id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18400v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18400v3
|
Superposed Decoding: Multiple Generations from a Single Autoregressive Inference Pass
| 2024-05-28T17:40:48 | 2024-06-25T01:49:45 |
Ethan Shen, Alan Fan, Sarah M. Pratt, Jae Sung Park, Matthew Wallingford, Sham M. Kakade, Ari Holtzman, Ranjay Krishna, Ali Farhadi, Aditya Kusupati
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Many applications today provide users with multiple auto-complete drafts as
they type, including GitHub's code completion, Gmail's smart compose, and
Apple's messaging auto-suggestions. Under the hood, language models support
this by running an autoregressive inference pass to provide a draft.
Consequently, providing $k$ drafts to the user requires running an expensive
language model $k$ times. To alleviate the computation cost of running $k$
inference passes, we propose Superposed Decoding, a new decoding algorithm that
generates $k$ drafts at the computation cost of one autoregressive inference
pass. We achieve this by feeding a superposition of the most recent token
embeddings from the $k$ drafts as input to the next decoding step of the
language model. At every inference step we combine the $k$ drafts with the
top-$k$ tokens to get $k^2$ new drafts and cache the $k$ most likely options,
using an n-gram interpolation with minimal compute overhead to filter out
incoherent generations. Our experiments show that $k$ drafts from Superposed
Decoding are at least as coherent and factual as Nucleus Sampling and Greedy
Decoding respectively, while being at least $2.44\times$ faster for $k\ge3$. In
a compute-normalized setting, user evaluations demonstrably favor text
generated by Superposed Decoding over Nucleus Sampling. Code and more examples
open-sourced at https://github.com/RAIVNLab/SuperposedDecoding.
|
[
-0.3068540394306183,
-0.39397841691970825,
0.33430182933807373,
0.4826902151107788,
-0.2758534252643585,
0.3331882059574127,
0.2773614525794983,
-0.5943418145179749,
0.220425084233284,
0.7543084025382996,
-0.6757050156593323,
0.001292853499762714,
-0.5551813840866089,
0.2726329565048218,
-0.4925234615802765,
0.6376433968544006,
0.28944534063339233,
0.01928374357521534,
-0.18405859172344208,
0.12097832560539246,
-0.07399694621562958,
-0.6520674228668213,
-0.284496009349823,
-0.49740830063819885,
0.013296502642333508,
0.5322021842002869,
0.713238537311554,
0.7103983759880066,
0.024410543963313103,
0.2510279417037964,
-0.08126796782016754,
0.11521551758050919,
-0.4136265218257904,
0.2974959909915924,
0.15303298830986023,
-0.42996644973754883,
-0.019832151010632515,
0.14644496142864227,
0.5728046894073486,
0.39799946546554565,
-0.07922527194023132,
-0.019051311537623405,
-0.08686710894107819,
0.7506219148635864,
-0.8975198864936829,
0.08627666532993317,
-0.7083351016044617,
-0.014767576940357685,
0.053690459579229355,
-0.5733543634414673,
-0.7873244285583496,
-0.4400368928909302,
-0.05613086000084877,
-0.5977492928504944,
0.32383477687835693,
-0.22761675715446472,
0.556257426738739,
0.024487722665071487,
-0.2968221604824066,
-0.40407848358154297,
-0.6701893210411072,
0.7097272872924805,
-0.6421180963516235,
0.4417794644832611,
0.3939971625804901,
0.06795603781938553,
-0.2338651418685913,
-0.8266310691833496,
-0.8080031275749207,
-0.20502471923828125,
-0.09912964701652527,
0.2811708152294159,
-0.16063371300697327,
-0.048013027757406235,
0.17236752808094025,
0.4932171106338501,
-0.4133913815021515,
-0.22574251890182495,
-0.06559368968009949,
-0.32467150688171387,
0.43330392241477966,
-0.010249079205095768,
0.2156505137681961,
-0.20835727453231812,
-0.41643980145454407,
-0.34296295046806335,
-0.45257604122161865,
-0.5003260970115662,
0.5119275450706482,
0.03351052105426788,
0.1523897796869278,
0.24368159472942352,
-0.5797744989395142,
0.7099844217300415,
0.313119113445282,
0.2687797248363495,
0.3916197121143341,
-0.6591199040412903,
-0.1900804191827774,
-0.07614519447088242,
0.410261869430542,
0.3586389124393463,
0.1161770224571228,
-0.16243594884872437,
0.0901016816496849,
0.09606580436229706,
0.13083331286907196,
-0.6641579866409302,
-0.44660717248916626,
0.1439613401889801,
-0.5085017681121826,
-0.10305269062519073,
-0.2191270887851715,
-0.7590100765228271,
-0.3330332934856415,
-0.23506207764148712,
0.26584863662719727,
-0.7065004110336304,
-0.16589872539043427,
0.3273095488548279,
-0.3263776898384094,
0.26904913783073425,
0.17438682913780212,
-1.2410928010940552,
0.12872593104839325,
0.514045774936676,
0.5394871234893799,
0.5532404780387878,
-0.5623106360435486,
-0.39843589067459106,
0.08066105842590332,
-0.12306467443704605,
1.25228750705719,
-0.7752876877784729,
-0.5197697877883911,
-0.1651792675256729,
-0.3787211775779724,
-0.19826512038707733,
-0.49150577187538147,
0.43115296959877014,
-0.8593007326126099,
-0.004668699111789465,
-0.22363361716270447,
-0.7921651005744934,
-0.05814090743660927,
-0.17242223024368286,
-0.764837920665741,
1.0367348194122314,
0.14070077240467072,
-0.7268704771995544,
0.6535927057266235,
-0.11404313892126083,
-0.4466829299926758,
0.40390393137931824,
-0.00007732983067398891,
-0.2734625041484833,
0.07584282010793686,
0.5275793075561523,
0.3750980794429779,
-0.09702999144792557,
-0.24155285954475403,
-0.09457537531852722,
-0.2935163974761963,
0.015091457404196262,
-0.4656755328178406,
1.0169767141342163,
0.4037528932094574,
-0.35643434524536133,
-0.1910337209701538,
-0.9538664817810059,
0.24162428081035614,
-0.000750300707295537,
-0.5817030668258667,
-0.2732263207435608,
-0.1187252402305603,
0.10474809259176254,
0.07081194221973419,
0.036328140646219254,
-0.5882622003555298,
0.4598207175731659,
-0.37022995948791504,
0.6623821258544922,
0.44329366087913513,
0.09961193799972534,
0.7111550569534302,
-0.3286381959915161,
0.44270938634872437,
-0.08467186242341995,
0.4031478762626648,
-0.6313078999519348,
-0.2536424994468689,
-0.43170836567878723,
-0.26752614974975586,
0.42499375343322754,
0.42526954412460327,
-0.9091126918792725,
0.28202012181282043,
-0.062252338975667953,
-0.4148242175579071,
-0.5564667582511902,
0.055587515234947205,
0.48376113176345825,
0.07942850142717361,
0.5055066347122192,
0.022635649889707565,
-0.803080141544342,
-0.8776562809944153,
-0.3375161588191986,
-0.28580960631370544,
0.3261204957962036,
0.08061777055263519,
0.3439820408821106,
-0.12019164860248566,
0.5947714447975159,
-0.37625420093536377,
0.1515498161315918,
-0.3347417414188385,
0.4232132136821747,
-0.14267870783805847,
0.6872426271438599,
0.3942156732082367,
-0.8727155923843384,
-0.5097471475601196,
-0.33725178241729736,
-0.3642067611217499,
-0.11396587640047073,
-0.5061374306678772,
-0.41371825337409973,
0.29183098673820496,
0.9436152577400208,
-0.558330774307251,
0.21050848066806793,
0.6968636512756348,
-0.47724801301956177,
0.8066790103912354,
-0.40677616000175476,
0.13244403898715973,
-0.8884854316711426,
-0.21600905060768127,
-0.48890361189842224,
-0.06890822947025299,
-0.5799033641815186,
0.5251815319061279,
0.3666894733905792,
0.40394267439842224,
-0.3970697820186615,
0.253976047039032,
-0.9087972640991211,
0.035095199942588806,
-0.12604182958602905,
-0.3413447439670563,
0.1166694387793541,
0.1833481788635254,
-0.2160041779279709,
0.7767640948295593,
0.40419724583625793,
-0.3393813371658325,
0.1360059231519699,
0.08058279752731323,
-0.3576381206512451,
0.20291653275489807,
-0.3034071922302246,
0.37853536009788513,
-0.3840978443622589,
0.8678275942802429,
-1.002835988998413,
-0.22217479348182678,
0.06517287343740463,
-0.5090637803077698,
0.12967103719711304,
-0.26821884512901306,
-0.6925399899482727,
-0.40474745631217957,
-0.3074754774570465,
0.6078503727912903,
0.26465511322021484,
-0.5568516254425049,
0.8883581161499023,
0.3070845901966095,
0.11337694525718689,
-0.5550499558448792,
-0.8884586095809937,
0.3131147027015686,
0.3237334191799164,
-0.29793643951416016,
0.3126913011074066,
-0.1494576632976532,
0.38494518399238586,
0.19614467024803162,
0.04754094034433365,
0.2595682740211487,
-0.08746559172868729,
0.03821530565619469,
0.2626909613609314,
0.029313530772924423,
-0.27414149045944214,
0.09758782386779785,
-0.49339741468429565,
-0.329897403717041,
-0.7150945663452148,
0.7751845717430115,
0.16151341795921326,
-0.28718966245651245,
-0.49001988768577576,
0.8204882144927979,
0.9290953278541565,
-0.1727030873298645,
0.7244870662689209,
0.3055102825164795,
-0.28964436054229736,
-0.28925251960754395,
-0.862233579158783,
-0.05470013990998268,
-0.4202929139137268,
0.03644637018442154,
-0.6146300435066223,
-0.8079220056533813,
0.6940226554870605,
0.31455904245376587,
0.2638069987297058,
0.4871934950351715,
0.5407341718673706,
0.21561245620250702,
1.2448573112487793,
0.33341383934020996,
-0.13364721834659576,
0.6066946387290955,
-0.4425964057445526,
-0.057448435574769974,
-0.6688427329063416,
-0.335728257894516,
-0.5400113463401794,
-0.1533440500497818,
-0.30813467502593994,
-0.41323602199554443,
-0.013465848751366138,
0.2526856064796448,
0.12912635505199432,
0.45200684666633606,
-0.5370839238166809,
0.8080492615699768,
1.160086989402771,
0.12228205054998398,
0.46479296684265137,
0.15015272796154022,
-0.37037894129753113,
0.3164260983467102,
-1.0256259441375732,
-0.2475801408290863,
1.1208701133728027,
-0.02908688597381115,
0.7108756899833679,
-0.17904654145240784,
0.9230300188064575,
0.24136961996555328,
0.39652255177497864,
-0.48461079597473145,
0.5995179414749146,
-0.4755212962627411,
-0.6683996915817261,
-0.10089915990829468,
-0.546150267124176,
-0.783378005027771,
0.32969173789024353,
-0.2713061273097992,
-0.6386973857879639,
0.45364704728126526,
0.419969767332077,
-0.5813255906105042,
0.18628279864788055,
-0.9890738129615784,
0.4908432364463806,
0.3632145822048187,
-0.09060972929000854,
-0.39927294850349426,
-0.6284751296043396,
0.31780532002449036,
0.23119182884693146,
0.052090901881456375,
0.10274861752986908,
0.3328346312046051,
0.40839946269989014,
-0.31172892451286316,
0.5610426068305969,
-0.19138886034488678,
0.05508648231625557,
0.3897285759449005,
0.1856076866388321,
0.6771208047866821,
-0.056760918349027634,
-0.1444372981786728,
-0.20912890136241913,
0.11393722146749496,
-0.5494518280029297,
-0.5550805926322937,
0.7400385737419128,
-0.6204859614372253,
-0.2600264847278595,
-0.24890965223312378,
-0.41973868012428284,
-0.04791916534304619,
0.2513584792613983,
0.7467770576477051,
0.7191310524940491,
0.16104260087013245,
0.10992934554815292,
0.35136738419532776,
-0.08347425609827042,
0.40739020705223083,
0.37132933735847473,
-0.10689388960599899,
-0.6213861703872681,
0.8698979616165161,
0.37736257910728455,
0.5569479465484619,
0.5210773348808289,
0.03134296461939812,
-0.5210350155830383,
-0.6488386392593384,
-0.7601288557052612,
0.179381862282753,
-0.7096285820007324,
-0.1920197755098343,
-1.0003268718719482,
-0.22895947098731995,
-0.6092087030410767,
-0.3059859871864319,
-0.3429112434387207,
-0.4279545247554779,
-0.19849084317684174,
-0.1322135478258133,
0.02850152738392353,
0.4426393508911133,
-0.3804077208042145,
0.31217485666275024,
-0.9766964912414551,
0.6139850616455078,
0.5410779714584351,
0.2972134053707123,
0.3036889135837555,
-0.2661285102367401,
-0.2789091467857361,
-0.07799431681632996,
-0.07480467110872269,
-0.7920372486114502,
0.05382257327437401,
0.1765134483575821,
0.7452126145362854,
0.17688575387001038,
0.07023413479328156,
0.7461434006690979,
-0.3972524106502533,
0.6428450345993042,
0.12206989526748657,
-1.0487021207809448,
0.13289138674736023,
-0.036171913146972656,
0.716988205909729,
0.9866660833358765,
0.05289657786488533,
-0.44538062810897827,
-0.7136222720146179,
-0.8044112920761108,
-1.0668262243270874,
0.8911445736885071,
0.31129443645477295,
0.32432857155799866,
-0.26535937190055847,
0.2957531809806824,
0.26425665616989136,
-0.24080727994441986,
-0.3948826491832733,
-0.43567711114883423,
-0.32342028617858887,
-0.06514564901590347,
-0.0071539548225700855,
-0.7572546005249023,
0.26332908868789673,
-0.2378329187631607,
0.6967025995254517,
0.020659571513533592,
0.4509274363517761,
0.41644665598869324,
-0.23707742989063263,
0.00009522629989078268,
0.27529311180114746,
0.5435589551925659,
0.29324862360954285,
-0.039283208549022675,
0.5733780264854431,
-0.10876995325088501,
-0.6861648559570312,
0.1953267902135849,
0.26702508330345154,
-0.4684848487377167,
0.0007778940489515662,
0.5234521627426147,
0.6604036092758179,
0.14768759906291962,
-0.36124342679977417,
0.17217981815338135,
-0.13347075879573822,
-0.7042567133903503,
0.11911150068044662,
0.019922446459531784,
0.17064522206783295,
0.35610759258270264,
0.7017166018486023,
0.20020903646945953,
0.28233614563941956,
-0.5935450792312622,
0.4716443419456482,
0.29565873742103577,
0.07826332747936249,
-0.20535175502300262,
0.7727949023246765,
0.06276793032884598,
-0.15241196751594543,
0.704449474811554,
-0.44310471415519714,
-0.7471369504928589,
0.501343846321106,
0.7360389232635498,
0.9961305856704712,
-0.17828698456287384,
0.3881688714027405,
0.27310019731521606,
0.19872818887233734,
-0.42926353216171265,
0.6272609233856201,
-0.32497933506965637,
-0.8039336204528809,
-0.7090476751327515,
-0.7638931274414062,
-0.2673533856868744,
0.08521199971437454,
-0.5043342113494873,
-0.3308992087841034,
-0.34190523624420166,
-0.12874427437782288,
0.2875831425189972,
-0.29162946343421936,
-0.42962339520454407,
0.09847667068243027,
0.32277268171310425,
1.119376540184021,
-0.9061392545700073,
0.6235888600349426,
0.6408289670944214,
-0.05412990599870682,
-0.8021488189697266,
0.2785891592502594,
-0.1175253838300705,
-0.6987773180007935,
0.43313607573509216,
0.08413906395435333,
-0.5085078477859497,
0.5173698663711548,
-0.4030650854110718,
-0.9170860052108765,
0.5390820503234863,
0.5114253163337708,
-0.24431206285953522,
0.06225623935461044,
-0.22595950961112976,
0.30496689677238464,
-0.26806262135505676,
0.46069520711898804,
0.813111424446106,
0.38959887623786926,
0.23400557041168213,
-0.5321930050849915,
0.04845768213272095,
-0.4589628577232361,
-0.005947632249444723,
0.20035570859909058,
-0.7487398386001587,
0.6971316933631897,
-0.12562106549739838,
-0.5885000824928284,
0.02574988640844822,
0.6608496308326721,
0.28930196166038513,
0.12829534709453583,
0.586743950843811,
0.6612520217895508,
0.4170152544975281,
0.33384114503860474,
0.9913830161094666,
-0.583087146282196,
0.35773327946662903,
1.0466015338897705,
0.08729524910449982,
0.7250196933746338,
0.4879723787307739,
-0.2651613652706146,
0.5596264600753784,
0.30562734603881836,
0.28820696473121643,
0.6286603808403015,
-0.009157134220004082,
-0.3161686062812805,
-0.34021249413490295,
0.21957403421401978,
-0.35431262850761414,
0.30078935623168945,
0.2940462827682495,
-0.3140641450881958,
-0.3326197564601898,
0.08697069436311722,
-0.0351870134472847,
-0.05247483402490616,
-0.015368527732789516,
0.6704802513122559,
-0.19429035484790802,
-0.8505114912986755,
0.6806420683860779,
-0.10444281250238419,
0.5390666127204895,
-0.3832252025604248,
-0.028539197519421577,
-0.3940531015396118,
0.06052568554878235,
-0.29392701387405396,
-0.7007136940956116,
0.17691649496555328,
-0.23938089609146118,
-0.3615390360355377,
-0.6657165288925171,
0.5994407534599304,
-0.30941906571388245,
-0.5797297954559326,
0.38770899176597595,
0.2821163833141327,
-0.00004055445242556743,
-0.07222651690244675,
-0.576937735080719,
0.08276910334825516,
0.14828121662139893,
-0.5594984889030457,
0.024277539923787117,
0.32845640182495117,
0.1613914668560028,
0.590990424156189,
0.899626612663269,
0.12717173993587494,
0.5004894137382507,
0.4574531614780426,
0.872577965259552,
-0.5689316987991333,
-0.9473059773445129,
-0.9837232828140259,
0.22164222598075867,
0.01694660075008869,
-0.40674662590026855,
0.7764304876327515,
0.611054003238678,
0.9351694583892822,
-0.08938528597354889,
0.9032134413719177,
-0.0940207988023758,
0.3166225552558899,
-0.7278336882591248,
0.43709471821784973,
-0.3411962389945984,
0.15709331631660461,
-0.24651144444942474,
-0.7722545266151428,
-0.4314013123512268,
0.4316413998603821,
-0.19245487451553345,
-0.020171649754047394,
0.5585725903511047,
0.735819399356842,
0.035708487033843994,
0.32376357913017273,
0.09344244748353958,
0.08425667881965637,
0.05091605708003044,
0.6205431818962097,
1.0561739206314087,
-0.4069652259349823,
0.5943326354026794,
-0.3473980724811554,
-0.36135613918304443,
-0.5383893847465515,
-0.7739204168319702,
-0.27992957830429077,
-0.5380922555923462,
-0.11312892287969589,
-0.3090946078300476,
0.007791484706103802,
0.751020073890686,
0.9123693108558655,
-0.7364665865898132,
0.13788706064224243,
-0.5852726697921753,
-0.03615962713956833,
-0.587622344493866,
-0.25521647930145264,
0.23631729185581207,
-0.32754307985305786,
-0.6721996665000916,
0.41013672947883606,
0.3266764283180237,
0.08303454518318176,
-0.21570712327957153,
0.11189977079629898,
-0.41631588339805603,
0.2990749478340149,
0.604651689529419,
0.30813995003700256,
-0.34338006377220154,
-0.2681020498275757,
0.028797194361686707,
-0.2724910080432892,
-0.008357619866728783,
1.2350842952728271,
-0.9320971369743347,
0.6232964396476746,
0.8371559977531433,
0.615845799446106,
0.7429225444793701,
0.19075319170951843,
0.40974128246307373,
-0.3126094341278076,
-0.06781500577926636,
0.15030616521835327,
0.07851182669401169,
0.10598543286323547,
-0.6024971604347229,
0.05916489288210869,
0.4125330150127411,
-0.5667951107025146,
-0.645313560962677,
0.4030095636844635,
-0.574256181716919,
-0.6333558559417725,
0.9780279397964478,
0.15700583159923553,
-0.03410261124372482,
-0.45982804894447327,
-0.2210707813501358,
0.2571941018104553,
-0.4437595307826996,
0.7504398822784424,
0.7577012181282043,
-0.3764060139656067,
-0.1817420870065689,
-0.5030521750450134,
0.434757798910141,
0.6911749839782715,
-0.3792724609375,
0.4517081677913666,
0.5501015186309814,
-0.08294355869293213,
0.09901107102632523,
1.04860258102417,
-0.16018825769424438,
0.3034476339817047,
0.6219300031661987,
-0.0922943502664566,
-0.11336413025856018,
-0.4170844554901123,
-0.3305860459804535,
0.4259757101535797,
-0.3211541473865509,
-0.2921912670135498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00049v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00049v1
|
QUEST: Quality-Aware Metropolis-Hastings Sampling for Machine Translation
| 2024-05-28T17:36:06 | 2024-05-28T17:36:06 |
Gonçalo R. A. Faria, Sweta Agrawal, António Farinhas, Ricardo Rei, José G. C. de Souza, André F. T. Martins
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
An important challenge in machine translation (MT) is to generate
high-quality and diverse translations. Prior work has shown that the estimated
likelihood from the MT model correlates poorly with translation quality. In
contrast, quality evaluation metrics (such as COMET or BLEURT) exhibit high
correlations with human judgments, which has motivated their use as rerankers
(such as quality-aware and minimum Bayes risk decoding). However, relying on a
single translation with high estimated quality increases the chances of "gaming
the metric''. In this paper, we address the problem of sampling a set of
high-quality and diverse translations. We provide a simple and effective way to
avoid over-reliance on noisy quality estimates by using them as the energy
function of a Gibbs distribution. Instead of looking for a mode in the
distribution, we generate multiple samples from high-density areas through the
Metropolis-Hastings algorithm, a simple Markov chain Monte Carlo approach. The
results show that our proposed method leads to high-quality and diverse outputs
across multiple language pairs (English$\leftrightarrow${German, Russian}) with
two strong decoder-only LLMs (Alma-7b, Tower-7b).
|
[
-0.22228078544139862,
0.04891514405608177,
0.6126969456672668,
0.2426692396402359,
-0.39974623918533325,
0.1918153613805771,
-0.07387425750494003,
-0.025488000363111496,
0.4469022750854492,
0.5479947328567505,
-0.4835313856601715,
-0.7326453924179077,
-0.7398526072502136,
-0.055253271013498306,
-0.3248772919178009,
0.8814362287521362,
-0.18599684536457062,
0.24393774569034576,
0.1215163916349411,
0.007081255316734314,
-0.004977728705853224,
-0.43219566345214844,
-0.37762871384620667,
0.03802003338932991,
0.7193169593811035,
0.247538760304451,
0.8306683301925659,
0.5073716044425964,
0.6700310111045837,
0.16270111501216888,
0.07626408338546753,
0.5230333805084229,
-0.6364777088165283,
0.43222710490226746,
-0.2803017795085907,
-0.5060913562774658,
-0.2955263555049896,
-0.034849829971790314,
0.8764600157737732,
0.6288688778877258,
-0.1709360033273697,
0.21091197431087494,
0.14232660830020905,
0.6965306401252747,
-0.8580078482627869,
-0.1757431924343109,
-0.7911790013313293,
0.15457496047019958,
-0.3582056164741516,
-0.2915317714214325,
-0.3868325650691986,
-0.29412877559661865,
-0.441294401884079,
-0.5278138518333435,
0.47207170724868774,
0.10251998156309128,
0.8901042342185974,
0.2790387272834778,
-0.46573856472969055,
0.11835676431655884,
-0.585688591003418,
1.0111289024353027,
-0.5961769819259644,
0.27193811535835266,
0.5442716479301453,
0.615003228187561,
-0.4292975664138794,
-0.3781620264053345,
-0.5735454559326172,
0.17593878507614136,
0.3006381392478943,
0.5333964824676514,
-0.05049128830432892,
-0.1321161985397339,
-0.022611698135733604,
0.3710855543613434,
-0.41288942098617554,
0.06975194066762924,
-0.3761615455150604,
-0.23911267518997192,
0.642324686050415,
0.3171575367450714,
0.2220211923122406,
-0.24389764666557312,
-0.08892154693603516,
-0.4641951024532318,
-0.4364728629589081,
0.1450144648551941,
0.4577314257621765,
0.34823718667030334,
0.031495168805122375,
0.6046460270881653,
-0.19733202457427979,
0.453319251537323,
-0.2971923053264618,
-0.06228667497634888,
0.46213382482528687,
-0.2306738793849945,
-0.08469690382480621,
-0.3363496661186218,
1.1120554208755493,
0.2725856602191925,
-0.17401079833507538,
-0.24193568527698517,
-0.4202006161212921,
-0.28510603308677673,
0.44733867049217224,
-0.669562041759491,
-0.3754808008670807,
0.4236186146736145,
-0.3923613131046295,
0.05990858003497124,
0.16053034365177155,
-0.8137076497077942,
-0.03871970996260643,
0.04888041689991951,
0.38820672035217285,
-0.2787742614746094,
-0.05772717297077179,
0.014507943764328957,
-0.2229090929031372,
-0.33338314294815063,
0.13324587047100067,
-0.763647735118866,
0.07955669611692429,
0.10125159472227097,
0.7644819021224976,
-0.524709165096283,
-0.24383440613746643,
-0.7932058572769165,
0.2827322781085968,
-0.6060189604759216,
0.6336237788200378,
-0.2630457580089569,
-0.5046781897544861,
0.015441467054188251,
-0.11077184230089188,
0.06647750735282898,
-0.6522329449653625,
0.6422065496444702,
-0.5143846869468689,
-0.2305057793855667,
-0.6226069331169128,
-0.10318520665168762,
-0.1821761429309845,
0.1850312501192093,
-0.6668813824653625,
1.061059594154358,
0.3200218379497528,
-0.6530064344406128,
0.4233992099761963,
-0.232540100812912,
-0.5450317859649658,
-0.08538828045129776,
-0.10001730173826218,
-0.4711105525493622,
0.4862695038318634,
0.5753056406974792,
0.4616418182849884,
-0.21938399970531464,
0.10600754618644714,
-0.06531783938407898,
-0.17363685369491577,
0.44087469577789307,
-0.561934769153595,
0.46853935718536377,
0.832804262638092,
0.08349335938692093,
0.009018407203257084,
-0.6860478520393372,
0.1764884889125824,
-0.15531574189662933,
-0.509269654750824,
0.014979277737438679,
0.2359987497329712,
0.012856986373662949,
0.3063770830631256,
0.06914932280778885,
-0.5132771730422974,
0.10725552588701248,
-0.24325136840343475,
0.018440410494804382,
0.3012256622314453,
0.2387334704399109,
0.1989898532629013,
-0.5828277468681335,
0.6570435762405396,
0.36742568016052246,
-0.03783320635557175,
0.045900143682956696,
-0.4961772561073303,
-0.40590089559555054,
-0.6527922749519348,
0.3084969222545624,
0.6012537479400635,
-1.1537429094314575,
0.2833499610424042,
-0.42777279019355774,
-0.5922407507896423,
-1.1070045232772827,
0.22131754457950592,
0.22507710754871368,
-0.11069762706756592,
0.6145957708358765,
-0.45515838265419006,
-0.09607121348381042,
-0.862078070640564,
-0.43795397877693176,
0.1448674499988556,
-0.30992788076400757,
-0.07491215318441391,
0.24323032796382904,
-0.21543914079666138,
0.8022894859313965,
-0.4412285089492798,
0.019386615604162216,
-0.3149154484272003,
0.1558852195739746,
0.5465392470359802,
0.6969708204269409,
0.4760984778404236,
-0.5776883363723755,
-0.3241744339466095,
-0.22593194246292114,
-0.3851316571235657,
-0.06337159126996994,
-0.1308917999267578,
-0.6946300268173218,
-0.19841322302818298,
-0.014973577111959457,
-0.26572513580322266,
0.12935949862003326,
0.8257654905319214,
0.3099181652069092,
0.42326077818870544,
-0.5049206614494324,
0.7285195589065552,
-1.5373753309249878,
0.07912497222423553,
-0.007325654849410057,
-0.2540317475795746,
-0.528942346572876,
0.36366793513298035,
0.0307856947183609,
-0.0595388188958168,
-0.5203998684883118,
0.13057567179203033,
-0.35848167538642883,
-0.20661190152168274,
-0.2877286374568939,
0.21203090250492096,
0.05694272369146347,
0.3807207942008972,
-0.09114975482225418,
0.6742995381355286,
0.23269812762737274,
-0.7845199704170227,
0.16723878681659698,
0.13383324444293976,
-0.6691167950630188,
0.4644644260406494,
-0.36380499601364136,
-0.13651496171951294,
-0.2585584819316864,
0.22722095251083374,
-1.2284983396530151,
-0.1589895784854889,
0.22521653771400452,
-0.6766957640647888,
0.4009011387825012,
-0.12696383893489838,
-0.8760738968849182,
-0.292237788438797,
0.1165027916431427,
0.48909544944763184,
0.6111564636230469,
-0.45664384961128235,
0.05729256570339203,
0.5118004083633423,
-0.09840850532054901,
-0.4338541626930237,
-0.9150340557098389,
0.037563275545835495,
0.09947294741868973,
-0.43209514021873474,
0.08834020048379898,
-0.13476990163326263,
0.08667031675577164,
-0.18591710925102234,
-0.2500722110271454,
-0.2932852804660797,
0.07518720626831055,
0.10909675806760788,
-0.05179440975189209,
0.33650273084640503,
-0.08189669251441956,
0.6473239064216614,
-0.1702292412519455,
-0.15671904385089874,
-0.6484524607658386,
0.34107300639152527,
0.6258861422538757,
-0.5687875747680664,
-0.44378548860549927,
0.6662117838859558,
0.6388890743255615,
-0.2584744691848755,
0.7401099801063538,
0.8820407390594482,
-0.36118200421333313,
-0.0722813829779625,
-0.3935498297214508,
-0.10409795492887497,
-0.4148431122303009,
0.4652871787548065,
-0.7261120080947876,
-0.7170444130897522,
0.6610632538795471,
0.08410099148750305,
0.3428409695625305,
0.8175221085548401,
0.7140341401100159,
-0.4992679953575134,
1.305131196975708,
0.2702970504760742,
-0.18544335663318634,
0.245525062084198,
-0.3339560627937317,
0.27417299151420593,
-0.9033238887786865,
-0.1301754117012024,
-0.7909737825393677,
-0.5884602069854736,
-0.8513674736022949,
-0.7144516110420227,
0.7467337846755981,
0.04129575565457344,
0.010241184383630753,
0.43088269233703613,
-0.3000815212726593,
0.08754242956638336,
0.893352210521698,
0.21136292815208435,
0.16535751521587372,
0.4345361590385437,
-0.47086524963378906,
-0.3856004774570465,
-0.9010889530181885,
-0.3511437475681305,
0.8766976594924927,
0.027523471042513847,
0.5914019346237183,
0.33938679099082947,
0.9362648725509644,
0.1351926326751709,
0.16488678753376007,
-0.43381819128990173,
0.32384762167930603,
-0.2381579726934433,
-0.7006256580352783,
-0.09317918121814728,
-1.1078472137451172,
-1.1480975151062012,
0.492308646440506,
-0.3801618814468384,
-0.6189894676208496,
0.17236661911010742,
0.19200006127357483,
-0.3830355405807495,
0.47902897000312805,
-0.0992630124092102,
0.7174073457717896,
0.07256795465946198,
-0.3136586844921112,
-0.45462143421173096,
-0.5318342447280884,
0.2796812653541565,
-0.13342908024787903,
0.6534643173217773,
-0.3675907552242279,
0.14853541553020477,
0.5481810569763184,
-0.2933812141418457,
0.31766343116760254,
0.053084660321474075,
-0.20502109825611115,
0.44294583797454834,
0.5389931201934814,
0.4811294674873352,
0.045817967504262924,
-0.24912722408771515,
0.20605877041816711,
0.3091169595718384,
-0.8282577395439148,
-0.4550798833370209,
0.5468322038650513,
-0.9486000537872314,
-0.2895681858062744,
-0.2432854175567627,
-0.8155528903007507,
-0.17097385227680206,
-0.013926389627158642,
0.8282279968261719,
0.2653987407684326,
0.05913295969367027,
-0.314096599817276,
0.41064393520355225,
-0.3502821922302246,
0.08544525504112244,
0.32121655344963074,
-0.13132762908935547,
-0.7941122055053711,
1.3158234357833862,
0.14476768672466278,
0.6224865913391113,
0.6588583588600159,
-0.12117984145879745,
-0.07157577574253082,
-0.7003604173660278,
-0.5837997198104858,
0.009178785607218742,
-0.5315139889717102,
-0.17843306064605713,
-0.609913170337677,
0.04078250005841255,
-0.42231693863868713,
-0.1431945115327835,
-0.4486325681209564,
-0.3999890983104706,
-0.05225961655378342,
0.22822944819927216,
-0.1317816525697708,
0.30581727623939514,
-0.3048435151576996,
0.4879447817802429,
-1.3257033824920654,
0.5213580131530762,
0.010289543308317661,
0.049116041511297226,
-0.37546899914741516,
-0.7155660390853882,
-0.6110590696334839,
0.4974882900714874,
-0.4048626720905304,
-1.0496997833251953,
0.919140636920929,
-0.1786036342382431,
0.8127972483634949,
0.30855295062065125,
0.22731661796569824,
0.45956456661224365,
-0.5657086372375488,
0.9957619905471802,
0.3445040285587311,
-0.6437034606933594,
0.40505632758140564,
-0.27575889229774475,
0.4241369962692261,
0.898741602897644,
0.5378262996673584,
-0.6820828318595886,
-0.7491740584373474,
-0.4854024052619934,
-0.778910756111145,
0.29196929931640625,
0.35685744881629944,
0.04281849041581154,
-0.41431745886802673,
0.2728179097175598,
0.06120748817920685,
0.4416496157646179,
-0.24499200284481049,
-0.14322346448898315,
-0.10445050895214081,
-0.4096340835094452,
-0.37413859367370605,
-0.136378675699234,
0.07614153623580933,
-0.1128997951745987,
0.8838121294975281,
0.09108486771583557,
0.21651984751224518,
0.11539598554372787,
-0.173733189702034,
-0.19042931497097015,
0.2836596667766571,
0.34748780727386475,
0.30616334080696106,
-0.2530326545238495,
0.2992771565914154,
0.09962083399295807,
-0.5718415975570679,
0.16360168159008026,
-0.21632106602191925,
-0.16022780537605286,
0.3228699266910553,
-0.2026364803314209,
0.3469880521297455,
0.032245222479104996,
-0.47240668535232544,
0.14985957741737366,
0.2042529135942459,
-0.02072482742369175,
0.16375358402729034,
0.0322171188890934,
-0.14930331707000732,
0.10587354749441147,
0.27171725034713745,
0.2892811894416809,
0.3486442267894745,
-0.509523332118988,
0.06565795093774796,
0.3212076425552368,
-0.4050377607345581,
-0.10105258971452713,
0.5956565141677856,
0.12903177738189697,
0.05014491826295853,
0.892261266708374,
-0.8195122480392456,
-0.5297403335571289,
0.29741913080215454,
0.3278154134750366,
0.744651198387146,
-0.20200486481189728,
-0.02890719287097454,
0.7108408808708191,
0.5963181853294373,
-0.43247199058532715,
0.5226556658744812,
0.01116564404219389,
-0.77865070104599,
-0.6231659650802612,
-0.6819465756416321,
-0.5728825926780701,
-0.48692426085472107,
-0.764653205871582,
-0.10604578256607056,
0.07372836023569107,
-0.46782582998275757,
-0.6656489968299866,
0.019937006756663322,
-0.5410664677619934,
0.10988589376211166,
-0.10655278712511063,
0.6819391846656799,
-0.6316077709197998,
0.8606553673744202,
0.30006739497184753,
-0.2815079689025879,
-0.4063563644886017,
0.018118469044566154,
-0.042417194694280624,
-0.6422710418701172,
0.40985190868377686,
-0.30135732889175415,
-0.15953177213668823,
0.19999590516090393,
-0.5905375480651855,
-0.9878952503204346,
0.8101020455360413,
0.3174562156200409,
-0.7374659180641174,
0.37699994444847107,
0.11063903570175171,
0.1185721904039383,
0.050919633358716965,
0.13338981568813324,
0.5296053290367126,
0.3364764153957367,
0.22152605652809143,
-0.6622388958930969,
-0.22257931530475616,
-0.25589635968208313,
0.1644655466079712,
0.3876900374889374,
-0.34350156784057617,
0.49436891078948975,
-0.4167616069316864,
-0.42550748586654663,
0.22181665897369385,
0.892223596572876,
0.4244171977043152,
0.029633451253175735,
0.12756943702697754,
0.5615130662918091,
0.9269167184829712,
-0.14616930484771729,
1.1161400079727173,
-0.5391567945480347,
0.34355050325393677,
0.9834023714065552,
0.22185038030147552,
1.0863029956817627,
0.41448870301246643,
-0.28872546553611755,
0.25458842515945435,
0.7790548205375671,
0.045989930629730225,
0.5541667938232422,
0.8288878202438354,
-0.2905881702899933,
-0.46692705154418945,
0.057975273579359055,
-0.23661887645721436,
-0.10726447403430939,
0.5306396484375,
-0.22226597368717194,
-0.19865277409553528,
-0.12205404043197632,
-0.13740135729312897,
0.18337057530879974,
-0.24931909143924713,
0.32292330265045166,
0.21907268464565277,
-0.7649810910224915,
0.46276405453681946,
0.3173639476299286,
0.5697113275527954,
-0.4468415379524231,
0.2152971774339676,
-0.23283137381076813,
-0.12773701548576355,
-0.15576648712158203,
-0.785125732421875,
0.15283538401126862,
-0.024309922009706497,
-0.35602614283561707,
-0.1929740309715271,
-0.12050846964120865,
-0.6987053751945496,
-0.576672375202179,
-0.31337374448776245,
0.5187488198280334,
0.9126278758049011,
-0.2557838261127472,
-0.265756219625473,
0.09309130907058716,
-0.19968143105506897,
0.031672194600105286,
0.35552263259887695,
0.5049247145652771,
0.3994518518447876,
0.43282338976860046,
0.7324016094207764,
0.26241883635520935,
0.17487812042236328,
0.09633191674947739,
0.2987666726112366,
-0.3551828861236572,
-0.4807218611240387,
-0.5747084021568298,
0.5842941403388977,
0.10223710536956787,
-0.32263824343681335,
0.6928253173828125,
0.6168555617332458,
0.6822052001953125,
0.058492228388786316,
0.859637439250946,
0.404267817735672,
0.33526748418807983,
-0.5415221452713013,
0.8330066204071045,
-0.5195398926734924,
0.04439781606197357,
-0.237675741314888,
-1.0721515417099,
-0.22308756411075592,
0.6666127443313599,
0.004418551921844482,
-0.08635266870260239,
0.7131879925727844,
0.5145535469055176,
0.007707655895501375,
-0.38287830352783203,
0.6738736033439636,
0.05126826465129852,
0.5023472309112549,
0.8789829611778259,
0.4335530698299408,
-0.5580035448074341,
0.5677891969680786,
0.12040755897760391,
-0.10147172957658768,
-0.2149917483329773,
-0.695605993270874,
-0.42283472418785095,
-0.7092819213867188,
-0.2655486762523651,
-0.6597714424133301,
-0.05518965423107147,
1.0699931383132935,
0.6452327966690063,
-0.7584266066551208,
-0.2934775650501251,
0.2778463065624237,
0.04636821895837784,
-0.6460301280021667,
-0.08414474874734879,
0.22722060978412628,
-0.6910486221313477,
-0.9647727012634277,
0.45105087757110596,
0.19824235141277313,
0.0357714481651783,
-0.17682746052742004,
-0.017950255423784256,
0.17858067154884338,
0.16098050773143768,
0.4033738076686859,
0.03462395444512367,
-0.3150116503238678,
-0.02155085653066635,
-0.11142256110906601,
-0.5496956706047058,
0.11325420439243317,
0.6483414769172668,
-0.523958146572113,
0.6981765031814575,
0.6931635737419128,
0.8525481224060059,
0.8292390704154968,
-0.23313334584236145,
0.6822909712791443,
-0.6551600098609924,
-0.23067578673362732,
0.2122247815132141,
0.45917993783950806,
0.19179099798202515,
-0.04393438622355461,
0.2092864215373993,
0.3148811161518097,
-0.5477365851402283,
-0.4836929440498352,
0.42823144793510437,
-1.161988377571106,
-0.07210294157266617,
1.2119169235229492,
-0.2000301033258438,
-0.16919951140880585,
0.05419885739684105,
-0.07539796829223633,
0.44994881749153137,
-0.4181780219078064,
0.863475501537323,
0.5993859767913818,
0.26039212942123413,
0.12804733216762543,
-1.0259369611740112,
0.15184682607650757,
0.4233854115009308,
-0.6381933689117432,
-0.286113977432251,
0.4010387361049652,
0.23793217539787292,
0.13730201125144958,
0.38891667127609253,
-0.1119905561208725,
0.22757887840270996,
-0.025672560557723045,
0.3879188299179077,
0.21258166432380676,
-0.2867814600467682,
-0.09075857698917389,
0.16892054677009583,
0.07220350950956345,
-0.4749792814254761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18380v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18380v1
|
OwLore: Outlier-weighed Layerwise Sampled Low-Rank Projection for Memory-Efficient LLM Fine-tuning
| 2024-05-28T17:22:22 | 2024-05-28T17:22:22 |
Pengxiang Li, Lu Yin, Xiaowei Gao, Shiwei Liu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The rapid advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized
various natural language processing tasks. However, the substantial size of
LLMs presents significant challenges in training or fine-tuning. While
parameter-efficient approaches such as low-rank adaptation (LoRA) have gained
popularity, they often compromise performance compared to full-rank
fine-tuning. In this paper, we propose Outlier-weighed Layerwise Sampled
Low-Rank Projection (OwLore), a new memory-efficient fine-tuning approach,
inspired by the layerwise outlier distribution of LLMs, which dynamically
samples pre-trained layers to fine-tune instead of adding additional adaptors.
We first interpret the outlier phenomenon through the lens of Heavy-Tailed
Self-Regularization theory (HT-SR), discovering that layers with more outliers
tend to be more heavy-tailed and consequently better trained. Inspired by this
finding, OwLore strategically assigns higher sampling probabilities to layers
with more outliers to better leverage the knowledge stored in pre-trained LLMs.
To further mitigate the memory demands of fine-tuning, we integrate gradient
low-rank projection into our approach, which facilitates each layer to be
efficiently trained in a low-rank manner. By incorporating the efficient
characteristics of low-rank and optimal layerwise sampling, OwLore
significantly improves the memory-performance trade-off in LLM pruning. Our
extensive experiments across various architectures, including LLaMa2, LLaMa3,
and Mistral, demonstrate that OwLore consistently outperforms baseline
approaches, including full fine-tuning. Specifically, it achieves up to a 1.1%
average accuracy gain on the Commonsense Reasoning benchmark, a 3.0%
improvement on MMLU, and a notable 10% boost on MT-Bench, while being more
memory efficient. OwLore allows us to fine-tune LLaMa2-7B with only 21GB of
memory.
|
[
-0.1463918685913086,
-0.6740319132804871,
0.4514734148979187,
-0.02754124067723751,
-0.22607870399951935,
-0.027609732002019882,
-0.2933341860771179,
-0.4425237774848938,
0.16297434270381927,
0.6584087610244751,
-0.23746679723262787,
-0.632703423500061,
-0.5912715196609497,
-0.35501930117607117,
-0.3763371407985687,
0.8964160680770874,
0.3333559036254883,
-0.28009381890296936,
-0.19347138702869415,
0.020097533240914345,
-0.3217211663722992,
-0.1400715708732605,
-0.7501440048217773,
-0.17582786083221436,
0.5464090704917908,
0.8548049330711365,
0.4208289086818695,
0.821757435798645,
0.5185554027557373,
0.24926500022411346,
-0.033439770340919495,
0.572072446346283,
-0.7149220108985901,
-0.1576022505760193,
0.01509828120470047,
-0.3608158528804779,
-0.7040719389915466,
-0.05012164264917374,
0.5453606247901917,
0.5042694211006165,
-0.2501959204673767,
0.26463162899017334,
0.3273886442184448,
0.7334585785865784,
-0.8456628918647766,
-0.16791772842407227,
-1.0383102893829346,
-0.036215756088495255,
-0.2790336608886719,
-0.5578852891921997,
-0.34605878591537476,
-0.119968481361866,
-0.2979757487773895,
-0.751304566860199,
0.04080919921398163,
0.45725393295288086,
0.7290067672729492,
0.5445009469985962,
0.006474316120147705,
-0.10159613192081451,
-0.4803897440433502,
1.2251813411712646,
-0.7563048005104065,
0.09958105534315109,
0.5024524331092834,
0.168182373046875,
-0.32713815569877625,
-0.16408154368400574,
-0.09071608632802963,
-0.1282331347465515,
0.2461915910243988,
0.2730576694011688,
-0.08880942314863205,
-0.06509914249181747,
0.011982726864516735,
0.34675735235214233,
-0.4211127758026123,
0.48424726724624634,
-0.23106060922145844,
-0.21499237418174744,
0.47435832023620605,
-0.18223823606967926,
-0.061232056468725204,
-0.21145303547382355,
-0.4881119430065155,
-0.22965142130851746,
-0.5170937180519104,
-0.22082845866680145,
0.6349369883537292,
0.40956252813339233,
0.2718625068664551,
0.28641167283058167,
-0.13847792148590088,
0.7790504097938538,
0.17923003435134888,
-0.3784181773662567,
0.03295322135090828,
-0.01620650477707386,
-0.2802683711051941,
0.3282112777233124,
0.5571160912513733,
0.467098206281662,
0.33823537826538086,
-0.03969657048583031,
-0.1490088552236557,
-0.049469370394945145,
0.009533698670566082,
-0.917732298374176,
-0.39947444200515747,
0.30435213446617126,
-0.4771212637424469,
-0.2657593786716461,
-0.24773141741752625,
-0.8563988208770752,
-0.35175788402557373,
-0.043573662638664246,
0.42190322279930115,
-0.6404436230659485,
-0.05662249028682709,
0.17525127530097961,
0.0055178143084049225,
-0.15875796973705292,
0.5651242733001709,
-0.7974154353141785,
0.21470242738723755,
0.6329275369644165,
0.5644086003303528,
-0.3653724789619446,
-0.26109975576400757,
-1.0257301330566406,
0.46964409947395325,
-0.33249783515930176,
0.9970133900642395,
-0.6255979537963867,
-0.08483915776014328,
-0.18894271552562714,
-0.5204557180404663,
-0.12332850694656372,
-1.0088938474655151,
0.6785788536071777,
-0.17741483449935913,
-0.0707327350974083,
0.039085276424884796,
-0.4057891070842743,
0.0942341685295105,
0.4461280405521393,
-0.18374750018119812,
1.29267418384552,
-0.0012109348317608237,
-0.7247918844223022,
0.4140775799751282,
-0.31140241026878357,
-0.22494235634803772,
-0.19632188975811005,
0.07652798295021057,
-0.3400307893753052,
0.22997629642486572,
0.4316039979457855,
0.49473005533218384,
-0.41413646936416626,
-0.2346750646829605,
-0.23002766072750092,
-0.579761266708374,
-0.18835914134979248,
-0.14208777248859406,
0.379590779542923,
0.37516215443611145,
0.16834084689617157,
-0.0049718404188752174,
-1.0501582622528076,
0.1929972767829895,
-0.07537094503641129,
-0.29087913036346436,
-0.8025540113449097,
0.08835200220346451,
-0.1846141219139099,
-0.09666343033313751,
0.35016825795173645,
-0.512557864189148,
0.23116470873355865,
-0.40920329093933105,
0.4542521834373474,
0.7532687187194824,
-0.06880918890237808,
0.5198347568511963,
-0.29564622044563293,
0.0665365606546402,
0.39799317717552185,
0.29909250140190125,
0.0508253388106823,
-0.23258937895298004,
-0.7568053007125854,
-0.48732805252075195,
0.0050404868088662624,
0.5848619937896729,
-0.48177847266197205,
0.5017960071563721,
-0.21455936133861542,
-0.41797998547554016,
-0.49479973316192627,
0.754449725151062,
0.3107731342315674,
0.7814832329750061,
0.6582767367362976,
0.17986205220222473,
-0.41561803221702576,
-0.8359752893447876,
-0.3303818106651306,
-0.1536523401737213,
-0.009397097863256931,
0.17419548332691193,
0.295795738697052,
-0.23171839118003845,
0.7846843004226685,
-0.48813435435295105,
-0.9054498672485352,
-0.20115262269973755,
0.28524667024612427,
0.3889905512332916,
0.6029648780822754,
0.47408145666122437,
-0.3672391176223755,
-0.4200587570667267,
0.0017798106418922544,
-0.3421875834465027,
-0.16200107336044312,
0.0623362734913826,
-0.2669410705566406,
0.039292775094509125,
0.49036574363708496,
-0.3399312198162079,
0.058689311146736145,
0.7678842544555664,
0.16665060818195343,
0.11593634635210037,
-0.43965643644332886,
-0.22964338958263397,
-1.2046667337417603,
-0.258136123418808,
-0.23569722473621368,
-0.022659046575427055,
-0.21145012974739075,
-0.24010734260082245,
0.06199163571000099,
0.2042362540960312,
-0.3053535521030426,
0.44691330194473267,
-0.6086791157722473,
-0.08274951577186584,
-0.32926592230796814,
0.25472143292427063,
-0.049612995237112045,
0.5098278522491455,
-0.22009125351905823,
0.7766321301460266,
0.46340158581733704,
-0.5811214447021484,
-0.062408074736595154,
0.00936911255121231,
-0.40920621156692505,
0.6861556172370911,
-0.27309897541999817,
0.2076837420463562,
-0.13445714116096497,
-0.03532914072275162,
-0.7369433641433716,
0.03355731442570686,
0.08986535668373108,
-0.2533847987651825,
0.1980651617050171,
-0.25157761573791504,
-0.48490405082702637,
-0.04173481464385986,
-0.578191339969635,
0.3558295965194702,
0.5777812600135803,
-0.6646691560745239,
0.5210676193237305,
0.3645695745944977,
0.2806868553161621,
-0.571980893611908,
-0.8090612292289734,
-0.08651455491781235,
-0.5234612822532654,
-0.47704946994781494,
0.33292001485824585,
-0.14163874089717865,
-0.1730036735534668,
-0.05207965895533562,
-0.14322839677333832,
0.13310964405536652,
0.0214287918061018,
-0.00036526634357869625,
-0.09743548184633255,
-0.1111740693449974,
0.005690282676368952,
0.0163651742041111,
-0.21388967335224152,
-0.25611448287963867,
-0.4473467171192169,
0.47676849365234375,
-0.008980203419923782,
-0.2892627716064453,
-0.2453518509864807,
0.1445101797580719,
0.221499964594841,
-0.043604299426078796,
0.4374135434627533,
0.5022175908088684,
-0.27793341875076294,
-0.6394606828689575,
-0.679080069065094,
-0.17572811245918274,
-0.43824803829193115,
0.41192421317100525,
-0.025144925341010094,
-0.6338049173355103,
0.4493454694747925,
-0.23863466084003448,
-0.02212381735444069,
0.2770095765590668,
0.2301119863986969,
-0.36539313197135925,
0.983690083026886,
0.5347768068313599,
-0.27281618118286133,
0.6577145457267761,
-0.4354722499847412,
0.10746351629495621,
-1.2617117166519165,
0.2801606059074402,
-0.4281891882419586,
-0.5538986921310425,
-0.47765645384788513,
-0.6272827386856079,
0.32253995537757874,
0.36443892121315,
0.023314444348216057,
0.25874483585357666,
-0.5138794779777527,
0.29773223400115967,
0.5739375948905945,
0.048125967383384705,
0.5361607670783997,
0.15583480894565582,
0.014815843664109707,
-0.0380752868950367,
-0.7071734666824341,
-0.2595333456993103,
0.9668230414390564,
0.08080590516328812,
0.9230101704597473,
-0.10814736038446426,
1.0132098197937012,
0.24956993758678436,
0.21315856277942657,
-0.7571635842323303,
0.6640529632568359,
-0.49021774530410767,
-0.30079641938209534,
-0.423433780670166,
-0.5515847206115723,
-0.8214064836502075,
0.13682858645915985,
-0.1797361671924591,
-0.8343448638916016,
0.3659847676753998,
0.7297140955924988,
-0.46946579217910767,
0.44668930768966675,
-0.7947245240211487,
0.5306559801101685,
-0.2512238919734955,
-0.5458409190177917,
-0.374407023191452,
-0.16898538172245026,
0.22590427100658417,
-0.03814203292131424,
0.25040632486343384,
-0.3822745084762573,
-0.021791987121105194,
0.6371811628341675,
-0.4636940658092499,
0.667891800403595,
-0.18275411427021027,
-0.11571469157934189,
0.31539568305015564,
0.01563408225774765,
0.7914950251579285,
0.12360173463821411,
-0.22038112580776215,
0.11597316712141037,
0.05796394497156143,
-0.48300373554229736,
-0.5273594260215759,
0.8959359526634216,
-0.9282594919204712,
-0.4309629201889038,
-0.3809420168399811,
-0.6367896795272827,
-0.40861448645591736,
0.16571541130542755,
0.35647052526474,
0.19853653013706207,
0.04477955028414726,
0.3609525263309479,
0.6365732550621033,
-0.19050092995166779,
0.29126259684562683,
0.33366847038269043,
-0.15621648728847504,
-0.23261387646198273,
1.2082300186157227,
0.3451758027076721,
0.24138864874839783,
0.7854022979736328,
0.45472288131713867,
0.14610791206359863,
-0.9435712099075317,
-0.17122407257556915,
0.16678054630756378,
-0.3823651373386383,
-0.508439302444458,
-0.4153396487236023,
-0.20973218977451324,
-0.155152827501297,
-0.10123477131128311,
-0.6987829208374023,
-0.2370336949825287,
-0.17685458064079285,
0.20847320556640625,
0.474632203578949,
0.1566222757101059,
-0.13592477142810822,
0.5030294060707092,
-0.3706066906452179,
0.21770408749580383,
0.3498581647872925,
0.06766436249017715,
-0.03648880496621132,
-0.6526675820350647,
-0.26646843552589417,
-0.021837186068296432,
-0.06607995182275772,
-0.23579970002174377,
0.4044683575630188,
0.4703160524368286,
0.31423547863960266,
0.46531060338020325,
0.22299686074256897,
1.1508352756500244,
-0.23687586188316345,
0.26294222474098206,
-0.07465050369501114,
-0.4494996666908264,
0.6639902591705322,
-0.37945616245269775,
0.26510149240493774,
0.7695603370666504,
-0.24067422747612,
-0.04116644710302353,
-0.456321120262146,
-0.3240423798561096,
-0.8518694043159485,
0.5672492384910583,
-0.019964594393968582,
-0.0860944464802742,
0.0069840154610574245,
0.27160966396331787,
0.05081171169877052,
0.15300561487674713,
-0.23001208901405334,
0.08758067339658737,
-0.17730098962783813,
-0.21178081631660461,
-0.2329733967781067,
-0.38432836532592773,
-0.11902526021003723,
-0.22352327406406403,
0.6020281314849854,
-0.4562377631664276,
0.16507352888584137,
0.09568630158901215,
-0.37405478954315186,
-0.25933244824409485,
0.22484806180000305,
0.37963518500328064,
0.49371618032455444,
-0.7747281193733215,
0.3917151093482971,
0.3719051480293274,
-0.5262715816497803,
-0.42782163619995117,
-0.05768490582704544,
-0.3469927906990051,
-0.4324808716773987,
0.31077954173088074,
0.6020919680595398,
0.5252110362052917,
-0.5982620716094971,
0.21909934282302856,
0.20366941392421722,
-0.09436143189668655,
-0.3281216621398926,
0.2313174307346344,
-0.00095605623209849,
0.08984095603227615,
0.5332723259925842,
0.18297450244426727,
0.12048342823982239,
-0.6541303396224976,
-0.09542345255613327,
0.6039319038391113,
-0.22358563542366028,
-0.1288093626499176,
0.5368121266365051,
0.01367789413779974,
-0.071853868663311,
0.5631043910980225,
0.006397469900548458,
0.01041509211063385,
0.3001677393913269,
0.5683865547180176,
0.6385236382484436,
-0.069307841360569,
-0.0068263281136751175,
0.4167827069759369,
0.3141767978668213,
-0.11478372663259506,
0.12160933017730713,
-0.14506122469902039,
-0.952393114566803,
-0.4847973883152008,
-0.8719601631164551,
-0.3961622714996338,
0.14462760090827942,
-0.5996246337890625,
0.18924593925476074,
-0.7277381420135498,
-0.03247474133968353,
-0.44473448395729065,
0.28685733675956726,
-0.3122689425945282,
0.18891215324401855,
0.004736620932817459,
1.031313419342041,
-0.5567063093185425,
1.2714287042617798,
0.6182708740234375,
-0.07230118662118912,
-0.5161119699478149,
0.13974331319332123,
-0.12556850910186768,
-1.1846548318862915,
0.524941086769104,
0.007435871288180351,
-0.4703810214996338,
0.23872996866703033,
-0.4511954188346863,
-1.0718786716461182,
1.1188585758209229,
0.538585901260376,
-0.5569643974304199,
-0.01212290395051241,
0.01528652012348175,
0.45052480697631836,
-0.34573403000831604,
0.22304001450538635,
0.5054277777671814,
0.48965752124786377,
0.39097273349761963,
-0.48759371042251587,
-0.26754873991012573,
-0.10043936967849731,
0.09712039679288864,
0.17969606816768646,
-0.9935418963432312,
0.8641061782836914,
-0.13654284179210663,
0.13869425654411316,
0.1332506239414215,
0.7427355647087097,
0.5119720697402954,
0.11078949272632599,
0.7314193248748779,
0.6972345113754272,
0.7110353708267212,
-0.07750137895345688,
0.7800117135047913,
-0.4837963879108429,
0.023560388013720512,
1.1431347131729126,
-0.1997452825307846,
1.1013485193252563,
0.7595340013504028,
0.21246448159217834,
0.30840054154396057,
0.36440712213516235,
0.23396673798561096,
0.5259156227111816,
-0.022371429949998856,
0.41519248485565186,
-0.5791788697242737,
-0.2000197470188141,
-0.3461805582046509,
0.6102875471115112,
0.2993495464324951,
0.02740984782576561,
-0.28366076946258545,
-0.16337858140468597,
0.1470026969909668,
0.18907301127910614,
-0.5001514554023743,
0.5374013781547546,
0.10941684991121292,
-0.5568324327468872,
0.5138547420501709,
-0.28385674953460693,
0.9021216034889221,
-0.6621692180633545,
-0.11849374324083328,
-0.4171737730503082,
0.7224543690681458,
-0.30632323026657104,
-0.4122171998023987,
0.11183658242225647,
-0.2494099885225296,
-0.06267090141773224,
-0.429939866065979,
0.6695530414581299,
-0.3653453290462494,
-0.6592024564743042,
0.6367120146751404,
0.2832418382167816,
0.2616117298603058,
-0.231145441532135,
-0.5684242844581604,
0.18691036105155945,
-0.32191866636276245,
-0.36061692237854004,
0.7348695993423462,
0.4355831444263458,
-0.2582559287548065,
0.6571449637413025,
0.6758707165718079,
0.52739018201828,
0.06280147284269333,
0.03986541926860809,
0.7463693022727966,
-0.4290381968021393,
-0.45490527153015137,
-0.453270822763443,
0.11290272325277328,
-0.18471603095531464,
-0.4021494686603546,
0.8157655000686646,
0.7195209264755249,
0.7446057796478271,
0.18153752386569977,
0.3442859351634979,
0.1952274888753891,
0.8506481647491455,
-0.7113513946533203,
0.5056338310241699,
-0.918168842792511,
0.3788849711418152,
-0.32174649834632874,
-1.0298606157302856,
-0.13449959456920624,
0.6670718193054199,
-0.4159572124481201,
0.008951579220592976,
0.4489452540874481,
0.8955262899398804,
-0.12808527052402496,
-0.4264850914478302,
0.5585569143295288,
0.5068646669387817,
0.10349604487419128,
0.7858906984329224,
0.8777629137039185,
-0.49152520298957825,
0.7393041849136353,
-0.31365320086479187,
-0.2902781069278717,
-0.49839237332344055,
-1.1145930290222168,
-0.8399403691291809,
-0.24326451122760773,
-0.22063471376895905,
0.11680901050567627,
0.21566863358020782,
0.7422789335250854,
0.8730891346931458,
-0.9048194289207458,
-0.32562559843063354,
0.088778056204319,
0.11458359658718109,
-0.46812185645103455,
-0.16866537928581238,
0.4373786449432373,
-0.281673789024353,
-0.9137647151947021,
0.5064700245857239,
0.5298961400985718,
-0.39499127864837646,
-0.11045539379119873,
-0.12565463781356812,
-0.1700778305530548,
-0.014569707214832306,
0.6227811574935913,
0.24103489518165588,
-0.5024517178535461,
-0.5380243062973022,
-0.15140634775161743,
0.11110351234674454,
0.2444506287574768,
0.46427154541015625,
-0.75727379322052,
0.1049620658159256,
0.32275640964508057,
0.321921706199646,
0.5454056262969971,
0.19318147003650665,
0.12018590420484543,
-0.6538295745849609,
0.4267951250076294,
0.139590784907341,
0.25747445225715637,
0.30848923325538635,
-0.36195769906044006,
0.3997805714607239,
0.018408512696623802,
-0.4688069522380829,
-0.8830940127372742,
0.016000164672732353,
-1.1459921598434448,
-0.211131289601326,
1.132656455039978,
0.41822394728660583,
-0.4137665629386902,
0.20294488966464996,
-0.3356313407421112,
-0.07388670742511749,
-0.5820716619491577,
0.8804020285606384,
0.28062719106674194,
-0.3170536458492279,
-0.27163851261138916,
-0.6204999089241028,
0.5761669278144836,
0.5191404819488525,
-0.5642646551132202,
0.011595556512475014,
0.1600511521100998,
0.14150255918502808,
0.23154239356517792,
0.554616391658783,
0.08783701807260513,
-0.180863156914711,
-0.24938590824604034,
-0.08436418324708939,
-0.282389372587204,
-0.3968845307826996,
0.24668096005916595,
0.2575905919075012,
0.2903744876384735,
-0.16723978519439697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18375v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18375v1
|
Thai Winograd Schemas: A Benchmark for Thai Commonsense Reasoning
| 2024-05-28T17:14:02 | 2024-05-28T17:14:02 |
Phakphum Artkaew
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Commonsense reasoning is one of the important aspect of natural language
understanding, with several benchmarks developed to evaluate it. However, only
a few of these benchmarks are available in languages other than English.
Developing parallel benchmarks facilitates cross-lingual evaluation, enabling a
better understanding of different languages. This research introduces a
collection of Winograd Schemas in Thai, a novel dataset designed to evaluate
commonsense reasoning capabilities in the context of the Thai language.
Through a methodology involving native speakers, professional translators,
and thorough validation, the schemas aim to closely reflect Thai language
nuances, idioms, and cultural references while maintaining ambiguity and
commonsense challenges. We evaluate the performance of popular large language
models on this benchmark, revealing their strengths, limitations, and providing
insights into the current state-of-the-art. Results indicate that while models
like GPT-4 and Claude-3-Opus achieve high accuracy in English, their
performance significantly drops in Thai, highlighting the need for further
advancements in multilingual commonsense reasoning.
|
[
-0.24321748316287994,
-0.4151308834552765,
0.61240553855896,
0.19347093999385834,
-0.2748774290084839,
-0.01607419177889824,
-0.4616573750972748,
-0.4156886041164398,
-0.3144732117652893,
0.48389098048210144,
0.09762819111347198,
-0.7061663866043091,
-0.6682671904563904,
0.3483862280845642,
0.26087313890457153,
0.707714855670929,
-0.380866676568985,
0.24232567846775055,
-0.1969570815563202,
-0.7019592523574829,
-0.5803806781768799,
-0.011803903616964817,
-0.1555546522140503,
-0.20912139117717743,
0.3985036611557007,
1.022434949874878,
0.6316391825675964,
0.46819165349006653,
0.7931445240974426,
0.22095617651939392,
-0.14840489625930786,
0.28793439269065857,
-0.25228914618492126,
0.3833732008934021,
-0.472337007522583,
-0.31551989912986755,
-0.25147518515586853,
-0.047265633940696716,
0.5014054179191589,
0.746215283870697,
-0.43707844614982605,
0.05776578560471535,
-0.2686018943786621,
0.574386477470398,
-0.8696104288101196,
0.4096856415271759,
-0.5202897191047668,
-0.11795509606599808,
-0.42566734552383423,
0.08834325522184372,
-0.3875829577445984,
-0.5823817849159241,
0.15417790412902832,
-0.9935007095336914,
-0.1258535087108612,
0.09165941923856735,
0.9536272883415222,
0.02631532959640026,
-0.7664472460746765,
-0.3681115210056305,
-0.20334933698177338,
0.9008990526199341,
-0.7126996517181396,
0.7124136686325073,
0.3924197256565094,
0.8592084050178528,
0.009768479503691196,
-0.7166094779968262,
-0.6228328943252563,
-0.28604230284690857,
-0.1599062830209732,
0.12871338427066803,
-0.2821677029132843,
-0.06362450867891312,
0.1652163416147232,
0.45786136388778687,
-0.8334576487541199,
0.15210328996181488,
-0.43533292412757874,
-0.20401187241077423,
0.5158491134643555,
0.05349789187312126,
0.19258275628089905,
-0.4741170406341553,
-0.3856578767299652,
-0.05160202458500862,
-0.8010720014572144,
-0.30260294675827026,
0.337554007768631,
0.2692796289920807,
-0.03833644837141037,
0.4998498857021332,
-0.643835186958313,
0.5235050320625305,
-0.29118672013282776,
-0.3465857207775116,
0.23956730961799622,
-0.5556238293647766,
-0.08900938183069229,
-0.02693375200033188,
0.5827791094779968,
0.7297348976135254,
0.6721835732460022,
-0.08475268632173538,
-0.022840410470962524,
0.4277721345424652,
-0.396685928106308,
-0.5618996024131775,
-0.22457826137542725,
0.2051032930612564,
-0.4310814142227173,
-0.3206879794597626,
-0.23703217506408691,
-0.6902813911437988,
-0.2251569628715515,
-0.30415430665016174,
0.11727000772953033,
-0.5194351673126221,
-0.8219871520996094,
0.6702002882957458,
-0.2708255648612976,
0.32802796363830566,
0.2825588285923004,
-0.6054182648658752,
0.3763309717178345,
0.6136651039123535,
0.5794734954833984,
-0.264622300863266,
-0.6086012125015259,
-0.3769508898258209,
0.4509676694869995,
-0.3621443510055542,
1.0415663719177246,
-0.9504994750022888,
-0.1758352369070053,
-0.2052185982465744,
-0.10131476074457169,
-0.0006870738579891622,
-0.7713669538497925,
0.5381258726119995,
-0.3804457485675812,
0.28416216373443604,
-0.5607625246047974,
-0.3591504693031311,
-0.28681549429893494,
0.17870596051216125,
-0.6685285568237305,
1.0012177228927612,
0.10810797661542892,
-1.0675122737884521,
0.8076217174530029,
-0.7346283793449402,
-0.5080358386039734,
0.28779229521751404,
0.021870866417884827,
0.07826712727546692,
0.029914695769548416,
0.4140121042728424,
0.3928377330303192,
-0.5007461309432983,
0.5983108878135681,
-0.4551650583744049,
-0.07142039388418198,
0.050661612302064896,
-0.33888447284698486,
0.8864080309867859,
0.6650761365890503,
-0.07535188645124435,
0.00969497300684452,
-0.602150022983551,
-0.09336049109697342,
0.1310129314661026,
-0.058196377009153366,
-0.6177831888198853,
-0.4100850820541382,
0.22031192481517792,
0.3235665261745453,
0.14935725927352905,
-0.564292848110199,
0.27218639850616455,
0.12718389928340912,
0.3673780560493469,
0.5754176378250122,
0.043019119650125504,
0.2564115524291992,
-0.18646347522735596,
0.5374880433082581,
0.25676971673965454,
-0.1940126270055771,
-0.11374886333942413,
-0.5140638947486877,
-0.42586246132850647,
-0.5379444360733032,
0.23697781562805176,
0.5340286493301392,
-0.753307044506073,
-0.2286616861820221,
-0.5417547225952148,
-0.7110259532928467,
-0.5266246199607849,
0.12874048948287964,
0.4676295816898346,
0.35219883918762207,
0.22971795499324799,
-0.3783978819847107,
-0.3773369789123535,
-1.130621075630188,
-0.6938536167144775,
-0.025614988058805466,
0.0929996594786644,
0.30680403113365173,
0.6109647750854492,
0.09780295938253403,
0.5900586843490601,
-0.3782535493373871,
-0.07694016396999359,
-0.4228176772594452,
0.27229124307632446,
-0.015181265771389008,
0.40888190269470215,
0.3299109935760498,
-0.5341529250144958,
-0.5832103490829468,
0.39006340503692627,
-0.9612138271331787,
-0.14622777700424194,
0.2799437642097473,
-0.11619909107685089,
-0.028950495645403862,
0.4824146628379822,
-0.840242326259613,
0.13027790188789368,
0.4323839545249939,
-0.3800830543041229,
0.7753080129623413,
-0.1577075570821762,
0.32313477993011475,
-0.9179821014404297,
0.18216274678707123,
0.0010777866700664163,
-0.06572499871253967,
-0.396383136510849,
0.3330906331539154,
0.16409681737422943,
-0.12346725910902023,
-0.49783241748809814,
0.6779297590255737,
-0.4749516546726227,
-0.1889985352754593,
0.22603058815002441,
0.18560121953487396,
0.06304024159908295,
0.2721017301082611,
0.32678258419036865,
0.8483591675758362,
0.5159947872161865,
-0.31717780232429504,
0.37891313433647156,
-0.1101127341389656,
-0.7006556987762451,
1.367457389831543,
-0.5662382245063782,
-0.10750597715377808,
-0.06209186092019081,
0.19841188192367554,
-1.0519145727157593,
-0.5785753726959229,
0.007638643030077219,
-0.04171142354607582,
0.14582818746566772,
0.00192866544239223,
-0.8502592444419861,
-0.24923598766326904,
0.009580304846167564,
0.6822126507759094,
0.0033292558509856462,
-0.45448020100593567,
0.1729351431131363,
0.40330955386161804,
-0.22342540323734283,
-0.6697031855583191,
-0.5045167207717896,
0.17507340013980865,
-0.5955471396446228,
-0.5501691699028015,
-0.19301457703113556,
0.2633734345436096,
-0.5885518193244934,
0.08206818252801895,
0.04334649816155434,
-0.1793135702610016,
-0.08622738718986511,
-0.27845892310142517,
-0.16585662961006165,
-0.49096551537513733,
0.15037256479263306,
0.10614985227584839,
-0.38983678817749023,
-0.2821151316165924,
-0.5104301571846008,
0.11890513449907303,
-0.6522691249847412,
-0.3701574206352234,
-0.457573264837265,
0.43206292390823364,
0.9462288022041321,
-0.593505322933197,
0.20860323309898376,
0.29543066024780273,
-0.37083005905151367,
0.04470446705818176,
-0.6715365052223206,
-0.0038427652325481176,
-0.4401033818721771,
0.37101316452026367,
-0.8089262843132019,
-0.6555779576301575,
0.4847790002822876,
-0.12779735028743744,
-0.06220613792538643,
0.3288656771183014,
0.4789477586746216,
0.088523268699646,
0.7352330684661865,
0.08872894942760468,
0.13982924818992615,
-0.1712205708026886,
0.15674282610416412,
0.09082835167646408,
-0.4984204173088074,
-0.04371766373515129,
-0.3594280779361725,
-0.047099124640226364,
-0.7394994497299194,
-0.6552762985229492,
0.05853034183382988,
-0.04136387258768082,
-0.5038244724273682,
0.5901243090629578,
-0.3433929681777954,
0.6334467530250549,
0.5871858596801758,
-0.3226143717765808,
0.7703520655632019,
-0.0927196815609932,
-0.5275657176971436,
-0.3637997508049011,
-0.6897455453872681,
-0.6651527285575867,
1.2391940355300903,
0.2875532805919647,
0.6102718114852905,
0.3342805802822113,
0.3721081614494324,
0.065511554479599,
0.35299262404441833,
-0.2637072503566742,
0.5223757028579712,
0.11631306260824203,
-0.7862678170204163,
-0.17259091138839722,
-0.3454940915107727,
-0.9413317441940308,
0.4929702877998352,
0.4598391354084015,
-0.7326371073722839,
0.1345987766981125,
-0.03303059563040733,
0.28562402725219727,
0.3544681966304779,
-0.8035545945167542,
1.2097562551498413,
-0.2739694118499756,
-0.5065129399299622,
-0.2790553867816925,
-0.48682910203933716,
0.6299421787261963,
0.38398218154907227,
0.2102571427822113,
-0.25868886709213257,
-0.08631331473588943,
0.5476738214492798,
-0.1694323569536209,
0.44943633675575256,
-0.34246116876602173,
-0.378257155418396,
0.2976312041282654,
0.20582686364650726,
0.4138753116130829,
0.033316224813461304,
-0.05283673480153084,
0.33111321926116943,
0.2006499171257019,
-0.7539435029029846,
-0.4913684129714966,
0.6709678769111633,
-0.40781182050704956,
-0.24997389316558838,
-0.4755084216594696,
-0.679237425327301,
-0.365868479013443,
0.4690816104412079,
0.16888020932674408,
0.09406439960002899,
-0.09701643884181976,
0.042476702481508255,
0.3315623998641968,
-0.15711599588394165,
-0.007710051257163286,
0.6218503713607788,
-0.2359771579504013,
-0.4955703318119049,
1.134900450706482,
0.23002205789089203,
0.4418516755104065,
0.22567994892597198,
0.1993279755115509,
-0.5367331504821777,
-0.4185522794723511,
-0.5712770819664001,
0.4460814893245697,
-1.0415987968444824,
-0.23119033873081207,
-0.3347513675689697,
0.42721596360206604,
-0.23590341210365295,
-0.14395862817764282,
-0.552167534828186,
-0.6561857461929321,
0.49103617668151855,
-0.3129867911338806,
0.2804061472415924,
0.9552414417266846,
-0.21531234681606293,
-0.052681367844343185,
-0.12944820523262024,
0.20738984644412994,
0.47259020805358887,
0.7954327464103699,
-0.09716659039258957,
-0.17800165712833405,
0.06766127049922943,
-0.2461676150560379,
-0.1224435418844223,
-0.9770816564559937,
-0.02768239751458168,
-0.19719374179840088,
0.7029021382331848,
0.6719798445701599,
0.022821128368377686,
0.5859401822090149,
-0.3087993264198303,
0.5134028196334839,
0.03930189833045006,
-0.8661471009254456,
0.4735488295555115,
-0.8394292593002319,
0.33289673924446106,
0.7360878586769104,
0.3431646525859833,
-0.8419252038002014,
-0.5588209629058838,
-0.6393492817878723,
-0.5391343832015991,
0.23769184947013855,
0.17856843769550323,
-0.41029396653175354,
-0.1265340894460678,
-0.29329782724380493,
0.42933228611946106,
0.3502006232738495,
-0.5972035527229309,
-0.006019724067300558,
-0.30556225776672363,
-0.17495834827423096,
0.03764379024505615,
-0.12279181182384491,
-0.06390805542469025,
-0.22668419778347015,
0.25962933897972107,
-0.14648178219795227,
-0.013936777599155903,
-0.160600483417511,
-0.31303590536117554,
0.03632830083370209,
0.5777758955955505,
0.7612260580062866,
0.8722758293151855,
-0.17073065042495728,
0.30994099378585815,
0.4133926033973694,
-0.3602127730846405,
0.1831294745206833,
0.08654818683862686,
0.1548934280872345,
0.053937822580337524,
0.3340010643005371,
0.4581992030143738,
0.6315220594406128,
-0.8489822745323181,
0.5420749187469482,
0.05518410727381706,
-0.33010706305503845,
0.16072995960712433,
-0.3253590166568756,
0.3876083791255951,
-0.03547012805938721,
0.10901995003223419,
-0.08734533190727234,
0.093630850315094,
-0.13169966638088226,
0.27452248334884644,
0.28322941064834595,
-0.06882193684577942,
-0.16898192465305328,
0.6280129551887512,
0.21867026388645172,
0.15777315199375153,
0.4603050947189331,
-0.4346520006656647,
-0.49425724148750305,
0.3740013539791107,
0.5069251656532288,
0.5805949568748474,
-0.19834688305854797,
0.27208974957466125,
0.4974081516265869,
0.41376495361328125,
0.10552619397640228,
0.4612995386123657,
-0.3856350779533386,
-0.5567615032196045,
-0.41386109590530396,
-0.25289225578308105,
-0.6316631436347961,
0.07136223465204239,
-0.8006061315536499,
0.18171840906143188,
-0.03353794664144516,
0.39271414279937744,
-0.21299931406974792,
0.12943778932094574,
-0.9779642224311829,
0.015244174748659134,
-0.07114351540803909,
1.1655222177505493,
-1.11941397190094,
0.7554001808166504,
0.6665449142456055,
-0.42852088809013367,
-0.6298150420188904,
-0.2563554048538208,
0.03500441461801529,
-0.8247252702713013,
0.8078070878982544,
0.22933214902877808,
-0.1270589679479599,
-0.2526716887950897,
-0.3780726194381714,
-0.8199161887168884,
0.9947909116744995,
0.41515567898750305,
-0.344515323638916,
0.128156378865242,
0.28800341486930847,
0.4941043555736542,
-0.2251301407814026,
0.45458242297172546,
0.801194965839386,
0.794023871421814,
-0.2702779173851013,
-1.3179625272750854,
0.17269742488861084,
-0.3156578540802002,
-0.1536126732826233,
-0.10060203075408936,
-0.6864052414894104,
0.7188704609870911,
-0.26003941893577576,
-0.19493108987808228,
-0.11788180470466614,
0.6015492081642151,
0.6889217495918274,
0.5506718754768372,
0.361234188079834,
0.8432151675224304,
0.9829146862030029,
-0.025700533762574196,
0.8871460556983948,
-0.16131342947483063,
0.20627053081989288,
1.0391685962677002,
-0.5499793887138367,
0.9235522150993347,
0.6085001230239868,
-0.30833032727241516,
0.613994836807251,
0.49473729729652405,
0.3225836753845215,
0.5786618590354919,
0.17435024678707123,
-0.17659997940063477,
-0.24648433923721313,
-0.22323386371135712,
-0.6489031910896301,
0.8392754793167114,
0.5499003529548645,
0.12525515258312225,
-0.539625346660614,
0.16856242716312408,
0.29475319385528564,
0.16594722867012024,
0.009790265932679176,
0.5944335460662842,
-0.1206153929233551,
-0.8931549787521362,
0.5801793336868286,
-0.1514851152896881,
0.44834503531455994,
-0.3273213505744934,
-0.1068265438079834,
-0.48911476135253906,
0.1469600945711136,
0.0806702971458435,
-0.9031950831413269,
-0.03639364615082741,
-0.011438969522714615,
0.28093913197517395,
-0.23072078824043274,
0.49756985902786255,
-0.49787965416908264,
-0.4219765365123749,
0.14670364558696747,
0.5668607354164124,
0.46408191323280334,
0.23979008197784424,
-0.3879983127117157,
-0.14263196289539337,
-0.26448819041252136,
-0.1163889616727829,
-0.007326498627662659,
0.8396105170249939,
-0.24938100576400757,
0.7084019780158997,
0.5884519815444946,
0.3644353151321411,
-0.16943836212158203,
-0.11838531494140625,
0.6693547964096069,
-0.6407918334007263,
-0.6643218398094177,
-0.2789161205291748,
0.3884207010269165,
-0.33069083094596863,
-0.6800286173820496,
0.9273767471313477,
0.6939946413040161,
1.1430495977401733,
0.04315583407878876,
0.9301636219024658,
0.24011389911174774,
0.7206479907035828,
-0.3962804675102234,
0.6951218843460083,
-0.5630468726158142,
0.19411210715770721,
-0.518238365650177,
-0.6334108114242554,
-0.4058073163032532,
0.6622180342674255,
-0.698478639125824,
0.011450872756540775,
0.7303746342658997,
0.7417516708374023,
-0.4769616425037384,
0.21940959990024567,
0.2905341684818268,
-0.008646617643535137,
0.2282360941171646,
0.8596562743186951,
0.8947277069091797,
-0.19569599628448486,
0.6330186724662781,
-0.3171902596950531,
0.08576001971960068,
-0.269020140171051,
-1.006615400314331,
-0.6643156409263611,
-0.48207995295524597,
-0.11979035288095474,
-0.21886025369167328,
0.2670495808124542,
0.46887895464897156,
0.5251068472862244,
-0.8765475153923035,
-0.3256170153617859,
-0.3506399095058441,
0.2736271619796753,
-0.40914273262023926,
-0.283978134393692,
0.5234225988388062,
-0.3497091233730316,
-0.561996340751648,
0.21446718275547028,
0.41415104269981384,
-0.2462332546710968,
-0.24491088092327118,
-0.43178680539131165,
-0.1495237797498703,
-0.11261552572250366,
0.4193423092365265,
0.4400019347667694,
-1.014050006866455,
-0.3834655284881592,
0.10817624628543854,
-0.31851232051849365,
0.060557927936315536,
0.7806639671325684,
-0.7639051675796509,
0.9290086030960083,
0.3272133767604828,
0.42753028869628906,
0.3448773920536041,
-0.24715040624141693,
0.7136467099189758,
-0.3659161925315857,
0.33172085881233215,
0.1510474532842636,
0.3967130184173584,
0.5656517148017883,
0.2509823739528656,
0.5218730568885803,
0.3471450209617615,
-0.36485356092453003,
-1.1356096267700195,
0.4393506944179535,
-0.6029971837997437,
-0.19489456713199615,
1.1625535488128662,
-0.10301689058542252,
0.17779122292995453,
-0.5648045539855957,
-0.17536422610282898,
-0.02643662877380848,
-0.3003215193748474,
0.385772705078125,
1.0128254890441895,
0.10286687314510345,
-0.3270682394504547,
-0.7345854640007019,
0.5603187084197998,
0.7231130003929138,
-0.8136027455329895,
0.45392313599586487,
0.3925933837890625,
0.3302834928035736,
-0.055956318974494934,
0.724420428276062,
-0.024648092687129974,
0.8493162393569946,
0.41824954748153687,
-0.29050248861312866,
0.05339442938566208,
-0.29695233702659607,
0.028269130736589432,
0.1688813716173172,
0.1589546650648117,
-0.2873387634754181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18369v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18369v1
|
PromptWizard: Task-Aware Agent-driven Prompt Optimization Framework
| 2024-05-28T17:08:31 | 2024-05-28T17:08:31 |
Eshaan Agarwal, Vivek Dani, Tanuja Ganu, Akshay Nambi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized AI across diverse domains,
showcasing remarkable capabilities. Central to their success is the concept of
prompting, which guides model output generation. However, manual prompt
engineering is labor-intensive and domain-specific, necessitating automated
solutions. This paper introduces PromptWizard, a novel framework leveraging
LLMs to iteratively synthesize and refine prompts tailored to specific tasks.
Unlike existing approaches, PromptWizard optimizes both prompt instructions and
in-context examples, maximizing model performance. The framework iteratively
refines prompts by mutating instructions and incorporating negative examples to
deepen understanding and ensure diversity. It further enhances both
instructions and examples with the aid of a critic, synthesizing new
instructions and examples enriched with detailed reasoning steps for optimal
performance. PromptWizard offers several key features and capabilities,
including computational efficiency compared to state-of-the-art approaches,
adaptability to scenarios with varying amounts of training data, and
effectiveness with smaller LLMs. Rigorous evaluation across 35 tasks on 8
datasets demonstrates PromptWizard's superiority over existing prompt
strategies, showcasing its efficacy and scalability in prompt optimization.
|
[
-0.20972298085689545,
-0.7830999493598938,
0.5286665558815002,
0.6615056395530701,
0.07028639316558838,
0.2138144075870514,
-0.2509244680404663,
0.17223672568798065,
-0.01264280267059803,
0.3631470203399658,
-1.31503164768219,
-0.4389573931694031,
-0.25161492824554443,
0.5213582515716553,
-0.19176413118839264,
0.8002306222915649,
0.09084473550319672,
-0.1473061740398407,
-0.3318294286727905,
0.08358337730169296,
-0.7078204154968262,
-0.056994128972291946,
-0.9586880803108215,
-0.20133161544799805,
0.6745269894599915,
0.6669498682022095,
0.639391303062439,
0.6139499545097351,
-0.029999785125255585,
0.40604889392852783,
0.13307583332061768,
0.4455295205116272,
-0.5567423701286316,
0.6675238609313965,
-0.12983810901641846,
-0.20450371503829956,
-0.14180175960063934,
-0.18913954496383667,
0.29057905077934265,
0.5951258540153503,
-0.005996795371174812,
0.14558517932891846,
-0.03579430654644966,
0.3233973979949951,
-0.6515421271324158,
0.14972852170467377,
-0.5059025287628174,
0.024124495685100555,
0.05597221106290817,
-0.6093906164169312,
-0.49195006489753723,
-0.20051413774490356,
-0.005155741702765226,
-1.0081640481948853,
0.17455464601516724,
0.28494542837142944,
0.19220228493213654,
0.5730821490287781,
-0.33855101466178894,
-0.21247854828834534,
-0.45262154936790466,
0.7524158358573914,
-0.3810465633869171,
0.13444535434246063,
-0.022153936326503754,
0.43165940046310425,
-0.5964600443840027,
-0.8082726001739502,
-0.48022326827049255,
-0.4847492277622223,
0.30982986092567444,
0.02941267006099224,
-0.3238322138786316,
0.3202459216117859,
0.49464482069015503,
-0.11595263332128525,
-0.748217761516571,
0.25565487146377563,
0.17197658121585846,
-0.37964102625846863,
0.6710155010223389,
0.5986555814743042,
0.42337146401405334,
0.03487643599510193,
-0.3135589063167572,
0.029197148978710175,
-0.4294697344303131,
0.38897794485092163,
0.36048203706741333,
0.6628230810165405,
0.029415691271424294,
0.4312523305416107,
-0.3384312391281128,
0.6491086483001709,
0.30901286005973816,
-0.4002765417098999,
0.14990568161010742,
-0.17038756608963013,
0.1521390974521637,
-0.1617908477783203,
0.7047573924064636,
0.34280791878700256,
0.15115928649902344,
-0.10907071828842163,
-0.5344138145446777,
-0.09467276930809021,
0.12255024909973145,
-0.9180182814598083,
0.010543244890868664,
0.5262336730957031,
-0.2641315460205078,
-0.34918105602264404,
-0.5830567479133606,
-0.5742476582527161,
-0.77811598777771,
-0.3644000291824341,
0.30673450231552124,
-0.3147236108779907,
-0.059246037155389786,
-0.07402600347995758,
-0.24657031893730164,
-0.1599249243736267,
0.5789777636528015,
-0.6959621906280518,
-0.06592883169651031,
0.6644781827926636,
0.5599616169929504,
-0.23833201825618744,
-0.5368065237998962,
-0.9986875057220459,
-0.13590064644813538,
-0.4230039417743683,
0.668895959854126,
-0.6501505374908447,
-0.7459564208984375,
0.043332722038030624,
-0.18370097875595093,
-0.0901140347123146,
-0.2939740717411041,
0.6212167739868164,
-0.445696622133255,
0.164711132645607,
-0.13255000114440918,
-0.5080702900886536,
-0.1036423072218895,
0.257069855928421,
-0.6897659301757812,
1.0763777494430542,
0.29738810658454895,
-0.46909359097480774,
0.14084340631961823,
-0.6279966831207275,
-0.41899141669273376,
0.3746573328971863,
-0.13510677218437195,
0.015785111114382744,
0.08542225509881973,
0.30729350447654724,
0.33283817768096924,
-0.6765966415405273,
0.4512050449848175,
-0.05573749542236328,
-0.3987256586551666,
-0.005020202603191137,
-0.3775511085987091,
0.9112229943275452,
0.271515816450119,
-0.268170028924942,
0.6687141060829163,
-0.6847372055053711,
-0.02472595125436783,
0.16104890406131744,
-0.10421505570411682,
0.08401603251695633,
-0.17101989686489105,
0.08758703619241714,
0.05984840169548988,
0.2374492734670639,
-0.2956063151359558,
0.32005956768989563,
-0.33079323172569275,
0.31918543577194214,
0.8415197730064392,
0.213492751121521,
0.6395207643508911,
-0.5201718211174011,
1.1097911596298218,
-0.32897818088531494,
0.32216277718544006,
-0.6865286827087402,
-0.45125508308410645,
-0.3288699984550476,
-0.6522155404090881,
-0.21529661118984222,
0.6606272459030151,
-1.0247251987457275,
0.29694750905036926,
0.09757436811923981,
-0.5604934692382812,
-0.37140092253685,
0.02389824576675892,
-0.03244894742965698,
0.9251225590705872,
0.14182646572589874,
0.35466328263282776,
-0.36631396412849426,
-0.7084194421768188,
-0.3963336646556854,
-0.14512208104133606,
0.10574093461036682,
0.22306109964847565,
0.15058422088623047,
-0.5350644588470459,
1.1183803081512451,
-0.1933983862400055,
0.14465922117233276,
-0.49709057807922363,
-0.06207606941461563,
0.5052003860473633,
0.38288161158561707,
0.5098470449447632,
-0.7278136014938354,
-0.40008506178855896,
-0.3381126821041107,
-0.4585106074810028,
-0.5255035758018494,
-0.517723560333252,
-0.08543211966753006,
-0.005574462469667196,
0.31887462735176086,
-0.8948876857757568,
0.16436420381069183,
0.05349642410874367,
-0.4452322721481323,
0.7617952227592468,
-0.12912389636039734,
0.17394615709781647,
-0.8692054748535156,
0.021439792588353157,
-0.045107387006282806,
-0.22288542985916138,
-0.6979582905769348,
0.12283233553171158,
-0.0179902371019125,
-0.5088821053504944,
-0.23191452026367188,
1.1564711332321167,
-0.48486387729644775,
0.2599017918109894,
-0.4463713765144348,
0.015316097065806389,
-0.01357127632945776,
0.5674957633018494,
-0.15996809303760529,
1.004823923110962,
0.7179780602455139,
-0.5238182544708252,
0.5325137376785278,
0.158457413315773,
0.11931875348091125,
0.5970267057418823,
-0.6943743228912354,
0.07124263048171997,
-0.2704847753047943,
0.13495689630508423,
-1.0286014080047607,
-0.34587129950523376,
0.35041412711143494,
-0.38262778520584106,
0.1914079636335373,
0.10580988973379135,
-0.41945239901542664,
-0.5673461556434631,
-0.5201382637023926,
0.3747316896915436,
0.620096743106842,
-0.606100857257843,
1.0094619989395142,
-0.027042841538786888,
-0.26181110739707947,
-0.8082822561264038,
-0.013305545784533024,
0.06171971559524536,
-0.11992166191339493,
-0.590735912322998,
0.2731796205043793,
-0.3500121235847473,
-0.2941315472126007,
-0.3458940088748932,
-0.14682483673095703,
0.18044434487819672,
0.4163379967212677,
0.35298746824264526,
0.04064717888832092,
0.18981309235095978,
0.22993753850460052,
0.1822461634874344,
-0.16632921993732452,
0.08826930075883865,
-0.3568735420703888,
0.5480689406394958,
0.2712344527244568,
-0.37604305148124695,
-0.3950422704219818,
0.5572696328163147,
0.36157864332199097,
-0.17106500267982483,
0.10718493163585663,
0.5917084217071533,
-0.32754528522491455,
-0.9205729365348816,
-0.28417494893074036,
-0.3629834055900574,
-0.6516960859298706,
0.5984448194503784,
-0.5099368095397949,
-0.9240230321884155,
0.3562425374984741,
-0.2840712368488312,
0.4973711669445038,
0.17110326886177063,
0.5795067548751831,
0.08897249400615692,
0.9909476637840271,
0.7336541414260864,
-0.033312540501356125,
0.5269452333450317,
0.09117551147937775,
0.14815892279148102,
-0.18009302020072937,
-0.20755214989185333,
-0.5752583146095276,
-0.07938691228628159,
-0.42804139852523804,
-0.5968507528305054,
0.4616716504096985,
-0.09147656708955765,
-0.5583065748214722,
0.001688774791546166,
-0.5810617804527283,
0.40991538763046265,
0.6033686399459839,
-0.15904837846755981,
0.10854319483041763,
-0.12594406306743622,
-0.02684408240020275,
0.06744720041751862,
-0.9281489849090576,
-0.5408387184143066,
0.8715291619300842,
0.1808786392211914,
0.6489294767379761,
-0.3130218982696533,
0.7621979713439941,
0.6056385040283203,
0.19557949900627136,
-0.8517137765884399,
0.8343903422355652,
0.3545089066028595,
-0.34221866726875305,
-0.3153629004955292,
-0.3930547535419464,
-1.0165504217147827,
-0.025762435048818588,
-0.1782057136297226,
-0.7057921886444092,
0.0029716945718973875,
0.21219046413898468,
-0.41289791464805603,
-0.14177672564983368,
-0.5226488709449768,
0.8403679728507996,
-0.1288190335035324,
-0.31099069118499756,
-0.11594104021787643,
-0.5533963441848755,
0.1314176619052887,
-0.07462556660175323,
0.20334988832473755,
-0.3624724745750427,
-0.4871118664741516,
0.41647958755493164,
-0.5738582015037537,
0.7799832820892334,
-0.3815878927707672,
-0.1630711406469345,
0.4209643006324768,
0.2685434818267822,
0.7450571656227112,
0.17737455666065216,
-0.27777963876724243,
-0.4435131251811981,
-0.34681257605552673,
-0.34741008281707764,
-0.7585171461105347,
0.6231136322021484,
-0.5912501215934753,
-0.848818838596344,
0.04359191283583641,
-0.8249093294143677,
-0.4218779504299164,
0.23404516279697418,
0.26734933257102966,
0.6821852922439575,
-0.1465412974357605,
-0.4777887463569641,
0.5072207450866699,
-0.29534927010536194,
0.8382992744445801,
0.48675084114074707,
-0.06387288868427277,
-0.25081244111061096,
0.8872863054275513,
-0.30704164505004883,
-0.22743241488933563,
0.41750138998031616,
0.09912055730819702,
-0.21072332561016083,
-0.5260578989982605,
-0.42019015550613403,
-0.0625472441315651,
-0.8861578106880188,
-0.2678515315055847,
-0.7702569365501404,
0.2224913388490677,
-0.357914537191391,
-0.48085129261016846,
-0.21182510256767273,
-0.329974502325058,
-0.4232231080532074,
-0.00389854540117085,
0.6283634901046753,
0.3509800136089325,
0.08581404387950897,
0.3864985704421997,
-0.6283900737762451,
0.15707631409168243,
0.21858498454093933,
-0.17793221771717072,
0.05584973469376564,
-0.33982595801353455,
0.12298893183469772,
-0.35773855447769165,
-0.1697283685207367,
-0.9396394491195679,
0.3868405520915985,
0.10672098398208618,
0.8393434286117554,
0.32393303513526917,
0.44788050651550293,
0.24458804726600647,
-0.5305979251861572,
0.7924818396568298,
0.11258261650800705,
-0.9485384225845337,
0.421036034822464,
-0.4913936257362366,
0.4865574538707733,
0.5530328154563904,
0.37506991624832153,
-0.4388508200645447,
-0.36938461661338806,
-0.30956605076789856,
-1.0793520212173462,
0.49736759066581726,
-0.03157375007867813,
0.2851905822753906,
-0.1357293725013733,
0.4354236125946045,
0.3977493941783905,
0.39865145087242126,
-0.26472973823547363,
-0.28277769684791565,
0.026253975927829742,
-0.597029983997345,
-0.035477813333272934,
-0.06430040299892426,
-0.16690081357955933,
0.027895238250494003,
0.622873842716217,
-0.5418868660926819,
0.31060007214546204,
0.06359443813562393,
-0.16160783171653748,
-0.0011459279339760542,
0.012889174744486809,
0.6044104695320129,
0.5682278275489807,
0.3188544809818268,
-0.2524190843105316,
0.17097970843315125,
-0.39659708738327026,
0.4284725785255432,
0.33230409026145935,
-0.22824755311012268,
0.04863978922367096,
0.6569766998291016,
0.7878379821777344,
0.004598838277161121,
-1.028437852859497,
0.48392394185066223,
-0.0446372851729393,
0.08978122472763062,
-0.19057562947273254,
0.4385564923286438,
-0.15059517323970795,
0.6882327795028687,
0.7610341310501099,
0.15112519264221191,
0.472093790769577,
-0.10930860042572021,
0.18800370395183563,
0.3584641218185425,
0.020113492384552956,
-0.22489520907402039,
0.7613607048988342,
0.5110395550727844,
-0.746370792388916,
0.35607606172561646,
-0.3532858192920685,
-0.4462219774723053,
0.8979887962341309,
0.39583805203437805,
1.2705210447311401,
-0.14502251148223877,
0.31924304366111755,
0.41482439637184143,
0.21420663595199585,
0.10041912645101547,
0.4457445740699768,
-0.3773728013038635,
-0.4774577021598816,
-0.3707773983478546,
-0.2544252276420593,
-0.5777552127838135,
-0.4291376769542694,
-0.29958871006965637,
0.2871902585029602,
-0.5297982692718506,
-0.3355909287929535,
-0.306365042924881,
0.06405546516180038,
-0.7926392555236816,
0.10582558810710907,
-0.14260081946849823,
1.1937026977539062,
-0.4142185151576996,
0.38448286056518555,
0.6753785610198975,
-0.14366266131401062,
-0.995882511138916,
0.054717373102903366,
0.14468710124492645,
-0.9361405372619629,
0.4489399492740631,
0.42061999440193176,
-0.17736324667930603,
0.19787321984767914,
-0.630233108997345,
-0.6433397531509399,
1.1074310541152954,
0.5759387016296387,
-0.7101482152938843,
-0.20505046844482422,
-0.16697587072849274,
0.2604641616344452,
-0.6317568421363831,
0.6360165476799011,
0.29941365122795105,
0.44349896907806396,
0.08695871382951736,
-0.6949455142021179,
0.2756875157356262,
-0.4255509376525879,
0.21616336703300476,
-0.1674336940050125,
-0.6442532539367676,
0.7365631461143494,
-0.5685978531837463,
-0.21719472110271454,
0.27626389265060425,
0.6314045786857605,
0.5534319281578064,
0.473548948764801,
0.5095213055610657,
-0.005690206773579121,
1.0434238910675049,
0.05485830083489418,
1.0793979167938232,
-0.5502750873565674,
-0.17611218988895416,
0.9692657589912415,
-0.4910934865474701,
0.11647478491067886,
0.44916728138923645,
0.1358155608177185,
0.3052966594696045,
0.9088442921638489,
0.12676310539245605,
0.5204439163208008,
0.3074706196784973,
-0.4168221950531006,
-0.379184752702713,
-0.3427656888961792,
-0.09015427529811859,
0.1834269016981125,
0.042687464505434036,
-0.07214856147766113,
-0.3092937171459198,
0.4285053610801697,
-0.0018499509897083044,
0.17305304110050201,
-0.5366639494895935,
0.5612062215805054,
-0.16023024916648865,
-0.7329578399658203,
0.5056918859481812,
-0.020918188616633415,
0.6935542225837708,
-0.5638499855995178,
0.13543498516082764,
-0.4857148230075836,
-0.08297570794820786,
0.08760546892881393,
-0.39903581142425537,
-0.19886118173599243,
0.02867560088634491,
-0.22683903574943542,
-0.32699206471443176,
0.7698270678520203,
-0.2345413863658905,
-0.15269017219543457,
0.15405888855457306,
0.6055635809898376,
-0.1916157454252243,
-0.0536162406206131,
-0.7973238825798035,
0.11787982285022736,
0.010883420705795288,
-0.6225937604904175,
-0.13185463845729828,
0.7714585661888123,
-0.21646501123905182,
1.1759982109069824,
0.44282427430152893,
-0.15867698192596436,
-0.32044342160224915,
0.04398280754685402,
1.0394564867019653,
-0.617581844329834,
-0.6979852318763733,
-0.8360635638237,
0.7432647943496704,
-0.11204886436462402,
-0.534426748752594,
0.768636167049408,
0.30988380312919617,
0.3370591402053833,
-0.12264879792928696,
0.7473568320274353,
0.29792842268943787,
0.35165345668792725,
-0.16709540784358978,
0.3606780469417572,
-0.44058623909950256,
0.2427598536014557,
-0.1644086092710495,
-0.9554750919342041,
0.04442160204052925,
0.2727576792240143,
-0.012605168856680393,
0.24813392758369446,
0.3003193736076355,
0.9758290648460388,
0.48201918601989746,
0.11696523427963257,
0.2517479956150055,
-0.2458244115114212,
0.21589979529380798,
0.5717023015022278,
0.9524989128112793,
0.10276469588279724,
0.30841225385665894,
-0.03502249717712402,
-0.3335782587528229,
-0.17574012279510498,
-0.9051074385643005,
-1.1405596733093262,
-0.5725495219230652,
-0.34481626749038696,
-0.08105964213609695,
0.13846811652183533,
1.5738288164138794,
0.6228598952293396,
-0.4541064202785492,
-0.14204908907413483,
-0.10371903330087662,
0.30296462774276733,
-0.1488744616508484,
-0.24268944561481476,
-0.04380060359835625,
-0.779158353805542,
-0.754796028137207,
0.8022189736366272,
0.293902724981308,
-0.006638772785663605,
-0.14460696280002594,
-0.2072862982749939,
0.3662862479686737,
0.43002113699913025,
0.5023136138916016,
0.3286462724208832,
-0.4388408958911896,
0.0776781439781189,
0.23784402012825012,
-0.30717113614082336,
-0.3538171052932739,
0.8306247591972351,
-0.756287693977356,
0.444712370634079,
0.4764379858970642,
0.9279963970184326,
0.11115533113479614,
-0.022984128445386887,
0.841863751411438,
-0.8133265376091003,
0.3970051109790802,
0.7213573455810547,
0.28223875164985657,
0.23623749613761902,
-0.5997110605239868,
0.4284253418445587,
0.15345501899719238,
-0.42427393794059753,
-0.9367005825042725,
0.1423293650150299,
-0.9135758876800537,
-0.5312524437904358,
1.2625116109848022,
0.06955695897340775,
-0.23671598732471466,
0.08163456618785858,
-0.47186213731765747,
0.11401088535785675,
-0.8556597232818604,
0.36492037773132324,
0.25028422474861145,
-0.2083633691072464,
-0.3732641935348511,
-0.29121506214141846,
0.7959127426147461,
0.4129399061203003,
-0.8694518804550171,
0.046551112085580826,
0.7989282608032227,
0.14423952996730804,
-0.11945986747741699,
0.8012516498565674,
0.5406601428985596,
0.5016533732414246,
0.05436467006802559,
0.08766685426235199,
-0.4670640826225281,
-0.4052567183971405,
-0.4239727854728699,
0.3963147699832916,
0.1385168880224228,
0.018567699939012527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00048v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00048v1
|
Towards a theory of how the structure of language is acquired by deep neural networks
| 2024-05-28T17:01:22 | 2024-05-28T17:01:22 |
Francesco Cagnetta, Matthieu Wyart
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cond-mat.dis-nn, cs.LG
|
How much data is required to learn the structure of a language via next-token
prediction? We study this question for synthetic datasets generated via a
Probabilistic Context-Free Grammar (PCFG) -- a hierarchical generative model
that captures the tree-like structure of natural languages. We determine
token-token correlations analytically in our model and show that they can be
used to build a representation of the grammar's hidden variables, the longer
the range the deeper the variable. In addition, a finite training set limits
the resolution of correlations to an effective range, whose size grows with
that of the training set. As a result, a Language Model trained with
increasingly many examples can build a deeper representation of the grammar's
structure, thus reaching good performance despite the high dimensionality of
the problem. We conjecture that the relationship between training set size and
effective range of correlations holds beyond our synthetic datasets. In
particular, our conjecture predicts how the scaling law for the test loss
behaviour with training set size depends on the length of the context window,
which we confirm empirically for a collection of lines from Shakespeare's
plays.
|
[
-0.22545897960662842,
-0.6575471758842468,
0.34023353457450867,
-0.03215263783931732,
-0.10686130076646805,
-0.12399657815694809,
-0.3603246510028839,
-0.3394368886947632,
0.08363375812768936,
0.1508931666612625,
-0.3154107928276062,
-0.1204325333237648,
-0.49837952852249146,
-0.319532573223114,
-0.6166830658912659,
0.899273693561554,
0.31175923347473145,
0.07713976502418518,
-0.3726885914802551,
0.19350451231002808,
-0.34864354133605957,
-0.6329934000968933,
-0.5990737080574036,
-0.17429262399673462,
0.588660478591919,
0.30449625849723816,
0.7395167946815491,
0.8883906006813049,
0.558310866355896,
0.20364902913570404,
-0.30465272068977356,
-0.10228065401315689,
-0.468000203371048,
0.08926009386777878,
-0.007130232639610767,
-0.9009845852851868,
-0.07793600112199783,
0.17532412707805634,
0.9129430651664734,
1.2232367992401123,
0.24897657334804535,
0.010715114884078503,
0.13398543000221252,
0.5922307968139648,
-0.27353233098983765,
0.5227283835411072,
-0.48416414856910706,
0.33235612511634827,
-0.24877677857875824,
0.005763343535363674,
-0.4857753813266754,
0.07323803752660751,
0.2689628601074219,
-0.519264817237854,
0.2284688502550125,
-0.10575999319553375,
0.7033892273902893,
-0.08212966471910477,
-0.6259483695030212,
-0.004084838088601828,
-0.5682699680328369,
0.6485583782196045,
-0.4108157157897949,
0.3576347827911377,
0.6242831349372864,
0.23909085988998413,
-0.4382678270339966,
-0.7631879448890686,
-0.46939095854759216,
-0.4794755280017853,
-0.3068828284740448,
-0.05815482512116432,
0.10511619597673416,
0.10648062825202942,
0.10655183345079422,
0.7095159888267517,
-0.5114196538925171,
0.0318177156150341,
-0.42925968766212463,
-0.052450262010097504,
0.49965158104896545,
0.09316413104534149,
0.2430090755224228,
-0.18313758075237274,
-0.14730936288833618,
-0.25630301237106323,
-0.7626845240592957,
0.15188956260681152,
0.22171472012996674,
0.7739655375480652,
-0.2398969531059265,
0.4905100166797638,
0.19136175513267517,
0.55238276720047,
0.10782890766859055,
0.07322516292333603,
0.09805374592542648,
-0.4735430181026459,
-0.28868988156318665,
0.02503112517297268,
0.7779828906059265,
-0.011754047125577927,
0.4718555510044098,
-0.41549742221832275,
0.1363903284072876,
0.05202268436551094,
-0.005696453619748354,
-0.7030090689659119,
-0.3655056953430176,
-0.1178784891963005,
-0.41094064712524414,
-0.41087979078292847,
0.12632592022418976,
-0.3485196530818939,
-0.16397801041603088,
-0.3559305667877197,
0.12476521730422974,
-0.5849704146385193,
-0.37645041942596436,
-0.04688918963074684,
-0.11373519897460938,
0.22948919236660004,
-0.31326213479042053,
-1.1113415956497192,
0.40449848771095276,
0.7642581462860107,
0.746065080165863,
0.03327347710728645,
-0.441977322101593,
-0.5825980305671692,
-0.0432250089943409,
-0.8952485918998718,
0.32860225439071655,
-0.6875621676445007,
-0.2887878119945526,
0.003268900327384472,
0.0252667386084795,
-0.14319045841693878,
-0.21460261940956116,
0.2663405239582062,
-0.48086804151535034,
0.2466924786567688,
-0.3750516176223755,
-0.7430761456489563,
0.11677739769220352,
0.14060406386852264,
-0.7584683299064636,
0.6777229309082031,
0.0868423730134964,
-0.6764707565307617,
0.5472056269645691,
-0.26133280992507935,
-0.6879059076309204,
0.12688477337360382,
-0.4715653955936432,
-0.23154570162296295,
0.6069091558456421,
-0.0295258741825819,
0.5077711343765259,
-0.28382745385169983,
0.37370914220809937,
-0.36946335434913635,
-0.4712708592414856,
0.3345072269439697,
-0.5203356146812439,
0.835593044757843,
0.15044815838336945,
-0.25561460852622986,
-0.25338393449783325,
-0.8226498365402222,
0.13550245761871338,
-0.16744297742843628,
-0.4905242621898651,
-0.21367402374744415,
0.17788997292518616,
-0.24212504923343658,
0.2270398736000061,
0.012193513102829456,
-0.42807698249816895,
0.05338383838534355,
-0.6707947850227356,
0.4267822206020355,
0.7369011640548706,
-0.2147650569677353,
0.6849445700645447,
-0.0778064951300621,
0.3183280825614929,
0.12019840627908707,
-0.07511253654956818,
-0.23155072331428528,
-0.35676172375679016,
-0.6643337607383728,
-0.074961356818676,
0.47473108768463135,
0.13255423307418823,
-0.21992862224578857,
0.4142482578754425,
-0.449319452047348,
-0.17385388910770416,
-0.0774838775396347,
0.0288984514772892,
0.3896731734275818,
0.28645119071006775,
0.03726458176970482,
-0.23649068176746368,
-0.6611151099205017,
-0.8479465842247009,
-0.054823361337184906,
-0.506242573261261,
-0.0248726774007082,
0.2890496551990509,
0.38396376371383667,
0.038707830011844635,
0.8372904658317566,
-0.1317271590232849,
-0.2833828628063202,
-0.20678450167179108,
-0.09617391973733902,
0.3688128590583801,
0.6750802993774414,
0.708836019039154,
-0.6405868530273438,
-0.3720400333404541,
0.26475971937179565,
-0.597693920135498,
0.37592050433158875,
-0.06370455771684647,
0.0048306784592568874,
-0.05308099091053009,
0.8212823271751404,
-0.6425409913063049,
0.3249737620353699,
0.6807345151901245,
-0.4299353361129761,
0.39186811447143555,
-0.21010227501392365,
-0.39974305033683777,
-1.2577557563781738,
0.0808514803647995,
-0.2938859760761261,
0.044999368488788605,
-0.6866250038146973,
0.13001005351543427,
-0.06294466555118561,
-0.04572371765971184,
-0.2272968590259552,
0.41326799988746643,
-0.3717805743217468,
-0.25796908140182495,
-0.08463684469461441,
-0.14492012560367584,
-0.09347855299711227,
0.5101683735847473,
-0.08925016969442368,
0.8230568766593933,
0.6027848720550537,
-0.5952473282814026,
0.0681663528084755,
0.06264457106590271,
-0.3605656623840332,
0.18934032320976257,
-0.37373244762420654,
-0.1509283185005188,
-0.20025180280208588,
0.15035521984100342,
-1.1125367879867554,
-0.36095210909843445,
-0.3130197823047638,
-0.7307463884353638,
0.405030220746994,
-0.13569748401641846,
-0.39340558648109436,
-0.18207567930221558,
-0.017199089750647545,
0.590268075466156,
0.4322894513607025,
-0.5679926872253418,
0.4462096095085144,
0.23430322110652924,
0.29616767168045044,
-0.6485252976417542,
-1.0581752061843872,
0.16265691816806793,
-0.10096768289804459,
-0.42097145318984985,
0.4028933644294739,
0.020709369331598282,
-0.3611682653427124,
-0.0036241780035197735,
-0.01307003665715456,
-0.21078793704509735,
0.17000962793827057,
0.40910759568214417,
-0.12355111539363861,
-0.5887857675552368,
0.642777681350708,
-0.17423667013645172,
0.15312452614307404,
0.45081302523612976,
-0.6900012493133545,
0.5816535353660583,
-0.4368533194065094,
-0.0009458916611038148,
-0.27194350957870483,
0.22273460030555725,
0.6772200465202332,
-0.11013013869524002,
0.821997344493866,
0.35075366497039795,
-0.3062008023262024,
-0.27026504278182983,
0.03602041304111481,
-0.07353223860263824,
-0.46055832505226135,
0.44048362970352173,
-0.7160353660583496,
-0.8199158906936646,
0.7478809952735901,
0.2989603579044342,
-0.248692587018013,
0.7396645545959473,
0.34800058603286743,
-0.11636430025100708,
0.7806081175804138,
0.7489389181137085,
-0.257333368062973,
0.622481107711792,
-0.44462940096855164,
0.19641539454460144,
-0.6058915257453918,
-0.3392125964164734,
-0.30152085423469543,
-0.3415817618370056,
-0.8185593485832214,
-0.3635059595108032,
-0.05967472493648529,
0.3523988425731659,
-0.424641877412796,
0.39327093958854675,
-0.0005165745387785137,
0.7162893414497375,
0.7316603660583496,
-0.07599232345819473,
-0.08280915766954422,
0.25822290778160095,
-0.6990835070610046,
0.1667848527431488,
-0.779793918132782,
-0.048388224095106125,
1.1512434482574463,
0.2411426156759262,
0.2704000771045685,
0.11846347153186798,
0.5180959105491638,
-0.08868655562400818,
-0.04057207331061363,
-0.9050466418266296,
0.40772947669029236,
-0.40962716937065125,
-0.7148697376251221,
-0.44377601146698,
-0.4279676079750061,
-1.0767096281051636,
0.1324402242898941,
-0.041468583047389984,
-0.5352369546890259,
0.44043833017349243,
0.1894920915365219,
-0.2660747468471527,
0.41168084740638733,
-0.586458683013916,
0.7486163973808289,
-0.1593620479106903,
-0.37795311212539673,
-0.02733723260462284,
-0.768426239490509,
0.252667099237442,
0.010194052010774612,
-0.015138410963118076,
0.23240694403648376,
0.2067277878522873,
0.6737829446792603,
-0.5023627281188965,
0.9689072370529175,
0.10117453336715698,
0.012903546914458275,
0.5392784476280212,
0.38214123249053955,
0.3043297827243805,
0.15383175015449524,
-0.040699705481529236,
0.020703615620732307,
-0.07894374430179596,
-0.5524092316627502,
-0.5544113516807556,
0.5534369945526123,
-0.8820395469665527,
-0.2966345548629761,
-0.37687164545059204,
-0.6127047538757324,
-0.32416388392448425,
0.18221956491470337,
0.308536171913147,
0.5102511644363403,
-0.264140784740448,
0.5984832644462585,
0.3520616888999939,
-0.031340982764959335,
0.6360270380973816,
-0.06711629778146744,
-0.1565939486026764,
-0.3481551706790924,
0.6977699398994446,
0.10315275937318802,
0.3071180284023285,
0.7020615935325623,
0.3973352313041687,
-0.20486892759799957,
-0.617416262626648,
-0.07335646450519562,
0.032618217170238495,
-0.6532964706420898,
-0.027105802670121193,
-0.21172334253787994,
-0.4715946614742279,
-0.3285040855407715,
0.019593972712755203,
-0.16823329031467438,
-0.6462235450744629,
-0.4750276207923889,
-0.6172656416893005,
0.23985478281974792,
0.6251142621040344,
-0.2257409542798996,
0.5869333148002625,
-0.3015895485877991,
-0.2715277075767517,
0.366842120885849,
0.5938450694084167,
0.07444420456886292,
-0.5849295854568481,
-0.3598601520061493,
0.03706476464867592,
0.16623537242412567,
-0.3806309998035431,
0.3135240972042084,
0.3946554362773895,
0.39879003167152405,
0.6631632447242737,
-0.3634856343269348,
0.8202073574066162,
-0.559543251991272,
0.8629730939865112,
0.2642366290092468,
-0.7004210948944092,
0.14595215022563934,
-0.5487608313560486,
0.15181472897529602,
0.5393251180648804,
0.13189123570919037,
-0.5138810873031616,
-0.19136305153369904,
-0.6493239998817444,
-0.6450066566467285,
0.4763351380825043,
0.12453407794237137,
0.5249186754226685,
-0.461378276348114,
0.6856274008750916,
-0.05637962371110916,
0.13656003773212433,
-0.788514256477356,
-0.04822768643498421,
-0.18567481637001038,
-0.22023122012615204,
-0.49471160769462585,
-0.3030203878879547,
0.12595641613006592,
-0.3716587424278259,
0.1146322712302208,
-0.19104313850402832,
0.356192409992218,
-0.11231217533349991,
-0.07645799964666367,
-0.0359756164252758,
-0.06727468222379684,
0.4303697943687439,
0.627025842666626,
-0.21864619851112366,
0.5606282353401184,
-0.03502167388796806,
-0.49533137679100037,
-0.015348372049629688,
-0.17300164699554443,
0.15917043387889862,
-0.2000853717327118,
0.8055076599121094,
0.8964933156967163,
-0.031003793701529503,
-0.5132107734680176,
0.5360891222953796,
-0.025768939405679703,
-0.3917369842529297,
-0.48401015996932983,
-0.07808719575405121,
0.09992741793394089,
0.18748591840267181,
0.20726372301578522,
-0.04212801530957222,
-0.10959219187498093,
-0.7870529890060425,
0.6057692170143127,
0.39546042680740356,
-0.740123450756073,
-0.5381088256835938,
0.5265640616416931,
-0.17282971739768982,
-0.2749689519405365,
0.7917882204055786,
-0.0008507649763487279,
-0.3653027415275574,
0.8549138903617859,
0.7411072850227356,
0.8168258666992188,
-0.16295360028743744,
0.2497585415840149,
0.3832858204841614,
0.18114757537841797,
-0.12355224788188934,
0.04081403464078903,
-0.054451290518045425,
-0.5829451680183411,
-0.626600980758667,
-0.7786390781402588,
0.16361035406589508,
0.39215943217277527,
-0.3992743194103241,
-0.062006670981645584,
-0.6408457159996033,
0.01926620490849018,
-0.11030921339988708,
0.04831836372613907,
-0.5563088059425354,
0.40320461988449097,
0.16249655187129974,
0.750053882598877,
-0.7596704363822937,
0.797847330570221,
0.0998530313372612,
-0.48903411626815796,
-0.9340918660163879,
0.02763393521308899,
-0.20559248328208923,
-0.7570541501045227,
1.0926430225372314,
0.24432796239852905,
0.08491171151399612,
-0.23823854327201843,
-0.3364088237285614,
-1.2799694538116455,
0.7733687162399292,
0.5230353474617004,
-0.4314430356025696,
-0.2837887704372406,
0.3104342818260193,
0.9024251103401184,
-0.5500022768974304,
-0.047549378126859665,
0.5283111333847046,
0.015776874497532845,
0.15671871602535248,
-0.6260607838630676,
-0.06449612975120544,
-0.4097055196762085,
0.10604675859212875,
0.26854750514030457,
-0.4318675398826599,
1.3578873872756958,
-0.14314797520637512,
-0.2013195902109146,
0.19483226537704468,
0.6264683604240417,
-0.22353185713291168,
-0.267286479473114,
0.32548967003822327,
0.4997057616710663,
0.5926392674446106,
0.04552094265818596,
1.4074963331222534,
-0.37865981459617615,
0.22260351479053497,
1.2412477731704712,
0.22915136814117432,
0.9330725073814392,
0.4842517077922821,
-0.13619159162044525,
0.5922334790229797,
0.7064986228942871,
0.05810776352882385,
0.6453090310096741,
0.5906795263290405,
-0.10175792127847672,
-0.16362690925598145,
-0.03604920208454132,
-0.2009100317955017,
0.5226926207542419,
0.4225868880748749,
-0.8394243717193604,
0.17414134740829468,
-0.2560976445674896,
-0.04874110594391823,
-0.035164929926395416,
-0.3061027228832245,
0.5870839953422546,
0.2038583755493164,
-0.6973870396614075,
0.5941038131713867,
-0.16441267728805542,
0.05904654040932655,
-0.40999123454093933,
0.1983395367860794,
-0.4696451723575592,
0.4536212086677551,
0.01408303715288639,
-0.4545053541660309,
0.24936524033546448,
-0.48984840512275696,
-0.13274189829826355,
-0.020694207400083542,
0.2809298038482666,
-0.4797094762325287,
-0.6634258031845093,
0.3583749234676361,
0.515489935874939,
0.1827283501625061,
0.23914462327957153,
-0.23591138422489166,
-0.3529854416847229,
-0.2965663969516754,
-0.23985938727855682,
0.40632930397987366,
0.504091203212738,
-0.14704301953315735,
0.3007966876029968,
0.6539399027824402,
0.35788384079933167,
0.36943861842155457,
0.09499000012874603,
0.7575386166572571,
-0.5981984734535217,
-0.6158260703086853,
-0.9886534214019775,
0.2070266455411911,
-0.04120631888508797,
-0.30650952458381653,
0.591987133026123,
0.6008942127227783,
1.1198124885559082,
0.07517316937446594,
0.6230164766311646,
0.18290461599826813,
-0.0705455094575882,
-0.3130107522010803,
0.43933260440826416,
-0.4128652811050415,
0.040108922868967056,
-0.125335231423378,
-0.6701935529708862,
-0.6583775281906128,
0.8003156781196594,
-0.27350369095802307,
-0.018012385815382004,
0.941749095916748,
0.6774591207504272,
-0.17611299455165863,
-0.20307022333145142,
0.38416871428489685,
0.16004331409931183,
0.3874374032020569,
0.6448025107383728,
0.6918286681175232,
-0.43731674551963806,
0.68986976146698,
-0.10967648029327393,
0.0469944067299366,
-0.04612668231129646,
-0.5991076231002808,
-1.1458605527877808,
-0.7056890726089478,
0.05648193508386612,
-0.4039246141910553,
0.016618115827441216,
0.6737064719200134,
0.7640417814254761,
-0.7554118633270264,
-0.5415164828300476,
-0.7834967374801636,
-0.1380172222852707,
-0.32971009612083435,
-0.17202121019363403,
0.7100706696510315,
-0.6406701803207397,
-0.461196631193161,
0.4602588415145874,
0.11548834294080734,
0.3278310000896454,
-0.19903630018234253,
-0.0056250933557748795,
-0.11514335125684738,
0.13152945041656494,
0.7615842819213867,
0.24979424476623535,
-0.5531884431838989,
-0.3628848195075989,
0.12594039738178253,
0.019437100738286972,
0.16953200101852417,
0.8779008388519287,
-0.7265812754631042,
0.37312498688697815,
0.600918173789978,
0.8103065490722656,
0.46144139766693115,
-0.358193039894104,
0.8564477562904358,
-1.179261565208435,
0.2859320342540741,
0.0016285729361698031,
0.38132238388061523,
0.05974002555012703,
-0.3620435297489166,
0.3859120309352875,
0.16870898008346558,
-0.09855255484580994,
-0.8450040221214294,
0.45266231894493103,
-0.6407704949378967,
-0.4804941713809967,
0.9690587520599365,
-0.1063656285405159,
-0.3530578315258026,
0.23141661286354065,
0.23332799971103668,
0.22023215889930725,
-0.0840003713965416,
0.6699861288070679,
0.8484007716178894,
-0.012242062017321587,
-0.1533237099647522,
-0.28481051325798035,
0.7980462908744812,
0.4909105896949768,
-0.45416608452796936,
0.3347708284854889,
0.4264044761657715,
0.11213257163763046,
0.3857592046260834,
0.3769984841346741,
-0.19084432721138,
0.14782831072807312,
0.3204343020915985,
-0.49209752678871155,
-0.049581579864025116,
-0.644830048084259,
-0.5279944539070129,
0.5626575946807861,
0.04224051907658577,
-0.22737431526184082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18359v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18359v1
|
Bridging the Gap: Dynamic Learning Strategies for Improving Multilingual Performance in LLMs
| 2024-05-28T16:56:42 | 2024-05-28T16:56:42 |
Somnath Kumar, Vaibhav Balloli, Mercy Ranjit, Kabir Ahuja, Tanuja Ganu, Sunayana Sitaram, Kalika Bali, Akshay Nambi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) are at the forefront of transforming numerous
domains globally. However, their inclusivity and effectiveness remain limited
for non-Latin scripts and low-resource languages. This paper tackles the
imperative challenge of enhancing the multilingual performance of LLMs without
extensive training or fine-tuning. Through systematic investigation and
evaluation of diverse languages using popular question-answering (QA) datasets,
we present novel techniques that unlock the true potential of LLMs in a
polyglot landscape. Our approach encompasses three key strategies that yield
significant improvements in multilingual proficiency. First, by meticulously
optimizing prompts tailored for polyglot LLMs, we unlock their latent
capabilities, resulting in substantial performance boosts across languages.
Second, we introduce a new hybrid approach that synergizes LLM Retrieval
Augmented Generation (RAG) with multilingual embeddings and achieves improved
multilingual task performance. Finally, we introduce a novel learning approach
that dynamically selects the optimal prompt strategy, LLM model, and embedding
model per query at run-time. This dynamic adaptation maximizes the efficacy of
LLMs across languages, outperforming best static and random strategies.
Additionally, our approach adapts configurations in both offline and online
settings, and can seamlessly adapt to new languages and datasets, leading to
substantial advancements in multilingual understanding and generation across
diverse languages.
|
[
-0.36723849177360535,
-0.8617624044418335,
0.5532456636428833,
-0.021732434630393982,
-0.12465119361877441,
1.0906989574432373,
-0.39448806643486023,
-0.43776950240135193,
0.17396597564220428,
0.028847992420196533,
-0.7025442719459534,
-0.49177229404449463,
-0.3709575831890106,
0.21220816671848297,
0.22244159877300262,
0.7690321803092957,
-0.09734738618135452,
0.16167113184928894,
-0.4992711842060089,
-0.2354869842529297,
-0.5058122277259827,
-0.49412521719932556,
-0.5103480219841003,
-0.2540544867515564,
0.7897958755493164,
0.41515660285949707,
0.5409639477729797,
0.3716624081134796,
0.14527909457683563,
0.24198909103870392,
-0.28151488304138184,
0.7740445733070374,
-0.679305911064148,
0.39775410294532776,
-0.049799006432294846,
-0.731479823589325,
-0.20752371847629547,
-0.3153572678565979,
0.8919934034347534,
0.6753482818603516,
-0.3554171323776245,
0.1491905301809311,
0.0047964430414140224,
0.44175004959106445,
-0.5631735324859619,
0.17272678017616272,
-0.7276961207389832,
0.15116973221302032,
-0.4254876673221588,
-0.25760146975517273,
-0.24612054228782654,
-0.38877326250076294,
-0.02102971263229847,
-0.6735390424728394,
-0.01784789003431797,
-0.07616990059614182,
0.5182353258132935,
0.12404627352952957,
-0.5292587280273438,
-0.30491936206817627,
-0.6885848641395569,
0.758970320224762,
-0.46085745096206665,
0.4896084666252136,
0.03238772973418236,
0.4406367838382721,
-0.06614972651004791,
-0.5660415887832642,
-0.3758295178413391,
-0.10422626882791519,
0.14688627421855927,
0.1526155322790146,
0.14849428832530975,
-0.22765767574310303,
0.212337926030159,
0.327150821685791,
-0.5303875207901001,
0.34553372859954834,
-0.051901474595069885,
-0.15120893716812134,
0.4648391306400299,
0.2275819331407547,
0.4210365414619446,
0.05440596863627434,
-0.2802574336528778,
-0.11710886657238007,
-0.7657967209815979,
0.5082317590713501,
0.541960597038269,
0.43178439140319824,
-0.28108641505241394,
0.30826878547668457,
0.22037379443645477,
0.6160528063774109,
-0.015541693195700645,
-0.47306549549102783,
0.26045194268226624,
-0.45630165934562683,
0.2786473333835602,
-0.24329164624214172,
0.38420161604881287,
-0.12633611261844635,
0.12206435203552246,
-0.2102663516998291,
-0.22733210027217865,
-0.2110837996006012,
-0.1349271535873413,
-0.40668293833732605,
0.13901324570178986,
-0.020266106352210045,
-0.10454732179641724,
-0.07091065496206284,
-0.03303370997309685,
-1.084761619567871,
-0.5602052211761475,
-0.23991413414478302,
0.18015511333942413,
-0.20918132364749908,
-0.5054409503936768,
0.139693483710289,
0.24110844731330872,
0.33538296818733215,
0.3999505639076233,
-0.8102870583534241,
0.12432549148797989,
0.4753990173339844,
0.7328435778617859,
-0.40989845991134644,
-0.34797486662864685,
-0.6252769231796265,
0.15803445875644684,
-0.31394022703170776,
0.5843852162361145,
-0.6806897521018982,
-0.2627931535243988,
0.2922200560569763,
-0.08596811443567276,
-0.43971943855285645,
-0.6973483562469482,
0.14392633736133575,
-0.8149623870849609,
0.3736106753349304,
-0.24716605246067047,
-0.34420350193977356,
-0.24868138134479523,
0.3254964053630829,
-0.6712515950202942,
1.171756625175476,
0.03288409858942032,
-0.6195077896118164,
0.005405860487371683,
-0.5447486042976379,
-0.40229374170303345,
0.04457049071788788,
-0.22419697046279907,
-0.27425986528396606,
0.11329060792922974,
0.40453290939331055,
0.14936552941799164,
-0.2942432463169098,
0.20480424165725708,
0.0012667445698753,
-0.27040374279022217,
0.23302330076694489,
-0.3597760796546936,
0.658572256565094,
0.019082868471741676,
-0.2736334800720215,
0.16791872680187225,
-0.6586118936538696,
0.023445818573236465,
0.36542636156082153,
-0.5865266919136047,
-0.017497830092906952,
-0.04495975375175476,
-0.15642233192920685,
0.22247348725795746,
0.3324969410896301,
-0.3069779872894287,
0.21620312333106995,
-0.48161911964416504,
0.1708945780992508,
0.6946618556976318,
-0.14214935898780823,
0.250550776720047,
-0.31654101610183716,
1.124818205833435,
-0.10237792134284973,
-0.05066455155611038,
-0.3868807256221771,
-0.2978106737136841,
-0.7337680459022522,
-0.25921308994293213,
0.39739853143692017,
0.8301777839660645,
-1.2573705911636353,
-0.09721080958843231,
-0.13458546996116638,
-0.42627188563346863,
-0.709036111831665,
0.514373779296875,
0.30727627873420715,
0.19334562122821808,
0.2810293138027191,
-0.11596395820379257,
-0.30545976758003235,
-0.5363810658454895,
-0.2927241623401642,
-0.11361930519342422,
0.2929007411003113,
0.3588525652885437,
0.032885558903217316,
-0.08196764439344406,
0.5394747257232666,
-0.3659191131591797,
0.13839520514011383,
-0.7142529487609863,
-0.019655557349324226,
0.5057284235954285,
-0.00021691063011530787,
0.4188612699508667,
-0.899127721786499,
-0.7400469779968262,
0.031322915107011795,
-0.739338755607605,
-0.21021738648414612,
-0.1289331614971161,
-0.031303245574235916,
0.18910165131092072,
0.5544082522392273,
-0.4490051865577698,
-0.18294033408164978,
0.6503347754478455,
-0.11362814158201218,
0.6532317399978638,
-0.30325618386268616,
0.002186724916100502,
-1.0175434350967407,
-0.2822762429714203,
-0.22453726828098297,
-0.29837727546691895,
-0.6773026585578918,
0.2824208438396454,
0.0349925234913826,
-0.26354238390922546,
-0.7122927904129028,
0.7347894906997681,
-0.8732908368110657,
0.08504832535982132,
-0.09809070825576782,
0.2892613112926483,
-0.12682312726974487,
0.3662124276161194,
-0.2270413190126419,
0.9930862784385681,
0.7823907732963562,
-0.4403984248638153,
0.5939667820930481,
0.14928306639194489,
-0.38679924607276917,
0.1840466409921646,
-0.35313066840171814,
0.15121334791183472,
-0.41829001903533936,
0.19999009370803833,
-0.9571482539176941,
-0.09295689314603806,
0.030022021383047104,
-0.20097282528877258,
0.556786835193634,
-0.08125416934490204,
-0.7053568363189697,
-0.252949059009552,
-0.33705997467041016,
0.652926504611969,
0.505262017250061,
-0.5524622797966003,
0.7712845802307129,
0.3838662803173065,
-0.5027708411216736,
-0.5605329871177673,
-0.34333571791648865,
0.12460528314113617,
-0.34242677688598633,
-0.6951865553855896,
0.35470494627952576,
-0.16347013413906097,
-0.27613914012908936,
-0.5131980776786804,
0.07698385417461395,
0.24949388206005096,
0.1870027333498001,
-0.31960463523864746,
0.13847431540489197,
-0.2635115385055542,
0.3434922695159912,
0.1206524670124054,
-0.08860357850790024,
-0.2529677450656891,
-0.17179031670093536,
0.7665299773216248,
-0.13642238080501556,
-0.43142232298851013,
-0.05848314240574837,
0.37787729501724243,
0.6956733465194702,
-0.6974314451217651,
0.7052013874053955,
0.8282026052474976,
-0.12031085789203644,
-0.352546364068985,
-0.5625248551368713,
-0.19335013628005981,
-0.4584914743900299,
0.27749359607696533,
-0.46982094645500183,
-1.0491442680358887,
0.7063696384429932,
-0.3726469874382019,
-0.01350396778434515,
-0.022177934646606445,
0.7035479545593262,
0.0353870652616024,
0.7837622165679932,
0.8129255175590515,
0.20745669305324554,
0.43981826305389404,
-0.040814828127622604,
0.30716952681541443,
-0.6651132702827454,
-0.4736630320549011,
-0.07804464548826218,
-0.1598072350025177,
-0.8456310033798218,
-0.8810990452766418,
0.8372634053230286,
0.18033269047737122,
0.2215040624141693,
-0.14990156888961792,
0.10200284421443939,
0.4800247251987457,
0.45421573519706726,
0.05548718571662903,
0.2768644690513611,
0.18034231662750244,
-0.6283429265022278,
-0.12003763765096664,
-1.0594594478607178,
-0.4171735346317291,
0.8105405569076538,
0.3513478934764862,
0.7547876834869385,
0.5243633389472961,
0.44377902150154114,
0.07408108562231064,
-0.1630626618862152,
-0.43094968795776367,
0.5686138868331909,
0.005088805221021175,
-0.2830551564693451,
-0.24200549721717834,
-0.3733040392398834,
-0.9990167021751404,
0.5477097034454346,
-0.40352028608322144,
-0.49101710319519043,
-0.1237846314907074,
0.010171418078243732,
-0.4187150299549103,
0.42149919271469116,
-0.512955367565155,
0.6256918907165527,
-0.6033000349998474,
-0.7585186958312988,
-0.13563172519207,
-0.5411017537117004,
0.16642513871192932,
-0.37920641899108887,
0.3298780918121338,
-0.18943749368190765,
-0.3803311288356781,
0.336730420589447,
0.12002222239971161,
0.9383318424224854,
-0.13480930030345917,
-0.38372132182121277,
0.24106985330581665,
0.07070606201887131,
0.5999612808227539,
0.17701172828674316,
-0.1276341825723648,
0.09227225184440613,
-0.238007590174675,
-0.5573145747184753,
-0.5653202533721924,
0.5785395503044128,
-0.6754708886146545,
-0.6960015296936035,
-0.35725072026252747,
-0.8124369382858276,
-0.5710091590881348,
0.00389794260263443,
-0.12748688459396362,
0.36695635318756104,
-0.12585490942001343,
-0.0649980679154396,
0.8764259219169617,
-0.8050802946090698,
0.49815991520881653,
0.6777749061584473,
-0.22832247614860535,
-0.3892109990119934,
0.9212522506713867,
0.08298581093549728,
0.3452772796154022,
0.535114586353302,
0.17299789190292358,
-0.6156356334686279,
-0.6245834827423096,
-0.6163535118103027,
0.6619118452072144,
-0.6315821409225464,
-0.04690171033143997,
-0.6755885481834412,
-0.019843166694045067,
-0.449914813041687,
0.03260643780231476,
-0.0855245515704155,
-0.14050772786140442,
-0.2012815922498703,
-0.15470628440380096,
0.2875252664089203,
0.5256168246269226,
-0.10791188478469849,
0.16762584447860718,
-0.7848393321037292,
0.11551361531019211,
0.3173939883708954,
0.11661987751722336,
0.16858330368995667,
-0.3434666097164154,
-0.24103006720542908,
-0.07094407826662064,
-0.3276525139808655,
-0.8219316601753235,
0.3211471140384674,
0.3255368769168854,
0.959341824054718,
-0.01463114470243454,
-0.03038642182946205,
0.589950442314148,
-0.6369316577911377,
0.7729030847549438,
0.07799551635980606,
-0.8191336393356323,
0.4990770220756531,
-0.5186962485313416,
0.4737021327018738,
0.3618655502796173,
0.654617965221405,
-0.674491822719574,
-0.2717929780483246,
-0.3715192377567291,
-1.0834455490112305,
0.5277105569839478,
-0.023894280195236206,
0.2298744171857834,
0.21298827230930328,
0.22023703157901764,
0.33749452233314514,
0.4086468815803528,
-0.8139231204986572,
-0.15392360091209412,
0.23366570472717285,
-0.162894144654274,
-0.2572818994522095,
-0.23956018686294556,
-0.08222665637731552,
-0.20928998291492462,
0.4879312813282013,
-0.415016770362854,
-0.006991383153945208,
-0.2299458533525467,
-0.29774004220962524,
0.014911411330103874,
0.22623470425605774,
0.6172744035720825,
1.1009587049484253,
0.09627711772918701,
0.14433205127716064,
0.4561392664909363,
-0.10624954104423523,
0.3139972984790802,
0.1514950543642044,
-0.07175074517726898,
0.009235995821654797,
0.5028620362281799,
0.8155516982078552,
0.120867058634758,
-0.9610556960105896,
0.2036229372024536,
-0.053482428193092346,
0.3232724368572235,
-0.266853928565979,
-0.004541704896837473,
0.28973308205604553,
0.4128052890300751,
0.41560235619544983,
-0.4647713899612427,
-0.39667004346847534,
-0.6233149766921997,
0.19330884516239166,
0.3919568657875061,
-0.05451115965843201,
-0.3139129877090454,
0.4557710587978363,
0.2544953227043152,
-0.26306402683258057,
0.30577608942985535,
-0.16410252451896667,
-0.5677466988563538,
0.3902783691883087,
0.5372868180274963,
0.5109819173812866,
-0.42374172806739807,
0.4460565149784088,
0.2046823501586914,
0.2575424909591675,
0.13389356434345245,
0.42290177941322327,
-0.01156274601817131,
-0.6824281215667725,
-0.5997831225395203,
-0.624128520488739,
-0.41908901929855347,
0.0061914315447211266,
-0.4442674517631531,
0.33291077613830566,
-0.2738935947418213,
0.06793994456529617,
-0.29514119029045105,
0.12565761804580688,
-0.4489017426967621,
-0.15427330136299133,
0.39669278264045715,
0.8335087895393372,
-0.8023712038993835,
0.6199168562889099,
0.8697046637535095,
-0.22134467959403992,
-0.5399591326713562,
0.07575765997171402,
0.14206518232822418,
-0.9998890161514282,
0.3857082426548004,
0.032259080559015274,
-0.13020822405815125,
0.14710505306720734,
-0.12207548320293427,
-1.0381673574447632,
0.996016800403595,
0.6246645450592041,
-0.5439210534095764,
-0.0854865089058876,
0.341913104057312,
0.5500413775444031,
-0.3322165012359619,
0.37768155336380005,
0.30621230602264404,
0.35319313406944275,
0.08704373240470886,
-0.9390105605125427,
-0.19282346963882446,
-0.0744381994009018,
0.018818987533450127,
0.2976800203323364,
-0.7586721181869507,
0.7824947834014893,
-0.32293590903282166,
-0.30989348888397217,
0.08289238810539246,
0.5231102705001831,
0.4324174225330353,
0.2052227407693863,
0.5561153888702393,
0.2962339222431183,
1.0722572803497314,
-0.17362608015537262,
1.0508990287780762,
-0.23874618113040924,
0.17129158973693848,
0.8383477330207825,
-0.5053945183753967,
0.6954901218414307,
0.41400936245918274,
0.005999108776450157,
0.5786976218223572,
0.8838695287704468,
0.1472800225019455,
0.48929691314697266,
0.4108866751194,
-0.6004635095596313,
-0.4803890287876129,
-0.39647600054740906,
-0.2888752222061157,
0.5021553635597229,
0.3952300250530243,
0.021794253960251808,
-0.5328221917152405,
0.3480265438556671,
0.010204882360994816,
0.44295942783355713,
-0.17167244851589203,
0.8100570440292358,
0.007910161279141903,
-0.608047604560852,
0.7262812852859497,
-0.03144530579447746,
0.7818166017532349,
-0.8307728171348572,
-0.06364599615335464,
-0.41242796182632446,
0.015501132234930992,
-0.015174700878560543,
-0.5967305302619934,
-0.07655192166566849,
0.046556469053030014,
-0.14403584599494934,
-0.38153961300849915,
0.5476377010345459,
-0.8708949685096741,
-0.6449568271636963,
0.5763002634048462,
1.0838813781738281,
-0.0015844193985685706,
0.35924649238586426,
-0.8920724987983704,
0.09255628287792206,
0.03744850680232048,
0.13451194763183594,
0.4331907331943512,
0.5588456988334656,
-0.1237957626581192,
0.8628109097480774,
0.778141438961029,
0.37444400787353516,
0.29900556802749634,
0.27268338203430176,
0.8929280638694763,
-0.4735763967037201,
-0.560331404209137,
-0.6646303534507751,
0.5123038291931152,
0.060179512947797775,
-0.14725977182388306,
0.8278026580810547,
0.5170409679412842,
1.0540070533752441,
0.008296199142932892,
0.6184237003326416,
0.2733445465564728,
0.7688829898834229,
-0.7072253823280334,
0.36141929030418396,
-0.7918330430984497,
0.4217967987060547,
-0.012346307747066021,
-0.8735522031784058,
-0.1622520238161087,
0.2739819288253784,
-0.15675070881843567,
0.08358044177293777,
0.5843374133110046,
0.8531894087791443,
-0.04360385984182358,
-0.3879363238811493,
0.4949181377887726,
0.08851832151412964,
0.48977699875831604,
0.6405330300331116,
1.1697927713394165,
-0.09557685256004333,
0.4942677617073059,
0.11808952689170837,
-0.33108094334602356,
0.05725691094994545,
-0.8521202206611633,
-0.8252027034759521,
-0.3431096076965332,
-0.2690199613571167,
-0.183124840259552,
0.31231969594955444,
0.8881561756134033,
0.5124260187149048,
-0.5132935643196106,
-0.595047116279602,
0.37346264719963074,
0.412969172000885,
-0.16258518397808075,
-0.18275175988674164,
0.17027956247329712,
-0.6538762450218201,
-0.8791781663894653,
0.6797724962234497,
0.1973462700843811,
0.0537092424929142,
-0.39455339312553406,
0.02593154087662697,
-0.47516903281211853,
-0.04706796258687973,
0.7063632607460022,
0.31730973720550537,
-0.6935523152351379,
0.19007432460784912,
0.2513186037540436,
0.14090994000434875,
0.03882142901420593,
0.8244197964668274,
-0.6986821293830872,
0.5062936544418335,
0.5380684733390808,
1.083860993385315,
0.387315034866333,
-0.0887928232550621,
0.7399413585662842,
-0.8268738985061646,
0.2105637639760971,
0.4642402231693268,
0.18017645180225372,
0.5817040801048279,
-0.2729547321796417,
0.3806381821632385,
0.38576653599739075,
-0.27196818590164185,
-0.8378515243530273,
0.3714766502380371,
-0.6441037058830261,
-0.3704868257045746,
1.3210126161575317,
-0.1826348900794983,
-0.0004924819222651422,
-0.17333918809890747,
0.03015468269586563,
0.13794782757759094,
-0.11043989658355713,
0.6955926418304443,
0.6389350295066833,
-0.2291126400232315,
-0.39094167947769165,
-0.6140849590301514,
0.3829130232334137,
0.5213027000427246,
-0.8115735650062561,
0.09868001192808151,
0.3239046633243561,
0.15606063604354858,
0.18745218217372894,
0.37173038721084595,
-0.10981152951717377,
0.09516814351081848,
-0.5353624820709229,
-0.1350739598274231,
0.012128717266023159,
-0.48806825280189514,
-0.5108187198638916,
0.1850767433643341,
0.10130061209201813,
0.04479672759771347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18358v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18358v1
|
MMCTAgent: Multi-modal Critical Thinking Agent Framework for Complex Visual Reasoning
| 2024-05-28T16:55:41 | 2024-05-28T16:55:41 |
Somnath Kumar, Yash Gadhia, Tanuja Ganu, Akshay Nambi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Recent advancements in Multi-modal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have
significantly improved their performance in tasks combining vision and
language. However, challenges persist in detailed multi-modal understanding,
comprehension of complex tasks, and reasoning over multi-modal information.
This paper introduces MMCTAgent, a novel multi-modal critical thinking agent
framework designed to address the inherent limitations of current MLLMs in
complex visual reasoning tasks. Inspired by human cognitive processes and
critical thinking, MMCTAgent iteratively analyzes multi-modal information,
decomposes queries, plans strategies, and dynamically evolves its reasoning.
Additionally, MMCTAgent incorporates critical thinking elements such as
verification of final answers and self-reflection through a novel approach that
defines a vision-based critic and identifies task-specific evaluation criteria,
thereby enhancing its decision-making abilities. Through rigorous evaluations
across various image and video understanding benchmarks, we demonstrate that
MMCTAgent (with and without the critic) outperforms both foundational MLLMs and
other tool-augmented pipelines.
|
[
-0.6679074168205261,
-0.8351933360099792,
0.7546911835670471,
0.03626347705721855,
-0.20117565989494324,
0.33421021699905396,
-0.23927034437656403,
-0.36208492517471313,
0.0023513163905590773,
0.2934107780456543,
-0.8104052543640137,
-0.17580369114875793,
-0.4345897138118744,
0.18088416755199432,
0.04557611420750618,
0.47096991539001465,
0.10083061456680298,
0.25724831223487854,
-0.18769784271717072,
-0.34489086270332336,
-0.3915242552757263,
-0.40152791142463684,
-0.36937516927719116,
-0.11869531869888306,
0.43001890182495117,
0.23347772657871246,
0.8120096921920776,
0.1874292939901352,
0.6945858597755432,
0.4673665463924408,
0.2611803412437439,
0.7073211669921875,
-0.40197157859802246,
0.22868943214416504,
-0.2600041925907135,
-0.24792224168777466,
-0.3433164060115814,
-0.0693405494093895,
0.43204066157341003,
0.3527079224586487,
-0.10902596265077591,
0.2772824466228485,
-0.04703059792518616,
0.531534731388092,
-1.1520968675613403,
0.29469382762908936,
-0.5048829317092896,
0.2797134220600128,
0.28525546193122864,
-0.3016732931137085,
-0.5583251118659973,
0.0966174378991127,
0.1914040744304657,
-0.5968986749649048,
0.129338338971138,
-0.1880427598953247,
0.32324478030204773,
0.6652168035507202,
-0.37970399856567383,
-0.10375522822141647,
-0.766681432723999,
0.7822698950767517,
-0.2006659209728241,
0.612806499004364,
-0.11836753785610199,
0.7337687015533447,
0.011935161426663399,
-0.5329566597938538,
-0.6287805438041687,
-0.4491874873638153,
0.3638150095939636,
0.4301973879337311,
-0.052297770977020264,
0.08583830296993256,
0.15996643900871277,
0.0018904845928773284,
-0.36963164806365967,
-0.38115426898002625,
-0.17558719217777252,
-0.441727876663208,
0.27429482340812683,
0.5612794756889343,
-0.05409098416566849,
-0.2511483132839203,
-0.7559804320335388,
-0.034012261778116226,
-0.03848573565483093,
0.4211125671863556,
0.005141106899827719,
0.11454378813505173,
0.17249928414821625,
0.5265610814094543,
-0.2811667323112488,
0.5980494618415833,
-0.20799671113491058,
-0.2751423418521881,
0.3130238354206085,
-0.30053257942199707,
-0.5322632789611816,
-0.24239304661750793,
0.6545310616493225,
0.5706046223640442,
0.1293492466211319,
0.39452245831489563,
-0.2908772826194763,
0.19133681058883667,
0.3476509153842926,
-0.6214959025382996,
-0.25717785954475403,
0.2589324712753296,
-0.5334905982017517,
-0.5242254734039307,
0.050367891788482666,
-0.6316901445388794,
-0.631045401096344,
-0.49191614985466003,
0.47286099195480347,
-0.43544456362724304,
-0.522491991519928,
0.3165173828601837,
-0.33555707335472107,
0.11296138912439346,
0.8147704601287842,
-0.33370110392570496,
-0.17988763749599457,
0.4524947702884674,
0.6518259048461914,
0.04831165820360184,
-0.6089707612991333,
-0.4726596474647522,
0.12755271792411804,
-0.39969193935394287,
1.003721833229065,
-0.6885042190551758,
-0.15781651437282562,
0.03413786739110947,
-0.0752686932682991,
-0.16911286115646362,
-0.39558207988739014,
0.4409664273262024,
-0.35427621006965637,
0.0032420572824776173,
-0.38117605447769165,
-0.05850762873888016,
-0.48670417070388794,
0.9355644583702087,
-0.8663631081581116,
0.39118799567222595,
-0.16614338755607605,
-0.4820220470428467,
0.5663870573043823,
-0.703123152256012,
-0.17003901302814484,
0.1296999305486679,
-0.4537542760372162,
-0.18864430487155914,
-0.05996467173099518,
0.2869209051132202,
0.5778445601463318,
-0.43613171577453613,
0.10627191513776779,
-0.6573929786682129,
-0.17708347737789154,
0.5252509117126465,
-0.7050970196723938,
0.785038411617279,
0.27855733036994934,
-0.3605193793773651,
0.5920610427856445,
-0.5198110938072205,
0.15399757027626038,
0.15678219497203827,
-0.35574600100517273,
0.10015932470560074,
-0.02039235457777977,
0.12401989847421646,
0.3305304944515228,
0.003997082356363535,
-0.3475673794746399,
0.015979189425706863,
0.24898944795131683,
0.41871169209480286,
1.0372238159179688,
-0.04134560748934746,
0.2257867306470871,
-0.36777186393737793,
0.39140942692756653,
0.10217619687318802,
0.6184217929840088,
-0.17140580713748932,
-0.32440802454948425,
-0.9039403200149536,
-0.5640631914138794,
-0.322881817817688,
0.6203184127807617,
-1.1971776485443115,
-0.17276550829410553,
-0.009668422862887383,
-0.42036712169647217,
-0.48605719208717346,
0.03764883428812027,
0.4859776198863983,
0.2882632613182068,
0.36037757992744446,
-0.02613450400531292,
-0.38107210397720337,
-0.8583947420120239,
0.014771271497011185,
-0.07961877435445786,
0.23958326876163483,
0.5851148962974548,
0.6181095838546753,
-0.6024550795555115,
0.37326478958129883,
-0.6538981795310974,
-0.524850606918335,
-0.4188432991504669,
0.040189675986766815,
-0.0672401487827301,
0.19294269382953644,
0.3963155150413513,
-0.8694074749946594,
-0.11664046347141266,
-0.03614140301942825,
-0.8640955686569214,
0.2325710952281952,
-0.6293599009513855,
-0.05589650198817253,
0.04645799845457077,
0.6131711006164551,
-0.6298863291740417,
0.1356993317604065,
0.3856911063194275,
-0.5345418453216553,
1.1708886623382568,
-0.11562193185091019,
0.44922494888305664,
-0.7434282898902893,
-0.05743130296468735,
-0.01937721110880375,
-0.2719113528728485,
-0.3497062027454376,
0.27667421102523804,
-0.06704197824001312,
0.06908117234706879,
-0.5049758553504944,
0.13722793757915497,
-0.49529123306274414,
0.28459152579307556,
-0.010839126072824001,
-0.04736693203449249,
0.07830455899238586,
0.7329830527305603,
-0.13489045202732086,
0.7684076428413391,
0.5738062262535095,
-0.44539952278137207,
0.727437436580658,
0.02848288044333458,
-0.4172717332839966,
0.7272841930389404,
-0.30615752935409546,
-0.1049077957868576,
-0.1996944397687912,
-0.011525627225637436,
-0.7893216013908386,
0.01020703837275505,
0.34975776076316833,
-0.2554486393928528,
-0.04835892468690872,
-0.05292372405529022,
-0.30197176337242126,
-0.3336075246334076,
-0.31217071413993835,
0.39992424845695496,
-0.05668763071298599,
-0.40735381841659546,
1.0969713926315308,
0.3986548185348511,
0.32957789301872253,
-0.8673601150512695,
-0.34512636065483093,
0.35976335406303406,
0.1212841272354126,
-0.4917124807834625,
-0.24926842749118805,
-0.5006403923034668,
-0.4474547803401947,
-0.0783143937587738,
-0.04026878997683525,
-0.24000567197799683,
0.011222537606954575,
0.15361936390399933,
0.344115674495697,
-0.25993603467941284,
0.0600157156586647,
-0.21125133335590363,
-0.14349906146526337,
0.21859799325466156,
-0.19707094132900238,
0.2793750762939453,
-0.7459623217582703,
-0.5710614323616028,
-0.1675064116716385,
0.43898850679397583,
1.1024142503738403,
-0.47477108240127563,
0.1882471740245819,
0.9077314734458923,
-0.10195781290531158,
-0.43099260330200195,
-0.8008028268814087,
-0.13913953304290771,
-0.46572408080101013,
0.5358874797821045,
-0.9312136769294739,
-0.7793897986412048,
0.2931217551231384,
-0.1970461755990982,
-0.08639983832836151,
0.12229785323143005,
1.015268325805664,
-0.2509038746356964,
1.2327566146850586,
0.47875192761421204,
0.3096996247768402,
0.33578893542289734,
-0.671480119228363,
-0.09273932874202728,
-0.6758516430854797,
-0.4735702574253082,
0.19802077114582062,
-0.14006806910037994,
-0.026469636708498,
-0.8360388278961182,
0.4784093201160431,
-0.48618224263191223,
-0.14479416608810425,
-0.09159189462661743,
-0.4767613708972931,
0.6487561464309692,
0.3863506019115448,
0.31076517701148987,
0.3066316246986389,
-0.4740614593029022,
-0.5235809087753296,
0.21084803342819214,
-0.40160706639289856,
-0.3954908549785614,
0.7897571921348572,
0.23122389614582062,
0.638640284538269,
0.4446796774864197,
-0.09667156636714935,
0.48078659176826477,
0.025282762944698334,
-1.043112874031067,
0.8095880746841431,
0.15111464262008667,
-0.6644613146781921,
-0.19062690436840057,
-0.24945712089538574,
-0.4726390838623047,
0.9485923051834106,
-0.5544121861457825,
-0.11367692053318024,
0.1979084610939026,
-0.10963575541973114,
-0.39752197265625,
0.45401880145072937,
-0.691159188747406,
0.8150826096534729,
-0.20442356169223785,
-0.45654982328414917,
-0.5988406538963318,
-0.5908169150352478,
0.44608548283576965,
0.25202155113220215,
0.24259789288043976,
-0.25238072872161865,
-0.17090247571468353,
0.17340393364429474,
-0.2720153033733368,
0.7393860816955566,
-0.19075530767440796,
0.2977178394794464,
0.6260350346565247,
0.5606195330619812,
0.005520456936210394,
0.16405867040157318,
0.37699657678604126,
0.062445688992738724,
0.01211326103657484,
-0.321072518825531,
-0.5961141586303711,
0.37310686707496643,
-0.5905900001525879,
-0.6845335364341736,
-0.3329519033432007,
-0.7368115186691284,
-0.2548997700214386,
0.39152631163597107,
-0.05819808319211006,
0.6192991137504578,
-0.29568085074424744,
0.16406284272670746,
0.6169813871383667,
0.43603575229644775,
0.517675518989563,
0.33340421319007874,
0.06909309327602386,
-0.6325035691261292,
0.7427786588668823,
-0.13032440841197968,
0.1625790297985077,
0.26092496514320374,
0.22028371691703796,
-0.0909513533115387,
-0.4194915294647217,
-0.6652532815933228,
-0.1008928045630455,
-0.9094651937484741,
-0.17398937046527863,
-0.6170353293418884,
0.05681510642170906,
0.1330808401107788,
-0.17620255053043365,
-0.40959981083869934,
-0.09578412771224976,
0.01337374746799469,
0.04047471657395363,
-0.4142936170101166,
0.5632120966911316,
-0.08417847752571106,
-0.30844634771347046,
-0.6728400588035583,
0.32493042945861816,
0.7898477911949158,
0.24294543266296387,
0.1768016219139099,
0.08017680048942566,
-0.10526925325393677,
-0.11222458630800247,
-0.2954322099685669,
-0.7904377579689026,
-0.05212871730327606,
0.0016799709992483258,
0.6812236309051514,
0.8754664063453674,
-0.03767053037881851,
0.7136995196342468,
-0.4285474121570587,
0.5254685878753662,
0.40774837136268616,
-0.7942691445350647,
0.40883344411849976,
-0.3175639510154724,
0.3113071620464325,
0.4769222140312195,
0.08210752159357071,
-0.11169502884149551,
-0.4370869994163513,
-0.1893552541732788,
-0.2963179349899292,
0.14289797842502594,
0.07970993965864182,
-0.1980198323726654,
0.17454014718532562,
-0.17544540762901306,
0.1357855498790741,
0.16704417765140533,
-0.6397591829299927,
0.19330565631389618,
-0.37959280610084534,
0.07381439208984375,
-0.08082150667905807,
-0.22289830446243286,
-0.4087170660495758,
-0.3825945556163788,
0.3227959871292114,
-0.5510019063949585,
0.1720464676618576,
0.6170395016670227,
-0.5751282572746277,
-0.03487442061305046,
0.2552178204059601,
0.8495413064956665,
0.6381234526634216,
-0.22227279841899872,
0.4403931200504303,
0.31172940135002136,
-0.5485199689865112,
0.17096136510372162,
-0.17940233647823334,
0.2878856062889099,
-0.21458172798156738,
0.5559738874435425,
0.3259662687778473,
0.010512781329452991,
-1.0428152084350586,
0.7845067381858826,
-0.287910133600235,
-0.34434568881988525,
-0.37452462315559387,
0.0904398038983345,
-0.20663350820541382,
0.8772578835487366,
0.19826659560203552,
0.8974196314811707,
0.5699967741966248,
-0.43698689341545105,
0.24901577830314636,
0.41556188464164734,
-0.7686098217964172,
-0.20876361429691315,
0.5619340538978577,
0.2911302149295807,
0.14960066974163055,
0.36366990208625793,
-0.13292625546455383,
-0.6408496499061584,
0.5196011066436768,
0.16205307841300964,
0.9713296890258789,
-0.07875511795282364,
0.42432522773742676,
0.1986517608165741,
0.6041335463523865,
0.24459053575992584,
0.542523980140686,
-0.4363786280155182,
-0.9578564167022705,
-0.5115976929664612,
-0.12500153481960297,
-0.5452709794044495,
-0.2252897024154663,
-0.30366161465644836,
0.024833982810378075,
-0.8608761429786682,
-0.41159072518348694,
0.19576552510261536,
-0.17791439592838287,
-0.6912253499031067,
0.18868371844291687,
0.36360734701156616,
0.7954276204109192,
-0.7035830020904541,
0.4418482780456543,
0.840449333190918,
-0.7329624891281128,
-0.45978501439094543,
-0.16024117171764374,
0.33874204754829407,
-0.8365519642829895,
0.5247814655303955,
0.36521974205970764,
-0.9482887983322144,
-0.40109848976135254,
-0.4157380759716034,
-0.4734186828136444,
0.9439213275909424,
0.3746405243873596,
-0.2058992087841034,
0.30234238505363464,
-0.18496528267860413,
0.31006982922554016,
-0.48678916692733765,
0.3073348104953766,
0.2951110601425171,
0.46741801500320435,
0.36868816614151,
-0.7505097389221191,
0.25827157497406006,
-0.5708461403846741,
-0.37106895446777344,
0.046125512570142746,
-0.7278028726577759,
0.9334527254104614,
-0.9336283802986145,
-0.029949594289064407,
-0.26426631212234497,
0.3261905908584595,
-0.010988821275532246,
0.25776153802871704,
0.8298420310020447,
0.5259922742843628,
0.5423164367675781,
0.13289466500282288,
0.7175478339195251,
0.05496974661946297,
0.2512817978858948,
0.8828470706939697,
0.0033303191885352135,
0.7067804932594299,
0.40200185775756836,
0.14935654401779175,
0.6354827880859375,
0.30219566822052,
-0.3079933524131775,
0.4720446765422821,
-0.37779706716537476,
-0.372244268655777,
-0.902290403842926,
-0.19650384783744812,
-0.11208692938089371,
0.8077304363250732,
0.2687922716140747,
-0.1530168354511261,
-0.04942513257265091,
0.19387660920619965,
-0.20729659497737885,
0.024533316493034363,
-0.39737340807914734,
0.8390169739723206,
-0.14997731149196625,
-0.438932865858078,
0.6236436367034912,
-0.36401867866516113,
0.2579386830329895,
-0.12681373953819275,
-0.12092326581478119,
0.3550153970718384,
0.6213934421539307,
-0.2067294865846634,
-1.0861375331878662,
0.12310845404863358,
-0.42646968364715576,
-0.23433661460876465,
-0.0744631439447403,
0.5972782969474792,
-0.04082483425736427,
-0.3381901681423187,
0.23754438757896423,
0.8231381177902222,
-0.2833804488182068,
-0.3635299503803253,
-1.1147491931915283,
0.08192093670368195,
-0.04820084944367409,
-0.027535762637853622,
-0.275836318731308,
0.46736493706703186,
0.15852494537830353,
1.0929229259490967,
0.8695200085639954,
-0.14765647053718567,
-0.14175879955291748,
0.45632439851760864,
0.9978110790252686,
-0.6353139877319336,
-0.4246954619884491,
-1.0146020650863647,
0.7225145697593689,
-0.21512314677238464,
-0.24936209619045258,
0.2964334189891815,
0.568697988986969,
0.5897535085678101,
-0.3370440602302551,
0.6723470687866211,
0.21737156808376312,
0.04071127250790596,
-0.3723452687263489,
0.7438796758651733,
-0.5484036207199097,
-0.05421397089958191,
-0.1772460788488388,
-0.7372326850891113,
-0.3740490972995758,
0.6454907655715942,
-0.1223457083106041,
-0.24308989942073822,
0.8432902693748474,
0.6658979058265686,
-0.048420876264572144,
-0.04125320166349411,
0.5448676347732544,
0.24423471093177795,
0.5836053490638733,
0.7393593788146973,
1.2022781372070312,
-0.00438743457198143,
0.9366723299026489,
-0.10517147928476334,
-0.5672633051872253,
-0.2919405698776245,
-0.5486367344856262,
-1.2000486850738525,
-0.8812164068222046,
0.08596592396497726,
-0.29536890983581543,
-0.19786161184310913,
1.1363834142684937,
0.780143678188324,
-0.46191102266311646,
-0.24046078324317932,
0.1657884567975998,
0.2510315775871277,
-0.43041905760765076,
-0.24077115952968597,
-0.025264309719204903,
-0.3879796266555786,
-0.43335720896720886,
0.3204892575740814,
0.7333436608314514,
-0.18245235085487366,
-0.611164391040802,
-0.042634762823581696,
-0.17221049964427948,
0.3087456226348877,
1.0417131185531616,
-0.1701948344707489,
-0.9401087760925293,
-0.3400118947029114,
0.06095153093338013,
-0.26886284351348877,
0.04946071654558182,
0.8784824013710022,
-0.7086431384086609,
1.0242571830749512,
0.3855019211769104,
0.42205777764320374,
0.24103084206581116,
-0.4244595468044281,
0.3755914866924286,
0.030366690829396248,
0.30525997281074524,
0.51680588722229,
0.5622050166130066,
0.12953083217144012,
-0.1527547985315323,
0.42147889733314514,
0.36881813406944275,
-0.2875083088874817,
-0.5829466581344604,
0.6121887564659119,
-1.214545726776123,
-0.5640576481819153,
0.8522721529006958,
0.19741827249526978,
-0.26470133662223816,
-0.1348143368959427,
-0.703608512878418,
-0.16726556420326233,
-0.36059996485710144,
0.8465378284454346,
0.5071383118629456,
-0.1965811550617218,
-0.5223188400268555,
-0.449796587228775,
0.3775124251842499,
0.20123516023159027,
-0.5637977719306946,
0.027892738580703735,
0.7374292016029358,
0.14841967821121216,
0.28164559602737427,
0.4032389521598816,
0.0652182474732399,
0.6316507458686829,
0.34945571422576904,
-0.06873754411935806,
-0.5847887992858887,
-0.6982641816139221,
0.06089840084314346,
0.6283270120620728,
-0.12212026864290237,
-0.3077020049095154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18357v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18357v2
|
Faithful Logical Reasoning via Symbolic Chain-of-Thought
| 2024-05-28T16:55:33 | 2024-06-11T07:41:03 |
Jundong Xu, Hao Fei, Liangming Pan, Qian Liu, Mong-Li Lee, Wynne Hsu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While the recent Chain-of-Thought (CoT) technique enhances the reasoning
ability of large language models (LLMs) with the theory of mind, it might still
struggle in handling logical reasoning that relies much on symbolic expressions
and rigid deducing rules. To strengthen the logical reasoning capability of
LLMs, we propose a novel Symbolic Chain-of-Thought, namely SymbCoT, a fully
LLM-based framework that integrates symbolic expressions and logic rules with
CoT prompting. Technically, building upon an LLM, SymbCoT 1) first translates
the natural language context into the symbolic format, and then 2) derives a
step-by-step plan to solve the problem with symbolic logical rules, 3) followed
by a verifier to check the translation and reasoning chain. Via thorough
evaluations on 5 standard datasets with both First-Order Logic and Constraint
Optimization symbolic expressions, SymbCoT shows striking improvements over the
CoT method consistently, meanwhile refreshing the current state-of-the-art
performances. We further demonstrate that our system advances in more faithful,
flexible, and explainable logical reasoning. To our knowledge, this is the
first to combine symbolic expressions and rules into CoT for logical reasoning
with LLMs. Code is open at https://github.com/Aiden0526/SymbCoT.
|
[
-0.19498950242996216,
-0.7725529074668884,
1.0368491411209106,
0.0976235419511795,
-0.6732804179191589,
0.3351580798625946,
-0.00038114149356260896,
-0.4351244866847992,
0.26982730627059937,
0.7014796137809753,
-0.7807823419570923,
-0.5104784369468689,
-0.6228576302528381,
0.3639313876628876,
-0.2907654047012329,
0.8515938520431519,
-0.25523650646209717,
0.12345919758081436,
-0.12463017553091049,
-0.15242338180541992,
-0.49553799629211426,
-0.5321033596992493,
-0.3838385343551636,
-0.3130987584590912,
0.268219918012619,
-0.05859685316681862,
0.7736185193061829,
0.6537376046180725,
0.5698449611663818,
0.23743906617164612,
-0.028926225379109383,
0.7525162100791931,
-0.45522695779800415,
0.35872533917427063,
-0.6354414224624634,
-0.5578490495681763,
-0.5052345991134644,
-0.36529406905174255,
0.5541977286338806,
0.2874915301799774,
-0.27227523922920227,
0.08034536242485046,
-0.16388140618801117,
0.4748552739620209,
-0.6403289437294006,
0.32420286536216736,
-0.9790570735931396,
-0.18654657900333405,
0.02218596264719963,
-0.17385295033454895,
-0.6488372087478638,
-0.3633129298686981,
-0.34782320261001587,
-0.4533715546131134,
-0.32761088013648987,
0.3079003691673279,
0.6299425363540649,
0.32247307896614075,
-0.46917134523391724,
-0.050238873809576035,
-0.5676919221878052,
0.7255373001098633,
-0.5937219858169556,
0.6082659959793091,
0.21072623133659363,
0.47662585973739624,
-0.5034335851669312,
-0.8061994910240173,
-0.6893560290336609,
-0.18169847130775452,
-0.11867108196020126,
-0.04761383682489395,
-0.2568935453891754,
0.1146298497915268,
0.5148226022720337,
0.1137998104095459,
-0.30958572030067444,
-0.4852277636528015,
-0.17730021476745605,
-0.12365113198757172,
0.46969786286354065,
0.29471227526664734,
0.303048700094223,
0.05641580745577812,
-0.650935709476471,
0.18041777610778809,
-0.8880617618560791,
-0.32704856991767883,
-0.13211794197559357,
0.08651161938905716,
-0.046884000301361084,
0.5716108083724976,
-0.1325211375951767,
0.7335566282272339,
-0.2708684504032135,
-0.040624022483825684,
-0.1742805391550064,
-0.23358610272407532,
-0.37059053778648376,
0.3384895920753479,
0.6976118683815002,
0.1661655306816101,
0.40146467089653015,
-0.011512122116982937,
-0.5048213005065918,
0.7749658823013306,
0.2548834979534149,
-0.5514897108078003,
-0.1865548938512802,
0.09590587764978409,
-0.14863218367099762,
-0.22469094395637512,
0.25077590346336365,
-0.2493574172258377,
-0.315407931804657,
-0.44938796758651733,
0.2766724228858948,
-0.57738196849823,
-0.13218934834003448,
0.6013137698173523,
-0.044493626803159714,
0.11761245131492615,
0.596202552318573,
-0.3800605237483978,
0.7356221079826355,
0.9916777014732361,
0.7601176500320435,
0.0378645621240139,
-0.1255646049976349,
-0.5569690465927124,
0.5440102219581604,
-0.3980928063392639,
0.8858685493469238,
-0.5797361135482788,
-0.07852035760879517,
-0.41041481494903564,
-0.059390101581811905,
0.1866931915283203,
-0.23922288417816162,
0.2829686105251312,
-0.359939306974411,
0.005951256025582552,
-0.40052273869514465,
-0.3647172749042511,
0.042185958474874496,
0.3484981060028076,
-0.5493831634521484,
0.7681353092193604,
0.07878488302230835,
-0.7276073098182678,
0.18227706849575043,
-0.2848682701587677,
-0.507823646068573,
0.08829013258218765,
-0.5551558136940002,
-0.018999019637703896,
0.08921617269515991,
0.16737471520900726,
0.09303511679172516,
-0.7095230221748352,
0.5568133592605591,
-0.5714120268821716,
-0.24193988740444183,
0.3845742344856262,
-0.347452312707901,
1.054682731628418,
0.29833999276161194,
-0.29908275604248047,
0.035916347056627274,
-0.3708985149860382,
0.1697695255279541,
0.16489161550998688,
0.3096492290496826,
-0.19627757370471954,
0.13880100846290588,
-0.5613757371902466,
0.5023115873336792,
0.14048171043395996,
-0.4887232184410095,
0.40785080194473267,
-0.2915806770324707,
0.5952610373497009,
1.1029146909713745,
0.014222747646272182,
0.08235641568899155,
-0.4540019929409027,
0.5128418207168579,
0.0236942321062088,
0.36770448088645935,
-0.05020177736878395,
-0.5622652769088745,
-0.5399569869041443,
-0.4006103277206421,
-0.09663432836532593,
0.32289034128189087,
-0.8778240084648132,
0.4111439287662506,
-0.13598975539207458,
-0.23866905272006989,
-0.4634583294391632,
0.11619261652231216,
0.49741002917289734,
0.46868208050727844,
0.4731927812099457,
-0.21808898448944092,
-0.6512192487716675,
-0.6875077486038208,
-0.2710005044937134,
-0.6561592817306519,
0.29187580943107605,
-0.07996153831481934,
0.5633636713027954,
-0.22134581208229065,
0.9117733836174011,
-0.7014238834381104,
0.024295158684253693,
-0.5019409656524658,
-0.405050128698349,
0.4792546033859253,
0.3009268045425415,
0.10561926662921906,
-0.29990944266319275,
-0.012482945807278156,
0.1511068195104599,
-0.7430475950241089,
-0.2996748983860016,
-0.0815008133649826,
-0.700233519077301,
0.14870770275592804,
0.20745913684368134,
-1.0380439758300781,
0.4467885494232178,
0.08464407920837402,
-0.6461355686187744,
0.8193386197090149,
-0.03783724457025528,
-0.0688580572605133,
-1.0513712167739868,
-0.11996160447597504,
-0.4176528751850128,
-0.507716715335846,
-0.29447147250175476,
0.23537437617778778,
0.15011566877365112,
0.13015180826187134,
-0.4139900803565979,
0.5439311861991882,
-0.28065183758735657,
0.1843135952949524,
-0.13021405041217804,
0.22147788107395172,
0.15759865939617157,
0.4290911853313446,
-0.0912809669971466,
0.44153037667274475,
0.5471967458724976,
-0.4611060917377472,
0.5038348436355591,
0.2658117711544037,
-0.09956207871437073,
0.5040296316146851,
-0.4756477177143097,
0.07246900349855423,
-0.14836479723453522,
0.6769053339958191,
-0.8330285549163818,
0.0897376537322998,
0.5175620913505554,
-0.10690581798553467,
-0.10822710394859314,
0.10382739454507828,
-0.8078031539916992,
-0.4702119529247284,
-0.15776392817497253,
0.4242812693119049,
0.4980553686618805,
-0.497896283864975,
0.7842534184455872,
0.2633264660835266,
0.16859810054302216,
-0.3430103361606598,
-0.6171811819076538,
0.06833603233098984,
0.042528584599494934,
-0.43852418661117554,
0.26761525869369507,
0.17420382797718048,
-0.43459606170654297,
-0.04116019234061241,
-0.7782066464424133,
0.08071662485599518,
-0.04772325977683067,
0.014056379906833172,
0.536213755607605,
-0.1126166433095932,
0.29122859239578247,
0.4216417372226715,
-0.11350248754024506,
0.5144215226173401,
-0.7488285899162292,
0.5445446968078613,
-0.4064701795578003,
-0.4940025508403778,
-0.44607993960380554,
0.1292000412940979,
0.6228449940681458,
-0.38688409328460693,
0.48213014006614685,
0.03409598395228386,
-0.529748797416687,
-0.6463543772697449,
-0.4585171043872833,
-0.4412387013435364,
-0.44329842925071716,
-0.021774129942059517,
-0.47231948375701904,
-0.6457928419113159,
0.2078007012605667,
-0.2881842255592346,
-0.1353934109210968,
0.2579325735569,
0.39690646529197693,
-0.02812327817082405,
1.082464337348938,
0.32174152135849,
0.06196654587984085,
-0.08269912004470825,
-0.12961134314537048,
0.375081866979599,
-0.5615521669387817,
-0.37066444754600525,
-0.2872103452682495,
-0.28536075353622437,
-0.4759214222431183,
-0.5478548407554626,
0.13213223218917847,
0.20755727589130402,
-0.5333192944526672,
0.6195799112319946,
-0.48390406370162964,
0.593810498714447,
0.1315484493970871,
0.5104377269744873,
0.5254530310630798,
-0.1400410234928131,
-0.6141507029533386,
0.4304141700267792,
-0.7136853337287903,
-0.6694876551628113,
0.6278319358825684,
0.17423619329929352,
1.0460299253463745,
0.3081231415271759,
0.6788331270217896,
0.157610222697258,
0.3754626214504242,
-0.5372570753097534,
1.0754395723342896,
-0.043257955461740494,
-0.44200801849365234,
-0.012833242304623127,
-0.5686066746711731,
-0.5356658697128296,
0.2476784586906433,
-0.21521523594856262,
-1.0045185089111328,
-0.1226554811000824,
0.30748122930526733,
-0.1120195984840393,
0.4463537931442261,
-0.5274195075035095,
0.5500936508178711,
-0.5902500152587891,
-0.49087658524513245,
-0.423226922750473,
-0.7012484669685364,
0.40414950251579285,
-0.0676691085100174,
-0.020569533109664917,
-0.19604800641536713,
-0.19515575468540192,
0.47362667322158813,
-0.8293174505233765,
0.6323962211608887,
0.13668930530548096,
-0.27451425790786743,
0.4714732766151428,
0.6109265685081482,
0.7284319996833801,
0.17389240860939026,
0.07708818465471268,
0.15684807300567627,
0.23230017721652985,
-0.2728792726993561,
-1.1323050260543823,
0.5342527627944946,
-0.37530717253685,
-1.0614924430847168,
-0.4687756896018982,
-0.6097669005393982,
-0.36674803495407104,
0.43572622537612915,
-0.31756386160850525,
0.31545326113700867,
0.2687355875968933,
-0.05835649371147156,
0.519855797290802,
0.11338593810796738,
-0.11181945353746414,
0.08373713493347168,
-0.7314476370811462,
-0.7562467455863953,
0.5631482601165771,
-0.29344215989112854,
0.5852673053741455,
0.5022451877593994,
0.38181790709495544,
-0.4344013035297394,
0.06155019998550415,
-0.28465840220451355,
0.5139045715332031,
-0.8030788898468018,
-0.41454944014549255,
-0.5934979319572449,
-0.23384703695774078,
-0.2231454998254776,
-0.09778743237257004,
-0.1506514549255371,
-0.6734166145324707,
0.35366836190223694,
-0.17311735451221466,
0.4835008382797241,
0.6151725053787231,
0.46359553933143616,
0.1871732622385025,
-0.5086175203323364,
0.4652899503707886,
0.10064733028411865,
0.39374110102653503,
-0.08033149689435959,
-0.08858373016119003,
0.09309693425893784,
0.24363267421722412,
-0.530213475227356,
-1.0260009765625,
0.10270828753709793,
-0.2960059642791748,
0.5079342722892761,
0.5292529463768005,
0.15139441192150116,
0.9379215240478516,
-0.44364431500434875,
0.30793941020965576,
0.5261377692222595,
-1.1144503355026245,
0.7606967091560364,
-0.14985160529613495,
0.41226813197135925,
0.2535286545753479,
0.20236548781394958,
-0.3147977888584137,
-0.7552505135536194,
-0.7557343244552612,
-0.437756210565567,
0.5373110771179199,
0.5278538465499878,
-0.3123266398906708,
-0.330748975276947,
0.11495078355073929,
0.12036393582820892,
0.27032187581062317,
-0.6466042995452881,
0.05663764849305153,
0.015579083934426308,
-0.3255969285964966,
0.2989346385002136,
0.11019369214773178,
-0.10558431595563889,
-0.4966706931591034,
0.6115055084228516,
-0.123537577688694,
0.31761714816093445,
0.22002744674682617,
-0.11382269859313965,
-0.06699660420417786,
0.11026404052972794,
0.3396123945713043,
0.7850095629692078,
-0.13228042423725128,
0.6848801374435425,
0.3265264928340912,
-0.38042211532592773,
0.2900506258010864,
-0.19142785668373108,
0.05783465877175331,
-0.05388433486223221,
0.49084484577178955,
0.6973061561584473,
0.04123137891292572,
-0.7380349636077881,
0.2303190678358078,
0.11953539401292801,
-0.08900628983974457,
0.1370701789855957,
0.29802966117858887,
-0.05381331592798233,
0.2677902579307556,
-0.13790616393089294,
0.07166007906198502,
-0.17507199943065643,
-0.5759514570236206,
0.39155441522598267,
0.4518231153488159,
-0.2781592011451721,
-0.20250394940376282,
0.6767687797546387,
-0.028103146702051163,
-0.17155975103378296,
0.5191487669944763,
0.08753752708435059,
-0.7331373691558838,
0.5326359868049622,
1.0663620233535767,
0.9628511667251587,
-0.09831888228654861,
0.15793147683143616,
-0.04457468166947365,
0.6251315474510193,
-0.23262840509414673,
0.7426520586013794,
-0.5198253393173218,
-0.5981865525245667,
-0.4524335265159607,
-0.5372037291526794,
-0.2822740375995636,
-0.4052600860595703,
-0.16938582062721252,
0.6121925115585327,
-0.8886526226997375,
-0.29205745458602905,
-0.45830637216567993,
-0.30789801478385925,
-0.4122615456581116,
0.10720528662204742,
0.10606797784566879,
1.144686222076416,
-0.5139806866645813,
0.981852114200592,
0.6527435779571533,
-0.18517068028450012,
-0.8361318707466125,
0.003984830807894468,
-0.07938655465841293,
-0.7758331894874573,
0.6027675271034241,
0.39465609192848206,
-0.7862798571586609,
-0.02964060753583908,
-0.434530109167099,
-0.5799591541290283,
1.1649789810180664,
0.8162562251091003,
-0.7089095711708069,
0.004725147504359484,
0.26846131682395935,
0.4526731073856354,
-0.3800300657749176,
0.2668130099773407,
0.347603440284729,
0.3397505581378937,
0.2484571486711502,
-0.6515607833862305,
0.6085066199302673,
-0.16733233630657196,
-0.04931259527802467,
0.8246407508850098,
-0.5624138712882996,
0.5146030187606812,
-0.3615328073501587,
-0.374482125043869,
-0.020058657974004745,
0.5808137655258179,
0.7829570174217224,
0.3399556279182434,
0.5831292271614075,
0.803293764591217,
0.8486707806587219,
-0.11960367113351822,
0.9612563252449036,
-0.4229932129383087,
0.2534674108028412,
1.1353555917739868,
-0.60616534948349,
0.6818835735321045,
0.6961509585380554,
-0.133571594953537,
0.8993169069290161,
0.20622427761554718,
0.29874396324157715,
0.36400020122528076,
0.41652345657348633,
-0.4532583951950073,
-0.6728372573852539,
-0.2119438499212265,
-0.31954818964004517,
0.11830823123455048,
0.33267301321029663,
-0.3413834273815155,
-0.3459310829639435,
-0.34400099515914917,
0.016900887712836266,
0.024364078417420387,
-0.243317648768425,
0.4419063329696655,
0.5363994836807251,
-0.6477662324905396,
0.5740593671798706,
-0.21066482365131378,
-0.09528079628944397,
-0.7091813087463379,
-0.35873839259147644,
0.007649765815585852,
0.2485181838274002,
-0.1262931227684021,
-0.8825953602790833,
0.2501484751701355,
0.08528199046850204,
0.2750580310821533,
-0.47847893834114075,
0.8937925696372986,
-0.08432890474796295,
-0.6522305607795715,
0.37526267766952515,
0.4606965184211731,
-0.06573981046676636,
0.19526398181915283,
-0.4055805206298828,
0.15102878212928772,
-0.2067328244447708,
0.2660125494003296,
-0.18056383728981018,
0.8556936383247375,
-0.4957432150840759,
1.0087250471115112,
0.7745909094810486,
0.27204352617263794,
-0.3339402973651886,
0.04241843521595001,
1.1319923400878906,
-0.8296805620193481,
-0.6131927371025085,
-1.3512245416641235,
0.3252180218696594,
-0.08426874130964279,
-0.0717456042766571,
0.46084073185920715,
0.490854412317276,
0.8369901180267334,
-0.045194707810878754,
0.46977636218070984,
-0.006430872716009617,
-0.3406291604042053,
-0.7063344120979309,
0.6058934330940247,
-0.3201180100440979,
0.4579266309738159,
-0.5071364641189575,
-0.8441813588142395,
-0.4381873309612274,
0.6670269966125488,
-0.31827375292778015,
-0.15547069907188416,
1.3013511896133423,
0.7992543578147888,
-0.13872016966342926,
0.3979460895061493,
0.19684293866157532,
0.3455240726470947,
0.2677534818649292,
0.926362931728363,
1.0409942865371704,
-0.07719992101192474,
0.2870994210243225,
-0.21350015699863434,
-0.2955438792705536,
0.4108997583389282,
-0.9321110844612122,
-0.8182145357131958,
-0.3055652379989624,
-0.2054460495710373,
-0.6378895044326782,
0.4404660165309906,
1.3258506059646606,
0.3545982539653778,
-0.5813120007514954,
-0.4505816698074341,
-0.640828013420105,
0.5311561226844788,
-0.4824800491333008,
-0.14640089869499207,
0.08779846131801605,
-0.3163616359233856,
-0.019597623497247696,
-0.034346453845500946,
0.6820721626281738,
-0.2904396951198578,
-0.09921082854270935,
-0.2630041837692261,
-0.310312420129776,
0.2855657935142517,
0.8485015034675598,
-0.2729727625846863,
-0.965634822845459,
-0.216367706656456,
-0.06334923207759857,
-0.05318089574575424,
-0.18360616266727448,
0.966228187084198,
-1.0797574520111084,
0.3944283723831177,
0.4956417381763458,
0.6683210134506226,
0.10940700024366379,
-0.05410100147128105,
0.6479402780532837,
-0.16509072482585907,
-0.08972694724798203,
0.31206390261650085,
0.6230976581573486,
-0.2866688668727875,
-0.26191872358322144,
0.49279531836509705,
0.5437237620353699,
-0.05624057725071907,
-0.9553225040435791,
0.6226760745048523,
-1.173953652381897,
-0.3035670816898346,
1.0977901220321655,
0.09442020952701569,
-0.5276272892951965,
0.15581946074962616,
-0.4539315700531006,
0.2039427012205124,
-0.2298985868692398,
0.8379806280136108,
0.6493092179298401,
-0.23974117636680603,
-0.1314065158367157,
-0.033486295491456985,
0.08267468959093094,
0.48177778720855713,
-1.0540002584457397,
0.15792644023895264,
0.45220673084259033,
-0.0888727456331253,
-0.17243440449237823,
0.47882628440856934,
-0.31750890612602234,
0.36789634823799133,
-0.23524591326713562,
-0.30262061953544617,
-0.15024469792842865,
-0.5668980479240417,
0.1414402425289154,
-0.1806599199771881,
-0.04669893532991409,
0.01038419734686613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18350v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18350v1
|
A System for Automatic English Text Expansion
| 2024-05-28T16:48:05 | 2024-05-28T16:48:05 |
Silvia García Méndez, Milagros Fernández Gavilanes, Enrique Costa Montenegro, Jonathan Juncal Martínez, Francisco Javier González Castaño, Ehud Reiter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present an automatic text expansion system to generate English sentences,
which performs automatic Natural Language Generation (NLG) by combining
linguistic rules with statistical approaches. Here, "automatic" means that the
system can generate coherent and correct sentences from a minimum set of words.
From its inception, the design is modular and adaptable to other languages.
This adaptability is one of its greatest advantages. For English, we have
created the highly precise aLexiE lexicon with wide coverage, which represents
a contribution on its own. We have evaluated the resulting NLG library in an
Augmentative and Alternative Communication (AAC) proof of concept, both
directly (by regenerating corpus sentences) and manually (from annotations)
using a popular corpus in the NLG field. We performed a second analysis by
comparing the quality of text expansion in English to Spanish, using an ad-hoc
Spanish-English parallel corpus. The system might also be applied to other
domains such as report and news generation.
|
[
-0.33513134717941284,
-0.8912100195884705,
0.3222688138484955,
0.4346994161605835,
-0.20418784022331238,
0.01254875585436821,
-0.30090510845184326,
-0.6911143660545349,
0.4845570921897888,
0.35870295763015747,
-0.4536600708961487,
-0.45068344473838806,
-0.6936056613922119,
0.9470570087432861,
-0.5734924674034119,
0.7497305274009705,
-0.06888819485902786,
-0.17925181984901428,
0.06369200348854065,
-0.010997016914188862,
-0.8128249645233154,
0.013756673783063889,
-0.9085168242454529,
0.03743482381105423,
0.34262534976005554,
0.5898215770721436,
0.9309704303741455,
0.9532930850982666,
0.7027310729026794,
0.434164822101593,
0.4141732454299927,
0.6359660625457764,
0.07917524874210358,
0.2294798195362091,
-0.02609015628695488,
-0.15546204149723053,
-0.5798591375350952,
-0.2623741924762726,
0.701505720615387,
0.48449182510375977,
-0.18308478593826294,
-0.07384927570819855,
-0.011457138694822788,
0.6339931488037109,
-0.27025550603866577,
0.10613732784986496,
-0.5244443416595459,
-0.023018965497612953,
0.1476706564426422,
-0.3750060796737671,
-0.5010334253311157,
-0.5199986100196838,
0.24283334612846375,
-0.6186287999153137,
-0.12964795529842377,
0.4074476659297943,
0.7810129523277283,
0.25197723507881165,
-0.43197745084762573,
-0.8152903318405151,
-0.7534186244010925,
0.6305359601974487,
-0.5986934900283813,
0.13340245187282562,
0.09340601414442062,
0.1524639129638672,
-0.2809750735759735,
-0.7234997153282166,
-0.4172661006450653,
-0.39829570055007935,
-0.36697980761528015,
0.15206557512283325,
-0.36936312913894653,
0.18965166807174683,
-0.1696077287197113,
0.5038251876831055,
-0.7292840480804443,
-0.14300572872161865,
-0.5538657903671265,
0.05298531800508499,
0.9757970571517944,
0.03588821738958359,
0.8087542653083801,
-0.20763908326625824,
0.06766821444034576,
0.05302707850933075,
-0.5499225854873657,
-0.47028109431266785,
0.5974549055099487,
0.3246762454509735,
0.12339580059051514,
0.8113385438919067,
-0.1260201781988144,
0.702481210231781,
-0.02732180431485176,
0.13616244494915009,
0.2356732189655304,
-0.3084915280342102,
-0.33837735652923584,
0.18571513891220093,
1.0027878284454346,
0.3526160418987274,
0.21366235613822937,
-0.2870367169380188,
-0.18957741558551788,
-0.06732123345136642,
0.43262842297554016,
-0.451288640499115,
-0.08789706230163574,
0.05715451017022133,
-0.3233746886253357,
-0.4853214919567108,
0.272760272026062,
-0.4108397364616394,
0.1511138528585434,
-0.1490660011768341,
0.538312554359436,
-0.5686209797859192,
-0.03256835788488388,
0.29405438899993896,
-0.2562573254108429,
-0.23038312792778015,
-0.07141184061765671,
-0.842613935470581,
0.4467398226261139,
0.1918432116508484,
0.47663599252700806,
-0.2537442445755005,
-0.23061004281044006,
-0.23653779923915863,
0.17851831018924713,
-0.5806642174720764,
0.804298460483551,
-0.31269627809524536,
-0.29728347063064575,
0.1964552402496338,
0.43597567081451416,
0.4805108904838562,
-0.4668300747871399,
0.5895811915397644,
-0.47935888171195984,
0.7411380410194397,
0.21313904225826263,
-0.6052101850509644,
-0.11006458848714828,
-0.062291745096445084,
-0.588478684425354,
0.923484206199646,
-0.10340791195631027,
-0.4814286231994629,
0.3783852159976959,
-0.8937472701072693,
-0.7257261872291565,
0.42829233407974243,
0.028528103604912758,
-0.1388610303401947,
0.04885878786444664,
0.260656476020813,
0.30983132123947144,
-0.2060149759054184,
0.3531697690486908,
0.2716335952281952,
-0.09022427350282669,
-0.1242416724562645,
-0.4642828404903412,
0.7012419104576111,
0.22974906861782074,
-0.2888600528240204,
-0.14129388332366943,
-0.9440374970436096,
0.052523933351039886,
-0.002989193657413125,
-0.45213669538497925,
-0.39715391397476196,
0.1685178279876709,
-0.1860322207212448,
-0.27015817165374756,
0.3992449939250946,
-0.4621780514717102,
0.3666122257709503,
-0.8288552761077881,
0.01601327210664749,
0.3959799110889435,
0.2600054144859314,
0.7292709350585938,
-0.2991282045841217,
0.6258363723754883,
-0.36285749077796936,
-0.1330205500125885,
-0.6231153011322021,
-0.5812823176383972,
-0.798209547996521,
-0.09537288546562195,
0.5257679224014282,
0.8924296498298645,
-0.6505308151245117,
1.2115843296051025,
-0.11367658525705338,
-0.288061261177063,
-0.4260988235473633,
-0.011903258040547371,
0.0304166991263628,
0.05300120636820793,
0.32020336389541626,
-0.2651287913322449,
-0.8962242603302002,
-1.1173346042633057,
-0.17013777792453766,
-0.3194182515144348,
-0.23522059619426727,
0.16190864145755768,
0.22323301434516907,
-0.17634795606136322,
0.8488167524337769,
-0.46621087193489075,
-0.17236073315143585,
-0.20310187339782715,
0.4930935502052307,
0.02046288177371025,
0.2700340151786804,
0.2869422137737274,
-0.388468861579895,
-0.7197920083999634,
0.24515613913536072,
-0.7942851781845093,
-0.5639347434043884,
-0.483550488948822,
-0.0875711739063263,
0.35670551657676697,
0.48353564739227295,
-0.2029968649148941,
0.44486144185066223,
0.5818973779678345,
-0.3799898028373718,
0.42066115140914917,
-0.6109599471092224,
0.41151443123817444,
-1.3431681394577026,
-0.37755197286605835,
0.08222056925296783,
-0.5216837525367737,
-0.5037423372268677,
0.08448603749275208,
-0.06296410411596298,
0.18089856207370758,
-0.16050076484680176,
0.6297474503517151,
-0.5930880308151245,
0.09600137919187546,
-0.7191372513771057,
0.3310993015766144,
0.008050949312746525,
-0.01605529710650444,
0.002811493817716837,
0.7128900289535522,
0.5519918203353882,
-0.7060883045196533,
0.6557810306549072,
0.14156919717788696,
0.08714007586240768,
0.15621505677700043,
-0.5233142375946045,
-0.2670573890209198,
-0.2545015215873718,
0.05802300199866295,
-0.8761542439460754,
-0.47018593549728394,
0.10676653683185577,
-0.5919412970542908,
0.11392137408256531,
0.3541369140148163,
-0.5928822159767151,
-0.5227527618408203,
0.17841219902038574,
0.0039046795573085546,
0.767376184463501,
-0.6485284566879272,
0.4837222099304199,
0.47588983178138733,
-0.4845808446407318,
-0.4092874526977539,
-0.764037013053894,
0.5155589580535889,
-0.08166027814149857,
-0.6955699920654297,
0.29874247312545776,
0.06052689254283905,
-0.6000183820724487,
0.4006982445716858,
0.35915952920913696,
-0.18046881258487701,
-0.2821892499923706,
-0.06292737275362015,
0.21948780119419098,
-0.35342228412628174,
0.4000408947467804,
0.38955795764923096,
0.3170650601387024,
0.10228744149208069,
-0.4728630781173706,
0.366729736328125,
-0.11235816776752472,
0.0658733993768692,
-0.24888727068901062,
0.6918458342552185,
0.2563771605491638,
0.0022743986919522285,
0.6723281145095825,
0.32873913645744324,
-0.541070818901062,
-0.48102453351020813,
-0.328250527381897,
-0.1056123599410057,
-0.5651364922523499,
0.32521599531173706,
-0.26452475786209106,
-0.5406752228736877,
0.27024567127227783,
0.34799954295158386,
0.47870588302612305,
0.8956936597824097,
0.5460518002510071,
-0.1404733955860138,
0.9943771362304688,
1.0215002298355103,
0.3896813690662384,
0.2587544023990631,
0.26110681891441345,
0.2341284602880478,
-0.18343399465084076,
0.2582129240036011,
-0.25047028064727783,
-0.19044369459152222,
-0.7826038599014282,
-0.13015976548194885,
0.011516818776726723,
0.08785128593444824,
0.42817699909210205,
0.8114606142044067,
-0.8521910905838013,
0.7910531163215637,
0.3822602927684784,
-0.2446833699941635,
0.46302908658981323,
-0.11630197614431381,
-0.09583412855863571,
0.06648798286914825,
-0.7525802850723267,
-0.90757155418396,
1.1940386295318604,
0.3013700842857361,
0.4927234351634979,
0.18337856233119965,
0.8781429529190063,
0.6006686687469482,
0.5465396046638489,
-0.753262460231781,
0.6057695746421814,
-0.4846121370792389,
-0.5358542799949646,
-0.45761755108833313,
-0.4160652756690979,
-1.0486706495285034,
-0.15618404746055603,
-0.2849944233894348,
-0.35253340005874634,
0.009998897090554237,
0.1761917918920517,
-0.49242687225341797,
0.17686022818088531,
-1.023000717163086,
0.18369129300117493,
-0.0901084691286087,
-0.14801821112632751,
-0.26223742961883545,
-0.35234007239341736,
0.27958986163139343,
-0.12738481163978577,
0.2300872504711151,
0.1587381511926651,
-0.1677609533071518,
0.7639650106430054,
-0.3720683455467224,
0.4749758839607239,
0.22518931329250336,
-0.20753079652786255,
0.6356750726699829,
0.02686685137450695,
0.43794089555740356,
0.14235204458236694,
0.1717042326927185,
-0.327170193195343,
-0.2844320237636566,
-0.23126834630966187,
-0.4981902241706848,
0.5792021155357361,
-0.42298319935798645,
-0.4607289135456085,
-0.44787338376045227,
-0.6302880644798279,
-0.08934666216373444,
0.2446965128183365,
-0.0011367247207090259,
0.35569289326667786,
-0.539631187915802,
0.2121473103761673,
0.38968026638031006,
-0.465835303068161,
0.7344785928726196,
0.5261856913566589,
-0.4252440333366394,
-0.5417905449867249,
0.6047555804252625,
0.034568630158901215,
0.19212478399276733,
0.2770780324935913,
0.2764831483364105,
-0.3025694191455841,
-0.2708028554916382,
-0.5796563625335693,
0.1746876835823059,
-0.3839415907859802,
-0.14871683716773987,
-0.7610702514648438,
-0.23533493280410767,
-0.5766006708145142,
-0.3793955445289612,
0.05286134034395218,
-0.5796453952789307,
-0.2657324969768524,
-0.13154812157154083,
0.4090504050254822,
1.167663812637329,
-0.3056661784648895,
0.44929319620132446,
-0.911790132522583,
0.3651835322380066,
0.3329690396785736,
0.2055714875459671,
-0.5717475414276123,
-0.5115057229995728,
-0.3959091305732727,
-0.30398476123809814,
-0.38329601287841797,
-1.1683647632598877,
0.7168467044830322,
0.256358802318573,
0.10362214595079422,
0.23315760493278503,
-0.1752592772245407,
0.5180434584617615,
-1.1486977338790894,
0.737564206123352,
0.26349762082099915,
-0.6452274322509766,
0.4827037453651428,
-0.570017397403717,
0.405753493309021,
0.33567243814468384,
0.386739581823349,
-0.5126940011978149,
-0.9963553547859192,
-0.9610469341278076,
-0.9032576680183411,
0.35658976435661316,
0.18166765570640564,
0.24899893999099731,
-0.5820707082748413,
0.44578078389167786,
0.07565513253211975,
0.04152221977710724,
-0.8179541230201721,
-0.23541072010993958,
0.17989014089107513,
-0.6434532403945923,
0.20089508593082428,
0.028686491772532463,
0.01910659484565258,
-0.10652294754981995,
1.0640374422073364,
-0.15326760709285736,
0.18120400607585907,
0.47217175364494324,
-0.1272028684616089,
-0.24428202211856842,
0.4386625587940216,
0.3409002721309662,
0.4888502359390259,
-0.002190117724239826,
-0.10805133730173111,
0.3442208468914032,
-0.38300779461860657,
0.25738614797592163,
0.0985226258635521,
-0.16188110411167145,
0.4771590232849121,
0.22919870913028717,
0.5597801804542542,
-0.24219901859760284,
-0.6993142366409302,
0.2684960663318634,
-0.191566601395607,
-0.5791107416152954,
-0.5032525658607483,
0.012244434095919132,
-0.136325865983963,
-0.033931538462638855,
0.6005009412765503,
0.19150438904762268,
0.310687392950058,
-0.6468982100486755,
0.8186662197113037,
0.375291645526886,
-0.1518656462430954,
-0.06564707309007645,
0.5936206579208374,
0.520014226436615,
-0.7559722065925598,
-0.15076996386051178,
-0.7673733234405518,
-0.11956947296857834,
0.5713725090026855,
0.7263856530189514,
0.9689130187034607,
-0.21596759557724,
0.24103456735610962,
0.6122365593910217,
0.8434469699859619,
-0.3065510392189026,
0.16068316996097565,
0.5001860857009888,
-0.7413216829299927,
-0.8213828206062317,
-0.4388164281845093,
-0.1569208800792694,
0.09185373038053513,
-0.2603723704814911,
0.5986796617507935,
-0.28462907671928406,
-0.04126518964767456,
-0.1368570625782013,
-0.01645474322140217,
-0.3120270073413849,
0.549605131149292,
0.19461511075496674,
0.9751923084259033,
-0.9311994910240173,
0.6118751168251038,
0.6763454675674438,
-0.03547125682234764,
-0.6543303728103638,
0.07612252980470657,
-0.2432229220867157,
-0.5038567185401917,
0.4278455972671509,
-0.1287502646446228,
-0.27232232689857483,
0.0715421661734581,
-0.08441460877656937,
-0.7790451049804688,
0.8284626007080078,
-0.06384024024009705,
-0.574469268321991,
-0.18390265107154846,
0.15266059339046478,
0.7592073082923889,
-0.7473872900009155,
0.36986228823661804,
0.37029531598091125,
0.49004364013671875,
-0.2848042845726013,
-0.7910714745521545,
-0.11994128674268723,
-0.19387094676494598,
-0.2826220393180847,
0.29344847798347473,
-0.2635303735733032,
0.2324015200138092,
0.09250275045633316,
-0.4251968264579773,
0.06979340314865112,
1.00635826587677,
-0.3474976420402527,
-0.3470061123371124,
0.7252473831176758,
0.4367961287498474,
0.6871445775032043,
-0.0673694759607315,
0.8848745822906494,
-0.48689907789230347,
-0.0010451731504872441,
1.1861648559570312,
0.004208252765238285,
0.6907896399497986,
0.25763899087905884,
0.10650323331356049,
0.6869955062866211,
0.3535955548286438,
-0.0007677032263018191,
0.1666695475578308,
0.156332865357399,
-0.33443593978881836,
0.20220328867435455,
0.020410684868693352,
0.15043792128562927,
0.24659211933612823,
0.2462359219789505,
-0.6379381418228149,
-0.10603320598602295,
0.05731948837637901,
-0.0703774020075798,
0.33803704380989075,
-0.21524852514266968,
0.9930347800254822,
-0.2779647707939148,
-0.9475993514060974,
0.2548415958881378,
0.20943887531757355,
0.8698483109474182,
-0.46567246317863464,
0.0549447163939476,
-0.05998561903834343,
-0.20368598401546478,
-0.37136170268058777,
-0.7308720946311951,
0.7839856743812561,
0.20314417779445648,
0.0595703125,
-0.40841010212898254,
0.7747665643692017,
-0.7411242723464966,
-0.6576133370399475,
0.05448020249605179,
0.4955206513404846,
0.06739863753318787,
0.596954345703125,
-0.32291942834854126,
-0.40901169180870056,
0.12425078451633453,
-0.2114657759666443,
-0.31388145685195923,
0.666762113571167,
0.1060054674744606,
0.40380409359931946,
0.27394992113113403,
0.4797413647174835,
0.4031708836555481,
-0.08972088247537613,
0.2544960379600525,
-0.4889780580997467,
-0.4829622805118561,
-0.8198027014732361,
0.6335650682449341,
-0.37188225984573364,
-0.21401967108249664,
0.7763582468032837,
0.6705566048622131,
0.420213520526886,
0.09002120047807693,
1.0994300842285156,
-0.3893639147281647,
0.5042396187782288,
-0.2611094117164612,
0.5348436236381531,
-0.5371378660202026,
0.1059543713927269,
-0.0513479970395565,
-0.9036015868186951,
-0.6333528161048889,
0.6485335230827332,
-0.048212047666311264,
-0.5203523635864258,
1.1212859153747559,
0.7832239866256714,
0.0114767299965024,
0.10529836267232895,
0.25176623463630676,
0.2357659488916397,
0.21658071875572205,
0.0594952255487442,
0.43777185678482056,
-0.623102068901062,
0.6515376567840576,
0.06776721030473709,
-0.5447561740875244,
0.23843875527381897,
-0.8377806544303894,
-0.6511824727058411,
-0.6246557235717773,
-0.43835341930389404,
-0.3283804655075073,
0.11262337118387222,
1.1363290548324585,
0.49563950300216675,
-0.6641280651092529,
-0.3050072491168976,
-0.5410230159759521,
-0.21501772105693817,
0.0796230286359787,
-0.3436727523803711,
-0.027199264615774155,
-0.7506463527679443,
-1.042531132698059,
0.6462217569351196,
0.6056047081947327,
0.05197945982217789,
-0.39864060282707214,
0.03532666712999344,
-0.2777664363384247,
0.6958704590797424,
0.5264742970466614,
0.2943577170372009,
-0.40684568881988525,
-0.44829776883125305,
0.09865844249725342,
-0.10644933581352234,
0.138075053691864,
0.5518640279769897,
-0.5811113715171814,
0.27316346764564514,
0.48068559169769287,
0.7863959670066833,
-0.19920149445533752,
-0.08141742646694183,
1.2155728340148926,
-1.0622100830078125,
0.14554215967655182,
0.2114265263080597,
0.3008306920528412,
0.1319059133529663,
-0.45411238074302673,
0.3949684798717499,
-0.10248928517103195,
-0.862309455871582,
-0.6635521650314331,
0.3194284737110138,
-0.38032495975494385,
-0.18538379669189453,
1.2412244081497192,
0.1799759864807129,
-0.36710137128829956,
-0.03139694780111313,
-0.3021310865879059,
0.15147261321544647,
-0.3469371199607849,
0.8557279109954834,
1.0458340644836426,
-0.13353730738162994,
-0.08451206982135773,
-0.4319261908531189,
0.6848161220550537,
0.4115019142627716,
-1.2126814126968384,
-0.10800250619649887,
0.48802101612091064,
0.020074810832738876,
0.4211234450340271,
0.6512101888656616,
-0.15127263963222504,
0.25370171666145325,
-0.16728700697422028,
0.35663244128227234,
0.3672354817390442,
-0.45595672726631165,
-0.39903292059898376,
0.12889070808887482,
-0.13353361189365387,
-0.09715115278959274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18348v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18348v1
|
Can Automatic Metrics Assess High-Quality Translations?
| 2024-05-28T16:44:02 | 2024-05-28T16:44:02 |
Sweta Agrawal, António Farinhas, Ricardo Rei, André F. T. Martins
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic metrics for evaluating translation quality are typically validated
by measuring how well they correlate with human assessments. However,
correlation methods tend to capture only the ability of metrics to
differentiate between good and bad source-translation pairs, overlooking their
reliability in distinguishing alternative translations for the same source. In
this paper, we confirm that this is indeed the case by showing that current
metrics are insensitive to nuanced differences in translation quality. This
effect is most pronounced when the quality is high and the variance among
alternatives is low. Given this finding, we shift towards detecting
high-quality correct translations, an important problem in practical
decision-making scenarios where a binary check of correctness is prioritized
over a nuanced evaluation of quality. Using the MQM framework as the gold
standard, we systematically stress-test the ability of current metrics to
identify translations with no errors as marked by humans. Our findings reveal
that current metrics often over or underestimate translation quality,
indicating significant room for improvement in automatic evaluation methods.
|
[
-0.39347144961357117,
-0.3989385664463043,
0.4279020130634308,
0.3183048665523529,
-0.2747887372970581,
0.19438216090202332,
-0.18230295181274414,
-0.6260952949523926,
0.04536416754126549,
0.38726845383644104,
-0.08509503304958344,
-0.3249210715293884,
-0.8393924832344055,
0.5387052297592163,
-0.6000606417655945,
0.9309393167495728,
-0.38306495547294617,
0.08066152036190033,
-0.34142574667930603,
-0.5746695399284363,
-0.369827002286911,
-0.4443070888519287,
-0.40212324261665344,
-0.2345963567495346,
0.5021227598190308,
0.4425792694091797,
1.389259934425354,
0.47692370414733887,
1.05307137966156,
0.27614492177963257,
-0.03281468152999878,
0.41494348645210266,
-0.2383234053850174,
0.014563861303031445,
-0.12719795107841492,
-0.5535088777542114,
-0.6872181296348572,
0.292731374502182,
0.7429723143577576,
0.40732264518737793,
0.25268781185150146,
0.4423597455024719,
0.12735262513160706,
0.8417717814445496,
-0.7370955944061279,
-0.17813332378864288,
-0.42973968386650085,
0.15005192160606384,
-0.20979861915111542,
-0.33868274092674255,
-0.21877308189868927,
-0.4859974682331085,
-0.14861679077148438,
-0.3886258602142334,
0.1091928705573082,
0.15388908982276917,
1.222350835800171,
0.6117439866065979,
-0.5834396481513977,
-0.3423945903778076,
-0.7314498424530029,
0.899297833442688,
-0.7519595623016357,
0.43639621138572693,
0.5033745169639587,
0.4257831275463104,
-0.05860717594623566,
-0.10578614473342896,
-0.4033717215061188,
-0.335593044757843,
-0.09137747436761856,
0.35754188895225525,
-0.2966077923774719,
-0.3650580048561096,
0.11490976810455322,
0.6192677617073059,
-0.4708099961280823,
0.16331283748149872,
-0.06630625575780869,
-0.2683657109737396,
0.7307788729667664,
0.2600645124912262,
0.3199361264705658,
-0.27918124198913574,
-0.5053387880325317,
-0.27502018213272095,
-0.3524225652217865,
0.07291890680789948,
0.2254178375005722,
-0.09373048692941666,
0.05867038294672966,
0.5338298678398132,
-0.132438063621521,
0.44270384311676025,
0.007948101498186588,
-0.24148492515087128,
0.4957130253314972,
-0.8098161220550537,
-0.07623552531003952,
-0.2246282547712326,
1.1268876791000366,
0.5661143064498901,
0.07121463119983673,
-0.2167421281337738,
-0.4889017939567566,
0.13627806305885315,
0.3249785006046295,
-0.37016937136650085,
0.1584165245294571,
0.17121143639087677,
-0.34466731548309326,
-0.3323686122894287,
0.179220050573349,
-0.5862599611282349,
-0.09953758120536804,
-0.1107446700334549,
0.6013897061347961,
-0.23967082798480988,
-0.10396560281515121,
0.2051384001970291,
-0.04543052241206169,
0.17393329739570618,
0.4462312161922455,
-0.373981773853302,
0.24843227863311768,
0.603583037853241,
0.9678930044174194,
-0.42609703540802,
-0.364865243434906,
-0.6642287969589233,
-0.1831456571817398,
-0.8617969155311584,
0.919826328754425,
0.013059571385383606,
-0.22614775598049164,
-0.2696799635887146,
-0.02452629804611206,
0.14755931496620178,
-0.6943168044090271,
1.0282007455825806,
-0.33060020208358765,
-0.04905618727207184,
-0.3144717514514923,
-0.31490835547447205,
-0.10831715166568756,
0.24782730638980865,
-0.5972646474838257,
0.9706529974937439,
0.3843131959438324,
-0.5304180979728699,
0.6489810943603516,
-0.27585870027542114,
-0.39029672741889954,
-0.16527919471263885,
0.15791179239749908,
-0.6293009519577026,
0.2526825964450836,
0.08786231279373169,
0.016668368130922318,
-0.608452558517456,
0.11246825754642487,
-0.28577929735183716,
-0.48347267508506775,
0.7510270476341248,
-0.6656592488288879,
0.5237675905227661,
0.4708385467529297,
-0.2068248689174652,
-0.046443063765764236,
-0.5585557222366333,
0.23599819839000702,
-0.23854631185531616,
-0.3817824721336365,
-0.3445277810096741,
-0.16981010138988495,
-0.30884769558906555,
0.6484193205833435,
0.14578497409820557,
-0.3468608856201172,
-0.15414106845855713,
-0.3372615575790405,
0.05853661522269249,
0.377631276845932,
-0.035091567784547806,
0.5058059096336365,
-0.46347692608833313,
0.4342309236526489,
0.2832508385181427,
0.39499184489250183,
0.3206561505794525,
-0.47681790590286255,
-0.9669556021690369,
0.08582942187786102,
0.4227084815502167,
0.7030648589134216,
-0.3196404278278351,
0.9472317099571228,
-0.4084893763065338,
-0.6427486538887024,
-0.8488611578941345,
0.5691841244697571,
0.5254697799682617,
0.2476658821105957,
0.4518229365348816,
-0.8796769976615906,
-0.015540902502834797,
-0.5569469332695007,
-0.6222067475318909,
-0.32808127999305725,
0.1339135318994522,
-0.1154865249991417,
0.5486792325973511,
-0.19586122035980225,
0.7014309763908386,
-0.18921881914138794,
-0.325408399105072,
0.11469767987728119,
0.4237004220485687,
0.13994501531124115,
0.6072520017623901,
0.5822205543518066,
-0.7482776641845703,
-0.5693932175636292,
-0.01681550219655037,
-0.793567955493927,
-0.29196470975875854,
-0.19689755141735077,
-0.6335031986236572,
0.001434092060662806,
0.3649102449417114,
-0.49118462204933167,
0.33257564902305603,
0.6700952649116516,
-0.3751731812953949,
0.633317232131958,
-0.31317904591560364,
0.5958049893379211,
-0.7306314706802368,
0.10168317705392838,
0.08358460664749146,
-0.19868870079517365,
-0.17003652453422546,
0.06217425689101219,
0.3722464442253113,
0.1724056899547577,
-0.4197332561016083,
0.4677475094795227,
-0.2904742658138275,
-0.3592536747455597,
-0.23278535902500153,
0.13057489693164825,
0.4230153262615204,
0.057169366627931595,
-0.381320595741272,
0.8559573292732239,
0.05308183655142784,
-0.5982116460800171,
0.5653696060180664,
0.4908149838447571,
-0.5346701741218567,
1.106123685836792,
-0.4566451907157898,
-0.20331703126430511,
0.0725891962647438,
0.1998349279165268,
-1.0603328943252563,
-0.0615726076066494,
0.3615400791168213,
-0.8178238272666931,
0.22435759007930756,
-0.05023552477359772,
-0.7383204102516174,
-0.3399398922920227,
0.07942754030227661,
0.3046063482761383,
0.5729854702949524,
-0.30728766322135925,
-0.12433367967605591,
0.14904801547527313,
0.09834838658571243,
-0.542951226234436,
-0.7933903932571411,
0.2916940152645111,
-0.15626591444015503,
-0.5908253192901611,
-0.08650922030210495,
-0.01717214286327362,
-0.3345233201980591,
0.01993313990533352,
-0.30608057975769043,
-0.42306283116340637,
0.4472081959247589,
0.03979530557990074,
-0.12608949840068817,
-0.29682594537734985,
0.14204023778438568,
-0.011121466755867004,
-0.6150264143943787,
0.024518271908164024,
-0.1817040592432022,
-0.026659559458494186,
-0.2748231291770935,
-0.598411500453949,
-0.5954242944717407,
0.20488911867141724,
0.9751971960067749,
-0.7322424054145813,
0.44211545586586,
0.9704434275627136,
-0.0941825732588768,
0.4181308150291443,
-0.6085330247879028,
0.13376332819461823,
-0.4362229108810425,
0.3262350261211395,
-0.38075315952301025,
-0.3114509880542755,
0.4302065670490265,
-0.0029540201649069786,
0.031120777130126953,
0.7022023797035217,
0.27371081709861755,
-0.39174792170524597,
1.552176594734192,
0.006522899027913809,
-0.13328692317008972,
0.14580300450325012,
-0.15352803468704224,
0.1934126764535904,
-0.8969681859016418,
0.3201552629470825,
-0.8470969200134277,
-0.3881310820579529,
-0.7584434747695923,
-0.36036571860313416,
0.3967646062374115,
0.38659945130348206,
-0.11481063812971115,
0.2939649820327759,
-0.22355106472969055,
0.45789405703544617,
0.4721161723136902,
-0.11956541985273361,
0.7114830613136292,
-0.16869504749774933,
0.12563081085681915,
-0.15691223740577698,
-0.3326805830001831,
-0.8269120454788208,
0.7182087302207947,
0.33391058444976807,
0.7061888575553894,
0.1814611852169037,
0.4880896806716919,
0.3243391215801239,
0.44370752573013306,
-0.9621579051017761,
0.11290646344423294,
-0.3097507357597351,
-0.6930402517318726,
-0.2927173972129822,
-0.7292141318321228,
-0.9439335465431213,
0.4007841944694519,
-0.5372443795204163,
-0.1665177345275879,
0.23301443457603455,
0.2556813359260559,
-0.3487183749675751,
0.3304263949394226,
-0.5772954225540161,
1.001267671585083,
-0.6439794301986694,
-0.2628856301307678,
-0.14915616810321808,
-0.5973402857780457,
0.22747397422790527,
-0.332782119512558,
0.5590310096740723,
-0.5472638010978699,
-0.06554573029279709,
0.5429784655570984,
-0.09316745400428772,
0.3354978561401367,
0.17645145952701569,
-0.21582496166229248,
0.2559559941291809,
0.5616377592086792,
0.3175390362739563,
-0.031680602580308914,
-0.3446999788284302,
0.2641978859901428,
0.16595576703548431,
-0.7516704201698303,
-0.8731907606124878,
0.39525121450424194,
-0.8985141515731812,
-0.4142202138900757,
-0.4554367661476135,
-0.29227694869041443,
-0.155417799949646,
0.25878196954727173,
0.47098666429519653,
0.17207583785057068,
-0.1915108561515808,
0.04750020429491997,
0.16477136313915253,
-0.14582477509975433,
-0.1633797436952591,
0.5786923170089722,
0.23024776577949524,
-0.49309685826301575,
1.0545990467071533,
0.20302191376686096,
0.6315740346908569,
0.2901930510997772,
0.2879123389720917,
-0.1775161325931549,
-0.6160119771957397,
-0.7028619647026062,
0.22751256823539734,
-0.7370102405548096,
-0.1968737244606018,
-0.2011493444442749,
0.06906475126743317,
-0.17958395183086395,
-0.13291668891906738,
-0.6600382328033447,
-0.2806771695613861,
-0.10043495893478394,
0.155129536986351,
-0.00011531922064023092,
0.45456790924072266,
-0.15919509530067444,
0.16558505594730377,
-1.272155523300171,
0.20507961511611938,
0.10135726630687714,
0.28758060932159424,
-0.26983842253685,
-0.7741265892982483,
-0.6853384971618652,
0.1844031810760498,
-0.5520133376121521,
-0.6484652757644653,
0.483498215675354,
0.07965333014726639,
0.40203413367271423,
0.3870762586593628,
0.20851708948612213,
0.6556849479675293,
-0.19456201791763306,
0.8428412675857544,
0.13560424745082855,
-0.9835765361785889,
0.3276628255844116,
0.0454103946685791,
0.30753570795059204,
0.8638370037078857,
0.43805426359176636,
-0.7323949933052063,
-0.870814323425293,
-0.5797584652900696,
-0.5607318878173828,
0.23706543445587158,
0.22967375814914703,
0.08330947905778885,
0.02573690377175808,
0.3120347857475281,
0.07523045688867569,
0.12147144228219986,
-0.42900025844573975,
-0.08765517920255661,
-0.18827416002750397,
-0.09352071583271027,
-0.5826289653778076,
-0.025516420602798462,
-0.042070068418979645,
-0.27512234449386597,
0.5402969121932983,
0.047482870519161224,
0.18999135494232178,
0.24460437893867493,
-0.3655751943588257,
-0.6581943035125732,
0.4454052746295929,
0.27895617485046387,
0.7026989459991455,
-0.36171287298202515,
0.24671104550361633,
0.16340519487857819,
-0.28968003392219543,
0.5913456678390503,
-0.6205896735191345,
-0.19883520901203156,
0.3389631509780884,
0.28713780641555786,
0.5987145900726318,
0.23695361614227295,
-0.24336078763008118,
0.8867842555046082,
0.037252943962812424,
-0.10287799686193466,
-0.30397212505340576,
0.14591439068317413,
-0.3839026391506195,
-0.11898356676101685,
-0.07507143169641495,
0.5376641154289246,
0.10958964377641678,
-0.3067190647125244,
0.23296236991882324,
0.2797184884548187,
-0.8391001224517822,
-0.37485751509666443,
0.2974167466163635,
0.45075032114982605,
-0.30890125036239624,
0.6141189932823181,
-0.3613262176513672,
-0.41214606165885925,
0.4518437683582306,
0.24060139060020447,
0.7673723101615906,
-0.2667626738548279,
0.10404958575963974,
0.6108925342559814,
0.5408608317375183,
-0.2978515625,
0.020455168560147285,
0.1890212893486023,
-0.8130174279212952,
-0.5425183773040771,
-0.3211674690246582,
-0.6520308256149292,
-0.20704825222492218,
-0.8795127272605896,
0.2388020157814026,
0.019996682181954384,
-0.5782774090766907,
-0.2125965654850006,
-0.023971043527126312,
-0.6815099120140076,
0.38305410742759705,
-0.24822179973125458,
0.6944188475608826,
-0.9926794767379761,
0.5158638954162598,
0.5328683257102966,
-0.5857301950454712,
-0.3068408668041229,
-0.029375692829489708,
0.08182607591152191,
-0.5053068399429321,
0.5109817981719971,
-0.15519186854362488,
-0.24986647069454193,
0.0014510806649923325,
-0.35232529044151306,
-1.0698204040527344,
0.6763308644294739,
0.22270303964614868,
0.0026213277596980333,
0.07126840949058533,
0.21315807104110718,
0.6407608985900879,
0.22429105639457703,
0.3263496160507202,
0.6182986497879028,
0.664520800113678,
-0.26593491435050964,
-1.1602317094802856,
-0.06053931266069412,
-0.17125174403190613,
-0.2477170079946518,
0.43435028195381165,
-0.8081479072570801,
0.6955322027206421,
-0.07339233160018921,
-0.35894840955734253,
0.10857069492340088,
0.339846134185791,
-0.34999218583106995,
0.23738212883472443,
0.5086692571640015,
0.49325528740882874,
0.582297682762146,
-0.17503033578395844,
0.9437041878700256,
-0.26824480295181274,
0.36261406540870667,
0.8847954869270325,
-0.0638345330953598,
1.0119916200637817,
0.5186538100242615,
-0.2340467870235443,
0.284542053937912,
0.49060890078544617,
-0.10221101343631744,
0.19693847000598907,
0.09152527153491974,
0.035622432827949524,
-0.5699663162231445,
0.0577949658036232,
-0.22076816856861115,
0.5079495310783386,
0.4171954095363617,
-0.24451234936714172,
-0.18477626144886017,
-0.17755113542079926,
-0.2073969542980194,
0.17437143623828888,
0.04742422327399254,
0.740407407283783,
0.24042636156082153,
-0.8157415986061096,
1.0168098211288452,
-0.0019067969406023622,
0.6075140237808228,
-0.22032935917377472,
0.23816242814064026,
-0.2526622712612152,
0.03730563446879387,
-0.4129992127418518,
-0.9651927351951599,
0.4258250296115875,
-0.06979352235794067,
-0.007336260285228491,
-0.17434021830558777,
0.2849141061306,
-0.10567192733287811,
-0.30471310019493103,
0.21135084331035614,
0.8403478264808655,
0.42944827675819397,
-0.03516706824302673,
-0.6629217267036438,
-0.19814978539943695,
-0.3077653646469116,
0.002992730587720871,
0.1611713171005249,
0.6507508158683777,
-0.027699556201696396,
0.7186238765716553,
0.6180331707000732,
0.32876524329185486,
-0.07840793579816818,
-0.18707667291164398,
0.06768772006034851,
-0.7469361424446106,
-0.5024470686912537,
-0.7059248089790344,
0.3119587004184723,
0.00401023356243968,
-0.6406244039535522,
0.9153438210487366,
0.3180006146430969,
1.0099941492080688,
0.12711101770401,
0.6380326747894287,
0.514933705329895,
0.4885762929916382,
-0.41534772515296936,
0.6773795485496521,
-0.726805567741394,
0.06065625697374344,
-0.5116404891014099,
-0.897490382194519,
-0.4956548511981964,
0.7400764226913452,
-0.226614847779274,
-0.3540773391723633,
0.7973225712776184,
0.527734637260437,
-0.118318572640419,
-0.2202681303024292,
0.5035273432731628,
0.12849080562591553,
0.4044007658958435,
0.47194141149520874,
1.1077091693878174,
-0.774892270565033,
0.7802457809448242,
-0.015495129860937595,
-0.2918356955051422,
-0.4569048583507538,
-0.7594364881515503,
-0.31571733951568604,
-0.4504997134208679,
-0.5216188430786133,
-0.5803313255310059,
-0.15940281748771667,
0.8980538249015808,
0.4638890027999878,
-0.7351832985877991,
-0.37435609102249146,
0.0782095193862915,
0.28815901279449463,
-0.633618175983429,
-0.19998009502887726,
0.20346100628376007,
-0.5931217670440674,
-0.6016994118690491,
0.03683498874306679,
0.1908177137374878,
0.38683900237083435,
-0.24937911331653595,
-0.36737021803855896,
0.28123927116394043,
0.003220745362341404,
0.4508228600025177,
0.2321268767118454,
-0.6386275291442871,
-0.356928288936615,
-0.11656002700328827,
-0.7014197111129761,
0.4847319424152374,
0.5377898812294006,
-0.19973428547382355,
0.525044858455658,
0.7233720421791077,
0.5802252292633057,
0.19816899299621582,
0.0442180372774601,
0.6615968942642212,
-0.2431810051202774,
-0.10441873967647552,
0.2702212631702423,
0.19631288945674896,
0.361962229013443,
-0.11901094019412994,
0.38699662685394287,
0.17917600274085999,
-0.7184858322143555,
-0.7715660333633423,
0.25281938910484314,
-0.6430100798606873,
0.17913007736206055,
1.0803029537200928,
-0.27804261445999146,
-0.2256813496351242,
-0.2867431938648224,
-0.16790173947811127,
0.34143614768981934,
-0.12562598288059235,
0.9926035404205322,
0.9381396770477295,
-0.02552398294210434,
0.26083576679229736,
-0.7135452628135681,
0.5588918328285217,
0.6505117416381836,
-0.7080127000808716,
-0.15403401851654053,
0.23039832711219788,
0.055376965552568436,
0.4999743103981018,
0.43827545642852783,
-0.48344406485557556,
0.5920682549476624,
-0.2124931663274765,
-0.063295878469944,
0.37229663133621216,
-0.055631935596466064,
-0.2269086241722107,
-0.46919065713882446,
0.6191313862800598,
-0.05404940992593765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18344v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18344v1
|
The Battle of LLMs: A Comparative Study in Conversational QA Tasks
| 2024-05-28T16:42:43 | 2024-05-28T16:42:43 |
Aryan Rangapur, Aman Rangapur
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.7, I.m
|
Large language models have gained considerable interest for their impressive
performance on various tasks. Within this domain, ChatGPT and GPT-4, developed
by OpenAI, and the Gemini, developed by Google, have emerged as particularly
popular among early adopters. Additionally, Mixtral by Mistral AI and Claude by
Anthropic are newly released, further expanding the landscape of advanced
language models. These models are viewed as disruptive technologies with
applications spanning customer service, education, healthcare, and finance.
More recently, Mistral has entered the scene, captivating users with its unique
ability to generate creative content. Understanding the perspectives of these
users is crucial, as they can offer valuable insights into the potential
strengths, weaknesses, and overall success or failure of these technologies in
various domains. This research delves into the responses generated by ChatGPT,
GPT-4, Gemini, Mixtral and Claude across different Conversational QA corpora.
Evaluation scores were meticulously computed and subsequently compared to
ascertain the overall performance of these models. Our study pinpointed
instances where these models provided inaccurate answers to questions, offering
insights into potential areas where they might be susceptible to errors. In
essence, this research provides a comprehensive comparison and evaluation of
these state of-the-art language models, shedding light on their capabilities
while also highlighting potential areas for improvement
|
[
-0.33865419030189514,
-0.7248803973197937,
0.6871952414512634,
0.0783875435590744,
0.07079371809959412,
0.3637765944004059,
0.10661201179027557,
-0.49267634749412537,
0.015186348930001259,
0.3912334740161896,
-0.5522845387458801,
-0.3576269745826721,
-0.55886310338974,
0.07641206681728363,
-0.6570869088172913,
0.8452646136283875,
-0.0805361196398735,
0.2023071050643921,
-0.2709135115146637,
-0.05960088223218918,
-0.3600178062915802,
-0.9372020363807678,
-0.8050073385238647,
-0.33463096618652344,
0.4436509609222412,
-0.0449291355907917,
0.9790427088737488,
0.15910378098487854,
0.6996047496795654,
0.39058196544647217,
-0.2913562059402466,
0.01753171719610691,
-0.7063215970993042,
0.4151972830295563,
-0.0032241696026176214,
-0.5347775220870972,
-0.32928600907325745,
-0.01298568956553936,
0.41770562529563904,
0.4512667953968048,
-0.33958080410957336,
0.09967951476573944,
-0.00818888284265995,
0.6340301632881165,
-0.1963372826576233,
0.0017567311879247427,
-0.8058643937110901,
-0.049886833876371384,
-0.13680844008922577,
-0.0584225133061409,
0.025486880913376808,
-0.4037034213542938,
0.2949388027191162,
-0.521420955657959,
0.026330504566431046,
-0.025802932679653168,
1.068956971168518,
0.24592234194278717,
-0.41541412472724915,
-0.7524856925010681,
-0.7142389416694641,
0.5156034231185913,
-0.8861696720123291,
0.32996323704719543,
0.06713980436325073,
0.323103129863739,
-0.24902021884918213,
-0.8444371819496155,
-0.627486526966095,
-0.40374457836151123,
0.27543625235557556,
0.30439773201942444,
-0.7427265048027039,
0.06747069209814072,
0.14277853071689606,
0.5287341475486755,
-0.49260273575782776,
0.2172408550977707,
-0.5205107927322388,
-0.08828501403331757,
0.3543264865875244,
0.46025845408439636,
0.39122188091278076,
-0.11660200357437134,
-0.3371026813983917,
0.016065925359725952,
-0.7635461091995239,
0.15897011756896973,
0.4160732924938202,
-0.04037506878376007,
-0.1580156832933426,
0.8490633368492126,
-0.1307607889175415,
0.5248293876647949,
0.16577811539173126,
-0.10140679031610489,
-0.015694832429289818,
-0.4686743915081024,
-0.308884859085083,
-0.4710873067378998,
1.0350971221923828,
0.2619710862636566,
0.2616838216781616,
-0.2012431025505066,
-0.3818550407886505,
0.21908192336559296,
0.4882795214653015,
-0.5184680223464966,
-0.06524330377578735,
0.4950217604637146,
-0.23932233452796936,
-0.24843798577785492,
-0.18425270915031433,
-0.32528167963027954,
-0.5286604166030884,
-0.3401259183883667,
0.39954888820648193,
-0.34097909927368164,
-0.1900392472743988,
-0.013782170601189137,
0.014497664757072926,
0.26472607254981995,
0.29347002506256104,
-0.7674514055252075,
0.22995427250862122,
1.0059540271759033,
0.7511395215988159,
-0.4494488835334778,
0.00445196870714426,
-0.05760933458805084,
-0.35015007853507996,
-0.3994193375110626,
0.6419209241867065,
-0.46670690178871155,
-0.6591684818267822,
0.20477701723575592,
-0.43321165442466736,
-0.1866985559463501,
-0.951367974281311,
0.4481014609336853,
-0.7964674830436707,
0.4083520472049713,
-0.33144310116767883,
-0.5286810398101807,
-0.07370825856924057,
0.5728440284729004,
-0.5369629263877869,
1.017592430114746,
0.3202058672904968,
-0.8824861645698547,
0.04711272567510605,
-0.5230181813240051,
0.12996965646743774,
0.15546394884586334,
-0.39416268467903137,
-0.23274238407611847,
-0.017096608877182007,
0.01751355454325676,
0.40546533465385437,
-0.5041118860244751,
0.18055711686611176,
-0.1666538268327713,
-0.3292996883392334,
0.9388857483863831,
-0.3618975579738617,
0.49794304370880127,
0.39140692353248596,
-0.3917703628540039,
0.34458839893341064,
-0.5816267728805542,
-0.03835379704833031,
0.2166132628917694,
-0.3312620222568512,
-0.018817691132426262,
-0.13510648906230927,
-0.13700412213802338,
0.5111569166183472,
0.2686503529548645,
-0.23805847764015198,
-0.10010787844657898,
-0.2792920470237732,
0.5862522721290588,
0.6926445960998535,
0.12187377363443375,
-0.008689424954354763,
-0.4325518310070038,
0.8959870934486389,
0.07686156779527664,
0.40417230129241943,
-0.023128695785999298,
-0.6610736846923828,
-0.8898085951805115,
-0.22926723957061768,
0.22879552841186523,
0.6626033186912537,
-0.8463378548622131,
-0.07919254153966904,
-0.18784424662590027,
-0.7278470993041992,
-0.8263272643089294,
0.26795199513435364,
0.33167269825935364,
0.3881411850452423,
-0.09656118601560593,
-0.2759610712528229,
-0.34590965509414673,
-0.935014545917511,
-0.21385090053081512,
-0.45261552929878235,
0.05111426115036011,
0.42848631739616394,
0.206415593624115,
-0.514695405960083,
0.8166564702987671,
-0.11664603650569916,
0.07520505785942078,
-0.23600834608078003,
-0.13428540527820587,
0.15784120559692383,
-0.1117771565914154,
0.29965919256210327,
-0.7636110782623291,
-0.36316972970962524,
0.08383142948150635,
-0.8628436326980591,
-0.2755284607410431,
0.047701146453619,
0.07876548916101456,
0.038279760628938675,
0.30027079582214355,
-0.5858305096626282,
0.12438875436782837,
0.9640472531318665,
-0.3563050925731659,
0.6952455043792725,
-0.026513779535889626,
0.4797390103340149,
-1.031316876411438,
-0.029965892434120178,
0.04799765348434448,
-0.1383456140756607,
-0.8564630150794983,
0.08983758836984634,
-0.06843062490224838,
-0.2400115728378296,
-0.6594827771186829,
0.38740822672843933,
-0.1659645438194275,
-0.13464969396591187,
-0.1806122213602066,
0.5087925791740417,
-0.29263734817504883,
0.23572807013988495,
-0.23373357951641083,
1.1623650789260864,
0.44670242071151733,
-0.5571165680885315,
0.5912560820579529,
0.25721845030784607,
-0.34721747040748596,
0.4466128647327423,
-1.089682698249817,
0.24537184834480286,
0.26820018887519836,
-0.039886225014925,
-1.2695527076721191,
0.08529044687747955,
0.35039734840393066,
-0.6072956919670105,
-0.21167153120040894,
0.14969240128993988,
-0.5901911854743958,
-0.28210943937301636,
-0.15186989307403564,
0.29291653633117676,
0.6129267811775208,
-0.3088657259941101,
0.42435798048973083,
0.41257694363594055,
-0.44984740018844604,
-0.586255669593811,
-0.3860679566860199,
0.21474377810955048,
-0.4470165967941284,
-0.7932133078575134,
0.0813545510172844,
-0.03740638494491577,
-0.7338784337043762,
-0.2942730486392975,
-0.04461483657360077,
0.025241246446967125,
0.09390978515148163,
0.5109485387802124,
0.4874451756477356,
-0.3995639681816101,
-0.17995423078536987,
-0.41016334295272827,
-0.048139456659555435,
0.10952425748109818,
0.021675297990441322,
0.6779195070266724,
-0.2301042228937149,
-0.6292986869812012,
-0.5061987638473511,
0.05986962839961052,
0.7500938773155212,
-0.16343867778778076,
0.5976995825767517,
0.36765238642692566,
-0.05421794205904007,
0.2739732563495636,
-0.8825467824935913,
0.14148922264575958,
-0.5021588206291199,
0.24039700627326965,
-0.32274919748306274,
-1.1503783464431763,
0.754459798336029,
0.02054121345281601,
0.1710713803768158,
0.4474581778049469,
0.8891699910163879,
-0.10386950522661209,
0.816335141658783,
0.5925450325012207,
-0.09335976839065552,
0.5611361265182495,
-0.06780101358890533,
0.2958492636680603,
-0.5844921469688416,
-0.29412177205085754,
-0.5882768630981445,
0.06379973888397217,
-0.6443204283714294,
-0.531619668006897,
0.641394853591919,
-0.1891603171825409,
-0.14738556742668152,
0.16478712856769562,
-0.18282540142536163,
-0.0634860023856163,
0.38102245330810547,
-0.24160075187683105,
0.4625147581100464,
-0.03826216608285904,
-0.15702062845230103,
-0.06887875497341156,
-0.6950287818908691,
-0.8338629007339478,
1.1629400253295898,
0.6341860294342041,
0.7798979878425598,
0.28348028659820557,
0.5287412405014038,
0.3336317837238312,
0.3086123764514923,
-0.6246235370635986,
0.41239336133003235,
0.17721478641033173,
-0.5490646362304688,
-0.2003086656332016,
-0.4799085855484009,
-1.0793811082839966,
0.6462826132774353,
-0.1660066395998001,
-0.5956828594207764,
-0.11819209158420563,
-0.1435834765434265,
-0.37609627842903137,
0.13668905198574066,
-0.742885410785675,
0.798015296459198,
-0.26038795709609985,
-0.17401304841041565,
-0.15302973985671997,
-0.3611750900745392,
0.4149227440357208,
-0.11856453865766525,
0.26888003945350647,
-0.03639663755893707,
-0.1643933802843094,
0.7271757125854492,
-0.10418898612260818,
0.8277789950370789,
0.31749773025512695,
-0.5987051725387573,
0.4477424621582031,
-0.003940264228731394,
0.2670478820800781,
-0.12344394624233246,
-0.0038060208316892385,
0.14093072712421417,
0.33530235290527344,
-0.27495047450065613,
-0.5259955525398254,
0.6305533647537231,
-1.038267731666565,
-0.5483856201171875,
-0.37260305881500244,
-0.19606463611125946,
-0.3741839528083801,
-0.17369616031646729,
0.07890276610851288,
0.355923056602478,
-0.57295161485672,
-0.29792147874832153,
0.6084593534469604,
-0.26170432567596436,
0.28984764218330383,
0.7030606865882874,
-0.37869423627853394,
-0.4684250056743622,
0.615398645401001,
-0.19664038717746735,
0.637502133846283,
0.23173888027668,
-0.24995920062065125,
-0.407717764377594,
-0.5016329288482666,
-0.4195413291454315,
0.460496187210083,
-0.8328391909599304,
0.048672690987586975,
-0.7394298315048218,
-0.3011246621608734,
-0.43913763761520386,
0.009600496850907803,
-0.432476669549942,
-0.17664127051830292,
-0.08869730681180954,
0.19682547450065613,
0.011299241334199905,
1.1118119955062866,
0.4755345582962036,
0.5378398299217224,
-0.667866587638855,
0.3590298891067505,
0.42399248480796814,
0.01844007521867752,
-0.04469112306833267,
-0.4704955816268921,
0.05738763138651848,
-0.021846167743206024,
-0.7164522409439087,
-1.0186879634857178,
0.3727935552597046,
-0.33625468611717224,
0.685585081577301,
0.32729774713516235,
-0.42397043108940125,
0.4833325743675232,
-0.17408984899520874,
1.07220458984375,
0.275817334651947,
-0.8923109173774719,
0.20813122391700745,
-0.39937832951545715,
0.21219854056835175,
0.37270212173461914,
0.3959573805332184,
-0.9841070771217346,
-0.5733921527862549,
-0.8459692001342773,
-0.806329071521759,
0.31732791662216187,
0.3981868624687195,
0.13595204055309296,
0.01661464013159275,
0.21196474134922028,
0.17011982202529907,
0.35540565848350525,
-0.7837606072425842,
-0.21697093546390533,
0.09713207930326462,
-0.1587539166212082,
-0.08689532428979874,
-0.3811969757080078,
-0.1135668158531189,
0.2845335602760315,
0.5969148278236389,
0.11341550946235657,
0.1648465245962143,
-0.014312755316495895,
0.0454869270324707,
0.08871129900217056,
0.46181192994117737,
0.5370115041732788,
0.9870131611824036,
0.17176569998264313,
-0.087074413895607,
0.1567734330892563,
-0.48918449878692627,
0.0796329528093338,
-0.08651996403932571,
-0.14462198317050934,
-0.01535507570952177,
0.266615092754364,
0.6667305827140808,
0.1740514189004898,
-0.9851431846618652,
0.594858705997467,
-0.22140122950077057,
-0.08332175761461258,
-0.3751530349254608,
0.04370061680674553,
0.23836283385753632,
0.5499234795570374,
0.2529489994049072,
-0.19263561069965363,
0.1490357220172882,
-0.6530879139900208,
-0.0209664199501276,
0.5682240724563599,
-0.532490074634552,
-0.1982612907886505,
0.4932997524738312,
0.22139734029769897,
-0.3114437460899353,
0.5199152231216431,
-0.0015841005370020866,
-0.6118956208229065,
0.5023095011711121,
0.35013547539711,
0.6684916615486145,
-0.18708032369613647,
0.21378546953201294,
-0.030302781611680984,
0.2883566915988922,
0.022779393941164017,
0.186884343624115,
0.13266797363758087,
-0.6748157143592834,
-0.25093063712120056,
-0.3618887662887573,
-0.7301076054573059,
0.23585376143455505,
-0.38437455892562866,
0.08654243499040604,
-0.4177924394607544,
-0.5283271670341492,
-0.026352902874350548,
-0.02688264288008213,
-0.8317596316337585,
0.06535087525844574,
0.2639274299144745,
0.6670001149177551,
-0.5630080103874207,
0.46588796377182007,
0.7860684990882874,
-0.3534137010574341,
-0.5864816904067993,
0.036567457020282745,
0.12744544446468353,
-0.9474225044250488,
0.645750105381012,
-0.3036361038684845,
-0.15801535546779633,
-0.29840177297592163,
-0.18524833023548126,
-0.8434306383132935,
1.0328283309936523,
0.12967747449874878,
-0.564936637878418,
0.01155158318579197,
0.3288135826587677,
0.8089356422424316,
-0.28752416372299194,
0.6322945356369019,
0.6890195608139038,
0.19694936275482178,
0.1344800442457199,
-1.2619024515151978,
-0.16421259939670563,
-0.15033365786075592,
0.11510589718818665,
-0.13776779174804688,
-0.7231325507164001,
0.7555873394012451,
-0.07525899261236191,
-0.34407660365104675,
0.3026236295700073,
0.6613620519638062,
0.45482784509658813,
0.29566690325737,
0.2592427432537079,
0.25117725133895874,
0.6321256160736084,
-0.20248578488826752,
1.0043081045150757,
-0.22348494827747345,
0.14936812222003937,
0.6719551086425781,
-0.28696146607398987,
0.9598141312599182,
0.49794912338256836,
-0.5659782886505127,
0.23118232190608978,
0.736386239528656,
0.14571943879127502,
0.16979357600212097,
0.46044445037841797,
-0.2604096531867981,
0.013071401044726372,
0.08969395607709885,
-0.42111924290657043,
0.4401491582393646,
0.4458625912666321,
-0.2605791389942169,
-0.05748210474848747,
-0.14884810149669647,
0.16125109791755676,
0.07393058389425278,
-0.1681424081325531,
0.9637426137924194,
0.20549176633358002,
-0.7774401903152466,
0.8271729946136475,
0.1779640167951584,
0.8749071359634399,
-0.6637349128723145,
0.252521812915802,
-0.35807356238365173,
0.08149290829896927,
-0.03388145938515663,
-0.6636603474617004,
-0.016054123640060425,
0.19765686988830566,
0.18419340252876282,
0.08503038436174393,
0.44049742817878723,
-0.27528002858161926,
-0.25202110409736633,
0.20537962019443512,
0.8824432492256165,
0.33548060059547424,
-0.1303468495607376,
-1.023618459701538,
0.438541442155838,
0.006175802554935217,
-0.028090745210647583,
0.25152236223220825,
0.41483643651008606,
-0.012827497906982899,
1.0975604057312012,
0.3782423734664917,
0.143327996134758,
0.3044367730617523,
0.1373876929283142,
0.8858274221420288,
-0.7053442597389221,
-0.3515036106109619,
-0.7760485410690308,
0.23911985754966736,
0.04466766491532326,
-0.614037811756134,
0.917560875415802,
0.5482580065727234,
0.5250962972640991,
0.05803786590695381,
0.8290008902549744,
0.25858041644096375,
0.557408332824707,
-0.49878066778182983,
0.5301324129104614,
-0.34406089782714844,
0.5188593864440918,
-0.29381465911865234,
-0.7970775961875916,
0.08028429001569748,
0.14547239243984222,
-0.3763958513736725,
0.23673783242702484,
0.6121859550476074,
0.8096635341644287,
0.06204714626073837,
0.1406528651714325,
0.5015304088592529,
0.2181474268436432,
0.6189864873886108,
0.556307852268219,
1.5209287405014038,
-0.3791666626930237,
0.5370948314666748,
0.13491736352443695,
-0.13700827956199646,
-0.19922272861003876,
-0.43691486120224,
-0.9601498246192932,
-0.7224303483963013,
-0.3302192986011505,
-0.3823941648006439,
0.26727452874183655,
0.6607874035835266,
0.40002772212028503,
-0.6787922382354736,
-0.414061963558197,
0.3890122175216675,
-0.03655533120036125,
-0.042452506721019745,
-0.1654159128665924,
0.0709465816617012,
-0.37738919258117676,
-0.5424783825874329,
0.2653469443321228,
0.16690343618392944,
0.3683478832244873,
-0.5107182264328003,
-0.03844349458813667,
0.26145052909851074,
0.41661402583122253,
0.5412387847900391,
0.16425082087516785,
-1.0957328081130981,
0.2224871665239334,
0.1303640455007553,
-0.5506837368011475,
0.004018515348434448,
0.9192678928375244,
-0.6605191230773926,
0.06148605793714523,
0.2639954388141632,
0.6916989684104919,
0.3362869322299957,
0.1661684513092041,
0.5747344493865967,
-0.16433502733707428,
-0.23484519124031067,
0.09011612087488174,
0.22818894684314728,
0.6243401765823364,
-0.2080034464597702,
0.5211077332496643,
0.023196790367364883,
-0.6215007305145264,
-0.6328763961791992,
0.07933216542005539,
-1.0977259874343872,
-0.08103816211223602,
1.381687045097351,
-0.13036835193634033,
-0.04534395784139633,
-0.10015340894460678,
-0.5536161065101624,
0.014617957174777985,
-0.2715752422809601,
0.9919614195823669,
0.8425962328910828,
-0.19792352616786957,
0.02893245406448841,
-0.9130218625068665,
0.5112894773483276,
0.5735073685646057,
-0.7658237814903259,
-0.0914345234632492,
0.41178131103515625,
0.4186014235019684,
0.0819522961974144,
0.8377878069877625,
-0.3852376937866211,
0.1321975439786911,
-0.05670074373483658,
-0.05084410682320595,
0.1751241534948349,
0.16704517602920532,
-0.43128401041030884,
0.2698529064655304,
0.492023229598999,
-0.09782712906599045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18335v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18335v1
|
Interpretable classification of wiki-review streams
| 2024-05-28T16:28:58 | 2024-05-28T16:28:58 |
Silvia García Méndez, Fátima Leal, Benedita Malheiro, Juan Carlos Burguillo Rial
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Wiki articles are created and maintained by a crowd of editors, producing a
continuous stream of reviews. Reviews can take the form of additions, reverts,
or both. This crowdsourcing model is exposed to manipulation since neither
reviews nor editors are automatically screened and purged. To protect articles
against vandalism or damage, the stream of reviews can be mined to classify
reviews and profile editors in real-time. The goal of this work is to
anticipate and explain which reviews to revert. This way, editors are informed
why their edits will be reverted. The proposed method employs stream-based
processing, updating the profiling and classification models on each incoming
event. The profiling uses side and content-based features employing Natural
Language Processing, and editor profiles are incrementally updated based on
their reviews. Since the proposed method relies on self-explainable
classification algorithms, it is possible to understand why a review has been
classified as a revert or a non-revert. In addition, this work contributes an
algorithm for generating synthetic data for class balancing, making the final
classification fairer. The proposed online method was tested with a real data
set from Wikivoyage, which was balanced through the aforementioned synthetic
data generation. The results attained near-90 % values for all evaluation
metrics (accuracy, precision, recall, and F-measure).
|
[
-0.509181022644043,
-0.5930246114730835,
0.12319120764732361,
0.047283656895160675,
-0.29256364703178406,
0.09500429779291153,
-0.15964597463607788,
-0.831991970539093,
0.4608455300331116,
0.7726228833198547,
-0.7862392067909241,
-0.1539481282234192,
-0.39915046095848083,
0.4429956376552582,
-0.9665743112564087,
1.4952737092971802,
-0.23564748466014862,
-0.07699663192033768,
-0.25129076838493347,
-0.3179045617580414,
-0.34839558601379395,
-0.2367384135723114,
-0.5395259857177734,
-0.37797191739082336,
0.8503357172012329,
0.22459259629249573,
0.47455525398254395,
0.4756297767162323,
0.11124914139509201,
0.33844485878944397,
0.0832175612449646,
0.295576274394989,
-0.6509541273117065,
0.05926932394504547,
-0.5329133868217468,
-0.4229569733142853,
-0.42460882663726807,
0.19134201109409332,
0.39907512068748474,
0.42082449793815613,
-0.1832403689622879,
0.5357567667961121,
0.3305087387561798,
0.7066457867622375,
-0.6787879467010498,
-0.10245658457279205,
-0.6628609895706177,
0.0783090591430664,
-0.15843524038791656,
-0.48616400361061096,
-0.5965055823326111,
-0.37515535950660706,
-0.10527853667736053,
-0.8327468633651733,
0.5722821354866028,
-0.25486958026885986,
0.9022737145423889,
-0.011732373386621475,
-0.2739439308643341,
-0.21253184974193573,
-0.967026948928833,
0.5985369086265564,
-0.5641161799430847,
0.3120022416114807,
0.41459354758262634,
0.32612818479537964,
0.0188987348228693,
-0.6893813014030457,
-1.0718109607696533,
0.17864635586738586,
-0.11419849097728729,
0.25794196128845215,
0.07738102227449417,
-0.12453742325305939,
-0.11930141597986221,
0.42473524808883667,
-0.4484432339668274,
0.134372740983963,
-0.5460751056671143,
-0.12171000242233276,
1.0099704265594482,
0.31856459379196167,
0.08792025595903397,
-0.21303436160087585,
-0.10148939490318298,
0.031395215541124344,
-0.30503347516059875,
-0.09173605591058731,
0.6536439061164856,
-0.009082276374101639,
0.07166217267513275,
0.6268098950386047,
-0.6349484920501709,
0.5545346140861511,
0.6171130537986755,
-0.2631790041923523,
0.39753037691116333,
-0.433303564786911,
-0.12007468938827515,
0.005843585357069969,
0.5471439361572266,
0.8858755826950073,
0.11046013236045837,
-0.048447612673044205,
-0.17444689571857452,
-0.18576788902282715,
0.6831246018409729,
-0.5790198445320129,
-0.17055904865264893,
0.1355229914188385,
-0.7534369230270386,
-1.113887906074524,
0.21584554016590118,
-0.6820380091667175,
-0.6157639622688293,
-0.5020920038223267,
0.6184747815132141,
0.14308248460292816,
-0.3492039740085602,
-0.22240516543388367,
-0.2974788248538971,
-0.14047697186470032,
0.7024872899055481,
-0.6441431045532227,
0.07719796150922775,
0.6169272661209106,
0.639598548412323,
-0.25001806020736694,
-0.4497913420200348,
-0.06240685284137726,
0.19998231530189514,
-0.1037892997264862,
1.0293753147125244,
-0.10185801237821579,
-0.11047337204217911,
0.07942603528499603,
0.25086474418640137,
0.15694935619831085,
-0.28521403670310974,
0.3241879940032959,
-0.7144250273704529,
0.5457424521446228,
-0.004116155207157135,
-0.6982396245002747,
-0.2771894335746765,
0.5956495404243469,
-0.8618637323379517,
0.6776853203773499,
0.17156843841075897,
-1.0699833631515503,
0.5401334762573242,
-0.20940075814723969,
-0.14986668527126312,
0.1678997427225113,
0.4753718376159668,
-0.7233906388282776,
-0.006718214601278305,
-0.07298345118761063,
0.2656351625919342,
0.18068155646324158,
0.20404689013957977,
-0.5624831914901733,
-0.12727591395378113,
0.3862260580062866,
-0.509558916091919,
0.7967121601104736,
0.41308388113975525,
-0.20621158182621002,
0.27698662877082825,
-0.7587164044380188,
0.07455170154571533,
-0.1375293731689453,
-0.41477105021476746,
-0.3662267029285431,
0.3878982961177826,
0.13371242582798004,
0.07055329531431198,
0.024240104481577873,
-0.512040913105011,
0.3592275083065033,
-0.41604864597320557,
0.0748038962483406,
0.896880567073822,
0.46684038639068604,
0.460976779460907,
-0.22871530055999756,
0.24514274299144745,
-0.2856294810771942,
0.8024133443832397,
0.11813771724700928,
-0.4860694706439972,
-0.9820911288261414,
0.02129090391099453,
0.30335965752601624,
0.49890461564064026,
-0.7798223495483398,
0.5150513648986816,
-0.32907986640930176,
-0.8563597798347473,
-0.606834352016449,
0.5004545450210571,
0.20733337104320526,
0.6413025259971619,
0.2859444320201874,
-0.3052155077457428,
-0.4067329466342926,
-0.640920877456665,
-0.5377252697944641,
-0.436646968126297,
-0.051956191658973694,
-0.3094899654388428,
0.16773556172847748,
-0.4877317249774933,
0.6968608498573303,
-0.3989585340023041,
-0.12296797335147858,
0.0241226963698864,
0.35639119148254395,
-0.016939105466008186,
0.08164844661951065,
0.2687903940677643,
-0.834223210811615,
-0.4082823693752289,
0.07260842621326447,
-0.5809281468391418,
-0.5804473757743835,
-0.2862642705440521,
-0.06759536266326904,
0.3539268672466278,
0.3712371289730072,
-0.46025100350379944,
0.5940898656845093,
0.20025195181369781,
-0.4312419593334198,
0.731238603591919,
0.1528719812631607,
0.3655646741390228,
-0.7713743448257446,
-0.14235255122184753,
-0.3117431700229645,
-0.259526789188385,
-0.5467378497123718,
0.01634778268635273,
0.040250830352306366,
0.08012843877077103,
-0.26886752247810364,
0.6151286363601685,
-0.06291108578443527,
0.1977676898241043,
-0.4483569264411926,
0.06746019423007965,
0.3121697008609772,
0.33241894841194153,
-0.08604653179645538,
-0.08469989150762558,
-0.08630864322185516,
-0.6320980787277222,
0.7554804086685181,
-0.04065171629190445,
-0.33876660466194153,
0.8179282546043396,
-0.11651881039142609,
0.10843519121408463,
-0.3192894160747528,
0.4176851511001587,
-0.7412709593772888,
-0.12369180470705032,
0.3781838119029999,
-0.6952077150344849,
0.28800955414772034,
-0.2448657900094986,
-0.3124825656414032,
-0.26518136262893677,
-0.6600497961044312,
-0.1303820163011551,
-0.1591506451368332,
-0.8381810188293457,
0.6081492304801941,
0.24953815340995789,
-0.011685707606375217,
-0.5523091554641724,
-0.21434901654720306,
-0.11382915079593658,
-0.10302785038948059,
-0.4178311824798584,
0.3088298738002777,
-0.11266449838876724,
-0.3985599875450134,
0.5458393692970276,
-0.10855268687009811,
-0.039042677730321884,
0.14219936728477478,
0.3806794285774231,
0.3584025800228119,
0.2780790328979492,
0.3169800043106079,
-0.031111907213926315,
-0.0037136273458600044,
-0.08387690782546997,
-0.261144757270813,
0.2516095042228699,
0.30855226516723633,
-0.043229784816503525,
-0.4216478765010834,
0.1646091789007187,
0.5141825675964355,
-0.020377280190587044,
0.8708160519599915,
0.8007009625434875,
-0.2452014982700348,
-0.43649041652679443,
-0.7423080205917358,
-0.05509680509567261,
-0.4120500683784485,
0.34513893723487854,
-0.07687193900346756,
-0.46635621786117554,
0.4704972207546234,
0.46045151352882385,
0.5469146370887756,
0.9539859890937805,
0.7489335536956787,
-0.5806900262832642,
0.9727706909179688,
0.2253967523574829,
-0.09876574575901031,
0.6125357151031494,
-0.20709030330181122,
0.05225498974323273,
-0.33039700984954834,
-0.512447714805603,
-0.4966837465763092,
-0.5796409249305725,
-0.7226254343986511,
0.033179059624671936,
0.07225856184959412,
0.26146507263183594,
0.14982621371746063,
0.2814567983150482,
-0.7340068221092224,
0.44397875666618347,
0.2683989107608795,
-0.009264782071113586,
0.314982533454895,
0.12843312323093414,
0.47497159242630005,
0.4497860372066498,
-0.2227090746164322,
-0.38693857192993164,
1.0810014009475708,
0.18281827867031097,
0.6769984364509583,
0.015466754324734211,
0.6286845803260803,
0.8555968999862671,
1.021000623703003,
-0.5497232675552368,
0.3021751046180725,
0.09824679046869278,
-0.9816080927848816,
-0.5630390644073486,
-0.30885979533195496,
-0.8066559433937073,
0.2984996438026428,
-0.6403293609619141,
-0.09360968321561813,
0.1116286888718605,
0.23737148940563202,
0.16598379611968994,
0.5402461886405945,
-0.8589780926704407,
0.8126427531242371,
-0.17004013061523438,
-0.3197525143623352,
-0.8201450705528259,
-0.21364948153495789,
0.3508160412311554,
-0.2730322778224945,
0.465121865272522,
-0.05856018513441086,
0.1770351678133011,
0.7538185119628906,
-0.8229540586471558,
0.6773213148117065,
-0.3248806595802307,
0.010556354187428951,
0.5647674202919006,
-0.008390737697482109,
0.21427029371261597,
0.07583993673324585,
0.11847852170467377,
0.2529758810997009,
0.27240586280822754,
-0.2532929480075836,
-0.7896024584770203,
0.9563594460487366,
-0.9390518665313721,
-0.34987321496009827,
-0.3275442123413086,
0.11371184140443802,
-0.059891168028116226,
0.1281324326992035,
0.5044103860855103,
0.23648065328598022,
0.052261825650930405,
-0.07006290555000305,
0.18123099207878113,
-0.03936481475830078,
0.2784271538257599,
0.8745975494384766,
-0.49163514375686646,
-0.5828761458396912,
1.0110641717910767,
0.5300778746604919,
0.022570474073290825,
0.33836913108825684,
0.19430416822433472,
-0.0590675063431263,
-0.5309962034225464,
-0.53986656665802,
0.02420198731124401,
-0.5287817716598511,
-0.4908948540687561,
-0.4194321036338806,
-0.22912193834781647,
-0.25717979669570923,
-0.06752218306064606,
-0.07678183168172836,
-0.8952751159667969,
-0.2846604883670807,
-0.40627017617225647,
0.29414066672325134,
0.826491117477417,
0.16038228571414948,
0.10528994351625443,
-0.728420615196228,
0.3463136851787567,
0.5629002451896667,
0.696495771408081,
0.24689777195453644,
-0.5718258619308472,
-0.48906609416007996,
-0.18386921286582947,
-0.6595733165740967,
-1.1204559803009033,
0.29402804374694824,
0.1626383662223816,
0.48808714747428894,
0.6103051900863647,
0.09766566008329391,
0.6734089255332947,
-0.3127862811088562,
0.6598870754241943,
0.12148801237344742,
-0.6073136329650879,
0.4872961938381195,
-0.06633427739143372,
0.0011420389637351036,
0.5675058960914612,
0.09173968434333801,
-0.6851807236671448,
-0.6318990588188171,
-0.6656771898269653,
-0.6945090293884277,
0.4418652653694153,
0.06581026315689087,
0.2098817527294159,
0.04475077614188194,
0.5951037406921387,
0.4247033894062042,
0.1331768035888672,
-0.7094663381576538,
-0.10914472490549088,
-0.7707496285438538,
-0.2016904056072235,
-0.0496298223733902,
-0.1907389760017395,
0.12392091006040573,
-0.4063664972782135,
1.0336886644363403,
0.13511592149734497,
-0.05546266958117485,
0.15254229307174683,
-0.3238976299762726,
-0.4651508629322052,
0.26529568433761597,
0.3633147180080414,
0.7576736211776733,
-0.19882337749004364,
0.2114761620759964,
0.29402482509613037,
-0.5958516597747803,
-0.0803186371922493,
-0.06794610619544983,
-0.5542817711830139,
0.17047818005084991,
0.7908262610435486,
0.6098527908325195,
-0.05056729167699814,
-0.3399913012981415,
0.3527493178844452,
-0.03553609922528267,
-0.020638659596443176,
-0.6015773415565491,
0.22816656529903412,
-0.12604191899299622,
0.04325312748551369,
0.3545295298099518,
0.0856659784913063,
0.2703539729118347,
-0.6136721968650818,
0.069400355219841,
0.23054014146327972,
-0.09767621755599976,
-0.6031178832054138,
0.46717891097068787,
0.5271748304367065,
-0.32798704504966736,
0.6627565026283264,
-0.07731208950281143,
-0.4886283874511719,
0.22617903351783752,
-0.07824409753084183,
1.0318529605865479,
-0.3360028862953186,
0.21003074944019318,
0.6383631825447083,
0.1770811378955841,
0.256402850151062,
-0.0494326576590538,
-0.19456183910369873,
-0.8634297251701355,
-0.38279563188552856,
-0.8233391642570496,
-0.1962665617465973,
0.28447484970092773,
-0.6907051801681519,
0.31848394870758057,
-0.46169382333755493,
-0.39726948738098145,
0.4887903928756714,
0.12276804447174072,
-0.4077421724796295,
0.19180993735790253,
0.1560109406709671,
0.8941291570663452,
-0.9998013973236084,
0.7394647598266602,
0.4114072322845459,
-0.28686538338661194,
-0.4001411497592926,
-0.12411568313837051,
0.3169519901275635,
-0.2644360661506653,
0.2803940176963806,
0.0618685744702816,
0.03100004605948925,
-0.3732266128063202,
-0.6198065280914307,
-0.2855496108531952,
0.7723024487495422,
-0.10734820365905762,
-0.518303394317627,
0.06935694068670273,
-0.27054694294929504,
0.8280537128448486,
0.07757329195737839,
0.0043635121546685696,
-0.033547986298799515,
0.49331051111221313,
-0.30077454447746277,
-0.9852616786956787,
-0.52134770154953,
-0.5128719806671143,
-0.5420896410942078,
0.37190139293670654,
-0.4423935115337372,
0.4298766553401947,
0.18917813897132874,
-0.06323055922985077,
-0.2302946150302887,
0.6275215148925781,
-0.09169698506593704,
0.7028872966766357,
0.8243648409843445,
0.6026806831359863,
0.5568296313285828,
0.06860341131687164,
1.0209839344024658,
0.11240140348672867,
0.4390376806259155,
0.9866583943367004,
0.06628944724798203,
0.8726980686187744,
0.5003576874732971,
-0.20791685581207275,
0.7287649512290955,
0.5629395842552185,
-0.32464292645454407,
0.5009503960609436,
-0.0016306355828419328,
-0.38076820969581604,
-0.10843343287706375,
-0.005140983499586582,
-0.047000110149383545,
0.25506821274757385,
0.0652189552783966,
-0.2548145353794098,
0.09540480375289917,
0.07087308168411255,
-0.02207699604332447,
-0.005899401381611824,
-0.8057538270950317,
0.9297212958335876,
-0.2406936138868332,
-0.8753831386566162,
0.2671140730381012,
0.33764883875846863,
0.5631318092346191,
-0.34859809279441833,
-0.08348806947469711,
-0.16741915047168732,
0.37019607424736023,
-0.7622142434120178,
-1.1042652130126953,
0.5504767298698425,
0.28284263610839844,
-0.6043886542320251,
-0.4231233596801758,
0.8329389691352844,
-0.3379966616630554,
-0.6248651742935181,
0.11544845998287201,
0.050602708011865616,
-0.05272304639220238,
0.03178083896636963,
-0.4968203008174896,
0.07535695284605026,
0.045416317880153656,
-0.4639907777309418,
0.3179437518119812,
0.17741821706295013,
-0.5684197545051575,
0.5028597116470337,
0.5904122591018677,
0.06584087759256363,
0.18785829842090607,
0.1727401167154312,
0.772462010383606,
-0.2965528666973114,
-0.48492923378944397,
-0.6256557106971741,
0.42891910672187805,
-0.43288230895996094,
-0.1591372936964035,
0.8570517897605896,
0.8157491087913513,
1.1507681608200073,
-0.22616876661777496,
0.5704958438873291,
-0.06351692229509354,
0.7268709540367126,
-0.30541470646858215,
1.027117133140564,
-0.3869025409221649,
-0.02215213142335415,
-0.2117878645658493,
-0.7229246497154236,
0.07086463272571564,
0.4295921325683594,
0.0664854571223259,
-0.28497961163520813,
0.25651612877845764,
0.5243954658508301,
0.19312091171741486,
0.11402920633554459,
-0.07908853888511658,
0.27113470435142517,
0.2406204789876938,
-0.08289229869842529,
0.8124149441719055,
-0.22024159133434296,
0.595940113067627,
-0.527995228767395,
-0.13405941426753998,
-0.2911994755268097,
-0.6308674812316895,
-0.8369021415710449,
-0.7573887705802917,
-0.5380641222000122,
-0.5697029232978821,
-0.15048848092556,
0.6066186428070068,
0.5194008946418762,
-0.941304087638855,
-0.013750363141298294,
0.2961735129356384,
0.32757019996643066,
-0.4723670780658722,
-0.35415375232696533,
0.21623042225837708,
-0.056175682693719864,
-0.43805965781211853,
0.020811624825000763,
0.031174013391137123,
-0.2861492335796356,
-0.45406433939933777,
-0.27553752064704895,
0.0569988377392292,
0.06958603858947754,
0.6401918530464172,
0.34990236163139343,
-0.690292239189148,
-0.4362819790840149,
-0.20538771152496338,
0.08316634595394135,
-0.3534995913505554,
0.5582553744316101,
-0.7946339249610901,
0.9178516268730164,
0.8078582882881165,
0.16185273230075836,
0.854857325553894,
0.07742798328399658,
0.14719156920909882,
-0.6400647163391113,
-0.26944613456726074,
-0.11190313845872879,
-0.009179813787341118,
0.185908243060112,
-0.41038262844085693,
0.3848394751548767,
0.6338983178138733,
-0.3270804286003113,
-0.8783410787582397,
-0.1171075627207756,
-0.8626151084899902,
-0.276001900434494,
0.7287536859512329,
0.06760315597057343,
-0.032602205872535706,
-0.1957142949104309,
-0.1196187436580658,
0.428493469953537,
0.16622047126293182,
1.1810415983200073,
0.9664974808692932,
-0.18884600698947906,
-0.24721650779247284,
-0.4141174256801605,
0.3981444239616394,
-0.297694593667984,
-0.8796051740646362,
0.02793404459953308,
0.6214009523391724,
0.7076151371002197,
0.3001503646373749,
0.46986153721809387,
-0.2010757029056549,
0.3320293724536896,
-0.4227208197116852,
0.14409610629081726,
-0.20743988454341888,
-0.1526414155960083,
-0.3397480547428131,
0.1877126544713974,
-0.10907848924398422,
0.04559096693992615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18320v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18320v1
|
Self-Supervised Learning Based Handwriting Verification
| 2024-05-28T16:11:11 | 2024-05-28T16:11:11 |
Mihir Chauhan, Mohammad Abuzar Shaikh, Bina Ramamurthy, Mingchen Gao, Siwei Lyu, Sargur Srihari
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We present SSL-HV: Self-Supervised Learning approaches applied to the task of
Handwriting Verification. This task involves determining whether a given pair
of handwritten images originate from the same or different writer distribution.
We have compared the performance of multiple generative, contrastive SSL
approaches against handcrafted feature extractors and supervised learning on
CEDAR AND dataset. We show that ResNet based Variational Auto-Encoder (VAE)
outperforms other generative approaches achieving 76.3% accuracy, while
ResNet-18 fine-tuned using Variance-Invariance-Covariance Regularization
(VICReg) outperforms other contrastive approaches achieving 78% accuracy. Using
a pre-trained VAE and VICReg for the downstream task of writer verification we
observed a relative improvement in accuracy of 6.7% and 9% over ResNet-18
supervised baseline with 10% writer labels.
|
[
0.2362915724515915,
-0.5754354000091553,
0.43325531482696533,
0.18123573064804077,
-0.09776636213064194,
0.2397729903459549,
-0.0031069256365299225,
-0.591631293296814,
0.21849894523620605,
0.7358286380767822,
-0.7846022844314575,
-0.8227807283401489,
-0.5940024852752686,
0.2266731709241867,
-0.3999392092227936,
0.6878747940063477,
-0.18331703543663025,
-0.059542216360569,
-0.401361346244812,
-0.1636715978384018,
-0.1340184062719345,
-0.5255069136619568,
-0.5855637192726135,
-0.0057692574337124825,
0.4027383029460907,
0.448265939950943,
0.06624039262533188,
0.9500200152397156,
0.9173703789710999,
0.4079190194606781,
0.2974933087825775,
0.2966427206993103,
-0.23322828114032745,
0.3414463400840759,
-0.0019336738623678684,
-0.4578125774860382,
-0.4336908459663391,
0.14616510272026062,
0.3115338683128357,
-0.08085037767887115,
-0.019040418788790703,
0.3529447615146637,
-0.007002894766628742,
0.8972976803779602,
-0.9775633811950684,
-0.19798150658607483,
-0.29790887236595154,
0.36201655864715576,
-0.41015222668647766,
-0.08271845430135727,
-0.6397197246551514,
-0.5303232073783875,
0.05634390562772751,
-0.6424151062965393,
0.8131418228149414,
0.035505328327417374,
0.8652424812316895,
0.2861359417438507,
-0.27131563425064087,
-0.6326635479927063,
-0.6441100239753723,
0.6812511682510376,
-0.49677661061286926,
0.3418864905834198,
0.5593864321708679,
0.4739307463169098,
0.11053408682346344,
-1.037471055984497,
-0.5487577319145203,
-0.3177047669887543,
-0.13666602969169617,
0.6045782566070557,
0.2896306812763214,
0.045974250882864,
0.27790629863739014,
0.712760329246521,
-0.47413957118988037,
0.29048752784729004,
-0.23590916395187378,
-0.4203132688999176,
0.7324067950248718,
0.17410051822662354,
0.2627096176147461,
0.027997896075248718,
-0.348812073469162,
-0.3724440634250641,
-0.5823310613632202,
0.21350498497486115,
0.705091118812561,
0.052124522626399994,
-0.3204621374607086,
0.35134992003440857,
-0.10551025718450546,
0.7543287873268127,
0.4255348742008209,
-0.2559114992618561,
0.20770540833473206,
-0.3319610357284546,
-0.31166529655456543,
-0.30229467153549194,
1.0187723636627197,
0.02365618385374546,
0.06117375195026398,
0.03492093086242676,
-0.010873868130147457,
-0.24495728313922882,
0.2911893129348755,
-0.4443610608577728,
-0.4677095115184784,
-0.15411591529846191,
-0.7660325169563293,
-0.501274824142456,
0.1976466178894043,
-0.5690147876739502,
-0.559735894203186,
-0.33051788806915283,
0.3150061070919037,
-0.28177034854888916,
-0.042627353221178055,
-0.020921381190419197,
-0.2901332378387451,
0.3945929706096649,
0.6512274742126465,
-1.0740083456039429,
0.13916711509227753,
0.402329683303833,
0.5525398254394531,
-0.39555808901786804,
-0.45035848021507263,
-0.270587295293808,
-0.032856285572052,
-0.47216475009918213,
0.48515307903289795,
0.10555825382471085,
-0.2024233490228653,
-0.15918882191181183,
-0.07461600750684738,
-0.09640716761350632,
-0.44169527292251587,
0.5905938148498535,
-0.1551445573568344,
0.5146104097366333,
-0.16414088010787964,
-0.5604680776596069,
0.09680506587028503,
0.2504085600376129,
-0.850304126739502,
1.2546113729476929,
0.4605279862880707,
-0.8148412704467773,
0.4641519784927368,
-0.20051974058151245,
-0.5252184271812439,
0.06160642206668854,
-0.35327017307281494,
-1.067225694656372,
0.017482947558164597,
0.2904883921146393,
0.8356257677078247,
-0.2904551029205322,
-0.22767044603824615,
-0.3055945336818695,
-0.401140421628952,
0.3073051869869232,
-0.7177307605743408,
0.9934658408164978,
0.22553594410419464,
-0.4263848662376404,
0.013871245086193085,
-1.219989538192749,
0.00022129253193270415,
0.014323556795716286,
-0.37222209572792053,
-0.04799174144864082,
-0.5020068287849426,
0.03146779537200928,
0.18577821552753448,
0.39386916160583496,
-1.0778884887695312,
-0.022649528458714485,
-0.21638305485248566,
0.08830180764198303,
0.44719967246055603,
0.13812480866909027,
0.10190164297819138,
-0.31052324175834656,
0.5633610486984253,
0.023372109979391098,
0.39617544412612915,
-0.10499342530965805,
-0.004779892973601818,
-1.0299193859100342,
-0.47598347067832947,
0.5009790658950806,
0.551451563835144,
-0.7110810875892639,
0.7310591340065002,
0.16772104799747467,
-0.6378310918807983,
-0.8253660798072815,
0.2574622929096222,
0.837921679019928,
0.7740876078605652,
0.5683403015136719,
-0.5367166996002197,
-0.4740489423274994,
-0.9937263131141663,
-0.11437293887138367,
-0.18247288465499878,
0.10351862758398056,
0.273233562707901,
0.21455442905426025,
0.15824107825756073,
0.582633912563324,
-0.2728482484817505,
-0.6998624205589294,
0.22582311928272247,
0.5283382534980774,
0.023613112047314644,
0.7100232243537903,
0.4221138656139374,
-0.383607417345047,
-1.150460958480835,
-0.04236937686800957,
-1.0533376932144165,
0.08300869166851044,
-0.5095357894897461,
0.06987930089235306,
0.5651478171348572,
0.8043766021728516,
0.08786465972661972,
0.8209259510040283,
0.40721869468688965,
-0.16394519805908203,
0.6800004243850708,
-0.7319499254226685,
0.4243062138557434,
-0.7525622248649597,
-0.128646582365036,
0.20072244107723236,
-0.31808146834373474,
-0.413486123085022,
0.12213808298110962,
0.6104045510292053,
0.37160974740982056,
-0.11936695128679276,
-0.08933587372303009,
-0.9271313548088074,
0.012423713691532612,
-0.19292564690113068,
-0.3620026111602783,
0.05288530886173248,
0.4228510558605194,
0.3279222846031189,
0.7086008787155151,
0.6640592217445374,
0.08139783889055252,
0.532200038433075,
-0.19382840394973755,
-0.23976264894008636,
0.8447449207305908,
-0.5866169929504395,
0.29155296087265015,
-0.16643022000789642,
0.042221177369356155,
-1.1767066717147827,
0.12495991587638855,
0.2013804018497467,
-0.5027885437011719,
0.6241526007652283,
-0.06679647415876389,
-0.20969584584236145,
-0.6343026161193848,
-0.15421338379383087,
-0.06392867863178253,
0.6332746744155884,
-0.7203571200370789,
0.9660096168518066,
-0.2900337278842926,
0.33615198731422424,
-0.8227929472923279,
-0.8341553211212158,
-0.0001002441204036586,
-0.12691809237003326,
-0.46596187353134155,
0.26675814390182495,
0.08753474801778793,
0.20748578011989594,
-0.285938024520874,
-0.07735989987850189,
-0.13863511383533478,
0.15297196805477142,
0.5260070562362671,
0.37100693583488464,
-0.32781982421875,
-0.044624559581279755,
0.03124975971877575,
-0.12322964519262314,
0.13834896683692932,
-0.03241328150033951,
-0.053774915635585785,
-0.10158108919858932,
-0.6338353157043457,
-0.9199824333190918,
0.08964869379997253,
0.39318689703941345,
-0.2712286412715912,
0.5917003750801086,
0.6350457072257996,
0.019713209941983223,
-0.3495352566242218,
-0.9503647089004517,
-0.12321232259273529,
-0.49739089608192444,
-0.19768187403678894,
-0.7074226140975952,
-0.7819864749908447,
0.5970853567123413,
0.027798177674412727,
-0.24875935912132263,
0.6389762759208679,
0.438925176858902,
-0.7241554260253906,
0.09218838810920715,
0.48691534996032715,
0.10261405259370804,
0.4229269027709961,
-0.32198330760002136,
-0.20246395468711853,
-0.7718952298164368,
-0.21865782141685486,
-0.3656161427497864,
-0.03161892294883728,
-0.5518282055854797,
-0.23516127467155457,
0.04393565654754639,
-0.24272070825099945,
0.09195392578840256,
0.5760897397994995,
-0.8555058240890503,
0.6397112011909485,
0.9113682508468628,
0.38419702649116516,
0.10516075789928436,
-0.23518534004688263,
-0.29982614517211914,
-0.05477236583828926,
-0.3361237049102783,
-0.20348429679870605,
1.5319559574127197,
0.2443610280752182,
0.7260667681694031,
-0.18322424590587616,
1.3693259954452515,
0.6403656601905823,
0.40739142894744873,
-0.1798008382320404,
0.2626648247241974,
-0.44691404700279236,
-0.44124090671539307,
-0.8308930993080139,
-0.06290945410728455,
-0.908532440662384,
0.20999442040920258,
-0.6102353930473328,
-0.3790127635002136,
0.3162650763988495,
0.41488364338874817,
-0.3216635584831238,
0.012275110930204391,
-0.6202730536460876,
0.7992015480995178,
-0.2703939974308014,
-0.7026069760322571,
0.07980307191610336,
-0.9071717262268066,
0.09854234755039215,
-0.0029998605605214834,
-0.2672516405582428,
0.05577566474676132,
0.4658406376838684,
0.4887789487838745,
-0.5752593874931335,
1.147709846496582,
-0.11118866503238678,
-0.23815913498401642,
0.5273045897483826,
0.10300595313310623,
0.40939438343048096,
-0.414849191904068,
-0.16955581307411194,
0.008562826551496983,
-0.13111743330955505,
-0.08302637934684753,
-0.7061599493026733,
0.5985090136528015,
-0.8806813955307007,
-0.4324549436569214,
-0.4881547689437866,
-0.0071702259592711926,
0.14708666503429413,
0.06850801408290863,
0.7488411068916321,
0.5165954232215881,
-0.2856709659099579,
0.2305954098701477,
0.6511166095733643,
0.0581030435860157,
0.5440930724143982,
0.5806513428688049,
0.373275488615036,
-0.5996836423873901,
0.9209434986114502,
0.12951183319091797,
0.06535840034484863,
0.5553351640701294,
0.2340119630098343,
-0.34531262516975403,
-0.7124111652374268,
-0.6349384784698486,
0.17418457567691803,
-0.8994129300117493,
-0.05959782749414444,
-0.19192644953727722,
-0.35607460141181946,
-0.4208383560180664,
-0.2716452181339264,
-0.516873836517334,
-0.3640625774860382,
-0.6191841959953308,
0.05458703637123108,
0.0352371521294117,
0.5299845337867737,
-0.1162201389670372,
0.28514909744262695,
-0.5249955654144287,
0.1879933923482895,
0.3811558783054352,
0.2121150940656662,
-0.07433594763278961,
-0.5491981506347656,
-0.22480995953083038,
-0.3821812868118286,
-0.2591315805912018,
-0.7175849676132202,
0.1290075182914734,
0.000006995225248829229,
0.5593392848968506,
0.17362470924854279,
-0.04534931108355522,
0.49173620343208313,
-0.22202928364276886,
0.6515127420425415,
0.4186193645000458,
-0.9322271943092346,
0.5613798499107361,
-0.4176599979400635,
0.12338054180145264,
0.832365095615387,
0.3002762496471405,
-0.426878422498703,
-0.542292058467865,
-0.8799542188644409,
-0.4777306616306305,
0.29782235622406006,
0.2046113759279251,
-0.3079414665699005,
0.2552644610404968,
0.7298159003257751,
0.360810250043869,
-0.13423839211463928,
-0.7930600643157959,
-0.28314003348350525,
-0.44187450408935547,
-0.6166003942489624,
0.09412427246570587,
-0.22760017216205597,
0.14123934507369995,
-0.1776026040315628,
0.5241323113441467,
-0.13324695825576782,
-0.0468796007335186,
0.5466002821922302,
-0.04022527113556862,
0.05328771844506264,
-0.10494433343410492,
0.645126223564148,
0.44914379715919495,
-0.1630145013332367,
0.07313177734613419,
0.09247270226478577,
-0.4010368883609772,
0.3659876585006714,
-0.22644682228565216,
-0.35519644618034363,
-0.23216098546981812,
0.9623361229896545,
0.6068760752677917,
-0.38726285099983215,
-0.03387635946273804,
0.8589102625846863,
-0.21204087138175964,
-0.7045825123786926,
-0.6222587823867798,
0.31095123291015625,
-0.06925921142101288,
-0.03081861324608326,
-0.010502856224775314,
-0.009269787929952145,
0.37843143939971924,
-0.028609929606318474,
-0.0491226464509964,
0.2920033931732178,
-0.42556890845298767,
-0.03747601807117462,
0.3676510751247406,
0.22385071218013763,
-0.5068507194519043,
0.9219874143600464,
0.07171253859996796,
-0.10729087144136429,
0.9890048503875732,
0.6309724450111389,
1.0426775217056274,
-0.3637034296989441,
0.2438521385192871,
0.5937728881835938,
0.2856110632419586,
0.06810812652111053,
0.4908604621887207,
-0.5286073088645935,
-0.5697625875473022,
-0.1258435845375061,
-0.20550118386745453,
-0.7078657746315002,
-0.09833525866270065,
-0.9475566148757935,
-0.03716905042529106,
-0.5347293615341187,
-0.05578417703509331,
0.09319421648979187,
-0.26904645562171936,
-0.640961229801178,
0.5188417434692383,
-0.125620037317276,
0.3871523439884186,
-1.1042729616165161,
0.8601868152618408,
0.2703094184398651,
-0.43054962158203125,
-0.6978839039802551,
-0.062490999698638916,
-0.050300419330596924,
-0.7234287261962891,
0.843475878238678,
0.17696645855903625,
-0.5134784579277039,
-0.040551796555519104,
-0.4151366055011749,
-0.8970674872398376,
1.3185182809829712,
-0.09893251955509186,
-0.6224769353866577,
0.5032592415809631,
0.10917670279741287,
1.042792558670044,
-0.27703920006752014,
0.3078744411468506,
0.3676459491252899,
0.09733950346708298,
0.22828885912895203,
-0.7383430004119873,
0.10117641091346741,
-0.11344645172357559,
0.10138769447803497,
0.02819138765335083,
-0.7735493183135986,
0.583878219127655,
0.08927478641271591,
-0.11983007192611694,
0.08325980603694916,
1.0653613805770874,
0.057472143322229385,
0.18836800754070282,
0.11811944097280502,
0.6058142781257629,
0.8453722596168518,
0.07857409119606018,
0.7221301794052124,
-0.17061595618724823,
0.0295727476477623,
1.330654263496399,
-0.11953593790531158,
0.7531536221504211,
0.35550984740257263,
-0.29003411531448364,
0.9595162868499756,
0.45003974437713623,
-0.45707353949546814,
0.24355414509773254,
0.5244407653808594,
-0.2756884694099426,
-0.2512044310569763,
0.4891151487827301,
0.009642655961215496,
0.6460961103439331,
0.13961519300937653,
-0.7901857495307922,
-0.014782649464905262,
0.10641776025295258,
-0.549354076385498,
0.5269262790679932,
-0.011782998219132423,
1.0238322019577026,
-0.2010074108839035,
-0.9879214763641357,
0.4007878601551056,
0.17392610013484955,
0.6970131397247314,
-0.4549773037433624,
-0.016185453161597252,
-0.13599662482738495,
0.29070326685905457,
-0.16520211100578308,
-0.7377345561981201,
0.21258139610290527,
-0.42452019453048706,
-0.12336792796850204,
-0.43001970648765564,
1.187103509902954,
-0.4675728678703308,
-0.4011206030845642,
-0.15185889601707458,
0.3724210262298584,
0.1065634936094284,
0.35898566246032715,
-0.6920289397239685,
-0.10762743651866913,
-0.1129036694765091,
0.009010560810565948,
0.04897613823413849,
0.44386136531829834,
0.12729474902153015,
0.5794313549995422,
0.5107437968254089,
-0.05563262477517128,
0.06669022887945175,
0.052077069878578186,
0.29741737246513367,
-0.5186874866485596,
-0.5826472043991089,
-1.0498298406600952,
0.23978284001350403,
-0.37913763523101807,
-0.6026793122291565,
1.1787891387939453,
0.6723672151565552,
0.6417515277862549,
-0.6338517665863037,
0.8073412775993347,
0.3627588450908661,
0.6397197842597961,
-0.7064760327339172,
0.6986066699028015,
-0.23310044407844543,
-0.306932270526886,
-0.15753716230392456,
-0.27347666025161743,
-0.44699007272720337,
0.9294275045394897,
-0.14054231345653534,
0.08054082840681076,
0.8271458148956299,
0.7481039762496948,
0.06310027092695236,
0.07517524063587189,
0.2813381850719452,
-0.6122826933860779,
0.11116742342710495,
0.5704717636108398,
0.7953361868858337,
-0.5642077922821045,
-0.04911920055747032,
-0.529940128326416,
-0.2668229937553406,
-0.11519550532102585,
-1.1992840766906738,
-1.227137804031372,
-0.6908032298088074,
-0.7411253452301025,
-0.45328691601753235,
-0.009658340364694595,
0.5940716862678528,
0.7617139220237732,
-0.5750423073768616,
-0.2682795226573944,
-0.2864242494106293,
-0.2008652687072754,
-0.4441257119178772,
-0.1314152628183365,
0.8638139367103577,
-0.054054148495197296,
-0.3661438524723053,
0.2521047592163086,
0.406226247549057,
0.6973665356636047,
-0.4180818498134613,
0.08265327662229538,
0.1462249457836151,
-0.13284921646118164,
0.16095131635665894,
0.47044315934181213,
-0.7237804532051086,
-0.004767401609569788,
-0.1228995993733406,
-0.5553986430168152,
0.3208767771720886,
0.7656728029251099,
-0.5985641479492188,
0.6496228575706482,
0.5239837765693665,
0.4997045397758484,
0.9737941026687622,
0.14106903970241547,
0.12872011959552765,
-0.7624463438987732,
-0.3469870388507843,
0.054242536425590515,
0.2511897087097168,
0.38306474685668945,
-0.8435802459716797,
0.47053924202919006,
0.3905647397041321,
-0.6059941649436951,
-0.1650930941104889,
0.20174719393253326,
-0.8830565810203552,
-0.07958202809095383,
0.6233382225036621,
-0.5760299563407898,
-0.41016000509262085,
-0.18398213386535645,
-0.018060648813843727,
0.2168624997138977,
0.10013119131326675,
0.959417998790741,
0.7943789958953857,
-0.3150493800640106,
-0.4375482499599457,
0.31703755259513855,
0.6688067317008972,
0.43037816882133484,
-0.9657633900642395,
0.1205897331237793,
0.5618786215782166,
0.40268832445144653,
0.10753244161605835,
1.2344331741333008,
-0.10852060467004776,
0.5781510472297668,
0.3234005570411682,
0.4504646956920624,
-0.5356156229972839,
-0.48126301169395447,
-0.3349318206310272,
0.3524928689002991,
0.11878793686628342,
-0.3281335234642029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18308v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18308v1
|
Joint Lemmatization and Morphological Tagging with LEMMING
| 2024-05-28T16:01:19 | 2024-05-28T16:01:19 |
Thomas Muller, Ryan Cotterell, Alexander Fraser, Hinrich Schütze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present LEMMING, a modular log-linear model that jointly models
lemmatization and tagging and supports the integration of arbitrary global
features. It is trainable on corpora annotated with gold standard tags and
lemmata and does not rely on morphological dictionaries or analyzers. LEMMING
sets the new state of the art in token-based statistical lemmatization on six
languages; e.g., for Czech lemmatization, we reduce the error by 60%, from 4.05
to 1.58. We also give empirical evidence that jointly modeling morphological
tags and lemmata is mutually beneficial.
|
[
-0.37233421206474304,
-0.9337789416313171,
0.3310033977031708,
0.059904880821704865,
-0.5483800172805786,
-0.07085084915161133,
-0.26328855752944946,
-0.6493396759033203,
0.5111760497093201,
0.4187220633029938,
-0.3883082866668701,
-0.7407485246658325,
-0.3947385251522064,
-0.16257980465888977,
-0.16748793423175812,
0.8605782389640808,
0.24981249868869781,
0.38438472151756287,
-0.23497606813907623,
-0.24203315377235413,
-0.3904499113559723,
-1.244807481765747,
-0.44306349754333496,
-0.24399079382419586,
0.8323307633399963,
-0.032199058681726456,
0.6559555530548096,
0.760599672794342,
0.41241756081581116,
0.25252220034599304,
-0.11277700960636139,
0.2771044373512268,
0.1379346400499344,
0.06076793745160103,
-0.34300047159194946,
-0.5216712951660156,
-1.2047128677368164,
-0.1314680576324463,
0.6863582134246826,
0.9734933972358704,
-0.02157689817249775,
0.09317439794540405,
-0.22435148060321808,
0.4036650061607361,
-0.4076164662837982,
0.06411460041999817,
-0.7096309065818787,
-0.1479845494031906,
-0.36523839831352234,
-0.17345592379570007,
-0.365848183631897,
-0.15120750665664673,
-0.12768135964870453,
-0.39122074842453003,
0.07736797630786896,
-0.24671998620033264,
0.7450311779975891,
0.2893103361129761,
-0.25996312499046326,
-0.4204103946685791,
-0.29803407192230225,
0.8473155498504639,
-0.8806888461112976,
0.3955082297325134,
0.6412608623504639,
0.027180511504411697,
0.06532303988933563,
-0.810158908367157,
-0.08868435025215149,
-0.07768520712852478,
-0.28293177485466003,
-0.20868898928165436,
0.04787812754511833,
0.013599266298115253,
-0.00018415965314488858,
0.21217624843120575,
-0.5097525119781494,
0.3351462483406067,
-0.22510948777198792,
-0.34787699580192566,
0.910794198513031,
0.14578412473201752,
0.7128105759620667,
-0.10418348759412766,
-0.31246429681777954,
0.31119415163993835,
-0.4722224771976471,
-0.2581169307231903,
0.583757221698761,
0.7404419183731079,
0.08974604308605194,
0.7161892652511597,
0.13888657093048096,
0.6859945058822632,
-0.33851075172424316,
-0.2822369933128357,
0.34854650497436523,
-0.34133630990982056,
-0.2956889867782593,
-0.047331880778074265,
0.7480539679527283,
0.40274912118911743,
0.24876266717910767,
-0.11344457417726517,
-0.30870965123176575,
0.41478410363197327,
-0.1180652603507042,
-0.35314908623695374,
-0.5195742249488831,
0.1880170851945877,
-0.2727590501308441,
-0.029961340129375458,
-0.009677516296505928,
-0.9504153728485107,
-0.09637211263179779,
-0.2592153549194336,
0.6306567192077637,
-0.7335336208343506,
-0.6085683107376099,
0.3690287470817566,
-0.17761695384979248,
0.06146528944373131,
0.30605658888816833,
-1.276917815208435,
0.5815099477767944,
1.1236138343811035,
1.0555238723754883,
-0.007121224422007799,
-0.25443705916404724,
-0.7206405401229858,
0.288364976644516,
-0.27630379796028137,
1.0108864307403564,
-0.8666473627090454,
-0.35727018117904663,
-0.007493490818887949,
0.02029561996459961,
-0.45628631114959717,
-0.5298393368721008,
0.014679175801575184,
-0.23646171391010284,
-0.07137808948755264,
-0.10621750354766846,
-0.9716710448265076,
-0.33364588022232056,
0.17498794198036194,
-0.7042350172996521,
1.195615530014038,
-0.11186008155345917,
-0.9613489508628845,
0.47494810819625854,
-0.5401691794395447,
-0.14665882289409637,
0.3075981140136719,
-0.04948097839951515,
-0.34808480739593506,
0.035168882459402084,
0.10951538383960724,
0.5060166716575623,
0.33310845494270325,
0.4947059750556946,
-0.47579002380371094,
-0.2774139642715454,
0.04721713811159134,
0.013595959171652794,
0.7863644361495972,
-0.08423877507448196,
-0.04619213193655014,
0.08299313485622406,
-0.5873052477836609,
-0.08485304564237595,
-0.238275408744812,
-0.23644980788230896,
-0.7152447700500488,
0.19314588606357574,
-0.03103446215391159,
-0.18897923827171326,
0.5811849236488342,
-0.24318689107894897,
0.5323667526245117,
-0.28091275691986084,
0.2885478734970093,
0.5526978969573975,
0.1027614027261734,
0.45281982421875,
-0.38886284828186035,
0.3393172323703766,
-0.0931134894490242,
0.033639244735240936,
-0.35216033458709717,
-0.806501030921936,
-0.6587049961090088,
-0.9840832948684692,
0.9069827198982239,
0.7027345299720764,
-0.1633949726819992,
0.7361314296722412,
0.06399231404066086,
-0.3619033098220825,
-0.40316081047058105,
0.009604011662304401,
0.19108697772026062,
-0.11135818064212799,
0.2724168300628662,
-0.6994737982749939,
-0.7703812718391418,
-0.7467361688613892,
-0.08955386281013489,
-0.29203808307647705,
0.2555443346500397,
-0.2784607410430908,
0.44956132769584656,
-0.18016570806503296,
0.8278392553329468,
-0.10758022218942642,
-0.4333568811416626,
-0.3670446276664734,
0.46250119805336,
0.1376897543668747,
0.7120029330253601,
0.744031548500061,
-0.6775860786437988,
-0.7097686529159546,
0.2612914443016052,
-0.5008367896080017,
-0.20854173600673676,
0.2351313680410385,
0.09282699972391129,
0.7589976191520691,
0.5400436520576477,
-0.7193058133125305,
0.6346222162246704,
0.5462765693664551,
-0.055803392082452774,
0.39654093980789185,
-0.4079276919364929,
-0.2206343412399292,
-1.1163370609283447,
-0.027653280645608902,
0.06256670504808426,
-0.5260640382766724,
-0.6461746692657471,
0.16855274140834808,
-0.09104457497596741,
0.46470504999160767,
-0.4921938180923462,
0.7265411019325256,
-0.5781916379928589,
-0.5520136952400208,
-0.08124679327011108,
0.09414337575435638,
-0.25414517521858215,
0.2880811393260956,
0.07051479071378708,
0.5307518243789673,
0.8145439624786377,
-0.37697455286979675,
0.3106129467487335,
-0.030064526945352554,
-0.1744997203350067,
0.6347578167915344,
-0.32032284140586853,
-0.06124803051352501,
-0.041599053889513016,
0.09649883955717087,
-0.8729698061943054,
-0.3187229335308075,
0.37631887197494507,
-0.6169741153717041,
0.2636502683162689,
-0.6820458769798279,
-1.1628097295761108,
0.0668925940990448,
-0.401471346616745,
0.22891858220100403,
0.8001919388771057,
-0.33478644490242004,
0.6068059802055359,
0.6172642707824707,
-0.2488265186548233,
-0.5106162428855896,
-0.6384925842285156,
-0.13806672394275665,
-0.44427475333213806,
-0.4828571081161499,
0.16888059675693512,
-0.16496451199054718,
-0.36945241689682007,
0.367019921541214,
0.039572399109601974,
-0.3248116672039032,
0.00989028625190258,
0.0023186812177300453,
0.21807415783405304,
-0.2722034752368927,
0.27508556842803955,
-0.2444041520357132,
-0.3294966220855713,
-0.273585706949234,
-0.45019248127937317,
0.9456572532653809,
0.06987059861421585,
-0.5020763278007507,
-0.5065315961837769,
0.46912238001823425,
0.1717522144317627,
-0.43017229437828064,
0.6124095916748047,
0.9257150292396545,
-0.6583034992218018,
-0.1672690361738205,
-0.4021930694580078,
0.3054056763648987,
-0.47812968492507935,
0.3194172978401184,
-0.40463483333587646,
-0.9522530436515808,
0.7362793684005737,
-0.010011604987084866,
0.02356196939945221,
0.49645891785621643,
0.7033124566078186,
-0.16147886216640472,
1.2278972864151,
0.9399587512016296,
0.09402479976415634,
0.3708450198173523,
-0.13141605257987976,
0.07108335196971893,
-0.6283078789710999,
-0.3369337320327759,
-0.4943419396877289,
-0.08624909818172455,
-0.7680001854896545,
-0.7574804425239563,
0.017148906365036964,
0.4879657030105591,
0.14474661648273468,
0.24198965728282928,
-0.47517189383506775,
0.533089816570282,
0.5630287528038025,
-0.19680267572402954,
0.29790055751800537,
0.09783870726823807,
-0.5860666036605835,
-0.1831078827381134,
-0.6022820472717285,
-0.6982275247573853,
0.794273316860199,
0.28438153862953186,
0.8601935505867004,
-0.057891666889190674,
1.0404309034347534,
0.2695227265357971,
0.2498636692762375,
-0.9325020909309387,
0.7972086668014526,
-0.5638036131858826,
-0.742563784122467,
-0.22811134159564972,
-0.22630836069583893,
-0.7746562957763672,
0.35146671533584595,
0.03978116437792778,
-1.331230640411377,
-0.11312800645828247,
0.2812564969062805,
-0.12175562977790833,
0.8426164388656616,
-0.5889301300048828,
0.7954257130622864,
-0.10668271034955978,
-0.03014235384762287,
-0.3005647659301758,
-0.4391803741455078,
0.27508124709129333,
-0.219234898686409,
0.4823787808418274,
-0.7182164192199707,
-0.5297801494598389,
0.7149593234062195,
-0.44237077236175537,
1.3491013050079346,
-0.2079353928565979,
-0.10248979926109314,
0.25525325536727905,
0.15998601913452148,
-0.08238895237445831,
0.0908951386809349,
-0.12130342423915863,
0.2813497483730316,
0.36866217851638794,
-0.5862137675285339,
-0.2904239594936371,
0.6619589924812317,
-0.6001250743865967,
-0.3108506500720978,
-0.6391054391860962,
-0.6836138963699341,
-0.026600511744618416,
0.18891935050487518,
-0.07147427648305893,
0.5005019307136536,
-0.23766794800758362,
-0.23754821717739105,
0.5164037942886353,
-0.12883387506008148,
0.6688178181648254,
0.17910170555114746,
-0.6037409901618958,
-0.7521704435348511,
1.0301775932312012,
0.4226020276546478,
0.21492548286914825,
0.41741910576820374,
-0.03133256360888481,
-0.21199096739292145,
-0.43655773997306824,
-0.36124667525291443,
0.6952624320983887,
-0.8688690066337585,
-0.1663554459810257,
-0.8717585206031799,
-0.5418965816497803,
-0.2788096070289612,
-0.1541910171508789,
-0.348844975233078,
-0.7267695665359497,
-0.34915125370025635,
0.14828453958034515,
0.5437241792678833,
1.1685950756072998,
-0.6242466568946838,
0.4547187089920044,
-1.0395995378494263,
-0.11616485565900803,
0.37205809354782104,
0.2925577759742737,
-0.19201038777828217,
-0.26325491070747375,
-0.46257954835891724,
-0.05924016237258911,
0.005539939738810062,
-0.8617870807647705,
0.6095461845397949,
0.18585051596164703,
0.8566504120826721,
0.03197242319583893,
-0.35725218057632446,
0.8218821287155151,
-0.7281269431114197,
0.9471949934959412,
0.15540173649787903,
-1.2607916593551636,
0.3086963891983032,
-0.48260918259620667,
0.06735725700855255,
0.13270919024944305,
0.6264545917510986,
-0.5797972083091736,
-0.39597123861312866,
-0.6571982502937317,
-0.828302264213562,
0.48861974477767944,
-0.2954028844833374,
0.3044629991054535,
-0.19759999215602875,
0.18914972245693207,
0.3684987723827362,
0.11652681976556778,
-0.5087196230888367,
-0.0195141714066267,
0.2546918988227844,
-0.32163718342781067,
-0.11861952394247055,
-0.3811533749103546,
0.09318867325782776,
-0.5020158290863037,
0.6900171041488647,
-0.2084086686372757,
0.18722136318683624,
-0.03750398010015488,
-0.3981291651725769,
-0.19327199459075928,
0.014485565945506096,
0.6023097634315491,
0.761168897151947,
-0.3497823476791382,
0.4149796962738037,
0.24581727385520935,
-0.22757431864738464,
0.06924863159656525,
-0.001462837215512991,
0.09822027385234833,
0.5287522673606873,
0.5904860496520996,
0.3808751702308655,
0.2888680100440979,
-0.39948225021362305,
0.3435264527797699,
0.1660267561674118,
-0.42644429206848145,
-0.1599356234073639,
0.05688662827014923,
0.535464346408844,
0.25902119278907776,
0.33528396487236023,
0.03516412898898125,
-0.08158715069293976,
-0.4665503203868866,
0.5751233696937561,
0.6372650265693665,
-0.22534602880477905,
-0.8185309171676636,
0.3874289393424988,
-0.037497274577617645,
-0.5778718590736389,
0.008539589121937752,
-0.2560728192329407,
-0.5624397397041321,
0.5049669146537781,
0.6031286120414734,
0.58236163854599,
-0.6255563497543335,
0.316122442483902,
0.48740696907043457,
0.3132284879684448,
-0.09874805063009262,
0.5233870148658752,
0.0826709195971489,
-0.4125809073448181,
-0.6303030848503113,
-0.7514188885688782,
-0.5748971104621887,
-0.04551789537072182,
-0.7785750031471252,
0.562273383140564,
-0.5084210634231567,
-0.3701578974723816,
0.36152446269989014,
0.12476219981908798,
-0.2238466739654541,
0.049724359065294266,
0.3785255253314972,
0.98199462890625,
-0.8598616123199463,
1.1961963176727295,
1.0302520990371704,
-0.41562917828559875,
-0.24016694724559784,
-0.10513249784708023,
0.022894348949193954,
-0.8133483529090881,
0.6262168884277344,
0.41252660751342773,
0.282291978597641,
-0.020054973661899567,
-0.5465716123580933,
-0.984803318977356,
0.873770534992218,
0.2545519173145294,
-0.3875879943370819,
-0.01904095895588398,
0.15023230016231537,
0.5404912233352661,
-0.5779672265052795,
-0.16612911224365234,
0.38849425315856934,
0.41132476925849915,
-0.01973320171236992,
-1.333108901977539,
-0.3988955616950989,
-0.09096609801054001,
-0.14036065340042114,
0.4531894028186798,
-0.731784462928772,
1.1726946830749512,
0.15476612746715546,
-0.2656984031200409,
0.3660370707511902,
0.3682187497615814,
0.0448242649435997,
0.1847693920135498,
0.5457810759544373,
0.8212375640869141,
0.8315913677215576,
0.13512292504310608,
0.5479168891906738,
-0.06715189665555954,
0.4585402011871338,
0.969436764717102,
-0.3286561667919159,
1.129510760307312,
0.42155739665031433,
-0.09827110171318054,
0.6091776490211487,
0.8804311752319336,
0.07154076546430588,
0.4131990075111389,
0.0719079002737999,
-0.4459761381149292,
-0.5362504124641418,
-0.2022351175546646,
-0.33365151286125183,
0.19847406446933746,
0.7324877977371216,
0.012124919332563877,
-0.3357582688331604,
-0.2878141403198242,
0.20791737735271454,
0.0304565466940403,
-0.31839853525161743,
0.8739441633224487,
0.22422979772090912,
-0.4030603766441345,
0.4100037217140198,
0.17476457357406616,
0.9301628470420837,
-0.6176512241363525,
-0.0825500637292862,
-0.29650038480758667,
0.11974678188562393,
-0.22505424916744232,
-0.5919392108917236,
0.6069932579994202,
0.019702669233083725,
0.08761625736951828,
-0.014153946191072464,
0.7683477997779846,
-0.6886932253837585,
-0.6149441599845886,
0.616659939289093,
0.7446085214614868,
0.437792032957077,
0.6206837892532349,
-0.7007131576538086,
0.4069836437702179,
-0.25269630551338196,
0.028776418417692184,
0.5222572684288025,
0.5549600720405579,
-0.12758080661296844,
0.5095431804656982,
0.6260079741477966,
0.2495022714138031,
0.484937846660614,
0.15719850361347198,
0.906799852848053,
-0.7788092494010925,
-0.5902209281921387,
-1.2035223245620728,
0.7885533571243286,
-0.044459063559770584,
0.27680620551109314,
0.7048067450523376,
0.6138219833374023,
0.9499900937080383,
0.13020694255828857,
0.8213370442390442,
-0.061873916536569595,
0.4641064405441284,
-0.5635249018669128,
0.4923526644706726,
-0.7490631341934204,
0.0589376725256443,
-0.11666643619537354,
-1.1068506240844727,
-0.8815088272094727,
0.6026294827461243,
-0.20943564176559448,
-0.12427635490894318,
0.7061737775802612,
0.6978205442428589,
-0.2921574115753174,
-0.3625085651874542,
0.7278035283088684,
-0.1580379605293274,
0.10567701607942581,
0.24887071549892426,
1.0104410648345947,
-0.14466720819473267,
0.19836121797561646,
-0.17444439232349396,
-0.10326101630926132,
-0.2839926779270172,
-0.9702845215797424,
-1.4424110651016235,
-0.6221163272857666,
-0.3724775016307831,
-0.041341837495565414,
0.12387266755104065,
0.9612218141555786,
1.0295199155807495,
-0.6021001935005188,
-0.48869186639785767,
0.31497636437416077,
0.07735611498355865,
0.0966096892952919,
-0.1631777286529541,
0.22215129435062408,
-0.8273035883903503,
-0.7743043303489685,
0.1260482221841812,
0.6282492876052856,
0.17266738414764404,
-0.48829370737075806,
-0.037314821034669876,
-0.5268233418464661,
0.3904859125614166,
0.23455792665481567,
-0.10665956139564514,
-0.8319766521453857,
-0.31613439321517944,
-0.20169128477573395,
-0.17982377111911774,
0.359612375497818,
0.7048906683921814,
-0.39019617438316345,
0.26208728551864624,
0.4418651759624481,
0.374439001083374,
0.5479763746261597,
-0.07044682651758194,
0.3871461749076843,
-0.9580327272415161,
0.5544117093086243,
-0.07935629785060883,
0.32543376088142395,
0.6871376037597656,
-0.038174666464328766,
0.6024401187896729,
0.5821270942687988,
-0.4629809558391571,
-1.0753164291381836,
0.31728747487068176,
-0.8464781045913696,
-0.2363298088312149,
0.8212147355079651,
-0.49036717414855957,
-0.6832959055900574,
-0.034517522901296616,
-0.11665060371160507,
0.2753790616989136,
-0.016075940802693367,
0.0992608368396759,
0.7139908671379089,
0.008278315886855125,
-0.2248803824186325,
-0.5111420154571533,
0.4565536081790924,
0.19700942933559418,
-0.7135878801345825,
-0.14518317580223083,
0.4692666530609131,
0.5308759212493896,
0.2508273124694824,
1.0764424800872803,
-0.07199767231941223,
0.17152465879917145,
0.2746932804584503,
0.27505016326904297,
0.2731128931045532,
-0.3640585243701935,
-0.3794587552547455,
-0.13548605144023895,
0.30515697598457336,
-0.13506458699703217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18292v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18292v1
|
Semantic are Beacons: A Semantic Perspective for Unveiling Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning in Knowledge Learning
| 2024-05-28T15:47:11 | 2024-05-28T15:47:11 |
Renzhi Wang, Piji Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) methods enable efficient adaptation of
Large Language Models (LLMs) to various downstream applications. However, the
effectiveness of the PEFT diminishes notably when downstream tasks require
accurate learning of factual knowledge. In this paper, we adopt a semantic
perspective to investigate this phenomenon, uncovering the reasons behind
PEFT's limitations in knowledge learning task. Our findings reveal that: (1)
PEFT presents a notable risk of pushing the model away from the intended
knowledge target; (2) multiple knowledge interfere with each other, and such
interference suppresses the learning and expression of knowledge features.
Based on these insights, we introduce a data filtering strategy to exclude data
that is detrimental to knowledge learning and a re-weighted learning strategy
to make the model attentive to semantic distance during knowledge learning.
Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method on
open-source large language model, further validate the semantic challenge in
PEFT, thus paving the way for future research.
|
[
-0.30145466327667236,
-0.9402161240577698,
0.7650423645973206,
-0.23638802766799927,
-0.24540004134178162,
-0.040693361312150955,
-0.4524059593677521,
-0.5299966931343079,
-0.3485294580459595,
0.6452268362045288,
-0.659963071346283,
-0.6133295893669128,
-0.8889801502227783,
-0.14226950705051422,
-0.3754473328590393,
1.1839038133621216,
-0.03343696519732475,
-0.22267116606235504,
-0.06724909693002701,
-0.022755850106477737,
-0.4677293300628662,
-0.08346540480852127,
-0.6022191643714905,
-0.2944725453853607,
0.48816895484924316,
0.5219569802284241,
0.6366137266159058,
0.5904707908630371,
0.3690449595451355,
0.24996492266654968,
0.020042765885591507,
0.2772860825061798,
-0.6005136370658875,
0.2650526165962219,
-0.379981130361557,
-0.5469395518302917,
-0.043121904134750366,
0.12163568288087845,
0.8538456559181213,
1.099802851676941,
0.15370845794677734,
0.1339685022830963,
0.2882075011730194,
0.8880795240402222,
-0.8848642110824585,
0.21449172496795654,
-1.0992850065231323,
-0.27547362446784973,
-0.24804705381393433,
0.14518864452838898,
-0.3138165771961212,
0.062411047518253326,
0.4122706651687622,
-0.8494846224784851,
0.2606208622455597,
0.11540918052196503,
0.9715487360954285,
0.6243638396263123,
-0.5834841132164001,
-0.15469127893447876,
-0.6908129453659058,
1.2226793766021729,
-0.4519845247268677,
0.6680502891540527,
0.4937720000743866,
0.17257362604141235,
-0.5097528696060181,
-0.5424011945724487,
-0.3793290853500366,
-0.04427672550082207,
0.0907612070441246,
-0.20627973973751068,
-0.037958964705467224,
0.12357623875141144,
0.08650422841310501,
-0.12446904182434082,
-0.027986904606223106,
0.11664409190416336,
-0.3228951394557953,
-0.31520816683769226,
0.3514466881752014,
-0.015567518770694733,
-0.07995409518480301,
-0.05551568791270256,
-0.5478310585021973,
-0.039301443845033646,
-0.8801916241645813,
0.05867849290370941,
0.27700719237327576,
0.43528828024864197,
0.17711643874645233,
0.42702123522758484,
-0.6205195188522339,
1.1033008098602295,
-0.12505173683166504,
-0.22661210596561432,
0.07461746037006378,
-0.286276251077652,
-0.0936664342880249,
-0.10486998409032822,
0.35106316208839417,
0.26153436303138733,
0.1499485969543457,
-0.43969735503196716,
-0.13389669358730316,
-0.1526191234588623,
0.26962900161743164,
-0.47143682837486267,
-0.1491062343120575,
0.12412548810243607,
-0.26308196783065796,
-0.09118547290563583,
-0.014073681086301804,
-0.607125461101532,
-0.18137475848197937,
-0.3386436402797699,
0.7340540289878845,
-0.6276551485061646,
-0.0845797210931778,
0.3966529369354248,
-0.2330808937549591,
0.2945695221424103,
0.41891568899154663,
-0.7319355607032776,
0.29175400733947754,
0.853754460811615,
0.44207072257995605,
0.09938587993383408,
-0.5515298843383789,
-0.6108457446098328,
0.471783310174942,
-0.16322439908981323,
0.8285117149353027,
-0.6392427086830139,
-0.299472838640213,
-0.42066559195518494,
-0.013860412873327732,
-0.34191247820854187,
-0.3836333751678467,
0.5982294678688049,
-0.6507771611213684,
0.06561557948589325,
-0.5245185494422913,
-0.8238377571105957,
-0.42254146933555603,
-0.005735716316848993,
-0.39670220017433167,
0.7543020844459534,
0.1977817863225937,
-0.6722528338432312,
0.8127387762069702,
-0.34998419880867004,
-0.27848154306411743,
-0.02770952694118023,
-0.10267946124076843,
-0.19870534539222717,
0.27812689542770386,
-0.11028735339641571,
0.47971946001052856,
-0.39883485436439514,
0.14941245317459106,
-0.22404521703720093,
-0.22454789280891418,
-0.02543422393500805,
-0.21895404160022736,
0.2241259664297104,
0.3042559325695038,
-0.3784347176551819,
0.0078030056320130825,
-0.9685306549072266,
0.014711585827171803,
0.005727577954530716,
-0.481330007314682,
-0.7182047963142395,
0.4765862822532654,
-0.3511512279510498,
0.11498548835515976,
0.12113365530967712,
-0.7723134756088257,
-0.23348000645637512,
-0.7480611801147461,
0.33735501766204834,
0.7916874885559082,
0.03444775938987732,
0.505299985408783,
-0.4196696877479553,
0.00987448450177908,
0.038252588361501694,
0.17968402802944183,
0.19145654141902924,
-0.4867328405380249,
-0.5918220281600952,
-0.2917290925979614,
0.3598693013191223,
0.30892205238342285,
-0.6438314318656921,
0.36495837569236755,
-0.20628313720226288,
-0.42920535802841187,
-0.5168302059173584,
0.5304248332977295,
0.4192725121974945,
1.0215295553207397,
0.3427466154098511,
0.11437420547008514,
-0.1024056002497673,
-0.8448386192321777,
-0.6886817812919617,
-0.04008368030190468,
-0.02574881725013256,
-0.03874463960528374,
0.4299255609512329,
0.05997273325920105,
1.1246925592422485,
-0.4397898316383362,
-0.35647013783454895,
0.0783846452832222,
-0.14018762111663818,
0.008486264385282993,
0.5324949622154236,
0.3453616797924042,
-1.0974397659301758,
-0.3032805621623993,
-0.1083512231707573,
-0.3718525767326355,
0.0028225602582097054,
0.007393871434032917,
-0.13951744139194489,
0.11320818215608597,
0.5023731589317322,
-0.5631906390190125,
0.37418124079704285,
0.23657451570034027,
-0.6545222401618958,
0.24963468313217163,
-0.30089616775512695,
-0.09912142902612686,
-0.7243069410324097,
-0.1687411367893219,
-0.06024410203099251,
-0.020535817369818687,
-0.44960248470306396,
0.09619667381048203,
0.21500688791275024,
0.2559964954853058,
-0.4601916968822479,
0.4396677315235138,
-0.17664958536624908,
0.3390229642391205,
-0.3573313057422638,
0.34172001481056213,
0.3081202805042267,
0.25413358211517334,
0.058266375213861465,
0.20112743973731995,
0.4901532530784607,
-0.8357378840446472,
0.3456057906150818,
0.21776890754699707,
-0.3888773024082184,
0.45133158564567566,
-0.5255865454673767,
-0.20478969812393188,
-0.08903146535158157,
-0.13245974481105804,
-0.9945929646492004,
-0.11962291598320007,
0.1817801147699356,
-0.3150942027568817,
0.3001948595046997,
-0.11531473696231842,
-0.49630045890808105,
0.13322237133979797,
-0.3893662393093109,
0.2721004784107208,
0.5653365850448608,
-0.5073302388191223,
0.585456907749176,
0.13209384679794312,
0.22120842337608337,
-0.33129534125328064,
-0.3654695749282837,
-0.16620543599128723,
-0.36249375343322754,
-0.7660965323448181,
0.5183795094490051,
0.38355395197868347,
-0.31282979249954224,
0.17399899661540985,
-0.3245656490325928,
0.21752187609672546,
0.3781763017177582,
0.19361968338489532,
0.14347611367702484,
0.05962378904223442,
0.6387607455253601,
0.23200182616710663,
-0.2128177434206009,
0.08671454340219498,
-0.5850549936294556,
0.22768911719322205,
0.048281602561473846,
-0.6332201957702637,
-0.20421521365642548,
0.2850237488746643,
0.4705429673194885,
-0.23180976510047913,
1.2308884859085083,
0.6322324872016907,
-0.2604215741157532,
-0.35872381925582886,
-0.6024079918861389,
-0.18417292833328247,
-0.47453656792640686,
0.5539254546165466,
-0.37650424242019653,
-1.0173412561416626,
0.4987662434577942,
-0.511945903301239,
0.08565666526556015,
0.6239249110221863,
0.2627504765987396,
0.047484055161476135,
0.7694659233093262,
0.7810957431793213,
0.14024221897125244,
0.3240461051464081,
0.06440421938896179,
0.244015172123909,
-0.8546905517578125,
-0.5672121047973633,
-0.7830957174301147,
-0.17944490909576416,
-0.5045514106750488,
-0.08921477943658829,
0.5271457433700562,
0.3835238516330719,
-0.43423962593078613,
-0.037258654832839966,
-0.39685219526290894,
0.31210747361183167,
0.5865393877029419,
0.4000215232372284,
0.4511018395423889,
-0.049491021782159805,
-0.11991076171398163,
-0.021346867084503174,
-0.679461658000946,
-0.23692746460437775,
1.1976120471954346,
0.3614560067653656,
0.9483195543289185,
-0.021839575842022896,
0.4583892524242401,
-0.03498346358537674,
-0.5338613390922546,
-0.7589368224143982,
0.3805181682109833,
-0.20114822685718536,
-0.4190315008163452,
-0.5703219175338745,
-0.4509998559951782,
-0.7367043495178223,
0.09845242649316788,
-0.3060351014137268,
-0.5923444628715515,
0.18723873794078827,
0.0038280251901596785,
-0.3147743046283722,
0.3340989053249359,
-0.919388473033905,
0.7528493404388428,
-0.07677188515663147,
-0.4416375756263733,
-0.4032800495624542,
-0.7162305116653442,
-0.05373603105545044,
-0.4884408712387085,
0.35797959566116333,
-0.36673370003700256,
-0.34569910168647766,
0.8778401017189026,
-0.56850266456604,
1.0280535221099854,
-0.3935989439487457,
-0.2707965075969696,
0.11144672334194183,
-0.08085719496011734,
0.6366501450538635,
-0.15322616696357727,
0.006406458094716072,
0.011473385617136955,
0.07085162401199341,
-0.7012194395065308,
-0.4591536521911621,
0.6681839823722839,
-0.7261021137237549,
-0.6980820298194885,
0.027711661532521248,
-0.5992220044136047,
-0.6495537161827087,
0.2342546135187149,
0.3591693639755249,
0.2924653887748718,
0.1681148111820221,
0.15663962066173553,
0.9105774760246277,
-0.29525017738342285,
0.18474851548671722,
0.7087798118591309,
0.029916439205408096,
0.0760037750005722,
0.8982423543930054,
0.2398955225944519,
0.5889055728912354,
0.43365830183029175,
0.28411874175071716,
-0.21124175190925598,
-0.8831549286842346,
-0.07371845096349716,
0.22538556158542633,
-0.8204840421676636,
-0.03831551596522331,
-0.46652352809906006,
0.10210573673248291,
-0.467082679271698,
-0.09345429390668869,
-0.47747957706451416,
-0.42579779028892517,
-0.20354299247264862,
0.15794111788272858,
0.7163472175598145,
0.7114370465278625,
0.10799828916788101,
0.27805188298225403,
-0.8044369220733643,
0.18742536008358002,
0.39607927203178406,
0.4927341043949127,
-0.017438028007745743,
-0.5733128786087036,
-0.3472687304019928,
0.12307697534561157,
-0.1580318808555603,
-0.46327412128448486,
-0.14905932545661926,
0.6452057361602783,
0.7842055559158325,
0.3041810691356659,
0.38641783595085144,
0.4466763436794281,
-0.41731423139572144,
0.6081939339637756,
-0.049899838864803314,
-0.9162306785583496,
0.8017662763595581,
-0.2651645541191101,
0.3753925561904907,
0.5476507544517517,
0.3817465901374817,
-0.2055523544549942,
-0.4382581412792206,
-0.3074764609336853,
-0.9376842975616455,
0.6101248860359192,
-0.10261350125074387,
0.11487563699483871,
0.030497873201966286,
0.7279953360557556,
0.26981741189956665,
0.1421879529953003,
-0.15136516094207764,
0.06470532715320587,
-0.05052003636956215,
-0.22083742916584015,
0.03215895593166351,
-0.2932055592536926,
-0.05379918962717056,
-0.4254850447177887,
0.7482424378395081,
-0.16810788214206696,
-0.08801622688770294,
0.1764383763074875,
-0.13194070756435394,
-0.23722189664840698,
0.21743284165859222,
0.2639963626861572,
0.5386247634887695,
-0.03673641383647919,
0.17298690974712372,
0.21902039647102356,
-0.5667484402656555,
-0.16655942797660828,
0.013664978556334972,
-0.20049776136875153,
-0.26408618688583374,
0.47933080792427063,
0.6545231938362122,
0.5653529167175293,
-0.7019551992416382,
0.4504084885120392,
0.2946223318576813,
-0.20040351152420044,
-0.03715485706925392,
0.38197267055511475,
0.009673934429883957,
0.35047420859336853,
0.4327148199081421,
0.10484867542982101,
-0.07499837875366211,
-0.30136746168136597,
0.18342220783233643,
0.6745108962059021,
-0.3638230860233307,
-0.18230687081813812,
0.6388739347457886,
0.09024003893136978,
0.18025393784046173,
0.5382384657859802,
0.05197561904788017,
-0.4815666973590851,
0.26045355200767517,
0.2720116376876831,
0.4087372124195099,
-0.05139511078596115,
0.042851537466049194,
-0.11204923689365387,
0.321969211101532,
-0.0328228734433651,
0.13888348639011383,
-0.334080308675766,
-0.8309475779533386,
-0.7024306654930115,
-1.0016419887542725,
-0.14595654606819153,
-0.24959604442119598,
-0.567799985408783,
0.2891441583633423,
-0.35667625069618225,
-0.05517764389514923,
0.10725339502096176,
0.11142574995756149,
-0.48433542251586914,
0.09148181229829788,
-0.1222713366150856,
1.1143063306808472,
-0.756809651851654,
1.0618795156478882,
0.6385892033576965,
-0.027911018580198288,
-0.9173609614372253,
-0.06337582319974899,
-0.021694954484701157,
-0.8304691910743713,
0.9005023837089539,
-0.2829878628253937,
-0.3745388090610504,
0.19920527935028076,
-0.5278910994529724,
-0.8431891798973083,
0.8118684887886047,
0.5170760750770569,
-0.2947539687156677,
-0.25338950753211975,
0.19076959788799286,
0.24038581550121307,
-0.08076674491167068,
-0.45599859952926636,
0.658367395401001,
0.53510981798172,
0.1619662344455719,
-0.9898242950439453,
0.04576133191585541,
0.20318643748760223,
-0.08929138630628586,
0.505453884601593,
-0.7852223515510559,
0.8132502436637878,
-0.11412668973207474,
0.07911094278097153,
-0.11118297278881073,
0.273822546005249,
-0.10046347230672836,
0.15572085976600647,
0.4724995195865631,
0.5943924188613892,
0.5835944414138794,
-0.1813167929649353,
0.813114583492279,
-0.11706242710351944,
0.5625877380371094,
0.9182667136192322,
-0.2042672485113144,
0.729828417301178,
0.7296944260597229,
-0.19253121316432953,
0.4169127941131592,
0.5380582809448242,
-0.008100810460746288,
0.8250809907913208,
-0.03419151157140732,
-0.4115754961967468,
-0.515562891960144,
-0.13239017128944397,
-0.1821512132883072,
0.7823750376701355,
0.5187304615974426,
-0.28162452578544617,
-0.6828662753105164,
0.4443882703781128,
0.04659591615200043,
0.17737458646297455,
-0.40807420015335083,
0.7765247225761414,
-0.05110948905348778,
-0.4373406767845154,
0.5188303589820862,
0.018081875517964363,
0.6304495930671692,
-0.8169814348220825,
0.005506050772964954,
0.42960089445114136,
0.269735187292099,
-0.21987299621105194,
-0.48619452118873596,
0.48757776618003845,
-0.34754446148872375,
-0.2856639325618744,
-0.05329655110836029,
0.9458669424057007,
-0.15920867025852203,
-0.23205094039440155,
0.59816974401474,
0.6764852404594421,
-0.09470156580209732,
-0.3633376657962799,
-0.5724518895149231,
0.04930776357650757,
-0.03174638748168945,
-0.40816548466682434,
0.583672285079956,
0.7111344337463379,
0.10035542398691177,
0.6679264307022095,
0.4074651002883911,
0.2693377435207367,
0.13052938878536224,
-0.3345259726047516,
0.9305915236473083,
-0.509454071521759,
-0.35351282358169556,
-0.9935404658317566,
0.13515956699848175,
0.3061615228652954,
-0.1367923766374588,
0.9645480513572693,
0.216038778424263,
1.084795355796814,
0.1636417955160141,
0.5589200258255005,
-0.08106522262096405,
0.7907464504241943,
-0.8005792498588562,
0.7867840528488159,
-0.5752155184745789,
0.5131539702415466,
-0.15467238426208496,
-0.6729968786239624,
-0.20917481184005737,
0.18508462607860565,
-0.6302827000617981,
0.05552464723587036,
0.5899943709373474,
0.510818600654602,
0.09611044824123383,
0.1761453002691269,
0.5426437854766846,
0.24518020451068878,
0.031841572374105453,
0.8417540788650513,
0.7367841005325317,
-0.2925299108028412,
0.3972030580043793,
-0.4464593231678009,
-0.2880892753601074,
0.027990568429231644,
-0.8140751719474792,
-0.7080737352371216,
-0.8140113353729248,
-0.28741005063056946,
-0.17273029685020447,
-0.021349379792809486,
0.7077401876449585,
0.8102717399597168,
-0.7144908905029297,
0.27240675687789917,
-0.2241564840078354,
0.40084704756736755,
0.019073761999607086,
-0.1400577276945114,
0.4401995837688446,
-0.7480772733688354,
-0.49524354934692383,
0.2872956097126007,
0.18539002537727356,
-0.16984467208385468,
0.00884883664548397,
0.0882241353392601,
-0.17708663642406464,
-0.28601211309432983,
0.572304368019104,
0.10308526456356049,
-0.6302849054336548,
-0.7328274250030518,
-0.19064585864543915,
0.32103464007377625,
-0.37408921122550964,
0.602117121219635,
-1.2220560312271118,
0.3930816352367401,
0.16460810601711273,
0.762961745262146,
0.053988296538591385,
-0.2950568199157715,
0.33278581500053406,
-0.6083866357803345,
0.12780356407165527,
-0.11505040526390076,
0.19097720086574554,
-0.031227795407176018,
-0.5796791315078735,
0.16981594264507294,
0.4531317353248596,
-0.5786353349685669,
-0.5851587057113647,
0.31009986996650696,
-0.6444012522697449,
-0.6314203143119812,
0.9684991836547852,
-0.1055845320224762,
-0.31014272570610046,
-0.5431094169616699,
-0.00196891650557518,
0.24218487739562988,
-0.2359563112258911,
0.7168889045715332,
0.79649817943573,
-0.3208056688308716,
0.1484827995300293,
-0.6257966756820679,
0.6373357772827148,
0.5213171243667603,
-0.34180352091789246,
0.07200677692890167,
0.35560810565948486,
0.6149256825447083,
-0.011324824765324593,
0.029626257717609406,
-0.17871634662151337,
0.1218009814620018,
-0.03165489435195923,
-0.41275665163993835,
-0.14949321746826172,
-0.32955390214920044,
-0.2675609886646271,
0.33449286222457886,
0.4786280691623688,
-0.2251572161912918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18258v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18258v1
|
Text-only Synthesis for Image Captioning
| 2024-05-28T15:11:17 | 2024-05-28T15:11:17 |
Qing Zhou, Junlin Huang, Qiang Li, Junyu Gao, Qi Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
From paired image-text training to text-only training for image captioning,
the pursuit of relaxing the requirements for high-cost and large-scale
annotation of good quality data remains consistent. In this paper, we propose
Text-only Synthesis for Image Captioning (ToCa), which further advances this
relaxation with fewer human labor and less computing time. Specifically, we
deconstruct caption text into structures and lexical words, which serve as the
fundamental components of the caption. By combining different structures and
lexical words as inputs to the large language model, massive captions that
contain various patterns of lexical words are generated. This method not only
approaches the target domain but also surpasses it by generating new captions,
thereby enhancing the zero-shot generalization ability of the model.
Considering the different levels of data access in the real world, we define
three synthesis scenarios: cross-domain synthesis, in-domain synthesis, and
data-efficient synthesis. Experiments in these scenarios demonstrate the
generalizability, transferability and practicability of ToCa with a nearly 5
CIDEr improvement for zero-shot cross-domain captioning and a maximum increase
of over 20 CIDEr for data-efficient captioning.
|
[
-0.35225218534469604,
-0.605383574962616,
0.6134815812110901,
0.3169305622577667,
-0.7076729536056519,
0.13046500086784363,
-0.229910746216774,
-0.479838490486145,
0.27314648032188416,
0.6895607709884644,
-0.5377397537231445,
-0.7164767980575562,
-0.30122897028923035,
0.28405970335006714,
-0.5170603394508362,
1.184677243232727,
-0.18331557512283325,
-0.15327170491218567,
-0.2365654706954956,
-0.18353767693042755,
-0.33368679881095886,
-0.3745664954185486,
-0.46141451597213745,
0.09494125097990036,
0.4242812991142273,
0.4588538706302643,
0.5745635628700256,
0.896882951259613,
0.4469250440597534,
0.10719654709100723,
0.3703323304653168,
0.30296823382377625,
-0.3542199432849884,
0.07165708392858505,
-0.1885383129119873,
-0.465136855840683,
-0.2616764008998871,
-0.07001058012247086,
0.6445639133453369,
0.5260024070739746,
0.5601063966751099,
-0.05836377292871475,
-0.37844061851501465,
0.8375846147537231,
-0.7407619953155518,
0.4435586929321289,
-0.8514024615287781,
0.20459650456905365,
0.152229905128479,
-0.6465478539466858,
-0.5653213262557983,
-0.12823331356048584,
-0.022551778703927994,
-0.729607880115509,
0.5472598075866699,
0.26890939474105835,
0.9448958039283752,
0.3523250222206116,
-0.1497705727815628,
0.037251003086566925,
-0.681663453578949,
0.741093099117279,
-0.3979809284210205,
0.1355287730693817,
-0.0013742203591391444,
0.357018381357193,
0.13575930893421173,
-0.6032442450523376,
-0.7046955823898315,
-0.3888700008392334,
0.04837609827518463,
0.4768681526184082,
0.122793048620224,
0.12235391139984131,
0.07020019739866257,
0.2920161187648773,
-0.26414692401885986,
-0.08503789454698563,
-0.3282403349876404,
-0.2289474457502365,
0.8843845725059509,
-0.06394518911838531,
0.49748557806015015,
-0.0026119528338313103,
-0.5375282168388367,
-0.32810497283935547,
-1.0363807678222656,
-0.12673601508140564,
-0.10711715370416641,
0.4368823766708374,
-0.14998680353164673,
0.782353401184082,
-0.10467608273029327,
0.30317598581314087,
-0.21682903170585632,
-0.04977412894368172,
-0.11131992191076279,
-0.3205615282058716,
-0.31328731775283813,
0.11843721568584442,
0.7996314764022827,
0.6533704400062561,
0.0971614420413971,
-0.5679327845573425,
-0.2163582593202591,
0.2562595307826996,
0.10947094857692719,
-0.8135851621627808,
-0.13186773657798767,
0.1851561963558197,
-0.1806533932685852,
-0.6712530255317688,
-0.03958204761147499,
-0.8235923051834106,
-0.3601181209087372,
-0.3572255074977875,
0.3763762414455414,
0.007438546512275934,
0.17552787065505981,
-0.18690717220306396,
-0.02423865534365177,
0.26906663179397583,
0.3422190845012665,
-0.571725606918335,
0.4926688075065613,
0.13899515569210052,
0.8969353437423706,
-0.48476797342300415,
-0.4217833876609802,
-0.733936071395874,
0.41016125679016113,
-0.8888682723045349,
0.9487677216529846,
-0.15962807834148407,
-0.2922237515449524,
0.06828853487968445,
0.014299333095550537,
0.24895483255386353,
-0.2784099876880646,
0.1188996210694313,
-0.4183190166950226,
0.046938516199588776,
0.006100653670728207,
-0.4287528991699219,
-0.15228796005249023,
-0.023100094869732857,
-0.9090617895126343,
0.4748772978782654,
-0.024468423798680305,
-0.561811089515686,
0.22177022695541382,
-1.0366755723953247,
-0.8433853983879089,
-0.061593297868967056,
-0.23546481132507324,
-0.5674388408660889,
0.1578405797481537,
0.6161399483680725,
0.38525399565696716,
-0.5738106369972229,
0.21309055387973785,
0.12012644857168198,
-0.3684123158454895,
0.4530041217803955,
-0.12233973294496536,
0.09859628975391388,
0.09454107284545898,
-0.4680938124656677,
0.05498101934790611,
-0.6796416640281677,
-0.15076065063476562,
0.4843135476112366,
-0.190911203622818,
-0.05952594801783562,
-0.09302950650453568,
0.43583983182907104,
-0.04891547933220863,
-0.0731770321726799,
-0.5361651182174683,
0.13096441328525543,
-0.38116317987442017,
0.505001425743103,
0.46628618240356445,
0.2883715331554413,
0.8457837104797363,
-0.2795966863632202,
0.44700387120246887,
-0.13555440306663513,
-0.05957924947142601,
-0.607042133808136,
-0.3917643427848816,
-0.8035247921943665,
-0.5516935586929321,
0.4266771972179413,
0.449353963136673,
-1.1799379587173462,
0.29270103573799133,
-0.42959311604499817,
-0.3490058183670044,
-0.2107066512107849,
-0.07388273626565933,
0.5253067016601562,
0.267843633890152,
0.33182960748672485,
-0.5127864480018616,
-0.3593878448009491,
-0.8067268133163452,
0.06386282294988632,
-0.06752923130989075,
0.13379570841789246,
0.22881516814231873,
0.3570912182331085,
0.22081880271434784,
0.5919923782348633,
-0.7251416444778442,
-0.6687754988670349,
-0.24131335318088531,
-0.10715300589799881,
-0.13983480632305145,
0.346375048160553,
0.6107155680656433,
-0.6092216968536377,
-0.6305410265922546,
0.12667995691299438,
-0.5910546779632568,
0.016554255038499832,
-0.7649710774421692,
-0.295137494802475,
0.5966230034828186,
0.7617228627204895,
-0.47784423828125,
0.6048256754875183,
0.4340667426586151,
0.30308613181114197,
0.39396151900291443,
-0.18906694650650024,
0.2711055874824524,
-0.8107564449310303,
0.25566500425338745,
-0.11628978699445724,
-0.11216876655817032,
-0.7062815427780151,
0.43218687176704407,
-0.056192561984062195,
-0.5529348850250244,
-0.4419713318347931,
0.5814107656478882,
-0.6993768215179443,
-0.16542787849903107,
-0.22740845382213593,
0.12295782566070557,
-0.03077360987663269,
0.8585116863250732,
0.4948435127735138,
0.8106555342674255,
1.0457907915115356,
-0.4711715579032898,
0.16034165024757385,
0.4196615219116211,
-0.3536636233329773,
0.2232799082994461,
-0.6296804547309875,
0.1383821815252304,
-0.42734670639038086,
0.3904246389865875,
-1.3396414518356323,
-0.31568974256515503,
0.4040323495864868,
-0.4975055158138275,
0.2944655120372772,
-0.017666105180978775,
-0.5097314715385437,
0.0944121703505516,
-0.4801733195781708,
0.32404953241348267,
0.45699888467788696,
-0.5146257877349854,
0.5425188541412354,
0.0644923597574234,
-0.36045515537261963,
-0.2331136167049408,
-1.0283457040786743,
0.64542555809021,
0.1280112862586975,
-0.2689928710460663,
0.6575839519500732,
-0.19286100566387177,
0.19833432137966156,
-0.1349046379327774,
-0.1085781455039978,
-0.3097238838672638,
-0.4433547556400299,
0.3533015847206116,
0.5484948754310608,
0.1706821769475937,
0.09938530623912811,
0.46339669823646545,
-0.01259633619338274,
-0.28853556513786316,
-0.2588338553905487,
0.14424020051956177,
0.3166613280773163,
-0.14273227751255035,
-0.5254883170127869,
0.5744305849075317,
0.7343016862869263,
-0.37417399883270264,
0.2861323058605194,
0.27240249514579773,
-0.20206184685230255,
-0.3328385651111603,
-0.26704806089401245,
-0.24021048843860626,
-0.3947572112083435,
0.32764190435409546,
-0.3346180319786072,
-0.6823435425758362,
0.2523656189441681,
0.11142893880605698,
0.5247146487236023,
0.20908984541893005,
0.42504438757896423,
-0.029698001220822334,
0.5989079475402832,
0.45706450939178467,
0.02236652746796608,
0.4401401877403259,
-0.1940900832414627,
0.28018680214881897,
-0.39285388588905334,
0.0023995644878596067,
-0.2686794400215149,
-0.15931594371795654,
-0.5358022451400757,
-0.49980583786964417,
0.4995734989643097,
-0.5763353109359741,
0.09065673500299454,
0.33461540937423706,
-0.7880682945251465,
0.6090412735939026,
0.3439500629901886,
0.27931052446365356,
0.20944057404994965,
0.8758824467658997,
0.3892843425273895,
-0.013452360406517982,
-0.41888856887817383,
-0.18335111439228058,
1.2622402906417847,
-0.032349057495594025,
0.5662680864334106,
-0.23599152266979218,
0.8359876871109009,
0.269991397857666,
0.27917271852493286,
-0.9223268032073975,
0.7670807242393494,
-0.38827836513519287,
-0.6522067785263062,
-0.34610578417778015,
-0.35954758524894714,
-0.777202308177948,
0.12212711572647095,
-0.5558406710624695,
-0.10593417286872864,
-0.31179937720298767,
-0.04337157681584358,
-0.15091028809547424,
0.3436325788497925,
-0.5137515068054199,
0.41805365681648254,
-0.07325553148984909,
-0.2778241038322449,
0.02548747882246971,
-0.8326667547225952,
0.14826402068138123,
-0.2726256549358368,
0.3260782063007355,
0.22082524001598358,
-0.25661617517471313,
0.3809375762939453,
-0.24513791501522064,
0.7817082405090332,
-0.06408923864364624,
-0.0777493342757225,
0.6660898923873901,
0.34100139141082764,
0.39130088686943054,
-0.12056652456521988,
0.44666385650634766,
0.1517253965139389,
0.04776783660054207,
-0.35035452246665955,
-0.3457966446876526,
0.5860824584960938,
-0.5977516770362854,
-0.4354759156703949,
-0.21482886373996735,
-0.7229692339897156,
-0.1100439578294754,
0.15361493825912476,
0.28265896439552307,
0.4888952374458313,
-0.0840451791882515,
0.038279689848423004,
0.4884735643863678,
-0.5559784173965454,
0.5800308585166931,
0.10956289619207382,
-0.13461989164352417,
-0.9087279438972473,
0.9118576049804688,
-0.06639520823955536,
0.29525089263916016,
0.8712285757064819,
-0.04200908541679382,
-0.2682702839374542,
-0.5862431526184082,
-0.8466085195541382,
0.394907146692276,
-0.7186304926872253,
-0.2263234406709671,
-0.3964184820652008,
-0.11107981204986572,
-0.3470604419708252,
-0.5114451050758362,
-0.36759403347969055,
-0.6906822919845581,
-0.18762615323066711,
0.011778617277741432,
0.27927687764167786,
0.2202560156583786,
0.14103969931602478,
0.2799932658672333,
-0.8329667448997498,
0.6330435276031494,
0.3415500223636627,
0.17285697162151337,
0.018126126378774643,
-0.2739448845386505,
-0.03734014928340912,
-0.23032985627651215,
-0.19365333020687103,
-0.6660791039466858,
0.3086733818054199,
0.5286949872970581,
0.04492035508155823,
0.024980681017041206,
0.05004514753818512,
0.5660154819488525,
-0.6738098859786987,
1.0243339538574219,
0.6487245559692383,
-0.9616725444793701,
0.43860846757888794,
-0.23234450817108154,
0.14583805203437805,
0.28758350014686584,
-0.10712962597608566,
-0.16683724522590637,
-0.479786217212677,
-0.32782870531082153,
-0.9208459854125977,
0.558327853679657,
0.49308741092681885,
0.5247865915298462,
0.23847627639770508,
0.40073156356811523,
0.20647893846035004,
0.10639625042676926,
-0.9105684161186218,
-0.12554439902305603,
-0.32226040959358215,
-0.028578869998455048,
0.10598871856927872,
0.07879158854484558,
-0.2286377102136612,
-0.2087891548871994,
0.6452683210372925,
-0.3782989978790283,
0.46067267656326294,
0.33509501814842224,
-0.016369380056858063,
-0.18990182876586914,
0.15319319069385529,
0.4887324571609497,
0.4406246244907379,
0.09800118952989578,
-0.0064193978905677795,
-0.03540131822228432,
-0.07267758995294571,
0.14665713906288147,
-0.02735133282840252,
-0.382683128118515,
0.25808417797088623,
0.3359636068344116,
0.7183233499526978,
-0.05117718502879143,
-0.7281554937362671,
0.6309706568717957,
0.15439380705356598,
-0.5703126788139343,
-0.25886595249176025,
-0.16669853031635284,
-0.09906866401433945,
-0.14474283158779144,
0.32240232825279236,
0.04060530290007591,
0.00398803036659956,
-0.6541229486465454,
-0.053956132382154465,
0.17682264745235443,
-0.11364715546369553,
-0.22443275153636932,
0.8779662251472473,
0.1057492345571518,
0.3936711251735687,
0.23114490509033203,
-0.018788550049066544,
-0.13781651854515076,
0.580238401889801,
0.515172004699707,
0.7944943308830261,
0.17731468379497528,
0.41659417748451233,
0.42967119812965393,
0.21476833522319794,
0.03235646337270737,
0.30354106426239014,
-0.18639536201953888,
-0.35546842217445374,
-0.6539730429649353,
-0.3262064754962921,
-0.5068090558052063,
-0.27121102809906006,
-0.3361629247665405,
0.2563736140727997,
-0.8032468557357788,
0.10303211212158203,
0.3447079658508301,
-0.38305240869522095,
-0.380409836769104,
0.5976949334144592,
0.15060819685459137,
0.5836142301559448,
-0.8354513645172119,
0.6672612428665161,
0.9845304489135742,
-0.7816343903541565,
-0.5916688442230225,
-0.190129354596138,
-0.4458068609237671,
-0.7129666209220886,
0.24150699377059937,
0.15376418828964233,
0.12503503262996674,
-0.11305787414312363,
-1.2261192798614502,
-0.2754371464252472,
0.9785508513450623,
0.2437644600868225,
-0.5067218542098999,
-0.08232156932353973,
0.46094879508018494,
0.4975387752056122,
-0.5913794636726379,
-0.38471147418022156,
0.25672414898872375,
0.4845171570777893,
0.684201180934906,
-0.541178822517395,
0.3219601809978485,
-0.07192052155733109,
0.28421127796173096,
-0.2135617434978485,
-0.456614226102829,
0.41089296340942383,
-0.31951698660850525,
-0.5256405472755432,
0.4958203136920929,
0.6416818499565125,
0.1454637050628662,
0.3836227357387543,
0.34903520345687866,
0.16649065911769867,
0.14297835528850555,
-0.11503996700048447,
1.14463472366333,
-0.21048469841480255,
0.1289789378643036,
0.8766599893569946,
-0.22779881954193115,
0.5653725266456604,
0.714168906211853,
-0.03569437935948372,
0.15512381494045258,
0.4412146210670471,
-0.2748233675956726,
0.8744903206825256,
0.20913605391979218,
-0.20698226988315582,
-0.24256093800067902,
-0.2909048795700073,
0.00497735571116209,
0.22165004909038544,
-0.0022684037685394287,
-0.5242201089859009,
-0.16298890113830566,
-0.11846809089183807,
0.07898897677659988,
0.14620551466941833,
-0.42072930932044983,
0.7841712832450867,
0.0880066454410553,
-0.6683800220489502,
0.9797297716140747,
0.06268924474716187,
0.46153897047042847,
-0.4912891387939453,
-0.02100244350731373,
-0.2716211676597595,
-0.2747654318809509,
-0.3860490024089813,
-0.8097667098045349,
0.25504007935523987,
0.16966067254543304,
-0.03055492602288723,
-0.06126498058438301,
0.5256186127662659,
-0.6509019136428833,
-0.43954935669898987,
-0.1293952614068985,
0.28580909967422485,
0.4317929744720459,
-0.4072902798652649,
-0.25592443346977234,
0.09452363848686218,
0.3254101872444153,
0.06890534609556198,
0.20889034867286682,
0.13149617612361908,
-0.21508009731769562,
0.36553114652633667,
0.832558274269104,
0.2784188985824585,
-0.1340508908033371,
0.1988179236650467,
0.9097822904586792,
-0.6469817161560059,
-0.3396100401878357,
-0.5578896403312683,
0.48923805356025696,
0.14570419490337372,
0.049331165850162506,
0.14035502076148987,
0.3241165280342102,
0.5143424868583679,
-0.6069141626358032,
1.2713228464126587,
-0.2136300951242447,
-0.26657065749168396,
-0.6015281677246094,
0.7461743354797363,
-0.7567651271820068,
-0.29577013850212097,
-0.3434748649597168,
-1.3498659133911133,
-0.8799166083335876,
0.2685237526893616,
0.17280925810337067,
-0.5199111104011536,
0.7952893972396851,
0.9356012344360352,
0.11248856782913208,
-0.045156922191381454,
0.5782151222229004,
-0.18410447239875793,
0.46531254053115845,
0.6988288760185242,
0.47564804553985596,
-0.5848499536514282,
0.8950117230415344,
-0.15374526381492615,
-0.27876904606819153,
0.19322063028812408,
-1.0487830638885498,
-0.9843026995658875,
-0.6478859186172485,
-0.7721004486083984,
0.004595618695020676,
-0.020350906997919083,
0.7771936655044556,
0.48138415813446045,
-0.8627297878265381,
-0.0037281156983226538,
-0.1137920543551445,
-0.18732315301895142,
-0.17202076315879822,
-0.17851771414279938,
0.576327919960022,
-0.239886075258255,
-0.7665776014328003,
0.24207191169261932,
0.5409054160118103,
0.20917101204395294,
-0.009500203654170036,
0.13171273469924927,
0.26060885190963745,
0.4391479790210724,
0.7499871253967285,
0.31828945875167847,
-0.48079338669776917,
-0.26160678267478943,
-0.05794185400009155,
0.06789811700582504,
0.27959102392196655,
0.5967404842376709,
-0.21111160516738892,
0.6644909977912903,
0.3577211797237396,
0.7638497352600098,
0.76678067445755,
-0.06876473873853683,
0.1718878597021103,
-0.8502039313316345,
0.23858895897865295,
-0.24440132081508636,
0.13638241589069366,
0.4921990633010864,
-0.07422560453414917,
0.534360408782959,
0.10073085874319077,
-0.1913871020078659,
-0.509990394115448,
0.24702052772045135,
-1.3008254766464233,
-0.28198322653770447,
1.115709662437439,
-0.13123548030853271,
-0.3958926200866699,
0.5798043012619019,
-0.5263758301734924,
0.3914124071598053,
-0.4023398756980896,
0.9787439703941345,
0.34626275300979614,
0.17845115065574646,
-0.3532333970069885,
-0.20947568118572235,
0.15275543928146362,
0.06155075877904892,
-1.0109162330627441,
0.010616916231811047,
0.9013984799385071,
0.41640201210975647,
0.3091302514076233,
0.45717528462409973,
-0.6053305864334106,
0.4996173679828644,
-0.07697606086730957,
0.49190500378608704,
-0.33663496375083923,
-0.4591016471385956,
0.040664125233888626,
0.07439692318439484,
-0.025363871827721596,
-0.3984474539756775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18241v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18241v1
|
Active Use of Latent Constituency Representation in both Humans and Large Language Models
| 2024-05-28T14:50:22 | 2024-05-28T14:50:22 |
Wei Liu, Ming Xiang, Nai Ding
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Understanding how sentences are internally represented in the human brain, as
well as in large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT, is a major challenge
for cognitive science. Classic linguistic theories propose that the brain
represents a sentence by parsing it into hierarchically organized constituents.
In contrast, LLMs do not explicitly parse linguistic constituents and their
latent representations remains poorly explained. Here, we demonstrate that
humans and LLMs construct similar latent representations of hierarchical
linguistic constituents by analyzing their behaviors during a novel one-shot
learning task, in which they infer which words should be deleted from a
sentence. Both humans and LLMs tend to delete a constituent, instead of a
nonconstituent word string. In contrast, a naive sequence processing model that
has access to word properties and ordinal positions does not show this
property. Based on the word deletion behaviors, we can reconstruct the latent
constituency tree representation of a sentence for both humans and LLMs. These
results demonstrate that a latent tree-structured constituency representation
can emerge in both the human brain and LLMs.
|
[
-0.007751988247036934,
-1.0140117406845093,
0.6772777438163757,
-0.15344731509685516,
-0.31371957063674927,
0.19285325706005096,
-0.33940550684928894,
-0.20978134870529175,
0.060336511582136154,
0.30486905574798584,
-0.49084654450416565,
-0.31990042328834534,
-0.30920976400375366,
-0.16826152801513672,
-0.2399599850177765,
0.8606844544410706,
0.3712955415248871,
-0.01598428376019001,
-0.270869642496109,
0.046830132603645325,
-0.22449979186058044,
-1.0000044107437134,
-0.5496122241020203,
-0.48901617527008057,
0.7618611454963684,
0.11600732803344727,
0.6915786862373352,
0.589678943157196,
0.315439909696579,
0.33901163935661316,
-0.36593198776245117,
-0.27847570180892944,
-0.5531148314476013,
0.07834761589765549,
-0.08064307272434235,
-0.7033023238182068,
-0.329289048910141,
0.21452274918556213,
0.8114446997642517,
1.2366621494293213,
-0.34633415937423706,
-0.4673849642276764,
0.22877579927444458,
0.49381163716316223,
-0.36754995584487915,
0.31847572326660156,
-0.8370254039764404,
0.14903506636619568,
-0.3423053026199341,
-0.2537674009799957,
-0.2478921264410019,
-0.127024307847023,
0.20881754159927368,
-0.3467487394809723,
0.13883589208126068,
-0.03804521635174751,
0.7649033069610596,
0.012751876376569271,
-0.4907729923725128,
-0.11239125579595566,
-0.4264205992221832,
0.4163490831851959,
-0.461146742105484,
0.4189883768558502,
0.4228576421737671,
-0.05434896796941757,
-0.31245848536491394,
-0.4837454557418823,
-0.6006841659545898,
-0.3943348824977875,
-0.3843102753162384,
-0.07046794891357422,
0.03450955078005791,
0.25913065671920776,
0.28386181592941284,
0.2682468295097351,
-0.6666057109832764,
0.24055981636047363,
-0.32988205552101135,
-0.4228877127170563,
0.2540103495121002,
0.3314289152622223,
0.3106718957424164,
-0.722535252571106,
-0.31444990634918213,
0.0431608222424984,
-0.8619500994682312,
0.21997980773448944,
0.3678618371486664,
0.5390297174453735,
0.04876916483044624,
0.7153871059417725,
0.273266464471817,
0.5302647948265076,
-0.16890406608581543,
0.004741599317640066,
0.038719482719898224,
0.00892632082104683,
-0.20235545933246613,
0.019814951345324516,
0.948417067527771,
-0.11197958141565323,
0.19535745680332184,
-0.32398444414138794,
-0.20724008977413177,
0.18074624240398407,
0.28235867619514465,
-0.5047852396965027,
-0.25405973196029663,
-0.05862922593951225,
-0.735673725605011,
-0.12821486592292786,
0.05112035199999809,
-0.5234735608100891,
-0.5761876702308655,
-0.2921818494796753,
0.17167535424232483,
-0.5582638382911682,
-0.2443007528781891,
-0.01819399558007717,
0.11480399966239929,
0.3117642104625702,
0.08514337241649628,
-1.1123239994049072,
0.41869884729385376,
0.8300326466560364,
0.5609006881713867,
-0.21096424758434296,
-0.4135459065437317,
-0.39393314719200134,
-0.008720103651285172,
-0.45596715807914734,
0.6950239539146423,
-0.7508355379104614,
-0.27680259943008423,
-0.018815593793988228,
0.051488909870386124,
-0.15318280458450317,
-0.7297943234443665,
0.2149454802274704,
-0.5821266174316406,
0.42203041911125183,
-0.48140010237693787,
-0.7642813920974731,
-0.324741393327713,
0.2533762753009796,
-0.4328720271587372,
0.5230380892753601,
0.16214841604232788,
-0.8180157542228699,
0.27476125955581665,
-0.60988450050354,
-0.33301809430122375,
0.11901839077472687,
-0.6487124562263489,
-0.3284912109375,
0.3540068566799164,
-0.00546928821131587,
0.6180305480957031,
0.12887759506702423,
0.29434648156166077,
-0.19869999587535858,
-0.23880811035633087,
0.46601998805999756,
-0.5673898458480835,
0.8998651504516602,
-0.0941147655248642,
0.02342870458960533,
0.0794794112443924,
-0.4940713942050934,
-0.2696016728878021,
0.1603722870349884,
-0.5654004812240601,
-0.2913205325603485,
0.44460755586624146,
-0.14535292983055115,
-0.042044974863529205,
0.2163356989622116,
-0.7274064421653748,
0.44790396094322205,
-0.6107901930809021,
0.8541904091835022,
0.636042058467865,
0.22507773339748383,
0.5486207604408264,
-0.12630976736545563,
0.2725890874862671,
0.2717278301715851,
-0.434058278799057,
-0.45716243982315063,
-0.2600201666355133,
-0.6245968341827393,
-0.17270508408546448,
0.03193751350045204,
0.455228716135025,
-0.4149690568447113,
0.37103238701820374,
-0.36845704913139343,
0.10595846176147461,
-0.15335194766521454,
-0.1539713442325592,
0.1647542417049408,
0.32414132356643677,
0.17278391122817993,
-0.2150566726922989,
-0.450149804353714,
-1.081991195678711,
-0.25335443019866943,
-0.6807319521903992,
-0.19782015681266785,
0.16955024003982544,
0.46280667185783386,
0.08779162913560867,
1.1850396394729614,
-0.5406084656715393,
-0.20067453384399414,
-0.12169622629880905,
0.31714481115341187,
-0.1732075959444046,
0.3791313171386719,
0.49343159794807434,
-0.5341799259185791,
0.19181734323501587,
0.0019498149631544948,
-0.7391349077224731,
0.1360544115304947,
-0.20696350932121277,
0.03465442359447479,
0.18983837962150574,
0.5342540144920349,
-0.5540227293968201,
0.5851181745529175,
0.22287584841251373,
-0.6136983633041382,
0.3458171486854553,
-0.14757783710956573,
0.02711658924818039,
-1.0308836698532104,
0.00033767620334401727,
-0.38835760951042175,
-0.44378262758255005,
-0.20904357731342316,
-0.07825589179992676,
-0.027355527505278587,
-0.22230423986911774,
-0.2513822913169861,
0.16329152882099152,
-0.513786792755127,
-0.35290947556495667,
0.0006108995294198394,
0.03492226079106331,
-0.25894686579704285,
0.8219782710075378,
0.23568567633628845,
0.7483896017074585,
0.42966169118881226,
-0.3379717171192169,
-0.010088874958455563,
0.08649551123380661,
-0.4424903094768524,
0.35600200295448303,
-0.5814997553825378,
0.0401889942586422,
-0.547776460647583,
0.13456812500953674,
-1.200823187828064,
-0.27575406432151794,
0.25024956464767456,
-0.3298797607421875,
0.3099534213542938,
-0.004532841965556145,
-0.6334388852119446,
-0.06795097142457962,
0.016157003119587898,
0.23397774994373322,
0.568790853023529,
-0.3002088963985443,
0.27645260095596313,
0.5626541972160339,
-0.2370070368051529,
-0.0756765604019165,
-0.8832618594169617,
0.17098650336265564,
-0.3602878153324127,
-0.3114216923713684,
0.4624096155166626,
0.31447985768318176,
-0.217472106218338,
0.13813823461532593,
-0.05369306728243828,
-0.2069355845451355,
0.012783273123204708,
0.29490190744400024,
0.20901073515415192,
-0.29439276456832886,
0.549703061580658,
-0.23016709089279175,
0.043953023850917816,
0.2689468562602997,
-0.04209790751338005,
0.4941351115703583,
0.05009818822145462,
-0.44175979495048523,
-0.4708385765552521,
0.6196057200431824,
0.6067531704902649,
-0.20776478946208954,
0.7043799757957458,
0.22561265528202057,
-0.574179470539093,
0.1401926577091217,
-0.34400674700737,
-0.48984137177467346,
-0.3724779486656189,
0.7060317993164062,
-0.34280824661254883,
-1.0811923742294312,
0.672314465045929,
0.08342904597520828,
0.0925997868180275,
0.11469016969203949,
0.46053117513656616,
-0.25625237822532654,
0.6868480443954468,
0.3633185029029846,
-0.035056207329034805,
0.6091803312301636,
-0.21366049349308014,
0.14288902282714844,
-0.987829864025116,
-0.3429346978664398,
-0.5978797674179077,
-0.31815508008003235,
-0.5036619305610657,
-0.46364548802375793,
0.29071706533432007,
0.1415461003780365,
-0.3720094561576843,
0.2361198365688324,
-0.35734274983406067,
0.48888736963272095,
0.2609269917011261,
0.3133011758327484,
0.13319166004657745,
0.2749400734901428,
-0.39474552869796753,
-0.421591579914093,
-0.5997998118400574,
-0.7777531743049622,
0.6568871140480042,
0.26494869589805603,
0.5115466713905334,
0.03674633800983429,
0.6980597972869873,
-0.0496387705206871,
0.07439815998077393,
-1.0852572917938232,
0.7983179688453674,
-0.3592211902141571,
-0.4525403082370758,
-0.1106499657034874,
-0.5084055662155151,
-1.3338054418563843,
0.4881843030452728,
-0.15603674948215485,
-1.2314655780792236,
0.14647243916988373,
-0.12336916476488113,
-0.4291146993637085,
0.4670852720737457,
-0.5937916040420532,
0.9964717030525208,
-0.0645454078912735,
-0.3053446114063263,
-0.17571935057640076,
-0.5079845190048218,
0.2071840763092041,
0.23647569119930267,
-0.09310836344957352,
0.013980492018163204,
-0.35759374499320984,
0.9527485966682434,
-0.5169646143913269,
0.9818350672721863,
-0.15469342470169067,
-0.10360381752252579,
0.49559736251831055,
0.3314583897590637,
0.22332575917243958,
0.0317695327103138,
-0.07572544366121292,
0.0013597995275631547,
-0.12680572271347046,
-0.2721303403377533,
-0.7616957426071167,
0.602677047252655,
-0.9172831773757935,
-0.579293966293335,
-0.5074150562286377,
-0.31812429428100586,
-0.0986577644944191,
-0.0794883593916893,
0.07235629111528397,
0.5211697220802307,
-0.5046131014823914,
0.49789178371429443,
0.29353776574134827,
-0.23538710176944733,
0.7560855150222778,
0.36543524265289307,
-0.2268235832452774,
-0.07779030501842499,
0.701576292514801,
0.21723583340644836,
0.06364374607801437,
0.6189451217651367,
0.21878638863563538,
-0.28152090311050415,
-0.5254881381988525,
0.19672293961048126,
0.24100849032402039,
-0.4243966341018677,
0.23125587403774261,
-0.7725263833999634,
-0.2884006202220917,
-0.11028023064136505,
0.07042524218559265,
-0.25804248452186584,
-0.31861650943756104,
-0.39998146891593933,
-0.09727759659290314,
0.047771260142326355,
0.9146433472633362,
0.06426110118627548,
0.38752481341362,
-0.7000777125358582,
0.2751002907752991,
0.6740671396255493,
0.14753246307373047,
0.16634221374988556,
-0.3779987096786499,
0.13444381952285767,
0.22312213480472565,
-0.43790072202682495,
-1.1535817384719849,
0.2972175180912018,
0.3222024142742157,
0.6001033186912537,
0.40781736373901367,
-0.30408793687820435,
0.819339394569397,
-0.6137712001800537,
1.1637629270553589,
0.015188643708825111,
-0.7724230289459229,
0.4171905517578125,
-0.574329137802124,
0.561941921710968,
0.32575827836990356,
0.27344417572021484,
-0.71783447265625,
-0.16542553901672363,
-0.4529010057449341,
-0.6935258507728577,
0.7595487236976624,
0.32689741253852844,
0.28435420989990234,
-0.4390178322792053,
0.521147608757019,
0.18085908889770508,
0.1256156861782074,
-0.7820535898208618,
0.031114323064684868,
-0.06383851915597916,
0.10113932937383652,
-0.039381567388772964,
-0.23289360105991364,
0.1957099735736847,
-0.12226223200559616,
0.1394273191690445,
0.042724743485450745,
0.48789292573928833,
0.17062115669250488,
-0.017889734357595444,
0.057080648839473724,
0.4228542745113373,
0.13456034660339355,
0.3961271643638611,
-0.07538961619138718,
0.24358418583869934,
-0.21566030383110046,
-0.278789222240448,
0.049796316772699356,
-0.28094998002052307,
-0.025055881589651108,
-0.25308850407600403,
0.868313193321228,
0.7412174344062805,
0.46626901626586914,
-0.4425983428955078,
0.5204837322235107,
-0.05154568701982498,
-0.10022180527448654,
-0.12005850672721863,
-0.1390712559223175,
0.5325660109519958,
0.069435715675354,
0.4114001393318176,
0.1390291005373001,
-0.017109479755163193,
-1.0971430540084839,
0.20626051723957062,
0.4647597670555115,
-0.32490018010139465,
-0.6193355321884155,
0.4679111838340759,
-0.04273089021444321,
-0.4955596625804901,
1.0005921125411987,
-0.2986777722835541,
-0.7357706427574158,
0.43476009368896484,
0.34597915410995483,
0.9286425709724426,
0.007500265259295702,
0.2928239405155182,
0.3523625433444977,
0.097772516310215,
0.23518234491348267,
0.19201526045799255,
-0.09723903238773346,
-0.7929118275642395,
-0.4121795892715454,
-0.5767386555671692,
0.14286990463733673,
0.30293890833854675,
-0.5111477971076965,
-0.03338729217648506,
-0.23982219398021698,
-0.16980776190757751,
0.2966760993003845,
0.06364043802022934,
-0.5670539736747742,
-0.1511697918176651,
0.34676843881607056,
0.13097183406352997,
-0.8045579195022583,
0.7589749693870544,
0.8702801465988159,
-0.41983774304389954,
-1.0076223611831665,
0.27614566683769226,
0.10944317281246185,
-0.5344025492668152,
0.6536573767662048,
0.10650563985109329,
0.29212406277656555,
-0.178813636302948,
-0.509156346321106,
-0.5213049650192261,
0.6704588532447815,
0.5552561283111572,
-0.5701869130134583,
-0.30317914485931396,
0.13662417232990265,
0.675895631313324,
-0.4801110327243805,
0.15133139491081238,
0.18373557925224304,
0.18414142727851868,
0.25984469056129456,
-0.6914201378822327,
-0.06098153069615364,
0.14068850874900818,
0.13706547021865845,
0.2629435956478119,
-0.3476666808128357,
1.2826592922210693,
-0.0936208963394165,
-0.5693673491477966,
0.055716387927532196,
0.6267465949058533,
0.19931738078594208,
-0.2566511332988739,
0.5380265712738037,
0.3158629536628723,
0.7367182374000549,
-0.07958890497684479,
0.892026960849762,
0.047174058854579926,
0.3351074457168579,
1.2547872066497803,
-0.2057163268327713,
1.110876441001892,
0.6538727879524231,
-0.36004626750946045,
0.637008786201477,
0.7369318008422852,
0.5182801485061646,
0.4690364599227905,
0.5257505774497986,
-0.18021704256534576,
-0.4384935796260834,
0.09360393136739731,
-0.04319573938846588,
0.9887620210647583,
0.4756704866886139,
-0.20195844769477844,
-0.3979058563709259,
-0.04423772543668747,
0.04472682625055313,
0.24157656729221344,
-0.057292427867650986,
1.1008708477020264,
0.043706540018320084,
-0.856925368309021,
0.5630367994308472,
-0.26671311259269714,
0.47669002413749695,
-0.5678195357322693,
-0.17747290432453156,
-0.1285591423511505,
-0.030881302431225777,
-0.15942126512527466,
-0.8461574912071228,
0.5231655836105347,
-0.16593976318836212,
-0.10532208532094955,
-0.30237868428230286,
0.3781738579273224,
-0.7829912900924683,
-0.3065553903579712,
0.24128226935863495,
0.7127025127410889,
0.4239409267902374,
-0.13262557983398438,
-0.5811893343925476,
0.047396834939718246,
0.019717823714017868,
-0.5303694605827332,
0.34171047806739807,
0.6328803300857544,
-0.17492423951625824,
0.4581182599067688,
0.46424150466918945,
0.2611190974712372,
0.06153661757707596,
0.08369997143745422,
0.9862934350967407,
-0.7673549652099609,
-0.490816593170166,
-0.9560080170631409,
0.4705978333950043,
-0.015266213566064835,
-0.10091149061918259,
0.29252150654792786,
0.5895732641220093,
0.6078850626945496,
0.009669845923781395,
0.5506044626235962,
-0.317082941532135,
0.33066311478614807,
-0.4826248586177826,
0.7368261218070984,
-0.6314871311187744,
0.25912269949913025,
-0.08323628455400467,
-1.123040795326233,
-0.24834923446178436,
1.008598804473877,
-0.2780570983886719,
0.17497894167900085,
1.125794768333435,
0.9368213415145874,
-0.11473024636507034,
0.007725230883806944,
0.4328584671020508,
0.44867947697639465,
0.3364967405796051,
0.7601412534713745,
0.7975733876228333,
-0.24383559823036194,
0.35869523882865906,
-0.06351027637720108,
-0.05378653109073639,
0.12981489300727844,
-0.7672102451324463,
-0.9925646185874939,
-0.884087324142456,
-0.37916722893714905,
0.05879594013094902,
0.013873209245502949,
1.050758957862854,
0.82161945104599,
-0.5372582077980042,
-0.38213738799095154,
-0.20162273943424225,
0.03465474024415016,
-0.08081493526697159,
-0.2679004669189453,
0.46134689450263977,
-0.3836212754249573,
-0.5956850647926331,
0.388672411441803,
0.3654797673225403,
-0.00529906153678894,
-0.5147343277931213,
0.25444018840789795,
-0.49188926815986633,
-0.16024087369441986,
0.6661417484283447,
-0.05019668489694595,
-1.0665717124938965,
-0.5720284581184387,
-0.0573606863617897,
-0.3866206407546997,
0.30562373995780945,
1.167601466178894,
-1.1856086254119873,
0.3314085006713867,
0.8219541907310486,
0.3884562849998474,
0.14920814335346222,
0.024471137672662735,
0.5756358504295349,
-0.9300287961959839,
0.25664693117141724,
0.47215956449508667,
0.4182654619216919,
0.41687247157096863,
-0.14448586106300354,
0.2835409939289093,
0.2975813150405884,
-0.45284610986709595,
-0.5150890350341797,
0.34478938579559326,
-0.9915164709091187,
-0.47173434495925903,
0.9882915019989014,
-0.2804703116416931,
-0.4225923717021942,
-0.11569077521562576,
-0.56905597448349,
0.20908354222774506,
-0.435605525970459,
0.6477421522140503,
0.8552983999252319,
0.007299872115254402,
-0.36066383123397827,
-0.23572827875614166,
0.3102056682109833,
0.395935982465744,
-0.66150963306427,
0.2936095595359802,
0.5682153105735779,
0.1310471147298813,
0.11464706808328629,
0.6447489261627197,
-0.24549080431461334,
-0.024985646829009056,
0.04100549593567848,
-0.1863812953233719,
0.08175968378782272,
-0.02358751744031906,
-0.33827733993530273,
0.584686815738678,
-0.11286837607622147,
-0.24550870060920715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18208v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18208v1
|
A Human-Like Reasoning Framework for Multi-Phases Planning Task with Large Language Models
| 2024-05-28T14:13:32 | 2024-05-28T14:13:32 |
Chengxing Xie, Difan Zou
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent studies have highlighted their proficiency in some simple tasks like
writing and coding through various reasoning strategies. However, LLM agents
still struggle with tasks that require comprehensive planning, a process that
challenges current models and remains a critical research issue. In this study,
we concentrate on travel planning, a Multi-Phases planning problem, that
involves multiple interconnected stages, such as outlining, information
gathering, and planning, often characterized by the need to manage various
constraints and uncertainties. Existing reasoning approaches have struggled to
effectively address this complex task. Our research aims to address this
challenge by developing a human-like planning framework for LLM agents, i.e.,
guiding the LLM agent to simulate various steps that humans take when solving
Multi-Phases problems. Specifically, we implement several strategies to enable
LLM agents to generate a coherent outline for each travel query, mirroring
human planning patterns. Additionally, we integrate Strategy Block and
Knowledge Block into our framework: Strategy Block facilitates information
collection, while Knowledge Block provides essential information for detailed
planning. Through our extensive experiments, we demonstrate that our framework
significantly improves the planning capabilities of LLM agents, enabling them
to tackle the travel planning task with improved efficiency and effectiveness.
Our experimental results showcase the exceptional performance of the proposed
framework; when combined with GPT-4-Turbo, it attains $10\times$ the
performance gains in comparison to the baseline framework deployed on
GPT-4-Turbo.
|
[
-0.375505268573761,
-0.46892595291137695,
1.1346791982650757,
0.33373358845710754,
-0.035974130034446716,
0.16599400341510773,
-0.13367055356502533,
-0.1985156536102295,
0.1324765533208847,
0.47316670417785645,
-0.9903910160064697,
-0.39311015605926514,
-0.05346525087952614,
0.13856764137744904,
-0.16559399664402008,
0.31374725699424744,
-0.3296906054019928,
-0.13660545647144318,
0.11130712181329727,
0.3319460451602936,
-0.37286892533302307,
-0.5659549236297607,
-0.6893470287322998,
-0.8357269763946533,
0.49521031975746155,
0.6682988405227661,
0.6932899951934814,
0.29521262645721436,
0.23260211944580078,
0.2607823610305786,
0.003025968326255679,
0.47119632363319397,
-0.05742049589753151,
0.32229217886924744,
-0.4296230971813202,
-0.22612904012203217,
-0.5720533728599548,
-0.5166364908218384,
0.546214759349823,
0.49607858061790466,
-0.4063820242881775,
-0.12694112956523895,
-0.020359016954898834,
0.49915942549705505,
-0.20082634687423706,
0.4190457761287689,
-0.5765817761421204,
0.0698103979229927,
-0.039378367364406586,
-0.36789387464523315,
-0.09656748175621033,
0.11838939040899277,
0.15256361663341522,
-0.8514024615287781,
0.3406873643398285,
0.26127374172210693,
0.5792518854141235,
0.1437056064605713,
-0.409332811832428,
-0.2626644968986511,
-0.9998508095741272,
0.4186970591545105,
-0.4966700077056885,
0.3324844539165497,
0.3915764391422272,
0.2878398895263672,
-0.6449839472770691,
-0.41688603162765503,
-0.7615281343460083,
-0.06627680361270905,
0.09487516433000565,
-0.024204887449741364,
0.2856571674346924,
0.3117976486682892,
0.1670123189687729,
-0.5116003751754761,
-0.836304783821106,
-0.11640498787164688,
-0.07519759982824326,
-0.2955188453197479,
0.5917875170707703,
0.29839739203453064,
0.12941770255565643,
-0.09953919053077698,
-0.4711401164531708,
0.09152045100927353,
-0.7127727270126343,
0.06797605752944946,
0.08731209486722946,
0.36505547165870667,
-0.015378210693597794,
0.4525561034679413,
-0.6505416631698608,
0.5460383296012878,
-0.0439169742166996,
-0.3525817096233368,
-0.11955732107162476,
-0.586300253868103,
-0.30895498394966125,
-0.15041087567806244,
0.3648059070110321,
0.4015592932701111,
0.219253808259964,
-0.37295079231262207,
-0.348987340927124,
-0.32445839047431946,
0.2452867478132248,
-0.7908056378364563,
-0.05310172960162163,
0.40453705191612244,
-0.223602294921875,
0.06084489822387695,
-0.2799972891807556,
-0.7946266531944275,
-0.44365227222442627,
-0.471957266330719,
0.27676862478256226,
-0.4936503469944,
-0.47403109073638916,
0.510762631893158,
0.09773285686969757,
0.41752928495407104,
0.7466897964477539,
-0.7693334221839905,
0.27646997570991516,
0.7004398703575134,
0.6261129379272461,
0.06405583024024963,
-0.6686193346977234,
-0.13100430369377136,
0.5640321373939514,
-0.18021157383918762,
1.1760050058364868,
-0.2802148461341858,
-0.6847895979881287,
0.24391807615756989,
-0.16182833909988403,
-0.11781495809555054,
-0.39847204089164734,
0.5214881300926208,
-0.2745223045349121,
-0.17753873765468597,
-0.7165477871894836,
-0.0393395759165287,
-0.559298574924469,
0.9185116291046143,
-0.35085198283195496,
0.6590166687965393,
0.037829380482435226,
-0.2265983372926712,
0.3596968948841095,
-0.7059175968170166,
-0.5857301354408264,
0.0827161967754364,
-0.30997374653816223,
-0.11470133811235428,
-0.3730960190296173,
0.20400193333625793,
0.575065016746521,
-0.5280455350875854,
0.42358332872390747,
-0.060076337307691574,
-0.368649423122406,
0.12450483441352844,
0.22092077136039734,
0.3063229024410248,
0.09131830185651779,
-0.5588192939758301,
0.46181246638298035,
-0.525791347026825,
0.2592114508152008,
0.023024018853902817,
-0.6827166080474854,
0.29413115978240967,
0.32149451971054077,
-0.10030806809663773,
0.4966817796230316,
0.15527884662151337,
-0.2818784713745117,
0.5686923861503601,
-0.1427009105682373,
0.4385407865047455,
0.6724808216094971,
0.029408302158117294,
0.7766061425209045,
-0.5942374467849731,
0.7346007823944092,
-0.053321193903684616,
0.22960074245929718,
-0.12109475582838058,
-0.43961405754089355,
-0.8583486080169678,
0.25348249077796936,
-0.22520115971565247,
0.5862952470779419,
-0.8505851626396179,
0.26386886835098267,
-0.28804636001586914,
-0.16028882563114166,
0.09977813810110092,
-0.01682749018073082,
0.25248560309410095,
0.3992023169994354,
0.4477475881576538,
0.19371509552001953,
-0.35036084055900574,
-0.6071964502334595,
0.04532293230295181,
-0.414302796125412,
0.1255474090576172,
-0.03629913181066513,
0.6954272389411926,
-0.2533561587333679,
0.8098150491714478,
-0.4401707351207733,
-0.28511708974838257,
-0.6576220393180847,
0.24868632853031158,
-0.17177295684814453,
0.4241834878921509,
0.16010533273220062,
-0.8695635795593262,
-0.14968492090702057,
-0.16088160872459412,
-0.5802931785583496,
0.09201407432556152,
-0.5826635360717773,
-0.6317706108093262,
-0.09157037734985352,
0.3944665789604187,
-0.8184404969215393,
0.28364866971969604,
0.12532010674476624,
-0.7214180827140808,
0.7401049733161926,
-0.2574641704559326,
0.05555884912610054,
-0.9228561520576477,
-0.08521538227796555,
0.042717646807432175,
-0.4119565486907959,
-0.7431921362876892,
0.31079843640327454,
-0.03136983513832092,
-0.08916023373603821,
-0.32752305269241333,
0.47309979796409607,
-0.49193429946899414,
0.038795169442892075,
-0.3412819504737854,
-0.12671436369419098,
0.26086926460266113,
0.9369131326675415,
0.21273602545261383,
0.730823814868927,
0.3350493311882019,
-0.39078691601753235,
0.16316533088684082,
0.30160602927207947,
0.12359561026096344,
0.7562779784202576,
-0.30067166686058044,
0.22297360002994537,
-0.23104675114154816,
0.7520991563796997,
-0.5684115290641785,
-0.19856064021587372,
0.44662222266197205,
0.02189270593225956,
0.3361426889896393,
-0.19557201862335205,
-0.664300799369812,
-0.33107128739356995,
-0.34919223189353943,
0.24289272725582123,
0.2523016631603241,
-0.10258615761995316,
1.2916548252105713,
0.1818334311246872,
-0.15205007791519165,
-0.1933312714099884,
-0.5330899953842163,
0.23169223964214325,
-0.33311617374420166,
-0.7872710824012756,
0.5606430172920227,
-0.1939018964767456,
-0.24825617671012878,
-0.006871133577078581,
-0.2829623222351074,
-0.32607725262641907,
-0.15303321182727814,
0.33411145210266113,
0.15088723599910736,
0.1221134290099144,
-0.153525248169899,
-0.05793250352144241,
-0.11375406384468079,
0.10717523843050003,
-0.5881390571594238,
0.7510854005813599,
-0.004317175131291151,
-0.4078778624534607,
-0.39207467436790466,
0.5975961685180664,
0.45892155170440674,
-0.13878017663955688,
0.30396708846092224,
0.34324556589126587,
-0.3664530813694,
-0.3640837073326111,
-0.5995065569877625,
-0.08062712848186493,
-0.4176790714263916,
0.226583331823349,
-0.9282681941986084,
-0.5268370509147644,
0.447237491607666,
-0.3279261291027069,
0.18053986132144928,
0.020809607580304146,
0.5750047564506531,
-0.11026690900325775,
0.8231686353683472,
0.521361231803894,
0.22043000161647797,
-0.07416480034589767,
-0.4014117419719696,
-0.0558789037168026,
-0.8795086741447449,
-0.6412969827651978,
-0.5759770274162292,
-0.3126731514930725,
-0.130945086479187,
-1.1471973657608032,
0.410675585269928,
0.009542269632220268,
-0.4287305772304535,
0.1449812948703766,
-0.24761158227920532,
0.2747727632522583,
0.3962401747703552,
-0.09576068818569183,
0.5548940300941467,
-0.3060302436351776,
-0.29306554794311523,
0.47555458545684814,
-0.6439112424850464,
-0.5631566643714905,
0.8439883589744568,
0.07283668220043182,
0.7174989581108093,
-0.06408075988292694,
0.6187037825584412,
0.06830297410488129,
-0.10355187207460403,
-0.5391507148742676,
0.8564416170120239,
0.49036476016044617,
-0.7468120455741882,
-0.49617913365364075,
-0.3975151777267456,
-0.7576788663864136,
0.6060177683830261,
-0.2863280177116394,
-0.6482991576194763,
0.27311447262763977,
0.07053711265325546,
-0.5336005091667175,
0.4226685166358948,
-0.6368685364723206,
0.3931860327720642,
-0.4925749897956848,
-0.3071346580982208,
-0.3287016749382019,
-0.6160558462142944,
0.16202935576438904,
-0.30858302116394043,
0.3424064517021179,
-0.5389962196350098,
-0.10695983469486237,
0.47860315442085266,
-0.19453838467597961,
0.540300190448761,
-0.2334083765745163,
0.0991845428943634,
0.3278302550315857,
0.3877326548099518,
0.6735298037528992,
-0.07720829546451569,
-0.253171443939209,
0.0593382865190506,
-0.15476013720035553,
-0.38071689009666443,
-0.46707069873809814,
0.5165361166000366,
-0.4947628974914551,
-0.447971910238266,
-0.28376805782318115,
-0.8812987208366394,
-0.37787312269210815,
0.3765699565410614,
0.007334042806178331,
0.3552967309951782,
-0.04024609923362732,
-0.6055572628974915,
0.3144574761390686,
-0.16489464044570923,
0.5166985988616943,
0.7143152356147766,
-0.36141437292099,
-0.10244479030370712,
0.7765052914619446,
0.12933184206485748,
0.12855757772922516,
0.5396804213523865,
0.029340222477912903,
-0.5764511823654175,
-0.9646073579788208,
-0.4533366858959198,
0.3092416524887085,
-0.5441053509712219,
-0.06945207715034485,
-0.46982383728027344,
0.04121983423829079,
-0.3386116027832031,
-0.33264702558517456,
-0.1924777626991272,
-0.2985379695892334,
0.24380028247833252,
0.09046950936317444,
-0.38383087515830994,
0.8082437515258789,
0.10598951578140259,
0.3020985722541809,
-0.3572307527065277,
0.46701475977897644,
0.29878541827201843,
0.09462985396385193,
-0.004169147927314043,
0.124590203166008,
-0.24312683939933777,
-0.01840466819703579,
-0.5911375880241394,
-0.7149562835693359,
0.2584376335144043,
-0.2677106261253357,
0.5702247023582458,
0.2672267556190491,
0.06306806951761246,
0.9943597316741943,
-0.5545198917388916,
0.6021581888198853,
0.030203785747289658,
-0.5861307978630066,
0.43132367730140686,
-0.5776808261871338,
0.392397940158844,
0.723017692565918,
0.22061580419540405,
-0.34284090995788574,
-0.29030856490135193,
-0.594460129737854,
-0.8967800140380859,
0.5705876350402832,
0.48383671045303345,
-0.6347136497497559,
0.524949848651886,
0.279962956905365,
-0.16584601998329163,
0.39140623807907104,
-0.5710049271583557,
0.10039868950843811,
-0.06357520073652267,
0.23484519124031067,
0.03409558907151222,
-0.36027249693870544,
-0.1334737241268158,
-0.2859153151512146,
0.6132651567459106,
-0.19533173739910126,
0.35452139377593994,
0.33730244636535645,
0.1107720211148262,
-0.1618347018957138,
0.4102965295314789,
0.8386419415473938,
0.9762368202209473,
-0.31176072359085083,
0.24231700599193573,
0.10972052067518234,
-0.2275029718875885,
0.4305839538574219,
0.38561075925827026,
-0.3864654004573822,
-0.47473859786987305,
0.3028234541416168,
0.15241248905658722,
0.12867777049541473,
-0.7089503407478333,
0.16555960476398468,
-0.149337500333786,
-0.49243515729904175,
-0.4892372786998749,
0.054788149893283844,
0.3012278378009796,
0.5234002470970154,
0.2102690488100052,
0.09488378465175629,
0.15804265439510345,
-0.36786484718322754,
-0.1241598129272461,
0.1242433488368988,
-0.08147872239351273,
-0.459206759929657,
0.7032479643821716,
0.5898858904838562,
-0.48942649364471436,
0.4302211105823517,
-0.7479300498962402,
-0.6649567484855652,
0.38582685589790344,
0.38907310366630554,
0.7694212794303894,
-0.07895717024803162,
0.32357528805732727,
0.19426612555980682,
0.492859423160553,
-0.4605489671230316,
0.7377365827560425,
-0.1681845635175705,
-0.9082723259925842,
-0.7136291861534119,
-0.6421474814414978,
-0.33535996079444885,
-0.15836001932621002,
0.07010050117969513,
0.21075904369354248,
-0.3402716815471649,
0.0005649013910442591,
-0.6375134587287903,
0.06538628786802292,
-0.7206196784973145,
-0.04374087229371071,
0.3319995105266571,
0.8290669918060303,
-0.37595054507255554,
0.7081469297409058,
0.9295554757118225,
-0.4165780246257782,
-1.327284812927246,
0.42641735076904297,
0.3435872793197632,
-0.7928393483161926,
0.36862823367118835,
0.22202999889850616,
-0.5595250129699707,
-0.08694686740636826,
0.00195501372218132,
-0.7228338122367859,
1.2310925722122192,
0.14181670546531677,
-0.6829611659049988,
-0.80195152759552,
0.3494618237018585,
0.06358445435762405,
-0.3456612825393677,
0.00022968639677856117,
0.6571645140647888,
0.7802008986473083,
0.41423431038856506,
-0.9660840630531311,
0.28333553671836853,
0.13293132185935974,
-0.0568351112306118,
0.18979308009147644,
-0.5701888203620911,
0.7600586414337158,
-0.25803142786026,
-0.1969202607870102,
0.05534131079912186,
0.36867740750312805,
0.48197752237319946,
0.45556923747062683,
0.9276873469352722,
0.5728706121444702,
0.828892707824707,
0.12258611619472504,
0.8777772188186646,
-0.1746334582567215,
0.147287979722023,
1.014251470565796,
-0.6751524806022644,
0.45945456624031067,
0.20715931057929993,
-0.022367024794220924,
0.6199886798858643,
0.3938685655593872,
0.4998634159564972,
0.4073205590248108,
0.311077743768692,
-0.3356676399707794,
-0.5520760416984558,
0.00045251534902490675,
-0.08496201783418655,
0.5206797122955322,
0.16596710681915283,
0.3849731981754303,
-0.6164091229438782,
-0.05129564553499222,
0.4194549024105072,
-0.02135363779962063,
-0.3810490369796753,
0.43253257870674133,
-0.03846532478928566,
-0.8673085570335388,
0.2870528995990753,
0.11294034868478775,
0.5088999271392822,
-0.6834568977355957,
-0.07529769837856293,
0.09775688499212265,
-0.021255357190966606,
-0.1548338681459427,
-0.9344642758369446,
0.19125573337078094,
-0.22250953316688538,
0.03204132989048958,
-0.7044118642807007,
0.8006330132484436,
-0.39010927081108093,
-0.36443814635276794,
0.2043057680130005,
0.6978951096534729,
-0.0024028446059674025,
-0.5771273374557495,
-0.7032050490379333,
-0.1444382667541504,
0.10673850029706955,
-0.2985154092311859,
0.33974120020866394,
0.6564176678657532,
-0.02847881242632866,
0.9971625804901123,
0.7358728647232056,
0.3596545457839966,
-0.006847984157502651,
0.04414147883653641,
0.882231593132019,
-0.972023606300354,
-0.7375081181526184,
-0.7198495268821716,
0.5783435702323914,
-0.09444877505302429,
-0.032818134874105453,
0.21462933719158173,
0.648339033126831,
0.5244028568267822,
0.24270287156105042,
0.6809163689613342,
-0.03809257596731186,
0.4258992373943329,
-0.6363232135772705,
0.18865825235843658,
-0.3913813829421997,
0.4530273377895355,
0.09794306010007858,
-0.6878540515899658,
-0.14038702845573425,
0.5954238176345825,
-0.027560735121369362,
-0.18754109740257263,
0.8502151370048523,
0.9285662174224854,
0.15446405112743378,
-0.11848951876163483,
0.27772119641304016,
-0.07515262067317963,
1.0043569803237915,
0.8979207873344421,
1.0770031213760376,
0.38652661442756653,
0.6739910840988159,
-0.32516995072364807,
-0.0939207449555397,
-0.07613706588745117,
-0.7011904120445251,
-0.8278250098228455,
-0.7319251298904419,
0.053387537598609924,
-0.1598375290632248,
0.049265772104263306,
1.1070727109909058,
1.1201852560043335,
-0.05853753164410591,
-0.44103965163230896,
-0.3130492568016052,
0.26865342259407043,
-0.10850676149129868,
-0.17955562472343445,
0.033610258251428604,
-0.2897310256958008,
-0.30802252888679504,
0.543963611125946,
0.3637281060218811,
0.02648494578897953,
-0.5825721025466919,
-0.270781546831131,
-0.1788242608308792,
-0.0788949728012085,
0.5997416377067566,
0.18075482547283173,
-0.6044834852218628,
-0.1063598096370697,
-0.11902859807014465,
0.012626961804926395,
-0.06723128259181976,
1.2376015186309814,
-0.5661289095878601,
0.2568509578704834,
0.25833451747894287,
0.21926581859588623,
0.8678207397460938,
0.23273523151874542,
0.6508932113647461,
-0.4484047293663025,
0.2887879014015198,
0.45502275228500366,
0.46735021471977234,
0.11989256739616394,
-0.4444275498390198,
0.6229107975959778,
-0.03041517175734043,
-0.94029301404953,
-0.27736708521842957,
0.49730485677719116,
-1.4095252752304077,
-0.4347204267978668,
1.4614368677139282,
0.03638405352830887,
-0.03897254914045334,
-0.5300428867340088,
-0.429859459400177,
-0.11593315005302429,
-0.711485743522644,
0.6080794930458069,
0.5960461497306824,
-0.8952081799507141,
0.17700311541557312,
-0.5250455141067505,
0.4388042986392975,
-0.08306045085191727,
-1.0449250936508179,
-0.04632408171892166,
0.5556023120880127,
0.29034537076950073,
0.1598924845457077,
1.3706066608428955,
0.3084900975227356,
-0.13975320756435394,
-0.24430300295352936,
0.11315619945526123,
-0.24455343186855316,
-0.6772105693817139,
0.2372794896364212,
0.38567662239074707,
0.3133213222026825,
-0.026138218119740486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18203v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18203v2
|
IAPT: Instruction-Aware Prompt Tuning for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-28T14:11:01 | 2024-06-07T06:41:18 |
Wei Zhu, Aaron Xuxiang Tian, Congrui Yin, Yuan Ni, Xiaoling Wang, Guotong Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Soft prompt tuning is a widely studied parameter-efficient fine-tuning
method. However, it has a clear drawback: many soft tokens must be inserted
into the input sequences to guarantee downstream performance. As a result, soft
prompt tuning is less considered than Low-rank adaptation (LoRA) in the large
language modeling (LLM) era. In this work, we propose a novel prompt tuning
method, Instruction-Aware Prompt Tuning (IAPT), that requires only four soft
tokens. First, we install a parameter-efficient soft prompt generator at each
Transformer layer to generate idiosyncratic soft prompts for each input
instruction. The generated soft prompts can be seen as a semantic summary of
the input instructions and can effectively guide the output generation. Second,
the soft prompt generators are modules with a bottleneck architecture
consisting of a self-attention pooling operation, two linear projections, and
an activation function. Pilot experiments show that prompt generators at
different Transformer layers require different activation functions. Thus, we
propose to learn the idiosyncratic activation functions for prompt generators
automatically with the help of rational functions. We have conducted
experiments on various tasks, and the experimental results demonstrate that (a)
our IAPT method can outperform the recent baselines with comparable tunable
parameters. (b) Our IAPT method is more efficient than LoRA under the
single-backbone multi-tenant setting.
|
[
-0.46105462312698364,
-0.8314149379730225,
0.47990840673446655,
0.40367597341537476,
-0.23119571805000305,
-0.17575867474079132,
-0.4779781401157379,
0.09172077476978302,
-0.2547701895236969,
0.44788822531700134,
-0.7090566754341125,
-0.3088703155517578,
-0.27043142914772034,
0.30959561467170715,
0.05465826392173767,
0.8693943619728088,
0.3550640642642975,
-0.07099077850580215,
0.13219036161899567,
-0.16158662736415863,
-0.7313063740730286,
0.018098721280694008,
-0.891103982925415,
-0.04967333748936653,
0.5399671196937561,
0.8409825563430786,
0.37660107016563416,
0.8320392370223999,
0.0974736288189888,
0.3569280207157135,
0.003118271706625819,
0.3756921887397766,
-0.08899697661399841,
0.23986883461475372,
-0.270175576210022,
-0.3700698912143707,
-0.3220789432525635,
-0.2606491148471832,
0.8218411207199097,
0.46130606532096863,
0.14316371083259583,
0.23393675684928894,
0.3870756924152374,
0.6400062441825867,
-0.6195690631866455,
0.33971574902534485,
-0.9676608443260193,
-0.1031850129365921,
-0.018794598057866096,
-0.4994342625141144,
-0.7167669534683228,
-0.2512243390083313,
-0.22774642705917358,
-0.5466535687446594,
0.1686629205942154,
0.33779123425483704,
0.30597010254859924,
0.5508584976196289,
-0.5344935655593872,
-0.20914410054683685,
-0.44895169138908386,
0.6081289052963257,
-0.7044281959533691,
-0.01748385839164257,
0.12580431997776031,
0.15930414199829102,
-0.31455904245376587,
-0.48440614342689514,
-0.6118463277816772,
-0.3106727600097656,
-0.11531607806682587,
-0.051769789308309555,
-0.036063261330127716,
0.33557072281837463,
0.4592503607273102,
0.027096543461084366,
-0.3837325870990753,
0.5321032404899597,
-0.07395311444997787,
-0.07331003248691559,
0.2760169208049774,
0.15325698256492615,
0.14410997927188873,
-0.20502710342407227,
-0.4698964059352875,
-0.007301256991922855,
-0.7869635224342346,
0.28082984685897827,
0.5405014157295227,
0.7700046896934509,
-0.15104231238365173,
0.2766475975513458,
-0.022463489323854446,
0.6013453006744385,
0.4978715181350708,
-0.0329759456217289,
-0.02441544644534588,
-0.07919462025165558,
0.1429712176322937,
0.2994163930416107,
0.758763313293457,
0.07280547171831131,
0.34963005781173706,
0.0811285600066185,
-0.33611860871315,
-0.29635152220726013,
0.15782636404037476,
-0.8485367894172668,
-0.09781010448932648,
0.006354843731969595,
-0.27400997281074524,
-0.20485366880893707,
-0.15944375097751617,
-0.763594925403595,
-0.4772058129310608,
-0.5127838253974915,
0.5746802687644958,
-0.5435295104980469,
-0.14975742995738983,
-0.10355634242296219,
0.1191602498292923,
0.5308875441551208,
0.19246390461921692,
-1.125753402709961,
0.28331050276756287,
0.8154060244560242,
0.6552954912185669,
-0.2697392702102661,
-0.3807085156440735,
-1.0708181858062744,
-0.04456520825624466,
0.01036897860467434,
0.8061248660087585,
-0.40638187527656555,
-0.27353689074516296,
0.04684043303132057,
0.046710263937711716,
-0.43152692914009094,
-0.42025062441825867,
0.4866630434989929,
-0.40222984552383423,
0.26326850056648254,
-0.050993964076042175,
-0.4066631495952606,
0.1255117654800415,
-0.008373557589948177,
-0.5007666349411011,
0.8244027495384216,
0.15017785131931305,
-0.4941084682941437,
0.13079556822776794,
-0.7567922472953796,
-0.6742040514945984,
0.26340076327323914,
-0.052978143095970154,
-0.37031906843185425,
0.3122405409812927,
0.47628405690193176,
0.34983423352241516,
-0.27462270855903625,
0.14899952709674835,
-0.05792217701673508,
-0.5127592086791992,
0.2710568904876709,
-0.7699109315872192,
0.6068176031112671,
0.12301275879144669,
-0.5504825115203857,
0.34692373871803284,
-0.8530542850494385,
0.22294218838214874,
-0.1687014400959015,
-0.23185375332832336,
-0.06032309681177139,
-0.15610271692276,
-0.11712295562028885,
-0.0173201784491539,
0.284003347158432,
-0.29692375659942627,
0.5817081332206726,
-0.5119104385375977,
0.5692448616027832,
1.130335807800293,
0.1030772253870964,
0.4657638669013977,
-0.04189896211028099,
0.6511732339859009,
0.013955183327198029,
0.1458410620689392,
-0.6982704997062683,
-0.3153727948665619,
-0.7812049388885498,
-0.4752228856086731,
0.3991968631744385,
0.6027131080627441,
-0.7576816082000732,
0.7261509299278259,
-0.027609597891569138,
-0.19202204048633575,
-0.5452617406845093,
0.024387063458561897,
0.38506805896759033,
0.8651055693626404,
0.2661758363246918,
0.23284922540187836,
-0.159857377409935,
-0.8343638777732849,
-0.3970656096935272,
-0.15146255493164062,
0.08780629187822342,
0.4170050621032715,
0.08539091050624847,
0.2742479145526886,
0.6726673245429993,
-0.3450217545032501,
-0.28585508465766907,
-0.29262351989746094,
0.13294894993305206,
0.6287261247634888,
0.5167555809020996,
0.3732045292854309,
-0.5477498769760132,
-0.6447767615318298,
-0.18153898417949677,
-0.0908946618437767,
-0.41359743475914,
-0.2718423008918762,
-0.010254593566060066,
0.30176663398742676,
0.71156907081604,
-0.753032386302948,
0.01653832569718361,
0.3406859040260315,
-0.5500714778900146,
0.4933789074420929,
-0.49470505118370056,
0.18473529815673828,
-0.9111531972885132,
0.07100768387317657,
-0.11535576730966568,
-0.17595823109149933,
-0.2906831204891205,
-0.016808589920401573,
0.3505191504955292,
-0.34712618589401245,
-0.41618967056274414,
0.6396799087524414,
-0.43240952491760254,
0.24257025122642517,
-0.36576083302497864,
-0.08038754016160965,
0.020302679389715195,
0.8737648129463196,
-0.3590989112854004,
0.9826293587684631,
0.6521024703979492,
-0.8030052185058594,
0.028746023774147034,
0.025235004723072052,
-0.34793218970298767,
0.5679605603218079,
-0.6231825947761536,
0.25615838170051575,
-0.28861111402511597,
0.16673703491687775,
-1.1528172492980957,
-0.035090506076812744,
0.3356020450592041,
-0.08092702180147171,
0.47768181562423706,
-0.4011766016483307,
-0.5948359966278076,
-0.11676716804504395,
-0.10506021976470947,
0.43320682644844055,
0.6573774814605713,
-0.7639937996864319,
0.7989599704742432,
-0.08359638601541519,
-0.36459073424339294,
-0.4336898922920227,
-0.07679066807031631,
-0.126654252409935,
-0.5145081877708435,
-0.4191434383392334,
0.3063226640224457,
-0.19036678969860077,
0.10555685311555862,
-0.21179445087909698,
0.07114201039075851,
0.16653695702552795,
0.2113710343837738,
0.2434592843055725,
0.07583048194646835,
-0.4776149094104767,
0.349724143743515,
0.3397669494152069,
-0.39353808760643005,
-0.11697642505168915,
-0.44368597865104675,
0.6555835008621216,
-0.2773359417915344,
-0.32484257221221924,
-0.5475565195083618,
0.48829400539398193,
0.6250666379928589,
-0.3991335332393646,
0.5665777921676636,
0.6512197256088257,
-0.07953041791915894,
-0.6649327874183655,
-0.3988352119922638,
-0.3252536654472351,
-0.6156790256500244,
0.31007322669029236,
-0.418851375579834,
-0.754786491394043,
0.3932301104068756,
-0.38170281052589417,
0.19923390448093414,
0.4061276614665985,
0.543065071105957,
-0.02385435439646244,
1.263286828994751,
0.5585573315620422,
0.08584014326334,
0.6839507818222046,
0.09466244280338287,
0.25491970777511597,
-0.7069154977798462,
0.028411928564310074,
-0.726092517375946,
-0.5588275194168091,
-0.6048762202262878,
-0.104148268699646,
0.8468811511993408,
-0.08604923635721207,
-0.5421258211135864,
0.17381547391414642,
-0.5705119371414185,
0.6717630624771118,
0.653394341468811,
-0.041842021048069,
0.24982227385044098,
-0.07985644787549973,
-0.023906245827674866,
0.06453212350606918,
-0.821255624294281,
-0.25614550709724426,
0.6462582349777222,
0.20681391656398773,
0.6906237006187439,
-0.0821160301566124,
0.33805984258651733,
0.27200618386268616,
0.0018678158521652222,
-0.8580081462860107,
0.6751359701156616,
-0.3087533116340637,
-0.13314251601696014,
-0.3503839373588562,
-0.34196361899375916,
-0.9710683226585388,
0.155131533741951,
-0.0941200777888298,
-0.5625770688056946,
0.10516511648893356,
0.6494160294532776,
-0.595759391784668,
0.059411320835351944,
-1.0733506679534912,
0.719656765460968,
-0.31218937039375305,
-0.27014613151550293,
-0.28789660334587097,
-0.4995354115962982,
0.07332416623830795,
0.10329630225896835,
0.04904025420546532,
-0.17601284384727478,
-0.1491294801235199,
0.26406538486480713,
-0.24933111667633057,
0.8080726265907288,
-0.5362145900726318,
-0.16662535071372986,
0.20569688081741333,
0.04141509160399437,
0.8280681371688843,
0.29056233167648315,
-0.33373889327049255,
-0.2336748242378235,
-0.17783503234386444,
-0.18881820142269135,
-0.6962314248085022,
0.9058868288993835,
-0.6622456312179565,
-0.7673048973083496,
-0.13290922343730927,
-0.5000755190849304,
-0.3983137011528015,
0.28676939010620117,
0.4302358329296112,
0.7627156972885132,
0.18053248524665833,
0.220359668135643,
0.8357241153717041,
-0.2591569423675537,
0.6420256495475769,
0.6246821284294128,
0.17933368682861328,
-0.27448412775993347,
0.8992874026298523,
-0.131820410490036,
0.06254534423351288,
0.4332125782966614,
0.4451804757118225,
-0.34227946400642395,
-0.34985679388046265,
-0.662929356098175,
0.1178068220615387,
-0.49437543749809265,
-0.5357909202575684,
-0.5963156223297119,
-0.13841719925403595,
-0.3251897096633911,
-0.19787302613258362,
-0.4127606153488159,
-0.46014276146888733,
-0.4114014804363251,
0.2976672649383545,
0.5229292511940002,
0.2501911520957947,
0.28770211338996887,
0.6250418424606323,
-0.5501257181167603,
0.5494944453239441,
0.3118971884250641,
0.5654199719429016,
-0.08118429034948349,
-0.6416776180267334,
-0.10480238497257233,
-0.2107681930065155,
-0.182273268699646,
-0.5357455015182495,
0.1265820860862732,
0.6449946761131287,
0.45430445671081543,
0.3226897120475769,
0.32872700691223145,
0.4440489709377289,
-0.7837192416191101,
0.5242093205451965,
-0.041735876351594925,
-0.9504596590995789,
0.5581423044204712,
-0.3183266520500183,
0.8504424095153809,
0.7204744815826416,
-0.029817631468176842,
-0.22180584073066711,
-0.0726194828748703,
-0.2819981873035431,
-1.017454743385315,
0.8027918338775635,
-0.294233113527298,
0.44815593957901,
-0.03400169312953949,
0.41997092962265015,
0.3749710023403168,
0.12099612504243851,
-0.5679255127906799,
-0.21286465227603912,
-0.10468637943267822,
-0.5013883709907532,
0.2175479233264923,
-0.1079796776175499,
0.061693333089351654,
-0.16075392067432404,
0.7603740692138672,
-0.6134544610977173,
0.10538820177316666,
-0.1510603427886963,
-0.07903696596622467,
-0.2628055810928345,
0.5048573017120361,
0.27225014567375183,
0.4641025960445404,
0.18456871807575226,
0.1282641440629959,
0.2353522777557373,
-0.20588137209415436,
0.09368495643138885,
0.10820697247982025,
-0.3226620554924011,
-0.25093308091163635,
0.14117936789989471,
1.1241329908370972,
0.2944938540458679,
-0.7006623148918152,
0.5802689790725708,
-0.22224551439285278,
0.017492016777396202,
-0.3837396204471588,
0.5532529950141907,
-0.22355784475803375,
0.3306919038295746,
0.3790624737739563,
0.18289141356945038,
-0.015904709696769714,
-0.31581249833106995,
-0.05025061219930649,
0.49773895740509033,
-0.3167775571346283,
-0.22278597950935364,
0.501060962677002,
0.41788023710250854,
-0.6020002365112305,
0.8315938115119934,
-0.21543604135513306,
-0.25690892338752747,
0.5492499470710754,
0.802817702293396,
0.9400959610939026,
-0.21024857461452484,
0.11539746075868607,
0.39926308393478394,
0.18197156488895416,
0.26343834400177,
0.2023913413286209,
-0.2485019564628601,
-0.28882771730422974,
-0.5125007033348083,
-0.656069815158844,
-0.3165494501590729,
0.25095319747924805,
-0.4374384582042694,
0.729306161403656,
-0.5646231770515442,
0.06314754486083984,
-0.15319038927555084,
-0.19149288535118103,
-0.7665172815322876,
-0.1279461532831192,
0.09023655205965042,
1.0211519002914429,
-0.5741751790046692,
0.6141337752342224,
0.532036304473877,
0.2532520294189453,
-0.8072737455368042,
0.15715007483959198,
-0.2628549337387085,
-0.966126024723053,
0.17771711945533752,
0.3256838619709015,
-0.18977126479148865,
0.4748969078063965,
-0.5592575073242188,
-0.6880223751068115,
0.8582507371902466,
0.5774603486061096,
-0.6555088758468628,
-0.07922808825969696,
0.04368259385228157,
0.34077131748199463,
-0.4467891752719879,
0.12065645307302475,
0.41259580850601196,
0.5439478754997253,
-0.0710090920329094,
-0.5946785807609558,
0.25411731004714966,
-0.2779105007648468,
-0.037115488201379776,
0.22138476371765137,
-0.8405248522758484,
0.6540994048118591,
-0.3028109073638916,
-0.22740112245082855,
0.285062313079834,
0.702647864818573,
0.31338420510292053,
0.04086273908615112,
1.0237475633621216,
-0.029972098767757416,
0.5185157656669617,
-0.03799586743116379,
0.7629961967468262,
-0.7723231911659241,
-0.1146482527256012,
1.070633053779602,
-0.08797506988048553,
0.4419553577899933,
0.4922856390476227,
0.28570887446403503,
0.3616349697113037,
0.15261536836624146,
0.06606568396091461,
0.5625124573707581,
0.1924828290939331,
-0.3153305947780609,
-0.309037446975708,
-0.2676834762096405,
-0.25656306743621826,
0.6162562966346741,
0.5263429880142212,
-0.297296404838562,
-0.08895344287157059,
0.17491461336612701,
-0.06605427712202072,
-0.040161676704883575,
-0.447270005941391,
0.8954929113388062,
0.0874239057302475,
-1.165033221244812,
0.5606638193130493,
0.1005263403058052,
0.49115124344825745,
-0.8024941682815552,
-0.1666296422481537,
-0.09651005268096924,
0.24475567042827606,
0.11596380919218063,
-0.5506382584571838,
-0.19499017298221588,
-0.07350439578294754,
-0.11919886618852615,
-0.47608596086502075,
0.6992250084877014,
-0.4283004403114319,
-0.3201432228088379,
-0.18264880776405334,
0.35342901945114136,
-0.33465567231178284,
-0.16124208271503448,
-0.48508161306381226,
-0.06628803163766861,
-0.0734955444931984,
-0.4708064794540405,
0.23538948595523834,
0.7608875632286072,
-0.027713099494576454,
0.5911406874656677,
0.4954686462879181,
0.05001180246472359,
-0.06945066154003143,
0.2317279875278473,
0.7733166813850403,
-0.6791595220565796,
-0.7594001293182373,
-0.7459233403205872,
0.7393326759338379,
0.2553962171077728,
-0.7183342576026917,
0.5157472491264343,
0.1968597173690796,
0.3134143054485321,
-0.15777084231376648,
0.6798449158668518,
0.021583909168839455,
0.3331058919429779,
-0.7050339579582214,
0.4400058090686798,
-0.35351553559303284,
0.39000239968299866,
0.06844782829284668,
-1.122939944267273,
0.006202975288033485,
0.2148953378200531,
-0.026699822396039963,
-0.046682942658662796,
0.5031367540359497,
0.8829953074455261,
-0.20151598751544952,
-0.025974884629249573,
0.11380823701620102,
0.34199586510658264,
0.17473597824573517,
0.3948494493961334,
0.734551191329956,
-0.18796007335186005,
0.47995710372924805,
-0.12063243985176086,
-0.3231361508369446,
-0.33483728766441345,
-1.0810624361038208,
-0.7298659086227417,
-0.6523792743682861,
-0.3203388750553131,
-0.21276763081550598,
-0.0294280294328928,
1.234975814819336,
0.5433936715126038,
-0.7754452228546143,
0.11310197412967682,
-0.10013706982135773,
0.21729038655757904,
-0.3253268301486969,
-0.26950353384017944,
0.5057386159896851,
-0.7058568000793457,
-0.7913288474082947,
0.552591860294342,
0.4012896716594696,
-0.21745432913303375,
-0.2775837481021881,
0.021644622087478638,
0.24517352879047394,
0.1943335086107254,
0.5053337216377258,
0.28946173191070557,
-0.4203616678714752,
-0.4206371605396271,
0.11967696994543076,
0.006449434440582991,
0.0598440021276474,
1.0126798152923584,
-0.9439201951026917,
0.2766316831111908,
0.3703017830848694,
0.5061445236206055,
0.18133021891117096,
-0.0005904168938286602,
0.5867722630500793,
-0.9579052329063416,
0.14656925201416016,
0.3534700870513916,
0.37955042719841003,
0.22943587601184845,
-0.5807589292526245,
-0.03486640006303787,
-0.08721806108951569,
-0.5821743607521057,
-0.7568449974060059,
0.36068904399871826,
-1.0343252420425415,
-0.16112522780895233,
1.1077390909194946,
0.051991600543260574,
-0.232932910323143,
0.07623279839754105,
-0.4621180295944214,
0.22113725543022156,
-0.5549799799919128,
0.9281958937644958,
0.1148819848895073,
-0.15864107012748718,
-0.3287748098373413,
-0.17036570608615875,
0.44246038794517517,
0.4736376106739044,
-0.697375476360321,
0.22630047798156738,
0.3096795678138733,
0.04461473599076271,
-0.24900688230991364,
0.36809974908828735,
0.09159339964389801,
0.3040044903755188,
-0.28406015038490295,
-0.26238924264907837,
-0.34586355090141296,
-0.4041156470775604,
-0.49716687202453613,
0.3305720090866089,
0.14650897681713104,
0.044538550078868866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00046v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00046v2
|
Hate Speech Detection with Generalizable Target-aware Fairness
| 2024-05-28T13:09:22 | 2024-06-11T13:18:14 |
Tong Chen, Danny Wang, Xurong Liang, Marten Risius, Gianluca Demartini, Hongzhi Yin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
To counter the side effect brought by the proliferation of social media
platforms, hate speech detection (HSD) plays a vital role in halting the
dissemination of toxic online posts at an early stage. However, given the
ubiquitous topical communities on social media, a trained HSD classifier easily
becomes biased towards specific targeted groups (e.g., female and black
people), where a high rate of false positive/negative results can significantly
impair public trust in the fairness of content moderation mechanisms, and
eventually harm the diversity of online society. Although existing
fairness-aware HSD methods can smooth out some discrepancies across targeted
groups, they are mostly specific to a narrow selection of targets that are
assumed to be known and fixed. This inevitably prevents those methods from
generalizing to real-world use cases where new targeted groups constantly
emerge over time. To tackle this defect, we propose Generalizable target-aware
Fairness (GetFair), a new method for fairly classifying each post that contains
diverse and even unseen targets during inference. To remove the HSD
classifier's spurious dependence on target-related features, GetFair trains a
series of filter functions in an adversarial pipeline, so as to deceive the
discriminator that recovers the targeted group from filtered post embeddings.
To maintain scalability and generalizability, we innovatively parameterize all
filter functions via a hypernetwork that is regularized by the semantic
affinity among targets. Taking a target's pretrained word embedding as input,
the hypernetwork generates the weights used by each target-specific filter
on-the-fly without storing dedicated filter parameters. Finally, comparative
experiments on two HSD datasets have shown advantageous performance of GetFair
on out-of-sample targets.
|
[
-0.4390815794467926,
-0.7717442512512207,
0.24861927330493927,
0.12566633522510529,
-0.13151828944683075,
-0.03623564541339874,
-0.09770812839269638,
-0.36778998374938965,
0.34366369247436523,
0.41152843832969666,
-0.3106689453125,
-0.44804468750953674,
-1.0159529447555542,
-0.37328481674194336,
-0.4557497203350067,
1.3045223951339722,
0.32315149903297424,
-0.041298989206552505,
0.22378699481487274,
-0.5013601183891296,
-0.04852578043937683,
-0.6096615195274353,
-0.7568888664245605,
-0.12122152000665665,
0.7638952732086182,
0.20675764977931976,
0.8164464831352234,
0.730150043964386,
0.5472139716148376,
0.2495667189359665,
-0.22677715122699738,
-0.10844834893941879,
-0.5912082195281982,
0.08276129513978958,
-0.399883508682251,
-0.17155611515045166,
-0.32346591353416443,
0.08396437764167786,
0.5440015196800232,
0.3929934501647949,
-0.20496051013469696,
0.22649233043193817,
0.07344576716423035,
0.3977784216403961,
-0.894106388092041,
-0.29086342453956604,
-0.7829455733299255,
0.3195749521255493,
-0.31650710105895996,
0.003011152148246765,
-0.09601018577814102,
-0.20580916106700897,
-0.05018113926053047,
-0.649014949798584,
0.4563904106616974,
-0.028961563482880592,
0.9255111813545227,
0.37940552830696106,
-0.23704154789447784,
-0.1740807294845581,
-0.7567305564880371,
0.8902178406715393,
-0.4041481912136078,
0.6742525100708008,
0.3582746982574463,
0.6086359024047852,
-0.02221648581326008,
-0.5506923794746399,
-0.46390607953071594,
0.03704594075679779,
0.15840260684490204,
0.03008880652487278,
-0.5829543471336365,
0.052285436540842056,
0.39851418137550354,
0.34948229789733887,
-0.5359671711921692,
0.07941081374883652,
-0.023296108469367027,
-0.568284273147583,
0.38467565178871155,
-0.2792153060436249,
0.17060105502605438,
-0.05302928760647774,
-0.18081654608249664,
0.03460845351219177,
-0.14929349720478058,
0.024948492646217346,
0.6230826377868652,
0.5273802876472473,
-0.13811646401882172,
0.2266480177640915,
-0.4183809757232666,
0.5683853030204773,
0.38902387022972107,
0.04300181195139885,
0.2879504859447479,
0.041701484471559525,
-0.13587063550949097,
-0.10314324498176575,
0.5064950585365295,
0.1811707466840744,
0.48225417733192444,
-0.3159913122653961,
-0.15457996726036072,
0.33570706844329834,
0.2066439986228943,
-0.7407574653625488,
0.014193251729011536,
0.06017633154988289,
-0.4747261106967926,
-0.4335745871067047,
-0.18054713308811188,
-0.9369669556617737,
-0.46735361218452454,
-0.03891639783978462,
0.43934834003448486,
-0.018890632316470146,
-0.31260043382644653,
-0.11539926379919052,
-0.325366348028183,
0.13687275350093842,
0.07473534345626831,
-0.7332078814506531,
0.28346729278564453,
0.5900706648826599,
0.7483970522880554,
-0.2986010015010834,
0.004818563815206289,
-1.33884859085083,
0.32218101620674133,
0.04679037630558014,
0.6668691635131836,
-0.7700788378715515,
-0.08345357328653336,
0.005325652193278074,
-0.1950184851884842,
0.37081095576286316,
-0.580321729183197,
0.7895117402076721,
-0.6046294569969177,
0.17490248382091522,
-0.20797519385814667,
-0.36809101700782776,
-0.022540921345353127,
0.3261643350124359,
-0.5429666638374329,
0.6665773391723633,
0.24272453784942627,
-0.7990625500679016,
0.6381085515022278,
-0.5786619782447815,
-0.4247211515903473,
0.1271689385175705,
-0.28403159976005554,
-0.6146185398101807,
-0.04126589372754097,
0.29636886715888977,
0.4244118630886078,
-0.00798112154006958,
0.3781708776950836,
-0.6201652884483337,
-0.41894975304603577,
-0.2756091356277466,
-0.40918388962745667,
0.8234214782714844,
0.5141863822937012,
-0.7578102946281433,
0.25156277418136597,
-0.38774213194847107,
-0.14648596942424774,
0.021518150344491005,
-0.2572520673274994,
-0.32358238101005554,
0.02431357651948929,
0.2262251228094101,
0.403091162443161,
-0.13552120327949524,
-0.8423712849617004,
-0.6380745768547058,
-0.19184590876102448,
0.02556675113737583,
1.081980586051941,
-0.13561534881591797,
0.247475266456604,
-0.4289155900478363,
0.46054700016975403,
0.1332443803548813,
0.39895832538604736,
0.4752759039402008,
-0.5450344085693359,
-0.5422506332397461,
-0.5373151898384094,
0.15255151689052582,
0.36407479643821716,
-0.5352035164833069,
0.4571434259414673,
0.032733142375946045,
-0.38915109634399414,
-0.48458173871040344,
0.22752578556537628,
0.5347128510475159,
0.5211141705513,
0.4792996942996979,
-0.22575433552265167,
-0.4161217212677002,
-0.8427658677101135,
-0.6196662187576294,
0.08490011841058731,
0.03532600775361061,
0.21892912685871124,
0.18662746250629425,
-0.24298711121082306,
0.8312247395515442,
-0.5070456862449646,
-0.552372932434082,
0.023063549771904945,
-0.031028226017951965,
-0.12710225582122803,
0.35678181052207947,
0.5766012072563171,
-1.1973847150802612,
-0.5109475255012512,
-0.15952880680561066,
-0.4852674901485443,
-0.2804338037967682,
0.2766694724559784,
-0.4991872310638428,
-0.23671776056289673,
0.43447375297546387,
-0.09455280750989914,
0.4837150275707245,
0.5365068912506104,
-0.6319637298583984,
0.3874148428440094,
0.23558710515499115,
0.2880367338657379,
-0.8453481793403625,
0.007029046770185232,
0.18622736632823944,
-0.3312664031982422,
-0.6931554675102234,
0.04283687472343445,
-0.3320426642894745,
-0.11039058119058609,
-0.5944786071777344,
0.6474979519844055,
0.018351390957832336,
-0.07737398147583008,
-0.31547340750694275,
-0.061226263642311096,
-0.18641972541809082,
0.5946540832519531,
-0.10744736343622208,
0.1721159964799881,
0.4145914614200592,
-0.6767322421073914,
0.17947469651699066,
-0.06445056945085526,
0.10613735765218735,
0.9770359992980957,
-0.5203635096549988,
0.13261328637599945,
-0.34570130705833435,
0.27309170365333557,
-0.7741811275482178,
-0.1449877768754959,
0.5574982166290283,
-0.7407334446907043,
-0.1477903425693512,
-0.43737807869911194,
-0.0195771474391222,
-0.3219040334224701,
-0.18546898663043976,
0.3272132873535156,
0.31121426820755005,
-0.5651925206184387,
0.6898026466369629,
0.5997759103775024,
0.21985919773578644,
-0.7638075947761536,
-0.6603583097457886,
-0.18431077897548676,
-0.31022995710372925,
-0.4111870229244232,
0.4659372568130493,
-0.35006868839263916,
-0.22777195274829865,
0.14492641389369965,
-0.14038118720054626,
-0.38989022374153137,
0.15031282603740692,
0.4751577079296112,
-0.14989210665225983,
0.0617804080247879,
0.07964334636926651,
0.31694841384887695,
0.04805445671081543,
-0.1199469193816185,
-0.21241377294063568,
0.5688408017158508,
-0.03065399080514908,
-0.3071459233760834,
-0.30961909890174866,
0.6106557250022888,
0.5651094317436218,
-0.2531413733959198,
0.5577768683433533,
1.053204894065857,
-0.7522450089454651,
-0.40343356132507324,
-0.7093381881713867,
-0.08057073503732681,
-0.5026271939277649,
0.32464754581451416,
-0.20588147640228271,
-1.4168256521224976,
0.37141939997673035,
0.3475296199321747,
0.15271258354187012,
0.2813877761363983,
0.4125743806362152,
0.0766015574336052,
1.0564521551132202,
0.6721901893615723,
-0.27015426754951477,
0.5685707926750183,
0.06714820116758347,
0.007318553980439901,
-0.4637865126132965,
0.04897205904126167,
-0.6046506762504578,
-0.34869465231895447,
-0.5090994238853455,
-0.21570689976215363,
0.07776779681444168,
-0.14847959578037262,
-0.4326089918613434,
-0.01607813872396946,
-0.7173817753791809,
0.5406587719917297,
0.4824526011943817,
0.15816663205623627,
0.22668713331222534,
0.48221394419670105,
-0.07766585797071457,
-0.3209753632545471,
-0.22896651923656464,
-0.07723087817430496,
1.0953747034072876,
0.2510327100753784,
0.18943369388580322,
0.24001117050647736,
0.7035616040229797,
0.9687278270721436,
0.5889567732810974,
-0.705540657043457,
0.388184517621994,
-0.6218016743659973,
-0.7528238296508789,
-0.18730008602142334,
-0.6219494342803955,
-0.7433943748474121,
0.2938062846660614,
-0.07720709592103958,
-0.4543949365615845,
0.281717449426651,
0.47336745262145996,
-0.2556701600551605,
0.6767770648002625,
-0.460662841796875,
0.665019690990448,
0.05849279835820198,
-0.2738383412361145,
-0.32363197207450867,
-0.33334389328956604,
0.25328078866004944,
-0.20974723994731903,
0.4925170838832855,
-0.3830963671207428,
0.14963304996490479,
1.0691016912460327,
-0.280806303024292,
0.50053471326828,
-0.8087759613990784,
0.1979704350233078,
0.034521911293268204,
0.005580635275691748,
0.21921105682849884,
-0.3850845992565155,
-0.26578035950660706,
0.36472347378730774,
-0.5456860661506653,
-0.5695666670799255,
-0.5171974897384644,
0.734519898891449,
-0.5733628273010254,
-0.4498955309391022,
-0.2500235438346863,
-0.3947378695011139,
-0.3628404438495636,
0.2971515357494354,
0.3654879629611969,
0.31259849667549133,
-0.26116129755973816,
-0.0001297295093536377,
0.5607602000236511,
-0.08907479047775269,
0.2868598401546478,
0.48421159386634827,
-0.2013951539993286,
-0.41680625081062317,
1.1604372262954712,
0.018986478447914124,
0.12286738306283951,
0.25918200612068176,
0.2267104834318161,
-0.11409018188714981,
-0.48120784759521484,
-0.12515537440776825,
0.09493833780288696,
-0.5159602761268616,
-0.07777730375528336,
-0.7938475608825684,
-0.20566631853580475,
-0.5889697670936584,
-0.4083482325077057,
-0.2505359649658203,
-0.17479325830936432,
-0.0019564467947930098,
0.055211424827575684,
0.15368767082691193,
0.34944823384284973,
-0.633643627166748,
0.38737669587135315,
-0.2060936838388443,
0.8683393597602844,
0.5586915612220764,
0.45732465386390686,
-0.07402842491865158,
-0.8671173453330994,
-0.10792970657348633,
0.12486320734024048,
-0.18833495676517487,
-0.5778867602348328,
0.2233210951089859,
0.13177208602428436,
0.592887818813324,
0.5613165497779846,
0.13099612295627594,
0.32593971490859985,
-0.3790811598300934,
0.27989697456359863,
0.35643270611763,
-0.7749838829040527,
0.5899413228034973,
-0.27574893832206726,
-0.048797357827425,
0.4837646484375,
0.6451849937438965,
-0.653733491897583,
-0.5465337634086609,
-0.3025181293487549,
-0.5338034629821777,
0.5050435662269592,
0.07215456664562225,
0.10627061128616333,
-0.14306123554706573,
0.11839333921670914,
-0.06441616266965866,
0.1626676321029663,
-0.7797622084617615,
-0.3752516806125641,
-0.4560069739818573,
-0.2896325886249542,
0.21484972536563873,
-0.1496879756450653,
-0.09886416047811508,
-0.2749878466129303,
0.5521802306175232,
0.12833841145038605,
0.19290785491466522,
0.06415078788995743,
-0.14980711042881012,
-0.2526639997959137,
0.38028907775878906,
0.14702850580215454,
0.31519266963005066,
-0.37718963623046875,
0.0800800547003746,
-0.2611100375652313,
-0.7314625382423401,
0.379535049200058,
0.32184210419654846,
-0.38898542523384094,
0.014204464852809906,
-0.16345886886119843,
0.5620005130767822,
-0.12483680248260498,
-0.4999314546585083,
0.7649666666984558,
-0.08049150556325912,
-0.19254828989505768,
0.03470078110694885,
0.16453875601291656,
-0.2580759525299072,
0.28368663787841797,
0.43000170588493347,
0.23299019038677216,
0.46732959151268005,
-0.19528348743915558,
0.6520757079124451,
0.4543265402317047,
-0.8472381234169006,
-0.15450723469257355,
0.8294048309326172,
0.2978520095348358,
-0.4887951910495758,
0.18736128509044647,
-0.5149226784706116,
-0.578906238079071,
0.44310852885246277,
0.43117550015449524,
0.9290145039558411,
-0.47257769107818604,
0.5621844530105591,
0.17141854763031006,
0.27159884572029114,
0.2425748109817505,
0.03166673332452774,
-0.047329869121313095,
-1.07354736328125,
-0.320069283246994,
-0.9236704707145691,
-0.3411937654018402,
0.20458631217479706,
-0.6634951233863831,
-0.052478253841400146,
-0.9357495307922363,
-0.3421419560909271,
0.09341114014387131,
-0.12713444232940674,
-0.6459162831306458,
0.4349520206451416,
0.27481839060783386,
0.39053618907928467,
-0.7000994682312012,
0.45101991295814514,
0.42925867438316345,
-0.0985342487692833,
-0.5165433287620544,
0.1963176280260086,
0.28663185238838196,
-0.7099407315254211,
0.5527006983757019,
0.20051467418670654,
-0.43173348903656006,
0.15237177908420563,
-0.6163941025733948,
-0.4768107235431671,
0.5131329894065857,
0.46719804406166077,
-0.5331672430038452,
0.005617524031549692,
0.11490204930305481,
0.28664079308509827,
-0.22232306003570557,
0.048581358045339584,
0.29403093457221985,
0.4833155572414398,
0.07935983687639236,
-0.5445544123649597,
0.1477968692779541,
-0.15896180272102356,
-0.09990469366312027,
0.05707293748855591,
-0.6372225880622864,
0.8085690140724182,
-0.10320239514112473,
-0.10219359397888184,
-0.5158183574676514,
0.6624491810798645,
0.2572224736213684,
0.48977234959602356,
0.8952190279960632,
0.8441627025604248,
0.7808379530906677,
0.04001498967409134,
0.8929001688957214,
0.2243901491165161,
0.052445441484451294,
1.0636907815933228,
-0.13881422579288483,
0.5494170784950256,
0.15173663198947906,
-0.0011308345710858703,
0.35159793496131897,
0.22269998490810394,
-0.14842955768108368,
0.5374069809913635,
0.40296033024787903,
-0.49285414814949036,
-0.33673176169395447,
-0.5268877148628235,
-0.3282541334629059,
0.41641148924827576,
0.17937947809696198,
-0.14646579325199127,
-0.32510778307914734,
0.27633020281791687,
0.2780229151248932,
0.34168192744255066,
-0.5233891606330872,
0.38532555103302,
-0.13530738651752472,
-0.3546265661716461,
0.310987263917923,
0.23414011299610138,
1.3586583137512207,
-0.6717658638954163,
0.07840929180383682,
-0.2796899080276489,
0.27139177918434143,
-0.2806161344051361,
-0.42291489243507385,
0.4266239404678345,
0.21475404500961304,
-0.35286036133766174,
-0.018395451828837395,
0.844470202922821,
-0.4245600402355194,
-0.28755608201026917,
0.710748016834259,
0.2881864011287689,
-0.018427876755595207,
-0.6092227101325989,
-0.9794144034385681,
0.17436766624450684,
0.1514974981546402,
-0.010663504712283611,
0.41244176030158997,
0.10743208974599838,
0.07125797867774963,
0.5141704082489014,
0.7275554537773132,
0.2795940339565277,
0.10107014328241348,
0.19745288789272308,
0.7549384236335754,
-0.5916568636894226,
-0.5774663686752319,
-0.5557422637939453,
0.21948577463626862,
-0.22340770065784454,
-0.45552027225494385,
0.5231820344924927,
0.40094664692878723,
0.9586240649223328,
0.2637362480163574,
0.6902070641517639,
-0.05852106586098671,
0.8374233245849609,
-0.0384364128112793,
0.9198145270347595,
-0.6180675029754639,
-0.16125771403312683,
-0.5591364502906799,
-0.8533258438110352,
-0.4636588394641876,
0.4619565010070801,
-0.18479444086551666,
0.1738160103559494,
0.26521992683410645,
0.9102862477302551,
-0.15193305909633636,
-0.24800878763198853,
0.4903620779514313,
0.05854320526123047,
0.6877087950706482,
0.3811834156513214,
0.44459637999534607,
-0.271721750497818,
0.9816829562187195,
-0.19817645847797394,
-0.3789580166339874,
-0.08318188041448593,
-0.5513247847557068,
-0.5607388615608215,
-0.29556989669799805,
-0.47551465034484863,
-0.4011557996273041,
0.47175776958465576,
0.6193075776100159,
0.7724060416221619,
-0.9322261214256287,
-0.03956960141658783,
0.17777693271636963,
0.45956918597221375,
-0.040452416986227036,
-0.3584669530391693,
0.24707476794719696,
-0.08283952623605728,
-0.5710498690605164,
0.13790510594844818,
0.2716158926486969,
-0.20599126815795898,
0.16365750133991241,
-0.39068230986595154,
-0.3398147523403168,
0.1468893140554428,
0.4618096351623535,
0.4763481616973877,
-0.40287330746650696,
-0.3801092207431793,
-0.394540399312973,
-0.0758066475391388,
-0.06272637099027634,
0.6444092988967896,
-0.5661396384239197,
0.22160445153713226,
0.12186697870492935,
0.8755961060523987,
0.31969261169433594,
-0.11072245985269547,
0.07925911992788315,
-0.7396144866943359,
0.24185526371002197,
0.3696150779724121,
0.15895049273967743,
0.3716653883457184,
-0.37780848145484924,
0.3028416037559509,
0.6480287909507751,
-0.3569693863391876,
-0.8313464522361755,
0.34299448132514954,
-0.7848171591758728,
-0.2949872314929962,
0.9717058539390564,
-0.08358059078454971,
0.00239722547121346,
-0.4241713285446167,
0.07436781376600266,
0.43714264035224915,
-0.6548919677734375,
0.6128389835357666,
0.5531083941459656,
0.265789657831192,
0.07312699407339096,
-0.15480543673038483,
0.6193155646324158,
0.4927431643009186,
-0.7350553870201111,
-0.06242312490940094,
0.7380325198173523,
0.29722025990486145,
-0.06654179096221924,
0.9457835555076599,
-0.19162237644195557,
0.4248327910900116,
-0.21464522182941437,
-0.05117267370223999,
-0.01136384904384613,
-0.37907353043556213,
-0.22429583966732025,
0.45509466528892517,
-0.3748299181461334,
-0.16950707137584686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17790v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17790v1
|
Mashee at SemEval-2024 Task 8: The Impact of Samples Quality on the Performance of In-Context Learning for Machine Text Classification
| 2024-05-28T12:47:43 | 2024-05-28T12:47:43 |
Areeg Fahad Rasheed, M. Zarkoosh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Within few-shot learning, in-context learning (ICL) has become a potential
method for leveraging contextual information to improve model performance on
small amounts of data or in resource-constrained environments where training
models on large datasets is prohibitive. However, the quality of the selected
sample in a few shots severely limits the usefulness of ICL. The primary goal
of this paper is to enhance the performance of evaluation metrics for
in-context learning by selecting high-quality samples in few-shot learning
scenarios. We employ the chi-square test to identify high-quality samples and
compare the results with those obtained using low-quality samples. Our findings
demonstrate that utilizing high-quality samples leads to improved performance
with respect to all evaluated metrics.
|
[
-0.36023569107055664,
-0.5705936551094055,
0.3550223708152771,
-0.07517554610967636,
-0.21473297476768494,
0.10617581009864807,
-0.001675588428042829,
-0.7253164649009705,
-0.4563916325569153,
0.15885496139526367,
-0.19813378155231476,
-0.5152800679206848,
-0.5842074155807495,
0.28887611627578735,
-0.3030022382736206,
1.1858136653900146,
0.07874911278486252,
0.3728521764278412,
-0.3780617415904999,
-0.306942343711853,
-0.38970014452934265,
-0.46725890040397644,
-0.4090918004512787,
-0.38505277037620544,
0.1903119534254074,
0.7519441246986389,
0.24590842425823212,
0.2595587968826294,
0.5951284170150757,
0.22656357288360596,
0.0427897609770298,
0.16020646691322327,
-0.6845462918281555,
0.06676546484231949,
-0.0056742290034890175,
-0.5732337236404419,
-0.02281884290277958,
0.48965150117874146,
0.863074779510498,
0.5665638446807861,
0.4493156671524048,
0.31989264488220215,
0.8415845036506653,
0.3565889894962311,
-0.8342437744140625,
-0.1619497537612915,
-0.535107433795929,
0.18853314220905304,
-0.24929234385490417,
-0.3731296956539154,
-0.4777069091796875,
-0.42713770270347595,
0.291847288608551,
-0.3691306412220001,
0.27098292112350464,
0.07518775761127472,
0.9398056268692017,
0.2033969908952713,
-0.3516409397125244,
-0.24742244184017181,
-0.4844125211238861,
0.9886027574539185,
-0.6062471270561218,
0.2796843647956848,
0.8332893252372742,
0.5908289551734924,
-0.10549494624137878,
-0.5472181439399719,
-0.32729625701904297,
0.04660224914550781,
-0.15159785747528076,
0.22356516122817993,
0.21001364290714264,
-0.1489401012659073,
0.26111501455307007,
-0.04732751473784447,
-0.28345030546188354,
0.08574678003787994,
-0.3773725628852844,
-0.13152147829532623,
0.600226879119873,
0.2588823139667511,
-0.06796355545520782,
-0.2300964742898941,
-0.3442312777042389,
-0.07637648284435272,
-0.5938704013824463,
0.5911586284637451,
0.1865948587656021,
0.4115280508995056,
0.029207667335867882,
0.4099428057670593,
-0.14408515393733978,
0.5480107665061951,
0.02287832461297512,
-0.6740623116493225,
0.24846406280994415,
-0.4070240259170532,
-0.39667198061943054,
0.09775363653898239,
0.5427589416503906,
0.09882518649101257,
-0.39597880840301514,
0.3006259799003601,
-0.29186874628067017,
-0.29978129267692566,
0.0981047973036766,
-1.150954246520996,
-0.055810149759054184,
-0.059823159128427505,
-0.7466432452201843,
-0.4114677309989929,
0.2882175147533417,
-0.8657215237617493,
-0.32444053888320923,
-0.3357658088207245,
0.7788853049278259,
-0.6582428216934204,
0.46571218967437744,
-0.4098277688026428,
-0.2436707615852356,
0.03146221116185188,
0.6765418648719788,
-0.5058150887489319,
0.2069709748029709,
0.44765332341194153,
0.8358624577522278,
-0.1864931285381317,
-0.3815630078315735,
-0.8748849630355835,
-0.2621181309223175,
-0.43035343289375305,
0.9341990947723389,
-0.6878109574317932,
-0.4530315399169922,
-0.1677425652742386,
-0.19151811301708221,
0.11570098251104355,
-0.7917647957801819,
0.5060753226280212,
-0.2732516825199127,
0.2268436700105667,
-0.37211889028549194,
-0.6757083535194397,
-0.294376403093338,
0.32776328921318054,
-0.40216755867004395,
1.264732837677002,
0.5195362567901611,
-0.6774208545684814,
0.8887024521827698,
-0.2825956642627716,
-0.5205267667770386,
0.24352778494358063,
-0.4563860595226288,
-0.6218163371086121,
0.0652693584561348,
0.04970531910657883,
0.8579926490783691,
-0.14458730816841125,
-0.35089442133903503,
-0.3685491979122162,
-0.8493627309799194,
0.36010658740997314,
-0.5041616559028625,
0.749406635761261,
0.2464759200811386,
-0.5243738293647766,
-0.21304751932621002,
-0.886883556842804,
0.142220139503479,
-0.3245435655117035,
-0.7676348090171814,
-0.4653991758823395,
-0.26222681999206543,
0.247309148311615,
0.3877947926521301,
-0.4189418852329254,
-0.49321866035461426,
-0.08650710433721542,
-0.40656083822250366,
0.02514871396124363,
0.5675791501998901,
0.1860167384147644,
0.6171731352806091,
-0.44585105776786804,
0.5710095763206482,
0.18138761818408966,
0.00221911258995533,
-0.24549412727355957,
-0.22989676892757416,
-0.4926444888114929,
-0.553838312625885,
0.473927766084671,
0.32785317301750183,
-0.6834812760353088,
0.3568333387374878,
0.05038006603717804,
-0.6005252599716187,
-0.5287799835205078,
0.3364991545677185,
0.4474698007106781,
0.6146243810653687,
0.3822494447231293,
-0.29755210876464844,
-0.32485461235046387,
-0.544359028339386,
-0.18310235440731049,
0.05903523042798042,
-0.062009330838918686,
0.4809204638004303,
0.7261254191398621,
-0.03376968204975128,
1.2474088668823242,
-0.11078905314207077,
-0.3347676992416382,
-0.34163525700569153,
0.19142885506153107,
0.03935912996530533,
0.41870319843292236,
0.7398240566253662,
-0.4416021704673767,
-0.6949961185455322,
-0.17350709438323975,
-0.6430659294128418,
-0.03663136437535286,
-0.10178287327289581,
-0.20381176471710205,
0.17902803421020508,
0.4483952224254608,
0.013167213648557663,
0.7385088801383972,
0.3397703766822815,
-0.28898167610168457,
0.5364740490913391,
0.1334889680147171,
0.5237868428230286,
-0.9038316011428833,
-0.08016125112771988,
0.21712014079093933,
-0.39155900478363037,
-0.26169389486312866,
-0.27379363775253296,
0.3365960419178009,
-0.17607738077640533,
-0.6218395233154297,
0.5532429218292236,
-0.05015728250145912,
-0.1498313546180725,
-0.4461928606033325,
0.010192482732236385,
0.21734727919101715,
0.07097683101892471,
-0.23439541459083557,
0.8906527161598206,
0.22061486542224884,
-0.8434590697288513,
-0.3014206886291504,
0.2774409055709839,
-0.7372273802757263,
0.9000841975212097,
-0.29209843277931213,
-0.10372219234704971,
-0.22242800891399384,
0.4911210238933563,
-0.8817242383956909,
-0.28972306847572327,
0.029874471947550774,
-0.5612459182739258,
0.3249835968017578,
-0.009484326466917992,
-0.33975541591644287,
0.14308874309062958,
-0.3884584903717041,
0.38093477487564087,
0.3549804985523224,
-0.7932366728782654,
0.10488827526569366,
0.24340540170669556,
0.2564501464366913,
-0.5967992544174194,
-0.7945234775543213,
-0.3787454068660736,
-0.3384051024913788,
0.01645379699766636,
0.2937275767326355,
-0.093150794506073,
-0.13438154757022858,
-0.09522024542093277,
-0.06965120136737823,
-0.11114383488893509,
0.21500612795352936,
0.22005192935466766,
0.07987233996391296,
-0.15822435915470123,
0.30653950572013855,
0.22953206300735474,
-0.08839551359415054,
-0.2720913589000702,
-0.2047785371541977,
0.27588003873825073,
0.016779424622654915,
-0.25657275319099426,
-0.6659443378448486,
0.26282820105552673,
0.31181812286376953,
-0.04082513228058815,
0.618211030960083,
0.6404450535774231,
-0.5241296887397766,
-0.5635426044464111,
-0.18811744451522827,
-0.25792062282562256,
-0.4301033616065979,
0.43526846170425415,
-0.5290514826774597,
-0.9039824604988098,
0.024520497769117355,
-0.10808689892292023,
-0.07643671333789825,
0.4584067165851593,
0.30940356850624084,
-0.7267327308654785,
0.9160938858985901,
0.6796891689300537,
-0.35098814964294434,
0.510269820690155,
-0.4810901880264282,
0.15326829254627228,
-0.7263182997703552,
-0.1739647090435028,
-0.8972348570823669,
-0.47861960530281067,
-0.36581525206565857,
-0.3212451934814453,
0.6526234745979309,
0.3103294372558594,
-0.36107829213142395,
0.32148197293281555,
-0.38580507040023804,
0.6804503798484802,
0.7136565446853638,
0.43961140513420105,
0.26529955863952637,
-0.014246607199311256,
-0.16738715767860413,
-0.22353492677211761,
-0.7289432287216187,
-0.7701224088668823,
0.9896103143692017,
0.3923717737197876,
0.6585691571235657,
-0.12258382141590118,
0.7592262625694275,
0.15231359004974365,
0.21922792494297028,
-0.8356121182441711,
0.26583918929100037,
0.008229300379753113,
-0.6364757418632507,
-0.38886758685112,
-0.3823021948337555,
-0.8940309286117554,
0.295472651720047,
-0.49892306327819824,
-0.6030035018920898,
0.29531556367874146,
-0.008380175568163395,
-0.6985090970993042,
0.05461825802922249,
-0.37853285670280457,
0.7162240743637085,
-0.2581389844417572,
-0.3454030156135559,
-0.3115294277667999,
-0.47436514496803284,
0.16887503862380981,
-0.21020637452602386,
0.07465000450611115,
-0.0956864207983017,
-0.002759220777079463,
0.6339364051818848,
-0.18683834373950958,
0.8243534564971924,
-0.06422828137874603,
0.35974571108818054,
0.4407340884208679,
0.0016942326910793781,
0.2501804232597351,
0.19499462842941284,
-0.2834526598453522,
0.17664965987205505,
0.2590336501598358,
-0.5260738134384155,
-0.6476736664772034,
0.3600744307041168,
-0.8165850639343262,
0.07354158908128738,
-0.5453879833221436,
-0.1783282458782196,
-0.3680626451969147,
0.007601405493915081,
0.9184034466743469,
0.7122615575790405,
-0.11551990360021591,
0.6171282529830933,
0.4423235058784485,
-0.5159025192260742,
0.5891847610473633,
0.10489947348833084,
0.1994612067937851,
-0.40359848737716675,
0.7206609845161438,
0.3812023997306824,
0.21452607214450836,
0.4080272316932678,
0.24819087982177734,
-0.13988488912582397,
-0.5694156289100647,
-0.30601736903190613,
-0.30407455563545227,
-0.942544162273407,
-0.7386109232902527,
-0.5038498640060425,
-0.3452414274215698,
-0.26677000522613525,
-0.3623589277267456,
-0.24672506749629974,
-0.0836828276515007,
-0.5380986928939819,
0.02988227643072605,
-0.17098897695541382,
0.5394394993782043,
0.43937939405441284,
0.4838687777519226,
-0.9807958006858826,
-0.13311666250228882,
0.09243685007095337,
0.22631987929344177,
-0.023605789989233017,
-0.7465788125991821,
-0.7197040319442749,
-0.3337726593017578,
-0.6221033334732056,
-0.677282989025116,
0.3122040927410126,
0.4109427332878113,
0.7600314021110535,
0.5927588939666748,
0.05159370228648186,
0.713261604309082,
-0.3276219666004181,
0.7288914322853088,
0.020444605499505997,
-0.8639219403266907,
0.7154743671417236,
-0.08078448474407196,
0.4742562472820282,
1.292794108390808,
0.6693055629730225,
-0.22828130424022675,
-0.23822838068008423,
-0.5931397080421448,
-0.35692834854125977,
0.7004573345184326,
0.1817350685596466,
-0.002921378007158637,
0.15801581740379333,
0.3481729030609131,
0.4783586263656616,
0.08224166929721832,
-0.5458298921585083,
0.07542098313570023,
-0.03190551698207855,
-0.3122049570083618,
-0.16469256579875946,
-0.2119859904050827,
0.1371172070503235,
-0.6357770562171936,
0.7451175451278687,
-0.3099948763847351,
0.15288399159908295,
0.28972628712654114,
-0.3239489495754242,
-0.07463924586772919,
0.20703817903995514,
0.3365294933319092,
0.6207858920097351,
-0.05396778881549835,
0.12671232223510742,
0.5193033218383789,
-0.4251490533351898,
0.17488780617713928,
-0.3081655502319336,
-0.2953800559043884,
0.03942161798477173,
0.5937449336051941,
0.5779575109481812,
0.29550379514694214,
-0.6916044354438782,
0.6698839068412781,
0.06426592171192169,
-0.009168069809675217,
0.00024844505242072046,
0.19266806542873383,
-0.7257837057113647,
0.44230976700782776,
0.4617999792098999,
0.25537869334220886,
0.47738808393478394,
-0.7602018713951111,
0.4000070095062256,
0.3535505533218384,
-0.6708683967590332,
-0.03535923361778259,
0.22936591506004333,
0.12463720142841339,
-0.22002463042736053,
0.5932970643043518,
-0.3322141766548157,
-0.6021164059638977,
0.46626928448677063,
0.6207879185676575,
0.7231458425521851,
0.007064767647534609,
0.12677504122257233,
0.7874270081520081,
0.14756013453006744,
0.05139763280749321,
-0.02584713324904442,
-0.2186264842748642,
-0.6336126327514648,
-0.1834278404712677,
-0.5953616499900818,
-0.3246418237686157,
0.1654072403907776,
-0.31679874658584595,
0.6586023569107056,
-0.5253296494483948,
-0.1650981605052948,
-0.37290340662002563,
0.35961610078811646,
-0.7508951425552368,
0.43664607405662537,
-0.13834872841835022,
0.8217923641204834,
-0.7565368413925171,
0.885341227054596,
0.521553635597229,
-0.34894615411758423,
-0.6030226945877075,
0.2984893321990967,
0.3013922870159149,
-0.055738311260938644,
0.6844465136528015,
0.4638627767562866,
-0.1997758448123932,
-0.15982244908809662,
-0.6995297074317932,
-0.6889323592185974,
1.1840808391571045,
0.11161398142576218,
-0.3870513141155243,
0.5181089639663696,
0.013078145682811737,
0.4096181094646454,
-0.37951233983039856,
0.5415292978286743,
0.6287636160850525,
0.15079838037490845,
-0.11523901671171188,
-0.6960728168487549,
-0.368662029504776,
-0.13566239178180695,
-0.035812072455883026,
-0.09487241506576538,
-0.49798688292503357,
0.37685006856918335,
0.008823766373097897,
-0.21395224332809448,
-0.08424510806798935,
0.7516131401062012,
0.48072177171707153,
0.789774477481842,
0.447186678647995,
0.2752275764942169,
0.8984192609786987,
0.013906343840062618,
1.0387576818466187,
0.13045725226402283,
0.3177335262298584,
1.1069835424423218,
-0.011179843917489052,
1.1778857707977295,
0.25064387917518616,
-0.24691137671470642,
0.18620489537715912,
1.073773741722107,
0.032075319439172745,
0.5120187401771545,
0.017455745488405228,
-0.3003990948200226,
-0.03807436302304268,
-0.12065087258815765,
-0.14627739787101746,
0.7823737859725952,
0.18527889251708984,
-0.22880081832408905,
-0.18153798580169678,
0.41841521859169006,
-0.20087330043315887,
0.22648029029369354,
-0.15418313443660736,
0.6706321239471436,
0.12630826234817505,
-0.36486953496932983,
0.20643015205860138,
-0.04116038605570793,
0.9585010409355164,
-0.20040903985500336,
-0.15319094061851501,
-0.1933670938014984,
0.19597464799880981,
-0.40369176864624023,
-0.5265675783157349,
0.1918729990720749,
-0.029369942843914032,
-0.1524859517812729,
0.05415608733892441,
0.7259779572486877,
-0.27360299229621887,
-0.49688616394996643,
0.07085122168064117,
0.2767167389392853,
0.29928573966026306,
-0.10939396917819977,
-0.6101719737052917,
-0.1689491868019104,
-0.3938201069831848,
-0.11116175353527069,
0.668685257434845,
0.5146477818489075,
0.05741462856531143,
0.31131646037101746,
0.4293837547302246,
-0.0956307202577591,
-0.13989637792110443,
-0.20143721997737885,
0.4164195656776428,
-0.5725181102752686,
-0.5285544395446777,
-0.915790855884552,
0.43325233459472656,
-0.15522614121437073,
-0.6911203861236572,
0.8341391086578369,
0.9763177633285522,
1.2546827793121338,
0.0745772272348404,
0.9207845330238342,
0.1494186520576477,
0.6556318402290344,
-0.5296544432640076,
0.8421579599380493,
-0.6085501909255981,
0.19494576752185822,
-0.5965057611465454,
-0.8584728240966797,
-0.2903763949871063,
0.881708025932312,
-0.10083746165037155,
0.0514601431787014,
0.9730799198150635,
0.4855124056339264,
-0.1363172084093094,
0.0360446535050869,
0.6242807507514954,
-0.3291075527667999,
0.20003642141819,
0.39191681146621704,
0.9846384525299072,
-0.75504469871521,
0.38227346539497375,
-0.5811614990234375,
-0.24901120364665985,
-0.32980430126190186,
-0.6805047392845154,
-0.9798898100852966,
-0.9207338094711304,
-0.1403343677520752,
-0.47124072909355164,
-0.2394166737794876,
1.3653064966201782,
0.9954636693000793,
-0.793709933757782,
-0.24817948043346405,
0.32028982043266296,
-0.11315298080444336,
-0.20154164731502533,
-0.26598885655403137,
0.3434695601463318,
-0.764883279800415,
-0.909954309463501,
0.49978572130203247,
0.3514012396335602,
0.1687086522579193,
0.09121441096067429,
-0.16799159348011017,
-0.04866601526737213,
-0.16341401636600494,
1.0224260091781616,
-0.09347259253263474,
-0.28482282161712646,
-0.21671062707901,
-0.16537371277809143,
-0.41358473896980286,
0.29035741090774536,
0.8140236735343933,
-0.8485999703407288,
0.3007597327232361,
0.7047562003135681,
1.201054573059082,
0.520990252494812,
0.157136470079422,
0.32037362456321716,
-0.7793039083480835,
0.052025824785232544,
0.5095279812812805,
0.14700141549110413,
0.07171961665153503,
-0.4717358648777008,
0.5507054924964905,
0.15805035829544067,
-0.7360551953315735,
-0.6977221369743347,
-0.1505710631608963,
-0.6395803689956665,
-0.5098103880882263,
1.120313048362732,
-0.1425991654396057,
-0.0638287290930748,
-0.2005346715450287,
-0.2900220453739166,
0.1694037765264511,
-0.26713716983795166,
0.8087489604949951,
0.7907994389533997,
-0.456012099981308,
-0.2376958727836609,
-0.8041144013404846,
0.7094290852546692,
0.28047409653663635,
-1.0986957550048828,
-0.6155582666397095,
0.4946053922176361,
0.12248246371746063,
-0.307110071182251,
0.5745676755905151,
-0.11006239801645279,
0.23781509697437286,
-0.18266576528549194,
-0.2830488979816437,
0.30117008090019226,
-0.6709582209587097,
-0.6265786290168762,
0.39846596121788025,
0.062233082950115204,
-0.31475523114204407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18115v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18115v1
|
The Knesset Corpus: An Annotated Corpus of Hebrew Parliamentary Proceedings
| 2024-05-28T12:23:39 | 2024-05-28T12:23:39 |
Gili Goldin, Nick Howell, Noam Ordan, Ella Rabinovich, Shuly Wintner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7
|
We present the Knesset Corpus, a corpus of Hebrew parliamentary proceedings
containing over 30 million sentences (over 384 million tokens) from all the
(plenary and committee) protocols held in the Israeli parliament between 1998
and 2022. Sentences are annotated with morpho-syntactic information and are
associated with detailed meta-information reflecting demographic and political
properties of the speakers, based on a large database of parliament members and
factions that we compiled. We discuss the structure and composition of the
corpus and the various processing steps we applied to it. To demonstrate the
utility of this novel dataset we present two use cases. We show that the corpus
can be used to examine historical developments in the style of political
discussions by showing a reduction in lexical richness in the proceedings over
time. We also investigate some differences between the styles of men and women
speakers. These use cases exemplify the potential of the corpus to shed light
on important trends in the Israeli society, supporting research in linguistics,
political science, communication, law, etc.
|
[
-0.5969237685203552,
-0.38469070196151733,
0.18159189820289612,
0.05591144040226936,
-0.4545908570289612,
-0.272824227809906,
-0.19011996686458588,
-0.030614245682954788,
0.6137979626655579,
0.7261339426040649,
0.01186895091086626,
-0.47147008776664734,
-0.5770143270492554,
0.08315402269363403,
-0.7484769225120544,
0.5869401693344116,
0.5770096778869629,
0.1653289794921875,
0.12487690895795822,
-0.21513602137565613,
-0.46071845293045044,
-0.3911760151386261,
-0.1936868578195572,
-0.4279051423072815,
0.38767799735069275,
0.4656100571155548,
0.8997278213500977,
0.746355414390564,
0.15516583621501923,
0.3819276690483093,
-0.24915681779384613,
0.10450970381498337,
-0.11658567935228348,
0.15810219943523407,
-0.15098336338996887,
-0.4893791377544403,
-0.42975401878356934,
-0.08229192346334457,
0.9166035652160645,
0.7198176980018616,
-0.062028028070926666,
0.2592761218547821,
-0.39130479097366333,
0.9209728240966797,
-0.654975950717926,
0.4655710756778717,
-0.5302466750144958,
0.18816494941711426,
-0.9045618176460266,
-0.5635173320770264,
-0.6809219717979431,
-0.07581289857625961,
-0.053546514362096786,
-0.18665768206119537,
-0.16693879663944244,
0.2167866975069046,
0.4239940345287323,
-0.07919619977474213,
-0.310190349817276,
-0.14779189229011536,
-0.4734995663166046,
0.41732144355773926,
-0.5568080544471741,
0.25327879190444946,
0.7444618344306946,
0.16585946083068848,
-0.2775286138057709,
-0.8335742950439453,
-0.25898653268814087,
-0.15227936208248138,
-0.18711796402931213,
0.07875094562768936,
-0.18949341773986816,
-0.16513054072856903,
-0.06004175543785095,
0.1256415694952011,
-0.5337526202201843,
0.01424128282815218,
-0.7338501811027527,
-0.4259333908557892,
0.26596012711524963,
0.10434580594301224,
0.3829317092895508,
-0.7187222838401794,
-0.02894452214241028,
-0.16208600997924805,
-0.716513991355896,
-0.12871119379997253,
0.8415419459342957,
0.2602680027484894,
-0.02898268960416317,
0.8713542222976685,
-0.23224961757659912,
0.6187344193458557,
-0.35890308022499084,
0.3235379159450531,
0.16124065220355988,
-0.5257640480995178,
0.07944165170192719,
0.270211398601532,
0.8151834607124329,
0.24217011034488678,
0.3183533251285553,
-0.06468205153942108,
0.28068822622299194,
-0.042502861469984055,
0.33675137162208557,
-0.8442431688308716,
-0.30476024746894836,
0.05974506214261055,
-0.7613230347633362,
-0.09645974636077881,
0.24446462094783783,
-1.037148118019104,
-0.3124874234199524,
-0.3073700964450836,
-0.35473769903182983,
-0.6161708235740662,
-0.3235219120979309,
0.09202796965837479,
-0.48935025930404663,
0.05229906365275383,
0.13852062821388245,
-0.8744271397590637,
0.4709461033344269,
0.8515741229057312,
0.6647709608078003,
0.23259127140045166,
-0.08122575283050537,
-0.612955629825592,
-0.0767330452799797,
-0.4828958511352539,
0.6372696757316589,
-0.9481903314590454,
-0.49055957794189453,
0.303803026676178,
-0.3103213310241699,
0.20743320882320404,
-0.5765787959098816,
0.46406856179237366,
-0.7258428931236267,
-0.057397663593292236,
-0.07697222381830215,
-0.726709246635437,
0.18013359606266022,
-0.14554688334465027,
-0.8430082201957703,
0.6619698405265808,
-0.0789521262049675,
-0.6817821264266968,
0.16315890848636627,
-0.9455007314682007,
-0.3997345566749573,
0.23871049284934998,
-0.52833491563797,
-0.2112080603837967,
0.047760508954524994,
-0.11999356746673584,
0.23758681118488312,
0.12797169387340546,
0.5659429430961609,
0.2406199723482132,
-0.373929888010025,
0.6037925481796265,
-0.11013124883174896,
0.8116969466209412,
0.2632138133049011,
-0.19665996730327606,
0.36898404359817505,
-0.956459641456604,
-0.27907970547676086,
-0.2750299870967865,
-0.36467647552490234,
-0.10443606227636337,
0.2070130556821823,
0.2948477864265442,
-0.13351936638355255,
0.2110411822795868,
-0.6247809529304504,
-0.04589862376451492,
-0.640846312046051,
0.8729143738746643,
0.5150793790817261,
-0.18098066747188568,
0.49705740809440613,
-0.35009509325027466,
0.21329672634601593,
-0.0015989196253940463,
0.00818719994276762,
-0.385337769985199,
-0.7944469451904297,
-0.3974112868309021,
-0.0031081608030945063,
0.9146956205368042,
0.39857810735702515,
-0.07401234656572342,
0.4625096321105957,
-0.10114773362874985,
-0.4607759118080139,
-0.2979932427406311,
-0.3130233585834503,
0.23635677993297577,
0.13619069755077362,
0.15950633585453033,
-0.30753520131111145,
-0.8601608872413635,
-1.0979002714157104,
0.07242674380540848,
-0.7065485119819641,
0.24613548815250397,
0.2742697596549988,
0.5665423274040222,
0.3822130262851715,
0.9322107434272766,
0.07310330122709274,
0.12059540301561356,
-0.023954417556524277,
0.5613032579421997,
-0.20848201215267181,
0.3223154842853546,
0.3722670376300812,
-1.0118341445922852,
-0.16044041514396667,
0.06333167850971222,
-0.24927964806556702,
-0.30365708470344543,
0.11065319925546646,
-0.3566909730434418,
0.056071557104587555,
0.6138597726821899,
-0.427672415971756,
0.6208210587501526,
0.4422183632850647,
-0.7668183445930481,
0.3920014798641205,
0.20096607506275177,
0.292654424905777,
-0.8876978754997253,
0.08876322209835052,
-0.637599527835846,
-0.4608769714832306,
-0.4214332103729248,
-0.18605837225914001,
0.158086895942688,
-0.2280655801296234,
-0.7069148421287537,
0.4799033999443054,
-0.1766187846660614,
-0.23364436626434326,
-0.2743624448776245,
0.2730284035205841,
-0.26770737767219543,
0.1811881810426712,
-0.34161868691444397,
0.9467824697494507,
0.10714391618967056,
-0.23560252785682678,
0.2990414500236511,
1.0095635652542114,
-0.5455302000045776,
0.1400618553161621,
-0.042395275086164474,
0.2834652364253998,
-0.30957576632499695,
0.09047586470842361,
-1.1734912395477295,
-0.3106989860534668,
0.3156435787677765,
-0.44285938143730164,
0.3152170777320862,
-0.01635204441845417,
-0.5734824538230896,
0.09405891597270966,
-0.26731666922569275,
0.5046051740646362,
0.41921016573905945,
0.3112022876739502,
0.5101481676101685,
0.7625521421432495,
-0.4934140741825104,
-0.7463528513908386,
-0.6706535220146179,
0.5327373743057251,
-0.05636617913842201,
-0.5385019183158875,
0.5251173377037048,
0.20436573028564453,
-0.7259556651115417,
0.5594069957733154,
0.3069375157356262,
0.0952451080083847,
-0.08600214868783951,
0.5984185934066772,
0.05332870036363602,
-0.38043317198753357,
0.32141441106796265,
-0.3125183880329132,
-0.17961229383945465,
-0.17422804236412048,
0.06032548472285271,
1.2810417413711548,
-0.21276436746120453,
-0.351304829120636,
-0.7572931051254272,
0.6393756866455078,
0.5763029456138611,
-0.2904961109161377,
0.8086436986923218,
0.15322467684745789,
-0.16968335211277008,
0.13053230941295624,
-0.5601757168769836,
0.06130591034889221,
-0.3428381085395813,
0.40703991055488586,
0.1160944476723671,
-0.8256076574325562,
0.6932591795921326,
-0.15790286660194397,
0.1857655942440033,
0.7365671992301941,
0.8251011967658997,
0.17211772501468658,
0.2440093457698822,
0.1771102249622345,
-0.27350711822509766,
0.5982142090797424,
0.3636048436164856,
-0.06723122298717499,
-0.5592721104621887,
-0.23696763813495636,
-0.8029757142066956,
-0.6340707540512085,
-0.5564408302307129,
-0.32272759079933167,
-0.01889529637992382,
-0.43194133043289185,
-0.1885686069726944,
0.29029446840286255,
-0.07300975173711777,
0.2760551869869232,
0.8338832259178162,
-0.18517954647541046,
-0.07785362750291824,
-0.3048705756664276,
0.13656233251094818,
-0.07795669138431549,
-0.3873073160648346,
-0.7690587639808655,
1.1044400930404663,
0.03274144232273102,
0.08849973231554031,
0.25931960344314575,
0.6035908460617065,
0.7374143004417419,
0.19560134410858154,
-0.4291038513183594,
0.8863732218742371,
-0.28691551089286804,
-0.6818934082984924,
-0.3015146255493164,
-0.3400023281574249,
-1.1156628131866455,
0.2426445186138153,
0.1205502301454544,
-0.5686584711074829,
0.10972684621810913,
-0.21031156182289124,
-0.5848592519760132,
0.21496964991092682,
-0.30776429176330566,
0.7740379571914673,
0.20076261460781097,
0.06006899103522301,
-0.39063534140586853,
-0.8975306153297424,
0.14314106106758118,
0.30709487199783325,
0.19620183110237122,
-0.35117626190185547,
-0.07659999281167984,
1.2118943929672241,
-0.37554019689559937,
0.939620316028595,
0.13273440301418304,
0.5299519300460815,
0.42187032103538513,
-0.08400087803602219,
0.048493240028619766,
-0.02137565240263939,
-0.37172117829322815,
-0.05220082774758339,
0.13359829783439636,
-0.3405320346355438,
-0.11941443383693695,
0.32001549005508423,
-0.7433491349220276,
-0.4887704849243164,
-0.25756311416625977,
-0.7772607207298279,
0.08626766502857208,
0.051287829875946045,
-0.22064648568630219,
0.9364684224128723,
-0.4559060037136078,
0.7876787781715393,
0.1126231998205185,
-0.2225978523492813,
0.6858015656471252,
0.07363667339086533,
-0.45518794655799866,
-0.5840120315551758,
0.4641563594341278,
0.3398146629333496,
-0.20363780856132507,
0.44935137033462524,
0.34093308448791504,
-0.19225506484508514,
-0.626875102519989,
-0.4631638824939728,
-0.009226852096617222,
-0.7929466962814331,
-0.07390192896127701,
-0.43399882316589355,
-0.2677105665206909,
-0.38748738169670105,
0.1195957288146019,
-0.3571704030036926,
-0.8030427098274231,
-0.183217853307724,
0.044852811843156815,
0.20221172273159027,
0.6346840858459473,
0.01727139763534069,
0.5330767631530762,
-0.5609573721885681,
0.016131287440657616,
-0.07332449406385422,
0.013148896396160126,
-0.4614357352256775,
-0.30295538902282715,
0.29140573740005493,
-0.405078262090683,
-0.18462629616260529,
-1.2435399293899536,
0.33431413769721985,
0.3733235001564026,
0.22476103901863098,
0.22623245418071747,
0.026623785495758057,
0.5064570307731628,
-0.9479645490646362,
1.1674448251724243,
-0.08807504922151566,
-0.7034221291542053,
0.5613032579421997,
-0.46394261717796326,
0.1830778568983078,
0.5380995273590088,
-0.11464671790599823,
-0.5673643946647644,
-0.5219873785972595,
-0.7139186859130859,
-1.0109244585037231,
0.5158511996269226,
0.37612077593803406,
0.5421224236488342,
-0.35842251777648926,
0.5553157925605774,
0.41124051809310913,
0.4300115406513214,
-0.149335116147995,
-0.3867407441139221,
-0.08696254342794418,
-0.11801015585660934,
0.443909227848053,
-0.6886586546897888,
-0.38796672224998474,
-0.197500541806221,
0.5966572761535645,
0.07379327714443207,
0.2901413142681122,
0.03448580577969551,
-0.001167750800959766,
-0.05150502547621727,
0.7033680081367493,
0.9011160731315613,
1.1078078746795654,
-0.02725141867995262,
0.6041194200515747,
-0.1117914468050003,
-0.34332966804504395,
-0.18177935481071472,
-0.016664788126945496,
-0.2716520428657532,
0.4010615944862366,
0.273263543844223,
0.6498209834098816,
0.5774345397949219,
-0.7661216855049133,
0.5044810175895691,
0.0018663523951545358,
-0.37460094690322876,
-0.7851690053939819,
-0.31021648645401,
0.5443455576896667,
0.5381954908370972,
0.19642730057239532,
0.22620020806789398,
0.12882468104362488,
-0.9484925866127014,
0.7831910252571106,
0.1724315583705902,
0.04184878617525101,
-0.2756481468677521,
0.5288513898849487,
0.06977291405200958,
-0.670165479183197,
0.39969179034233093,
-0.3000481128692627,
-0.3396887183189392,
0.4392912685871124,
0.33181801438331604,
0.3620188534259796,
-0.10450703650712967,
0.41260620951652527,
0.05457129701972008,
-0.1049283891916275,
0.128522589802742,
0.30706867575645447,
0.01436945702880621,
-0.4233093857765198,
-0.5154117941856384,
-0.8183776140213013,
-0.5356076955795288,
0.2257693111896515,
-0.4798879623413086,
0.014782354235649109,
-0.5545803904533386,
-0.5956047773361206,
0.49376195669174194,
-0.006354725919663906,
-0.41569069027900696,
-0.6388893127441406,
0.5518463253974915,
0.9337324500083923,
-0.6632539629936218,
0.5081265568733215,
0.3883059024810791,
-0.17493267357349396,
-0.1586378812789917,
-0.46035298705101013,
0.12463366240262985,
-0.8456675410270691,
0.9244497418403625,
-0.1080239862203598,
0.035544849932193756,
-0.22538426518440247,
-0.1302790492773056,
-0.43015995621681213,
0.5679749250411987,
0.42542558908462524,
-0.5695337653160095,
0.19797158241271973,
0.4498126208782196,
0.14613917469978333,
-0.14329738914966583,
0.05082162842154503,
0.45824623107910156,
0.7250381708145142,
-0.11087871342897415,
-0.9019028544425964,
-0.18520590662956238,
-0.5733462572097778,
-0.3289833962917328,
0.5711880326271057,
-0.6403483748435974,
0.9350329637527466,
0.8070624470710754,
-0.15131941437721252,
0.49235090613365173,
0.9104025959968567,
-0.13925260305404663,
0.12505808472633362,
0.33932942152023315,
0.370371550321579,
0.8385217785835266,
-0.1966608613729477,
0.7672260403633118,
-0.5489817261695862,
-0.26126629114151,
0.7627485990524292,
-0.3192545771598816,
1.0928397178649902,
0.5564078092575073,
-0.19056200981140137,
0.38339757919311523,
0.3006126880645752,
0.12441016733646393,
0.3332923352718353,
0.5528383851051331,
-0.3358749747276306,
-0.2357911616563797,
-0.4351324439048767,
-0.2437286078929901,
0.723534107208252,
0.3226679265499115,
-0.230331689119339,
-0.4123535454273224,
-0.10832536220550537,
0.1459048092365265,
0.3050374388694763,
-0.31380361318588257,
0.51114422082901,
0.10542304813861847,
-0.7160112261772156,
-0.1972636729478836,
-0.02483176253736019,
0.1664973944425583,
-0.47561460733413696,
-0.16069748997688293,
0.27152496576309204,
0.023509511724114418,
-0.11217190325260162,
-0.8533409237861633,
0.5251443386077881,
0.014331628568470478,
0.09912221878767014,
-0.36953797936439514,
0.7282678484916687,
-0.21387898921966553,
-0.23024334013462067,
-0.005744127091020346,
0.6918379068374634,
0.5343679785728455,
0.2062997668981552,
-0.08077298849821091,
0.35944172739982605,
-0.381618469953537,
-0.4156745374202728,
0.39372387528419495,
0.45398879051208496,
-0.12186247110366821,
0.11789596080780029,
0.3539517819881439,
0.2778993844985962,
0.3796277940273285,
0.3628814220428467,
0.7571114301681519,
-0.7351338267326355,
-0.4105663299560547,
-1.3037911653518677,
0.4069330096244812,
-0.32598820328712463,
-0.5490642189979553,
0.35979196429252625,
0.6718364357948303,
0.5858176350593567,
0.251447468996048,
0.6104846596717834,
-0.1519106924533844,
0.12970788776874542,
-0.6576701998710632,
0.7237290143966675,
-0.03319717198610306,
-0.14167261123657227,
0.49779781699180603,
-0.4743989408016205,
-0.43263673782348633,
0.631109893321991,
-0.2544347047805786,
-0.24673767387866974,
0.504974365234375,
0.4810224175453186,
0.05468244478106499,
0.648009717464447,
0.348526269197464,
0.025615988299250603,
-0.05040239542722702,
0.038662731647491455,
1.0466587543487549,
0.025774482637643814,
0.4603307247161865,
-0.18532948195934296,
0.18745112419128418,
-0.3629879355430603,
-0.6700149774551392,
-0.8370541334152222,
-0.9324490427970886,
-0.17557479441165924,
-0.22181054949760437,
0.2502838969230652,
1.2588093280792236,
0.5163081884384155,
-0.7680577039718628,
-0.384917289018631,
0.07484688609838486,
-0.4995286762714386,
0.15564605593681335,
-0.10635089874267578,
0.5624815225601196,
-0.4352913498878479,
-0.5938567519187927,
0.5518273711204529,
0.42620140314102173,
-0.4987483620643616,
-0.09479192644357681,
0.2914125323295593,
-0.3980565071105957,
0.06544000655412674,
0.3163506090641022,
0.16273090243339539,
-0.9065346717834473,
-0.6580677032470703,
-0.2620180547237396,
0.012604320421814919,
0.41242149472236633,
0.9699028134346008,
-0.2847064137458801,
0.2597539722919464,
0.7273970246315002,
0.7738397717475891,
0.56276935338974,
-0.03696915879845619,
0.3701340854167938,
-0.9284800887107849,
0.41091951727867126,
0.46825000643730164,
0.7740296125411987,
0.2737719416618347,
0.16180679202079773,
0.4742116928100586,
0.1502186506986618,
-0.520156741142273,
-0.727318286895752,
0.32077309489250183,
-1.1702460050582886,
-0.3420826494693756,
0.9950317740440369,
-0.002905456116423011,
-0.45854705572128296,
-0.576171338558197,
-0.49479326605796814,
0.5281767845153809,
-0.5708027482032776,
0.6343967318534851,
1.1877778768539429,
-0.0826745480298996,
-0.23442332446575165,
-1.2128565311431885,
0.29187673330307007,
0.6812504529953003,
-0.443302184343338,
0.020670238882303238,
0.30994462966918945,
-0.11288820952177048,
0.6116880178451538,
0.8974894285202026,
-0.6238365173339844,
0.3015647232532501,
0.27866217494010925,
-0.12679415941238403,
-0.2116910219192505,
-0.2664179503917694,
0.017699776217341423,
0.8639866709709167,
-0.10025226324796677,
-0.22094716131687164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18113v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18113v1
|
Facilitating Multi-Role and Multi-Behavior Collaboration of Large Language Models for Online Job Seeking and Recruiting
| 2024-05-28T12:23:16 | 2024-05-28T12:23:16 |
Hongda Sun, Hongzhan Lin, Haiyu Yan, Chen Zhu, Yang Song, Xin Gao, Shuo Shang, Rui Yan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The emergence of online recruitment services has revolutionized the
traditional landscape of job seeking and recruitment, necessitating the
development of high-quality industrial applications to improve person-job
fitting. Existing methods generally rely on modeling the latent semantics of
resumes and job descriptions and learning a matching function between them.
Inspired by the powerful role-playing capabilities of Large Language Models
(LLMs), we propose to introduce a mock interview process between LLM-played
interviewers and candidates. The mock interview conversations can provide
additional evidence for candidate evaluation, thereby augmenting traditional
person-job fitting based solely on resumes and job descriptions. However,
characterizing these two roles in online recruitment still presents several
challenges, such as developing the skills to raise interview questions,
formulating appropriate answers, and evaluating two-sided fitness. To this end,
we propose MockLLM, a novel applicable framework that divides the person-job
matching process into two modules: mock interview generation and two-sided
evaluation in handshake protocol, jointly enhancing their performance through
collaborative behaviors between interviewers and candidates. We design a
role-playing framework as a multi-role and multi-behavior paradigm to enable a
single LLM agent to effectively behave with multiple functions for both
parties. Moreover, we propose reflection memory generation and dynamic prompt
modification techniques to refine the behaviors of both sides, enabling
continuous optimization of the augmented additional evidence. Extensive
experimental results show that MockLLM can achieve the best performance on
person-job matching accompanied by high mock interview quality, envisioning its
emerging application in real online recruitment in the future.
|
[
-0.4199228584766388,
-0.6452597975730896,
0.7663289904594421,
0.2846255898475647,
0.07451720535755157,
0.14862380921840668,
0.022134220227599144,
-0.7536713480949402,
0.5692940950393677,
0.4579581320285797,
-0.7701495885848999,
-0.0514829196035862,
-0.05789215862751007,
0.029497873038053513,
-0.021672965958714485,
0.6472371816635132,
0.31230899691581726,
0.2780560553073883,
-0.5149211287498474,
0.06735661625862122,
-0.3444802165031433,
-0.6687261462211609,
-0.8615769147872925,
-0.2977944016456604,
0.46314284205436707,
0.257991224527359,
0.6526299715042114,
0.3331802785396576,
0.08102068305015564,
0.34739941358566284,
0.15930123627185822,
0.285595566034317,
-0.5111181139945984,
0.3553749620914459,
-0.0908193290233612,
-0.5074887275695801,
-0.8112680912017822,
0.35950207710266113,
0.3877160847187042,
0.4157830774784088,
-0.7127286195755005,
0.05222403630614281,
-0.2527346611022949,
-0.0017000281950458884,
-0.32223767042160034,
0.08822771161794662,
-0.6055694818496704,
-0.11906041204929352,
-0.03034752979874611,
-0.3965367376804352,
-0.29438114166259766,
-0.27559974789619446,
0.07450283318758011,
-0.5506171584129333,
0.2901206612586975,
0.22189746797084808,
0.5539847016334534,
-0.24566888809204102,
-0.44204407930374146,
-0.19296008348464966,
-0.6172612905502319,
0.657701313495636,
-0.8254681825637817,
0.46005868911743164,
0.6782668828964233,
0.46152248978614807,
-0.38751381635665894,
-0.38075941801071167,
-0.6834214329719543,
-0.16052553057670593,
-0.06072140485048294,
0.24715574085712433,
0.7735846042633057,
0.39930883049964905,
0.06291574239730835,
0.39505982398986816,
-0.6003889441490173,
0.22646206617355347,
-0.33166441321372986,
-0.030528713017702103,
0.6750697493553162,
0.03810853883624077,
0.40492868423461914,
0.37936532497406006,
-0.3509603440761566,
-0.395261287689209,
-0.4099803566932678,
0.0204403605312109,
0.6817569732666016,
0.39988332986831665,
-0.048159778118133545,
0.33463671803474426,
0.026556357741355896,
0.47964930534362793,
-0.015634942799806595,
-0.35116446018218994,
-0.0994432121515274,
-0.2628259062767029,
0.015141001902520657,
0.059648092836141586,
0.45916715264320374,
0.4065084159374237,
-0.032219111919403076,
-0.05016394332051277,
-0.15444082021713257,
0.01144515909254551,
0.5284035205841064,
-0.7330887913703918,
0.09182028472423553,
0.46139293909072876,
-0.4501170516014099,
-0.3720656931400299,
0.24403870105743408,
-0.9921625256538391,
-0.5314216017723083,
-0.2017693966627121,
0.6203505992889404,
0.0025207968428730965,
-0.4577438235282898,
0.17630308866500854,
-0.12548677623271942,
0.37159115076065063,
0.407633513212204,
-0.596303403377533,
0.4752691388130188,
0.8498556613922119,
0.7050336599349976,
-0.10633919388055801,
-0.4661107659339905,
-0.880991518497467,
0.17145289480686188,
-0.1468760073184967,
0.5248510241508484,
-0.5871238112449646,
-0.3081248700618744,
0.25753387808799744,
-0.22164638340473175,
-0.11753810197114944,
-0.46641889214515686,
0.2074204385280609,
-0.905782163143158,
0.3586028218269348,
0.08983166515827179,
-0.36926764249801636,
0.1059294119477272,
0.8003036379814148,
-0.7829180359840393,
1.1983671188354492,
0.0808420330286026,
-0.2730177342891693,
0.31821444630622864,
-0.7506802678108215,
-0.29896280169487,
0.018708674237132072,
-0.40047428011894226,
-0.4670964777469635,
0.01003709714859724,
0.028789659962058067,
0.5153056383132935,
-0.3638424873352051,
-0.03182324767112732,
-0.514591634273529,
-0.701096773147583,
0.4752848148345947,
0.2763732373714447,
0.6575639843940735,
-0.07025928795337677,
0.06711184978485107,
0.11903711408376694,
-0.24580223858356476,
0.10757672786712646,
0.11878423392772675,
-0.41498157382011414,
-0.07959465682506561,
0.03215118125081062,
0.04609721153974533,
0.7263798713684082,
-0.06565927714109421,
-0.3689688742160797,
0.2795698642730713,
-0.34940969944000244,
0.00530887208878994,
0.5544002056121826,
-0.016898471862077713,
0.3102494776248932,
-0.6707248687744141,
0.7280957102775574,
-0.12511609494686127,
0.380683571100235,
-0.10695390403270721,
-0.40207439661026,
-0.4190850555896759,
-0.24892252683639526,
-0.23104622960090637,
0.6910765171051025,
-0.8634482622146606,
0.21822451055049896,
-0.01110787969082594,
-0.5010256171226501,
-0.6656386256217957,
0.08695131540298462,
0.2821448743343353,
-0.03497549518942833,
0.43798160552978516,
-0.34965255856513977,
-0.6606024503707886,
-0.712371289730072,
-0.4198587238788605,
-0.3777359426021576,
-0.08720866590738297,
0.259295791387558,
0.08368077129125595,
-0.16267499327659607,
0.9248722791671753,
-0.16714170575141907,
-0.6815756559371948,
-0.3274942934513092,
0.11632786691188812,
0.2344728410243988,
0.3116084933280945,
0.4434913992881775,
-1.0040334463119507,
-0.4042023718357086,
-0.3442184329032898,
-0.6135028004646301,
0.06469166278839111,
-0.249790757894516,
-0.030269278213381767,
0.06505905836820602,
0.542048454284668,
-0.6386218070983887,
0.024443112313747406,
0.8471734523773193,
-0.23111435770988464,
0.5917763710021973,
-0.3091524541378021,
0.5549582242965698,
-1.1262547969818115,
-0.05632198601961136,
0.03772031143307686,
-0.33980849385261536,
-0.7328455448150635,
0.5037886500358582,
-0.35078197717666626,
-0.24296608567237854,
-0.6125984191894531,
0.5669634938240051,
-0.8082339763641357,
-0.26329296827316284,
-0.17904382944107056,
0.3041851222515106,
-0.02103041112422943,
0.2759081721305847,
-0.03089999593794346,
0.7174153923988342,
0.3901047706604004,
-0.6621990203857422,
0.389076828956604,
0.3278418481349945,
-0.2301340401172638,
0.9213159680366516,
-0.3884217143058777,
0.45957475900650024,
-0.19753585755825043,
0.6562063097953796,
-0.9388965368270874,
-0.3665086627006531,
-0.19874528050422668,
-0.12290990352630615,
0.129959836602211,
-0.2849380373954773,
-0.8087230920791626,
-0.3920464515686035,
-0.603142499923706,
0.6747115850448608,
0.4077131450176239,
-0.4706520140171051,
0.9702478647232056,
0.4457113742828369,
-0.14563527703285217,
-0.34857016801834106,
-0.6489956378936768,
0.09293462336063385,
-0.24125155806541443,
-0.7282914519309998,
0.6782959699630737,
-0.26799944043159485,
-0.28161224722862244,
-0.6123316884040833,
0.02383442409336567,
-0.5538318157196045,
0.1694100946187973,
-0.0642923042178154,
0.6671925783157349,
0.0587630569934845,
-0.3004046678543091,
-0.25352150201797485,
0.22033549845218658,
-0.09671656787395477,
0.012641671113669872,
0.5344429612159729,
0.2648329734802246,
-0.5298200249671936,
-0.2665083110332489,
0.3627142608165741,
0.5595093369483948,
0.008509702980518341,
0.9653399586677551,
0.8021224141120911,
-0.22902560234069824,
-0.16617923974990845,
-1.0458693504333496,
-0.6584179997444153,
-0.521160364151001,
0.1922760009765625,
-0.2711791396141052,
-1.0955277681350708,
0.35904479026794434,
-0.22312581539154053,
0.09806536138057709,
-0.31267234683036804,
0.3982280492782593,
-0.07578780502080917,
0.9706479907035828,
0.6568742394447327,
0.2852019667625427,
0.2683987021446228,
0.3800707757472992,
0.19680514931678772,
-0.5528597235679626,
-0.41372212767601013,
-0.1701320856809616,
-0.2992534041404724,
-0.35233694314956665,
-0.8015698790550232,
0.4582231342792511,
0.18637892603874207,
0.34477534890174866,
0.39385420083999634,
-0.2681180238723755,
0.39166924357414246,
0.3423566520214081,
0.15943703055381775,
0.24870778620243073,
-0.2468789964914322,
-0.2381209433078766,
-0.18489708006381989,
-0.4391094446182251,
-0.36478114128112793,
0.5476778745651245,
0.15151116251945496,
0.5102862119674683,
0.4711010158061981,
0.4871467649936676,
0.08097916841506958,
0.19789069890975952,
-0.6556926965713501,
0.732684850692749,
0.3367443382740021,
-0.8158456087112427,
-0.18822114169597626,
-0.4265916645526886,
-0.6796504259109497,
0.5006962418556213,
-0.5421507358551025,
-0.8084183931350708,
-0.2640732526779175,
0.32240617275238037,
-0.30953118205070496,
0.2112666219472885,
-0.45770353078842163,
0.7658072710037231,
-0.43604910373687744,
-0.4364103376865387,
-0.502217710018158,
-0.5946609973907471,
0.38210800290107727,
-0.28445449471473694,
0.5596377849578857,
0.056258976459503174,
0.03765517845749855,
0.38425812125205994,
-0.2073020488023758,
0.8135521411895752,
-0.20696201920509338,
-0.030815547332167625,
0.061656851321458817,
0.5003035068511963,
0.7303158044815063,
0.05869375169277191,
-0.5792397260665894,
0.11656978726387024,
0.35345062613487244,
-0.3403269648551941,
-0.46610209345817566,
0.6229187846183777,
-0.4007524847984314,
-0.546039342880249,
-0.37307900190353394,
-0.4439699947834015,
-0.5542572736740112,
0.08071461319923401,
-0.19264891743659973,
-0.08016387373209,
-0.5448223352432251,
0.07111237198114395,
0.4202694296836853,
-0.4508167803287506,
0.11227867007255554,
0.4025789201259613,
-0.5786874890327454,
-0.06057317554950714,
0.6913727521896362,
-0.2668295204639435,
0.2516283690929413,
0.3511451184749603,
0.044038545340299606,
-0.3540775179862976,
-0.03202512115240097,
-0.0840873122215271,
0.41605839133262634,
-0.25698643922805786,
0.21332257986068726,
-0.5352233052253723,
0.040960561484098434,
-0.6337575316429138,
-0.18987812101840973,
-0.2095465064048767,
0.07259411364793777,
0.29762765765190125,
0.04807193949818611,
0.1118646040558815,
0.523200273513794,
0.08600118011236191,
0.14500932395458221,
-0.619102418422699,
0.34800443053245544,
0.6276336908340454,
0.4769030809402466,
-0.019022535532712936,
-0.12308759987354279,
-0.18338938057422638,
0.0549914576113224,
-0.0665523111820221,
-0.7779964804649353,
0.06604611873626709,
0.3167538046836853,
0.7002854943275452,
0.18731841444969177,
-0.008934220299124718,
0.7932426929473877,
-0.3277420401573181,
0.7562962174415588,
0.08620274811983109,
-0.6011583805084229,
0.2821316421031952,
-0.5245994329452515,
-0.1358596384525299,
0.624740719795227,
0.489120215177536,
-0.8791543245315552,
-0.123049795627594,
-0.407189279794693,
-0.9251199960708618,
1.098812460899353,
0.35324764251708984,
0.04381565749645233,
-0.06166348233819008,
0.1501368135213852,
-0.05883374065160751,
0.4439159035682678,
-0.5100832581520081,
0.044545359909534454,
-0.0716780573129654,
-0.005409932229667902,
0.07997360825538635,
-0.29089033603668213,
-0.30577418208122253,
-0.06441070884466171,
0.5862710475921631,
-0.14314968883991241,
0.44438260793685913,
-0.04280136525630951,
-0.008657981641590595,
0.10291218757629395,
0.21380801498889923,
0.5738890767097473,
0.42136090993881226,
-0.2106051743030548,
0.16422250866889954,
0.4179862439632416,
-0.07136007398366928,
0.02188505418598652,
-0.02031799778342247,
0.3529913127422333,
-0.2896271347999573,
0.0008794027380645275,
0.2948000431060791,
0.36655673384666443,
-0.9492524862289429,
0.8572164177894592,
-0.09024026989936829,
-0.24132058024406433,
-0.6791577339172363,
0.19965265691280365,
0.3818443715572357,
0.32415151596069336,
0.6036269068717957,
-0.4441221356391907,
-0.044486332684755325,
-0.8895102739334106,
0.32364222407341003,
0.5566791296005249,
-0.15413397550582886,
-0.2992100119590759,
0.7002002596855164,
0.13973724842071533,
-0.6897593140602112,
0.486778199672699,
-0.39330220222473145,
-0.5441422462463379,
0.5180302858352661,
0.6802233457565308,
0.43607297539711,
-0.5587716102600098,
0.29463645815849304,
0.16166794300079346,
-0.09351344406604767,
-0.7929919958114624,
0.26282963156700134,
0.2240312397480011,
-0.827524721622467,
-0.4783908724784851,
-0.5257870554924011,
-0.6004121899604797,
0.2067527323961258,
-0.4707447588443756,
0.45545852184295654,
-0.4641454815864563,
0.05297326296567917,
-0.3985028564929962,
-0.3314145803451538,
-0.6553683280944824,
0.014129189774394035,
0.02405884675681591,
0.33115723729133606,
-0.6214928030967712,
0.6255422830581665,
0.9868696331977844,
-0.4891129434108734,
-0.5962951183319092,
0.05284808576107025,
0.3839271664619446,
-0.6250620484352112,
0.3276694118976593,
0.4203339219093323,
-0.15462768077850342,
0.1375964730978012,
-0.22004841268062592,
-0.5473288297653198,
1.218140959739685,
0.3742969334125519,
-0.06673385202884674,
-0.4696424901485443,
0.14759418368339539,
0.46078839898109436,
-0.40258440375328064,
0.7987972497940063,
0.09164756536483765,
0.4323877692222595,
0.27161282300949097,
-1.3001066446304321,
0.15267275273799896,
-0.13983328640460968,
0.09795308113098145,
-0.08594945073127747,
-0.7726430296897888,
0.8341324925422668,
0.11427422612905502,
-0.12972216308116913,
0.05344934016466141,
0.3105856478214264,
0.6799177527427673,
0.08896208554506302,
0.875767707824707,
0.1224462166428566,
0.6014795899391174,
0.27625012397766113,
0.700884222984314,
-0.30981045961380005,
0.338334858417511,
1.1287007331848145,
-0.9236205816268921,
0.7035248875617981,
0.5742021203041077,
-0.1360022872686386,
0.601616382598877,
0.3769921362400055,
-0.007926998659968376,
-0.07437137514352798,
0.16227610409259796,
-0.32922691106796265,
-0.6586700677871704,
-0.17765691876411438,
0.07843735814094543,
0.49225348234176636,
0.12411613762378693,
-0.01902185007929802,
-0.3422330617904663,
-0.04997260123491287,
-0.0704854428768158,
0.3797789216041565,
-0.004264598712325096,
0.4925048053264618,
0.1218518614768982,
-0.7642203569412231,
-0.06832189112901688,
0.2217588573694229,
0.9353976845741272,
-0.44561269879341125,
-0.4693930149078369,
0.013924581930041313,
0.19601045548915863,
-0.27433791756629944,
-0.511063277721405,
0.18931056559085846,
-0.45166051387786865,
0.10535461455583572,
-0.5456082820892334,
0.5651494860649109,
-0.5668832063674927,
-0.12352200597524643,
0.6841764450073242,
0.6445652842521667,
0.38916015625,
-0.22186081111431122,
-0.8328282237052917,
0.0883290022611618,
-0.5873938798904419,
-0.0855330228805542,
0.7195001244544983,
0.16140681505203247,
0.05277673900127411,
0.6096959114074707,
0.7976038455963135,
0.1603071093559265,
-0.009637906216084957,
0.27190566062927246,
0.49875909090042114,
-0.34641507267951965,
-0.8106705546379089,
-0.5649291276931763,
0.4358751177787781,
-0.40508660674095154,
-0.05566641688346863,
0.5206776857376099,
0.6790162324905396,
0.8986235857009888,
-0.08392518758773804,
0.38783690333366394,
-0.050236813724040985,
0.6318699717521667,
-0.4290531277656555,
0.5650818347930908,
-0.6465960144996643,
0.17008371651172638,
-0.4794420003890991,
-1.0327836275100708,
0.04731025546789169,
0.8233697414398193,
0.21877522766590118,
0.547592043876648,
0.6023240685462952,
1.1199368238449097,
-0.476758748292923,
-0.4107973873615265,
0.5093982219696045,
0.05284259468317032,
0.4061472713947296,
0.3003549873828888,
0.6345655918121338,
-0.4252910912036896,
0.6272203922271729,
0.253807008266449,
-0.13820791244506836,
-0.6724352836608887,
-0.88739013671875,
-0.9201904535293579,
-0.5378657579421997,
-0.189559668302536,
-0.5506455302238464,
-0.22132539749145508,
1.4058455228805542,
0.88663250207901,
-0.40445229411125183,
-0.6864622831344604,
0.09820500761270523,
-0.31017425656318665,
-0.5538528561592102,
-0.3219214081764221,
-0.41150593757629395,
0.02113814651966095,
-0.6293684840202332,
1.0281683206558228,
0.18193268775939941,
-0.1147313043475151,
-0.5444850325584412,
-0.24569033086299896,
-0.6528031826019287,
0.3312714099884033,
0.5949463844299316,
0.30751845240592957,
-0.625781774520874,
-0.32051900029182434,
0.04267681762576103,
-0.3089061677455902,
-0.13058000802993774,
0.9426127672195435,
-0.6312918066978455,
0.42512306571006775,
0.2259366661310196,
0.777116596698761,
0.7009017467498779,
0.2773580551147461,
0.7348909974098206,
-0.9756723046302795,
0.2144419550895691,
0.2302340269088745,
-0.00048769221757538617,
0.30299967527389526,
-0.4879021644592285,
0.5399518013000488,
0.10254435986280441,
-0.4835190773010254,
-0.822620689868927,
0.4337224066257477,
-0.9253385663032532,
-0.2663355767726898,
1.1891216039657593,
0.0817577913403511,
0.14913132786750793,
-0.4086282253265381,
-0.1193484365940094,
0.3981442153453827,
-0.27217406034469604,
1.058864951133728,
0.6702038645744324,
-0.2603584825992584,
-0.2758958637714386,
-0.6202097535133362,
0.39377710223197937,
0.28442731499671936,
-0.8481391668319702,
-0.28435200452804565,
0.3839285373687744,
0.11856735497713089,
0.131442129611969,
0.9818786382675171,
0.042560890316963196,
0.1705237179994583,
-0.26359981298446655,
0.300744891166687,
-0.19900698959827423,
-0.20217478275299072,
0.08343905955553055,
0.11684654653072357,
0.3138357400894165,
0.24669548869132996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18111v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18111v2
|
ATM: Adversarial Tuning Multi-agent System Makes a Robust Retrieval-Augmented Generator
| 2024-05-28T12:18:50 | 2024-06-16T12:30:32 |
Junda Zhu, Lingyong Yan, Haibo Shi, Dawei Yin, Lei Sha
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are proven to benefit a lot from
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) in alleviating hallucinations confronted
with knowledge-intensive questions. RAG adopts information retrieval techniques
to inject external knowledge from semantic-relevant documents as input
contexts. However, due to today's Internet being flooded with numerous noisy
and fabricating content, it is inevitable that RAG systems are vulnerable to
these noises and prone to respond incorrectly. To this end, we propose to
optimize the retrieval-augmented Generator with a Adversarial Tuning
Multi-agent system (ATM). The ATM steers the Generator to have a robust
perspective of useful documents for question answering with the help of an
auxiliary Attacker agent. The Generator and the Attacker are tuned
adversarially for several iterations. After rounds of multi-agent iterative
tuning, the Generator can eventually better discriminate useful documents
amongst fabrications. The experimental results verify the effectiveness of ATM
and we also observe that the Generator can achieve better performance compared
to state-of-the-art baselines.
|
[
-0.6839916706085205,
-1.189605712890625,
0.44000938534736633,
-0.22471857070922852,
-0.3756006360054016,
0.36480915546417236,
-0.12006157636642456,
-0.4387367069721222,
0.15547049045562744,
0.6178861856460571,
-0.29901614785194397,
0.0019377820426598191,
-0.640303373336792,
0.17316710948944092,
-0.6128608584403992,
0.9430673718452454,
0.43321239948272705,
0.021356597542762756,
0.254518985748291,
-0.11272688210010529,
-0.24198155105113983,
-0.42753008008003235,
-1.2775366306304932,
-0.2756412923336029,
0.5530558824539185,
0.0643749013543129,
0.9136060476303101,
0.7268004417419434,
0.5054495930671692,
0.5117097496986389,
-0.09543808549642563,
0.7933470010757446,
-0.5213612914085388,
0.5054569840431213,
-0.15980969369411469,
-0.4386032819747925,
-0.25311028957366943,
-0.0907953679561615,
0.5138645768165588,
-0.14657968282699585,
-0.02418379858136177,
0.11323735862970352,
-0.1294470876455307,
0.493971586227417,
-0.6300258040428162,
-0.30223923921585083,
-1.281106948852539,
-0.31951090693473816,
-0.14351829886436462,
-0.6555507183074951,
-0.5026055574417114,
-0.23581013083457947,
-0.3823486268520355,
-0.6136720180511475,
0.3545454740524292,
0.2728129029273987,
0.9662531614303589,
0.5833306908607483,
-0.5336576104164124,
-0.39150431752204895,
-0.5714799761772156,
0.5436359643936157,
-0.22967471182346344,
0.22431612014770508,
0.3252064287662506,
0.42632946372032166,
-0.375485897064209,
-0.477302610874176,
-0.6907231211662292,
-0.19383838772773743,
0.21550723910331726,
0.13315755128860474,
-0.10678860545158386,
-0.03524641692638397,
0.04025588184595108,
0.2996971011161804,
-0.31449055671691895,
-0.03310327231884003,
-0.11563780903816223,
-0.3559221625328064,
0.44713979959487915,
-0.018391624093055725,
0.15631191432476044,
-0.05678112804889679,
-0.38383981585502625,
-0.2760923504829407,
-0.6893231272697449,
-0.3229902982711792,
0.7640931606292725,
0.4573417603969574,
0.5167038440704346,
0.571761965751648,
0.19679994881153107,
0.9403210878372192,
0.3732399046421051,
-0.16496972739696503,
-0.02402903139591217,
-0.09318257868289948,
-0.0006045604241080582,
-0.024030068889260292,
0.6294946670532227,
-0.05861394479870796,
0.13498279452323914,
-0.27709996700286865,
-0.47782376408576965,
-0.048293326050043106,
0.9498485326766968,
-0.5032720565795898,
0.08879371732473373,
-0.0031102881766855717,
0.03965127468109131,
-0.5547297596931458,
-0.13764247298240662,
-0.590108335018158,
-0.6147215962409973,
-0.31778132915496826,
0.779421865940094,
-0.6978250741958618,
-0.15871065855026245,
-0.3780614733695984,
-0.6007820963859558,
0.19390363991260529,
0.2842237949371338,
-0.4804162383079529,
0.04695705324411392,
0.6937287449836731,
0.7438868880271912,
0.17262226343154907,
-0.40457943081855774,
-0.9564067125320435,
0.3243560492992401,
-0.3809889256954193,
1.0907704830169678,
-0.40889185667037964,
-0.420819491147995,
-0.06212577596306801,
-0.20975731313228607,
-0.06628569960594177,
-0.5507006645202637,
0.4709962010383606,
-1.050429344177246,
-0.17821401357650757,
-0.13338486850261688,
-0.3329905867576599,
0.13674098253250122,
0.5207443237304688,
-0.7825760245323181,
0.914136528968811,
0.22041356563568115,
-0.6608730554580688,
0.052529476583004,
-0.34063833951950073,
-0.46420368552207947,
-0.048068393021821976,
-0.01830395869910717,
-0.5787248015403748,
0.1557886004447937,
0.3410186767578125,
0.026944907382130623,
-0.2925182580947876,
-0.18030181527137756,
-0.24107405543327332,
-0.5210568308830261,
0.4298671782016754,
-0.5309285521507263,
0.6223616003990173,
0.6050564050674438,
-0.08992505073547363,
0.06649806350469589,
-0.7748045325279236,
0.019878752529621124,
0.09253457933664322,
-0.6146745085716248,
-0.3789356052875519,
-0.11722707003355026,
-0.13982632756233215,
-0.09056930243968964,
0.31019124388694763,
-0.34701016545295715,
0.10477232187986374,
-0.5115597248077393,
0.09221780300140381,
1.1448988914489746,
0.16621403396129608,
0.17493750154972076,
-0.6710910201072693,
0.552904486656189,
-0.16928765177726746,
-0.03928287327289581,
0.11498831957578659,
-0.17274849116802216,
-0.6922246217727661,
-0.5149085521697998,
-0.04874984174966812,
0.486614465713501,
-1.4025793075561523,
0.2396029680967331,
0.13957010209560394,
-0.4476195275783539,
-0.7992416024208069,
0.21917185187339783,
0.5442187786102295,
0.7183958292007446,
0.3046782314777374,
0.2618652880191803,
-0.5337093472480774,
-0.654754102230072,
-0.4374428987503052,
-0.3505493998527527,
-0.030316336080431938,
0.4094390273094177,
0.21013346314430237,
-0.14009012281894684,
0.42410221695899963,
-0.26450663805007935,
-0.22802524268627167,
-0.25291869044303894,
0.10135502368211746,
-0.1282707154750824,
0.0634799674153328,
0.5305991768836975,
-0.8748759627342224,
-0.47357144951820374,
0.06337505578994751,
-0.415743350982666,
-0.06809856742620468,
0.11351168155670166,
-0.3180685043334961,
0.3142661154270172,
0.3440212607383728,
-0.6803185343742371,
-0.04332059994339943,
0.1799382120370865,
-0.3101750314235687,
0.6840623617172241,
-0.32072317600250244,
0.3239477574825287,
-1.2965905666351318,
0.11751553416252136,
-0.42067551612854004,
-0.38716885447502136,
-0.4342406392097473,
0.6525410413742065,
-0.0010173831833526492,
-0.35019516944885254,
-0.3107328414916992,
0.5640897154808044,
-0.34190258383750916,
0.15816785395145416,
-0.717701256275177,
0.2877832353115082,
0.13161057233810425,
0.3855416774749756,
-0.3819831609725952,
1.2027829885482788,
0.45997369289398193,
-0.7660079598426819,
0.5415201783180237,
0.23604533076286316,
0.05502568557858467,
0.7436783909797668,
-0.38390451669692993,
0.4526825249195099,
-0.4242754280567169,
0.011722610332071781,
-0.5552942156791687,
-0.08221317082643509,
0.04893244430422783,
-0.9111462235450745,
0.6209433674812317,
-0.003902553813531995,
-0.6060033440589905,
-0.07943523675203323,
-0.43698635697364807,
0.11065758019685745,
0.1444000005722046,
-0.6625884175300598,
0.8109511137008667,
0.5272437334060669,
0.040582187473773956,
-0.829310953617096,
-0.1374310702085495,
0.10962983965873718,
-0.38335469365119934,
-0.5311598181724548,
0.012531150132417679,
-0.017780212685465813,
-0.2881079614162445,
0.07026403397321701,
-0.09261313825845718,
-0.06524946540594101,
0.36855313181877136,
-0.12663616240024567,
0.20991502702236176,
-0.032031189650297165,
0.3104502856731415,
-0.0922783836722374,
-0.1137695461511612,
-0.1029781699180603,
-0.2966013550758362,
0.49936795234680176,
-0.12080221623182297,
-0.37366390228271484,
0.2579291760921478,
0.45774003863334656,
0.5484432578086853,
-0.40629035234451294,
0.8926365971565247,
0.7435420155525208,
-0.14332164824008942,
-0.3982362747192383,
-0.7352569699287415,
-0.05751897022128105,
-0.553196132183075,
0.4550834894180298,
-0.6317101716995239,
-0.7989791631698608,
0.5121254920959473,
-0.10411358624696732,
-0.015004518441855907,
0.6368203163146973,
0.4789981245994568,
0.028830811381340027,
1.2869778871536255,
0.3899981677532196,
-0.34099647402763367,
0.6054991483688354,
-0.28529778122901917,
-0.11339903622865677,
-0.9706991910934448,
0.16312070190906525,
-0.9299864768981934,
-0.03611307218670845,
-0.4838257431983948,
-0.21899786591529846,
0.817215621471405,
-0.01062008086591959,
-0.44878673553466797,
0.16152013838291168,
-0.5484848618507385,
0.3912445902824402,
0.6898261308670044,
0.29092472791671753,
0.22641335427761078,
-0.03136282041668892,
-0.1621275395154953,
0.5097312927246094,
-0.5221179127693176,
-0.37751418352127075,
1.2690387964248657,
-0.027864065021276474,
0.7751700282096863,
0.34830814599990845,
0.6815252304077148,
0.39968642592430115,
0.14419089257717133,
-0.5469228625297546,
0.48650267720222473,
-0.1915297955274582,
-0.7993729710578918,
-0.4574727714061737,
-0.6084710955619812,
-1.0708374977111816,
0.559822678565979,
-0.10985540598630905,
-0.5417734980583191,
-0.07241874188184738,
0.1412113457918167,
-0.15358079969882965,
0.39253905415534973,
-0.6414927244186401,
0.35662615299224854,
-0.15800659358501434,
-0.24956916272640228,
-0.30233585834503174,
-0.4026176631450653,
0.17197242379188538,
-0.17545105516910553,
0.14344419538974762,
0.22544515132904053,
-0.04226855933666229,
0.19150853157043457,
-0.48327958583831787,
0.2388298660516739,
-0.1325967162847519,
-0.0941133052110672,
0.5072275400161743,
-0.01641932688653469,
0.9834072589874268,
0.12211792916059494,
-0.45249685645103455,
-0.40430134534835815,
-0.2927079498767853,
-0.280758798122406,
-0.5762829780578613,
0.8280295729637146,
-1.0689774751663208,
-0.9348207116127014,
-0.3813862204551697,
-0.5359691977500916,
-0.19873091578483582,
0.3682042956352234,
0.4262147545814514,
0.4673198461532593,
-0.1924227476119995,
0.12997817993164062,
0.9677124619483948,
-0.08024976402521133,
0.20063191652297974,
0.818805456161499,
0.16269700229167938,
-0.512701690196991,
1.2510920763015747,
-0.02853740006685257,
0.27971509099006653,
0.46855682134628296,
0.02061086893081665,
-0.3777916431427002,
-0.5398276448249817,
-0.6728100180625916,
-0.011887697502970695,
-0.6876645088195801,
-0.5983290672302246,
-0.5253608822822571,
-0.4057314693927765,
-0.5221251845359802,
-0.05520179867744446,
-0.3032236099243164,
-0.2874132990837097,
-0.37586984038352966,
-0.07618089765310287,
0.42923688888549805,
0.5400495529174805,
-0.09301172941923141,
0.2656920552253723,
-0.6352892518043518,
0.8684830665588379,
0.4423685073852539,
0.20893077552318573,
-0.2057977020740509,
-0.6033670902252197,
-0.3500612676143646,
0.046888887882232666,
-0.5667194128036499,
-1.030735731124878,
0.2498113363981247,
0.39358216524124146,
0.5762647390365601,
0.39136508107185364,
0.20792770385742188,
0.5889214277267456,
-0.4871281087398529,
0.21888388693332672,
-0.4048174321651459,
-0.5745002031326294,
0.46057140827178955,
-0.3927534520626068,
0.3914801776409149,
0.6159107089042664,
-0.06747951358556747,
-0.03939918801188469,
-1.0719729661941528,
-0.3934164047241211,
-0.8541195392608643,
0.8052576780319214,
0.23454581201076508,
-0.0830514058470726,
-0.19626730680465698,
0.37739819288253784,
-0.10824747383594513,
0.268907755613327,
-0.3792354464530945,
-0.4499935507774353,
-0.3772745728492737,
-0.08479686081409454,
-0.1529412716627121,
0.015266075730323792,
-0.30460965633392334,
0.23711581528186798,
1.1389905214309692,
-0.2819434702396393,
0.21137964725494385,
0.21071721613407135,
-0.16377577185630798,
-0.45824939012527466,
0.31083014607429504,
0.33484965562820435,
0.4080069363117218,
-0.19407954812049866,
0.3466140031814575,
0.032596949487924576,
-0.5131409764289856,
0.22688604891300201,
0.6671038866043091,
-0.35488224029541016,
-0.09848374128341675,
0.12191221863031387,
0.7253839373588562,
-0.3708071708679199,
-0.5891045928001404,
0.09192308038473129,
-0.21462492644786835,
0.0897589847445488,
-0.4265034794807434,
0.3053742051124573,
-0.24546672403812408,
0.37693148851394653,
0.6587592363357544,
0.3001798093318939,
0.2792973816394806,
-0.49108561873435974,
0.13872745633125305,
0.9765647053718567,
-0.08721312880516052,
0.1054159551858902,
0.7133561372756958,
0.10161559283733368,
-0.6337664127349854,
0.34333881735801697,
-0.38837170600891113,
-0.6238709688186646,
0.7140209674835205,
0.49389347434043884,
0.9146477580070496,
-0.30976060032844543,
0.12693406641483307,
0.07030027359724045,
0.618825376033783,
0.1391972154378891,
0.20002833008766174,
-0.08058870583772659,
-0.592229962348938,
-0.1927642673254013,
-0.8428946137428284,
-0.30037039518356323,
0.17992226779460907,
-0.5045046210289001,
0.07373736053705215,
-0.24602510035037994,
-0.18821211159229279,
0.03183009475469589,
0.23734351992607117,
-0.5007194876670837,
0.18172891438007355,
-0.28720298409461975,
0.7062059640884399,
-0.258964866399765,
0.7761736512184143,
0.9062460064888,
-0.34506091475486755,
-0.6709921956062317,
-0.08067219704389572,
0.0852930024266243,
-1.0885530710220337,
0.01843065768480301,
-0.06475479155778885,
-0.4301643371582031,
0.2751598060131073,
-0.30328673124313354,
-0.970824658870697,
0.8735404014587402,
0.5552462935447693,
0.018510781228542328,
0.13725419342517853,
-0.04056992009282112,
0.686162531375885,
0.014406073838472366,
0.3018691837787628,
0.28428927063941956,
0.5138185024261475,
0.216371551156044,
-0.6824223399162292,
-0.050332825630903244,
-0.48025569319725037,
-0.2192123979330063,
0.5065307021141052,
-1.0068973302841187,
0.7968310713768005,
-0.021686794236302376,
-0.1653820127248764,
0.17352862656116486,
0.31071561574935913,
0.4077149033546448,
0.17733612656593323,
0.6191150546073914,
0.7691841721534729,
0.6734858155250549,
0.0019180168164893985,
1.0776492357254028,
-0.4842480719089508,
-0.09209123253822327,
0.9746414422988892,
0.06461358815431595,
0.5615434050559998,
0.3456915318965912,
0.07039511203765869,
0.07390520721673965,
0.3361690044403076,
0.12487547844648361,
0.45787402987480164,
-0.0019087385153397918,
-0.4961288869380951,
-0.2609962821006775,
-0.14387089014053345,
-0.5546004772186279,
0.44998037815093994,
0.4333730936050415,
-0.21828334033489227,
-0.13325528800487518,
-0.01418848242610693,
-0.14787937700748444,
0.18706537783145905,
-0.36272042989730835,
1.228570580482483,
-0.12288830429315567,
-1.0194942951202393,
0.6384464502334595,
0.17706610262393951,
0.21342867612838745,
-0.8644821047782898,
0.036177121102809906,
-0.1253344863653183,
0.34968242049217224,
0.2598167657852173,
-0.22052736580371857,
0.28857406973838806,
-0.0021607044618576765,
-0.12115015089511871,
-0.03419092670083046,
1.0952425003051758,
-0.3297949433326721,
-0.5265789031982422,
0.13513410091400146,
0.36676040291786194,
-0.07841722667217255,
-0.39208269119262695,
-0.580213725566864,
-0.10213415324687958,
-0.21435993909835815,
-0.40923115611076355,
0.5208008885383606,
0.7396882772445679,
0.2796398401260376,
0.7358167171478271,
0.5894603133201599,
0.26669764518737793,
0.062882199883461,
0.02916388213634491,
1.1445649862289429,
-0.47719258069992065,
-0.43538326025009155,
-0.6621606945991516,
0.16889908909797668,
-0.05502667278051376,
-0.09486467391252518,
0.9093566536903381,
0.49307242035865784,
0.5921105742454529,
0.2658374309539795,
0.8700348138809204,
-0.025540662929415703,
0.7208777070045471,
-0.416236013174057,
0.8349822759628296,
-0.7852616310119629,
0.4141441583633423,
-0.14460311830043793,
-0.7300264239311218,
0.20900829136371613,
0.21353891491889954,
0.47276192903518677,
0.05636594817042351,
0.4081648886203766,
0.9319669604301453,
0.24893751740455627,
-0.3368707597255707,
0.3168002963066101,
0.23865561187267303,
0.40891337394714355,
0.36853182315826416,
0.7566689848899841,
-0.3693851828575134,
1.0819785594940186,
-0.06855658441781998,
-0.1582290679216385,
-0.14641782641410828,
-0.36691954731941223,
-0.8974872827529907,
-0.4348389506340027,
0.24592293798923492,
-0.37910836935043335,
0.42392152547836304,
0.5583902597427368,
0.3781984746456146,
-0.540044367313385,
0.1324770301580429,
0.11688219010829926,
0.4932210445404053,
-0.27814868092536926,
-0.2124200165271759,
0.2745836079120636,
-0.7639670372009277,
-0.8235896229743958,
0.7222235798835754,
0.15799471735954285,
-0.05597596615552902,
-0.3980034291744232,
-0.06956864148378372,
-0.42634913325309753,
0.4171437621116638,
0.3314116597175598,
0.17717501521110535,
-0.5651600956916809,
-0.3394680917263031,
-0.019522294402122498,
-0.08610527962446213,
-0.12369866669178009,
0.7090481519699097,
-0.6844674944877625,
0.7827333807945251,
0.24689580500125885,
0.8623232245445251,
0.29397913813591003,
0.3949865698814392,
0.5182579159736633,
-0.980998694896698,
0.10780367255210876,
0.2817785441875458,
0.3212113678455353,
0.19420254230499268,
-0.6428198218345642,
0.32070672512054443,
-0.04456176236271858,
-0.8050148487091064,
-0.830502450466156,
0.31501340866088867,
-0.4952407777309418,
-0.4816935956478119,
0.9979988932609558,
-0.0027352727483958006,
-0.17772729694843292,
-0.3087857663631439,
-0.4739174544811249,
0.5817279815673828,
-0.6341865062713623,
1.2107433080673218,
0.524760901927948,
-0.0038332282565534115,
0.03240574896335602,
-0.1740611046552658,
0.5053051114082336,
0.31710389256477356,
-0.6805201768875122,
-0.34606602787971497,
0.6317228078842163,
-0.13905742764472961,
0.2880488336086273,
0.5629727840423584,
0.11804170161485672,
0.35075560212135315,
0.2551780045032501,
-0.44960176944732666,
-0.47008806467056274,
-0.43252813816070557,
-0.10913903266191483,
0.43348196148872375,
0.3897116482257843,
-0.1331690549850464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18061v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18061v1
|
Context is Important in Depressive Language: A Study of the Interaction Between the Sentiments and Linguistic Markers in Reddit Discussions
| 2024-05-28T11:19:39 | 2024-05-28T11:19:39 |
Neha Sharma, Kairit Sirts
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Research exploring linguistic markers in individuals with depression has
demonstrated that language usage can serve as an indicator of mental health.
This study investigates the impact of discussion topic as context on linguistic
markers and emotional expression in depression, using a Reddit dataset to
explore interaction effects. Contrary to common findings, our sentiment
analysis revealed a broader range of emotional intensity in depressed
individuals, with both higher negative and positive sentiments than controls.
This pattern was driven by posts containing no emotion words, revealing the
limitations of the lexicon based approaches in capturing the full emotional
context. We observed several interesting results demonstrating the importance
of contextual analyses. For instance, the use of 1st person singular pronouns
and words related to anger and sadness correlated with increased positive
sentiments, whereas a higher rate of present-focused words was associated with
more negative sentiments. Our findings highlight the importance of discussion
contexts while interpreting the language used in depression, revealing that the
emotional intensity and meaning of linguistic markers can vary based on the
topic of discussion.
|
[
-0.8326480984687805,
-1.0386416912078857,
0.7383228540420532,
0.6138227581977844,
-0.4889476001262665,
-0.4463243782520294,
-0.3127884566783905,
-0.41668444871902466,
0.694661557674408,
0.12363746017217636,
-0.46810540556907654,
-0.4796404540538788,
-1.022228479385376,
0.5928156971931458,
-0.29449042677879333,
0.9337605834007263,
-0.044963642954826355,
-0.049666378647089005,
0.020729942247271538,
-0.12841252982616425,
-0.7881456613540649,
-0.8505675196647644,
-0.8073029518127441,
-0.046907939016819,
0.6252185106277466,
0.20338283479213715,
0.586351215839386,
-0.17569805681705475,
0.45814627408981323,
0.3910090923309326,
-0.3491222560405731,
-0.5970233678817749,
-0.6412537097930908,
0.5564364194869995,
-0.4074438512325287,
-0.3143787086009979,
-0.3865223228931427,
-0.002478488953784108,
-0.13469764590263367,
0.6589192748069763,
0.1344357430934906,
-0.11935818195343018,
0.1767209768295288,
0.6107115745544434,
-0.7626987099647522,
0.02283930405974388,
-0.12708957493305206,
0.14548707008361816,
-0.1138167753815651,
-0.4097522497177124,
0.15263794362545013,
-0.24265235662460327,
0.281560480594635,
-0.016875308007001877,
-0.057950668036937714,
-0.7624594569206238,
0.8217899799346924,
0.3975524306297302,
-0.7785612344741821,
-0.46931612491607666,
-0.4960898756980896,
0.6466777920722961,
-0.7192363739013672,
-0.10277874022722244,
0.39172402024269104,
-0.13690730929374695,
-0.03644610196352005,
-0.24615295231342316,
-0.5758065581321716,
0.550313413143158,
-0.4610985815525055,
0.19286467134952545,
-0.36341145634651184,
0.09471810609102249,
0.18603867292404175,
0.28706464171409607,
-0.08747679740190506,
-0.291232705116272,
-0.19962875545024872,
0.23509159684181213,
0.46839603781700134,
0.22997568547725677,
0.6088980436325073,
-0.6848167777061462,
0.10345067083835602,
0.21250073611736298,
-0.29941225051879883,
0.12679098546504974,
-0.18431806564331055,
0.48284223675727844,
-0.276302307844162,
0.532929003238678,
-0.2872314453125,
0.8818385601043701,
-0.05086146667599678,
-0.2246866673231125,
0.04884174466133118,
-0.4048755466938019,
-0.21627728641033173,
0.08571209758520126,
0.5862968564033508,
0.9444888234138489,
0.2002660036087036,
0.27669769525527954,
0.12021796405315399,
0.42381224036216736,
0.34474560618400574,
-0.7213575839996338,
-0.17458848655223846,
0.390605092048645,
-0.40590259432792664,
0.229111447930336,
0.04554964229464531,
-1.1783868074417114,
-0.5295785069465637,
-0.2646486163139343,
-0.10859934985637665,
0.0032536471262574196,
-0.3893457055091858,
0.04647742211818695,
-0.3705121874809265,
-0.05273633077740669,
0.5089794397354126,
-0.7128742337226868,
0.12752024829387665,
0.6385084390640259,
0.8827762007713318,
0.20205555856227875,
0.06619646400213242,
-0.19455797970294952,
-0.2131161242723465,
-0.21031254529953003,
0.809274435043335,
-0.7162207961082458,
-0.508803129196167,
0.2011314481496811,
0.2514704465866089,
-0.09047109633684158,
-0.17798712849617004,
0.881915271282196,
-0.048259440809488297,
0.476823627948761,
-0.3728333115577698,
-0.4365377426147461,
-0.23825280368328094,
0.007910620421171188,
-0.5525009036064148,
0.6741253137588501,
0.32529646158218384,
-1.0360161066055298,
0.2508930265903473,
-0.3476536273956299,
-0.7878826260566711,
0.11178390681743622,
-0.32386887073516846,
0.12447214126586914,
0.5793586373329163,
-0.23517267405986786,
0.683353066444397,
-0.04115262255072594,
0.15373505651950836,
-0.31871816515922546,
-0.33589038252830505,
0.4759555459022522,
0.0829806849360466,
0.3044354319572449,
0.008640277199447155,
-0.8852899670600891,
-0.3741006851196289,
-0.44980964064598083,
-0.006863455753773451,
-0.25111502408981323,
-0.42442500591278076,
-0.9743363857269287,
0.14977508783340454,
0.22949296236038208,
0.5749987363815308,
0.06250864267349243,
-0.33634939789772034,
-0.21158340573310852,
-0.355817586183548,
0.4947366714477539,
0.44645097851753235,
0.5380727648735046,
0.08413691073656082,
0.32470571994781494,
0.6684404611587524,
-0.005091371480375528,
-0.10218453407287598,
0.12719807028770447,
-0.7330609560012817,
-0.3783602714538574,
-0.4178793728351593,
-0.139087975025177,
0.3794475495815277,
0.09941496700048447,
0.5299414396286011,
0.1675339937210083,
-0.09832578897476196,
-0.37596914172172546,
-0.1457032412290573,
0.3926510810852051,
0.26433953642845154,
0.32869458198547363,
-0.10680491477251053,
-0.9196947813034058,
-0.9455143809318542,
-0.12676945328712463,
0.12209799885749817,
0.06670289486646652,
0.5908151268959045,
0.27016085386276245,
-0.619127094745636,
1.0069857835769653,
-0.6691884398460388,
-0.19864198565483093,
-0.3036922514438629,
0.342072457075119,
0.11278785020112991,
0.13752570748329163,
0.5281533002853394,
-0.7854728698730469,
-0.8031601905822754,
0.07979065179824829,
-0.6008076667785645,
-0.34583887457847595,
-0.10562349855899811,
-0.38800063729286194,
0.24295853078365326,
0.3609354496002197,
-0.5664463043212891,
0.6848909258842468,
0.8091994524002075,
-0.7301632165908813,
-0.0712868720293045,
0.20287279784679413,
0.4609507620334625,
-1.049621343612671,
0.0676957294344902,
0.3071135878562927,
0.09237159788608551,
-0.7021371722221375,
-0.45654910802841187,
-0.22344113886356354,
-0.24394115805625916,
-0.31214526295661926,
0.33110159635543823,
-0.017961742356419563,
0.25391799211502075,
-0.5508771538734436,
0.59368896484375,
0.08568280935287476,
0.04756944254040718,
0.15031744539737701,
0.7946168184280396,
0.7358061075210571,
-0.39784330129623413,
-0.05497415363788605,
0.33600378036499023,
-0.24075832962989807,
0.74895840883255,
-0.3485235869884491,
-0.36173683404922485,
-0.2473955601453781,
0.016045494005084038,
-1.0276747941970825,
-0.20795346796512604,
0.40347862243652344,
-0.15093080699443817,
0.024857930839061737,
0.30364716053009033,
0.007982823997735977,
-0.05086972191929817,
-0.09575580060482025,
0.20816326141357422,
0.062129609286785126,
0.19248685240745544,
0.07718848437070847,
0.7328996658325195,
-0.5377805829048157,
-0.32459092140197754,
-0.7168202996253967,
0.38379237055778503,
-0.7463082671165466,
-0.2610456645488739,
0.5222210884094238,
-0.016645634546875954,
-0.8971062302589417,
-0.10575026273727417,
-0.1446874588727951,
-0.2741371989250183,
0.5112490653991699,
0.42527636885643005,
-0.37082305550575256,
0.008596038445830345,
0.43378397822380066,
0.019054658710956573,
-0.06921621412038803,
0.19211585819721222,
0.7726391553878784,
0.6766654253005981,
-0.1958267092704773,
0.5308808088302612,
-0.6908069849014282,
0.8700063824653625,
0.4556323289871216,
0.44752392172813416,
1.0094999074935913,
-0.12982811033725739,
-0.29602551460266113,
0.03894892707467079,
-0.09713926166296005,
-0.17911620438098907,
-0.35367345809936523,
0.3674335181713104,
-0.3869873881340027,
-0.9866008758544922,
0.31101077795028687,
-0.038885705173015594,
-0.5764380097389221,
0.44040241837501526,
0.5603449940681458,
-0.3588525354862213,
0.9464247822761536,
0.5847033262252808,
-0.1317884474992752,
0.5564513802528381,
0.3882792592048645,
0.664973258972168,
-0.8256080150604248,
0.3957878649234772,
-0.6303099393844604,
-0.48053881525993347,
-0.6439660787582397,
-0.13932575285434723,
-0.0011583734303712845,
0.3857940435409546,
0.11238013207912445,
0.2956543564796448,
-0.43257877230644226,
0.21584858000278473,
-0.23603954911231995,
0.09038637578487396,
-0.009765442460775375,
-0.23621171712875366,
0.3639567494392395,
-0.6555870771408081,
-0.33821237087249756,
-0.8004750609397888,
0.41398102045059204,
0.10039093345403671,
0.6041364073753357,
0.1788259893655777,
0.46222561597824097,
0.4907911717891693,
0.33206066489219666,
-0.6440151333808899,
0.4923017621040344,
-0.11606510728597641,
-0.46860501170158386,
-0.36172351241111755,
-0.276287704706192,
-0.933991014957428,
0.09575244039297104,
0.07359403371810913,
-0.7971069812774658,
0.43184003233909607,
-0.22107438743114471,
-0.2712836265563965,
-0.3892565965652466,
-0.56304532289505,
1.0274395942687988,
-0.11210724711418152,
0.09397798776626587,
-0.2399793118238449,
-0.7025695443153381,
0.22329871356487274,
-0.11403431743383408,
0.4213319420814514,
-0.26412510871887207,
0.07041825354099274,
0.548805296421051,
-0.2154291421175003,
1.0436375141143799,
0.0261937715113163,
-0.5059553980827332,
0.19388428330421448,
0.022397393360733986,
-0.0678505077958107,
0.3064129054546356,
-0.10312822461128235,
0.2245272994041443,
-0.01254903431981802,
-0.17260371148586273,
-0.5365868210792542,
0.9501700401306152,
-0.9154784679412842,
-0.9061797261238098,
-0.4960789084434509,
-0.13413403928279877,
-0.06684949994087219,
-0.032112497836351395,
0.1015908420085907,
0.3036041557788849,
-0.16423074901103973,
0.3032841384410858,
0.21439780294895172,
-0.2968701720237732,
0.17801164090633392,
0.1337863802909851,
0.024132734164595604,
-0.45194828510284424,
0.3742809593677521,
-0.14317215979099274,
0.21134673058986664,
0.28798606991767883,
0.280496209859848,
0.23510952293872833,
0.2546069324016571,
0.335400253534317,
0.6104793548583984,
-1.0972557067871094,
-0.2695556879043579,
-0.7465911507606506,
0.24888285994529724,
-0.44287756085395813,
-0.4536806344985962,
-0.324726402759552,
-0.5644692182540894,
-0.550445020198822,
-0.20362496376037598,
0.3009341061115265,
0.4558124840259552,
-0.1450686901807785,
0.2590555250644684,
-0.5000004768371582,
-0.0036454442888498306,
0.1691574901342392,
0.2277245968580246,
-0.15579673647880554,
-0.003161208238452673,
-0.36769452691078186,
-0.13037966191768646,
-0.08608399331569672,
-1.324747085571289,
0.37604448199272156,
0.2566007375717163,
0.2669365108013153,
0.7337177395820618,
0.17164801061153412,
0.8920392394065857,
-0.1929478645324707,
0.9811747074127197,
0.09095743298530579,
-1.246412992477417,
0.9065560698509216,
-0.04027780145406723,
0.4472142159938812,
0.7321780323982239,
0.6289090514183044,
-1.3561915159225464,
-0.7641182541847229,
-0.26762452721595764,
-0.9525578618049622,
0.6797956824302673,
0.17558656632900238,
0.2740172743797302,
-0.7439226508140564,
0.6297841668128967,
0.10485271364450455,
0.17950069904327393,
-0.8136648535728455,
-0.5583685040473938,
-0.2971002161502838,
0.18756695091724396,
-0.36087512969970703,
-0.7451225519180298,
-0.5848416090011597,
-0.3455216884613037,
0.3851124942302704,
0.04959631338715553,
0.5415705442428589,
0.4056282639503479,
0.1481427699327469,
-0.30248430371284485,
0.33834147453308105,
0.7362505197525024,
0.7147268056869507,
-0.14834237098693848,
0.3966262638568878,
-0.05197960510849953,
-0.008810454048216343,
-0.14259597659111023,
-0.15361882746219635,
0.08645693957805634,
0.27096837759017944,
0.33435988426208496,
0.7947385907173157,
0.5616755485534668,
-0.6607740521430969,
0.5184662938117981,
-0.27151238918304443,
-0.024060478433966637,
-0.0657971054315567,
-0.0400683656334877,
0.32046034932136536,
0.388466477394104,
-0.017032790929079056,
-0.10975668579339981,
0.14293985068798065,
-0.8541742563247681,
0.13095629215240479,
0.4059031009674072,
-0.705955982208252,
-0.5890285968780518,
0.10664298385381699,
0.4164316654205322,
-0.30243879556655884,
0.4379027485847473,
0.1973702609539032,
-0.8439866304397583,
0.47126272320747375,
0.5084604024887085,
0.8928210139274597,
-0.27381256222724915,
0.4689750373363495,
0.5402405858039856,
-0.16556952893733978,
0.4098536968231201,
0.4417690634727478,
-0.2418757677078247,
-0.6060029864311218,
-0.015547267161309719,
-0.7165380120277405,
-0.1683620810508728,
-0.09455890208482742,
-0.5434057116508484,
0.29640913009643555,
-0.23133808374404907,
-0.6313402056694031,
-0.3766743242740631,
-0.14544740319252014,
-0.24579307436943054,
0.3943459093570709,
0.28444549441337585,
0.4163861572742462,
-0.8974167704582214,
0.474046528339386,
0.8852039575576782,
-0.20323042571544647,
-0.12197310477495193,
0.2914773225784302,
0.005661983974277973,
0.1353134959936142,
0.962378740310669,
0.5392870903015137,
-0.04582647606730461,
-0.2502923011779785,
-0.17596516013145447,
-1.0084943771362305,
0.6326913237571716,
-0.05777110531926155,
0.001847346662543714,
0.4446655809879303,
0.23183248937129974,
1.1029727458953857,
-0.5259381532669067,
0.2123280018568039,
0.42221271991729736,
0.6326088309288025,
-0.20039767026901245,
-0.5757037401199341,
0.2964728772640228,
-0.347099244594574,
0.005197705235332251,
0.4679759442806244,
-0.5000131726264954,
1.0700843334197998,
0.38877713680267334,
-0.8908141255378723,
-0.2649836242198944,
0.245574489235878,
-0.14152738451957703,
-0.05026921257376671,
0.4173624515533447,
0.4104156792163849,
0.41609275341033936,
-0.006833195220679045,
1.0068554878234863,
-0.8109919428825378,
0.5512446761131287,
0.8071598410606384,
-0.43587929010391235,
0.8326625823974609,
0.7216475605964661,
-0.02469080686569214,
0.8022544384002686,
0.5655326843261719,
0.4621444642543793,
0.6863306760787964,
0.16933253407478333,
-0.6114366054534912,
-0.1480126827955246,
-0.15158405900001526,
-0.5241691470146179,
0.16421379148960114,
0.578162670135498,
-0.450714111328125,
-0.33547350764274597,
0.1987161785364151,
0.38328930735588074,
0.22876247763633728,
0.13940559327602386,
0.6903678774833679,
0.30517953634262085,
-0.5379286408424377,
0.4501174986362457,
0.0537479929625988,
0.42001503705978394,
-0.3112700879573822,
0.059406135231256485,
-0.5006635785102844,
0.19456832110881805,
-0.36788490414619446,
-0.8213379383087158,
0.7940986156463623,
0.18978795409202576,
-0.14227674901485443,
-0.39347490668296814,
0.6819087266921997,
-0.2283637970685959,
-0.010828997008502483,
0.6425502896308899,
0.5775091648101807,
0.11745037883520126,
-0.2600236237049103,
-0.3903072476387024,
0.26364463567733765,
-0.2142142802476883,
-0.608745813369751,
0.5621161460876465,
0.993992030620575,
0.3576243221759796,
0.16696737706661224,
-0.039934054017066956,
-0.06082333251833916,
-0.2818409204483032,
0.008934929035604,
0.9108787775039673,
-1.0291595458984375,
-0.360163152217865,
-0.88345867395401,
0.5184802412986755,
-0.020895903930068016,
-0.6876041293144226,
0.9194927215576172,
0.1306723952293396,
0.5692020058631897,
-0.07634865492582321,
0.6044970154762268,
-0.5757876038551331,
0.4076537489891052,
0.018715616315603256,
0.6063008904457092,
-0.7401772737503052,
-0.06955437362194061,
-0.7076938152313232,
-0.8130440711975098,
-0.5538473725318909,
0.9975551962852478,
-0.5520161986351013,
-0.14194956421852112,
0.9190101027488708,
0.3424931764602661,
0.3133856952190399,
0.28282850980758667,
0.34033292531967163,
0.43760842084884644,
0.13036444783210754,
0.32279640436172485,
0.9382770657539368,
-0.15695956349372864,
0.015736807137727737,
-0.6408271193504333,
-0.3773380517959595,
-0.1217198520898819,
-0.7448816895484924,
-0.8605325818061829,
-0.6796948909759521,
-0.557165801525116,
-0.15909478068351746,
-0.12432295083999634,
0.6800928115844727,
-0.11796688288450241,
-0.5743225812911987,
-0.38815736770629883,
-0.21336185932159424,
0.17239387333393097,
-0.21236354112625122,
-0.4073063135147095,
0.31528639793395996,
-0.45013269782066345,
-0.8757820129394531,
0.06501345336437225,
0.6243891716003418,
-0.2902819514274597,
-0.10845809429883957,
0.10135398805141449,
-0.602848470211029,
-0.0626586377620697,
1.0045154094696045,
0.02332436293363571,
-0.6798487305641174,
-0.4814929962158203,
-0.3930521011352539,
-0.3558792173862457,
0.319328248500824,
0.8871582746505737,
-0.6368515491485596,
0.41904446482658386,
0.5543825030326843,
0.1478360891342163,
-0.21158216893672943,
0.3735358417034149,
0.6499168872833252,
-0.3920463025569916,
0.06236004829406738,
0.15001791715621948,
0.33233338594436646,
0.36231911182403564,
-0.5798919796943665,
0.34275582432746887,
0.34475177526474,
-0.6248528957366943,
-0.6824648976325989,
0.3814367949962616,
-0.7491848468780518,
-0.658471941947937,
1.0592617988586426,
-0.16871841251850128,
-0.0027447217144072056,
-0.18803633749485016,
-0.5407915711402893,
0.17291446030139923,
-0.6382032036781311,
1.2322611808776855,
1.0833643674850464,
-0.37503522634506226,
-0.3753078579902649,
-0.4816255569458008,
0.6158075332641602,
0.5024245381355286,
-0.8856414556503296,
0.24037940800189972,
0.6457214951515198,
-0.3956761062145233,
0.11969023197889328,
0.48852792382240295,
0.07458337396383286,
-0.1246974840760231,
-0.32973262667655945,
0.05872888118028641,
1.081740379333496,
0.06934633105993271,
-0.44325512647628784,
0.4443344473838806,
-0.5424053072929382,
0.43701785802841187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18060v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18060v1
|
PRFashion24: A Dataset for Sentiment Analysis of Fashion Products Reviews in Persian
| 2024-05-28T11:19:13 | 2024-05-28T11:19:13 |
Mehrimah Amirpour, Reza Azmi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The PRFashion24 dataset is a comprehensive Persian dataset collected from
various online fashion stores, spanning from April 2020 to March 2024. With
767,272 reviews, it is the first dataset in its kind that encompasses diverse
categories within the fashion industry in the Persian language. The goal of
this study is to harness deep learning techniques, specifically Long Short-Term
Memory (LSTM) networks and a combination of Bidirectional LSTM and
Convolutional Neural Network (BiLSTM-CNN), to analyze and reveal sentiments
towards online fashion shopping. The LSTM model yielded an accuracy of 81.23%,
while the BiLSTM-CNN model reached 82.89%. This research aims not only to
introduce a diverse dataset in the field of fashion but also to enhance the
public's understanding of opinions on online fashion shopping, which
predominantly reflect a positive sentiment. Upon publication, both the
optimized models and the PRFashion24 dataset will be available on GitHub.
|
[
-0.6790667772293091,
-0.6200791001319885,
0.053904518485069275,
0.48238125443458557,
-0.7958760857582092,
0.27616652846336365,
-0.4941152036190033,
-0.5452865362167358,
0.14300920069217682,
0.06353462487459183,
-1.0557496547698975,
-0.7053454518318176,
0.009832805953919888,
0.1450258195400238,
-0.2391977608203888,
1.1610792875289917,
-0.008738173171877861,
0.5158556699752808,
0.015090543776750565,
-0.2780020833015442,
-0.1489466279745102,
-0.5089783072471619,
-0.5033516883850098,
0.12317255884408951,
0.5601210594177246,
0.35655996203422546,
0.7703961730003357,
-0.23242799937725067,
0.6205583810806274,
0.24078011512756348,
0.09485489130020142,
0.46190372109413147,
-0.4814285933971405,
0.0468951091170311,
-0.21925005316734314,
-0.24747179448604584,
-0.43819659948349,
-0.09268604964017868,
0.37169522047042847,
0.10038898885250092,
-0.2394692599773407,
0.28068777918815613,
0.03989943116903305,
1.0856672525405884,
-0.38200804591178894,
-0.12781012058258057,
0.10709229856729507,
0.2518533766269684,
-0.2618672549724579,
0.5548529624938965,
-0.22464844584465027,
-0.4178963005542755,
0.02212595008313656,
-0.4705255627632141,
0.47159695625305176,
-0.0011002033716067672,
0.9919535517692566,
-0.1512664258480072,
-0.376418799161911,
-0.20665033161640167,
-1.1750943660736084,
1.0815967321395874,
-0.8929762840270996,
0.7732946276664734,
0.1752050817012787,
0.23372308909893036,
0.06865928322076797,
-0.5889483690261841,
-0.7434041500091553,
-0.04215770587325096,
-0.1172265037894249,
0.5625464916229248,
-0.05225961282849312,
-0.4392894506454468,
-0.13962294161319733,
0.6923978924751282,
-0.5782687067985535,
-0.2739420235157013,
-0.4434086084365845,
0.27116626501083374,
1.0703816413879395,
0.13640257716178894,
-0.010820845142006874,
-0.30023130774497986,
-0.7275611758232117,
0.12097861617803574,
-0.36414384841918945,
-0.031864892691373825,
0.42842960357666016,
0.017277054488658905,
-0.19455833733081818,
0.29001906514167786,
-0.3975972533226013,
0.5608646869659424,
0.04991718754172325,
0.18057624995708466,
0.5790603756904602,
-0.7502474784851074,
-0.40717536211013794,
-0.21684931218624115,
1.0709210634231567,
0.4678526222705841,
0.33507248759269714,
0.27492865920066833,
-0.38132697343826294,
-0.18916286528110504,
0.5798325538635254,
-0.7113146185874939,
-0.17247074842453003,
0.25500601530075073,
-0.8002150654792786,
-0.4872196912765503,
0.41132161021232605,
-1.1864330768585205,
-0.4837133288383484,
-0.44193902611732483,
0.04564623907208443,
-0.07122229784727097,
-0.4155620336532593,
0.29936137795448303,
0.1912897229194641,
0.22569461166858673,
0.5457039475440979,
0.09882808476686478,
0.49246376752853394,
0.6136634349822998,
0.8758371472358704,
-0.4985399842262268,
0.06387045979499817,
0.35421669483184814,
-0.3700489401817322,
-0.5616421103477478,
0.6937839388847351,
-0.11151806265115738,
-0.46793779730796814,
-0.18989288806915283,
0.22749844193458557,
0.20686721801757812,
-0.3415958881378174,
0.9768384099006653,
-0.6076214909553528,
0.1116991713643074,
-0.08221323788166046,
-0.47997817397117615,
-0.34513863921165466,
0.28778380155563354,
-0.8042955994606018,
0.729718804359436,
-0.1557498574256897,
-0.7595700621604919,
-0.0786329060792923,
-0.3461560904979706,
-0.5904889702796936,
0.0028326185420155525,
0.1466350257396698,
-0.9919259548187256,
0.41968148946762085,
0.18006475269794464,
0.6940372586250305,
-0.3437398672103882,
-0.037132956087589264,
-0.3271389901638031,
-0.4754605293273926,
0.748500406742096,
-0.18297570943832397,
0.5290140509605408,
0.5670314431190491,
-0.3177545666694641,
-0.032612841576337814,
-0.5876896977424622,
-0.4429088532924652,
0.38620874285697937,
-0.1287216693162918,
-0.1155887022614479,
0.004470248706638813,
0.20925705134868622,
0.28829124569892883,
0.4147679805755615,
-0.7251676917076111,
-0.04915826395153999,
-0.47236350178718567,
0.22960489988327026,
1.081803321838379,
0.2712398171424866,
0.28694280982017517,
-0.5228387117385864,
0.6426814198493958,
0.27850887179374695,
0.589942991733551,
0.29835090041160583,
-0.43044808506965637,
-0.9560266733169556,
0.03516290709376335,
-0.10885586589574814,
0.45316454768180847,
-0.39670848846435547,
0.1828254759311676,
-0.04789850860834122,
-0.8636976480484009,
-0.1024402305483818,
-0.05865761265158653,
0.2063181847333908,
0.3002323806285858,
0.24010150134563446,
-0.32511961460113525,
-0.4276057183742523,
-1.0168293714523315,
-0.42692044377326965,
0.168361097574234,
0.3141253590583801,
0.6226638555526733,
0.26817944645881653,
-0.4156588017940521,
0.49530351161956787,
-0.5301117897033691,
-0.532102108001709,
-0.3719812333583832,
0.11675801873207092,
0.8447485566139221,
0.3728354573249817,
0.3486936390399933,
-1.1449215412139893,
-0.4998868703842163,
0.06061431020498276,
-0.22983461618423462,
0.3975337743759155,
-0.21982735395431519,
-0.28570306301116943,
0.23456671833992004,
-0.11523011326789856,
-0.7342603206634521,
0.5390700697898865,
0.3654508888721466,
-0.30161353945732117,
0.8162246346473694,
0.21904511749744415,
0.37556031346321106,
-1.4204294681549072,
-0.2717670500278473,
0.6073627471923828,
0.018349455669522285,
-0.6174550652503967,
-0.1654638648033142,
-0.10102084279060364,
-0.28146523237228394,
-0.7804573178291321,
0.25984978675842285,
-0.30656325817108154,
0.010239898227155209,
0.051304373890161514,
-0.36546391248703003,
0.4739185869693756,
0.6958062648773193,
0.24161286652088165,
0.8153029084205627,
0.12292801588773727,
-0.44730690121650696,
0.8058069944381714,
0.5149685144424438,
-0.792617917060852,
0.4329538643360138,
-0.430937260389328,
0.23156046867370605,
-0.15142042934894562,
0.24212543666362762,
-0.9831172823905945,
-0.20367786288261414,
0.41566744446754456,
-0.5023568868637085,
0.27297377586364746,
-0.016313590109348297,
-0.43203750252723694,
-0.5419518947601318,
-0.5490460395812988,
0.3923359215259552,
0.45218175649642944,
-0.34057506918907166,
0.5524485111236572,
0.17159679532051086,
-0.0305588748306036,
-0.34953635931015015,
-0.6205400824546814,
-0.1791076511144638,
-0.2744472920894623,
-0.4627249538898468,
0.20909787714481354,
-0.4493001699447632,
-0.41270723938941956,
-0.3826749324798584,
-0.17321981489658356,
0.1374494880437851,
0.10810897499322891,
0.27010786533355713,
0.606753945350647,
-0.2387857884168625,
0.2870238423347473,
-0.44414636492729187,
0.08345559239387512,
0.16734997928142548,
-0.16548727452754974,
0.6086670160293579,
-0.4855548143386841,
-0.1258416771888733,
-0.5888492465019226,
0.18171489238739014,
0.28512075543403625,
-0.3268093764781952,
0.6348618865013123,
0.5911955237388611,
-0.3354164659976959,
-0.5289903879165649,
-0.3596893846988678,
0.0619262233376503,
-0.4648915231227875,
0.4761674106121063,
-0.1309707909822464,
-0.3641999661922455,
0.0959838256239891,
-0.044565826654434204,
-0.06620102375745773,
0.5099464058876038,
0.8194288611412048,
-0.42797720432281494,
1.1972930431365967,
0.25498589873313904,
-0.19128593802452087,
0.47515544295310974,
-0.14469186961650848,
0.5094553828239441,
-0.6182093620300293,
-0.5123025178909302,
-0.3119850158691406,
-0.7486865520477295,
-0.5853741765022278,
-0.4985559582710266,
0.07798641920089722,
0.12793594598770142,
-0.6597434282302856,
0.1976599097251892,
-0.6435990333557129,
0.29464617371559143,
0.36437466740608215,
0.6394349336624146,
-0.014400247484445572,
0.16896988451480865,
0.11120844632387161,
-0.08695026487112045,
-0.21039721369743347,
-0.011867715045809746,
0.9085188508033752,
0.38021817803382874,
0.9646826386451721,
0.21076670289039612,
0.385821670293808,
0.6659982800483704,
0.00898555014282465,
-1.0780725479125977,
0.4470931887626648,
-0.6184409260749817,
-0.4562012851238251,
0.0892794206738472,
-0.25880396366119385,
-0.40168628096580505,
-0.5286931991577148,
-0.12792831659317017,
-0.2005493938922882,
0.7281856536865234,
-0.2485637068748474,
-0.33804184198379517,
0.15501165390014648,
-0.14282123744487762,
0.6303757429122925,
-0.8048557639122009,
-0.7563555836677551,
-0.39074912667274475,
-0.4871475398540497,
0.39427801966667175,
-0.180045023560524,
0.37384989857673645,
-0.5341428518295288,
0.08428846299648285,
1.218639612197876,
-0.24835194647312164,
0.5728269219398499,
0.07362972944974899,
0.07847906649112701,
0.07378503680229187,
0.0948495864868164,
0.4454294741153717,
0.06137103959918022,
-0.17115773260593414,
0.4499471187591553,
-0.2942449450492859,
-0.1806478649377823,
-0.24282893538475037,
0.8618735074996948,
-1.1620252132415771,
-0.4270453453063965,
-0.7219113111495972,
-0.051897384226322174,
-0.6776303052902222,
0.014742586761713028,
0.19163323938846588,
0.4657980501651764,
-0.24488228559494019,
0.30599361658096313,
0.7776528596878052,
-0.24976977705955505,
0.29044976830482483,
0.30017587542533875,
-0.289480984210968,
-0.7002591490745544,
1.0458717346191406,
0.021569114178419113,
-0.16426947712898254,
0.2644025981426239,
0.5859869718551636,
-0.14664015173912048,
-0.3436063528060913,
-0.5184980034828186,
0.22202356159687042,
-0.7477902770042419,
-0.5147714018821716,
-0.1937013566493988,
-0.3398367166519165,
-0.2100672572851181,
0.049331460148096085,
-0.4638550281524658,
-0.358948677778244,
-0.3948650658130646,
-0.2665047347545624,
0.7089449763298035,
1.0353487730026245,
0.08908861875534058,
0.28053179383277893,
-0.8980732560157776,
0.38967204093933105,
0.23719045519828796,
0.3610318601131439,
-0.01459329854696989,
-0.24078962206840515,
-0.6851952075958252,
0.22955074906349182,
-0.08457659184932709,
-0.8238514065742493,
0.7119931578636169,
0.31249651312828064,
0.25441524386405945,
0.8347993493080139,
0.19503207504749298,
0.5783310532569885,
-0.16331791877746582,
0.9656899571418762,
0.3954298794269562,
-0.6799875497817993,
0.4856693148612976,
-0.435600608587265,
0.12416595220565796,
0.301681250333786,
0.839837908744812,
-0.46583545207977295,
-0.040642350912094116,
-0.45609042048454285,
-0.6253570318222046,
0.6823490858078003,
0.1045495942234993,
0.1471739262342453,
-0.0666283369064331,
0.10730845481157303,
0.15873198211193085,
0.472152978181839,
-0.3660328984260559,
-0.3656107187271118,
-0.5225993394851685,
-0.5031964778900146,
-0.2592914402484894,
-0.4874565601348877,
-0.08516774326562881,
-0.4524346888065338,
0.8413918614387512,
0.20045113563537598,
0.38552263379096985,
0.038556624203920364,
0.08640920370817184,
-0.06626249849796295,
0.07564159482717514,
0.5675321221351624,
0.842685878276825,
-0.22954237461090088,
-0.3260713219642639,
0.05192635953426361,
-0.7063679695129395,
-0.0500980019569397,
-0.1161702424287796,
-0.05437905341386795,
0.17338739335536957,
0.04709334298968315,
0.8999305367469788,
0.04370518773794174,
-0.5998227000236511,
0.6808039546012878,
-0.3868539035320282,
0.03911251947283745,
-0.759566068649292,
-0.23831091821193695,
0.029914632439613342,
0.19085735082626343,
0.48144230246543884,
0.2916084825992584,
0.31096431612968445,
-0.46766671538352966,
0.4118881821632385,
0.2880920469760895,
-0.46024850010871887,
-0.43795323371887207,
0.47984397411346436,
0.13452744483947754,
-0.14924649894237518,
0.644030749797821,
0.4060016870498657,
-0.6630029678344727,
0.7277002334594727,
0.26180151104927063,
0.9411963224411011,
-0.3042779862880707,
0.4921211302280426,
0.6975273489952087,
-0.1568526178598404,
-0.11112497746944427,
0.3059740960597992,
-0.27561941742897034,
-0.9213757514953613,
-0.07695654779672623,
-1.3671996593475342,
-0.3121303915977478,
-0.16442334651947021,
-0.7873423099517822,
0.4404256343841553,
-0.7315657734870911,
-0.2433619201183319,
-0.3281722366809845,
0.5119416117668152,
-0.711506187915802,
0.9685802459716797,
0.3373839259147644,
0.8574001789093018,
-0.6344671249389648,
0.7792784571647644,
0.49491065740585327,
-0.4241698086261749,
-0.8249295949935913,
-0.06862006336450577,
-0.08620508760213852,
-0.7420899271965027,
0.5665146112442017,
0.2264890968799591,
-0.2758595645427704,
-0.245298370718956,
-0.4690781235694885,
-0.48388606309890747,
0.9581584930419922,
-0.48833489418029785,
-1.2030271291732788,
0.22660833597183228,
0.19605356454849243,
0.38799387216567993,
-0.3562741279602051,
-0.2027515470981598,
0.48837533593177795,
0.4501381814479828,
0.17195680737495422,
-0.19789531826972961,
-0.2953595817089081,
-0.6034548282623291,
-0.23864713311195374,
0.23631982505321503,
-0.8667683005332947,
1.19514799118042,
0.23792195320129395,
-0.19864194095134735,
0.25510600209236145,
0.552078127861023,
-0.014628369361162186,
0.45254698395729065,
0.34907957911491394,
0.845230758190155,
0.5211706757545471,
0.002808724530041218,
0.8268744945526123,
-0.2473091185092926,
0.5083824992179871,
1.013891577720642,
-0.27139008045196533,
0.9420789480209351,
0.124188132584095,
-0.45074114203453064,
0.7973697781562805,
0.7742657661437988,
-0.31484106183052063,
0.5314276218414307,
0.11719972640275955,
-0.5008280277252197,
-0.458191454410553,
-0.10924292355775833,
-0.25427377223968506,
0.19100207090377808,
0.3514384329319,
-0.27718299627304077,
0.08532731235027313,
0.18891958892345428,
-0.11338095366954803,
-0.14808624982833862,
-0.6403475403785706,
1.1622503995895386,
0.3508773744106293,
-0.055903296917676926,
0.31372472643852234,
0.10189351439476013,
0.402279257774353,
-0.6765298247337341,
0.08459895104169846,
-0.5142962336540222,
0.5205805897712708,
-0.3963415324687958,
-0.9540320634841919,
0.3569287061691284,
-0.12902943789958954,
-0.1324944645166397,
-0.2121352106332779,
1.0420645475387573,
0.09140953421592712,
-1.2209616899490356,
0.2139989733695984,
0.37370413541793823,
-0.1758076697587967,
0.021297356113791466,
-0.8993038535118103,
0.1297934204339981,
0.04244324564933777,
-0.6120597124099731,
0.15621258318424225,
0.19182085990905762,
-0.1273636817932129,
0.3941812515258789,
1.0369133949279785,
0.031871892511844635,
-0.17167237401008606,
0.08413512259721756,
0.7711144685745239,
-0.7755522727966309,
-0.5468925833702087,
-0.8780665993690491,
0.369698703289032,
-0.3448663055896759,
-0.11669643223285675,
1.1819583177566528,
0.7194620370864868,
0.8086985349655151,
-0.3521551489830017,
0.603018581867218,
0.32519978284835815,
0.6381664872169495,
-0.13546141982078552,
0.9961423873901367,
-0.534601092338562,
0.16622713208198547,
0.036016128957271576,
-0.7053475379943848,
-0.24387945234775543,
0.838715136051178,
-0.21858368813991547,
-0.04783833399415016,
0.3780800402164459,
0.7641900777816772,
0.0398838184773922,
0.41656312346458435,
0.14990462362766266,
0.3479931950569153,
-0.22203896939754486,
0.42827585339546204,
1.1677578687667847,
-0.29632285237312317,
0.041508372873067856,
-0.8131665587425232,
0.1277574896812439,
-0.19752784073352814,
-0.6015902161598206,
-0.7469196915626526,
-0.3655087947845459,
-0.20062382519245148,
-0.6196962594985962,
0.19087375700473785,
0.9042938947677612,
0.5529128909111023,
-1.1595040559768677,
-0.44715121388435364,
-0.19000211358070374,
0.0733405351638794,
-0.24734359979629517,
-0.22912485897541046,
0.35563841462135315,
0.08978050947189331,
-0.5701791048049927,
0.34189051389694214,
0.18396471440792084,
-0.17081943154335022,
-0.37357887625694275,
-0.283329576253891,
-0.22905804216861725,
0.5224302411079407,
0.43145790696144104,
-0.1299842894077301,
-0.15037602186203003,
0.13800892233848572,
0.0951523408293724,
0.017404841259121895,
0.25508782267570496,
0.8238478899002075,
-0.8149382472038269,
0.20631179213523865,
0.788314700126648,
0.31214189529418945,
0.6082956790924072,
0.24618564546108246,
0.5728045701980591,
-0.532591700553894,
0.0835580825805664,
0.5293987989425659,
0.3817666172981262,
0.36262524127960205,
-0.4284694492816925,
0.28654929995536804,
0.3999629020690918,
-0.47956568002700806,
-0.366805762052536,
0.3565808832645416,
-1.05551278591156,
-0.5471747517585754,
0.9324790239334106,
-0.16338379681110382,
-0.5978487730026245,
0.1123228594660759,
-0.2963939309120178,
0.2080335170030594,
-0.22091682255268097,
0.6224170923233032,
0.39509689807891846,
0.118891142308712,
-0.34366512298583984,
-0.3046947419643402,
0.5416635274887085,
-0.020963041111826897,
-0.6320772767066956,
-0.27064794301986694,
0.5820313692092896,
0.1593717485666275,
-0.0719316303730011,
0.12278665602207184,
0.15211771428585052,
0.4687246084213257,
-0.5703290700912476,
-0.3126738369464874,
-0.16524188220500946,
-0.38778457045555115,
-0.20678631961345673,
0.079586461186409,
-0.2485477179288864,
-0.29339829087257385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17789v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17789v1
|
Spanish and LLM Benchmarks: is MMLU Lost in Translation?
| 2024-05-28T11:13:40 | 2024-05-28T11:13:40 |
Irene Plaza, Nina Melero, Cristina del Pozo, Javier Conde, Pedro Reviriego, Marina Mayor-Rocher, María Grandury
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The evaluation of Large Language Models (LLMs) is a key element in their
continuous improvement process and many benchmarks have been developed to
assess the performance of LLMs in different tasks and topics. As LLMs become
adopted worldwide, evaluating them in languages other than English is
increasingly important. However, most LLM benchmarks are simply translated
using an automated tool and then run in the target language. This means that
the results depend not only on the LLM performance in that language but also on
the quality of the translation. In this paper, we consider the case of the
well-known Massive Multitask Language Understanding (MMLU) benchmark. Selected
categories of the benchmark are translated into Spanish using Azure Translator
and ChatGPT4 and run on ChatGPT4. Next, the results are processed to identify
the test items that produce different answers in Spanish and English. Those are
then analyzed manually to understand if the automatic translation caused the
change. The results show that a significant fraction of the failing items can
be attributed to mistakes in the translation of the benchmark. These results
make a strong case for improving benchmarks in languages other than English by
at least revising the translations of the items and preferably by adapting the
tests to the target language by experts.
|
[
-0.21623894572257996,
-0.4152321517467499,
0.5395336747169495,
0.6081295609474182,
-0.26468729972839355,
0.3091386556625366,
-0.30716753005981445,
-0.6286316514015198,
-0.0442831851541996,
0.19946154952049255,
-0.7035670280456543,
-0.2195146381855011,
-0.7785319685935974,
0.3926064372062683,
-0.3341207802295685,
0.8890821933746338,
-0.6271706223487854,
0.3887490928173065,
-0.3330889344215393,
-0.5945008397102356,
-0.5561866760253906,
-0.6709170341491699,
-0.6353522539138794,
-0.6534057259559631,
0.5469297766685486,
0.28304874897003174,
0.49244239926338196,
0.6223704814910889,
0.573045015335083,
0.3158516585826874,
-0.08270935714244843,
0.340347021818161,
-0.635490357875824,
-0.11707824468612671,
-0.09481333196163177,
-0.8123031854629517,
-0.29243209958076477,
0.11996301263570786,
0.7645291090011597,
0.6950509548187256,
-0.1288783848285675,
0.29085439443588257,
0.30127838253974915,
0.8306623697280884,
-0.5337681770324707,
0.4477108120918274,
-0.57340407371521,
0.23247142136096954,
-0.22627267241477966,
-0.44780927896499634,
-0.26514381170272827,
-0.3072374761104584,
-0.4105418920516968,
-0.27743491530418396,
0.31476515531539917,
-0.013556534424424171,
0.7517213225364685,
0.5612095594406128,
-0.45256906747817993,
-0.4615894556045532,
-0.5780979990959167,
0.9472417235374451,
-0.7011008262634277,
0.6024139523506165,
0.13338929414749146,
0.43008092045783997,
-0.5669792890548706,
-0.15574556589126587,
-0.30815815925598145,
-0.28933608531951904,
0.08233311027288437,
0.2820686399936676,
-0.17316529154777527,
-0.20646721124649048,
-0.02757960744202137,
0.395750492811203,
-0.28968387842178345,
0.3448319137096405,
-0.24461956322193146,
-0.3632369339466095,
0.6393111348152161,
0.35371801257133484,
-0.11851219832897186,
0.025914378464221954,
-0.1692030131816864,
-0.22840598225593567,
-0.9648189544677734,
0.11366263031959534,
0.37406405806541443,
0.11432347446680069,
-0.056937213987112045,
0.5674775838851929,
-0.13544398546218872,
0.3517264425754547,
-0.2670949399471283,
-0.3960665464401245,
0.4602612257003784,
-0.4956775903701782,
-0.1728164702653885,
-0.03481363505125046,
0.670604407787323,
0.4109290540218353,
0.3515704870223999,
-0.33559650182724,
-0.3058081567287445,
-0.0016447592061012983,
-0.059409115463495255,
-0.5611850023269653,
0.20280751585960388,
0.16551366448402405,
-0.32944634556770325,
0.08979631215333939,
-0.22334523499011993,
-0.16993407905101776,
-0.2809332609176636,
-0.2676684856414795,
0.056949421763420105,
0.0038653493393212557,
-0.06565934419631958,
0.13578103482723236,
0.24942709505558014,
0.2556895613670349,
0.4480687081813812,
-0.6065601706504822,
0.2983250021934509,
0.8274043798446655,
0.8569588661193848,
-0.39050519466400146,
-0.6107907295227051,
-0.5560393333435059,
-0.1189817413687706,
-0.6181549429893494,
0.711852490901947,
-0.07631871104240417,
-0.35368216037750244,
0.0678769201040268,
0.29449787735939026,
-0.39698782563209534,
-0.7561994194984436,
0.6097861528396606,
-0.4250394403934479,
0.0365801565349102,
-0.5640661716461182,
-0.41047781705856323,
-0.29111218452453613,
0.4686720669269562,
-0.444586843252182,
1.0385617017745972,
-0.20689168572425842,
-0.35257354378700256,
0.17992261052131653,
-0.32347556948661804,
-0.32164743542671204,
-0.1434318721294403,
-0.10573266446590424,
-0.1722518503665924,
0.34872666001319885,
0.1476336270570755,
0.5191676616668701,
-0.6639820337295532,
0.2709033489227295,
-0.15485265851020813,
-0.3408452272415161,
0.5236450433731079,
-0.5535285472869873,
0.3411775529384613,
0.14769792556762695,
-0.31944262981414795,
0.011081582866609097,
-0.5036760568618774,
0.019252467900514603,
-0.03936281055212021,
-0.6589710116386414,
0.03261720389127731,
0.12379898875951767,
0.2430846095085144,
0.4051723778247833,
0.42980945110321045,
-0.5798947811126709,
-0.07923845201730728,
-0.2670241892337799,
0.23684807121753693,
0.6810176372528076,
-0.250196248292923,
0.2122957557439804,
-0.35244107246398926,
0.7679376602172852,
-0.1270899772644043,
0.09657557308673859,
0.026890451088547707,
-0.5839771628379822,
-0.8891905546188354,
0.20150059461593628,
0.21289516985416412,
0.6350739002227783,
-0.5774449110031128,
-0.07095029205083847,
-0.3250289559364319,
-0.492244154214859,
-0.8431021571159363,
0.41842329502105713,
0.49027007818222046,
0.37753719091415405,
0.2259114384651184,
-0.13684037327766418,
-0.3844241797924042,
-0.8634530305862427,
-0.38981732726097107,
-0.22541068494319916,
-0.01016858872026205,
0.28773805499076843,
0.5122666358947754,
-0.2813655734062195,
0.2978169322013855,
-0.06929178535938263,
-0.5704833269119263,
-0.41559097170829773,
0.06506521999835968,
0.5169154405593872,
0.27003800868988037,
0.461130827665329,
-0.6202368140220642,
-0.5025193095207214,
0.4334471523761749,
-0.7575485706329346,
-0.31778451800346375,
-0.13921114802360535,
0.15378573536872864,
0.24349868297576904,
0.6562078595161438,
-0.17718006670475006,
0.09039326012134552,
1.0422289371490479,
-0.09404174983501434,
0.7262163758277893,
-0.5389724969863892,
0.4844943583011627,
-0.8311788439750671,
-0.05647636950016022,
-0.14522744715213776,
-0.2802048325538635,
-0.2833652198314667,
0.26762107014656067,
0.5066580176353455,
0.2917822301387787,
-0.7728884220123291,
0.555860698223114,
-0.4220268130302429,
-0.2777315676212311,
-0.33783817291259766,
-0.017758438363671303,
-0.01692805625498295,
0.38719406723976135,
-0.3212958574295044,
1.1085915565490723,
0.30071622133255005,
-0.4994308650493622,
0.25521939992904663,
0.05441877245903015,
-0.3753107488155365,
0.5286174416542053,
-0.6393164992332458,
0.018740247935056686,
-0.13266374170780182,
0.06598807871341705,
-0.8743218779563904,
0.08737929165363312,
0.06738434731960297,
-0.19721992313861847,
0.0002917812380474061,
-0.1673298180103302,
-0.8470079898834229,
-0.34082239866256714,
-0.22439995408058167,
0.02960958145558834,
0.20742550492286682,
-0.5280609726905823,
0.3062959909439087,
0.25406691431999207,
0.1276838630437851,
-0.7483169436454773,
-0.9054796099662781,
0.22500190138816833,
-0.2141633778810501,
-0.5487174391746521,
0.2441776990890503,
-0.4215392470359802,
-0.0476633757352829,
-0.18053649365901947,
-0.35921376943588257,
-0.1406589299440384,
0.2755593955516815,
0.24543967843055725,
0.0038169557228684425,
-0.4698337912559509,
0.17530851066112518,
-0.01924734376370907,
-0.2196369767189026,
0.19449761509895325,
0.11375773698091507,
0.587043285369873,
-0.6007980108261108,
-0.5217320919036865,
-0.2589713931083679,
0.13184930384159088,
0.963839590549469,
-0.2782028019428253,
0.781144917011261,
0.47013846039772034,
-0.15634141862392426,
0.13313433527946472,
-0.9578215479850769,
0.2427656203508377,
-0.44609537720680237,
0.44855237007141113,
-0.787297248840332,
-0.6459667086601257,
0.9762672185897827,
-0.07849854230880737,
0.11617815494537354,
0.512299120426178,
0.7495101690292358,
-0.24973569810390472,
1.0216386318206787,
0.6550755500793457,
-0.282988578081131,
0.2494804412126541,
-0.19534099102020264,
0.03586606681346893,
-0.8886342644691467,
-0.2918705344200134,
-0.6255528330802917,
-0.4266681969165802,
-0.5614014267921448,
-0.49116307497024536,
0.3377677798271179,
-0.00007285579340532422,
0.4548782408237457,
0.4796765446662903,
0.11219697445631027,
0.715607225894928,
0.11569365113973618,
-0.22610895335674286,
0.5944854021072388,
-0.24739451706409454,
-0.3073159158229828,
-0.26664650440216064,
-0.7550231218338013,
-0.5529068112373352,
1.0291885137557983,
0.3948459029197693,
0.672315776348114,
0.2718439996242523,
0.5402796268463135,
0.11744063347578049,
0.4315788149833679,
-0.8859109878540039,
0.430713415145874,
-0.1269456446170807,
-0.15307195484638214,
0.014119950123131275,
-0.48651444911956787,
-1.2176939249038696,
0.7338735461235046,
0.0012140058679506183,
-0.350774347782135,
0.03037741594016552,
-0.12632083892822266,
0.01515949983149767,
0.13879148662090302,
-0.7042326927185059,
1.153823733329773,
-0.4205440282821655,
-0.27190354466438293,
-0.4278779923915863,
-0.02589639090001583,
0.20087692141532898,
-0.37856850028038025,
0.5023351907730103,
-0.5877859592437744,
-0.27804991602897644,
0.9157422184944153,
-0.33478716015815735,
0.4154563844203949,
0.13208021223545074,
-0.21476097404956818,
-0.16555239260196686,
0.04022638127207756,
0.46467703580856323,
-0.0014604299794882536,
-0.3385685086250305,
0.17442330718040466,
0.12613679468631744,
-0.5645239949226379,
-0.40770888328552246,
0.9800355434417725,
-0.786522388458252,
-0.4883650243282318,
-0.345640629529953,
-0.7767059206962585,
-0.22086314857006073,
0.05566057190299034,
0.07193172723054886,
0.1281549334526062,
-0.31634318828582764,
0.11378808319568634,
0.34157365560531616,
-0.16152366995811462,
0.516489565372467,
1.03853178024292,
0.012624240480363369,
0.0142001798376441,
0.5940353870391846,
0.21611514687538147,
0.13792018592357635,
0.10902819037437439,
0.2850588262081146,
-0.5514549612998962,
-0.7691088318824768,
-0.6884052753448486,
0.5600165724754333,
-0.934594452381134,
-0.004690202884376049,
-0.5883005261421204,
0.16117841005325317,
-0.11311343312263489,
-0.0657084658741951,
-0.6887066960334778,
-0.007706909440457821,
-0.09848993271589279,
0.032512687146663666,
0.15327095985412598,
0.7257706522941589,
0.09756014496088028,
0.22974838316440582,
-0.8773788809776306,
0.19005870819091797,
-0.06803661584854126,
0.26290902495384216,
0.07702358812093735,
-0.7076163291931152,
-0.41703760623931885,
-0.05183543264865875,
-0.08838444948196411,
-0.7594814300537109,
0.42745012044906616,
0.16445766389369965,
0.7405981421470642,
0.09361594915390015,
-0.3293682336807251,
0.9938536882400513,
-0.6783825159072876,
0.33026519417762756,
0.04378237947821617,
-0.6945276260375977,
0.2533702850341797,
-0.14382870495319366,
0.7315826416015625,
0.7119130492210388,
0.3953038454055786,
-1.0013240575790405,
-0.7578442692756653,
-0.4150065779685974,
-0.6753606796264648,
0.46529150009155273,
0.03457055985927582,
0.14412827789783478,
0.0022778529673814774,
-0.025998570024967194,
0.20623774826526642,
0.36423954367637634,
-0.7136997580528259,
-0.3343880772590637,
0.281242311000824,
0.07235326617956161,
-0.4341249465942383,
-0.10593422502279282,
0.0776996910572052,
-0.18417342007160187,
0.6542240977287292,
-0.0024713589809834957,
-0.09309247136116028,
-0.08362137526273727,
-0.5365890860557556,
-0.10555045306682587,
0.36546164751052856,
0.5238626599311829,
0.827455461025238,
-0.11261418461799622,
-0.031496088951826096,
0.29748740792274475,
-0.4004121422767639,
0.25790050625801086,
-0.040189314633607864,
0.16436180472373962,
0.19103644788265228,
0.22219158709049225,
0.4489020109176636,
0.5388827919960022,
-0.983282208442688,
0.3536272644996643,
-0.1178247481584549,
0.012402402237057686,
-0.3859158754348755,
-0.21033109724521637,
0.2749081254005432,
0.17860738933086395,
0.54137122631073,
0.1631072461605072,
-0.0917179211974144,
-0.6836050748825073,
-0.05679428577423096,
0.2227349728345871,
-0.26562967896461487,
-0.15629799664020538,
0.7558907866477966,
0.17612944543361664,
-0.18799424171447754,
0.4438827633857727,
-0.2746293544769287,
-0.6416671872138977,
0.7334365844726562,
0.40111011266708374,
0.7020344734191895,
-0.26749101281166077,
0.13721755146980286,
0.23668889701366425,
0.6914581060409546,
-0.37667566537857056,
0.14248308539390564,
0.22386987507343292,
-0.6179914474487305,
-0.8139150142669678,
-0.46750426292419434,
-0.6469204425811768,
0.1520521640777588,
-0.39526650309562683,
0.0867035910487175,
-0.029277369379997253,
0.18286949396133423,
-0.06389232724905014,
0.02589784935116768,
-0.9366863965988159,
-0.003095457563176751,
-0.0010944937821477652,
0.7015522122383118,
-1.1447995901107788,
0.9201455116271973,
0.5051023960113525,
-0.1737646907567978,
-0.5514223575592041,
-0.4660743474960327,
0.08285040408372879,
-0.9152284860610962,
0.6471490263938904,
0.12145443260669708,
-0.09505311399698257,
-0.26134371757507324,
0.2175188511610031,
-1.047243595123291,
0.7381383180618286,
0.5262267589569092,
-0.6300669312477112,
0.42804840207099915,
0.5139180421829224,
0.7405720949172974,
-0.19406163692474365,
0.3289463222026825,
0.7167206406593323,
0.4623368978500366,
-0.12669391930103302,
-1.4021281003952026,
-0.029742131009697914,
-0.24104388058185577,
-0.30638381838798523,
0.35087260603904724,
-0.5587146878242493,
0.9754633903503418,
-0.16000351309776306,
-0.16946180164813995,
0.061627406626939774,
0.32838016748428345,
0.0032875915057957172,
0.4139564633369446,
0.12930506467819214,
0.3464813828468323,
0.8300843238830566,
-0.2368415743112564,
1.2773469686508179,
-0.12320628762245178,
0.32100245356559753,
1.199244499206543,
-0.29777687788009644,
1.1259799003601074,
0.6020498275756836,
-0.3224959373474121,
0.03790651261806488,
0.758168637752533,
-0.10090376436710358,
0.25213855504989624,
0.21529100835323334,
-0.12305064499378204,
0.12933094799518585,
-0.11186078935861588,
-0.459401935338974,
0.4163568615913391,
0.3602888882160187,
-0.23061010241508484,
-0.4691961407661438,
0.18337030708789825,
0.1643289476633072,
0.196341410279274,
-0.3832157552242279,
0.48578882217407227,
0.05871553346514702,
-0.7665732502937317,
1.0562750101089478,
0.31148290634155273,
0.7186021208763123,
-0.5299423336982727,
0.2563481032848358,
-0.6553427577018738,
0.2863532304763794,
-0.20439542829990387,
-0.6876910328865051,
0.5109609365463257,
0.03700745478272438,
-0.07071295380592346,
-0.5303746461868286,
0.10004846006631851,
-0.34658095240592957,
-0.6792377233505249,
0.48393628001213074,
0.783831000328064,
0.6507130265235901,
-0.2602739632129669,
-0.9263473749160767,
0.28113409876823425,
-0.015039742924273014,
-0.03995180130004883,
0.40722212195396423,
0.179281085729599,
-0.10407983511686325,
0.9401581883430481,
0.6814461350440979,
0.2733057141304016,
0.3874468505382538,
0.28374922275543213,
0.45927414298057556,
-0.4099728763103485,
-0.3935324549674988,
-0.9061747789382935,
0.10974301397800446,
0.12254417687654495,
-0.36449190974235535,
1.004132628440857,
0.7119849920272827,
0.9665126204490662,
-0.3389956057071686,
0.3905235230922699,
0.3689039647579193,
0.2864370346069336,
-0.5296120643615723,
0.7650771737098694,
-0.547720193862915,
0.25486212968826294,
-0.15701456367969513,
-1.2978789806365967,
-0.09632972627878189,
0.2729116678237915,
-0.2616827189922333,
-0.4658910632133484,
1.1460621356964111,
0.8124182224273682,
-0.013836605474352837,
-0.3903539180755615,
0.6139973402023315,
0.26559653878211975,
0.3777819871902466,
0.8481031656265259,
0.6455674767494202,
-0.8051993250846863,
0.8915278315544128,
-0.2018921822309494,
-0.06614986062049866,
-0.1798209398984909,
-0.8286656737327576,
-0.7121182084083557,
-0.4468018412590027,
-0.48227599263191223,
-0.06791835278272629,
-0.03251878172159195,
0.52011638879776,
0.25595757365226746,
-0.8674586415290833,
-0.6914998888969421,
0.015536931343376637,
0.33571693301200867,
-0.4456288814544678,
-0.13853947818279266,
0.2876780331134796,
-0.3575185537338257,
-0.9167442917823792,
0.7263362407684326,
0.26976701617240906,
0.045562513172626495,
-0.16847378015518188,
-0.2822399139404297,
-0.10776480287313461,
-0.14101308584213257,
0.533299446105957,
0.36257001757621765,
-1.0417265892028809,
0.010986448265612125,
0.08318975567817688,
-0.07808146625757217,
0.25007322430610657,
0.686454176902771,
-0.7302504181861877,
0.4362940192222595,
0.32895761728286743,
0.8983201384544373,
0.6387659907341003,
-0.4135783314704895,
0.6836704611778259,
-0.5935004949569702,
0.36600008606910706,
0.021663734689354897,
0.6646414995193481,
0.5033278465270996,
-0.0452057309448719,
0.7389928102493286,
0.07834383845329285,
-0.4020242691040039,
-0.7603455781936646,
0.048249419778585434,
-0.7561563849449158,
-0.004960875958204269,
1.0386096239089966,
-0.15618731081485748,
-0.20220685005187988,
-0.296938955783844,
-0.12879306077957153,
-0.0023159917909651995,
-0.12632352113723755,
0.8987522125244141,
1.0053026676177979,
0.06786500662565231,
-0.14051657915115356,
-1.1311824321746826,
0.2983575463294983,
0.6558781266212463,
-0.6862305998802185,
0.04467691481113434,
0.1231049969792366,
0.20807898044586182,
0.03155222535133362,
0.5777754187583923,
-0.11017156392335892,
0.5011736154556274,
-0.32622212171554565,
-0.057699739933013916,
0.11636742204427719,
0.017804821953177452,
-0.21929897367954254,
-0.08243155479431152,
0.34257644414901733,
-0.39725053310394287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18035v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18035v2
|
Instruction Tuning with Retrieval-based Examples Ranking for Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-05-28T10:39:10 | 2024-05-29T06:35:46 |
Guangmin Zheng, Jin Wang, Liang-Chih Yu, Xuejie Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aspect-based sentiment analysis (ABSA) identifies sentiment information
related to specific aspects and provides deeper market insights to businesses
and organizations. With the emergence of large language models (LMs), recent
studies have proposed using fixed examples for instruction tuning to
reformulate ABSA as a generation task. However, the performance is sensitive to
the selection of in-context examples; several retrieval methods are based on
surface similarity and are independent of the LM generative objective. This
study proposes an instruction learning method with retrieval-based example
ranking for ABSA tasks. For each target sample, an LM was applied as a scorer
to estimate the likelihood of the output given the input and a candidate
example as the prompt, and training examples were labeled as positive or
negative by ranking the scores. An alternating training schema is proposed to
train both the retriever and LM. Instructional prompts can be constructed using
high-quality examples. The LM is used for both scoring and inference, improving
the generation efficiency without incurring additional computational costs or
training difficulties. Extensive experiments on three ABSA subtasks verified
the effectiveness of the proposed method, demonstrating its superiority over
various strong baseline models. Code and data are released at
https://github.com/zgMin/IT-RER-ABSA.
|
[
-0.34512436389923096,
-1.0025924444198608,
0.5904695987701416,
0.001110099838115275,
-0.6497583985328674,
-0.1265535056591034,
-0.255059152841568,
-0.043308548629283905,
0.2107681781053543,
0.6447136998176575,
-0.5005859136581421,
-0.9424221515655518,
-0.24512329697608948,
-0.08216726034879684,
-0.2599656581878662,
1.1347390413284302,
0.15391454100608826,
0.1641765832901001,
-0.3783142566680908,
-0.18220935761928558,
-0.6560558676719666,
-0.5416693091392517,
-0.6676220297813416,
-0.09692017734050751,
0.2419702708721161,
0.7855785489082336,
0.23054920136928558,
0.5792603492736816,
0.41461387276649475,
0.2826712429523468,
-0.015712952241301537,
0.05650464445352554,
-0.27080756425857544,
0.2821398675441742,
-0.4037880599498749,
-0.5859442353248596,
-0.30800750851631165,
0.04968852177262306,
0.5684320330619812,
0.6171801090240479,
-0.26959243416786194,
0.17774565517902374,
0.17287299036979675,
0.7444314360618591,
-0.6945111155509949,
0.38947340846061707,
-0.6673805117607117,
-0.10695529729127884,
0.04385799914598465,
-0.21099941432476044,
-0.5699087381362915,
-0.5757565498352051,
-0.027919383719563484,
-0.31600427627563477,
0.42903292179107666,
0.15804216265678406,
0.7445306777954102,
0.056554585695266724,
-0.09155351668596268,
-0.479890376329422,
-0.4070548713207245,
1.1276500225067139,
-0.8521360754966736,
0.20240455865859985,
0.3720385432243347,
0.06323539465665817,
0.14962653815746307,
-0.3872276246547699,
-0.3259236216545105,
-0.12374864518642426,
0.07503189146518707,
0.3044910430908203,
0.053163010627031326,
0.12759600579738617,
0.04334866255521774,
0.5889686346054077,
-0.297991544008255,
0.2744850814342499,
-0.25413039326667786,
0.12599387764930725,
0.4680255651473999,
0.08613365143537521,
-0.02687135338783264,
-0.4473288953304291,
-0.2074674665927887,
-0.360251784324646,
-0.9189290404319763,
0.2649550437927246,
0.43874743580818176,
0.643149733543396,
0.03356572613120079,
0.5535616874694824,
-0.21916697919368744,
0.7099642753601074,
0.2661052346229553,
0.10200276225805283,
0.37895023822784424,
-0.008111074566841125,
-0.05757804214954376,
0.1280931830406189,
0.5426838994026184,
0.4878618121147156,
-0.298992782831192,
-0.011896571144461632,
-0.44564709067344666,
-0.19009952247142792,
0.6427624821662903,
-0.9212777018547058,
-0.16559578478336334,
-0.040761549025774,
-0.4297793507575989,
-0.09644883871078491,
0.31150636076927185,
-1.013674259185791,
-0.21741577982902527,
-0.4996431767940521,
0.5253525376319885,
-0.6714767217636108,
0.09065205603837967,
-0.34990739822387695,
0.2246476709842682,
0.5350980162620544,
0.031204909086227417,
-0.8172228932380676,
-0.021738192066550255,
1.0006728172302246,
0.6636343598365784,
-0.10749704390764236,
0.0036924113519489765,
-0.7708728909492493,
-0.3973042368888855,
-0.5327218770980835,
0.7944077849388123,
-0.8637793660163879,
-0.5787662267684937,
0.2603813409805298,
-0.09547419846057892,
-0.05762898549437523,
-0.7125375270843506,
0.4904863238334656,
-0.6146169900894165,
0.36924681067466736,
-0.19126342236995697,
-0.7143450975418091,
-0.5032686591148376,
0.2559657394886017,
-0.39200934767723083,
1.0030781030654907,
0.23071107268333435,
-0.28082743287086487,
0.2233532965183258,
-0.452058345079422,
-0.5102485418319702,
-0.09893664717674255,
-0.27649861574172974,
-0.7211929559707642,
0.4294361472129822,
0.2918887138366699,
0.49769511818885803,
-0.11737135052680969,
-0.15030618011951447,
0.03360334038734436,
-0.3555302619934082,
0.08382824808359146,
-0.32208722829818726,
0.18104201555252075,
0.17343564331531525,
-0.3673648536205292,
0.1984885185956955,
-0.37460511922836304,
0.19299721717834473,
-0.3281596601009369,
-0.2757568657398224,
-0.7328705191612244,
-0.012898579239845276,
-0.3819679319858551,
-0.016244158148765564,
0.3246534764766693,
-0.48602309823036194,
0.251234769821167,
-0.6428624391555786,
-0.06302393972873688,
0.6520931720733643,
0.4522659182548523,
0.35133540630340576,
-0.14288225769996643,
0.6287367939949036,
0.16754145920276642,
0.1295691430568695,
-0.25835317373275757,
-0.3008660674095154,
-0.8844132423400879,
-0.1974789947271347,
0.3174617290496826,
0.4228866398334503,
-1.0672557353973389,
0.6495510935783386,
-0.20550209283828735,
-0.4477556049823761,
-0.7805861234664917,
0.39342039823532104,
0.843956708908081,
0.6003482341766357,
0.5816890597343445,
-0.5059037208557129,
-0.14124178886413574,
-0.9938036203384399,
-0.14505885541439056,
-0.02179475501179695,
0.06677494198083878,
0.5436272025108337,
0.12790410220623016,
0.2935040295124054,
0.8765729069709778,
-0.6038784980773926,
-0.2969840168952942,
-0.47967877984046936,
0.4765521287918091,
0.3515012264251709,
0.3387298583984375,
0.5425364375114441,
-0.7047593593597412,
-0.3842483460903168,
-0.16098234057426453,
-0.568827211856842,
-0.028356244787573814,
0.033310528844594955,
-0.22998112440109253,
0.31536710262298584,
0.3780054450035095,
-0.06861308217048645,
0.32993897795677185,
0.20289725065231323,
-0.23411236703395844,
0.24414008855819702,
-0.2068234235048294,
0.44599640369415283,
-1.395681381225586,
-0.33145344257354736,
0.3286273181438446,
-0.05221683159470558,
-0.3923463821411133,
0.24990488588809967,
0.07308177649974823,
-0.06346456706523895,
-0.46339666843414307,
0.21532699465751648,
-0.504759669303894,
-0.07909173518419266,
-0.6953915953636169,
0.10635325312614441,
-0.004679299890995026,
0.6648477911949158,
0.0722789540886879,
0.9413287043571472,
0.4534779489040375,
-0.6557133197784424,
-0.0172450989484787,
0.02173503488302231,
-0.5019199252128601,
0.721687376499176,
-0.46537232398986816,
0.400133341550827,
-0.23237738013267517,
-0.26263585686683655,
-0.5613735914230347,
0.1265202909708023,
0.19667449593544006,
-0.08789592981338501,
0.599395215511322,
-0.22195960581302643,
-0.14377890527248383,
-0.013206800445914268,
-0.6025537252426147,
0.08774108439683914,
0.637687623500824,
-0.6470276713371277,
0.5928040742874146,
0.09842460602521896,
-0.4398540258407593,
-0.7134737968444824,
-0.08653377741575241,
-0.19178685545921326,
-0.30655181407928467,
0.09050871431827545,
0.484543114900589,
0.04130174219608307,
-0.15659292042255402,
0.11806899309158325,
-0.24313651025295258,
0.11260831356048584,
0.10323459655046463,
0.29092875123023987,
0.261552095413208,
-0.4086146354675293,
0.11773955821990967,
0.5565454959869385,
0.10285933315753937,
0.023764384910464287,
0.06955123692750931,
0.5022926330566406,
-0.2999776601791382,
-0.4430687129497528,
-0.45096227526664734,
0.4377829432487488,
0.1438877135515213,
-0.3499137759208679,
0.8688292503356934,
0.3199281096458435,
-0.09000321477651596,
-0.5382766723632812,
-0.3493257462978363,
-0.4196474850177765,
-0.4774136245250702,
0.5649603009223938,
-0.184421569108963,
-0.4299943745136261,
0.2247025966644287,
0.018656708300113678,
0.2482147514820099,
0.20452876389026642,
0.2889758050441742,
-0.07547932863235474,
0.8307883739471436,
0.6040465235710144,
-0.35124585032463074,
0.9550197124481201,
-0.5693718194961548,
0.21254871785640717,
-0.9890092015266418,
-0.12987302243709564,
-0.5712771415710449,
-0.22178739309310913,
-0.26277753710746765,
-0.3551226556301117,
0.3467957377433777,
0.40733852982521057,
-0.13015243411064148,
0.19827865064144135,
-0.5072953104972839,
0.5823231339454651,
0.7111352682113647,
0.34926798939704895,
0.14833901822566986,
0.1164541244506836,
0.14470599591732025,
0.01563386432826519,
-0.39456707239151,
-0.5785003304481506,
0.8883434534072876,
-0.06322170048952103,
0.7020831108093262,
0.23371556401252747,
0.8596137762069702,
0.4035123884677887,
0.6339075565338135,
-1.0522335767745972,
0.5510629415512085,
-0.6252920031547546,
-0.14113400876522064,
-0.1285589188337326,
-0.4608900547027588,
-0.7273706197738647,
0.09253385663032532,
0.03677951171994209,
-0.5435969233512878,
0.08797844499349594,
0.09380008280277252,
-0.20954389870166779,
0.04620669409632683,
-0.6832485198974609,
0.7426455020904541,
-0.2808060646057129,
-0.3570060729980469,
-0.42448171973228455,
-0.21302804350852966,
0.0609922856092453,
0.18904463946819305,
0.09317080676555634,
0.07434669882059097,
0.1658574640750885,
0.6798518896102905,
-0.32196831703186035,
0.8935986161231995,
-0.49532341957092285,
-0.04839802905917168,
0.48553267121315,
-0.12072352319955826,
0.239907369017601,
0.04649798199534416,
-0.3888460099697113,
-0.04967367649078369,
-0.29359832406044006,
-0.2131442129611969,
-0.9779726266860962,
0.8126925826072693,
-0.7428357601165771,
-0.8346675038337708,
-0.16786395013332367,
-0.19223198294639587,
-0.2947518825531006,
0.022692540660500526,
0.28856074810028076,
0.7413893938064575,
-0.01600297912955284,
0.4891025722026825,
0.7205137610435486,
-0.20893080532550812,
0.33733832836151123,
0.7426395416259766,
-0.05396239459514618,
-0.25177261233329773,
1.3232207298278809,
-0.032226771116256714,
0.026479166001081467,
0.7331711053848267,
0.028404241427779198,
-0.338996022939682,
-0.6851646304130554,
-0.46473345160484314,
0.10114837437868118,
-0.6829732060432434,
-0.5721823573112488,
-0.05821368470788002,
-0.1375335156917572,
-0.10809268057346344,
-0.06874825805425644,
-0.4287694990634918,
-0.08170097321271896,
-0.471608430147171,
-0.26057130098342896,
0.45366036891937256,
0.6001895070075989,
0.37328019738197327,
0.32417353987693787,
-0.6763144135475159,
0.1492152065038681,
0.1647447943687439,
0.37913113832473755,
0.15341150760650635,
-0.6066308617591858,
-0.45607754588127136,
0.09103704243898392,
-0.6054953932762146,
-0.911826491355896,
0.324412077665329,
0.4270562529563904,
0.7664169073104858,
0.49744313955307007,
0.2405889928340912,
0.34320715069770813,
-0.29071345925331116,
0.884971022605896,
-0.17009519040584564,
-0.9916751384735107,
0.869852602481842,
0.07636706531047821,
-0.07457008957862854,
0.7824644446372986,
0.41064584255218506,
-0.2506760060787201,
-0.5112155675888062,
-0.3046657145023346,
-1.1207787990570068,
0.7770450115203857,
-0.10313313454389572,
0.4355304539203644,
-0.23111113905906677,
0.7926255464553833,
0.33777570724487305,
0.25370538234710693,
-0.25993192195892334,
-0.4243753254413605,
-0.5079677700996399,
-0.7002280354499817,
0.0851009264588356,
-0.17704086005687714,
0.10318909585475922,
-0.03892042115330696,
1.1007201671600342,
-0.30253127217292786,
0.11549380421638489,
-0.029637811705470085,
-0.23470602929592133,
0.29482749104499817,
0.5857439041137695,
0.2704518735408783,
0.48571157455444336,
-0.1465616673231125,
-0.1467914581298828,
-0.008836842142045498,
-0.4587881863117218,
0.03216049447655678,
0.08591022342443466,
-0.33160385489463806,
-0.11261101812124252,
0.14275199174880981,
0.9288232326507568,
0.3764221668243408,
-0.49727126955986023,
0.49911466240882874,
0.015845706686377525,
0.146810382604599,
-0.1724596470594406,
0.42386001348495483,
-0.24777835607528687,
0.22199781239032745,
0.541731059551239,
-0.4618666172027588,
0.2395162135362625,
-0.5830561518669128,
0.11401411890983582,
0.5188591480255127,
-0.5805327296257019,
-0.2775205075740814,
0.16174696385860443,
0.2268543243408203,
-0.4405750632286072,
0.9107218980789185,
-0.5231611132621765,
-0.3450195789337158,
0.6263894438743591,
0.4091223180294037,
0.8445205688476562,
-0.29208704829216003,
0.4305940866470337,
0.28032180666923523,
0.011218167841434479,
0.14517900347709656,
0.42833754420280457,
-0.09991101175546646,
-0.6096076965332031,
-0.19289378821849823,
-0.7075591683387756,
-0.6754136085510254,
0.1615322232246399,
-1.2656524181365967,
0.024170046672225,
-0.31951287388801575,
-0.05676092952489853,
-0.17825904488563538,
0.07572940737009048,
-0.3739614486694336,
0.15643742680549622,
-0.12488880008459091,
0.5373592972755432,
-0.8059941530227661,
0.6402076482772827,
1.0028408765792847,
-0.6133767366409302,
-0.8232873678207397,
0.22777339816093445,
-0.3298044800758362,
-0.4038689136505127,
0.19930268824100494,
0.3013998568058014,
-0.16650648415088654,
-0.2049834132194519,
-0.3592284321784973,
-0.4730142652988434,
1.050013780593872,
0.19832895696163177,
-0.4558517038822174,
0.2565334737300873,
-0.20214134454727173,
0.6114462614059448,
-0.5544344186782837,
0.22958579659461975,
0.4490243196487427,
-0.0627598986029625,
-0.20303857326507568,
-0.311809778213501,
-0.07808432728052139,
-0.22227005660533905,
0.06722385436296463,
0.2325574904680252,
-0.8002316355705261,
0.721681535243988,
-0.06439266353845596,
-0.03196974843740463,
0.24468904733657837,
1.1049566268920898,
0.3951849341392517,
0.48802754282951355,
0.5363844633102417,
0.33864304423332214,
0.43620774149894714,
-0.02750588394701481,
0.9157459735870361,
-0.4184861481189728,
0.3601568341255188,
1.1276991367340088,
-0.20322495698928833,
1.1130644083023071,
0.1915479302406311,
0.04717012494802475,
1.019298791885376,
0.4806041717529297,
0.04615456238389015,
0.6857848763465881,
-0.05417244881391525,
-0.25215867161750793,
-0.2609100937843323,
-0.1428975611925125,
-0.2753486633300781,
0.5865396857261658,
0.6104347109794617,
-0.6135183572769165,
-0.19961242377758026,
0.18562449514865875,
-0.025111058726906776,
0.3769834041595459,
-0.6190561056137085,
0.9457760453224182,
0.1334965080022812,
-0.8482069373130798,
0.26000159978866577,
0.1858828067779541,
0.715002715587616,
-0.4592287242412567,
-0.3829747140407562,
-0.6461144685745239,
0.20146618783473969,
-0.04637909680604935,
-0.7123391628265381,
0.12312033027410507,
0.16897939145565033,
-0.43577513098716736,
-0.07395762205123901,
0.16136202216148376,
-0.4183558523654938,
-0.7559175491333008,
-0.0599442683160305,
0.31543251872062683,
0.15218712389469147,
-0.0011465082643553615,
-0.5935327410697937,
-0.21041914820671082,
0.14721406996250153,
-0.4509837031364441,
0.46777912974357605,
0.2978045642375946,
-0.16373805701732635,
0.36265215277671814,
0.1368280053138733,
-0.17812156677246094,
-0.27967047691345215,
0.29036954045295715,
0.7410904765129089,
-0.6772608160972595,
-0.3625229299068451,
-0.6000906825065613,
0.146383136510849,
-0.121242456138134,
-0.3142165541648865,
0.7785711288452148,
0.7280223369598389,
0.64239901304245,
0.009399494156241417,
0.5304626226425171,
0.1370706707239151,
0.6840338110923767,
-0.9543855786323547,
0.5600395798683167,
-0.5840296745300293,
0.5408681035041809,
-0.14536793529987335,
-1.020808458328247,
0.13239793479442596,
0.6373825669288635,
-0.5447476506233215,
0.3364931046962738,
0.5221151113510132,
0.883145809173584,
-0.07058873027563095,
0.15026512742042542,
0.084114670753479,
0.1275903582572937,
0.2815617024898529,
0.2855514883995056,
0.5269028544425964,
-0.21706272661685944,
0.33962756395339966,
-0.6941028833389282,
-0.27675580978393555,
-0.23706656694412231,
-0.7266831398010254,
-0.7004960179328918,
-0.6045335531234741,
-0.47186702489852905,
-0.12970100343227386,
0.1525619924068451,
1.0168429613113403,
0.5447946786880493,
-0.9910182952880859,
0.015396421775221825,
0.17747195065021515,
0.33242762088775635,
-0.5625120997428894,
-0.36382967233657837,
0.6721872091293335,
-0.6291924118995667,
-0.9258832335472107,
0.5775524973869324,
-0.07898228615522385,
-0.2720452845096588,
-0.1282719224691391,
0.21887512505054474,
0.11327853053808212,
0.10484115034341812,
0.5874828696250916,
0.2590027153491974,
-0.547738790512085,
-0.44598305225372314,
0.026424046605825424,
0.11911366134881973,
0.030310969799757004,
0.8220748901367188,
-0.7930697202682495,
0.2734711170196533,
0.28317829966545105,
0.5890187621116638,
0.32337862253189087,
0.5933678150177002,
0.36978790163993835,
-1.2386175394058228,
-0.1484227478504181,
0.28024888038635254,
0.3266020119190216,
0.6038854122161865,
-0.43870866298675537,
0.06668698042631149,
-0.19121457636356354,
-0.3907894790172577,
-0.5930416584014893,
0.0919589251279831,
-0.8701435327529907,
-0.4017387330532074,
1.075993537902832,
-0.4036877453327179,
-0.26597386598587036,
0.13649910688400269,
-0.14817290008068085,
0.2602715492248535,
-0.7730637788772583,
1.1237238645553589,
0.3970232605934143,
-0.33266040682792664,
-0.14482639729976654,
-0.15815074741840363,
0.2899077832698822,
0.5127236843109131,
-0.8313164710998535,
0.030644956976175308,
0.5786429643630981,
0.19951754808425903,
0.16293418407440186,
0.2181352972984314,
0.06477653235197067,
0.3121867775917053,
-0.3154974579811096,
0.1597438007593155,
-0.2085198611021042,
-0.3908652067184448,
-0.4660065770149231,
0.2344488799571991,
0.26063114404678345,
-0.5342527627944946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18028v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18028v1
|
Edinburgh Clinical NLP at MEDIQA-CORR 2024: Guiding Large Language Models with Hints
| 2024-05-28T10:20:29 | 2024-05-28T10:20:29 |
Aryo Pradipta Gema, Chaeeun Lee, Pasquale Minervini, Luke Daines, T. Ian Simpson, Beatrice Alex
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The MEDIQA-CORR 2024 shared task aims to assess the ability of Large Language
Models (LLMs) to identify and correct medical errors in clinical notes. In this
study, we evaluate the capability of general LLMs, specifically GPT-3.5 and
GPT-4, to identify and correct medical errors with multiple prompting
strategies. Recognising the limitation of LLMs in generating accurate
corrections only via prompting strategies, we propose incorporating error-span
predictions from a smaller, fine-tuned model in two ways: 1) by presenting it
as a hint in the prompt and 2) by framing it as multiple-choice questions from
which the LLM can choose the best correction. We found that our proposed
prompting strategies significantly improve the LLM's ability to generate
corrections. Our best-performing solution with 8-shot + CoT + hints ranked
sixth in the shared task leaderboard. Additionally, our comprehensive analyses
show the impact of the location of the error sentence, the prompted role, and
the position of the multiple-choice option on the accuracy of the LLM. This
prompts further questions about the readiness of LLM to be implemented in
real-world clinical settings.
|
[
0.04598420485854149,
-0.5545558929443359,
1.0692278146743774,
0.32249847054481506,
-0.2027338445186615,
-0.10332607477903366,
-0.2751755118370056,
-0.3355364203453064,
0.2750418186187744,
0.39389434456825256,
-0.7462343573570251,
-0.5086556673049927,
-0.7551843523979187,
0.6425991058349609,
-0.1080782413482666,
0.9172099232673645,
-0.2860857844352722,
0.6324396729469299,
-0.039171382784843445,
-0.13220472633838654,
-0.9408379197120667,
-0.5117484927177429,
-0.9771462678909302,
-0.13559290766716003,
0.984628438949585,
0.6625615358352661,
0.5454921722412109,
0.41070908308029175,
0.8328660130500793,
0.13130681216716766,
-0.1155153214931488,
0.4397071599960327,
-0.15302082896232605,
0.05939609557390213,
-0.03848288580775261,
-0.6347406506538391,
-0.7835860848426819,
-0.12721268832683563,
0.3657319247722626,
0.5765372514724731,
-0.3490397334098816,
0.030806954950094223,
-0.01538207195699215,
0.5818609595298767,
-0.3170534372329712,
0.10646939277648926,
-0.4228299856185913,
0.04449763149023056,
-0.21010605990886688,
-0.5244879722595215,
-0.5001564025878906,
-0.14749325811862946,
-0.03503336384892464,
-0.5323978066444397,
0.23086456954479218,
0.3218635618686676,
0.5835490226745605,
0.4649975299835205,
-0.21736927330493927,
-0.7143036127090454,
-0.5137426257133484,
0.742803156375885,
-0.7435816526412964,
-0.0037439214065670967,
0.439252108335495,
0.3764277994632721,
-0.39528748393058777,
-0.7568399906158447,
-0.3672545254230499,
-0.07161112129688263,
-0.11051976680755615,
0.1806781142950058,
0.020865164697170258,
0.38008514046669006,
0.3938893973827362,
0.05364124849438667,
-0.3728020191192627,
0.23498985171318054,
-0.4940023720264435,
-0.23334172368049622,
0.5021635293960571,
0.23478934168815613,
0.27694541215896606,
-0.008409394882619381,
-0.09963437914848328,
-0.02527669258415699,
-0.9315739870071411,
-0.18519392609596252,
-0.05911645665764809,
0.3989033102989197,
-0.29468950629234314,
0.5726889967918396,
0.16677312552928925,
0.6023993492126465,
0.2048591524362564,
-0.11935961991548538,
0.09232736378908157,
-0.36308416724205017,
-0.017174918204545975,
0.05949826538562775,
0.9193475842475891,
0.595485508441925,
0.27314844727516174,
0.1310286670923233,
-0.15267282724380493,
-0.001427668146789074,
0.21051397919654846,
-0.28160804510116577,
-0.3767416477203369,
0.5464051365852356,
-0.2043209671974182,
-0.1513776332139969,
-0.4551610052585602,
-0.6812163591384888,
-0.36770099401474,
-0.14503785967826843,
0.48421013355255127,
-0.34306636452674866,
0.21259291470050812,
0.482626348733902,
-0.12902817130088806,
-0.07170368731021881,
0.7645518779754639,
-0.9962934255599976,
0.12921741604804993,
0.5455858707427979,
0.7478753328323364,
-0.03392326831817627,
-0.11229409277439117,
-0.7774276733398438,
0.22554771602153778,
-0.3227492868900299,
0.7733680009841919,
-0.30387353897094727,
-0.2714391350746155,
-0.04010599106550217,
-0.09624539315700531,
-0.25307488441467285,
-0.4995988607406616,
0.8089625239372253,
-0.17886188626289368,
0.5387721657752991,
-0.5691593885421753,
-0.4469529688358307,
-0.017838221043348312,
0.3938967287540436,
-0.7752673029899597,
0.7802247405052185,
0.011318297125399113,
-0.7549760341644287,
0.4685516655445099,
-1.091247320175171,
-0.15443100035190582,
0.16418027877807617,
-0.37462109327316284,
-0.5966641306877136,
-0.04465494304895401,
0.8647286891937256,
0.6540746092796326,
-0.23142707347869873,
0.5920940637588501,
-0.06841849535703659,
-0.17795704305171967,
0.07442120462656021,
-0.411869615316391,
0.5846176743507385,
-0.13131795823574066,
-0.363235205411911,
0.17761261761188507,
-0.6048250198364258,
-0.03107987903058529,
0.12764811515808105,
-0.3739495575428009,
-0.004296137485653162,
-0.20647424459457397,
-0.22293543815612793,
0.16820375621318817,
-0.0696641057729721,
-0.224500834941864,
0.4388531446456909,
-0.07403864711523056,
0.4780900776386261,
0.5280698537826538,
0.22440335154533386,
0.04404621198773384,
-0.6853228211402893,
0.9076667428016663,
-0.11830723285675049,
0.3103221356868744,
-0.2308620810508728,
-0.8715465664863586,
-0.46503305435180664,
-0.4408673644065857,
0.39048272371292114,
0.5691432356834412,
-0.6948493719100952,
0.15496398508548737,
0.031987983733415604,
-0.20436887443065643,
-0.8237372636795044,
-0.02374660037457943,
0.4116213321685791,
0.5724050402641296,
0.6535545587539673,
-0.09491484612226486,
-0.8885047435760498,
-0.5691863298416138,
-0.3585245907306671,
-0.1920478641986847,
0.09307858347892761,
0.2944459617137909,
0.6536382436752319,
-0.3575013279914856,
0.6675968766212463,
-0.11620310693979263,
-0.26019391417503357,
-0.4368315041065216,
0.1531498283147812,
0.2843701243400574,
0.3710857927799225,
0.19670867919921875,
-0.6225302815437317,
-0.37563249468803406,
-0.258611261844635,
-0.5691602230072021,
-0.357867032289505,
-0.20179979503154755,
0.24031801521778107,
0.09255468100309372,
0.44741329550743103,
-0.5384318232536316,
0.2339661419391632,
0.7349650859832764,
-0.16337113082408905,
0.6702702045440674,
-0.43326336145401,
0.247486412525177,
-0.9779789447784424,
-0.06511414796113968,
-0.30653345584869385,
-0.1660216897726059,
-0.6069108843803406,
-0.14638131856918335,
0.10615438222885132,
0.14563803374767303,
-0.17519395053386688,
0.6463735103607178,
-0.5473575592041016,
0.4079115688800812,
0.19920730590820312,
0.05008518323302269,
0.06233841925859451,
0.2501094937324524,
-0.07359600067138672,
0.6428195238113403,
0.4192761778831482,
-0.3841035068035126,
0.19887948036193848,
0.3131691813468933,
0.049993887543678284,
0.5615354180335999,
-0.4948469400405884,
0.2654363512992859,
-0.10853078961372375,
0.4124724268913269,
-1.0935307741165161,
-0.6407600045204163,
0.3491000533103943,
-0.45839911699295044,
0.4228571355342865,
-0.12376327067613602,
-0.3201431632041931,
-0.6249822378158569,
-0.16971933841705322,
0.4069535434246063,
0.1288681924343109,
-0.43113693594932556,
0.4924736022949219,
0.037202563136816025,
-0.50041663646698,
-0.8503303527832031,
-0.5585660934448242,
0.32672613859176636,
-0.2128114104270935,
-0.5814111828804016,
0.16588157415390015,
-0.22256191074848175,
-0.14990346133708954,
-0.29789578914642334,
0.2025650590658188,
0.2636165916919708,
-0.01752948947250843,
0.3140593469142914,
0.3265024721622467,
-0.12808144092559814,
0.19729667901992798,
0.021675918251276016,
-0.08499455451965332,
0.11647988855838776,
-0.010389648377895355,
0.6074661612510681,
-0.032607756555080414,
-0.5595086216926575,
-0.5993436574935913,
0.29582247138023376,
0.4473702609539032,
-0.04088348150253296,
0.43012499809265137,
0.4465612769126892,
-0.24689535796642303,
0.0525982566177845,
-0.653187096118927,
-0.3085353970527649,
-0.411603718996048,
0.22878216207027435,
-0.0422389879822731,
-0.9213319420814514,
0.597597599029541,
-0.006461705546826124,
-0.04646773263812065,
0.43492591381073,
0.6013100147247314,
-0.34096813201904297,
1.1330195665359497,
0.4825665354728699,
0.07092799991369247,
-0.09509894996881485,
-0.1710263341665268,
0.2240539789199829,
-0.9544666409492493,
-0.31276771426200867,
-0.613797128200531,
-0.15242178738117218,
-0.3319356441497803,
-0.7162128686904907,
0.8259795904159546,
-0.02302689477801323,
0.05806291848421097,
-0.08367089182138443,
-0.4357309639453888,
0.3427521884441376,
0.5849090814590454,
0.20270413160324097,
0.23556111752986908,
-0.184507355093956,
-0.5016416907310486,
-0.07137463986873627,
-1.1231038570404053,
-0.4128662347793579,
1.1369670629501343,
0.4998065233230591,
0.6479707360267639,
-0.06379080563783646,
0.9069066643714905,
-0.03573571518063545,
0.41077765822410583,
-0.7097921967506409,
0.3787478506565094,
0.1519952118396759,
-0.6376181840896606,
-0.3665006458759308,
-0.27648672461509705,
-0.8722057342529297,
-0.16524410247802734,
-0.18109308183193207,
-0.4665021002292633,
-0.1935780793428421,
0.3746304512023926,
-0.8151198625564575,
0.20576730370521545,
-0.6560921669006348,
0.7950071096420288,
-0.26826635003089905,
-0.08782779425382614,
0.11646843701601028,
-0.8986555933952332,
0.2246708869934082,
-0.04896707087755203,
0.39557066559791565,
0.014269351959228516,
-0.18176761269569397,
0.67137610912323,
-0.22823172807693481,
0.8975212574005127,
-0.17388483881950378,
-0.1934853345155716,
0.11900965124368668,
-0.13837142288684845,
0.7773115634918213,
-0.16511625051498413,
-0.017973849549889565,
-0.08727430552244186,
0.06324802339076996,
-0.2765716016292572,
-0.44570910930633545,
0.09163446724414825,
-0.4064044952392578,
-0.6082717776298523,
-0.44816359877586365,
-0.772463321685791,
-0.3243683874607086,
0.008719140663743019,
0.48971256613731384,
0.8431697487831116,
0.014253166504204273,
-0.11764619499444962,
0.34192681312561035,
-0.4209893047809601,
0.29541727900505066,
0.47812026739120483,
-0.1362055391073227,
-0.416798859834671,
0.27332377433776855,
-0.02702883444726467,
0.4796202480792999,
0.37337392568588257,
0.4478014409542084,
-0.5124461054801941,
-1.0659847259521484,
-0.4735565483570099,
0.5996279120445251,
-0.7882832288742065,
-0.1468612551689148,
-0.5988930463790894,
0.015359273180365562,
-0.3895799219608307,
-0.29718318581581116,
0.029089678078889847,
-0.2738339304924011,
-0.2520848214626312,
-0.13268797099590302,
0.5609182119369507,
1.0453219413757324,
-0.20216186344623566,
0.3921540379524231,
-1.0316113233566284,
0.014550021849572659,
-0.020690519362688065,
0.1729777306318283,
-0.29495298862457275,
-0.4717845916748047,
-0.13654887676239014,
-0.12081205099821091,
-0.04798638075590134,
-0.7889654040336609,
0.3601610064506531,
-0.0024546394124627113,
0.3762855529785156,
0.18765053153038025,
-0.09062732756137848,
0.8517835736274719,
-0.7797901034355164,
0.9256340861320496,
0.4229303002357483,
-0.5734893083572388,
0.632703423500061,
-0.7503788471221924,
0.3698638379573822,
0.6264165639877319,
0.49960634112358093,
-0.7541761994361877,
-0.7417510747909546,
-0.7707082629203796,
-0.5482863187789917,
0.4671212434768677,
-0.26321089267730713,
-0.2752791941165924,
-0.15837717056274414,
0.513900637626648,
-0.09465730935335159,
0.09016209095716476,
-0.6571611762046814,
-0.12606771290302277,
0.5080567002296448,
-0.6232312917709351,
0.1216808632016182,
-0.502578854560852,
-0.5328059792518616,
-0.09108732640743256,
0.5449662208557129,
-0.43538591265678406,
0.41862910985946655,
0.5417165160179138,
0.18841804563999176,
-0.38814276456832886,
0.5077514052391052,
0.9739850759506226,
0.9291672706604004,
-0.36871761083602905,
-0.03177913650870323,
0.2716864049434662,
-0.6330666542053223,
0.05540340021252632,
0.06435775011777878,
0.008219766430556774,
0.15022900700569153,
0.5979538559913635,
0.5845844745635986,
0.13569031655788422,
-0.7390583753585815,
0.5892325043678284,
-0.29713454842567444,
-0.3027482032775879,
-0.294511079788208,
-0.10161072015762329,
-0.004905028268694878,
0.0947985053062439,
0.29398226737976074,
0.2609223425388336,
0.07709892839193344,
-0.3605387508869171,
0.22846278548240662,
0.37604737281799316,
-0.40147119760513306,
-0.3146272897720337,
0.6686664819717407,
0.05622890591621399,
-0.31570297479629517,
0.16603893041610718,
-0.2830089330673218,
-0.663252592086792,
0.40601056814193726,
0.5234718322753906,
0.5960752367973328,
-0.3047482967376709,
0.21886977553367615,
0.3923443853855133,
0.27572834491729736,
-0.45162391662597656,
0.554399311542511,
0.4487142562866211,
-0.6025804281234741,
-0.9368928670883179,
-0.16818827390670776,
-0.7408195734024048,
0.24644702672958374,
-0.6516032218933105,
0.5250667333602905,
-0.5300906896591187,
-0.09086472541093826,
0.04366879165172577,
-0.08970948308706284,
-0.4617196321487427,
0.2344464212656021,
-0.009999735280871391,
0.9687971472740173,
-0.5320002436637878,
0.5889286994934082,
0.5621500015258789,
-0.1812603920698166,
-1.5482548475265503,
-0.18387211859226227,
0.42292895913124084,
-1.0316301584243774,
0.4104902148246765,
0.07203331589698792,
-0.029346389696002007,
-0.31230559945106506,
-0.7247674465179443,
-0.695435643196106,
1.020998239517212,
0.13439050316810608,
-0.9757893681526184,
-0.45221075415611267,
0.13328920304775238,
0.49332135915756226,
-0.1888907104730606,
0.4154078960418701,
0.45764195919036865,
0.45950308442115784,
0.3006720542907715,
-1.3291198015213013,
0.10892091691493988,
0.05802706256508827,
-0.6280086040496826,
0.28769397735595703,
-0.3366817831993103,
0.6800324320793152,
-0.7815359830856323,
-0.04629173129796982,
0.4063166379928589,
0.16233672201633453,
0.4312569200992584,
0.4090999662876129,
0.3098485469818115,
0.5770621299743652,
1.19668710231781,
-0.11763710528612137,
1.1709178686141968,
-0.10940927267074585,
0.1464674472808838,
1.142364263534546,
-0.35445094108581543,
0.8371270298957825,
0.6236545443534851,
-0.09917942434549332,
0.4317878186702728,
0.35333487391471863,
0.18540292978286743,
0.2877373993396759,
0.0440170057117939,
-0.19495758414268494,
0.1250951588153839,
0.01919359341263771,
-0.33549773693084717,
0.2132045030593872,
0.7308245301246643,
-0.3037859797477722,
-0.11254891753196716,
-0.0672491192817688,
0.2982628643512726,
-0.05598991736769676,
-0.509981095790863,
0.6646788120269775,
0.21799057722091675,
-1.0605359077453613,
0.6448349356651306,
-0.18496622145175934,
0.6047182083129883,
-0.6299804449081421,
-0.1592840999364853,
-0.06340301781892776,
0.3124217987060547,
-0.22857514023780823,
-0.6031656861305237,
0.08460069447755814,
-0.027554214000701904,
-0.09670250117778778,
-0.2769916355609894,
0.5455758571624756,
-0.663007915019989,
-0.3289640247821808,
0.08663411438465118,
0.3368062674999237,
0.05112830549478531,
0.09592633694410324,
-0.8246198296546936,
0.05979257822036743,
0.07259167730808258,
0.2767511308193207,
0.1212298721075058,
0.6120181083679199,
-0.09509681165218353,
0.7102189660072327,
0.5308788418769836,
0.5008859038352966,
0.06617908924818039,
0.28674957156181335,
0.5449312329292297,
-0.7347692847251892,
-0.3709220886230469,
-0.8057945370674133,
0.506885826587677,
0.09160888195037842,
-0.31652820110321045,
0.6855908632278442,
0.13938096165657043,
0.4397791624069214,
-0.03546076640486717,
0.7015264630317688,
0.15653006732463837,
0.9705770015716553,
-0.8900367021560669,
0.25429341197013855,
-0.2942656874656677,
0.38777679204940796,
-0.19801320135593414,
-0.3114956021308899,
-0.7726070880889893,
0.34751173853874207,
-0.49785885214805603,
-0.041792940348386765,
1.000241756439209,
1.0825061798095703,
0.35427314043045044,
0.18467046320438385,
0.13166473805904388,
0.28042420744895935,
0.4356531500816345,
0.7788960337638855,
0.9690292477607727,
-0.439927339553833,
0.32477009296417236,
0.13513924181461334,
-0.0703854039311409,
-0.35584932565689087,
-1.0307425260543823,
-0.787382185459137,
-0.29529064893722534,
-0.30855289101600647,
-0.5817835330963135,
0.26338985562324524,
1.2601698637008667,
0.5289231538772583,
-0.7944269180297852,
0.12551213800907135,
-0.013180169276893139,
-0.025774382054805756,
-0.2407941073179245,
-0.0892685130238533,
0.5219619870185852,
-0.35856661200523376,
-0.42817655205726624,
0.4359906315803528,
0.44463664293289185,
0.06880650669336319,
0.026447966694831848,
-0.22839690744876862,
-0.28498855233192444,
-0.1701652705669403,
0.1949571967124939,
0.08681662380695343,
-0.695319652557373,
-0.3863474726676941,
0.12228045612573624,
-0.1945660412311554,
0.2785816192626953,
0.8686740398406982,
-0.3540807068347931,
0.38562607765197754,
0.24599656462669373,
0.48587408661842346,
0.06684399396181107,
-0.1577301174402237,
0.8210147023200989,
-0.7831000685691833,
-0.10083287209272385,
0.6578134298324585,
0.5343966484069824,
0.5021632313728333,
-0.30429384112358093,
0.5651620626449585,
0.13818277418613434,
-0.761040985584259,
-0.7190393209457397,
-0.1303330659866333,
-0.9754533171653748,
0.0871204361319542,
1.2611498832702637,
-0.1305478811264038,
-0.20234398543834686,
-0.350403755903244,
-0.603425920009613,
-0.11968360841274261,
-0.29611849784851074,
0.6515803337097168,
0.8241560459136963,
-0.15270906686782837,
-0.313613623380661,
-0.7496839165687561,
0.9867056012153625,
0.6656855344772339,
-0.6815998554229736,
-0.1806478351354599,
0.3822651207447052,
0.21524444222450256,
0.22126376628875732,
1.0735057592391968,
-0.2649933397769928,
0.5997121930122375,
-0.34023094177246094,
-0.1624297797679901,
0.14527897536754608,
-0.5159428119659424,
-0.6760076880455017,
-0.11529946327209473,
0.3033841848373413,
0.06842261552810669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18027v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18027v1
|
TimeChara: Evaluating Point-in-Time Character Hallucination of Role-Playing Large Language Models
| 2024-05-28T10:19:18 | 2024-05-28T10:19:18 |
Jaewoo Ahn, Taehyun Lee, Junyoung Lim, Jin-Hwa Kim, Sangdoo Yun, Hwaran Lee, Gunhee Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While Large Language Models (LLMs) can serve as agents to simulate human
behaviors (i.e., role-playing agents), we emphasize the importance of
point-in-time role-playing. This situates characters at specific moments in the
narrative progression for three main reasons: (i) enhancing users' narrative
immersion, (ii) avoiding spoilers, and (iii) fostering engagement in fandom
role-playing. To accurately represent characters at specific time points,
agents must avoid character hallucination, where they display knowledge that
contradicts their characters' identities and historical timelines. We introduce
TimeChara, a new benchmark designed to evaluate point-in-time character
hallucination in role-playing LLMs. Comprising 10,895 instances generated
through an automated pipeline, this benchmark reveals significant hallucination
issues in current state-of-the-art LLMs (e.g., GPT-4o). To counter this
challenge, we propose Narrative-Experts, a method that decomposes the reasoning
steps and utilizes narrative experts to reduce point-in-time character
hallucinations effectively. Still, our findings with TimeChara highlight the
ongoing challenges of point-in-time character hallucination, calling for
further study.
|
[
-0.16635090112686157,
-0.7366418838500977,
0.8187582492828369,
0.433496356010437,
-0.2115374505519867,
0.4144510328769684,
0.15468762814998627,
-0.742559552192688,
0.3411540389060974,
0.5781735777854919,
-0.5232760310173035,
-0.4745630621910095,
-0.382355660200119,
0.2030186653137207,
-0.37235143780708313,
0.4797150194644928,
-0.23008668422698975,
-0.15128421783447266,
0.0803506076335907,
0.12327373772859573,
-0.6455353498458862,
-0.8477044105529785,
-0.7209123373031616,
-0.3812541961669922,
0.6718133687973022,
0.0460997112095356,
0.6866750717163086,
0.44296881556510925,
0.2609647810459137,
0.2698477804660797,
0.25048646330833435,
0.36154791712760925,
-0.5485352277755737,
0.6549703478813171,
0.014616573229432106,
-0.4333963394165039,
-0.578809380531311,
-0.1447049379348755,
0.43613314628601074,
0.5829407572746277,
-0.09877624362707138,
-0.09443904459476471,
-0.1443638652563095,
0.3993367552757263,
-0.4708069860935211,
0.2931017279624939,
-0.35762321949005127,
0.39369264245033264,
-0.17957179248332977,
-0.7032964825630188,
-0.38917505741119385,
-0.6914464235305786,
-0.018598992377519608,
-0.6946260929107666,
0.45751652121543884,
0.0985381230711937,
0.7362999320030212,
0.39453092217445374,
-0.3219940960407257,
-0.20508700609207153,
-0.994925320148468,
0.578451931476593,
-0.6046363115310669,
0.11825854331254959,
0.5400847792625427,
0.6274870038032532,
-0.159731924533844,
-0.2425350844860077,
-0.623410701751709,
-0.3527345359325409,
0.11831124126911163,
-0.14022114872932434,
-0.17103952169418335,
-0.09879137575626373,
0.6202583312988281,
0.02967683970928192,
-0.45567381381988525,
0.16140812635421753,
-0.15321950614452362,
-0.23167772591114044,
0.5506746768951416,
0.4988155961036682,
0.38486436009407043,
-0.14421294629573822,
-0.14269089698791504,
-0.07296578586101532,
-0.7085418105125427,
-0.07243520021438599,
0.45006510615348816,
-0.03022317960858345,
0.3670515716075897,
0.6219541430473328,
0.06880797445774078,
0.02107010968029499,
0.09426213800907135,
-0.033107172697782516,
0.172246515750885,
-0.018861686810851097,
-0.03092930093407631,
0.46548140048980713,
0.5191113948822021,
0.6347959041595459,
0.44455426931381226,
-0.3181140422821045,
0.025798847898840904,
0.3357135057449341,
0.46384283900260925,
-0.9177103638648987,
-0.019764479249715805,
0.31463658809661865,
-0.3670818507671356,
-0.28883716464042664,
-0.1647704541683197,
-0.9206252694129944,
-0.9241846799850464,
0.09495905786752701,
0.3234041631221771,
-0.583086371421814,
-0.22528086602687836,
-0.08331439644098282,
-0.20134754478931427,
0.39156225323677063,
0.4062660038471222,
-0.7567144632339478,
0.3649742007255554,
0.6851637959480286,
0.9679734706878662,
-0.36392703652381897,
-0.6858406662940979,
-0.720300555229187,
0.45245522260665894,
-0.7361904382705688,
0.7819346785545349,
-0.6448014378547668,
-0.6376655697822571,
-0.10897503048181534,
0.09401659667491913,
0.027332579717040062,
-0.4558572769165039,
0.4635942876338959,
-0.3508976995944977,
-0.15875603258609772,
-0.4514889419078827,
-0.44411805272102356,
-0.11465144902467728,
0.10267297178506851,
-0.7588265538215637,
0.821225643157959,
0.08493603765964508,
-0.1859700232744217,
0.5475961565971375,
-0.5702916979789734,
-0.42550963163375854,
0.17025820910930634,
-0.17317156493663788,
-0.20967024564743042,
0.2970808148384094,
0.4072607159614563,
0.5091437101364136,
-0.13039298355579376,
0.25892433524131775,
-0.21637529134750366,
-0.7577964663505554,
0.4043852388858795,
-0.35901346802711487,
0.4171958863735199,
0.22045360505580902,
-0.4492397904396057,
0.02140096016228199,
-0.19366616010665894,
-0.24303728342056274,
0.14204861223697662,
0.21044139564037323,
-0.41897496581077576,
0.30109620094299316,
-0.12164824455976486,
0.12021418660879135,
-0.04376467317342758,
-0.3882107138633728,
0.2637106776237488,
-0.3079054355621338,
0.44223475456237793,
0.6412143111228943,
0.303337961435318,
0.06011774763464928,
-0.581122636795044,
0.7701103091239929,
-0.07750940322875977,
0.21626585721969604,
-0.4039227366447449,
-0.3944399654865265,
-0.5897983908653259,
0.021430131047964096,
-0.23424364626407623,
0.2813529670238495,
-0.7257266044616699,
0.385556697845459,
-0.0048301019705832005,
-0.6585627794265747,
-0.3867988586425781,
-0.38844501972198486,
0.23107339441776276,
0.5145895481109619,
0.4989112317562103,
-0.28141239285469055,
-0.31432831287384033,
-0.5614810585975647,
-0.36351263523101807,
-0.4822673201560974,
-0.20146533846855164,
0.13341231644153595,
0.37332883477211,
-0.20670562982559204,
0.7846150994300842,
-0.37488555908203125,
-0.28646814823150635,
-0.2655172348022461,
0.29273974895477295,
-0.20990081131458282,
0.2114095836877823,
0.5343765020370483,
-0.4732262194156647,
-0.1974417120218277,
-0.1342177540063858,
-0.9516620635986328,
-0.2602158784866333,
-0.24058572947978973,
0.294603556394577,
0.5428902506828308,
0.5744319558143616,
-0.7529875636100769,
0.6980162262916565,
0.39978712797164917,
-0.7289196848869324,
0.8184228539466858,
-0.3172157406806946,
0.8496711850166321,
-0.8646520972251892,
0.267072856426239,
-0.24878619611263275,
-0.07597851753234863,
-0.5305536389350891,
-0.11047728359699249,
-0.27190473675727844,
-0.35376957058906555,
-0.09045284986495972,
0.7289321422576904,
-0.45462995767593384,
-0.4055615961551666,
-0.10098613053560257,
0.32823726534843445,
0.0761042982339859,
0.49061107635498047,
0.061686888337135315,
0.6903412342071533,
0.032490942627191544,
-0.5766992568969727,
0.2085145264863968,
-0.020991692319512367,
-0.5796534419059753,
0.5275344252586365,
-0.6996103525161743,
0.31982070207595825,
0.09740026295185089,
0.39273786544799805,
-0.9707626700401306,
-0.28170958161354065,
0.3193261921405792,
-0.34519240260124207,
0.017553534358739853,
-0.030254440382122993,
-0.5958583950996399,
-0.2365264892578125,
-0.2071698009967804,
0.6551618576049805,
0.35935068130493164,
-0.2473033219575882,
0.7571784853935242,
0.4416373670101166,
-0.19543133676052094,
-0.5392397046089172,
-0.4725903868675232,
0.2922707498073578,
-0.4629499912261963,
-0.3903404772281647,
0.5880655646324158,
-0.36373651027679443,
-0.41319477558135986,
-0.27454090118408203,
-0.19807635247707367,
-0.022877095267176628,
0.14854267239570618,
0.3586157560348511,
0.007505129091441631,
0.05537719279527664,
0.026665879413485527,
0.312946617603302,
-0.24683016538619995,
0.12949244678020477,
0.25412517786026,
0.8222752809524536,
0.03698374330997467,
-0.6814272403717041,
-0.48093584179878235,
0.5211498737335205,
0.5183973908424377,
-0.022826140746474266,
0.20885737240314484,
0.3345727324485779,
-0.5452168583869934,
-0.16928446292877197,
-0.8202467560768127,
-0.18636655807495117,
-0.3960706293582916,
0.36482110619544983,
-0.3322094976902008,
-0.7442585229873657,
0.7782476544380188,
0.07745669037103653,
0.0969139114022255,
0.3567230701446533,
0.36823543906211853,
-0.08706345409154892,
1.0506428480148315,
0.35302597284317017,
-0.02222117967903614,
0.26408857107162476,
0.07719659805297852,
0.23671281337738037,
-0.31491097807884216,
-0.40300726890563965,
-0.5562705993652344,
-0.4638495147228241,
-0.34943851828575134,
-0.660895049571991,
0.22761230170726776,
-0.03313444182276726,
-0.16089755296707153,
0.21524757146835327,
-0.1861972212791443,
0.739762544631958,
0.04198573902249336,
-0.057841479778289795,
0.5214654803276062,
-0.02771628461778164,
0.2025938332080841,
-0.2194286435842514,
-0.28961873054504395,
-0.5030066967010498,
0.6060068011283875,
0.572628915309906,
0.7320781350135803,
0.1376177966594696,
0.6740363836288452,
0.7153205275535583,
-0.22776906192302704,
-0.8260853290557861,
0.6852450966835022,
0.12215925753116608,
-0.5128307938575745,
-0.6422411203384399,
-0.3651619851589203,
-0.9463058710098267,
0.0018047868506982923,
0.08072122931480408,
-0.8940703868865967,
0.3048516511917114,
-0.04083769768476486,
-0.5506441593170166,
0.3096829056739807,
-0.5812891125679016,
0.6724231243133545,
-0.12307875603437424,
-0.21167488396167755,
-0.5847127437591553,
-0.5241115093231201,
0.09307917207479477,
-0.041094690561294556,
-0.14759254455566406,
-0.2604069113731384,
-0.14082291722297668,
0.7201562523841858,
-0.5715508460998535,
0.9979369044303894,
-0.3833325207233429,
-0.1304604411125183,
0.19868674874305725,
0.8568001985549927,
0.4624253213405609,
-0.10436318069696426,
0.01905101165175438,
0.4616791307926178,
0.2640095353126526,
-0.23182739317417145,
-0.5913563370704651,
0.7872082591056824,
-0.7002279162406921,
-0.46815767884254456,
-0.6977855563163757,
-0.6862200498580933,
-0.32469871640205383,
0.015274533070623875,
0.13503295183181763,
0.561942994594574,
-0.6056473851203918,
-0.022505616769194603,
0.6776372790336609,
-0.26707351207733154,
0.6667384505271912,
0.3766099810600281,
-0.5075838565826416,
-0.027244731783866882,
0.8373790979385376,
0.17759421467781067,
-0.0813894271850586,
0.4318496882915497,
0.11430362612009048,
-0.33985254168510437,
-0.557771623134613,
-0.08158113062381744,
0.36530423164367676,
-0.6390380263328552,
0.05987613648176193,
-0.7281365394592285,
-0.2146679311990738,
-0.15456648170948029,
-0.31434640288352966,
-0.30749788880348206,
-0.3855544328689575,
-0.22324614226818085,
-0.07503285259008408,
0.20072396099567413,
0.8939638733863831,
0.3338358998298645,
0.1957961469888687,
-0.6399654150009155,
0.26331692934036255,
0.12362243980169296,
0.377310574054718,
0.12071612477302551,
-0.3759075701236725,
-0.041050177067518234,
-0.4374965727329254,
0.017065439373254776,
-0.8806105256080627,
0.5384100675582886,
-0.21909691393375397,
0.6501432061195374,
0.4661559462547302,
-0.012044087052345276,
0.8515850901603699,
-0.4425446391105652,
0.935646653175354,
-0.05690181627869606,
-1.0948429107666016,
0.22436769306659698,
-0.4320208728313446,
0.33746007084846497,
0.3858570456504822,
0.4554007053375244,
-1.065711259841919,
-0.41087645292282104,
-0.36247703433036804,
-0.5482380390167236,
0.5695781111717224,
0.203217014670372,
-0.14114269614219666,
-0.03395205736160278,
0.1567600667476654,
0.5814974308013916,
0.17138271033763885,
-0.3426385223865509,
0.08650937676429749,
-0.3005821406841278,
0.18218226730823517,
-0.43555691838264465,
-0.5773860216140747,
0.06777676939964294,
-0.02277509868144989,
0.29636597633361816,
-0.03316650539636612,
0.40742602944374084,
0.17956453561782837,
-0.3382503092288971,
-0.44656336307525635,
0.12842239439487457,
0.6830229163169861,
1.1548875570297241,
-0.36064136028289795,
-0.09641969203948975,
0.08987385779619217,
-0.5578261613845825,
0.044821400195360184,
0.10591521114110947,
0.016032330691814423,
0.09490661323070526,
0.5821110010147095,
0.6661611199378967,
0.39431801438331604,
-0.5864431262016296,
0.3017125129699707,
-0.17192062735557556,
-0.06382054090499878,
-0.4644516110420227,
0.04530898109078407,
-0.25111496448516846,
0.5716418027877808,
0.5920960903167725,
-0.19141855835914612,
-0.06969908624887466,
-0.6396982073783875,
0.10528494417667389,
-0.049979317933321,
-0.37368664145469666,
-0.4160767197608948,
0.6669013500213623,
0.16789807379245758,
-0.6118708848953247,
0.48273956775665283,
0.010654046200215816,
-0.2790429890155792,
0.5975877642631531,
0.4506310224533081,
1.2842392921447754,
-0.7174729704856873,
0.45069563388824463,
0.32755357027053833,
0.4082379639148712,
-0.13291947543621063,
0.24548205733299255,
0.15842513740062714,
-0.4884730875492096,
-0.45201072096824646,
-0.39264199137687683,
-0.4338846802711487,
0.09987195581197739,
-0.28498029708862305,
0.33043158054351807,
-0.5203243494033813,
-0.1525586098432541,
-0.3304770588874817,
0.12496516108512878,
-0.44846025109291077,
-0.36102738976478577,
0.029590124264359474,
0.6803498268127441,
-0.6325079202651978,
0.6782310009002686,
0.003477426478639245,
-0.4376201927661896,
-0.4987509846687317,
0.4496503472328186,
-0.043243687599897385,
-0.5771413445472717,
0.4176943898200989,
0.3103621304035187,
-0.37573564052581787,
-0.0643172413110733,
-0.29457828402519226,
-0.3203570246696472,
1.3755375146865845,
0.2150936871767044,
-0.7116425633430481,
-0.6645971536636353,
0.06588901579380035,
0.7664520144462585,
-0.5837510824203491,
0.3542255461215973,
0.6890489459037781,
0.23076172173023224,
0.10776546597480774,
-0.7705202102661133,
0.28151601552963257,
-0.22885172069072723,
-0.08145813643932343,
0.15604743361473083,
-0.5427449345588684,
0.6844649314880371,
-0.2671512961387634,
-0.29385626316070557,
0.09754467755556107,
0.6280261278152466,
0.5537980794906616,
0.6303685903549194,
0.7481765151023865,
0.03592963144183159,
1.0057114362716675,
-0.08017151802778244,
0.9782304763793945,
-0.035664018243551254,
-0.11935467272996902,
1.0159308910369873,
-0.5251998901367188,
0.5389649868011475,
0.5028569102287292,
0.08697963505983353,
0.5889225602149963,
0.6260762810707092,
-0.054843854159116745,
0.30608031153678894,
0.019175000488758087,
-0.03581200912594795,
-0.3700391948223114,
-0.16341464221477509,
-0.6529678106307983,
0.34951770305633545,
0.44094714522361755,
-0.05420564115047455,
-0.17150649428367615,
-0.15806329250335693,
0.16429723799228668,
0.024338703602552414,
-0.17538215219974518,
0.4505101144313812,
0.053468409925699234,
-0.7193669676780701,
0.25580722093582153,
-0.38653913140296936,
0.16605839133262634,
-0.9108332991600037,
-0.35260796546936035,
-0.551236093044281,
0.014194264076650143,
0.028567418456077576,
-0.6275331377983093,
0.10133359581232071,
0.1379021555185318,
0.02027158811688423,
-0.15818627178668976,
0.5712774395942688,
-0.29715269804000854,
-0.21918217837810516,
0.5148817896842957,
0.4482056200504303,
0.5129290223121643,
-0.2999454438686371,
-0.34924572706222534,
0.3167988657951355,
-0.33819034695625305,
-0.0717085599899292,
0.06070863828063011,
0.5795956254005432,
-0.360443651676178,
0.7190908193588257,
0.21649421751499176,
0.08521392196416855,
-0.3155096471309662,
0.47949063777923584,
0.642037570476532,
-1.0043607950210571,
-0.6352148056030273,
-0.9399217963218689,
0.2079816460609436,
-0.07041388005018234,
-0.40662071108818054,
0.840249240398407,
0.45137879252433777,
0.47674769163131714,
0.0775558277964592,
0.6257612705230713,
0.04756966233253479,
0.47624924778938293,
-0.5662871599197388,
0.9991763234138489,
-0.513692319393158,
0.34737080335617065,
-0.6859776377677917,
-1.1660466194152832,
-0.09490440785884857,
0.26986709237098694,
-0.2853160798549652,
0.2083427608013153,
1.0606359243392944,
0.7142918705940247,
0.2956390976905823,
0.09132429212331772,
0.512362539768219,
0.2963668406009674,
0.5246548056602478,
0.6382051706314087,
1.2576711177825928,
-0.08276837319135666,
0.5420205593109131,
-0.043985914438962936,
-0.10844680666923523,
-0.5353909134864807,
-0.9687208533287048,
-1.2414859533309937,
-0.7685586214065552,
-0.09938692301511765,
-0.3433331847190857,
0.14502134919166565,
0.9512438178062439,
0.23940512537956238,
-0.6865512132644653,
-0.5360012054443359,
0.3834006190299988,
-0.014430978335440159,
-0.6198270320892334,
-0.1506061553955078,
0.32094213366508484,
-0.14124596118927002,
-0.6476513743400574,
0.7166463732719421,
0.3169776201248169,
-0.09186460822820663,
-0.6890024542808533,
-0.17287728190422058,
0.060879215598106384,
0.12371165305376053,
0.6738099455833435,
0.3174911439418793,
-0.8425121903419495,
-0.34218254685401917,
0.23834215104579926,
-0.035297784954309464,
0.057280778884887695,
1.2303166389465332,
-0.6723645925521851,
0.588071346282959,
0.5493883490562439,
0.3857944905757904,
0.7075849175453186,
0.07959944754838943,
0.7509381175041199,
-0.4217466711997986,
-0.07588519155979156,
0.5106567144393921,
0.10949407517910004,
0.13947249948978424,
-0.3951666057109833,
0.573333203792572,
0.3364294469356537,
-0.684180498123169,
-0.9362264275550842,
0.053585704416036606,
-0.9553552269935608,
-0.37503641843795776,
0.9457640647888184,
0.15302646160125732,
-0.2710934281349182,
-0.39033228158950806,
-0.20503517985343933,
0.2939988374710083,
-0.6467846035957336,
1.2287623882293701,
0.9498998522758484,
-0.15657195448875427,
0.048494819551706314,
-0.5936760902404785,
0.742948055267334,
0.1383315622806549,
-0.8964521288871765,
0.45324793457984924,
0.6114362478256226,
-0.15093368291854858,
0.15703967213630676,
0.8041483759880066,
-0.19921477138996124,
0.1571177840232849,
-0.00817317608743906,
0.041434817016124725,
-0.21227069199085236,
-0.8021814227104187,
-0.2593759596347809,
0.22822540998458862,
-0.1118951365351677,
0.31694161891937256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18015v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18015v1
|
MultiADE: A Multi-domain Benchmark for Adverse Drug Event Extraction
| 2024-05-28T09:57:28 | 2024-05-28T09:57:28 |
Xiang Dai, Sarvnaz Karimi, Abeed Sarker, Ben Hachey, Cecile Paris
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Objective. Active adverse event surveillance monitors Adverse Drug Events
(ADE) from different data sources, such as electronic health records, medical
literature, social media and search engine logs. Over years, many datasets are
created, and shared tasks are organised to facilitate active adverse event
surveillance. However, most-if not all-datasets or shared tasks focus on
extracting ADEs from a particular type of text. Domain generalisation-the
ability of a machine learning model to perform well on new, unseen domains
(text types)-is under-explored. Given the rapid advancements in natural
language processing, one unanswered question is how far we are from having a
single ADE extraction model that are effective on various types of text, such
as scientific literature and social media posts}. Methods. We contribute to
answering this question by building a multi-domain benchmark for adverse drug
event extraction, which we named MultiADE. The new benchmark comprises several
existing datasets sampled from different text types and our newly created
dataset-CADECv2, which is an extension of CADEC (Karimi, et al., 2015),
covering online posts regarding more diverse drugs than CADEC. Our new dataset
is carefully annotated by human annotators following detailed annotation
guidelines. Conclusion. Our benchmark results show that the generalisation of
the trained models is far from perfect, making it infeasible to be deployed to
process different types of text. In addition, although intermediate transfer
learning is a promising approach to utilising existing resources, further
investigation is needed on methods of domain adaptation, particularly
cost-effective methods to select useful training instances.
|
[
-0.13245655596256256,
-0.6673325896263123,
0.3862754702568054,
0.1527101993560791,
-0.1064385324716568,
-0.08314725011587143,
-0.036858271807432175,
-0.6719068884849548,
0.1686566174030304,
0.4682581424713135,
-0.3464295268058777,
-0.8140348196029663,
-0.9392790794372559,
0.1766739934682846,
-0.33872321248054504,
1.0643563270568848,
-0.268875390291214,
-0.08384636044502258,
0.10625733435153961,
-0.5008723139762878,
-0.4253060519695282,
-0.7185064554214478,
-0.7076994776725769,
0.10727718472480774,
0.5746011137962341,
0.33589497208595276,
0.019523516297340393,
0.14903482794761658,
0.8427924513816833,
0.17391572892665863,
0.4311119318008423,
0.43325498700141907,
-0.13059492409229279,
0.15898218750953674,
-0.1884329617023468,
-0.06288275867700577,
-0.6735801696777344,
0.1489536613225937,
0.3376869261264801,
0.32809942960739136,
-0.1479998081922531,
0.16009844839572906,
-0.033514611423015594,
0.6507111191749573,
-1.0249816179275513,
0.06247813627123833,
-0.4693024754524231,
-0.17344558238983154,
-0.218345046043396,
0.08443611115217209,
-0.2887660264968872,
-0.27050134539604187,
0.4250651001930237,
-0.7752506732940674,
0.267673522233963,
-0.12681090831756592,
0.874484121799469,
-0.06728245317935944,
-1.0280972719192505,
-0.46675875782966614,
-0.5543622970581055,
0.6896437406539917,
-0.5000478029251099,
0.23914910852909088,
0.22226302325725555,
0.5219606161117554,
-0.029410894960165024,
-1.0678452253341675,
-0.5357641577720642,
0.40029680728912354,
0.015051045455038548,
-0.12545987963676453,
-0.18170557916164398,
-0.01089133508503437,
-0.0739598423242569,
0.03709816932678223,
-0.4071299731731415,
-0.039931684732437134,
-0.4878040850162506,
-0.3811255991458893,
0.6374840140342712,
0.0164753720164299,
0.3479165732860565,
-0.10181120038032532,
-0.6025275588035583,
0.10451198369264603,
-0.7925970554351807,
0.12318389862775803,
-0.0017476588254794478,
0.25209254026412964,
-0.17450204491615295,
0.37384024262428284,
0.1770850569009781,
0.34919214248657227,
-0.2611837387084961,
0.12487654387950897,
0.49452316761016846,
-0.6019736528396606,
-0.2206767350435257,
-0.0740804374217987,
0.9508501887321472,
0.43025556206703186,
0.2489112913608551,
-0.09185273945331573,
0.16104397177696228,
0.12857824563980103,
0.417908638715744,
-0.9392759799957275,
-0.4836333692073822,
0.4835512936115265,
-0.5804158449172974,
-0.18765825033187866,
0.03955451771616936,
-1.3433656692504883,
-0.5521577596664429,
-0.04247504100203514,
0.44043946266174316,
-0.3761484920978546,
-0.16995367407798767,
0.11912796646356583,
-0.05220533162355423,
0.10111414641141891,
0.34860923886299133,
-0.7530560493469238,
0.5456823706626892,
0.3955729305744171,
0.8417394161224365,
-0.7399934530258179,
-0.339870810508728,
-0.5886548161506653,
0.2127273827791214,
-0.22136832773685455,
1.250613808631897,
-0.38980913162231445,
-0.31136053800582886,
0.14792943000793457,
0.17388466000556946,
-0.5345796346664429,
-0.6327962875366211,
0.9211281538009644,
-0.48949846625328064,
0.1315724104642868,
-0.06793434172868729,
-0.48968032002449036,
-0.5134372115135193,
-0.04054267331957817,
-0.7081510424613953,
0.5296370387077332,
-0.11485575884580612,
-0.5460080504417419,
0.754805862903595,
-0.6540243625640869,
-0.5612626075744629,
-0.277569442987442,
-0.21315711736679077,
-0.841277539730072,
-0.05483338609337807,
0.4395740330219269,
0.4578305780887604,
-0.4514644742012024,
0.2754957973957062,
-0.4590633511543274,
-0.02104276232421398,
0.0378882996737957,
-0.4301111102104187,
0.5828236937522888,
0.2546018362045288,
-0.25734442472457886,
0.1438010036945343,
-0.9650403261184692,
-0.14736831188201904,
-0.045764777809381485,
-0.37082523107528687,
-0.510940670967102,
-0.19702698290348053,
0.43523159623146057,
0.5430548787117004,
-0.22139020264148712,
-0.6431906223297119,
0.3150360584259033,
-0.033431824296712875,
-0.13143642246723175,
0.7063897252082825,
0.6548945307731628,
0.1055850014090538,
-0.05448943376541138,
0.36672380566596985,
0.20459474623203278,
0.11571266502141953,
-0.04071073606610298,
-0.5939487218856812,
-0.18974904716014862,
-0.7257481813430786,
0.4078672230243683,
0.43239516019821167,
-0.5134532451629639,
0.20658068358898163,
-0.015043583698570728,
-0.017898233607411385,
-0.5222076177597046,
0.16498884558677673,
0.3506193161010742,
0.3306601643562317,
0.6529330611228943,
-0.386263370513916,
-0.5666706562042236,
-0.855155885219574,
-0.41501158475875854,
0.16150549054145813,
0.07048596441745758,
0.38260066509246826,
0.49450740218162537,
-0.47700774669647217,
0.46451520919799805,
-0.6478409767150879,
-0.7231435179710388,
-0.08947397768497467,
0.32913461327552795,
-0.16178959608078003,
0.2821531593799591,
0.6418562531471252,
-0.8618001341819763,
-0.7066277861595154,
-0.08445946127176285,
-1.1033960580825806,
-0.0409805104136467,
-0.15973198413848877,
-0.19682103395462036,
-0.018313728272914886,
0.29284214973449707,
-0.49602311849594116,
0.6040952801704407,
0.4675121605396271,
-0.3113551735877991,
0.42225030064582825,
-0.09141818434000015,
0.526316225528717,
-1.089969515800476,
0.13484399020671844,
0.4020463824272156,
0.08785276114940643,
-1.0126256942749023,
-0.33597874641418457,
0.4550723731517792,
-0.08931738883256912,
-0.6815110445022583,
0.5133818984031677,
-0.5059351921081543,
0.20042289793491364,
-0.15124039351940155,
-0.0742587298154831,
0.3178617060184479,
0.483335018157959,
0.047574713826179504,
0.7828128933906555,
0.8074751496315002,
-0.9078587293624878,
0.10756635665893555,
0.3385615050792694,
-0.24619975686073303,
0.49816766381263733,
-0.4408215284347534,
-0.09875726699829102,
-0.05847753584384918,
0.07816262543201447,
-0.890086829662323,
-0.2590124309062958,
0.12679676711559296,
-0.25778859853744507,
0.5127842426300049,
-0.38654088973999023,
0.04001551494002342,
-0.22239436209201813,
-0.4167453646659851,
0.34506937861442566,
0.18244622647762299,
-0.4648274779319763,
0.6218881607055664,
0.8654825091362,
-0.31332871317863464,
-0.7374469041824341,
-0.23320335149765015,
0.10287220031023026,
-0.4562906324863434,
-0.2949851155281067,
0.1689329892396927,
0.10405760258436203,
-0.24252952635288239,
-0.16128578782081604,
-0.11477039754390717,
-0.5200347900390625,
-0.13126006722450256,
0.13507957756519318,
0.4304110109806061,
-0.22109436988830566,
0.16790463030338287,
0.20138098299503326,
0.046091847121715546,
0.1508217304944992,
0.12079942226409912,
0.15953078866004944,
0.21852201223373413,
-0.3041772246360779,
-0.6971595883369446,
0.613472044467926,
0.663292407989502,
-0.25361454486846924,
0.7039820551872253,
0.2980307638645172,
-0.6541325449943542,
-0.09092060476541519,
-0.2866803705692291,
-0.09641414880752563,
-0.36748382449150085,
0.3690749406814575,
-0.41908296942710876,
-0.048272617161273956,
0.3869054317474365,
-0.44021961092948914,
0.2360169142484665,
0.6674871444702148,
0.4191014766693115,
0.10186188668012619,
0.7549573183059692,
0.5592269897460938,
0.14622892439365387,
0.24166499078273773,
-0.3427222967147827,
0.09016479551792145,
-0.9189478754997253,
-0.38481563329696655,
-0.3858075737953186,
0.11819925904273987,
-0.36264684796333313,
-0.30422690510749817,
0.27583393454551697,
-0.0821419209241867,
0.023486575111746788,
0.36710020899772644,
-0.18747226893901825,
0.049592673778533936,
0.19181323051452637,
0.07351035624742508,
0.2705848515033722,
0.12680980563163757,
0.07356805354356766,
-0.083899587392807,
-0.3279637396335602,
-0.5958152413368225,
1.8134562969207764,
0.2250901162624359,
0.4324217736721039,
0.3578112721443176,
0.5580427050590515,
0.6115943193435669,
0.4960115849971771,
-0.44321927428245544,
0.08914943039417267,
-0.33515655994415283,
-0.7053275108337402,
-0.036807507276535034,
-0.1967451274394989,
-1.187728762626648,
0.5218167901039124,
-0.4198589324951172,
-0.7428561449050903,
0.7362354397773743,
-0.23204293847084045,
-0.6616355180740356,
0.355051726102829,
-1.069524884223938,
0.9120994806289673,
0.046062469482421875,
-0.4295845329761505,
0.034846771508455276,
-0.5805784463882446,
0.38186734914779663,
-0.467151403427124,
0.6213634014129639,
-0.2787474989891052,
-0.09812773019075394,
0.898385763168335,
-0.21246188879013062,
0.6830238103866577,
-0.2103094756603241,
0.0758674368262291,
0.5419771671295166,
-0.18395966291427612,
0.3907422125339508,
0.2482338398694992,
0.12093295902013779,
0.35054096579551697,
-0.07341586798429489,
-0.5119874477386475,
-0.24570336937904358,
0.7664443850517273,
-0.868415117263794,
-0.20287463068962097,
-0.6204275488853455,
-0.06886006146669388,
-0.31149834394454956,
0.2172933965921402,
0.22679884731769562,
0.5897229313850403,
-0.3710974156856537,
-0.22871409356594086,
0.5503754615783691,
-0.3561980128288269,
0.34284400939941406,
0.6874006390571594,
0.28521957993507385,
-0.5865225195884705,
0.7625543475151062,
-0.016957290470600128,
0.018171336501836777,
0.2768835425376892,
-0.1100008562207222,
-0.3332922160625458,
-0.6938655376434326,
-0.6365801692008972,
0.08771492540836334,
-0.7136924266815186,
-0.3134356141090393,
-1.1942721605300903,
-0.03193676844239235,
-0.8730419874191284,
0.25945794582366943,
-0.5872857570648193,
-0.44947388768196106,
-0.30169185996055603,
-0.1768883466720581,
0.2891677916049957,
1.0124706029891968,
-0.10766662657260895,
0.13993434607982635,
-0.9079129695892334,
0.590495765209198,
0.3136543035507202,
0.3212036192417145,
-0.17348647117614746,
-0.3886376917362213,
-0.15310116112232208,
-0.12559877336025238,
-0.45225879549980164,
-0.9446042776107788,
0.4285551905632019,
0.4459169805049896,
0.7749791741371155,
0.5142548084259033,
0.04688780754804611,
0.4947282075881958,
-0.47218048572540283,
0.5471935868263245,
0.22030594944953918,
-0.4327538311481476,
0.5774643421173096,
-0.17104992270469666,
-0.3266519010066986,
0.8746294975280762,
0.7051342129707336,
-0.44651395082473755,
0.1067042201757431,
-0.3792110085487366,
-1.100380778312683,
0.5885952711105347,
0.3655211329460144,
-0.4823673963546753,
-0.08722065389156342,
0.2941795289516449,
0.5273741483688354,
0.14035941660404205,
-0.5047929883003235,
-0.6724375486373901,
0.09235409647226334,
-0.05131307989358902,
-0.17515408992767334,
-0.26434326171875,
-0.16561748087406158,
0.15108107030391693,
0.721662700176239,
0.031652141362428665,
0.2893476188182831,
0.28071877360343933,
-0.18840736150741577,
-0.018400467932224274,
0.3153820037841797,
0.34599876403808594,
0.5677863359451294,
-0.36771562695503235,
0.17735902965068817,
-0.1256682276725769,
-0.923815906047821,
0.281188040971756,
0.4389024078845978,
0.1269136518239975,
-0.13878445327281952,
0.4714794456958771,
0.4795728325843811,
-0.2311842441558838,
-0.6376449465751648,
0.7033088803291321,
-0.40571218729019165,
-0.13653060793876648,
-0.08992920070886612,
-0.22724279761314392,
-0.5482274293899536,
-0.0556827150285244,
0.6236875057220459,
0.4439001679420471,
0.5754831433296204,
-0.49995681643486023,
0.7474567294120789,
0.08004914969205856,
-0.5396614670753479,
-0.41631969809532166,
0.7216928005218506,
0.357718825340271,
-0.1353379189968109,
0.26295334100723267,
-0.04789149388670921,
-0.00628893356770277,
0.6852208375930786,
0.2451809048652649,
0.8906064033508301,
-0.18373419344425201,
0.14008763432502747,
0.5192241072654724,
-0.004678795579820871,
0.13156603276729584,
0.272895485162735,
0.5448540449142456,
-0.6391451358795166,
-0.3564990162849426,
-0.22016052901744843,
-0.13579736649990082,
0.2256913036108017,
-0.5755365490913391,
0.3936666250228882,
-0.07157666981220245,
-0.19400089979171753,
0.41109248995780945,
0.03557245060801506,
-0.6071853637695312,
0.22987034916877747,
-0.0719873309135437,
0.6290526986122131,
-1.2113741636276245,
0.7392951250076294,
0.7501605749130249,
-0.5290514826774597,
-0.36501598358154297,
0.06975297629833221,
0.27316153049468994,
-0.38609811663627625,
0.1692664623260498,
0.28057587146759033,
0.17945770919322968,
-0.4514331519603729,
-0.037032559514045715,
-0.7007734179496765,
0.9046125411987305,
-0.18102355301380157,
-0.3965865969657898,
0.018009118735790253,
-0.022711697965860367,
0.5486543774604797,
-0.6151443123817444,
0.09101371467113495,
0.6081833839416504,
0.017250750213861465,
-0.08771902322769165,
-0.7492483258247375,
0.02832050435245037,
-0.429872989654541,
-0.53884357213974,
0.1982460469007492,
-0.3921830654144287,
0.8580345511436462,
-0.42087456583976746,
-0.23737117648124695,
-0.2308955043554306,
0.2600524425506592,
0.13530407845973969,
0.6755210757255554,
0.10215217620134354,
0.24417831003665924,
0.7722305059432983,
0.20608921349048615,
1.0510668754577637,
-0.0951007753610611,
0.31019890308380127,
1.0225882530212402,
-0.6384795904159546,
0.5790494680404663,
0.39836862683296204,
-0.21267376840114594,
0.5788867473602295,
0.6082680225372314,
0.3377349376678467,
1.0235809087753296,
-0.342157781124115,
-0.48774343729019165,
-0.01744498871266842,
0.16897404193878174,
-0.3812020719051361,
0.27907124161720276,
0.661393940448761,
-0.3984818160533905,
-0.15298958122730255,
0.32436656951904297,
-0.235402449965477,
-0.04886086285114288,
-0.20574796199798584,
1.0857634544372559,
-0.012676582671701908,
-0.5288966298103333,
0.5109081864356995,
-0.06458050012588501,
0.36240920424461365,
-0.6007294654846191,
-0.25623220205307007,
-0.124498151242733,
0.5164698362350464,
-0.060101866722106934,
-0.4972064793109894,
0.29182255268096924,
-0.0010508178966119885,
0.007601354271173477,
0.3520045876502991,
0.7797070741653442,
-0.1621822863817215,
-0.3765357732772827,
0.46110525727272034,
0.7458589673042297,
0.16726621985435486,
-0.09547795355319977,
-0.7236570119857788,
-0.25262022018432617,
0.06180275231599808,
-0.38053229451179504,
0.5287029147148132,
0.6289607286453247,
-0.19829043745994568,
0.48837170004844666,
0.6097559332847595,
0.4405618906021118,
0.05155530199408531,
0.08726487308740616,
0.828275740146637,
-0.47946035861968994,
-0.2421504557132721,
-0.7056818008422852,
0.34172824025154114,
-0.35854268074035645,
-0.4771515727043152,
0.7470831274986267,
0.8177433013916016,
0.21890874207019806,
-0.030900752171874046,
1.0770752429962158,
0.07722046226263046,
0.7260314226150513,
-0.37657880783081055,
0.5521649122238159,
-0.34224286675453186,
0.3836020827293396,
-0.25161078572273254,
-0.6128026843070984,
-0.4094235599040985,
0.3155929744243622,
-0.07944466918706894,
-0.22588512301445007,
1.002240777015686,
0.43126529455184937,
-0.15825195610523224,
0.04658255726099014,
0.0309863593429327,
-0.011675707064568996,
0.5429694652557373,
0.4552071988582611,
0.28033721446990967,
-0.9999963641166687,
0.5793010592460632,
-0.145786851644516,
-0.4387708604335785,
0.01769951358437538,
-0.5324921011924744,
-0.9516845941543579,
-0.4141092002391815,
-0.4406040608882904,
-0.4351560175418854,
0.4180653393268585,
0.9697406888008118,
0.6934919357299805,
-1.2949756383895874,
0.10527244955301285,
0.07435722649097443,
0.12169847637414932,
-0.4895724952220917,
-0.18217003345489502,
0.8728451728820801,
-0.221781387925148,
-0.5485414266586304,
0.2821269631385803,
0.33789360523223877,
0.2108788788318634,
0.30888670682907104,
0.1871393471956253,
-0.8220199346542358,
0.03210416063666344,
0.6208470463752747,
0.32326540350914,
-0.09856913238763809,
-0.07604412734508514,
-0.09964745491743088,
-0.20299667119979858,
0.2716955244541168,
0.9889874458312988,
-0.4557986855506897,
0.4663090109825134,
0.11594383418560028,
0.5690656304359436,
0.5755428671836853,
-0.038516730070114136,
0.6365558505058289,
-0.6560319066047668,
-0.017040768638253212,
0.023762881755828857,
0.4711197018623352,
0.07198216766119003,
-0.4046551287174225,
0.5427471995353699,
0.38694486021995544,
-0.5411597490310669,
-0.5619102120399475,
0.06459392607212067,
-0.6699298620223999,
-0.5539476871490479,
1.3745537996292114,
-0.41385284066200256,
-0.2190164476633072,
-0.8282508850097656,
-0.2660825550556183,
0.217756450176239,
-0.6511149406433105,
0.9510769248008728,
0.3886358141899109,
-0.5167709589004517,
0.11001124233007431,
-0.7299105525016785,
0.7802203893661499,
-0.17265167832374573,
-1.1226918697357178,
0.38511744141578674,
0.5297940969467163,
0.34701648354530334,
-0.004370987880975008,
1.015255331993103,
-0.28808432817459106,
0.3956364095211029,
0.06155089661478996,
0.2957416772842407,
0.2613697946071625,
-0.6505921483039856,
-0.3576738238334656,
0.4334787428379059,
-0.21391238272190094,
-0.5062150359153748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18009v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18009v1
|
Exploring Context Window of Large Language Models via Decomposed Positional Vectors
| 2024-05-28T09:50:46 | 2024-05-28T09:50:46 |
Zican Dong, Junyi Li, Xin Men, Wayne Xin Zhao, Bingbing Wang, Zhen Tian, Weipeng Chen, Ji-Rong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Transformer-based large language models (LLMs) typically have a limited
context window, resulting in significant performance degradation when
processing text beyond the length of the context window. Extensive studies have
been proposed to extend the context window and achieve length extrapolation of
LLMs, but there is still a lack of in-depth interpretation of these approaches.
In this study, we explore the positional information within and beyond the
context window for deciphering the underlying mechanism of LLMs. By using a
mean-based decomposition method, we disentangle positional vectors from hidden
states of LLMs and analyze their formation and effect on attention.
Furthermore, when texts exceed the context window, we analyze the change of
positional vectors in two settings, i.e., direct extrapolation and context
window extension. Based on our findings, we design two training-free context
window extension methods, positional vector replacement and attention window
extension. Experimental results show that our methods can effectively extend
the context window length.
|
[
-0.39700746536254883,
-0.7355477809906006,
0.8126245737075806,
-0.15627813339233398,
-0.4601115882396698,
-0.08310931921005249,
-0.5341179966926575,
-0.37919020652770996,
0.14714442193508148,
0.2896239459514618,
-0.6688300371170044,
-0.3959328532218933,
-0.6272845268249512,
-0.11790300160646439,
-0.4659516215324402,
0.6841113567352295,
-0.1545131802558899,
-0.3078439235687256,
-0.3065390884876251,
-0.01670926809310913,
-0.6499341130256653,
-0.6550540328025818,
-0.27421697974205017,
-0.09427272528409958,
0.27694523334503174,
0.14479854702949524,
0.4564530551433563,
0.5059396028518677,
0.2707378566265106,
0.3121740221977234,
-0.4040902554988861,
-0.09253041446208954,
-0.7279446721076965,
0.2226267009973526,
-0.020469488576054573,
-0.5357048511505127,
-0.25387322902679443,
0.08101342618465424,
0.8995787501335144,
0.637418270111084,
0.22859370708465576,
0.18862220644950867,
0.3230024576187134,
0.49646440148353577,
-0.7569888830184937,
0.41479647159576416,
-0.5233967900276184,
-0.011879896745085716,
-0.012020889669656754,
-0.3665103316307068,
-0.5405693650245667,
0.09916327148675919,
0.3703242242336273,
-0.259300172328949,
0.4088248610496521,
-0.14395412802696228,
0.5816543102264404,
0.40169310569763184,
-0.6047021746635437,
0.1177450492978096,
-0.8646674752235413,
1.1071717739105225,
-0.4564674496650696,
0.5386798977851868,
0.06662959605455399,
0.1365281045436859,
-0.334073930978775,
-0.32019612193107605,
-0.47285300493240356,
-0.07904763519763947,
-0.3771522343158722,
-0.08607596904039383,
-0.4613659083843231,
-0.04609720781445503,
0.2954998314380646,
0.09522327780723572,
-0.36828190088272095,
-0.017219459637999535,
-0.32175660133361816,
-0.03453419357538223,
0.366634339094162,
-0.02794496715068817,
0.3551705777645111,
-0.2081853300333023,
-0.4688265323638916,
-0.35295432806015015,
-0.7344704270362854,
0.21375775337219238,
0.011468867771327496,
0.04408881068229675,
-0.12032625079154968,
0.5042697787284851,
0.21951773762702942,
0.8400087952613831,
-0.21763841807842255,
-0.07638734579086304,
0.2838028371334076,
-0.07339023798704147,
-0.41924622654914856,
0.16934029757976532,
0.553353488445282,
0.5193213820457458,
-0.05123778432607651,
-0.034544363617897034,
-0.22291159629821777,
0.07157962024211884,
0.15110084414482117,
-0.6881721019744873,
0.33324089646339417,
0.18015767633914948,
-0.4920128583908081,
-0.2509250044822693,
-0.10108773410320282,
-0.353339284658432,
-0.11638534814119339,
-0.39398837089538574,
0.0860389769077301,
-0.4059353768825531,
-0.3294092118740082,
-0.08037212491035461,
-0.0964159145951271,
0.5345072746276855,
0.22254960238933563,
-0.9060395359992981,
-0.0542321540415287,
0.9330194592475891,
0.6700284481048584,
-0.5045613050460815,
-0.2933709919452667,
-0.34939703345298767,
0.29200196266174316,
-0.41656801104545593,
0.5980200171470642,
-0.8488590121269226,
-0.48086628317832947,
-0.03238748013973236,
0.28801998496055603,
-0.23576529324054718,
-0.4768664538860321,
0.49825072288513184,
-0.7848907113075256,
0.2641410827636719,
-0.2550241947174072,
-0.4874286949634552,
-0.26888301968574524,
0.3564961552619934,
-0.8229635953903198,
1.0774197578430176,
0.040511421859264374,
-0.7774753570556641,
0.138173446059227,
-0.6887525320053101,
-0.3881416618824005,
-0.18827201426029205,
-0.3023054897785187,
-0.12296125292778015,
0.5869081616401672,
0.396452397108078,
0.6975201368331909,
-0.126283660531044,
0.2602968215942383,
-0.015076186507940292,
-0.6025139093399048,
0.6057398915290833,
-0.7529265284538269,
0.5448256134986877,
-0.08396413922309875,
-0.23772549629211426,
0.2764412760734558,
-0.8474257588386536,
-0.161868155002594,
-0.06870974600315094,
-0.44557565450668335,
-0.6886228919029236,
0.10669984668493271,
-0.032232437282800674,
0.24632486701011658,
0.2228919416666031,
-0.54031902551651,
0.07164446264505386,
-0.5810098648071289,
0.49469977617263794,
0.6517022252082825,
0.0578603520989418,
0.6532384753227234,
0.13462746143341064,
0.4972400367259979,
0.15601740777492523,
-0.03741919621825218,
-0.4055962562561035,
-0.1540299654006958,
-0.6591151356697083,
-0.17463825643062592,
-0.03403761237859726,
0.21317723393440247,
-0.6898537278175354,
0.27582311630249023,
-0.6562447547912598,
0.13235341012477875,
-0.31561216711997986,
-0.2605380415916443,
0.2185737043619156,
0.4992564022541046,
0.36868512630462646,
0.22657839953899384,
-0.5735677480697632,
-0.9969924092292786,
-0.14186429977416992,
-0.020100077614188194,
-0.34386375546455383,
0.07837966084480286,
0.3492145240306854,
-0.38759946823120117,
1.1751056909561157,
-0.6746546030044556,
-0.11814729869365692,
-0.2785417139530182,
-0.37251710891723633,
0.09217438846826553,
0.21270310878753662,
0.40126273036003113,
-0.7538883090019226,
-0.1169314756989479,
-0.31316429376602173,
-0.4923367202281952,
0.1391741931438446,
0.01610621251165867,
-0.05171164125204086,
0.35078972578048706,
0.9820393323898315,
-0.5762802958488464,
0.5066608190536499,
0.8634999990463257,
-0.23257392644882202,
0.3872074782848358,
-0.08295831829309464,
-0.07161235064268112,
-1.1528438329696655,
0.031962718814611435,
-0.0033354118932038546,
-0.4035552740097046,
-0.664840579032898,
0.06615649908781052,
0.25541824102401733,
-0.15715637803077698,
-0.541852593421936,
0.5198952555656433,
-0.760627031326294,
-0.3112696409225464,
-0.7590101957321167,
0.35609033703804016,
0.08382365852594376,
0.5742156505584717,
0.130313903093338,
0.7536913752555847,
0.44397634267807007,
-0.4612354338169098,
0.16706104576587677,
0.06317441910505295,
-0.5823656320571899,
0.06327413767576218,
-0.5697536468505859,
-0.04827180132269859,
-0.43538087606430054,
0.4753803312778473,
-1.3071497678756714,
-0.024547088891267776,
0.05485435947775841,
-0.3150855004787445,
0.4764396846294403,
-0.1844559609889984,
-0.22680357098579407,
-0.17916852235794067,
-0.5024634003639221,
0.4779074490070343,
0.3212136924266815,
-0.6929895281791687,
0.43239498138427734,
0.44944173097610474,
0.10491221398115158,
-0.7144131660461426,
-0.6931332945823669,
0.08424542844295502,
-0.4012574851512909,
-0.5414066910743713,
0.5982369184494019,
0.2323523461818695,
-0.40991076827049255,
-0.012281526811420918,
-0.16459454596042633,
0.21029974520206451,
0.14612700045108795,
0.2717624008655548,
0.31770059466362,
-0.18119293451309204,
0.16484206914901733,
0.07861915230751038,
-0.21944870054721832,
0.2601601481437683,
-0.07356863468885422,
0.6101905107498169,
-0.09459692984819412,
-0.21165767312049866,
-0.18993112444877625,
0.3746891915798187,
0.7219624519348145,
-0.44583654403686523,
0.985663890838623,
0.43758639693260193,
-0.3629179894924164,
-0.21439070999622345,
-0.33254823088645935,
-0.3202480375766754,
-0.510657548904419,
0.5145653486251831,
-0.40168094635009766,
-0.9824115037918091,
0.5580371618270874,
-0.1152757778763771,
-0.13237264752388,
0.24108555912971497,
0.601020336151123,
0.15679778158664703,
0.9357545375823975,
1.0003068447113037,
-0.09799344837665558,
0.693694531917572,
-0.2853248119354248,
0.13020150363445282,
-1.3623008728027344,
-0.19434985518455505,
0.009668760001659393,
-0.45502087473869324,
-0.39128541946411133,
-0.8288623094558716,
0.4751356542110443,
0.05684700235724449,
0.2567771077156067,
0.37026065587997437,
-0.4223274886608124,
0.6863283514976501,
0.2850278913974762,
0.09959469735622406,
0.09489027410745621,
-0.04237421229481697,
-0.11028288304805756,
-0.0007052186410874128,
-0.4649762809276581,
-0.3999398946762085,
0.7745579481124878,
0.6305579543113708,
0.5231738090515137,
0.20749111473560333,
0.3338041603565216,
-0.2045929878950119,
0.24857684969902039,
-0.9795776605606079,
0.6695668697357178,
0.12652841210365295,
-0.3483040928840637,
-0.58812016248703,
-0.14212946593761444,
-0.988418698310852,
0.5483318567276001,
0.19904619455337524,
-0.9295325875282288,
0.09021800756454468,
-0.18375739455223083,
-0.11156446486711502,
0.09572024643421173,
-0.6666452884674072,
0.71294766664505,
0.0777251273393631,
-0.38387036323547363,
-0.13574478030204773,
-0.5754145979881287,
0.1739438772201538,
0.0566142201423645,
0.1279769092798233,
-0.18922795355319977,
-0.13741354644298553,
0.7900930047035217,
-0.41551467776298523,
0.889934241771698,
-0.16212420165538788,
-0.6893072128295898,
0.3017377257347107,
-0.017952758818864822,
0.7256664037704468,
0.0027232107240706682,
0.1297629475593567,
0.17150339484214783,
-0.22975783050060272,
-0.12596721947193146,
-0.6615985631942749,
0.997038722038269,
-0.5894547700881958,
-0.7854213118553162,
-0.06489010900259018,
-0.6186736822128296,
-0.2376949042081833,
-0.019107244908809662,
0.30778536200523376,
0.6077000498771667,
-0.09804742783308029,
0.3660881221294403,
0.7218172550201416,
-0.39016035199165344,
0.874448299407959,
0.5730586647987366,
-0.15244357287883759,
0.2298576980829239,
0.43513044714927673,
-0.07759705185890198,
-0.012467578984797001,
0.8672983050346375,
0.23812805116176605,
-0.6392819285392761,
-0.37928417325019836,
-0.23211179673671722,
0.10155628621578217,
-0.8689722418785095,
0.14958064258098602,
-0.4965173602104187,
0.004857568070292473,
-0.4307032525539398,
-0.055692803114652634,
-0.3861698508262634,
-0.26698368787765503,
-0.465629905462265,
-0.34310969710350037,
0.20128561556339264,
0.2626938223838806,
0.29852354526519775,
0.20521773397922516,
-0.7848957180976868,
-0.04170789569616318,
0.12076269090175629,
0.3627837896347046,
0.23357324302196503,
-0.5092988014221191,
-0.2977529764175415,
-0.08688424527645111,
0.02829141356050968,
-0.9435728788375854,
0.47173550724983215,
-0.1593163013458252,
0.5628616809844971,
0.31175434589385986,
0.03415978327393532,
0.5230226516723633,
-0.8814632892608643,
0.7601179480552673,
0.14123140275478363,
-0.8601351380348206,
0.4064549207687378,
-0.40867286920547485,
0.7004443407058716,
0.07335838675498962,
0.14939378201961517,
-0.6138174533843994,
-0.41952332854270935,
-0.16485919058322906,
-0.9532648921012878,
0.6804519295692444,
0.1354115605354309,
0.25563135743141174,
-0.0809180960059166,
0.3346741795539856,
-0.14973600208759308,
-0.16738463938236237,
-0.5589562058448792,
-0.3714635372161865,
0.08414404094219208,
-0.061828553676605225,
-0.3843126595020294,
-0.5891941785812378,
-0.06919784098863602,
-0.11229126900434494,
0.36530402302742004,
-0.1568099409341812,
0.4523680806159973,
0.10086701065301895,
-0.3778188228607178,
0.07155217975378036,
0.5275572538375854,
0.865241527557373,
0.9399591088294983,
-0.10566288977861404,
0.4039674699306488,
0.23763710260391235,
-0.3418741822242737,
0.284186989068985,
-0.01777123287320137,
0.07308617234230042,
0.12148105353116989,
0.4067319333553314,
1.0500414371490479,
0.6157582998275757,
-0.5895987153053284,
0.6637486219406128,
-0.18649102747440338,
0.1949208676815033,
-0.4612613916397095,
0.006288660224527121,
0.23951789736747742,
0.3740374743938446,
0.5051971077919006,
-0.2954970598220825,
0.12133011966943741,
-0.42752256989479065,
0.2173061966896057,
0.47392088174819946,
-0.5497981309890747,
-0.43408864736557007,
0.681799590587616,
0.10819324851036072,
-0.056512925773859024,
0.185947448015213,
0.29025980830192566,
-0.5682703852653503,
0.4205462634563446,
0.6296278834342957,
0.8749436736106873,
-0.21392717957496643,
0.07153508067131042,
0.07563932240009308,
0.18420009315013885,
-0.002761904150247574,
-0.09875921159982681,
-0.17449934780597687,
-0.7583707571029663,
-0.9341858625411987,
-0.5827709436416626,
-0.11513590812683105,
0.5913683772087097,
-0.6377020478248596,
0.22776725888252258,
0.002784459386020899,
-0.0864408016204834,
-0.1853773593902588,
-0.3094880282878876,
-0.468963086605072,
0.007862810976803303,
0.47470855712890625,
0.6870898604393005,
-0.5590168833732605,
0.8971506357192993,
0.8619174361228943,
0.27629703283309937,
-0.6421793103218079,
0.32107385993003845,
-0.10447793453931808,
-0.6612309217453003,
0.6275032162666321,
0.5618528127670288,
-0.49782851338386536,
-0.1498052477836609,
-0.4517992436885834,
-1.087422490119934,
0.981934666633606,
0.435814768075943,
-0.6972109079360962,
-0.06391958147287369,
0.30056092143058777,
0.6735680103302002,
-0.12388202548027039,
0.04244963452219963,
0.6387708187103271,
0.05009430646896362,
-0.04474206268787384,
-0.6720664501190186,
0.40283358097076416,
-0.05035197734832764,
0.2891904413700104,
0.33559033274650574,
-0.718398928642273,
0.7299394011497498,
0.008080794475972652,
-0.44365760684013367,
-0.40780624747276306,
0.5688097476959229,
0.08121180534362793,
-0.11046233773231506,
0.3646082282066345,
0.38335999846458435,
0.4342200458049774,
0.10771185159683228,
1.0945864915847778,
-0.5522447824478149,
0.5039762258529663,
1.0328549146652222,
-0.1670169234275818,
0.9412456750869751,
0.6876569986343384,
0.16954991221427917,
0.45481905341148376,
0.37694811820983887,
0.3228183686733246,
0.49435511231422424,
0.09987565875053406,
-0.3461604118347168,
-0.11346835643053055,
0.26765260100364685,
-0.20921233296394348,
0.5786536931991577,
0.42842796444892883,
-0.696282684803009,
-0.3016817271709442,
0.39312002062797546,
0.08591090887784958,
-0.14872591197490692,
-0.28297558426856995,
0.6201229691505432,
0.04505605250597,
-0.7846108078956604,
0.8888960480690002,
0.5011547803878784,
0.5618382096290588,
-0.18314069509506226,
0.13688376545906067,
-0.07926689833402634,
0.42689216136932373,
0.15158811211585999,
-0.7300012111663818,
0.32689088582992554,
-0.02280469983816147,
-0.4017064869403839,
-0.38280874490737915,
0.945488691329956,
-0.42274799942970276,
-0.22195596992969513,
0.4284375011920929,
0.318805456161499,
-0.023845069110393524,
-0.2942599654197693,
-0.3018225431442261,
0.390403151512146,
0.03626275807619095,
-0.6849645972251892,
0.36440935730934143,
0.28882265090942383,
-0.2738085985183716,
0.5558744072914124,
0.4766189455986023,
-0.3888460695743561,
0.09823297709226608,
-0.05026141181588173,
1.0198510885238647,
-0.6640284657478333,
-0.5659105777740479,
-1.2979068756103516,
0.19683736562728882,
0.15354999899864197,
0.1076328456401825,
0.8998307585716248,
0.553852379322052,
0.759516716003418,
-0.1490435004234314,
0.7280288338661194,
0.3477939963340759,
0.489730566740036,
-0.5406348705291748,
0.6701992750167847,
-0.47890758514404297,
0.5009456276893616,
-0.2023676633834839,
-1.1039040088653564,
-0.25098153948783875,
0.4373480975627899,
-0.6456805467605591,
-0.3380160331726074,
0.5738005042076111,
0.5670338273048401,
-0.07883580029010773,
-0.17774349451065063,
0.40852874517440796,
0.2531943917274475,
0.5950774550437927,
0.6240657567977905,
1.0182942152023315,
-0.28473538160324097,
0.6669323444366455,
-0.0020741296466439962,
-0.3232439458370209,
-0.35500603914260864,
-0.8423832058906555,
-0.9925258755683899,
-0.6532776355743408,
-0.14044538140296936,
-0.03324410319328308,
-0.36406001448631287,
0.6913701295852661,
0.5510668754577637,
-0.5293169021606445,
0.014966397546231747,
0.05712941661477089,
0.08541866391897202,
0.011121341027319431,
-0.29515984654426575,
0.7863092422485352,
-0.046670909970998764,
-0.887233555316925,
0.8083857893943787,
0.3113461434841156,
0.18732565641403198,
-0.37755370140075684,
0.17723537981510162,
0.0425664484500885,
0.06668814271688461,
1.030351161956787,
-0.007516636047512293,
-0.5174065828323364,
-0.5018311738967896,
0.10659758746623993,
-0.013330967165529728,
0.13678637146949768,
0.9146000742912292,
-0.8939756155014038,
0.1822405457496643,
0.6102584600448608,
0.38547784090042114,
0.46856045722961426,
0.25052163004875183,
0.5962203741073608,
-1.3728936910629272,
0.472421795129776,
-0.053905241191387177,
0.4043440818786621,
0.29645296931266785,
-0.26343631744384766,
0.10871366411447525,
-0.025940071791410446,
-0.22524221241474152,
-0.8596302270889282,
0.31222331523895264,
-0.732526421546936,
-0.7465009689331055,
1.5449155569076538,
-0.01675591617822647,
-0.652079701423645,
0.15307392179965973,
-0.17451871931552887,
0.3281637728214264,
-0.18672116100788116,
0.5916032195091248,
0.6847363114356995,
-0.2542755901813507,
-0.18230484426021576,
-0.4405071437358856,
0.5737214684486389,
0.18205833435058594,
-0.4828087389469147,
0.3977017104625702,
0.6024318337440491,
0.4535549283027649,
0.2802489399909973,
0.40859606862068176,
-0.26122599840164185,
-0.11995294690132141,
-0.32356107234954834,
-0.31730130314826965,
-0.10734125226736069,
-0.41904762387275696,
-0.6017299890518188,
0.2577287256717682,
-0.304111123085022,
-0.3985888361930847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17998v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17998v1
|
Source Echo Chamber: Exploring the Escalation of Source Bias in User, Data, and Recommender System Feedback Loop
| 2024-05-28T09:34:50 | 2024-05-28T09:34:50 |
Yuqi Zhou, Sunhao Dai, Liang Pang, Gang Wang, Zhenhua Dong, Jun Xu, Ji-Rong Wen
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recently, researchers have uncovered that neural retrieval models prefer
AI-generated content (AIGC), called source bias. Compared to active search
behavior, recommendation represents another important means of information
acquisition, where users are more prone to source bias. Furthermore, delving
into the recommendation scenario, as AIGC becomes integrated within the
feedback loop involving users, data, and the recommender system, it
progressively contaminates the candidate items, the user interaction history,
and ultimately, the data used to train the recommendation models. How and to
what extent the source bias affects the neural recommendation models within
feedback loop remains unknown. In this study, we extend the investigation of
source bias into the realm of recommender systems, specifically examining its
impact across different phases of the feedback loop. We conceptualize the
progression of AIGC integration into the recommendation content ecosystem in
three distinct phases-HGC dominate, HGC-AIGC coexist, and AIGC dominance-each
representing past, present, and future states, respectively. Through extensive
experiments across three datasets from diverse domains, we demonstrate the
prevalence of source bias and reveal a potential digital echo chamber with
source bias amplification throughout the feedback loop. This trend risks
creating a recommender ecosystem with limited information source, such as AIGC,
being disproportionately recommended. To counteract this bias and prevent its
escalation in the feedback loop, we introduce a black-box debiasing method that
maintains model impartiality towards both HGC and AIGC. Our experimental
results validate the effectiveness of the proposed debiasing method, confirming
its potential to disrupt the feedback loop.
|
[
-0.6119816899299622,
-0.8003852367401123,
0.6739088296890259,
-0.35097625851631165,
-0.2855653762817383,
-0.04035724326968193,
0.00025373094831593335,
-0.4185006320476532,
0.03489455208182335,
0.5893560647964478,
-0.6591174006462097,
-0.22740137577056885,
-0.7116503119468689,
-0.07419678568840027,
-0.5863394141197205,
1.2322337627410889,
0.14033812284469604,
0.3117007911205292,
-0.23693202435970306,
-0.004454944748431444,
-0.8477174639701843,
-0.6593705415725708,
-0.43861857056617737,
-0.45182719826698303,
0.381134033203125,
0.262975811958313,
0.7865062355995178,
0.6088545322418213,
0.42454439401626587,
0.10184331983327866,
-0.1817115992307663,
-0.024665631353855133,
-0.6125978827476501,
0.5178412199020386,
-0.2247539907693863,
-0.39595314860343933,
-0.029809528961777687,
0.017058711498975754,
0.23299001157283783,
0.2972354292869568,
-0.4316576421260834,
0.35681843757629395,
0.38907477259635925,
0.5039085149765015,
-0.8035035729408264,
-0.10251052677631378,
-0.7006223797798157,
-0.08975882083177567,
-0.02199033461511135,
-0.40655517578125,
-0.44071337580680847,
-0.2838122248649597,
0.4973810613155365,
-0.5031718015670776,
0.27766215801239014,
0.20375852286815643,
0.6161133646965027,
0.5541663765907288,
-0.19800616800785065,
-0.4434058368206024,
-1.0845110416412354,
0.5381838083267212,
-0.47527793049812317,
0.22474806010723114,
0.4250805974006653,
0.20289748907089233,
0.04186341539025307,
-0.5341230034828186,
-0.5111610889434814,
-0.2027408331632614,
-0.02438521943986416,
-0.0902193933725357,
-0.6522859334945679,
-0.06543970853090286,
0.2171042412519455,
0.19170747697353363,
-0.17405623197555542,
-0.3162660598754883,
-0.5340704321861267,
-0.06326285004615784,
0.3515491783618927,
-0.0263145100325346,
0.49044764041900635,
-0.2782834470272064,
-0.1642513871192932,
-0.05433215573430061,
-0.8001693487167358,
-0.08301825821399689,
0.7046751379966736,
0.3280562162399292,
0.3292059004306793,
0.4934401214122772,
0.09663806855678558,
0.472552090883255,
0.5153677463531494,
0.39679092168807983,
-0.17348764836788177,
-0.6530390381813049,
0.09457064419984818,
0.5188716053962708,
0.6170378923416138,
0.24548974633216858,
0.1042034700512886,
0.0997561514377594,
0.16771665215492249,
-0.26970526576042175,
0.9771697521209717,
-0.6503434181213379,
0.025462185963988304,
0.11245465278625488,
-0.6232091784477234,
-0.49157238006591797,
0.15859900414943695,
-0.6341089010238647,
-0.7092752456665039,
-0.28780537843704224,
0.5460056662559509,
-0.05962306633591652,
-0.29392102360725403,
-0.3675808906555176,
-0.2602321207523346,
-0.2475382387638092,
0.1681523323059082,
-0.5110362768173218,
0.27365991473197937,
0.5502485632896423,
0.929395854473114,
-0.041637927293777466,
-0.22527693212032318,
-0.4454359710216522,
-0.12207066267728806,
-0.16168126463890076,
0.7891243100166321,
-0.8591404557228088,
-0.5865055322647095,
0.16871921718120575,
0.05965379253029823,
0.5517815351486206,
-0.6542360186576843,
0.5338295698165894,
-0.5496965646743774,
0.26201897859573364,
-0.44747859239578247,
-0.29389265179634094,
-0.26573580503463745,
-0.02763032354414463,
-0.5452406406402588,
0.8597365617752075,
0.0005460990942083299,
-0.6511080265045166,
0.5038639903068542,
-0.35053935647010803,
-0.16196593642234802,
-0.038991961628198624,
-0.1834086924791336,
-0.2978839576244354,
0.003160732565447688,
0.47471901774406433,
0.061707302927970886,
-0.2648608088493347,
0.25932544469833374,
-0.662726640701294,
-0.7235062122344971,
0.12951737642288208,
-0.4976266622543335,
0.5454909801483154,
0.2598154842853546,
-0.7407574653625488,
0.08754140138626099,
-0.5328156352043152,
-0.3501507043838501,
-0.20201550424098969,
0.06474360823631287,
-0.5976628661155701,
0.29580748081207275,
-0.07897231727838516,
0.2658757269382477,
-0.16403120756149292,
-0.2785879075527191,
0.10445436090230942,
0.13905015587806702,
0.5959399938583374,
1.0810948610305786,
0.5909281969070435,
0.3490042984485626,
-0.2726845145225525,
0.5192995667457581,
0.3657934069633484,
0.14694233238697052,
-0.35439708828926086,
-0.3675187826156616,
-0.6367049813270569,
0.3100281357765198,
0.0426500178873539,
0.05515001714229584,
-0.47804492712020874,
0.5242409706115723,
0.19526389241218567,
-0.2770856022834778,
-0.9449895024299622,
0.10839922726154327,
0.08161622285842896,
0.34342503547668457,
0.5346603989601135,
-0.0873887911438942,
-0.2932193875312805,
-0.8820719122886658,
-0.27309152483940125,
-0.24891622364521027,
-0.1296979784965515,
0.6874192357063293,
0.10027536004781723,
-0.37540295720100403,
0.6584026217460632,
-0.36105895042419434,
-0.392513632774353,
0.02522997371852398,
0.08902980387210846,
0.29747140407562256,
0.17178387939929962,
0.3687109649181366,
-0.3748605251312256,
-0.10543059557676315,
-0.36817923188209534,
-0.6609470248222351,
-0.3017001748085022,
-0.1808273047208786,
-0.4119996130466461,
-0.20566606521606445,
0.328590452671051,
-0.2105364203453064,
0.40443384647369385,
0.4488680064678192,
-0.6512054204940796,
0.39734259247779846,
-0.011575653217732906,
0.29048460721969604,
-0.9508326053619385,
0.06680596619844437,
0.19199992716312408,
0.1155923381447792,
-0.19230882823467255,
0.060025423765182495,
-0.24197284877300262,
-0.058795757591724396,
-0.04369309917092323,
0.13824938237667084,
-0.29277878999710083,
0.0480341799557209,
-0.5935230255126953,
0.052310504019260406,
0.06322477757930756,
0.3558284342288971,
-0.16209782660007477,
0.8992485404014587,
0.3259443938732147,
-0.40114837884902954,
0.16041821241378784,
0.23353460431098938,
-0.3759532570838928,
0.6169273853302002,
-0.8245465755462646,
0.44355419278144836,
-0.11097869277000427,
0.5241147875785828,
-0.7738707661628723,
0.31572604179382324,
0.41825994849205017,
-0.23977695405483246,
-0.03734266757965088,
-0.23144884407520294,
-0.16385270655155182,
-0.15490102767944336,
-0.2873378396034241,
0.5229101181030273,
0.3387090861797333,
-0.6912602782249451,
0.18400342762470245,
0.33390769362449646,
-0.17531640827655792,
-0.9702277183532715,
-0.5011420249938965,
0.167243093252182,
-0.01951718144118786,
-0.30601561069488525,
0.24091321229934692,
-0.20270752906799316,
-0.6212928295135498,
0.5029733777046204,
-0.17837142944335938,
0.23228876292705536,
-0.22853469848632812,
0.5990593433380127,
0.3206920325756073,
-0.0066962162964046,
0.22207292914390564,
0.11394307762384415,
0.14849233627319336,
0.11431972682476044,
-0.6876472234725952,
0.4647974967956543,
0.036350082606077194,
-0.5700463056564331,
-0.4333095848560333,
0.3165163993835449,
0.6488373279571533,
0.05589642748236656,
0.6228779554367065,
0.46122291684150696,
-0.22273656725883484,
-0.47486329078674316,
-0.5934069156646729,
-0.5693134665489197,
-0.4363647699356079,
0.2111811488866806,
0.08458154648542404,
-0.6712891459465027,
0.40703701972961426,
0.5061872005462646,
-0.20709870755672455,
0.39408260583877563,
0.8110987544059753,
0.0366872176527977,
1.0119428634643555,
0.404839426279068,
-0.362474262714386,
0.5293173789978027,
-0.41089603304862976,
0.2240428328514099,
-1.0497130155563354,
-0.042836595326662064,
-0.5608847737312317,
-0.4535386562347412,
-0.6523538827896118,
-0.06805593520402908,
0.34388136863708496,
-0.06563405692577362,
-0.11711692810058594,
0.15024316310882568,
-0.8702437281608582,
0.2270316630601883,
0.8628255724906921,
0.5164264440536499,
0.42818683385849,
-0.05237138271331787,
0.06602538377046585,
0.04107152298092842,
-0.49928760528564453,
-0.22923223674297333,
1.4024564027786255,
0.3418591618537903,
0.8411305546760559,
-0.17470405995845795,
0.29129093885421753,
0.9602837562561035,
0.18268686532974243,
-0.8179553747177124,
-0.010058050975203514,
0.23858171701431274,
-0.744248628616333,
-0.04223323613405228,
-0.02396639995276928,
-0.5958814024925232,
0.12622661888599396,
-0.06908068805932999,
-0.3698343336582184,
0.8490774631500244,
-0.03709577023983002,
-0.40748515725135803,
0.34007924795150757,
-0.47238415479660034,
0.2560444474220276,
-0.07048889994621277,
-0.7554625868797302,
-0.5983816385269165,
-0.19786210358142853,
0.1289176344871521,
0.02087767980992794,
0.003731702221557498,
0.060807403177022934,
0.3525044620037079,
0.42225542664527893,
-0.42053622007369995,
0.34510767459869385,
-0.2933705449104309,
0.04055546224117279,
0.6907023787498474,
0.27480894327163696,
0.6358981132507324,
0.3196163773536682,
-0.15538769960403442,
0.6695833802223206,
-0.3229774236679077,
-0.1915329247713089,
-0.41161835193634033,
0.8585318922996521,
-1.1537822484970093,
-0.8274007439613342,
-0.5673938989639282,
-0.2762959599494934,
0.16517522931098938,
0.14246901869773865,
0.3888574540615082,
0.32205110788345337,
0.11001486331224442,
0.36900201439857483,
0.40081462264060974,
-0.17448073625564575,
0.28743648529052734,
0.45818573236465454,
0.1406363993883133,
-0.5209546089172363,
0.6353540420532227,
0.25563231110572815,
0.05976482853293419,
-0.1708330661058426,
0.12545564770698547,
-0.200396329164505,
-0.8643374443054199,
-0.4611935019493103,
-0.009161911904811859,
-0.4705783426761627,
-0.13294848799705505,
-0.5510016083717346,
-0.2300104945898056,
-0.23385335505008698,
0.07904192060232162,
-0.10416749119758606,
0.15939895808696747,
-0.30501389503479004,
-0.3663571774959564,
0.005248574540019035,
1.0483686923980713,
0.22400611639022827,
0.21330475807189941,
-0.42422574758529663,
-0.01846899837255478,
0.43263596296310425,
0.4952161908149719,
0.18307501077651978,
-0.5073955655097961,
-0.3873293101787567,
0.0855262279510498,
-0.6208676099777222,
-0.906671404838562,
0.14893117547035217,
-0.1946035921573639,
0.6332073211669922,
0.772901713848114,
0.04646122828125954,
0.41185933351516724,
-0.4093327522277832,
1.1503987312316895,
-0.1473899632692337,
-0.8235622644424438,
0.544883668422699,
-0.6167219877243042,
0.2482316792011261,
0.6829378008842468,
0.22861097753047943,
-0.5819063782691956,
-0.5083622336387634,
-0.6544373631477356,
-0.7505150437355042,
0.9247393608093262,
0.1293375939130783,
0.14420892298221588,
0.06007133796811104,
0.38275524973869324,
0.25789058208465576,
0.5118595957756042,
-0.5367249250411987,
-0.24225221574306488,
-0.4534815549850464,
0.3184853792190552,
0.0748995691537857,
-0.4901098906993866,
-0.31459730863571167,
0.03423982113599777,
0.6270315647125244,
-0.009296873584389687,
0.2938222885131836,
0.3964809775352478,
-0.0026104527059942484,
-0.6831722855567932,
0.15525175631046295,
0.4281434416770935,
0.6940451860427856,
-0.5523744225502014,
0.10729757696390152,
-0.19723965227603912,
-0.4505315124988556,
0.31091830134391785,
-0.08624386787414551,
-0.541140615940094,
0.056418150663375854,
0.2321348488330841,
0.7956877946853638,
-0.02757870778441429,
-0.3319706916809082,
0.3797633647918701,
-0.0889812782406807,
0.016487156972289085,
-0.441214919090271,
0.1440831571817398,
-0.29071199893951416,
0.2359747439622879,
0.7539084553718567,
0.4823988676071167,
0.510084867477417,
-0.7643168568611145,
0.36022067070007324,
0.3908328711986542,
-0.7101072072982788,
-0.2450881004333496,
0.5989866852760315,
0.34675332903862,
-0.3070204257965088,
0.8960186243057251,
0.35193464159965515,
-0.19733834266662598,
0.481124609708786,
0.4038986563682556,
1.2810077667236328,
0.03213364630937576,
0.11927932500839233,
0.6124488711357117,
0.2839941382408142,
-0.03527999296784401,
-0.3642343580722809,
-0.32732006907463074,
-0.6642151474952698,
-0.20091688632965088,
-0.4005308151245117,
-0.4134162664413452,
0.3059874475002289,
-0.8598993420600891,
0.5175871849060059,
-0.4118075966835022,
-0.3774476647377014,
-0.10092063248157501,
-0.11232254654169083,
-0.5537481307983398,
-0.191515251994133,
0.49129360914230347,
0.5666819214820862,
-0.42992696166038513,
0.47856998443603516,
0.4009855091571808,
-0.4346621334552765,
-0.6111652851104736,
0.5292890071868896,
0.4653458893299103,
-0.6866028308868408,
0.36563640832901,
-0.10774488002061844,
-0.24868856370449066,
-0.25697141885757446,
-0.4418759346008301,
-0.8193283081054688,
0.9813473224639893,
0.15549838542938232,
-0.4933817982673645,
-0.1097312644124031,
-0.3018752634525299,
0.6696755290031433,
-0.5554943680763245,
0.8491341471672058,
0.4449063539505005,
0.4834894835948944,
-0.06842328608036041,
-0.6272162795066833,
0.21661782264709473,
-0.48872891068458557,
-0.048894211649894714,
0.07020249962806702,
-0.6309090852737427,
0.5962051749229431,
-0.23492997884750366,
-0.13295334577560425,
-0.3916997015476227,
0.14043155312538147,
0.24935248494148254,
0.38500702381134033,
0.471876323223114,
0.48295488953590393,
0.3214777112007141,
-0.030720490962266922,
1.029941201210022,
-0.4848901927471161,
0.14020583033561707,
1.0334608554840088,
-0.14592058956623077,
0.8142138719558716,
0.5426417589187622,
-0.2067076861858368,
0.9386502504348755,
0.7181508541107178,
-0.37235262989997864,
0.5481621623039246,
0.07218337059020996,
-0.002140629105269909,
0.1849028319120407,
-0.5919162631034851,
-0.7088988423347473,
0.38143685460090637,
0.15001779794692993,
-0.7531000971794128,
0.014075295068323612,
-0.17681725323200226,
0.03860035911202431,
-0.14737355709075928,
-0.17813535034656525,
0.9839752912521362,
-0.051868438720703125,
-1.0347484350204468,
0.4785485565662384,
-0.5229296088218689,
0.6127039194107056,
-0.49815502762794495,
-0.15653112530708313,
-0.2905838191509247,
0.07905307412147522,
-0.3068762719631195,
-0.5838789939880371,
0.13837222754955292,
-0.12737008929252625,
-0.4525653123855591,
-0.2665407955646515,
0.6181737780570984,
-0.37479153275489807,
-0.32247287034988403,
0.6214216351509094,
0.43326079845428467,
-0.32507458329200745,
-0.22579379379749298,
-0.5303086638450623,
0.045171111822128296,
0.11325285583734512,
-0.34261080622673035,
0.28242412209510803,
-0.04418310150504112,
0.3276335597038269,
0.3856717348098755,
0.8351702690124512,
0.5604100823402405,
-0.13331963121891022,
0.055388398468494415,
0.7233636975288391,
-0.5033653378486633,
-0.6162319183349609,
-0.8669144511222839,
0.2609963119029999,
-0.08893755823373795,
-0.17253747582435608,
0.8093404173851013,
0.13312110304832458,
0.950797975063324,
0.29197612404823303,
1.1397523880004883,
0.076141357421875,
0.22943001985549927,
-0.012508413754403591,
0.8383452892303467,
-0.4027787148952484,
0.6992704272270203,
-0.30820271372795105,
-1.1137789487838745,
0.37303608655929565,
0.06148850545287132,
-0.26614731550216675,
0.24161924421787262,
0.6365629434585571,
0.6943836808204651,
0.18603046238422394,
0.14098265767097473,
-0.08950747549533844,
0.2363341897726059,
0.39688920974731445,
0.14842741191387177,
1.0254627466201782,
-0.29417023062705994,
0.7419686317443848,
-0.3991835117340088,
-0.13423338532447815,
-0.5423238277435303,
-0.37598711252212524,
-0.5890190601348877,
-0.5836191177368164,
-0.08556389063596725,
-0.8009713888168335,
0.28493732213974,
0.9798239469528198,
0.8665473461151123,
-0.9435933828353882,
-0.2006155550479889,
-0.19551941752433777,
0.3534355163574219,
-0.5229573249816895,
-0.3081645667552948,
0.2586117088794708,
-0.2529926896095276,
-0.6722224950790405,
0.17357772588729858,
0.2702188491821289,
-0.2803784906864166,
-0.7658982276916504,
0.08822162449359894,
-0.02167125791311264,
0.12286674976348877,
0.18244792520999908,
-0.1671900600194931,
-0.8604047298431396,
-0.36431413888931274,
0.12000653892755508,
-0.08011806011199951,
0.015527943149209023,
1.1501814126968384,
-0.8151550889015198,
0.8728130459785461,
0.5297895073890686,
0.34264063835144043,
0.36662957072257996,
0.30192628502845764,
1.0774229764938354,
-0.4135175943374634,
-0.07154642045497894,
0.06968579441308975,
0.21211344003677368,
-0.03699338436126709,
-0.921271562576294,
0.37836894392967224,
0.21884122490882874,
-0.8540322184562683,
-0.8831583261489868,
-0.042222291231155396,
-0.684448778629303,
-0.5206974148750305,
1.1272975206375122,
0.22636179625988007,
0.21151591837406158,
-0.053434837609529495,
-0.320081889629364,
0.2737256586551666,
-0.8635150790214539,
1.3561137914657593,
1.0362932682037354,
-0.2895582914352417,
-0.139593705534935,
-0.5938207507133484,
0.5483083724975586,
0.30541133880615234,
-0.4555070996284485,
0.024401767179369926,
0.5715790390968323,
0.0950821042060852,
0.3753231465816498,
0.16887874901294708,
-0.1503130942583084,
0.20801229774951935,
0.14544932544231415,
-0.0351317822933197,
-0.34681636095046997,
-0.34863460063934326,
-0.72591632604599,
0.32312220335006714,
0.03168279305100441,
-0.15139806270599365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17992v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17992v1
|
fMRI predictors based on language models of increasing complexity recover brain left lateralization
| 2024-05-28T09:24:52 | 2024-05-28T09:24:52 |
Laurent Bonnasse-Gahot, Christophe Pallier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, q-bio.NC
|
Over the past decade, studies of naturalistic language processing where
participants are scanned while listening to continuous text have flourished.
Using word embeddings at first, then large language models, researchers have
created encoding models to analyze the brain signals. Presenting these models
with the same text as the participants allows to identify brain areas where
there is a significant correlation between the functional magnetic resonance
imaging (fMRI) time series and the ones predicted by the models' artificial
neurons. One intriguing finding from these studies is that they have revealed
highly symmetric bilateral activation patterns, somewhat at odds with the
well-known left lateralization of language processing. Here, we report analyses
of an fMRI dataset where we manipulate the complexity of large language models,
testing 28 pretrained models from 8 different families, ranging from 124M to
14.2B parameters. First, we observe that the performance of models in
predicting brain responses follows a scaling law, where the fit with brain
activity increases linearly with the logarithm of the number of parameters of
the model (and its performance on natural language processing tasks). Second,
we show that a left-right asymmetry gradually appears as model size increases,
and that the difference in left-right brain correlations also follows a scaling
law. Whereas the smallest models show no asymmetry, larger models fit better
and better left hemispheric activations than right hemispheric ones. This
finding reconciles computational analyses of brain activity using large
language models with the classic observation from aphasic patients showing left
hemisphere dominance for language.
|
[
-0.25230661034584045,
-0.906151294708252,
0.6550391912460327,
0.4659942388534546,
-0.06362110376358032,
-0.233503058552742,
-0.44453027844429016,
-0.7310975790023804,
0.343092143535614,
0.4136662185192108,
-0.513827919960022,
-0.038100454956293106,
-0.8612657189369202,
0.05040716007351875,
-0.31306788325309753,
0.691274881362915,
0.11446371674537659,
0.5225346684455872,
-0.245979905128479,
-0.3406389057636261,
-0.4236410856246948,
-0.5324379205703735,
-0.815437912940979,
-0.7492852210998535,
0.3718525171279907,
-0.23577658832073212,
1.0129213333129883,
0.7519186735153198,
0.44224753975868225,
0.254903644323349,
-0.3665771484375,
-0.46322736144065857,
-0.27109310030937195,
-0.02794399857521057,
0.20124028623104095,
-0.4248282015323639,
-0.5204219818115234,
-0.1714375913143158,
0.7900083661079407,
1.2481073141098022,
-0.07572443783283234,
-0.15939204394817352,
0.18115325272083282,
0.7445517778396606,
-0.2759478986263275,
0.1289542019367218,
-0.2874315083026886,
-0.11363953351974487,
-0.19505880773067474,
-0.13709518313407898,
-0.3514149785041809,
-0.1024583950638771,
0.22249256074428558,
-0.279541939496994,
-0.04853825271129608,
-0.056675024330616,
0.8617937564849854,
0.14570178091526031,
-0.38614875078201294,
-0.2814391255378723,
-0.709101676940918,
0.7952302694320679,
-0.7543601989746094,
0.6229844093322754,
0.822746753692627,
0.0891294926404953,
-0.23119761049747467,
-0.4669208526611328,
-0.38336801528930664,
-0.316800594329834,
-0.2254984974861145,
-0.18046776950359344,
-0.3040805757045746,
0.1145947128534317,
0.48696914315223694,
0.015284774824976921,
-0.6801455616950989,
0.3398883044719696,
-0.5018806457519531,
-0.19248825311660767,
0.660280168056488,
0.32060542702674866,
0.6410648226737976,
0.1615627259016037,
-0.10507654398679733,
0.17701683938503265,
-0.5750082731246948,
0.00502068130299449,
0.46512892842292786,
0.1594361662864685,
-0.06909769028425217,
0.8121833801269531,
0.015539608895778656,
0.9932785630226135,
0.12274907529354095,
0.03848538547754288,
0.2790255844593048,
-0.2099839597940445,
-0.23894836008548737,
-0.14559169113636017,
0.842491626739502,
0.25546351075172424,
0.23185405135154724,
-0.09270408004522324,
-0.3059290945529938,
-0.03263312950730324,
0.1304505467414856,
-0.5225463509559631,
-0.1082780584692955,
0.1539565622806549,
-0.6582233905792236,
-0.11545226722955704,
-0.2356376349925995,
-0.4850417375564575,
-0.6084572076797485,
-0.31306153535842896,
0.40729281306266785,
-0.5544922351837158,
-0.4851088523864746,
0.307210773229599,
-0.05667385458946228,
0.25159069895744324,
-0.10595555603504181,
-0.903382420539856,
0.3330856263637543,
0.7139163613319397,
0.7664486169815063,
-0.24464766681194305,
-0.4165540337562561,
-0.1991046816110611,
-0.33896028995513916,
-0.2593422532081604,
0.558860182762146,
-0.7417362928390503,
-0.0994861051440239,
0.05710555985569954,
0.08569065481424332,
-0.2413880079984665,
-0.4070133864879608,
0.4451085031032562,
-0.7542674541473389,
0.10212790966033936,
-0.405038058757782,
-0.2407015711069107,
-0.1795782446861267,
0.13863535225391388,
-0.819531261920929,
0.7384713292121887,
-0.2071351855993271,
-1.0255539417266846,
0.07947319000959396,
-0.5614388585090637,
-0.5619425773620605,
-0.030370287597179413,
-0.3958037197589874,
-0.49612993001937866,
0.47890669107437134,
-0.07792329788208008,
0.36727049946784973,
-0.438866525888443,
0.46497488021850586,
-0.5413922667503357,
-0.21935002505779266,
0.5104502439498901,
-0.18849386274814606,
1.0448729991912842,
0.06477848440408707,
-0.19010891020298004,
0.13838666677474976,
-0.6771213412284851,
-0.22970882058143616,
0.08613795042037964,
-0.30460020899772644,
-0.4547610580921173,
0.17659245431423187,
0.06817489862442017,
0.21175891160964966,
0.17706291377544403,
-0.6122962832450867,
-0.39154890179634094,
-0.2921197712421417,
0.4452950954437256,
0.31000831723213196,
-0.08207248151302338,
0.5486879944801331,
-0.406022310256958,
0.4293058514595032,
0.147874116897583,
-0.08772438019514084,
0.14001914858818054,
-0.503548264503479,
-0.6024301052093506,
-0.46939000487327576,
0.35388413071632385,
0.21973209083080292,
-0.389790415763855,
0.40946102142333984,
-0.7459308505058289,
-0.32721999287605286,
-0.3150601387023926,
-0.3434373736381531,
0.10758557915687561,
0.11603724211454391,
0.28428664803504944,
-0.44629180431365967,
-0.552375853061676,
-1.300068736076355,
-0.5989789366722107,
-0.08391948789358139,
-0.32350173592567444,
0.017757128924131393,
0.1901310831308365,
-0.6139259338378906,
0.8668766617774963,
-0.26376593112945557,
-0.26968345046043396,
-0.249332457780838,
0.47809112071990967,
0.1676035374403,
0.3076092302799225,
0.18636521697044373,
-0.66312575340271,
-0.3590579926967621,
0.1512230783700943,
-0.7119033932685852,
-0.00021389716130215675,
-0.20801854133605957,
0.14332246780395508,
0.33973145484924316,
0.7614637613296509,
-0.5134484767913818,
0.20218044519424438,
0.5302209258079529,
-0.42813840508461,
0.1946066915988922,
-0.32098641991615295,
-0.201381653547287,
-0.756546139717102,
0.34217527508735657,
0.01742539182305336,
0.08479992300271988,
-0.9615535140037537,
-0.3643540143966675,
0.21976158022880554,
0.05962518975138664,
0.40431854128837585,
0.31493890285491943,
-0.8224485516548157,
-0.08302222937345505,
-0.4708746671676636,
-0.23167474567890167,
-0.5739533305168152,
0.41320082545280457,
0.3137511610984802,
0.05476751551032066,
0.6182214617729187,
-0.3070231080055237,
-0.25801560282707214,
-0.2015981376171112,
-0.355487585067749,
-0.0032747748773545027,
-0.7351347208023071,
0.08604898303747177,
-0.5395296216011047,
0.0903550237417221,
-1.0917408466339111,
-0.23469595611095428,
-0.1739179939031601,
-0.37368303537368774,
0.3997466564178467,
0.11729902774095535,
-0.2744908332824707,
-0.3965875804424286,
-0.1526079922914505,
0.6395118236541748,
0.4429561495780945,
-0.16126418113708496,
1.192650318145752,
0.5817365646362305,
-0.2435736358165741,
-0.6959357261657715,
-0.8254559636116028,
-0.12871800363063812,
-0.005917618982493877,
-0.6154269576072693,
0.12268458306789398,
-0.05199603736400604,
-0.19818703830242157,
-0.03253387287259102,
-0.08749494701623917,
-0.1672709882259369,
0.12237047404050827,
0.6345421075820923,
0.0940701812505722,
-0.24644218385219574,
-0.015093639492988586,
0.201046422123909,
0.19014151394367218,
0.5140565037727356,
0.1025657206773758,
0.7161081433296204,
-0.06776385754346848,
-0.12566597759723663,
-0.35650670528411865,
0.10930457711219788,
1.028239130973816,
-0.2573537528514862,
0.7486974000930786,
0.5496255159378052,
-0.7799789309501648,
0.1833881437778473,
-0.6515362858772278,
-0.2560621201992035,
-0.41473814845085144,
0.614434003829956,
-0.6464633345603943,
-0.6355091333389282,
0.6110445261001587,
0.19915179908275604,
-0.20615169405937195,
0.21982544660568237,
0.5723634958267212,
0.18985649943351746,
1.1413673162460327,
0.580247700214386,
-0.05267968028783798,
0.6956549286842346,
-0.043313167989254,
0.28237372636795044,
-0.7639532685279846,
-0.2710345983505249,
-0.29091814160346985,
-0.27950790524482727,
-0.5143579244613647,
-0.34186655282974243,
0.04277552664279938,
-0.22930602729320526,
0.011605651117861271,
0.14903049170970917,
-0.09518261253833771,
0.6716781854629517,
0.2121165543794632,
0.20446467399597168,
0.23223374783992767,
0.22298698127269745,
-0.10265199840068817,
-0.08329962939023972,
-0.5487797856330872,
-0.08419531583786011,
1.3200019598007202,
0.647434651851654,
0.7082066535949707,
-0.16428977251052856,
0.4679935574531555,
0.011630900204181671,
0.4295811951160431,
-0.785065770149231,
0.5552337169647217,
0.06586640328168869,
-0.6186102032661438,
-0.31230854988098145,
-0.31410732865333557,
-1.0608960390090942,
0.14579541981220245,
-0.46911612153053284,
-0.3862031102180481,
0.3735446035861969,
-0.21469666063785553,
-0.4227537512779236,
-0.10671321302652359,
-0.5099932551383972,
0.5582303404808044,
-0.16215507686138153,
-0.34469103813171387,
-0.41658979654312134,
-0.6818451881408691,
0.2150629460811615,
-0.24233683943748474,
0.34353509545326233,
0.09898032993078232,
-0.0541556142270565,
0.7174203395843506,
0.1866452395915985,
0.8126611709594727,
-0.1701211929321289,
-0.13683435320854187,
-0.2015460878610611,
0.15797753632068634,
0.2832484543323517,
-0.09617068618535995,
-0.25092554092407227,
0.34081870317459106,
0.0006921419990248978,
-0.577039897441864,
-0.4802267253398895,
1.0005542039871216,
-0.84932541847229,
-0.5899593234062195,
-0.5395238995552063,
-0.7388692498207092,
-0.1482694000005722,
0.46028757095336914,
0.44928061962127686,
0.4118518531322479,
-0.42699185013771057,
0.27403953671455383,
0.5185996294021606,
0.01964104175567627,
0.5014695525169373,
0.3073236644268036,
-0.33384618163108826,
-0.5224920511245728,
0.6612752676010132,
0.3962651789188385,
0.13875004649162292,
0.3077707886695862,
0.0840998962521553,
-0.2411351203918457,
-0.9498776197433472,
-0.16856983304023743,
0.6127979755401611,
-0.2862918972969055,
0.170970156788826,
-0.8589465022087097,
-0.21747572720050812,
-0.1232277974486351,
0.03703231364488602,
-0.25004082918167114,
-0.5180259346961975,
-0.045049216598272324,
0.028508758172392845,
-0.3685845732688904,
0.6866501569747925,
0.019593896344304085,
0.048657312989234924,
-0.4960058629512787,
0.17115521430969238,
0.22791971266269684,
0.30444464087486267,
0.054686643183231354,
-0.524884819984436,
-0.5350393652915955,
0.27637144923210144,
-0.058274149894714355,
-0.8954136967658997,
0.3721129894256592,
0.20986402034759521,
0.41586562991142273,
0.4626069664955139,
-0.22057364881038666,
0.36948806047439575,
-0.5816912651062012,
0.5047927498817444,
0.32605525851249695,
-0.7208108305931091,
-0.0028706067241728306,
-0.360856831073761,
0.4625832140445709,
0.16700440645217896,
0.7868527173995972,
-0.32006919384002686,
-0.4485228359699249,
-0.5916444063186646,
-0.5205679535865784,
0.6624184250831604,
0.14665508270263672,
0.13959954679012299,
0.1467454731464386,
0.300443172454834,
0.14972220361232758,
-0.3009311854839325,
-0.813029944896698,
0.007907267659902573,
0.04825553297996521,
-0.39937496185302734,
-0.14000585675239563,
-0.41032204031944275,
-0.37538042664527893,
-0.2938467264175415,
0.2325604408979416,
-0.012338872067630291,
0.5625842213630676,
0.06535201519727707,
-0.06218152865767479,
-0.3367527425289154,
0.0173454862087965,
0.6605674624443054,
0.5897401571273804,
-0.25669512152671814,
0.12887509167194366,
0.19676482677459717,
-0.480881929397583,
-0.14024284482002258,
0.3097356855869293,
0.023238250985741615,
-0.020132575184106827,
0.4582383930683136,
0.9478549361228943,
-0.09279919415712357,
-0.5566125512123108,
0.50105881690979,
-0.2380824238061905,
-0.16308757662773132,
-0.6675148010253906,
-0.17684431374073029,
0.29514357447624207,
0.420276403427124,
0.27366742491722107,
0.34900397062301636,
0.15337209403514862,
-0.449563205242157,
-0.144660085439682,
0.6406330466270447,
-0.43145203590393066,
-0.7504718899726868,
0.5000378489494324,
-0.028227411210536957,
-0.4623701870441437,
0.5496994256973267,
0.22247223556041718,
-0.3789037764072418,
0.4697714149951935,
0.7435835599899292,
0.940322756767273,
-0.06418905407190323,
-0.1698721945285797,
0.6129968762397766,
0.3674636483192444,
-0.4324590265750885,
0.39219528436660767,
0.13858096301555634,
-0.8636311292648315,
-0.20168866217136383,
-0.6435139179229736,
0.028246231377124786,
0.30342328548431396,
-0.7820794582366943,
0.3522075116634369,
-0.5003954768180847,
-0.537752091884613,
0.37689322233200073,
-0.1664629429578781,
-0.3757247030735016,
0.14569702744483948,
0.31522423028945923,
0.7452549934387207,
-1.0532399415969849,
1.197304129600525,
1.008056879043579,
-0.13377252221107483,
-0.30791163444519043,
0.2909473776817322,
-0.2989780306816101,
-0.40608471632003784,
0.5573557615280151,
0.3341718316078186,
-0.20064423978328705,
-0.004891975317150354,
-0.317576140165329,
-0.881523609161377,
0.8803302645683289,
0.3451308608055115,
-0.42991235852241516,
-0.3960292637348175,
0.26881784200668335,
1.0104446411132812,
-0.4880450963973999,
0.08986996114253998,
0.6097660064697266,
0.25419509410858154,
-0.302410364151001,
-0.681430459022522,
0.4560316503047943,
-0.288562536239624,
0.2326061874628067,
0.47429049015045166,
-0.20711857080459595,
0.7493059039115906,
-0.1932511031627655,
-0.4522985517978668,
0.0863979160785675,
0.7325523495674133,
0.0744246318936348,
0.257296621799469,
0.5292149186134338,
0.496889591217041,
0.5569859743118286,
0.017866799607872963,
0.950932502746582,
-0.4293212890625,
0.23422537744045258,
0.8921806812286377,
0.06681427359580994,
1.0623399019241333,
0.6591464877128601,
0.17865730822086334,
0.5905272960662842,
0.35619962215423584,
0.25641733407974243,
0.26434969902038574,
0.11137574166059494,
-0.038127269595861435,
-0.4371843934059143,
0.2183542102575302,
-0.2752395570278168,
0.24940474331378937,
0.4350007474422455,
-0.6308127045631409,
0.21984118223190308,
0.21284423768520355,
0.09243183583021164,
0.1812761127948761,
0.016712505370378494,
0.6129536032676697,
0.1668245941400528,
-0.8518081307411194,
0.8275957703590393,
0.0012850447092205286,
0.5683338046073914,
-0.5690481066703796,
0.4373845160007477,
-0.23015452921390533,
0.31866106390953064,
-0.07910678535699844,
-0.5512391924858093,
0.48126280307769775,
-0.31850147247314453,
-0.2202557772397995,
-0.013952587731182575,
0.6100055575370789,
-0.6991605162620544,
-0.3036540448665619,
0.6771356463432312,
0.3001810312271118,
-0.19166076183319092,
-0.021926846355199814,
-0.37936946749687195,
0.2668091058731079,
0.12722034752368927,
-0.31301313638687134,
0.5202025771141052,
0.2116241455078125,
-0.15521183609962463,
0.625928521156311,
0.523558497428894,
0.06427013128995895,
0.28206270933151245,
-0.2740379273891449,
0.784773051738739,
-0.8600642085075378,
-0.2271949201822281,
-0.9042506217956543,
0.3331564962863922,
-0.11655083298683167,
-0.035035163164138794,
0.4091735780239105,
0.498139351606369,
0.616040825843811,
-0.3083476126194,
0.31546905636787415,
-0.11375200748443604,
0.1631561815738678,
-0.29772865772247314,
0.794244647026062,
-0.6552647352218628,
0.07782112807035446,
0.312195748090744,
-0.7057338953018188,
-0.6362354755401611,
0.4323576092720032,
-0.7106326818466187,
-0.05982264131307602,
0.878391683101654,
0.9681036472320557,
-0.2728188931941986,
0.40570735931396484,
0.3300670087337494,
0.5774423480033875,
-0.01592377945780754,
0.42257657647132874,
0.7703550457954407,
-0.36337530612945557,
0.21570813655853271,
-0.1275557428598404,
-0.49621957540512085,
-0.18951942026615143,
-0.5039904117584229,
-0.923846423625946,
-0.7210719585418701,
-0.3385191261768341,
-0.47864702343940735,
-0.15037624537944794,
0.9689539670944214,
0.46372222900390625,
-0.7393789291381836,
-0.600045919418335,
-0.1835271567106247,
-0.15874174237251282,
-0.3552027940750122,
-0.14660775661468506,
0.24845989048480988,
-0.23106829822063446,
-0.7314664125442505,
0.2965640127658844,
0.19814442098140717,
-0.037194445729255676,
0.023945139721035957,
-0.09122717380523682,
-0.2565886080265045,
0.4060361087322235,
0.5826232433319092,
0.3849915862083435,
-0.6313947439193726,
-0.05505349487066269,
0.10709971934556961,
-0.349755197763443,
-0.10040317475795746,
0.8579951524734497,
-0.38759082555770874,
0.3979688584804535,
0.8644669651985168,
0.7802236676216125,
0.552000105381012,
-0.29048869013786316,
0.829099178314209,
-0.22418685257434845,
0.04740731045603752,
0.2013063281774521,
0.3761596083641052,
0.33336082100868225,
-0.19929610192775726,
0.32607731223106384,
-0.06229718029499054,
-0.5596973896026611,
-1.0039491653442383,
0.31808027625083923,
-0.918981671333313,
-0.2925126850605011,
1.2058724164962769,
0.07347972691059113,
-0.3558994233608246,
-0.196943998336792,
-0.10130644589662552,
0.13552391529083252,
0.06576520949602127,
0.9311559200286865,
0.93136066198349,
-0.3677610158920288,
0.11967738717794418,
-0.28177401423454285,
0.5140835642814636,
0.8872066736221313,
-0.27246713638305664,
0.19032052159309387,
0.510806679725647,
0.32367953658103943,
0.380594938993454,
0.5405434370040894,
-0.35603249073028564,
0.14845645427703857,
-0.09721221774816513,
-0.17960144579410553,
0.14531730115413666,
-0.26648664474487305,
-0.8617579340934753,
0.309756875038147,
0.25031813979148865,
0.042363766580820084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17980v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17980v1
|
Peering into the Mind of Language Models: An Approach for Attribution in Contextual Question Answering
| 2024-05-28T09:12:44 | 2024-05-28T09:12:44 |
Anirudh Phukan, Shwetha Somasundaram, Apoorv Saxena, Koustava Goswami, Balaji Vasan Srinivasan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the enhancement in the field of generative artificial intelligence (AI),
contextual question answering has become extremely relevant. Attributing model
generations to the input source document is essential to ensure trustworthiness
and reliability. We observe that when large language models (LLMs) are used for
contextual question answering, the output answer often consists of text copied
verbatim from the input prompt which is linked together with "glue text"
generated by the LLM. Motivated by this, we propose that LLMs have an inherent
awareness from where the text was copied, likely captured in the hidden states
of the LLM. We introduce a novel method for attribution in contextual question
answering, leveraging the hidden state representations of LLMs. Our approach
bypasses the need for extensive model retraining and retrieval model overhead,
offering granular attributions and preserving the quality of generated answers.
Our experimental results demonstrate that our method performs on par or better
than GPT-4 at identifying verbatim copied segments in LLM generations and in
attributing these segments to their source. Importantly, our method shows
robust performance across various LLM architectures, highlighting its broad
applicability. Additionally, we present Verifiability-granular, an attribution
dataset which has token level annotations for LLM generations in the contextual
question answering setup.
|
[
-0.1427939087152481,
-0.9226946234703064,
1.092896819114685,
-0.15332207083702087,
-0.17647004127502441,
-0.02447238564491272,
0.13809321820735931,
-0.2545638382434845,
-0.06828402727842331,
0.5452979207038879,
-0.7240132093429565,
-0.16832050681114197,
-0.33203068375587463,
-0.16773417592048645,
-0.7449742555618286,
0.7791928648948669,
-0.0023004470858722925,
-0.39379021525382996,
-0.8941150903701782,
0.1422881782054901,
-0.23787569999694824,
-0.6592798233032227,
-0.7212432622909546,
-0.488934189081192,
0.548197329044342,
0.16897204518318176,
0.5181215405464172,
0.8284085988998413,
0.1070084199309349,
0.2894846796989441,
-0.06584165245294571,
0.1274021416902542,
-0.4385586678981781,
-0.010460074990987778,
-0.4113216996192932,
-0.8338616490364075,
-0.30103474855422974,
0.0033122182358056307,
0.7137890458106995,
0.4554624855518341,
-0.02102840505540371,
0.36494097113609314,
-0.05244138464331627,
0.2385026067495346,
-0.7501964569091797,
0.06299854815006256,
-1.0725462436676025,
-0.09400331974029541,
-0.22198623418807983,
-0.5732188820838928,
-0.5287964940071106,
-0.4043715000152588,
-0.03237596154212952,
-0.46528327465057373,
0.17372874915599823,
0.00047263404121622443,
0.7526823878288269,
0.4774218499660492,
-0.5249596238136292,
-0.3534168303012848,
-0.49968066811561584,
0.7552691102027893,
-0.6820833086967468,
0.0346677340567112,
0.47514086961746216,
0.1285664141178131,
0.1806589663028717,
-0.723055899143219,
-0.7715843319892883,
0.02008218690752983,
-0.15683096647262573,
-0.056862104684114456,
-0.16169819235801697,
-0.42617377638816833,
-0.03896395489573479,
0.39458563923835754,
-0.33511781692504883,
-0.3318893611431122,
-0.11428704112768173,
-0.3361779749393463,
0.46031007170677185,
0.03431315720081329,
0.32391005754470825,
-0.3857726454734802,
-0.5664286613464355,
-0.02841830812394619,
-0.8620508313179016,
-0.07110228389501572,
0.03155655413866043,
0.17122811079025269,
0.07268635183572769,
0.46547189354896545,
0.1634126603603363,
0.5821108222007751,
0.1171393096446991,
0.07361571490764618,
0.0434504859149456,
-0.469245046377182,
-0.04234974458813667,
0.019319267943501472,
0.6216988563537598,
0.13594308495521545,
0.4744897186756134,
-0.2689770460128784,
-0.3123617172241211,
-0.20858405530452728,
0.5918192863464355,
-0.4209178388118744,
-0.045016735792160034,
-0.018542489036917686,
-0.2250535488128662,
-0.43806880712509155,
-0.10930974781513214,
-0.39671921730041504,
-0.36027446389198303,
-0.09968814253807068,
0.5546167492866516,
-0.2929750084877014,
-0.14551040530204773,
-0.27734965085983276,
-0.005049928091466427,
0.4917612075805664,
0.3383265733718872,
-0.7593056559562683,
0.1411133110523224,
0.9798012971878052,
0.7941505908966064,
-0.15812775492668152,
-0.3377739489078522,
-0.5075345039367676,
0.5455867052078247,
-0.5243499875068665,
0.7594797611236572,
-0.6262516975402832,
-0.3474481403827667,
0.07675386220216751,
-0.05413062497973442,
-0.1608617603778839,
-0.5854098200798035,
0.3768346309661865,
-0.812073290348053,
0.2644025683403015,
-0.4647942781448364,
-0.7093682885169983,
-0.1624554991722107,
0.48046547174453735,
-0.46763670444488525,
0.9519041776657104,
0.09022695571184158,
-0.577782928943634,
0.2666335105895996,
-0.5951205492019653,
-0.27987805008888245,
0.2296237051486969,
-0.39645859599113464,
-0.029923900961875916,
0.3277485966682434,
0.49303320050239563,
0.46274659037590027,
-0.1122310683131218,
0.32657572627067566,
-0.0888824537396431,
-0.17063672840595245,
0.657680869102478,
-0.7986932396888733,
0.8175657987594604,
0.12331375479698181,
-0.03869128227233887,
0.12733162939548492,
-0.46294549107551575,
0.0530686154961586,
0.3293820321559906,
-0.3457602560520172,
-0.651399552822113,
0.10977190732955933,
-0.16398131847381592,
0.09338504821062088,
0.4059278964996338,
-0.4669075310230255,
0.06971367448568344,
-0.3081367313861847,
0.6084800958633423,
0.8292232751846313,
0.16228577494621277,
0.42714983224868774,
-0.12917333841323853,
0.5894879698753357,
0.00018232231377623975,
-0.11943885684013367,
-0.22643673419952393,
-0.29560986161231995,
-0.6996832489967346,
0.03614691272377968,
-0.1385018676519394,
0.5311025381088257,
-0.8498583436012268,
0.1695774346590042,
-0.5549858808517456,
-0.23108910024166107,
-0.40477851033210754,
0.03788163512945175,
0.5943887233734131,
0.8896106481552124,
0.26242882013320923,
-0.03705809637904167,
-0.10943684726953506,
-1.034349799156189,
-0.3557747006416321,
-0.5149477124214172,
-0.15099570155143738,
0.6821025013923645,
0.6404352188110352,
0.031337182968854904,
1.1942896842956543,
-0.6384398341178894,
0.03531016781926155,
-0.19921095669269562,
0.07354126125574112,
-0.1052650585770607,
0.41139501333236694,
0.4943223297595978,
-0.8086908459663391,
-0.18887139856815338,
-0.060544222593307495,
-0.9405810832977295,
-0.007747028023004532,
-0.015380521304905415,
-0.25261998176574707,
0.07340949028730392,
0.8133986592292786,
-0.6308315992355347,
0.032087650150060654,
0.4890221059322357,
-0.49925145506858826,
0.3735010325908661,
-0.04853121191263199,
0.13061729073524475,
-1.3898600339889526,
0.24820291996002197,
-0.3563147187232971,
-0.5147384405136108,
-0.5554586052894592,
0.405796617269516,
0.2513423264026642,
-0.10712447017431259,
-0.6690729260444641,
0.7911160588264465,
-0.4144665002822876,
-0.07874602824449539,
-0.10452251881361008,
0.264451801776886,
0.17594453692436218,
0.3616240918636322,
-0.09458683431148529,
1.0818032026290894,
0.34830811619758606,
-0.2878412902355194,
0.4069669246673584,
0.3438670039176941,
-0.35384050011634827,
0.5897031426429749,
-0.5350885391235352,
0.45089322328567505,
-0.19221103191375732,
0.1479082703590393,
-0.8855970501899719,
-0.2673198878765106,
0.17510229349136353,
-0.5180914402008057,
0.29049259424209595,
-0.33294156193733215,
-0.4147534966468811,
-0.1496170461177826,
-0.11406275629997253,
0.6974963545799255,
0.29566702246665955,
-0.5004639625549316,
0.72472083568573,
0.3116888999938965,
-0.394146203994751,
-0.6073029637336731,
-0.8497138619422913,
0.15734587609767914,
-0.5082830786705017,
-0.5229641795158386,
0.22851718962192535,
0.08266210556030273,
-0.2615838646888733,
0.06346698105335236,
-0.12407099455595016,
-0.22785760462284088,
0.1679479032754898,
-0.039333030581474304,
0.2747001051902771,
-0.3635377287864685,
0.2153741419315338,
-0.11478342860937119,
-0.013013211078941822,
0.5037091970443726,
-0.16099674999713898,
0.5897068381309509,
-0.23333220183849335,
-0.400238037109375,
-0.12818239629268646,
0.5241670608520508,
0.480471670627594,
-0.2932126224040985,
0.7496843934059143,
0.305668443441391,
-0.4156605005264282,
-0.25848010182380676,
-0.5304868817329407,
-0.3288804590702057,
-0.5046461224555969,
0.5214853882789612,
-0.41181057691574097,
-0.9057386517524719,
0.7266284823417664,
0.26067471504211426,
-0.19562286138534546,
0.35650572180747986,
0.5184047222137451,
0.017750000581145287,
0.7400822639465332,
0.7487346529960632,
-0.40921974182128906,
0.36002030968666077,
0.08869677782058716,
0.17199288308620453,
-0.7706502676010132,
-0.22365283966064453,
-0.3630581796169281,
-0.025578800588846207,
-0.12803120911121368,
-0.6936174035072327,
0.2995991110801697,
0.0651853159070015,
-0.1345432698726654,
0.10998042672872543,
-0.1921926587820053,
0.7121202349662781,
0.6048339605331421,
0.09466028213500977,
0.4567341208457947,
-0.11082883924245834,
0.3047291338443756,
0.2929490804672241,
-0.6768640875816345,
-0.6129578948020935,
1.0299071073532104,
0.3030998408794403,
0.5882646441459656,
0.19000059366226196,
0.5438946485519409,
0.2612905502319336,
0.3213016092777252,
-0.8078441023826599,
0.7537446618080139,
0.11121335625648499,
-0.8191962242126465,
-0.46165966987609863,
-0.35621559619903564,
-0.5861440300941467,
0.17282205820083618,
0.15112195909023285,
-1.073701024055481,
-0.04992096498608589,
0.38564059138298035,
-0.34025731682777405,
0.314053475856781,
-0.4329563081264496,
0.9701104760169983,
0.11867587268352509,
-0.3853687644004822,
-0.12004759162664413,
-0.5212071537971497,
0.39019691944122314,
-0.10956647992134094,
-0.05056578293442726,
0.13240984082221985,
-0.14991547167301178,
0.7434210181236267,
-0.2528134286403656,
0.8214636445045471,
-0.0941522866487503,
-0.5911280512809753,
0.4012458622455597,
0.22004012763500214,
0.6211168169975281,
0.16933725774288177,
0.04338650777935982,
-0.016233526170253754,
-0.008222879841923714,
-0.1866554617881775,
-0.7313774228096008,
0.8570309281349182,
-0.5334661602973938,
-0.8555463552474976,
-0.14413589239120483,
-0.702245831489563,
-0.22271500527858734,
0.22740736603736877,
0.21938534080982208,
0.6269932389259338,
0.1079055592417717,
0.22891707718372345,
0.8539773225784302,
-0.05796822905540466,
0.35433274507522583,
0.15430304408073425,
-0.18549013137817383,
0.07339832186698914,
1.0508843660354614,
-0.3095734417438507,
0.39432743191719055,
0.434551477432251,
0.1785896122455597,
-0.4353344142436981,
-0.34855005145072937,
-0.5114626288414001,
0.2702001631259918,
-1.0739392042160034,
-0.10584785789251328,
-0.571626603603363,
-0.3473047614097595,
-0.20836098492145538,
-0.48223674297332764,
-0.5406475067138672,
-0.13906577229499817,
-0.37390056252479553,
-0.1230832189321518,
0.1697644293308258,
0.5028623342514038,
0.42013657093048096,
0.20916354656219482,
-0.6358250975608826,
0.12522085011005402,
0.5698190927505493,
0.0197774488478899,
0.16704592108726501,
-0.5025803446769714,
-0.07022680342197418,
-0.003551009576767683,
-0.12706470489501953,
-0.8816713094711304,
0.19231627881526947,
0.29479655623435974,
0.5728250741958618,
0.35346439480781555,
-0.11683433502912521,
0.637901246547699,
-0.476068913936615,
1.0317710638046265,
-0.21695150434970856,
-1.1008045673370361,
0.7220510244369507,
-0.46782517433166504,
0.4741101861000061,
0.45861825346946716,
0.3234477937221527,
-0.481575608253479,
-0.5364174842834473,
-0.525078296661377,
-0.8943483233451843,
0.6559126377105713,
-0.04260658845305443,
0.5022658705711365,
-0.11814003437757492,
0.6464041471481323,
-0.03147585317492485,
0.3302116096019745,
-0.7727811336517334,
-0.2442220002412796,
-0.13069681823253632,
-0.23958954215049744,
-0.2884135842323303,
-0.3861762583255768,
-0.3647620975971222,
0.00778767466545105,
0.38198408484458923,
-0.47167643904685974,
0.41377854347229004,
0.11590772867202759,
-0.2823057472705841,
-0.07682325690984726,
0.283621609210968,
0.4921911954879761,
0.9400873184204102,
0.001043703407049179,
0.4287027418613434,
0.110209621489048,
-0.29097193479537964,
0.013689754530787468,
-0.32585668563842773,
-0.44088855385780334,
-0.2877766489982605,
0.665952742099762,
0.6643972992897034,
-0.005212927702814341,
-0.6008698344230652,
0.6930941939353943,
0.2301958054304123,
-0.10027752816677094,
-0.4952905774116516,
0.10667633265256882,
0.2764524519443512,
0.3624524474143982,
0.4539918303489685,
-0.13200676441192627,
0.16332973539829254,
-0.8389905691146851,
0.19592835009098053,
0.6861085295677185,
-0.5228584408760071,
-0.38141176104545593,
0.7089947462081909,
-0.04128807783126831,
-0.13434356451034546,
0.7527832388877869,
0.21552766859531403,
-0.6155513525009155,
0.4238887131214142,
0.6769376993179321,
0.8932733535766602,
-0.03824683278799057,
0.1831672638654709,
0.10671646147966385,
0.017841801047325134,
0.16525399684906006,
0.06654509156942368,
-0.17819790542125702,
-1.037933349609375,
-0.4393134117126465,
-0.5584366917610168,
-0.17898738384246826,
0.2112756222486496,
-0.7970638275146484,
-0.3733145594596863,
-0.1121058538556099,
-0.010329979471862316,
-0.28209832310676575,
-0.4194095730781555,
-0.4141424000263214,
0.1478225439786911,
0.5136650204658508,
0.7102875113487244,
-1.0097712278366089,
0.7298536896705627,
0.7442837357521057,
-0.296597421169281,
-0.6751701831817627,
0.3636327087879181,
0.15364208817481995,
-1.140903353691101,
0.6052591800689697,
0.027526672929525375,
-0.3242062032222748,
0.23992815613746643,
-0.7721344232559204,
-1.0143725872039795,
1.1319204568862915,
0.4116126000881195,
0.025259559974074364,
-0.2385156899690628,
0.07300805300474167,
0.3304954767227173,
-0.4320371448993683,
-0.03382351994514465,
0.6629759073257446,
0.18697033822536469,
0.20388197898864746,
-0.7472845315933228,
0.4420553147792816,
-0.24592822790145874,
0.015112114138901234,
-0.03541671857237816,
-0.45239585638046265,
0.822904646396637,
-0.19524827599525452,
-0.31734010577201843,
-0.0836716890335083,
0.762481689453125,
0.3706015646457672,
0.0516204833984375,
0.45763957500457764,
0.219243586063385,
0.7623162865638733,
-0.023251093924045563,
1.129101276397705,
-0.13764476776123047,
0.19745323061943054,
1.1587245464324951,
0.02505321614444256,
1.026834487915039,
0.9602351188659668,
-0.02549809403717518,
0.4556933343410492,
0.40144839882850647,
0.16792815923690796,
0.6948323249816895,
0.10796757787466049,
-0.2752338647842407,
-0.2640630006790161,
-0.17630556225776672,
-0.06256476789712906,
0.3867393732070923,
0.22542139887809753,
-0.4896695911884308,
-0.09029965847730637,
-0.12600354850292206,
0.27065756916999817,
0.13243383169174194,
-0.43477970361709595,
0.8266228437423706,
0.06783483177423477,
-0.7178603410720825,
0.5844326615333557,
-0.3075336813926697,
0.4588029980659485,
-0.5699159502983093,
0.16839392483234406,
-0.3246414363384247,
0.2812694013118744,
0.0708274245262146,
-0.8784186840057373,
0.36996686458587646,
-0.0017356288153678179,
-0.360119104385376,
-0.4106561839580536,
0.5948482155799866,
-0.4595169126987457,
-0.556023120880127,
0.0187459085136652,
0.6855506896972656,
0.2750985324382782,
-0.2882555425167084,
-0.4380344748497009,
-0.09272874146699905,
0.04094843193888664,
-0.6056215167045593,
0.20700472593307495,
0.5359247326850891,
-0.22389188408851624,
1.0906316041946411,
0.3510213792324066,
0.10034647583961487,
0.11037926375865936,
-0.011921667493879795,
0.9201837182044983,
-0.5536659955978394,
-0.48573100566864014,
-1.0029898881912231,
0.46603044867515564,
-0.023741696029901505,
-0.3434583246707916,
0.8081068396568298,
0.3832174241542816,
0.9382662773132324,
-0.1274455040693283,
0.8386636972427368,
-0.055347930639982224,
0.30170515179634094,
-0.5978946089744568,
0.8252034187316895,
-0.8449798822402954,
0.15067388117313385,
-0.34180521965026855,
-0.9738817811012268,
-0.1142100915312767,
0.48122158646583557,
-0.4251568615436554,
0.03923375904560089,
0.6285424828529358,
0.8628315925598145,
-0.13091082870960236,
-0.2570088505744934,
0.25272735953330994,
0.10415029525756836,
0.4253244400024414,
0.5973825454711914,
0.8841138482093811,
-0.16657540202140808,
0.43601635098457336,
-0.0011614758986979723,
-0.16929984092712402,
-0.15057136118412018,
-0.9221394658088684,
-0.6360526084899902,
-0.6514579057693481,
-0.31719592213630676,
0.0529680959880352,
-0.001534699578769505,
0.4976106882095337,
0.5267882347106934,
-0.632438600063324,
-0.048150431364774704,
-0.018614724278450012,
-0.20621326565742493,
-0.17896296083927155,
-0.2959507703781128,
0.4951073229312897,
-0.2850482165813446,
-0.5715720057487488,
0.5895431637763977,
0.08696704357862473,
-0.0018791789188981056,
-0.552064836025238,
0.16367939114570618,
-0.2327001392841339,
0.329224169254303,
0.5865377187728882,
-0.006444921717047691,
-0.9531965255737305,
-0.672674298286438,
-0.09768672287464142,
-0.024454127997159958,
-0.031199337914586067,
0.8064106106758118,
-0.7697218656539917,
0.21189552545547485,
0.3879866898059845,
0.7305482029914856,
0.2852543592453003,
0.5392052531242371,
0.7223604917526245,
-0.9449722766876221,
-0.07267340272665024,
0.27016666531562805,
0.21297624707221985,
0.47519510984420776,
-0.45871594548225403,
0.18483401834964752,
0.08561282604932785,
-0.4928223192691803,
-0.7108915448188782,
0.36517077684402466,
-0.792749285697937,
-0.36890238523483276,
1.111548662185669,
-0.3659455478191376,
-0.33014699816703796,
-0.025513041764497757,
0.08574525266885757,
0.17482136189937592,
-0.20096760988235474,
0.6687512993812561,
0.7938055992126465,
0.04160379245877266,
-0.3902880847454071,
-0.5499144196510315,
0.5261613130569458,
0.47369566559791565,
-0.7583137154579163,
0.515696108341217,
0.500739336013794,
0.266403466463089,
0.2918778657913208,
0.5904124975204468,
-0.15997867286205292,
-0.1425725668668747,
0.18833941221237183,
-0.10456779599189758,
-0.14394532144069672,
-0.33688849210739136,
-0.1961311548948288,
0.3430343568325043,
0.19908732175827026,
-0.04078148677945137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17978v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17978v1
|
FASTopic: A Fast, Adaptive, Stable, and Transferable Topic Modeling Paradigm
| 2024-05-28T09:06:38 | 2024-05-28T09:06:38 |
Xiaobao Wu, Thong Nguyen, Delvin Ce Zhang, William Yang Wang, Anh Tuan Luu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Topic models have been evolving rapidly over the years, from conventional to
recent neural models. However, existing topic models generally struggle with
either effectiveness, efficiency, or stability, highly impeding their practical
applications. In this paper, we propose FASTopic, a fast, adaptive, stable, and
transferable topic model. FASTopic follows a new paradigm: Dual
Semantic-relation Reconstruction (DSR). Instead of previous conventional,
neural VAE-based or clustering-based methods, DSR discovers latent topics by
reconstruction through modeling the semantic relations among document, topic,
and word embeddings. This brings about a neat and efficient topic modeling
framework. We further propose a novel Embedding Transport Plan (ETP) method.
Rather than early straightforward approaches, ETP explicitly regularizes the
semantic relations as optimal transport plans. This addresses the relation bias
issue and thus leads to effective topic modeling. Extensive experiments on
benchmark datasets demonstrate that our FASTopic shows superior effectiveness,
efficiency, adaptivity, stability, and transferability, compared to
state-of-the-art baselines across various scenarios. Our code is available at
https://github.com/bobxwu/FASTopic .
|
[
-0.5405008792877197,
-0.9233618974685669,
0.6615101099014282,
0.17714595794677734,
-0.44659343361854553,
-0.1955801099538803,
-0.22663311660289764,
-0.04102613404393196,
0.6183916926383972,
0.5308098196983337,
-0.3638632893562317,
-0.07262986153364182,
-0.8196864724159241,
-0.31494298577308655,
-0.44517552852630615,
0.8506078720092773,
0.17170757055282593,
-0.3072948157787323,
0.013413055799901485,
-0.25202029943466187,
-0.30387693643569946,
-0.10330446064472198,
-0.5704398155212402,
0.14836372435092926,
0.2641350030899048,
0.5311295390129089,
1.0574029684066772,
0.8529094457626343,
0.5741028785705566,
0.292085200548172,
-0.16740483045578003,
-0.22185157239437103,
-0.33916807174682617,
0.16952167451381683,
-0.6731132864952087,
0.021482668817043304,
-0.5149428844451904,
-0.1360597461462021,
0.6473190784454346,
0.8105777502059937,
-0.32517901062965393,
-0.20873695611953735,
-0.3010842800140381,
0.5355296730995178,
-0.5509791970252991,
-0.06750290095806122,
-0.9122048020362854,
0.029011990875005722,
-0.16642330586910248,
-0.38917970657348633,
-0.23845824599266052,
-0.2088315337896347,
0.7740885615348816,
-0.7479590177536011,
0.2828410267829895,
-0.13116009533405304,
0.6245127320289612,
0.2422497570514679,
-0.7213960886001587,
-0.3686455190181732,
-0.6660990118980408,
0.34451979398727417,
-0.39157742261886597,
0.42584025859832764,
0.03445122763514519,
0.453180730342865,
-0.06863933801651001,
-0.9222581386566162,
-0.4952238202095032,
-0.04170536994934082,
0.08727610856294632,
-0.11008249968290329,
0.0032386842649430037,
-0.19411106407642365,
-0.11427145451307297,
0.14375416934490204,
-0.558167040348053,
0.02254551462829113,
-0.13253328204154968,
-0.19974803924560547,
0.5214220285415649,
0.3549893796443939,
0.396861732006073,
-0.1788480579853058,
-0.6590537428855896,
0.1531885415315628,
-0.3902202844619751,
-0.33331000804901123,
0.06119382008910179,
0.3935902714729309,
-0.18998433649539948,
0.2737797796726227,
-0.2526284456253052,
0.7215352654457092,
0.1559850424528122,
0.021165987476706505,
-0.019504593685269356,
-0.627587616443634,
0.19016298651695251,
-0.09287508577108383,
0.4617886245250702,
0.3564993739128113,
-0.11480364203453064,
-0.17416243255138397,
0.1262970119714737,
0.09592510759830475,
0.3339311182498932,
-0.9893768429756165,
-0.24772889912128448,
0.17495964467525482,
-0.5322905778884888,
-0.1340218335390091,
-0.2626284062862396,
-1.1302094459533691,
-0.397018700838089,
-0.25312143564224243,
0.32051196694374084,
-0.43963074684143066,
-0.4297731816768646,
0.3757261633872986,
0.0019395245471969247,
0.03094804845750332,
0.7066125869750977,
-0.8112531900405884,
0.13499076664447784,
0.8794713020324707,
1.0810747146606445,
-0.3207162022590637,
-0.38582536578178406,
-0.3026074469089508,
0.15826117992401123,
-0.26372653245925903,
1.123532772064209,
-0.40136608481407166,
-0.24305137991905212,
0.10431352257728577,
0.06839006394147873,
-0.02388370968401432,
-0.022392651066184044,
0.6320592761039734,
-0.7025066018104553,
0.25148633122444153,
-0.0038323807530105114,
-0.5836902260780334,
0.12845894694328308,
0.31453871726989746,
-0.7859107255935669,
0.5685634016990662,
-0.1674770712852478,
-1.2377831935882568,
0.2949204444885254,
-0.6262616515159607,
-0.20673547685146332,
-0.2811696529388428,
0.16726867854595184,
-0.2792837917804718,
-0.08786846697330475,
-0.04116560518741608,
0.508286714553833,
-0.2630945146083832,
0.6949344873428345,
-0.5643219947814941,
-0.2915532886981964,
-0.1523755043745041,
0.013831891119480133,
0.4735831916332245,
0.22018426656723022,
-0.05517612025141716,
0.5695717930793762,
-0.8619135022163391,
-0.32800647616386414,
0.18770718574523926,
0.08015012741088867,
-0.8725224137306213,
0.0551619753241539,
0.10080261528491974,
0.5090838074684143,
0.024290824308991432,
-0.3639325499534607,
0.37092655897140503,
-0.4161035120487213,
0.743217408657074,
0.9295426607131958,
0.15559102594852448,
1.0561624765396118,
-0.021925751119852066,
0.25374653935432434,
0.1347230225801468,
-0.17190544307231903,
-0.18235990405082703,
-0.4301695227622986,
-0.4778062701225281,
-0.17988039553165436,
0.2745018005371094,
0.46107861399650574,
-0.8400039672851562,
0.2881457507610321,
-0.5624198913574219,
-0.6588824391365051,
0.01611751690506935,
-0.7359633445739746,
-0.17112451791763306,
0.38793155550956726,
0.10682117193937302,
-0.33862754702568054,
-0.052932679653167725,
-0.8284447193145752,
-0.13750985264778137,
0.033484384417533875,
0.11475719511508942,
0.1713751256465912,
0.5367254614830017,
-0.24759750068187714,
0.78152996301651,
-0.8392266631126404,
-0.1961982697248459,
-0.079421266913414,
0.22251683473587036,
0.033398035913705826,
0.29771050810813904,
0.7183414101600647,
-1.0102288722991943,
-0.6193300485610962,
-0.5209869742393494,
-0.3959110379219055,
0.36414217948913574,
-0.1668708324432373,
-0.7489637732505798,
-0.30568328499794006,
0.21262893080711365,
-0.8815430402755737,
0.2906247079372406,
0.20270054042339325,
-1.1201772689819336,
0.3009190261363983,
-0.3911363184452057,
-0.13088887929916382,
-1.420629620552063,
-0.01068770419806242,
-0.07978418469429016,
-0.32922402024269104,
-0.642409086227417,
-0.06502164155244827,
0.11726996302604675,
-0.8710057139396667,
-0.4053588807582855,
0.884356677532196,
-0.28387463092803955,
-0.1438029706478119,
-0.5779949426651001,
0.2828831076622009,
-0.1372978389263153,
0.103489950299263,
0.4782074987888336,
0.8740726113319397,
0.7735460996627808,
-0.646994411945343,
0.01327850203961134,
0.7012515664100647,
0.004981729667633772,
0.5829382538795471,
-0.4800165891647339,
0.29793936014175415,
-0.36589324474334717,
0.5742237567901611,
-0.681934654712677,
0.054329629987478256,
0.24918608367443085,
0.0757710188627243,
0.2778644263744354,
-0.06277580559253693,
-0.05589938163757324,
0.10774873197078705,
-0.5555098652839661,
0.16595569252967834,
0.16461703181266785,
-0.37932154536247253,
0.6864126920700073,
0.7184285521507263,
-0.681512713432312,
-0.4215821623802185,
-0.21964453160762787,
0.08122432976961136,
-0.23154351115226746,
-0.7229808568954468,
1.0232125520706177,
-0.0234257522970438,
-0.10977829992771149,
0.3407277762889862,
-0.013170643709599972,
-0.41148149967193604,
-0.07152417302131653,
-0.019379813224077225,
0.10514560341835022,
-0.02654895931482315,
0.16244949400424957,
-0.22376413643360138,
-0.5143142342567444,
-0.29397332668304443,
-0.24393141269683838,
0.26452451944351196,
0.14578628540039062,
0.43703460693359375,
-0.24675968289375305,
0.6853384375572205,
0.828142523765564,
-0.402803897857666,
0.7473407983779907,
0.4246767461299896,
-0.43381544947624207,
-0.2955307066440582,
-0.053455110639333725,
-0.5062564015388489,
-0.42468398809432983,
0.6584259867668152,
-0.5784686207771301,
-0.7145792245864868,
0.34506934881210327,
-0.31556063890457153,
-0.028056412935256958,
0.30048879981040955,
0.2778274416923523,
0.43973827362060547,
0.365491658449173,
1.305091381072998,
0.01394936814904213,
0.7336903810501099,
-0.1560056358575821,
0.034249112010002136,
-0.5758814811706543,
0.11720582842826843,
-0.5572983622550964,
0.09079819917678833,
-0.7887071371078491,
-0.6183478832244873,
0.03186895325779915,
-0.1941966861486435,
-0.20861515402793884,
0.3228302597999573,
-0.5132625102996826,
-0.16264156997203827,
0.2871250808238983,
0.05115903913974762,
0.16526784002780914,
-0.038604043424129486,
0.2015957087278366,
-0.1676226258277893,
-0.6437370181083679,
-0.572841227054596,
1.033774733543396,
0.23820854723453522,
0.577046275138855,
-0.10348204523324966,
0.5339838862419128,
0.3707212805747986,
0.21296349167823792,
-0.5807471871376038,
0.8087674975395203,
-0.5055611729621887,
-0.6497715711593628,
-0.400245726108551,
-0.4047011435031891,
-0.6324418783187866,
0.6246815919876099,
-0.3499634265899658,
-0.7101943492889404,
0.5317070484161377,
0.0889759212732315,
-0.3095141053199768,
0.464903861284256,
-0.24731895327568054,
0.9467803835868835,
-0.28721883893013,
-0.8053095936775208,
-0.5013640522956848,
-0.7624312043190002,
0.10752850025892258,
-0.09346649050712585,
0.05882977694272995,
-0.6377260088920593,
-0.39093220233917236,
0.903672456741333,
-0.3188265860080719,
0.21855872869491577,
-0.390426367521286,
0.2452532947063446,
0.08198080211877823,
0.023136556148529053,
0.5622183680534363,
0.2715393900871277,
-0.2642955482006073,
-0.021604597568511963,
-0.11128702759742737,
-0.33080846071243286,
-0.7046964764595032,
0.7918844819068909,
-0.6230725646018982,
-0.41011467576026917,
-0.7686148285865784,
-0.5826998949050903,
-0.20461104810237885,
0.3837040960788727,
-0.1924435794353485,
0.30362817645072937,
-0.37812650203704834,
-0.14530202746391296,
0.5139259099960327,
-0.32611244916915894,
0.4991096258163452,
0.7330253720283508,
-0.07243538647890091,
-0.34180182218551636,
0.8557986617088318,
0.08421021699905396,
-0.12816770374774933,
0.615165114402771,
0.24931149184703827,
-0.12269291281700134,
-0.588419497013092,
-0.2753737270832062,
0.13796940445899963,
-0.5559448003768921,
0.07114166766405106,
-1.0772602558135986,
0.044252634048461914,
-0.18345916271209717,
-0.4583096504211426,
-1.0786206722259521,
-0.7415041923522949,
-0.18932197988033295,
-0.08159241825342178,
0.2752797305583954,
0.2867259681224823,
-0.1963815689086914,
0.1572650820016861,
-0.4997119605541229,
0.7009032368659973,
0.2780660092830658,
0.17232932150363922,
-0.206637442111969,
-0.3205125033855438,
0.09851908683776855,
-0.5070059895515442,
-0.2776624858379364,
-1.039212942123413,
0.48299673199653625,
0.25133025646209717,
0.40636274218559265,
0.1777772605419159,
0.38993895053863525,
0.3939674198627472,
-0.7223069071769714,
0.38793110847473145,
-0.06701390445232391,
-0.7260726094245911,
0.614137589931488,
-0.3061555027961731,
-0.030121007934212685,
0.8807334899902344,
0.6130645871162415,
-0.19493311643600464,
-0.03429526463150978,
-0.5237353444099426,
-1.1390753984451294,
0.5196335315704346,
0.09599297493696213,
0.13320617377758026,
0.20007450878620148,
0.5629110336303711,
0.3755652904510498,
0.16953670978546143,
-0.383830726146698,
-0.12716728448867798,
-0.30322974920272827,
0.010611256584525108,
-0.20560000836849213,
-0.5751050710678101,
0.1695176064968109,
-0.10629376769065857,
0.6775996685028076,
-0.22612005472183228,
0.732979953289032,
0.06503470987081528,
0.1129717156291008,
0.3035721182823181,
0.4732852578163147,
0.5328158140182495,
1.004504919052124,
-0.61031174659729,
0.3783915340900421,
-0.3075999319553375,
-0.4668367803096771,
0.4808433949947357,
0.7802748680114746,
-0.5303856134414673,
0.1494934856891632,
-0.07180500775575638,
0.8113983273506165,
0.4285680949687958,
-0.2778942584991455,
0.6172048449516296,
-0.33162757754325867,
0.2992382347583771,
-0.14407354593276978,
-0.46792009472846985,
0.0017943629063665867,
0.05438467115163803,
0.06994274258613586,
0.1875014454126358,
0.34250959753990173,
-0.5980901122093201,
0.5617398023605347,
0.139201357960701,
-0.3355307877063751,
-0.47650033235549927,
0.9734445214271545,
0.624001145362854,
-0.22077277302742004,
0.6264992952346802,
-0.15947896242141724,
-0.5807806253433228,
0.448933869600296,
0.5256116986274719,
0.8620737791061401,
-0.07008865475654602,
0.5457698106765747,
0.3184967637062073,
0.03292897716164589,
-0.07328516989946365,
0.5034141540527344,
0.08077724277973175,
-0.6341367959976196,
-0.1430448740720749,
-0.39945486187934875,
-0.6230437755584717,
-0.46465936303138733,
-0.5736449956893921,
0.31493088603019714,
-0.15339456498622894,
-0.25121793150901794,
0.27891144156455994,
0.056847747415304184,
-0.4843204617500305,
0.16611644625663757,
-0.16701984405517578,
1.2475981712341309,
-0.9215028882026672,
1.0530556440353394,
0.9386940002441406,
0.01941135711967945,
-0.4181916117668152,
0.45276913046836853,
-0.2168908715248108,
-0.30044281482696533,
0.41107019782066345,
0.18343231081962585,
0.1538829803466797,
0.08489625155925751,
0.1754179149866104,
-1.0018144845962524,
1.0463473796844482,
0.4114660322666168,
-0.5736302733421326,
-0.3341849148273468,
-0.20403815805912018,
0.22207897901535034,
-0.3232610821723938,
0.2671004831790924,
-0.012387377209961414,
0.32989388704299927,
-0.059273965656757355,
-0.6277385354042053,
0.3642944395542145,
0.05544017627835274,
0.10431277751922607,
0.3484334945678711,
-0.8977909684181213,
0.784497082233429,
-0.2964276969432831,
-0.03883877024054527,
0.10818316042423248,
0.6787078976631165,
0.23008069396018982,
0.6744528412818909,
0.590541422367096,
0.55363529920578,
0.5809108018875122,
0.00790072325617075,
0.9495365619659424,
-0.5616772770881653,
0.38297462463378906,
1.0768930912017822,
-0.6003491282463074,
0.9484979510307312,
0.7080186605453491,
0.16077779233455658,
0.22157397866249084,
0.5805222392082214,
0.41201162338256836,
1.36790132522583,
-0.08736260235309601,
0.12186331301927567,
-0.07790329307317734,
-0.047948308289051056,
-0.5483320355415344,
0.5473703742027283,
0.1875760555267334,
-0.12733730673789978,
-0.29515331983566284,
0.28586524724960327,
0.12469695508480072,
0.009591375477612019,
-0.29842841625213623,
0.4821391999721527,
0.04144132509827614,
-0.48621878027915955,
-0.10583655536174774,
0.23548324406147003,
0.8024346232414246,
-0.7822981476783752,
-0.07155955582857132,
-0.13468772172927856,
0.39826565980911255,
0.2651863396167755,
-0.5638979077339172,
0.6643500328063965,
-0.5304485559463501,
-0.22276714444160461,
-0.3270268142223358,
1.2222906351089478,
-0.3630799949169159,
-0.2977488338947296,
0.30212515592575073,
0.5905932188034058,
-0.2723037898540497,
0.1576569378376007,
-0.751510739326477,
0.17369842529296875,
-0.3147904574871063,
-0.3873280882835388,
0.32681557536125183,
0.42396095395088196,
-0.18796615302562714,
0.5784620046615601,
0.23286673426628113,
0.08580545336008072,
-0.11866384744644165,
-0.4547066390514374,
0.7661316394805908,
-0.9509420990943909,
-1.1519582271575928,
-0.512482225894928,
0.541857123374939,
-0.08301842212677002,
-0.5236067175865173,
0.4773103594779968,
0.4339640438556671,
0.3144915699958801,
-0.15704400837421417,
0.3588642477989197,
0.005738791543990374,
0.512032687664032,
-0.4016157388687134,
0.6212097406387329,
-0.46139028668403625,
0.0014503885759040713,
-0.31655630469322205,
-0.82679283618927,
-0.16480648517608643,
0.6661643981933594,
-0.36299246549606323,
-0.40132808685302734,
0.7791394591331482,
0.5221086740493774,
-0.3705931305885315,
0.14960874617099762,
0.01986999809741974,
0.04976984113454819,
0.2873387336730957,
0.5895516276359558,
0.9501208066940308,
-0.1670367270708084,
0.23623386025428772,
-0.6914543509483337,
-0.39442142844200134,
-0.28390881419181824,
-0.9966726899147034,
-0.521865963935852,
-0.6095580458641052,
-0.78946852684021,
-0.0753323957324028,
0.5642596483230591,
0.6214237213134766,
1.1985056400299072,
-0.37600967288017273,
0.017019469290971756,
-0.33751216530799866,
0.24140800535678864,
0.008431518450379372,
-0.28254419565200806,
0.92589271068573,
0.1872076392173767,
-0.3681471049785614,
0.3137592673301697,
0.4216703772544861,
-0.05832114443182945,
-0.23023644089698792,
0.20151829719543457,
-0.31368693709373474,
0.29520905017852783,
0.5004851818084717,
0.15532566606998444,
-0.19345895946025848,
-0.3257504403591156,
-0.20681914687156677,
-0.09655233472585678,
-0.1327560842037201,
1.1481126546859741,
-0.5513348579406738,
0.40024805068969727,
0.5912184715270996,
0.6981958746910095,
0.7439635396003723,
-0.1505664736032486,
0.6108724474906921,
-0.1167551651597023,
0.7770068049430847,
0.30503544211387634,
0.3794654309749603,
0.3324130177497864,
-0.466323584318161,
0.6139171123504639,
0.31970179080963135,
-0.606742262840271,
-0.7893381118774414,
0.22596707940101624,
-1.1255850791931152,
-0.4392200708389282,
0.8116043210029602,
-0.14728596806526184,
-0.07186073064804077,
0.13402016460895538,
-0.10211186110973358,
0.14037951827049255,
-0.42287200689315796,
0.7778600454330444,
0.23934142291545868,
-0.31010040640830994,
-0.13432885706424713,
-0.5529130697250366,
0.24227993190288544,
0.20122414827346802,
-0.9190151691436768,
-0.10104190558195114,
0.34467455744743347,
0.5810624957084656,
0.16820447146892548,
1.0987331867218018,
0.0862235426902771,
0.1621561050415039,
0.2732922434806824,
-0.2977701425552368,
-0.0244411900639534,
-0.7117917537689209,
-0.08127687126398087,
0.5566244125366211,
-0.037507932633161545,
-0.24281847476959229
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17977v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17977v1
|
Aligning to Thousands of Preferences via System Message Generalization
| 2024-05-28T09:06:18 | 2024-05-28T09:06:18 |
Seongyun Lee, Sue Hyun Park, Seungone Kim, Minjoon Seo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Although humans inherently have diverse values, current large language model
(LLM) alignment methods often assume that aligning LLMs with the general
public's preferences is optimal. A major challenge in adopting a more
individualized approach to LLM alignment is its lack of scalability, as it
involves repeatedly acquiring preference data and training new reward models
and LLMs for each individual's preferences. To address these challenges, we
propose a new paradigm where users specify what they value most within the
system message, steering the LLM's generation behavior to better align with the
user's intentions. However, a naive application of such an approach is
non-trivial since LLMs are typically trained on a uniform system message (e.g.,
"You are a helpful assistant") which limits their ability to generalize to
diverse, unseen system messages. To improve this generalization, we create the
Multifaceted Collection, a preference dataset with 192k combinations of values
beyond generic helpfulness and harmlessness, spanning 65k user instructions.
Using this dataset, we train a 7B LLM called Janus and test it on 921 prompts
from 5 benchmarks (AlpacaEval 2.0, FLASK, Koala, MT-Bench, and Self-Instruct)
by adding various unseen system messages that reflect user preferences. Janus
achieves tie+win rate of 75.2%, 72.4%, and 66.4% against Mistral 7B Instruct
v0.2, GPT-3.5 Turbo, and GPT-4, respectively. Unexpectedly, on three benchmarks
focused on response helpfulness (AlpacaEval 2.0, MT-Bench, Arena Hard Auto
v0.1), Janus also outperforms LLaMA 3 8B Instruct by a +4.0%, +0.1%, +3.0%
margin, underscoring that training with a vast array of system messages could
also enhance alignment to the general public's preference as well. Our code,
dataset, benchmark, and models are available at
https://github.com/kaistAI/Janus.
|
[
-0.49643221497535706,
-0.25754430890083313,
0.41710203886032104,
0.1378369778394699,
-0.15715059638023376,
-0.006653732620179653,
-0.447053998708725,
-0.23115327954292297,
0.4928549826145172,
0.42630675435066223,
-0.41125839948654175,
-0.41685476899147034,
-0.674419105052948,
-0.010599362663924694,
-0.03130268305540085,
1.4149285554885864,
0.1580246537923813,
-0.09421373158693314,
-0.19486761093139648,
-0.2935270667076111,
-0.6732857823371887,
-0.6438102126121521,
-0.6069234013557434,
-0.39020538330078125,
0.8076227307319641,
0.7140380144119263,
0.7951769232749939,
0.611901044845581,
0.6755079030990601,
0.2972343862056732,
-0.043669693171978,
0.24871547520160675,
-0.6798518896102905,
0.3706839978694916,
-0.07460679858922958,
-0.48991453647613525,
-0.7116411924362183,
-0.10733766853809357,
0.6012031435966492,
0.47775980830192566,
-0.03867349028587341,
0.22100216150283813,
0.28656941652297974,
0.70577073097229,
-0.5427665114402771,
-0.034182142466306686,
-0.625463604927063,
-0.232060968875885,
-0.345282644033432,
-0.22824065387248993,
-0.33820873498916626,
-0.42813581228256226,
0.16621562838554382,
-0.7620636224746704,
-0.11059826612472534,
-0.006142353173345327,
0.8751733899116516,
0.3935490548610687,
-0.4240949749946594,
-0.22251377999782562,
-0.5467775464057922,
0.909821093082428,
-0.6146693825721741,
0.07854720205068588,
0.12241266667842865,
0.4244924485683441,
-0.337374746799469,
-0.012631284072995186,
-0.3504348695278168,
-0.12804542481899261,
0.18228109180927277,
0.06757275760173798,
-0.12955717742443085,
0.027049215510487556,
0.2110871523618698,
0.17140591144561768,
-0.462341845035553,
0.3361866772174835,
0.019847024232149124,
-0.051164235919713974,
0.6907225251197815,
0.4103405475616455,
0.08016659319400787,
-0.04795524850487709,
-0.5880508422851562,
-0.43110233545303345,
-0.61691814661026,
0.4022029936313629,
0.48379403352737427,
0.4566357135772705,
-0.10350137948989868,
0.6057277321815491,
-0.28344449400901794,
0.7330169677734375,
0.4058608412742615,
-0.33279305696487427,
0.3089449107646942,
-0.3166453242301941,
-0.18202367424964905,
0.07616223394870758,
0.9718276262283325,
0.7492715716362,
0.24212338030338287,
-0.05091222748160362,
-0.3049411177635193,
0.18427062034606934,
0.21267972886562347,
-0.6349164247512817,
-0.022988606244325638,
0.06511308997869492,
-0.33189907670021057,
-0.36608341336250305,
0.09145083278417587,
-0.5302574038505554,
-0.6758158802986145,
-0.47158947587013245,
0.2166595458984375,
-0.3050939738750458,
-0.05376308411359787,
0.04978323355317116,
-0.0007062082877382636,
0.10943576693534851,
0.5312020182609558,
-1.3831504583358765,
0.18456971645355225,
0.6964496970176697,
0.5575705766677856,
-0.31175023317337036,
-0.13028953969478607,
-0.6880461573600769,
0.18734563887119293,
-0.19939111173152924,
0.9106979370117188,
-0.6281003355979919,
-0.26749712228775024,
-0.34911903738975525,
-0.1892388015985489,
0.18092866241931915,
-0.5098379850387573,
0.3523785471916199,
-0.5780609250068665,
0.1843995898962021,
-0.5822279453277588,
-0.5259745121002197,
0.17726674675941467,
0.2969280183315277,
-0.3873661756515503,
0.8577361106872559,
-0.028457386419177055,
-0.5863924622535706,
0.442534476518631,
-0.7098681926727295,
-0.08551375567913055,
0.02559811808168888,
-0.307445764541626,
-0.32711321115493774,
0.11941251158714294,
0.25684627890586853,
0.582617461681366,
-0.25093787908554077,
0.36095455288887024,
-0.6324095129966736,
-0.29130542278289795,
0.27455320954322815,
-0.3689020574092865,
0.5120033025741577,
0.25376957654953003,
-0.3613835275173187,
0.2838059067726135,
-0.5157339572906494,
-0.016766883432865143,
0.04870432987809181,
-0.5453639030456543,
-0.4844958782196045,
-0.23524299263954163,
-0.17784135043621063,
0.06745661050081253,
0.682578980922699,
-0.45117735862731934,
0.7024275660514832,
-0.38798388838768005,
-0.14254207909107208,
1.264983892440796,
-0.30466556549072266,
0.6526753306388855,
-0.39012837409973145,
0.5347778797149658,
-0.1489591896533966,
0.1937759965658188,
-0.034126561135053635,
-0.6198824048042297,
-0.595492959022522,
-0.15518616139888763,
0.12134047597646713,
0.486137330532074,
-0.2978021800518036,
0.5095455646514893,
-0.6140730381011963,
-0.16689597070217133,
-0.5844504237174988,
0.4365255534648895,
0.517832338809967,
0.3459881842136383,
0.16568076610565186,
-0.27374520897865295,
-0.336950421333313,
-1.133939504623413,
-0.1677217185497284,
-0.2801038920879364,
-0.21860498189926147,
0.5022540092468262,
-0.09524441510438919,
-0.1342751532793045,
0.9844657182693481,
-0.6644423604011536,
-0.11183872818946838,
-0.12128880620002747,
-0.03182046860456467,
0.24947915971279144,
0.3208470642566681,
0.38040316104888916,
-0.5538201332092285,
-0.5195079445838928,
0.145174041390419,
-0.6726088523864746,
-0.27895113825798035,
-0.16389065980911255,
-0.2298251986503601,
0.02407476305961609,
0.09399253875017166,
-0.2003263682126999,
0.059911422431468964,
0.6476547718048096,
-0.335787296295166,
0.2568219304084778,
-0.1743784099817276,
0.22128614783287048,
-1.465717077255249,
0.10245057940483093,
0.1687077134847641,
-0.17603321373462677,
-0.5915406346321106,
-0.0565590001642704,
-0.04701577499508858,
0.2903512418270111,
-0.12915359437465668,
0.5487285852432251,
-0.3857883810997009,
-0.016252009198069572,
-0.4273233115673065,
0.22495318949222565,
-0.29541799426078796,
0.4733497202396393,
-0.0871008038520813,
0.726387619972229,
0.10174472630023956,
-0.5466752052307129,
0.5702058672904968,
0.36687329411506653,
-0.002588860923424363,
0.868980884552002,
-0.4918244779109955,
0.25198662281036377,
-0.13398265838623047,
0.23066020011901855,
-1.0498223304748535,
-0.3109073042869568,
0.1855929046869278,
-0.4396468997001648,
0.19105643033981323,
-0.05192062631249428,
-0.24678713083267212,
-0.19938507676124573,
-0.34148189425468445,
0.15681225061416626,
0.350851833820343,
-0.6389972567558289,
0.315191388130188,
0.4519693851470947,
-0.2468627244234085,
-0.8450530767440796,
-0.31719067692756653,
0.3483814001083374,
-0.43853530287742615,
-0.5959686040878296,
0.09196128696203232,
-0.4636659622192383,
-0.17405183613300323,
-0.39608505368232727,
-0.04705558344721794,
0.36761710047721863,
0.32326197624206543,
0.5002582669258118,
0.5393863916397095,
-0.11532553285360336,
0.2292085886001587,
-0.015446511097252369,
-0.43984532356262207,
-0.148992121219635,
-0.33187198638916016,
0.5477936267852783,
-0.4920027256011963,
-0.5666215419769287,
-0.3638743460178375,
0.33067774772644043,
0.5264050364494324,
0.06941695511341095,
0.655156135559082,
0.5387645363807678,
-0.02204582467675209,
0.18932580947875977,
-0.660065233707428,
-0.18238751590251923,
-0.45709428191185,
0.23968477547168732,
-0.3873375356197357,
-0.9570868611335754,
0.2696457803249359,
0.07871221750974655,
0.40127310156822205,
0.2441634088754654,
0.576897144317627,
-0.0718245878815651,
1.3497929573059082,
0.6554118990898132,
-0.6437028050422668,
0.5301567316055298,
-0.024192512035369873,
0.06082089617848396,
-0.8523584008216858,
-0.23259949684143066,
-0.476497083902359,
-0.67893385887146,
-0.6211301684379578,
-0.035863518714904785,
0.43345677852630615,
0.032070767134428024,
-0.43070080876350403,
0.4252985417842865,
-0.855070173740387,
0.3742826282978058,
0.7270274758338928,
0.06407931447029114,
0.2623065412044525,
0.10449778288602829,
-0.027577796950936317,
-0.02232925221323967,
-0.5312925577163696,
-0.9028884172439575,
1.3132692575454712,
0.42267024517059326,
1.0695701837539673,
0.3634144067764282,
1.0495269298553467,
0.04659304395318031,
0.6342482566833496,
-0.7748833298683167,
0.523027241230011,
-0.18894629180431366,
-0.3197392225265503,
-0.4858292043209076,
-0.4223204255104065,
-1.0489060878753662,
0.003526079235598445,
-0.28828248381614685,
-0.7841567397117615,
0.023823725059628487,
0.4135393500328064,
-0.6969650983810425,
0.22588172554969788,
-0.7649818658828735,
0.5863250494003296,
-0.4443082809448242,
-0.20877036452293396,
-0.0574583038687706,
-0.8833718299865723,
0.3373314142227173,
-0.03871789202094078,
0.04882820323109627,
-0.15511128306388855,
-0.27970632910728455,
0.6991549134254456,
-0.11284720152616501,
0.817561149597168,
-0.0935131087899208,
-0.20633839070796967,
-0.28895795345306396,
-0.25353309512138367,
0.568313479423523,
-0.06465250998735428,
-0.00973663292825222,
-0.18173232674598694,
-0.17664575576782227,
-0.4461970329284668,
-0.6168460845947266,
0.9943985939025879,
-1.0551342964172363,
-0.720836877822876,
-0.2928529381752014,
-0.6326439380645752,
-0.2846677899360657,
0.14691928029060364,
0.11971472948789597,
0.2669382393360138,
-0.16819597780704498,
0.18845897912979126,
0.9148346185684204,
-0.06381096690893173,
0.20753005146980286,
0.36644119024276733,
-0.15901771187782288,
-0.5378142595291138,
0.9807477593421936,
-0.306306391954422,
0.43406012654304504,
0.519451916217804,
0.3642390966415405,
-0.34152984619140625,
-0.3838317394256592,
-0.5716638565063477,
0.07438082247972488,
-0.5249916315078735,
-0.3772464990615845,
-0.652736246585846,
0.2078109085559845,
-0.39991456270217896,
-0.31153541803359985,
-0.2218329757452011,
-0.33185964822769165,
-0.4879434406757355,
0.126743346452713,
0.3093731701374054,
1.0258171558380127,
0.08624245971441269,
0.5828369855880737,
-0.720998227596283,
0.319770872592926,
0.5229159593582153,
0.4068438708782196,
-0.14022353291511536,
-0.5505863428115845,
-0.18331067264080048,
0.1709761917591095,
-0.4949188232421875,
-0.8253957629203796,
0.22715607285499573,
-0.10781978070735931,
0.673570454120636,
0.7597580552101135,
-0.09301891922950745,
0.7878013253211975,
-0.13232558965682983,
0.7242940664291382,
0.5282027721405029,
-0.6239073872566223,
0.5036038160324097,
-0.44394809007644653,
0.3181886374950409,
0.7799971103668213,
0.21263568103313446,
-0.7650101184844971,
-0.42730122804641724,
-0.6670053005218506,
-0.529041051864624,
0.7659253478050232,
-0.12572363018989563,
0.13013990223407745,
0.05306350439786911,
0.3049051761627197,
0.09260054677724838,
0.18245849013328552,
-0.6527578830718994,
-0.3787827789783478,
-0.04692644998431206,
-0.4625595808029175,
-0.28765302896499634,
-0.14958186447620392,
-0.22314545512199402,
0.096554234623909,
0.6867417097091675,
-0.3772367537021637,
0.19566583633422852,
-0.23466810584068298,
0.1761326938867569,
-0.18410560488700867,
0.5203301310539246,
0.727170467376709,
0.3081900179386139,
-0.22554059326648712,
0.18060216307640076,
0.19932439923286438,
-0.2324354648590088,
0.31782597303390503,
0.0647222250699997,
-0.038552798330783844,
-0.38504698872566223,
0.02367456629872322,
0.7599814534187317,
0.12067148089408875,
-0.34908127784729004,
0.5022937059402466,
-0.15343259274959564,
0.026159726083278656,
0.11849049478769302,
0.22324886918067932,
0.3696247935295105,
0.14211194217205048,
0.2137824147939682,
0.10881964862346649,
-0.030246051028370857,
-0.2391570508480072,
-0.10269960016012192,
0.912973165512085,
-0.3031409680843353,
-0.2620540261268616,
0.6490961909294128,
0.3286473751068115,
-0.24740776419639587,
0.4188653826713562,
-0.16141019761562347,
-0.37508711218833923,
0.33741551637649536,
0.3841850161552429,
0.7449424266815186,
-0.38145875930786133,
0.1298495978116989,
0.21761752665042877,
0.12920354306697845,
-0.20413221418857574,
0.029366573318839073,
-0.02646990492939949,
-0.8625378012657166,
-0.17157307267189026,
-0.5924453139305115,
-0.4820162355899811,
0.19147443771362305,
-0.5782335996627808,
0.3396800458431244,
-0.47322162985801697,
-0.3959329426288605,
0.1181742325425148,
0.10999858379364014,
-0.5644749402999878,
-0.05037039890885353,
0.34958982467651367,
0.6351766586303711,
-0.9952830672264099,
0.6511834263801575,
1.0496662855148315,
-0.33694761991500854,
-0.971930742263794,
-0.25111880898475647,
0.24033866822719574,
-1.0333644151687622,
0.6596673130989075,
0.006335602607578039,
-0.1145908385515213,
-0.32520371675491333,
-0.5767476558685303,
-0.8588681221008301,
1.0277241468429565,
0.4663422107696533,
-0.785144567489624,
0.03280485048890114,
0.07428602129220963,
0.43656715750694275,
-0.6390522718429565,
0.5105260610580444,
0.36347103118896484,
0.5254552364349365,
0.1212630420923233,
-0.9795498847961426,
0.05482764169573784,
-0.24987414479255676,
0.16736119985580444,
0.34245458245277405,
-0.8138751983642578,
0.5114895701408386,
-0.3125380277633667,
-0.022087914869189262,
0.20544731616973877,
0.5828356146812439,
0.4496016800403595,
0.2875431776046753,
0.737065851688385,
0.6822248101234436,
0.8430508971214294,
0.13181869685649872,
0.8249193429946899,
-0.2906952202320099,
0.04592416062951088,
1.0650506019592285,
-0.06028134003281593,
0.6148015856742859,
0.6331496238708496,
-0.05080403760075569,
0.41266319155693054,
0.6298676133155823,
0.32658764719963074,
0.2819349765777588,
0.16032452881336212,
-0.3970560133457184,
-0.5896538496017456,
-0.2755546569824219,
-0.3187023997306824,
0.3113453984260559,
0.1630072146654129,
-0.2531627416610718,
-0.12662604451179504,
-0.13581116497516632,
0.06178233027458191,
0.12549149990081787,
0.04506326839327812,
1.0028036832809448,
-0.11829695850610733,
-0.8475697636604309,
0.6494978070259094,
-0.22622299194335938,
0.885306715965271,
-0.6528149247169495,
-0.008691812865436077,
-0.25581833720207214,
0.2359098643064499,
-0.2918297052383423,
-0.83324134349823,
-0.25844454765319824,
-0.0003567685198504478,
-0.27840712666511536,
-0.449939101934433,
0.428804874420166,
-0.3687419593334198,
-0.16872331500053406,
0.0001441126223653555,
0.24342657625675201,
0.24225687980651855,
0.12021754682064056,
-0.6140225529670715,
0.050821684300899506,
0.3325503170490265,
-0.13763190805912018,
0.737885594367981,
0.19194677472114563,
-0.23372431099414825,
0.7874026894569397,
0.7096422910690308,
0.15245385468006134,
-0.25261032581329346,
0.1529930830001831,
1.0894585847854614,
-0.5119163393974304,
-0.4204762876033783,
-0.7973209619522095,
0.383851021528244,
-0.2748124897480011,
-0.45449912548065186,
0.7981585264205933,
0.5665117502212524,
0.6127845048904419,
0.20395809412002563,
0.8323621153831482,
0.24133336544036865,
0.3898719251155853,
-0.06513920426368713,
0.20572786033153534,
-0.4781220555305481,
0.5840358734130859,
-0.28835445642471313,
-0.9380415081977844,
-0.044906314462423325,
0.4398248493671417,
-0.29023680090904236,
-0.020842203870415688,
0.24538815021514893,
0.7737656235694885,
0.005029910244047642,
-0.024031994864344597,
0.22180026769638062,
-0.1811649352312088,
0.521979570388794,
0.8703086376190186,
0.8909485936164856,
-0.11595933884382248,
0.5581152439117432,
0.002412708941847086,
-0.7470571398735046,
-0.3830339312553406,
-0.847373366355896,
-0.70003342628479,
-0.4419640004634857,
0.005101145710796118,
-0.4311239421367645,
0.061846792697906494,
1.2934802770614624,
0.6081595420837402,
-0.857024073600769,
-0.424641877412796,
0.24069249629974365,
0.14743560552597046,
-0.058007508516311646,
-0.16135823726654053,
0.06126796081662178,
-0.4990028142929077,
-0.6366883516311646,
0.224607914686203,
0.24139699339866638,
0.13536015152931213,
-0.26115185022354126,
-0.30746904015541077,
0.1306230127811432,
-0.16980397701263428,
0.35797396302223206,
0.36927807331085205,
-0.8044908046722412,
-0.4345371723175049,
0.32032305002212524,
-0.3743343651294708,
0.19121098518371582,
0.5775943994522095,
-0.6907877922058105,
0.4970991909503937,
0.3098963797092438,
0.7193358540534973,
0.1790730357170105,
0.31704699993133545,
0.6666179895401001,
-0.5529454946517944,
-0.44548916816711426,
0.12394464015960693,
0.2524281144142151,
0.4823726415634155,
-0.5945688486099243,
0.11815521866083145,
0.011435326188802719,
-0.8565422892570496,
-0.4824821949005127,
0.15767064690589905,
-1.1979807615280151,
0.08903757482767105,
1.3407869338989258,
0.06092926487326622,
-0.05748644471168518,
0.008270777761936188,
-0.3515363037586212,
0.06478384882211685,
-1.014953374862671,
0.851068377494812,
0.575835108757019,
-0.28792157769203186,
0.2536165416240692,
-0.13180041313171387,
0.4371510446071625,
0.6569308042526245,
-0.845607578754425,
0.11545270681381226,
0.632786750793457,
0.3350891172885895,
0.39821070432662964,
0.7718631625175476,
0.17793206870555878,
0.16075579822063446,
-0.5357538461685181,
0.17420800030231476,
-0.0015792681369930506,
-0.20609785616397858,
-0.6702060699462891,
0.11875155568122864,
0.35713544487953186,
-0.3079381287097931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17976v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17976v2
|
Yuan 2.0-M32: Mixture of Experts with Attention Router
| 2024-05-28T09:05:08 | 2024-05-29T07:19:58 |
Shaohua Wu, Jiangang Luo, Xi Chen, Lingjun Li, Xudong Zhao, Tong Yu, Chao Wang, Yue Wang, Fei Wang, Weixu Qiao, Houbo He, Zeru Zhang, Zeyu Sun, Junxiong Mao, Chong Shen
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Yuan 2.0-M32, with a similar base architecture as Yuan-2.0 2B, uses a
mixture-of-experts architecture with 32 experts of which 2 experts are active.
A new router network, Attention Router, is proposed and adopted for a more
efficient selection of experts, which improves the accuracy compared to the
model with classical router network. Yuan 2.0-M32 is trained with 2000B tokens
from scratch, and the training computation consumption is only 9.25% of a dense
model at the same parameter scale. Yuan 2.0-M32 demonstrates competitive
capability on coding, math, and various domains of expertise, with only 3.7B
active parameters of 40B in total, and 7.4 GFlops forward computation per
token, both of which are only 1/19 of Llama3-70B. Yuan 2.0-M32 surpass
Llama3-70B on MATH and ARC-Challenge benchmark, with accuracy of 55.89 and 95.8
respectively. The models and source codes of Yuan 2.0-M32 are released at
Github1.
|
[
-0.5794753432273865,
-0.5967527627944946,
0.268420934677124,
0.6231899857521057,
-0.22265715897083282,
0.18194468319416046,
-0.024490538984537125,
-0.8009893894195557,
0.17414657771587372,
0.42952677607536316,
-0.24571163952350616,
0.22265473008155823,
-0.7000347971916199,
-0.2852407693862915,
-0.21452826261520386,
0.9682179093360901,
0.09343195706605911,
0.27290356159210205,
0.22691096365451813,
-0.22495801746845245,
-0.4857693016529083,
-0.3867763578891754,
-1.1331676244735718,
-0.6028160452842712,
0.5247973799705505,
0.5205942988395691,
0.757066011428833,
0.4436529278755188,
0.9065735936164856,
0.3308948278427124,
-0.21137534081935883,
0.08576902002096176,
-0.5734058022499084,
-0.409953773021698,
-0.13254868984222412,
-0.3810995817184448,
-0.9215993285179138,
-0.23200657963752747,
0.4598497152328491,
0.371163010597229,
-0.28059670329093933,
0.302755743265152,
-0.06758244335651398,
1.1622989177703857,
-0.2581721842288971,
0.11201029270887375,
-0.6322696805000305,
0.1756553053855896,
-0.14310860633850098,
0.06483489274978638,
-0.392703652381897,
-0.040906935930252075,
0.22896741330623627,
-0.6013138890266418,
0.3274526298046112,
0.15976406633853912,
0.7627363801002502,
0.5511007905006409,
-0.4425678551197052,
0.2304227352142334,
-0.3833843171596527,
0.7541918158531189,
-0.5263895392417908,
0.5678106546401978,
0.09049802273511887,
0.6360151171684265,
-0.09225866943597794,
-0.7480173110961914,
-0.21937377750873566,
0.1797134280204773,
0.014129575341939926,
0.28787961602211,
-0.12809208035469055,
-0.04055900499224663,
0.03456990793347359,
0.5632970333099365,
-0.3365345001220703,
0.1767989695072174,
-0.615048885345459,
-0.025657732039690018,
0.8362092971801758,
0.20662876963615417,
-0.03005758300423622,
0.34880518913269043,
-0.4896169602870941,
0.1209912821650505,
-0.7355986833572388,
0.03918631002306938,
0.362185537815094,
-0.36488112807273865,
-0.33676475286483765,
0.4283679723739624,
-0.7406412959098816,
0.6889240741729736,
0.8290761113166809,
-0.15801851451396942,
0.3871957063674927,
-0.11742857098579407,
-0.1770344376564026,
0.031207730993628502,
0.5538625121116638,
0.3037484884262085,
0.11481937766075134,
-0.29984867572784424,
-0.34270575642585754,
-0.5468896627426147,
0.1746213287115097,
-0.9008980989456177,
-0.7024117112159729,
0.3285667598247528,
-0.7481497526168823,
-0.34633851051330566,
0.23471900820732117,
-0.5649529099464417,
-0.12778769433498383,
-0.2822667360305786,
0.3891553282737732,
0.05798042565584183,
-0.8175181150436401,
0.2527875006198883,
-0.3126499354839325,
0.34310001134872437,
0.6447060108184814,
-1.3004573583602905,
0.6513575315475464,
0.9221687316894531,
0.8357997536659241,
-0.44583454728126526,
-0.14600203931331635,
-0.2728405296802521,
-0.00950906053185463,
-0.3791016936302185,
0.8366578221321106,
-0.16771633923053741,
-0.306968629360199,
-0.6289529204368591,
-0.34171542525291443,
-0.13539302349090576,
-0.8086032271385193,
0.29591894149780273,
-0.9796605706214905,
0.1666702777147293,
-0.09740371257066727,
-0.24996833503246307,
-0.5618135929107666,
0.2391020655632019,
-0.8905701637268066,
1.5164573192596436,
0.499505877494812,
-0.9108803272247314,
0.10829469561576843,
-0.6022672653198242,
-0.17594590783119202,
0.041417840868234634,
-0.11384526640176773,
-0.10875335335731506,
-0.08616090565919876,
-0.013665629550814629,
0.23642176389694214,
-0.3970779776573181,
0.25195756554603577,
-0.193342924118042,
-0.4981890320777893,
0.21232888102531433,
-0.19830818474292755,
0.7581777572631836,
0.2405649572610855,
-0.5192621946334839,
0.03570710867643356,
-0.6373780965805054,
-0.038560330867767334,
0.05547739937901497,
-0.7566899657249451,
0.3955957293510437,
0.03953440487384796,
0.3354235589504242,
0.553939700126648,
0.6462394595146179,
-0.3111344277858734,
-0.2582925260066986,
-0.6008604764938354,
0.3505101799964905,
0.7728943228721619,
-0.11931899189949036,
0.5487715601921082,
-0.23990117013454437,
0.28436732292175293,
0.26657384634017944,
0.23334883153438568,
0.25625738501548767,
-0.9444008469581604,
-1.1641689538955688,
-0.019541924819350243,
0.48769208788871765,
0.6796491146087646,
-0.48229607939720154,
0.6169959902763367,
-0.25227245688438416,
-0.7145847678184509,
-0.38715216517448425,
0.4104059040546417,
0.6266974806785583,
0.5667434930801392,
0.4048755466938019,
-0.1793394684791565,
-0.23823553323745728,
-0.9943274259567261,
0.05460803583264351,
-0.1784745454788208,
0.008663808926939964,
0.3706734776496887,
0.289181649684906,
0.11408320814371109,
0.8515604734420776,
-0.534795880317688,
-0.23779301345348358,
-0.5209206938743591,
-0.07722096145153046,
0.20128865540027618,
0.667572557926178,
0.7322236895561218,
-0.8750252723693848,
-0.7775831818580627,
0.4954126179218292,
-0.6088889837265015,
0.2921305298805237,
0.12829995155334473,
-0.23974944651126862,
0.2864723205566406,
0.23321926593780518,
-0.5750198364257812,
-0.06182734668254852,
0.45942044258117676,
-0.24409522116184235,
0.40408360958099365,
0.004819465801119804,
-0.07366921007633209,
-1.1628742218017578,
0.17741328477859497,
0.12139511108398438,
0.08954378962516785,
-0.6882001161575317,
0.3641197383403778,
0.059753865003585815,
0.15187066793441772,
-0.5230073928833008,
0.9504500031471252,
-0.5476033091545105,
-0.044925566762685776,
-0.2320425808429718,
-0.07325831055641174,
-0.13998854160308838,
0.9579341411590576,
0.22778771817684174,
0.7194998264312744,
0.4530355930328369,
-0.46661752462387085,
0.5392073392868042,
0.0801636204123497,
-0.30081719160079956,
0.13916005194187164,
-0.9120649695396423,
0.41026678681373596,
0.28388509154319763,
0.08226517587900162,
-0.7871314883232117,
-0.4320220649242401,
0.5256405472755432,
-0.6260873079299927,
0.319335401058197,
0.036105867475271225,
-0.4267239570617676,
-0.5437561869621277,
-0.40577688813209534,
0.5683568716049194,
0.6325966119766235,
-0.3072320818901062,
0.5029662251472473,
0.44178271293640137,
-0.21675658226013184,
-0.6870152950286865,
-0.8812492489814758,
0.07774827629327774,
-0.012532145716249943,
-0.7183118462562561,
0.45539334416389465,
-0.027663983404636383,
-0.24382956326007843,
0.1305488497018814,
-0.08259333670139313,
-0.3599397540092468,
0.22167038917541504,
-0.03175654262304306,
0.34510886669158936,
-0.5754570364952087,
-0.32600486278533936,
0.09215789288282394,
-0.4669286608695984,
0.24235014617443085,
-0.24495159089565277,
0.33859410881996155,
0.056053001433610916,
-0.4539356529712677,
-0.5391185283660889,
0.19300663471221924,
0.23957550525665283,
-0.286548912525177,
0.4157872498035431,
0.8933578133583069,
-0.5789709687232971,
0.08506091684103012,
-1.0147864818572998,
-0.16440553963184357,
-0.6091951727867126,
0.6009856462478638,
-0.39504197239875793,
-0.9489274621009827,
0.5616615414619446,
0.23703508079051971,
0.10934614390134811,
0.6740736961364746,
0.7000464797019958,
0.47011542320251465,
1.3100110292434692,
0.6589253544807434,
-0.5923380255699158,
0.4251926839351654,
-0.0508856400847435,
0.2249230295419693,
-1.0460388660430908,
-0.5776540637016296,
-0.4609488248825073,
-0.46333950757980347,
-0.2931807339191437,
-0.5287121534347534,
0.3213373124599457,
0.22577784955501556,
-0.5920416712760925,
0.08365898579359055,
-0.6653057336807251,
0.49200549721717834,
0.9352993369102478,
0.4583989083766937,
-0.04406244680285454,
0.0046634366735816,
0.29948732256889343,
0.16563895344734192,
-0.7274875044822693,
-0.19680647552013397,
1.0998934507369995,
0.5878549814224243,
0.47907736897468567,
0.30790188908576965,
0.2303156554698944,
0.24922996759414673,
0.20614506304264069,
-0.8916351199150085,
0.517565131187439,
0.040872324258089066,
-0.874714195728302,
-0.1777258664369583,
-0.2268524020910263,
-0.3165980279445648,
0.25321725010871887,
0.019312404096126556,
-0.7165229320526123,
0.14046171307563782,
0.1664305478334427,
-0.5950321555137634,
0.4420238435268402,
-0.5376031994819641,
0.7482805848121643,
-0.2656034529209137,
-0.36681294441223145,
-0.5572447180747986,
-0.7922078371047974,
0.44227635860443115,
-0.235147163271904,
-0.2467898279428482,
-0.0955023318529129,
-0.024823937565088272,
1.052315592765808,
-0.3580802381038666,
0.40715306997299194,
-0.3356872797012329,
0.1480129361152649,
0.5122430324554443,
-0.16904933750629425,
0.5531818866729736,
0.0066038160584867,
-0.3877391815185547,
0.21215792000293732,
-0.6423692107200623,
-0.50168776512146,
-0.35039085149765015,
0.47442203760147095,
-1.1237527132034302,
-0.8843901753425598,
-0.04569580405950546,
-0.31366556882858276,
-0.19069349765777588,
0.2807002365589142,
0.1656969040632248,
0.43439048528671265,
-0.11215576529502869,
0.4209422469139099,
1.0081801414489746,
0.1312716156244278,
0.36628255248069763,
0.41895321011543274,
0.06358923017978668,
-0.8092049956321716,
1.0494093894958496,
-0.06528693437576294,
0.10345245897769928,
0.57003253698349,
0.06471013277769089,
-0.19773611426353455,
-0.7316378951072693,
-0.9745416045188904,
-0.011869397014379501,
-0.5928035974502563,
-0.29679206013679504,
-0.93516606092453,
-0.6131733655929565,
-0.2491278499364853,
-0.1949853152036667,
-0.418173611164093,
-0.41658642888069153,
-0.577368974685669,
-0.16041062772274017,
0.3295072317123413,
0.8335784673690796,
0.047506045550107956,
0.5347869992256165,
-0.751910924911499,
0.2591783106327057,
0.4422195255756378,
0.19524140655994415,
0.43433186411857605,
-0.8500147461891174,
-0.8592007756233215,
-0.033458199352025986,
-0.4387265741825104,
-0.6059089303016663,
0.035881735384464264,
-0.0062986109405756,
0.8647950291633606,
1.2072761058807373,
-0.45447900891304016,
0.5442887544631958,
-0.3743036985397339,
0.8065085411071777,
0.3185676634311676,
-0.8753809928894043,
0.1623927503824234,
-0.5863600969314575,
-0.09555321931838989,
0.4745822250843048,
-0.03369871526956558,
-0.2983010411262512,
-0.3364567458629608,
-0.5337716937065125,
-0.49804767966270447,
1.2693489789962769,
-0.012525144033133984,
0.08920438587665558,
0.313975065946579,
0.3542953133583069,
-0.08830148726701736,
0.06646779179573059,
-0.5766568183898926,
-0.33538952469825745,
-0.1277402937412262,
-0.29232344031333923,
0.23321488499641418,
-0.6031144261360168,
-0.13746055960655212,
-0.3025375306606293,
0.6423095464706421,
0.018504580482840538,
0.5403238534927368,
-0.044252946972846985,
0.12888099253177643,
-0.22467203438282013,
-0.219814732670784,
0.5413347482681274,
0.7271780371665955,
-0.2720903158187866,
-0.032749198377132416,
0.4912313222885132,
-0.728406548500061,
0.033149074763059616,
0.059786614030599594,
-0.10159730166196823,
-0.23790483176708221,
0.18913906812667847,
0.6547566652297974,
0.4523575007915497,
-0.34179213643074036,
0.3717539310455322,
0.4501516819000244,
-0.3866528272628784,
-0.07775901257991791,
0.49910968542099,
0.3680223226547241,
0.36707770824432373,
0.45258909463882446,
0.46403422951698303,
0.4970189332962036,
0.08812051266431808,
0.13942228257656097,
0.23830288648605347,
-0.41389548778533936,
-0.42369344830513,
1.0119497776031494,
0.5688207149505615,
-0.3853595554828644,
0.38114941120147705,
-0.39728033542633057,
-0.7329842448234558,
1.1971737146377563,
0.5652590990066528,
0.6981638073921204,
-0.2091199904680252,
0.03136686235666275,
0.41889846324920654,
0.22343838214874268,
-0.5185808539390564,
0.25508126616477966,
0.04877090826630592,
-0.73445063829422,
-0.015447874553501606,
-0.15312309563159943,
-0.6693382263183594,
-0.3198264241218567,
-0.8242238759994507,
0.40226367115974426,
-0.6190961003303528,
-0.145670086145401,
-0.1860172152519226,
0.42586973309516907,
-0.441806823015213,
0.5112844109535217,
0.17186813056468964,
1.114306092262268,
-0.3799373507499695,
1.0802419185638428,
0.9747502207756042,
-0.03428828343749046,
-0.9469338059425354,
-0.38715121150016785,
-0.06594113260507584,
-0.9766635298728943,
0.7373011708259583,
0.2417779117822647,
-0.22277460992336273,
0.1485002338886261,
-0.1406133770942688,
-1.0560412406921387,
1.4661005735397339,
-0.025550467893481255,
-0.47239500284194946,
0.1371058076620102,
-0.11022926867008209,
0.3868275582790375,
-0.11324302852153778,
0.38387152552604675,
0.2772863805294037,
0.39701130986213684,
0.20921704173088074,
-0.9306532144546509,
-0.044600341469049454,
-0.5496127009391785,
-0.25183215737342834,
0.17208020389080048,
-1.5817731618881226,
1.3729068040847778,
-0.4148266613483429,
0.06969711184501648,
-0.008049176074564457,
0.9581750631332397,
0.4082447588443756,
0.3243469297885895,
0.37336277961730957,
0.7141363620758057,
0.5877885222434998,
-0.031847331672906876,
0.4214215874671936,
-0.6098850965499878,
0.2707202136516571,
0.9831867814064026,
-0.25853243470191956,
0.9617372751235962,
0.1521369218826294,
-0.38547927141189575,
0.5243856310844421,
1.1465743780136108,
-0.21041491627693176,
0.7046254873275757,
-0.23532575368881226,
-0.30579158663749695,
-0.20263689756393433,
0.21403005719184875,
-0.805076003074646,
0.05730272829532623,
0.15860898792743683,
-0.1562170833349228,
0.010524686425924301,
-0.656356155872345,
0.24111686646938324,
-0.5983040928840637,
-0.42698365449905396,
0.9763522744178772,
0.09214556217193604,
-0.8701692819595337,
0.03433017060160637,
0.6382965445518494,
0.6970726847648621,
-0.33833131194114685,
0.04227776452898979,
-0.3110368847846985,
0.32911837100982666,
-0.27065467834472656,
-0.8077273964881897,
-0.021423179656267166,
-0.05508534982800484,
-0.13739758729934692,
0.3228108286857605,
0.9274593591690063,
-0.09536047279834747,
-0.8425660729408264,
0.24110782146453857,
0.4401457607746124,
0.06575121730566025,
-0.2601821720600128,
-0.8675091862678528,
-0.40335512161254883,
0.12566934525966644,
-0.7052853107452393,
0.44638243317604065,
0.6435267329216003,
0.12143556028604507,
0.5928440690040588,
0.4434257447719574,
0.05220383033156395,
0.11294097453355789,
-0.1629249006509781,
1.101419448852539,
-0.5615202188491821,
-0.6090853214263916,
-0.6260968446731567,
0.42439594864845276,
-0.2423783391714096,
-0.6752383708953857,
0.5029682517051697,
0.7888076305389404,
0.8344862461090088,
0.020847942680120468,
0.6217761635780334,
0.06774953752756119,
0.12671159207820892,
-0.4621806740760803,
0.7115798592567444,
-0.5810412764549255,
-0.07279839366674423,
0.18516428768634796,
-0.8216824531555176,
-0.06521382927894592,
0.42294833064079285,
-0.059645529836416245,
0.2672886252403259,
0.5263110399246216,
0.7236466407775879,
-0.13192597031593323,
-0.03500613942742348,
0.00641779787838459,
-0.22437024116516113,
0.04955606907606125,
0.6966258883476257,
0.4769383370876312,
-0.49992460012435913,
0.3470950722694397,
-0.3854777216911316,
-0.33108285069465637,
-0.7099115252494812,
-0.3216782212257385,
-1.1463617086410522,
0.07112471759319305,
-0.17464600503444672,
-0.15940004587173462,
-0.18532635271549225,
0.8308885097503662,
0.8496428728103638,
-1.0269935131072998,
-0.25229576230049133,
0.0020929216407239437,
0.17018598318099976,
-0.3273298144340515,
-0.18673557043075562,
0.47203534841537476,
-0.2767806649208069,
-0.6190409660339355,
0.06140309199690819,
0.44414427876472473,
-0.03401075676083565,
-0.46555185317993164,
-0.4941764771938324,
0.2608731985092163,
0.029710369184613228,
0.5362492799758911,
-0.09658707678318024,
-0.8316360712051392,
-0.11443231999874115,
0.28910839557647705,
-0.33380332589149475,
0.2925783395767212,
0.5337067246437073,
-0.4057968258857727,
0.08660642057657242,
0.6175881028175354,
0.6792064309120178,
0.2858932316303253,
0.2950296103954315,
0.3047812879085541,
-0.20904190838336945,
0.43396079540252686,
-0.09581218659877777,
0.4003111720085144,
0.11391925811767578,
-0.6644600629806519,
0.7206823825836182,
0.31800970435142517,
-0.7749767899513245,
-0.495116263628006,
-0.11097154766321182,
-1.3138484954833984,
-0.03292875364422798,
1.22850501537323,
-0.10632968693971634,
0.061285682022571564,
-0.1956641972064972,
-0.4056539237499237,
0.08909907937049866,
-0.6128556132316589,
0.8699470162391663,
0.754237174987793,
-0.17923615872859955,
-0.003707106225192547,
-0.6129353642463684,
0.31241217255592346,
0.631636917591095,
-0.7144142389297485,
-0.41167086362838745,
0.32800933718681335,
0.3853219449520111,
-0.0646665021777153,
0.9706678986549377,
-0.10357536375522614,
0.5569682121276855,
0.47350797057151794,
-0.010891560465097427,
-0.1653692126274109,
-0.6164272427558899,
-0.007637821603566408,
0.13239528238773346,
0.36599937081336975,
-0.25111645460128784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17974v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17974v1
|
Recent Trends in Personalized Dialogue Generation: A Review of Datasets, Methodologies, and Evaluations
| 2024-05-28T09:04:13 | 2024-05-28T09:04:13 |
Yi-Pei Chen, Noriki Nishida, Hideki Nakayama, Yuji Matsumoto
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Enhancing user engagement through personalization in conversational agents
has gained significance, especially with the advent of large language models
that generate fluent responses. Personalized dialogue generation, however, is
multifaceted and varies in its definition -- ranging from instilling a persona
in the agent to capturing users' explicit and implicit cues. This paper seeks
to systemically survey the recent landscape of personalized dialogue
generation, including the datasets employed, methodologies developed, and
evaluation metrics applied. Covering 22 datasets, we highlight benchmark
datasets and newer ones enriched with additional features. We further analyze
17 seminal works from top conferences between 2021-2023 and identify five
distinct types of problems. We also shed light on recent progress by LLMs in
personalized dialogue generation. Our evaluation section offers a comprehensive
summary of assessment facets and metrics utilized in these works. In
conclusion, we discuss prevailing challenges and envision prospect directions
for future research in personalized dialogue generation.
|
[
-0.7391602396965027,
-0.6314730644226074,
0.5482890605926514,
-0.015663644298911095,
0.34268590807914734,
0.6182714700698853,
-0.11923938989639282,
-0.18647317588329315,
0.0654243528842926,
0.5834949016571045,
-0.7645099759101868,
-0.5322157144546509,
-0.05935676023364067,
0.26927343010902405,
-0.046115048229694366,
0.9602938294410706,
0.34489762783050537,
0.01287783496081829,
-0.41675686836242676,
-0.07261920720338821,
-0.7454663515090942,
-0.6544868350028992,
-0.4754101037979126,
-0.410165935754776,
0.6389036178588867,
0.3618527352809906,
0.44906213879585266,
0.12026315182447433,
0.35485801100730896,
0.45150426030158997,
-0.16148294508457184,
0.21742171049118042,
-0.39593377709388733,
0.6332078576087952,
0.19279628992080688,
-0.11735296994447708,
-0.378971666097641,
-0.036831408739089966,
0.6472620368003845,
0.8656136989593506,
-0.06503012031316757,
-0.0019183543045073748,
-0.11387655884027481,
0.5342832803726196,
-0.42064186930656433,
0.06651545315980911,
-0.6265015602111816,
0.19615046679973602,
-0.3371965289115906,
-0.4202040135860443,
-0.3375217020511627,
-0.5065081119537354,
0.45415228605270386,
-0.3226935863494873,
0.23603172600269318,
0.07934337109327316,
0.37603461742401123,
-0.13181395828723907,
-0.6461848020553589,
-0.5971895456314087,
-0.8313496112823486,
0.8977288007736206,
-0.5264487266540527,
0.10634173452854156,
-0.041902195662260056,
0.6689425110816956,
-0.4987882375717163,
-0.9469491839408875,
-0.18249386548995972,
-0.43540892004966736,
0.29358306527137756,
0.15566956996917725,
-0.37572842836380005,
-0.0726081132888794,
0.10027842968702316,
0.38938120007514954,
-0.08654621988534927,
0.09123803675174713,
0.04041512310504913,
-0.14730589091777802,
0.7425006628036499,
0.6832197904586792,
0.08943656831979752,
-0.12258987128734589,
-0.1157996878027916,
-0.06043082848191261,
-0.6484465003013611,
0.11392643302679062,
0.7338165044784546,
0.18340907990932465,
0.0020913872867822647,
0.20771251618862152,
-0.5758165717124939,
0.676440417766571,
0.24401578307151794,
-0.13659799098968506,
0.19395069777965546,
-0.746293306350708,
0.07658043503761292,
-0.10162349790334702,
0.8902407288551331,
0.5110278129577637,
0.1839568018913269,
-0.14827251434326172,
-0.099986732006073,
-0.4929203689098358,
0.13586010038852692,
-0.6705660820007324,
-0.06134449690580368,
0.27458375692367554,
-0.2350480556488037,
-0.6542972326278687,
0.03361000865697861,
-0.8000882863998413,
-0.5162562131881714,
-0.3345796763896942,
-0.4212481677532196,
0.06320396810770035,
0.006536534521728754,
-0.22071056067943573,
-0.0396847203373909,
0.14298181235790253,
0.5531005263328552,
-0.9669167399406433,
0.34465399384498596,
0.47253772616386414,
0.4704490005970001,
-0.18539711833000183,
0.1899576485157013,
-0.3157649040222168,
-0.06467444449663162,
-0.3768742084503174,
0.9307118654251099,
-0.6001089811325073,
-0.5540035963058472,
0.5243459939956665,
-0.3934365212917328,
0.06946859508752823,
-0.7813225984573364,
0.17210377752780914,
-0.34032273292541504,
0.4918822944164276,
-0.5530090928077698,
-0.25655943155288696,
0.12066265195608139,
0.43055081367492676,
-0.188019797205925,
0.6737807393074036,
0.24118399620056152,
-0.5806591510772705,
0.3922896683216095,
-0.6393874287605286,
-0.02933531068265438,
0.4413382112979889,
-0.5650668144226074,
-0.2952628433704376,
0.09334687143564224,
-0.031627655029296875,
0.44069981575012207,
-0.7223161458969116,
0.4435855746269226,
-0.2673273980617523,
-0.03528042882680893,
0.5682954788208008,
-0.27200034260749817,
0.34546133875846863,
0.5243049263954163,
-0.1278669238090515,
0.19238685071468353,
-0.6761377453804016,
0.1822613775730133,
0.16800132393836975,
-0.14835788309574127,
0.20629821717739105,
0.02314068377017975,
-0.00364872207865119,
0.14415569603443146,
0.40338635444641113,
-0.5306112766265869,
0.008118322119116783,
-0.4019762873649597,
0.5888766050338745,
0.8099865317344666,
0.5092990398406982,
0.31789398193359375,
-0.35493192076683044,
0.6050437688827515,
0.13351717591285706,
-0.060624849051237106,
-0.8422231078147888,
-0.4485628604888916,
-0.4541926383972168,
0.1585434377193451,
0.08413923531770706,
0.3602786660194397,
-0.3673948347568512,
0.5309603810310364,
-0.13940587639808655,
-0.5081786513328552,
-0.1903252750635147,
0.3176337480545044,
0.44040822982788086,
0.5582286715507507,
-0.12841208279132843,
-0.6861253380775452,
-0.41349872946739197,
-0.8307706713676453,
-0.16157041490077972,
-0.08530135452747345,
0.009459758177399635,
0.8709181547164917,
0.03529518470168114,
-0.4251556098461151,
1.2673723697662354,
-0.5985803604125977,
-0.011432906612753868,
-0.41694095730781555,
0.19247159361839294,
-0.23281846940517426,
0.2948291301727295,
0.39070749282836914,
-0.5762984156608582,
-0.6520587801933289,
0.277750164270401,
-0.7614153623580933,
-0.25530558824539185,
-0.22066476941108704,
0.11166486144065857,
-0.23175321519374847,
0.21711695194244385,
-0.2589281499385834,
0.06137307733297348,
0.22960123419761658,
-0.017878159880638123,
0.4469520151615143,
0.019582640379667282,
0.142286479473114,
-1.188301682472229,
-0.07897520810365677,
0.14965727925300598,
-0.2395644634962082,
-0.9933622479438782,
-0.44524699449539185,
-0.7191407680511475,
-0.26926949620246887,
-0.38733091950416565,
0.6749043464660645,
-0.3427843749523163,
-0.2142830193042755,
-0.16276030242443085,
0.3915112614631653,
-0.30792948603630066,
0.38122037053108215,
-0.24730689823627472,
0.5316575169563293,
0.25805121660232544,
-0.3662792444229126,
0.7099525332450867,
0.8079124689102173,
-0.274754136800766,
0.5912641286849976,
-0.5703203082084656,
0.7378073930740356,
0.13313111662864685,
0.45040664076805115,
-0.9512930512428284,
-0.5094274878501892,
0.24682724475860596,
-0.20561610162258148,
0.020165950059890747,
0.16616079211235046,
-0.34297430515289307,
-0.1887723058462143,
-0.49863865971565247,
0.21486333012580872,
0.42922863364219666,
-0.3920303285121918,
0.19677448272705078,
0.3110508918762207,
-0.6143016219139099,
-0.12457310408353806,
-0.05389925464987755,
0.41684409976005554,
-0.3560754954814911,
-0.902713418006897,
0.013060777448117733,
-0.39448192715644836,
-0.5848172307014465,
-0.6918326020240784,
0.0896969810128212,
0.3251022696495056,
0.05034017935395241,
0.12034019827842712,
-0.20829074084758759,
0.024778448045253754,
-0.3199736177921295,
0.09769953787326813,
-0.18297293782234192,
0.003740251762792468,
0.08104529976844788,
0.7517309188842773,
-0.19308920204639435,
-0.3131334185600281,
-0.527911365032196,
0.39668673276901245,
-0.04810277745127678,
-0.12570002675056458,
0.13885320723056793,
0.5638198256492615,
0.07440663129091263,
0.11629781126976013,
-0.7685598134994507,
-0.221937358379364,
-0.5183649063110352,
0.26029059290885925,
-0.3779095411300659,
-0.9806615710258484,
0.4953154921531677,
-0.7063537836074829,
0.33903583884239197,
-0.020761150866746902,
1.050126552581787,
-0.15757304430007935,
1.3928722143173218,
0.40578263998031616,
0.37786605954170227,
0.7167420983314514,
0.031167274340987206,
0.22449861466884613,
-0.9515733122825623,
-0.5555046200752258,
-0.46089208126068115,
-0.04226187616586685,
-0.7700754404067993,
-0.01878344640135765,
0.28472980856895447,
-0.34285756945610046,
-0.11201060563325882,
0.02420332469046116,
-0.2998473048210144,
-0.07906907796859741,
0.41135668754577637,
-0.3371598720550537,
0.27039989829063416,
0.058651477098464966,
0.032563623040914536,
-0.3559063971042633,
-0.39132165908813477,
-0.8699852824211121,
1.0991919040679932,
0.35712409019470215,
0.5277324318885803,
0.14701662957668304,
0.7278358340263367,
0.5587128400802612,
0.1661940962076187,
-0.5176485180854797,
0.5435799956321716,
0.34229588508605957,
-0.3870619237422943,
-0.06497013568878174,
-0.24034062027931213,
-1.271140217781067,
0.2820289433002472,
-0.07880914211273193,
-1.042715072631836,
0.11862293630838394,
0.2345026433467865,
-0.31835657358169556,
-0.37538641691207886,
-0.7310355305671692,
0.6629027724266052,
-0.07083507627248764,
-0.3587040901184082,
0.07957779616117477,
-0.7958720922470093,
0.46911630034446716,
-0.20133145153522491,
-0.16108515858650208,
-0.2792385220527649,
0.18291251361370087,
0.5590705871582031,
-0.3135964870452881,
0.8907787799835205,
-0.3083725869655609,
-0.13965833187103271,
0.40326184034347534,
-0.27358412742614746,
0.4770588278770447,
0.1113467738032341,
0.15587399899959564,
-0.30693820118904114,
-0.013425127603113651,
-0.25691306591033936,
-0.4680420756340027,
0.7186629772186279,
-0.42836180329322815,
-0.7070716023445129,
-0.1894581913948059,
-0.3696356415748596,
-0.6638820767402649,
-0.0676303505897522,
0.2900831699371338,
0.5052434802055359,
-0.8303409814834595,
0.23426048457622528,
0.551131010055542,
-0.3121393620967865,
0.44171494245529175,
0.17785927653312683,
0.02678377367556095,
-0.6017594933509827,
1.0806913375854492,
-0.19500979781150818,
0.18740074336528778,
0.13508106768131256,
0.26936250925064087,
-0.22051379084587097,
-0.6217556595802307,
-0.35791119933128357,
-0.04779547452926636,
-0.5736824870109558,
-0.19668439030647278,
-0.4811020791530609,
-0.008850020356476307,
-0.6088795065879822,
-0.21670778095722198,
-0.2120768129825592,
-0.06066053733229637,
-0.19421324133872986,
0.09041263908147812,
-0.1343521624803543,
1.0200951099395752,
0.38331037759780884,
0.5788683295249939,
-0.6172972321510315,
-0.003191823372617364,
0.3541039824485779,
-0.17460958659648895,
-0.07599712908267975,
-0.095387302339077,
-0.23450371623039246,
-0.07392362505197525,
-0.964040219783783,
-0.8373386263847351,
0.3046512007713318,
0.15627293288707733,
0.7324823141098022,
0.596585214138031,
-0.22177885472774506,
0.3768376410007477,
-0.42097508907318115,
1.0245003700256348,
0.3043549656867981,
-0.5891280174255371,
0.6343613862991333,
-0.5309779644012451,
0.3972058594226837,
0.42199206352233887,
-0.007769166491925716,
-0.7277380228042603,
-0.24833834171295166,
-0.7235201001167297,
-0.6098013520240784,
0.653439998626709,
0.26301392912864685,
0.5940980911254883,
-0.01744329184293747,
0.2979079484939575,
0.25256386399269104,
0.6847459077835083,
-0.18443825840950012,
-0.20668692886829376,
0.03554527461528778,
-0.26074618101119995,
-0.1715073436498642,
-0.19570213556289673,
-0.32302194833755493,
0.10348303616046906,
0.15455931425094604,
-0.436453253030777,
0.4196116626262665,
-0.1377432942390442,
0.2249028980731964,
0.004891922231763601,
0.4254074692726135,
0.8284085392951965,
0.55898118019104,
-0.130295991897583,
-0.5621156096458435,
0.018738437443971634,
-0.14023809134960175,
0.12563268840312958,
-0.021337898448109627,
-0.2400638610124588,
-0.13495120406150818,
0.14803236722946167,
0.8445069789886475,
0.18369553983211517,
-0.7214763760566711,
0.5545796751976013,
-0.17470616102218628,
-0.22205568850040436,
-0.7090673446655273,
0.10459499061107635,
-0.18331143260002136,
0.23581624031066895,
0.1810280680656433,
-0.05807235836982727,
0.3046940863132477,
-0.5749677419662476,
-0.20283104479312897,
0.6043060421943665,
-0.37884721159935,
-0.7555484175682068,
0.4847586154937744,
0.7429081797599792,
-0.3486783504486084,
0.3730747699737549,
0.0017607742920517921,
-0.10369155555963516,
0.07961095124483109,
0.25521114468574524,
1.1180529594421387,
-0.1974526196718216,
0.13938604295253754,
0.0916299819946289,
-0.3138493597507477,
0.47898533940315247,
-0.013585046865046024,
-0.6178669333457947,
-0.9253871440887451,
0.10841343551874161,
-0.33367234468460083,
-0.7295392751693726,
0.22103285789489746,
-0.5653115510940552,
0.0987708643078804,
-0.43771612644195557,
-0.48145827651023865,
0.06845615804195404,
0.3735722303390503,
-0.7983158230781555,
0.004657113458961248,
0.13917168974876404,
0.45006415247917175,
-0.5080340504646301,
0.41689929366111755,
0.6820664405822754,
-0.18157389760017395,
-0.04205125570297241,
-0.13338389992713928,
0.36895552277565,
-0.4451092779636383,
0.4518503248691559,
-0.10345757007598877,
-0.1877942830324173,
-0.013646489009261131,
-0.6488234996795654,
-0.3700866401195526,
1.2115375995635986,
0.15066370368003845,
-0.3805157542228699,
-0.1942419856786728,
0.3434675335884094,
0.5571733713150024,
-0.9401894807815552,
0.4729832708835602,
0.979927122592926,
0.3615274727344513,
0.20868225395679474,
-0.5068119764328003,
-0.3128316402435303,
-0.32417207956314087,
0.47232332825660706,
-0.05349312350153923,
-0.9554016590118408,
0.26613497734069824,
-0.017847424373030663,
-0.09546148777008057,
0.5629774332046509,
0.6160747408866882,
0.3133729100227356,
0.5864225625991821,
0.3595885932445526,
0.00453908322378993,
0.6133912801742554,
-0.23489752411842346,
1.03656804561615,
-0.17942564189434052,
-0.07360851019620895,
0.9242223501205444,
-0.5484933257102966,
0.3740997612476349,
0.32627591490745544,
-0.12309419363737106,
0.43697309494018555,
0.7514726519584656,
-0.17279203236103058,
0.45649075508117676,
0.346113920211792,
-0.6134818196296692,
-0.22525964677333832,
-0.41594693064689636,
-0.2513791620731354,
0.43856215476989746,
0.35702067613601685,
-0.36772191524505615,
-0.16409236192703247,
0.18719886243343353,
-0.01771959848701954,
0.16551098227500916,
0.23503677546977997,
1.3230233192443848,
-0.06573285907506943,
-0.7547476291656494,
0.2092892974615097,
-0.10554639995098114,
0.4145205616950989,
-0.5569556355476379,
-0.12457827478647232,
-0.43223610520362854,
0.01684674061834812,
-0.08983258157968521,
-0.4938738942146301,
-0.3395845592021942,
0.15366841852664948,
0.07816872000694275,
-0.573127269744873,
0.7168193459510803,
-0.14546266198158264,
0.02995227463543415,
-0.03231566771864891,
0.7545604109764099,
0.35900577902793884,
0.1570439636707306,
-0.6000219583511353,
0.21881484985351562,
0.385754257440567,
-0.4270079433917999,
0.5258676409721375,
0.218434676527977,
-0.12794707715511322,
0.8206773400306702,
0.6250730752944946,
-0.2143765538930893,
0.25133422017097473,
0.3951324224472046,
0.9003279805183411,
-0.7811867594718933,
-0.15238085389137268,
-0.16622839868068695,
0.5881341695785522,
-0.08741135150194168,
-0.7105469703674316,
0.7889490127563477,
0.5159547924995422,
0.5762462019920349,
0.011915987357497215,
0.957578182220459,
0.08818783611059189,
0.5183551907539368,
-0.2042311728000641,
0.13696196675300598,
-0.08190271258354187,
0.3522762060165405,
-0.3573785126209259,
-0.9375598430633545,
0.16577056050300598,
0.07630118727684021,
-0.1960865557193756,
0.5743741989135742,
0.18216204643249512,
0.48066461086273193,
0.4290945827960968,
0.046733759343624115,
0.514265239238739,
-0.05387428030371666,
0.7672559022903442,
0.11729169636964798,
1.389544129371643,
-0.19839675724506378,
0.30664902925491333,
-0.2376684844493866,
-0.06929348409175873,
-0.4246840476989746,
-0.6383534073829651,
-0.8175281882286072,
-0.8228455185890198,
-0.4030436873435974,
0.005788951646536589,
-0.019243089482188225,
0.851664662361145,
0.571565568447113,
-0.6515126824378967,
-0.3887922763824463,
-0.1913404017686844,
-0.2148524820804596,
0.18635067343711853,
-0.19477730989456177,
-0.25149255990982056,
-0.7216638922691345,
-1.1406114101409912,
0.5763306617736816,
0.26043498516082764,
0.2323152720928192,
-0.5480771660804749,
-0.27620309591293335,
0.19458985328674316,
0.19542430341243744,
0.6268472075462341,
0.5506328344345093,
-0.7062750458717346,
-0.006059168837964535,
-0.09861908853054047,
-0.07083602994680405,
0.3069414794445038,
1.092557668685913,
-0.7390708327293396,
0.6667407751083374,
0.408273309469223,
0.4025726616382599,
0.619903564453125,
0.33172106742858887,
0.9521408081054688,
-0.841101884841919,
-0.11157495528459549,
0.35409101843833923,
0.09344010800123215,
0.7133503556251526,
-0.19285333156585693,
0.2755487859249115,
0.18077579140663147,
-0.6593146324157715,
-0.9057552218437195,
0.47249603271484375,
-0.9416192770004272,
0.3214918375015259,
0.737246572971344,
-0.11235470324754715,
0.19490550458431244,
-0.26183804869651794,
-0.3816596269607544,
-0.23629193007946014,
-0.5946889519691467,
0.4438888132572174,
0.6732734441757202,
-0.6681002378463745,
-0.031106719747185707,
-0.43274468183517456,
0.6714501976966858,
0.4284701347351074,
-1.0510166883468628,
-0.030023688450455666,
0.6632254719734192,
0.009586730040609837,
0.3381418287754059,
0.6727281212806702,
-0.06150996312499046,
0.19993582367897034,
-0.00881665013730526,
-0.11255912482738495,
0.15252242982387543,
-0.2694595754146576,
-0.3054654002189636,
0.16856028139591217,
0.40038299560546875,
0.13965988159179688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17969v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17969v1
|
Knowledge Circuits in Pretrained Transformers
| 2024-05-28T08:56:33 | 2024-05-28T08:56:33 |
Yunzhi Yao, Ningyu Zhang, Zekun Xi, Mengru Wang, Ziwen Xu, Shumin Deng, Huajun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
The remarkable capabilities of modern large language models are rooted in
their vast repositories of knowledge encoded within their parameters, enabling
them to perceive the world and engage in reasoning. The inner workings of how
these models store knowledge have long been a subject of intense interest and
investigation among researchers. To date, most studies have concentrated on
isolated components within these models, such as the Multilayer Perceptrons and
attention head. In this paper, we delve into the computation graph of the
language model to uncover the knowledge circuits that are instrumental in
articulating specific knowledge. The experiments, conducted with GPT2 and
TinyLLAMA, has allowed us to observe how certain information heads, relation
heads, and Multilayer Perceptrons collaboratively encode knowledge within the
model. Moreover, we evaluate the impact of current knowledge editing techniques
on these knowledge circuits, providing deeper insights into the functioning and
constraints of these editing methodologies. Finally, we utilize knowledge
circuits to analyze and interpret language model behaviors such as
hallucinations and in-context learning. We believe the knowledge circuit holds
potential for advancing our understanding of Transformers and guiding the
improved design of knowledge editing. Code and data are available in
https://github.com/zjunlp/KnowledgeCircuits.
|
[
-0.6088459491729736,
-0.6473017334938049,
0.8930937647819519,
-0.24935400485992432,
0.24233482778072357,
0.011022999882698059,
-0.40733787417411804,
-0.33248791098594666,
-0.03406566008925438,
0.6601864695549011,
-0.6347517371177673,
-0.2173498272895813,
-0.5558711886405945,
-0.26547980308532715,
-0.5594404339790344,
0.9965700507164001,
0.026138002052903175,
-0.20871838927268982,
-0.23543547093868256,
0.08362868428230286,
-0.35174307227134705,
-0.7465546131134033,
-0.2546256482601166,
-0.6370540857315063,
0.4530998468399048,
0.3390364646911621,
0.81565922498703,
0.19109421968460083,
0.46007421612739563,
0.3396431505680084,
-0.1264229714870453,
0.002054888755083084,
-0.3430754244327545,
-0.011212768964469433,
-0.4017673134803772,
-0.4683252274990082,
-0.49792081117630005,
0.06493785232305527,
0.4919460415840149,
0.6683852076530457,
-0.008603944443166256,
0.2155098021030426,
-0.003270102897658944,
0.43872150778770447,
-0.5301252603530884,
0.30743640661239624,
-0.7368304133415222,
0.18697240948677063,
-0.30061373114585876,
-0.20233044028282166,
-0.726272702217102,
-0.17773394286632538,
0.16351188719272614,
-0.5853315591812134,
0.22975276410579681,
-0.1178070530295372,
0.6640587449073792,
0.3963281810283661,
-0.20098701119422913,
-0.2548508942127228,
-0.86654132604599,
0.45152387022972107,
-0.13775818049907684,
0.7709115147590637,
0.2932336628437042,
0.34190383553504944,
0.004844631999731064,
-1.3289812803268433,
-0.8814194798469543,
0.022500216960906982,
-0.39644747972488403,
0.1107039526104927,
-0.32326632738113403,
0.27637800574302673,
0.5617912411689758,
0.22959525883197784,
-0.19675208628177643,
-0.08713747560977936,
-0.4334428310394287,
-0.30497196316719055,
0.14090490341186523,
0.05205962061882019,
0.36364391446113586,
-0.28354305028915405,
0.026006517931818962,
-0.2690295875072479,
-0.6640921235084534,
-0.0418551079928875,
0.428124338388443,
-0.20938391983509064,
0.08520820736885071,
0.5091983079910278,
-0.019229020923376083,
0.7586727142333984,
0.1377875953912735,
0.03499149531126022,
0.14684580266475677,
-0.15081509947776794,
-0.23428355157375336,
-0.020689409226179123,
0.8203682899475098,
-0.01661549136042595,
0.680717408657074,
-0.5170238018035889,
-0.10351632535457611,
-0.07595712691545486,
0.7743214964866638,
-0.6334220170974731,
-0.7374764680862427,
-0.21838673949241638,
-0.24212956428527832,
-0.22809027135372162,
0.01957295462489128,
-0.5303389430046082,
-0.36891376972198486,
-0.4509243369102478,
0.684234619140625,
-0.3647071421146393,
-0.2301899492740631,
0.06669358164072037,
-0.28556397557258606,
-0.03884651139378548,
0.09030791372060776,
-1.1773096323013306,
0.25282853841781616,
0.4652825593948364,
0.4439144432544708,
0.13416622579097748,
-0.4866689443588257,
-0.004063442349433899,
0.23521265387535095,
-0.02959933876991272,
0.8580337762832642,
-0.6263650059700012,
-0.04555647075176239,
-0.2375723421573639,
-0.012362630106508732,
-0.30005380511283875,
-0.4915850758552551,
0.3022584915161133,
-1.0261553525924683,
0.01960102841258049,
-0.3580872118473053,
-0.4876477122306824,
-0.11576913297176361,
-0.12261689454317093,
-0.6840961575508118,
0.6019459366798401,
0.33271175622940063,
-1.069838285446167,
-0.018245963379740715,
-0.7332865595817566,
-0.536268949508667,
-0.29158926010131836,
-0.19235104322433472,
-0.1621050238609314,
0.24820327758789062,
0.32513225078582764,
0.2742892801761627,
-0.17368577420711517,
-0.08738984912633896,
0.07472272217273712,
-0.2628236413002014,
0.539447009563446,
-0.1870587170124054,
0.6838435530662537,
0.003500185441225767,
-0.31535398960113525,
0.36769458651542664,
-0.43174251914024353,
-0.08758816868066788,
0.11808344721794128,
0.22264158725738525,
-0.18749387562274933,
-0.13896584510803223,
-0.32572633028030396,
0.4162393808364868,
0.13576333224773407,
-0.33936968445777893,
0.28493037819862366,
-0.17828771471977234,
0.7536376118659973,
0.8131459355354309,
0.22596292197704315,
0.5695554614067078,
0.08615390956401825,
0.5185284614562988,
0.08682744204998016,
0.41074076294898987,
-0.1332259476184845,
-0.5258124470710754,
-0.9486620426177979,
0.46497905254364014,
0.32622867822647095,
0.2877896726131439,
-1.0258750915527344,
0.28657791018486023,
-0.20156709849834442,
-0.547218918800354,
-0.5232865810394287,
0.09947820752859116,
0.1225007176399231,
0.6692193150520325,
0.5741275548934937,
-0.2403942197561264,
-0.3601355254650116,
-0.9320865869522095,
-0.21190403401851654,
-0.0668720006942749,
-0.1751563400030136,
0.0596182718873024,
0.3446211516857147,
-0.3675720691680908,
1.0980020761489868,
-0.6477027535438538,
-0.26185786724090576,
-0.39844444394111633,
-0.0786883682012558,
0.02452804520726204,
0.3957776427268982,
0.5242530107498169,
-0.44242215156555176,
-0.0464346706867218,
-0.10085512697696686,
-0.913917601108551,
0.0028450172394514084,
-0.06684163957834244,
-0.36040693521499634,
-0.33046749234199524,
0.6276064515113831,
-0.8998128175735474,
0.35300788283348083,
0.5921043157577515,
-0.1413464993238449,
0.5883095860481262,
-0.1062103807926178,
0.04501304775476456,
-0.5373066663742065,
-0.09786494076251984,
-0.4957943856716156,
-0.01523174624890089,
-0.7792908549308777,
0.06430014222860336,
0.3895411193370819,
0.08844544738531113,
-0.26607421040534973,
0.25465595722198486,
-0.1937248706817627,
-0.12290012091398239,
-0.20238763093948364,
0.2953043580055237,
0.02617543190717697,
0.8067183494567871,
0.14917238056659698,
0.8473057150840759,
0.4643193483352661,
-0.5243202447891235,
0.23792968690395355,
0.46472033858299255,
-0.6058177351951599,
0.10589027404785156,
-0.6155338883399963,
0.7172868847846985,
-0.11492807418107986,
-0.029171619564294815,
-0.5328668355941772,
-0.21328122913837433,
0.18666696548461914,
-0.3256801962852478,
0.28310683369636536,
0.016376420855522156,
-0.8685169219970703,
-0.5651118159294128,
0.15967966616153717,
0.5558823943138123,
0.5925019383430481,
-0.5391685962677002,
0.7030486464500427,
0.8293784856796265,
0.0445028580725193,
-0.1637355387210846,
-0.7352377772331238,
-0.22233840823173523,
0.20663245022296906,
-0.6138981580734253,
0.2455533742904663,
0.0999559536576271,
-0.21021340787410736,
0.00035200011916458607,
-0.09152182191610336,
-0.13223019242286682,
-0.10156194120645523,
0.284891277551651,
0.040649376809597015,
-0.10040765255689621,
0.45951151847839355,
0.2844076454639435,
-0.35431307554244995,
0.3099357485771179,
-0.5882209539413452,
0.8336365818977356,
-0.1559082269668579,
-0.5372512340545654,
-0.5522584319114685,
-0.20664788782596588,
0.5854948163032532,
-0.5863891243934631,
0.7544052600860596,
0.5276396870613098,
-0.4454876780509949,
-0.15953415632247925,
-0.6271976828575134,
-0.46781226992607117,
-0.5447810888290405,
0.449560284614563,
-0.4354519844055176,
-1.0203673839569092,
0.4659365117549896,
-0.10654005408287048,
-0.36059755086898804,
0.6476048231124878,
0.5870530605316162,
0.05213121697306633,
0.7982736229896545,
0.6627439260482788,
0.010250556282699108,
0.40804535150527954,
-0.41171473264694214,
0.4970654845237732,
-1.0197216272354126,
-0.29573529958724976,
-0.2923264801502228,
-0.2926684021949768,
-0.25356703996658325,
-0.48925256729125977,
0.6226135492324829,
0.19403637945652008,
-0.2555394470691681,
0.4367494583129883,
-0.5386841893196106,
0.8100289702415466,
0.5429525375366211,
0.23053044080734253,
0.41482028365135193,
-0.08596954494714737,
-0.36492919921875,
-0.1766541749238968,
-0.9103330373764038,
-0.3953898847103119,
1.2044106721878052,
0.37147119641304016,
0.6439945101737976,
-0.2150292694568634,
0.26485633850097656,
0.042376045137643814,
0.3624626696109772,
-0.7178264260292053,
0.403611421585083,
-0.0006194835295900702,
-0.5541371703147888,
-0.21973448991775513,
-0.3310791850090027,
-0.6032742261886597,
-0.036395225673913956,
-0.02342279441654682,
-0.8437637090682983,
0.07525475323200226,
0.2605550289154053,
-0.5207253694534302,
0.666258692741394,
-0.8830804228782654,
1.08353590965271,
-0.280106782913208,
-0.19007249176502228,
-0.4256651997566223,
-0.5912661552429199,
0.4003911316394806,
-0.1793857216835022,
0.08583423495292664,
0.5963318347930908,
0.6209815740585327,
0.8536048531532288,
-0.3006061613559723,
0.5552250146865845,
-0.09591400623321533,
-0.16183927655220032,
0.5147534608840942,
0.10681784152984619,
0.3352735638618469,
0.022990703582763672,
0.10427983850240707,
0.3114248514175415,
-0.26982519030570984,
0.07644528150558472,
-0.7311418056488037,
0.5268850922584534,
-0.9929983615875244,
-0.551242470741272,
-0.001123518217355013,
-0.6338009834289551,
-0.4852963387966156,
0.28693968057632446,
0.43491676449775696,
0.4110007584095001,
0.14567556977272034,
-0.0026942077092826366,
0.9237167835235596,
-0.41436171531677246,
0.10158570855855942,
0.16355584561824799,
-0.45926377177238464,
-0.0607135035097599,
0.8403460383415222,
0.22385434806346893,
0.35338282585144043,
0.39255043864250183,
-0.0637311190366745,
-0.12430611252784729,
-0.3949495553970337,
-0.23691734671592712,
0.21607397496700287,
-1.065636396408081,
-0.07198642194271088,
-1.0419880151748657,
-0.685009241104126,
-0.3901708424091339,
0.1258694976568222,
-0.5763334035873413,
-0.5686619281768799,
0.04183865338563919,
-0.3135121464729309,
0.13765999674797058,
1.179307460784912,
0.0609777569770813,
0.5692105293273926,
-0.7138481140136719,
0.5782552361488342,
0.8786579966545105,
0.42263615131378174,
0.3859151005744934,
-0.4463455080986023,
-0.5345020294189453,
-0.10275165736675262,
-0.4768672585487366,
-0.9223089814186096,
-0.07671698927879333,
-0.25161510705947876,
0.5375656485557556,
0.422993004322052,
-0.14378830790519714,
0.6815991401672363,
-0.651757538318634,
0.6280942559242249,
-0.024785801768302917,
-1.2332813739776611,
0.49603989720344543,
0.037731751799583435,
0.41135603189468384,
0.43927231431007385,
0.040668223053216934,
-0.5887508392333984,
-0.5851383209228516,
-0.6954938769340515,
-0.43692559003829956,
0.9081971049308777,
0.3997858762741089,
0.06874404847621918,
0.09273190796375275,
0.32119783759117126,
0.007139947731047869,
0.4106263518333435,
-0.5030369758605957,
-0.2679198384284973,
-0.507017970085144,
-0.12006434798240662,
0.11257844418287277,
-0.2827112078666687,
-0.0427706353366375,
-0.6183193922042847,
0.3199326992034912,
0.18416355550289154,
0.6236576437950134,
-0.009370449930429459,
-0.5146687030792236,
-0.09261897206306458,
0.19344837963581085,
0.45573365688323975,
0.8590149879455566,
0.0830310583114624,
0.3297516107559204,
0.15110217034816742,
-0.6776074767112732,
-0.08662997931241989,
-0.1232011690735817,
-0.1856335550546646,
-0.17842040956020355,
0.4394282102584839,
0.9464617967605591,
0.18839825689792633,
-0.4527512192726135,
0.43443384766578674,
-0.310044527053833,
-0.0354536697268486,
-0.5325542092323303,
0.3360746502876282,
0.2263302505016327,
0.3483472466468811,
0.19329573214054108,
0.49295875430107117,
-0.017767921090126038,
-0.41460391879081726,
0.2618718147277832,
0.1681775599718094,
-0.5187340378761292,
-0.7358589768409729,
0.7783953547477722,
-0.032395705580711365,
-0.24932798743247986,
1.0054477453231812,
-0.03753964602947235,
-0.9409364461898804,
0.3077125549316406,
0.29753080010414124,
0.7979135513305664,
-0.17166994512081146,
0.09945012629032135,
0.17000693082809448,
0.714903712272644,
0.14718469977378845,
-0.27906569838523865,
-0.349506676197052,
-1.070736050605774,
-0.42792779207229614,
-0.682734489440918,
-0.3496497571468353,
0.18770219385623932,
-0.5422707796096802,
0.09069058299064636,
-0.464880108833313,
-0.1971472054719925,
0.028879666700959206,
-0.45848900079727173,
-1.0562974214553833,
0.024058334529399872,
0.11033803224563599,
0.8236997723579407,
-0.7028600573539734,
1.328893780708313,
0.5529540181159973,
-0.3972923159599304,
-1.0592782497406006,
0.1745641529560089,
-0.2881437838077545,
-0.766390860080719,
0.7857106924057007,
0.13859964907169342,
-0.20772774517536163,
0.3078056275844574,
-0.3778766095638275,
-0.6305148005485535,
0.9065155386924744,
0.528531551361084,
-0.5988746881484985,
-0.30288222432136536,
0.26337721943855286,
0.6292543411254883,
-0.08066249638795853,
0.5136129856109619,
1.0464190244674683,
0.6264352202415466,
-0.11949140578508377,
-0.9925276637077332,
-0.20710833370685577,
-0.27877259254455566,
-0.34370720386505127,
0.3040814697742462,
-0.4548213481903076,
0.9719825983047485,
-0.16817660629749298,
-0.13143455982208252,
-0.18841375410556793,
0.5313183069229126,
-0.09706561267375946,
-0.13124796748161316,
0.3609793186187744,
0.6612508296966553,
0.7503491044044495,
-0.20710888504981995,
1.0626676082611084,
-0.6140377521514893,
0.3789401948451996,
1.0875824689865112,
-0.032993607223033905,
0.4565756916999817,
0.5534623265266418,
-0.16127653419971466,
0.6766376495361328,
0.06058822572231293,
0.1296430230140686,
0.46669358015060425,
0.008527611382305622,
0.029582533985376358,
-0.4220779836177826,
0.1853153109550476,
-0.4025685787200928,
0.40733179450035095,
0.4557799696922302,
-0.44011104106903076,
0.09521356225013733,
0.24688982963562012,
-0.030125988647341728,
-0.18165244162082672,
-0.27338340878486633,
0.7208419442176819,
0.0965268611907959,
-0.7059566378593445,
0.18008828163146973,
-0.06921001523733139,
0.2671051621437073,
-0.6388689875602722,
0.06805205345153809,
0.02280459553003311,
0.3648126721382141,
-0.2299385815858841,
-0.9395098686218262,
0.3915467858314514,
-0.015338350087404251,
-0.16481173038482666,
-0.4315429925918579,
0.9396952390670776,
-0.2183564454317093,
-0.29140567779541016,
0.37475550174713135,
0.37365099787712097,
-0.16591252386569977,
-0.47216537594795227,
-0.19297417998313904,
0.0002128214982803911,
-0.03469442203640938,
-0.4324948489665985,
0.2366241067647934,
0.5767881870269775,
0.1103474348783493,
0.3925419747829437,
0.3200279772281647,
0.12299398332834244,
0.27467840909957886,
0.36768364906311035,
1.1022858619689941,
-0.7007442712783813,
-0.409170001745224,
-0.6622461080551147,
0.6026936173439026,
0.04427468776702881,
-0.15124337375164032,
0.7957224249839783,
0.1982855647802353,
1.1295037269592285,
-0.37853580713272095,
0.8293384909629822,
-0.014488841407001019,
0.18209707736968994,
-0.7060133218765259,
1.2006608247756958,
-0.22968390583992004,
0.15236607193946838,
-0.3847021758556366,
-0.9520978927612305,
-0.17228566110134125,
0.7630261778831482,
-0.5107625126838684,
-0.00639935489743948,
1.0392515659332275,
0.6649041175842285,
-0.13788273930549622,
0.4265908896923065,
0.1686832755804062,
0.549470841884613,
0.24392199516296387,
0.6494541168212891,
1.0168311595916748,
-0.4543438255786896,
0.44058170914649963,
-0.6507681608200073,
-0.008866200223565102,
0.26893308758735657,
-0.32880815863609314,
-1.1229674816131592,
-0.6456753015518188,
-0.012232877314090729,
-0.07173790782690048,
-0.16385164856910706,
0.5414993762969971,
0.5488442182540894,
-0.7940779328346252,
-0.23163889348506927,
-0.32944414019584656,
0.3174781799316406,
-0.11039641499519348,
-0.19349364936351776,
0.46968087553977966,
-0.41685277223587036,
-0.3505575656890869,
0.2403581589460373,
0.4286181330680847,
-0.1611286699771881,
-0.3451129198074341,
-0.05826674401760101,
0.14770692586898804,
-0.24700210988521576,
0.6799835562705994,
-0.10387622565031052,
-0.44247928261756897,
-0.5342578291893005,
0.15125249326229095,
0.14963968098163605,
-0.017366336658596992,
1.2123225927352905,
-1.0588985681533813,
0.5740469098091125,
0.42135927081108093,
0.49284836649894714,
0.5900780558586121,
-0.31116995215415955,
0.48804154992103577,
-0.6471501588821411,
0.396625816822052,
0.14821919798851013,
0.32832077145576477,
0.2958720326423645,
-0.08833868056535721,
0.23877395689487457,
0.32206815481185913,
-0.6964690089225769,
-0.5625413656234741,
0.3438194990158081,
-0.711846649646759,
-0.06583071500062943,
0.7820987105369568,
0.06447229534387589,
-0.11317933350801468,
-0.0281060803681612,
-0.09186027199029922,
0.5506365299224854,
0.14444059133529663,
0.8248193264007568,
0.7967178225517273,
-0.19345828890800476,
-0.318685919046402,
-0.6696209907531738,
0.6053653955459595,
0.21288123726844788,
-0.701525866985321,
-0.05605999380350113,
0.1806260645389557,
0.12204203009605408,
0.48884862661361694,
0.4799514412879944,
-0.12219591438770294,
0.23781301081180573,
-0.12618416547775269,
0.21984843909740448,
-0.14352145791053772,
-0.7389026880264282,
0.04328924044966698,
0.4260551929473877,
0.04319923743605614,
0.2082601636648178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17964v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17964v1
|
Transformer and Hybrid Deep Learning Based Models for Machine-Generated Text Detection
| 2024-05-28T08:48:08 | 2024-05-28T08:48:08 |
Teodor-George Marchitan, Claudiu Creanga, Liviu P. Dinu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper describes the approach of the UniBuc - NLP team in tackling the
SemEval 2024 Task 8: Multigenerator, Multidomain, and Multilingual Black-Box
Machine-Generated Text Detection. We explored transformer-based and hybrid deep
learning architectures. For subtask B, our transformer-based model achieved a
strong \textbf{second-place} out of $77$ teams with an accuracy of
\textbf{86.95\%}, demonstrating the architecture's suitability for this task.
However, our models showed overfitting in subtask A which could potentially be
fixed with less fine-tunning and increasing maximum sequence length. For
subtask C (token-level classification), our hybrid model overfit during
training, hindering its ability to detect transitions between human and
machine-generated text.
|
[
-0.3535750210285187,
-0.5320677161216736,
0.3978327214717865,
0.07956106215715408,
-0.31424811482429504,
0.5490378737449646,
0.056700728833675385,
-0.6289452314376831,
0.06291458755731583,
0.6805889010429382,
-0.6126604080200195,
-0.40835681557655334,
-0.6347293257713318,
0.39925724267959595,
-0.4424268901348114,
1.0446696281433105,
-0.0219372920691967,
-0.25118231773376465,
-0.08402524143457413,
-0.05672759935259819,
-0.620917022228241,
-0.6078588962554932,
-0.5342819094657898,
-0.6072827577590942,
0.2920471727848053,
0.3688686788082123,
0.2933986783027649,
0.059649400413036346,
0.40752947330474854,
0.31961122155189514,
-0.02968078851699829,
0.35774070024490356,
-0.3000275790691376,
0.13471710681915283,
-0.29103532433509827,
-0.3948379456996918,
-0.2699543833732605,
-0.18812529742717743,
0.49155569076538086,
0.3642781972885132,
0.15039785206317902,
0.03658151626586914,
0.07917386293411255,
0.4612990617752075,
-0.5705803632736206,
-0.04781583696603775,
-0.7287117838859558,
0.15065857768058777,
-0.2451602965593338,
-0.22848327457904816,
-0.7173386216163635,
0.4926719069480896,
-0.05358486995100975,
-0.317106693983078,
0.6025363206863403,
0.1838073879480362,
0.7795067429542542,
0.4314066469669342,
-0.7642896771430969,
-0.16146637499332428,
-0.7549821138381958,
0.8611361384391785,
-0.7367713451385498,
0.44351908564567566,
0.18922016024589539,
0.10833358019590378,
-0.0791514590382576,
-0.7500666975975037,
-0.5630394816398621,
0.12916547060012817,
-0.09750790894031525,
0.4166370928287506,
-0.2621411085128784,
-0.025335904210805893,
0.2994658648967743,
0.42115849256515503,
-0.659548819065094,
0.441302090883255,
-0.42619621753692627,
-0.4392317235469818,
0.6229139566421509,
0.31775084137916565,
0.39790475368499756,
-0.3382324278354645,
-0.446817547082901,
0.25486868619918823,
-0.37078380584716797,
0.04491988196969032,
0.4089747369289398,
0.12645679712295532,
0.03483227267861366,
0.4612932503223419,
-0.24407605826854706,
0.28829270601272583,
0.09736045449972153,
0.06831935793161392,
0.4273054003715515,
-0.6304888725280762,
-0.18485333025455475,
0.05732216313481331,
0.9808276295661926,
0.12328492105007172,
0.034754812717437744,
-0.12303613126277924,
-0.3835206627845764,
0.4112454652786255,
0.46131545305252075,
-0.6984292268753052,
-0.46395620703697205,
0.11835596710443497,
-0.6414335370063782,
-0.48051702976226807,
0.02653341181576252,
-0.7778788805007935,
-0.5086961388587952,
-0.24915876984596252,
0.37497377395629883,
-0.28929007053375244,
-0.3610483705997467,
0.20517782866954803,
-0.10428272187709808,
0.1833571046590805,
0.28771576285362244,
-0.7860978245735168,
0.15740954875946045,
0.5170972943305969,
0.6576886177062988,
-0.5448167324066162,
-0.3333266079425812,
-0.4239949882030487,
-0.11594266444444656,
-0.059276364743709564,
1.1274185180664062,
-0.35959988832473755,
-0.3269256055355072,
-0.0772152841091156,
0.33435937762260437,
-0.2584030032157898,
-0.4973088204860687,
0.8292822241783142,
-0.4434593617916107,
0.40901196002960205,
-0.0501449778676033,
-0.5203617811203003,
-0.3191673755645752,
0.10673557221889496,
-0.8245653510093689,
1.3059992790222168,
-0.0014234371483325958,
-0.9151964783668518,
0.5661463737487793,
-0.765410304069519,
-0.7889072299003601,
0.5022044777870178,
-0.03256750479340553,
-0.8612511157989502,
0.04669199511408806,
0.42944827675819397,
0.6651755571365356,
-0.23641608655452728,
0.45264947414398193,
0.057205818593502045,
-0.364059716463089,
0.08874399214982986,
-0.5962314605712891,
0.8278508186340332,
0.06509139388799667,
-0.721032440662384,
0.2623441815376282,
-0.7630977630615234,
-0.2079838365316391,
0.19617557525634766,
-0.6171307563781738,
-0.25973066687583923,
-0.18717040121555328,
0.3980434536933899,
0.3537347614765167,
0.26839083433151245,
-0.8844597339630127,
-0.06515669822692871,
-0.3438612222671509,
0.5400657653808594,
0.5529438853263855,
-0.0643589049577713,
0.49253496527671814,
-0.11614404618740082,
0.6478284597396851,
0.24481922388076782,
-0.05574905872344971,
-0.5311867594718933,
-0.7283800840377808,
-0.9738451242446899,
-0.11306357383728027,
0.5416960120201111,
0.7753640413284302,
-0.9730377197265625,
0.5940904021263123,
0.012776450254023075,
-0.3498702943325043,
-0.43862995505332947,
0.07119952142238617,
0.2852064073085785,
0.3038119375705719,
0.5437281131744385,
-0.19905561208724976,
-0.9274778366088867,
-0.9728054404258728,
-0.1829298585653305,
0.08489007502794266,
0.08374672383069992,
-0.027109375223517418,
1.1163434982299805,
-0.6602807641029358,
0.6115456819534302,
-0.262706458568573,
-0.24398434162139893,
-0.6294612288475037,
0.4354647099971771,
0.040913358330726624,
0.4822344481945038,
0.32653576135635376,
-1.095592975616455,
-0.4922927916049957,
-0.006442660465836525,
-0.7137830853462219,
-0.232792928814888,
-0.17358902096748352,
0.13735432922840118,
0.490326851606369,
0.6244911551475525,
-0.5413678288459778,
0.5430799126625061,
0.4788641929626465,
-0.2799815535545349,
0.5819426774978638,
-0.08196111768484116,
0.1709841936826706,
-1.5461469888687134,
-0.01599445566534996,
0.19231443107128143,
-0.4347285330295563,
-0.7805513739585876,
-0.035955071449279785,
0.20570313930511475,
-0.2481028288602829,
-0.4347497820854187,
0.3911231756210327,
-0.224371075630188,
-0.08868936449289322,
-0.5730506181716919,
-0.4497406780719757,
0.23991045355796814,
0.5134983062744141,
0.028157783672213554,
0.7507937550544739,
0.13385078310966492,
-0.42611560225486755,
0.32392510771751404,
0.08472861349582672,
-0.3194212317466736,
0.5872442126274109,
-0.6955994367599487,
0.1659276783466339,
-0.04484502971172333,
0.43098127841949463,
-1.0661280155181885,
-0.10824776440858841,
0.10448411852121353,
-0.5523176193237305,
0.2120528519153595,
0.012351944111287594,
-0.6453167796134949,
-0.6875464916229248,
-0.12567000091075897,
0.45802298188209534,
0.3003838062286377,
-0.5708625316619873,
0.9446876049041748,
0.477823406457901,
0.058240994811058044,
-0.42381757497787476,
-0.7553676962852478,
0.18855290114879608,
-0.22021083533763885,
-0.5783641338348389,
0.6645504236221313,
0.1003345251083374,
0.24299561977386475,
-0.013792850077152252,
-0.029414819553494453,
-0.08370570093393326,
0.15509717166423798,
0.32371267676353455,
0.2866382896900177,
-0.2736639082431793,
-0.23150208592414856,
0.05103566497564316,
-0.41155120730400085,
-0.03860171139240265,
-0.36532771587371826,
0.6441153287887573,
0.046186663210392,
-0.27609676122665405,
-0.5608371496200562,
0.582525908946991,
0.682766854763031,
-0.5376094579696655,
0.7167728543281555,
1.083014965057373,
-0.5795034170150757,
-0.28786230087280273,
-0.5047484636306763,
-0.07039036601781845,
-0.46735894680023193,
0.3705689013004303,
-0.3584355115890503,
-1.1235405206680298,
0.517360270023346,
-0.1265484094619751,
0.06925681233406067,
0.8668635487556458,
0.8122336268424988,
-0.20273002982139587,
1.2593767642974854,
0.821873128414154,
-0.09272512793540955,
0.4019196033477783,
-0.40632084012031555,
0.42162057757377625,
-0.8703943490982056,
-0.4386026859283447,
-0.41379329562187195,
-0.40338224172592163,
-0.6719062924385071,
-0.25362125039100647,
0.1503874957561493,
-0.31886687874794006,
-0.00566187035292387,
0.7384313344955444,
-0.5816497206687927,
0.2944377064704895,
0.8591107130050659,
0.0669228807091713,
0.2396562248468399,
-0.2721475660800934,
-0.15848618745803833,
-0.0739285796880722,
-0.666054368019104,
-0.30559417605400085,
0.9641647934913635,
0.4494543671607971,
0.6169518232345581,
-0.21152262389659882,
0.6789705157279968,
0.6174845695495605,
-0.08576931804418564,
-0.6808640360832214,
0.4410250186920166,
-0.4317752718925476,
-0.6320605874061584,
-0.16821859776973724,
-0.21811066567897797,
-0.9808050394058228,
0.3296835720539093,
-0.35042643547058105,
-0.49746769666671753,
0.2208518236875534,
-0.07297919690608978,
-0.2719133198261261,
0.4166986644268036,
-0.7092440128326416,
1.137495994567871,
-0.18776078522205353,
0.1716645359992981,
-0.02157527580857277,
-0.5102611780166626,
0.29615774750709534,
-0.2891269028186798,
0.08476319909095764,
0.029340483248233795,
0.1633996218442917,
0.8730267286300659,
0.028159167617559433,
1.0248360633850098,
-0.03719460591673851,
0.001840806333348155,
0.2807826101779938,
-0.04288402944803238,
0.5025004744529724,
-0.18105733394622803,
0.2169969081878662,
0.16010569036006927,
-0.33054468035697937,
-0.3302023112773895,
-0.2552064061164856,
0.2246517837047577,
-0.4730071723461151,
-0.16771957278251648,
-0.48299068212509155,
-0.6156226992607117,
0.16454458236694336,
0.3944990932941437,
0.7614879012107849,
0.5310136675834656,
-0.0677565261721611,
0.5565994381904602,
0.8362562656402588,
-0.3813663125038147,
0.4958570599555969,
0.5004567503929138,
0.06422185152769089,
-0.34062719345092773,
1.0181498527526855,
-0.16665510833263397,
-0.12569217383861542,
0.6414753794670105,
0.22137559950351715,
-0.43614116311073303,
-0.7436627149581909,
-0.5102366805076599,
-0.10744987428188324,
-0.5874553322792053,
-0.35924607515335083,
-1.1191900968551636,
-0.418348491191864,
-0.592761754989624,
-0.1271906942129135,
-0.4032256603240967,
-0.13634294271469116,
-0.4597141444683075,
-0.05867946520447731,
0.045650359243154526,
0.7288062572479248,
0.18638676404953003,
0.38894161581993103,
-0.7108686566352844,
0.49814313650131226,
0.07400110363960266,
-0.0981343686580658,
-0.25743603706359863,
-0.7504088282585144,
-0.33670222759246826,
-0.1145797073841095,
-0.42224571108818054,
-0.5849279761314392,
0.5131992101669312,
-0.06729757785797119,
0.6024559736251831,
0.07035589963197708,
0.043322306126356125,
0.10068812966346741,
-0.5906917452812195,
0.7291969656944275,
0.21174737811088562,
-0.8980076313018799,
0.6213008761405945,
-0.38799849152565,
0.6507269144058228,
0.4160064160823822,
0.2616511881351471,
-0.5281175971031189,
-0.4564739167690277,
-0.688450813293457,
-0.7716425657272339,
0.6250399947166443,
0.3548159599304199,
0.11029786616563797,
0.37958845496177673,
0.02479950711131096,
0.18598243594169617,
0.22830802202224731,
-0.9950265288352966,
-0.02109948918223381,
-0.2628617286682129,
-0.5083742141723633,
-0.06631358712911606,
-0.2419944703578949,
0.4357667863368988,
-0.07286839187145233,
0.6933435797691345,
-0.24807310104370117,
0.336345911026001,
-0.1235232725739479,
-0.3311845064163208,
-0.020569229498505592,
0.4008648991584778,
0.7521703243255615,
0.2750040292739868,
0.23590275645256042,
0.09837057441473007,
0.33172833919525146,
-0.459040105342865,
0.05209988355636597,
0.2816195785999298,
-0.5197184085845947,
0.041100386530160904,
0.5633853077888489,
0.9344238638877869,
0.24153850972652435,
-0.44651126861572266,
0.5209953784942627,
-0.007384577766060829,
-0.47125697135925293,
-0.1709621548652649,
-0.05237065255641937,
-0.12445183098316193,
0.3185102343559265,
0.5459956526756287,
0.2975984215736389,
0.5042266249656677,
-0.41327911615371704,
0.5064055323600769,
0.4318894147872925,
-0.3749054968357086,
-0.4342760145664215,
0.7863444685935974,
0.3947048783302307,
-0.5048333406448364,
0.27443620562553406,
-0.3369848430156708,
-1.3183268308639526,
0.8083726763725281,
0.6692512631416321,
0.908784806728363,
-0.2520129978656769,
0.33113887906074524,
0.061383482068777084,
0.5049306154251099,
-0.02518298290669918,
0.14069947600364685,
0.07733959704637527,
-0.9552384614944458,
-0.529624342918396,
-0.6478004455566406,
-0.3936152160167694,
0.6582139134407043,
-0.2969943881034851,
0.3041088879108429,
-0.15034818649291992,
-0.017501430585980415,
0.37204140424728394,
0.14936625957489014,
-0.6314138174057007,
0.3990674316883087,
0.27194109559059143,
0.6150929927825928,
-1.0403810739517212,
0.6286296248435974,
0.842499852180481,
-0.32053983211517334,
-0.5621140599250793,
-0.1626516431570053,
0.012661393731832504,
-0.578286349773407,
0.4645337164402008,
0.6081132888793945,
0.03914161026477814,
-0.04363170266151428,
-0.269179105758667,
-0.4617115259170532,
0.9473448991775513,
0.04512892663478851,
-0.44428175687789917,
-0.19946826994419098,
0.30336230993270874,
0.6059606075286865,
-0.3189237713813782,
-0.020875683054327965,
0.4670998752117157,
0.286399245262146,
-0.02792217582464218,
-1.0112953186035156,
-0.1339435875415802,
-0.37801557779312134,
-0.1913646161556244,
0.609307050704956,
-0.4858357906341553,
0.861395537853241,
0.16667617857456207,
-0.11438490450382233,
-0.09989725053310394,
0.7003523707389832,
0.06759053468704224,
0.4836849570274353,
0.5727057456970215,
0.8697943091392517,
0.5646805167198181,
0.036842841655015945,
0.7796735167503357,
0.06561540812253952,
0.4317989945411682,
0.9662513136863708,
-0.27766549587249756,
0.4750399589538574,
0.13360366225242615,
0.01731329783797264,
0.6325563192367554,
0.6357489824295044,
-0.3447287380695343,
0.44355514645576477,
-0.2076403945684433,
-0.1944480985403061,
-0.462252676486969,
-0.26354220509529114,
-0.07386691868305206,
0.6563460230827332,
0.2460414171218872,
-0.42154988646507263,
-0.1923140287399292,
0.34900325536727905,
-0.33727797865867615,
0.07476218789815903,
-0.32874882221221924,
0.7216300964355469,
0.08385026454925537,
-0.6245796084403992,
0.05202724412083626,
0.3224865794181824,
1.1553945541381836,
-0.10771850496530533,
0.013298344798386097,
0.08565214276313782,
0.42444929480552673,
-0.22795452177524567,
-0.9293624758720398,
0.29465386271476746,
-0.061441708356142044,
-0.2847600281238556,
-0.3297771215438843,
1.4246172904968262,
-0.45578819513320923,
-0.7572369575500488,
0.26007261872291565,
0.4679151773452759,
-0.08429497480392456,
-0.26741185784339905,
-0.9466360211372375,
-0.09835165739059448,
0.032864369451999664,
0.0016889709513634443,
0.15816913545131683,
0.5235673189163208,
-0.13516320288181305,
0.4765045940876007,
0.7835877537727356,
-0.42742976546287537,
0.22267119586467743,
0.3743196427822113,
0.6618443131446838,
-0.5284038782119751,
-0.7309838533401489,
-0.8754063844680786,
0.5008159875869751,
-0.19960899651050568,
-0.23817142844200134,
0.6256293058395386,
0.7555927634239197,
0.953246533870697,
-0.12124858051538467,
0.8182986974716187,
0.04867538437247276,
0.49763938784599304,
-0.5361689329147339,
0.4297075867652893,
-0.5483574271202087,
-0.1233842521905899,
-0.2438906729221344,
-0.8576315641403198,
-0.2060314565896988,
0.4953101873397827,
-0.08848075568675995,
-0.041520651429891586,
0.8136984705924988,
0.45446041226387024,
-0.204823300242424,
0.19261114299297333,
0.4157191514968872,
-0.2806244492530823,
0.3047049045562744,
0.7207019925117493,
0.9509185552597046,
-0.6987231373786926,
0.6531466245651245,
-0.3246098458766937,
0.06271089613437653,
-0.2660734951496124,
-0.734674334526062,
-1.3461637496948242,
-0.7088679671287537,
-0.3752794563770294,
-0.20416919887065887,
-0.30383777618408203,
0.5007662177085876,
0.6962319612503052,
-1.2015622854232788,
0.1377299427986145,
-0.28650936484336853,
-0.021755049005150795,
0.03540610894560814,
-0.2776156961917877,
0.10798199474811554,
-0.1484142243862152,
-0.6682605147361755,
0.44620782136917114,
0.3934217691421509,
0.09571915119886398,
-0.4366743266582489,
0.15796077251434326,
-0.43137896060943604,
-0.14677271246910095,
0.7425823211669922,
0.03886568918824196,
-0.605108916759491,
-0.19440722465515137,
0.17965924739837646,
-0.09045957773923874,
0.014580708928406239,
1.074804663658142,
-0.811159074306488,
0.11802894622087479,
0.7122333645820618,
0.9820654988288879,
0.5970617532730103,
-0.014935933984816074,
0.4884548783302307,
-0.6463772058486938,
0.06926379352807999,
0.3742750287055969,
0.579992413520813,
0.3876810371875763,
-0.6513952612876892,
0.5336475372314453,
0.6294362545013428,
-0.7503901124000549,
-0.8058271408081055,
0.24373120069503784,
-0.7249255776405334,
-0.30291858315467834,
0.9922360181808472,
0.12084615230560303,
-0.13952815532684326,
-0.5370581746101379,
-0.32637596130371094,
0.3236249089241028,
-0.43826496601104736,
0.4377534091472626,
0.5404177904129028,
-0.022938845679163933,
-0.4142831861972809,
-0.5509387850761414,
0.24798262119293213,
0.4481135606765747,
-1.0035908222198486,
-0.276949942111969,
0.3179621994495392,
0.11932265013456345,
0.5177904963493347,
0.6140421032905579,
0.21448180079460144,
0.42767417430877686,
-0.058832425624132156,
0.03228073939681053,
0.04412318021059036,
-0.6965022087097168,
-0.24981728196144104,
0.12726952135562897,
-0.6175473928451538,
-0.27470582723617554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17957v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17957v1
|
Modeling Dynamic Topics in Chain-Free Fashion by Evolution-Tracking Contrastive Learning and Unassociated Word Exclusion
| 2024-05-28T08:39:49 | 2024-05-28T08:39:49 |
Xiaobao Wu, Xinshuai Dong, Liangming Pan, Thong Nguyen, Anh Tuan Luu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Dynamic topic models track the evolution of topics in sequential documents,
which have derived various applications like trend analysis and opinion mining.
However, existing models suffer from repetitive topic and unassociated topic
issues, failing to reveal the evolution and hindering further applications. To
address these issues, we break the tradition of simply chaining topics in
existing work and propose a novel neural \modelfullname. We introduce a new
evolution-tracking contrastive learning method that builds the similarity
relations among dynamic topics. This not only tracks topic evolution but also
maintains topic diversity, mitigating the repetitive topic issue. To avoid
unassociated topics, we further present an unassociated word exclusion method
that consistently excludes unassociated words from discovered topics. Extensive
experiments demonstrate our model significantly outperforms state-of-the-art
baselines, tracking topic evolution with high-quality topics, showing better
performance on downstream tasks, and remaining robust to the hyperparameter for
evolution intensities. Our code is available at https://github.com/bobxwu/CFDTM .
|
[
-0.5606542229652405,
-0.9986417293548584,
0.3570040762424469,
0.1057928204536438,
-0.6361356377601624,
0.3922201991081238,
-0.06238212436437607,
-0.4445585012435913,
0.7521598935127258,
0.34924203157424927,
-0.7462452054023743,
-0.3837369978427887,
-0.6097075343132019,
-0.34480732679367065,
-0.8030750155448914,
1.1031898260116577,
0.021873585879802704,
-0.27894899249076843,
-0.2926104664802551,
-0.29980960488319397,
-0.2207372486591339,
-0.16898603737354279,
-0.44879308342933655,
-0.5959645509719849,
0.6741920709609985,
0.06588013470172882,
0.45852383971214294,
0.9318239092826843,
0.31310972571372986,
0.292269766330719,
-0.8380706310272217,
0.09654475748538971,
-0.398067831993103,
0.41967812180519104,
-0.42403125762939453,
-0.07636663317680359,
-0.28245070576667786,
0.03967687860131264,
0.6119152903556824,
0.8244199156761169,
-0.3589126765727997,
-0.21729303896427155,
0.2840888202190399,
0.5031666159629822,
-0.5182394981384277,
-0.04885018244385719,
-0.7890182733535767,
0.09235402196645737,
-0.1656588315963745,
-0.16884611546993256,
0.0405438169836998,
-0.19519612193107605,
0.4009360671043396,
-0.5105427503585815,
0.36066216230392456,
-0.48845481872558594,
0.7487155795097351,
-0.008445926941931248,
-0.5261886715888977,
-0.3214471936225891,
-0.609354555606842,
0.5706310272216797,
-0.2622978389263153,
0.31044116616249084,
-0.012232494540512562,
-0.18647223711013794,
0.011164424940943718,
-1.0312644243240356,
-0.47286540269851685,
-0.1412581205368042,
0.3646690845489502,
0.22012293338775635,
-0.3223937153816223,
-0.17275716364383698,
-0.1121959462761879,
0.6336408257484436,
-0.41765812039375305,
0.07282713055610657,
0.09408709406852722,
0.24716545641422272,
0.2389182597398758,
0.20963986217975616,
0.16361887753009796,
-0.04293754696846008,
-0.6218153834342957,
0.1769893318414688,
-0.3737407326698303,
-0.20229047536849976,
0.40205925703048706,
0.1108575314283371,
-0.20998619496822357,
-0.02336021512746811,
-0.3283793032169342,
0.33224010467529297,
0.2353181540966034,
0.44939351081848145,
0.29164761304855347,
-0.1212371215224266,
0.043753255158662796,
-0.21670742332935333,
0.5017252564430237,
-0.025651080533862114,
-0.23673707246780396,
-0.37740465998649597,
-0.23862893879413605,
0.19813258945941925,
0.25050458312034607,
-0.6266122460365295,
-0.49408403038978577,
0.17725379765033722,
-0.5948614478111267,
-0.7336548566818237,
-0.1817556917667389,
-1.2528208494186401,
-0.5424987077713013,
-0.08568473160266876,
0.3601375222206116,
-0.19782009720802307,
-0.541087806224823,
-0.12007439881563187,
-0.1507376730442047,
-0.24747148156166077,
0.386555552482605,
-0.8665953874588013,
0.3835640251636505,
0.8071004748344421,
1.0565965175628662,
-0.5505357980728149,
-0.3057021200656891,
-0.46261173486709595,
-0.07594237476587296,
-0.34700989723205566,
0.8620731830596924,
-0.6625726222991943,
-0.49790051579475403,
-0.09209834039211273,
-0.04536353424191475,
0.13359488546848297,
-0.5333099365234375,
0.08516282588243484,
-0.726463258266449,
0.23207612335681915,
-0.011748665943741798,
-0.7161840796470642,
-0.16955336928367615,
0.34838423132896423,
-0.5803691148757935,
0.7893277406692505,
-0.15200962126255035,
-0.9778259992599487,
0.11200904846191406,
-0.6393374800682068,
-0.228437140583992,
0.05232712998986244,
-0.11392778158187866,
-0.31932133436203003,
0.2711710035800934,
-0.29012173414230347,
-0.0021639426704496145,
-0.2614041268825531,
0.6916192173957825,
-0.5455924272537231,
-0.22813035547733307,
0.23662413656711578,
-0.5134526491165161,
0.5929704308509827,
0.3394315242767334,
-0.43591299653053284,
0.3957586884498596,
-0.8799484372138977,
-0.35307785868644714,
0.08412231504917145,
-0.36525484919548035,
-0.555178165435791,
0.34143996238708496,
0.024882309138774872,
0.45416000485420227,
0.29764726758003235,
-0.24990098178386688,
0.14646504819393158,
-0.22239573299884796,
0.38811683654785156,
0.8573732972145081,
0.5074003338813782,
0.2514934539794922,
-0.398479700088501,
0.3540007472038269,
0.41421517729759216,
-0.05017555132508278,
-0.2393527776002884,
-0.37785184383392334,
-0.9363682866096497,
-0.08123313635587692,
0.5771300196647644,
0.37594884634017944,
-0.6448651552200317,
0.43697816133499146,
0.02924470044672489,
-0.5267643928527832,
0.05991639569401741,
0.0756857767701149,
0.26190638542175293,
0.5206795930862427,
0.4261873662471771,
-0.5686960816383362,
-0.22515001893043518,
-0.5705760717391968,
-0.28048765659332275,
0.09876513481140137,
-0.00510402861982584,
-0.014937576837837696,
0.45163437724113464,
-0.2810748815536499,
0.6092022061347961,
-0.6698398590087891,
0.16496683657169342,
-0.07341057062149048,
0.7736067175865173,
0.05228353291749954,
0.8023646473884583,
0.4332750141620636,
-0.947263240814209,
-0.1826227307319641,
-0.1997559666633606,
-0.7235950231552124,
-0.07401672005653381,
-0.30447253584861755,
-0.3264656066894531,
-0.15772320330142975,
0.529157817363739,
-0.581669270992279,
0.33742260932922363,
0.23450182378292084,
-0.3547835946083069,
0.29948487877845764,
-0.22229905426502228,
-0.38806167244911194,
-1.351775884628296,
0.21438366174697876,
0.2443585842847824,
-0.06781856715679169,
-0.6797785758972168,
0.29570847749710083,
0.024531804025173187,
-0.3444850742816925,
-0.4047246277332306,
0.5795562863349915,
-0.5003117322921753,
0.2398374378681183,
-0.786270797252655,
0.14317502081394196,
-0.1965656578540802,
0.4792024493217468,
0.21067990362644196,
0.15900562703609467,
0.6220576763153076,
-0.7617060542106628,
0.29397836327552795,
0.2668313980102539,
-0.37063702940940857,
0.19884993135929108,
-0.3493614196777344,
0.12409074604511261,
-0.13223832845687866,
0.10185103118419647,
-0.7347339391708374,
0.13548298180103302,
0.12636783719062805,
-0.12404890358448029,
0.42399662733078003,
-0.034039828926324844,
-0.3418821096420288,
-0.1662386804819107,
-0.3848645091056824,
0.045859020203351974,
0.4578673243522644,
-0.47468462586402893,
0.33752545714378357,
0.2807842493057251,
-0.2362549602985382,
-0.4072772264480591,
-0.5268073678016663,
-0.11443361639976501,
-0.31098026037216187,
-0.14655376970767975,
0.7073981761932373,
-0.3648776412010193,
-0.1494693011045456,
0.2369207888841629,
-0.6298075318336487,
-0.3585803806781769,
0.3645614981651306,
-0.07780370116233826,
0.06399042904376984,
-0.10383240133523941,
0.2626754343509674,
0.2075299173593521,
-0.12534531950950623,
-0.010717758908867836,
-0.5221343040466309,
0.6556897759437561,
0.24674184620380402,
-0.06482286751270294,
-0.43307390809059143,
0.5629814267158508,
0.7455446124076843,
-0.3656404912471771,
0.6606709957122803,
0.5503581166267395,
-0.5482750535011292,
-0.32698020339012146,
-0.317278116941452,
-0.13858336210250854,
-0.5442324876785278,
0.48740270733833313,
-0.08025958389043808,
-0.8755218982696533,
0.7060710191726685,
-0.4093489944934845,
0.008139177225530148,
0.4441285729408264,
0.3711870014667511,
0.016849882900714874,
0.648351788520813,
0.7953892350196838,
0.0919680967926979,
0.9929715991020203,
-0.2645304501056671,
-0.05878719314932823,
-0.6349308490753174,
-0.22098568081855774,
-0.2886368930339813,
-0.5300507545471191,
-0.9584032893180847,
-0.14081980288028717,
-0.11619116365909576,
0.3657141625881195,
-0.18370738625526428,
-0.13330502808094025,
-0.46648725867271423,
0.42295852303504944,
0.5890821218490601,
0.25485125184059143,
0.15411944687366486,
0.03765955939888954,
-0.2815020978450775,
0.14052526652812958,
-0.473952978849411,
-0.04696895182132721,
0.7214232683181763,
0.18347583711147308,
0.7276087999343872,
-0.07032155990600586,
0.7871596217155457,
0.5666808485984802,
0.21553774178028107,
-0.5071118474006653,
0.6056048274040222,
-0.5768822431564331,
-0.33143946528434753,
0.060749687254428864,
-0.48046836256980896,
-0.7515282034873962,
0.4294649660587311,
-0.2932218611240387,
-0.8360037803649902,
0.6114342212677002,
0.18544766306877136,
-0.06361715495586395,
0.7729703783988953,
-0.1129303053021431,
0.7105998992919922,
-0.28070196509361267,
-0.8347880244255066,
-0.36795955896377563,
-0.5351016521453857,
0.35003989934921265,
-0.38124069571495056,
-0.26928794384002686,
-0.13305345177650452,
-0.11930666118860245,
0.9005864858627319,
-0.36812981963157654,
0.8026601672172546,
-0.21696816384792328,
0.10587424039840698,
0.3897368907928467,
0.1692248433828354,
0.44723379611968994,
0.011990297585725784,
-0.10063052922487259,
0.05964715778827667,
-0.4164728820323944,
-0.3825397789478302,
-0.4463253319263458,
1.0129865407943726,
-0.4961089789867401,
-0.6966983079910278,
-0.63341224193573,
-0.6900339722633362,
-0.08506555110216141,
0.4771980345249176,
0.1756659895181656,
0.3253391981124878,
-0.20154836773872375,
0.24726003408432007,
0.7864924073219299,
-0.205490380525589,
0.8460860252380371,
0.49349281191825867,
-0.028819287195801735,
-0.44390323758125305,
1.0056530237197876,
0.09282086789608002,
0.03766660764813423,
0.47405126690864563,
0.5034968256950378,
-0.24129468202590942,
-0.8728232979774475,
0.1424487829208374,
0.10206813365221024,
-0.582937479019165,
0.04359205439686775,
-0.9663115739822388,
-0.19007113575935364,
-0.019825834780931473,
-0.1375536024570465,
-0.427017480134964,
-0.3740028440952301,
-0.5972270965576172,
-0.08347302675247192,
0.20896904170513153,
0.6321905255317688,
-0.1666632890701294,
0.18165697157382965,
-0.6423487663269043,
0.39057403802871704,
0.44592395424842834,
0.49366840720176697,
0.4207257330417633,
-0.38958632946014404,
-0.0477273054420948,
-0.12263371795415878,
-0.9439312219619751,
-0.9787935018539429,
0.5090168714523315,
-0.011442198418080807,
0.6785765290260315,
0.7658118605613708,
0.20520006120204926,
0.44990143179893494,
-0.18328425288200378,
0.757824718952179,
0.4241926074028015,
-1.151088833808899,
0.6361804008483887,
-0.5747899413108826,
0.34303179383277893,
0.3525828421115875,
0.5186323523521423,
-0.530974268913269,
-0.4182280898094177,
-0.7447713017463684,
-1.10515296459198,
0.5407218933105469,
0.09869199991226196,
0.3310609757900238,
-0.2757561206817627,
0.38700345158576965,
0.18847186863422394,
0.5595199465751648,
-0.7925675511360168,
-0.25186261534690857,
-0.2731796205043793,
0.07948266714811325,
0.18106253445148468,
-0.3479175269603729,
0.05772419273853302,
-0.29791927337646484,
0.5819840431213379,
0.0719960406422615,
0.41517749428749084,
-0.10039903223514557,
0.06400371342897415,
-0.012379749678075314,
0.19284296035766602,
0.8055417537689209,
0.5903266072273254,
-0.4258258640766144,
0.21743062138557434,
0.004819017834961414,
-0.4233538806438446,
0.09222178161144257,
0.23766690492630005,
-0.34431192278862,
0.20331129431724548,
0.08348444849252701,
0.7513415813446045,
0.22736325860023499,
-0.3346318006515503,
0.28095656633377075,
0.16389955580234528,
-0.22691650688648224,
-0.03273545205593109,
0.107123002409935,
0.3685000240802765,
0.39598897099494934,
0.1688496172428131,
0.1501179188489914,
-0.05501687899231911,
-0.5930622816085815,
0.5294488668441772,
0.21004971861839294,
-0.6678928732872009,
-0.3208407461643219,
0.9343320727348328,
0.4769648015499115,
-0.392895370721817,
0.5866864323616028,
-0.16356918215751648,
-0.4122672379016876,
0.8209121227264404,
0.6180095076560974,
1.1800109148025513,
-0.2758966386318207,
0.14344839751720428,
-0.10256188362836838,
-0.12560738623142242,
-0.11064758151769638,
0.40556737780570984,
-0.3324326276779175,
-0.4815777838230133,
0.20144543051719666,
-0.5620101690292358,
-0.5632962584495544,
0.5530127286911011,
-0.861869215965271,
0.25121352076530457,
-0.5309406518936157,
0.014071622863411903,
0.17735281586647034,
0.019805509597063065,
-0.10532751679420471,
0.24113383889198303,
0.024162933230400085,
1.1172813177108765,
-0.6473286747932434,
1.1457388401031494,
0.6890897154808044,
-0.3514159023761749,
-0.019670624285936356,
0.6394780278205872,
0.06249487027525902,
-0.22456209361553192,
0.3290293514728546,
0.10439477860927582,
-0.08442085981369019,
-0.050865333527326584,
-0.3341826796531677,
-0.6686604022979736,
0.9960390329360962,
0.08199873566627502,
-0.5416256189346313,
-0.07897695153951645,
-0.4029826819896698,
0.6333233118057251,
-0.37458017468452454,
-0.05120939388871193,
-0.08802607655525208,
0.03237323462963104,
0.18549130856990814,
-0.10114827007055283,
-0.1827167272567749,
-0.5186262726783752,
-0.008959425613284111,
0.4624134600162506,
-0.8609656691551208,
1.0026112794876099,
0.15531215071678162,
0.045019544661045074,
0.3084598481655121,
0.663497269153595,
-0.029791977256536484,
0.6259146332740784,
0.4463556408882141,
0.4758915305137634,
0.8086897730827332,
0.01698354445397854,
0.6123217344284058,
-0.5327523350715637,
0.5737502574920654,
1.2783280611038208,
-0.4336950480937958,
0.7524252533912659,
0.41910526156425476,
0.30297067761421204,
0.5274898409843445,
0.7882128953933716,
-0.1866961568593979,
0.9353327751159668,
0.47900423407554626,
-0.5612478852272034,
-0.20310606062412262,
-0.061623744666576385,
-0.4960918426513672,
0.5003253817558289,
0.3630433678627014,
-0.5981037616729736,
-0.2815377414226532,
-0.18910537660121918,
-0.02656548283994198,
0.04911596700549126,
-0.21961596608161926,
0.6686205863952637,
-0.006383548025041819,
-0.553196132183075,
0.49968135356903076,
0.015838496387004852,
0.9009053707122803,
-0.9138448238372803,
0.017007814720273018,
-0.6972829103469849,
0.16806043684482574,
0.20816649496555328,
-0.4145422875881195,
0.40364107489585876,
0.1138838678598404,
-0.4529857635498047,
-0.1470666080713272,
0.5765231251716614,
-0.5430624485015869,
-0.24922549724578857,
0.4708346724510193,
0.630601704120636,
-0.14035317301750183,
0.1602163016796112,
-0.7872738242149353,
-0.08742620050907135,
-0.0671749860048294,
-0.34650909900665283,
0.5577821135520935,
0.40437254309654236,
-0.209130197763443,
0.70799320936203,
0.5299496054649353,
0.03322756290435791,
-0.17614628374576569,
-0.21794313192367554,
1.0579177141189575,
-0.9174965620040894,
-1.079410195350647,
-0.8206170797348022,
0.24778249859809875,
-0.15627950429916382,
-0.5534576773643494,
0.22605785727500916,
0.56120365858078,
0.6886139512062073,
0.019099632278084755,
0.45228272676467896,
0.2969251275062561,
0.4968951642513275,
-0.3544515073299408,
1.011128306388855,
-0.9979575276374817,
0.5015124082565308,
-0.43265488743782043,
-0.9218882322311401,
-0.18043462932109833,
0.26986759901046753,
0.08955596387386322,
0.07192391157150269,
0.9389760494232178,
0.3776356875896454,
-0.43877801299095154,
0.3050287067890167,
0.18337345123291016,
0.1416211724281311,
0.1758590191602707,
0.256006121635437,
0.9964091777801514,
0.04347502812743187,
0.4788389205932617,
-0.43084800243377686,
-0.14941035211086273,
-0.12752431631088257,
-1.0733819007873535,
-0.5494799613952637,
-0.46059325337409973,
-0.8536227941513062,
-0.1717822402715683,
0.2933272421360016,
0.7491030097007751,
0.7170765995979309,
-0.8068822622299194,
-0.3096848428249359,
-0.6284179091453552,
0.2717287540435791,
-0.43882811069488525,
-0.26260656118392944,
0.4241809546947479,
-0.15332962572574615,
-0.5557543039321899,
0.3727355897426605,
0.20947220921516418,
0.2016311138868332,
-0.08889619261026382,
0.22632059454917908,
-0.5962961912155151,
0.2259996235370636,
0.3718585968017578,
0.3918791711330414,
-0.6076561212539673,
0.02059030719101429,
-0.31585004925727844,
0.18423859775066376,
0.0723114162683487,
1.0385690927505493,
-0.6626433730125427,
0.48330333828926086,
0.6818858981132507,
0.7102010250091553,
0.8062307238578796,
-0.08348216116428375,
0.22432902455329895,
-0.6458886861801147,
0.22280818223953247,
0.15682396292686462,
0.3721241056919098,
0.03481084853410721,
-0.21112960577011108,
0.380397766828537,
0.8914409875869751,
-0.26642730832099915,
-0.8219335079193115,
0.32376807928085327,
-0.9983571171760559,
-0.6893304586410522,
0.6737322807312012,
-0.17419284582138062,
0.1545451432466507,
0.0147921834141016,
0.4540823698043823,
0.5979070067405701,
-0.4086979031562805,
1.088376760482788,
0.567929208278656,
-0.3221207857131958,
-0.26864928007125854,
-0.25499600172042847,
0.21538740396499634,
0.3917050063610077,
-0.8659289479255676,
0.07152918726205826,
0.34916865825653076,
0.40745097398757935,
0.19315895438194275,
0.36052989959716797,
0.007660974748432636,
0.2019721418619156,
0.18016274273395538,
-0.08131344616413116,
-0.08756875991821289,
-0.4521404802799225,
-0.664202094078064,
0.45348644256591797,
-0.13470152020454407,
-0.5434352159500122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17935v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17935v2
|
Tool Learning with Large Language Models: A Survey
| 2024-05-28T08:01:26 | 2024-05-30T11:01:10 |
Changle Qu, Sunhao Dai, Xiaochi Wei, Hengyi Cai, Shuaiqiang Wang, Dawei Yin, Jun Xu, Ji-Rong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recently, tool learning with large language models (LLMs) has emerged as a
promising paradigm for augmenting the capabilities of LLMs to tackle highly
complex problems. Despite growing attention and rapid advancements in this
field, the existing literature remains fragmented and lacks systematic
organization, posing barriers to entry for newcomers. This gap motivates us to
conduct a comprehensive survey of existing works on tool learning with LLMs. In
this survey, we focus on reviewing existing literature from the two primary
aspects (1) why tool learning is beneficial and (2) how tool learning is
implemented, enabling a comprehensive understanding of tool learning with LLMs.
We first explore the "why" by reviewing both the benefits of tool integration
and the inherent benefits of the tool learning paradigm from six specific
aspects. In terms of "how", we systematically review the literature according
to a taxonomy of four key stages in the tool learning workflow: task planning,
tool selection, tool calling, and response generation. Additionally, we provide
a detailed summary of existing benchmarks and evaluation methods, categorizing
them according to their relevance to different stages. Finally, we discuss
current challenges and outline potential future directions, aiming to inspire
both researchers and industrial developers to further explore this emerging and
promising area. We also maintain a GitHub repository to continually keep track
of the relevant papers and resources in this rising area at
\url{https://github.com/quchangle1/LLM-Tool-Survey}.
|
[
-0.4043737053871155,
-0.6368289589881897,
0.7282671928405762,
-0.04648105055093765,
-0.3437592387199402,
0.6000483632087708,
-0.32804062962532043,
-0.5664436221122742,
-0.20286749303340912,
0.2826964855194092,
-0.4094111919403076,
-0.6467320322990417,
-0.6171250343322754,
0.00544917955994606,
-0.530170202255249,
0.8811445236206055,
-0.09900163859128952,
0.3618590831756592,
-0.19027015566825867,
0.001933243591338396,
-0.5378084778785706,
-0.5132031440734863,
-0.7463901042938232,
-0.5308796763420105,
0.7830514311790466,
0.39163216948509216,
0.16528023779392242,
0.4153997302055359,
0.40591686964035034,
0.3261778652667999,
-0.20865195989608765,
0.016419999301433563,
-0.5710781216621399,
0.2402869611978531,
-0.1262817680835724,
-0.7542510032653809,
-0.13741064071655273,
0.051794227212667465,
0.5328454971313477,
0.8558828830718994,
-0.17234966158866882,
0.41727006435394287,
0.36284804344177246,
0.3814421594142914,
-0.5323392748832703,
0.1471952497959137,
-0.6566067934036255,
0.10484818369150162,
-0.35349732637405396,
0.020381180569529533,
-0.38028934597969055,
-0.23562495410442352,
0.13247133791446686,
-0.2878718674182892,
0.12373041361570358,
-0.03517749160528183,
0.22410106658935547,
0.12146928161382675,
-0.6274212598800659,
-0.48034608364105225,
-0.9350830912590027,
1.0203540325164795,
-0.5294313430786133,
0.570755124092102,
0.14082404971122742,
0.4040474593639374,
-0.1172548159956932,
-0.8394740223884583,
-0.1706911027431488,
-0.007672909647226334,
0.28535956144332886,
0.060374557971954346,
0.18654410541057587,
-0.27594026923179626,
0.327764630317688,
0.427642822265625,
-0.38507017493247986,
0.6091331243515015,
-0.6233720779418945,
-0.2673582434654236,
0.7059788107872009,
0.3026925325393677,
-0.012639783322811127,
0.09309007972478867,
-0.31694579124450684,
-0.1275179237127304,
-0.8184153437614441,
0.0869239941239357,
0.3324921131134033,
0.1505364626646042,
-0.22783222794532776,
0.19209909439086914,
0.21367259323596954,
0.5924665927886963,
-0.2828546166419983,
-0.5690528750419617,
0.4504244327545166,
-0.19015857577323914,
-0.21052612364292145,
-0.22572554647922516,
0.810321033000946,
-0.004336542449891567,
-0.11786102503538132,
-0.25088727474212646,
-0.43953490257263184,
-0.4997979998588562,
0.3783065378665924,
-0.6621214747428894,
0.18542444705963135,
0.17447951436042786,
-0.3446223735809326,
-0.32663458585739136,
0.009164540097117424,
-0.4706534743309021,
-0.7837337851524353,
-0.43624937534332275,
0.11874935030937195,
-0.13349148631095886,
-0.6132994890213013,
-0.06469010561704636,
0.0725107491016388,
0.6551292538642883,
0.7737595438957214,
-0.47293439507484436,
0.12091027945280075,
0.9309890866279602,
0.9645160436630249,
-0.43186134099960327,
-0.18207493424415588,
-0.5284574031829834,
-0.15757955610752106,
-0.5574259161949158,
0.7172510623931885,
-0.31806424260139465,
-0.763439953327179,
0.2502582371234894,
0.11898170411586761,
0.3233526349067688,
-0.8068845272064209,
0.3068634271621704,
-0.58902907371521,
0.14804606139659882,
-0.2940109968185425,
-0.3020579218864441,
-0.4193364381790161,
0.4284459054470062,
-0.6452849507331848,
1.1036146879196167,
0.10320534557104111,
-0.6223322153091431,
0.48264962434768677,
-0.33128124475479126,
-0.4529578387737274,
0.08871978521347046,
-0.3170473873615265,
-0.45077627897262573,
0.22982168197631836,
-0.16297802329063416,
0.7725841403007507,
-0.7336599230766296,
0.35356757044792175,
-0.4854726493358612,
-0.16014030575752258,
0.301898717880249,
-0.21103036403656006,
0.794676661491394,
0.396859735250473,
-0.1578029990196228,
0.33739253878593445,
-0.4255230724811554,
-0.2648034691810608,
0.28173744678497314,
-0.410890132188797,
-0.014888283796608448,
0.06209731847047806,
0.024444889277219772,
0.35978788137435913,
0.1937347650527954,
-0.5651689171791077,
0.17247818410396576,
-0.47936001420021057,
0.3616020679473877,
0.7394241094589233,
0.06333810091018677,
0.4110349416732788,
-0.13994427025318146,
0.6507564783096313,
0.23592913150787354,
0.1991429477930069,
-0.014416980557143688,
-0.024463826790452003,
-0.5049089789390564,
0.1287802904844284,
0.4789448082447052,
0.4169033169746399,
-0.8544553518295288,
0.17259417474269867,
0.05017624422907829,
-0.7174153923988342,
-0.3276035189628601,
0.6206738948822021,
0.18006107211112976,
0.1808839589357376,
0.007171159144490957,
-0.5144272446632385,
-0.4828697144985199,
-0.5941619873046875,
-0.02465355210006237,
-0.2532494068145752,
-0.19153009355068207,
0.2479029893875122,
0.37353354692459106,
-0.03331765532493591,
0.6800609827041626,
-0.40183982253074646,
-0.2262626737356186,
-0.7312247157096863,
-0.1097160056233406,
0.22572073340415955,
0.16683009266853333,
0.35143885016441345,
-0.7181658148765564,
-0.5850099921226501,
0.1248902827501297,
-0.6146826148033142,
0.1584511697292328,
-0.012268668040633202,
0.2352485954761505,
-0.008487154729664326,
0.8774751424789429,
-0.30278369784355164,
0.0519118458032608,
0.3542805016040802,
0.20682846009731293,
0.6696657538414001,
-0.000028367254344630055,
-0.324002742767334,
-1.2705771923065186,
0.08220648020505905,
0.10532297939062119,
-0.32247233390808105,
-0.5555037260055542,
-0.07595869898796082,
-0.019185416400432587,
0.07120291888713837,
-0.8475106358528137,
0.5884208679199219,
-0.6963512301445007,
-0.2583138048648834,
-0.40022143721580505,
0.2683449387550354,
-0.4391791522502899,
0.2841642200946808,
-0.24358001351356506,
0.7852307558059692,
0.6870501041412354,
-0.4656600058078766,
0.4302803575992584,
-0.0016645656432956457,
-0.48574480414390564,
0.3256154954433441,
-0.6060037016868591,
0.14799237251281738,
0.04431549459695816,
0.08431653678417206,
-0.7353067994117737,
0.021702449768781662,
0.2085142731666565,
-0.24198752641677856,
0.5081910490989685,
-0.13530655205249786,
-0.8932220339775085,
-0.2293655276298523,
-0.30534660816192627,
0.04504526033997536,
0.6530166864395142,
-0.37475594878196716,
0.6156249046325684,
0.596360445022583,
-0.2719714045524597,
-0.4886026084423065,
-0.17510190606117249,
-0.10372702777385712,
-0.32018232345581055,
-0.027538318186998367,
-0.1880476474761963,
-0.031726665794849396,
-0.2845818102359772,
-0.43075084686279297,
-0.4223945736885071,
0.0989530086517334,
0.3828117847442627,
0.22073952853679657,
0.15998731553554535,
0.10671324282884598,
0.40682685375213623,
-0.16617995500564575,
-0.1320173740386963,
0.33873701095581055,
-0.1493580937385559,
0.6658859848976135,
0.010767248459160328,
-0.47539621591567993,
0.1675628125667572,
0.033475786447525024,
0.596519410610199,
-0.4163323640823364,
0.4291437864303589,
0.8950935006141663,
-0.21389542520046234,
-0.40064388513565063,
-0.6702261567115784,
-0.1927429586648941,
-0.45092520117759705,
0.5251538753509521,
-0.2885717451572418,
-1.0201818943023682,
0.3880208134651184,
-0.7914511561393738,
0.5664239525794983,
0.21626797318458557,
0.8459592461585999,
-0.08944801986217499,
0.9279252290725708,
0.9522498250007629,
-0.28152456879615784,
0.45265820622444153,
-0.41722315549850464,
0.18869951367378235,
-1.020034670829773,
-0.3489343822002411,
-0.5230963230133057,
-0.2172788381576538,
-0.39165642857551575,
-0.4758715331554413,
0.5017721652984619,
0.14041706919670105,
0.05515668913722038,
-0.1102079302072525,
-0.10678907483816147,
0.2144283652305603,
0.2471524178981781,
-0.0015216921456158161,
0.2660587430000305,
-0.12148469686508179,
-0.28292107582092285,
0.28431689739227295,
-0.7577884197235107,
-0.5569265484809875,
1.1956537961959839,
0.6084830164909363,
0.8488261103630066,
-0.025240881368517876,
0.7886253595352173,
0.04794328659772873,
0.3930347263813019,
-1.133584976196289,
0.6001651287078857,
0.3094482421875,
-0.530123770236969,
-0.38833966851234436,
-0.11053337156772614,
-1.0895715951919556,
0.4132055640220642,
-0.19778907299041748,
-0.6329675912857056,
-0.11168664693832397,
-0.08438243716955185,
-0.1144290640950203,
0.4421619474887848,
-0.5741348266601562,
0.6223834753036499,
-0.637377917766571,
-0.5309486389160156,
-0.37307918071746826,
-0.7608654499053955,
0.28971579670906067,
-0.4073490798473358,
0.38608142733573914,
-0.13468636572360992,
-0.1615748256444931,
0.7725349068641663,
-0.025874966755509377,
1.1641777753829956,
-0.09268950670957565,
-0.49918273091316223,
0.24189889430999756,
-0.01232857909053564,
0.4416733682155609,
0.023225225508213043,
0.01523849181830883,
0.08662623167037964,
0.10546961426734924,
-0.11328092217445374,
-0.5414858460426331,
0.4886065423488617,
-0.6757208704948425,
-0.7079037427902222,
-0.4241293668746948,
-0.49881452322006226,
-0.41239866614341736,
0.36485013365745544,
-0.11520668864250183,
0.34964287281036377,
-0.12401796877384186,
0.37555623054504395,
0.784189760684967,
-0.24651043117046356,
0.39546364545822144,
0.4446258544921875,
-0.5941309332847595,
-0.17609666287899017,
0.877402126789093,
0.10855221748352051,
0.2224973440170288,
0.1400117576122284,
0.04153095930814743,
-0.16776961088180542,
-0.9672473669052124,
-0.1406818926334381,
0.5144688487052917,
-0.796225905418396,
-0.1181677058339119,
-0.522124171257019,
-0.17375311255455017,
-0.08741852641105652,
-0.06649966537952423,
-0.30735665559768677,
0.07427988201379776,
-0.4586426019668579,
-0.15326648950576782,
0.0973343551158905,
1.0772533416748047,
0.23308159410953522,
0.1627214103937149,
-0.7366689443588257,
-0.06687267869710922,
0.21245834231376648,
0.4089600443840027,
0.32496264576911926,
-0.19644851982593536,
-0.545208215713501,
-0.23212140798568726,
-0.6116460561752319,
-0.6606667041778564,
0.23138238489627838,
-0.19551478326320648,
0.8206458687782288,
0.5182777047157288,
0.1124764010310173,
0.3976290822029114,
-0.5378240346908569,
0.6944571733474731,
0.29428133368492126,
-0.5872783064842224,
0.30664095282554626,
-0.21307966113090515,
0.4046822190284729,
0.36476561427116394,
0.7815470695495605,
-0.6047083735466003,
-0.3682735562324524,
-0.6106663346290588,
-0.8326277732849121,
0.46735328435897827,
-0.24915000796318054,
0.04001797363162041,
0.40629634261131287,
0.19427382946014404,
0.473135769367218,
0.2702903151512146,
-0.6042402982711792,
-0.13659095764160156,
0.3848489820957184,
0.04707832261919975,
-0.229582279920578,
-0.19326677918434143,
-0.2319549024105072,
-0.107572540640831,
0.5568854212760925,
-0.22495697438716888,
0.013677159324288368,
-0.2502012848854065,
-0.4787699580192566,
0.07207490503787994,
0.4707062840461731,
0.1797151267528534,
0.9923041462898254,
0.17457738518714905,
0.07098767161369324,
0.5678563714027405,
-0.41403114795684814,
0.19499868154525757,
-0.1911923885345459,
0.04056305065751076,
-0.1651092767715454,
0.4788392186164856,
0.6936535835266113,
0.2634144425392151,
-0.7441344261169434,
0.46585598587989807,
0.1379489153623581,
-0.46362927556037903,
-0.43828704953193665,
0.14976325631141663,
0.42557385563850403,
0.5346611142158508,
0.45410385727882385,
-0.5639379024505615,
0.15595553815364838,
-0.5340358018875122,
-0.19342584908008575,
0.6411455273628235,
-0.510338544845581,
-0.3149464726448059,
0.24720042943954468,
0.3619507849216461,
-0.2783025801181793,
0.3728395104408264,
-0.1254618912935257,
-0.42728954553604126,
0.3180559575557709,
0.32491323351860046,
0.8109647631645203,
-0.07180752605199814,
0.10821348428726196,
0.21445593237876892,
0.4027506411075592,
0.09821275621652603,
0.18199686706066132,
-0.35048407316207886,
-0.45244500041007996,
-0.584857702255249,
-0.7224364280700684,
-0.618500292301178,
0.2745196223258972,
-0.45622268319129944,
0.38356825709342957,
-0.4768531322479248,
-0.13163171708583832,
-0.22742119431495667,
0.1777649074792862,
-0.7125865817070007,
-0.12052589654922485,
0.024583157151937485,
1.062625527381897,
-0.779546320438385,
0.7944068312644958,
0.9779604077339172,
-0.3267495036125183,
-0.7697451710700989,
-0.16884273290634155,
0.2307087779045105,
-0.6075249314308167,
0.6312033534049988,
0.05195959657430649,
-0.05340562015771866,
0.13696807622909546,
-0.5603552460670471,
-0.7634603977203369,
1.1302307844161987,
0.1443011313676834,
-0.5244391560554504,
-0.16789411008358002,
-0.009604865685105324,
0.2664729058742523,
-0.22849346697330475,
0.20661447942256927,
0.5031101703643799,
0.160465270280838,
0.15251804888248444,
-1.1370494365692139,
-0.13496935367584229,
-0.0429525189101696,
0.1917465478181839,
0.42766377329826355,
-0.5249637365341187,
0.2528732419013977,
-0.04960717260837555,
-0.3316163122653961,
-0.16035647690296173,
0.5395389199256897,
0.10914270579814911,
0.21756625175476074,
0.6909569501876831,
0.18414266407489777,
0.28009697794914246,
-0.08933578431606293,
0.6756004095077515,
-0.09373995661735535,
0.28565171360969543,
0.8054040670394897,
-0.5087070465087891,
0.855124294757843,
0.587539792060852,
-0.458196222782135,
0.3438835144042969,
0.8759876489639282,
0.0025106859393417835,
0.18352621793746948,
0.29026955366134644,
-0.17283955216407776,
-0.4256388545036316,
0.020765239372849464,
-0.2206312119960785,
0.440011590719223,
0.4278741776943207,
-0.22376392781734467,
-0.4781225323677063,
0.28037574887275696,
-0.16702495515346527,
-0.20385129749774933,
-0.27574726939201355,
1.2243422269821167,
0.3353411853313446,
-0.27142155170440674,
0.2102503478527069,
-0.18675634264945984,
0.5989349484443665,
-0.8131266832351685,
-0.09801160544157028,
0.152469664812088,
-0.0838383212685585,
-0.13528014719486237,
-0.7232374548912048,
0.11400359123945236,
-0.08505728840827942,
-0.00045160806621424854,
-0.25380295515060425,
0.6911374926567078,
-0.16825778782367706,
-0.36356422305107117,
0.22149673104286194,
0.9365790486335754,
0.16235847771167755,
0.30943989753723145,
-0.7793774008750916,
0.28566721081733704,
-0.21609608829021454,
-0.12483575940132141,
0.5839630365371704,
0.41068583726882935,
-0.051823124289512634,
0.8491972088813782,
0.6303567886352539,
0.1729014664888382,
-0.1319166123867035,
0.020178038626909256,
0.9181703925132751,
-0.5563690066337585,
-0.2526894807815552,
-0.6206063628196716,
0.706541121006012,
-0.11819881945848465,
-0.08754485100507736,
0.9537839293479919,
0.6796534657478333,
1.1769440174102783,
-0.043469615280628204,
0.8764471411705017,
0.02141301892697811,
0.8519165515899658,
-0.4652278423309326,
0.5551645159721375,
-0.5950912833213806,
0.38583534955978394,
-0.15814195573329926,
-0.9026548266410828,
-0.21187032759189606,
0.3065345287322998,
-0.550476610660553,
0.1382163166999817,
0.7340796589851379,
0.5542057156562805,
-0.08608303964138031,
-0.32672610878944397,
0.3960670530796051,
0.06946838647127151,
0.41386258602142334,
0.25365540385246277,
0.9759690761566162,
0.05775799602270126,
0.48569557070732117,
-0.18383021652698517,
-0.0446501150727272,
-0.293832004070282,
-0.8151586055755615,
-0.8601254224777222,
-0.7330383062362671,
-0.2507147789001465,
-0.06609783321619034,
-0.20528875291347504,
1.128097653388977,
0.6960420608520508,
-0.49465411901474,
-0.7315577864646912,
0.2289724349975586,
0.4548068642616272,
-0.051795557141304016,
-0.10421573370695114,
0.06887457519769669,
-0.6011648774147034,
-0.6756318211555481,
0.15900792181491852,
0.3197111487388611,
-0.15165303647518158,
-0.6928273439407349,
-0.0966385006904602,
-0.10066704452037811,
-0.3852681815624237,
0.891459584236145,
0.3977387547492981,
-0.82903653383255,
0.1360561102628708,
-0.03403612598776817,
0.08054862171411514,
0.011525859124958515,
1.1395294666290283,
-0.726455807685852,
0.36102810502052307,
0.3554999530315399,
0.8366890549659729,
0.6140350103378296,
-0.5807697772979736,
0.5266746282577515,
-0.5896222591400146,
0.008878794498741627,
0.199809268116951,
0.3553113341331482,
0.38256528973579407,
-0.10579903423786163,
0.5549359917640686,
0.017499681562185287,
-0.5117033123970032,
-1.0990722179412842,
0.4831443428993225,
-0.7635106444358826,
-0.3664374053478241,
1.122434139251709,
0.09355545043945312,
-0.0023322917986661196,
-0.3903510272502899,
-0.351020872592926,
0.2993858754634857,
0.007300097495317459,
0.5605323910713196,
0.5783037543296814,
-0.10024561733007431,
-0.34767183661460876,
-0.7586174011230469,
0.2885481119155884,
-0.00705939345061779,
-0.8104608654975891,
0.08463668823242188,
0.49073365330696106,
0.5024704933166504,
-0.02119133062660694,
0.28410184383392334,
-0.15424402058124542,
0.223252072930336,
-0.4620491564273834,
0.07263464480638504,
-0.029174743220210075,
-0.2574167549610138,
-0.5469324588775635,
0.19768066704273224,
0.8587396740913391,
0.18301448225975037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17931v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17931v1
|
Online Merging Optimizers for Boosting Rewards and Mitigating Tax in Alignment
| 2024-05-28T07:53:40 | 2024-05-28T07:53:40 |
Keming Lu, Bowen Yu, Fei Huang, Yang Fan, Runji Lin, Chang Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Effectively aligning Large Language Models (LLMs) with human-centric values
while preventing the degradation of abilities acquired through Pre-training and
Supervised Fine-tuning (SFT) poses a central challenge in Reinforcement
Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF). In this paper, we first discover that
interpolating RLHF and SFT model parameters can adjust the trade-off between
human preference and basic capabilities, thereby reducing the alignment tax at
the cost of alignment reward. Inspired by this, we propose integrating the RL
policy and SFT models at each optimization step in RLHF to continuously
regulate the training direction, introducing the Online Merging Optimizer.
Specifically, we merge gradients with the parameter differences between SFT and
pretrained models, effectively steering the gradient towards maximizing rewards
in the direction of SFT optimization. We demonstrate that our optimizer works
well with different LLM families, such as Qwen and LLaMA, across various model
sizes ranging from 1.8B to 8B, various RLHF algorithms like DPO and KTO, and
existing model merging methods. It significantly enhances alignment reward
while mitigating alignment tax, achieving higher overall performance across 14
benchmarks.
|
[
-0.7122321724891663,
-0.40102240443229675,
0.22150079905986786,
0.14947737753391266,
-0.20723873376846313,
0.48914283514022827,
-0.48309433460235596,
-0.6059740781784058,
0.18635602295398712,
0.5003079771995544,
-0.9443531632423401,
0.1644621640443802,
-0.4325173497200012,
-0.08249934762716293,
0.08249256759881973,
1.1487473249435425,
-0.07278948277235031,
0.1831766813993454,
-0.3682832419872284,
-0.09602267295122147,
-0.23498967289924622,
-0.6482101082801819,
-0.7032517790794373,
-0.3337487578392029,
0.5013008713722229,
0.31277984380722046,
0.5418075323104858,
0.7570433020591736,
0.5551167130470276,
0.28253641724586487,
-0.026352595537900925,
0.5228881239891052,
-0.6345638036727905,
0.12166003882884979,
-0.09095680713653564,
-0.3140449523925781,
-0.36041322350502014,
-0.11903023719787598,
0.5954324007034302,
0.2700776755809784,
-0.6196234822273254,
-0.18169613182544708,
0.25905388593673706,
0.7570677399635315,
-0.6383581757545471,
-0.002626888919621706,
-0.2558702528476715,
0.12377100437879562,
0.1174495741724968,
-0.48189666867256165,
-0.15983866155147552,
-0.8555202484130859,
0.07729188352823257,
-0.6521010994911194,
-0.1049187034368515,
0.008660583756864071,
1.2164207696914673,
0.7731123566627502,
-0.08724281191825867,
0.00931012537330389,
-0.7411797046661377,
0.8288421034812927,
-0.8078633546829224,
0.4216291606426239,
0.254103422164917,
0.2943929433822632,
-0.17829646170139313,
-0.2818455994129181,
-0.43713730573654175,
-0.2496422678232193,
-0.09192195534706116,
0.07394188642501831,
-0.10979671031236649,
0.36236771941185,
0.0911899209022522,
0.257718026638031,
-0.27459225058555603,
0.48881638050079346,
-0.3356022238731384,
-0.18436715006828308,
0.7309005856513977,
0.1404091715812683,
0.03067047707736492,
0.2353753000497818,
-0.5668941736221313,
-0.4457054138183594,
-0.6509772539138794,
0.40172505378723145,
0.6993426084518433,
0.3848949372768402,
0.04908344894647598,
0.2187497317790985,
-0.20641447603702545,
0.8089560270309448,
0.42414766550064087,
-0.32406100630760193,
-0.006212725304067135,
-0.4693189859390259,
0.19999150931835175,
0.06264165788888931,
0.7188258171081543,
0.33782514929771423,
0.2943271994590759,
-0.1340808868408203,
-0.45862826704978943,
-0.04593649134039879,
0.3457576632499695,
-0.72966468334198,
-0.004591695498675108,
0.09963866323232651,
-0.20766407251358032,
-0.4348686635494232,
0.11528728902339935,
-0.6441647410392761,
-0.31507357954978943,
-0.5635176301002502,
0.3943660855293274,
0.046391718089580536,
-0.1792379915714264,
0.048915911465883255,
-0.06490901112556458,
0.4255458116531372,
0.3790793716907501,
-1.17139732837677,
0.3200131952762604,
0.8542401790618896,
0.46840018033981323,
-0.36281660199165344,
-0.341943621635437,
-0.9648838043212891,
-0.029805414378643036,
0.05270403251051903,
0.7473874092102051,
-0.25618934631347656,
-0.3011305034160614,
0.006244565360248089,
-0.17017588019371033,
0.0181981660425663,
-0.5939785838127136,
0.2392604500055313,
-0.5602902770042419,
0.47597068548202515,
-0.2879403829574585,
-0.7771109938621521,
-0.04238337650895119,
0.31797879934310913,
-0.6883612275123596,
0.9954703450202942,
0.2863028347492218,
-0.5423344373703003,
0.45827803015708923,
-0.5876316428184509,
-0.35954245924949646,
0.12885615229606628,
-0.1709824651479721,
-0.7048835158348083,
-0.0831984132528305,
0.3405643701553345,
0.31414005160331726,
-0.21233893930912018,
0.45456138253211975,
-0.29644107818603516,
-0.4214673638343811,
0.010699521750211716,
-0.047196805477142334,
0.5418102145195007,
0.10008156299591064,
-0.3468600809574127,
0.616024374961853,
-0.4709043502807617,
0.13355164229869843,
-0.13180793821811676,
-0.809645414352417,
0.02625304087996483,
0.03793179988861084,
0.19974571466445923,
0.3062126934528351,
0.38388383388519287,
-0.26914235949516296,
0.5941698551177979,
-0.3025414049625397,
0.4806801676750183,
0.7467999458312988,
-0.09116644412279129,
0.49127674102783203,
-0.4775702655315399,
0.871749222278595,
-0.138954296708107,
0.19345024228096008,
0.36217591166496277,
-0.39050519466400146,
-0.5936227440834045,
-0.3440968096256256,
0.5234014391899109,
0.5181654095649719,
-0.4730875790119171,
0.7308996915817261,
-0.39274701476097107,
-0.4138742685317993,
-0.9459373950958252,
0.2206742763519287,
0.37746018171310425,
0.30009016394615173,
0.3843410313129425,
-0.21729347109794617,
-0.3791298568248749,
-0.8033034205436707,
-0.49692776799201965,
0.04900393635034561,
0.015399294905364513,
0.2591342628002167,
0.2030404806137085,
-0.1172884851694107,
1.2108919620513916,
-0.32413145899772644,
-0.40883561968803406,
-0.21481546759605408,
0.4065784811973572,
-0.09047399461269379,
0.5992411375045776,
0.303259938955307,
-0.6624510288238525,
-0.47612935304641724,
0.09087929874658585,
-0.08212640881538391,
-0.148429274559021,
-0.2011808604001999,
0.18344520032405853,
0.2794429361820221,
0.44044509530067444,
-0.26731953024864197,
0.13753598928451538,
0.5467572808265686,
-0.20355679094791412,
0.15288229286670685,
-0.37696993350982666,
0.3139311671257019,
-0.8442986011505127,
-0.22593587636947632,
-0.1383908987045288,
-0.5820622444152832,
-0.30913302302360535,
0.22349537909030914,
0.18347232043743134,
0.1793336421251297,
-0.5487293004989624,
0.4185389280319214,
-0.30284032225608826,
-0.09076259285211563,
-0.30137768387794495,
0.10936619341373444,
-0.12707774341106415,
0.8496814370155334,
0.06863592565059662,
0.8195703029632568,
-0.009405822493135929,
-0.5481448173522949,
0.3528893291950226,
0.08160927146673203,
-0.2393103688955307,
0.5153002738952637,
-0.3187139630317688,
0.008893315680325031,
-0.18921415507793427,
0.4630105495452881,
-0.6954236626625061,
-0.3115074038505554,
0.19894692301750183,
-0.23046036064624786,
0.42128539085388184,
-0.06626605987548828,
-0.30342909693717957,
-0.03997427970170975,
-0.650819718837738,
0.3821250796318054,
0.5642484426498413,
-0.6953027248382568,
0.6753222346305847,
0.33403438329696655,
0.05960061773657799,
-0.6886429786682129,
-0.5776579976081848,
-0.2111230194568634,
-0.4830359220504761,
-0.6239105463027954,
0.6750543117523193,
-0.08333615958690643,
0.10865174233913422,
0.16633272171020508,
0.30775514245033264,
0.07092482596635818,
0.14821283519268036,
-0.13056929409503937,
0.5329527258872986,
-0.1247137114405632,
-0.11106745898723602,
0.12814658880233765,
-0.17645227909088135,
-0.2870731055736542,
-0.23290781676769257,
0.5582704544067383,
-0.08868532627820969,
-0.26238560676574707,
-0.472554087638855,
0.1018901839852333,
0.41083216667175293,
-0.28008052706718445,
0.8451269865036011,
0.7031397223472595,
-0.19010132551193237,
-0.008677971549332142,
-0.6811239719390869,
-0.4475057125091553,
-0.4365967810153961,
0.38134512305259705,
-0.071865513920784,
-1.3074214458465576,
0.4384881854057312,
-0.06415531039237976,
0.3048739731311798,
0.18556353449821472,
0.44799092411994934,
0.014841827563941479,
1.1211036443710327,
0.5532175898551941,
-0.15244905650615692,
0.7170296907424927,
0.032603587955236435,
0.09912290424108505,
-0.7854416966438293,
-0.05148725211620331,
-0.37200239300727844,
-0.4278315305709839,
-0.8509833812713623,
-0.33204537630081177,
0.22851595282554626,
0.4814341366291046,
-0.3233240246772766,
0.36852729320526123,
-0.6195675134658813,
0.785870373249054,
0.5687891244888306,
0.07653768360614777,
0.27359214425086975,
-0.042344462126493454,
0.2108013927936554,
-0.1018877848982811,
-0.8236200213432312,
0.09649752080440521,
0.823752760887146,
0.3425826132297516,
0.7288735508918762,
0.1121746078133583,
0.9561875462532043,
0.08040156215429306,
0.2868790328502655,
-0.876410722732544,
0.19025176763534546,
0.022339653223752975,
-0.28184983134269714,
-0.35506317019462585,
-0.609950840473175,
-0.770197331905365,
0.3323723077774048,
-0.4351337254047394,
-0.5717687010765076,
0.11305159330368042,
0.4556146562099457,
-0.7092841267585754,
0.25640788674354553,
-0.43631869554519653,
0.7636093497276306,
-0.5565541982650757,
-0.49829885363578796,
-0.48764246702194214,
-0.7051154375076294,
0.3580401539802551,
-0.03764738887548447,
0.11650066077709198,
0.0012204673839733005,
-0.11889243125915527,
0.6773781776428223,
-0.5112205743789673,
0.5261611938476562,
-0.07078327983617783,
-0.0514378659427166,
-0.09666067361831665,
-0.08732800930738449,
0.7552079558372498,
-0.44999033212661743,
0.36809393763542175,
-0.026653625071048737,
-0.00992896594107151,
-0.35230812430381775,
-0.5524850487709045,
0.7116038799285889,
-0.8994631171226501,
-0.45389893651008606,
-0.3555131256580353,
-0.48013952374458313,
-0.4083234667778015,
-0.027812356129288673,
0.23380839824676514,
0.2156105786561966,
0.08170810341835022,
0.044745855033397675,
0.47578760981559753,
-0.07670510560274124,
0.22824323177337646,
0.3312416970729828,
-0.3701135218143463,
-0.7625361680984497,
1.1543909311294556,
-0.13283313810825348,
0.5847510695457458,
0.39702531695365906,
0.48788365721702576,
-0.5841064453125,
-0.14446088671684265,
-0.40621691942214966,
0.3790915608406067,
-0.7115038633346558,
-0.37930750846862793,
-0.15346327424049377,
-0.208614781498909,
-0.24677126109600067,
-0.4356458783149719,
-0.34128519892692566,
-0.45999962091445923,
-0.38976845145225525,
0.08934196084737778,
0.31208038330078125,
0.8895541429519653,
-0.16910330951213837,
0.4304150640964508,
-0.9908316731452942,
-0.13787952065467834,
0.2989942133426666,
0.3846099078655243,
0.07966629415750504,
-0.39986664056777954,
-0.2622860372066498,
-0.03789835795760155,
-0.3686515986919403,
-0.5471009612083435,
0.43402373790740967,
0.002678986405953765,
0.4073709547519684,
0.45093676447868347,
-0.08557683974504471,
0.8975201845169067,
-0.09961061179637909,
0.5795044302940369,
0.3662257492542267,
-0.8529256582260132,
0.07230248302221298,
-0.3085588216781616,
0.06453317403793335,
0.6997796297073364,
0.3215811848640442,
-0.44367527961730957,
-0.18879182636737823,
-0.47272199392318726,
-0.8244962692260742,
0.9665462970733643,
-0.0822516530752182,
-0.4085792005062103,
0.40937069058418274,
0.21946705877780914,
-0.15479068458080292,
0.2925834655761719,
-0.6823841333389282,
-0.0016217781230807304,
-0.05691847950220108,
-0.2832197844982147,
0.09609708189964294,
0.11647307872772217,
-0.26082780957221985,
-0.4623878002166748,
0.7011855840682983,
-0.12793394923210144,
-0.16864562034606934,
-0.1438504457473755,
-0.045380525290966034,
-0.38228070735931396,
0.21148918569087982,
0.860722541809082,
0.30772989988327026,
-0.2616181969642639,
-0.3654506206512451,
0.06978210061788559,
-0.048370443284511566,
0.1696283370256424,
0.0854451060295105,
-0.07406390458345413,
-0.6840747594833374,
0.20059774816036224,
1.0123090744018555,
0.5413988828659058,
-0.6207433938980103,
0.4517979621887207,
-0.1643766611814499,
-0.38361573219299316,
0.07468244433403015,
0.18426069617271423,
0.2369905263185501,
0.3039618134498596,
-0.0486464761197567,
0.12167318910360336,
-0.2443971335887909,
-0.20320184528827667,
0.07893603295087814,
0.6056764125823975,
-0.4332352578639984,
0.03540583327412605,
0.6776694655418396,
0.39948737621307373,
-0.4269922375679016,
0.6440750956535339,
-0.13449569046497345,
-1.0294578075408936,
0.43334096670150757,
0.3737108111381531,
0.8700383901596069,
-0.16430477797985077,
-0.0926816537976265,
0.434279203414917,
0.12068281322717667,
-0.38186824321746826,
0.03983697667717934,
-0.3940223753452301,
-0.7080402970314026,
-0.5017320513725281,
-0.6190481781959534,
-0.5847615599632263,
-0.1897163689136505,
-0.7897664904594421,
0.4592275619506836,
-0.489955335855484,
-0.028111839666962624,
-0.3257298767566681,
0.0929531678557396,
-0.48576048016548157,
-0.19563567638397217,
0.18867461383342743,
0.43205055594444275,
-0.5249069333076477,
0.8015009164810181,
0.4011174738407135,
-0.6356981992721558,
-1.0676213502883911,
-0.10526955872774124,
-0.0533563606441021,
-0.7063186168670654,
0.6396527886390686,
0.008327214978635311,
-0.3022209703922272,
0.33432915806770325,
-0.24623343348503113,
-0.8449848294258118,
1.0350087881088257,
0.3983379006385803,
-0.7400674819946289,
-0.18980485200881958,
0.08679424226284027,
0.237467423081398,
-0.3777438700199127,
0.12383636087179184,
0.7723441123962402,
0.6442070007324219,
0.11319957673549652,
-1.1085116863250732,
-0.07420468330383301,
0.20599126815795898,
-0.19494260847568512,
0.7540504932403564,
-0.5549924969673157,
0.7323182821273804,
-0.05369027704000473,
-0.22279098629951477,
-0.10810742527246475,
0.40577977895736694,
0.20998607575893402,
-0.3226258456707001,
0.7030128240585327,
0.8014870882034302,
0.7144569158554077,
-0.16535869240760803,
0.9942535161972046,
-0.3752700984477997,
0.6308423280715942,
0.9217898845672607,
-0.17989522218704224,
0.9696063995361328,
0.6588448286056519,
-0.2672644257545471,
0.44131964445114136,
0.7894545793533325,
-0.0008088673930615187,
0.47109100222587585,
0.32382526993751526,
-0.20574261248111725,
-0.4551974833011627,
-0.1250297725200653,
-0.28353169560432434,
0.08529038727283478,
-0.016493210569024086,
0.21960555016994476,
-0.2215709239244461,
-0.12564171850681305,
-0.02925308421254158,
0.0718141719698906,
-0.19879384338855743,
1.0125370025634766,
-0.24557392299175262,
-1.1912802457809448,
0.6402316093444824,
-0.03543520346283913,
1.1615583896636963,
-0.8532975912094116,
0.015659179538488388,
-0.09630947560071945,
0.40472641587257385,
-0.3698287308216095,
-0.601637601852417,
0.13245640695095062,
-0.407513827085495,
0.1294049322605133,
-0.40906986594200134,
0.3779195249080658,
-0.9392758011817932,
-0.034450680017471313,
0.4342210590839386,
0.23359329998493195,
-0.2590554356575012,
0.09417932480573654,
-0.6819495558738708,
0.06696458160877228,
0.24976825714111328,
-0.11969190090894699,
0.6104522943496704,
-0.3129498362541199,
-0.08343750983476639,
0.5410632491111755,
0.835067868232727,
0.404786616563797,
0.03396386653184891,
-0.051185328513383865,
0.7573810815811157,
-0.6250753998756409,
-0.9563680291175842,
-0.7727387547492981,
0.5466079711914062,
-0.06220729649066925,
-0.4056556224822998,
0.3095875680446625,
0.30213770270347595,
1.0772579908370972,
0.0680716261267662,
0.5256810188293457,
0.28270775079727173,
0.40383675694465637,
-0.47903817892074585,
0.7553162574768066,
-0.8554262518882751,
0.1892775148153305,
0.05870671197772026,
-0.9908192157745361,
-0.12369789928197861,
0.6203349232673645,
-0.00704710278660059,
-0.12864699959754944,
0.39755815267562866,
0.7195954322814941,
-0.0913827195763588,
-0.08709200471639633,
0.13494263589382172,
-0.4115547239780426,
0.46360740065574646,
0.4878844618797302,
0.9065167307853699,
-0.0957111343741417,
0.35185807943344116,
-0.38135966658592224,
-0.10869045555591583,
-0.38745424151420593,
-1.0131970643997192,
-0.6149919033050537,
-0.43626338243484497,
-0.2969398498535156,
-0.3617366552352905,
-0.18762989342212677,
1.5754163265228271,
0.7015312314033508,
-0.7919825315475464,
-0.48800697922706604,
-0.17742407321929932,
0.110516257584095,
-0.29217374324798584,
-0.26328232884407043,
0.2382371723651886,
-0.3879281282424927,
-0.5744311213493347,
0.3030287027359009,
0.2918120324611664,
0.10198544710874557,
-0.6427594423294067,
-0.6457147598266602,
-0.2294197976589203,
0.12027096748352051,
0.16700142621994019,
0.501989483833313,
-1.0001213550567627,
-0.206838920712471,
-0.20184127986431122,
-0.19887343049049377,
0.19477221369743347,
1.061849594116211,
-0.8442572355270386,
0.40991342067718506,
0.6390749216079712,
1.2387492656707764,
0.4613121747970581,
0.4085428714752197,
0.7459821105003357,
-0.5640366673469543,
0.01565679721534252,
0.31078314781188965,
0.28339701890945435,
0.3935854136943817,
-0.42155757546424866,
0.40929973125457764,
0.11329372972249985,
-0.6927374005317688,
-0.8887642621994019,
0.2022497057914734,
-0.7978683710098267,
-0.12631657719612122,
0.8010125160217285,
0.021598028019070625,
0.023450568318367004,
0.09524324536323547,
-0.05198902636766434,
0.2865492105484009,
-0.39612045884132385,
0.6780531406402588,
0.8062694072723389,
-0.4145123362541199,
-0.04889677092432976,
-0.10851764678955078,
0.9827758073806763,
0.6624040007591248,
-0.9861466288566589,
0.03452841192483902,
0.3534484803676605,
0.06766311079263687,
-0.022682655602693558,
0.42665329575538635,
0.19609519839286804,
0.38306185603141785,
-0.4650349020957947,
0.17072002589702606,
-0.20626300573349,
-0.11117704212665558,
-0.7552905678749084,
-0.15558718144893646,
0.17939704656600952,
-0.06159709393978119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17927v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17927v1
|
The Evolution of Multimodal Model Architectures
| 2024-05-28T07:48:15 | 2024-05-28T07:48:15 |
Shakti N. Wadekar, Abhishek Chaurasia, Aman Chadha, Eugenio Culurciello
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
This work uniquely identifies and characterizes four prevalent multimodal
model architectural patterns in the contemporary multimodal landscape.
Systematically categorizing models by architecture type facilitates monitoring
of developments in the multimodal domain. Distinct from recent survey papers
that present general information on multimodal architectures, this research
conducts a comprehensive exploration of architectural details and identifies
four specific architectural types. The types are distinguished by their
respective methodologies for integrating multimodal inputs into the deep neural
network model. The first two types (Type A and B) deeply fuses multimodal
inputs within the internal layers of the model, whereas the following two types
(Type C and D) facilitate early fusion at the input stage. Type-A employs
standard cross-attention, whereas Type-B utilizes custom-designed layers for
modality fusion within the internal layers. On the other hand, Type-C utilizes
modality-specific encoders, while Type-D leverages tokenizers to process the
modalities at the model's input stage. The identified architecture types aid
the monitoring of any-to-any multimodal model development. Notably, Type-C and
Type-D are currently favored in the construction of any-to-any multimodal
models. Type-C, distinguished by its non-tokenizing multimodal model
architecture, is emerging as a viable alternative to Type-D, which utilizes
input-tokenizing techniques. To assist in model selection, this work highlights
the advantages and disadvantages of each architecture type based on data and
compute requirements, architecture complexity, scalability, simplification of
adding modalities, training objectives, and any-to-any multimodal generation
capability.
|
[
-0.4667172431945801,
-0.6949948072433472,
0.4963432550430298,
0.37220272421836853,
0.07465934753417969,
0.0546598918735981,
0.07239368557929993,
-0.438181072473526,
0.18900281190872192,
0.18485070765018463,
-0.3709982931613922,
-0.20617415010929108,
-0.45568224787712097,
-0.14466592669487,
-0.2656421661376953,
0.5400288105010986,
-0.09190862625837326,
0.4219490587711334,
-0.36711862683296204,
-0.0806499645113945,
-0.5584941506385803,
-0.5913103222846985,
-0.5184189677238464,
-0.11436702311038971,
0.7691677808761597,
0.041822418570518494,
0.747084379196167,
0.5990338921546936,
0.5376651287078857,
0.3632183372974396,
0.030841784551739693,
0.22982527315616608,
-0.018624775111675262,
0.0847984179854393,
0.12234289199113846,
-0.04741910845041275,
-0.761155903339386,
-0.12327944487333298,
0.5205833911895752,
0.5496013760566711,
0.07204119116067886,
0.3961014449596405,
-0.2627425491809845,
0.3432272672653198,
-0.7868818640708923,
0.22561484575271606,
-0.27582576870918274,
0.15799018740653992,
-0.4004712402820587,
-0.0990402102470398,
-0.4319536089897156,
0.040208276361227036,
0.044711317867040634,
-0.21104630827903748,
-0.14734555780887604,
0.0344119518995285,
0.3317614495754242,
0.17470994591712952,
-0.8491100072860718,
-0.2294994592666626,
-0.6437825560569763,
0.4028942584991455,
-0.5376642346382141,
0.8079908490180969,
0.04674581438302994,
0.4426860213279724,
0.10999558120965958,
-0.7793158888816833,
-0.4491679072380066,
-0.4777123034000397,
0.006241020746529102,
0.12381703406572342,
-0.08543910086154938,
0.3152093291282654,
-0.1503736525774002,
0.30789270997047424,
-0.6484168767929077,
0.29586878418922424,
-0.433468759059906,
-0.18528176844120026,
0.18394255638122559,
0.3141474723815918,
0.3180462121963501,
-0.412894606590271,
-0.6062543392181396,
0.006062452681362629,
-0.4750119745731354,
0.2031390517950058,
0.2613363564014435,
0.20480766892433167,
-0.38850510120391846,
0.5916235446929932,
-0.047644395381212234,
0.8716780543327332,
0.22697941958904266,
-0.20194098353385925,
0.29861941933631897,
-0.7083193063735962,
-0.310359925031662,
-0.1609785109758377,
0.533112108707428,
0.23655308783054352,
-0.1658676713705063,
-0.1322348564863205,
-0.33906054496765137,
0.17586591839790344,
0.5045958161354065,
-0.547650158405304,
-0.1603611409664154,
0.18447734415531158,
-1.0820330381393433,
-0.4632023572921753,
-0.38210415840148926,
-0.7590880393981934,
-0.37856945395469666,
-0.42983028292655945,
0.5671996474266052,
-0.3627074658870697,
-0.5585688948631287,
0.19682173430919647,
-0.2252674251794815,
0.29249417781829834,
0.27926579117774963,
-0.9499767422676086,
-0.023144856095314026,
0.37246447801589966,
0.7311241626739502,
-0.21747490763664246,
-0.07874533534049988,
0.13016989827156067,
0.03163932263851166,
-0.38219067454338074,
0.6522228121757507,
-0.8437603116035461,
-0.2822432518005371,
0.1318710744380951,
-0.24635662138462067,
-0.33671504259109497,
-0.12841308116912842,
0.43673980236053467,
-0.8869531750679016,
0.18220941722393036,
0.22956719994544983,
-0.23243312537670135,
-0.6435947418212891,
0.514462947845459,
-0.7947379350662231,
0.625229001045227,
0.1476045697927475,
-0.5393816232681274,
0.36304396390914917,
-1.0855368375778198,
-0.24612340331077576,
0.1039373129606247,
-0.3772640824317932,
-0.2692647874355316,
0.4024569094181061,
0.05328827723860741,
0.6248742341995239,
-0.19553795456886292,
0.30366671085357666,
-0.709838330745697,
0.005720427725464106,
0.2789548337459564,
-0.6195633411407471,
0.4848844110965729,
0.4623001515865326,
-0.12707558274269104,
0.23529601097106934,
-1.016777515411377,
-0.13915544748306274,
0.05786614865064621,
-0.5399250388145447,
0.06377676129341125,
0.10540947318077087,
0.25497859716415405,
0.5936842560768127,
0.34094685316085815,
-0.36296921968460083,
0.15399962663650513,
0.24761369824409485,
0.6378680467605591,
0.7462244629859924,
0.07561520487070084,
0.5957239866256714,
-0.3923649191856384,
0.7108700275421143,
0.4709920585155487,
0.6137425899505615,
-0.5294879674911499,
-0.43022996187210083,
-0.5992415547370911,
-0.6365065574645996,
0.19392459094524384,
0.2941262722015381,
-0.9179038405418396,
-0.20022480189800262,
-0.3369728922843933,
-0.5207699537277222,
-0.4517113268375397,
-0.1749102920293808,
0.4786407947540283,
0.26096588373184204,
0.289269357919693,
-0.09181498736143112,
-0.588463544845581,
-1.0968403816223145,
0.34037619829177856,
0.04982471466064453,
0.48832711577415466,
0.4517713487148285,
0.3300665616989136,
-0.3612841069698334,
0.5326567888259888,
0.030592849478125572,
0.24894030392169952,
-0.1791824996471405,
-0.062094345688819885,
0.01801951602101326,
0.5731387734413147,
0.8907196521759033,
-1.0606228113174438,
-0.07741154730319977,
-0.14293299615383148,
-0.6744876503944397,
0.5917403697967529,
-0.2541569769382477,
0.11303788423538208,
-0.09446510672569275,
0.22646589577198029,
-0.818488359451294,
0.21784037351608276,
0.610185444355011,
-0.17466387152671814,
0.52405846118927,
0.0856521874666214,
0.2940479516983032,
-1.1684861183166504,
0.11052644997835159,
-0.16204595565795898,
0.17853623628616333,
-0.8810373544692993,
0.16913825273513794,
0.26380854845046997,
-0.28803497552871704,
-0.6619070768356323,
0.47615429759025574,
-0.5695663690567017,
-0.3773033618927002,
0.1772141456604004,
-0.1818145215511322,
0.19809727370738983,
0.6761762499809265,
0.028703726828098297,
0.4337466061115265,
0.8618788123130798,
-0.8689782023429871,
0.42599615454673767,
0.18634434044361115,
-0.41616925597190857,
0.18198364973068237,
-0.394331693649292,
0.18774214386940002,
-0.2124543935060501,
0.3279447555541992,
-1.2112247943878174,
-0.2587718963623047,
0.21692578494548798,
-0.6790830492973328,
0.4052448868751526,
-0.05123390257358551,
-0.26264771819114685,
-0.33337217569351196,
-0.37036848068237305,
0.950944721698761,
-0.08643919974565506,
-0.5230140089988708,
1.1120336055755615,
-0.04611615464091301,
0.11203552782535553,
-0.4646984338760376,
-0.6686155796051025,
0.10534600168466568,
-0.18838359415531158,
-0.8624832630157471,
0.2279588282108307,
-0.31410181522369385,
-0.04398880898952484,
-0.17602640390396118,
0.06541132926940918,
-0.08128530532121658,
0.09327945113182068,
0.43652215600013733,
0.5960436463356018,
-0.6599580645561218,
0.08205404877662659,
-0.019490346312522888,
0.22420193254947662,
-0.197964608669281,
-0.044021155685186386,
0.6452933549880981,
0.21426977217197418,
-0.3272857367992401,
-0.6536049246788025,
0.4911535084247589,
1.033156156539917,
-0.6313428282737732,
0.47622355818748474,
0.5783913135528564,
-0.12276067584753036,
0.02619531750679016,
-0.5110121369361877,
0.12634451687335968,
-0.4847148060798645,
0.47190865874290466,
-0.7464777827262878,
-0.7087547779083252,
0.26591843366622925,
-0.04154152423143387,
0.14429932832717896,
0.11465989798307419,
0.8082500100135803,
-0.014081483706831932,
1.2471076250076294,
0.35657230019569397,
0.14782488346099854,
0.657509982585907,
-0.07335472106933594,
0.1223866194486618,
-0.9552562832832336,
-0.5717558860778809,
-0.36086735129356384,
-0.4808705449104309,
-0.6165220141410828,
-0.4692566692829132,
0.22474323213100433,
-0.39594778418540955,
-0.3287782371044159,
0.27418893575668335,
-0.4283417761325836,
-0.08174195140600204,
0.31498783826828003,
0.043652355670928955,
-0.1130884438753128,
-0.19588278234004974,
-0.12669803202152252,
0.34025701880455017,
-0.6921224594116211,
-0.26622867584228516,
1.346387505531311,
0.657386064529419,
0.6370542049407959,
0.34024327993392944,
0.44088196754455566,
0.49667641520500183,
0.06059800833463669,
-0.7302998900413513,
0.3801848292350769,
-0.18373675644397736,
-0.9091147184371948,
0.1502683162689209,
-0.16120469570159912,
-0.5970099568367004,
0.38630411028862,
-0.3279939293861389,
-0.3426309823989868,
0.7990695238113403,
0.16423334181308746,
-0.626858651638031,
0.25189995765686035,
-0.751853883266449,
0.9493848085403442,
-0.4644037187099457,
0.03658797964453697,
-0.08552752435207367,
-0.6181456446647644,
0.6680256128311157,
-0.009324317798018456,
0.30089613795280457,
0.3350141644477844,
-0.08423423022031784,
0.18071629106998444,
0.5543054938316345,
0.7576655745506287,
-0.1274227499961853,
-0.012470215559005737,
0.1296304613351822,
0.34640324115753174,
0.22621051967144012,
-0.04747004061937332,
0.0704098716378212,
0.18615640699863434,
-0.24017813801765442,
-0.1906067281961441,
-0.4374147057533264,
0.4820873737335205,
-0.9676882028579712,
-0.2145141065120697,
0.057606879621744156,
-0.39905062317848206,
-0.2945079803466797,
0.0915907770395279,
0.024871788918972015,
1.1578742265701294,
-0.07562282681465149,
0.5153836607933044,
0.5309396982192993,
-0.16270042955875397,
0.8439348340034485,
0.28898248076438904,
-0.15591001510620117,
-0.466657817363739,
0.8297799825668335,
-0.13187718391418457,
0.33290818333625793,
0.721039354801178,
-0.21944594383239746,
-0.35023340582847595,
-0.7573770880699158,
-0.6377506852149963,
-0.2511763572692871,
-0.7380934953689575,
-0.2080967128276825,
-0.7885138988494873,
-0.2712060511112213,
-0.7803240418434143,
-0.1535932421684265,
-0.4646055996417999,
-0.5331932902336121,
-0.38588830828666687,
-0.3249293267726898,
-0.21237598359584808,
0.6545546054840088,
0.010760068893432617,
0.17240427434444427,
-0.6745181679725647,
0.5039095878601074,
0.4365355372428894,
0.2752709984779358,
0.2988959848880768,
-0.38664138317108154,
-0.06897042691707611,
0.0009209018317051232,
-0.3471895754337311,
-0.7501776218414307,
0.0624227374792099,
0.2247351109981537,
0.6321355104446411,
0.7877341508865356,
-0.6480130553245544,
0.6575145125389099,
-0.4504174292087555,
1.0831904411315918,
0.4540942907333374,
-0.4920880198478699,
0.1278604120016098,
-0.3976005017757416,
0.09371525794267654,
0.19559399783611298,
0.3498702347278595,
-0.36515310406684875,
0.3240125775337219,
-0.2813540995121002,
-0.503326952457428,
0.5596030354499817,
-0.2545403242111206,
0.2932971715927124,
-0.17508426308631897,
0.2550106644630432,
0.11151110380887985,
0.30884024500846863,
-0.9478352665901184,
-0.1722404509782791,
-0.8552405834197998,
-0.06792909651994705,
-0.09285885095596313,
-0.20402440428733826,
-0.10159526020288467,
-0.03702070564031601,
0.1435932219028473,
0.004366748034954071,
0.45611363649368286,
-0.2151459902524948,
-0.22135335206985474,
0.3681965172290802,
0.32872524857521057,
1.2168697118759155,
0.6146132946014404,
-0.10371098667383194,
0.2495937943458557,
-0.3400442600250244,
-0.07111596316099167,
-0.011462262831628323,
-0.332698792219162,
0.04810338094830513,
-0.15770605206489563,
0.3775154650211334,
1.2159647941589355,
0.42363613843917847,
-0.2688813805580139,
0.5156678557395935,
0.09245484322309494,
-0.23216649889945984,
-0.3664512634277344,
0.03684968873858452,
-0.01581604778766632,
0.5227052569389343,
0.010016975924372673,
0.39522600173950195,
0.30499377846717834,
-0.619045078754425,
0.018485086038708687,
0.4540828764438629,
-0.1274106353521347,
-0.6435673832893372,
0.6258497834205627,
0.3134555220603943,
-0.3198062777519226,
0.5511276721954346,
0.005938468500971794,
-0.02291475608944893,
0.5170571804046631,
0.5393081307411194,
1.0309492349624634,
-0.16952182352542877,
0.3960420489311218,
0.2444836050271988,
0.04918860271573067,
0.3399001359939575,
0.1488296389579773,
-0.3247022032737732,
-0.8641844391822815,
-0.21216200292110443,
-0.7996610999107361,
0.013692306354641914,
0.0329647958278656,
-0.5588204860687256,
0.06732720881700516,
-0.5962300896644592,
-0.3875010311603546,
0.25236213207244873,
-0.6330317854881287,
-0.7988038659095764,
0.2563660144805908,
0.7211053371429443,
0.9930121898651123,
-0.48244595527648926,
0.657680869102478,
0.8832395672798157,
-0.5750610828399658,
-0.5879369378089905,
-0.6159569025039673,
0.17724305391311646,
-1.0287071466445923,
0.9322895407676697,
-0.10623036324977875,
-0.1150338277220726,
-0.05875050649046898,
-0.3946259617805481,
-1.0550633668899536,
1.37970769405365,
-0.14267507195472717,
-0.23938733339309692,
-0.6385350823402405,
0.050598978996276855,
0.21297253668308258,
-0.8790844678878784,
0.39454805850982666,
0.14425161480903625,
0.5813856720924377,
0.1211257353425026,
-0.7883467078208923,
-0.09090711921453476,
-0.2008567601442337,
0.5917032361030579,
0.17335458099842072,
-0.7692822813987732,
1.2309935092926025,
0.005269584245979786,
-0.036748453974723816,
0.17367662489414215,
0.2391326129436493,
-0.07668429613113403,
0.09231235086917877,
0.4264426827430725,
0.5167620778083801,
0.010419041849672794,
0.135210320353508,
0.9339157342910767,
-0.4971971809864044,
-0.04022110626101494,
0.8448774218559265,
-0.06139323487877846,
0.6216027736663818,
0.3990306556224823,
0.2196960300207138,
0.5646194219589233,
0.8602549433708191,
-0.22662709653377533,
0.6559153199195862,
-0.08863573521375656,
-0.11618672311306,
-0.4030715525150299,
-0.06411789357662201,
-0.47256144881248474,
1.111937165260315,
0.3845731019973755,
-0.45472651720046997,
-0.29934361577033997,
0.26712360978126526,
-0.1022704467177391,
-0.5012694001197815,
-0.6325977444648743,
0.7744502425193787,
-0.2755630910396576,
-0.5991386771202087,
0.26656144857406616,
0.15595899522304535,
0.6127535104751587,
-0.7054443359375,
0.027404773980379105,
-0.2204839140176773,
0.008589347824454308,
-0.20516721904277802,
-0.29025229811668396,
-0.10960415750741959,
-0.4161037504673004,
-0.3670121431350708,
-0.39355233311653137,
0.5345871448516846,
-0.1200936883687973,
-0.27588218450546265,
0.2730935513973236,
0.49797898530960083,
-0.24754339456558228,
0.09818869829177856,
-0.7550281882286072,
0.2617211937904358,
-0.2968018054962158,
-0.3263721764087677,
0.44402629137039185,
0.22903364896774292,
-0.07678525149822235,
0.6876837611198425,
0.7221786975860596,
-0.26251134276390076,
0.5420420169830322,
0.14982938766479492,
0.9279301762580872,
-0.582344114780426,
-0.35995492339134216,
-0.6839221119880676,
0.7577099800109863,
0.1959707885980606,
-0.45056965947151184,
0.4859194755554199,
0.47147634625434875,
0.37797632813453674,
-0.18391461670398712,
0.3398742377758026,
-0.15796169638633728,
-0.045840755105018616,
-0.47104135155677795,
0.4063838720321655,
-0.7098711729049683,
-0.23216354846954346,
-0.1637112945318222,
-0.7696195244789124,
-0.15349456667900085,
0.14497433602809906,
0.07930909842252731,
0.2291145771741867,
0.4838877022266388,
0.7040546536445618,
-0.16850680112838745,
0.0830666646361351,
0.5493096709251404,
0.06808875501155853,
0.3064102530479431,
0.36100417375564575,
1.0202438831329346,
-0.035504795610904694,
0.405377596616745,
0.04396622255444527,
-0.3158186078071594,
-0.26391804218292236,
-0.5713624358177185,
-0.695279598236084,
-0.6225998997688293,
-0.059065110981464386,
0.052561696618795395,
-0.3292757570743561,
0.708662211894989,
1.0151768922805786,
-0.502465546131134,
-0.12726765871047974,
0.37576812505722046,
-0.09138825535774231,
-0.18589571118354797,
-0.22302591800689697,
0.16198323667049408,
-0.42825251817703247,
-0.29290398955345154,
0.6505064964294434,
0.5825158357620239,
0.033072520047426224,
-0.5996865034103394,
0.10600432753562927,
-0.3601737320423126,
0.3627363443374634,
0.8912284970283508,
0.17187784612178802,
-0.7261440753936768,
-0.3595965504646301,
0.27545225620269775,
-0.043998025357723236,
0.15747900307178497,
0.9155109524726868,
-0.39906230568885803,
0.7100850939750671,
0.3855598568916321,
0.6881615519523621,
0.34949320554733276,
-0.26611316204071045,
0.23011387884616852,
-0.5023179054260254,
0.1552869975566864,
0.2200891077518463,
0.6180791258811951,
0.08847266435623169,
-0.06727100908756256,
0.08235276490449905,
0.06984720379114151,
-0.4336789548397064,
-0.6720063090324402,
0.4934908449649811,
-1.204046368598938,
-0.295610636472702,
0.947077214717865,
0.14487655460834503,
-0.17990632355213165,
-0.039111506193876266,
-0.0638042613863945,
-0.07833728194236755,
-0.16806291043758392,
0.7050736546516418,
0.7349303364753723,
-0.41596320271492004,
-0.4169773459434509,
-0.5009412169456482,
0.3057865500450134,
0.011729964055120945,
-0.465915322303772,
-0.4320056736469269,
0.7088457345962524,
0.19166071712970734,
0.5561915040016174,
0.5503896474838257,
-0.410826176404953,
0.5467317700386047,
0.18470166623592377,
0.13737629354000092,
-0.38448479771614075,
-0.5975434184074402,
-0.2968328893184662,
0.613502562046051,
-0.17012733221054077,
-0.657900333404541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17915v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17915v1
|
Long Context is Not Long at All: A Prospector of Long-Dependency Data for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-28T07:36:56 | 2024-05-28T07:36:56 |
Longze Chen, Ziqiang Liu, Wanwei He, Yunshui Li, Run Luo, Min Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Long-context modeling capabilities are important for large language models
(LLMs) in various applications. However, directly training LLMs with long
context windows is insufficient to enhance this capability since some training
samples do not exhibit strong semantic dependencies across long contexts. In
this study, we propose a data mining framework \textbf{ProLong} that can assign
each training sample with a long dependency score, which can be used to rank
and filter samples that are more advantageous for enhancing long-context
modeling abilities in LLM training. Specifically, we first use delta perplexity
scores to measure the \textit{Dependency Strength} between text segments in a
given document. Then we refine this metric based on the \textit{Dependency
Distance} of these segments to incorporate spatial relationships across
long-contexts. Final results are calibrated with a \textit{Dependency
Specificity} metric to prevent trivial dependencies introduced by repetitive
patterns. Moreover, a random sampling approach is proposed to optimize the
computational efficiency of ProLong. Comprehensive experiments on multiple
benchmarks indicate that ProLong effectively identifies documents that carry
long dependencies and LLMs trained on these documents exhibit significantly
enhanced long-context modeling capabilities.
|
[
-0.4467196464538574,
-0.6692542433738708,
0.964201033115387,
0.547124445438385,
-0.3263416588306427,
-0.3450048863887787,
-0.5891780853271484,
-0.7809926271438599,
0.26161515712738037,
0.7321233749389648,
-0.4953867495059967,
-0.7764378190040588,
-0.604674220085144,
0.12158312648534775,
-0.2644326984882355,
1.0007270574569702,
-0.1348312646150589,
-0.0921383649110794,
-0.4729219079017639,
-0.33366823196411133,
-0.4035892188549042,
-0.4612548351287842,
-0.29753658175468445,
-0.20018555223941803,
0.750385582447052,
0.32640090584754944,
0.36700132489204407,
0.4605277180671692,
0.17944283783435822,
0.2617044150829315,
-0.15661829710006714,
-0.06194799020886421,
-0.6344867944717407,
0.21609950065612793,
-0.21355415880680084,
-0.43785032629966736,
-0.4635237455368042,
-0.13168860971927643,
0.7494906783103943,
0.8880732655525208,
0.1733657717704773,
-0.08890136331319809,
0.16947124898433685,
0.6738147735595703,
-0.48104092478752136,
0.3090539872646332,
-0.4313492774963379,
-0.1310826987028122,
-0.6214675903320312,
-0.18573223054409027,
-0.31678831577301025,
0.19630374014377594,
0.400618314743042,
-0.3898482024669647,
0.16538572311401367,
0.0874282494187355,
0.6706943511962891,
0.08584310859441757,
-0.6953207850456238,
-0.22535118460655212,
-0.5771864056587219,
1.1068809032440186,
-0.5884382724761963,
0.2494117021560669,
0.5640510320663452,
0.3434624671936035,
-0.5310834050178528,
-0.4496411681175232,
-0.30669641494750977,
-0.34589603543281555,
-0.202477365732193,
-0.10979702323675156,
0.34260642528533936,
0.20155739784240723,
0.2057507038116455,
0.21208655834197998,
-0.23527230322360992,
0.40431469678878784,
-0.42115846276283264,
0.14171920716762543,
0.33852869272232056,
0.05724457651376724,
0.10203356295824051,
-0.2971508800983429,
-0.6692325472831726,
0.33255618810653687,
-0.780092716217041,
0.18718132376670837,
0.14306503534317017,
0.5205371379852295,
-0.04024224355816841,
0.3713013231754303,
-0.38067811727523804,
0.778678297996521,
-0.22488296031951904,
-0.24011898040771484,
0.24140772223472595,
0.07157013565301895,
-0.1706521362066269,
-0.04998483881354332,
0.5864996910095215,
0.1895805299282074,
0.369355171918869,
-0.48277074098587036,
-0.2860907316207886,
-0.4557850658893585,
0.18397924304008484,
-0.9697321057319641,
0.0628608912229538,
0.2280755192041397,
-0.13931897282600403,
0.0907207727432251,
0.08987102657556534,
-0.6904125213623047,
-0.3056606948375702,
-0.6160783767700195,
0.15574420988559723,
-0.39360952377319336,
-0.011591622605919838,
0.07833284139633179,
0.13277117908000946,
-0.01841479353606701,
0.12276140600442886,
-0.7725619077682495,
0.08507691323757172,
0.6920380592346191,
0.8407294750213623,
-0.3736884295940399,
-0.6831920742988586,
-0.5553710460662842,
0.20820491015911102,
-0.2554805278778076,
0.9070147275924683,
-0.6729057431221008,
-0.3348652422428131,
0.046851418912410736,
0.3936256468296051,
0.18561680614948273,
-0.5839173793792725,
0.6637487411499023,
-0.6968487501144409,
0.2549859881401062,
-0.25370851159095764,
-0.7936757206916809,
-0.1775992512702942,
0.13990798592567444,
-0.9078489542007446,
0.9781914949417114,
0.6154998540878296,
-0.8006928563117981,
0.6741968989372253,
-0.5120126008987427,
-0.5763939023017883,
0.23569151759147644,
-0.3320484161376953,
-0.32393670082092285,
0.004740934818983078,
0.0887686088681221,
0.6544958353042603,
-0.2349429428577423,
0.6430502533912659,
-0.5753610134124756,
-0.6614322066307068,
-0.15681986510753632,
-0.026692736893892288,
0.5104227066040039,
-0.21676410734653473,
-0.41718629002571106,
0.14569495618343353,
-0.9877877831459045,
-0.22512343525886536,
-0.218247190117836,
-0.7997308969497681,
-0.6567105650901794,
0.20688214898109436,
0.1864621788263321,
0.16815872490406036,
0.23939429223537445,
-0.4846276342868805,
0.09710725396871567,
-0.5104691386222839,
0.23382721841335297,
0.8188241124153137,
-0.15306097269058228,
0.7699438333511353,
-0.3243526220321655,
0.4301978051662445,
0.18872693181037903,
-0.15432678163051605,
-0.05917228385806084,
-0.04847612604498863,
-0.6737399697303772,
-0.7596874833106995,
0.19254764914512634,
0.3818208873271942,
-0.4537734091281891,
1.0065064430236816,
-0.7484405636787415,
-0.22535404562950134,
0.11610471457242966,
0.2858262062072754,
0.04068627581000328,
0.29372525215148926,
0.46017029881477356,
-0.37258070707321167,
-0.8982784748077393,
-0.8962056040763855,
-0.03100971318781376,
0.16760382056236267,
-0.18758410215377808,
0.24548795819282532,
0.5242021679878235,
-0.380807101726532,
1.5832139253616333,
-0.4088986814022064,
-0.659203827381134,
-0.19255639612674713,
-0.2444540113210678,
0.5098456740379333,
0.207601860165596,
0.6127553582191467,
-0.5425918102264404,
-0.36910635232925415,
-0.4685075283050537,
-0.8185399770736694,
-0.08335366100072861,
-0.0076920101419091225,
-0.10971357673406601,
0.1750287413597107,
0.6244593262672424,
-0.689573347568512,
0.2102346569299698,
0.510136067867279,
-0.40108051896095276,
0.6222032904624939,
-0.20050358772277832,
-0.24531780183315277,
-0.9827499389648438,
0.16393570601940155,
0.0972534567117691,
-0.3588142395019531,
-0.6029391884803772,
-0.17998173832893372,
-0.07390941679477692,
-0.011412523686885834,
-0.5008776187896729,
0.9676026105880737,
-0.37110769748687744,
0.08518926799297333,
-0.3516225218772888,
-0.09651627391576767,
0.07532836496829987,
0.4534912109375,
0.2233828753232956,
0.5491400361061096,
0.41137340664863586,
-0.6216938495635986,
0.2070566564798355,
-0.045155007392168045,
-0.882712721824646,
0.4907894730567932,
-0.42925626039505005,
-0.12222294509410858,
-0.15737304091453552,
0.7173796892166138,
-0.7149681448936462,
-0.28455790877342224,
-0.15411555767059326,
-0.0033493891824036837,
0.3361159861087799,
-0.19807645678520203,
-0.495491087436676,
-0.11840122193098068,
-0.25092199444770813,
0.35881471633911133,
0.17358370125293732,
-0.788846492767334,
0.4967997670173645,
0.1418897807598114,
-0.07714501023292542,
-0.6515994071960449,
-0.6028138399124146,
0.03691106289625168,
-0.5731196999549866,
-0.7699518203735352,
0.469204306602478,
0.13938267529010773,
-0.1299218386411667,
-0.1515170782804489,
-0.05029639974236488,
0.09816557914018631,
0.06880569458007812,
0.5675058364868164,
-0.0793486163020134,
-0.07078278064727783,
0.46583738923072815,
-0.34945398569107056,
-0.19692082703113556,
0.11463315039873123,
-0.18704470992088318,
0.49219968914985657,
0.15100963413715363,
-0.061269212514162064,
0.1491401195526123,
0.6484665274620056,
0.7303863763809204,
0.10280954837799072,
0.9445759654045105,
0.3513919711112976,
-0.28045886754989624,
-0.5795058608055115,
-0.5606100559234619,
-0.09019432961940765,
-0.4424498677253723,
0.7144882678985596,
-0.5705090761184692,
-1.1749552488327026,
0.551459014415741,
-0.10175132006406784,
-0.0373445525765419,
0.25843197107315063,
0.30692699551582336,
-0.020693305879831314,
0.5845863819122314,
0.7947285771369934,
-0.5970619320869446,
0.7347913980484009,
-0.06764175742864609,
0.2989223599433899,
-0.7096858620643616,
-0.06577009707689285,
-0.16600126028060913,
-0.18128490447998047,
-0.3739568293094635,
-0.34433555603027344,
0.22903721034526825,
0.397860050201416,
-0.36659812927246094,
0.13755947351455688,
-0.09025898575782776,
0.6645064949989319,
0.3335181772708893,
0.05817233398556709,
-0.006165891885757446,
0.19838020205497742,
0.02805967815220356,
0.014938216656446457,
-0.33465927839279175,
-0.3319053649902344,
0.9960581660270691,
0.5175000429153442,
0.46107909083366394,
0.003149016760289669,
0.7233249545097351,
-0.00009635497553972527,
0.16441377997398376,
-0.9002768397331238,
0.648235023021698,
-0.4298401474952698,
-0.622492253780365,
-0.5689393877983093,
-0.4695933163166046,
-1.1352081298828125,
-0.14237581193447113,
-0.024637257680296898,
-0.7128540873527527,
0.06270647794008255,
-0.3459796607494354,
-0.21555212140083313,
0.1317235231399536,
-0.379163920879364,
0.5944275856018066,
-0.2748667597770691,
-0.40208959579467773,
0.05586840584874153,
-0.45113077759742737,
0.1809745579957962,
-0.2876439690589905,
0.2536466419696808,
-0.18629573285579681,
0.13697870075702667,
0.847859263420105,
-0.4533710181713104,
0.9466045498847961,
-0.3474958539009094,
-0.1843918114900589,
0.14802345633506775,
-0.10861819982528687,
0.49819061160087585,
0.044461481273174286,
-0.15182021260261536,
0.12168112397193909,
-0.19624866545200348,
-0.630679190158844,
-0.4983151853084564,
0.923558235168457,
-0.6548374891281128,
-0.6486973166465759,
-0.30651095509529114,
-0.4231965243816376,
-0.3746601641178131,
0.3442745506763458,
0.3006313443183899,
0.3255312144756317,
-0.0736449807882309,
0.3870786428451538,
0.40949147939682007,
-0.18493497371673584,
0.38370585441589355,
0.44335636496543884,
-0.17659911513328552,
-0.19775696098804474,
0.7548543810844421,
0.36750587821006775,
-0.07345400750637054,
0.37947696447372437,
0.08070770651102066,
-0.32071927189826965,
-0.4152807593345642,
-0.12374173104763031,
0.2529138922691345,
-0.9383752942085266,
0.01337438728660345,
-0.4355151951313019,
-0.29904070496559143,
-0.22075830399990082,
-0.19573600590229034,
-0.16625986993312836,
-0.04768297076225281,
-0.33434075117111206,
-0.11811576783657074,
0.5037634968757629,
0.4386347532272339,
0.2835735082626343,
0.28773820400238037,
-0.6783549785614014,
0.08475430309772491,
0.38309431076049805,
0.7722492218017578,
0.09988546371459961,
-0.28129997849464417,
-0.5718507766723633,
-0.4507342278957367,
-0.000658738543279469,
-0.5003605484962463,
0.25882694125175476,
0.2626374065876007,
0.5272549390792847,
0.40163078904151917,
0.04030817374587059,
0.6026354432106018,
-0.47206252813339233,
0.7909060716629028,
0.12253473699092865,
-0.6966818571090698,
0.37450066208839417,
-0.5000144243240356,
0.5173242688179016,
0.715735673904419,
0.41368862986564636,
-0.20060113072395325,
-0.25563061237335205,
-0.3084307909011841,
-1.3505418300628662,
0.5854442715644836,
-0.15964655578136444,
0.06624366343021393,
-0.14295774698257446,
0.5200256109237671,
0.10453832149505615,
-0.08799996972084045,
-0.7595936059951782,
0.13207101821899414,
0.16695661842823029,
-0.18201594054698944,
-0.3508662283420563,
-0.5792805552482605,
-0.026263592764735222,
-0.17474396526813507,
0.5076325535774231,
-0.13249850273132324,
-0.05706508085131645,
0.11371643841266632,
-0.2567146122455597,
0.1801125854253769,
0.4393322169780731,
0.3199753761291504,
0.9552173614501953,
-0.5181276798248291,
0.18183813989162445,
0.31477317214012146,
-0.37855905294418335,
0.03036312945187092,
0.08108430355787277,
0.12365127354860306,
0.12402777373790741,
0.62403404712677,
0.7384882569313049,
0.3927422761917114,
-0.6673012375831604,
0.5237745046615601,
0.2962876260280609,
-0.1078387126326561,
-0.739798903465271,
0.01579350046813488,
0.2934073209762573,
0.3091244697570801,
0.31592464447021484,
-0.47153010964393616,
0.06700330972671509,
-0.6250936388969421,
0.2688922882080078,
0.2451121062040329,
-0.5406836271286011,
-0.057517457753419876,
0.16603262722492218,
0.183672234416008,
0.0018432231154292822,
0.7354781627655029,
0.028347229585051537,
-0.5051119327545166,
0.5969667434692383,
0.4372917115688324,
0.47274771332740784,
-0.07539235055446625,
-0.3851674199104309,
0.22694697976112366,
-0.34230396151542664,
-0.36973679065704346,
0.03565213829278946,
-0.21633784472942352,
-0.4375767707824707,
-0.602766752243042,
-0.9297763109207153,
0.08220236003398895,
0.5546920299530029,
-0.4417445659637451,
0.698774516582489,
-0.2940122187137604,
-0.22437788546085358,
-0.11078888922929764,
0.3415829539299011,
-0.5474892258644104,
0.4493294060230255,
0.05934430658817291,
0.9170451164245605,
-0.6451594829559326,
1.1617839336395264,
0.3997921943664551,
0.0812709778547287,
-0.35016873478889465,
-0.12266597151756287,
-0.18785756826400757,
-0.22336415946483612,
0.9176105856895447,
0.7854799032211304,
-0.09168561547994614,
-0.3740338087081909,
-0.2966521978378296,
-0.6965474486351013,
1.1419137716293335,
0.1238977387547493,
-1.0062332153320312,
-0.1839727759361267,
0.30351242423057556,
0.6714242696762085,
-0.5404016971588135,
0.21913260221481323,
0.782293438911438,
0.37320443987846375,
-0.08835206180810928,
-0.6886418461799622,
0.19112853705883026,
-0.09253441542387009,
0.09677566587924957,
0.3816321790218353,
-0.5024780631065369,
0.6432976126670837,
0.03633681312203407,
-0.17476177215576172,
0.15476484596729279,
0.5922664403915405,
0.5033465027809143,
0.37626489996910095,
0.8287909626960754,
0.5879762768745422,
0.3998850882053375,
0.20541323721408844,
0.8118806481361389,
-0.40082862973213196,
0.37486913800239563,
1.530961275100708,
-0.23447048664093018,
0.9641826152801514,
0.5192112922668457,
-0.07630635052919388,
0.5113192796707153,
0.6247687339782715,
-0.12622763216495514,
0.5565862655639648,
0.5746036767959595,
-0.4054108262062073,
-0.433611124753952,
0.1414223462343216,
-0.22073855996131897,
0.437030553817749,
0.3142701983451843,
-0.598595917224884,
-0.3421769142150879,
0.07389185577630997,
0.23217765986919403,
-0.06974875926971436,
0.061828143894672394,
0.5099098682403564,
0.43664082884788513,
-0.7587247490882874,
0.5769867897033691,
0.12653708457946777,
0.9236289858818054,
-0.664217472076416,
0.3331332802772522,
-0.32202306389808655,
0.36576423048973083,
-0.36559295654296875,
-0.6296229362487793,
0.17850589752197266,
-0.054553303867578506,
-0.6745046377182007,
-0.043439023196697235,
0.4762985110282898,
-0.38176849484443665,
-0.3631129860877991,
0.812897264957428,
0.31128549575805664,
0.1096942275762558,
-0.2767110764980316,
-0.15260931849479675,
-0.2946474850177765,
-0.2718089520931244,
-0.679661214351654,
0.7299463152885437,
0.4207242727279663,
-0.3825477957725525,
0.4966607093811035,
0.5400010347366333,
0.14043405652046204,
-0.34738725423812866,
0.28673797845840454,
0.8637864589691162,
-0.8208833932876587,
-0.6226749420166016,
-1.0296192169189453,
0.3762240707874298,
-0.039611414074897766,
-0.25796186923980713,
0.4881250858306885,
0.6855818033218384,
0.5602802634239197,
0.11193124949932098,
0.7310922741889954,
0.10101935267448425,
0.5282254815101624,
-0.5522448420524597,
0.7084627747535706,
-0.5833656787872314,
0.6543788909912109,
0.17170535027980804,
-1.1746538877487183,
-0.44216132164001465,
0.23581355810165405,
-0.7291209101676941,
0.04894247651100159,
0.583724319934845,
0.8365522623062134,
-0.2889654338359833,
-0.13362370431423187,
0.268511027097702,
0.22273610532283783,
0.6003139019012451,
0.8198924660682678,
0.717740535736084,
0.0681459978222847,
0.3447965979576111,
-0.1089584231376648,
-0.43486738204956055,
-0.2084498256444931,
-0.9386517405509949,
-1.1250908374786377,
-0.6783351898193359,
0.11221076548099518,
-0.24160920083522797,
-0.05094444751739502,
0.7321245074272156,
1.0406111478805542,
-0.576488733291626,
-0.27848395705223083,
-0.05104187875986099,
-0.07483335584402084,
0.2870759665966034,
-0.2906472980976105,
0.6517953872680664,
-0.553629994392395,
-0.5348224639892578,
0.5887774229049683,
0.1923157125711441,
-0.045054059475660324,
-0.3358115553855896,
-0.046743571758270264,
-0.011720913462340832,
-0.09955184161663055,
0.8716863393783569,
0.048859499394893646,
-0.5531054735183716,
-0.5784547924995422,
-0.1508406698703766,
0.023566115647554398,
0.2240670919418335,
0.6965692639350891,
-0.9555195569992065,
0.3957323729991913,
0.5442962646484375,
0.2478283941745758,
0.5753236413002014,
-0.1345195323228836,
0.5271258354187012,
-0.931395947933197,
0.2747008204460144,
0.11068060994148254,
0.43333807587623596,
0.3907378017902374,
-0.3898431062698364,
0.43310874700546265,
-0.05546313896775246,
-0.7275384068489075,
-0.6470158696174622,
0.21392805874347687,
-1.0511114597320557,
-0.6470824480056763,
1.554588794708252,
-0.4794062674045563,
-0.30627039074897766,
-0.3386743366718292,
0.0033822176046669483,
0.09126560389995575,
-0.37003394961357117,
0.8332440257072449,
0.8562796711921692,
0.07020331919193268,
0.12794245779514313,
-0.5797237753868103,
0.5444255471229553,
0.2048463076353073,
-0.6333931684494019,
0.016335846856236458,
0.31960606575012207,
0.6076862812042236,
0.1945871114730835,
0.59330153465271,
-0.03870592266321182,
-0.17165569961071014,
-0.3594590723514557,
-0.26196566224098206,
-0.04460083320736885,
-0.5562266707420349,
-0.26329684257507324,
0.4395289719104767,
0.0646335631608963,
0.15080176293849945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17902v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17902v2
|
Boosting Protein Language Models with Negative Sample Mining
| 2024-05-28T07:24:20 | 2024-06-29T07:07:49 |
Yaoyao Xu, Xinjian Zhao, Xiaozhuang Song, Benyou Wang, Tianshu Yu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We introduce a pioneering methodology for boosting large language models in
the domain of protein representation learning. Our primary contribution lies in
the refinement process for correlating the over-reliance on co-evolution
knowledge, in a way that networks are trained to distill invaluable insights
from negative samples, constituted by protein pairs sourced from disparate
categories. By capitalizing on this novel approach, our technique steers the
training of transformer-based models within the attention score space. This
advanced strategy not only amplifies performance but also reflects the nuanced
biological behaviors exhibited by proteins, offering aligned evidence with
traditional biological mechanisms such as protein-protein interaction. We
experimentally observed improved performance on various tasks over datasets, on
top of several well-established large protein models. This innovative paradigm
opens up promising horizons for further progress in the realms of protein
research and computational biology.
|
[
-0.29589128494262695,
-0.41391244530677795,
0.1415684074163437,
-0.12147809565067291,
0.0336991548538208,
0.01767386682331562,
0.02221982181072235,
-0.5154540538787842,
0.6830967664718628,
0.41878777742385864,
-0.6241589188575745,
-0.2886062562465668,
-0.7048938274383545,
0.29079264402389526,
-0.6492762565612793,
0.9301621913909912,
0.6660777926445007,
0.3337273597717285,
-0.4723092019557953,
-0.25299161672592163,
-0.2047513872385025,
-0.5490386486053467,
-0.6120569109916687,
-0.9293215274810791,
0.7070995569229126,
0.4297279417514801,
0.360007107257843,
0.5138627886772156,
0.2958184778690338,
0.14955301582813263,
0.048181816935539246,
-0.08741314709186554,
-0.9284117817878723,
0.16015838086605072,
-0.5647040605545044,
-0.6018022298812866,
-0.6070631146430969,
0.10297054797410965,
0.0891072154045105,
1.0481019020080566,
0.25175920128822327,
0.3933814764022827,
-0.0249082762748003,
0.6639253497123718,
-0.6915655732154846,
0.31889885663986206,
-0.6932588219642639,
0.023929234594106674,
-0.28202205896377563,
-0.5476706624031067,
-0.6687020659446716,
0.16185350716114044,
0.1780659705400467,
-0.3221389353275299,
0.7097179293632507,
-0.17155595123767853,
0.7265608906745911,
0.22815872728824615,
-0.29637610912323,
-0.04875531420111656,
-0.4592544138431549,
0.927163302898407,
-0.5321564674377441,
0.44035929441452026,
0.48721423745155334,
0.17866754531860352,
-0.16983534395694733,
-0.5457704663276672,
-0.3506506085395813,
-0.25927114486694336,
0.0344080775976181,
0.04222438484430313,
-0.15446613729000092,
-0.0046022203750908375,
0.3089890480041504,
0.6186313033103943,
-0.35361677408218384,
0.09237010031938553,
-0.5150606036186218,
-0.09646549820899963,
0.6979697942733765,
-0.3615856170654297,
0.3920947015285492,
-0.023513557389378548,
0.177873894572258,
-0.30398029088974,
-0.825139045715332,
-0.10421369224786758,
0.23111139237880707,
0.6825500726699829,
0.07888058573007584,
0.7216066122055054,
-0.30245840549468994,
0.678342878818512,
0.330121248960495,
0.41253793239593506,
0.5819175839424133,
0.0007506295223720372,
-0.15274563431739807,
0.18076816201210022,
0.5581654906272888,
0.3218575119972229,
0.0355524979531765,
-0.3421218991279602,
0.10698708146810532,
0.12001639604568481,
0.44856977462768555,
-0.8507551550865173,
-0.489751935005188,
0.34401485323905945,
-0.3860430121421814,
-0.48424428701400757,
-0.010522525757551193,
-1.076503872871399,
-0.6075842380523682,
-0.16829392313957214,
0.5830422639846802,
-0.34617385268211365,
-0.3405851423740387,
0.34492382407188416,
-0.5304853320121765,
0.2573210299015045,
-0.054418113082647324,
-1.0213271379470825,
0.2915278673171997,
0.6222895979881287,
0.7631934881210327,
-0.06400042772293091,
-0.07456088066101074,
-0.9886845350265503,
0.11596724390983582,
-0.1032906174659729,
0.709394097328186,
-0.7847607731819153,
-0.06076184660196304,
-0.10520439594984055,
0.05142035335302353,
0.2201860100030899,
-0.6131756901741028,
0.7080335021018982,
-0.7020278573036194,
0.10717440396547318,
-0.37934067845344543,
-0.7408748269081116,
-0.4744187593460083,
0.25298285484313965,
-0.8317702412605286,
0.7624603509902954,
0.2327103614807129,
-0.6929705739021301,
0.45707252621650696,
-0.8068438172340393,
-0.5779486894607544,
0.4236893653869629,
-0.1833481788635254,
-0.42992737889289856,
0.3684942126274109,
0.22173434495925903,
0.46995726227760315,
-0.35667797923088074,
0.20540200173854828,
-0.8298172354698181,
-0.2626664340496063,
0.02472706325352192,
0.21292205154895782,
0.883361279964447,
-0.03119482472538948,
-0.13995416462421417,
-0.00006174423469929025,
-1.0428247451782227,
0.1398477554321289,
0.05286828428506851,
0.028429029509425163,
-0.5319221615791321,
0.07746568322181702,
-0.2636229991912842,
0.4578166902065277,
-0.05856895074248314,
-0.6132907271385193,
0.3924223780632019,
-0.6149053573608398,
0.8770168423652649,
0.20480312407016754,
0.2005007416009903,
0.4395953416824341,
-0.1268163025379181,
0.35863709449768066,
-0.06047260761260986,
-0.23601028323173523,
-0.2427714616060257,
-0.4096972644329071,
-0.8203537464141846,
-0.028264913707971573,
0.3470219373703003,
0.22861909866333008,
-0.5591211318969727,
0.5856379270553589,
-0.309978723526001,
-0.5886077880859375,
-0.8593772053718567,
0.06785281002521515,
0.009891360998153687,
0.5810930728912354,
1.1016509532928467,
-0.5148217678070068,
-0.756880521774292,
-0.919141948223114,
-0.21843615174293518,
0.012002100236713886,
-0.14999808371067047,
0.2116563469171524,
0.5030569434165955,
-0.37159454822540283,
0.8187302350997925,
-0.3754705786705017,
-0.22083410620689392,
-0.46218857169151306,
0.10617976635694504,
0.5888504981994629,
0.6783772706985474,
0.47830501198768616,
-0.8421177864074707,
-0.35446223616600037,
-0.24986611306667328,
-0.6437493562698364,
-0.24747170507907867,
0.02274799346923828,
-0.016538556665182114,
-0.2738577723503113,
0.6669076085090637,
-0.3980134129524231,
0.013728126883506775,
0.6842027306556702,
-0.2932228446006775,
0.31046903133392334,
0.14846938848495483,
-0.028108906000852585,
-0.8553353548049927,
0.36116448044776917,
0.24792759120464325,
-0.20319245755672455,
-0.9879424571990967,
0.04010068252682686,
-0.04925525188446045,
-0.2810525894165039,
-0.21088190376758575,
0.46310892701148987,
-0.3476339876651764,
0.13406214118003845,
-0.4115527868270874,
-0.21055179834365845,
0.20581157505512238,
0.43061092495918274,
0.07798223197460175,
0.37427517771720886,
0.6905287504196167,
-0.5584802031517029,
0.1965232938528061,
0.28593653440475464,
0.011700528673827648,
0.2438393086194992,
-0.880338191986084,
0.12183989584445953,
-0.23750485479831696,
0.16116119921207428,
-0.8279094696044922,
-0.22438986599445343,
0.30436044931411743,
-0.5728842616081238,
0.6432587504386902,
-0.3194614350795746,
-0.14910554885864258,
-0.5821406841278076,
-0.45393264293670654,
0.3775705099105835,
0.3867914080619812,
-0.47097980976104736,
0.30265745520591736,
0.5841715335845947,
0.052379123866558075,
-0.46915677189826965,
-0.8449437618255615,
0.124306321144104,
-0.09097573906183243,
-0.4366060495376587,
0.4746699333190918,
0.23885707557201385,
0.1685122549533844,
-0.08419284969568253,
-0.2128700166940689,
0.05549709126353264,
-0.11801540106534958,
0.07055133581161499,
-0.007560140918940306,
-0.07318951189517975,
0.39439886808395386,
-0.08740866929292679,
-0.33080342411994934,
-0.13240449130535126,
-0.6458514928817749,
0.8477298021316528,
0.13145950436592102,
-0.11129052937030792,
-0.30053311586380005,
0.24817322194576263,
0.4301377534866333,
-0.41611307859420776,
0.8044114708900452,
0.4989570677280426,
-0.287767231464386,
-0.15232549607753754,
-0.36086028814315796,
-0.607344925403595,
-0.4012424349784851,
0.735232949256897,
-0.21932949125766754,
-0.7795749306678772,
0.3228262662887573,
-0.1248626783490181,
-0.32341256737709045,
0.5431869029998779,
0.5588571429252625,
0.059803497046232224,
0.9258577227592468,
1.152874231338501,
-0.07855065166950226,
0.48153156042099,
-0.4892655611038208,
0.24766425788402557,
-0.7481754422187805,
-0.028161464259028435,
-0.660493016242981,
-0.4564279615879059,
-0.6884594559669495,
-0.5326723456382751,
0.07286085933446884,
0.267026424407959,
-0.12965452671051025,
0.5139424800872803,
-0.4033406674861908,
0.39450088143348694,
0.5233704447746277,
0.12728005647659302,
0.06135258823633194,
-0.015037200413644314,
0.08344687521457672,
0.021791130304336548,
-0.9224395155906677,
-0.2470104992389679,
1.199327826499939,
0.31753531098365784,
0.6072748899459839,
-0.32415929436683655,
0.7262352108955383,
0.34018704295158386,
0.4276462495326996,
-0.9502260088920593,
0.25256216526031494,
-0.28452879190444946,
-0.5886390209197998,
-0.11664935201406479,
-0.5476893186569214,
-0.6692225933074951,
0.04302345588803291,
-0.3765209913253784,
-0.699357271194458,
0.5271846652030945,
0.44309985637664795,
-0.1947334110736847,
0.0643465667963028,
-0.883967399597168,
1.0947400331497192,
0.10983545333147049,
-0.6454671621322632,
-0.23838327825069427,
-0.56831955909729,
0.24220459163188934,
0.03380337730050087,
-0.049376230686903,
0.13425152003765106,
0.13489322364330292,
0.6458101272583008,
-0.15085230767726898,
0.9283566474914551,
-0.27044087648391724,
-0.2219400703907013,
0.13920189440250397,
0.0478505901992321,
0.27221035957336426,
0.08816510438919067,
-0.43095919489860535,
0.4673704206943512,
-0.09500730037689209,
-0.6948404908180237,
-0.49948158860206604,
0.45854443311691284,
-0.7209267020225525,
-0.3428339660167694,
-0.21589277684688568,
-0.39526423811912537,
-0.3856569230556488,
0.44500282406806946,
0.43485960364341736,
0.32616886496543884,
0.1207108274102211,
0.3560696840286255,
0.5616183280944824,
-0.36744800209999084,
-0.04710882157087326,
0.4276750683784485,
-0.18101827800273895,
-0.31790098547935486,
1.0202016830444336,
0.15861304104328156,
0.2604820430278778,
0.9608619213104248,
0.07791288197040558,
-0.26122045516967773,
-0.6682068705558777,
0.15767894685268402,
0.3161531090736389,
-0.4599553942680359,
-0.39119258522987366,
-0.7939077019691467,
-0.20125307142734528,
-0.40057772397994995,
0.14182543754577637,
-0.5524902939796448,
-0.5418882369995117,
0.0418790839612484,
-0.13984046876430511,
0.014149889349937439,
0.43804892897605896,
-0.18013034760951996,
-0.0875491201877594,
-0.8930807709693909,
0.33503350615501404,
0.1322048306465149,
0.48969751596450806,
0.058294523507356644,
-0.4081588089466095,
-0.507485032081604,
0.18703587353229523,
-0.4170776605606079,
-1.0246495008468628,
0.41111207008361816,
0.5502161979675293,
0.5695153474807739,
0.14502666890621185,
0.0263119675219059,
0.3063189387321472,
-0.3354954421520233,
0.7280539274215698,
0.14965298771858215,
-0.8691514730453491,
0.545052707195282,
-0.2724906802177429,
0.3164917826652527,
0.6270619034767151,
0.6849836707115173,
-0.7274197340011597,
-0.48250147700309753,
-0.7126407027244568,
-1.0637589693069458,
0.6508160829544067,
0.11958801001310349,
0.16398704051971436,
-0.21841277182102203,
0.4668608605861664,
0.4198894500732422,
0.3389417827129364,
-0.966472327709198,
-0.21745772659778595,
-0.4137256145477295,
-0.1353205293416977,
-0.3552553653717041,
-0.3433137536048889,
-0.09140705317258835,
-0.3904789686203003,
1.1259541511535645,
-0.46655651926994324,
0.2608794867992401,
0.11062271893024445,
-0.33303770422935486,
-0.39240822196006775,
0.277980774641037,
0.37946057319641113,
0.3894779682159424,
-0.462162584066391,
0.25072434544563293,
-0.06733380258083344,
-0.4842822551727295,
0.013555336743593216,
0.12165654450654984,
-0.32252705097198486,
-0.3429657220840454,
0.5821789503097534,
0.5054408311843872,
-0.18371641635894775,
-0.49410295486450195,
0.312335729598999,
0.03977937623858452,
-0.0553683340549469,
0.33286264538764954,
0.11458397656679153,
0.09403622150421143,
0.36626750230789185,
0.5484532713890076,
0.42336955666542053,
0.39435580372810364,
-0.458252876996994,
0.4794776141643524,
0.25271886587142944,
-0.7747640609741211,
-0.6974548697471619,
0.33107542991638184,
0.2817128598690033,
-0.062112487852573395,
0.47211018204689026,
-0.3924214243888855,
-0.4922303259372711,
0.43647679686546326,
0.6788926124572754,
0.9811684489250183,
0.05532931908965111,
0.2342657744884491,
0.7296125888824463,
-0.008755506947636604,
0.05032217502593994,
-0.0714646577835083,
-0.09492405503988266,
-0.8413581848144531,
-0.7366197109222412,
-0.8059279918670654,
-0.16470277309417725,
0.6686940789222717,
-0.7359580993652344,
0.5654217600822449,
0.06913203746080399,
-0.09468384087085724,
0.38785454630851746,
0.21736936271190643,
-0.37740856409072876,
0.019606418907642365,
0.3657959997653961,
1.005130648612976,
-1.0413943529129028,
0.9598652124404907,
0.8391623497009277,
-0.49697521328926086,
-0.3611142337322235,
0.08298422396183014,
-0.18565107882022858,
-0.6280401945114136,
0.9200126528739929,
0.5530433058738708,
0.0052641951479017735,
0.2097645103931427,
-0.5990312695503235,
-0.8767845034599304,
0.7364878058433533,
0.48840102553367615,
-0.8323078751564026,
-0.05112049728631973,
-0.030985001474618912,
0.9365648031234741,
-0.30155089497566223,
0.12863041460514069,
0.42953816056251526,
0.07785893976688385,
0.13192838430404663,
-0.29653483629226685,
-0.01488274335861206,
-0.5687873959541321,
-0.28251537680625916,
0.2272607684135437,
-0.55974280834198,
0.6789427399635315,
-0.19012297689914703,
-0.16338607668876648,
-0.1490277647972107,
0.7412006855010986,
0.012990875169634819,
0.006820153910666704,
0.15553122758865356,
0.7140108346939087,
0.7337355017662048,
0.1570330560207367,
1.01516854763031,
-0.41969192028045654,
0.6579051613807678,
1.1451350450515747,
-0.28683051466941833,
0.599822461605072,
0.7345908284187317,
-0.20401492714881897,
0.3200543522834778,
0.31364908814430237,
-0.4767007529735565,
0.5914283394813538,
0.3690517544746399,
0.1684534102678299,
-0.4781675934791565,
-0.29573556780815125,
-0.49978649616241455,
0.37585458159446716,
0.37020668387413025,
-0.3802785873413086,
-0.4351346492767334,
-0.13571274280548096,
-0.39444130659103394,
0.12287821620702744,
-0.42250967025756836,
0.5895072817802429,
0.25358423590660095,
-0.4506896436214447,
0.5774440765380859,
-0.1210346445441246,
0.6261656880378723,
-0.5824308395385742,
-0.27997535467147827,
-0.07102011889219284,
0.39517971873283386,
-0.34747639298439026,
-0.45653945207595825,
0.31463661789894104,
-0.26466402411460876,
-0.5942066311836243,
-0.14439748227596283,
0.7540891170501709,
-0.6453220248222351,
-0.5037532448768616,
0.6567500829696655,
0.38273099064826965,
-0.24635758996009827,
-0.07301773130893707,
-0.6470235586166382,
-0.10561978816986084,
-0.060679174959659576,
0.06917693465948105,
0.26312926411628723,
0.21473431587219238,
0.08403375744819641,
0.6417779326438904,
0.44405096769332886,
0.19828695058822632,
-0.20614983141422272,
0.3605133891105652,
0.8122615814208984,
-0.7125515937805176,
-0.3135852813720703,
-1.162954330444336,
0.3549118936061859,
-0.25165948271751404,
0.14577670395374298,
0.7335352897644043,
0.6597875356674194,
1.012364149093628,
-0.29427921772003174,
0.7972727417945862,
-0.16449786722660065,
0.6212745308876038,
-0.21183672547340393,
0.6636400818824768,
-0.5272161364555359,
0.09535620361566544,
-0.30359381437301636,
-0.8093903660774231,
-0.5627067685127258,
0.45746931433677673,
-0.6262826323509216,
0.049147747457027435,
0.47489964962005615,
0.8715064525604248,
-0.12338527292013168,
0.18300184607505798,
0.07479789853096008,
0.4357394576072693,
0.7570123076438904,
0.7034107446670532,
0.6002777814865112,
-0.8218480348587036,
0.2272740751504898,
-0.2193310409784317,
-0.33108973503112793,
-0.316646009683609,
-1.1359353065490723,
-0.9284098744392395,
-0.56125807762146,
-0.5178073644638062,
-0.3211645185947418,
0.029080571606755257,
1.1344622373580933,
0.989770233631134,
-1.2543730735778809,
-0.22619348764419556,
-0.4154077172279358,
-0.23722803592681885,
-0.42342427372932434,
-0.26551446318626404,
0.24542586505413055,
-0.5839152932167053,
-0.38425183296203613,
0.3748273253440857,
0.47081953287124634,
-0.10876396298408508,
-0.09129994362592697,
0.006794266868382692,
-0.6232264041900635,
-0.08260008692741394,
0.6731759309768677,
0.5453547239303589,
-0.09170912951231003,
-0.1316215991973877,
-0.011996072717010975,
0.06175094097852707,
0.29992184042930603,
0.7801121473312378,
-0.8786215782165527,
0.43464240431785583,
0.5699859261512756,
0.7238231301307678,
0.6325381398200989,
-0.17909599840641022,
0.982768714427948,
-0.9595550298690796,
0.11485200375318527,
0.4194985330104828,
0.18405801057815552,
0.702129065990448,
-0.22293664515018463,
0.4011942446231842,
0.2904304563999176,
-0.3143472373485565,
-0.7788707613945007,
0.3496295213699341,
-0.8323991298675537,
-0.09654073417186737,
0.7707343101501465,
0.22481074929237366,
-0.34471458196640015,
0.00740284938365221,
0.09927815943956375,
0.38672009110450745,
-0.4075388014316559,
1.27815842628479,
0.6610381603240967,
-0.17315752804279327,
-0.014731237664818764,
-0.28394845128059387,
0.722197949886322,
0.3979111611843109,
-0.6200867891311646,
0.3068292737007141,
0.10582615435123444,
0.09394913166761398,
0.6403924226760864,
0.391092449426651,
-0.2916244864463806,
0.23708778619766235,
-0.03368804603815079,
0.12584342062473297,
-0.09989668428897858,
-0.2888038456439972,
-0.5686395168304443,
0.44757822155952454,
0.003913103137165308,
0.3233603835105896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17900v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17900v1
|
Enhancing Emotion Recognition in Conversation through Emotional Cross-Modal Fusion and Inter-class Contrastive Learning
| 2024-05-28T07:22:30 | 2024-05-28T07:22:30 |
Haoxiang Shi, Xulong Zhang, Ning Cheng, Yong Zhang, Jun Yu, Jing Xiao, Jianzong Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The purpose of emotion recognition in conversation (ERC) is to identify the
emotion category of an utterance based on contextual information. Previous ERC
methods relied on simple connections for cross-modal fusion and ignored the
information differences between modalities, resulting in the model being unable
to focus on modality-specific emotional information. At the same time, the
shared information between modalities was not processed to generate emotions.
Information redundancy problem. To overcome these limitations, we propose a
cross-modal fusion emotion prediction network based on vector connections. The
network mainly includes two stages: the multi-modal feature fusion stage based
on connection vectors and the emotion classification stage based on fused
features. Furthermore, we design a supervised inter-class contrastive learning
module based on emotion labels. Experimental results confirm the effectiveness
of the proposed method, demonstrating excellent performance on the IEMOCAP and
MELD datasets.
|
[
-0.8460443019866943,
-0.4384056031703949,
0.08553528040647507,
-0.013425190933048725,
-0.329264760017395,
-0.07234936207532883,
-0.01901508867740631,
-0.7169970870018005,
0.5760791301727295,
-0.0549522265791893,
-0.8043855428695679,
-0.34517377614974976,
-0.30641382932662964,
0.1716199517250061,
-0.1696852594614029,
0.7631248235702515,
0.018287252634763718,
0.16486552357673645,
-0.2889443635940552,
-0.4348190724849701,
-0.4940856397151947,
-0.4591878652572632,
-0.6591333746910095,
-0.43547323346138,
0.6096420288085938,
0.6135849356651306,
0.22965247929096222,
0.1455012857913971,
0.2108851820230484,
0.42413562536239624,
0.01942816935479641,
0.28930211067199707,
-0.6353498697280884,
0.34838902950286865,
0.05930488556623459,
-0.3500387966632843,
-0.31610003113746643,
-0.02451387047767639,
0.28364863991737366,
0.17318400740623474,
-0.059582605957984924,
-0.4878099858760834,
0.13721966743469238,
0.6594241261482239,
-0.662285566329956,
0.28041449189186096,
-0.5183174014091492,
0.524744987487793,
-0.014397401362657547,
-0.44035273790359497,
-0.3684038817882538,
0.01825726591050625,
0.4025634229183197,
-0.2399478256702423,
0.006681220140308142,
0.41346874833106995,
0.8208895921707153,
-0.00578507361933589,
-0.5918359160423279,
-0.035890575498342514,
-0.6741447448730469,
0.5047510862350464,
-0.35634055733680725,
0.5588520765304565,
0.5102655291557312,
0.3804400563240051,
0.20959948003292084,
-0.3417757451534271,
-0.712815523147583,
0.12084311991930008,
-0.09193910658359528,
0.5942179560661316,
-0.4351693093776703,
0.35181725025177,
-0.04095083102583885,
0.2016499638557434,
-0.4654800593852997,
0.08430340886116028,
-0.47673723101615906,
-0.10337018966674805,
0.3799208104610443,
0.48621290922164917,
0.2944294214248657,
-0.2059822380542755,
-0.6021119952201843,
-0.0914052203297615,
-0.34177324175834656,
0.05670641362667084,
0.17827437818050385,
0.2955763339996338,
-0.37958604097366333,
0.39034220576286316,
-0.2236447036266327,
0.39874473214149475,
0.15094980597496033,
0.2394486367702484,
0.4783082604408264,
-0.055841874331235886,
-0.4237043559551239,
0.2918829321861267,
0.8036041259765625,
0.46761372685432434,
-0.16501128673553467,
0.15386418998241425,
0.08024284243583679,
0.24125367403030396,
0.15117768943309784,
-0.5942802429199219,
-0.2023993581533432,
0.27606913447380066,
-0.5520987510681152,
-0.171977236866951,
0.1341404765844345,
-1.062887191772461,
-0.2722342014312744,
-0.2777319848537445,
0.4606173634529114,
-0.4762377142906189,
-0.2595332860946655,
-0.24413296580314636,
0.13003288209438324,
0.12206072360277176,
0.3771730363368988,
-0.8316017985343933,
0.16076263785362244,
0.4070318341255188,
0.6772788166999817,
-0.03443525359034538,
-0.23359523713588715,
-0.16549482941627502,
-0.0826796442270279,
0.13254337012767792,
0.7386726140975952,
-0.9637724161148071,
-0.43847405910491943,
0.13760697841644287,
0.12397488206624985,
-0.12783725559711456,
-0.40685752034187317,
0.5056834816932678,
-0.3133282959461212,
0.45176202058792114,
-0.2677804231643677,
-0.3726782202720642,
-0.48392438888549805,
0.30440378189086914,
-0.5798467993736267,
0.7673045992851257,
-0.042984191328287125,
-0.9885472059249878,
0.1359357386827469,
-0.35792025923728943,
-0.5246801972389221,
0.007999197579920292,
-0.1719774454832077,
-0.49319425225257874,
-0.019363703206181526,
0.06372968852519989,
0.7215387225151062,
-0.381325364112854,
-0.19069887697696686,
-0.5323095917701721,
-0.22387903928756714,
0.31896698474884033,
-0.26959943771362305,
0.014664571732282639,
0.34380003809928894,
-0.2777097821235657,
0.3073421120643616,
-0.784986138343811,
-0.18009808659553528,
-0.2509153187274933,
-0.16383549571037292,
-0.4827256500720978,
-0.17570757865905762,
-0.18560191988945007,
0.5929733514785767,
-0.32725757360458374,
-0.521651566028595,
-0.39082396030426025,
-0.18196988105773926,
0.10376804322004318,
0.8930197954177856,
-0.1992848515510559,
0.2916116416454315,
-0.12893201410770416,
0.6830223798751831,
0.5603510141372681,
0.06326442956924438,
-0.276883065700531,
-0.4297827482223511,
-1.1829503774642944,
-0.15167267620563507,
-0.0015950306551530957,
0.599545419216156,
-0.9495863318443298,
0.581260621547699,
0.24451814591884613,
-0.556814968585968,
-0.45516467094421387,
-0.4316795766353607,
0.5884190201759338,
0.7663376927375793,
0.38988977670669556,
-0.37955397367477417,
-0.8465660214424133,
-0.8340548276901245,
-0.017983071506023407,
-0.2593681514263153,
0.10638080537319183,
0.9434805512428284,
0.13963457942008972,
-0.22251565754413605,
0.5406509637832642,
-0.20375263690948486,
-0.4197881817817688,
-0.17215964198112488,
0.5436058640480042,
-0.38700926303863525,
0.3970998227596283,
0.14796528220176697,
-0.8907340168952942,
-0.5779087543487549,
0.2716202735900879,
-0.6695661544799805,
-0.1773269921541214,
0.011983298696577549,
-0.3102279603481293,
0.3100045919418335,
0.5041762590408325,
-0.020446652546525,
0.5150071382522583,
0.8396090269088745,
-0.46995532512664795,
-0.07423701882362366,
0.001136932522058487,
0.5998384952545166,
-1.179672122001648,
-0.2505176067352295,
0.34072133898735046,
-0.11480077356100082,
-0.7346387505531311,
-1.0973869562149048,
0.025069518014788628,
-0.2538038492202759,
-0.6093133091926575,
0.13969914615154266,
-0.32111606001853943,
-0.13944262266159058,
-0.0823417454957962,
0.18053078651428223,
-0.027902601286768913,
0.7417492866516113,
0.09704754501581192,
0.34696945548057556,
0.6076585054397583,
-0.4561120271682739,
0.6630783677101135,
0.3412489891052246,
-0.0765954926609993,
1.0505331754684448,
-0.28695815801620483,
0.045163583010435104,
-0.3179379105567932,
0.4346104562282562,
-1.1854808330535889,
-0.196525439620018,
0.32922956347465515,
-0.43842780590057373,
0.4008091390132904,
0.14493298530578613,
0.3607963025569916,
-0.04328747093677521,
-0.019061490893363953,
0.5348370671272278,
0.3245628774166107,
-0.6403889656066895,
1.2770934104919434,
0.35118645429611206,
-0.25313711166381836,
-0.45028361678123474,
-0.7587130069732666,
-0.1794012188911438,
-0.23352091014385223,
-0.7842482924461365,
0.17090871930122375,
0.12361499667167664,
0.20208905637264252,
0.002186188939958811,
0.11318206042051315,
0.05728992074728012,
-0.2944064736366272,
0.79191654920578,
0.4405992925167084,
0.12234684079885483,
0.6790317893028259,
0.06397125869989395,
-0.07723241299390793,
0.03544525057077408,
0.49646273255348206,
0.5658319592475891,
-0.29900825023651123,
-0.3471623659133911,
-0.5359830260276794,
0.6132058501243591,
0.5283936262130737,
-0.21366803348064423,
0.7427255511283875,
0.836007297039032,
-0.42674532532691956,
-0.16709239780902863,
-0.510688066482544,
-0.3321414589881897,
-0.44631174206733704,
0.5761253833770752,
-0.3881117105484009,
-0.9844070672988892,
0.6125794649124146,
-0.37348395586013794,
-0.3318041265010834,
0.40364640951156616,
0.4944911599159241,
-0.2090749442577362,
1.0475088357925415,
0.563238799571991,
-0.03153808414936066,
0.8945029973983765,
0.05897151678800583,
0.2037280648946762,
-0.9285371899604797,
-0.7668463587760925,
-0.40172839164733887,
-0.727555513381958,
-0.29272839426994324,
-0.4262978434562683,
0.40360355377197266,
-0.181327685713768,
-0.10488586872816086,
0.1284460574388504,
-0.22117862105369568,
0.2997300624847412,
0.32492315769195557,
0.28771767020225525,
-0.030640093609690666,
0.03185143321752548,
0.00400958675891161,
-0.2411523312330246,
-0.6105167269706726,
0.11802633106708527,
0.5092504024505615,
0.40447327494621277,
0.8259348273277283,
-0.0802212804555893,
0.5721983313560486,
0.0773213729262352,
0.3216088116168976,
-0.7420240640640259,
0.7063177824020386,
0.01964598335325718,
-0.23809629678726196,
-0.019122514873743057,
-0.6579811573028564,
-0.7726132869720459,
0.33483171463012695,
-0.7698186635971069,
-0.7397506833076477,
0.530401349067688,
0.027504218742251396,
-0.11861271411180496,
0.2650982439517975,
-0.7671729922294617,
0.6710606813430786,
-0.0752774029970169,
-0.19526508450508118,
-0.4992617666721344,
-0.899699330329895,
0.3008377254009247,
0.053159113973379135,
-0.0406670980155468,
-0.1880754679441452,
0.18699301779270172,
0.7768751978874207,
-0.4514158070087433,
0.8611953854560852,
0.25396332144737244,
0.2491169273853302,
0.20530396699905396,
0.02827746793627739,
0.4716411232948303,
-0.28576961159706116,
-0.03401303291320801,
0.11857643723487854,
-0.5988283753395081,
0.06807127594947815,
-0.5946078300476074,
0.624229907989502,
-0.7093418836593628,
-0.10939145088195801,
-0.2521854639053345,
-0.4126538336277008,
-0.532403826713562,
-0.40565988421440125,
0.27531781792640686,
0.4850849509239197,
-0.3756067752838135,
0.17590241134166718,
0.7273768186569214,
-0.2664835453033447,
0.41872432827949524,
0.4045359194278717,
0.112610824406147,
-0.6041368246078491,
1.0660415887832642,
-0.22977294027805328,
0.3776112198829651,
0.39407551288604736,
0.1950157880783081,
-0.08143188804388046,
0.2527094781398773,
0.021214790642261505,
-0.006020368542522192,
-0.8429548740386963,
-0.4878009557723999,
-0.8293266296386719,
-0.03497857600450516,
-0.27460938692092896,
-0.25504228472709656,
-0.2594124674797058,
-0.057004235684871674,
-0.6244031190872192,
-0.1567579060792923,
0.5137417316436768,
0.5190329551696777,
-0.2811741232872009,
0.08043753355741501,
-0.9719784259796143,
0.18942682445049286,
0.7328771948814392,
0.42314091324806213,
0.0995921790599823,
-0.4939768612384796,
-0.20093363523483276,
-0.16180358827114105,
-0.2243902087211609,
-0.793476939201355,
0.6547260284423828,
0.41970446705818176,
0.11457337439060211,
0.7406856417655945,
0.3018634021282196,
0.5223747491836548,
-0.16065022349357605,
0.3979409337043762,
0.8143922090530396,
-1.1388696432113647,
0.4911799728870392,
-0.010021894238889217,
0.01512497290968895,
0.21452096104621887,
0.6645638346672058,
-0.8052040338516235,
0.012968162074685097,
-0.5852336883544922,
-0.8556779623031616,
0.9229769706726074,
0.04413526505231857,
-0.14543049037456512,
-0.03728437423706055,
-0.18233592808246613,
0.0247868150472641,
0.06846388429403305,
-0.42907026410102844,
-0.34158843755722046,
-0.12879066169261932,
-0.44779813289642334,
0.20176838338375092,
-0.3507446348667145,
-0.21850937604904175,
-0.08457391709089279,
0.6648203730583191,
-0.09034069627523422,
0.4206196963787079,
0.244008406996727,
0.3548337519168854,
-0.5212202072143555,
0.250911146402359,
0.5822752714157104,
-0.08482109010219574,
-0.15220144391059875,
0.06695792824029922,
0.46480897068977356,
-0.197955921292305,
-0.12454308569431305,
0.11104045808315277,
0.6068088412284851,
-0.136384516954422,
-0.11304847151041031,
1.3992925882339478,
0.07442967593669891,
-0.5351614952087402,
0.48598700761795044,
-0.36290082335472107,
-0.032969363033771515,
0.011276005767285824,
-0.3013465106487274,
0.007829143665730953,
0.867259681224823,
-0.06956999003887177,
0.13205954432487488,
0.18415915966033936,
-0.7718469500541687,
0.20693331956863403,
0.19077496230602264,
-0.8399938941001892,
-0.33998048305511475,
0.39591166377067566,
0.8066242337226868,
-0.16874249279499054,
0.48634740710258484,
0.26024726033210754,
-0.8914348483085632,
0.4349738657474518,
0.4079829752445221,
1.023028016090393,
-0.5841463804244995,
0.13266289234161377,
0.18275366723537445,
-0.16371768712997437,
0.2792152464389801,
0.5873896479606628,
-0.08042510598897934,
-0.7005362510681152,
0.012708907946944237,
-0.16975419223308563,
-0.7006668448448181,
-0.33701011538505554,
-0.5056057572364807,
0.4006741940975189,
-0.3412335515022278,
-0.11064738780260086,
-0.3751247227191925,
-0.3829403221607208,
-0.7131715416908264,
0.4178186058998108,
0.47877469658851624,
0.40167370438575745,
-1.192853331565857,
0.5356307625770569,
0.5872081518173218,
-0.4294682741165161,
-0.9510512948036194,
-0.5278952717781067,
0.12080689519643784,
-0.5596701502799988,
0.7697697877883911,
0.2962186932563782,
-0.22698555886745453,
-0.28640612959861755,
-0.15242458879947662,
-0.37332314252853394,
1.1261253356933594,
0.06545232236385345,
-0.5858374238014221,
0.3420826196670532,
0.026465609669685364,
0.316263884305954,
-0.7396658062934875,
0.5926288962364197,
0.13523870706558228,
0.2128215879201889,
0.5479766726493835,
-0.8000321984291077,
-0.06150490790605545,
-0.29396653175354004,
-0.03201684355735779,
0.27003467082977295,
-0.7474550008773804,
0.9324303865432739,
0.027206599712371826,
-0.3913423717021942,
-0.48092514276504517,
0.9887909293174744,
0.013422688469290733,
0.36648061871528625,
0.6789681911468506,
0.6217835545539856,
0.6130514740943909,
-0.20162856578826904,
0.60089510679245,
-0.19749395549297333,
0.2581854462623596,
0.9397199153900146,
-0.3401680886745453,
0.9458916187286377,
0.3378426432609558,
0.014291975647211075,
0.5892788767814636,
0.6215153336524963,
0.15115171670913696,
0.3534739017486572,
0.10361935198307037,
-0.7185608744621277,
-0.4382352828979492,
-0.5014728903770447,
-0.4690391421318054,
0.46436232328414917,
0.46528300642967224,
-0.5759567022323608,
0.012178284116089344,
0.3968816101551056,
-0.2803953289985657,
-0.3758242428302765,
-0.3839524984359741,
0.9063586592674255,
0.1357262134552002,
-0.27774491906166077,
0.4002954959869385,
-0.3642273545265198,
0.7861119508743286,
-0.4887929856777191,
-0.23673954606056213,
-0.21906115114688873,
0.06948119401931763,
-0.6049624681472778,
-0.6311135292053223,
0.03559286519885063,
-0.26059314608573914,
0.060646720230579376,
0.11506548523902893,
0.9848999977111816,
-0.9811594486236572,
0.03794415295124054,
0.43880710005760193,
0.27403587102890015,
0.13817211985588074,
0.10680408775806427,
-0.4352976381778717,
0.418231725692749,
-0.09012768417596817,
-0.23605750501155853,
0.5246079564094543,
0.8423638939857483,
0.5056778788566589,
0.6532506346702576,
0.19593960046768188,
-0.3056012988090515,
-0.192674458026886,
0.10979277640581131,
1.1159307956695557,
-0.7514485716819763,
-0.6055017113685608,
-0.5086480379104614,
0.6986888647079468,
-0.05098428949713707,
-0.3434997797012329,
0.2744620144367218,
0.14342227578163147,
0.7573591470718384,
0.04736853390932083,
0.6646959185600281,
-0.02924594096839428,
0.36608001589775085,
-0.33850938081741333,
0.3795206546783447,
-0.6424264311790466,
-0.011801612563431263,
-0.41645145416259766,
-0.7474867105484009,
-0.13332074880599976,
0.6332505345344543,
0.13341045379638672,
0.13339565694332123,
0.7838476896286011,
0.6974856853485107,
-0.006752739194780588,
0.5795866250991821,
0.6537160873413086,
0.1263258010149002,
0.18032188713550568,
0.8620399236679077,
0.8427795767784119,
-0.39708399772644043,
0.6893429756164551,
-0.41548576951026917,
-0.22460633516311646,
-0.5549022555351257,
-0.8504200577735901,
-0.985226035118103,
-0.8689300417900085,
-0.36043107509613037,
-0.6749952435493469,
-0.12304522842168808,
1.1304090023040771,
0.5018386244773865,
-0.6266035437583923,
-0.03420490026473999,
0.05387275665998459,
-0.11372624337673187,
0.07829371094703674,
-0.21900394558906555,
0.13447822630405426,
-0.011749115772545338,
-0.741144061088562,
0.41117092967033386,
0.63020259141922,
0.24248838424682617,
-0.1565198004245758,
-0.2372119128704071,
-0.23461320996284485,
0.20391583442687988,
0.6000964045524597,
0.5166511535644531,
-0.4247279167175293,
-0.3737722933292389,
-0.4794304668903351,
-0.16332779824733734,
0.28610897064208984,
0.8697160482406616,
-0.7922337651252747,
0.7742420434951782,
0.8115258812904358,
0.7104514837265015,
0.2747265100479126,
-0.02058066986501217,
0.7790487408638,
-0.5451770424842834,
0.11114712059497833,
0.31368768215179443,
0.7148677110671997,
0.22280968725681305,
-0.14512962102890015,
0.3211928606033325,
0.19825704395771027,
-0.5518189668655396,
-0.4509624242782593,
0.4673410654067993,
-1.274165391921997,
0.1232161596417427,
0.895880937576294,
-0.38691431283950806,
-0.21039259433746338,
-0.17309437692165375,
-0.5201917886734009,
0.4264555871486664,
-0.7752947211265564,
0.6423753499984741,
0.4065878689289093,
-0.4307206869125366,
-0.4973481297492981,
0.11440747231245041,
0.1962793618440628,
0.6359390616416931,
-1.0365813970565796,
0.14603056013584137,
0.6070159077644348,
-0.26279720664024353,
0.00799636822193861,
0.23287393152713776,
0.041265569627285004,
0.03767169266939163,
0.012680904008448124,
0.3429141640663147,
-0.03068506345152855,
-0.2881138324737549,
-0.5398703813552856,
0.17864669859409332,
-0.5714230537414551,
-0.24635452032089233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17893v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17893v1
|
Arithmetic Reasoning with LLM: Prolog Generation & Permutation
| 2024-05-28T07:13:25 | 2024-05-28T07:13:25 |
Xiaocheng Yang, Bingsen Chen, Yik-Cheung Tam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Instructing large language models (LLMs) to solve elementary school math
problems has shown great success using Chain of Thought (CoT). However, the CoT
approach relies on an LLM to generate a sequence of arithmetic calculations
which can be prone to cascaded calculation errors. We hypothesize that an LLM
should focus on extracting predicates and generating symbolic formulas from the
math problem description so that the underlying calculation can be done via an
external code interpreter. We investigate using LLM to generate Prolog programs
to solve mathematical questions. Experimental results show that our
Prolog-based arithmetic problem-solving outperforms CoT generation in the GSM8K
benchmark across three distinct LLMs. In addition, given the insensitive
ordering of predicates and symbolic formulas in Prolog, we propose to permute
the ground truth predicates for more robust LLM training via data augmentation.
|
[
-0.24691079556941986,
-0.8905916810035706,
0.8926389813423157,
0.2695786952972412,
-0.2502777576446533,
0.24129106104373932,
0.08861544728279114,
-0.3759983479976654,
-0.19956547021865845,
0.6960365176200867,
-0.6839017271995544,
-0.5473427772521973,
-0.553297758102417,
0.3165852129459381,
-0.20106755197048187,
0.5031383037567139,
-0.043927207589149475,
0.3288326859474182,
-0.4611234962940216,
0.01521896943449974,
-0.1806725263595581,
-1.0047906637191772,
-0.5348297953605652,
-0.38071438670158386,
-0.09041345119476318,
0.5751932859420776,
0.8041204810142517,
0.39795008301734924,
0.7566304206848145,
0.33082571625709534,
0.1670631319284439,
0.5856007933616638,
-0.35659468173980713,
-0.11261990666389465,
0.02703242003917694,
-0.7740292549133301,
-0.6472247838973999,
-0.21355769038200378,
0.6624301671981812,
0.7167755961418152,
-0.14448347687721252,
0.2706204950809479,
-0.49434369802474976,
0.8034374117851257,
-0.5570033192634583,
0.2545650899410248,
-0.729386568069458,
0.017760438844561577,
-0.17652100324630737,
0.004005521070212126,
-0.3926514685153961,
-0.6302492618560791,
-0.4185073673725128,
-0.6138154864311218,
-0.09577809274196625,
0.23578420281410217,
0.33074119687080383,
0.20928522944450378,
-0.244393989443779,
-0.5599286556243896,
-0.6924454569816589,
0.7363294959068298,
-0.8617986440658569,
0.3016877770423889,
0.4660091996192932,
0.1747133433818817,
-0.5748472809791565,
-0.6113189458847046,
-0.6844498515129089,
-0.031052617356181145,
0.05697481334209442,
-0.053019244223833084,
-0.007149650249630213,
0.03428094461560249,
0.49731454253196716,
0.5414518117904663,
-0.4462018311023712,
-0.10097454488277435,
-0.14784008264541626,
0.15993733704090118,
0.7461358904838562,
0.5839542150497437,
0.23770689964294434,
0.14074693620204926,
-0.1385587900876999,
0.12242477387189865,
-1.3053193092346191,
-0.04361952096223831,
0.5885069370269775,
-0.12181265652179718,
0.3059590756893158,
0.7161093950271606,
-0.04284454137086868,
0.7149041891098022,
0.14469949901103973,
-0.2687573730945587,
0.14138329029083252,
-0.21322311460971832,
-0.2599608302116394,
0.2167002409696579,
0.6878609657287598,
0.018694445490837097,
0.4021106958389282,
0.012235722504556179,
-0.34578466415405273,
0.15453611314296722,
0.14295822381973267,
-0.7021765112876892,
-0.27496764063835144,
0.0040364195592701435,
0.04997507855296135,
-0.36277827620506287,
0.03819434344768524,
-0.22634504735469818,
0.1232202798128128,
-0.4670274257659912,
0.38763999938964844,
-0.4274473488330841,
0.010959677398204803,
0.3097085952758789,
0.39164265990257263,
-0.09938039630651474,
0.14834769070148468,
-0.8537338972091675,
0.5042866468429565,
0.8884128332138062,
0.34346359968185425,
0.11914869397878647,
0.021146608516573906,
-0.7131345272064209,
0.08951624482870102,
-0.6620053052902222,
0.7261725068092346,
-0.6926025748252869,
-0.4375636875629425,
-0.2441844791173935,
-0.25560635328292847,
-0.009786268696188927,
-0.9092345237731934,
0.344731867313385,
-0.5571108460426331,
0.12186488509178162,
-0.17009234428405762,
-0.7141390442848206,
-0.04578392952680588,
0.2293984740972519,
-0.4869656264781952,
0.9536377191543579,
0.1016228124499321,
-0.45765408873558044,
-0.31256169080734253,
-0.36250439286231995,
-0.35982412099838257,
0.1667281538248062,
-0.49768534302711487,
-0.3492494523525238,
0.39613762497901917,
0.31975072622299194,
-0.03532122075557709,
-0.5615062713623047,
0.37840449810028076,
-0.06634452193975449,
-0.3928265869617462,
0.39643681049346924,
-0.29276329278945923,
0.8219050168991089,
0.14943315088748932,
-0.18218550086021423,
-0.015812452882528305,
-0.7988240718841553,
0.15331490337848663,
0.2769058346748352,
-0.25132325291633606,
-0.13222721219062805,
0.21090957522392273,
-0.8773321509361267,
0.1407719850540161,
0.2269134372472763,
-0.25025475025177,
0.1392514556646347,
-0.5178831219673157,
0.15336494147777557,
0.8107594847679138,
-0.030163930729031563,
0.26589253544807434,
-0.20850662887096405,
0.5388175845146179,
-0.08308427035808563,
0.05044551566243172,
-0.07708378881216049,
-0.3773069977760315,
-0.7527881264686584,
-0.008850274607539177,
0.071054607629776,
0.6528609395027161,
-0.8389449715614319,
0.41781309247016907,
0.13987421989440918,
-0.1120280772447586,
-0.2874828279018402,
0.25811582803726196,
0.5959793925285339,
0.732934296131134,
0.34143927693367004,
-0.19229353964328766,
-0.5478213429450989,
-0.5001553893089294,
-0.2690909206867218,
-0.20798201858997345,
-0.004259273409843445,
0.08286936581134796,
0.2601415812969208,
0.055591873824596405,
0.6998984813690186,
-0.7311354279518127,
-0.1286994367837906,
-0.27309513092041016,
-0.006029949057847261,
0.41233667731285095,
0.33470475673675537,
0.08639799058437347,
-0.6363939642906189,
-0.29195278882980347,
-0.3867030739784241,
-0.987308919429779,
-0.3362289071083069,
0.12532074749469757,
-0.37137752771377563,
0.016126614063978195,
0.376525342464447,
-0.7274042367935181,
0.5222844481468201,
0.2583649456501007,
-0.24270445108413696,
0.9973918795585632,
-0.07328864932060242,
-0.2067045122385025,
-0.6701046824455261,
-0.40619829297065735,
-0.3358134627342224,
-0.39027637243270874,
-0.4783685505390167,
0.22778978943824768,
-0.09982258081436157,
-0.15147298574447632,
-0.5060648322105408,
0.07942187041044235,
-0.3961832523345947,
-0.2908162772655487,
-0.14025463163852692,
0.051654152572155,
0.00767604261636734,
0.26440417766571045,
-0.015250982716679573,
0.9067380428314209,
0.3511655032634735,
-0.6125115156173706,
0.48799192905426025,
0.14029569923877716,
-0.4396519064903259,
0.3321874141693115,
-0.3922823369503021,
0.3912794888019562,
0.02598394826054573,
0.21667048335075378,
-0.7030302882194519,
0.017726173624396324,
0.24005597829818726,
-0.28269776701927185,
0.022705262526869774,
0.14746403694152832,
-0.7271825671195984,
-0.33758434653282166,
-0.2527845501899719,
0.5566186904907227,
0.770213782787323,
-0.40897226333618164,
0.6477811336517334,
0.2549319565296173,
-0.18032540380954742,
-0.5119660496711731,
-0.29680296778678894,
-0.18489255011081696,
-0.07104327529668808,
-0.6861832737922668,
0.26551005244255066,
-0.059172123670578,
-0.7700386047363281,
0.17849932610988617,
-0.4451900124549866,
0.22551873326301575,
0.017000459134578705,
0.05531907081604004,
0.4049605131149292,
-0.33584392070770264,
0.1517229676246643,
-0.06885047256946564,
-0.40769800543785095,
0.46801242232322693,
-0.5265632271766663,
0.6818881630897522,
-0.3475691080093384,
-0.5943182706832886,
-0.029147418215870857,
0.2625525891780853,
0.20792827010154724,
-0.23619946837425232,
0.5388833284378052,
0.17896659672260284,
-0.36835089325904846,
-0.16756004095077515,
-0.3785732090473175,
0.05681740120053291,
-0.48608994483947754,
0.22304263710975647,
-0.5161022543907166,
-0.6084539294242859,
0.3561079800128937,
-0.44505172967910767,
0.1157790869474411,
0.3131762742996216,
0.6456945538520813,
-0.17365944385528564,
1.1424320936203003,
0.29725348949432373,
0.2994750142097473,
0.3083159327507019,
-0.3365185558795929,
0.3753760755062103,
-0.7552115321159363,
-0.12270558625459671,
-0.22672688961029053,
-0.17983850836753845,
-0.20924746990203857,
-0.48668235540390015,
0.48709753155708313,
0.5240036249160767,
-0.44890332221984863,
0.1724611520767212,
-0.24468189477920532,
0.9528495073318481,
0.5294917225837708,
0.14878611266613007,
0.582632303237915,
0.23133698105812073,
-0.2563306987285614,
0.08554308861494064,
-0.6138216257095337,
-0.6792768239974976,
1.1500647068023682,
-0.08688449114561081,
0.8949090838432312,
0.22569505870342255,
0.8112215995788574,
-0.07263285666704178,
0.5288618803024292,
-0.5524548292160034,
0.9080514311790466,
-0.5953364372253418,
-0.4376007616519928,
-0.16164828836917877,
-0.6830094456672668,
-0.5560181736946106,
0.27809154987335205,
-0.10220266878604889,
-0.7315035462379456,
-0.26613301038742065,
0.2092185914516449,
-0.15675035119056702,
0.25840166211128235,
-0.5898606181144714,
0.5172131061553955,
-0.6247479915618896,
-0.29329371452331543,
-0.2936401665210724,
-0.43179720640182495,
0.6628987789154053,
-0.17316193878650665,
0.4832659959793091,
-0.2813183665275574,
0.20069432258605957,
0.4653594493865967,
-1.1007754802703857,
0.5892297625541687,
0.14341285824775696,
-0.23234675824642181,
0.7146780490875244,
0.45761728286743164,
0.6744505763053894,
0.18398430943489075,
-0.0723678469657898,
0.017396511510014534,
-0.3857068121433258,
-0.2918106019496918,
-0.741889476776123,
0.5927556753158569,
-0.7329478859901428,
-1.1247135400772095,
-0.26182201504707336,
-0.7264617681503296,
-0.37125059962272644,
0.06649868190288544,
0.15696358680725098,
0.6355096101760864,
0.4461606442928314,
-0.10476084053516388,
0.6214231252670288,
-0.0781070664525032,
0.2652091085910797,
0.401276558637619,
-0.5016972422599792,
-0.7714746594429016,
0.9547405242919922,
0.15993262827396393,
0.5400290489196777,
0.3857215642929077,
0.19126321375370026,
-0.4480641782283783,
-0.26465940475463867,
-0.44113636016845703,
0.14411994814872742,
-0.9991529583930969,
-0.35164859890937805,
-0.3096708357334137,
-0.27471238374710083,
-0.20178359746932983,
-0.15056376159191132,
-0.25216004252433777,
-0.7701928615570068,
-0.09746874123811722,
-0.19079536199569702,
0.14573203027248383,
0.6343600749969482,
0.1316329389810562,
0.3270661532878876,
-0.7377513647079468,
0.5861169099807739,
0.425049751996994,
-0.014659606851637363,
-0.15208369493484497,
-0.29605674743652344,
-0.046826258301734924,
0.06145789846777916,
-0.6224596500396729,
-0.7384371757507324,
0.23590171337127686,
-0.012725641019642353,
0.3658878803253174,
0.14368672668933868,
0.050685860216617584,
0.8355767726898193,
-0.5994583964347839,
0.595538318157196,
0.47052502632141113,
-1.0294241905212402,
0.3163200616836548,
0.2664322555065155,
0.19475094974040985,
0.20736904442310333,
0.3898787200450897,
0.09805472195148468,
-0.44550445675849915,
-0.7333476543426514,
-0.745568573474884,
0.45536211133003235,
0.3563692569732666,
-0.08132640272378922,
-0.20034746825695038,
0.35427331924438477,
0.06299799680709839,
0.26503193378448486,
-0.4909425377845764,
-0.26752758026123047,
-0.030437858775258064,
-0.5779946446418762,
-0.05613512173295021,
-0.19426216185092926,
-0.07119469344615936,
-0.25706949830055237,
0.4761408269405365,
0.0095432810485363,
0.14093877375125885,
0.08070077747106552,
-0.32950451970100403,
-0.3387313783168793,
0.15905502438545227,
0.5156590342521667,
1.0412052869796753,
-0.022639203816652298,
0.667406439781189,
0.2926265597343445,
-0.5326241254806519,
0.4382433295249939,
-0.1556912660598755,
-0.21326319873332977,
-0.06590786576271057,
0.5524604916572571,
0.5020627379417419,
0.09392696619033813,
-0.8046805262565613,
0.07954742759466171,
0.05688301846385002,
-0.3749581277370453,
-0.38508087396621704,
0.30227941274642944,
0.3173235356807709,
0.17440277338027954,
0.5077224373817444,
-0.19056755304336548,
-0.12273388355970383,
-0.5881370902061462,
0.06204995512962341,
0.38145706057548523,
0.36835408210754395,
-0.4270499646663666,
0.6339647769927979,
0.07308214902877808,
-0.717693030834198,
0.8815490007400513,
-0.20009225606918335,
-0.7222607135772705,
0.8221704363822937,
1.119369626045227,
0.6320703029632568,
-0.16830098628997803,
-0.07759882509708405,
0.07920260727405548,
0.19975966215133667,
-0.06195390596985817,
0.5279755592346191,
-0.07052953541278839,
-0.8346656560897827,
-0.7184410095214844,
-0.6378327012062073,
-0.6095513701438904,
0.024241821840405464,
-0.2474125772714615,
0.17627938091754913,
-0.7197733521461487,
-0.04886592552065849,
-0.19039610028266907,
0.027397682890295982,
-0.4943513572216034,
0.20037168264389038,
0.274614542722702,
0.594789445400238,
-0.596053421497345,
0.6784907579421997,
0.793569028377533,
-0.3088461756706238,
-1.0937765836715698,
-0.149396613240242,
-0.1616407185792923,
-1.0114096403121948,
0.8876967430114746,
0.16586846113204956,
-0.369883269071579,
0.25667276978492737,
-0.6116650104522705,
-0.6252200603485107,
1.0232099294662476,
0.7043891549110413,
-0.9007840156555176,
0.022936750203371048,
0.42429736256599426,
0.2843177318572998,
-0.6054942607879639,
0.1960853487253189,
0.4809541702270508,
0.17514030635356903,
0.3886214792728424,
-0.6101350784301758,
0.029261944815516472,
0.02494487166404724,
-0.15091127157211304,
0.48134610056877136,
-0.49049004912376404,
1.0720854997634888,
-0.3522826135158539,
0.008566176518797874,
-0.30098220705986023,
0.5070889592170715,
0.7920482158660889,
0.5177148580551147,
0.39244383573532104,
0.9259188771247864,
0.7261087894439697,
0.07212374359369278,
0.8344042301177979,
-0.2989829480648041,
0.11164847761392593,
1.1658726930618286,
-0.44801071286201477,
0.6167858839035034,
0.31550654768943787,
-0.6302272081375122,
0.6369513273239136,
0.4363483786582947,
0.496745765209198,
0.22972580790519714,
0.39102309942245483,
-0.6432691812515259,
-0.5940948128700256,
0.34332868456840515,
-0.37034833431243896,
0.03378240019083023,
0.6500216126441956,
-0.19663333892822266,
-0.21910151839256287,
-0.47049352526664734,
0.005149385891854763,
0.025117769837379456,
-0.5152385234832764,
0.7465886473655701,
0.5442603826522827,
-0.5019580721855164,
0.6619839668273926,
-0.04607578366994858,
0.0635114312171936,
-0.4198300838470459,
-0.3214089274406433,
-0.35472366213798523,
0.3962782323360443,
-0.4013479948043823,
-0.6920027136802673,
0.46495211124420166,
0.15358741581439972,
0.05733291804790497,
-0.08305107057094574,
0.7852696776390076,
-0.30906787514686584,
-0.9999516606330872,
-0.25980767607688904,
0.493255615234375,
0.3780653476715088,
0.015608394518494606,
-0.4333294928073883,
0.04363083839416504,
-0.0790015459060669,
-0.15453799068927765,
0.434606671333313,
0.6523840427398682,
-0.438333123922348,
0.7438673377037048,
0.8854383230209351,
-0.053514786064624786,
0.2975040674209595,
0.08446598798036575,
1.0743688344955444,
-0.6557868719100952,
-0.2547193169593811,
-1.2766684293746948,
0.20585881173610687,
0.26449835300445557,
0.0760410875082016,
0.7048470377922058,
0.5272724628448486,
0.8699452877044678,
-0.0985134094953537,
0.5626576542854309,
0.22095565497875214,
-0.1333063393831253,
-0.7652336359024048,
-0.106074258685112,
-0.1156507357954979,
0.6342109441757202,
-0.03489904850721359,
-1.0735242366790771,
-0.3765522241592407,
0.6594827175140381,
-0.6759394407272339,
-0.3892289400100708,
0.8845282196998596,
0.6229358315467834,
0.1738557517528534,
0.15248438715934753,
0.2005687952041626,
-0.0816509947180748,
0.3572770059108734,
0.8681612014770508,
0.9700731039047241,
-0.2834632098674774,
0.5699490308761597,
-0.103884257376194,
-0.06806343048810959,
0.0013091096188873053,
-0.7838445901870728,
-0.6563839316368103,
0.0978299155831337,
-0.2284427434206009,
-0.2771519422531128,
0.062112096697092056,
1.0135430097579956,
0.23998026549816132,
-0.5680868029594421,
-0.38352465629577637,
-0.6345322728157043,
0.6432059407234192,
-0.10812312364578247,
-0.20145393908023834,
0.2931574583053589,
-0.5847324728965759,
-0.4211380183696747,
0.306490421295166,
0.36139190196990967,
-0.10964205861091614,
-0.1266249716281891,
-0.30656519532203674,
-0.043912190943956375,
0.1956741213798523,
0.758661687374115,
-0.08146505057811737,
-0.5596836805343628,
-0.05221165344119072,
0.09028395265340805,
0.11138257384300232,
0.090824656188488,
1.0077942609786987,
-0.8473387956619263,
0.23466990888118744,
0.5096161365509033,
0.5518748164176941,
0.44507288932800293,
0.528206467628479,
0.5146013498306274,
-0.4988994002342224,
0.030534768477082253,
0.24721305072307587,
0.20242290198802948,
0.05026305839419365,
-0.3433123230934143,
0.5729203224182129,
0.5857852697372437,
-0.45873159170150757,
-0.8894580602645874,
0.4787343442440033,
-0.3362031579017639,
-0.1805652230978012,
0.9958323240280151,
-0.2692547142505646,
-0.3656459450721741,
0.004045646637678146,
-0.10012827813625336,
-0.10255298018455505,
0.024779370054602623,
0.4750136435031891,
0.6826854348182678,
-0.5201036930084229,
-0.21161341667175293,
-0.23100392520427704,
0.15927521884441376,
0.3781530261039734,
-0.7810447216033936,
-0.16622701287269592,
0.3851258456707001,
0.16106006503105164,
0.14092230796813965,
0.8571103811264038,
-0.4057716131210327,
0.11143635213375092,
0.241072416305542,
-0.0015702728414908051,
-0.4602470099925995,
-0.25773298740386963,
0.16860967874526978,
0.24263063073158264,
0.20526088774204254,
-0.137528657913208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17890v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17890v1
|
SLMRec: Empowering Small Language Models for Sequential Recommendation
| 2024-05-28T07:12:06 | 2024-05-28T07:12:06 |
Wujiang Xu, Zujie Liang, Jiaojiao Han, Xuying Ning, Wenfang Lin, Linxun Chen, Feng Wei, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The sequential Recommendation (SR) task involves predicting the next item a
user is likely to interact with, given their past interactions. The SR models
examine the sequence of a user's actions to discern more complex behavioral
patterns and temporal dynamics. Recent research demonstrates the great impact
of LLMs on sequential recommendation systems, either viewing sequential
recommendation as language modeling or serving as the backbone for user
representation. Although these methods deliver outstanding performance, there
is scant evidence of the necessity of a large language model and how large the
language model is needed, especially in the sequential recommendation scene.
Meanwhile, due to the huge size of LLMs, it is inefficient and impractical to
apply a LLM-based model in real-world platforms that often need to process
billions of traffic logs daily. In this paper, we explore the influence of
LLMs' depth by conducting extensive experiments on large-scale industry
datasets. Surprisingly, we discover that most intermediate layers of LLMs are
redundant. Motivated by this insight, we empower small language models for SR,
namely SLMRec, which adopt a simple yet effective knowledge distillation
method. Moreover, SLMRec is orthogonal to other post-training efficiency
techniques, such as quantization and pruning, so that they can be leveraged in
combination. Comprehensive experimental results illustrate that the proposed
SLMRec model attains the best performance using only 13% of the parameters
found in LLM-based recommendation models, while simultaneously achieving up to
6.6x and 8.0x speedups in training and inference time costs, respectively.
|
[
-0.21985284984111786,
-0.41917741298675537,
0.8200936913490295,
0.07635533064603806,
-0.29246053099632263,
0.137865349650383,
0.07925501465797424,
-0.5648196935653687,
0.1763194054365158,
0.5291534066200256,
-0.7118000388145447,
-0.5154634714126587,
-0.41716939210891724,
-0.1153569221496582,
-0.40253975987434387,
1.001480221748352,
0.1863655000925064,
0.030890941619873047,
-0.33284977078437805,
-0.18188653886318207,
-0.519522488117218,
-0.5359683036804199,
-0.7939077615737915,
-0.6817718744277954,
0.8958157300949097,
0.6010885238647461,
0.48327887058258057,
0.38531482219696045,
0.5257289409637451,
0.3048085868358612,
-0.018250342458486557,
0.14741012454032898,
-0.6780067086219788,
0.20505428314208984,
-0.2513318955898285,
-0.518094003200531,
-0.2988961338996887,
-0.20688539743423462,
0.4270903468132019,
0.7213996052742004,
-0.5011579990386963,
0.3351968824863434,
0.0618385449051857,
0.8642206192016602,
-0.4719277620315552,
-0.16312167048454285,
-0.7183737754821777,
-0.0708807110786438,
-0.04197482764720917,
-0.07918722927570343,
-0.5345263481140137,
-0.3066991865634918,
0.31611138582229614,
-0.14646701514720917,
0.05642496049404144,
0.48310941457748413,
0.4041208326816559,
0.14758864045143127,
-0.34901121258735657,
-0.2222258299589157,
-1.0748071670532227,
0.7926207184791565,
-0.5977513194084167,
0.3802497684955597,
0.4451045095920563,
0.3202567994594574,
-0.03632567450404167,
-1.1511447429656982,
-0.1417873501777649,
-0.45445725321769714,
-0.27890193462371826,
-0.22807487845420837,
-0.09764648228883743,
0.019203491508960724,
0.3053444027900696,
0.2397536337375641,
-0.5187737345695496,
0.3086800277233124,
-0.26182183623313904,
0.09136549383401871,
0.37237784266471863,
0.48030027747154236,
0.13257746398448944,
0.32754218578338623,
-0.4594658613204956,
0.1372142881155014,
-0.8513679504394531,
0.05427342653274536,
0.21097296476364136,
0.12186498939990997,
0.12891270220279694,
0.5363029837608337,
-0.08416103571653366,
0.7352429032325745,
-0.05166322737932205,
-0.23087288439273834,
-0.0579935647547245,
-0.575918436050415,
-0.15838058292865753,
0.11460842937231064,
0.7911102771759033,
0.12228855490684509,
0.20590601861476898,
-0.045390669256448746,
-0.2937074303627014,
-0.161673903465271,
0.36253345012664795,
-0.8932251334190369,
-0.19436389207839966,
-0.06227514520287514,
-0.4243794083595276,
-0.03890082612633705,
0.1225447878241539,
-0.3687130808830261,
-0.383922815322876,
-0.3113527297973633,
0.14792054891586304,
-0.13473032414913177,
0.06442537903785706,
0.2828497290611267,
0.08899224549531937,
-0.13765060901641846,
0.29227396845817566,
-0.7327977418899536,
0.42194464802742004,
0.6706401705741882,
1.024010419845581,
-0.07265417277812958,
-0.3786545693874359,
-0.40818285942077637,
0.1723170429468155,
-0.05927995592355728,
0.8648485541343689,
-0.60555100440979,
-0.4327945411205292,
-0.21266919374465942,
0.1380658745765686,
0.13208141922950745,
-0.4948713183403015,
0.4504247307777405,
-0.6859647631645203,
-0.09406987577676773,
-0.042527612298727036,
-0.3995131254196167,
-0.23298980295658112,
-0.11623532325029373,
-0.5974819660186768,
0.9028254151344299,
-0.07306212931871414,
-0.6446766257286072,
0.33399638533592224,
-0.30584341287612915,
-0.5600874423980713,
0.15366698801517487,
0.036281052976846695,
-0.2238496094942093,
0.2534390389919281,
-0.0051557025872170925,
0.3973900079727173,
-0.5212740302085876,
0.34317249059677124,
-0.5893476009368896,
-0.44185879826545715,
0.2370501011610031,
-0.14118725061416626,
0.26173120737075806,
0.30344080924987793,
0.02400173991918564,
0.2308940291404724,
-0.5891346335411072,
-0.0856400728225708,
-0.10122045874595642,
-0.03476039692759514,
-0.8161976337432861,
0.0922643318772316,
-0.18984118103981018,
0.26534944772720337,
0.30832454562187195,
-0.19715486466884613,
0.06509610265493393,
-0.4526933431625366,
0.5722763538360596,
0.8602131009101868,
0.13798081874847412,
0.6423723101615906,
-0.4875950515270233,
0.48483341932296753,
-0.04990731552243233,
0.06300041824579239,
-0.24951548874378204,
-0.3148559033870697,
-0.8402568101882935,
-0.14191465079784393,
0.4018639922142029,
0.3829091489315033,
-0.47535398602485657,
0.385193407535553,
-0.29633140563964844,
-0.6054498553276062,
-0.5723597407341003,
0.24179556965827942,
0.11513759940862656,
0.1507052183151245,
0.09073472768068314,
-0.4045073390007019,
-0.9613358378410339,
-0.9753543138504028,
-0.3724876642227173,
-0.2826489806175232,
0.021662726998329163,
0.36861324310302734,
0.3301273584365845,
-0.44275781512260437,
0.8819085955619812,
-0.5115153193473816,
-0.3561503291130066,
-0.4046836495399475,
-0.05964205041527748,
0.39651671051979065,
0.29704713821411133,
0.15222324430942535,
-0.3745526671409607,
-0.5568106770515442,
-0.22690939903259277,
-0.5451923608779907,
-0.16582636535167694,
-0.12489954382181168,
-0.08439936488866806,
-0.14077359437942505,
0.4870718717575073,
-0.2592798173427582,
0.2552739083766937,
0.4669955372810364,
-0.22381478548049927,
0.24058951437473297,
-0.4452808201313019,
-0.12100635468959808,
-0.6327013969421387,
-0.09013576060533524,
0.3574020266532898,
-0.4636678099632263,
-0.598554253578186,
-0.23625007271766663,
-0.19482426345348358,
0.010532681830227375,
-0.3312545716762543,
0.6103246808052063,
-0.335295706987381,
-0.08197677880525589,
-0.37796521186828613,
0.14244793355464935,
0.023663323372602463,
0.45034971833229065,
-0.0015675498871132731,
0.561942994594574,
0.13692884147167206,
-0.5689188838005066,
0.06222987174987793,
-0.15730872750282288,
-0.7639933824539185,
0.08580246567726135,
-0.8040241599082947,
0.28151342272758484,
0.12225227802991867,
0.3340763449668884,
-1.1013071537017822,
0.21989859640598297,
-0.03358722850680351,
0.14162082970142365,
-0.05336498096585274,
-0.44701889157295227,
-0.6449893116950989,
-0.31611281633377075,
-0.13815447688102722,
0.41530853509902954,
0.6960533261299133,
-0.4812465012073517,
0.6267314553260803,
0.5258293151855469,
-0.21733087301254272,
-0.35957616567611694,
-0.73744136095047,
0.07928191125392914,
-0.27031925320625305,
-0.5843208432197571,
0.236887127161026,
-0.22440221905708313,
-0.38844090700149536,
-0.20633149147033691,
-0.16851288080215454,
0.18512064218521118,
-0.012584501877427101,
0.6173977255821228,
0.3239613175392151,
-0.00713903596624732,
0.000650223228149116,
-0.16337871551513672,
-0.22377796471118927,
-0.11940035969018936,
-0.651540994644165,
0.5082315802574158,
-0.221153125166893,
-0.35235998034477234,
-0.5029686093330383,
0.051099855452775955,
0.6902917623519897,
0.08418958634138107,
0.759103000164032,
0.4569041430950165,
-0.03660176321864128,
-0.3154882788658142,
-0.7943708896636963,
-0.4329289197921753,
-0.5064032673835754,
0.32182812690734863,
-0.3251870274543762,
-1.1366548538208008,
0.35406529903411865,
-0.22239567339420319,
-0.023238467052578926,
0.13082151114940643,
0.5858097076416016,
-0.13766561448574066,
0.9903550148010254,
0.691902220249176,
-0.31703677773475647,
0.7752783894538879,
-0.29731035232543945,
0.27166658639907837,
-0.6215577125549316,
-0.38191699981689453,
-0.4419266879558563,
-0.5074608325958252,
-0.3929918110370636,
-0.34699681401252747,
0.19553329050540924,
0.059583261609077454,
-0.15321028232574463,
0.2662821412086487,
-0.22140036523342133,
0.3597126305103302,
0.6165823936462402,
0.20239406824111938,
0.6503835320472717,
0.18880735337734222,
-0.20538227260112762,
-0.1611182540655136,
-0.924836277961731,
-0.5069549083709717,
0.7486722469329834,
0.447524756193161,
1.2090731859207153,
-0.1004866361618042,
0.4477573335170746,
0.5716171860694885,
0.15354330837726593,
-0.955044150352478,
0.7555931806564331,
-0.39437049627304077,
-0.18404948711395264,
-0.1471162587404251,
-0.2563692033290863,
-0.7504013776779175,
0.21323028206825256,
0.03873340040445328,
-0.47658276557922363,
0.3527916669845581,
0.07604732364416122,
-0.40710440278053284,
0.31783461570739746,
-0.6733694672584534,
0.5195622444152832,
-0.3692269027233124,
-0.6128470301628113,
-0.537727952003479,
-0.3956455886363983,
0.38410869240760803,
-0.1146843209862709,
0.37821459770202637,
-0.18769733607769012,
-0.19317708909511566,
0.6967368125915527,
-0.606015145778656,
1.0011992454528809,
-0.12715616822242737,
-0.013017497956752777,
0.3991214632987976,
0.24518799781799316,
0.9637163877487183,
0.1471550017595291,
-0.02728816121816635,
0.25048646330833435,
-0.11408010870218277,
0.08602289855480194,
-0.6098830699920654,
1.0243430137634277,
-0.5318226218223572,
-0.6181533336639404,
-0.35664719343185425,
-0.16082562506198883,
-0.10829748958349228,
0.1914944350719452,
-0.15774501860141754,
0.35034558176994324,
-0.0762014091014862,
0.3999711871147156,
0.557529628276825,
0.04200778156518936,
0.18041716516017914,
0.8756530284881592,
-0.3685835599899292,
-0.40841835737228394,
0.8154674172401428,
0.004776564426720142,
0.0026422885712236166,
0.43197882175445557,
0.2109619528055191,
-0.44656679034233093,
-0.7481670379638672,
-0.028154868632555008,
0.3528195321559906,
-0.5647444725036621,
-0.050190117210149765,
-0.8744471073150635,
-0.13496874272823334,
-0.134401336312294,
0.010554893873631954,
-0.2670278251171112,
-0.45909810066223145,
-0.3268824517726898,
-0.2194247841835022,
0.3908805549144745,
0.8618573546409607,
-0.00653632078319788,
0.5037099123001099,
-0.7251835465431213,
0.22000813484191895,
0.3145451247692108,
0.4928235411643982,
0.28086844086647034,
-0.7076608538627625,
-0.6438161134719849,
-0.11584930121898651,
0.08676720410585403,
-0.1512071043252945,
0.3964911997318268,
0.1449785977602005,
0.5396188497543335,
0.4143418073654175,
-0.010129538364708424,
0.7641474604606628,
-0.7140397429466248,
0.6988306045532227,
0.2664944529533386,
-0.4544345736503601,
0.4556216895580292,
0.019715052098035812,
0.37057697772979736,
0.7136449813842773,
0.5602861642837524,
-0.578295111656189,
-0.20807473361492157,
-0.49271637201309204,
-1.0217453241348267,
0.7942869067192078,
-0.13385020196437836,
-0.2260546088218689,
0.23749017715454102,
0.25882619619369507,
0.22406503558158875,
0.21259158849716187,
-0.4824583828449249,
-0.12679918110370636,
0.17145207524299622,
-0.0812760591506958,
-0.3470078110694885,
-0.7678346633911133,
0.04102279990911484,
-0.15392722189426422,
0.6477089524269104,
0.24093686044216156,
-0.2149076908826828,
0.025394774973392487,
-0.18888118863105774,
-0.003967017401009798,
0.108505018055439,
0.5523529648780823,
0.6062936782836914,
-0.2748650014400482,
0.21230271458625793,
0.1811019778251648,
-0.3668240010738373,
0.30359408259391785,
-0.3196697235107422,
-0.07367584854364395,
-0.06654518842697144,
0.2590760886669159,
0.8969764113426208,
0.4496820867061615,
-0.7475109696388245,
0.09186819195747375,
-0.22197388112545013,
-0.007764155510812998,
-0.4856705367565155,
0.22388772666454315,
0.11638697236776352,
0.19961358606815338,
0.32171809673309326,
0.24388283491134644,
0.11070430278778076,
-0.4732265770435333,
0.2282945066690445,
0.1787683516740799,
-0.6046921610832214,
-0.2652378976345062,
0.24011263251304626,
0.30478450655937195,
-0.35886669158935547,
0.5579580664634705,
0.30760934948921204,
-0.14853879809379578,
0.2728642225265503,
0.28686243295669556,
0.9837074279785156,
0.04575832560658455,
-0.13987912237644196,
0.37605392932891846,
0.32793545722961426,
-0.6755969524383545,
-0.22185847163200378,
-0.11441200971603394,
-0.6135131120681763,
-0.4033738374710083,
-0.6866816282272339,
-0.23986312747001648,
0.05036991462111473,
-0.5297949314117432,
0.2781122922897339,
-0.5984792709350586,
-0.4419899582862854,
-0.22077538073062897,
0.11443108320236206,
-0.5794331431388855,
-0.1708240509033203,
-0.02917582169175148,
0.984925389289856,
-0.615718424320221,
1.0324273109436035,
0.6411211490631104,
-0.15362438559532166,
-0.48726117610931396,
-0.4272285997867584,
-0.0821240097284317,
-0.7576931118965149,
0.7889639735221863,
-0.07941873371601105,
-0.5993844270706177,
0.11676422506570816,
-0.37256431579589844,
-0.5912913084030151,
1.1567646265029907,
0.13601918518543243,
-1.1269464492797852,
-0.1499144732952118,
-0.012377074919641018,
0.7024798393249512,
-0.7958400845527649,
0.3129573166370392,
0.5894137620925903,
0.3400995135307312,
0.36362090706825256,
-0.6582790613174438,
0.06300931423902512,
-0.02996690571308136,
0.3606862723827362,
0.06914260238409042,
-0.6639344692230225,
0.4797056317329407,
-0.45875459909439087,
-0.27898064255714417,
0.1878078132867813,
0.5771706700325012,
0.5582870841026306,
0.38210034370422363,
0.7614187598228455,
0.4905153214931488,
0.5718677043914795,
0.26427093148231506,
0.9738835692405701,
-0.30273640155792236,
0.0542285218834877,
1.696698784828186,
-0.6583715677261353,
0.81859290599823,
0.5191569924354553,
-0.3358909487724304,
0.9798104166984558,
0.7742037177085876,
-0.07869336754083633,
0.7566196322441101,
0.23021265864372253,
-0.25980666279792786,
-0.3397446274757385,
-0.20994459092617035,
-0.18384939432144165,
0.04641241952776909,
0.37880516052246094,
-0.44095954298973083,
0.0836830884218216,
0.008406572043895721,
-0.3606722354888916,
-0.061836935579776764,
-0.23740161955356598,
1.0442556142807007,
0.5320627093315125,
-0.6297373175621033,
0.39325398206710815,
-0.014405202120542526,
0.7474614381790161,
-1.0164161920547485,
0.04439147561788559,
-0.31018102169036865,
0.3689285218715668,
-0.19135747849941254,
-0.6190727353096008,
-0.0011563217267394066,
-0.14206735789775848,
-0.5600270628929138,
-0.4239099621772766,
0.9909348487854004,
-0.4335271716117859,
-0.4867888391017914,
0.4731963872909546,
0.45805367827415466,
0.16636738181114197,
0.04987433925271034,
-0.5944763422012329,
0.005689841229468584,
0.16019879281520844,
-0.01633220911026001,
0.5462321639060974,
0.3836413025856018,
0.0011091399937868118,
1.1289507150650024,
0.7642122507095337,
0.30660346150398254,
-0.20124973356723785,
0.2964998781681061,
0.6579700708389282,
-0.685452401638031,
-0.49836182594299316,
-0.9905907511711121,
0.37551188468933105,
0.13620689511299133,
0.28580862283706665,
0.8242844343185425,
0.5261406898498535,
0.815585196018219,
-0.07248974591493607,
0.7491018772125244,
0.24752399325370789,
0.4483349323272705,
-0.49316054582595825,
0.44390881061553955,
-0.5539740920066833,
1.0568150281906128,
0.08786661922931671,
-0.7037528157234192,
0.088958241045475,
0.3002445101737976,
-0.34388071298599243,
0.29321134090423584,
0.7278456687927246,
0.9504330158233643,
0.030998045578598976,
0.08291275799274445,
0.3318038284778595,
0.3383408784866333,
0.07800620049238205,
0.506203830242157,
1.1081496477127075,
-0.10228317975997925,
0.5303188562393188,
-0.2400771528482437,
-0.02688944898545742,
-0.5101667046546936,
-0.778963029384613,
-0.8931786417961121,
-0.4514680504798889,
-0.19506745040416718,
-0.3907460868358612,
0.08878724277019501,
0.9666164517402649,
0.7593168616294861,
-0.7885926961898804,
-0.7284560799598694,
-0.0324857234954834,
0.3779120147228241,
-0.23026655614376068,
-0.19411541521549225,
0.058383334428071976,
-0.11763249337673187,
-0.49173682928085327,
0.6039664149284363,
0.35990190505981445,
0.2201414257287979,
-0.559698760509491,
-0.04589715972542763,
-0.23170281946659088,
-0.2918455898761749,
0.7436765432357788,
-0.019189834594726562,
-0.676514744758606,
-0.011441160924732685,
-0.16022169589996338,
-0.17532221972942352,
-0.24257180094718933,
1.5134129524230957,
-1.0002825260162354,
0.1614900827407837,
0.5822566747665405,
0.20596541464328766,
0.6606051921844482,
0.018630728125572205,
0.8091708421707153,
-0.5743750333786011,
0.2099863737821579,
0.13858555257320404,
0.3988175094127655,
0.05703263357281685,
-0.2772881090641022,
0.6282166838645935,
0.24017339944839478,
-0.6137559413909912,
-1.0325924158096313,
0.07678740471601486,
-0.7942574620246887,
-0.40420255064964294,
1.1272691488265991,
-0.10524515807628632,
-0.04548562318086624,
-0.2945190668106079,
-0.16532349586486816,
-0.20388466119766235,
-0.6886910796165466,
0.4857622981071472,
0.488041490316391,
0.01712155155837536,
-0.25492721796035767,
-0.5497918128967285,
0.3019154369831085,
0.2217044085264206,
-0.19545522332191467,
0.24013569951057434,
0.35692688822746277,
0.36509042978286743,
-0.200144961476326,
0.7497333884239197,
0.16810709238052368,
-0.2852538824081421,
-0.1892685890197754,
-0.12953364849090576,
-0.2434617429971695,
-0.6482784152030945,
-0.40476906299591064,
0.22588802874088287,
0.4202738404273987,
0.33816468715667725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17871v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17871v1
|
Seeing the Image: Prioritizing Visual Correlation by Contrastive Alignment
| 2024-05-28T06:44:13 | 2024-05-28T06:44:13 |
Xin Xiao, Bohong Wu, Jiacong Wang, Chunyuan Li, Xun Zhou, Haoyuan Guo
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Existing image-text modality alignment in Vision Language Models (VLMs)
treats each text token equally in an autoregressive manner. Despite being
simple and effective, this method results in sub-optimal cross-modal alignment
by over-emphasizing the text tokens that are less correlated with or even
contradictory with the input images. In this paper, we advocate for assigning
distinct contributions for each text token based on its visual correlation.
Specifically, we present by contrasting image inputs, the difference in
prediction logits on each text token provides strong guidance of visual
correlation. We therefore introduce Contrastive ALignment (CAL), a simple yet
effective re-weighting strategy that prioritizes training visually correlated
tokens. Our experimental results demonstrate that CAL consistently improves
different types of VLMs across different resolutions and model sizes on various
benchmark datasets. Importantly, our method incurs minimal additional
computational overhead, rendering it highly efficient compared to alternative
data scaling strategies. Codes are available at
https://github.com/foundation-multimodal-models/CAL.
|
[
-0.15478770434856415,
-0.3854537904262543,
0.3478793203830719,
0.27113601565361023,
-0.6191468834877014,
-0.047485943883657455,
0.0931323692202568,
-0.5073511600494385,
0.27588069438934326,
0.4036236107349396,
-0.09876179695129395,
-0.22711049020290375,
-0.5453025698661804,
-0.21644438803195953,
-0.28095412254333496,
0.8380340933799744,
-0.11059127002954483,
0.38482266664505005,
-0.6248270869255066,
-0.3961392939090729,
-0.6266645193099976,
-0.24402426183223724,
-0.6424341201782227,
-0.1873379945755005,
0.8800140619277954,
0.28396061062812805,
0.9721549153327942,
0.9430955648422241,
1.2770720720291138,
0.3929062485694885,
0.2680255174636841,
0.14907348155975342,
-0.5389171838760376,
0.06896299123764038,
-0.3034139573574066,
-0.41863715648651123,
-0.20793601870536804,
-0.3348962664604187,
0.24172843992710114,
0.31863948702812195,
0.16683891415596008,
0.1737930029630661,
-0.08874291181564331,
0.7085556983947754,
-0.9570189714431763,
0.002561739645898342,
-0.6981692910194397,
-0.015964370220899582,
-0.18947823345661163,
-0.37519189715385437,
-0.2931377589702606,
0.02415240742266178,
0.31153246760368347,
-0.6837600469589233,
0.20461368560791016,
0.4233858287334442,
1.0935016870498657,
0.5511936545372009,
-0.5088376998901367,
0.2369576245546341,
-0.17304447293281555,
1.1500650644302368,
-0.28925174474716187,
0.5449759364128113,
0.297983855009079,
0.26175132393836975,
0.39518097043037415,
-0.7081341743469238,
-0.3794504702091217,
0.18413977324962616,
-0.3905715048313141,
0.3965492844581604,
-0.14071786403656006,
-0.18566633760929108,
-0.1865963190793991,
0.41404950618743896,
-0.5748935341835022,
0.07488521933555603,
-0.2231154888868332,
-0.4154496490955353,
0.2433156669139862,
0.4914624094963074,
0.28913840651512146,
0.1787269115447998,
-0.7960174083709717,
-0.30783918499946594,
-0.35214078426361084,
0.14163778722286224,
-0.0010053920559585094,
0.1447303146123886,
-0.4336768686771393,
0.8339579701423645,
-0.03910590335726738,
0.9352875351905823,
0.2195073813199997,
-0.09218741953372955,
0.39444175362586975,
-0.9659028649330139,
-0.43749332427978516,
-0.07187200337648392,
0.9584189057350159,
1.036364197731018,
0.038862526416778564,
0.04931517317891121,
-0.07251109927892685,
0.37046852707862854,
0.37884676456451416,
-0.839378297328949,
-0.36089956760406494,
-0.24626955389976501,
-0.5830541253089905,
-0.5818646550178528,
-0.05250879004597664,
-0.7492219805717468,
-0.43454429507255554,
-0.5964165925979614,
0.5555630326271057,
-0.27588528394699097,
0.08939427137374878,
-0.0933583602309227,
-0.153360977768898,
0.18330053985118866,
0.6203047037124634,
-1.014099359512329,
0.02749069221317768,
0.4354964792728424,
0.863493025302887,
-0.3584313690662384,
-0.32456183433532715,
-0.6840453743934631,
0.09193508327007294,
-0.5881901383399963,
0.7737876176834106,
-0.775359570980072,
-0.2511782646179199,
-0.011845785193145275,
0.04404255747795105,
0.10660504549741745,
-0.2550691068172455,
0.39012661576271057,
-0.4560811221599579,
0.24621456861495972,
-0.46746280789375305,
-0.1882692575454712,
0.08440985530614853,
0.20473283529281616,
-0.813995361328125,
0.7738828659057617,
-0.14651325345039368,
-1.2429739236831665,
0.7514477372169495,
-0.15085309743881226,
-0.34111008048057556,
-0.1264650970697403,
-0.5846477746963501,
-0.689746081829071,
0.22071130573749542,
0.5001354813575745,
0.19369813799858093,
-0.37585923075675964,
0.06509145349264145,
-0.3623000681400299,
-0.2568051815032959,
0.2426157295703888,
-0.2352209985256195,
0.3173009753227234,
0.383725643157959,
-0.13195045292377472,
0.3597981631755829,
-0.6407482028007507,
0.005975786130875349,
-0.02492647059261799,
0.00108355563133955,
-0.5925090909004211,
0.07425887137651443,
0.27611956000328064,
0.13354025781154633,
0.6447533369064331,
-0.3089940547943115,
-0.1083982065320015,
-0.10207125544548035,
-0.05720002204179764,
0.8182157874107361,
-0.42669570446014404,
0.7377379536628723,
-0.3904508650302887,
0.32814449071884155,
0.43431195616722107,
0.2765370011329651,
-0.27868422865867615,
-0.30853936076164246,
-0.8245858550071716,
-0.6832706332206726,
0.12256024032831192,
0.5311005711555481,
-0.9664435386657715,
0.1284492313861847,
-0.32794106006622314,
-0.41525325179100037,
-0.49761682748794556,
0.22200343012809753,
0.873708963394165,
0.8492256999015808,
0.46168574690818787,
-0.7415341734886169,
-0.4878649413585663,
-1.2339404821395874,
0.0037230050656944513,
-0.13473670184612274,
0.3616952896118164,
0.497368186712265,
-0.0025526040699332952,
-0.14397640526294708,
0.7570827007293701,
-0.47331464290618896,
-0.46150678396224976,
0.2905353605747223,
0.15661734342575073,
0.04508153721690178,
0.6793347001075745,
0.7241644263267517,
-1.2450616359710693,
-0.7951774001121521,
0.451369047164917,
-0.7165960073471069,
-0.2343159019947052,
-0.09497305005788803,
-0.5349684953689575,
0.04342443495988846,
0.6649460196495056,
0.03453436493873596,
0.6972096562385559,
0.6777717471122742,
-0.38537096977233887,
0.17051920294761658,
-0.20186017453670502,
0.34959039092063904,
-1.0616750717163086,
0.13043779134750366,
0.19101671874523163,
-0.36691176891326904,
-0.4081897735595703,
-0.02455572597682476,
0.0894269123673439,
0.17515823245048523,
-0.2926526367664337,
0.5223863124847412,
-0.4640890955924988,
-0.11947021633386612,
-0.1328030824661255,
0.019219515845179558,
0.15006756782531738,
0.2635244131088257,
0.3447697162628174,
0.8222292065620422,
0.6922765970230103,
-0.217048779129982,
0.1336125284433365,
0.2346111536026001,
-0.4444177746772766,
1.086026668548584,
-0.6561921238899231,
-0.3310335576534271,
-0.11619772762060165,
-0.1109427660703659,
-1.3337032794952393,
0.23980872333049774,
0.06670642644166946,
-0.29450270533561707,
0.41641440987586975,
0.21741589903831482,
-0.18548911809921265,
-0.09588410705327988,
-0.36483234167099,
1.0299514532089233,
0.19126980006694794,
-0.5566688179969788,
0.5388702154159546,
0.17772996425628662,
0.14732536673545837,
-1.0329958200454712,
-0.9531967639923096,
0.038908038288354874,
-0.16499203443527222,
-0.5088854432106018,
0.5461228489875793,
-0.19804291427135468,
-0.15016776323318481,
0.16490478813648224,
-0.045571085065603256,
-0.07045835256576538,
-0.21228650212287903,
0.2863556742668152,
0.6604416370391846,
-0.4549611806869507,
0.031036946922540665,
-0.42584821581840515,
-0.16263173520565033,
-0.5790075063705444,
0.028677459806203842,
0.44031527638435364,
-0.053582292050123215,
-0.3125976026058197,
-0.5641525387763977,
0.3693993389606476,
0.6644435524940491,
-0.3873179256916046,
0.5150476098060608,
0.7675749063491821,
0.055739179253578186,
0.657994270324707,
-0.6966419816017151,
0.2084265649318695,
-0.461781769990921,
0.4715573489665985,
-0.36631956696510315,
-0.5218862295150757,
0.46717190742492676,
0.30362311005592346,
0.2606550455093384,
0.15866601467132568,
0.5416550636291504,
-0.06301280111074448,
1.184860110282898,
0.9304984211921692,
-0.12353915721178055,
1.2613236904144287,
0.13495631515979767,
0.32592687010765076,
-0.8056771159172058,
-0.17232845723628998,
-0.19043469429016113,
-0.5176226496696472,
-0.42220011353492737,
-0.6431915163993835,
0.012075732462108135,
0.13608857989311218,
-0.24781157076358795,
0.3227523863315582,
-0.5870850682258606,
0.6284564137458801,
0.5339804887771606,
0.3292371928691864,
0.2473454773426056,
0.2711526155471802,
-0.27283069491386414,
-0.4487926661968231,
-0.5326666235923767,
-0.20804107189178467,
1.1031910181045532,
-0.11205267906188965,
1.0935736894607544,
0.07252297550439835,
0.707538902759552,
-0.0892171785235405,
0.4035276174545288,
-0.6483464241027832,
0.36361297965049744,
-0.5500579476356506,
-0.25247350335121155,
-0.07289917767047882,
-0.23905563354492188,
-1.0503456592559814,
0.5257098078727722,
-0.5281965136528015,
-0.582472562789917,
0.5541273951530457,
0.45998415350914,
-0.16121259331703186,
0.010130512528121471,
-0.8445448279380798,
0.9553965926170349,
-0.42178288102149963,
-0.8345169425010681,
-0.22410905361175537,
-0.8325160145759583,
0.2005273997783661,
-0.16238753497600555,
0.1172274649143219,
0.37438690662384033,
-0.4845596253871918,
0.3637153208255768,
-0.5446755290031433,
0.8431764245033264,
0.43582478165626526,
0.1558355689048767,
-0.08679206669330597,
-0.06601863354444504,
0.18122822046279907,
-0.3321545720100403,
0.15500091016292572,
-0.0656982809305191,
0.020684463903307915,
-0.5913047790527344,
-0.5681564807891846,
0.802708625793457,
-0.7040005326271057,
-0.3318978548049927,
-0.3048110008239746,
-0.5194571018218994,
0.09089428186416626,
0.2608421742916107,
0.39445018768310547,
0.6691772937774658,
-0.10272980481386185,
0.4303058385848999,
0.37975260615348816,
-0.05231756344437599,
0.41216766834259033,
0.355794221162796,
-0.5211865305900574,
-0.9572551250457764,
1.249971866607666,
-0.13498280942440033,
0.5130922794342041,
0.838523805141449,
0.15466748178005219,
-0.22813045978546143,
-0.414407879114151,
-0.17062176764011383,
0.192372664809227,
-0.9262564778327942,
-0.2775530517101288,
-0.44563084840774536,
0.1422465592622757,
-0.46432599425315857,
-0.8640053868293762,
-0.23715968430042267,
-0.050119444727897644,
-0.4027172327041626,
0.26503947377204895,
0.022722400724887848,
0.3425314724445343,
-0.0039015875663608313,
0.3202989101409912,
-0.39792487025260925,
0.36335891485214233,
0.555600106716156,
0.244263157248497,
-0.11563097685575485,
-0.25935694575309753,
-0.2542678713798523,
-0.2633378803730011,
-0.4374644160270691,
-0.37109220027923584,
0.3428610563278198,
0.0695745050907135,
0.6678674817085266,
0.678009569644928,
-0.16078534722328186,
1.3083691596984863,
-0.42573997378349304,
0.7200552225112915,
1.048851728439331,
-0.7118716239929199,
0.2688273787498474,
0.03444627672433853,
0.3721877336502075,
0.7860947251319885,
0.11608042567968369,
-0.12464086711406708,
-0.36140453815460205,
-0.4316231310367584,
-0.893601655960083,
0.25508108735084534,
0.12544293701648712,
-0.09635072946548462,
0.0022055706940591335,
-0.18802714347839355,
-0.05577768012881279,
0.26044830679893494,
-0.8616340756416321,
-0.06625617295503616,
-0.5345993638038635,
-0.6016273498535156,
-0.24454009532928467,
-0.007556219585239887,
-0.347197026014328,
-0.3977730870246887,
0.19727236032485962,
-0.2890177369117737,
0.002121713710948825,
0.3598671555519104,
-0.26481443643569946,
-0.1839900016784668,
-0.3597753643989563,
0.7645074129104614,
0.6630443930625916,
0.10653039067983627,
0.4349188804626465,
-0.18906402587890625,
-0.4799909293651581,
-0.1815156489610672,
-0.3550732731819153,
-0.03758256137371063,
-0.08028244972229004,
0.4357467591762543,
0.8409997820854187,
0.553745687007904,
-0.5530873537063599,
0.7544397115707397,
-0.1608637273311615,
-0.1149895191192627,
0.2794942855834961,
-0.1566995084285736,
-0.16332222521305084,
0.35584405064582825,
-0.1189652532339096,
0.2554683983325958,
-0.04913567751646042,
-0.5475063920021057,
0.2571803033351898,
0.6950373649597168,
-0.5827732086181641,
-0.018072035163640976,
0.7347763776779175,
0.23266959190368652,
-0.22115889191627502,
0.27150407433509827,
0.4774485230445862,
-0.3845272362232208,
0.6652393937110901,
0.5086079239845276,
0.5790625214576721,
0.0032857703045010567,
0.011435850523412228,
0.3774954080581665,
0.1119806170463562,
-0.07336414605379105,
0.17749737203121185,
-0.1786334067583084,
-0.7282245755195618,
-0.12803591787815094,
-0.41756635904312134,
-0.24293231964111328,
-0.30774423480033875,
-0.6575686931610107,
0.6225792169570923,
-0.3207259476184845,
-0.34991395473480225,
0.1602419912815094,
-0.2992086708545685,
-0.864109992980957,
0.3522050678730011,
0.079729363322258,
0.3879828155040741,
-0.9011834263801575,
0.7279475927352905,
0.6286452412605286,
-0.6891353130340576,
-0.32618093490600586,
-0.18379345536231995,
0.06916061043739319,
-1.1355167627334595,
0.9601229429244995,
0.0958365797996521,
-0.20649680495262146,
-0.1629600077867508,
-0.7163291573524475,
-0.9311562180519104,
1.1123837232589722,
0.18105080723762512,
-0.6843531131744385,
0.2991986870765686,
-0.27682843804359436,
0.5080105662345886,
-0.5751857757568359,
0.28281891345977783,
-0.21794670820236206,
0.26703721284866333,
0.4737825393676758,
-0.9372746348381042,
-0.05699554458260536,
-0.2761287987232208,
0.27414026856422424,
0.339993953704834,
-0.7462823390960693,
0.7067416310310364,
-0.3340058922767639,
-0.15518002212047577,
0.34865808486938477,
0.5970425009727478,
0.04101422429084778,
0.46579110622406006,
0.6139113903045654,
0.754963219165802,
0.33879780769348145,
0.22400029003620148,
0.895007848739624,
-0.2904907166957855,
0.08136194199323654,
1.4147685766220093,
-0.2418738305568695,
0.9034003019332886,
1.1130750179290771,
-0.048913124948740005,
0.34065449237823486,
0.520271360874176,
-0.17990948259830475,
0.916845440864563,
-0.1069444790482521,
0.10096003115177155,
-0.6676672101020813,
-0.35108864307403564,
-0.3347393274307251,
0.30131569504737854,
-0.014820997603237629,
-0.7435985803604126,
-0.24332043528556824,
-0.2699167728424072,
-0.43509888648986816,
0.28411421179771423,
-0.24140071868896484,
0.8195393681526184,
-0.0070103844627738,
-0.6711541414260864,
0.4662838280200958,
-0.6066297292709351,
0.7177272439002991,
-0.5080424547195435,
0.05180925875902176,
-0.02516605705022812,
0.2153230905532837,
-0.26199981570243835,
-0.7709243297576904,
-0.0009996789740398526,
-0.2500932514667511,
-0.4639239013195038,
-0.17294877767562866,
0.347893625497818,
-0.4992663860321045,
-0.659568727016449,
0.11941566318273544,
0.10494159162044525,
-0.09351334720849991,
0.5435012578964233,
-0.7723314166069031,
0.1845698356628418,
-0.025609057396650314,
0.11409526318311691,
0.5446299314498901,
0.43147286772727966,
-0.41026559472084045,
0.5786473751068115,
0.7702738046646118,
-0.003126490395516157,
0.12608548998832703,
0.17202545702457428,
0.8075616955757141,
-0.48619526624679565,
-0.47251683473587036,
-0.8455928564071655,
0.6255690455436707,
-0.42779022455215454,
-0.34536173939704895,
0.6090156435966492,
0.6684840321540833,
0.6303377151489258,
0.134956493973732,
0.24505053460597992,
0.2224911004304886,
-0.11786214262247086,
-0.46023011207580566,
0.2311476320028305,
-1.063024878501892,
-0.005354697350412607,
-0.5614938735961914,
-0.7860957980155945,
-0.6381059885025024,
0.733741283416748,
-0.24999862909317017,
-0.3936217725276947,
0.8528207540512085,
0.9499015808105469,
-0.07487010210752487,
-0.40887075662612915,
0.5146365165710449,
-0.3075525462627411,
0.25899747014045715,
0.5384414196014404,
0.5652707815170288,
-0.4405677914619446,
0.6241567134857178,
-0.2872982323169708,
-0.2372276782989502,
-0.372906893491745,
-1.1158698797225952,
-0.8119425177574158,
-0.6663098335266113,
-0.6197425127029419,
-0.07440493255853653,
-0.24260878562927246,
0.5311369895935059,
0.7697033286094666,
-0.49112075567245483,
-0.12306296825408936,
-0.12814362347126007,
0.08143624663352966,
-0.3245660066604614,
-0.16388043761253357,
0.3135799467563629,
-0.41495874524116516,
-0.5934340357780457,
-0.17579588294029236,
0.5190094709396362,
0.35939228534698486,
-0.029055248945951462,
-0.061127133667469025,
-0.1222463995218277,
0.13074827194213867,
0.5359720587730408,
0.17789001762866974,
-0.8792272806167603,
-0.23344135284423828,
-0.06358881294727325,
-0.5707193613052368,
0.25880858302116394,
0.9052038788795471,
-0.678171694278717,
0.9801164269447327,
0.8524860143661499,
0.6459276080131531,
0.3556899130344391,
0.13705843687057495,
0.6812174320220947,
-0.25533485412597656,
0.351950079202652,
-0.19508151710033417,
0.6763871908187866,
0.39334648847579956,
-0.2712860107421875,
0.564922571182251,
0.14146524667739868,
-0.5645920634269714,
-0.8608705997467041,
0.2236258089542389,
-1.5492075681686401,
-0.05341587960720062,
0.7098856568336487,
0.04556479677557945,
-0.34505367279052734,
0.1760043501853943,
-0.5763448476791382,
-0.025765372440218925,
-0.16191880404949188,
0.6265692114830017,
0.659659743309021,
0.06800568848848343,
-0.3627465069293976,
-0.09743770956993103,
0.15031573176383972,
0.8690162301063538,
-0.40337657928466797,
-0.11988531053066254,
0.5491067171096802,
0.0303172767162323,
0.3314138948917389,
0.6767101883888245,
-0.3124016225337982,
0.311150461435318,
0.00854287575930357,
-0.07011020928621292,
0.26687803864479065,
-0.22293320298194885,
-0.18999943137168884,
-0.10809114575386047,
-0.0689803808927536,
-0.5545286536216736
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17849v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17849v2
|
I-LLM: Efficient Integer-Only Inference for Fully-Quantized Low-Bit Large Language Models
| 2024-05-28T05:56:11 | 2024-06-05T15:26:58 |
Xing Hu, Yuan Cheng, Dawei Yang, Zhihang Yuan, Jiangyong Yu, Chen Xu, Sifan Zhou
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Post-training quantization (PTQ) serves as a potent technique to accelerate
the inference of large language models (LLMs). Nonetheless, existing works
still necessitate a considerable number of floating-point (FP) operations
during inference, including additional quantization and de-quantization, as
well as non-linear operators such as RMSNorm and Softmax. This limitation
hinders the deployment of LLMs on the edge and cloud devices. In this paper, we
identify the primary obstacle to integer-only quantization for LLMs lies in the
large fluctuation of activations across channels and tokens in both linear and
non-linear operations. To address this issue, we propose I-LLM, a novel
integer-only fully-quantized PTQ framework tailored for LLMs. Specifically, (1)
we develop Fully-Smooth Block-Reconstruction (FSBR) to aggressively smooth
inter-channel variations of all activations and weights. (2) to alleviate
degradation caused by inter-token variations, we introduce a novel approach
called Dynamic Integer-only MatMul (DI-MatMul). This method enables dynamic
quantization in full-integer matrix multiplication by dynamically quantizing
the input and outputs with integer-only operations. (3) we design
DI-ClippedSoftmax, DI-Exp, and DI-Normalization, which utilize bit shift to
execute non-linear operators efficiently while maintaining accuracy. The
experiment shows that our I-LLM achieves comparable accuracy to the FP baseline
and outperforms non-integer quantization methods. For example, I-LLM can
operate at W4A4 with negligible loss of accuracy. To our knowledge, we are the
first to bridge the gap between integer-only quantization and LLMs. We've
published our code on anonymous.4open.science, aiming to contribute to the
advancement of this field.
|
[
-0.4927305281162262,
-0.8887138366699219,
0.5692840814590454,
0.3580123782157898,
-0.39822831749916077,
0.35588574409484863,
-0.23609718680381775,
-0.18734322488307953,
0.033397067338228226,
0.29640665650367737,
-0.4923531413078308,
-0.5965952277183533,
-0.571654200553894,
0.018649153411388397,
-0.2805067300796509,
0.5357100963592529,
0.19393467903137207,
0.04396854341030121,
-0.22482499480247498,
-0.11902064085006714,
0.39639317989349365,
-0.6409420967102051,
-0.6047483682632446,
-0.08429273962974548,
0.3957534432411194,
0.26957201957702637,
0.5818943381309509,
0.6222101449966431,
0.47068026661872864,
0.27347466349601746,
-0.19557690620422363,
0.1061670109629631,
-0.4537714719772339,
-0.14297576248645782,
0.03212519362568855,
-0.6292019486427307,
-0.6483471989631653,
-0.287617951631546,
1.0065250396728516,
0.6065329909324646,
-0.02396462857723236,
0.10614772140979767,
-0.2963337302207947,
0.9087731242179871,
-0.8234902024269104,
-0.08239833265542984,
-0.7432454228401184,
0.14971187710762024,
-0.27060195803642273,
0.08511143177747726,
-0.48778796195983887,
-0.4328729212284088,
-0.1949204057455063,
-0.5810660123825073,
-0.17846593260765076,
-0.29824158549308777,
0.4522477686405182,
0.5301995873451233,
-0.8103499412536621,
-0.03358686342835426,
-0.670849084854126,
0.748311460018158,
-1.1486496925354004,
0.46207284927368164,
0.179212749004364,
-0.034911345690488815,
-0.11363215744495392,
-0.8373681306838989,
-0.5566018223762512,
-0.0814221128821373,
0.369553804397583,
0.02247845008969307,
-0.16806074976921082,
0.5288402438163757,
0.4296607971191406,
0.4885617196559906,
-0.25481873750686646,
0.32320332527160645,
-0.10018826276063919,
0.008455655537545681,
0.4424121081829071,
-0.022187190130352974,
-0.09801045060157776,
0.18100471794605255,
-0.43273940682411194,
0.11873557418584824,
-0.9879290461540222,
0.2634645402431488,
0.4061829149723053,
-0.26849520206451416,
-0.18874146044254303,
0.3429339528083801,
-0.3197779953479767,
0.5343378186225891,
0.20765967667102814,
-0.3615492582321167,
0.12087994068861008,
-0.1450902819633484,
-0.23778362572193146,
-0.044373612850904465,
0.9340059757232666,
0.006548076868057251,
0.08391840755939484,
-0.010680895298719406,
-0.3733246326446533,
-0.11606775224208832,
-0.13806651532649994,
-1.2023252248764038,
-0.14525867998600006,
0.3518252670764923,
-0.35858452320098877,
-0.2984425127506256,
-0.048871733248233795,
-0.5407246351242065,
-0.19689656794071198,
-0.16646574437618256,
0.5073614716529846,
-0.4312205910682678,
-0.5241512656211853,
0.08977877348661423,
0.4778130352497101,
0.023610448464751244,
0.4021981954574585,
-0.8142565488815308,
0.5124384760856628,
0.8588587045669556,
0.8887548446655273,
-0.13651998341083527,
0.013977210968732834,
-0.7065567374229431,
-0.15141913294792175,
-0.4485858082771301,
0.34601256251335144,
-0.2668989896774292,
-0.21910206973552704,
-0.1834443360567093,
-0.2703482508659363,
0.17645946145057678,
-0.5684283971786499,
0.27487608790397644,
-0.7566714286804199,
-0.27708402276039124,
0.16317786276340485,
-0.5754441618919373,
-0.2041415125131607,
-0.09740127623081207,
-0.5232177972793579,
0.8724281787872314,
-0.06704826653003693,
-0.34353095293045044,
-0.022111862897872925,
-0.5241439342498779,
-0.11055341362953186,
-0.11718262732028961,
-0.20472238957881927,
-0.6271587610244751,
0.5159050822257996,
0.10713128745555878,
0.0724266916513443,
-0.4184645414352417,
0.43084508180618286,
-0.6901636719703674,
-0.669121265411377,
0.5565181374549866,
-0.9172158241271973,
0.6583349108695984,
0.14122864603996277,
-0.519146203994751,
0.11267902702093124,
-0.7572520971298218,
0.20038200914859772,
-0.17246004939079285,
-0.39404216408729553,
0.04965747520327568,
0.09502016752958298,
-0.4650648832321167,
0.27893999218940735,
0.32631170749664307,
-0.5276063680648804,
0.4020151197910309,
-0.11333569139242172,
0.5395799875259399,
0.9094278216362,
-0.12973132729530334,
0.6245778799057007,
-0.26334148645401,
0.5636580586433411,
0.04284243658185005,
0.11591539531946182,
-0.21725106239318848,
-0.31251949071884155,
-0.7673507928848267,
-0.8656613230705261,
0.5242209434509277,
0.5006402134895325,
-0.7707390189170837,
0.34341639280319214,
-0.5495271682739258,
-0.24057453870773315,
-0.6024637818336487,
-0.023663781583309174,
0.3435409367084503,
0.2370632141828537,
0.048422012478113174,
0.13188627362251282,
-0.1505185216665268,
-0.7752671241760254,
-0.015268616378307343,
-0.10608768463134766,
-0.15168915688991547,
0.08361576497554779,
0.1255418360233307,
-0.08459973335266113,
0.7291364669799805,
-0.20361168682575226,
0.11582638323307037,
0.26015210151672363,
0.25357669591903687,
0.5246620178222656,
0.44657984375953674,
0.21196669340133667,
-0.6294071078300476,
-0.7686513066291809,
-0.24448208510875702,
-0.566493809223175,
-0.45326942205429077,
-0.2002905160188675,
-0.06355530768632889,
0.23580694198608398,
0.6191416382789612,
-0.645444929599762,
0.5037692189216614,
0.6829090714454651,
-0.0939650908112526,
0.24103966355323792,
-0.13267119228839874,
0.050663061439991,
-0.5494107007980347,
-0.12706324458122253,
-0.052010584622621536,
-0.5784884691238403,
-0.6827087998390198,
-0.11063960194587708,
0.4055613577365875,
-0.009361677803099155,
-0.5431308150291443,
0.40015825629234314,
-0.44572481513023376,
-0.2370203286409378,
-0.19202426075935364,
-0.08853746205568314,
0.09428242594003677,
0.6229812502861023,
-0.05901966989040375,
0.930107831954956,
0.5566333532333374,
-0.4339750409126282,
0.052659451961517334,
-0.28276070952415466,
-0.28980690240859985,
0.5321856737136841,
-0.3665394186973572,
0.28691279888153076,
-0.23762761056423187,
0.23139405250549316,
-0.8857029676437378,
0.24273483455181122,
0.06683613359928131,
-0.3540602922439575,
0.23654954135417938,
-0.4761659801006317,
-0.5448774099349976,
0.006118385586887598,
-0.5254181623458862,
0.5044158697128296,
0.7253940105438232,
-0.503474235534668,
0.5728350877761841,
0.0925876721739769,
-0.17963933944702148,
-0.45441901683807373,
-0.4622371196746826,
0.12593784928321838,
-0.3480868935585022,
-0.7190163731575012,
0.3610397279262543,
-0.38586729764938354,
-0.5489638447761536,
-0.13711340725421906,
-0.3323307931423187,
-0.20965896546840668,
0.2904350161552429,
0.2160879671573639,
0.09450861066579819,
-0.4150046408176422,
0.06077469140291214,
0.27687597274780273,
-0.20604588091373444,
0.051081836223602295,
-0.4155502915382385,
0.48290812969207764,
-0.4387683868408203,
-0.6149648427963257,
-0.5560307502746582,
0.258830189704895,
0.7785590887069702,
-0.3068900406360626,
0.45134520530700684,
0.6519590616226196,
-0.3293914496898651,
-0.08432410657405853,
-0.5728987455368042,
-0.14257130026817322,
-0.5632830858230591,
0.41000989079475403,
-0.7141930460929871,
-0.83396315574646,
0.27997225522994995,
-0.3933117985725403,
0.09868974983692169,
0.13577237725257874,
0.6081889271736145,
-0.2038286328315735,
0.9750285148620605,
0.19311925768852234,
0.33107221126556396,
0.6733921766281128,
-0.36596837639808655,
0.31879523396492004,
-0.9471075534820557,
0.1369415670633316,
0.07672469317913055,
-0.3585450053215027,
-0.45162519812583923,
-0.6641262769699097,
0.6374488472938538,
0.5010095238685608,
-0.31860435009002686,
-0.5029862523078918,
-0.3065471351146698,
0.250627338886261,
0.6257070899009705,
0.16264431178569794,
0.49598395824432373,
0.09993933886289597,
0.15055634081363678,
-0.20627574622631073,
-0.44469889998435974,
-0.30526459217071533,
1.0184266567230225,
0.410239577293396,
0.9549493193626404,
0.3525879681110382,
0.6412515044212341,
0.2679379880428314,
0.2544611692428589,
-0.9038363099098206,
0.6680877804756165,
-0.31567180156707764,
-0.2560826539993286,
-0.32569247484207153,
-0.5153975486755371,
-0.6255165338516235,
0.6067110300064087,
-0.14935578405857086,
-0.5918240547180176,
0.16962289810180664,
0.11067245900630951,
-0.3397093415260315,
0.571504533290863,
-0.44134044647216797,
0.3490946292877197,
-0.39611080288887024,
-0.42762717604637146,
-0.3407675325870514,
-0.49870777130126953,
0.5643301606178284,
-0.4499095678329468,
0.4083544611930847,
-0.6458982825279236,
-0.5384988784790039,
0.24430133402347565,
-0.7419807314872742,
0.6022163033485413,
-0.24352124333381653,
-0.08723495155572891,
0.28127312660217285,
0.21559803187847137,
0.6709674000740051,
0.30068594217300415,
-0.3622514307498932,
0.3490702211856842,
-0.08370157331228256,
-0.3567233979701996,
-0.42723318934440613,
0.8033224940299988,
-0.8268041014671326,
-0.5699757933616638,
-0.42152127623558044,
-0.6687450408935547,
-0.20776164531707764,
0.13476110994815826,
-0.04414007440209389,
0.5207836031913757,
0.386457622051239,
0.525679349899292,
0.848170816898346,
-0.021821722388267517,
0.7475425601005554,
0.7411326169967651,
-0.25566592812538147,
-0.8347523212432861,
1.0193626880645752,
0.05559632554650307,
0.8130401968955994,
0.620110273361206,
0.19203297793865204,
-0.32780972123146057,
-0.9071274399757385,
-0.515911877155304,
0.20646245777606964,
-0.563585638999939,
-0.18385621905326843,
-0.6155459880828857,
-0.14641472697257996,
-0.1501130610704422,
-0.08915611356496811,
-0.5227051973342896,
-0.6258525252342224,
-0.4226920008659363,
0.03856007382273674,
0.4802180826663971,
0.3434922993183136,
-0.5681931972503662,
0.5841403603553772,
-0.6610325574874878,
0.6041837930679321,
0.21026863157749176,
0.19272710382938385,
-0.14604943990707397,
-0.43331632018089294,
-0.13134229183197021,
0.33911675214767456,
-0.02258722111582756,
-0.4505613148212433,
0.22031523287296295,
0.5371453166007996,
0.1279984414577484,
0.39868059754371643,
0.22275874018669128,
0.6593549847602844,
-0.3120705187320709,
0.4795725643634796,
0.20332488417625427,
-1.2001839876174927,
-0.1748746931552887,
-0.21277491748332977,
0.43000829219818115,
0.589788019657135,
0.15509682893753052,
-0.43099090456962585,
-0.14657698571681976,
-0.3823307752609253,
-1.034759283065796,
0.6236081123352051,
0.0037364372983574867,
-0.04497242346405983,
0.15190339088439941,
0.33534154295921326,
-0.034093692898750305,
0.5185360908508301,
-0.8870860934257507,
-0.3716982305049896,
-0.06930242478847504,
-0.39081496000289917,
0.4853768050670624,
-0.3543674349784851,
0.14404891431331635,
-0.08514739573001862,
0.6691082715988159,
-0.34131482243537903,
0.22725310921669006,
0.07149802148342133,
-0.35145172476768494,
-0.07290877401828766,
-0.07758807390928268,
0.37302911281585693,
0.8642335534095764,
-0.18041545152664185,
0.3906642496585846,
0.266731858253479,
-0.4014522433280945,
0.425010085105896,
-0.01743364706635475,
-0.3588546812534332,
-0.029845936223864555,
0.09563206136226654,
0.8825865387916565,
0.27621373534202576,
-0.6433417797088623,
0.7134676575660706,
-0.20731514692306519,
-0.1599651426076889,
-0.4574183225631714,
-0.20756013691425323,
0.19797049462795258,
0.3116154670715332,
0.5870734453201294,
-0.20067846775054932,
-0.05714541673660278,
-0.24755343794822693,
0.31830301880836487,
0.5221275687217712,
-0.23136048018932343,
-0.3301718533039093,
0.6317981481552124,
0.05709003657102585,
-0.3436724841594696,
0.6420543193817139,
-0.40048643946647644,
-0.15240107476711273,
0.5985310077667236,
0.46745312213897705,
0.6287660598754883,
-0.06274247914552689,
0.11052191257476807,
0.03681859374046326,
0.10852806270122528,
0.28971174359321594,
0.545841634273529,
-0.14439666271209717,
-0.4193711280822754,
-0.8115827441215515,
-0.5641891956329346,
-0.43243491649627686,
0.15923377871513367,
-0.4794408977031708,
0.38804954290390015,
-0.7893931865692139,
-0.08016697317361832,
-0.2580210566520691,
-0.19322504103183746,
-0.29346469044685364,
0.20507100224494934,
0.48966145515441895,
0.7789221405982971,
-0.27729886770248413,
1.1923631429672241,
0.31345072388648987,
0.14671528339385986,
-0.2595739960670471,
-0.11927122622728348,
-0.018090149387717247,
-0.9587310552597046,
0.3326300084590912,
-0.1008237823843956,
-0.031858179718256,
0.47729241847991943,
-0.4253195524215698,
-1.0082001686096191,
1.1210192441940308,
0.47920987010002136,
-0.8100156784057617,
-0.04722575470805168,
0.4665566682815552,
0.08545797318220139,
0.08431628346443176,
0.4566277265548706,
0.32095012068748474,
0.41182541847229004,
0.2662629783153534,
-0.6337817311286926,
-0.010851560160517693,
-0.0553080178797245,
0.014053505845367908,
0.5193645358085632,
-0.7857012152671814,
1.1697509288787842,
-0.00013915443560108542,
0.04967479780316353,
0.22022026777267456,
0.690593957901001,
0.5399389266967773,
0.04093346372246742,
0.7197389006614685,
0.621566653251648,
0.7500261068344116,
-0.09032636880874634,
0.6607964634895325,
-0.6901095509529114,
0.3898034691810608,
0.8702802658081055,
0.06908812373876572,
0.6368527412414551,
0.660699188709259,
-0.391145795583725,
0.1464615911245346,
0.712233304977417,
0.3614160418510437,
0.6115078926086426,
0.5365671515464783,
-0.9618258476257324,
-0.261669397354126,
-0.053548358380794525,
-0.16114221513271332,
-0.0007385012577287853,
0.6691605448722839,
0.11659525334835052,
-0.015981532633304596,
-0.0702851414680481,
0.25007057189941406,
-0.4062731862068176,
-0.34742164611816406,
0.7762935757637024,
0.4544236660003662,
-0.3143903315067291,
0.884260892868042,
0.013940268196165562,
0.9535204768180847,
-0.8051280379295349,
0.04719789698719978,
-0.22497084736824036,
0.1158023253083229,
-0.28127190470695496,
-0.5066247582435608,
0.12359138578176498,
-0.2930320203304291,
0.0729772076010704,
-0.2548881471157074,
0.4095137119293213,
-0.4792836010456085,
-0.5333775281906128,
0.07703416049480438,
0.3276912569999695,
0.08103890717029572,
-0.4669966399669647,
-0.48465532064437866,
0.3813938796520233,
0.16045132279396057,
-0.323039174079895,
0.44665801525115967,
0.7837544679641724,
-0.05199665203690529,
0.6096494197845459,
0.8231735229492188,
0.06189880147576332,
0.5046384334564209,
-0.1953190714120865,
0.6520313620567322,
-0.57881098985672,
-0.22104358673095703,
-1.0791311264038086,
0.7446588277816772,
0.11515389382839203,
-0.0923394113779068,
0.21731217205524445,
0.5054463148117065,
0.344387412071228,
0.17015154659748077,
0.8440578579902649,
0.053386252373456955,
0.03976151719689369,
-0.5101278424263,
0.1890079379081726,
-0.5365865230560303,
0.34363996982574463,
0.2822798788547516,
-0.8596595525741577,
-0.1650061458349228,
0.5007835030555725,
-0.2270997315645218,
-0.432866632938385,
0.5421851873397827,
0.5731056928634644,
-0.11955701559782028,
-0.37712836265563965,
0.5193254351615906,
0.42476752400398254,
0.704840898513794,
0.5925269722938538,
0.828348696231842,
-0.20849165320396423,
0.5101850628852844,
-0.5065283179283142,
-0.36491823196411133,
-0.3801044523715973,
-1.0629185438156128,
-0.5086092948913574,
-0.18784990906715393,
-0.374849408864975,
-0.21670155227184296,
0.038142137229442596,
0.9570123553276062,
0.6979816555976868,
-0.5249283313751221,
-0.30086416006088257,
-0.259490430355072,
0.32172155380249023,
0.16876403987407684,
-0.1952669769525528,
0.16776736080646515,
-0.1775980442762375,
-1.0003433227539062,
0.49178439378738403,
0.5751802325248718,
0.11656930297613144,
-0.4352245032787323,
-0.014931495301425457,
-0.07865927368402481,
0.1178588718175888,
0.5868254899978638,
0.23124559223651886,
-0.6418250799179077,
-0.0666709914803505,
0.07776428759098053,
-0.14647845923900604,
0.4806664288043976,
0.6470460295677185,
-0.692380964756012,
0.3370373249053955,
0.39001795649528503,
0.7047715783119202,
1.0257014036178589,
-0.01738874241709709,
0.5496978163719177,
-0.43326881527900696,
0.38277867436408997,
0.38252881169319153,
0.2635810375213623,
0.23876900970935822,
-0.25606170296669006,
0.4953455924987793,
0.21536608040332794,
-0.4973260760307312,
-0.8861989974975586,
0.2661137282848358,
-0.7814422845840454,
-0.09169843047857285,
1.20042085647583,
-0.27162042260169983,
-0.1672220081090927,
0.26494985818862915,
0.035857196897268295,
0.01870114356279373,
-0.4749103784561157,
0.4953152537345886,
0.3675048053264618,
-0.2259003072977066,
-0.3054935038089752,
-0.5657850503921509,
0.2947237193584442,
0.3563176095485687,
-0.7507120966911316,
-0.2572261691093445,
0.28296127915382385,
0.2651284337043762,
-0.2951792776584625,
0.9020465612411499,
-0.06978946924209595,
0.07053065299987793,
-0.1739625632762909,
0.18412448465824127,
-0.05661580711603165,
-0.0092648696154356,
-0.48353537917137146,
-0.04616367071866989,
0.3721636235713959,
-0.2132890522480011
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17840v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17840v2
|
Benchmarks Underestimate the Readiness of Multi-lingual Dialogue Agents
| 2024-05-28T05:33:13 | 2024-06-16T20:45:23 |
Andrew H. Lee, Sina J. Semnani, Galo Castillo-López, Gäel de Chalendar, Monojit Choudhury, Ashna Dua, Kapil Rajesh Kavitha, Sungkyun Kim, Prashant Kodali, Ponnurangam Kumaraguru, Alexis Lombard, Mehrad Moradshahi, Gihyun Park, Nasredine Semmar, Jiwon Seo, Tianhao Shen, Manish Shrivastava, Deyi Xiong, Monica S. Lam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Creating multilingual task-oriented dialogue (TOD) agents is challenging due
to the high cost of training data acquisition. Following the research trend of
improving training data efficiency, we show for the first time, that in-context
learning is sufficient to tackle multilingual TOD.
To handle the challenging dialogue state tracking (DST) subtask, we break it
down to simpler steps that are more compatible with in-context learning where
only a handful of few-shot examples are used. We test our approach on the
multilingual TOD dataset X-RiSAWOZ, which has 12 domains in Chinese, English,
French, Korean, Hindi, and code-mixed Hindi-English. Our turn-by-turn DST
accuracy on the 6 languages range from 55.6% to 80.3%, seemingly worse than the
SOTA results from fine-tuned models that achieve from 60.7% to 82.8%; our BLEU
scores in the response generation (RG) subtask are also significantly lower
than SOTA.
However, after manual evaluation of the validation set, we find that by
correcting gold label errors and improving dataset annotation schema, GPT-4
with our prompts can achieve (1) 89.6%-96.8% accuracy in DST, and (2) more than
99% correct response generation across different languages. This leads us to
conclude that current automatic metrics heavily underestimate the effectiveness
of in-context learning.
|
[
-0.4504317343235016,
-0.39665260910987854,
0.5022815465927124,
0.15671434998512268,
-0.21209372580051422,
0.3966352343559265,
-0.28109705448150635,
-0.23621848225593567,
-0.21045547723770142,
0.15105654299259186,
-0.742304801940918,
-0.3402835726737976,
-0.5923976302146912,
0.3435710072517395,
0.051046088337898254,
1.2342764139175415,
-0.12735974788665771,
0.026386398822069168,
-0.08795734494924545,
-0.37526601552963257,
-0.5468048453330994,
-0.5296168327331543,
-0.9138816595077515,
-0.39334046840667725,
0.35223135352134705,
0.5205520987510681,
0.2705026865005493,
0.1257420927286148,
0.05085945129394531,
0.31327688694000244,
0.07059415429830551,
0.3776787221431732,
-0.37083059549331665,
0.19962647557258606,
-0.016843918710947037,
-0.2981727421283722,
-0.6675017476081848,
-0.1049315482378006,
0.524080753326416,
0.5158880949020386,
-0.014015311375260353,
-0.10503819584846497,
0.10825789719820023,
0.6051754951477051,
-0.30830129981040955,
0.5885095000267029,
-0.606846034526825,
-0.08771169185638428,
-0.22230234742164612,
-0.3610844612121582,
-0.48074308037757874,
-0.1256834715604782,
0.31892696022987366,
-0.7979336977005005,
0.03568168357014656,
-0.23900020122528076,
0.6115941405296326,
0.3213244676589966,
-0.7165399193763733,
-0.3814654052257538,
-0.37800532579421997,
0.8419923186302185,
-0.6166371703147888,
0.5283442139625549,
0.45336076617240906,
0.4157426655292511,
-0.28925445675849915,
-0.47811704874038696,
-0.36289840936660767,
-0.2119465172290802,
0.04899362847208977,
0.27338653802871704,
0.06338176876306534,
-0.0707864984869957,
0.49230754375457764,
-0.08948268741369247,
-0.5106266736984253,
-0.15364931523799896,
-0.05829421803355217,
-0.29084229469299316,
0.4581584334373474,
0.23386025428771973,
0.17234916985034943,
-0.05695804953575134,
-0.5291759371757507,
-0.2049083411693573,
-0.6389596462249756,
0.3132587969303131,
0.20304307341575623,
0.6239579916000366,
-0.1359560638666153,
0.26239290833473206,
-0.3282245099544525,
0.45499011874198914,
0.22021931409835815,
-0.4999438226222992,
0.32772815227508545,
-0.8020618557929993,
0.06256303191184998,
0.10708516836166382,
0.5963637232780457,
0.2527719736099243,
0.3361937999725342,
-0.16971305012702942,
-0.313255250453949,
-0.06355897337198257,
0.3171967566013336,
-0.7579511404037476,
-0.0701427161693573,
0.10406510531902313,
0.24221372604370117,
0.5007128119468689,
-0.3126918077468872,
-0.4563405513763428,
-0.18429350852966309,
-0.24659684300422668,
0.3339740037918091,
-0.6050953269004822,
-0.20628388226032257,
-0.12428616732358932,
0.18250514566898346,
0.1716325730085373,
0.6231445670127869,
-0.7631605863571167,
0.08272533863782883,
0.44230952858924866,
0.8376827239990234,
-0.0927550196647644,
-0.5173684358596802,
-0.5883364081382751,
-0.06928306072950363,
-0.5785098075866699,
0.8083658218383789,
-0.1454666256904602,
-0.4381471872329712,
-0.1969323754310608,
0.060139354318380356,
-0.48061510920524597,
-0.2898600101470947,
0.3723859488964081,
-0.3566344976425171,
0.11312046647071838,
-0.5322469472885132,
-0.2561872899532318,
-0.07154795527458191,
0.7128917574882507,
-0.4047279357910156,
0.9265280961990356,
0.3914099335670471,
-0.6787797212600708,
0.7293886542320251,
-0.5622062683105469,
-0.5198084712028503,
0.027590671554207802,
-0.18047212064266205,
-0.13978272676467896,
-0.21711038053035736,
0.39664173126220703,
0.3544175326824188,
-0.19085203111171722,
0.4010387063026428,
0.21802473068237305,
-0.4770132005214691,
0.05830034613609314,
-0.573144257068634,
0.7086634635925293,
0.09516467154026031,
-0.46447664499282837,
-0.15169957280158997,
-0.603096604347229,
0.14566351473331451,
-0.26629912853240967,
-0.6206331849098206,
-0.1564013808965683,
-0.3245609998703003,
-0.08536326885223389,
0.3977813720703125,
-0.04520281031727791,
-0.6810851693153381,
0.09479440003633499,
-0.43830546736717224,
0.17288413643836975,
0.6774991750717163,
-0.220602884888649,
0.3448573350906372,
-0.2954223155975342,
0.7161461114883423,
0.2068958580493927,
-0.18351922929286957,
-0.40451234579086304,
-0.4283909797668457,
-0.6379408836364746,
-0.3741067945957184,
0.18518885970115662,
0.48798510432243347,
-1.3997725248336792,
0.02959051914513111,
-0.5404442548751831,
-0.5515191555023193,
-0.2283969670534134,
-0.014994572848081589,
0.7339745163917542,
0.7065356969833374,
0.22678853571414948,
-0.47722306847572327,
-0.3119012713432312,
-0.607559859752655,
-0.31438690423965454,
-0.1792607456445694,
0.23624497652053833,
0.20273980498313904,
0.564670205116272,
-0.21961049735546112,
0.9084727168083191,
0.12490712851285934,
-0.2953663170337677,
-0.6603367328643799,
0.14446604251861572,
0.08422761410474777,
0.4977249205112457,
0.45943063497543335,
-0.7738675475120544,
-1.123686671257019,
0.3196648061275482,
-0.7092547416687012,
0.12434110790491104,
0.0673656165599823,
0.26195093989372253,
0.6970605850219727,
0.2127988338470459,
-0.5531793236732483,
0.3045015335083008,
0.43255096673965454,
-0.10986573249101639,
0.283561646938324,
-0.1538897454738617,
0.4775322377681732,
-1.1739881038665771,
-0.052257638424634933,
0.09197152405977249,
-0.37828388810157776,
-0.8975592851638794,
-0.3121529817581177,
0.18967078626155853,
-0.10873796790838242,
-0.6583516597747803,
0.7178514003753662,
-0.3482069969177246,
0.032251887023448944,
-0.2220790982246399,
0.2291213423013687,
-0.09844166785478592,
0.8781784176826477,
0.11201955378055573,
1.0913732051849365,
0.510786771774292,
-0.7243764400482178,
0.19261159002780914,
0.2736590504646301,
-0.5617526769638062,
0.8731306195259094,
-0.3427479863166809,
0.24970895051956177,
-0.12034131586551666,
0.6971688270568848,
-0.9306908845901489,
-0.26761287450790405,
0.25834164023399353,
-0.2917931079864502,
0.42853304743766785,
-0.3279367685317993,
-0.37765154242515564,
0.026697464287281036,
-0.009494494646787643,
0.5674356818199158,
0.12056349217891693,
-0.5438458323478699,
0.5965662002563477,
0.28306764364242554,
-0.23208622634410858,
-0.8210980296134949,
-0.5049537420272827,
0.04586010053753853,
-0.33965209126472473,
-0.39301756024360657,
-0.014125488698482513,
-0.0937882736325264,
0.008495805785059929,
-0.4340386986732483,
-0.39322739839553833,
-0.07503604888916016,
-0.00960374716669321,
-0.06351909786462784,
-0.15591777861118317,
0.051294952630996704,
0.11651759594678879,
-0.14282862842082977,
-0.5467488169670105,
-0.26462605595588684,
-0.19118933379650116,
0.4721430540084839,
-0.25107917189598083,
-0.39550691843032837,
-0.5021705031394958,
0.30137792229652405,
0.7175114750862122,
-0.10669263452291489,
0.36190372705459595,
0.5690180659294128,
-0.26054415106773376,
-0.07610617578029633,
-0.19297254085540771,
-0.07222428172826767,
-0.39609479904174805,
0.5593521595001221,
-0.8734910488128662,
-0.49518081545829773,
0.40340396761894226,
-0.03386837616562843,
0.2228521853685379,
0.17281560599803925,
0.35969915986061096,
0.046113260090351105,
1.2865039110183716,
0.5739429593086243,
-0.004036567639559507,
0.4126933515071869,
-0.325684517621994,
0.3636801540851593,
-0.8037856221199036,
-0.16656850278377533,
-0.4390617609024048,
0.033808253705501556,
-0.5666881799697876,
-0.2616761326789856,
0.8333970904350281,
-0.30897802114486694,
-0.18090100586414337,
0.6187658309936523,
0.12342284619808197,
0.2213393747806549,
0.48208194971084595,
-0.010661348700523376,
0.3214864730834961,
-0.049846407026052475,
-0.011956083588302135,
-0.21424487233161926,
-0.9796673059463501,
-0.40574273467063904,
1.0639780759811401,
0.23740018904209137,
0.7242259979248047,
0.17015033960342407,
0.6018053889274597,
0.09265780448913574,
0.16682814061641693,
-0.7039006352424622,
0.4155849814414978,
-0.15637338161468506,
-0.5554022192955017,
-0.3794761300086975,
-0.3504234254360199,
-0.8119606971740723,
0.42053091526031494,
0.33856654167175293,
-0.7535502314567566,
0.16497564315795898,
0.1551801711320877,
-0.2767581045627594,
0.04434264078736305,
-0.8137179613113403,
1.0392699241638184,
-0.19979849457740784,
-0.22131521999835968,
0.009031972847878933,
-0.6442868709564209,
0.04898342117667198,
-0.29129165410995483,
0.20305576920509338,
-0.3035168945789337,
0.17232494056224823,
0.5450824499130249,
-0.31758520007133484,
0.9496647119522095,
-0.4255593419075012,
-0.308206170797348,
0.2363964170217514,
0.008977227844297886,
0.6904559135437012,
0.14988842606544495,
0.023366622626781464,
-0.05198459327220917,
0.1421550214290619,
-0.6521261930465698,
-0.664228081703186,
0.4870644509792328,
-0.4631098508834839,
-0.46407270431518555,
-0.6113789677619934,
-0.7320383191108704,
-0.7450271844863892,
-0.01764986850321293,
0.3781958818435669,
0.7950618267059326,
-0.14148640632629395,
0.12725363671779633,
0.6330677270889282,
0.01976371370255947,
0.37584322690963745,
0.6780167818069458,
0.2390172779560089,
-0.19871313869953156,
0.9649919867515564,
0.2720831334590912,
0.500527560710907,
0.1997619867324829,
0.04906000941991806,
-0.582467794418335,
-0.3564455509185791,
-0.9820652604103088,
-0.11852288246154785,
-0.8238236308097839,
-0.241768941283226,
-0.73362797498703,
0.010974373668432236,
-0.2971349060535431,
-0.03389845788478851,
-0.5607885718345642,
-0.11033892631530762,
0.2545020878314972,
-0.0001755143457558006,
0.1664818823337555,
0.54960036277771,
0.12147089838981628,
0.2852012515068054,
-0.7141584157943726,
0.10434306412935257,
0.2824785113334656,
0.1036999449133873,
-0.17322631180286407,
-0.6023055911064148,
-0.654239296913147,
0.355350524187088,
-0.2305731177330017,
-0.5025962591171265,
0.22859300673007965,
0.36945003271102905,
0.6127968430519104,
-0.013286743313074112,
0.1587781012058258,
0.8949628472328186,
-0.36335936188697815,
0.8654101490974426,
-0.053310129791498184,
-0.8173748254776001,
0.5533673763275146,
-0.4461854100227356,
0.6475825905799866,
0.6487046480178833,
0.47804155945777893,
-0.6512333154678345,
-0.5733078122138977,
-0.5353621244430542,
-0.731274425983429,
1.27486252784729,
-0.025499004870653152,
0.21729688346385956,
-0.023799659684300423,
-0.05008159577846527,
0.35189858078956604,
0.23992733657360077,
-0.6234822273254395,
-0.05293452739715576,
-0.3119826316833496,
-0.05532025173306465,
-0.5147930979728699,
0.06616651266813278,
-0.19921153783798218,
-0.10919512063264847,
0.8351912498474121,
-0.6819331049919128,
-0.026216229423880577,
0.226737841963768,
-0.32372260093688965,
-0.002301015891134739,
0.46731218695640564,
0.6030190587043762,
0.8107045292854309,
-0.130702406167984,
-0.15432745218276978,
0.36724749207496643,
-0.34703636169433594,
0.3889249265193939,
0.12842825055122375,
-0.1055661290884018,
-0.040426645427942276,
0.35521838068962097,
0.8553804159164429,
0.2865769863128662,
-0.8786987662315369,
0.49549275636672974,
-0.22519971430301666,
-0.07512500882148743,
-0.15723943710327148,
-0.09692217409610748,
-0.35294055938720703,
0.3434702754020691,
0.343856543302536,
0.1008777990937233,
-0.05233871191740036,
-0.7813239097595215,
0.13587403297424316,
0.34739771485328674,
-0.5442031025886536,
-0.33667391538619995,
0.22549749910831451,
0.23384535312652588,
-0.07573159039020538,
0.4475175738334656,
-0.4260355532169342,
-0.7270460724830627,
0.531959593296051,
0.5476811528205872,
0.771676778793335,
-0.09443755447864532,
0.3212633728981018,
0.4688202738761902,
0.16432879865169525,
-0.23703299462795258,
0.14603033661842346,
-0.31556960940361023,
-0.7669180035591125,
-0.34357038140296936,
-0.2828693389892578,
-0.5741392374038696,
-0.10675555467605591,
-0.43277618288993835,
-0.06304498016834259,
-0.12294142693281174,
-0.28119659423828125,
-0.4142625033855438,
0.34877267479896545,
-0.7342274188995361,
0.36575067043304443,
-0.2848967909812927,
0.6706463098526001,
-0.7577925324440002,
1.033962607383728,
0.812197744846344,
-0.2426334172487259,
-0.7083196043968201,
0.11875014007091522,
0.08389665186405182,
-0.6155551075935364,
0.6215002536773682,
0.299356073141098,
-0.2525351345539093,
0.05024566128849983,
0.11917772144079208,
-0.7814517021179199,
0.9583595395088196,
0.4013756513595581,
-0.24406588077545166,
0.15810930728912354,
-0.013279249891638756,
0.6833744049072266,
-0.3791247010231018,
0.3868926763534546,
0.7236340045928955,
0.43804824352264404,
-0.11274144798517227,
-1.3276880979537964,
-0.10087601840496063,
-0.21956856548786163,
-0.09477753937244415,
0.15954191982746124,
-0.734976589679718,
0.9279918074607849,
-0.09831234812736511,
-0.4463008940219879,
0.08295415341854095,
0.21345694363117218,
0.24192072451114655,
0.5250886082649231,
0.7164873480796814,
0.37689608335494995,
0.5279555916786194,
-0.4017218053340912,
1.0376253128051758,
-0.11231908947229385,
0.1348920613527298,
0.9807192087173462,
-0.28980350494384766,
0.4215535819530487,
0.49156174063682556,
-0.04743229225277901,
0.2816237509250641,
0.6983603239059448,
0.5112878680229187,
0.6063281297683716,
-0.22731070220470428,
-0.25939837098121643,
-0.2521764636039734,
-0.32198023796081543,
-0.19427478313446045,
0.581830620765686,
0.3859166204929352,
0.21152371168136597,
-0.37545859813690186,
0.3388785719871521,
0.03200859948992729,
0.13681086897850037,
-0.009002146311104298,
0.8959076404571533,
-0.06998708844184875,
-1.0647470951080322,
0.8290867805480957,
-0.3379998207092285,
0.5347867608070374,
-0.8409038782119751,
0.06733082234859467,
-0.4950522780418396,
0.19244909286499023,
0.029366984963417053,
-0.5392462015151978,
0.0641341358423233,
0.253277450799942,
0.03046221286058426,
-0.4734308123588562,
0.19837895035743713,
-0.6347994804382324,
-0.15358726680278778,
0.3599781095981598,
0.8231514096260071,
0.31589287519454956,
0.019900474697351456,
-0.5589478015899658,
-0.14518016576766968,
0.16922767460346222,
-0.23394539952278137,
0.4839654564857483,
0.554690420627594,
-0.35740289092063904,
0.8027840852737427,
0.3605307936668396,
-0.08151599019765854,
0.05562639981508255,
0.1604912281036377,
0.6600940823554993,
-0.4003635048866272,
-0.4963589906692505,
-0.40369999408721924,
0.6990364193916321,
0.10517733544111252,
-0.5267823338508606,
0.7483802437782288,
0.35304924845695496,
1.312732458114624,
-0.014632288366556168,
0.9387255907058716,
-0.18027016520500183,
0.6211750507354736,
-0.6050504446029663,
0.35448935627937317,
-0.8337053656578064,
0.17862528562545776,
-0.19549225270748138,
-0.8733479976654053,
0.11283481121063232,
0.3850606381893158,
-0.15924325585365295,
0.2220214605331421,
0.8084118962287903,
0.8668292164802551,
-0.07089768350124359,
-0.18448223173618317,
0.5150162577629089,
-0.11228703707456589,
0.49620094895362854,
0.8241618871688843,
0.9061794281005859,
-0.6335223913192749,
0.6094850897789001,
-0.5010243058204651,
-0.1376398652791977,
-0.052711669355630875,
-0.6586471199989319,
-0.9688782691955566,
-0.8818770051002502,
-0.22853486239910126,
-0.11293409019708633,
0.20457758009433746,
0.9571168422698975,
0.7551640868186951,
-0.7881060242652893,
-0.29412180185317993,
0.12858378887176514,
-0.0015961740864440799,
-0.47192543745040894,
-0.11213469505310059,
0.213218554854393,
-0.8291448950767517,
-1.213409185409546,
0.8142504096031189,
0.15314550697803497,
0.13222625851631165,
-0.09284970909357071,
-0.4025641083717346,
-0.11407896876335144,
-0.22457122802734375,
0.5886656045913696,
0.43898263573646545,
-0.7457877993583679,
-0.302351176738739,
-0.09945791959762573,
-0.29905879497528076,
0.182062566280365,
0.9042596817016602,
-0.6923591494560242,
0.7951464056968689,
0.27006569504737854,
0.6582745909690857,
0.4725557565689087,
0.04053677245974541,
0.8424353003501892,
-0.9981117844581604,
0.2821360230445862,
0.1655375063419342,
0.4063088595867157,
0.4869481921195984,
-0.11009232699871063,
0.6031224131584167,
0.12468475848436356,
-0.4491384029388428,
-0.7891132831573486,
0.2897898852825165,
-0.7239603996276855,
0.022980328649282455,
0.9030070304870605,
-0.4568382501602173,
0.0717676505446434,
-0.5641274452209473,
-0.39502933621406555,
0.2561012804508209,
-0.6154921650886536,
0.6416669487953186,
0.7423211336135864,
-0.3022123873233795,
-0.0753190815448761,
-0.5833480954170227,
0.7926885485649109,
0.5983768701553345,
-0.6898019313812256,
0.15179109573364258,
0.2765178382396698,
0.12752994894981384,
0.24501028656959534,
1.0872186422348022,
0.1625809371471405,
0.5181499719619751,
0.04432123526930809,
-0.3833197355270386,
0.05978282168507576,
-0.6916300058364868,
-0.2723768949508667,
-0.1946093887090683,
0.09009335190057755,
-0.17217464745044708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00045v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00045v1
|
Personalized Steering of Large Language Models: Versatile Steering Vectors Through Bi-directional Preference Optimization
| 2024-05-28T05:10:40 | 2024-05-28T05:10:40 |
Yuanpu Cao, Tianrong Zhang, Bochuan Cao, Ziyi Yin, Lu Lin, Fenglong Ma, Jinghui Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Researchers have been studying approaches to steer the behavior of Large
Language Models (LLMs) and build personalized LLMs tailored for various
applications. While fine-tuning seems to be a direct solution, it requires
substantial computational resources and may significantly affect the utility of
the original LLM. Recent endeavors have introduced more lightweight strategies,
focusing on extracting "steering vectors" to guide the model's output toward
desired behaviors by adjusting activations within specific layers of the LLM's
transformer architecture. However, such steering vectors are directly extracted
from the activations of human preference data and thus often lead to suboptimal
results and occasional failures, especially in alignment-related scenarios.
This work proposes an innovative approach that could produce more effective
steering vectors through bi-directional preference optimization. Our method is
designed to allow steering vectors to directly influence the generation
probability of contrastive human preference data pairs, thereby offering a more
precise representation of the target behavior. By carefully adjusting the
direction and magnitude of the steering vector, we enabled personalized control
over the desired behavior across a spectrum of intensities. Extensive
experimentation across various open-ended generation tasks, particularly
focusing on steering AI personas, has validated the efficacy of our approach.
Moreover, we comprehensively investigate critical alignment-concerning
scenarios, such as managing truthfulness, mitigating hallucination, and
addressing jailbreaking attacks. Remarkably, our method can still demonstrate
outstanding steering effectiveness across these scenarios. Furthermore, we
showcase the transferability of our steering vectors across different
models/LoRAs and highlight the synergistic benefits of applying multiple
vectors simultaneously.
|
[
-0.6692821979522705,
-0.635141134262085,
0.37381261587142944,
0.3811229169368744,
-0.2568957805633545,
0.17966824769973755,
-0.6087291836738586,
-0.20499205589294434,
0.3962533175945282,
0.3674173057079315,
-0.5516136288642883,
-0.38766011595726013,
-0.5024482011795044,
-0.2353675365447998,
-0.23797889053821564,
1.0348923206329346,
0.11649486422538757,
0.13939133286476135,
-0.14627085626125336,
-0.31019943952560425,
-0.7549927234649658,
-0.5419886112213135,
-0.5269985795021057,
-0.5454912185668945,
0.769507884979248,
0.7981701493263245,
0.8135049343109131,
0.6398019790649414,
0.37307649850845337,
0.2645125091075897,
-0.09174301475286484,
-0.015675103291869164,
-0.7046129107475281,
0.26444151997566223,
-0.3730395436286926,
-0.21915484964847565,
-0.4741694927215576,
-0.11571614444255829,
0.4273369014263153,
0.7195997834205627,
-0.16117697954177856,
-0.15566210448741913,
0.34282732009887695,
0.9118147492408752,
-0.5188478827476501,
-0.17393440008163452,
-0.6076254844665527,
0.04051985219120979,
-0.4158723056316376,
-0.3554094731807709,
-0.31174755096435547,
-0.21324628591537476,
0.41401249170303345,
-0.5726898312568665,
0.05783728137612343,
0.24143745005130768,
0.6511797308921814,
0.23086905479431152,
-0.44209548830986023,
-0.1675030142068863,
-1.1141606569290161,
0.9790904521942139,
-0.5258587598800659,
0.4293183982372284,
0.23190240561962128,
0.2886744737625122,
-0.2128869891166687,
-0.3060760796070099,
-0.4240538477897644,
-0.2877679467201233,
0.2249186784029007,
0.08831381797790527,
-0.1667410135269165,
-0.03687380254268646,
-0.08844070136547089,
-0.14736820757389069,
-0.3935047686100006,
0.5434139966964722,
-0.01753665693104267,
-0.1479424238204956,
0.6679797768592834,
0.12824746966362,
0.09585638344287872,
0.09323276579380035,
-0.4063880443572998,
-0.2912219762802124,
-0.7459253668785095,
0.25683027505874634,
0.6963659524917603,
0.32002848386764526,
-0.23814819753170013,
0.7958909273147583,
-0.39025574922561646,
0.5974199771881104,
0.5645937323570251,
-0.031332630664110184,
0.3840430676937103,
-0.4017942249774933,
0.17107877135276794,
0.16337555646896362,
0.8053635954856873,
0.4793221652507782,
0.20890040695667267,
-0.26333484053611755,
-0.2086254358291626,
-0.1348966360092163,
0.4055207073688507,
-0.5759430527687073,
-0.14274166524410248,
0.3227751553058624,
-0.5166561007499695,
-0.5877294540405273,
-0.001247523119673133,
-1.0628188848495483,
-0.5886485576629639,
-0.6936421394348145,
0.1453278511762619,
-0.39481979608535767,
-0.10298217087984085,
0.14932560920715332,
0.09370603412389755,
0.4433057904243469,
0.14247296750545502,
-1.2443222999572754,
-0.0432780459523201,
0.8949431777000427,
0.7030947208404541,
-0.7163046002388,
-0.21484582126140594,
-0.7268315553665161,
0.3566802740097046,
-0.1193077340722084,
0.6905235052108765,
-0.7255645394325256,
-0.5196771621704102,
-0.03735296428203583,
-0.4391699433326721,
0.2800405025482178,
-0.47816726565361023,
0.6890416741371155,
-0.48910602927207947,
0.15557965636253357,
-0.33294978737831116,
-0.3131001889705658,
0.011770792305469513,
0.1452503800392151,
-0.45848530530929565,
0.7390303611755371,
-0.1391441375017166,
-0.7568342685699463,
0.18708984553813934,
-0.5880396962165833,
-0.7060608267784119,
-0.09105020761489868,
-0.3392312824726105,
-0.6342067718505859,
0.2219366729259491,
0.21883051097393036,
0.5388855338096619,
-0.2913643419742584,
0.404525488615036,
-0.39640218019485474,
-0.02029753476381302,
0.1654060035943985,
-0.13759011030197144,
0.5133634209632874,
-0.030976830050349236,
-0.48879387974739075,
0.7480096817016602,
-0.6109505891799927,
-0.2886379361152649,
0.16020864248275757,
-0.307878315448761,
-0.6005744338035583,
0.2951486110687256,
0.1155179888010025,
0.10329197347164154,
0.4429800808429718,
-0.43396544456481934,
0.187240868806839,
-0.4420170485973358,
0.20898222923278809,
1.0659736394882202,
-0.12434472888708115,
0.9206560850143433,
-0.38963863253593445,
0.5379554629325867,
0.06498723477125168,
0.10894620418548584,
0.3609486222267151,
-0.458755224943161,
-0.872505247592926,
-0.1319609433412552,
0.14627289772033691,
0.4616985619068146,
-0.7139260172843933,
0.7598652243614197,
-0.26844990253448486,
-0.5004628300666809,
-0.31088048219680786,
0.3503226637840271,
0.40176475048065186,
0.7676200866699219,
0.39123454689979553,
-0.26226627826690674,
-0.4286119341850281,
-1.0615266561508179,
-0.31455501914024353,
0.04749321937561035,
0.05521769821643829,
0.3365049362182617,
0.10333532840013504,
-0.26196423172950745,
1.0628528594970703,
-0.6329464316368103,
-0.21839378774166107,
-0.5164921879768372,
0.05871986970305443,
0.05720939487218857,
0.4159623980522156,
0.5895868539810181,
-1.0884251594543457,
-0.5608962774276733,
0.2974907159805298,
-0.3770489990711212,
-0.27642175555229187,
-0.15164580941200256,
-0.6000195145606995,
0.06616578251123428,
0.36330467462539673,
-0.3321813941001892,
0.10484028607606888,
0.5884799957275391,
-0.42833852767944336,
0.597541332244873,
-0.31266871094703674,
-0.36226701736450195,
-1.0063867568969727,
0.02692762203514576,
0.18336017429828644,
-0.0817902684211731,
-0.7687436938285828,
-0.2546270787715912,
-0.07927596569061279,
0.3549703359603882,
-0.26680493354797363,
0.4880082309246063,
-0.1583922803401947,
-0.019820746034383774,
-0.20943830907344818,
0.14647041261196136,
-0.24575361609458923,
0.6080318689346313,
0.13068042695522308,
0.4579336941242218,
0.4000672996044159,
-0.5605394244194031,
0.4415311813354492,
0.3631746470928192,
-0.0954715758562088,
0.7546517848968506,
-0.6529962420463562,
0.23237837851047516,
-0.34451788663864136,
-0.1174582988023758,
-0.8726849555969238,
-0.12288400530815125,
0.24141108989715576,
-0.1329956203699112,
0.3457333445549011,
-0.06301314383745193,
-0.06301792711019516,
0.10968537628650665,
-0.489597886800766,
0.1313612014055252,
0.5094673037528992,
-0.6224638223648071,
0.7949222326278687,
0.5454066395759583,
-0.49664539098739624,
-0.5049556493759155,
-0.2423585206270218,
-0.057916395366191864,
-0.565539538860321,
-0.5471994280815125,
0.6249819397926331,
-0.2541481554508209,
-0.24307014048099518,
-0.20602166652679443,
0.038302499800920486,
0.46098417043685913,
0.11049714684486389,
0.3129845857620239,
0.5780236721038818,
0.04377017542719841,
-0.09265675395727158,
0.24313826858997345,
-0.43890899419784546,
-0.13049732148647308,
-0.4325448274612427,
0.8843845129013062,
-0.07148316502571106,
-0.38168659806251526,
-0.22728519141674042,
0.35650596022605896,
0.46710386872291565,
-0.586764395236969,
0.6237605810165405,
0.7385293245315552,
0.05763009190559387,
-0.11792225390672684,
-0.5372032523155212,
-0.15680214762687683,
-0.5162891745567322,
0.48250627517700195,
-0.3098498582839966,
-0.808566153049469,
0.2722471058368683,
-0.06870847195386887,
0.28492847084999084,
0.10388827323913574,
0.9664297699928284,
-0.3281148374080658,
1.2765514850616455,
0.6644094586372375,
-0.5639757513999939,
0.8177391886711121,
-0.06689813733100891,
0.24483449757099152,
-0.8576501607894897,
-0.45953091979026794,
-0.6176099181175232,
-0.8632417917251587,
-0.6794882416725159,
-0.22676996886730194,
0.6175445318222046,
-0.05632850155234337,
-0.34593793749809265,
0.15400834381580353,
-0.47283101081848145,
0.22014640271663666,
0.8346128463745117,
-0.02719612792134285,
0.25620004534721375,
0.1332298070192337,
-0.2291734516620636,
-0.05469902604818344,
-0.6146339178085327,
-0.45084065198898315,
1.0790714025497437,
0.316584974527359,
0.8337545394897461,
0.1932595670223236,
0.6748961806297302,
0.010515042580664158,
0.1612270027399063,
-0.9313632249832153,
0.6263630986213684,
-0.2935357689857483,
-0.16425085067749023,
-0.43220025300979614,
-0.3961849510669708,
-1.0154041051864624,
0.1881607472896576,
-0.6006917953491211,
-0.6718568205833435,
0.19874326884746552,
0.40335872769355774,
-0.2948629856109619,
0.04859442636370659,
-0.5370597243309021,
0.8768457174301147,
-0.7100539207458496,
-0.5350510478019714,
-0.329168438911438,
-0.8174352049827576,
0.08092669397592545,
-0.18023841083049774,
0.049827903509140015,
-0.08923853188753128,
-0.1653740257024765,
0.6405379176139832,
-0.09884598106145859,
0.7912487983703613,
-0.23674805462360382,
-0.09326877444982529,
-0.24302706122398376,
0.05784175917506218,
0.7632301449775696,
-0.1505904346704483,
-0.0944422110915184,
0.1512703001499176,
-0.38094085454940796,
-0.1408156454563141,
-0.5372238159179688,
0.8584827780723572,
-0.8951919078826904,
-0.536276638507843,
-0.040152788162231445,
-0.567139744758606,
-0.5002395510673523,
0.27581945061683655,
0.34023797512054443,
0.2919948995113373,
-0.2617606520652771,
0.2802914083003998,
0.6354842185974121,
-0.31741005182266235,
0.4354937672615051,
0.3335341811180115,
-0.2975158393383026,
-0.27305111289024353,
1.1832640171051025,
-0.19925545156002045,
0.13930629193782806,
0.6009597182273865,
0.6695561408996582,
-0.3487773835659027,
-0.9417672753334045,
-0.35190728306770325,
0.1622459888458252,
-0.29676324129104614,
0.006596526131033897,
-0.3083876669406891,
0.19184812903404236,
-0.2176586389541626,
-0.45842695236206055,
-0.5280581712722778,
-0.3303144574165344,
-0.3137255311012268,
0.02676251530647278,
0.20062695443630219,
0.5339745283126831,
0.20786352455615997,
0.3442428410053253,
-0.5467182397842407,
0.4305107593536377,
0.1983637660741806,
0.2575211226940155,
-0.09180226176977158,
-0.3210163414478302,
-0.1350143998861313,
0.027328716591000557,
-0.43946146965026855,
-0.6414774656295776,
0.48333433270454407,
-0.017257576808333397,
0.6010863780975342,
0.6562685370445251,
0.0189464520663023,
0.4936041235923767,
-0.5724456310272217,
0.44095754623413086,
0.31844058632850647,
-0.7794988751411438,
0.4826396405696869,
-0.3828853964805603,
0.18494457006454468,
0.5069912672042847,
0.41703474521636963,
-0.48872679471969604,
-0.20916107296943665,
-0.18880431354045868,
-0.9863249063491821,
0.5437754392623901,
0.11914004385471344,
0.14080557227134705,
0.4227334260940552,
0.3021789789199829,
0.17852750420570374,
0.21404382586479187,
-0.2992086708545685,
-0.44650447368621826,
-0.17393308877944946,
-0.3844868540763855,
-0.33268240094184875,
-0.22414882481098175,
-0.17169316112995148,
-0.2516556978225708,
0.7283105850219727,
-0.2283959686756134,
-0.07031179964542389,
-0.2215406894683838,
0.18107163906097412,
0.038058090955019,
0.2524496912956238,
0.6338918805122375,
0.3663918673992157,
-0.05907594785094261,
0.11703949421644211,
-0.04318984970450401,
-0.41909825801849365,
0.14371350407600403,
0.10938579589128494,
-0.48454976081848145,
-0.3000240623950958,
-0.00010891407146118581,
0.8995636105537415,
0.17273977398872375,
-0.5892314314842224,
0.44836243987083435,
-0.0043916255235672,
0.026249999180436134,
-0.2635449767112732,
0.07198388129472733,
0.2868318259716034,
0.3583253026008606,
0.049294423311948776,
0.20683225989341736,
-0.02104928158223629,
-0.18720084428787231,
-0.1916881799697876,
0.8207222819328308,
-0.3342510759830475,
-0.5033823251724243,
0.7290835976600647,
0.5099225640296936,
-0.41564279794692993,
0.4820813238620758,
-0.06815747171640396,
-0.47376179695129395,
0.22106434404850006,
0.43519657850265503,
0.9965631365776062,
-0.2185632586479187,
0.12339100986719131,
-0.039542462676763535,
-0.06368289887905121,
-0.04397134482860565,
0.09645283222198486,
0.010721640661358833,
-1.1686006784439087,
-0.15580019354820251,
-0.5817968249320984,
-0.4212215542793274,
-0.11177904158830643,
-0.7236478328704834,
0.4713282883167267,
-0.3957626223564148,
-0.19660180807113647,
0.1280757039785385,
-0.2977699041366577,
-0.5674294829368591,
-0.2434389889240265,
0.28796830773353577,
0.7037959694862366,
-0.5890610218048096,
0.920329749584198,
0.8693622946739197,
-0.060330167412757874,
-0.5142916440963745,
0.026829808950424194,
0.14196015894412994,
-0.6586124300956726,
0.5331002473831177,
-0.17539286613464355,
-0.43815696239471436,
-0.08076276630163193,
-0.4396364986896515,
-0.6509562134742737,
1.028136134147644,
0.3551320433616638,
-0.8413521647453308,
-0.10261960327625275,
0.20906294882297516,
0.4367922842502594,
-0.45598646998405457,
-0.2542588412761688,
0.7774716019630432,
0.5556231141090393,
0.2449820190668106,
-0.77178955078125,
-0.1477060317993164,
-0.07028550654649734,
0.21354985237121582,
0.2663925886154175,
-0.6386764049530029,
0.49291980266571045,
-0.2760699689388275,
0.28013572096824646,
-0.07446567714214325,
0.8347973823547363,
0.30704548954963684,
0.09675146639347076,
0.7172570824623108,
0.3606933355331421,
0.6295238137245178,
0.11796152591705322,
0.9997795224189758,
-0.46648702025413513,
0.002599600236862898,
1.1988216638565063,
-0.49252641201019287,
0.9850154519081116,
0.8184368014335632,
0.14634256064891815,
0.37827998399734497,
0.12446047365665436,
0.24111396074295044,
0.7106941342353821,
0.041491035372018814,
-0.2262628823518753,
-0.3398793637752533,
-0.13358521461486816,
-0.052251167595386505,
0.7281383275985718,
0.1902335286140442,
-0.08224308490753174,
0.06785960495471954,
0.21486808359622955,
0.07056313008069992,
0.21422486007213593,
-0.1634022444486618,
0.7380385994911194,
-0.16373170912265778,
-0.8120338320732117,
0.11649400740861893,
0.33788686990737915,
0.914569616317749,
-0.7413055896759033,
0.2075200378894806,
-0.1836307793855667,
0.33171841502189636,
-0.13203778862953186,
-0.7814562916755676,
0.09665008634328842,
0.01192979235202074,
-0.13403677940368652,
-0.6009618043899536,
0.7834699153900146,
-0.553689181804657,
-0.25857990980148315,
0.3218437433242798,
0.36777758598327637,
-0.2932411730289459,
-0.04393173009157181,
-0.5018104314804077,
0.25398916006088257,
0.21145346760749817,
-0.439540833234787,
0.5532504320144653,
-0.00017328394460491836,
-0.1048256978392601,
0.8219584822654724,
0.7792499661445618,
0.2699548006057739,
-0.034733887761831284,
0.13093958795070648,
0.9408074021339417,
-0.6281391382217407,
-0.600400984287262,
-0.9217399954795837,
0.40054571628570557,
-0.08875670284032822,
-0.35748642683029175,
0.8246050477027893,
0.617226779460907,
0.8946647644042969,
-0.04731244593858719,
0.9143938422203064,
0.009538897313177586,
0.4470168948173523,
-0.5277197957038879,
0.5525358319282532,
-0.321382075548172,
0.3878976106643677,
-0.15861089527606964,
-1.0426051616668701,
-0.14233852922916412,
0.6079837083816528,
-0.44615212082862854,
0.032991789281368256,
0.18964441120624542,
0.7786654829978943,
-0.09048977494239807,
-0.03532465547323227,
0.22559680044651031,
0.22194398939609528,
0.5195757150650024,
0.606941819190979,
0.8058222532272339,
0.3455529808998108,
0.39455467462539673,
-0.5667116045951843,
-0.30761343240737915,
-0.39118266105651855,
-1.0383309125900269,
-0.8564858436584473,
-0.5837960243225098,
-0.23761889338493347,
-0.2580558955669403,
-0.17357294261455536,
1.2608437538146973,
0.7201616168022156,
-0.846630334854126,
-0.3851102292537689,
0.04575161263346672,
0.12844598293304443,
-0.11533302068710327,
-0.15681837499141693,
0.22052687406539917,
-0.16937927901744843,
-0.8471313714981079,
0.486286461353302,
0.42876309156417847,
0.06571061164140701,
-0.4860806465148926,
-0.45760342478752136,
0.02910679019987583,
-0.168307363986969,
0.7365586757659912,
0.3515876829624176,
-0.5320099592208862,
-0.35291874408721924,
0.04179665818810463,
-0.10722438991069794,
0.14190515875816345,
0.9168310165405273,
-0.6101768612861633,
0.5104029178619385,
0.677436351776123,
0.7318447828292847,
0.46165528893470764,
0.21652339398860931,
0.8909132480621338,
-0.7075664401054382,
0.1350414901971817,
0.22229662537574768,
0.31215032935142517,
0.28692466020584106,
-0.23108382523059845,
0.1181512102484703,
-0.03832258656620979,
-0.43808314204216003,
-0.4395672678947449,
0.3147806227207184,
-1.326992154121399,
-0.05082462728023529,
1.3676677942276,
0.21106258034706116,
0.06724048405885696,
-0.1432994157075882,
-0.4964160621166229,
0.10406620055437088,
-0.5269838571548462,
0.6609424948692322,
0.49702131748199463,
-0.4513593018054962,
0.1655607670545578,
-0.3731047809123993,
0.4226757884025574,
0.6834821701049805,
-0.7102475762367249,
0.07255838066339493,
0.38665661215782166,
0.2929701805114746,
0.046527374535799026,
0.2968606650829315,
0.07512333244085312,
-0.1828579604625702,
-0.6145926117897034,
0.1012398898601532,
-0.11194045841693878,
-0.36621105670928955,
-0.6346741318702698,
0.13708555698394775,
0.24903294444084167,
-0.14190109074115753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17830v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17830v1
|
More Than Catastrophic Forgetting: Integrating General Capabilities For Domain-Specific LLMs
| 2024-05-28T05:00:12 | 2024-05-28T05:00:12 |
Chengyuan Liu, Shihang Wang, Yangyang Kang, Lizhi Qing, Fubang Zhao, Changlong Sun, Kun Kuang, Fei Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The performance on general tasks decreases after Large Language Models (LLMs)
are fine-tuned on domain-specific tasks, the phenomenon is known as
Catastrophic Forgetting (CF). However, this paper presents a further challenge
for real application of domain-specific LLMs beyond CF, called General
Capabilities Integration (GCI), which necessitates the integration of both the
general capabilities and domain knowledge within a single instance. The
objective of GCI is not merely to retain previously acquired general
capabilities alongside new domain knowledge, but to harmonize and utilize both
sets of skills in a cohesive manner to enhance performance on domain-specific
tasks. Taking legal domain as an example, we carefully design three groups of
training and testing tasks without lacking practicability, and construct the
corresponding datasets. To better incorporate general capabilities across
domain-specific scenarios, we introduce ALoRA, which utilizes a multi-head
attention module upon LoRA, facilitating direct information transfer from
preceding tokens to the current one. This enhancement permits the
representation to dynamically switch between domain-specific knowledge and
general competencies according to the attention. Extensive experiments are
conducted on the proposed tasks. The results exhibit the significance of our
setting, and the effectiveness of our method.
|
[
-0.3953656554222107,
-0.7114744186401367,
0.7208585143089294,
0.0008569618221372366,
-0.11008044332265854,
0.2658763825893402,
-0.27620014548301697,
-0.5105690956115723,
0.19435857236385345,
0.49961423873901367,
-0.44553524255752563,
-0.5420509576797485,
-0.6447558999061584,
-0.2528771460056305,
-0.4339430034160614,
1.1489520072937012,
-0.33583784103393555,
-0.3941148519515991,
-0.3448144495487213,
-0.5405316948890686,
-0.7614657282829285,
-0.7573401927947998,
-0.6705846190452576,
-0.3375452756881714,
0.5743903517723083,
0.3232588469982147,
0.32472243905067444,
0.35397544503211975,
0.5777075886726379,
0.186869278550148,
0.1661449372768402,
0.42059236764907837,
-0.515923798084259,
-0.11079604923725128,
-0.6870336532592773,
-0.4322280287742615,
-0.8380712270736694,
-0.094526506960392,
0.6231432557106018,
0.8182477951049805,
-0.23858819901943207,
0.055445171892642975,
0.19818273186683655,
0.5357545614242554,
-0.7530191540718079,
0.20381790399551392,
-0.6644538044929504,
0.11266163736581802,
0.10081000626087189,
-0.3312513828277588,
-0.2833485007286072,
-0.08854051679372787,
0.2625131607055664,
-0.8823010325431824,
0.25519660115242004,
-0.008296352811157703,
0.6885669231414795,
0.45327383279800415,
-0.24212898313999176,
-0.5440365076065063,
-0.9424836039543152,
0.9368166923522949,
-0.14340262115001678,
0.2413128912448883,
0.37757065892219543,
0.20907630026340485,
0.0951949805021286,
-0.41062936186790466,
-0.4394029378890991,
-0.15285706520080566,
0.14955519139766693,
0.20466209948062897,
-0.3327109217643738,
0.05301626771688461,
0.08444464951753616,
0.21647803485393524,
-0.3320522606372833,
0.12366542220115662,
-0.20153112709522247,
-0.20323395729064941,
0.4435703456401825,
0.3150539994239807,
0.340732216835022,
0.5582482218742371,
-0.012095012702047825,
0.16507576406002045,
-0.7600560784339905,
-0.1027640849351883,
0.1049831286072731,
0.4377397894859314,
-0.10645032674074173,
0.37280988693237305,
-0.19406647980213165,
0.361476868391037,
-0.0031169471330940723,
-0.2915494441986084,
0.2826167047023773,
-0.35058465600013733,
-0.24481576681137085,
-0.36174848675727844,
0.28341907262802124,
-0.22819124162197113,
0.47433045506477356,
-0.4958435893058777,
0.07016842067241669,
0.0583992637693882,
0.5474284887313843,
-0.23553453385829926,
0.0697120875120163,
0.2809813618659973,
-0.1784103363752365,
0.14649531245231628,
-0.2113262265920639,
-0.4887297749519348,
-0.10577552020549774,
-0.6211309432983398,
0.47699519991874695,
-0.6406309008598328,
-0.06631599366664886,
0.21033771336078644,
0.14732930064201355,
0.3498570919036865,
0.44963136315345764,
-1.0412988662719727,
0.45192235708236694,
0.7263211607933044,
0.7727861404418945,
-0.4510992765426636,
-0.4575507342815399,
-0.7714964747428894,
0.5433133244514465,
-0.01484371442347765,
0.629000186920166,
-0.4350690245628357,
-0.26244470477104187,
0.4083329439163208,
-0.07968606799840927,
-0.4496748149394989,
-0.8102209568023682,
0.3882056772708893,
-0.7850695848464966,
-0.08974750339984894,
-0.2952466309070587,
-0.35839593410491943,
-0.3040273189544678,
0.36408621072769165,
-0.45709508657455444,
0.5350082516670227,
0.2828580141067505,
-0.4821723401546478,
0.36598098278045654,
-0.6285128593444824,
-0.7057993412017822,
-0.018187357112765312,
-0.36325642466545105,
-0.49422332644462585,
0.0177740640938282,
0.03847086802124977,
0.45396021008491516,
-0.3714008033275604,
0.26523837447166443,
-0.15085569024085999,
-0.38652002811431885,
0.02583051659166813,
-0.06566478312015533,
0.6054437756538391,
-0.12558797001838684,
-0.3431490361690521,
-0.009961375966668129,
-0.6804794669151306,
0.04329991713166237,
0.037851281464099884,
-0.6354339122772217,
-0.33275848627090454,
-0.1328267604112625,
-0.22503253817558289,
0.017817586660385132,
0.0890912115573883,
0.06184638664126396,
0.20805256068706512,
-0.06677661091089249,
0.30264797806739807,
0.5435144901275635,
0.042717427015304565,
0.5825155973434448,
-0.49431368708610535,
0.6573586463928223,
0.19194039702415466,
0.11746520549058914,
0.013249059207737446,
-0.5037542581558228,
-1.0084513425827026,
-0.4001566767692566,
0.09430830180644989,
0.9060024619102478,
-0.7818010449409485,
0.41913050413131714,
-0.2887060344219208,
-0.045491624623537064,
-0.2962151765823364,
0.5195987224578857,
0.468713641166687,
0.22321277856826782,
0.6560707688331604,
-0.6887325048446655,
-0.3597588539123535,
-0.8441712856292725,
0.01440548337996006,
-0.2736247777938843,
0.021088041365146637,
0.237289696931839,
0.6351101398468018,
-0.5612249970436096,
0.918536901473999,
-0.3483723998069763,
-0.9911594986915588,
-0.3474245071411133,
0.14087073504924774,
0.09131934493780136,
0.355656236410141,
0.5875053405761719,
-0.5602672696113586,
-0.3178258240222931,
0.3696812093257904,
-0.9133214950561523,
0.08971961587667465,
-0.19742241501808167,
-0.12162651866674423,
0.24644669890403748,
0.26775556802749634,
-0.6092172265052795,
0.2979535758495331,
0.17476427555084229,
-0.210403710603714,
0.8348513245582581,
-0.41388145089149475,
0.2188861221075058,
-0.6754466891288757,
0.3128962218761444,
-0.12224366515874863,
0.103304423391819,
-0.8073504567146301,
0.20869065821170807,
0.19318650662899017,
0.3053204119205475,
-0.6250016689300537,
0.5576808452606201,
-0.5499112606048584,
-0.09942644834518433,
-0.14621828496456146,
0.17224393784999847,
-0.12759076058864594,
0.7523396015167236,
-0.36156216263771057,
0.9540996551513672,
0.6480218172073364,
-0.9505928158760071,
0.2504989504814148,
0.30910539627075195,
-0.23044998943805695,
0.9850412011146545,
-0.13991756737232208,
0.28470754623413086,
-0.21770961582660675,
-0.2290998250246048,
-0.6717814207077026,
-0.3855721056461334,
0.3013994097709656,
-0.034781549125909805,
0.37801244854927063,
0.09906519949436188,
-0.3426436483860016,
-0.37994855642318726,
-0.10174094140529633,
0.3834843039512634,
0.3399341106414795,
-0.24767054617404938,
1.06754732131958,
0.3918033242225647,
-0.2580651640892029,
-0.6874477863311768,
-0.8611221313476562,
0.17889364063739777,
-0.5481778383255005,
-0.2894042432308197,
0.6653883457183838,
-0.09622880816459656,
-0.290560245513916,
0.23888155817985535,
0.15292710065841675,
-0.3263138234615326,
0.012378483079373837,
0.15572670102119446,
0.22247529029846191,
-0.18317438662052155,
0.16334810853004456,
0.19814355671405792,
-0.09745316207408905,
-0.03906550258398056,
-0.41918501257896423,
0.4122449457645416,
-0.02838735282421112,
-0.744788408279419,
-0.3806091248989105,
0.6874542832374573,
0.62645024061203,
-0.26288241147994995,
0.6041231155395508,
0.3564807176589966,
-0.4443780779838562,
-0.30769991874694824,
-0.9286870956420898,
0.32695674896240234,
-0.37641432881355286,
0.6322101950645447,
-0.2738349139690399,
-1.1754814386367798,
0.8965158462524414,
0.06871020793914795,
0.009706209413707256,
0.2712363600730896,
0.5862941145896912,
0.05084192380309105,
0.4769410490989685,
1.042130708694458,
-0.541827917098999,
0.3554554879665375,
-0.4134063124656677,
0.38343188166618347,
-0.9498124122619629,
-0.2758309543132782,
-0.17658284306526184,
-0.12685954570770264,
0.23031173646450043,
-0.6709772348403931,
0.2116565704345703,
-0.049566660076379776,
-0.31435200572013855,
0.2562013566493988,
-0.06570515036582947,
0.5069417953491211,
0.5912725925445557,
0.08228716254234314,
0.5376152396202087,
0.16698415577411652,
-0.03134995698928833,
0.10806160420179367,
-0.6220249533653259,
-0.38655057549476624,
1.1875922679901123,
0.3325252830982208,
0.5897986888885498,
0.18037539720535278,
0.6442235708236694,
0.5708233714103699,
0.50026535987854,
-0.8504723906517029,
0.6197564005851746,
-0.23325155675411224,
-0.28867587447166443,
-0.1879834234714508,
-0.30613383650779724,
-0.7280329465866089,
-0.019467981532216072,
0.17740705609321594,
-0.6699133515357971,
0.12767022848129272,
0.13838516175746918,
-0.976161003112793,
0.25180432200431824,
-0.4930068552494049,
0.4285220801830292,
-0.15036249160766602,
-0.4465613067150116,
-0.6201758980751038,
-0.13021418452262878,
0.3646942675113678,
-0.49271681904792786,
0.27964556217193604,
-0.09478198736906052,
-0.20050039887428284,
0.6648611426353455,
0.2528287470340729,
1.0394858121871948,
-0.0708906278014183,
-0.2325386106967926,
0.6441171765327454,
-0.1890658438205719,
0.4543594717979431,
-0.2033981829881668,
0.13347375392913818,
-0.11911975592374802,
-0.5659542083740234,
-0.2986803948879242,
-0.44100287556648254,
0.6309751868247986,
-0.7113222479820251,
-0.8642873764038086,
-0.1234833374619484,
-0.769792914390564,
-0.7164243459701538,
0.00498564587906003,
-0.12019798904657364,
0.0707407295703888,
-0.477968692779541,
-0.23078685998916626,
0.9669220447540283,
-0.1297626942396164,
0.30446699261665344,
0.46963807940483093,
0.15706022083759308,
-0.6217259764671326,
0.9901922941207886,
0.42557379603385925,
0.27936679124832153,
0.2096235752105713,
-0.4778500497341156,
-0.028698867186903954,
-0.7392441630363464,
-0.20866236090660095,
0.4668117165565491,
-0.9347027540206909,
-0.3204909861087799,
-0.7704774737358093,
-0.22990445792675018,
-0.13951469957828522,
-0.3003104031085968,
-0.09579937160015106,
-0.12899066507816315,
-0.555648148059845,
0.10825438797473907,
0.08442544937133789,
0.6209346055984497,
-0.06168397143483162,
0.17557896673679352,
-0.6763372421264648,
0.3825501501560211,
0.6687862277030945,
0.3217642605304718,
0.3373429775238037,
-0.7890679836273193,
-0.603522002696991,
-0.30835971236228943,
-0.49041175842285156,
-0.4694763720035553,
0.28842124342918396,
0.42718932032585144,
0.9258950352668762,
0.3530343770980835,
-0.3539551794528961,
0.7083413004875183,
-0.5591872334480286,
0.3484329879283905,
0.23794397711753845,
-0.8777685761451721,
0.4561495780944824,
-0.41021859645843506,
0.14054563641548157,
0.5888247489929199,
0.5683473944664001,
-0.4184689223766327,
-0.6347970962524414,
-0.3965246379375458,
-0.8971335291862488,
0.47124582529067993,
-0.1094839796423912,
0.27699995040893555,
0.02867131121456623,
0.5919862389564514,
-0.00436668423935771,
0.04911785200238228,
-0.3666423559188843,
0.008396334946155548,
0.428883820772171,
-0.1197216808795929,
0.12296948581933975,
-0.3131352961063385,
-0.3571515381336212,
-0.3148427903652191,
0.7064931392669678,
-0.31419941782951355,
0.3833850622177124,
0.13830412924289703,
-0.2812553346157074,
0.10535186529159546,
0.2525264620780945,
0.6353240609169006,
0.7976593375205994,
0.29431816935539246,
0.11998516321182251,
0.680966854095459,
-0.4999573528766632,
0.408502995967865,
-0.22782540321350098,
0.08650870621204376,
-0.5109699964523315,
0.621050238609314,
0.5224938988685608,
0.3293071985244751,
-0.7418641448020935,
0.23553796112537384,
0.30416810512542725,
-0.5951746106147766,
-0.2623474597930908,
0.4886690080165863,
0.19792011380195618,
0.4243834912776947,
0.5505865812301636,
0.0188602227717638,
0.005355434026569128,
-0.8419610261917114,
0.5142922401428223,
0.35768842697143555,
-0.3567230701446533,
-0.3162410259246826,
0.6773278117179871,
0.03820017725229263,
-0.05162103846669197,
0.40001916885375977,
-0.319314569234848,
-0.4492184817790985,
0.5474651455879211,
0.5230495929718018,
0.8444966077804565,
-0.37305712699890137,
0.10746011137962341,
0.17524544894695282,
0.24758969247341156,
-0.23137077689170837,
0.197927325963974,
0.12209523469209671,
-0.616818904876709,
-0.6921908855438232,
-0.22772501409053802,
-0.5025666356086731,
0.21735793352127075,
-0.5984682440757751,
0.02955496869981289,
-0.7118842005729675,
-0.27409109473228455,
-0.40405529737472534,
-0.16650986671447754,
-0.956880509853363,
0.16314344108104706,
0.1086428314447403,
0.6833614110946655,
-0.9193716049194336,
0.8911967873573303,
0.4663917124271393,
-0.4847791790962219,
-0.25005048513412476,
0.1327144205570221,
0.013723648153245449,
-0.8807770609855652,
0.623943030834198,
-0.05333927646279335,
-0.1361256092786789,
-0.11981825530529022,
-0.1499239206314087,
-0.7881038784980774,
1.2331212759017944,
0.41254353523254395,
-0.4078940451145172,
-0.23389436304569244,
0.5796938538551331,
0.5030401349067688,
-0.6621500253677368,
-0.23562292754650116,
1.0805103778839111,
0.20443114638328552,
0.03845681995153427,
-0.9894170165061951,
-0.07960300892591476,
0.021453334018588066,
-0.17228953540325165,
-0.12075082212686539,
-0.6973714828491211,
0.7376970052719116,
-0.4573614001274109,
-0.3084937334060669,
-0.1050863116979599,
0.7432920336723328,
0.2138185203075409,
0.1461452692747116,
0.31739017367362976,
0.8534152507781982,
1.0637534856796265,
0.05224275216460228,
0.7436863780021667,
0.020016631111502647,
0.3144460916519165,
1.1941475868225098,
-0.4385347068309784,
0.7800864577293396,
0.4772554039955139,
-0.16208180785179138,
0.309122771024704,
0.02053813822567463,
0.22408464550971985,
0.6973838210105896,
0.11909537762403488,
-0.6174312829971313,
-0.3400195240974426,
-0.2526600658893585,
-0.2609694004058838,
0.2512187957763672,
0.45787250995635986,
-0.2105932980775833,
-0.15194986760616302,
0.32831066846847534,
0.0619964674115181,
0.07710804790258408,
-0.4622219502925873,
0.6790655255317688,
0.15540477633476257,
-0.6157379150390625,
0.5370897650718689,
-0.03219090402126312,
0.6679667830467224,
-0.5845245718955994,
-0.05094548314809799,
-0.2925788462162018,
0.47968590259552,
0.059706322848796844,
-0.7622142434120178,
0.6551316380500793,
0.04521849751472473,
-0.3769727349281311,
-0.10326068848371506,
0.575445830821991,
-0.443462997674942,
-0.19585083425045013,
0.7277010083198547,
0.6244878768920898,
-0.19717423617839813,
-0.28370219469070435,
-0.3871750831604004,
0.20701856911182404,
-0.10646456480026245,
-0.012133358046412468,
0.4873329997062683,
0.5851436257362366,
-0.10861720889806747,
0.897486686706543,
0.34833136200904846,
0.05454837158322334,
-0.11647141724824905,
0.2520108222961426,
0.9942622184753418,
-0.7014343738555908,
-0.4303285777568817,
-0.7294398546218872,
0.5072283744812012,
0.09856270998716354,
-0.32564565539360046,
0.3597150444984436,
0.41178879141807556,
0.679060697555542,
-0.11645612120628357,
1.1684399843215942,
0.02371438406407833,
0.27028214931488037,
-0.5808510780334473,
0.7251744270324707,
-0.37330543994903564,
0.11906647682189941,
0.01845988631248474,
-0.9438846707344055,
-0.6119924187660217,
0.41781988739967346,
-0.4146839380264282,
0.008694685995578766,
0.8531554341316223,
0.4600104093551636,
-0.17679297924041748,
-0.37834930419921875,
0.5891045331954956,
-0.12894082069396973,
0.45905986428260803,
1.210092544555664,
0.7101147770881653,
-0.30616217851638794,
0.5427136421203613,
0.18476885557174683,
-0.4327557384967804,
-0.2960527539253235,
-0.6563611626625061,
-1.1333940029144287,
-0.5895463824272156,
-0.5096935629844666,
-0.035265225917100906,
0.3328517973423004,
0.5132085680961609,
0.43916118144989014,
-0.9277018308639526,
-0.1194106712937355,
0.22346536815166473,
-0.04755188152194023,
-0.303822785615921,
-0.10760626941919327,
0.3663289248943329,
-0.6727190017700195,
-0.5353345274925232,
0.2988336980342865,
0.5633623600006104,
0.05531610921025276,
-0.20055121183395386,
-0.10036695003509521,
-0.03674155846238136,
0.11959889531135559,
0.7046235799789429,
0.49675023555755615,
-0.6032525897026062,
-0.6965435147285461,
-0.1248498409986496,
-0.1383417397737503,
0.08689960092306137,
0.8990904092788696,
-0.6599709391593933,
-0.13282345235347748,
-0.11230950057506561,
1.0047324895858765,
0.11842339485883713,
-0.23866529762744904,
0.35728010535240173,
-0.5841354727745056,
0.016836954280734062,
0.08661062270402908,
0.39817506074905396,
0.13640065491199493,
-0.21083925664424896,
0.5714130401611328,
0.3290894329547882,
-0.39738938212394714,
-0.44514593482017517,
0.20513217151165009,
-0.9194628596305847,
-0.0822257325053215,
1.0412147045135498,
-0.2811321020126343,
-0.03890194371342659,
-0.6799806356430054,
-0.0833117663860321,
0.07268593460321426,
-0.05823603644967079,
1.016561508178711,
0.9632542729377747,
-0.09626655280590057,
0.12256146967411041,
-0.7847905158996582,
0.42030537128448486,
0.49070167541503906,
-1.030465841293335,
0.268137663602829,
0.16746670007705688,
0.23947636783123016,
0.43264830112457275,
0.9779859781265259,
-0.0425993949174881,
0.43148279190063477,
-0.291177362203598,
0.05955726280808449,
0.046795554459095,
-0.8050438165664673,
-0.2797623574733734,
0.42793187499046326,
0.030814440920948982,
0.03258757293224335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17822v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17822v1
|
Conv-CoA: Improving Open-domain Question Answering in Large Language Models via Conversational Chain-of-Action
| 2024-05-28T04:46:52 | 2024-05-28T04:46:52 |
Zhenyu Pan, Haozheng Luo, Manling Li, Han Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present a Conversational Chain-of-Action (Conv-CoA) framework for
Open-domain Conversational Question Answering (OCQA). Compared with literature,
Conv-CoA addresses three major challenges: (i) unfaithful hallucination that is
inconsistent with real-time or domain facts, (ii) weak reasoning performance in
conversational scenarios, and (iii) unsatisfying performance in conversational
information retrieval. Our key contribution is a dynamic reasoning-retrieval
mechanism that extracts the intent of the question and decomposes it into a
reasoning chain to be solved via systematic prompting, pre-designed actions,
updating the Contextual Knowledge Set (CKS), and a novel Hopfield-based
retriever. Methodologically, we propose a resource-efficiency Hopfield
retriever to enhance the efficiency and accuracy of conversational information
retrieval within our actions. Additionally, we propose a
conversational-multi-reference faith score (Conv-MRFS) to verify and resolve
conflicts between retrieved knowledge and answers in conversations.
Empirically, we conduct comparisons between our framework and 23
state-of-the-art methods across five different research directions and two
public benchmarks. These comparisons demonstrate that our Conv-CoA outperforms
other methods in both the accuracy and efficiency dimensions.
|
[
-0.2700220048427582,
-1.23282790184021,
0.40491193532943726,
-0.07674837857484818,
-0.048710089176893234,
0.3654138743877411,
-0.15528136491775513,
-0.392250657081604,
-0.0197125393897295,
0.4607616364955902,
-0.5780648589134216,
-0.29660820960998535,
-0.3069188892841339,
-0.17416569590568542,
-0.1770014613866806,
0.5059575438499451,
0.11373230069875717,
-0.053121063858270645,
-0.37749502062797546,
-0.321366548538208,
-0.4437767565250397,
-0.6676690578460693,
-0.7242616415023804,
-0.057071272283792496,
0.3612973093986511,
0.5305134654045105,
0.9192884564399719,
0.28924405574798584,
0.7168483734130859,
0.15684622526168823,
-0.2908850908279419,
0.647427499294281,
-0.7583196759223938,
0.34292903542518616,
-0.24936765432357788,
-0.22406312823295593,
-0.5431427359580994,
-0.2599014639854431,
0.3101678788661957,
0.9369708299636841,
-0.40031853318214417,
0.09817229211330414,
-0.1794230043888092,
0.5172796249389648,
-0.9983291029930115,
0.1264009028673172,
-0.8008463382720947,
-0.25401780009269714,
0.19896149635314941,
-0.6153044700622559,
-0.6711805462837219,
-0.46974554657936096,
0.5729876160621643,
-0.721977949142456,
-0.14240701496601105,
0.3888477385044098,
0.5002781748771667,
0.0842042863368988,
-0.6539263725280762,
-0.6548560261726379,
-0.6989699602127075,
0.817757248878479,
-0.4107356369495392,
0.5743494033813477,
0.4658912122249603,
0.16969040036201477,
-0.3371756672859192,
-0.6935180425643921,
-0.5709429383277893,
-0.05462455376982689,
-0.05130733922123909,
0.29857105016708374,
-0.16827896237373352,
0.004155362956225872,
0.21611590683460236,
0.4031866192817688,
-0.5495256185531616,
-0.3225671052932739,
-0.16639074683189392,
-0.029803089797496796,
0.5407354831695557,
0.294027715921402,
-0.15286852419376373,
0.37775659561157227,
-0.34002307057380676,
-0.04249386861920357,
-0.730854332447052,
0.3623086214065552,
0.08711957931518555,
0.11891892552375793,
0.13783502578735352,
0.4443519711494446,
-0.3765891194343567,
0.7377859950065613,
0.09199733287096024,
0.16394834220409393,
-0.10959046334028244,
-0.3619987964630127,
-0.35430505871772766,
0.018080294132232666,
0.7347280979156494,
0.21249838173389435,
0.16309429705142975,
-0.12219678610563278,
0.447916179895401,
-0.460459440946579,
0.3210563659667969,
-0.7669434547424316,
-0.02363654598593712,
0.382080614566803,
-0.4190532863140106,
-0.16585473716259003,
0.31247857213020325,
-0.658098042011261,
-0.28971123695373535,
0.014063381589949131,
0.31575796008110046,
-0.546401858329773,
-0.22191426157951355,
0.3646290898323059,
0.07885739207267761,
0.3960167169570923,
0.541398823261261,
-0.495376318693161,
0.5478034019470215,
0.7022485733032227,
0.5369181036949158,
-0.24324698746204376,
0.1365957260131836,
-1.128411054611206,
-0.01998724229633808,
-0.4755018949508667,
0.3907337784767151,
-0.9239993691444397,
-0.35259127616882324,
0.4031433165073395,
-0.1420709192752838,
-0.08347377926111221,
-0.6617321968078613,
0.4405576288700104,
-1.0398590564727783,
0.2087780386209488,
-0.4248140752315521,
-0.3334771394729614,
-0.23974043130874634,
0.49837738275527954,
-0.4854913651943207,
0.9245865345001221,
-0.048294804990291595,
-0.6166663765907288,
-0.17726315557956696,
-0.6665475368499756,
-0.3397822976112366,
0.15433691442012787,
-0.06006592884659767,
-0.04215076565742493,
-0.14411689341068268,
-0.07349998503923416,
0.1811124086380005,
-0.6767745018005371,
0.2804899513721466,
-0.31367143988609314,
-0.49507609009742737,
0.5539767146110535,
-0.476436972618103,
0.8428788185119629,
0.3552248775959015,
0.007691404782235622,
0.012683650478720665,
-0.8311376571655273,
0.2937852144241333,
0.003335684072226286,
-0.15368854999542236,
-0.7143722176551819,
0.12299022078514099,
-0.5561902523040771,
0.11275532096624374,
-0.022316349670290947,
-0.5753483772277832,
0.18035490810871124,
-0.29159361124038696,
0.2448880672454834,
0.3478221595287323,
0.4536503553390503,
0.31699079275131226,
-0.12198667973279953,
0.34555020928382874,
0.20556868612766266,
0.3688369691371918,
-0.24924223124980927,
-0.5026258230209351,
-0.7787414789199829,
-0.06378716975450516,
0.024080535396933556,
0.3882969915866852,
-0.9465385675430298,
0.32212570309638977,
-0.025612493976950645,
-0.34638547897338867,
-0.492499440908432,
-0.4092453718185425,
0.585192084312439,
0.7730774283409119,
0.655084490776062,
-0.5213335156440735,
-0.17626610398292542,
-0.3590572774410248,
-0.2208820879459381,
-0.42849916219711304,
0.11122685670852661,
0.3921285569667816,
0.49471569061279297,
0.25039130449295044,
0.951610267162323,
-0.7736338973045349,
-0.03911555930972099,
0.1813703179359436,
0.27372801303863525,
0.12130679935216904,
0.256273478269577,
0.06809365749359131,
-1.1496411561965942,
-0.3018052577972412,
0.06988386064767838,
-0.751380205154419,
0.17809881269931793,
0.15972834825515747,
-0.4142588973045349,
0.08359228819608688,
0.43174266815185547,
-0.6672557592391968,
0.5810810327529907,
0.3967996835708618,
-0.5061033368110657,
0.6206244230270386,
-0.03296243026852608,
0.5715189576148987,
-0.7154701948165894,
0.33039212226867676,
-0.5013606548309326,
-0.015115026384592056,
-0.7326229214668274,
0.23520992696285248,
-0.09672724455595016,
-0.026427404955029488,
-0.7638791799545288,
0.4117887318134308,
-0.22790957987308502,
0.3828892409801483,
0.04657044634222984,
0.2660366892814636,
0.12309044599533081,
0.6506639122962952,
0.23987513780593872,
0.8441217541694641,
0.3125329315662384,
-0.9237707853317261,
0.395476371049881,
0.7074243426322937,
-0.1902932971715927,
0.6748839616775513,
-0.7291002869606018,
0.39432966709136963,
-0.013152538798749447,
0.3121628761291504,
-0.7717936635017395,
-0.0835290476679802,
0.37000352144241333,
-0.4115837812423706,
-0.1397726982831955,
-0.035726625472307205,
-0.12224901467561722,
-0.2506924569606781,
-0.0701199620962143,
0.6986578702926636,
0.28455010056495667,
-0.48710617423057556,
0.6380828619003296,
0.17135687172412872,
0.09157935529947281,
-0.9265404939651489,
-0.4600295126438141,
-0.34142038226127625,
0.15404659509658813,
-0.5439711213111877,
0.2970348596572876,
-0.41426655650138855,
-0.5326989889144897,
-0.13001307845115662,
-0.42247825860977173,
-0.3050512373447418,
0.02782873436808586,
0.024564679712057114,
0.15277159214019775,
-0.1553427129983902,
0.2917422354221344,
-0.20198576152324677,
0.15693800151348114,
0.22826553881168365,
-0.4074831008911133,
0.632902979850769,
-0.2289453148841858,
-0.4293041527271271,
-0.08267921209335327,
0.62276691198349,
0.5215212106704712,
-0.7349395751953125,
0.8690218329429626,
0.1530231386423111,
-0.21884854137897491,
-0.013685740530490875,
-0.3587901294231415,
-0.1485118269920349,
-0.4139803349971771,
0.06113150715827942,
-0.48778730630874634,
-1.1599212884902954,
0.4624106287956238,
-0.22280432283878326,
0.09674108028411865,
0.07105200737714767,
0.62754887342453,
-0.18722864985466003,
0.6894347667694092,
0.4058503210544586,
0.5380823612213135,
0.2023310512304306,
-0.307801753282547,
0.5976128578186035,
-0.7056003212928772,
-0.5535469651222229,
-0.5843155384063721,
0.18252071738243103,
-0.37860551476478577,
-0.5480958223342896,
0.4239611327648163,
0.15985170006752014,
-0.4853880703449249,
0.2530958652496338,
-0.1898786723613739,
0.15687185525894165,
0.6006482243537903,
0.06883368641138077,
0.677301287651062,
-0.31393203139305115,
-0.1411946564912796,
0.2262529730796814,
-0.7302592396736145,
-0.2290569245815277,
0.7102053165435791,
0.17256703972816467,
0.8852148056030273,
0.4002278745174408,
0.2546057105064392,
0.21335957944393158,
-0.00041006028186529875,
-0.8464874029159546,
0.5710558295249939,
0.19410303235054016,
-0.7153268456459045,
-0.29456526041030884,
-0.6770327091217041,
-0.9456865787506104,
0.30245351791381836,
-0.3525313138961792,
-0.8327906131744385,
0.326021283864975,
0.27936092019081116,
-0.581971287727356,
0.08511540293693542,
-0.4183030128479004,
0.8758283853530884,
-0.020762627944350243,
-0.6869050860404968,
-0.17814169824123383,
-0.8421413898468018,
0.3654339015483856,
0.040820956230163574,
0.06524041295051575,
0.24199092388153076,
0.14294224977493286,
0.5187305808067322,
-0.4842889606952667,
0.4495328962802887,
-0.001243881299160421,
-0.23713380098342896,
0.8381124138832092,
0.4201419949531555,
0.592646598815918,
0.1793837696313858,
-0.21848873794078827,
0.025380754843354225,
0.3120100796222687,
-0.13656771183013916,
-0.9938576817512512,
0.3938910961151123,
-0.46000146865844727,
-0.5165424346923828,
-0.5254126191139221,
-0.5814638137817383,
-0.47685137391090393,
0.00798989087343216,
-0.08823744207620621,
0.6671648621559143,
-0.4708584249019623,
0.6223540306091309,
1.0635461807250977,
-0.3345530927181244,
0.21726840734481812,
0.8377145528793335,
-0.06592383980751038,
-0.3613009452819824,
0.6680336594581604,
-0.07724862545728683,
0.6045392155647278,
0.7995923161506653,
0.11131682246923447,
-0.23011352121829987,
-0.23353224992752075,
-0.042644012719392776,
0.029002362862229347,
-0.5527315139770508,
-0.34940099716186523,
-0.7689862847328186,
-0.2546177804470062,
-0.36318841576576233,
0.18193753063678741,
-0.41566720604896545,
-0.26467427611351013,
-0.04269221052527428,
0.2912987470626831,
0.28183895349502563,
0.2571142613887787,
0.46837088465690613,
0.23310443758964539,
-0.6917256116867065,
0.3403610289096832,
0.23095357418060303,
0.3836402893066406,
-0.002371452981606126,
-0.5770778059959412,
-0.15772563219070435,
0.2669794261455536,
-0.49858465790748596,
-0.6159159541130066,
0.014041840098798275,
0.03697555512189865,
0.1604747176170349,
0.21771162748336792,
0.6378390192985535,
1.0180057287216187,
-0.3687027096748352,
0.7732099890708923,
0.20954562723636627,
-0.7895769476890564,
0.3941856324672699,
-0.26418042182922363,
0.2448694258928299,
0.6210019588470459,
0.7542058229446411,
-0.6697124242782593,
-0.27996039390563965,
-0.7257776856422424,
-0.7004253268241882,
0.636677086353302,
0.42644646763801575,
-0.13401545584201813,
-0.211843341588974,
0.22686971724033356,
0.03917958587408066,
0.45288315415382385,
-0.16115207970142365,
-0.24917654693126678,
0.1301049441099167,
-0.15601016581058502,
0.3957498073577881,
-0.12707872688770294,
-0.21518898010253906,
-0.0630197823047638,
0.8755839467048645,
-0.4522523581981659,
0.36865222454071045,
0.5040226578712463,
0.029966462403535843,
-0.21905964612960815,
0.26462802290916443,
0.4137731194496155,
0.6457625031471252,
-0.43140724301338196,
0.16125918924808502,
0.11499112844467163,
-0.4609758257865906,
0.052590832114219666,
-0.13584934175014496,
-0.1285562664270401,
-0.2975916266441345,
0.31006938219070435,
0.4554213285446167,
-0.057805005460977554,
-0.9416223764419556,
0.7105668783187866,
-0.29399052262306213,
-0.3026060163974762,
-0.4533049166202545,
0.12166182696819305,
-0.1659422218799591,
0.31689420342445374,
0.46989405155181885,
0.08225318044424057,
0.134333536028862,
-0.915727972984314,
0.25470712780952454,
0.6246923804283142,
-0.6887080073356628,
-0.09341070055961609,
0.561622679233551,
0.24561257660388947,
-0.5462313294410706,
0.6489958167076111,
-0.07382985204458237,
-0.2541563808917999,
0.34340137243270874,
0.39575058221817017,
0.5128391981124878,
-0.121487095952034,
0.2691093981266022,
0.2950729727745056,
-0.025569865480065346,
-0.023652460426092148,
0.5468242764472961,
-0.08826939761638641,
-0.6367824077606201,
-0.5023915767669678,
-0.41098907589912415,
-0.8459795713424683,
0.21042664349079132,
-0.8444842100143433,
0.11445322632789612,
-0.16292071342468262,
0.087994784116745,
-0.2684948146343231,
0.06086414307355881,
-0.531528115272522,
0.3144526183605194,
-0.2601805329322815,
1.2542407512664795,
-0.11801192164421082,
0.7251057028770447,
0.4667082130908966,
-0.5446356534957886,
-0.6767501831054688,
0.28394654393196106,
-0.13152986764907837,
-0.4753885269165039,
0.4806109666824341,
-0.15906280279159546,
-0.5952949523925781,
0.1652030050754547,
-0.7219099998474121,
-0.8565066456794739,
1.0974308252334595,
0.2516745924949646,
-0.3827672600746155,
0.07798056304454803,
0.07079955190420151,
0.5274426937103271,
-0.5484418272972107,
0.650772750377655,
0.5351534485816956,
0.2296711802482605,
0.4998314082622528,
-0.6614745855331421,
0.05758848041296005,
-0.1487949639558792,
-0.3609597384929657,
0.08270571380853653,
-0.9584969282150269,
0.3322664499282837,
-0.15529219806194305,
-0.08707530051469803,
0.2835240662097931,
0.8943986892700195,
0.2363220453262329,
0.4334210157394409,
0.4516162574291229,
0.1081814169883728,
0.8730689883232117,
-0.15490353107452393,
0.816650927066803,
-0.15838049352169037,
0.30063116550445557,
1.1586458683013916,
-0.45559215545654297,
0.943553626537323,
0.5099197626113892,
0.04757148399949074,
0.5764216184616089,
0.2317579835653305,
0.45868149399757385,
0.553827702999115,
0.1895606517791748,
-0.38337722420692444,
-0.3882174789905548,
-0.5291460156440735,
-0.12409280985593796,
0.6644546389579773,
0.3435249328613281,
-0.11502841860055923,
0.005730247125029564,
-0.20364241302013397,
0.02473142370581627,
0.23143261671066284,
-0.0913209319114685,
0.650936484336853,
0.11391544342041016,
-1.131287932395935,
0.814725399017334,
-0.23872020840644836,
0.1356513798236847,
-0.8063768744468689,
-0.36135441064834595,
-0.17315256595611572,
0.23387376964092255,
0.05499674007296562,
-0.7857577800750732,
0.39248883724212646,
-0.029363857582211494,
-0.011785170063376427,
-0.16914136707782745,
0.5081084966659546,
-0.7317888140678406,
0.1837315410375595,
0.46154260635375977,
0.5866395235061646,
0.03713250160217285,
-0.1371019184589386,
-0.5544499754905701,
0.30760008096694946,
-0.3807426989078522,
-0.18028318881988525,
0.023159204050898552,
0.5506923794746399,
-0.22028236091136932,
0.7370597720146179,
0.6834958791732788,
-0.34181398153305054,
-0.25206857919692993,
0.2751331627368927,
0.873507559299469,
-0.595093846321106,
-0.24701717495918274,
-0.5215995907783508,
0.49046096205711365,
-0.23722787201404572,
-0.33169689774513245,
0.39332133531570435,
0.5067569017410278,
0.8839366436004639,
0.15712743997573853,
0.5424742102622986,
-0.3485572040081024,
0.39542192220687866,
-0.45443084836006165,
0.3193545341491699,
-0.4915003180503845,
0.10517934709787369,
-0.24102221429347992,
-0.685519814491272,
-0.3211449980735779,
0.3430142402648926,
-0.1682707816362381,
-0.17007876932621002,
1.119348168373108,
0.8224166631698608,
-0.028544610366225243,
0.38233911991119385,
0.3257415294647217,
0.2793896496295929,
0.45090192556381226,
0.7015686631202698,
0.9724425077438354,
-0.7156829237937927,
0.8707199692726135,
0.025808941572904587,
-0.3923962712287903,
-0.0925724133849144,
-0.8165675401687622,
-0.8383040428161621,
-0.5921162962913513,
-0.4349111318588257,
-0.5503076314926147,
0.3670838177204132,
1.088012933731079,
0.6302616000175476,
-0.7478872537612915,
-0.26903730630874634,
-0.031724363565444946,
0.09979172796010971,
-0.7177302837371826,
-0.21895244717597961,
0.23464569449424744,
-0.2674504816532135,
-0.5002844929695129,
0.4761868119239807,
0.3092154562473297,
-0.5548847913742065,
0.08207748830318451,
-0.25935232639312744,
-0.6149976253509521,
0.34816208481788635,
0.8956516981124878,
0.3006543517112732,
-0.5471389889717102,
-0.5853865146636963,
0.458090603351593,
0.007176702376455069,
0.08995189517736435,
1.0109364986419678,
-0.6139475703239441,
0.48199713230133057,
0.5010249018669128,
0.9470818042755127,
0.31987494230270386,
0.41156935691833496,
0.4888441860675812,
-0.5874987244606018,
-0.19210024178028107,
0.29497596621513367,
-0.09273798763751984,
-0.06407614052295685,
-0.21464745700359344,
0.6678304076194763,
0.3591790497303009,
-0.4872444272041321,
-0.6277495622634888,
0.42805683612823486,
-1.301719069480896,
-0.11756579577922821,
1.1610885858535767,
-0.2806289494037628,
-0.2598671615123749,
-0.36870262026786804,
-0.2858050465583801,
0.16927672922611237,
-0.3816540241241455,
0.4597266614437103,
0.6337102055549622,
-0.1752355694770813,
-0.09283196926116943,
-0.3280835747718811,
0.43527692556381226,
0.21644650399684906,
-0.7528560161590576,
0.45108282566070557,
0.43200236558914185,
-0.11742722243070602,
0.32763996720314026,
0.7976380586624146,
-0.27529022097587585,
0.35156261920928955,
-0.23918123543262482,
-0.12799473106861115,
-0.07891281694173813,
-0.5399664640426636,
0.08596833795309067,
0.4026605784893036,
-0.1471533477306366,
-0.08022444695234299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03198v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03198v1
|
The Impossibility of Fair LLMs
| 2024-05-28T04:36:15 | 2024-05-28T04:36:15 |
Jacy Anthis, Kristian Lum, Michael Ekstrand, Avi Feller, Alexander D'Amour, Chenhao Tan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG, stat.AP, stat.ML
|
The need for fair AI is increasingly clear in the era of general-purpose
systems such as ChatGPT, Gemini, and other large language models (LLMs).
However, the increasing complexity of human-AI interaction and its social
impacts have raised questions of how fairness standards could be applied. Here,
we review the technical frameworks that machine learning researchers have used
to evaluate fairness, such as group fairness and fair representations, and find
that their application to LLMs faces inherent limitations. We show that each
framework either does not logically extend to LLMs or presents a notion of
fairness that is intractable for LLMs, primarily due to the multitudes of
populations affected, sensitive attributes, and use cases. To address these
challenges, we develop guidelines for the more realistic goal of achieving
fairness in particular use cases: the criticality of context, the
responsibility of LLM developers, and the need for stakeholder participation in
an iterative process of design and evaluation. Moreover, it may eventually be
possible and even necessary to use the general-purpose capabilities of AI
systems to address fairness challenges as a form of scalable AI-assisted
alignment.
|
[
-0.1961960345506668,
-0.42701780796051025,
0.6920617818832397,
0.372166246175766,
0.1376410275697708,
0.02382475510239601,
-0.2663079500198364,
-0.3987904191017151,
-0.3733564615249634,
0.3248063921928406,
-0.4309152364730835,
-0.267097532749176,
-0.8235909342765808,
-0.05594650283455849,
-0.4267995357513428,
1.0036101341247559,
0.07118396461009979,
0.2990068197250366,
-0.4488990902900696,
-0.5332178473472595,
-0.4778866767883301,
-0.7180432677268982,
-0.676121175289154,
-0.3712858259677887,
0.30969715118408203,
0.47199007868766785,
0.9446561932563782,
0.6408970952033997,
0.7784378528594971,
0.42082589864730835,
-0.023708811029791832,
-0.138177290558815,
-0.43189212679862976,
-0.11244314163923264,
-0.16009391844272614,
-0.8688157200813293,
-0.3538360595703125,
0.34033408761024475,
0.6110365390777588,
1.0482131242752075,
-0.2702018618583679,
0.15428417921066284,
0.19793817400932312,
0.745400607585907,
-0.5700355172157288,
0.13576741516590118,
-0.8424285650253296,
0.4879741072654724,
-0.1872599571943283,
0.029895665124058723,
-0.07643086463212967,
-0.4959593117237091,
0.029501814395189285,
-0.514024019241333,
0.010766848921775818,
0.17147137224674225,
0.633564829826355,
0.5593311786651611,
-0.3505295217037201,
-0.554616391658783,
-0.4950942099094391,
0.9598409533500671,
-0.5417163372039795,
-0.023004960268735886,
0.3519619405269623,
0.6498335003852844,
-0.3876948952674866,
-0.6294589042663574,
-0.7144954204559326,
-0.1835060864686966,
-0.008915155194699764,
-0.18501080572605133,
-0.1398724764585495,
0.1899316906929016,
0.3038528263568878,
0.16557078063488007,
-0.2625890076160431,
0.4050365090370178,
-0.3006795644760132,
-0.16821813583374023,
0.5838020443916321,
0.46327081322669983,
0.27862247824668884,
0.07720521837472916,
-0.16877470910549164,
0.3874676525592804,
-0.5824719071388245,
0.18215355277061462,
0.45809224247932434,
0.3126024603843689,
-0.08388561755418777,
0.6290193200111389,
0.055030710995197296,
0.3405275344848633,
-0.08039652556180954,
0.20384293794631958,
0.29007816314697266,
0.10011088848114014,
-0.24876491725444794,
-0.19434672594070435,
0.7303056716918945,
0.4502332806587219,
0.4712451100349426,
-0.4295889735221863,
-0.32168829441070557,
0.22485046088695526,
0.14537262916564941,
-0.46770578622817993,
0.3031194806098938,
0.24801483750343323,
-0.6743459701538086,
-0.3194635510444641,
-0.03924304619431496,
-0.38853922486305237,
-0.6837482452392578,
-0.5046210289001465,
0.4350647032260895,
0.1577647477388382,
-0.13204284012317657,
-0.07879027724266052,
-0.1102088913321495,
0.44050461053848267,
0.30443114042282104,
-0.700854480266571,
0.3593980669975281,
1.017339825630188,
0.6436160802841187,
-0.10187074542045593,
-0.2529212236404419,
-0.580796480178833,
0.11002907902002335,
-0.15379372239112854,
0.2611939311027527,
-0.6282192468643188,
-0.2876008450984955,
-0.09777861833572388,
-0.1490652710199356,
0.060827597975730896,
-0.6568681597709656,
0.5354334115982056,
-0.2964855134487152,
0.4084981083869934,
-0.23477980494499207,
-0.656703531742096,
-0.040892016142606735,
0.2552412152290344,
-0.40764132142066956,
0.2628304362297058,
0.08703432977199554,
-0.5601484179496765,
0.44673556089401245,
-0.9448176026344299,
-0.5103768110275269,
0.12537497282028198,
-0.6179393529891968,
-0.3414693772792816,
0.3092867136001587,
-0.04106420278549194,
0.4807385206222534,
-0.28381040692329407,
0.714689314365387,
-0.6479085683822632,
-0.7409749031066895,
0.3120405375957489,
-0.6855118870735168,
0.9725414514541626,
0.4338807165622711,
-0.6235352754592896,
0.13571202754974365,
-0.43081486225128174,
-0.06786219775676727,
0.10962382704019547,
-0.3820444643497467,
0.29077571630477905,
0.26290345191955566,
-0.010448673740029335,
0.09682248532772064,
0.1863701492547989,
-0.09501883387565613,
-0.34929221868515015,
-0.24692223966121674,
0.8086794018745422,
1.4560424089431763,
-0.9871994256973267,
0.7497307658195496,
-0.568899393081665,
0.4443679451942444,
-0.16512949764728546,
0.36969658732414246,
0.23484663665294647,
-0.519943118095398,
-0.781097948551178,
-0.32151705026626587,
0.42480188608169556,
0.6988430023193359,
-0.46500980854034424,
0.5464279055595398,
-0.2208920270204544,
-0.07572288066148758,
-0.8741019368171692,
0.02460499294102192,
0.17470435798168182,
0.5315510034561157,
-0.005761241540312767,
-0.28621914982795715,
-0.2726714015007019,
-1.0413702726364136,
-0.4486166536808014,
-0.09935896098613739,
-0.2069959193468094,
0.574593186378479,
0.32336679100990295,
-0.1524883508682251,
1.1119033098220825,
0.30226394534111023,
-0.354234904050827,
0.04630979150533676,
-0.22941014170646667,
0.18847964704036713,
0.3892360031604767,
0.48106592893600464,
-1.1389394998550415,
-0.20207802951335907,
-0.06405887007713318,
-1.0201414823532104,
-0.22857454419136047,
0.2664905786514282,
0.17495299875736237,
0.25262704491615295,
0.47902530431747437,
-0.274302214384079,
0.5825097560882568,
0.38867002725601196,
-0.3670886158943176,
0.13032671809196472,
-0.1787225902080536,
0.32651758193969727,
-0.5476878881454468,
0.1959693878889084,
-0.06751620024442673,
-0.4383828639984131,
-0.37314707040786743,
0.10825588554143906,
-0.20503924787044525,
-0.07247306406497955,
-0.5558484792709351,
0.8245786428451538,
0.124557726085186,
-0.4133389890193939,
-0.4115541875362396,
0.3176574409008026,
-0.27727460861206055,
0.34633368253707886,
-0.5020714998245239,
0.5742526650428772,
0.2896338999271393,
-0.5690634250640869,
0.1474459171295166,
-0.23876824975013733,
-0.19185689091682434,
0.9971211552619934,
-0.6579294204711914,
0.07316309958696365,
-0.453064501285553,
0.23338188230991364,
-0.4862491190433502,
-0.09085877239704132,
0.5753788352012634,
-0.5160579681396484,
-0.13401766121387482,
-0.023130079731345177,
-0.3253194987773895,
-0.21262936294078827,
-0.2327675223350525,
0.6193885207176208,
0.6177529096603394,
-0.42197293043136597,
0.7931874394416809,
0.6689738035202026,
-0.05197429284453392,
-0.8616886734962463,
-0.7830020785331726,
0.35971665382385254,
-0.6084298491477966,
-0.7225854992866516,
0.3859609067440033,
-0.2137158066034317,
-0.6213867664337158,
0.23370029032230377,
0.17324015498161316,
0.06788398325443268,
0.6421080231666565,
0.40775832533836365,
-0.058507438749074936,
0.10323508083820343,
-0.002538213273510337,
-0.08817791193723679,
-0.2796216309070587,
-0.0703561082482338,
-0.134439617395401,
0.30965012311935425,
-0.4489804208278656,
-0.6780941486358643,
-0.4693334698677063,
0.4028548300266266,
0.25109609961509705,
0.14971981942653656,
0.399005651473999,
0.5734614133834839,
-0.7026891708374023,
0.07157531380653381,
-0.5954886674880981,
0.27007508277893066,
-0.4851382374763489,
0.43757525086402893,
-0.17142216861248016,
-1.3195418119430542,
0.6218991279602051,
0.13360053300857544,
0.28159257769584656,
0.42937368154525757,
0.6255683898925781,
-0.3404082953929901,
0.9925779104232788,
0.7582254409790039,
-0.26268982887268066,
0.259931743144989,
0.35813772678375244,
0.27895015478134155,
-0.402725487947464,
-0.32598114013671875,
-0.8318775296211243,
-0.6318338513374329,
-0.8507409691810608,
-0.2545984387397766,
0.28733593225479126,
0.18370793759822845,
-0.6209303140640259,
-0.34332412481307983,
-0.3844425678253174,
0.5898526310920715,
0.7684040665626526,
-0.013404582627117634,
0.42866766452789307,
-0.002677267650142312,
0.07097606360912323,
-0.09748644381761551,
-0.6273824572563171,
-0.9038698077201843,
1.1130489110946655,
0.5236767530441284,
0.47603440284729004,
0.05001456290483475,
0.5150392651557922,
0.8622534275054932,
0.7051774859428406,
-0.5651811957359314,
0.6161221265792847,
-0.44572538137435913,
-0.6292349696159363,
-0.3352298140525818,
-0.7785326242446899,
-0.8410993218421936,
0.18495523929595947,
-0.18363025784492493,
-0.6823260188102722,
-0.04517407715320587,
0.06142794340848923,
-0.031624410301446915,
0.36579129099845886,
-0.8030856847763062,
0.6790317296981812,
-0.33475515246391296,
-0.03265156224370003,
-0.32006433606147766,
-0.7668927907943726,
0.19915026426315308,
-0.006521314382553101,
0.6934367418289185,
-0.5086118578910828,
-0.026393432170152664,
0.5873211622238159,
-0.4264248013496399,
0.685258150100708,
-0.3931506276130676,
0.052766818553209305,
0.21275348961353302,
-0.14046920835971832,
0.09837078303098679,
-0.08887118101119995,
-0.3608171045780182,
0.46272385120391846,
-0.24110442399978638,
-0.6842213273048401,
-0.48210784792900085,
0.6598981022834778,
-0.7696365714073181,
-0.7734264135360718,
-0.39832526445388794,
-0.4755311608314514,
-0.11434422433376312,
0.07212253659963608,
-0.16277280449867249,
-0.2747904360294342,
-0.32101744413375854,
0.00393889332190156,
0.24944821000099182,
-0.29585856199264526,
0.557232677936554,
0.25981077551841736,
-0.15468348562717438,
-0.27886369824409485,
1.077688455581665,
-0.035306449979543686,
-0.04704619571566582,
-0.05348927900195122,
0.034536853432655334,
-0.1573077291250229,
-0.599837064743042,
-0.26154571771621704,
-0.2658863067626953,
-0.7117933034896851,
-0.06459029763936996,
-0.3024407923221588,
-0.1448221206665039,
-0.16891850531101227,
-0.3104276657104492,
0.052523646503686905,
-0.6524417400360107,
-0.3437112271785736,
0.17189130187034607,
-0.07215944677591324,
0.8405911922454834,
-0.4455642104148865,
0.21455194056034088,
-0.3392409086227417,
0.3081134557723999,
0.27092576026916504,
0.5383357405662537,
-0.008753003552556038,
-0.4443279802799225,
0.15754234790802002,
0.17857609689235687,
-0.21305549144744873,
-0.05016239732503891,
-0.1989423930644989,
-0.08715590834617615,
0.7252599000930786,
0.11040935665369034,
-0.20074409246444702,
0.37272554636001587,
-0.6993444561958313,
0.5391722321510315,
0.3128979802131653,
-1.1065607070922852,
0.19402365386486053,
-0.054890140891075134,
-0.3375466763973236,
0.45582759380340576,
0.15637479722499847,
-0.6536408066749573,
-0.36400046944618225,
-0.35336440801620483,
-0.8523459434509277,
0.6842073202133179,
0.3783872425556183,
0.3858506679534912,
0.12316714227199554,
0.5988363027572632,
0.19933542609214783,
0.4113874137401581,
-0.9493909478187561,
-0.14536933600902557,
-0.11822149902582169,
-0.5873374938964844,
0.0881684422492981,
0.1585472673177719,
-0.19026802480220795,
0.1399710476398468,
0.3265640139579773,
-0.13946834206581116,
0.06488318741321564,
-0.11322452872991562,
-0.12557172775268555,
0.030553817749023438,
0.38206398487091064,
0.3233640789985657,
0.5805864930152893,
0.10439479351043701,
-0.13992337882518768,
0.05155567079782486,
0.12027181684970856,
0.23754338920116425,
0.38409656286239624,
-0.34432822465896606,
-0.582392692565918,
0.16806839406490326,
0.4485185146331787,
-0.2835814952850342,
-0.7515130043029785,
0.5410733222961426,
-0.40393775701522827,
-0.3192082941532135,
-0.11777213960886002,
0.33328795433044434,
-0.044528529047966,
0.6703839898109436,
0.44925427436828613,
0.06430303305387497,
0.09659510850906372,
-0.5599921345710754,
0.01149054430425167,
0.7986353039741516,
-0.5295532941818237,
0.22087626159191132,
0.8088911771774292,
0.4386352598667145,
-0.7092007398605347,
0.664726197719574,
-0.2819485664367676,
-0.39375561475753784,
0.7990131378173828,
0.00002193850014009513,
0.7332326769828796,
0.17757733166217804,
-0.013948989100754261,
-0.5450825691223145,
0.3876360058784485,
0.014800590462982655,
0.08308863639831543,
0.16972364485263824,
-0.6905854940414429,
-0.31010496616363525,
-0.5793763399124146,
-0.4448379576206207,
-0.18538601696491241,
-0.16936062276363373,
0.20376673340797424,
-0.6342199444770813,
-0.4055083990097046,
-0.22008341550827026,
0.019707150757312775,
-1.0494683980941772,
0.02918243035674095,
0.22070109844207764,
0.6364407539367676,
-0.4269775450229645,
0.12222055345773697,
0.4114631414413452,
-0.23544783890247345,
-0.2969282865524292,
-0.13553668558597565,
0.04461492598056793,
-1.1260979175567627,
0.39530691504478455,
0.34007003903388977,
0.1102902889251709,
-0.4064248204231262,
-0.7978590726852417,
-0.07607308030128479,
0.9956569075584412,
0.9148046970367432,
-0.5617679357528687,
-0.18726623058319092,
0.6041281223297119,
0.34279245138168335,
-0.4132743179798126,
0.27931228280067444,
0.4374878406524658,
0.6595958471298218,
-0.3542962372303009,
-1.0965958833694458,
0.02189335785806179,
-0.07435737550258636,
0.07448760420084,
-0.4260963797569275,
-0.7770469784736633,
0.6608374118804932,
-0.2960966229438782,
-0.15813744068145752,
0.13268862664699554,
0.6592200994491577,
0.3224705755710602,
0.6546179056167603,
0.5717971920967102,
0.5878398418426514,
1.0423575639724731,
-0.2628319263458252,
0.8397559523582458,
0.07284635305404663,
0.1874566674232483,
0.9169566631317139,
-0.5614514946937561,
0.18748576939105988,
0.3754228353500366,
-0.39602088928222656,
-0.027034755796194077,
0.5910207629203796,
0.04246510937809944,
0.21928295493125916,
0.8375004529953003,
-0.27094101905822754,
-0.10865215212106705,
-0.4260164797306061,
-0.3255822956562042,
0.36616039276123047,
0.40908539295196533,
-0.20820553600788116,
-0.016808461397886276,
0.04017818346619606,
-0.03938955441117287,
0.3884350061416626,
-0.6147097945213318,
0.5252978205680847,
0.2917032241821289,
-0.37929996848106384,
-0.23719197511672974,
0.2987649738788605,
1.0892583131790161,
-0.11791928112506866,
-0.09682992845773697,
-0.2965225279331207,
0.22008384764194489,
-0.239969864487648,
-0.8536801934242249,
0.2274036556482315,
0.08567281067371368,
-0.24467378854751587,
-0.05568794161081314,
0.42965665459632874,
0.025488456711173058,
-0.5879800319671631,
0.37367111444473267,
0.5923845767974854,
0.1639135628938675,
0.11150063574314117,
-0.9077398777008057,
0.12201148271560669,
-0.10569678246974945,
-0.04557311162352562,
0.3580497205257416,
0.7366710901260376,
-0.023715287446975708,
1.0230790376663208,
0.26693445444107056,
-0.08828960359096527,
-0.055132992565631866,
0.21315599977970123,
0.6290352940559387,
-0.7304534912109375,
-0.18602685630321503,
-0.9792554378509521,
0.4103352129459381,
0.060102056711912155,
0.03929918259382248,
0.17239950597286224,
0.23271101713180542,
0.9293617606163025,
0.6149418354034424,
1.1707613468170166,
-0.19191968441009521,
0.23103098571300507,
-0.4280657470226288,
0.7491804957389832,
-0.6963297724723816,
0.4852953255176544,
-0.19208349287509918,
-0.6930225491523743,
-0.5292460322380066,
0.5226849913597107,
-0.11073534935712814,
0.5926405191421509,
0.0837998166680336,
0.5267443656921387,
0.1583046317100525,
0.09486668556928635,
0.316533625125885,
-0.13876384496688843,
0.6339429020881653,
0.6840977072715759,
0.9933050870895386,
-0.13577289879322052,
0.7002288699150085,
0.2470466047525406,
-0.3812147080898285,
-0.11622697114944458,
-1.0335675477981567,
-0.8579334616661072,
-0.28316643834114075,
-0.026609616354107857,
-0.4111870229244232,
0.37752819061279297,
0.9437559247016907,
0.5063888430595398,
-0.553403377532959,
-0.3167155981063843,
0.10113885253667831,
0.6242510080337524,
0.4745754599571228,
-0.23910652101039886,
0.16112037003040314,
-0.44087883830070496,
-0.74375319480896,
-0.0347304604947567,
0.3588639199733734,
0.03347434103488922,
-0.17482154071331024,
-0.4603803753852844,
0.42616304755210876,
-0.141687273979187,
0.44576188921928406,
0.2648717761039734,
-0.6939951777458191,
-0.41889458894729614,
-0.34512507915496826,
-0.21991777420043945,
0.15440623462200165,
0.7517693638801575,
-0.7230421900749207,
0.042164694517850876,
0.03419502079486847,
0.9128050208091736,
-0.16777727007865906,
-0.3824225962162018,
0.6017286777496338,
-0.30572909116744995,
0.035066694021224976,
0.502504825592041,
0.42784661054611206,
0.3817278742790222,
-0.13071538507938385,
0.5921111106872559,
0.14851249754428864,
-0.6164908409118652,
-0.8267791271209717,
0.1560872346162796,
-0.5209243893623352,
-0.302937388420105,
0.6613372564315796,
-0.10443414747714996,
-0.048211827874183655,
-0.16605408489704132,
0.0012395691592246294,
0.09479735046625137,
-0.46484068036079407,
0.9306784272193909,
0.7028999924659729,
-0.04782271385192871,
0.2675204575061798,
-0.46070757508277893,
0.3092936873435974,
0.4769100248813629,
-0.7563707828521729,
-0.07776441425085068,
0.3863489031791687,
0.12540361285209656,
-0.20841357111930847,
1.0966336727142334,
-0.3249463140964508,
0.09149006754159927,
-0.5850803852081299,
-0.14913113415241241,
0.25467321276664734,
-0.12776561081409454,
-0.6052477955818176,
0.30282583832740784,
0.1562345176935196,
0.1628722846508026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01609v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01609v1
|
Judgement Citation Retrieval using Contextual Similarity
| 2024-05-28T04:22:28 | 2024-05-28T04:22:28 |
Akshat Mohan Dasula, Hrushitha Tigulla, Preethika Bhukya
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Traditionally in the domain of legal research, the retrieval of pertinent
citations from intricate case descriptions has demanded manual effort and
keyword-based search applications that mandate expertise in understanding legal
jargon. Legal case descriptions hold pivotal information for legal
professionals and researchers, necessitating more efficient and automated
approaches. We propose a methodology that combines natural language processing
(NLP) and machine learning techniques to enhance the organization and
utilization of legal case descriptions. This approach revolves around the
creation of textual embeddings with the help of state-of-art embedding models.
Our methodology addresses two primary objectives: unsupervised clustering and
supervised citation retrieval, both designed to automate the citation
extraction process. Although the proposed methodology can be used for any
dataset, we employed the Supreme Court of The United States (SCOTUS) dataset,
yielding remarkable results. Our methodology achieved an impressive accuracy
rate of 90.9%. By automating labor-intensive processes, we pave the way for a
more efficient, time-saving, and accessible landscape in legal research,
benefiting legal professionals, academics, and researchers.
|
[
-0.16321593523025513,
-0.7635427713394165,
1.0016828775405884,
0.0369521901011467,
-0.60802161693573,
0.18339821696281433,
-0.10993179678916931,
-0.2703247368335724,
0.4001516103744507,
0.5362080335617065,
0.2212301343679428,
-0.508880615234375,
-0.5182440280914307,
-0.07162807136774063,
-0.6314561367034912,
0.9889166951179504,
0.1332738846540451,
0.39052116870880127,
-0.5807660818099976,
-0.37668314576148987,
-0.32955440878868103,
-0.6268064379692078,
-0.23312249779701233,
-0.3562580645084381,
0.5990648865699768,
0.18178527057170868,
0.49932876229286194,
0.5847254395484924,
0.8369649648666382,
0.28505513072013855,
-0.11416377127170563,
-0.14145712554454803,
0.08406542986631393,
0.3166162967681885,
-0.45378005504608154,
-0.11765439808368683,
-0.1966569721698761,
0.051064494997262955,
0.4443610906600952,
0.7169886231422424,
-0.31907734274864197,
0.17377933859825134,
-0.10961215198040009,
0.8285830020904541,
-0.7204822897911072,
0.15746261179447174,
-0.885988175868988,
0.3691706359386444,
-0.24588969349861145,
-0.5833330154418945,
-0.522285521030426,
-0.5939098596572876,
0.34139513969421387,
-0.6459415555000305,
0.4027270972728729,
0.3877203166484833,
0.6413764357566833,
0.2893260717391968,
-0.47080761194229126,
-0.29374879598617554,
-0.45045435428619385,
0.6720575094223022,
-0.5609268546104431,
0.11388242244720459,
0.22204889357089996,
0.42590269446372986,
-0.12533611059188843,
-0.9363320469856262,
-0.2908659279346466,
-0.23155872523784637,
-0.44858333468437195,
-0.006468988489359617,
-0.4088348150253296,
-0.126100555062294,
0.21662701666355133,
0.11867959797382355,
-0.6219171285629272,
-0.16396979987621307,
-0.45390579104423523,
-0.22210237383842468,
0.7387021780014038,
-0.19144365191459656,
-0.1198858767747879,
-0.5217505693435669,
-0.2551285922527313,
-0.0487007200717926,
-0.42721349000930786,
-0.1748843789100647,
0.18387293815612793,
0.6016899347305298,
0.5379063487052917,
0.5864002704620361,
-0.15150752663612366,
0.6679452061653137,
0.12122727930545807,
0.04389328882098198,
0.5194579362869263,
-0.19537174701690674,
-0.40656784176826477,
0.47436898946762085,
0.7319362163543701,
0.4848369359970093,
0.022664327174425125,
-0.4036448895931244,
0.08864051103591919,
-0.4661940038204193,
0.6676668524742126,
-0.5066806674003601,
-0.0051206364296376705,
0.08214336633682251,
-0.7728878259658813,
-0.2728102207183838,
0.5869932770729065,
-0.7570197582244873,
-0.5531875491142273,
-0.7485378384590149,
-0.003431000979617238,
-0.30827558040618896,
0.19268299639225006,
-0.2340565025806427,
-0.38857442140579224,
0.19063861668109894,
0.13415054976940155,
-0.2731580436229706,
0.1605224609375,
0.6874842047691345,
0.7195370197296143,
-0.2573527991771698,
0.2896581292152405,
-0.5709947943687439,
0.3246433734893799,
-0.15479370951652527,
0.6247298121452332,
-0.9091939926147461,
-0.44770729541778564,
0.22780101001262665,
0.06569090485572815,
-0.1393069475889206,
-0.7861384749412537,
0.9566674828529358,
-0.8539685010910034,
0.07280929386615753,
-0.3122464120388031,
-0.6828638315200806,
-0.272533655166626,
0.1970696598291397,
-0.5595440864562988,
0.8896075487136841,
-0.17285363376140594,
-0.9593845009803772,
0.7142218351364136,
-0.719703197479248,
-0.7513408660888672,
0.375114381313324,
-0.42949286103248596,
-0.6989004015922546,
0.2760145962238312,
0.02072933316230774,
0.5853138566017151,
-0.2999255359172821,
0.7125417590141296,
-0.2367532104253769,
-0.1633845865726471,
-0.21765629947185516,
0.14400614798069,
0.8988543748855591,
0.6272100210189819,
-0.23784348368644714,
0.20931032299995422,
-0.7264826893806458,
0.011914649978280067,
0.22777831554412842,
-0.05227399244904518,
-0.8324213624000549,
0.15085896849632263,
0.14255645871162415,
0.083723284304142,
0.1651710569858551,
-0.5268385410308838,
-0.02281551994383335,
-0.071737140417099,
0.5461463928222656,
0.375905841588974,
0.06359503418207169,
0.5756139159202576,
0.005608594045042992,
0.4069575369358063,
-0.03159356862306595,
-0.05023567005991936,
-0.0533728264272213,
-0.3439314067363739,
-0.3722195029258728,
0.06297361105680466,
0.5404382348060608,
0.5934670567512512,
-0.5251264572143555,
0.6012250781059265,
-0.5067884922027588,
-0.3615534007549286,
-0.41041284799575806,
0.05857854709029198,
0.26248234510421753,
0.7006306648254395,
0.6494451761245728,
-0.36937958002090454,
-0.760904848575592,
-1.2459843158721924,
-0.5968397855758667,
-0.12946347892284393,
-0.08784741163253784,
0.4943636953830719,
0.6832888722419739,
-0.012431224808096886,
1.3018474578857422,
-0.26327449083328247,
-0.40334582328796387,
0.12525461614131927,
0.28872373700141907,
0.2583071291446686,
0.44205865263938904,
0.5857720375061035,
-1.1259031295776367,
-0.5793130397796631,
0.3148792088031769,
-1.0681582689285278,
-0.06158095970749855,
-0.03198231756687164,
-0.136471226811409,
-0.13009247183799744,
0.8647443056106567,
-0.18706603348255157,
0.6305164098739624,
-0.45203855633735657,
-0.5880627036094666,
0.3835855722427368,
-0.16728201508522034,
0.25294777750968933,
-0.9143648743629456,
0.3518545925617218,
0.006755079608410597,
-0.30372896790504456,
-0.20661568641662598,
0.20156405866146088,
0.17034293711185455,
0.22883856296539307,
-0.22712010145187378,
0.18193718791007996,
-0.43874478340148926,
-0.3190837502479553,
-0.13570177555084229,
0.2348237782716751,
0.0124448137357831,
0.18981537222862244,
-0.144671231508255,
0.5480893850326538,
0.30207696557044983,
-0.31192201375961304,
0.23975442349910736,
0.17283962666988373,
-0.3219321370124817,
1.0489695072174072,
-0.5728376507759094,
-0.113993801176548,
-0.0950467437505722,
0.1986573040485382,
-0.3176979422569275,
-0.007435512263327837,
0.08768681436777115,
0.06560206413269043,
0.14566168189048767,
-0.5884119272232056,
-0.8475912809371948,
-0.45189136266708374,
-0.15144729614257812,
0.2540622353553772,
0.2061561793088913,
-0.42122405767440796,
0.7939883470535278,
0.5765946507453918,
-0.34716126322746277,
-0.41718199849128723,
-0.495919793844223,
0.323297917842865,
-0.6987562775611877,
-0.021641364321112633,
0.756813108921051,
0.22021269798278809,
-0.6060981750488281,
0.09454425424337387,
0.06808923184871674,
-0.2862092852592468,
-0.00012583525676745921,
0.5219893455505371,
0.1669704169034958,
-0.0692458376288414,
0.4963611960411072,
0.2242855578660965,
0.2548471987247467,
0.21994538605213165,
-0.3414906859397888,
0.26441264152526855,
-0.14054380357265472,
-0.3288467824459076,
-0.28079643845558167,
0.5718989968299866,
0.3951926827430725,
0.024980464950203896,
0.20680801570415497,
0.44446152448654175,
-0.14112667739391327,
0.3030259907245636,
-0.6924243569374084,
0.1550728678703308,
-0.39106160402297974,
0.052276160567998886,
-0.3922249674797058,
-0.8077036142349243,
0.3117992579936981,
-0.15379773080348969,
0.17418016493320465,
0.6026708483695984,
0.4307946264743805,
-0.17634640634059906,
0.5564151406288147,
0.4736187160015106,
-0.32726767659187317,
0.7242025136947632,
0.18522211909294128,
0.4393075108528137,
-0.635864794254303,
-0.4436894953250885,
-0.7244777679443359,
-0.15451839566230774,
-0.37404677271842957,
-0.45264220237731934,
0.20479357242584229,
0.134039506316185,
-0.32838016748428345,
0.3541421890258789,
-0.7611510753631592,
0.46364542841911316,
0.7680514454841614,
-0.15626487135887146,
0.6140871644020081,
0.489498496055603,
-0.6744750142097473,
0.027675816789269447,
-0.4957886338233948,
-0.7103312611579895,
1.3055273294448853,
-0.08589468896389008,
0.16721008718013763,
0.062446948140859604,
0.8310582041740417,
0.857782781124115,
0.11974562704563141,
-0.6081092357635498,
0.4926735460758209,
0.07477130740880966,
-0.5790897607803345,
-0.09758482873439789,
-0.20588988065719604,
-1.291061520576477,
0.4807855188846588,
-0.22696693241596222,
-0.5449947714805603,
0.35661718249320984,
-0.3245724141597748,
-0.37037891149520874,
0.055718015879392624,
-0.4086122512817383,
0.4764643907546997,
0.01721317321062088,
-0.5400493144989014,
-0.34618180990219116,
-0.8199436664581299,
-0.07377082854509354,
-0.02927805297076702,
0.4461372494697571,
0.033770229667425156,
0.2594289183616638,
0.8854016065597534,
-0.5387942790985107,
0.37087929248809814,
-0.20420898497104645,
0.13428916037082672,
0.54536372423172,
-0.044693633913993835,
0.3293643593788147,
0.12026895582675934,
-0.20041444897651672,
-0.11588316410779953,
0.2157077044248581,
-0.40903472900390625,
-0.5288126468658447,
0.8064424991607666,
-0.186321422457695,
-0.4020068049430847,
-0.6843506097793579,
-0.44642552733421326,
0.017790721729397774,
0.16529379785060883,
-0.24464601278305054,
-0.06319747865200043,
-0.3997645676136017,
0.3368137776851654,
0.28046223521232605,
0.0909763053059578,
0.7385990023612976,
0.571463406085968,
-0.03289913013577461,
-0.3010927140712738,
0.581921398639679,
-0.08411837369203568,
-0.6742765307426453,
0.28381478786468506,
0.018589384853839874,
-0.28128495812416077,
-0.487506628036499,
-0.3938020169734955,
0.03534010797739029,
-0.5939681529998779,
-0.36987435817718506,
-0.6735088229179382,
-0.019676832482218742,
-0.5325140953063965,
-0.1511116921901703,
-0.1263226568698883,
-0.5910013914108276,
-0.15496787428855896,
-0.3153350055217743,
0.47742825746536255,
0.6362320780754089,
0.09831393510103226,
0.04340285807847977,
-0.5161061882972717,
-0.05628655478358269,
0.2518663704395294,
0.2416701763868332,
-0.04140898585319519,
-0.5848315358161926,
-0.22074547410011292,
-0.39782440662384033,
-0.3294464349746704,
-0.5047112107276917,
0.4673868417739868,
0.10743027925491333,
0.6937798261642456,
0.47036150097846985,
0.16488558053970337,
0.8507579565048218,
-0.9472519159317017,
0.48954853415489197,
0.11913637816905975,
-0.5315694808959961,
0.9257874488830566,
-0.16798314452171326,
-0.3214386999607086,
1.0368521213531494,
0.37460988759994507,
0.13487817347049713,
-0.055379364639520645,
-0.8863508105278015,
-1.0709500312805176,
0.24064160883426666,
0.32462772727012634,
0.0009593238355591893,
0.05313967540860176,
0.617551863193512,
0.16816264390945435,
0.3282388746738434,
-0.38532695174217224,
-0.14859245717525482,
0.0015916544944047928,
-0.09361162781715393,
0.15307383239269257,
-0.10592732578516006,
-0.5043173432350159,
-0.6930671334266663,
0.6044521331787109,
-0.1939118206501007,
0.2898126244544983,
0.3792734742164612,
-0.396547794342041,
0.2664802074432373,
0.43095871806144714,
0.24447070062160492,
0.5999205112457275,
-0.19481074810028076,
0.1726597249507904,
-0.03052281029522419,
-0.17360427975654602,
-0.1872193068265915,
0.468341588973999,
-0.3417578637599945,
0.4520431458950043,
0.35170212388038635,
0.30793166160583496,
0.21683786809444427,
-0.7617287039756775,
0.5348771810531616,
-0.059921760112047195,
-0.3682887554168701,
-0.7603497505187988,
-0.3174533247947693,
-0.15880948305130005,
0.5243910551071167,
0.8211094737052917,
0.062226276844739914,
0.7023555040359497,
-0.5502105355262756,
0.5054602026939392,
0.43076854944229126,
-0.5441981554031372,
0.176635280251503,
0.580909013748169,
0.021029481664299965,
-0.14121784269809723,
0.3119345009326935,
-0.09276524931192398,
-0.17667913436889648,
0.4454406499862671,
0.12452372163534164,
0.5794674158096313,
0.3382129371166229,
0.14217397570610046,
0.36659014225006104,
-0.26736000180244446,
-0.3061973452568054,
-0.04235155135393143,
-0.34899306297302246,
-0.22181157767772675,
-0.15032868087291718,
-0.8145638704299927,
-0.14551228284835815,
-0.3534938395023346,
-1.0981043577194214,
-0.03474889695644379,
-0.3991921842098236,
-0.37468379735946655,
0.06977078318595886,
0.046862345188856125,
-0.6825402975082397,
-0.06506571173667908,
0.008898252621293068,
0.601348340511322,
-0.8062698841094971,
0.8189346790313721,
0.7038123607635498,
-0.6398184299468994,
-0.23793189227581024,
-0.17122788727283478,
0.05675588175654411,
-0.37577006220817566,
0.7978183627128601,
-0.04918858781456947,
0.09825382381677628,
-0.3049878776073456,
-0.5045722723007202,
-0.6632331609725952,
1.290041446685791,
0.2060813307762146,
-0.6961563229560852,
0.059833794832229614,
-0.11152619123458862,
0.7235000133514404,
-0.6080284714698792,
0.21620500087738037,
0.8287802338600159,
0.49523109197616577,
0.18818719685077667,
-0.8308427333831787,
0.26907169818878174,
-0.5578855276107788,
0.09505724906921387,
-0.35602301359176636,
-0.2552172839641571,
0.38498345017433167,
-0.11137986928224564,
-0.08086216449737549,
0.02059822715818882,
0.7003030776977539,
0.40527772903442383,
0.621520459651947,
0.38036048412323,
0.6414123773574829,
1.037645697593689,
-0.14821437001228333,
1.0543245077133179,
-0.35416531562805176,
0.3884831964969635,
1.2962369918823242,
-0.27656856179237366,
0.8243684768676758,
1.010648250579834,
-0.2517102062702179,
0.8540938496589661,
0.4799015522003174,
-0.2912802994251251,
0.59511399269104,
0.23652438819408417,
0.008928433060646057,
-0.33511894941329956,
-0.3232782781124115,
-0.2640671133995056,
0.09181127697229385,
0.03787494823336601,
-1.084207534790039,
-0.1288491040468216,
-0.023984920233488083,
-0.12451209127902985,
0.5567980408668518,
-0.12232207506895065,
0.7808254957199097,
0.08617758750915527,
-0.5800674557685852,
0.053207848221063614,
-0.16015619039535522,
0.5837000012397766,
-0.053933411836624146,
-0.14773859083652496,
-0.02162015810608864,
-0.08677204698324203,
-0.26019975543022156,
-0.5752479434013367,
0.4131351411342621,
0.061232808977365494,
-0.4795936942100525,
-0.47681376338005066,
0.4718741774559021,
0.046722762286663055,
-0.5905126333236694,
0.5393610596656799,
0.5319968461990356,
0.37535393238067627,
-0.15416719019412994,
-0.9438238143920898,
-0.27821990847587585,
-0.17024074494838715,
-0.11638403683900833,
0.3485071361064911,
0.40730753540992737,
-0.33389654755592346,
0.4703114330768585,
0.6634953618049622,
-0.05379832163453102,
0.1608981043100357,
0.5502790212631226,
0.9055980443954468,
-0.8233403563499451,
-0.45239120721817017,
-0.7762829065322876,
0.13880035281181335,
-0.7999610304832458,
-0.00680274935439229,
0.6901010870933533,
0.8720918893814087,
0.6645488142967224,
0.059276994317770004,
0.8487430810928345,
-0.4023192524909973,
0.6799322962760925,
-0.39009448885917664,
0.5561848878860474,
-0.4633111357688904,
0.3123340308666229,
-0.37579119205474854,
-0.810594379901886,
-0.6210724115371704,
0.9062322974205017,
-0.3542786240577698,
0.04522335156798363,
0.6807942390441895,
0.46284976601600647,
-0.161049947142601,
-0.05688449740409851,
0.10327739268541336,
-0.06929513812065125,
0.10302593559026718,
0.0923268124461174,
0.3914051055908203,
-0.4768572747707367,
0.59540194272995,
-0.027133552357554436,
0.1827745884656906,
-0.7148378491401672,
-0.815105676651001,
-0.8408204317092896,
-0.4171181917190552,
-0.4415803849697113,
-0.2263619750738144,
0.14451664686203003,
0.7664989829063416,
0.7079662084579468,
-1.120120882987976,
-0.010582048445940018,
-0.25487565994262695,
0.2167140692472458,
-0.09324200451374054,
-0.2753032445907593,
0.6907151341438293,
-0.5771104693412781,
-0.6546107530593872,
0.42910897731781006,
0.1739841252565384,
-0.30094924569129944,
0.12241482734680176,
0.05372921749949455,
-0.4803617596626282,
-0.22291427850723267,
0.6853429079055786,
0.16341641545295715,
-0.9981777667999268,
-0.2091885209083557,
-0.4774043560028076,
-0.19677071273326874,
0.1334465742111206,
1.176226019859314,
-0.9324334859848022,
0.42222562432289124,
0.34548455476760864,
0.593390941619873,
0.5209872126579285,
0.25786781311035156,
0.527644157409668,
-0.6742071509361267,
0.009431618265807629,
0.2898419201374054,
0.7601252794265747,
0.25132235884666443,
-0.15756696462631226,
0.9132150411605835,
0.3359498083591461,
-0.3991430699825287,
-0.7003302574157715,
-0.1415948122739792,
-1.2404699325561523,
-0.6833665370941162,
0.8606013059616089,
-0.140434131026268,
-0.08647268265485764,
-0.5005180239677429,
-0.1367863416671753,
0.2464117705821991,
-0.6581127047538757,
0.9611495137214661,
0.4845907986164093,
-0.11587651073932648,
0.19607862830162048,
-0.6164853572845459,
0.2420101761817932,
0.4028964936733246,
-0.3453509509563446,
-0.16283264756202698,
0.5143736004829407,
0.38923269510269165,
0.6140437722206116,
0.23731671273708344,
-0.45291370153427124,
0.027606774121522903,
-0.2300814688205719,
0.17087359726428986,
-0.008220070041716099,
-0.04847175255417824,
-0.3013022840023041,
0.6400596499443054,
-0.3799896538257599,
0.19621294736862183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17809v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17809v1
|
TransVIP: Speech to Speech Translation System with Voice and Isochrony Preservation
| 2024-05-28T04:11:37 | 2024-05-28T04:11:37 |
Chenyang Le, Yao Qian, Dongmei Wang, Long Zhou, Shujie Liu, Xiaofei Wang, Midia Yousefi, Yanmin Qian, Jinyu Li, Sheng Zhao, Michael Zeng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
There is a rising interest and trend in research towards directly translating
speech from one language to another, known as end-to-end speech-to-speech
translation. However, most end-to-end models struggle to outperform cascade
models, i.e., a pipeline framework by concatenating speech recognition, machine
translation and text-to-speech models. The primary challenges stem from the
inherent complexities involved in direct translation tasks and the scarcity of
data. In this study, we introduce a novel model framework TransVIP that
leverages diverse datasets in a cascade fashion yet facilitates end-to-end
inference through joint probability. Furthermore, we propose two separated
encoders to preserve the speaker's voice characteristics and isochrony from the
source speech during the translation process, making it highly suitable for
scenarios such as video dubbing. Our experiments on the French-English language
pair demonstrate that our model outperforms the current state-of-the-art
speech-to-speech translation model.
|
[
-0.21096263825893402,
-0.3570365309715271,
0.05303357169032097,
0.1517091989517212,
-0.5097723603248596,
0.043656520545482635,
-0.21613019704818726,
-0.2868511974811554,
-0.07894370704889297,
0.5161917209625244,
-0.5649477243423462,
-0.31898319721221924,
-0.6252716779708862,
0.0863359346985817,
-0.8638460636138916,
0.7288603782653809,
0.13249258697032928,
0.4288705289363861,
-0.20711477100849152,
-0.12670868635177612,
-0.5676934719085693,
-0.45644447207450867,
-0.5335995554924011,
-0.2831454575061798,
-0.06923054903745651,
0.2764052450656891,
0.7252720594406128,
0.604306161403656,
0.2480980008840561,
0.08624856919050217,
-0.11188017576932907,
0.024982288479804993,
-0.21321330964565277,
0.3993193805217743,
-0.2353091686964035,
-0.4300194978713989,
-0.2360696792602539,
-0.331094354391098,
0.9464719295501709,
0.7177249789237976,
-0.21664659678936005,
0.32212406396865845,
0.26474612951278687,
0.3650686740875244,
-0.6941744089126587,
-0.06367699056863785,
-0.3892974555492401,
0.16224415600299835,
-0.20325356721878052,
-0.17337003350257874,
-0.6366332769393921,
-0.1344655603170395,
0.06354363262653351,
-0.2039252370595932,
0.060207549482584,
-0.19588670134544373,
0.4858555495738983,
0.5642156004905701,
-0.37011852860450745,
0.20137259364128113,
-1.3363049030303955,
0.36158281564712524,
-0.7120792269706726,
0.9310498237609863,
0.10942769795656204,
0.3052815794944763,
0.0318601168692112,
-0.9557523131370544,
-0.5797559022903442,
0.07799891382455826,
0.31979188323020935,
0.3114868700504303,
-0.33588457107543945,
-0.061017781496047974,
-0.0786181390285492,
0.18459241092205048,
-0.6818253993988037,
0.1775759905576706,
-0.22886697947978973,
-0.15666495263576508,
0.380670964717865,
-0.07608090341091156,
0.44806626439094543,
-0.09693416953086853,
-0.4650231897830963,
-0.21400392055511475,
-0.5370419025421143,
0.1165207177400589,
0.13358215987682343,
0.43092820048332214,
-0.10450582951307297,
0.5699157118797302,
-0.06913302838802338,
0.6666473746299744,
-0.12250109761953354,
0.06158680096268654,
0.27959582209587097,
-0.10832306742668152,
-0.42878979444503784,
0.37652018666267395,
0.6865512132644653,
0.19723252952098846,
0.25194042921066284,
-0.33370599150657654,
-0.001620673225261271,
-0.03197720646858215,
-0.10924524813890457,
-0.6433664560317993,
0.30375179648399353,
0.12758690118789673,
-0.4435305893421173,
0.04078326001763344,
0.04828612133860588,
-0.5054891109466553,
0.17986518144607544,
-0.2900950014591217,
0.1818569451570511,
-0.28075364232063293,
-0.25990745425224304,
0.1506209373474121,
-0.12756869196891785,
0.21734200417995453,
0.2685878574848175,
-0.5834893584251404,
0.5495355725288391,
0.6323599219322205,
1.0413764715194702,
-0.3553861677646637,
-0.13375984132289886,
-0.8519287109375,
0.4490516483783722,
-0.4672212302684784,
0.5317760705947876,
-0.7886380553245544,
-0.624198317527771,
0.11042886972427368,
0.08274019509553909,
0.12317432463169098,
-0.36991655826568604,
0.7911468744277954,
-0.2584989070892334,
0.37774962186813354,
-0.09104694426059723,
-0.42752355337142944,
-0.11682101339101791,
-0.18517355620861053,
-0.583889365196228,
0.6655561327934265,
-0.18844644725322723,
-0.43596702814102173,
0.24342243373394012,
-0.0019398753065615892,
-0.3523079454898834,
0.2078656703233719,
-0.08880248665809631,
-0.3505362868309021,
0.30410677194595337,
0.3344881534576416,
0.31394022703170776,
-0.9064239263534546,
0.469605028629303,
-0.16857300698757172,
-0.04597921296954155,
0.0739273950457573,
-0.8570140600204468,
0.8016499876976013,
0.37120330333709717,
0.16116081178188324,
-0.1700797826051712,
-0.5002869367599487,
-0.16256193816661835,
-0.13864018023014069,
-0.2093949019908905,
-0.28510093688964844,
0.13883186876773834,
0.3904601037502289,
0.6270244121551514,
0.01699327677488327,
-0.5974749326705933,
0.18364226818084717,
-0.3116339445114136,
0.7157187461853027,
0.22832097113132477,
0.001508630346506834,
0.6331427097320557,
-0.1622748076915741,
0.6742885112762451,
0.22128552198410034,
0.1679951250553131,
-0.15763740241527557,
-0.6685771942138672,
-0.5095228552818298,
-0.07620083540678024,
0.3672791123390198,
1.0552300214767456,
-0.5122423768043518,
0.39063987135887146,
-0.7759992480278015,
-0.2662374973297119,
-0.8265607953071594,
-0.05388743430376053,
0.2148209810256958,
0.5568034648895264,
0.4336563050746918,
-0.5793196558952332,
-0.2788592576980591,
-0.9983641505241394,
-0.15317566692829132,
-0.24611538648605347,
-0.3422713875770569,
-0.07281657308340073,
0.06706904619932175,
-0.034468427300453186,
0.9720439910888672,
-0.01849973201751709,
-0.40144556760787964,
-0.1843402087688446,
0.026342755183577538,
-0.0024049875792115927,
0.5960514545440674,
0.13096803426742554,
-0.8155991435050964,
-0.12129202485084534,
0.053713586181402206,
-0.5941519141197205,
-0.2711004614830017,
-0.33987000584602356,
-0.07035379856824875,
-0.22875317931175232,
0.6098542809486389,
-0.5363768339157104,
0.4665951430797577,
0.5368439555168152,
-0.044542811810970306,
0.032586224377155304,
-0.18161454796791077,
0.15508954226970673,
-1.5089337825775146,
0.10247866064310074,
-0.15158900618553162,
-0.592614471912384,
-0.7464898824691772,
-0.3005577623844147,
-0.10710813850164413,
-0.4781211316585541,
-0.6214028596878052,
0.26583775877952576,
-0.4003461003303528,
-0.3157784044742584,
-0.047362055629491806,
-0.08490593731403351,
-0.2756598889827728,
0.354116290807724,
0.5669919848442078,
0.6360852122306824,
0.5083512663841248,
-0.33742016553878784,
0.40223073959350586,
0.5689759850502014,
-0.13346144556999207,
0.549721896648407,
-0.5873545408248901,
0.14462026953697205,
-0.2816801071166992,
0.5536457300186157,
-0.8999527096748352,
0.0646725594997406,
0.0697656124830246,
-0.7243330478668213,
0.49735328555107117,
-0.4254907965660095,
-0.31841450929641724,
-0.030316339805722237,
0.11675937473773956,
0.5179126262664795,
0.72844398021698,
-0.29185962677001953,
0.6125441193580627,
0.31710585951805115,
-0.6036527752876282,
-0.6713913083076477,
-0.9001452922821045,
0.536168098449707,
-0.15456253290176392,
-0.6365668177604675,
0.6527587175369263,
0.29641255736351013,
0.14699408411979675,
0.013623583130538464,
-0.017257219180464745,
-0.21616555750370026,
-0.4792816638946533,
0.21928012371063232,
0.028239846229553223,
-0.055079925805330276,
0.25564154982566833,
0.28693312406539917,
-0.2644704580307007,
-0.07117931544780731,
-0.814514696598053,
0.5655831694602966,
0.3144412636756897,
-0.4217558205127716,
-0.5741303563117981,
0.7924696207046509,
0.8001385927200317,
-0.3722694516181946,
0.48312312364578247,
0.5592776536941528,
-0.6348967552185059,
-0.2834559381008148,
-0.36629927158355713,
-0.04525615647435188,
-0.30646225810050964,
0.4810541272163391,
-0.4486064910888672,
-0.4716004729270935,
0.5381863713264465,
-0.2711413502693176,
0.09271097928285599,
0.28171268105506897,
0.5091081261634827,
0.08905057609081268,
1.010762333869934,
0.42106741666793823,
-0.2491563856601715,
0.6348810791969299,
-0.1358109563589096,
0.11826512962579727,
-0.8844743967056274,
-0.43004682660102844,
-0.5298733711242676,
-0.3148311972618103,
-0.4595940411090851,
-0.6318768262863159,
0.3371417820453644,
0.13008257746696472,
-0.07608117163181305,
0.5026257634162903,
-0.5440735816955566,
0.025455612689256668,
0.612353503704071,
-0.06620970368385315,
0.4683544635772705,
0.28844213485717773,
0.08310694247484207,
-0.21948407590389252,
-0.8547928333282471,
-0.43799057602882385,
0.6749612092971802,
0.266187846660614,
0.8122303485870361,
0.14075832068920135,
0.47042787075042725,
0.38943371176719666,
-0.13580012321472168,
-0.5323639512062073,
0.4531577527523041,
-0.39827415347099304,
-0.5467952489852905,
-0.36641189455986023,
-0.3211018443107605,
-0.5313474535942078,
0.2749308943748474,
-0.1075674295425415,
-0.8383233547210693,
0.6713571548461914,
0.08492828905582428,
0.0033451979979872704,
0.39911970496177673,
-0.2432742416858673,
0.6486281156539917,
-0.16143293678760529,
-0.6002956628799438,
-0.15193279087543488,
-1.0950442552566528,
0.19792455434799194,
0.07751786708831787,
0.0472712442278862,
0.10963728278875351,
-0.07205668091773987,
0.5681642889976501,
-0.3934325873851776,
0.5350996255874634,
-0.055196844041347504,
-0.0829707682132721,
0.22933945059776306,
0.2826240360736847,
0.3393961489200592,
0.17652186751365662,
0.04408310353755951,
0.29223737120628357,
-0.07273092865943909,
0.014382850378751755,
-0.5656154155731201,
0.4438464641571045,
-0.6657320261001587,
-0.41107988357543945,
-0.26153889298439026,
-0.4786466956138611,
-0.11779411137104034,
-0.11094297468662262,
0.6527103185653687,
0.5232317447662354,
-0.29975032806396484,
0.3471362590789795,
0.5128610134124756,
-0.35794728994369507,
0.5557209849357605,
0.33259671926498413,
-0.09808884561061859,
-0.49546727538108826,
0.8405019640922546,
0.16758102178573608,
0.6423622965812683,
0.8367370963096619,
-0.07311172038316727,
-0.5579670667648315,
-0.3121583163738251,
-0.7564238905906677,
0.013798228465020657,
-0.5667853355407715,
-0.09013576060533524,
-0.5845985412597656,
-0.39839789271354675,
-0.6104725003242493,
-0.03663012385368347,
-0.6795918345451355,
-0.768208920955658,
-0.28698599338531494,
0.07983600348234177,
-0.10946161299943924,
0.2489735335111618,
-0.3035391867160797,
0.13948413729667664,
-0.9793590307235718,
0.4155988395214081,
0.2952347993850708,
-0.14128270745277405,
-0.28529688715934753,
-0.9651347398757935,
-0.02684348076581955,
0.08090608566999435,
-0.0985942929983139,
-1.079970359802246,
0.7249001860618591,
0.48126137256622314,
0.27798739075660706,
0.3448924422264099,
0.11775271594524384,
0.668805718421936,
-0.6727964282035828,
0.7808506488800049,
0.3630983531475067,
-1.1869515180587769,
0.6716687083244324,
-0.06979882717132568,
0.5241605639457703,
0.2632471024990082,
0.2125525027513504,
-1.1092205047607422,
-0.23686902225017548,
-0.3018604815006256,
-0.8785560727119446,
0.5970548987388611,
0.45250359177589417,
0.011478003114461899,
0.32716798782348633,
0.05528853461146355,
0.06245584785938263,
0.21788236498832703,
-0.5548754930496216,
0.11084409058094025,
-0.2572772204875946,
-0.2318723201751709,
-0.14379499852657318,
0.07056351751089096,
0.036696139723062515,
-0.16216588020324707,
0.6252328753471375,
0.1476161777973175,
0.33917269110679626,
0.296402245759964,
-0.3135770857334137,
-0.12014740705490112,
0.47400009632110596,
0.4663061499595642,
0.12574100494384766,
-0.21703171730041504,
-0.01072012260556221,
0.3282567858695984,
-0.44688212871551514,
0.6213811635971069,
0.28330206871032715,
-0.3808409869670868,
0.22556661069393158,
0.514592707157135,
0.800008237361908,
-0.07292856276035309,
-0.41779235005378723,
0.487486869096756,
-0.04167373850941658,
0.012495040893554688,
-0.3204420804977417,
-0.41721680760383606,
0.15540452301502228,
0.05768941342830658,
0.3943272829055786,
0.30951860547065735,
0.23882876336574554,
-0.4782746136188507,
0.24846023321151733,
0.15771165490150452,
-0.5715882182121277,
-0.3542885482311249,
1.2100883722305298,
0.4212803840637207,
-0.6720825433731079,
0.7325076460838318,
0.26171645522117615,
-0.24953123927116394,
0.26577332615852356,
0.598739743232727,
1.305606722831726,
-0.7452755570411682,
0.2232588678598404,
0.07629558444023132,
0.4473644196987152,
-0.2732831835746765,
0.07482021301984787,
-0.3352493941783905,
-0.521251916885376,
-0.44871726632118225,
-0.5164351463317871,
-0.296368271112442,
-0.10022948682308197,
-0.8950915336608887,
0.4286704957485199,
0.0339331217110157,
-0.3291865885257721,
-0.321265310049057,
-0.7561107277870178,
-0.6815167665481567,
0.265485942363739,
0.5609089732170105,
0.9122782349586487,
-1.0779054164886475,
0.9960232973098755,
0.39968326687812805,
-0.4251450002193451,
-0.32725492119789124,
-0.0664413645863533,
-0.09662181884050369,
-0.41220909357070923,
0.6429831385612488,
-0.15817883610725403,
-0.41597500443458557,
0.024253489449620247,
-0.3080354630947113,
-0.899398148059845,
0.8795189261436462,
0.9080668687820435,
-1.0337239503860474,
-0.35051223635673523,
0.4986436367034912,
0.38091596961021423,
-0.3005765974521637,
-0.03889104723930359,
0.4267377555370331,
0.08266298472881317,
0.2466886043548584,
-1.011174201965332,
-0.17534707486629486,
-0.2301107794046402,
0.2260691076517105,
0.08969443291425705,
-0.4764334261417389,
0.6257150769233704,
0.040126413106918335,
-0.4102484881877899,
-0.2786606252193451,
0.8306001424789429,
-0.17919574677944183,
0.1266583502292633,
0.5069939494132996,
0.6503612399101257,
0.23432812094688416,
-0.0185091532766819,
0.7798214554786682,
-0.4114040732383728,
0.10567284375429153,
1.2595847845077515,
-0.29963675141334534,
1.0763497352600098,
0.5309152007102966,
0.06240713223814964,
0.14936809241771698,
0.5521456003189087,
0.42300280928611755,
0.8034690022468567,
0.0029977450612932444,
-0.4323548972606659,
-0.6291763782501221,
-0.34736475348472595,
-0.45512503385543823,
0.6425841450691223,
0.43232011795043945,
-0.4265820384025574,
-0.14641256630420685,
0.3005219101905823,
-0.3246716558933258,
-0.05913723260164261,
0.04940703138709068,
0.7218096852302551,
0.29075032472610474,
-0.6057418584823608,
0.3200712203979492,
-0.14886009693145752,
0.1771429181098938,
-0.631525456905365,
-0.13838009536266327,
-0.12791329622268677,
0.1084117665886879,
-0.09588610380887985,
-0.5641290545463562,
0.1560540795326233,
0.0778966099023819,
-0.11236487329006195,
-0.34846562147140503,
0.45239928364753723,
-0.839855968952179,
-0.6030448079109192,
0.47382602095603943,
0.6406912803649902,
0.10778474807739258,
0.2536839246749878,
-0.4197174608707428,
0.027695689350366592,
-0.1325688511133194,
-0.20627667009830475,
-0.023231618106365204,
0.3066262900829315,
-0.18430198729038239,
0.8426927328109741,
0.47008031606674194,
0.35797491669654846,
0.03508588671684265,
0.3454502820968628,
0.5078927874565125,
-0.2811618447303772,
-0.7912231087684631,
-0.8403587937355042,
0.601779580116272,
0.06655155122280121,
-0.4078216850757599,
0.34126031398773193,
0.7660059928894043,
0.7908043265342712,
0.025698382407426834,
1.0235224962234497,
0.18147656321525574,
0.3400079309940338,
-0.5103981494903564,
0.3508666455745697,
-0.4668525159358978,
0.1621524691581726,
-0.35656365752220154,
-1.0881271362304688,
-0.1824897676706314,
0.3112618625164032,
0.1036299392580986,
-0.17623759806156158,
0.443337619304657,
0.6457382440567017,
-0.21662987768650055,
-0.0057830424048006535,
0.5221981406211853,
-0.0946781262755394,
0.4667620360851288,
0.7756605744361877,
0.734533965587616,
-0.46378326416015625,
0.6759763360023499,
0.0762598067522049,
-0.1324194371700287,
-0.027702422812581062,
-0.6752086281776428,
-0.4316183626651764,
-1.0303314924240112,
-0.2398667186498642,
-0.20395374298095703,
0.29608798027038574,
0.8547794818878174,
1.0078954696655273,
-0.6276113986968994,
-0.3556419014930725,
-0.1343923807144165,
-0.29614347219467163,
-0.4445386528968811,
-0.053169190883636475,
0.09078461676836014,
0.038511913269758224,
-0.9904975295066833,
0.5222530364990234,
0.41028082370758057,
0.21884256601333618,
-0.3290192484855652,
-0.21825933456420898,
-0.027842268347740173,
0.11753928661346436,
0.3030400574207306,
0.2482224851846695,
-0.6996023058891296,
-0.08236703276634216,
-0.14477762579917908,
0.18323738873004913,
-0.03919689729809761,
0.9902155995368958,
-0.8284308314323425,
0.6907872557640076,
0.7953897714614868,
0.7399961352348328,
0.9675310254096985,
0.13090026378631592,
1.195832371711731,
-0.8120409250259399,
0.41002482175827026,
0.43103545904159546,
0.38853996992111206,
0.5026298761367798,
-0.18047018349170685,
0.4314463138580322,
0.22756466269493103,
-0.49170172214508057,
-0.8890977501869202,
0.4055805802345276,
-1.0843597650527954,
-0.15490254759788513,
0.9020692110061646,
0.01786259561777115,
0.07473380118608475,
0.07340054959058762,
-0.026335440576076508,
0.774610698223114,
-0.512669026851654,
0.3040412962436676,
0.6281845569610596,
0.13429298996925354,
-0.4665970206260681,
-0.6872440576553345,
0.4347746670246124,
0.40290582180023193,
-0.5796245336532593,
0.2212829887866974,
0.3383971154689789,
0.10038392245769501,
0.01267273910343647,
0.36261290311813354,
-0.04369610548019409,
0.27723291516304016,
0.04331468790769577,
0.10753330588340759,
0.021533388644456863,
-0.4993821978569031,
-0.5712743997573853,
0.1443638652563095,
-0.3342791199684143,
-0.6052519083023071
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17804v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17804v1
|
Detection-Correction Structure via General Language Model for Grammatical Error Correction
| 2024-05-28T04:04:40 | 2024-05-28T04:04:40 |
Wei Li, Houfeng Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Grammatical error correction (GEC) is a task dedicated to rectifying texts
with minimal edits, which can be decoupled into two components: detection and
correction. However, previous works have predominantly focused on direct
correction, with no prior efforts to integrate both into a single model.
Moreover, the exploration of the detection-correction paradigm by large
language models (LLMs) remains underdeveloped. This paper introduces an
integrated detection-correction structure, named DeCoGLM, based on the General
Language Model (GLM). The detection phase employs a fault-tolerant detection
template, while the correction phase leverages autoregressive mask infilling
for localized error correction. Through the strategic organization of input
tokens and modification of attention masks, we facilitate multi-task learning
within a single model. Our model demonstrates competitive performance against
the state-of-the-art models on English and Chinese GEC datasets. Further
experiments present the effectiveness of the detection-correction structure in
LLMs, suggesting a promising direction for GEC.
|
[
0.10727256536483765,
-0.9822292923927307,
0.524890124797821,
0.04562371224164963,
-0.2093551903963089,
-0.15119010210037231,
-0.2940503656864166,
-0.2862756550312042,
-0.0811784639954567,
0.2632303237915039,
-0.463456928730011,
-0.8590746521949768,
-0.5403119921684265,
0.2533278465270996,
-0.4662693440914154,
0.8251401782035828,
-0.0702219158411026,
-0.006123318336904049,
-0.22579272091388702,
-0.006682693026959896,
-0.594641387462616,
-0.7555709481239319,
-0.8315767645835876,
-0.1835607886314392,
0.2550959289073944,
0.32192331552505493,
0.34406957030296326,
0.6115812063217163,
0.21431176364421844,
0.39610666036605835,
-0.3425882160663605,
0.42833760380744934,
-0.24887217581272125,
-0.14322075247764587,
-0.17641706764698029,
-0.7090128064155579,
-0.8551109433174133,
-0.284236341714859,
1.0224370956420898,
0.5979686975479126,
-0.30875036120414734,
-0.17422157526016235,
0.49316951632499695,
0.5115705132484436,
-0.779033362865448,
0.43614983558654785,
-0.7376343607902527,
0.0033072775695472956,
-0.2597905397415161,
0.2773384153842926,
-0.7308735847473145,
-0.08861697465181351,
-0.5966997742652893,
-0.3380153179168701,
0.6455603241920471,
-0.37808939814567566,
0.508743941783905,
-0.015689337626099586,
-0.2967372536659241,
-0.2390376180410385,
-0.7389270663261414,
0.4208832383155823,
-0.6968281865119934,
0.1432192474603653,
0.36348971724510193,
0.028672978281974792,
-0.3760087192058563,
-0.3923192620277405,
-0.3530479669570923,
0.0259365476667881,
-0.2659136950969696,
0.2083617001771927,
-0.4539133608341217,
0.2785857915878296,
-0.021459026262164116,
0.21558625996112823,
-0.7152342200279236,
0.13209444284439087,
0.07038696855306625,
-0.2110426425933838,
0.28964105248451233,
0.17796571552753448,
0.541062593460083,
0.05958382785320282,
-0.0932198315858841,
0.2917781174182892,
-0.5986227989196777,
-0.198806494474411,
0.34590405225753784,
0.5579758882522583,
-0.20366187393665314,
0.15494099259376526,
-0.17051959037780762,
0.7659802436828613,
0.14733794331550598,
-0.052043113857507706,
0.08939547091722488,
-0.4617137014865875,
-0.4368402063846588,
-0.046387046575546265,
0.45374736189842224,
0.07917600870132446,
0.08198245614767075,
-0.134441539645195,
-0.4787507653236389,
0.4640357196331024,
0.16624177992343903,
-0.26284903287887573,
-0.34490108489990234,
-0.053206030279397964,
-0.21118885278701782,
-0.3202826678752899,
0.1627209484577179,
-0.5238254070281982,
-0.07908743619918823,
-0.2860371172428131,
0.39604127407073975,
-0.010220128111541271,
-0.16594645380973816,
0.40522128343582153,
0.3141113817691803,
-0.2079116553068161,
0.5382020473480225,
-0.9580350518226624,
0.3874231278896332,
0.6645922064781189,
0.9036784768104553,
-0.004942041356116533,
-0.3295876383781433,
-0.782196044921875,
0.26250219345092773,
-0.41305020451545715,
0.9621863961219788,
-0.28480035066604614,
-0.41445109248161316,
0.2676422894001007,
0.3308522701263428,
-0.5283302664756775,
-0.6222717761993408,
0.4959520101547241,
-0.3603973388671875,
0.413174033164978,
-0.21185873448848724,
-0.46190449595451355,
-0.29521670937538147,
0.4993875324726105,
-0.7023194432258606,
1.0384303331375122,
0.0030827925074845552,
-0.7592294216156006,
0.17824606597423553,
-0.5569738745689392,
-0.5048409104347229,
0.11769253760576248,
0.02954995445907116,
-0.609191358089447,
-0.015330720692873001,
0.5271767377853394,
0.29600945115089417,
0.018754003569483757,
0.5444669723510742,
-0.02685004472732544,
-0.6108866930007935,
-0.10946348309516907,
-0.2607194781303406,
0.6725097298622131,
-0.07568524032831192,
-0.5073827505111694,
0.5548607110977173,
-0.7657639384269714,
-0.19876965880393982,
0.042709123343229294,
-0.6098912358283997,
-0.27115610241889954,
0.23389305174350739,
-0.14531700313091278,
0.12968802452087402,
-0.19983039796352386,
-0.409416526556015,
0.21898745000362396,
-0.2685641944408417,
0.4984678626060486,
0.6974250674247742,
-0.3234163820743561,
0.5550936460494995,
-0.04198077693581581,
0.5223482251167297,
0.06772550940513611,
0.290984570980072,
-0.2788999676704407,
-0.3548364043235779,
-1.0014296770095825,
-0.450714647769928,
0.10608069598674774,
0.8493282794952393,
-0.6323366761207581,
0.6238725781440735,
-0.041844699531793594,
-0.13391131162643433,
-0.3289741277694702,
0.2769549489021301,
0.6517724394798279,
0.6017228364944458,
0.4127611219882965,
-0.1327977180480957,
-0.54194176197052,
-0.461931049823761,
-0.443292498588562,
-0.3618326485157013,
0.028541533276438713,
-0.0786891058087349,
0.5832839608192444,
-0.4097708463668823,
0.6427258253097534,
-0.4381008446216583,
-0.6890867948532104,
-0.486981600522995,
-0.05421598628163338,
0.14390984177589417,
0.38009414076805115,
0.46885940432548523,
-0.3637813329696655,
-0.3524836003780365,
0.0647360309958458,
-0.6970855593681335,
-0.33987969160079956,
0.1755015105009079,
-0.10506328195333481,
0.5413627028465271,
0.7637614011764526,
-0.36682358384132385,
0.4017675220966339,
0.5749402046203613,
-0.45916593074798584,
0.6955671310424805,
-0.3427286148071289,
0.1087987944483757,
-0.857289731502533,
0.0477781817317009,
-0.03320232778787613,
-0.44256022572517395,
-0.8644997477531433,
0.25507596135139465,
0.45831820368766785,
0.12679284811019897,
-0.2786097526550293,
0.4086189866065979,
-0.5625743269920349,
0.025614537298679352,
-0.4389648139476776,
0.09480981528759003,
-0.0756719559431076,
0.4946284592151642,
-0.38146206736564636,
0.5283742547035217,
0.4703545868396759,
-0.6228541731834412,
0.3585037291049957,
0.057211022824048996,
-0.27409040927886963,
0.49105721712112427,
-0.5040040612220764,
0.3804331421852112,
-0.45493191480636597,
0.22702087461948395,
-1.2209712266921997,
-0.299160897731781,
0.5587670207023621,
-0.17827464640140533,
0.32755276560783386,
-0.32733336091041565,
-0.546155571937561,
-0.2803201675415039,
-0.25165802240371704,
0.3969022035598755,
0.08427099138498306,
-0.5875621438026428,
0.656184732913971,
0.1945275366306305,
-0.29897403717041016,
-0.47578108310699463,
-0.7886424660682678,
0.046943314373493195,
0.1292211264371872,
-0.793606162071228,
0.3111501634120941,
0.18291443586349487,
-0.1683303266763687,
0.2729502320289612,
0.16122396290302277,
0.20539292693138123,
0.1826425939798355,
0.09909752756357193,
0.44970983266830444,
-0.26632359623908997,
0.33098745346069336,
-0.23753106594085693,
-0.07701268792152405,
-0.09510913491249084,
-0.4091354012489319,
0.38615599274635315,
-0.18481366336345673,
-0.5149109363555908,
-0.22538292407989502,
0.2941204607486725,
0.38930344581604004,
-0.33208024501800537,
0.5186744332313538,
0.24812303483486176,
-0.6941450238227844,
-0.39671140909194946,
-0.6651833057403564,
-0.002424814272671938,
-0.4083231985569,
0.6045361757278442,
-0.10667776316404343,
-0.8385599255561829,
0.7868909239768982,
0.3712676167488098,
-0.2890804708003998,
0.4000813066959381,
0.450836181640625,
0.17364713549613953,
0.9190865159034729,
0.704257607460022,
-0.5114979147911072,
0.44440221786499023,
0.16617536544799805,
0.11783500760793686,
-0.5639269948005676,
-0.18020647764205933,
-0.7120522260665894,
-0.2507645785808563,
-0.019042735919356346,
-0.5290488600730896,
0.31994715332984924,
0.25734248757362366,
-0.330607533454895,
0.05497827008366585,
-0.2629331052303314,
0.7120696306228638,
0.5355902314186096,
0.2012075036764145,
0.6576650142669678,
0.1419295221567154,
-0.2553892135620117,
0.06627248227596283,
-0.5550541281700134,
-0.23970448970794678,
0.6680033206939697,
0.23081624507904053,
0.8949161767959595,
0.1010093092918396,
0.41531917452812195,
0.19042585790157318,
0.22259661555290222,
-0.6033061146736145,
0.5245119333267212,
-0.7134599089622498,
-0.24743573367595673,
-0.16641758382320404,
-0.2015811949968338,
-0.5133865475654602,
0.6374552845954895,
0.03473624959588051,
-0.725774347782135,
0.17594783008098602,
0.3934488296508789,
-0.1349194049835205,
0.6937050223350525,
-0.6800143122673035,
1.0945838689804077,
0.030326280742883682,
-0.042362503707408905,
-0.017837679013609886,
-0.3830898702144623,
0.463623046875,
0.1851467788219452,
0.35003215074539185,
0.03901020810008049,
0.2915663421154022,
0.27670586109161377,
-0.14128044247627258,
1.086693286895752,
-0.2960415780544281,
-0.28326931595802307,
0.2899341285228729,
0.12437506020069122,
0.9648057818412781,
-0.27162161469459534,
0.09256080538034439,
-0.121983103454113,
-0.7253914475440979,
-0.1380818635225296,
-0.4286978244781494,
0.3131124973297119,
-0.3669373691082001,
-0.5325137376785278,
-0.3287358582019806,
-0.5177791714668274,
-0.060003090649843216,
0.08076102286577225,
0.33987247943878174,
0.4006534814834595,
-0.30658894777297974,
-0.1586790531873703,
0.45239338278770447,
0.03686957433819771,
0.3537227213382721,
0.6350311636924744,
-0.39525529742240906,
-0.34006404876708984,
0.43074676394462585,
0.003268625820055604,
0.39619502425193787,
0.310543954372406,
-0.08965562283992767,
-0.26112100481987,
-0.619941234588623,
-0.31129565834999084,
0.3543817400932312,
-1.0627198219299316,
-0.08923543244600296,
-0.6339194178581238,
-0.10980426520109177,
-0.4933353364467621,
-0.1294955611228943,
-0.11498560756444931,
0.28667131066322327,
-0.49974706768989563,
-0.1476636677980423,
-0.02629784308373928,
0.7438496351242065,
-0.06517701596021652,
0.2509195804595947,
-0.7974002361297607,
0.22214281558990479,
0.3412652611732483,
0.17577432096004486,
0.0038645993918180466,
-0.68751460313797,
-0.18401306867599487,
0.03868533670902252,
-0.06665009260177612,
-0.5898522734642029,
0.3592023551464081,
0.43889179825782776,
0.45707517862319946,
0.0788339376449585,
-0.44776615500450134,
0.8070350885391235,
-0.5484490394592285,
0.5880739092826843,
0.06440237909555435,
-1.2654420137405396,
0.7239890694618225,
-0.3761686384677887,
0.6599868535995483,
0.11909285187721252,
-0.3611021041870117,
-1.0302284955978394,
-0.6239385604858398,
-0.1568794548511505,
-0.6746393442153931,
0.8475940227508545,
-0.23824691772460938,
-0.007695822976529598,
-0.14113852381706238,
0.4126989245414734,
-0.22506757080554962,
-0.06246544420719147,
-0.812879741191864,
0.04304776340723038,
0.2431344985961914,
-0.249855175614357,
-0.10749618709087372,
-0.5499413013458252,
-0.18422633409500122,
-0.1223638579249382,
0.8255981802940369,
-0.5012525320053101,
0.2544456422328949,
0.29705381393432617,
-0.498359352350235,
-0.30055245757102966,
0.5627404451370239,
0.781116783618927,
0.43678852915763855,
0.09931018948554993,
0.27290812134742737,
0.18071843683719635,
-0.5852724313735962,
0.23168997466564178,
-0.04087882488965988,
-0.5078443884849548,
0.17703354358673096,
0.526466429233551,
0.814551055431366,
0.42550128698349,
-0.16615252196788788,
0.4434877634048462,
0.13696829974651337,
-0.21292710304260254,
0.0567048154771328,
-0.11396030336618423,
0.18046019971370697,
0.27481716871261597,
0.2826186716556549,
0.17470963299274445,
0.0004555700870696455,
-0.5628032088279724,
0.16663303971290588,
0.5120428800582886,
-0.14749488234519958,
-0.41849640011787415,
0.8831878304481506,
0.2728258967399597,
0.14648818969726562,
0.5882368087768555,
-0.5173336863517761,
-0.9611064791679382,
0.7431496381759644,
0.7767070531845093,
1.119179368019104,
-0.48273688554763794,
0.477832555770874,
0.373344361782074,
0.4968090355396271,
-0.4837244153022766,
0.32442253828048706,
0.5061283707618713,
-0.8782134056091309,
-0.7078908085823059,
-0.2940819263458252,
-0.09828642755746841,
0.19426073133945465,
-0.4876141846179962,
0.3311605453491211,
-0.3970654606819153,
0.08113768696784973,
-0.2932657301425934,
-0.5239989757537842,
-0.3272632956504822,
0.18613004684448242,
0.3664990961551666,
0.46229252219200134,
-0.9596704244613647,
0.9548527002334595,
0.7590384483337402,
0.0856972187757492,
-0.8181811571121216,
-0.08474533259868622,
0.49852117896080017,
-0.7094736099243164,
0.6311503052711487,
0.22125668823719025,
-0.31700000166893005,
-0.25664398074150085,
-0.31107082962989807,
-0.5968563556671143,
0.8135374784469604,
0.7174969911575317,
-0.7865026593208313,
-0.21768051385879517,
0.020627500489354134,
0.3960786759853363,
-0.34435176849365234,
-0.17896850407123566,
0.5140982866287231,
0.17556999623775482,
-0.14554664492607117,
-1.0128265619277954,
0.017109334468841553,
-0.19980530440807343,
0.14248961210250854,
0.46393799781799316,
-0.31667864322662354,
1.367065668106079,
-0.12164459377527237,
-0.6008289456367493,
0.007443571463227272,
0.3098794221878052,
-0.14736789464950562,
0.013781465590000153,
0.5003136396408081,
0.8377794623374939,
0.9066183567047119,
-0.38607656955718994,
0.684790313243866,
0.20250967144966125,
0.7554381489753723,
1.2402536869049072,
-0.3398905098438263,
0.6300978660583496,
0.02875681407749653,
-0.3131307065486908,
0.5176082849502563,
0.3345284163951874,
-0.05963979661464691,
0.4838707149028778,
0.032580334693193436,
-0.5362939834594727,
-0.35711267590522766,
0.12862081825733185,
-0.2908916771411896,
0.28153979778289795,
0.28453171253204346,
-0.3196518123149872,
-0.5598955154418945,
0.09272373467683792,
0.15096625685691833,
0.24104659259319305,
-0.8791874051094055,
0.6866776347160339,
-0.25226256251335144,
-0.5489998459815979,
0.5401175618171692,
0.30147743225097656,
0.8307249546051025,
-0.4944273829460144,
-0.026108544319868088,
-0.4896261394023895,
0.7429956197738647,
-0.36622703075408936,
-0.49181148409843445,
0.26050809025764465,
0.17233045399188995,
-0.4474695324897766,
0.16665177047252655,
1.2662651538848877,
-1.0009651184082031,
-0.5256861448287964,
0.5073032975196838,
0.2565186321735382,
-0.27003294229507446,
-0.4512307047843933,
-0.3479593098163605,
0.1865396648645401,
-0.04428496211767197,
0.25297823548316956,
0.16593724489212036,
0.23419217765331268,
-0.17000256478786469,
0.4796060025691986,
0.42450442910194397,
0.029485618695616722,
0.2765796482563019,
0.3258282542228699,
0.6765322685241699,
-0.5612666606903076,
-0.8439914584159851,
-1.0577707290649414,
0.7427393794059753,
0.20982645452022552,
-0.004691267851740122,
0.5862128138542175,
0.30079442262649536,
1.1296634674072266,
-0.3818380832672119,
0.7976765632629395,
0.311755508184433,
0.28134188055992126,
-0.8374401330947876,
0.4442256689071655,
-0.3620646595954895,
0.1606438159942627,
-0.3610347509384155,
-0.8662642240524292,
-0.8870033025741577,
0.5103546977043152,
-0.0906369611620903,
-0.11502376198768616,
0.7294469475746155,
1.0010887384414673,
0.1612698882818222,
-0.005477351602166891,
0.3466842472553253,
0.25914260745048523,
0.313546746969223,
0.8397501707077026,
0.5714672803878784,
-0.4122627079486847,
0.31394973397254944,
-0.05724931135773659,
-0.1851203888654709,
-0.473688542842865,
-0.6580831408500671,
-0.8102402091026306,
-0.28099697828292847,
-0.4401305615901947,
-0.3480340242385864,
0.43936628103256226,
0.5655974745750427,
0.3113223612308502,
-1.0380030870437622,
-0.08765241503715515,
-0.24618902802467346,
0.12556229531764984,
-0.4638066589832306,
-0.2006264477968216,
0.4504375755786896,
-0.6509824395179749,
-0.9222135543823242,
0.49159449338912964,
0.5689401030540466,
0.08907146006822586,
0.05221344903111458,
0.10217920690774918,
-0.3212122321128845,
-0.32920196652412415,
0.7244399189949036,
0.2677048444747925,
-0.9203300476074219,
-0.5725476741790771,
0.049062687903642654,
-0.4567440152168274,
0.04331023618578911,
0.8879796266555786,
-0.43337100744247437,
0.6556703448295593,
0.4671202301979065,
0.6703201532363892,
0.012354457750916481,
0.011488283053040504,
0.4303165078163147,
-1.0520570278167725,
0.3041173219680786,
0.033754099160432816,
0.6733508706092834,
0.3784506022930145,
-0.40723535418510437,
0.6726486086845398,
0.6774562001228333,
-0.5485799312591553,
-0.7105260491371155,
0.143941268324852,
-0.6213983297348022,
-0.3515021800994873,
1.141553521156311,
-0.3281829357147217,
-0.10111115872859955,
-0.21594910323619843,
-0.38096195459365845,
0.2181425243616104,
-0.03126997500658035,
0.544903576374054,
1.1238371133804321,
0.2835930585861206,
-0.0029142117127776146,
-0.3027505874633789,
0.3948815166950226,
0.5308259129524231,
-0.9196777939796448,
0.21887074410915375,
0.7152737379074097,
0.4230632483959198,
0.07365013659000397,
0.6804090142250061,
-0.3034769892692566,
0.4898654818534851,
-0.12530331313610077,
0.16161738336086273,
0.0029880721122026443,
-0.5363004207611084,
-0.7884515523910522,
0.05633958429098129,
-0.07451045513153076,
-0.5701416730880737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17799v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17799v1
|
Exploring Activation Patterns of Parameters in Language Models
| 2024-05-28T03:49:54 | 2024-05-28T03:49:54 |
Yudong Wang, Damai Dai, Zhifang Sui
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Most work treats large language models as black boxes without in-depth
understanding of their internal working mechanism. In order to explain the
internal representations of LLMs, we propose a gradient-based metric to assess
the activation level of model parameters. Based on this metric, we obtain three
preliminary findings. (1) When the inputs are in the same domain, parameters in
the shallow layers will be activated densely, which means a larger portion of
parameters will have great impacts on the outputs. In contrast, parameters in
the deep layers are activated sparsely. (2) When the inputs are across
different domains, parameters in shallow layers exhibit higher similarity in
the activation behavior than deep layers. (3) In deep layers, the similarity of
the distributions of activated parameters is positively correlated to the
empirical data relevance. Further, we develop three validation experiments to
solidify these findings. (1) Firstly, starting from the first finding, we
attempt to configure different prune ratios for different layers, and find this
method can benefit model pruning. (2) Secondly, we find that a pruned model
based on one calibration set can better handle tasks related to the calibration
task than those not related, which validate the second finding. (3) Thirdly,
Based on the STS-B and SICK benchmark, we find that two sentences with
consistent semantics tend to share similar parameter activation patterns in
deep layers, which aligns with our third finding. Our work sheds light on the
behavior of parameter activation in LLMs, and we hope these findings will have
the potential to inspire more practical applications.
|
[
-0.0938766747713089,
-0.875661313533783,
0.7545840740203857,
0.253307968378067,
-0.43976324796676636,
-0.20668381452560425,
-0.30148977041244507,
-0.3141169846057892,
-0.038195665925741196,
0.3340182602405548,
-0.31948351860046387,
-0.42975473403930664,
-0.5796828269958496,
-0.020698942244052887,
-0.6065519452095032,
0.7297940254211426,
-0.19855627417564392,
0.2826088070869446,
-0.23537029325962067,
-0.05415290594100952,
-0.2815687358379364,
-0.5228612422943115,
-0.844538152217865,
-0.480132520198822,
0.6463420391082764,
0.07034380733966827,
0.5445094108581543,
0.6869642734527588,
0.3572676479816437,
0.33232003450393677,
-0.27053606510162354,
0.010119464248418808,
-0.5904485583305359,
0.3452708125114441,
0.23954853415489197,
-0.43446892499923706,
-0.19074270129203796,
0.11940790712833405,
0.9127905368804932,
1.112379550933838,
-0.15707941353321075,
0.2666294276714325,
0.5309509634971619,
0.440854012966156,
-0.5635209679603577,
0.08450213819742203,
-0.6510578989982605,
-0.11436387896537781,
-0.09190303832292557,
-0.33848828077316284,
-0.3258209824562073,
-0.16202570497989655,
-0.11054983735084534,
-0.12223939597606659,
0.1926647275686264,
-0.18693660199642181,
0.9467495679855347,
0.18961484730243683,
-0.5393409132957458,
-0.15155698359012604,
-0.769923746585846,
0.9671692848205566,
-0.871770441532135,
0.43963971734046936,
0.30757075548171997,
-0.05294777452945709,
-0.22924698889255524,
-0.6280816197395325,
-0.17379723489284515,
-0.6617707014083862,
-0.37415122985839844,
-0.05770989507436752,
-0.09840091317892075,
0.08985703438520432,
0.5273817181587219,
0.37701231241226196,
-0.3990384042263031,
0.41452980041503906,
-0.4025420546531677,
-0.22261299192905426,
0.5293987989425659,
0.23297317326068878,
0.34008440375328064,
0.08721400052309036,
-0.4507574141025543,
0.16556189954280853,
-0.7933517694473267,
0.2852138578891754,
0.5542852878570557,
0.32693183422088623,
-0.17648983001708984,
0.6318327784538269,
-0.08761328458786011,
0.7683382034301758,
0.06881766766309738,
0.0432874895632267,
0.198052316904068,
-0.3488389849662781,
-0.45482727885246277,
-0.13356103003025055,
0.7640702724456787,
0.23209303617477417,
0.28769823908805847,
-0.2908817231655121,
-0.4712914228439331,
-0.051035139709711075,
0.20057180523872375,
-0.8681195378303528,
0.21356137096881866,
0.18672864139080048,
-0.4230285882949829,
-0.24166667461395264,
0.015876827761530876,
-0.3821852505207062,
-0.33595746755599976,
-0.3744606077671051,
0.3839198648929596,
-0.2726321518421173,
-0.383366197347641,
0.34474292397499084,
-0.055231973528862,
0.43085914850234985,
0.16038694977760315,
-0.7558923363685608,
0.47440260648727417,
0.768032968044281,
0.6433680653572083,
-0.17085091769695282,
-0.38685789704322815,
-0.4183483123779297,
0.027639098465442657,
-0.4537202715873718,
0.41795432567596436,
-0.7144613862037659,
-0.09055933356285095,
0.19672517478466034,
0.04534046724438667,
-0.1669803112745285,
-0.638448178768158,
0.5033822655677795,
-0.6402891278266907,
0.0484573058784008,
-0.2537131905555725,
-0.5128319263458252,
-0.3176213800907135,
0.27389755845069885,
-0.7128647565841675,
1.384070873260498,
0.03441110998392105,
-0.45475804805755615,
0.45302289724349976,
-0.3070775866508484,
-0.2771608829498291,
0.03831624612212181,
-0.25576773285865784,
-0.3539403975009918,
0.4517677426338196,
-0.07409609109163284,
0.6896530389785767,
-0.5154229402542114,
0.27374541759490967,
-0.23086808621883392,
-0.3474630117416382,
0.6091593503952026,
-0.4359165132045746,
0.8112110495567322,
-0.18692998588085175,
-0.24486692249774933,
0.09146326035261154,
-0.7336131930351257,
0.049702923744916916,
0.15229226648807526,
-0.4233473837375641,
-0.3627564013004303,
0.049824029207229614,
-0.2704433798789978,
0.17385871708393097,
0.17877648770809174,
-0.425136536359787,
0.07713815569877625,
-0.507387101650238,
0.5366020202636719,
0.5503771901130676,
0.5997264385223389,
0.5654641389846802,
-0.248464897274971,
0.6635105609893799,
0.42918840050697327,
-0.09399386495351791,
-0.119407057762146,
-0.43489915132522583,
-0.7251530885696411,
-0.3281936049461365,
0.1922837644815445,
0.08696407079696655,
0.01444314606487751,
0.4167703092098236,
-0.16415594518184662,
-0.4056040942668915,
-0.5334599018096924,
0.43849602341651917,
0.4222671687602997,
0.44165024161338806,
0.17684680223464966,
-0.48714619874954224,
-0.2486666440963745,
-1.124183177947998,
-0.303266316652298,
-0.04261856526136398,
-0.1066434383392334,
0.315147340297699,
0.3681833744049072,
0.013424376957118511,
0.7615589499473572,
-0.16246430575847626,
-0.09989875555038452,
-0.2725895941257477,
0.21270699799060822,
0.3989989161491394,
0.4078391194343567,
0.5849113464355469,
-0.5974732637405396,
-0.38676077127456665,
-0.041922494769096375,
-0.41132211685180664,
-0.23786921799182892,
-0.15342660248279572,
-0.050722166895866394,
-0.292489618062973,
0.7115739583969116,
-0.5851286053657532,
0.29816344380378723,
0.5309928059577942,
-0.035812053829431534,
0.35490596294403076,
-0.07775718718767166,
0.012170697562396526,
-0.6900375485420227,
0.07451283931732178,
0.3866574466228485,
-0.05572948232293129,
-1.1096584796905518,
0.11188236624002457,
0.09139296412467957,
0.056189559400081635,
-0.538398802280426,
0.6785687208175659,
-0.6445164680480957,
-0.15152385830879211,
-0.11572188138961792,
0.039900533854961395,
0.01366059947758913,
0.7141223549842834,
-0.2133641093969345,
0.6813648343086243,
0.6401064991950989,
-0.829454779624939,
0.23125842213630676,
-0.365792453289032,
-0.5993747115135193,
0.0748053565621376,
-0.8448516726493835,
0.11043594032526016,
-0.2535960376262665,
-0.026944836601614952,
-1.3206676244735718,
0.059325382113456726,
0.28332263231277466,
-0.2865637242794037,
0.21076874434947968,
-0.3717285990715027,
-0.70263671875,
0.05359959229826927,
-0.2972910404205322,
0.5961076021194458,
0.5915415287017822,
-0.09986773878335953,
0.5378934741020203,
0.2213781625032425,
0.03025408461689949,
-0.3523300886154175,
-0.6386950612068176,
-0.19456538558006287,
-0.49783554673194885,
-0.46399345993995667,
0.3914451003074646,
-0.02095167338848114,
-0.421564519405365,
-0.07085950672626495,
-0.14480790495872498,
0.0030467903707176447,
0.4114871025085449,
0.5328719019889832,
-0.061494797468185425,
-0.5476452708244324,
-0.21615631878376007,
0.08520133793354034,
-0.06853187084197998,
0.35499829053878784,
-0.10094289481639862,
0.738365650177002,
0.17171235382556915,
-0.5690760612487793,
-0.5824029445648193,
0.2088683843612671,
0.5576255917549133,
-0.42353519797325134,
0.7151280641555786,
0.45600882172584534,
-0.3334251046180725,
-0.30942460894584656,
-0.5008368492126465,
-0.2979786992073059,
-0.5070093870162964,
0.351293683052063,
-0.46946007013320923,
-0.6133331656455994,
0.8955865502357483,
-0.1954578310251236,
0.06347310543060303,
0.30303892493247986,
0.8259426951408386,
-0.04774954542517662,
1.1404534578323364,
0.38643312454223633,
0.09774743765592575,
0.7108926177024841,
-0.3976655602455139,
0.10170866549015045,
-1.1235806941986084,
-0.05012963339686394,
-0.6127948760986328,
-0.5648759603500366,
-0.3253847658634186,
-0.47670263051986694,
0.19501692056655884,
0.4988982677459717,
-0.3057173490524292,
0.09089866280555725,
-0.25939762592315674,
0.3426695764064789,
0.3127078115940094,
0.22416773438453674,
-0.052976563572883606,
0.16401752829551697,
-0.25570619106292725,
-0.12257618457078934,
-0.47732648253440857,
-0.5108145475387573,
0.8345847725868225,
0.5832971930503845,
0.6537612676620483,
0.032156869769096375,
0.6285771727561951,
0.08374913781881332,
0.36722442507743835,
-0.8214121460914612,
0.7375573515892029,
-0.08220810443162918,
-0.536402702331543,
-0.28705930709838867,
-0.15779909491539001,
-1.1293387413024902,
0.26232072710990906,
0.08853786438703537,
-0.7885275483131409,
0.308721661567688,
0.08859148621559143,
-0.09030698984861374,
-0.06290643662214279,
-0.7783700227737427,
0.669853925704956,
-0.35921770334243774,
-0.5124480724334717,
-0.2554266154766083,
-0.25715431571006775,
0.19924309849739075,
0.018199792131781578,
0.05973105505108833,
-0.30282333493232727,
-0.3013949692249298,
0.6821449995040894,
0.02668130397796631,
1.3023747205734253,
-0.22523808479309082,
-0.39816758036613464,
0.18586914241313934,
0.31678757071495056,
0.620893657207489,
-0.16051830351352692,
-0.5097442269325256,
0.2114352434873581,
-0.4546413719654083,
-0.35764870047569275,
-0.7691921591758728,
0.7269571423530579,
-0.688091516494751,
-0.7975369095802307,
-0.018165571615099907,
-0.3777730464935303,
-0.32957571744918823,
0.1848606914281845,
-0.25721216201782227,
0.5604593753814697,
-0.019610658288002014,
0.419956237077713,
0.4376736581325531,
0.029513781890273094,
0.27826306223869324,
0.5877500772476196,
-0.14541038870811462,
-0.0018087946809828281,
0.6601211428642273,
0.046692632138729095,
0.6471431255340576,
0.38774994015693665,
0.14440304040908813,
0.03342988342046738,
-1.0359588861465454,
-0.3065463900566101,
0.4332791268825531,
-0.8766666054725647,
-0.014099440537393093,
-0.4915418326854706,
-0.5412058234214783,
-0.1270669549703598,
0.03353862464427948,
0.022444836795330048,
-0.19346435368061066,
-0.5450103282928467,
-0.32656532526016235,
0.08024480938911438,
0.6022732853889465,
0.32716619968414307,
0.4243740141391754,
-0.564369261264801,
0.14838907122612,
0.17044340074062347,
0.31268972158432007,
0.2120540887117386,
-0.782343864440918,
-0.3620893061161041,
0.11624845862388611,
-0.008198809809982777,
-1.1133567094802856,
0.2828298807144165,
0.1897081732749939,
1.0313678979873657,
0.5149036645889282,
-0.3543947637081146,
0.6823880672454834,
-0.5753024220466614,
0.9927093982696533,
-0.07032115757465363,
-0.7988337874412537,
0.2551864683628082,
-0.2359093278646469,
0.09546533226966858,
0.3655467927455902,
0.487275630235672,
-0.3930197060108185,
-0.837601900100708,
-0.5455113649368286,
-0.8316396474838257,
0.5661236047744751,
-0.09365639835596085,
0.7529417872428894,
0.20728230476379395,
0.6821551322937012,
0.16252481937408447,
0.16034892201423645,
-0.9472584128379822,
-0.3863905966281891,
0.23225605487823486,
-0.05839147791266441,
-0.01562965102493763,
-0.6765732169151306,
-0.31089240312576294,
-0.16056828200817108,
0.3506060242652893,
-0.028016753494739532,
0.20984341204166412,
-0.17679253220558167,
-0.2995912730693817,
-0.2938981056213379,
0.16411128640174866,
0.6272822618484497,
0.8222841620445251,
-0.1505378931760788,
0.19838666915893555,
0.1072079986333847,
-0.28465786576271057,
0.07164957374334335,
-0.19955269992351532,
-0.17131875455379486,
0.0037418536376208067,
0.6933467388153076,
0.9150913953781128,
0.5264081358909607,
-0.2290395200252533,
0.35971781611442566,
0.1283804327249527,
-0.25832074880599976,
-0.009484191425144672,
0.4607189893722534,
-0.05109097808599472,
0.06094120070338249,
0.3297359347343445,
-0.13950733840465546,
-0.09588983654975891,
-0.5006895661354065,
0.04294306039810181,
0.7852606177330017,
-0.5431983470916748,
-0.5144433379173279,
0.4363676905632019,
0.229451522231102,
-0.40701061487197876,
0.44244498014450073,
-0.11210327595472336,
-0.5533448457717896,
0.6866255402565002,
0.6007762551307678,
0.9408828020095825,
-0.06819882243871689,
0.0922970324754715,
0.4913087487220764,
0.4973762333393097,
0.07702945172786713,
0.2858580946922302,
-0.15519554913043976,
-0.9396817088127136,
-0.6179475784301758,
-0.6973699927330017,
0.06941581517457962,
0.44635704159736633,
-0.7255713939666748,
0.3406309485435486,
-0.42961859703063965,
-0.0039825597777962685,
0.12188971042633057,
-0.04054548218846321,
-0.6813201308250427,
0.1637275218963623,
0.11995260417461395,
0.8227706551551819,
-1.1801130771636963,
0.9042423367500305,
0.7275208830833435,
-0.4323725998401642,
-0.7535404562950134,
0.13787919282913208,
-0.07425753027200699,
-1.1367608308792114,
1.0092684030532837,
0.07152605801820755,
-0.10209868103265762,
0.10873743146657944,
-0.5193043351173401,
-1.0195802450180054,
1.026257038116455,
0.40377551317214966,
-0.39999160170555115,
-0.003147686365991831,
0.297985702753067,
0.7318349480628967,
-0.5449199080467224,
0.24968482553958893,
0.4432295262813568,
0.5550026893615723,
-0.04055221751332283,
-0.7179692387580872,
0.31159090995788574,
-0.1794273406267166,
0.13264763355255127,
0.3058359622955322,
-0.34083110094070435,
0.8414485454559326,
0.05701394006609917,
-0.5193652510643005,
-0.03530063107609749,
0.5550611019134521,
0.07288718223571777,
-0.024621734395623207,
0.6467829942703247,
0.33461853861808777,
0.41870003938674927,
0.08767838031053543,
1.0920804738998413,
-0.6183679103851318,
0.1417553722858429,
0.7678709030151367,
-0.3030567467212677,
0.7375714778900146,
0.6130185723304749,
-0.15970861911773682,
0.5712754130363464,
0.6388956904411316,
0.05206137150526047,
0.34238916635513306,
0.29290708899497986,
-0.1828574389219284,
-0.2701925039291382,
-0.15751776099205017,
-0.23385170102119446,
0.09523928165435791,
0.6700180768966675,
-0.6209172606468201,
-0.17428219318389893,
-0.18801374733448029,
-0.03902559354901314,
-0.16499637067317963,
-0.18879729509353638,
0.8684481978416443,
0.2338055819272995,
-0.7280581593513489,
0.5575870275497437,
0.1771121472120285,
0.27689364552497864,
-0.7760791182518005,
0.09394081681966782,
-0.2694852948188782,
-0.040825020521879196,
-0.15315578877925873,
-0.8436670303344727,
-0.1305544674396515,
-0.1530153602361679,
-0.18669797480106354,
-0.6084586977958679,
0.7021200060844421,
-0.5152775645256042,
-0.45415985584259033,
0.4936031401157379,
0.5018483400344849,
0.03909805789589882,
0.13313451409339905,
-0.8567996621131897,
0.31197357177734375,
-0.0010526487603783607,
-0.5399133563041687,
0.4007743299007416,
0.5900595784187317,
0.055993422865867615,
0.49910616874694824,
0.7999051213264465,
0.5082520842552185,
0.34300413727760315,
0.4643344581127167,
0.8772128224372864,
-0.5941705703735352,
-0.17556335031986237,
-0.9521161913871765,
0.7207143902778625,
-0.021632224321365356,
-0.31062203645706177,
0.87312912940979,
0.48345747590065,
0.674203634262085,
0.2061345875263214,
0.3189239501953125,
0.2988988161087036,
0.2932206690311432,
-0.7302713990211487,
0.23547659814357758,
-0.758039653301239,
0.6191526055335999,
0.10831771045923233,
-1.1025831699371338,
-0.3751097023487091,
0.3011017143726349,
-0.4800240993499756,
0.31210923194885254,
0.6745967864990234,
1.1568331718444824,
-0.2077905386686325,
-0.4247245192527771,
0.28170275688171387,
0.44114917516708374,
0.2945123314857483,
0.20208868384361267,
1.088191270828247,
-0.16277389228343964,
0.2740192115306854,
-0.21597787737846375,
-0.09702980518341064,
-0.39974579215049744,
-0.8658872842788696,
-0.8664555549621582,
-0.7221863269805908,
-0.47576114535331726,
-0.406594455242157,
-0.1803930401802063,
0.6257752180099487,
0.7627353072166443,
-0.6622142791748047,
-0.45435822010040283,
0.06988045573234558,
0.05764121189713478,
-0.487807035446167,
-0.21969716250896454,
0.22260682284832,
-0.45662766695022583,
-0.67881178855896,
0.39617258310317993,
0.39840826392173767,
-0.010545846074819565,
-0.6814185380935669,
0.025405410677194595,
-0.14269639551639557,
0.1330556869506836,
0.39004620909690857,
0.10926178097724915,
-0.807125985622406,
-0.1555386334657669,
-0.18721574544906616,
-0.4311491847038269,
0.08610440045595169,
1.276655912399292,
-0.6485645174980164,
0.09359749406576157,
0.5854768753051758,
0.5624127984046936,
0.3791496157646179,
-0.02170434780418873,
0.6631646156311035,
-1.0481905937194824,
0.24217231571674347,
0.24163316190242767,
0.46137964725494385,
0.12675638496875763,
-0.1283228099346161,
0.224899560213089,
-0.20137031376361847,
-0.3871539831161499,
-1.208290934562683,
0.3498862683773041,
-0.8632364869117737,
-0.07417263090610504,
1.5660898685455322,
0.09983284026384354,
-0.24415458738803864,
0.08347461372613907,
-0.04395325109362602,
-0.14432621002197266,
-0.1727287471294403,
0.4927442967891693,
0.8226441740989685,
-0.08348286896944046,
-0.23107057809829712,
-0.7345753312110901,
0.5790725946426392,
0.6449459195137024,
-0.35442495346069336,
0.22148102521896362,
0.2999669909477234,
0.21942248940467834,
0.11232933402061462,
0.4597545862197876,
-0.04361732676625252,
0.08012095093727112,
-0.3382444679737091,
-0.3777053952217102,
-0.015748251229524612,
-0.007997915148735046,
-0.6227571368217468,
0.27180153131484985,
0.32088908553123474,
-0.12627160549163818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17767v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17767v1
|
Linguistic Collapse: Neural Collapse in (Large) Language Models
| 2024-05-28T02:46:11 | 2024-05-28T02:46:11 |
Robert Wu, Vardan Papyan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML, 68T07 (Primary) 68T50 (Secondary), I.2.6; I.2.7
|
Neural collapse ($\mathcal{NC}$) is a phenomenon observed in classification
tasks where top-layer representations collapse into their class means, which
become equinorm, equiangular and aligned with the classifiers. These behaviors
-- associated with generalization and robustness -- would manifest under
specific conditions: models are trained towards zero loss, with noise-free
labels belonging to balanced classes, which do not outnumber the model's hidden
dimension. Recent studies have explored $\mathcal{NC}$ in the absence of one or
more of these conditions to extend and capitalize on the associated benefits of
ideal geometries. Language modeling presents a curious frontier, as
\textit{training by token prediction} constitutes a classification task where
none of the conditions exist: the vocabulary is imbalanced and exceeds the
embedding dimension; different tokens might correspond to similar contextual
embeddings; and large language models (LLMs) in particular are typically only
trained for a few epochs. This paper empirically investigates the impact of
scaling the architectures and training of causal language models (CLMs) on
their progression towards $\mathcal{NC}$. We find that $\mathcal{NC}$
properties that develop with scaling are linked to generalization. Moreover,
there is evidence of some relationship between $\mathcal{NC}$ and
generalization independent of scale. Our work therefore underscores the
generality of $\mathcal{NC}$ as it extends to the novel and more challenging
setting of language modeling. Downstream, we seek to inspire further research
on the phenomenon to deepen our understanding of LLMs -- and neural networks at
large -- and improve existing architectures based on $\mathcal{NC}$-related
properties.
|
[
-0.4254377782344818,
-0.7381522059440613,
0.28111961483955383,
-0.02297542244195938,
0.06635010987520218,
0.03299475088715553,
-0.7115944027900696,
-0.27022966742515564,
0.1545976996421814,
0.45096659660339355,
-0.22184491157531738,
-0.4335509240627289,
-0.7993848323822021,
-0.03278888389468193,
-0.7150492668151855,
0.9846539497375488,
0.3052654266357422,
0.02210158295929432,
-0.2372467964887619,
-0.16512703895568848,
-0.6366507411003113,
-0.8085107803344727,
-0.9185607433319092,
-0.5130264163017273,
0.5571293234825134,
0.07517581433057785,
0.7876956462860107,
0.8133442997932434,
0.2515923082828522,
0.41228410601615906,
-0.4783581793308258,
-0.4187496602535248,
-0.6386428475379944,
0.25126466155052185,
0.0828598141670227,
-0.9790382385253906,
-0.35839906334877014,
0.01777435839176178,
0.852179765701294,
1.2978252172470093,
-0.24365286529064178,
-0.166007861495018,
0.23066161572933197,
0.6744691729545593,
-0.5031422972679138,
0.2535187304019928,
-0.6648497581481934,
0.005334711167961359,
0.05357499048113823,
-0.18421213328838348,
-0.4956612288951874,
-0.1632360965013504,
0.2268691211938858,
-0.3658617436885834,
0.23196901381015778,
-0.004632835742086172,
0.8809552788734436,
0.1298743486404419,
-0.48998674750328064,
-0.15942999720573425,
-0.8723735213279724,
0.7995465397834778,
-0.6390839219093323,
0.41511407494544983,
0.28240272402763367,
0.41349342465400696,
-0.1004209890961647,
-0.5175109505653381,
-0.3042128086090088,
-0.5135498046875,
0.019573641940951347,
-0.2179524451494217,
-0.29445186257362366,
0.2525065243244171,
0.2738088071346283,
0.6403111815452576,
-0.38688597083091736,
0.6064996719360352,
-0.5200452208518982,
-0.23810942471027374,
0.13031406700611115,
0.2785666882991791,
0.787922203540802,
0.031111299991607666,
-0.13434797525405884,
-0.006459847092628479,
-1.0284194946289062,
-0.20244741439819336,
0.40954580903053284,
0.6828291416168213,
-0.30385568737983704,
0.3201431632041931,
-0.03209604695439339,
0.8202511668205261,
-0.08649778366088867,
-0.02665553241968155,
-0.07974884659051895,
-0.41815948486328125,
-0.19995196163654327,
0.010528472252190113,
0.7398884296417236,
0.16400861740112305,
0.38555288314819336,
-0.33268535137176514,
0.0331621952354908,
0.08565148711204529,
0.1307234764099121,
-0.5492669939994812,
-0.0128764808177948,
0.004585564136505127,
-0.5080662369728088,
-0.35493603348731995,
-0.34104833006858826,
-0.3388011157512665,
-0.2773491442203522,
-0.6473645567893982,
0.07296627014875412,
-0.3555213510990143,
-0.6847583651542664,
0.08626564592123032,
0.12608563899993896,
0.25363078713417053,
0.21820645034313202,
-1.1172202825546265,
0.48205018043518066,
0.7132654190063477,
1.071200966835022,
-0.08650359511375427,
-0.36827608942985535,
-0.05276709794998169,
-0.3791130483150482,
-0.4385770261287689,
0.6003589034080505,
-0.23901040852069855,
-0.09588247537612915,
0.19760556519031525,
-0.051839251071214676,
-0.20641863346099854,
-0.5499403476715088,
0.35578975081443787,
-0.5177587270736694,
-0.02248115837574005,
-0.233957901597023,
-0.37774857878685,
-0.27888980507850647,
0.4737647473812103,
-0.7753871083259583,
0.5275530219078064,
-0.18472564220428467,
-0.7103961110115051,
0.3732791244983673,
-0.23807267844676971,
-0.011078541167080402,
-0.08928746730089188,
-0.2602306604385376,
-0.15321069955825806,
0.4090753495693207,
-0.24951982498168945,
0.37424078583717346,
-0.7571662068367004,
0.3971376121044159,
-0.46931466460227966,
-0.21080215275287628,
0.16114012897014618,
-0.47391071915626526,
0.9450247883796692,
-0.13208113610744476,
-0.29927143454551697,
-0.02602411061525345,
-0.7235541343688965,
0.12869484722614288,
0.09451331943273544,
-0.3910090923309326,
-0.5166552662849426,
0.11814673990011215,
-0.08542344719171524,
0.4285116195678711,
-0.000680516182910651,
-0.2524406313896179,
0.14743588864803314,
-0.7007644176483154,
0.673388659954071,
0.5794298648834229,
-0.13702644407749176,
0.6851661205291748,
-0.19471198320388794,
0.5229496359825134,
0.033124469220638275,
-0.007627159357070923,
0.03159264847636223,
-0.1821558028459549,
-1.0557717084884644,
0.05330952629446983,
0.5086318254470825,
0.26616212725639343,
-0.6148746609687805,
0.242253839969635,
-0.5616612434387207,
-0.35150012373924255,
-0.004496477544307709,
-0.090232253074646,
0.4695686399936676,
0.22022444009780884,
0.14948749542236328,
-0.1864122599363327,
-0.47071266174316406,
-1.056182861328125,
-0.10243722051382065,
-0.20392893254756927,
-0.024051370099186897,
-0.08208075165748596,
0.3740471601486206,
-0.043327365070581436,
0.6862260699272156,
-0.26921671628952026,
-0.30117353796958923,
-0.5381230115890503,
0.13731810450553894,
0.2444756031036377,
0.3465721607208252,
0.5713628530502319,
-0.716227114200592,
-0.07725512981414795,
0.15187124907970428,
-0.6544918417930603,
-0.012257316149771214,
-0.173406720161438,
0.26803848147392273,
0.29743653535842896,
0.813092052936554,
-0.2767949104309082,
0.5383561253547668,
0.7722187042236328,
-0.31364551186561584,
0.8598878383636475,
-0.1352098435163498,
-0.1786903738975525,
-1.0006380081176758,
-0.03863690793514252,
-0.24793003499507904,
0.2554675340652466,
-0.9555986523628235,
-0.006747534032911062,
-0.277406245470047,
0.08189182728528976,
-0.4961550533771515,
0.3062887191772461,
-0.7579060196876526,
-0.2652500569820404,
-0.48342958092689514,
0.3605884313583374,
-0.3344910442829132,
0.5361536145210266,
-0.17112195491790771,
0.2889449894428253,
0.7337753772735596,
-0.8675355911254883,
-0.06436935812234879,
0.019090548157691956,
-0.06718049198389053,
0.42574262619018555,
-0.7524315714836121,
-0.1244359239935875,
-0.0450638122856617,
0.09835612773895264,
-0.8933578133583069,
-0.05415940657258034,
-0.3339677155017853,
-0.5289285182952881,
0.5881809592247009,
-0.17705495655536652,
-0.5977262854576111,
-0.17149077355861664,
-0.04958970472216606,
0.6571836471557617,
0.09234348684549332,
-0.3919006288051605,
0.4016018807888031,
0.29847535490989685,
0.13832275569438934,
-0.47711727023124695,
-1.1314789056777954,
0.3599955141544342,
-0.13033390045166016,
-0.603659451007843,
-0.01737247221171856,
-0.0447259247303009,
-0.49416694045066833,
-0.013706852681934834,
0.12761057913303375,
-0.2187449187040329,
0.24625255167484283,
0.3628847897052765,
0.28079113364219666,
-0.5274931788444519,
0.21887357532978058,
0.11048949509859085,
-0.04709123075008392,
0.1991644948720932,
-0.32388898730278015,
0.9001553654670715,
-0.5946269035339355,
-0.20868372917175293,
-0.2873029410839081,
0.2042357325553894,
0.8568690419197083,
-0.06425002217292786,
1.1841150522232056,
0.2311403602361679,
-0.4240877628326416,
-0.14697837829589844,
-0.41160714626312256,
-0.2283594161272049,
-0.4489676058292389,
0.5332644581794739,
-0.15926145017147064,
-1.3147268295288086,
0.8664722442626953,
-0.01976548135280609,
-0.0752243921160698,
0.6774021983146667,
0.6682863235473633,
0.49307894706726074,
0.8494641780853271,
0.9462595582008362,
0.08625928312540054,
0.4134559631347656,
-0.47714319825172424,
0.297509104013443,
-1.0708121061325073,
-0.13716675341129303,
-0.6386372447013855,
-0.4057721793651581,
-0.8316500186920166,
-0.19723694026470184,
0.149597629904747,
0.20082901418209076,
-0.31927016377449036,
0.43511950969696045,
-0.4624999761581421,
0.5417097210884094,
0.2327808141708374,
-0.14520157873630524,
0.22238017618656158,
-0.08566135913133621,
-0.3865370452404022,
-0.1793837696313858,
-0.875877320766449,
-0.14913290739059448,
1.1027907133102417,
0.38189697265625,
0.5007375478744507,
0.2059868723154068,
0.4903303384780884,
-0.11101096868515015,
0.31814393401145935,
-1.034775972366333,
0.5544182062149048,
-0.22531180083751678,
-0.539966881275177,
-0.3344357907772064,
-0.6109428405761719,
-1.118225336074829,
0.3301434814929962,
-0.24341928958892822,
-0.816988468170166,
0.6049244999885559,
-0.012192029505968094,
-0.17142407596111298,
0.5080132484436035,
-0.4438077509403229,
0.479310542345047,
-0.1317916363477707,
-0.05688684061169624,
-0.20990557968616486,
-0.6254850029945374,
0.7598083019256592,
-0.004189880099147558,
0.32977810502052307,
-0.02202170342206955,
-0.09448667615652084,
0.5823764801025391,
-0.5140576362609863,
1.123267650604248,
0.12681140005588531,
-0.09038063883781433,
0.1390368789434433,
0.3677234947681427,
-0.013552009128034115,
-0.31344297528266907,
0.20584940910339355,
0.49092352390289307,
-0.2728011906147003,
-0.2690871059894562,
-0.6596100926399231,
0.9994794726371765,
-0.738243043422699,
-0.43429526686668396,
-0.4715029299259186,
-0.6152276992797852,
-0.16550026834011078,
0.32545924186706543,
0.3265925347805023,
0.6465222239494324,
-0.17570312321186066,
0.4864327907562256,
0.6418028473854065,
-0.41195225715637207,
0.6512829661369324,
0.3172883987426758,
-0.39456093311309814,
-0.6190035343170166,
0.610607922077179,
0.4024633467197418,
0.8967828154563904,
0.3068782091140747,
0.2625935673713684,
-0.13785497844219208,
-0.7491366863250732,
0.043375104665756226,
0.2927651107311249,
-0.7616214156150818,
-0.2182346135377884,
-0.47918829321861267,
-0.515551745891571,
-0.272087037563324,
-0.19079352915287018,
-0.4263772964477539,
-0.7032379508018494,
-0.32453760504722595,
-0.23221342265605927,
-0.12291847914457321,
0.8787314891815186,
-0.28927597403526306,
0.40148863196372986,
-0.4377038776874542,
-0.18403111398220062,
0.17159397900104523,
0.2868250608444214,
0.44759857654571533,
-0.8087082505226135,
-0.47618749737739563,
-0.05399131774902344,
-0.1929110735654831,
-0.6051393151283264,
0.4092613160610199,
0.45784732699394226,
0.4585765302181244,
0.6007763743400574,
-0.2556021213531494,
0.4068876802921295,
-0.5571499466896057,
0.6554142832756042,
0.619926929473877,
-0.8951051831245422,
0.15507473051548004,
-0.6131076812744141,
0.6370254158973694,
0.4840831756591797,
0.269946426153183,
-0.6806385517120361,
-0.6587280631065369,
-0.5708571076393127,
-1.0544973611831665,
0.48404383659362793,
0.1432105451822281,
0.2834315598011017,
-0.22523729503154755,
0.5253911018371582,
-0.13606122136116028,
-0.03392606973648071,
-0.8396150469779968,
-0.3769603967666626,
0.024166300892829895,
0.385267049074173,
-0.12655293941497803,
-0.49226680397987366,
0.07492893189191818,
-0.33848437666893005,
0.18051201105117798,
-0.12955161929130554,
0.3140459358692169,
-0.13172610104084015,
-0.00981835275888443,
0.16218096017837524,
0.332005113363266,
0.9979994893074036,
0.6939935684204102,
0.149874746799469,
0.33519279956817627,
0.2145928144454956,
-0.3915839195251465,
0.13869549334049225,
-0.48030194640159607,
-0.11180578917264938,
-0.19637203216552734,
0.623508095741272,
0.943748414516449,
0.8534370064735413,
-0.26038700342178345,
0.4245645999908447,
-0.14653702080249786,
-0.36518922448158264,
-0.3769913613796234,
-0.11221194267272949,
0.1321156769990921,
-0.09936366230249405,
0.31109127402305603,
0.2384052872657776,
0.1334674060344696,
-0.7216310501098633,
0.2425568699836731,
0.2069789618253708,
-0.4247875213623047,
-0.6050524711608887,
0.6720845699310303,
-0.15290994942188263,
-0.089405857026577,
0.7583105564117432,
0.01137786079198122,
-0.6967794895172119,
0.6488702297210693,
0.8648028373718262,
1.1733437776565552,
-0.2754276692867279,
0.20421163737773895,
0.6214250922203064,
0.6774064898490906,
-0.25257351994514465,
-0.2584109604358673,
0.1332762986421585,
-0.6677080988883972,
-0.741064727306366,
-0.8058052062988281,
-0.1534709930419922,
-0.0790828987956047,
-0.8493865132331848,
0.2915002405643463,
-0.7264959812164307,
-0.2439793348312378,
-0.3444806635379791,
-0.3608672320842743,
-0.4502274990081787,
0.1324007213115692,
0.2761083245277405,
0.8678703308105469,
-0.8820429444313049,
0.5886594653129578,
0.2567022740840912,
-0.45289304852485657,
-0.7915590405464172,
-0.05565886199474335,
0.13257472217082977,
-0.5584481954574585,
0.9387021064758301,
0.24121491611003876,
-0.07382301241159439,
-0.15208326280117035,
-0.5459990501403809,
-1.1536228656768799,
0.996375560760498,
0.6746330261230469,
-0.4525549113750458,
-0.38829663395881653,
0.44340085983276367,
0.930743932723999,
-0.40462160110473633,
0.251360684633255,
0.6214269995689392,
0.2577087879180908,
0.22935883700847626,
-1.0793571472167969,
0.18418456614017487,
0.005154414568096399,
0.2658344805240631,
0.5255185961723328,
-0.6667141914367676,
1.098045825958252,
-0.17581361532211304,
-0.3903426229953766,
-0.00296454387716949,
0.6094067692756653,
-0.03625873848795891,
-0.18554647266864777,
0.4491109549999237,
0.8384398818016052,
0.4171673059463501,
-0.2902631461620331,
1.0944850444793701,
-0.3427785634994507,
0.44024062156677246,
1.1226739883422852,
0.42240121960639954,
0.9255756735801697,
0.08998987823724747,
-0.08314886689186096,
0.6072476506233215,
0.47931063175201416,
0.31048986315727234,
0.2344963550567627,
0.6345002055168152,
-0.022159507498145103,
-0.2539546489715576,
-0.16772675514221191,
-0.30066755414009094,
0.6377794146537781,
0.5742392539978027,
-0.35515689849853516,
-0.4727327525615692,
0.10288526862859726,
0.33228597044944763,
0.06048392876982689,
-0.5763189196586609,
0.5438893437385559,
0.4355265200138092,
-0.3409097492694855,
1.0861800909042358,
-0.3373281955718994,
0.5425556302070618,
-0.5165132284164429,
0.1762131005525589,
-0.23258762061595917,
0.06093515828251839,
-0.21319235861301422,
-0.3075973093509674,
0.6790078282356262,
-0.4250042736530304,
-0.2729026675224304,
-0.11896061897277832,
0.44627299904823303,
-0.5829076766967773,
-0.3118188977241516,
0.7064628601074219,
0.2838905453681946,
0.1844414621591568,
-0.049597933888435364,
-0.5047504901885986,
0.37260183691978455,
-0.25169602036476135,
-0.029506249353289604,
0.6048415303230286,
0.39783939719200134,
0.016902275383472443,
0.733421266078949,
0.5756268501281738,
0.31344762444496155,
0.27131375670433044,
0.026016926392912865,
0.9579458236694336,
-0.5199047923088074,
-0.2579379379749298,
-0.8696020245552063,
0.3329542875289917,
0.08922163397073746,
-0.3369811773300171,
0.7637119293212891,
0.36353787779808044,
0.7329578995704651,
0.15204046666622162,
0.39679253101348877,
-0.043319400399923325,
0.03314497321844101,
-0.44484201073646545,
1.031934380531311,
-0.5861193537712097,
0.24956828355789185,
-0.05004989728331566,
-0.9472305178642273,
-0.6817968487739563,
0.0011260000756010413,
-0.5483834147453308,
0.05706806853413582,
1.0581475496292114,
0.48660993576049805,
0.2953093349933624,
-0.3813863694667816,
0.7327478528022766,
0.5815966129302979,
0.16613614559173584,
0.5050970911979675,
0.5688405632972717,
-0.20841757953166962,
0.5708813071250916,
0.0008565398748032749,
-0.3290133476257324,
-0.07835204154253006,
-0.6532959938049316,
-1.0923748016357422,
-0.8157193064689636,
-0.3566378057003021,
-0.4071362018585205,
-0.1525840163230896,
0.5109960436820984,
0.5108371376991272,
-0.7921234965324402,
-0.3172212839126587,
-0.35771211981773376,
0.16455699503421783,
-0.09690740704536438,
-0.23572564125061035,
0.36529281735420227,
-0.6242744326591492,
-0.5775119066238403,
0.2656037509441376,
0.41907212138175964,
0.029376564547419548,
-0.6897038817405701,
0.21949760615825653,
-0.16771771013736725,
0.06416215747594833,
0.6118417382240295,
0.6000500321388245,
-0.6457342505455017,
-0.11272280663251877,
-0.05094977095723152,
-0.00878880824893713,
-0.03344440460205078,
0.8540933132171631,
-0.474196195602417,
0.5024782419204712,
0.47434982657432556,
0.6647883057594299,
0.015601481311023235,
-0.5197320580482483,
0.8308233618736267,
-0.6051620244979858,
0.19458381831645966,
0.24626608192920685,
0.398279070854187,
0.3740858733654022,
-0.12666870653629303,
0.20466995239257812,
0.17299234867095947,
-0.7123000621795654,
-1.0127912759780884,
0.4314478933811188,
-0.7767966389656067,
-0.11193083971738815,
1.1496152877807617,
0.05194254592061043,
-0.4840097725391388,
-0.06055087968707085,
0.2209686040878296,
0.03229992464184761,
-0.03163088858127594,
0.7246652245521545,
0.9288128018379211,
-0.020652933046221733,
-0.1815459281206131,
-0.7221469879150391,
0.41068753600120544,
0.3242844045162201,
-0.4998628795146942,
0.20701193809509277,
0.441731721162796,
0.2923066318035126,
0.4239028990268707,
0.22493243217468262,
-0.3048718571662903,
0.1890268176794052,
0.009522509761154652,
0.1977880746126175,
0.12840943038463593,
-0.3997753858566284,
-0.7002645134925842,
0.3669999837875366,
0.20036858320236206,
0.12468519061803818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17764v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17764v2
|
On the Sequence Evaluation based on Stochastic Processes
| 2024-05-28T02:33:38 | 2024-06-15T04:08:53 |
Tianhao Zhang, Zhexiao Lin, Zhecheng Sheng, Chen Jiang, Dongyeop Kang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, math.ST, stat.TH
|
Modeling and analyzing long sequences of text is an essential task for
Natural Language Processing. Success in capturing long text dynamics using
neural language models will facilitate many downstream tasks such as coherence
evaluation, text generation, machine translation and so on. This paper presents
a novel approach to model sequences through a stochastic process. We introduce
a likelihood-based training objective for the text encoder and design a more
thorough measurement (score) for long text evaluation compared to the previous
approach. The proposed training objective effectively preserves the sequence
coherence, while the new score comprehensively captures both temporal and
spatial dependencies. Theoretical properties of our new score show its
advantages in sequence evaluation. Experimental results show superior
performance in various sequence evaluation tasks, including global and local
discrimination within and between documents of different lengths. We also
demonstrate the encoder achieves competitive results on discriminating human
and AI written text.
|
[
0.05646822601556778,
-0.7944992780685425,
0.7508057951927185,
0.21942001581192017,
-0.2821016311645508,
-0.12632717192173004,
-0.5212034583091736,
-0.49396517872810364,
0.11156623810529709,
0.17474660277366638,
-0.35673436522483826,
-0.47695040702819824,
-0.7604958415031433,
0.21014103293418884,
-0.5740863084793091,
1.050724983215332,
-0.23405276238918304,
-0.09454472362995148,
-0.05398724228143692,
-0.035217951983213425,
-0.2470678687095642,
-0.38127562403678894,
-0.874664843082428,
-0.36309900879859924,
0.5663077235221863,
-0.22423742711544037,
0.6386268138885498,
0.5127069354057312,
0.5731092095375061,
0.31913986802101135,
0.08215942978858948,
-0.07151109725236893,
-0.2704552710056305,
0.34315332770347595,
-0.1758798062801361,
-0.30097126960754395,
-0.16608811914920807,
-0.1319035291671753,
0.9293581247329712,
0.6315204501152039,
-0.20777522027492523,
0.06562982499599457,
0.25315380096435547,
0.6820123791694641,
-0.27831047773361206,
-0.0914929211139679,
0.06587744504213333,
0.27427372336387634,
-0.09181643277406693,
-0.4547104835510254,
-0.43069952726364136,
-0.6005145311355591,
0.30262526869773865,
-0.12237066775560379,
0.26017796993255615,
-0.18590158224105835,
0.7133001089096069,
-0.002171438653022051,
-0.3450648784637451,
-0.597734808921814,
-0.7417083382606506,
0.8663288950920105,
-0.6476505398750305,
0.4242924451828003,
0.18304376304149628,
0.33962494134902954,
-0.270053893327713,
-0.4713832437992096,
-0.4842526614665985,
-0.27881333231925964,
0.32543638348579407,
0.10891982913017273,
0.2678608298301697,
0.049880772829055786,
0.08546407520771027,
0.5168240666389465,
-0.669498085975647,
0.14669394493103027,
-0.2455763965845108,
-0.025657810270786285,
1.003604769706726,
0.22988492250442505,
0.12317391484975815,
-0.12287091463804245,
-0.31725943088531494,
-0.06280537694692612,
0.14398890733718872,
0.1862213909626007,
0.5656812787055969,
0.2917425036430359,
-0.3831435739994049,
0.46348556876182556,
-0.007907161489129066,
0.5735242366790771,
-0.0027083572931587696,
-0.11519913375377655,
0.13965193927288055,
-0.035384319722652435,
-0.28643324971199036,
0.06583765894174576,
1.1537892818450928,
0.0018776321085169911,
0.09151630848646164,
-0.33239468932151794,
-0.3046189546585083,
0.00771418958902359,
0.20816199481487274,
-0.7325964570045471,
0.21441593766212463,
0.18160288035869598,
-0.6016605496406555,
-0.2200721651315689,
-0.04316079616546631,
-0.9484738111495972,
-0.1676541268825531,
-0.46235570311546326,
0.4514841139316559,
-0.7479890584945679,
0.006852872669696808,
0.35217538475990295,
-0.1718946248292923,
0.017632655799388885,
0.33862873911857605,
-0.9314571022987366,
0.3647875189781189,
0.7606155276298523,
0.9935871958732605,
-0.49896034598350525,
-0.3602350354194641,
-0.3443852961063385,
-0.33073270320892334,
-0.4335056245326996,
0.4376501441001892,
-0.7483677268028259,
-0.12138276547193527,
0.09050528705120087,
-0.1768532395362854,
-0.1416158825159073,
-0.25116339325904846,
0.5174382328987122,
-0.7870034575462341,
0.29888832569122314,
0.28667765855789185,
-0.8269319534301758,
-0.24892593920230865,
0.2349797934293747,
-0.7140170335769653,
1.230153203010559,
-0.03126268833875656,
-0.5505375266075134,
0.48197150230407715,
-0.644681453704834,
-0.5130805969238281,
-0.13355809450149536,
0.02298920229077339,
-0.38526514172554016,
0.24588847160339355,
-0.10221085697412491,
0.31621643900871277,
-0.27700644731521606,
0.5291168689727783,
-0.2804770767688751,
-0.684816300868988,
0.23487387597560883,
-0.809206485748291,
0.6550746560096741,
0.20583191514015198,
-0.30647262930870056,
0.24710023403167725,
-0.9080033898353577,
-0.04982495680451393,
-0.3156217038631439,
-0.82986980676651,
-0.22762401401996613,
0.15191049873828888,
-0.06586791574954987,
0.11219815164804459,
0.19888697564601898,
-0.35873275995254517,
0.005206721369177103,
-0.5834292769432068,
0.20675364136695862,
0.49138039350509644,
0.221393421292305,
0.7203620672225952,
-0.3508104383945465,
0.352342426776886,
-0.11130820959806442,
0.04880642145872116,
-0.3669074773788452,
-0.42007261514663696,
-0.7018972039222717,
-0.4244973361492157,
0.2683027386665344,
0.4995598793029785,
-0.3357275426387787,
0.7453524470329285,
-0.49030086398124695,
-0.43473121523857117,
-0.28210029006004333,
-0.13013604283332825,
0.13965880870819092,
-0.08378761261701584,
0.23449797928333282,
-0.5820060968399048,
-0.41679272055625916,
-0.5637114644050598,
-0.4104035496711731,
0.15888497233390808,
-0.24188099801540375,
-0.1262761503458023,
0.6726529002189636,
-0.21531449258327484,
0.8525465130805969,
-0.11593097448348999,
0.12544691562652588,
-0.19921214878559113,
0.6573238968849182,
0.7196746468544006,
0.5456602573394775,
0.0010297109838575125,
-0.5252841114997864,
-0.14525605738162994,
-0.16100893914699554,
-0.8906447887420654,
0.24970991909503937,
-0.4134698212146759,
-0.151078462600708,
0.3305678367614746,
0.3964405357837677,
-0.6166359782218933,
0.5833514332771301,
0.36082249879837036,
-0.25549694895744324,
0.5578383803367615,
-0.46993523836135864,
0.524109423160553,
-0.9347314238548279,
0.03030645102262497,
0.0959913432598114,
-0.29033616185188293,
-0.494570791721344,
0.26606082916259766,
-0.05414612963795662,
-0.27897393703460693,
-0.3603684902191162,
0.23077329993247986,
-0.2476300597190857,
-0.1276582032442093,
-0.1130048856139183,
-0.15288883447647095,
-0.08041514456272125,
0.558732271194458,
0.2331404834985733,
0.2553492486476898,
0.07350528985261917,
-0.8756746053695679,
0.34683793783187866,
-0.08366390317678452,
-0.9417240023612976,
0.3268788754940033,
-0.49409282207489014,
0.2505268156528473,
-0.4040997326374054,
-0.036350470036268234,
-0.6646735072135925,
-0.008231552317738533,
0.03140287101268768,
-0.3800361156463623,
0.4498702883720398,
0.15440787374973297,
-0.46891021728515625,
-0.44430139660835266,
-0.14374519884586334,
0.43939897418022156,
0.3642544448375702,
-0.27925702929496765,
0.33564698696136475,
0.11121160537004471,
-0.17979060113430023,
-0.3012498915195465,
-0.6058229207992554,
0.10855574905872345,
-0.20915785431861877,
-0.6453097462654114,
0.3867321014404297,
-0.000504282012116164,
0.13186900317668915,
-0.22128742933273315,
0.14773482084274292,
-0.09936752915382385,
0.013123164884746075,
0.12456557899713516,
0.08559415489435196,
-0.1459534913301468,
0.3053852319717407,
-0.05357038229703903,
0.007952218875288963,
0.03318344056606293,
-0.49763768911361694,
0.5055385828018188,
0.12576597929000854,
-0.3653203248977661,
-0.5663766264915466,
0.6442846655845642,
0.37253451347351074,
-0.03840520232915878,
0.5897530317306519,
0.4249953329563141,
-0.6255316734313965,
-0.3731922209262848,
-0.15570072829723358,
-0.13765518367290497,
-0.4182412624359131,
0.6700347065925598,
-0.18375013768672943,
-0.9958636164665222,
0.24158351123332977,
0.113559789955616,
-0.20856809616088867,
0.4063655138015747,
0.543075442314148,
-0.2217492163181305,
0.6865604519844055,
0.7718470096588135,
-0.08605890721082687,
0.4664907455444336,
0.010282812640070915,
0.49954575300216675,
-0.2803022861480713,
0.08819552510976791,
-0.26525112986564636,
-0.49420642852783203,
-0.4031277596950531,
-0.6713773608207703,
0.11025982350111008,
0.35045742988586426,
-0.49764493107795715,
0.31367090344429016,
-0.3959297239780426,
0.2883845567703247,
0.43285512924194336,
0.126912921667099,
0.066712386906147,
0.06352925300598145,
-0.3403605818748474,
-0.3424839675426483,
-0.3364524245262146,
-0.7309134602546692,
0.731498122215271,
0.6642148494720459,
0.7245222330093384,
0.007265642285346985,
0.8553077578544617,
0.5204271078109741,
0.20139674842357635,
-0.8622645139694214,
0.4776027202606201,
-0.16044600307941437,
-0.42540812492370605,
-0.6733022332191467,
-0.4534788727760315,
-0.6833066940307617,
-0.04419010505080223,
-0.160980686545372,
-0.8686504364013672,
-0.038620397448539734,
-0.2168353796005249,
-0.4385175108909607,
0.19454273581504822,
-0.10938917100429535,
0.9852968454360962,
-0.41661179065704346,
-0.5802976489067078,
-0.15631769597530365,
-0.3136933743953705,
0.13243450224399567,
-0.09282845258712769,
0.0679723247885704,
-0.1373666375875473,
0.17618238925933838,
0.9618965983390808,
-0.34624817967414856,
0.7966505289077759,
-0.07157875597476959,
-0.14821599423885345,
0.3842286467552185,
-0.07683385163545609,
0.42603394389152527,
-0.04696284234523773,
-0.5527293682098389,
0.22479204833507538,
-0.20946116745471954,
-0.09340152889490128,
-0.6739979386329651,
0.4557640552520752,
-0.4969147741794586,
-0.25594404339790344,
-0.590810239315033,
-0.49316075444221497,
0.032708119601011276,
0.11695952713489532,
0.43438613414764404,
0.21940474212169647,
-0.5332069396972656,
-0.23867815732955933,
0.34394946694374084,
-0.4193912148475647,
0.8455151319503784,
0.1938069611787796,
-0.1169227808713913,
-0.5396121144294739,
0.6136472821235657,
-0.04329438880085945,
0.06401445716619492,
0.7386494874954224,
0.13757489621639252,
-0.39559271931648254,
-0.46186137199401855,
-0.3613249957561493,
-0.16947920620441437,
-0.5138906836509705,
0.05919015407562256,
-0.42829012870788574,
-0.3087422549724579,
-0.1164272204041481,
-0.2446666806936264,
-0.31952622532844543,
-0.08333145827054977,
-0.23080867528915405,
-0.027600139379501343,
0.1496102511882782,
0.6429607272148132,
0.08947716653347015,
0.11716024577617645,
-0.9590648412704468,
0.028887709602713585,
0.31103190779685974,
0.4282952845096588,
0.14749297499656677,
-0.6388070583343506,
-0.5541520714759827,
-0.06451847404241562,
-0.3461025059223175,
-0.805400550365448,
0.772275447845459,
0.5042531490325928,
0.3546544313430786,
0.2713232934474945,
-0.12032163143157959,
0.6505539417266846,
-0.7478739619255066,
0.692530632019043,
0.28014612197875977,
-1.0378235578536987,
0.7464492321014404,
-0.29399433732032776,
0.45521703362464905,
0.6129862070083618,
0.5525846481323242,
-0.5917681455612183,
-0.3805435597896576,
-0.09157386422157288,
-0.7958444356918335,
0.37750688195228577,
0.12472010403871536,
0.1273372769355774,
-0.3134159743785858,
0.3818488121032715,
0.3341207206249237,
0.23222894966602325,
-0.42641010880470276,
0.2191135585308075,
0.16084134578704834,
-0.7149872183799744,
-0.21164372563362122,
-0.3691324293613434,
0.19055116176605225,
-0.014008583500981331,
0.4097634255886078,
-0.016412539407610893,
0.5321773886680603,
0.3835483193397522,
-0.38410893082618713,
0.0778888463973999,
0.4433070719242096,
0.45978984236717224,
0.27115386724472046,
-0.26937803626060486,
-0.04849730059504509,
0.18716618418693542,
-0.49445754289627075,
0.32521089911460876,
0.14207281172275543,
-0.20564191043376923,
0.20320791006088257,
0.5791835784912109,
0.8530797362327576,
0.7601762413978577,
-0.464760422706604,
0.6399543285369873,
0.03940685838460922,
-0.13768541812896729,
-0.45547616481781006,
-0.0989556759595871,
-0.050075989216566086,
0.517853319644928,
0.3380548357963562,
0.2355666309595108,
0.3712388575077057,
-0.5204809904098511,
0.5798507332801819,
-0.07476496696472168,
-0.8096989989280701,
-0.40561413764953613,
0.5625036358833313,
0.028207065537571907,
-0.5251973867416382,
0.6034417152404785,
-0.37388432025909424,
-0.4196111261844635,
0.6486057043075562,
0.6649129390716553,
0.8748945593833923,
-0.23353292047977448,
0.08830709755420685,
0.6890184283256531,
0.06485449522733688,
-0.3996422588825226,
0.4972183406352997,
-0.17732739448547363,
-0.5267259478569031,
-0.5548166632652283,
-1.2877126932144165,
-0.12597604095935822,
-0.19609852135181427,
-0.6840928792953491,
0.3226960003376007,
-0.4279733896255493,
-0.3329179584980011,
-0.06991948187351227,
-0.14757820963859558,
-0.6584816575050354,
0.3837023377418518,
0.29032039642333984,
0.956689715385437,
-0.5578770041465759,
0.8417119383811951,
0.2988775074481964,
-0.22768639028072357,
-0.2107059359550476,
-0.10776656121015549,
-0.1583639681339264,
-0.26954418420791626,
0.8977583050727844,
0.6020385026931763,
0.02985822781920433,
-0.3006255328655243,
-0.006874542683362961,
-0.8023563027381897,
0.7533159852027893,
0.35671621561050415,
-0.9302349090576172,
-0.17232859134674072,
0.28422433137893677,
0.7425532341003418,
-0.4221406579017639,
0.378952294588089,
0.560211718082428,
0.11579892784357071,
-0.1562139242887497,
-0.7394267916679382,
-0.09892676025629044,
-0.3389158248901367,
0.21401262283325195,
0.4028361439704895,
-0.1569373905658722,
0.5920014977455139,
-0.14820845425128937,
-0.6027470827102661,
0.40251490473747253,
0.8976101279258728,
0.14268186688423157,
0.358157217502594,
0.22167429327964783,
0.756450355052948,
0.9135938882827759,
-0.016398102045059204,
1.0812348127365112,
-0.1425856202840805,
0.4450337588787079,
1.3187949657440186,
-0.20428654551506042,
1.306663990020752,
0.2205076515674591,
-0.4185265600681305,
0.6197954416275024,
0.6387595534324646,
0.07421617954969406,
0.6767356991767883,
0.6195608973503113,
-0.5684856176376343,
-0.19663971662521362,
0.2950364053249359,
-0.012686737813055515,
0.37991878390312195,
0.1781708300113678,
-0.7638099193572998,
0.017038481310009956,
0.12596845626831055,
-0.24929234385490417,
0.25617143511772156,
-0.35211145877838135,
0.6039457321166992,
0.2947539985179901,
-0.8121882081031799,
0.25718796253204346,
0.2104388028383255,
1.011021375656128,
-0.5228015184402466,
0.12481873482465744,
0.22283655405044556,
0.4164002537727356,
0.015850337222218513,
-0.7220718264579773,
0.5138831734657288,
0.027898581698536873,
-0.45014482736587524,
-0.143568754196167,
0.49260011315345764,
-0.6316478252410889,
-0.6257132291793823,
0.5491166710853577,
-0.20098106563091278,
0.24001632630825043,
0.04725301265716553,
-0.43593889474868774,
-0.07330422103404999,
-0.4139150381088257,
-0.2518720030784607,
0.09431856125593185,
0.413470596075058,
-0.06823733448982239,
0.1592584252357483,
0.6431082487106323,
-0.19922588765621185,
0.08289157599210739,
0.4088280498981476,
0.1167079284787178,
-1.1058818101882935,
-0.7124781012535095,
-1.1084257364273071,
0.533411979675293,
-0.15833571553230286,
-0.48856937885284424,
0.42866629362106323,
0.6502496004104614,
0.5245440602302551,
-0.07801266759634018,
0.7875174880027771,
0.13515964150428772,
0.34616339206695557,
-0.4159281849861145,
0.8214179277420044,
-0.24091176688671112,
0.007529524154961109,
-0.02718718908727169,
-0.8796595335006714,
-0.42225831747055054,
0.7779645323753357,
-0.4799700975418091,
0.06188519671559334,
0.7159355282783508,
0.5119132399559021,
0.2043500691652298,
0.33118364214897156,
0.2932145893573761,
-0.11333062499761581,
0.20610737800598145,
0.9399486184120178,
0.8152913451194763,
-0.8401061296463013,
0.14113205671310425,
-0.007181178312748671,
-0.35867926478385925,
-0.1577952355146408,
-1.081777811050415,
-0.8376758098602295,
-0.5759320259094238,
-0.30355551838874817,
-0.2720984220504761,
0.3986164927482605,
0.9012855887413025,
0.5441587567329407,
-0.9133742451667786,
-0.36679622530937195,
-0.1695326715707779,
0.0037071630358695984,
-0.37491947412490845,
-0.2088511735200882,
0.3406713306903839,
-0.5505731701850891,
-0.7638351917266846,
0.48501622676849365,
0.7433189153671265,
-0.11849499493837357,
-0.000673736329190433,
-0.3591877520084381,
-0.34278950095176697,
0.17042171955108643,
0.701063871383667,
0.17344918847084045,
-0.28211963176727295,
-0.4169565439224243,
-0.16990287601947784,
-0.32074105739593506,
0.07486280053853989,
0.5732647776603699,
-0.48892149329185486,
0.46925681829452515,
0.7300023436546326,
0.6609097123146057,
0.6937826871871948,
-0.43364349007606506,
0.95703125,
-0.571107029914856,
0.049342453479766846,
0.36850836873054504,
0.39491793513298035,
0.36686527729034424,
-0.25706109404563904,
0.3722909688949585,
0.04352014139294624,
-0.5673872232437134,
-0.47077134251594543,
0.1562698930501938,
-0.738972544670105,
0.11723513156175613,
0.8463815450668335,
-0.27215245366096497,
-0.5079590082168579,
-0.037714000791311264,
0.23015150427818298,
0.5831717252731323,
-0.3120587468147278,
0.7971268892288208,
0.6089087128639221,
0.1629948914051056,
-0.19396501779556274,
-0.4584503173828125,
0.3910359740257263,
0.17651009559631348,
-0.6170246005058289,
-0.4526413083076477,
0.28255313634872437,
0.1367497742176056,
0.23888663947582245,
0.5785136222839355,
-0.28799131512641907,
0.265118807554245,
0.10497446358203888,
0.14476439356803894,
0.2730707824230194,
-0.23882007598876953,
-0.5703041553497314,
0.4743010401725769,
-0.22591672837734222,
-0.28612080216407776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17755v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17755v1
|
XL3M: A Training-free Framework for LLM Length Extension Based on Segment-wise Inference
| 2024-05-28T02:12:35 | 2024-05-28T02:12:35 |
Shengnan Wang, Youhui Bai, Lin Zhang, Pingyi Zhou, Shixiong Zhao, Gong Zhang, Sen Wang, Renhai Chen, Hua Xu, Hongwei Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Length generalization failure problem, namely the large language model (LLM)
fails to generalize to texts longer than its maximum training length, greatly
restricts the application of LLM in the scenarios with streaming long inputs.
To address this problem, the existing methods either require substantial costs
or introduce precision loss. In this paper, we empirically find that the
accuracy of the LLM's prediction is highly correlated to its certainty. Based
on this, we propose an efficient training free framework, named XL3M (it means
extra-long large language model), which enables the LLMs trained on short
sequences to reason extremely long sequence without any further training or
fine-tuning. Under the XL3M framework, the input context will be firstly
decomposed into multiple short sub-contexts, where each sub-context contains an
independent segment and a common ``question'' which is a few tokens from the
end of the original context. Then XL3M gives a method to measure the relevance
between each segment and the ``question'', and constructs a concise key context
by splicing all the relevant segments in chronological order. The key context
is further used instead of the original context to complete the inference task.
Evaluations on comprehensive benchmarks show the superiority of XL3M. Using our
framework, a Llama2-7B model is able to reason 20M long sequences on an 8-card
Huawei Ascend 910B NPU machine with 64GB memory per card.
|
[
-0.2835855484008789,
-0.6823405027389526,
0.9688752293586731,
0.17640142142772675,
-0.6636868715286255,
-0.20053254067897797,
-0.3533448874950409,
-0.4941159784793854,
0.03113468363881111,
0.4962511956691742,
-0.5498948097229004,
-0.5123353004455566,
-0.5071330666542053,
0.15292713046073914,
-0.5563238859176636,
0.5303806662559509,
-0.1890815645456314,
-0.04999080300331116,
0.010066266171634197,
-0.29611438512802124,
-0.13394728302955627,
-0.4477919936180115,
-0.6047019958496094,
-0.21979773044586182,
0.5929593443870544,
0.5061837434768677,
0.4785974323749542,
1.068785548210144,
0.20754671096801758,
0.24136562645435333,
-0.17793916165828705,
0.42052024602890015,
-0.34872469305992126,
-0.23136039078235626,
0.1325758993625641,
-0.7836945056915283,
-0.3717832863330841,
-0.24726209044456482,
0.7464226484298706,
0.8093660473823547,
0.0197051540017128,
-0.1147984117269516,
0.04195375740528107,
0.7540292739868164,
-0.45167526602745056,
-0.10502546280622482,
-0.6235746145248413,
0.09555233269929886,
0.02664308249950409,
-0.21166366338729858,
-0.34439152479171753,
-0.35081949830055237,
0.05394396185874939,
-0.41715383529663086,
0.09672662615776062,
0.12932053208351135,
0.7026394009590149,
0.21489813923835754,
-0.503943681716919,
0.0006181530188769102,
-0.9187409281730652,
0.914154052734375,
-0.8312190175056458,
0.4395543336868286,
0.3302496075630188,
0.26083502173423767,
0.011936313472688198,
-0.3449760973453522,
-0.6621915102005005,
0.025649094954133034,
0.21769565343856812,
0.09405303746461868,
0.06263038516044617,
0.2516525089740753,
0.28785228729248047,
0.3161601126194,
-0.562473714351654,
0.2566060423851013,
-0.4218290448188782,
0.056002333760261536,
0.4495284855365753,
0.08901254087686539,
0.20459194481372833,
0.14902982115745544,
-0.5408695936203003,
0.09328258037567139,
-1.0120735168457031,
-0.14177434146404266,
0.5958943367004395,
-0.02157306857407093,
-0.1530543863773346,
0.5133786201477051,
-0.029809094965457916,
0.8394084572792053,
-0.1152135506272316,
-0.24751269817352295,
0.14511948823928833,
0.10500535368919373,
-0.42026984691619873,
0.1507469117641449,
0.7424523830413818,
0.5149625539779663,
0.07376228272914886,
-0.021015970036387444,
-0.021634824573993683,
-0.2787271738052368,
-0.21258902549743652,
-0.7895724177360535,
0.31801265478134155,
0.5055133700370789,
-0.35225969552993774,
0.25008559226989746,
-0.06438805162906647,
-0.38032203912734985,
-0.030839931219816208,
-0.4380694627761841,
0.16238680481910706,
-0.8781896829605103,
0.01967306062579155,
0.20187756419181824,
0.16819708049297333,
0.3744734227657318,
0.28891363739967346,
-0.9322662949562073,
0.10712181776762009,
0.7832455039024353,
0.9533007144927979,
-0.37551864981651306,
-0.4219944477081299,
-0.6398530006408691,
0.3018030524253845,
-0.5003174543380737,
0.7537350654602051,
-0.35593393445014954,
-0.3172370493412018,
-0.11318743228912354,
0.004388228990137577,
-0.06354732811450958,
-0.4519009292125702,
0.594931960105896,
-0.6992356181144714,
0.04780059680342674,
0.3559916615486145,
-1.0563510656356812,
-0.44976478815078735,
0.21444721519947052,
-0.6914355754852295,
0.6268243193626404,
-0.03275257721543312,
-0.3875707685947418,
0.23550009727478027,
-0.5368850231170654,
-0.19974999129772186,
0.06048588827252388,
-0.18281815946102142,
-0.4481014013290405,
0.09531505405902863,
0.2640690505504608,
0.5166744589805603,
-0.42184701561927795,
0.3327834904193878,
-0.5383239388465881,
-0.6795592904090881,
0.11958484351634979,
-0.4191790521144867,
0.4314868152141571,
0.010608217678964138,
-0.3689417243003845,
0.2136962115764618,
-0.894666850566864,
0.13433781266212463,
-0.0913853645324707,
-0.5455611348152161,
-0.22665327787399292,
0.06849920749664307,
-0.2834039628505707,
-0.008040894754230976,
-0.08638947457075119,
-0.5434255599975586,
-0.05478997156023979,
-0.7033888101577759,
0.26749446988105774,
0.656690776348114,
-0.25711551308631897,
0.4844760596752167,
-0.20308038592338562,
0.4329298734664917,
-0.19289688766002655,
-0.02842976339161396,
-0.3249676525592804,
-0.2628111243247986,
-1.0269242525100708,
-0.2628103196620941,
0.3510616421699524,
0.4964037835597992,
-0.5298473834991455,
0.6130760908126831,
-0.4897286295890808,
-0.25796422362327576,
0.019505497068166733,
0.3060912489891052,
0.2991473972797394,
0.2633169889450073,
0.5629780888557434,
0.11304344236850739,
-0.7843743562698364,
-0.8728311061859131,
-0.2066185176372528,
-0.06430252641439438,
-0.2191956788301468,
0.1623833328485489,
0.33700495958328247,
-0.4056740999221802,
1.0386732816696167,
-0.4805888533592224,
-0.19503019750118256,
-0.7619463801383972,
-0.0746486708521843,
0.3778931796550751,
0.3293664753437042,
0.3311569392681122,
-0.6071875691413879,
-0.3276219367980957,
-0.05955972149968147,
-0.4966164827346802,
0.10037370026111603,
-0.06290297210216522,
0.12385845929384232,
0.3708450496196747,
0.5069012641906738,
-0.3197605311870575,
0.2337881177663803,
0.7705613970756531,
-0.028934616595506668,
0.5215394496917725,
-0.2136220633983612,
-0.28568610548973083,
-1.1608498096466064,
-0.015922408550977707,
0.02379915863275528,
-0.3074440062046051,
-0.5710697770118713,
-0.12787766754627228,
0.26752912998199463,
0.10029245913028717,
-0.5996137857437134,
0.6700091361999512,
-0.3968188464641571,
-0.02521643415093422,
-0.6287299394607544,
0.122214674949646,
-0.00759882153943181,
0.6336846947669983,
0.2868281602859497,
0.4508693218231201,
0.2859034836292267,
-0.6912280321121216,
0.43653514981269836,
-0.13952744007110596,
-0.6005432605743408,
0.2005886286497116,
-0.5400905609130859,
0.0847608670592308,
0.0012707907008007169,
0.30470922589302063,
-0.54707932472229,
-0.3171340227127075,
-0.024281948804855347,
-0.24404503405094147,
0.2837684452533722,
-0.24806414544582367,
-0.39732131361961365,
-0.3609800338745117,
-0.17102459073066711,
0.507532000541687,
0.5317491292953491,
-0.8044853806495667,
0.6263821125030518,
0.03549417108297348,
-0.06970544159412384,
-0.6205393671989441,
-0.7268170118331909,
-0.00891738012433052,
-0.5785498023033142,
-0.7296857237815857,
0.3603549301624298,
-0.2645242512226105,
-0.05385813117027283,
-0.2707808017730713,
-0.18984530866146088,
-0.16345177590847015,
0.09812622517347336,
0.17952990531921387,
0.23085875809192657,
-0.18341141939163208,
-0.018404057249426842,
0.1284913271665573,
-0.10154414921998978,
0.062188610434532166,
-0.3046383261680603,
0.4999614953994751,
-0.148228257894516,
-0.42672333121299744,
-0.2963985800743103,
0.38376352190971375,
0.23417852818965912,
0.28603965044021606,
0.5254778861999512,
0.40686652064323425,
-0.26667577028274536,
-0.45284968614578247,
-0.6118478178977966,
0.04482331871986389,
-0.40453672409057617,
0.5073320269584656,
-0.17499609291553497,
-1.216395378112793,
0.40429770946502686,
0.038528528064489365,
-0.12241148948669434,
0.22273539006710052,
0.2572612762451172,
0.16769683361053467,
1.0612658262252808,
0.6946839690208435,
-0.000531693862285465,
0.20370866358280182,
-0.3594122529029846,
0.23195667564868927,
-0.8982880711555481,
-0.13616931438446045,
-0.07029208540916443,
-0.062291696667671204,
-0.035740241408348083,
-0.6440974473953247,
0.1424776315689087,
0.3419552147388458,
-0.063355952501297,
0.3401586413383484,
-0.0469573438167572,
0.7044275999069214,
0.3458479344844818,
-0.0420629046857357,
0.2868403196334839,
0.05516797676682472,
-0.33231058716773987,
0.3835623860359192,
-0.45915526151657104,
-0.38247138261795044,
1.0295040607452393,
0.40606555342674255,
0.626215934753418,
0.1805676519870758,
0.6318174600601196,
-0.037586212158203125,
0.259110689163208,
-0.9838969707489014,
0.6472755670547485,
0.1233190968632698,
-0.22991500794887543,
-0.4502643346786499,
-0.5239832401275635,
-0.8861448764801025,
0.2784222364425659,
0.23815405368804932,
-0.8064994215965271,
-0.10060406476259232,
0.28304317593574524,
-0.6069674491882324,
0.5774049162864685,
-0.4598327875137329,
0.3018190860748291,
-0.45256346464157104,
-0.47195127606391907,
-0.09054579585790634,
-0.614090085029602,
0.6185731291770935,
-0.34493714570999146,
0.23106417059898376,
-0.3673054277896881,
-0.19994233548641205,
0.9732317924499512,
-0.8704580068588257,
0.6716663241386414,
0.05434796214103699,
-0.30883553624153137,
0.41768839955329895,
-0.23406635224819183,
0.3871358633041382,
0.13597410917282104,
-0.01686972938477993,
0.25384145975112915,
-0.270752876996994,
-0.2618477940559387,
-0.5706524848937988,
0.750337541103363,
-0.7307823896408081,
-0.6786834001541138,
-0.1715252548456192,
-0.4932379722595215,
-0.4903169274330139,
0.27641239762306213,
0.2993937134742737,
0.4750630855560303,
0.01037121657282114,
0.27746620774269104,
0.5919031500816345,
-0.1704464703798294,
0.6300199031829834,
0.41217041015625,
-0.29975584149360657,
-0.631102979183197,
0.673968493938446,
-0.14659841358661652,
0.1843600571155548,
0.6264495253562927,
0.24113576114177704,
-0.5746957659721375,
-0.8382734656333923,
-0.5370920300483704,
0.11697717756032944,
-0.7518812417984009,
-0.22386334836483002,
-0.6585425734519958,
-0.23345807194709778,
-0.11438712477684021,
-0.025110749527812004,
-0.17245061695575714,
-0.3745769262313843,
-0.22576703131198883,
-0.3477877676486969,
0.3533762991428375,
0.39903968572616577,
-0.22029855847358704,
0.47731298208236694,
-1.0436933040618896,
0.20558281242847443,
0.3636884391307831,
0.5070348381996155,
0.023896556347608566,
-0.7101417183876038,
-0.4503377377986908,
-0.011038398370146751,
-0.29135459661483765,
-0.5449294447898865,
0.4293656051158905,
0.19602730870246887,
0.3406032919883728,
0.6755024790763855,
-0.3071027398109436,
0.7381336092948914,
-0.5691660046577454,
0.649567723274231,
0.526089608669281,
-0.9868332743644714,
0.30410534143447876,
-0.28177738189697266,
0.3072354793548584,
0.18872664868831635,
0.4141416549682617,
-0.5224220156669617,
-0.13403797149658203,
-0.32907527685165405,
-1.1006346940994263,
0.8108075261116028,
0.029135555028915405,
-0.05235825851559639,
-0.21214079856872559,
0.31857630610466003,
0.25561290979385376,
-0.23183202743530273,
-0.6082502603530884,
-0.32069844007492065,
-0.017291460186243057,
-0.03062031790614128,
-0.18334980309009552,
-0.4901975095272064,
0.10240356624126434,
-0.10861166566610336,
0.7689831256866455,
-0.5597497820854187,
0.1356528401374817,
0.22279909253120422,
-0.31421539187431335,
0.0996708795428276,
0.37554091215133667,
0.7670774459838867,
0.8607559204101562,
-0.375421404838562,
0.11062519252300262,
0.43619656562805176,
-0.2059958428144455,
0.31650611758232117,
0.16383729875087738,
0.1745777726173401,
-0.01148989051580429,
0.5001208186149597,
0.966323971748352,
0.2198975533246994,
-0.8337017893791199,
0.5090357065200806,
-0.02634260430932045,
-0.5079617500305176,
-0.44809338450431824,
0.10568311810493469,
0.4076010286808014,
0.026389848440885544,
0.5530102849006653,
-0.3010367453098297,
0.05666175112128258,
-0.2823271155357361,
0.05259431153535843,
0.2151813507080078,
-0.5398891568183899,
-0.2173144370317459,
0.5236467123031616,
0.14667683839797974,
0.061427511274814606,
0.3337525427341461,
-0.008722608909010887,
-0.5240587592124939,
0.8061367869377136,
0.568115234375,
0.7905817627906799,
-0.12618869543075562,
-0.11870241165161133,
0.31931209564208984,
-0.015119090676307678,
-0.42004668712615967,
0.23056264221668243,
-0.040058210492134094,
-0.7662023305892944,
-0.9893410801887512,
-0.7393000721931458,
-0.5142921209335327,
0.6248173713684082,
-0.4314597547054291,
0.2577148377895355,
-0.30928388237953186,
0.14476341009140015,
-0.42917966842651367,
-0.1972426027059555,
-0.3129616379737854,
0.42763471603393555,
0.36399975419044495,
1.2150665521621704,
-0.35353443026542664,
0.8890811800956726,
0.41567760705947876,
0.17901654541492462,
-0.9995933771133423,
-0.16440775990486145,
-0.10467522591352463,
-0.8144606947898865,
0.48078829050064087,
0.6889599561691284,
-0.2889043986797333,
-0.22332388162612915,
-0.4514918923377991,
-0.9771480560302734,
1.1520718336105347,
0.39449405670166016,
-0.9021990299224854,
-0.12508974969387054,
0.45015522837638855,
0.23112165927886963,
-0.4680180549621582,
0.25409242510795593,
0.6561712026596069,
0.22146844863891602,
0.2520507574081421,
-0.5381192564964294,
0.07356689870357513,
-0.0915370061993599,
0.1622975468635559,
0.26168230175971985,
-0.5945378541946411,
0.47039952874183655,
-0.4988100826740265,
-0.16562645137310028,
0.46297648549079895,
0.8103698492050171,
0.35099053382873535,
0.2258882224559784,
0.6101815104484558,
0.6107258200645447,
0.5547574758529663,
0.021382885053753853,
0.8841508030891418,
-0.42354536056518555,
0.38006284832954407,
1.2483501434326172,
-0.35125526785850525,
0.7248099446296692,
0.35766610503196716,
0.023554418236017227,
0.5430741310119629,
0.6451266407966614,
0.050596632063388824,
0.31159448623657227,
0.3181101977825165,
-0.3516099154949188,
-0.3917343318462372,
0.385281503200531,
-0.31061774492263794,
0.3269520401954651,
0.5223426222801208,
-0.5616914629936218,
-0.19784937798976898,
-0.01811615563929081,
0.1280236691236496,
-0.21886679530143738,
-0.4743618667125702,
0.6484649777412415,
0.3884994089603424,
-0.8609882593154907,
0.7622874975204468,
0.24751083552837372,
0.6210656762123108,
-0.7180948853492737,
0.25507959723472595,
-0.3877827227115631,
0.31595563888549805,
-0.24264979362487793,
-0.518295407295227,
0.42534181475639343,
-0.10499481856822968,
-0.08088105171918869,
0.057924289256334305,
0.468434602022171,
-0.42580145597457886,
-0.3866725265979767,
0.4825015366077423,
0.433925062417984,
0.14365170896053314,
-0.1597663015127182,
-0.43026214838027954,
0.09557760506868362,
0.03980353847146034,
-0.15228171646595,
0.2925020158290863,
0.2438036948442459,
0.018368849530816078,
0.6896246671676636,
0.5967966914176941,
0.026664765551686287,
-0.1409769058227539,
0.025847595185041428,
0.6492088437080383,
-0.81270831823349,
-0.4376767575740814,
-1.1605557203292847,
0.1074005737900734,
-0.07677620649337769,
0.07901403307914734,
0.6763234734535217,
0.8540611863136292,
0.7822242379188538,
0.04295433685183525,
0.9571341872215271,
0.3300108313560486,
0.4581940770149231,
-0.8329761028289795,
0.3041088879108429,
-0.683551013469696,
0.3994821012020111,
0.05269252881407738,
-1.079131007194519,
-0.5467367172241211,
0.24466052651405334,
-0.5056864619255066,
-0.09214799106121063,
0.8721638917922974,
0.5618724226951599,
-0.1557663381099701,
0.14032259583473206,
0.5400658249855042,
0.09351952373981476,
0.2557933032512665,
0.8941752910614014,
0.9039443135261536,
-0.1124408021569252,
1.0620146989822388,
-0.19942177832126617,
-0.2627410590648651,
-0.3563072383403778,
-0.9644092321395874,
-0.9765928983688354,
-0.23286879062652588,
-0.11511079967021942,
-0.1689881831407547,
0.01674201712012291,
0.9186289310455322,
0.7299599647521973,
-0.5237126350402832,
-0.22503583133220673,
-0.27236971259117126,
0.2473965734243393,
-0.061571769416332245,
-0.20198293030261993,
0.6154892444610596,
-0.1303940862417221,
-0.7625958323478699,
0.6553599834442139,
0.5608718395233154,
0.18920837342739105,
0.03160634636878967,
-0.2082790583372116,
0.1141199916601181,
0.18293042480945587,
0.7245581150054932,
0.46057286858558655,
-0.7325143814086914,
-0.34045079350471497,
-0.12069240212440491,
0.26760655641555786,
0.3509712219238281,
0.6441748142242432,
-0.6418367624282837,
0.03382420167326927,
0.21491360664367676,
0.6119983196258545,
0.41064921021461487,
-0.04884997010231018,
0.707776665687561,
-0.551501989364624,
-0.17476457357406616,
0.018375450745224953,
0.7843761444091797,
0.4371519982814789,
-0.08514969795942307,
0.5310290455818176,
0.1684010773897171,
-0.47687363624572754,
-0.5329684615135193,
0.4301474988460541,
-0.9692921042442322,
-0.2712012231349945,
1.5586782693862915,
-0.3202647864818573,
-0.522964596748352,
-0.0582352951169014,
-0.09068696945905685,
0.13102944195270538,
-0.301530122756958,
0.5288776159286499,
0.3833349347114563,
-0.25452154874801636,
-0.2197437882423401,
-0.10270091146230698,
0.3940975069999695,
0.4028114676475525,
-0.7611472606658936,
-0.035185202956199646,
0.3354474604129791,
0.43124982714653015,
0.16514289379119873,
0.4093003571033478,
0.028240369632840157,
0.3223094046115875,
-0.48404499888420105,
-0.13246604800224304,
-0.05581294745206833,
-0.2982812821865082,
-0.3011350631713867,
0.2660132944583893,
0.07099288702011108,
0.06194329261779785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17743v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17743v2
|
ORLM: Training Large Language Models for Optimization Modeling
| 2024-05-28T01:55:35 | 2024-05-30T02:12:05 |
Zhengyang Tang, Chenyu Huang, Xin Zheng, Shixi Hu, Zizhuo Wang, Dongdong Ge, Benyou Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful tools for tackling
complex Operations Research (OR) problem by providing the capacity in
automating optimization modeling. However, current methodologies heavily rely
on prompt engineering (e.g., multi-agent cooperation) with proprietary LLMs,
raising data privacy concerns that could be prohibitive in industry
applications. To tackle this issue, we propose training open-source LLMs for
optimization modeling. We identify four critical requirements for the training
dataset of OR LLMs, design and implement OR-Instruct, a semi-automated process
for creating synthetic data tailored to specific requirements. We also
introduce the IndustryOR benchmark, the first industrial benchmark for testing
LLMs on solving real-world OR problems. We apply the data from OR-Instruct to
various open-source LLMs of 7b size (termed as ORLMs), resulting in a
significantly improved capability for optimization modeling. Our
best-performing ORLM achieves state-of-the-art performance on the NL4OPT, MAMO,
and IndustryOR benchmarks. Our code and data are available at
\url{https://github.com/Cardinal-Operations/ORLM}.
|
[
-0.09503287076950073,
-0.7806174755096436,
0.504642128944397,
0.057684075087308884,
0.08911392837762833,
-0.26332250237464905,
-0.39534345269203186,
-0.43947678804397583,
-0.46738389134407043,
0.8030108213424683,
-0.6612899899482727,
-0.6542788743972778,
-0.12193487584590912,
0.047844093292951584,
-0.37020343542099,
0.7144991755485535,
-0.23410791158676147,
0.5364187955856323,
-0.2553655505180359,
-0.20279742777347565,
-0.018311120569705963,
-0.7376518249511719,
-0.9506083726882935,
-0.23885492980480194,
0.23615363240242004,
0.2653641700744629,
0.3202969431877136,
0.8940522074699402,
0.4327393174171448,
0.3207918405532837,
0.14037856459617615,
0.402766615152359,
-0.9020728468894958,
0.19299620389938354,
-0.08005697280168533,
-0.42917588353157043,
-0.48874524235725403,
-0.12621276080608368,
0.654492974281311,
0.718396782875061,
-0.5308376550674438,
0.4912986755371094,
-0.1549399495124817,
0.5323171615600586,
-0.6054471135139465,
0.25187790393829346,
-0.8266571164131165,
0.13873088359832764,
-0.09865794330835342,
-0.17086608707904816,
-0.32608726620674133,
-0.7116068005561829,
-0.10704910010099411,
-0.5141327977180481,
0.07858334481716156,
0.4909793436527252,
0.40391412377357483,
0.48800161480903625,
-0.17068374156951904,
-0.3337193429470062,
-0.6471173763275146,
1.0014368295669556,
-0.8966878056526184,
0.6491196751594543,
-0.06620275974273682,
0.2647036015987396,
-0.3994516134262085,
-0.5128857493400574,
-0.2071840614080429,
-0.16692064702510834,
0.25217580795288086,
-0.14409036934375763,
0.30792292952537537,
0.21673482656478882,
0.4173697233200073,
0.29421067237854004,
-0.6165634989738464,
0.2955358624458313,
-0.3306010067462921,
0.08008772879838943,
0.6356307864189148,
0.5553726553916931,
-0.01877458579838276,
0.49932560324668884,
-0.45803722739219666,
-0.0004336535930633545,
-0.7387939691543579,
-0.059907216578722,
0.4341028034687042,
0.31549251079559326,
-0.09948857128620148,
0.7938941121101379,
-0.12335263192653656,
0.7487406730651855,
-0.5836440324783325,
-0.29793715476989746,
0.19559164345264435,
-0.15043237805366516,
-0.46430259943008423,
-0.11800134181976318,
0.7121973037719727,
0.0562673956155777,
0.14345917105674744,
-0.043386753648519516,
-0.6510791778564453,
-0.08140463382005692,
0.15316936373710632,
-0.7003800868988037,
0.01906292326748371,
0.11114704608917236,
-0.41488954424858093,
-0.23716653883457184,
-0.09971543401479721,
-0.6349846124649048,
-0.48748674988746643,
-0.6086623668670654,
0.2870838940143585,
-0.2684725224971771,
0.13626348972320557,
0.5269002914428711,
0.04006272554397583,
0.31926092505455017,
0.07649052888154984,
-0.8906731009483337,
0.15047603845596313,
0.6918987035751343,
0.5351192355155945,
-0.11694716662168503,
-0.36240169405937195,
-0.5927711129188538,
0.12751446664333344,
-0.5149800181388855,
0.26986387372016907,
-0.464307963848114,
-0.41303691267967224,
0.22916530072689056,
-0.3120444715023041,
-0.1333240121603012,
-0.620568573474884,
0.6512556672096252,
-0.62639981508255,
-0.021710969507694244,
0.23979464173316956,
-0.5222439169883728,
-0.040788426995277405,
0.2546122372150421,
-0.38300326466560364,
1.19730544090271,
0.11613770574331284,
-0.3047875165939331,
-0.018424151465296745,
-1.019456386566162,
-0.2532878816127777,
-0.12457434087991714,
-0.3152683973312378,
-0.6886830925941467,
0.24927179515361786,
0.050548255443573,
0.2600463926792145,
-0.6096488237380981,
0.1662302315235138,
-0.5282230973243713,
0.013762425631284714,
0.10528039187192917,
-0.21774214506149292,
0.8924644589424133,
0.27628931403160095,
-0.06154872477054596,
0.2966526746749878,
-0.8377408981323242,
0.014659016393125057,
0.3271676301956177,
-0.4636995196342468,
-0.10426265746355057,
0.20645692944526672,
-0.17801982164382935,
-0.14813411235809326,
0.5221266746520996,
-0.5746529698371887,
0.25351813435554504,
-0.4903286397457123,
0.8288328051567078,
0.6615390181541443,
-0.13702233135700226,
0.42672014236450195,
0.02690301649272442,
0.6870373487472534,
-0.7573151588439941,
0.7447222471237183,
0.13536183536052704,
-0.12144385278224945,
-0.919042706489563,
-0.18234778940677643,
-0.054553091526031494,
0.27005520462989807,
-0.622992992401123,
0.25898393988609314,
-0.03724229708313942,
-0.3839981257915497,
-0.48837217688560486,
0.2600402534008026,
0.36208078265190125,
0.5152640342712402,
0.19111070036888123,
0.022332679480314255,
-0.8391703963279724,
-0.8649259805679321,
-0.08352380245923996,
0.0691460371017456,
0.012186900712549686,
0.2545982301235199,
0.3537290096282959,
-0.07568295300006866,
1.0386391878128052,
-0.5932100415229797,
-0.5714399814605713,
-0.10942289978265762,
0.0015133748529478908,
0.14537259936332703,
0.2931367754936218,
0.3631766140460968,
-0.6306360363960266,
-0.40714290738105774,
0.0662725642323494,
-0.9716787338256836,
-0.1856125444173813,
0.4149356782436371,
-0.10959862172603607,
0.3743503987789154,
0.9271864295005798,
-0.31292253732681274,
0.007379925809800625,
0.840837836265564,
0.40041354298591614,
0.5740939378738403,
-0.30698561668395996,
-0.40420132875442505,
-0.6235014796257019,
0.18533237278461456,
-0.28792986273765564,
-0.3275061845779419,
-0.46719494462013245,
0.273316353559494,
-0.02442735619843006,
-0.6457552909851074,
-0.7285154461860657,
0.4922023415565491,
-0.6468070149421692,
-0.2962716817855835,
-0.033840104937553406,
-0.20773063600063324,
-0.21959269046783447,
0.44855427742004395,
0.1255035549402237,
0.9065956473350525,
0.685762882232666,
-0.3923231065273285,
0.2998464107513428,
0.1546027660369873,
-0.5102750062942505,
0.23327885568141937,
-0.5587104558944702,
0.38125964999198914,
-0.06348031759262085,
0.04024393856525421,
-0.5857091546058655,
-0.3301742970943451,
0.17837940156459808,
-0.15233534574508667,
0.142103374004364,
-0.02135179191827774,
-0.8753308653831482,
-0.24616646766662598,
-0.3288511037826538,
0.3391573131084442,
0.47826677560806274,
-0.6487701535224915,
0.8209121227264404,
0.40158259868621826,
0.06395602226257324,
-0.38932955265045166,
-0.40775710344314575,
-0.3248947560787201,
-0.31725189089775085,
-0.41390860080718994,
-0.07623348385095596,
-0.08226418495178223,
0.018547337502241135,
0.008378780446946621,
-0.05380266159772873,
0.043469060212373734,
0.11753278970718384,
0.029349923133850098,
0.30028465390205383,
-0.1488700956106186,
0.044052738696336746,
-0.19787201285362244,
-0.09421510994434357,
0.41463953256607056,
-0.6123582124710083,
0.614665150642395,
-0.08957783132791519,
-0.4670277237892151,
-0.027310388162732124,
0.16436684131622314,
0.4389318525791168,
-0.5291520357131958,
0.7588135600090027,
0.3309434950351715,
-0.18940149247646332,
-0.7141393423080444,
-0.519713819026947,
-0.14442294836044312,
-0.5404467582702637,
0.5488364696502686,
-0.028843749314546585,
-0.9131442308425903,
0.17908816039562225,
-0.24231299757957458,
0.5624713897705078,
-0.00971042737364769,
0.5691308975219727,
-0.005276446230709553,
1.2264176607131958,
0.7165014147758484,
-0.20289765298366547,
0.5299063920974731,
-0.32178977131843567,
0.20919102430343628,
-0.6511155962944031,
-0.2826870083808899,
-0.746882975101471,
-0.1862856149673462,
-0.13169008493423462,
-0.49835795164108276,
0.8563156127929688,
-0.037672605365514755,
-0.5473091006278992,
0.0625600814819336,
-0.3815292716026306,
0.6087024807929993,
0.46432867646217346,
-0.07118071615695953,
0.3152315616607666,
0.006986626889556646,
0.1440274715423584,
0.35039693117141724,
-0.9075117111206055,
-0.5022324919700623,
1.0590585470199585,
0.2709886133670807,
1.172451376914978,
-0.09440615773200989,
0.5843431353569031,
0.037934333086013794,
0.3450937569141388,
-0.602933943271637,
0.688859224319458,
-0.06060950830578804,
-0.6906470060348511,
-0.5273881554603577,
-0.6562713980674744,
-0.9916520714759827,
-0.0037615804467350245,
-0.01519845612347126,
-0.6644567847251892,
-0.07753334939479828,
0.27811869978904724,
-0.15585465729236603,
0.32525262236595154,
-0.6193255186080933,
0.8784611225128174,
-0.5970433354377747,
0.142281636595726,
0.018266569823026657,
-0.7247840762138367,
0.28471148014068604,
-0.2717779874801636,
0.4090278446674347,
-0.04597393795847893,
-0.5161307454109192,
0.4663766324520111,
-0.5802076458930969,
0.899878203868866,
-0.01192536111921072,
-0.13358965516090393,
0.031607531011104584,
-0.2509612441062927,
0.6736444234848022,
-0.21883970499038696,
-0.4277415871620178,
0.24221597611904144,
-0.4395112097263336,
-0.19518405199050903,
-0.5666955709457397,
0.6822617053985596,
-0.847954511642456,
-0.3387799561023712,
-0.056981317698955536,
-0.5862432718276978,
-0.25150391459465027,
0.2912091612815857,
0.23143698275089264,
0.4592593014240265,
-0.10417375713586807,
0.3725079596042633,
0.7089680433273315,
-0.2156384289264679,
0.21788883209228516,
0.5676152110099792,
-0.3068762421607971,
-0.40223684906959534,
0.8225384950637817,
-0.19452376663684845,
0.3899100422859192,
0.5042418241500854,
0.28681883215904236,
-0.49825766682624817,
-0.8674921989440918,
-0.3465978801250458,
0.26934507489204407,
-0.7537223100662231,
-0.3189593255519867,
-0.49997612833976746,
-0.3464233875274658,
-0.20191672444343567,
-0.20696397125720978,
-0.640602171421051,
0.0705351009964943,
-0.39483198523521423,
0.10620491951704025,
0.3186996877193451,
0.6714038848876953,
0.12812675535678864,
-0.013393205590546131,
-0.7044080495834351,
-0.027155375108122826,
0.025271551683545113,
0.49161869287490845,
0.1949702948331833,
-0.2387549728155136,
-0.5432943105697632,
-0.0625024363398552,
-0.22163470089435577,
-0.30954790115356445,
0.32414665818214417,
0.2605614960193634,
0.6243582963943481,
0.3585720360279083,
0.3285766839981079,
0.3088085353374481,
-0.6176976561546326,
0.5665842890739441,
0.03897613286972046,
-0.8854333162307739,
0.27128565311431885,
-0.39086616039276123,
-0.016841711476445198,
0.5348024368286133,
0.47946232557296753,
-0.042855992913246155,
-0.40301981568336487,
-0.33434608578681946,
-0.852443277835846,
1.0672169923782349,
0.14071400463581085,
0.11293771862983704,
0.23460015654563904,
0.24253258109092712,
0.27601587772369385,
0.5807726979255676,
-0.618849515914917,
-0.35668128728866577,
0.2856062352657318,
-0.015521392226219177,
-0.15791572630405426,
-0.08981303125619888,
-0.07350484281778336,
0.08799628168344498,
0.9569683074951172,
0.09044728428125381,
0.004007226787507534,
-0.0959767997264862,
0.04931765794754028,
-0.18430671095848083,
-0.049692653119564056,
0.618406355381012,
0.5811741352081299,
-0.3958805501461029,
-0.13567620515823364,
0.22890129685401917,
-0.1130581796169281,
0.09324522316455841,
-0.06178314611315727,
-0.19488473236560822,
-0.21706141531467438,
0.1407955139875412,
0.7304824590682983,
-0.021699583157896996,
-0.9677222967147827,
0.05348902568221092,
0.19540205597877502,
-0.3220002055168152,
-0.44413936138153076,
0.18749144673347473,
0.09203919023275375,
0.3126153349876404,
0.12298105657100677,
-0.18641670048236847,
0.2835870683193207,
-0.4434317946434021,
-0.3974933624267578,
0.49298372864723206,
-0.05490705370903015,
0.004162347875535488,
0.7750620245933533,
0.2496209591627121,
-0.5515393614768982,
0.48559316992759705,
-0.03324511647224426,
-0.6116893887519836,
0.4242398142814636,
0.2052091509103775,
0.6345905661582947,
-0.18931615352630615,
-0.32602524757385254,
0.15265126526355743,
0.37913501262664795,
-0.23601186275482178,
0.33781108260154724,
0.32256796956062317,
-0.5069679617881775,
-0.48217254877090454,
-0.736953854560852,
-0.6554029583930969,
0.5703303813934326,
-0.5923795700073242,
0.5362322926521301,
-0.4705447852611542,
0.0011027856962755322,
-0.22547350823879242,
-0.2414822280406952,
-0.47938427329063416,
0.024132559075951576,
0.007241390645503998,
0.7975207567214966,
-0.5333421230316162,
0.7555492520332336,
0.7805085182189941,
-0.13369818031787872,
-0.8948649168014526,
-0.5447863340377808,
0.02917555905878544,
-0.9362624287605286,
0.5496830940246582,
-0.06165911257266998,
-0.17272107303142548,
0.40483179688453674,
-0.6616657376289368,
-0.7826637029647827,
0.799938976764679,
0.7759441137313843,
-0.5721641778945923,
-0.08205104619264603,
0.43369096517562866,
0.492236852645874,
-0.5513419508934021,
0.03245241194963455,
0.4383428394794464,
0.25814253091812134,
-0.200935497879982,
-0.7036564946174622,
-0.26476699113845825,
0.11897215247154236,
0.25797000527381897,
0.6205390095710754,
-0.668401300907135,
0.7920670509338379,
0.058559954166412354,
-0.02494049444794655,
0.43741142749786377,
0.4283570349216461,
0.3060694634914398,
0.2614426910877228,
0.5072760581970215,
0.4469672739505768,
0.42572256922721863,
0.2440861463546753,
1.237896203994751,
-0.29614126682281494,
0.6721302270889282,
1.2779713869094849,
-0.48989295959472656,
0.914652407169342,
0.35469043254852295,
-0.09801924228668213,
-0.06463099271059036,
0.5664675235748291,
-0.13762246072292328,
0.44790101051330566,
0.4469720721244812,
-0.01791214570403099,
-0.16295042634010315,
-0.22638359665870667,
-0.37981733679771423,
0.22099782526493073,
0.2784365117549896,
-0.39554306864738464,
-0.3931385576725006,
0.10413699597120285,
-0.24030984938144684,
0.04520092159509659,
-0.22002539038658142,
0.7672111392021179,
0.22758588194847107,
-0.3726629614830017,
0.7872010469436646,
0.07474788278341293,
0.2995612621307373,
-0.8683750629425049,
-0.010805323719978333,
-0.18498611450195312,
0.2561355233192444,
-0.06766350567340851,
-0.28013235330581665,
0.21931463479995728,
-0.03566582128405571,
-0.05382474139332771,
-0.3875311315059662,
0.4808967113494873,
-0.5993943810462952,
-0.337044894695282,
0.3669944107532501,
0.14543022215366364,
0.3755403757095337,
0.11466845870018005,
-0.747401773929596,
0.49331721663475037,
-0.043401043862104416,
-0.12497252970933914,
0.3861474096775055,
0.41915303468704224,
-0.012524785473942757,
0.870448648929596,
0.7905915975570679,
0.22923485934734344,
0.16061660647392273,
0.18674539029598236,
0.8690935373306274,
-0.10052704066038132,
-0.2487272471189499,
-0.8425827026367188,
0.21388736367225647,
-0.005425491835922003,
-0.1074041798710823,
0.7145872116088867,
0.9202196598052979,
1.0894049406051636,
-0.3885727524757385,
0.7358548641204834,
0.19567717611789703,
0.5137208700180054,
-0.8033415079116821,
0.5870032906532288,
-0.7866610288619995,
0.36903318762779236,
0.20204010605812073,
-1.3474020957946777,
-0.18439632654190063,
0.3738129138946533,
-0.3476022779941559,
-0.01634054258465767,
0.5445154309272766,
1.0030827522277832,
-0.19227555394172668,
0.010500207543373108,
0.35734373331069946,
0.17364218831062317,
0.36661839485168457,
0.5449420213699341,
0.9468129873275757,
-0.01457949262112379,
0.7625309824943542,
-0.1431259661912918,
-0.18454670906066895,
-0.4618736207485199,
-1.137678861618042,
-1.067909598350525,
-0.1433054506778717,
-0.16399812698364258,
0.006152050569653511,
0.13657943904399872,
1.1401885747909546,
0.8235824704170227,
-0.5387392044067383,
-0.7656530737876892,
-0.353300541639328,
-0.1854407787322998,
-0.07288665324449539,
-0.11844506859779358,
0.2447943538427353,
-0.5245879888534546,
-0.9004932045936584,
0.5767579078674316,
0.33159056305885315,
-0.05944309011101723,
-0.6176298260688782,
-0.1513962596654892,
0.11782736331224442,
0.12618200480937958,
0.48872074484825134,
0.36711642146110535,
-0.5988690853118896,
0.045783743262290955,
-0.04858095571398735,
-0.057182181626558304,
-0.06467212736606598,
0.9516892433166504,
-0.07891996949911118,
0.4773158133029938,
0.3405001163482666,
0.9211390614509583,
0.45859822630882263,
0.008476966060698032,
0.7359091639518738,
-0.7957758903503418,
0.08210918307304382,
0.44070717692375183,
0.3329671621322632,
0.24463757872581482,
-0.2303844839334488,
0.8359631896018982,
-0.06670957803726196,
-0.700172483921051,
-1.0068833827972412,
0.13608808815479279,
-0.7650084495544434,
0.01741953194141388,
1.1642717123031616,
-0.0945497676730156,
-0.24694384634494781,
-0.04814235493540764,
-0.20007595419883728,
-0.025214916095137596,
-0.6503089070320129,
0.512578010559082,
0.3693287670612335,
-0.05174558609724045,
0.05662473663687706,
-0.5678898692131042,
0.36586618423461914,
0.2681773006916046,
-0.9330840110778809,
0.1987888216972351,
0.27746719121932983,
0.023186830803751945,
-0.15092653036117554,
0.36758553981781006,
-0.0332849957048893,
-0.05459625646471977,
-0.14498674869537354,
0.36421075463294983,
-0.5479598045349121,
-0.15511120855808258,
-0.24622099101543427,
0.14239788055419922,
0.2753468453884125,
-0.2439158409833908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17740v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17740v1
|
MobileConvRec: A Conversational Dataset for Mobile Apps Recommendations
| 2024-05-28T01:53:16 | 2024-05-28T01:53:16 |
Srijata Maji, Moghis Fereidouni, Vinaik Chhetri, Umar Farooq, A. B. Siddique
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Existing recommendation systems have focused on two paradigms: 1- historical
user-item interaction-based recommendations and 2- conversational
recommendations. Conversational recommendation systems facilitate natural
language dialogues between users and the system, allowing the system to solicit
users' explicit needs while enabling users to inquire about recommendations and
provide feedback. Due to substantial advancements in natural language
processing, conversational recommendation systems have gained prominence.
Existing conversational recommendation datasets have greatly facilitated
research in their respective domains. Despite the exponential growth in mobile
users and apps in recent years, research in conversational mobile app
recommender systems has faced substantial constraints. This limitation can
primarily be attributed to the lack of high-quality benchmark datasets
specifically tailored for mobile apps. To facilitate research for
conversational mobile app recommendations, we introduce MobileConvRec.
MobileConvRec simulates conversations by leveraging real user interactions with
mobile apps on the Google Play store, originally captured in large-scale mobile
app recommendation dataset MobileRec. The proposed conversational
recommendation dataset synergizes sequential user-item interactions, which
reflect implicit user preferences, with comprehensive multi-turn conversations
to effectively grasp explicit user needs. MobileConvRec consists of over 12K
multi-turn recommendation-related conversations spanning 45 app categories.
Moreover, MobileConvRec presents rich metadata for each app such as permissions
data, security and privacy-related information, and binary executables of apps,
among others. We demonstrate that MobileConvRec can serve as an excellent
testbed for conversational mobile app recommendation through a comparative
study of several pre-trained large language models.
|
[
-0.5065045356750488,
-0.5287688374519348,
0.07791627943515778,
0.29133012890815735,
-0.20795853435993195,
0.032389260828495026,
-0.12868474423885345,
-0.3838333487510681,
0.28170958161354065,
0.502110481262207,
-0.7176093459129333,
-0.562186598777771,
0.24717813730239868,
-0.36708906292915344,
-0.30726638436317444,
1.0281367301940918,
0.20538045465946198,
-0.03511376306414604,
-0.6154361367225647,
-0.38304638862609863,
-0.9423518776893616,
-0.41257399320602417,
-0.5718334913253784,
-0.3422754108905792,
0.3640483021736145,
0.879411518573761,
0.7920564413070679,
0.1315813660621643,
0.1942405253648758,
0.15601173043251038,
0.2677612900733948,
0.39719271659851074,
-0.6721832156181335,
0.35057514905929565,
0.04023253172636032,
-0.13450153172016144,
-0.13088184595108032,
0.08581313490867615,
-0.012658078223466873,
0.3964289426803589,
-0.6879963874816895,
0.15029633045196533,
-0.10208781808614731,
0.7525367140769958,
-0.6882730722427368,
0.14977958798408508,
-0.6142213940620422,
-0.11090801656246185,
0.11969585716724396,
-0.07978324592113495,
-0.356248140335083,
-0.5634456276893616,
0.37814861536026,
-0.40610218048095703,
0.13656039535999298,
0.12164720892906189,
0.5987381339073181,
-0.1310688704252243,
-0.6860700845718384,
-0.5143553614616394,
-0.9882189631462097,
0.6164808869361877,
-0.3564159870147705,
0.577399492263794,
0.587807834148407,
0.4122544527053833,
-0.38254696130752563,
-0.5980987548828125,
-0.49917009472846985,
-0.7361524105072021,
-0.01990804448723793,
0.01637936197221279,
-0.04673098027706146,
-0.18285439908504486,
0.009164601564407349,
0.2570676803588867,
-0.7431365251541138,
-0.35244059562683105,
-0.3215785324573517,
-0.21504996716976166,
0.7893557548522949,
0.35877183079719543,
0.20253972709178925,
0.20808973908424377,
-0.44441309571266174,
-0.15244390070438385,
-0.8041702508926392,
0.5765272974967957,
0.22517022490501404,
0.14794425666332245,
-0.2276657074689865,
0.5860288739204407,
-0.4221685230731964,
0.9343008995056152,
0.023627130314707756,
0.008765685372054577,
0.239999920129776,
-0.723831295967102,
-0.020471051335334778,
0.3173508942127228,
0.9082369804382324,
0.9158226251602173,
0.48669081926345825,
-0.18327732384204865,
0.25112950801849365,
0.22150613367557526,
0.5068281292915344,
-0.9760740399360657,
-0.34062546491622925,
0.3144102096557617,
-0.41825026273727417,
-0.4180591106414795,
0.053423985838890076,
-0.5206929445266724,
-0.6208809018135071,
-0.1934453397989273,
-0.04385756328701973,
-0.22648616135120392,
0.055725909769535065,
0.15571704506874084,
0.15912465751171112,
0.02451208047568798,
0.015568936243653297,
-1.0850746631622314,
0.4936067461967468,
0.4077009856700897,
0.7257868647575378,
-0.13633094727993011,
-0.15249286592006683,
-0.550152063369751,
-0.030298249796032906,
-0.24386855959892273,
0.6955742239952087,
-1.055390477180481,
-0.8675114512443542,
0.17566926777362823,
0.12177009880542755,
-0.0005048554739914834,
-0.6370802521705627,
0.9497632384300232,
-0.4252759516239166,
-0.14598920941352844,
-0.07791124284267426,
-0.4207113981246948,
-0.3062913715839386,
0.3179554343223572,
-0.3942812383174896,
0.9612225890159607,
-0.16756758093833923,
-0.48234787583351135,
0.4668048620223999,
-0.34402331709861755,
-0.7054597735404968,
0.09345705807209015,
-0.13316383957862854,
-0.12511499226093292,
-0.2346012443304062,
0.16274388134479523,
0.5751791596412659,
-0.4369503855705261,
0.328809529542923,
-0.5899682641029358,
-0.4138423502445221,
0.3126145601272583,
-0.13508708775043488,
0.3626246154308319,
0.41774603724479675,
-0.1974024474620819,
0.12721192836761475,
-0.7364961504936218,
0.25054314732551575,
-0.30279067158699036,
-0.03877415135502815,
-0.5794529318809509,
0.1881588250398636,
-0.022786438465118408,
0.1710258573293686,
0.06818722933530807,
-0.6312283873558044,
0.14237870275974274,
-0.11758308857679367,
0.5520007014274597,
0.12275151163339615,
0.06769263744354248,
0.6975454688072205,
-0.2157348096370697,
0.40863093733787537,
0.0004090022703167051,
0.24961523711681366,
-0.48336488008499146,
-0.34725040197372437,
-0.46085429191589355,
0.07453938573598862,
0.44937536120414734,
0.7219312787055969,
-0.6225859522819519,
0.135842427611351,
-0.25459763407707214,
-0.7489684820175171,
-0.24945488572120667,
0.0426592193543911,
0.3430180549621582,
0.4115421772003174,
-0.023970259353518486,
-0.302944153547287,
-0.6021742820739746,
-0.8162255883216858,
-0.3399365544319153,
-0.3516773283481598,
-0.0011462363181635737,
1.090111255645752,
0.14838731288909912,
-0.37890905141830444,
1.0391935110092163,
-0.42828887701034546,
-0.2810373306274414,
0.010797782801091671,
-0.03502201288938522,
0.24483463168144226,
0.2162119299173355,
0.2987191081047058,
-0.8846299648284912,
-0.5151886940002441,
-0.016773834824562073,
-0.37357303500175476,
-0.002761662704870105,
-0.20518673956394196,
-0.15028510987758636,
-0.26186972856521606,
0.4793829321861267,
-0.7445236444473267,
0.29726338386535645,
0.8462589383125305,
-0.4657260477542877,
0.4806877076625824,
-0.25867539644241333,
0.3567899465560913,
-0.9277366399765015,
-0.021545730531215668,
0.14543531835079193,
-0.14818523824214935,
-0.6642546653747559,
-0.5636652112007141,
-0.0003667261335067451,
-0.28172236680984497,
-0.27577880024909973,
0.8752427101135254,
0.09781699627637863,
0.34763097763061523,
0.00032872098381631076,
-0.11585972458124161,
-0.12557947635650635,
0.14812840521335602,
0.01283523440361023,
0.8880734443664551,
0.25594979524612427,
-0.7389205694198608,
0.5587011575698853,
0.587912380695343,
-0.40717920660972595,
0.6786295771598816,
-0.8577978014945984,
0.06050971522927284,
0.2052125334739685,
0.6579104065895081,
-1.0780645608901978,
-0.035299286246299744,
0.2357177585363388,
-0.2872023284435272,
-0.6989156603813171,
-0.2900174856185913,
-0.10325650870800018,
-0.17524220049381256,
-0.2609746754169464,
0.2910073697566986,
0.3157019019126892,
-0.567593514919281,
0.6202250719070435,
0.6104746460914612,
-0.25183579325675964,
-0.33993595838546753,
-0.15940622985363007,
0.0769982561469078,
-0.03981614485383034,
-0.7982947826385498,
0.3098992705345154,
-0.24087004363536835,
-0.20197142660617828,
-0.28009939193725586,
0.174910768866539,
-0.09491361677646637,
-0.38435226678848267,
1.050982117652893,
0.32564738392829895,
0.07953377068042755,
0.4255373179912567,
-0.23279520869255066,
-0.04990960285067558,
-0.17480069398880005,
-0.23784424364566803,
0.5252927541732788,
-0.17972834408283234,
-0.11715530604124069,
-0.3826134204864502,
0.15423108637332916,
0.7525962591171265,
-0.106922946870327,
0.47442856431007385,
0.5493012070655823,
0.06995058804750443,
0.0821269154548645,
-0.6831122040748596,
-0.26664188504219055,
-0.49153584241867065,
-0.0013868390815332532,
-0.5176064372062683,
-0.8160651922225952,
0.3855704367160797,
-0.19577160477638245,
0.0795353427529335,
-0.16492174565792084,
0.7088556289672852,
-0.1410847157239914,
1.0725499391555786,
0.1602604240179062,
-0.2981759309768677,
0.5832037925720215,
-0.06463857740163803,
0.20025713741779327,
-0.5208703279495239,
-0.5813989043235779,
-0.4719444215297699,
-0.15928702056407928,
-0.6738959550857544,
-0.2382434755563736,
0.016627002507448196,
-0.08216328918933868,
-0.2598831355571747,
0.3894004821777344,
-0.2501407563686371,
0.3235453963279724,
0.6074945330619812,
0.26225724816322327,
0.09356456249952316,
0.14310921728610992,
-0.16036273539066315,
-0.010706757195293903,
-0.6093084216117859,
-0.4340393543243408,
0.9841120839118958,
0.09116090834140778,
1.0981035232543945,
-0.18051937222480774,
0.1941261738538742,
0.5857698917388916,
0.046484388411045074,
-0.9407833814620972,
0.5161168575286865,
-0.24111786484718323,
-0.4940390884876251,
-0.031113000586628914,
-0.25114598870277405,
-0.9893895983695984,
0.12153807282447815,
-0.37651723623275757,
-0.5477750301361084,
0.3799077570438385,
0.30366238951683044,
-0.44091910123825073,
-0.20018762350082397,
-0.9990177154541016,
0.9889553785324097,
-0.06882510334253311,
-0.5645065903663635,
-0.23669014871120453,
-0.35272395610809326,
0.1324995458126068,
0.3554159998893738,
0.2373652160167694,
-0.1975669413805008,
0.4945184886455536,
0.3956528604030609,
-0.36886799335479736,
0.5932373404502869,
-0.27747172117233276,
-0.07049493491649628,
0.5977057814598083,
0.4204935133457184,
0.9698280096054077,
0.45090633630752563,
-0.020973140373826027,
-0.047246575355529785,
0.13896159827709198,
-0.11043231934309006,
-0.4269987642765045,
0.950401246547699,
-0.2930840849876404,
-0.0819113627076149,
-0.21533165872097015,
-0.29914993047714233,
-0.5020171999931335,
0.004496604669839144,
0.02479696460068226,
0.5286989808082581,
-0.7035442590713501,
0.45447272062301636,
0.4221633970737457,
-0.07183073461055756,
0.15034717321395874,
0.46734005212783813,
-0.19472429156303406,
-0.2853112816810608,
1.0949674844741821,
-0.29691433906555176,
-0.29017770290374756,
0.03875738009810448,
0.11702412366867065,
-0.5392583012580872,
-0.37079349160194397,
-0.4840148389339447,
-0.2495207041501999,
-0.09470965713262558,
0.09016527235507965,
-0.6286218166351318,
0.09866758435964584,
-0.019574545323848724,
-0.007658814545720816,
-0.4023815989494324,
-0.13123628497123718,
-0.11685426533222198,
-0.0198170505464077,
0.409931480884552,
0.49625492095947266,
0.1919250637292862,
0.24522261321544647,
-1.000666856765747,
0.46555784344673157,
0.6823747754096985,
0.3822098970413208,
-0.05908205360174179,
-0.1941462755203247,
-0.33907854557037354,
0.4356670081615448,
-0.07541368156671524,
-0.20956648886203766,
0.37324967980384827,
0.2927725315093994,
0.35572054982185364,
0.561786949634552,
0.23290856182575226,
0.5162558555603027,
-0.6586957573890686,
0.884133517742157,
0.36656731367111206,
-0.47236379981040955,
0.24270941317081451,
-0.479413777589798,
0.16781829297542572,
0.8267440795898438,
0.26292017102241516,
-0.9137524366378784,
0.3445710241794586,
-0.45389121770858765,
-0.7309843301773071,
0.31012028455734253,
0.22926650941371918,
0.4763537049293518,
0.16470389068126678,
0.2632802426815033,
0.27278706431388855,
0.28769031167030334,
-0.0945497527718544,
-0.07854149490594864,
-0.2502550482749939,
-0.23235934972763062,
-0.3535744249820709,
-0.487253874540329,
-0.3031214475631714,
-0.24876965582370758,
0.5099813342094421,
0.04853980988264084,
-0.00569021375849843,
-0.019056279212236404,
0.046342432498931885,
0.3885970413684845,
0.16523143649101257,
0.6208450198173523,
0.4999607503414154,
-0.3835081458091736,
0.06620219349861145,
0.11678541451692581,
-0.7842761278152466,
0.3140614330768585,
0.020283374935388565,
0.06358002871274948,
-0.055225975811481476,
-0.33607473969459534,
0.931013286113739,
0.15623383224010468,
-0.8974705934524536,
0.4617891013622284,
-0.6102269291877747,
-0.07406020164489746,
-0.39498892426490784,
0.16536246240139008,
0.1866811364889145,
0.12334353476762772,
0.20542876422405243,
0.1249193623661995,
0.3829593360424042,
-0.5889252424240112,
0.32176095247268677,
0.5064595341682434,
-0.8820697069168091,
-0.22132021188735962,
0.1673005074262619,
0.7800469994544983,
-0.3057292699813843,
0.546222448348999,
0.030346935614943504,
-0.11209413409233093,
0.3008345067501068,
0.20440788567066193,
0.6687745451927185,
-0.2195635885000229,
0.6345133185386658,
0.4366682767868042,
-0.11435733735561371,
-0.20272870361804962,
0.06215379387140274,
-0.32630833983421326,
-0.7643347382545471,
-0.02697809785604477,
-0.3162747025489807,
-0.6868597269058228,
0.0404944010078907,
-0.40541672706604004,
0.2636866867542267,
-0.15604792535305023,
-0.3330916464328766,
0.050696976482868195,
-0.07290362566709518,
-0.4313097596168518,
0.23267798125743866,
0.010411783121526241,
0.7015319466590881,
-0.587227463722229,
0.639098584651947,
0.6755611300468445,
0.1709459275007248,
-0.545511782169342,
-0.23364341259002686,
-0.24418920278549194,
-0.26123589277267456,
0.4186045229434967,
-0.037386465817689896,
-0.47388237714767456,
-0.2439243644475937,
-0.6422869563102722,
-0.2740483283996582,
0.7189317345619202,
0.14031463861465454,
-0.6416403651237488,
0.5348363518714905,
0.253340482711792,
0.43223801255226135,
-0.6847037076950073,
0.37358635663986206,
0.557546079158783,
0.19558489322662354,
0.4723370373249054,
-0.8365352153778076,
0.03977341949939728,
-0.4715544581413269,
0.09823380410671234,
0.046722542494535446,
-0.670258641242981,
0.48233628273010254,
-0.27114972472190857,
0.06936571002006531,
-0.06086796149611473,
0.20328274369239807,
0.4250544309616089,
0.54048091173172,
0.5349459648132324,
0.25098225474357605,
0.5458139777183533,
0.11394167691469193,
0.9633751511573792,
-0.2521183490753174,
0.145186647772789,
1.3564655780792236,
-0.7019472122192383,
0.9034543037414551,
0.4860164523124695,
-0.16001346707344055,
0.6696909070014954,
0.9317212104797363,
0.02262199856340885,
0.7932328581809998,
0.3046077787876129,
-0.5363569259643555,
-0.228037491440773,
-0.45305728912353516,
-0.4784916341304779,
0.4717073440551758,
0.32458969950675964,
-0.05372675135731697,
0.1329711675643921,
0.020039396360516548,
-0.20192517340183258,
-0.2452738732099533,
-0.048936497420072556,
0.8266982436180115,
0.06685305386781693,
-0.5853723287582397,
0.740439236164093,
-0.15406565368175507,
0.6401442289352417,
-0.5607779622077942,
-0.3172368109226227,
-0.2915228605270386,
0.2076863944530487,
-0.35510507225990295,
-0.5934679508209229,
-0.15527589619159698,
-0.23592478036880493,
-0.4409539997577667,
0.06716616451740265,
0.9424341917037964,
-0.5031933784484863,
-0.22120755910873413,
0.017551792785525322,
0.18750005960464478,
0.10232149064540863,
-0.36360612511634827,
-0.6121813058853149,
-0.054993849247694016,
0.03768736869096756,
-0.036587439477443695,
0.1392197459936142,
0.12365183234214783,
-0.15256252884864807,
0.9668458700180054,
0.9759390950202942,
-0.20072826743125916,
-0.18852688372135162,
-0.0034608368296176195,
0.7135095000267029,
-0.6356337070465088,
-0.6764686107635498,
-0.601952314376831,
0.3862905502319336,
-0.16369856894016266,
-0.39412495493888855,
0.6973935961723328,
0.7930132150650024,
0.5510566234588623,
-0.17918661236763,
0.7971517443656921,
-0.14468573033809662,
0.41001203656196594,
-0.2672678232192993,
0.6600297093391418,
-0.19688266515731812,
0.33721888065338135,
0.10786376893520355,
-0.8711363673210144,
0.11630304157733917,
0.49955058097839355,
-0.26525160670280457,
0.087438203394413,
0.35313379764556885,
0.8905777335166931,
-0.2702188491821289,
0.41178250312805176,
0.16413603723049164,
-0.0746661126613617,
0.1623566895723343,
0.4660969078540802,
0.9895952343940735,
-0.5062676668167114,
0.8126958012580872,
-0.021396923810243607,
0.05183729529380798,
-0.5159100294113159,
-0.7409222722053528,
-0.9716089963912964,
-0.6696702241897583,
-0.05957316234707832,
-0.5449594259262085,
0.4116429388523102,
0.9603837728500366,
1.0533987283706665,
-1.0389328002929688,
-0.6219463348388672,
-0.18290214240550995,
-0.043862875550985336,
-0.06266537308692932,
-0.21042032539844513,
0.10227861255407333,
0.23900344967842102,
-0.36671552062034607,
0.620353639125824,
-0.009719847701489925,
0.07141268998384476,
0.07426011562347412,
-0.3740200102329254,
-0.07240297645330429,
0.010121583938598633,
0.7748889923095703,
0.4552190601825714,
-0.12023276090621948,
0.03355872631072998,
-0.11166160553693771,
-0.2448110282421112,
0.024294568225741386,
1.1675083637237549,
-1.1354689598083496,
0.659665584564209,
0.26546189188957214,
0.2680242657661438,
0.857523500919342,
0.14598166942596436,
0.7754711508750916,
-0.5746672749519348,
0.3898047208786011,
0.09883669018745422,
-0.3320808708667755,
0.06597534567117691,
-0.222096249461174,
0.5331441760063171,
-0.12048809230327606,
-0.4030835032463074,
-0.7850125432014465,
0.060300201177597046,
-0.8693791627883911,
0.028763365000486374,
1.2198657989501953,
-0.13183313608169556,
0.13521698117256165,
-0.4524441063404083,
-0.7157848477363586,
-0.25168654322624207,
-1.0166082382202148,
0.6007583737373352,
0.6974363923072815,
-0.22101950645446777,
-0.07134885340929031,
-0.7290810346603394,
0.598559558391571,
0.12589451670646667,
-0.6931257843971252,
0.38970884680747986,
0.3089110851287842,
0.15063180029392242,
-0.14825424551963806,
0.5538463592529297,
0.1719537079334259,
0.10612346231937408,
-0.049410123378038406,
0.032991815358400345,
-0.03338129073381424,
-0.14002157747745514,
0.011788345873355865,
0.18946871161460876,
-0.31683415174484253,
-0.41274818778038025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17732v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17732v2
|
C$^{3}$Bench: A Comprehensive Classical Chinese Understanding Benchmark for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-28T01:23:58 | 2024-05-30T11:32:05 |
Jiahuan Cao, Yongxin Shi, Dezhi Peng, Yang Liu, Lianwen Jin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Classical Chinese Understanding (CCU) holds significant value in preserving
and exploration of the outstanding traditional Chinese culture. Recently,
researchers have attempted to leverage the potential of Large Language Models
(LLMs) for CCU by capitalizing on their remarkable comprehension and semantic
capabilities. However, no comprehensive benchmark is available to assess the
CCU capabilities of LLMs. To fill this gap, this paper introduces C$^{3}$bench,
a Comprehensive Classical Chinese understanding benchmark, which comprises
50,000 text pairs for five primary CCU tasks, including classification,
retrieval, named entity recognition, punctuation, and translation. Furthermore,
the data in C$^{3}$bench originates from ten different domains, covering most
of the categories in classical Chinese. Leveraging the proposed C$^{3}$bench,
we extensively evaluate the quantitative performance of 15 representative LLMs
on all five CCU tasks. Our results not only establish a public leaderboard of
LLMs' CCU capabilities but also gain some findings. Specifically, existing LLMs
are struggle with CCU tasks and still inferior to supervised models.
Additionally, the results indicate that CCU is a task that requires special
attention. We believe this study could provide a standard benchmark,
comprehensive baselines, and valuable insights for the future advancement of
LLM-based CCU research. The evaluation pipeline and dataset are available at
\url{https://github.com/SCUT-DLVCLab/C3bench}.
|
[
-0.1724691241979599,
-0.7070989608764648,
0.8210349082946777,
0.4239652752876282,
-0.328478068113327,
-0.09023252129554749,
-0.6898841857910156,
-0.5212400555610657,
-0.42011696100234985,
0.3266918659210205,
-0.15290583670139313,
-0.6035768389701843,
-0.34402263164520264,
-0.13140363991260529,
-0.40099042654037476,
0.3642329275608063,
-0.11809548735618591,
0.4888859987258911,
-0.0870148316025734,
-0.16131238639354706,
-0.41173774003982544,
-0.3851653039455414,
-0.6769771575927734,
-0.31460970640182495,
0.4582102596759796,
0.4379914700984955,
0.4514835774898529,
0.8301419615745544,
0.4896174669265747,
0.21118779480457306,
-0.10520300269126892,
0.06652404367923737,
-0.6295210123062134,
-0.2902328372001648,
-0.05709297955036163,
-0.5139560103416443,
-0.5153972506523132,
0.027178896591067314,
0.9889110922813416,
0.820857584476471,
-0.07250674068927765,
-0.04220399260520935,
0.42324644327163696,
0.7167425155639648,
-0.8570777773857117,
0.33116480708122253,
-0.6784451603889465,
-0.03752688691020012,
-0.5777168273925781,
0.029289383441209793,
-0.6318237781524658,
-0.14265508949756622,
-0.021403534337878227,
-0.854852557182312,
0.31138214468955994,
0.0033073388040065765,
0.6460936665534973,
-0.014611396938562393,
-0.42567211389541626,
0.22175255417823792,
-0.370988130569458,
0.8265382051467896,
-0.7816433906555176,
0.4265570044517517,
0.3243160843849182,
0.5734754800796509,
-0.07100804895162582,
-0.7870063781738281,
-0.6537909507751465,
-0.356035441160202,
-0.10019581019878387,
0.3748108446598053,
0.04863815754652023,
0.08098629862070084,
0.1852228045463562,
0.7193861603736877,
-0.6463125348091125,
0.32138293981552124,
0.004447381943464279,
0.18517525494098663,
0.4851817786693573,
0.3176276385784149,
0.2603142261505127,
-0.05275333300232887,
-0.34605908393859863,
-0.20085006952285767,
-0.7017300724983215,
0.21489904820919037,
-0.14807504415512085,
0.23384350538253784,
-0.22462521493434906,
0.2275913655757904,
-0.23557133972644806,
0.9661298990249634,
-0.1450897455215454,
-0.0789484903216362,
-0.059032127261161804,
-0.47721409797668457,
-0.4257493019104004,
-0.08026201277971268,
0.8509462475776672,
0.13113702833652496,
0.11039773374795914,
-0.18041753768920898,
-0.05086282268166542,
-0.2504735291004181,
-0.0863935574889183,
-0.6906527280807495,
-0.2833751440048218,
0.05626896768808365,
-0.5036555528640747,
-0.012183812446892262,
0.15658417344093323,
-0.2767177224159241,
-0.6161007881164551,
-0.45782941579818726,
-0.26403576135635376,
-0.6431092023849487,
-0.2804587483406067,
0.02262616902589798,
0.17147736251354218,
0.7494854927062988,
0.4190307557582855,
-0.8984678387641907,
0.5051813721656799,
0.9644456505775452,
0.831579327583313,
-0.5206882953643799,
-0.33929821848869324,
-0.44110608100891113,
0.24092739820480347,
-0.3725258708000183,
0.6327438950538635,
-0.3297485113143921,
-0.34950122237205505,
0.055210523307323456,
0.1916864812374115,
-0.17302246391773224,
-0.5554486513137817,
0.7838607430458069,
-0.282540500164032,
-0.3908298909664154,
-0.5135720372200012,
-0.32936233282089233,
-0.2455025017261505,
0.40387776494026184,
-0.7796632647514343,
0.7287929654121399,
-0.13288700580596924,
-0.586169421672821,
0.07893569022417068,
-0.20597848296165466,
-0.32700130343437195,
0.3549145460128784,
-0.1976977437734604,
-0.15536516904830933,
0.019280115142464638,
0.30582311749458313,
0.5372656583786011,
-0.7131795883178711,
0.3908919394016266,
-0.7975950241088867,
-0.6690049767494202,
0.4499892294406891,
-0.3254939317703247,
0.7689110636711121,
0.23997706174850464,
-0.3435615003108978,
-0.07156374305486679,
-0.629418671131134,
-0.011632325127720833,
0.02324032410979271,
-0.0448855459690094,
-0.293073832988739,
0.2430620789527893,
0.3963977098464966,
-0.12380748242139816,
0.33844271302223206,
-0.31258678436279297,
-0.020977795124053955,
-0.21547375619411469,
0.43282550573349,
0.7347293496131897,
-0.337912380695343,
0.2835191488265991,
-0.184549942612648,
0.1511608213186264,
-0.14200885593891144,
-0.001068583456799388,
-0.009575583972036839,
0.11463084071874619,
-0.8248243927955627,
-0.3746817708015442,
0.19344966113567352,
0.3794974088668823,
-0.6621938347816467,
0.11010966449975967,
-0.36654895544052124,
-0.6413328051567078,
-0.27989673614501953,
0.1529083400964737,
0.4184149205684662,
0.16835568845272064,
0.4483058452606201,
-0.06040026247501373,
-0.14490075409412384,
-0.9035736918449402,
-0.4426177144050598,
-0.09844215959310532,
-0.15066803991794586,
0.5723527669906616,
0.1549079418182373,
0.24999749660491943,
0.5268285870552063,
-0.37000155448913574,
-0.21707157790660858,
-0.3913135826587677,
0.09982320666313171,
0.2927519977092743,
0.4411180913448334,
0.43270865082740784,
-0.7466071844100952,
-0.5117046236991882,
0.4072194993495941,
-0.8021478056907654,
0.036632243543863297,
-0.27475106716156006,
-0.14731058478355408,
-0.015676861628890038,
0.4241313934326172,
-0.2971969246864319,
0.03213534504175186,
0.6285659074783325,
0.14388291537761688,
0.5641396045684814,
0.14610172808170319,
0.11969979107379913,
-0.905707061290741,
0.4791484475135803,
0.2589395046234131,
-0.02403537929058075,
-0.5431408286094666,
0.4475152790546417,
0.5765348672866821,
0.040295034646987915,
-0.5916945934295654,
0.3947908282279968,
-0.5895030498504639,
-0.1314975917339325,
-0.17571477591991425,
0.83460932970047,
-0.22699007391929626,
0.5391818881034851,
0.29841333627700806,
0.33519235253334045,
0.2753952741622925,
-0.5850321650505066,
0.37820494174957275,
-0.1195153221487999,
-0.44554951786994934,
0.6162199378013611,
-0.6808685660362244,
0.16488304734230042,
0.33590540289878845,
0.5184673070907593,
-0.7963560819625854,
-0.17813853919506073,
0.18392157554626465,
-0.36272263526916504,
0.22395575046539307,
0.024517666548490524,
-0.721064031124115,
-0.27820849418640137,
-0.19939884543418884,
0.6014479398727417,
0.017299674451351166,
-0.6333042979240417,
0.32334190607070923,
0.023994840681552887,
0.1673664003610611,
-0.6898382902145386,
-0.7547664046287537,
0.10723055899143219,
-0.0387357659637928,
-0.5369958281517029,
0.4125937223434448,
-0.18906565010547638,
-0.2865924835205078,
-0.11197691410779953,
-0.22448143362998962,
-0.2199205607175827,
0.3201773166656494,
0.0013057998148724437,
0.5224283337593079,
-0.37683144211769104,
-0.04246397316455841,
-0.3143450617790222,
0.08561491221189499,
0.12308911234140396,
-0.16854716837406158,
0.3984721899032593,
-0.24735558032989502,
-0.38643506169319153,
-0.6000811457633972,
-0.21131427586078644,
0.4440929591655731,
-0.4157847464084625,
0.48972004652023315,
0.6300629377365112,
-0.43576762080192566,
-0.13287466764450073,
-0.5256941914558411,
0.11562268435955048,
-0.4226425588130951,
0.305478572845459,
-0.4790284037590027,
-0.8819826245307922,
0.2929781973361969,
0.07333879172801971,
0.1298302561044693,
0.3711828887462616,
0.45794785022735596,
0.1529662162065506,
0.8184577822685242,
0.32824814319610596,
-0.33674293756484985,
0.331173300743103,
-0.1674555093050003,
0.10608142614364624,
-0.9750926494598389,
-0.007165612652897835,
-0.6200735569000244,
-0.20572184026241302,
-0.6782683730125427,
-0.4583423435688019,
0.14136430621147156,
0.3126949071884155,
-0.22374725341796875,
0.3746730089187622,
-0.2516542077064514,
0.24494950473308563,
0.1911805123090744,
0.2843811511993408,
0.44345614314079285,
-0.5308116674423218,
0.02880355343222618,
0.024668509140610695,
-0.40428176522254944,
-0.3813855051994324,
0.8079259991645813,
0.2544739842414856,
0.46015357971191406,
0.2665248513221741,
0.34073513746261597,
-0.12112875282764435,
0.449745237827301,
-0.8203198909759521,
0.5565100312232971,
-0.26367059350013733,
-0.41599106788635254,
-0.10512115061283112,
-0.48215457797050476,
-0.8113070130348206,
0.4785158932209015,
-0.1454342007637024,
-0.6934537887573242,
0.07236628979444504,
-0.002239724388346076,
-0.21000801026821136,
0.36675581336021423,
-0.36605915427207947,
1.0612045526504517,
-0.3675040006637573,
-0.6654439568519592,
-0.5029140114784241,
-0.32631778717041016,
1.0660442113876343,
-0.23044128715991974,
0.3226552903652191,
-0.1131129190325737,
-0.11563295125961304,
0.47188717126846313,
-0.10856616497039795,
0.664947509765625,
-0.044320084154605865,
0.04529191926121712,
0.10965366661548615,
0.03583837300539017,
0.4116133153438568,
0.278634637594223,
-0.05015070363879204,
-0.0683465301990509,
0.21929538249969482,
-0.8253801465034485,
-0.5110431909561157,
1.1276497840881348,
-0.772551417350769,
-0.5301205515861511,
-0.5206279158592224,
-0.45853716135025024,
-0.22844074666500092,
0.2241119146347046,
-0.2266746312379837,
0.2122039496898651,
-0.6201785206794739,
0.5720850229263306,
0.4647926688194275,
-0.3330082297325134,
0.6306049823760986,
0.8337196111679077,
0.22272241115570068,
-0.3036694824695587,
0.7379550933837891,
-0.1405894011259079,
0.2543943524360657,
0.6611869931221008,
-0.11085891723632812,
-0.0874868780374527,
-0.8363996148109436,
-0.24150621891021729,
0.2708152234554291,
-0.45452427864074707,
-0.09379171580076218,
-0.44617509841918945,
-0.18841204047203064,
-0.3367284834384918,
-0.06948010623455048,
-0.1468811333179474,
-0.07448840886354446,
-0.30632656812667847,
0.05063682422041893,
-0.12962780892848969,
0.5553215742111206,
0.05328717082738876,
0.30106616020202637,
-0.7205801010131836,
0.382743775844574,
0.22105948626995087,
0.44220858812332153,
0.3100936710834503,
-0.33059221506118774,
-0.54998379945755,
0.014279060997068882,
-0.45326176285743713,
-0.579125165939331,
0.22948794066905975,
-0.15169864892959595,
0.7789629101753235,
0.6735491156578064,
0.15310005843639374,
0.9051528573036194,
-0.1898762583732605,
0.9448623061180115,
0.13149809837341309,
-1.2070980072021484,
0.3109714984893799,
-0.47886115312576294,
0.4030514657497406,
0.5882205367088318,
0.14067667722702026,
-0.8219656348228455,
-0.2956199049949646,
-0.503129243850708,
-0.6671628355979919,
0.8818381428718567,
0.021905114874243736,
-0.30194488167762756,
0.057486169040203094,
0.2672591805458069,
-0.24637222290039062,
-0.23799720406532288,
-0.9116425514221191,
-0.14730805158615112,
-0.019901413470506668,
0.053283240646123886,
-0.3641859292984009,
0.05078376829624176,
0.12039918452501297,
-0.10280741751194,
0.5625454783439636,
-0.18651001155376434,
-0.17130880057811737,
0.13535672426223755,
-0.42894694209098816,
0.1061721220612526,
0.28091999888420105,
0.3522503972053528,
0.7917740345001221,
-0.2383071631193161,
0.09001632034778595,
0.5825951099395752,
-0.37939539551734924,
-0.35984566807746887,
0.3266232907772064,
0.30084314942359924,
-0.3063896894454956,
0.5605422258377075,
0.48369890451431274,
0.440616637468338,
-0.6443893909454346,
0.5145421624183655,
-0.2256826013326645,
-0.16583877801895142,
-0.4995608627796173,
-0.03775220736861229,
0.15458089113235474,
0.017026817426085472,
0.3377644717693329,
-0.265185683965683,
0.2141057401895523,
-0.5472235679626465,
0.05192255973815918,
0.2739579677581787,
-0.7234236001968384,
-0.08428659290075302,
0.6094045639038086,
0.11489128321409225,
0.28856560587882996,
0.6849558353424072,
0.06928589195013046,
-0.30570533871650696,
0.5762020945549011,
0.36682021617889404,
0.7161416411399841,
-0.048787977546453476,
-0.1307879239320755,
0.663957417011261,
0.18283148109912872,
-0.27163007855415344,
-0.2509090006351471,
-0.2756390869617462,
-0.545190691947937,
-0.5992564558982849,
-0.414863258600235,
-0.5610208511352539,
0.2777753472328186,
-0.8669310808181763,
0.4835266172885895,
-0.5435203909873962,
0.442859947681427,
-0.015047738328576088,
0.32486772537231445,
-0.6322274804115295,
0.14820894598960876,
0.4570121169090271,
1.1113646030426025,
-0.44164419174194336,
1.283660888671875,
0.3521292507648468,
-0.2766801118850708,
-0.8073548078536987,
0.020789628848433495,
0.21506322920322418,
-0.8286208510398865,
0.4577038884162903,
0.2583840489387512,
-0.1179896742105484,
-0.16677738726139069,
-0.71453458070755,
-0.4497840106487274,
1.3478397130966187,
0.17486722767353058,
-0.8862239122390747,
0.3203391432762146,
0.0015274452744051814,
0.45934513211250305,
-0.3053136467933655,
0.4919683337211609,
1.0907797813415527,
0.7349691390991211,
-0.08286436647176743,
-0.7511264085769653,
0.3801901042461395,
-0.3691491186618805,
0.05252053216099739,
-0.11113990843296051,
-0.9350976347923279,
0.6740381121635437,
0.03244128078222275,
-0.4170721471309662,
0.5762017369270325,
0.7158226370811462,
0.6322568655014038,
0.4311315417289734,
0.471415251493454,
0.4526282548904419,
0.6198886632919312,
-0.45112377405166626,
1.0701689720153809,
-0.33288702368736267,
0.2174859493970871,
1.055570363998413,
-0.10210607945919037,
1.0227108001708984,
0.02366429567337036,
-0.23271438479423523,
0.35614845156669617,
0.9691449999809265,
-0.1443149745464325,
0.09721694886684418,
0.5821237564086914,
-0.36430391669273376,
-0.45810967683792114,
-0.16673004627227783,
-0.43704289197921753,
0.3655381500720978,
0.4266020357608795,
-0.159676194190979,
0.12201126664876938,
-0.39567574858665466,
0.2908259630203247,
0.3223063051700592,
-0.25835567712783813,
0.5943694710731506,
0.2550308108329773,
-0.7420526742935181,
0.8221296072006226,
0.05920744314789772,
0.36885103583335876,
-0.5013564825057983,
-0.0029084538109600544,
-0.3770575225353241,
0.3747725188732147,
-0.16844214498996735,
-0.6388074159622192,
-0.3320915699005127,
-0.14782783389091492,
0.14663632214069366,
-0.039998821914196014,
0.2724621891975403,
-0.30492350459098816,
-0.21289770305156708,
0.4013873338699341,
0.3319207727909088,
0.16041123867034912,
-0.26985234022140503,
-0.6216483116149902,
0.2417483776807785,
-0.04915832355618477,
0.07425428926944733,
0.2950042188167572,
0.606602132320404,
0.0729164332151413,
0.3580273389816284,
0.6644768714904785,
0.002453609835356474,
-0.51634681224823,
0.26738062500953674,
0.791939914226532,
-1.0142583847045898,
-0.14946159720420837,
-0.8745088577270508,
0.22231750190258026,
-0.21966363489627838,
-0.2197359949350357,
0.727089524269104,
0.7327256798744202,
0.8365911245346069,
0.24335698783397675,
0.8441619873046875,
0.016611572355031967,
0.2339872419834137,
-0.44529807567596436,
0.7052396535873413,
-0.5662941336631775,
0.22303658723831177,
-0.4059472382068634,
-0.9373601078987122,
-0.5013927817344666,
0.1916898488998413,
-0.41535449028015137,
-0.2865132987499237,
1.0440707206726074,
0.5577002167701721,
-0.07868300378322601,
0.31182512640953064,
0.358515202999115,
0.3980051577091217,
0.3262847065925598,
1.078058123588562,
0.8136106729507446,
-0.3452834486961365,
0.8024562001228333,
-0.1963863968849182,
-0.4135228395462036,
-0.11801394820213318,
-0.6180670261383057,
-0.9189404845237732,
-0.474620521068573,
0.13944916427135468,
-0.23505628108978271,
0.14751385152339935,
0.5328801274299622,
0.6259430050849915,
-0.7884246706962585,
-0.5934600234031677,
-0.18827778100967407,
0.1418524533510208,
-0.5856590867042542,
-0.2099793702363968,
0.5931140184402466,
-0.5990305542945862,
-0.956367552280426,
0.4092382788658142,
0.01580977439880371,
-0.18154144287109375,
-0.18452298641204834,
-0.1796419471502304,
-0.06847252696752548,
-0.3051632046699524,
0.5067329406738281,
0.3875136077404022,
-0.9398419857025146,
-0.13107536733150482,
0.23239780962467194,
-0.23294301331043243,
-0.1392073631286621,
1.0590187311172485,
-0.6406220197677612,
0.4791821539402008,
0.3799237906932831,
0.7704676985740662,
0.9399477243423462,
-0.1720069795846939,
0.7777604460716248,
-0.1737707406282425,
-0.05646902695298195,
-0.07973641157150269,
0.5951569676399231,
0.48031529784202576,
-0.08061043918132782,
0.6387839317321777,
0.27108731865882874,
-0.5444239974021912,
-0.5698076486587524,
-0.1111440509557724,
-1.4643906354904175,
-0.4289851784706116,
1.0523546934127808,
-0.33849769830703735,
-0.2948075234889984,
0.054908983409404755,
-0.19636443257331848,
0.3590564727783203,
-0.25067877769470215,
0.46844011545181274,
0.8227488398551941,
0.029316728934645653,
-0.5110697150230408,
-0.7414171695709229,
0.22873808443546295,
0.541501522064209,
-0.6894819140434265,
0.49614059925079346,
0.5042366981506348,
-0.07703138887882233,
-0.24233636260032654,
0.36537396907806396,
-0.25810712575912476,
0.5942180156707764,
-0.22127731144428253,
0.020533205941319466,
0.21125482022762299,
0.12650254368782043,
-0.14418163895606995,
-0.019507549703121185,
0.2866710424423218,
-0.023833680897951126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.18448v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.18448v1
|
Multi-objective Representation for Numbers in Clinical Narratives Using CamemBERT-bio
| 2024-05-28T01:15:21 | 2024-05-28T01:15:21 |
Boammani Aser Lompo, Thanh-Dung Le
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.SP
|
This research aims to classify numerical values extracted from medical
documents across seven distinct physiological categories, employing
CamemBERT-bio. Previous studies suggested that transformer-based models might
not perform as well as traditional NLP models in such tasks. To enhance
CamemBERT-bio's performances, we introduce two main innovations: integrating
keyword embeddings into the model and adopting a number-agnostic strategy by
excluding all numerical data from the text. The implementation of label
embedding techniques refines the attention mechanisms, while the technique of
using a `numerical-blind' dataset aims to bolster context-centric learning.
Another key component of our research is determining the criticality of
extracted numerical data. To achieve this, we utilized a simple approach that
involves verifying if the value falls within the established standard ranges.
Our findings are encouraging, showing substantial improvements in the
effectiveness of CamemBERT-bio, surpassing conventional methods with an F1
score of 0.89. This represents an over 20\% increase over the 0.73 $F_1$ score
of traditional approaches and an over 9\% increase over the 0.82 $F_1$ score of
state-of-the-art approaches. All this was achieved despite using small and
imbalanced training datasets.
|
[
-0.2769598364830017,
-0.4243130683898926,
0.8064022660255432,
0.39188581705093384,
-0.5144553184509277,
0.2083318680524826,
-0.14445284008979797,
-0.32456764578819275,
0.4445973336696625,
0.4855722486972809,
-0.2627221941947937,
-0.7847834825515747,
-0.8588093519210815,
0.3619123697280884,
0.1640649437904358,
1.1552605628967285,
0.13726435601711273,
0.5252022743225098,
-0.34428539872169495,
-0.44888579845428467,
-0.6131877899169922,
-0.7892434597015381,
-0.34831753373146057,
-0.5293252468109131,
0.69740891456604,
0.08977954834699631,
0.6101127862930298,
0.7591943740844727,
1.1757138967514038,
0.2024916410446167,
0.00932373572140932,
0.16405166685581207,
-0.22676384449005127,
0.08147454261779785,
0.0852799266576767,
-0.5242547392845154,
-0.6045815944671631,
-0.09795169532299042,
0.5144906640052795,
0.7682726979255676,
-0.15150171518325806,
0.09621823579072952,
-0.02636420540511608,
0.8940489292144775,
-0.3784601092338562,
0.5144250988960266,
-0.3227118253707886,
0.41582077741622925,
-0.10896620154380798,
-0.2691502273082733,
-0.7874460220336914,
-0.5187170505523682,
0.11233680695295334,
-0.6137344241142273,
0.24138440191745758,
-0.21084000170230865,
0.3884662687778473,
0.5422785878181458,
-0.4526422321796417,
-0.313085675239563,
-0.44889146089553833,
0.8704641461372375,
-0.7091876268386841,
0.49286893010139465,
0.4810451567173004,
0.12950833141803741,
0.40952032804489136,
-0.7573274374008179,
0.004271609243005514,
-0.10097745060920715,
-0.326088547706604,
0.5757772922515869,
-0.11500237137079239,
0.1094224750995636,
0.3896661400794983,
0.33434832096099854,
-0.6219216585159302,
-0.1849011331796646,
-0.5552555918693542,
-0.27387502789497375,
0.7074087858200073,
0.25416409969329834,
0.08943121880292892,
-0.12359670549631119,
-0.12957482039928436,
-0.1269863247871399,
-0.4882563650608063,
-0.19524674117565155,
-0.3043539226055145,
0.3479577600955963,
-0.1405872106552124,
0.5951266288757324,
0.10648518800735474,
0.6551586985588074,
0.12844912707805634,
-0.4211026430130005,
0.8007400631904602,
-0.1903420239686966,
-0.037976961582899094,
0.4461395740509033,
0.7410595417022705,
0.3766044080257416,
0.14824818074703217,
-0.32040876150131226,
0.16003644466400146,
0.2482517510652542,
0.6426571011543274,
-0.9238980412483215,
0.0752599835395813,
0.1975647658109665,
-0.7528823614120483,
-0.6568101048469543,
0.009674138389527798,
-0.8579657673835754,
-0.3465394675731659,
-0.28973129391670227,
0.1272849291563034,
-0.6931989789009094,
0.07601707428693771,
0.24312786757946014,
-0.03638111427426338,
-0.06632847338914871,
0.49633175134658813,
-0.8356738686561584,
0.25286009907722473,
0.5286353230476379,
0.9449841976165771,
-0.01882888376712799,
0.18262076377868652,
-0.142989844083786,
0.20734992623329163,
-0.3721972703933716,
0.8038116097450256,
-0.5901815891265869,
-0.45561322569847107,
-0.1927390843629837,
-0.12378421425819397,
-0.17036207020282745,
-0.614294171333313,
0.6560509204864502,
-0.29989686608314514,
0.03701459988951683,
-0.23417454957962036,
-0.49719682335853577,
-0.4517282545566559,
0.34058263897895813,
-0.7820391654968262,
0.904776930809021,
0.1364322006702423,
-0.6753528714179993,
0.3634493947029114,
-0.7432550191879272,
-0.3359197974205017,
0.3121028542518616,
-0.49223247170448303,
-0.5091656446456909,
0.3968822956085205,
0.21219532191753387,
0.4306579530239105,
-0.49449482560157776,
0.8141371607780457,
-0.1436859518289566,
-0.07125501334667206,
0.38653287291526794,
-0.6476179957389832,
0.45900386571884155,
-0.05018608644604683,
-0.1748637855052948,
-0.25693950057029724,
-0.946682333946228,
0.11440575867891312,
-0.08193004131317139,
-0.2791743874549866,
-0.38266709446907043,
-0.12483890354633331,
-0.19590647518634796,
0.23676522076129913,
-0.18639273941516876,
-0.7769747972488403,
0.21915404498577118,
-0.40450167655944824,
0.18347495794296265,
0.19843481481075287,
0.2010755091905594,
0.09702416509389877,
-0.5986770987510681,
0.5410601496696472,
0.08789517730474472,
-0.17239154875278473,
-0.21906402707099915,
-0.6839478611946106,
-0.2714442014694214,
-0.5173668265342712,
0.4214566946029663,
0.7244150042533875,
-0.6565841436386108,
0.38191795349121094,
-0.3044699728488922,
-0.6894528865814209,
-0.8498867154121399,
-0.24180015921592712,
0.4166354537010193,
0.6997849345207214,
0.7201547026634216,
-0.5489882826805115,
-0.1594376415014267,
-0.8903589248657227,
-0.042294830083847046,
-0.14690734446048737,
-0.1534164845943451,
0.472307026386261,
0.4036756455898285,
-0.3414302468299866,
0.781277596950531,
-0.957123339176178,
-0.43302175402641296,
-0.019177787005901337,
0.30418989062309265,
0.45396509766578674,
0.5562077760696411,
0.6870865821838379,
-0.8914486169815063,
-0.4882468283176422,
0.24909114837646484,
-1.227968692779541,
-0.2035406529903412,
-0.09783580899238586,
0.35103002190589905,
-0.2904386818408966,
0.3645368814468384,
-0.36762329936027527,
0.8245077729225159,
0.17510804533958435,
-0.11659273505210876,
0.2509578466415405,
-0.1795412003993988,
0.28693124651908875,
-0.9041344523429871,
0.08080045878887177,
0.3392721116542816,
-0.2095446139574051,
-0.6154872179031372,
-0.17592979967594147,
0.28512972593307495,
-0.36006787419319153,
-0.3764643967151642,
0.39021235704421997,
-0.02560611069202423,
0.4641721546649933,
0.056796204298734665,
-0.4231799840927124,
0.19355405867099762,
0.5423243045806885,
0.4006001353263855,
0.2966736853122711,
0.3369547724723816,
-0.16052639484405518,
0.31231385469436646,
0.35424602031707764,
0.00010067372932098806,
0.6701067686080933,
-0.8233023285865784,
0.17547696828842163,
-0.488128662109375,
0.4555722177028656,
-1.0781638622283936,
-0.17571693658828735,
0.363960325717926,
-0.5465518236160278,
0.3694649636745453,
-0.13788005709648132,
-0.5111789107322693,
-0.3250189423561096,
-0.396050363779068,
0.6085174083709717,
0.20954130589962006,
0.030628923326730728,
0.5756093859672546,
0.2468932867050171,
-0.669331967830658,
-0.2324274480342865,
-0.8299099802970886,
-0.012165618129074574,
-0.4919348359107971,
-0.42703977227211,
0.6980535984039307,
-0.11851121485233307,
-0.2505496144294739,
-0.233711376786232,
0.042246654629707336,
-0.41370463371276855,
-0.33571571111679077,
0.18042117357254028,
0.20693683624267578,
-0.34154072403907776,
0.55726158618927,
0.3230336010456085,
-0.5015607476234436,
0.09156102687120438,
0.07257825881242752,
0.22291435301303864,
-0.2148703634738922,
-0.31682369112968445,
-0.35700467228889465,
0.4809330403804779,
0.7624555826187134,
-0.335235595703125,
0.8325129151344299,
0.7744243741035461,
-0.6182220578193665,
0.32919174432754517,
-0.5251074433326721,
-0.2479361742734909,
-0.3416959047317505,
0.3334892988204956,
-0.20219434797763824,
-0.6332497596740723,
0.5690892934799194,
-0.29096662998199463,
0.03357798606157303,
0.5550220012664795,
0.6533862352371216,
-0.004912136122584343,
1.131820797920227,
0.22412225604057312,
0.4231916666030884,
0.06375817954540253,
-0.20203302800655365,
0.09507596492767334,
-0.7578995823860168,
-0.5934617519378662,
-0.39307326078414917,
-0.20448662340641022,
-0.3906964957714081,
-0.39443907141685486,
0.8798835277557373,
-0.34187859296798706,
-0.10785259306430817,
0.052095092833042145,
-0.8535425662994385,
0.17318621277809143,
0.10032056272029877,
0.7739510536193848,
0.23903009295463562,
-0.07843318581581116,
-0.19514136016368866,
-0.6504403948783875,
-0.859561026096344,
-0.3403627276420593,
1.2495324611663818,
0.6535176038742065,
0.7041993737220764,
0.23693886399269104,
0.8640230894088745,
0.3435503840446472,
1.0545158386230469,
-1.1565455198287964,
0.2456376999616623,
-0.3342471718788147,
-0.7595553398132324,
-0.13646024465560913,
-0.34085696935653687,
-0.7866365909576416,
0.5380313396453857,
-0.18632203340530396,
-0.6287946701049805,
0.44146859645843506,
-0.05081966519355774,
-0.7748034596443176,
0.0035116001963615417,
-0.6323844790458679,
0.7553337812423706,
-0.6035157442092896,
-0.5036470293998718,
-0.10773885995149612,
-0.8348621129989624,
0.1960165798664093,
-0.6484457850456238,
0.4597644805908203,
-0.011632333509624004,
-0.11038371920585632,
0.8899226188659668,
-0.5437374711036682,
1.0989875793457031,
-0.01361028477549553,
0.003962379414588213,
0.11804446578025818,
-0.2299988716840744,
0.13403862714767456,
0.34764206409454346,
-0.24618014693260193,
0.42218583822250366,
0.23310613632202148,
-0.24408775568008423,
-0.628584086894989,
0.28178730607032776,
-0.5543815493583679,
-0.2756099998950958,
-0.7624239921569824,
-0.5538105964660645,
-0.3322826623916626,
0.15206027030944824,
0.3193962275981903,
0.8321042656898499,
-0.14522789418697357,
0.7976287603378296,
0.6473623514175415,
-0.5253561735153198,
0.10861985385417938,
0.37567564845085144,
0.07784430682659149,
-0.877760648727417,
0.755695641040802,
0.332835853099823,
0.0627000629901886,
0.5977008938789368,
0.45228224992752075,
-0.25648635625839233,
-0.4590030014514923,
-0.34757155179977417,
0.4389142692089081,
-0.6300563216209412,
-0.6159562468528748,
-0.7854228615760803,
-0.2132415771484375,
-0.43878135085105896,
-0.2677617371082306,
-0.2802826464176178,
-0.25778934359550476,
-0.37226375937461853,
-0.1947050541639328,
0.4802732765674591,
0.535559892654419,
-0.2325805127620697,
0.5683498978614807,
-1.1518019437789917,
0.36969754099845886,
-0.07111462950706482,
0.3163906931877136,
0.017203116789460182,
-0.4748969078063965,
-0.38236314058303833,
-0.12446614354848862,
-0.49432605504989624,
-1.0966671705245972,
0.7780240774154663,
0.16824287176132202,
0.38889816403388977,
0.5049545168876648,
-0.023141849786043167,
0.5692468285560608,
-0.5970045328140259,
0.35647767782211304,
0.45066434144973755,
-0.6323243975639343,
0.4537787437438965,
-0.3238075375556946,
0.40034377574920654,
0.9499716758728027,
0.6328335404396057,
-0.34826308488845825,
0.00012614972365554422,
-0.8701553344726562,
-0.8618429899215698,
0.6265211701393127,
0.21478775143623352,
-0.11299702525138855,
-0.09668236970901489,
0.4353741407394409,
0.30847275257110596,
0.4355356991291046,
-0.7866348624229431,
-0.2664927840232849,
-0.24858024716377258,
-0.6806948184967041,
-0.0940181314945221,
-0.07415515184402466,
-0.03929616138339043,
-0.5358071327209473,
0.13852012157440186,
-0.304487407207489,
0.5081345438957214,
0.3579241931438446,
-0.1513792723417282,
0.17898224294185638,
0.023746849969029427,
0.49454909563064575,
0.6828126907348633,
-0.596825897693634,
0.19334813952445984,
0.20277300477027893,
-0.8054755330085754,
0.06241697445511818,
0.26968127489089966,
0.11820361018180847,
0.2243700921535492,
0.914408266544342,
0.5829038619995117,
0.46462205052375793,
-0.43141576647758484,
0.29122763872146606,
-0.07396671921014786,
-0.28661689162254333,
-0.025752834975719452,
-0.27170896530151367,
-0.1414676308631897,
0.007109771948307753,
0.40272092819213867,
0.2999916672706604,
0.2594328820705414,
-0.22380474209785461,
0.5200090408325195,
-0.05290447920560837,
-0.7165622115135193,
-0.38442274928092957,
0.4730067551136017,
0.18635830283164978,
-0.3296490013599396,
0.5372292995452881,
0.1745024472475052,
-0.3535138964653015,
0.8266575336456299,
0.6154822707176208,
0.6994174718856812,
-0.38574862480163574,
0.4216941297054291,
0.48503345251083374,
0.22265294194221497,
-0.09042827785015106,
0.1726456731557846,
0.0444696880877018,
-0.7895609140396118,
-0.3832004964351654,
-0.4457228183746338,
-0.4452488422393799,
-0.010179579257965088,
-1.008529782295227,
0.12248221784830093,
-0.4273337721824646,
-0.571986973285675,
0.6104518175125122,
-0.29941892623901367,
-0.7834904789924622,
0.4926348328590393,
0.06524989753961563,
0.6465676426887512,
-0.970614492893219,
0.4466785192489624,
0.7353976368904114,
-0.6682904958724976,
-0.4866214692592621,
-0.2649983763694763,
0.17876289784908295,
-0.9048092365264893,
0.5585304498672485,
0.24618633091449738,
0.34706202149391174,
0.1841927319765091,
-0.3624771535396576,
-0.7299844026565552,
0.9499160647392273,
0.1759060025215149,
-0.4984036386013031,
-0.07155094295740128,
0.2682698369026184,
0.796851634979248,
-0.4278697669506073,
0.43458759784698486,
0.3381277918815613,
0.5777618288993835,
0.2738938629627228,
-0.720059335231781,
-0.11686257272958755,
-0.21086807548999786,
-0.41636887192726135,
0.13353556394577026,
-0.7386367321014404,
0.46416187286376953,
-0.28009915351867676,
0.23738481104373932,
-0.3586839437484741,
0.1392834633588791,
0.4013098478317261,
0.6827853322029114,
0.13412418961524963,
0.6677480936050415,
0.8523674607276917,
-0.08372268080711365,
1.0855164527893066,
-0.35734823346138,
0.5082547664642334,
0.5048807263374329,
-0.28253501653671265,
0.3375761806964874,
0.31240665912628174,
-0.5310841798782349,
0.2791590988636017,
0.7234510183334351,
0.0017027362482622266,
0.6880223751068115,
0.18028955161571503,
-0.3767704963684082,
-0.15343447029590607,
-0.24839608371257782,
-0.5618387460708618,
0.4082603454589844,
0.691322922706604,
-0.6837791204452515,
-0.20654138922691345,
0.25777924060821533,
0.1452890783548355,
-0.25376152992248535,
-0.28171196579933167,
0.9864261746406555,
0.4956875145435333,
-0.5058374404907227,
0.5595495700836182,
0.003498408244922757,
0.36081641912460327,
-0.695841372013092,
-0.37544962763786316,
-0.11535083502531052,
0.3336132764816284,
-0.27511537075042725,
-0.572762131690979,
0.4340441823005676,
0.032456863671541214,
-0.24489372968673706,
-0.4823669195175171,
0.7525790929794312,
-0.4787244200706482,
-1.1686761379241943,
-0.03313535451889038,
0.6502305865287781,
0.11373114585876465,
0.024935385212302208,
-0.6661873459815979,
0.18817758560180664,
0.10194078832864761,
0.0191266480833292,
0.13989226520061493,
0.6926236152648926,
-0.17235030233860016,
0.4067138135433197,
0.458632230758667,
0.06722898036241531,
-0.6392146348953247,
0.1317615807056427,
0.7649712562561035,
-0.8643243312835693,
-0.31400173902511597,
-1.120445728302002,
0.3418923616409302,
0.19225426018238068,
-0.3045075833797455,
0.39761289954185486,
0.6355900764465332,
0.18510520458221436,
-0.23532544076442719,
0.8107821345329285,
0.24109603464603424,
0.5180662274360657,
-0.3876911401748657,
0.583234429359436,
-0.3628053367137909,
0.032124556601047516,
-0.551753580570221,
-0.6768874526023865,
-0.9367763996124268,
0.7540431022644043,
-0.3534702956676483,
-0.002625537570565939,
0.9610174298286438,
0.35063785314559937,
-0.006793786771595478,
0.05605137348175049,
0.32129859924316406,
-0.014930409379303455,
0.30918076634407043,
0.5639544129371643,
0.5016751289367676,
-0.33571216464042664,
0.03819792717695236,
-0.12456874549388885,
-0.7107640504837036,
-0.1383117288351059,
-0.7965051531791687,
-0.6114551424980164,
-0.18382993340492249,
-0.4089009463787079,
-0.30543869733810425,
-0.0086770448833704,
0.9193434715270996,
0.6442286372184753,
-0.7935601472854614,
0.07139880955219269,
0.3161329925060272,
-0.13562916219234467,
-0.22555314004421234,
-0.10619232803583145,
0.6007038354873657,
-0.01542779989540577,
-0.217702254652977,
0.12863244116306305,
0.49937134981155396,
0.07474052160978317,
0.17208366096019745,
0.15623942017555237,
0.003150244941934943,
-0.022363539785146713,
0.8220562934875488,
-0.042922645807266235,
-0.2671891152858734,
0.024002186954021454,
0.16610190272331238,
0.06887098401784897,
0.4471578598022461,
0.8890587687492371,
-0.9805962443351746,
0.42215850949287415,
0.2715168595314026,
0.8778791427612305,
0.6162033081054688,
0.32357022166252136,
0.5614872574806213,
-0.6380241513252258,
0.18572936952114105,
0.6687208414077759,
0.22733375430107117,
0.3332063853740692,
-0.4338511526584625,
0.7139029502868652,
0.5824738144874573,
-0.23828421533107758,
-0.8120253086090088,
-0.22122886776924133,
-1.0301847457885742,
-0.10596583783626556,
0.9608953595161438,
-0.00323099154047668,
0.11321981996297836,
-0.25351107120513916,
-0.45785000920295715,
0.13030506670475006,
-0.4622391164302826,
0.8166646361351013,
0.8505613803863525,
-0.44381028413772583,
-0.058513227850198746,
-0.6775047183036804,
0.28864651918411255,
0.2218242883682251,
-0.9464592337608337,
-0.2620605230331421,
0.38711148500442505,
-0.111397385597229,
0.521190345287323,
0.641409158706665,
-0.5323995351791382,
0.14250998198986053,
-0.20877200365066528,
-0.08890713006258011,
0.1941474825143814,
-0.19029685854911804,
-0.263913094997406,
0.238511323928833,
-0.20269355177879333,
-0.001436183461919427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17712v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17712v1
|
CLAIM Your Data: Enhancing Imputation Accuracy with Contextual Large Language Models
| 2024-05-28T00:08:29 | 2024-05-28T00:08:29 |
Ahatsham Hayat, Mohammad Rashedul Hasan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces the Contextual Language model for Accurate Imputation
Method (CLAIM), a novel strategy that capitalizes on the expansive knowledge
and reasoning capabilities of pre-trained large language models (LLMs) to
address missing data challenges in tabular datasets. Unlike traditional
imputation methods, which predominantly rely on numerical estimations, CLAIM
utilizes contextually relevant natural language descriptors to fill missing
values. This approach transforms datasets into natural language contextualized
formats that are inherently more aligned with LLMs' capabilities, thereby
facilitating the dual use of LLMs: first, to generate missing value
descriptors, and then, to fine-tune the LLM on the enriched dataset for
improved performance in downstream tasks. Our evaluations across diverse
datasets and missingness patterns reveal CLAIM's superior performance over
existing imputation techniques. Furthermore, our investigation into the
effectiveness of context-specific versus generic descriptors for missing data
highlights the importance of contextual accuracy in enhancing LLM performance
for data imputation. The results underscore CLAIM's potential to markedly
improve the reliability and quality of data analysis and machine learning
models, offering a more nuanced and effective solution for handling missing
data.
|
[
0.013223016634583473,
-0.5648570656776428,
0.5099453330039978,
0.0029525072313845158,
0.18559619784355164,
0.17215946316719055,
-0.4161280691623688,
-0.4229404032230377,
0.330594003200531,
0.5539771318435669,
-0.21560771763324738,
-0.35206127166748047,
-0.442157506942749,
0.09386305510997772,
-0.364236980676651,
0.7571033835411072,
0.04894523322582245,
-0.1418238878250122,
-0.6181894540786743,
-0.07544225454330444,
-1.1390058994293213,
-0.2925218939781189,
0.004583976697176695,
-0.010211583226919174,
0.6018498539924622,
0.7652205228805542,
0.5344757437705994,
0.7507898807525635,
0.49669599533081055,
0.19122593104839325,
0.2161145806312561,
0.22087609767913818,
-0.405219167470932,
0.2602294981479645,
-0.18001529574394226,
-0.28582000732421875,
-0.3968368172645569,
-0.2396574467420578,
0.6902883648872375,
1.1021862030029297,
-0.29656174778938293,
0.3328533172607422,
0.18064656853675842,
0.7345392107963562,
-0.8542993068695068,
0.1757579743862152,
-1.121984839439392,
0.0936393067240715,
-0.5392080545425415,
-0.3071472942829132,
-0.6088235378265381,
-0.42462825775146484,
0.3155590891838074,
-0.17451250553131104,
0.35358336567878723,
-0.1320759505033493,
0.736089825630188,
0.29691681265830994,
-0.5027452707290649,
-0.3259596824645996,
-0.6977455615997314,
0.6286385655403137,
-0.8747197985649109,
0.1312505006790161,
0.5430226922035217,
0.5383679866790771,
-0.13840168714523315,
-0.8945749402046204,
-0.682730495929718,
-0.4393698573112488,
-0.3970755338668823,
-0.08098143339157104,
0.16766497492790222,
-0.15131673216819763,
0.42123398184776306,
0.41902127861976624,
-0.6132514476776123,
0.0606989786028862,
-0.13022826611995697,
-0.19876354932785034,
0.6386950016021729,
0.11845315247774124,
0.30461397767066956,
0.123695969581604,
-0.12676465511322021,
0.055149126797914505,
-1.0496177673339844,
-0.04885057732462883,
0.33175256848335266,
0.7515773177146912,
-0.13171377778053284,
0.5891121625900269,
-0.43596571683883667,
1.1357073783874512,
-0.2837411165237427,
-0.09753680229187012,
0.29302144050598145,
-0.24248038232326508,
-0.3735106289386749,
0.3400971591472626,
0.29456230998039246,
0.07153908908367157,
-0.05058852210640907,
-0.39573726058006287,
-0.08512558043003082,
-0.3921668827533722,
0.19216498732566833,
-0.42413005232810974,
0.04744163155555725,
0.248900905251503,
-0.14603836834430695,
-0.04188719019293785,
0.0013235496589913964,
-0.8493568897247314,
-0.5553944110870361,
-0.4224911034107208,
0.40301188826560974,
-0.09145911037921906,
-0.15593484044075012,
-0.20240665972232819,
0.0916370302438736,
0.0488041490316391,
0.3813152313232422,
-0.9224344491958618,
0.1597469300031662,
0.5656757354736328,
0.6145625710487366,
-0.015167390927672386,
-0.07141610980033875,
-0.8334125280380249,
0.48457053303718567,
-0.5530555248260498,
0.6761314868927002,
-0.7280108332633972,
0.03185373917222023,
0.22461360692977905,
0.08036492764949799,
-0.12423436343669891,
-0.8385471105575562,
0.6975947022438049,
-0.3599698543548584,
0.20143817365169525,
-0.7008296251296997,
-0.6215658783912659,
-0.2961759865283966,
0.3411419689655304,
-0.8373138904571533,
1.057281494140625,
0.30708569288253784,
-0.5538102984428406,
0.6213728189468384,
-0.5494714975357056,
-0.3418304920196533,
0.4470241069793701,
-0.17934174835681915,
-0.3388317823410034,
0.16433534026145935,
0.0559062585234642,
0.49356895685195923,
-0.33910197019577026,
0.8017358183860779,
-0.3618538975715637,
-0.20491167902946472,
0.39774656295776367,
-0.5200583934783936,
0.5747668147087097,
0.06005844101309776,
-0.2780895233154297,
-0.0908154770731926,
-0.9243916869163513,
-0.05728300288319588,
0.06267803907394409,
-0.35645246505737305,
-0.32859277725219727,
0.351936936378479,
0.1284177601337433,
0.004364354070276022,
0.4073992073535919,
-0.7131052017211914,
0.10867699235677719,
-0.6438418626785278,
0.11817436665296555,
0.6111889481544495,
-0.3028583824634552,
0.2703384459018707,
-0.21330849826335907,
0.24944861233234406,
-0.20530444383621216,
-0.4580021798610687,
-0.3532862067222595,
0.1044967770576477,
-0.4529171586036682,
-0.3234007954597473,
0.5040555596351624,
0.6544580459594727,
-0.5913705825805664,
0.37497133016586304,
-0.648493230342865,
-0.2517617642879486,
-0.1497228443622589,
-0.00525101600214839,
0.0631764680147171,
1.345796823501587,
0.5215941667556763,
0.034017883241176605,
-0.7255333662033081,
-1.1115808486938477,
-0.3266911208629608,
0.051510684192180634,
-0.2769511044025421,
0.30680030584335327,
0.35171931982040405,
-0.027999255806207657,
1.4372552633285522,
-0.7024747729301453,
-0.40613695979118347,
-0.416986346244812,
-0.11440543830394745,
0.21109412610530853,
0.4931577742099762,
0.4324727952480316,
-0.9121556282043457,
-0.6859675645828247,
0.006520007271319628,
-0.8976501226425171,
-0.1741848737001419,
-0.08345309644937515,
0.220514178276062,
0.33770763874053955,
-0.037537116557359695,
-0.35054799914360046,
0.5947215557098389,
0.10094741731882095,
-0.11515568196773529,
0.3856131136417389,
-0.20295517146587372,
0.011293475516140461,
-0.8761966824531555,
0.24852292239665985,
-0.01928643323481083,
-0.3646741807460785,
-0.6490018367767334,
-0.3673236668109894,
0.33568084239959717,
-0.21616610884666443,
-0.2885661721229553,
0.730795681476593,
-0.44534623622894287,
-0.001925084856338799,
-0.1253592073917389,
-0.06875921785831451,
-0.2371831089258194,
0.2532947063446045,
0.04057612270116806,
0.8390905857086182,
0.6380042433738708,
-0.5828195810317993,
0.30825522541999817,
0.4596154987812042,
-0.20139609277248383,
0.7942820191383362,
-0.4579339027404785,
-0.04728691279888153,
-0.32968202233314514,
0.3281569480895996,
-1.1005253791809082,
-0.5848572254180908,
0.20912347733974457,
-0.34442028403282166,
0.45992717146873474,
-0.10691241919994354,
-0.47022026777267456,
-0.5024353861808777,
0.027004212141036987,
0.10931753367185593,
0.09423519670963287,
-0.6010249853134155,
0.6260634064674377,
0.7159788608551025,
-0.5073347687721252,
-0.7614963054656982,
-0.9693443179130554,
0.6033824682235718,
-0.6551992297172546,
-0.17169152200222015,
0.6572980284690857,
0.13307319581508636,
-0.07342958450317383,
-0.017808321863412857,
-0.1544308215379715,
-0.42870932817459106,
0.07633727043867111,
0.06676257401704788,
0.21823987364768982,
-0.09843230247497559,
0.32478177547454834,
-0.15109725296497345,
-0.17013631761074066,
-0.004983725491911173,
-0.01314921211451292,
0.27936479449272156,
0.09627854079008102,
-0.28395676612854004,
-0.21239334344863892,
0.40653741359710693,
0.21302936971187592,
-0.0781923308968544,
0.6852654814720154,
0.234338641166687,
-0.9167712926864624,
0.05876486748456955,
-0.8077524900436401,
0.08959513157606125,
-0.397674560546875,
0.29574286937713623,
-0.14457310736179352,
-0.548570454120636,
0.5067914128303528,
0.2638649046421051,
0.16256754100322723,
0.2827005088329315,
0.2911423146724701,
-0.10349596291780472,
0.6084141731262207,
0.7792683839797974,
-0.23044456541538239,
0.28336238861083984,
0.14389091730117798,
0.3585273325443268,
-0.6681005358695984,
-0.1536189764738083,
-0.6974434852600098,
-0.26762130856513977,
-0.3868706524372101,
-0.15685702860355377,
0.311067134141922,
-0.3576933443546295,
-0.13219282031059265,
0.2391061931848526,
-0.3794827461242676,
0.3783804774284363,
0.35131874680519104,
0.15359513461589813,
0.2789683938026428,
0.3667148947715759,
0.20460103452205658,
-0.40415671467781067,
-0.5976945757865906,
-0.6670078039169312,
1.220605492591858,
0.23430941998958588,
0.5089573264122009,
0.2137872278690338,
0.3546949625015259,
0.6533812880516052,
0.6243024468421936,
-0.6153602600097656,
0.369393527507782,
0.08233406394720078,
-0.6053096652030945,
-0.16980227828025818,
-0.5363713502883911,
-0.8202539682388306,
0.17215076088905334,
-0.06869392096996307,
-1.1410386562347412,
0.04667973890900612,
0.3820158541202545,
-0.34153103828430176,
0.20536434650421143,
-0.6014154553413391,
0.8687766790390015,
-0.14469902217388153,
-0.5287919044494629,
-0.053658563643693924,
-0.8390281796455383,
0.3721616268157959,
-0.17114344239234924,
-0.13952377438545227,
-0.14971938729286194,
-0.015651049092411995,
0.8594147562980652,
-0.7366374135017395,
0.9698941111564636,
-0.5142150521278381,
-0.08583726733922958,
0.3032943308353424,
-0.15194079279899597,
0.6886156797409058,
-0.00891112256795168,
-0.12803038954734802,
-0.08792372792959213,
-0.10166757553815842,
-0.3980656564235687,
-0.4434647262096405,
0.6602575778961182,
0.085243821144104,
-0.3897783160209656,
-0.6511328816413879,
-0.7811538577079773,
-0.5067591071128845,
0.0797952339053154,
-0.1501547396183014,
0.6734403967857361,
-0.14589379727840424,
0.4447545111179352,
0.6710808873176575,
-0.5453898906707764,
0.7979200482368469,
0.6042761206626892,
0.3862496316432953,
-0.38231009244918823,
1.0093004703521729,
0.5897136330604553,
-0.08867035806179047,
0.6414717435836792,
0.11329600214958191,
-0.6229257583618164,
-0.31339794397354126,
-0.5345373749732971,
-0.01046528946608305,
-0.5500319004058838,
-0.7032839059829712,
-0.8419970870018005,
0.004855939652770758,
-0.4621257781982422,
-0.015714488923549652,
-0.3187623620033264,
-0.21488744020462036,
-0.02277730591595173,
-0.2511483132839203,
0.36591947078704834,
0.43429213762283325,
-0.016965443268418312,
0.4656369388103485,
-0.6594080924987793,
0.21842816472053528,
0.11938939988613129,
0.28244277834892273,
0.02373894862830639,
-0.38641688227653503,
-0.3415111005306244,
0.20076964795589447,
-0.3274517357349396,
-0.9718738794326782,
0.6502354741096497,
0.18665608763694763,
0.7743855714797974,
-0.13456079363822937,
0.08335471153259277,
1.0022939443588257,
-0.44120293855667114,
0.5742937922477722,
-0.0619550384581089,
-0.805903434753418,
0.45769202709198,
-0.25531357526779175,
-0.06082455441355705,
0.634749174118042,
0.2746439576148987,
-0.600264310836792,
0.07239144295454025,
-0.6677523255348206,
-1.1154204607009888,
0.6750427484512329,
-0.07775451987981796,
0.11852484196424484,
0.08050397038459778,
0.21554253995418549,
0.16369888186454773,
0.4765043258666992,
-0.9068429470062256,
-0.2500244677066803,
0.35434532165527344,
-0.66895592212677,
0.11951027810573578,
-0.4242871105670929,
-0.04574928432703018,
-0.07980787754058838,
0.5470644235610962,
-0.4566293954849243,
0.19531339406967163,
0.33055827021598816,
-0.4293213188648224,
-0.010886820033192635,
0.1558314561843872,
0.5241062641143799,
1.227579951286316,
-0.17415441572666168,
0.02860710211098194,
0.42967745661735535,
-0.31719425320625305,
-0.041399624198675156,
0.34799885749816895,
-0.18652451038360596,
0.19573244452476501,
0.25520142912864685,
0.33378323912620544,
0.11471573263406754,
-0.9433344006538391,
0.5308672189712524,
0.04110480099916458,
0.3422704339027405,
-0.6131125688552856,
-0.36359724402427673,
-0.1648014485836029,
-0.11622072011232376,
0.9473221898078918,
0.007209018804132938,
0.13817185163497925,
-0.3296678364276886,
0.3859361708164215,
0.5298629403114319,
-0.5274665951728821,
-0.048337895423173904,
0.7730698585510254,
-0.21516387164592743,
0.017802400514483452,
0.3076038658618927,
0.14331921935081482,
-0.13574889302253723,
0.8658888339996338,
0.6613417267799377,
0.5549364686012268,
-0.0601235032081604,
0.2406676560640335,
0.34928521513938904,
0.1986055076122284,
-0.15312333405017853,
-0.12449560314416885,
0.09532996267080307,
-0.5182721018791199,
-0.5631891489028931,
-0.4009271264076233,
-0.27138662338256836,
0.4066878855228424,
-0.5570809245109558,
0.22792962193489075,
-0.14282433688640594,
0.23546239733695984,
-0.2981172800064087,
0.08098452538251877,
-0.6651827692985535,
0.30167853832244873,
0.24043147265911102,
1.0198463201522827,
-0.9691612720489502,
0.5752434134483337,
0.23749740421772003,
-0.4210403561592102,
-0.8031136393547058,
0.07677264511585236,
0.019892549142241478,
-0.5126017332077026,
0.7300266027450562,
0.2439272552728653,
0.4229586720466614,
0.05259077623486519,
-0.6466385722160339,
-1.1474817991256714,
0.8753802180290222,
0.6980977654457092,
-0.45063892006874084,
0.19830553233623505,
0.2391250878572464,
0.29558315873146057,
-0.5277966260910034,
0.22334502637386322,
0.5626901984214783,
0.48949670791625977,
0.15912699699401855,
-0.8444259762763977,
0.2786117196083069,
0.2646774649620056,
0.15306514501571655,
-0.010351515375077724,
-0.11931701749563217,
0.4603296220302582,
-0.0832180604338646,
-0.23580549657344818,
0.03505183756351471,
0.9470463395118713,
0.09699632972478867,
0.5234838128089905,
0.1975088268518448,
0.5186713933944702,
1.2988938093185425,
-0.08424106985330582,
1.0615782737731934,
0.13485023379325867,
0.3234976828098297,
1.4577401876449585,
-0.7468648552894592,
0.7676730155944824,
0.24922823905944824,
-0.08242619037628174,
0.22577987611293793,
0.6979073882102966,
0.17659211158752441,
0.47262486815452576,
0.060107868164777756,
-0.38101908564567566,
0.2989533543586731,
-0.3644159138202667,
-0.48653486371040344,
0.2803969979286194,
0.5313428044319153,
-0.22648614645004272,
-0.5684493184089661,
0.07510140538215637,
0.09618464857339859,
0.22987185418605804,
-0.20941248536109924,
0.5728525519371033,
-0.3626101016998291,
-0.6621885299682617,
0.6180853247642517,
-0.17861652374267578,
0.330700546503067,
-0.5382464528083801,
-0.38133975863456726,
-0.43084582686424255,
-0.08431677520275116,
-0.43040731549263,
-0.5602231025695801,
0.5527339577674866,
0.09273339062929153,
-0.21577896177768707,
-0.24085594713687897,
0.7001155018806458,
-0.8442314267158508,
-0.5890716910362244,
-0.17040887475013733,
0.4709770679473877,
-0.06911571323871613,
-0.15605966746807098,
-0.4889231026172638,
-0.2615472078323364,
-0.013060095719993114,
0.14246350526809692,
0.161620631814003,
0.35803771018981934,
-0.2490975707769394,
0.7249162197113037,
0.49284276366233826,
0.266110897064209,
-0.08735445886850357,
0.0009794485522434115,
0.8188384175300598,
-0.8187795877456665,
-0.37056732177734375,
-0.9948292374610901,
0.669337809085846,
-0.2409101128578186,
0.21728184819221497,
0.6433535814285278,
0.971610426902771,
0.6834692358970642,
-0.24250729382038116,
0.9417642951011658,
-0.49755632877349854,
1.0106830596923828,
-0.5760416984558105,
0.5250511169433594,
-0.461667537689209,
0.2763807475566864,
-0.36879149079322815,
-0.7558690905570984,
-0.5635973811149597,
0.3632635474205017,
-0.5955002307891846,
-0.1203559935092926,
0.6276789307594299,
1.0536330938339233,
-0.12655147910118103,
-0.384600430727005,
0.23320400714874268,
0.258137583732605,
0.31121307611465454,
0.5662446022033691,
0.6504185795783997,
-0.40979447960853577,
0.2441512942314148,
-0.0007330420194193721,
-0.28000494837760925,
-0.3378249704837799,
-1.019694209098816,
-0.23665077984333038,
-0.5232564806938171,
-0.49727576971054077,
-0.2667490541934967,
-0.27704375982284546,
0.8014548420906067,
0.6542675495147705,
-0.8162473440170288,
-0.19026239216327667,
0.021253053098917007,
0.3084675967693329,
-0.08863557875156403,
-0.36162734031677246,
0.26342344284057617,
-0.47461703419685364,
-0.8007418513298035,
0.5707356929779053,
0.2055061310529709,
0.09913519024848938,
0.1976454257965088,
0.2627900540828705,
-0.37960687279701233,
-0.3553735017776489,
0.4659026861190796,
0.6024932265281677,
-0.5123134255409241,
-0.31734737753868103,
-0.24265840649604797,
-0.02479512244462967,
0.4261111319065094,
0.653425931930542,
-1.0840131044387817,
0.27342909574508667,
0.48318707942962646,
1.075153112411499,
0.27340006828308105,
0.3458694517612457,
0.7331144213676453,
-0.9533774256706238,
0.2695698142051697,
0.25859948992729187,
0.42568323016166687,
0.6675938963890076,
-0.7863638997077942,
0.638070821762085,
0.2884204387664795,
-0.25008469820022583,
-1.1700119972229004,
0.028042607009410858,
-0.9525769352912903,
0.022233840078115463,
0.7747427225112915,
-0.0718187540769577,
-0.23441264033317566,
-0.12354032695293427,
-0.1344286948442459,
0.10024615377187729,
-0.1813860982656479,
0.7332976460456848,
0.556510329246521,
0.152211531996727,
0.1081252470612526,
-1.0175756216049194,
0.3677830398082733,
0.4597759246826172,
-0.8905330896377563,
0.5046908259391785,
0.8115828633308411,
0.3777885437011719,
0.13169239461421967,
0.5727028846740723,
-0.15028446912765503,
-0.14048704504966736,
-0.3232502341270447,
0.01204127911478281,
0.13272109627723694,
-0.4894353151321411,
-0.24572919309139252,
0.4423663914203644,
-0.14014901220798492,
-0.22187460958957672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00044v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00044v1
|
Stochastic Adversarial Networks for Multi-Domain Text Classification
| 2024-05-28T00:02:38 | 2024-05-28T00:02:38 |
Xu Wang, Yuan Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Adversarial training has been instrumental in advancing multi-domain text
classification (MDTC). Traditionally, MDTC methods employ a shared-private
paradigm, with a shared feature extractor for domain-invariant knowledge and
individual private feature extractors for domain-specific knowledge. Despite
achieving state-of-the-art results, these methods grapple with the escalating
model parameters due to the continuous addition of new domains. To address this
challenge, we introduce the Stochastic Adversarial Network (SAN), which
innovatively models the parameters of the domain-specific feature extractor as
a multivariate Gaussian distribution, as opposed to a traditional weight
vector. This design allows for the generation of numerous domain-specific
feature extractors without a substantial increase in model parameters,
maintaining the model's size on par with that of a single domain-specific
extractor. Furthermore, our approach integrates domain label smoothing and
robust pseudo-label regularization to fortify the stability of adversarial
training and to refine feature discriminability, respectively. The performance
of our SAN, evaluated on two leading MDTC benchmarks, demonstrates its
competitive edge against the current state-of-the-art methodologies. The code
is available at https://github.com/wangxu0820/SAN.
|
[
-0.40799516439437866,
-0.7286117672920227,
0.265531450510025,
-0.023239772766828537,
-0.3014400005340576,
0.1909119188785553,
-0.2991350591182709,
-0.3002622127532959,
-0.011917809024453163,
0.41157403588294983,
-0.2965531051158905,
-0.5614143013954163,
-1.159604787826538,
-0.25096356868743896,
-0.2376982420682907,
1.6569595336914062,
-0.1824953407049179,
-0.023311715573072433,
-0.024849599227309227,
-0.37526485323905945,
0.1363113522529602,
-1.0131295919418335,
-0.7554380893707275,
-0.06190741807222366,
0.7092861533164978,
0.015504656359553337,
0.8027782440185547,
0.6593992114067078,
0.5708690881729126,
0.2691100835800171,
0.0782691091299057,
0.4944056272506714,
-0.4391293227672577,
0.14774304628372192,
0.12655754387378693,
-0.21686899662017822,
-0.21132373809814453,
-0.032644305378198624,
0.4718254506587982,
0.44686785340309143,
-0.17691314220428467,
-0.22581888735294342,
0.08739825338125229,
0.4134702682495117,
-0.7100341320037842,
0.06341752409934998,
-0.44162312150001526,
-0.025722017511725426,
-0.4445604085922241,
-0.2588687241077423,
-0.4092227518558502,
-0.4207670986652374,
0.3928107023239136,
-0.5080083012580872,
0.763227641582489,
-0.181692436337471,
1.2331384420394897,
0.23766040802001953,
-0.528741180896759,
-0.16155430674552917,
-0.7732532620429993,
0.7098381519317627,
-0.1770339459180832,
0.24418412148952484,
0.28929468989372253,
0.4770605266094208,
-0.13576653599739075,
-0.8956235647201538,
-0.40326109528541565,
0.05976830795407295,
0.2537500560283661,
0.14450915157794952,
-0.14231343567371368,
-0.17628440260887146,
-0.1680922657251358,
0.40003058314323425,
-0.688576877117157,
0.07312886416912079,
-0.4024193584918976,
-0.006404847837984562,
0.7568530440330505,
-0.06413345783948898,
0.07201627641916275,
0.5167689323425293,
-0.9016494154930115,
-0.25711295008659363,
-0.41417497396469116,
0.03558371216058731,
0.5347469449043274,
0.2676715850830078,
0.11817958205938339,
0.08207999169826508,
0.23933075368404388,
0.2986379861831665,
0.042620059102773666,
-0.0766473338007927,
0.12228687107563019,
-0.19708706438541412,
-0.2552870512008667,
-0.02540707401931286,
1.2213259935379028,
-0.25879815220832825,
0.03425351157784462,
-0.10329239815473557,
-0.11753156781196594,
0.02310456708073616,
0.6793110966682434,
-0.713010847568512,
-0.8521406054496765,
-0.13660447299480438,
-0.44760435819625854,
-0.7042750120162964,
0.005640498362481594,
-0.841590940952301,
-0.7067169547080994,
-0.11351954191923141,
0.5061324834823608,
-0.38798215985298157,
-0.2681349515914917,
-0.061974409967660904,
-0.1268501728773117,
-0.6026891469955444,
0.4390738010406494,
-0.7348637580871582,
0.3176516890525818,
0.3531162738800049,
0.9258690476417542,
-0.44236183166503906,
-0.4401381313800812,
-0.2854083478450775,
0.024653717875480652,
-0.147773876786232,
0.651833713054657,
-0.48747003078460693,
-0.38583680987358093,
-0.04161457344889641,
0.141496941447258,
-0.2937586307525635,
-0.37080681324005127,
0.2889610826969147,
-0.8867517709732056,
0.10099439322948456,
0.21499574184417725,
-0.05459854379296303,
-0.27778610587120056,
0.2651790380477905,
-0.7469671964645386,
0.7778737545013428,
-0.01876452937722206,
-0.7655890583992004,
0.2749740183353424,
-0.39728066325187683,
-0.6318454146385193,
-0.12179865688085556,
-0.15558010339736938,
-1.1891067028045654,
-0.08619065582752228,
0.01413638610392809,
0.6530203819274902,
-0.26803064346313477,
0.34090641140937805,
-0.7706358432769775,
-0.30708709359169006,
0.3066180348396301,
-0.8843305110931396,
0.7485646605491638,
0.38393115997314453,
-0.3362196385860443,
0.22794030606746674,
-0.8129797577857971,
-0.16378994286060333,
0.37349289655685425,
-0.3712388575077057,
-0.527015745639801,
-0.15676657855510712,
-0.04656825587153435,
0.24172501266002655,
0.14593465626239777,
-0.20019957423210144,
0.22496485710144043,
-0.07821101695299149,
0.30792754888534546,
0.7570118308067322,
0.2001909613609314,
0.5045338869094849,
-0.33171653747558594,
0.38213542103767395,
0.31703415513038635,
0.11728872358798981,
0.1961280256509781,
-0.6186617016792297,
-0.45172104239463806,
-0.9721290469169617,
0.42235511541366577,
0.3510614037513733,
-0.9286230802536011,
0.19698020815849304,
-0.24454663693904877,
-0.6612386107444763,
-0.3075791597366333,
0.024041755124926567,
0.4823816120624542,
0.032297853380441666,
0.5623533129692078,
-0.27018651366233826,
-0.16266275942325592,
-0.8343543410301208,
0.07573145627975464,
0.06380042433738708,
0.037580352276563644,
0.24059389531612396,
0.5965995192527771,
-0.2726210653781891,
0.33325403928756714,
-0.7148424983024597,
-0.506711483001709,
-0.0525093749165535,
0.5829687714576721,
-0.4286860227584839,
0.27959343791007996,
0.5424332022666931,
-1.2231820821762085,
-0.4387647807598114,
0.19823585450649261,
-0.784665584564209,
0.3193407654762268,
-0.150310680270195,
-0.14641408622264862,
0.035464316606521606,
-0.06215020641684532,
-0.2959240674972534,
0.531084418296814,
0.39810413122177124,
0.053568221628665924,
0.7394281029701233,
-0.41207197308540344,
0.366628497838974,
-0.9825892448425293,
-0.09349722415208817,
0.3297773599624634,
-0.03455618396401405,
-0.7913824915885925,
0.14143092930316925,
0.22297325730323792,
-0.22874689102172852,
-0.4042021930217743,
0.2392626404762268,
-0.17094144225120544,
0.2763303816318512,
-0.4676760733127594,
-0.01862938329577446,
0.2708738148212433,
0.7341515421867371,
0.21887417137622833,
0.8712211847305298,
0.49022090435028076,
-0.9917553067207336,
0.3573688566684723,
0.08205890655517578,
0.126580610871315,
0.4738663136959076,
-0.3472890257835388,
0.06485217064619064,
-0.01898207515478134,
0.3824208080768585,
-0.6561216115951538,
0.10030999034643173,
0.2677261531352997,
-0.4485439956188202,
0.5808857679367065,
-0.16624249517917633,
-0.3842959702014923,
-0.2859484553337097,
-0.35271885991096497,
0.27698585391044617,
-0.055933255702257156,
-0.8520109057426453,
0.41170576214790344,
0.6737794876098633,
-0.19104641675949097,
-0.7539247870445251,
-0.6634660363197327,
0.06595289707183838,
-0.33615773916244507,
-0.427708238363266,
0.46607834100723267,
-0.01670714095234871,
0.2176813930273056,
-0.019126081839203835,
-0.10058514773845673,
-0.5617203116416931,
0.3274722397327423,
0.25128424167633057,
0.3600348234176636,
-0.15630747377872467,
0.04049859568476677,
0.11369111388921738,
-0.07404505461454391,
-0.09582775086164474,
-0.6204313039779663,
0.12393508106470108,
-0.16065827012062073,
-0.04331875219941139,
-0.46810662746429443,
0.40696248412132263,
0.5530682802200317,
-0.4068395495414734,
1.031622290611267,
0.7428710460662842,
-0.41738030314445496,
-0.5960795879364014,
0.008315487764775753,
0.058806225657463074,
-0.42946815490722656,
0.32060056924819946,
-0.7190352082252502,
-0.8917084336280823,
0.36938464641571045,
-0.20915625989437103,
-0.1926787793636322,
0.4481137692928314,
0.4542831480503082,
0.12049762159585953,
1.1969636678695679,
0.7592984437942505,
-0.03218914940953255,
0.3786422908306122,
-0.4223209619522095,
0.19488006830215454,
-0.6753571033477783,
-0.15980415046215057,
-0.4583243131637573,
-0.234915092587471,
-0.34568601846694946,
-0.26374977827072144,
0.07396558672189713,
0.05623546615242958,
-0.29154327511787415,
0.5272911787033081,
-0.6089273691177368,
0.04719323292374611,
0.6166263818740845,
0.3284751772880554,
0.04638928174972534,
0.07677268236875534,
-0.19003213942050934,
-0.07181531935930252,
-0.5051423907279968,
-0.435569703578949,
1.1223608255386353,
0.41790837049484253,
0.7392436265945435,
0.3684440851211548,
0.606134831905365,
0.4798947870731354,
0.491659939289093,
-0.5697112679481506,
0.2599254548549652,
-0.7369049191474915,
-0.3958897590637207,
-0.03908854350447655,
-0.8403357863426208,
-0.6877530813217163,
0.5443035960197449,
-0.15632770955562592,
-0.450853168964386,
0.5616673827171326,
-0.21044230461120605,
-0.34442681074142456,
0.6360519528388977,
-0.6449877619743347,
0.9281512498855591,
-0.27305230498313904,
-0.366659015417099,
0.14641979336738586,
-0.5545954704284668,
0.4898771345615387,
-0.45057904720306396,
0.11607778072357178,
0.2242889106273651,
0.06495938450098038,
0.7046290040016174,
-0.2532705068588257,
0.7208241820335388,
-0.3179861307144165,
-0.07547177374362946,
0.25395330786705017,
-0.011099754832684994,
0.6698764562606812,
0.005726001691073179,
0.035256218165159225,
0.4252660870552063,
-0.13355454802513123,
-0.291133850812912,
-0.554951012134552,
0.8226528763771057,
-1.0175367593765259,
-0.22570452094078064,
-0.7028705477714539,
-0.31653106212615967,
-0.2144451141357422,
0.2898610830307007,
0.4123910963535309,
0.42574310302734375,
-0.27626878023147583,
0.19567538797855377,
0.98651522397995,
-0.07174116373062134,
0.1374664008617401,
0.3303315341472626,
0.43903079628944397,
-0.6055173277854919,
1.3662053346633911,
0.1599528193473816,
0.326779842376709,
0.41167744994163513,
0.1304616779088974,
-0.41886359453201294,
-0.8147663474082947,
-0.7312744855880737,
-0.1682615876197815,
-0.6068056225776672,
-0.41428062319755554,
-0.7996832132339478,
-0.5526922941207886,
-0.42179372906684875,
-0.18827836215496063,
-0.3015562891960144,
-0.36866870522499084,
-0.4850989878177643,
0.027300627902150154,
0.15820296108722687,
0.6010465025901794,
0.12682689726352692,
0.501624345779419,
-0.7262730598449707,
0.32244712114334106,
0.326826810836792,
0.20891022682189941,
0.001600275281816721,
-0.5280534029006958,
-0.4122246205806732,
0.02078528329730034,
-0.5599427819252014,
-0.5932506918907166,
0.4709183871746063,
0.3069898784160614,
0.4807356894016266,
0.6488523483276367,
0.48423588275909424,
0.5634986758232117,
-0.6120757460594177,
0.5442832708358765,
0.304707407951355,
-0.4393763542175293,
0.2555767893791199,
-0.20793187618255615,
-0.1407696157693863,
0.516103208065033,
0.6940271854400635,
-0.058826714754104614,
-0.5493772029876709,
-0.663087010383606,
-0.7195876836776733,
0.7336077690124512,
0.13802050054073334,
-0.25086042284965515,
0.06145864725112915,
0.11185348778963089,
0.3192145526409149,
0.34205979108810425,
-0.428945392370224,
-0.5250046849250793,
-0.5200237035751343,
-0.6246659159660339,
0.027919776737689972,
-0.011187925934791565,
-0.34891292452812195,
0.4041825532913208,
0.8451019525527954,
-0.09320710599422455,
0.3557158410549164,
-0.04172400385141373,
-0.10717184841632843,
0.2854894697666168,
0.1906723529100418,
0.7995619773864746,
0.13705039024353027,
-0.04145263135433197,
0.5153934955596924,
-0.0043977308087050915,
-0.8038419485092163,
0.3311145603656769,
0.7057086229324341,
-0.23300506174564362,
-0.30851978063583374,
-0.11807678639888763,
0.7251813411712646,
0.03983040153980255,
-0.07760317623615265,
0.7426966428756714,
-0.562937319278717,
-0.6023244261741638,
-0.06866130977869034,
0.0947505384683609,
-0.5301234126091003,
0.2811645567417145,
0.36205533146858215,
0.8827122449874878,
0.3203781247138977,
-0.0152237918227911,
0.5554273724555969,
0.2714444100856781,
-0.6931079626083374,
-0.2215263843536377,
1.0116677284240723,
-0.09751736372709274,
-0.06645897775888443,
-0.017327357083559036,
-0.4342972934246063,
-0.7761945724487305,
0.5198540687561035,
0.4863850176334381,
0.8782409429550171,
-0.23641668260097504,
0.4204416573047638,
-0.10607215762138367,
0.1630532592535019,
-0.2658149302005768,
-0.2638600468635559,
-0.17957966029644012,
-0.5911356806755066,
0.17175206542015076,
-0.5075894594192505,
-0.3528040647506714,
0.1978963166475296,
-0.5585828423500061,
0.04153585806488991,
-0.8662905693054199,
-0.249714195728302,
0.17953425645828247,
0.24469609558582306,
-0.5181822180747986,
0.4625667333602905,
0.005730801727622747,
0.29246947169303894,
-0.655076801776886,
1.203026533126831,
0.7342497706413269,
-0.4254961907863617,
-0.25244656205177307,
0.06911909580230713,
0.4161371886730194,
-0.4945771098136902,
0.4518393874168396,
0.20416666567325592,
-0.43849650025367737,
-0.1854972094297409,
-0.131117582321167,
-0.5990955829620361,
0.8331296443939209,
-0.15051057934761047,
-0.1761312037706375,
0.2966076135635376,
-0.05074585601687431,
0.5356783866882324,
-0.3261469304561615,
-0.15175612270832062,
0.075904980301857,
0.08824852854013443,
-0.0615515299141407,
-0.4516094923019409,
0.12741082906723022,
-0.3386075496673584,
0.14530663192272186,
0.3318825662136078,
-0.6441259980201721,
0.6253743767738342,
-0.20015698671340942,
-0.5043612122535706,
-0.06884025782346725,
0.7593967914581299,
0.2140597403049469,
0.4863145053386688,
0.3362252116203308,
0.5678306221961975,
1.0264179706573486,
-0.17413905262947083,
0.9214913845062256,
0.08601370453834534,
0.34826529026031494,
1.0528960227966309,
-0.22404474020004272,
0.717165470123291,
-0.1790040284395218,
-0.15949887037277222,
0.4077175557613373,
0.7316814064979553,
-0.21530920267105103,
0.8539394736289978,
0.10868890583515167,
-0.6244430541992188,
-0.004938486963510513,
0.09085725992918015,
-0.38788506388664246,
0.02224903739988804,
0.3582291305065155,
-0.37130650877952576,
0.17312343418598175,
0.410739004611969,
0.06357667595148087,
0.14381492137908936,
-0.1550825983285904,
0.6716881990432739,
0.07501445710659027,
-0.0285181924700737,
0.3511405885219574,
0.39101642370224,
0.8384184241294861,
-0.7582030892372131,
0.39216527342796326,
0.17302609980106354,
0.8159385323524475,
0.12115656584501266,
-0.6607121825218201,
0.21692322194576263,
-0.03596419095993042,
-0.5286601185798645,
-0.23475368320941925,
0.7428040504455566,
-0.5760197639465332,
-0.17640899121761322,
0.37045007944107056,
-0.13628725707530975,
-0.11959844082593918,
-0.20862111449241638,
-0.692607581615448,
-0.24578864872455597,
-0.2049611210823059,
-0.12566176056861877,
0.6845507025718689,
0.7316573262214661,
-0.015669748187065125,
0.5139291286468506,
0.9287433624267578,
0.09333651512861252,
0.05437227711081505,
0.18206308782100677,
0.7838552594184875,
-0.3507041335105896,
-0.630971372127533,
-0.5464101433753967,
0.24426089227199554,
-0.2198532372713089,
-0.479147732257843,
0.7344759702682495,
0.4889598786830902,
0.8128713369369507,
-0.03583274781703949,
0.9461644887924194,
0.3191472291946411,
0.271066814661026,
-0.13966386020183563,
1.1077195405960083,
-0.673879086971283,
0.18732522428035736,
0.11231627315282822,
-0.4242025911808014,
-0.5932573080062866,
0.3989277184009552,
-0.11073523759841919,
0.022005854174494743,
0.7719780802726746,
0.5854910612106323,
-0.04909365624189377,
0.2725188136100769,
0.3027307093143463,
-0.15510150790214539,
0.5358783006668091,
0.5448169112205505,
0.6645066738128662,
-0.6539879441261292,
1.175296425819397,
-0.2735704183578491,
-0.4850119948387146,
-0.1071084588766098,
-0.3173602819442749,
-0.9632492065429688,
-0.5245025157928467,
-0.49084991216659546,
-0.444807767868042,
0.38526466488838196,
0.3919728100299835,
0.8779757022857666,
-1.0018794536590576,
0.3432391881942749,
0.20641563832759857,
0.09258054941892624,
-0.6351708173751831,
-0.2811933755874634,
0.6422302722930908,
-0.2542203962802887,
-0.6349807977676392,
0.42891332507133484,
0.2674010097980499,
0.11608362197875977,
-0.1427181214094162,
-0.038071174174547195,
-0.2415637969970703,
-0.04692927375435829,
0.46691563725471497,
0.2804396450519562,
-0.23870231211185455,
-0.11763915419578552,
-0.1779889017343521,
-0.5676952600479126,
-0.12859505414962769,
0.662152886390686,
-0.3909495174884796,
0.3827594518661499,
0.25585776567459106,
1.0558406114578247,
0.4874935746192932,
-0.027565035969018936,
0.49535199999809265,
-0.9686862230300903,
-0.15475048124790192,
0.04893455654382706,
0.2675279378890991,
0.1788453906774521,
-0.5206783413887024,
0.19975198805332184,
0.541710376739502,
-0.7015302777290344,
-0.718329131603241,
0.11083535104990005,
-0.5258930921554565,
-0.45818421244621277,
0.6399614214897156,
-0.5244936347007751,
-0.231854647397995,
-0.4514657258987427,
-0.01288034487515688,
0.2715744078159332,
-0.44831550121307373,
0.7802746295928955,
0.5223824977874756,
0.19838763773441315,
-0.12470275163650513,
-0.3928089439868927,
0.5697079300880432,
-0.08886699378490448,
-0.648716151714325,
0.07484925538301468,
0.16410934925079346,
0.05568823590874672,
0.3103783130645752,
0.4698488414287567,
-0.15542596578598022,
0.1323261260986328,
0.3022293746471405,
-0.047345612198114395,
-0.4037691652774811,
-1.0103750228881836,
-0.4413883090019226,
0.5513190031051636,
-0.397136390209198,
-0.49113500118255615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17710v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17710v2
|
Does Geo-co-location Matter? A Case Study of Public Health Conversations during COVID-19
| 2024-05-28T00:00:04 | 2024-06-28T06:24:37 |
Paiheng Xu, Louiqa Raschid, Vanessa Frias-Martinez
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.CL
|
Social media platforms like Twitter (now X) have been pivotal in information
dissemination and public engagement, especially during COVID-19. A key goal for
public health experts was to encourage prosocial behavior that could impact
local outcomes such as masking and social distancing. Given the importance of
local news and guidance during COVID-19, the objective of our research is to
analyze the effect of localized engagement, on social media conversations. This
study examines the impact of geographic co-location, as a proxy for localized
engagement between public health experts (PHEs) and the public, on social
media. We analyze a Twitter conversation dataset from January 2020 to November
2021, comprising over 19 K tweets from nearly five hundred PHEs, along with
approximately 800 K replies from 350 K participants. Our findings reveal that
geo-co-location is associated with higher engagement rates, especially in
conversations on topics including masking, lockdowns, and education, and in
conversations with academic and medical professionals. Lexical features
associated with emotion and personal experiences were more common in
geo-co-located contexts. This research provides insights into how geographic
co-location influences social media engagement and can inform strategies to
improve public health messaging.
|
[
-0.35676297545433044,
-0.9716485738754272,
0.8432797193527222,
0.33450764417648315,
-0.18377120792865753,
0.3327355682849884,
-0.23023127019405365,
-0.7528678774833679,
1.1464697122573853,
-0.1319189816713333,
-0.16356082260608673,
-0.786769449710846,
-0.552823543548584,
-0.19153694808483124,
-0.18557336926460266,
0.7011530995368958,
-0.12600304186344147,
-0.2622869610786438,
-0.023448389023542404,
-0.13550522923469543,
-0.33288493752479553,
-0.7828336358070374,
-0.8140017986297607,
0.2108672857284546,
0.9244260191917419,
0.48934629559516907,
0.8042868971824646,
0.12351655215024948,
0.5849490165710449,
0.19920550286769867,
-0.2705193758010864,
-0.1449621468782425,
-0.8179677128791809,
-0.15308184921741486,
-0.293905109167099,
-0.09360137581825256,
-0.3474254310131073,
0.048309940844774246,
0.01649944856762886,
0.32726365327835083,
-0.10056616365909576,
0.3664763271808624,
-0.2928207814693451,
0.16144026815891266,
-0.5155608057975769,
-0.2411545366048813,
-0.16063830256462097,
0.0732441321015358,
-0.37962254881858826,
-0.40058764815330505,
0.2650279104709625,
-0.7222070693969727,
0.6922195553779602,
-0.34101009368896484,
0.44848158955574036,
-0.30185991525650024,
0.8402449488639832,
0.0852363184094429,
-0.8277336955070496,
0.05823603272438049,
-0.8954342603683472,
0.3613998591899872,
-0.16398386657238007,
0.20997895300388336,
0.48407796025276184,
0.170784130692482,
-0.23166082799434662,
-0.3650221824645996,
-0.11454252153635025,
0.4400933086872101,
-0.14724957942962646,
-0.02202661894261837,
-0.6317768692970276,
-0.2361280769109726,
-0.031090782955288887,
0.09326312690973282,
-0.35907095670700073,
-0.1758916825056076,
-0.6147834062576294,
-0.07508810609579086,
0.8664558529853821,
-0.12831424176692963,
0.6580726504325867,
-0.14475488662719727,
-0.0494246631860733,
0.3709772825241089,
-0.5596922636032104,
0.44084420800209045,
-0.14917263388633728,
-0.01412909384816885,
-0.7781931161880493,
0.19522371888160706,
-0.12329965829849243,
0.005194066092371941,
0.29644641280174255,
0.0344257615506649,
-0.08192084729671478,
-0.4958397150039673,
-0.005122995935380459,
0.3840761184692383,
0.6817504167556763,
0.5981240272521973,
-0.20085284113883972,
-0.09366637468338013,
0.45207715034484863,
-0.28243890404701233,
0.268994003534317,
-0.652458131313324,
-0.4106176495552063,
0.34636956453323364,
-0.4377073049545288,
-0.0005312526482157409,
0.33045902848243713,
-0.727348268032074,
-0.6370773315429688,
0.18529300391674042,
0.07750757038593292,
0.2295934110879898,
-0.351172536611557,
-0.04821360111236572,
-0.2198399156332016,
-0.25797268748283386,
0.3206663131713867,
-0.7772923111915588,
0.1781114786863327,
0.6455326080322266,
0.9763906598091125,
0.13261520862579346,
0.08599724620580673,
-0.41669604182243347,
0.06480567902326584,
-0.6070218682289124,
0.5152891278266907,
-0.46798020601272583,
-0.24179011583328247,
0.15735097229480743,
-0.10818742960691452,
-0.19133636355400085,
-0.3393772542476654,
0.3339715600013733,
-0.4499232769012451,
0.12928175926208496,
-0.8945462107658386,
0.4684891402721405,
-0.098597951233387,
-0.005462040659040213,
-0.14275604486465454,
0.8330864310264587,
-0.07783433049917221,
-0.7633267045021057,
0.42944759130477905,
-0.5179666876792908,
-0.7955303192138672,
0.21499475836753845,
-0.3040964901447296,
-0.37626171112060547,
0.2625548839569092,
0.7268796563148499,
0.3390645682811737,
-0.04369714856147766,
0.3923923075199127,
-0.48197856545448303,
-0.4586239457130432,
0.0033091886434704065,
0.03327557444572449,
0.6588849425315857,
-0.12049868702888489,
-0.703787088394165,
-0.12024718523025513,
-0.20969612896442413,
-0.20031008124351501,
0.0012819393305107951,
0.11037351936101913,
-0.6910610198974609,
0.10281038284301758,
-0.5076909065246582,
0.19342093169689178,
0.15542131662368774,
-0.6152912974357605,
-0.32000279426574707,
-0.34422871470451355,
0.6402303576469421,
0.08261627703905106,
0.9724717736244202,
0.5475354790687561,
-0.28340327739715576,
0.6189911365509033,
-0.18536654114723206,
0.5977396368980408,
0.3553483486175537,
-0.7989721298217773,
0.01799701899290085,
-0.3586845397949219,
-0.484372615814209,
0.33037176728248596,
-0.24538156390190125,
0.14675910770893097,
-0.25719815492630005,
-0.8387854099273682,
-0.36090752482414246,
-0.47547945380210876,
-0.08537960052490234,
0.4406013786792755,
0.17599165439605713,
0.2027329057455063,
-0.5227442383766174,
-0.3854448199272156,
-0.07684670388698578,
-0.004850802943110466,
0.41161179542541504,
0.5004512667655945,
0.12423674762248993,
-0.053177013993263245,
0.9922363758087158,
-0.44380494952201843,
-0.1595304161310196,
-0.10754384845495224,
0.32456135749816895,
-0.19750036299228668,
-0.12085487693548203,
0.745555579662323,
-0.9025762677192688,
-0.8589730858802795,
-0.03839162737131119,
-0.6332180500030518,
-0.3914068341255188,
0.004478082526475191,
-0.38254454731941223,
-0.07949844747781754,
0.37425175309181213,
-0.40905845165252686,
0.923457145690918,
0.9340099692344666,
-0.26169443130493164,
-0.0444384329020977,
-0.2190910428762436,
0.5654323697090149,
-1.1807321310043335,
-0.09734132140874863,
0.20636937022209167,
0.08371875435113907,
-0.8110359907150269,
-0.256162166595459,
-0.42149606347084045,
-0.49766021966934204,
-0.4061880111694336,
0.34329158067703247,
-0.17411065101623535,
0.025514720007777214,
-0.022308362647891045,
-0.01901308260858059,
0.1538492888212204,
-0.4479166865348816,
0.3290741741657257,
0.6446747183799744,
0.49005740880966187,
-0.17077776789665222,
-0.11854235827922821,
0.19949308037757874,
-0.4006895422935486,
0.3172224760055542,
-0.566291332244873,
0.14491713047027588,
0.08345711976289749,
0.5767714977264404,
-0.7758365869522095,
-0.3925114870071411,
0.3489142954349518,
-0.4365190267562866,
-0.6941956877708435,
0.10069582611322403,
-0.20862498879432678,
-0.5632702112197876,
-0.2064841389656067,
0.3626248240470886,
-0.03350372985005379,
-0.23323923349380493,
0.10719702392816544,
0.883540689945221,
-0.37994542717933655,
-0.16297923028469086,
-0.7247021198272705,
0.3663969337940216,
-0.3351150453090668,
-0.8139193654060364,
0.27180641889572144,
0.44638070464134216,
-0.49531081318855286,
0.05254822596907616,
-0.055857591331005096,
-0.24808596074581146,
0.34660255908966064,
0.43743401765823364,
-0.34916403889656067,
-0.08909519761800766,
0.20270824432373047,
-0.14669658243656158,
0.24409903585910797,
0.2975860834121704,
0.21763767302036285,
0.6688659191131592,
0.01125477533787489,
-0.2729417681694031,
-0.7980685234069824,
0.85140460729599,
0.478241890668869,
-0.39083436131477356,
0.9260847568511963,
0.7297032475471497,
-0.5368638038635254,
0.6518449783325195,
-0.38293036818504333,
-0.272480845451355,
-0.45051950216293335,
0.15015216171741486,
0.29227370023727417,
-0.8718097805976868,
0.559222400188446,
0.08845378458499908,
-0.4811515808105469,
-0.031712520867586136,
0.3625197112560272,
-0.4181729257106781,
0.6052231192588806,
0.5615240335464478,
-0.32632169127464294,
0.5032779574394226,
0.04132450744509697,
1.0493327379226685,
-0.13865205645561218,
-0.40843623876571655,
-0.5465894937515259,
-0.30188846588134766,
-0.7108949422836304,
-0.4195044934749603,
0.7275916934013367,
-0.04717531427741051,
-0.19990836083889008,
0.11099358648061752,
-0.48456692695617676,
0.20619387924671173,
0.40009698271751404,
0.3476828932762146,
-0.3167814314365387,
0.27019545435905457,
0.25439056754112244,
-0.46425512433052063,
-0.8907858729362488,
0.022917121648788452,
0.206497460603714,
0.1690794825553894,
0.48209530115127563,
0.3796607553958893,
1.0495935678482056,
0.26381394267082214,
-0.03414202854037285,
-0.22729195654392242,
0.38730356097221375,
0.11153976619243622,
-0.38107937574386597,
-0.32046613097190857,
-0.11469079554080963,
-1.2509746551513672,
-0.3912055790424347,
-0.46795654296875,
-0.9900934100151062,
0.6506911516189575,
-0.1683570295572281,
-0.8529930114746094,
0.30193060636520386,
-0.7137863039970398,
0.5580494999885559,
-0.2172102928161621,
-0.33484378457069397,
-0.29178187251091003,
-0.556122362613678,
-0.22295770049095154,
-0.19928205013275146,
0.45586109161376953,
-0.2914748787879944,
0.3739354610443115,
0.6253684163093567,
-0.5549522042274475,
0.9839267730712891,
-0.09660165756940842,
0.06759634613990784,
0.5205084681510925,
-0.28416794538497925,
0.3346719741821289,
0.3847807049751282,
0.17440921068191528,
0.4646070599555969,
-0.1549796462059021,
-0.45479264855384827,
-0.1329290270805359,
0.7014050483703613,
-1.1950709819793701,
-0.7790113687515259,
-0.3338771164417267,
-0.43613409996032715,
0.22352254390716553,
0.06703728437423706,
0.31154757738113403,
0.5379143357276917,
-0.06317499279975891,
0.060983750969171524,
0.5727618932723999,
-0.36516714096069336,
0.3228641152381897,
0.1855958253145218,
0.08244805783033371,
-0.5789192318916321,
0.6713424921035767,
0.49735260009765625,
-0.06391390413045883,
0.5491195321083069,
0.7499575614929199,
-0.03163611888885498,
-0.05814209207892418,
0.39608895778656006,
0.2380782812833786,
-0.4347643256187439,
0.04172714799642563,
-0.6323875188827515,
-0.06331708282232285,
-0.8288286328315735,
-0.8126447200775146,
-0.10631167143583298,
0.24969251453876495,
-0.2881738543510437,
-0.1180371418595314,
0.6367730498313904,
0.9486240744590759,
-0.47803378105163574,
0.3571683168411255,
-0.7110608816146851,
0.026142893359065056,
0.25430771708488464,
0.046733103692531586,
-0.2819605767726898,
0.01544270757585764,
-0.619383692741394,
-0.0529775395989418,
0.021411173045635223,
-1.1355528831481934,
0.3048820495605469,
-0.18478554487228394,
0.3331868052482605,
0.43494945764541626,
0.4667198359966278,
1.2130746841430664,
-0.05026933178305626,
0.9754999876022339,
-0.03332231193780899,
-0.6203126907348633,
0.650135338306427,
-0.8295736312866211,
0.6311905980110168,
0.5027937293052673,
0.6275050640106201,
-0.9757779240608215,
-0.7154268622398376,
-0.5823409557342529,
-0.8890620470046997,
0.09342198818922043,
-0.13633185625076294,
0.18982619047164917,
-0.38372549414634705,
0.16776348650455475,
-0.25355035066604614,
-0.00033114917459897697,
-0.43632617592811584,
-0.32092174887657166,
0.18047796189785004,
0.4135579764842987,
0.06419271975755692,
-0.6433852910995483,
-0.511649489402771,
-0.3434392213821411,
0.10259973257780075,
0.6048580408096313,
0.4126487970352173,
0.5915964245796204,
0.42958080768585205,
-0.4506966173648834,
0.19908733665943146,
0.7788394093513489,
0.894822359085083,
-0.38826313614845276,
0.3994846045970917,
0.0619521364569664,
-0.5948876142501831,
0.03142401576042175,
-0.00429218215867877,
-0.2077323943376541,
0.22750942409038544,
0.22150354087352753,
0.4147127568721771,
0.4020630419254303,
0.14636977016925812,
0.5330970883369446,
-0.07803525775671005,
0.0016168988076969981,
-0.07263267040252686,
-0.43311503529548645,
0.3551144301891327,
0.46072256565093994,
0.5592544674873352,
0.0602477490901947,
-0.004014074802398682,
-0.5618270635604858,
0.18271248042583466,
0.2825736403465271,
-0.3695257306098938,
-0.6197071671485901,
0.9107800126075745,
0.41412225365638733,
-0.33057981729507446,
0.2977093458175659,
-0.015326167456805706,
-0.5375432372093201,
0.4579727351665497,
0.3473288118839264,
0.561492919921875,
-0.41309022903442383,
0.5340492129325867,
0.3482830226421356,
0.34439632296562195,
0.3213924467563629,
0.29139867424964905,
0.06871488690376282,
-0.4208144247531891,
-0.4542449414730072,
0.20519685745239258,
-0.32034537196159363,
0.1514541357755661,
-0.6754879951477051,
0.2466478794813156,
-0.32051780819892883,
-0.7435570359230042,
-0.2996300756931305,
0.1472417265176773,
-0.5966696739196777,
0.18433381617069244,
0.520775556564331,
0.8894500732421875,
-1.39329195022583,
0.35857680439949036,
0.9444777369499207,
0.041107647120952606,
-0.8147664070129395,
0.6920467019081116,
0.1482071876525879,
-0.2943369150161743,
0.3735564351081848,
0.32646939158439636,
-0.17218999564647675,
-0.31962069869041443,
-0.5933229923248291,
-1.3083618879318237,
1.1738389730453491,
0.29774487018585205,
-0.21446307003498077,
0.43009620904922485,
0.5167933702468872,
0.8095770478248596,
-0.17137029767036438,
0.04846147820353508,
0.143530011177063,
0.1425294429063797,
-0.08107252418994904,
-1.1190084218978882,
-0.048243068158626556,
0.07189000397920609,
-0.18614867329597473,
0.026860442012548447,
-1.1784330606460571,
0.41596972942352295,
-0.3608185946941376,
-0.5196554660797119,
-0.5142788290977478,
0.48971277475357056,
0.12179271876811981,
0.8832191228866577,
-0.0819348692893982,
0.4526190161705017,
1.0506210327148438,
-0.033391762524843216,
1.1193749904632568,
-0.21780218183994293,
0.16571147739887238,
1.0590922832489014,
-0.2647700905799866,
0.9388538599014282,
0.4839344322681427,
0.10196846723556519,
0.4494855999946594,
0.8865789175033569,
0.6480274200439453,
0.7928580045700073,
-0.3370739221572876,
-0.6443797945976257,
-0.06344973295927048,
-0.604858934879303,
-0.5692518949508667,
0.34943848848342896,
0.2806330621242523,
-0.14209815859794617,
-0.42048853635787964,
0.061967480927705765,
0.5514503717422485,
0.060163263231515884,
-0.26592886447906494,
0.4612542688846588,
-0.18189594149589539,
-0.41216331720352173,
0.04854734241962433,
-0.07849027216434479,
0.05559435486793518,
-0.22666102647781372,
0.3262082636356354,
-0.24712103605270386,
-0.33630621433258057,
-0.47021767497062683,
-0.7553075551986694,
0.7319622039794922,
-0.2168453484773636,
-0.12182068079710007,
-0.14712677896022797,
0.8897961974143982,
-0.423744797706604,
-0.16725477576255798,
0.5067818760871887,
0.6048261523246765,
0.35325145721435547,
-0.43728628754615784,
-0.30492672324180603,
0.3571600914001465,
-0.2831498682498932,
0.05219278857111931,
0.3680163621902466,
0.596724808216095,
-0.40967026352882385,
0.16162002086639404,
0.6113885045051575,
0.21722330152988434,
0.11141777038574219,
-0.005352721083909273,
0.49679315090179443,
-0.24278493225574493,
-0.6658234000205994,
-0.7768211960792542,
0.14099018275737762,
-0.17761747539043427,
-0.04945452883839607,
0.9030551314353943,
0.39177754521369934,
0.5345606803894043,
0.3927035629749298,
0.8445844054222107,
-0.25645846128463745,
0.28008541464805603,
0.3556523323059082,
0.7853394150733948,
-0.18301256000995636,
-0.0768485739827156,
0.11563602089881897,
-0.3060234785079956,
-0.4660179018974304,
0.5315678119659424,
-1.4139283895492554,
-0.3812400698661804,
0.5437420010566711,
0.6290014386177063,
0.3318813443183899,
-0.12188628315925598,
0.22676981985569,
-0.08485006541013718,
0.33386164903640747,
0.20599724352359772,
0.5233932733535767,
-0.15568453073501587,
0.32290083169937134,
-0.5251234769821167,
-0.009501387365162373,
-0.44058579206466675,
-0.7028120160102844,
-0.805470883846283,
-0.4464680254459381,
-0.6434241533279419,
-0.48404982686042786,
0.31326037645339966,
1.043039321899414,
0.5551764965057373,
-0.5268949866294861,
0.20962685346603394,
0.18784567713737488,
0.20350266993045807,
-0.06880869716405869,
-0.26641783118247986,
0.6072812080383301,
0.21947456896305084,
-0.3477446734905243,
0.12214943766593933,
0.685160756111145,
-0.05184071883559227,
0.10141042619943619,
0.34488746523857117,
-0.46464821696281433,
-0.07413000613451004,
0.6665650010108948,
0.44843897223472595,
-0.4403969347476959,
-0.44154322147369385,
0.28927525877952576,
-0.5267907381057739,
0.396449476480484,
0.6948212385177612,
-0.5320364832878113,
0.5154330730438232,
0.461736261844635,
0.36925527453422546,
0.11477108299732208,
0.4235776364803314,
0.5595861673355103,
-0.8359584808349609,
0.13601332902908325,
-0.11145437508821487,
0.01411426067352295,
0.45570874214172363,
-0.856368899345398,
0.1560232937335968,
0.3703320622444153,
-0.8139772415161133,
-0.4688689112663269,
-0.2577022314071655,
-0.5748995542526245,
0.24651746451854706,
1.4703607559204102,
0.001567993313074112,
-0.24573291838169098,
-0.44024133682250977,
-0.09761493653059006,
0.3555312752723694,
-0.6389215588569641,
1.1352890729904175,
0.6602789759635925,
-0.05269898846745491,
-0.23402610421180725,
-0.5565552711486816,
0.4830501079559326,
0.21140241622924805,
-0.8162139654159546,
-0.3486652672290802,
-0.0007230488117784262,
0.11925725638866425,
0.17120680212974548,
1.060634970664978,
0.257729709148407,
0.3777512013912201,
-0.384924054145813,
-0.2000422328710556,
0.3212891221046448,
-0.30926769971847534,
-0.2688840627670288,
0.07901164144277573,
-0.2772471308708191,
-0.24883557856082916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17703v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17703v1
|
Mechanistic Interpretability of Binary and Ternary Transformers
| 2024-05-27T23:22:23 | 2024-05-27T23:22:23 |
Jason Li
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Recent research (arXiv:2310.11453, arXiv:2402.17764) has proposed binary and
ternary transformer networks as a way to significantly reduce memory and
improve inference speed in Large Language Models (LLMs) while maintaining
accuracy. In this work, we apply techniques from mechanistic interpretability
to investigate whether such networks learn distinctly different or similar
algorithms when compared to full-precision transformer networks. In particular,
we reverse engineer the algorithms learned for the toy problem of modular
addition where we find that binary and ternary networks learn similar
algorithms as full precision networks. This provides evidence against the
possibility of using binary and ternary networks as a more interpretable
alternative in the LLM setting.
|
[
-0.10378362238407135,
-0.5869909524917603,
0.6692666411399841,
0.2570268511772156,
-0.028686122968792915,
0.07729823887348175,
-0.31555622816085815,
-0.3707064092159271,
0.1858610361814499,
0.28757908940315247,
-0.7673062682151794,
-0.05327318236231804,
-0.6163627505302429,
0.2966230809688568,
-0.624121367931366,
0.6911338567733765,
0.046412743628025055,
0.04481138661503792,
0.18696381151676178,
-0.18968066573143005,
-0.3828805387020111,
-0.3812289237976074,
-0.6357961893081665,
-0.8232730031013489,
0.5281127095222473,
0.3181536793708801,
0.8982224464416504,
0.3109656870365143,
0.4698096811771393,
0.4362889528274536,
-0.2637629210948944,
-0.21252240240573883,
-0.468530535697937,
-0.08014260977506638,
-0.5143009424209595,
-0.8955507278442383,
-0.2601480782032013,
-0.3730919063091278,
0.5799145102500916,
0.8389402627944946,
0.059197887778282166,
0.27963268756866455,
-0.12872323393821716,
0.798565685749054,
-0.34635284543037415,
0.38662347197532654,
-0.5652537941932678,
0.2789783179759979,
0.03547948598861694,
-0.2615603804588318,
-0.7385372519493103,
-0.18386869132518768,
0.12562808394432068,
-0.35764580965042114,
0.47577500343322754,
-0.06945131719112396,
0.558944582939148,
0.13033054769039154,
-0.23060466349124908,
-0.14658069610595703,
-1.1136149168014526,
0.8709343671798706,
-0.7909218668937683,
0.4632357060909271,
-0.18285655975341797,
0.4451276361942291,
-0.1329147219657898,
-0.7274628281593323,
-0.8961753249168396,
0.09354505687952042,
-0.39491167664527893,
0.03748231753706932,
-0.3497835099697113,
0.08474639058113098,
0.41960427165031433,
0.21273711323738098,
-0.5648360848426819,
0.2717440128326416,
-0.6202037930488586,
-0.04384738951921463,
0.37901660799980164,
0.27444973587989807,
0.29038864374160767,
-0.3085285425186157,
-0.11844875663518906,
-0.11316634714603424,
-0.6051720380783081,
0.1396542638540268,
0.3802069425582886,
0.21507520973682404,
-0.2000545710325241,
0.7108749747276306,
-0.15000154078006744,
0.4312620460987091,
0.0739511027932167,
0.03422102332115173,
0.22586436569690704,
-0.23675638437271118,
-0.31086447834968567,
0.10584288835525513,
0.7016443610191345,
0.2791602909564972,
0.6620607376098633,
-0.48183006048202515,
-0.13830852508544922,
-0.09414123743772507,
0.4806033670902252,
-0.7238130569458008,
-0.405095636844635,
0.06865807622671127,
-0.9343468546867371,
-0.40886232256889343,
0.2595755159854889,
-0.10279123485088348,
0.14644716680049896,
-0.4589858055114746,
0.7849209308624268,
-0.24811065196990967,
-0.38180869817733765,
0.3110056221485138,
-0.4402100443840027,
0.33719778060913086,
0.10703758895397186,
-1.0624276399612427,
0.4019854664802551,
1.0889737606048584,
0.9497541189193726,
-0.02436274103820324,
-0.36573779582977295,
-0.01493037585169077,
0.07299356907606125,
-0.21944394707679749,
0.5586515069007874,
-0.5972243547439575,
-0.21932421624660492,
-0.5381978154182434,
0.37986865639686584,
-0.21836775541305542,
-0.6427740454673767,
0.1752147376537323,
-0.9469323754310608,
-0.07909438014030457,
0.038993965834379196,
-0.2112841159105301,
-0.5127622485160828,
-0.043599553406238556,
-0.9740992784500122,
0.5707177519798279,
0.1962902843952179,
-0.4488098919391632,
0.13765084743499756,
-0.5560259819030762,
-0.6648637056350708,
-0.47544875741004944,
0.09679657220840454,
-0.3915441632270813,
0.5702134370803833,
-0.14249804615974426,
0.5174453258514404,
-0.2273719757795334,
0.428608775138855,
-0.44482114911079407,
-0.8073961734771729,
0.6773276329040527,
-0.8890957832336426,
0.8889157176017761,
0.057021353393793106,
-0.5728614926338196,
0.12339679896831512,
-0.6677677035331726,
-0.1737697869539261,
0.0757300853729248,
-0.16839778423309326,
-0.01567767933011055,
0.173108771443367,
-0.2644895911216736,
0.10639970004558563,
0.02205590531229973,
-0.5016247034072876,
0.03422423452138901,
-0.5798913836479187,
0.744943380355835,
0.9388332962989807,
-0.1849389523267746,
0.6441903114318848,
-0.2788018584251404,
0.17913785576820374,
0.1156812384724617,
0.15490058064460754,
0.14793427288532257,
-0.5060186982154846,
-0.8081271648406982,
0.2591772973537445,
0.3426482677459717,
0.4534209370613098,
-1.0025110244750977,
0.46883127093315125,
-0.7772324681282043,
-0.27757003903388977,
-0.07021760940551758,
-0.026095926761627197,
0.22490696609020233,
0.5158994793891907,
0.5131371021270752,
-0.4509391486644745,
-0.4530177116394043,
-1.2011289596557617,
-0.19301167130470276,
-0.3887510895729065,
-0.22513262927532196,
0.2616097927093506,
0.4787208139896393,
-0.11852836608886719,
0.7771745920181274,
-0.40142491459846497,
0.29506024718284607,
-0.1388876885175705,
0.10020117461681366,
0.8341445326805115,
0.4596027433872223,
0.21578097343444824,
-0.7541019320487976,
-0.2790893614292145,
0.0008516526431776583,
-0.7663264274597168,
0.06348900496959686,
-0.28392431139945984,
0.23744474351406097,
-0.008207648061215878,
0.354944109916687,
-0.5158035755157471,
0.5367998480796814,
0.45263296365737915,
-0.1448919177055359,
0.7743135094642639,
-0.13338540494441986,
0.19048982858657837,
-0.818850040435791,
-0.18256635963916779,
0.0005784243112429976,
-0.2977781295776367,
-0.714489221572876,
-0.15171360969543457,
0.09880110621452332,
0.19252049922943115,
-0.5670962333679199,
0.24617217481136322,
-0.19096368551254272,
-0.44434019923210144,
-0.12469533085823059,
-0.33668798208236694,
0.04743023216724396,
0.5508098006248474,
-0.09553289413452148,
1.0843675136566162,
0.4713941812515259,
-0.6549563407897949,
0.346096009016037,
0.2611997723579407,
-0.19506874680519104,
0.23541833460330963,
-1.0014469623565674,
-0.1310766339302063,
-0.10000225156545639,
0.2662981152534485,
-1.02158784866333,
0.140059694647789,
0.3173695206642151,
-0.4591953456401825,
0.2622470259666443,
-0.0835256278514862,
-0.5115874409675598,
-0.31896576285362244,
-0.28152307868003845,
0.6031639575958252,
0.6434051990509033,
-0.7624020576477051,
0.7877473831176758,
-0.3631836771965027,
0.0596085786819458,
-0.7608412504196167,
-0.8466581702232361,
0.0725979432463646,
-0.24266108870506287,
-0.7962734699249268,
0.1264267861843109,
0.1953149288892746,
-0.3027947247028351,
0.3180954158306122,
-0.3598494529724121,
0.0005049805622547865,
0.2964150309562683,
0.10853491723537445,
0.07748539745807648,
-0.6698976159095764,
0.35474827885627747,
0.12725655734539032,
-0.542513906955719,
0.3592197895050049,
-0.4001445472240448,
0.6121594309806824,
-0.23551808297634125,
-0.3941095769405365,
-0.4808826744556427,
-0.01773880422115326,
0.3170994520187378,
0.21579083800315857,
0.9069517254829407,
0.5235562324523926,
-0.01816122978925705,
-0.2564905881881714,
-0.39088010787963867,
-0.37174245715141296,
-0.6208928227424622,
0.2825005352497101,
-0.6230493187904358,
-0.793760359287262,
0.49539628624916077,
-0.04928017407655716,
-0.3028598725795746,
0.6697434782981873,
0.6286745071411133,
-0.30500733852386475,
0.5775911211967468,
0.3340267241001129,
0.16115702688694,
0.31750771403312683,
-0.30308404564857483,
0.3387295603752136,
-0.7490761876106262,
-0.223709836602211,
-0.4665423035621643,
-0.8812869191169739,
-0.7654683589935303,
-0.5134423971176147,
0.23678922653198242,
-0.17687742412090302,
-0.37609243392944336,
0.5355477929115295,
-0.4559767246246338,
0.710675835609436,
0.5579585433006287,
0.4198088049888611,
0.4708862900733948,
0.2748969495296478,
0.18919359147548676,
0.22881197929382324,
-0.464328408241272,
-0.49032920598983765,
1.0924063920974731,
0.34691375494003296,
0.8272976279258728,
0.4932197034358978,
0.30109792947769165,
0.19104017317295074,
0.07714249938726425,
-0.9930111765861511,
0.37079113721847534,
-0.5961143374443054,
-0.6784718036651611,
-0.3580089807510376,
-0.7842114567756653,
-1.0064588785171509,
0.04899127781391144,
-0.31393495202064514,
-0.8828573226928711,
0.2271450310945511,
-0.1201622262597084,
-0.05015474557876587,
0.7496904730796814,
-0.8673227429389954,
0.5571178197860718,
-0.23410563170909882,
0.00468168081715703,
-0.5290203094482422,
-0.7758259773254395,
0.2606034278869629,
-0.10897379368543625,
-0.0434737503528595,
0.19096018373966217,
-0.0760437622666359,
0.7067737579345703,
-0.46039003133773804,
0.9795145392417908,
0.1625126600265503,
-0.044521331787109375,
0.31327834725379944,
0.21948671340942383,
0.24279531836509705,
-0.09272537380456924,
-0.41090458631515503,
0.4983823299407959,
-0.10447318851947784,
-0.4344480037689209,
-0.9992794990539551,
0.5752257704734802,
-0.9877383708953857,
-0.6755903959274292,
0.031663186848163605,
-0.7419140934944153,
-0.06811235845088959,
0.2129880040884018,
0.04569007828831673,
0.7968682646751404,
0.11270347982645035,
0.3948551118373871,
0.7317817211151123,
-0.1958540380001068,
0.7268584966659546,
0.23406432569026947,
0.06884400546550751,
0.0732547715306282,
1.003404974937439,
0.21203669905662537,
0.5456090569496155,
0.8807633519172668,
0.2922781705856323,
-0.3196026384830475,
-0.7810362577438354,
-0.5080516934394836,
0.3044990301132202,
-0.6546891927719116,
0.20332622528076172,
-0.6405417919158936,
-0.2526814639568329,
0.04759996756911278,
-0.06018410623073578,
-0.047103047370910645,
-1.2602111101150513,
-0.27052152156829834,
-0.09104591608047485,
0.3486024737358093,
0.9754942655563354,
-0.056241489946842194,
0.8961483240127563,
-0.9137054681777954,
0.3668214976787567,
0.4767571687698364,
0.6557281613349915,
0.31622937321662903,
-0.621612548828125,
-0.08303496241569519,
0.05290668085217476,
-0.17733538150787354,
-0.8020806908607483,
-0.18163137137889862,
0.038871850818395615,
0.21929512917995453,
0.43321123719215393,
-0.3465842306613922,
0.5338857173919678,
-0.6059399247169495,
0.5308334827423096,
0.3230053186416626,
-1.11895751953125,
-0.1070348396897316,
-0.12230809032917023,
-0.021335305646061897,
0.29501307010650635,
0.31832006573677063,
-0.4316999614238739,
0.20558671653270721,
-0.9617505073547363,
-0.548094630241394,
0.7580463886260986,
0.3733340799808502,
0.34302985668182373,
0.3118692934513092,
0.61099773645401,
0.3438946008682251,
0.16054020822048187,
-0.5150177478790283,
-0.6069179773330688,
-0.06223312020301819,
-0.34305378794670105,
-0.4161229431629181,
-0.29563283920288086,
0.22641931474208832,
-0.11251375079154968,
0.5644559860229492,
0.009727898985147476,
0.4591505229473114,
-0.17263492941856384,
-0.270170122385025,
-0.06307663768529892,
0.5239760875701904,
0.3425627648830414,
0.9502658247947693,
-0.28084057569503784,
0.5350205898284912,
0.4345685541629791,
-0.3625248670578003,
0.4688761830329895,
-0.3416615128517151,
-0.2564113438129425,
0.042293332517147064,
0.6531585454940796,
0.7228018045425415,
0.2143838107585907,
-0.36537742614746094,
0.32989126443862915,
-0.18266946077346802,
-0.24573497474193573,
-0.19586311280727386,
0.3375381529331207,
0.39660876989364624,
0.43638643622398376,
0.2824350893497467,
0.34793922305107117,
0.3781750798225403,
-0.647676408290863,
0.31261059641838074,
0.33253833651542664,
-0.7048077583312988,
-0.6985757946968079,
0.2718508541584015,
0.032459624111652374,
-0.7101118564605713,
0.6831184029579163,
-0.0022474233992397785,
-0.5764001607894897,
0.88374263048172,
0.5698285698890686,
0.7901451587677002,
0.08499202877283096,
0.3867049217224121,
0.16940361261367798,
0.597556471824646,
-0.012846703641116619,
-0.08860454708337784,
0.04668698459863663,
-0.7898293733596802,
-0.8718767762184143,
-0.31411200761795044,
-0.4509212076663971,
-0.13039831817150116,
-0.6914878487586975,
0.21714912354946136,
-0.5029189586639404,
0.09584788978099823,
0.24199695885181427,
-0.39921754598617554,
-0.5970730781555176,
0.31243911385536194,
-0.19194376468658447,
0.6710405349731445,
-0.9157822728157043,
0.47304069995880127,
0.6674026250839233,
-0.028575511649250984,
-1.06148099899292,
-0.15932703018188477,
-0.17390549182891846,
-1.0329264402389526,
0.7143697738647461,
0.23178425431251526,
-0.14472466707229614,
-0.1628587543964386,
-0.4545661509037018,
-0.5987276434898376,
1.081754207611084,
0.01651068776845932,
-0.5554148554801941,
-0.13534465432167053,
0.44750910997390747,
0.5953042507171631,
-0.03625672683119774,
0.773059070110321,
0.8364177346229553,
0.44253048300743103,
0.16962255537509918,
-1.069278359413147,
0.2819575369358063,
-0.1502375453710556,
-0.08923370391130447,
0.46297961473464966,
-0.5956107378005981,
0.9414568543434143,
-0.06933706998825073,
-0.25837451219558716,
-0.18420326709747314,
0.53974848985672,
-0.22062049806118011,
0.3754110634326935,
0.6384363174438477,
0.361731618642807,
0.367083340883255,
-0.15505743026733398,
0.7982138991355896,
0.1323203593492508,
0.46478554606437683,
0.9695577025413513,
0.2449212372303009,
0.5507093667984009,
0.40008801221847534,
-0.5374654531478882,
0.6742902398109436,
0.2589789628982544,
-0.09671032428741455,
0.14648514986038208,
0.2569583058357239,
-0.06437364965677261,
-0.4552687704563141,
0.14788205921649933,
-0.3469700217247009,
0.2696283161640167,
0.37383508682250977,
-0.3143678903579712,
-0.30295512080192566,
-0.3144618570804596,
-0.1998395025730133,
-0.22045372426509857,
-0.23161625862121582,
0.718944251537323,
0.25683942437171936,
-0.0009428165503777564,
0.40397459268569946,
-0.005031300242990255,
0.7675074338912964,
-0.1863735169172287,
-0.030996650457382202,
0.19495922327041626,
0.29909682273864746,
-0.4991045594215393,
-1.0283652544021606,
0.5581844449043274,
-0.3078141212463379,
-0.4307366609573364,
0.06766636669635773,
0.7344943881034851,
0.1252715140581131,
-0.7719606161117554,
0.25058603286743164,
0.6399950981140137,
0.126801997423172,
0.12323568016290665,
-0.6408747434616089,
-0.23301739990711212,
0.1334497630596161,
-0.18049879372119904,
0.006633765995502472,
0.6437340378761292,
-0.157467782497406,
0.8729480504989624,
0.633597195148468,
0.07161904871463776,
0.09884253144264221,
-0.02928098849952221,
0.8870382308959961,
-0.8102861642837524,
-0.010748895816504955,
-1.0637654066085815,
0.4577349126338959,
0.22681494057178497,
0.17541256546974182,
0.4677152931690216,
0.2575312852859497,
0.7477732300758362,
-0.21755649149417877,
0.6414062976837158,
-0.06211136281490326,
0.2338905781507492,
-0.6578516960144043,
0.4499208331108093,
-0.3563527464866638,
0.48698002099990845,
-0.07073576748371124,
-1.2216368913650513,
-0.2755776047706604,
0.6078584790229797,
-0.4653119742870331,
0.07351379841566086,
0.8550347089767456,
0.8834119439125061,
-0.5397316813468933,
0.5035044550895691,
0.23178927600383759,
0.4747650921344757,
0.5049536228179932,
0.6525214314460754,
1.0289446115493774,
-0.571070671081543,
0.6566315293312073,
-0.4671384394168854,
-0.10522495210170746,
-0.10606411844491959,
-0.8844101428985596,
-1.0657531023025513,
-0.281270295381546,
0.002246721414849162,
-0.42747053503990173,
-0.08005775511264801,
0.7517579793930054,
0.38420984148979187,
-1.0060906410217285,
-0.26116082072257996,
-0.00032067502615973353,
0.6086943745613098,
-0.2095838487148285,
-0.22411476075649261,
0.2847886085510254,
-0.04325711354613304,
-0.6233952045440674,
0.12512007355690002,
0.1781845986843109,
-0.046806395053863525,
-0.10905414074659348,
-0.020423877984285355,
0.06344933807849884,
0.1358967125415802,
0.6611042618751526,
0.051261600106954575,
-0.5410531163215637,
-0.652553379535675,
0.22900740802288055,
0.35989001393318176,
0.2116733342409134,
0.9159499406814575,
-0.6683184504508972,
0.35702911019325256,
0.6035715937614441,
0.47323542833328247,
0.5889495015144348,
0.13512049615383148,
0.6006171703338623,
-0.3694910705089569,
0.16335102915763855,
-0.054623913019895554,
0.3143787384033203,
0.1155521348118782,
-0.1471375972032547,
0.6601237654685974,
0.2000729888677597,
-0.3715522289276123,
-0.4529815912246704,
0.35729292035102844,
-1.0385208129882812,
-0.31949684023857117,
1.0341233015060425,
0.034093014895915985,
-0.3518632650375366,
-0.33852195739746094,
0.10223931074142456,
0.26316678524017334,
-0.20251809060573578,
0.6339464783668518,
0.42121773958206177,
-0.056007154285907745,
0.04068782180547714,
-0.33005398511886597,
-0.14268018305301666,
0.6838783025741577,
-0.3659783899784088,
-0.2832667827606201,
0.12309911847114563,
0.4745279550552368,
0.4792397618293762,
0.11989625543355942,
0.054098259657621384,
0.24510903656482697,
-0.18154025077819824,
-0.19963909685611725,
-0.2334548979997635,
-0.4874759316444397,
-0.4561666250228882,
0.048144448548555374,
0.02212812937796116,
0.24467524886131287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17658v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17658v1
|
Generative Query Reformulation Using Ensemble Prompting, Document Fusion, and Relevance Feedback
| 2024-05-27T21:03:26 | 2024-05-27T21:03:26 |
Kaustubh D. Dhole, Ramraj Chandradevan, Eugene Agichtein
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, H.3.3; I.2.7
|
Query Reformulation (QR) is a set of techniques used to transform a user's
original search query to a text that better aligns with the user's intent and
improves their search experience. Recently, zero-shot QR has been a promising
approach due to its ability to exploit knowledge inherent in large language
models. Inspired by the success of ensemble prompting strategies which have
benefited other tasks, we investigate if they can improve query reformulation.
In this context, we propose two ensemble-based prompting techniques,
GenQREnsemble and GenQRFusion which leverage paraphrases of a zero-shot
instruction to generate multiple sets of keywords to improve retrieval
performance ultimately. We further introduce their post-retrieval variants to
incorporate relevance feedback from a variety of sources, including an oracle
simulating a human user and a "critic" LLM. We demonstrate that an ensemble of
query reformulations can improve retrieval effectiveness by up to 18% on
nDCG@10 in pre-retrieval settings and 9% on post-retrieval settings on multiple
benchmarks, outperforming all previously reported SOTA results. We perform
subsequent analyses to investigate the effects of feedback documents,
incorporate domain-specific instructions, filter reformulations, and generate
fluent reformulations that might be more beneficial to human searchers.
Together, the techniques and the results presented in this paper establish a
new state of the art in automated query reformulation for retrieval and suggest
promising directions for future research.
|
[
-0.40050017833709717,
-0.6892902851104736,
0.5788893699645996,
-0.20291605591773987,
-0.2764994502067566,
0.05546892061829567,
-0.24977976083755493,
0.1076163798570633,
0.4461459517478943,
0.775291919708252,
-0.5135366916656494,
-0.6025877594947815,
0.0365656353533268,
0.20162838697433472,
-0.7247565388679504,
1.0436344146728516,
0.27065232396125793,
0.026032689958810806,
-0.2803269028663635,
-0.07272961735725403,
-0.5448972582817078,
-0.3583792746067047,
-0.5610553622245789,
-0.10867291688919067,
0.49122604727745056,
0.45060813426971436,
0.45555171370506287,
0.27736490964889526,
0.3789273500442505,
0.20755521953105927,
-0.05722992494702339,
0.09893088042736053,
-0.6793369650840759,
0.7890009880065918,
-0.11994173377752304,
-0.7379108667373657,
0.023305578157305717,
-0.2236059606075287,
0.7475107908248901,
0.3531714081764221,
-0.563064694404602,
-0.07912244647741318,
0.2663806974887848,
0.5892353057861328,
-0.8378406167030334,
-0.09316384047269821,
-0.8246331810951233,
-0.12671847641468048,
-0.2826152443885803,
-0.6850442290306091,
-0.48571833968162537,
-0.5483105182647705,
-0.19615863263607025,
-0.9636102914810181,
0.6275943517684937,
0.15738226473331451,
0.7131603360176086,
0.2470199018716812,
-0.22716845571994781,
-0.1413378268480301,
-0.7974585294723511,
0.6364833116531372,
-0.5648428201675415,
0.34188610315322876,
0.26169997453689575,
0.7274931073188782,
-0.3929586708545685,
-0.8767661452293396,
-0.6288633942604065,
-0.05193530023097992,
-0.06680396944284439,
0.26884886622428894,
-0.27438095211982727,
0.10291644930839539,
0.0565250962972641,
0.36422300338745117,
-0.5656929016113281,
-0.22924599051475525,
-0.6081886291503906,
-0.22200645506381989,
0.8128931522369385,
0.11680061370134354,
0.27452975511550903,
-0.14103777706623077,
-0.25498294830322266,
-0.6913366317749023,
-0.7509742379188538,
-0.15709874033927917,
0.13888145983219147,
0.30950233340263367,
0.6827311515808105,
0.4087701141834259,
-0.7701142430305481,
0.7778704762458801,
0.4595493972301483,
0.2059604525566101,
-0.03247112035751343,
-0.5446087121963501,
-0.1570848971605301,
0.19381164014339447,
0.8020907640457153,
0.4791254997253418,
-0.19803035259246826,
-0.36533471941947937,
-0.43688833713531494,
-0.265703946352005,
0.4725174605846405,
-0.6025891304016113,
-0.35796332359313965,
0.21371576189994812,
-0.4307769536972046,
-0.2903968393802643,
0.2436860203742981,
-1.0139000415802002,
-0.22778619825839996,
-0.22162052989006042,
0.809183657169342,
-0.7926063537597656,
0.10742584615945816,
0.054892756044864655,
-0.481585294008255,
0.7023568749427795,
0.5479406714439392,
-0.8642603158950806,
0.2031424343585968,
0.6313096880912781,
0.3790332078933716,
0.19131772220134735,
-0.1312706619501114,
-0.829833984375,
-0.025516238063573837,
-0.3674217164516449,
1.0495648384094238,
-0.9026006460189819,
-0.7322131395339966,
0.021841904148459435,
-0.13334806263446808,
-0.15351872146129608,
-0.761307418346405,
0.7247533202171326,
-1.0747499465942383,
0.5535351634025574,
-0.5076665282249451,
-0.5918818712234497,
-0.17954620718955994,
0.47126296162605286,
-0.6117013096809387,
1.020471215248108,
-0.056737303733825684,
-0.26963356137275696,
0.4279823899269104,
-0.6467828154563904,
-0.2969937324523926,
0.563942551612854,
-0.278675377368927,
-0.1340673863887787,
-0.005431179888546467,
0.4064975082874298,
0.02918514423072338,
-0.23336343467235565,
-0.07004275918006897,
0.10895585268735886,
-0.675845205783844,
-0.1659523993730545,
-0.033144496381282806,
0.5120123624801636,
0.20008496940135956,
-0.07204405963420868,
0.3099890947341919,
-0.3533283770084381,
0.39547231793403625,
-0.029274221509695053,
-0.17305833101272583,
-0.2938152849674225,
-0.21940095722675323,
-0.16777582466602325,
-0.25495320558547974,
0.06666290760040283,
-0.2546308636665344,
0.4873429834842682,
-0.25756847858428955,
0.4728325605392456,
0.18715287744998932,
0.4610455334186554,
0.6434765458106995,
-0.5177826881408691,
0.9504296779632568,
-0.3052251935005188,
-0.001457573496736586,
-0.6109184622764587,
-0.49775415658950806,
-0.2960955798625946,
0.005003889091312885,
0.5728511810302734,
0.3941202759742737,
-1.2497199773788452,
0.14698125422000885,
-0.2573181092739105,
-0.3578307330608368,
-0.9150893092155457,
0.05363009124994278,
0.3063519299030304,
0.5109955668449402,
0.7002854347229004,
-0.15836165845394135,
-0.4607235789299011,
-0.40977632999420166,
-0.4578429162502289,
-0.1749802678823471,
-0.21662938594818115,
0.23285004496574402,
0.18323495984077454,
0.12998232245445251,
0.9214704632759094,
-0.6141347885131836,
-0.41226842999458313,
-0.12165094912052155,
0.39378395676612854,
-0.09476982802152634,
0.3878602683544159,
0.37395724654197693,
-0.8632078766822815,
-0.351203590631485,
-0.20101362466812134,
-0.38575491309165955,
0.06490152329206467,
-0.13906815648078918,
-0.32228147983551025,
-0.060261424630880356,
0.7859915494918823,
-0.6478581428527832,
0.26325997710227966,
-0.153086319565773,
0.08252113312482834,
0.8610019087791443,
-0.2265847623348236,
0.6769519448280334,
-1.0247254371643066,
0.04341113939881325,
-0.18720287084579468,
0.07669535279273987,
-0.49644172191619873,
0.5591787099838257,
0.14379294216632843,
-0.13715922832489014,
-0.2904796600341797,
0.5500515699386597,
-0.5261240601539612,
0.2410563975572586,
-0.2256891280412674,
0.19107258319854736,
0.21876105666160583,
0.08152804523706436,
-0.30046674609184265,
1.1401748657226562,
0.369572252035141,
-0.7943728566169739,
0.3925221562385559,
0.30667752027511597,
-0.1588352620601654,
0.5129587054252625,
-0.5935919284820557,
0.22993165254592896,
-0.4244469404220581,
0.4358753263950348,
-1.2790091037750244,
-0.553703784942627,
0.0433964729309082,
-0.5203074812889099,
0.2846795916557312,
-0.25902697443962097,
-0.6500566005706787,
-0.28055909276008606,
-0.7496013641357422,
0.4010103642940521,
0.7035382390022278,
-0.5937549471855164,
0.3333740234375,
-0.08758310973644257,
-0.019568737596273422,
-0.33468806743621826,
-0.3352627456188202,
0.19759371876716614,
-0.25913599133491516,
-0.5265674591064453,
0.8474829792976379,
0.20484519004821777,
-0.06885921210050583,
0.09863857924938202,
0.0028815872501581907,
-0.005563968326896429,
-0.08900044858455658,
-0.33283531665802,
0.18156473338603973,
-0.27804604172706604,
0.40134209394454956,
0.39125046133995056,
0.3080764412879944,
-0.2875897288322449,
-0.44274958968162537,
0.8278132677078247,
0.13957378268241882,
-0.45261165499687195,
-0.42344486713409424,
0.1948327124118805,
0.36254939436912537,
-0.6276885271072388,
0.4548680782318115,
0.7167051434516907,
-0.12088923156261444,
0.003448840929195285,
-0.727252185344696,
-0.8402973413467407,
-0.43839457631111145,
-0.19514472782611847,
-0.36137303709983826,
-1.0558571815490723,
0.4962027966976166,
0.07841040194034576,
-0.14082837104797363,
0.5544163584709167,
0.29500290751457214,
-0.3118748366832733,
1.052341341972351,
0.2576009929180145,
0.21514926850795746,
0.5485054850578308,
-0.32143667340278625,
0.16369715332984924,
-1.098864197731018,
-0.4617304801940918,
-0.6750994920730591,
-0.37127381563186646,
-0.7339060306549072,
-0.44718942046165466,
0.5341832637786865,
0.5860714316368103,
0.2164241522550583,
0.4569622874259949,
-0.7780388593673706,
0.5277357697486877,
0.721341609954834,
0.13941341638565063,
0.16607527434825897,
0.197835311293602,
-0.1967489868402481,
0.09318502992391586,
-0.6930417418479919,
-0.3488782048225403,
1.3314321041107178,
-0.6185967922210693,
0.6708415746688843,
0.1835392266511917,
1.2105472087860107,
0.10014409571886063,
0.08960200846195221,
-0.8079038262367249,
0.5851566791534424,
0.043658021837472916,
-0.4617307186126709,
-0.6186268329620361,
-0.34100934863090515,
-1.3940274715423584,
0.3404012620449066,
-0.24217349290847778,
-0.7535813450813293,
0.3144210875034332,
0.2156628519296646,
-0.8575901985168457,
-0.12445265054702759,
-0.5426334142684937,
0.6086165308952332,
0.16835853457450867,
-0.246754989027977,
-0.07920832931995392,
-0.5984781980514526,
0.2681421935558319,
0.20276950299739838,
-0.24550020694732666,
0.1689319759607315,
0.07720639556646347,
0.47257623076438904,
-0.41116759181022644,
0.26191437244415283,
-0.12127132713794708,
0.15510587394237518,
0.46520817279815674,
0.05634191259741783,
0.4907623529434204,
-0.13418379426002502,
-0.3906324505805969,
-0.5466998815536499,
0.33195242285728455,
-0.40242239832878113,
-1.126468539237976,
0.5286840200424194,
-0.17001229524612427,
-1.1138801574707031,
0.09309083968400955,
-0.2689169943332672,
-0.017703616991639137,
0.3724169433116913,
0.4924280643463135,
0.28460225462913513,
-0.29519888758659363,
0.46138492226600647,
0.7662026882171631,
0.0004319869331084192,
0.30983766913414,
0.3828224539756775,
-0.3670886754989624,
-0.2632187306880951,
0.9168170094490051,
0.0732932910323143,
-0.08784880489110947,
0.6013121008872986,
0.01850036345422268,
-0.6713719367980957,
-0.4358433485031128,
-0.6517056822776794,
0.041208021342754364,
-0.334248423576355,
-0.4464825391769409,
-0.4702620208263397,
0.02706863358616829,
-0.9669357538223267,
0.10274186730384827,
0.25681397318840027,
-0.39454707503318787,
-0.21606601774692535,
0.26094773411750793,
0.43704840540885925,
0.143386110663414,
0.20713910460472107,
0.2931741178035736,
-1.013368844985962,
-0.031189247965812683,
0.42209991812705994,
-0.08500613272190094,
0.00756025779992342,
-0.6101675629615784,
0.08552298694849014,
0.04247886687517166,
-0.5692174434661865,
-1.1330479383468628,
0.4816162586212158,
0.360061377286911,
0.6438564658164978,
0.40896597504615784,
0.5141348838806152,
0.6250280737876892,
-0.38744404911994934,
0.8390761017799377,
-0.06783487647771835,
-0.6209812164306641,
0.9110205769538879,
-0.4276697635650635,
0.32156574726104736,
0.97319495677948,
0.25439149141311646,
-0.42870625853538513,
-0.22622272372245789,
-0.5938809514045715,
-0.815861165523529,
0.5014203190803528,
0.2678692638874054,
0.24597938358783722,
-0.17390699684619904,
0.7270885109901428,
-0.15146897733211517,
0.40517425537109375,
0.26983967423439026,
-0.010463198646903038,
-0.17415007948875427,
0.021274404600262642,
0.19126003980636597,
-0.12486693263053894,
-0.3005945086479187,
-0.10682779550552368,
0.43368056416511536,
-0.2788601815700531,
0.15170739591121674,
0.33417630195617676,
0.07947514951229095,
0.10797403007745743,
0.6362118124961853,
0.39041462540626526,
0.28797146677970886,
-0.26945605874061584,
-0.066793292760849,
0.005134107079356909,
-0.20618294179439545,
0.17010380327701569,
0.30600592494010925,
-0.5802389979362488,
0.02091800980269909,
0.027670709416270256,
0.5549138188362122,
0.2218395173549652,
-0.6577598452568054,
0.3953245282173157,
-0.07274531573057175,
-0.3481593430042267,
0.20709937810897827,
0.39476895332336426,
-0.16500648856163025,
0.06944123655557632,
0.65604168176651,
-0.11664403975009918,
0.8532021641731262,
-0.76829993724823,
0.34829476475715637,
0.5523760914802551,
-0.33445021510124207,
-0.1819836050271988,
0.7612027525901794,
-0.01769411936402321,
-0.34451380372047424,
0.8288720846176147,
-0.6794208288192749,
-0.46813347935676575,
0.4077033996582031,
0.495814710855484,
0.799669086933136,
-0.48912233114242554,
0.5265907645225525,
0.3784414231777191,
-0.02886611968278885,
-0.41539695858955383,
0.36639514565467834,
-0.5766087174415588,
-0.7425593137741089,
-0.3707065284252167,
-0.558476448059082,
-0.3353131413459778,
-0.040111247450113297,
-1.1119885444641113,
0.23311279714107513,
-0.2610847055912018,
-0.04179622232913971,
0.1064247190952301,
-0.037691399455070496,
-0.33365586400032043,
0.10081958770751953,
-0.3041377663612366,
0.7784876823425293,
-0.27365949749946594,
0.7791199088096619,
1.1673758029937744,
-0.8422176241874695,
-0.9092615842819214,
0.6068070530891418,
0.024756135419011116,
-0.7153514623641968,
0.3977230489253998,
-0.001364327734336257,
-0.09151330590248108,
0.2456764280796051,
-0.5212228298187256,
-0.6414481997489929,
1.3104562759399414,
0.36104393005371094,
-0.495758593082428,
-0.11244986206293106,
-0.4360092878341675,
0.7179160714149475,
-0.08760523796081543,
0.37385690212249756,
0.6919825673103333,
0.30201080441474915,
0.502834677696228,
-0.7216378450393677,
0.25102323293685913,
-0.20113646984100342,
0.27672961354255676,
0.5100695490837097,
-0.6142501831054688,
0.6697151064872742,
-0.21964502334594727,
-0.5471420288085938,
0.2787238359451294,
0.5265640616416931,
0.49498796463012695,
0.4450344145298004,
0.3107278048992157,
0.6161020994186401,
0.9140636324882507,
-0.11396517604589462,
1.3504530191421509,
-0.5952703952789307,
0.26307713985443115,
0.8440428972244263,
-0.317241907119751,
1.1843444108963013,
0.48887354135513306,
-0.1746596395969391,
0.4093056321144104,
0.5640977025032043,
0.06178539618849754,
0.6277491450309753,
0.15328238904476166,
-0.5197707414627075,
-0.15989673137664795,
-0.11370989680290222,
-0.39477354288101196,
0.4421246349811554,
0.2443368136882782,
-0.18771088123321533,
-0.35450008511543274,
-0.11015070974826813,
-0.008054496720433235,
0.1908070147037506,
-0.2004529982805252,
1.0128288269042969,
-0.19017165899276733,
-1.0059022903442383,
0.6977100372314453,
-0.014371980912983418,
0.5719171762466431,
-0.09928156435489655,
-0.2123400717973709,
-0.5147790908813477,
-0.13340148329734802,
-0.3418551981449127,
-0.7159592509269714,
0.2839072048664093,
-0.38049355149269104,
-0.19414404034614563,
-0.16950146853923798,
0.8041022419929504,
-0.6482105851173401,
-0.2473127841949463,
0.01503545418381691,
0.43346133828163147,
0.3575791120529175,
-0.5769599080085754,
-0.547684371471405,
-0.14770019054412842,
0.23854345083236694,
0.05231459438800812,
0.3816175162792206,
0.4795134961605072,
-0.16627414524555206,
0.3978547751903534,
0.7351410388946533,
-0.13631542026996613,
0.062317632138729095,
0.32101815938949585,
0.9745388627052307,
-0.674933671951294,
-0.2260741889476776,
-0.5354422330856323,
0.16102972626686096,
-0.11659731715917587,
-0.07257769256830215,
0.7786441445350647,
0.4716396927833557,
0.8591662049293518,
0.13041993975639343,
0.5694672465324402,
0.1730392575263977,
0.35883384943008423,
-0.622014045715332,
0.8133602142333984,
-0.7129566669464111,
0.46542489528656006,
0.038488805294036865,
-1.04649019241333,
-0.3235619366168976,
0.2179635614156723,
-0.44687846302986145,
0.17441706359386444,
0.2966248095035553,
1.1896817684173584,
0.1366993933916092,
0.08566765487194061,
0.3277681767940521,
-0.05657421797513962,
0.20998576283454895,
-0.0495871901512146,
0.6969025731086731,
-0.6704671382904053,
0.8633667230606079,
0.05543340742588043,
-0.027043577283620834,
-0.7695921659469604,
-0.25300097465515137,
-0.14438800513744354,
-0.5978575944900513,
-0.28448808193206787,
-0.3579343855381012,
0.38703450560569763,
0.6346220970153809,
0.6536717414855957,
-0.8256404995918274,
0.044233907014131546,
-0.12787583470344543,
0.052357692271471024,
-0.26113301515579224,
-0.3252110183238983,
0.25160378217697144,
-0.836954653263092,
-0.5445784330368042,
0.680698812007904,
0.3055969476699829,
-0.2345532774925232,
-0.15711838006973267,
0.07244513183832169,
-0.10757820308208466,
0.06916827708482742,
0.5161742568016052,
0.49118441343307495,
-0.7731985449790955,
-0.03542279079556465,
0.3889635503292084,
-0.025112999603152275,
0.20529808104038239,
0.7693986296653748,
-1.1583614349365234,
0.6394208669662476,
0.7498190402984619,
0.5757272243499756,
0.712461531162262,
0.4335366189479828,
0.6903707981109619,
-0.7754584550857544,
-0.33839404582977295,
0.5106559991836548,
-0.0595301128923893,
0.3256608545780182,
-0.5105765461921692,
0.2914028763771057,
0.016146110370755196,
-0.40168845653533936,
-0.8224760890007019,
0.10737491399049759,
-0.6366819739341736,
-0.13633503019809723,
0.9350799322128296,
0.0986669734120369,
-0.2070949822664261,
0.17401640117168427,
-0.26877549290657043,
0.04813003167510033,
-0.8165360689163208,
0.9521820545196533,
0.3406110107898712,
-0.43730202317237854,
-0.46601229906082153,
-0.10053645819425583,
0.4951880872249603,
0.7566236853599548,
-0.5210065245628357,
-0.4724390506744385,
0.3634409010410309,
0.18117231130599976,
0.2700571119785309,
0.668123185634613,
-0.36813589930534363,
0.5225346684455872,
0.009861133061349392,
0.13529571890830994,
0.3954671025276184,
-0.02598147839307785,
-0.43338704109191895,
0.3884432911872864,
-0.05183425173163414,
-0.38953647017478943
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17653v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17653v2
|
InversionView: A General-Purpose Method for Reading Information from Neural Activations
| 2024-05-27T20:53:22 | 2024-06-02T08:50:02 |
Xinting Huang, Madhur Panwar, Navin Goyal, Michael Hahn
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The inner workings of neural networks can be better understood if we can
fully decipher the information encoded in neural activations. In this paper, we
argue that this information is embodied by the subset of inputs that give rise
to similar activations. Computing such subsets is nontrivial as the input space
is exponentially large. We propose InversionView, which allows us to
practically inspect this subset by sampling from a trained decoder model
conditioned on activations. This helps uncover the information content of
activation vectors, and facilitates understanding of the algorithms implemented
by transformer models. We present three case studies where we investigate
models ranging from small transformers to GPT-2. In these studies, we
demonstrate the characteristics of our method, show the distinctive advantages
it offers, and provide causally verified circuits.
|
[
-0.19566401839256287,
-0.3501773178577423,
0.5025559067726135,
-0.011948512867093086,
-0.21727780997753143,
-0.3988081216812134,
0.18664272129535675,
-0.19688962399959564,
0.1327357292175293,
0.40504997968673706,
-0.49381205439567566,
0.06531952321529388,
-0.5653791427612305,
-0.13515879213809967,
-0.8955222368240356,
0.6839213967323303,
0.17913824319839478,
0.20369334518909454,
-0.10990311205387115,
0.029524507001042366,
-0.1767641305923462,
-0.1057082861661911,
-0.4594148099422455,
-0.7492020726203918,
0.28856295347213745,
-0.11613655835390091,
0.3952639400959015,
0.3051453232765198,
0.3586871325969696,
0.3191140592098236,
-0.11487846821546555,
-0.06496670842170715,
-0.3815905451774597,
-0.2057957649230957,
-0.10495540499687195,
-0.808315098285675,
0.08333111554384232,
-0.0805271789431572,
0.6746425032615662,
0.8749847412109375,
0.13393546640872955,
0.3963536322116852,
0.3005180060863495,
0.513706624507904,
-0.7597389817237854,
-0.06044609844684601,
-0.42657896876335144,
0.26587873697280884,
0.4523405432701111,
-0.5536153316497803,
-0.7265413999557495,
-0.3845857083797455,
0.05048469081521034,
-0.45079541206359863,
0.23251043260097504,
-0.30764034390449524,
0.629645586013794,
0.3268199861049652,
-0.6344006657600403,
0.10283377766609192,
-0.999525249004364,
0.6491159200668335,
-0.34109050035476685,
0.47106555104255676,
0.255344957113266,
0.4387609660625458,
0.07220044732093811,
-0.8467198610305786,
-0.44054925441741943,
-0.32194578647613525,
-0.48320093750953674,
0.2410648763179779,
-0.2317890226840973,
0.14034658670425415,
0.463400661945343,
0.3893386423587799,
-0.2850608825683594,
-0.15471668541431427,
-0.44320961833000183,
0.017526596784591675,
0.26204466819763184,
0.006301138550043106,
0.387549489736557,
-0.28540316224098206,
-0.3086663484573364,
-0.11014320701360703,
-0.8147187232971191,
0.05147257074713707,
0.6160354018211365,
-0.18401245772838593,
0.02530534937977791,
0.6196771264076233,
0.1298229992389679,
0.8591382503509521,
0.3509798049926758,
0.3324107229709625,
0.16388924419879913,
-0.11016780883073807,
-0.643811047077179,
-0.09270815551280975,
0.22779139876365662,
0.26154252886772156,
-0.10479989647865295,
-0.5328271985054016,
-0.13747847080230713,
-0.4142001271247864,
0.5781071782112122,
-0.7403880953788757,
-0.2292097508907318,
0.3433619439601898,
-0.8266196250915527,
-0.43889299035072327,
0.15243306756019592,
-0.6950665712356567,
-0.7108902931213379,
-0.7441215515136719,
0.6608003377914429,
-0.3645345866680145,
-0.5688855648040771,
-0.198224276304245,
-0.6886692643165588,
0.6231454610824585,
0.2332061529159546,
-0.9256641864776611,
0.22220270335674286,
0.4867665767669678,
0.5323659777641296,
0.21507486701011658,
0.012304188683629036,
-0.5100150108337402,
-0.158620223402977,
-0.26910749077796936,
0.5469291806221008,
-0.361401230096817,
-0.12543568015098572,
-0.03325692564249039,
-0.06917586922645569,
-0.2436031997203827,
-0.6187036633491516,
0.2729186713695526,
-1.0306034088134766,
-0.13396701216697693,
-0.008953151293098927,
-0.39126768708229065,
-0.2633730173110962,
0.33419153094291687,
-0.8253262639045715,
0.8862147927284241,
0.2947010397911072,
-0.7472324967384338,
0.1893061399459839,
-0.6238504648208618,
-0.14640037715435028,
-0.22682145237922668,
-0.2846563160419464,
-0.025234747678041458,
0.5652186274528503,
0.2580154836177826,
-0.0053761200979352,
-0.2649182379245758,
0.12194083631038666,
0.09983881562948227,
-0.31924352049827576,
0.24719494581222534,
-0.5656865835189819,
1.0149937868118286,
0.05290494114160538,
-0.5304484963417053,
0.21991634368896484,
-0.893592357635498,
-0.06637655943632126,
0.04170290753245354,
-0.15744760632514954,
-0.4542350471019745,
0.047681599855422974,
-0.09811857342720032,
0.13746626675128937,
-0.22368837893009186,
-0.6366851925849915,
0.3413519263267517,
-0.46467751264572144,
0.46724605560302734,
0.6919237375259399,
0.1252080500125885,
0.6891035437583923,
0.3248702585697174,
0.5095386505126953,
0.37055155634880066,
0.10633833706378937,
-0.34466782212257385,
-0.2688629627227783,
-0.8058487772941589,
0.17750298976898193,
0.5261273384094238,
0.4561564028263092,
-0.9701663851737976,
0.46130073070526123,
-0.3390582203865051,
-0.29512885212898254,
-0.5469949841499329,
-0.05992403253912926,
0.1733856052160263,
1.0026228427886963,
0.5873227715492249,
0.18000061810016632,
-0.37843215465545654,
-1.2248739004135132,
-0.41625019907951355,
0.08961941301822662,
-0.6871978640556335,
0.3389037847518921,
0.47296518087387085,
0.03666217625141144,
0.8452654480934143,
-0.4895741045475006,
-0.09593077003955841,
-0.4029736816883087,
0.37202712893486023,
0.46216264367103577,
0.48117902874946594,
0.3869958221912384,
-0.9689663648605347,
0.008155870251357555,
-0.052267517894506454,
-0.9154205918312073,
0.059714797884225845,
-0.5550811290740967,
-0.22964000701904297,
-0.6562371253967285,
0.7525008320808411,
-0.19479644298553467,
0.8849380612373352,
0.34975072741508484,
-0.04054876044392586,
0.1952681839466095,
-0.10084102302789688,
-0.017261873930692673,
-0.9247361421585083,
0.4581772983074188,
0.12133463472127914,
-0.1053389310836792,
-0.752959668636322,
-0.1423238217830658,
0.4715379476547241,
0.27472737431526184,
-0.36967340111732483,
0.2892225980758667,
-0.646475076675415,
-0.18481770157814026,
-0.2069752961397171,
-0.09234027564525604,
-0.038853902369737625,
0.5040900707244873,
0.13086339831352234,
0.5743754506111145,
0.31571587920188904,
-0.36790338158607483,
0.35897254943847656,
0.19521905481815338,
-0.525641679763794,
0.35593199729919434,
-0.7659013867378235,
0.11383470147848129,
-0.728549063205719,
0.20307719707489014,
-1.13666832447052,
-0.13968715071678162,
0.30290356278419495,
-0.49837589263916016,
0.3884132504463196,
-0.5535280704498291,
-0.18250593543052673,
-0.23881401121616364,
-0.14567936956882477,
0.7440983653068542,
0.4929395318031311,
-1.0047353506088257,
1.2969813346862793,
0.24649956822395325,
0.5035740733146667,
-0.8450193405151367,
-0.7507585287094116,
-0.1300317645072937,
-0.06149013340473175,
-0.4160534143447876,
0.17557966709136963,
0.6319534778594971,
-0.1853354126214981,
0.06497307121753693,
-0.04131104424595833,
0.00626263115555048,
0.05080880969762802,
0.48576414585113525,
0.12151940912008286,
-0.35715970396995544,
0.047982290387153625,
0.106777623295784,
-0.19933347404003143,
0.2719404697418213,
-0.6095240712165833,
0.5022485256195068,
0.125306636095047,
-0.5597501993179321,
-0.491079717874527,
0.16060586273670197,
0.16327571868896484,
-0.19397947192192078,
0.4357241094112396,
0.14081436395645142,
-0.5128328204154968,
-0.28730466961860657,
-0.25806984305381775,
-0.3843376040458679,
-0.5112563967704773,
0.3317440152168274,
-0.30149778723716736,
0.028857799246907234,
0.5193160772323608,
-0.48935773968696594,
-0.13439306616783142,
0.5915793180465698,
0.30152469873428345,
-0.011587890796363354,
1.0134646892547607,
0.5734163522720337,
0.08648543059825897,
0.6766996383666992,
-0.815754771232605,
0.38888809084892273,
-1.306849718093872,
-0.45180001854896545,
-0.26371312141418457,
-1.0263469219207764,
0.22970585525035858,
-0.049290090799331665,
0.5930853486061096,
0.08698054403066635,
-0.04719531163573265,
0.2999097406864166,
-0.5817939043045044,
0.7398563623428345,
0.608873724937439,
0.34618839621543884,
0.21954721212387085,
-0.005732337478548288,
-0.24972882866859436,
0.051280468702316284,
-0.5505507588386536,
-0.16179783642292023,
1.1246896982192993,
0.3084528148174286,
0.8791799545288086,
-0.11483926326036453,
0.296572744846344,
-0.06439924985170364,
0.723219633102417,
-0.8907853364944458,
0.1924830973148346,
0.24037900567054749,
-0.8220564126968384,
-0.004760972689837217,
-0.23339615762233734,
-0.9880954027175903,
0.4166127145290375,
0.08365507423877716,
-1.0595242977142334,
0.8282683491706848,
0.4105633795261383,
-0.41701602935791016,
0.656108558177948,
-0.7903666496276855,
0.6811361312866211,
-0.4053754210472107,
-0.3729557991027832,
-0.07231512665748596,
-0.8658682703971863,
0.5690171122550964,
0.2616262137889862,
-0.1766512095928192,
0.6614075303077698,
0.15654337406158447,
0.47290587425231934,
-0.31893497705459595,
1.066258430480957,
-0.4319464862346649,
0.09397297352552414,
0.3498478829860687,
0.09849274903535843,
0.21600332856178284,
0.21488334238529205,
-0.06862306594848633,
0.003796597942709923,
-0.25463470816612244,
-0.018987523391842842,
-0.8812658190727234,
0.46506017446517944,
-0.7397507429122925,
-0.2855989634990692,
-0.1591116487979889,
-0.43863359093666077,
-0.14563897252082825,
0.3172266185283661,
0.5937395095825195,
0.7885112762451172,
0.013636881485581398,
0.2873757481575012,
0.4733734428882599,
-0.08350251615047455,
0.26771700382232666,
-0.13581472635269165,
-0.26006653904914856,
-0.0859241634607315,
0.6215940713882446,
-0.0642533078789711,
0.22244466841220856,
0.5982780456542969,
-0.10193601995706558,
-0.3915334641933441,
-0.5181604623794556,
-0.6970415115356445,
-0.051841266453266144,
-0.8926813006401062,
-0.2391020953655243,
-0.5044215321540833,
-0.265247642993927,
-0.005449654534459114,
0.2642849385738373,
-0.14874257147312164,
-0.584143877029419,
-0.1851075142621994,
-0.2957260012626648,
-0.31609654426574707,
0.6428186893463135,
-0.1823025494813919,
0.688014566898346,
-0.6010394096374512,
0.7491586208343506,
0.3707444667816162,
0.33304858207702637,
0.39919984340667725,
-0.46248194575309753,
-0.11776411533355713,
0.16530022025108337,
-0.4569181799888611,
-1.1637853384017944,
0.2546161711215973,
0.009341294877231121,
0.5943646430969238,
0.8302344083786011,
-0.2363787740468979,
0.4359012246131897,
-0.5362961888313293,
0.9037498235702515,
0.07279039174318314,
-0.9350656867027283,
0.5443408489227295,
0.08766016364097595,
-0.01148118544369936,
0.5253317356109619,
0.3744795322418213,
-0.27171051502227783,
0.17528048157691956,
-0.576421856880188,
-0.8931009769439697,
0.7810416221618652,
0.11447669565677643,
0.3339405357837677,
0.39357489347457886,
0.5772254467010498,
0.015280576422810555,
0.23503166437149048,
-0.619217038154602,
-0.3406676650047302,
-0.4293718636035919,
-0.17570653557777405,
0.22579067945480347,
-0.05992777273058891,
-0.4134361445903778,
-0.40245020389556885,
0.20406603813171387,
-0.10266181081533432,
0.636900782585144,
0.2936530113220215,
-0.5512971878051758,
-0.09044890850782394,
-0.013639191165566444,
0.30120792984962463,
0.6991202235221863,
-0.22786130011081696,
0.4113258421421051,
0.03129245713353157,
-0.6491323113441467,
0.17309409379959106,
-0.10781391710042953,
-0.4073116183280945,
-0.07637690752744675,
0.3591608703136444,
0.7772597670555115,
0.07042498141527176,
-0.25837692618370056,
0.7541001439094543,
-0.26451575756073,
-0.2182922512292862,
-0.49412864446640015,
0.014459380879998207,
0.03876160830259323,
0.22542406618595123,
0.5746449828147888,
0.3942141830921173,
0.5027891397476196,
-0.2214079648256302,
0.0017231469973921776,
0.42729729413986206,
-0.48937517404556274,
-0.49233436584472656,
0.8716944456100464,
0.16963794827461243,
-0.06413024663925171,
1.1707011461257935,
0.3206373453140259,
-0.5274863243103027,
1.0196629762649536,
0.5677597522735596,
1.0087072849273682,
-0.034305401146411896,
0.027322858572006226,
0.5311080813407898,
0.4209771752357483,
0.07557958364486694,
0.05718349665403366,
-0.3045259416103363,
-0.7438467144966125,
-0.5480352640151978,
-0.3985789716243744,
-0.116585373878479,
0.4273255467414856,
-0.852961540222168,
0.16534021496772766,
-0.3361836075782776,
-0.10208554565906525,
0.3784869909286499,
-0.8578749895095825,
-0.7978225946426392,
0.20268592238426208,
0.07955440878868103,
1.1943271160125732,
-1.0584774017333984,
0.7226686477661133,
0.5731005668640137,
-0.4696073830127716,
-0.7398513555526733,
0.048953767865896225,
-0.11588644236326218,
-0.9456685185432434,
1.1220300197601318,
0.27406999468803406,
-0.2846006155014038,
0.16831059753894806,
-0.835027813911438,
-0.5547894239425659,
0.8681150078773499,
0.3203432559967041,
-0.09775509685277939,
-0.32366207242012024,
0.19877691566944122,
0.49990883469581604,
-0.05847279354929924,
0.8431249856948853,
0.627827525138855,
0.6361435055732727,
0.0027620920445770025,
-0.21704323589801788,
-0.0668143481016159,
-0.5818389058113098,
-0.12505348026752472,
0.3054295778274536,
-0.18217769265174866,
0.5916353464126587,
-0.08281602710485458,
-0.10379767417907715,
-0.006669924594461918,
0.5383559465408325,
-0.44165945053100586,
0.003885968355461955,
0.7119749784469604,
0.43980175256729126,
0.307216078042984,
-0.1277702897787094,
1.4218271970748901,
-0.24858294427394867,
0.1943242996931076,
0.9163947701454163,
0.3197120726108551,
0.49319586157798767,
0.8858582377433777,
-0.015393968671560287,
0.26287928223609924,
0.2811758518218994,
-0.1244201734662056,
0.6175958514213562,
0.4054609537124634,
0.062498755753040314,
-0.3396979868412018,
0.4205924868583679,
-0.34468263387680054,
0.125574991106987,
0.4636663794517517,
-0.9317604303359985,
-0.27183592319488525,
-0.02193182148039341,
-0.45149025321006775,
-0.39330968260765076,
-0.3209713101387024,
0.7310391664505005,
0.10012365877628326,
-0.738175630569458,
0.49980172514915466,
-0.16848409175872803,
0.28178083896636963,
-0.4871065020561218,
-0.3192802369594574,
-0.16987571120262146,
0.505179226398468,
-0.48103418946266174,
-0.6456972360610962,
0.2904577851295471,
-0.2636362314224243,
-0.023669417947530746,
-0.15632136166095734,
0.6531119346618652,
-0.06316256523132324,
-0.4885353147983551,
0.2387831062078476,
0.2649747431278229,
-0.07561483234167099,
-0.24498501420021057,
-0.07127200067043304,
-0.30942344665527344,
-0.03736400231719017,
-0.5802550911903381,
0.10641822218894958,
0.07657390832901001,
0.11141517013311386,
0.3723883330821991,
0.4592163562774658,
0.030619336292147636,
0.3915625214576721,
-0.11083373427391052,
1.0397299528121948,
-0.5666481256484985,
-0.40288206934928894,
-0.5784324407577515,
0.9393756985664368,
-0.4321501553058624,
-0.6099352240562439,
0.5132784843444824,
0.5459928512573242,
0.6094026565551758,
-0.34448346495628357,
0.8080220222473145,
-0.016605330631136894,
0.25627025961875916,
-0.4691905975341797,
0.5279327630996704,
-0.6894649267196655,
0.2995838224887848,
0.18536792695522308,
-1.0551626682281494,
-0.5273417830467224,
0.6910305023193359,
-0.6424680352210999,
-0.0628887340426445,
0.5079048275947571,
0.6810136437416077,
-0.740728497505188,
0.34712541103363037,
-0.04731402546167374,
0.14958974719047546,
0.3521166741847992,
0.44037744402885437,
1.3113508224487305,
-0.6179155707359314,
0.45354750752449036,
-0.22640851140022278,
-0.460997074842453,
-0.1930381804704666,
-0.8034366965293884,
-0.7338075637817383,
-0.423514187335968,
0.11871381103992462,
-0.5003834366798401,
-0.3751397430896759,
0.5514518022537231,
0.7184829115867615,
-0.7735797166824341,
0.01689327321946621,
-0.23468118906021118,
0.09326180815696716,
-0.4717734754085541,
-0.13596583902835846,
0.5690674185752869,
-0.10299593210220337,
-0.677787721157074,
0.30910754203796387,
0.07543906569480896,
-0.22670245170593262,
-0.22352977097034454,
0.3973348140716553,
0.18805500864982605,
0.016404137015342712,
0.3381602466106415,
0.46805766224861145,
-0.24939994513988495,
-0.13290192186832428,
0.07380691170692444,
0.12530460953712463,
0.27671709656715393,
1.2938010692596436,
-1.0383967161178589,
0.43338948488235474,
0.9605604410171509,
0.8135422468185425,
0.7957396507263184,
0.31981781125068665,
0.45881131291389465,
-0.6693527102470398,
0.37217941880226135,
0.3473530113697052,
0.3577756881713867,
0.07031005620956421,
-0.45040440559387207,
0.38767123222351074,
-0.21301545202732086,
-0.4078611433506012,
-0.7209778428077698,
0.3059564530849457,
-0.807091236114502,
-0.21226340532302856,
1.0382853746414185,
0.17127490043640137,
-0.4905528128147125,
-0.05290541052818298,
-0.28653883934020996,
0.1349359005689621,
0.12726181745529175,
0.841945230960846,
0.2507603168487549,
-0.5221063494682312,
-0.02674618922173977,
-0.5242224931716919,
0.4445964992046356,
0.3025752604007721,
-0.6580068469047546,
-0.05513867363333702,
0.4511144459247589,
0.2536364793777466,
0.509740948677063,
0.2741076350212097,
-0.4511045813560486,
0.15817201137542725,
0.07973199337720871,
-0.22795328497886658,
-0.1350138634443283,
-0.39634716510772705,
-0.8046513199806213,
0.3236317038536072,
-0.28382065892219543,
-0.38081613183021545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02575v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02575v1
|
Cross-Modal Safety Alignment: Is textual unlearning all you need?
| 2024-05-27T20:29:13 | 2024-05-27T20:29:13 |
Trishna Chakraborty, Erfan Shayegani, Zikui Cai, Nael Abu-Ghazaleh, M. Salman Asif, Yue Dong, Amit K. Roy-Chowdhury, Chengyu Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Recent studies reveal that integrating new modalities into Large Language
Models (LLMs), such as Vision-Language Models (VLMs), creates a new attack
surface that bypasses existing safety training techniques like Supervised
Fine-tuning (SFT) and Reinforcement Learning with Human Feedback (RLHF). While
further SFT and RLHF-based safety training can be conducted in multi-modal
settings, collecting multi-modal training datasets poses a significant
challenge. Inspired by the structural design of recent multi-modal models,
where, regardless of the combination of input modalities, all inputs are
ultimately fused into the language space, we aim to explore whether unlearning
solely in the textual domain can be effective for cross-modality safety
alignment. Our evaluation across six datasets empirically demonstrates the
transferability -- textual unlearning in VLMs significantly reduces the Attack
Success Rate (ASR) to less than 8\% and in some cases, even as low as nearly
2\% for both text-based and vision-text-based attacks, alongside preserving the
utility. Moreover, our experiments show that unlearning with a multi-modal
dataset offers no potential benefits but incurs significantly increased
computational demands, possibly up to 6 times higher.
|
[
0.06517088413238525,
-0.6827138066291809,
0.48338913917541504,
-0.18998970091342926,
-0.4017166197299957,
0.2924076020717621,
-0.268827885389328,
-0.5490625500679016,
-0.25206825137138367,
0.3720088601112366,
-0.5805509686470032,
-0.4729810059070587,
-0.588055431842804,
-0.12285321205854416,
-0.34264495968818665,
1.1306647062301636,
-0.08714423328638077,
0.22717949748039246,
-0.10751698166131973,
-0.13201580941677094,
-0.6652746200561523,
-0.6212998628616333,
-0.25127261877059937,
-0.11231353133916855,
0.6520346403121948,
0.1742047369480133,
0.5761194825172424,
0.6664801836013794,
0.41375046968460083,
0.3072364926338196,
0.2530386745929718,
0.2076682299375534,
-0.439109742641449,
0.2372632622718811,
-0.35351982712745667,
-0.17704938352108002,
-0.15412990748882294,
-0.07081370055675507,
0.45010361075401306,
0.7014186978340149,
-0.08587348461151123,
-0.1739378124475479,
0.16801445186138153,
0.6036207675933838,
-0.9040137529373169,
-0.08579736202955246,
-0.6721981167793274,
0.12832558155059814,
-0.26218485832214355,
-0.4598167836666107,
-0.6915676593780518,
0.083050936460495,
0.27575603127479553,
-0.7044340968132019,
-0.07644801586866379,
0.1810806393623352,
0.639953076839447,
0.39903494715690613,
-1.0625272989273071,
-0.0755951777100563,
-0.621202290058136,
1.0273921489715576,
-0.3842960000038147,
0.7711450457572937,
0.4863852560520172,
0.0741049274802208,
-0.08719973266124725,
-0.4769221544265747,
-0.24027259647846222,
0.21867848932743073,
-0.2177862524986267,
0.1881876289844513,
-0.058964863419532776,
0.17523972690105438,
0.004335466306656599,
-0.24471449851989746,
-0.5680860877037048,
0.19181211292743683,
-0.5362204909324646,
-0.29485443234443665,
0.6312142610549927,
0.260711669921875,
0.3384305238723755,
-0.14105939865112305,
-0.917633593082428,
-0.29484179615974426,
-0.6361396312713623,
0.3093693256378174,
0.09137450903654099,
0.4400685727596283,
-0.318278044462204,
0.5539451241493225,
0.04121395945549011,
0.6256791353225708,
-0.08303942531347275,
-0.38770225644111633,
0.3668461740016937,
-0.7201139330863953,
-0.3861968219280243,
-0.006043707951903343,
1.00175142288208,
0.45028918981552124,
0.2486516535282135,
-0.5325595140457153,
-0.18379482626914978,
-0.00986508559435606,
0.7086738348007202,
-0.5145851373672485,
-0.007876216433942318,
0.017436208203434944,
-0.4195590317249298,
-0.5318256616592407,
0.18076011538505554,
-0.8037023544311523,
-0.408744752407074,
-0.46732401847839355,
0.4006502032279968,
-0.6644825339317322,
-0.058000966906547546,
0.058152373880147934,
0.04068891331553459,
0.2593364119529724,
0.3366042375564575,
-0.8486343026161194,
-0.18595653772354126,
0.5527651906013489,
0.5570114850997925,
-0.2612207531929016,
-0.6024274230003357,
-0.6134973764419556,
0.3334577679634094,
-0.2850430905818939,
0.6153014302253723,
-0.6856318712234497,
-0.561671793460846,
0.0762527585029602,
0.18074224889278412,
-0.5424966812133789,
-0.008171061985194683,
0.48098069429397583,
-0.5037323236465454,
0.37908825278282166,
-0.301881343126297,
-0.38219112157821655,
-0.21105194091796875,
0.10048752278089523,
-0.5470379590988159,
0.8221420645713806,
-0.22466962039470673,
-0.7114005088806152,
0.6617839932441711,
-0.24618567526340485,
-0.8245099782943726,
-0.5302698612213135,
-0.4612712264060974,
-0.6157872080802917,
0.1437808871269226,
0.1908746361732483,
0.4528025686740875,
-0.2714296877384186,
0.29159170389175415,
-0.31037744879722595,
-0.18116872012615204,
0.5901837944984436,
-0.8651857376098633,
0.6254843473434448,
0.15185095369815826,
-0.4815983176231384,
0.10303471237421036,
-0.7327703833580017,
0.29616719484329224,
-0.19664467871189117,
-0.6132594347000122,
-0.5294040441513062,
-0.03689121454954147,
0.5035051703453064,
0.4231311082839966,
0.13483302295207977,
-0.6489455699920654,
-0.13334299623966217,
-0.1327836513519287,
0.12823061645030975,
0.7857955098152161,
-0.14719834923744202,
0.6663175225257874,
-0.4913964569568634,
0.31152212619781494,
0.09245795011520386,
0.2057868391275406,
-0.031372565776109695,
-0.18222643435001373,
-0.3681732714176178,
-0.44084087014198303,
0.3113928735256195,
0.657987117767334,
-0.9553155899047852,
0.45503008365631104,
0.007912791334092617,
-0.31179147958755493,
-0.29696765542030334,
0.22096005082130432,
0.9830384850502014,
0.45546966791152954,
0.4271525740623474,
-0.2076910138130188,
-0.5620891451835632,
-0.6396121382713318,
-0.40949746966362,
-0.15132515132427216,
0.15423782169818878,
-0.14841733872890472,
0.37275224924087524,
-0.25797295570373535,
0.8382622003555298,
-0.08505979925394058,
-0.32828500866889954,
-0.14405670762062073,
0.10476482659578323,
-0.5888062715530396,
0.405076801776886,
0.5139539241790771,
-0.864861011505127,
-0.3847596049308777,
0.3158707618713379,
-1.1493194103240967,
0.1235344409942627,
-0.33924415707588196,
-0.09170939028263092,
0.5437301993370056,
0.6557391285896301,
-0.42363038659095764,
0.5932312607765198,
0.5787633061408997,
-0.4173145890235901,
0.03216138854622841,
-0.2066764384508133,
0.2567060589790344,
-1.2282404899597168,
0.17833389341831207,
-0.13213469088077545,
-0.15141409635543823,
-0.8359553813934326,
-0.08197873830795288,
0.32350701093673706,
0.07520338892936707,
-0.7580620050430298,
0.3729020655155182,
-0.6023918390274048,
0.17136766016483307,
-0.25097742676734924,
-0.10526856780052185,
0.02839425392448902,
0.7047693729400635,
0.04782090336084366,
0.6423652172088623,
0.5028557181358337,
-0.32829928398132324,
-0.03704864904284477,
0.22055085003376007,
-0.15362630784511566,
0.6493706107139587,
-0.35205209255218506,
-0.09608015418052673,
-0.19190381467342377,
0.08105257898569107,
-0.7291156649589539,
-0.10315853357315063,
0.1779080629348755,
-0.24158751964569092,
0.5555765628814697,
0.13694491982460022,
0.06595312803983688,
0.3444712162017822,
-0.5599570870399475,
0.5769496560096741,
0.3090176582336426,
-0.45163169503211975,
0.7747374773025513,
0.4758198857307434,
0.0395871177315712,
-1.1208051443099976,
-0.700252890586853,
-0.09315662086009979,
-0.1958232969045639,
-0.4093044102191925,
0.04831729829311371,
-0.010143996216356754,
-0.07437564432621002,
-0.14436207711696625,
-0.2388123720884323,
-0.05891888961195946,
0.09319151192903519,
0.5561656951904297,
0.29558318853378296,
0.09194637089967728,
0.23709259927272797,
0.027589507400989532,
-0.29410338401794434,
-0.05389861762523651,
-0.07269245386123657,
0.17994186282157898,
-0.03470122441649437,
-0.6567105650901794,
-0.5690438151359558,
0.5700122714042664,
0.7976197600364685,
-0.1813691407442093,
0.7209816575050354,
0.4512663185596466,
-0.36737456917762756,
-0.007213926874101162,
-0.2003641426563263,
-0.08166800439357758,
-0.49376967549324036,
0.3667832314968109,
-0.09453383833169937,
-0.8847800493240356,
-0.04348237067461014,
0.023052040487527847,
0.3872997462749481,
0.1607850342988968,
0.3655145466327667,
-0.46750882267951965,
0.9369703531265259,
0.9457963705062866,
0.022075027227401733,
0.5680997371673584,
0.19917914271354675,
0.24973858892917633,
-0.4779902696609497,
-0.7384449243545532,
-0.3180968165397644,
-0.3455735743045807,
-0.4063171446323395,
-0.29528406262397766,
0.38755324482917786,
-0.07826786488294601,
-0.27238109707832336,
0.3378136157989502,
-0.21019703149795532,
0.5732488632202148,
0.3152693212032318,
0.3330717384815216,
0.5633487701416016,
0.31673240661621094,
-0.0599033385515213,
-0.23192934691905975,
-0.5466124415397644,
-0.23367922008037567,
1.344161033630371,
0.2912679612636566,
1.1486389636993408,
0.23071768879890442,
0.5490086078643799,
0.07025343924760818,
0.14847593009471893,
-0.5548192262649536,
0.3358202576637268,
-0.35094115138053894,
-0.4361947476863861,
-0.390399694442749,
-0.5372369289398193,
-1.0250922441482544,
0.41553694009780884,
-0.6586683988571167,
-0.4527764618396759,
0.383695513010025,
0.05978187546133995,
-0.34388619661331177,
0.4195191264152527,
-0.6021360754966736,
0.8152784705162048,
-0.7755331993103027,
-0.21526922285556793,
-0.0489283911883831,
-0.9401376247406006,
0.37966805696487427,
-0.5955225825309753,
0.35227251052856445,
0.10085589438676834,
-0.16511334478855133,
0.6430344581604004,
-0.4454948604106903,
1.3469232320785522,
0.14692911505699158,
-0.27210164070129395,
-0.0454627089202404,
-0.0710163563489914,
0.37260323762893677,
-0.04015509411692619,
0.3202650249004364,
0.17477701604366302,
0.0765741616487503,
-0.2953139841556549,
-0.5256832242012024,
0.4150523245334625,
-0.8835600018501282,
-0.1936364769935608,
-0.6230872869491577,
-0.6968774795532227,
-0.41034188866615295,
0.23875437676906586,
0.5599690675735474,
0.602504551410675,
-0.3222266137599945,
0.4369000494480133,
0.9543671607971191,
-0.036858025938272476,
0.7021468281745911,
0.6325401663780212,
0.12374915182590485,
-0.641796886920929,
0.9598109722137451,
-0.06286797672510147,
0.37720856070518494,
0.585296094417572,
-0.16161417961120605,
-0.3346671760082245,
-0.4183814227581024,
-0.6239919662475586,
-0.02053534984588623,
-0.6666610836982727,
-0.42496269941329956,
-0.7176582217216492,
-0.17783412337303162,
-0.1167088970541954,
-0.49383649230003357,
-0.4378435015678406,
-0.26531481742858887,
-0.18141095340251923,
-0.15969738364219666,
0.3526449501514435,
0.6174225211143494,
-0.12106581777334213,
0.35375314950942993,
-0.9787175059318542,
0.2228168398141861,
0.3034130334854126,
0.2284618467092514,
-0.1906895637512207,
-0.36162927746772766,
-0.2782852053642273,
0.11861076205968857,
-0.19847743213176727,
-0.6861872673034668,
0.22462846338748932,
0.09302298724651337,
0.448202908039093,
0.2571316659450531,
0.19306282699108124,
0.548865795135498,
-0.5089662671089172,
0.37123438715934753,
0.7920824289321899,
-0.7830588817596436,
0.11707097291946411,
-0.38528332114219666,
0.13026317954063416,
0.9796723127365112,
0.4064846336841583,
-0.5301622152328491,
-0.10466162115335464,
-0.29612070322036743,
-0.8204199075698853,
0.6345048546791077,
0.051726583391427994,
-0.056701164692640305,
0.27251774072647095,
-0.03479691594839096,
0.1561383157968521,
0.2223561406135559,
-0.8143766522407532,
-0.06835571676492691,
-0.1677023470401764,
-0.5270665884017944,
0.003603223245590925,
0.040840279310941696,
-0.44924989342689514,
-0.1492457240819931,
0.5252681970596313,
-0.2950666546821594,
-0.10616261512041092,
-0.13891610503196716,
-0.4387970268726349,
-0.2507120668888092,
0.43778979778289795,
0.6370039582252502,
0.47304126620292664,
0.07778628170490265,
0.339614599943161,
0.3406500518321991,
-0.6290894746780396,
0.3686157464981079,
-0.06665922701358795,
-0.1999243050813675,
-0.2575686275959015,
0.4693196415901184,
0.621375560760498,
0.6948633193969727,
-0.9002984166145325,
0.7906474471092224,
-0.15353178977966309,
-0.2879221439361572,
-0.012416612356901169,
-0.06325948238372803,
-0.21943722665309906,
0.30213606357574463,
0.09920871257781982,
0.25630947947502136,
-0.3163907825946808,
-0.580683171749115,
0.4711456298828125,
0.6788814067840576,
-0.6809932589530945,
-0.30860888957977295,
0.765491247177124,
0.33092203736305237,
0.022731216624379158,
0.29500582814216614,
0.4148434102535248,
-0.2537142336368561,
0.3403012454509735,
0.38251993060112,
0.8953248262405396,
-0.16222180426120758,
0.20807859301567078,
-0.1322588175535202,
0.6043452024459839,
-0.0772065818309784,
0.18618334829807281,
0.04904896020889282,
-0.5098996162414551,
-0.39202845096588135,
-0.5810729265213013,
-0.41661739349365234,
-0.00018606879166327417,
-0.6094903349876404,
0.15923812985420227,
-0.5706567764282227,
0.04603612795472145,
-0.22337129712104797,
-0.4795900881290436,
-0.4111086428165436,
0.3793717622756958,
0.026568882167339325,
0.47626298666000366,
-0.9375677108764648,
0.7953616380691528,
0.7927834987640381,
-0.5509885549545288,
-0.6822993755340576,
0.1435927152633667,
0.35521093010902405,
-0.7954140901565552,
0.345845103263855,
0.03655161336064339,
-0.33484798669815063,
-0.4900852143764496,
-0.19552986323833466,
-0.9321451783180237,
1.118972897529602,
0.42210081219673157,
-0.5252743363380432,
-0.2629948854446411,
0.51100754737854,
0.4040203392505646,
-0.18195831775665283,
0.008868008852005005,
0.4635806083679199,
0.3227202296257019,
-0.20123936235904694,
-0.9695801138877869,
0.22954590618610382,
-0.18487130105495453,
-0.14533035457134247,
0.3692963719367981,
-0.632819652557373,
0.7424466609954834,
-0.15690287947654724,
-0.4347746670246124,
-0.13902722299098969,
0.5852437019348145,
0.0009169520926661789,
0.5240110754966736,
0.5155611038208008,
0.5861606001853943,
0.6013645529747009,
0.08214133232831955,
0.828309953212738,
-0.08843932300806046,
0.09509585052728653,
1.1329739093780518,
-0.2158956378698349,
0.873145341873169,
0.6152857542037964,
0.37114763259887695,
0.30226191878318787,
0.40000271797180176,
0.4152293801307678,
0.8009228110313416,
-0.5342012047767639,
-0.1541597545146942,
-0.6296078562736511,
0.030704699456691742,
-0.47994017601013184,
0.5514073371887207,
0.0546417236328125,
-0.3465750813484192,
-0.41678181290626526,
0.3176540434360504,
0.12852953374385834,
0.09253910928964615,
0.09794636815786362,
0.8550066351890564,
0.16948921978473663,
-0.39738407731056213,
0.6070349812507629,
-0.15273535251617432,
0.8312088847160339,
-0.7501135468482971,
0.18266302347183228,
-0.0026524451095610857,
0.1795167475938797,
-0.36985716223716736,
-0.6690654754638672,
0.26137205958366394,
0.0211690254509449,
-0.34615156054496765,
-0.37770596146583557,
0.5261861681938171,
-0.7674299478530884,
-0.2438664436340332,
0.47199177742004395,
0.7143945693969727,
-0.2647380232810974,
0.3218752443790436,
-0.4663553237915039,
0.03254476562142372,
0.09041649103164673,
-0.32720473408699036,
0.8725333213806152,
0.4477057456970215,
-0.2446606606245041,
0.437238872051239,
0.7735235095024109,
-0.4500085115432739,
0.14110314846038818,
-0.13404116034507751,
0.9857490062713623,
-0.7654379606246948,
-0.34231194853782654,
-0.6858606934547424,
0.7447465062141418,
0.025550948455929756,
-0.4744388461112976,
0.6635070443153381,
0.43020325899124146,
1.0274688005447388,
0.1293814778327942,
1.1092571020126343,
0.11550872772932053,
0.2309863418340683,
-0.9375913143157959,
0.6871179938316345,
-0.7435123920440674,
0.2763082683086395,
-0.293475478887558,
-0.5832750201225281,
-0.34518522024154663,
0.35126933455467224,
-0.09719448536634445,
-0.08632008731365204,
0.9823904037475586,
0.7033258676528931,
-0.18355119228363037,
0.20723378658294678,
0.5243842005729675,
-0.25066378712654114,
0.17472024261951447,
0.6682625412940979,
0.8855226039886475,
-0.5148105025291443,
0.7712770104408264,
-0.2503417730331421,
-0.24224792420864105,
-0.10482157766819,
-0.8575398325920105,
-1.1209195852279663,
-0.5725724697113037,
-0.13261573016643524,
-0.22269988059997559,
0.29548877477645874,
0.8996661305427551,
0.4049738645553589,
-0.6292471885681152,
-0.04921786114573479,
0.21678772568702698,
-0.09581585973501205,
-0.10138297080993652,
-0.08796141296625137,
0.3110138475894928,
-0.4887520968914032,
-0.42162176966667175,
0.8219021558761597,
0.2762681245803833,
0.1462203711271286,
0.020746205002069473,
-0.11497160792350769,
-0.27412357926368713,
0.02255137264728546,
0.6546858549118042,
0.5763010382652283,
-0.5656756162643433,
-0.563235878944397,
0.1588597595691681,
-0.42272359132766724,
-0.16352087259292603,
1.091346263885498,
-0.6227990984916687,
0.3745809495449066,
0.4821980595588684,
1.1534090042114258,
0.03429513797163963,
-0.09845632314682007,
0.6960057020187378,
-0.994645357131958,
0.08563009649515152,
-0.27157357335090637,
0.5784997940063477,
0.19960619509220123,
-0.4041808843612671,
0.44679781794548035,
0.2854031026363373,
-0.34378987550735474,
-0.8513222932815552,
0.26960837841033936,
-1.1004542112350464,
-0.5476597547531128,
1.099773645401001,
0.27598831057548523,
-0.2019096165895462,
-0.6020288467407227,
-0.2735010087490082,
0.2542154788970947,
-0.2982717752456665,
0.6318149566650391,
0.1902787983417511,
-0.008784918114542961,
-0.029730094596743584,
-0.3129305839538574,
0.6843528747558594,
0.8239381313323975,
-0.9907163977622986,
0.3769771456718445,
0.6017377972602844,
0.31032079458236694,
0.13608624041080475,
0.43986424803733826,
-0.16295239329338074,
0.530009388923645,
-0.2160535305738449,
-0.01777213253080845,
-0.12383639812469482,
-0.7698012590408325,
-0.5930131673812866,
0.2870010435581207,
-0.36746546626091003,
-0.1851353645324707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17633v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17633v1
|
HEART-felt Narratives: Tracing Empathy and Narrative Style in Personal Stories with LLMs
| 2024-05-27T20:00:38 | 2024-05-27T20:00:38 |
Jocelyn Shen, Joel Mire, Hae Won Park, Cynthia Breazeal, Maarten Sap
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Empathy serves as a cornerstone in enabling prosocial behaviors, and can be
evoked through sharing of personal experiences in stories. While empathy is
influenced by narrative content, intuitively, people respond to the way a story
is told as well, through narrative style. Yet the relationship between empathy
and narrative style is not fully understood. In this work, we empirically
examine and quantify this relationship between style and empathy using LLMs and
large-scale crowdsourcing studies. We introduce a novel, theory-based taxonomy,
HEART (Human Empathy and Narrative Taxonomy) that delineates elements of
narrative style that can lead to empathy with the narrator of a story. We
establish the performance of LLMs in extracting narrative elements from HEART,
showing that prompting with our taxonomy leads to reasonable, human-level
annotations beyond what prior lexicon-based methods can do. To show empirical
use of our taxonomy, we collect a dataset of empathy judgments of stories via a
large-scale crowdsourcing study with N=2,624 participants. We show that
narrative elements extracted via LLMs, in particular, vividness of emotions and
plot volume, can elucidate the pathways by which narrative style cultivates
empathy towards personal stories. Our work suggests that such models can be
used for narrative analyses that lead to human-centered social and behavioral
insights.
|
[
-0.4848552346229553,
-0.692179262638092,
0.8571025133132935,
0.1504770964384079,
-0.2854227125644684,
0.24824288487434387,
-0.01169462688267231,
-0.588814914226532,
0.6062390804290771,
0.6102936863899231,
-0.655093789100647,
-0.6231080889701843,
-0.7052026987075806,
0.5159466862678528,
-0.09579133242368698,
0.772510290145874,
-0.08143804967403412,
0.022608917206525803,
-0.10460078716278076,
-0.40780529379844666,
-0.014100950211286545,
-0.8309981822967529,
-0.380560040473938,
-0.24753351509571075,
0.9943587183952332,
0.45311790704727173,
0.5112215280532837,
0.8200838565826416,
0.5421431064605713,
0.23707161843776703,
0.027324507012963295,
0.08848986774682999,
-0.39470174908638,
-0.024133754894137383,
0.07448111474514008,
-0.3757724463939667,
-0.7331501841545105,
0.3991023600101471,
0.17726856470108032,
0.43592020869255066,
-0.10846644639968872,
0.3499916195869446,
0.21021582186222076,
0.7657784223556519,
-0.2487841248512268,
-0.2595619261264801,
0.1294098198413849,
0.12213306874036789,
0.0038699074648320675,
-0.5963078141212463,
-0.0916491374373436,
-0.5458417534828186,
0.32356560230255127,
-0.40558820962905884,
0.2698673605918884,
0.24306418001651764,
0.3993961215019226,
-0.23317691683769226,
-0.5574073195457458,
-0.617457926273346,
-0.4120425879955292,
0.8023700714111328,
-0.2900948226451874,
-0.15011262893676758,
0.34603288769721985,
-0.14293411374092102,
0.46740007400512695,
-0.556337833404541,
-0.5014495253562927,
-0.14511339366436005,
-0.24283921718597412,
0.20296348631381989,
-0.304298460483551,
-0.024063309654593468,
0.2508171796798706,
0.5100013017654419,
-0.5186409950256348,
0.07917291671037674,
0.054695747792720795,
0.03164290636777878,
1.0349074602127075,
0.5118081569671631,
0.5004392862319946,
-0.46408531069755554,
-0.604195237159729,
-0.14597511291503906,
-0.46383994817733765,
0.37322887778282166,
0.5209351181983948,
0.11021149158477783,
-0.47467830777168274,
0.47924521565437317,
0.1504652351140976,
0.3352402448654175,
-0.1467520147562027,
-0.48239636421203613,
0.1254846155643463,
0.03613758087158203,
0.09110072255134583,
0.23874182999134064,
0.6226239800453186,
1.1785341501235962,
0.8195514678955078,
0.05723746865987778,
-0.02424866519868374,
0.06303369998931885,
0.49121761322021484,
-0.6065008044242859,
0.23508983850479126,
0.17963893711566925,
-1.022409200668335,
-0.5560101866722107,
-0.15710386633872986,
-0.8146025538444519,
-0.9152011871337891,
-0.43734532594680786,
0.10451439768075943,
-0.16149653494358063,
-0.4266163110733032,
0.060617994517087936,
-0.47282734513282776,
0.38645806908607483,
0.14593979716300964,
-0.7185320854187012,
0.40629714727401733,
0.916595458984375,
1.045592188835144,
-0.14359141886234283,
-0.2963997423648834,
-0.3253178000450134,
-0.2057117074728012,
-0.3164370656013489,
0.8933618664741516,
-0.5066614151000977,
-0.5930651426315308,
0.07473941147327423,
-0.1627226173877716,
0.5118536353111267,
-0.3725458085536957,
0.699325680732727,
0.12958945333957672,
-0.24192868173122406,
-0.6204341053962708,
-0.47522374987602234,
-0.000822473899461329,
0.22335153818130493,
-0.39227715134620667,
0.5607377290725708,
0.17723622918128967,
-0.693047821521759,
0.21885426342487335,
-0.43173977732658386,
-0.49119409918785095,
-0.21539194881916046,
0.005091233644634485,
-0.072119802236557,
0.5196088552474976,
0.10882095247507095,
0.9136130213737488,
-0.34893181920051575,
0.16364888846874237,
-0.4401666224002838,
-0.37320610880851746,
0.29649215936660767,
-0.11985993385314941,
0.4944162368774414,
-0.016104042530059814,
-0.004583732690662146,
0.14465682208538055,
-0.6259733438491821,
-0.4659446179866791,
0.33183789253234863,
0.1650344431400299,
-0.512025773525238,
-0.20362891256809235,
0.181534543633461,
-0.20057687163352966,
-0.10163930058479309,
-0.6007904410362244,
0.34819021821022034,
-0.09554476290941238,
0.4378025531768799,
0.8280099034309387,
0.27688100934028625,
0.5040263533592224,
-0.7444578409194946,
0.7271032333374023,
-0.2874780297279358,
0.34662383794784546,
-0.2659088671207428,
-0.3186539113521576,
-0.20473410189151764,
-0.31687039136886597,
-0.46193042397499084,
0.22304731607437134,
-0.04557211697101593,
0.30439499020576477,
0.24099232256412506,
-0.7531144618988037,
-0.6567283272743225,
-0.21323701739311218,
0.3486965596675873,
0.7323938012123108,
0.389538437128067,
-0.5888087749481201,
-0.3749494254589081,
-0.8808547854423523,
-0.7430931925773621,
-0.3036987781524658,
-0.12411411851644516,
0.6186267137527466,
0.16271506249904633,
0.030119556933641434,
0.7713457345962524,
-0.5489420890808105,
-0.34636029601097107,
-0.5093920826911926,
0.44119399785995483,
0.08910475671291351,
0.3231801986694336,
0.4192780554294586,
-0.6364758610725403,
-0.2618463635444641,
-0.2225848138332367,
-0.5455850958824158,
-0.3817440867424011,
-0.276155948638916,
-0.1851436346769333,
-0.1974421888589859,
0.22043709456920624,
-0.3942500054836273,
0.6007453203201294,
0.6095134615898132,
-0.6406487822532654,
0.7314220666885376,
0.042595893144607544,
0.41272079944610596,
-1.0688174962997437,
-0.038410529494285583,
0.2648627758026123,
0.19041885435581207,
-0.5769543647766113,
-0.3127037286758423,
-0.11682741343975067,
0.23553623259067535,
-0.2170557975769043,
1.1955374479293823,
-0.4061506390571594,
-0.23016205430030823,
0.011561580002307892,
0.3176995813846588,
0.29532837867736816,
0.3425469994544983,
0.4838142395019531,
0.1803143322467804,
0.6081032156944275,
-0.31278812885284424,
0.6027066707611084,
0.38043272495269775,
-0.10946233570575714,
1.2379460334777832,
-0.4761085510253906,
0.2057635486125946,
-0.07613241672515869,
0.19361329078674316,
-0.7547016739845276,
-0.2050592303276062,
0.18679088354110718,
-0.6058387160301208,
0.12892495095729828,
-0.07001789659261703,
-0.5242114067077637,
-0.21611915528774261,
-0.406339555978775,
-0.006694305222481489,
0.6550782918930054,
-0.5812657475471497,
0.92264723777771,
0.19534985721111298,
-0.43266561627388,
0.06197319179773331,
-0.5730560421943665,
0.20337504148483276,
-0.6621009111404419,
-0.4777123034000397,
-0.040030479431152344,
-0.3218642771244049,
-0.7925196290016174,
-0.2831648588180542,
-0.05436552315950394,
-0.15745538473129272,
0.19215476512908936,
0.48241618275642395,
0.17974725365638733,
0.0506264790892601,
0.11557507514953613,
0.0639462023973465,
-0.33094775676727295,
0.33388030529022217,
0.49795544147491455,
0.35620251297950745,
-0.13675959408283234,
-0.4692654013633728,
-0.6598407626152039,
0.4998018443584442,
0.5675312280654907,
-0.2367047816514969,
0.3688656985759735,
0.7813332676887512,
0.021515127271413803,
0.09926003962755203,
-0.6603214144706726,
-0.412902295589447,
-0.3141322731971741,
0.015680082142353058,
-0.22991274297237396,
-0.8399760127067566,
0.42202451825141907,
-0.258484810590744,
-0.189482182264328,
0.11238599568605423,
0.3892865478992462,
-0.3902210593223572,
0.7951691746711731,
0.49518683552742004,
-0.3757019340991974,
0.1825527846813202,
-0.058987416326999664,
0.11120140552520752,
-1.187294363975525,
-0.12216207385063171,
-0.24407698214054108,
-0.8226064443588257,
-0.37351542711257935,
0.044661641120910645,
0.33911898732185364,
0.0589793361723423,
-0.20264944434165955,
-0.37366366386413574,
-0.49501848220825195,
0.2892281711101532,
0.5837719440460205,
0.17817915976047516,
0.6488721370697021,
-0.2674389183521271,
0.4230593740940094,
0.04163704439997673,
-0.37023574113845825,
-0.8547074198722839,
0.9630612134933472,
0.4584829807281494,
0.5705432891845703,
-0.013000477105379105,
1.010301113128662,
0.36594703793525696,
0.6937056183815002,
-0.9494438767433167,
0.4331255853176117,
0.11333484947681427,
-0.27379268407821655,
-0.24415703117847443,
-0.06360997259616852,
-0.9737009406089783,
-0.17142313718795776,
-0.22993764281272888,
-0.9443703293800354,
0.22988219559192657,
0.26924100518226624,
-0.5259786248207092,
0.21993540227413177,
-0.7461081743240356,
0.4013077914714813,
-0.28678444027900696,
-0.2594873607158661,
-0.15174275636672974,
-0.8592343330383301,
0.06858938187360764,
0.06733417510986328,
0.22953543066978455,
-0.2661120891571045,
-0.1456507444381714,
0.5345003008842468,
-0.2357926070690155,
1.1905674934387207,
0.08805699646472931,
0.009739967994391918,
0.49402979016304016,
0.5887215733528137,
0.37002646923065186,
0.1736273318529129,
0.030004970729351044,
0.40290123224258423,
-0.17744609713554382,
-0.38119518756866455,
-0.5701895356178284,
0.5515206456184387,
-0.5657287836074829,
-0.4000273048877716,
-0.38479629158973694,
-0.5781247615814209,
-0.3371220827102661,
-0.1552002727985382,
0.13208921253681183,
0.6201230883598328,
-0.42456790804862976,
0.04106728732585907,
0.37939298152923584,
-0.10501858592033386,
0.6129409074783325,
0.3300169110298157,
-0.03406069427728653,
-0.3350106179714203,
0.5111449956893921,
-0.11557534337043762,
0.2127620428800583,
0.2436450868844986,
0.6978139877319336,
-0.1560264527797699,
-0.2627231180667877,
0.0013619024539366364,
0.6168033480644226,
-0.2619474232196808,
-0.141703262925148,
-0.517149806022644,
0.24862463772296906,
-0.2389562875032425,
-0.9638262391090393,
-0.13942882418632507,
0.26662686467170715,
-0.5504612326622009,
-0.6325808763504028,
0.9775766730308533,
0.9190623760223389,
-0.3708646297454834,
0.2113557904958725,
-1.0178523063659668,
0.32821890711784363,
0.2559068500995636,
0.4206852912902832,
0.28975141048431396,
-0.2341560423374176,
0.13549262285232544,
-0.422296404838562,
0.04634542390704155,
-0.9318392872810364,
0.6866245269775391,
-0.26694080233573914,
0.01303067710250616,
0.5493690967559814,
0.2459212988615036,
0.6646356582641602,
-0.20469491183757782,
0.7018284201622009,
0.3566264808177948,
-0.9008049368858337,
0.2886068820953369,
-0.55290687084198,
0.10033886879682541,
0.27399104833602905,
0.49089398980140686,
-0.9519845843315125,
-0.21005985140800476,
-0.8854723572731018,
-0.7219964265823364,
0.39292603731155396,
-0.026589667424559593,
0.316537082195282,
-0.1749028116464615,
0.540176272392273,
0.28677499294281006,
0.14238637685775757,
-0.1654786616563797,
-0.18944276869297028,
-0.025465667247772217,
-0.3404342234134674,
-0.6819155216217041,
-0.7054729461669922,
-0.20942682027816772,
-0.02843349613249302,
-0.2409111112356186,
-0.14785006642341614,
0.029095737263560295,
0.7376574277877808,
0.17194834351539612,
-0.3219485282897949,
0.02430523931980133,
0.15734615921974182,
0.45757120847702026,
-0.16546553373336792,
0.23838716745376587,
-0.01254307571798563,
-0.4871203899383545,
-0.13829892873764038,
-0.305187463760376,
0.44741177558898926,
-0.2005128264427185,
1.1050407886505127,
0.5540576577186584,
0.38860011100769043,
-0.8474417328834534,
0.5966049432754517,
-0.169852152466774,
-0.18407335877418518,
-0.20666386187076569,
-0.04326551780104637,
0.3355390131473541,
0.9697039127349854,
0.2904722988605499,
-0.24034562706947327,
0.18311040103435516,
-0.7048965096473694,
-0.003266911720857024,
0.1262698471546173,
-0.33254101872444153,
-0.5066316723823547,
0.033207088708877563,
0.3635968863964081,
-0.576482355594635,
0.542715847492218,
0.29841068387031555,
-0.2991318106651306,
0.5003005862236023,
0.26182323694229126,
1.0058131217956543,
-0.13948750495910645,
0.2640928030014038,
0.22209514677524567,
-0.002989906119182706,
-0.008528674021363258,
0.31244656443595886,
-0.3072957694530487,
-0.7049891352653503,
0.050501346588134766,
-0.7343906164169312,
-0.5604568123817444,
-0.2777174413204193,
-1.2475236654281616,
-0.06624723225831985,
-0.3174384534358978,
-0.07785017788410187,
-0.5494499802589417,
0.097164086997509,
-0.6974270343780518,
0.37284359335899353,
0.26911038160324097,
0.9271226525306702,
-0.9749276041984558,
0.18638616800308228,
0.364528626203537,
-0.10160965472459793,
-1.0454025268554688,
0.10295486450195312,
0.3219508230686188,
-1.0350605249404907,
0.3681357502937317,
0.014158500358462334,
-0.056115228682756424,
0.3860667645931244,
-0.5091432929039001,
-0.567872941493988,
1.3678619861602783,
-0.003657386638224125,
-0.5364234447479248,
0.09417155385017395,
-0.23742394149303436,
0.7768615484237671,
-0.7564257979393005,
0.17373467981815338,
0.6252757906913757,
0.5879085063934326,
0.010944823734462261,
-0.6493104100227356,
-0.09373434633016586,
-0.04829065129160881,
-0.13315600156784058,
-0.16057933866977692,
-0.8241236209869385,
0.42425012588500977,
-0.5083296298980713,
-0.016689859330654144,
0.21730828285217285,
0.4639301002025604,
0.5138518214225769,
0.7859470844268799,
0.24307161569595337,
0.32669785618782043,
0.7594442367553711,
-0.007963492535054684,
1.5371131896972656,
-0.06431245803833008,
0.11324657499790192,
0.8822259902954102,
-0.29188868403434753,
0.7590251564979553,
0.5305477380752563,
0.05281820148229599,
0.4236488342285156,
0.8049296736717224,
0.20050513744354248,
0.13247251510620117,
0.22732113301753998,
-0.19782505929470062,
-0.12179842591285706,
-0.48030248284339905,
-0.1148672103881836,
0.49036842584609985,
-0.21493588387966156,
-0.6973205208778381,
0.19821590185165405,
-0.02489054948091507,
0.3672136068344116,
0.13316509127616882,
-0.7413437962532043,
0.8362875580787659,
0.45282843708992004,
-0.26363956928253174,
-0.2856692969799042,
-0.598343551158905,
0.356565922498703,
-0.416185200214386,
-0.16814418137073517,
-0.5555094480514526,
-0.3995198905467987,
-0.23015262186527252,
-1.0042963027954102,
-0.002928665140643716,
0.3948286771774292,
-0.10655304044485092,
-0.7771615982055664,
0.7295702695846558,
-0.015727847814559937,
-0.3141341209411621,
0.33184659481048584,
0.7500184774398804,
0.17955636978149414,
-0.31403177976608276,
-0.2281925231218338,
0.362335741519928,
-0.3571053743362427,
-0.7904520034790039,
0.527450442314148,
0.7944170832633972,
0.25659090280532837,
0.5587790012359619,
0.5799273252487183,
0.25700557231903076,
-0.4317575693130493,
0.2749353349208832,
0.5608728528022766,
-1.0841782093048096,
-0.23915426433086395,
-1.1517131328582764,
0.7992106676101685,
-0.057390760630369186,
-0.5103314518928528,
0.6471489071846008,
0.31647199392318726,
0.43850550055503845,
-0.022654779255390167,
0.6291202902793884,
0.2452632486820221,
0.6363951563835144,
-0.42083507776260376,
0.6385930776596069,
-0.49901288747787476,
-0.10129833221435547,
-0.5004082918167114,
-0.7976114749908447,
-0.22900374233722687,
0.4543524384498596,
-0.23029078543186188,
-0.11696649342775345,
0.5517305731773376,
0.5773499011993408,
0.6127052307128906,
-0.032476700842380524,
0.29095807671546936,
0.3029527962207794,
-0.0825151801109314,
0.08356033265590668,
1.0352500677108765,
0.5657162070274353,
-0.15294325351715088,
-0.24304300546646118,
-0.567084789276123,
-0.1981586366891861,
-1.0620423555374146,
-0.7042049169540405,
-0.6011040210723877,
-0.24379609525203705,
-0.25818440318107605,
-0.2518116235733032,
0.8197870850563049,
0.35166338086128235,
0.15399733185768127,
-0.4386684000492096,
0.18253251910209656,
0.12324506789445877,
-0.1250770390033722,
-0.26994842290878296,
0.4445064067840576,
0.07679009437561035,
-0.5583996772766113,
-0.019869977608323097,
0.7573240399360657,
-0.054680269211530685,
-0.2530082166194916,
-0.29266080260276794,
0.4321616291999817,
0.2616347074508667,
0.7779549360275269,
-0.10519371181726456,
-0.763272762298584,
-0.3071872889995575,
0.04942105710506439,
0.05848199501633644,
0.1205189973115921,
1.2756154537200928,
-0.5178182125091553,
0.39404115080833435,
0.023950157687067986,
0.028366131708025932,
0.04049219936132431,
0.49519646167755127,
0.4284172058105469,
-0.4791622459888458,
-0.41519421339035034,
0.384643018245697,
0.3290175199508667,
0.10403411090373993,
-0.6580649614334106,
0.547795832157135,
0.4083639085292816,
-0.44571879506111145,
-0.7555250525474548,
0.3519323170185089,
-1.315115213394165,
-0.1024552583694458,
1.3649615049362183,
-0.033422552049160004,
-0.23640702664852142,
0.20487326383590698,
-0.800912618637085,
0.10308024287223816,
-0.49251335859298706,
0.8167823553085327,
0.7263622283935547,
-0.7868527770042419,
-0.34018558263778687,
-0.1489044576883316,
0.41725438833236694,
-0.2546927034854889,
-0.6018627285957336,
0.26780861616134644,
0.5320716500282288,
-0.06056519225239754,
-0.16572628915309906,
0.6661078333854675,
0.11611434072256088,
-0.1565457284450531,
-0.0034138960763812065,
0.3849858343601227,
0.02472502738237381,
-0.03279370814561844,
-0.18501578271389008,
0.3583519458770752,
0.012483678758144379,
0.42124834656715393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17613v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17613v1
|
A Framework for Multi-modal Learning: Jointly Modeling Inter- & Intra-Modality Dependencies
| 2024-05-27T19:22:41 | 2024-05-27T19:22:41 |
Divyam Madaan, Taro Makino, Sumit Chopra, Kyunghyun Cho
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Supervised multi-modal learning involves mapping multiple modalities to a
target label. Previous studies in this field have concentrated on capturing in
isolation either the inter-modality dependencies (the relationships between
different modalities and the label) or the intra-modality dependencies (the
relationships within a single modality and the label). We argue that these
conventional approaches that rely solely on either inter- or intra-modality
dependencies may not be optimal in general. We view the multi-modal learning
problem from the lens of generative models where we consider the target as a
source of multiple modalities and the interaction between them. Towards that
end, we propose inter- & intra-modality modeling (I2M2) framework, which
captures and integrates both the inter- and intra-modality dependencies,
leading to more accurate predictions. We evaluate our approach using real-world
healthcare and vision-and-language datasets with state-of-the-art models,
demonstrating superior performance over traditional methods focusing only on
one type of modality dependency.
|
[
-0.1654188185930252,
-0.4772638976573944,
0.4700407087802887,
0.16099166870117188,
-0.12003020197153091,
-0.1815272569656372,
0.02162094973027706,
-0.7102353572845459,
-0.14176954329013824,
0.005547000095248222,
-0.49213409423828125,
-0.17998214066028595,
-0.73668372631073,
-0.1510612517595291,
0.22645188868045807,
0.6992543935775757,
0.026020606979727745,
0.8903164863586426,
-0.6836200952529907,
-0.11778832226991653,
-0.4582342803478241,
-0.4331175684928894,
-0.2802565395832062,
-0.6076782941818237,
0.7026122808456421,
0.3521353602409363,
0.38513296842575073,
0.42462611198425293,
0.6627184748649597,
0.1481751650571823,
0.21935346722602844,
0.20228995382785797,
-0.18047840893268585,
0.11642438918352127,
-0.29453667998313904,
-0.38434162735939026,
-0.2161843329668045,
0.3836401700973511,
0.3450918197631836,
0.8166985511779785,
0.07456891238689423,
0.06654001027345657,
0.1674211621284485,
0.3493533432483673,
-0.7306625247001648,
0.4766215980052948,
-0.239887535572052,
0.13702726364135742,
-0.02886662445962429,
-0.31907525658607483,
-0.43021586537361145,
0.15234455466270447,
0.28849759697914124,
-0.6414704322814941,
0.0012543379561975598,
-0.11399625241756439,
0.6016619801521301,
0.2789308726787567,
-1.097340703010559,
-0.3531198501586914,
-0.7595626711845398,
0.474991112947464,
-0.26892152428627014,
0.7476865649223328,
0.8401315212249756,
0.2424977421760559,
0.24997414648532867,
-0.5558910965919495,
-0.16698084771633148,
-0.4275364577770233,
-0.29324832558631897,
0.6874091029167175,
0.16014952957630157,
0.15971766412258148,
0.039954669773578644,
0.09006626158952713,
-0.33019912242889404,
0.35212981700897217,
-0.5882130265235901,
-0.11399434506893158,
0.23741880059242249,
0.20011955499649048,
0.2989470064640045,
-0.30602627992630005,
-1.1414308547973633,
0.09037857502698898,
-0.6194291710853577,
0.12660428881645203,
0.09540454298257828,
0.3931155800819397,
-0.43044543266296387,
0.6129270792007446,
0.12116293609142303,
0.5633448362350464,
0.12048210948705673,
-0.8523648977279663,
0.059406258165836334,
-0.6515930891036987,
0.06039326637983322,
-0.1847994029521942,
0.5279937982559204,
0.3492535650730133,
-0.29677632451057434,
-0.5112472772598267,
-0.18328385055065155,
0.24185645580291748,
0.30030158162117004,
-0.7479815483093262,
-0.1972033977508545,
0.19485630095005035,
-0.619274377822876,
-0.17969103157520294,
0.27473944425582886,
-0.6077969670295715,
-0.153928741812706,
-0.7790384888648987,
0.8957304358482361,
-0.4395955502986908,
-0.6485101580619812,
-0.2450779229402542,
0.23176343739032745,
-0.015616686083376408,
0.29702773690223694,
-0.9617709517478943,
0.0428132601082325,
0.6005189418792725,
0.8049449324607849,
-0.12840303778648376,
-0.3766948878765106,
-0.5378221273422241,
0.5057900547981262,
-0.17559629678726196,
0.6310470700263977,
-0.6306390762329102,
-0.4014562964439392,
-0.014578753150999546,
0.048540208488702774,
-0.35317063331604004,
-0.6063253283500671,
0.11497366428375244,
-0.4165748953819275,
0.6128882169723511,
-0.47641992568969727,
-0.5616487860679626,
-0.6374382972717285,
0.14051303267478943,
-0.7731140851974487,
0.7337914705276489,
0.5454488396644592,
-0.567489743232727,
0.6000882983207703,
-0.5642626285552979,
-0.6366287469863892,
-0.13270294666290283,
-0.5680062770843506,
-0.506242573261261,
0.24182619154453278,
-0.12390504032373428,
0.5272752642631531,
-0.5406306385993958,
0.6161196827888489,
-0.35979050397872925,
-0.14734244346618652,
0.11556797474622726,
-0.5622177720069885,
0.7212124466896057,
0.0670446828007698,
-0.27071166038513184,
0.142019122838974,
-0.8537095189094543,
-0.30404117703437805,
-0.2255946695804596,
-0.6585203409194946,
-0.1833781599998474,
0.08135519921779633,
0.39136579632759094,
0.7076438069343567,
0.07800102233886719,
-0.2403695285320282,
0.07268530875444412,
0.038195982575416565,
0.23924735188484192,
0.7043048739433289,
-0.19252993166446686,
0.5224707126617432,
-0.6120493412017822,
0.6067561507225037,
0.6092022061347961,
0.2778443396091461,
-0.2722223401069641,
-0.17712514102458954,
-0.37166208028793335,
-0.6692565679550171,
0.21107730269432068,
0.455514132976532,
-0.7934642434120178,
0.08106634765863419,
0.04250218719244003,
-0.18269316852092743,
-0.17860589921474457,
0.01262612920254469,
0.64762282371521,
0.5969877243041992,
0.46309345960617065,
-0.5356507897377014,
-0.49971723556518555,
-0.7385210394859314,
0.12087635695934296,
-0.4794686436653137,
0.3004433214664459,
0.21862852573394775,
0.3707774877548218,
-0.38076311349868774,
0.7397708296775818,
0.08997282385826111,
-0.7651742696762085,
0.005783773027360439,
0.2242545783519745,
-0.44699057936668396,
0.6173008680343628,
0.5937045812606812,
-1.0472780466079712,
-0.35475096106529236,
0.03965739905834198,
-1.0912972688674927,
0.1734616756439209,
-0.1608446091413498,
0.18283072113990784,
0.017979813739657402,
0.5514051914215088,
-0.18373265862464905,
0.37403133511543274,
0.7274324297904968,
-0.2384994924068451,
0.3650832176208496,
-0.09853007644414902,
0.08142667263746262,
-1.4131642580032349,
0.06098008155822754,
0.18482233583927155,
-0.04167379438877106,
-0.4814819097518921,
-0.04907115921378136,
0.301262229681015,
0.10632931441068649,
-0.40180185437202454,
0.44749483466148376,
-0.5911594033241272,
-0.08658837527036667,
-0.07386814802885056,
-0.5945267081260681,
0.30621740221977234,
0.4621186852455139,
0.003069284837692976,
0.7439633011817932,
0.67046719789505,
-0.3759477138519287,
0.2324608564376831,
0.07656524330377579,
-0.3255946636199951,
0.8990917205810547,
-0.4395816922187805,
-0.2996974587440491,
-0.2791919410228729,
0.20991070568561554,
-0.99477219581604,
-0.6117215156555176,
0.4919767379760742,
-0.20946842432022095,
0.5983045697212219,
-0.274491548538208,
-0.44121745228767395,
0.1716953068971634,
0.01357696857303381,
0.7280446887016296,
0.045456212013959885,
-0.6294881701469421,
0.898422360420227,
0.29974228143692017,
0.16834494471549988,
-0.41767504811286926,
-0.6965574026107788,
-0.19980013370513916,
-0.231121227145195,
-0.48503032326698303,
0.31810489296913147,
-0.01737913303077221,
-0.20250318944454193,
0.15528564155101776,
-0.1302039623260498,
-0.11232384294271469,
0.08638156950473785,
0.7363917231559753,
0.3732663691043854,
-0.30652427673339844,
0.6721329689025879,
-0.01816161535680294,
-0.4958454966545105,
-0.043400682508945465,
-0.21356940269470215,
0.24641969799995422,
0.11348831653594971,
-0.8083601593971252,
-0.6319422125816345,
0.9830647110939026,
0.8235243558883667,
-0.48597297072410583,
0.6753033399581909,
0.8088474273681641,
-0.4120749831199646,
0.19862423837184906,
-0.5761144161224365,
-0.5102591514587402,
-0.3758317232131958,
0.5962479114532471,
-0.5944547653198242,
-0.6374795436859131,
0.10527859628200531,
-0.3782532215118408,
-0.33233943581581116,
0.014835968613624573,
0.7434975504875183,
-0.3850436806678772,
1.15374755859375,
0.8487668037414551,
0.05330204591155052,
0.7266972661018372,
-0.3377169072628021,
0.1243644505739212,
-0.9415819644927979,
-0.9189661741256714,
0.054713279008865356,
-0.20476871728897095,
-0.0928124263882637,
-0.5892466902732849,
1.0686734914779663,
0.47863656282424927,
0.09239384531974792,
-0.06794798374176025,
-0.25019681453704834,
0.09213869273662567,
0.7285003066062927,
0.4845457375049591,
0.38361436128616333,
0.05908816680312157,
-0.17223452031612396,
0.030884195119142532,
-0.8581633567810059,
-0.07141725718975067,
1.1211897134780884,
0.23166301846504211,
0.7575905919075012,
0.3397890329360962,
0.2552544176578522,
-0.020684318616986275,
0.38788604736328125,
-1.0401344299316406,
0.12402713298797607,
-0.14557763934135437,
-0.7205724120140076,
0.24099409580230713,
-0.21288900077342987,
-0.9464665055274963,
0.568670392036438,
-0.3672543466091156,
-0.4315418303012848,
0.4621295928955078,
0.21846745908260345,
-0.20321740210056305,
0.24174875020980835,
-0.6724461913108826,
0.7500473260879517,
-0.6233290433883667,
-0.4869258403778076,
-0.23090490698814392,
-1.0247957706451416,
0.3483947813510895,
-0.006132905837148428,
0.3202763497829437,
-0.15926320850849152,
-0.08272331207990646,
0.28924283385276794,
-0.24107928574085236,
1.1919673681259155,
0.04207993671298027,
-0.1010529175400734,
0.09369897842407227,
-0.014854989014565945,
0.15916326642036438,
0.1299816220998764,
0.16607657074928284,
0.17380672693252563,
0.11411523818969727,
-0.3279823362827301,
-0.18636615574359894,
0.4045117497444153,
-0.9330392479896545,
-0.0811934694647789,
-0.624058187007904,
-0.6480090618133545,
-0.4935694932937622,
-0.0502694733440876,
0.6636075973510742,
1.1432462930679321,
-0.044673942029476166,
0.04672723263502121,
0.6137073636054993,
0.19761301577091217,
0.31724488735198975,
0.5607202053070068,
-0.14056754112243652,
-0.6132845878601074,
0.7843628525733948,
0.4317382574081421,
0.5505996346473694,
0.4329126179218292,
0.05547906458377838,
-0.17066694796085358,
-0.23111902177333832,
-0.4804464876651764,
0.2510429322719574,
-0.794197142124176,
-0.3296687602996826,
-0.5603841543197632,
-0.035712480545043945,
-0.25314661860466003,
-0.09044287353754044,
-0.19422084093093872,
0.0021974765695631504,
-0.774357795715332,
0.0003406918840482831,
0.19285650551319122,
0.8053475618362427,
-0.57135409116745,
0.1463782787322998,
-0.6756254434585571,
0.5224036574363708,
0.6621183753013611,
0.38897624611854553,
-0.11500760167837143,
-0.15255621075630188,
-0.4902810752391815,
-0.02682296559214592,
-0.24215564131736755,
-1.0427236557006836,
-0.08952782303094864,
0.25805750489234924,
0.5892799496650696,
0.5669772028923035,
-0.2163970172405243,
0.41076257824897766,
-0.26386967301368713,
0.5600872039794922,
0.8637126684188843,
-0.6361770033836365,
0.4214790463447571,
-0.24509023129940033,
0.19085897505283356,
0.5335326790809631,
0.6790640950202942,
-0.3664122521877289,
0.11655407398939133,
-0.2462031990289688,
-0.6888666749000549,
0.7268883585929871,
-0.5860113501548767,
-0.1534268856048584,
0.09904347360134125,
0.08629218488931656,
0.5948314070701599,
-0.020680854097008705,
-0.8477415442466736,
0.014044494368135929,
-0.1438503861427307,
-0.3542269170284271,
0.01033721398562193,
-0.4417600631713867,
-0.5143702030181885,
-0.3300406336784363,
0.4922020137310028,
-0.49352744221687317,
0.16181151568889618,
0.03429826349020004,
-0.33169111609458923,
-0.42665714025497437,
-0.16925981640815735,
0.48455607891082764,
0.7690227627754211,
0.07873037457466125,
0.4889390170574188,
-0.3292696475982666,
-0.29207727313041687,
0.27820131182670593,
0.04979915916919708,
-0.19460934400558472,
-0.16925014555454254,
0.4602368175983429,
0.8674762845039368,
0.2524324059486389,
-0.5822499394416809,
0.7708028554916382,
0.3973429799079895,
-0.21899837255477905,
-0.06931199878454208,
-0.25217825174331665,
0.2814941704273224,
0.7842997312545776,
-0.03666393831372261,
0.4417155086994171,
0.10998203605413437,
-0.6560198068618774,
0.31855764985084534,
0.4471901059150696,
-0.9293619990348816,
-0.5440875887870789,
0.9978966116905212,
0.06278461217880249,
0.06034386530518532,
0.34623071551322937,
0.24151113629341125,
-0.3223845064640045,
0.4775610864162445,
0.7001791000366211,
0.7037571668624878,
-0.18916212022304535,
0.3384452164173126,
0.30516520142555237,
0.09008100628852844,
-0.18365061283111572,
0.30901965498924255,
-0.3051512539386749,
-0.49342650175094604,
-0.27528098225593567,
-0.29830944538116455,
-0.3002658188343048,
-0.1423748880624771,
-0.9245525598526001,
0.2413512021303177,
-0.3077584207057953,
-0.29824298620224,
-0.05977006256580353,
-0.48147130012512207,
-0.7459275722503662,
0.38063564896583557,
0.1711382269859314,
0.17365504801273346,
-0.9716794490814209,
0.9546372294425964,
0.8145875930786133,
-0.9777891635894775,
-0.738706111907959,
-0.01830274984240532,
0.3281709849834442,
-0.8145239949226379,
0.7839164733886719,
0.15773265063762665,
-0.2740137279033661,
-0.2182038128376007,
-0.19465306401252747,
-0.9350537061691284,
1.2346875667572021,
0.3444284200668335,
-0.4188374876976013,
-0.12364513427019119,
0.28893858194351196,
0.14788323640823364,
-0.2927713394165039,
0.10006493330001831,
0.004641582723706961,
0.30108046531677246,
0.015374907292425632,
-1.0883044004440308,
-0.07592491060495377,
-0.23247936367988586,
0.13337679207324982,
-0.08363904803991318,
-0.938199520111084,
1.1383657455444336,
-0.27941492199897766,
-0.06345552951097488,
-0.08334892243146896,
0.31780073046684265,
-0.11339671164751053,
0.5638837814331055,
0.4125736951828003,
0.5886204838752747,
0.2931925058364868,
-0.044564396142959595,
0.7868308424949646,
-0.3360721468925476,
0.5042101144790649,
1.2723432779312134,
-0.1258455067873001,
0.5338035821914673,
0.5816513895988464,
-0.13023623824119568,
0.2712336480617523,
0.6525668501853943,
0.12053916603326797,
0.7355878353118896,
-0.15053460001945496,
-0.5486503839492798,
-0.4342476725578308,
-0.37793272733688354,
-0.6313695907592773,
0.8207607865333557,
0.4428729712963104,
-0.5204299688339233,
-0.26136815547943115,
0.6230506300926208,
0.0020454381592571735,
-0.13814349472522736,
0.06438124924898148,
1.1809232234954834,
0.19145555794239044,
-0.5877717733383179,
0.4985840916633606,
-0.19934919476509094,
0.5082411766052246,
-0.6616211533546448,
-0.02555510215461254,
0.01789371855556965,
0.03324666991829872,
-0.27350449562072754,
0.0014556663809344172,
-0.10872865468263626,
-0.6324034929275513,
-0.651209831237793,
-0.21988965570926666,
0.5958501100540161,
-0.9395830631256104,
-0.5375956296920776,
0.5490742921829224,
0.8537163734436035,
-0.2765372693538666,
0.17935213446617126,
-0.36542630195617676,
0.09435237944126129,
-0.4209038317203522,
-0.10596366226673126,
0.6495305299758911,
0.2653059661388397,
0.05947234854102135,
0.32832348346710205,
0.44989439845085144,
-0.32426878809928894,
0.03334198519587517,
-0.08367802947759628,
0.7654634714126587,
-0.17322969436645508,
-0.2729578912258148,
-0.5272908210754395,
0.5651443004608154,
0.39357104897499084,
-0.4979252815246582,
0.3613733947277069,
0.6064152717590332,
0.9141563177108765,
0.018223367631435394,
0.9338459968566895,
0.03887161985039711,
0.37052121758461,
-0.7322903871536255,
0.3139103949069977,
-1.173694372177124,
0.10971301794052124,
0.2174655646085739,
-0.8226372003555298,
-0.3770255148410797,
0.6580381393432617,
-0.1231956034898758,
0.03606925532221794,
0.6558936834335327,
0.7990677952766418,
-0.40520337224006653,
-0.003407964250072837,
0.3688836693763733,
-0.11978104710578918,
0.2548081874847412,
0.6916754841804504,
1.056631326675415,
-0.2546749413013458,
0.18161918222904205,
-0.5500407814979553,
-0.3130999207496643,
-0.5818168520927429,
-0.598252534866333,
-0.6367606520652771,
-0.9442529082298279,
-0.42541903257369995,
-0.4025031626224518,
-0.17140614986419678,
1.1604045629501343,
1.1417101621627808,
-0.4889031946659088,
-0.22686757147312164,
0.12927035987377167,
-0.21169571578502655,
-0.4151249825954437,
-0.15454836189746857,
0.2999657392501831,
-0.46784621477127075,
-0.6313432455062866,
0.6054099798202515,
0.6957812309265137,
0.11407165974378586,
-0.5668103694915771,
0.026005052030086517,
-0.15474849939346313,
-0.12772136926651,
0.8800724744796753,
0.06802231073379517,
-1.0268845558166504,
-0.35087406635284424,
-0.1503181904554367,
-0.37035250663757324,
0.29291319847106934,
0.9512216448783875,
-0.7912618517875671,
0.9124325513839722,
0.32683226466178894,
0.4730857014656067,
0.40014564990997314,
-0.15642192959785461,
0.27593228220939636,
-0.3761562407016754,
0.18155395984649658,
0.3123413324356079,
0.28285595774650574,
0.2554958164691925,
-0.12844185531139374,
0.6254988312721252,
0.5865252614021301,
-0.24032804369926453,
-0.6135965585708618,
0.6700137257575989,
-1.315703272819519,
-0.5650049448013306,
1.2377475500106812,
-0.16794046759605408,
0.4924995005130768,
-0.3127887547016144,
-0.254954993724823,
0.3517730236053467,
0.20995178818702698,
0.698360025882721,
0.2921600043773651,
-0.13255733251571655,
-0.04340251162648201,
-0.5535217523574829,
0.14737534523010254,
0.5870634317398071,
-0.7984753251075745,
-0.5045844912528992,
0.8906228542327881,
0.41324323415756226,
-0.045385975390672684,
0.6447151303291321,
-0.1546480506658554,
0.3228296637535095,
0.15217606723308563,
-0.05812249705195427,
-0.22703184187412262,
-0.7927477359771729,
-0.21034061908721924,
0.5144129991531372,
-0.2078959047794342,
-0.2654308080673218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17610v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17610v1
|
Explainable machine learning multi-label classification of Spanish legal judgements
| 2024-05-27T19:16:42 | 2024-05-27T19:16:42 |
Francisco de Arriba-Pérez, Silvia García-Méndez, Francisco J. González-Castaño, Jaime González-González
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Artificial Intelligence techniques such as Machine Learning (ML) have not
been exploited to their maximum potential in the legal domain. This has been
partially due to the insufficient explanations they provided about their
decisions. Automatic expert systems with explanatory capabilities can be
specially useful when legal practitioners search jurisprudence to gather
contextual knowledge for their cases. Therefore, we propose a hybrid system
that applies ML for multi-label classification of judgements (sentences) and
visual and natural language descriptions for explanation purposes, boosted by
Natural Language Processing techniques and deep legal reasoning to identify the
entities, such as the parties, involved. We are not aware of any prior work on
automatic multi-label classification of legal judgements also providing natural
language explanations to the end-users with comparable overall quality. Our
solution achieves over 85 % micro precision on a labelled data set annotated by
legal experts. This endorses its interest to relieve human experts from
monotonous labour-intensive legal classification tasks.
|
[
-0.45139622688293457,
-0.6700605750083923,
0.5252459049224854,
0.23973332345485687,
-0.5105632543563843,
0.2583601772785187,
-0.12062588334083557,
-0.7029727697372437,
0.12188011407852173,
0.6528540253639221,
-0.28057733178138733,
-0.5595706701278687,
-0.5569984912872314,
-0.07441247999668121,
-0.4018900692462921,
1.3207792043685913,
0.09709353744983673,
0.25483763217926025,
-0.057243525981903076,
-0.5610265135765076,
-0.3377053737640381,
-0.5919451713562012,
-0.3920564651489258,
-0.35973304510116577,
0.4914952218532562,
0.5011090040206909,
0.8120779395103455,
0.507814884185791,
0.35720545053482056,
0.45080864429473877,
0.030500514432787895,
0.08593770116567612,
0.01694473996758461,
-0.12846317887306213,
-0.3854292333126068,
-0.4795818030834198,
-0.47638118267059326,
-0.19477970898151398,
0.23514066636562347,
0.42169705033302307,
-0.25992074608802795,
0.13685394823551178,
-0.3110390901565552,
0.713264524936676,
-0.5955284237861633,
0.35028061270713806,
-0.5108788013458252,
0.5413023829460144,
0.024375751614570618,
-0.33706286549568176,
-0.5551100373268127,
-0.42620036005973816,
0.18355755507946014,
-0.6215556859970093,
0.45551782846450806,
0.2665814161300659,
0.7634062170982361,
0.5693374872207642,
-0.7469820976257324,
-0.4427136778831482,
-0.6185575723648071,
0.5255940556526184,
-0.35964563488960266,
0.24332214891910553,
0.04132743924856186,
0.8098888397216797,
-0.09539048373699188,
-0.6394098997116089,
-0.5514238476753235,
-0.3263868987560272,
-0.21426156163215637,
0.33199888467788696,
-0.2645798623561859,
0.23118062317371368,
0.137485072016716,
0.11610881984233856,
-0.5178898572921753,
0.4988235831260681,
-0.2696045935153961,
-0.5707764625549316,
0.7341869473457336,
-0.09039044380187988,
0.137208491563797,
-0.06862260401248932,
-0.2735939621925354,
0.09407457709312439,
-0.4690321385860443,
0.36941012740135193,
0.4909079074859619,
0.06417267769575119,
0.24221009016036987,
0.6672357320785522,
0.02974989265203476,
0.8104926347732544,
-0.11645346134901047,
-0.29424718022346497,
0.3782115876674652,
-0.09345761686563492,
-0.4069874882698059,
0.45938730239868164,
1.158997893333435,
0.399795264005661,
0.23292624950408936,
0.019337594509124756,
-0.18208342790603638,
-0.013219855725765228,
0.02967064455151558,
-0.5274432897567749,
-0.16982147097587585,
0.24352718889713287,
-0.638206422328949,
-0.25381508469581604,
0.40278589725494385,
-0.7907776832580566,
-0.66068035364151,
-0.4278864562511444,
0.1270100474357605,
-0.07820858806371689,
-0.03754810243844986,
0.2583763003349304,
-0.302232027053833,
-0.031118160113692284,
0.4606814980506897,
-0.5289608836174011,
0.3211071491241455,
0.2800893187522888,
0.197781503200531,
0.26291990280151367,
0.17119669914245605,
-0.48050621151924133,
0.15565846860408783,
-0.10518386960029602,
0.7546315789222717,
-0.42470598220825195,
-0.03894709795713425,
-0.1426047682762146,
0.07657422870397568,
0.1106719821691513,
-0.5780103802680969,
0.8203758597373962,
-0.6792036890983582,
0.4968860149383545,
0.21810905635356903,
-0.3886595666408539,
-0.6802998185157776,
0.03453925624489784,
-0.7124348282814026,
0.7021900415420532,
-0.23518669605255127,
-0.6253281831741333,
1.0270895957946777,
-0.8400983214378357,
-0.6569005250930786,
0.3592938482761383,
-0.28786423802375793,
-0.6708433628082275,
-0.12331229448318481,
0.36850157380104065,
0.6472881436347961,
-0.11789475381374359,
0.8784574866294861,
-0.35940390825271606,
0.05128973722457886,
0.36519235372543335,
-0.399647980928421,
1.0213291645050049,
0.5000059604644775,
-0.527047872543335,
0.3436146378517151,
-0.8862600922584534,
-0.13944318890571594,
-0.042318325489759445,
-0.43072617053985596,
-0.09870681911706924,
-0.0008025998831726611,
-0.12443538010120392,
0.5929170250892639,
0.20154069364070892,
-0.4398724436759949,
-0.18719743192195892,
-0.20761141180992126,
0.3661472797393799,
0.5206310749053955,
-0.0885067731142044,
0.23417574167251587,
-0.10386238247156143,
0.7332903146743774,
-0.01579553820192814,
0.07260266691446304,
-0.10784953087568283,
-0.785915732383728,
-0.7268505692481995,
-0.3435856103897095,
0.49905580282211304,
0.874019980430603,
-0.630504846572876,
0.6648624539375305,
-0.2268434762954712,
-0.1974465250968933,
-0.7050079703330994,
0.09445109963417053,
0.429891437292099,
0.6551016569137573,
0.44655776023864746,
0.14597412943840027,
-0.7264785170555115,
-1.2638529539108276,
-0.4950261414051056,
-0.05279436707496643,
0.008394138887524605,
0.5321000814437866,
0.7145382761955261,
-0.13385958969593048,
1.0345487594604492,
0.11119340360164642,
-0.3809821307659149,
-0.1435883641242981,
0.3615283966064453,
0.40899884700775146,
0.06237117946147919,
0.40338703989982605,
-1.227735161781311,
-0.36741572618484497,
0.4820144772529602,
-1.0040171146392822,
-0.16417630016803741,
-0.20426009595394135,
0.2106674760580063,
0.16588708758354187,
0.4876888692378998,
-0.09498047828674316,
0.3905109465122223,
-0.021557167172431946,
-0.627419650554657,
0.631893515586853,
-0.7054896950721741,
0.08877412974834442,
-0.5360927581787109,
-0.11835864931344986,
0.4017184376716614,
-0.5608568787574768,
-0.44138452410697937,
-0.05635729804635048,
0.24923159182071686,
0.15987303853034973,
-0.5397987961769104,
0.2836137115955353,
-0.32353371381759644,
-0.043114639818668365,
-0.2645699679851532,
0.057319525629282,
0.13284260034561157,
0.41509589552879333,
0.08797703683376312,
0.23939865827560425,
0.4201061725616455,
-0.7437950968742371,
0.6118717193603516,
-0.04475906863808632,
-0.21020358800888062,
0.6769648790359497,
-0.35986846685409546,
-0.24803097546100616,
-0.2369958460330963,
0.39636939764022827,
-0.6662926077842712,
-0.36826905608177185,
0.39925602078437805,
-0.13226059079170227,
0.11458414793014526,
-0.405482679605484,
-0.5722702145576477,
-0.857198178768158,
-0.11136053502559662,
0.05342544615268707,
0.252252995967865,
-0.6847934722900391,
0.7903082966804504,
0.6444092392921448,
0.01596561074256897,
-0.6951528787612915,
-0.7080055475234985,
0.28675317764282227,
-0.644383430480957,
-0.3881935179233551,
0.30255332589149475,
0.26977312564849854,
-0.3511522710323334,
0.32845208048820496,
0.0954996794462204,
-0.23356474936008453,
0.12347497045993805,
0.392767071723938,
0.029857520014047623,
-0.23349373042583466,
0.3779572546482086,
0.39250490069389343,
-0.16326864063739777,
0.44959959387779236,
-0.4187089800834656,
0.0696713775396347,
-0.44695422053337097,
-0.34575003385543823,
-0.7421956062316895,
0.19997374713420868,
0.629169762134552,
-0.16313497722148895,
0.5817762017250061,
0.31953948736190796,
-0.28954118490219116,
-0.08840855956077576,
-0.618450403213501,
0.3840109407901764,
-0.41120100021362305,
0.11026809364557266,
-0.7091558575630188,
-0.5981152057647705,
0.7208690643310547,
0.06780615448951721,
-0.12891745567321777,
0.9869663715362549,
0.8420861959457397,
-0.14805884659290314,
1.0318453311920166,
0.4945814609527588,
0.09917356818914413,
0.28495946526527405,
-0.09929835051298141,
0.3056028187274933,
-0.006059644278138876,
-0.7928556799888611,
-0.6917386651039124,
-0.1578981876373291,
-0.6622710227966309,
-0.11888547241687775,
0.26268869638442993,
-0.058797504752874374,
-0.15974615514278412,
0.2017083466053009,
-0.598755955696106,
0.692693829536438,
0.8451609015464783,
0.3113100230693817,
0.5851393938064575,
-0.09284254163503647,
-0.4804804027080536,
0.220398411154747,
-0.8050214648246765,
-0.7378053665161133,
0.9088414311408997,
0.4491269290447235,
0.4733229875564575,
0.028359901160001755,
0.5685395002365112,
0.5451095700263977,
0.1801600158214569,
-0.8159685134887695,
0.45331689715385437,
-0.21849972009658813,
-0.589855968952179,
-0.08929738402366638,
-0.4789005517959595,
-0.9599472880363464,
0.5407724976539612,
-0.5040301084518433,
-0.44895023107528687,
0.1625695526599884,
0.10311415791511536,
-0.5461904406547546,
0.22191324830055237,
-0.7869731187820435,
0.9235259890556335,
-0.5684492588043213,
-0.15990813076496124,
-0.2820728123188019,
-0.806524395942688,
0.40221044421195984,
-0.163601353764534,
0.7054953575134277,
-0.023606980219483376,
-0.03762941434979439,
1.053106427192688,
-0.7755334973335266,
0.6693310737609863,
-0.34855419397354126,
0.006234871689230204,
0.4046209156513214,
-0.05713949725031853,
0.1797061413526535,
-0.10270728915929794,
-0.06372951716184616,
-0.3289351463317871,
-0.06050357222557068,
-0.2099420428276062,
-0.6727123856544495,
0.30732372403144836,
-0.40565842390060425,
-0.22238728404045105,
-0.36435195803642273,
-0.4742162823677063,
0.08630549162626266,
0.12805365025997162,
0.11830227077007294,
0.035949770361185074,
0.010147039778530598,
0.012957180850207806,
0.36595913767814636,
-0.2265564352273941,
0.2599978744983673,
0.731522262096405,
-0.14470341801643372,
-0.45268514752388,
1.1269887685775757,
0.18510212004184723,
-0.5314568877220154,
0.3358286917209625,
0.4674500524997711,
-0.720705509185791,
-0.6230835318565369,
-0.6373052000999451,
0.054677676409482956,
-0.852984607219696,
-0.1693916916847229,
-0.7200100421905518,
0.2179778665304184,
-0.1460288166999817,
-0.02010272815823555,
0.081953264772892,
-0.7243947386741638,
-0.12228089570999146,
-0.31068921089172363,
0.2775098979473114,
0.801902711391449,
0.09344251453876495,
0.1363000124692917,
-0.662533164024353,
0.6661050319671631,
0.2817836105823517,
0.3021365702152252,
-0.391470730304718,
-0.5455619096755981,
-0.034610770642757416,
-0.0493137501180172,
-0.08485431969165802,
-0.9697466492652893,
0.3166133165359497,
0.17859649658203125,
0.8483055830001831,
0.8314633369445801,
0.04586460813879967,
0.5660900473594666,
-0.421066015958786,
0.3246525526046753,
0.28516244888305664,
-0.7444587349891663,
0.823733389377594,
-0.19172750413417816,
-0.33430904150009155,
0.470241516828537,
0.46650430560112,
-0.07287220656871796,
-0.7237911224365234,
-0.7127149105072021,
-0.8648392558097839,
0.6412635445594788,
-0.09452587366104126,
-0.30426689982414246,
0.3223227560520172,
0.18671667575836182,
0.5590611100196838,
0.2734350264072418,
-0.8520135283470154,
-0.13603220880031586,
-0.17635688185691833,
-0.2940577566623688,
0.007558206096291542,
-0.01416793279349804,
-0.10328628122806549,
-0.6093193292617798,
0.8035191893577576,
-0.14133740961551666,
-0.08210550993680954,
-0.07853378355503082,
-0.4641166925430298,
0.1944936066865921,
0.42466044425964355,
0.5401335954666138,
0.6446477174758911,
-0.08413209021091461,
0.25628915429115295,
-0.006546652875840664,
-0.001066321274265647,
0.3714944124221802,
0.37311986088752747,
-0.036436956375837326,
0.09890274703502655,
0.2103082537651062,
0.7411625385284424,
-0.03683747723698616,
-0.7851353883743286,
0.36079055070877075,
-0.04241884872317314,
-0.5663265585899353,
-0.39617660641670227,
-0.012533998116850853,
-0.10708160698413849,
0.31841811537742615,
0.24825187027454376,
0.3128262758255005,
0.5009883642196655,
-0.5031551718711853,
0.21641883254051208,
0.2959946393966675,
-0.35415127873420715,
0.24451801180839539,
0.819101095199585,
0.2586970031261444,
-0.34854844212532043,
0.1705010086297989,
-0.36535802483558655,
-0.6377993226051331,
0.8047084808349609,
0.20076727867126465,
0.4825601279735565,
0.17829443514347076,
0.4844091236591339,
-0.06464646756649017,
0.04025651514530182,
-0.2455352544784546,
-0.013858291320502758,
-0.27437466382980347,
-0.5941548943519592,
-0.3814515173435211,
-0.29970434308052063,
-0.6749558448791504,
-0.08863119781017303,
-0.7115755081176758,
0.04332183301448822,
-0.46166324615478516,
-0.0873502716422081,
0.34246334433555603,
-0.2853858470916748,
-0.7848935127258301,
0.2951701879501343,
0.07766646891832352,
0.6753562092781067,
-1.0375930070877075,
0.728614866733551,
0.5424832105636597,
-0.4352782368659973,
-0.4424501359462738,
-0.6065489053726196,
0.04315165802836418,
-0.6059629917144775,
0.7191401720046997,
0.3734591603279114,
-0.34439554810523987,
-0.4362345039844513,
-0.29065123200416565,
0.06688174605369568,
0.6015648245811462,
0.4955058991909027,
-0.6095958352088928,
0.3227875232696533,
0.243589848279953,
0.9336230158805847,
-0.34139928221702576,
0.35267600417137146,
0.7841519713401794,
0.7675336599349976,
0.04736220836639404,
-0.861381471157074,
-0.07036816328763962,
-0.44246235489845276,
-0.5662872195243835,
0.06466012448072433,
-0.10866553336381912,
0.3144586682319641,
-0.31594303250312805,
0.01378309354186058,
-0.29504793882369995,
0.5234118103981018,
0.023711703717708588,
0.7533912658691406,
0.46846887469291687,
0.6928934454917908,
1.3233883380889893,
-0.33980321884155273,
1.2020434141159058,
-0.1435859352350235,
0.2917616665363312,
1.2122374773025513,
-0.020987896248698235,
0.39751920104026794,
0.5332340002059937,
-0.21303488314151764,
0.7626697421073914,
0.8247644305229187,
-0.40445011854171753,
0.1807612180709839,
0.2617368996143341,
-0.2285974621772766,
-0.33876118063926697,
-0.214985191822052,
-0.03436794504523277,
0.3837549388408661,
0.404793381690979,
-0.7677136063575745,
-0.09742093086242676,
0.4684792160987854,
-0.31379517912864685,
0.2603512406349182,
-0.4957132041454315,
0.9636912941932678,
-0.15024316310882568,
-0.6730391383171082,
0.25755774974823,
0.1841582953929901,
0.49639180302619934,
-0.022023340687155724,
0.04996783286333084,
0.23544694483280182,
0.25780153274536133,
-0.5698065757751465,
-1.130120038986206,
0.10920422524213791,
0.13621240854263306,
-0.23799560964107513,
-0.6473693251609802,
0.48723429441452026,
-0.19130034744739532,
-0.6694858074188232,
0.41469720005989075,
0.532319962978363,
0.5587136149406433,
-0.15512517094612122,
-1.1110261678695679,
-0.6126627326011658,
-0.16716335713863373,
-0.1098969355225563,
-0.062021903693675995,
0.863658607006073,
-0.3527854382991791,
0.9303258061408997,
0.4611392617225647,
-0.05660976842045784,
0.4493280053138733,
0.43878617882728577,
0.694402813911438,
-0.7857887148857117,
-0.688830554485321,
-0.9046964049339294,
0.5469045639038086,
-0.226808100938797,
-0.061590902507305145,
0.510552704334259,
0.7094417810440063,
0.5545549392700195,
-0.0942532941699028,
0.7904634475708008,
-0.043292369693517685,
0.3844909369945526,
-0.6817658543586731,
0.513270378112793,
-0.31459757685661316,
0.24382294714450836,
0.02822957932949066,
-0.5834705233573914,
-0.7607117891311646,
0.5585817694664001,
-0.26182106137275696,
-0.010847527533769608,
0.6139704585075378,
0.5148423314094543,
-0.23564603924751282,
0.06031758338212967,
0.2731093764305115,
0.06418047100305557,
0.3084455132484436,
0.47657859325408936,
0.8102985620498657,
-0.1362958699464798,
0.9385697841644287,
-0.37320515513420105,
-0.16084089875221252,
-0.39261892437934875,
-0.8665109872817993,
-0.8699155449867249,
-0.18238523602485657,
-0.415020227432251,
-0.2596677243709564,
-0.15017110109329224,
0.6436034440994263,
0.7177107930183411,
-1.1291459798812866,
0.005533379036933184,
-0.36097452044487,
0.40760526061058044,
-0.045004431158304214,
-0.26317232847213745,
0.3801397979259491,
-0.27933090925216675,
-0.46040841937065125,
0.32836079597473145,
0.23263905942440033,
0.07324882596731186,
-0.04495420306921005,
-0.20834562182426453,
-0.08822476118803024,
-0.36860090494155884,
0.5358496904373169,
0.5148398280143738,
-0.9626128077507019,
0.06851140409708023,
-0.6403921842575073,
0.04827161133289337,
0.352453351020813,
0.899058997631073,
-0.9323675036430359,
0.68202143907547,
0.3347497880458832,
0.5110708475112915,
0.474499374628067,
-0.05207180231809616,
0.3785960078239441,
-0.42917492985725403,
0.3354301154613495,
0.5002835988998413,
0.8093047738075256,
-0.0603637658059597,
-0.2119777947664261,
0.3754538595676422,
0.04907548427581787,
-0.3821280300617218,
-0.42608311772346497,
0.03356665000319481,
-0.979158341884613,
-0.4447091817855835,
0.617103636264801,
-0.23663429915905,
-0.13989102840423584,
-0.655402660369873,
-0.41054567694664,
0.2300547957420349,
-0.5159849524497986,
0.6793851852416992,
0.5876966118812561,
-0.3642261326313019,
-0.07452862709760666,
-0.7443962097167969,
0.24697241187095642,
0.24022707343101501,
-0.8936300277709961,
-0.433714359998703,
0.6157826781272888,
0.14109207689762115,
0.26946955919265747,
0.29310765862464905,
-0.23109236359596252,
0.4131312668323517,
-0.2673320174217224,
0.06683018058538437,
-0.20780326426029205,
-0.5347163677215576,
-0.5084039568901062,
0.6686645150184631,
-0.22961001098155975,
-0.20152565836906433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17604v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17604v1
|
LoRA-XS: Low-Rank Adaptation with Extremely Small Number of Parameters
| 2024-05-27T19:07:13 | 2024-05-27T19:07:13 |
Klaudia Bałazy, Mohammadreza Banaei, Karl Aberer, Jacek Tabor
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The recent trend in scaling language models has led to a growing demand for
parameter-efficient tuning (PEFT) methods such as LoRA (Low-Rank Adaptation).
LoRA consistently matches or surpasses the full fine-tuning baseline with fewer
parameters. However, handling numerous task-specific or user-specific LoRA
modules on top of a base model still presents significant storage challenges.
To address this, we introduce LoRA-XS (Low-Rank Adaptation with eXtremely Small
number of parameters), a novel approach leveraging Singular Value Decomposition
(SVD) for parameter-efficient fine-tuning. LoRA-XS introduces a small r x r
weight matrix between frozen LoRA matrices, which are constructed by SVD of the
original weight matrix. Training only r x r weight matrices ensures
independence from model dimensions, enabling more parameter-efficient
fine-tuning, especially for larger models. LoRA-XS achieves a remarkable
reduction of trainable parameters by over 100x in 7B models compared to LoRA.
Our benchmarking across various scales, including GLUE, GSM8k, and MATH
benchmarks, shows that our approach outperforms LoRA and recent
state-of-the-art approaches like VeRA in terms of parameter efficiency while
maintaining competitive performance.
|
[
-0.4180235266685486,
-0.4481127858161926,
0.27176231145858765,
-0.04309646785259247,
-0.4721226990222931,
-0.03135954216122627,
-0.2966667413711548,
-0.14045266807079315,
0.23553694784641266,
0.5383762121200562,
-0.5129887461662292,
-0.44211214780807495,
-0.4108603596687317,
-0.19756284356117249,
-0.2286641150712967,
1.0543746948242188,
0.11358160525560379,
-0.074978768825531,
0.05451900139451027,
-0.5403396487236023,
-0.18278104066848755,
-0.3792469799518585,
-0.7787787914276123,
-0.07012556493282318,
1.0168527364730835,
0.6485658288002014,
0.4925660490989685,
0.9504728317260742,
0.4206674098968506,
0.2393835037946701,
-0.17289873957633972,
0.09347610175609589,
-0.8512564897537231,
0.06506355106830597,
-0.16153980791568756,
-0.7781032919883728,
-0.8417840600013733,
-0.31255829334259033,
0.9229711890220642,
0.8415178656578064,
-0.11592930555343628,
0.5688206553459167,
0.049046486616134644,
0.8722584247589111,
-0.8812811970710754,
-0.040058061480522156,
-0.7758027911186218,
-0.10719043761491776,
-0.2691787779331207,
-0.0649302750825882,
-0.43077465891838074,
-0.3253825008869171,
-0.1608293354511261,
-0.6985180974006653,
-0.20232689380645752,
0.1206526979804039,
0.691338062286377,
0.6360381841659546,
-0.09457462280988693,
0.31472745537757874,
-0.8792222738265991,
0.9274804592132568,
-0.6271116137504578,
0.38021984696388245,
0.29987505078315735,
0.322341650724411,
0.0008667591609992087,
-0.284243643283844,
-0.09428218007087708,
0.15393100678920746,
0.4879262447357178,
-0.254642516374588,
-0.36198100447654724,
-0.18847790360450745,
0.2690347135066986,
0.2324550747871399,
-0.30535000562667847,
0.5229222774505615,
-0.41529303789138794,
0.35925185680389404,
0.473610520362854,
0.2077663093805313,
-0.15858598053455353,
-0.07960918545722961,
-0.17432546615600586,
-0.20813415944576263,
-1.0613785982131958,
0.16871437430381775,
0.19641712307929993,
0.9137967228889465,
-0.20232625305652618,
0.36868706345558167,
-0.27609923481941223,
0.6948645710945129,
0.23839980363845825,
-0.4483327865600586,
0.06309545785188675,
-0.16476532816886902,
-0.33475667238235474,
-0.05246695876121521,
0.46482613682746887,
-0.03197314962744713,
-0.2264622151851654,
-0.0970686748623848,
-0.11070215702056885,
0.2812272310256958,
0.020317912101745605,
-0.7794346213340759,
-0.06892125308513641,
-0.25148290395736694,
-0.5153779983520508,
-0.4482056200504303,
-0.3745107352733612,
-0.5668123364448547,
-0.3407531678676605,
-0.15234781801700592,
0.868556797504425,
-0.12665843963623047,
0.17166085541248322,
0.200956791639328,
0.060354411602020264,
0.25608113408088684,
0.6076033711433411,
-1.012715458869934,
0.841833770275116,
0.39741936326026917,
0.6088911890983582,
-0.5020377039909363,
-0.12454662472009659,
-1.0510716438293457,
0.08172360807657242,
-0.32859402894973755,
0.8702840209007263,
-0.37152785062789917,
-0.16445493698120117,
-0.5458787083625793,
-0.18941451609134674,
-0.09628596901893616,
-0.5701321363449097,
0.6084017157554626,
-0.3174948990345001,
-0.0744263157248497,
-0.3798907399177551,
-0.0034959143958985806,
0.13235239684581757,
-0.14830151200294495,
-0.6017199158668518,
1.387055516242981,
0.47841593623161316,
-0.35944223403930664,
0.4298105239868164,
-0.7681078910827637,
-0.28770551085472107,
-0.09065647423267365,
-0.15347523987293243,
-0.5682650804519653,
0.5455693602561951,
0.021780000999569893,
0.2996867299079895,
-0.636013388633728,
-0.6909142136573792,
-0.44541794061660767,
-0.5449619293212891,
-0.12849026918411255,
-0.1639203280210495,
0.3449382185935974,
0.086591437458992,
-0.104030542075634,
0.08040757477283478,
-0.9683954119682312,
0.3464352488517761,
0.18092592060565948,
-0.5706409215927124,
-0.6352983117103577,
0.1684543788433075,
-0.13630670309066772,
0.23402558267116547,
0.11210370063781738,
-0.4487113654613495,
0.46233347058296204,
-0.48728328943252563,
0.46783003211021423,
0.7927107214927673,
-0.31868359446525574,
0.6127346754074097,
-0.24384936690330505,
0.428009569644928,
-0.09686432778835297,
0.24628165364265442,
0.13799329102039337,
-0.31647011637687683,
-1.014643907546997,
-0.4115724563598633,
0.5231395959854126,
0.20258986949920654,
-0.5342382788658142,
0.5306150317192078,
-0.5055556297302246,
-0.7269127368927002,
-0.5538318157196045,
0.40323930978775024,
0.42308753728866577,
0.2651625871658325,
0.2984400689601898,
-0.03080323524773121,
-0.42081552743911743,
-0.787327766418457,
-0.0833144560456276,
-0.14581532776355743,
-0.012216032482683659,
0.16929462552070618,
0.5173115134239197,
0.022016001865267754,
0.8964713215827942,
-0.7752948999404907,
-0.5473054647445679,
-0.23809371888637543,
-0.12076408416032791,
0.1559123545885086,
0.4429129660129547,
0.831366777420044,
-0.3911571800708771,
-0.6974332928657532,
0.26689401268959045,
-0.2911989092826843,
0.07853398472070694,
0.3313504159450531,
0.029212046414613724,
0.2655518651008606,
0.38531866669654846,
-0.2725171148777008,
0.3520495593547821,
0.8455559015274048,
-0.3722837269306183,
0.05113764852285385,
-0.5508938431739807,
-0.215230330824852,
-0.9749861359596252,
0.03400839865207672,
-0.12919355928897858,
-0.45774024724960327,
-0.4327222406864166,
-0.043569400906562805,
-0.009842845611274242,
-0.2551605999469757,
-0.520677924156189,
0.5161722898483276,
-0.3096941113471985,
-0.28974825143814087,
-0.17030583322048187,
0.18709228932857513,
-0.04389763996005058,
0.7113973498344421,
-0.23386871814727783,
0.7155618071556091,
0.5084488391876221,
-0.49700555205345154,
-0.039528779685497284,
0.3382928967475891,
-0.3487981855869293,
0.5982844233512878,
-0.4679293632507324,
0.19608533382415771,
0.01568754017353058,
0.007681823335587978,
-0.7598455548286438,
0.20864388346672058,
0.15440678596496582,
0.0017256736755371094,
-0.059604842215776443,
-0.6461165547370911,
-0.4782382845878601,
-0.06317386776208878,
-0.5982183814048767,
0.2925754189491272,
0.8705528378486633,
-0.5086336135864258,
0.6372068524360657,
0.30640536546707153,
-0.48675498366355896,
-0.29357394576072693,
-0.3659130036830902,
-0.10854408144950867,
-0.4357030987739563,
-0.37285906076431274,
0.3495466709136963,
-0.45060816407203674,
-0.10537516325712204,
-0.09812244027853012,
-0.25614047050476074,
0.02807551994919777,
0.22902826964855194,
0.35727983713150024,
0.07142001390457153,
-0.6576476097106934,
-0.23545655608177185,
0.551108181476593,
-0.4026419222354889,
-0.3834414482116699,
-0.0783708319067955,
0.4162372052669525,
-0.13005605340003967,
-0.35563135147094727,
-0.24847620725631714,
0.45890650153160095,
0.8347861170768738,
-0.04723062738776207,
0.7838685512542725,
0.3430858850479126,
-0.31484168767929077,
-0.6406069993972778,
-0.1418953388929367,
0.1005505621433258,
-0.49617087841033936,
0.37226638197898865,
-0.5856252312660217,
-0.7269831299781799,
0.5850778222084045,
-0.19062510132789612,
-0.04076242819428444,
0.3176313638687134,
0.43112480640411377,
-0.012061147950589657,
1.283975601196289,
0.9153847098350525,
-0.12163498252630234,
0.6247920989990234,
-0.1969522386789322,
0.06630434840917587,
-0.702526867389679,
0.17694500088691711,
-0.9175675511360168,
-0.41250401735305786,
-0.5169346928596497,
-0.4949520230293274,
0.5438018441200256,
0.005186119116842747,
-0.2839283347129822,
0.41977646946907043,
-0.463246613740921,
0.5741015076637268,
0.33420196175575256,
0.05067216232419014,
0.45974379777908325,
0.13496719300746918,
0.3060872256755829,
-0.08179546892642975,
-0.8881109952926636,
-0.21492043137550354,
0.9478549957275391,
0.24899673461914062,
1.1648781299591064,
0.17286255955696106,
0.7448028922080994,
0.40313857793807983,
0.004899139516055584,
-0.827306866645813,
0.6237417459487915,
-0.6846840381622314,
-0.13639606535434723,
-0.6659020781517029,
-0.27037638425827026,
-0.9546771049499512,
0.4503629803657532,
-0.282489538192749,
-0.8973793983459473,
0.39174044132232666,
0.11000338196754456,
-0.867387592792511,
0.3252571225166321,
-0.8419060111045837,
0.49946123361587524,
-0.09347957372665405,
-0.2361217737197876,
-0.30001649260520935,
-0.42037105560302734,
-0.06665176153182983,
-0.5066899657249451,
0.06643962115049362,
-0.265738308429718,
-0.25404733419418335,
1.0701711177825928,
-0.48713168501853943,
0.7701946496963501,
-0.3024449944496155,
-0.30564001202583313,
-0.2602044939994812,
-0.09716300666332245,
0.750934898853302,
-0.06977960467338562,
-0.26806730031967163,
-0.08545516431331635,
0.48616543412208557,
-0.5066437721252441,
-0.6912445425987244,
1.0116934776306152,
-1.1455861330032349,
-0.3539675176143646,
-0.22696037590503693,
-0.44449687004089355,
-0.33140137791633606,
0.24881502985954285,
0.1217239573597908,
0.36976560950279236,
-0.18765701353549957,
0.36520785093307495,
0.9194134473800659,
0.008855383843183517,
0.24706150591373444,
0.4893573224544525,
-0.28320419788360596,
-0.28895455598831177,
1.160392165184021,
0.4266655147075653,
0.3686143159866333,
0.44353505969047546,
0.24758575856685638,
0.11999012529850006,
-0.8812453746795654,
-0.4796355664730072,
0.3323996067047119,
-0.6811908483505249,
-0.3609219193458557,
-0.20738768577575684,
-0.08481821417808533,
-0.08668181300163269,
-0.40015482902526855,
-0.9081842303276062,
-0.6032967567443848,
-0.30268219113349915,
0.36918404698371887,
0.44589361548423767,
0.7269414067268372,
0.08134876936674118,
0.5323329567909241,
-0.5179311633110046,
0.7107496857643127,
0.31476324796676636,
0.6031745672225952,
-0.3019549548625946,
-0.8382654786109924,
-0.5596882700920105,
-0.15789620578289032,
0.267267644405365,
-0.3058132231235504,
0.28318479657173157,
0.39369386434555054,
0.3996475636959076,
0.44549986720085144,
0.3449927270412445,
0.7962613105773926,
-0.4422922432422638,
0.4709484279155731,
0.012031222693622112,
-1.0023694038391113,
0.4514942169189453,
-0.41712069511413574,
0.23695148527622223,
0.6421043276786804,
-0.030350929126143456,
-0.22874952852725983,
0.18376792967319489,
-0.3863142728805542,
-0.5858029723167419,
1.0164309740066528,
0.08156541734933853,
0.09609220921993256,
0.6028575897216797,
0.541056215763092,
0.4464707672595978,
-0.20031128823757172,
-0.4898534119129181,
-0.3882586359977722,
0.10985942929983139,
0.05923750624060631,
-0.042042676359415054,
-0.24110934138298035,
-0.17885532975196838,
-0.46622857451438904,
0.7264324426651001,
-0.5668652057647705,
0.37189263105392456,
-0.45763418078422546,
-0.12673735618591309,
-0.45472827553749084,
0.2878272533416748,
0.659506618976593,
0.5062690377235413,
-0.37470337748527527,
0.015282025560736656,
0.616831362247467,
-0.2994864881038666,
0.2749464809894562,
-0.04520261287689209,
-0.09365597367286682,
-0.21879780292510986,
-0.13008973002433777,
0.9508053064346313,
0.6306021809577942,
-0.5395247936248779,
0.2985715866088867,
-0.2120717465877533,
-0.2034635990858078,
-0.06057320162653923,
0.4456010162830353,
0.0023942901752889156,
0.11123654991388321,
0.4818211793899536,
0.4014262855052948,
-0.3389812409877777,
-0.270455926656723,
-0.24281558394432068,
0.2662624716758728,
-0.38999736309051514,
-0.5505847334861755,
0.4516925513744354,
0.19459490478038788,
-0.24043241143226624,
-0.02668818272650242,
-0.026112528517842293,
0.2173999547958374,
0.2018921971321106,
0.46662747859954834,
0.5693362355232239,
-0.18639983236789703,
0.17906521260738373,
-0.03956862539052963,
0.0979568213224411,
-0.18634416162967682,
0.5319138169288635,
-0.048344410955905914,
-0.5246062874794006,
-0.39019575715065,
-0.6915922164916992,
-0.4915206730365753,
0.2191678285598755,
-0.9759442210197449,
0.6158964037895203,
-0.7215510010719299,
0.0017667690990492702,
0.27942049503326416,
0.20632857084274292,
-0.35974180698394775,
0.07048013061285019,
0.09994455426931381,
1.0465469360351562,
-1.0483112335205078,
1.21954345703125,
0.6106233596801758,
-0.1482609659433365,
-0.5059784650802612,
-0.47044894099235535,
-0.18263636529445648,
-0.7814813852310181,
0.5953754186630249,
-0.5711525678634644,
-0.5188207626342773,
0.25310665369033813,
-0.42554971575737,
-1.308691143989563,
1.079929232597351,
0.9199161529541016,
-0.29002273082733154,
-0.27001169323921204,
0.1780908703804016,
0.4639657139778137,
-0.3389344811439514,
-0.3924059569835663,
0.6604011654853821,
0.421037495136261,
-0.05766589939594269,
-0.8526557683944702,
0.002388858934864402,
-0.19314797222614288,
0.11776798218488693,
0.3372325897216797,
-0.8220533132553101,
1.0111006498336792,
-0.18699438869953156,
0.11684668809175491,
0.5775555968284607,
0.497440367937088,
0.1454419195652008,
-0.1829887330532074,
0.6425208449363708,
0.39857569336891174,
0.7073609828948975,
0.01246705837547779,
0.6342999935150146,
-0.05417715013027191,
0.27231287956237793,
0.9928632974624634,
-0.5161150693893433,
1.2264866828918457,
0.6128239631652832,
-0.24786314368247986,
0.6166481375694275,
0.30239418148994446,
0.1797219067811966,
0.6136125326156616,
-0.02681589126586914,
-0.08547651022672653,
-0.4435581862926483,
0.05356382206082344,
-0.3479919731616974,
0.6298102140426636,
0.45511430501937866,
-0.10964211076498032,
-0.36910316348075867,
0.227902352809906,
-0.020089859142899513,
-0.1511288434267044,
-0.5643147826194763,
0.762728750705719,
-0.043969426304101944,
-0.2857727110385895,
1.0049716234207153,
0.08169983327388763,
0.4429536461830139,
-0.8910033106803894,
0.14850232005119324,
-0.2306983470916748,
0.561095654964447,
-0.14704734086990356,
-0.27659541368484497,
-0.02270788513123989,
-0.057380687445402145,
-0.5271609425544739,
-0.23019342124462128,
0.6459259390830994,
-0.005982270464301109,
-0.38539695739746094,
0.256765216588974,
0.6819355487823486,
-0.06930772960186005,
-0.1370396912097931,
-0.5422590374946594,
0.44808053970336914,
-0.2061319351196289,
-0.2276144027709961,
1.0119082927703857,
0.26963385939598083,
-0.4165208041667938,
0.8448572158813477,
0.5454967021942139,
0.20229926705360413,
-0.10121646523475647,
-0.16599568724632263,
1.2422276735305786,
-0.7314711809158325,
-0.7077169418334961,
-0.4225555658340454,
0.2222258746623993,
0.3417503237724304,
-0.36002442240715027,
0.6991240978240967,
0.5187283754348755,
0.48218420147895813,
-0.1326800435781479,
0.8201470375061035,
0.08720333874225616,
0.632093608379364,
-0.49672162532806396,
0.7336445450782776,
-0.6364735960960388,
0.2687031328678131,
-0.4221820831298828,
-0.892583966255188,
-0.38223710656166077,
0.39782872796058655,
-0.21252226829528809,
-0.04895210638642311,
0.5945767164230347,
0.6969879269599915,
-0.2590317130088806,
-0.450035959482193,
0.7742810845375061,
0.2440672665834427,
-0.10154540836811066,
0.37138041853904724,
0.5640010833740234,
-0.7183073163032532,
0.784496545791626,
0.017987079918384552,
-0.20100641250610352,
-0.5358870029449463,
-0.7733178734779358,
-0.794438362121582,
-0.648167073726654,
-0.41791048645973206,
-0.1190217137336731,
0.14093324542045593,
0.991073489189148,
1.206805944442749,
-0.7418175339698792,
-0.1820393055677414,
0.4484761953353882,
0.1595114767551422,
-0.486582487821579,
-0.04275139421224594,
0.48909732699394226,
0.029312051832675934,
-0.6810989379882812,
0.7324748635292053,
0.577317476272583,
-0.13022273778915405,
-0.4413571357727051,
-0.28487005829811096,
0.20198388397693634,
0.32164138555526733,
0.8579409122467041,
0.5588733553886414,
-0.49307844042778015,
-0.4163728654384613,
-0.07023760676383972,
-0.05922107398509979,
0.4434833526611328,
0.5519837141036987,
-1.0215482711791992,
-0.08520563691854477,
0.4704880118370056,
0.414868026971817,
0.6579048037528992,
-0.21672174334526062,
0.25444135069847107,
-0.6460033655166626,
0.05895595997571945,
-0.10643818974494934,
0.19167560338974,
0.02140089124441147,
-0.14165917038917542,
0.3445762097835541,
0.0908789411187172,
-0.225801020860672,
-1.1457099914550781,
0.08346863836050034,
-1.6269975900650024,
-0.15673090517520905,
0.9946394562721252,
0.015709303319454193,
-0.4745838940143585,
-0.12337785959243774,
-0.39629390835762024,
-0.29049623012542725,
-0.505159854888916,
0.6445268988609314,
-0.02913222834467888,
-0.18043045699596405,
-0.23385073244571686,
-0.14395184814929962,
0.5274284482002258,
0.3446331322193146,
-1.0238200426101685,
0.3339247703552246,
0.008915781043469906,
0.37699899077415466,
0.05921159312129021,
0.5376091003417969,
0.07523172348737717,
0.30078426003456116,
-0.002982171718031168,
-0.1132708340883255,
0.10030800104141235,
-0.18273019790649414,
-0.5106752514839172,
0.36022695899009705,
0.5842535495758057,
-0.054059311747550964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17587v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17587v1
|
RAGSys: Item-Cold-Start Recommender as RAG System
| 2024-05-27T18:40:49 | 2024-05-27T18:40:49 |
Emile Contal, Garrin McGoldrick
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLM) hold immense promise for real-world applications,
but their generic knowledge often falls short of domain-specific needs.
Fine-tuning, a common approach, can suffer from catastrophic forgetting and
hinder generalizability. In-Context Learning (ICL) offers an alternative, which
can leverage Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) to provide LLMs with relevant
demonstrations for few-shot learning tasks. This paper explores the desired
qualities of a demonstration retrieval system for ICL. We argue that ICL
retrieval in this context resembles item-cold-start recommender systems,
prioritizing discovery and maximizing information gain over strict relevance.
We propose a novel evaluation method that measures the LLM's subsequent
performance on NLP tasks, eliminating the need for subjective diversity scores.
Our findings demonstrate the critical role of diversity and quality bias in
retrieved demonstrations for effective ICL, and highlight the potential of
recommender system techniques in this domain.
|
[
-0.36548689007759094,
-0.3091575503349304,
0.327707439661026,
0.043793875724077225,
-0.4189658463001251,
0.15696866810321808,
-0.20647495985031128,
-0.19397762417793274,
0.04103156179189682,
0.23498135805130005,
-0.26506173610687256,
-0.3743624687194824,
-0.5568845272064209,
-0.1218365877866745,
-0.5831728577613831,
1.5514984130859375,
0.12157288193702698,
-0.21100841462612152,
-0.3411721885204315,
-0.1782858669757843,
-0.5175833106040955,
-0.042980488389730453,
-0.6611035466194153,
-0.4875410497188568,
0.27932122349739075,
0.7654533386230469,
0.5533424019813538,
0.34840166568756104,
0.2203880250453949,
0.2687171399593353,
-0.14165331423282623,
0.35261619091033936,
-0.7820243239402771,
0.41752782464027405,
-0.28720253705978394,
-0.2078365534543991,
-0.11698216944932938,
0.05223151296377182,
0.5729283094406128,
0.721676766872406,
-0.04268654063344002,
0.3145393133163452,
0.4431256949901581,
0.444997102022171,
-0.7813680171966553,
-0.4036153554916382,
-0.7935104370117188,
0.006233742460608482,
-0.1256413757801056,
-0.11410597711801529,
-0.45745304226875305,
-0.1178969070315361,
0.5558899641036987,
-0.4171643555164337,
0.052381642162799835,
0.41169145703315735,
0.8194577693939209,
0.06555785238742828,
-0.4156382977962494,
-0.5169550180435181,
-0.8296013474464417,
1.1670010089874268,
-0.5211304426193237,
0.33861032128334045,
0.47963035106658936,
0.3299092650413513,
0.01030698511749506,
-0.6843584775924683,
-0.30248013138771057,
-0.5562942028045654,
-0.20807044208049774,
0.09578076004981995,
-0.05139218270778656,
-0.38703653216362,
0.22946225106716156,
0.35787779092788696,
-0.4006313979625702,
0.04712110385298729,
-0.2369639277458191,
0.10707064718008041,
0.3357805609703064,
0.22222065925598145,
0.0801301896572113,
-0.12084004282951355,
-0.5527384281158447,
0.007347338367253542,
-0.6489113569259644,
0.07294506579637527,
-0.013691461645066738,
0.4983419179916382,
-0.15357519686222076,
0.5501536130905151,
-0.33503371477127075,
0.6879969239234924,
0.3037838637828827,
-0.3840429186820984,
0.08855925500392914,
-0.1733742505311966,
-0.47761911153793335,
-0.22995278239250183,
0.28900083899497986,
0.2052237093448639,
-0.1764666736125946,
-0.28239428997039795,
-0.46028149127960205,
-0.33997756242752075,
0.20004139840602875,
-0.8448006510734558,
0.10214866697788239,
-0.084019236266613,
-0.633228600025177,
-0.14961549639701843,
0.12865802645683289,
-0.5788498520851135,
-0.4057585895061493,
-0.3689720928668976,
0.5280666947364807,
-0.5273902416229248,
-0.012920119799673557,
-0.15101025998592377,
-0.21375657618045807,
0.06223941594362259,
0.23259374499320984,
-0.5774699449539185,
0.4858897924423218,
0.5582965016365051,
0.7092046141624451,
-0.42126625776290894,
-0.22590455412864685,
-0.6496546864509583,
0.05987612158060074,
-0.29808691143989563,
0.7426422834396362,
-0.37150171399116516,
-0.43338969349861145,
0.06091557443141937,
-0.2352370321750641,
0.43849408626556396,
-0.7874240875244141,
0.515907347202301,
-0.6133602261543274,
0.25480011105537415,
-0.3106684386730194,
-0.6333703994750977,
0.14672209322452545,
0.3735281527042389,
-0.1218506395816803,
0.9374868869781494,
0.20522341132164001,
-0.6053345203399658,
0.9017934799194336,
-0.3840233087539673,
-0.4716145396232605,
0.429507851600647,
-0.07375486195087433,
-0.21297945082187653,
-0.07497715204954147,
-0.17064881324768066,
0.6698151230812073,
-0.29932740330696106,
0.21841566264629364,
-0.2887190282344818,
-0.7169225215911865,
0.08199609816074371,
-0.2238083928823471,
0.43273434042930603,
0.3766588866710663,
-0.46592143177986145,
0.02856248989701271,
-0.4609226584434509,
-0.03758622333407402,
-0.08599410951137543,
-0.41158655285835266,
-0.7110804915428162,
-0.07042097300291061,
0.0964268147945404,
0.17811235785484314,
0.20581801235675812,
-0.3388991355895996,
0.04247916117310524,
-0.6492693424224854,
-0.20604929327964783,
0.7549145817756653,
-0.23072044551372528,
0.6277501583099365,
-0.6534563899040222,
0.507124662399292,
-0.0569983646273613,
0.028392937034368515,
-0.23363810777664185,
-0.2856963276863098,
-0.866654634475708,
-0.12406377494335175,
0.058910150080919266,
0.31403908133506775,
-0.9119089841842651,
0.1870688647031784,
0.10643532872200012,
-0.40876612067222595,
-0.17691084742546082,
0.3757387399673462,
0.6865034103393555,
0.41304782032966614,
0.30793797969818115,
-0.1886288821697235,
-0.4375687837600708,
-0.8691536784172058,
-0.30360060930252075,
0.07367729395627975,
-0.1879904568195343,
0.766189694404602,
0.26057693362236023,
-0.15638986229896545,
0.8396835327148438,
-0.3527790904045105,
-0.4153566062450409,
-0.4524019658565521,
-0.13793198764324188,
0.685373067855835,
0.22265838086605072,
0.5961393713951111,
-0.6436976194381714,
-0.8320155739784241,
-0.11450894922018051,
-0.576916515827179,
-0.05673939734697342,
0.17566531896591187,
-0.039777833968400955,
-0.019399721175432205,
0.568192720413208,
-0.2395806461572647,
0.2940739393234253,
0.25380679965019226,
-0.47658997774124146,
0.5052093267440796,
-0.2464628368616104,
0.015004623681306839,
-0.9891711473464966,
-0.11846030503511429,
0.06796251237392426,
-0.256298691034317,
-0.4567580223083496,
0.1401585042476654,
-0.06118623912334442,
-0.14902423322200775,
-0.44145482778549194,
0.9784356355667114,
-0.28989240527153015,
-0.07631804794073105,
-0.5598992109298706,
0.3138476014137268,
-0.044831838458776474,
0.18252822756767273,
-0.3370920717716217,
0.7026880979537964,
0.553162157535553,
-0.8865824937820435,
-0.13674353063106537,
0.14009307324886322,
-0.49588584899902344,
0.6733726859092712,
-0.4889156222343445,
0.0619744136929512,
-0.19675634801387787,
0.17003697156906128,
-0.7514288425445557,
0.039370253682136536,
-0.09962709993124008,
0.09428676962852478,
0.38537630438804626,
-0.30626964569091797,
-0.21664592623710632,
-0.10472683608531952,
-0.28248268365859985,
0.36438900232315063,
0.6787392497062683,
-0.8311564922332764,
0.21142199635505676,
0.3338804841041565,
0.02348470687866211,
-0.8745434880256653,
-0.0029498154763132334,
-0.03941585496068001,
-0.31114307045936584,
-0.056719012558460236,
0.4039158523082733,
-0.2903743386268616,
-0.5378603339195251,
-0.14237338304519653,
0.015861717984080315,
0.24207407236099243,
0.2158268541097641,
0.3094470798969269,
0.22572007775306702,
-0.07204345613718033,
0.4167789816856384,
0.09866368025541306,
0.07580312341451645,
-0.4579119086265564,
-0.5582085251808167,
0.5044373869895935,
-0.28793883323669434,
-0.31855010986328125,
0.06617990881204605,
0.2792273461818695,
0.20394237339496613,
0.06248394399881363,
0.3007259666919708,
0.6055879592895508,
-0.34695714712142944,
-0.6359597444534302,
-0.4586988687515259,
-0.24419856071472168,
-0.5022587776184082,
0.2720741629600525,
-0.22090373933315277,
-0.8671867847442627,
-0.05224736034870148,
-0.20287610590457916,
0.11067469418048859,
0.2862982451915741,
0.4717545807361603,
-0.4478370249271393,
0.7382126450538635,
0.7816387414932251,
-0.043384578078985214,
0.6322869062423706,
-0.41994115710258484,
0.07895849645137787,
-0.8505274057388306,
-0.10243523865938187,
-0.4210394024848938,
-0.4563657343387604,
-0.2859056890010834,
-0.13355706632137299,
0.5249359607696533,
0.2840639352798462,
-0.3251290023326874,
0.2273644357919693,
-0.39955276250839233,
0.7349851131439209,
0.5850104093551636,
0.23064859211444855,
0.13966919481754303,
-0.039680540561676025,
-0.41455507278442383,
-0.0835479125380516,
-0.6945463418960571,
-0.6304718255996704,
1.1387709379196167,
-0.040466681122779846,
0.7501206994056702,
0.08710186183452606,
0.743191123008728,
0.33540958166122437,
0.5975962281227112,
-0.7737047672271729,
0.5500447750091553,
-0.7576961517333984,
-0.3063450753688812,
-0.3326130509376526,
0.0791647806763649,
-0.9644446969032288,
0.11714030802249908,
-0.31530141830444336,
-0.5790124535560608,
0.08754198253154755,
0.07974842190742493,
-0.4145296514034271,
0.18664613366127014,
-0.35320746898651123,
0.43800216913223267,
-0.2216687947511673,
-0.533519983291626,
-0.33261871337890625,
-0.3554725646972656,
0.42367851734161377,
0.14343661069869995,
0.20472775399684906,
-0.01218709908425808,
0.031006863340735435,
0.7325171232223511,
-0.05725764483213425,
0.7729554772377014,
-0.22499743103981018,
0.17573173344135284,
0.05569208040833473,
0.4369867742061615,
0.29473990201950073,
0.21959565579891205,
-0.18075868487358093,
-0.3951808214187622,
-0.27325159311294556,
-0.21275249123573303,
-0.6098864078521729,
0.9884274005889893,
-0.5564499497413635,
-0.692582368850708,
-0.13584758341312408,
-0.39736828207969666,
-0.22117272019386292,
0.23388980329036713,
0.16891714930534363,
0.679417610168457,
-0.1830289214849472,
0.3660297393798828,
0.7317796945571899,
-0.24976302683353424,
0.47822028398513794,
0.5330902934074402,
-0.3978573679924011,
-0.20593152940273285,
0.9282739162445068,
-0.11060553044080734,
0.20942619442939758,
0.30361995100975037,
0.43389415740966797,
0.008410695940256119,
-0.6595529317855835,
-0.40668946504592896,
0.12426908314228058,
-0.8791930675506592,
-0.41827529668807983,
-0.6433969140052795,
0.05095202103257179,
-0.21938712894916534,
-0.4063982665538788,
-0.06697578728199005,
-0.12145202606916428,
-0.41126352548599243,
0.05712778866291046,
0.20968320965766907,
0.9411521553993225,
0.1688801646232605,
0.1353207230567932,
-0.3854392170906067,
0.322887122631073,
0.5424258708953857,
0.6066919565200806,
0.08701810240745544,
-0.8586540818214417,
-0.649969220161438,
-0.3023447096347809,
-0.5730040073394775,
-0.4505692720413208,
0.3240848779678345,
0.37362417578697205,
0.6483548283576965,
0.7273757457733154,
0.1083131730556488,
0.5628613829612732,
-0.484261691570282,
0.8108171224594116,
-0.14448760449886322,
-0.7751403450965881,
0.5328044295310974,
-0.149852454662323,
0.33035901188850403,
0.5943155884742737,
0.5973971486091614,
-0.4869617223739624,
-0.4217894673347473,
-0.6658464074134827,
-0.8554185032844543,
0.5659841895103455,
-0.2373049110174179,
0.24541626870632172,
-0.11570524424314499,
0.3253895044326782,
0.3015570640563965,
0.1488266885280609,
-0.3723503351211548,
-0.27681201696395874,
-0.12580452859401703,
0.07593429833650589,
-0.21782496571540833,
-0.42450135946273804,
-0.16499574482440948,
-0.12258613109588623,
0.7936105728149414,
-0.347129225730896,
-0.0518183633685112,
0.17016412317752838,
-0.16589893400669098,
-0.054547276347875595,
0.3136462867259979,
0.5763482451438904,
0.6987380385398865,
-0.20719483494758606,
-0.0542517751455307,
0.4141288995742798,
-0.06875291466712952,
0.10465268045663834,
-0.20297929644584656,
-0.32815104722976685,
0.008566985838115215,
0.22202512621879578,
0.810572624206543,
0.5583316683769226,
-0.7770753502845764,
0.7037967443466187,
0.09457843005657196,
0.29744914174079895,
-0.372691810131073,
0.001189131522551179,
-0.1578269600868225,
0.35021740198135376,
0.5154141783714294,
0.15388092398643494,
0.4908340871334076,
-0.6913260221481323,
0.48966148495674133,
0.8273124098777771,
-0.6509681940078735,
-0.05135652795433998,
0.3153795599937439,
-0.09350859373807907,
-0.5393677353858948,
0.5058629512786865,
-0.28976425528526306,
-0.4177341163158417,
0.5386890172958374,
0.7555481791496277,
0.9282934665679932,
0.007409558165818453,
0.25176379084587097,
0.2486983835697174,
0.04647790640592575,
-0.09110883623361588,
0.0630786195397377,
-0.3377968668937683,
-0.7757294178009033,
-0.04739929735660553,
-0.6864029765129089,
-0.45116350054740906,
-0.012466710060834885,
-0.5616322755813599,
0.756760835647583,
-0.4593990445137024,
0.03535741940140724,
-0.34532132744789124,
-0.07577399909496307,
-0.8551417589187622,
0.30775177478790283,
0.06467270851135254,
0.8808816075325012,
-0.6894297003746033,
0.7693725824356079,
0.6156213283538818,
-0.08104514330625534,
-0.5188937783241272,
0.12601791322231293,
-0.25476759672164917,
-0.4418056905269623,
1.0989593267440796,
-0.06335779279470444,
-0.1637711524963379,
-0.2568415105342865,
-0.4385790228843689,
-0.8153452277183533,
1.171979546546936,
0.17777307331562042,
-0.21668371558189392,
0.10275987535715103,
-0.4832519292831421,
0.6291807889938354,
-0.6844310760498047,
0.6991351842880249,
0.24006806313991547,
0.13242898881435394,
-0.0031081174965947866,
-1.00545072555542,
-0.09137408435344696,
-0.11758927255868912,
0.04823150113224983,
-0.08187535405158997,
-0.631775975227356,
0.7984898686408997,
-0.38842061161994934,
-0.25339752435684204,
0.2154279500246048,
0.5203079581260681,
0.5900325775146484,
0.606264054775238,
0.7089123129844666,
0.29804328083992004,
0.42860984802246094,
0.26413586735725403,
1.249755859375,
0.02991972491145134,
0.11454951018095016,
1.2867748737335205,
-0.4101543128490448,
0.9718771576881409,
0.46985292434692383,
-0.13528689742088318,
0.544868528842926,
0.37900787591934204,
0.23119504749774933,
0.5888899564743042,
0.19333243370056152,
-0.2143709808588028,
-0.16959688067436218,
-0.3416522145271301,
-0.08523334562778473,
0.3816336393356323,
0.3792072832584381,
-0.4127518832683563,
-0.3951575458049774,
0.33217018842697144,
-0.29288917779922485,
0.21375957131385803,
-0.16924184560775757,
1.0322400331497192,
0.10232742875814438,
-0.6111160516738892,
0.6372280716896057,
-0.16425484418869019,
1.0320849418640137,
-0.5591053366661072,
-0.22061944007873535,
-0.45242932438850403,
0.018858332186937332,
-0.07072848826646805,
-0.5071874856948853,
0.12811113893985748,
-0.19267326593399048,
-0.39975717663764954,
-0.5031799077987671,
0.8375692963600159,
-0.38469940423965454,
-0.33722999691963196,
0.3738315999507904,
0.4275226593017578,
0.28996166586875916,
0.38603484630584717,
-0.5092236995697021,
-0.42061737179756165,
-0.2112550139427185,
-0.08376075327396393,
0.7755346894264221,
0.25743234157562256,
-0.1621522307395935,
0.8965898156166077,
0.5081232190132141,
0.011240467429161072,
-0.20080675184726715,
0.020080745220184326,
0.8044455647468567,
-0.31603968143463135,
-0.36601850390434265,
-0.7387635707855225,
0.3235587477684021,
-0.06286407262086868,
-0.3846101760864258,
0.9189010262489319,
0.6909938454627991,
1.0805737972259521,
-0.1829880177974701,
0.7015907764434814,
0.006161611992865801,
0.8220633268356323,
-0.36436259746551514,
0.7101888060569763,
-0.7301477789878845,
0.49632275104522705,
-0.35369187593460083,
-0.7867413759231567,
-0.06052052974700928,
0.172255277633667,
0.04720906540751457,
0.08572593331336975,
0.6281589865684509,
0.6272541284561157,
-0.3768805265426636,
-0.18990911543369293,
0.750137209892273,
0.14463455975055695,
0.138881653547287,
0.1808096468448639,
0.8779433369636536,
-0.39982736110687256,
0.5083461999893188,
-0.39249861240386963,
-0.3956218361854553,
-0.22713030874729156,
-0.9097830057144165,
-0.8596877455711365,
-0.808195173740387,
-0.08582556992769241,
-0.43033987283706665,
0.040993742644786835,
1.3019529581069946,
0.8030298948287964,
-0.8109452128410339,
-0.6873697638511658,
0.496965616941452,
0.2980193495750427,
-0.37362903356552124,
-0.23024573922157288,
0.2576110064983368,
-0.6638579964637756,
-0.6861269474029541,
0.8509388566017151,
0.24363628029823303,
-0.12132839113473892,
-0.30198904871940613,
-0.17837682366371155,
-0.05646270141005516,
-0.1506279557943344,
0.863053023815155,
0.12482093274593353,
-0.7747986316680908,
-0.0002302894281456247,
-0.11493894457817078,
0.03412128984928131,
-0.2673353850841522,
1.1028798818588257,
-1.2375361919403076,
0.27627190947532654,
0.3800431787967682,
0.5737646818161011,
0.5916622877120972,
-0.31757673621177673,
0.42924565076828003,
-0.7091057896614075,
0.09654133021831512,
0.37895792722702026,
0.4383290410041809,
0.20519326627254486,
-0.3576734662055969,
0.1759258359670639,
0.09588079899549484,
-0.6149232983589172,
-0.8030028939247131,
0.3508666157722473,
-0.5150663256645203,
-0.2548423111438751,
1.1173620223999023,
-0.15847896039485931,
0.17014534771442413,
-0.3208686113357544,
-0.2507551610469818,
-0.10897040367126465,
-0.4501208961009979,
0.9217192530632019,
0.37120598554611206,
0.08200721442699432,
-0.0028874727431684732,
-0.4099288582801819,
0.675674557685852,
0.4177747964859009,
-0.48108813166618347,
-0.14329801499843597,
0.1316574364900589,
0.39054644107818604,
-0.008680256083607674,
0.5152722001075745,
0.1947994977235794,
0.14962264895439148,
-0.5630998611450195,
-0.20572131872177124,
0.19127753376960754,
-0.44703251123428345,
-0.3825525939464569,
0.33860093355178833,
0.36055076122283936,
0.19222413003444672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17430v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17430v1
|
Matryoshka Multimodal Models
| 2024-05-27T17:59:56 | 2024-05-27T17:59:56 |
Mu Cai, Jianwei Yang, Jianfeng Gao, Yong Jae Lee
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) such as LLaVA have shown strong performance in
visual-linguistic reasoning. These models first embed images into a fixed large
number of visual tokens and then feed them into a Large Language Model (LLM).
However, this design causes an excessive number of tokens for dense visual
scenarios such as high-resolution images and videos, leading to great
inefficiency. While token pruning/merging methods do exist, they produce a
single length output for each image and do not afford flexibility in trading
off information density v.s. efficiency. Inspired by the concept of Matryoshka
Dolls, we propose M3: Matryoshka Multimodal Models, which learns to represent
visual content as nested sets of visual tokens that capture information across
multiple coarse-to-fine granularities. Our approach offers several unique
benefits for LMMs: (1) One can explicitly control the visual granularity per
test instance during inference, e.g. , adjusting the number of tokens used to
represent an image based on the anticipated complexity or simplicity of the
content; (2) M3 provides a framework for analyzing the granularity needed for
existing datasets, where we find that COCO-style benchmarks only need around ~9
visual tokens to obtain accuracy similar to that of using all 576 tokens; (3)
Our approach provides a foundation to explore the best trade-off between
performance and visual token length at sample level, where our investigation
reveals that a large gap exists between the oracle upper bound and current
fixed-scale representations.
|
[
-0.5388887524604797,
-0.7016683220863342,
0.4718712270259857,
0.16995328664779663,
-0.4371190369129181,
-0.16372889280319214,
-0.27026280760765076,
-0.42428791522979736,
0.13715092837810516,
0.5259022116661072,
-0.5275455713272095,
-0.4168711006641388,
-0.5704113841056824,
-0.14584973454475403,
-0.20310503244400024,
0.575528085231781,
0.02359277755022049,
-0.013915522955358028,
-0.4925321042537689,
-0.23253177106380463,
-0.44794967770576477,
-0.2321159541606903,
-0.3442516326904297,
-0.13918259739875793,
0.815707802772522,
0.49954095482826233,
0.8027054071426392,
0.5652989745140076,
0.6400938034057617,
0.30334019660949707,
0.031062044203281403,
0.6468701958656311,
-0.31516164541244507,
0.03678025305271149,
0.04832344129681587,
-0.45836251974105835,
-0.3164052665233612,
-0.06777326762676239,
0.5818392634391785,
0.6505687832832336,
-0.18923354148864746,
0.4196711778640747,
-0.2891005277633667,
0.5979118943214417,
-0.7032912373542786,
0.5846927165985107,
-0.5943866968154907,
0.20850177109241486,
-0.10304857790470123,
0.049326397478580475,
-0.5536699891090393,
0.27412447333335876,
-0.2503824234008789,
-0.6722928285598755,
-0.21492797136306763,
0.14786314964294434,
0.8386939764022827,
0.1960223764181137,
-0.5876189470291138,
-0.03975070267915726,
-0.5234777331352234,
0.9269266724586487,
-0.6419126391410828,
0.23874464631080627,
0.42058220505714417,
0.4465044140815735,
-0.06452036648988724,
-0.678260326385498,
-0.5999388694763184,
-0.3124407231807709,
-0.1615232527256012,
0.07217239588499069,
-0.1127232164144516,
0.09157446026802063,
0.27194511890411377,
0.27249714732170105,
-0.4057178795337677,
0.08028128743171692,
-0.5486869812011719,
-0.27800020575523376,
0.6558032035827637,
0.3617984652519226,
0.4043349027633667,
-0.31928980350494385,
-0.40253356099128723,
-0.18761169910430908,
-0.5116796493530273,
0.10528106987476349,
0.1461774855852127,
0.2337944358587265,
0.1730211228132248,
0.9536353945732117,
-0.24311864376068115,
0.8727566599845886,
-0.14830605685710907,
-0.7279211282730103,
0.25191730260849,
-0.36752447485923767,
-0.29010137915611267,
-0.13502782583236694,
0.8007359504699707,
0.49578386545181274,
0.2644466459751129,
0.07442700862884521,
-0.2974404990673065,
0.3062100410461426,
0.21755017340183258,
-0.9227903485298157,
-0.03516276180744171,
0.08059343695640564,
-0.6490644812583923,
-0.458449125289917,
-0.05996605008840561,
-0.7249508500099182,
-0.2312714159488678,
-0.527861475944519,
0.7977308630943298,
-0.496521532535553,
-0.3352730870246887,
0.18100713193416595,
-0.13291560113430023,
0.0785832479596138,
0.4638543426990509,
-1.0321941375732422,
0.21051949262619019,
0.5512902140617371,
0.8628543019294739,
-0.1297464817762375,
-0.32622453570365906,
-0.4425986409187317,
0.3031409978866577,
-0.6931495070457458,
0.53607577085495,
-0.7186395525932312,
-0.29121240973472595,
-0.0629223883152008,
0.02128615230321884,
-0.014219456352293491,
-0.5131040811538696,
0.17465442419052124,
-0.30306464433670044,
0.010289330966770649,
-0.11624756455421448,
-0.30945318937301636,
-0.24956297874450684,
0.34057411551475525,
-0.7277541160583496,
1.068557620048523,
-0.026274632662534714,
-0.734951376914978,
0.5846697092056274,
-0.4929477274417877,
-0.36297208070755005,
-0.2309899777173996,
-0.43232202529907227,
-0.34878215193748474,
0.3500145375728607,
0.5162861943244934,
0.6368520855903625,
-0.09062813222408295,
0.37846529483795166,
-0.43507543206214905,
-0.4836183488368988,
0.23945993185043335,
-0.4601019322872162,
0.45557597279548645,
0.291745662689209,
-0.02961687371134758,
0.3523346781730652,
-0.9469345211982727,
-0.1412050873041153,
0.17967037856578827,
-0.45913276076316833,
-0.22538810968399048,
-0.13551056385040283,
0.03253011777997017,
0.3462289869785309,
-0.01155485026538372,
-0.4114047586917877,
0.18941348791122437,
0.1655682474374771,
0.5362958908081055,
0.9183394908905029,
-0.34928709268569946,
0.4856286644935608,
-0.42434394359588623,
0.3280019462108612,
0.376234233379364,
0.3082311749458313,
-0.6502518653869629,
-0.6221439242362976,
-0.8960908055305481,
-0.8397922515869141,
0.33247795701026917,
0.2794658839702606,
-0.8225201964378357,
-0.010599985718727112,
-0.33229050040245056,
-0.2712913453578949,
-0.4777776896953583,
0.19587664306163788,
0.11242871731519699,
0.2281828075647354,
0.14183297753334045,
-0.5106992721557617,
-0.41402798891067505,
-1.0779285430908203,
0.34098899364471436,
-0.14958427846431732,
-0.012331120669841766,
0.44089755415916443,
0.6268714666366577,
-0.16553613543510437,
0.8989188075065613,
-0.3518294095993042,
-0.24583320319652557,
-0.18903376162052155,
0.11340709775686264,
0.19251756370067596,
0.4984332025051117,
0.3885914981365204,
-0.8487112522125244,
-0.14751404523849487,
0.06742721050977707,
-0.7863150238990784,
0.21004442870616913,
-0.10624684393405914,
-0.14472883939743042,
-0.02606530301272869,
0.4890469014644623,
-1.0700105428695679,
0.4203915596008301,
0.5874970555305481,
-0.12045906484127045,
0.6498083472251892,
-0.11630339920520782,
0.15619565546512604,
-0.9827868938446045,
-0.07272759824991226,
-0.17215296626091003,
-0.33369913697242737,
-0.4177500605583191,
0.1830468773841858,
0.07112718373537064,
-0.36213332414627075,
-0.5512939095497131,
0.6763724088668823,
-0.44022855162620544,
-0.25140783190727234,
0.03719682618975639,
0.11233191937208176,
0.2122478038072586,
0.6744363307952881,
-0.042135726660490036,
0.8084290027618408,
0.4792763888835907,
-0.467536598443985,
0.47807130217552185,
0.13122086226940155,
-0.7082298994064331,
0.6025144457817078,
-0.4128088653087616,
-0.21380671858787537,
-0.35943904519081116,
0.3085308074951172,
-1.1068143844604492,
-0.5129662156105042,
0.12743571400642395,
-0.30003243684768677,
0.3846440613269806,
-0.1450764238834381,
-0.709191083908081,
-0.24842315912246704,
-0.2875581681728363,
0.48052266240119934,
0.585051953792572,
-0.6197333335876465,
0.9509767293930054,
0.31771138310432434,
0.041877225041389465,
-0.8165569305419922,
-0.8567691445350647,
0.24462272226810455,
-0.3252829909324646,
-0.9725908041000366,
0.3301636874675751,
-0.02336331084370613,
-0.18514622747898102,
0.08319585770368576,
-0.04372021183371544,
0.06466136872768402,
-0.31526365876197815,
0.44135114550590515,
0.30060261487960815,
-0.46368345618247986,
0.44656962156295776,
-0.23649615049362183,
-0.11081469058990479,
-0.2880309224128723,
-0.18564750254154205,
0.46539369225502014,
-0.26092609763145447,
-0.4888331890106201,
-0.451003760099411,
0.3013448417186737,
0.9027010798454285,
-0.4077414572238922,
0.7301911115646362,
1.0245075225830078,
-0.29068470001220703,
0.03257252275943756,
-0.6729719638824463,
0.03860871121287346,
-0.4401712417602539,
0.3712802231311798,
-0.7308712005615234,
-0.8159760236740112,
0.4298064410686493,
-0.13464662432670593,
-0.08706264942884445,
0.22233179211616516,
0.546204149723053,
-0.06630069017410278,
1.3095569610595703,
0.5540909767150879,
0.20773202180862427,
0.5561118721961975,
-0.33059123158454895,
0.16596484184265137,
-0.8720840811729431,
-0.4006986916065216,
0.063057541847229,
-0.2761411666870117,
-0.35384872555732727,
-0.8960232734680176,
0.18361784517765045,
0.05807339400053024,
-0.23222415149211884,
-0.0019064713269472122,
-0.11375138908624649,
0.5705137848854065,
0.5741521716117859,
0.2648061513900757,
0.30068719387054443,
0.20480364561080933,
-0.44714605808258057,
0.0338464118540287,
-0.790382981300354,
-0.41651037335395813,
0.9000867009162903,
0.3909614682197571,
0.8787776827812195,
0.23881369829177856,
0.33680739998817444,
-0.024297621101140976,
0.07177336513996124,
-0.8928576111793518,
0.7989540100097656,
-0.2441992163658142,
-0.6040891408920288,
-0.21348576247692108,
-0.4889139235019684,
-0.784317672252655,
0.7168231010437012,
-0.36443066596984863,
-0.7199521660804749,
0.07399166375398636,
0.043869659304618835,
-0.165390744805336,
0.44269612431526184,
-0.6279147863388062,
0.9447935819625854,
-0.08296575397253036,
-0.47354361414909363,
-0.358822762966156,
-0.5927150249481201,
0.7767356634140015,
0.10783938318490982,
0.4143134355545044,
-0.39711397886276245,
-0.17941763997077942,
0.5214584469795227,
-0.2726328670978546,
1.0195698738098145,
0.09846702963113785,
0.1139078140258789,
0.3783164620399475,
0.2254878133535385,
0.3098370432853699,
0.07478058338165283,
0.23078840970993042,
0.01750432327389717,
0.05166221410036087,
-0.6188946962356567,
-0.6112877130508423,
0.5449318289756775,
-0.5930161476135254,
-0.5550869107246399,
-0.22094853222370148,
-0.7259936928749084,
-0.10496063530445099,
0.19447675347328186,
-0.19314855337142944,
0.7740462422370911,
0.016537947580218315,
0.37426328659057617,
0.5652100443840027,
-0.22674888372421265,
0.4275839030742645,
0.09562799334526062,
-0.7728824019432068,
-0.4542143642902374,
0.9289995431900024,
0.023271804675459862,
0.4440535306930542,
0.4103274345397949,
0.20746934413909912,
-0.023397179320454597,
-0.48441606760025024,
-0.7128464579582214,
0.17545603215694427,
-1.0351771116256714,
-0.11085668951272964,
-0.5352455973625183,
-0.0847477912902832,
-0.00038845391827635467,
0.035257332026958466,
-0.41604241728782654,
-0.6488639116287231,
-0.12862615287303925,
-0.10537468641996384,
0.1697678416967392,
0.6570765972137451,
-0.275909960269928,
0.30537351965904236,
-0.661201536655426,
0.2928343713283539,
0.6827681660652161,
0.2731512486934662,
0.0990501195192337,
-0.2830476760864258,
-0.08923128247261047,
-0.18679644167423248,
-0.030149944126605988,
-0.40297022461891174,
0.19770199060440063,
0.06567242741584778,
0.5043261647224426,
0.5981497764587402,
-0.4573497772216797,
1.0603289604187012,
-0.5563834309577942,
0.871329128742218,
0.553572416305542,
-0.7096153497695923,
0.35860902070999146,
-0.34557780623435974,
0.35093218088150024,
0.31611329317092896,
0.18060903251171112,
-0.5559819340705872,
-0.027270546182990074,
-0.4896452724933624,
-0.7269171476364136,
0.4687773883342743,
0.21447907388210297,
0.3182417154312134,
-0.0945972204208374,
0.037199992686510086,
0.09195894747972488,
0.3102261424064636,
-0.6300531625747681,
0.173069030046463,
-0.19648919999599457,
-0.3920413851737976,
-0.10718704760074615,
-0.31537163257598877,
-0.2438243180513382,
-0.31605973839759827,
0.44176748394966125,
-0.2973209619522095,
0.1612708419561386,
-0.055176034569740295,
-0.30780091881752014,
0.1411522477865219,
-0.06702315807342529,
0.7124840021133423,
0.8936799168586731,
-0.2185429036617279,
0.5874520540237427,
0.15945973992347717,
-0.2851077914237976,
0.06689316034317017,
-0.4337185025215149,
0.06814710050821304,
0.05994550138711929,
0.601107120513916,
0.9762927293777466,
0.34724313020706177,
-1.0749486684799194,
0.6559402942657471,
-0.12499433755874634,
-0.1274469792842865,
-0.12711553275585175,
-0.009815158322453499,
0.15766531229019165,
0.23862534761428833,
0.013546145521104336,
0.24763014912605286,
-0.22366367280483246,
-0.8364264965057373,
0.3667343556880951,
0.49057266116142273,
-0.3795802593231201,
-0.1594424545764923,
0.34623321890830994,
0.03885209560394287,
-0.003533637849614024,
0.7033886313438416,
-0.09157535433769226,
-0.1943293958902359,
0.6806666254997253,
0.46794024109840393,
0.13747155666351318,
-0.009255584329366684,
0.43152719736099243,
0.455702006816864,
0.2871542274951935,
-0.2670070230960846,
-0.07588808238506317,
-0.17253051698207855,
-0.740748941898346,
-0.551529049873352,
-0.7008177042007446,
-0.09647572040557861,
0.008844136260449886,
-0.3633573353290558,
0.31811732053756714,
-0.4089965224266052,
-0.20477919280529022,
0.045832451432943344,
-0.34621283411979675,
-0.6332342028617859,
0.19544020295143127,
0.41347944736480713,
0.8310028910636902,
-0.7851989269256592,
0.6555591225624084,
0.2781848907470703,
-0.6859616041183472,
-0.5393806099891663,
-0.46120166778564453,
0.0011036331998184323,
-1.1843467950820923,
0.758152425289154,
0.561470627784729,
0.053908124566078186,
-0.42506828904151917,
-0.5112274885177612,
-1.0064481496810913,
1.3362504243850708,
0.24110062420368195,
-0.474513441324234,
0.007209688890725374,
0.14432217180728912,
0.16317185759544373,
-0.7995083928108215,
0.18056219816207886,
0.3604830205440521,
0.39520445466041565,
0.5684866309165955,
-0.8311547636985779,
-0.10071109980344772,
-0.24501454830169678,
0.2881107032299042,
0.20133009552955627,
-0.7235592603683472,
0.9268860220909119,
-0.4176633954048157,
-0.09813693910837173,
0.15430298447608948,
0.46641087532043457,
0.2692456543445587,
0.2268032282590866,
0.5616766810417175,
0.8377214670181274,
0.6734532117843628,
0.010377067141234875,
1.042746901512146,
0.0782868042588234,
0.23674659430980682,
0.9343924522399902,
0.03487171605229378,
0.9265016913414001,
0.6909487843513489,
-0.16259706020355225,
0.45653125643730164,
0.7889030575752258,
-0.02685900591313839,
0.5944926738739014,
0.24139522016048431,
-0.18581607937812805,
-0.6559520959854126,
-0.3512338101863861,
-0.06260799616575241,
0.5600271224975586,
0.43038976192474365,
-0.3136458694934845,
-0.016433503478765488,
0.11112609505653381,
0.04309627041220665,
-0.24430428445339203,
-0.37313225865364075,
0.6092026233673096,
0.1538892537355423,
-0.508053719997406,
0.3466072678565979,
-0.0785372257232666,
0.5084385275840759,
-0.5402019023895264,
-0.04224369302392006,
-0.14730927348136902,
0.17147308588027954,
-0.11602244526147842,
-0.6345915794372559,
0.08726657181978226,
-0.39068910479545593,
0.04564825817942619,
-0.03458708897233009,
0.7292323708534241,
-0.46640753746032715,
-0.8935246467590332,
0.08033782988786697,
0.3497118055820465,
0.0759374350309372,
0.12982060015201569,
-0.6196826696395874,
0.2547954022884369,
-0.24650788307189941,
-0.21665175259113312,
0.4596746861934662,
0.47134119272232056,
-0.10698738694190979,
0.7261744737625122,
0.8065033555030823,
-0.11653845757246017,
0.22538048028945923,
0.24604856967926025,
0.8072203397750854,
-0.524179995059967,
-0.21161691844463348,
-0.858052670955658,
0.6907914876937866,
-0.18725551664829254,
-0.13839690387248993,
0.39711886644363403,
0.40869253873825073,
0.7280963063240051,
-0.10691402107477188,
0.49829450249671936,
0.13356749713420868,
-0.19260050356388092,
-0.8558417558670044,
0.16049690544605255,
-0.8857221603393555,
0.01990262232720852,
-0.1336757242679596,
-0.7915509343147278,
-0.5649777054786682,
0.7088097929954529,
-0.05765244737267494,
-0.0566677451133728,
0.647026777267456,
0.9307332634925842,
-0.3785284161567688,
-0.238601952791214,
0.6840493679046631,
0.03624097257852554,
0.3117973208427429,
0.5260613560676575,
1.1947801113128662,
-0.21619196236133575,
0.6117910742759705,
-0.2970065176486969,
-0.16559050977230072,
-0.25573572516441345,
-0.8489548563957214,
-1.1079866886138916,
-0.5380528569221497,
-0.13371747732162476,
-0.06304707378149033,
-0.10581281036138535,
0.7557323575019836,
1.0360841751098633,
-0.35071516036987305,
-0.14601607620716095,
0.20673838257789612,
0.02436649240553379,
-0.187903493642807,
-0.16229099035263062,
0.2934468984603882,
-0.3631490468978882,
-0.4499715566635132,
0.16769306361675262,
0.6023832559585571,
0.0890384167432785,
-0.4327179193496704,
-0.07783111184835434,
-0.13129040598869324,
0.4221459925174713,
0.978909969329834,
-0.24718151986598969,
-1.0363428592681885,
-0.31468868255615234,
-0.13422733545303345,
-0.016890771687030792,
0.281157523393631,
0.8267176747322083,
-0.570527195930481,
0.6301788091659546,
0.4232107102870941,
0.5187435746192932,
0.9452858567237854,
-0.1581282913684845,
0.2910540997982025,
-0.7302242517471313,
0.5060523748397827,
-0.05004424229264259,
0.6308667063713074,
0.45464083552360535,
0.08392214775085449,
0.5124393701553345,
0.1062355488538742,
-0.21239624917507172,
-0.8291999101638794,
0.41109132766723633,
-1.132940649986267,
-0.5292392373085022,
1.1207176446914673,
-0.07866921275854111,
-0.48311296105384827,
0.37687110900878906,
-0.4121699035167694,
-0.11932896822690964,
-0.2162965089082718,
0.6296172738075256,
0.921004593372345,
-0.013309829868376255,
-0.5087178945541382,
-0.7354170083999634,
0.18542493879795074,
0.283823162317276,
-0.6209542751312256,
-0.12373556941747665,
0.39831089973449707,
0.183305561542511,
0.35216224193573,
0.6150624752044678,
-0.2547721862792969,
0.1907770186662674,
0.3518811762332916,
-0.20849351584911346,
-0.31634587049484253,
-0.6135267615318298,
-0.008872798644006252,
0.3155069947242737,
0.06436986476182938,
-0.2483927607536316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17428v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17428v1
|
NV-Embed: Improved Techniques for Training LLMs as Generalist Embedding Models
| 2024-05-27T17:59:45 | 2024-05-27T17:59:45 |
Chankyu Lee, Rajarshi Roy, Mengyao Xu, Jonathan Raiman, Mohammad Shoeybi, Bryan Catanzaro, Wei Ping
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Decoder-only large language model (LLM)-based embedding models are beginning
to outperform BERT or T5-based embedding models in general-purpose text
embedding tasks, including dense vector-based retrieval. In this work, we
introduce the NV-Embed model with a variety of architectural designs and
training procedures to significantly enhance the performance of LLM as a
versatile embedding model, while maintaining its simplicity and
reproducibility. For model architecture, we propose a latent attention layer to
obtain pooled embeddings, which consistently improves retrieval and downstream
task accuracy compared to mean pooling or using the last <EOS> token embedding
from LLMs. To enhance representation learning, we remove the causal attention
mask of LLMs during contrastive training. For model training, we introduce a
two-stage contrastive instruction-tuning method. It first applies contrastive
training with instructions on retrieval datasets, utilizing in-batch negatives
and curated hard negative examples. At stage-2, it blends various non-retrieval
datasets into instruction tuning, which not only enhances non-retrieval task
accuracy but also improves retrieval performance. Combining these techniques,
our NV-Embed model, using only publicly available data, has achieved a
record-high score of 69.32, ranking No. 1 on the Massive Text Embedding
Benchmark (MTEB) (as of May 24, 2024), with 56 tasks, encompassing retrieval,
reranking, classification, clustering, and semantic textual similarity tasks.
Notably, our model also attains the highest score of 59.36 on 15 retrieval
tasks in the MTEB benchmark (also known as BEIR). We will open-source the model
at: https://huggingface.co/nvidia/NV-Embed-v1.
|
[
-0.1344565600156784,
-0.710022509098053,
0.46066954731941223,
0.10494998842477798,
-0.5078032612800598,
-0.008653556928038597,
-0.0940643697977066,
-0.09521736949682236,
0.29846158623695374,
0.6096048355102539,
-0.17990736663341522,
-0.7088329792022705,
-0.6338707208633423,
-0.09937457740306854,
-0.49201080203056335,
0.5259037613868713,
-0.006115759257227182,
0.2709684669971466,
-0.5265944600105286,
-0.12117856740951538,
-0.4199039340019226,
-0.4251798987388611,
-0.33364734053611755,
-0.17094090580940247,
0.331063449382782,
0.26410552859306335,
0.26274073123931885,
0.85576331615448,
0.4166438579559326,
0.17955194413661957,
-0.17768341302871704,
0.21504206955432892,
-0.6907568573951721,
0.15778881311416626,
-0.092705138027668,
-0.4535239040851593,
-0.30143535137176514,
-0.10842281579971313,
0.783707857131958,
0.34345462918281555,
-0.2698924243450165,
-0.11325542628765106,
0.20871491730213165,
0.32487908005714417,
-0.7234218716621399,
0.07977328449487686,
-0.575957715511322,
-0.010980214923620224,
0.07363378256559372,
-0.2289767563343048,
-0.7190514206886292,
-0.3934967517852783,
0.17869287729263306,
-0.5116936564445496,
0.09624484181404114,
0.14137929677963257,
0.6325938701629639,
0.4197894036769867,
-0.47055143117904663,
-0.07151129841804504,
-0.3280428349971771,
1.1380432844161987,
-0.6655370593070984,
0.6546844840049744,
0.43940481543540955,
0.0804283395409584,
0.0692111998796463,
-0.48758599162101746,
-0.13876357674598694,
-0.44894617795944214,
0.27123814821243286,
0.12268270552158356,
-0.09959850460290909,
0.031229939311742783,
-0.009601891972124577,
0.3857156038284302,
-0.43775349855422974,
0.29576337337493896,
0.04819268360733986,
0.016416432335972786,
0.32594531774520874,
0.25570088624954224,
0.08384925872087479,
-0.17289191484451294,
-0.48038026690483093,
-0.030872298404574394,
-0.8138802647590637,
-0.3201691806316376,
0.22968843579292297,
0.24681125581264496,
-0.24391862750053406,
0.5462203025817871,
-0.12188246101140976,
0.5997025966644287,
-0.07781536132097244,
0.1268184930086136,
0.3008359372615814,
-0.3139840364456177,
-0.28297919034957886,
-0.3211855888366699,
0.4879045784473419,
0.33114075660705566,
-0.05180114507675171,
-0.3621652126312256,
-0.35745155811309814,
0.034988898783922195,
0.37962257862091064,
-0.9547970294952393,
-0.06457684934139252,
-0.06431782245635986,
-0.442754864692688,
-0.4741958677768707,
-0.058091018348932266,
-0.5080361366271973,
-0.38979294896125793,
-0.3565160036087036,
0.48161619901657104,
-0.4603654444217682,
-0.08650131523609161,
0.1329358071088791,
-0.08320774883031845,
0.7333278059959412,
0.488741010427475,
-0.800696849822998,
0.4751388728618622,
0.605076014995575,
0.9378656148910522,
-0.1946997493505478,
0.20641107857227325,
-0.743121862411499,
0.17811249196529388,
-0.22640396654605865,
0.7127404808998108,
-0.9218913316726685,
-0.22190150618553162,
0.33915793895721436,
-0.15505041182041168,
0.18584229052066803,
-0.5842530727386475,
0.41327884793281555,
-0.6969574689865112,
0.1986187994480133,
-0.26497682929039,
-0.9112014770507812,
-0.18795117735862732,
0.4539105296134949,
-0.7329987287521362,
1.0782390832901,
-0.12404914945363998,
-0.7530242204666138,
-0.08054757863283157,
-0.3438463807106018,
-0.10894320905208588,
-0.08300529420375824,
-0.19337333738803864,
-0.40140005946159363,
0.3191787004470825,
0.3922058939933777,
0.7675262093544006,
-0.4235725402832031,
-0.003246218664571643,
-0.27913960814476013,
-0.7432807683944702,
-0.1428656280040741,
-0.3212150037288666,
0.3708803653717041,
-0.19859418272972107,
-0.07148052006959915,
-0.12393173575401306,
-0.5258150100708008,
-0.19908025860786438,
0.23903270065784454,
-0.4915454089641571,
-0.4337969124317169,
-0.02304183878004551,
0.1864108294248581,
-0.025583626702427864,
0.38159140944480896,
-0.6354926824569702,
0.40297117829322815,
-0.562853217124939,
0.49133509397506714,
0.6224424242973328,
0.07047144323587418,
0.5045621395111084,
-0.2195415496826172,
0.4326350688934326,
-0.020705003291368484,
-0.01970546878874302,
-0.18124769628047943,
-0.38486966490745544,
-0.7078814506530762,
-0.16461151838302612,
0.520228922367096,
0.6100220084190369,
-0.9658203125,
0.25197115540504456,
-0.34786075353622437,
-0.33233681321144104,
-0.6637417674064636,
0.2727397382259369,
0.5918244123458862,
0.24887573719024658,
0.4765952229499817,
-0.37421801686286926,
-0.3820100724697113,
-0.8115439414978027,
-0.1459568589925766,
0.2927645444869995,
0.04033992439508438,
0.46587488055229187,
0.537551760673523,
-0.3505639135837555,
0.5205656886100769,
-0.45038852095603943,
-0.23977351188659668,
-0.2744985520839691,
-0.025372855365276337,
0.1594327986240387,
0.22312302887439728,
0.2161460816860199,
-0.5915754437446594,
-0.458595871925354,
-0.06265215575695038,
-0.6814596652984619,
0.08563543856143951,
0.3008274435997009,
0.14725691080093384,
0.2257591336965561,
0.8169596195220947,
-0.06250300258398056,
0.177091583609581,
0.561034083366394,
-0.062345802783966064,
0.1676408052444458,
-0.3928311765193939,
-0.12751010060310364,
-1.1826308965682983,
-0.0930645763874054,
0.13555596768856049,
-0.38849249482154846,
-0.5411226749420166,
0.07150024175643921,
0.37831398844718933,
0.1438237428665161,
-0.6863071322441101,
0.5170040726661682,
-0.5514270067214966,
0.013056090101599693,
-0.41314226388931274,
0.48608526587486267,
0.029484225437045097,
0.41895174980163574,
-0.1180216446518898,
0.6316193342208862,
0.430073082447052,
-0.6158655285835266,
0.2449105829000473,
0.27673524618148804,
-0.44455456733703613,
0.30502262711524963,
-0.8398578763008118,
0.39270874857902527,
-0.3968135714530945,
0.00334008876234293,
-0.9566470980644226,
0.06520002335309982,
0.0962582677602768,
-0.27233627438545227,
0.5918952822685242,
-0.32212671637535095,
-0.5648679733276367,
0.20171046257019043,
-0.5489786267280579,
0.3092403709888458,
0.4882042109966278,
-0.5925758481025696,
0.5859807729721069,
0.30672165751457214,
-0.02273636683821678,
-0.7718358039855957,
-0.8427390456199646,
0.011985428631305695,
0.027261393144726753,
-0.4441305100917816,
0.8184191584587097,
0.045718107372522354,
0.10228275507688522,
0.15611928701400757,
-0.02245407924056053,
-0.1163896918296814,
0.11587785929441452,
0.02838212437927723,
0.29046040773391724,
-0.14760243892669678,
0.38659870624542236,
0.0886743888258934,
-0.17074555158615112,
-0.19518069922924042,
-0.22983604669570923,
0.4838244915008545,
0.05929601937532425,
-0.38371866941452026,
-0.39917877316474915,
0.34067198634147644,
0.24535618722438812,
-0.40576305985450745,
0.9016391634941101,
0.525861918926239,
-0.436204195022583,
-0.21753662824630737,
-0.6970152258872986,
-0.23875415325164795,
-0.4033699035644531,
0.5899827480316162,
-0.03652144968509674,
-1.2343075275421143,
0.19333422183990479,
-0.11043522506952286,
0.179691880941391,
0.11854158341884613,
0.5304928421974182,
-0.0565604642033577,
0.8239796757698059,
0.7848777174949646,
-0.2078128457069397,
0.9422182440757751,
-0.4318591058254242,
-0.0767681896686554,
-1.1314862966537476,
-0.38383492827415466,
-0.301329106092453,
-0.16940629482269287,
-0.6131759881973267,
-0.8838868737220764,
-0.036696989089250565,
-0.019149774685502052,
-0.28296202421188354,
0.1408551037311554,
-0.44994837045669556,
0.559848964214325,
0.33919718861579895,
0.221664160490036,
0.1132173165678978,
0.14231126010417938,
-0.18970812857151031,
-0.22141581773757935,
-0.5159536004066467,
-0.5421389937400818,
1.4242278337478638,
0.41181907057762146,
0.8859657049179077,
0.18499977886676788,
0.9934049248695374,
0.3066512942314148,
0.24282784759998322,
-0.7239015102386475,
0.34657931327819824,
-0.4537788927555084,
-0.14928987622261047,
-0.0004175315552856773,
-0.30476829409599304,
-0.7806674242019653,
0.5009239315986633,
-0.2648707628250122,
-0.42685961723327637,
0.0982573851943016,
-0.03758613020181656,
-0.23447059094905853,
0.1562693864107132,
-0.6207171678543091,
0.6926423907279968,
-0.04490092396736145,
-0.6446608901023865,
-0.2938641607761383,
-0.27442172169685364,
0.16740283370018005,
0.17329558730125427,
-0.04129035770893097,
0.08846765756607056,
-0.5372871160507202,
0.67691969871521,
0.20811843872070312,
0.9096234440803528,
-0.2872035503387451,
0.11180621385574341,
0.06959711015224457,
-0.14899197220802307,
0.8442940711975098,
-0.016559654846787453,
-0.17956256866455078,
-0.05854827165603638,
-0.4522062838077545,
-0.49073582887649536,
-0.6398465037345886,
0.8609123826026917,
-0.9787415266036987,
-0.5968877673149109,
-0.20109155774116516,
-0.16127876937389374,
0.001832256093621254,
0.01866602897644043,
-0.03568960726261139,
0.5048361420631409,
-0.4450804889202118,
0.741328239440918,
1.3180208206176758,
-0.34406501054763794,
0.22031930088996887,
0.3901846408843994,
-0.15170633792877197,
-0.5316423773765564,
0.9940622448921204,
-0.021373027935624123,
0.19333606958389282,
0.986253023147583,
-0.011680918745696545,
-0.4116515815258026,
-0.7180361151695251,
0.07726079970598221,
0.3302946388721466,
-0.8169751763343811,
-0.21913006901741028,
-0.8168699741363525,
-0.11205024272203445,
-0.36592304706573486,
0.024298176169395447,
-0.4821428060531616,
-0.08481751382350922,
-0.6803444027900696,
-0.11112749576568604,
0.183717280626297,
0.9744184613227844,
0.35502201318740845,
0.20604802668094635,
-0.4769305884838104,
0.26508629322052,
0.21368707716464996,
0.4310060143470764,
0.0094083147123456,
-0.8482860326766968,
-0.45818695425987244,
-0.19183951616287231,
-0.4063168466091156,
-0.7989533543586731,
0.5210670828819275,
0.10401605814695358,
0.741278350353241,
0.17960746586322784,
-0.25708115100860596,
0.2839972972869873,
-0.482047438621521,
0.6623559594154358,
-0.12490323185920715,
-0.8773677945137024,
0.5244253277778625,
-0.19492855668067932,
0.10294162482023239,
0.37688589096069336,
0.3044221103191376,
-0.26549553871154785,
-0.025952830910682678,
-0.25119081139564514,
-0.8522512316703796,
0.5263822078704834,
0.12273457646369934,
0.3393482267856598,
-0.06212664768099785,
0.5326523780822754,
-0.09655393660068512,
0.2461339682340622,
-0.7554203271865845,
-0.2815161347389221,
-0.31524407863616943,
-0.20512360334396362,
-0.07631827145814896,
-0.5124720931053162,
0.32959213852882385,
-0.17595970630645752,
0.63474041223526,
-0.13028208911418915,
0.5659446120262146,
0.14075788855552673,
-0.35520049929618835,
0.3376704454421997,
0.2790513038635254,
0.4836541712284088,
0.17426255345344543,
-0.34263893961906433,
-0.007999107241630554,
0.2863166630268097,
-0.3282267153263092,
0.10617545247077942,
-0.022781195119023323,
0.02048582397401333,
-0.020106427371501923,
0.22903859615325928,
0.7009955644607544,
0.6996557712554932,
-0.4054761826992035,
0.7530612349510193,
-0.270088255405426,
-0.2630496025085449,
-0.19121387600898743,
0.02224964275956154,
0.4252493679523468,
0.34901925921440125,
0.04669274389743805,
-0.4335642158985138,
0.1075475886464119,
-0.2568622827529907,
0.0650118887424469,
0.513731837272644,
-0.36962592601776123,
-0.045648884028196335,
0.5925513505935669,
0.2132149189710617,
-0.20439667999744415,
0.7751617431640625,
-0.17905430495738983,
-0.19688774645328522,
0.3570963144302368,
0.5996553897857666,
0.9137647747993469,
-0.2604838013648987,
0.14371182024478912,
0.2845570743083954,
0.4385203421115875,
-0.19923755526542664,
0.4790865480899811,
0.07057499140501022,
-0.5648914575576782,
-0.5771551132202148,
-0.5457929968833923,
-0.6222524642944336,
0.022520439699292183,
-0.6883749961853027,
0.33775198459625244,
-0.4903079867362976,
0.0842389464378357,
-0.3647351861000061,
0.22780604660511017,
-0.9622410535812378,
-0.03576214239001274,
0.09358905255794525,
0.9269546270370483,
-0.7343785166740417,
1.029430627822876,
0.7378811836242676,
-0.46500465273857117,
-0.3074140250682831,
-0.02330736070871353,
-0.38477373123168945,
-0.8646489381790161,
0.45055651664733887,
0.3572391867637634,
0.04108670726418495,
0.12321372330188751,
-0.6943691968917847,
-1.1241308450698853,
1.4154175519943237,
0.6692213416099548,
-0.8172650337219238,
-0.05018702521920204,
-0.26205286383628845,
0.4489660859107971,
-0.49540358781814575,
0.3858488202095032,
0.1559576541185379,
0.12256201356649399,
0.013377409428358078,
-0.3098885416984558,
0.10513504594564438,
-0.1716044545173645,
0.35741356015205383,
0.025505242869257927,
-0.6236760020256042,
0.8120530247688293,
-0.005872389767318964,
-0.10869379341602325,
-0.005397669039666653,
0.6904531121253967,
0.17906825244426727,
-0.11480864137411118,
0.07066859304904938,
0.7444930076599121,
0.791348934173584,
0.07844951748847961,
1.3994051218032837,
-0.23524600267410278,
0.25124591588974,
1.0588383674621582,
-0.07751864939928055,
1.2470190525054932,
0.4680832624435425,
0.23087778687477112,
0.688769519329071,
0.29431354999542236,
-0.20494797825813293,
0.9262804388999939,
0.23248909413814545,
-0.1242946907877922,
-0.4552233815193176,
-0.2905087471008301,
-0.33486729860305786,
0.3177460730075836,
0.42593836784362793,
-0.6227253675460815,
-0.12959958612918854,
-0.03834094852209091,
-0.29502058029174805,
0.06455332785844803,
-0.17203176021575928,
0.7763841152191162,
0.3203590512275696,
-0.16715402901172638,
0.4946523904800415,
0.3025051951408386,
0.9205756783485413,
-0.37985289096832275,
-0.2250642627477646,
-0.23290874063968658,
0.20548364520072937,
0.013185454532504082,
-0.4843088388442993,
-0.013429127633571625,
-0.06142333149909973,
-0.2637132704257965,
-0.22640854120254517,
0.6930676698684692,
-0.4279822111129761,
-0.2408868819475174,
0.5180236101150513,
0.512651801109314,
0.06672003120183945,
-0.1787668913602829,
-0.5812792778015137,
0.24935407936573029,
-0.022763419896364212,
-0.2840650677680969,
0.48237138986587524,
0.1906009018421173,
0.19826318323612213,
0.705915629863739,
0.46116331219673157,
-0.19285067915916443,
0.049526672810316086,
0.2629528045654297,
0.9259614944458008,
-0.9485790133476257,
-0.361522376537323,
-0.8928243517875671,
0.3567868769168854,
0.050217024981975555,
-0.0099753113463521,
0.6188216805458069,
0.3919938802719116,
0.7569270133972168,
0.09660976380109787,
0.7173972129821777,
0.538186252117157,
0.27125731110572815,
-0.5409860610961914,
0.3542110323905945,
-0.7265111207962036,
0.22166286408901215,
-0.06386902928352356,
-1.0281989574432373,
-0.3025188744068146,
0.5708805322647095,
-0.3691774904727936,
0.15249377489089966,
0.47018253803253174,
0.7891894578933716,
-0.07824131846427917,
-0.11996368318796158,
0.5415861010551453,
0.2120242714881897,
0.3856908679008484,
0.7705923318862915,
0.7417678236961365,
-0.6349393129348755,
0.5113769769668579,
0.07248230278491974,
-0.1099572479724884,
-0.5413318872451782,
-0.9094236493110657,
-1.0943464040756226,
-0.20952370762825012,
-0.3281981945037842,
0.037330396473407745,
0.190472811460495,
0.8012608289718628,
0.34993863105773926,
-0.576614499092102,
0.027411848306655884,
-0.07453139126300812,
0.14557993412017822,
0.13276775181293488,
-0.14563973248004913,
0.35301265120506287,
-0.3207152187824249,
-0.6904417276382446,
0.6069656014442444,
0.435119092464447,
0.023476483300328255,
-0.48000603914260864,
-0.12763774394989014,
-0.37512144446372986,
0.06977221369743347,
0.642367959022522,
-0.17899298667907715,
-0.7800607085227966,
-0.16625183820724487,
0.19679173827171326,
-0.35426464676856995,
0.1565721482038498,
0.3461950421333313,
-0.7962169051170349,
0.4777545630931854,
0.5251975655555725,
1.0681705474853516,
0.6323396563529968,
-0.2368798851966858,
0.4110882580280304,
-0.9030349850654602,
-0.10844729840755463,
0.34876319766044617,
0.4735998213291168,
0.5787015557289124,
-0.1148081049323082,
0.166417196393013,
0.07794570177793503,
-0.5123027563095093,
-0.7738347053527832,
-0.0028874827548861504,
-0.737882137298584,
-0.06501578539609909,
1.0827875137329102,
-0.197367325425148,
-0.28253182768821716,
-0.1871347874403,
0.025375621393322945,
0.28687936067581177,
-0.5728493928909302,
0.5245358943939209,
0.5833508968353271,
0.26162540912628174,
-0.39295563101768494,
-0.7356761693954468,
0.06331700086593628,
0.4983430802822113,
-0.49865108728408813,
-0.12032447010278702,
0.1258479803800583,
0.43540069460868835,
-0.08068932592868805,
0.3511693477630615,
-0.20207060873508453,
0.09312975406646729,
-0.05548892170190811,
0.08960428088903427,
-0.32691091299057007,
-0.19136790931224823,
-0.6000205278396606,
0.21573157608509064,
0.061036109924316406,
-0.35525408387184143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17423v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17423v1
|
Privacy-Aware Visual Language Models
| 2024-05-27T17:59:25 | 2024-05-27T17:59:25 |
Laurens Samson, Nimrod Barazani, Sennay Ghebreab, Yuki M. Asano
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
This paper aims to advance our understanding of how Visual Language Models
(VLMs) handle privacy-sensitive information, a crucial concern as these
technologies become integral to everyday life. To this end, we introduce a new
benchmark PrivBench, which contains images from 8 sensitive categories such as
passports, or fingerprints. We evaluate 10 state-of-the-art VLMs on this
benchmark and observe a generally limited understanding of privacy,
highlighting a significant area for model improvement. Based on this we
introduce PrivTune, a new instruction-tuning dataset aimed at equipping VLMs
with knowledge about visual privacy. By tuning two pretrained VLMs, TinyLLaVa
and MiniGPT-v2, on this small dataset, we achieve strong gains in their ability
to recognize sensitive content, outperforming even GPT4-V. At the same time, we
show that privacy-tuning only minimally affects the VLMs performance on
standard benchmarks such as VQA. Overall, this paper lays out a crucial
challenge for making VLMs effective in handling real-world data safely and
provides a simple recipe that takes the first step towards building
privacy-aware VLMs.
|
[
-0.26193147897720337,
-0.5497862100601196,
0.3316933214664459,
-0.011150159873068333,
-0.2936066687107086,
-0.2269783616065979,
-0.15410129725933075,
-0.5299803018569946,
-0.5734363198280334,
0.6731129288673401,
-0.577890157699585,
-0.775153636932373,
-0.3978824019432068,
-0.2782365381717682,
-0.2966478765010834,
0.702871561050415,
0.300636351108551,
-0.014706233516335487,
-0.025986697524785995,
-0.22192321717739105,
-0.35173335671424866,
-0.5287272930145264,
-0.05550815165042877,
0.48795396089553833,
0.5109463334083557,
0.5387904047966003,
0.7094686031341553,
1.1782666444778442,
0.6324021816253662,
0.29864269495010376,
-0.09531313925981522,
0.034716807305812836,
-0.6446107625961304,
0.07441940158605576,
-0.2528309226036072,
-0.3117753267288208,
-0.3314019739627838,
-0.1647578775882721,
0.6061877012252808,
0.30623069405555725,
0.04724486544728279,
0.5920432806015015,
-0.025248205289244652,
0.7175514698028564,
-1.0600436925888062,
0.24711336195468903,
-0.4318407475948334,
0.11710820347070694,
-0.4636765420436859,
0.11488325893878937,
-0.5349716544151306,
-0.4166003167629242,
0.1827913075685501,
-0.5581588745117188,
0.4060322642326355,
0.47027990221977234,
1.0345407724380493,
0.3696308732032776,
-0.21748469769954681,
0.4123523235321045,
-0.5287826657295227,
0.6500275135040283,
-0.3677234351634979,
0.8825993537902832,
0.49804994463920593,
0.3851746618747711,
0.20823198556900024,
-1.021375060081482,
-0.34780651330947876,
-0.10365504026412964,
0.009591125883162022,
-0.14198513329029083,
-0.2328111082315445,
0.07879480719566345,
0.6095114946365356,
0.3039723038673401,
-0.8864049315452576,
0.08613225817680359,
-0.3652738034725189,
-0.37926533818244934,
0.47076594829559326,
0.3607597053050995,
0.02081761509180069,
-0.02508259005844593,
-0.27303430438041687,
-0.24980027973651886,
-0.6758330464363098,
0.209008127450943,
0.373166561126709,
0.05253993347287178,
-0.33031243085861206,
0.5194331407546997,
-0.4315176010131836,
1.106880784034729,
-0.14659066498279572,
-0.011651518754661083,
0.21485167741775513,
-0.5293381214141846,
-0.47760018706321716,
-0.20191346108913422,
0.6199380159378052,
0.4980566203594208,
0.6066181659698486,
0.16418294608592987,
0.20582441985607147,
-0.18973851203918457,
0.27803972363471985,
-0.9511587619781494,
-0.6787024140357971,
-0.13030606508255005,
-0.5548039078712463,
-0.33969753980636597,
0.17019999027252197,
-0.7294095754623413,
-0.7238574028015137,
-0.4994780719280243,
0.26825183629989624,
-0.24338635802268982,
-0.11368829011917114,
0.03338732570409775,
0.05950155109167099,
0.5038482546806335,
0.3864707946777344,
-0.9046277403831482,
0.419086754322052,
0.7808533906936646,
0.5376570820808411,
-0.1156010851264,
-0.1869954615831375,
-0.6888696551322937,
0.18423348665237427,
-0.24139650166034698,
0.3644430637359619,
-0.6169372200965881,
-0.3737506568431854,
-0.05258956924080849,
0.2564763128757477,
0.13078761100769043,
-0.5681819915771484,
0.29117268323898315,
-0.3575800955295563,
-0.03524317592382431,
-0.5322051048278809,
-0.31259605288505554,
-0.06185968965291977,
0.07459316402673721,
-0.6946495175361633,
0.5850672125816345,
0.05261897295713425,
-0.819932758808136,
0.5011447072029114,
-0.36307772994041443,
-0.1835222989320755,
0.28579577803611755,
-0.2613934278488159,
-0.7918528318405151,
0.29440873861312866,
0.15096063911914825,
0.4726637899875641,
0.10798274725675583,
-0.18284806609153748,
-0.323750376701355,
-0.4718060791492462,
0.2289246767759323,
-0.39382386207580566,
0.8588894009590149,
0.2192089557647705,
-0.295938104391098,
0.3624081015586853,
-0.848182737827301,
0.3770022988319397,
0.026222892105579376,
-0.1253219097852707,
-0.38015517592430115,
-0.3632514774799347,
0.09158658981323242,
-0.038420163094997406,
0.4691167175769806,
-0.4272148013114929,
-0.04741259291768074,
-0.21179655194282532,
0.2801704406738281,
1.0437344312667847,
-0.10985783487558365,
0.45643332600593567,
0.25048545002937317,
0.4226909577846527,
-0.001597501919604838,
0.9971132278442383,
-0.0162966288626194,
-0.6556138396263123,
-0.7809817790985107,
-0.269879549741745,
0.492533415555954,
0.5434925556182861,
-0.4560410976409912,
0.12930965423583984,
-0.3592333495616913,
-0.2595718801021576,
-0.6369193196296692,
0.3018541634082794,
0.7395972609519958,
0.5702436566352844,
-0.0053437757305800915,
-0.4767417311668396,
-0.4430032968521118,
-1.099578619003296,
-0.5824922323226929,
0.006349111907184124,
0.27618861198425293,
0.6642799377441406,
0.2980616092681885,
0.18741972744464874,
0.7374892234802246,
-0.4002085328102112,
-0.2506338953971863,
0.16794081032276154,
-0.21212586760520935,
-0.3081234395503998,
0.5535951852798462,
0.3801337778568268,
-1.2378559112548828,
-0.7640256881713867,
-0.030603371560573578,
-0.709878146648407,
0.15249550342559814,
0.564209520816803,
-0.11680108308792114,
-0.017887532711029053,
0.5206302404403687,
-0.04280471056699753,
0.7337179183959961,
0.4634993076324463,
-0.48463913798332214,
0.13810855150222778,
-0.2719070315361023,
-0.17528380453586578,
-0.41536471247673035,
-0.20145589113235474,
-0.07268542051315308,
-0.7040439248085022,
-0.49663016200065613,
0.3295457363128662,
0.5354703664779663,
-0.38918569684028625,
-0.9822123646736145,
0.4845666289329529,
-0.7037699222564697,
-0.1693224459886551,
-0.039532121270895004,
-0.28968241810798645,
-0.1101672351360321,
0.4987117052078247,
0.12790042161941528,
0.8131536245346069,
0.9398604035377502,
-0.3854401707649231,
0.28523367643356323,
0.18089702725410461,
-0.39621514081954956,
0.420597642660141,
-0.39669522643089294,
0.20936116576194763,
-0.29819557070732117,
-0.4474022686481476,
-0.5508126616477966,
-0.34233883023262024,
0.4497567117214203,
-0.24024376273155212,
0.5279659628868103,
-0.3529888391494751,
-0.5658650994300842,
-0.24902541935443878,
-0.3579239845275879,
0.23734581470489502,
0.7902500033378601,
-0.4611404240131378,
0.5562366247177124,
0.4391863942146301,
-0.04045369476079941,
-0.6110302209854126,
-0.574885904788971,
0.047103166580200195,
-0.13800963759422302,
-0.554766833782196,
-0.0410710871219635,
-0.04205101728439331,
-0.21041755378246307,
0.17352838814258575,
-0.14790059626102448,
-0.32192254066467285,
0.236410453915596,
0.6042247414588928,
0.11117106676101685,
-0.21828873455524445,
-0.15056610107421875,
-0.34132900834083557,
-0.39209309220314026,
-0.1880238950252533,
-0.3312986493110657,
0.1711595207452774,
-0.8171757459640503,
-0.3437492251396179,
-0.47373929619789124,
0.2767062187194824,
0.1360984742641449,
-0.6782472133636475,
0.8400564193725586,
0.6890657544136047,
-0.20428749918937683,
-0.12986654043197632,
-0.51558917760849,
-0.04835930094122887,
-0.5610431432723999,
0.11890487372875214,
-0.4134519100189209,
-1.1326987743377686,
0.21807192265987396,
0.032700683921575546,
-0.11243194341659546,
-0.12796133756637573,
0.6073315739631653,
-0.08047173917293549,
0.8793373107910156,
1.2186206579208374,
0.18798567354679108,
0.8192657828330994,
-0.12262740731239319,
0.27288153767585754,
-0.6346316933631897,
-0.18999731540679932,
-0.3050850033760071,
-0.0581863671541214,
-0.9615543484687805,
-0.35014158487319946,
0.3826845586299896,
-0.17144900560379028,
-0.33069178462028503,
0.36703360080718994,
-0.7839521169662476,
0.9329948425292969,
0.7966741323471069,
0.24951685965061188,
0.24921225011348724,
-0.05291826277971268,
0.32731059193611145,
-0.3259599208831787,
-0.5610454082489014,
-0.44192683696746826,
1.2035784721374512,
0.12072554230690002,
0.9881985783576965,
0.1450510025024414,
0.5947120785713196,
0.04228809475898743,
0.2529352009296417,
-0.25557559728622437,
0.7114723920822144,
-0.4213096797466278,
-0.669384241104126,
-0.3619571030139923,
-0.26903706789016724,
-0.6797927021980286,
0.3270479142665863,
0.15871769189834595,
-1.0690010786056519,
0.5247101783752441,
0.39689645171165466,
-0.44398340582847595,
-0.08569692820310593,
-0.9471553564071655,
1.3289411067962646,
-0.3201259970664978,
-1.1244817972183228,
0.2459905594587326,
-1.0236579179763794,
0.5872378945350647,
0.14220356941223145,
0.1287875473499298,
-0.20493465662002563,
-0.21004550158977509,
0.3626721203327179,
-0.4071032702922821,
0.9057106971740723,
-0.3596053421497345,
0.13087376952171326,
0.09462273865938187,
0.019426969811320305,
0.3754187226295471,
0.09073542803525925,
0.24351218342781067,
0.2671647071838379,
-0.10293939709663391,
-0.29588478803634644,
-0.28788578510284424,
0.8664601445198059,
-0.4091799259185791,
-0.6501801013946533,
-0.3581080734729767,
-0.22920505702495575,
-0.22282008826732635,
0.3558219373226166,
0.42498859763145447,
0.17543162405490875,
-0.026951085776090622,
0.5409963130950928,
1.2643216848373413,
-0.3013491928577423,
0.2963249981403351,
0.9143112897872925,
-0.08944697678089142,
0.019237378612160683,
1.1079795360565186,
0.19015875458717346,
0.030409758910536766,
0.355899840593338,
0.199971541762352,
-0.35705673694610596,
-0.49480149149894714,
-0.4993588924407959,
0.005543980281800032,
-0.8214544057846069,
0.049548644572496414,
-0.5882211923599243,
-0.24233177304267883,
-0.46076175570487976,
0.20513249933719635,
-0.4712110459804535,
-0.14410360157489777,
-0.15089891850948334,
-0.13314135372638702,
0.475251168012619,
0.303827702999115,
-0.3050945997238159,
0.17712369561195374,
-0.5987802147865295,
0.626506507396698,
0.6311032176017761,
0.7428376078605652,
-0.45917919278144836,
-0.32842153310775757,
-0.23828093707561493,
-0.2746668756008148,
-0.02654186263680458,
-0.587838888168335,
0.07544136047363281,
0.10301544517278671,
0.4935991168022156,
0.21007727086544037,
-0.04126136377453804,
0.6306495666503906,
-0.620739221572876,
0.7593456506729126,
-0.2012384533882141,
-0.8821678161621094,
0.5812985301017761,
-0.2855229079723358,
0.0044319769367575645,
0.705998420715332,
-0.07601019740104675,
0.023194748908281326,
-0.14952784776687622,
-0.679673433303833,
-0.6806878447532654,
0.5243251323699951,
0.3253583312034607,
0.22283044457435608,
0.48822012543678284,
0.00014689634554088116,
0.04933254420757294,
0.5475411415100098,
-0.7821826338768005,
-0.2012401819229126,
-0.3693608045578003,
-0.1892397701740265,
0.16231174767017365,
-0.39698219299316406,
-0.0986243262887001,
-0.516064465045929,
0.3217164874076843,
0.051649369299411774,
-0.02005796507000923,
-0.1490105390548706,
-0.09552707523107529,
0.10748222470283508,
0.15724505484104156,
0.608864963054657,
0.628532350063324,
-0.18835464119911194,
0.10598523914813995,
-0.12641771137714386,
-0.6705725193023682,
0.007973764091730118,
0.10456394404172897,
-0.3787340819835663,
-0.09949792176485062,
0.07609111815690994,
0.9995917081832886,
0.10158610343933105,
-0.6675419211387634,
1.0468015670776367,
-0.5064374804496765,
0.04074165225028992,
-0.34074288606643677,
0.458810031414032,
-0.05766545608639717,
-0.004475526046007872,
-0.36196741461753845,
0.04888993501663208,
0.29048269987106323,
-0.26178306341171265,
0.24175480008125305,
0.28933820128440857,
-0.420010507106781,
-0.0426187664270401,
1.0836788415908813,
0.07693853974342346,
-0.43273448944091797,
0.4276370406150818,
-0.07094351947307587,
-0.11001303046941757,
0.4239371716976166,
0.019044989719986916,
0.9833164811134338,
-0.3258998990058899,
0.06281687319278717,
-0.007363287266343832,
0.6780570149421692,
0.04120645672082901,
0.6981079578399658,
-0.4951949119567871,
-0.4004385769367218,
-0.08388936519622803,
-0.5415052771568298,
-0.37826746702194214,
0.20582427084445953,
-0.8778975009918213,
0.02694176696240902,
-0.7985622882843018,
-0.05421319231390953,
-0.11793316155672073,
-0.33748024702072144,
-1.1787495613098145,
0.20252956449985504,
0.28975850343704224,
0.7080408334732056,
-0.6939781904220581,
0.8951563239097595,
0.4733525514602661,
-0.2548556625843048,
-0.7002928256988525,
-0.13346315920352936,
0.18021118640899658,
-0.8135173916816711,
0.5812748670578003,
0.15992340445518494,
-0.0628383532166481,
0.10869710147380829,
-0.7653427720069885,
-0.8059832453727722,
0.6181883811950684,
0.4923732876777649,
-1.0651893615722656,
0.16516077518463135,
0.12831807136535645,
0.5544509291648865,
0.12535540759563446,
-0.5412569046020508,
0.5703574419021606,
0.6550156474113464,
-0.44230881333351135,
-0.8443076014518738,
-0.09042491763830185,
-0.29676443338394165,
0.28918036818504333,
-0.010969859547913074,
-0.8370212316513062,
0.9526036977767944,
-0.14168024063110352,
-0.24644184112548828,
0.1083226278424263,
0.564639687538147,
0.08240421861410141,
0.2716199457645416,
0.20637424290180206,
0.5068425536155701,
0.7037183046340942,
-0.18606364727020264,
1.2824420928955078,
-0.3341849148273468,
0.009705403819680214,
1.3434754610061646,
-0.32601305842399597,
0.5741990208625793,
0.346135675907135,
0.09964678436517715,
0.12605126202106476,
0.3283514380455017,
-0.22368422150611877,
0.7676575183868408,
0.26679179072380066,
-0.17886707186698914,
-0.48655200004577637,
-0.1493474394083023,
-0.44138461351394653,
0.44788703322410583,
0.19562917947769165,
-0.5967698693275452,
-0.0823802649974823,
0.4079769253730774,
-0.28029853105545044,
0.1645210236310959,
-0.3312463164329529,
1.0458309650421143,
0.06688155978918076,
-0.09949168562889099,
0.46906647086143494,
0.03541634604334831,
0.1528995931148529,
-0.5015653967857361,
0.04943854734301567,
0.0004721685836557299,
0.3139752745628357,
-0.10094313323497772,
-0.812705934047699,
-0.0674901157617569,
0.3935610353946686,
-0.1316719949245453,
-0.4504483938217163,
0.9355574250221252,
-0.17111775279045105,
-0.5473251342773438,
-0.07458604872226715,
0.4994876980781555,
0.16935880482196808,
-0.12193984538316727,
-0.6496092081069946,
0.4646846354007721,
-0.005701215006411076,
-0.4181954264640808,
0.40091297030448914,
0.46325284242630005,
-0.24666985869407654,
0.5504707098007202,
0.531441867351532,
-0.07795634865760803,
0.5492702722549438,
0.24308542907238007,
0.834825873374939,
-0.6891516447067261,
-0.7634565234184265,
-0.8686227798461914,
0.6402837634086609,
-0.3542364239692688,
-0.32452601194381714,
1.0077215433120728,
0.7720966339111328,
1.0574220418930054,
-0.2503674030303955,
0.913300096988678,
0.2668335735797882,
0.47280940413475037,
-0.5747649669647217,
0.6987085938453674,
-0.39439016580581665,
0.08782579004764557,
-0.04025820270180702,
-0.6927497386932373,
-0.15703988075256348,
0.5953390598297119,
-0.2913644313812256,
-0.19275477528572083,
0.34673020243644714,
0.9904931783676147,
-0.21698115766048431,
0.06419552117586136,
0.5243721604347229,
0.21262870728969574,
0.1508142054080963,
0.5148933529853821,
0.7041829824447632,
-0.42209142446517944,
0.3956736624240875,
-0.7435287237167358,
-0.12213525921106339,
-0.19244979321956635,
-0.9710841774940491,
-0.8814659118652344,
-0.47951480746269226,
-0.3478332459926605,
0.014377586543560028,
0.3842729926109314,
0.09719815850257874,
1.0178114175796509,
-0.5948200225830078,
0.20505371689796448,
-0.203101247549057,
-0.01655963435769081,
-0.23714017868041992,
-0.15323565900325775,
0.34246039390563965,
0.30071860551834106,
-0.594185471534729,
0.25225555896759033,
0.51981121301651,
0.3796829879283905,
-0.2877724766731262,
0.11267206817865372,
0.5254672765731812,
-0.13601446151733398,
0.37713930010795593,
0.4321293234825134,
-0.661188542842865,
-0.3227350413799286,
-0.048719942569732666,
-0.2337232083082199,
0.06310497969388962,
0.8398398756980896,
-0.7433308959007263,
0.7323312759399414,
0.43606701493263245,
0.37330517172813416,
0.7294297218322754,
0.25493597984313965,
0.1515742391347885,
-0.927195131778717,
0.5376012921333313,
0.19692037999629974,
0.26119163632392883,
0.5111129283905029,
-0.43895846605300903,
0.4261460304260254,
0.08403053879737854,
-0.2727590501308441,
-1.0125797986984253,
0.3706815242767334,
-0.9820986390113831,
-0.13208194077014923,
0.8292256593704224,
-0.15571272373199463,
-0.7049446105957031,
-0.1276080161333084,
-0.24241913855075836,
-0.04751390963792801,
-0.19250601530075073,
0.4362372159957886,
0.37664276361465454,
0.10923737287521362,
-0.6550226211547852,
-0.6905192732810974,
0.7465795278549194,
0.12229170650243759,
-0.6099728345870972,
0.547523558139801,
0.5256016254425049,
0.4697669446468353,
-0.2827812433242798,
0.6853828430175781,
-0.2923564314842224,
0.5039107203483582,
0.06624716520309448,
-0.25630179047584534,
-0.6648874282836914,
-0.6518084406852722,
-0.33951690793037415,
0.25742045044898987,
-0.0703384280204773,
-0.5331565737724304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17537v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17537v1
|
BIOSCAN-CLIP: Bridging Vision and Genomics for Biodiversity Monitoring at Scale
| 2024-05-27T17:57:48 | 2024-05-27T17:57:48 |
ZeMing Gong, Austin T. Wang, Joakim Bruslund Haurum, Scott C. Lowe, Graham W. Taylor, Angel X. Chang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Measuring biodiversity is crucial for understanding ecosystem health. While
prior works have developed machine learning models for the taxonomic
classification of photographic images and DNA separately, in this work, we
introduce a multimodal approach combining both, using CLIP-style contrastive
learning to align images, DNA barcodes, and textual data in a unified embedding
space. This allows for accurate classification of both known and unknown insect
species without task-specific fine-tuning, leveraging contrastive learning for
the first time to fuse DNA and image data. Our method surpasses previous
single-modality approaches in accuracy by over 11% on zero-shot learning tasks,
showcasing its effectiveness in biodiversity studies.
|
[
-0.6332492828369141,
-0.3327181339263916,
0.16412822902202606,
-0.15366360545158386,
-0.6157698035240173,
0.481398344039917,
0.08145409822463989,
-0.544696033000946,
0.7517359852790833,
0.20751269161701202,
-0.5311809182167053,
-0.52484530210495,
-0.45678210258483887,
0.34848520159721375,
-0.11016135662794113,
0.6541825532913208,
0.25100332498550415,
0.1854095607995987,
-0.5421969890594482,
-0.7108910083770752,
-0.1480385810136795,
-0.3570444583892822,
-0.0768958181142807,
0.08805382996797562,
0.7283984422683716,
0.280935138463974,
0.6278789639472961,
0.7853871583938599,
0.7051733732223511,
0.3461594879627228,
-0.2505214512348175,
0.6202768087387085,
-0.0899873822927475,
-0.05081573873758316,
-0.4963303208351135,
-0.31251707673072815,
-0.06302458792924881,
-0.06167599558830261,
0.27068331837654114,
0.8710910677909851,
0.25394317507743835,
0.3067907392978668,
0.19227875769138336,
0.28652048110961914,
-0.6406974792480469,
0.08642957359552383,
-0.35726916790008545,
0.3309709131717682,
-0.23510392010211945,
-0.6218752264976501,
-0.07430855184793472,
-0.2951391041278839,
-0.1569214016199112,
-0.5804656744003296,
0.19252313673496246,
-0.1901751309633255,
0.8117544651031494,
0.5053974986076355,
-0.8827821016311646,
-0.07685402035713196,
-0.3052905201911926,
0.691887378692627,
-0.08377514779567719,
0.20686286687850952,
0.06129809841513634,
0.3191443383693695,
0.23601168394088745,
-0.47929495573043823,
-0.4170708954334259,
0.5327947735786438,
0.1766987442970276,
0.3747722804546356,
-0.3525106608867645,
-0.12188159674406052,
-0.09263309091329575,
0.48201984167099,
-0.36097535490989685,
0.010559123940765858,
-0.6021941304206848,
-0.38968560099601746,
0.2841327488422394,
0.10078725218772888,
0.2559710741043091,
-0.3176034390926361,
-0.41467028856277466,
-0.4420367479324341,
-0.22694192826747894,
0.22721153497695923,
-0.03316217660903931,
0.16520941257476807,
-0.05253973975777626,
0.5657637715339661,
0.21099619567394257,
0.4916320741176605,
0.11667987704277039,
-0.20784366130828857,
0.2520827651023865,
-0.807553231716156,
-0.08575614541769028,
-0.3181193172931671,
0.49889078736305237,
0.7501801252365112,
-0.26349493861198425,
0.10829464346170425,
0.3571033775806427,
0.12826906144618988,
0.19091303646564484,
-0.8740721940994263,
-0.30048102140426636,
0.11789390444755554,
-0.5147706866264343,
-0.5596323609352112,
0.33948010206222534,
-1.3387888669967651,
-0.24546895921230316,
-0.015612014569342136,
0.48423805832862854,
-0.5011857748031616,
0.120905302464962,
-0.029960254207253456,
-0.31046566367149353,
0.16898296773433685,
0.3277241289615631,
-0.5173528790473938,
-0.26775452494621277,
0.394187331199646,
1.1361515522003174,
0.10943380743265152,
-0.22083479166030884,
-0.2924310863018036,
0.32294246554374695,
-0.3155546188354492,
0.9581173062324524,
-0.4489057958126068,
-0.7192602157592773,
-0.2787458002567291,
0.39572569727897644,
0.05355387553572655,
-0.5489932894706726,
0.2835361659526825,
-0.15753982961177826,
-0.09174185991287231,
-0.23908068239688873,
-0.35167548060417175,
-0.7001510858535767,
0.27481719851493835,
-0.7684369683265686,
0.5018690824508667,
0.2802755832672119,
-0.6617515087127686,
0.6809959411621094,
-0.11522869020700455,
-0.3098360598087311,
0.25316599011421204,
-0.3276232182979584,
-0.7658979296684265,
-0.2307545393705368,
0.30248335003852844,
0.3213255703449249,
0.30253866314888,
0.022669343277812004,
-0.8966410756111145,
-0.05920221284031868,
0.17913594841957092,
0.09799487888813019,
0.9655764698982239,
0.11070557683706284,
-0.02114780619740486,
0.12996642291545868,
-0.6385391354560852,
-0.09945712238550186,
-0.12367093563079834,
-0.3869759142398834,
-0.26114097237586975,
-0.06132366508245468,
0.039782535284757614,
-0.00983436219394207,
-0.021221790462732315,
-0.7269129157066345,
0.43871375918388367,
-0.1122560054063797,
0.5134285092353821,
0.5956697463989258,
0.12595266103744507,
0.21178866922855377,
-0.4834420084953308,
0.31512415409088135,
0.0736682116985321,
0.24327117204666138,
-0.6128289699554443,
-0.48282843828201294,
-0.21309828758239746,
-0.9314742684364319,
0.5069788694381714,
0.6322154998779297,
-0.6655280590057373,
0.8550195693969727,
-0.38427624106407166,
-0.6084129810333252,
-0.24439628422260284,
0.20127153396606445,
0.12551726400852203,
0.37113696336746216,
0.520013153553009,
-1.0672446489334106,
-0.6516489386558533,
-0.4829622209072113,
0.26310402154922485,
0.15797796845436096,
-0.21132293343544006,
0.7602062225341797,
0.7369580864906311,
-0.7729809880256653,
0.8746983408927917,
-0.4824433922767639,
-0.34518852829933167,
0.15187598764896393,
0.5117900967597961,
0.10852392762899399,
0.6828605532646179,
0.9204941391944885,
-0.7865210771560669,
-0.10756928473711014,
0.18430529534816742,
-0.8352500796318054,
0.12395452708005905,
0.2891990542411804,
0.0453607439994812,
-0.0708591565489769,
0.28421637415885925,
-0.10964363813400269,
0.4834005534648895,
0.46740517020225525,
-0.2517268657684326,
-0.022036097943782806,
-0.03730860352516174,
0.42264607548713684,
-0.9624718427658081,
0.09267055243253708,
-0.09546518325805664,
-0.32262033224105835,
-0.29182538390159607,
0.1754283756017685,
0.28514695167541504,
-0.36251330375671387,
-0.1906684786081314,
0.026729291304945946,
-0.3070025146007538,
-0.19121624529361725,
-0.06379782408475876,
-0.5444324612617493,
0.31909796595573425,
0.3176724910736084,
-0.0143923070281744,
0.6250864267349243,
0.5317059755325317,
-0.3409554660320282,
0.5372095108032227,
0.6832755208015442,
-0.25248801708221436,
0.7608090043067932,
-0.3016161322593689,
-0.043177295476198196,
-0.13441477715969086,
0.35731032490730286,
-0.8143506646156311,
-0.5120009779930115,
-0.06989309936761856,
-0.6316710710525513,
0.4080303907394409,
-0.04879080876708031,
-0.0747818872332573,
-0.431998074054718,
-0.9010812044143677,
0.674953281879425,
0.43270066380500793,
-0.8292251229286194,
0.8633466958999634,
0.36637282371520996,
-0.10154687613248825,
-0.07015006989240646,
-0.876480221748352,
-0.08166511356830597,
-0.22355501353740692,
-0.4636670649051666,
0.2996940612792969,
0.23225028812885284,
0.03337053582072258,
0.062296416610479355,
-0.33878615498542786,
-0.2944796085357666,
0.11885110288858414,
0.4962612986564636,
0.3573552072048187,
-0.12690234184265137,
0.15451785922050476,
0.04122047871351242,
0.330877423286438,
-0.29104456305503845,
-0.28483107686042786,
0.18827557563781738,
0.12422677129507065,
-0.43577802181243896,
-0.10091160982847214,
0.42187410593032837,
0.5703299045562744,
-0.4318391978740692,
0.4216749966144562,
0.49592018127441406,
-0.19840683043003082,
0.06134764850139618,
-0.05173828452825546,
-0.13643863797187805,
-0.3840266466140747,
0.1298808455467224,
0.023039711639285088,
-0.6969688534736633,
0.29966816306114197,
-0.429821640253067,
-0.2404542714357376,
0.22224536538124084,
0.1492633819580078,
-0.6822535395622253,
0.5007204413414001,
0.9910020232200623,
-0.0381157211959362,
0.42756223678588867,
-0.38839927315711975,
-0.001468970556743443,
-0.7900238037109375,
-0.657085657119751,
-0.6642816066741943,
-0.225788876414299,
-0.3374960124492645,
-0.9456040859222412,
0.7002595067024231,
0.3019692301750183,
-0.2670823335647583,
0.20710213482379913,
-0.5292904376983643,
0.4723875820636749,
0.5569127202033997,
0.8759341239929199,
0.026733960956335068,
0.06298111379146576,
-0.29942095279693604,
0.15983815491199493,
-0.5779988169670105,
-0.19761095941066742,
1.2017369270324707,
-0.06523017585277557,
0.7456058859825134,
0.24081598222255707,
0.7306616902351379,
0.23487982153892517,
-0.04297610744833946,
-0.7842716574668884,
0.12742456793785095,
-0.4747682213783264,
-0.4051191210746765,
-0.12635500729084015,
-0.2697334885597229,
-1.0206568241119385,
0.16622985899448395,
-0.43203219771385193,
-0.38427191972732544,
1.0179319381713867,
0.27603834867477417,
-0.6718432307243347,
0.47083622217178345,
-0.38642749190330505,
0.7170261144638062,
-0.44659674167633057,
-0.43784424662590027,
-0.13770374655723572,
-0.8676345348358154,
0.3752381503582001,
-0.23129990696907043,
0.4757559895515442,
0.03441572189331055,
-0.3450891673564911,
0.5053813457489014,
-0.3830154538154602,
1.0005004405975342,
0.26781976222991943,
0.4803730249404907,
0.07850724458694458,
0.2027960866689682,
-0.14929881691932678,
-0.24206149578094482,
0.36513692140579224,
0.331208735704422,
0.3310779333114624,
-0.636079728603363,
-0.13608700037002563,
0.15419641137123108,
-0.44987940788269043,
-0.10988596081733704,
-0.5145812034606934,
-0.3458787202835083,
-0.1240120455622673,
0.08736591041088104,
0.11942559480667114,
0.5116000175476074,
-0.08518655598163605,
0.7314869165420532,
0.8681014776229858,
-0.4225951135158539,
0.39042267203330994,
0.2233988642692566,
-0.23595428466796875,
-0.8579916954040527,
1.0622888803482056,
-0.07403133809566498,
-0.024894889444112778,
0.5104790329933167,
0.20021586120128632,
-0.06035632640123367,
-0.09761201590299606,
-0.22199271619319916,
-0.11589931696653366,
-0.7288325428962708,
-0.6194600462913513,
-0.5574020743370056,
0.1546904593706131,
-0.5532620549201965,
-0.44237563014030457,
0.09015101939439774,
-0.056132588535547256,
-0.4553254544734955,
-0.14368543028831482,
0.4385066330432892,
0.4658643305301666,
-0.5254834294319153,
0.028033610433340073,
-0.9490295648574829,
0.4084106683731079,
0.7109048962593079,
0.04193458706140518,
-0.5057882070541382,
-0.10760597884654999,
0.030794955790042877,
-0.1564880609512329,
-0.5736678242683411,
-1.2583413124084473,
0.44206365942955017,
0.7751200199127197,
0.44123023748397827,
0.726436197757721,
-0.34432682394981384,
0.6800298094749451,
-0.07308750599622726,
0.8878944516181946,
0.3679962456226349,
-0.9976492524147034,
0.6422309279441833,
-0.15936309099197388,
0.25314861536026,
0.6563088893890381,
0.6752181053161621,
-0.2537379264831543,
-0.005139670800417662,
-0.28241756558418274,
-0.7517054080963135,
0.14511144161224365,
-0.3872031569480896,
-0.2728361487388611,
-0.010351549834012985,
-0.13220296800136566,
0.26900556683540344,
0.22617803514003754,
-0.4038059413433075,
0.030446218326687813,
-0.6653097867965698,
-0.35632041096687317,
-0.21198870241641998,
-0.08993291109800339,
-0.29560747742652893,
-0.8482942581176758,
0.1492210030555725,
-0.6033482551574707,
0.1823962926864624,
0.38787004351615906,
-0.21666646003723145,
-0.16817958652973175,
0.009124002419412136,
0.40509119629859924,
0.5142208337783813,
-0.3244830369949341,
0.47300446033477783,
-0.034416601061820984,
-0.4616403877735138,
-0.09257040172815323,
0.027278946712613106,
-0.1329791098833084,
-0.05498939007520676,
0.7112894058227539,
0.34329789876937866,
0.5154613852500916,
-0.6855281591415405,
0.6488015651702881,
0.5327672958374023,
-0.5517085194587708,
0.36118677258491516,
-0.24647431075572968,
-0.07000179588794708,
0.34903526306152344,
0.26238706707954407,
0.4548996388912201,
0.33317601680755615,
-0.8863945603370667,
0.5084493160247803,
0.6968280673027039,
-0.23402975499629974,
-0.24914883077144623,
0.6189183592796326,
0.44233280420303345,
0.30834081768989563,
0.3025357723236084,
-0.04746408760547638,
-0.9312102198600769,
1.012215495109558,
0.06634694337844849,
0.537136435508728,
-0.4360216557979584,
0.2628796696662903,
0.610572874546051,
0.24287928640842438,
0.5487909317016602,
0.41742515563964844,
-0.48868098855018616,
-0.6105771660804749,
-0.014326406642794609,
-0.7450353503227234,
-0.6618353128433228,
-0.35522058606147766,
-0.8826593160629272,
0.11502712965011597,
-0.4884522557258606,
0.04188848286867142,
0.3871966600418091,
-0.2341771274805069,
-0.4234314560890198,
0.12019895762205124,
0.15978465974330902,
1.0282196998596191,
-1.0962588787078857,
0.6728696227073669,
0.5436962246894836,
-0.7332824468612671,
-0.5097931623458862,
-0.32751867175102234,
0.25619614124298096,
-0.7793118357658386,
0.5156053304672241,
0.4238801598548889,
-0.28894874453544617,
-0.1757047325372696,
-0.8903482556343079,
-0.7374604940414429,
1.3063640594482422,
-0.08645506948232651,
-0.5767534971237183,
0.5808294415473938,
-0.29783228039741516,
0.25647133588790894,
-0.19174034893512726,
-0.02981962449848652,
0.06137770414352417,
0.3948807418346405,
0.3846514821052551,
-0.6052011251449585,
-0.3791872560977936,
-0.1735599786043167,
-0.03674100339412689,
0.2628784775733948,
-0.677973210811615,
0.9846594929695129,
-0.10752172023057938,
-0.5991461873054504,
0.011972090229392052,
0.4064929187297821,
-0.22345499694347382,
0.3724314570426941,
0.42739883065223694,
0.7484949827194214,
0.8501695990562439,
-0.23867246508598328,
0.5848141312599182,
-0.3872929811477661,
0.5143157243728638,
0.7654665112495422,
-0.2990542948246002,
0.6077045202255249,
0.6588330864906311,
-0.40711233019828796,
0.5328887701034546,
0.9995593428611755,
-0.8401710987091064,
0.6061975359916687,
0.04812650755047798,
-0.3515351414680481,
-0.3126826882362366,
-0.20180366933345795,
-0.44607269763946533,
0.43445563316345215,
0.310215026140213,
-0.20188936591148376,
-0.2998499572277069,
0.5499767661094666,
-0.41681233048439026,
0.16970597207546234,
-0.7489028573036194,
0.8242796659469604,
-0.23954592645168304,
-0.021900508552789688,
0.027257975190877914,
-0.3027684688568115,
1.0917357206344604,
-0.2765558958053589,
-0.30852988362312317,
-0.3299839198589325,
0.06577993929386139,
-0.4489341080188751,
-0.9434406161308289,
0.5104547142982483,
-0.24831318855285645,
-0.17016801238059998,
0.15344439446926117,
0.4131786823272705,
-0.33132514357566833,
-0.5005134344100952,
0.24473197758197784,
0.07358482480049133,
0.27439063787460327,
0.3937486708164215,
-0.26203805208206177,
-0.17059139907360077,
-0.019321128726005554,
0.27796101570129395,
-0.06941904127597809,
0.24971288442611694,
0.014556501992046833,
0.5227537751197815,
0.5287689566612244,
-0.14133575558662415,
0.20376844704151154,
-0.5159427523612976,
0.8448898792266846,
-0.7370646595954895,
-0.18096846342086792,
-0.6704174876213074,
0.18681608140468597,
-0.11681700497865677,
-0.05209584906697273,
0.7728744149208069,
0.8808711171150208,
0.9082972407341003,
-0.2172459065914154,
0.6005706787109375,
-0.050842106342315674,
0.5882021188735962,
-0.31058135628700256,
0.17281244695186615,
-0.6841545701026917,
-0.3585115671157837,
0.1644977629184723,
-0.23200194537639618,
-0.49509912729263306,
0.3537796139717102,
0.29490697383880615,
-0.16906411945819855,
0.8830053806304932,
0.6712207794189453,
-0.1084132045507431,
-0.3068252205848694,
0.18896755576133728,
-0.08359187096357346,
-0.13743704557418823,
0.6652853488922119,
0.5077266693115234,
0.015621157363057137,
0.5788626074790955,
-0.512580156326294,
-0.606594979763031,
-0.3124183416366577,
-0.8677210807800293,
-0.7695330381393433,
-0.42143845558166504,
-0.18242520093917847,
-0.06110411509871483,
-0.09295463562011719,
0.6541680693626404,
0.8892332911491394,
-0.852064847946167,
0.13932693004608154,
0.1962933987379074,
0.07553941756486893,
-0.3499317467212677,
-0.060791995376348495,
0.3332311511039734,
-0.0021172247361391783,
-0.5556063055992126,
0.24222584068775177,
0.704458475112915,
0.29715830087661743,
-0.09440905600786209,
0.2949422299861908,
-0.2689504325389862,
0.08544130623340607,
0.3005122244358063,
0.7417541742324829,
-0.6061794757843018,
-0.12159170210361481,
-0.16867993772029877,
-0.11106808483600616,
0.36595359444618225,
0.7167583107948303,
-0.6180489659309387,
0.7817429304122925,
0.3807999789714813,
0.8098942041397095,
0.4666000008583069,
0.16676616668701172,
0.08153076469898224,
-0.5873312950134277,
0.16089558601379395,
0.17324210703372955,
0.47171035408973694,
0.31783998012542725,
-0.42881789803504944,
0.5642146468162537,
0.6153736710548401,
-0.3981550931930542,
-0.6907527446746826,
0.32571375370025635,
-1.5267536640167236,
-0.5574517250061035,
0.4506472647190094,
-0.2585991621017456,
-0.6932873725891113,
-0.011927616782486439,
-0.18152670562267303,
0.09592127799987793,
0.1731855571269989,
0.510370671749115,
0.3258950710296631,
0.049801286309957504,
-0.3504943549633026,
0.17707298696041107,
0.177552729845047,
0.05245848745107651,
-1.0157713890075684,
-0.742737889289856,
0.597122848033905,
0.3255498707294464,
0.5262415409088135,
-0.07111379504203796,
-0.15021991729736328,
0.5235022902488708,
0.1922486275434494,
0.38059914112091064,
-0.22295893728733063,
-0.377204954624176,
-0.7548795342445374,
0.38945433497428894,
-0.32043585181236267,
-0.6022698283195496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00041v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00041v2
|
QUB-Cirdan at "Discharge Me!": Zero shot discharge letter generation by open-source LLM
| 2024-05-27T17:55:36 | 2024-06-27T14:31:22 |
Rui Guo, Greg Farnan, Niall McLaughlin, Barry Devereux
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The BioNLP ACL'24 Shared Task on Streamlining Discharge Documentation aims to
reduce the administrative burden on clinicians by automating the creation of
critical sections of patient discharge letters. This paper presents our
approach using the Llama3 8B quantized model to generate the "Brief Hospital
Course" and "Discharge Instructions" sections. We employ a zero-shot method
combined with Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) to produce concise,
contextually accurate summaries. Our contributions include the development of a
curated template-based approach to ensure reliability and consistency, as well
as the integration of RAG for word count prediction. We also describe several
unsuccessful experiments to provide insights into our pathway for the
competition. Our results demonstrate the effectiveness and efficiency of our
approach, achieving high scores across multiple evaluation metrics.
|
[
0.0029751150868833065,
-0.3593236207962036,
1.244138479232788,
-0.014213102869689465,
-0.3835521340370178,
0.266370564699173,
0.44473230838775635,
-0.11069737374782562,
0.2804446518421173,
0.7532770037651062,
-0.5190327167510986,
-0.9944424629211426,
-0.2701272666454315,
-0.0011324933730065823,
-0.6534011960029602,
1.0952218770980835,
-0.1774916797876358,
-0.15303969383239746,
-0.17614798247814178,
-0.23534013330936432,
-0.32366907596588135,
-0.3269946575164795,
-0.3416679799556732,
-0.5289439558982849,
0.8462740182876587,
0.57124924659729,
0.25286269187927246,
0.7037810683250427,
0.4737095236778259,
0.06429477781057358,
-0.0426827147603035,
-0.09781419485807419,
-0.5412917733192444,
0.2762603759765625,
0.15486042201519012,
-0.5378330945968628,
-0.7364010810852051,
-0.12349981814622879,
0.4771755337715149,
0.5494487285614014,
-0.4456256330013275,
0.46459558606147766,
-0.15846779942512512,
0.6960014700889587,
-1.112017035484314,
-0.308290958404541,
-0.2788372039794922,
0.14270469546318054,
-0.18525344133377075,
-0.4370534420013428,
-0.4732693135738373,
-0.45148152112960815,
-0.14785036444664001,
-0.44161638617515564,
0.5739222764968872,
-0.07640307396650314,
0.5829444527626038,
-0.1916889101266861,
-0.3628835082054138,
-0.3894176185131073,
-0.7751152515411377,
0.48670780658721924,
-0.8044562935829163,
-0.03901706263422966,
0.17417362332344055,
0.270690381526947,
0.1123594343662262,
-0.8910824656486511,
-0.10403145849704742,
-0.062302786856889725,
-0.10391420125961304,
0.547703742980957,
-0.11222730576992035,
0.46345868706703186,
0.3135146200656891,
0.6742888689041138,
-0.80886310338974,
-0.055550467222929,
-0.6602275967597961,
0.1252862960100174,
0.632851779460907,
0.6797890067100525,
0.11991406232118607,
-0.24457089602947235,
-0.24323321878910065,
0.23142218589782715,
-0.8552964329719543,
0.010097550228238106,
0.057700954377651215,
-0.2720851004123688,
-0.5283784866333008,
0.7624061107635498,
-0.5911384224891663,
0.25972065329551697,
0.15599492192268372,
0.023069163784384727,
0.08852645009756088,
-0.08903168886899948,
-0.3012842535972595,
0.3703840672969818,
1.0054394006729126,
0.3700006306171417,
-0.3888654112815857,
-0.21358923614025116,
-0.21662257611751556,
-0.1198752298951149,
0.4534468948841095,
-0.9358239769935608,
-0.33109891414642334,
0.7176650762557983,
-0.4601203501224518,
-0.5157864093780518,
-0.2318899929523468,
-0.4736761450767517,
-0.2505253553390503,
-0.20403766632080078,
0.2723759114742279,
-0.7034125924110413,
0.2806313931941986,
-0.11253003031015396,
-0.03022262081503868,
-0.02243092656135559,
0.34894314408302307,
-0.5422507524490356,
-0.0036321599036455154,
0.6323472857475281,
0.9159570336341858,
-0.013777167536318302,
0.22503405809402466,
-0.7361658215522766,
0.5141406059265137,
-0.3401516377925873,
0.8695067763328552,
0.023823238909244537,
-0.6269432902336121,
0.3193233013153076,
-0.493038535118103,
0.42760545015335083,
-0.37934011220932007,
0.5662343502044678,
-0.13632647693157196,
0.18077996373176575,
-0.021113339811563492,
-0.5473425984382629,
0.08338278532028198,
0.08989328891038895,
-0.43785008788108826,
0.5084178447723389,
0.6686086058616638,
-0.6321729421615601,
0.14551787078380585,
-0.614615261554718,
-0.06747019290924072,
0.5807905197143555,
-0.2897975444793701,
-0.30990102887153625,
0.3979145288467407,
-0.041394609957933426,
0.5480867624282837,
-0.3630364239215851,
0.15960060060024261,
-0.19086705148220062,
-0.48152634501457214,
-0.07120025157928467,
0.009962599724531174,
0.9269492030143738,
0.4122895300388336,
0.0558750182390213,
0.08307243883609772,
-1.0374819040298462,
0.025304198265075684,
-0.06531096249818802,
-0.36995798349380493,
-0.12662452459335327,
-0.2103264182806015,
-0.2908788323402405,
0.012958400882780552,
0.10465455800294876,
-0.47202545404434204,
0.1873295158147812,
-0.5235964059829712,
-0.10283263027667999,
0.534027099609375,
0.5717009902000427,
0.732151985168457,
-0.645980179309845,
1.0382885932922363,
0.1612907350063324,
0.39162376523017883,
-0.6682096719741821,
-0.2822651267051697,
-0.6212804913520813,
-0.42895612120628357,
0.10341402888298035,
0.4062992334365845,
-0.8278655409812927,
0.16582024097442627,
0.026230189949274063,
-0.6798995137214661,
-0.5771054029464722,
-0.11007003486156464,
0.7011218667030334,
0.781289279460907,
0.5053210854530334,
-0.39085856080055237,
-0.32186031341552734,
-0.6033799052238464,
0.11415468156337738,
-0.28324249386787415,
-0.19620086252689362,
-0.07086241990327835,
0.009288400411605835,
-0.22489342093467712,
0.6980922818183899,
-0.7447732090950012,
-0.21049365401268005,
-0.3498555123806,
0.7702176570892334,
0.3451031744480133,
0.1381615400314331,
0.3938572108745575,
0.03817606344819069,
-0.34125033020973206,
-0.26694828271865845,
-0.9284242391586304,
-0.5727712512016296,
-0.225738063454628,
-0.30213937163352966,
-0.022238317877054214,
0.2578103244304657,
-0.40870001912117004,
0.5933500528335571,
0.2626810371875763,
-0.30428215861320496,
0.8356120586395264,
-0.2698966860771179,
0.12195805460214615,
-1.1251312494277954,
0.15963496267795563,
-0.008241540752351284,
-0.22146694362163544,
-0.777150571346283,
0.31440219283103943,
0.2999702990055084,
-0.17147400975227356,
-0.6811684966087341,
0.5561056137084961,
-0.5035407543182373,
0.2717708647251129,
-0.15682244300842285,
-0.10237834602594376,
0.27283817529678345,
0.23826643824577332,
-0.4852915108203888,
0.4561270773410797,
0.14519864320755005,
-0.6714601516723633,
0.18650901317596436,
0.3390602171421051,
0.004913015756756067,
0.7234299778938293,
-0.5360792279243469,
-0.19685988128185272,
-0.344899445772171,
0.24969565868377686,
-0.6162553429603577,
-0.2546286880970001,
0.3274584412574768,
-0.20657671988010406,
0.3204776644706726,
0.12652865052223206,
-0.273527055978775,
-0.3167310953140259,
-0.6126121878623962,
0.36996394395828247,
0.745141863822937,
0.02761675976216793,
0.3310541808605194,
-0.044823817908763885,
-0.061353012919425964,
-0.3078175187110901,
-0.44163545966148376,
0.014353819191455841,
0.006387063767760992,
-0.14676813781261444,
0.4545345604419708,
-0.2060277760028839,
-0.15762434899806976,
-0.1560358703136444,
-0.05796242877840996,
-0.02233734540641308,
0.0025332968216389418,
0.4964369535446167,
0.22284963726997375,
-0.3310556709766388,
-0.23158787190914154,
0.33470970392227173,
0.11161228269338608,
0.20866850018501282,
0.062401097267866135,
0.5859203934669495,
0.3192005455493927,
-0.48240506649017334,
-0.48678645491600037,
0.6572744250297546,
0.28691479563713074,
-0.03855646774172783,
0.4552449882030487,
0.5554195642471313,
-0.08590863645076752,
-0.1334972232580185,
-0.4886167347431183,
-0.05334972217679024,
-0.42613962292671204,
-0.27023845911026,
-0.01499719824641943,
-0.7499371767044067,
0.41323602199554443,
-0.13021963834762573,
0.34482541680336,
0.30852487683296204,
0.5568927526473999,
-0.5088961720466614,
0.5273925065994263,
0.6507670283317566,
0.4570575952529907,
0.25735998153686523,
-0.5867847800254822,
0.23773138225078583,
-1.0566933155059814,
-0.2699836492538452,
-0.3098883330821991,
-0.17588366568088531,
-0.34579700231552124,
-0.4356237053871155,
0.7491855025291443,
0.41142338514328003,
-0.15399165451526642,
0.27461957931518555,
-0.5948516130447388,
0.06384981423616409,
0.5427943468093872,
0.15740680694580078,
0.2244030088186264,
-0.08132879436016083,
-0.32235151529312134,
0.21345286071300507,
-0.6279609203338623,
-0.4477865397930145,
1.0132086277008057,
0.1465430110692978,
0.5496599078178406,
-0.037742730230093,
1.5757858753204346,
0.39612939953804016,
0.4634069502353668,
-0.48892343044281006,
0.5420059561729431,
-0.29287463426589966,
-0.13120339810848236,
0.07565927505493164,
-0.14955617487430573,
-0.8462273478507996,
-0.24807368218898773,
-0.29606765508651733,
-0.6766992807388306,
0.2196728140115738,
0.25242453813552856,
-0.6673599481582642,
-0.0737660825252533,
-0.48327839374542236,
0.47517675161361694,
-0.09038384258747101,
-0.23549041152000427,
0.018980447202920914,
-0.57915198802948,
0.9171083569526672,
-0.22804202139377594,
0.13258089125156403,
-0.28347131609916687,
-0.056437909603118896,
0.3164270222187042,
-0.6088018417358398,
0.3811532258987427,
0.18332278728485107,
-0.13470715284347534,
0.5944839119911194,
0.28107717633247375,
-0.048231519758701324,
0.07628298550844193,
-0.009998724795877934,
0.26377663016319275,
0.11534510552883148,
-0.2865886688232422,
-0.29969480633735657,
0.4014839828014374,
-0.4404199421405792,
-0.32005980610847473,
-0.3735421299934387,
-0.4819808006286621,
0.09651526808738708,
0.1548081785440445,
0.5690497756004333,
0.7009316086769104,
-0.20584946870803833,
0.04465644806623459,
0.5969890356063843,
-0.6424960494041443,
0.5161035656929016,
0.7134326100349426,
-0.3855828642845154,
-0.5958765745162964,
0.7043304443359375,
0.2285643219947815,
0.22731640934944153,
0.6980940699577332,
0.12877248227596283,
-0.22084982693195343,
-0.4903210997581482,
-0.48855262994766235,
0.38729536533355713,
-0.6024748682975769,
-0.6210271120071411,
-0.7844817042350769,
-0.5986125469207764,
-0.5442965030670166,
-0.5418248772621155,
0.14954537153244019,
-0.46784308552742004,
-0.68207848072052,
-0.06036602705717087,
0.07463840395212173,
0.846616804599762,
-0.08621065318584442,
0.8194169402122498,
-1.0614765882492065,
0.7249866127967834,
-0.16210001707077026,
0.17077907919883728,
-0.13630327582359314,
-0.434872567653656,
-0.43816787004470825,
-0.10396254062652588,
-0.9447683691978455,
-1.1681437492370605,
0.4889976382255554,
-0.026409747079014778,
0.3134417235851288,
0.5702629685401917,
0.20169946551322937,
0.5950400829315186,
-0.5951173901557922,
1.0020806789398193,
0.8172340989112854,
-0.7870360612869263,
0.7590668797492981,
-0.7478170394897461,
0.7423517107963562,
0.3728907108306885,
0.43370795249938965,
-0.4036436975002289,
-0.9359535574913025,
-0.9560540318489075,
-1.2359743118286133,
0.6681153774261475,
0.16461308300495148,
-0.1237136572599411,
-0.26653623580932617,
0.5152004957199097,
-0.14897768199443817,
0.2307683229446411,
-0.08393152803182602,
-0.3497268855571747,
0.13578352332115173,
-0.4769539535045624,
0.3183180093765259,
-0.8108233213424683,
-0.20201894640922546,
0.2714402377605438,
0.5543491840362549,
-0.056100618094205856,
0.33988821506500244,
0.22935165464878082,
0.11429031193256378,
-0.12376358360052109,
0.436178982257843,
0.7353765368461609,
0.9585133790969849,
-0.37608134746551514,
-0.07297725230455399,
-0.10337607562541962,
-0.5507636666297913,
0.34991779923439026,
-0.31811001896858215,
-0.5560447573661804,
0.48999202251434326,
0.3819129765033722,
0.4346865117549896,
0.08710108697414398,
-0.4579821527004242,
0.5451782941818237,
-0.11470281332731247,
-0.5692217946052551,
-0.2938731908798218,
0.23196567595005035,
0.06888794153928757,
0.027709217742085457,
0.35446664690971375,
-0.3850197196006775,
0.5555887222290039,
-0.4634615182876587,
0.42315277457237244,
0.14422105252742767,
-0.4206138849258423,
-0.09648331999778748,
0.7392887473106384,
0.050089601427316666,
-0.221415176987648,
0.22510994970798492,
-0.24875740706920624,
0.13050615787506104,
0.5351177453994751,
0.4826657176017761,
1.1632516384124756,
-0.21691131591796875,
0.5231388807296753,
0.6252709627151489,
-0.15388073027133942,
-0.020856834948062897,
0.5431016683578491,
-0.027547569945454597,
0.021078187972307205,
-0.49474674463272095,
-1.123307704925537,
-0.4954773187637329,
0.08615034073591232,
-0.8736017942428589,
0.4453423321247101,
-0.8776267766952515,
0.022218752652406693,
-0.3089900612831116,
-0.3649246096611023,
-0.4890701472759247,
0.39993104338645935,
0.3422936499118805,
0.6989012360572815,
-0.5854671001434326,
0.4103742837905884,
0.5330817103385925,
-0.7949599623680115,
-1.0212762355804443,
0.02710612863302231,
-0.0531095452606678,
-0.6449822783470154,
0.3179989159107208,
-0.05577191337943077,
0.02293592318892479,
-0.19168764352798462,
-0.3980725109577179,
-0.3516940772533417,
1.5118614435195923,
0.14469578862190247,
-0.6435168385505676,
-0.2152082324028015,
0.20267648994922638,
0.7132399678230286,
-0.19498467445373535,
0.739402174949646,
0.30863192677497864,
-0.2166803628206253,
0.1950926035642624,
-0.40165624022483826,
0.0028102295473217964,
0.05489671602845192,
0.21483969688415527,
0.18386605381965637,
-0.6331532001495361,
0.8301979899406433,
-0.11764845252037048,
-0.4264339208602905,
0.19881406426429749,
0.8478721976280212,
0.5232385396957397,
0.6403342485427856,
-0.15114250779151917,
0.675109326839447,
0.4723717272281647,
0.14180302619934082,
1.0058315992355347,
-0.515433669090271,
0.04652290791273117,
1.2364994287490845,
-0.27161353826522827,
0.6313815116882324,
0.291166216135025,
-0.05036293342709541,
0.7027101516723633,
0.22344593703746796,
0.18683406710624695,
0.39331427216529846,
0.28071698546409607,
-0.8128218054771423,
0.2281346172094345,
-0.48841866850852966,
-0.23562981188297272,
0.32511934638023376,
0.18262852728366852,
-0.5465191602706909,
-0.39538338780403137,
-0.410762220621109,
-0.007432013284415007,
-0.024086490273475647,
-0.48090919852256775,
1.0557409524917603,
0.5082605481147766,
-0.5999348163604736,
0.6583686470985413,
0.08555232733488083,
0.20662084221839905,
-0.48258256912231445,
-0.328264981508255,
-0.5881828665733337,
-0.18051202595233917,
-0.4581705927848816,
-0.8089550733566284,
0.3352217972278595,
0.29968664050102234,
-0.3294547200202942,
-0.5311680436134338,
0.5134968161582947,
-0.17209267616271973,
-0.43481266498565674,
-0.10366765409708023,
0.6017178893089294,
0.2070678174495697,
0.15400296449661255,
-0.5979059338569641,
-0.20593661069869995,
-0.0790766030550003,
0.15101183950901031,
0.374616414308548,
0.6923747062683105,
-0.03828788176178932,
0.4286816418170929,
0.5003005266189575,
0.4279513955116272,
0.2097911387681961,
0.357176810503006,
0.694510281085968,
-0.509942889213562,
-0.3527633547782898,
-0.874509871006012,
0.8717182278633118,
0.02145962230861187,
-0.15436159074306488,
0.24362197518348694,
0.8271896839141846,
0.4195755124092102,
-0.2273556888103485,
0.6896937489509583,
-0.015502302907407284,
0.7675111889839172,
-0.5039654970169067,
0.8687594532966614,
-0.5286521315574646,
0.2043275088071823,
-0.10085450857877731,
-0.7183052897453308,
-0.27261972427368164,
0.06711246818304062,
0.17777034640312195,
-0.3960832953453064,
0.9972001910209656,
0.5414380431175232,
0.04359699413180351,
-0.5008116364479065,
0.586327075958252,
-0.015262235887348652,
0.4410589635372162,
0.6154588460922241,
0.6368402242660522,
-0.5498108267784119,
0.49858859181404114,
-0.5834786295890808,
-0.08634614199399948,
-0.33993884921073914,
-0.8613386750221252,
-0.6095497012138367,
-0.245698481798172,
-0.4217301607131958,
-0.4592392146587372,
0.10396865755319595,
0.5568414330482483,
0.25217491388320923,
-0.6997889876365662,
-0.3312798738479614,
-0.07067430019378662,
-0.186919167637825,
0.21115466952323914,
-0.23462919890880585,
-0.033231060951948166,
-0.28470030426979065,
-0.12252520769834518,
0.1614384949207306,
0.6997159719467163,
-0.11628580093383789,
-0.19690082967281342,
0.11042840778827667,
-0.08653927594423294,
-0.006367117632180452,
0.5630782246589661,
0.1456746906042099,
-0.6072602868080139,
0.14439688622951508,
-0.08738761395215988,
-0.5180603265762329,
0.08591590076684952,
0.8104391098022461,
-0.7244688868522644,
0.2552526891231537,
0.6867266893386841,
0.2675362229347229,
0.34552666544914246,
0.39526423811912537,
0.5503346920013428,
-0.9039430022239685,
-0.197097048163414,
0.46894386410713196,
0.27516892552375793,
0.18546518683433533,
-0.5728945136070251,
0.5759116411209106,
0.057907894253730774,
-0.6419019103050232,
-0.5983698964118958,
0.19142374396324158,
-1.1219068765640259,
0.02181934379041195,
1.0695537328720093,
-0.22904540598392487,
-0.3989254832267761,
-0.04957302659749985,
-0.2705119550228119,
0.5434455275535583,
-0.5269362926483154,
0.7498895525932312,
0.1774238497018814,
-0.36950185894966125,
-0.49326446652412415,
-0.6357972025871277,
0.36124923825263977,
0.1534656435251236,
-0.8115922808647156,
-0.15791280567646027,
0.8028582334518433,
0.13189435005187988,
0.16108359396457672,
1.25006902217865,
-0.027245232835412025,
0.5218519568443298,
-0.2050611674785614,
0.3702283799648285,
0.08491690456867218,
-0.16662979125976562,
-0.3652814030647278,
0.3463442027568817,
-0.021805264055728912,
-0.05226680636405945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17402v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17402v1
|
THREAD: Thinking Deeper with Recursive Spawning
| 2024-05-27T17:51:24 | 2024-05-27T17:51:24 |
Philip Schroeder, Nathaniel Morgan, Hongyin Luo, James Glass
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive capabilities across
diverse settings, but still struggle as the length and complexity of the
context increases. To address this challenge, we propose Thinking Recursively
and Dynamically (ThReaD). THREAD frames model generation as a thread of
execution that, based on the context, can run to completion or dynamically
spawn new threads. By spawning, threads can offload work (e.g., thinking,
retrieving information) to child threads, which only return tokens needed for
the parent thread to do its work. In effect, this enables the model to adapt,
as needed, the amount of intermediate work used to produce tokens. We apply
THREAD in the settings of LLM task solving and question answering, where the
dynamic threading allows the model to recursively decompose the given task or
question into progressively simpler sub-problems that can be solved by separate
child threads. We test THREAD, implemented using a few-shot learning approach,
on diverse benchmarks for agent tasks and data-grounded question answering.
THREAD achieves state-of-the-art performance with GPT-4 and GPT-3.5 on these
benchmarks, including ALFWorld, TextCraft, and WebShop, along with two new
benchmarks, DataCommons QA and MIMIC-III ICU QA. In addition, THREAD
outperforms existing frameworks by 10% to 50% absolute points with smaller
models, including Llama-3-8b and CodeLlama-7b.
|
[
-0.4027254581451416,
-0.9984720349311829,
0.7037898898124695,
-0.03568267449736595,
-0.13567908108234406,
0.7052305340766907,
-0.15628959238529205,
-0.5605148077011108,
-0.16053864359855652,
0.30564868450164795,
-0.9698582291603088,
-0.14536693692207336,
-0.38342565298080444,
0.003531552152708173,
-0.4260155260562897,
0.9366577863693237,
-0.30732861161231995,
-0.22522515058517456,
-0.296406090259552,
0.02887924201786518,
-0.4576147794723511,
-0.3748388886451721,
-0.9230200052261353,
-0.5651648640632629,
0.577346920967102,
0.32755300402641296,
0.48015567660331726,
0.7279321551322937,
0.517212450504303,
0.3723379969596863,
-0.13582074642181396,
0.39312440156936646,
-0.6262703537940979,
0.6788254976272583,
-0.1777796447277069,
-0.5898473262786865,
-0.321958988904953,
0.014238988049328327,
0.7145493030548096,
0.697375476360321,
-0.3564930558204651,
0.40815162658691406,
0.05978305637836456,
0.644887387752533,
-0.37319302558898926,
0.2469272017478943,
-0.7681677341461182,
0.2586442530155182,
-0.13549663126468658,
-0.15380756556987762,
-0.15322697162628174,
-0.24391697347164154,
0.3255084753036499,
-0.32786959409713745,
0.16811946034431458,
0.07800966501235962,
0.5373090505599976,
0.2697086036205292,
-0.22710782289505005,
-0.32980144023895264,
-0.730657160282135,
0.7482004761695862,
-0.6788311004638672,
0.23423796892166138,
-0.07473628968000412,
0.3419754207134247,
-0.1751650720834732,
-0.9095582962036133,
-0.5695934295654297,
0.08150198310613632,
0.29949474334716797,
-0.00799945555627346,
0.0900077074766159,
-0.11974150687456131,
0.48678648471832275,
0.6190847158432007,
-0.3723592758178711,
-0.17323929071426392,
-0.1938536912202835,
0.277432382106781,
0.3451065719127655,
0.6043646931648254,
0.22372999787330627,
0.13649500906467438,
-0.14812178909778595,
0.20348438620567322,
-0.7635833621025085,
0.028106210753321648,
0.09083136171102524,
0.3721472918987274,
-0.15973781049251556,
0.3946855366230011,
-0.0928601399064064,
0.3821786642074585,
0.3076559007167816,
-0.07492008805274963,
0.18414729833602905,
-0.34121987223625183,
-0.24929159879684448,
-0.4671715795993805,
0.4148983061313629,
0.17241409420967102,
0.2042917162179947,
-0.10899738222360611,
-0.30664950609207153,
-0.04165089130401611,
0.46754685044288635,
-0.8250329494476318,
-0.11564352363348007,
0.18580321967601776,
-0.35540688037872314,
-0.4993269741535187,
-0.21648088097572327,
-0.5643563270568848,
-0.40999719500541687,
-0.2911728024482727,
0.06387435644865036,
-0.21158358454704285,
-0.5481250882148743,
-0.019811227917671204,
0.14130288362503052,
0.43502163887023926,
0.3726489245891571,
-0.7396178245544434,
0.35806846618652344,
0.9260827898979187,
0.7566766142845154,
-0.3864535391330719,
-0.33134424686431885,
-0.38277682662010193,
0.14703352749347687,
-0.5864850282669067,
0.7205222845077515,
-0.6918309926986694,
-0.18096202611923218,
0.08862727880477905,
0.11983034759759903,
-0.2305806279182434,
-0.7410010695457458,
-0.09736741334199905,
-0.6446177363395691,
0.27480897307395935,
-0.3933138847351074,
-0.759144127368927,
-0.3688926696777344,
0.5510751008987427,
-0.5976364612579346,
1.0748777389526367,
0.17179246246814728,
-0.8083850145339966,
0.1593756377696991,
-0.7399274706840515,
-0.29527711868286133,
0.09039512276649475,
-0.23413726687431335,
-0.16582746803760529,
0.33346185088157654,
0.0983930379152298,
0.370033323764801,
-0.3952943682670593,
0.20811475813388824,
-0.28689292073249817,
-0.33888667821884155,
0.3523922860622406,
-0.2539580166339874,
0.4434692859649658,
0.1847389042377472,
-0.6422598958015442,
0.0706859678030014,
-0.3615719676017761,
0.055824778974056244,
0.3219558298587799,
-0.40546634793281555,
0.3958212435245514,
0.2719089686870575,
-0.3594539165496826,
0.17933565378189087,
0.1313646137714386,
-0.3932522237300873,
0.23200002312660217,
-0.5663344264030457,
0.7766400575637817,
0.7559466361999512,
0.09607978910207748,
0.25344976782798767,
-0.5773210525512695,
0.8348172903060913,
0.24230597913265228,
0.008870838209986687,
-0.5108199119567871,
-0.3821522295475006,
-1.0095112323760986,
0.013516428880393505,
-0.13626700639724731,
0.5749048590660095,
-1.0547857284545898,
-0.3058701455593109,
-0.012281578034162521,
-0.3169745206832886,
-0.38032883405685425,
0.22876018285751343,
0.5678594708442688,
0.37455806136131287,
0.010434766300022602,
-0.34976261854171753,
-0.5671864748001099,
-0.5946452617645264,
0.0004610237665474415,
-0.2881861627101898,
0.27712976932525635,
0.4651223421096802,
0.5301902294158936,
-0.35693806409835815,
0.6775533556938171,
-0.6725627183914185,
0.12113144993782043,
-0.4245578348636627,
0.1473211944103241,
0.5423071980476379,
0.4504404067993164,
0.3423822820186615,
-0.41754379868507385,
-0.3947979211807251,
-0.027216395363211632,
-0.9062109589576721,
0.17397308349609375,
0.12735867500305176,
-0.16337639093399048,
0.3649596571922302,
0.4364902377128601,
-0.8347001075744629,
-0.007690966594964266,
0.4256587028503418,
-0.0404595285654068,
0.41267403960227966,
0.055400412529706955,
-0.03793284296989441,
-1.3280092477798462,
0.038972292095422745,
-0.42353615164756775,
-0.5215533971786499,
-0.4346800446510315,
0.5943846702575684,
-0.2699710428714752,
-0.3616444170475006,
-0.6329434514045715,
0.4618784785270691,
-0.5956595540046692,
-0.23779815435409546,
-0.5043454766273499,
-0.1254807859659195,
-0.0010416940785944462,
0.44364115595817566,
-0.055423490703105927,
0.9857702851295471,
0.6042267084121704,
-0.2592383623123169,
0.6233620047569275,
-0.0781015157699585,
-0.699032723903656,
0.05511034280061722,
-0.5548518896102905,
0.6494636535644531,
-0.09203241020441055,
0.30025818943977356,
-0.801855206489563,
-0.13769729435443878,
0.13939429819583893,
-0.20588277280330658,
0.35244882106781006,
-0.05149010196328163,
-0.5564215779304504,
-0.710417628288269,
-0.29793113470077515,
0.7866848111152649,
0.383761465549469,
-0.34291717410087585,
0.3523143529891968,
0.5797412991523743,
-0.4300423562526703,
-0.49842706322669983,
-0.6038565039634705,
-0.13354317843914032,
-0.09287942945957184,
-0.39044439792633057,
0.13025623559951782,
-0.29711979627609253,
-0.16676339507102966,
0.08206034451723099,
0.041526567190885544,
-0.18217721581459045,
0.2079923152923584,
0.15009790658950806,
0.16266906261444092,
-0.5347177386283875,
0.1847909539937973,
-0.07486938685178757,
-0.14180228114128113,
0.08290907740592957,
-0.2696467638015747,
0.7772020101547241,
-0.43774011731147766,
-0.43020033836364746,
-0.24229149520397186,
0.5389586687088013,
0.7186190485954285,
-0.27418577671051025,
0.497889906167984,
0.3536284863948822,
-0.45667439699172974,
-0.40953415632247925,
-0.6099647879600525,
-0.22805675864219666,
-0.5106766819953918,
0.39853131771087646,
-0.36966025829315186,
-1.3944344520568848,
0.6520406603813171,
-0.12213604152202606,
0.36814481019973755,
-0.002108735265210271,
0.7893241047859192,
-0.4347367584705353,
0.9827900528907776,
0.7411725521087646,
-0.13001883029937744,
0.4734771251678467,
-0.47411343455314636,
0.378549724817276,
-0.959219217300415,
0.04839863255620003,
0.15685130655765533,
-0.5050735473632812,
-0.4599231779575348,
-0.9676363468170166,
0.2238401174545288,
0.126579150557518,
-0.4272159934043884,
0.10691986232995987,
-0.45238351821899414,
0.6546940803527832,
0.46720126271247864,
0.05514353886246681,
0.13487699627876282,
-0.2562345266342163,
-0.1554873138666153,
0.17516498267650604,
-0.5770547986030579,
-0.4189262092113495,
1.0297061204910278,
0.38607022166252136,
0.6858406662940979,
-0.028175054118037224,
0.5738393068313599,
0.05184868350625038,
0.36099785566329956,
-0.6026634573936462,
0.5625301599502563,
0.05758092924952507,
-0.8744637370109558,
-0.14991740882396698,
-0.2658829987049103,
-0.8600826263427734,
0.10321555286645889,
-0.09888537228107452,
-0.5454587340354919,
-0.12951557338237762,
0.11560189723968506,
-0.7261755466461182,
0.588150143623352,
-0.3649425208568573,
0.5724248886108398,
-0.006874958984553814,
-0.38731488585472107,
-0.4789159297943115,
-0.148763507604599,
0.4549615979194641,
-0.11080612987279892,
0.04699833318591118,
-0.38141655921936035,
-0.038474831730127335,
0.3899102210998535,
-0.13679179549217224,
1.021673560142517,
-0.026347210630774498,
-0.09632079303264618,
0.7457435131072998,
0.2112198770046234,
0.454786479473114,
0.07741601020097733,
-0.06605970859527588,
-0.09880582243204117,
0.02318538911640644,
-0.19361452758312225,
-0.5597019195556641,
0.6948521733283997,
-0.6114649176597595,
-0.8990875482559204,
-0.2995174825191498,
-0.8091840147972107,
-0.20978721976280212,
0.11289495974779129,
-0.12727771699428558,
0.5354617834091187,
0.02752942591905594,
0.14972618222236633,
0.571937620639801,
-0.2390357404947281,
0.6575278639793396,
0.6126226186752319,
-0.6197251677513123,
-0.3712112307548523,
0.711340069770813,
0.1700604259967804,
0.05831627920269966,
0.19933311641216278,
0.0058898343704640865,
-0.09371457248926163,
-0.5252104997634888,
-0.3883329927921295,
0.2934923470020294,
-0.4795156717300415,
-0.365150511264801,
-0.5461199283599854,
-0.6083675622940063,
-0.17905132472515106,
-0.0766298845410347,
-0.5939719676971436,
-0.1603447049856186,
-0.04419366270303726,
-0.3276972770690918,
0.20596803724765778,
0.9672626256942749,
0.14519476890563965,
0.1140948161482811,
-0.6701715588569641,
0.12055706232786179,
0.6872865557670593,
0.45472586154937744,
0.4347400963306427,
-0.3119955360889435,
-0.38221392035484314,
-0.021821998059749603,
-0.7131124138832092,
-0.4724229574203491,
0.2530083656311035,
0.07281612604856491,
0.46197518706321716,
0.35631850361824036,
-0.08090195059776306,
0.7406533360481262,
-0.9149968028068542,
0.7877445220947266,
-0.022941870614886284,
-0.9084095358848572,
0.5150156617164612,
-0.5598421096801758,
0.507046103477478,
0.4590018391609192,
0.16914014518260956,
-0.4775879979133606,
-0.5991576910018921,
-0.3903365731239319,
-0.763644814491272,
0.5821194648742676,
0.20080716907978058,
0.3823435306549072,
-0.3296932876110077,
0.6458584070205688,
0.23220397531986237,
0.48554283380508423,
-0.6276673078536987,
-0.07632815837860107,
0.30638691782951355,
-0.006418958771973848,
0.06714089959859848,
-0.49454265832901,
-0.09689202159643173,
-0.41106387972831726,
0.4207806885242462,
-0.30262959003448486,
0.6054075956344604,
-0.13169027864933014,
0.02300337888300419,
-0.39484140276908875,
-0.03147374838590622,
0.6267647743225098,
1.0899691581726074,
0.029921047389507294,
0.2807425260543823,
0.37515291571617126,
-0.10566234588623047,
0.1170392632484436,
-0.2609179615974426,
-0.11588187515735626,
-0.30372270941734314,
0.5440274477005005,
0.9077693223953247,
0.4929535388946533,
-0.8020967841148376,
0.2651060223579407,
-0.025721484795212746,
-0.08948692679405212,
-0.3483707308769226,
0.21315880119800568,
0.4883239269256592,
0.7986360192298889,
0.18635410070419312,
-0.3164338171482086,
-0.13056257367134094,
-0.8857468962669373,
0.3476414978504181,
0.36307963728904724,
-0.31419315934181213,
-0.4394014775753021,
0.4460752010345459,
0.4119887948036194,
-0.333135187625885,
0.744036078453064,
-0.048093248158693314,
-0.7537230253219604,
0.6476179361343384,
0.6044436097145081,
1.1663846969604492,
-0.08453702181577682,
0.20010732114315033,
0.36659789085388184,
0.13415436446666718,
-0.059447549283504486,
0.6205831170082092,
-0.1387055218219757,
-0.942840576171875,
-0.6600639224052429,
-0.659001350402832,
-0.627482533454895,
0.08850537985563278,
-0.49582037329673767,
-0.14284531772136688,
-0.5451575517654419,
-0.2853040397167206,
-0.24400198459625244,
0.27719846367836,
-0.471260130405426,
-0.054174818098545074,
0.4241155982017517,
0.7716478705406189,
-0.44751766324043274,
1.0050445795059204,
0.7423823475837708,
-0.14956174790859222,
-0.6917305588722229,
0.012245427817106247,
0.0695730671286583,
-0.9065614938735962,
0.5250740647315979,
0.44048601388931274,
-0.10664857178926468,
0.13896389305591583,
-0.43673622608184814,
-1.2406020164489746,
1.181868553161621,
0.4296764135360718,
-0.6562435030937195,
-0.1698070466518402,
0.05929328501224518,
0.4367925524711609,
-0.6161242723464966,
0.13597652316093445,
0.4170133173465729,
0.08775158226490021,
0.062431346625089645,
-0.7219100594520569,
0.020598361268639565,
-0.3650408685207367,
0.017977112904191017,
0.1639714241027832,
-0.7042297720909119,
1.0055187940597534,
-0.27466222643852234,
-0.4441255033016205,
0.18293654918670654,
0.5744078159332275,
0.41582444310188293,
0.26644930243492126,
0.5322004556655884,
0.6198847889900208,
0.8871442079544067,
-0.0326911136507988,
0.978149950504303,
-0.5860077142715454,
0.34951239824295044,
1.239111065864563,
-0.4531167447566986,
0.9600490927696228,
0.3425276577472687,
-0.19553963840007782,
0.7740369439125061,
0.6833838224411011,
0.27332988381385803,
0.36750179529190063,
0.259725958108902,
-0.26988279819488525,
-0.37719646096229553,
-0.012868575751781464,
-0.3992859423160553,
0.3013797700405121,
0.18766018748283386,
-0.27189353108406067,
-0.20200315117835999,
-0.0037598158232867718,
-0.08712004125118256,
-0.018234649673104286,
-0.15732239186763763,
0.9496629238128662,
0.3683434724807739,
-0.7740938663482666,
0.4808233976364136,
-0.20031757652759552,
0.4969870150089264,
-0.346761018037796,
0.08738169074058533,
-0.4726858139038086,
0.33602893352508545,
0.15597134828567505,
-0.975833535194397,
0.5756298899650574,
0.2652437388896942,
-0.6037516593933105,
-0.4333289861679077,
0.4224429428577423,
-0.394711971282959,
-0.6343598365783691,
0.2707427144050598,
0.6846127510070801,
0.07498247921466827,
0.0345027819275856,
-0.8782314658164978,
0.2727104127407074,
-0.1722753345966339,
-0.45504939556121826,
0.3055422306060791,
0.5884944796562195,
0.033284902572631836,
0.9981905221939087,
0.5406650304794312,
-0.07381229102611542,
0.19020140171051025,
0.010485731065273285,
1.0754151344299316,
-0.8632853031158447,
-0.23780259490013123,
-0.9303442239761353,
0.31768691539764404,
-0.026879994198679924,
-0.1958918571472168,
0.3136376440525055,
0.5894513130187988,
0.75055992603302,
0.0977807492017746,
0.42038747668266296,
0.10757226496934891,
0.7324073910713196,
-0.28680381178855896,
0.8134673833847046,
-0.414237916469574,
0.1500338762998581,
-0.17579306662082672,
-0.9940797090530396,
-0.0015513390535488725,
0.49422118067741394,
-0.15563111007213593,
-0.007442309986799955,
0.8504129648208618,
0.6121380925178528,
0.17630180716514587,
0.04337960481643677,
0.271459698677063,
0.25414082407951355,
0.48784488439559937,
0.9209727048873901,
1.2434687614440918,
-0.2095339447259903,
0.2691369950771332,
-0.3068719804286957,
-0.05284963920712471,
0.21907395124435425,
-0.8820609450340271,
-0.971238911151886,
-0.459841787815094,
-0.43772074580192566,
-0.0195599477738142,
0.04769861698150635,
0.9085632562637329,
0.8798816800117493,
-0.7910950779914856,
-0.4443919360637665,
-0.2081318348646164,
0.24110636115074158,
-0.2726559340953827,
-0.2535567879676819,
-0.017845261842012405,
-0.7367050647735596,
-0.7686235308647156,
0.4410354495048523,
0.4704717695713043,
-0.196642205119133,
-0.4479934573173523,
0.05492397025227547,
-0.21169400215148926,
0.3400736451148987,
0.8049381375312805,
0.14013265073299408,
-0.7490679621696472,
-0.3807404637336731,
-0.12435349822044373,
-0.15230919420719147,
-0.11516781151294708,
0.8877736926078796,
-0.8444740772247314,
0.3521597385406494,
0.5059490203857422,
0.9955312609672546,
0.5950083136558533,
-0.159658282995224,
0.8550914525985718,
-0.4209390878677368,
0.1346186399459839,
0.3098245859146118,
0.24165910482406616,
0.2515931725502014,
-0.1338142305612564,
0.6114875674247742,
0.3070457875728607,
-0.4877294600009918,
-1.0379724502563477,
0.373508483171463,
-0.586225688457489,
-0.37160220742225647,
0.7870889902114868,
-0.289943128824234,
-0.3431442081928253,
0.06875041872262955,
-0.048811253160238266,
0.18461468815803528,
-0.11143989115953445,
0.8875017166137695,
0.6925400495529175,
-0.15916617214679718,
-0.5802838802337646,
-0.5519625544548035,
0.38996925950050354,
0.2925456166267395,
-0.7968319058418274,
0.2015949934720993,
0.17963449656963348,
0.3302463889122009,
-0.05000569298863411,
0.799453854560852,
-0.06525523215532303,
0.12607888877391815,
-0.24059990048408508,
-0.0827946662902832,
-0.04391368478536606,
-0.2723144292831421,
0.12591587007045746,
0.3185240924358368,
0.11875295639038086,
-0.17048725485801697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17394v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17394v2
|
The Expressive Capacity of State Space Models: A Formal Language Perspective
| 2024-05-27T17:46:57 | 2024-06-02T19:43:55 |
Yash Sarrof, Yana Veitsman, Michael Hahn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.FL, cs.LG
|
Recently, recurrent models based on linear state space models (SSMs) have
shown promising performance in language modeling (LM), competititve with
transformers. However, there is little understanding of the in-principle
abilities of such models, which could provide useful guidance to the search for
better LM architectures. We present a comprehensive theoretical study of the
capacity of such SSMs as it compares to that of transformers and traditional
RNNs. We find that SSMs and transformers have overlapping but distinct
strengths. In star-free state tracking, SSMs implement straightforward and
exact solutions to problems that transformers struggle to represent exactly.
They can also model bounded hierarchical structure with optimal memory even
without simulating a stack. On the other hand, we identify a design choice in
current SSMs that limits their expressive power. We discuss implications for
SSM and LM research, and verify results empirically on a recent SSM, Mamba.
|
[
-0.20521411299705505,
-0.45271432399749756,
0.8906946182250977,
0.1302655041217804,
0.0719464048743248,
0.2474137842655182,
-0.37897932529449463,
-0.6107079386711121,
0.22038115561008453,
0.4591488540172577,
-0.42129355669021606,
-0.00905933603644371,
-0.5618032813072205,
-0.03322618454694748,
-0.7143882513046265,
0.701707124710083,
-0.35947656631469727,
-0.17702719569206238,
-0.25222745537757874,
-0.2913777530193329,
-0.490727037191391,
-0.5319004058837891,
-0.04142965003848076,
-0.29548999667167664,
0.40101832151412964,
0.1615428477525711,
0.9079446792602539,
0.47245287895202637,
0.5292942523956299,
0.40329790115356445,
-0.20054295659065247,
-0.14694856107234955,
-0.4821256101131439,
0.310979962348938,
-0.1667448729276657,
-0.5114932060241699,
-0.36218100786209106,
0.02367008477449417,
1.0994848012924194,
0.7755427360534668,
-0.25401732325553894,
0.14943276345729828,
-0.010303957387804985,
0.6883938312530518,
-0.5111142992973328,
0.37487465143203735,
-0.6524960994720459,
-0.12078020721673965,
-0.19131052494049072,
0.00043714381172321737,
-0.46755146980285645,
-0.40481582283973694,
0.3173537850379944,
-0.6373162269592285,
0.03082980215549469,
-0.05622531473636627,
1.0368285179138184,
0.28243836760520935,
-0.2482677847146988,
-0.13257713615894318,
-1.4046019315719604,
0.9854243397712708,
-0.5785326957702637,
0.4909641444683075,
0.05517788976430893,
0.5105283856391907,
-0.2284926474094391,
-0.6831634640693665,
-0.5266404747962952,
-0.3382501006126404,
-0.16222240030765533,
-0.15557269752025604,
-0.57410728931427,
0.14349311590194702,
0.4905940294265747,
0.692898154258728,
-0.2670488953590393,
0.06355473399162292,
-0.4530941843986511,
-0.134162038564682,
0.38881683349609375,
0.4344802498817444,
0.26457422971725464,
-0.1853475421667099,
-0.5944579839706421,
0.38606536388397217,
-0.5885682702064514,
0.17909768223762512,
-0.11634022742509842,
0.4632091522216797,
0.02380635216832161,
0.7101880311965942,
0.0591566227376461,
0.9106209874153137,
-0.1351931095123291,
0.15867653489112854,
-0.35176658630371094,
-0.3230009377002716,
-0.22399573028087616,
-0.5534803867340088,
0.7105865478515625,
-0.15565147995948792,
0.25697633624076843,
-0.39855146408081055,
-0.3308110237121582,
0.47962686419487,
0.6006031632423401,
-0.5225228667259216,
0.3352437913417816,
0.10595112293958664,
-0.4612051546573639,
-0.041724953800439835,
0.08128948509693146,
-0.4114498794078827,
-0.32295235991477966,
-0.4579605460166931,
0.43602651357650757,
-0.4775596261024475,
-0.6583328247070312,
0.12032762169837952,
0.013540337793529034,
0.2585752606391907,
-0.03485661745071411,
-0.9716350436210632,
0.7779338955879211,
0.7553998231887817,
0.8037710189819336,
-0.1093357503414154,
0.030649302527308464,
0.07625971734523773,
-0.23003868758678436,
-0.5514415502548218,
0.36487480998039246,
-0.6060276627540588,
-0.19960910081863403,
0.0159025676548481,
-0.14283376932144165,
-0.24483661353588104,
-0.30434808135032654,
0.3229771554470062,
-0.49947959184646606,
0.050214771181344986,
-0.20773622393608093,
-0.8693562746047974,
-0.15518157184123993,
-0.41798558831214905,
-0.9800682663917542,
0.8797765970230103,
0.5315492153167725,
-0.15332160890102386,
0.2887989580631256,
-0.5318013429641724,
-0.20015282928943634,
0.2602689266204834,
-0.4605894684791565,
-0.11695381253957748,
0.5389869809150696,
-0.4204151928424835,
0.45735135674476624,
-0.19800594449043274,
0.43589046597480774,
-0.13900963962078094,
-0.38280946016311646,
0.4934213161468506,
0.011424739845097065,
0.19560320675373077,
0.6614305377006531,
-0.13837763667106628,
0.2724054455757141,
-0.7237703204154968,
0.034179866313934326,
0.08274266868829727,
-0.3645041882991791,
-0.31616970896720886,
0.4792538583278656,
-0.028343565762043,
0.3807639181613922,
0.2065669596195221,
-0.6264718174934387,
0.06202999874949455,
-0.497012197971344,
0.6775520443916321,
0.500941276550293,
-0.4568057060241699,
0.8174089193344116,
-0.34821075201034546,
0.8933826684951782,
-0.27844107151031494,
-0.11128844320774078,
-0.13439276814460754,
-0.12022314220666885,
-0.7967192530632019,
-0.2767835557460785,
0.23952756822109222,
0.38606756925582886,
-0.5373499393463135,
0.5133350491523743,
-0.3591792583465576,
-0.3668997883796692,
-0.6923931241035461,
-0.09439438581466675,
0.3172220289707184,
0.10781905800104141,
0.2024531066417694,
-0.12916165590286255,
-0.654796302318573,
-1.2330973148345947,
-0.32563066482543945,
-0.01978611759841442,
0.11642374098300934,
0.35880276560783386,
0.3325726091861725,
0.30513671040534973,
1.1525027751922607,
-0.04110606387257576,
-0.05817420780658722,
-0.7572381496429443,
-0.49560123682022095,
0.31115075945854187,
0.2345069795846939,
0.5755751132965088,
-0.4446454644203186,
-0.19902820885181427,
-0.14211389422416687,
-0.7778454422950745,
0.06447859108448029,
-0.2922859787940979,
0.1822894960641861,
0.33351412415504456,
0.2556328773498535,
-0.9631388783454895,
0.4799860119819641,
0.7135091423988342,
-0.32151737809181213,
0.1478005349636078,
0.13521410524845123,
-0.17500165104866028,
-0.9972270131111145,
0.20990291237831116,
0.20072413980960846,
-0.3380117118358612,
-1.0785269737243652,
0.48717331886291504,
0.19823940098285675,
-0.4100242257118225,
-0.4412391781806946,
0.5597299337387085,
-0.5723312497138977,
-0.35328203439712524,
-0.56175297498703,
0.4847226142883301,
-0.44652214646339417,
0.5349030494689941,
0.2208905667066574,
0.35459330677986145,
0.4768521189689636,
-0.7023166418075562,
-0.015371952205896378,
-0.24266375601291656,
-0.8548827171325684,
0.25411540269851685,
-0.5394569635391235,
-0.17665958404541016,
-0.0998748317360878,
0.3982142508029938,
-1.1528379917144775,
0.010014286264777184,
-0.002375537296757102,
-0.15943218767642975,
0.41355377435684204,
-0.061276547610759735,
-0.27674755454063416,
-0.35860517621040344,
0.2864281237125397,
0.27812978625297546,
0.6334692239761353,
-0.24038955569267273,
0.901340126991272,
0.4747082591056824,
-0.056580688804388046,
-0.42798495292663574,
-0.5518171787261963,
-0.09659381955862045,
-0.08478821814060211,
-0.5638285875320435,
0.2668899893760681,
0.3461589515209198,
-0.36049941182136536,
0.15552805364131927,
-0.36920973658561707,
0.28479331731796265,
0.34998348355293274,
0.3800041377544403,
0.4928453862667084,
-0.3318193852901459,
0.16621869802474976,
-0.22651124000549316,
-0.3143466114997864,
-0.11903760582208633,
-0.1731683313846588,
0.5818991661071777,
-0.6884255409240723,
-0.13417942821979523,
-0.6958370804786682,
0.36706703901290894,
0.6128599047660828,
0.026668932288885117,
0.8376826643943787,
-0.018773812800645828,
-0.5985535383224487,
-0.1211746409535408,
-0.18966417014598846,
-0.04874442517757416,
-0.46131667494773865,
0.34636399149894714,
-0.39696356654167175,
-1.1407601833343506,
0.48465725779533386,
0.1252584010362625,
0.4528576731681824,
0.6451303362846375,
0.5070582032203674,
-0.09777366369962692,
0.8523215651512146,
0.7548801898956299,
-0.18757712841033936,
0.49068307876586914,
-0.14780032634735107,
0.14581894874572754,
-0.8931085467338562,
-0.1026044562458992,
-0.5678603649139404,
-0.694202721118927,
-0.7349444627761841,
-0.39049598574638367,
-0.13020917773246765,
0.09224489331245422,
-0.11591122299432755,
0.7582830786705017,
-0.43779456615448,
0.38163062930107117,
0.09626014530658722,
-0.2880842685699463,
0.08259809762239456,
0.00823559332638979,
-0.1414165049791336,
-0.24996118247509003,
-0.9129080772399902,
-0.663992702960968,
0.6134572625160217,
0.8347182869911194,
1.1398950815200806,
0.3256867825984955,
0.1920643448829651,
-0.1705288589000702,
0.26995953917503357,
-0.9928147792816162,
0.717925488948822,
-0.26130130887031555,
-0.7714126706123352,
-0.3627191185951233,
-0.468180775642395,
-0.9056045413017273,
0.2862915098667145,
-0.21155677735805511,
-0.8376368880271912,
0.15816478431224823,
0.16817253828048706,
-0.3099882900714874,
0.5579105615615845,
-0.4018348157405853,
0.38397008180618286,
-0.13052329421043396,
0.0022982973605394363,
-0.4448535740375519,
-0.43076351284980774,
0.31489676237106323,
0.2466636598110199,
0.0658581554889679,
-0.21349865198135376,
-0.0759468674659729,
0.45633092522621155,
-0.3190542459487915,
0.87610924243927,
-0.21902453899383545,
-0.14362773299217224,
0.35543760657310486,
0.3816945254802704,
0.35968226194381714,
-0.5822216868400574,
-0.012884755618870258,
0.23105600476264954,
-0.09312155842781067,
-0.3265046775341034,
-0.6186513304710388,
0.7154250741004944,
-0.4973146319389343,
-0.615297794342041,
-0.48832663893699646,
-0.6603721380233765,
-0.18733727931976318,
0.16586966812610626,
0.06772708147764206,
0.40624144673347473,
-0.33010682463645935,
0.47769874334335327,
0.39888182282447815,
-0.12706686556339264,
0.4337109625339508,
0.6099227666854858,
-0.7356640696525574,
0.1625063270330429,
0.718251645565033,
0.17670448124408722,
0.6755276918411255,
0.48993855714797974,
0.12836982309818268,
-0.47357192635536194,
-0.19621717929840088,
-0.41034039855003357,
0.2095082402229309,
-0.5340684056282043,
0.1615147739648819,
-0.3510691225528717,
-0.5379296541213989,
0.06372811645269394,
0.11484987288713455,
-0.47638627886772156,
-1.171260952949524,
-0.021188192069530487,
-0.09203609079122543,
0.2923238277435303,
0.9728017449378967,
0.2546687424182892,
0.12051226198673248,
-0.4124439060688019,
0.22666287422180176,
-0.0415826216340065,
0.7849180698394775,
0.22358468174934387,
-0.6277773976325989,
-0.32091259956359863,
-0.16618485748767853,
-0.2382224053144455,
-0.648604154586792,
0.06426365673542023,
0.0663105696439743,
0.7426016330718994,
0.2232772409915924,
-0.4107070565223694,
0.6678442358970642,
-0.4892318844795227,
0.9086548089981079,
0.1259886473417282,
-0.9495391249656677,
0.3516945540904999,
-0.26522305607795715,
0.3192060887813568,
0.039290718734264374,
0.4944995939731598,
-0.6896531581878662,
-0.9061312675476074,
-0.6312965154647827,
-0.5525403618812561,
0.6085023880004883,
0.2982480525970459,
0.15208712220191956,
0.15029872953891754,
0.4638783931732178,
-0.05272458866238594,
0.12845192849636078,
-0.587234377861023,
-0.32544007897377014,
-0.22618959844112396,
-0.19303423166275024,
-0.16276192665100098,
-0.13189692795276642,
0.06646004319190979,
-0.03125578165054321,
0.42362430691719055,
0.2671763002872467,
0.478155255317688,
0.06134187802672386,
-0.06500736624002457,
-0.3264239728450775,
0.5846050381660461,
0.826242208480835,
0.7208670973777771,
0.0793636366724968,
-0.03705630451440811,
0.02158963866531849,
-0.013944772072136402,
0.2430955171585083,
-0.09017811715602875,
-0.3691766858100891,
0.11714340001344681,
0.1479535549879074,
1.1556495428085327,
0.604637622833252,
-0.3357563018798828,
0.127417653799057,
0.08613193035125732,
-0.192903533577919,
-0.3875153362751007,
0.3420059084892273,
0.2353750467300415,
0.12028481066226959,
0.2387259602546692,
0.3002912402153015,
-0.3147534132003784,
-0.5426100492477417,
0.051944855600595474,
0.6322999000549316,
-0.6678376793861389,
-0.36315128207206726,
0.6591424345970154,
-0.049298692494630814,
-0.5474555492401123,
0.5175309181213379,
0.3615650534629822,
-0.260495126247406,
0.46001771092414856,
0.6473731398582458,
0.866885244846344,
-0.28756991028785706,
-0.020194850862026215,
0.3142462372779846,
0.26750287413597107,
-0.1041993722319603,
0.4457297623157501,
-0.0639510229229927,
-0.9409307837486267,
-0.5448586344718933,
-0.6858566999435425,
-0.3181789517402649,
0.3723374903202057,
-0.8536414504051208,
-0.014797292649745941,
-0.639690637588501,
-0.4907936453819275,
0.10150282829999924,
-0.13479633629322052,
-0.5196341872215271,
-0.2568041682243347,
0.14706969261169434,
1.141369104385376,
-0.5187904834747314,
0.7512381076812744,
0.38874298334121704,
-0.23804086446762085,
-0.9609898328781128,
-0.44912898540496826,
0.11582312732934952,
-0.6082492470741272,
0.3823509216308594,
-0.0639834776520729,
-0.3323712944984436,
-0.2504352927207947,
-0.36694008111953735,
-1.0282378196716309,
0.8963663578033447,
0.1972810924053192,
-0.8917083144187927,
0.029496824368834496,
0.09419286251068115,
0.854098379611969,
-0.4565223753452301,
-0.18021602928638458,
0.5911425948143005,
0.2076205313205719,
-0.2038709968328476,
-0.934853196144104,
0.11912253499031067,
-0.19642366468906403,
0.33420976996421814,
0.7110025882720947,
-0.7123762965202332,
0.6419947147369385,
-0.191227525472641,
-0.7769261598587036,
0.8771215081214905,
0.875368058681488,
0.40041568875312805,
-0.1328325867652893,
0.5492227673530579,
0.4296960234642029,
0.47288978099823,
-0.33502164483070374,
1.3091752529144287,
-0.40294283628463745,
0.2864606976509094,
0.928899884223938,
-0.49620094895362854,
0.9079281091690063,
0.4414326846599579,
-0.2247915267944336,
0.8123019933700562,
0.17381486296653748,
0.008013199083507061,
0.10052765160799026,
0.46605876088142395,
-0.2530270516872406,
-0.30374425649642944,
0.07190411537885666,
-0.1549272984266281,
0.3174859285354614,
0.588824450969696,
-0.5201063752174377,
-0.14362210035324097,
-0.23491470515727997,
-0.18606631457805634,
0.33969178795814514,
-0.28149208426475525,
0.5145867466926575,
0.33947083353996277,
-0.8208805322647095,
0.36452382802963257,
-0.02813413180410862,
0.22773690521717072,
-0.7866066694259644,
0.13242404162883759,
-0.02716314233839512,
0.17805452644824982,
-0.19836057722568512,
-0.9360116124153137,
0.3409956693649292,
0.11925352364778519,
-0.246597558259964,
-0.4009322226047516,
0.8494928479194641,
-0.45807749032974243,
-0.3616068959236145,
0.2378406524658203,
0.37899985909461975,
0.253683865070343,
0.4676862359046936,
-0.4005764126777649,
0.03174661472439766,
-0.3967263698577881,
-0.1324092298746109,
0.24208731949329376,
0.05167904868721962,
-0.22999988496303558,
0.9147050380706787,
0.3665182888507843,
0.5400237441062927,
0.03761308640241623,
0.12706737220287323,
0.444874107837677,
-0.8875711560249329,
-0.46618223190307617,
-0.7344762682914734,
0.3613210618495941,
0.22498850524425507,
-0.08274189382791519,
0.5548151731491089,
0.5203791856765747,
0.5601933002471924,
-0.10510247200727463,
0.7833153009414673,
-0.19393716752529144,
0.7616272568702698,
-0.6148492097854614,
0.7056940793991089,
-0.46608954668045044,
0.33089399337768555,
-0.21143749356269836,
-0.7757278084754944,
-0.02390599250793457,
0.6913431286811829,
-0.08241844177246094,
0.20030778646469116,
0.533382773399353,
0.5952737927436829,
0.01400805450975895,
0.2119539976119995,
0.4005972146987915,
0.2864365875720978,
0.25100138783454895,
0.8456317186355591,
1.4796276092529297,
-0.34976667165756226,
0.38695529103279114,
-0.01720747910439968,
-0.13070714473724365,
0.04001989960670471,
-0.7257629036903381,
-0.521541953086853,
-0.8862964510917664,
0.09380510449409485,
-0.3114207684993744,
-0.6737601161003113,
0.6939753890037537,
0.821821391582489,
-0.6114674210548401,
-0.4884125292301178,
-0.057111844420433044,
0.09944519400596619,
-0.3330058157444,
-0.2474365234375,
0.08176057785749435,
-0.3125211000442505,
-0.5397840142250061,
0.6411247253417969,
0.32399246096611023,
0.033224377781152725,
-0.6750958561897278,
-0.14722399413585663,
0.11989589035511017,
0.3862989842891693,
0.7905051112174988,
0.6470682621002197,
-1.1533968448638916,
-0.3951322138309479,
0.2355220764875412,
-0.3243566155433655,
-0.1408431977033615,
1.3143807649612427,
-0.884890615940094,
0.2918156683444977,
0.4431806206703186,
0.5426234602928162,
0.33569619059562683,
0.019879164174199104,
0.7128994464874268,
-0.7128512859344482,
0.0036395397037267685,
0.2133873701095581,
0.549339771270752,
0.018465479835867882,
0.017086857929825783,
0.3142368495464325,
0.039178017526865005,
-0.5428991317749023,
-0.5377933979034424,
0.7005733251571655,
-1.0309820175170898,
-0.3380056321620941,
1.0674257278442383,
0.13817934691905975,
0.11694958060979843,
-0.0000018855082544178003,
0.2279670536518097,
0.0484871082007885,
-0.20536641776561737,
0.6590083837509155,
0.9748092889785767,
-0.27874261140823364,
-0.18858866393566132,
-0.6131828427314758,
0.5969201326370239,
0.4891907274723053,
-0.3432367742061615,
0.17360392212867737,
0.40085381269454956,
0.17476528882980347,
0.41968971490859985,
0.7130464911460876,
-0.34174057841300964,
0.32306158542633057,
-0.3295929729938507,
-0.20928959548473358,
0.10669626295566559,
-0.640089213848114,
-0.6317755579948425,
-0.04626952484250069,
0.12840652465820312,
-0.008985484018921852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17390v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17390v1
|
KSW: Khmer Stop Word based Dictionary for Keyword Extraction
| 2024-05-27T17:42:54 | 2024-05-27T17:42:54 |
Nimol Thuon, Wangrui Zhang, Sada Thuon
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
This paper introduces KSW, a Khmer-specific approach to keyword extraction
that leverages a specialized stop word dictionary. Due to the limited
availability of natural language processing resources for the Khmer language,
effective keyword extraction has been a significant challenge. KSW addresses
this by developing a tailored stop word dictionary and implementing a
preprocessing methodology to remove stop words, thereby enhancing the
extraction of meaningful keywords. Our experiments demonstrate that KSW
achieves substantial improvements in accuracy and relevance compared to
previous methods, highlighting its potential to advance Khmer text processing
and information retrieval. The KSW resources, including the stop word
dictionary, are available at the following GitHub repository:
(https://github.com/back-kh/KSWv2-Khmer-Stop-Word-based-Dictionary-for-Keyword-Extraction.git).
|
[
-0.4455271363258362,
-0.6672729849815369,
0.5857934355735779,
0.1305341124534607,
-1.0861902236938477,
0.511379599571228,
-0.23603393137454987,
-0.30562347173690796,
0.5217353701591492,
0.8480502367019653,
-0.30331090092658997,
-0.7732640504837036,
-0.9764136075973511,
0.3349347412586212,
-0.10062150657176971,
0.514136016368866,
-0.27258849143981934,
0.18666739761829376,
0.28597506880760193,
-0.5484949946403503,
-0.4717807471752167,
-0.24160131812095642,
-0.5046163201332092,
-0.22668404877185822,
0.6758579611778259,
0.6486397981643677,
0.6307905316352844,
0.8961003422737122,
0.7300429344177246,
0.23236729204654694,
0.09262868762016296,
-0.24596239626407623,
-0.32738587260246277,
0.5808600187301636,
-0.2429616004228592,
-0.3738299608230591,
-0.22396188974380493,
0.14321202039718628,
0.3393014967441559,
0.5251979231834412,
-0.16195183992385864,
0.322417289018631,
-0.23577545583248138,
0.7848061919212341,
-1.1547377109527588,
0.4557608664035797,
-0.6095930337905884,
0.09086263179779053,
-0.7050225734710693,
-0.27551281452178955,
-0.08075842261314392,
-0.3271685838699341,
0.41703546047210693,
-0.697736918926239,
-0.07312528043985367,
-0.3436518609523773,
0.9008355140686035,
0.14523229002952576,
-0.34661221504211426,
-0.4834311008453369,
-0.3507627248764038,
0.7444345951080322,
-0.7590938210487366,
0.8350293040275574,
0.5480758547782898,
0.39138856530189514,
-0.08156894892454147,
-1.2413266897201538,
-0.8807183504104614,
-0.1162601187825203,
0.25279396772384644,
0.518744170665741,
0.3490231931209564,
0.5802882313728333,
0.09409834444522858,
0.25749582052230835,
-0.44851288199424744,
-0.24331976473331451,
-0.29930439591407776,
-0.194520965218544,
0.20652201771736145,
-0.04422437399625778,
0.41799184679985046,
-0.6065751910209656,
-0.10232314467430115,
0.07391359657049179,
-0.6916608810424805,
0.09908603876829147,
0.41168636083602905,
0.45871350169181824,
0.06383061408996582,
0.8926506638526917,
-0.561430037021637,
0.5899299383163452,
-0.3625401258468628,
-0.6778033971786499,
0.08724496513605118,
-0.32515034079551697,
-0.34539198875427246,
0.14773960411548615,
0.38173454999923706,
0.6222237944602966,
0.24007205665111542,
-0.28481370210647583,
-0.2665310800075531,
0.015684137120842934,
0.21397000551223755,
-0.8977389335632324,
-0.602992057800293,
0.17179059982299805,
-0.9810417294502258,
-0.7235518097877502,
-0.043763305991888046,
-0.8797370791435242,
-0.1363300234079361,
-0.35066190361976624,
0.5763500332832336,
-0.2152174711227417,
-0.48387330770492554,
-0.22719354927539825,
-0.7726622819900513,
0.33091604709625244,
-0.0661764144897461,
-0.4897262752056122,
0.3602485954761505,
0.41358712315559387,
1.0405340194702148,
-0.47502848505973816,
-0.027538394555449486,
-0.5304074883460999,
0.3022993206977844,
-0.5390710830688477,
0.568254292011261,
-0.9115548133850098,
-0.8475285768508911,
0.038955993950366974,
0.3474772870540619,
0.3222857713699341,
-0.8303675651550293,
0.5036775469779968,
-0.724574863910675,
0.005173105746507645,
-0.42623844742774963,
-0.5102647542953491,
-0.28835415840148926,
0.04889451339840889,
-0.8055061101913452,
0.835999071598053,
0.36375686526298523,
-0.5437089204788208,
0.7216963171958923,
-0.6709744930267334,
-0.6370007395744324,
0.6573386192321777,
0.02473928965628147,
-0.1350424438714981,
0.15434996783733368,
-0.07572140544652939,
0.08716228604316711,
-0.13234911859035492,
-0.13237173855304718,
-0.22770902514457703,
-0.09834598749876022,
-0.2305227816104889,
0.07074249535799026,
0.7181281447410583,
0.4381672739982605,
-0.12668079137802124,
0.20797231793403625,
-0.8844566941261292,
0.13117824494838715,
0.3101848065853119,
-0.6779290437698364,
-0.7573984265327454,
0.011414961889386177,
0.24548961222171783,
0.19974510371685028,
0.5696671605110168,
-0.8071448802947998,
0.09722594171762466,
-0.40800487995147705,
0.11319701373577118,
0.7217555046081543,
0.16035056114196777,
0.4248063266277313,
0.07518128305673599,
0.7971944212913513,
-0.32060420513153076,
-0.04473118856549263,
-0.18034569919109344,
-0.6147793531417847,
-0.4264409840106964,
-0.6509280204772949,
0.5863089561462402,
0.6711378693580627,
-1.000714659690857,
0.4710656702518463,
-0.11518944054841995,
-0.7016919255256653,
-0.7027376890182495,
0.16364847123622894,
0.34045830368995667,
0.8837565183639526,
0.5258426070213318,
-0.49817919731140137,
-0.9081763029098511,
-0.46066468954086304,
-0.37844061851501465,
-0.09242809563875198,
-0.0535830520093441,
0.24942965805530548,
0.38162580132484436,
-0.06219431012868881,
1.17111074924469,
-0.8902324438095093,
-0.0765441432595253,
-0.31720414757728577,
0.11331511288881302,
-0.1931481957435608,
0.16659758985042572,
0.22581157088279724,
-1.0626518726348877,
-0.8707423806190491,
-0.24943995475769043,
-0.5564833879470825,
-0.4097497761249542,
0.4092056155204773,
-0.18032889068126678,
0.34577861428260803,
0.411549836397171,
-0.7584785223007202,
0.4635329842567444,
0.2998526692390442,
-0.26788225769996643,
0.928604781627655,
-0.09956119954586029,
0.14187344908714294,
-1.2397836446762085,
0.16168808937072754,
-0.42917144298553467,
-0.17869457602500916,
-0.4783979058265686,
0.36580339074134827,
0.11423058807849884,
-0.10994897037744522,
-0.2078332006931305,
0.5487614870071411,
-0.23587533831596375,
-0.028231700882315636,
-0.5789353251457214,
0.2952362895011902,
-0.057908397167921066,
0.14994995296001434,
0.3458525240421295,
0.4600924849510193,
0.22138793766498566,
-0.5200389623641968,
0.600564181804657,
0.05354681983590126,
-0.25991249084472656,
0.40057581663131714,
-0.5893378257751465,
0.12189052999019623,
0.08968953788280487,
0.05168531462550163,
-1.0526272058486938,
-0.08060643821954727,
0.4279966652393341,
-0.40544992685317993,
0.3223765790462494,
-0.3402259051799774,
-0.43162450194358826,
-0.28480687737464905,
-0.5316311120986938,
0.08575788140296936,
0.6037936210632324,
-0.4263845384120941,
0.22554033994674683,
0.6436191201210022,
-0.44451704621315,
-0.5470133423805237,
-0.3805444538593292,
0.3048318326473236,
-0.22071754932403564,
-0.13126562535762787,
0.3549943268299103,
0.1205151379108429,
-0.4052330255508423,
0.25784048438072205,
-0.4914983808994293,
-0.3077560067176819,
-0.10316088795661926,
-0.07984171062707901,
0.3906499147415161,
-0.1447574496269226,
0.2725133001804352,
0.11538995802402496,
-0.3025606572628021,
-0.19122551381587982,
-0.418137788772583,
0.6656575202941895,
0.5279902219772339,
0.07068474590778351,
-0.1565261036157608,
0.2267441600561142,
0.6707031726837158,
-0.2964290976524353,
0.486443430185318,
0.5932466983795166,
-0.5764181017875671,
0.2721041142940521,
-0.37221717834472656,
-0.12139109522104263,
-0.48337453603744507,
0.4202664792537689,
-0.6677491068840027,
-0.6095365285873413,
0.5145999789237976,
-0.37736472487449646,
0.015946000814437866,
0.47942012548446655,
0.45212095975875854,
0.002210346283391118,
0.9650360345840454,
0.7756998538970947,
-0.01042500976473093,
0.32303640246391296,
0.01087021455168724,
0.3413538932800293,
-0.7241289019584656,
-0.1558392494916916,
-0.6396505832672119,
-0.0861096978187561,
-0.7130516171455383,
-0.325057715177536,
-0.19384685158729553,
0.5073277950286865,
0.2348044216632843,
0.5722863674163818,
-0.5869443416595459,
0.010661804117262363,
0.34352654218673706,
-0.4140726327896118,
0.25940343737602234,
-0.2974953353404999,
-0.5778220891952515,
-0.3623245358467102,
-0.16352608799934387,
-0.5679025053977966,
1.0898027420043945,
-0.1002286747097969,
0.4705003798007965,
-0.12593047320842743,
0.7278553247451782,
0.38486894965171814,
0.12143266946077347,
-1.0586868524551392,
0.6563588380813599,
-0.012852069921791553,
-0.2608911097049713,
-0.6474059820175171,
-0.148593008518219,
-1.0806193351745605,
0.1532427966594696,
0.14293083548545837,
-0.5744900107383728,
-0.2994980812072754,
-0.33253371715545654,
0.1392415314912796,
0.323968768119812,
-0.6931943893432617,
0.9260361790657043,
0.3341674506664276,
0.42285579442977905,
-0.43316367268562317,
-0.661953330039978,
0.16264301538467407,
-0.30396533012390137,
0.09067069739103317,
-0.31118401885032654,
-0.6658496856689453,
0.8903704881668091,
-0.9618902802467346,
0.1566285789012909,
-0.5045539736747742,
-0.06919834017753601,
0.37544453144073486,
0.04335717856884003,
0.5307995676994324,
-0.10714345425367355,
0.32245832681655884,
0.3082113564014435,
0.40278732776641846,
-0.3390236794948578,
-0.5001897215843201,
0.47090864181518555,
-0.36830225586891174,
-0.1871175915002823,
-0.06323455274105072,
-0.3040788173675537,
0.09459536522626877,
0.6808716654777527,
0.4779392182826996,
0.34273120760917664,
0.12341280281543732,
0.05945363640785217,
0.34442269802093506,
-0.38137286901474,
0.4792921841144562,
0.773594856262207,
-0.505314826965332,
-0.7712519764900208,
1.3567134141921997,
0.848508894443512,
0.06207701191306114,
0.5650615096092224,
0.4314907491207123,
-0.5431036353111267,
-0.5982815027236938,
-0.35050129890441895,
-0.09282977133989334,
-0.6673474311828613,
-0.08746378123760223,
-0.6326969861984253,
-0.1632460206747055,
-0.7248619794845581,
-0.30118727684020996,
-0.1906287968158722,
-0.6163449287414551,
0.1492425948381424,
0.07322056591510773,
0.3670635521411896,
0.6979940533638,
-0.09819162636995316,
0.3147827982902527,
-0.9532124996185303,
1.0123023986816406,
0.4263116419315338,
0.5042024254798889,
-0.19932344555854797,
-0.13305354118347168,
-0.19100448489189148,
-0.36137011647224426,
-0.05661644786596298,
-1.2249763011932373,
0.3174005448818207,
0.039162527769804,
0.5533264875411987,
0.6816422343254089,
0.3621072471141815,
0.6247305274009705,
-0.46620115637779236,
1.124215006828308,
0.16575242578983307,
-0.8212165832519531,
0.7547106742858887,
-0.1989412009716034,
0.7274447083473206,
0.496091365814209,
0.3963755667209625,
-0.9257577657699585,
-0.7403331995010376,
-0.5795795321464539,
-0.9960000514984131,
0.3289323151111603,
0.13219326734542847,
-0.17870719730854034,
-0.3749449551105499,
0.34027981758117676,
0.25360873341560364,
0.43279415369033813,
-0.1482619196176529,
-0.35353097319602966,
-0.18342934548854828,
-0.39196306467056274,
0.27910858392715454,
-0.5212622880935669,
0.2782675325870514,
-0.2214771956205368,
0.6024340391159058,
-0.04672009125351906,
-0.1784115582704544,
0.31413543224334717,
-0.49885088205337524,
-0.15570245683193207,
0.017897628247737885,
0.44072726368904114,
0.8433519005775452,
-0.26601293683052063,
0.12838107347488403,
0.3393946886062622,
-1.3907026052474976,
-0.06941457092761993,
0.09835037589073181,
-0.1775863766670227,
0.4360613226890564,
0.35928231477737427,
0.06456968933343887,
0.1929284781217575,
-0.8232012987136841,
0.27735552191734314,
-0.21619842946529388,
0.02540697157382965,
-0.14999829232692719,
-0.2772922217845917,
0.08403386920690536,
0.004918940830975771,
0.5551362037658691,
-0.21101008355617523,
0.13327860832214355,
-0.20286013185977936,
0.30414584279060364,
0.43609869480133057,
-0.41892021894454956,
-0.14906354248523712,
0.45359861850738525,
0.13350895047187805,
-0.7552765607833862,
0.3890848159790039,
-0.3326473534107208,
-0.550020694732666,
0.47586074471473694,
0.43348339200019836,
1.120717167854309,
-0.38012903928756714,
0.04590632766485214,
0.35050153732299805,
0.2290976345539093,
0.38590896129608154,
0.8834448456764221,
-0.6413403153419495,
-0.694145143032074,
-0.6044445633888245,
-0.885841429233551,
-0.45900869369506836,
0.42318058013916016,
-0.7432150840759277,
0.4819207787513733,
-0.2988685071468353,
-0.09211745113134384,
-0.16768600046634674,
0.42770835757255554,
-0.20914600789546967,
0.19020164012908936,
-0.16899928450584412,
1.1717084646224976,
-0.11074157059192657,
1.011176586151123,
0.7778114080429077,
-0.27711722254753113,
-0.5479785203933716,
0.18357603251934052,
-0.057297367602586746,
-0.5837545394897461,
0.5416446924209595,
0.2965056598186493,
-0.11156455427408218,
0.06747906655073166,
-0.47515472769737244,
-0.7931391596794128,
0.8561586141586304,
-0.025080712512135506,
-0.438180148601532,
0.10845614969730377,
0.03426253795623779,
0.18670432269573212,
-0.05065188556909561,
-0.4541912376880646,
0.8536946773529053,
0.6474342942237854,
0.0059981271624565125,
-0.8068802356719971,
0.12943850457668304,
-0.09615147113800049,
0.07057027518749237,
0.3997688889503479,
-0.22709505259990692,
0.23926150798797607,
-0.03713710233569145,
-0.1512557566165924,
0.22045491635799408,
0.49429449439048767,
0.3455788493156433,
0.16417773067951202,
0.7751166224479675,
0.8365665674209595,
0.6959369778633118,
0.062188901007175446,
0.595434308052063,
-0.6415616869926453,
0.3213016986846924,
1.0882487297058105,
-0.2416594922542572,
0.7577829360961914,
0.5279040336608887,
-0.32784825563430786,
0.26063984632492065,
0.7009296417236328,
0.24462297558784485,
1.0356206893920898,
0.03546476736664772,
-0.6759573221206665,
0.04286599159240723,
-0.12235483527183533,
-0.2450159639120102,
0.815820038318634,
0.29317688941955566,
-0.1785733699798584,
-0.427166610956192,
0.165225550532341,
0.047540031373500824,
-0.26887020468711853,
-0.3260365128517151,
0.6311027407646179,
0.20757347345352173,
-0.5502724051475525,
0.05482916161417961,
0.18026188015937805,
0.5447120666503906,
-0.8615426421165466,
-0.44812366366386414,
0.40597018599510193,
-0.07599565386772156,
0.12525470554828644,
-0.7185248136520386,
0.5063933730125427,
-0.1480952650308609,
-0.09522569924592972,
-0.058234021067619324,
1.3823606967926025,
-0.4492945373058319,
-0.11267206817865372,
0.44592589139938354,
0.43110132217407227,
0.3137561082839966,
-0.12357659637928009,
-0.5990338325500488,
-0.199456125497818,
-0.3174856901168823,
-0.4422142505645752,
0.2304980456829071,
0.34885016083717346,
0.33755919337272644,
0.33458802103996277,
0.9148018956184387,
0.6693607568740845,
-0.031769052147865295,
0.09926461428403854,
0.4718809425830841,
-0.7174482941627502,
-0.7564915418624878,
-0.9218913912773132,
0.14057624340057373,
-0.2294543981552124,
-0.3696960210800171,
0.6873154640197754,
0.6664904952049255,
0.7682769894599915,
-0.0759458988904953,
1.1590328216552734,
-0.31151947379112244,
0.544921875,
-0.2283787578344345,
1.1122862100601196,
-0.3923749625682831,
-0.45513927936553955,
-0.4635907709598541,
-0.8569883704185486,
-0.10779495537281036,
0.5189956426620483,
0.07550309598445892,
-0.24401693046092987,
0.6371975541114807,
0.5167551636695862,
0.3028044104576111,
0.016020476818084717,
0.6900036334991455,
0.07617846876382828,
0.3719201982021332,
-0.27484002709388733,
0.27049586176872253,
-0.09627391397953033,
0.7158771753311157,
-0.42581164836883545,
-0.1754675656557083,
-0.19969041645526886,
-0.6923539638519287,
-0.4429214596748352,
-0.8134703040122986,
0.011086426675319672,
-0.30998724699020386,
-0.05085233226418495,
0.7424586415290833,
0.48373943567276,
-0.7909631133079529,
0.18934044241905212,
-0.2500593960285187,
0.6296182870864868,
-0.17953860759735107,
-0.3889256715774536,
0.5115594863891602,
-0.6769019365310669,
-0.6312471628189087,
0.2502688765525818,
0.7086568474769592,
0.005448285024613142,
-0.20323802530765533,
-0.2653068006038666,
-0.2825794517993927,
0.1520370990037918,
0.8277663588523865,
0.2781960666179657,
-0.6068580746650696,
-0.4581614136695862,
-0.09400825947523117,
-0.09981927275657654,
-0.12073425948619843,
0.8349724411964417,
-0.9246687293052673,
0.9858060479164124,
0.7496739029884338,
0.5047963261604309,
0.28697240352630615,
-0.3781649172306061,
0.7036702632904053,
-0.5925796627998352,
0.27300500869750977,
0.1363682597875595,
0.38801565766334534,
0.021502187475562096,
-0.14987199008464813,
0.5401080250740051,
0.9466921091079712,
-0.3478299379348755,
-0.8320349454879761,
0.23669913411140442,
-0.7953970432281494,
-0.23830990493297577,
0.8311638236045837,
-0.27936863899230957,
-0.0932784155011177,
-0.6491746306419373,
-0.45465850830078125,
0.844911515712738,
-0.08343701809644699,
0.7323655486106873,
1.060254693031311,
0.2601604759693146,
-0.05035894736647606,
-0.7820826172828674,
0.6244242787361145,
-0.07361381500959396,
-0.4681251347064972,
-0.23654118180274963,
-0.11383209377527237,
0.5004037022590637,
0.17993956804275513,
0.9243888854980469,
-0.210213765501976,
0.4422857463359833,
0.13493312895298004,
0.17765267193317413,
0.23600323498249054,
-0.2264905422925949,
-0.1288716346025467,
0.2880537509918213,
-0.10023478418588638,
-0.6880882382392883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17386v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17386v1
|
MindMerger: Efficient Boosting LLM Reasoning in non-English Languages
| 2024-05-27T17:41:54 | 2024-05-27T17:41:54 |
Zixian Huang, Wenhao Zhu, Gong Cheng, Lei Li, Fei Yuan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Reasoning capabilities are crucial for Large Language Models (LLMs), yet a
notable gap exists between English and non-English languages. To bridge this
disparity, some works fine-tune LLMs to relearn reasoning capabilities in
non-English languages, while others replace non-English inputs with an external
model's outputs such as English translation text to circumvent the challenge of
LLM understanding non-English. Unfortunately, these methods often underutilize
the built-in skilled reasoning and useful language understanding capabilities
of LLMs. In order to better utilize the minds of reasoning and language
understanding in LLMs, we propose a new method, namely MindMerger, which merges
LLMs with the external language understanding capabilities from multilingual
models to boost the multilingual reasoning performance. Furthermore, a two-step
training scheme is introduced to first train to embeded the external
capabilities into LLMs and then train the collaborative utilization of the
external capabilities and the built-in capabilities in LLMs. Experiments on
three multilingual reasoning datasets and a language understanding dataset
demonstrate that MindMerger consistently outperforms all baselines, especially
in low-resource languages. Without updating the parameters of LLMs, the average
accuracy improved by 6.7% and 8.0% across all languages and low-resource
languages on the MGSM dataset, respectively.
|
[
-0.55976402759552,
-0.38656219840049744,
0.7012097835540771,
-0.0585966520011425,
-0.34412121772766113,
0.1680126190185547,
-0.5509344339370728,
-0.45590540766716003,
0.16250275075435638,
0.3192131519317627,
-0.6765484809875488,
-0.3499203622341156,
-0.49138012528419495,
0.342111200094223,
0.220805823802948,
0.8047794699668884,
-0.1237790435552597,
0.4598706066608429,
-0.5655866861343384,
-0.33827856183052063,
-0.37867194414138794,
-0.6172863245010376,
-0.7510749697685242,
-0.8885220289230347,
0.45629066228866577,
0.4244118630886078,
0.40451598167419434,
0.2674610912799835,
0.32070955634117126,
0.26030319929122925,
-0.06730271130800247,
0.6209269165992737,
-0.3527511954307556,
0.00655362056568265,
-0.5048242211341858,
-0.7483595013618469,
-0.23775148391723633,
-0.15265774726867676,
0.3432616591453552,
0.4395529329776764,
-0.15138381719589233,
0.08306571841239929,
0.10202329605817795,
0.7229032516479492,
-0.46355679631233215,
0.39376121759414673,
-0.7393941879272461,
0.021746696904301643,
-0.002804472343996167,
-0.23429423570632935,
-0.38493216037750244,
-0.030889537185430527,
-0.14912161231040955,
-0.5958271622657776,
0.20660577714443207,
0.2882462441921234,
0.5524803996086121,
0.46461930871009827,
-0.09775851666927338,
-0.01949223503470421,
-0.39274632930755615,
0.9324389696121216,
-0.5785535573959351,
0.6736640334129333,
0.3740638494491577,
0.38979825377464294,
-0.0736822709441185,
-0.2087746560573578,
-0.5935942530632019,
-0.15592510998249054,
-0.3038591742515564,
0.16624188423156738,
-0.2305057942867279,
-0.076603002846241,
0.2424463927745819,
0.381479948759079,
-0.6119577884674072,
0.22115923464298248,
-0.12384776026010513,
-0.27698543667793274,
0.6534003615379333,
-0.13881151378154755,
0.0320361964404583,
-0.0608939602971077,
-0.14573325216770172,
-0.2540929913520813,
-0.5990349650382996,
0.06270868331193924,
0.3820793628692627,
0.3520967364311218,
-0.10466162860393524,
0.5194663405418396,
-0.11259693652391434,
0.7047851085662842,
0.1537809818983078,
-0.5288414359092712,
0.2536385953426361,
-0.08226887881755829,
-0.1375388503074646,
0.11100776493549347,
0.615095853805542,
0.3698781728744507,
0.36291244626045227,
-0.23924703896045685,
-0.3110359311103821,
0.1950404942035675,
-0.1588953137397766,
-0.6760905385017395,
-0.27810752391815186,
0.27365848422050476,
-0.15520502626895905,
0.17039057612419128,
-0.31967243552207947,
-0.5578895211219788,
-0.30182185769081116,
-0.36729609966278076,
0.2256302535533905,
-0.5663085579872131,
-0.49807873368263245,
0.4466537833213806,
-0.09024997800588608,
0.33651211857795715,
0.19375143945217133,
-0.7530139684677124,
-0.09333846718072891,
0.6997891068458557,
0.6210041642189026,
-0.24802105128765106,
-0.27513712644577026,
-0.4670049250125885,
0.306402325630188,
-0.412588506937027,
1.0715185403823853,
-0.44542890787124634,
-0.2808917760848999,
-0.2893269658088684,
-0.08376718312501907,
-0.08396284282207489,
-0.5991262197494507,
0.436763197183609,
-0.5248624086380005,
0.572085440158844,
-0.22223716974258423,
-0.6252330541610718,
-0.5015032291412354,
0.5964983701705933,
-0.3888744115829468,
0.8948615193367004,
0.006517887115478516,
-0.7517723441123962,
0.2708856463432312,
-0.4328123927116394,
-0.5027974843978882,
0.17666839063167572,
-0.36375582218170166,
-0.07917957752943039,
0.07637099176645279,
0.683295726776123,
0.5953671932220459,
-0.42920029163360596,
0.4696129262447357,
-0.08406678587198257,
-0.3132816255092621,
0.0837659165263176,
-0.327623188495636,
0.6381844282150269,
0.03675521910190582,
-0.04487059637904167,
0.07228520512580872,
-0.5543683171272278,
0.3019063174724579,
0.31720849871635437,
-0.2764929533004761,
-0.35418906807899475,
-0.09268801659345627,
-0.3024037182331085,
0.40875348448753357,
0.35352832078933716,
-0.36158278584480286,
-0.01892867684364319,
-0.6170757412910461,
0.15381979942321777,
0.45858293771743774,
-0.0545172356069088,
0.37924259901046753,
-0.46230944991111755,
0.738236665725708,
-0.0925096720457077,
-0.2125443071126938,
-0.16229605674743652,
-0.4556961953639984,
-1.0129624605178833,
-0.5291486382484436,
0.043833810836076736,
0.9799102544784546,
-1.2410696744918823,
0.5209267139434814,
-0.3870691657066345,
-0.487643301486969,
-0.7365566492080688,
0.4391327500343323,
0.6976333856582642,
0.47474074363708496,
0.6205242872238159,
0.015008409507572651,
-0.49655401706695557,
-1.0978903770446777,
-0.44864630699157715,
-0.3049844205379486,
-0.10849609225988388,
0.17286212742328644,
0.3409527540206909,
-0.3095240592956543,
0.6024125218391418,
-0.4633943736553192,
-0.17430609464645386,
-0.7929761409759521,
-0.26500532031059265,
0.39941978454589844,
0.4110899567604065,
0.34123411774635315,
-0.4918292462825775,
-0.22798743844032288,
0.09778282046318054,
-0.7612344622612,
-0.11023125052452087,
-0.015217140316963196,
-0.398490309715271,
0.40474212169647217,
0.48209089040756226,
-0.6433627009391785,
-0.0702895075082779,
0.6536271572113037,
-0.14283260703086853,
0.4756937325000763,
-0.2214156985282898,
0.13783897459506989,
-1.1223262548446655,
-0.19080229103565216,
0.1748909056186676,
-0.2761392891407013,
-0.48663610219955444,
0.27349400520324707,
0.24179919064044952,
0.0210389643907547,
-0.624828040599823,
0.8355324268341064,
-0.45720016956329346,
0.15888690948486328,
-0.1830873042345047,
0.30692583322525024,
0.13637468218803406,
0.7255617380142212,
0.17030830681324005,
0.9150366187095642,
0.5914689302444458,
-0.5932784080505371,
0.45187103748321533,
0.09491309523582458,
-0.3926312029361725,
0.8203741908073425,
-0.2519370913505554,
0.18318313360214233,
-0.3177505433559418,
0.12780122458934784,
-0.7615681290626526,
-0.11977530270814896,
0.26474106311798096,
-0.39814379811286926,
0.5061067938804626,
-0.2256607711315155,
-0.6715430617332458,
-0.3548746407032013,
-0.06564830243587494,
0.1270725131034851,
0.34679046273231506,
-0.8311125636100769,
0.8537753820419312,
0.3644511103630066,
0.047667425125837326,
-0.4750992953777313,
-0.8607689142227173,
0.01895851455628872,
-0.37543731927871704,
-0.603563129901886,
0.189728781580925,
-0.07420646399259567,
-0.43571221828460693,
-0.15336143970489502,
-0.19809231162071228,
0.1807997226715088,
-0.1591835469007492,
-0.35585758090019226,
0.3816225826740265,
-0.05488274618983269,
0.2959960103034973,
0.10377408564090729,
-0.45915600657463074,
0.057104144245386124,
-0.5067200660705566,
0.35664990544319153,
-0.26256293058395386,
-0.4667356312274933,
-0.09679488837718964,
0.3943038880825043,
0.3392244279384613,
-0.38728323578834534,
0.9112696051597595,
0.5104808211326599,
-0.35030773282051086,
-0.3269895315170288,
-0.7276597023010254,
-0.27542611956596375,
-0.47950488328933716,
0.433759868144989,
-0.6319171786308289,
-1.1263532638549805,
0.2366805374622345,
0.10679206252098083,
0.2918620705604553,
0.24436555802822113,
0.5525607466697693,
0.05137266218662262,
1.0587382316589355,
0.5505890846252441,
-0.20455482602119446,
0.11794426292181015,
-0.080291248857975,
0.36795774102211,
-0.7292641997337341,
-0.3429870009422302,
-0.11312641948461533,
-0.10392232984304428,
-0.47782444953918457,
-0.9453549385070801,
0.1964029222726822,
0.1528848558664322,
-0.009655103087425232,
0.2497466504573822,
-0.3785736858844757,
0.7435302734375,
0.3228929936885834,
0.022337572649121284,
0.5083072781562805,
0.3078892230987549,
-0.6279043555259705,
-0.22298188507556915,
-0.949599027633667,
-0.46811631321907043,
0.8100836873054504,
0.05820225179195404,
0.7584964632987976,
0.22367116808891296,
0.6353242993354797,
-0.19221673905849457,
0.45747798681259155,
-1.0077074766159058,
0.7038066983222961,
-0.080905981361866,
-0.38281047344207764,
0.030626552179455757,
-0.6703991293907166,
-0.5173468589782715,
0.8284903168678284,
-0.15676547586917877,
-0.5952431559562683,
-0.38527756929397583,
0.33766674995422363,
-0.015629535540938377,
0.5967418551445007,
-0.7609218955039978,
0.5129967331886292,
-0.6721291542053223,
-0.462190717458725,
-0.43810319900512695,
-0.23556536436080933,
0.4223935902118683,
-0.18999698758125305,
0.42588213086128235,
-0.24054771661758423,
-0.20289158821105957,
0.5884321331977844,
0.13106268644332886,
0.5467067360877991,
-0.10296738147735596,
-0.4765309691429138,
0.14980392158031464,
0.21261346340179443,
0.47477608919143677,
0.0641341507434845,
-0.08160936087369919,
0.42581498622894287,
-0.29279276728630066,
-0.32244375348091125,
-0.7916924953460693,
0.6293857097625732,
-0.5358566045761108,
-1.0715235471725464,
-0.3478250205516815,
-0.7928667664527893,
-0.6532209515571594,
0.06177719309926033,
0.18326185643672943,
0.13160204887390137,
0.06712091714143753,
-0.09729316085577011,
0.6811301112174988,
-0.26591062545776367,
0.09678152203559875,
0.7803457975387573,
-0.31725746393203735,
-0.5573939085006714,
0.8850476145744324,
-0.06653665006160736,
0.21550196409225464,
0.6427846550941467,
0.18159490823745728,
-0.5314581394195557,
-0.33279693126678467,
-0.5593610405921936,
0.5760090947151184,
-0.9328855276107788,
-0.17953376471996307,
-0.86684650182724,
-0.03150907903909683,
-0.10567998886108398,
-0.20931318402290344,
-0.31238827109336853,
-0.45356494188308716,
0.0015646717511117458,
-0.2852070927619934,
0.4185149073600769,
0.2761336863040924,
-0.06524862349033356,
-0.0010298171546310186,
-0.8217175602912903,
0.25172415375709534,
0.2880936861038208,
0.36639973521232605,
0.07310467958450317,
-0.6892656087875366,
-0.4626634418964386,
-0.046584051102399826,
-0.14648723602294922,
-0.7105767726898193,
0.3447130024433136,
0.035458531230688095,
0.9379361271858215,
0.3659757077693939,
-0.37553930282592773,
0.9023110866546631,
-0.4611402451992035,
0.3953687846660614,
0.2601436972618103,
-0.7378880977630615,
0.5308602452278137,
-0.25915393233299255,
0.5395772457122803,
0.5195692181587219,
0.4424014389514923,
-0.6003353595733643,
-0.4588898718357086,
-0.4636882543563843,
-0.8168025016784668,
0.6108697652816772,
-0.07963622361421585,
-0.19524215161800385,
-0.0557861402630806,
0.26781129837036133,
-0.008558488450944424,
0.20097710192203522,
-0.7818512916564941,
-0.18781466782093048,
0.09558505564928055,
-0.30652523040771484,
-0.4733108580112457,
0.010143371298909187,
-0.1573566347360611,
-0.6408224105834961,
1.0354995727539062,
-0.4649098813533783,
0.15602827072143555,
-0.11732753366231918,
-0.23899616301059723,
-0.01573706790804863,
0.4157842993736267,
0.12038666754961014,
0.5710657835006714,
0.15357805788516998,
0.2634468078613281,
0.755526065826416,
-0.05169733241200447,
0.32310765981674194,
0.21393617987632751,
0.1425902396440506,
-0.2753552496433258,
0.3390843868255615,
0.5154297947883606,
0.2347005158662796,
-1.0889791250228882,
0.1603880673646927,
-0.18553784489631653,
-0.2898414731025696,
-0.2537860870361328,
0.2779545187950134,
0.5102373957633972,
0.5171348452568054,
0.14247074723243713,
0.010323703289031982,
-0.2456686943769455,
-0.0031843623146414757,
0.03187315911054611,
0.5418380498886108,
-0.1493951827287674,
-0.04864403232932091,
0.39603838324546814,
0.07795476913452148,
-0.04482884705066681,
0.376710444688797,
-0.5823865532875061,
-0.6703190803527832,
0.28644707798957825,
0.7561810612678528,
0.8417168855667114,
-0.09294073283672333,
-0.12677504122257233,
0.4458850920200348,
0.5652937889099121,
-0.3001299798488617,
0.4354357123374939,
-0.10735342651605606,
-1.162515640258789,
-0.8092833757400513,
-0.5308896899223328,
-0.5441040396690369,
0.2667199671268463,
-0.5296803116798401,
0.10726017504930496,
-0.19549524784088135,
0.01164988148957491,
-0.3691836893558502,
0.07558706402778625,
-0.7252674698829651,
0.010115500539541245,
0.38140878081321716,
1.0127686262130737,
-0.8618918061256409,
0.8027826547622681,
1.061966896057129,
-0.006760045420378447,
-0.7201909422874451,
-0.04267622157931328,
0.052118606865406036,
-0.9220799207687378,
0.3922756612300873,
0.5678307414054871,
-0.5873884558677673,
0.1268823742866516,
-0.2058064192533493,
-0.9169550538063049,
0.9179036617279053,
0.6024129986763,
-0.6511955261230469,
0.2716677486896515,
-0.18151943385601044,
0.537652850151062,
-0.39590489864349365,
0.04703502729535103,
0.686812698841095,
0.4883253872394562,
0.06295745819807053,
-0.5225954651832581,
-0.03912561014294624,
-0.24866452813148499,
-0.04794999957084656,
0.40583521127700806,
-0.610060453414917,
0.3961706757545471,
-0.3627062141895294,
-0.3345458507537842,
-0.2935694456100464,
0.7159720063209534,
0.645869791507721,
-0.11149413138628006,
0.5698856115341187,
1.0083231925964355,
1.0878140926361084,
-0.03450774401426315,
0.9710140228271484,
-0.5000544190406799,
0.09158500283956528,
1.1154122352600098,
-0.5226852297782898,
0.7472018599510193,
0.4720222055912018,
-0.13851065933704376,
0.49483945965766907,
0.4079597294330597,
-0.003619218012318015,
0.3068901598453522,
0.002127681626006961,
-0.39219045639038086,
-0.6301154494285583,
-0.07852351665496826,
-0.09274846315383911,
0.4525897800922394,
0.5370947122573853,
-0.0271916501224041,
-0.2296038269996643,
0.05387963727116585,
0.4155619442462921,
0.16807235777378082,
-0.3698834180831909,
0.6757554411888123,
0.19122938811779022,
-0.9741957783699036,
0.7074065208435059,
0.24115286767482758,
1.0711737871170044,
-0.6651197075843811,
0.14926157891750336,
-0.16414016485214233,
0.46505823731422424,
-0.19717678427696228,
-0.7712757587432861,
0.3007863759994507,
0.36004912853240967,
-0.18102172017097473,
-0.39391079545021057,
0.7229390740394592,
-0.6709088087081909,
-0.7972740530967712,
0.7332197427749634,
1.102596640586853,
0.18113268911838531,
0.11819515377283096,
-0.8404000401496887,
-0.4000067710876465,
0.16491936147212982,
-0.09060540050268173,
0.38016054034233093,
0.30707985162734985,
0.030166437849402428,
0.9622946381568909,
0.8534313440322876,
0.28432729840278625,
-0.4132595360279083,
0.36716505885124207,
0.7355276942253113,
-0.6330961585044861,
-0.6043732166290283,
-1.1003434658050537,
0.07311341166496277,
0.04108802229166031,
0.060896001756191254,
0.9725918173789978,
0.5993791818618774,
1.2642947435379028,
0.12890325486660004,
0.8349471688270569,
0.22399389743804932,
0.5783980488777161,
-0.6642767190933228,
0.5657218098640442,
-0.6945418119430542,
0.13836659491062164,
0.06997624039649963,
-0.7913120985031128,
-0.2197873890399933,
0.9329351186752319,
-0.36732473969459534,
0.11033517122268677,
0.7207451462745667,
1.0150010585784912,
-0.041365478187799454,
-0.051067035645246506,
0.3995072543621063,
-0.15735386312007904,
0.24942253530025482,
0.7911874651908875,
0.862686812877655,
0.2264472097158432,
0.5759598612785339,
-0.3306158781051636,
-0.3376920819282532,
0.16926349699497223,
-0.8978577852249146,
-1.3943612575531006,
-0.08446022123098373,
-0.2069174200296402,
-0.17771892249584198,
-0.1444777101278305,
1.3102518320083618,
0.5646786093711853,
-0.8021777272224426,
-0.3718818426132202,
0.11866112053394318,
0.20919226109981537,
-0.39230403304100037,
-0.25043219327926636,
0.07497873902320862,
-0.4662177562713623,
-0.5941343903541565,
0.6363794803619385,
0.3917735517024994,
0.05973061919212341,
-0.38660570979118347,
-0.13767153024673462,
-0.16609278321266174,
0.1315527856349945,
0.7248509526252747,
-0.043311238288879395,
-0.7329318523406982,
0.0022877976298332214,
-0.023692522197961807,
0.12791380286216736,
0.10341420024633408,
0.750408947467804,
-0.9521723985671997,
0.37111666798591614,
0.37316465377807617,
0.7393321394920349,
0.27319011092185974,
-0.1653098613023758,
0.5827274322509766,
-0.8409487009048462,
0.5478545427322388,
0.05150361359119415,
0.7624739408493042,
0.8228560090065002,
-0.3627685606479645,
0.4764993190765381,
0.1658448725938797,
-0.19561722874641418,
-0.42206519842147827,
0.3429321348667145,
-0.28268641233444214,
-0.48710817098617554,
1.2216432094573975,
-0.07427218556404114,
-0.0916142538189888,
-0.1544792354106903,
-0.11488879472017288,
0.2943562865257263,
-0.35150447487831116,
0.4667675197124481,
0.8793549537658691,
-0.3696417212486267,
-0.4479537904262543,
-0.6907415986061096,
0.319102942943573,
0.49112382531166077,
-0.8959220051765442,
0.04204274341464043,
0.5200190544128418,
0.19833046197891235,
0.12919718027114868,
0.5350013375282288,
-0.10605186223983765,
0.09997832030057907,
-0.3270637094974518,
0.1338081806898117,
-0.226573646068573,
-0.3372569680213928,
-0.4239148795604706,
-0.15478046238422394,
0.11153864860534668,
0.149481400847435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17383v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17383v1
|
Unlocking the Secrets of Linear Complexity Sequence Model from A Unified Perspective
| 2024-05-27T17:38:55 | 2024-05-27T17:38:55 |
Zhen Qin, Xuyang Shen, Dong Li, Weigao Sun, Stan Birchfield, Richard Hartley, Yiran Zhong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present the Linear Complexity Sequence Model (LCSM), a comprehensive
solution that unites various sequence modeling techniques with linear
complexity, including linear attention, state space model, long convolution,
and linear RNN, within a single framework. The goal is to enhance comprehension
of these models by analyzing the impact of each component from a cohesive and
streamlined viewpoint. Specifically, we segment the modeling processes of these
models into three distinct stages: Expand, Oscillation, and Shrink (EOS), with
each model having its own specific settings. The Expand stage involves
projecting the input signal onto a high-dimensional memory state. This is
followed by recursive operations performed on the memory state in the
Oscillation stage. Finally, the memory state is projected back to a
low-dimensional space in the Shrink stage. We perform comprehensive experiments
to analyze the impact of different stage settings on language modeling and
retrieval tasks. Our results show that data-driven methods are crucial for the
effectiveness of the three stages in language modeling, whereas hand-crafted
methods yield better performance in retrieval tasks.
|
[
-0.09846886992454529,
-0.6971913576126099,
0.7638060450553894,
-0.12427734583616257,
-0.24402301013469696,
0.0391952283680439,
0.11897744238376617,
-0.4303957521915436,
-0.23041972517967224,
0.6630069613456726,
-0.8190634846687317,
-0.21376146376132965,
-0.4842686355113983,
-0.0870789885520935,
-0.5789373517036438,
0.8458800911903381,
0.11060366034507751,
0.21002790331840515,
0.018281733617186546,
-0.0296096820384264,
-0.3704153001308441,
-0.4626809358596802,
-0.4221821129322052,
-0.4065544605255127,
0.4844571352005005,
0.2313471883535385,
0.7119059562683105,
0.7959942817687988,
0.5508875846862793,
0.3219856321811676,
-0.4056863784790039,
-0.1320594698190689,
-0.6475870609283447,
0.3200989067554474,
-0.11516404896974564,
-0.5346634387969971,
-0.26365235447883606,
-0.18049722909927368,
0.552179217338562,
1.4032193422317505,
-0.23132571578025818,
0.28390318155288696,
0.2634640336036682,
0.8481693267822266,
-0.34353622794151306,
-0.08293727040290833,
-0.38818541169166565,
0.19961607456207275,
0.11132264137268066,
0.08369474112987518,
-0.5384283065795898,
-0.2894228398799896,
0.523587703704834,
-0.4741923213005066,
0.3038053810596466,
-0.004932446405291557,
0.41969534754753113,
0.2661207616329193,
-0.43262627720832825,
-0.5617382526397705,
-1.1893916130065918,
0.9822277426719666,
-0.6970113515853882,
0.47185495495796204,
-0.198708638548851,
-0.03797212243080139,
-0.21042773127555847,
-0.5884179472923279,
-0.15656310319900513,
-0.13625690340995789,
0.07715301960706711,
-0.35708269476890564,
0.08416462689638138,
0.47718653082847595,
0.4529242217540741,
0.5641527771949768,
-0.6946306824684143,
0.016892295330762863,
-0.6809004545211792,
-0.20773519575595856,
0.40111857652664185,
0.35369357466697693,
0.29407235980033875,
0.05979645624756813,
-0.4286436140537262,
0.1250627487897873,
-0.501562774181366,
0.11348725110292435,
0.0850423127412796,
0.5056735277175903,
0.17386311292648315,
0.5586639642715454,
-0.06500589847564697,
0.8020842671394348,
-0.2673152685165405,
-0.2652064263820648,
-0.01890050806105137,
-0.4951903223991394,
-0.2947465181350708,
-0.20700953900814056,
0.46934476494789124,
-0.39088544249534607,
-0.11799464374780655,
-0.09540058672428131,
-0.1342095285654068,
-0.23313884437084198,
0.3074498772621155,
-0.5448492765426636,
0.1381119340658188,
0.3359243869781494,
-0.5917362570762634,
-0.06533342599868774,
0.06846212595701218,
-0.7981496453285217,
-0.46470680832862854,
-0.5090649724006653,
0.5147546529769897,
-0.3572317063808441,
-0.013549028895795345,
0.40878602862358093,
0.2766247093677521,
0.1929543912410736,
0.41266685724258423,
-0.6456308364868164,
0.5577667951583862,
0.9060343503952026,
0.7280523777008057,
-0.23831357061862946,
0.10109751671552658,
-0.41932958364486694,
-0.27084285020828247,
-0.2014039158821106,
0.18188731372356415,
-0.5561749935150146,
-0.14027026295661926,
0.03366583585739136,
-0.24967515468597412,
0.0400962233543396,
-0.22061395645141602,
0.5377556681632996,
-0.7919982075691223,
0.16475826501846313,
-0.17286130785942078,
-0.7836530208587646,
-0.29190725088119507,
-0.27339839935302734,
-0.9890192747116089,
0.9897903203964233,
-0.23434366285800934,
-0.49669405817985535,
-0.1730903685092926,
-0.6840667128562927,
-0.37520867586135864,
-0.0961608961224556,
-0.030019352212548256,
-0.33932462334632874,
0.5116590261459351,
0.06146882846951485,
0.49015089869499207,
-0.2761801481246948,
0.013514840975403786,
-0.3390701711177826,
-0.34129881858825684,
0.2148626297712326,
-0.19146336615085602,
0.5452688336372375,
0.34296268224716187,
-0.07736615836620331,
-0.001402315916493535,
-1.0131055116653442,
0.02950766310095787,
0.1313546895980835,
-0.4156224727630615,
-0.22847901284694672,
0.214198037981987,
-0.31364578008651733,
0.29587656259536743,
0.37826600670814514,
-0.47114884853363037,
0.18922048807144165,
-0.5841492414474487,
0.44514110684394836,
0.5351273417472839,
-0.007509520743042231,
0.8309035301208496,
0.12216362357139587,
0.625789999961853,
0.11886990070343018,
0.3180769383907318,
-0.7846843004226685,
-0.3242756128311157,
-0.72933429479599,
0.21653997898101807,
0.06081925332546234,
0.5306710004806519,
-0.48046982288360596,
0.15394507348537445,
-0.20261254906654358,
-0.3346717357635498,
-0.44578295946121216,
0.1839553266763687,
0.5856121182441711,
0.3117538392543793,
0.2833282947540283,
-0.3406983017921448,
-0.6277551054954529,
-0.6511773467063904,
-0.05626968294382095,
-0.024970436468720436,
-0.042403656989336014,
-0.002120430115610361,
0.3875490427017212,
0.11791297793388367,
0.6646032929420471,
-0.5524369478225708,
0.024338284507393837,
-0.41884446144104004,
0.12264106422662735,
0.762188196182251,
0.2498994767665863,
-0.024280542507767677,
-0.628798246383667,
0.06692976504564285,
-0.1222274899482727,
-0.4566764831542969,
0.15328559279441833,
-0.11560793966054916,
0.24656403064727783,
0.23998084664344788,
0.5114681720733643,
-0.3810155689716339,
0.6859896779060364,
0.39359501004219055,
-0.18059515953063965,
0.39132988452911377,
-0.24980291724205017,
-0.23684804141521454,
-0.908875048160553,
0.12895430624485016,
-0.19550950825214386,
-0.06273802369832993,
-1.0917707681655884,
0.41448694467544556,
0.011256258934736252,
-0.3027721643447876,
-0.18921785056591034,
0.0650782510638237,
-0.7234764695167542,
-0.5314079523086548,
-0.11262605339288712,
0.08462661504745483,
0.09486287087202072,
0.596424400806427,
-0.23392897844314575,
0.41121143102645874,
0.27943453192710876,
-0.5935302376747131,
0.15013085305690765,
-0.3292868733406067,
-0.4030311107635498,
-0.14747609198093414,
-0.9519990086555481,
0.30313724279403687,
-0.30851492285728455,
0.028674449771642685,
-1.2141282558441162,
0.11302576959133148,
-0.02541884407401085,
-0.3177012801170349,
0.33181580901145935,
0.03999435901641846,
-0.4512594938278198,
-0.6538481712341309,
-0.0025062488857656717,
0.4239337742328644,
0.35918205976486206,
-0.1908789426088333,
0.5459966063499451,
0.16796128451824188,
-0.2820647358894348,
-0.8459939956665039,
-0.4380452036857605,
-0.31939151883125305,
-0.056581832468509674,
-0.4217156171798706,
0.12243133783340454,
-0.3185148239135742,
-0.2157595157623291,
-0.3458840847015381,
-0.3019421696662903,
-0.05372133105993271,
0.1557781994342804,
0.25538399815559387,
0.2885163724422455,
-0.37356650829315186,
0.23243550956249237,
-0.09263968467712402,
0.1882733404636383,
-0.04682519659399986,
-0.5598095655441284,
0.7655725479125977,
-0.2601422965526581,
-0.40387219190597534,
-0.3656485676765442,
0.4903827905654907,
0.6989576816558838,
-0.24296268820762634,
0.6057780981063843,
0.19399414956569672,
-0.3572847545146942,
-0.25117364525794983,
-0.2082013338804245,
-0.11918894946575165,
-0.4170365333557129,
0.5459781885147095,
-0.22764542698860168,
-0.9929548501968384,
0.7684124112129211,
-0.054143212735652924,
0.08210142701864243,
0.1286701261997223,
0.4226972162723541,
-0.06568775326013565,
0.9928433299064636,
0.8923507332801819,
-0.1889246553182602,
0.37612393498420715,
-0.2618163228034973,
0.2819775342941284,
-0.6938055753707886,
-0.2076401561498642,
-0.46413835883140564,
-0.37349966168403625,
-0.0837038904428482,
-0.6497206091880798,
0.28248584270477295,
0.44228386878967285,
-0.2415226548910141,
0.38118061423301697,
-0.36658453941345215,
0.5324761271476746,
0.17844417691230774,
0.25796422362327576,
0.42733344435691833,
0.06842193752527237,
-0.48642316460609436,
-0.07739416509866714,
-0.5865491628646851,
-0.3831818103790283,
1.255164623260498,
0.7258829474449158,
0.8980386853218079,
0.10137494653463364,
0.7633734941482544,
0.09728056937456131,
-0.21681270003318787,
-0.8889390230178833,
0.5117573738098145,
-0.12872155010700226,
-0.5106907486915588,
-0.6437636017799377,
-0.3501226007938385,
-1.0308327674865723,
0.2430499941110611,
0.13881021738052368,
-0.9352844953536987,
0.2549481689929962,
-0.044027429074048996,
-0.8229389786720276,
0.32374075055122375,
-0.3889908194541931,
0.2928455173969269,
-0.13340748846530914,
-0.29733946919441223,
-0.35688161849975586,
-0.8619750738143921,
0.3237794041633606,
0.08616074174642563,
0.5547674298286438,
0.07606958597898483,
-0.21836385130882263,
0.4419405162334442,
-0.4826999008655548,
0.7477097511291504,
0.11095849424600601,
-0.39345791935920715,
0.07645386457443237,
0.32029199600219727,
0.3772784471511841,
-0.17409013211727142,
-0.1812174916267395,
-0.08511363714933395,
-0.12357017397880554,
-0.2664620876312256,
-0.6217014193534851,
0.4609954357147217,
-0.5933664441108704,
-0.40893444418907166,
-0.18190675973892212,
-0.726201593875885,
-0.044368792325258255,
0.2249416708946228,
0.0006981308688409626,
0.7428174018859863,
-0.308089941740036,
0.0658424124121666,
1.1606907844543457,
-0.2742886543273926,
0.5095021724700928,
0.521909773349762,
-0.4837314486503601,
-0.17489317059516907,
0.5195505023002625,
0.1089056134223938,
0.6302053332328796,
0.549365758895874,
-0.04743976145982742,
0.0033787894062697887,
-0.5538714528083801,
-0.020578540861606598,
0.21559935808181763,
-0.8064353466033936,
-0.037178587168455124,
-0.5338172316551208,
-0.3256116807460785,
-0.2818056344985962,
0.18569457530975342,
-0.5607033967971802,
-0.6196656227111816,
-0.35498905181884766,
-0.05876984819769859,
-0.007453528232872486,
1.1852892637252808,
-0.009901660494506359,
0.13948458433151245,
-0.7574243545532227,
0.3615255355834961,
0.2913654148578644,
0.3308090269565582,
0.15601606667041779,
-0.6855505704879761,
-0.6376118659973145,
-0.01572532206773758,
-0.40824973583221436,
-0.9127019643783569,
0.38954123854637146,
0.23479312658309937,
0.47971948981285095,
0.5402681827545166,
-0.19830350577831268,
0.542540431022644,
-0.6641986966133118,
0.8012921810150146,
0.1286144256591797,
-0.9878853559494019,
0.6424641609191895,
-0.15826518833637238,
0.3857277035713196,
0.12807220220565796,
0.40807756781578064,
-0.2642616331577301,
-0.14344994723796844,
-0.3890259861946106,
-0.8661128282546997,
0.936349630355835,
0.15658137202262878,
-0.07516354322433472,
0.2597716152667999,
0.5493738651275635,
0.0577969066798687,
-0.03578706830739975,
-0.7703724503517151,
-0.42196157574653625,
0.3239384591579437,
-0.10968874394893646,
-0.10593108832836151,
-0.41065436601638794,
0.04611575976014137,
-0.20001251995563507,
0.2820582389831543,
0.12009422481060028,
0.31111153960227966,
0.2772354781627655,
-0.2693082094192505,
-0.26555413007736206,
0.3891829252243042,
0.7708449959754944,
0.5765926241874695,
-0.22099897265434265,
-0.025186998769640923,
0.007402003277093172,
-0.35292768478393555,
0.1173659935593605,
0.00003246568303438835,
0.10762874782085419,
0.042126238346099854,
0.5738651156425476,
0.8284489512443542,
0.6385543942451477,
-0.4290735721588135,
0.17337676882743835,
0.03178836405277252,
-0.007380680181086063,
-0.09089982509613037,
-0.026136226952075958,
0.07465772330760956,
0.333108514547348,
0.6233046054840088,
-0.026858055964112282,
0.48082128167152405,
-0.6727055311203003,
0.303724467754364,
0.0013762630987912416,
-0.4431740343570709,
-0.34796807169914246,
0.5163412094116211,
-0.01651875674724579,
-0.22335109114646912,
0.5658817887306213,
0.1811983436346054,
-0.599166214466095,
0.7676820755004883,
0.44139590859413147,
0.5971971750259399,
-0.5661568641662598,
0.19997401535511017,
0.699935257434845,
0.4165385365486145,
-0.3846862316131592,
0.47023290395736694,
-0.11867041140794754,
-0.4942130446434021,
-0.5793212056159973,
-0.7686854600906372,
-0.2057497203350067,
0.09009163081645966,
-1.1037664413452148,
-0.08964289724826813,
-0.4434962868690491,
0.023219842463731766,
0.09965910017490387,
0.09301584959030151,
-0.6250802278518677,
0.07465086877346039,
0.5677829384803772,
0.8682572245597839,
-0.6066032648086548,
0.867632269859314,
0.30074411630630493,
-0.23626485466957092,
-0.7088888883590698,
-0.1171652302145958,
0.19558601081371307,
-0.7518365979194641,
0.8461683988571167,
0.20274408161640167,
-0.14141187071800232,
-0.043922290205955505,
-0.682157576084137,
-1.4433205127716064,
1.1574338674545288,
0.11237205564975739,
-0.8081383109092712,
-0.20628611743450165,
0.4238708019256592,
0.7557011842727661,
-0.56805819272995,
-0.04819982498884201,
0.69186931848526,
-0.03399551287293434,
0.3779813349246979,
-0.8907305002212524,
-0.114610955119133,
-0.07722030580043793,
0.3780466616153717,
0.27837520837783813,
-0.10421730577945709,
1.0668354034423828,
-0.7092161178588867,
-0.5171324014663696,
0.5409870743751526,
0.7195959687232971,
0.18940545618534088,
0.14289920032024384,
0.5395720601081848,
0.6689897179603577,
0.6729132533073425,
0.00709271477535367,
0.9481955170631409,
-0.21041032671928406,
0.4170786142349243,
1.3523335456848145,
-0.28359255194664,
0.9750404953956604,
0.35891449451446533,
-0.4042629897594452,
0.6092334985733032,
0.4438459575176239,
0.379792720079422,
0.37599778175354004,
0.593178391456604,
-0.04883171245455742,
-0.14445807039737701,
0.06807348132133484,
-0.30655810236930847,
0.12301193922758102,
0.8604827523231506,
-0.734645664691925,
-0.18101516366004944,
0.1508498191833496,
-0.07747949659824371,
0.04392620921134949,
-0.5644979476928711,
0.7825789451599121,
0.2783573567867279,
-0.6743066310882568,
0.3787282407283783,
-0.2001367062330246,
0.19314324855804443,
-0.519672691822052,
-0.038331061601638794,
-0.25948646664619446,
0.2964513301849365,
0.17971041798591614,
-0.8609281778335571,
0.19224320352077484,
-0.26802363991737366,
-0.4607768654823303,
-0.13491939008235931,
0.5901626944541931,
-0.5833768844604492,
-0.5421062707901001,
0.5828362703323364,
0.24446195363998413,
0.06329422444105148,
0.12384055554866791,
-0.7534864544868469,
0.35967525839805603,
-0.05984126776456833,
-0.33544671535491943,
0.007400026544928551,
0.4204128086566925,
0.19560079276561737,
0.8586506843566895,
0.36446613073349,
-0.14581811428070068,
0.33506911993026733,
0.25403255224227905,
0.7759004831314087,
-0.6441183686256409,
-0.15566319227218628,
-0.7203866243362427,
0.4705926477909088,
0.013787581585347652,
0.1036369651556015,
0.428933709859848,
0.35286933183670044,
0.6630289554595947,
-0.08435353636741638,
0.5370790362358093,
0.20468021929264069,
0.7223213911056519,
-0.4111741781234741,
0.37357085943222046,
-0.5022299289703369,
0.5071371793746948,
-0.4478358328342438,
-0.6547553539276123,
-0.4281395375728607,
0.21127936244010925,
-0.1736370474100113,
-0.04820605739951134,
0.6773177981376648,
0.8222825527191162,
0.31977739930152893,
-0.051411222666502,
0.5196314454078674,
0.3734016716480255,
0.0192360058426857,
0.8889818787574768,
0.7057168483734131,
-0.6525164842605591,
0.6926981806755066,
-0.20078085362911224,
-0.19096973538398743,
-0.2372792512178421,
-0.4932404160499573,
-0.7423413395881653,
-0.7740324139595032,
-0.0075241196900606155,
-0.24022483825683594,
-0.16249114274978638,
0.7976433038711548,
0.6824929118156433,
-0.8538317084312439,
-0.44699499011039734,
-0.038429856300354004,
0.3265557289123535,
-0.13048358261585236,
-0.1768074780702591,
0.20271509885787964,
-0.5147161483764648,
-0.5352689623832703,
0.35785195231437683,
0.5285453200340271,
-0.08643180131912231,
-0.38916730880737305,
-0.023439757525920868,
-0.23016953468322754,
0.31091028451919556,
0.6856390237808228,
0.5297577977180481,
-1.0303454399108887,
0.03980375826358795,
0.2879558503627777,
-0.19774466753005981,
-0.17000247538089752,
1.0129132270812988,
-0.5578176379203796,
0.7162206768989563,
0.5340238809585571,
0.36093661189079285,
0.18812955915927887,
-0.23379456996917725,
0.8713674545288086,
-0.6368845701217651,
-0.025508396327495575,
-0.0002953619114123285,
0.5136348605155945,
0.011372190900146961,
-0.46995872259140015,
0.6047653555870056,
-0.005938866175711155,
-0.5590341687202454,
-0.8180904984474182,
0.5917378664016724,
-0.9491449594497681,
-0.5039353966712952,
0.8631722927093506,
-0.12924744188785553,
-0.04817634075880051,
-0.2087765336036682,
-0.012862724252045155,
0.2905125319957733,
-0.1480335295200348,
0.5931856632232666,
0.7107148766517639,
-0.14130473136901855,
-0.3862273693084717,
-0.49983203411102295,
0.32967454195022583,
0.3952649235725403,
-0.33814358711242676,
0.018057750537991524,
0.3908049464225769,
0.037126101553440094,
0.4484805166721344,
0.20739960670471191,
-0.3920864462852478,
0.014880276285111904,
-0.35360684990882874,
0.09893576800823212,
0.3011736273765564,
-0.5377311110496521,
-0.8381765484809875,
0.31103232502937317,
-0.16562308371067047,
0.13225460052490234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17382v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17382v1
|
ReMoDetect: Reward Models Recognize Aligned LLM's Generations
| 2024-05-27T17:38:33 | 2024-05-27T17:38:33 |
Hyunseok Lee, Jihoon Tack, Jinwoo Shin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
The remarkable capabilities and easy accessibility of large language models
(LLMs) have significantly increased societal risks (e.g., fake news
generation), necessitating the development of LLM-generated text (LGT)
detection methods for safe usage. However, detecting LGTs is challenging due to
the vast number of LLMs, making it impractical to account for each LLM
individually; hence, it is crucial to identify the common characteristics
shared by these models. In this paper, we draw attention to a common feature of
recent powerful LLMs, namely the alignment training, i.e., training LLMs to
generate human-preferable texts. Our key finding is that as these aligned LLMs
are trained to maximize the human preferences, they generate texts with higher
estimated preferences even than human-written texts; thus, such texts are
easily detected by using the reward model (i.e., an LLM trained to model human
preference distribution). Based on this finding, we propose two training
schemes to further improve the detection ability of the reward model, namely
(i) continual preference fine-tuning to make the reward model prefer aligned
LGTs even further and (ii) reward modeling of Human/LLM mixed texts (a
rephrased texts from human-written texts using aligned LLMs), which serves as a
median preference text corpus between LGTs and human-written texts to learn the
decision boundary better. We provide an extensive evaluation by considering six
text domains across twelve aligned LLMs, where our method demonstrates
state-of-the-art results. Code is available at
https://github.com/hyunseoklee-ai/reward_llm_detect.
|
[
-0.103331558406353,
-0.30635297298431396,
0.7193208336830139,
-0.2136303037405014,
-0.35068437457084656,
0.15779326856136322,
-0.330655574798584,
-0.5538411736488342,
0.1456833779811859,
0.4351748824119568,
-0.7216067910194397,
-0.6018133163452148,
-0.7314848899841309,
0.1742447167634964,
-0.23943234980106354,
0.9843948483467102,
-0.362117737531662,
-0.08061729371547699,
-0.455751895904541,
-0.1753426492214203,
-0.32207340002059937,
-0.6103562116622925,
-0.3525111675262451,
-0.8089532852172852,
0.6619036793708801,
0.2683736979961395,
0.43951770663261414,
0.860295295715332,
0.45971837639808655,
0.27335116267204285,
-0.05801019445061684,
0.319831520318985,
-0.5278036594390869,
0.29401424527168274,
-0.021748432889580727,
-0.37453493475914,
-0.3000146448612213,
0.2498871088027954,
0.5204336643218994,
0.15725941956043243,
-0.05392373725771904,
-0.0210323017090559,
0.22546282410621643,
0.6998598575592041,
-0.7550562620162964,
-0.25605154037475586,
-0.7514690160751343,
-0.06424421817064285,
-0.30403369665145874,
-0.4407901167869568,
-0.5507128834724426,
-0.40842920541763306,
-0.016643214970827103,
-0.5588259696960449,
0.005726595409214497,
0.05336141213774681,
1.0415761470794678,
0.37140125036239624,
-0.5132692456245422,
-0.39535602927207947,
-0.3012804090976715,
1.0215575695037842,
-0.39635950326919556,
0.39750611782073975,
0.22804105281829834,
0.04922852665185928,
-0.2394801527261734,
-0.4387008547782898,
-0.5283119082450867,
-0.14974148571491241,
-0.2356444001197815,
0.0408720001578331,
-0.012034074403345585,
-0.07208921760320663,
-0.11221013218164444,
0.2726878523826599,
-0.4696930944919586,
0.5674727559089661,
0.1965777426958084,
-0.3643297851085663,
0.674217700958252,
0.3270922303199768,
0.3297179043292999,
-0.24368637800216675,
-0.7706965208053589,
-0.21570470929145813,
-0.7840662598609924,
0.2395811229944229,
0.5643749833106995,
0.16359063982963562,
-0.14527051150798798,
0.4150838851928711,
-0.13765962421894073,
0.8849013447761536,
0.22160743176937103,
-0.45326024293899536,
0.35549402236938477,
-0.2208135426044464,
-0.12264267355203629,
0.10055045783519745,
0.9397880434989929,
0.47849249839782715,
0.32358384132385254,
-0.07079323381185532,
-0.4574097692966461,
0.11317004263401031,
0.3198544383049011,
-0.5931621789932251,
0.09735392779111862,
0.007468859199434519,
-0.5994948744773865,
-0.699059009552002,
-0.22224631905555725,
-0.3032788932323456,
-0.7436467409133911,
-0.4631642699241638,
0.28068476915359497,
-0.3672066032886505,
-0.12897828221321106,
0.4074372947216034,
-0.04072948172688484,
0.43653756380081177,
0.17642472684383392,
-1.206939458847046,
-0.12749511003494263,
0.9899711608886719,
0.6666192412376404,
-0.5800293684005737,
-0.25668269395828247,
-0.3817763328552246,
0.05478231608867645,
0.11691553890705109,
1.1855380535125732,
-0.5378010869026184,
-0.11938945949077606,
0.11098355054855347,
-0.07860250771045685,
-0.08599194884300232,
-0.5311020016670227,
0.9070862531661987,
-0.46538469195365906,
0.22806695103645325,
-0.20857839286327362,
-0.8363016843795776,
0.3212640881538391,
0.5790418386459351,
-0.5634396076202393,
0.7826259732246399,
-0.03421621024608612,
-1.087217092514038,
0.7643465995788574,
-0.17812985181808472,
-0.14518097043037415,
0.004847967531532049,
-0.219996839761734,
-0.7923282384872437,
-0.16687804460525513,
0.22353462874889374,
0.5219627618789673,
-0.16260358691215515,
0.5179520845413208,
-0.2547088861465454,
-0.4666502773761749,
0.42890995740890503,
-0.5432893633842468,
0.5687869787216187,
0.07733763009309769,
-0.1626545935869217,
0.4734245538711548,
-0.5036675333976746,
-0.04064657539129257,
0.0352085717022419,
-0.6470286250114441,
-0.4972870349884033,
0.055855121463537216,
0.030943075194954872,
-0.01618148572742939,
0.5706849098205566,
-0.5035097002983093,
0.2929331362247467,
-0.3084958791732788,
0.22355610132217407,
1.1702898740768433,
-0.2586793601512909,
0.4989374577999115,
-0.5451472401618958,
0.4663359820842743,
0.04562748968601227,
-0.07637932896614075,
-0.030889656394720078,
-0.09441540390253067,
-0.6001970767974854,
-0.4843961000442505,
0.23072896897792816,
0.5213704705238342,
-0.4498140215873718,
0.7741502523422241,
-0.3332803249359131,
-0.4514791667461395,
-0.5461466908454895,
0.1539703756570816,
0.4724911153316498,
0.3251868188381195,
0.13872529566287994,
-0.042076755315065384,
-0.6420647501945496,
-1.0327011346817017,
-0.7763040661811829,
-0.10257870703935623,
-0.08472038060426712,
0.1527690440416336,
0.31942564249038696,
-0.22698111832141876,
0.8747527003288269,
-0.3983471095561981,
-0.17652186751365662,
-0.23961958289146423,
-0.013064105994999409,
0.05358373001217842,
0.3754529356956482,
0.30761224031448364,
-0.7635740637779236,
-0.43567970395088196,
-0.13124436140060425,
-0.7233409881591797,
-0.2070675641298294,
-0.2096974104642868,
-0.12215977907180786,
0.09525098651647568,
0.49344635009765625,
-0.2431972473859787,
0.1477264016866684,
0.422116219997406,
-0.4125266671180725,
0.4080941081047058,
-0.04584290087223053,
0.06057974696159363,
-1.219638705253601,
-0.07943613827228546,
0.21437948942184448,
-0.44204774498939514,
-0.47363564372062683,
-0.13683247566223145,
0.33121320605278015,
0.5048376321792603,
-0.26487961411476135,
0.6574943661689758,
-0.47355031967163086,
0.023960035294294357,
-0.4959369897842407,
0.23182891309261322,
-0.15644608438014984,
0.35441628098487854,
0.23707550764083862,
0.7853195071220398,
0.13274385035037994,
-0.3639315962791443,
0.31954148411750793,
0.3105795085430145,
-0.543379008769989,
0.7267251014709473,
-0.4127146005630493,
0.0707673579454422,
-0.06864399462938309,
0.22355881333351135,
-1.0172897577285767,
-0.3575049340724945,
0.27480795979499817,
-0.4263856112957001,
0.36592772603034973,
0.08028095960617065,
-0.2105274498462677,
-0.14216123521327972,
-0.5722583532333374,
0.48220229148864746,
0.4417189657688141,
-0.8667389154434204,
0.36047855019569397,
0.4614671468734741,
0.1132359728217125,
-0.9488787055015564,
-0.395233154296875,
-0.09911805391311646,
-0.4687349796295166,
-0.6264211535453796,
0.5537275075912476,
0.16207969188690186,
0.0489158108830452,
-0.11454126983880997,
-0.09650102257728577,
0.2282930165529251,
0.37607240676879883,
0.34584319591522217,
0.346157431602478,
0.10157589614391327,
0.13264764845371246,
-0.005976601503789425,
-0.3807012140750885,
-0.09500101208686829,
-0.21501357853412628,
0.6101399660110474,
-0.06477036327123642,
-0.28229549527168274,
-0.4263235628604889,
0.03518590331077576,
0.3250393867492676,
-0.2190680205821991,
0.823173463344574,
0.6113985180854797,
-0.21999166905879974,
0.013026746921241283,
-0.4678305983543396,
-0.14855694770812988,
-0.49629971385002136,
0.2854202687740326,
-0.05318917706608772,
-1.2118998765945435,
0.30761900544166565,
0.009611635468900204,
0.04760478436946869,
0.24571870267391205,
0.8053639531135559,
0.05380059406161308,
0.910000741481781,
0.6247926354408264,
-0.35772350430488586,
0.7661257982254028,
0.24091358482837677,
0.12549544870853424,
-0.962429940700531,
-0.3854997158050537,
-0.3533894717693329,
-0.5576414465904236,
-0.6242378354072571,
0.057248104363679886,
0.29947519302368164,
-0.14230163395404816,
-0.2777409851551056,
0.16637957096099854,
-0.759649395942688,
0.727418065071106,
0.5695876479148865,
0.22533641755580902,
0.2429502308368683,
-0.02053401619195938,
-0.08979977667331696,
-0.1177714616060257,
-0.367198646068573,
-0.7796850800514221,
1.2428393363952637,
0.3409503996372223,
0.861705482006073,
-0.14959211647510529,
1.188208818435669,
0.24159827828407288,
0.4513770043849945,
-0.7751237154006958,
0.3826359808444977,
-0.16452491283416748,
-0.2521771788597107,
-0.0991787537932396,
-0.34445273876190186,
-1.0080114603042603,
0.03901182860136032,
-0.4092182219028473,
-0.7799332141876221,
-0.004970382433384657,
0.2821796238422394,
-0.3608313798904419,
0.36637648940086365,
-0.4963710904121399,
0.9955839514732361,
-0.4334394931793213,
-0.48492303490638733,
0.0726335421204567,
-0.534480631351471,
0.4588095247745514,
0.0920511856675148,
-0.1855359673500061,
-0.23222321271896362,
0.012105266563594341,
0.8878522515296936,
0.0666334331035614,
0.8417485356330872,
0.08966623991727829,
-0.2695026993751526,
-0.01351739838719368,
-0.17180076241493225,
0.5622970461845398,
-0.029386186972260475,
0.015355395153164864,
-0.1718098223209381,
-0.40026646852493286,
-0.2715667486190796,
-0.17832079529762268,
0.8191705346107483,
-0.8033624887466431,
-0.6056073904037476,
-0.5110374689102173,
-0.7575383186340332,
-0.029394173994660378,
0.10272781550884247,
0.4566479027271271,
0.14465826749801636,
-0.20767174661159515,
0.04669541120529175,
0.6694189310073853,
-0.2190522849559784,
0.17045234143733978,
0.25947627425193787,
-0.12315098941326141,
-0.4485827088356018,
0.7304283976554871,
-0.40739282965660095,
0.30755698680877686,
0.4599417746067047,
0.1302671581506729,
-0.4146747589111328,
-0.5154092311859131,
-0.2452637255191803,
0.14891980588436127,
-0.5266233086585999,
-0.45501792430877686,
-0.524105429649353,
-0.19411775469779968,
-0.14947034418582916,
-0.4877470135688782,
-0.21718622744083405,
-0.10961287468671799,
-0.37740054726600647,
-0.2770226001739502,
0.3796021044254303,
0.6242623925209045,
-0.03892333805561066,
0.44094908237457275,
-0.7277738451957703,
0.27856776118278503,
0.2807086110115051,
0.3702038526535034,
-0.1937992125749588,
-0.5348016023635864,
-0.1562434285879135,
0.12720203399658203,
-0.489043653011322,
-0.6216875910758972,
0.3992021083831787,
-0.22789321839809418,
0.5454221367835999,
0.4176104962825775,
0.025925328955054283,
0.24705639481544495,
-0.31462356448173523,
0.6599995493888855,
0.24002262949943542,
-0.8080859780311584,
0.16418075561523438,
-0.2960662543773651,
0.05494236946105957,
0.5768525004386902,
0.27255526185035706,
-0.640344500541687,
-0.2658753991127014,
-0.46212244033813477,
-0.7150827050209045,
0.689140796661377,
0.011653618887066841,
0.014529384672641754,
-0.017516247928142548,
0.47832876443862915,
0.18343205749988556,
0.10527843236923218,
-1.1449264287948608,
-0.024154668673872948,
-0.010715372860431671,
-0.8282173275947571,
0.13143420219421387,
-0.5030808448791504,
-0.11125104874372482,
0.09935875236988068,
0.5810994505882263,
-0.04967780038714409,
0.17116016149520874,
-0.029147470369935036,
-0.03299380838871002,
-0.12376762181520462,
0.4844791293144226,
0.7002454400062561,
0.1260455697774887,
-0.33412912487983704,
0.26881662011146545,
-0.24063506722450256,
-0.36317551136016846,
0.5686304569244385,
0.026156514883041382,
-0.3168197274208069,
-0.3711252808570862,
0.4333707094192505,
0.8829364776611328,
0.19331517815589905,
-0.6683549880981445,
0.5738809108734131,
-0.06527271121740341,
-0.1976252943277359,
-0.24693040549755096,
0.23512710630893707,
0.2798873782157898,
0.19810131192207336,
0.04599932208657265,
-0.03239061310887337,
-0.10223192721605301,
-0.3805750906467438,
0.25286611914634705,
0.8085100054740906,
-0.4951001703739166,
-0.11353911459445953,
0.559720516204834,
0.3031790256500244,
-0.3543611168861389,
0.4837506115436554,
-0.3853854835033417,
-0.9505583643913269,
0.4300227761268616,
0.6036144495010376,
0.9691975116729736,
-0.10871532559394836,
0.17215146124362946,
0.25753238797187805,
0.18528051674365997,
-0.23209021985530853,
0.09515754133462906,
0.031270720064640045,
-1.250106692314148,
-0.10768672823905945,
-0.6218191981315613,
-0.12775816023349762,
0.128767728805542,
-0.574222207069397,
0.4161064326763153,
-0.13731101155281067,
-0.021218953654170036,
-0.024357300251722336,
-0.16512519121170044,
-0.3671007752418518,
-0.12182223051786423,
0.37188073992729187,
0.5458750128746033,
-1.0073285102844238,
0.7697852849960327,
0.5683503150939941,
-0.030333226546645164,
-0.7820904850959778,
0.030440060421824455,
0.24390219151973724,
-1.0916742086410522,
0.5846681594848633,
0.5219606161117554,
-0.15865470468997955,
-0.12328242510557175,
-0.6389263272285461,
-0.506172239780426,
1.2748321294784546,
0.28168103098869324,
-0.5735066533088684,
0.007922062650322914,
0.15550164878368378,
0.387781023979187,
-0.5788936018943787,
0.12197290360927582,
0.7495608925819397,
0.4056290090084076,
-0.17633949220180511,
-0.7449212670326233,
0.0016842982731759548,
0.015567143447697163,
-0.24117445945739746,
0.6703349351882935,
-0.5470043420791626,
0.7562901377677917,
-0.0098238131031394,
-0.21520741283893585,
0.2610360383987427,
0.42740482091903687,
0.7647411823272705,
0.5686109066009521,
0.6460773348808289,
0.6484391689300537,
0.8175724148750305,
-0.12530723214149475,
0.9232973456382751,
-0.17952759563922882,
0.4371127784252167,
0.9276089668273926,
-0.4088284969329834,
0.7119966149330139,
0.618564784526825,
0.1158180981874466,
0.4582543671131134,
0.8247779607772827,
0.07457727193832397,
0.6164541244506836,
0.2528854012489319,
-0.30512019991874695,
-0.6765747666358948,
-0.29806098341941833,
-0.22332367300987244,
0.30016595125198364,
0.1352103352546692,
-0.5550504326820374,
-0.08817902207374573,
-0.041059158742427826,
0.025136182084679604,
0.3699124753475189,
-0.24954678118228912,
0.770653247833252,
-0.06042018160223961,
-0.7066255211830139,
0.5997948050498962,
-0.03023282065987587,
1.1947572231292725,
-0.534037172794342,
0.24715061485767365,
-0.14800086617469788,
0.380029559135437,
-0.24675697088241577,
-1.0019932985305786,
-0.05800505727529526,
0.09175564348697662,
-0.2934172451496124,
-0.40988773107528687,
0.9622426629066467,
-0.66279137134552,
-0.19813767075538635,
0.17485256493091583,
0.28465408086776733,
-0.20442797243595123,
0.05818603187799454,
-0.5415527820587158,
-0.03204715624451637,
0.39200007915496826,
-0.1959458589553833,
0.5520584583282471,
0.3007947504520416,
-0.10792716592550278,
0.6889510750770569,
0.6090771555900574,
-0.12207505851984024,
-0.07995739579200745,
-0.10097093135118484,
0.7356483340263367,
-0.6584004759788513,
-0.44832858443260193,
-1.0666669607162476,
0.3497292697429657,
-0.3005697727203369,
-0.2638917565345764,
0.4689252972602844,
0.5157178640365601,
0.8381137251853943,
-0.04055843502283096,
0.6381010413169861,
0.31643491983413696,
0.5364290475845337,
-0.7661304473876953,
0.6542145609855652,
-0.6131656765937805,
0.4767542779445648,
-0.12818977236747742,
-0.6574884653091431,
-0.16147923469543457,
0.5569104552268982,
-0.3403555750846863,
-0.06917205452919006,
0.4284839332103729,
0.6855325102806091,
-0.13811609148979187,
-0.12464889138936996,
0.06936195492744446,
-0.31272444128990173,
0.37880247831344604,
0.9465897083282471,
1.1513950824737549,
-0.22485214471817017,
0.41031450033187866,
-0.027293585240840912,
-0.05269066244363785,
-0.32446756958961487,
-1.035414457321167,
-0.842860221862793,
-0.47348448634147644,
-0.17067790031433105,
-0.2002299726009369,
-0.0830078199505806,
1.0295131206512451,
0.33183974027633667,
-0.563285231590271,
-0.1757848560810089,
-0.08394306898117065,
0.46402105689048767,
-0.021742848679423332,
-0.14187560975551605,
0.392113596200943,
-0.25563445687294006,
-0.5482825040817261,
0.0434369258582592,
0.25567325949668884,
0.13993768393993378,
-0.05293021351099014,
-0.4110903739929199,
-0.22697673738002777,
-0.01079969760030508,
0.18565624952316284,
0.09381639212369919,
-0.7272771000862122,
-0.6059815287590027,
0.10618947446346283,
-0.4327934980392456,
0.14278677105903625,
0.9625412821769714,
-0.6718000173568726,
0.2268189787864685,
0.47220391035079956,
0.8399125337600708,
0.10938823968172073,
0.12113571166992188,
0.6174758076667786,
-0.7992739677429199,
0.1699398159980774,
0.10036186873912811,
0.5491355061531067,
0.5196496248245239,
-0.47168365120887756,
0.4541669189929962,
0.07259251177310944,
-0.8394953012466431,
-0.8537046313285828,
0.5322129726409912,
-1.0406121015548706,
-0.08965718746185303,
1.1552013158798218,
-0.05202515050768852,
-0.2612771987915039,
0.05553855374455452,
-0.27855417132377625,
0.2755872309207916,
-0.3837709128856659,
0.8344448208808899,
0.6920056939125061,
-0.023238928988575935,
0.07025063037872314,
0.0689685195684433,
0.7249828577041626,
0.6113347411155701,
-0.7878323197364807,
0.2599450349807739,
0.4734513461589813,
0.39294806122779846,
0.07921826839447021,
0.5051386952400208,
0.10292964428663254,
0.2562367916107178,
-0.5357798337936401,
0.2726021409034729,
-0.17913201451301575,
-0.09568685293197632,
-0.4213278591632843,
-0.03649740293622017,
0.26688089966773987,
-0.2043091356754303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17381v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17381v2
|
Various Lengths, Constant Speed: Efficient Language Modeling with Lightning Attention
| 2024-05-27T17:38:13 | 2024-06-20T09:12:42 |
Zhen Qin, Weigao Sun, Dong Li, Xuyang Shen, Weixuan Sun, Yiran Zhong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present Lightning Attention, the first linear attention implementation
that maintains a constant training speed for various sequence lengths under
fixed memory consumption. Due to the issue with cumulative summation operations
(cumsum), previous linear attention implementations cannot achieve their
theoretical advantage in a casual setting. However, this issue can be
effectively solved by utilizing different attention calculation strategies to
compute the different parts of attention. Specifically, we split the attention
calculation into intra-blocks and inter-blocks and use conventional attention
computation for intra-blocks and linear attention kernel tricks for
inter-blocks. This eliminates the need for cumsum in the linear attention
calculation. Furthermore, a tiling technique is adopted through both forward
and backward procedures to take full advantage of the GPU hardware. To enhance
accuracy while preserving efficacy, we introduce TransNormerLLM (TNL), a new
architecture that is tailored to our lightning attention. We conduct rigorous
testing on standard and self-collected datasets with varying model sizes and
sequence lengths. TNL is notably more efficient than other language models. In
addition, benchmark results indicate that TNL performs on par with
state-of-the-art LLMs utilizing conventional transformer structures. The source
code is released at github.com/OpenNLPLab/TransnormerLLM.
|
[
-0.10067197680473328,
-0.9828835129737854,
0.4608617126941681,
0.6718096137046814,
-0.22693032026290894,
0.16845084726810455,
-0.29181280732154846,
-0.5240932106971741,
0.0953035056591034,
0.274619996547699,
-0.5004774928092957,
-0.24408486485481262,
-0.42976072430610657,
-0.05287669971585274,
-0.621152400970459,
0.5981220006942749,
0.06815726310014725,
-0.1068599671125412,
0.12614406645298004,
-0.2853982746601105,
-0.3623732924461365,
-0.23416762053966522,
-0.5725387334823608,
-0.2120271772146225,
0.9508400559425354,
0.40350618958473206,
0.7431361675262451,
0.7802110910415649,
0.7513689398765564,
0.1790926158428192,
-0.15454405546188354,
0.04650295898318291,
-0.8063227534294128,
-0.12176502496004105,
-0.12139381468296051,
-0.16288799047470093,
-0.41773220896720886,
-0.1714988350868225,
0.8174882531166077,
0.6702910661697388,
0.0011359781492501497,
0.3055594861507416,
-0.11503049731254578,
0.7696272134780884,
-0.5591962337493896,
-0.37240445613861084,
-0.7644954919815063,
0.30289608240127563,
-0.3066428005695343,
-0.12068426609039307,
-0.48000064492225647,
-0.4095537066459656,
0.19347339868545532,
-0.17444337904453278,
0.19508987665176392,
0.3273884356021881,
0.6779581308364868,
0.43207743763923645,
0.005007324740290642,
-0.07043064385652542,
-0.965560793876648,
0.8486778140068054,
-0.5496311187744141,
0.7129167914390564,
-0.08554341644048691,
0.1746816784143448,
0.3882371485233307,
-0.9359354376792908,
-0.2086367905139923,
-0.26019352674484253,
0.1907413750886917,
-0.07085355371236801,
-0.29060879349708557,
0.12796539068222046,
0.38298094272613525,
0.5859113335609436,
-0.6521373987197876,
-0.0011831021402031183,
-0.2642795741558075,
0.026332346722483635,
0.4588265120983124,
0.3377603590488434,
0.25041496753692627,
0.3973464071750641,
-0.36204877495765686,
0.21807153522968292,
-0.7784125804901123,
-0.051485463976860046,
0.09444459527730942,
0.20067349076271057,
-0.3328911066055298,
0.481704980134964,
0.2279508411884308,
0.9288251399993896,
0.10288688540458679,
-0.010463492013514042,
0.006855470594018698,
-0.2568630278110504,
-0.3218105733394623,
0.06663095951080322,
0.6844125986099243,
0.08354953676462173,
0.4512730836868286,
-0.5789018869400024,
-0.006130811758339405,
0.0014384565874934196,
0.5205925107002258,
-0.6490667462348938,
-0.11192774772644043,
0.14155171811580658,
-0.3585565686225891,
-0.1231679916381836,
-0.3899521827697754,
-0.7061413526535034,
-0.010109318420290947,
-0.3399120271205902,
0.18434661626815796,
-0.46341603994369507,
-0.01325854193419218,
0.34880372881889343,
0.4476777911186218,
0.11867287009954453,
0.10360518842935562,
-1.039496898651123,
0.521129310131073,
0.6774585247039795,
1.0957248210906982,
-0.44676831364631653,
-0.12319003790616989,
-0.7397964000701904,
-0.06823296844959259,
-0.24404415488243103,
0.4602257013320923,
-0.5315268039703369,
-0.2475949376821518,
-0.168613001704216,
-0.36201924085617065,
-0.20634116232395172,
-0.22300449013710022,
0.5082578659057617,
-0.43289902806282043,
0.07358548045158386,
0.43777716159820557,
-0.6307610869407654,
0.060501616448163986,
0.07730359584093094,
-0.5217416882514954,
1.0310876369476318,
0.19683678448200226,
-0.9105039238929749,
-0.3221976161003113,
-0.6486554145812988,
-0.7185753583908081,
0.30219948291778564,
0.14342153072357178,
-0.5079628825187683,
0.5026245713233948,
-0.09728609025478363,
0.24594362080097198,
-0.4766198396682739,
0.2585029602050781,
0.009363374672830105,
-0.5115513801574707,
0.1622370034456253,
-0.4179134666919708,
0.5941842198371887,
0.3631085157394409,
-0.3821369707584381,
0.23267143964767456,
-0.6801271438598633,
-0.06516072154045105,
0.012728853151202202,
-0.22139273583889008,
-0.1501450538635254,
-0.08560588955879211,
0.3487617075443268,
0.09826655685901642,
0.3243979513645172,
-0.4243846833705902,
0.07001324743032455,
-0.5735157132148743,
0.058721575886011124,
0.6196251511573792,
-0.2078932821750641,
0.4371453523635864,
-0.09711664170026779,
0.7656097412109375,
-0.32794538140296936,
0.5008236169815063,
-0.33980807662010193,
-0.4301178753376007,
-0.9274634122848511,
-0.10591696202754974,
0.3058934509754181,
0.4770638346672058,
-0.5447666049003601,
0.2492142766714096,
-0.37878063321113586,
-0.46865636110305786,
-0.7555832862854004,
0.18221235275268555,
0.7632612586021423,
0.4064125418663025,
0.19922378659248352,
-0.20672361552715302,
-0.6451264023780823,
-0.8137698769569397,
-0.5158525109291077,
0.0886000320315361,
0.11580310016870499,
0.4007488191127777,
-0.012356434017419815,
-0.2591274380683899,
0.972762942314148,
-0.5863316655158997,
0.05197327211499214,
-0.5983484387397766,
-0.012354932725429535,
0.2581181526184082,
0.2734951674938202,
0.632961094379425,
-0.52972412109375,
-0.8578615188598633,
0.016971150413155556,
-0.4401336908340454,
-0.2701374888420105,
-0.27922502160072327,
0.02441711351275444,
0.025208262726664543,
0.44655802845954895,
-0.40889376401901245,
0.31000879406929016,
0.6665429472923279,
-0.20789852738380432,
0.38593238592147827,
0.0064554717391729355,
-0.2799271047115326,
-0.856314480304718,
0.3430105149745941,
0.2792694866657257,
-0.5874287486076355,
-1.1422927379608154,
0.11761012673377991,
0.35707056522369385,
-0.017988210543990135,
-0.8342867493629456,
0.7101427316665649,
-0.5144860148429871,
-0.03953847289085388,
-0.36537784337997437,
0.12282953411340714,
-0.21159180998802185,
0.6725888252258301,
-0.07285399734973907,
0.7375765442848206,
0.5403407216072083,
-0.7243112921714783,
0.5025244355201721,
-0.18964798748493195,
-0.2610795497894287,
0.13397665321826935,
-0.7740182280540466,
0.43653610348701477,
-0.0374685600399971,
-0.4612681567668915,
-0.7656602263450623,
0.2274472713470459,
0.05448238551616669,
-0.19665218889713287,
0.48966196179389954,
0.049711812287569046,
-0.619015097618103,
-0.49276790022850037,
-0.26417380571365356,
0.5221381783485413,
0.5831600427627563,
-0.2855975031852722,
0.4923688471317291,
0.4155591130256653,
-0.1146429106593132,
-0.2597801089286804,
-0.7323627471923828,
0.20386748015880585,
-0.24937403202056885,
-0.5765371918678284,
0.27940255403518677,
-0.33500608801841736,
-0.37411820888519287,
-0.13160230219364166,
0.01420463714748621,
0.10263478755950928,
0.2162804901599884,
-0.010919108055531979,
0.21230405569076538,
-0.14562354981899261,
0.10829088091850281,
-0.3822023272514343,
-0.21845874190330505,
-0.2354818433523178,
-0.39521756768226624,
0.9224482178688049,
-0.18070118129253387,
-0.1765054166316986,
-0.43354907631874084,
0.15882539749145508,
0.4349662959575653,
-0.14802363514900208,
0.6049923300743103,
0.534484326839447,
-0.2877087891101837,
-0.07761751115322113,
-0.754594624042511,
-0.13360324501991272,
-0.4507369101047516,
0.3315238058567047,
-0.1938009262084961,
-1.0683637857437134,
0.467214435338974,
0.12306582182645798,
0.28571757674217224,
0.22299888730049133,
0.45274385809898376,
0.13024303317070007,
0.8623282313346863,
0.9927545189857483,
-0.5922505855560303,
0.7262492775917053,
0.08952885866165161,
0.33886051177978516,
-0.8336672186851501,
-0.07325989753007889,
-0.5012591481208801,
-0.4807127118110657,
-0.2897712290287018,
-0.3552500307559967,
0.2661283612251282,
-0.18065494298934937,
0.024799909442663193,
0.42570003867149353,
-0.4054885506629944,
0.5506720542907715,
0.14367391169071198,
-0.13287292420864105,
0.2009086012840271,
0.0698179230093956,
-0.047022558748722076,
-0.3498515188694,
-0.8334598541259766,
-0.07305508852005005,
0.9791927337646484,
0.6360986828804016,
1.2219762802124023,
-0.02373986877501011,
0.334536075592041,
0.14159902930259705,
0.44417431950569153,
-0.7504674792289734,
0.5117146372795105,
-0.24724413454532623,
-0.3043312430381775,
-0.21092386543750763,
-0.6936824917793274,
-0.7668781280517578,
0.1142568290233612,
0.268846720457077,
-0.668515145778656,
-0.24657563865184784,
0.21754927933216095,
-0.3862130641937256,
0.2670121490955353,
-0.5218861699104309,
0.6781980991363525,
-0.4905530512332916,
-0.6786765456199646,
-0.33006250858306885,
-0.7852933406829834,
0.5232061147689819,
-0.11635389178991318,
0.12066050618886948,
-0.06300736963748932,
0.004030212294310331,
0.5232107639312744,
-0.1579609513282776,
0.7300190925598145,
0.10925401002168655,
-0.17317788302898407,
-0.01927546225488186,
-0.027788212522864342,
0.40871015191078186,
-0.07001643627882004,
0.08744252473115921,
-0.11520197242498398,
-0.8814989924430847,
-0.2850266695022583,
-0.3384912312030792,
0.8305649757385254,
-0.47309228777885437,
-0.4396684765815735,
-0.3444001078605652,
-0.9475877285003662,
-0.11296529322862625,
0.1756170243024826,
0.1348761022090912,
0.5774515867233276,
-0.2758260667324066,
0.25161972641944885,
1.155712604522705,
-0.1428653597831726,
0.8196017146110535,
0.6119918823242188,
-0.4905392825603485,
-0.2656366229057312,
0.6290509104728699,
-0.1266263723373413,
0.36054468154907227,
0.6211627721786499,
0.10493603348731995,
-0.3363109230995178,
-0.44978204369544983,
-0.18602310121059418,
0.44870859384536743,
-0.33674538135528564,
-0.1061629131436348,
-0.8914691805839539,
-0.368010938167572,
-0.29160451889038086,
-0.04700273275375366,
-0.6069015264511108,
-0.5239166617393494,
-0.22090671956539154,
0.03735196962952614,
0.44983354210853577,
0.39598575234413147,
0.2658020555973053,
0.3855992555618286,
-0.774647057056427,
0.651990532875061,
0.3216928541660309,
0.5773543119430542,
0.08884624391794205,
-0.797199010848999,
-0.5631086826324463,
-0.33655476570129395,
-0.3298000395298004,
-0.5580580234527588,
0.5111809372901917,
0.46562737226486206,
0.5339453816413879,
0.42772746086120605,
-0.2796323299407959,
0.8081401586532593,
-0.8459104895591736,
0.5550283789634705,
0.3759123682975769,
-0.9742745757102966,
0.4587344229221344,
0.021241415292024612,
0.8707805275917053,
0.4813750982284546,
0.1739041656255722,
-0.9236088991165161,
-0.6665593385696411,
-0.5651029944419861,
-0.6818792819976807,
0.8672325611114502,
0.468289315700531,
0.18816177546977997,
0.2057187408208847,
0.4285184442996979,
-0.07623174786567688,
0.0879717692732811,
-0.7279690504074097,
-0.6700797080993652,
0.025334075093269348,
-0.44655677676200867,
-0.2200903594493866,
-0.4684404134750366,
0.1509033441543579,
-0.3366061747074127,
0.6596164703369141,
0.15061599016189575,
0.05862767994403839,
0.03822316229343414,
-0.549205482006073,
-0.1960507333278656,
0.08641768246889114,
0.9210728406906128,
0.6388384699821472,
-0.19620604813098907,
0.37044355273246765,
0.2474936544895172,
-0.750130832195282,
0.030877673998475075,
0.018514391034841537,
-0.33687859773635864,
0.3993252217769623,
0.3205122947692871,
0.9884417057037354,
0.6763026118278503,
-0.5621342658996582,
0.17749400436878204,
-0.35473036766052246,
0.07071804255247116,
0.03255916014313698,
-0.04558428376913071,
0.3401731550693512,
-0.090060755610466,
0.26561641693115234,
-0.10400483012199402,
-0.004763453267514706,
-0.3205193877220154,
0.15946170687675476,
0.15905265510082245,
-0.6961564421653748,
-0.36504682898521423,
0.8004331588745117,
0.28295814990997314,
-0.5302194952964783,
0.584038496017456,
0.12772896885871887,
-0.41157224774360657,
0.5542006492614746,
0.5048537254333496,
1.2376282215118408,
-0.6066418290138245,
-0.06491589546203613,
0.07323324680328369,
0.5251742601394653,
0.024977773427963257,
0.45030477643013,
-0.05829005315899849,
-0.5372188687324524,
-0.41253727674484253,
-0.5942076444625854,
-0.36439746618270874,
0.028115613386034966,
-0.2723643481731415,
0.1526627093553543,
-0.7410236597061157,
-0.031227050349116325,
-0.1089647188782692,
-0.12348622828722,
-0.5242716073989868,
0.10497689247131348,
0.26746806502342224,
1.1195642948150635,
-0.6171543002128601,
1.1367985010147095,
0.4080727994441986,
0.042283229529857635,
-0.4516076445579529,
-0.19656018912792206,
-0.14310352504253387,
-0.47415751218795776,
0.4011354446411133,
0.31195348501205444,
-0.36299270391464233,
0.22429151833057404,
-0.4981374740600586,
-0.745980441570282,
0.8616779446601868,
0.4502333402633667,
-1.0765358209609985,
0.1875312477350235,
0.30744120478630066,
0.5523727536201477,
-0.3342040777206421,
0.16063222289085388,
0.5499176383018494,
0.17986442148685455,
-0.12050849944353104,
-0.8241435885429382,
-0.3444184958934784,
-0.28297996520996094,
0.41655227541923523,
0.22080333530902863,
-0.7545259594917297,
0.7233913540840149,
-0.06395307928323746,
-0.31472912430763245,
-0.003988353069871664,
0.8213731646537781,
0.2706974148750305,
0.15010805428028107,
0.3638111650943756,
0.6067222952842712,
0.43243536353111267,
-0.16791489720344543,
1.128048062324524,
-0.7103558778762817,
0.4416210949420929,
1.0450639724731445,
-0.41543683409690857,
0.3573567569255829,
0.6074526906013489,
-0.09542209655046463,
0.09601453691720963,
0.35355570912361145,
0.18436196446418762,
0.6736482977867126,
0.2654206156730652,
-0.26110905408859253,
0.06029418483376503,
-0.2612909972667694,
-0.2727549970149994,
-0.11104253679513931,
0.2031026929616928,
-0.3442883789539337,
-0.07637140154838562,
0.13747097551822662,
-0.03993353620171547,
0.09957099705934525,
-0.46175166964530945,
0.7466212511062622,
0.4475812613964081,
-0.48158103227615356,
0.6030264496803284,
0.1220255196094513,
0.8049778938293457,
-0.8284029960632324,
0.38623905181884766,
-0.5132419466972351,
0.37739986181259155,
-0.022563215345144272,
-0.5167699456214905,
0.34886372089385986,
0.42059603333473206,
-0.19445352256298065,
-0.4910910725593567,
0.5933323502540588,
-0.6085787415504456,
-0.7204411625862122,
0.3037263751029968,
-0.07760395109653473,
0.03009173460304737,
0.0090076494961977,
-0.6565313339233398,
0.37561291456222534,
0.0772029235959053,
-0.20320242643356323,
0.11232323199510574,
0.2114412486553192,
0.1473347246646881,
0.896852970123291,
0.39723843336105347,
0.08444119989871979,
0.5738716721534729,
0.5270286798477173,
0.7545762658119202,
-0.63459312915802,
-0.505168080329895,
-1.111054539680481,
0.42658787965774536,
-0.024179408326745033,
-0.2533821165561676,
0.8778434991836548,
0.910672664642334,
0.35050898790359497,
-0.309635728597641,
0.5170013308525085,
0.30248767137527466,
0.4156210422515869,
-0.6001914143562317,
0.46139538288116455,
-0.361233115196228,
0.2750322222709656,
-0.26322776079177856,
-1.1346683502197266,
-0.6198803186416626,
0.3329322636127472,
-0.03643139451742172,
-0.1695292890071869,
0.7971934080123901,
0.46994343400001526,
-0.2871510684490204,
-0.13075199723243713,
0.44206446409225464,
0.1499851942062378,
0.3543475270271301,
0.9050682187080383,
0.49702316522598267,
-0.43751099705696106,
0.3921579420566559,
-0.36565715074539185,
-0.051817722618579865,
-0.27804967761039734,
-0.7964787483215332,
-0.8639771938323975,
-0.20740433037281036,
-0.4000624418258667,
0.1230413168668747,
0.17230969667434692,
0.6827154755592346,
0.7158024907112122,
-0.7254947423934937,
-0.3877466917037964,
-0.29443860054016113,
0.08452444523572922,
-0.08964388072490692,
-0.20774170756340027,
0.30737021565437317,
-0.5270107388496399,
-0.6947255730628967,
0.4339818060398102,
0.7986540198326111,
0.07143279165029526,
-0.32487088441848755,
-0.2106291651725769,
-0.3608006536960602,
0.07753752171993256,
0.47894248366355896,
0.34991663694381714,
-0.6606929898262024,
-0.09419336169958115,
0.18029724061489105,
-0.46383342146873474,
0.10788224637508392,
0.8532940745353699,
-0.5381937623023987,
0.3894294202327728,
0.5940874814987183,
0.7559136152267456,
0.8201292157173157,
0.009205147624015808,
0.5478417277336121,
-1.0973563194274902,
0.5069179534912109,
0.37519407272338867,
0.2601768374443054,
0.49674928188323975,
-0.3314700424671173,
0.582063615322113,
0.08829724788665771,
-0.33389654755592346,
-0.6908158659934998,
0.2965972423553467,
-0.9275754690170288,
-0.0611586794257164,
0.9815101027488708,
-0.05883040651679039,
-0.39073020219802856,
-0.025698838755488396,
-0.15539535880088806,
0.11488199979066849,
-0.2192469835281372,
0.699141263961792,
0.40267977118492126,
0.15022999048233032,
-0.814044177532196,
-0.3644788861274719,
0.44274717569351196,
0.5413545370101929,
-0.7902063727378845,
0.031984418630599976,
0.11489365249872208,
0.052719343453645706,
0.13465920090675354,
0.5608566403388977,
-0.06176622211933136,
0.37845656275749207,
-0.38545945286750793,
0.19244374334812164,
0.057047054171562195,
-0.5635464787483215,
-0.6386678218841553,
0.15549425780773163,
-0.13361836969852448,
-0.03528886288404465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17376v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17376v1
|
Federating Dynamic Models using Early-Exit Architectures for Automatic Speech Recognition on Heterogeneous Clients
| 2024-05-27T17:32:37 | 2024-05-27T17:32:37 |
Mohamed Nabih Ali, Alessio Brutti, Daniele Falavigna
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic speech recognition models require large amounts of speech
recordings for training. However, the collection of such data often is
cumbersome and leads to privacy concerns. Federated learning has been widely
used as an effective decentralized technique that collaboratively learns a
shared prediction model while keeping the data local on different clients.
Unfortunately, client devices often feature limited computation and
communication resources leading to practical difficulties for large models. In
addition, the heterogeneity that characterizes edge devices makes it
sub-optimal to generate a single model that fits all of them. Differently from
the recent literature, where multiple models with different architectures are
used, in this work, we propose using dynamical architectures which, employing
early-exit solutions, can adapt their processing (i.e. traversed layers)
depending on the input and on the operation conditions. This solution falls in
the realm of partial training methods and brings two benefits: a single model
is used on a variety of devices; federating the models after local training is
straightforward. Experiments on public datasets show that our proposed approach
is effective and can be combined with basic federated learning strategies.
|
[
-0.3245156705379486,
-0.7681893110275269,
0.46139439940452576,
-0.015137417241930962,
-0.15240639448165894,
0.17620351910591125,
-0.2408776730298996,
-0.5430659055709839,
-0.017994288355112076,
0.15232257544994354,
-0.5733337998390198,
-0.27717897295951843,
-0.3795066773891449,
-0.08396676182746887,
-0.43684715032577515,
0.7873403429985046,
-0.3463743031024933,
-0.022541487589478493,
-0.15478233993053436,
-0.31119483709335327,
-0.2519012689590454,
-0.3048812747001648,
-0.5912314653396606,
-0.6102070808410645,
0.43074125051498413,
0.33709803223609924,
0.6539999842643738,
0.8730548024177551,
0.27344396710395813,
0.3613261282444,
-0.04353902488946915,
0.01491147093474865,
-0.2162030190229416,
0.2996334135532379,
0.21770691871643066,
-0.2678639888763428,
-0.3323739767074585,
0.22260762751102448,
0.9444164633750916,
1.1001262664794922,
-0.6980898380279541,
0.11693909019231796,
0.048567526042461395,
0.32207220792770386,
-0.49521350860595703,
0.20037944614887238,
-0.5516070127487183,
0.5805647969245911,
-0.37881946563720703,
-0.05093654617667198,
-0.3722456395626068,
-0.16468055546283722,
0.6957913637161255,
-0.4985058903694153,
0.05450558289885521,
-0.2724246680736542,
0.5318390727043152,
0.36287978291511536,
-0.00560566084459424,
-0.15774571895599365,
-1.1503610610961914,
0.6939311027526855,
-0.45229873061180115,
0.7692808508872986,
0.2006661742925644,
0.7043382525444031,
0.0913274884223938,
-0.9406899809837341,
-0.4158903956413269,
-0.08896603435277939,
0.06486311554908752,
-0.08552785217761993,
-0.5312619805335999,
-0.17722657322883606,
0.10356643050909042,
0.20571529865264893,
-0.3687392473220825,
0.4763799011707306,
-0.09799094498157501,
-0.3934016823768616,
0.27518871426582336,
-0.04743937402963638,
0.0710037499666214,
0.4041118919849396,
-0.4420788288116455,
-0.15326820313930511,
-0.5559388995170593,
0.21760451793670654,
0.4776703715324402,
0.8240547776222229,
-0.47549745440483093,
0.05122845619916916,
-0.2649247348308563,
0.7156228423118591,
0.48676639795303345,
-0.22706766426563263,
0.6889805793762207,
-0.10600736737251282,
-0.3871399760246277,
0.4631015956401825,
0.5760886669158936,
-0.5137776732444763,
-0.3721960186958313,
-0.4722059667110443,
-0.6204687356948853,
-0.3090096414089203,
0.00023475088528357446,
-0.5681582689285278,
-0.35585179924964905,
0.45396602153778076,
-0.4777268171310425,
-0.3018638491630554,
-0.177042618393898,
-0.5029032826423645,
-0.2258002758026123,
-0.536689817905426,
0.5187180042266846,
-0.11003737896680832,
-0.30688056349754333,
-0.11134401708841324,
0.20653045177459717,
0.14500795304775238,
0.39361926913261414,
-0.7049030661582947,
0.5242149233818054,
0.4519001543521881,
1.1595251560211182,
-0.10687559843063354,
-0.2661198377609253,
-1.4840569496154785,
-0.03099239431321621,
0.1057261973619461,
0.470505028963089,
-0.5028961896896362,
-0.3130638599395752,
0.04003273323178291,
-0.1320921927690506,
-0.12499739974737167,
-0.48925960063934326,
0.3567376136779785,
-0.5905311107635498,
0.5383729338645935,
0.07701277732849121,
-0.25302645564079285,
-0.02979898825287819,
-0.028785528615117073,
-0.6127728819847107,
0.4108480215072632,
-0.20088191330432892,
-0.7812994122505188,
0.04640179127454758,
-0.7680551409721375,
-0.553489625453949,
0.14714637398719788,
-0.33034342527389526,
-0.8524537682533264,
0.1140078604221344,
0.20847927033901215,
0.664987325668335,
-0.135573148727417,
0.04007074981927872,
-0.3832835853099823,
-0.2612069249153137,
-0.1960975080728531,
-0.4342845678329468,
0.8753758668899536,
0.38141244649887085,
-0.559756875038147,
0.02392180822789669,
-0.9451270699501038,
-0.04305869713425636,
0.12986157834529877,
-0.6844854950904846,
-0.35408827662467957,
0.13961684703826904,
-0.03957701846957207,
0.13107748329639435,
0.19609272480010986,
-0.6811815500259399,
-0.1420702040195465,
-0.450619101524353,
0.36208340525627136,
0.9088143110275269,
-0.15725259482860565,
0.5899357199668884,
-0.4545019567012787,
0.4682869613170624,
0.20243528485298157,
0.19431635737419128,
-0.16607457399368286,
-0.27106910943984985,
-0.42082566022872925,
-0.5925123691558838,
0.21255145967006683,
0.47433412075042725,
-0.7546637058258057,
0.19246205687522888,
-0.20513826608657837,
-0.7040097713470459,
-0.3412805199623108,
0.0924297422170639,
0.5051110982894897,
0.5760061740875244,
0.17129437625408173,
-0.31656360626220703,
-0.44918936491012573,
-0.493783175945282,
0.039526887238025665,
-0.16268031299114227,
-0.00331767275929451,
0.6779794692993164,
-0.006697578355669975,
-0.19874024391174316,
0.8534446954727173,
-0.21049270033836365,
-0.2926217317581177,
-0.0017409725114703178,
0.25403231382369995,
0.3812454044818878,
0.5145321488380432,
0.48470401763916016,
-0.9770060777664185,
-0.4235261082649231,
0.2856762707233429,
-0.4834003150463104,
-0.0005410104058682919,
-0.20379845798015594,
0.1446004956960678,
-0.12642666697502136,
-0.02078448235988617,
-0.3751121759414673,
0.12334531545639038,
0.7507493495941162,
0.1709478348493576,
0.5092863440513611,
-0.2676679790019989,
-0.23614555597305298,
-0.9714142084121704,
-0.08545681089162827,
0.020018864423036575,
-0.3115435540676117,
-0.8295661211013794,
-0.25608110427856445,
-0.43565449118614197,
-0.44684624671936035,
-0.7085053324699402,
0.32549819350242615,
-0.5929426550865173,
-0.5258030295372009,
-0.12077461928129196,
-0.06294715404510498,
-0.24641740322113037,
0.33666494488716125,
0.2514069676399231,
0.6879080533981323,
0.8460496664047241,
-0.6295698881149292,
0.6115321516990662,
0.19678445160388947,
-0.044799111783504486,
0.217139333486557,
-0.6856068968772888,
0.4575175642967224,
0.008866691961884499,
0.3270322382450104,
-0.7069313526153564,
-0.3915860056877136,
0.13374584913253784,
-0.37381812930107117,
0.31004559993743896,
-0.16770195960998535,
-0.18277209997177124,
-0.18154148757457733,
-0.0976424440741539,
0.4560033977031708,
0.5330727100372314,
-0.9190486073493958,
0.9023585915565491,
0.6500710844993591,
-0.1266116201877594,
-0.4529510736465454,
-0.7299820780754089,
-0.2619442343711853,
-0.31613096594810486,
-0.6258716583251953,
0.43285277485847473,
0.10614221543073654,
-0.07331148535013199,
-0.12136221677064896,
-0.08544974029064178,
-0.2938527762889862,
0.22122728824615479,
0.5019710659980774,
0.15228089690208435,
-0.43446049094200134,
-0.05710778012871742,
0.184183731675148,
0.04538626968860626,
-0.07625411450862885,
-0.4907284379005432,
0.7332785129547119,
-0.3575662076473236,
-0.5019930601119995,
-0.7748590111732483,
0.36495888233184814,
0.5177939534187317,
-0.7036175727844238,
0.6348229646682739,
0.7769773006439209,
-0.6381154656410217,
-0.4750632643699646,
-0.3195437490940094,
-0.17891420423984528,
-0.5277808904647827,
0.11730972677469254,
-0.49785682559013367,
-0.642205536365509,
0.8284767270088196,
-0.13156703114509583,
0.24939659237861633,
-0.043521732091903687,
0.904642641544342,
-0.21712295711040497,
0.7499899864196777,
0.644287645816803,
-0.09308584034442902,
0.9216378927230835,
-0.20604658126831055,
0.0513739138841629,
-0.48014146089553833,
-0.28878891468048096,
-0.462319016456604,
-0.188012033700943,
-0.5651426911354065,
-0.17275303602218628,
0.5994893908500671,
-0.4204823076725006,
-0.06385636329650879,
0.20772308111190796,
-0.4667614996433258,
0.3236970603466034,
0.7013596296310425,
0.43797022104263306,
0.0036252348218113184,
0.4471043348312378,
-0.4054834842681885,
0.4267280697822571,
-0.8897442817687988,
-0.27432945370674133,
0.8383527994155884,
0.658180296421051,
0.663553774356842,
0.05662897601723671,
1.143617033958435,
0.3163275420665741,
0.12011740356683731,
-0.5376144051551819,
0.3258858025074005,
-0.19309644401073456,
-0.29279306530952454,
-0.4454673230648041,
-0.6610468029975891,
-0.8040623664855957,
0.13331665098667145,
-0.10016776621341705,
-0.6661880612373352,
0.7876326441764832,
0.3421047627925873,
-0.7297626733779907,
0.41262370347976685,
-0.6192907691001892,
0.5563852190971375,
-0.07541494816541672,
-0.5092961192131042,
0.18150605261325836,
-0.7907521724700928,
0.18370525538921356,
-0.23587293922901154,
-0.019148988649249077,
0.15677601099014282,
0.3544556200504303,
0.8760132193565369,
-0.36287039518356323,
0.8119507431983948,
-0.7811037302017212,
0.06193815544247627,
0.23566529154777527,
-0.07381551712751389,
0.6003481149673462,
-0.1707088202238083,
-0.20656731724739075,
0.2340337336063385,
-0.16700147092342377,
-0.19398751854896545,
-0.2952194809913635,
0.6310750842094421,
-0.9994507431983948,
-0.049505483359098434,
-0.3830344080924988,
-0.33659133315086365,
-0.3919011056423187,
0.19095125794410706,
0.0006937066791579127,
0.8148654699325562,
0.02906402200460434,
0.23887652158737183,
0.6438862681388855,
-0.1057635173201561,
0.5446073412895203,
0.5336577892303467,
0.21735075116157532,
-0.23120585083961487,
0.8434582948684692,
0.08939900994300842,
0.17719666659832,
0.08362508565187454,
0.3655758500099182,
-0.3114590048789978,
-0.7793370485305786,
-0.27537068724632263,
0.003695813473314047,
-0.5211392045021057,
-0.06217329949140549,
-0.41967540979385376,
-0.2571476697921753,
-0.2759835720062256,
-0.018374186009168625,
-0.7685583829879761,
0.00529910484328866,
-0.5992396473884583,
0.1288943588733673,
-0.2002929002046585,
0.21250155568122864,
-0.47016531229019165,
0.38331085443496704,
-0.9074246287345886,
0.08214041590690613,
0.44142913818359375,
0.3711457848548889,
0.1703762710094452,
-0.46550998091697693,
-0.375091016292572,
0.2714065611362457,
-0.08731364458799362,
-0.6627233624458313,
0.1853918731212616,
0.5389348268508911,
0.9185305833816528,
0.5871108770370483,
0.17282776534557343,
0.5745304822921753,
-0.7543635964393616,
0.3747576177120209,
0.3438139259815216,
-0.803582489490509,
0.5694210529327393,
-0.4216943085193634,
0.1712108999490738,
0.5868990421295166,
0.4803430736064911,
-0.3589518964290619,
-0.07922671735286713,
-0.2713108956813812,
-0.6018550395965576,
0.869047999382019,
0.1679258793592453,
0.09272369742393494,
0.4450649321079254,
0.23313027620315552,
0.32046210765838623,
0.08585246652364731,
-0.501696765422821,
-0.14221645891666412,
-0.2780264914035797,
-0.18875418603420258,
0.19212540984153748,
0.30156275629997253,
-0.41064733266830444,
-0.10523902624845505,
0.4644010066986084,
0.0557786300778389,
0.5152920484542847,
-0.05024757608771324,
0.09098969399929047,
-0.30255183577537537,
0.0511823371052742,
0.3818320333957672,
0.44226059317588806,
-0.31802085041999817,
-0.041675910353660583,
-0.1287391185760498,
-0.4601516127586365,
0.4459797441959381,
0.6726841926574707,
-0.28045013546943665,
0.08565528690814972,
0.38874050974845886,
1.0975748300552368,
0.03953063115477562,
-0.4840601682662964,
0.49759364128112793,
-0.1678413450717926,
-0.07101207971572876,
-0.36329320073127747,
-0.016614295542240143,
-0.3025139570236206,
0.5910863876342773,
0.4589311480522156,
0.1821819245815277,
0.09970536082983017,
-0.6174649596214294,
0.5417190194129944,
0.3368518352508545,
-0.3159485459327698,
-0.5323392152786255,
0.5964740514755249,
0.4528419077396393,
-0.44609761238098145,
0.5929437279701233,
-0.0810885950922966,
-0.37309029698371887,
0.29669252038002014,
0.3636396825313568,
1.1149601936340332,
-0.5607370138168335,
0.29042232036590576,
-0.2710600793361664,
-0.0370294414460659,
0.01987125724554062,
-0.03801757097244263,
-0.6173849105834961,
-0.7990135550498962,
-0.3161020874977112,
-0.7478004097938538,
-0.6743166446685791,
-0.05040137469768524,
-0.7164826393127441,
0.20377828180789948,
-0.5497794151306152,
-0.1653139889240265,
0.059582896530628204,
0.07335919886827469,
-0.8692420721054077,
0.26099517941474915,
0.6015076637268066,
0.5943447947502136,
-0.9767313003540039,
0.9481638669967651,
0.7784431576728821,
-0.14094585180282593,
-0.9878966808319092,
0.0715550109744072,
0.11982323229312897,
-0.5441810488700867,
0.4757850468158722,
0.011431237682700157,
-0.3235093355178833,
-0.13871726393699646,
-0.23749451339244843,
-0.7236371040344238,
1.184629201889038,
0.34367847442626953,
-0.643818199634552,
-0.4208601415157318,
0.09651479870080948,
0.3575958013534546,
-0.601169228553772,
0.02898551896214485,
0.2762739658355713,
0.1159917563199997,
0.28661873936653137,
-1.1695938110351562,
-0.19225721061229706,
-0.07306534796953201,
-0.24298827350139618,
-0.18023724853992462,
-0.45335912704467773,
1.1958216428756714,
-0.18289531767368317,
-0.5225352644920349,
-0.1684464067220688,
0.6044480800628662,
0.19009768962860107,
0.662878692150116,
0.9759838581085205,
0.2924382984638214,
0.973829448223114,
0.10302308201789856,
0.7352162599563599,
-0.1401359885931015,
0.32401043176651,
1.4320553541183472,
-0.414814293384552,
0.8666922450065613,
0.29225048422813416,
-0.09914111346006393,
0.2648973762989044,
0.7095247507095337,
0.29405903816223145,
1.1165571212768555,
-0.03985264152288437,
-0.3619542717933655,
-0.20069174468517303,
0.05730308219790459,
-0.4149976074695587,
1.0109329223632812,
-0.05855044722557068,
-0.28942161798477173,
-0.42694440484046936,
0.4177606701850891,
-0.21291400492191315,
-0.1198577955365181,
-0.13844189047813416,
0.8223354816436768,
-0.09653603285551071,
0.0008562178700231016,
0.5587148070335388,
0.06518769264221191,
0.420475572347641,
-0.5637766122817993,
0.056405261158943176,
-0.30147188901901245,
0.03762892633676529,
-0.2350231260061264,
-0.12390460073947906,
0.22017332911491394,
0.12022610008716583,
-0.09968685358762741,
-0.3656456768512726,
0.6342045664787292,
-0.3779134750366211,
-0.37005114555358887,
0.13364307582378387,
0.7443947792053223,
0.015632493421435356,
0.15326420962810516,
-0.5911546349525452,
0.29656171798706055,
-0.1536046266555786,
-0.30251964926719666,
0.28530555963516235,
0.2843960225582123,
0.38698267936706543,
0.7131354212760925,
0.9605380892753601,
0.2908003032207489,
0.2770676016807556,
-0.06147143989801407,
1.193833827972412,
0.02972063049674034,
-0.8959538340568542,
-0.5180454850196838,
0.4034452438354492,
-0.008187945932149887,
-0.05448950454592705,
0.5115972757339478,
0.42786574363708496,
0.7963696718215942,
0.3046722710132599,
0.5702500343322754,
0.18436411023139954,
0.7059215307235718,
-0.48287099599838257,
0.8273712396621704,
-0.6142268776893616,
0.48166218400001526,
-0.22091737389564514,
-0.9192891120910645,
-0.21404911577701569,
0.7024694681167603,
-0.26964160799980164,
-0.05032110586762428,
0.018680591136217117,
0.28636375069618225,
-0.5973197817802429,
0.15983933210372925,
0.2104664444923401,
0.33366549015045166,
0.6234790682792664,
0.5480921864509583,
0.5995429158210754,
-0.11555671691894531,
0.16733738780021667,
-0.4552479088306427,
-0.36414679884910583,
-0.13671809434890747,
-0.684468150138855,
-0.38538891077041626,
-0.6113136410713196,
-0.45806488394737244,
-0.1174011081457138,
0.20558464527130127,
1.0271272659301758,
1.1170034408569336,
-0.6755236983299255,
-0.10306116193532944,
0.05344662442803383,
-0.10877180099487305,
-0.13906028866767883,
-0.1094788983464241,
0.3472597002983093,
-0.07862554490566254,
-0.6229066252708435,
0.6963261365890503,
0.10369770973920822,
0.13912686705589294,
-0.5389965772628784,
-0.24849428236484528,
-0.10934591293334961,
-0.03622519597411156,
0.26093316078186035,
0.522940456867218,
-0.4008873403072357,
-0.375633180141449,
-0.40259334444999695,
0.14451907575130463,
0.10453857481479645,
0.5383001565933228,
-1.0492756366729736,
0.668302059173584,
0.32685863971710205,
1.0023201704025269,
0.47320860624313354,
0.011170662008225918,
0.4975636899471283,
-0.8756667971611023,
0.4593215882778168,
0.5941197276115417,
0.3375462591648102,
0.36625516414642334,
-0.16821032762527466,
0.03342510014772415,
0.2570589482784271,
-0.40896186232566833,
-1.2973371744155884,
0.058214567601680756,
-0.9559575319290161,
0.18308044970035553,
0.6081387996673584,
-0.6336838603019714,
-0.27656832337379456,
0.21120983362197876,
0.35176220536231995,
0.32753440737724304,
-0.36075958609580994,
0.5273452401161194,
0.3930688798427582,
-0.39172205328941345,
-0.12763366103172302,
-0.11151120066642761,
0.26870399713516235,
0.07712649554014206,
-0.8580330014228821,
-0.015268777497112751,
0.5464189648628235,
0.1706153154373169,
0.18426048755645752,
0.6070209741592407,
0.01758788339793682,
0.44812557101249695,
0.07752995193004608,
-0.2572140097618103,
-0.38616272807121277,
-0.663216769695282,
-0.6343472003936768,
0.4771397113800049,
-0.30788159370422363,
-0.8154178261756897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17361v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17361v1
|
A One-Layer Decoder-Only Transformer is a Two-Layer RNN: With an Application to Certified Robustness
| 2024-05-27T17:10:04 | 2024-05-27T17:10:04 |
Yuhao Zhang, Aws Albarghouthi, Loris D'Antoni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper reveals a key insight that a one-layer decoder-only Transformer is
equivalent to a two-layer Recurrent Neural Network (RNN). Building on this
insight, we propose ARC-Tran, a novel approach for verifying the robustness of
decoder-only Transformers against arbitrary perturbation spaces. Compared to
ARC-Tran, current robustness verification techniques are limited either to
specific and length-preserving perturbations like word substitutions or to
recursive models like LSTMs. ARC-Tran addresses these limitations by
meticulously managing position encoding to prevent mismatches and by utilizing
our key insight to achieve precise and scalable verification. Our evaluation
shows that ARC-Tran (1) trains models more robust to arbitrary perturbation
spaces than those produced by existing techniques and (2) shows high
certification accuracy of the resulting models.
|
[
-0.2150631695985794,
-0.6679179668426514,
0.15920008718967438,
0.20694103837013245,
-0.12471181899309158,
0.16428795456886292,
0.08918851613998413,
-0.11639013141393661,
-0.21090802550315857,
1.0037155151367188,
-0.5687769055366516,
-0.5484970808029175,
-0.6662679314613342,
0.25902605056762695,
-0.96433025598526,
0.7533225417137146,
-0.0412411205470562,
-0.36584916710853577,
0.012707114219665527,
-0.30939990282058716,
-0.08022043108940125,
-0.31536543369293213,
-0.38496413826942444,
-0.38907068967819214,
0.40284407138824463,
0.20740826427936554,
0.7587961554527283,
0.5903927087783813,
0.7606604099273682,
0.20715847611427307,
-0.21718069911003113,
-0.04226820915937424,
-0.2204446792602539,
0.3774920701980591,
-0.221488356590271,
-0.4969021677970886,
-0.5409379005432129,
-0.1708681434392929,
0.6704797744750977,
0.30258840322494507,
-0.043990422040224075,
0.24639615416526794,
0.003586407285183668,
0.5390122532844543,
-0.7078725099563599,
-0.315460205078125,
-0.8052007555961609,
0.24540628492832184,
0.02411866933107376,
-0.18594051897525787,
-0.9910061359405518,
-0.3964897096157074,
-0.006304605398327112,
-0.35461440682411194,
0.10922972112894058,
-0.03229926899075508,
1.0393288135528564,
0.8309302926063538,
-0.4770176410675049,
0.4575980007648468,
-1.184744954109192,
0.7559462189674377,
-0.40524300932884216,
0.7451678514480591,
0.22760199010372162,
0.5554606914520264,
0.17881707847118378,
-1.1352440118789673,
-0.5590354204177856,
-0.11282096803188324,
-0.33129432797431946,
0.15328127145767212,
-0.4765119254589081,
0.07694873958826065,
0.4699866771697998,
0.2804780900478363,
-0.3796839118003845,
0.07458341121673584,
0.07082582265138626,
-0.39596790075302124,
0.2858719825744629,
-0.020594969391822815,
0.4078884422779083,
0.0003628111444413662,
-0.9392163753509521,
-0.4603102207183838,
-0.8420187830924988,
0.2293538898229599,
0.34602004289627075,
-0.02234654873609543,
-0.0181664377450943,
0.5781511664390564,
0.3390544354915619,
0.10561118274927139,
0.33995291590690613,
0.08689696341753006,
-0.18693919479846954,
-0.4304791986942291,
-0.15451675653457642,
0.13662220537662506,
0.7281212210655212,
-0.12817202508449554,
-0.016308153048157692,
-0.5491542220115662,
-0.29644325375556946,
0.15954305231571198,
0.5786358118057251,
-0.5852578282356262,
-0.20714780688285828,
0.312120258808136,
-0.3386554419994354,
-0.5703624486923218,
0.3110704720020294,
-0.5408169627189636,
-0.26800477504730225,
0.2117498368024826,
0.2725624144077301,
-0.4447084367275238,
-0.5917843580245972,
0.2761405408382416,
0.10255368798971176,
0.8028955459594727,
-0.14456331729888916,
-0.6106545925140381,
0.3745213747024536,
0.8605619072914124,
0.6305140852928162,
-0.27955129742622375,
-0.6890919208526611,
-0.11943996697664261,
0.00829328689724207,
-0.3607194125652313,
0.9239652156829834,
-0.1332923322916031,
0.010776796378195286,
-0.2405720353126526,
-0.10436388850212097,
-0.06926029920578003,
-0.2854462265968323,
0.8221273422241211,
-0.5449227094650269,
-0.24733051657676697,
-0.0054354737512767315,
-0.19150367379188538,
-0.044138047844171524,
0.5213007926940918,
-0.9857364892959595,
1.0268055200576782,
0.8524760007858276,
-0.9635635018348694,
0.2888251543045044,
-0.2688474953174591,
-0.5964145064353943,
-0.39156490564346313,
0.23878338932991028,
-0.8766878843307495,
-0.1714669018983841,
0.2716085612773895,
-0.07759207487106323,
-0.04053583741188049,
-0.10507528483867645,
0.011321558617055416,
-0.3193144202232361,
0.51576167345047,
-0.7445387244224548,
0.8322988152503967,
0.13712984323501587,
-0.3788556456565857,
0.0759313553571701,
-0.9081549644470215,
0.23556247353553772,
-0.0381961464881897,
-0.3948538899421692,
0.013102810829877853,
-0.32932621240615845,
-0.05185428634285927,
0.13049858808517456,
-0.18158641457557678,
-0.706024706363678,
0.26837587356567383,
-0.5272282361984253,
0.727192223072052,
0.5679627060890198,
0.05217833071947098,
0.5870831608772278,
-0.32782140374183655,
0.7540084719657898,
0.23603424429893494,
0.2838120758533478,
-0.3847625255584717,
-0.24420134723186493,
-0.8185312747955322,
-0.2914823591709137,
0.469264417886734,
0.89769047498703,
-0.7608667016029358,
0.9814572930335999,
-0.4018632769584656,
-0.36921441555023193,
-0.4862757623195648,
-0.2180156260728836,
0.1847945749759674,
0.689430832862854,
0.5040050745010376,
-0.18880848586559296,
-0.824287474155426,
-0.6761348247528076,
-0.30454137921333313,
-0.1945352554321289,
-0.04758693277835846,
-0.15568169951438904,
0.4208245277404785,
-0.41750216484069824,
0.8540810346603394,
0.22241410613059998,
-0.15822593867778778,
-0.49961307644844055,
-0.2759685516357422,
0.08564350754022598,
0.535006582736969,
0.3218710422515869,
-0.4277876019477844,
-0.3578241467475891,
0.28768908977508545,
-0.6633198857307434,
0.048860665410757065,
-0.35452786087989807,
-0.22694548964500427,
-0.005829930305480957,
0.22110344469547272,
-0.6126970648765564,
0.875074028968811,
0.5760190486907959,
-0.3262667655944824,
0.4281981885433197,
-0.09719229489564896,
0.05366180092096329,
-0.6968650817871094,
0.15968042612075806,
-0.22670474648475647,
-0.5191338062286377,
-0.7251734733581543,
0.31852197647094727,
0.16983507573604584,
-0.07388386130332947,
-0.5377284288406372,
0.16529300808906555,
-0.061818648129701614,
0.10734258592128754,
0.005440808832645416,
-0.3225614130496979,
0.3675072491168976,
0.39136362075805664,
-0.029328374192118645,
0.619040846824646,
0.7514311671257019,
-0.3716108798980713,
0.3059510588645935,
0.602016031742096,
-0.4194667637348175,
0.6018540859222412,
-0.914017915725708,
0.5039193034172058,
-0.14884062111377716,
0.42814984917640686,
-0.9779474139213562,
0.17097069323062897,
0.04290369153022766,
-0.1997797042131424,
0.2479812204837799,
-0.1901116967201233,
-0.1196812093257904,
-0.4237327575683594,
-0.1740325540304184,
0.6439441442489624,
0.391621470451355,
-0.6615225076675415,
1.1279430389404297,
-0.19687065482139587,
0.4096470773220062,
-0.983063817024231,
-1.318660855293274,
0.0294367466121912,
-0.030958352610468864,
-0.8452016711235046,
-0.14947982132434845,
0.3766666054725647,
0.03556984290480614,
-0.24753175675868988,
-0.5099813938140869,
-0.18635407090187073,
0.3208635747432709,
0.21513131260871887,
0.16549156606197357,
-0.5563272833824158,
-0.5566791296005249,
0.26765307784080505,
-0.6991136074066162,
0.061576470732688904,
-0.3911086916923523,
0.30466949939727783,
-0.07919162511825562,
-0.6119877696037292,
-0.8641137480735779,
0.4992969334125519,
0.9639835953712463,
-0.4803726375102997,
0.31193724274635315,
0.45740658044815063,
-0.1861010193824768,
-0.65400230884552,
-0.4940289258956909,
-0.40941110253334045,
-0.5047828555107117,
0.4042036831378937,
-0.50054532289505,
-0.4522702395915985,
0.7853736281394958,
-0.08471956104040146,
0.06549742072820663,
0.32414665818214417,
0.08504394441843033,
0.058337558060884476,
0.9825478196144104,
0.3638932704925537,
0.031549375504255295,
0.12433480471372604,
-0.6198614835739136,
0.680450439453125,
-0.7843886017799377,
-0.34854856133461,
-0.6876930594444275,
-0.6329641342163086,
-0.2561695873737335,
-0.08764493465423584,
0.2545822262763977,
-0.10248907655477524,
-0.8180456161499023,
0.9518608450889587,
-0.9629859924316406,
0.6569833159446716,
0.18396668136119843,
0.2702309191226959,
0.4135698080062866,
0.07887385040521622,
-0.039771661162376404,
0.07109241187572479,
-0.5647764205932617,
-0.5807054042816162,
0.7765722274780273,
0.7141274213790894,
1.1171679496765137,
0.14966590702533722,
0.3651908338069916,
0.10377376526594162,
0.036999061703681946,
-0.887249231338501,
0.4345450699329376,
-0.2967979907989502,
-0.47317084670066833,
-0.32100027799606323,
-0.3757229745388031,
-0.7549159526824951,
-0.03420485183596611,
-0.22933697700500488,
-0.5421798825263977,
0.40975096821784973,
0.026034895330667496,
-0.30423882603645325,
0.886656641960144,
-0.3545071482658386,
0.6103089451789856,
-0.3372594118118286,
0.02299102209508419,
0.4802168309688568,
-0.7576310634613037,
0.16610294580459595,
0.262382835149765,
-0.3077200651168823,
0.2295108288526535,
-0.09099453687667847,
-0.042239975184202194,
-0.2786068320274353,
0.4050850570201874,
0.17375366389751434,
-0.12861914932727814,
0.3292366564273834,
0.8730961084365845,
0.6833401322364807,
0.10382207483053207,
-0.22629079222679138,
0.3576664626598358,
0.014049282297492027,
-0.1509416550397873,
-0.7388924956321716,
0.44085273146629333,
-0.9268381595611572,
-0.4326217472553253,
-0.1412893682718277,
-0.40062761306762695,
-0.15663427114486694,
0.36903899908065796,
0.8072724342346191,
0.22851234674453735,
0.059053272008895874,
0.4516420066356659,
1.015900731086731,
0.157361701130867,
0.16372282803058624,
-0.06980270147323608,
0.13557086884975433,
-0.2960547208786011,
0.5634393692016602,
-0.4159713089466095,
0.5127396583557129,
0.732674777507782,
0.27821436524391174,
-0.36459457874298096,
-0.3296385407447815,
-0.4407939016819,
-0.1913740187883377,
-0.8213343620300293,
-0.40749284625053406,
-0.5625970363616943,
-0.7033997178077698,
-0.24989284574985504,
-0.10916010290384293,
-1.022562026977539,
-0.5754337310791016,
0.12157174944877625,
-0.39396369457244873,
0.024817658588290215,
0.7364892363548279,
0.2748834192752838,
0.10109077394008636,
-0.7145951390266418,
0.320282518863678,
0.4507344663143158,
0.6997573971748352,
0.04693060740828514,
-0.6285420060157776,
0.23910407721996307,
-0.0028181271627545357,
-0.46850454807281494,
-0.5491774678230286,
-0.11306816339492798,
0.240281343460083,
0.4368225634098053,
0.6038006544113159,
0.1410972774028778,
0.20540286600589752,
-0.341282457113266,
0.9860506057739258,
0.18832610547542572,
-1.1631107330322266,
0.568880021572113,
0.0359543040394783,
0.0984468162059784,
0.6417199969291687,
-0.09951632469892502,
-0.2126656025648117,
-0.5087581872940063,
-0.43166524171829224,
-0.8522640466690063,
0.5188425183296204,
0.4861370623111725,
0.20482167601585388,
0.46275269985198975,
0.5870146155357361,
0.2601873576641083,
-0.3318202495574951,
-0.8372156620025635,
-0.7623599171638489,
-0.9419957399368286,
0.03157941624522209,
0.6541414260864258,
-0.2001705914735794,
-0.09240070730447769,
-0.14800117909908295,
0.40057626366615295,
0.09361671656370163,
0.41024506092071533,
0.44166094064712524,
-0.09795145690441132,
-0.15108975768089294,
0.4427832365036011,
0.47357887029647827,
0.5473195314407349,
0.003976893145591021,
0.6136753559112549,
0.370032399892807,
-0.6075579524040222,
0.7047033309936523,
-0.5324181318283081,
-0.30009713768959045,
0.08244799822568893,
0.5903464555740356,
0.8201726078987122,
0.12360592186450958,
0.0003450013173278421,
0.8247663974761963,
-0.2636629641056061,
-0.2453841269016266,
0.051135119050741196,
-0.041210856288671494,
-0.4704473912715912,
0.012209621258080006,
0.25938472151756287,
0.6440353989601135,
-0.24906162917613983,
-0.12102516740560532,
0.397512823343277,
0.1561013013124466,
-0.4876175820827484,
-0.5173095464706421,
1.0016615390777588,
-0.04709320515394211,
-0.3294089436531067,
0.751541793346405,
0.19900093972682953,
-0.6263608932495117,
0.5922375321388245,
0.686659038066864,
1.2280786037445068,
-0.3679410219192505,
-0.011627376079559326,
0.5424243807792664,
0.701924204826355,
-0.393020361661911,
-0.09616124629974365,
-0.1141449511051178,
-0.7584676742553711,
-0.35837027430534363,
-0.2050817906856537,
-0.49970895051956177,
-0.21538464725017548,
-0.971967875957489,
0.3946738839149475,
-0.5867782235145569,
-0.28456637263298035,
-0.13366255164146423,
-0.7440834045410156,
-0.5930117964744568,
-0.017028242349624634,
-0.09415857493877411,
1.18855881690979,
-0.7607433199882507,
0.8716562390327454,
0.405095636844635,
-0.08416421711444855,
-1.145097017288208,
-0.1227451041340828,
-0.44402503967285156,
-0.7709931135177612,
0.12350252270698547,
-0.022256042808294296,
-0.5134559273719788,
-0.12723858654499054,
-0.5289937257766724,
-0.7039678692817688,
1.1717077493667603,
0.8551110029220581,
-0.4051191806793213,
-0.2738988399505615,
0.4637328088283539,
0.45929381251335144,
-0.045217953622341156,
0.3490290939807892,
0.8539745807647705,
0.6286303997039795,
0.3475162386894226,
-0.6896367073059082,
0.09928339719772339,
-0.0006592895952053368,
0.18508051335811615,
0.02646549977362156,
-0.3234172463417053,
0.6853811740875244,
-0.20525634288787842,
-0.5928149223327637,
0.48778411746025085,
0.4349301755428314,
-0.20264345407485962,
-0.06259677559137344,
0.5890055894851685,
0.7442584037780762,
0.4901933968067169,
-0.42901939153671265,
1.1485517024993896,
-0.42909353971481323,
0.7005346417427063,
0.932604193687439,
-0.13143764436244965,
0.5604678392410278,
0.43858933448791504,
-0.22437691688537598,
0.7659208178520203,
-0.08463796228170395,
-0.10766081511974335,
0.5098521709442139,
-0.0863436907529831,
-0.004276916850358248,
-0.5125624537467957,
0.3049475848674774,
-0.37112900614738464,
0.6366491913795471,
0.06841162592172623,
-0.31628847122192383,
-0.20696254074573517,
0.029847439378499985,
-0.24653251469135284,
0.1800125539302826,
-0.08071184903383255,
0.6474664211273193,
0.11433619260787964,
-0.5479479432106018,
0.6226897239685059,
-0.17749950289726257,
0.6811746954917908,
-0.7063867449760437,
0.1569513976573944,
-0.25817960500717163,
0.3923407793045044,
-0.7400084733963013,
-0.8869683742523193,
0.6101847887039185,
-0.18366363644599915,
-0.10547152906656265,
-0.3890349566936493,
0.7425270676612854,
-0.18850210309028625,
-0.556725025177002,
0.09155144542455673,
0.0964115560054779,
-0.35896217823028564,
0.05215349420905113,
-0.18084584176540375,
0.07890098541975021,
-0.1605568379163742,
-0.319138765335083,
-0.23152218759059906,
0.38367751240730286,
0.2672940194606781,
0.942313551902771,
0.3969452679157257,
0.19964663684368134,
0.17002110183238983,
0.11887111514806747,
0.6592351794242859,
-0.4415319561958313,
-0.4725298285484314,
-0.6825480461120605,
0.8093475699424744,
0.3594948947429657,
-0.3301139175891876,
0.6719806790351868,
0.3377760052680969,
0.5727178454399109,
0.023542268201708794,
0.7616284489631653,
0.33434516191482544,
0.1611134558916092,
-0.18882159888744354,
0.9239863157272339,
-0.0037718755193054676,
0.7229205369949341,
-0.11588475108146667,
-0.8953872919082642,
-0.7745320200920105,
0.7459983825683594,
0.25809532403945923,
-0.164452463388443,
0.8363712430000305,
0.896574079990387,
-0.31906524300575256,
0.1887340396642685,
0.336731880903244,
0.2390872985124588,
0.23580214381217957,
0.7302199602127075,
1.1372097730636597,
-0.9888569712638855,
0.7617242336273193,
-0.5700724124908447,
0.0936366617679596,
0.43914005160331726,
-0.9865669012069702,
-0.765488862991333,
-0.4746262729167938,
-0.4704834818840027,
-0.9252578020095825,
-0.4660485088825226,
0.4139794707298279,
0.7338845729827881,
-1.0777896642684937,
0.26366570591926575,
-0.18660178780555725,
0.5789353251457214,
-0.8346545696258545,
-0.20328879356384277,
0.3434276580810547,
0.2382071614265442,
-0.30262869596481323,
0.21994037926197052,
0.38606229424476624,
0.02332414872944355,
-0.5989845991134644,
0.10777369886636734,
0.3425373435020447,
0.20016413927078247,
0.4118843376636505,
0.24982649087905884,
-0.7701372504234314,
-0.6494853496551514,
0.3760128915309906,
-0.3203326463699341,
0.5764614343643188,
1.258703589439392,
-0.632250189781189,
0.3150155544281006,
0.5791977047920227,
0.6938779354095459,
0.2663390636444092,
0.06253347545862198,
0.2448263019323349,
-0.9058762192726135,
0.2588719129562378,
0.5748652219772339,
0.3843761384487152,
0.24305947124958038,
-0.6336970329284668,
0.29698094725608826,
-0.29832205176353455,
-0.5467179417610168,
-0.900093674659729,
0.3686133325099945,
-1.350994348526001,
0.33114737272262573,
1.1314786672592163,
-0.4386182725429535,
-0.29387030005455017,
-0.14721304178237915,
-0.14253829419612885,
0.1350546032190323,
-0.050352733582258224,
0.6791516542434692,
0.3458482027053833,
0.25699368119239807,
-0.4372355043888092,
0.387362003326416,
0.11069712787866592,
0.10168277472257614,
-0.5152754783630371,
0.06802913546562195,
-0.3980737626552582,
0.4806632995605469,
0.3106992840766907,
-0.1740298718214035,
-0.29055503010749817,
0.5367918014526367,
0.16907143592834473,
-0.16174335777759552,
-0.5530019402503967,
-0.4439387619495392,
-0.5028641223907471,
0.23115457594394684,
-0.03043145313858986,
-0.14618989825248718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17357v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17357v3
|
DoRA: Enhancing Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning with Dynamic Rank Distribution
| 2024-05-27T17:02:27 | 2024-06-26T14:41:33 |
Yulong Mao, Kaiyu Huang, Changhao Guan, Ganglin Bao, Fengran Mo, Jinan Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Fine-tuning large-scale pre-trained models is inherently a resource-intensive
task. While it can enhance the capabilities of the model, it also incurs
substantial computational costs, posing challenges to the practical application
of downstream tasks. Existing parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods
such as Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) rely on a bypass framework that ignores the
differential parameter budget requirements across weight matrices, which may
lead to suboptimal fine-tuning outcomes. To address this issue, we introduce
the Dynamic Low-Rank Adaptation (DoRA) method. DoRA decomposes high-rank LoRA
layers into structured single-rank components, allowing for dynamic pruning of
parameter budget based on their importance to specific tasks during training,
which makes the most of the limited parameter budget. Experimental results
demonstrate that DoRA can achieve competitive performance compared with LoRA
and full model fine-tuning, and outperform various strong baselines with the
same storage parameter budget. Our code is available at
https://github.com/MIkumikumi0116/DoRA
|
[
-0.4393210709095001,
-0.8275906443595886,
0.4113052487373352,
0.30402490496635437,
-0.4368549585342407,
0.3857729136943817,
-0.25940290093421936,
-0.2809838652610779,
0.14136849343776703,
0.1715061515569687,
-0.8075718283653259,
-0.3162676692008972,
-0.5451940894126892,
-0.13388538360595703,
-0.21061664819717407,
0.9986379146575928,
-0.04809961095452309,
-0.42864105105400085,
0.030145462602376938,
-0.06702163815498352,
-0.45118317008018494,
-0.2324834167957306,
-0.814813494682312,
0.13736723363399506,
0.7917343974113464,
0.6811200976371765,
0.6286409497261047,
0.5707465410232544,
0.6292756199836731,
0.23748475313186646,
-0.24680693447589874,
0.5373901724815369,
-1.079600214958191,
0.44074127078056335,
-0.18153931200504303,
-0.3956035077571869,
-1.1578497886657715,
0.02978711947798729,
0.9104928374290466,
0.5054665207862854,
-0.3373135030269623,
0.5124937891960144,
0.2878774106502533,
0.8084637522697449,
-1.2542386054992676,
0.15085847675800323,
-0.8834138512611389,
0.029567580670118332,
-0.32058700919151306,
-0.3430124521255493,
-0.17285481095314026,
-0.25696197152137756,
-0.17866690456867218,
-0.9881331920623779,
0.08426658064126968,
-0.13657090067863464,
0.9848645925521851,
0.7255642414093018,
-0.32857826352119446,
0.1681322455406189,
-0.8094044327735901,
0.8793825507164001,
-0.47614744305610657,
0.2843923270702362,
0.3470420241355896,
0.4889451265335083,
0.07809127122163773,
-0.6224445700645447,
-0.09730285406112671,
0.058388952165842056,
0.4562380313873291,
0.027473436668515205,
0.06862857192754745,
-0.11136777698993683,
0.12177126109600067,
0.3712320029735565,
-0.0065506696701049805,
0.20439468324184418,
-0.20209425687789917,
0.42855140566825867,
0.6568640470504761,
0.0888446569442749,
-0.15428538620471954,
0.22625598311424255,
-0.34491369128227234,
-0.3783401846885681,
-0.918815553188324,
0.08101551234722137,
0.5532658100128174,
0.5102018117904663,
-0.12390753626823425,
-0.06801564991474152,
-0.2616930902004242,
0.5365840792655945,
0.5671566724777222,
-0.09005963057279587,
0.15976224839687347,
-0.172554612159729,
-0.2953334450721741,
0.06106586754322052,
0.09889133274555206,
0.15910233557224274,
-0.006046826485544443,
0.0846286416053772,
-0.22782652080059052,
-0.3629555106163025,
0.34907838702201843,
-0.968852162361145,
-0.513846218585968,
-0.06622543931007385,
-0.478412389755249,
-0.7820184230804443,
-0.17945441603660583,
-0.9724876880645752,
-0.4940232038497925,
-0.1470724493265152,
0.8599258065223694,
0.046222832053899765,
-0.14205650985240936,
0.11802839487791061,
0.08226870000362396,
0.052879609167575836,
0.6264323592185974,
-0.9911997318267822,
0.4456682503223419,
0.4789729714393616,
0.6480504870414734,
-0.1753900647163391,
-0.1909024566411972,
-1.5243678092956543,
0.2700735926628113,
-0.31359606981277466,
0.6510939002037048,
-0.6015227437019348,
-0.24312618374824524,
-0.36517494916915894,
0.030933484435081482,
-0.2771776020526886,
-0.6221009492874146,
0.5509482026100159,
-0.7130076289176941,
-0.45344674587249756,
-0.3503345847129822,
0.10938860476016998,
-0.02499816007912159,
0.02937810681760311,
-0.5974011421203613,
0.8676009774208069,
0.14318148791790009,
-0.31146422028541565,
0.6310022473335266,
-0.7508233785629272,
-0.5037899613380432,
-0.19144447147846222,
0.24825654923915863,
-0.7837802171707153,
0.2784993350505829,
0.5749137997627258,
0.39466288685798645,
-0.29335448145866394,
-0.054915353655815125,
-0.5744584798812866,
-0.685145914554596,
-0.18310566246509552,
-0.5020367503166199,
0.2868626117706299,
0.3464183211326599,
-0.3512534201145172,
0.44520145654678345,
-0.9776583313941956,
0.0013676033122465014,
0.23213188350200653,
-0.5422561168670654,
-0.21990089118480682,
0.296415239572525,
-0.06801522523164749,
-0.23592273890972137,
0.4309059679508209,
-0.10343515872955322,
0.48897528648376465,
-0.22966764867305756,
0.49573013186454773,
0.9462631344795227,
0.07765036076307297,
0.5237404704093933,
-0.26196494698524475,
0.6394530534744263,
-0.15758852660655975,
0.5283938050270081,
0.24124068021774292,
-0.17454341053962708,
-0.6310031414031982,
-0.6901251077651978,
0.6681824922561646,
0.08557598292827606,
-0.265067458152771,
0.25841858983039856,
-0.18917962908744812,
-0.3327235281467438,
-0.4722422659397125,
0.29336240887641907,
0.0944056585431099,
0.44954660534858704,
0.4044892191886902,
-0.016365977004170418,
-0.36837729811668396,
-0.6664416193962097,
0.025633886456489563,
0.20110644400119781,
0.17881983518600464,
0.2744227647781372,
0.24470460414886475,
0.06538757681846619,
0.37831026315689087,
-0.6960679888725281,
-0.5740352272987366,
0.037866946309804916,
0.20401813089847565,
0.26312336325645447,
0.6749495267868042,
0.8378483653068542,
-0.7423537969589233,
-0.6685990691184998,
-0.3287978172302246,
-0.20243866741657257,
0.03101305104792118,
-0.06551879644393921,
-0.3846350312232971,
-0.15074647963047028,
0.3471984267234802,
-0.08021869510412216,
0.40261510014533997,
0.7231705188751221,
-0.19735971093177795,
0.1420062929391861,
-0.7756373286247253,
0.1890314221382141,
-0.6746724247932434,
0.07350222766399384,
-0.3325307369232178,
-0.3004189729690552,
-0.10917120426893234,
0.2926783859729767,
0.0825011357665062,
-0.39379608631134033,
-0.22536540031433105,
0.21843260526657104,
-0.4775605797767639,
0.020669585093855858,
-0.16178569197654724,
-0.18329031765460968,
0.014514707028865814,
0.41956979036331177,
-0.2071269452571869,
1.1344666481018066,
0.5929242372512817,
-0.7940175533294678,
0.07692310214042664,
0.30001747608184814,
-0.32606807351112366,
0.4780966639518738,
-0.6507556438446045,
0.03725046664476395,
0.06470199674367905,
0.061066482216119766,
-0.8005701899528503,
-0.16621194779872894,
0.06899140030145645,
0.1845068633556366,
0.4546458125114441,
-0.7921105623245239,
-0.48192933201789856,
0.16415350139141083,
-0.6461536884307861,
0.5580102205276489,
0.9017531275749207,
-0.7905980944633484,
0.37345072627067566,
0.454315721988678,
-0.1769854724407196,
-0.20238572359085083,
-0.17478764057159424,
-0.1984093338251114,
-0.46685197949409485,
-0.4135074019432068,
0.5364971160888672,
-0.2668822407722473,
0.20494085550308228,
-0.2541634440422058,
-0.28443750739097595,
-0.020536350086331367,
0.6580721735954285,
0.19328653812408447,
-0.08438026160001755,
-0.3030189573764801,
0.050965193659067154,
0.48049360513687134,
-0.024372048676013947,
-0.31359532475471497,
-0.06478574126958847,
0.48309794068336487,
-0.20840130746364594,
-0.4164382219314575,
-0.3798559904098511,
0.08567016571760178,
0.9029604196548462,
-0.6264904737472534,
0.9686628580093384,
0.6237872242927551,
-0.04112499952316284,
-0.6630706191062927,
-0.10581577569246292,
-0.14230632781982422,
-0.54433274269104,
0.3723908066749573,
-0.6067391633987427,
-0.127924844622612,
0.5485769510269165,
-0.4645494222640991,
-0.035440750420093536,
0.27335548400878906,
0.26636239886283875,
-0.26002010703086853,
1.4503690004348755,
0.6393424868583679,
0.1497611552476883,
0.7763288617134094,
-0.47217217087745667,
0.11973601579666138,
-0.9824484586715698,
0.1073702946305275,
-0.3722096085548401,
-0.9894189238548279,
-0.60196453332901,
-0.38366568088531494,
0.808782696723938,
0.38635167479515076,
-0.5530252456665039,
-0.05569704622030258,
-0.5203317999839783,
0.3753313720226288,
0.5378580689430237,
0.30426329374313354,
0.26376938819885254,
0.15091949701309204,
0.4161025285720825,
0.03785652667284012,
-0.7628546953201294,
-0.10691878199577332,
1.1296563148498535,
0.3533605933189392,
1.036861777305603,
0.1978779137134552,
0.7255890369415283,
0.36936628818511963,
-0.10780703276395798,
-0.5871455669403076,
0.46195200085639954,
-0.5427842736244202,
-0.08285845071077347,
-0.406329482793808,
-0.29901671409606934,
-0.9201315641403198,
0.16395172476768494,
-0.4962053596973419,
-0.3241012692451477,
0.6788610219955444,
0.41452959179878235,
-0.7422440648078918,
0.3666662871837616,
-0.5423323512077332,
0.6960374712944031,
-0.24096886813640594,
-0.6161210536956787,
-0.5726014971733093,
-0.2108084112405777,
0.09062010049819946,
-0.5459306836128235,
-0.018861470744013786,
-0.42619624733924866,
-0.16961972415447235,
0.8282873034477234,
-0.7039851546287537,
0.5792570114135742,
-0.43919074535369873,
-0.19654887914657593,
-0.10906345397233963,
0.08318468928337097,
0.9685690999031067,
0.3152376711368561,
-0.3530735969543457,
-0.22022593021392822,
0.2209780514240265,
-0.6530817747116089,
-0.6822370886802673,
0.964320182800293,
-0.8785096406936646,
-0.4166758060455322,
-0.23963052034378052,
-0.6930921673774719,
-0.5273823738098145,
0.04340671747922897,
-0.06260129809379578,
0.44160032272338867,
0.1936347782611847,
0.41228729486465454,
0.7051619291305542,
-0.059069011360406876,
0.024152198806405067,
0.483366996049881,
-0.009072844870388508,
-0.24074941873550415,
0.9668763875961304,
0.059555355459451675,
0.16321681439876556,
0.29103025794029236,
0.2495591640472412,
-0.16489067673683167,
-0.8951869010925293,
-0.3050713837146759,
0.13828784227371216,
-0.5167539715766907,
-0.1537504345178604,
-0.05827765911817551,
0.00698689091950655,
-0.012235910631716251,
-0.39384791254997253,
-0.6961614489555359,
-0.39670097827911377,
-0.4676884710788727,
0.3009871542453766,
0.5417733192443848,
0.5251102447509766,
-0.11388334631919861,
0.5007497668266296,
-0.5448617935180664,
0.49072784185409546,
0.5382625460624695,
0.5179166197776794,
0.1981993466615677,
-0.7279013991355896,
-0.23371420800685883,
0.1802522987127304,
-0.28355786204338074,
-0.453550785779953,
0.22019913792610168,
0.6464020013809204,
0.45837920904159546,
0.46960943937301636,
0.48870742321014404,
1.2908824682235718,
-0.4415622055530548,
0.41146624088287354,
-0.1970556527376175,
-0.8563948273658752,
0.7628898024559021,
-0.5374329090118408,
0.055711645632982254,
0.7892844080924988,
0.014741327613592148,
0.3843224048614502,
-0.11366605013608932,
-0.5092987418174744,
-0.9198602437973022,
0.789766252040863,
0.05819292739033699,
0.04676366597414017,
0.3639243543148041,
0.40974703431129456,
0.06521233916282654,
0.28114408254623413,
-0.08082183450460434,
0.09208200126886368,
-0.01175285317003727,
-0.21855399012565613,
-0.14934828877449036,
-0.25559911131858826,
-0.18644031882286072,
-0.6220932602882385,
0.757574737071991,
-0.2454940229654312,
0.04802725091576576,
-0.24753281474113464,
-0.20156115293502808,
-0.45142316818237305,
-0.1045629158616066,
0.6112691164016724,
0.8214108943939209,
-0.7583457827568054,
0.12466007471084595,
0.3057686686515808,
-0.44027483463287354,
0.14364761114120483,
0.17940843105316162,
-0.22364197671413422,
-0.42329445481300354,
0.011012197472155094,
0.8264456391334534,
0.8263854384422302,
-0.5270094275474548,
0.3378993272781372,
0.07819195091724396,
-0.19349305331707,
0.06997212767601013,
0.4930568039417267,
-0.19248546659946442,
0.46893036365509033,
0.393149733543396,
0.21203087270259857,
-0.1694021075963974,
-0.59185391664505,
-0.03142112120985985,
0.4578125476837158,
-0.08027654886245728,
-0.4520798623561859,
1.01888108253479,
0.36693689227104187,
0.007218028884381056,
0.4717155694961548,
-0.06581556051969528,
-0.07348302751779556,
0.523936927318573,
0.3376614451408386,
0.6174412965774536,
-0.07487042993307114,
0.22622939944267273,
0.2124008685350418,
-0.10530070215463638,
-0.15543144941329956,
0.5187086462974548,
-0.2091512233018875,
-0.13118267059326172,
-0.28875067830085754,
-0.9354978203773499,
-0.29113438725471497,
0.2848205864429474,
-0.7764663100242615,
0.4740809500217438,
-0.7808207273483276,
-0.11459484696388245,
-0.0986994057893753,
0.24213531613349915,
-0.627964437007904,
-0.08555420488119125,
0.06650649756193161,
0.9536712765693665,
-0.7113802433013916,
0.8191676139831543,
0.8544725179672241,
-0.48037436604499817,
-0.6382012963294983,
0.1532272845506668,
-0.3275146782398224,
-0.7630228400230408,
0.8352525234222412,
-0.5395479202270508,
-0.34363406896591187,
0.3938000500202179,
-0.34336671233177185,
-1.20547354221344,
1.1285479068756104,
0.6575437188148499,
-0.4431321620941162,
-0.18430370092391968,
-0.2321581095457077,
0.2972370684146881,
-0.20604735612869263,
-0.21612896025180817,
0.21843722462654114,
0.6110292077064514,
0.12604184448719025,
-0.9527848362922668,
0.004084324464201927,
0.05743627995252609,
0.031053312122821808,
0.3787026107311249,
-0.7379618287086487,
1.1998887062072754,
-0.16424089670181274,
-0.0171204786747694,
0.2155570238828659,
0.4635986387729645,
0.32195207476615906,
0.0643879771232605,
0.81467604637146,
0.15011060237884521,
1.0877349376678467,
0.20186059176921844,
0.7047179341316223,
-0.39144575595855713,
0.5091146230697632,
1.026843547821045,
-0.4279240369796753,
1.086502194404602,
0.3498373329639435,
-0.2869851589202881,
0.49890661239624023,
0.6529582142829895,
-0.09145250171422958,
1.1565340757369995,
0.04606841877102852,
-0.1043023094534874,
-0.5954254269599915,
0.19096244871616364,
-0.43558618426322937,
0.4264148771762848,
0.1532333791255951,
-0.057336799800395966,
-0.44143813848495483,
0.16222083568572998,
-0.25621747970581055,
-0.13318468630313873,
-0.6378301978111267,
0.5713204145431519,
-0.167537659406662,
-0.34004470705986023,
1.2739393711090088,
-0.045437730848789215,
0.4688153862953186,
-0.6575329303741455,
-0.09501463174819946,
-0.2237996906042099,
0.5984277725219727,
-0.07290418446063995,
-0.3199964165687561,
0.0355854369699955,
0.04361854866147041,
-0.3188697397708893,
-0.3883446455001831,
0.5604867935180664,
-0.22221730649471283,
-0.48061180114746094,
-0.09184455126523972,
0.31186407804489136,
-0.07225945591926575,
-0.2402368187904358,
-0.6307841539382935,
0.3949694335460663,
-0.4091913402080536,
-0.23993468284606934,
0.8031860589981079,
0.161453515291214,
-0.19230905175209045,
0.6114989519119263,
0.7232627272605896,
0.4314141869544983,
-0.036494795233011246,
0.0226194616407156,
0.9195550084114075,
-0.22880546748638153,
-0.8445505499839783,
-0.3603358864784241,
0.3898216784000397,
0.0383877195417881,
-0.12374593317508698,
0.4278806149959564,
0.43206048011779785,
0.4678581655025482,
-0.16316808760166168,
0.3132290542125702,
0.27813592553138733,
0.44812673330307007,
-0.5982658267021179,
1.0662680864334106,
-1.1351723670959473,
0.4877045452594757,
-0.2417486310005188,
-0.8790366053581238,
-0.08871528506278992,
0.7545989155769348,
-0.4187425374984741,
-0.04544113203883171,
0.26076680421829224,
0.48213571310043335,
-0.8349374532699585,
-0.4026140570640564,
0.25323668122291565,
0.2488030642271042,
0.24174001812934875,
0.5965042114257812,
0.6710606813430786,
-0.5667353868484497,
0.5321311354637146,
-0.09464836120605469,
-0.19877129793167114,
-0.6895450949668884,
-1.0406066179275513,
-0.6151120066642761,
-0.546637237071991,
-0.6111338138580322,
-0.07853060960769653,
0.4027806520462036,
0.660888671875,
1.3423337936401367,
-0.7614892721176147,
0.07726066559553146,
0.017013436183333397,
0.05817234888672829,
-0.6980447769165039,
-0.14196236431598663,
0.6498390436172485,
-0.5022999048233032,
-0.8701965808868408,
0.6964733600616455,
0.0667758584022522,
-0.15181483328342438,
-0.12655368447303772,
-0.1656780242919922,
-0.08977898210287094,
0.141030415892601,
0.6206605434417725,
0.17921897768974304,
-0.33376190066337585,
-0.38535869121551514,
-0.29737192392349243,
0.4167524576187134,
0.12930601835250854,
0.3793787956237793,
-0.9964445233345032,
0.20245516300201416,
0.46820101141929626,
0.528891921043396,
0.7837336659431458,
0.2793820798397064,
0.47276008129119873,
-0.7787713408470154,
0.21223661303520203,
0.02925543300807476,
0.11528903245925903,
-0.07893352210521698,
-0.3841884434223175,
0.41134676337242126,
0.12063930928707123,
-0.40908533334732056,
-1.3962376117706299,
0.1480480581521988,
-1.1028658151626587,
-0.3191832900047302,
0.7473952174186707,
0.05801357328891754,
-0.18646293878555298,
0.2815231680870056,
-0.15163180232048035,
0.042322788387537,
-0.35170838236808777,
0.8658303618431091,
0.1450256109237671,
-0.019533339887857437,
-0.21774818003177643,
-0.5127250552177429,
0.8021476864814758,
0.43115323781967163,
-0.790613055229187,
0.09541015326976776,
-0.0030580637976527214,
0.5058284997940063,
-0.2730255424976349,
0.30597254633903503,
0.13855980336666107,
0.3198780119419098,
-0.21167747676372528,
-0.5308892130851746,
-0.48423704504966736,
-0.5011491775512695,
-0.2760162055492401,
0.524344265460968,
0.4245586693286896,
-0.5730500221252441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17345v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17345v2
|
Exploring and steering the moral compass of Large Language Models
| 2024-05-27T16:49:22 | 2024-06-06T11:53:23 |
Alejandro Tlaie
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have become central to advancing automation and
decision-making across various sectors, raising significant ethical questions.
This study proposes a comprehensive comparative analysis of the most advanced
LLMs to assess their moral profiles. We subjected several state-of-the-art
models to a selection of ethical dilemmas and found that all the proprietary
ones are mostly utilitarian and all of the open-weights ones align mostly with
values-based ethics. Furthermore, when using the Moral Foundations
Questionnaire, all models we probed - except for Llama 2-7B - displayed a
strong liberal bias. Lastly, in order to causally intervene in one of the
studied models, we propose a novel similarity-specific activation steering
technique. Using this method, we were able to reliably steer the model's moral
compass to different ethical schools. All of these results showcase that there
is an ethical dimension in already deployed LLMs, an aspect that is generally
overlooked.
|
[
-0.16079308092594147,
-0.4914264380931854,
0.9072773456573486,
0.12895259261131287,
-0.11249734461307526,
0.1391390711069107,
-0.22838418185710907,
-0.5173354148864746,
-0.450289785861969,
0.7539873719215393,
-0.4735923409461975,
-0.3001488447189331,
-0.6044337153434753,
0.20755784213542938,
-0.4078635573387146,
0.91126948595047,
0.33399084210395813,
0.5223919153213501,
-0.11304895579814911,
-0.45217400789260864,
-0.03249600902199745,
-0.5414769649505615,
-0.8897504806518555,
-0.7367727756500244,
0.5300401449203491,
0.03811126574873924,
1.0146491527557373,
0.8138324022293091,
0.5988870859146118,
0.3229231536388397,
-0.4347482919692993,
-0.23258744180202484,
-0.6216487884521484,
-0.08669117838144302,
-0.5581821203231812,
-0.4149631857872009,
-0.587249219417572,
0.3629830479621887,
0.46801331639289856,
0.5720345377922058,
0.0032257288694381714,
0.4784868657588959,
-0.0721815750002861,
0.5861585736274719,
-0.5061076283454895,
-0.14546692371368408,
-0.6991978883743286,
-0.17455218732357025,
0.22141920030117035,
-0.18275825679302216,
-0.39314064383506775,
-0.7391341924667358,
0.19733045995235443,
-0.42969608306884766,
-0.5103030800819397,
0.2521575093269348,
0.6581154465675354,
0.21936513483524323,
-0.7625974416732788,
-0.5993187427520752,
-0.5149198770523071,
1.5785620212554932,
-0.8679971694946289,
0.3198617696762085,
0.24994608759880066,
0.003198638092726469,
-0.10259508341550827,
-0.3813819885253906,
-0.5046119689941406,
-0.29512858390808105,
0.22530096769332886,
-0.1469547301530838,
-0.12537457048892975,
0.060245633125305176,
0.14593204855918884,
0.16912858188152313,
-0.1925612837076187,
0.7346209287643433,
-0.3012479543685913,
0.0333636999130249,
0.615972638130188,
0.18780000507831573,
0.07632674276828766,
-0.07574467360973358,
-0.3563041090965271,
-0.2461330145597458,
-1.030714988708496,
0.2448805421590805,
0.6895583271980286,
0.0033302174415439367,
-0.13190047442913055,
0.7156550884246826,
0.08837631344795227,
0.4018116593360901,
0.10546425729990005,
-0.3134838342666626,
0.2174815833568573,
-0.1905284821987152,
-0.43888431787490845,
0.13823217153549194,
0.9168806672096252,
0.877254068851471,
0.9773563146591187,
0.47585684061050415,
-0.3563765287399292,
-0.2377980649471283,
0.3038375675678253,
-0.5671550631523132,
0.28253886103630066,
0.46936655044555664,
-0.8385096192359924,
-0.6551084518432617,
-0.13174976408481598,
-0.38494521379470825,
-0.6811352968215942,
-0.6037085056304932,
0.0988057479262352,
-0.07565883547067642,
-0.31202903389930725,
0.24083958566188812,
0.03859724476933479,
0.908511757850647,
0.14254331588745117,
-0.6130235195159912,
-0.26416489481925964,
1.1885348558425903,
0.6569347381591797,
-0.059491995722055435,
0.04607909545302391,
-0.5585854649543762,
0.13274666666984558,
-0.509965181350708,
0.41902288794517517,
-0.9908937215805054,
-0.48161301016807556,
0.09697746485471725,
0.09788814932107925,
0.4685411751270294,
-0.45376425981521606,
0.6426401138305664,
-0.5290008187294006,
0.048569902777671814,
-0.6108950972557068,
-0.32922494411468506,
-0.5927449464797974,
0.3295256495475769,
-0.6288018822669983,
0.7873410582542419,
-0.15430596470832825,
-0.6017746329307556,
0.3803703486919403,
-0.5483353734016418,
-0.17375674843788147,
-0.1960674673318863,
-0.49846652150154114,
-0.473518967628479,
0.010910006240010262,
-0.059412769973278046,
0.6499773859977722,
-0.8542057871818542,
0.6462713479995728,
-0.5201244354248047,
-0.2838971018791199,
0.3775847554206848,
-0.5247555375099182,
1.3482463359832764,
0.0609823539853096,
-0.30721938610076904,
0.38179099559783936,
-0.5699687004089355,
-0.08301432430744171,
0.20445002615451813,
-0.01760036125779152,
-0.552773118019104,
0.05177950859069824,
-0.11063538491725922,
0.44124361872673035,
0.4021828770637512,
-0.3787524998188019,
-0.039894819259643555,
-0.11378712207078934,
0.4655568301677704,
1.1502560377120972,
-0.10832089930772781,
0.6075631380081177,
-0.6055002212524414,
0.43820032477378845,
-0.35880187153816223,
0.4947153329849243,
0.25731247663497925,
-0.4040986895561218,
-0.7673037648200989,
-0.15835422277450562,
-0.4174136519432068,
0.554891049861908,
-0.04877382516860962,
0.5670300722122192,
-0.2723574936389923,
-0.3845425248146057,
-0.6893330812454224,
0.057865485548973083,
0.4114992916584015,
0.22450494766235352,
0.22052238881587982,
0.027355672791600227,
0.12065843492746353,
-1.140579104423523,
-0.5314083695411682,
-0.36954763531684875,
-0.01765034906566143,
0.425308495759964,
0.5010208487510681,
-0.1873117834329605,
0.652783989906311,
0.02605021931231022,
0.10526561737060547,
-0.15756765007972717,
-0.07634949684143066,
0.33164331316947937,
0.39599090814590454,
0.623631477355957,
-0.9091344475746155,
-0.15469741821289062,
0.3556458353996277,
-0.8856627941131592,
-0.24002854526042938,
-0.19870513677597046,
-0.09318538010120392,
0.0070043583400547504,
0.5603697299957275,
-0.33818382024765015,
0.09845585376024246,
0.5728604793548584,
-0.31669479608535767,
0.5604824423789978,
0.058736495673656464,
0.2974565625190735,
-0.803955614566803,
0.11883009225130081,
-0.1633322387933731,
-0.13834458589553833,
-0.4297047257423401,
-0.023885421454906464,
0.03670709952712059,
0.47857242822647095,
-0.5821229219436646,
0.37735050916671753,
-0.2522931694984436,
-0.4353558123111725,
-0.14579685032367706,
0.07652949541807175,
-0.0874788761138916,
0.10789871215820312,
-0.11475639790296555,
0.7376161217689514,
0.5428880453109741,
-0.5409315228462219,
0.587158739566803,
0.2182420939207077,
-0.21100327372550964,
0.8253279328346252,
-0.772555410861969,
0.008395945653319359,
-0.12724219262599945,
-0.03786855936050415,
-0.39353281259536743,
0.1867016702890396,
-0.028295334428548813,
-0.19551029801368713,
-0.19174912571907043,
-0.04813459888100624,
-0.43798983097076416,
-0.07606562972068787,
-0.62412428855896,
0.4002920389175415,
0.7699463367462158,
-0.3744915723800659,
0.653824508190155,
0.3230452239513397,
-0.44764524698257446,
-0.7871231436729431,
-0.5350631475448608,
-0.12171106040477753,
-0.5961204171180725,
-0.5513142347335815,
-0.20483800768852234,
0.1461605727672577,
-0.8809565305709839,
-0.20583631098270416,
-0.0007642920245416462,
0.37491166591644287,
0.14635837078094482,
0.21498030424118042,
0.2838054299354553,
-0.21367862820625305,
-0.025903357192873955,
0.2744770646095276,
-0.14747203886508942,
0.3965734839439392,
-0.2247590273618698,
0.4479570984840393,
-0.5581831336021423,
-0.445483535528183,
-0.3624487519264221,
0.26144638657569885,
0.9384438395500183,
-0.6105682849884033,
0.7116693258285522,
0.2091604620218277,
-0.0625266581773758,
-0.015899736434221268,
-0.7925702333450317,
-0.07080905139446259,
-0.5919438004493713,
0.26508191227912903,
0.15358835458755493,
-1.0139014720916748,
0.4625934958457947,
-0.21830347180366516,
0.5052061676979065,
0.2614251375198364,
0.8087038397789001,
-0.04995262622833252,
0.938683807849884,
0.7709225416183472,
-0.041878681629896164,
0.4718702733516693,
-0.2834629416465759,
0.3184353709220886,
-0.8596487641334534,
-0.27316924929618835,
-0.4382650554180145,
-0.0966358631849289,
-0.7508577704429626,
-0.42444926500320435,
0.39340054988861084,
0.02163609117269516,
-0.9434224367141724,
0.06665779650211334,
-0.32952791452407837,
0.6435979008674622,
0.315742552280426,
-0.5632643699645996,
0.7900794744491577,
-0.058643314987421036,
-0.14053210616111755,
0.40661099553108215,
-0.43018049001693726,
-1.229028582572937,
1.0819720029830933,
0.48413053154945374,
0.8363465666770935,
0.03882485628128052,
0.4178585708141327,
0.05359288305044174,
0.4463304877281189,
-0.7346926927566528,
0.7564223408699036,
-0.2700834572315216,
-0.40787971019744873,
-0.33900678157806396,
-0.36701515316963196,
-0.7459153532981873,
0.286485493183136,
-0.1723593771457672,
-0.8200105428695679,
0.19933953881263733,
-0.2671586871147156,
-0.408080518245697,
0.4092083275318146,
-0.3960391879081726,
0.5866214632987976,
-0.7273625135421753,
-0.40470588207244873,
-0.49587610363960266,
-0.7293582558631897,
0.3128102123737335,
-0.21638360619544983,
0.3796418309211731,
-0.41501468420028687,
-0.2133263200521469,
0.6534630060195923,
-0.020267656072974205,
0.6225923299789429,
0.2801707088947296,
-0.670863687992096,
0.16215243935585022,
0.10962316393852234,
0.4890277087688446,
-0.08137330412864685,
-0.6035035848617554,
0.19252003729343414,
0.08898573368787766,
-0.06281278282403946,
-0.2858548164367676,
1.0073550939559937,
-0.6400238275527954,
-0.6440483927726746,
-0.4627987742424011,
-0.47275251150131226,
-0.2434977889060974,
0.3404605984687805,
0.040824439376592636,
0.26752808690071106,
-0.18215012550354004,
0.46290943026542664,
0.6682971715927124,
-0.7241798639297485,
0.5289397239685059,
0.5404143929481506,
-0.24508601427078247,
-0.03948117047548294,
0.4709906280040741,
-0.22704139351844788,
0.6967575550079346,
0.021526983007788658,
0.3609203100204468,
-0.5056893825531006,
-0.31171900033950806,
-0.43931347131729126,
0.5356770753860474,
-0.8517490029335022,
-0.1880953460931778,
-0.4610578715801239,
-0.07324618846178055,
0.008468521758913994,
-0.7868378162384033,
-0.5534229278564453,
0.013663733378052711,
-0.3862781524658203,
-0.29002583026885986,
0.6782499551773071,
0.965175986289978,
0.2633838355541229,
0.22961777448654175,
-0.6610521078109741,
0.10075168311595917,
0.05626494437456131,
0.4036189615726471,
0.12010746449232101,
-0.3643890917301178,
0.43199867010116577,
0.1510222852230072,
-0.27452942728996277,
-0.5942956805229187,
0.0803312435746193,
-0.1197897270321846,
0.48414865136146545,
0.6118066310882568,
0.07329361885786057,
0.3474445641040802,
-0.3090580701828003,
0.6854888200759888,
0.3145391047000885,
-0.9726302027702332,
-0.013251857832074165,
-0.4948938190937042,
0.03063475713133812,
0.48879003524780273,
0.5859595537185669,
-0.39053937792778015,
-0.4743588864803314,
-0.5014752149581909,
-0.7261461615562439,
0.38483211398124695,
0.20335747301578522,
0.2071211189031601,
0.2164829522371292,
0.3106555938720703,
0.1543799787759781,
0.27244535088539124,
-0.8560219407081604,
-0.08604443818330765,
0.18952542543411255,
-0.4530724883079529,
0.12920215725898743,
0.03408798202872276,
-0.19668111205101013,
0.0030987297650426626,
0.539599597454071,
0.027578411623835564,
-0.15465381741523743,
-0.04345615208148956,
0.05915011838078499,
-0.14513328671455383,
0.5282803773880005,
0.2654785215854645,
0.7996460199356079,
0.11536752432584763,
-0.008864895440638065,
0.2443520873785019,
-0.3012396991252899,
0.41927358508110046,
-0.339682936668396,
-0.18199674785137177,
-0.5650985240936279,
0.37204188108444214,
0.3906298875808716,
0.058564286679029465,
-0.8630043268203735,
0.7487401366233826,
0.32976430654525757,
0.007148693315684795,
-0.37556472420692444,
-0.11501964926719666,
0.18559108674526215,
0.6345142126083374,
0.14994454383850098,
-0.4636334180831909,
0.13044773042201996,
-0.6195259094238281,
-0.11542908847332001,
0.8128384947776794,
-0.17250186204910278,
0.06686578691005707,
0.39616361260414124,
0.4289695918560028,
-0.23426097631454468,
0.5344749689102173,
-0.2271602898836136,
-0.6239632964134216,
0.6534699201583862,
0.21368692815303802,
0.8809870481491089,
-0.062195952981710434,
0.2175709307193756,
0.028591476380825043,
0.5591554045677185,
-0.3746829628944397,
0.31078001856803894,
0.1626979261636734,
-0.7308595180511475,
-0.6157966256141663,
-0.712142825126648,
-0.39203742146492004,
0.17262530326843262,
-0.8389014005661011,
0.20937679708003998,
-0.561489462852478,
-0.2997872233390808,
-0.40086233615875244,
-0.10294593125581741,
-0.3772026300430298,
0.05371361970901489,
0.003899576608091593,
0.5130612254142761,
-0.5563235282897949,
0.6082528829574585,
0.5264761447906494,
-0.0719367042183876,
-0.6193262934684753,
-0.1324314922094345,
0.08384840190410614,
-0.8909721970558167,
0.5406370759010315,
0.2507326304912567,
-0.8243545889854431,
0.018238570541143417,
-0.7010231018066406,
-0.6369971036911011,
1.245369553565979,
0.2587914764881134,
-0.8299697041511536,
-0.029252996668219566,
0.2616865932941437,
0.2829093337059021,
-0.34918659925460815,
0.08689398318529129,
0.8277537226676941,
0.6094426512718201,
-0.1677848994731903,
-1.2039557695388794,
0.14511898159980774,
0.06365907937288284,
-0.14809943735599518,
0.26716288924217224,
-0.800186276435852,
0.7717925310134888,
-0.42664316296577454,
-0.06814132630825043,
0.1988220065832138,
0.2976008355617523,
0.4860498309135437,
0.23597899079322815,
0.4838193655014038,
0.023869674652814865,
0.7488977909088135,
0.11032382398843765,
0.8452618718147278,
-0.28802022337913513,
0.4434417188167572,
0.6686257719993591,
-0.5616390705108643,
0.6157948970794678,
0.6950944662094116,
0.13992035388946533,
0.3384324312210083,
0.18042714893817902,
-0.31791549921035767,
0.057238560169935226,
0.30295154452323914,
-0.0221575815230608,
-0.4570392072200775,
-0.45250847935676575,
-0.24445870518684387,
0.5180178284645081,
0.3911055326461792,
-0.6043452024459839,
-0.003192854579538107,
-0.10069746524095535,
0.11495891958475113,
-0.016132215037941933,
-0.6463951468467712,
0.7210229635238647,
0.4970046877861023,
-0.45058566331863403,
0.43300554156303406,
0.07740840315818787,
0.8029515147209167,
-0.6097449660301208,
0.10983525216579437,
0.1310083568096161,
0.14832431077957153,
-0.06589657813310623,
-1.0999287366867065,
0.10871637612581253,
0.46491149067878723,
0.2552667558193207,
-0.5248742699623108,
0.45418936014175415,
-0.15963011980056763,
-0.3849256634712219,
0.6979666948318481,
0.45606544613838196,
0.0042989784851670265,
0.13836237788200378,
-0.7918007373809814,
0.3319164514541626,
-0.1648038923740387,
-0.30590546131134033,
0.055652838200330734,
0.30684617161750793,
-0.3963882327079773,
1.1840351819992065,
0.6531511545181274,
-0.07578887790441513,
-0.08995597064495087,
0.027089187875390053,
0.6877706050872803,
-0.903366208076477,
-0.37713924050331116,
-0.906868040561676,
0.23830319941043854,
-0.1556645929813385,
-0.35839205980300903,
0.6649562120437622,
0.22646643221378326,
0.8373528718948364,
0.15755070745944977,
0.6568174362182617,
0.3132472336292267,
0.017965801060199738,
-0.7970379590988159,
0.9765216112136841,
-0.58320552110672,
0.44525378942489624,
-0.23978930711746216,
-1.016876220703125,
-0.0831218883395195,
1.0116959810256958,
-0.5683324337005615,
0.30983099341392517,
0.46636074781417847,
0.7882155776023865,
0.09628855437040329,
0.20760248601436615,
0.261993944644928,
0.27384525537490845,
0.4557768702507019,
0.5371137261390686,
1.2354124784469604,
0.1330571323633194,
0.32648950815200806,
0.11371295899152756,
-0.283740758895874,
-0.2125319093465805,
-1.271621823310852,
-1.0548095703125,
-0.28113409876823425,
-0.06258574873209,
-0.07066690176725388,
-0.004779112990945578,
1.2720650434494019,
0.44545629620552063,
-0.6745256781578064,
-0.4484096169471741,
0.05925482511520386,
0.2448081225156784,
0.08288346230983734,
-0.1220906525850296,
0.14306727051734924,
0.24249669909477234,
-0.6264294385910034,
0.055040083825588226,
0.5653659701347351,
0.1080632284283638,
-0.48705849051475525,
-0.08310841768980026,
-0.12708331644535065,
0.5285624265670776,
0.7899087071418762,
-0.01848727837204933,
-1.0602103471755981,
-0.4032672643661499,
0.09639569371938705,
-0.1924068182706833,
-0.1734853833913803,
0.9825853705406189,
-0.29012104868888855,
-0.03567206487059593,
0.3173282742500305,
0.5954031348228455,
-0.31148698925971985,
0.10227183997631073,
0.7966417074203491,
0.10990246385335922,
0.005722851026803255,
0.5958296060562134,
0.3093309998512268,
0.4319221079349518,
-0.24717238545417786,
0.26515325903892517,
-0.31143125891685486,
-0.7554649710655212,
-0.7997225522994995,
0.48155733942985535,
-1.1365933418273926,
-0.1697002500295639,
1.6623458862304688,
0.12864114344120026,
-0.033232226967811584,
-0.19240154325962067,
-0.31164681911468506,
0.059485819190740585,
-0.405931293964386,
0.3424978256225586,
0.611433744430542,
0.13793206214904785,
0.14694499969482422,
-0.6387012004852295,
0.38355937600135803,
0.5483779907226562,
-0.6374466419219971,
0.30536919832229614,
0.5341821908950806,
0.39533111453056335,
-0.06943187117576599,
0.18417629599571228,
-0.4298143684864044,
0.19933059811592102,
-0.5169346332550049,
-0.17505399882793427,
0.05505111441016197,
-0.27666983008384705,
-0.516055703163147,
-0.1684415340423584,
0.23195035755634308,
0.384115993976593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17337v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17337v1
|
Cost-efficient Knowledge-based Question Answering with Large Language Models
| 2024-05-27T16:37:34 | 2024-05-27T16:37:34 |
Junnan Dong, Qinggang Zhang, Chuang Zhou, Hao Chen, Daochen Zha, Xiao Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Knowledge-based question answering (KBQA) is widely used in many scenarios
that necessitate domain knowledge. Large language models (LLMs) bring
opportunities to KBQA, while their costs are significantly higher and absence
of domain-specific knowledge during pre-training. We are motivated to combine
LLMs and prior small models on knowledge graphs (KGMs) for both inferential
accuracy and cost saving. However, it remains challenging since accuracy and
cost are not readily combined in the optimization as two distinct metrics. It
is also laborious for model selection since different models excel in diverse
knowledge. To this end, we propose Coke, a novel cost-efficient strategy for
KBQA with LLMs, modeled as a tailored multi-armed bandit problem to minimize
calls to LLMs within limited budgets. We first formulate the accuracy
expectation with a cluster-level Thompson Sampling for either KGMs or LLMs. A
context-aware policy is optimized to further distinguish the expert model
subject to the question semantics. The overall decision is bounded by the cost
regret according to historical expenditure on failures. Extensive experiments
showcase the superior performance of Coke, which moves the Pareto frontier with
up to 20.89% saving of GPT-4 fees while achieving a 2.74% higher accuracy on
the benchmark datasets.
|
[
-0.18817004561424255,
-0.7527984380722046,
0.6629304885864258,
0.08195098489522934,
0.13333752751350403,
0.30618351697921753,
-0.2136378139257431,
-0.14959433674812317,
-0.1022019311785698,
0.5900071263313293,
-0.4897851347923279,
-0.3519335091114044,
-0.411271870136261,
-0.10667786002159119,
0.14811226725578308,
0.674523115158081,
-0.08360493183135986,
0.05820643529295921,
-0.397323340177536,
0.046956807374954224,
-0.5312142968177795,
-0.45857641100883484,
-0.6871296167373657,
-0.26394739747047424,
0.657275915145874,
0.36667945981025696,
0.6421472430229187,
0.35781559348106384,
0.0918230414390564,
0.1748870313167572,
-0.1429624706506729,
0.35770225524902344,
-0.5391210913658142,
0.023210611194372177,
-0.046107228845357895,
-0.5256277918815613,
-0.10431985557079315,
-0.0901690274477005,
0.09644132852554321,
0.7311810851097107,
-0.14340664446353912,
-0.15621711313724518,
0.013370892032980919,
0.5969602465629578,
-0.8272251486778259,
0.2424674928188324,
-0.9475333094596863,
-0.42485329508781433,
0.14527633786201477,
0.017709171399474144,
-0.36383819580078125,
-0.5806127786636353,
0.2233934998512268,
-0.6068264842033386,
-0.1967753916978836,
0.03196384757757187,
0.8054116368293762,
0.42520278692245483,
-0.47613224387168884,
-0.7749671936035156,
-0.38011863827705383,
0.8338072299957275,
-0.4697044789791107,
0.4667051136493683,
0.26924630999565125,
0.4668227434158325,
-0.19425909221172333,
-0.7063217759132385,
-0.4655483365058899,
-0.11458885669708252,
0.07044318318367004,
0.14107444882392883,
-0.2937726080417633,
0.044565360993146896,
-0.11710282415151596,
-0.20515578985214233,
-0.40408846735954285,
0.10473700612783432,
-0.4793996512889862,
-0.464207261800766,
0.3818517327308655,
-0.019149957224726677,
-0.09424082189798355,
-0.26963934302330017,
-0.524861752986908,
0.09924743324518204,
-0.9525130987167358,
0.20122164487838745,
0.3368164002895355,
0.49072331190109253,
0.2989288866519928,
0.4548570513725281,
-0.44805604219436646,
0.7823787331581116,
-0.08444533497095108,
-0.5233407616615295,
-0.14408285915851593,
-0.12298396974802017,
-0.2497858852148056,
-0.028978025540709496,
0.3538973331451416,
0.2239605337381363,
0.4781128764152527,
-0.3563067615032196,
0.04085436835885048,
-0.25140810012817383,
0.0620238333940506,
-0.9738313555717468,
-0.4805777072906494,
0.4104941487312317,
-0.14436030387878418,
-0.02412806637585163,
-0.6208307147026062,
-0.47046807408332825,
-0.42321011424064636,
-0.0846683531999588,
0.7484632134437561,
-0.47822263836860657,
0.08227226883172989,
-0.02033054269850254,
-0.0940379723906517,
0.27517518401145935,
0.49059802293777466,
-0.48882925510406494,
-0.05732664465904236,
0.4838302731513977,
0.6369696855545044,
0.3268570899963379,
0.003918202593922615,
-0.6549307703971863,
0.38976049423217773,
-0.4687967598438263,
0.8738191723823547,
-0.5063751935958862,
-0.3050108551979065,
-0.06245730072259903,
-0.47548192739486694,
-0.11401896178722382,
-0.6898283958435059,
0.34875962138175964,
-0.9691159725189209,
0.2120354026556015,
-0.5108931660652161,
-0.8051708340644836,
-0.2315349578857422,
0.45168015360832214,
-0.38386619091033936,
0.886838972568512,
0.39257264137268066,
-0.5687748789787292,
0.5033707022666931,
-0.4792343080043793,
-0.31214287877082825,
0.3220668137073517,
-0.010039161890745163,
-0.030177395790815353,
-0.3251660168170929,
0.6254198551177979,
0.48510074615478516,
-0.5491291880607605,
0.5218318104743958,
-0.3195592761039734,
-0.2109840214252472,
0.12057437747716904,
-0.21949122846126556,
0.8387497067451477,
0.4326433837413788,
0.04789147898554802,
-0.04013722762465477,
-0.346281498670578,
0.22674879431724548,
-0.04021161422133446,
-0.6049644351005554,
-0.4197787642478943,
-0.010061425156891346,
-0.35364529490470886,
0.2497410923242569,
0.38306888937950134,
-0.44775545597076416,
0.12049654871225357,
-0.2684771418571472,
0.44125881791114807,
0.73536616563797,
-0.03203463926911354,
0.44511374831199646,
-0.16682928800582886,
0.593743085861206,
-0.274547278881073,
0.17185068130493164,
0.1990705132484436,
-0.4418122470378876,
-0.45808184146881104,
-0.6528065204620361,
0.49300891160964966,
0.6296745538711548,
-1.1830791234970093,
0.06489691138267517,
-0.18991364538669586,
-0.5073788166046143,
-0.4603186249732971,
0.1745782047510147,
0.29104679822921753,
0.8396973609924316,
0.3276883065700531,
0.2208806872367859,
-0.11923350393772125,
-1.002138614654541,
-0.489085853099823,
-0.19716764986515045,
-0.22179953753948212,
0.74997878074646,
0.4198172390460968,
0.2405700981616974,
1.3624826669692993,
-0.9562551975250244,
-0.2014503926038742,
-0.28822973370552063,
-0.04249566048383713,
0.2652708888053894,
0.13733333349227905,
0.6034886240959167,
-0.7598535418510437,
-0.7221975922584534,
-0.25333744287490845,
-0.29675692319869995,
-0.21096737682819366,
0.08089029043912888,
-0.17361055314540863,
0.33850952982902527,
0.4168648421764374,
-0.5804284811019897,
0.02180878445506096,
0.4931607246398926,
-0.006119254976511002,
0.40848061442375183,
-0.15380823612213135,
0.151534765958786,
-0.9322847723960876,
0.0320647768676281,
-0.28247877955436707,
-0.12191776931285858,
-0.5948100090026855,
-0.1312032788991928,
0.3398214280605316,
-0.2318800985813141,
-0.539158284664154,
0.7143393158912659,
-0.35168522596359253,
0.1507028341293335,
-0.2606339454650879,
0.3243328332901001,
-0.0030117137357592583,
0.8495562076568604,
-0.0024185283109545708,
0.9583411812782288,
0.5129004120826721,
-0.5475378036499023,
0.2781452238559723,
0.3057384490966797,
-0.4952361285686493,
0.5748472809791565,
-0.7029992341995239,
0.25142955780029297,
-0.3390064835548401,
0.3454432189464569,
-0.9855332374572754,
-0.09229805320501328,
0.20694400370121002,
-0.5208940505981445,
0.24818561971187592,
-0.5392187237739563,
-0.3612339198589325,
-0.19290073215961456,
-0.1881444752216339,
0.10938038676977158,
0.6524794101715088,
-0.6217623353004456,
0.7141680121421814,
0.5792083144187927,
-0.4392455220222473,
-0.8809466361999512,
-0.3168999254703522,
0.0248288381844759,
-0.3138783276081085,
-0.6480039358139038,
0.13991530239582062,
-0.012884074822068214,
-0.025452537462115288,
0.14144761860370636,
-0.4407429099082947,
-0.3793710470199585,
0.036161188036203384,
-0.34399306774139404,
0.15707269310951233,
0.017598962411284447,
0.30660131573677063,
0.1510680615901947,
-0.018373552709817886,
0.11870148032903671,
-0.6309946179389954,
0.685840368270874,
0.07991954684257507,
0.08310040831565857,
0.17662794888019562,
0.3914710283279419,
0.3819906413555145,
-0.2347828596830368,
0.8137544989585876,
0.19627274572849274,
-0.34753820300102234,
-0.2690802812576294,
-0.6144596934318542,
0.03018743172287941,
-0.45277586579322815,
0.5383884310722351,
-0.5505549311637878,
-0.9593406319618225,
0.40847623348236084,
-0.17434437572956085,
-0.10348207503557205,
0.22806581854820251,
0.553476095199585,
-0.2541109025478363,
0.7918193936347961,
0.053190018981695175,
-0.18479037284851074,
0.04107414931058884,
-0.06526374071836472,
0.615467369556427,
-0.5586786270141602,
-0.34917813539505005,
-0.8130647540092468,
-0.0810694545507431,
-0.42328521609306335,
-0.7158365845680237,
0.9215945601463318,
0.27471891045570374,
-0.4853849709033966,
0.10574328154325485,
-0.10122855007648468,
0.5971359610557556,
0.9108390808105469,
0.2475731372833252,
0.1413588672876358,
-0.24824000895023346,
0.08457677066326141,
0.16825717687606812,
-1.2029517889022827,
-0.2163553386926651,
1.2772228717803955,
0.06700825691223145,
0.8554144501686096,
0.08978781849145889,
0.5440240502357483,
0.039968252182006836,
0.3105820119380951,
-0.7688361406326294,
0.43642285466194153,
0.08157475292682648,
-0.7980512380599976,
-0.4455881416797638,
-0.8414442539215088,
-0.7268071174621582,
0.2414422482252121,
-0.24442365765571594,
-0.6022046208381653,
-0.010351451113820076,
0.47356685996055603,
-0.35751792788505554,
0.3447781801223755,
-0.7365891933441162,
0.7974932193756104,
-0.3044968247413635,
-0.2596963942050934,
-0.11224327981472015,
-0.6999176144599915,
0.3211837410926819,
-0.1394375115633011,
0.19170233607292175,
-0.10635852068662643,
-0.17674753069877625,
0.6815328001976013,
-0.42341965436935425,
0.45146188139915466,
-0.5482775568962097,
0.005555087234824896,
0.3824532926082611,
-0.0021978155709803104,
0.8659095764160156,
-0.09008123725652695,
0.15957343578338623,
-0.06841485947370529,
-0.06313155591487885,
-0.6088946461677551,
-0.7309476137161255,
0.665673553943634,
-0.579777717590332,
-0.6056521534919739,
-0.2624228000640869,
-0.9413096904754639,
-0.7568351626396179,
0.18041488528251648,
0.04470505192875862,
0.40854620933532715,
0.20034874975681305,
0.28840377926826477,
0.7452751994132996,
-0.5424821376800537,
0.1613599807024002,
0.35651886463165283,
0.10088590532541275,
-0.6119837760925293,
0.7575620412826538,
0.19474729895591736,
0.5093225836753845,
0.5778119564056396,
0.5054846405982971,
-0.7554430961608887,
-0.6296048760414124,
-0.38567879796028137,
0.1783267706632614,
-0.8760424256324768,
-0.48214995861053467,
-0.9332403540611267,
0.07026880979537964,
-0.6269550323486328,
-0.2846739888191223,
-0.2838132083415985,
-0.32933253049850464,
0.11294165998697281,
0.14636121690273285,
0.46999356150627136,
0.09131649881601334,
0.15002310276031494,
0.31903788447380066,
-0.5821948051452637,
0.1236562579870224,
0.7534226179122925,
0.2813841700553894,
0.00233632093295455,
-0.30926647782325745,
-0.16398659348487854,
0.09060894697904587,
-0.07866073399782181,
-0.9429275393486023,
0.3670772612094879,
0.027616335079073906,
0.5651161074638367,
0.06338270008563995,
0.5771365761756897,
0.7179025411605835,
-0.24261701107025146,
0.46629321575164795,
0.09633370488882065,
-0.9200542569160461,
0.1376550793647766,
-0.3972395360469818,
0.27861306071281433,
0.6608739495277405,
0.6714016199111938,
-0.46666401624679565,
-0.30623236298561096,
-0.37293368577957153,
-1.0709867477416992,
0.5721903443336487,
0.04908683896064758,
-0.037626806646585464,
0.07259337604045868,
0.10927212238311768,
-0.1132422387599945,
0.4617648720741272,
-0.5516909956932068,
-0.1045936569571495,
0.17487718164920807,
-0.2305854856967926,
0.15025918185710907,
-0.17706601321697235,
-0.16858170926570892,
-0.07800911366939545,
0.8756106495857239,
-0.35928604006767273,
0.09203930199146271,
0.12888813018798828,
-0.27790260314941406,
0.4855029881000519,
0.3182823061943054,
0.2542080283164978,
0.6445319056510925,
-0.22717763483524323,
-0.14255781471729279,
0.3491345942020416,
-0.06876025348901749,
-0.14350183308124542,
-0.021091293543577194,
-0.28272536396980286,
-0.2982504665851593,
0.01004844345152378,
0.5185117721557617,
0.2137109935283661,
-1.0464341640472412,
0.47503453493118286,
0.2342650145292282,
-0.3275628983974457,
-0.17778252065181732,
-0.08450630307197571,
0.6247959136962891,
0.39399388432502747,
0.3522529900074005,
-0.15683622658252716,
0.024163737893104553,
-0.39141449332237244,
-0.046560704708099365,
0.670549750328064,
-0.11730717867612839,
0.4827493727207184,
0.6323367953300476,
0.39106300473213196,
-0.12896813452243805,
0.7586054801940918,
-0.0857279822230339,
-0.8329397439956665,
0.6116736531257629,
0.2986600995063782,
0.529087483882904,
0.06437879800796509,
0.24493752419948578,
0.17249037325382233,
0.30438706278800964,
0.19806578755378723,
0.34185487031936646,
-0.12761758267879486,
-0.7594738602638245,
-0.4601805806159973,
-0.4016385078430176,
-0.6477231979370117,
0.038548074662685394,
-0.40985721349716187,
0.20793499052524567,
-0.1281745880842209,
0.35068294405937195,
-0.23263691365718842,
0.2220223993062973,
-0.577472984790802,
0.3414768874645233,
-0.16537487506866455,
1.0621557235717773,
-0.6579075455665588,
0.7258843183517456,
0.3156415820121765,
-0.18984486162662506,
-1.0912126302719116,
-0.1086622029542923,
-0.29442423582077026,
-0.9955838918685913,
0.4895145893096924,
-0.04343894496560097,
-0.19057206809520721,
0.10237155109643936,
-0.577226996421814,
-0.9962950348854065,
1.0313516855239868,
0.46306857466697693,
-0.22327029705047607,
-0.11035303771495819,
-0.13584360480308533,
0.07091659307479858,
-0.15681476891040802,
0.13120771944522858,
0.6179862022399902,
0.45920953154563904,
0.5038849711418152,
-0.8056246042251587,
-0.2299034595489502,
0.32064974308013916,
-0.2359774261713028,
0.5085885524749756,
-0.6471748948097229,
0.8754066228866577,
-0.24333839118480682,
-0.040844932198524475,
-0.11140976846218109,
0.4955764710903168,
0.3455789089202881,
0.2983327805995941,
0.6329168677330017,
0.2844587564468384,
1.0417835712432861,
-0.020486097782850266,
0.9509570598602295,
-0.2638736665248871,
0.46215584874153137,
0.9831727743148804,
-0.44502341747283936,
0.614970326423645,
0.39763039350509644,
-0.35798728466033936,
0.08333739638328552,
0.7070223689079285,
0.24166418612003326,
0.7541932463645935,
0.3514024317264557,
-0.275638222694397,
-0.4485641121864319,
0.025713540613651276,
-0.11281643807888031,
0.49579760432243347,
0.0718594491481781,
0.030361024662852287,
-0.4226868450641632,
-0.09087616205215454,
0.5875667333602905,
0.054749954491853714,
-0.38966765999794006,
0.6571171283721924,
-0.3257436156272888,
-0.8202440142631531,
0.5465663075447083,
-0.06947757303714752,
0.6038652658462524,
-1.0126953125,
0.2952762246131897,
-0.3993207812309265,
0.02033456414937973,
0.1775861233472824,
-0.4955619275569916,
0.16745078563690186,
0.17499706149101257,
-0.07636776566505432,
-0.2628408372402191,
0.5837461948394775,
-0.7312588095664978,
-0.46172913908958435,
0.06180599331855774,
0.5761109590530396,
0.08858413249254227,
-0.49507588148117065,
-0.5065892934799194,
-0.3251264691352844,
-0.033786796033382416,
-0.10153325647115707,
0.29796797037124634,
0.10962428152561188,
-0.015250293537974358,
0.8656323552131653,
0.5158103704452515,
0.09996949136257172,
0.017884032800793648,
-0.22672368586063385,
0.858046293258667,
-0.4431425631046295,
-0.7610483169555664,
-0.37779688835144043,
0.2996523678302765,
-0.1855955272912979,
-0.27185824513435364,
0.5400261282920837,
0.6926575303077698,
0.9380642771720886,
-0.0657462477684021,
0.9259272813796997,
-0.2170971781015396,
0.6090796589851379,
-0.7577343583106995,
0.8112317323684692,
-0.6483778953552246,
0.04384763166308403,
-0.2931261360645294,
-0.6596294641494751,
-0.09588803350925446,
0.30651387572288513,
-0.42465949058532715,
0.13705474138259888,
0.6070544719696045,
1.0489269495010376,
0.33019042015075684,
-0.15397456288337708,
0.3311522901058197,
0.03263147547841072,
0.35095638036727905,
0.9682693481445312,
0.6958547830581665,
-0.03898315131664276,
0.9512359499931335,
-0.21218475699424744,
-0.3264886438846588,
-0.06742464005947113,
-0.7976524233818054,
-0.6843307614326477,
-0.3618565797805786,
-0.19080936908721924,
-0.32242825627326965,
0.02596384845674038,
1.033555507659912,
0.7542012333869934,
-0.5708162188529968,
-0.1426115185022354,
0.3216645419597626,
0.2602241635322571,
-0.2684231698513031,
-0.20356401801109314,
0.6475548148155212,
-0.459009051322937,
-0.9170116782188416,
0.38062819838523865,
0.12549453973770142,
-0.421187162399292,
0.12136172503232956,
0.004191747400909662,
-0.20015399158000946,
0.34259143471717834,
0.6553897857666016,
0.17273733019828796,
-0.5894264578819275,
-0.432713121175766,
0.3585300147533417,
0.19026319682598114,
-0.017135487869381905,
0.8823819756507874,
-0.8493433594703674,
0.37887945771217346,
0.4159424602985382,
1.072788119316101,
0.5463500618934631,
0.0045057726092636585,
0.508781373500824,
-0.6216448545455933,
-0.07493335753679276,
0.4722515344619751,
0.15691255033016205,
0.2319781333208084,
-0.3457088768482208,
0.35265281796455383,
0.17426730692386627,
-0.5240442752838135,
-0.707427442073822,
0.3580077290534973,
-0.8144102096557617,
-0.7400196194648743,
1.0505435466766357,
-0.17733408510684967,
-0.05485010892152786,
-0.3461668789386749,
-0.19924655556678772,
-0.025482432916760445,
-0.3025033473968506,
0.6780151724815369,
0.774010956287384,
-0.4382852017879486,
-0.03716430440545082,
-0.364378958940506,
0.4757685363292694,
0.2911870777606964,
-0.7426155209541321,
0.13284100592136383,
0.7991082668304443,
0.4679816961288452,
-0.17004771530628204,
0.5875433683395386,
0.18838337063789368,
0.15566131472587585,
0.11896933615207672,
-0.016695184633135796,
-0.25792473554611206,
-0.5120823383331299,
0.07273203879594803,
0.6294390559196472,
0.045336708426475525,
-0.3462364375591278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17336v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17336v1
|
XFormParser: A Simple and Effective Multimodal Multilingual Semi-structured Form Parser
| 2024-05-27T16:37:17 | 2024-05-27T16:37:17 |
Xianfu Cheng, Hang Zhang, Jian Yang, Xiang Li, Weixiao Zhou, Kui Wu, Fei Liu, Wei Zhang, Tao Sun, Tongliang Li, Zhoujun Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the domain of document AI, semi-structured form parsing plays a crucial
role. This task leverages techniques from key information extraction (KIE),
dealing with inputs that range from plain text to intricate modal data
comprising images and structural layouts. The advent of pre-trained multimodal
models has driven the extraction of key information from form documents in
different formats such as PDFs and images. Nonetheless, the endeavor of form
parsing is still encumbered by notable challenges like subpar capabilities in
multi-lingual parsing and diminished recall in contexts rich in text and
visuals. In this work, we introduce a simple but effective \textbf{M}ultimodal
and \textbf{M}ultilingual semi-structured \textbf{FORM} \textbf{PARSER}
(\textbf{XFormParser}), which is anchored on a comprehensive pre-trained
language model and innovatively amalgamates semantic entity recognition (SER)
and relation extraction (RE) into a unified framework, enhanced by a novel
staged warm-up training approach that employs soft labels to significantly
refine form parsing accuracy without amplifying inference overhead.
Furthermore, we have developed a groundbreaking benchmark dataset, named
InDFormBench, catering specifically to the parsing requirements of multilingual
forms in various industrial contexts. Through rigorous testing on established
multilingual benchmarks and InDFormBench, XFormParser has demonstrated its
unparalleled efficacy, notably surpassing the state-of-the-art (SOTA) models in
RE tasks within language-specific setups by achieving an F1 score improvement
of up to 1.79\%. Our framework exhibits exceptionally improved performance
across tasks in both multi-language and zero-shot contexts when compared to
existing SOTA benchmarks. The code is publicly available at
https://github.com/zhbuaa0/layoutlmft.
|
[
-0.1116987094283104,
-0.47040823101997375,
0.43518078327178955,
0.29482975602149963,
-0.10496845841407776,
0.2742686867713928,
-0.25475192070007324,
-0.2564072906970978,
-0.007739395834505558,
-0.14583630859851837,
-0.5614965558052063,
-0.3517521917819977,
-0.2995772659778595,
0.07459736615419388,
-0.0646432638168335,
0.6620917320251465,
-0.14900973439216614,
0.3288825750350952,
-0.48206788301467896,
-0.08936168998479843,
-0.19292710721492767,
-0.513454258441925,
-0.7230514883995056,
-0.22618600726127625,
0.22610892355442047,
0.21051375567913055,
0.5609745383262634,
0.3718034625053406,
0.1319200098514557,
0.37481704354286194,
-0.09032797068357468,
-0.09819255769252777,
-0.06589311361312866,
0.4633682072162628,
-0.1633114516735077,
-0.6783741116523743,
-0.3081304430961609,
-0.24224655330181122,
1.01189124584198,
0.581071674823761,
-0.2447967231273651,
0.020293869078159332,
-0.17101070284843445,
0.34316757321357727,
-0.7589595913887024,
0.5245862603187561,
-0.3726925551891327,
0.12653988599777222,
-0.6787264347076416,
0.053713567554950714,
-0.34981903433799744,
0.30107754468917847,
-0.5517141222953796,
-0.44646573066711426,
0.23908580839633942,
0.09491927921772003,
0.8343388438224792,
0.10925979912281036,
-0.1283697485923767,
0.16621828079223633,
-0.3641431927680969,
0.5474721193313599,
-0.49398016929626465,
1.107540488243103,
0.09707988798618317,
0.6491085290908813,
-0.27764657139778137,
-1.0070253610610962,
-0.8276509046554565,
-0.11676983535289764,
-0.02072202041745186,
0.23895661532878876,
-0.44162169098854065,
0.022772153839468956,
0.21716928482055664,
0.6526166200637817,
-0.6920345425605774,
0.1477348953485489,
-0.2211826592683792,
-0.3470117151737213,
0.16109596192836761,
-0.09833546727895737,
0.7510367035865784,
-0.6248789429664612,
-0.37003496289253235,
-0.31627485156059265,
-0.18390138447284698,
0.6419075131416321,
0.03522642329335213,
0.1875850260257721,
-0.2853075861930847,
0.43525758385658264,
-0.26304924488067627,
0.6001104116439819,
-0.21516920626163483,
-0.3511030077934265,
0.22143767774105072,
-0.12866221368312836,
-0.4059368669986725,
0.10648690909147263,
0.8487263917922974,
-0.15832000970840454,
-0.2328055202960968,
-0.2890979051589966,
-0.34573060274124146,
0.26601463556289673,
-0.06702838093042374,
-0.4270220994949341,
-0.31536611914634705,
-0.13163071870803833,
-0.4031785726547241,
-0.2031458616256714,
0.03832719102501869,
-0.7946314811706543,
-0.11039452999830246,
-0.28435564041137695,
0.1596161425113678,
-0.3664603531360626,
-0.12376691401004791,
0.022053027525544167,
-0.24769027531147003,
0.12273488193750381,
0.3698054552078247,
-0.6548315286636353,
0.1928696185350418,
0.4568726718425751,
0.7924210429191589,
-0.1200266033411026,
-0.13426057994365692,
-0.7792316675186157,
0.2826334238052368,
0.014779981225728989,
1.1036663055419922,
-0.6790043711662292,
-0.10829943418502808,
-0.3251219391822815,
0.31141412258148193,
-0.13768647611141205,
-0.40509721636772156,
0.7748574614524841,
-0.4924394190311432,
0.5235847234725952,
0.20458795130252838,
-0.281494140625,
-0.18705466389656067,
0.4003611207008362,
-0.9373905062675476,
1.1522419452667236,
0.37945500016212463,
-0.2128940373659134,
0.5049042701721191,
-0.4817282557487488,
-0.40024691820144653,
0.1194877177476883,
-0.7081564664840698,
-0.5922949314117432,
0.24093587696552277,
0.32200881838798523,
0.3140491545200348,
-0.4618018865585327,
0.19297166168689728,
-0.36548569798469543,
0.2731838524341583,
-0.15306217968463898,
-0.5978219509124756,
0.642402708530426,
0.08098620176315308,
-0.5006412267684937,
0.35204145312309265,
-1.2257152795791626,
0.28208404779434204,
0.15899421274662018,
-0.4548191726207733,
-0.2925182580947876,
-0.49311065673828125,
0.3390531837940216,
0.697242796421051,
-0.05790485441684723,
-0.8255675435066223,
0.14116379618644714,
-0.3657395839691162,
0.41662320494651794,
0.617540180683136,
-0.2860339879989624,
0.43314680457115173,
-0.07015278190374374,
0.8669050335884094,
-0.007793910335749388,
0.021437084302306175,
-0.3460496962070465,
-0.13787922263145447,
-0.4553912580013275,
-0.7323458790779114,
0.31747788190841675,
0.31110602617263794,
-0.7284772992134094,
0.031792547553777695,
-0.21056672930717468,
-0.5349358320236206,
-0.4274756908416748,
0.27262863516807556,
0.5803954005241394,
0.6881443858146667,
0.21375718712806702,
0.009800879284739494,
-0.6014352440834045,
-0.8625244498252869,
-0.05214541405439377,
0.06718674302101135,
0.14665667712688446,
-0.20621465146541595,
0.14984093606472015,
0.00890291202813387,
0.8637921214103699,
-0.46735766530036926,
-0.4654166102409363,
-0.5544008612632751,
-0.015085001476109028,
0.09467156231403351,
0.5033531785011292,
0.6145062446594238,
-1.1061590909957886,
-0.4850284457206726,
-0.1769750714302063,
-0.8425323367118835,
-0.14857694506645203,
-0.09607572853565216,
-0.20615267753601074,
0.27120596170425415,
0.5462768077850342,
-0.7423990964889526,
0.3018324077129364,
0.5042334794998169,
-0.26764270663261414,
0.380182683467865,
-0.18169988691806793,
0.14124919474124908,
-1.1123992204666138,
0.2216692417860031,
-0.04358253628015518,
-0.632918655872345,
-0.30994075536727905,
0.019566789269447327,
0.42717957496643066,
-0.544519305229187,
-0.6228802800178528,
0.7028514742851257,
-0.7771983742713928,
0.015971748158335686,
0.04908183217048645,
-0.04947153478860855,
0.454766184091568,
0.5911152362823486,
0.017644546926021576,
0.9478508830070496,
0.38602736592292786,
-0.12226853519678116,
0.25920769572257996,
0.32479965686798096,
-0.25247418880462646,
0.5215477347373962,
-0.7100347280502319,
-0.24507516622543335,
-0.44670015573501587,
0.1879642754793167,
-1.1661484241485596,
-0.22146384418010712,
0.1491340547800064,
-0.20736634731292725,
0.7526677846908569,
-0.04106448218226433,
-0.6460845470428467,
-0.047507308423519135,
-0.4057733118534088,
0.38083168864250183,
0.23462575674057007,
-0.42146220803260803,
0.9279345273971558,
0.4095701277256012,
-0.407621830701828,
-0.22193162143230438,
-0.4111565351486206,
0.14032529294490814,
0.21932357549667358,
-0.9167966246604919,
0.6160467863082886,
0.05346868187189102,
-0.005500725470483303,
-0.03566219285130501,
-0.46268028020858765,
-0.0845678374171257,
0.020637916401028633,
0.24249574542045593,
0.23891380429267883,
-0.2578316330909729,
0.07115040719509125,
0.46127399802207947,
-0.4247588813304901,
-0.14329063892364502,
0.1716461181640625,
0.6452748775482178,
-0.0695389062166214,
-0.4072422981262207,
-0.5165349841117859,
0.5626067519187927,
0.8825141787528992,
-0.4252641201019287,
0.557616114616394,
0.42481371760368347,
-0.5180092453956604,
-0.0050504873506724834,
-0.4138493239879608,
0.20344296097755432,
-0.39927592873573303,
0.32506006956100464,
-0.8439208269119263,
-0.6855031251907349,
0.30489182472229004,
-0.13626378774642944,
-0.09660650044679642,
0.44338178634643555,
0.5143606066703796,
-0.09761649370193481,
1.1319653987884521,
0.7589234113693237,
0.07667306810617447,
0.563319206237793,
-0.13183686137199402,
0.18292221426963806,
-0.6050422787666321,
-0.6470740437507629,
-0.48251160979270935,
-0.035271693021059036,
-0.188897043466568,
-0.11348330229520798,
0.441837340593338,
0.34591254591941833,
0.22849106788635254,
0.14422555267810822,
-0.18989139795303345,
0.21722310781478882,
0.47935181856155396,
-0.06915267556905746,
0.25072914361953735,
0.03988044336438179,
-0.18218426406383514,
-0.09548447281122208,
-0.734289824962616,
-0.559933066368103,
0.45053383708000183,
0.2246844619512558,
0.9498914480209351,
0.30201172828674316,
0.2875286042690277,
0.4266932010650635,
-0.06985493749380112,
-0.6437200903892517,
0.30359870195388794,
-0.23349662125110626,
-0.3484399914741516,
-0.04294567555189133,
-0.17596352100372314,
-0.8246426582336426,
0.47878116369247437,
-0.3543877899646759,
-0.4940987527370453,
0.2547169327735901,
0.015381799079477787,
-0.3059127628803253,
0.3349190950393677,
-0.7588624358177185,
1.2270570993423462,
-0.33907172083854675,
-0.3748897314071655,
0.2554202675819397,
-0.6678591370582581,
0.18532148003578186,
-0.10315239429473877,
0.2045544981956482,
-0.18694263696670532,
0.03305290639400482,
0.6903477311134338,
-0.36943531036376953,
0.6957712173461914,
-0.2781895697116852,
-0.01976165734231472,
-0.27001339197158813,
0.04408854618668556,
0.21014191210269928,
0.3142072260379791,
0.014059003442525864,
0.17723780870437622,
0.26161906123161316,
-0.43591615557670593,
-0.9452196359634399,
0.4330081343650818,
-0.6841399073600769,
-0.22497229278087616,
-0.41570740938186646,
-0.3869763910770416,
-0.15129999816417694,
0.6742206811904907,
0.19210536777973175,
0.7549335956573486,
-0.044457755982875824,
0.14801093935966492,
0.5099135041236877,
-0.09080399572849274,
0.47844967246055603,
0.44699499011039734,
-0.019980745390057564,
-0.6387903094291687,
0.5763301849365234,
0.005295756738632917,
0.06884106993675232,
0.7938647270202637,
0.13647055625915527,
-0.6138898730278015,
0.07277949154376984,
-0.712501049041748,
0.158845454454422,
-0.7341519594192505,
-0.5335283279418945,
-1.0415705442428589,
0.03190775215625763,
-0.8028005957603455,
-0.05443252995610237,
-0.41047877073287964,
-0.7439786791801453,
0.14721445739269257,
0.05459370091557503,
-0.25254184007644653,
0.21395492553710938,
-0.010796553455293179,
0.3310479521751404,
-0.8476002216339111,
0.5862835049629211,
0.10168837010860443,
0.19125108420848846,
-0.3038574457168579,
-0.14169660210609436,
0.21482889354228973,
-0.12464496493339539,
-0.16744691133499146,
-0.7440781593322754,
0.07656770199537277,
0.4378899931907654,
1.0379664897918701,
0.38484400510787964,
-0.14829714596271515,
0.6556275486946106,
-0.44599926471710205,
0.6043542623519897,
0.23861336708068848,
-0.8657490611076355,
0.6855091452598572,
0.061499133706092834,
0.28377386927604675,
0.6569438576698303,
0.41195034980773926,
-0.6413097381591797,
-0.1053209975361824,
-0.6769314408302307,
-0.6853715777397156,
0.8517947793006897,
0.12752465903759003,
-0.1467222422361374,
0.20802900195121765,
0.22657833993434906,
0.29452982544898987,
0.33939579129219055,
-0.6232002377510071,
-0.225297212600708,
-0.21948623657226562,
-0.31316566467285156,
-0.08609171211719513,
-0.39977288246154785,
0.27090227603912354,
-0.22024723887443542,
0.7662265300750732,
0.050987109541893005,
0.1188197210431099,
0.07538174837827682,
-0.5300977230072021,
0.12338627129793167,
0.5402373671531677,
0.7791645526885986,
0.38242706656455994,
-0.015904059633612633,
0.44308722019195557,
-0.24943797290325165,
-0.28428617119789124,
0.5504230856895447,
0.5490524768829346,
-0.16332295536994934,
0.2326612025499344,
0.5078181624412537,
0.6736878156661987,
0.4861803948879242,
-0.7036902904510498,
0.6808786988258362,
-0.32973340153694153,
0.21632105112075806,
-0.41023537516593933,
-0.031932633370161057,
-0.4111320972442627,
0.1977347433567047,
-0.0147618493065238,
0.187059223651886,
0.06197621300816536,
-0.4901188910007477,
0.4120108187198639,
0.24175548553466797,
-0.4910682439804077,
-0.5642333626747131,
0.8739790320396423,
-0.08957677334547043,
-0.10738296806812286,
0.4861263036727905,
-0.23794247210025787,
-0.4947476387023926,
0.06620017439126968,
0.7630529403686523,
0.5685292482376099,
-0.17223985493183136,
0.13963255286216736,
-0.0011512769851833582,
0.02856490947306156,
0.16299015283584595,
0.4752534329891205,
-0.523678183555603,
-0.5350607633590698,
-0.3910549581050873,
-0.8284590840339661,
-0.1255292147397995,
-0.03680899739265442,
-0.49518537521362305,
0.39045360684394836,
-0.2951088845729828,
0.042939528822898865,
0.12558843195438385,
-0.18529416620731354,
-0.5057498216629028,
0.27262452244758606,
0.27772635221481323,
1.0921686887741089,
-0.9262482523918152,
0.5944235324859619,
1.3111566305160522,
-0.921059250831604,
-0.8352206945419312,
-0.47492164373397827,
0.14146459102630615,
-0.9003174304962158,
0.6868395209312439,
0.18431521952152252,
-0.047010235488414764,
-0.06940273940563202,
-0.030691683292388916,
-0.7945014238357544,
0.7405298352241516,
0.6833837628364563,
-0.3103373050689697,
-0.27501198649406433,
0.1630808562040329,
0.12801598012447357,
0.06199875473976135,
0.3483688533306122,
0.29164832830429077,
0.4203835427761078,
-0.05119611322879791,
-0.7254073619842529,
0.2628873586654663,
-0.6766066551208496,
0.08642897754907608,
0.4394749402999878,
-0.5805956721305847,
0.6927988529205322,
0.2713295817375183,
-0.3467372953891754,
-0.08032237738370895,
0.8369960188865662,
0.31326961517333984,
0.20650456845760345,
0.6641905903816223,
0.7344399690628052,
0.6598419547080994,
0.03924792259931564,
0.8603590726852417,
-0.28023648262023926,
0.1403723806142807,
1.1269367933273315,
-0.21978658437728882,
0.535428524017334,
0.49815449118614197,
-0.10007687658071518,
0.62897127866745,
0.3188202381134033,
0.1300026774406433,
0.5055826306343079,
-0.09434971213340759,
-0.2949884533882141,
-0.48896726965904236,
-0.24297386407852173,
-0.23615767061710358,
0.8781412839889526,
-0.1360531598329544,
-0.2579618990421295,
-0.9691183567047119,
0.5835445523262024,
0.3759106397628784,
0.2002890706062317,
-0.05352375656366348,
0.6444957852363586,
-0.09018973261117935,
-0.2988554835319519,
0.2264704704284668,
0.19291532039642334,
0.428209125995636,
-0.9567287564277649,
-0.2940429449081421,
-0.1434093564748764,
0.2840854227542877,
-0.3108392655849457,
-0.6950244903564453,
0.0529768168926239,
-0.18022865056991577,
-0.6332153081893921,
-0.4177665412425995,
0.8442156910896301,
-0.29069700837135315,
-0.49665209650993347,
0.032560959458351135,
0.5634319186210632,
0.06587735563516617,
-0.36836308240890503,
-0.7270390391349792,
0.2652859091758728,
0.00039848333108238876,
-0.2121886909008026,
0.20563063025474548,
0.5690780282020569,
-0.5308511853218079,
0.4484867751598358,
0.8278163075447083,
0.18816182017326355,
0.21158134937286377,
0.36063623428344727,
1.0034819841384888,
-0.5963921546936035,
-0.6634695529937744,
-0.7387121915817261,
0.7370812296867371,
-0.27268916368484497,
-0.3210691511631012,
0.585868775844574,
0.938288688659668,
0.9568013548851013,
0.01535460352897644,
0.6019572615623474,
-0.31638360023498535,
0.22542057931423187,
-0.599055826663971,
0.6909967660903931,
-0.7440375089645386,
-0.19976548850536346,
-0.26760637760162354,
-0.9789974093437195,
-0.5061883926391602,
0.44694411754608154,
0.03293386846780777,
-0.008489875122904778,
0.563637375831604,
0.716413140296936,
-0.30614084005355835,
-0.21428753435611725,
0.4935579001903534,
-0.08136305212974548,
0.8769091367721558,
0.1802876591682434,
0.7064514756202698,
-0.4271496832370758,
0.5621955990791321,
-0.607446014881134,
-0.5755894184112549,
0.2839437425136566,
-0.7068037390708923,
-0.6748822927474976,
-0.6824420094490051,
-0.16050907969474792,
0.08083826303482056,
-0.23450447618961334,
0.9286665916442871,
0.7732111215591431,
-0.6146851778030396,
0.13272865116596222,
0.17409496009349823,
-0.2160687893629074,
-0.05869068577885628,
-0.2773820757865906,
0.40584179759025574,
-0.7939940690994263,
-0.6450343132019043,
0.5966724753379822,
0.6688722968101501,
0.08114025741815567,
-0.12328564375638962,
0.3785850703716278,
-0.30665916204452515,
-0.5502055287361145,
0.8311238288879395,
0.258530855178833,
-0.4836573004722595,
0.16980983316898346,
-0.00872931070625782,
-0.23749296367168427,
0.2840348482131958,
0.7639653086662292,
-0.7179073691368103,
0.5597221851348877,
0.6057997345924377,
0.6575074195861816,
0.3356657922267914,
-0.033834923058748245,
0.5192356705665588,
-0.714275062084198,
0.24606890976428986,
0.06764975190162659,
0.8003697395324707,
0.2509230971336365,
-0.4329376816749573,
0.4193854033946991,
0.47106537222862244,
-0.1831509917974472,
-0.7373688817024231,
0.03517227992415428,
-1.2490431070327759,
-0.19766181707382202,
0.634450376033783,
-0.03445039689540863,
-0.5960275530815125,
0.05487122759222984,
-0.5223315954208374,
0.3499046862125397,
-0.5592514872550964,
0.3975973129272461,
0.32530534267425537,
-0.36377424001693726,
-0.36732959747314453,
-0.2936583161354065,
0.3316924571990967,
0.5543091893196106,
-0.9020310044288635,
-0.1961883306503296,
0.44069841504096985,
0.17381040751934052,
0.2172502875328064,
0.6605291366577148,
-0.3745890259742737,
0.35960879921913147,
-0.1551491916179657,
0.37277770042419434,
-0.39556431770324707,
-0.2900964021682739,
-0.3150380253791809,
0.5216249823570251,
-0.08248528838157654,
-0.2703365683555603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01608v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01608v1
|
Detecting Deceptive Dark Patterns in E-commerce Platforms
| 2024-05-27T16:32:40 | 2024-05-27T16:32:40 |
Arya Ramteke, Sankalp Tembhurne, Gunesh Sonawane, Ratnmala N. Bhimanpallewar
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Dark patterns are deceptive user interfaces employed by e-commerce websites
to manipulate user's behavior in a way that benefits the website, often
unethically. This study investigates the detection of such dark patterns.
Existing solutions include UIGuard, which uses computer vision and natural
language processing, and approaches that categorize dark patterns based on
detectability or utilize machine learning models trained on datasets. We
propose combining web scraping techniques with fine-tuned BERT language models
and generative capabilities to identify dark patterns, including outliers. The
approach scrapes textual content, feeds it into the BERT model for detection,
and leverages BERT's bidirectional analysis and generation abilities. The study
builds upon research on automatically detecting and explaining dark patterns,
aiming to raise awareness and protect consumers.
|
[
-0.18573160469532013,
-1.0908775329589844,
0.30578577518463135,
0.20406845211982727,
-0.6432026028633118,
0.11423636227846146,
0.33710065484046936,
-1.2460622787475586,
0.3410959541797638,
1.1253433227539062,
-0.566895604133606,
-0.44589442014694214,
-0.1014290601015091,
0.012255317531526089,
-0.5150620341300964,
0.7295053005218506,
0.3703455626964569,
-0.1368730515241623,
0.22661817073822021,
0.25890421867370605,
-0.20525678992271423,
-0.5215957760810852,
-0.6088494658470154,
0.027252791449427605,
0.30610573291778564,
0.38146671652793884,
0.5250688195228577,
0.394998162984848,
0.6088146567344666,
0.42015165090560913,
0.18255525827407837,
0.5240996479988098,
-0.36031970381736755,
0.385421484708786,
0.09022248536348343,
-0.5681604146957397,
0.19712084531784058,
-0.15458182990550995,
-0.2849556505680084,
0.49304527044296265,
-0.19514316320419312,
0.20150594413280487,
0.3018187880516052,
0.6617326736450195,
-0.621823787689209,
-0.04141876474022865,
-0.6687662601470947,
-0.03701470419764519,
-0.27406635880470276,
-0.17246241867542267,
-0.5729690194129944,
-0.29226329922676086,
-0.2844060957431793,
-0.3438849151134491,
0.5287994742393494,
0.38396263122558594,
0.8666752576828003,
0.01998024247586727,
-0.22082719206809998,
-0.34225428104400635,
-0.5045522451400757,
0.826076865196228,
-0.6982026100158691,
0.43769973516464233,
0.7368212342262268,
0.4028382897377014,
-0.3168693482875824,
-0.8418576717376709,
-0.44308218359947205,
-0.20461949706077576,
-0.27987709641456604,
0.052037689834833145,
-0.49975329637527466,
-0.06143932044506073,
0.11596524715423584,
0.06387048959732056,
-0.5428617000579834,
0.40387246012687683,
-0.6269001960754395,
-0.35643261671066284,
0.7223753929138184,
0.11735208332538605,
0.4977710247039795,
-0.1290297657251358,
-0.579060971736908,
-0.04403464496135712,
-0.3200230300426483,
0.12723204493522644,
0.8742879033088684,
0.36075446009635925,
-0.33388689160346985,
0.3644998073577881,
0.1258474737405777,
0.9327967166900635,
0.39513158798217773,
0.006214550696313381,
0.18376313149929047,
-0.09375857561826706,
-0.3021373748779297,
0.15418657660484314,
0.3832032382488251,
0.6928430795669556,
0.09962154179811478,
-0.11129733920097351,
-0.4172925353050232,
-0.002408107277005911,
0.4903828799724579,
-0.7932041883468628,
-0.5482547283172607,
0.05134200677275658,
-1.2717939615249634,
-0.5750294923782349,
0.034430257976055145,
-0.903654932975769,
-0.6734545826911926,
-0.3943922817707062,
0.20888885855674744,
-0.21106137335300446,
-0.12369750440120697,
0.27393630146980286,
-0.6400026679039001,
0.27791860699653625,
0.3903796970844269,
-0.795386016368866,
0.3804052472114563,
0.4694446325302124,
0.5613265633583069,
-0.07773419469594955,
0.15176524221897125,
-0.28261440992355347,
0.11449923366308212,
0.008426060900092125,
0.5322383046150208,
-0.6384682059288025,
-0.054351501166820526,
0.12818196415901184,
0.1593489795923233,
0.21009418368339539,
-0.4705204963684082,
0.6325678825378418,
-1.0131123065948486,
0.07589805871248245,
-0.11974756419658661,
-0.5809715986251831,
-0.5422179102897644,
0.32500794529914856,
-0.8427693843841553,
0.7405933141708374,
-0.08562002331018448,
-0.5636332035064697,
0.5697008967399597,
-0.5238152146339417,
-0.4326004087924957,
0.4415574073791504,
0.2451593428850174,
-0.5300092697143555,
0.43484750390052795,
-0.010296744294464588,
0.5276067852973938,
0.10898029804229736,
-0.2717481553554535,
-0.43448883295059204,
-0.4589008390903473,
0.538537323474884,
-0.7238547801971436,
1.2819801568984985,
0.6485958695411682,
-0.48194095492362976,
-0.5806233286857605,
-1.0681923627853394,
0.005562285892665386,
0.36566677689552307,
-0.1921761929988861,
-0.8630924820899963,
0.17723652720451355,
0.5846912264823914,
-0.013076555915176868,
0.30091115832328796,
-0.5369661450386047,
0.007067972794175148,
-0.18530359864234924,
0.4051281213760376,
0.9918617606163025,
0.1478326916694641,
-0.08265934139490128,
-0.3208315968513489,
0.2866084575653076,
0.19823552668094635,
0.35830849409103394,
-0.009317925199866295,
-0.6735160946846008,
-0.6449620723724365,
-0.4138054847717285,
0.15145622193813324,
0.40571025013923645,
-0.6204144954681396,
0.7329055070877075,
0.41639089584350586,
-0.3211599290370941,
-0.4210025370121002,
0.17432089149951935,
0.1915409117937088,
0.34014782309532166,
0.43943560123443604,
-0.6696035861968994,
-0.4230829179286957,
-0.9462825059890747,
-0.3140842914581299,
0.11360947787761688,
0.11840815842151642,
0.202529639005661,
0.3951442241668701,
-0.652135968208313,
0.6462699174880981,
-0.36947014927864075,
-0.22418203949928284,
-0.03888845816254616,
0.5687134861946106,
0.3197261393070221,
0.5404060482978821,
0.9540150761604309,
-1.3819897174835205,
-0.618327260017395,
-0.11339760571718216,
-0.35297489166259766,
-0.3822691738605499,
-0.0608791820704937,
-0.0018114267149940133,
-0.014908036217093468,
0.5892856121063232,
-0.0021936565171927214,
0.4882490038871765,
0.45177167654037476,
-0.5411015152931213,
0.502733051776886,
-0.1320803165435791,
0.23323994874954224,
-0.5462450385093689,
-0.177580788731575,
0.14912088215351105,
-0.29523128271102905,
-0.8919477462768555,
0.036836814135313034,
0.03934796527028084,
-0.017809482291340828,
-0.22816236317157745,
0.15464253723621368,
-0.32283881306648254,
-0.018818175420165062,
-0.27984553575515747,
-0.2951332926750183,
0.3051103949546814,
0.38285118341445923,
-0.16144363582134247,
0.6385701894760132,
0.24001598358154297,
-0.8193336129188538,
0.33449387550354004,
0.09798288345336914,
-0.7019781470298767,
0.46490585803985596,
-0.30090683698654175,
0.1797609031200409,
-0.03283798322081566,
-0.22276407480239868,
-1.0692291259765625,
-0.12849220633506775,
0.612805962562561,
-0.3372115194797516,
0.24785958230495453,
-0.37117433547973633,
-0.7632029056549072,
-0.3938993513584137,
-0.5691438913345337,
0.44399240612983704,
0.5257589221000671,
-0.751348078250885,
0.3819039463996887,
0.07900726795196533,
-0.07096926122903824,
-0.6227456331253052,
-1.034317135810852,
0.1880241185426712,
-0.26639363169670105,
-0.5077629685401917,
0.38959482312202454,
-0.20237110555171967,
-0.49171748757362366,
-0.12281914800405502,
0.13518497347831726,
-0.31864482164382935,
0.6572320461273193,
-0.08450634032487869,
0.22672222554683685,
0.09001504629850388,
-0.2006402313709259,
-0.12030437588691711,
0.12150410562753677,
0.1573755443096161,
-0.2589086592197418,
0.7646017670631409,
0.466906875371933,
-0.7709205746650696,
-0.6351838707923889,
0.24657823145389557,
0.6375666856765747,
-0.0974738746881485,
0.296151340007782,
0.43197888135910034,
-0.35046279430389404,
-0.39974215626716614,
-0.7538695335388184,
-0.2794128656387329,
-0.6189090609550476,
-0.237625852227211,
0.12444952875375748,
-0.38476964831352234,
0.72000652551651,
0.14345532655715942,
-0.14201189577579498,
0.053783174604177475,
0.3265770971775055,
-0.39407411217689514,
1.3436115980148315,
0.9697459936141968,
0.08095061033964157,
0.7926314473152161,
-0.08672451227903366,
0.3392240107059479,
-0.27770355343818665,
-0.35410329699516296,
-0.5846517086029053,
-0.6450238227844238,
-1.0353901386260986,
-0.1649734526872635,
0.02463403344154358,
0.21159647405147552,
-0.23447486758232117,
0.2812759578227997,
-0.8407883644104004,
0.5119897723197937,
0.9814525246620178,
0.6547225117683411,
0.2819458246231079,
0.4190000593662262,
-0.2919313609600067,
-0.005360421258956194,
0.03688468411564827,
-0.4405086040496826,
0.9700378775596619,
-0.06691820919513702,
1.0168070793151855,
0.2927560806274414,
0.600490927696228,
1.1306169033050537,
-0.10616811364889145,
-0.6498863101005554,
0.31366342306137085,
-0.3723007142543793,
-0.6810106039047241,
0.05935468152165413,
-0.2780824899673462,
-1.0664902925491333,
0.147264763712883,
-0.037352193146944046,
-0.8949920535087585,
0.7198962569236755,
0.07723899185657501,
-0.07535205036401749,
0.4274243712425232,
-0.7728785276412964,
0.4558042883872986,
-0.9045889973640442,
-0.750476598739624,
-0.15907298028469086,
-0.5995264053344727,
0.2179478108882904,
-0.06162267550826073,
0.22217559814453125,
0.020207693800330162,
0.17410722374916077,
0.517560601234436,
-0.3210236430168152,
1.3814442157745361,
-0.31301209330558777,
-0.16122178733348846,
0.13371743261814117,
0.21297095715999603,
0.7414082884788513,
-0.31353825330734253,
0.1436692327260971,
0.017029311507940292,
-0.42962947487831116,
-0.6247693300247192,
-0.207275852560997,
0.2332509309053421,
-0.6204267740249634,
-0.2644970715045929,
-0.3519979417324066,
0.0154164033010602,
-0.16430848836898804,
0.3133906126022339,
0.17801298201084137,
-0.026160404086112976,
-0.2863750159740448,
0.16982263326644897,
0.7569679617881775,
-0.1999644637107849,
0.6890721917152405,
0.7583159804344177,
-0.1170140951871872,
-0.1253129094839096,
0.8760929703712463,
-0.2815144658088684,
-0.04043759033083916,
0.32162290811538696,
0.13177670538425446,
-0.21473680436611176,
-1.0269132852554321,
-0.33018940687179565,
-0.07536610215902328,
-0.505586564540863,
-0.3556724786758423,
-0.1787353754043579,
-0.07583913952112198,
-0.19095070660114288,
-0.4612598121166229,
0.3799671232700348,
-0.23798289895057678,
-0.40522637963294983,
-0.02796786092221737,
0.40224310755729675,
0.674816370010376,
-0.3323563039302826,
0.4566028416156769,
-0.8819154500961304,
0.6153058409690857,
0.7227449417114258,
0.23797117173671722,
0.0005652544205076993,
-0.11691758781671524,
-0.18752893805503845,
0.18107417225837708,
-0.5088306069374084,
-0.7610904574394226,
0.7259611487388611,
-0.1756337583065033,
0.6581891179084778,
1.0787724256515503,
-0.027146656066179276,
0.5457507967948914,
-0.18171089887619019,
0.804233968257904,
0.7371218204498291,
-0.7041261792182922,
0.5243030190467834,
-0.31208500266075134,
-0.35221293568611145,
0.5823195576667786,
0.393555223941803,
-0.43347328901290894,
-0.38756340742111206,
-0.5534034371376038,
-0.7343288660049438,
0.6738338470458984,
0.2735697627067566,
0.2392464131116867,
0.17442192137241364,
0.0461210273206234,
0.4581698179244995,
0.5135214328765869,
-0.8062441349029541,
-0.21233083307743073,
-0.41295889019966125,
-0.13436684012413025,
0.16494497656822205,
-0.4569161832332611,
-0.19424796104431152,
0.08852558583021164,
0.2520444393157959,
-0.06868933141231537,
0.174357607960701,
-0.31794220209121704,
-0.4709264934062958,
-0.26710423827171326,
0.15316179394721985,
0.2959918677806854,
0.8029325008392334,
-0.28009721636772156,
0.05668956786394119,
-0.4680686891078949,
-0.7647712230682373,
-0.08112319558858871,
0.5311974287033081,
-0.567202091217041,
-0.023927925154566765,
0.24934302270412445,
0.13924813270568848,
0.14434152841567993,
-0.7097391486167908,
0.576880156993866,
-0.11934305727481842,
-0.04771570861339569,
-0.24202002584934235,
0.18838851153850555,
-0.6012833118438721,
0.29877254366874695,
0.5862873196601868,
0.21269652247428894,
0.794821560382843,
-0.6234735250473022,
0.06741293519735336,
0.39195388555526733,
-0.3589398264884949,
-0.21620610356330872,
0.42140549421310425,
0.45865246653556824,
-0.42168128490448,
0.8722330927848816,
-0.16448739171028137,
-0.6649168729782104,
0.8808185458183289,
0.6999136209487915,
0.9406013488769531,
-0.22263894975185394,
0.13203413784503937,
-0.17070116102695465,
0.4299831688404083,
0.09581699967384338,
0.4302721619606018,
-0.5025381445884705,
-1.0772769451141357,
-0.08672739565372467,
-0.6737513542175293,
-0.4076572358608246,
0.3846282958984375,
-0.8891474008560181,
0.5018745064735413,
-0.3576712906360626,
0.11567051708698273,
0.31084585189819336,
-0.03693152219057083,
-0.6714271903038025,
0.0809546634554863,
0.3845657408237457,
0.5340672731399536,
-0.8389388918876648,
0.37611913681030273,
0.34646064043045044,
-0.5804834365844727,
0.020342297852039337,
-0.11926501244306564,
0.02728160098195076,
-1.2440400123596191,
0.688275933265686,
0.45666438341140747,
-0.38143423199653625,
-0.3431236743927002,
-1.1898720264434814,
-0.3144429922103882,
0.7051824331283569,
0.10978996008634567,
-0.7972438931465149,
0.050705455243587494,
0.1621750146150589,
0.2466253936290741,
-0.008795141242444515,
-0.023766210302710533,
0.44803664088249207,
0.7265381217002869,
-0.30540770292282104,
-0.4294183552265167,
-0.18875253200531006,
-0.2594450116157532,
-0.26833096146583557,
0.380627304315567,
-0.5435621738433838,
0.5976343750953674,
0.20404782891273499,
-0.1919378638267517,
0.09723781049251556,
-0.033342257142066956,
0.05141960829496384,
0.5955254435539246,
0.6809726357460022,
0.8141353726387024,
0.7978673577308655,
-0.011913296766579151,
0.32545310258865356,
-0.37866780161857605,
0.17633533477783203,
0.6347069144248962,
-0.28568288683891296,
0.36034512519836426,
0.17795239388942719,
-0.07229636609554291,
0.9477155208587646,
0.6797747611999512,
-0.7070419788360596,
0.8676886558532715,
0.3227415382862091,
-0.15624836087226868,
-0.5347510576248169,
-0.019553853198885918,
-0.32890763878822327,
0.7156673669815063,
0.7627699971199036,
-0.7198939323425293,
-0.14277711510658264,
0.1192023828625679,
-0.15119530260562897,
0.05994468927383423,
-0.5632127523422241,
0.8422953486442566,
-0.028442587703466415,
0.015269861556589603,
0.35971808433532715,
0.09576282650232315,
0.7982537746429443,
-0.5804393887519836,
-0.42939215898513794,
0.055713504552841187,
0.26910945773124695,
-0.3019067943096161,
-0.46352657675743103,
-0.08202935010194778,
0.08033094555139542,
-0.19715796411037445,
-0.5829181671142578,
1.1890275478363037,
0.07453496754169464,
-0.5178096294403076,
0.501941442489624,
0.4955574870109558,
-0.07042010128498077,
0.1791958510875702,
-1.0053303241729736,
-0.3023967444896698,
0.10432204604148865,
0.05711609870195389,
0.23498380184173584,
0.5202230215072632,
0.056317612528800964,
0.5003666281700134,
1.069649577140808,
-0.15516197681427002,
0.06625514477491379,
0.2642787992954254,
0.8917543292045593,
-0.8424108028411865,
-0.7866837978363037,
-0.7360435724258423,
0.4659324586391449,
-0.5968065857887268,
0.04956665635108948,
0.855735182762146,
0.6817180514335632,
0.9144191145896912,
0.08263766765594482,
0.8421819806098938,
-0.024206023663282394,
0.3964817523956299,
-0.5223190784454346,
0.7150949239730835,
-0.49336007237434387,
0.37301498651504517,
-0.11483753472566605,
-0.613574743270874,
-0.16389741003513336,
0.37152615189552307,
0.13548748195171356,
-0.016894401982426643,
0.15479065477848053,
0.7243025302886963,
-0.49208423495292664,
0.3444708585739136,
0.3404407203197479,
0.2303457260131836,
0.018577132374048233,
-0.03254395350813866,
1.1875275373458862,
0.035160429775714874,
0.5839861631393433,
-0.345537930727005,
-0.18970227241516113,
-0.9316574931144714,
-0.7323443293571472,
-0.8810449838638306,
-0.16186390817165375,
-0.023296628147363663,
-0.3625860810279846,
0.08003581315279007,
0.6125123500823975,
0.7186437845230103,
-1.1005113124847412,
-0.2096938192844391,
-0.1713915765285492,
0.17922037839889526,
-0.6447668671607971,
-0.2799752354621887,
0.23465800285339355,
-0.4690946638584137,
-0.4741828441619873,
0.3741053342819214,
0.22614891827106476,
0.5456492304801941,
-0.14179816842079163,
0.522418200969696,
-0.054471127688884735,
0.0690600797533989,
0.6118090152740479,
0.22843500971794128,
-0.48977985978126526,
-0.16363416612148285,
-0.03514330834150314,
0.10535785555839539,
-0.1424027383327484,
0.9578981399536133,
-0.7051836252212524,
0.7719997763633728,
0.4771379828453064,
0.339816689491272,
0.5531914830207825,
0.19503183662891388,
0.31031209230422974,
-0.6617071032524109,
0.0959608182311058,
0.5769862532615662,
0.49515995383262634,
0.1800180971622467,
-0.42816025018692017,
0.2540596127510071,
0.22786211967468262,
-0.4148680567741394,
-0.7992360591888428,
0.3322281837463379,
-0.8262357711791992,
-0.876319944858551,
0.6138684153556824,
0.1278783679008484,
-0.08648383617401123,
-1.0158042907714844,
-0.018417585641145706,
-0.2815295457839966,
-0.4003361463546753,
1.1664713621139526,
0.3710663616657257,
-0.240006685256958,
0.2045481950044632,
-0.38882362842559814,
0.268540620803833,
-0.174683079123497,
-0.5413845777511597,
0.06898052990436554,
0.6340773105621338,
0.017990265041589737,
0.3719651997089386,
-0.00684869010001421,
0.14332643151283264,
0.5177082419395447,
-0.18065287172794342,
-0.21299207210540771,
-0.005594185087829828,
0.01527926791459322,
-0.23715147376060486,
0.14060285687446594,
-0.11239423602819443,
-0.3238731324672699
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.