557617545127869,
-0.39159226417541504,
-0.3456816077232361,
-0.0017492409097030759,
0.7382571697235107,
1.0064661502838135,
-0.6544812321662903,
-0.11009994894266129,
-0.5650850534439087,
0.04325643181800842,
-0.08921565115451813,
-0.30192917585372925,
0.5781998038291931,
-0.1899406462907791,
-0.5215238928794861,
0.36472228169441223,
0.4537273049354553,
0.09164923429489136,
-0.1389920860528946,
0.3775617778301239,
-0.19733422994613647,
-0.6698290705680847,
0.4444234371185303,
0.6098340749740601,
-0.34070101380348206,
-0.41917672753334045,
-0.018690114840865135,
0.16212612390518188,
0.27682241797447205,
1.0090608596801758,
-0.9408270716667175,
0.642262876033783,
0.6285653710365295,
0.826113760471344,
0.557540237903595,
-0.38631147146224976,
0.6607623100280762,
-0.8301406502723694,
0.5379709005355835,
0.4679679572582245,
0.28952348232269287,
0.1586863398551941,
-0.21445327997207642,
0.49529170989990234,
0.29230889678001404,
-0.2347746193408966,
-1.0673060417175293,
0.07993414998054504,
-0.8891094326972961,
0.0043387748301029205,
0.8793268799781799,
-0.46596837043762207,
-0.422006219625473,
-0.11050554364919662,
-0.25344207882881165,
0.4112633764743805,
-0.5100029110908508,
0.6565074324607849,
0.5093329548835754,
0.007313414476811886,
-0.37520086765289307,
-0.5923305153846741,
0.1672060489654541,
-0.04542962461709976,
-0.8653202652931213,
0.3290453553199768,
0.20163647830486298,
0.3088972568511963,
0.2723391354084015,
0.14696192741394043,
-0.01983625814318657,
0.33954569697380066,
0.18405809998512268,
0.47259095311164856,
-0.4773009121417999,
-0.7413702011108398,
0.1014266163110733,
0.7989298105239868,
-0.06152984872460365,
-0.2570642828941345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10040v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10040v1
|
SynthesizRR: Generating Diverse Datasets with Retrieval Augmentation
| 2024-05-16T12:22:41 | 2024-05-16T12:22:41 |
Abhishek Divekar, Greg Durrett
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) are versatile and can address many tasks, but
for computational efficiency, it is often desirable to distill their
capabilities into smaller student models. One way to do this for classification
tasks is via dataset synthesis, which can be accomplished by generating
examples of each label from the LLM. Prior approaches to synthesis use few-shot
prompting, which relies on the LLM's parametric knowledge to generate usable
examples. However, this leads to issues of repetition, bias towards popular
entities, and stylistic differences from human text. In this work, we propose
Synthesize by Retrieval and Refinement (SynthesizRR), which uses retrieval
augmentation to introduce variety into the dataset synthesis process: as
retrieved passages vary, the LLM is "seeded" with different content to generate
its examples. We empirically study the synthesis of six datasets, covering
topic classification, sentiment analysis, tone detection, and humor, requiring
complex synthesis strategies. We find SynthesizRR greatly improves lexical and
semantic diversity, similarity to human-written text, and distillation
performance, when compared to standard 32-shot prompting and six baseline
approaches.
|
[
-0.45356258749961853,
-0.7322659492492676,
0.25093740224838257,
0.20579595863819122,
-0.03371885046362877,
0.3617822825908661,
-0.37809041142463684,
-0.21177709102630615,
0.11067751049995422,
0.46074387431144714,
-0.6153247952461243,
-0.5260948538780212,
-0.0012647053226828575,
0.39464694261550903,
-0.5136268734931946,
1.2299381494522095,
0.09846692532300949,
-0.09987451136112213,
-0.046273812651634216,
0.10544523596763611,
-0.3593546748161316,
-0.3777576684951782,
-0.15114836394786835,
-0.3847754895687103,
0.7022261619567871,
0.5092400908470154,
0.27920326590538025,
0.5539467334747314,
0.35449856519699097,
0.299614280462265,
-0.051567960530519485,
0.3622397184371948,
-0.736322820186615,
0.673711359500885,
-0.16499297320842743,
-0.47643446922302246,
0.10463762283325195,
-0.08048137277364731,
0.9320262670516968,
0.802294909954071,
-0.008148467168211937,
0.0899316668510437,
0.28315600752830505,
0.6067888736724854,
-0.5183805823326111,
-0.19711950421333313,
-1.116439700126648,
-0.07151655852794647,
-0.36484047770500183,
-0.055384695529937744,
-0.4448513984680176,
-0.38199278712272644,
0.12060555070638657,
-0.4920194447040558,
0.7006392478942871,
0.08181815594434738,
0.40215665102005005,
0.13448280096054077,
-0.1130470484495163,
-0.17831404507160187,
-0.775671660900116,
0.9769513607025146,
-0.672906219959259,
0.24630334973335266,
-0.13520990312099457,
0.47555798292160034,
-0.46789586544036865,
-0.8980551362037659,
-0.7110977172851562,
-0.08159065246582031,
-0.025606347247958183,
-0.01053563505411148,
-0.02285677194595337,
-0.12926028668880463,
0.3752517104148865,
0.6380953192710876,
-0.5175589919090271,
0.008676107972860336,
-0.4890082776546478,
-0.2903241813182831,
0.6763838529586792,
0.40613874793052673,
0.1931966245174408,
-0.3871181309223175,
-0.08722510188817978,
-0.35888615250587463,
-0.8027617335319519,
-0.3007941246032715,
0.7045325040817261,
0.8269631862640381,
0.44681933522224426,
0.7685428261756897,
-0.371134489774704,
0.7705138921737671,
-0.08380328118801117,
-0.292794793844223,
0.5009342432022095,
-0.5194865465164185,
-0.08277105540037155,
-0.053015973418951035,
0.688847005367279,
0.14216268062591553,
-0.20122940838336945,
-0.07665994018316269,
-0.25786423683166504,
-0.13146181404590607,
0.22755195200443268,
-0.8110355734825134,
-0.3195588290691376,
0.12394659221172333,
-0.2348473072052002,
-0.31987959146499634,
0.08324772864580154,
-0.8133609890937805,
-0.24803298711776733,
-0.5138615965843201,
0.28008773922920227,
-0.579780638217926,
0.0899166390299797,
0.04106784611940384,
-0.43604108691215515,
0.037388551980257034,
0.37117013335227966,
-0.7605721354484558,
0.16946643590927124,
0.5798141956329346,
0.4237545430660248,
-0.44120603799819946,
-0.4319323003292084,
-0.49078473448753357,
-0.048507608473300934,
-0.19913607835769653,
0.6332036852836609,
-0.6057219505310059,
-0.5388599634170532,
-0.11618906259536743,
-0.21132764220237732,
0.33476200699806213,
-0.7668552994728088,
0.2936282753944397,
-0.19315727055072784,
0.3520093262195587,
-0.33010920882225037,
-0.4477061331272125,
-0.14050932228565216,
0.2045556604862213,
-0.7294058799743652,
1.2650017738342285,
0.26296180486679077,
-0.7554992437362671,
0.4308401346206665,
-0.3055567741394043,
-0.6222764253616333,
0.24117951095104218,
-0.3341563940048218,
-0.15020525455474854,
0.19974221289157867,
0.1939227133989334,
0.2652483582496643,
-0.2573547661304474,
0.31300294399261475,
0.031810179352760315,
-0.3691386282444,
0.4798898696899414,
-0.4469285309314728,
0.23687933385372162,
0.4342983365058899,
0.12421666085720062,
-0.10033458471298218,
-0.975060224533081,
0.06150687858462334,
-0.15827035903930664,
-0.5886951088905334,
-0.4245111644268036,
-0.20078173279762268,
0.37797802686691284,
-0.0036785718984901905,
0.07983135432004929,
-0.3582427203655243,
0.25052088499069214,
-0.5568187832832336,
0.30770769715309143,
0.32536932826042175,
0.2162841111421585,
0.36742421984672546,
-0.5920224189758301,
0.3236357569694519,
-0.060176216065883636,
-0.3939894735813141,
-0.4537573456764221,
-0.2961719036102295,
-0.580877423286438,
-0.49535080790519714,
0.3602277636528015,
0.2557041347026825,
-1.0959041118621826,
0.48158344626426697,
-0.2497164011001587,
-0.48786017298698425,
-0.6774047017097473,
0.36952948570251465,
0.2483753114938736,
0.4839663505554199,
0.38236111402511597,
-0.11222592741250992,
-0.822717010974884,
-0.9069995284080505,
-0.339490681886673,
-0.08131205290555954,
-0.31510475277900696,
0.1405545473098755,
0.33936092257499695,
-0.14382927119731903,
1.0616525411605835,
-0.6339691877365112,
-0.09917884320020676,
-0.5944477915763855,
0.21956570446491241,
0.3078298270702362,
0.46102285385131836,
0.5514801144599915,
-0.6684722304344177,
-0.41569411754608154,
-0.12305537611246109,
-0.34048718214035034,
-0.16795283555984497,
-0.12737219035625458,
-0.13602231442928314,
-0.16977357864379883,
0.2706608176231384,
-0.29273536801338196,
0.11241850256919861,
0.0000794031293480657,
0.3450353145599365,
0.44273272156715393,
0.024376900866627693,
0.2707380950450897,
-1.3029894828796387,
0.024504847824573517,
0.026271043345332146,
-0.07456214725971222,
-0.7346387505531311,
0.1581113338470459,
-0.3122771382331848,
-0.1985490769147873,
-0.5240475535392761,
0.6384679675102234,
-0.3513096868991852,
0.01663399673998356,
-0.2388973981142044,
-0.07325593382120132,
0.25398749113082886,
0.10068798065185547,
0.002498196205124259,
0.7992658615112305,
0.3822229504585266,
-0.6129820942878723,
0.43352416157722473,
0.23606517910957336,
-0.5003988146781921,
0.275606244802475,
-0.5647048950195312,
0.001400242792442441,
-0.3787451386451721,
0.24278303980827332,
-1.113862156867981,
-0.5684051513671875,
0.046750545501708984,
-0.15622946619987488,
0.3213861584663391,
-0.07923951745033264,
-0.40799471735954285,
-0.4638155400753021,
-0.35734349489212036,
0.35540637373924255,
0.615234375,
-0.6077970266342163,
0.5271661281585693,
0.09439373761415482,
-0.4619419574737549,
-0.40182942152023315,
-0.9172270894050598,
0.05994999036192894,
-0.4508148431777954,
-0.3464469909667969,
0.6383323073387146,
-0.2197388857603073,
-0.38892999291419983,
-0.15951226651668549,
0.1265944391489029,
0.1325145959854126,
-0.10836656391620636,
-0.004793156869709492,
0.23706361651420593,
0.09631559252738953,
0.3770553469657898,
0.36080676317214966,
0.3468664884567261,
-0.39761894941329956,
-0.144508495926857,
0.5318621397018433,
0.18036149442195892,
-0.37755048274993896,
-0.1618328094482422,
0.28384435176849365,
0.1644301414489746,
-0.017430901527404785,
0.3090752065181732,
0.5701168775558472,
-0.18791362643241882,
-0.6842641830444336,
-0.6526812314987183,
-0.5887177586555481,
-0.4824804365634918,
0.41531577706336975,
-0.47755640745162964,
-1.0714346170425415,
0.47024327516555786,
0.21964578330516815,
0.2498159408569336,
0.09406152367591858,
0.663703441619873,
0.11483056843280792,
0.5829164981842041,
0.06794851273298264,
0.13807344436645508,
0.6329329609870911,
-0.11162662506103516,
-0.1236916333436966,
-0.8519262671470642,
-0.06293708831071854,
-0.6191339492797852,
-0.52935791015625,
-0.7306383848190308,
-0.5007042288780212,
0.17255130410194397,
-0.28422811627388,
-0.07270142436027527,
0.26269620656967163,
-0.6364303231239319,
0.6483831405639648,
0.5806246995925903,
0.26445698738098145,
0.2571151554584503,
0.6449992656707764,
0.0032248003408312798,
-0.3398865759372711,
-0.5781201720237732,
-0.4622519910335541,
1.2760080099105835,
0.12408537417650223,
1.0420869588851929,
-0.0419192872941494,
1.2635542154312134,
0.11992715299129486,
0.34946775436401367,
-0.8802400231361389,
0.6176459193229675,
-0.47628411650657654,
-0.5593051910400391,
-0.15322785079479218,
-0.6982372403144836,
-0.9257518649101257,
0.3480343520641327,
-0.27430474758148193,
-0.5267078280448914,
0.13291025161743164,
-0.014194486662745476,
-0.20377203822135925,
-0.09859661757946014,
-0.5521103143692017,
0.34583431482315063,
0.10532789677381516,
-0.4227578043937683,
0.11314395070075989,
-0.5749374628067017,
0.4538659453392029,
-0.2059459686279297,
0.017930883914232254,
-0.04195426404476166,
0.3625379204750061,
0.49635258316993713,
-0.284752756357193,
0.6775683760643005,
0.1895260065793991,
-0.0011286805383861065,
0.6453281044960022,
0.15081781148910522,
0.2592334449291229,
0.08303110301494598,
-0.4302637577056885,
-0.33286264538764954,
-0.28026556968688965,
-0.062133707106113434,
-0.6403605937957764,
0.8515809774398804,
-0.4106263518333435,
-0.818325936794281,
-0.09983275085687637,
-0.8898669481277466,
-0.2072560042142868,
0.05272560194134712,
0.22730284929275513,
0.5050144195556641,
-0.34132304787635803,
0.41225987672805786,
0.5116588473320007,
-0.258554071187973,
0.33017444610595703,
0.29478538036346436,
-0.3540840446949005,
-0.556561291217804,
1.0237873792648315,
0.06993979960680008,
0.2807193994522095,
0.36469557881355286,
0.061285655945539474,
-0.3069312274456024,
-0.5590712428092957,
-0.22348490357398987,
0.16536641120910645,
-0.780185878276825,
-0.1633947789669037,
-0.40301138162612915,
-0.2026502788066864,
-0.4366038143634796,
0.11346564441919327,
-0.15978263318538666,
-0.5987464189529419,
-0.44605445861816406,
-0.1802508383989334,
0.5200865268707275,
0.5315263271331787,
-0.12510249018669128,
0.2407037913799286,
-0.7246220707893372,
0.39267104864120483,
0.45393234491348267,
-0.02941686473786831,
-0.07896594703197479,
-0.5683547854423523,
0.1450926661491394,
0.22856687009334564,
-0.3470444083213806,
-0.7736123204231262,
0.5411337018013,
0.4001311659812927,
0.668278157711029,
-0.02990688569843769,
0.028523830696940422,
0.4977521002292633,
-0.5883432626724243,
0.8896276354789734,
0.1762191355228424,
-0.673983097076416,
0.6121463775634766,
-0.2529458701610565,
0.24418845772743225,
0.8857130408287048,
0.2916885316371918,
-0.2696032226085663,
-0.6297683715820312,
-0.335742712020874,
-0.9458247423171997,
0.5275309085845947,
0.3514851927757263,
0.3539794981479645,
-0.2788905203342438,
0.409873902797699,
0.5125122666358948,
0.43161672353744507,
-0.44116219878196716,
-0.28164437413215637,
-0.11454878747463226,
-0.5365135073661804,
0.13017058372497559,
0.040644533932209015,
-0.10239952057600021,
-0.18858806788921356,
0.6844459176063538,
-0.15147288143634796,
-0.18194879591464996,
0.052517060190439224,
0.056694019585847855,
0.2075929045677185,
0.6059737205505371,
0.170758917927742,
0.5523235201835632,
-0.08220279961824417,
0.2943825423717499,
-0.0011547972681000829,
-0.4011373221874237,
0.3208560049533844,
0.3319839835166931,
-0.4391147494316101,
0.2514286935329437,
0.0649452805519104,
0.7088763117790222,
-0.03585830703377724,
-0.6973484754562378,
-0.07040277123451233,
0.04850582778453827,
-0.1077442541718483,
0.2378622591495514,
0.3855249285697937,
-0.11280384659767151,
0.3324771523475647,
0.6371265053749084,
-0.2676040232181549,
0.46020588278770447,
-0.6540166139602661,
0.29376402497291565,
0.29233673214912415,
0.07924368977546692,
-0.14525610208511353,
0.38046327233314514,
-0.028162531554698944,
0.016238218173384666,
0.7717882990837097,
-0.3600769340991974,
-0.3175116181373596,
0.39688393473625183,
0.5817036032676697,
0.6901400685310364,
-0.27666252851486206,
0.3580576479434967,
0.3969811797142029,
-0.08593638241291046,
-0.37282460927963257,
0.39093026518821716,
0.135763481259346,
-0.7433934807777405,
-0.4116327166557312,
-0.8648778796195984,
-0.299186646938324,
0.20885874330997467,
-0.6969525218009949,
0.2985633611679077,
-0.20096519589424133,
-0.298878014087677,
0.18215513229370117,
-0.2460678070783615,
-0.6224443316459656,
0.22050273418426514,
-0.09315793216228485,
0.5964102745056152,
-0.8271561861038208,
0.5968183279037476,
0.8153660297393799,
-0.49811622500419617,
-0.846640944480896,
0.08659039437770844,
-0.23153378069400787,
-0.3555304706096649,
0.8304154872894287,
0.10843507945537567,
0.3534974157810211,
0.16019637882709503,
-0.5046620965003967,
-0.47261902689933777,
0.8691897988319397,
0.2932985723018646,
-0.6951470971107483,
-0.004601833876222372,
0.32418200373649597,
0.7379239201545715,
-0.47488704323768616,
0.08646944910287857,
0.5585625171661377,
0.3548949360847473,
0.5448012948036194,
-0.6388843059539795,
0.049622949212789536,
-0.2345881313085556,
0.4099004864692688,
-0.07973328232765198,
-0.26743850111961365,
0.9591514468193054,
-0.11602534353733063,
-0.2543274164199829,
0.20741242170333862,
0.6737299561500549,
0.7477188110351562,
0.1542704701423645,
0.12280110269784927,
0.5675430297851562,
0.8223374485969543,
-0.22669868171215057,
0.8437040448188782,
0.1661709100008011,
0.11640314757823944,
1.3933815956115723,
-0.4932018518447876,
0.7257317304611206,
0.6658162474632263,
-0.3396645188331604,
0.45519179105758667,
0.5298725962638855,
-0.24309872090816498,
0.625602126121521,
0.5066463947296143,
-0.4161127805709839,
-0.20630857348442078,
-0.19118927419185638,
-0.44513481855392456,
0.27490460872650146,
0.48075640201568604,
-0.4770694077014923,
-0.31071221828460693,
0.29178276658058167,
-0.2528243362903595,
0.08424434810876846,
-0.07854874432086945,
0.8297903537750244,
0.07385849952697754,
-0.6476350426673889,
0.6447933912277222,
-0.18207591772079468,
0.5455434322357178,
-0.3803947865962982,
-0.12773819267749786,
-0.3517586290836334,
-0.07930660247802734,
-0.16341865062713623,
-0.9800235629081726,
0.06591666489839554,
-0.0477471686899662,
-0.3443843126296997,
-0.06544332206249237,
0.6619445085525513,
-0.8831201791763306,
-0.6360263228416443,
-0.3450763523578644,
0.5283687114715576,
0.27292394638061523,
0.1523086130619049,
-0.47473740577697754,
0.23797017335891724,
0.24038362503051758,
-0.23329177498817444,
0.3948030471801758,
0.5912447571754456,
0.009930589236319065,
0.5155265927314758,
0.6908110976219177,
0.16326582431793213,
-0.011423076502978802,
0.38978245854377747,
1.1803058385849,
-0.4460861384868622,
-0.2093709111213684,
-0.7581638097763062,
0.4578000009059906,
-0.017304616048932076,
-0.019874464720487595,
0.8730590343475342,
0.6965830326080322,
0.8154944777488708,
-0.31836003065109253,
1.2232180833816528,
-0.1324913203716278,
0.6437358260154724,
-0.5892868041992188,
0.3595627546310425,
-0.49133893847465515,
0.5348394513130188,
-0.2514701783657074,
-1.2562248706817627,
-0.2620322108268738,
0.44166630506515503,
-0.17165188491344452,
0.11171630769968033,
0.36943694949150085,
0.9372614622116089,
-0.0835346207022667,
0.019478322938084602,
0.08437307178974152,
0.011143938638269901,
0.4147673547267914,
0.3599153161048889,
0.9291999340057373,
-0.35521090030670166,
0.5057938694953918,
-0.1173032820224762,
0.10875217616558075,
-0.2104131132364273,
-0.8696733713150024,
-0.8350268006324768,
-0.502534806728363,
-0.4000253975391388,
-0.36057305335998535,
0.041411470621824265,
1.0430026054382324,
0.324025422334671,
-0.8764967322349548,
-0.1410023421049118,
-0.05299583077430725,
0.15788230299949646,
0.15464343130588531,
-0.3123027980327606,
0.01582515612244606,
-0.506751537322998,
-0.9332606196403503,
0.6104243397712708,
0.024582406505942345,
0.30050891637802124,
-0.30882030725479126,
0.21305522322654724,
0.07554998248815536,
-0.14249105751514435,
0.38440757989883423,
0.15395957231521606,
-0.6288614273071289,
-0.12661613523960114,
0.027090348303318024,
-0.029089463874697685,
0.07656640559434891,
0.7950463891029358,
-0.9374958872795105,
0.5344102382659912,
1.0185848474502563,
0.7109503746032715,
0.5001389980316162,
0.2962903678417206,
0.5554172992706299,
-1.1898857355117798,
0.1805126965045929,
0.26277023553848267,
0.2797185480594635,
0.6628898978233337,
-0.0631929337978363,
0.2614167630672455,
0.17419804632663727,
-0.3239661455154419,
-0.9196780920028687,
0.42569443583488464,
-0.7852615714073181,
-0.4245270788669586,
1.2623528242111206,
0.013074005953967571,
-0.24542784690856934,
0.016114968806505203,
-0.44531673192977905,
0.13708525896072388,
-0.6314424276351929,
0.7673051953315735,
0.6034141778945923,
0.029335908591747284,
0.055506836622953415,
-0.07172837108373642,
0.4057946503162384,
0.0010150641901418567,
-0.9357495903968811,
0.05520685389637947,
0.8859336376190186,
0.3821946084499359,
0.3054963946342468,
0.09413094818592072,
-0.10694169998168945,
-0.06741704046726227,
-0.08254914730787277,
0.01593797653913498,
-0.09063953906297684,
-0.37922245264053345,
0.03737260401248932,
0.11041316390037537,
0.06178940087556839,
0.3047337234020233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13032v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13032v2
|
Faithful Attention Explainer: Verbalizing Decisions Based on Discriminative Features
| 2024-05-16T12:13:24 | 2024-05-27T07:20:52 |
Yao Rong, David Scheerer, Enkelejda Kasneci
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
In recent years, model explanation methods have been designed to interpret
model decisions faithfully and intuitively so that users can easily understand
them. In this paper, we propose a framework, Faithful Attention Explainer
(FAE), capable of generating faithful textual explanations regarding the
attended-to features. Towards this goal, we deploy an attention module that
takes the visual feature maps from the classifier for sentence generation.
Furthermore, our method successfully learns the association between features
and words, which allows a novel attention enforcement module for attention
explanation. Our model achieves promising performance in caption quality
metrics and a faithful decision-relevance metric on two datasets (CUB and
ACT-X). In addition, we show that FAE can interpret gaze-based human attention,
as human gaze indicates the discriminative features that humans use for
decision-making, demonstrating the potential of deploying human gaze for
advanced human-AI interaction.
|
[
-0.17112666368484497,
-0.7921783328056335,
0.8726434111595154,
0.3157881200313568,
-0.14872321486473083,
-0.330729603767395,
-0.03328585997223854,
-0.3626047968864441,
-0.15466901659965515,
0.7352965474128723,
-0.7416136264801025,
-0.3977929949760437,
-0.3328748643398285,
0.07262574881315231,
-0.45135578513145447,
0.8934998512268066,
-0.24918247759342194,
0.042976077646017075,
-0.5837814211845398,
-0.28529512882232666,
-0.5865373015403748,
-0.17073965072631836,
-0.6078810095787048,
-0.2987145483493805,
0.45189833641052246,
0.3778204619884491,
0.9571124315261841,
0.770321249961853,
0.5982378125190735,
0.33956652879714966,
0.3100907504558563,
0.3355008363723755,
-0.5876849889755249,
-0.10546533018350601,
-0.5468866229057312,
-0.8275907635688782,
-0.5098260045051575,
-0.0014705669600516558,
0.5958454608917236,
0.6143646240234375,
0.06582800298929214,
0.2796595096588135,
0.1214311420917511,
0.6587134003639221,
-0.3887039124965668,
0.3823348581790924,
-0.6258724331855774,
0.07726651430130005,
0.04673057794570923,
-0.16448599100112915,
-0.5566244721412659,
-0.2224275916814804,
0.20243725180625916,
-1.0380970239639282,
0.6963761448860168,
0.295559823513031,
1.3563259840011597,
0.6689951419830322,
-0.026576047763228416,
0.08984692394733429,
-0.6303297877311707,
0.8771418929100037,
-0.19237929582595825,
0.49244850873947144,
0.6639728546142578,
0.42346447706222534,
0.0760231614112854,
-0.8019897937774658,
-0.6245405077934265,
-0.04636305570602417,
-0.29567673802375793,
0.3436083197593689,
-0.13052037358283997,
0.12280266731977463,
0.17914284765720367,
0.3530474007129669,
-0.5298076868057251,
-0.37371331453323364,
0.0330532006919384,
-0.06002228707075119,
0.8027397394180298,
0.18620723485946655,
0.2864430248737335,
0.15708190202713013,
-0.3581496775150299,
0.19286297261714935,
-0.403004914522171,
0.12941940128803253,
-0.016412483528256416,
-0.059148333966732025,
-0.13686074316501617,
0.5982862710952759,
-0.023147115483880043,
0.698157787322998,
0.4713400900363922,
0.20508192479610443,
0.007445340044796467,
-0.2662084996700287,
-0.34674522280693054,
-0.1168995201587677,
0.7122927904129028,
0.438279926776886,
0.6859650015830994,
-0.3473256826400757,
-0.10553004592657089,
0.2578875422477722,
0.5479967594146729,
-0.45079565048217773,
-0.1036883071064949,
0.1744958460330963,
-0.7299537062644958,
-0.4543572962284088,
0.09412415325641632,
-0.7830016613006592,
-0.11167046427726746,
-0.4326464831829071,
0.19797968864440918,
-0.37085652351379395,
-0.16614477336406708,
0.1514926254749298,
-0.11023623496294022,
0.37164509296417236,
0.35636475682258606,
-0.9148836135864258,
0.4239371418952942,
0.4807264804840088,
0.5999967455863953,
-0.2197403907775879,
-0.42422401905059814,
-0.6603530049324036,
0.43342170119285583,
-0.3065102696418762,
0.5967585444450378,
-0.6860962510108948,
-0.022675450891256332,
-0.05531113222241402,
0.17112115025520325,
-0.2734629511833191,
-0.36528533697128296,
0.47543326020240784,
-0.4124438166618347,
0.23959305882453918,
-0.12378253787755966,
-0.3659776449203491,
-0.4280964434146881,
0.07177547365427017,
-0.6410489082336426,
0.8914236426353455,
0.14132577180862427,
-0.6678542494773865,
0.43250977993011475,
-0.9253458380699158,
-0.5087082982063293,
0.259069561958313,
-0.05863251909613609,
-0.5840940475463867,
0.24438171088695526,
0.40333712100982666,
0.3696240484714508,
-0.030894923955202103,
0.4495048224925995,
-0.3713940978050232,
-0.2933392822742462,
0.7304337620735168,
-0.5946527719497681,
0.5772148370742798,
0.12161868810653687,
-0.4068717658519745,
0.24304448068141937,
-0.39787206053733826,
-0.2585758566856384,
0.4399241507053375,
-0.05545918270945549,
-0.16041195392608643,
0.24359309673309326,
0.09835560619831085,
-0.02928939275443554,
0.29579153656959534,
-0.20406045019626617,
-0.3909490704536438,
-0.31030508875846863,
0.44200342893600464,
0.48947224020957947,
0.02030584216117859,
0.6080392003059387,
-0.2658255696296692,
0.5471118092536926,
-0.16039115190505981,
0.6361001133918762,
-0.3916319012641907,
-0.3621179461479187,
-0.8361927270889282,
-0.2478412389755249,
0.27139610052108765,
0.39107146859169006,
-0.6811504364013672,
0.2073659598827362,
-0.48351427912712097,
0.30747514963150024,
-0.8772799968719482,
0.16393572092056274,
0.7696107029914856,
0.4284427762031555,
0.17832736670970917,
-0.042842328548431396,
-0.033931322395801544,
-1.1119606494903564,
-0.3659322261810303,
-0.4643362760543823,
-0.055460650473833084,
0.5034001469612122,
0.3115309774875641,
0.03501087427139282,
1.1853790283203125,
-0.4188612401485443,
-0.2669728398323059,
-0.35589438676834106,
0.05623605474829674,
-0.38244661688804626,
0.004507223144173622,
0.7205830216407776,
-1.2957417964935303,
-0.2012227326631546,
0.11314138025045395,
-0.9741730093955994,
-0.11132409423589706,
-0.5876519680023193,
-0.3965227007865906,
0.10060445964336395,
0.44130241870880127,
-0.6052375435829163,
0.4916042685508728,
0.021660175174474716,
-0.32818660140037537,
0.35410168766975403,
0.07552199065685272,
0.08626605570316315,
-0.6958566904067993,
0.0748397633433342,
0.11320509016513824,
-0.6990217566490173,
-0.36561843752861023,
0.2741784155368805,
-0.06951864063739777,
-0.12213516235351562,
-0.33150044083595276,
0.7234935164451599,
-0.38107046484947205,
-0.16596761345863342,
0.012601913884282112,
0.47750553488731384,
0.4799167811870575,
0.6836397647857666,
0.22664637863636017,
0.5615983605384827,
0.3461341857910156,
-0.49052655696868896,
0.20164799690246582,
0.8205384612083435,
0.23052065074443817,
0.5879840850830078,
-0.6424537301063538,
-0.015296511352062225,
-0.17427785694599152,
-0.135650634765625,
-1.1175634860992432,
-0.6240649819374084,
0.3381686508655548,
-0.8809495568275452,
0.2936679720878601,
-0.11465145647525787,
-0.19182196259498596,
-0.46272632479667664,
-0.3622108995914459,
0.08678574860095978,
0.256512314081192,
-0.6544263362884521,
0.8477701544761658,
0.20383886992931366,
-0.13791947066783905,
-0.3627156615257263,
-0.8936660289764404,
0.20876599848270416,
-0.4128513038158417,
-0.6923025846481323,
0.27699029445648193,
-0.14764779806137085,
-0.4156326949596405,
0.14544174075126648,
0.03838895261287689,
-0.13816726207733154,
0.29895007610321045,
0.5108054280281067,
0.39449891448020935,
-0.21724657714366913,
0.2259821742773056,
0.03404391556978226,
0.0262730922549963,
0.3660428524017334,
-0.08279142528772354,
0.009578214026987553,
-0.18398131430149078,
-0.32008519768714905,
-0.8593176603317261,
0.3899403512477875,
0.8281790018081665,
-0.4853806793689728,
0.3896508812904358,
0.6120894551277161,
-0.3643318712711334,
-0.19906389713287354,
-0.3963560461997986,
-0.26086902618408203,
-0.4615214169025421,
0.32795536518096924,
-0.6154385805130005,
-0.6227740049362183,
0.37633416056632996,
-0.018488572910428047,
0.07477062195539474,
0.36683571338653564,
0.287476122379303,
-0.2552475333213806,
1.3555127382278442,
0.7075713276863098,
0.05097365751862526,
0.5907458066940308,
0.1556513011455536,
0.11976132541894913,
-0.6473740935325623,
-0.21498864889144897,
-0.264219731092453,
-0.16201047599315643,
-0.22003059089183807,
-0.014865009114146233,
-0.1299283653497696,
0.15782688558101654,
0.021975861862301826,
0.044246919453144073,
-0.553837776184082,
0.3449890911579132,
0.44346505403518677,
0.3286888599395752,
-0.021567625924944878,
0.09261824190616608,
0.21251444518566132,
-0.21429342031478882,
-0.6823999881744385,
-0.6767052412033081,
0.7803285121917725,
0.5625453591346741,
0.7020266652107239,
-0.017773462459445,
0.5053046345710754,
0.3787207305431366,
0.42409631609916687,
-0.7968484163284302,
0.510718822479248,
-0.14688917994499207,
-0.47230303287506104,
-0.3985808789730072,
-0.24418821930885315,
-0.8537849187850952,
-0.0013054974842816591,
-0.17611977458000183,
-0.5935685038566589,
0.08267314732074738,
0.23633907735347748,
-0.4339953064918518,
-0.3481699824333191,
-0.9669976830482483,
1.108906626701355,
-0.46646684408187866,
-0.7464166879653931,
-0.2419985979795456,
-0.660632848739624,
0.4990130066871643,
0.01703246496617794,
0.05974263325333595,
0.10784625262022018,
0.013858845457434654,
0.6102927327156067,
-0.14608962833881378,
0.9683442711830139,
-0.1535317301750183,
0.1330401748418808,
0.22672250866889954,
0.04031289368867874,
0.20950579643249512,
0.28810977935791016,
0.053034357726573944,
0.005176047328859568,
-0.5657891035079956,
-0.19286970794200897,
-0.8627177476882935,
0.33266302943229675,
-0.48135292530059814,
-0.8116406798362732,
-0.012870590202510357,
-0.6122526526451111,
-0.20112276077270508,
0.010119199752807617,
0.05876260623335838,
0.36614990234375,
-0.33624371886253357,
-0.0966590866446495,
0.853672206401825,
-0.17797061800956726,
0.2581321597099304,
0.4943939745426178,
-0.2550997734069824,
-0.23832891881465912,
1.074800729751587,
-0.4538922905921936,
0.17512603104114532,
0.608854353427887,
0.17494355142116547,
-0.4641045033931732,
-0.6560046672821045,
-0.48642420768737793,
0.4185057580471039,
-0.4734927713871002,
-0.017092544585466385,
-0.5727450847625732,
-0.18884912133216858,
-0.154222771525383,
-0.36644989252090454,
-0.014023267664015293,
-0.29792487621307373,
-0.4690547287464142,
-0.1528460830450058,
0.3142593801021576,
0.6187186241149902,
0.3699304461479187,
0.422982782125473,
-0.6684682965278625,
0.9686386585235596,
0.4219511151313782,
0.1581493467092514,
-0.14997269213199615,
-0.5432087779045105,
-0.14498969912528992,
0.20228531956672668,
-0.502117395401001,
-0.7577651143074036,
0.3418351709842682,
0.43568235635757446,
0.7851081490516663,
0.8433468341827393,
0.0007412409759126604,
0.5885266065597534,
-0.40926581621170044,
0.8206495642662048,
0.06480555981397629,
-1.0256375074386597,
0.9180721044540405,
-0.358784943819046,
0.32705816626548767,
0.41399243474006653,
0.08709094673395157,
-0.10602937638759613,
-0.765248715877533,
-0.6444671154022217,
-0.5049481391906738,
1.0056238174438477,
0.5646097660064697,
0.15273776650428772,
0.012256201356649399,
0.6755953431129456,
0.13832330703735352,
0.0775211974978447,
-0.7556248903274536,
-0.1763816475868225,
-0.33147546648979187,
-0.584338903427124,
0.07652967423200607,
-0.19635489583015442,
-0.2026117891073227,
-0.029477421194314957,
0.584142804145813,
-0.3833467960357666,
0.4389915466308594,
0.34082916378974915,
-0.38779252767562866,
-0.21722261607646942,
0.09302802383899689,
0.4896043837070465,
0.754821240901947,
-0.010419871658086777,
-0.08719789981842041,
0.007163084577769041,
-0.4718906581401825,
-0.38649246096611023,
0.3538515567779541,
-0.3358038365840912,
0.2366056591272354,
0.5998874306678772,
0.9609923362731934,
0.2459009736776352,
-0.47981125116348267,
0.6151477098464966,
-0.25679880380630493,
-0.24646881222724915,
0.058157600462436676,
0.10850606858730316,
0.06185455247759819,
0.26982277631759644,
0.1324784755706787,
-0.0029947804287075996,
0.3649253845214844,
-0.3990839123725891,
0.2618255615234375,
0.330893337726593,
-0.7947201728820801,
-0.34548091888427734,
1.137545108795166,
0.40507960319519043,
-0.1490664929151535,
0.4788568615913391,
-0.041751399636268616,
-0.690735399723053,
0.7572028040885925,
0.33023765683174133,
1.1261104345321655,
-0.35470789670944214,
0.6016912460327148,
0.13156923651695251,
0.24337755143642426,
0.07957770675420761,
0.24851688742637634,
-0.48235076665878296,
-0.7043004035949707,
-0.24337445199489594,
-0.5953021049499512,
-0.29793524742126465,
-0.050844088196754456,
-0.9711835980415344,
0.11183852702379227,
-0.15745624899864197,
-0.11270508170127869,
0.5566568970680237,
-0.49819067120552063,
-0.616690993309021,
0.29380032420158386,
0.24437101185321808,
0.5789433717727661,
-0.7012453675270081,
0.45823928713798523,
0.7762815952301025,
-0.5509971976280212,
-0.4097924530506134,
0.27330008149147034,
-0.18726766109466553,
-0.9921585917472839,
0.4867780804634094,
0.333964079618454,
-0.3738000988960266,
-0.23806263506412506,
-0.7573411464691162,
-0.28378385305404663,
0.8938630223274231,
0.7438457012176514,
-0.614159107208252,
0.023768004029989243,
0.24433228373527527,
0.5017557144165039,
-0.40064775943756104,
0.10473527014255524,
0.5072256326675415,
0.6456793546676636,
-0.12754902243614197,
-0.6293690800666809,
0.033179741352796555,
-0.16337557137012482,
0.033385131508111954,
-0.06383715569972992,
-0.6507526636123657,
0.1462855339050293,
-0.4848465621471405,
-0.3865981101989746,
0.10641761869192123,
0.770135760307312,
0.010016432963311672,
0.7236194610595703,
0.32099390029907227,
0.3172590136528015,
0.5334272980690002,
-0.26864495873451233,
1.1736482381820679,
0.037227604538202286,
0.29476290941238403,
1.2101794481277466,
-0.24647343158721924,
0.7122127413749695,
0.5231308341026306,
-0.1165752112865448,
0.4664525091648102,
0.7319154739379883,
-0.12039110064506531,
0.5662233233451843,
-0.18104441463947296,
-0.1290358603000641,
-0.6193262934684753,
-0.32892924547195435,
0.2041095346212387,
0.49129095673561096,
0.4360029697418213,
-0.7640559077262878,
-0.04935964569449425,
0.2505132853984833,
-0.352509081363678,
0.3394043743610382,
-0.40998849272727966,
1.0316977500915527,
0.16247563064098358,
-0.7732241153717041,
0.48785147070884705,
-0.2843729853630066,
0.03586455434560776,
-0.5604570508003235,
-0.3877905309200287,
-0.10903484374284744,
0.43405967950820923,
-0.22082538902759552,
-1.1001750230789185,
0.2502749562263489,
0.03612826019525528,
-0.5933911800384521,
-0.4085484743118286,
0.5717039704322815,
-0.5152605772018433,
-0.42043229937553406,
0.2982483208179474,
0.17684493958950043,
0.22972558438777924,
-0.306824654340744,
-1.0268480777740479,
-0.049435898661613464,
0.16690275073051453,
-0.22663097083568573,
-0.11810365319252014,
0.568941593170166,
-0.3804636001586914,
0.8432031273841858,
0.3212987780570984,
-0.4804568886756897,
-0.10320758819580078,
0.4460110664367676,
0.6478227376937866,
-0.45392608642578125,
-0.5526154637336731,
-0.7586836218833923,
0.5720243453979492,
-0.1935591995716095,
-0.19170138239860535,
0.442394495010376,
0.5232383608818054,
0.43867215514183044,
-0.2773427665233612,
0.9206992387771606,
0.30982252955436707,
0.16404011845588684,
-0.5771508812904358,
0.7507352828979492,
-0.6519327163696289,
-0.09148861467838287,
0.07215485721826553,
-0.8992055654525757,
-0.13573503494262695,
0.6204820871353149,
-0.08975904434919357,
0.05398384854197502,
0.8548871278762817,
0.5488433837890625,
-0.18633221089839935,
0.13073700666427612,
0.452767014503479,
0.35515648126602173,
-0.021455056965351105,
0.45480987429618835,
0.7962292432785034,
-0.31125298142433167,
0.6551550030708313,
0.104609914124012,
-0.21764110028743744,
-0.22952331602573395,
-0.3478315770626068,
-1.107372760772705,
-0.5622336268424988,
-0.5925661325454712,
-0.13541682064533234,
0.2807316482067108,
0.1616130918264389,
0.7270827293395996,
-0.6450944542884827,
0.31511303782463074,
-0.24583788216114044,
0.23289459943771362,
-0.47335192561149597,
-0.3804236948490143,
0.4293781816959381,
-0.5079743266105652,
-0.781179666519165,
0.1659291684627533,
0.3250297009944916,
-0.057086631655693054,
-0.2432219386100769,
-0.31080809235572815,
0.05201907083392143,
0.22400493919849396,
0.41902396082878113,
-0.0037652996834367514,
-1.1663222312927246,
-0.3211935758590698,
0.1355782449245453,
0.04521803930401802,
-0.023519784212112427,
0.7273504137992859,
-0.665905773639679,
0.6613761186599731,
-0.0020966215524822474,
0.5287938714027405,
0.6577962040901184,
0.27089935541152954,
0.8271565437316895,
-0.6542893052101135,
-0.2026377171278,
0.012986751273274422,
0.3002549111843109,
0.5962921380996704,
-0.6614585518836975,
0.5163635611534119,
0.15418080985546112,
-0.3156863749027252,
-0.5655857920646667,
0.23979933559894562,
-1.3362092971801758,
-0.19368241727352142,
1.0722911357879639,
-0.48348644375801086,
-0.5946900248527527,
-0.4263426959514618,
-0.4247390925884247,
0.2190038412809372,
-0.40923070907592773,
0.8598285913467407,
0.7088807225227356,
-0.08246829360723495,
-0.4343312978744507,
-0.4840465188026428,
0.5584313273429871,
0.35545632243156433,
-1.001083493232727,
0.5575695037841797,
0.5293416976928711,
0.21123751997947693,
0.14106430113315582,
0.11892114579677582,
-0.31040510535240173,
0.7519881725311279,
-0.05501902103424072,
0.07150585204362869,
-0.15207380056381226,
-0.43729284405708313,
-0.3185838758945465,
-0.08140363544225693,
-0.06590787321329117,
-0.6515283584594727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10025v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10025v1
|
Listen Again and Choose the Right Answer: A New Paradigm for Automatic Speech Recognition with Large Language Models
| 2024-05-16T12:05:45 | 2024-05-16T12:05:45 |
Yuchen Hu, Chen Chen, Chengwei Qin, Qiushi Zhu, Eng Siong Chng, Ruizhe Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have promoted generative
error correction (GER) for automatic speech recognition (ASR), which aims to
predict the ground-truth transcription from the decoded N-best hypotheses.
Thanks to the strong language generation ability of LLMs and rich information
in the N-best list, GER shows great effectiveness in enhancing ASR results.
However, it still suffers from two limitations: 1) LLMs are unaware of the
source speech during GER, which may lead to results that are grammatically
correct but violate the source speech content, 2) N-best hypotheses usually
only vary in a few tokens, making it redundant to send all of them for GER,
which could confuse LLM about which tokens to focus on and thus lead to
increased miscorrection. In this paper, we propose ClozeGER, a new paradigm for
ASR generative error correction. First, we introduce a multimodal LLM (i.e.,
SpeechGPT) to receive source speech as extra input to improve the fidelity of
correction output. Then, we reformat GER as a cloze test with logits
calibration to remove the input information redundancy and simplify GER with
clear instructions. Experiments show that ClozeGER achieves a new breakthrough
over vanilla GER on 9 popular ASR datasets.
|
[
-0.348487913608551,
-0.7202727794647217,
0.5336271524429321,
-0.004144300706684589,
-0.22730840742588043,
0.0009215767495334148,
-0.4910663068294525,
-0.32412102818489075,
-0.04301949217915535,
0.5381234884262085,
-0.3468862473964691,
-0.41610628366470337,
-0.8209182620048523,
0.2789364457130432,
-0.5250239968299866,
0.7779492139816284,
-0.01818010024726391,
0.2242632508277893,
-0.05482030287384987,
-0.32973232865333557,
-0.5613370537757874,
-0.5990561246871948,
-0.7820627093315125,
-0.2432929277420044,
0.4025321900844574,
0.29580286145210266,
0.7075856924057007,
0.6840817928314209,
0.13318827748298645,
0.41214901208877563,
-0.2384454905986786,
0.30374273657798767,
-0.2337815761566162,
-0.026508957147598267,
0.14745420217514038,
-0.4805539846420288,
-0.4397260248661041,
-0.4291408956050873,
0.7357563972473145,
0.41615691781044006,
-0.4696623980998993,
-0.038513343781232834,
-0.02670893445611,
0.5238465070724487,
-0.40696412324905396,
0.14260050654411316,
-0.7019972205162048,
-0.1469828188419342,
-0.14642830193042755,
-0.11079609394073486,
-0.4655073285102844,
-0.4932146966457367,
0.1797298640012741,
-0.5289046764373779,
0.5694199800491333,
-0.10689819604158401,
0.4537909924983978,
0.5209347605705261,
-0.06857655197381973,
-0.5183705687522888,
-0.8353368639945984,
0.6745135188102722,
-0.9382360577583313,
0.6031327247619629,
0.18089111149311066,
0.3593357503414154,
-0.12572628259658813,
-0.5221830606460571,
-0.8723370432853699,
-0.17763501405715942,
0.03081502951681614,
-0.18631240725517273,
-0.3263055682182312,
0.058734696358442307,
0.295329749584198,
0.1469765305519104,
-0.46623873710632324,
-0.01395333930850029,
-0.5458321571350098,
-0.6453155279159546,
0.6456358432769775,
-0.16240862011909485,
0.23337377607822418,
0.21236544847488403,
-0.1447611302137375,
-0.27794885635375977,
-0.6388367414474487,
-0.26822274923324585,
0.137516051530838,
0.35696443915367126,
0.15608379244804382,
0.3636564612388611,
0.07227431982755661,
0.9755920171737671,
0.2864607274532318,
-0.24954476952552795,
0.49530038237571716,
0.04076681658625603,
-0.16077537834644318,
0.6345518827438354,
0.6722622513771057,
0.25102490186691284,
0.17727331817150116,
0.04909253865480423,
-0.13796070218086243,
0.22876405715942383,
0.04058917984366417,
-0.5200490355491638,
-0.18009500205516815,
0.19171930849552155,
-0.07868969440460205,
0.13942000269889832,
-0.07885409891605377,
-0.7025666236877441,
-0.4922853410243988,
-0.5131546258926392,
0.5060567855834961,
-0.4045092761516571,
-0.060135360807180405,
0.1533927470445633,
-0.11321932077407837,
-0.038305435329675674,
0.6480020880699158,
-0.6546717286109924,
0.027634501457214355,
0.46264058351516724,
0.7135138511657715,
0.16208796203136444,
-0.3120902180671692,
-0.8535897135734558,
0.0921480804681778,
-0.39945125579833984,
0.7952287197113037,
-0.3784147799015045,
-0.53951495885849,
0.05114693567156792,
-0.29940274357795715,
-0.12630465626716614,
-0.7719706892967224,
0.5916133522987366,
-0.5610299706459045,
0.07669030129909515,
-0.30482885241508484,
-0.6037218570709229,
-0.2835233807563782,
-0.12331728637218475,
-0.6158456802368164,
0.6632880568504333,
-0.1361013501882553,
-0.3672195076942444,
0.48418453335762024,
-0.5759996175765991,
-0.49506860971450806,
-0.03223620727658272,
-0.14469124376773834,
-0.5668133497238159,
0.044060658663511276,
0.3891400396823883,
0.11133700609207153,
-0.023894477635622025,
0.37983959913253784,
-0.2715090811252594,
-0.2569069564342499,
0.3217238783836365,
-0.4822594225406647,
0.6108114123344421,
0.22013327479362488,
-0.39839544892311096,
0.2668781578540802,
-1.0007597208023071,
0.26042184233665466,
-0.13942141830921173,
-0.5449389815330505,
-0.037551358342170715,
0.02102060057222843,
-0.030307408422231674,
0.04714256897568703,
0.032982341945171356,
-0.6750625371932983,
-0.07002146542072296,
-0.353626549243927,
0.8521461486816406,
0.7989393472671509,
-0.41682079434394836,
0.38728588819503784,
-0.3513249158859253,
0.2048925906419754,
-0.1971752792596817,
-0.13430453836917877,
-0.08073359727859497,
-0.14134275913238525,
-0.9299532175064087,
-0.3341781795024872,
0.2670944333076477,
0.680082380771637,
-0.5229207873344421,
0.5110750198364258,
-0.2502007782459259,
-0.34633198380470276,
-0.8315184116363525,
0.3448132574558258,
0.3497292399406433,
0.42122364044189453,
0.43337103724479675,
-0.13439182937145233,
-0.9059374928474426,
-0.6271301507949829,
-0.22046566009521484,
-0.2283395379781723,
-0.10525684058666229,
0.18956319987773895,
0.20018570125102997,
-0.4542878568172455,
1.0269675254821777,
-0.30590349435806274,
-0.48975300788879395,
-0.30542945861816406,
0.1785479038953781,
0.2217370718717575,
0.3583030700683594,
0.044887907803058624,
-0.7830827832221985,
-0.3976452946662903,
-0.06867221742868423,
-0.45627498626708984,
-0.056814998388290405,
0.06364179402589798,
0.2777766287326813,
0.3096592128276825,
0.5813913345336914,
-0.7028773427009583,
0.1896362006664276,
0.5514026284217834,
0.1513756960630417,
0.41953402757644653,
-0.29026737809181213,
-0.1276666671037674,
-0.7697083353996277,
-0.14707939326763153,
-0.40067586302757263,
-0.17475488781929016,
-0.6807821393013,
-0.21052995324134827,
0.16051684319972992,
-0.03730573505163193,
-0.24684202671051025,
0.43470507860183716,
-0.3785943388938904,
-0.048950936645269394,
-0.35735270380973816,
0.15283963084220886,
-0.21508827805519104,
0.22046448290348053,
-0.01123233325779438,
0.9787359237670898,
0.535280168056488,
-0.7550486326217651,
0.6545289754867554,
0.6224505305290222,
-0.3352464437484741,
0.5026240944862366,
-0.7562059760093689,
0.5103995203971863,
-0.5743717551231384,
0.5632597208023071,
-0.9710880517959595,
-0.4733435809612274,
0.08180403709411621,
-0.7102643251419067,
0.45835381746292114,
0.018315520137548447,
-0.4031563401222229,
-0.40688979625701904,
0.07855170220136642,
0.3694764971733093,
0.529491662979126,
-0.8078912496566772,
0.8241053223609924,
0.3050810992717743,
-0.3073263466358185,
-0.59151291847229,
-0.5621590614318848,
0.17675524950027466,
-0.07192610949277878,
-0.755214273929596,
0.020479511469602585,
-0.2531144320964813,
-0.12013646960258484,
-0.238991841673851,
-0.1528320014476776,
0.006479818373918533,
-0.32063087821006775,
0.16907091438770294,
0.1726539582014084,
-0.27044281363487244,
0.19007505476474762,
-0.39217105507850647,
-0.2481064647436142,
-0.26763200759887695,
-0.3099743723869324,
0.6242288947105408,
-0.4350489675998688,
-0.32353514432907104,
-0.5865837931632996,
0.24587716162204742,
0.6015328168869019,
-0.2782410681247711,
0.15927179157733917,
0.6320183277130127,
-0.24032296240329742,
-0.21052095293998718,
-0.8496348857879639,
-0.08329468965530396,
-0.46416470408439636,
0.48044657707214355,
-0.06018509343266487,
-1.014864206314087,
0.2655777633190155,
0.1804259568452835,
0.1372206211090088,
0.2983708381652832,
0.47468826174736023,
-0.10093076527118683,
0.8863180875778198,
0.3043360710144043,
-0.23116077482700348,
0.3033696115016937,
-0.027741238474845886,
0.5386276841163635,
-0.7371705770492554,
-0.008399061858654022,
-0.4509297013282776,
-0.1070687398314476,
-0.38762935996055603,
-0.3798278272151947,
0.7118799090385437,
-0.0072350515983998775,
-0.137099951505661,
0.3089837431907654,
-0.3437872529029846,
0.2951911985874176,
0.7725551128387451,
0.17785465717315674,
0.27928584814071655,
0.09685540944337845,
0.18632864952087402,
0.17400847375392914,
-0.6777663230895996,
-0.33165115118026733,
0.880516529083252,
0.14501595497131348,
0.8338788747787476,
0.1586061269044876,
0.7111198902130127,
0.31721246242523193,
0.4197932183742523,
-0.6924211978912354,
0.5353780388832092,
-0.12982523441314697,
-0.6541609764099121,
-0.572756290435791,
-0.309924453496933,
-0.7110645174980164,
0.39899104833602905,
0.03842757269740105,
-0.4083191454410553,
0.1951044201850891,
0.8264053463935852,
-0.6905931830406189,
0.2679649293422699,
-0.635009765625,
0.6183010339736938,
-0.14228317141532898,
-0.10483812540769577,
-0.13102969527244568,
-0.8279880285263062,
0.04601127654314041,
0.035281699150800705,
0.4565353989601135,
0.07855468988418579,
0.2773841619491577,
0.5577948093414307,
-0.33906692266464233,
0.9052101373672485,
-0.2637106478214264,
-0.22526375949382782,
0.5111344456672668,
-0.07714735716581345,
0.7778506278991699,
-0.16095471382141113,
-0.05038939416408539,
0.2889634966850281,
-0.22545935213565826,
-0.01611274853348732,
-0.5337717533111572,
0.444254994392395,
-0.6759402751922607,
-0.7051891088485718,
-0.5114126205444336,
-0.3772856891155243,
-0.2846834063529968,
0.19843216240406036,
0.6287814974784851,
0.5704544186592102,
-0.14056172966957092,
0.24197758734226227,
0.807883083820343,
-0.0886797085404396,
0.22838254272937775,
0.49814432859420776,
0.07166212052106857,
-0.7324557900428772,
0.8274914622306824,
0.02947448194026947,
0.3542758524417877,
0.316078245639801,
0.23742645978927612,
-0.5664557814598083,
-0.6416378617286682,
-0.7521069645881653,
0.22343574464321136,
-0.8409613966941833,
-0.1751643717288971,
-0.7366803288459778,
-0.18168428540229797,
-0.40286117792129517,
-0.24100732803344727,
-0.2961691617965698,
0.00920951459556818,
-0.32734477519989014,
-0.154976949095726,
0.3076440393924713,
0.32785820960998535,
-0.41519469022750854,
0.41972312331199646,
-0.9904541969299316,
0.1777544468641281,
0.4614447057247162,
0.10511297732591629,
-0.13683515787124634,
-0.5437981486320496,
0.12237201631069183,
0.27983400225639343,
-0.15657269954681396,
-0.5703199505805969,
0.3036791980266571,
0.5200616717338562,
0.45153793692588806,
0.2243121713399887,
-0.137882262468338,
0.8136420845985413,
-0.8494635820388794,
0.46103033423423767,
0.41095852851867676,
-1.1174983978271484,
0.3770299255847931,
-0.24379828572273254,
0.24748870730400085,
0.4000486135482788,
-0.20048244297504425,
-0.8888850212097168,
-0.21863894164562225,
-0.5375043153762817,
-0.8595266938209534,
0.5178861618041992,
-0.1417667269706726,
0.15575359761714935,
-0.008786676451563835,
0.12712033092975616,
0.15825580060482025,
0.4087063670158386,
-0.5012751817703247,
-0.0379006527364254,
-0.3293857276439667,
-0.34537139534950256,
-0.3797033429145813,
-0.3414951264858246,
-0.2615867853164673,
-0.10198941826820374,
0.7717438340187073,
-0.1371881365776062,
0.3172302842140198,
0.4974287748336792,
-0.30651694536209106,
-0.353112131357193,
0.6770435571670532,
0.7274032831192017,
0.7553066611289978,
-0.04270637780427933,
0.21522855758666992,
0.44351720809936523,
-0.26316526532173157,
0.25729966163635254,
0.04365678131580353,
-0.3578486740589142,
0.2833910286426544,
0.41068723797798157,
1.0971205234527588,
0.17482063174247742,
-0.8283538222312927,
0.4435354769229889,
0.3425696790218353,
-0.20060425996780396,
-0.8550825119018555,
0.18396222591400146,
-0.002432645997032523,
0.2552928328514099,
0.31966593861579895,
0.5102629661560059,
0.0489465706050396,
-0.5267579555511475,
0.4744890332221985,
0.4533950388431549,
-0.2122759073972702,
-0.16905638575553894,
0.7035485506057739,
0.1387035846710205,
-0.362376868724823,
0.5060118436813354,
0.007082074414938688,
-0.7696556448936462,
0.38366156816482544,
0.5656323432922363,
0.732980489730835,
-0.5943500399589539,
0.11980488151311874,
0.5805268883705139,
0.13374678790569305,
-0.44284316897392273,
0.1445787250995636,
0.17997251451015472,
-0.9271059632301331,
-0.5350714325904846,
-0.569546639919281,
-0.33300498127937317,
0.16280609369277954,
-0.6862313151359558,
0.11584080010652542,
-0.5154392719268799,
-0.0808812603354454,
0.057990897446870804,
-0.7161432504653931,
-0.5337875485420227,
0.14492829144001007,
0.13433313369750977,
0.5360225439071655,
-0.41130316257476807,
0.7059006690979004,
0.3891061544418335,
0.07698094099760056,
-0.5446850657463074,
-0.007315380964428186,
0.27353665232658386,
-1.1220475435256958,
0.5843726396560669,
0.0792178064584732,
-0.3993383049964905,
0.10230547934770584,
-0.6207047700881958,
-1.074425458908081,
0.8320204615592957,
0.33139604330062866,
-0.9852957129478455,
-0.04573380574584007,
-0.04668479412794113,
0.41401490569114685,
-0.09160901606082916,
-0.28621500730514526,
0.5741633772850037,
0.5282679200172424,
0.32418084144592285,
-1.1601067781448364,
-0.11323355883359909,
0.131059467792511,
0.09673794358968735,
0.40376996994018555,
-0.5031378269195557,
0.8493509888648987,
-0.7551472187042236,
-0.3399938941001892,
0.29564011096954346,
0.6724563837051392,
0.2499515563249588,
0.3772788643836975,
0.7914790511131287,
0.5075168609619141,
0.8748040199279785,
-0.03670438006520271,
0.8715299963951111,
0.13670845329761505,
0.35545119643211365,
1.2536673545837402,
-0.3406529128551483,
0.9749547839164734,
0.36557111144065857,
-0.3188508450984955,
0.24965068697929382,
0.28375619649887085,
-0.13474997878074646,
0.5117090940475464,
0.2928825616836548,
-0.35822802782058716,
-0.31623178720474243,
0.21647901833057404,
-0.4139549136161804,
0.4877433776855469,
0.2878517210483551,
-0.09810633212327957,
-0.30680057406425476,
0.19519256055355072,
0.18183188140392303,
0.091762974858284,
-0.3438279628753662,
0.7341063618659973,
-0.05237428471446037,
-0.4859772324562073,
0.8085258603096008,
-0.15376047790050507,
0.7139272689819336,
-0.6439415812492371,
-0.18738985061645508,
0.05003596097230911,
0.4690491557121277,
-0.1696079820394516,
-0.35227951407432556,
0.17387105524539948,
-0.10290507972240448,
-0.23646947741508484,
0.034118641167879105,
0.5995612740516663,
-0.7381646037101746,
-0.5619015097618103,
0.07088188081979752,
0.11666232347488403,
-0.04355953261256218,
-0.051854994148015976,
-0.21164467930793762,
0.3523757755756378,
0.12833192944526672,
0.384576678276062,
0.01000239234417677,
0.11358452588319778,
0.11246991902589798,
0.7332566380500793,
0.7807950973510742,
0.10097227990627289,
0.27844884991645813,
0.011068052612245083,
0.4925187826156616,
-0.5269278883934021,
-0.6090025305747986,
-0.7894821763038635,
0.3444511294364929,
0.009643376804888248,
-0.2168271541595459,
0.5268040299415588,
0.2920970618724823,
1.0311720371246338,
-0.1691053807735443,
1.196332573890686,
-0.0883360505104065,
0.8264761567115784,
-0.6269275546073914,
0.2783015966415405,
-0.37551766633987427,
0.04185843840241432,
-0.18699440360069275,
-0.6044926047325134,
-0.36197882890701294,
0.8567498922348022,
-0.21562670171260834,
0.0042666178196668625,
0.5257446765899658,
0.8444034457206726,
0.19448596239089966,
0.22944588959217072,
0.30836910009384155,
0.5048477649688721,
0.3278624415397644,
0.450761616230011,
0.8294907212257385,
-0.3664487600326538,
0.5975595712661743,
0.1490297019481659,
-0.17412219941616058,
-0.5175721645355225,
-0.5621811747550964,
-0.4207019507884979,
-0.5623111724853516,
-0.27260226011276245,
-0.45211467146873474,
0.24591630697250366,
1.211868166923523,
0.5191413164138794,
-1.076372504234314,
-0.1173463836312294,
-0.0846654549241066,
-0.03135211393237114,
-0.3790980875492096,
-0.13948090374469757,
0.39351481199264526,
-0.27559617161750793,
-0.7031456232070923,
0.5342874526977539,
0.10204372555017471,
0.08747962862253189,
0.1891554594039917,
-0.2893587350845337,
0.36535710096359253,
-0.17070968449115753,
0.6512749791145325,
0.46617424488067627,
-1.0765377283096313,
-0.4950273931026459,
-0.20563378930091858,
0.1709745079278946,
0.30625200271606445,
0.9455798864364624,
-0.36416783928871155,
0.7129920721054077,
0.2714161276817322,
0.7601402401924133,
0.3152119815349579,
-0.10233454406261444,
0.6423775553703308,
-0.4367973506450653,
-0.057949721813201904,
0.36910247802734375,
0.40502047538757324,
0.624947726726532,
-0.310530424118042,
0.23680798709392548,
0.21956440806388855,
-0.5010017156600952,
-0.7421351075172424,
0.27017438411712646,
-0.8982246518135071,
-0.0414416529238224,
1.2605854272842407,
0.11432617157697678,
0.0318061001598835,
-0.2000192254781723,
-0.5846922397613525,
0.2215379923582077,
-0.5818603038787842,
0.8445985913276672,
0.8566889762878418,
-0.13692542910575867,
-0.2919873893260956,
-0.6340031623840332,
0.6014790534973145,
0.3281037211418152,
-0.42440128326416016,
0.2999212443828583,
0.9213888645172119,
0.6177996397018433,
0.34554949402809143,
0.7083353400230408,
-0.12903466820716858,
0.43085142970085144,
-0.1306082010269165,
0.10804611444473267,
-0.1090378612279892,
-0.36898067593574524,
-0.3419951796531677,
0.05398290976881981,
0.24272209405899048,
-0.3192153573036194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10020v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10020v2
|
Natural Language Can Help Bridge the Sim2Real Gap
| 2024-05-16T12:02:02 | 2024-07-02T07:29:04 |
Albert Yu, Adeline Foote, Raymond Mooney, Roberto Martín-Martín
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, I.2.9; I.2.7; I.2.6
|
The main challenge in learning image-conditioned robotic policies is
acquiring a visual representation conducive to low-level control. Due to the
high dimensionality of the image space, learning a good visual representation
requires a considerable amount of visual data. However, when learning in the
real world, data is expensive. Sim2Real is a promising paradigm for overcoming
data scarcity in the real-world target domain by using a simulator to collect
large amounts of cheap data closely related to the target task. However, it is
difficult to transfer an image-conditioned policy from sim to real when the
domains are very visually dissimilar. To bridge the sim2real visual gap, we
propose using natural language descriptions of images as a unifying signal
across domains that captures the underlying task-relevant semantics. Our key
insight is that if two image observations from different domains are labeled
with similar language, the policy should predict similar action distributions
for both images. We demonstrate that training the image encoder to predict the
language description or the distance between descriptions of a sim or real
image serves as a useful, data-efficient pretraining step that helps learn a
domain-invariant image representation. We can then use this image encoder as
the backbone of an IL policy trained simultaneously on a large amount of
simulated and a handful of real demonstrations. Our approach outperforms widely
used prior sim2real methods and strong vision-language pretraining baselines
like CLIP and R3M by 25 to 40%. See additional videos and materials at
https://robin-lab.cs.utexas.edu/lang4sim2real/.
|
[
-0.39913874864578247,
-0.6095693111419678,
0.31425046920776367,
0.07447274029254913,
-0.26569074392318726,
0.1540663093328476,
-0.34087082743644714,
-0.5920673608779907,
-0.08162041753530502,
0.6166549324989319,
-0.6121407151222229,
-0.16691318154335022,
-0.7028608322143555,
-0.15015119314193726,
0.2728767693042755,
0.6162616610527039,
-0.27332526445388794,
0.11026110500097275,
-0.4209427535533905,
-0.16312551498413086,
-0.5256655216217041,
-0.043270666152238846,
-0.5794914960861206,
-0.620668351650238,
0.24244099855422974,
0.2868655025959015,
1.2461345195770264,
0.6120334267616272,
0.7110764980316162,
0.2733114957809448,
0.4683499038219452,
0.4290580749511719,
-0.32701635360717773,
-0.3768989145755768,
-0.36928898096084595,
-0.4873909056186676,
0.05376866087317467,
-0.04946025460958481,
0.48954764008522034,
0.6445428729057312,
0.013896068558096886,
-0.2828822135925293,
0.018879860639572144,
0.7722400426864624,
-0.446987122297287,
0.3829784095287323,
-0.41220539808273315,
0.30498194694519043,
0.0366114117205143,
-0.21936780214309692,
-0.07024907320737839,
-0.14655423164367676,
0.0726219192147255,
-0.960060179233551,
-0.020582055673003197,
0.34295162558555603,
1.4732184410095215,
0.5987377762794495,
-0.4122459590435028,
-0.0938100516796112,
-0.9672812819480896,
0.9664393663406372,
-0.2207828313112259,
0.20543347299098969,
0.6811529397964478,
0.6316027641296387,
-0.303390771150589,
-0.5985907912254333,
-0.7687185406684875,
-0.14138232171535492,
-0.2809353172779083,
0.32852113246917725,
-0.32872888445854187,
0.34120404720306396,
0.33185625076293945,
-0.10819198936223984,
-0.627444863319397,
0.01716608740389347,
-0.6512336134910583,
-0.34720686078071594,
0.7142536044120789,
-0.10251256823539734,
0.5104029178619385,
-0.033950839191675186,
-0.755244255065918,
-0.33212146162986755,
-0.6398133635520935,
0.1653379499912262,
0.37381699681282043,
0.1370898336172104,
-0.42270389199256897,
0.48535165190696716,
-0.10154478996992111,
0.7313573360443115,
-0.47638019919395447,
-0.23283010721206665,
0.13212472200393677,
-0.1674027144908905,
-0.1420910656452179,
-0.20427677035331726,
0.6558252573013306,
0.6159924864768982,
0.7231481671333313,
-0.20897625386714935,
-0.22642534971237183,
0.3133847117424011,
0.4607692062854767,
-0.7683722972869873,
-0.11142001301050186,
-0.08473800867795944,
-0.36467140913009644,
0.2954305112361908,
0.40393874049186707,
-0.7647523880004883,
-0.2505042254924774,
-0.8046106100082397,
0.3903850317001343,
-0.3300040066242218,
-0.24490156769752502,
0.41676440834999084,
-0.1247808113694191,
0.37397393584251404,
0.3764795660972595,
-0.5265190005302429,
0.7054500579833984,
0.6283437013626099,
0.7975749373435974,
0.019006196409463882,
-0.302204430103302,
-0.4230349361896515,
0.3421145975589752,
-0.3859604597091675,
0.7416527271270752,
-0.6453086733818054,
-0.05854121968150139,
0.19945499300956726,
-0.09862961620092392,
-0.1492536962032318,
-0.7064610719680786,
-0.03089313395321369,
-0.4571037292480469,
-0.05843951925635338,
0.1458786129951477,
-0.3595173954963684,
-0.3140052855014801,
0.28423887491226196,
-0.7974104881286621,
0.8211231827735901,
0.14034651219844818,
-0.530447781085968,
0.4945324659347534,
-0.6506941318511963,
-0.5989202260971069,
-0.05756966024637222,
-0.6168764233589172,
-0.35398218035697937,
-0.011039969511330128,
0.2020312398672104,
0.3570282459259033,
-0.43254604935646057,
0.33425968885421753,
-0.163005068898201,
-0.4261942505836487,
0.20910343527793884,
-0.300300657749176,
0.4395100474357605,
0.23608516156673431,
-0.21227921545505524,
-0.24910886585712433,
-0.32425448298454285,
0.04171718657016754,
0.2182416021823883,
-0.016672875732183456,
-0.3158511221408844,
-0.11696241050958633,
-0.02175019308924675,
0.39569616317749023,
0.04573174938559532,
-0.4663098454475403,
0.34533584117889404,
-0.45377612113952637,
-0.02168865315616131,
0.507042407989502,
-0.004868375137448311,
0.6497620940208435,
-0.18445077538490295,
0.7363986372947693,
0.041695598512887955,
0.20550790429115295,
0.020642928779125214,
-0.38276010751724243,
-0.5670817494392395,
-0.31666994094848633,
0.08934707194566727,
0.7420722842216492,
-1.2554285526275635,
0.0711284801363945,
-0.20480220019817352,
-0.04217279702425003,
-0.5629706978797913,
0.3126249313354492,
0.6644421219825745,
0.12601301074028015,
0.46086323261260986,
-0.48069053888320923,
-0.48324230313301086,
-1.0555994510650635,
-0.26945599913597107,
-0.11690729856491089,
0.015306799672544003,
0.456196129322052,
0.5451206564903259,
-0.22530169785022736,
0.973296046257019,
-0.5259280800819397,
-0.7623763084411621,
-0.4152320921421051,
0.3169199824333191,
-0.1431172788143158,
0.4092535078525543,
0.5389763116836548,
-1.1374653577804565,
-0.29631614685058594,
0.07956311106681824,
-0.8813013434410095,
0.26188087463378906,
-0.5779349207878113,
-0.35305339097976685,
0.023242296651005745,
0.7083792686462402,
-0.5681165456771851,
0.7814429402351379,
0.33449655771255493,
-0.08555757999420166,
-0.02159472368657589,
-0.4767398536205292,
-0.07824161648750305,
-0.963350772857666,
-0.3965226411819458,
0.1098250150680542,
-0.1096295416355133,
-0.4541585147380829,
-0.17784202098846436,
-0.1685311198234558,
-0.11052947491407394,
-0.5786113142967224,
0.7277125716209412,
-0.5542933940887451,
-0.3486019968986511,
-0.2604992091655731,
-0.131246879696846,
-0.11198174953460693,
0.610163688659668,
0.4177842140197754,
0.7180889844894409,
0.9422403573989868,
-0.7172051668167114,
0.3106934726238251,
0.3331294655799866,
-0.44206592440605164,
0.5126931071281433,
-0.4603569209575653,
-0.10217412561178207,
-0.3152630031108856,
0.3669021427631378,
-0.6115447878837585,
-0.534058153629303,
0.38401904702186584,
-0.2895565927028656,
0.4097294807434082,
-0.24797135591506958,
-0.5910083055496216,
-0.4129389524459839,
0.0603581964969635,
0.41142135858535767,
0.7555482387542725,
-0.5773814916610718,
0.669994592666626,
0.3933342695236206,
0.25537821650505066,
-0.6414989233016968,
-0.8464422225952148,
0.18172867596149445,
0.01065855473279953,
-0.4101179242134094,
0.30603188276290894,
0.23864886164665222,
-0.14417840540409088,
0.3382505476474762,
-0.09768044948577881,
-0.3235619366168976,
0.08461084216833115,
0.5768728852272034,
0.34192195534706116,
0.0820416659116745,
0.19503308832645416,
-0.011952266097068787,
-0.32058244943618774,
0.0613054558634758,
-0.49416017532348633,
0.2810942530632019,
0.015558544546365738,
-0.4915810525417328,
-0.6642768979072571,
0.17844480276107788,
0.2368585467338562,
-0.17343027889728546,
0.5331166982650757,
0.6625936627388,
-0.6416698098182678,
-0.27741295099258423,
-0.01537548378109932,
-0.16757212579250336,
-0.4803890883922577,
0.2603815793991089,
-0.27173885703086853,
-0.5610149502754211,
-0.0680738240480423,
-0.6176498532295227,
-0.1140160784125328,
-0.031031683087348938,
0.23555272817611694,
-0.22981984913349152,
0.927395761013031,
0.8326461911201477,
0.17983761429786682,
0.3804316818714142,
-0.5038508176803589,
0.4472731351852417,
-0.4800485074520111,
-0.5332123637199402,
-0.07136067003011703,
-0.5316427946090698,
-0.36555537581443787,
-0.8684889078140259,
0.14525100588798523,
0.17280186712741852,
-0.13313981890678406,
0.3261216878890991,
-0.15047043561935425,
0.7506499290466309,
0.5294843912124634,
0.048915207386016846,
-0.1365954428911209,
0.48842376470565796,
-0.06677599251270294,
-0.250177800655365,
-0.667621374130249,
-0.5941817164421082,
0.7664962410926819,
0.11899983882904053,
1.141607642173767,
-0.11322426050901413,
0.7475548386573792,
0.3729337155818939,
0.029148465022444725,
-0.7235393524169922,
0.5809135437011719,
-0.10396750271320343,
-0.22885870933532715,
-0.08967967331409454,
-0.3165627419948578,
-1.0789612531661987,
0.11906730383634567,
-0.30407994985580444,
-0.5262279510498047,
0.13781306147575378,
0.4615112245082855,
-0.28973379731178284,
0.4421032667160034,
-0.4583737552165985,
0.8825276494026184,
-0.5596466660499573,
-0.47277912497520447,
-0.2733807861804962,
-1.0021710395812988,
0.1978570967912674,
0.29017165303230286,
0.28708207607269287,
-0.36399221420288086,
-0.055493276566267014,
0.4308525025844574,
-0.2937527000904083,
1.0402402877807617,
-0.32264643907546997,
0.2507878541946411,
0.4565083682537079,
0.006669172085821629,
0.35210761427879333,
-0.015202437527477741,
0.39250582456588745,
0.20511668920516968,
-0.39034128189086914,
-0.5752893686294556,
-0.7576259970664978,
0.26246628165245056,
-0.9615037441253662,
-0.2878740429878235,
-0.6188679933547974,
-0.5669149160385132,
-0.34526586532592773,
-0.10673438757658005,
0.158690944314003,
0.4580951929092407,
-0.3038998544216156,
-0.010757679119706154,
0.6106202006340027,
-0.49299782514572144,
0.19423584640026093,
0.2328578531742096,
-0.191841721534729,
-0.07712726294994354,
1.166175365447998,
-0.16761206090450287,
0.4466004967689514,
0.5159774422645569,
-0.012025106698274612,
-0.2358696311712265,
-0.18005217611789703,
-0.4253399968147278,
0.15498913824558258,
-0.501853346824646,
-0.5567426085472107,
-0.5794609189033508,
-0.16916252672672272,
-0.08534125238656998,
-0.4645494818687439,
-0.399204283952713,
-0.2667377293109894,
-0.18309323489665985,
-0.019977224990725517,
0.4031144082546234,
0.8095712065696716,
-0.299310564994812,
0.34027498960494995,
-0.4264806807041168,
0.8173835277557373,
0.35807308554649353,
0.393953412771225,
-0.31340262293815613,
-0.3237154185771942,
-0.13551361858844757,
0.32204899191856384,
0.014065911993384361,
-0.3942910432815552,
0.4878197908401489,
0.534525990486145,
0.4462517499923706,
0.3857547342777252,
0.1413903385400772,
1.0170865058898926,
-0.623604416847229,
0.5815014243125916,
0.5040562748908997,
-0.47608309984207153,
0.6681802272796631,
0.13047660887241364,
0.2616327106952667,
0.48789021372795105,
0.5010613799095154,
-0.27409693598747253,
-0.45394670963287354,
-0.5632581114768982,
-0.7663564682006836,
0.8568874001502991,
0.2630690634250641,
0.42660632729530334,
0.13176490366458893,
0.08631467819213867,
0.0648316815495491,
0.08917935937643051,
-0.4620170593261719,
-0.043933235108852386,
-0.294076532125473,
-0.2668539583683014,
0.18878842890262604,
-0.008084366098046303,
-0.3647758364677429,
-0.07224774360656738,
0.4333873987197876,
-0.28533297777175903,
0.5367739200592041,
0.02654896304011345,
-0.3629019856452942,
0.02075294591486454,
0.12581056356430054,
0.3393838703632355,
0.3648136556148529,
-0.02771390788257122,
0.3363288938999176,
-0.19388681650161743,
-0.42039501667022705,
0.07096317410469055,
-0.019038189202547073,
-0.10615870356559753,
-0.04433830827474594,
0.39026331901550293,
1.1054975986480713,
0.12143543362617493,
-0.9672313332557678,
0.7566277384757996,
-0.08515077084302902,
-0.38659074902534485,
-0.43093010783195496,
0.14041991531848907,
-0.1959211379289627,
0.29247769713401794,
0.061574142426252365,
0.47533005475997925,
0.01297788042575121,
-0.5895199179649353,
0.5071797966957092,
0.41000238060951233,
-0.5902695059776306,
-0.31287118792533875,
0.5309932827949524,
0.046779755502939224,
-0.08111106604337692,
0.6405031681060791,
-0.6425407528877258,
-0.5426415801048279,
1.0074210166931152,
0.640796959400177,
0.5584024786949158,
0.14468157291412354,
0.6451525688171387,
0.4814862906932831,
0.5652431845664978,
-0.37782415747642517,
0.4272899329662323,
0.07900088280439377,
-0.8269669413566589,
-0.22198128700256348,
-0.46768027544021606,
-0.28560805320739746,
-0.2580530643463135,
-0.8797643780708313,
0.09805599600076675,
-0.6143185496330261,
0.09954407811164856,
-0.26965561509132385,
-0.27404892444610596,
-1.2043002843856812,
0.2045256346464157,
0.41602563858032227,
0.562277615070343,
-1.0264426469802856,
0.8107365369796753,
0.9016193151473999,
-0.5839427709579468,
-0.7606460452079773,
0.07036750763654709,
0.057934295386075974,
-1.0834431648254395,
0.9755035042762756,
0.40200042724609375,
-0.2639446556568146,
-0.33403268456459045,
-0.8762400150299072,
-0.7211127281188965,
1.0305503606796265,
0.43773043155670166,
-0.3727376163005829,
0.27195820212364197,
0.35370591282844543,
0.4934645891189575,
-0.5679512023925781,
-0.15600670874118805,
0.49372321367263794,
0.5507540702819824,
0.2593111991882324,
-0.6181433796882629,
-0.15248353779315948,
-0.07783951610326767,
0.20674124360084534,
0.28778931498527527,
-0.47921881079673767,
0.3686990439891815,
-0.6466770768165588,
-0.4771635830402374,
0.018563268706202507,
0.8699220418930054,
-0.1119745522737503,
0.4148803651332855,
0.5521016716957092,
0.4614119529724121,
0.6270408630371094,
-0.22390185296535492,
1.388862133026123,
-0.019791409373283386,
0.1434381604194641,
1.1113033294677734,
-0.4591446816921234,
0.6161399483680725,
0.48574838042259216,
-0.05093996599316597,
0.44829338788986206,
0.3587442636489868,
-0.024407437071204185,
0.6965551376342773,
0.23668420314788818,
-0.07222640514373779,
-0.5223764181137085,
-0.6406158804893494,
-0.00993017852306366,
0.46785056591033936,
0.5452609658241272,
0.08642018586397171,
-0.3224414885044098,
0.5163644552230835,
-0.02378823608160019,
0.45613551139831543,
-0.21711358428001404,
0.8355984091758728,
0.1722242385149002,
-0.6089358925819397,
0.34915024042129517,
-0.2848186492919922,
0.4304591417312622,
-0.6951804161071777,
-0.5419560670852661,
-0.08757317066192627,
0.2159692645072937,
-0.10566482692956924,
-0.9641218185424805,
0.29189884662628174,
-0.10811887681484222,
0.19396813213825226,
-0.4550776481628418,
0.7209803462028503,
-0.7240936160087585,
-0.425151526927948,
0.4407517611980438,
0.3446606397628784,
0.2872411608695984,
0.29539579153060913,
-1.0382498502731323,
0.028247930109500885,
-0.004061075858771801,
0.043394021689891815,
0.24826528131961823,
0.42233195900917053,
-0.3284980058670044,
0.7493910789489746,
0.4308634102344513,
0.10867813974618912,
0.00549928518012166,
0.06486470997333527,
0.7393348217010498,
-0.4803013503551483,
-0.33200278878211975,
-0.37330418825149536,
0.29034870862960815,
-0.22147709131240845,
-0.12622442841529846,
0.21124112606048584,
0.37345442175865173,
1.1510469913482666,
-0.10158861428499222,
0.8860727548599243,
-0.23470266163349152,
0.055094506591558456,
-0.8321186304092407,
0.23455074429512024,
-0.7757671475410461,
0.013307694345712662,
0.2668693959712982,
-0.7575898170471191,
-0.4392482340335846,
0.8392395377159119,
-0.1405758112668991,
-0.18142154812812805,
0.6198379993438721,
1.0340193510055542,
-0.33759814500808716,
-0.4922148585319519,
0.427242249250412,
-0.15470312535762787,
0.015129350125789642,
0.617983341217041,
0.9173529148101807,
-0.3169243335723877,
0.5556803345680237,
-0.30603864789009094,
-0.0015626730164512992,
-0.04059746116399765,
-0.653969407081604,
-0.9639413356781006,
-0.3674745261669159,
-0.5154764652252197,
-0.17093199491500854,
0.34349632263183594,
1.1309443712234497,
0.6855016946792603,
-0.5349944233894348,
-0.19859351217746735,
-0.1533348113298416,
0.07156717032194138,
-0.4642776548862457,
-0.14572419226169586,
0.3042994737625122,
-0.3642811179161072,
-0.7454871535301208,
0.07790864259004593,
0.6068112850189209,
0.35092565417289734,
-0.05915162339806557,
-0.5756660103797913,
-0.13556161522865295,
0.12507957220077515,
0.3044920861721039,
0.6483288407325745,
-0.7925863265991211,
-0.18700826168060303,
-0.2589508593082428,
-0.24326400458812714,
0.023760320618748665,
0.9579964280128479,
-0.8324041962623596,
0.6997760534286499,
0.10862959176301956,
0.8704134821891785,
0.3131882846355438,
0.05561409518122673,
0.6518617868423462,
-0.8694863319396973,
0.7147026658058167,
0.2053346484899521,
0.3029230535030365,
0.4269767999649048,
-0.13652917742729187,
0.7674639225006104,
0.06904011964797974,
-0.019144894555211067,
-0.495650976896286,
0.626960813999176,
-1.0370110273361206,
-0.2980692982673645,
1.25379478931427,
-0.16933122277259827,
-0.18974722921848297,
-0.20366546511650085,
-0.38401511311531067,
0.12733136117458344,
-0.2833470106124878,
0.36788102984428406,
0.21455378830432892,
-0.03478280454874039,
-0.0998094454407692,
-0.9392482042312622,
0.676264762878418,
0.3081624209880829,
-0.9074574112892151,
-0.15463995933532715,
0.5254113674163818,
-0.22540850937366486,
-0.0885220319032669,
0.481075644493103,
-0.007744394242763519,
0.3039710223674774,
-0.03247978538274765,
0.3199846148490906,
-0.05369811877608299,
-0.686457633972168,
-0.10094801336526871,
-0.32556626200675964,
-0.034958235919475555,
-0.4131181836128235
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.