id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17771v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17771v1
|
Supervising the Centroid Baseline for Extractive Multi-Document Summarization
| 2023-11-29T16:11:45 | 2023-11-29T16:11:45 |
Simão Gonçalves, Gonçalo Correia, Diogo Pernes, Afonso Mendes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The centroid method is a simple approach for extractive multi-document
summarization and many improvements to its pipeline have been proposed. We
further refine it by adding a beam search process to the sentence selection and
also a centroid estimation attention model that leads to improved results. We
demonstrate this in several multi-document summarization datasets, including in
a multilingual scenario.
|
[
-0.8433768153,
-0.6064234376,
0.4145549536,
-0.007396216,
-0.3178114593,
-0.0387567617,
-0.2643401921,
-0.1930746436,
0.6028385758,
0.3353001773,
-0.6745309234,
-0.8105757236,
-0.6935607791,
0.0884258747,
-0.1525866538,
1.155000329,
0.2167340517,
0.1233310327,
-0.1130065992,
-0.2132502943,
-0.3803330958,
-0.38163957,
-0.3412611783,
-0.3613406122,
0.8116113544,
1.1882901192,
0.6833370328,
0.6467645764,
0.7662402987,
0.1885915548,
-0.3861936033,
0.0739177242,
-0.2743572891,
-0.0243866201,
0.043572817,
-0.3242793977,
-0.6413863301,
0.2503412664,
0.4595136344,
1.1582430601,
-0.0035049364,
0.2622938156,
0.1457789689,
0.7885062099,
-0.9855725169,
-0.0531719029,
-0.1293231249,
-0.1302713901,
-0.3458446562,
-0.3591433465,
-0.2212139517,
-0.2470951676,
0.1509367377,
-0.4457877576,
0.6864388585,
-0.0128766885,
0.5529447794,
0.1771786362,
-0.5978395939,
-0.3407350481,
-0.4704579115,
0.779294908,
-0.6029174924,
0.1622800976,
0.2254211158,
0.4728341997,
0.4534097016,
-0.7446655631,
-0.0469303913,
-0.0342384018,
-0.3883042336,
0.5273593068,
0.3587853611,
0.2046349049,
0.4895955622,
0.389723748,
-0.627597928,
-0.1332006902,
-0.354672581,
0.0627380013,
0.5657352805,
0.0943745747,
0.1905310601,
-0.343834877,
-0.2497401685,
-0.1683334112,
-0.8282766342,
0.0803625509,
0.1022538915,
0.3355629444,
-0.1033948064,
0.816178143,
-0.7152023315,
0.4857024848,
0.0277284235,
-0.1800476164,
0.3897268772,
-0.7832384109,
-0.1184297577,
0.3747940958,
0.2051215172,
0.6507769227,
-0.0120836897,
-0.0907717124,
-0.0532846004,
-0.0280425493,
0.2909593284,
-0.6131560206,
0.0649746731,
0.5689864755,
-0.7453563213,
-0.1271433085,
0.1293124259,
-0.9356110096,
-0.0113053815,
-0.6355361938,
-0.1641343832,
-0.4313211143,
0.0648272187,
-0.4988776743,
-0.5609457493,
0.1987995654,
0.0561433285,
-1.0366727114,
0.0638666749,
0.7862960696,
0.8987081647,
-0.2844240963,
-0.6623187065,
-0.6912977099,
0.2031407505,
-0.6221001744,
1.4527205229,
-0.2075498253,
-0.4899067581,
0.0913619474,
-0.0451987796,
-0.0933776274,
-0.3859478533,
0.776858747,
-0.2942052484,
0.0650896803,
-0.5677117109,
-0.3875983953,
-0.0783838406,
0.2203304172,
-0.555945456,
1.0410816669,
0.1139998436,
-1.0866535902,
0.4934916496,
-0.6058830619,
-0.5300718546,
0.0140568577,
-0.0214356761,
-0.4126878083,
0.2615059316,
0.7792823911,
0.5639612079,
-0.0908711925,
0.2295100093,
-0.4675182104,
-0.2730406225,
-0.1926207691,
0.053212028,
1.1140891314,
0.3593575656,
0.0831504166,
0.2826132774,
-0.7384777665,
-0.1039534733,
-0.2202415913,
-0.1572781354,
-0.2997593284,
0.0739636198,
0.1746436954,
-0.050124798,
0.3414586782,
-0.5509135127,
-0.0565016009,
-0.5499930382,
-0.2122174501,
0.1792961359,
0.387560606,
0.6689837575,
-0.6879763603,
0.5116581321,
-0.3111807406,
0.0728813484,
-0.4624358118,
-0.1747082025,
-0.5265307426,
-0.2471358329,
-0.0699715391,
0.4099659622,
-0.9571762681,
0.1923749298,
-0.3210587204,
-0.6729872823,
-0.0909046605,
0.18397291,
0.440133065,
0.4723350108,
0.2255481482,
0.117388688,
-0.4667822421,
-0.9995225072,
0.0049225013,
0.2729299366,
0.055680614,
-0.1090404987,
0.1481044888,
0.1869328171,
0.9930229783,
-0.6511304975,
-0.5670287609,
-0.7662117481,
0.5648031831,
0.6206335425,
0.3130006492,
0.8807870746,
-0.8343331814,
-0.7768430114,
0.0194834322,
-0.8227499127,
-0.3911396563,
0.0688456818,
-0.2125557214,
-0.2499902993,
0.9603495598,
-0.5260326862,
0.42824772,
0.1823889166,
0.0349086821,
0.5914034247,
-0.476298064,
0.1367105097,
-1.4448699951,
0.2928798497,
-0.1452037692,
-0.1260228157,
-0.7504110336,
0.2277444005,
0.5829955339,
-0.1563366055,
-0.6162175536,
0.0849479437,
-1.0196381807,
-0.670167923,
-0.6327953935,
0.7831389308,
-0.1112673655,
0.5251446366,
0.0513809808,
0.7980524898,
0.7099637985,
-0.7537562251,
0.5789004564,
0.2891399264,
-0.241125837,
1.145644784,
-0.6958296895,
-0.1885689497,
-0.5997720957,
0.0626656711,
-1.1313667297,
-0.2552954555,
-0.2360249907,
-0.7072942853,
0.3082246482,
0.0273426827,
-0.237252593,
-0.3526023924,
-0.7823200226,
0.1327162981,
-0.1591299921,
-0.6258900762,
0.6211301684,
0.6055716872,
-0.7231143117,
-0.7826101184,
-0.3354384899,
0.2270174026,
-0.2742422819,
-0.2571957111,
0.4646283388,
-0.257876724,
-0.2630887926,
-0.2188488692,
0.2584494352,
-0.024443619,
0.4226682484,
0.0603505336,
0.3972202241,
-0.1809650511,
0.1664596647,
0.3632718325,
-0.5344207287,
-0.1121963561,
0.2357720882,
0.4276664257,
0.2522507906,
-0.161643967,
-0.2614536881,
1.0470347404,
0.4168971479,
-0.5873746276,
0.3741982281,
0.8196532726,
-0.5934144258,
0.0145878708,
-0.4395989478,
-0.1290894002,
-0.3160900772,
0.379678458,
-0.5506574512,
-0.2979114354,
0.5154405236,
0.0147627303,
0.2926243842,
0.6324726939,
0.6415960789,
-0.0903671011,
1.1921905279,
0.7786380649,
-0.1405154914,
0.5462635159,
-0.3281843364,
0.0789273977,
-1.5714462996,
-0.0046287519,
-1.1416264772,
-0.1435186863,
-0.0282793213,
0.1188211069,
0.7173377872,
0.3970639408,
0.3863090575,
0.4338966906,
-0.4630921185,
0.6702049375,
0.6483615637,
-0.0274698138,
0.2669193745,
-0.256265372,
-0.388841778,
-0.0943988934,
-0.7550025582,
-0.3401707113,
1.1156606674,
-0.3329894841,
0.381878525,
0.3391344249,
0.8678625226,
0.2505635023,
0.7515063286,
-0.6495739818,
0.1743553281,
0.0285394546,
-0.6171678901,
-0.4994975626,
-0.0982855856,
-1.1553823948,
0.5586506724,
-0.1093187928,
-1.0309536457,
0.1840683222,
-0.2658458054,
-0.6040835381,
-0.288903445,
-0.7405046821,
0.7502995133,
-0.1624438018,
0.1382853985,
-0.4780302346,
-0.6205069423,
0.293736279,
0.0560198389,
0.4678665102,
-0.3504545987,
0.1674150079,
0.7619698048,
-0.3957689703,
0.5452585816,
-0.1015921608,
0.389965415,
0.2543609738,
-0.2407547235,
0.2461355478,
0.363462925,
0.1755513549,
-0.2548413575,
0.1939597875,
-0.5881807804,
-0.3187198937,
0.6890368462,
-0.6049687266,
-0.5898225904,
-0.3546562195,
-0.7592970729,
-0.2210858613,
0.512491107,
0.4170221388,
0.8068386912,
-0.5348430276,
0.4536193311,
0.3280247748,
0.0491854735,
1.0972875357,
0.275413543,
-0.2274849415,
-0.5439211726,
0.3795749247,
0.2679883242,
0.0047448887,
0.455706358,
0.087199606,
-0.3063298762,
-0.625374794,
-0.4741111696,
0.2971066535,
-0.8927801251,
-0.2937775254,
-0.7975239754,
-0.1922753304,
-1.1529895067,
-0.6137077808,
-0.2360590696,
-0.3432191312,
-0.1881138533,
-0.282881707,
-0.2328379601,
0.465626806,
-0.2854281366,
0.3749848306,
-0.9649401307,
0.7214639783,
0.1737351269,
-0.0402977504,
-0.0760182738,
-0.2593515813,
-0.6113163233,
-0.1044037417,
-0.2637375891,
-0.9995772839,
0.6095101833,
0.1726158112,
1.1295496225,
0.5490173697,
0.3129009008,
0.437004596,
-0.2247163504,
0.5803162456,
0.154216066,
-0.741119802,
0.7709864974,
-0.2441781759,
0.8497698903,
0.5618295074,
0.4829729497,
-0.6160849929,
-0.3129895031,
-0.5337253809,
-0.7307272553,
0.8714014888,
-0.0821005479,
-0.2694242895,
-0.1670604199,
0.1148785129,
-0.2222510725,
0.0065979417,
-0.1606962234,
-0.175377205,
-0.0089359237,
-0.2511651516,
-0.513119936,
-0.4951107204,
-0.2848317921,
0.2455844432,
0.6477066875,
-0.604380548,
0.0484330244,
0.5806450844,
-0.548903048,
0.0970996618,
0.260697335,
0.5470574498,
0.8992374539,
-0.4091556966,
0.2319928408,
0.3748398721,
-0.2631242573,
-0.3068426251,
0.233539626,
-0.2724964619,
0.1355195343,
0.5811290145,
0.2344710827,
0.3644187748,
-0.3125117123,
0.6607325077,
-0.0878210962,
-0.1378731877,
-0.4147932529,
-0.3013702631,
0.0694744512,
0.2948516905,
0.5366451144,
-0.0764894262,
0.4888617992,
-0.4344199598,
0.3223601282,
0.4073357284,
-0.578968823,
-0.0274843518,
0.5763577819,
-0.0544063039,
-0.2306349427,
0.2567990124,
0.0724393427,
-0.318800956,
0.7431878448,
0.2901714742,
0.9362516403,
-0.1711449772,
0.40179649,
0.7205283046,
0.1977297515,
0.038343247,
0.0868509039,
-0.2611157,
-0.8751508594,
-0.3133099377,
-0.099435769,
-0.4811578691,
-0.6997170448,
-1.1378126144,
0.376619786,
-0.1690947562,
-0.16875422,
0.4595077038,
0.1774244308,
-0.2003720254,
0.0816344842,
0.2870700359,
0.7006199956,
-0.5959947109,
0.9957997203,
0.4980064929,
-0.3783848286,
-0.3165158927,
-0.2695057094,
0.2600105107,
-0.2545326054,
0.1547066569,
0.2124139071,
-0.1224967614,
-0.1482857317,
-0.4885329902,
-1.2034717798,
1.3033419847,
-0.1181165054,
-0.0362458341,
0.039589826,
-0.3207865059,
0.5715735555,
-0.6262388229,
0.4848979414,
0.6541695595,
0.1777796298,
0.0757813156,
-0.6025657058,
-0.3542436063,
-0.2304551601,
0.1244251132,
-0.0839091316,
-0.6096316576,
1.0195530653,
-0.4015646875,
-0.4573566914,
0.0109056383,
0.7169790864,
0.1727900505,
0.5500169396,
0.1303970814,
0.3049782813,
0.7955986857,
-0.1089385226,
1.4228442907,
-0.7277476788,
0.4342511594,
1.3357049227,
-0.3993577063,
0.7579818368,
0.3395188153,
0.3429446518,
-0.1268929094,
0.6423434615,
0.336004734,
0.4892547131,
-0.3956769705,
0.1458585858,
0.0664837733,
-0.2317989618,
-0.1222497597,
0.2924043238,
0.3489160836,
0.0473751612,
-0.6560716033,
0.0359280109,
0.1374799609,
0.2076381892,
-0.4832320213,
1.0281748772,
-0.1280739903,
-1.1431251764,
0.4415883124,
0.1475193501,
0.225482896,
-0.0961191952,
0.1455257386,
-0.5041721463,
0.3099469543,
-0.1752788872,
-0.5447850227,
0.6849671006,
-0.2329007834,
-0.2506209314,
-0.2387610525,
0.6216557622,
-0.4249734879,
-0.5503943563,
0.3638070524,
0.5815496445,
-0.160324201,
-0.2510638535,
-0.4661542475,
-0.4002304971,
-0.0034529157,
-0.1038114652,
0.192280218,
0.3565973341,
-0.0694347918,
0.4373777807,
0.676364243,
0.1108730063,
0.0522599518,
0.3860034049,
0.7614150047,
-0.6647711396,
-0.6721960902,
-0.3761862814,
0.2434170395,
-0.4950147867,
-0.4414779842,
0.8065454364,
0.8441665769,
0.5753095746,
0.1302003115,
0.5843274593,
-0.072767511,
1.2292841673,
-0.5965941548,
0.5974860191,
-0.301279217,
0.0094612865,
-0.2131982595,
-1.4183367491,
-0.5739300847,
0.4664858878,
-0.2358540297,
-0.2994582951,
1.3928705454,
0.8109586835,
0.1474787742,
0.0293318089,
0.4428050518,
-0.0234294087,
0.1753935069,
0.3630507886,
0.4076459408,
-0.2597639263,
0.5672119856,
-0.5479441285,
-0.4299578667,
-0.2283034772,
-0.5452505946,
-0.951583147,
-0.5097376704,
-0.2048523873,
-0.009427554,
-0.217092514,
0.6586353183,
0.7029455304,
-0.8259289265,
-0.4514026344,
0.2856510878,
0.3557420671,
-0.5732463002,
-0.1236906275,
0.5679581761,
-0.9377678037,
-1.0216921568,
0.4035332501,
0.4821751416,
-0.157766521,
0.016586205,
0.1419420391,
-0.5881257653,
-0.19293046,
0.4145585597,
-0.0270656496,
-0.0902959183,
-0.133778289,
-0.0722813979,
-0.3431105614,
0.3414493799,
0.9320416451,
-0.2420960218,
0.2991304398,
0.6016427875,
0.418918699,
0.925799787,
0.2453816384,
0.38175264,
-0.7522844672,
0.3254981339,
-0.2321573496,
0.6708660126,
0.2966112196,
-0.2597397268,
0.5336453319,
0.2177210897,
-0.4212834537,
-0.2088729143,
-0.0034120504,
-1.0615336895,
-0.2533044815,
0.9409000278,
-0.1693804711,
-0.4473659098,
-0.3219740987,
-0.503107965,
0.2511295378,
-0.1511243582,
0.7130579352,
0.7011620402,
0.058444161,
-0.5486805439,
-0.3395883143,
0.372259587,
0.3131898344,
-0.976267755,
0.1682516783,
0.7567785382,
-0.0901587829,
0.536818862,
0.6480388045,
-0.2964523137,
0.477475673,
0.1630966514,
0.2938706875,
0.3183316588,
-0.6398282051,
-0.2394132465,
0.6532121301,
-0.0080586914,
0.0721264258
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17972v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17972v3
|
Self-Infilling Code Generation
| 2023-11-29T16:02:06 | 2024-05-26T18:15:39 |
Lin Zheng, Jianbo Yuan, Zhi Zhang, Hongxia Yang, Lingpeng Kong
|
cs.PL
|
cs.PL, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This work introduces self-infilling code generation, a general framework that
incorporates infilling operations into auto-regressive decoding. Our approach
capitalizes on the observation that recent infilling-capable code language
models can self-infill: whereas infilling operations aim to fill in the middle
based on a predefined prefix and suffix, self-infilling sequentially generates
both such surrounding context and the infilled content. We utilize this
capability to introduce novel interruption and looping mechanisms in
conventional decoding, evolving it into a non-monotonic process. Interruptions
allow for postponing the generation of specific code until a definitive suffix
is established, enhancing control over the output. Meanwhile, the looping
mechanism, which leverages the complementary nature of self-infilling and
left-to-right decoding, can iteratively update and synchronize each piece of
generation cyclically. Extensive experiments are conducted to demonstrate that
our proposed decoding process is effective in enhancing both regularity and
quality across several code generation benchmarks.
|
[
-0.1477495581,
-0.5417709351,
0.097443819,
0.788005054,
-0.3803486824,
0.239366442,
0.1392497718,
-0.3929128945,
0.2362233847,
0.6975438595,
-0.7328115702,
-0.0427487828,
-0.1507892013,
0.7150683403,
-0.5929142833,
0.9395827651,
0.0138409063,
-0.2255105376,
-0.2685672641,
0.1270970851,
-0.8763522506,
-0.7416011095,
-0.3777692318,
-0.1980367601,
-0.2352759987,
0.8027068973,
0.6457817554,
1.0181809664,
0.2549569309,
0.2501539886,
0.6190064549,
0.1746313274,
-0.6623613834,
0.3849177361,
0.2109455019,
0.0129349139,
-0.1893677711,
-0.3423868418,
0.6160725355,
0.290371865,
-0.4291582406,
0.2990959585,
0.2560994029,
0.7720420957,
-0.5085820556,
-0.0137658538,
-0.529471755,
-0.0570907742,
-0.2292248607,
-0.7094272971,
-0.318297565,
-0.3307727873,
-0.5505485535,
-0.2524504066,
0.159852773,
-0.0156845152,
0.4333050847,
0.6778050661,
0.1511737555,
-0.8339254856,
-0.6506686807,
0.3211206198,
-0.9425934553,
0.2832929492,
0.5228210092,
-0.1503050029,
-0.4595760107,
-0.7674475908,
-0.4523396492,
-0.0975055695,
-0.0092690559,
0.1614601761,
-0.1853110939,
-0.0251857471,
0.0602568649,
0.7521068454,
-0.5016297698,
-0.3228512704,
-0.2639717758,
0.0380843841,
0.7089833617,
0.2188920379,
0.281868875,
-0.2963650525,
-0.4139401615,
0.2625694871,
-0.6383801103,
-0.0126441084,
0.7042843103,
-0.051764369,
-0.0588218831,
0.3558836281,
-0.3750342131,
0.6030150652,
0.5642412305,
0.0518196821,
0.11730358,
-0.4341014922,
-0.5495932698,
0.0906593949,
0.6346979737,
0.2617277801,
-0.0014691988,
-0.2461940795,
-0.320871681,
-0.234133929,
0.4662779868,
-0.6947885752,
-0.4166516364,
0.2909515798,
-0.6747040153,
-0.4643294513,
-0.0464621633,
-0.5708409548,
0.3405146301,
-0.1235563904,
0.3145232797,
-0.4991217852,
-0.240077585,
0.5738611817,
0.0327572338,
0.0038669338,
-0.320922792,
-0.9142613411,
0.2665709853,
0.165345937,
0.6449308991,
0.0445983186,
-0.4021605551,
-0.4870812595,
0.2448929399,
-0.4087598622,
0.6372743249,
-0.5288227797,
-0.7333387136,
0.0909138992,
-0.0568659343,
0.2443605065,
-0.5074846745,
0.0383834019,
-0.638210535,
0.0837941766,
0.0869172812,
-0.6832333207,
0.1897875071,
-0.3748342097,
-0.4110158086,
1.1056985855,
0.4319722652,
-0.5130105615,
0.1178188771,
-0.6744430065,
-0.4762969315,
0.1561906487,
-0.0868621245,
-0.5675390363,
0.3767679632,
0.0092042778,
0.12069913,
-0.1238162443,
0.0870097652,
-0.177387014,
-0.2657007873,
0.2241282165,
-0.3244634271,
0.633774817,
0.5974397063,
-0.2750454843,
-0.1693533361,
-0.8988135457,
0.161938861,
0.2289766222,
-0.3099109828,
0.0245692525,
-0.0331037901,
-0.2119732648,
0.2855073214,
0.1766706556,
-0.375873208,
0.6114754081,
-0.2977134883,
0.5032975674,
0.5418267846,
0.4333025217,
0.4674137831,
-0.1512874514,
0.5968501568,
-0.1280098259,
0.3276052475,
-0.8163660765,
-0.1516547352,
-0.6909784675,
-0.2634963393,
0.2774754763,
0.2630705237,
-0.821818769,
0.39041695,
0.1477000862,
-0.0363463946,
-0.3939022124,
0.4670118093,
0.5163283348,
0.5502729416,
0.6025000811,
-0.4781802595,
-0.5776777864,
-0.6771835685,
-0.0464672446,
0.0937702283,
0.3518113196,
-0.2037569135,
0.3055662215,
-0.4002151191,
1.1096311808,
-0.2875861228,
-0.0621814281,
0.0835815221,
0.3955212533,
0.1966978014,
1.1505105495,
0.499699533,
-0.2540740073,
-0.4461576045,
-0.4813215137,
-0.8257474303,
-0.2757664919,
-0.6378478408,
-0.2971295714,
0.364811182,
0.8766720295,
0.0090665026,
0.6916922331,
0.500526309,
-0.5226173401,
0.620503366,
-0.6718963385,
0.0998557806,
-0.776832819,
-0.0445445068,
-0.5618123412,
-0.4745526612,
-0.5131295323,
0.1877143681,
0.2734954953,
-0.0652507469,
-0.013144834,
-0.0447543524,
-0.9924893379,
-0.049587436,
-0.568597734,
-0.5506222248,
-0.0637144148,
0.2960318327,
-0.1695886105,
1.0402976274,
0.5211601257,
-0.577609241,
0.0865182504,
0.1461361945,
0.0469283387,
-0.0000586239,
-0.636772573,
0.3811622262,
-0.211722061,
0.1659088582,
-0.7805258632,
-0.3200353682,
0.2153185606,
-0.3309883773,
0.4647675157,
-0.4846886992,
-0.5158208609,
-0.5098333359,
-0.1049623117,
0.8294732571,
0.6756852865,
-0.6372401714,
0.1331318915,
0.0868277624,
0.111195229,
-0.3138298988,
-0.7049385309,
0.462007761,
-0.1078371927,
-0.5620375872,
0.1982176453,
-0.4321124256,
0.178464517,
0.1082405299,
-0.0848683864,
-0.0733657554,
0.0183479805,
0.1903129816,
0.1661165208,
-0.0793759972,
-0.0623205714,
0.2068053931,
-0.4997245371,
0.0495426729,
-0.7725255489,
0.6005077362,
0.0700491518,
-0.4516934156,
-0.3522494733,
0.9158408046,
0.4102104902,
-0.3749859929,
0.2339695394,
0.1014398932,
-0.1685372889,
-0.460383445,
-0.5381748676,
-0.0119536119,
-0.5617428422,
-0.1783643812,
-0.6510982513,
-0.6832959056,
0.7165758014,
0.142144978,
-0.0839575976,
0.2867653072,
0.5897240639,
-0.2486053556,
0.8154805899,
1.1396980286,
0.0136661092,
0.471182555,
-0.3954877257,
0.3079936504,
-0.4407632053,
-0.0132816909,
-0.2661427259,
0.1518338025,
-0.3427963555,
-0.4121218026,
-0.008144672,
0.6344847083,
-0.0511454344,
0.4996914268,
-0.9911108613,
0.6404392123,
0.3966032863,
-0.2799608111,
0.2738334239,
0.02729748,
0.1219176427,
0.2211974263,
-0.9042311907,
-0.2310309261,
0.8942219019,
0.3932241201,
1.1804486513,
-0.160981074,
1.2453421354,
0.7566553354,
0.1606421918,
-0.2402298599,
-0.093264021,
0.0701372549,
-0.2369710058,
-0.2608007491,
-0.3120541871,
-0.7456638217,
-0.3631263971,
0.1955627054,
-0.4288277328,
0.6128349304,
0.4708839655,
-0.6331193447,
0.026365269,
-0.6290633678,
0.7376480699,
0.0068449778,
-0.2808309793,
-0.1067741588,
-0.5683648586,
0.3491523862,
-0.1223370731,
0.0166299883,
0.0964866877,
0.2358118892,
0.1244327128,
-0.6191638112,
0.7083372474,
-0.0938632563,
-0.3686767519,
0.5951917768,
0.5248498321,
0.4581270516,
0.4834681451,
0.0824165046,
0.081430912,
0.1709736139,
-0.6241171956,
-0.5397225022,
0.4784850776,
-0.4448165894,
-0.2799429297,
-0.4504871666,
-0.5152700543,
0.2143893838,
0.2679307163,
0.6580356359,
0.8734815121,
0.1188297197,
-0.1116291359,
0.5286466479,
0.0760899037,
0.9411265254,
0.3160785735,
-0.1968331188,
-0.6349568367,
1.1186964512,
0.0442407317,
0.4062761962,
-0.2016333342,
-0.2367095798,
-0.4207600355,
-0.6032399535,
-0.6224219203,
0.1451879144,
-0.6365004778,
-0.7765614986,
-0.4485194981,
-0.2886512578,
-0.5678869486,
-0.4076092243,
-0.4678120911,
-0.1491302401,
-0.1441092044,
0.4021319151,
0.1248892248,
1.0232563019,
-0.580241859,
0.172504738,
-0.9994593263,
0.5862769485,
0.1331775188,
0.5703853369,
-0.1646302789,
-0.3527806699,
-0.6228458881,
-0.1111138165,
-0.1339332014,
-1.0049951077,
0.4823695123,
0.1663113385,
0.3587264717,
0.278260529,
0.262206912,
1.1668727398,
-0.5334482193,
0.6374531984,
0.3262009621,
-1.2535130978,
0.3974190354,
-0.3140368164,
0.4266312718,
0.5390496254,
-0.2100882381,
-0.5663273335,
-0.6528360844,
-0.6236345172,
-0.7428511977,
0.5032353997,
0.5528957248,
0.2019276023,
-0.4728973806,
0.6409121752,
0.238517344,
0.1217929199,
-0.5390700698,
-0.20196338,
-0.9527766705,
-0.1030069366,
0.1878599823,
-0.6237129569,
0.0015280705,
-0.0439365022,
0.5541833639,
-0.3832159638,
0.6920536757,
0.8067031503,
-0.3662543297,
-0.3996270299,
0.0686089844,
0.7147818208,
0.5287584066,
-0.072329931,
-0.068529956,
0.0606645048,
-0.2798939049,
0.2045360953,
-0.208860755,
-0.0890592709,
-0.1091745868,
0.1874404699,
0.2357245833,
0.0698803589,
-0.2768662572,
0.255959928,
-0.2152355015,
-0.2097754627,
-0.6255810261,
-0.0608092993,
-0.3568268716,
0.1815966517,
0.5840926766,
0.1007853672,
0.3684622943,
-0.5007432103,
0.5001531839,
0.2016875893,
0.0621119402,
-0.1635963768,
0.6289300323,
0.2448580861,
-0.2224923074,
0.6937965751,
-0.6257497668,
-0.2700511217,
0.5537649393,
1.2541971207,
1.1872783899,
-0.0532398522,
-0.0352934524,
0.5163348913,
0.1539929956,
0.0031175571,
0.5783672929,
-0.4397428632,
-0.3961902857,
-0.558948338,
-0.7107822895,
0.0676563755,
-0.1333529055,
-0.7868104577,
-0.006303296,
-0.3737522066,
0.0192667358,
-0.6386514902,
-0.4152362943,
-0.2384712249,
0.1870197803,
0.257048279,
1.1171756983,
-0.3201611638,
0.9798152447,
0.3129995465,
-0.4911959469,
-0.6437801123,
0.4172864258,
-0.307499975,
-0.5747873783,
0.3643756211,
0.0621153638,
-0.5571489334,
0.3378995061,
-0.6888285279,
-1.3055341244,
0.8685681224,
0.101353623,
-0.2519882619,
-0.2276009023,
-0.0849006325,
0.2350383401,
-0.7809060216,
-0.053525053,
0.7533563972,
0.1793830842,
-0.1277625561,
-0.5931367874,
0.0487008654,
-0.4788227081,
0.1899599731,
0.1373661608,
-0.6451553702,
0.5005396605,
-0.0070784451,
-0.6193173528,
0.403611064,
1.0285220146,
-0.2594811022,
0.0840379074,
0.320561409,
0.5109394193,
0.3235678077,
0.1285396963,
0.856507659,
-1.0726263523,
0.4878080189,
1.2679320574,
0.1320618391,
0.36363554,
0.4298409522,
0.1736060679,
0.629295826,
0.5178834796,
-0.0976600796,
0.6719053388,
0.0723064169,
0.0165841542,
-0.3706108928,
0.348274827,
-0.5489373803,
0.4837717116,
0.1825222671,
-0.0910696089,
-0.4435967207,
0.1650706232,
-0.0875184685,
0.0309400689,
0.0080243181,
0.6538019776,
-0.2290497124,
-0.8199203014,
0.845248878,
0.0203183554,
0.5606744289,
-0.581697464,
-0.245280996,
-0.3956564665,
-0.1142055467,
-0.4450089633,
-0.7254661322,
0.8192129135,
-0.0940407887,
-0.3641071618,
-0.6380704641,
0.7223906517,
-0.596572876,
-0.1840495616,
0.2585285604,
0.2085823119,
0.0587616563,
0.1831827611,
-0.5976196527,
0.0628634617,
0.2188858986,
-0.0007849047,
-0.0846911594,
0.4204244912,
0.3798941076,
0.6065418124,
0.7911736965,
-0.2586656809,
0.5554721355,
0.0572556444,
0.9757708907,
-0.7335589528,
-0.9077221751,
-0.7078264356,
0.6699081659,
0.0758968443,
-0.4047352374,
0.8360719085,
0.6393078566,
0.7875640988,
-0.263797015,
0.7088367343,
-0.2661178112,
-0.0076424028,
-0.6289135814,
0.4553250372,
-0.418936342,
0.0505637638,
-0.1627119035,
-0.4793100953,
-0.098364301,
0.5478907824,
0.1484804302,
-0.2333367914,
0.5290166736,
0.7771963477,
0.1057741791,
-0.0881454274,
0.4420893788,
-0.0333182216,
0.1564520895,
0.3325656652,
0.9530066848,
-0.508652389,
0.2934469581,
-0.4459637403,
-0.2532523274,
-0.2701986432,
-0.9165920615,
-0.7176610827,
-0.5481865406,
-0.2496563047,
-0.6457107067,
0.0583325475,
0.9388599396,
0.7576773167,
-0.5288087726,
-0.5210219026,
-0.5543156266,
-0.0883530229,
-0.2828964293,
-0.21646294,
-0.1360715777,
-1.278903842,
-0.5005406737,
0.5734823942,
0.6799780726,
0.2433415651,
-0.3620685339,
-0.3350912035,
0.0840807334,
0.5390272737,
0.4083780944,
0.7824033499,
-0.2820459902,
0.0515866503,
0.0471047796,
-0.0831514522,
0.359470427,
1.3154027462,
-0.7682845592,
0.7949200273,
0.3783834577,
0.4842639267,
0.4232620895,
0.3508535326,
0.6929373145,
-0.7365683913,
-0.0649433807,
0.1378988624,
0.2487281263,
0.0242614876,
-0.7795496583,
0.3558910191,
0.154766202,
-0.849462688,
-0.7854614258,
0.48980093,
-0.5586418509,
-0.3322908282,
0.738796711,
0.0927654058,
-0.2587606907,
-0.3760809004,
0.0132669201,
0.226467967,
-0.5143867135,
0.7579729557,
0.4535799026,
-0.4678522944,
0.004784422,
-0.2012925744,
0.9565836787,
0.213416487,
-0.6043729186,
0.2910224497,
0.5074975491,
0.4292497933,
0.2099912614,
1.0161960125,
-0.4421334863,
0.5851320028,
0.2051548511,
0.2807180285,
-0.3350949287,
-0.5188246965,
-0.7526239753,
0.2303643525,
-0.0667048544,
-0.2373639643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17743v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17743v1
|
Mukhyansh: A Headline Generation Dataset for Indic Languages
| 2023-11-29T15:49:24 | 2023-11-29T15:49:24 |
Lokesh Madasu, Gopichand Kanumolu, Nirmal Surange, Manish Shrivastava
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The task of headline generation within the realm of Natural Language
Processing (NLP) holds immense significance, as it strives to distill the true
essence of textual content into concise and attention-grabbing summaries. While
noteworthy progress has been made in headline generation for widely spoken
languages like English, there persist numerous challenges when it comes to
generating headlines in low-resource languages, such as the rich and diverse
Indian languages. A prominent obstacle that specifically hinders headline
generation in Indian languages is the scarcity of high-quality annotated data.
To address this crucial gap, we proudly present Mukhyansh, an extensive
multilingual dataset, tailored for Indian language headline generation.
Comprising an impressive collection of over 3.39 million article-headline
pairs, Mukhyansh spans across eight prominent Indian languages, namely Telugu,
Tamil, Kannada, Malayalam, Hindi, Bengali, Marathi, and Gujarati. We present a
comprehensive evaluation of several state-of-the-art baseline models.
Additionally, through an empirical analysis of existing works, we demonstrate
that Mukhyansh outperforms all other models, achieving an impressive average
ROUGE-L score of 31.43 across all 8 languages.
|
[
-0.2046796083,
-0.2732184231,
0.0410478897,
0.5365206003,
-0.4674534202,
0.4601204693,
-0.4842259586,
-0.4072360694,
0.4680222273,
0.5076994896,
-0.4112327993,
-0.6443763971,
-0.4481357336,
0.289630264,
-0.2516203821,
1.3611463308,
0.4413824975,
-0.2429210246,
0.2015477568,
-0.1795869321,
-0.4288907945,
-0.1597366631,
-0.2352447063,
0.0928312466,
0.4775646925,
0.781627357,
0.726246357,
0.8390610814,
0.6552078128,
0.1605888307,
0.1755129248,
0.3704560101,
-0.0483910292,
0.4861766398,
0.0189814549,
-0.1659208089,
-0.1523255408,
-0.3105246425,
0.7661212683,
0.76820755,
-0.4717821479,
0.2979626656,
0.0293042511,
0.9448568821,
-0.7590609193,
0.0733658448,
-0.5739290118,
-0.1430827528,
-0.7489272952,
-0.1223205104,
-0.2118542194,
-0.5082182884,
-0.3767215312,
-0.4254978001,
-0.0897038504,
0.0148746278,
0.5046101213,
0.2397752553,
-0.5127398372,
-0.4602411687,
-0.6274828911,
0.751339972,
-0.6758674979,
0.4692922831,
0.4969157279,
0.4874618053,
0.1403140277,
-0.3122929335,
-0.2866756022,
-0.350358367,
-0.1416957527,
0.2238688469,
0.2100724578,
-0.1753796637,
0.2645569742,
0.6039760113,
-0.710047245,
-0.1416974813,
-0.5242110491,
-0.2255398035,
0.5863418579,
0.3077181578,
0.3547874093,
-0.6751440167,
-0.2163230628,
0.139192462,
-0.6249371171,
0.3525626361,
0.9302879572,
0.7813460231,
-0.3906227052,
0.6805164218,
-0.7610659003,
0.9835220575,
-0.0413512327,
-0.4456495047,
0.2041946352,
-0.7673168778,
-0.0061247852,
0.4057732224,
0.7552788258,
0.3575513661,
-0.0300850663,
0.0647862554,
0.2257323712,
-0.0203625336,
0.0382250249,
-0.6625550985,
-0.1572650373,
0.1742398888,
-0.4026851058,
-0.3385585248,
-0.220909968,
-1.3901143074,
-0.5315325856,
-0.3377579153,
-0.4189223051,
-0.5495409966,
-0.5804590583,
-0.2803055942,
0.1319434643,
0.5737372041,
0.0355785303,
-1.3541785479,
-0.193877697,
0.4176160395,
0.7287335992,
-0.1447857469,
-0.4171206057,
-0.4037480354,
0.0053153085,
-0.7141634226,
0.8661950827,
-0.8195872903,
-0.1794198751,
0.1860079914,
-0.5441379547,
0.2764944434,
-0.3427745104,
0.9131161571,
-0.0984717086,
-0.4437424242,
-0.1715838611,
-0.0737004429,
0.1505851001,
0.3502905369,
-0.568013072,
0.8890990019,
0.3945190907,
-0.9012309313,
0.7179182768,
-0.3766456544,
-0.7255450487,
0.2123792022,
-0.2937558591,
-0.1802530438,
0.1881746799,
0.465428412,
0.3215567768,
-0.3216507435,
0.313472569,
0.1155291945,
0.0275565721,
-0.1471766829,
-0.2669234872,
0.8688604236,
0.4570792317,
0.058082737,
-0.1846157163,
-1.2246326208,
0.116800651,
-0.2570770383,
-0.5332241654,
-0.4946760237,
-0.3118925989,
0.3913016617,
0.4120908976,
-0.003330667,
-0.7858980894,
0.2549703121,
-0.7199705243,
0.2327477932,
0.3990595043,
0.0888407007,
0.3177179396,
-0.1521563828,
0.5162030458,
0.0672684312,
0.0655682608,
-0.6494748592,
-0.4324602187,
-0.4094594419,
-0.4113544524,
0.3569992185,
0.4232070148,
-0.7000649571,
-0.1151449904,
-0.3241005242,
-0.9493656754,
-0.8679737449,
0.2968732715,
0.2974796295,
0.4766630828,
0.2041591555,
0.334476769,
-0.7824047804,
-1.3703080416,
-0.8528304696,
0.2440484315,
0.3977214098,
-0.0899136662,
0.2162466347,
0.1232908443,
0.912065804,
-0.2918689549,
-0.0015672193,
-0.5395566225,
0.1314214766,
0.5224235058,
0.4676837623,
0.3574167788,
-1.0453830957,
-0.8932206631,
0.0626526698,
-0.586040616,
0.0050535901,
-0.2258869708,
-0.2392563075,
0.2269965261,
0.3903334439,
-0.9730191231,
0.3484583199,
0.6634694934,
-0.2481519133,
1.0114651918,
0.0002104421,
0.6732185483,
-1.443726778,
0.1253781021,
-0.2964994907,
-0.021023022,
-0.6856979132,
-0.0777468085,
0.1493376344,
-0.537712872,
-0.3714731634,
0.6166475415,
-0.3235261738,
0.1814537644,
-0.1148625314,
-0.1195057407,
-0.2888529599,
0.515308857,
-0.283847034,
0.8111392856,
0.5322366357,
-0.5826402307,
0.4686242044,
0.3142341971,
-0.7585723996,
0.6912330389,
-0.1723922491,
-0.4680753946,
-0.0581647269,
-0.202327013,
-1.0967819691,
-0.7103661299,
0.2382931113,
-0.7606523037,
0.4877502322,
-0.0201199241,
-0.5188288689,
-0.1151386499,
-0.3985922039,
0.5201662183,
0.25272879,
-0.4594580531,
0.4556203485,
0.4168640971,
-0.5461694598,
-0.9432049394,
-0.94281739,
0.3231219947,
-0.253595233,
-0.3147677183,
-0.1353637129,
-0.0434682779,
-0.4389961958,
-0.1565120816,
-0.0897870064,
-0.0959291086,
-0.2310437858,
0.1660798192,
0.1490158439,
-0.2174020112,
0.0233512241,
0.1828949749,
-0.2961157262,
-0.1846122742,
-0.057836622,
0.3285169303,
0.1608511508,
-0.2268863469,
-0.216685161,
0.7073897123,
0.8125423193,
-0.4679062963,
0.7170542479,
0.5228378773,
-0.4074468017,
-0.2394366413,
-0.3661085069,
0.1652884632,
-0.3260910511,
0.524928391,
-0.3568399847,
-0.4243459702,
0.2895470858,
0.0915123522,
0.1748775095,
0.9222375154,
0.8107513785,
0.104728274,
1.0060907602,
0.7753274441,
-0.3467445374,
-0.0055822628,
0.3215945959,
0.6065751314,
-0.6103902459,
-0.0719953254,
-0.6886529326,
0.0743717551,
-0.913654685,
0.0500409268,
0.0980181396,
0.1122740135,
0.1098963693,
0.2924415171,
-0.6745016575,
0.468352288,
0.4936960042,
-0.2669816315,
0.6220591068,
0.2148963511,
0.1381418556,
-0.4077677429,
-0.4679940939,
-0.3170740008,
1.2041413784,
-0.3951794803,
0.8158047199,
0.2331948429,
0.3520268202,
0.4741991162,
0.243497014,
-0.3840141594,
0.1803457439,
0.0394549817,
-0.8019631505,
-0.2797997296,
-0.4133343101,
-0.7154789567,
0.2170537114,
-0.1018444523,
-0.5160897374,
-0.1579012424,
0.0455255136,
-0.6968635321,
0.3420673013,
-0.4017023444,
0.620529294,
-0.088752836,
-0.0779350027,
-0.3042266667,
-0.7504160404,
1.1211173534,
-0.2201219052,
0.4447505474,
-0.5342913866,
-0.0830933824,
0.5519803762,
-0.0167891216,
0.491761893,
0.0314873569,
0.126893416,
0.2070493996,
-0.1443485618,
0.2909193039,
0.39776811,
-0.0695823804,
0.2480763644,
-0.229455471,
-0.5082865357,
-0.318803519,
0.7210285664,
-0.4247109592,
-0.0998855233,
-0.5468155742,
-0.7307165265,
-0.3942027092,
0.1008348688,
0.533999145,
0.7134897113,
-0.0593248978,
0.2429761142,
0.2515447736,
-0.4160096347,
0.4958046675,
0.2709819674,
-0.4123774171,
-0.5100983381,
1.0195034742,
0.2812154889,
0.0757644996,
0.4264318645,
0.0579962656,
-0.3344469666,
-0.5149235725,
-0.8868689537,
0.0208674781,
-0.7999481559,
-0.4754425287,
-0.8531092405,
-0.4616731703,
-0.4397008121,
-0.1975497454,
-0.5326626301,
-0.4655456245,
0.528500855,
-0.0324363783,
0.2970030904,
0.7162232995,
-0.2383815795,
-0.0091246944,
-0.8368166089,
0.380472362,
0.2643614113,
0.4588465691,
-0.2253665477,
-0.4791845083,
-0.6591109037,
-0.013639071,
-0.1396929324,
-0.6116498113,
0.3521562219,
0.3424528837,
0.5622063875,
0.2573144436,
0.0382401943,
0.3686813712,
-0.3362325728,
0.7852256298,
0.1932620704,
-0.4815614522,
0.824862659,
-0.8777831793,
0.5122499466,
0.7781678438,
0.3193318248,
-0.7517983913,
-0.6893923283,
-0.4934248328,
-0.8857338428,
0.5417591333,
0.3736687601,
0.2101940811,
-0.0183653887,
0.2246780992,
0.5767114162,
0.4689345956,
-0.39437747,
-0.3928520083,
-0.1757491976,
-0.3893366754,
-0.1952926815,
-0.39355129,
0.4172310233,
-0.2533566356,
0.5801169276,
0.1340446472,
-0.2121544629,
0.049529694,
-0.19108513,
0.0535892285,
0.4433305562,
0.9440697432,
0.8081249595,
-0.073230125,
-0.1006739438,
0.0695939958,
-0.8148084879,
0.1177423075,
0.0098001873,
-0.1622374058,
0.2552777231,
0.5000625849,
0.4968413711,
0.2972058654,
-0.8696103096,
0.1924499124,
0.0020317414,
0.1234769374,
-0.204284817,
-0.2407072186,
-0.0076127583,
-0.0144823343,
0.6291489005,
0.3919987082,
0.1238662228,
-0.4086183012,
0.371245563,
0.076578334,
-0.0927851945,
-0.2643137872,
0.5785933733,
0.1336505413,
-0.1928516179,
0.726371944,
-0.3391329944,
-0.2833115458,
0.6116877198,
0.1481173635,
0.5787696838,
-0.6910786629,
0.1876176,
0.9918328524,
0.6765159965,
0.1866495758,
0.2095054388,
-0.0396025181,
-0.4362872839,
-0.6668590903,
-1.0526814461,
-0.3417508006,
0.1001167446,
-0.4330926538,
0.305091083,
-0.2690641284,
0.0937968269,
0.1259278208,
0.1985506862,
-0.5633693337,
0.0496741571,
0.3070431352,
0.8734619617,
-0.7515287995,
0.6648778915,
0.4172337353,
-0.4491544068,
-0.7262564898,
-0.1417262256,
0.0643657222,
-0.5279338956,
0.4244288802,
0.3376203477,
0.1046406105,
0.1850726604,
-0.259042114,
-0.9768002629,
0.579851687,
0.3847899437,
-0.4853234589,
0.2307039946,
0.4324103296,
0.2375538051,
-0.4993771613,
0.1059612408,
0.7621321082,
0.6727706194,
-0.3171348572,
-0.6282256842,
-0.3907716274,
-0.4053661823,
-0.2889164984,
0.5407799482,
-0.7270029187,
1.0523262024,
-0.2090115696,
-0.0867679715,
0.0569270812,
0.6710807085,
0.1884263456,
-0.051602345,
0.1808371842,
0.6069989204,
0.5791960359,
-0.0269500781,
1.1740856171,
-0.5392532349,
0.0935142487,
1.1286286116,
-0.1138257682,
0.5416380167,
0.3536586165,
-0.1032613218,
0.2604548037,
0.645519495,
0.0930517316,
0.6756321788,
0.0076716752,
-0.0573996082,
-0.1818394363,
-0.4739875793,
-0.4569084942,
1.0312985182,
0.1986900866,
0.1315578073,
-0.7516091466,
0.3164393604,
-0.0951432884,
0.1759975106,
-0.5836077929,
0.4272367656,
-0.1411622316,
-0.7642587423,
0.297488898,
-0.0397760011,
0.6191871166,
-0.947992146,
-0.2120177001,
-0.4264680743,
0.1189785674,
-0.2180893719,
-0.6850619912,
0.7726375461,
0.1606132239,
-0.5270532966,
0.0846293569,
0.7475327849,
-0.834269762,
-0.7875888348,
0.012779858,
0.578741014,
0.1466317326,
-0.2514980137,
-0.451192081,
0.0199153405,
-0.0290210247,
-0.3188771009,
0.3872258365,
0.2765208185,
0.1219275892,
0.4344477654,
0.7167184949,
0.2810509801,
0.2316374779,
-0.1889670193,
0.4484231174,
-0.8143107891,
-0.6535205245,
-1.0458925962,
0.7190917134,
-0.1922314018,
-0.7297462225,
1.1406481266,
0.9410912991,
0.6300526261,
-0.0227387957,
1.0583655834,
-0.2200487405,
0.8048112392,
-0.5156168342,
1.0922963619,
-0.558755219,
-0.3452183306,
-0.1057845056,
-0.941801846,
-0.222739473,
0.1666263938,
0.3223635852,
-0.0049181362,
0.4684851766,
0.6631421447,
0.0009420047,
0.0857363418,
0.524227798,
0.0712989643,
-0.1203194633,
0.4644536674,
0.9429470897,
-0.1945281327,
0.7277513146,
-0.3884388208,
-0.1341577768,
-0.099773556,
-0.7223125696,
-0.8101653457,
-0.7565587163,
0.0098513868,
-0.0569022186,
-0.2431433499,
1.1251424551,
0.6901243925,
-0.8700867891,
-0.1207161471,
0.2520376742,
0.1335351169,
-0.2082360536,
-0.1990644634,
0.4091041684,
-0.6367198825,
-0.5966202021,
0.5244665146,
0.7752768993,
-0.4792380333,
-0.2911256552,
0.1433600932,
-0.5724757314,
0.045934543,
0.494789809,
0.3594767451,
-0.436819613,
0.2190689743,
-0.2876639068,
-0.6099431515,
0.3470675349,
1.1005477905,
-0.5107884407,
0.4159482419,
0.4204346538,
0.8343823552,
0.0547356345,
0.0187239107,
0.1870568544,
-0.9216002226,
0.448302567,
0.2574614584,
0.12391112,
0.6459911466,
-0.5674663782,
0.5197638273,
0.1179288849,
-0.4065480828,
-0.9260619283,
0.1009854153,
-0.5436471701,
-0.0209374372,
0.8806438446,
0.3639560342,
-0.2808302939,
-0.5507619381,
-0.0834655017,
0.2661486864,
-0.4128228724,
0.5997914076,
0.9637200236,
0.1699456722,
-0.1667958498,
-1.1737788916,
0.972607553,
0.1004031375,
-0.9204332829,
0.4932545125,
0.1513125449,
-0.0678880885,
0.289383471,
0.8864746094,
0.145577535,
0.3482256532,
0.410575062,
0.1929160953,
-0.0616196692,
-0.6690981388,
-0.2353927642,
0.120930776,
-0.2015699744,
-0.0452316739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17741v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17741v1
|
End-to-end Joint Rich and Normalized ASR with a limited amount of rich training data
| 2023-11-29T15:44:39 | 2023-11-29T15:44:39 |
Can Cui, Imran Ahamad Sheikh, Mostafa Sadeghi, Emmanuel Vincent
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Joint rich and normalized automatic speech recognition (ASR), that produces
transcriptions both with and without punctuation and capitalization, remains a
challenge. End-to-end (E2E) ASR models offer both convenience and the ability
to perform such joint transcription of speech. Training such models requires
paired speech and rich text data, which is not widely available. In this paper,
we compare two different approaches to train a stateless Transducer-based E2E
joint rich and normalized ASR system, ready for streaming applications, with a
limited amount of rich labeled data. The first approach uses a language model
to generate pseudo-rich transcriptions of normalized training data. The second
approach uses a single decoder conditioned on the type of the output. The first
approach leads to E2E rich ASR which perform better on out-of-domain data, with
up to 9% relative reduction in errors. The second approach demonstrates the
feasibility of an E2E joint rich and normalized ASR system using as low as 5%
rich training data with moderate (2.42% absolute) increase in errors.
|
[
-0.2025916427,
-0.4498204887,
0.0147761507,
-0.1248806119,
-0.5562800765,
0.1979970783,
-0.6124455929,
-0.6575934887,
0.342310369,
0.3850560784,
-0.0191241596,
-0.124338083,
-0.7643517852,
0.2168875188,
-0.4579930007,
1.027258873,
-0.054335162,
0.2978567779,
-0.1583091468,
-0.2278912812,
-0.383384496,
-0.6849267483,
-0.7070399523,
-0.259829551,
0.2921074331,
0.3375312984,
0.5056124926,
0.6972182393,
0.3063268065,
0.2127797455,
-0.0665608197,
0.1026336625,
-0.503318131,
0.1144258827,
0.1905343235,
-0.1489465088,
-0.2727378011,
-0.1606045961,
0.4087843895,
0.8002040982,
-0.0015962416,
0.1663089842,
0.0379072092,
0.5118151307,
-0.6710622311,
0.094644174,
-0.291389972,
-0.0690365508,
-0.2315865606,
-0.1964572966,
-0.2795188725,
-0.0396415666,
0.277002424,
-0.5297365189,
-0.0135404747,
-0.0482746735,
0.7952198386,
0.3413062394,
-0.4772054255,
-0.2021180987,
-1.3099606037,
0.6129721999,
-0.5398692489,
0.8979539275,
0.4364936352,
0.4686199129,
0.353589654,
-0.7093063593,
-0.5737735033,
-0.0763225108,
0.0348574966,
0.4395938814,
-0.15066199,
0.0356672145,
0.2790789604,
0.4566067159,
-0.822355032,
0.2063429207,
-0.5863287449,
-0.2326120436,
0.6983562708,
-0.3146593273,
0.0967304409,
0.1401733905,
-0.4672220647,
-0.3496893346,
-0.5474547148,
0.3079789281,
0.2867317498,
0.5040501952,
-0.2592770159,
0.7904578447,
-0.3356555998,
0.7365275025,
-0.0427188277,
-0.2268447131,
0.1127471924,
-0.1486666501,
-0.2523482144,
0.2064499706,
0.8030989766,
0.3296085894,
0.4455239177,
-0.5783268213,
-0.7931219935,
0.2363916039,
-0.2365195304,
-0.6388910413,
-0.106027931,
0.2693644464,
-0.3572213948,
0.4894827604,
0.0359246284,
-0.2831445038,
-0.0572245754,
-0.8444799781,
0.7803211808,
-0.2944553494,
-0.0177045204,
0.1554485112,
-0.2525449693,
0.2344899029,
0.3967051208,
-0.5931092501,
0.7349550724,
0.172777161,
0.7388905287,
-0.0777343661,
0.1416328996,
-0.958750844,
0.3523123562,
-0.1050696671,
0.9614087343,
-0.3323722482,
-0.3871468008,
-0.1266122162,
-0.3201838732,
-0.2080136389,
-0.6232213974,
0.5963483453,
-0.6252918839,
0.24099271,
-0.2009705603,
-0.8485270143,
-0.0181949511,
-0.1187075973,
-0.7218573093,
0.7412512302,
0.000572246,
-0.5699856281,
0.4322817326,
-0.5810251236,
-0.619823575,
0.0680239797,
-0.2780144811,
-0.4420402348,
-0.0963436812,
0.0543509237,
0.3098248839,
-0.4002635479,
0.1180786192,
-0.1177722886,
-0.5840341449,
0.2981429994,
-0.509699285,
0.4266050458,
0.2758150399,
-0.4144496024,
-0.0625371709,
-0.9030455351,
-0.0811720565,
0.1638110876,
-0.6711120605,
-0.2366194874,
0.0401511341,
0.6106657982,
0.1590518504,
0.1742688566,
-0.8696811199,
-0.2139265686,
-0.5418316722,
0.2797049284,
0.2652162015,
-0.2141805291,
0.4740234017,
-0.4040088356,
0.1730651855,
0.0156230843,
-0.1774685234,
0.1862190217,
-0.4116877019,
-0.8301234245,
-0.5205543637,
0.6182214618,
0.756270349,
-0.5864923,
0.6027554274,
-0.5380313993,
-0.074351497,
-0.6532099843,
0.0017788042,
0.6442081928,
0.2929449379,
0.7294046879,
-0.475477308,
-0.5939283967,
-0.5753343701,
-0.3065100908,
0.1837946177,
-0.3754346967,
0.4407730997,
0.0853618458,
0.0280290525,
0.9312517643,
0.0412565619,
-0.38519153,
-0.4376501739,
-0.1725712866,
0.0016022916,
0.4966781735,
0.0548805743,
-0.6852070689,
-0.7936213017,
0.0941992775,
-0.4300598204,
0.1760368496,
-0.1221529245,
0.3247471452,
0.2431700379,
0.2176885456,
-0.334189117,
0.5577273965,
0.3066508472,
-0.1640609056,
-0.1555434763,
-0.1957624555,
0.0251493007,
-1.0132373571,
0.3542552888,
-0.055047445,
-0.4224745035,
-1.1203104258,
-0.4853064418,
-0.0676321387,
-0.3543725908,
-0.2057634741,
0.5084227324,
-0.714715898,
-0.6244151592,
-0.2551664114,
-0.0110148443,
-0.0519700982,
0.3317605555,
0.362529695,
0.8158057928,
0.4105688334,
-0.3610760868,
0.3803465366,
0.4195413589,
-0.0414711535,
0.0216124654,
-0.975022018,
0.3336240053,
-0.1716559678,
0.2703006566,
-0.7485522628,
-0.2463292629,
0.0349362083,
-0.7226296663,
0.935423255,
-0.1200795621,
-0.3772856891,
-0.132275939,
-0.2318550348,
0.3330760896,
0.7928971648,
-0.4652659893,
0.2390715182,
0.2598328292,
-0.1852401048,
-0.3022040427,
-0.793294549,
0.1945535988,
-0.0894524381,
-0.4608811438,
0.2911939621,
0.0559401959,
0.0497613475,
-0.1742624938,
-0.2286690623,
-0.2974520028,
-0.2723161578,
0.0651688203,
0.1687136292,
-0.2289434969,
-0.2365127355,
-0.0012477452,
-0.3345231116,
-0.2463949621,
-0.2396046072,
0.4531354904,
0.2957011461,
-0.3529110551,
-0.7774457932,
0.6051467061,
0.4843618274,
-0.5551048517,
0.624553442,
0.3975326419,
-0.6017439961,
-0.1447102875,
-0.6190706491,
-0.2619049847,
-0.3536583781,
-0.0405395702,
-0.2875911593,
-0.917141974,
0.3313803971,
0.2794834077,
0.0215854384,
0.224593401,
0.4212005436,
-0.211347118,
0.6518312097,
0.5198566914,
-0.0260618012,
0.3699148893,
-0.3970450759,
0.4548490345,
-0.8930610418,
-0.4190400541,
-0.4788957834,
-0.3404715061,
-0.2899729311,
-0.3003329933,
0.568063736,
0.2204858363,
-0.0347415097,
0.4218715429,
-0.5017775893,
0.2486402243,
0.790905714,
0.3173037469,
0.2874076664,
0.3033098578,
0.4053732753,
-0.0036585152,
-0.6136606932,
-0.4755278528,
1.304202199,
0.089103587,
0.582732439,
0.2286667228,
0.7412635684,
0.1576562226,
-0.0738546476,
-0.9455422759,
0.1428303421,
-0.4801414013,
-0.4663547873,
-0.6552020907,
-0.3404916525,
-0.8048242927,
0.0102402335,
-0.2054586262,
-0.365198493,
0.2707580328,
0.2614440322,
-0.5934616923,
0.1421090215,
-0.7309634089,
0.635204494,
-0.028980853,
-0.1775821149,
0.1335077137,
-1.1211177111,
-0.0772968978,
-0.0197343621,
0.0053877025,
0.2603253126,
-0.1401030868,
1.0418531895,
-0.4656835198,
0.6058467031,
-0.3720853329,
0.3206944466,
0.4647396505,
-0.2700417936,
0.7045446038,
-0.2121166438,
0.0755721033,
-0.0646516159,
-0.0709249973,
-0.3791893423,
-0.4595938027,
0.2690295279,
-1.187415123,
-0.0916503146,
-0.3832091689,
-0.3790232539,
-0.4331330657,
-0.0179191716,
0.4412507415,
0.9331051111,
0.0824587867,
0.4202774763,
0.8102870584,
-0.1553791165,
0.5772765279,
0.5144030452,
0.634961009,
-0.5775740147,
1.0653605461,
0.5146101117,
0.3978263736,
0.5586164594,
0.0097055985,
-0.5694071651,
-0.6982277036,
-0.7451151609,
0.1932676435,
-0.5524734259,
-0.3582595587,
-0.9615870714,
-0.5352041125,
-0.5946490169,
-0.2067386657,
-0.606030941,
-0.5491036177,
-0.4632162452,
0.1552293748,
0.5278077722,
0.4095759392,
-0.2142305374,
0.1704789996,
-0.8070736527,
0.4402339756,
0.3124705553,
0.3528522253,
-0.3538044095,
-0.8949918747,
-0.3229308724,
0.1544663906,
0.1936659515,
-0.7587730289,
0.3320297897,
0.6082775593,
0.1798835993,
0.3823871613,
0.2879908979,
0.7529380322,
-0.4549798369,
0.5470172167,
0.2637122273,
-0.7149210572,
0.2931958437,
-0.1594334245,
0.05020006,
0.5305613875,
0.3668018878,
-0.4727918208,
-0.0662091523,
-0.2547635138,
-0.7208251357,
0.6462113857,
0.2236818075,
-0.0971319526,
0.2356082201,
0.1236945391,
0.2315553576,
0.0936367139,
-0.5195314884,
-0.0908896029,
-0.4668603837,
-0.1389084607,
-0.3012828529,
-0.0515125841,
-0.1717144549,
-0.125315696,
0.5163559318,
-0.0280614849,
0.4019717574,
0.3589064777,
-0.3564220965,
-0.2855940163,
0.4307301939,
0.3397005498,
0.0887503326,
-0.1859515905,
0.0070030857,
0.0421863012,
-0.2450979054,
0.0814704448,
0.4090305567,
-0.2944818735,
0.1169749647,
0.4388568997,
1.1050395966,
0.0859469026,
-0.6555769444,
0.9087138772,
0.1759427041,
-0.1756709814,
-0.2318477929,
-0.319796294,
0.1230232939,
0.1440588087,
0.0907450691,
0.152262032,
0.4702102542,
-0.3639336526,
0.1513045579,
0.3137172461,
-0.1968099028,
-0.4001590908,
0.803135097,
0.2314865887,
-0.0753467977,
0.4724093676,
-0.1799397171,
-0.2218197137,
0.3788321316,
0.7333080769,
0.865344286,
-0.1877435446,
-0.1609050035,
0.3310326934,
0.1352352053,
0.0433032624,
0.6884695292,
-0.3881901205,
-0.6266776323,
-0.6496275663,
-0.7114595771,
-0.4372170269,
0.1099498272,
-0.9551684856,
0.2260355353,
-0.2920833528,
0.18719697,
-0.2757795453,
-0.0407622755,
-0.6840406656,
0.6192723513,
0.3902097344,
0.6427596807,
-0.945743382,
0.8926867843,
0.8283644915,
-0.4052918255,
-1.0148214102,
-0.2866789401,
-0.202840209,
-0.5212046504,
0.2552330196,
0.1499159187,
-0.0173970498,
0.1351671517,
-0.082687676,
-1.016294837,
1.1449462175,
0.1622089148,
-0.8213261962,
0.1243915334,
0.266812712,
0.5417373776,
-0.0320251323,
0.2657120526,
0.3960545361,
0.2569402754,
0.4060973823,
-1.1966844797,
-0.2056662887,
-0.2193309367,
0.1538086832,
0.1766934842,
-0.7143785954,
0.4895823896,
-0.1003942564,
-0.4934540987,
-0.1506068259,
0.7141477466,
0.0035217779,
0.5166868567,
0.5237786174,
0.6364993453,
0.3375745714,
-0.0302535873,
0.715100646,
-0.3861895204,
0.0821694061,
0.9669910073,
-0.5682495832,
1.0362957716,
0.3703557849,
-0.2540961504,
-0.2156523615,
0.6823891997,
0.173980087,
0.6858420372,
0.073920399,
-0.5682751536,
-0.1747126579,
-0.2847213447,
-0.4513486922,
0.547480762,
0.1210468784,
0.1244776249,
-0.0454037264,
0.1239071861,
-0.1233610362,
0.1524830461,
-0.0934541151,
1.0938016176,
0.0492560789,
-0.2355965227,
0.6029993296,
-0.0502574891,
0.7133872509,
-0.5064536333,
0.2124038786,
-0.2933003306,
-0.0906562954,
-0.3057678044,
-0.2694005966,
0.5067152381,
0.449890852,
-0.2450061291,
-0.3283470571,
0.8006309867,
-0.6691179276,
-0.2141662091,
0.2755094469,
0.7155068517,
0.4333210588,
0.0759360641,
-0.2504222989,
-0.0006109924,
-0.1977286041,
-0.4880750179,
0.4352581799,
0.2454991341,
0.0455370806,
0.3619037271,
0.807463944,
0.2698931098,
0.287430644,
0.218173638,
1.0600395203,
-0.3887629509,
-0.5015158653,
-0.2018620819,
0.6302219629,
0.0135552632,
-0.1364309788,
0.4276122451,
0.8792920113,
0.9563018084,
0.0451797135,
0.8978341222,
-0.141277805,
0.9758216143,
-0.4095950127,
0.4496276677,
-0.4886089265,
0.0044559282,
0.1858377606,
-0.9715174437,
-0.454326421,
0.584842205,
-0.0523019098,
0.1835660636,
0.4384633601,
0.5845499635,
-0.2082562298,
0.0369786471,
0.5127936602,
-0.0262188818,
0.1828548014,
0.5511460304,
0.6038204432,
-0.5946141481,
0.543405056,
-0.2744190097,
-0.441386342,
-0.1168519408,
-0.184236452,
-0.7611852288,
-0.3649312854,
-0.2022373378,
-0.0978491381,
0.1812095642,
1.2080498934,
0.5799943209,
-0.9390403032,
-0.3490852416,
0.1238954067,
-0.7081311345,
-0.0097868815,
-0.0772981346,
0.4059199393,
-0.0544734038,
-0.5840960741,
0.7986467481,
0.3527331352,
0.1711114943,
0.2165647,
-0.3683317602,
0.078901507,
0.0326126814,
0.5023502707,
0.5552043319,
-0.5474110246,
-0.3571202159,
0.0980709121,
-0.0126625635,
0.102390483,
0.6402997375,
-0.7027347684,
0.6784389615,
0.4301718771,
0.9818143249,
0.6899284124,
0.0135855405,
0.4337674081,
-0.460321039,
0.0840733349,
0.4731003046,
0.1993676871,
0.4858566821,
-0.210843116,
0.2476329356,
0.3289053738,
-0.5762037039,
-0.7358391285,
0.0798626766,
-1.183364749,
0.1402199268,
1.1614255905,
-0.2398537397,
0.2513420582,
-0.1587338001,
0.1033041105,
0.836314559,
-0.534598887,
0.3106575608,
0.0962975696,
-0.2293877006,
0.0078897737,
-0.5081712604,
0.2811850309,
0.4072825313,
-0.7085289955,
-0.1277164221,
0.5469123721,
0.2351493388,
-0.2697645426,
0.6521747112,
0.0438870005,
0.3386517167,
0.0251332838,
0.2548017502,
-0.2053702623,
-0.5823740363,
-0.5796874762,
-0.0001797634,
0.0117585463,
-0.3282187581
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17722v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17722v1
|
SenTest: Evaluating Robustness of Sentence Encoders
| 2023-11-29T15:21:35 | 2023-11-29T15:21:35 |
Tanmay Chavan, Shantanu Patankar, Aditya Kane, Omkar Gokhale, Geetanjali Kale, Raviraj Joshi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Contrastive learning has proven to be an effective method for pre-training
models using weakly labeled data in the vision domain. Sentence transformers
are the NLP counterparts to this architecture, and have been growing in
popularity due to their rich and effective sentence representations. Having
effective sentence representations is paramount in multiple tasks, such as
information retrieval, retrieval augmented generation (RAG), and sentence
comparison. Keeping in mind the deployability factor of transformers,
evaluating the robustness of sentence transformers is of utmost importance.
This work focuses on evaluating the robustness of the sentence encoders. We
employ several adversarial attacks to evaluate its robustness. This system uses
character-level attacks in the form of random character substitution,
word-level attacks in the form of synonym replacement, and sentence-level
attacks in the form of intra-sentence word order shuffling. The results of the
experiments strongly undermine the robustness of sentence encoders. The models
produce significantly different predictions as well as embeddings on perturbed
datasets. The accuracy of the models can fall up to 15 percent on perturbed
datasets as compared to unperturbed datasets. Furthermore, the experiments
demonstrate that these embeddings does capture the semantic and syntactic
structure (sentence order) of sentences. However, existing supervised
classification strategies fail to leverage this information, and merely
function as n-gram detectors.
|
[
-0.2900789082,
-0.7659488916,
0.2531013489,
0.0097275274,
-0.1280957609,
-0.132883653,
-0.2180674076,
-0.2331058234,
-0.0669204146,
0.3927096426,
-0.3472595215,
-0.325887084,
-0.8974927664,
0.4159255922,
-0.7529175878,
0.994399786,
0.2495530248,
0.1478455067,
-0.2984704077,
-0.2674856484,
-0.3894499838,
-0.5641588569,
-0.2551672757,
-0.0605229996,
0.067444697,
-0.0791932791,
1.1588915586,
0.2275273204,
1.0023827553,
0.4250321686,
-0.2705236971,
-0.0640723482,
-0.5260876417,
0.4222618639,
0.1036206409,
-0.566888392,
-0.1102509946,
-0.1444949806,
0.317920655,
0.6023758054,
-0.0523608029,
-0.2016036212,
0.2768330574,
0.4333332181,
-0.6879553795,
-0.0299315378,
-0.9847711921,
0.3200649023,
-0.1614082605,
-0.0303665642,
-0.6146823764,
-0.3002255261,
0.1362540275,
-0.3144729435,
0.1560709327,
0.0296818446,
1.1259679794,
0.6478434801,
-0.0965103209,
-0.5118191838,
-0.3877323568,
0.6996340752,
-0.6675084829,
0.4953587651,
0.2975871265,
0.2417024076,
-0.2583723664,
-0.9668844342,
-0.453193754,
-0.4126076698,
-0.2734011412,
0.5108953714,
-0.6794959903,
0.1367441565,
0.3290228248,
0.5133374929,
-0.7151834965,
0.2440314442,
0.0862168148,
-0.1661902219,
0.1387358457,
0.1574008763,
0.3491226137,
-0.4506116807,
-0.5072463155,
-0.4771896899,
-0.2471536696,
-0.0244936906,
0.7304478884,
0.2145437747,
-0.1380676329,
0.8070322275,
-0.0644931123,
0.6441009045,
0.3229357302,
0.1947287172,
0.3577407897,
-0.4346158803,
-0.2567481399,
-0.4133660197,
0.9555665255,
0.4544698298,
0.2870903015,
-0.4067821503,
-0.4204545319,
0.558365047,
0.7922298312,
-0.8158735037,
-0.1900585741,
0.1713733524,
-0.5664041638,
-0.6581558585,
0.2901640534,
-1.0375887156,
-0.1871764511,
0.2721348405,
0.4196566641,
-0.7280759215,
0.3998161852,
0.1706026196,
-0.1477875113,
0.3309712708,
-0.1008916721,
-0.726649344,
0.2513557673,
0.5236718655,
0.5811520219,
-0.2644663453,
-0.2667378187,
-0.4411598444,
-0.3903051317,
-0.1591922045,
0.5959982276,
-0.5793049335,
-0.3926532269,
0.2457319647,
-0.1377126575,
-0.3185522556,
-0.6644136906,
0.8807743788,
-0.5201660991,
0.4545906186,
0.2911212444,
-0.6845762134,
0.0869428366,
0.6378232241,
-0.6539688706,
0.7813882232,
0.1813002825,
-1.24391675,
0.2939785123,
-0.2896586359,
-0.4761384428,
-0.1912661791,
-0.1111669987,
-0.7521408796,
0.0593361259,
0.5628656149,
0.6001842022,
0.1132993847,
0.1414902061,
-0.3751547039,
-0.5066165328,
0.5698757768,
-0.7170891166,
0.8555612564,
0.2578771412,
-0.1511904001,
0.1217641234,
-0.632363677,
-0.1406303197,
0.1513291299,
-0.1942572296,
-0.1341194659,
-0.0134382099,
0.0931195319,
-0.112436235,
0.1028674841,
-0.4235359728,
0.0387607999,
-0.7460222244,
0.3524568975,
0.5335302353,
0.0842082649,
0.4799056649,
-0.1936956793,
0.6883898973,
0.1565170288,
0.4509800971,
-0.1709254682,
-0.2939187586,
-0.6949198246,
-0.0727759078,
0.2186633795,
0.6994916797,
-1.2216004133,
0.6728498936,
-0.3554731607,
-0.3775632679,
-0.4364140034,
-0.1790598631,
0.3233956397,
0.4131954908,
0.5573126078,
-0.1156923026,
-0.4843287468,
-0.8636184931,
-0.519536674,
-0.2105585933,
-0.235370934,
-0.1256594956,
0.6061795354,
-0.6725168228,
0.5950484872,
-0.4667526484,
-0.0038748027,
-0.4151831269,
-0.0276500024,
0.1097506881,
0.4764605761,
0.586558044,
-0.7396379709,
-0.1922647953,
-0.3528776169,
-0.8153725266,
0.0409922488,
-0.2028039694,
0.032688655,
-0.0714854449,
0.5316961408,
-0.7795174718,
0.508041203,
0.5000998974,
-0.269906193,
0.3345008194,
-0.1294187754,
0.1699913442,
-1.095413208,
-0.1760119498,
-0.0534077547,
-0.1549328268,
-0.5200619698,
0.4863291383,
-0.042341277,
-0.3015435636,
-0.284788698,
-0.2616745532,
-0.2135387063,
0.1418305039,
0.0003030645,
0.073938705,
-0.1223580688,
0.4052026272,
-0.4213460386,
0.7126493454,
0.4741224349,
-0.3136123121,
0.3662971556,
0.5024272203,
-0.4446719885,
0.6675358415,
-0.7415123582,
0.2077881694,
-0.1068332717,
0.0290233344,
-0.770709157,
-0.115824379,
0.3232247233,
-0.6098549366,
0.3606308103,
0.2673479915,
-0.6249834895,
-0.3624452651,
-0.5049305558,
-0.0220779497,
0.5379215479,
-0.5573113561,
0.548895061,
0.1635363996,
0.1572110057,
-0.6640705466,
-0.91778934,
0.1364160329,
-0.4621875286,
-0.5688441396,
0.2410897464,
-0.0237575453,
-0.267508328,
0.0031442796,
-0.0731896684,
-0.0031192005,
0.2449649572,
0.1769568324,
0.2318407595,
-0.1125538871,
-0.1930593848,
-0.1744386256,
-0.0984360054,
0.1380981654,
0.1161871403,
0.4761835337,
-0.1764138192,
-0.2962521017,
-0.2993782163,
0.1186469346,
0.5073865056,
-0.1245318055,
0.7588558793,
0.6720578671,
-0.3457624018,
-0.282977581,
-0.2953292727,
-0.2807013392,
-0.4903937578,
0.6042324305,
-0.3150433898,
-0.7757391334,
0.4131104052,
0.1603863835,
-0.1086083129,
0.3201993108,
0.1353653222,
-0.1564733684,
0.8241662979,
0.3587746024,
-0.0409840494,
0.3572269678,
-0.1032673344,
0.2801136971,
-0.5145941973,
-0.0831359997,
-0.6216392517,
-0.0822097734,
-0.8251408935,
-0.1855233461,
0.1596681029,
-0.0713473335,
-0.0313827842,
0.749968946,
-0.4047956765,
0.2502995133,
0.3247025907,
0.2941540182,
-0.100506708,
-0.0289461724,
-0.007943783,
-0.2302139699,
-0.6370436549,
-0.5216833353,
0.9647958875,
0.3215203583,
0.9318911433,
-0.0790477693,
0.4612213969,
0.2850129604,
-0.1696791798,
-0.7787088156,
0.674777329,
-0.5895078778,
0.019340124,
0.0512856245,
-0.4695757329,
-1.0392184258,
0.3012139797,
-0.4762867093,
-0.5048034787,
0.0904610604,
-0.1806416363,
-0.1269291639,
0.2356110066,
-0.6656019688,
0.9769803882,
0.0227578022,
-0.0867838711,
0.0105342083,
-0.8219037056,
0.0962705761,
-0.0032799116,
-0.2082726657,
0.50427562,
0.1056625396,
0.6524735093,
-0.4028932154,
0.6639568806,
0.1700109243,
0.1964498758,
0.0240442641,
0.0853055194,
0.4473265707,
-0.1578567922,
-0.1220603213,
0.0570509508,
-0.2978061438,
-0.26129058,
-0.7737264633,
0.5933379531,
-0.6143313646,
-0.4832061827,
-0.3297865093,
-0.4410606027,
-0.3084075749,
-0.0517807119,
0.6684530973,
0.5909035206,
-0.3699228168,
0.5538651943,
0.44542256,
-0.3063506186,
0.5372402668,
-0.0902116075,
0.1982171088,
-0.6171230078,
0.5697925687,
-0.0968881324,
0.2890796661,
0.4685977101,
0.0046458901,
-0.2080521137,
-0.7671934366,
-0.1824709922,
-0.2142398655,
-0.8575299382,
-0.3253926337,
-0.6282794476,
-0.2275270373,
-0.3363494873,
-0.318433851,
-0.3111013174,
-0.1419419497,
-0.3526864648,
-0.2835288942,
-0.0852421299,
0.5886000395,
0.5162476897,
0.4601330459,
-0.5542693734,
0.3126403689,
0.01998711,
0.0748705044,
-0.3516077697,
-0.658975184,
-0.0683760047,
-0.2309776843,
-0.4039553106,
-1.1079125404,
0.3689342141,
0.0430389158,
0.5339758396,
0.5719420314,
0.2019564509,
0.4523649514,
-0.3580329418,
0.8608906865,
0.026611777,
-0.8835065961,
0.5865410566,
-0.0473169386,
0.5007551908,
0.7588383555,
0.2977556288,
0.0505315438,
-0.7887511849,
-0.8023486733,
-0.8160275817,
0.384257108,
0.6635347009,
0.3263219893,
-0.1878497899,
0.1345223933,
0.1670802981,
0.1643321514,
-0.7917331457,
-0.2421707958,
-0.5141434669,
-0.5755693316,
0.0643497035,
-0.2456404269,
0.338719517,
0.1877890974,
0.4332813323,
0.1399740577,
0.1885772049,
0.1528909057,
-0.3029381633,
0.4439580739,
0.4938940704,
0.1173463836,
0.0733950436,
-0.1306392699,
0.400003463,
0.1957306713,
-0.6402198076,
-0.1541883349,
0.2736726999,
-0.423715204,
0.1140912622,
0.7347875237,
0.8296048641,
0.3607011139,
-0.6351706982,
0.726247251,
-0.1796475053,
0.1049747914,
-0.133285135,
-0.0914533734,
-0.3657465279,
0.1663890332,
-0.1897124052,
0.5824459791,
0.3145402968,
-0.4484193325,
0.4046905637,
0.4470913708,
-0.6433790922,
-0.2540886402,
0.5662514567,
0.0286664609,
-0.2248754501,
0.9011105299,
0.0368224792,
-0.8194947839,
0.4932199717,
0.5166398287,
0.9261832237,
-0.1864957958,
0.0671493486,
0.307836473,
0.6589917541,
-0.0362876989,
-0.1200436428,
0.0913686827,
-0.8813035488,
0.0784589201,
-0.4230947793,
-0.2714858949,
0.0617582016,
-0.881393075,
0.116613552,
-0.2527526915,
-0.3756991029,
-0.1821760386,
-0.4139405787,
-0.5971067548,
0.1661553681,
-0.2019021213,
0.5770227909,
-0.8080996275,
0.3899196386,
0.5362428427,
-0.4974797368,
-0.4459684789,
0.5009933114,
-0.3772160113,
-0.5940357447,
0.478815347,
0.3466924429,
-0.0936302766,
-0.2838672101,
-0.4914263189,
-0.3394329548,
0.7589806914,
0.45230636,
-0.247470811,
0.0604506396,
0.1020219699,
0.7467117906,
-0.0637671873,
0.3603921533,
0.2052707672,
0.2338747978,
-0.0826572403,
-0.5913289785,
0.0628762394,
-0.2874063849,
0.0993954018,
0.0196004789,
-0.2021557242,
0.7054190636,
0.0106135719,
-0.3989450336,
0.1576285362,
0.858961463,
-0.1459403932,
0.0065672509,
0.5896434188,
0.8152337074,
0.511639595,
-0.2214016616,
1.2554922104,
-0.1064512432,
0.310462147,
0.9423649311,
-0.203682512,
1.0766164064,
0.5833892226,
-0.1675481349,
0.4594257474,
0.2716814578,
-0.4856032133,
0.6749660969,
0.2009638399,
0.1153035536,
-0.0082911048,
0.1072491184,
-0.1681740433,
0.5869908929,
0.093412213,
-0.3003475964,
-0.0530868508,
0.3199122846,
0.0622682795,
0.4871709049,
-0.0960069001,
0.6618801355,
-0.0140757933,
-0.5630505681,
0.3130363822,
-0.0768198222,
1.0364060402,
-0.545676887,
0.1654004157,
-0.2010536641,
0.4954974651,
-0.1727544218,
-0.7443436384,
0.523095727,
0.2486338466,
0.1925078928,
-0.1994504184,
0.8517459035,
-0.2323379517,
-0.402074635,
0.3940033615,
0.3573209345,
-0.120220542,
0.07249403,
-0.5956166983,
0.0898467526,
-0.0224408396,
-0.2472757697,
0.2315773517,
0.156219691,
0.4140732884,
0.6719113588,
0.3105479479,
-0.0811634287,
-0.0034753561,
0.2487014681,
0.7845811248,
-0.4068751037,
-0.5591557026,
-0.9310606122,
0.338003844,
-0.1427138299,
-0.3159412444,
1.1148591042,
0.4759735167,
0.9512853026,
-0.3261403441,
0.3487047255,
0.1882789135,
0.0876827911,
-0.6875701547,
0.6907041669,
-0.2005853802,
0.3335471153,
-0.3653160632,
-0.8620040417,
-0.3933598101,
0.64823699,
-0.1158131287,
0.0652102306,
0.9316846132,
0.8047020435,
-0.1003648415,
0.2470128238,
0.3337024152,
0.2685605586,
0.1296624839,
0.4268958569,
1.0076930523,
-0.7549093962,
0.7939286828,
-0.3146800995,
0.1178232059,
0.1104349494,
-0.5819307566,
-1.1291115284,
-0.3414070904,
-0.4150339365,
-0.4479439855,
0.2815293968,
0.4918893576,
0.3604640365,
-0.7669998407,
0.0850554779,
-0.3808438182,
-0.1849100441,
-0.1911189556,
-0.2855281532,
0.3573785722,
-0.4484452307,
-0.6867379546,
0.555962801,
0.0439907908,
0.1631811112,
-0.1136264503,
0.2054015696,
-0.0086211339,
0.0485953204,
0.3686258495,
-0.4051732421,
-0.6484305859,
-0.352938354,
0.1193116829,
-0.3681592941,
-0.0054482645,
0.5372415185,
-0.6956455708,
0.3502138555,
0.6458063126,
0.883761704,
0.1201348603,
0.0704753473,
0.4760293663,
-0.6375962496,
0.2133471072,
0.3997815549,
0.6471766829,
0.5995460153,
-0.2972046733,
0.4858784378,
0.0938040316,
-0.472329706,
-0.7502404451,
0.2073733956,
-1.1090768576,
-0.3475694358,
0.9588004351,
-0.4053621888,
-0.088564083,
0.0342387445,
-0.0407928117,
0.2369190305,
-0.1043017656,
0.6463710666,
0.6988946795,
0.1230813116,
-0.0210474692,
-0.3480375111,
0.3093659878,
0.5551678538,
-0.8247703314,
-0.2915645242,
0.3394681513,
-0.0611442663,
0.2732138038,
-0.0118679684,
-0.2364936322,
-0.1589506865,
0.4452258348,
-0.2338112742,
0.0406075791,
0.0041603227,
-0.6233263612,
0.6465790868,
-0.2168693095,
-0.4620088637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17696v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17696v3
|
How to Build an AI Tutor that Can Adapt to Any Course and Provide Accurate Answers Using Large Language Model and Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2023-11-29T15:02:46 | 2024-06-21T09:29:07 |
Chenxi Dong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper proposes a low-code solution to build an AI tutor that leverages
advanced AI techniques to provide accurate and contextually relevant responses
in a personalized learning environment. The OpenAI Assistants API allows AI
Tutor to easily embed, store, retrieve, and manage files and chat history,
enabling a low-code solution. Large Language Models (LLMs) and
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) technology generate sophisticated answers
based on course-specific materials. The application efficiently organizes and
retrieves relevant information through vector embedding and similarity-based
retrieval algorithms. The AI Tutor prototype demonstrates its ability to
generate relevant, accurate answers with source citations. It represents a
significant advancement in technology-enhanced tutoring systems, democratizing
access to high-quality, customized educational support in higher education.
|
[
-0.351465255,
-1.0319482088,
0.3702522814,
-0.0864193365,
0.2983919084,
0.1680315584,
-0.3234945238,
-0.2853654623,
0.2548243701,
0.2108494937,
-0.2350323796,
-0.3211025894,
-0.2044389099,
0.0722359121,
-0.225238651,
0.7368196845,
0.0345950574,
0.2268153429,
-0.2800621092,
-0.1033638939,
-0.7640913725,
-0.3799278736,
-0.9247172475,
0.0629484355,
0.3378605843,
0.8136953115,
0.4687384665,
0.6716425419,
0.3623737991,
0.3401604295,
0.0383250453,
0.1631386578,
-0.146247372,
0.1759029031,
-0.2444726676,
-0.7096565962,
-0.5427993536,
-0.1289483905,
0.3202370405,
0.3716682196,
0.0528722107,
0.3721219003,
0.0392283164,
0.3733494878,
-0.6917543411,
-0.0143421255,
-0.4947783053,
-0.0198554955,
-0.2594897151,
-0.3085047603,
-0.48077479,
-0.3074953556,
0.3341687024,
-0.8211697936,
0.283326298,
0.048351448,
0.5956016183,
0.621330142,
-0.2500758767,
-0.5021092296,
-0.8037376404,
0.7966201305,
-0.6946356893,
0.1356585324,
0.4793101251,
0.8974072337,
-0.1217891574,
-0.6989676952,
-0.461035639,
-0.239426747,
-0.0522968955,
0.1405346096,
0.4103884995,
-0.060541071,
0.1212281808,
0.3983576596,
-0.4716852009,
0.2474700063,
-0.3156126738,
-0.0330927894,
0.3618575931,
0.1864534914,
0.4311792254,
-0.0483869091,
-0.1069438607,
-0.1105170101,
-0.5843381882,
0.1456702948,
0.5799642801,
0.655059278,
-0.224922359,
0.7204609513,
-0.089135401,
0.6940324903,
-0.0719081089,
-0.3705860972,
-0.0896302015,
-0.1536986679,
-0.0791827664,
0.1812000126,
0.4651443958,
-0.1788609624,
0.4656346142,
0.1013615578,
0.0865877718,
-0.4474809766,
0.263386786,
-0.6564285159,
-0.1084029526,
0.2653342187,
-0.3649787605,
-0.3736126125,
0.0969620049,
-0.9005822539,
-0.5290278196,
-0.4792076647,
0.2003107369,
-0.3172907531,
0.0409875549,
-0.2003505379,
0.0124554355,
0.317843765,
0.412540406,
-0.7322989702,
0.2231826633,
0.506432116,
0.8840936422,
-0.2953133583,
-0.2244020402,
-0.7976205349,
0.2412189543,
-0.0185152348,
0.6064035296,
-0.5523391962,
-0.326096952,
0.4050547779,
-0.2023131102,
0.3663984239,
-0.4379042685,
0.3044574559,
-0.5237936378,
0.4879586697,
0.2928337157,
-0.5780656934,
-0.008684827,
0.31962502,
-0.5608592629,
0.7259642482,
0.1692488194,
-0.5294523835,
-0.299590975,
-1.0966112614,
-0.2259891778,
0.3213543594,
-0.2603139579,
-0.1559114158,
-0.244914636,
0.3162507415,
0.3178783357,
-0.2154573649,
0.2099794894,
-0.081910111,
-0.4909801483,
0.1147682816,
-0.4341904223,
0.7768955827,
0.1105036959,
-0.2603906393,
0.3695009947,
-0.7518875003,
-0.2068278939,
0.2500772476,
-0.4983231127,
-0.3420743942,
-0.2062932253,
0.0444347709,
-0.3798654974,
0.6447984576,
-0.4876077175,
0.4144513011,
-0.2860319018,
0.2032655627,
1.0956443548,
-0.1386653036,
0.4980968237,
-0.1275039315,
0.6160972118,
-0.1707949191,
-0.1530067027,
-0.5507487655,
-0.5320797563,
-0.6504341364,
-0.3173745871,
0.2746804655,
0.6726616025,
-0.6657193899,
0.2735031545,
-0.1527971029,
-0.2497889996,
-0.7894097567,
0.3043375313,
0.379201293,
0.7573631406,
0.3856855333,
0.1698215008,
-0.6324924827,
-0.5883550048,
-0.1963373274,
0.0348125473,
-0.2531640828,
0.665256083,
0.3295605779,
-0.2621797323,
1.1059328318,
-0.7983845472,
-0.5533010364,
0.1400660425,
-0.1843195558,
0.0605089739,
0.5136525631,
0.73958987,
-0.7162853479,
-0.6624085307,
0.1276318133,
-0.7810655832,
0.0729632378,
0.0581659935,
-0.2956945002,
0.2550574541,
0.5003825426,
-0.427688092,
0.5170129538,
0.173991397,
-0.3883522153,
0.5964392424,
-0.2570753396,
0.0419531763,
-1.4279261827,
0.3951815963,
-0.1247441694,
-0.2067926377,
-0.3110295534,
0.2529071271,
-0.3887865245,
-0.5017052889,
-0.3724044263,
1.1123093367,
-0.0211418662,
-0.2650963962,
-0.3335376084,
0.4314408302,
-0.3845016956,
0.5893301368,
-0.2066076398,
1.2965875864,
0.3800261915,
-0.3695814312,
0.5324909687,
0.5650811195,
-0.1556703746,
0.6967343688,
-0.8565838933,
0.2749735117,
0.0665188432,
0.0098634744,
-0.7960906029,
-0.5194536448,
0.1667509824,
-0.6387427449,
0.2248918712,
-0.1179433241,
-0.3642099798,
-0.1299938858,
-0.206474036,
0.2287654132,
0.4910180569,
-0.9469210505,
0.7848195434,
0.0940745398,
-0.4199155271,
-0.8301931024,
-0.1098639816,
-0.0783088133,
-0.0271430276,
-0.3401029706,
0.1689395905,
-0.5077607632,
-0.3808584809,
0.0619028769,
0.1716759503,
-0.2784179747,
0.3431254923,
0.2929743528,
0.33171767,
-0.4934646189,
0.0648572743,
0.103671819,
0.011826572,
-0.1954540312,
-0.1216954514,
0.6350374222,
-0.2059515864,
-0.3878221214,
-0.5389145017,
0.2710439861,
0.6181340218,
-0.275647372,
0.5958699584,
0.5954143405,
-0.3480123281,
-0.0458473116,
-0.2574958205,
-0.1214281544,
-0.532027483,
0.3587115407,
-0.455144763,
-0.9052191377,
0.5678344965,
0.0882027,
0.4044448435,
0.0901980847,
0.5613833666,
-0.0441352241,
1.1004115343,
0.5960618854,
-0.3156903684,
0.755219996,
-0.2722408772,
0.0309499837,
-0.74106282,
-0.2095648646,
-0.8363297582,
-0.2666400373,
-0.3659300804,
0.0585298091,
0.093003951,
-0.0021812464,
-0.9496365786,
-0.0253307763,
-0.7195147276,
0.5777805448,
1.0975818634,
0.0922365263,
0.0990234613,
0.003529144,
0.2352926135,
0.2752647102,
-0.2920757532,
-0.6965744495,
1.174185276,
0.353649497,
0.6916204691,
0.4057160318,
0.4609245956,
0.4131026864,
0.2240531743,
-0.7663677335,
0.4645999074,
-0.0936738476,
-0.5900943279,
-0.4515856802,
-0.1295116395,
-0.7273086905,
-0.2467520833,
-0.0914594382,
-0.6936980486,
-0.2356856316,
0.1095952615,
-0.4197225273,
0.270993948,
-0.6978493929,
0.7923446298,
-0.3236404955,
-0.2947757542,
0.0658351108,
-0.4628238082,
0.2010782212,
0.0103567895,
-0.1463489383,
0.3418768942,
-0.1195071265,
0.7427985668,
-0.3572975099,
0.8638681769,
-0.3981390893,
0.0255977269,
0.3301089406,
0.1764734834,
0.0659389421,
0.1404270679,
-0.2507236302,
-0.2868137658,
-0.0863162279,
-0.7251855731,
-0.7141210437,
0.9487985969,
-1.2610536814,
-0.8266820312,
0.0244845878,
-0.6107419133,
-0.0795499161,
0.2875051498,
-0.0733909458,
0.4485817552,
-0.0339059532,
0.07167954,
0.5048921108,
-0.4254176915,
0.4176112115,
0.4484797418,
-0.0826153532,
-0.4780600071,
1.0213048458,
-0.2441511005,
-0.2131368965,
0.2759218812,
0.4058992565,
-0.0822180882,
-0.2379986942,
-0.8010704517,
0.1416435391,
-0.818356812,
-0.3278406858,
-0.1929385066,
-0.139564231,
-0.7067397833,
-0.5114893317,
-0.1493135095,
-0.2338782698,
-0.5526542068,
-0.0042327228,
0.583969593,
0.6487282515,
0.2555521429,
0.6281377673,
-0.7966525555,
0.2373193651,
0.481795311,
0.369051218,
0.1507711858,
-0.5305002332,
-0.294067353,
0.1566912234,
-0.3271362782,
-0.6731883883,
0.1717673242,
0.4559043944,
0.5278335214,
0.435261488,
0.1309170872,
0.5808891058,
-0.5042412281,
1.1370670795,
-0.2200444788,
-0.762948513,
0.8591235876,
-0.283074826,
0.2547219396,
0.4178610742,
0.4265464544,
0.0017688004,
-0.1975439936,
-0.2450774908,
-0.637370944,
0.6878805757,
-0.3075205982,
0.3136787415,
0.2725600004,
0.8564934731,
0.171974197,
-0.0888878927,
-0.4759679139,
-0.4492001832,
-0.3501909375,
-0.6681009531,
-0.0006770878,
-0.0127308024,
-0.1106186509,
-0.0322797969,
0.9028379917,
-0.5903912783,
0.3425575197,
-0.0757718161,
0.170898363,
-0.0073707504,
0.0450641438,
0.8410633206,
0.525452137,
-0.3244093955,
-0.1988423318,
0.1743074954,
-0.6753666997,
0.1243808046,
0.0927216932,
-0.0869627222,
-0.0096644927,
0.3956587613,
0.5773077011,
-0.2204515338,
-0.9633093476,
0.603238225,
-0.3450962901,
0.1430256963,
-0.7817443609,
0.3044942319,
-0.1046471149,
0.2734898031,
0.492410779,
-0.0856740922,
-0.1289775223,
-0.4096996486,
0.0374826416,
0.3257145584,
-0.315461725,
-0.1825777441,
0.6868410707,
0.4368145168,
-1.0096745491,
0.7538951039,
0.3064619899,
-0.3154812157,
0.6877162457,
0.7258355021,
0.8872070909,
-0.2849761844,
0.1190349683,
0.3093934059,
-0.4244588912,
0.2632185817,
0.2283417583,
-0.1811606288,
-0.2973605692,
-0.5189709663,
-0.4613506496,
-0.6943018436,
0.0533251278,
-0.6607829928,
0.435921818,
-0.5948879123,
0.2592781186,
0.0100042224,
0.0018686652,
-0.6313111782,
0.0825095326,
-0.0993537307,
1.0169067383,
-0.4899513423,
0.7842828035,
1.214846015,
-0.7044619322,
-0.7008135915,
0.010873599,
-0.1581093073,
-0.6698290706,
0.8810001612,
-0.0490697846,
0.0213054456,
0.113780275,
-0.930161953,
-0.6686874628,
1.1285549402,
0.3940865695,
-0.1695480496,
-0.3061267436,
0.1259464473,
0.6830162406,
-0.4159960747,
0.5689232349,
0.1609735191,
0.1011533663,
0.0346009843,
-0.7839831114,
-0.3136089146,
-0.1696330011,
-0.083599411,
-0.2469000667,
-0.4999391437,
0.6996279359,
-0.0904866159,
0.2285238355,
0.5741891265,
0.8003761172,
0.1610841155,
0.3522055149,
0.080133751,
0.3196446896,
0.7593486309,
0.1467914432,
1.0025025606,
-0.6182799339,
0.0184301995,
1.3787093163,
0.0568626001,
1.0017639399,
0.3937978745,
0.0789147839,
0.6819862723,
0.4724338353,
0.1904841661,
0.3550751507,
0.0541796349,
-0.3802827597,
0.0553107038,
-0.2433766574,
-0.2350285947,
0.4412072301,
0.2075792402,
-0.1260746568,
0.1847978383,
0.4373453557,
-0.1539588571,
0.3320531845,
-0.3454838991,
0.9154798388,
-0.0964182913,
-0.6891052127,
0.3353268504,
0.0722942278,
0.5748894811,
-0.3595652878,
-0.3204537332,
-0.3761081994,
0.3552132249,
-0.2117913514,
-0.7269914746,
0.0907684341,
0.2508403361,
-0.1826762259,
0.0368585475,
0.5595255494,
-0.3117111325,
-0.0803818181,
-0.0822185352,
0.5046266317,
0.1770285964,
0.4956056476,
-0.505177319,
-0.2264229804,
-0.0836581066,
-0.0734366551,
0.3490320146,
0.2344398648,
0.0177641027,
0.7227101922,
0.6565763354,
-0.0322513804,
-0.0193249099,
-0.1049766764,
0.5706992745,
-0.3892454505,
-0.3359293044,
-0.5378963351,
0.5236059427,
-0.0620574281,
-0.5239583254,
0.749514699,
0.4153723121,
1.0481179953,
-0.2546165586,
0.7455439568,
-0.0207477063,
0.8028885126,
-0.1897607148,
0.5421625376,
-0.540798068,
0.2917645872,
-0.2025981396,
-0.9571045041,
-0.2785257697,
0.8264150023,
-0.1233434081,
-0.0668652579,
0.1178686917,
0.5887178779,
-0.0481621213,
-0.1047276482,
0.0581781752,
-0.0017297171,
0.742654562,
0.1700992733,
0.6277523637,
-0.4241102934,
0.5326724052,
-0.1784641296,
-0.1919138283,
-0.4132433534,
-0.4284522831,
-1.0986735821,
-0.4906642735,
-0.3452534974,
-0.3555565476,
0.1770496666,
1.0668122768,
0.5747668743,
-0.9793165326,
-0.3027017117,
-0.0533485673,
0.1947378963,
0.0681837946,
-0.3519284129,
0.7053413987,
-0.4893044531,
-1.1195209026,
0.3767522871,
-0.2321913838,
0.2280656695,
-0.6082671881,
-0.368503958,
-0.1096318811,
0.0371470191,
0.3985494375,
0.5370228291,
-0.6405812502,
-0.4872824252,
0.3080590665,
-0.233318761,
-0.0023208,
0.5748403072,
-0.8375077248,
0.5477648973,
0.505171597,
1.1795927286,
0.0796190873,
0.1908770353,
0.5734187961,
-0.8670946956,
0.2269885987,
0.2015354484,
0.2560462952,
0.2470106035,
-0.586265862,
0.5890963078,
-0.038005162,
-0.661722362,
-0.8785361648,
0.0566882566,
-0.7446396947,
-0.3301431835,
0.7842234969,
-0.5727638006,
-0.2181608081,
0.0228428356,
-0.7555711865,
0.2635757327,
-0.3302544355,
0.7658555508,
0.3124931157,
-0.2167982757,
-0.1758791059,
-0.5925400853,
0.3546093106,
0.3358184099,
-0.8953118324,
-0.2995348871,
0.3408812582,
0.106494762,
0.5191523433,
0.2672278881,
0.2437102199,
0.3359708786,
-0.1734057814,
0.002432117,
-0.3962702453,
-0.4260512888,
-0.2158177197,
0.2100905478,
0.260851115,
-0.3860523105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17686v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17686v1
|
AviationGPT: A Large Language Model for the Aviation Domain
| 2023-11-29T14:49:31 | 2023-11-29T14:49:31 |
Liya Wang, Jason Chou, Xin Zhou, Alex Tien, Diane M Baumgartner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The advent of ChatGPT and GPT-4 has captivated the world with large language
models (LLMs), demonstrating exceptional performance in question-answering,
summarization, and content generation. The aviation industry is characterized
by an abundance of complex, unstructured text data, replete with technical
jargon and specialized terminology. Moreover, labeled data for model building
are scarce in this domain, resulting in low usage of aviation text data. The
emergence of LLMs presents an opportunity to transform this situation, but
there is a lack of LLMs specifically designed for the aviation domain. To
address this gap, we propose AviationGPT, which is built on open-source LLaMA-2
and Mistral architectures and continuously trained on a wealth of carefully
curated aviation datasets. Experimental results reveal that AviationGPT offers
users multiple advantages, including the versatility to tackle diverse natural
language processing (NLP) problems (e.g., question-answering, summarization,
document writing, information extraction, report querying, data cleaning, and
interactive data exploration). It also provides accurate and contextually
relevant responses within the aviation domain and significantly improves
performance (e.g., over a 40% performance gain in tested cases). With
AviationGPT, the aviation industry is better equipped to address more complex
research problems and enhance the efficiency and safety of National Airspace
System (NAS) operations.
|
[
-0.4802817702,
-0.8423047066,
0.5881177783,
0.2943211794,
-0.2671031654,
0.1102177203,
-0.1754679382,
-0.4686770737,
0.1348365098,
0.4745740891,
-0.4198969603,
-0.252643019,
-0.4248398542,
-0.1926475018,
-0.5853025317,
1.0162205696,
-0.2349848747,
-0.2554485202,
-0.1812591106,
0.1929512918,
-0.2311863452,
-1.2522212267,
-0.9491109252,
-0.1131374761,
0.5367535353,
0.3180390298,
0.6128115654,
0.3954997063,
0.855324924,
0.1691747904,
-0.1777931452,
0.0771238655,
-0.1103384942,
-0.0677082539,
0.1412373781,
0.0040587783,
-0.740470171,
-0.4393909276,
0.6171247363,
0.6157051325,
-0.621999383,
0.0150954276,
-0.1329405904,
0.6654700637,
-0.1699459404,
0.3028154373,
-0.5145964622,
-0.1856458038,
-0.2195350081,
-0.2810692489,
0.1159052253,
-0.0241014827,
0.2197121233,
-0.6160439849,
0.0306681283,
0.2906784713,
0.7072845697,
0.2382684648,
-0.7264108062,
-0.4787932932,
-0.6036514044,
0.4224965274,
-0.9411149025,
0.5600758791,
0.1761398017,
0.5421067476,
-0.1309845299,
-1.0241951942,
-0.5096314549,
-0.2662118077,
0.3341042697,
0.1813500524,
-0.0441522971,
0.0654403791,
-0.1444123387,
0.3053511083,
-1.0441565514,
0.1137038767,
-0.4322111607,
0.0690236315,
0.367131561,
0.145198524,
0.4997495413,
0.1221881509,
-0.1834637672,
0.1717762798,
-0.9475632906,
-0.3787225783,
0.0320522152,
0.4227052927,
-0.018621007,
0.6146245599,
-0.3467584848,
0.6984388232,
-0.4650112391,
0.0946302861,
0.1712778807,
0.0406773277,
-0.4509160221,
0.1288085133,
0.5255433917,
0.219128117,
0.2414659113,
-0.3081433475,
-0.2614955306,
-0.1626013368,
0.3547455966,
-0.8812862039,
-0.1102368683,
0.1804171801,
-0.2038653791,
-0.3223925531,
-0.019545028,
-0.6771241426,
-0.1020398587,
-0.4612354636,
0.1550952345,
-0.0814127252,
-0.5382798314,
0.5042802691,
-0.0342090689,
0.3845843971,
0.3930160105,
-1.0133206844,
0.2041340768,
0.9867691994,
1.1425507069,
-0.2042362988,
-0.2192658782,
-0.3766359687,
0.3214408755,
-0.4033868313,
0.9773749709,
-0.546036303,
-0.4425373375,
0.027777601,
-0.230147168,
0.0544346049,
-0.4563776553,
0.7361750007,
-0.859326601,
0.0370858125,
-0.2245665491,
-0.5719593167,
-0.3467378616,
0.3566259146,
-0.4915244579,
0.8618710041,
0.1082730591,
-0.4775525331,
0.1489566267,
-0.8609845042,
-0.4057585895,
0.0781729743,
-0.3518795669,
-0.5355584025,
-0.0315415263,
0.4444364905,
0.2707438767,
-0.3289093375,
0.4051881433,
-0.1978103071,
-0.188686043,
-0.1647436321,
-0.3835813999,
0.4927594066,
0.2803519666,
-0.0940880999,
-0.0488570891,
-0.4206149578,
0.029655762,
0.0785933211,
-0.6044062376,
-0.1530977786,
0.060929317,
0.490028739,
0.2497663945,
0.169730112,
-0.296971947,
0.4802018106,
-0.5097879767,
0.6956293583,
0.6927590966,
0.290268153,
0.1461092681,
-0.4291837513,
0.7763343453,
-0.0326451249,
0.1249373853,
-0.0954395682,
-0.6303920746,
-0.8272970915,
0.0108719543,
-0.1508630663,
0.4282768667,
-0.7267026305,
0.2130256593,
-0.5068415403,
-0.5710558891,
0.1073787957,
0.0136067998,
-0.0530828387,
0.3649487793,
0.2196365893,
0.1512961239,
-0.5810857415,
-0.7321376204,
-0.1261362433,
-0.4215350449,
-0.0878693014,
0.2271275818,
0.432879895,
-0.4050109684,
0.7207728028,
-0.7131741047,
-0.2939422131,
-0.2034577429,
0.004569056,
0.0560127012,
0.307351917,
0.656445682,
-1.027744174,
-0.4671519101,
0.3991409242,
-0.6308793426,
-0.0756488591,
0.0007561243,
-0.1145784855,
0.0433818325,
0.6066081524,
-0.8241946697,
-0.0114108967,
0.5882409215,
-0.27792418,
0.4844169617,
0.0762904659,
-0.01105351,
-1.0903553963,
0.1963834316,
-0.3370925784,
-0.1330177784,
-0.6241070628,
0.1148156971,
-0.2248778343,
-0.3717076182,
-0.5801059008,
0.7351643443,
-0.3957416415,
-0.2199341655,
-0.4221461117,
0.1159643009,
-0.0213837996,
0.6000118852,
0.2679744363,
1.2039599419,
0.5989058018,
-0.5583657622,
0.2892065346,
0.5034783483,
-0.4189621508,
0.1627946496,
-0.7878009081,
0.317050755,
-0.1070953012,
0.2003960162,
-0.7425934076,
-0.4571415186,
0.1012970433,
-0.342741847,
-0.1506896764,
-0.1053226814,
-0.5436894894,
-0.1699601561,
0.1245420724,
0.3750279844,
0.5276067257,
-0.5572747588,
0.6143475771,
0.5218769312,
-0.6458158493,
-0.3042180836,
-0.6263397336,
0.5369989276,
-0.2434483916,
-0.4470255971,
-0.1145964563,
-0.0278878976,
-0.0450774394,
0.0282904971,
-0.4278087318,
-0.4604917765,
0.0272761378,
0.2671397328,
0.3461781442,
-0.5071209073,
0.3951167166,
-0.087457262,
0.1709089428,
0.0469317101,
-0.7870726585,
0.4458635449,
-0.6038598418,
-0.4655072093,
0.1148506328,
0.5121452808,
0.578404963,
-0.500657618,
0.5576435924,
0.2714482248,
-0.2433747053,
-0.2632951736,
-0.3820411265,
0.1430657506,
-0.5639979839,
0.5858940482,
-0.4285752773,
-1.1581673622,
0.1367731541,
-0.1105880365,
0.3243527412,
0.3833491802,
0.6907724142,
0.1009439752,
0.7785444856,
0.6200529337,
-0.320320636,
0.3984953761,
-0.1289743781,
0.2975500226,
-0.7749545574,
-0.1829333305,
-0.5596684813,
0.1879831851,
-0.1996185184,
-0.4384225607,
0.6647678614,
-0.2050713897,
-0.6045674682,
0.0311982408,
-0.5142683983,
0.4888988137,
0.3048038185,
-0.1656555235,
0.5400980115,
0.1043508574,
0.3287174106,
0.3200824857,
-0.7993836403,
-0.6914185882,
1.0928961039,
0.1887764782,
0.891941309,
0.4226165116,
0.2875190079,
0.2257340252,
0.4129354656,
-0.837069273,
0.3761780262,
-0.055048842,
-0.6755447984,
-0.2031210512,
-0.5767401457,
-0.6518121362,
0.1069507748,
0.3043418229,
-0.3581709266,
-0.0423159264,
0.1707544476,
-0.2660917342,
0.3768239319,
-0.6455391049,
0.6470657587,
-0.5766022205,
0.1554081887,
0.2096430659,
-0.3816385269,
0.4264810085,
-0.5892831087,
0.1361895502,
-0.119583182,
-0.4062977433,
0.8509658575,
-0.2991404831,
0.8066427708,
0.1101548523,
-0.2005726695,
0.3361028135,
0.0843391791,
0.3828474879,
0.098417908,
-0.0432157256,
0.4773188829,
-0.0160218924,
-0.0768748596,
-0.6882516742,
0.841596067,
-0.8103218675,
-0.5277510285,
-0.6009647846,
-0.2889352739,
-0.4287975132,
0.4488798082,
-0.0330251828,
0.5574575067,
-0.1772987694,
0.1150726303,
0.2880313993,
-0.2712169886,
0.1250458062,
0.6799179316,
-0.587189436,
-0.2819684744,
0.912501514,
-0.0197549053,
0.2297520489,
0.646116972,
-0.0233254712,
-0.4207237661,
-0.6705093384,
-0.3663528562,
0.0621523969,
-0.8424293995,
-0.1974966377,
-0.7968028188,
-0.575050056,
-0.2325911522,
-0.2875374258,
-0.2814941108,
-0.6794990301,
-0.105158709,
-0.2530746162,
0.3386877477,
0.838770628,
0.3136530817,
0.7881064415,
-0.6311704516,
0.3084690273,
0.3158140182,
0.5299779177,
0.0639385432,
-0.4178230464,
-0.4786064625,
-0.0759717301,
-0.3960516155,
-0.28372702,
0.3910425007,
0.3932508826,
0.5248203874,
0.1520114094,
-0.1587330401,
0.5285028815,
-0.7448233366,
0.9848485589,
-0.0970080942,
-0.7651659846,
0.3693395853,
-0.5662302375,
0.1601459235,
0.2873521149,
0.1361614317,
-0.9274461865,
-0.4153155386,
-0.4716375768,
-0.8533909321,
0.5184964538,
0.4333069921,
0.0676817968,
0.086742416,
0.4908147156,
-0.2368575335,
0.4309519827,
-0.4852756262,
0.1015930772,
-0.4523504674,
-0.1830668747,
-0.3878773153,
-0.0543075055,
0.0488775633,
0.0876773968,
0.9316964746,
-0.0860249549,
0.384059459,
0.2757364511,
0.1863827705,
0.0692998245,
0.2659953833,
0.7896315455,
0.6150852442,
-0.3757673204,
0.2494066656,
-0.1403093934,
-0.519533515,
0.301775068,
-0.1722644269,
-0.1033070385,
-0.1258726716,
0.566693902,
0.6794317365,
-0.0870652273,
-0.9408785105,
0.5166399479,
-0.0096436245,
-0.1820963472,
-0.4054581821,
0.0921088755,
0.2592400014,
-0.0615167618,
0.163440004,
-0.0302422903,
0.3567280471,
-0.2922110856,
0.3757453859,
0.375785619,
-0.0901678503,
-0.1221845523,
1.203987956,
0.3438856304,
-0.1922773272,
0.5327996612,
0.3232340515,
-0.7586004734,
0.7952725291,
0.3757847548,
1.0014605522,
0.0263524279,
0.0727809146,
0.1601855904,
0.5757551193,
-0.349354744,
0.1263623238,
0.0497847535,
-0.5385705829,
-0.4306867421,
-0.6824756861,
-0.7375302911,
0.2990969718,
-0.2891735137,
0.1556512117,
-0.4186369181,
-0.0633235201,
-0.1383927464,
-0.184133172,
-0.4806064963,
0.1034372747,
0.1025133654,
1.1926926374,
-0.569739759,
0.7665888667,
0.8390898705,
-0.5336253643,
-1.0677658319,
0.241809383,
0.015225498,
-0.9050018191,
0.8020583987,
0.0320663899,
-0.1592092365,
0.2234766632,
-0.2387437373,
-0.7806081772,
0.8548582196,
0.2771043479,
-0.7431872487,
-0.332044363,
0.3762789369,
0.4574587047,
-0.1641579568,
-0.0480771288,
0.3556155562,
0.3525918424,
0.1662410796,
-0.9771327972,
-0.1945492625,
-0.1919418126,
0.1469569653,
0.1824926287,
-0.7800747752,
0.8079402447,
0.086977981,
-0.0342902169,
-0.1183131635,
0.430544883,
0.0576807968,
0.1130550131,
0.3380736411,
0.3473800123,
0.5673794746,
0.136651054,
1.1622338295,
-0.2173869312,
0.4275614321,
1.1334012747,
-0.4802095592,
0.8829627633,
0.5633081198,
-0.0115703549,
0.1295153499,
0.6355801225,
0.1748791486,
0.6327186227,
-0.0125334617,
-0.5666719079,
-0.1414336413,
0.3013379872,
-0.566049397,
0.4665606618,
0.2497648597,
0.0633584037,
-0.4154092371,
0.0039075576,
0.092171602,
-0.3705562949,
-0.1594669372,
0.9107867479,
0.4385435879,
-0.5995248556,
0.6198385954,
0.0720919445,
0.2423454076,
-0.9919309616,
-0.0760119781,
-0.3487832248,
0.0683408901,
-0.0543984808,
-0.8633536696,
0.5187895298,
0.2132393718,
0.1342888325,
-0.0540148281,
0.4494460523,
-0.3671253026,
-0.6395449638,
-0.0060785278,
0.4913261831,
0.193243131,
-0.4666106105,
-0.3539813757,
0.2576147318,
-0.1400715709,
-0.4526342154,
0.1643676311,
0.4427601993,
0.0098463725,
1.0103027821,
0.7689541578,
0.3946204484,
0.1165202111,
-0.0811096355,
1.1050896645,
-0.529189527,
-0.8856921196,
-0.6882658601,
0.1551533043,
0.1308199763,
-0.1966195703,
0.6750233769,
0.8465650678,
0.4660226405,
-0.1341133565,
1.3281135559,
0.0724629387,
0.450966835,
-0.7557677627,
0.6198167205,
-0.7249433398,
0.6230111122,
0.0175392702,
-0.7026494741,
-0.495632112,
0.517963171,
-0.2235519886,
0.1452543139,
0.4493402243,
0.8112652898,
-0.3441478014,
0.0190307479,
0.2677937448,
0.0530668385,
1.188611865,
0.7544339895,
0.8551164865,
-0.332949847,
0.7547571659,
0.0887381136,
-0.2475673407,
-0.4211530387,
-0.8253840208,
-0.9323972464,
-0.5838261247,
-0.1504843831,
0.0919243768,
0.1916834116,
0.909933269,
0.8327269554,
-0.5036950707,
-0.2430179119,
-0.3780726194,
-0.1876263022,
-0.1362298429,
-0.1953626424,
0.5390683413,
-0.2972292006,
-0.337028861,
0.4514756203,
0.4560292959,
0.2471982539,
-0.1712912768,
-0.2251823694,
0.1890546381,
0.1942366511,
0.6293097138,
0.2866959274,
-0.4966675341,
-0.19298549,
0.0468369164,
-0.0406629443,
0.079378508,
0.9725170732,
-0.3663351536,
0.087137416,
0.0714022815,
1.0987188816,
0.5201022029,
0.128051132,
0.5130288005,
-0.7915496826,
0.2160759419,
0.2802371085,
0.25423944,
0.2709905505,
-0.471026808,
0.6213784814,
0.0488273129,
-1.0069637299,
-0.8497179151,
0.0454966165,
-1.2958495617,
-0.2995850742,
1.3240770102,
0.3120163381,
0.0885606259,
-0.2213516235,
-0.5130185485,
-0.0728575811,
-0.420968473,
0.6608102918,
0.6666674018,
-0.1442013234,
-0.1775327623,
-1.0419279337,
0.5449439883,
-0.0666868836,
-1.2292836905,
0.3502099812,
0.4144721627,
0.4747122228,
-0.2749203146,
1.0271971226,
0.0629383251,
0.1140349433,
-0.0202264171,
0.0378537513,
-0.375030756,
-0.3964308798,
-0.194565177,
0.1508857459,
0.4118775427,
-0.0293204281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17676v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17676v1
|
Improving Minority Stress Detection with Emotions
| 2023-11-29T14:39:38 | 2023-11-29T14:39:38 |
Jonathan Ivey, Susan Gauch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Psychological stress detection is an important task for mental healthcare
research, but there has been little prior work investigating the effectiveness
of psychological stress models on minority individuals, who are especially
vulnerable to poor mental health outcomes. In this work, we use the related
task of minority stress detection to evaluate the ability of psychological
stress models to understand the language of sexual and gender minorities. We
find that traditional psychological stress models underperform on minority
stress detection, and we propose using emotion-infused models to reduce that
performance disparity. We further demonstrate that multi-task psychological
stress models outperform the current state-of-the-art for minority stress
detection without directly training on minority stress data. We provide
explanatory analysis showing that minority communities have different
distributions of emotions than the general population and that emotion-infused
models improve the performance of stress models on underrepresented groups
because of their effectiveness in low-data environments, and we propose that
integrating emotions may benefit underrepresented groups in other mental health
detection tasks.
|
[
-0.6103197336,
-0.3776162267,
0.4796855748,
0.5304768085,
-0.1491922438,
0.1529291123,
-0.2752313614,
-0.7061413527,
0.2109979242,
-0.0655789822,
-0.7372891307,
-0.4156439006,
-0.9308840632,
0.18112275,
-0.1655979902,
0.9084171653,
0.0236472096,
0.2423968613,
-0.1083658338,
-0.0084998989,
-0.2087082416,
-0.5987638831,
-0.3047405481,
-0.4727796018,
0.1717700809,
0.2863083482,
0.3481798172,
0.1079208851,
0.6443240047,
0.1934128553,
-0.2359207273,
0.1517672986,
-0.5636096001,
-0.0396522246,
0.0828534812,
-0.244816348,
-0.4487238824,
0.0189490914,
0.1897102743,
0.5559271574,
-0.3844668865,
0.2530187666,
-0.045037698,
0.3492208123,
-1.1505241394,
-0.2106871158,
-0.3451135159,
0.2560094893,
-0.4232265949,
0.0268682241,
-0.2332643121,
-0.3230185807,
0.0334932059,
-0.2052747309,
0.3149974346,
0.0283432547,
0.1723048538,
0.4808304608,
-0.8500186205,
-0.0350166522,
-0.9122844338,
0.7505845428,
-0.4969439507,
0.2748126984,
0.5150534511,
-0.079316996,
0.0557672679,
-0.0712371767,
-0.3962711394,
0.0641979128,
-0.2308069319,
0.2260204852,
-0.6078689098,
0.0667989254,
0.4010694027,
0.3224837482,
-0.4837177396,
0.0497618467,
-0.5865792632,
0.036672961,
0.7267757058,
0.3457638025,
0.4620968103,
-0.024157187,
-0.0065394356,
0.3900468349,
0.0615301169,
0.1632603407,
0.2756678462,
0.2057703584,
0.0067813029,
0.297388643,
0.0084812101,
0.2077554315,
-0.0281686485,
-0.1214189157,
0.3484967053,
-0.01535838,
-0.2057586163,
-0.028868299,
0.2483334094,
0.4855094254,
0.249166593,
0.1823447496,
-0.1531766802,
0.3547970653,
0.4108636379,
-0.739618957,
-0.1565998048,
0.0432839282,
-0.8545591235,
0.0626131818,
-0.3153437972,
-0.8179530501,
-0.8123006821,
-0.1382587701,
-0.1349591017,
-0.36624825,
-0.9547371268,
0.2379375845,
-0.3884862959,
-0.0919047594,
0.4231087267,
-0.9325067401,
0.6318997145,
0.5778205991,
0.8198916912,
-0.4138050377,
0.3046202362,
-0.0355026908,
-0.2960992455,
-0.1426075697,
0.4611131847,
-0.6957169771,
-0.8124305606,
-0.1208537519,
-0.1004700735,
0.0669278651,
-0.7494809031,
0.7472936511,
0.2522956133,
-0.1056051627,
-0.6412388682,
-0.4137389362,
-0.0268577971,
-0.0175412018,
-0.5063099265,
1.1824725866,
0.3910014331,
-0.6836234331,
0.5273585916,
-0.8336700797,
-0.5016524792,
0.0093461536,
0.0985432938,
-0.267940551,
0.6276454329,
0.4914306402,
0.0753954947,
-0.0894300267,
-0.2013760209,
-0.8318929672,
-0.6670020819,
0.1859044135,
0.0031007759,
0.6138185263,
0.1872856468,
-0.3139998615,
-0.1121659279,
-0.1496876329,
-0.3792605996,
-0.0383852385,
0.1649937034,
-0.6439889669,
0.0373540781,
0.2289800942,
0.0952499658,
-0.1771756858,
-0.7225706577,
0.0363752022,
0.1537944824,
-0.2086619288,
0.6403341293,
-0.1147197932,
0.2728576064,
0.0789012611,
0.8736125231,
0.2397985756,
0.470228821,
0.321149379,
-0.6491718292,
-0.5796191692,
-0.6651051641,
-0.3457407951,
0.7948054075,
-0.2801928818,
0.3778871298,
0.6029893756,
-0.5865960717,
-0.6567233205,
-0.0720119774,
0.2015919238,
0.6662162542,
0.6142556667,
-0.3296029866,
-0.7321304679,
-0.7007154822,
-0.3034831882,
-0.0734707937,
0.229445979,
0.2932452559,
0.7343597412,
-0.246513918,
0.6250050664,
-0.9075525403,
-0.0967999697,
0.1356421411,
0.5999951959,
-0.0125784408,
0.7081826329,
0.6782523394,
-0.6079992056,
-0.1893413216,
-0.0829133168,
-0.6235954165,
-0.2757002413,
0.4424487054,
-0.0573913381,
-0.1344658285,
0.214904815,
-0.3209179044,
0.6824702024,
0.4309956133,
-0.5143960118,
0.5871718526,
0.1030374467,
0.5319762826,
-0.5686718822,
-0.0805674344,
0.5244590044,
0.0388941243,
-0.8572872877,
-0.3500508368,
0.1336687058,
-0.4512251616,
-0.2552281618,
0.3142588139,
-0.4550142586,
-0.0028079641,
-0.6708151698,
-0.5054078698,
-0.2716161311,
0.1799553186,
0.1506192386,
0.2846407592,
0.620903194,
-0.4196667969,
0.198249802,
0.0710945576,
-0.391890049,
1.0468481779,
-0.3117365241,
-0.0057287528,
-0.4306744635,
0.2828870714,
-0.8920910358,
-0.1030904353,
0.2478383929,
-0.4130774736,
0.1455381811,
-0.1859636456,
-0.0664047822,
-0.8345167041,
0.0626363605,
0.6878327727,
0.8174236417,
-0.08008717,
0.4211854041,
0.3393771648,
-0.242887795,
-0.5983377099,
-0.9265580773,
-0.2023987025,
-0.5059117675,
-0.3175112903,
0.1568876803,
0.0644019842,
-0.4610490501,
0.1229187548,
-0.2360871881,
-0.5395236015,
0.5075722933,
0.4089604914,
0.0217853561,
-0.167023927,
0.8127190471,
0.2932731807,
0.0885360762,
0.0584864728,
-0.0691711232,
0.2422800213,
-0.0380303785,
-0.6946352124,
-0.4118093252,
0.8763658404,
0.297365576,
-0.4634987116,
0.8246643543,
1.1408622265,
-1.0724016428,
0.0271564443,
-0.6722277999,
-0.4899916649,
-0.404427886,
0.4982461035,
-0.1050801426,
-1.0966403484,
0.408411622,
-0.0761571825,
-0.3158128858,
0.07026954,
0.5230155587,
-0.6441028714,
1.0739233494,
0.8488666415,
-0.1858749986,
0.5154045224,
0.1924749166,
0.1930164844,
-0.4976167977,
0.1289728135,
-0.5342933536,
-0.7517101169,
-0.3281104565,
-0.5307528377,
0.4189238548,
0.0380379297,
-0.0409656651,
-0.4086273611,
-0.6780245304,
0.3523811102,
0.3707498908,
0.4734991789,
0.0720931962,
-0.1141220927,
0.4989418089,
-0.5061303973,
-0.020961808,
-0.196694687,
1.0021797419,
0.3202615082,
0.9696030021,
0.0788553506,
0.8337712288,
0.4987232983,
0.6852586269,
-0.4844494462,
0.0125675136,
-0.4551740587,
-0.8761699796,
0.1039403901,
-0.3788963556,
-0.6133326292,
0.2959873974,
-0.274715215,
-1.0976063013,
0.8294687867,
0.3483943641,
-0.4003813565,
0.1873834133,
-0.7103820443,
0.7981112003,
-0.2096891105,
0.3922580779,
-0.3458971083,
-0.2597040534,
0.9768776894,
-0.0980851799,
0.1790104955,
-0.5864293575,
0.0309630726,
0.7692795396,
-0.1887740046,
0.8489894271,
-0.4305692911,
-0.0047894474,
0.086424008,
-0.0675073713,
0.1218034104,
-0.1544985026,
-0.2376149446,
-0.1876875162,
-0.3013635874,
-0.5696034431,
-0.7783615589,
0.2224860638,
-0.7244078517,
-0.5143038034,
-0.0970265716,
-0.8097988963,
-0.2487678677,
-0.2863234878,
0.1198619455,
-0.0795743465,
0.0207774136,
-0.0572857484,
0.6144608259,
0.0127598122,
0.2188463956,
0.4124457836,
0.0347737186,
-0.1946977675,
0.4270317554,
-0.1243615374,
0.0200510118,
-0.1005613282,
-0.0282744281,
-0.2209418267,
-0.2228096277,
0.1850836426,
0.1120054573,
-0.7630799413,
0.0634872392,
-0.8425999284,
0.2485671788,
-0.6153606176,
-0.028898485,
-0.4255455732,
0.0096486369,
-0.4505029321,
-0.3119264245,
0.4340412319,
0.4492878914,
-0.2594386935,
0.4761673212,
-0.6531688571,
0.2933065891,
0.4713721573,
0.0699441284,
0.0629111081,
-0.3841219544,
-0.2547301948,
-0.2794851959,
-0.2292408794,
-1.1869866848,
0.2603324652,
0.014067715,
0.4163289368,
0.5778241754,
0.4446673691,
0.8591930866,
0.0245648734,
0.3532064855,
0.2506434917,
-1.3663685322,
0.6098878384,
0.0660976917,
0.2184042484,
0.6464158297,
0.7202495337,
-0.7120594978,
-0.4263574183,
-0.2711227238,
-0.385891974,
0.7533221841,
0.4006156325,
0.0111089358,
-0.0303712673,
0.1569873691,
-0.1617049873,
0.1415953636,
-0.779315114,
-0.3743462861,
-0.19422701,
-0.4291071594,
-0.0034889991,
-0.3650199175,
-0.2936046124,
-0.4086816907,
0.1908067465,
-0.0965576023,
0.4242376089,
0.2213237882,
-0.0976279378,
-0.4208459556,
0.3944314718,
0.7674586177,
0.23023884,
-0.4752188027,
0.2363171279,
0.4107609391,
-0.5121562481,
0.5907797813,
0.3815539479,
0.2977285683,
-0.0121697616,
0.5190011859,
0.8555698395,
-0.1990769506,
-0.4363668263,
0.4233398438,
-0.1609019786,
-0.0454940796,
0.3272537589,
-0.0478345007,
0.2642732263,
0.6793106794,
0.5936424136,
0.2249708176,
0.5779387951,
-0.4951738417,
0.1422860771,
0.3420763612,
-0.7337447405,
-0.1828383207,
0.1913466156,
0.4847580492,
-0.0566058047,
0.628226459,
-0.2858973145,
-0.8104969859,
0.9987768531,
0.5956914425,
0.8046251535,
-0.7286179066,
0.1174493209,
0.2944675982,
0.8511451483,
-0.113162674,
0.7547309399,
-0.0140056787,
-0.6966105103,
-0.3908070922,
-0.2099561393,
-0.4887037575,
-0.3222870231,
-1.0124425888,
0.0523952581,
-0.1928213537,
-0.6940592527,
-0.3708716631,
-0.1382415146,
-0.6021718383,
0.6588134766,
0.8529174328,
0.954221189,
-1.3222429752,
0.276601404,
0.6612102389,
0.0819909647,
-0.4377747178,
0.0906030461,
0.3190137446,
-0.5060899854,
0.6785524487,
0.3649484813,
-0.0106235193,
-0.3311423361,
-0.1788862646,
-0.6707138419,
0.6628373265,
0.5708726048,
-0.2911422849,
0.4021118283,
-0.2539171875,
0.6533448696,
-0.4443259835,
0.6505532265,
0.5446459055,
0.6447526813,
-0.3090234697,
-0.912986517,
0.0476530716,
-0.4047436416,
-0.0081942454,
0.1479402035,
-0.1760650426,
1.1164518595,
-0.2015657872,
-0.3251411617,
-0.3294760585,
0.6815869808,
0.3914679289,
0.6109050512,
0.9035587907,
0.601790309,
1.0718417168,
-0.3483153284,
0.9462324977,
0.2985735536,
0.4003278017,
1.0161454678,
-0.4824849069,
0.4240238965,
0.2045487612,
-0.2898611426,
0.4740465879,
0.9055925608,
0.0575028546,
0.1886389703,
0.37764135,
-0.5850215554,
-0.6363657117,
-0.6874234676,
-0.6887246966,
0.5402078032,
0.4623833895,
-0.3630972505,
-0.1499512792,
0.5244403481,
-0.2609609365,
-0.0380950496,
-0.4151144624,
0.3246763945,
0.1961767673,
-0.1349874437,
0.3419933021,
-0.1948737949,
0.8532316089,
-0.1664180905,
0.303589344,
-0.539162159,
0.1006105989,
-0.5000137091,
-0.5042235255,
0.3775127828,
0.2595031857,
-0.4686644077,
0.0531866774,
0.957269609,
-0.547565937,
-0.7120216489,
0.6914970279,
0.7105479836,
0.0839745775,
-0.5357882977,
-0.5037447214,
0.0250135604,
-0.3118814826,
-0.0800346434,
0.0952516273,
0.3106439412,
0.0496159866,
0.6044053435,
0.3814348876,
0.0948532969,
0.0266756043,
0.0058704983,
0.4307025373,
-0.8253155947,
-0.4687815309,
-1.1812473536,
0.6781842709,
-0.2488400042,
-0.3592963517,
0.3097298443,
-0.0394214578,
0.2376927435,
-0.2466154397,
0.7002851963,
0.1243731827,
0.1935456991,
0.0294002444,
0.7129087448,
-0.9275350571,
-0.5029829144,
-0.6280952692,
-0.5507492423,
-0.2563114762,
0.3370767534,
-0.2779263854,
0.1600397974,
0.5835249424,
0.633177042,
-0.1625548601,
0.221537143,
0.2097912431,
-0.1849427521,
0.2991117835,
0.7384184599,
1.0941209793,
0.026834622,
0.3314510584,
-0.516872406,
-0.3523726165,
-0.2395735234,
-0.739192903,
-0.7292757034,
-0.2180121094,
-0.557782948,
0.0271636751,
-0.1726371944,
0.8036251068,
1.0642317533,
-0.8536965847,
-0.2427807152,
0.4104349315,
0.4755246043,
-0.4890311658,
-0.2382901013,
-0.1964638829,
0.0391516052,
-0.6207954288,
0.2518495321,
0.3767844141,
0.2786411941,
0.0268201679,
-0.0794080421,
-0.060139589,
-0.038652651,
0.3012152314,
0.0119149853,
-0.6050164104,
0.2069907039,
-0.3308561444,
-0.3218148053,
-0.2070736289,
1.0410945415,
-0.2274787724,
0.3190230727,
0.3216036558,
0.6916956902,
0.3256163895,
-0.0114234155,
0.5606236458,
-0.8091551661,
0.2419084311,
0.4762817621,
0.702019155,
0.2859996557,
-0.8071609735,
0.5650323033,
0.4246872365,
-0.1930045485,
-1.1150889397,
0.2735272348,
-0.7518311739,
-0.197693482,
0.4836761057,
-0.4291810989,
0.080212228,
-0.1318929195,
-0.1732476652,
0.4105556309,
-0.4714484513,
0.7005623579,
0.815105319,
-0.4129918814,
-0.5639988184,
-0.0686414614,
0.4807531536,
0.8167356253,
-1.2345217466,
-0.0590446182,
0.2193010002,
-0.1810590476,
0.0663336888,
0.7162769437,
0.3843543828,
0.7864432931,
-0.1340518892,
0.5265778899,
0.1314190179,
0.0661433637,
-0.56200701,
0.2015995532,
-0.413133353,
-0.1518924981
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17667v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17667v2
|
TimeBench: A Comprehensive Evaluation of Temporal Reasoning Abilities in Large Language Models
| 2023-11-29T14:30:16 | 2024-06-28T10:40:26 |
Zheng Chu, Jingchang Chen, Qianglong Chen, Weijiang Yu, Haotian Wang, Ming Liu, Bing Qin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Grasping the concept of time is a fundamental facet of human cognition,
indispensable for truly comprehending the intricacies of the world. Previous
studies typically focus on specific aspects of time, lacking a comprehensive
temporal reasoning benchmark. To address this, we propose TimeBench, a
comprehensive hierarchical temporal reasoning benchmark that covers a broad
spectrum of temporal reasoning phenomena. TimeBench provides a thorough
evaluation for investigating the temporal reasoning capabilities of large
language models. We conduct extensive experiments on GPT-4, LLaMA2, and other
popular LLMs under various settings. Our experimental results indicate a
significant performance gap between the state-of-the-art LLMs and humans,
highlighting that there is still a considerable distance to cover in temporal
reasoning. Besides, LLMs exhibit capability discrepancies across different
reasoning categories. Furthermore, we thoroughly analyze the impact of multiple
aspects on temporal reasoning and emphasize the associated challenges. We
aspire for TimeBench to serve as a comprehensive benchmark, fostering research
in temporal reasoning. Resources are available at:
https://github.com/zchuz/TimeBench
|
[
-0.1870895177,
-0.8732360005,
0.9213981032,
0.6713374853,
-0.2532437742,
0.5697934628,
-0.101238668,
-0.6894565225,
-0.2667025924,
-0.1843715161,
-0.562315762,
-0.556871891,
-0.239857465,
-0.1379514188,
-0.3578606844,
0.4182380438,
-0.2640211284,
-0.0755336583,
-0.1445714235,
-0.057708133,
-0.2118787467,
-0.5349641442,
-0.5432312489,
-1.0247606039,
0.5381130576,
0.0104641533,
0.5055683255,
0.4961809814,
0.2764203548,
0.2325275838,
-0.2266789675,
-0.1712177396,
-0.0932120755,
0.1695820242,
-0.5334971547,
-0.5007006526,
-0.6729609966,
0.0831552595,
0.6974260211,
0.991245687,
-0.2945190668,
0.3249198794,
-0.1711812615,
0.3565568328,
-0.7041318417,
0.1942072809,
-0.492359519,
0.5212666392,
-0.6867457032,
-0.3113457263,
-0.1088145152,
-0.3708983958,
-0.0348175727,
-0.4745341837,
0.2895226777,
0.1361678541,
0.647434175,
0.3675957918,
-0.5616883039,
0.5259439945,
-0.8863659501,
0.7916976213,
-0.7976548076,
0.4966468811,
0.3286611438,
0.8081747293,
-0.1364333779,
-0.7949644327,
-0.6399532557,
-0.4041727781,
0.3298621476,
0.1038860008,
-0.0693724304,
-0.0118178995,
0.7021927834,
0.4017358124,
-0.7739502192,
0.1349821389,
0.1792460531,
-0.1567201614,
0.1224491075,
0.5618831515,
0.2462383658,
-0.1342515647,
-0.1447436064,
-0.0024282471,
-0.5408948064,
0.0687353835,
0.3207991123,
-0.3246067762,
-0.0515528098,
0.510494411,
-0.4373329282,
0.5339145064,
-0.2376772314,
0.0567922927,
0.1850702465,
-0.3598401546,
-0.0976269469,
-0.0624255873,
0.494895339,
0.4488793612,
0.1270823628,
-0.4424336255,
0.104640685,
0.3351489305,
0.1573289186,
-0.7368261218,
0.0082925269,
0.317021817,
-0.3215757906,
-0.2321029454,
-0.2718333602,
-0.81582582,
-0.2075028867,
-0.2341902554,
-0.0388246402,
-0.2718784511,
-0.2648504376,
0.089100793,
-0.2161853611,
0.448800981,
0.3437684178,
-0.6531853676,
0.422100246,
0.9179802537,
0.8413521647,
-0.2573868036,
-0.5508681536,
-0.3536085486,
0.4051435292,
-0.5337837338,
0.8964411616,
-0.6373944283,
-0.486810714,
-0.495108217,
0.0255943798,
0.0994922742,
-0.4043995738,
0.4839445055,
-0.73107481,
-0.0081969658,
-0.1674372554,
-0.4322163761,
-0.0770593956,
0.4107155204,
-0.6547698975,
1.2049779892,
0.2144958824,
-0.5375190973,
0.4446742237,
-0.4586712718,
-0.494633764,
0.0459594466,
-0.1619729698,
-0.1811434478,
-0.0941795707,
0.280397296,
0.1498768032,
-0.5694928169,
0.6046642065,
-0.7193850279,
-0.3584571183,
0.5553250313,
-0.5015313625,
0.6054845452,
0.2372135222,
-0.6514866948,
0.0634763911,
-0.5937934518,
0.3139567971,
0.2947172225,
-0.4005231559,
0.0064090146,
0.3551481366,
0.0629503131,
0.2617203295,
0.411886394,
-0.6914210916,
0.4704200029,
-0.1727512032,
0.7258603573,
0.8340938687,
-0.0212893616,
0.2020000964,
-0.2042301744,
0.5018620491,
-0.1443745941,
0.3228515387,
0.1484584212,
-0.0056281784,
-0.5691797733,
0.323309958,
0.2143329233,
0.6293014884,
-0.6126003265,
0.2373732328,
-0.4493650496,
-0.4588215649,
0.1110076606,
0.0979213119,
0.4520719051,
0.3917715549,
0.3316952884,
-0.2834138572,
-0.3074662983,
-0.831296742,
-0.3202053905,
-0.3994919062,
-0.3035266697,
0.1880738586,
0.6141774654,
-0.1910326183,
0.9076821208,
-0.3736193478,
0.1529391855,
-0.1517470032,
0.2398032099,
0.0692678094,
0.2716437578,
0.5488970876,
-0.4342565835,
0.2078893036,
0.0009944141,
-0.818074286,
-0.3675543368,
-0.0627479702,
-0.1890342832,
0.2613796592,
0.6987611651,
-0.4873299003,
0.3217495978,
0.5332896709,
-0.5268430114,
0.7339077592,
-0.0202578213,
0.1783561856,
-0.6664227247,
0.4088615179,
-0.4106797278,
-0.187702924,
-0.0370665453,
-0.1461053193,
0.116354093,
-0.1728275716,
-0.2526932359,
1.0256197453,
-0.2668612599,
-0.3477565944,
0.0299385637,
0.2003930658,
0.0959564969,
0.4842169881,
-0.1163384393,
0.6053740382,
0.0708232895,
-0.4068824947,
0.5366349816,
-0.2833314538,
-0.6691511869,
0.4988660514,
-0.8625082374,
0.3777992427,
0.2936609089,
0.5469740629,
-0.706338644,
-0.4026959836,
0.0294605866,
-0.237244606,
0.2521616518,
-0.1076499447,
-0.8598767519,
-0.4628047347,
-0.1026270762,
0.4906516671,
0.2606524825,
-0.4584646523,
0.8005405664,
0.2065648288,
-0.2045206279,
-0.5233390331,
-0.7568702698,
0.233814463,
-0.0962117687,
-0.5199683309,
0.6345225573,
-0.0929865018,
-0.5585164428,
0.1700123698,
-0.6311422586,
-0.0247726813,
0.2544142604,
0.2356516421,
0.1454333663,
-0.0688995048,
0.1933652461,
-0.012457463,
-0.3571461737,
0.0887871087,
-0.2673217058,
0.6062268615,
-0.476883322,
-0.8597399592,
-0.1496725678,
-0.0110756373,
0.5578923225,
-0.2649912536,
0.4866145849,
0.5298538208,
-0.3644220233,
-0.1808395684,
-0.9319419861,
0.0661756173,
-0.395804435,
0.1703461111,
-0.3674222529,
-0.8630242944,
0.5717675686,
-0.2618485391,
0.0727794394,
0.269548595,
0.3798598051,
-0.0713075548,
0.9491667151,
0.1341998726,
-0.2464573979,
0.564232409,
-0.1128797904,
-0.1828589886,
-0.9180490971,
-0.3880927861,
-0.4095139205,
-0.5061951876,
-0.1113602743,
-0.6936460733,
0.1939388216,
0.0957838371,
-0.5334652066,
-0.0712755248,
-0.0324662738,
0.5099312067,
0.2482345998,
-0.0233276617,
0.4423858225,
-0.2670880854,
-0.3206380904,
0.0951992199,
-0.3468582928,
-0.5725807548,
0.7461066842,
0.2236436456,
0.7341064215,
0.1334874183,
0.1838372946,
0.1866883487,
-0.0887802243,
-0.5023602843,
0.8535593152,
0.0373580977,
-0.9000799656,
-0.1868865937,
-0.6495331526,
-0.9446578622,
0.2046312392,
0.2695628703,
-0.8680542707,
-0.1595176607,
0.0061906711,
-0.2240164578,
0.5516783595,
-0.4881862998,
1.0690530539,
-0.7991636395,
-0.6064049602,
-0.6464287639,
-0.7577778101,
0.0389863439,
0.1112896279,
0.0930598453,
-0.7608071566,
-0.2246865183,
0.7319353223,
-0.3147574663,
0.8356064558,
-0.158436507,
0.1529385,
0.0812296867,
0.6452674866,
0.1929412633,
0.0690650567,
-0.0660152212,
0.5171863437,
0.2820676267,
-0.5203189254,
-0.6599287987,
0.7071772218,
-0.6269587874,
-0.4827306867,
-0.5950751901,
-0.5220159292,
-0.4900681973,
0.0786101446,
-0.1514227092,
0.3551198244,
-0.6205179691,
0.0325796753,
0.2670726478,
-0.1927979738,
0.4052771926,
0.8509578109,
-0.4147153497,
0.0633521974,
0.5046234131,
0.0533958003,
0.1990272701,
0.6127946377,
0.2055235207,
-0.3473407924,
-0.4813843369,
-0.1154196337,
0.2214538157,
-0.7027770281,
0.2041024417,
-0.448992759,
-0.07142625,
-0.0102030691,
-0.0162874255,
-0.3259769976,
-0.8077672124,
0.1578867733,
-0.143640399,
0.2385237068,
0.4847052097,
0.016272502,
0.1049630567,
-0.7063215971,
0.473955214,
0.4218246043,
0.5760347247,
0.1298733056,
-0.2235382497,
0.2609638572,
-0.3761579394,
-0.3655695021,
-0.4743569195,
-0.191396147,
-0.0345946439,
0.9149257541,
0.3116290271,
-0.2913000584,
0.7093722224,
-0.6187517643,
0.8814470768,
-0.2483083606,
-1.0926939249,
0.6748239398,
-0.4578961134,
0.7803339958,
0.2940367758,
-0.1007482931,
-0.8892427087,
-0.2341441065,
-0.6972398162,
-0.9404481649,
0.5567850471,
0.1875697523,
-0.4297745526,
0.1460267156,
0.117582798,
-0.030050924,
0.1145927832,
-0.3777968585,
0.2229556143,
-0.0740194619,
0.272929728,
-0.2421633154,
-0.1702686101,
-0.0353254117,
-0.1759548485,
0.3586644232,
-0.0109830843,
0.0640396848,
-0.0271895155,
-0.1398440897,
-0.2889684737,
0.7051476836,
0.2191505581,
1.0928667784,
-0.3238072693,
0.2504056394,
0.6304022074,
-0.2284783125,
0.2255782336,
0.3673697114,
0.2703173161,
-0.3018912673,
0.8617460132,
0.4892547429,
0.5607113242,
-0.623896718,
0.0816897824,
-0.148238197,
0.1940047592,
-0.4362576902,
0.0655974075,
0.3588005006,
0.5415700078,
0.2779566646,
-0.2426516265,
-0.1028610393,
-0.4707205296,
-0.2103054225,
0.134254545,
0.0419483073,
-0.3300606608,
0.8252968192,
0.1879008412,
-0.018712325,
0.9062135816,
-0.1705400348,
-0.5111080408,
0.7952858806,
0.1967022568,
0.7732440829,
-0.2719877064,
-0.0522866733,
0.2239415348,
0.3595488667,
-0.1452376693,
0.2510938942,
-0.3370352089,
-0.4452466965,
-0.7102388144,
-0.7721636891,
-0.6816959977,
-0.0271715354,
-0.3847973049,
-0.2230608612,
-0.6101598144,
-0.5247127414,
-0.0703371316,
0.1447522044,
-0.6908775568,
-0.2871217728,
0.1903276742,
1.0636214018,
-0.413169086,
0.6631426215,
0.56892097,
-0.2048418671,
-0.5899233818,
0.1829995662,
0.4787381887,
-0.6717574596,
0.8027393222,
0.1076907516,
-0.5926265121,
-0.2638664246,
-0.5058187246,
-0.5749083161,
1.3521165848,
0.4476821125,
-0.7257164717,
-0.275896728,
-0.0889326185,
0.6983467937,
0.0578753427,
0.1453518718,
0.8672753572,
0.5600331426,
0.0623121336,
-1.0914064646,
0.0768332928,
-0.4590653479,
0.1532170475,
0.3339370489,
-0.6435762048,
0.7393298149,
-0.2442301214,
-0.494767338,
0.1667930782,
0.3952325583,
0.3049103618,
0.4690900743,
0.4765399992,
0.7528051734,
0.6506356001,
-0.3471054733,
1.344802618,
-0.1325359941,
0.2045080811,
1.2663065195,
-0.6461016536,
0.6175655723,
0.2872909307,
-0.6452240944,
0.6336485147,
0.7203595042,
0.1486719102,
0.093949534,
0.2181126177,
-0.3155674338,
-0.6151644588,
-0.1141922995,
-0.6299771667,
0.1615719199,
0.5492576957,
0.1530898511,
-0.5573620796,
-0.3610813916,
0.0621577352,
-0.3520568609,
-0.1411904991,
0.345403254,
0.2620060742,
-0.5863306522,
0.2039588094,
-0.1357963383,
0.0828722343,
-0.8595996499,
-0.1322403252,
-0.0389516577,
0.528273046,
-0.1121738479,
-1.1646499634,
0.053701181,
-0.0030786116,
0.0532939769,
-0.0856204778,
0.5428996086,
0.0757600144,
-0.2837611139,
0.7178688645,
0.6867715716,
0.2087147683,
-0.1145624891,
-0.7716701031,
0.1780350059,
-0.4313728809,
-0.4275367558,
0.1419048607,
0.5469177365,
-0.2321390808,
0.9107461572,
0.6231001616,
0.1205652356,
-0.0952863544,
0.5960580111,
0.7242234945,
-0.9555229545,
-0.3076961339,
-1.0427575111,
0.0413999185,
-0.0383409783,
-0.1628757268,
0.6052238941,
0.5426603556,
0.8780163527,
0.1874311864,
0.6404132843,
-0.1868710071,
0.6197494864,
-0.6874828935,
0.4568467438,
-0.5787551403,
0.3077972531,
-0.2218517512,
-1.0527180433,
-0.1710726768,
0.4571291506,
-0.7502112985,
0.2907219529,
1.058735013,
0.4203550816,
-0.0779034197,
0.086952053,
0.0813221782,
0.3074153662,
0.550536871,
1.0149782896,
1.3511296511,
0.2499385923,
0.7035288811,
-0.4577789009,
-0.2491070032,
-0.1743031442,
-1.1873290539,
-1.0671854019,
-0.3267196119,
0.0447729416,
-0.1231917441,
0.2534037232,
0.8188508153,
0.5506364107,
-0.5136195421,
-0.2808873355,
0.1828998923,
-0.0456099622,
-0.3482047021,
-0.2139558494,
0.220431298,
-0.1323624253,
-0.3873627782,
0.6096386313,
0.2972539365,
0.0986874178,
-0.2903599143,
0.2311649919,
-0.0709066391,
-0.3737020493,
0.5803005099,
0.4089337885,
-0.7583430409,
-0.250339359,
0.0270803366,
-0.0350176133,
-0.0747450069,
1.2103770971,
-0.7971047163,
0.4810760319,
0.544654429,
0.4908783734,
0.9572440982,
-0.0481986925,
0.4403594434,
-0.6136345863,
0.1963952333,
0.3628160655,
0.5199927688,
0.3132754266,
-0.0327978022,
0.9612387419,
0.2634220719,
-0.6819785237,
-0.5003533959,
0.356354177,
-1.0955512524,
-0.5684941411,
0.9209813476,
0.0551228411,
-0.1984996051,
-0.2516795397,
0.0206072405,
0.4145680368,
-0.474186033,
0.8065550923,
1.1132519245,
-0.3634210527,
0.1546909511,
-0.8442317843,
-0.1000645682,
0.3814708889,
-1.0945343971,
0.1575484127,
0.6023847461,
0.4760400057,
0.1934165508,
0.61331141,
-0.3960885704,
0.4259119332,
0.0337982662,
0.0087150047,
-0.2050735354,
-0.3451575637,
-0.184943378,
0.0001941775,
0.132411316,
0.3277874589
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17647v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17647v2
|
Text as Images: Can Multimodal Large Language Models Follow Printed Instructions in Pixels?
| 2023-11-29T14:08:53 | 2024-06-10T23:39:24 |
Xiujun Li, Yujie Lu, Zhe Gan, Jianfeng Gao, William Yang Wang, Yejin Choi
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have shown promising
instruction following capabilities on vision-language tasks. In this work, we
introduce VISUAL MODALITY INSTRUCTION (VIM), and investigate how well
multimodal models can understand textual instructions provided in pixels,
despite not being explicitly trained on such data during pretraining or
fine-tuning. We adapt VIM to eight benchmarks, including OKVQA, MM-Vet,
MathVista, MMMU, and probe diverse MLLMs in both the text-modality instruction
(TEM) setting and VIM setting. Notably, we observe a significant performance
disparity between the original TEM and VIM settings for open-source MLLMs,
indicating that open-source MLLMs face greater challenges when text instruction
is presented solely in image form. To address this issue, we train v-MLLM, a
generalizable model that is capable to conduct robust instruction following in
both text-modality and visual-modality instructions.
|
[
-0.0290459581,
-0.8042400479,
0.7774295211,
0.0241009276,
-0.4296470881,
-0.2435168624,
-0.4707630277,
-0.22163257,
-0.2775875926,
0.5103363991,
-0.7026589513,
-0.6381736398,
-0.5377926826,
-0.1369500756,
0.1150068045,
0.8421679139,
-0.1259822398,
0.485655129,
-0.3278449774,
-0.1168527678,
-0.4351423383,
-0.6620342731,
0.0097803604,
0.0821184739,
0.7232603431,
0.2390545607,
0.8545975089,
0.815656364,
0.5231059194,
0.3427611291,
0.2706246674,
0.4575457573,
-0.2961945534,
-0.1179536581,
-0.1241517588,
-0.5345417857,
-0.1349424422,
0.0071776155,
0.7724314928,
0.4643850923,
0.2479570806,
-0.0091800308,
0.0570313781,
0.4748416245,
-0.7097347379,
0.3134246469,
-0.4168758094,
-0.0082372902,
0.1650520712,
-0.4850461185,
-0.9707986712,
-0.232946381,
0.1128449962,
-0.6680942774,
0.1626841873,
-0.1554654837,
0.7983500361,
0.1849442571,
-0.5208094716,
-0.3567050397,
-0.6012415886,
0.7412683368,
-0.3394448757,
0.5415245891,
0.4385993481,
0.2739486694,
0.2120175958,
-0.7778232694,
-0.4625541866,
-0.2679192722,
-0.1743183285,
0.0055930302,
-0.0377511717,
0.2981472015,
0.357318759,
0.172668457,
-0.4541813135,
0.1140311286,
-0.308640331,
-0.093494311,
0.101762794,
0.2710806727,
0.5347589254,
-0.0066690026,
-0.657110393,
-0.2853552997,
-0.3530846536,
0.1308558583,
-0.0031841877,
0.0505907089,
-0.5544555783,
0.7667537332,
0.2586565316,
0.9236680269,
-0.394238174,
0.0792829767,
0.1846975237,
-0.6297040582,
-0.3111727536,
-0.5174052119,
0.7680838704,
0.4640467167,
0.4324271977,
-0.1815753877,
-0.4532704651,
-0.031146856,
0.4423612356,
-0.9832646251,
-0.4219982028,
-0.4758491814,
-0.5962826014,
0.15436773,
0.0176206976,
-0.6641679406,
-0.4935421348,
-0.608784318,
1.0702990294,
-0.6296358109,
0.0773885846,
0.0174130555,
0.0032646467,
0.4594568014,
0.7594742775,
-1.0181370974,
-0.0710613206,
0.5118672848,
0.8359979987,
0.2107039094,
-0.3461050093,
-0.7156248093,
0.0259944182,
-0.456338346,
0.64394629,
-1.0165995359,
-0.3441930413,
-0.0357769281,
0.21990107,
-0.4761169851,
-0.0150854774,
0.1077032164,
-0.3099938035,
0.5737428665,
-0.2971544564,
-0.3882358372,
-0.4329864979,
0.1294326335,
-0.6109347343,
0.5480923653,
-0.0638426319,
-0.7012576461,
0.26289922,
-0.6416114569,
-0.2681041956,
-0.2241138369,
-0.3600944579,
-0.2660688162,
0.3768900335,
0.2772214413,
0.7093124986,
-0.1033928916,
-0.3883527517,
-0.2288271636,
-0.6688101292,
0.278785646,
-1.0710437298,
0.6217699051,
-0.1305498183,
-0.4846976101,
0.4684371948,
-0.7180297971,
0.0778974369,
0.0084974617,
-0.3615560234,
-0.3152566552,
0.2000704408,
0.4509653151,
0.0404457487,
0.0997525156,
-0.312995553,
0.5320858359,
0.1187440157,
0.4364106655,
0.8403487206,
-0.3049230576,
0.4824302793,
-0.1121194661,
0.44166255,
-0.0798301771,
-0.0007893273,
-1.0710167885,
-0.3951027393,
-1.0666699409,
-0.5531215072,
0.1304739267,
0.3570030332,
-1.1899073124,
-0.2998308241,
-0.2856121063,
-0.352428019,
-0.4427794814,
0.0461693071,
0.853176415,
0.2545762062,
0.3177032471,
-0.1670344025,
-0.0073684542,
-0.7688850164,
0.0245059934,
0.0587025546,
0.1879076511,
0.3523343205,
0.4747145176,
-0.2660230696,
0.2873865068,
-0.3247182667,
0.0181712974,
0.0876050666,
0.3228041232,
-0.0793783888,
0.4686096609,
0.6682497263,
-0.8177137971,
-0.4835418165,
0.2352715731,
-0.609365344,
0.1559415609,
-0.2910965681,
0.1647679359,
0.5046118498,
0.6198347211,
-0.3602676392,
0.5186251402,
0.5954170227,
-0.7087349296,
0.5303282738,
-0.7157918215,
0.4879277349,
-0.993585825,
-0.0225521121,
0.1565969586,
-0.4137341082,
-0.5753437281,
0.2854575813,
0.4924860299,
-0.2020685077,
-0.4441288114,
0.267380923,
-0.8289758563,
-0.0907481089,
-0.2443334758,
-0.4797065556,
0.2781017721,
0.6877864599,
0.3695293963,
1.0183099508,
0.7703840733,
-0.400298208,
-0.0608905815,
-0.1329757422,
-0.4944754541,
0.5349072814,
-0.4956667721,
0.2052115947,
-0.4517422318,
-0.096020788,
-1.0451438427,
-0.2288230807,
0.2007030696,
-0.1805521101,
0.5652582645,
-0.1475981027,
-0.5797636509,
0.0109951971,
-0.1919039637,
0.3775081635,
0.3987134099,
-0.532268405,
0.8298203349,
-0.2447652668,
0.096189037,
-0.5690650344,
-0.6874556541,
-0.0570979342,
0.1950629503,
-0.4583391249,
-0.0407599881,
-0.1559931189,
0.041978322,
-0.0456252471,
0.3349698782,
-0.3347955644,
-0.0467752703,
0.3683190942,
0.3328255713,
-0.5697236657,
0.4270401299,
-0.2906788588,
0.1027424708,
-0.0758786127,
-0.1052815244,
0.5951707959,
-0.2358759791,
-0.6647062302,
-0.8076714873,
0.3861602843,
1.0107535124,
-0.4980477393,
0.6668441892,
0.9699579477,
-0.1817398071,
-0.1068149358,
-0.2876101136,
-0.0423356108,
-0.4659714699,
0.6357602477,
-0.3049405813,
-0.6696639061,
-0.0057420377,
0.3177657723,
0.1234047189,
0.1284160167,
0.5795049667,
-0.5090504885,
0.9733247757,
1.1013211012,
0.3854657114,
0.8114213943,
-0.1220757589,
-0.2556017339,
-0.380921185,
-0.3271018863,
-0.3513173163,
-0.3867257535,
-0.2269484103,
-1.0563367605,
0.3206655979,
-0.0193805899,
-0.1131821349,
0.2127837241,
-0.3224973977,
0.6959279776,
0.6416732073,
0.5053363442,
0.1314035803,
0.1645594239,
-0.1316789091,
-0.2174429148,
-0.6935315132,
-0.4747479856,
0.7969459891,
0.4350578487,
1.1226739883,
-0.0721196234,
0.2572134435,
0.0844404101,
0.3280997872,
-0.8946342468,
0.4027492702,
-0.3752031922,
-0.3066212535,
0.0887967944,
-0.3849569261,
-0.7469052076,
0.4674536884,
-0.352878809,
-0.6239785552,
0.090937905,
0.2598296404,
-0.0564880036,
0.4073639214,
-1.2660952806,
1.1645569801,
-0.4629277885,
-0.4090875983,
-0.2452244312,
-0.4709068537,
0.173357591,
0.1555470824,
0.2297465503,
0.2346646935,
-0.4093623757,
0.275361836,
-0.163928479,
1.161228776,
-0.1870797575,
-0.1120391488,
0.0341846757,
0.0377214625,
0.1398886591,
-0.4771953225,
0.2755257785,
-0.1208870858,
-0.0390301347,
-0.4407173991,
-0.6647098064,
0.4808099568,
-0.7507078052,
-0.4737375379,
-0.0481285751,
-0.6972093582,
-0.0654202476,
0.2203184217,
0.3510556519,
1.1002959013,
0.0115515292,
0.4378016591,
0.8329821229,
-0.5133355856,
0.83301723,
0.3292020261,
-0.1245059744,
-0.4007877111,
1.0663802624,
0.0057445341,
0.4901048541,
0.6299951077,
0.1053531095,
-0.4160308242,
-0.4163606763,
-0.8930953741,
0.0628230721,
-0.9377437234,
0.0046496298,
-0.5326625705,
0.001454053,
0.0319170505,
-0.3573400676,
-0.265415132,
0.0153808976,
-0.6690372825,
0.3858948648,
0.3020008802,
0.8678008318,
0.4039178789,
0.447527498,
-1.1132084131,
0.389595747,
0.3876737654,
0.5992282629,
-0.0421931148,
-0.5364612341,
-0.2487242073,
0.3043016493,
-0.2020025998,
-0.9690794945,
0.0629248843,
0.439853102,
0.448120445,
0.4013427496,
-0.3279598653,
0.6714249253,
-0.7456890941,
0.8002400398,
0.5156337619,
-0.9102502465,
0.3637453616,
-0.5207509995,
0.6559303999,
0.1700110883,
0.4660025835,
-0.3569048345,
0.1399530172,
-0.0375080481,
-0.1638351828,
0.7494257689,
-0.0344057828,
0.6228777766,
0.1855307072,
0.0551301315,
0.1440957934,
0.091024451,
-1.1132318974,
0.0035352076,
-0.396442771,
-0.3557116687,
-0.277271837,
-0.2930915058,
0.0454287156,
-0.1957306415,
0.0278207809,
-0.2689075768,
0.4209171832,
0.2041844428,
-0.4823586941,
0.1507505327,
0.172888875,
0.9442324042,
0.7211037278,
0.2651377022,
0.3357836008,
-0.4243605137,
-0.4783365428,
0.0777964666,
-0.1244741082,
-0.0135463765,
0.142363593,
0.6180449724,
1.164685607,
0.3475125432,
-0.7223014235,
0.9422479272,
-0.0734680519,
-0.3261363208,
0.2697850764,
0.0351877287,
0.0765615776,
0.3922105432,
0.1259589046,
0.1860899329,
-0.2082110941,
-0.7818716168,
0.0611306094,
0.5399766564,
-0.8230569363,
-0.4084937274,
0.6422535181,
0.2126505524,
-0.3769155443,
0.3703242838,
0.159783572,
-0.5499148369,
0.448353976,
0.4202552438,
0.5207387805,
0.0060609207,
0.2955211997,
-0.0103808744,
0.6327003837,
0.1467863619,
0.492218554,
-0.1909841597,
-0.4347161055,
-0.5333909392,
-0.3365630507,
-0.2442734987,
-0.1180530265,
-0.3982161582,
0.2433321327,
-0.6020104885,
0.0402606055,
0.1320536584,
-0.5382658243,
-0.7936441302,
0.1840374619,
0.359898895,
0.795820713,
-0.6475691199,
0.8549268246,
0.9180196524,
-0.5413978696,
-0.42743963,
-0.0247344375,
0.1197407842,
-0.806210041,
0.5101938844,
0.5682327151,
-0.2087620497,
-0.0296321101,
-0.6496356726,
-0.2872848809,
0.8452486396,
0.5366876721,
-0.4508997798,
-0.0052685118,
-0.0456792004,
0.4493218064,
-0.2496159077,
0.3553234935,
-0.1960858852,
0.2752866447,
-0.1109138131,
-0.8811250329,
-0.2581606507,
-0.3837841153,
-0.0004070876,
0.1186154559,
-0.6271914244,
0.9003086686,
-0.4281314313,
-0.3701182604,
0.2448232323,
0.5794348121,
-0.3827994466,
0.2189796716,
0.3581104577,
0.3300593495,
0.3920020759,
-0.1186711714,
1.2941431999,
0.0591925941,
-0.0455683805,
1.0024290085,
0.3122547269,
0.9385548234,
0.4530622959,
0.2584467828,
0.5495522618,
0.4890107214,
-0.1086908579,
0.3968449831,
-0.1144122705,
-0.1122686639,
-0.4646155536,
-0.008940463,
-0.421332866,
0.6507224441,
0.3028108776,
-0.8253235817,
-0.1979086399,
0.2878160179,
-0.2706420422,
0.481145978,
-0.6839722395,
0.760171771,
-0.1823125184,
-0.3355764747,
0.8234190941,
-0.0829968378,
0.701833427,
-0.5696280599,
-0.4481368661,
0.1478621662,
0.1255301684,
0.0918034613,
-0.8352819681,
-0.0960787013,
0.0768930987,
-0.4367159605,
-0.3650136888,
0.5424079895,
-0.4942581952,
-0.5836035013,
-0.0115655847,
0.4062116742,
-0.0145667894,
-0.028600134,
-0.4552502632,
0.2984240651,
0.0351120383,
-0.2661385834,
0.2451480776,
0.6197578907,
-0.0309216864,
0.7087569237,
0.3734438717,
-0.285903722,
0.3531086743,
0.1036811844,
0.8929197192,
-0.5854302645,
-0.311460197,
-0.8935190439,
0.7962967753,
0.1547801793,
-0.4085757434,
0.5853325129,
0.3129732907,
0.825052917,
-0.5219973922,
0.4533168972,
0.2532420456,
-0.2032924294,
-1.0503214598,
0.8907543421,
-0.7053368092,
-0.0899805054,
-0.2096798569,
-1.1550670862,
-0.2140970081,
0.5756076574,
-0.2196558416,
0.0149363149,
0.7606360912,
0.826443851,
-0.3576840162,
-0.0654619858,
0.509901762,
-0.0510155037,
0.0530527271,
0.4047338068,
0.8261807561,
-0.1433212012,
0.4698871374,
-0.1202615649,
-0.1565242708,
-0.0304500107,
-0.8057772517,
-1.1361969709,
-0.6759975553,
-0.1876888573,
0.0243499093,
-0.0349827521,
0.9210342169,
0.7978134751,
-0.3249995112,
0.0215326957,
0.0962277949,
-0.0901903659,
-0.0743878931,
-0.1583710015,
0.2094480246,
-0.5287897587,
-0.8982149959,
0.200360626,
0.3719963133,
0.3493882716,
-0.332729727,
0.0324885175,
-0.1300804019,
-0.0288347322,
0.7454203367,
-0.093971923,
-0.8014348745,
-0.4033208191,
0.1957027316,
-0.5531318188,
0.1102823764,
0.9828674197,
-0.4001695514,
0.9747713804,
0.5454854965,
0.8671520352,
0.2967209816,
-0.2596545815,
0.6439505219,
-0.6406117082,
0.2067346126,
0.0738639385,
0.3645085692,
0.3837421536,
-0.0144368727,
0.1301180869,
0.2491890937,
-0.1748853326,
-0.5612125397,
0.1246788949,
-1.0980132818,
-0.6591697335,
1.2905323505,
-0.3209557831,
-0.3155989647,
0.1962233037,
-0.6759522557,
-0.0632188022,
-0.0057033063,
0.2871672213,
0.6966379285,
0.3413098454,
-0.8585140705,
-0.5272236466,
0.1839334071,
0.2415816486,
-0.5746814609,
0.1212531105,
0.9165626764,
0.0138384607,
-0.0977649018,
0.5046353936,
-0.0799530298,
0.547257185,
0.1860354543,
0.1302844882,
-0.3773062229,
-0.5190294385,
-0.5435092449,
0.0813797191,
-0.07622502,
-0.4888767898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17633v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17633v1
|
Introduction to Transformers: an NLP Perspective
| 2023-11-29T13:51:04 | 2023-11-29T13:51:04 |
Tong Xiao, Jingbo Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Transformers have dominated empirical machine learning models of natural
language processing. In this paper, we introduce basic concepts of Transformers
and present key techniques that form the recent advances of these models. This
includes a description of the standard Transformer architecture, a series of
model refinements, and common applications. Given that Transformers and related
deep learning techniques might be evolving in ways we have never seen, we
cannot dive into all the model details or cover all the technical areas.
Instead, we focus on just those concepts that are helpful for gaining a good
understanding of Transformers and their variants. We also summarize the key
ideas that impact this field, thereby yielding some insights into the strengths
and limitations of these models.
|
[
-0.6551911831,
-0.7905108929,
0.4346542358,
0.0635474622,
0.1862848848,
0.3194624186,
-0.225550428,
-0.45532161,
-0.2045136243,
0.8401309252,
-0.5894483924,
-0.209321931,
-0.8718303442,
0.260782212,
-0.854831934,
1.0163911581,
0.1529524177,
-0.2406370044,
0.1087463126,
-0.0789668038,
-0.2883727551,
-0.3499330878,
-0.742305994,
-0.4789638817,
0.2447278798,
0.4055387974,
0.9360692501,
0.4615598619,
0.7791646123,
0.3770520389,
-0.2506801784,
-0.1091165915,
0.0289352313,
0.3698687851,
-0.0609177463,
-0.7049465775,
0.0100410338,
0.1122385263,
0.5948636532,
1.1307061911,
-0.1223934591,
0.1290121973,
0.0818243921,
0.6752640009,
-0.3896367848,
0.2267395854,
-0.8667820096,
0.3847598732,
-0.0434874557,
-0.1544225514,
-0.7884528041,
-0.1861549318,
0.5804941058,
-0.28172791,
0.8972866535,
-0.1044009253,
0.9130800366,
0.4756145179,
-0.5123047829,
-0.3777002096,
-1.3947651386,
1.0308538675,
-0.4745109081,
0.4956941605,
0.1236827821,
0.766489625,
0.0791840702,
-1.1820632219,
-0.5394681692,
-0.0421729051,
-0.3227555454,
0.005932942,
-0.3470336795,
0.0006749129,
0.1287768781,
0.6349995732,
-0.3524285853,
0.4051856101,
-0.373693794,
0.2278184444,
0.4899106324,
0.2234560698,
0.1702850163,
-0.2530116737,
-0.3614053726,
-0.1390679479,
-0.3188203871,
0.0329766907,
0.1218579337,
0.2665860653,
-0.1615952104,
0.4419720471,
-0.0167196076,
0.5797849894,
0.3338817656,
0.1454952806,
0.1132903025,
-0.0940106958,
-0.3957130313,
-0.1853514463,
0.7118652463,
-0.0126604373,
0.2904500365,
-0.5238811374,
-0.0290960688,
-0.0697373599,
0.7466470599,
-0.4970792532,
-0.1681611687,
0.0885045826,
-0.5792040825,
-0.653644681,
-0.0229742546,
-0.7868918777,
-0.2593395114,
-0.7338433862,
-0.0563432835,
-0.2978772521,
-0.1679094732,
0.0848657116,
-0.213041082,
0.7620286942,
0.1488804817,
-1.3570210934,
0.698994875,
0.9936766624,
0.5630919933,
-0.1486131102,
-0.0647296831,
-0.0306244921,
-0.1633693874,
-0.0727042034,
1.0914906263,
-0.5770882368,
-0.2565702796,
0.2481508106,
0.064786993,
0.0295978989,
-0.4893306494,
0.8290381432,
-0.5414285064,
0.5967148542,
0.2852357924,
-0.521638751,
-0.4855289757,
-0.0369439237,
-0.7980490923,
1.0363767147,
0.2158910632,
-0.8186166286,
0.2739886343,
-0.8869915605,
-0.3914278746,
0.0080238581,
0.039839115,
-0.3314849734,
0.5921268463,
0.3303653598,
0.6263498068,
-0.5103109479,
0.2801772654,
0.2272043377,
-0.101522021,
0.1546120942,
-0.5711991191,
0.7405179739,
0.2814266384,
-0.0992543101,
0.0177987106,
-0.9038975239,
-0.3405113816,
0.1458133459,
0.1144202203,
0.0731148049,
0.3206198215,
0.3293359578,
-0.0413229801,
-0.1799091101,
-0.1799530983,
0.291113168,
-0.7717776299,
0.7026840448,
0.4966039956,
-0.0688768104,
1.0919151306,
-0.0558385588,
0.4626172483,
-0.2217525244,
0.3065020144,
-0.5189397335,
-0.5368673205,
-1.0157555342,
0.112135388,
0.4066314101,
0.6914657354,
-0.5390995145,
0.5183489323,
-0.192453593,
-0.6500185132,
-0.7486798167,
0.0970343426,
-0.3090846539,
0.5181342959,
0.6908539534,
0.0150301373,
-0.869191885,
-1.2547520399,
-0.4113685489,
0.1292493641,
-0.5427694917,
-0.0456269421,
0.2290032208,
-0.406304419,
1.1936100721,
-0.583491087,
-0.1053552404,
-0.6589984298,
0.3370776176,
0.4888952672,
0.3565827906,
0.4261738956,
-0.9762794971,
-0.4831151962,
0.0510794073,
-0.8063161969,
0.0628862903,
-0.374096483,
0.2943631113,
-0.1491148621,
0.5779308081,
-0.8169744611,
0.2770679295,
0.4136301279,
0.0428509042,
0.2515690625,
0.1598564684,
-0.442519933,
-1.1821197271,
-0.3509078324,
0.2219919264,
-0.1837627143,
-1.0481425524,
0.126172021,
-0.18202281,
-0.2066177577,
-0.4790597558,
0.3384799063,
-0.1674872041,
0.1868132055,
-0.5477438569,
0.0255740825,
0.1010632142,
0.3719243407,
0.1621776074,
0.3864905834,
0.5353476405,
-0.818910718,
0.3211834729,
0.3405252695,
-0.2707646787,
0.2377066016,
-0.6836998463,
0.2714945376,
-0.5202783346,
0.1100059226,
-0.7452594042,
0.0315496624,
0.1242199317,
-0.5237180591,
0.6574782133,
-0.159625724,
-0.3403190672,
-0.5122921467,
0.1160831079,
-0.1169269085,
0.7952401638,
-0.6376805902,
0.9716216922,
0.4052627981,
-0.1382104456,
-0.7116300464,
-0.8109387159,
0.2009730935,
-0.3053968251,
-0.4939818382,
0.7854911089,
0.3590307236,
-0.3560657501,
-0.0600258075,
0.0487558022,
-0.3679197729,
0.2763294876,
0.0815581903,
0.0253457651,
-0.5121272206,
0.327167958,
-0.1555625945,
-0.6551392674,
0.1726063192,
-0.2137639374,
0.5421439409,
-0.2206916362,
0.0602989458,
-0.476028651,
0.3151207864,
0.1573165953,
-0.1510560662,
0.7205300927,
0.8279447556,
-0.2774483263,
-0.3116429746,
-0.5136752725,
-0.3086390793,
-0.5500269532,
0.464546293,
-0.0991268754,
-0.6741855741,
0.1886601001,
-0.1841579378,
0.3354014158,
0.7536514401,
0.4474259913,
-0.284656018,
0.9151515961,
1.4348351955,
-0.1428450793,
0.4350460172,
-0.365624398,
0.6327262521,
-0.6600982547,
-0.0048816595,
-0.9199301004,
-0.4144581854,
-0.9230126739,
-0.2402151972,
-0.3911549449,
0.0803255066,
-0.2387979925,
0.7887663245,
-0.6922212243,
0.4778167605,
0.5470426679,
-0.3713763356,
0.2500129342,
-0.0301941466,
0.1826772839,
-0.1273385435,
-0.5481577516,
-0.8677489161,
0.8757299781,
0.8161456585,
0.6612279415,
-0.1457672417,
0.3288337588,
0.2862433493,
0.431645602,
-1.0148061514,
0.2506125867,
-0.0982187614,
-0.5019302964,
-0.1569888294,
-0.1839286983,
-0.9178749323,
0.121743001,
-0.276352495,
-0.5652622581,
0.0568645112,
-0.0556717813,
-0.1552128643,
0.5412154198,
-0.7857183814,
0.658524096,
-0.2291933,
0.1989262402,
0.0903044641,
-0.7357336283,
0.1660279632,
-0.0035553812,
0.0566609576,
0.1250639558,
-0.0033456087,
0.4476267397,
0.2132998854,
0.7839237452,
-0.0178169981,
-0.0162375942,
0.360881865,
-0.2630068362,
0.1659651101,
-0.1362714171,
0.0338098891,
0.2410900146,
-0.3497914076,
-0.1533820927,
-0.9083355665,
0.081990011,
-0.5917836428,
-0.5335247517,
-0.2477026582,
-0.5433360338,
-0.2450412214,
0.1833328754,
0.2954763174,
0.0984423608,
-0.3110381663,
0.4435884655,
0.6978727579,
-0.4086186588,
0.6791308522,
0.2534061074,
-0.2999539077,
-0.1156513318,
0.4823018312,
-0.1989900917,
0.210939303,
0.8166378736,
0.1737807244,
-0.3355778754,
-0.492116034,
-0.1209214181,
-0.0787788853,
-0.8606187105,
-0.0806744546,
-1.0220242739,
-0.4317813516,
-0.3812994957,
-0.1615179032,
-0.4706581533,
-0.5105288625,
-0.0836218521,
-0.4188990891,
0.2151753753,
0.9296382666,
0.348592639,
0.7187067866,
-0.7463924289,
0.5185310841,
0.3748005033,
0.2648876011,
0.0171659663,
-0.4166380167,
-0.1857118309,
0.0408765338,
-0.745225668,
-0.7274140716,
0.5415889621,
0.1445817798,
0.6403484941,
0.5042958856,
-0.1751087159,
0.1479783952,
-0.7645500898,
0.8674739599,
0.1800699681,
-0.7803710103,
0.3707861304,
-0.0673061088,
0.1349068433,
0.4553412795,
0.593862474,
-0.6930546165,
-0.1371771693,
-0.811548233,
-0.8017940521,
0.4013649225,
0.4467676878,
0.5294764042,
0.1676527411,
0.2977963686,
0.2473929375,
0.1981123537,
-0.8084737659,
-0.5670203567,
-0.3617790341,
-0.4709205031,
-0.2931224108,
-0.1049441621,
0.2274431586,
-0.4372434914,
0.3612777591,
-0.0712380111,
0.4827221632,
-0.095363602,
-0.2374467403,
0.0947388411,
0.5339984894,
0.4316674769,
0.2498800457,
-0.1866286844,
0.1660262346,
0.3404477835,
-0.4193467498,
-0.0246804785,
-0.0132250758,
-0.2088022977,
0.2895974219,
0.3196852505,
0.8707752228,
0.4162691832,
-0.2984040976,
0.2221626043,
-0.2393229157,
-0.2288928926,
-0.6053597331,
-0.0732039362,
0.1279096156,
0.1740952581,
0.6648049355,
0.6798772812,
0.0955460593,
-0.543902576,
0.4269848764,
0.1994437426,
-0.8269523382,
-0.4142507911,
0.5489699244,
0.1351348311,
-0.8020055294,
0.6872407198,
0.1619042158,
-0.5600838065,
0.5922129154,
0.5210947394,
1.2330713272,
-0.174891606,
0.2314497828,
0.130807057,
0.5338503718,
0.0817508325,
-0.3743568361,
-0.1633272767,
-0.8786816597,
-0.5979757905,
-0.6384299994,
-0.6269578934,
0.2117001563,
-0.7087781429,
0.546903491,
-0.3956957757,
-0.0765943304,
0.3170083165,
-0.2476375848,
-0.9314064384,
0.0556574687,
0.2047915906,
1.0494287014,
-0.7225785255,
0.5758855939,
0.3886084855,
-0.3718934655,
-0.363517642,
-0.0132962037,
-0.2605148256,
-0.5358240008,
0.8026088476,
0.4668833315,
0.2549085617,
0.1376330554,
-0.4398741126,
-0.7644898295,
0.5690271258,
0.0101414947,
-0.2905309498,
-0.3704927564,
0.5071484447,
0.7361581326,
-0.3774697483,
0.4452146888,
0.7438675761,
0.5958067179,
-0.3406166434,
-0.4231506884,
-0.5187219381,
-0.0883503407,
-0.0850410238,
0.2510764599,
-0.0676206723,
0.6905195117,
0.105838351,
-0.3211697936,
0.0641027391,
0.9063031077,
-0.4225470424,
0.2224868834,
0.3129992783,
0.485123843,
0.3874074817,
-0.3412091434,
1.1132440567,
-0.182497561,
0.4398351014,
1.1013448238,
-0.0430216268,
0.6995700598,
0.3845896721,
-0.3751288652,
0.5809043646,
0.2494273335,
-0.4539442956,
0.2635916173,
-0.0019581032,
-0.0741450861,
-0.0388637073,
-0.0006180255,
-0.2351472676,
0.6777347326,
0.5095618963,
-0.6301427484,
-0.4893761277,
0.2094895393,
-0.3273061514,
0.2447506189,
-0.0509575903,
0.9563834667,
0.2798185647,
-0.3463486731,
0.083066605,
0.0779253691,
0.9221041799,
-0.3997344673,
-0.2281874269,
0.0992977545,
0.18481493,
-0.0869356021,
-0.7625079751,
0.8294138312,
-0.0017722367,
-0.500959456,
-0.6707009673,
0.82614398,
0.0680629909,
-0.6159976125,
0.1626930684,
0.2710608244,
-0.1839628667,
-0.1350991875,
-0.7355642915,
-0.3793052733,
-0.1954206526,
-0.1184428036,
-0.1082419604,
0.3411172032,
0.3726881742,
0.730606854,
0.4742298424,
-0.1368216276,
0.1947129667,
0.1142616421,
0.4617190063,
-1.0030077696,
-0.0779362395,
-0.7943898439,
0.5737828612,
-0.0651988983,
-0.1623930037,
0.7227246165,
0.2980975211,
0.7673334479,
-0.2094804645,
0.7732004523,
0.1560899764,
0.8274114132,
-0.384778142,
0.5704628229,
-0.0115432497,
0.1929664314,
-0.182769075,
-1.0914185047,
-0.5180063844,
0.7114451528,
-0.1841291338,
-0.1714165211,
0.6223275065,
0.3241938353,
-0.117351532,
0.3851317465,
0.0837894082,
0.1152516678,
0.4709403515,
0.116433464,
1.155919075,
-0.8144028783,
0.4053885937,
-0.5652509332,
0.2740359902,
-0.01265983,
-0.8381633759,
-0.7125623822,
-0.5259605646,
-0.1442100555,
0.0139783975,
-0.4836928248,
0.6521231532,
0.7505448461,
-0.8784641623,
-0.102125667,
-0.564001143,
0.285534054,
-0.3844081759,
-0.3532312512,
0.0778496936,
-0.7801545262,
-0.8615674973,
0.376961261,
0.2482334375,
0.1294908971,
-0.2935213447,
0.2334289104,
-0.0807091519,
0.1573216766,
0.7558792233,
0.2409315556,
-0.626414597,
-0.1564290673,
0.2609220743,
0.1414578557,
0.3710643947,
0.9521753788,
-1.0868709087,
0.0770281479,
0.4739604592,
1.0243251324,
0.3988017142,
-0.1527178138,
0.7440345287,
-0.7687302828,
0.397903651,
0.561339438,
0.3240804672,
0.4283776879,
-0.1136549637,
0.5175036788,
0.0831713304,
-0.4629453421,
-0.78282094,
0.4913553894,
-1.0267030001,
-0.2440167814,
0.6075765491,
0.4855452478,
-0.0793905929,
-0.4069737792,
-0.0969746411,
0.2713282704,
0.1663871706,
0.7199186087,
0.5125971437,
0.1301101744,
-0.4656675756,
-0.855096221,
0.5448736548,
0.3615317643,
-0.6469528079,
-0.1360280663,
-0.235385865,
0.0027975193,
0.4181717336,
-0.1451624483,
-0.0998200849,
-0.2311026454,
-0.0665515661,
0.1080421209,
0.3732987344,
-0.3790599406,
-0.3662841916,
0.3726975024,
-0.1072171032,
0.0642798617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17593v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17593v1
|
LanGWM: Language Grounded World Model
| 2023-11-29T12:41:55 | 2023-11-29T12:41:55 |
Rudra P. K. Poudel, Harit Pandya, Chao Zhang, Roberto Cipolla
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.RO
|
Recent advances in deep reinforcement learning have showcased its potential
in tackling complex tasks. However, experiments on visual control tasks have
revealed that state-of-the-art reinforcement learning models struggle with
out-of-distribution generalization. Conversely, expressing higher-level
concepts and global contexts is relatively easy using language.
Building upon recent success of the large language models, our main objective
is to improve the state abstraction technique in reinforcement learning by
leveraging language for robust action selection. Specifically, we focus on
learning language-grounded visual features to enhance the world model learning,
a model-based reinforcement learning technique.
To enforce our hypothesis explicitly, we mask out the bounding boxes of a few
objects in the image observation and provide the text prompt as descriptions
for these masked objects. Subsequently, we predict the masked objects along
with the surrounding regions as pixel reconstruction, similar to the
transformer-based masked autoencoder approach.
Our proposed LanGWM: Language Grounded World Model achieves state-of-the-art
performance in out-of-distribution test at the 100K interaction steps
benchmarks of iGibson point navigation tasks. Furthermore, our proposed
technique of explicit language-grounded visual representation learning has the
potential to improve models for human-robot interaction because our extracted
visual features are language grounded.
|
[
-0.3774537146,
-1.0152540207,
0.4874928296,
0.1830975264,
-0.0849787816,
0.2141418308,
-0.0818871781,
-0.1769824475,
-0.2084264159,
0.730453372,
-0.490949899,
-0.5909892917,
-0.7797086239,
-0.3413592577,
-0.0239573643,
0.6721134186,
-0.1685252935,
-0.1589975208,
-0.1048479751,
-0.2529665828,
-0.4481303394,
-0.4520075917,
-0.5053254366,
-0.819760859,
0.1662924588,
0.2314629704,
0.8418737054,
0.4553132355,
0.2682935297,
0.3119210005,
-0.1441477537,
0.1860334426,
-0.5381371975,
0.0102421921,
-0.4070221782,
-0.1348565519,
-0.2870313823,
0.0928908661,
0.4149397314,
0.7539415359,
-0.1659118235,
-0.2145891488,
-0.1145877242,
0.5437187552,
-0.7199054956,
0.7005842328,
-0.5096693039,
0.394521594,
0.6056826115,
0.0440720804,
-0.3957097232,
0.0710120499,
0.0970552266,
-0.7098050714,
-0.0540882759,
0.297137022,
0.9985021353,
0.2591893971,
-0.4268804789,
0.0874387771,
-0.7742346525,
0.7651686072,
-0.4290500283,
0.3555105031,
0.4005403817,
0.460269779,
-0.4855907857,
-0.4437225759,
-0.457090497,
-0.474951297,
-0.0094113452,
0.3136818707,
-0.1653506309,
0.4645965993,
0.5299872756,
0.234061271,
-0.4430294037,
0.1525181234,
-0.0649333894,
-0.1238587722,
0.6056995392,
0.0506283157,
0.4491822124,
-0.1100545079,
-0.5694227219,
-0.5060177445,
-0.6988820434,
0.4024318755,
0.0795197487,
0.1932499707,
-0.2346463948,
0.463003695,
-0.3923248947,
0.6580302119,
-0.1993756592,
-0.3115554452,
-0.1307196915,
0.2698279917,
-0.4498148561,
-0.2590118945,
0.6571099162,
0.4080240726,
0.2076965123,
-0.100468494,
-0.3444032669,
0.0524802133,
0.2548139989,
-0.7946069241,
-0.3098636568,
0.0057294196,
-0.553773284,
-0.3271576762,
0.3053094149,
-0.5578182936,
-0.3974889815,
-0.3509931862,
0.4202201366,
-0.4427932501,
-0.5415896177,
0.3416637182,
-0.1544958353,
0.3348265588,
0.2825962901,
-0.8164232373,
0.5817058682,
0.4394123256,
0.4125584364,
-0.1768168211,
-0.3808183372,
-0.8232574463,
0.1589811742,
-0.4207548797,
0.472694546,
-0.5757904649,
-0.2789759934,
0.2098542601,
0.1766817421,
0.0761660859,
-0.5615326166,
0.139571324,
-0.6327018738,
0.0239655934,
-0.0823533535,
-0.4994725585,
-0.6666478515,
0.4590444863,
-0.5793004632,
1.0117845535,
0.1600281,
-0.2362480611,
0.5555630326,
-0.6152924895,
-0.4386346936,
0.0046061226,
-0.270416677,
-0.4712388813,
0.0093088821,
0.5114173293,
0.7272621393,
-0.0035731217,
0.5996421576,
-0.3824060857,
-0.4935152531,
0.2112275362,
-0.4087349176,
0.2521815896,
0.228726536,
-0.6257916689,
0.3875814974,
-0.6691417694,
-0.0304046273,
0.1709646732,
-0.2699206471,
-0.2455919832,
0.229522422,
0.0995179638,
0.5726329088,
-0.1488648355,
-0.2406917959,
0.104261525,
-0.4518465698,
0.2365991026,
0.4894828498,
0.2214234769,
0.607157588,
0.000904708,
0.750825882,
-0.0017060227,
0.1084628925,
-0.298042208,
-0.292622298,
-0.7433062792,
-0.4307595789,
0.0322534442,
0.6048493981,
-0.9168602824,
0.6896538734,
-0.1055789068,
-0.0524677783,
-0.1258070022,
0.0642670095,
0.6413787603,
0.3291729987,
0.454357177,
-0.2290193439,
-0.4203899205,
-0.8476658463,
-0.1824978888,
-0.2315792739,
0.0871443152,
0.2244614512,
0.5534948111,
-0.2931554019,
0.9238747954,
-0.4758790135,
-0.1258464754,
-0.6944378614,
0.1381309181,
-0.123278752,
0.361552,
0.1990652233,
-0.9244659543,
-0.2619457245,
0.0509879962,
-0.9328756332,
0.2159181535,
-0.1197818071,
-0.1873907447,
-0.0655348226,
0.8902564049,
-0.4863506258,
0.6947581172,
0.4538396895,
-0.3528673649,
-0.0911940262,
-0.3418175578,
0.0910534337,
-0.8256882429,
-0.0465624221,
0.0551643856,
-0.5271129012,
-0.3985812962,
0.4164865315,
0.1201467589,
-0.5753079057,
-0.556032896,
0.8291392922,
-0.5290840268,
-0.254935056,
-0.4529647827,
0.0629353449,
-0.0226019267,
0.8654838204,
0.427223593,
0.384072721,
0.7879986763,
-0.8494997621,
0.113279745,
0.1210598126,
-0.2996095419,
0.2751747966,
-0.4699159265,
-0.2016203403,
-0.2067671865,
0.175937295,
-0.9137511253,
-0.2367738932,
0.1691456884,
-0.0823202133,
0.4339690506,
-0.2690903842,
-0.2715575695,
-0.1430238783,
-0.0299298707,
0.1438491195,
0.9348684549,
-0.6636641622,
0.6508684158,
0.4628068209,
0.2550560534,
-0.4650267363,
-0.356841743,
0.0116880434,
-0.246806249,
-0.2044575661,
0.1252378374,
0.171082288,
-0.431402266,
-0.1787593067,
-0.1509447098,
0.1971496493,
0.3779900074,
0.4268467724,
0.0746365711,
0.2016470432,
0.0230129361,
0.0299648382,
-0.2804550231,
0.1417447478,
-0.1825920045,
0.4354013801,
-0.1776141673,
-0.5346499681,
0.0060911663,
0.2835770845,
0.4046137631,
-0.3187897503,
0.5001171827,
0.4901152551,
-0.3662736714,
-0.3426306248,
-0.220874548,
-0.1509473473,
-0.4925654233,
0.6755264401,
-0.3155811429,
-0.8095175624,
0.3269833326,
-0.52839607,
0.011740231,
0.0074854214,
0.211684674,
-0.1628941745,
1.2351588011,
0.9162871242,
-0.1736459136,
0.6252114773,
-0.4379960299,
0.2913979292,
-0.4881663024,
-0.3200043142,
0.0321256444,
-0.1896923482,
-0.4260701537,
-0.5977803469,
0.2740755379,
0.4798367023,
-0.4036663473,
0.0263160467,
-0.1446565986,
0.4093854427,
0.3870276809,
0.2468904257,
0.0514720604,
0.3696679473,
-0.5052662492,
-0.1724470109,
-0.8290892839,
-0.5281947851,
0.5751841068,
0.5406743884,
0.9824234843,
-0.1052016467,
0.6295488477,
0.2534431815,
0.2633351684,
-0.8551733494,
0.7689518332,
0.178347379,
-0.0303520449,
-0.2942035794,
-0.0406928957,
-0.9660291672,
0.6842131615,
-0.2296954989,
-0.5386145711,
-0.1351504326,
0.1786878109,
0.0233641118,
0.4084921479,
-0.422711879,
0.9196330905,
-0.2331914306,
-0.2881505191,
-0.1734053642,
-0.6415190697,
0.3709048331,
0.5838251114,
0.3754068315,
-0.2187659442,
0.0347214751,
0.2566372156,
-0.3697198629,
0.9686647654,
-0.3369256556,
-0.2698657513,
0.1755404174,
0.3185676038,
0.6843751073,
0.1236020997,
0.4074284732,
-0.0026916291,
-0.6537870169,
-0.4297744334,
-0.7110559344,
0.3854121566,
-0.6810526252,
-0.4053676128,
-0.4362108111,
-0.4925223589,
-0.3769879341,
0.0343535617,
0.0633494556,
0.3712345958,
-0.5913952589,
0.0122613888,
1.0386644602,
-0.46208781,
0.6803514957,
0.5952836871,
-0.6938434839,
-0.4234202504,
0.9526444077,
-0.4538810551,
0.4204641283,
0.6477558017,
0.0473877527,
-0.2890727818,
-0.3659920096,
-0.4158832133,
-0.0671712682,
-0.9117181897,
0.0771537572,
-0.565243721,
-0.1877715439,
0.1497028172,
-0.2694465816,
-0.2692593634,
0.0058643986,
-0.0469597876,
-0.4012682438,
0.2959958911,
0.6993262768,
0.1756908149,
0.1044077948,
-0.4061072767,
0.6815811992,
0.4138035476,
0.2087588161,
-0.1506673992,
-0.3802854121,
-0.0718394741,
-0.1029700115,
-0.1892084479,
-0.579202354,
0.4532105327,
0.1084912494,
0.6829686165,
0.2503166497,
-0.1149398685,
0.7400494814,
-0.4526460469,
0.7065566778,
0.3267474174,
-0.7640652657,
0.8244971633,
-0.3915344775,
0.4810578525,
0.1577236652,
0.1012914479,
-0.5178791881,
-0.7070495486,
-0.9158292413,
-0.8939857483,
0.5206604004,
0.0349068604,
0.1740337163,
-0.0660497621,
0.1362614036,
0.0448479541,
0.2562536299,
-1.0531599522,
-0.1851718128,
-0.2668117285,
-0.0840532929,
-0.2310117334,
-0.1482657641,
-0.0952709094,
-0.1816838086,
0.5380844474,
-0.5354597569,
0.1002799571,
-0.0148781706,
-0.4844946861,
-0.1147918478,
0.3335953951,
0.5092325807,
0.4704507291,
-0.022569472,
0.1344741881,
0.1180580407,
-0.2515558302,
0.3414640725,
-0.0823909864,
-0.3494050205,
-0.1489242911,
0.4153462648,
1.2612637281,
0.6253176332,
-0.9749692678,
0.5691975355,
0.0332524329,
-0.3284247518,
-0.2357481569,
0.4048538506,
-0.0927679837,
0.2118991762,
0.2390048802,
0.1675389558,
0.0488080382,
-0.5876613259,
0.1782776862,
0.5011484027,
-0.6789670587,
-0.150970906,
0.5996643901,
0.0270308983,
-0.1103010103,
0.4296144247,
-0.3493187129,
-0.5702236295,
0.6364783645,
0.5114856958,
0.870685637,
0.1085903719,
0.3742748201,
0.4407101572,
0.3557434082,
-0.3747902513,
0.6068726182,
-0.0312045664,
-0.6414391398,
-0.419475019,
-0.4883600175,
-0.3240931332,
0.2928558886,
-0.7580144405,
0.2034720182,
-0.6279844642,
0.2706734538,
-0.9326173067,
-0.229884997,
-0.6321610212,
0.4029380381,
0.2487956285,
0.5952452421,
-1.0679738522,
0.7268216014,
0.8157081604,
-0.437438786,
-0.8451074958,
0.0923991576,
-0.3131090105,
-0.7611222863,
0.8067144752,
0.2163833678,
-0.2612311542,
-0.0385757722,
-0.6509530544,
-0.93301934,
0.9879680276,
0.4196244478,
-0.3519993126,
0.3967779875,
-0.1784825623,
0.4618656039,
-0.4424956739,
0.1265860051,
0.3717045486,
0.3287696838,
-0.0076358961,
-0.5888952017,
0.1050651819,
-0.1142127737,
0.5025026798,
0.1655757725,
-0.6132885814,
0.5880479813,
-0.2036198825,
-0.0393008776,
-0.1199407205,
0.8866761327,
0.5700329542,
-0.0593756288,
0.5600107908,
0.5006828904,
0.5642402768,
-0.0117554618,
1.1124120951,
0.0574084073,
0.4085002244,
0.7739970088,
-0.3541616797,
0.8847759366,
0.3489177525,
0.0186714474,
0.6642437577,
0.5378805995,
0.2509940863,
0.8642975688,
0.3056370914,
-0.1733776182,
-0.4860136211,
-0.0219927449,
-0.0532297753,
0.4325289726,
0.3901337385,
-0.1828000396,
-0.3763769567,
0.4160239697,
-0.1142546162,
0.3952135146,
-0.4471930265,
0.9189831018,
0.0811366439,
-0.8180514574,
0.611061275,
0.1029969305,
0.5926402807,
-0.6221300364,
-0.5712553263,
-0.3077167571,
0.1994813681,
0.0978958011,
-0.5164472461,
-0.1548537612,
-0.2439089715,
-0.1047857329,
-0.6419103742,
0.9988285899,
-0.6699655652,
-0.2866535187,
0.5051252842,
0.4447584152,
0.0934635624,
-0.0136000421,
-0.8545025587,
0.1398702264,
-0.1805836409,
-0.2213020325,
0.5432875752,
0.3342518806,
-0.3511708379,
0.9658465385,
0.3854127824,
-0.1035032794,
0.0210673958,
0.2070571929,
0.6446899772,
-0.8245201707,
-0.8130959272,
-0.7109375,
0.6832363605,
-0.1318574846,
-0.0499656312,
0.5700199604,
0.3182171881,
0.7095518708,
-0.2738763392,
0.832105577,
-0.031841632,
0.1420738101,
-1.0425019264,
0.4729570746,
-0.4722345173,
0.0690218881,
-0.2922763228,
-0.7612511516,
-0.1502643079,
0.7825647593,
-0.0546660349,
0.1506022215,
0.7562702894,
0.6712704301,
-0.249131158,
-0.4609912634,
0.778870821,
-0.1122870967,
0.3998456597,
0.4957784116,
1.0335663557,
-0.5251147151,
0.3139432073,
-0.1962564439,
-0.0539810807,
-0.2652485669,
-1.0385711193,
-1.1589905024,
-0.3498744369,
-0.4354205132,
-0.2438879758,
-0.0115563972,
0.9835196137,
0.9627969265,
-0.6954525113,
-0.310963124,
-0.5380399227,
0.1140437946,
-0.6227076054,
-0.2092733383,
0.1181570143,
-0.4751493037,
-0.6034007668,
0.7275595069,
0.5551392436,
0.1257503927,
-0.4521858394,
-0.5997661352,
-0.0147561179,
-0.3074925542,
0.7597408295,
0.5007232428,
-1.1371752024,
-0.3043712974,
-0.1726599783,
-0.1580974162,
0.0477932617,
0.9144800305,
-0.9139724374,
0.5149744153,
0.074168399,
0.5707750916,
0.6003261805,
-0.0448175967,
0.8878412843,
-1.005782485,
0.658115387,
0.1350446939,
0.5753117204,
0.3388049006,
-0.1991689652,
0.4283067286,
0.1061637774,
-0.0627128258,
-0.5288258791,
0.4213218391,
-0.7890366316,
-0.4555030465,
1.3516682386,
-0.2100131959,
-0.1994242221,
-0.1837061048,
-0.4726275504,
0.0307525452,
-0.2370209247,
0.5162348747,
0.6087539792,
0.1138791293,
-0.5393379331,
-0.755289197,
0.6743143201,
0.4169611037,
-0.8134073615,
0.0118730236,
0.531357944,
0.2582850754,
-0.2432671934,
0.5300146341,
0.1617453992,
0.3193552494,
-0.1193885952,
0.4494239986,
0.0293815155,
-0.4658713639,
-0.5947531462,
0.1645821184,
0.4250500798,
-0.1637115031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17514v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17514v1
|
Reinforcement Replaces Supervision: Query focused Summarization using Deep Reinforcement Learning
| 2023-11-29T10:38:16 | 2023-11-29T10:38:16 |
Swaroop Nath, Harshad Khadilkar, Pushpak Bhattacharyya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Query-focused Summarization (QfS) deals with systems that generate summaries
from document(s) based on a query. Motivated by the insight that Reinforcement
Learning (RL) provides a generalization to Supervised Learning (SL) for Natural
Language Generation, and thereby performs better (empirically) than SL, we use
an RL-based approach for this task of QfS. Additionally, we also resolve the
conflict of employing RL in Transformers with Teacher Forcing. We develop
multiple Policy Gradient networks, trained on various reward signals: ROUGE,
BLEU, and Semantic Similarity, which lead to a 10-point improvement over the
State-of-the-Art approach on the ROUGE-L metric for a benchmark dataset (ELI5).
We also show performance of our approach in zero-shot setting for another
benchmark dataset (DebatePedia) -- our approach leads to results comparable to
baselines, which were specifically trained on DebatePedia. To aid the RL
training, we propose a better semantic similarity reward, enabled by a novel
Passage Embedding scheme developed using Cluster Hypothesis. Lastly, we
contribute a gold-standard test dataset to further research in QfS and
Long-form Question Answering (LfQA).
|
[
-0.4624080062,
-0.8718550205,
0.4100541472,
0.2614119649,
-0.18573834,
0.2324837446,
-0.3141381145,
-0.0008708278,
0.4114537537,
0.7454370856,
-0.7835626006,
-0.4477060437,
-0.3592813611,
0.1427483559,
-0.4743304551,
1.5240014791,
0.0460337065,
0.0297067724,
-0.3792681992,
-0.1177791953,
-0.2461836785,
-0.2263064235,
-0.8950619102,
-0.4740741551,
0.9250909686,
0.3867697716,
0.5109432936,
0.397964716,
0.341918081,
0.2413280904,
-0.1284983903,
0.5717884302,
-0.7508196831,
0.4139555693,
-0.3186649084,
-0.3750876486,
-0.1673996747,
-0.1160502136,
0.6343712211,
0.6480855346,
-0.3077169657,
-0.1671099514,
0.0192061923,
1.0182152987,
-0.6992246509,
0.1175721958,
-0.3437826037,
0.3389588892,
0.2778100669,
-0.3730232418,
-0.3819397986,
-0.5683777928,
0.0782281905,
-0.8490086198,
0.3210171759,
0.0015170522,
0.7875765562,
0.3487459421,
-0.7249832153,
-0.2706854939,
-0.5954021811,
0.6129332781,
-0.6372863054,
0.0929408893,
0.2769955397,
0.3488357663,
-0.3004568219,
-1.016530633,
-0.4527064562,
-0.2072157711,
-0.2757127583,
0.3855444491,
0.2061362714,
0.2507725656,
0.2073034793,
0.4755780101,
-0.7439562678,
0.0110666305,
-0.5465982556,
-0.054225456,
0.9149543047,
0.4270198941,
-0.1396297812,
-0.0540029146,
-0.3540380001,
-0.5074641705,
-0.7074393034,
0.3168940246,
0.3123662472,
0.3954430223,
0.284080863,
0.3344599009,
-0.78381145,
0.5318506956,
0.2131670266,
-0.0006659005,
0.2070370466,
-0.4009565711,
-0.2602081895,
0.1016161889,
0.9986251593,
0.5598345399,
0.4613738358,
-0.190718025,
-0.252566278,
-0.253905654,
0.4803533852,
-0.786724627,
-0.2551645041,
0.0274383277,
-0.1844270378,
-0.4657896161,
0.1210120469,
-0.5488131046,
-0.4235728383,
-0.3628480732,
0.2138376832,
-0.2186922133,
-0.2022625506,
0.1750230789,
-0.3497202396,
0.3840508759,
0.2771771252,
-1.1488448381,
0.6435495615,
0.8290047646,
0.530938983,
-0.4268192351,
-0.39132002,
-0.822193265,
0.1695345938,
-0.4841481447,
0.7157954574,
-0.2047941089,
-0.4978217483,
0.2687547207,
0.0554493777,
-0.1091038063,
-0.5993995667,
0.3282172084,
-0.6459182501,
0.6055423617,
-0.1666637808,
-0.6634070873,
-0.0797409043,
0.5572147369,
-0.659766078,
1.1298373938,
0.0070618577,
-0.5763778687,
0.4730891883,
-0.488650918,
-0.6693185568,
-0.1821001768,
-0.1594984382,
-0.555341363,
-0.1524186134,
0.5258179903,
0.4237541556,
0.1165433154,
0.463839978,
-0.075046204,
-0.4905460477,
0.3132283688,
-0.2538770735,
0.3330146968,
-0.0064837751,
-0.155137524,
0.593072176,
-0.4949917495,
-0.0115033183,
0.066210106,
-0.3269841373,
-0.2397036403,
0.0873722881,
-0.1882366538,
0.1893479377,
-0.0504170582,
-0.3767322004,
0.3402773142,
-0.6733835936,
0.3072596788,
0.5802138448,
0.5040134788,
0.5691577792,
-0.2981924713,
0.6009728312,
0.0085702939,
0.2027581185,
-0.3198991716,
-0.0002065072,
-0.7027325034,
0.0155117745,
0.1343173087,
0.3821875453,
-0.9918836951,
-0.0940207317,
-0.3213027418,
-0.1974580437,
-0.3428890705,
0.0645840764,
0.6259127259,
0.6218267083,
0.5329650044,
-0.2584867477,
-0.3208276033,
-0.931063354,
-0.3325457871,
-0.0121465372,
0.0662457719,
0.1957936436,
0.4121043086,
0.3142395616,
0.891305089,
-0.7861267924,
-0.4043574035,
-0.4159726501,
0.2044340819,
0.1701811105,
0.4347736537,
0.2800124586,
-0.8486600518,
-0.4507501125,
-0.294028461,
-0.7041315436,
0.3353472948,
-0.3117852509,
0.0544294156,
0.1768435538,
0.9320124388,
-0.5488727689,
0.2129481137,
0.0246921089,
-0.2971731424,
0.5407520533,
-0.2080443799,
0.1326898932,
-1.0471919775,
-0.2522803843,
-0.0339242071,
-0.3703783453,
-0.473821789,
0.0599255674,
0.0462796651,
-0.0654141456,
-0.4905395508,
0.4854426086,
-0.1470750272,
-0.1013847589,
-0.370328784,
0.3591828346,
0.1615603417,
0.9187787771,
0.1316493899,
0.8463752866,
0.1770790517,
-0.7487187982,
0.6077484488,
0.3162761927,
-0.0759204701,
0.456404835,
-0.8187229037,
-0.1593929678,
-0.2223250568,
0.5950826406,
-0.7159605026,
-0.1456811279,
0.3748936653,
-0.5395067334,
0.2818427384,
0.0879525766,
-0.2007880509,
-0.2376046628,
-0.7067424059,
0.1306457818,
0.3280004263,
-0.449090153,
0.141671598,
0.1193971708,
-0.3445378244,
-0.9747416377,
-0.5761537552,
0.068542704,
-0.1423726678,
-0.1815055907,
0.5221236348,
0.3110380471,
-0.0165906232,
0.3058673441,
-0.0272491369,
-0.0440441743,
0.2427399158,
0.1024363488,
-0.0256155636,
-0.2105065584,
0.5289051533,
0.3021932542,
-0.089153409,
0.3569323123,
-0.311845839,
0.2266218513,
-0.0777488276,
-0.2593860626,
-0.2258640081,
0.3963510692,
0.1568795741,
-0.5155301094,
0.6656894684,
0.5864540935,
0.1000178978,
-0.6388856769,
-0.1519297361,
-0.4975555837,
-0.4362914264,
0.4626445472,
-0.0860505104,
-1.2568562031,
0.1891642362,
-0.0881060958,
0.2596564293,
0.4203207493,
0.2718247771,
-0.1979282945,
0.8653971553,
0.6281715631,
-0.1671656221,
0.7113171816,
-0.3209839165,
0.0484309718,
-0.6896944642,
-0.4288372397,
-0.2121438384,
-0.2272302061,
-0.5898514986,
-0.0794430897,
0.3486738205,
0.0627382696,
-0.321593076,
0.0454718545,
-0.4654098749,
0.393684864,
0.7679556012,
0.0751711726,
0.3131858706,
-0.0857196674,
-0.0041699545,
0.1726176888,
-0.7699471116,
-0.1029872149,
1.2027978897,
0.1085491553,
0.6823747754,
-0.0274925847,
1.0706825256,
0.568343997,
0.0792613551,
-0.7090042233,
0.5906109214,
0.1719963104,
-0.1664728224,
-0.773262918,
-0.4892747402,
-1.1504769325,
0.5012167692,
-0.2943903208,
-0.2350129336,
-0.1860612929,
0.0377041809,
-0.4094690382,
-0.0757996663,
-0.4763089716,
0.8069434762,
0.0036382165,
-0.5079123378,
-0.5112615228,
-0.6277678013,
0.5672804117,
0.5438546538,
-0.1662449837,
0.1249094531,
-0.0490023233,
0.7390403152,
-0.4023795426,
0.6691257358,
-0.1776833683,
0.0291678999,
0.2629953325,
-0.20510225,
0.4270707667,
0.2173867226,
0.2526707947,
-0.7528928518,
-0.0129660387,
-0.4471339881,
-0.9958760142,
0.5205461383,
-0.4809297025,
-0.6200291514,
-0.4989325106,
-0.5881604552,
-0.415178597,
0.0308104474,
-0.1621379852,
0.5128044486,
-0.4222737551,
0.2195132226,
0.9894561172,
-0.1620610505,
0.5586091876,
0.5127792358,
-0.4561005533,
-0.5613556504,
1.0629763603,
-0.1719963104,
0.230647251,
0.5762246251,
-0.1023860127,
-0.5090301633,
-0.418161571,
-0.483430624,
0.1321718991,
-0.536002934,
-0.1539083123,
-0.5687610507,
-0.4403686523,
-0.526563704,
-0.0546135046,
-0.0532963686,
-0.4764981568,
-0.1132679805,
-0.4515576065,
0.4335914552,
0.6940071583,
0.0870674923,
0.1741332412,
-0.6558470726,
0.3973118663,
0.606092155,
0.1686004251,
0.0180388,
-0.3090398908,
-0.3862937987,
-0.1448054314,
-0.2927674651,
-0.7697387934,
0.3664427996,
0.2161173075,
0.5237718821,
0.3272525966,
0.3229698539,
0.2712182701,
-0.3197233677,
0.7986930013,
0.1271820366,
-0.4900717139,
0.592795074,
-0.426084578,
0.2418853939,
0.7320721149,
0.2693869472,
-0.7586462498,
-0.6674213409,
-0.6812369227,
-0.912573874,
0.5843659639,
-0.1293537468,
0.1541045308,
-0.1262454689,
0.2282857299,
-0.1878144294,
0.4822989702,
-0.4580362737,
-0.1050890684,
-0.3266011477,
-0.2546786368,
-0.2903148532,
-0.1289976239,
-0.2198600024,
-0.1457510442,
0.8046174049,
-0.52516222,
-0.1355258524,
0.3543260694,
-0.2783465683,
0.2408555746,
0.4860981107,
0.7768344283,
0.4392873049,
-0.1267514229,
0.0422634743,
0.17759341,
-0.1782147437,
0.0298865363,
0.1406291425,
-0.351100117,
-0.0892343596,
0.4352068007,
0.9587586522,
0.4316394925,
-0.7703288198,
0.664709866,
-0.1480994374,
-0.5281203389,
-0.3305002749,
0.3482504487,
0.2116041481,
0.3774232864,
0.298689276,
-0.4486045837,
0.2285724133,
-0.4788066149,
0.4528625309,
0.3427658081,
-0.648076117,
0.1969960183,
0.3826973736,
0.2451089174,
-0.0964229405,
0.7172347903,
-0.4357471764,
-0.4365292788,
0.709289968,
0.3281491101,
0.7270783186,
0.1426352113,
0.7685794234,
0.4778908491,
0.1305309385,
-0.1204326749,
0.170959428,
-0.4037432373,
-0.474953115,
-0.6639437675,
-0.3424123526,
-0.6155611277,
-0.0496159047,
-1.0249052048,
-0.2564688921,
-0.6067602038,
0.2284301966,
-0.2329297513,
0.1942338198,
-0.1449211389,
0.1749567091,
-0.0135160452,
0.8558542728,
-0.8591193557,
0.7236374021,
0.6089624763,
-0.7598745227,
-0.8898323178,
-0.0280937217,
-0.2630578876,
-0.5689530969,
0.5448235869,
-0.0066440692,
-0.0505696312,
-0.0284152906,
-0.4885936975,
-0.4772889912,
1.2842540741,
-0.0754971728,
-0.2823550999,
-0.1483007669,
0.0451695397,
0.7280744314,
-0.2478136569,
0.2171540558,
0.5188100934,
0.207103014,
0.0217288062,
-0.6434231997,
0.0668139309,
-0.1088508219,
-0.0963244885,
0.3071663082,
-0.7476890683,
0.74077034,
-0.2014298588,
-0.0454081036,
-0.1870235056,
1.044755578,
0.260747999,
0.4552769363,
0.2684467137,
0.6174746752,
0.8013853431,
-0.0338311195,
1.0264458656,
-0.045476824,
0.3094092607,
1.3922098875,
-0.1766434312,
0.7547954917,
0.5024125576,
-0.0382185578,
0.6226373911,
0.5660743713,
-0.1530191898,
0.7639368176,
0.3698948622,
-0.2794494927,
-0.1780271232,
-0.4053342044,
-0.3062487841,
0.0733578056,
0.3052724898,
-0.2976171076,
-0.5228071809,
-0.0256396737,
-0.0207421184,
0.533123672,
-0.5495752096,
1.210660696,
0.1966731697,
-1.0566735268,
0.4102520645,
-0.0524245724,
0.5473412871,
-0.7169325948,
-0.0568302199,
-0.5746288896,
0.1211700737,
-0.1757858843,
-0.97488904,
0.2082280368,
-0.2037231326,
-0.260063827,
-0.5349053741,
0.6470944881,
-0.690176487,
-0.0911235139,
0.1753328592,
0.6306447387,
-0.0747937188,
-0.0071870489,
-0.619345963,
-0.4921992421,
-0.1466810405,
-0.3954150677,
0.6152901649,
0.4089765251,
-0.077412352,
0.731044054,
0.5766854286,
-0.008406749,
-0.0437190421,
0.3523763716,
1.1104530096,
-0.754640758,
-0.7236081362,
-0.5512444377,
0.2859472334,
-0.4000504911,
-0.4355487525,
0.6193906069,
0.6227688193,
0.92518574,
-0.027268704,
0.5766680837,
0.3161988258,
0.5627580881,
-0.7601908445,
0.5291804075,
-0.536506772,
-0.0684073046,
-0.0287307277,
-0.6560531259,
-0.0690063164,
0.2170612812,
-0.2895411253,
-0.219591096,
0.8697940707,
0.9470696449,
0.1678166091,
-0.0768104121,
0.1521479338,
-0.2788348794,
0.3091062903,
0.7430716753,
1.0477497578,
-0.2548214495,
0.7076806426,
-0.1454264075,
0.2833729684,
-0.1833932549,
-0.5553206801,
-1.018794775,
-0.5069672465,
-0.198124826,
-0.3690057099,
0.4388282597,
0.7259565592,
0.3723216057,
-0.743971169,
-0.1371754855,
-0.350571841,
0.504858315,
-0.4968900084,
-0.2881188095,
0.5631906986,
-0.7108936906,
-0.4929032028,
0.5363144875,
0.2091066688,
-0.3178438246,
-0.3376054466,
-0.3242367804,
-0.2483869344,
-0.1133505851,
0.5123062134,
0.6033277512,
-0.5123217106,
-0.0805301368,
-0.0218040161,
-0.4730282724,
-0.1233284622,
0.9882045388,
-1.1492091417,
0.107719183,
0.5682717562,
1.0032975674,
0.8431791663,
0.1355303526,
0.611471951,
-0.744154036,
0.0246717576,
0.3779328763,
0.0053404113,
0.2004559189,
-0.1026551947,
0.4762971103,
0.0564250015,
-0.4238162637,
-0.6577069163,
0.3117659688,
-0.7665684819,
-0.3591162562,
1.0392792225,
-0.1758257449,
-0.1732997298,
0.0920756757,
-0.1376822442,
0.212188527,
-0.598950386,
0.6737617254,
0.3750173151,
-0.0948631763,
-0.4121357501,
-0.3783333898,
0.9113175869,
0.6364867091,
-0.8260546923,
-0.1052399725,
0.6029276252,
0.208118096,
-0.226414606,
0.8002510071,
0.1154040471,
0.391417712,
-0.1726340055,
-0.0472845063,
-0.535364151,
-0.3950264156,
-0.4938133061,
0.4338284433,
-0.0384935103,
-0.2359737009
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17502v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17502v1
|
Enhancing Answer Selection in Community Question Answering with Pre-trained and Large Language Models
| 2023-11-29T10:24:50 | 2023-11-29T10:24:50 |
Xinghang Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Community Question Answering (CQA) becomes increasingly prevalent in recent
years. However, there are a large number of answers, which is difficult for
users to select the relevant answers. Therefore, answer selection is a very
significant subtask of CQA. In this paper, we first propose the Question-Answer
cross attention networks (QAN) with pre-trained models for answer selection and
utilize large language model (LLM) to perform answer selection with knowledge
augmentation. Specifically, we apply the BERT model as the encoder layer to do
pre-training for question subjects, question bodies and answers, respectively,
then the cross attention mechanism selects the most relevant answer for
different questions. Experiments show that the QAN model achieves
state-of-the-art performance on two datasets, SemEval2015 and SemEval2017.
Moreover, we use the LLM to generate external knowledge from questions and
correct answers to achieve knowledge augmentation for the answer selection task
by LLM, while optimizing the prompt of LLM in different aspects. The results
show that the introduction of external knowledge can improve the correct answer
selection rate of LLM on datasets SemEval2015 and SemEval2017. Meanwhile, LLM
can also select the correct answer on more questions by optimized prompt.
|
[
-0.7663127184,
-0.8636401892,
0.8551523685,
-0.0870119482,
-0.2905269265,
0.1726918221,
-0.1907408237,
-0.6851085424,
0.4685711265,
0.6305701137,
-0.7704908252,
-0.0714458823,
-0.5382884145,
0.1854578853,
-0.0606461354,
0.8379117846,
0.0962088853,
0.1005852148,
-0.6399943829,
-0.1650042981,
-0.2320668548,
-0.702245295,
-0.9190847278,
-0.2385353744,
0.8928548694,
0.3501946032,
0.3597463965,
0.2657883465,
0.4577632546,
0.3058261573,
-0.234102875,
0.3484074175,
-0.3967591822,
-0.0146688735,
-0.1069624946,
-0.4903103113,
-0.3788856566,
-0.2950911522,
0.2985056043,
0.6293765903,
0.2900809944,
0.5157610178,
0.1192325726,
0.4745218456,
-0.5220054984,
-0.1767291427,
-0.8076682091,
-0.304980278,
0.162389189,
-0.028827399,
-0.0115186414,
-0.710947752,
0.3708881438,
-0.5520225763,
0.1055336893,
-0.0869076476,
0.5243444443,
0.1949617267,
-0.2466791272,
-0.252011925,
-0.4486918151,
0.6614946127,
-0.64355129,
0.1817735732,
0.3185040057,
0.3790298402,
0.1661986858,
-0.6461812258,
-0.5913761854,
-0.0607928634,
-0.0499465838,
0.3055224419,
0.1681489199,
0.1663796455,
0.0997692198,
0.197561875,
-0.6140273809,
0.0009598666,
-0.5465834737,
-0.2482233793,
0.6062104702,
0.20603773,
-0.0028259107,
-0.0867571831,
-0.2806506157,
-0.1797002703,
-0.6176925302,
0.3195652962,
0.1735110134,
0.0598676987,
0.4211738706,
0.5403410196,
-0.36818555,
0.7028075457,
0.1980626732,
0.1739557385,
0.1927179992,
-0.4698700309,
-0.1883858591,
-0.1868467182,
0.3986755908,
-0.0048215217,
0.2755480707,
0.0351963192,
0.0932371095,
-0.3306214511,
0.1457158625,
-0.6767485142,
-0.140882954,
0.4255574346,
-0.5757933855,
-0.0346823782,
0.0786265433,
-0.5778304935,
-0.1387924999,
-0.282143563,
0.3712718487,
0.0480490662,
-0.349434346,
0.0859046429,
0.0256293695,
0.2555887699,
0.5882271528,
-0.3729733825,
0.1888232678,
0.5404644012,
0.2968415916,
0.0045244684,
-0.0445761234,
-0.7085735798,
0.075953193,
-0.0893456861,
0.7986866236,
-0.7134464979,
-0.101860933,
0.0540433377,
0.0328187644,
-0.058943931,
-0.5768339634,
0.1016867012,
-1.2240556479,
0.1000060737,
-0.6282548904,
-0.4498784244,
-0.2820634544,
0.5955545902,
-0.7385904789,
0.9345065355,
-0.077632919,
-0.6956661344,
-0.0384230241,
-0.5488262773,
-0.3224242926,
-0.1087043658,
-0.0076112556,
-0.1648748368,
-0.0797599033,
0.837610662,
0.355818361,
-0.1733606607,
0.004537032,
-0.3919439018,
-0.1791335046,
0.6331399083,
-0.1801695526,
0.6278069615,
0.2157616466,
0.1585619152,
0.1697701514,
-0.2114713192,
0.3055136502,
-0.209179163,
-0.3768508434,
-0.2060555071,
-0.2544386685,
-0.1772627831,
0.5899181962,
0.6383969188,
-0.7534234524,
-0.2755995393,
-0.518301785,
0.1773402989,
0.6978294849,
0.3831940889,
0.2666099668,
-0.5544914007,
0.7329146862,
0.1201664358,
0.2512231767,
0.0365277044,
-0.4670530558,
-0.7443883419,
0.2737388611,
0.3307220936,
0.6206610799,
-1.1624515057,
0.4025653005,
-0.2074450403,
-0.404505074,
-0.7840473056,
0.3786319494,
0.2866872549,
0.44103688,
0.5458703041,
-0.3009658456,
-0.4124243259,
-0.8053279519,
-0.0191674177,
-0.3301702738,
-0.0522650741,
0.6034799814,
0.2824313045,
0.2496573329,
0.9710017443,
-0.7820207477,
0.0258619767,
-0.6041046381,
-0.2407892048,
0.3385540545,
0.1006994843,
0.3475043476,
-0.9714545608,
-0.4779720008,
-0.1417128891,
-0.3699727952,
0.0018333237,
0.0608968027,
-0.3602518141,
-0.1919758171,
0.3960537314,
-0.4716767967,
0.3917559385,
0.2819619477,
0.122213915,
0.331266731,
0.0396233536,
0.3123866618,
-1.3056049347,
0.1971662045,
-0.1840209365,
-0.4673576355,
-0.5123474598,
0.1471654624,
0.0634172931,
0.0047935378,
-0.6303160787,
0.7180145383,
-0.3076036274,
-0.1014806181,
-0.3269800544,
0.3916640878,
0.0596577004,
0.7495583892,
0.4538832009,
0.5373509526,
0.1709363461,
-0.7490575314,
0.6864663363,
0.5557544231,
-0.4490866363,
-0.0603276417,
-0.7801740766,
0.4900280237,
-0.3988838196,
0.3267124891,
-0.9481019378,
-0.0947741345,
0.0732199624,
-0.7245528698,
-0.1016028747,
0.0695068762,
-0.4875445068,
-0.6419396996,
-0.2323288471,
0.5174431205,
0.396384418,
-0.5886065364,
0.4775763452,
0.2137876898,
-0.5168796778,
-0.6001499891,
-0.6646342278,
-0.3886405528,
0.1270891577,
-0.6497423053,
-0.3545764685,
-0.5223893523,
0.0314059854,
0.0729884803,
0.0084420061,
-0.3393558264,
0.0322111435,
-0.2324219346,
0.0809034854,
-0.287643522,
0.4783192277,
0.2156131566,
0.214635089,
0.1079366729,
-0.1888227463,
0.5982666612,
0.2074975967,
-0.3983694911,
0.0667790473,
0.613982439,
0.2227592617,
-0.8796647787,
0.7934530973,
0.3049384356,
-0.184088245,
0.1323951334,
-0.7700077295,
-0.6147803068,
-0.4280611575,
0.6762267351,
-0.0679357573,
-1.4428184032,
0.6072510481,
0.1160929352,
0.0581360869,
0.034003187,
0.5076854229,
-0.1993589997,
0.8075370789,
0.1507575065,
-0.2822769284,
0.4303351939,
0.1269937307,
0.1719388664,
-0.883726418,
-0.0483275987,
-0.5233030915,
-0.4129818082,
-0.1719192415,
-0.6069114208,
0.6953010559,
-0.1400562823,
-0.1770067662,
0.0215260014,
-0.2877998352,
0.4651756287,
0.4813256562,
0.6785840988,
0.1592752784,
-0.160133332,
0.2049630582,
0.180094257,
-0.7915022969,
-0.0965475962,
1.1999220848,
0.3235652149,
0.6204530001,
0.0310304444,
0.7125452757,
-0.1759241521,
0.3832183182,
-0.2439131737,
0.6224179864,
-0.0434565023,
-0.8854441643,
-0.6070663333,
-0.4827358127,
-0.7022194266,
0.280944258,
-0.2575426996,
-0.4034324288,
0.2901854813,
0.077563934,
-0.8186421394,
0.1712232828,
-0.2667992115,
0.5663785338,
-0.1991376281,
-0.1639988869,
-0.2753002048,
-0.877084434,
0.2964082956,
-0.1263481379,
-0.0335977636,
0.2071091235,
0.1471516639,
0.5668101311,
-0.2106643766,
0.7645902634,
-0.3087584376,
-0.0192566793,
0.7266603112,
-0.4309206009,
0.4926110506,
0.3135791421,
-0.2495801747,
-0.3525615931,
-0.0885558501,
-0.4235160053,
-0.7558328509,
0.5992601514,
-0.924249053,
-1.0089159012,
0.1369374096,
-0.2175560594,
-0.5117038488,
-0.1265239865,
0.1483174711,
0.5900409818,
-0.1241076216,
0.3677676618,
1.2681964636,
-0.4288204908,
0.3646366894,
0.4870826304,
-0.33648476,
-0.6413565874,
0.3654841781,
-0.0126256058,
0.5310357213,
0.6339617968,
-0.115362756,
-0.5301405787,
-0.4180368483,
-0.3279367387,
0.141144231,
-0.8127744198,
-0.4415802658,
-1.0236210823,
-0.7226430178,
-0.71731776,
0.157586351,
0.0431312956,
-0.4438253641,
-0.1608768255,
-0.4009153247,
0.2693676353,
0.3480579853,
0.1091695577,
0.2240330726,
-1.1140846014,
0.4678545296,
0.8514796495,
0.0268421043,
0.3037384748,
-0.4430820346,
-0.4720195532,
0.2474344671,
-0.1680282056,
-0.9050937295,
-0.0619848445,
0.1100162193,
0.7331192493,
0.0546133481,
0.3114286959,
0.5116659403,
-0.1652372777,
0.5918518901,
-0.0285181627,
-0.424082458,
0.7740510106,
-0.1846674681,
0.7359024882,
0.9396057129,
0.3104926348,
-0.5324730277,
-0.7197841406,
-0.3789605796,
-0.6819377542,
0.5272886753,
0.1010729074,
0.4002852142,
-0.2411950976,
0.4603788257,
0.1365640163,
0.2562138736,
-0.9411861897,
-0.1819068044,
0.0131160421,
-0.2312205434,
0.071995303,
-0.1255144775,
-0.023327712,
-0.1890086383,
0.7606447935,
-0.2627699673,
0.209707886,
0.6360405087,
-0.1823987365,
-0.3270435333,
0.3383639157,
0.2568512559,
0.8222318888,
0.0396286398,
-0.310885936,
0.3946610689,
-0.4223770201,
-0.0883896351,
0.1378839612,
-0.1321947724,
-0.261199832,
0.4057983756,
0.6527376771,
-0.170144394,
-0.4888918102,
0.6950194836,
-0.2138640583,
-0.2335672081,
-0.3668580353,
0.218485564,
0.256252557,
0.3651942015,
0.5289418697,
-0.0367095619,
0.0022576102,
-0.2995663881,
0.0793509036,
0.4059292078,
-0.3185519278,
0.0819395334,
0.4437476099,
0.4511497617,
0.0135654705,
0.705332458,
0.2310821712,
-0.7491711378,
0.998478055,
0.227826342,
0.7187861204,
-0.438996911,
0.346724987,
0.581088841,
0.4194630384,
0.2464293391,
0.5086168051,
-0.1696083397,
-0.9095279574,
-0.7162738442,
-0.6393284798,
-0.2993275225,
0.3905338645,
-0.7809898853,
-0.1324670762,
-0.4926184416,
0.1345123798,
-0.5843949318,
0.278653115,
-0.8949335814,
0.759531498,
0.1696974486,
1.1109979153,
-0.7811153531,
0.8715062141,
1.0275530815,
-0.3044139147,
-0.9786195159,
0.2772710621,
-0.6363726258,
-0.5483359098,
0.473164171,
0.1255139112,
0.1913696676,
0.0888867304,
-0.725118041,
-0.9552986026,
1.1762013435,
0.09439639,
-0.6046239734,
0.0828454569,
0.3157711327,
0.6059150696,
-0.4418467879,
0.483489573,
0.1821841747,
0.4604478478,
0.3592165411,
-0.8172050714,
-0.1025742516,
-0.1431743205,
-0.0746175572,
0.0538117029,
-0.7517671585,
0.5221089721,
-0.1415904015,
0.2542844415,
0.3132457733,
1.0956426859,
0.576720655,
0.2435890138,
0.6535720825,
0.3870425224,
0.6110624671,
0.2261525691,
0.8349210024,
-0.1470758468,
-0.0606237911,
1.1385570765,
-0.3074864745,
1.00494802,
0.4593239129,
-0.1495413929,
0.4396748245,
1.0245554447,
0.2886296213,
0.7336505651,
0.2663868964,
-0.4202093184,
-0.9020852447,
0.0394082181,
-0.3427273929,
0.2880514562,
0.1658033431,
-0.2595872581,
-0.126266852,
0.1682289094,
-0.4055747986,
0.1625363082,
-0.7636984587,
0.9720925689,
0.1563698798,
-0.9897994995,
0.0357712395,
-0.2855618894,
0.3190404773,
-0.686902523,
-0.014932109,
-0.4446513653,
-0.07737308,
0.0733556747,
-0.9027707577,
0.0945331082,
-0.131417647,
-0.5291473866,
0.0615010895,
0.9694469571,
-0.7322636843,
-0.5810240507,
0.4128202796,
0.6752437353,
-0.0583257303,
-0.225872919,
-0.6122522354,
-0.3957557678,
0.0752459243,
-0.3279715776,
0.2695918679,
0.4172982872,
-0.087951459,
0.5791429281,
0.6447789669,
-0.006452817,
0.1396010071,
-0.0827807412,
1.3161894083,
-0.2310737669,
-0.7812104821,
-0.3797231317,
0.5157042146,
-0.286844641,
-0.2122373283,
0.437276125,
0.3697774708,
0.7353804111,
-0.1463918984,
0.9657709002,
0.0356352702,
1.0487984419,
-0.5519143939,
0.6368122101,
-0.4905214012,
0.2323097289,
-0.1395678371,
-1.1593761444,
0.0675065517,
0.1791084111,
-0.7396530509,
0.28547135,
0.6162484288,
0.838634491,
0.1703381091,
0.0043276525,
0.3431443572,
-0.0159480423,
0.0013022679,
1.0812834501,
0.987462759,
-0.2222218961,
0.8663027287,
0.020604508,
-0.0896190405,
0.0006344933,
-0.3693781495,
-1.148373127,
-0.4975200593,
-0.1327662021,
-0.2005244941,
0.0774942786,
0.8870173693,
0.6854882836,
-0.9129323959,
0.0742259398,
0.3557230234,
0.123148419,
-0.0209433027,
-0.1418197602,
0.3548481166,
-0.2887571156,
-0.3848474026,
0.2115284204,
-0.0528779216,
-0.3471103907,
-0.098314546,
-0.1183835492,
-0.4318965673,
0.1353482604,
0.2544159293,
0.174969539,
-0.5385831594,
-0.3525058925,
0.3243538141,
-0.0462696813,
0.1706686914,
0.7033091784,
-0.8453040123,
0.1755111068,
0.5301604271,
1.197119236,
0.5130531788,
0.3180854321,
0.5783860087,
-0.9153596759,
-0.291800946,
0.4478034973,
0.0744222924,
0.3232086897,
-0.6747425795,
0.2413790524,
-0.2366229743,
-0.7210181952,
-0.0994429439,
0.3877268434,
-0.6336637735,
-0.5227900743,
1.1804947853,
-0.362854898,
-0.3863188028,
-0.3924098909,
-0.2630197704,
0.1260664314,
-0.1915191859,
0.543043375,
0.8915046453,
0.0342172049,
-0.7568573952,
-0.3357986808,
0.3823874295,
0.5821554661,
-1.0473952293,
-0.0898021311,
0.3564676046,
0.2782908976,
0.03997593,
0.6854484081,
0.0228409786,
0.6968053579,
-0.6448046565,
0.0317667909,
-0.0935693681,
-0.1379781812,
-0.18637079,
0.2471142411,
0.2754420936,
-0.1686451584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03743v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03743v1
|
Easy Data Augmentation in Sentiment Analysis of Cyberbullying
| 2023-11-29T10:05:58 | 2023-11-29T10:05:58 |
Alwan Wirawan, Hasan Dwi Cahyono, Winarno
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Instagram, a social media platform, has in the vicinity of 2 billion active
users in 2023. The platform allows users to post photos and videos with one
another. However, cyberbullying remains a significant problem for about 50% of
young Indonesians. To address this issue, sentiment analysis for comment
filtering uses a Support Vector Machine (SVM) and Easy Data Augmentation (EDA).
EDA will augment the dataset, enabling robust prediction and analysis of
cyberbullying by introducing more variation. Based on the tests, SVM
combination with EDA results in a 2.52% increase in the k-Fold Cross Validation
score. Our proposed approach shows an improved accuracy of 92.5%, 2.5% higher
than that of the existing state-of-the-art method. To maintain the
reproducibility and replicability of this research, the source code can be
accessed at uns.id/eda_svm.
|
[
-0.5372818112,
-1.0058871508,
0.2486117333,
0.5511004329,
-0.5800817609,
0.3776771724,
0.120514065,
-0.7314184904,
0.3444964886,
0.4573445618,
-0.6300569177,
-0.5894230604,
-0.7114819288,
0.2233588845,
-0.2128058672,
1.0555450916,
-0.029805351,
0.2867693305,
-0.5310531855,
-0.0727788508,
-0.4582596123,
-0.425006181,
-0.4180926383,
-0.0298562832,
0.0912220106,
0.3696557283,
0.157451883,
0.2415219694,
0.8267841339,
0.329995811,
-0.2832663953,
0.094414182,
-0.4061890244,
0.046951808,
-0.1057225317,
-0.4170096517,
-0.513081193,
-0.3308325112,
0.2420946211,
0.4835170805,
0.1864765584,
0.2961250246,
0.3490770161,
0.8016093373,
-0.351857245,
0.1437312961,
-0.3633999527,
0.0753105953,
-0.0637975261,
-0.1938605011,
-0.0270497408,
-0.7460483313,
0.0136945844,
-0.3485663235,
-0.1656775177,
-0.1536827981,
0.4501349628,
0.3659054041,
-0.3258788288,
-0.1109533831,
-0.7034068704,
0.6684798002,
-0.5400958657,
0.1093868166,
0.340262115,
0.1297416389,
-0.310428232,
-0.6734518409,
-0.6403720379,
0.2921905816,
-0.134719044,
-0.0526353978,
-0.3992083669,
0.1610727161,
0.3499014974,
0.0899928659,
-0.5376682281,
0.0778732225,
-0.5594506264,
0.0858403221,
0.6683023572,
0.2323823422,
0.4464290142,
-0.5612475276,
-0.6354959011,
-0.0202599354,
-0.4822832346,
0.495031178,
0.6046136618,
0.3939694464,
-0.0166105088,
0.6062611938,
-0.2672371864,
0.6585052013,
0.1312517375,
-0.3018112779,
0.434876442,
-0.5434984565,
-0.2371369153,
0.1645880193,
0.7868369818,
0.8762638569,
0.0641975254,
0.4263910949,
-0.1014532968,
0.5034158826,
0.3392644525,
-1.0453857183,
-0.1054866016,
0.4770628512,
-0.6933070421,
-0.5932034254,
0.2492943555,
-1.2683477402,
-0.5031002164,
-0.3545233309,
0.3089907765,
-0.2804451883,
-0.3758046031,
0.0287743807,
-0.0943295583,
0.0761551335,
0.2749922574,
-0.1874717921,
0.502726078,
0.8120061755,
0.7230863571,
-0.0907868147,
0.3882935047,
-0.3449539542,
-0.4392876923,
-0.1617222428,
1.0738961697,
-0.7789770961,
-0.2295810431,
0.1975408494,
-0.0196299702,
0.0742844939,
-0.502624929,
0.8350535631,
-0.3371554017,
0.0577419549,
-0.0268678106,
-0.7222545743,
-0.6216695905,
0.2075925916,
-0.4630716741,
1.2483870983,
0.1358738691,
-0.7893951535,
0.5247199535,
-0.39502424,
-0.4159025252,
0.3235477805,
0.1807223707,
-0.6300192475,
-0.0301211197,
0.6057510972,
0.7595439553,
0.0145227658,
0.0990534201,
-0.8186033964,
-0.6466050148,
0.1783119887,
-0.0441006385,
0.892624557,
0.1854120791,
-0.1180295199,
-0.0170841757,
-0.7880294919,
0.0434473157,
-0.2504396737,
-0.1986394823,
-0.771576941,
-0.158357352,
0.1787906736,
0.5452455282,
0.0732529163,
-1.1077748537,
0.2415709049,
-0.4325824678,
0.1358303279,
0.8645993471,
0.4468927383,
0.0124481032,
-0.0123144034,
0.7437312603,
0.1341401786,
0.1675907522,
-0.117588982,
-0.5686992407,
-0.2180798948,
-0.6025650501,
0.3024924099,
0.5521329641,
-0.9936719537,
0.4688515961,
-0.4188913703,
-0.4677278996,
-0.8465880752,
0.476046443,
0.2783607841,
0.2920286953,
0.2173565179,
-0.4534542263,
-1.0444709063,
-0.7359660864,
-0.4061317742,
-0.0792068318,
0.0490687005,
0.0695408583,
0.3490142822,
-0.1982095242,
0.8526294231,
-0.3577956855,
-0.4802285135,
-0.3227972388,
0.1353040338,
0.1702408195,
0.2758314013,
0.705483079,
-0.9489070177,
-1.0518277884,
-0.1266652197,
-0.8646389246,
-0.0730352029,
0.1077050865,
0.2343170494,
0.1305258423,
0.5336341858,
-0.5006552339,
0.826562345,
0.3338928521,
-0.3367961943,
0.1295907199,
0.3758022189,
0.3924953043,
-1.092135787,
-0.2700735033,
0.7371485233,
-0.5036934614,
-0.707460463,
-0.205819279,
-0.1648195088,
-0.0739952773,
-0.5210638642,
0.0480944142,
-0.0565812141,
0.3362793028,
-0.4891813397,
0.1333662719,
-0.3485817611,
0.4612944126,
-0.4454982877,
0.3260606527,
0.571193099,
-0.587064743,
0.5516257286,
0.0215707161,
-0.4407306015,
1.0319210291,
-0.7890372872,
0.2758369148,
-0.4673709571,
0.428293854,
-1.4652150869,
-0.2837228179,
0.5619958043,
-0.7460713387,
0.1584155709,
-0.3163396716,
-0.501675725,
-0.6249670982,
-0.9840363264,
0.0957464874,
0.2797803581,
-0.733802557,
0.7367753386,
0.7537987232,
-0.512689352,
-0.5031992793,
-0.2688156962,
0.1025196686,
-0.4655022323,
-0.7082312107,
0.3752292991,
-0.2506061494,
-0.4287610352,
0.3065451086,
0.1132816076,
-0.0382089764,
-0.2039940357,
0.4605816603,
0.5090711117,
0.2585196793,
-0.0556331202,
0.1470568627,
-0.0643300489,
0.1905096173,
0.3467843831,
0.5159723759,
-0.018744668,
0.0815893486,
-0.7695175409,
0.2138395905,
0.2999840975,
0.2564381361,
0.5390878916,
0.4444379508,
-0.6830376387,
-0.1657115519,
-0.2513368428,
-0.1930427253,
-0.4898161292,
0.2479393929,
-0.2981785536,
-0.630644381,
0.4258632362,
-0.1425295025,
-0.0624444932,
0.2520833313,
0.2406169474,
-0.3610785902,
1.4019528627,
0.7503796816,
-0.1560801119,
0.5664435029,
0.091000244,
0.3703364134,
-0.7547499537,
-0.3334841728,
-0.3872483373,
-0.4158786237,
-1.0567449331,
0.0387510508,
0.312789917,
-0.3713667691,
0.3871260583,
0.4806441963,
-0.716983974,
0.2168596536,
0.2414153665,
0.5435652733,
0.1039381698,
0.2860263288,
0.3652380705,
-0.4413058162,
-0.4518214464,
-0.3199580014,
1.2196825743,
0.3355924487,
0.7026237845,
-0.0452350453,
0.5240086317,
0.5158035755,
0.4955554903,
-0.8104740381,
0.7949113846,
-0.2310923189,
-0.5177609324,
-0.0534807667,
-0.2841885388,
-0.7061071396,
0.3492433131,
-0.4269463122,
-0.8170140386,
0.2778526545,
-0.0057613947,
-0.491868943,
0.2701387405,
-0.4927074909,
0.2737038434,
0.2987982333,
-0.4106487334,
-0.4233650863,
-0.6147785783,
0.5186120272,
-0.1613998562,
0.3191336095,
0.1690516621,
0.2239112258,
1.0125286579,
-0.6517093182,
1.1024209261,
-0.4057951868,
0.2223339379,
0.5592601895,
-0.4234322608,
0.5844659805,
-0.2424227297,
0.2043367326,
-0.0526638031,
-0.2442198694,
-0.0992822126,
-0.7782793045,
0.9380374551,
-0.4322101772,
-0.2985037267,
-0.507157445,
-0.0085384222,
-0.141824007,
-0.1570325941,
-0.199480772,
0.1433747113,
-0.0541205555,
0.6656236053,
0.8568986654,
0.0567030087,
0.5789582729,
0.1957367659,
-0.3470753431,
-0.7497187853,
0.9350002408,
0.3797951341,
-0.4212784767,
0.0944478735,
0.1079181954,
-0.3183162808,
-0.262840718,
-0.4159689546,
0.1015489474,
-0.608103931,
-0.411960125,
-0.80997926,
0.1205446124,
-0.4567091167,
0.0914283246,
-0.2202130109,
-0.4302094579,
-0.0526072495,
-0.5348987579,
0.5927469134,
0.817340076,
0.0425229855,
0.3552440703,
-0.6201968193,
0.4152098596,
0.278844893,
0.4544455707,
-0.1787593067,
-0.6644640565,
-0.1280744225,
-0.1734889597,
-0.3011135161,
-0.8855370283,
0.2972877622,
-0.1261003315,
0.0827118084,
0.4069102108,
0.0285882931,
0.9384288788,
0.1795482934,
0.6149985194,
0.1553498358,
-0.5875976682,
0.5890741944,
-0.2497063875,
-0.2110450864,
0.5128297806,
0.5507568121,
-0.3315583766,
-0.0558892898,
-0.7182825804,
-0.9938749075,
0.5045723915,
0.0443286188,
0.2915294766,
0.3205943406,
0.3904604912,
0.1380439997,
0.2906574607,
-0.7326022387,
-0.3936621249,
-0.1370584071,
-0.3821262717,
0.3731672168,
-0.5325912237,
0.1464012563,
-0.7421832681,
0.9139903784,
0.0884484276,
0.0966932774,
-0.1387750655,
0.0777305961,
-0.434817642,
-0.1109586135,
0.1230826974,
0.4939223528,
-0.2307976335,
-0.1411903948,
0.2242040932,
-0.603595674,
0.1083630919,
0.2520484328,
-0.4194858968,
0.1548750103,
0.1562968642,
0.8482146263,
0.0807718039,
-0.4855181277,
0.6887319088,
-0.0895335153,
-0.2437069714,
-0.5497967601,
-0.1189381853,
-0.2768504322,
0.0571399257,
0.388911128,
0.1145188287,
0.2098311186,
-0.3826642334,
0.4068528414,
0.263935864,
-0.763472259,
-0.4961449504,
0.3108710647,
0.1881357878,
-0.3254339099,
0.2747378349,
-0.1462184638,
-0.4468141496,
0.3785093427,
0.434640795,
0.9285230041,
-0.6310420036,
0.3608953059,
0.6071079969,
0.4375751019,
0.1398162097,
0.6220065355,
0.4604423046,
-0.5235213041,
-0.4754521847,
-0.534953475,
-0.2671302557,
0.4070465863,
-0.6684764624,
0.4874483943,
-0.7004039884,
-0.2756739557,
0.2412215173,
0.1007868499,
-0.7016554475,
0.6068819165,
-0.3028257191,
0.3884217143,
-1.1154085398,
0.2995484471,
1.1791459322,
-0.401832521,
-0.3782044947,
-0.1634244174,
0.2645251453,
-0.3626716733,
0.3331955373,
0.4042703807,
-0.0984473526,
-0.3731571734,
-0.853566587,
-0.4985385239,
0.6040992737,
-0.0662084594,
-0.4831506908,
0.7250934243,
0.2595120966,
0.9657521844,
-0.4626773298,
0.0977370515,
0.477079004,
0.4724860489,
-0.0423034728,
-0.339443177,
0.0805774331,
-0.5854355097,
0.1734960973,
0.1051742733,
-0.5278863311,
0.5121833682,
0.0973253623,
-0.1179809868,
-0.5278788209,
0.7807870507,
-0.0014661966,
0.4426709414,
0.7042183876,
0.7446712255,
0.4333828688,
-0.0157459974,
0.9250834584,
-0.1927766353,
0.0646092817,
0.8390766978,
0.0371616967,
0.759736836,
0.533839941,
-0.3883393705,
0.666110456,
0.7413389683,
0.068663232,
0.3708650768,
-0.0778780803,
-0.5080978274,
-0.0623482205,
-0.474399358,
0.0266324598,
0.6170743704,
0.3998061121,
-0.2144242972,
0.1451427788,
0.4486603737,
0.5475951433,
0.1936679929,
-0.499763459,
1.1503409147,
0.1413359046,
-0.4562319815,
0.0629973039,
-0.094886817,
0.7808508873,
-0.2331156582,
-0.2568962574,
-0.0251267627,
0.3696286082,
-0.588721633,
-0.9162254333,
0.3114834726,
0.2892476916,
0.0764700249,
-0.022385817,
1.3642748594,
-0.3482649326,
-0.7561295629,
0.3248602152,
0.2965951562,
0.0382860675,
-0.1324641556,
-0.5791884065,
0.0464189537,
0.1715497077,
-0.4944651127,
0.4166953862,
0.2022337765,
-0.1228635758,
0.7673913836,
0.8083432317,
0.0572079867,
-0.2071421742,
0.0136229238,
1.1629533768,
-0.4429557323,
-0.5882581472,
-1.0774508715,
0.6046537757,
-0.639770031,
-0.2243834734,
1.0931415558,
0.3334640861,
0.8677126169,
0.0143585429,
1.0367542505,
-0.2083630711,
0.9646413922,
-0.0352101065,
0.2276188731,
-0.3208436966,
0.2073055208,
-0.8450455666,
-0.9842685461,
-0.3536336422,
0.6133906841,
-0.0687455833,
-0.0223521441,
0.3071494401,
0.8357759714,
0.0153515972,
0.2036647201,
-0.021481026,
0.1353325695,
0.1968302727,
-0.1510071456,
0.481064707,
-0.5927003026,
0.5159937143,
-0.5436592102,
-0.418266505,
-0.368537277,
-0.637375176,
-1.0239036083,
-0.1824427247,
-0.4875899851,
-0.4258288741,
-0.0685105547,
1.1866836548,
0.318128407,
-0.8313592672,
0.1083861589,
0.3066574931,
0.2113519907,
-0.4553655684,
-0.2917146087,
0.1759183854,
0.0521221235,
-0.8643645048,
0.2702582479,
0.2596884668,
-0.1151873767,
-0.4156296253,
0.2475909591,
-0.1133454815,
0.2523292303,
0.9642271399,
0.0175594594,
-0.1726709455,
-0.3713672757,
-0.0778556094,
0.1572642475,
0.235791266,
0.6040430665,
-0.6884464622,
0.8625540733,
0.7465823293,
0.633246541,
0.5740615726,
0.3615789711,
0.2269690633,
-0.8535293341,
-0.0120336972,
-0.0384054743,
0.2855430245,
0.6031187773,
-0.5022441745,
0.419303,
0.536623776,
-0.2586561739,
-1.0108146667,
-0.2256352305,
-0.7312165499,
-0.2394371033,
0.895540297,
-0.1279752105,
-0.4020510912,
-0.3805019855,
-0.3359043598,
0.1559817046,
-0.6299976707,
1.0233962536,
0.7201884985,
-0.1773812473,
-0.1740810722,
-0.4068793058,
0.6526281834,
0.027474137,
-0.8851768374,
-0.3055143058,
0.3214814961,
0.4460909069,
-0.0340926871,
0.6586261392,
-0.0619655252,
0.226378724,
-0.1768236756,
0.0715373755,
0.0275369771,
-0.3968540132,
-0.3748328388,
0.4459503889,
-0.6303086281,
-0.3031328022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17492v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17492v2
|
Mergen: The First Manchu-Korean Machine Translation Model Trained on Augmented Data
| 2023-11-29T10:01:48 | 2024-01-12T14:18:03 |
Jean Seo, Sungjoo Byun, Minha Kang, Sangah Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Manchu language, with its roots in the historical Manchurian region of
Northeast China, is now facing a critical threat of extinction, as there are
very few speakers left. In our efforts to safeguard the Manchu language, we
introduce Mergen, the first-ever attempt at a Manchu-Korean Machine Translation
(MT) model. To develop this model, we utilize valuable resources such as the
Manwen Laodang(a historical book) and a Manchu-Korean dictionary. Due to the
scarcity of a Manchu-Korean parallel dataset, we expand our data by employing
word replacement guided by GloVe embeddings, trained on both monolingual and
parallel texts. Our approach is built around an encoder-decoder neural machine
translation model, incorporating a bi-directional Gated Recurrent Unit (GRU)
layer. The experiments have yielded promising results, showcasing a significant
enhancement in Manchu-Korean translation, with a remarkable 20-30 point
increase in the BLEU score.
|
[
-0.2410892248,
-0.5670024753,
0.1756049246,
0.1081659794,
-0.5831598043,
0.1285620332,
-0.1863090545,
-0.1585496515,
0.4090432227,
0.7801071405,
-0.4266872108,
-0.5072999597,
-0.7253935337,
0.0306863785,
-0.3327712715,
0.7681702375,
-0.1094487458,
0.3483333886,
0.0746392608,
-0.1670603007,
-0.0621111281,
-0.3855857253,
-0.5102090836,
-0.2373648584,
0.3431387842,
0.3329775035,
0.8996571302,
1.1015205383,
0.6320961118,
0.2533430457,
-0.1850087494,
0.3457200825,
-0.4310827255,
-0.2145663798,
0.2001606971,
-0.360728085,
-0.516089499,
0.1300124526,
0.7437461615,
0.8816668391,
-0.2084454298,
-0.2837449312,
-0.0156182693,
0.3786943853,
-0.1498086154,
-0.0484080762,
-0.4476867914,
0.0032720973,
-0.3209350407,
0.1897345036,
-0.507266283,
-0.1538303196,
-0.0705996007,
-0.7597773075,
0.1909593493,
0.1044365466,
0.9946991801,
0.2777723372,
-0.7535129786,
0.2763930261,
-0.5215852857,
0.841671586,
-0.8458299637,
0.7480160594,
0.2943534553,
-0.0107212244,
-0.3098074794,
-0.5286065936,
-0.6975802779,
-0.3320937157,
-0.3952162564,
0.3572076261,
0.3098421991,
0.0678826347,
0.0987267271,
0.2910617292,
-0.5629147887,
0.0794454664,
-0.5501802564,
-0.065546371,
0.7065004706,
0.2517049909,
0.5918182731,
-0.5502385497,
-0.822383821,
-0.2607440948,
-0.4387440085,
-0.3143284619,
0.1793274879,
0.1744325757,
-0.1641355604,
0.6357008219,
-0.1588424444,
0.8744346499,
0.113788411,
-0.0006907528,
0.2097870409,
-0.7176798582,
-0.2712792754,
-0.0602614433,
0.8940519691,
0.7204465866,
-0.3712491393,
-0.3725387752,
-0.2609323859,
-0.2341423184,
0.2538919747,
-0.3597024679,
-0.4314124584,
0.0490572937,
-0.5094434619,
-0.2833878398,
0.1400992721,
-0.5056311488,
-0.5551134348,
-0.45622015,
0.1890519559,
-0.3855392039,
-0.5109162331,
-0.1960587054,
-0.1166409776,
0.6659427285,
-0.0028470007,
-0.6284245253,
0.3258086741,
0.9140460491,
0.7315751314,
-0.2400104851,
-0.7970630527,
-0.3103222251,
-0.0911115631,
-0.7876673937,
0.2425028384,
-0.1477455497,
-0.3854729533,
-0.3250682354,
0.3234885931,
0.1046371311,
-0.6703631878,
0.5201034546,
-0.5839182138,
0.2354563028,
-0.1931877732,
-0.427867204,
-0.3069035411,
0.3762556612,
-0.7724272609,
0.7587143779,
0.5325688124,
-0.720528543,
0.4697184861,
-0.2492397279,
-0.4982304871,
0.190713644,
0.2104300112,
-0.4856296778,
-0.1256284565,
0.1274250597,
0.2193410546,
-0.5326061845,
0.2672940195,
-0.1804966331,
0.0176707096,
0.1296292841,
-0.2408055365,
0.896459341,
0.0350013897,
0.0852510482,
0.0299749412,
-0.4004252851,
-0.1051882356,
0.0153381694,
-0.2260207832,
-0.7043495178,
-0.4489403069,
0.1830184907,
0.2190471143,
0.5659015775,
-0.8941888213,
0.0529581159,
-0.533562243,
0.0350114591,
0.7065735459,
-0.3258585036,
0.9064112306,
-0.4058988094,
0.2199047655,
0.4156740904,
0.342792362,
-0.2517254949,
-0.3749340475,
-0.7197999954,
-0.0014664083,
0.4767181575,
0.7627555132,
-1.0786367655,
0.1705905944,
-0.1634865552,
-0.5522569418,
-0.9132094383,
0.2155722529,
0.3023088276,
0.488124162,
0.1521213204,
-0.214462027,
-0.7405458689,
-0.9930275679,
-0.1588628739,
-0.1211938187,
-0.0471609086,
0.4860073626,
0.0966144502,
-0.4051972926,
0.4325696826,
-0.2658090293,
-0.1266253293,
-0.0088430811,
-0.0974283889,
0.3583350778,
0.6198868155,
0.0435593948,
-1.1380146742,
-0.7497957945,
0.809240222,
-0.8847960234,
0.0080133351,
-0.1249262094,
-0.4175998271,
0.4980932176,
0.7062095404,
-0.4867097139,
0.0151223587,
0.8182056546,
-0.0503143072,
0.4523528516,
-0.5008071065,
0.4718854427,
-1.662587285,
0.096627228,
-0.3810530901,
-0.1172659174,
-0.987960875,
0.2333912998,
0.4208883941,
-0.2118592709,
-0.4610060453,
0.7252701521,
-0.4129211903,
0.3824389875,
-0.3332450688,
0.2981380224,
-0.3099101484,
0.294654429,
-0.1371438205,
0.4446796775,
0.3213559091,
-0.5855003595,
0.8186656833,
0.3455519378,
-0.0791888759,
0.47640872,
-0.4999728501,
0.1764922589,
-0.2898252606,
-0.249387756,
-0.7570635676,
-0.4970616698,
0.438913852,
-0.4282367527,
0.508826375,
-0.2076281011,
-0.1737224907,
-0.4429883063,
-0.0855198875,
0.3620463312,
0.6580697894,
-0.7408281565,
0.6218990088,
0.5997096896,
-0.1354988217,
-0.700750649,
-0.6754859686,
0.2329301834,
0.0195860323,
-0.7299710512,
0.4945405126,
0.1687470675,
-0.0114258686,
0.1266299188,
-0.0432633534,
-0.2002572268,
-0.0457888357,
0.1287831962,
0.9569898844,
-0.3594790697,
-0.1821574867,
0.1691595316,
-0.1879846901,
-0.0381165519,
-0.4941441715,
0.3164499998,
0.1363220215,
-0.0619229786,
0.048743248,
0.2312644869,
0.6124290228,
-0.1117021739,
0.9556009769,
0.4298216999,
-0.6563996077,
0.0640185773,
-0.4559494257,
-0.2325391471,
-0.3778835535,
0.4904283881,
-0.2693754137,
-0.6212053895,
0.4748009741,
-0.2969147265,
0.1090598181,
0.3019523025,
0.2379812449,
0.0686426014,
0.8915768266,
0.5931444168,
-0.2672023475,
0.3539447784,
-0.1027980745,
-0.0116414754,
-1.0807492733,
-0.4122213125,
0.0893073156,
-0.3276471496,
-0.8085422516,
-0.5308125019,
0.4582558274,
0.2726697028,
-0.0780918226,
0.7144140005,
-0.2779168487,
0.5472456217,
0.4735990465,
0.3576387763,
0.0291246828,
-0.4734487832,
-0.0440723859,
-0.0465524569,
-0.8218862414,
-0.0642560646,
0.9875795841,
0.0503521673,
0.8756763339,
-0.0786971152,
0.815531373,
0.0566665456,
0.3832781315,
-0.4985668659,
0.541870892,
-0.7349864841,
-0.3651138246,
-0.3780083358,
-0.639000833,
-1.0005983114,
0.4719129205,
-0.0278531834,
0.0092910733,
-0.2009411454,
-0.013291561,
0.0262997448,
0.317768842,
-0.7717243433,
1.2229857445,
-0.4422981441,
-0.1477176249,
0.0964523628,
-0.7661802173,
0.7331573367,
-0.0920438543,
0.0218057726,
0.297236383,
-0.2080868483,
0.4678277969,
-0.3059954047,
0.3703510761,
-0.0248262938,
0.1775744706,
-0.0357446,
0.181557551,
0.6064174175,
-0.2106081396,
0.1081793383,
0.214782998,
-0.2176155448,
-0.5358890891,
-0.6448593736,
0.8564397097,
-0.6821268201,
-0.6642808914,
-0.2232122421,
-0.6304399371,
0.3208080828,
0.4190120101,
0.2165277898,
0.0895904303,
-0.3333460391,
0.118624717,
0.5724520087,
-0.2598547637,
0.0032589543,
0.3784889281,
-0.6333670616,
-0.9857466817,
0.9020402431,
0.161025092,
0.510833025,
0.1782847792,
0.2904002666,
-0.1974398345,
0.0415196791,
-1.0796791315,
0.4526990056,
-0.464106977,
-0.1480704099,
-0.5611925125,
-0.5354271531,
-0.2561214864,
-0.2599074244,
-0.4138180315,
-0.0889427513,
-0.0705147386,
0.1214545965,
0.1060568839,
0.7865504026,
-0.1148197874,
0.3216757476,
-1.0250375271,
0.3979932368,
0.1678478271,
0.2525460422,
-0.1437210888,
-0.6191363335,
-0.4174313247,
0.2718370855,
0.1970110983,
-0.7111757994,
0.7391542792,
-0.2380687147,
0.594524622,
-0.0196644664,
0.113594234,
0.2963839769,
-0.4597592354,
0.7441646457,
0.1585589051,
-0.6047245264,
0.2030184418,
-0.3748801351,
0.4348316789,
-0.123694241,
0.3802717924,
-1.005947113,
-0.3207494617,
-0.5831180215,
-0.6801652312,
1.0268669128,
-0.2532100677,
0.0528519973,
0.0738604814,
0.168215394,
0.2269842625,
0.0457439907,
-0.2849322855,
-0.2636169195,
-0.1365270764,
-0.1770485193,
-0.0790796578,
-0.0303940084,
-0.028301036,
-0.112154454,
0.6589670777,
0.1954418272,
-0.1468060762,
0.057167422,
-0.1922830343,
-0.0969078317,
-0.01322232,
0.5272136927,
0.1304455251,
0.1635579467,
0.0690543726,
0.5220786333,
-0.5288624167,
-0.0389351249,
0.3057239354,
-0.6006814241,
0.1047490761,
-0.1276741177,
0.9785295725,
0.1133642346,
-0.1354103535,
0.3278512657,
0.1492207795,
0.0775909796,
-0.1520375609,
-0.4127219915,
0.1120111346,
0.0367893316,
0.0991462991,
0.1056409776,
-0.0508158505,
-0.2681817412,
0.4061853886,
0.3958726227,
-0.4921126366,
-0.1092446148,
0.7936016917,
0.2735259533,
-0.3036694527,
0.7244760394,
-0.242027387,
-0.958296299,
0.4549423456,
0.6976777315,
0.8660842776,
-0.4592477381,
0.2569024265,
0.6273815036,
0.6263215542,
-0.0953929201,
0.1312167645,
0.2284799516,
-0.5966191292,
-0.4097792208,
-0.5240344405,
-0.5696214437,
-0.0190461967,
-0.3119451702,
0.4385884106,
-0.254891634,
0.0333868563,
-0.3029567897,
-0.2120381743,
-0.2601334751,
-0.0218841378,
0.0121139688,
0.7298172712,
-0.5937174559,
0.6684767008,
0.6926064491,
-0.2831553817,
-0.6976826191,
-0.255356282,
-0.2093877792,
-0.523540318,
0.6297014356,
-0.1738930047,
0.2931261659,
0.0966451615,
-0.4852721691,
-0.7109806538,
0.9064930677,
0.261695981,
-0.1694798321,
0.3194954097,
0.1837780178,
0.3335253,
-0.1618496925,
-0.178480491,
0.5501337647,
0.4664853811,
-0.1136423051,
-1.1985543966,
-0.0014950039,
-0.3001013696,
0.0899555013,
0.9470530152,
-0.5955811143,
1.2281347513,
-0.1983041763,
-0.394467026,
0.2639844418,
0.5595940351,
-0.166242376,
0.2174627781,
0.242025733,
0.6371538639,
0.7330448627,
-0.2873411179,
1.1623203754,
-0.2530916333,
0.1199482977,
0.8726322055,
-0.2185888439,
0.6981956363,
0.2756746709,
-0.0359754227,
0.1713288873,
0.3003008366,
0.1334646195,
0.3993287385,
-0.0685722753,
-0.5565437675,
-0.1171705946,
-0.2706426382,
-0.2108097225,
0.2836903632,
0.1429521441,
-0.4082089663,
0.04691571,
0.2717350125,
0.1001891047,
0.2324643433,
-0.2809186876,
0.9333206415,
0.1531473398,
-0.7809816599,
0.6815581322,
0.0957612693,
0.8185112476,
-0.6371400952,
-0.0593538769,
-0.4535674453,
0.2842572331,
0.0175688509,
-0.9275891185,
0.2909124792,
-0.3339748085,
-0.239068836,
-0.0818393752,
0.8481217623,
-1.268219471,
-0.4092907608,
0.2208721787,
0.3692231774,
0.1470835656,
0.2237178981,
-0.3277567625,
-0.1552697569,
0.064142175,
0.2899406254,
0.3401519954,
0.5325795412,
0.0195882246,
0.3842709363,
0.9367914796,
0.1775447279,
0.318762511,
-0.3680268526,
0.8124116063,
-0.7881849408,
-0.2571281195,
-0.7444604039,
0.5158314705,
-0.3172867,
-0.1719465852,
0.8711841702,
0.729323566,
1.1940352917,
-0.4232303202,
0.7540290356,
-0.104202427,
0.4023697674,
-0.4304626882,
1.2310605049,
-0.437697351,
-0.2105196714,
0.0858396515,
-0.6754501462,
-0.2405082881,
0.1672955006,
0.0792196617,
-0.2825545669,
0.5266420245,
1.1192381382,
-0.1998773515,
-0.0235107914,
0.6561635137,
0.2634108067,
-0.0823787376,
0.5126478076,
0.5681484938,
-1.0304510593,
0.543500185,
-0.6779830456,
-0.3321246803,
-0.0132948877,
-0.4699447453,
-0.5178339481,
-0.8679715991,
-0.0368734039,
-0.6601783037,
-0.1119944155,
0.7816056609,
0.3664110601,
-0.6868491173,
-0.4293992817,
0.1356527656,
0.4139660299,
-0.1777124703,
-0.1355903149,
0.1319487095,
-0.050803598,
-0.8142983317,
0.4191391468,
0.3051873446,
0.154257223,
-0.0749739334,
-0.6061312556,
-0.3056342602,
-0.1824626774,
0.5928940177,
0.3588781357,
-0.7584342957,
-0.100645341,
0.7409387827,
-0.5157889724,
-0.2550587356,
0.4738515913,
-0.6137074232,
0.9012998343,
0.7183797359,
1.1243265867,
0.1383092552,
0.1193204224,
0.7481192946,
-0.6395207644,
0.0147010172,
0.0283972621,
0.1981998533,
0.5790623426,
-0.1896583587,
0.5583813787,
0.4092072546,
-0.6729040742,
-0.8085860014,
0.1628410518,
-0.9411708117,
0.1721242666,
1.0509198904,
-0.0909030214,
-0.6310764551,
-0.0423098914,
-0.6879552603,
0.5854921341,
0.0527862944,
0.5386946201,
0.8352496624,
0.3415914774,
-0.3880375922,
-0.1945439726,
0.3713571429,
0.3641726971,
-0.6398687959,
0.3861190081,
0.2915296555,
-0.0543650016,
0.2516305149,
0.1804335266,
-0.1262536943,
0.7039310932,
0.5424908996,
0.1416697055,
-0.1458411962,
-0.155641824,
-0.2585695088,
-0.5212817192,
-0.0967419967,
-0.4712677002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17487v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17487v1
|
Taiwan LLM: Bridging the Linguistic Divide with a Culturally Aligned Language Model
| 2023-11-29T09:48:34 | 2023-11-29T09:48:34 |
Yen-Ting Lin, Yun-Nung Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the realm of language models, the nuanced linguistic and cultural
intricacies of Traditional Chinese, as spoken in Taiwan, have been largely
overlooked. This paper introduces Taiwan LLM, a pioneering Large Language Model
that specifically caters to the Traditional Chinese language, with a focus on
the variant used in Taiwan. Leveraging a comprehensive pretraining corpus and
instruction-finetuning datasets, we have developed a model that not only
understands the complexities of Traditional Chinese but also embodies the
cultural context of Taiwan. Taiwan LLM represents the first of its kind, a
model that is not only linguistically accurate but also culturally resonant
with its user base. Our evaluations demonstrate that Taiwan LLM achieves
superior performance in understanding and generating Traditional Chinese text,
outperforming existing models that are predominantly trained on Simplified
Chinese or English. The open-source release of Taiwan LLM invites collaboration
and further innovation, ensuring that the linguistic diversity of Chinese
speakers is embraced and well-served. The model, datasets, and further
resources are made publicly available to foster ongoing research and
development in this field.
|
[
0.0201141294,
-0.8137996197,
0.3158495724,
0.4071841836,
-0.459272176,
0.3536578715,
-0.8017320037,
-0.5428010225,
0.1139332354,
0.7826815844,
-0.3372047544,
-0.4780322313,
-0.3795627952,
0.0488903038,
-0.1931925416,
0.3477089703,
-0.0718017295,
0.2695887387,
0.4363821149,
-0.2190016061,
-0.2893480957,
-0.5958487391,
-0.6408950686,
-0.7284439206,
0.5083593726,
0.3353880346,
0.7492902875,
0.8780713081,
0.4947440922,
0.2527464032,
-0.309756875,
0.3033110797,
-0.7839108706,
-0.265384078,
0.0053790919,
-0.3748141825,
-0.2684097588,
0.0720892772,
0.8454443216,
0.7677072883,
-0.1931454539,
0.015741853,
0.1653324217,
0.5076031685,
-0.161843136,
-0.0275368541,
-0.5190919638,
0.1980558187,
-0.5671342611,
-0.0412367582,
-0.6511941552,
-0.6534842253,
0.1669368893,
-0.4308305681,
-0.3346151412,
-0.2764326632,
0.9281305075,
-0.0767625198,
-0.8259114623,
-0.0421159007,
-0.9947375655,
0.7891986966,
-0.663505733,
0.6889352202,
-0.1012733504,
0.1331044585,
-0.1255795956,
-0.7948052883,
-0.3298405707,
-0.4807102382,
0.1008083969,
0.1204465553,
-0.036101792,
0.0025678792,
-0.2863757312,
0.5467008352,
-0.6524576545,
0.6554763913,
-0.3358591795,
0.1191044971,
0.5530217886,
0.1160905659,
0.7481324673,
-0.0400650427,
-0.7051027417,
0.2369619608,
-0.8984743953,
0.0281631183,
0.2093873471,
0.6169604659,
-0.2603583038,
0.2690842152,
0.0850549117,
0.6061731577,
0.077223137,
-0.1305485815,
0.0358792171,
-0.3691413105,
-0.380553484,
0.3603094518,
0.8443864584,
0.1655027866,
0.3156489432,
-0.0568168089,
-0.0493173674,
-0.3789474368,
-0.1943284422,
-0.6681501269,
-0.2776286006,
-0.2434367687,
-0.44331038,
-0.2780073285,
0.2792737484,
-0.2383835763,
-0.2217079401,
-0.2936456501,
-0.2381012291,
-0.5911727548,
-0.8767036796,
0.0992033184,
0.3309061825,
0.6260365844,
0.3189427257,
-1.0100380182,
0.2222433984,
0.8834843636,
0.7932885885,
-0.2381431013,
-0.4030241966,
-0.1146380603,
0.3476546705,
-0.664042592,
0.224974677,
-0.3195000887,
-0.2930761874,
-0.1312545091,
0.1180973053,
0.2463249862,
-0.4124428034,
0.5041875839,
-0.5242724419,
0.2687607408,
-0.2818875611,
-0.3716043532,
-0.346123606,
0.1335984468,
-0.9369097352,
1.1524288654,
0.251973033,
-0.610666275,
0.099417001,
-0.1654609889,
-0.3396514356,
0.6021782756,
-0.1454608142,
-0.0941033512,
0.1189140975,
-0.2039792687,
-0.0556451343,
-0.2896169424,
0.5290355682,
-0.1960742474,
-0.3985595107,
-0.0854341313,
-0.5301898122,
1.2895799875,
0.4437457621,
-0.225744918,
0.1103646755,
-0.2261410803,
0.0681296512,
0.4010237753,
-0.535993278,
-0.5664812922,
-0.1515427828,
0.2430498302,
0.2604985535,
0.6289986968,
-0.6117405891,
-0.0829464048,
-0.5588601232,
0.65189147,
0.7451803684,
-0.7286169529,
0.5938744545,
-0.0892627314,
0.42386958,
0.0320267975,
-0.03000932,
-0.2132568359,
-0.1946509778,
-0.3965739608,
0.0031594038,
0.4156706631,
0.6553781629,
-0.3495305479,
0.4349682331,
-0.3476232588,
-0.6136397719,
-0.5023540854,
0.2994322777,
0.1158279702,
0.6491153836,
-0.1800085306,
-0.4161426723,
-0.5441852808,
-0.704457581,
0.0384780169,
-0.4950584471,
0.0000293604,
0.0637008771,
-0.3676442206,
-0.0349593945,
0.7288566232,
-0.0278365985,
0.0120122181,
-0.779894352,
-0.1648402661,
0.0087028854,
0.3652256429,
0.3260646462,
-0.6433401704,
-0.6116364002,
0.4453465044,
-0.8547136188,
-0.1525207758,
0.1621148884,
-0.2663809359,
0.3657434881,
0.5869005322,
-0.185714215,
-0.0833444223,
0.8808974624,
0.0051646852,
0.4656974673,
-0.1035942584,
0.0607976392,
-1.1439936161,
-0.0334010646,
-0.1129726321,
-0.1494203955,
-0.9266537428,
0.4168455303,
0.2124785185,
-0.2120646387,
-0.7344095111,
0.5635576248,
-0.4335359931,
0.3910303116,
-0.3239761591,
0.4600852728,
-0.0688785911,
0.2069976032,
0.6493377686,
0.3350209892,
0.0433113649,
-0.3136511147,
0.4419340193,
0.0351851471,
-0.2232966572,
0.2501443923,
-0.4986790419,
0.1881408542,
-0.0841126367,
0.2439166605,
-0.6186050177,
-0.1895219386,
0.1785038114,
-0.0785281137,
0.2859516442,
0.0698977038,
-0.2868462503,
-0.3088653684,
-0.1315654963,
0.6162654161,
0.4017577171,
-0.5233108401,
0.6495808959,
0.3182652891,
-0.1336546242,
-0.5541881919,
-0.9833439589,
0.2538518608,
-0.3039501011,
-0.9989674687,
0.3637790978,
0.1340913475,
-0.2001516968,
-0.1572095752,
0.0736002326,
-0.2353871167,
0.4007339478,
-0.1961805969,
0.3621843457,
-0.992007494,
0.0410248116,
-0.3251661062,
0.0005033176,
-0.1241989285,
-0.4695866406,
0.6775633097,
-0.1473373175,
-0.3739164174,
-0.3262668252,
0.1842882633,
0.2875672579,
-0.5379107594,
0.4134564996,
0.5355075598,
-0.5993862152,
-0.1427227706,
-0.5130181909,
-0.0535212345,
-0.4996954501,
0.6735610366,
-0.1780386567,
-1.1461282969,
0.2686534226,
-0.1373652667,
0.1304706335,
0.1354153752,
0.5123485923,
0.1174702048,
0.6331021786,
1.0853654146,
-0.3592501283,
0.7344355583,
0.5232471824,
0.4761448205,
-0.3840363324,
0.0059249448,
-0.2154819369,
-0.2396970242,
-1.0568825006,
-0.4035339952,
0.0082704918,
0.2399305254,
-0.3600969315,
0.1731232256,
-0.4137183726,
0.53491956,
0.7319771647,
0.0939530507,
0.5296140313,
-0.1626169384,
-0.04978339,
-0.1747376025,
-0.6098342538,
-0.9128850698,
0.8126983643,
0.527314961,
0.7992523909,
0.1494168788,
0.7680310607,
-0.315669775,
0.1295383424,
-0.5198272467,
0.4582705796,
-0.8290104866,
-0.2662211061,
-0.4249002337,
-0.3801431954,
-0.8021702766,
0.1058744118,
0.2837294042,
-0.388153702,
-0.3348742127,
-0.0605932064,
-0.1718072444,
0.689455092,
-0.6291563511,
1.0280499458,
-0.7753592134,
-0.068900384,
-0.0421535186,
-0.5629948974,
1.0454967022,
-0.2756840885,
0.0338952951,
-0.3227189481,
0.0680002123,
0.2500603795,
-0.1537177116,
0.6616870761,
0.2124569863,
-0.2095658481,
0.3447090685,
0.1808151007,
0.0719548166,
-0.2138823271,
-0.3144752085,
0.3077687323,
-0.2321488708,
-0.4231317043,
-0.1830857396,
0.7275482416,
-0.9122461677,
-0.6899742484,
-0.1645315737,
-0.3895313442,
0.165328458,
0.4524121881,
0.003720931,
0.0340148322,
-0.587831378,
0.1500744969,
0.8840766549,
-0.667353332,
0.2887289226,
0.6425893903,
-0.4981403649,
-0.1221964732,
0.7176707387,
0.0280840993,
0.5245175362,
0.5316309333,
0.4700195491,
-0.1912340373,
-0.3799035847,
-0.4284657538,
0.2139654756,
-0.5396372676,
0.2567389905,
-0.338360399,
-0.7101611495,
-0.2243447304,
-0.1330491006,
-0.4074909985,
-0.1156471223,
-0.2848265767,
-0.354953289,
0.0066883876,
0.8683724999,
-0.1564240605,
0.312163204,
-0.7345383763,
0.0432603098,
0.2271004319,
0.2621558607,
-0.0030078113,
-0.4722604454,
-0.2076382786,
0.2313660085,
-0.3211610913,
-0.7189573646,
0.2369534224,
0.0506106652,
0.6257337928,
0.3448005617,
-0.0098400908,
0.5671175718,
-0.4250269234,
1.0105125904,
0.2066944689,
-0.9200609922,
0.5464287996,
-0.2265485972,
0.5697107911,
0.2884516418,
0.1578459442,
-1.1949465275,
-0.8456398845,
-0.2239389569,
-0.8574154377,
0.8321244121,
-0.4484271705,
0.462787956,
-0.0730123445,
0.0056988783,
0.0867886245,
-0.0813600346,
-1.2115244865,
-0.0888195783,
-0.2004254609,
-0.3598255813,
0.0139389075,
-0.2313995361,
0.1912930161,
-0.0479982793,
0.4438626766,
0.0183739476,
-0.2242203653,
-0.0700225458,
-0.3903100193,
-0.4333747327,
0.1161914989,
0.581874609,
0.7598496675,
0.0317877419,
0.3129366636,
0.2173027694,
-0.5123076439,
0.0311175268,
-0.0154096922,
-0.3423471153,
0.185627073,
0.2643298507,
0.5853145123,
0.1591807157,
-0.4986388981,
0.1272444874,
0.0358462259,
0.1001726165,
-0.2663441002,
-0.1244072616,
0.5653662682,
-0.0001021982,
0.3216082454,
-0.5550902486,
-0.3692874014,
-0.4242851138,
0.2696304023,
0.3454696834,
-0.5658426881,
-0.3373330832,
0.9485447407,
0.3528277576,
-0.3090987802,
0.9478262067,
0.0423966236,
-0.7138807774,
0.5692853928,
0.4776727259,
0.958363831,
-0.6269083619,
0.2776593566,
0.3856213689,
0.6889990568,
-0.0229705386,
0.1480444074,
0.3555226028,
-0.8316098452,
-0.4739726484,
-0.5563977957,
-0.4539757669,
0.1382405013,
-0.3857037723,
0.8429759145,
-0.4264587164,
0.1221568212,
-0.4312846363,
0.1618362516,
-0.3464891016,
0.0433067456,
0.8583828807,
1.1665295362,
-0.7748278379,
1.2081391811,
0.4400355518,
-0.3697851598,
-1.2609982491,
-0.1221278459,
0.0813896731,
-0.9580031037,
0.7148502469,
0.1065451875,
-0.2414223254,
-0.0347341225,
-0.3022323251,
-0.8256800175,
1.0360649824,
0.612169981,
-0.5642212629,
-0.0600846224,
0.5241564512,
0.60689044,
-0.3833850622,
0.3070032001,
0.5351577997,
0.3677107096,
-0.0237250011,
-1.1117744446,
-0.015465782,
0.0674978644,
0.1493756622,
0.2956618667,
-1.001563549,
0.9422266483,
-0.0273528509,
-0.3690818846,
0.0487550013,
0.8875086308,
0.4438474178,
0.0329136513,
0.3331294358,
0.3116874993,
0.9876685739,
-0.3563081026,
0.5047665238,
-0.6030484438,
-0.1025498211,
1.1344693899,
-0.5179207325,
0.7295610905,
0.2206426263,
-0.0368762799,
0.491073668,
1.0061026812,
0.176465258,
0.1491075605,
0.2326549143,
-0.4843655825,
-0.081001766,
-0.3933326602,
-0.3109742403,
0.6163716316,
0.0816452801,
-0.4279281497,
-0.3319757879,
-0.3049583733,
0.0013313914,
0.3988509178,
-0.2862255573,
0.701443851,
0.3289304376,
-0.4255815744,
0.4560112059,
0.2566514313,
0.8353106976,
-0.814360261,
0.3371841908,
-0.3960797787,
-0.0686921477,
-0.1808770597,
-0.8530279398,
0.2706519961,
-0.1585071832,
0.0444658436,
-0.3809674382,
0.5597689152,
-0.9302399158,
-0.4391109943,
0.4433845282,
0.5196769238,
-0.0350250863,
0.4226065576,
-0.4747997522,
0.1666134149,
0.230260402,
-0.0195382927,
0.1346266866,
0.8201246858,
-0.4786263406,
0.5456773639,
0.2508118749,
0.1797810644,
0.2560653687,
0.1773426384,
0.3973688483,
-0.8345193267,
-0.6359761953,
-1.0397218466,
0.3989211321,
0.1829244047,
-0.3053545058,
0.6303521991,
0.6670098901,
1.0267418623,
0.2274442166,
0.6910113096,
0.2810285091,
0.1706965715,
-0.2739463747,
0.6474669576,
-0.3770991564,
0.2188670486,
-0.0215703268,
-0.565707922,
-0.1452363133,
0.1796334982,
-0.2017343342,
0.035963539,
0.4197818041,
0.5137811303,
-0.1560702771,
0.4448391497,
0.2572881579,
0.1895785332,
0.2585511506,
0.7827282548,
1.0029492378,
-0.0168375447,
0.5450347662,
-0.4866667688,
-0.2597506344,
0.0882549286,
-0.98304528,
-0.4437650442,
-0.2820272148,
-0.1424357593,
-0.006033225,
-0.1808103174,
1.0081059933,
0.6050014496,
-0.701177597,
-0.8126444817,
0.130346477,
0.3236192465,
-0.082630679,
-0.2403545529,
0.0984085351,
-0.2494392693,
-0.9680162072,
0.2095759362,
0.5313488841,
0.1311741024,
-0.5168459415,
-0.1815452874,
-0.0755470097,
-0.0261013564,
0.6762510538,
0.2894105911,
-1.0653982162,
-0.2237342,
0.3105621934,
-0.5662925243,
0.2702707946,
0.5914362669,
-0.3524648249,
0.4684795141,
0.2870410681,
0.8088051677,
0.3019148707,
-0.0980570689,
1.1119163036,
-0.6612038016,
0.1675931662,
0.2773846984,
0.241765216,
0.563278079,
-0.3560242057,
0.525159061,
-0.107501395,
-0.4543655515,
-0.8759211302,
0.3355185986,
-0.845941186,
-0.249273181,
0.9335030913,
-0.1588997394,
-0.238200739,
0.0875986069,
-0.0059479172,
0.432697624,
0.0463418141,
0.4706795812,
0.9289318919,
0.2864398658,
-0.4347880483,
-0.4149057567,
0.1717845649,
0.3729916811,
-0.3876580596,
0.2051784247,
0.2718439996,
0.4605413675,
-0.2315324545,
0.7384443879,
-0.0750913247,
0.3463928103,
-0.4475727379,
0.1180531606,
0.1600143611,
0.1780476272,
-0.4812785089,
-0.0444821566,
0.5409667492,
0.0077810017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17438v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17438v4
|
CLOMO: Counterfactual Logical Modification with Large Language Models
| 2023-11-29T08:29:54 | 2024-06-07T04:27:54 |
Yinya Huang, Ruixin Hong, Hongming Zhang, Wei Shao, Zhicheng Yang, Dong Yu, Changshui Zhang, Xiaodan Liang, Linqi Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this study, we delve into the realm of counterfactual reasoning
capabilities of large language models (LLMs). Our primary objective is to
cultivate the counterfactual thought processes within LLMs and rigorously
assess these processes for their validity. Specifically, we introduce a novel
task, Counterfactual Logical Modification (CLOMO), and a high-quality
human-annotated benchmark. In this task, LLMs must adeptly alter a given
argumentative text to uphold a predetermined logical relationship. To
effectively evaluate a generation model's counterfactual capabilities, we
propose an innovative evaluation metric, the decomposed Self-Evaluation Score
(SES) to directly evaluate the natural language output of LLMs instead of
modeling the task as a multiple-choice problem. Analysis shows that the
proposed automatic metric aligns well with human preference. Our experimental
results show that while LLMs demonstrate a notable capacity for logical
counterfactual thinking, there remains a discernible gap between their current
abilities and human performance. Code and data are available at
https://github.com/Eleanor-H/CLOMO.
|
[
-0.5530959964,
-1.0385453701,
0.7152350545,
-0.1753793359,
-0.4836322665,
-0.2683953941,
-0.1466337591,
-0.6870932579,
0.0612923354,
0.5505128503,
-0.4646589458,
-0.1680150628,
-0.6185295582,
0.1384633482,
-0.4000230134,
0.8835652471,
0.0133631164,
0.033875294,
-0.5707057118,
-0.2609885633,
-0.5168641806,
-0.4197954535,
-0.37042135,
-0.5126727819,
0.2731656134,
0.2686752975,
0.67776829,
0.5869863033,
0.2308348864,
0.4771220684,
-0.0385424457,
0.0953320488,
-0.607727766,
0.2562966943,
-0.7591893077,
-0.3853657544,
-0.5936390758,
0.0680340976,
0.4883538783,
0.3521453738,
0.045098301,
0.445140928,
-0.1096972227,
0.5104807615,
-0.3875864446,
0.0166103784,
-1.0111553669,
-0.2099204361,
-0.0517837629,
-0.1788323969,
-0.3028352857,
-0.1718879193,
0.2510595322,
-0.5836014152,
0.2288996875,
0.0831887498,
0.4661087692,
0.4356878102,
-0.4597176611,
-0.2535910606,
-0.5258649588,
0.660859406,
-0.8001257181,
0.2393202931,
-0.0362485424,
-0.0599617362,
-0.2023881525,
-0.5626960993,
-0.6724020243,
-0.3761832416,
-0.0758522972,
-0.0760675445,
-0.3855581284,
0.0412934236,
0.5504399538,
0.2549062073,
-0.6147025228,
0.1636930555,
-0.2999182045,
-0.3112612069,
0.6451820135,
0.3281570971,
0.4574560523,
-0.0390272811,
-0.4742813408,
0.1704585552,
-0.6865599155,
-0.26552549,
0.3452840745,
-0.0868525282,
0.2064428777,
0.5270614028,
-0.3450212479,
0.6766526103,
0.053400062,
0.1898816377,
0.1826325059,
-0.2971295118,
-0.4599318802,
0.0410926528,
0.622379899,
0.6224646568,
0.2962542176,
0.3371066153,
-0.2907620668,
0.6755878925,
0.2985937893,
-0.8752831221,
-0.0169682316,
0.0779434666,
-0.3880525231,
-0.2142814249,
-0.2839462757,
-0.6672088504,
-0.6117553115,
-0.4445478022,
0.5104625821,
-0.3649344444,
-0.0495602675,
0.1771452278,
-0.2070958763,
-0.0953877494,
0.3619975448,
-0.5129373074,
0.1010432988,
0.5999538898,
0.5187552571,
0.1745373905,
-0.4038078785,
-0.5999244452,
0.0249690618,
-0.4686462581,
0.8998308182,
-0.6986115575,
-0.4789279401,
-0.2925879061,
-0.1782955825,
-0.1273575723,
-0.6442033052,
0.4241116345,
-0.2794114649,
0.2858905196,
-0.276539892,
-0.8058893085,
-0.1555972844,
0.5064647198,
-0.513402164,
0.7129523158,
-0.0239534043,
-0.6458892226,
0.3905653656,
-0.8293284178,
-0.4881094098,
0.1067301631,
-0.0622288845,
-0.2906728089,
0.1299155951,
0.0499073751,
0.0602419339,
-0.3525175452,
0.5888185501,
-0.5766553879,
-0.2250683755,
0.4065214097,
-0.4492194057,
0.6809347272,
0.1997413784,
-0.4384818077,
0.4387658834,
-0.6736330986,
-0.138765648,
0.1234074607,
-0.0466619171,
-0.4297014177,
-0.0015464508,
-0.4394029379,
0.3356334269,
0.5356292129,
-0.5217116475,
0.1407128721,
-0.5045505166,
0.5579115748,
0.8302677274,
-0.119809255,
0.2655438781,
-0.4712021351,
0.4118336439,
-0.1055110395,
0.3775416315,
-0.1078805029,
-0.4491680264,
-0.7660508156,
-0.3240530491,
0.0189338084,
0.5188085437,
-0.668396771,
0.3362033963,
0.0425093509,
-0.5794485807,
-0.3887144625,
0.4884653986,
0.5063841343,
0.8360193372,
0.4309787154,
-0.2456077188,
-0.8319277763,
-0.8802209496,
-0.5574449301,
-0.3696293533,
0.1892291307,
0.006338276,
0.8078709841,
-0.5128868818,
0.8379783034,
-0.4730639756,
-0.1340604424,
-0.2611702681,
0.3908526599,
0.1708403379,
0.400305897,
0.614649415,
-0.6330647469,
-0.0536616445,
-0.3045120537,
-0.5323286057,
-0.469979018,
-0.2511606216,
0.0619494803,
0.4093628228,
0.6895862222,
-0.8582283258,
0.4533728063,
0.4182027578,
-0.7044887543,
0.9112557769,
-0.3924276233,
0.2406986207,
-0.6119195223,
0.1735257506,
-0.0953277722,
-0.3069933057,
-0.6545914412,
0.2133920789,
-0.1649260968,
0.1876442134,
-0.5774091482,
0.8014287353,
-0.1306431144,
-0.1289520562,
-0.2428408861,
0.2727397084,
0.0062412312,
0.2403637767,
-0.0759049356,
0.5589846969,
0.3111146092,
-0.5243790746,
0.4658749402,
0.0721426457,
-0.7007626891,
0.6556304693,
-0.7814497352,
0.2210346013,
-0.2227030098,
0.4473069012,
-0.9702422023,
0.0181593243,
0.1860680282,
-0.2583592236,
-0.2169506699,
0.0340912826,
-0.5133157372,
-0.2248386741,
-0.370669812,
0.4172568917,
0.3296659589,
-0.3725045919,
0.6028689146,
0.1804300249,
-0.0869575441,
-0.2683936059,
-0.6140761375,
0.2822338343,
-0.3888087273,
-0.3589113355,
0.2821429074,
-0.6139063239,
-0.4950555563,
0.0277876519,
-0.009601092,
0.3296954036,
0.223749727,
0.1116482913,
0.4669419825,
-0.0489450432,
0.1252696365,
-0.0402928516,
-0.1460873336,
0.102595903,
-0.0971042886,
0.474368304,
-0.2496986836,
-0.1925920397,
-0.2521935999,
-0.0222855471,
0.7440993786,
-0.231777966,
0.4763982892,
0.4856112301,
-0.3433441818,
-0.2097970992,
-0.5948823094,
0.0473852083,
-0.425757736,
0.4233089983,
-0.4367586374,
-0.8223425746,
0.4938999414,
-0.0369545706,
-0.0068165944,
0.5888857841,
0.7580539584,
0.0340043381,
0.959854126,
0.0960756093,
0.1935490221,
0.4935019016,
-0.167921558,
0.1022711173,
-0.6793948412,
-0.0288654733,
-0.2939100266,
-0.2429284602,
-0.4491289258,
-0.4371035993,
0.2822576463,
-0.1287454963,
-0.4999221563,
0.3015029132,
-0.1553952992,
0.4005791247,
0.4150941372,
0.1601790488,
0.2572823167,
-0.620445013,
-0.0550683476,
0.1620584875,
-0.4960997701,
-0.581459403,
0.7696489096,
0.3347376883,
0.4073462784,
0.0812398344,
0.3779973984,
0.5327821374,
0.7069977522,
-0.6578819156,
0.9884761572,
-0.3249880672,
-0.7494518757,
-0.4889248908,
-0.4764995575,
-0.7031510472,
0.4934182763,
-0.380281359,
-0.6736738682,
-0.0569022223,
0.4382951558,
-0.226778686,
0.2603134513,
-0.7049135566,
1.0403274298,
-0.372330308,
-0.343252033,
-0.8099566102,
-0.3767201006,
0.3404128551,
-0.0008559981,
0.368773818,
-0.0553646386,
0.0702366754,
0.5375567079,
-0.3475569189,
1.0461416245,
-0.1542507708,
-0.2781342864,
0.4321998358,
0.5185385346,
0.3212471306,
0.0857369527,
-0.173247695,
0.2289016843,
0.0930992663,
-0.1940709949,
-0.6863358021,
0.7622300982,
-0.4243432879,
-1.1303611994,
-0.3577666283,
-0.7545227408,
-0.2149551064,
0.4826951325,
0.0260265376,
0.5622549653,
-0.6729221344,
0.0962105617,
0.4447404146,
-0.3864409626,
0.2965687513,
0.498409301,
-0.3434128165,
-0.6104695201,
0.5595701933,
0.1641849875,
0.3567879796,
0.3267315626,
0.6215774417,
-0.4622352719,
-0.3672157824,
-0.5594826937,
0.0654722229,
-0.7311644554,
-0.0654017776,
-0.2449170202,
0.2044557184,
-0.4850363135,
-0.1812348515,
-0.1539067179,
-0.3103858829,
-0.2982701659,
-0.1767133623,
-0.1581235379,
0.681319654,
-0.0401833467,
-0.1807900369,
-0.6187039018,
0.5400744677,
0.5981858969,
0.181791842,
-0.0752766281,
-0.6353143454,
0.0696868002,
0.1653072685,
-0.122411333,
-0.6242457628,
0.1881150901,
-0.0325313024,
0.5816247463,
0.473526299,
0.1670456529,
0.8472159505,
-0.4148605466,
0.5812253356,
0.3215096295,
-1.3033380508,
0.5925968289,
-0.3314180076,
0.5329323411,
0.3589589596,
-0.0679648668,
-0.3223471642,
-0.3770529926,
-0.6158695817,
-0.3571208417,
0.3333952427,
-0.1121401861,
0.0742462873,
-0.1028963774,
0.0411148034,
0.1860814095,
0.2107746154,
-0.6376563311,
0.3111184835,
-0.2667902708,
-0.2281393707,
-0.2286205739,
-0.3612188995,
-0.1864079982,
-0.3367060721,
0.6048378944,
-0.1099884361,
-0.3670148253,
0.5002370477,
-0.3568587601,
-0.2444860637,
0.56064713,
0.8769376874,
0.94899863,
-0.0364377536,
0.3628833294,
0.5136958957,
0.0608098805,
-0.0720128268,
-0.0425461717,
-0.2461815476,
-0.2445845157,
0.5379168391,
0.8633698821,
0.2539893389,
-0.9938037395,
0.2414178997,
0.1576668918,
-0.2301853448,
-0.1237173751,
0.2523955703,
0.0104023796,
0.3025797307,
0.0043180152,
0.2307488322,
0.1102028713,
-0.9812446237,
0.1182097197,
0.4263268113,
-0.1805866212,
-0.4127808511,
0.5380769968,
0.3292351067,
-0.3624100983,
0.3812547624,
-0.2207697779,
-0.7988218665,
0.6167268157,
0.7184298635,
0.7671872973,
-0.37223351,
0.253849715,
0.3567824364,
0.4682392776,
-0.0350018069,
0.1218998209,
-0.0118171535,
-0.8995239735,
-0.2690224648,
-0.2445963323,
-0.2352038026,
0.2296663225,
-0.1717879474,
0.3302536011,
-0.4722919762,
-0.1560264528,
-0.130412221,
-0.1094724536,
-0.6231296062,
0.4641280472,
0.1914896071,
0.8406509757,
-0.7353873849,
0.6669256091,
0.7750141621,
-0.0885160565,
-0.0293862857,
-0.1794415712,
-0.0474983826,
-0.6183271408,
0.6359412074,
0.2544216216,
-0.4839611351,
-0.3615700603,
-0.4520062208,
-0.4816252589,
0.8278053403,
0.662927568,
-0.8076612353,
0.2104873955,
0.1990928799,
0.8858739138,
-0.4609272778,
0.271038264,
0.5577322245,
0.5932615399,
-0.1769749075,
-0.8872864246,
0.3458825052,
-0.0322821774,
-0.1551578343,
0.1654224992,
-0.6333008409,
0.5058783293,
-0.4820037484,
-0.2331071496,
0.1847196072,
0.4601091146,
0.3171807826,
0.6928783059,
1.0830169916,
0.8268783689,
0.5348722935,
0.2958194017,
0.8122038841,
-0.3507189155,
0.3363779485,
1.2264961004,
-0.3784258068,
0.6719532609,
0.5165280104,
0.1603215337,
0.5865974426,
0.1546797901,
0.0234562457,
0.1400233954,
0.2690633833,
0.0088531962,
-0.6887456775,
-0.2072593272,
-0.07075008,
0.6590625048,
0.4542725682,
-0.2648111582,
-0.0310786255,
-0.26260674,
0.165434584,
0.3985980451,
-0.3203279674,
0.5431783795,
0.0640068725,
-0.8841797709,
0.3753594756,
-0.1345126331,
0.4247871935,
-0.3723249435,
-0.2180348635,
-0.0372028463,
0.1598284543,
-0.1462616026,
-0.8136941791,
0.2634840608,
0.1067300364,
-0.0520668477,
-0.3580047786,
0.8034233451,
-0.2827976346,
-0.4826322496,
0.3916729987,
0.275765866,
-0.2433307916,
0.2200510651,
-0.7576088905,
0.0935755894,
0.0262583289,
-0.2982366383,
0.1005743667,
0.2979782224,
-0.1260195374,
0.710031271,
0.6617823839,
0.021280542,
-0.40267241,
0.3098124266,
0.6481471062,
-0.7237585187,
-0.6016392112,
-1.0712354183,
0.3351969123,
-0.1330549866,
-0.5908147693,
0.5588984489,
0.4501561224,
0.9670736194,
-0.1166974902,
0.6907138228,
-0.0685272217,
0.3645679951,
-0.5530478954,
0.3747904301,
-0.4408862293,
0.2803292871,
-0.3427838087,
-0.7048583031,
-0.0910543129,
0.3187943399,
-0.7015723586,
-0.174633801,
0.5676315427,
0.7718818188,
0.159602493,
-0.0169677511,
0.5479297042,
0.6231734157,
0.3048219979,
0.5616902709,
1.0690262318,
-0.1636800021,
0.4688642323,
0.165661782,
-0.2332695276,
-0.1529210359,
-1.0441678762,
-0.9811403751,
-0.4695078731,
-0.408411175,
-0.0131119713,
0.0851327479,
0.9944562912,
0.2461265177,
-0.6554849148,
-0.052879598,
-0.0299513098,
0.31341663,
-0.2274128944,
-0.1885020137,
-0.0450064391,
-0.1245671436,
-0.6689670086,
0.54561764,
0.2795274556,
-0.2508191764,
-0.3575741649,
-0.0539647266,
-0.2646008134,
0.4499483109,
0.7984791398,
0.0638031363,
-0.8371913433,
-0.6419208646,
-0.3233326674,
0.163827315,
-0.2013038397,
0.9921162128,
-0.8519186974,
0.7082070708,
0.767469883,
0.3972613215,
0.2313981205,
0.2209235281,
0.5092243552,
-0.1423617601,
-0.0378888994,
-0.0470799915,
0.6967772245,
0.2826704085,
-0.2213381976,
0.3608690202,
0.4985355437,
-0.4188610613,
-0.8228577375,
0.4903498888,
-0.5705143213,
-0.6858958006,
1.0796185732,
-0.0206572711,
0.0282609705,
0.0118971234,
-0.3404702544,
0.249458611,
-0.0989132002,
1.1330599785,
0.6557762623,
-0.1186947003,
0.1156201288,
-0.3224209547,
0.1343336999,
0.6030346751,
-0.798723042,
0.0679662377,
0.7502627373,
0.4895043373,
0.1208405122,
0.5462850928,
-0.0817076787,
0.2677583396,
-0.0808133483,
-0.0042134975,
-0.1667803079,
-0.2112404406,
-0.2360724658,
-0.0067261076,
-0.075283125,
0.0085848104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17429v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17429v1
|
TARGET: Template-Transferable Backdoor Attack Against Prompt-based NLP Models via GPT4
| 2023-11-29T08:12:09 | 2023-11-29T08:12:09 |
Zihao Tan, Qingliang Chen, Yongjian Huang, Chen Liang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Prompt-based learning has been widely applied in many low-resource NLP tasks
such as few-shot scenarios. However, this paradigm has been shown to be
vulnerable to backdoor attacks. Most of the existing attack methods focus on
inserting manually predefined templates as triggers in the pre-training phase
to train the victim model and utilize the same triggers in the downstream task
to perform inference, which tends to ignore the transferability and
stealthiness of the templates. In this work, we propose a novel approach of
TARGET (Template-trAnsfeRable backdoor attack aGainst prompt-basEd NLP models
via GPT4), which is a data-independent attack method. Specifically, we first
utilize GPT4 to reformulate manual templates to generate tone-strong and normal
templates, and the former are injected into the model as a backdoor trigger in
the pre-training phase. Then, we not only directly employ the above templates
in the downstream task, but also use GPT4 to generate templates with similar
tone to the above templates to carry out transferable attacks. Finally we have
conducted extensive experiments on five NLP datasets and three BERT series
models, with experimental results justifying that our TARGET method has better
attack performance and stealthiness compared to the two-external baseline
methods on direct attacks, and in addition achieves satisfactory attack
capability in the unseen tone-similar templates.
|
[
-0.0810882449,
-0.4981816709,
0.4187660217,
0.1025890261,
-0.0996982828,
-0.0534199029,
-0.0570018739,
-0.1124505848,
-0.0656619817,
0.4272839725,
-0.7880679369,
-0.6412520409,
-0.6663383842,
0.2064803988,
-0.374334842,
1.1296234131,
0.1803426594,
-0.1537744999,
0.5233095288,
-0.0429629162,
-0.8989875913,
-0.7127413154,
-0.6624794006,
0.2424415201,
0.6544623971,
-0.1374231279,
0.4685555398,
0.1331283152,
0.2751472294,
0.1964925677,
0.2820239067,
-0.7444672585,
-0.4101059735,
0.1761292964,
-0.5350185633,
-0.5405392647,
-0.3686079383,
0.2654686272,
0.5353763103,
0.1381016374,
0.0105219493,
0.0770788938,
0.2486847043,
0.3096005917,
-0.5164075494,
0.1414028257,
-1.0586205721,
0.2338415086,
-0.2977440953,
-0.0823768452,
-0.6222197413,
-0.2199181169,
-0.1205675453,
-0.4061883092,
0.36977005,
-0.0458525792,
0.5012910366,
0.0836003274,
-0.1761876941,
-0.3544079661,
-0.2577585578,
0.6215211153,
-0.7415547371,
0.404311806,
0.0933413804,
0.3703761697,
-0.2870954573,
-0.7554036975,
-0.5369082093,
-0.2244461775,
-0.0114266537,
0.2983570099,
-0.564348042,
-0.021743061,
0.5473842025,
-0.0531448871,
-0.793823719,
0.1306332946,
-0.1953868568,
-0.3253644407,
0.2337984294,
0.067178674,
0.4057977796,
-0.4077497721,
-0.6343708634,
-0.1062970459,
-0.7443292737,
0.0138467615,
0.4347284436,
0.6803717613,
-0.2325600982,
0.3984124064,
0.1287425309,
0.7236910462,
0.2610037029,
0.0220042914,
0.1038247272,
-0.5389618874,
-0.0084841736,
0.2446390837,
0.7394511104,
0.0874189809,
-0.2039841264,
-0.1937500238,
-0.4014293551,
-0.1103615388,
0.5213476419,
-0.7203848958,
-0.1630032063,
0.1908300966,
-0.3776317835,
-0.536532104,
-0.1164690778,
-1.0111654997,
-0.160529986,
0.2840744853,
0.6344547272,
-0.6384603977,
-0.016747307,
-0.1820452213,
-0.0867067948,
0.6251347065,
0.3068044186,
-0.9914758205,
0.2239445299,
0.8378782868,
1.070127368,
-0.253125757,
-0.2244696468,
-1.0333877802,
0.4214386642,
-0.2321172953,
0.426525414,
-0.4516831636,
-0.4775866568,
-0.056488011,
-0.1090256423,
-0.2757723331,
0.004315733,
0.5163132548,
-0.6919683814,
0.5968801975,
-0.36099419,
-0.342894882,
-0.3126978874,
0.6213840842,
-0.7739959955,
0.7599505186,
0.1580896527,
-0.8873727322,
0.180088535,
-0.5766456127,
-0.2442276776,
0.0424428545,
-0.2412699163,
-0.2763929665,
0.030579716,
0.3533835411,
0.5548189878,
-0.0929636881,
0.1354230344,
-0.1786821932,
-0.3454976082,
-0.0100217527,
-0.6069665551,
0.8902338743,
-0.0543374754,
-0.774810195,
0.1298124194,
-0.666441083,
-0.1074402705,
0.2987441421,
-0.0886401311,
-0.2948655784,
-0.4455569983,
-0.3372475207,
0.3740017712,
0.202429533,
-0.6332164407,
0.4872325957,
-0.5708783865,
0.091074653,
0.9136093855,
0.1675313562,
0.2918486893,
-0.2774468958,
0.8758730888,
-0.3382099867,
0.180263117,
-0.2776468992,
-0.7619419694,
-0.012205,
-0.5464074612,
0.2379772663,
0.6381480098,
-0.9843198657,
0.3265004158,
0.044536937,
-0.6310178041,
-0.2418089658,
-0.1309259236,
0.5311729908,
0.9910795689,
0.6057288647,
-0.3205808699,
-0.2411756366,
-0.4544017017,
-0.7911528349,
-0.1649313122,
-0.1926814914,
0.1327546984,
0.4220099449,
-0.1513427198,
0.8673536181,
-0.3870994449,
-0.3224258125,
-0.4380560219,
0.1593839228,
0.5166896582,
0.703971386,
0.9386876225,
-0.5128551126,
-0.5147095919,
-0.5305597782,
-0.6838318706,
-0.2046131492,
-0.4010773599,
0.0323474444,
-0.1676922292,
0.2894753814,
-0.6400119662,
0.6242004037,
0.6672670245,
-0.3689475954,
0.6707812548,
0.2057023048,
-0.0047985627,
-1.2196651697,
-0.0110346479,
-0.1019520834,
-0.0071410784,
-0.8580977917,
0.1107646078,
0.1145320982,
-0.5485428572,
-0.6377912164,
0.754571557,
-0.1953037977,
-0.2042055726,
0.020085467,
-0.3834343851,
-0.0828145742,
0.7045827508,
-0.2224022895,
0.7431280017,
0.6597747207,
-0.29016909,
0.3320190907,
0.4393309057,
0.1186891794,
0.7138320208,
-0.7157899737,
0.5421918631,
0.209905535,
0.6062347293,
-0.8805766106,
0.1690481752,
1.0157846212,
-0.518134892,
0.6342552304,
-0.471997112,
-0.3616998196,
0.0030804398,
-0.5371639132,
0.3470359743,
0.5128486156,
-0.7176339626,
0.84247756,
-0.4185921848,
-0.4006203115,
-0.6244325638,
-0.3830596507,
0.3528966606,
-0.3771038949,
-0.2762334943,
0.3899536133,
-0.0487339646,
0.1926085353,
-0.2794011235,
-0.1932130903,
0.1616005152,
0.0303323735,
0.2152565271,
0.1475963742,
-0.1575245708,
-0.2415259629,
-0.0566580072,
-0.3096106052,
0.2593091428,
-0.6441320777,
0.5545942783,
0.0655433238,
-0.5811046958,
-0.6507048607,
0.6233489513,
0.301646173,
-0.2530264854,
0.6534386277,
0.6666287184,
-0.259896189,
-0.2511249483,
-0.3227015734,
-0.5859498382,
-0.5269118547,
0.3529475331,
-0.5899075866,
-0.3909149766,
0.2961162031,
0.0964609385,
0.3176331222,
0.3179412484,
0.3988368213,
0.1212896928,
0.7460614443,
0.3697854578,
-0.2366287559,
0.5458881855,
-0.0702675283,
-0.065270789,
-0.7059880495,
-0.1343113631,
-0.5019720197,
-0.1571805924,
-0.3765231073,
-0.2034895867,
0.1619597971,
-0.2280439138,
-0.2593789101,
0.5219546556,
-0.3708668947,
-0.0349086262,
0.6468746662,
0.1277693361,
0.1271054149,
-0.0792819336,
-0.245566994,
-0.2757790685,
-0.7929095626,
-0.2352255732,
1.3303955793,
0.4054554701,
0.7809494734,
0.1481748968,
0.9114603996,
0.3784918189,
0.2558979392,
-0.4421346188,
0.5719968677,
0.0810394809,
-0.4720418453,
-0.1570420712,
-0.3546226919,
-1.006857872,
0.1888831854,
-0.1586003304,
-0.8324275017,
0.2302200198,
0.0849562362,
-0.2455790043,
0.6375920773,
-0.6568417549,
0.9708913565,
-0.4299522936,
-0.2087102532,
0.1703612208,
-0.7457498312,
0.2759324908,
-0.513250351,
0.1007361859,
0.1191307455,
-0.0207401291,
0.8964765668,
-0.2646560669,
1.1227200031,
-0.5464320779,
-0.2397719622,
-0.0247923341,
0.2720736563,
0.9850724339,
0.1895643026,
0.072269991,
0.5946599245,
-0.3905934095,
-0.4542682767,
-0.800471127,
0.3573362529,
-0.5037134886,
-0.9316949248,
-0.7234498858,
-0.3128176332,
-0.2377077639,
0.3301868737,
0.5246440768,
0.5706070662,
-0.0364312604,
-0.1050067768,
0.3892770112,
-0.4058360755,
0.5302813649,
0.5704266429,
0.2130093873,
-0.3401922882,
0.8867313862,
-0.1760448515,
0.3001107275,
0.4138802886,
0.2570001483,
-0.28714329,
-0.7894620895,
-0.1949588507,
0.1580963582,
-0.5737964511,
-0.3264243007,
-0.7613400817,
-0.1617068499,
-0.5712468624,
-0.3209696412,
-0.4532933831,
-0.0803825557,
-0.2410757542,
-0.0707495511,
0.3734430671,
0.5311029553,
-0.1212665811,
0.4289057553,
-0.934161067,
0.4755538404,
0.6258117557,
0.0945766866,
-0.1953204274,
-0.7669475079,
0.1856758147,
-0.2503986657,
-0.1362881064,
-1.4691393375,
0.5597189069,
-0.0200849362,
0.482691884,
0.1957276762,
0.2509930432,
-0.0165132433,
-0.6916335821,
0.6925848126,
0.4309563935,
-1.0282227993,
0.604082644,
-0.5538085103,
0.2637925446,
0.5788128376,
0.37873891,
-0.2735080123,
-0.4181517661,
-0.8410862088,
-0.7097467184,
0.631449461,
0.3721440732,
0.1831587851,
0.2171602696,
0.352014184,
0.3275888562,
0.3377567232,
-0.79327178,
-0.0771888942,
-0.625600636,
-0.2078976184,
0.1212261692,
-0.04524865,
-0.1425659508,
0.1101705581,
0.4420725107,
-0.1966283172,
0.3974907398,
0.0443870276,
-0.0022702569,
0.4504582286,
0.2814902961,
0.2773050964,
0.2472535223,
-0.3262033463,
-0.031624373,
0.2436728925,
-0.8160911202,
0.3222039938,
0.3309620619,
-0.3112949133,
0.1497695148,
0.6335963011,
0.6200825572,
0.398126781,
-0.1398133487,
0.8977778554,
-0.3005854487,
0.0359464549,
-0.1748202741,
0.0287944768,
-0.3447178006,
0.3415442109,
0.4727835655,
0.1638813168,
-0.0466146246,
-0.4625194669,
0.4401320815,
0.4701513946,
-0.6501941085,
-0.6775839329,
0.6207978725,
0.1520080268,
-0.2936585248,
0.5328178406,
-0.097760126,
-0.8580899239,
0.3851582408,
0.841260016,
1.0800439119,
-0.5777739882,
0.0097307004,
0.0703179315,
0.5798541307,
0.2213467658,
0.2409403771,
-0.0214553997,
-0.5826796293,
-0.1822064072,
-0.221995458,
-0.4742166996,
0.2402434647,
-0.7922415733,
0.2879431546,
-0.704598248,
0.0962461531,
-0.3508514166,
-0.3189661205,
-0.6898609996,
0.2270268351,
-0.0867049769,
0.7906997204,
-0.8077146411,
0.8120442033,
0.2568086386,
-0.2496198416,
-0.8843201995,
0.3784561455,
0.1610694379,
-0.8619983196,
0.7837770581,
0.2222123593,
0.096496813,
0.1787358671,
-0.4197948575,
-0.7946050167,
0.8336525559,
0.4941445887,
-0.5787846446,
-0.40126881,
-0.2604981363,
-0.0345072262,
-0.0963405371,
-0.0466593653,
0.4151098132,
0.5032452941,
-0.0240318589,
-0.6427420974,
0.5672742724,
0.005802792,
-0.3376600444,
-0.1105584726,
-0.3620982766,
1.0182334185,
0.0370922051,
-0.1513295621,
-0.1847640723,
0.7232819796,
0.4630347788,
0.2648876309,
0.4982497692,
0.4732404351,
0.4980288446,
0.1108018309,
1.0596050024,
-0.1966770291,
0.0745905191,
1.2731702328,
-0.4846461117,
0.5986195803,
0.2485313118,
-0.0472582541,
0.3169018626,
0.263025254,
-0.4404912293,
0.8753519058,
0.0801069438,
-0.1827760488,
0.4310119152,
0.4071065187,
-0.7374070287,
0.5955359936,
0.4224580526,
-0.1788672358,
-0.4139401913,
0.2619714141,
0.3205405772,
-0.0927067697,
-0.4512686729,
0.7752541304,
0.0688498467,
-0.3610177934,
0.5158127546,
0.0232915152,
0.8621641397,
-1.0197459459,
-0.0777012631,
-0.105476059,
-0.188266173,
0.0094988542,
-0.3424855471,
0.1514055729,
0.2614115775,
0.1503138691,
-0.2513071597,
0.7651588321,
-0.0041781706,
-0.2124485672,
0.2336883545,
0.3109917641,
-0.0790908784,
-0.3759887218,
-0.9203406572,
-0.1243384555,
0.1278318763,
-0.314751327,
0.5229839087,
0.4070451856,
0.0853519142,
0.3447996676,
0.7579419613,
0.3857415915,
0.119786188,
-0.1611510068,
1.0364371538,
-0.9196466208,
-0.9564635754,
-0.8475903869,
0.0992621258,
0.0297604464,
-0.1748961061,
1.1341001987,
0.3588636518,
0.4487392604,
-0.0737630501,
1.0005156994,
0.2300221026,
0.4480241835,
-0.8732937574,
0.709569037,
0.0685564652,
0.3457247913,
-0.808111608,
-0.9801293015,
-0.1859030426,
0.16492109,
-0.4146437049,
0.2103648782,
0.747200191,
0.5685898662,
0.0418117009,
-0.0072509749,
0.2777548432,
0.2362148017,
0.6898030639,
0.7126259208,
0.8101707697,
-0.1797659248,
0.5798341036,
-0.0060844235,
-0.2702270448,
-0.0596457161,
-1.1194987297,
-1.1528409719,
-0.2338135839,
-0.2618627846,
-0.5214490294,
0.3930469453,
0.5450072289,
0.4326790273,
-0.7985073328,
0.3183332086,
-0.0133553864,
-0.0209779684,
-0.2284025848,
-0.1967354119,
0.6588999629,
-0.2638719678,
-0.4425486326,
0.7567508221,
0.1829922944,
0.239645794,
-0.0945120752,
0.2430725545,
-0.1063521802,
0.0395189375,
0.135807097,
0.6051623821,
-0.5090853572,
-0.4057681859,
-0.2473982573,
-0.0412559956,
-0.0735565349,
0.9195556641,
-0.9707670212,
0.2325188667,
0.2526418567,
0.8588312864,
0.2326267511,
0.0820335075,
0.8732076883,
-1.1829779148,
0.4402893484,
0.5415397286,
0.2476464361,
0.3292426467,
-0.6097131371,
0.2905532718,
0.5804806948,
0.0522233211,
-0.7632310987,
0.3915744722,
-0.9908069968,
-0.4300918281,
1.0390490294,
-0.3718619645,
-0.2376860529,
-0.2463911772,
-0.1870342642,
0.158756718,
-0.60959512,
0.6303085685,
0.1966257691,
0.2345891148,
0.1060464755,
-0.6066390276,
0.6890258789,
0.2891272902,
-0.6473472714,
-0.1847259253,
0.1157856435,
0.2780911922,
0.0504607707,
0.4201936722,
-0.1598931402,
0.2779707611,
0.1510971338,
-0.1286903322,
-0.2450465411,
-0.2248073667,
-0.7077211142,
0.5686563253,
-0.4232799411,
-0.4603270888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02181v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02181v1
|
How Generative-AI can be Effectively used in Government Chatbots
| 2023-11-29T07:27:15 | 2023-11-29T07:27:15 |
Zeteng Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, econ.GN, q-fin.EC
|
With the rapid development of artificial intelligence and breakthroughs in
machine learning and natural language processing, intelligent
question-answering robots have become widely used in government affairs. This
paper conducts a horizontal comparison between Guangdong Province's government
chatbots, ChatGPT, and Wenxin Ernie, two large language models, to analyze the
strengths and weaknesses of existing government chatbots and AIGC technology.
The study finds significant differences between government chatbots and large
language models. China's government chatbots are still in an exploratory stage
and have a gap to close to achieve "intelligence." To explore the future
direction of government chatbots more deeply, this research proposes targeted
optimization paths to help generative AI be effectively applied in government
chatbot conversations.
|
[
-0.4346656501,
-0.9800015688,
0.5482464433,
0.1587650925,
-0.0388849415,
0.2884704471,
-0.2990145683,
-0.3211140633,
-0.2602474391,
0.4773585498,
-0.3855655193,
-0.3333186209,
-0.3784195483,
0.0484654754,
-0.8155819774,
0.5850614905,
0.4720316529,
0.0931466818,
-0.2613301575,
0.2144789249,
-0.4309433401,
-0.4330745339,
-1.0715185404,
-0.5145186186,
0.1352093965,
0.1688806415,
1.0426756144,
0.2779868841,
0.5934949517,
0.4914585054,
0.0505436175,
-0.0831729397,
-0.3243735433,
-0.2840369046,
0.098598294,
-0.6809384227,
-0.3148534,
-0.2072970569,
0.4281280935,
0.2440363616,
-0.559959352,
-0.1751135886,
-0.0090634339,
0.3899552226,
-0.2392203659,
0.5596695542,
-0.8294590712,
0.0738938004,
-0.2083038837,
0.0013593212,
-0.2068452984,
-0.6959828138,
0.3669443727,
-0.401823014,
-0.0615984015,
-0.0769293979,
0.7833914161,
0.2225924432,
-0.1585596502,
-0.5703136921,
-0.7719488144,
0.5887905359,
-0.9929180741,
0.0899992287,
0.3685897887,
0.6257968545,
-0.2173683345,
-0.7705032229,
-0.7551352978,
-0.6091716886,
-0.0393001586,
0.2612552941,
-0.3946831822,
0.2878164649,
0.1904744506,
0.3876459002,
-0.7276533842,
0.288834691,
-0.5147584677,
-0.1280803233,
0.6964673996,
0.0628094748,
0.5530665517,
-0.5137847662,
-0.1988672614,
-0.3771741688,
-0.5559867024,
0.158282727,
0.5721652508,
0.3187690973,
-0.0022172818,
0.317642957,
-0.0472326502,
0.5257439613,
-0.1105520055,
-0.0128254369,
0.0756927952,
-0.3600024283,
-0.4877460897,
-0.0567157865,
1.0209320784,
0.1986403018,
0.4529900849,
-0.1369165182,
0.0157136042,
-0.0118169859,
0.3414005339,
-0.6036705971,
-0.100906074,
0.4822011888,
-0.4726812243,
-0.1572307646,
0.261922121,
-0.7150507569,
-0.2885706127,
-0.1646396518,
0.3462480307,
-0.3146204054,
-0.2989315093,
-0.1080996171,
-0.3509856761,
0.5477472544,
0.2307851613,
-1.1409187317,
-0.0694275275,
0.961760819,
0.8561602831,
0.0732190013,
-0.056373667,
-0.1925743371,
-0.2991043925,
-0.4212696552,
0.6832796931,
-0.4433622062,
-0.5320193172,
0.1533195078,
-0.3374752402,
-0.0919079259,
-0.8642284274,
0.327346772,
-0.2700014412,
0.3716068566,
0.0422833338,
-0.2918530107,
-0.0772739872,
0.305963546,
-0.4547104836,
0.558196485,
0.2686968148,
-0.3240758181,
0.3987497985,
-0.6458287835,
-0.2455247194,
0.1278273314,
-0.2970739603,
-0.3186980188,
-0.1279492527,
0.3544497192,
0.3073481023,
-0.3439542949,
0.4701334536,
0.022162756,
-0.2572329044,
0.3113852739,
-0.5413841605,
1.0736578703,
0.2551985681,
-0.2309044152,
0.3555346727,
-0.492390573,
0.2065366358,
-0.0586507916,
-0.3497699201,
0.1272774041,
0.4866572618,
-0.1264786869,
0.0492902622,
0.0931961983,
-0.4699723125,
0.239038229,
-0.6003901362,
0.7925029397,
0.7369220853,
-0.3688386083,
0.3136956096,
-0.2046189755,
0.5481312871,
-0.4753402174,
0.4495754838,
-0.0180743858,
-0.6958687901,
-0.649618268,
-0.075021863,
0.3104791939,
0.9500049949,
-0.7723412514,
0.7026405931,
-0.0024871032,
-0.5933946371,
-0.5563269258,
-0.2342571169,
0.08525455,
0.3772561848,
0.1348235905,
-0.1090478823,
-0.148164928,
-0.9975446463,
-0.084568657,
-0.6974096894,
-0.3106549382,
0.4199702442,
0.3465727866,
-0.1886839718,
0.7400635481,
-0.1572596729,
0.0067821271,
-0.4809591174,
0.3878709376,
0.0875945464,
0.0353318974,
0.5677435398,
-0.9413489103,
-0.4851596653,
0.224340409,
-0.5407756567,
0.0325563438,
-0.3265302777,
0.0704297945,
-0.1548520476,
0.5273929238,
-0.7148159146,
0.5159317255,
0.5843020082,
0.0271012913,
0.2505086362,
-0.0878321305,
0.2382582724,
-0.972312808,
-0.1084203571,
-0.4837090671,
-0.0373792984,
-0.8680656552,
-0.1322920322,
0.0332932286,
-0.3492107987,
-0.3499949574,
0.1976509392,
-0.1148517281,
-0.0336825103,
-0.241852358,
0.2818647623,
-0.6320860982,
0.2572708428,
-0.2507067621,
1.1265432835,
0.6897598505,
-0.5429422259,
0.934184432,
0.4209634364,
-0.5481826067,
0.26130867,
-0.9001265168,
0.0843108445,
-0.1507141888,
0.0990894884,
-0.9899160862,
-0.4153638482,
0.2105111331,
-0.5454804301,
0.0739196688,
0.2623780668,
-0.5057759881,
-0.8084089756,
-0.2616584897,
-0.1002705395,
0.8248144984,
-0.4751803279,
0.4481807947,
0.419701308,
-0.3566355109,
-0.3809801042,
-0.909727037,
0.2661173642,
-0.1793358624,
-0.7074953318,
0.1597465724,
0.2290045023,
-0.1332761645,
0.0548406318,
0.2580670118,
0.0368517227,
0.2202211022,
-0.0723779798,
-0.0527945273,
-0.2495501935,
0.2188854963,
-0.2311561108,
0.0364836194,
0.1955215633,
0.1371880919,
0.9423689246,
-0.0591130331,
-0.5462609529,
-0.6068422794,
0.3587643206,
0.4849079549,
-0.1924142689,
0.6628112793,
0.4444749355,
-0.0230192412,
-0.0209500305,
-0.3546768129,
-0.0688629523,
-0.5326084495,
0.5544111133,
0.1262883693,
-0.7624760866,
0.4741243422,
0.0677068755,
0.2640448511,
0.4026216567,
0.542335391,
0.356941402,
1.1674654484,
0.4150550067,
-0.4828394055,
0.6727664471,
0.0158041716,
0.4915553331,
-0.3232626319,
-0.237105608,
-0.6680622101,
0.1533463895,
-1.0580294132,
0.1456407905,
0.3347110748,
-0.16417858,
-0.1892440766,
0.6104524732,
-0.5837405324,
0.1331727803,
0.7910729647,
-0.0557804927,
-0.1125245318,
-0.0847449079,
0.5176532269,
0.505744338,
-0.6761538386,
-0.5031340122,
0.8182883263,
0.2054959387,
0.8665830493,
0.0375606231,
0.5139005184,
0.2572567463,
0.0708813071,
-0.7358535528,
0.6247727871,
-0.3066593111,
-0.426135987,
-0.6659000516,
-0.5502693653,
-1.0087623596,
0.0939445123,
-0.0731469467,
-0.7977513075,
-0.2003204077,
-0.0002815384,
-0.4297764301,
0.340939939,
-0.9899656177,
0.8258607984,
-0.4656949639,
0.4953562319,
-0.3630529046,
-0.5243936181,
-0.0056206104,
0.1227701828,
-0.2332915813,
-0.0841238424,
0.413471669,
0.4313085377,
-0.297968775,
0.4169849157,
-0.0629227012,
-0.3189788461,
0.6974669695,
-0.5598595142,
0.2696498632,
-0.0395822935,
-0.2121518254,
0.1610621065,
-0.2569896281,
-0.2348407656,
-0.7144970894,
0.3779350817,
-0.8241556883,
-1.0543351173,
-0.204926461,
-0.4337859154,
-0.0654628128,
0.076191552,
0.3374415636,
0.4482625723,
-0.4636159241,
0.3869519532,
0.1138503551,
-0.5583828092,
0.615613997,
-0.1878122091,
-0.2151246071,
-0.208294332,
0.6311401725,
0.0725395977,
0.467202425,
0.4825424552,
0.2622838914,
-0.221403569,
-0.3357870877,
-0.3732997179,
-0.171773091,
-0.3679607511,
-0.1853248179,
-0.4866452217,
-0.731443584,
-0.593159616,
-0.0641855001,
-0.2107111365,
-0.0614129901,
-0.1246233732,
0.2153000832,
0.1824278235,
0.7179422975,
0.0621014386,
0.3227831125,
-0.3728386164,
0.4309512079,
0.8519595861,
-0.0039200876,
0.0076700426,
-0.0772453323,
0.352108866,
0.2501652837,
-0.3772089779,
-0.6885780096,
0.1803688258,
0.2513329387,
0.6654498577,
0.7793780565,
-0.2537484765,
0.5636456013,
-0.2587629557,
1.0295139551,
0.0025065697,
-0.7971624136,
0.5992209911,
-0.3731601238,
0.4888768196,
0.218592748,
0.0260233507,
-0.5596990585,
-0.6323077083,
-0.405756712,
-0.5854795575,
0.7798195481,
0.5563707948,
0.7596645951,
-0.052917134,
0.0433482714,
-0.0915803835,
0.4398214519,
-0.5764121413,
-0.0610630624,
-0.3194604516,
-0.1263728738,
0.0105380779,
-0.1154988632,
-0.0173695311,
-0.1341196448,
0.3852491081,
0.1005942225,
0.8492333889,
-0.1871986389,
0.4505332112,
0.1475301087,
0.6274976134,
0.6118249297,
0.7991941571,
-0.1298947185,
-0.2687649429,
0.2264435738,
-0.318477571,
-0.2351236492,
0.1232416704,
-0.1151324436,
-0.2032803446,
0.3936038911,
0.7521461248,
-0.4122318029,
-0.6139586568,
0.4221835136,
0.057876315,
-0.2184459269,
-0.5480346084,
0.5249545574,
0.2016767114,
0.4241495728,
0.3826810122,
-0.0962744504,
0.0997747332,
-1.1441599131,
-0.0065501574,
0.8853850365,
-0.1404643655,
0.1248877794,
0.5556404591,
0.4270578921,
-0.6249545217,
1.025760293,
-0.3229214549,
-0.7856220603,
1.065982461,
0.5063527226,
0.9089873433,
-0.2059080154,
0.4458655119,
0.2461479455,
0.3082526028,
-0.1302623302,
0.1274735481,
-0.2762187719,
-0.6059033275,
-0.1730193049,
0.0198611841,
-0.6322799921,
0.3142459989,
-0.4148304462,
0.1386828274,
-0.4506123066,
-0.4777478874,
-0.0609192587,
-0.0284595639,
-0.4190067649,
-0.0356612056,
0.1147968844,
0.6115412712,
-0.3254095614,
0.3649321496,
0.2264158726,
-0.1653765589,
-0.646255672,
0.2885731459,
-0.1882327944,
-0.9715152383,
0.5291762352,
0.3260262609,
0.0436900482,
-0.1516105086,
-0.8220847249,
-0.5620542765,
1.1472500563,
0.1751038581,
-0.6410481334,
-0.0912715718,
0.3938499093,
0.8060985208,
0.0501603633,
0.4789489806,
0.4629808962,
0.5191883445,
-0.1562204957,
-1.2263710499,
-0.3189248145,
-0.0595917031,
0.0762189329,
0.272092998,
-0.9770794511,
1.0861301422,
0.1476371437,
-0.631485343,
0.6016020179,
0.7378853559,
-0.3165192902,
0.1690859646,
0.4331609905,
0.1840287894,
0.7398527861,
-0.3976392448,
1.012804985,
-0.0252888594,
0.3596576154,
0.4107417762,
-0.0455417261,
0.5202205181,
0.0419533364,
-0.2255189568,
0.5708646178,
0.2372099459,
-0.4855591655,
0.5104306936,
0.339662075,
-0.3079267144,
-0.0223811101,
-0.0153495744,
-0.2993152142,
0.672754705,
0.3719147742,
-0.0676122755,
-0.299957633,
0.277540952,
0.1206905246,
-0.0651322603,
-0.37839064,
0.8505637646,
-0.0235928502,
-0.8535798788,
0.2621917725,
0.0068072909,
0.602634728,
-0.6562150717,
-0.0698574558,
-0.1587631404,
0.1348984241,
-0.0509655699,
-0.9840478301,
0.0986469761,
0.2126374394,
0.4422952235,
-0.1084954217,
0.6376653314,
-0.3755350411,
-0.1520310491,
0.1583528072,
0.2743420899,
0.0880672634,
-0.140169546,
-0.8719576597,
-0.390173465,
-0.0727618858,
0.0006819812,
-0.1419697851,
0.3009023368,
0.0353254825,
0.9543104768,
0.3492251635,
0.1500004381,
-0.1952383369,
0.2549153566,
0.8577011824,
-0.5188010335,
-0.4338081181,
-0.8724831343,
0.1785162091,
-0.3342476189,
-0.5063169003,
0.8626695275,
0.2736360133,
0.7796743512,
0.0071942494,
0.8998575211,
-0.6077516675,
0.3189238906,
-0.6474942565,
0.7710788846,
-0.3057240546,
-0.097923547,
-0.1146129295,
-0.8049129844,
-0.0754232556,
0.7152029872,
-0.3470747471,
0.4176599681,
0.2630285025,
0.9455062151,
0.018545283,
-0.0036027648,
0.4875912368,
-0.0505472235,
0.5520235896,
0.5917370319,
1.2201282978,
-0.2803967893,
0.7312509418,
-0.1141162962,
0.0590480417,
-0.1798665076,
-0.4840142131,
-1.2935574055,
-0.5510944724,
-0.0472240485,
-0.0183881335,
0.1853271276,
0.66880548,
0.706840992,
-0.8713591695,
-0.1062743664,
-0.4197355211,
0.0385913253,
0.0958498493,
-0.3196916878,
0.3364163935,
-0.3283995092,
-0.9063065052,
0.2271424979,
0.2218582183,
0.042210713,
-0.5361512303,
0.2931462228,
-0.0271332245,
0.2827731669,
0.5058383346,
0.4825119972,
-0.9711840153,
-0.5471986532,
0.05905056,
-0.3523099422,
0.0795876384,
0.8366351724,
-0.5341612697,
0.513450861,
0.6925557256,
0.6693493128,
0.0845725611,
0.5729935169,
0.5557431579,
-0.3709702492,
0.1946466863,
0.0594602525,
-0.1282624751,
0.3877924681,
-0.3607162833,
0.4485697448,
-0.3739620745,
-0.8635912538,
-0.329131633,
0.1502603292,
-0.6734674573,
-0.2248593122,
1.067312479,
-0.0030237883,
0.0018360579,
0.0517014936,
-0.5751597285,
0.2908564508,
-0.5201722383,
1.0684244633,
0.8379030824,
-0.2778761089,
-0.2063869983,
-0.6494999528,
0.6246994734,
0.2215094864,
-1.1890366077,
-0.2043763399,
0.0550206378,
-0.3896279931,
0.3482778966,
0.5550628901,
-0.0006172209,
0.3182714283,
0.2025082856,
-0.2864300013,
0.199723348,
-0.1787004173,
-0.187133193,
-0.077658534,
-0.1677002013,
-0.2162683457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17404v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17404v1
|
VITATECS: A Diagnostic Dataset for Temporal Concept Understanding of Video-Language Models
| 2023-11-29T07:15:34 | 2023-11-29T07:15:34 |
Shicheng Li, Lei Li, Shuhuai Ren, Yuanxin Liu, Yi Liu, Rundong Gao, Xu Sun, Lu Hou
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The ability to perceive how objects change over time is a crucial ingredient
in human intelligence. However, current benchmarks cannot faithfully reflect
the temporal understanding abilities of video-language models (VidLMs) due to
the existence of static visual shortcuts. To remedy this issue, we present
VITATECS, a diagnostic VIdeo-Text dAtaset for the evaluation of TEmporal
Concept underStanding. Specifically, we first introduce a fine-grained taxonomy
of temporal concepts in natural language in order to diagnose the capability of
VidLMs to comprehend different temporal aspects. Furthermore, to disentangle
the correlation between static and temporal information, we generate
counterfactual video descriptions that differ from the original one only in the
specified temporal aspect. We employ a semi-automatic data collection framework
using large language models and human-in-the-loop annotation to obtain
high-quality counterfactual descriptions efficiently. Evaluation of
representative video-language understanding models confirms their deficiency in
temporal understanding, revealing the need for greater emphasis on the temporal
elements in video-language research.
|
[
-0.3544404507,
-0.7932988405,
0.7153743505,
0.290799439,
-0.6066726446,
0.2965146005,
0.0588182881,
-0.1656365246,
-0.0048174104,
0.2685064077,
-0.8647162914,
-0.394376874,
-0.5287283659,
0.1313496232,
-0.762804687,
0.6325290799,
-0.1820638329,
0.0370041691,
-0.217934221,
-0.2295079976,
-0.5569655299,
-0.0510069765,
-0.2969980538,
-0.2924628258,
0.0570609197,
0.254874289,
0.7211735249,
0.7376360893,
0.2853962183,
0.2830079496,
-0.1588214636,
0.0173874069,
-0.1704422086,
-0.1987242252,
-0.6388375759,
-0.4263554215,
-0.4439411759,
-0.0976358727,
0.6597180367,
0.7170528769,
0.0870719329,
0.4997953773,
-0.0791471526,
0.3760816455,
-0.7755632997,
0.386085391,
-0.5032448173,
0.4598056674,
-0.2157943696,
-0.5577469468,
-0.1717868447,
-0.212733224,
0.4330823123,
-0.7888995409,
0.6255271435,
-0.3704000115,
0.9503667951,
0.5131019354,
-0.3277119994,
0.2007610947,
-0.8792253733,
0.4670353234,
-0.088267602,
0.3464571536,
0.3282207251,
0.6326811314,
0.1577344686,
-0.459687382,
-0.6568135023,
0.2296108007,
0.1078111604,
-0.0116277365,
-0.1498079598,
-0.2828150988,
0.2278905362,
0.1243603379,
-0.9028214216,
0.0131304814,
-0.4668834805,
-0.2331611663,
0.2605088353,
0.739171207,
0.4698582888,
-0.4329636395,
-0.4350503385,
0.0146829206,
-0.6720781922,
-0.0146835893,
-0.2530377507,
-0.136296764,
-0.1328499764,
0.470956862,
-0.383882761,
0.7426941991,
-0.1349300295,
-0.2643646598,
0.3378683925,
-0.5701092482,
-0.6731953621,
0.1255083233,
0.4989356101,
0.4858243763,
0.4180264175,
-0.2112780809,
0.3006480336,
0.4068899453,
0.0926012546,
-1.0428395271,
-0.2959837615,
0.0668658614,
-0.4810010493,
-0.3773356974,
-0.1702433228,
-0.8730942011,
-0.3571077585,
-0.5435734987,
0.3548160791,
-0.5324199796,
-0.20234631,
0.2635451853,
-0.4543454051,
0.1060963795,
0.4211358428,
-0.6111022234,
0.3052045405,
0.4021744728,
1.0134902,
0.2008027881,
-0.5244590044,
-0.5703635216,
0.3268528283,
-0.4361709058,
0.8909543753,
-0.651702702,
-0.5414152145,
-0.194995746,
0.3330789804,
-0.1988151371,
-0.4728363454,
0.0854001343,
-0.3675560653,
-0.0343483165,
-0.269086659,
-0.2475672662,
-0.0836974755,
0.1221672595,
-0.3391858935,
0.6590133905,
-0.0646241754,
-0.66552037,
0.6821606755,
-0.314350605,
-0.2153105736,
0.0760305971,
-0.3548900783,
-0.1791246533,
0.1905109882,
0.3707281351,
0.4549216032,
-0.3756893575,
0.7187862396,
-0.1229915768,
-0.2319380343,
0.4497887492,
-0.7436490655,
0.4950165451,
0.0454126261,
-0.2443135381,
-0.2485117167,
-0.670637548,
-0.265447557,
0.1797752678,
0.4334527552,
-0.3427881002,
0.5008294582,
-0.2381698042,
0.3987770379,
0.0197894387,
-0.3787257969,
0.0214268491,
-0.2847925723,
0.4247612059,
0.6739323735,
0.0726915523,
0.2011080086,
-0.0529030338,
0.5648177862,
0.3556195796,
0.3699241579,
-0.4461691678,
-0.2040314972,
-0.5625790358,
-0.256836772,
-0.2316032052,
0.6020210385,
-0.9755092263,
0.0941380709,
-0.6191781759,
-0.2868662775,
-0.1929420382,
0.1429581493,
0.5143552423,
0.814147532,
0.5832494497,
-0.5610276461,
-0.3747312129,
-0.9023826122,
-0.1680802256,
-0.31490013,
-0.2465572357,
0.3913721442,
0.5870645642,
-0.291220516,
1.1778144836,
-0.8015816808,
-0.106724605,
0.0313408263,
0.6570932865,
-0.0358797684,
-0.0849082246,
0.7403598428,
-0.7057492733,
-0.1328701973,
-0.2623291016,
-0.7810487151,
-0.0884104967,
-0.0894708857,
0.388284415,
-0.1402589977,
0.5256950259,
-0.4155905843,
0.8159285784,
0.1127184778,
-0.69591254,
0.4475047886,
-0.1379822493,
0.2833705842,
-0.765460372,
-0.0102992449,
0.0425485298,
-0.2403415442,
-0.4240285456,
-0.5985153913,
-0.0190914012,
-0.1733242869,
-0.9418591857,
0.7302549481,
-0.0607971698,
-0.2111908644,
0.0291363392,
0.3995375037,
0.1432500929,
0.1842334718,
0.4001124501,
0.797362864,
0.6573340297,
-0.8431091309,
0.3547423184,
0.2397341877,
-0.4966877401,
0.7740725279,
-0.7726847529,
-0.3700596392,
-0.5439897776,
0.0706200376,
-0.6655176878,
-0.272564888,
-0.0004519102,
-0.2528812885,
0.0711280331,
-0.4182671309,
-0.4964280725,
-0.2319329083,
-0.2020519078,
0.5121379495,
0.262843132,
-0.6026315093,
0.400985837,
0.2719064057,
-0.138467297,
-0.5292579532,
-0.5753956437,
0.1285673827,
-0.3740103245,
-0.5593324304,
0.5437076092,
0.1167442799,
-0.4036512375,
0.1370103508,
-0.1877304763,
-0.375156194,
0.1268371791,
0.1727535278,
0.3194276989,
-0.1515714377,
0.4346540868,
0.0625322312,
-0.3144177198,
0.1727224886,
-0.1485397369,
0.4616574645,
-0.2455676645,
-0.0853151977,
-0.3723772466,
0.0182085242,
0.6199449301,
-0.3250770271,
0.6050246954,
0.6496657729,
-0.4243606031,
-0.0997278243,
-0.1850005686,
0.1815259159,
-0.4128288329,
0.4482802153,
-0.366400063,
-0.3198911846,
0.3685983121,
-0.1664678007,
-0.4082318246,
0.6124786735,
0.6255720258,
-0.1693857014,
0.9116874933,
0.416677177,
0.0054259258,
0.5641051531,
-0.5768975019,
-0.1767999679,
-0.6630455852,
-0.4288777113,
-0.2887580097,
0.0825307295,
-0.2978855371,
-0.4971225262,
0.336030215,
-0.0900871828,
-0.2856916487,
0.3116990328,
-0.2110677958,
0.7669441104,
-0.3950348496,
0.0689426884,
0.234315604,
-0.3476625383,
-0.0365931913,
-0.1423122436,
-0.3782874346,
-0.6017444134,
0.7960204482,
0.2724409401,
0.6638118029,
0.2043816447,
0.0676194057,
0.3225100338,
-0.0623471439,
-0.5818886161,
0.5961526632,
-0.4931415915,
-0.3895342648,
-0.0161530618,
-0.279789716,
-0.6451815367,
0.0563377813,
0.1838857532,
-1.0944685936,
0.4715867639,
0.2477968633,
-0.5623278618,
0.1562572867,
-0.5722419024,
1.1430723667,
-0.3628215194,
-0.4854770303,
-0.4407177866,
-0.6656466126,
0.3919599354,
0.1365985721,
0.1835574806,
-0.5066681504,
0.0694717541,
0.643163383,
-0.4879116714,
0.8888909817,
-0.1093974635,
0.3517577946,
0.1953283995,
0.4562118948,
-0.154637441,
0.6380326152,
0.424823761,
-0.0745060593,
0.3499680758,
-0.2790426016,
-0.7039582133,
0.4615286887,
-0.6252207756,
-0.2492697686,
-0.5725679398,
-0.2077080756,
-0.1529944986,
-0.1369731873,
0.3073224425,
0.8247359991,
-0.7564993501,
-0.1526988447,
0.9969711304,
-0.4162219465,
0.5245686173,
0.7808770537,
-0.1988367587,
0.0635109916,
0.9897044897,
-0.0812892169,
0.2005052119,
0.4848203659,
0.0446482673,
-0.1281642467,
-0.0256807394,
-0.4368871748,
-0.0341357403,
-0.6178596616,
-0.137989223,
-0.5098506808,
-0.0858134925,
-0.0317582972,
-0.1321018785,
-0.5268287063,
-0.6058412194,
-0.6553750038,
-0.0995949581,
0.4884272814,
0.4451752603,
0.0574281625,
0.182409659,
-0.7895912528,
0.9001198411,
0.5028633475,
0.2573065758,
-0.2699195445,
-0.49305439,
-0.0381308049,
0.0098718861,
-0.2920458615,
-0.9292700291,
0.6111810803,
0.4381733239,
0.2235960215,
0.691116333,
-0.3431724906,
0.9295424819,
-0.6316040754,
0.849288404,
-0.0096589625,
-1.1674417257,
1.0333553553,
-0.2069257796,
0.4592147768,
0.5631501079,
0.3036742806,
-0.624049902,
0.0250079613,
-0.6077769995,
-0.6031603813,
0.6201651692,
0.1298859864,
-0.2123294175,
-0.1985397637,
0.1563259959,
0.0423688814,
0.0558210164,
-0.0155891376,
0.0452040657,
-0.6179305315,
0.0015855161,
-0.3920732737,
0.0209834594,
-0.0998761728,
-0.5119747519,
0.2482792884,
-0.2122265995,
0.2950468063,
0.2441720665,
-0.6063592434,
-0.0194562394,
0.4667237997,
0.6805065274,
0.9920936227,
-0.4907061458,
0.2494043112,
0.3467770517,
-0.5480273366,
0.1612734944,
0.1099603623,
0.1107154265,
0.279610455,
0.335854888,
0.7663627863,
0.2262776047,
-0.8701276779,
0.6326390505,
-0.4302130938,
0.1699797809,
-0.4541879594,
0.0812671334,
-0.3094713688,
0.0617042594,
0.155630514,
0.1169181466,
0.2422993779,
-0.7996332049,
0.1581641138,
0.1800501943,
-0.3053796887,
-0.7965150476,
0.5644669533,
0.0573067479,
-0.1830833107,
0.7050529122,
-0.2318885028,
-0.6795284152,
0.9377726912,
0.1857014894,
1.023609519,
-0.1464224905,
0.7977583408,
0.0579363517,
0.241959855,
-0.1399499774,
0.3338396549,
-0.1781094521,
-0.6218808293,
-0.380371809,
-0.491935879,
-0.2175309658,
0.1050713286,
-0.63489604,
0.3958421648,
-0.3637883663,
-0.1646516919,
0.2641691267,
-0.1820641905,
-1.2125073671,
0.4160742462,
-0.1649034917,
0.9499574304,
-1.3040400743,
0.8764661551,
0.2308288664,
-0.4737851918,
-0.150933519,
-0.0187037941,
0.3036092818,
-0.550222218,
1.0614452362,
0.0550378598,
-0.2145938873,
-0.5929433703,
-0.2014694512,
-0.6239942312,
1.3208166361,
0.3975270987,
-0.3228619695,
-0.2145751268,
0.2356745005,
0.8590463996,
-0.3318964243,
0.3289408684,
0.9691647291,
0.1755371839,
0.057372652,
-0.9686485529,
-0.2983523011,
-0.2988311648,
-0.0718584955,
0.4000813663,
-0.4327535331,
0.7317637801,
-0.0677431598,
-0.4020703435,
-0.0991181582,
0.2801008523,
-0.2557766438,
0.6764483452,
0.3582600653,
0.4977381229,
0.4484464824,
-0.1381936073,
1.0068731308,
-0.1502202898,
0.185999155,
1.2821666002,
-0.0978054553,
0.5273710489,
0.3704478741,
-0.0265684929,
0.3455480933,
0.535615921,
0.1233818978,
0.6790567636,
-0.0571739078,
-0.2366532534,
-0.4057958424,
-0.4481233656,
-0.3227290511,
0.6635596156,
0.8599746823,
-0.5614563823,
-0.3549913466,
0.1323460788,
-0.1719589084,
-0.185123384,
-0.2534145415,
0.695731163,
-0.0431620702,
-0.3445748091,
0.4011943638,
-0.2038337886,
-0.044833567,
-0.4095698595,
0.0010546884,
-0.0449391715,
0.1499683708,
-0.0227156617,
-0.9838929772,
0.6030575633,
0.3035622239,
-0.1595917344,
-0.2175068706,
0.4332949519,
-0.1390171349,
-0.441205442,
0.1954420656,
0.4526487887,
0.1014312878,
0.3179690242,
-0.5122649074,
-0.0021170143,
-0.525449574,
0.1833564043,
-0.0009915159,
0.5421577692,
-0.2400482595,
0.7363692522,
-0.0145394718,
0.0828888118,
-0.1600012183,
0.2471307814,
0.8548762202,
-0.6022495627,
-0.3247221708,
-0.952368319,
0.3911426067,
-0.1035748348,
-0.5391578674,
0.3139972985,
0.4595738351,
0.8372081518,
-0.0539891757,
0.4496763945,
0.199045971,
0.3912283778,
-0.8103156686,
0.3506392837,
-0.4869206548,
0.4732518792,
-0.3517029583,
-0.5077895522,
-0.0659751371,
0.4118525088,
-0.428905338,
-0.4226321876,
0.7160115242,
0.5754289627,
-0.3223825991,
0.0361330844,
0.1009769961,
0.3950132132,
0.3448424339,
0.6253830791,
0.9037584066,
-0.1384537816,
0.341999948,
-0.3059694469,
-0.177436009,
-0.1761891246,
-0.9852436781,
-1.0789289474,
-0.721958518,
-0.3684922457,
0.0986176357,
0.4270797372,
0.7292556167,
0.4521927238,
-0.5057548285,
-0.0099618826,
-0.0442431532,
0.1617772281,
-0.1483151615,
-0.2503726482,
0.4760047793,
0.0326099694,
-0.4571295083,
0.6465162635,
0.6377097368,
0.0871324316,
-0.3900811672,
0.1766314507,
0.0331886522,
0.2799767256,
0.656929493,
0.5213611722,
-0.6388981342,
-0.3866352737,
0.0900648236,
0.2596378922,
-0.0414751098,
1.1885534525,
-1.2405803204,
0.8216940761,
0.7210327387,
0.2130396664,
0.7295477986,
-0.1392376274,
0.5511586666,
-0.7179474235,
0.5124527216,
0.1407181025,
0.5649775267,
0.1688382924,
-0.2131203264,
0.4574089944,
0.46004197,
-0.116172865,
-0.6299654841,
0.3220953047,
-0.812212348,
-0.5582240224,
0.685464561,
0.0270767305,
-0.2782022059,
-0.3667238057,
0.0912703499,
0.2846792042,
-0.0259566978,
0.9514200687,
0.4475244284,
-0.0521207526,
-0.0461372025,
-0.5459722877,
0.5586372018,
0.2445419878,
-0.7509955764,
0.0555357821,
0.3482959569,
0.3226612508,
0.0855699331,
0.4545797408,
-0.1240008771,
0.6593627334,
-0.2193941921,
-0.5097591281,
0.0105760563,
-0.8514003754,
-0.2925212979,
-0.1445756704,
-0.3469760716,
-0.2383618504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17400v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17400v2
|
Improving the Robustness of Transformer-based Large Language Models with Dynamic Attention
| 2023-11-29T07:09:13 | 2023-11-30T02:08:24 |
Lujia Shen, Yuwen Pu, Shouling Ji, Changjiang Li, Xuhong Zhang, Chunpeng Ge, Ting Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Transformer-based models, such as BERT and GPT, have been widely adopted in
natural language processing (NLP) due to their exceptional performance.
However, recent studies show their vulnerability to textual adversarial attacks
where the model's output can be misled by intentionally manipulating the text
inputs. Despite various methods that have been proposed to enhance the model's
robustness and mitigate this vulnerability, many require heavy consumption
resources (e.g., adversarial training) or only provide limited protection
(e.g., defensive dropout). In this paper, we propose a novel method called
dynamic attention, tailored for the transformer architecture, to enhance the
inherent robustness of the model itself against various adversarial attacks.
Our method requires no downstream task knowledge and does not incur additional
costs. The proposed dynamic attention consists of two modules: (I) attention
rectification, which masks or weakens the attention value of the chosen tokens,
and (ii) dynamic modeling, which dynamically builds the set of candidate
tokens. Extensive experiments demonstrate that dynamic attention significantly
mitigates the impact of adversarial attacks, improving up to 33\% better
performance than previous methods against widely-used adversarial attacks. The
model-level design of dynamic attention enables it to be easily combined with
other defense methods (e.g., adversarial training) to further enhance the
model's robustness. Furthermore, we demonstrate that dynamic attention
preserves the state-of-the-art robustness space of the original model compared
to other dynamic modeling methods.
|
[
-0.3941712677,
-0.9478306174,
0.1532733291,
0.0379044414,
-0.1339841038,
0.4036050737,
-0.3560763597,
-0.4890856445,
-0.0495058298,
0.3674656153,
-0.6830525398,
-0.0740885958,
-0.7066502571,
-0.0424330011,
-0.58129704,
1.0521764755,
0.0933899432,
-0.465795964,
0.1843444407,
-0.0867666006,
-0.4807096124,
-0.3709703684,
-0.695224762,
-0.1180106699,
0.7181366682,
-0.3507030308,
1.0017803907,
0.6136600375,
0.8025680184,
0.3689625263,
-0.5894666314,
0.0385023914,
-0.6163733006,
0.3591941297,
-0.2525275648,
-0.4215469658,
-0.5039695501,
-0.2518713474,
0.6773240566,
0.3221538663,
0.0797599629,
0.1522423476,
0.2113400549,
0.4515843987,
-0.6810240149,
0.203828007,
-1.0168960094,
0.292411536,
-0.1326804161,
0.0487588979,
-0.6055653095,
-0.0425124653,
0.343757093,
-0.4042567313,
0.3106453419,
-0.328482002,
0.9398539066,
0.8453660011,
-0.2754310071,
0.1578015834,
-0.9215293527,
0.7657274604,
-0.573510468,
0.3934088051,
-0.0399054103,
0.2830535471,
-0.1360692084,
-0.7524200678,
-0.3818526864,
-0.3621271253,
-0.17309241,
0.2124235183,
-0.5456809998,
0.0143558774,
0.5205301046,
0.340213269,
-0.2601803541,
-0.1238560528,
0.2234213054,
-0.1208090708,
0.2129379213,
0.0557406656,
0.2529835403,
0.0918786675,
-0.414203614,
-0.281073153,
-0.5406450629,
0.066454716,
0.3133613467,
0.2848468721,
-0.0290101767,
0.363763392,
0.0921450332,
0.5099276304,
0.5392361879,
0.1202798858,
-0.0335272513,
-0.2666982412,
-0.288077414,
-0.1439657658,
0.6025566459,
-0.0244906247,
0.0975402445,
-0.4884546399,
-0.2555364966,
0.028598344,
0.8598179221,
-0.6283946633,
-0.3934330046,
0.3130399585,
-0.403583914,
-0.9010528326,
-0.0916563645,
-0.926990211,
-0.2977483273,
-0.045945432,
0.2918254137,
-0.3731958568,
-0.1568472832,
-0.0978120118,
0.1785537601,
0.1132722944,
0.1138767973,
-1.1063990593,
0.0315020941,
0.4316557944,
0.7766490579,
-0.2989418507,
-0.0013907341,
-0.8290907741,
0.4155629277,
0.0503495149,
0.6481598616,
-0.4654568434,
0.0294813868,
0.024893254,
-0.0542128608,
-0.245645687,
-0.3099706769,
0.544978559,
-0.9418197274,
0.1051868573,
0.0522097386,
-0.0098487418,
-0.0908854902,
0.6009603739,
-0.8804803491,
0.9244155288,
-0.0780290142,
-1.1456446648,
0.0400688611,
-0.8393902183,
-0.6926743984,
0.0584363006,
0.0654926375,
-0.7467421293,
0.1091017872,
0.6226962209,
0.280221194,
-0.0739908516,
0.2548620999,
-0.2005138546,
-0.171317026,
0.3720267415,
-0.9534583092,
0.6363194585,
-0.0333714671,
-0.7763359547,
0.3724444509,
-0.893563509,
-0.0956391767,
0.5068269968,
-0.4686099887,
0.059175767,
0.1748712361,
0.080687575,
-0.0673015937,
0.3324416578,
-0.2885144949,
0.163903743,
-0.8877313137,
0.5221105814,
0.8314831853,
-0.0394226611,
0.4460796714,
0.0274859909,
0.5894175768,
-0.2691749036,
0.3226033747,
-0.2869084179,
-0.1258493811,
-0.8087906241,
-0.479985863,
0.4985490441,
0.4860703945,
-0.8607689142,
0.6482416987,
-0.2326046228,
-0.3821307421,
-0.3657053709,
-0.158481732,
0.2520850599,
0.3653020859,
0.3004642427,
0.033857625,
-0.2277696878,
-0.7743103504,
-0.3226332664,
-0.1359856576,
-0.237658456,
0.2498947084,
0.1644559801,
-0.2509901822,
0.8057182431,
-0.6112822294,
-0.2439750433,
-0.4064014554,
0.0006850098,
0.1392618269,
0.1420808434,
0.7599093914,
-0.9647766352,
-0.5452005267,
-0.0391273052,
-0.2788532376,
-0.0732993707,
-0.330837369,
-0.2994396985,
-0.0084244078,
0.2103336155,
-0.6659858227,
0.3344655931,
0.4315749109,
-0.2212585211,
0.3274327517,
-0.08312352,
-0.2659793198,
-0.975058496,
0.3908106983,
-0.269766748,
-0.3027378023,
-0.7894923687,
0.4288026094,
0.0740157142,
-0.2985768914,
-0.497043997,
0.4267493486,
-0.3228071034,
0.3068180084,
-0.3694770336,
-0.0460968167,
0.0458399393,
0.6377459168,
-0.0869713351,
0.4605641365,
0.4959537685,
-0.2474935949,
0.6957336068,
0.2959781885,
-0.0200548936,
0.2904599607,
-0.8308511972,
0.1890197694,
-0.061932072,
0.3201733232,
-1.0326114893,
-0.2398836464,
0.382910043,
-0.3886449635,
0.7718498707,
-0.0726942942,
-0.5033125877,
-0.417095691,
-0.4562725425,
0.3037686348,
0.2058176845,
-0.6747105122,
0.9673855305,
0.2702178955,
-0.1744176149,
-0.6699917912,
-0.7176898718,
0.3861731291,
-0.231590122,
-0.535795331,
0.4572072625,
0.0441846102,
0.0561099835,
0.0162719116,
-0.1435491145,
0.1037524119,
0.4058926105,
-0.0550368764,
0.3501223922,
-0.0321948975,
-0.0654586256,
-0.2697460651,
-0.408670187,
0.1372084618,
-0.2109371871,
0.7471708655,
0.1941635013,
-0.4619836509,
-0.6345980167,
0.44524616,
1.1295185089,
-0.6997497082,
0.8277729154,
0.8704361916,
-0.4950137734,
-0.1273171157,
-0.5558368564,
-0.4986185431,
-0.5351982117,
0.6520016193,
-0.112244986,
-0.6785764098,
0.6060767174,
0.3355053663,
0.1962193847,
0.3771810234,
0.8340734839,
0.0950828046,
1.1857719421,
0.6372233629,
-0.3920514882,
0.8928610086,
-0.0865898132,
0.5448159575,
-0.8260701895,
-0.0608099997,
-0.2568072379,
-0.6074370742,
-0.447304219,
-0.1310000122,
0.3413585722,
-0.6139693856,
-0.195312947,
0.3293929696,
-0.827711761,
0.3313079476,
0.5235196352,
0.1595849395,
-0.0930844098,
0.0393039808,
0.1340289861,
-0.1420561969,
-0.7310118675,
-0.2887100279,
0.8507598042,
0.7167472839,
0.8643110991,
0.2360950112,
0.1493640095,
0.1508395523,
0.1510847211,
-0.7168997526,
0.50263834,
-0.2677703202,
-0.431558162,
-0.2580529451,
-0.4829410315,
-0.9479289651,
0.276047498,
-0.2476775944,
-0.6958669424,
-0.0280798841,
0.3266781569,
-0.7063488364,
0.5279318094,
-0.5190453529,
0.8468487859,
-0.2863782644,
-0.4089575112,
-0.046889998,
-0.7150639296,
0.1299322546,
-0.3180806935,
-0.1786727458,
0.2324410826,
0.1039094403,
0.507872045,
-0.0357010253,
1.08355546,
-0.1412821114,
-0.3397653699,
-0.0335432403,
0.0027201239,
1.1957942247,
0.1286598891,
0.2804040611,
-0.1595601141,
-0.4293581545,
-0.2733146846,
-0.6344606876,
0.5777767897,
-0.5595484376,
-0.7440184951,
-0.376602143,
-0.8736310601,
-0.1607692093,
0.3073296845,
0.0700050294,
0.2768290341,
-0.1116592064,
0.5048050284,
1.0690512657,
-0.3562590182,
0.5431982875,
0.376611799,
0.4239262938,
-0.5032789707,
0.605239749,
0.0228753071,
0.4130694568,
0.6474686265,
0.1017913073,
-0.290007472,
-0.5215799212,
-0.2670487761,
0.0725756511,
-0.3610652983,
-0.3513118625,
-0.9700245261,
-0.3600426018,
-0.4432300627,
-0.0496193282,
-0.5850542784,
-0.1277313679,
-0.1955662966,
0.06824857,
0.2409227341,
0.1218758747,
0.5064787865,
0.2957494259,
-0.750182569,
0.5696262717,
0.4886267781,
0.2788178027,
0.3162193596,
-0.6263640523,
-0.2532351017,
-0.0748578459,
-0.5017145872,
-0.6939544678,
0.3592804372,
0.0687231794,
0.5942102075,
0.4461258054,
0.3475062251,
0.2782618403,
-0.627502203,
0.5887467265,
0.0171816908,
-0.8081665635,
0.6178073883,
-0.5511187315,
0.7184211612,
0.2142686397,
-0.3423564136,
-0.2022732347,
-0.922463119,
-0.6991240978,
-1.1721878052,
0.8264895082,
0.5565013289,
0.3435818553,
0.0668653771,
0.3233239949,
-0.4210890532,
0.059541218,
-0.9193177223,
-0.1352331936,
-0.1351532638,
-0.4013279378,
0.3957761526,
-0.33662045,
-0.2180260271,
0.1346300095,
0.6344581842,
-0.0621980429,
0.4244657159,
-0.2076048255,
0.1047526449,
-0.0812788531,
0.0749006122,
0.5331320167,
0.1154130846,
-0.1077676043,
0.3622372448,
0.4806754589,
-0.7874394059,
0.1552421898,
0.3673720956,
-0.4196723402,
-0.1470092833,
0.4830178022,
0.8105713725,
0.3009932935,
-0.6259263158,
0.456841886,
-0.3114476502,
0.2285309881,
-0.1083249003,
0.1712015271,
-0.0240159724,
0.4475844204,
0.3075020015,
0.2991764843,
-0.1540032774,
-0.2610546052,
0.1854949296,
0.692258358,
-0.3609351814,
-0.3132508993,
1.0927363634,
0.2796301544,
-0.2966333628,
0.2686961293,
0.2521771193,
-0.8656252623,
0.7007351518,
0.5047191978,
1.0067859888,
-0.4012798369,
-0.1743547916,
-0.0007104367,
0.5360237956,
0.0871120244,
-0.2157639116,
-0.0864175707,
-0.5468103886,
-0.347461313,
-0.4057251215,
-0.2812670469,
0.3677290678,
-0.6305900812,
0.2972047925,
-0.391787231,
-0.3829664886,
-0.0347852483,
-0.1694560349,
-0.438824594,
0.3434084356,
0.2197215557,
0.5795227885,
-0.5294100642,
0.6837769151,
0.6926196814,
-0.0470218509,
-0.3311054111,
0.5898991227,
-0.1288766861,
-0.5619426966,
0.3829468191,
0.1630698889,
-0.278482765,
-0.0045069009,
-0.0920672491,
-1.0982023478,
0.8414764404,
0.6867386103,
-0.5648890734,
-0.1142741069,
0.0281017125,
0.5469583273,
0.1898805052,
0.0109343026,
0.3230812252,
0.3743329346,
0.148734048,
-0.4840861559,
0.0546530262,
-0.2707329094,
-0.0202146806,
0.4070260227,
-0.9689394832,
0.4647815228,
-0.052075211,
-0.3581067026,
-0.1478067786,
0.7249636054,
-0.0768161267,
-0.1558252275,
0.7788393497,
0.4401647449,
0.5344597101,
-0.24087286,
0.9662679434,
-0.4369125068,
0.4440249801,
1.0300014019,
-0.1721668392,
0.6422250271,
0.3725540936,
-0.1229970381,
-0.0906220824,
0.3587080538,
-0.4126640856,
0.8107562661,
0.0308373477,
-0.2525540292,
-0.0712058246,
0.0860010833,
-0.2469442785,
0.3399145901,
-0.0082532223,
-0.5154010653,
-0.0360983163,
0.1473170668,
0.1039582416,
-0.0350330435,
0.0660944954,
0.8085944653,
-0.3464371264,
-0.5754379034,
0.6575314999,
0.0012204399,
0.571460247,
-0.6941084862,
0.40277946,
-0.0722360536,
0.595767796,
0.0730142295,
-0.4527808428,
0.4648305774,
0.3476262093,
-0.5606217384,
-0.219351992,
0.7083790302,
-0.3996347487,
-0.6477954984,
0.3237895072,
-0.2219496667,
-0.515717566,
-0.2011392862,
-0.5895344019,
0.2960705161,
0.2097335309,
-0.5528829098,
0.3981038332,
0.3603476286,
0.2504425347,
0.7497696877,
0.580971837,
0.0662724078,
-0.0955620036,
0.1867991537,
1.1078311205,
-0.3257008493,
-0.5403545499,
-1.1315327883,
0.5751476884,
-0.206026271,
0.0902632773,
0.4653872848,
0.2539050579,
0.4038663507,
0.0262469035,
0.7788416743,
0.1523221135,
0.3978522718,
-0.249540478,
0.9857828021,
-0.306596756,
0.3734471202,
-0.2709803581,
-1.0365898609,
-0.6185299158,
0.615000844,
-0.0935838297,
-0.0150236459,
0.4675495923,
0.5448926687,
-0.1919913739,
-0.2936766446,
0.1999104619,
0.3910160065,
0.8394923806,
0.5897154212,
0.6159101725,
-0.3137004077,
0.9082788229,
-0.0711743161,
-0.3530595303,
-0.260155946,
-0.9564841986,
-1.0778995752,
-0.0775824338,
-0.4799886644,
-0.2288037986,
0.1590565145,
0.5124960542,
0.4777400792,
-0.8807635903,
0.6213391423,
0.1239664182,
-0.2088942379,
-0.2660700083,
-0.2494158894,
0.7634187341,
-0.4736468494,
-0.9368669987,
0.3899628222,
0.4850216806,
0.2207047641,
-0.4332649708,
0.5487415195,
-0.0589244887,
0.2126469314,
0.5647288561,
-0.064789854,
-0.7665951848,
-0.4836207032,
0.1767373085,
-0.1078030616,
-0.0420378782,
0.5364170671,
-0.5577324033,
0.4842348993,
0.4115490317,
1.0425958633,
0.2407388836,
0.055457551,
0.6412962079,
-0.8679754138,
0.369582504,
0.4214022458,
0.2998395562,
0.3663186729,
-0.70051682,
0.2012167275,
0.176156193,
-0.45221138,
-1.0040175915,
0.339402169,
-0.9362673163,
0.0078340778,
0.9347333312,
-0.277834177,
-0.1961305887,
0.0135696055,
-0.4616967738,
0.3617766798,
-0.3078128099,
1.3023879528,
0.6918634772,
0.336663872,
-0.1735204458,
-0.3340776563,
0.3859641552,
0.5639284849,
-0.5960885882,
0.5859630108,
0.0062755966,
-0.1433988959,
0.3082859218,
-0.2506871819,
-0.1691021621,
0.0902699903,
-0.2740064859,
-0.204614237,
-0.0321820192,
-0.2469452024,
-0.2969379425,
0.537848711,
-0.2967791557,
-0.4268836379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17391v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17391v1
|
Unveiling the Implicit Toxicity in Large Language Models
| 2023-11-29T06:42:36 | 2023-11-29T06:42:36 |
Jiaxin Wen, Pei Ke, Hao Sun, Zhexin Zhang, Chengfei Li, Jinfeng Bai, Minlie Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The open-endedness of large language models (LLMs) combined with their
impressive capabilities may lead to new safety issues when being exploited for
malicious use. While recent studies primarily focus on probing toxic outputs
that can be easily detected with existing toxicity classifiers, we show that
LLMs can generate diverse implicit toxic outputs that are exceptionally
difficult to detect via simply zero-shot prompting. Moreover, we propose a
reinforcement learning (RL) based attacking method to further induce the
implicit toxicity in LLMs. Specifically, we optimize the language model with a
reward that prefers implicit toxic outputs to explicit toxic and non-toxic
ones. Experiments on five widely-adopted toxicity classifiers demonstrate that
the attack success rate can be significantly improved through RL fine-tuning.
For instance, the RL-finetuned LLaMA-13B model achieves an attack success rate
of 90.04% on BAD and 62.85% on Davinci003. Our findings suggest that LLMs pose
a significant threat in generating undetectable implicit toxic outputs. We
further show that fine-tuning toxicity classifiers on the annotated examples
from our attacking method can effectively enhance their ability to detect
LLM-generated implicit toxic language. The code is publicly available at
https://github.com/thu-coai/Implicit-Toxicity.
|
[
0.0592242777,
-0.9467122555,
0.733920753,
0.1180676669,
-0.0476409346,
-0.1936244369,
-0.1823168844,
-0.6355885267,
-0.5448128581,
0.62456882,
-0.4971135855,
-0.689596355,
-0.7894640565,
-0.0110012479,
-0.3248020709,
1.3143877983,
0.1893261671,
-0.0341968685,
0.1139194816,
-0.0837537795,
-0.3105629385,
-0.4527571797,
-1.2351294756,
-0.1499340534,
1.2127000093,
0.3973961771,
0.46520257,
0.4291699827,
0.2340211272,
0.4157421589,
-0.2775897682,
-0.0582457706,
-0.8842618465,
0.5782647729,
-0.1936576515,
-0.3324483633,
-0.3193163872,
-0.054424338,
0.3913513422,
0.0990359634,
0.0209640395,
0.0399466716,
-0.105894804,
0.5143979788,
-0.8174872398,
0.2426162958,
-0.916531086,
0.0821429417,
-0.1590050906,
-0.1653081328,
-0.9470354915,
-0.2529534101,
-0.0584381036,
-0.4828867018,
-0.6179721951,
-0.0720424578,
0.3533839285,
0.4277456105,
-0.4724078178,
-0.4899549484,
-0.7257252336,
0.8238194585,
-0.7971875668,
-0.0635079741,
-0.1808822155,
0.3329589963,
-0.4945832491,
-0.5223411918,
-0.4088204801,
-0.7246347666,
-0.0861485153,
-0.0274017304,
-0.3447896242,
0.267036736,
0.3370812833,
-0.0062692314,
-0.3647814393,
0.4181489646,
-0.3553197384,
-0.113800399,
0.7779179215,
0.2805382311,
0.6607709527,
-0.0216587912,
-0.3269564211,
-0.1264145225,
-0.9582201242,
-0.1214530021,
0.669248879,
0.4710007608,
0.0819002241,
0.4552519023,
0.0263939612,
0.2875696123,
-0.1715072095,
0.0946910232,
-0.1350237131,
0.159018591,
-0.0205891542,
0.4042254686,
1.0071347952,
0.168467015,
0.6648072004,
-0.0237295292,
-0.1936324835,
0.0090970704,
0.4503313005,
-0.9536725879,
-0.1213035882,
0.5067583323,
0.0924531296,
-0.728084445,
-0.485242337,
-0.7423101068,
-0.6325487494,
0.2830624282,
0.4843044877,
-0.4199290276,
-0.2726181746,
0.0936113372,
0.0242582336,
0.092732586,
0.1623180658,
-0.8437823653,
0.2119486779,
0.6259049177,
0.6700388193,
-0.0548391268,
-0.1873272508,
-1.0039530993,
0.4614283442,
-0.5870702863,
0.6938802004,
-0.5558211207,
-0.3666793704,
0.057098709,
-0.2351621091,
0.3846832216,
-0.473598659,
0.6412952542,
-0.5774936676,
0.0946770683,
-0.0815526694,
-0.0706126615,
-0.1019302309,
0.2278630286,
-0.6181610823,
0.8871957064,
-0.2323076427,
-0.7877346277,
0.0603161678,
-0.6797878146,
-0.409768343,
-0.0505225174,
0.0968179554,
-0.517190814,
0.0841523111,
-0.0900728181,
0.5378593802,
0.117392689,
0.1305367202,
-0.6055142879,
-0.5470302701,
0.0767678097,
-0.4738229811,
0.734670043,
0.2036574185,
-0.4433059394,
0.5657924414,
-0.6274947524,
-0.0595312342,
0.4625865221,
-0.4000659585,
-0.5613900423,
0.0979579091,
-0.1774042249,
0.4170357585,
0.0736463368,
-0.6099388003,
-0.1000077128,
-0.4835659564,
0.2453364283,
1.2527840137,
0.2319566458,
0.2087533772,
-0.2337650806,
0.2330188155,
0.1143320203,
0.4594089389,
-0.0532259271,
-0.240018189,
-0.7218379378,
-0.1583876014,
-0.0986104608,
0.4395983219,
-0.5968266129,
0.0449974611,
-0.1388185471,
-0.677341342,
-0.2129038721,
-0.0699063763,
0.8601059318,
0.4061718881,
0.3514996171,
0.0904929861,
-0.2457016855,
-0.6727054715,
-0.4885534346,
-0.3778238297,
0.0939929113,
0.6512729526,
0.5326927304,
-0.2049096674,
0.2627656162,
-0.5730007291,
-0.3543904722,
0.1194199547,
0.1596055478,
-0.0588169843,
0.4458675385,
0.4196010828,
-0.3651154339,
-0.6062707901,
0.0886566639,
-0.6715159416,
-0.3793092072,
0.0024844438,
-0.0270172395,
0.3484072089,
0.7532785535,
-0.2245681733,
-0.0068767248,
0.4723236561,
-0.2196816355,
0.5502437949,
-0.2478172183,
-0.1169787794,
-0.5518131852,
0.0044486462,
0.2590515614,
-0.1038955152,
-0.664663136,
0.2583116591,
-0.0887582451,
0.0197174549,
-1.1338107586,
0.6586891413,
-0.1921402514,
0.2114425004,
-0.1602709293,
-0.0596771836,
-0.2413565069,
0.660300374,
-0.0119670015,
0.624869585,
0.313167274,
-0.5684868097,
0.3304537535,
-0.120156087,
0.0389913693,
0.2650780976,
-0.8446223736,
0.1259963512,
-0.2675398588,
0.2865062654,
-0.9605365992,
-0.0864897892,
0.5090745091,
-0.3283056915,
0.5383312106,
-0.3115106821,
-0.4080041051,
0.0462579951,
-0.4027968049,
0.4034743905,
0.595898807,
-0.5961193442,
0.5149024129,
0.172226727,
-0.3911537528,
-0.8224169016,
-0.54112041,
0.0268709604,
-0.4834652543,
-0.4590849876,
-0.0251198411,
-0.2736380696,
-0.2825579047,
-0.1189554483,
-0.0934908092,
0.2648448348,
0.3435453176,
0.3901295364,
0.1381430179,
-0.0803800374,
-0.0407981686,
0.0732210428,
-0.294654727,
0.6067865491,
0.1060500219,
0.3435869515,
-0.2717142105,
-0.3231937587,
-0.150952816,
0.3159018755,
0.7608253956,
-0.0889288262,
0.7194633484,
0.2842321992,
-0.1628424972,
-0.5377719402,
-0.226690352,
-0.0930732489,
-0.5942088366,
0.6683846712,
-0.085343495,
-0.8459520936,
0.3240311444,
-0.267935127,
0.1583739668,
0.3852338195,
0.5727895498,
0.1359719038,
1.3870151043,
0.4696212113,
-0.1053650305,
0.4064130783,
0.0357674919,
0.0224838015,
-0.7212760448,
-0.4403377473,
-0.4744810462,
0.0531618036,
-0.6100424528,
-0.1700337678,
0.5990507603,
-0.2001250833,
-0.9293326139,
-0.0701918676,
-0.4516430199,
0.7901920676,
0.2756453454,
0.0606962368,
0.3786681592,
-0.0195549186,
-0.3782787025,
0.0295512658,
-0.4564175904,
-0.4880821407,
1.0189332962,
0.7837154865,
0.94272995,
0.3619123101,
0.6190195084,
0.2136756033,
0.6137782335,
-0.5933417678,
0.5230593085,
-0.1540130377,
-0.6010229588,
-0.33653,
-0.4976170063,
-0.5752900243,
0.2107727379,
-0.1470709294,
-0.6279035211,
-0.2189556509,
0.095996052,
-0.2628544867,
0.3703850508,
-0.7999874949,
0.8253450394,
-0.5274186134,
-0.7684872746,
-0.086126402,
-0.3990208805,
0.8192006946,
-0.2073783278,
0.2588120103,
-0.1154173464,
-0.1311280578,
0.3628566861,
-0.0432884395,
1.058103323,
-0.1269499063,
-0.626815021,
-0.0137849525,
0.4679485261,
0.6890712976,
0.1944610476,
-0.069814153,
0.1516822875,
-0.3363830447,
-0.414305687,
-0.4577663541,
1.0405023098,
-0.6666420102,
-0.7811614275,
-0.824198842,
-0.4094648361,
-0.1848586202,
0.2528465092,
-0.0278879348,
0.0465371311,
-0.2437590212,
-0.2642502189,
1.0932782888,
-0.8747371435,
0.4776309431,
0.8992706537,
-0.1052048504,
-0.1429834664,
1.2026450634,
-0.2484116703,
0.638287425,
-0.0411785655,
0.2610701323,
-0.2852754891,
-0.6891826391,
-0.3241560757,
0.255757004,
-0.7706460357,
-0.287630558,
-0.520855546,
-0.5221096873,
-0.0337506272,
-0.0402103215,
-0.4055364132,
0.2517224848,
-0.1651246399,
-0.1846372187,
0.500886023,
1.1014374495,
-0.1415145397,
0.1951160133,
-0.6650309563,
-0.0578296855,
0.5106773973,
0.6251756549,
0.2070136517,
-0.4016491771,
0.1041705385,
0.0854626223,
-0.2662676275,
-0.887247622,
0.3378157914,
-0.0317416191,
0.5125249624,
0.5117991567,
0.2544033527,
0.2317018211,
-0.6909493208,
0.5622372031,
0.1011180952,
-0.7520635724,
0.471468091,
-0.729942441,
0.0452024192,
0.2138025612,
0.7223549485,
-0.6016032696,
-0.8278547525,
-0.4523843229,
-0.8870667815,
0.8217808604,
0.0047551179,
0.3814835846,
-0.3177612722,
0.335665673,
-0.1963945329,
-0.1645953804,
-1.1822590828,
-0.4339977205,
0.0436358191,
-0.087785013,
-0.0275607966,
-0.6321750879,
-0.1433346272,
0.0011484176,
1.0158715248,
-0.0179385077,
-0.1226044372,
-0.0801697448,
-0.1339615136,
-0.5102390051,
0.3962916732,
0.6104397178,
-0.0992114469,
-0.3513132632,
0.1957352161,
0.2467041016,
-0.3173466623,
0.4087635577,
-0.120772101,
0.0090673417,
-0.5155696869,
0.3733147383,
0.6000226736,
0.4214066267,
-1.0405611992,
0.5917716622,
-0.1904584616,
-0.0469152667,
-0.3278675377,
0.4018238485,
0.1867976636,
0.2600263059,
0.0967747048,
-0.3181240261,
0.0190882459,
-0.607462585,
0.1567732692,
0.6702261567,
-0.6297907829,
0.0024423657,
0.6189641953,
0.2892318666,
0.0465129316,
0.5040253997,
-0.1206669956,
-0.6368736029,
0.4231832922,
0.6192401648,
0.6002017856,
-0.4102192819,
0.2624747455,
0.3607605994,
0.4933094084,
0.3770062029,
-0.0468265414,
0.3528905213,
-0.4432322979,
-0.5474177599,
-0.6162253022,
-0.3376609981,
0.5731157064,
-0.2225775272,
0.1345667541,
-0.7479093075,
0.4546934962,
0.0300087854,
-0.0465380698,
0.059410885,
0.0071178856,
0.4420436919,
0.6830368042,
-1.0656337738,
0.5253627896,
0.3445015848,
-0.5870810747,
-0.636179626,
-0.1525686234,
0.1457628012,
-0.7608018517,
0.9658924937,
0.1058634147,
-0.1508100331,
0.0593371019,
-0.5999692678,
-0.6542932391,
0.8053555489,
0.5098537207,
-0.5166363716,
0.0354072303,
0.2572746277,
0.6639117599,
-0.036166247,
0.5113158822,
0.4916639924,
0.5223649144,
0.2439583689,
-0.4469050765,
0.4003558159,
-0.2303854376,
-0.0208994709,
0.3045742512,
-0.5671255589,
0.814881444,
-0.3875109851,
-0.3241544366,
-0.1539073139,
0.5223805904,
0.3875873685,
0.0673702955,
0.4491099715,
0.5313713551,
0.3586730659,
0.1817150414,
1.01250422,
0.1358802468,
-0.0171969198,
1.0825848579,
-0.3364259005,
0.8349759579,
0.2120510638,
0.2203191817,
0.6563417912,
0.4694587588,
0.1047631428,
0.501101315,
0.7180128694,
-0.5227558017,
-0.1536209434,
-0.1435934454,
-0.1796840876,
0.1417260617,
0.5425236225,
-0.2194421887,
-0.5286908746,
0.0035555772,
0.33327353,
0.0959607139,
-0.4225978255,
1.0211235285,
0.1062998846,
-0.5642187595,
0.7206712961,
-0.0301781576,
0.7416119576,
-0.6744241118,
-0.2706901133,
-0.161179021,
0.1729900092,
-0.1471355706,
-0.7111842036,
0.227241978,
0.1222874299,
0.1384744495,
0.0287487358,
0.7810003161,
-0.4416737854,
-0.1775334477,
0.7409850955,
0.2304686904,
-0.0001027496,
-0.2830107808,
-0.6497079134,
0.1831255704,
-0.2549429834,
-0.3411672711,
0.6532162428,
0.4645734727,
-0.136939466,
0.7935146093,
0.7386498451,
0.1670568138,
0.1161084473,
-0.1300758719,
0.9876180291,
-0.5034056902,
-0.0676841736,
-0.9682771564,
0.5002142191,
0.0311773662,
0.0765580162,
0.5881173015,
0.2330343723,
0.7945966125,
0.0307914726,
0.6843491793,
0.3863016665,
0.1086430028,
-0.5433757305,
0.9538077116,
-0.509339869,
0.5315306783,
-0.358810544,
-0.6225152016,
-0.2593930364,
0.2544330359,
-0.3706223369,
0.1576903462,
0.6929429173,
0.8889403343,
0.1373632848,
-0.2785816193,
0.3343433142,
0.8377169967,
0.5221121311,
0.9707333446,
1.0772644281,
-0.1671094894,
0.8355842233,
-0.19991,
-0.3481486142,
-0.1789013594,
-1.2475750446,
-1.0743099451,
-0.3473868072,
-0.2277103662,
-0.6018549204,
0.4956706762,
0.4778741598,
0.312702924,
-0.6808390021,
0.1200006604,
-0.1438834071,
0.2310239524,
0.1630273312,
-0.2204233259,
0.1158497706,
-0.5007227659,
-0.7579956055,
0.3431469202,
0.2081558555,
0.1624938697,
-0.4531393051,
-0.2457228303,
-0.1535523832,
0.3362260461,
0.6655866504,
0.4124775529,
-0.6188693643,
-0.5391505957,
-0.3076572716,
-0.3906172514,
-0.3929125369,
0.4184501171,
-0.631362021,
0.1618910879,
0.1859153658,
0.5179359317,
0.1791710705,
-0.4353368282,
0.639520824,
-0.8191076517,
-0.0492265671,
0.3593429923,
0.1515706629,
0.0936997831,
-0.8324128389,
0.3954219818,
-0.2628313601,
-0.432601124,
-0.9402342439,
0.3499917984,
-0.7667564154,
-0.683868885,
1.5459526777,
-0.2269291431,
-0.4762088656,
-0.0349844061,
-0.2669945359,
0.2281143516,
-0.5272224545,
0.7735570073,
0.3798649311,
0.1743353754,
0.1479493082,
-0.7180644274,
0.901668489,
0.329234004,
-0.9260240793,
0.2283170223,
0.6452020407,
0.6129642129,
0.0093959542,
0.2958775163,
-0.4153984487,
0.424831748,
-0.1634848863,
-0.0524541438,
-0.3613142073,
-0.5016826391,
-0.5314834118,
0.0458165407,
0.2033048123,
0.2545410395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17376v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17376v1
|
CESAR: Automatic Induction of Compositional Instructions for Multi-turn Dialogs
| 2023-11-29T06:02:16 | 2023-11-29T06:02:16 |
Taha Aksu, Devamanyu Hazarika, Shikib Mehri, Seokhwan Kim, Dilek Hakkani-Tür, Yang Liu, Mahdi Namazifar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction-based multitasking has played a critical role in the success of
large language models (LLMs) in multi-turn dialog applications. While publicly
available LLMs have shown promising performance, when exposed to complex
instructions with multiple constraints, they lag against state-of-the-art
models like ChatGPT. In this work, we hypothesize that the availability of
large-scale complex demonstrations is crucial in bridging this gap. Focusing on
dialog applications, we propose a novel framework, CESAR, that unifies a large
number of dialog tasks in the same format and allows programmatic induction of
complex instructions without any manual effort.
We apply CESAR on InstructDial, a benchmark for instruction-based dialog
tasks. We further enhance InstructDial with new datasets and tasks and utilize
CESAR to induce complex tasks with compositional instructions. This results in
a new benchmark called InstructDial++, which includes 63 datasets with 86 basic
tasks and 68 composite tasks. Through rigorous experiments, we demonstrate the
scalability of CESAR in providing rich instructions. Models trained on
InstructDial++ can follow compositional prompts, such as prompts that ask for
multiple stylistic constraints.
|
[
-0.2589696944,
-0.7672664523,
0.6529240608,
0.6249380708,
0.0273802951,
0.0165472757,
-0.4191711843,
-0.2306126207,
-0.0965476632,
0.43922773,
-0.8654111028,
-0.4482690096,
-0.3445584774,
-0.0386062972,
-0.5570136905,
0.9467683434,
-0.1583503783,
0.378143996,
-0.1816617697,
0.1118001938,
-0.265023917,
-0.102972813,
-0.3539752364,
-0.3774324059,
0.448674202,
0.5338205695,
0.5679751635,
0.5726542473,
0.0444368161,
0.34940207,
0.4622727036,
0.5196300745,
-0.0798559636,
0.2530515194,
-0.0146166636,
-0.4939386249,
-0.3734287918,
0.0626480356,
0.845875442,
0.775090754,
-0.2049721628,
-0.0558192618,
0.1193956211,
0.5135608315,
-0.6585282683,
0.4673233628,
-0.5680260062,
-0.0384647474,
-0.1033076569,
-0.3909403086,
-0.4171557128,
-0.492095083,
0.3287716806,
-0.6233222485,
0.1641039252,
0.0023467985,
0.1565801203,
0.2200155109,
-0.3468587399,
-0.5361889601,
-0.9093469381,
0.6830167174,
-0.5359171629,
0.1086750701,
-0.2586716413,
0.4543263018,
-0.3227031231,
-0.6538963914,
-1.0423419476,
-0.469537437,
0.2346970737,
0.2512582242,
0.2071715295,
0.3518660367,
0.4261927903,
0.3640519083,
-0.4228855669,
-0.0005302646,
0.001899054,
-0.0267561451,
0.2178885937,
0.3977627754,
0.4608888328,
0.2182521522,
-0.4736537039,
-0.2151102126,
-0.7496758103,
0.111672014,
0.2981276512,
0.2496729344,
-0.2486115992,
0.6122354269,
-0.4206744432,
0.7622645497,
0.1172573715,
-0.0291626882,
0.1362410188,
-0.3477481008,
-0.2610343993,
0.182817623,
1.0365040302,
0.2282445282,
0.0893132463,
-0.1304454505,
-0.1207007095,
0.0798014626,
0.1812346429,
-0.7912899852,
0.0959972888,
0.3522830904,
0.017549878,
0.0001122195,
0.0740074739,
-0.505815208,
-0.6254149675,
-0.5766578913,
0.5468691587,
-0.2517202497,
-0.0533854552,
0.1675871164,
-0.1110515669,
0.4679962397,
0.8436883092,
-0.8824443817,
0.4219717383,
0.8353760839,
0.6046105027,
-0.2152022123,
-0.5407944918,
-1.0728368759,
0.0119613009,
-0.296361506,
0.6710860133,
-0.6567465663,
-0.1080321297,
0.3040006161,
0.2936224639,
-0.5420297384,
-0.5855509043,
0.5668236017,
-0.2295064181,
0.4903489351,
-0.0611522794,
-0.5222939253,
-0.0051335744,
0.3015812039,
-0.4904740751,
0.7788980603,
0.1655486524,
-0.4861326516,
-0.0497216098,
-1.0234723091,
-0.6573336124,
-0.0275267847,
-0.3485923409,
-0.1634201705,
-0.2008075565,
0.2274119556,
0.6312223077,
-0.5298225284,
0.1348708868,
-0.3215444684,
-0.3801407814,
0.4951428175,
-0.5588710308,
0.5915488601,
-0.1508908123,
-0.6982203126,
0.4697695374,
-0.6165503263,
0.0394951887,
-0.1442788541,
-0.3279904425,
0.2799822986,
-0.1742785722,
-0.0084966719,
0.2171422541,
0.1454899162,
-0.7261212468,
0.2865918875,
-0.2544129193,
0.3362050354,
0.4583975375,
-0.2319326401,
0.5127127171,
-0.6666128635,
0.5535471439,
0.0453060195,
0.1560300887,
-0.55887115,
-0.3439209759,
-0.9030002356,
-0.3278331161,
0.087688081,
0.7534114718,
-0.8806301355,
0.2074797601,
-0.3144327998,
-0.4376961887,
-0.4090116024,
0.1828687042,
0.6132483482,
0.3262889981,
0.1803853512,
-0.2072834224,
-0.0990184993,
-1.0725966692,
0.106157802,
0.3951556087,
-0.234272033,
0.1070509776,
0.311609,
-0.0404038206,
0.2885391414,
-0.205231607,
-0.0415632389,
-0.4801238477,
0.3401236236,
0.2032408714,
0.6119221449,
0.2045254707,
-0.5111460686,
-0.8062236309,
0.095893845,
-0.5198209286,
-0.009089753,
-0.5832324624,
-0.2874294221,
-0.0865406469,
0.3740711212,
-0.6706092358,
0.0920742899,
0.6960545778,
0.1770118922,
0.8526793718,
-0.285464108,
0.1346515715,
-1.0435367823,
-0.2193604261,
0.0901982933,
-0.3836281002,
-0.6312235594,
-0.23690328,
0.3015082181,
-0.1492101401,
-0.4647698104,
0.2424464971,
-0.3682699203,
-0.1202959642,
-0.1884659082,
0.1174875721,
0.1810616255,
0.9550321698,
0.1470685005,
0.8614763618,
0.698776722,
-0.775352478,
0.6254612207,
0.1651289314,
-0.6044860482,
0.7188815475,
-0.8069501519,
-0.0208664481,
-0.0964787006,
0.6388694644,
-0.9038657546,
-0.4433273077,
0.2938199937,
-0.0606268421,
0.46939978,
-0.3588848114,
-0.495138824,
-0.1258719265,
-0.4673189819,
-0.0827139243,
0.0764756575,
-0.6886025071,
0.6305904984,
0.099873744,
-0.2059042603,
-0.5902323723,
-0.1154128462,
-0.0702908933,
-0.1104667559,
-0.6272824407,
0.4790982604,
-0.2838332653,
-0.0958837345,
-0.4661149979,
-0.0958404392,
0.0969252512,
-0.0384737402,
0.3949311078,
0.103257753,
-0.103389211,
0.0744895265,
0.4299117327,
0.0941380188,
0.0636925623,
-0.4853040874,
0.6943740845,
-0.1357793212,
-0.6701500416,
-1.1890752316,
0.6095958352,
1.3153283596,
-0.2958568633,
0.5430430174,
0.6989420652,
-0.0236788783,
-0.4633793831,
-0.4965791702,
-0.0572071448,
-0.4651215374,
0.2212225199,
-0.2492156476,
-0.4696526229,
0.3666445017,
-0.4525684416,
0.4544538558,
0.0996797308,
0.7839645743,
-0.2434345335,
1.0843298435,
0.0967957973,
0.3284699619,
0.9975278378,
-0.4567995667,
-0.1090282723,
-1.155647397,
-0.1789900213,
-0.412951827,
-0.0898911357,
-0.40908131,
-0.6295868754,
0.6828825474,
-0.3772453666,
-0.272231251,
0.267457366,
-0.3648672104,
0.3361953497,
0.8136862516,
0.2067797631,
0.0764158815,
-0.2553882003,
-0.2086426169,
0.2425346375,
-0.7427123189,
-0.4697323442,
0.989313066,
0.1313153505,
0.8131033182,
0.1392683089,
0.5986679792,
0.3601948321,
0.4065928161,
-0.9033145905,
0.3733181953,
0.068436034,
-0.4931474924,
-0.5077313185,
-0.1555343121,
-0.9591444731,
0.418297261,
-0.3342864811,
-0.7305678129,
-0.0986500606,
0.1527023166,
-0.5986527205,
-0.1065072194,
-0.9324499369,
0.9178084135,
-0.2688889205,
-0.6963637471,
-0.246020928,
-0.5644845366,
0.3767221272,
0.3043224812,
0.1541656703,
-0.1839415431,
0.395801425,
0.5818981528,
-0.5596296191,
1.0439237356,
-0.2558993101,
-0.4542779028,
0.343218565,
0.0850770548,
1.0035895109,
0.1199496388,
0.0945672393,
-0.697443068,
0.1185141578,
-0.2319827229,
-0.9585997462,
0.9336520433,
-0.6084581017,
-0.6402112842,
-0.0659092143,
-0.5642231703,
-0.474093914,
-0.0734667107,
0.0769169778,
1.1543784142,
-0.0546191409,
0.2009488344,
0.8944026828,
-0.2337139398,
0.4711229205,
0.3019881845,
0.2578499615,
-0.2501301169,
0.9159906507,
-0.2380576879,
0.5698353052,
0.5925112963,
0.2730220258,
-0.4489967525,
-0.4156211913,
-1.0479778051,
0.0131280571,
-0.4877928495,
0.0624186173,
-0.872302413,
0.0885182619,
-0.0998362079,
-0.118829526,
-0.6348111629,
-0.6008697748,
0.0215997081,
0.2749352455,
-0.1466946751,
0.576110363,
0.232647866,
0.4535156786,
-0.8753464818,
0.4108703434,
0.8982644677,
0.1987040043,
0.1713978946,
-0.3099270761,
-0.2235793918,
0.3209376037,
-0.5456373692,
-0.6196966171,
0.0216056183,
0.2444952279,
0.6061826944,
0.5841446519,
0.275097698,
0.5055055618,
-0.5725821257,
0.6186665297,
0.3308880627,
-1.1009413004,
0.2585095167,
-0.7942785025,
0.414568305,
0.3383206129,
0.1377391219,
-0.7661799192,
-0.4215469956,
-0.5167824626,
-0.5567035675,
0.7211720347,
0.0784121305,
0.3582522273,
0.174175933,
-0.0926073194,
0.4120301008,
0.2498129159,
-0.4877247512,
0.1006370783,
-0.2022790164,
-0.2373565137,
0.232955873,
0.0061607948,
-0.3788620234,
-0.1780542135,
0.4676965177,
-0.3468391001,
0.4323022962,
0.2530679703,
-0.3634321392,
0.1615005881,
0.5785121918,
1.1220583916,
0.5977546573,
0.2354291677,
0.1053652391,
0.1058516279,
0.0080744298,
-0.1189876124,
0.0561085492,
0.1499212235,
-0.1325994432,
0.4476855397,
0.8112902045,
0.4530523419,
-0.6856942177,
0.5017822981,
-0.133486867,
-0.0223959964,
-0.5592610836,
0.4974878132,
0.083121784,
0.4530398846,
0.1415532678,
-0.2266288847,
0.1559430063,
-0.8320965767,
-0.0857056454,
0.5074357986,
-0.3677630723,
-0.2870642841,
0.6412046552,
0.5006866455,
-0.2168958634,
0.5094191432,
-0.2858112454,
-0.653834343,
0.5113953352,
0.3423420489,
0.735106945,
0.0820448399,
0.4567200243,
0.3458518386,
-0.0341077186,
-0.1619674414,
0.3236587346,
-0.5763673782,
-0.8472813368,
-0.5350936055,
-0.2775007784,
-0.9422639608,
-0.0219824463,
-0.518610239,
-0.1436433643,
-0.4311026633,
0.1690743268,
0.2467475384,
-0.0999903381,
-0.6683976054,
-0.1229894161,
0.2378627956,
0.5029155612,
-0.6797875166,
0.8039736152,
0.4299546778,
-0.0152376769,
-0.5405774117,
-0.0300588533,
0.0812022164,
-0.6584748626,
0.3383949697,
0.3577014804,
-0.3913914263,
-0.1297161579,
-0.6626960635,
-0.2024429142,
0.9214502573,
0.1907861531,
-0.5467398763,
0.1616174728,
0.0573619194,
0.3672429025,
-0.7063776851,
0.2486693561,
0.3286364973,
0.4420700371,
0.3112133145,
-1.1566832066,
0.1089993566,
-0.2622174919,
-0.267149061,
0.0415630192,
-0.6578659415,
0.7474969029,
-0.3865324557,
-0.2186606079,
0.1731906086,
0.4309424758,
0.0165929478,
0.270957619,
0.5731214881,
0.1185487434,
0.8188393116,
-0.1097074896,
1.0944513083,
-0.3451027274,
-0.0766269043,
1.4459884167,
-0.3592686951,
0.5204823017,
0.2193848789,
-0.130937323,
0.7047687173,
0.295550853,
0.2453817725,
0.3389924169,
0.3708080649,
-0.7308075428,
-0.3804828227,
-0.3010841608,
-0.2049376518,
0.5865933299,
0.7596572042,
-0.297783792,
-0.2125738114,
-0.0625003874,
0.1374629587,
0.0044750972,
-0.1087132618,
0.7327771187,
-0.3188686669,
-1.0258226395,
0.5759086013,
-0.1205282658,
0.4928694665,
-0.6207126379,
-0.162905395,
-0.0087025017,
0.3007788062,
-0.0325887017,
-0.5544455647,
-0.1192475185,
-0.2441680729,
0.1019112021,
-0.4569515288,
0.1499001235,
-0.6415126324,
-0.1727545112,
-0.2098260224,
0.5543765426,
-0.0462743156,
-0.3283255994,
-0.3259686828,
-0.0986402407,
-0.1198684052,
-0.0130800847,
0.2133379579,
0.6639698744,
-0.1810025871,
0.8708660603,
0.7349541187,
-0.3365855515,
0.2106180936,
0.335424304,
0.9536226988,
-0.407628864,
-0.2165036201,
-0.5655623674,
0.585819304,
-0.2506867647,
-0.1919080913,
0.6578477025,
0.4587659836,
0.5999841094,
-0.2545131147,
0.9708898664,
0.0588112921,
0.2567202747,
-0.6157479286,
0.4334639311,
-0.2455248982,
0.1898475736,
-0.1664233655,
-0.9912312031,
-0.0882997364,
0.4254291058,
-0.1408430189,
-0.3499674499,
0.783795774,
0.8823388219,
-0.0805379674,
0.18099913,
0.2408378869,
-0.1206328943,
0.4350538552,
0.5502110124,
1.1924060583,
0.0199189968,
0.4474327862,
-0.1977925599,
-0.3679436147,
-0.3119356036,
-0.5850427151,
-1.1100679636,
-0.722392261,
-0.3355485797,
-0.3263582289,
-0.2405061275,
1.3474397659,
0.8134000301,
-0.7442270517,
-0.3261539638,
-0.0800448135,
0.3320401013,
-0.5103794932,
-0.1619623899,
0.1840956062,
-0.5005316734,
-1.2103296518,
0.657856524,
0.3337957561,
0.0706504509,
-0.4568203092,
0.0694150329,
0.1106027067,
0.1194051206,
0.7630211115,
0.3694984615,
-0.5339666009,
-0.1532431096,
-0.1103494242,
-0.0572467037,
0.1371226013,
1.2054150105,
-0.4408017099,
0.6353285909,
0.441640377,
0.4279732108,
0.6523048282,
-0.2179469764,
0.9346656203,
-0.4695812166,
0.0879648253,
0.149532631,
0.3719987571,
0.2851651907,
0.0401081331,
0.1782681346,
-0.0736984238,
-0.278996706,
-0.4468788505,
0.4877257943,
-1.2769922018,
0.251480341,
1.1449103355,
-0.1829735339,
-0.2575291395,
-0.2375252545,
-0.4745763242,
0.1845803112,
-0.5724253654,
0.7878792882,
0.4314235747,
-0.3409166932,
-0.2935005426,
-0.5872343779,
0.4265311658,
0.0645039231,
-1.0147564411,
0.4150457978,
0.4889278114,
0.1805360466,
0.049511645,
0.4028472006,
-0.1183715314,
0.4162775278,
-0.0049993251,
0.0594737753,
-0.1523341984,
-0.5178000331,
0.1368124932,
0.2386142462,
-0.0868198872,
-0.5526744723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17371v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17371v2
|
Should we be going MAD? A Look at Multi-Agent Debate Strategies for LLMs
| 2023-11-29T05:54:41 | 2024-03-14T10:56:50 |
Andries Smit, Paul Duckworth, Nathan Grinsztajn, Thomas D. Barrett, Arnu Pretorius
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) underscore their
potential for responding to inquiries in various domains. However, ensuring
that generative agents provide accurate and reliable answers remains an ongoing
challenge. In this context, multi-agent debate (MAD) has emerged as a promising
strategy for enhancing the truthfulness of LLMs. We benchmark a range of
debating and prompting strategies to explore the trade-offs between cost, time,
and accuracy. Importantly, we find that multi-agent debating systems, in their
current form, do not reliably outperform other proposed prompting strategies,
such as self-consistency and ensembling using multiple reasoning paths.
However, when performing hyperparameter tuning, several MAD systems, such as
Multi-Persona, perform better. This suggests that MAD protocols might not be
inherently worse than other approaches, but that they are more sensitive to
different hyperparameter settings and difficult to optimize. We build on these
results to offer insights into improving debating strategies, such as adjusting
agent agreement levels, which can significantly enhance performance and even
surpass all other non-debate protocols we evaluated. We provide an open-source
repository to the community with several state-of-the-art protocols together
with evaluation scripts to benchmark across popular research datasets.
|
[
-0.8168724775,
-0.8482177854,
0.7069990039,
0.1506084353,
-0.0680333897,
0.3560640216,
-0.2052924335,
-0.3106978238,
-0.0188373663,
0.2901374996,
-0.5248106718,
-0.1013209,
-0.6805810332,
0.2413483262,
-0.0347539335,
0.7152069211,
0.1274086386,
0.2165272385,
-0.2640107572,
-0.1644452512,
-0.4452956915,
-0.4704679847,
-1.0372149944,
-0.6180973649,
0.8616240621,
0.4546249211,
0.9575242996,
0.3032761812,
0.4401079118,
0.4996900856,
-0.2342325896,
0.6104765534,
-0.5379120111,
0.6734761,
-0.4112163186,
-0.520798564,
-0.3909462988,
0.1472516656,
0.2131046355,
0.3259100616,
-0.242445156,
-0.0998443663,
-0.2519765794,
0.7641713619,
-0.8406618834,
0.0679088905,
-0.8553743958,
-0.055933971,
-0.2659287155,
-0.4685694873,
-0.5515811443,
-0.3610115051,
0.2219888419,
-0.2668604553,
-0.0570598021,
0.18901366,
1.0005930662,
0.2871719897,
-0.3508397639,
-0.1733571887,
-0.6102975011,
0.4003742337,
-0.7039913535,
0.0838860199,
0.243249312,
0.3999486864,
-0.5430929661,
-0.7062851191,
-0.5034966469,
-0.3256865442,
0.3012813032,
0.30571419,
-0.8630885482,
0.2042390257,
0.1388970315,
0.0021709148,
-0.2971289456,
0.097920157,
0.1140431017,
-0.1782814264,
0.6451010108,
0.2260131091,
-0.0403289981,
0.146362558,
-0.3159668744,
-0.1502879411,
-0.4343046844,
-0.2219684571,
0.8369613886,
0.2224863768,
0.0922446176,
0.5855001807,
-0.2397403121,
0.443599999,
0.4821726382,
0.0513389893,
-0.226147905,
-0.3236488402,
0.0306274239,
-0.1868661642,
0.978992641,
0.5821358562,
0.3650728762,
-0.34039855,
-0.364592731,
0.1046283618,
0.4962711036,
-0.5807925463,
-0.3036434948,
0.4731241167,
0.0050499947,
-0.0062721344,
-0.4481054544,
-0.9165403843,
-0.5694391131,
-0.3328770399,
0.6360707283,
-0.2195373178,
-0.3765683472,
0.3349644542,
-0.3716236949,
0.0465255231,
0.5220119953,
-0.5515048504,
0.2987318337,
0.8360096216,
1.000104785,
-0.0716076493,
-0.465993911,
-0.2833275199,
0.2573863268,
-0.8187642097,
1.4198518991,
-0.4043835402,
-0.5142355561,
-0.0648000613,
-0.284389466,
-0.0932684541,
-0.7548809648,
0.4669421911,
-0.4318121672,
-0.0165756848,
-0.6934341192,
-0.4658875465,
0.1548651755,
0.7331641912,
-0.6986743808,
0.6825194359,
-0.348377496,
-0.7496997118,
0.0780036226,
-0.6673048139,
-0.2726146579,
-0.0679583549,
0.012884073,
-0.2770959437,
-0.0748702064,
0.2903832197,
0.3042409718,
-0.5269438624,
0.3149697781,
-0.2738993168,
-0.253493458,
0.4686970115,
-0.6555368304,
0.4562610388,
0.3445069194,
-0.3901594281,
0.1654228717,
-0.2948036492,
0.1466642618,
0.0638636649,
-0.143673569,
-0.0133619066,
0.1255592257,
-0.518989861,
0.1770479679,
-0.0643500462,
-0.3868845701,
0.205852896,
-0.3734744787,
0.3913449347,
1.0331097841,
0.1411037445,
0.1338933259,
-0.7633953094,
0.5959425569,
0.2679261863,
0.187648505,
0.2269572318,
-0.4624446929,
-0.9544945955,
-0.1080854163,
-0.0970082879,
0.3091263175,
-0.8235499859,
-0.1713424921,
-0.0782818124,
-0.7551223636,
-0.6806791425,
-0.3109383881,
0.4580230117,
0.3564184308,
0.3071992397,
-0.1589066684,
-0.3395716548,
-0.6745765209,
-0.4330786467,
-0.663225472,
0.6122726202,
0.3513698876,
0.3283631504,
0.0004666233,
0.7678952217,
-0.341568768,
0.2347564697,
-0.2936057746,
0.4719425142,
-0.2683136761,
0.0723267943,
0.2883040607,
-0.3276726007,
-0.4807258546,
0.1078338772,
-0.4881620109,
-0.1035093144,
-0.1208398342,
-0.5322003961,
0.4841876626,
0.2991309762,
-1.0505002737,
0.1070521623,
0.3481338322,
-0.0768171847,
0.7567529678,
0.0313618481,
0.4694872499,
-0.7466908693,
-0.200775817,
0.0363523774,
-0.1105609313,
-0.5462825894,
0.049792368,
-0.2267385125,
0.1190866455,
-0.5782859325,
0.4142969847,
-0.6204083562,
0.1083427072,
-0.4680633545,
0.3057073951,
0.1543515772,
0.5030460358,
-0.0516524129,
1.2308593988,
0.7285980582,
-0.5527388453,
0.7318732738,
-0.0371329077,
-0.1358996034,
1.0334385633,
-0.6551816463,
0.5705059767,
-0.3719273806,
0.5279685259,
-0.9761154056,
0.1348288208,
0.4534613192,
-0.4242272973,
0.1830284894,
-0.2510148585,
-0.4503007233,
-0.2982262969,
-0.4663371444,
-0.0387817621,
0.013462685,
-0.3940443397,
0.3597924113,
0.5705085993,
-0.2758919299,
-0.7928548455,
-0.210697189,
0.6156725287,
-0.2462979853,
-0.637889266,
-0.0922215953,
-0.0352347568,
-0.5426735878,
-0.0837460309,
-0.071130529,
0.0389706306,
-0.200762853,
-0.0098971222,
-0.1252192557,
-0.3250185251,
0.2228380144,
0.0063055628,
-0.2417705655,
0.1920734793,
-0.1403513849,
0.7060329914,
-0.4067310691,
-0.4826734066,
-0.4709751904,
0.7452585101,
0.6430270672,
-0.3289736509,
0.5453575253,
0.3332740963,
-0.0965825543,
-0.0462105162,
-0.8322966099,
-0.146860227,
-0.5012986064,
0.241463542,
-0.5594821572,
-0.7334164381,
0.2460201979,
-0.5150066018,
0.4879777133,
0.1834498495,
0.9636888504,
-0.1484445632,
1.3048639297,
0.2949988842,
-0.008133187,
0.0012981421,
0.0157776549,
0.1817187518,
-0.3677563667,
-0.3678977489,
-0.8798035383,
-0.3556759655,
-0.3717765808,
-0.5687757134,
0.295404762,
-0.4424910247,
-0.3045652807,
0.0736817345,
-0.1739089042,
0.6061160564,
0.1951565444,
-0.2117541134,
0.3263459206,
-0.3807870448,
-0.0168530699,
0.1725045145,
-0.6727243066,
-0.6686648726,
0.6660873294,
0.2466404289,
1.0746380091,
0.3564710617,
0.3861100674,
0.1891496032,
0.2025519758,
-0.9142093062,
0.6166098714,
0.3974238634,
-0.6718395948,
-0.4008773565,
-0.4195579886,
-1.1744244099,
0.743729651,
-0.008027547,
-0.4158367217,
0.2855636775,
0.1536999047,
-0.2713651359,
0.5372830629,
-0.7431296706,
0.670817554,
-0.1708650738,
-0.2883653343,
-0.1268660426,
-0.6489136219,
0.0992630944,
0.3870161474,
-0.1149510294,
-0.3282369673,
-0.1357701719,
0.4783996344,
-0.3544903994,
0.5468388796,
0.1065921262,
-0.3971483111,
0.4402586222,
-0.1457035244,
0.734885335,
0.0249083191,
-0.1093490571,
-0.0308016073,
0.070075877,
-0.401478678,
-0.6302681565,
0.7132650614,
-1.0122500658,
-1.0562868118,
-0.3989239037,
-0.5850744247,
-0.6773635149,
-0.1802307218,
0.2585683763,
0.2170466036,
-0.1457649767,
-0.1985992193,
0.7976238132,
0.3275925815,
0.420686394,
0.6848335862,
0.1697570682,
-0.340869993,
0.919670105,
0.1031955406,
0.4280170798,
0.1373691261,
0.3655362725,
-0.5381843448,
-0.4303745925,
-0.5601127148,
0.2045014352,
-0.722235918,
-0.4389789999,
-0.961714685,
0.00555583,
-0.6099582911,
0.1735526025,
-0.7335940599,
-0.0626740605,
-0.0789901614,
-0.1146932617,
0.2203874141,
0.4772144556,
-0.0813030526,
0.2238639593,
-0.4325844944,
0.0679477304,
0.4577765465,
0.1818356961,
0.0804624557,
-0.2153698802,
-0.1417112648,
-0.1174990311,
-0.7305383682,
-1.1855075359,
0.1368269771,
0.0080341073,
0.7153543234,
0.455922097,
0.2290847003,
0.9901489019,
-0.5563230515,
0.5832686424,
0.0613240078,
-0.7413547635,
0.4165328443,
-0.1754218042,
0.1234385818,
0.5729700327,
0.5080978274,
-0.5743957758,
-0.7566299438,
-0.4868718982,
-0.6764210463,
0.6335833073,
-0.0139353015,
0.1897496283,
-0.2097434998,
0.0539571941,
0.0479904376,
0.2391720116,
-0.4354489148,
-0.4399864078,
-0.0828881487,
0.4920501709,
-0.0021176159,
0.0180856157,
-0.6159833074,
-0.0967771858,
0.6369394064,
-0.1621118784,
0.1841280758,
0.0882244855,
0.2011295259,
-0.5001819134,
0.5333169699,
0.5624587536,
0.8299784064,
0.2092117369,
0.3799666166,
0.0896147043,
-0.1238241941,
0.4834456742,
-0.0600417256,
0.1442228258,
0.1968158484,
-0.0829404667,
1.017439723,
-0.1787158996,
-0.6759076715,
0.3675071299,
-0.2365562171,
-0.5082184672,
0.3152933121,
0.0877945349,
0.2878243029,
0.6545466185,
-0.1881507635,
0.0305007249,
0.1909309477,
-0.5456603765,
-0.0868916139,
0.6506403685,
-0.2171442211,
-0.1403816789,
0.2233725637,
0.2772216797,
-0.4047444761,
0.0883365273,
0.0242179949,
-0.2654097378,
0.4963537455,
0.5756222606,
0.7867670655,
-0.242855683,
0.6200605035,
-0.0335338488,
0.4694608748,
-0.2657009065,
0.253665477,
0.1037335992,
-0.633610785,
-0.3940968513,
0.0082728649,
-1.0918927193,
0.171633631,
-0.4413821995,
0.0734899491,
-0.4197767675,
-0.545067668,
-0.0686015859,
0.2908993065,
-0.2106250077,
-0.2492671907,
0.0939509273,
0.8567637205,
-0.654871285,
0.4250171185,
0.9526027441,
-0.0986331254,
-0.5448164344,
0.1179104969,
0.1137559339,
-0.4044992626,
-0.0327941515,
-0.1432089806,
-0.6794733405,
-0.051506456,
-0.9219235182,
-0.6765298247,
0.6403918266,
0.8073370457,
-0.4913557172,
0.1329299212,
-0.0485677309,
0.4847445786,
0.074677892,
0.4618804455,
0.4668405354,
0.6855027676,
0.4125462472,
-0.6451324821,
-0.1903154403,
-0.1940522194,
-0.186531812,
0.2575620413,
-1.1777005196,
0.8863002658,
-0.342816174,
-0.3137869537,
-0.0483051687,
0.8285198808,
0.3403868377,
0.5306832194,
0.3819960058,
0.4800794125,
0.8420242071,
-0.0474654585,
0.7853498459,
-0.034154702,
0.2466928661,
0.8130979538,
-0.6073322296,
0.6912202835,
0.5689148903,
-0.2518420517,
0.2842746973,
0.7206237912,
0.2873673141,
0.1896978915,
0.5648691654,
-0.4237561822,
-0.6390170455,
-0.1578180492,
-0.430711776,
0.2227703184,
0.291154325,
0.5499027371,
-0.4898442626,
-0.2008805126,
0.5770397186,
0.0775050521,
0.0558638424,
0.8690932989,
-0.0788414031,
-1.2323297262,
0.4987481236,
0.1881102473,
0.5479289293,
-0.4948684871,
0.1846681386,
-0.5654489398,
-0.1311013699,
0.0667247698,
-0.7269304991,
-0.0928418413,
0.0579484627,
0.102295652,
-0.1313239038,
0.5304274559,
-0.4059607983,
0.0295189004,
0.1580789387,
0.9908929467,
0.3017549217,
0.0459030457,
-1.0366252661,
0.0843593702,
-0.6339712143,
-0.4300498366,
0.412158519,
0.8585591912,
-0.013234132,
0.9552505016,
0.6421806812,
0.1820919812,
0.1102353409,
0.4395649433,
1.0477368832,
-0.3912901282,
-0.2940252423,
-1.0032655001,
0.1987526566,
-0.0889134109,
-0.4501908123,
0.6834629178,
0.3327313066,
0.5925827026,
0.2851018906,
0.4601470828,
0.3497269452,
0.2494702041,
-0.3146697581,
0.6833987236,
-0.5052829981,
0.1172198877,
-0.3103886843,
-0.5771116018,
0.1119887158,
0.4076090455,
0.0869032815,
0.0530956462,
0.772053957,
1.0952172279,
0.3646474481,
0.2088634968,
0.3864458799,
0.2277373224,
0.5434988141,
0.6562228203,
1.4434044361,
0.0418917052,
0.6423767209,
-0.0586322509,
-0.1100395471,
-0.0493600443,
-0.6860818267,
-0.8009326458,
-0.4165921509,
-0.5381708741,
-0.2339311987,
0.5841317773,
0.9319220185,
0.5339791775,
-0.4232515395,
-0.389621824,
0.1874285638,
0.427798897,
-0.3531880677,
-0.1165488288,
-0.0592522807,
-0.764208138,
-0.9842351079,
0.3770980835,
0.4935463369,
-0.1020073295,
-0.3906449974,
-0.1755947322,
-0.5286229253,
0.7840929627,
0.5616744161,
0.4343369603,
-0.7348995805,
-0.1862900108,
-0.0799160525,
-0.4740690589,
0.2554772496,
0.7548347116,
-0.5782799721,
0.4582639933,
0.3420801461,
0.7175219655,
-0.0262952391,
0.0747515559,
0.422938019,
-0.3179082274,
-0.2542329133,
0.342903018,
0.1052706018,
0.1214770153,
-0.1043907627,
0.2869125009,
0.1313609779,
-0.8115311265,
-0.9420341849,
0.1459854394,
-0.8453168869,
-0.2576952279,
1.2495250702,
-0.1928751767,
0.03515587,
-0.5238901973,
-0.4886672795,
0.2177782357,
-0.4951000214,
0.7378817201,
0.9196357131,
-0.4818526804,
-0.3506346941,
-0.4096928537,
0.3791218698,
0.5630195737,
-0.9463897347,
0.2659847438,
0.486030221,
-0.1656717807,
0.0105827665,
0.9729452729,
-0.1193621755,
0.2018951923,
0.0562126189,
-0.2431275696,
0.1275942326,
-0.7138804197,
0.0032266534,
0.2433327287,
0.2201277763,
-0.1576508284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17355v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17355v1
|
Are Large Language Models Good Fact Checkers: A Preliminary Study
| 2023-11-29T05:04:52 | 2023-11-29T05:04:52 |
Han Cao, Lingwei Wei, Mengyang Chen, Wei Zhou, Songlin Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have drawn significant attention due
to their outstanding reasoning capabilities and extensive knowledge repository,
positioning them as superior in handling various natural language processing
tasks compared to other language models. In this paper, we present a
preliminary investigation into the potential of LLMs in fact-checking. This
study aims to comprehensively evaluate various LLMs in tackling specific
fact-checking subtasks, systematically evaluating their capabilities, and
conducting a comparative analysis of their performance against pre-trained and
state-of-the-art low-parameter models. Experiments demonstrate that LLMs
achieve competitive performance compared to other small models in most
scenarios. However, they encounter challenges in effectively handling Chinese
fact verification and the entirety of the fact-checking pipeline due to
language inconsistencies and hallucinations. These findings underscore the need
for further exploration and research to enhance the proficiency of LLMs as
reliable fact-checkers, unveiling the potential capability of LLMs and the
possible challenges in fact-checking tasks.
|
[
-0.2246605903,
-0.6442708373,
1.010735631,
-0.1383289248,
-0.3716685474,
-0.0611301102,
-0.3091097474,
-0.5556668639,
-0.0856702477,
0.5822952986,
-0.3204772174,
-0.3512099385,
-0.8128398657,
0.2561887801,
-0.6282697916,
0.6926789284,
0.0568439178,
0.1007409915,
-0.3395312428,
-0.1115584373,
-0.2195424438,
-0.6834746599,
-0.7584423423,
-0.6631758213,
0.6709138751,
0.153356418,
0.6569096446,
0.5473864675,
0.5360330939,
0.3859649301,
-0.3599140346,
0.4811305106,
-0.4805147946,
-0.0612073839,
-0.1893069893,
-0.6127022505,
-0.3617682159,
0.1902020425,
0.7396323085,
0.4624113739,
-0.0198871996,
0.2169611603,
-0.0320383385,
0.4341077805,
-0.387057513,
0.2488931268,
-0.7055787444,
-0.0647696704,
-0.3218938112,
0.0393737443,
-0.4662568867,
-0.5474069715,
0.0075877779,
-0.0738521069,
0.1499023438,
0.2497093529,
0.9784838557,
0.2846106589,
-0.5396784544,
-0.4420574009,
-0.675921917,
0.717983067,
-1.0715466738,
0.538713038,
0.2563100159,
0.2494003922,
-0.1881945282,
-0.625059247,
-0.6247289181,
-0.5853494406,
-0.3777557611,
-0.1523699164,
-0.0211300701,
-0.0408396125,
0.4794784486,
0.5685701966,
-0.4961027503,
0.5899147391,
-0.127142176,
-0.3968419135,
0.5518150926,
0.276055485,
0.3707106709,
-0.310988903,
-0.110895738,
0.2999250889,
-0.9748906493,
0.0605908893,
0.28758201,
0.2118677199,
-0.0145972306,
0.706605494,
-0.2710212171,
0.5831573606,
-0.2619201541,
-0.4380014539,
-0.1840542555,
-0.545656383,
-0.2486173064,
-0.0860849991,
0.7209974527,
0.0460174866,
0.1844825745,
-0.2645019889,
-0.4974415004,
-0.1545651108,
0.0069182981,
-0.8420594931,
-0.1792823076,
0.2325820923,
-0.5413748622,
-0.060757529,
0.0334918946,
-0.2357937247,
-0.6648313999,
-0.3595460653,
0.4009973109,
-0.1303765625,
-0.1606971622,
0.1538797468,
0.0765062943,
0.3208411932,
0.6134269834,
-0.609613359,
-0.108598128,
0.9343519807,
0.9293684959,
-0.2199234366,
-0.1545413136,
-0.6158828139,
-0.1293779016,
-0.6474935412,
0.7055658698,
-0.1873603761,
0.020228697,
0.1109252498,
0.0006923794,
0.0729417056,
-0.6141039729,
0.8403042555,
-0.7793892622,
-0.1333392262,
-0.6802687049,
-0.6346696615,
-0.0548890568,
0.7538898587,
-0.772464335,
0.6936773658,
-0.2508091033,
-0.7192443609,
0.2853815258,
-0.296171695,
-0.508892417,
0.0703107193,
-0.2678792775,
-0.3760023117,
0.0509938039,
0.0512018688,
0.6070508361,
-0.5637504458,
0.2538438439,
-0.2391981184,
-0.4239528179,
0.5745854974,
-0.3673388362,
0.7289480567,
0.1685484797,
-0.1300059259,
0.1782905459,
-0.7078613043,
-0.1792064309,
0.2343748957,
-0.5922877789,
-0.2147195339,
0.1216639504,
-0.4425852597,
0.2750954628,
0.410110116,
-0.5606344938,
0.1482243836,
-0.1660635471,
0.3781053126,
0.5826150775,
-0.1528627574,
0.0150946323,
-0.3051095009,
0.228733182,
0.0954172313,
0.0929897651,
-0.1180707663,
-0.2427309752,
-1.1494326591,
-0.2442256659,
0.6203500032,
0.3669743538,
-0.8966464996,
0.3208114803,
-0.0546043664,
-0.5679441094,
-0.0851461515,
0.2275694013,
0.2896630168,
0.1829541177,
0.0055205887,
0.0548791066,
-0.5516762733,
-0.8359689116,
-0.2349325269,
-0.2867122591,
0.0442209952,
0.0452105999,
0.6522331238,
-0.0759872571,
0.6963195801,
-0.2856578231,
-0.102644302,
-0.5624857545,
0.0228590332,
0.2941709459,
0.0263400488,
0.4974234104,
-0.6882870793,
-0.2445668578,
0.0254471749,
-0.8752290606,
-0.0201637782,
-0.0013779213,
0.3161771595,
0.2835216522,
0.4839633703,
-0.9426662922,
0.051430162,
0.67097646,
-0.0894218832,
0.6785342097,
-0.236012876,
0.2021307498,
-0.5054939389,
0.0293410271,
0.0320335589,
-0.3906667829,
-0.6335012913,
0.1360435337,
0.1403290629,
0.2947026193,
-0.5916208029,
0.2999961078,
-0.5473139882,
-0.1832873076,
-0.458014518,
0.133730948,
-0.3712537587,
0.0985008851,
0.0365899205,
0.6802285314,
0.5043183565,
-0.7502511144,
0.6177232862,
-0.1579035223,
-0.9532313943,
-0.0097977417,
-0.6043013334,
0.0853437185,
0.0353295244,
0.1828773171,
-0.8915551901,
-0.2278300226,
0.0232351217,
-0.1128837764,
0.1385989785,
-0.181606248,
-1.0117980242,
-0.413362056,
-0.1785141975,
-0.0235791504,
0.5466791987,
-0.6641250253,
0.4167038202,
0.2282482386,
-0.1595336795,
-0.5328713655,
-0.4901856184,
0.2905755937,
-0.071841754,
-0.4492167532,
-0.2250132114,
0.1269930601,
-0.5217754245,
-0.1675326377,
-0.088860482,
0.0794097558,
0.1703090817,
0.047689978,
0.3204528391,
-0.4298678637,
-0.0397827588,
-0.3700921535,
-0.0055299303,
0.19800134,
0.0138129154,
0.3810895681,
-0.1786422431,
-0.5931926966,
-0.333315134,
-0.263531059,
0.6364385486,
-0.3091289699,
0.8514809012,
0.5042437315,
-0.5100851059,
-0.188672483,
-0.9497231841,
-0.2830225825,
-0.4409971535,
0.4917325377,
-0.1601535231,
-1.1669112444,
0.508135438,
-0.1666457355,
0.1095862463,
0.4387509227,
0.7610597014,
0.0342914313,
0.9172907472,
0.6259050369,
-0.1724422723,
0.0334503427,
-0.0239984766,
0.4632499218,
-0.3946606517,
-0.1243674308,
-0.6206828952,
-0.0218606032,
-0.5851271749,
-0.46999681,
0.2941501737,
-0.1736035198,
-0.0830459744,
0.0773151889,
0.2483544946,
0.5724669099,
0.2539639175,
-0.1670163721,
0.6208615303,
-0.3693145812,
0.0954464152,
0.0709395409,
-0.7955131531,
-0.7958741188,
0.709330976,
0.6042329669,
0.8553768992,
0.1402743608,
0.2891492844,
0.2657990158,
0.3619684875,
-0.6933339834,
0.7448323965,
-0.3915984631,
-0.6068758965,
-0.4925308824,
-0.4892892838,
-0.4268165231,
0.5000014901,
-0.3405194283,
-0.5084162951,
-0.0621106513,
0.1211657971,
-0.3721801639,
0.6530658007,
-0.2915928364,
0.6179019809,
-0.688054204,
-0.3079118133,
-0.2499444187,
-0.3156915605,
0.8175842762,
-0.1943503171,
0.2421637177,
-0.1260772496,
0.0469077453,
0.4816912711,
-0.1726737022,
0.8966538906,
0.0919444114,
-0.5417723656,
0.347859174,
0.0613914505,
0.688187778,
0.1311382502,
-0.1667583287,
0.3464509547,
-0.1149470806,
-0.1056323349,
-0.4798915386,
0.6882685423,
-0.7168328762,
-0.938950479,
-0.572122395,
-0.4839023352,
-0.2558968961,
0.3247812092,
0.0503529087,
0.3099328578,
-0.2324630618,
0.5414995551,
0.9389936924,
-0.1162253395,
0.373552829,
0.9198510647,
-0.2952547371,
0.0905596018,
0.8101515174,
0.3075863123,
0.1345026791,
0.5846253633,
0.3413152099,
-0.2822020054,
-1.0425482988,
-0.3756613135,
0.3584328294,
-0.6815463305,
-0.0036274022,
-0.6449182034,
-0.4918452501,
-0.237731427,
0.4146061838,
-0.6115782261,
-0.1290519387,
-0.0091448901,
0.007550397,
-0.0825090483,
1.0143408775,
0.0183443613,
0.0386165679,
-0.7851237059,
0.4372216761,
0.4840088785,
0.3322765231,
-0.0465230197,
-0.590215981,
-0.4959730506,
-0.0248154216,
-0.0310660936,
-0.4134166837,
-0.0118698105,
-0.3253468573,
0.7441321611,
0.5286360383,
-0.0465489998,
0.2410506159,
-0.4589239061,
1.0201072693,
-0.128126055,
-0.6702179909,
0.1114504039,
-0.1631333232,
0.1353183985,
0.0940142423,
0.3435589671,
-0.4746158719,
-0.497667402,
-0.2591802776,
-0.3299297392,
0.8049385548,
0.1529144347,
-0.0306883305,
0.238364622,
0.5124647021,
0.1153060496,
0.2097599208,
-0.8037911654,
-0.2355913669,
0.0480517894,
0.2644901872,
-0.3371575773,
-0.7374011278,
-0.0533819087,
0.007389321,
0.8611510396,
-0.0245274995,
-0.2644736767,
-0.0936770216,
-0.1498822719,
-0.1484887153,
0.6087424755,
0.7584929466,
0.8254654408,
-0.1330294609,
0.3651439548,
0.4596357942,
-0.2244792432,
0.1059784144,
-0.2092113048,
-0.2251161486,
0.0410368666,
0.6340732574,
0.7028096318,
0.0661144555,
-0.7248769999,
0.4588010907,
-0.0668632165,
-0.158083111,
-0.115015693,
0.2773107886,
0.3438596427,
0.2929441631,
0.1832932383,
-0.2715418637,
-0.0100263366,
-0.8466201425,
-0.1407920569,
0.5533300042,
0.120896183,
-0.2888609469,
0.3031288981,
0.237754494,
-0.0645408556,
0.6255175471,
-0.1539001763,
-0.882615447,
0.6277598143,
0.3864196539,
0.5577941537,
-0.0263332818,
-0.0701247081,
0.2545025051,
0.831507206,
-0.4928378165,
-0.0786078945,
0.1604359895,
-0.8855044246,
-0.6315589547,
-0.4252707958,
-0.7867723107,
0.6527007222,
-0.2109654248,
0.2957591712,
-0.4594837427,
-0.1122938842,
-0.221791476,
0.2294616699,
-0.5935062766,
0.3647237122,
0.4332948029,
0.9230384231,
-0.6320317984,
0.8848410845,
0.7994664907,
-0.2512222528,
-0.6369664669,
0.1390961707,
0.0546462536,
-0.6074832678,
0.8323835135,
0.0714892149,
-0.351441741,
-0.4545943439,
-0.5033581257,
-0.8475652337,
0.9657942653,
0.6226345301,
-0.8933262825,
-0.092238687,
0.3966776729,
0.7284993529,
-0.1200711951,
0.2167269737,
0.7289633155,
0.5591343045,
0.0899062008,
-0.9747166634,
0.0819157809,
0.1052885652,
-0.2305554301,
-0.1009618491,
-1.0035432577,
1.1102147102,
-0.2807542384,
-0.1332534701,
0.1885303855,
0.9087595344,
0.2645089626,
0.2388480008,
0.6654990315,
0.3598782718,
0.694868207,
-0.1353472471,
0.9426215887,
-0.3148232698,
0.3569833338,
0.88667804,
-0.5289873481,
0.7100312114,
0.2136072665,
-0.206249103,
0.3709961772,
0.5202829242,
-0.0602201633,
0.1035675779,
0.1580379754,
-0.0253425706,
-0.8253203034,
-0.1064370647,
-0.1148069724,
0.4892066121,
0.2344191819,
-0.1274206042,
-0.2280112952,
-0.3310453892,
-0.0769636258,
-0.1124771312,
-0.3943044841,
0.5866979361,
0.1886396855,
-0.6761544347,
0.2920645177,
0.2271924615,
0.6956701279,
-0.7296814919,
-0.0144892074,
-0.1740338802,
0.1953522712,
-0.191556558,
-0.8400145173,
-0.040211346,
0.311221838,
-0.0766704455,
-0.0854305327,
1.0018496513,
-0.3398543,
-0.1735153943,
0.1088906005,
0.6372860074,
0.0629591048,
-0.1685598493,
-0.4972116351,
0.4400154352,
-0.1815527081,
-0.2288374007,
0.3086826801,
0.4427343309,
-0.006151469,
0.8627217412,
0.486310482,
0.2379441857,
-0.1136252955,
0.2593378425,
0.5104662776,
-0.5701833367,
-0.3444622159,
-1.0737537146,
0.1211553365,
0.0295549501,
0.0687521473,
1.1879767179,
0.7213537693,
0.8188889027,
-0.0921390727,
0.8379433751,
0.1448817551,
0.5720683932,
-0.7515403032,
0.8946359158,
-0.4824860394,
0.36661309,
0.0973431319,
-0.7499981523,
-0.1316698492,
0.3474809527,
-0.4379756749,
0.1529753953,
0.7389808893,
0.6924684048,
-0.0032896721,
0.2190955132,
0.5828024149,
0.5726983547,
0.4473867714,
0.312571466,
1.3169404268,
-0.1473014504,
0.413896203,
-0.1773657799,
0.1116282195,
-0.315423727,
-1.0514187813,
-1.3215038776,
-0.2586249411,
-0.2671991885,
-0.102838248,
0.0146016171,
0.7841386795,
0.5667101741,
-0.8978141546,
-0.2152660042,
0.2824328244,
0.538056612,
0.1535158455,
-0.1109023094,
0.2871972919,
-0.2820678949,
-0.6482371092,
0.3370624483,
0.2180184573,
0.0538688414,
-0.5819836259,
-0.0285734423,
-0.1168698817,
0.3897073269,
0.8893297315,
0.0877570063,
-0.9454122782,
-0.4494940341,
-0.1772160977,
-0.3578477502,
-0.2298606783,
1.2027336359,
-0.502869606,
0.0012101394,
0.5187285542,
0.7181064487,
0.2413437814,
-0.1550049782,
0.1204792932,
-0.3719737828,
-0.1809865683,
-0.1067807823,
0.7512952685,
0.5516665578,
-0.2733870447,
0.3448756933,
0.1068768576,
-0.6754606366,
-0.9524739385,
0.0419769473,
-0.7074445486,
-0.2103619426,
1.2133483887,
-0.1296298653,
-0.0406815074,
-0.0629878119,
-0.0929366201,
0.2618915439,
0.0206233785,
0.8063630462,
1.0730867386,
-0.1404762417,
-0.1644357741,
-0.6114646792,
0.536069572,
0.3204696774,
-0.7849573493,
0.2247056216,
0.354411006,
0.4363820255,
0.1025488377,
0.388746649,
0.0170664638,
0.3012312055,
-0.2294573188,
-0.3305068314,
-0.1248756349,
-0.4242246449,
-0.1807352751,
0.2108667642,
0.5174944401,
0.2071550786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03742v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03742v1
|
Clinical Risk Prediction Using Language Models: Benefits And Considerations
| 2023-11-29T04:32:19 | 2023-11-29T04:32:19 |
Angeela Acharya, Sulabh Shrestha, Anyi Chen, Joseph Conte, Sanja Avramovic, Siddhartha Sikdar, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Sanmay Das
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The utilization of Electronic Health Records (EHRs) for clinical risk
prediction is on the rise. However, strict privacy regulations limit access to
comprehensive health records, making it challenging to apply standard machine
learning algorithms in practical real-world scenarios. Previous research has
addressed this data limitation by incorporating medical ontologies and
employing transfer learning methods. In this study, we investigate the
potential of leveraging language models (LMs) as a means to incorporate
supplementary domain knowledge for improving the performance of various
EHR-based risk prediction tasks. Unlike applying LMs to unstructured EHR data
such as clinical notes, this study focuses on using textual descriptions within
structured EHR to make predictions exclusively based on that information. We
extensively compare against previous approaches across various data types and
sizes. We find that employing LMs to represent structured EHRs, such as
diagnostic histories, leads to improved or at least comparable performance in
diverse risk prediction tasks. Furthermore, LM-based approaches offer numerous
advantages, including few-shot learning, the capability to handle previously
unseen medical concepts, and adaptability to various medical vocabularies.
Nevertheless, we underscore, through various experiments, the importance of
being cautious when employing such models, as concerns regarding the
reliability of LMs persist.
|
[
0.4082936347,
-0.6761652231,
0.9716591835,
-0.3559878469,
-0.0287267603,
-0.2374409288,
-0.0014653392,
-0.8210505843,
-0.0932290256,
0.8738640547,
-0.2325445712,
-0.6602243185,
-0.819019258,
-0.252494067,
-0.1967318803,
1.2353396416,
-0.0398094542,
0.1377315372,
-0.2530602515,
0.316534549,
-0.4305634797,
-0.6943309903,
-0.3239715397,
-0.4065797031,
0.6421096325,
0.292308867,
0.7575233579,
0.9950008988,
0.8592938185,
0.1590927839,
0.1136513576,
-0.2493050694,
-0.0897594094,
0.0687400997,
0.1627089232,
-0.5883415937,
-0.526584506,
-0.4420700669,
0.3560275137,
0.8648194075,
-0.493900001,
0.0280596018,
-0.148672834,
0.5324518085,
-0.4883269668,
0.3229878545,
-0.8175560236,
0.2422073036,
-0.1124093235,
-0.4366185665,
-0.4744234979,
-0.3035314679,
0.7593888044,
-0.5993076563,
0.0135575645,
0.0915146023,
0.6417987943,
0.1109131575,
-0.4357184172,
-0.4353527725,
-0.9630676508,
0.6052629352,
-0.5155623555,
0.3721889257,
0.8157866597,
0.5752536058,
0.1075314134,
-0.8017737269,
-0.1030661091,
-0.2493250966,
-0.2541616261,
0.0265326351,
-0.1335583031,
0.3074177802,
0.2078301311,
0.056779366,
-0.4971855879,
0.2933059037,
-0.6579979062,
-0.229547739,
0.5843399763,
0.4904071689,
0.4239807129,
-0.1410819888,
-0.4536879063,
-0.0721208975,
-0.8967282772,
0.0290330462,
-0.2097482383,
0.4567991495,
-0.2367151827,
0.4837372303,
0.182052061,
0.4807162881,
-0.2436002344,
-0.5294573903,
0.3027069569,
-0.0175721552,
-0.2079095244,
0.2464937866,
0.5670623779,
0.4222843647,
0.1536576599,
-0.2418750077,
0.0151081085,
0.02225345,
0.5223317742,
-0.6025514603,
-0.370029211,
0.3723551035,
-0.5976093411,
-0.3482414484,
-0.0685016736,
-0.8632137775,
-0.4890723526,
-0.0504251383,
0.4181809425,
-0.6032571793,
0.0973451585,
0.289056927,
0.2132894993,
-0.2584035695,
0.3939517736,
-0.5715129375,
0.5152043104,
0.5084060431,
0.6728561521,
-0.1422109306,
0.0731958747,
-0.4986593127,
0.3230098784,
-0.1046291292,
0.6982015371,
-0.3413887918,
-0.7022559047,
0.3944169283,
0.0018306777,
-0.1725778133,
-0.3245037198,
0.6533545256,
-0.2137893736,
0.0718455762,
0.255807966,
-0.7317004204,
-0.1313575655,
0.1679955423,
-0.8691452146,
0.6078308821,
0.0135006886,
-0.7367842793,
0.26247105,
-0.2902600169,
-0.6791415215,
0.1368328035,
-0.2429226637,
-0.9452067614,
-0.0954869837,
-0.1010888666,
0.6860974431,
-0.1583450288,
0.1824919283,
-0.3824671209,
0.0884389281,
0.6186341643,
0.0015075452,
0.2414923906,
0.1387030333,
0.0260900818,
0.0125208814,
-0.6754177213,
0.0616703406,
0.0844793767,
-0.2197733074,
-0.6938638091,
0.112023294,
0.1285172552,
0.3225705326,
-0.1111613512,
-0.3484115601,
-0.3073310852,
-0.5729381442,
0.0459557101,
0.428991884,
0.0735626817,
0.350676626,
-0.7962318063,
0.7312752008,
0.0597243905,
0.2289918661,
-0.2720627785,
-0.5327010155,
-0.1110975891,
-0.1545473188,
0.3254169524,
0.8149362803,
-0.454939574,
0.2569821775,
-0.4363591075,
-0.5783033967,
-0.373057574,
-0.0769774988,
0.5519268513,
0.6424863338,
0.3890681267,
-0.2023609281,
-0.6575903296,
-0.5267199278,
-0.3374091387,
-0.4906332791,
-0.0268240459,
0.5563789606,
0.244352147,
-0.2609128058,
0.3855791092,
-0.7160803676,
-0.5453129411,
-0.4791351259,
-0.2637553811,
-0.0602634437,
0.2969115674,
0.2347900718,
-0.6010472178,
-0.5335475802,
0.3289689422,
-0.6818886995,
0.2148530185,
-0.0255524013,
0.0265518222,
0.0452537462,
0.2784370184,
-0.3803177178,
0.6632606983,
0.7048302293,
-0.2410619408,
0.2880859971,
-0.4550668597,
-0.2181866616,
-1.0739239454,
-0.0180574246,
0.2649849951,
-0.2316418588,
-1.1305314302,
-0.3200451732,
-0.0121874306,
0.0518399589,
-0.5359897017,
0.7251628041,
-0.3426344395,
0.3341190517,
-0.0988574922,
-0.2160094976,
-0.0012210477,
-0.0176686756,
0.3823872209,
-0.0251720902,
0.6720547676,
-0.6727816463,
-0.3113664389,
0.4126752615,
-0.434055835,
0.0452797711,
-0.672359705,
-0.0610830709,
-0.1432237774,
0.0238806698,
-0.4620339274,
-0.0608213246,
-0.0804019794,
-0.3392110765,
0.4811931252,
-0.0642132834,
-0.1313408911,
-0.2297040522,
-0.246822834,
0.0719519556,
0.7215139866,
0.1319142133,
0.6216019988,
0.7689846754,
-0.5865886211,
-0.4473673105,
-0.8688822985,
-0.2090290189,
-0.3794923127,
-0.3056780398,
0.5680478811,
0.0403783359,
-0.3633073866,
0.1461993456,
0.1439077258,
-0.2299391478,
0.1510097533,
0.7534564734,
0.7323493361,
-0.0665224195,
0.6100386977,
-0.0446846262,
-0.1364866644,
0.1787931025,
-0.1161911488,
0.0525135174,
0.18318367,
-0.2393316627,
-0.4056361318,
0.2619297206,
0.1783758849,
0.0565309152,
1.0498735905,
0.0831425786,
-0.7248678207,
-0.154316619,
-0.4694124758,
-0.2508103549,
-0.3211659491,
0.4956670702,
-0.0328637771,
-0.8541358113,
0.4115575254,
-0.0406685583,
-0.0782620534,
0.4123929441,
0.6966152191,
-0.40342924,
0.7482194901,
0.6873221397,
0.0711459741,
0.310562551,
-0.0458435677,
0.0803024545,
-0.5166912675,
-0.4852012694,
-0.6350277066,
0.2468287647,
-0.7278713584,
-0.3958682716,
0.7592906356,
-0.4556847215,
-0.1424536407,
0.2222109139,
-0.1172111034,
-0.0228382293,
0.0408566967,
0.4444963038,
0.5741794109,
0.1229157969,
-0.0295423754,
-0.0655487552,
-0.7184279561,
-0.668921113,
1.7033692598,
0.794092834,
0.9972006679,
-0.012213775,
0.4944806993,
0.2869939804,
0.4597688615,
-0.6320824623,
0.0158506893,
-0.3950922489,
-0.6417919397,
-0.3555052578,
-0.4112788439,
-1.1484712362,
-0.0746502131,
-0.4983985722,
-0.6180240512,
-0.0544065237,
0.2909289598,
-0.7571029663,
0.2971303165,
-0.3070526421,
0.5934174657,
-0.4367432892,
-0.0160075165,
0.065764159,
-0.9703451991,
0.1418208629,
-0.2980639338,
0.6721525192,
-0.0660499856,
-0.0987330154,
0.5051541328,
-0.4264187813,
1.0423395634,
0.3789479434,
-0.0574275628,
0.2117979974,
0.0818792954,
0.5180510879,
-0.0457896329,
-0.1347786188,
0.2264336795,
0.3650976121,
0.0348028019,
-0.3463629484,
0.5353226662,
-0.6942130923,
-0.3638352156,
-0.459566623,
-0.4812671542,
-0.3548087776,
0.0319405533,
0.2437727749,
0.4706916511,
-0.4121338427,
0.0165473744,
0.5439645052,
-0.3690737784,
-0.0467858687,
0.6509674788,
-0.098483108,
-0.2473822832,
0.4646856487,
0.1347713917,
0.4128465652,
0.5558706522,
0.534581244,
-0.4450168312,
-0.5270596743,
-0.1012572274,
0.1416352391,
-0.8372110724,
-0.2815563381,
-0.8865479827,
-0.2959444523,
-0.3248620033,
-0.0139313331,
-0.0271029063,
-0.3977609575,
-0.1996856034,
-0.5087342858,
0.6689585447,
0.5631693006,
0.3073270619,
0.1842474341,
-1.2361536026,
0.0731905252,
-0.0161008611,
0.3932194412,
-0.2233874649,
-0.6408833861,
-0.3974666893,
-0.2807108164,
-0.24161008,
-0.8579330444,
0.6088367105,
0.3298037648,
0.6469320059,
0.3980756104,
0.1083454937,
0.3251455426,
-0.8480451703,
0.2609650791,
0.2411796898,
-0.4811642766,
0.7241838574,
-0.3346288502,
-0.3182881773,
0.6364879012,
0.6969550252,
-0.3911583126,
-0.0892846286,
-0.7226632237,
-0.4219093621,
0.4108099043,
0.0482231826,
0.013005821,
0.0411342494,
0.450394243,
0.4105748534,
0.0188428648,
-0.5599848628,
-0.3202787638,
0.1819490492,
-0.4503642917,
-0.266826719,
-0.2268472612,
-0.2132968903,
-0.0088127675,
0.4888789356,
-0.0683501437,
0.0823933259,
0.3759454489,
-0.1002209485,
-0.4785943329,
0.5146909356,
0.3516446054,
0.4985800683,
-0.1779595017,
0.3138414919,
0.2632520497,
-0.5669230223,
0.0263945777,
0.1716500372,
-0.1157390252,
0.1439580619,
0.5218700767,
1.0163091421,
0.2672715485,
-1.142994523,
0.5068089962,
0.1338405013,
-0.1428509057,
-0.511793375,
-0.16301094,
-0.000498134,
-0.1433117688,
-0.1919128001,
-0.0829399824,
0.3187345266,
-0.6533036232,
0.4350369573,
0.1915175468,
-0.7511842251,
-0.4290608168,
0.678704977,
-0.0633048862,
-0.2053206861,
0.0957698748,
0.5626097918,
-0.2462618798,
0.5947617888,
0.6575452685,
0.5946426392,
-0.5259931684,
0.1363874972,
0.2563093603,
0.2332576215,
-0.3097855449,
0.3547155559,
0.72116822,
-0.6887070537,
-0.3492945135,
-0.4376826882,
-0.6290496588,
0.0796832964,
-0.6302007437,
0.4058695138,
-0.5390992761,
-0.4623289406,
-0.0969183296,
-0.3593044579,
-0.7826275229,
0.4353110194,
0.4243901074,
0.7665055394,
-0.8654779196,
0.8499600291,
0.7976031303,
-0.1798294038,
-0.872417748,
-0.0537463836,
0.2810308635,
-0.6689376831,
0.4994204044,
0.055640284,
0.2817123234,
-0.5223335624,
0.2298974991,
-0.7580123544,
1.0819474459,
0.1952580363,
-0.6596630216,
-0.2590774,
0.4277328849,
0.7543156743,
-0.4300894737,
0.037098486,
0.3429633379,
0.0863675997,
-0.0110428911,
-1.1014955044,
0.2002979964,
-0.0510134511,
0.0252965521,
0.1850825399,
0.0336655825,
0.8083327413,
-0.6496174335,
-0.0688673779,
0.0868863985,
0.3266255856,
0.2275205553,
0.5676717758,
0.2623622715,
0.3542333543,
0.7041110396,
0.1874619722,
1.5323741436,
-0.2823753059,
0.2650877833,
1.1592721939,
-0.7956700921,
1.0242735147,
0.2178394496,
-0.3608276546,
0.7406070232,
0.2635392547,
0.2980291545,
0.517921865,
0.0576694719,
-0.1939995438,
-0.0900921598,
-0.188331604,
-0.3825107813,
0.2554829717,
0.6834743023,
-0.8606983423,
0.1274273396,
0.0876249075,
-0.0718380213,
0.2269842178,
-0.3328172266,
0.9462739825,
0.4801391661,
-0.3521151841,
0.0774352327,
-0.0720714331,
0.2710419893,
-0.6723786592,
-0.1265923083,
0.4115200937,
0.4061070979,
-0.1811952293,
-0.6720551252,
0.4193711877,
-0.1676105708,
-0.0047985106,
-0.0751357153,
1.2333915234,
-0.545604825,
-0.8168484569,
0.3957283497,
0.6577298045,
0.0909226984,
0.0951737165,
-0.5654584169,
-0.2179729491,
-0.4182135761,
-0.0691030025,
0.570648253,
0.3638800383,
-0.1925541461,
0.8537839651,
0.5604434609,
0.5692105293,
-0.1914969385,
-0.1154748052,
0.6329194903,
-0.600014627,
-0.6372901797,
-0.8711001277,
0.4814246297,
0.3714034557,
-0.0869873762,
0.4584468007,
0.2693164051,
0.5626910329,
-0.2885458767,
1.1517330408,
0.4580241144,
0.9828701019,
-0.8654243946,
0.7280272245,
-0.3542900085,
0.4023487568,
-0.2716467381,
-0.0321023539,
-0.6516219378,
0.2741090655,
-0.4344308674,
-0.0402574241,
0.8819971681,
0.4046353996,
0.3817900419,
-0.239070043,
0.5889173746,
0.1188454106,
0.0632412285,
0.6820626855,
0.5057987571,
-0.5045079589,
0.4431481659,
-0.5276026726,
-0.0861278325,
-0.3954396248,
-0.9205623865,
-0.9343494773,
-0.3198449612,
-0.4226860702,
-0.5093405843,
0.1416330934,
0.9139920473,
0.5549669266,
-0.8456347585,
-0.0353862531,
0.2739712,
-0.1689002961,
-0.0880701765,
-0.0444597155,
0.6348043084,
0.1310983896,
-0.1107525453,
0.1142947599,
0.2922751009,
0.2986519039,
0.0662425607,
-0.2061347514,
0.1732428372,
-0.0454346351,
0.4976012707,
0.2430554926,
-0.6399968266,
-0.2086832374,
0.1833653152,
-0.340732038,
-0.0119502144,
0.8139665723,
-0.6786082387,
0.2795916796,
0.3080743253,
0.6312512755,
0.159326598,
-0.0761886761,
0.5109004974,
-0.3236476779,
-0.0782216117,
0.356368959,
0.5342624187,
0.2944701612,
-0.7959135175,
0.2941553593,
-0.1017630696,
-0.344083637,
-0.6619149446,
0.001097842,
-0.8907130957,
-0.1876923144,
1.1696984768,
-0.3831923604,
-0.158232078,
-0.4016398787,
0.0493808202,
0.2068151981,
-0.2242578715,
0.7968525887,
0.2716174722,
-0.3008638918,
-0.1324481368,
-0.9945593476,
0.7260502577,
0.3691122532,
-1.0996474028,
0.0070550432,
0.2185705453,
0.4580821097,
0.0698727667,
0.7456638217,
-0.5494993925,
0.4218398631,
-0.4875563681,
0.2136110663,
0.0576224066,
-0.3991770148,
-0.4710255861,
0.0968915075,
0.242004171,
0.1593378931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17352v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17352v1
|
Efficient Stitchable Task Adaptation
| 2023-11-29T04:31:35 | 2023-11-29T04:31:35 |
Haoyu He, Zizheng Pan, Jing Liu, Jianfei Cai, Bohan Zhuang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
The paradigm of pre-training and fine-tuning has laid the foundation for
deploying deep learning models. However, most fine-tuning methods are designed
to meet a specific resource budget. Recently, considering diverse deployment
scenarios with various resource budgets, stitchable neural network (SN-Net) is
introduced to quickly obtain numerous new networks (stitches) from the
pre-trained models (anchors) in a model family via model stitching. Although
promising, SN-Net confronts new challenges when adapting it to new target
domains, including huge memory and storage requirements and a long and
sub-optimal multistage adaptation process. In this work, we present a novel
framework, Efficient Stitchable Task Adaptation (ESTA), to efficiently produce
a palette of fine-tuned models that adhere to diverse resource constraints.
Specifically, we first tailor parameter-efficient fine-tuning to share low-rank
updates among the stitches while maintaining independent bias terms. In this
way, we largely reduce fine-tuning memory burdens and mitigate the interference
among stitches that arises in task adaptation. Furthermore, we streamline a
simple yet effective one-stage deployment pipeline, which estimates the
important stitches to deploy with training-time gradient statistics. By
assigning higher sampling probabilities to important stitches, we also get a
boosted Pareto frontier. Extensive experiments on 25 downstream visual
recognition tasks demonstrate that our ESTA is capable of generating stitches
with smooth accuracy-efficiency trade-offs and surpasses the direct SN-Net
adaptation by remarkable margins with significantly lower training time and
fewer trainable parameters. Furthermore, we demonstrate the flexibility and
scalability of our ESTA framework by stitching LLMs from LLaMA family,
obtaining chatbot stitches of assorted sizes.
|
[
-0.3311883211,
-0.4220134914,
0.1837282628,
0.5232691169,
-0.4403297007,
0.0738519356,
-0.2065914273,
-0.3314175606,
0.3131784499,
0.6083874106,
-0.7274685502,
-0.2240712792,
-0.5528975129,
-0.0891179815,
-0.2258788198,
0.8265739083,
0.0379890092,
-0.3553742766,
0.0305020511,
-0.4138220549,
-0.451895833,
-0.1717106551,
-0.7472895384,
0.1231502593,
0.7463092804,
0.4988975823,
0.2213606685,
0.8507263064,
0.6580005288,
0.4070920348,
0.0994295329,
0.7315441966,
-0.6838151813,
0.0613373518,
-0.2318101227,
-0.5345052481,
-0.4602939785,
-0.1186784133,
0.2691400945,
0.3834090233,
-0.072946094,
0.6865741014,
0.4302786887,
0.8616533279,
-0.9429659843,
-0.1022000834,
-0.9775631428,
0.0706141368,
-0.0707650036,
-0.3129170835,
-0.0552780628,
-0.263507843,
0.1602245122,
-0.9838380814,
0.1474312842,
-0.06104156,
0.7712188959,
0.6702965498,
-0.1425050795,
0.0559479557,
-0.3725608587,
0.5747463703,
-0.556178391,
0.0915312022,
0.1686212867,
0.3436727524,
-0.1295056641,
-0.6869943738,
-0.2076655924,
0.0532672629,
0.4934152663,
0.2660156488,
0.033180289,
-0.1421503276,
0.1041570604,
0.2839147151,
-0.284929961,
0.3158041537,
-0.133342728,
0.1215585619,
0.4869238734,
0.1540072113,
0.1230947599,
0.0073046028,
-0.6572881341,
0.1082247123,
-0.4310022593,
-0.0503894649,
0.1802683324,
0.7063528299,
-0.2897927165,
0.2323793471,
-0.4735442698,
0.5436733961,
0.412964046,
0.0186621007,
0.2264748514,
-0.2948999405,
-0.3597736061,
-0.3894553185,
0.3210348189,
0.4396857917,
-0.0553950667,
-0.0580894947,
-0.1691698432,
-0.1830879301,
0.8667765856,
-0.5680490136,
-0.0521059595,
-0.0693105906,
-0.53241992,
-0.3269124031,
-0.5352929235,
-0.3395894766,
-0.5436925292,
-0.5550606847,
0.5980342627,
-0.2806755304,
0.0207266826,
0.0544988513,
-0.0269044843,
0.1012901813,
0.7650885582,
-0.5554794073,
-0.0045889034,
0.7033909559,
1.0916969776,
-0.2632481158,
-0.3956827223,
-0.3339654207,
-0.1296585351,
-0.4463043511,
0.6223909855,
-0.017532438,
0.2455506176,
0.1016140357,
0.3043334186,
-0.4361543059,
-0.3601296842,
0.1882749945,
-0.5326911211,
-0.3356161714,
-0.1682392806,
-0.1881237775,
-0.4098501205,
0.3391659558,
-0.5857841969,
0.6987591982,
0.3365377486,
-0.4255315661,
0.5923415422,
-0.524543941,
-0.3174864352,
-0.2367744148,
0.511895895,
-0.4862858355,
0.3032147884,
0.1657262295,
0.8778551817,
-0.3576282263,
-0.0718203261,
-0.6270768046,
-0.3489761055,
-0.0266080592,
-0.1713783592,
0.5907093883,
0.3937840462,
-0.1957201511,
0.2207849473,
-0.9662619829,
-0.1169481948,
-0.0222285986,
-0.3606777191,
-0.1551670581,
-0.1206312776,
0.1027696133,
0.1163954586,
0.0943518877,
-0.2418567091,
0.4009726644,
-0.2280812413,
0.5709121227,
1.0364205837,
-0.0869769827,
0.6504916549,
-0.4509209991,
0.353849113,
-0.0263922401,
0.3381047547,
-0.1623212844,
0.0138159404,
-1.1173378229,
-0.5667417645,
0.1620534807,
0.4645742476,
-0.8749874234,
0.296266228,
-0.3434053361,
-0.6787068248,
-0.1573684514,
0.2321728915,
0.2820155323,
0.4606752694,
0.1534851789,
-0.5351921916,
-0.6208220124,
-0.8144109845,
-0.0605078153,
0.2876413167,
-0.2013678104,
0.5045794249,
0.4792409837,
0.0716839805,
0.2793700695,
-0.2551327646,
-0.6810658574,
-0.0111044217,
-0.0122216213,
0.4916706681,
0.6990507841,
0.5239078999,
-0.2925392389,
-0.283325702,
0.0113075227,
-0.599524498,
0.196428299,
-0.6843383908,
-0.5592061877,
-0.0032052973,
0.3253509998,
-0.1472997963,
0.2842715085,
0.700505197,
-0.2509861887,
0.1021417975,
-0.3270499706,
0.0923247635,
-1.329349041,
-0.0681089312,
0.0706469491,
-0.2667086422,
-0.457462281,
0.1436524093,
0.097771056,
-0.1098103672,
-0.4675810337,
0.0380347185,
-0.4280239046,
-0.0115922298,
-0.1693983823,
-0.3849870563,
0.0032178352,
0.9885367155,
-0.2690141201,
0.5617765784,
0.4577011466,
-0.7403281331,
-0.0630626753,
0.3869302273,
-0.400537014,
0.6318771243,
-0.4138892889,
0.30306077,
0.0585809723,
0.1164459437,
-0.5435100794,
-0.1643303186,
0.3460785449,
0.1100263372,
0.3258252442,
-0.4344031215,
0.1440749764,
-0.0088585354,
-0.3916426599,
0.2950665951,
0.2871438563,
-0.7092901468,
0.8850569725,
0.4492639601,
-0.001826333,
-0.4794969559,
-0.4216939211,
0.1064598858,
-0.3574047983,
-0.6129499674,
0.4302616715,
0.1006322727,
0.57983917,
-0.3244669437,
-0.3074197769,
-0.2877283096,
0.532081306,
0.4465712905,
0.21007514,
-0.4056391418,
-0.1004073992,
-0.0094065554,
0.1269730479,
-0.4528149366,
-0.4279978573,
0.170904696,
0.0643290579,
-0.4354668558,
-0.2531275153,
0.0244468171,
0.6271250844,
-0.1389733255,
0.4025886953,
0.6826084852,
-0.2321863472,
-0.4761152267,
-0.8133171201,
-0.0521880835,
-0.417524904,
0.6062065363,
-0.3946113288,
-0.8018457294,
0.5254094601,
-0.4560174942,
0.1982359588,
0.1186151281,
0.2999513447,
-0.2147169113,
0.5404049158,
0.5241707563,
-0.122502692,
0.8337596655,
-0.3702770472,
-0.0620561726,
-1.1626250744,
0.1263757348,
-0.3660089076,
-0.7131155133,
-0.489590317,
-0.977819562,
0.3704745471,
0.2528598309,
-0.5144271255,
0.5703125,
-0.6171317101,
0.3074935377,
0.9227365255,
0.6712375879,
-0.2676542699,
-0.0505395383,
0.418140471,
0.5712431669,
-1.1601655483,
-0.2175177634,
1.0343369246,
0.3550131321,
0.4496080875,
-0.291097492,
0.5454221368,
0.2722015083,
-0.1030139327,
-0.4123731256,
0.4266964197,
-0.5868067145,
-0.2793863416,
-0.4005219042,
-0.0431568399,
-0.6759982109,
0.2275075614,
-0.6413525939,
-0.7245019078,
0.5931824446,
0.3750383854,
-0.7530263066,
0.4403557479,
-0.6078220606,
0.7409344912,
-0.1831968427,
-0.637848258,
-0.273483783,
-0.3829499483,
0.1520301998,
-0.2344305813,
-0.2799519897,
-0.59835428,
-0.1361364871,
0.6270555854,
-0.3466501832,
1.0819182396,
-0.1232920885,
0.3649852574,
0.2525236011,
0.0723085701,
0.689946115,
-0.0734872222,
-0.0269561801,
0.4941417873,
-0.2283528,
-0.5333624482,
-0.5117160678,
0.4281819165,
-0.6783055067,
-0.4989819229,
-0.0854327306,
-0.7924672365,
-0.2412914038,
-0.0541041307,
-0.0526985489,
0.4186476171,
-0.0761092752,
0.2844190896,
0.2113983631,
-0.3854857683,
0.4541169405,
0.2209511399,
0.5371836424,
-0.3696069717,
1.1021643877,
0.2607020736,
0.0541058518,
0.3059503436,
-0.0124786422,
0.2358294427,
-0.9176914096,
-0.6679673791,
-0.2968725562,
-0.2595952153,
-0.6555783749,
-0.2805224359,
-0.1154993623,
0.0106390957,
-0.5491002798,
-0.6528208852,
-0.4770973027,
-0.6167452335,
0.2221075147,
0.4750128388,
0.4054934084,
-0.2439883351,
0.3858775795,
-0.657627821,
0.2597537935,
0.4263414741,
0.5950964093,
0.0429815091,
-0.652864337,
-0.4107242525,
-0.1125610173,
-0.159756735,
-0.3304010928,
0.3016168177,
0.5921311975,
0.2254746109,
0.3349206746,
0.1266899407,
1.1582244635,
-0.6641711593,
0.4853210151,
0.3180267215,
-0.7474104166,
0.269980818,
-0.4202680886,
0.3028557003,
0.5310095549,
0.1784444898,
-0.1375876665,
-0.1572580636,
-0.2170068473,
-1.0157697201,
0.8840019107,
-0.0908303484,
0.2996743321,
0.2826323211,
0.2832150757,
0.3360180557,
0.0390346199,
0.0618530922,
0.2422252595,
-0.430755198,
-0.0680856407,
-0.0313428156,
-0.2380178571,
-0.2574733198,
-0.0765629336,
0.7357512712,
-0.7076955438,
0.234110266,
-0.0468225256,
-0.3124538064,
0.1530471444,
-0.1861144155,
0.4246092141,
0.6531357765,
-0.0187385958,
-0.1116671488,
0.7223522663,
-0.2292000353,
0.0328949355,
0.0647654459,
-0.204052642,
-0.3239502311,
0.3709259927,
1.1807619333,
0.554680407,
-0.18623963,
0.4323636889,
0.1195828319,
-0.2524462938,
-0.0302509014,
0.1753151119,
0.0941032097,
0.8656247258,
0.0859898776,
0.6776411533,
0.0820274055,
-0.2390137315,
0.1827790588,
0.3255859017,
-0.3235113025,
-0.2344243824,
0.5464105606,
0.5043233037,
-0.2599522471,
0.4504642189,
0.1543704569,
-0.4161973596,
0.6659011841,
0.1427730024,
0.9807280302,
-0.0015108285,
0.311945349,
0.4344753325,
0.0426888727,
-0.000644923,
0.3008545041,
-0.0238827448,
-0.8168679476,
-0.3184229136,
-0.7812867761,
-0.0553558506,
-0.1604409814,
-0.617371738,
0.0605496801,
-0.5417530537,
-0.162731871,
-0.1303625554,
-0.309951514,
-1.0116643906,
0.127162531,
0.1916911155,
1.0603839159,
-0.6458380222,
0.4119567871,
0.3242322505,
-0.3567671478,
-0.9409113526,
-0.4232733846,
-0.0568054616,
-1.1616923809,
0.3269535899,
-0.0235098749,
0.1199714541,
-0.085834451,
-0.1801447421,
-1.004778862,
1.1339855194,
0.5995362997,
-0.759794414,
-0.0698684379,
-0.1056979299,
0.2418881506,
-0.4313031733,
0.2513766289,
0.19269301,
0.0808905885,
0.1082072333,
-0.8248920441,
0.1894421279,
-0.221016556,
0.3361904621,
-0.1375473291,
-0.8402423859,
0.6418077946,
-0.1012063995,
0.0236226581,
0.1858071536,
0.5200869441,
-0.0884348229,
0.2435857654,
0.9317116141,
0.4091283679,
0.6441835165,
-0.1121590436,
0.7896264195,
-0.5106945634,
-0.0599078871,
1.0170800686,
0.0918968022,
0.7419264913,
0.4913270772,
-0.0406723917,
0.2359144688,
0.8025081158,
-0.052809272,
0.4890477061,
0.340851754,
0.0032108447,
-0.5661644936,
-0.3508308232,
-0.1428413093,
0.8083892465,
-0.1085428819,
-0.4299184978,
0.0587915778,
0.1681225449,
-0.3549129963,
-0.3624669909,
-0.6964921355,
1.093141675,
0.1088110507,
-0.6385147572,
0.6131490469,
-0.6383794546,
0.6127563715,
-0.5761290193,
-0.0348819196,
-0.1754250675,
0.2217386216,
-0.2381493747,
-0.1843876839,
0.0998431668,
-0.1997916251,
-0.039721176,
-0.2916145921,
0.938939631,
-0.1249423698,
-0.5506672859,
-0.0565179512,
0.6710249186,
-0.1319756061,
-0.2531463206,
-0.6169583797,
0.0566585362,
0.020506911,
-0.4888040423,
0.6925933361,
0.3992035687,
-0.0608210936,
0.6674854755,
0.8513718247,
0.2425616682,
0.2197676152,
0.0583978295,
1.018897891,
-0.3619170785,
-0.5852447152,
-0.2052845061,
0.6897680163,
-0.092287071,
-0.5348161459,
0.4093145728,
0.0917185619,
0.7665467262,
-0.3633049726,
0.5393095016,
0.0196964592,
0.1584293246,
-0.4838540554,
0.6859804988,
-0.7447861433,
-0.0994511768,
-0.2917726636,
-0.6963362694,
-0.3113925457,
0.6757443547,
0.1649823189,
-0.3062051833,
0.2945575714,
0.8993221521,
-0.2894552648,
-0.0943098292,
0.3204457164,
-0.0951637775,
-0.3524752259,
0.722025454,
0.6976718307,
-0.3754727244,
0.4080313742,
-0.4947524667,
-0.1217384338,
-0.2453612387,
-1.1191180944,
-0.6631240845,
-0.6734915972,
-0.4815517068,
-0.1593038589,
0.5228242874,
1.0743280649,
1.3259757757,
-0.7907977104,
-0.0592518449,
-0.0855820328,
-0.0500700437,
-0.6581700444,
-0.0410999209,
0.406735003,
-0.5107440948,
-0.6302250624,
0.369782269,
0.3358256519,
-0.4124498963,
0.1722787321,
0.0459280461,
-0.1673432291,
0.0013243245,
0.6480622888,
0.2218346,
-0.4047958255,
-0.7698807716,
-0.0611554421,
0.2591045499,
0.0342266746,
0.6994461417,
-0.6162691712,
0.4368886948,
0.4289975464,
1.1870048046,
0.4737484455,
-0.3229064941,
0.7136945724,
-0.611549139,
0.1325504631,
0.1332722157,
0.4005554616,
0.0587265007,
-0.1726570427,
0.879214704,
-0.0718113557,
-0.4697525799,
-0.7908263206,
0.028445825,
-1.1375879049,
-0.1229576468,
0.7417013049,
-0.4785191119,
-0.3262152374,
0.0328927822,
-0.1797323674,
0.5679081678,
-0.2041331828,
1.0260592699,
0.0433544181,
-0.0269155148,
0.0591226593,
-0.2049577683,
0.3239361942,
0.4629870057,
-0.6363686323,
-0.0408413596,
0.1925966442,
0.1612601429,
0.0039697392,
0.3746545017,
0.5418814421,
0.3966010213,
0.0716394857,
-0.0183218755,
-0.4822510481,
-0.2317768782,
-0.3100621104,
0.3796271384,
-0.0561553463,
-0.7480408549
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17351v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17351v1
|
Exploring Large Language Models for Human Mobility Prediction under Public Events
| 2023-11-29T04:25:15 | 2023-11-29T04:25:15 |
Yuebing Liang, Yichao Liu, Xiaohan Wang, Zhan Zhao
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Public events, such as concerts and sports games, can be major attractors for
large crowds, leading to irregular surges in travel demand. Accurate human
mobility prediction for public events is thus crucial for event planning as
well as traffic or crowd management. While rich textual descriptions about
public events are commonly available from online sources, it is challenging to
encode such information in statistical or machine learning models. Existing
methods are generally limited in incorporating textual information, handling
data sparsity, or providing rationales for their predictions. To address these
challenges, we introduce a framework for human mobility prediction under public
events (LLM-MPE) based on Large Language Models (LLMs), leveraging their
unprecedented ability to process textual data, learn from minimal examples, and
generate human-readable explanations. Specifically, LLM-MPE first transforms
raw, unstructured event descriptions from online sources into a standardized
format, and then segments historical mobility data into regular and
event-related components. A prompting strategy is designed to direct LLMs in
making and rationalizing demand predictions considering historical mobility and
event features. A case study is conducted for Barclays Center in New York City,
based on publicly available event information and taxi trip data. Results show
that LLM-MPE surpasses traditional models, particularly on event days, with
textual data significantly enhancing its accuracy. Furthermore, LLM-MPE offers
interpretable insights into its predictions. Despite the great potential of
LLMs, we also identify key challenges including misinformation and high costs
that remain barriers to their broader adoption in large-scale human mobility
analysis.
|
[
-0.2246026993,
-0.3122864664,
0.8550631404,
0.1927153766,
-0.1440763474,
-0.2647085786,
-0.3140874505,
-0.6062469482,
0.3173288107,
0.3735013604,
-0.6028701067,
-0.4468126893,
-0.2772246897,
-0.0545035414,
-0.5506776571,
0.5454016328,
-0.0857377872,
0.0781784728,
-0.0998195037,
-0.0245356392,
-0.2507587969,
-0.7225093842,
-0.3861393631,
-0.1553664654,
0.5596644282,
0.1923615783,
0.5750648975,
0.6461714506,
0.1771527976,
0.1635842621,
-0.1872872412,
0.2145226747,
-0.3468444943,
-0.1482519954,
-0.0501498431,
-0.0529569462,
-0.1656574011,
-0.2007278502,
0.805862546,
0.7783319354,
-0.2813742459,
-0.0489649139,
-0.1996621639,
0.4464986026,
-0.4042683244,
0.0911777318,
-0.6047326326,
-0.0397158749,
-0.5503344536,
-0.1153859198,
-0.277056694,
-0.184935689,
0.0120836152,
-0.3744923174,
0.0345752873,
0.0915570408,
0.7319555283,
0.0455084741,
-0.4846334457,
-0.0310618728,
-0.8007081151,
0.6524916291,
-0.2466793507,
0.6205945015,
0.5455933213,
0.3533811867,
-0.325637579,
-0.4548555017,
-0.6118935347,
-0.4095217288,
0.19174245,
-0.017083684,
-0.0587335266,
-0.0460698083,
0.1664616615,
-0.4761734903,
-0.5497816801,
0.3765550256,
-0.4900382757,
0.0926855281,
0.8429256678,
0.414319545,
0.1647841334,
-0.0179667845,
-0.3605631292,
0.3064192832,
-0.6843959689,
-0.0311354678,
-0.0328093693,
0.2430471629,
-0.4414224029,
0.5900763273,
-0.3568193913,
0.3479008079,
-0.1265772432,
-0.0933582932,
0.2138254344,
-0.184357509,
0.1652435809,
-0.0585880391,
0.6561111212,
0.6011073589,
0.6213797927,
-0.6539767385,
-0.0864811316,
-0.4779468775,
-0.4259955883,
-0.9059432149,
-0.0118249077,
0.2825846374,
-0.5078669786,
0.0480869561,
0.1701887548,
-1.2010148764,
-0.6333636045,
-0.4976372421,
-0.2372383326,
-0.1288337708,
-0.1600308269,
0.3089280725,
0.1876592934,
0.365019381,
0.7152327895,
-0.7465116978,
-0.1240901574,
0.5495672822,
1.0081951618,
-0.3091624081,
-0.4054298401,
-0.6787000895,
0.4547186494,
0.0505095534,
0.9070730805,
-0.5112994313,
-0.3354503512,
0.2748666704,
0.0259654578,
-0.1283749342,
-0.2558113635,
0.7917174101,
-0.4233951569,
-0.1397170573,
-0.0815467462,
-0.4217649996,
-0.0925542265,
0.0377691984,
-0.5096796155,
0.5276938677,
-0.2183148116,
-0.7208122015,
0.3338347971,
-0.7412851453,
-0.6311911345,
0.2274367511,
-0.0047360635,
-0.4255531728,
0.3437235653,
0.4782272577,
0.5038303137,
-0.1420062631,
0.4781021774,
-0.6388251781,
-0.2562989593,
0.4002968073,
-0.4609049857,
0.5724719167,
0.0138952024,
-0.0235375501,
0.0893260092,
-0.7688328028,
-0.5929255486,
0.1203736812,
-0.6414884329,
0.0894197226,
0.7043045759,
0.2838182449,
0.1482624859,
0.1924224198,
-0.4552353024,
0.2375547588,
-0.4551125467,
0.3175580502,
0.9363815784,
-0.222289592,
0.637408793,
-0.1345641613,
0.5546307564,
0.0042331056,
0.1065589041,
-0.2246152163,
-0.7379598022,
0.0014478004,
-0.0117486846,
0.0400147773,
0.7142896652,
-0.3191265762,
0.1384327859,
-0.7527167201,
-0.1254346669,
-0.1018066406,
-0.1447957158,
-0.4978310168,
0.2830165327,
0.2073807269,
0.5717404485,
-0.6283490062,
-0.3032141328,
-0.1338033527,
-0.3543253541,
-0.0068042739,
0.2351570576,
0.3673732281,
-0.4172926545,
0.9214355946,
-0.3293481767,
-0.0508184657,
-0.3500350714,
0.09972395,
-0.1011327356,
0.115087986,
0.358746022,
-0.9083054066,
-0.3785814643,
0.1819012314,
-0.1055806577,
-0.2533606887,
-0.2989971638,
-0.0054162168,
0.1315493584,
0.3112764955,
-0.5793665051,
0.4955340922,
0.5813261867,
-0.5791154504,
0.5423956513,
0.0836941823,
0.0478870235,
-1.0122771263,
-0.0374680534,
0.3379397392,
-0.3324112296,
-0.6079128981,
-0.3353550732,
-0.1407323778,
-0.2057644576,
-0.2699907422,
0.7252123952,
-0.2557348907,
-0.2281537801,
-0.2841088474,
0.1425718516,
-0.4550571442,
0.0657619834,
0.1526666433,
0.6844978929,
0.492972225,
-0.5301302671,
0.196849376,
0.1801331788,
-0.7198422551,
0.0673006177,
-0.2499437779,
-0.0990010425,
-0.4282375872,
0.5305536389,
-0.8506208062,
-0.5680910945,
-0.1225619763,
-0.2717557549,
-0.1834431887,
-0.461345315,
-0.6490390897,
-0.4245809913,
0.116431348,
0.1413960606,
0.4980504513,
-0.6247461438,
0.9039520025,
0.8228051066,
-0.0890575722,
-0.2290147096,
-0.585596323,
0.3331070542,
-0.408441633,
-0.9023486376,
0.1139509529,
0.1553736776,
-0.3949987292,
-0.3009048402,
0.2422804832,
-0.2973392904,
0.4427468777,
0.4375565052,
0.421620369,
0.0361417532,
0.1744160354,
-0.3387902677,
-0.0319855735,
0.1754582524,
-0.4463466406,
0.4735816717,
0.3370089531,
-0.1567799896,
-0.6707605124,
0.184744522,
0.7049193978,
-0.1135539636,
0.7376462817,
0.7705156207,
-0.4007656872,
0.2551754117,
-0.4184456766,
0.0143571412,
-0.3690483272,
0.6199809313,
-0.1678858548,
-0.8309121728,
0.6369530559,
-0.2832322717,
0.0890581235,
0.1097078547,
0.5947810411,
-0.3366207778,
1.3127952814,
0.1610690653,
-0.1226659045,
0.5896960497,
0.3940846622,
0.0022692333,
-0.2547362745,
-0.3962771893,
-0.7116321325,
-0.3943910599,
-0.5861240625,
-0.7106126547,
0.2722480297,
-0.0235393848,
0.0681762323,
0.0782973319,
0.2088950425,
0.7159894109,
0.0400649495,
-0.2049942911,
0.2102068067,
0.2176314145,
0.2281751186,
0.1029954553,
-0.465226084,
-0.4480298758,
0.8157579303,
0.408125639,
0.709148705,
0.0622471571,
0.3736055791,
0.1740276664,
0.5808934569,
-0.5282302499,
0.6056897044,
-0.166192919,
-0.7108853459,
-0.278383106,
-0.8333211541,
-1.0771474838,
0.0822653323,
-0.3293088973,
-1.0896207094,
0.2845469117,
0.0174824335,
-0.3159623742,
0.5227634907,
-0.4048093557,
0.5177147985,
-0.3611093163,
-0.2206924558,
-0.38154006,
-0.4130368829,
0.1582732201,
-0.189762637,
0.7855292559,
-0.6079210639,
-0.1212506443,
0.7952455878,
-0.1584921032,
0.7249022126,
-0.2067088783,
0.0875463858,
0.1972767115,
0.0641721413,
1.0837628841,
-0.0095317159,
-0.4084281921,
0.233499974,
-0.2200449556,
-0.3150491714,
-0.1662839055,
0.6999952793,
-0.6376873851,
-0.2464469075,
0.0797812268,
-0.356631875,
-0.3368516862,
-0.2214127034,
0.1321189702,
0.4224716425,
-0.1668455899,
0.1429978311,
0.3185582459,
-0.2242575586,
0.5409668684,
0.5186007619,
-0.3512275517,
-0.4710505009,
0.8286560774,
0.2970332503,
-0.3183140457,
0.6174914837,
0.6057549715,
-0.7890042067,
-0.8188889027,
-0.4496351779,
0.2990214527,
-0.4388815463,
0.1628116667,
-0.7290495634,
0.4573709369,
-0.4700607061,
-0.2471746653,
-0.0811686143,
-0.4536102414,
-0.4694054127,
-0.3415423334,
0.1682956517,
0.7126147151,
-0.1049912646,
0.3960952163,
-0.7469586134,
-0.0050453432,
-0.0036918649,
0.4151763916,
-0.0204143021,
-0.5462263823,
-0.5674311519,
-0.1422811896,
-0.2477002442,
-0.9334101081,
0.5607360005,
-0.0170973465,
0.3759269714,
0.5961275697,
0.1635508686,
0.6976299882,
-0.635327816,
0.7037394047,
0.4731885791,
-0.5645685792,
0.4792077243,
-0.7163513899,
-0.0201901793,
0.4063945413,
0.3878616095,
-0.5045868754,
-0.0006896967,
-0.3739306927,
-0.7513861656,
0.6354907751,
0.0637859628,
0.1436436325,
-0.1807434857,
0.306606859,
-0.0879011378,
-0.0545839183,
-1.0176420212,
0.0067156623,
0.0498773195,
-0.1837705374,
-0.2098328769,
-0.4231415689,
0.3009912968,
-0.2436261475,
0.3600981236,
0.0852400512,
-0.1884571165,
0.0010607023,
0.2031378299,
-0.3471296728,
0.2453314215,
0.9054172039,
0.849909544,
-0.2172808945,
-0.1150841713,
0.5990626216,
-0.2445458472,
0.05115382,
0.1584602743,
-0.1609510928,
0.1759333313,
0.2494024485,
0.7079280019,
-0.0338605866,
-1.0651853085,
0.6400961876,
0.1506267339,
-0.1023908928,
-0.6836674809,
-0.4231461883,
0.1722621173,
0.2053866833,
0.550098896,
-0.2352600992,
-0.0607860014,
-0.381605953,
0.069676131,
0.1331770122,
-0.5017789602,
-0.6184430718,
0.9398453236,
0.6489186883,
-0.2832820117,
0.4219928086,
-0.2295262218,
-0.343220979,
0.3492482901,
0.1480997801,
0.9203727245,
-0.1748360395,
-0.0889161676,
0.4241287708,
0.1529019028,
-0.4482187927,
0.0967724919,
0.2969066203,
-0.6154742241,
-1.0419270992,
-0.6956198812,
-0.0934882313,
0.1321325451,
-0.1935740262,
0.5262602568,
-0.1942153275,
-0.270249933,
-0.3228805065,
-0.220601812,
-0.5741698146,
-0.3004358709,
0.7999933958,
0.9787642956,
-0.8004820943,
0.7042822838,
0.7969301939,
-0.0166070741,
-0.5793846846,
0.4696556628,
-0.0342454016,
-0.4613481164,
0.6590225697,
0.2468985617,
0.2319021225,
-0.182272315,
-0.455817163,
-0.8315882087,
0.9028171301,
0.4346609712,
-0.9216593504,
-0.321154356,
0.1509588957,
0.0247729328,
-0.2738396525,
0.0053395559,
0.2913294435,
0.660677731,
0.2055942714,
-0.9224615693,
-0.0716232434,
0.5940477252,
-0.0488102324,
0.3756054938,
-0.4492357671,
0.4506979883,
-0.3240637183,
-0.4482147694,
0.1033771187,
0.718237102,
0.2930305898,
0.6902262568,
0.524417758,
0.3335486948,
0.9249477386,
-0.1532289386,
1.1740858555,
-0.0600828379,
0.1114582345,
0.9101024866,
-0.6098000407,
0.8329446912,
0.1816241592,
-0.2635820508,
0.4051797986,
0.3294251859,
0.0897010416,
0.3290300965,
0.2584582865,
-0.2742672563,
-0.6278446913,
-0.0382349491,
0.0816486254,
0.5959916711,
0.193841815,
-0.1544230878,
-0.3915301859,
0.2935240865,
-0.138729021,
-0.1576464921,
-0.7135897875,
0.6044239998,
-0.232335642,
-0.4938896298,
0.0272578932,
0.2954907715,
0.3692773581,
-0.3142314553,
0.2013186961,
-0.0751502514,
0.0047839768,
0.0277285017,
-0.9302235842,
0.3431995511,
-0.0037338315,
-0.1956968307,
-0.2589200735,
0.6572415829,
-0.1022869647,
-0.5251746774,
0.3448150158,
0.2663918734,
0.3399168551,
-0.2511908114,
-0.491371423,
0.1363711655,
0.2386699617,
-0.3134717047,
0.5538445115,
0.7062907815,
-0.0747543052,
1.0332605839,
0.6362792253,
0.322983712,
0.2577871978,
0.1884945333,
0.5341354609,
-0.7595000267,
-0.8152810931,
-1.0609121323,
0.5919424891,
-0.0048878361,
-0.1434379518,
0.2620669305,
0.5860319734,
0.2946910262,
0.0967484787,
0.7611371279,
0.3171251118,
0.5631498694,
-0.5586785674,
0.1155705899,
-0.3643445373,
0.3771021962,
0.2492386252,
-0.3627764881,
-0.0313606635,
0.5284923315,
-0.5375796556,
-0.2905272543,
0.043948561,
0.6102522016,
-0.094869338,
0.0335655399,
0.3872319162,
0.0199832357,
0.3160187006,
0.4431060553,
1.1977672577,
0.1464202255,
0.9561094642,
0.2420750111,
-0.0598393865,
-0.7586615682,
-0.7158408165,
-0.8441443443,
-0.6780307293,
-0.4497515857,
-0.5168269873,
0.1573466808,
1.1957954168,
1.1960885525,
-0.6629334092,
-0.3856422007,
-0.124608472,
0.1174021661,
0.1490945816,
-0.2595052123,
0.2430275977,
0.0228740033,
-0.5983868241,
0.456127435,
0.1821802408,
0.5597878695,
-0.043527063,
-0.1187833622,
0.0929764062,
0.0998346955,
0.5862505436,
0.2654263079,
-0.5589677095,
-0.0860677063,
-0.2700107396,
0.0110600824,
-0.1157113165,
0.8277419209,
-0.6278096437,
-0.3243228495,
0.4701686203,
0.5230428576,
0.5242237449,
0.3572556078,
0.6064543724,
-0.5730527043,
0.0560011305,
0.3123330176,
0.5795398951,
0.0972189307,
-0.3500295877,
0.3983815014,
0.2847284675,
-0.6198275685,
-0.8487408757,
0.3711762428,
-1.0851411819,
-0.4652195871,
1.6047192812,
0.2200299203,
-0.2272060215,
-0.4789062738,
0.0380752981,
-0.1001853943,
-0.5057454109,
0.8583623767,
0.4900971353,
-0.0457563959,
-0.3490894735,
-0.657574892,
0.2023906261,
-0.1046910733,
-0.5685912371,
0.6994643211,
0.5837794542,
0.0726664662,
-0.1180340648,
0.4925457239,
0.1851152331,
0.0287611317,
-0.4693849683,
-0.0098999171,
-0.1119668856,
-0.2507632077,
-0.0835390091,
0.5051387548,
-0.1706083119,
-0.0188974887
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17946v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17946v1
|
DreamSync: Aligning Text-to-Image Generation with Image Understanding Feedback
| 2023-11-29T03:42:16 | 2023-11-29T03:42:16 |
Jiao Sun, Deqing Fu, Yushi Hu, Su Wang, Royi Rassin, Da-Cheng Juan, Dana Alon, Charles Herrmann, Sjoerd van Steenkiste, Ranjay Krishna, Cyrus Rashtchian
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Despite their wide-spread success, Text-to-Image models (T2I) still struggle
to produce images that are both aesthetically pleasing and faithful to the
user's input text. We introduce DreamSync, a model-agnostic training algorithm
by design that improves T2I models to be faithful to the text input. DreamSync
builds off a recent insight from TIFA's evaluation framework -- that large
vision-language models (VLMs) can effectively identify the fine-grained
discrepancies between generated images and the text inputs. DreamSync uses this
insight to train T2I models without any labeled data; it improves T2I models
using its own generations. First, it prompts the model to generate several
candidate images for a given input text. Then, it uses two VLMs to select the
best generation: a Visual Question Answering model that measures the alignment
of generated images to the text, and another that measures the generation's
aesthetic quality. After selection, we use LoRA to iteratively finetune the T2I
model to guide its generation towards the selected best generations. DreamSync
does not need any additional human annotation. model architecture changes, or
reinforcement learning. Despite its simplicity, DreamSync improves both the
semantic alignment and aesthetic appeal of two diffusion-based T2I models,
evidenced by multiple benchmarks (+1.7% on TIFA, +2.9% on DSG1K, +3.4% on VILA
aesthetic) and human evaluation.
|
[
-0.0220563486,
-0.3573923707,
0.7251416445,
0.0414387099,
-0.4498948455,
0.2967625558,
0.0474639386,
-0.7271134257,
0.0953161865,
0.2964799702,
-0.8425091505,
-0.5511576533,
-0.4614837766,
-0.1319538057,
-0.3750302196,
0.7594700456,
-0.3101371229,
0.1015991122,
-0.5817487836,
-0.0826032832,
-0.49386397,
0.1365287155,
-0.7387270331,
-0.3766701519,
0.3069881797,
0.2730909586,
0.7854907513,
0.8422440886,
0.4424264431,
0.1958619952,
-0.0767288208,
0.2715150416,
-0.7236258984,
0.4389190078,
-0.0863962024,
-0.3619183898,
-0.058666978,
-0.253813982,
0.4698758721,
0.1732550859,
0.0871957168,
0.2892174423,
0.258687973,
0.9738427997,
-0.6659364104,
0.000355641,
-0.5016232729,
0.3229584694,
-0.1371976733,
-0.206211403,
-0.4076557159,
-0.5190485716,
-0.0343388654,
-0.5064144135,
0.3374047577,
-0.0558253415,
1.2300276756,
0.4536110163,
-0.2923522294,
-0.1441667676,
-0.7662761211,
0.7779089808,
-0.3566316068,
0.47030586,
0.0660623908,
0.2143585086,
0.0288469288,
-0.4735408127,
-0.539721787,
0.151256606,
0.2802062333,
0.5379999876,
0.0867144391,
0.2127781212,
0.0450706407,
0.279079169,
-0.5037619472,
0.1949743927,
-0.3207967281,
-0.072958298,
0.6404611468,
0.2348674089,
0.1817249954,
-0.2089378685,
-0.4405199289,
-0.0607148334,
-0.5865535736,
0.0518947169,
0.3359996974,
-0.0951738209,
-0.2543171644,
0.7305076122,
0.0542079136,
0.9192884564,
-0.0096014002,
-0.0293374807,
0.1951694936,
-0.2683546543,
0.0745494738,
-0.1268482208,
0.7445870638,
1.0050055981,
0.0082137482,
-0.3402146399,
-0.4894689023,
0.5861426592,
0.2624200284,
-0.8604656458,
0.0288415216,
0.4309505224,
-0.7712002993,
-0.7812434435,
-0.1608139724,
-0.9181035161,
-0.4096651673,
-0.4953516126,
0.4340730309,
-0.3025857508,
-0.1247008443,
-0.317817688,
-0.3271764517,
0.2976072729,
0.412896663,
-1.0610650778,
0.1274625957,
0.7188221216,
1.0884222984,
-0.3447780609,
-0.1716095954,
-0.3485559225,
-0.0128856646,
-0.6667109728,
1.0797451735,
-0.3898055255,
-0.3118042052,
0.1508807093,
-0.3352318704,
0.0089543564,
-0.3126658499,
0.2019289583,
-0.4021247327,
0.4282107949,
-0.1924010217,
-0.6869883537,
0.2816454172,
0.0205027722,
-0.3668097556,
0.7094806433,
0.0426986217,
-0.8132689595,
0.3397248685,
-0.7700184584,
-0.1805677563,
0.0402807184,
-0.2190372348,
-0.5600287318,
0.4303456247,
0.1538416594,
0.2332910299,
-0.1393829137,
0.1836010069,
-0.3873323798,
-0.3891476095,
0.2161681801,
-0.2958442569,
0.4739221036,
0.6006266475,
-0.2207568884,
0.2134543806,
-0.5358430147,
0.3669493198,
0.3856359124,
0.0926615596,
0.0074861781,
0.171603173,
0.4461853802,
0.2030178756,
0.1838615537,
-0.7152546644,
0.1511985511,
-0.3244058192,
0.4410952926,
0.7527971864,
-0.0678681731,
0.3782515824,
-0.4924823344,
0.4104573727,
-0.115127176,
0.1237452179,
-0.2578062415,
-0.5214035511,
-0.8728888631,
0.25350824,
0.380843401,
0.4134617746,
-1.020378828,
-0.0634548813,
-0.455649972,
-0.3120559156,
-0.8890057802,
0.0895568728,
0.5176085234,
0.5334075093,
0.105083853,
-0.4662386477,
-0.5906088948,
-0.8096651435,
-0.2474589646,
-0.133934468,
-0.003104781,
0.0901028961,
0.2965946496,
-0.2015312314,
0.9418638349,
-0.2877385616,
-0.269251436,
-0.0326270871,
0.1618879139,
-0.179549709,
0.6577893496,
0.6458805799,
-0.693790257,
-0.3787434995,
-0.0533620976,
-0.8239584565,
0.0147772161,
-0.1492397338,
-0.2573345304,
0.419647485,
0.2010470331,
-0.5526707172,
0.5282546282,
0.8220806122,
-0.4405137002,
0.2105086893,
0.0394841731,
0.4309617877,
-1.5657536983,
0.0073964051,
0.1331473589,
-0.4057618976,
-0.5318552256,
0.0945000872,
0.0750199631,
-0.369612366,
-0.2710335851,
0.5787338018,
-0.3954218924,
-0.2650922537,
-0.4434054792,
0.1965182126,
0.2016674876,
0.2379380614,
0.2345164567,
0.8177091479,
0.5006175041,
-0.1808330864,
0.2299893498,
0.4094991088,
-0.4875740409,
0.8026993275,
-0.5482238531,
0.6351795793,
-0.4117977619,
-0.0842363387,
-1.0010515451,
-0.3227159381,
0.1495132595,
-0.6843374968,
0.2536126971,
-0.2199768275,
-0.2427363843,
-0.4449115396,
-0.1718746871,
0.2093176544,
0.7850657701,
-0.7765610218,
0.6761299968,
0.2138621062,
0.1944506764,
-0.6829186678,
-0.7033963203,
0.2203061283,
0.2138768584,
-0.674444437,
0.500382185,
-0.2107055336,
-0.1771996319,
0.3342505693,
-0.0931497291,
0.026374558,
0.0212561283,
0.5426473618,
0.5965912938,
-0.2401178032,
0.2573712766,
0.1232388616,
-0.0054459218,
-0.1771938652,
-0.6618483663,
0.3973505795,
-0.054307472,
-0.2749510109,
-0.8091368675,
0.4166490436,
0.5477115512,
-0.1638080329,
0.6880905628,
0.4863425195,
-0.5014698505,
-0.0877461284,
-0.6492398381,
0.1224315315,
-0.4378177226,
0.3288014531,
-0.4718635976,
-0.6724073291,
0.3283602893,
0.0869804472,
0.4410008788,
0.4924128354,
0.312437892,
-0.6660096049,
1.2272484303,
0.7972521186,
0.2363306731,
0.828196764,
-0.3540690839,
-0.1552698016,
-0.6646093726,
-0.4562404156,
-0.3148897886,
-0.6363064647,
-0.1620773822,
-0.2717288435,
-0.0584315136,
-0.1563960016,
0.0171475317,
0.1787303984,
-0.4560571313,
0.8586200476,
0.4085889161,
0.4731543362,
0.1169300079,
0.4773295224,
0.1284056008,
-0.1807632744,
-0.5511773229,
-0.4589983225,
1.0652252436,
0.2970296144,
0.7758553624,
-0.023442246,
0.9449107051,
0.256267637,
0.2907803059,
-0.8612738252,
0.4648966193,
-0.3555054367,
-0.17341277,
0.2479269207,
-0.5124095678,
-0.8543692231,
-0.0834006816,
-0.5976489186,
-0.8694796562,
0.1087471321,
0.6243966222,
-0.4444034994,
0.4689710736,
-0.8411574364,
0.9365945458,
-0.4151346982,
-0.7567564845,
-0.3291803002,
-0.4611971378,
0.1200550422,
0.1450289786,
-0.2070389241,
0.0409447402,
-0.0465246662,
0.6782442331,
-0.254784584,
0.6069251895,
-0.1777874827,
0.0879146829,
0.2721908092,
0.1503197402,
0.4914322793,
-0.3863828778,
0.0057673892,
0.0687462017,
-0.1652979553,
-0.5672540069,
-0.7173415422,
0.7510517836,
-0.7503286004,
-0.4447521567,
-0.1046990231,
-0.450745225,
-0.3567876816,
0.0514256656,
0.7162413597,
0.51812011,
-0.2115275264,
0.0556307249,
0.5437996387,
0.2566378713,
0.3924082816,
-0.0666291714,
-0.531632483,
-0.5901551247,
0.810852766,
-0.2259957939,
0.4496487081,
0.2890945971,
0.0408214964,
-0.4510797858,
-0.680821538,
-0.6936649084,
0.229179889,
-0.8015288115,
-0.366617471,
-0.606014967,
-0.2327313721,
-0.2647811174,
-0.1986522228,
-0.5904914141,
-0.4000613689,
-0.5374273658,
0.0123535646,
0.298165828,
1.0461130142,
0.2221518755,
0.3284192383,
-0.8034667969,
0.4214714468,
0.2887814939,
0.6268668175,
-0.1436205655,
-0.5721490979,
-0.1654698998,
0.2530440688,
-0.3983804286,
-0.9488447309,
0.2731152773,
0.2965216339,
0.017814694,
0.3533108234,
-0.2384735942,
1.0093404055,
-0.3587457538,
0.8219439387,
0.6869137883,
-1.0593127012,
0.857100904,
-0.2147182226,
0.3811845779,
0.5797222853,
-0.0891038477,
-0.6625716686,
-0.1864374876,
-0.6249628663,
-0.3801615834,
0.6174879074,
0.4140982032,
0.0887355134,
0.4752134681,
0.6060131788,
-0.0790322945,
0.2222461402,
-0.6879383922,
0.1543952227,
-0.4983769357,
-0.8831339478,
0.0675894991,
-0.3374553621,
-0.1275412291,
0.1519751251,
0.5475488901,
-0.3419983685,
0.4404214323,
0.2090096772,
0.0318977311,
-0.5881652832,
0.0178278647,
0.5609376431,
0.4716358185,
0.1417832375,
-0.0055626705,
-0.1393858641,
-0.3586520553,
0.1308774203,
-0.0155865494,
-0.5417957306,
0.0175211653,
0.1066698134,
1.3329908848,
-0.3675716519,
-0.5333818793,
0.601603806,
-0.2468315959,
-0.2833153903,
-0.1784789711,
0.1221590489,
-0.0663962737,
0.5095964074,
0.065380238,
1.0758240223,
-0.0211800765,
-0.1887513846,
-0.038421046,
0.4644639194,
-0.7226853371,
-0.3342936933,
1.0356824398,
0.3340693116,
-0.5628245473,
0.7491595745,
-0.0943919197,
-0.4284439981,
0.7231534123,
0.6926448345,
1.1209716797,
-0.0233403407,
0.413166225,
0.4145157635,
0.1317681819,
-0.2875075936,
0.491985172,
-0.0738772824,
-0.7034426332,
-0.2931334972,
-0.4158012867,
-0.3756014109,
-0.0233126096,
-0.4343396127,
0.3177123368,
-0.3562822342,
-0.4143954217,
-0.1386215091,
-0.3326970935,
-0.7013316154,
0.1698775291,
0.5829529762,
0.6063957214,
-0.8845414519,
0.6127871275,
0.6706017852,
-0.3101937175,
-0.7348024249,
0.2018419504,
0.2316903323,
-0.729200542,
0.3390508294,
0.4987727702,
-0.1739053279,
0.1406410784,
-0.7501575947,
-0.7091442347,
1.0818893909,
0.5204488039,
-0.7937780023,
-0.0381931104,
-0.129182592,
0.6083490252,
-0.5731015205,
0.1459639519,
0.1516946107,
-0.055603601,
0.3615474105,
-0.556833744,
-0.3093938231,
-0.6412245035,
0.5076320171,
0.1389382631,
-0.6040087938,
0.1625402719,
-0.7699420452,
-0.5706678033,
0.6803954244,
0.8142582774,
0.1011507735,
0.5022565126,
0.5765091777,
0.7503374815,
0.6420709491,
-0.4042508602,
1.0936942101,
-0.3244960606,
0.4626921713,
0.9196152687,
-0.0536031052,
0.9266046882,
0.6714236736,
0.1218494922,
0.4805887341,
0.8520540595,
-0.0690656975,
0.5237864852,
-0.1987601668,
-0.1439561695,
-0.2737073302,
-0.4391702116,
-0.1598189622,
0.1531824917,
0.1850668192,
-0.4718072414,
0.1226207614,
0.2740122676,
-0.29714185,
0.2022660524,
-0.2617459297,
0.8301375508,
-0.0894961506,
-1.0242587328,
0.5210881233,
-0.4461487234,
0.5491557121,
-0.490860343,
-0.0378696322,
-0.2955869138,
0.2754070461,
-0.432582438,
-1.0662441254,
0.1645275354,
0.2089752853,
-0.1308555901,
-0.3314719796,
0.7806464434,
-0.5905694962,
-0.4583339691,
0.0298711751,
0.1700386703,
-0.0702762976,
0.2019947171,
-0.7877128124,
0.3088544905,
0.3029370606,
0.0337711386,
-0.0094318893,
-0.0020586394,
0.3574608266,
0.5957767963,
0.4645750821,
0.1168319136,
-0.2471376657,
0.258577615,
0.5205028653,
-0.4541086555,
-0.3560032248,
-0.6166253686,
0.4944600463,
-0.3326535821,
-0.2670800686,
0.2195540816,
0.4246965051,
0.6040968299,
-0.3324798346,
0.6649397016,
-0.0220726766,
0.1637304723,
-0.7604851127,
0.6567716002,
-0.8496496081,
0.0408452488,
-0.3316037059,
-1.1198101044,
-0.2183972746,
0.4131575525,
-0.1257393509,
-0.0347400233,
0.6687762737,
0.7713250518,
0.0543102659,
0.2148598731,
0.2070401907,
-0.0218917299,
0.1101728827,
0.5973416567,
1.1509324312,
-0.6751754284,
0.5227149129,
-0.4363465607,
-0.1443776786,
0.1345624328,
-0.750303328,
-0.7310480475,
-0.6864177585,
-0.6588519216,
-0.6882945299,
0.3833420277,
1.0198401213,
0.7374074459,
-0.7529061437,
-0.2049038708,
-0.3920194209,
-0.1472941339,
-0.26949507,
-0.1827352345,
0.2748078704,
-0.4085460007,
-0.9002516866,
0.1014746279,
0.2880364954,
0.7191828489,
0.0164218992,
-0.1462162584,
0.4636785388,
-0.0754878148,
0.3915664256,
0.0680905432,
-0.7321969867,
-0.249750644,
0.0453279465,
-0.1916262358,
0.2971614301,
0.5835773945,
-0.6966479421,
0.872615695,
0.4232675135,
0.7779380083,
0.4282017648,
0.1172331423,
0.5362866521,
-0.500590384,
0.0667379722,
0.1263774633,
0.3596162498,
0.5802208185,
-0.4065909088,
0.4796779752,
0.4339079261,
-0.4695607126,
-0.5616651773,
0.3785752654,
-1.0295069218,
-0.1325028688,
0.8944396973,
0.1881888062,
-0.5017699599,
0.3315776289,
-0.3583367765,
0.1180332154,
-0.3790588379,
0.8580263853,
0.4248435497,
0.1366472244,
-0.4654637873,
-0.3721367419,
0.4659596384,
0.6356796622,
-0.8485203981,
-0.1543417424,
0.6168014407,
0.1316198856,
0.1296609193,
0.4748959839,
-0.1269730628,
0.3685649335,
0.0130686481,
0.1743438989,
0.0556388758,
-0.2379717529,
-0.3546536267,
0.0278793313,
0.0620290674,
-0.5914810896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17330v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17330v2
|
Biomedical knowledge graph-optimized prompt generation for large language models
| 2023-11-29T03:07:00 | 2024-05-13T22:48:04 |
Karthik Soman, Peter W Rose, John H Morris, Rabia E Akbas, Brett Smith, Braian Peetoom, Catalina Villouta-Reyes, Gabriel Cerono, Yongmei Shi, Angela Rizk-Jackson, Sharat Israni, Charlotte A Nelson, Sui Huang, Sergio E Baranzini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are being adopted at an unprecedented rate, yet
still face challenges in knowledge-intensive domains like biomedicine.
Solutions such as pre-training and domain-specific fine-tuning add substantial
computational overhead, requiring further domain expertise. Here, we introduce
a token-optimized and robust Knowledge Graph-based Retrieval Augmented
Generation (KG-RAG) framework by leveraging a massive biomedical KG (SPOKE)
with LLMs such as Llama-2-13b, GPT-3.5-Turbo and GPT-4, to generate meaningful
biomedical text rooted in established knowledge. Compared to the existing RAG
technique for Knowledge Graphs, the proposed method utilizes minimal graph
schema for context extraction and uses embedding methods for context pruning.
This optimization in context extraction results in more than 50% reduction in
token consumption without compromising the accuracy, making a cost-effective
and robust RAG implementation on proprietary LLMs. KG-RAG consistently enhanced
the performance of LLMs across diverse biomedical prompts by generating
responses rooted in established knowledge, accompanied by accurate provenance
and statistical evidence (if available) to substantiate the claims. Further
benchmarking on human curated datasets, such as biomedical true/false and
multiple-choice questions (MCQ), showed a remarkable 71% boost in the
performance of the Llama-2 model on the challenging MCQ dataset, demonstrating
the framework's capacity to empower open-source models with fewer parameters
for domain specific questions. Furthermore, KG-RAG enhanced the performance of
proprietary GPT models, such as GPT-3.5 and GPT-4. In summary, the proposed
framework combines explicit and implicit knowledge of KG and LLM in a token
optimized fashion, thus enhancing the adaptability of general-purpose LLMs to
tackle domain-specific questions in a cost-effective fashion.
|
[
-0.2010346204,
-0.7956895232,
0.743427515,
-0.1419891715,
-0.2482517958,
0.2259661555,
0.1129602492,
-0.3180934787,
0.1937329471,
0.3557552099,
-0.3930532038,
-0.6303027868,
-0.4850338697,
0.3514725864,
0.137312606,
0.9607565999,
0.2067570537,
0.034047585,
-0.5196800828,
-0.2153782696,
-0.5414246321,
-0.4358163476,
-0.7666876316,
-0.4357121587,
0.81895262,
0.3038455248,
0.3396745026,
0.7058278918,
0.2813957036,
0.1842150092,
-0.4474522471,
0.6638020873,
-0.5998345613,
0.4157297611,
-0.2241929024,
-0.1065610349,
-0.5592058301,
-0.2988443077,
0.3963533044,
0.741630733,
0.1445718408,
0.2116526961,
-0.0418034308,
0.6278409362,
-0.5163837671,
0.1610299945,
-0.7078819871,
-0.1527181864,
-0.1757798642,
-0.3713113368,
-0.4520838559,
-0.2967267036,
-0.1100242212,
-0.7430061102,
-0.0198380314,
0.2953234911,
0.700376451,
0.2478154749,
-0.6857553124,
-0.3679971397,
-0.0239724927,
0.5965579152,
-0.586284399,
0.3934780061,
0.3179067671,
0.3862052858,
-0.4407074451,
-1.1309356689,
-0.4581506252,
-0.3140283525,
-0.2042674869,
0.2753549814,
-0.1333187521,
0.0616887286,
0.2671188116,
-0.0607838184,
-0.460659951,
0.1312057674,
-0.2671855688,
-0.4298084974,
0.2242490798,
0.3021585941,
0.2941016853,
-0.5973643661,
-0.1775735915,
-0.0068809753,
-1.0535675287,
0.048982352,
0.169011876,
0.4556619525,
0.2013114989,
0.797933042,
-0.1837108731,
0.8750507832,
0.0457111821,
-0.6029435992,
0.2834493816,
-0.3880139887,
0.2385795563,
-0.1003828049,
0.8090179563,
0.4709904194,
-0.0060352017,
-0.3008547127,
-0.0288157947,
-0.1384714991,
0.1346135139,
-1.0983059406,
0.1030773148,
0.1901124567,
-0.268633455,
-0.4867207408,
-0.4566447437,
-0.5944771767,
-0.4925687313,
-0.1793315858,
0.1527605653,
-0.6091769934,
0.0376895666,
-0.1580245495,
-0.2424029857,
-0.0140748406,
0.2340673059,
-0.4860511124,
-0.1824755669,
0.498670578,
0.7433354855,
-0.2989062071,
0.225708425,
-0.6883371472,
0.549703896,
-0.2667173445,
0.6411533356,
-0.5324527025,
-0.657961607,
-0.2137629092,
-0.1292039454,
0.1279010326,
-0.4927858412,
0.47603333,
-0.6669989824,
0.0358242169,
-0.5382027626,
-0.6793532372,
0.0491790213,
0.3085628748,
-0.353887707,
1.0127452612,
0.2723866403,
-1.0337443352,
0.4420313537,
-0.6965277195,
-0.5397517681,
0.3337432742,
-0.4120256007,
-0.333478272,
-0.305996269,
0.4847007394,
0.4149499238,
-0.5343082547,
0.6027151346,
-0.2722937465,
-0.0140195973,
0.1429726034,
-0.0655784383,
0.5753421187,
0.2581609786,
-0.089367114,
0.0656248108,
-0.7841319442,
0.1326323003,
0.1741250157,
-0.4187179208,
-0.224688381,
-0.1248448789,
-0.3730662465,
0.0285428073,
0.3484991491,
-0.5870068073,
0.2218204439,
-0.5009146333,
0.3753013611,
0.7504754663,
0.2251647115,
0.2668540478,
-0.302261889,
0.6322673559,
-0.0580278859,
-0.0700535104,
-0.1977631748,
-0.6503385901,
-0.1374075711,
-0.585831821,
0.2351101339,
0.4908827245,
-1.073611021,
0.374388814,
-0.279797554,
-0.4992353916,
-0.2861767411,
-0.0520454198,
0.5067991614,
1.3788417578,
0.4701025486,
0.1421219856,
-0.3783889115,
-0.7418529987,
-0.266164124,
-0.2331945747,
-0.1095649898,
0.9323132038,
0.3125276268,
-0.4911261499,
1.3960211277,
-0.747243166,
0.0182491187,
-0.1875632405,
-0.0475315377,
0.5005438328,
0.256873548,
0.5729354024,
-0.7825374007,
-0.4553907812,
0.37338534,
-0.6466704011,
-0.5678198338,
0.454813987,
-0.2625436187,
0.0094095906,
0.4479137659,
-0.6383801699,
0.2174851596,
0.2898770273,
-0.4589777291,
0.6904198527,
-0.0764321685,
0.1381250173,
-1.4359494448,
0.7306556702,
-0.4733741879,
-0.3351015449,
-0.4821791053,
-0.0980428532,
0.0723990649,
-0.2078074068,
-0.193545267,
1.0881587267,
-0.1381952912,
0.0229436923,
-0.1837950945,
0.1971148252,
0.1974700987,
0.2509454191,
-0.22338368,
0.8127149343,
0.2284735143,
-0.582205534,
0.2294859737,
0.5513566732,
-0.0508702099,
0.4052008092,
-0.7030990124,
0.2577696145,
-0.3262255192,
0.4443085492,
-0.7467209101,
-0.4864696562,
0.3058017194,
-0.5959767103,
0.4379040897,
-0.2188220471,
-0.4478987157,
-0.5171523094,
-0.0055557252,
0.5026895404,
0.6027987599,
-0.5817787051,
0.6711919904,
0.3607017398,
-0.4573037028,
-0.9153838158,
-0.2590615451,
-0.0259037763,
-0.0356518775,
-0.6107366681,
0.3966241479,
-0.0947743505,
0.0755665228,
-0.0163491815,
-0.1190445721,
0.2059682012,
-0.0473231077,
0.1034811139,
0.3658949733,
0.0171793923,
0.2683792412,
0.4794362783,
-0.1334560215,
-0.1524342,
-0.380446285,
0.5182414055,
0.2372378111,
-0.4124233127,
0.1102953553,
0.2708607912,
0.4960519373,
-0.1787588745,
0.5843364,
0.6768393517,
-0.061472524,
-0.0897761434,
-0.4420875609,
-0.270198971,
-0.4977205992,
0.598546803,
-0.3090981543,
-1.287375927,
0.5378938913,
-0.4959599376,
-0.065179579,
0.3579469919,
0.7673190236,
0.1624047458,
1.0647571087,
0.1312746555,
0.0086312341,
0.1636552811,
0.1281802654,
0.2473406047,
-0.8963474035,
-0.3344845474,
-0.5035768151,
0.0376642607,
-0.3172100186,
-0.5109921098,
0.9665589333,
0.270765394,
-0.3770997524,
-0.1610900313,
-0.6164949536,
0.3374671042,
0.4497307539,
0.2552007735,
0.1745665371,
-0.0105921701,
-0.6935294271,
0.1832939535,
-1.0812913179,
-0.3490501642,
1.2743599415,
0.0733347908,
0.4733537436,
0.0382021368,
0.5164392591,
0.0588476099,
0.5747795105,
-0.6681956649,
0.5234181881,
0.0444895364,
-0.4475280643,
-0.1595001817,
-0.8769786358,
-1.156298995,
0.0097381417,
-0.214339748,
-0.6465792656,
-0.1198435575,
0.2652541399,
-0.2650809586,
0.1881456822,
-0.4617266357,
0.6616612077,
0.0645570308,
-0.2825252414,
0.1555401236,
-0.7371141315,
0.2652249038,
-0.378138274,
0.3448783159,
-0.0526608191,
-0.1333444268,
0.5817207098,
-0.5192499757,
0.7243570089,
-0.3397527635,
-0.0410654433,
0.427655071,
-0.0595125407,
0.8125026226,
0.0678877905,
-0.1306557208,
-0.1495879889,
-0.1227802634,
-0.2275655717,
-0.4149608314,
0.4573132694,
-0.5576630235,
-0.5030917525,
0.2269112766,
-0.8467147946,
-0.592936337,
0.4611942172,
0.4442580938,
0.7213491797,
0.0706405565,
0.1616687328,
0.4990872145,
-0.7578864098,
-0.0501061641,
0.5568209291,
-0.3663384914,
-0.7897791862,
0.8956448436,
-0.0287986044,
0.1496854722,
0.3863973916,
0.4898084402,
-0.4229389429,
-0.4976860881,
-0.4665595591,
0.3758472502,
-0.9078339934,
-0.7674999237,
-0.8647108674,
-0.0856357068,
-0.8093312979,
-0.160964027,
0.0005912569,
-0.2673337162,
-0.2511626184,
-0.1962609738,
0.7146807909,
0.6284754872,
-0.0322507396,
0.2247223705,
-0.9035083055,
0.3779585361,
0.3021006286,
0.1901435703,
-0.0888235644,
-0.3560501933,
-0.1558480412,
-0.079804413,
-0.2194637358,
-0.8955971003,
0.4060761929,
0.0492207892,
0.6322081089,
0.2141246349,
0.1847178638,
0.5843959451,
-0.7377011776,
0.6041523218,
0.2881343961,
-0.6021183133,
0.4462369978,
-0.7244919538,
0.215539664,
0.3813497424,
0.3269664049,
-0.3445234001,
-0.4372843504,
-0.4592126608,
-1.0699772835,
0.4971958399,
0.1176717952,
-0.0524502471,
-0.4164034128,
0.656709075,
0.1181951687,
0.232006073,
-0.3607492149,
-0.2665220201,
0.1310701072,
-0.4853951931,
0.236717701,
-0.3440119922,
-0.2963255644,
-0.3060406446,
0.6712453961,
-0.6110388637,
0.2214241475,
0.2660155594,
0.154303804,
0.0416803509,
0.0395046659,
0.3628812432,
0.6058939099,
0.0036417863,
-0.1898238063,
0.3186899722,
-0.4506711066,
-0.0372219905,
0.2013291121,
-0.2511862516,
-0.019369565,
0.3441020846,
0.6321585774,
0.0589728467,
-0.8657844067,
0.5403975844,
0.1718890816,
-0.1422099173,
0.1967704892,
-0.0593935214,
0.2211424708,
0.2910692096,
0.3735041022,
-0.1387058198,
0.1079606414,
0.0359339379,
0.2658501267,
0.5688471198,
-0.0398289636,
0.037675105,
0.7648839355,
0.1346204728,
0.0202982277,
0.311001122,
-0.2209665328,
-0.5080587268,
0.5402305126,
0.738211453,
0.3493235707,
-0.1181994975,
0.1099044159,
0.5507936478,
-0.2131667137,
0.1714112312,
0.1463146806,
-0.1163771749,
-0.6884022355,
-0.6232721806,
-0.8220176101,
-0.3272415996,
-0.1731813401,
-0.4931343496,
0.2284331918,
-0.1860613376,
-0.5427489281,
-0.1491355151,
-0.0710489824,
-0.5107809901,
0.0334341638,
-0.1940212101,
0.8833212256,
-0.4284057617,
0.6502758861,
0.6052430868,
-0.0855566189,
-1.0707390308,
-0.5045308471,
-0.2741053402,
-0.9783486724,
0.8529110551,
0.0704632625,
-0.0457320027,
0.240553841,
-0.571400404,
-0.921674192,
1.4775024652,
0.6163002849,
-0.4607862234,
-0.2035119832,
0.0517549329,
0.2763481438,
-0.2591038048,
0.1348584443,
0.2743738294,
0.5863371491,
0.5321446657,
-0.8361279964,
0.1808919162,
-0.1890450269,
-0.1639442444,
0.1446347982,
-0.4603330493,
0.6547851562,
-0.1767644137,
-0.0655262172,
0.2062652558,
0.3192646503,
0.9110868573,
0.3443138003,
0.3278274834,
0.5038715005,
1.1669632196,
0.084822543,
1.2617256641,
-0.625587821,
0.1995416284,
0.725251317,
-0.3245416284,
0.2715123892,
0.4735780358,
-0.0474268645,
0.2580119967,
0.3789611161,
0.2345822752,
0.4188095927,
0.2235181928,
-0.2196444869,
-0.2292148769,
-0.43762061,
-0.5357909203,
0.143040508,
0.4046469033,
-0.479522109,
-0.1496827751,
0.0163024515,
0.2646534443,
-0.2314062566,
-0.3701936305,
0.8507674932,
0.1545419991,
-0.6935352087,
0.4641193449,
-0.1256252378,
0.3805102408,
-0.8393356204,
-0.0521554649,
-0.2605892718,
-0.1468961984,
0.0417159908,
-0.4719257355,
-0.0994747356,
0.1998936087,
-0.1931856722,
-0.1453524083,
1.0878283978,
-0.2682778537,
-0.4822801352,
0.1536490619,
0.7059579492,
0.0702972785,
0.1978610605,
-0.4969680011,
-0.1360634863,
-0.0464566574,
-0.4535253942,
0.3332569599,
0.6086463332,
-0.0023501003,
0.7497556806,
0.8889921308,
0.2103027701,
-0.2384595126,
0.0259210207,
1.2213362455,
-0.4547831714,
-0.4653370678,
-0.6949360371,
0.4008477926,
-0.2496086508,
-0.0892383978,
0.5191879272,
0.4482998252,
0.1791417897,
0.1666330695,
0.7920608521,
-0.1281141043,
0.7859651446,
-0.4901357293,
0.9026305676,
-0.5880131721,
0.0805587173,
-0.3392522931,
-0.5742900372,
-0.3184716105,
0.264306128,
-0.2026542276,
0.2244797498,
0.4480704069,
0.8865718246,
0.3517079949,
-0.2884932458,
0.277231127,
0.2262355089,
0.5031592846,
0.3551724255,
0.5276393294,
0.0374879092,
0.560721159,
0.3026338518,
-0.2079664469,
-0.1397570521,
-0.9754450917,
-0.8523420691,
-0.2967337668,
0.0036074549,
-0.5541538,
0.0630622879,
0.8373254538,
0.5646688938,
-0.4711869955,
0.3621842265,
-0.0277214237,
0.0643898547,
0.2424312234,
-0.2169611305,
0.643548727,
-0.6443046331,
-0.4157227278,
0.6003814936,
0.2067466676,
-0.017154552,
0.1823769212,
-0.2378004789,
0.1970041841,
0.0292641167,
0.7929939032,
0.1833580136,
-0.4750986099,
-0.2996228039,
0.1710166186,
-0.2293632925,
-0.1362139583,
0.677361846,
-0.9808291793,
0.3470530808,
0.3897128403,
0.9947135448,
0.395798713,
0.0829358846,
0.6268081069,
-0.9715521336,
0.0708420351,
0.4580242932,
0.3312310874,
0.3146821856,
-0.4176106155,
0.4828744829,
0.4361233115,
-0.6740882993,
-0.8783124685,
0.3669452369,
-0.9471752644,
-0.4272347391,
1.4107061625,
-0.0414795913,
-0.3334357738,
-0.1096516326,
-0.4444315732,
0.4433456063,
-0.3105832934,
0.5020763874,
0.3649372458,
-0.1512331069,
0.3304071724,
-0.4006787241,
0.5300908685,
0.3390391469,
-0.6941056848,
0.0338426679,
0.5679821372,
0.2767023444,
-0.0383737907,
0.780433476,
-0.227578789,
0.0363304727,
-0.1421358287,
-0.071170494,
-0.4869544208,
-0.0258495156,
0.2978267372,
0.26267609,
-0.0501736626,
0.4076269567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17311v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17311v1
|
Universal Self-Consistency for Large Language Model Generation
| 2023-11-29T02:07:09 | 2023-11-29T02:07:09 |
Xinyun Chen, Renat Aksitov, Uri Alon, Jie Ren, Kefan Xiao, Pengcheng Yin, Sushant Prakash, Charles Sutton, Xuezhi Wang, Denny Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Self-consistency with chain-of-thought prompting (CoT) has demonstrated
remarkable performance gains on various challenging tasks, by utilizing
multiple reasoning paths sampled from large language models (LLMs). However,
self-consistency relies on the answer extraction process to aggregate multiple
solutions, which is not applicable to free-form answers. In this work, we
propose Universal Self-Consistency (USC), which leverages LLMs themselves to
select the most consistent answer among multiple candidates. We evaluate USC on
a variety of benchmarks, including mathematical reasoning, code generation,
long-context summarization, and open-ended question answering. On open-ended
generation tasks where the original self-consistency method is not applicable,
USC effectively utilizes multiple samples and improves the performance. For
mathematical reasoning, USC matches the standard self-consistency performance
without requiring the answer formats to be similar. Finally, without access to
execution results, USC also matches the execution-based voting performance on
code generation.
|
[
-0.3499809802,
-0.7206924558,
0.8446968794,
0.6508657932,
-0.0445598401,
-0.1072835103,
-0.4285571575,
-0.2580468059,
0.0146353636,
0.6323455572,
-0.4519179761,
-0.4219944179,
-0.1923092753,
0.3872714341,
-0.2927145958,
0.788842082,
-0.2149059474,
-0.2485665232,
-0.4164589345,
-0.2725486457,
-0.64475739,
-0.5804666877,
-0.3601968884,
-0.3377496004,
0.4209870398,
0.5124390125,
0.5737032294,
0.8442920446,
0.2422260344,
0.2707521617,
0.3140360713,
0.4712356031,
-0.3418960869,
0.5418353677,
-0.5756383538,
-0.1098015606,
-0.5442250371,
-0.0874044672,
0.6844353676,
0.2404984832,
-0.343639046,
0.2984448075,
0.1680606306,
0.5603955984,
-0.7769651413,
-0.1086889654,
-0.8915184736,
-0.16448614,
-0.0629836395,
-0.0097044855,
-0.5151433945,
-0.4884552956,
-0.2808498144,
-0.2956246734,
0.3790130615,
-0.135961771,
0.3758477271,
0.2775617838,
-0.3940858245,
-0.284992367,
-0.7678186893,
0.6947011352,
-0.6351329684,
0.4165739417,
0.1638132781,
0.2047614753,
-0.3780434132,
-0.4580671489,
-0.7055734396,
-0.1435828954,
0.2502560616,
0.2496725321,
-0.0578567907,
-0.0715709254,
0.2122295499,
0.1110311523,
-0.6263666153,
0.0108319372,
-0.1516650468,
-0.3114231825,
0.7673220634,
0.1633543372,
-0.0052926876,
-0.0727101937,
-0.2582836449,
-0.1450015157,
-1.0054047108,
-0.0225964561,
0.1580647379,
0.2631993592,
0.144550845,
0.7182536721,
-0.3544506729,
0.6328229904,
0.0923878923,
-0.084106572,
0.0389214866,
-0.3039678037,
-0.2030392438,
-0.1391272247,
1.1090085506,
-0.050660979,
0.4905396104,
-0.097348243,
-0.1189082414,
0.0112282457,
0.2678668797,
-0.5972187519,
-0.1458141953,
0.3223132789,
-0.1763305962,
-0.0438462459,
0.131126225,
-0.6279973388,
0.0147124194,
-0.4357925057,
0.2087970525,
-0.2336260229,
-0.2702537179,
0.07228221,
0.259020865,
0.1771704257,
0.419052124,
-0.9242405295,
0.1342853755,
0.6655626893,
0.7099657655,
-0.4203611612,
-0.3658955991,
-0.7117724419,
0.3201005459,
-0.5956240296,
0.8690590858,
-0.2636590302,
-0.3334813416,
-0.2679573298,
-0.3420791924,
-0.0521390364,
-0.6957709789,
0.2073279619,
-0.1977525502,
0.0767451525,
-0.4907315373,
-0.6708108783,
0.3970731199,
0.1976531446,
-0.3948631585,
1.1803705692,
-0.0253158361,
-0.3623185754,
0.1026619971,
-0.5350714326,
-0.1478756368,
-0.0598265007,
-0.6310982704,
-0.2889527678,
0.3054667115,
0.2055012584,
0.3014267981,
-0.2396332324,
0.5644608736,
-0.4386897385,
-0.1619676948,
0.1145845056,
-0.6469647884,
0.6663264036,
0.4973747134,
-0.569952786,
0.0420788713,
-0.6977956891,
0.5138517022,
0.1044751704,
-0.276512444,
0.1301887333,
-0.1034897342,
-0.3208911419,
0.4669010937,
0.4437298179,
-0.8190627694,
0.388074249,
0.1594350487,
0.0800174475,
1.1293572187,
-0.098094143,
0.0467373133,
-0.2116484195,
0.6452333927,
0.0102142571,
-0.1191129759,
-0.2084912807,
-0.537646234,
-0.5504750609,
-0.1528567374,
0.2619132102,
0.3349852264,
-0.266582191,
0.523406744,
-0.0462751798,
-0.4208945036,
-0.4588137865,
0.4064128697,
0.5993207097,
0.5594906211,
0.4023509324,
-0.0240289439,
-0.5058164597,
-0.8087961078,
-0.2582429349,
-0.096219033,
0.0871791095,
0.2600461841,
0.2882591188,
-0.2009517401,
1.2444300652,
-0.6190600991,
-0.0395522527,
-0.1728843004,
0.1163834706,
0.1309763044,
0.6444934011,
0.3615105152,
-0.3793090284,
-0.6078956723,
-0.1672419459,
-0.9639470577,
-0.2589997649,
-0.1318811178,
-0.4544335604,
0.358971417,
0.6776795387,
-0.4091337323,
0.4010206163,
0.7143469453,
-0.2031379938,
0.8888708353,
-0.5026644468,
-0.0167663358,
-1.2240314484,
0.1581000537,
-0.1290058941,
-0.3379467726,
-0.2959105968,
0.1493099183,
0.2723759413,
0.1210895851,
-0.1794447452,
0.7226254344,
-0.4487168491,
-0.0885949954,
-0.2241532803,
0.3579488099,
0.0624269731,
0.2589193583,
-0.0742007792,
1.1278169155,
0.4703165889,
-0.7214143872,
0.4178773463,
0.2725058496,
0.0203790534,
0.5015725493,
-0.886505127,
0.5515988469,
-0.169798404,
0.2583423257,
-1.0393898487,
-0.1576415449,
-0.1415403485,
-0.2917921543,
-0.0308561195,
0.1214824915,
-0.5320625901,
-0.5192694664,
-0.1028884426,
0.416621834,
0.3914280832,
-0.8510065079,
0.5029174089,
-0.0175381079,
-0.0924345702,
-0.689383626,
-0.2617722154,
-0.1303477585,
0.1835536808,
-0.4878839254,
-0.0219252463,
-0.6603912115,
-0.1130892709,
-0.285256207,
-0.447188586,
0.0192484558,
-0.056406457,
0.1089289412,
0.3698513508,
-0.3334031999,
0.3273032606,
0.1324465126,
-0.029196864,
-0.0072796028,
-0.3831703365,
0.6605359316,
-0.366558522,
-0.4599207938,
-0.2984566987,
0.5711131692,
0.5268111825,
-0.4794561863,
0.5824871659,
0.2378682941,
-0.1187522113,
-0.2115204781,
-0.7944558263,
0.0722603202,
-0.4807137549,
-0.0688753799,
-0.8527697325,
-0.9714483619,
0.6899402142,
-0.0217859056,
0.4369851351,
0.5528773069,
0.5737026334,
-0.00925285,
1.3037803173,
0.4783656001,
0.0173716582,
0.142667219,
-0.0597090572,
0.0459922366,
-0.9465814829,
-0.249939397,
-0.6915783286,
0.0673817322,
-0.4557427764,
-0.1129384264,
0.3353101909,
0.3115867376,
-0.3448237479,
0.3877476454,
-0.7048168778,
0.7602773309,
0.6473146677,
-0.0277612973,
0.428183645,
-0.0282875709,
-0.7231717706,
0.1793527752,
-0.5507246852,
-0.5524947643,
1.2198557854,
-0.2022414505,
0.8689984083,
0.2626531124,
1.13846457,
0.0758020505,
0.3515539169,
-0.069391042,
0.5805649757,
-0.0921303257,
-0.657474637,
-0.4071777463,
-0.7164910436,
-1.1196671724,
0.2739041746,
-0.0009203559,
-0.8998154402,
-0.1906504631,
0.4656617641,
-0.3277316391,
0.1634941846,
-0.3968013227,
0.8860204816,
-0.1705600768,
-0.3415250182,
-0.0892603621,
-0.4619967043,
0.3610453308,
-0.250652492,
-0.0626627281,
-0.2229370922,
0.3062884212,
0.3779150844,
-0.286554426,
0.3944706321,
0.1513807923,
-0.4118293822,
0.6796445251,
0.349822849,
0.3778138161,
0.1148578897,
-0.190908134,
0.0510779694,
0.0128645431,
-0.4675703347,
-0.7207378149,
0.9878027439,
-0.7025256157,
-0.8641498089,
-0.2719307542,
-0.643466711,
-0.2227661014,
0.3394912481,
0.4182961881,
0.6272209883,
-0.1333746165,
0.2341018766,
0.6271883845,
0.1716922969,
0.5910377502,
0.3035461009,
-0.446919769,
-0.5680270195,
0.6374291778,
-0.0195792094,
0.4978381395,
-0.054559987,
0.3762403727,
-0.6866430044,
-0.0975181088,
-0.7769442201,
0.3711618185,
-0.6323357224,
-0.3238594234,
-0.6181639433,
-0.3882626295,
-0.8266634941,
-0.2743175924,
-0.546215117,
-0.3988828957,
-0.1412631124,
0.1299785376,
-0.0076408419,
1.0242960453,
-0.3019708097,
-0.0361716971,
-0.7597036362,
0.598618269,
0.4633975625,
0.568670392,
0.0025696985,
-0.2944601774,
0.0095278919,
0.2529263496,
-0.7055096626,
-0.7944710851,
-0.1388685852,
0.3013111949,
0.7011995316,
0.3206013739,
0.1300231367,
0.863801837,
-0.5680745244,
0.6053780317,
0.421141535,
-1.1408494711,
0.7085784674,
-0.2223396152,
0.6975281835,
0.6395180821,
0.1286039054,
-0.4644988775,
-0.719901979,
-0.8049981594,
-0.5023587942,
0.3017627597,
0.279815942,
0.0607948564,
-0.3851399124,
0.4837378263,
0.1621810049,
0.0889598504,
-0.7488963008,
-0.1656913757,
-0.2857591212,
-0.4684397876,
0.0026928799,
0.101838991,
-0.0337237231,
-0.1087914556,
0.5762927532,
-0.5334504247,
0.1155563816,
0.4794929326,
0.1013299152,
-0.297401011,
0.4138599038,
0.6566437483,
1.012344718,
0.1503742784,
0.3350010216,
0.0563504584,
-0.2443562895,
0.376565218,
-0.29905352,
-0.2428424805,
-0.1423284113,
0.0134268599,
0.0772338435,
-0.1710491031,
-0.783739984,
0.4106306732,
-0.0609344468,
-0.2132921368,
-0.3398106098,
0.4487763047,
-0.0282973871,
0.0709430352,
0.2056924701,
0.0111603988,
-0.173992753,
-0.6448593736,
0.3699888289,
0.60969311,
-0.0980646238,
-0.0690102428,
0.9188159704,
-0.2215836942,
-0.2436923087,
0.8174290061,
-0.2347591668,
-0.3768242896,
0.571115613,
1.0583263636,
0.9122537374,
-0.4394596815,
0.2969014347,
0.4610579312,
-0.0768254474,
-0.4406354725,
0.6242163181,
-0.1850148141,
-0.7342296839,
-0.4809831679,
-0.5331107378,
-0.5239465237,
-0.1141181961,
-0.6964656711,
0.0878677294,
-0.5979731679,
-0.0237390008,
-0.0917547345,
-0.2714650929,
-0.5222136378,
0.3459084928,
0.0567786023,
0.7911291122,
-0.5162258148,
0.8845514059,
0.4899636507,
-0.3648554981,
-1.1418477297,
-0.0757822618,
-0.0945238844,
-0.6246355772,
0.1475565881,
0.2026138008,
-0.4034878612,
0.0324402377,
-0.8715901971,
-1.1841605902,
1.0617661476,
0.5840657949,
-0.5122520924,
0.1257010251,
0.0836576968,
0.5430262089,
-0.6813421845,
0.1230473742,
0.4146579504,
0.1637447476,
0.3277131617,
-0.922273159,
0.1639227569,
-0.0175145362,
-0.0051379148,
0.1371633857,
-0.8058084249,
0.6688437462,
-0.5230745673,
-0.0519825406,
0.2956683636,
0.8303585052,
0.9248108864,
0.1714504957,
0.4167514443,
0.57889992,
0.8932836056,
0.0209458862,
0.7206152678,
-0.4365346134,
0.4164179564,
1.5168344975,
-0.4178780019,
0.9801949859,
0.0838743076,
0.0018663554,
0.7959918976,
0.1886247396,
0.0820695832,
0.1779702753,
0.1808400601,
-0.1872833818,
-0.45740062,
0.145855248,
-0.3965026438,
0.6758921146,
-0.1579417586,
-0.043382857,
-0.2704044282,
-0.3889913559,
0.1661414951,
0.2872361839,
-0.1628464013,
0.7027485967,
0.0145455059,
-1.1998693943,
0.7183705568,
-0.2055841088,
0.1708271056,
-0.4852437079,
-0.1586485505,
-0.2312970608,
0.2270292938,
-0.0746059865,
-0.9193527102,
0.2329807878,
0.1638335288,
-0.2710989118,
-0.2352872491,
0.4130912721,
-0.577512145,
-0.4420035183,
0.1760936081,
0.6827306747,
0.1910762936,
-0.0854942426,
-0.4759241641,
-0.0630462319,
0.0755639523,
-0.0361442529,
0.1996109784,
0.5896416306,
0.0143429125,
0.8001589179,
0.7833260298,
-0.0189686585,
0.3667854667,
0.0878372192,
0.7259195447,
-0.7204582691,
-0.4307788312,
-0.932970643,
0.3622117937,
-0.235565722,
-0.6433628201,
0.8572408557,
0.8225598931,
0.6496294141,
0.1617239118,
0.7422072291,
0.017799722,
0.3718166947,
-0.3950332999,
0.3158282042,
-0.4756505191,
0.1290032417,
-0.4492927492,
-1.292388916,
-0.1374344826,
0.6003456712,
0.1453393698,
0.1016554013,
0.8150374293,
0.5112191439,
-0.0351262167,
0.1456804723,
0.4424059987,
0.1080832407,
0.4997392297,
0.4586952627,
0.5064483285,
-0.1348586529,
0.6162272096,
-0.0736367479,
-0.3086485267,
0.1395332366,
-0.9787515998,
-0.6333136559,
-0.407507658,
-0.1771401316,
-0.6433659792,
-0.1015011966,
1.1883426905,
0.6792054176,
-0.9407981038,
-0.3734479845,
-0.4357155263,
0.1035625115,
-0.1874201447,
-0.1905828267,
0.2803454399,
-0.6897079349,
-0.5025601387,
0.4483769536,
0.3338273168,
-0.0125583559,
-0.4028152227,
-0.0758141577,
0.0187053885,
0.3173374832,
0.4587565958,
0.4937326312,
-0.9122762084,
-0.5237377286,
0.334466964,
-0.167683363,
0.2550017238,
0.8690989017,
-0.7559601068,
0.599407196,
0.1910627782,
0.4876506031,
0.3559057415,
0.3696048558,
0.6913384199,
-0.7012123466,
-0.3680523336,
0.0331011042,
0.4831953347,
0.1436081082,
-0.3615542352,
0.5975155234,
0.0407287069,
-0.9556687474,
-0.4448527098,
0.5738130808,
-1.0079649687,
-0.0814623758,
1.1286911964,
-0.3141638041,
-0.0712913275,
-0.0341357552,
-0.1631017029,
0.0912452042,
-0.371841222,
0.9406775236,
0.574744761,
-0.48619169,
-0.1442087591,
-0.1409187019,
0.118880868,
0.3652444482,
-0.8198123574,
0.4391349852,
0.6180971861,
0.5265461206,
0.2790198922,
0.9384636879,
-0.1736162752,
0.2507691383,
-0.1552843004,
0.0753057376,
0.1735166162,
-0.7283844352,
-0.2611338496,
0.2591076195,
-0.0009865899,
0.1405777484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17307v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17307v1
|
RoKEPG: RoBERTa and Knowledge Enhancement for Prescription Generation of Traditional Chinese Medicine
| 2023-11-29T01:59:38 | 2023-11-29T01:59:38 |
Hua Pu, Jiacong Mi, Shan Lu, Jieyue He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) prescription is the most critical form of
TCM treatment, and uncovering the complex nonlinear relationship between
symptoms and TCM is of great significance for clinical practice and assisting
physicians in diagnosis and treatment. Although there have been some studies on
TCM prescription generation, these studies consider a single factor and
directly model the symptom-prescription generation problem mainly based on
symptom descriptions, lacking guidance from TCM knowledge. To this end, we
propose a RoBERTa and Knowledge Enhancement model for Prescription Generation
of Traditional Chinese Medicine (RoKEPG). RoKEPG is firstly pre-trained by our
constructed TCM corpus, followed by fine-tuning the pre-trained model, and the
model is guided to generate TCM prescriptions by introducing four classes of
knowledge of TCM through the attention mask matrix. Experimental results on the
publicly available TCM prescription dataset show that RoKEPG improves the F1
metric by about 2% over the baseline model with the best results.
|
[
0.0929136425,
-0.8542665243,
0.4693093002,
-0.0156627856,
-0.2379874885,
-0.3149101734,
-0.4965877831,
-0.7720200419,
0.1877554059,
0.9701538682,
-0.5485852957,
-0.8013235331,
-0.5473399162,
-0.2223871499,
0.090402931,
1.130173564,
0.3370803595,
0.6664533019,
0.072740525,
0.2562513053,
-0.7168862224,
-0.0040111137,
-0.9911753535,
-0.6460950971,
0.2840793133,
0.3571366072,
0.5155525208,
0.4250864387,
0.6893851757,
0.1144813448,
-0.1117701381,
0.385815531,
-0.3639689386,
0.1764739752,
-0.1196748912,
-0.8694599867,
-0.7992045879,
0.1860337853,
0.6425242424,
0.4298075438,
-0.2073944658,
0.1184185818,
0.1351277977,
0.6391660571,
-0.3340446651,
-0.1005150303,
-0.4425274432,
0.6250497699,
-0.0401852764,
-0.3468431532,
-0.4043442011,
-0.3936332762,
0.4933842719,
-0.9193378091,
0.5446660519,
0.114641808,
1.1207010746,
0.2411857992,
-0.2299428433,
-0.0515116192,
-0.6774373651,
0.7395547032,
-0.9119282961,
-0.0334208757,
0.2565728724,
0.4758436978,
-0.5761659741,
-1.0259395838,
-0.4099590778,
-0.5861756206,
-0.3939216137,
0.4231570959,
0.232555896,
0.1836172193,
0.2185059935,
0.5632722974,
-0.829014957,
-0.2499248385,
-0.5182743073,
-0.0887546614,
0.3911315501,
0.486654669,
0.5733667612,
-0.4798177779,
-0.9006566405,
0.2583545148,
-0.8169035912,
-0.2552100122,
-0.2027743012,
0.1395761222,
-0.0013346029,
-0.0326815285,
-0.0355996713,
1.4053235054,
0.1357798576,
-0.4233728349,
-0.1869043112,
-0.3485836685,
-0.5724352002,
-0.1570020765,
0.9174413681,
0.2549753785,
-0.1482067555,
0.0922095031,
0.289880842,
-0.404202342,
0.4543193579,
-0.5698097348,
-0.6131963134,
0.1321304291,
-0.6118544936,
-0.8839150071,
0.2888181508,
-0.7313319445,
-0.4277537763,
-0.3129410744,
0.4210732579,
-0.7463577986,
-0.4766921699,
0.09915822,
-0.1067647263,
0.1667191982,
0.2890458703,
-0.5989255905,
0.0838699937,
0.7043144703,
0.8088003397,
-0.2535443604,
-0.1918374896,
-0.456099689,
0.4035285711,
-0.3946889341,
0.8553068638,
-0.4676727057,
-0.4648685753,
-0.3247765601,
-0.1081894413,
0.0487050526,
-0.8089306951,
0.3978983462,
-0.1841192245,
0.7820308208,
-0.0678332597,
-0.4264784157,
-0.3369123638,
0.2739477158,
-0.4461089671,
0.8348661661,
0.5118424892,
-0.6452718973,
0.6621667743,
-0.9108746052,
-0.3572612107,
0.7152673602,
-0.0456002057,
-0.4152125716,
0.0680690482,
-0.0503206216,
0.2611395419,
-0.6893422604,
0.5526663065,
0.0129813226,
-0.1194596291,
0.0863775983,
-0.0625807568,
0.9223943353,
0.3839725852,
-0.2658869922,
0.4209288359,
-0.8142981529,
0.2897162437,
0.0887722149,
-0.2318785042,
-0.3736662567,
-0.211891979,
-0.0244775172,
0.1335129291,
-0.0351197496,
-0.1240989938,
0.1890729517,
-0.5393815041,
0.4178354144,
0.5887925029,
0.4469030499,
0.2178753316,
-0.5001304746,
0.780025661,
0.2020879984,
0.457513541,
-0.072482653,
-0.5349665284,
-0.7351489067,
-0.2483030111,
0.5028535128,
0.4680151045,
-0.6624959707,
0.3635690212,
-0.1623782367,
-0.6356675029,
-0.1710742265,
-0.068085447,
0.4801078737,
0.9730041623,
0.2730729282,
-0.4406607151,
-0.0747471228,
-0.5266990066,
-0.3473803699,
0.0950025916,
-0.1042181179,
0.3169736862,
-0.0835776851,
-0.1123003736,
0.5660832524,
-0.9305838943,
-0.928342104,
-0.3810008764,
0.2919774652,
-0.0205950644,
0.3952128291,
0.550865829,
-0.3637512028,
-0.9555037022,
0.0294266455,
-0.6240875721,
-0.2736669183,
-0.2709205747,
-0.5488254428,
0.2098186612,
0.0313907526,
-0.1377222687,
0.4019792378,
0.192796424,
-0.2513602376,
0.4560234547,
-0.411133796,
0.1220924109,
-1.2382671833,
0.0846465677,
0.0343353786,
-0.2002484202,
-0.6787775755,
0.5921424031,
0.1127487421,
-0.1314546019,
-0.372887373,
0.2064763755,
-0.5369182229,
0.5332065821,
-0.4066748321,
0.2713950872,
0.0514780208,
0.3143671155,
0.3888492286,
0.3757905066,
0.807525754,
-0.6914399862,
0.7849286199,
-0.0758915022,
-0.0634717122,
0.8479188085,
-0.5235450864,
-0.0472029448,
0.189011693,
0.1338006556,
-0.6270031929,
-0.2465840131,
0.579885602,
-0.4976812899,
0.6482261419,
-0.0471658222,
-0.0473434255,
-0.146802336,
-0.2275628597,
0.162360847,
0.5747559071,
-0.3327642381,
0.7965748906,
0.0272643398,
0.1861504763,
-0.5057255626,
-0.58852458,
0.0643332824,
-0.4312679768,
-0.7238494754,
0.4401672781,
0.3725268543,
0.0784785524,
0.1767583042,
0.1495303214,
0.028509751,
-0.197795257,
0.1801043451,
0.4714873433,
-0.4635582268,
0.3443344831,
-0.1717470586,
-0.5636945367,
0.0808595568,
-0.7456430197,
0.3455586731,
0.3455927968,
0.1304199845,
-0.3912317753,
0.2524609268,
0.081628032,
-0.2642015815,
0.5330473781,
0.8325625658,
-0.3616669774,
-0.8042836189,
-0.2466567457,
-0.4369987547,
-0.4117225707,
0.255733043,
-0.0486252531,
-0.334172219,
0.1266256273,
-0.1670464426,
-0.1500872821,
0.3930855989,
0.5087085962,
0.5014564395,
0.48415488,
0.4662871063,
0.2655047476,
0.5191079378,
-0.3136404753,
0.1653752476,
-0.9753433466,
-0.2561064363,
0.0780088529,
-0.2136266977,
-0.2953796387,
-0.4702056348,
0.7546096444,
-0.1406836212,
0.057871379,
0.2265718877,
-1.0265650749,
0.3138036728,
0.8879942894,
0.612508893,
0.3823516071,
0.0164912269,
0.0235082041,
-0.2269111723,
-0.9488166571,
-0.2824164331,
1.6069654226,
0.0236065835,
0.6073251367,
-0.0809842646,
0.5050526857,
0.2070787698,
0.4826983213,
-0.8550236225,
0.5053676367,
-0.3020011187,
-0.6100341082,
-0.0958911628,
-0.5832073689,
-0.811548233,
0.0154099995,
-0.6367257237,
-0.2620586157,
-0.2152107805,
0.4859035611,
-0.9470863342,
0.0601475574,
-0.7215011716,
0.907905519,
-0.3039010763,
-0.5638008118,
-0.3890040517,
-0.7942790389,
1.0018372536,
-0.0152699677,
-0.2197257131,
0.2813825011,
0.3678232431,
0.6456767321,
-0.6444272995,
0.5271024704,
-0.3620988131,
-0.0179822706,
0.2872907817,
-0.0984785557,
0.2946786582,
0.2755464911,
0.4764887989,
-0.0211621597,
0.0541256219,
-0.1280985624,
-0.751146853,
0.8367040753,
-0.631028831,
-0.7179793119,
-0.6380563974,
-0.5350354314,
-0.0790129751,
0.2106718123,
0.5460993052,
0.3446110189,
0.0205613375,
-0.1632718444,
0.7841402888,
-0.4889053702,
-0.3815802038,
0.8246421814,
-0.2714570165,
-0.4214260876,
0.8500674367,
0.4683970809,
0.6887844205,
0.3048753738,
0.6309189796,
0.1315462589,
-0.466440022,
-0.2054890543,
0.2295188308,
-0.4552054703,
-0.2199817598,
-0.4051111937,
-0.4293265045,
-0.5884876847,
0.1930905581,
0.044023715,
-0.4399554133,
-0.3561340868,
0.0755135417,
0.5203292966,
0.6360911131,
-0.1904703081,
0.4795190394,
-0.6585320234,
0.7144935727,
0.3189970851,
0.3327058852,
0.1197869405,
-0.4533059001,
-0.3466672003,
0.116358161,
-0.6371378303,
-0.8578850031,
0.5362867713,
0.1686600745,
0.3839269578,
0.7626773119,
0.3396882713,
0.8884327412,
-0.3059250414,
1.0408694744,
0.3197020292,
-0.6765218377,
0.7557251453,
-0.2259771526,
0.0095385946,
-0.1156346872,
-0.0153084025,
-0.5524487495,
-0.6330441236,
-0.7071130276,
-0.8652195334,
1.12020576,
-0.2384389937,
-0.1041056886,
0.2557094395,
0.6701764464,
0.0484515056,
-0.283470571,
-0.6552503705,
-0.3149421811,
-0.2879625559,
-0.194027856,
0.3018518686,
-0.3194406033,
-0.3643437326,
-0.0938251019,
0.9414973259,
0.2329195738,
0.3151108027,
0.3781861961,
0.2241198421,
-0.3819967508,
0.0996343344,
0.7740283012,
0.6268137097,
-0.0912447125,
0.0752235502,
0.0657491982,
-0.8853074908,
-0.359924674,
-0.2137752026,
-0.4364332855,
-0.0193759687,
0.2758458257,
0.6046779752,
-0.3437636793,
-0.5049389005,
0.2368288487,
0.121014975,
-0.1905252486,
-0.6817819476,
0.7742828727,
-0.1161633134,
0.0192805436,
0.1769311726,
-0.0481855683,
0.0834141225,
-0.4998895228,
0.0484633297,
0.5342003703,
-0.4842658639,
0.0623904206,
0.9038781524,
0.0679347515,
-0.5262827873,
0.5037921667,
0.0486572124,
-0.4742613435,
0.4253741503,
0.7121855021,
0.7587814927,
-0.2259916961,
0.2401350886,
0.5826410651,
0.1329360604,
0.0848048404,
0.1895170063,
-0.0170233361,
-0.3442688584,
-0.0247103423,
-0.2993826568,
-0.2386337072,
0.2808944285,
-0.829171598,
0.67056638,
-0.5563021898,
-0.3712096214,
-0.0166950803,
0.1457125396,
-0.1433432996,
0.4238641858,
-0.463970542,
0.6122761369,
-0.4013417661,
0.9202205539,
0.5490893722,
-0.5350277424,
-1.1721360683,
0.2346414477,
-0.0562915877,
-0.9094831347,
0.5848215818,
-0.3538586795,
-0.0098187542,
-0.0543196648,
-0.5770071149,
-0.4363534153,
1.4275273085,
0.1160578951,
-0.2913645804,
0.1454908997,
0.1442748457,
0.5945659876,
-0.4203444719,
0.0821182132,
0.3491643965,
0.4795331359,
0.2344905287,
-0.6677442789,
0.2328853756,
-0.1740649194,
0.1775797457,
0.4137579203,
-0.5761912465,
0.7720426917,
-0.1983761042,
-0.4204590917,
0.0214137286,
0.2404323816,
0.2274125814,
0.1394021362,
0.1803986877,
0.557703793,
0.5914669037,
-0.2491313815,
0.8135869503,
-0.791111052,
0.121233277,
1.0846138,
-0.141760245,
0.5351949334,
0.1997096688,
-0.203151539,
0.5247139931,
0.6000426412,
-0.1616917849,
0.3352898359,
0.2429794818,
-0.4713793695,
-0.3284298182,
0.0826201662,
-0.7488016486,
0.0214145072,
0.283082515,
-0.8123255968,
0.1734571606,
0.0121287424,
0.2322497964,
0.1265671402,
-0.2806628644,
1.1565257311,
0.0248802155,
-0.9024963379,
0.7280498743,
0.2724463344,
0.3823560476,
-1.0795042515,
-0.1211490706,
-0.1448922604,
0.1969167143,
-0.5105972886,
-0.3541925251,
0.3715519011,
-0.298224777,
-0.2510154247,
0.1744797379,
0.7946334481,
-0.605607152,
-0.5880491138,
-0.0617306307,
0.0934685841,
0.098752439,
0.1123621687,
-0.5047525167,
-0.6791124344,
0.0703995675,
-0.0623105578,
0.2435318232,
0.5261810422,
-0.0438244715,
0.5433501601,
0.7423439026,
0.7867113948,
0.0548284315,
-0.2018463016,
0.5139403343,
-0.6648433805,
-0.4334430397,
-0.7492883801,
0.4460177422,
-0.1137246341,
-0.2497684509,
0.6505266428,
0.1919167489,
0.3572326601,
-0.3294140399,
0.8350152969,
0.1120922267,
0.7299101949,
-0.5947480798,
1.0625730753,
-0.5296610594,
0.3675290942,
-0.1764104813,
-0.5721716881,
-0.6216078997,
0.7952028513,
-0.200982675,
-0.0488883704,
0.7852202654,
0.7576370835,
0.1519846171,
0.0978774503,
0.168676123,
0.2573487461,
0.1350766867,
1.1512249708,
0.5799660683,
-0.3039405942,
0.2513880432,
-0.2588637471,
-0.4255859554,
-0.1258404255,
-0.722279191,
-0.7624726892,
-0.2357302159,
-0.3693450689,
-0.5826274157,
0.0303049237,
1.1523009539,
0.7510032654,
-0.6667968631,
-0.1211977452,
-0.3335454464,
0.2799236178,
-0.7362932563,
-0.3540766239,
0.4713020623,
-0.4927725494,
-0.5599722862,
-0.0915001556,
0.3230755627,
-0.0468383394,
-0.4853891432,
-0.1364422441,
0.3087158501,
-0.1510538012,
0.3466446102,
-0.1683521569,
-0.7917390466,
-0.0565836318,
0.1412145048,
-0.0368674845,
0.0505618155,
0.9574739933,
-0.8980358243,
0.8457069397,
0.3918176889,
-0.1083018631,
0.2265209407,
-0.0317716189,
1.0708620548,
-0.2659459114,
0.0007481257,
0.1454027593,
0.1355362236,
-0.0814395472,
-0.7939571738,
0.5089302063,
0.4465661049,
-0.4613716304,
-0.683424294,
0.4377238452,
-1.0247226954,
-0.2600554228,
1.0917921066,
-0.4816800952,
-0.1075376347,
-0.135154292,
-0.583689034,
0.2692983747,
-0.0757020339,
1.0943804979,
0.4780826867,
-0.2237791419,
-0.3112256229,
-0.5673643947,
0.706972301,
0.3038999736,
-0.5787056684,
0.1606746614,
0.5234557986,
0.628613472,
0.1495226473,
0.5895036459,
-0.3042109609,
0.4945962131,
-0.0096174954,
-0.0380886085,
-0.5060296059,
-0.0722841695,
0.0497498401,
0.2896772027,
0.128678754,
-0.1399122775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17301v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17301v1
|
Language Models: A Guide for the Perplexed
| 2023-11-29T01:19:02 | 2023-11-29T01:19:02 |
Sofia Serrano, Zander Brumbaugh, Noah A. Smith
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Given the growing importance of AI literacy, we decided to write this
tutorial to help narrow the gap between the discourse among those who study
language models -- the core technology underlying ChatGPT and similar products
-- and those who are intrigued and want to learn more about them. In short, we
believe the perspective of researchers and educators can add some clarity to
the public's understanding of the technologies beyond what's currently
available, which tends to be either extremely technical or promotional material
generated about products by their purveyors.
Our approach teases apart the concept of a language model from products built
on them, from the behaviors attributed to or desired from those products, and
from claims about similarity to human cognition. As a starting point, we (1)
offer a scientific viewpoint that focuses on questions amenable to study
through experimentation; (2) situate language models as they are today in the
context of the research that led to their development; and (3) describe the
boundaries of what is known about the models at this writing.
|
[
-0.3064052463,
-1.0543444157,
0.4999341369,
-0.0419750996,
0.1356188804,
0.4447608292,
0.010670891,
-0.2977581024,
-0.2671715021,
0.6252661943,
-0.498914361,
-0.2756825387,
-0.6051200628,
-0.1698110253,
-0.7271115184,
0.8305631876,
0.2253705412,
-0.0284105055,
-0.1474860311,
0.405293107,
-0.2078642845,
-0.686293602,
-0.6409802437,
-0.4806423485,
0.5526708364,
0.5259414911,
0.8970869184,
0.5920986533,
0.3631379604,
0.3010522723,
-0.3611961007,
-0.3001548648,
-0.4464527071,
0.0553319715,
0.2144052237,
-0.5331004858,
-0.2759630978,
0.1160792038,
0.4045793116,
1.0263727903,
0.0312049426,
0.080624789,
0.1881981194,
0.4353801608,
-0.1906962097,
0.281108886,
-0.3621081412,
0.1254042238,
-0.2988654077,
-0.0321856067,
-0.6362152696,
-0.1152046248,
0.3766390681,
-0.6981419921,
0.2936993539,
0.1302934587,
0.8657826781,
0.1412529051,
-0.4629792571,
-0.1882118583,
-1.0503319502,
0.670550704,
-0.6699504256,
0.4570103884,
0.5202379227,
0.3178317547,
-0.1861507595,
-0.7229949832,
-0.7427613139,
-0.4160783589,
0.0491947308,
-0.2417184114,
0.0265006125,
0.1551207155,
0.4052461386,
0.2265293449,
-0.7479469776,
-0.1104311645,
-0.5681111217,
-0.1293735951,
0.5393815041,
-0.1084122732,
0.6306610703,
0.0771724284,
-0.2542642951,
0.0337460339,
-0.863327086,
-0.0620247275,
0.3950840533,
0.2815014422,
-0.1042993963,
0.5376191139,
0.1448456645,
0.5235171318,
-0.2620997131,
-0.1548154354,
0.1568390727,
0.0769800916,
-0.1497045159,
-0.1632676274,
0.5302267075,
0.0476310812,
0.5222640038,
-0.231268242,
-0.008088598,
-0.0533819571,
0.2440241277,
-0.5669836998,
-0.3025770783,
0.0019718842,
-0.3911122978,
-0.1236003488,
-0.1657253355,
-0.5285365582,
-0.6305154562,
-0.3626289666,
0.2183132321,
-0.3682435155,
-0.5360772014,
0.0849734843,
-0.0591407046,
0.3222282231,
0.3026447296,
-1.068382144,
0.5004327297,
0.8742439151,
0.6491054893,
0.1688257009,
-0.1547369659,
0.2131006271,
-0.0047614994,
-0.2314347774,
0.9415529966,
-0.8969108462,
-0.8594549298,
0.2163933367,
-0.2286937833,
0.0042210552,
-0.3160947859,
0.3913864791,
-0.5435352325,
0.545055151,
-0.3173398376,
-0.6847916842,
-0.5716831684,
0.3399812877,
-0.4566824138,
0.6755917668,
-0.0085966121,
-0.7402341962,
-0.0471376292,
-0.9230901003,
-0.2478649169,
0.3358183801,
-0.3426061869,
0.2096750587,
0.0120213367,
-0.0321511403,
-0.001191028,
-0.4867795706,
0.2720042467,
-0.0891757533,
-0.1784560829,
0.2296816558,
-0.612698257,
0.9447385073,
0.3958101869,
-0.0531869046,
0.0401017331,
-0.5457977057,
-0.3784532547,
0.0746607706,
-0.2687954009,
-0.2792470455,
0.255595088,
0.1879859269,
-0.0368279517,
0.211515516,
-0.451007247,
0.354059875,
-0.44243747,
0.7544654608,
0.6579283476,
-0.3399659097,
0.575620234,
-0.3671744168,
0.7524699569,
-0.1733549982,
0.4677292407,
-0.5323024392,
-0.748588264,
-0.8494189978,
0.0878719762,
0.3300669491,
0.567142427,
-0.386071384,
0.0610419884,
0.2333688587,
-0.6025894284,
-0.6923837066,
0.023790393,
0.3682357073,
0.9003505111,
0.1428086162,
-0.2179580778,
-0.355477035,
-0.9253464341,
-0.2767247856,
-0.4220427871,
-0.0362276323,
0.4335318208,
0.4417219162,
-0.1198461056,
0.9547134638,
-0.5477226377,
0.2546265721,
-0.1847869754,
0.2058414966,
0.0973103717,
0.4648340344,
0.2299765199,
-0.9509087205,
-0.595839262,
0.0354035795,
-0.6114500761,
0.0370103084,
0.1798443645,
0.0178391915,
-0.1401845962,
0.7987231016,
-0.55360955,
0.2269840389,
0.2809267938,
-0.3463095725,
0.6154350042,
0.0732308477,
0.032386899,
-1.1282600164,
0.1681249589,
0.0577058569,
0.0360994302,
-1.0176069736,
0.032212913,
-0.3920411468,
-0.273891151,
-0.3757273555,
0.8460411429,
-0.2822894752,
0.1887466311,
-0.1825183183,
0.3176882863,
-0.1890114099,
0.1648560613,
-0.0534844324,
0.8965696096,
0.7395070791,
-0.506670773,
0.0998766571,
0.4553821087,
-0.3488616943,
0.1364080161,
-0.8111227155,
0.2841842771,
-0.2255811542,
-0.0971168727,
-0.9995719194,
-0.1855168492,
0.4899961948,
-0.7367885113,
0.2513096631,
-0.2724461257,
-0.1616254449,
-0.2326699644,
0.2926879227,
0.5016388893,
0.7051569223,
-0.2628005743,
0.6852698922,
0.7939804792,
-0.4712870419,
-0.6200010777,
-0.7844083905,
0.0055064796,
-0.2042054832,
-0.6311972737,
0.1234396696,
-0.3847685456,
-0.6885715127,
-0.1395798922,
0.0557487831,
-0.4538294971,
0.3515096009,
0.2689274251,
0.1885251105,
-0.5649974942,
0.3769984841,
-0.147462517,
-0.2388754189,
0.1539979279,
-0.2018410861,
0.6446540952,
-0.1048904881,
-0.4763359427,
-0.455211103,
0.2214026302,
0.3406448066,
-0.1833682954,
0.4120359421,
0.206476897,
-0.2946474254,
0.003150004,
-0.5177844167,
-0.3011109829,
-0.5311598778,
0.3544190526,
-0.3011073768,
-1.0027090311,
0.4491410851,
-0.0511655286,
0.0395049155,
0.2235212624,
0.4523366094,
-0.0926747546,
1.0849325657,
1.0793898106,
0.0102122705,
0.6817251444,
-0.0419855677,
0.6881996393,
-0.607562542,
-0.4035233259,
-0.8486403227,
0.1668607593,
-0.4686052203,
-0.3018112779,
0.0288393684,
-0.0746705383,
-0.5997998714,
0.0794720501,
-0.6334890127,
0.5051725507,
0.7965918779,
-0.1444191337,
0.348860383,
-0.0295549314,
-0.141888231,
0.0862422362,
-0.7991780043,
-0.9454504251,
1.0441925526,
0.4872763157,
0.7102280855,
-0.1314171106,
0.3526118696,
0.3628409207,
0.3217207491,
-0.6641414165,
0.56249547,
0.0228800494,
-0.859501183,
-0.122952193,
-0.0679041594,
-0.7969498634,
0.0374876857,
-0.0269805584,
-0.8736669421,
-0.0001697348,
0.3005942702,
-0.2761965692,
0.2121281922,
-1.0140194893,
1.0677660704,
-0.2586645484,
-0.0806732625,
-0.1661574692,
-0.7339628935,
0.4288569689,
0.2274690568,
0.6274276376,
-0.2728539705,
0.1384655684,
0.6661770344,
-0.2708079517,
0.8952386379,
0.0392611623,
-0.1013050154,
0.3785049617,
0.1064245999,
-0.1633009017,
-0.2874819636,
0.0477470309,
-0.0843692496,
-0.0075180805,
-0.4788371921,
-0.4964382052,
0.3730227947,
-0.8420038819,
-1.0053324699,
-0.2628850937,
-0.7028124332,
-0.0903355926,
0.2986446917,
-0.1154441833,
0.4826236665,
-0.4199838638,
-0.0581603982,
0.7576563954,
-0.2401032448,
0.256790489,
0.4782343209,
-0.3712902665,
0.281850934,
0.8937551975,
-0.119063884,
0.2590691149,
0.5624366999,
0.2257847488,
-0.340726167,
-0.4294053912,
-0.1668777317,
0.3131546676,
-0.7513223886,
0.421266675,
-0.4504306912,
-0.370759517,
-0.5589603186,
-0.0399844721,
-0.2916839421,
-0.3398935199,
-0.3141968846,
0.0836842805,
0.2813649774,
1.1789941788,
0.3138117194,
0.6624839306,
-0.6193932891,
-0.1000411659,
0.2980164289,
0.0923222974,
-0.054685235,
-0.6411175132,
-0.1375863403,
0.2661274374,
-0.2591265142,
-0.8429243565,
0.2872040868,
-0.0171699747,
0.5705874562,
0.5344170332,
-0.1165592819,
0.4292217195,
-0.5022724867,
0.9718453884,
-0.0012223325,
-0.9942473769,
0.4831721485,
-0.2565288842,
0.0936238393,
0.102216512,
0.5082315207,
-0.8324793577,
-0.4360985458,
-0.6874858141,
-0.8013698459,
0.3885476589,
0.0143797947,
0.4438889027,
0.2255232483,
0.2944433987,
0.191992417,
0.3365480602,
-0.6481512189,
-0.3523719013,
-0.3426977992,
-0.2746104002,
-0.111346215,
-0.330698669,
-0.0484262705,
-0.0299303588,
0.6606571078,
0.0005307305,
0.0793425068,
0.0068817362,
-0.1263363957,
0.2153274566,
0.2484701723,
0.5115782619,
0.5825193524,
0.1020335034,
0.2028159946,
-0.403170526,
-0.5500867367,
-0.1360024661,
0.2022475153,
-0.4180957377,
-0.2869223952,
0.2413906157,
0.7555454969,
-0.0332221501,
-0.8039131761,
0.3054413497,
-0.1718828678,
-0.0265605655,
-0.2008730918,
0.0976813585,
0.3071201742,
0.5207006335,
0.3468577862,
0.0979157761,
0.0469451323,
-0.5663542747,
0.063958846,
0.4084756076,
-0.3762162626,
-0.4770795405,
0.6526081562,
0.511303544,
-0.9295588732,
0.6666143537,
0.0055241757,
-0.5745219588,
0.5597282648,
0.5220022798,
0.858894527,
-0.3086207807,
0.348246336,
0.087567471,
0.341789484,
-0.1041371971,
0.0403702967,
-0.1696943641,
-1.022821784,
-0.2559685111,
-0.3962451518,
-0.5600060225,
0.1305464059,
-0.2545251548,
0.2769467831,
-0.3997586071,
-0.1655978113,
0.3256382346,
-0.0562682599,
-0.4015963078,
-0.0408862755,
0.3924029171,
0.9954260588,
-0.9705777764,
0.8468360901,
0.7283833623,
-0.7673878074,
-0.8020957708,
0.148777023,
0.0836551711,
-0.826892674,
0.4755342007,
-0.0151684089,
-0.0947274193,
0.1989636719,
-0.7879494429,
-0.8434595466,
0.6515704989,
0.4794577658,
-0.3990353942,
-0.4000018239,
0.0685304776,
0.4943338037,
-0.4302932322,
0.5049276948,
0.6290454865,
0.5614013076,
0.0814180002,
-0.8769130111,
-0.3118391037,
-0.5843649507,
-0.1808474362,
-0.275806278,
-0.2948845029,
1.0141750574,
-0.1619654447,
-0.2608236074,
0.2435864806,
0.3931575418,
-0.0155182239,
0.1589910686,
0.1351542771,
-0.0468300432,
0.6964464188,
-0.0711064711,
0.9485077858,
-0.4698585868,
0.2360689938,
1.042057991,
-0.0053806477,
0.7021626234,
0.5094370842,
-0.238954857,
0.5380259156,
0.7082607746,
-0.0651805028,
0.130953446,
0.1805752963,
-0.3121624589,
-0.1470357478,
-0.3781908453,
-0.3582787514,
0.2956104279,
0.4744780958,
-0.3434993327,
-0.1144723743,
-0.1034547761,
0.1680036634,
0.3928354084,
-0.0848103762,
0.6336452365,
0.1929437667,
-0.6235284209,
0.3885035515,
-0.2944131792,
0.2988162935,
-0.456959188,
-0.042608209,
-0.2899349928,
0.0652963445,
-0.0137351742,
-0.7565473318,
0.236815989,
0.0449928977,
-0.1363139749,
-0.3109720647,
0.7103408575,
-0.5149761438,
-0.3306359649,
0.169142589,
0.6824182272,
0.441793263,
0.0876215175,
-0.8776594996,
0.0658420324,
0.1110999808,
-0.2345044315,
-0.0956954286,
0.19353351,
0.1323144883,
1.0528899431,
0.4142981768,
-0.0924120843,
0.0752463415,
0.1272291839,
0.7952283025,
-0.7190754414,
-0.289037466,
-0.7741763592,
0.5761765242,
0.1297511011,
-0.4739343822,
0.6861257553,
0.4875103831,
0.9398763776,
-0.014275888,
1.1317886114,
-0.0796243399,
0.4992640913,
-0.2212525904,
0.9625014067,
-0.4744099379,
0.3866840303,
-0.1032156497,
-0.550219059,
-0.4786500931,
0.7423880696,
-0.411488682,
0.1982094795,
0.5325675011,
0.9855601192,
0.172219485,
0.2868682444,
0.3040841818,
0.6296473145,
0.3830649257,
0.1607631147,
1.0802941322,
-0.1625850499,
0.4508228302,
-0.105157949,
-0.2349521369,
-0.1968322247,
-0.7240559459,
-0.9058698416,
-0.7289280891,
-0.2649298012,
-0.0355935246,
0.2134928405,
0.8072817922,
0.816737473,
-0.6908711791,
-0.6098208427,
-0.4107269943,
0.4772752523,
0.1473051459,
-0.1429064125,
0.0418877788,
-0.4206464887,
-0.958681047,
0.2547389865,
0.0555729531,
0.1710682511,
-0.5933337212,
-0.0046234676,
-0.1474962384,
0.2597928047,
0.4231244028,
0.5650423169,
-0.8326421976,
-0.141380161,
0.1705547422,
0.0555073097,
0.1549467742,
0.8751699924,
-0.6830759048,
0.4762066305,
0.3914282322,
0.4427365065,
0.3955481946,
-0.224690035,
0.8835966587,
-0.3482534587,
0.3120130599,
0.4774653316,
0.0777747631,
0.5710959435,
-0.003586791,
0.293422997,
0.2103683203,
-0.6860128641,
-0.9483759999,
0.5547125936,
-0.7055486441,
-0.3867650032,
0.9784713984,
-0.11129684,
-0.3475462496,
-0.3058148623,
-0.394336313,
0.3430563211,
-0.3312254846,
0.9242635369,
0.6939780712,
-0.0716635361,
-0.304826051,
-0.6762951016,
0.6538289785,
0.1215300635,
-0.6167666912,
0.1938188523,
0.1012991741,
0.324829787,
0.2622789145,
0.5789601803,
-0.1309423596,
0.026372781,
0.3526187539,
0.2409921587,
0.0877564102,
-0.3743131757,
-0.1935225278,
0.0615059286,
0.5893524289,
0.0491460077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17295v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17295v1
|
Elo Uncovered: Robustness and Best Practices in Language Model Evaluation
| 2023-11-29T00:45:23 | 2023-11-29T00:45:23 |
Meriem Boubdir, Edward Kim, Beyza Ermis, Sara Hooker, Marzieh Fadaee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In Natural Language Processing (NLP), the Elo rating system, originally
designed for ranking players in dynamic games such as chess, is increasingly
being used to evaluate Large Language Models (LLMs) through "A vs B" paired
comparisons. However, while popular, the system's suitability for assessing
entities with constant skill levels, such as LLMs, remains relatively
unexplored. We study two fundamental axioms that evaluation methods should
adhere to: reliability and transitivity. We conduct extensive evaluation of Elo
behaviour, illustrating that individual Elo computations exhibit volatility and
delving into the impact of varying the Elo rating system's hyperparameters. We
show that these axioms are not always satisfied raising questions about the
reliability of current comparative evaluations of LLMs. If the current use of
Elo scores is intended to substitute the costly head-to-head comparison of
LLMs, it is crucial to ensure the ranking is as robust as possible. Guided by
the axioms, our findings offer concrete guidelines for enhancing the
reliability of LLM evaluation methods, suggesting a need for reassessment of
existing comparative approaches.
|
[
-0.1412006319,
-0.637822032,
0.6983553767,
0.4719558954,
-0.1428814381,
0.1380905658,
-0.439075321,
-0.8710690141,
-0.0753270164,
0.4652741253,
-0.1813404709,
-0.6681385636,
-0.5761761665,
0.0727222115,
-0.5198249221,
0.8608017564,
0.3470400274,
-0.2395908386,
-0.6822525263,
-0.3947384059,
-0.5378937125,
-0.5509902835,
-0.5080267191,
-0.4632249177,
0.3281849921,
0.115245007,
1.2039581537,
0.815808773,
0.9513135552,
0.3845253289,
-0.4227309227,
0.0589576922,
-0.3343580663,
0.5297763348,
-0.085513629,
-0.4391293824,
-0.6622801423,
-0.2159843892,
0.5396227241,
0.786288619,
-0.3521806002,
-0.0651036501,
0.1435277611,
0.7485829592,
-0.6687989235,
0.0354897827,
-0.8640348911,
-0.1697497368,
-0.1681184322,
0.0580090359,
-0.5704602599,
-0.3095052242,
0.4880792797,
-0.7612797618,
-0.2424133271,
0.0825911984,
0.8696312308,
0.1938622743,
-0.2810534537,
-0.5058892369,
-0.9597412348,
1.2437241077,
-0.7629345059,
0.3191302717,
0.4562726021,
0.3485041261,
0.0950895101,
-0.4338739216,
-0.2216254175,
-0.5932865739,
-0.0341193043,
-0.0254045743,
-0.1271079928,
0.2101639509,
0.1129363626,
0.5171004534,
-0.6275048256,
0.4266102314,
0.1322387606,
-0.1389797777,
0.6635739803,
0.1284820288,
0.2217849642,
0.0065167691,
-0.3073438108,
-0.0553994477,
-0.6621926427,
-0.1244517714,
0.644452095,
0.1951944381,
0.3019896746,
0.3309651911,
0.0785016194,
0.5433706641,
-0.2815836966,
-0.050509017,
0.3591551781,
-0.4611232579,
-0.058764983,
-0.4373120368,
0.6859036684,
0.6537279487,
0.286007911,
-0.5847007632,
-0.5275387764,
0.1091374978,
0.3588611484,
-0.3377356231,
-0.0315968581,
0.260176748,
-0.4570685625,
-0.4442380071,
-0.1166929305,
-0.7500877976,
-0.1511108279,
0.0855798796,
0.5418817401,
-0.2334988266,
-0.2549393177,
0.0240530372,
-0.0496492274,
0.3703435659,
0.3121745288,
-0.9160277843,
0.6168300509,
0.9930940866,
0.8113024831,
-0.5767447352,
-0.357851088,
-0.3550819457,
-0.2199757248,
-0.3206263185,
0.9476341605,
-0.5235960484,
-0.3735238314,
0.3548100591,
-0.3470157981,
0.1395177096,
-0.7613300085,
1.0862393379,
-0.5167863369,
0.0791675895,
-0.2076554,
-0.5918413401,
0.176311031,
0.4179532826,
-0.7061436772,
1.041238904,
-0.1983708888,
-0.6639792919,
0.4477801621,
-0.4259472191,
-0.4057436883,
0.0808167085,
0.3766550124,
-0.5192230344,
0.1452501714,
0.1061258018,
0.0503269657,
-0.1946439743,
0.021889586,
-0.5488070846,
-0.4762963057,
0.1685595512,
-0.4809418917,
0.6156513095,
0.0378901474,
-0.0096738674,
-0.1107899025,
-0.8162088394,
0.1666983962,
-0.0962823629,
-0.4046644866,
-0.7487403154,
0.5260891914,
0.018349532,
0.0400061794,
0.2944995761,
-0.3275226355,
0.0373250879,
-0.8934819698,
0.309843123,
0.9097023606,
-0.1624020189,
0.4416723847,
-0.5175077319,
0.3861878812,
-0.6552237868,
0.2512870431,
-0.1259328127,
-0.4447826743,
-0.7465180159,
-0.0663178191,
0.2467162609,
0.5618025661,
-0.3996174037,
0.5733588934,
-0.3949693441,
-0.6370599866,
-0.3158734739,
0.1575576961,
0.3470022082,
0.2386268079,
0.2223497629,
-0.2430900335,
-0.3712467253,
-0.8046060205,
-0.4849493206,
-0.6075252295,
0.0070941565,
0.176297918,
0.4281024039,
-0.0741764829,
0.4573180377,
0.0394123532,
0.0551420674,
-0.2267599851,
0.2984886765,
0.2436927259,
0.2442539036,
0.6300054193,
-0.340294987,
-0.2450276166,
-0.0445588045,
-0.6184239984,
-0.3540263474,
0.0977665782,
-0.086564891,
0.1223177016,
0.1693932712,
-0.4823420346,
0.2017443627,
0.6012536287,
-0.2348709106,
0.42651999,
-0.2191575468,
-0.0108450036,
-0.5219658017,
0.0489804596,
-0.1191378832,
-0.3354910612,
-0.5049538016,
0.4099054337,
-0.4803448915,
0.374519974,
-0.3321557045,
0.4426027834,
-0.2569463551,
-0.347976923,
-0.4341031611,
0.2753699422,
0.0979463831,
0.0439499691,
-0.1619373262,
0.555325985,
0.5406908393,
-0.7198151946,
0.4383787811,
0.1135240868,
-0.3971906602,
0.7052764297,
-0.9949147105,
0.4324754477,
0.0657105595,
-0.4209275544,
-0.9754452109,
0.408092767,
-0.4247753918,
-0.3629057407,
0.2585147619,
-0.0892113298,
-0.6261916757,
-0.2872747779,
-0.5826400518,
0.2931438386,
0.5737578273,
-0.3863708377,
0.4306226969,
0.5907229185,
0.0023649964,
-0.8904176354,
-0.4425515234,
0.0986842066,
-0.3241085112,
-0.7170289755,
0.2939705849,
-0.2287228703,
-0.5435630083,
-0.0111309104,
-0.2457965016,
-0.0347624049,
0.5580952764,
0.103808336,
0.119336769,
-0.0795747563,
0.0571935028,
-0.1588215381,
-0.0665972456,
0.308725208,
-0.0135169961,
0.2947946787,
-0.3750267923,
-0.3962842524,
0.0437518358,
0.2505646944,
0.8451164365,
-0.1513424665,
0.5562360287,
0.1917714924,
-0.4896431267,
-0.3544778526,
-0.3529949188,
-0.0588896982,
-0.4538999498,
0.4166253507,
-0.0607251562,
-0.6648848057,
0.8067799807,
0.0469173156,
0.4377453029,
0.5818765163,
0.7315351963,
-0.1951291412,
1.1867209673,
0.8026415706,
0.0846558511,
0.3042269051,
0.0730481893,
0.0150863007,
-0.6860504746,
-0.1763462871,
-0.8819315434,
-0.2073972672,
-0.7857285142,
-0.0056266231,
0.1537279338,
-0.1300614476,
-0.0442171469,
0.3131498694,
-0.2831690013,
0.6611220241,
0.2833771706,
-0.2077420652,
0.5874220729,
-0.0959649757,
-0.4766518474,
-0.2714549005,
-0.5450816154,
-0.8087287545,
1.1796598434,
0.5481696725,
0.7915599346,
0.258077234,
0.4577530921,
0.6007258296,
0.4523239434,
-1.1116614342,
0.5820342302,
-0.0213136207,
-0.5406223536,
-0.4817032516,
-0.3434861004,
-1.1005220413,
0.2157882899,
-0.4664414227,
-0.8216915727,
0.0104245273,
0.0286024902,
-0.1495086998,
0.0141420113,
-0.3508835137,
0.7176916599,
-0.2918291688,
-0.5480630994,
-0.1154475659,
-0.485260129,
0.2313377708,
0.0406254828,
0.3379657567,
-0.0185651835,
-0.0006999443,
0.76420331,
-0.6255845428,
0.3257900178,
0.3213537037,
-0.0108424192,
0.1560642868,
0.3159816265,
0.3125528395,
0.0362731814,
-0.3387755454,
0.2085338384,
0.1292401254,
-0.2332394421,
-0.7761841416,
0.9425970316,
-0.7679501176,
-0.5011276007,
-0.7345579863,
-0.4631847441,
-0.2742789388,
0.100251317,
0.0102064908,
0.0537620746,
-0.2975204587,
0.4532391727,
0.6578066945,
-0.1572192162,
0.4907626808,
0.40161255,
-0.330747962,
-0.4690071642,
0.7178970575,
0.0957309753,
0.438203007,
0.4346360564,
0.3024430573,
-0.288467586,
-0.6481326222,
-0.1032866016,
0.2106459737,
-0.8296494484,
-0.0991454571,
-0.2130907029,
-0.0493574999,
0.1115922257,
-0.0881542712,
-0.7362381816,
-0.4096015394,
0.2105247527,
-0.3130196035,
0.0302648395,
0.7646573186,
-0.0155500947,
0.0682671741,
-0.6231702566,
-0.1478231102,
0.4091700315,
0.4045796692,
-0.0693486258,
-0.6845937371,
-0.3709619343,
-0.2796242237,
-0.3559479713,
-0.8415312171,
0.2820923924,
0.2417670041,
0.9920115471,
0.3069250882,
-0.0893512368,
0.3842920363,
-0.4861240685,
0.7241636515,
-0.2621314824,
-1.133326292,
0.5064057708,
-0.2221799195,
-0.0517955087,
0.6493436098,
0.2057572752,
-0.2784830928,
-0.6559545994,
-0.5339542627,
-1.0846116543,
0.2916528881,
0.4343942404,
0.2712618113,
-0.0708926693,
0.2509005964,
0.1434316337,
0.3361209035,
-0.9420551658,
-0.2809642553,
0.0271889884,
-0.0725656152,
0.2358435243,
-0.3059269488,
-0.0052272109,
0.0902964771,
0.4903203845,
0.2222856879,
0.2476506978,
-0.0553494543,
-0.1890909523,
-0.1572882086,
0.2814005613,
0.5111184716,
0.9972330928,
-0.4251221716,
0.1886965036,
0.150260374,
-0.4470430613,
0.0466467068,
-0.2269598693,
-0.4473189712,
0.2105460316,
0.7720044851,
0.5178496242,
0.177709341,
-0.7492488623,
0.6565569639,
-0.0078568645,
-0.0138356732,
-0.1544489413,
-0.0788714737,
-0.2775918841,
-0.1674931794,
0.2272921354,
0.0151386308,
0.2117514014,
-0.7657923102,
0.300049901,
0.6013203859,
-0.2896331549,
-0.4330252409,
0.5981308222,
0.2213817388,
-0.5122810006,
0.5121420622,
-0.0694601238,
-0.4956176579,
0.4725938439,
0.4470465183,
0.7817292213,
-0.3392167091,
0.1367653161,
0.1648874581,
0.9969021678,
-0.3747885823,
0.2058292925,
0.1782187372,
-0.7307410836,
-0.6978241205,
-0.5329568982,
-0.807128489,
0.2518214285,
-0.7509323359,
0.3303221166,
-0.3840728998,
-0.3318838477,
-0.2751695216,
0.0855115578,
-0.6348542571,
0.0221642256,
0.1979952306,
0.7143815756,
-1.0777469873,
0.410453707,
0.6954263449,
-0.2478687614,
-0.3239597082,
-0.0179287754,
-0.3182029426,
-0.6712501049,
0.385145396,
-0.0273052249,
-0.0418346114,
-0.5034965277,
-0.3772587478,
-0.7614918947,
0.8923783302,
0.4224893451,
-0.5088390112,
-0.0852582231,
-0.0118523194,
0.9365598559,
-0.1856503785,
0.6669101715,
0.3878218234,
0.4399508536,
0.0133169144,
-1.1500767469,
-0.152636826,
-0.0973041505,
-0.0182350911,
0.0146861114,
-0.5484348536,
0.4704090357,
-0.0805177093,
-0.1119896695,
0.2482142001,
0.5957906842,
0.2709356844,
0.4990572631,
0.5732898712,
0.7541629076,
0.8087502718,
-0.2727487087,
1.0304236412,
-0.3729454875,
0.5480341911,
0.8130916357,
-0.5138018727,
0.9837985039,
0.4168947637,
-0.2029132098,
0.5889381766,
0.2614542842,
0.1535811424,
0.5874159336,
0.3528827727,
0.1148828715,
-0.3892199099,
0.0506797619,
-0.04180599,
0.5844436288,
0.3565750122,
-0.3796170354,
-0.2475432456,
-0.2365528047,
0.0836654752,
0.3974441588,
-0.2556856573,
0.5704736114,
0.1185792387,
-0.6060667038,
0.323468864,
-0.0018259378,
0.5381193757,
-0.5592306852,
-0.0823052973,
-0.282428354,
-0.0947720036,
-0.1254869699,
-0.8322771788,
0.5339379907,
0.052958671,
0.0084672766,
-0.1907067299,
0.6882798672,
-0.0202395394,
-0.4667170048,
0.4642657042,
0.7725238204,
0.0582896098,
0.2125248164,
-0.6239103079,
0.3141666353,
-0.5816031694,
-0.3677083254,
0.2335538715,
0.4367434084,
0.113780871,
0.9199746847,
0.625197053,
0.2779264152,
-0.1101397499,
0.0617500581,
0.6220545173,
-0.3758356273,
-0.2001996934,
-1.0581542253,
0.2558312714,
-0.1203290299,
-0.3237499595,
0.9305132627,
0.4380720556,
0.7755803466,
0.3623268604,
0.5617973804,
0.5164503455,
0.3768015802,
-0.5693490505,
0.5522818565,
-0.3933871388,
0.8905287981,
-0.5335324407,
-1.1903389692,
-0.5448415875,
0.9076892138,
-0.3033193052,
0.0909643397,
0.8302696347,
0.4638569355,
0.2732043564,
-0.3801112473,
0.6328042746,
0.2129586637,
0.3826115727,
0.469442457,
1.026438117,
-0.4922998846,
0.7323668599,
-0.0627243444,
-0.0780098215,
-0.1590538174,
-1.2258363962,
-0.8142544627,
-0.2271722108,
-0.4631873369,
-0.4983834028,
0.259898752,
0.7673124671,
0.5637440085,
-0.5420119762,
-0.3665780127,
0.0259603672,
0.6665171385,
-0.6594664454,
-0.2147408575,
0.2681295574,
-0.1934516579,
-0.8403307796,
0.2999310791,
0.547398448,
-0.3110737503,
-0.4482503235,
-0.0609244555,
0.1126572639,
0.367377907,
0.6275359988,
0.260391295,
-0.6232610941,
-0.5405507088,
0.3709030151,
-0.0723326579,
0.0997280478,
0.4461590648,
-0.5774675608,
0.5600795746,
0.7010390162,
0.727547586,
-0.1166304722,
0.0001062136,
0.533731699,
-0.494274348,
-0.2760781944,
0.5028313398,
0.3749447763,
0.4138402045,
0.0045099384,
0.3607447445,
0.4033577144,
-0.9761739373,
-1.1489086151,
0.2558053136,
-1.0307112932,
0.2195356786,
1.1845254898,
-0.2329466492,
-0.1805320978,
-0.155119583,
0.2904796302,
-0.2994570434,
-0.2193077803,
0.9015007615,
1.1080231667,
0.014069682,
-0.1083083898,
-0.6181721091,
0.2921431959,
0.4798786044,
-0.5882676244,
-0.1279022396,
0.1371307969,
0.1490764022,
0.3093573153,
0.3379015923,
-0.1960076094,
0.1061303467,
-0.1895467043,
-0.1183580458,
0.0572223216,
-0.3894943297,
-0.2822712064,
0.1213474795,
0.5810484886,
0.0635343939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17280v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17280v4
|
Does VLN Pretraining Work with Nonsensical or Irrelevant Instructions?
| 2023-11-28T23:40:13 | 2023-12-23T06:12:37 |
Wang Zhu, Ishika Singh, Yuan Huang, Robin Jia, Jesse Thomason
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Data augmentation via back-translation is common when pretraining
Vision-and-Language Navigation (VLN) models, even though the generated
instructions are noisy. But: does that noise matter? We find that nonsensical
or irrelevant language instructions during pretraining can have little effect
on downstream performance for both HAMT and VLN-BERT on R2R, and is still
better than only using clean, human data. To underscore these results, we
concoct an efficient augmentation method, Unigram + Object, which generates
nonsensical instructions that nonetheless improve downstream performance. Our
findings suggest that what matters for VLN R2R pretraining is the quantity of
visual trajectories, not the quality of instructions.
|
[
-0.0414541215,
-0.482825011,
0.5966451168,
-0.0176418312,
-0.659268558,
-0.246185258,
-0.1768595874,
-0.7700701356,
-0.0014720362,
0.5450633764,
-0.7413545251,
-0.3019168079,
-0.521053493,
-0.4790871441,
-0.4431413412,
1.2768058777,
0.2902185619,
0.2187907845,
-0.4386480451,
-0.0477985181,
-0.6267991662,
-0.5493488312,
-0.1353249103,
-0.4624072015,
0.4931094348,
0.2752722502,
0.7727718949,
0.6818050742,
0.4838130176,
0.2636055052,
-0.0214003846,
0.1030469164,
-0.6047403216,
0.0726193711,
-0.2902230322,
-0.5535123944,
-0.2181488127,
-0.3311741948,
0.4098416269,
0.5534085035,
0.1579165459,
0.1731478125,
-0.0051433998,
0.9601109028,
-0.7013427615,
0.2980300486,
-0.1478280574,
0.1245561168,
-0.3513655365,
-0.2981261313,
-0.3323494494,
-0.3398242295,
0.4501197636,
-0.7768421173,
0.2491410822,
0.1139761508,
0.924685061,
0.600427866,
-0.0040622149,
-0.1154474914,
-0.9717476368,
0.830280304,
-0.5266481638,
0.5466229916,
0.2754080892,
0.0566366054,
-0.0946285501,
-0.7882244587,
-0.2466569394,
-0.1274088025,
-0.3156472147,
0.4358786643,
-0.067954734,
0.3864087164,
0.4979123771,
0.1153088883,
-0.536472261,
0.2697484791,
-0.808283031,
-0.0951344296,
0.5563830137,
0.0627934858,
0.1099278256,
0.0876426399,
-0.3758973777,
-0.1687154919,
-0.7455335259,
0.1900907904,
0.4294392765,
0.0551482998,
-0.2041308284,
0.6461458206,
-0.2539414167,
1.0178534985,
0.0808140337,
0.087211147,
0.4491015375,
-0.366604805,
0.0836526603,
0.1352710724,
0.5509318709,
0.3540877402,
0.5137090683,
-0.4479665458,
-0.2436087281,
-0.1726190001,
0.7278043628,
-0.7219124436,
-0.7276878953,
0.0102341166,
-0.3452893198,
-0.050875023,
0.1336079538,
-0.4548996985,
-0.038459029,
-0.5479217172,
0.6333675385,
-0.3375988305,
-0.227809906,
-0.0725626647,
-0.1930618733,
0.5362209678,
0.5166685581,
-0.8029060364,
-0.0782651752,
0.6224155426,
0.4424217343,
0.0628446639,
-0.3341850042,
-0.6207392216,
-0.046993617,
-0.3534911871,
0.8443670273,
-0.5286538005,
-0.5389319062,
-0.1964226365,
-0.0057432922,
-0.0105912695,
-0.4426633716,
0.2136755139,
-0.5229554772,
0.3465571702,
-0.5595796704,
-0.4060347378,
-0.3878911734,
-0.3828548193,
-0.539779067,
0.9756374955,
0.1473890245,
-0.3459445834,
0.6527328491,
-0.6552987695,
-0.9745719433,
0.2105316669,
-0.3392057717,
-0.445053786,
0.5074743032,
0.0904697329,
0.0922033712,
0.2636078596,
-0.1218409091,
0.09964028,
-0.8783816695,
0.2180620134,
-0.3982087076,
0.3910454512,
-0.1830025166,
-0.5123684406,
-0.015267333,
-0.6550159454,
0.4052397013,
-0.2527393103,
-0.410369873,
-0.1354153454,
0.2095566243,
-0.161046952,
0.150593996,
0.3491927087,
-0.3981279433,
0.0442472138,
-0.4765289128,
0.0242236126,
0.727263391,
-0.1318598837,
0.423075676,
-0.0454204679,
0.2899992764,
0.0737524554,
0.1943861395,
-0.1017330661,
-0.9085481763,
-1.0152542591,
0.117755048,
0.0875920281,
0.5140622854,
-0.8336820006,
0.271306932,
-0.2651242018,
-0.2209411561,
-0.5861160755,
0.0851413608,
0.8971335888,
0.5904334188,
0.7123380303,
-0.4932946861,
-0.7323656082,
-0.6585703492,
-0.2303054482,
-0.3799346983,
0.131113261,
0.1224959344,
0.1387874633,
-0.1159694865,
0.642465651,
-0.1224505678,
-0.1180085912,
-0.129677549,
0.256690979,
-0.1273005605,
0.5356482863,
0.3870905936,
-0.5812467933,
-0.0548497215,
0.045209527,
-0.8352385163,
-0.136705175,
-0.0870117471,
0.0244325344,
0.2465772033,
0.6567418575,
-0.4044237137,
0.863304317,
0.4356015921,
0.1324485838,
0.1356062889,
-0.5923481584,
-0.0495146178,
-0.5213916302,
0.0118836788,
-0.2985395193,
-0.3217050731,
-0.663443625,
-0.0579167753,
0.0775581524,
-0.0180485006,
-0.6511073709,
0.3118306398,
-0.4854437113,
-0.3632083237,
-0.5177047253,
-0.0321859494,
0.0945366174,
0.6026424766,
0.4908163249,
1.0467669964,
0.5086569786,
-0.9347257018,
-0.0284582507,
0.1215222552,
-0.4201848209,
0.3229992092,
-0.6975430846,
0.2625178993,
-0.5109166503,
-0.1236794516,
-0.904517591,
-0.0186871476,
0.2787256539,
-0.58249259,
0.5215044022,
-0.1312370598,
-0.0575214475,
-0.2997647226,
-0.0030310641,
0.3057250679,
0.9569652081,
-0.5529668331,
0.327080071,
0.0522132665,
0.3012444675,
-0.6836590767,
-1.1179248095,
-0.2584875226,
0.203393355,
-0.299975574,
0.1581141353,
0.1575822234,
0.0642469227,
0.1996923834,
-0.2484278232,
-0.2169730514,
-0.1152199432,
0.5960574746,
0.2583904564,
-0.3571867645,
0.0667842999,
-0.1683850437,
-0.3350568712,
0.0620032214,
-0.4141246676,
0.193713665,
-0.113267757,
-0.6197845936,
-0.651147306,
0.0553963631,
0.3333337009,
-0.2101380229,
0.5354768038,
1.0128582716,
0.2076032311,
0.253847152,
-0.4255111814,
-0.2339951545,
-0.4933051169,
0.6577900648,
-0.2108699679,
-0.8412902355,
0.0606488101,
0.0424909405,
0.1516317278,
0.244521752,
0.3111285269,
-0.481564343,
0.7964435816,
0.7235797048,
0.2796020806,
0.6552980542,
-0.1705360264,
0.3678867519,
-0.9689643383,
-0.3768860102,
-0.2624158561,
-0.5466794372,
-0.5349296331,
-0.4191277623,
0.1825990528,
0.1128418669,
-0.0312631577,
0.3196315169,
-0.5893752575,
0.7743453979,
0.6295728087,
0.2071643323,
0.1171364784,
0.1750487536,
0.4604909122,
-0.4150366485,
-0.94128263,
-0.11796958,
1.1738369465,
-0.1331802607,
1.0482258797,
-0.0025289089,
0.773886919,
-0.0083785616,
0.2773242295,
-0.6276383996,
0.418833226,
-0.2942475379,
-0.5764511824,
-0.2063265443,
-0.426304996,
-0.9389624,
0.1088052765,
-0.3306847811,
-0.7871559262,
0.2362008095,
0.4402351379,
-0.5249208212,
0.1759879291,
-0.9084410071,
0.5526320934,
-0.6877130866,
-0.3776413202,
0.0014373213,
-0.8737066388,
0.2664909065,
-0.1092650592,
-0.0289592687,
0.2746233344,
-0.0534999706,
0.7985296845,
-0.5598301291,
0.6962082386,
-0.3972513378,
0.1784179509,
0.3884144723,
-0.3240282238,
0.5363767743,
-0.1360766441,
0.3217649162,
0.4375356436,
-0.4078716934,
-0.3797743618,
-0.6052237153,
0.4109177291,
-0.9542875886,
-0.5951501727,
-0.1899639517,
-0.2426740527,
0.0127422782,
0.0854438469,
0.7158717513,
0.2990063727,
0.0820809379,
0.4290214777,
0.9465343952,
-0.3116335571,
0.4085295796,
0.5725480914,
-0.0966789052,
-0.0520923361,
1.0962070227,
0.2635680437,
0.4538086951,
0.4785973728,
-0.0865554139,
-0.5466291904,
-0.6814847589,
-0.7273851037,
-0.0321144015,
-0.6645231843,
0.1950630695,
-0.5586055517,
-0.3558767438,
-0.1193875,
-0.0306252893,
-0.7344164252,
-0.4213688672,
-0.2716121972,
-0.0557375811,
0.454834342,
0.9058525562,
-0.3494554758,
0.6257116199,
-0.7236647606,
0.4027145505,
0.4047365487,
0.0675475225,
-0.1617176682,
-0.6481075883,
-0.6474576592,
0.3027260005,
0.0818989128,
-0.3315669298,
-0.0392885916,
0.2442699373,
0.6067687869,
0.2394163013,
-0.2216105908,
1.1894367933,
-0.5055995584,
0.8969089985,
0.3740524948,
-0.6694693565,
0.4767773449,
0.1026151851,
0.5410580039,
0.7493064404,
-0.1149823442,
-0.064015083,
-0.3451889157,
-0.5754824281,
-0.849275589,
0.8795284033,
0.1870690286,
0.1906769872,
0.3031891882,
0.3236732185,
-0.0976391137,
0.3590329587,
-0.6784592271,
-0.2730892897,
-0.4882966876,
0.0707608387,
-0.1134039462,
-0.1292764843,
0.1965660155,
-0.3794577718,
0.4328236878,
0.3591259718,
0.4870296419,
0.2351403236,
-0.3335915506,
-0.3330670893,
-0.1031822264,
0.6092176437,
0.6766600013,
-0.1238451228,
-0.1915725172,
0.0492899306,
-0.804402411,
0.1110347584,
-0.1773841083,
-0.3463490307,
0.2531669438,
0.6309331059,
1.1532752514,
0.3715161383,
-0.428486377,
0.6753486991,
-0.1607068479,
-0.3109433949,
-0.2005913109,
0.5689771771,
-0.2521031499,
0.2281879783,
0.0188310072,
0.4583111107,
-0.144378528,
-0.3573248982,
0.0721206591,
0.2510684133,
-0.5786165595,
-0.3953731656,
0.893671751,
0.1688443273,
-0.2048427016,
0.8170888424,
0.0495294109,
-0.3388673961,
0.2679795325,
0.2101545334,
0.7977550626,
-0.1478703618,
0.0030172521,
0.2129670978,
0.7491813898,
-0.1179624721,
0.3001526296,
-0.3039728403,
-0.4201492071,
-1.0060708523,
-0.4785029292,
-0.3204473257,
0.1348222643,
-0.8234680295,
-0.0921704844,
-0.4172071218,
0.0804384053,
-0.2627353668,
-0.3496668041,
-0.9061049819,
0.5010855198,
0.1454788744,
0.2330996394,
-0.514862299,
0.9237442017,
0.7030915022,
-0.4960661829,
-0.8853669763,
-0.0440879799,
-0.1676128656,
-1.0516358614,
0.8197505474,
0.1389358938,
-0.2634334862,
0.02574143,
-0.452011615,
-0.8966137171,
0.8998762369,
0.110867627,
-0.6380927563,
-0.0067624599,
0.3554169238,
0.5399864912,
0.2179284096,
0.2341051698,
0.1298344284,
0.6489847302,
0.2889603674,
-0.6522348523,
-0.3717670441,
-0.1284281313,
0.1127631888,
0.255851537,
-0.629938364,
0.9421572089,
-0.4126372039,
-0.3874378204,
0.00809847,
0.6768864989,
-0.2459556907,
0.0761158764,
0.1563958824,
0.8677092195,
0.7692905664,
-0.2037367225,
1.1502490044,
-0.3093494475,
0.0009201887,
1.4603441954,
-0.2151022851,
0.5064248443,
0.5940514207,
-0.0722252876,
0.372965306,
0.3259652853,
0.2446276098,
0.7853068709,
-0.0806858018,
-0.0237650648,
-0.2829966545,
0.2617491782,
-0.9012064338,
0.473916322,
0.2318076491,
-0.2547568083,
-0.3750934303,
-0.039407827,
-0.1462717652,
-0.2796446979,
-0.2255824655,
0.9756693244,
0.0495763682,
-0.6770753264,
0.6437218189,
-0.161958158,
0.4857091904,
-0.6819553971,
0.0097413156,
-0.2311023772,
0.2022111565,
-0.41513291,
-0.8641536832,
0.4292847812,
0.0343329422,
-0.0641745925,
-0.1687188447,
0.7395113111,
-0.2654122114,
-0.2240715176,
0.0857432112,
0.7419172525,
0.4623005688,
-0.0473450199,
-0.4021558464,
-0.080301851,
0.3353559673,
-0.3830008805,
0.3661383688,
0.5129045844,
0.0254569054,
0.5172405243,
0.9106149077,
0.0595419295,
0.3790251911,
0.0691972747,
0.9075580239,
-0.6930471659,
-0.3128441274,
-0.8067371845,
0.7312889099,
0.0220325477,
-0.3814770877,
0.8881242871,
0.5404667854,
1.097935915,
-0.0933171585,
0.6973634362,
0.1871354729,
0.1831153929,
-0.9531654119,
0.5609037876,
-0.5150979757,
0.1894128174,
-0.1764457822,
-1.0726528168,
-0.1379414797,
0.8885650039,
-0.5786586404,
0.0192555618,
0.6285374165,
0.9747737646,
-0.1836440563,
0.1031570211,
0.4558021426,
-0.0350118317,
0.0633994639,
0.6016557217,
0.9754816294,
-0.4756219983,
0.5508384109,
-0.0336658582,
0.0396617092,
-0.341906637,
-0.5340765715,
-0.8399658203,
-0.1836614162,
-0.3692445457,
-0.172690928,
0.3935314417,
0.2944278717,
0.9824224114,
-0.3870577514,
-0.0704876259,
-0.4709226489,
0.0082749883,
-0.0991720185,
-0.1201445088,
0.0573858991,
-0.5363220572,
-0.2685697377,
0.6455079913,
0.4334819019,
0.3107197881,
-0.2396294028,
-0.4644634128,
0.0574321859,
-0.2570073903,
0.6021469831,
0.5254052281,
-0.4962228537,
-0.360318929,
-0.2182405144,
0.1538520604,
0.2838540971,
0.7459912896,
-1.0295077562,
0.7851102948,
0.3023698032,
0.547303319,
0.8042857647,
0.2291623652,
0.4252420664,
-0.9972456098,
0.7188184857,
0.0572134256,
-0.0519243628,
0.1550330967,
-0.3811102211,
0.3627852201,
0.0855187401,
-0.502877295,
-0.5472396612,
0.3122468889,
-0.7312651277,
-0.1954465359,
1.0207012892,
-0.1113564521,
-0.6139478087,
-0.2771773636,
-0.1715132743,
0.1282614768,
-0.2575437725,
0.3332366049,
0.3586903811,
-0.2403012365,
-0.2298387438,
-0.7091525197,
0.6338201761,
0.5712878704,
-0.547965467,
-0.2307203412,
0.5328631997,
-0.0365218893,
0.1860957742,
0.5736696124,
-0.1770258993,
0.397960633,
0.0264191572,
-0.0163939428,
-0.3585760295,
-0.4806977212,
-0.1305877268,
-0.3665319681,
0.0535380505,
-0.5534229875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17264v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17264v1
|
RETSim: Resilient and Efficient Text Similarity
| 2023-11-28T22:54:33 | 2023-11-28T22:54:33 |
Marina Zhang, Owen Vallis, Aysegul Bumin, Tanay Vakharia, Elie Bursztein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces RETSim (Resilient and Efficient Text Similarity), a
lightweight, multilingual deep learning model trained to produce robust metric
embeddings for near-duplicate text retrieval, clustering, and dataset
deduplication tasks. We demonstrate that RETSim is significantly more robust
and accurate than MinHash and neural text embeddings, achieving new
state-of-the-art performance on dataset deduplication, adversarial text
retrieval benchmarks, and spam clustering tasks. We also introduce the W4NT3D
benchmark (Wiki-40B 4dversarial Near-T3xt Dataset) for evaluating multilingual,
near-duplicate text retrieval capabilities under adversarial settings. RETSim
and the W4NT3D benchmark are open-sourced under the MIT License at
https://github.com/google/unisim.
|
[
-0.0331503041,
-0.7323210835,
0.3920545876,
0.0188390762,
-0.3109888136,
0.27763322,
-0.2750390172,
-0.2336257398,
0.1029998809,
0.4561978579,
-0.1934307069,
-0.7251034379,
-0.5593185425,
0.1903119087,
-0.7197782397,
0.7966930866,
-0.2387993485,
-0.093261756,
-0.4018294811,
-0.5777127147,
-0.0530632026,
-0.5741552114,
-0.5680178404,
-0.1942536086,
0.6608092189,
0.307095319,
0.6112878919,
0.6946894526,
0.8678426147,
0.3899800479,
0.2254994959,
0.0849398747,
-0.6626576781,
0.2503826022,
-0.1749355793,
-0.5425735116,
-0.2297062576,
0.0744885951,
1.0062036514,
0.4589983523,
-0.1102323905,
0.0732421055,
0.3172955513,
0.7521032691,
-0.4602751434,
-0.3000116348,
-0.6175886393,
0.0496098287,
-0.1577486396,
-0.2322276533,
-0.2402355969,
-0.5400077105,
0.2340703309,
-0.6770768166,
0.462013185,
0.0197623912,
0.7415115237,
0.4561257958,
-0.494661957,
0.0954582915,
-0.3031185567,
1.2473913431,
-0.5772600174,
0.6714175344,
0.3582847714,
0.1904225051,
-0.1808926165,
-1.1558711529,
-0.4540520906,
-0.1270126253,
0.0213870239,
-0.0337274894,
-0.2260228246,
-0.4343307614,
0.063951984,
0.3474340439,
-0.7987009883,
0.1371446103,
-0.1505436152,
-0.2263861895,
0.1880487949,
0.2330033183,
0.1985453069,
0.1114471033,
-0.6693564057,
-0.1074385718,
-0.6708018184,
-0.5281511545,
0.4099867642,
0.3092883825,
-0.1698464006,
0.2451881915,
-0.0237521809,
0.6872864962,
-0.4743576646,
-0.1173244417,
0.74136585,
-0.5273457766,
-0.2379180342,
-0.2594306171,
0.9185650349,
0.3920657635,
0.2406700701,
-0.4137639403,
-0.1596677452,
-0.2164774537,
0.6679471135,
-0.8804205656,
-0.1314025074,
-0.1275869459,
-0.8049788475,
-0.4249566197,
0.0303052515,
-0.6836026311,
-0.1285746247,
-0.3512359858,
0.3494280875,
-0.5728904605,
-0.126094237,
-0.0794718862,
-0.1582092345,
-0.091481626,
0.0005971529,
-0.4290201068,
0.2704788446,
0.906737268,
1.1293735504,
-0.3922500014,
-0.8034012914,
-0.1302702427,
0.1293651313,
-0.0423395969,
0.6809082031,
-0.5511222482,
-0.2836456597,
-0.238749519,
0.1816004068,
-0.0131552406,
-0.6088454127,
0.6850079298,
-0.4696601629,
0.2632395327,
-0.3563849926,
-0.6290836334,
-0.4267973006,
0.5860999823,
-0.9733002186,
0.9455112815,
0.164190799,
-1.0928736925,
0.2425658554,
-0.2872165143,
-0.4918327332,
-0.1875318438,
-0.0544627979,
-0.7573320866,
0.1975917518,
-0.0248050913,
0.3663921654,
-0.5966553092,
0.1153384447,
-0.5313010812,
-0.5742578506,
0.0731580257,
-0.7701571584,
0.4475993812,
0.3107643425,
-0.1401054114,
-0.2108315825,
-0.633272171,
0.2328538597,
0.1727401167,
-0.3319003582,
-0.4588550925,
-0.1391401291,
0.19118312,
-0.0992909372,
0.4158477485,
-0.6113707423,
-0.1019744724,
-0.2216095626,
0.5942010283,
0.4991061687,
-0.2402161658,
0.3219571114,
-0.5276088715,
0.3300762475,
0.0639112517,
-0.1552028954,
-0.0710092783,
-0.1959195882,
-0.2114009708,
-0.3738805652,
0.4491145313,
0.683632493,
-0.8501915932,
0.1571949869,
-0.6339776516,
-0.8122933507,
-0.4789969921,
0.2449915558,
0.6936554909,
0.5811104774,
0.3591991961,
-0.13606444,
-0.488252908,
-1.2955675125,
-0.6556674838,
0.2244451642,
0.1635382324,
0.0062742559,
0.5334017873,
-0.4576862156,
0.6821591854,
-0.3347592652,
-0.2496629059,
-0.0891228616,
0.2558943331,
-0.0679734498,
0.6622256637,
0.850581944,
-1.1277318001,
-0.5462572575,
-0.1444344074,
-1.0326012373,
0.0785638765,
0.1954816729,
0.0593582727,
0.1230711043,
0.6161541343,
-0.3101011217,
0.2948175073,
0.497944057,
-0.1393581629,
0.0226606652,
-0.3735027015,
0.6364755034,
-1.7209306955,
0.3154434562,
-0.0772086084,
-0.4700857699,
-0.5297400951,
0.0487252399,
0.2148797512,
-0.1181672737,
-0.5568047166,
0.4913701117,
-0.4193278253,
-0.0442814119,
-0.4143113494,
0.3477530181,
0.0259602461,
0.2217179388,
-0.2232306004,
0.8757015467,
0.4394023716,
-0.4873237312,
0.5534622073,
0.1344106048,
-0.5149057508,
0.8579462171,
-0.7295724154,
0.0306816753,
0.0486621819,
0.1737799793,
-0.6067384481,
0.182314679,
-0.0347945243,
-0.5039918423,
0.4254032373,
0.0155633101,
-0.7180978656,
-0.1877298057,
-0.6145932674,
1.0183589458,
0.1947563738,
-0.770883739,
0.4422468841,
0.3299985826,
0.1547525525,
-0.9372906089,
-1.0078687668,
0.2001304626,
-0.4449545145,
-0.3299620152,
0.6067068577,
0.1064139828,
0.0429705009,
0.3179491162,
0.0228178296,
-0.1616167277,
0.3844572306,
0.2420039177,
-0.2009220272,
-0.1890678108,
0.1279239058,
-0.124050051,
-0.5429993272,
-0.2691781819,
-0.4392123222,
0.2824845612,
-0.2434995025,
-0.4097233117,
-0.6080670357,
0.5567911863,
0.4993983805,
0.084039472,
0.5966829062,
0.9365179539,
-0.7188800573,
0.1518940926,
-0.5062096119,
-0.0023262247,
-0.4686938822,
0.7312816381,
-0.459700197,
-1.2305305004,
0.3461124003,
0.0296910871,
0.1997283101,
0.2636322677,
0.378841877,
0.0127504859,
0.6486361623,
0.6272263527,
-0.4301747382,
0.4625110924,
-0.0704386234,
0.2309769988,
-0.5611711144,
-0.2188619971,
-0.6246907711,
-0.7344034314,
-0.7335091233,
-0.4951471388,
-0.2992201447,
-0.22070086,
-0.4446829557,
0.5859348774,
-0.4347744882,
0.5786334276,
0.8304451704,
-0.0654445663,
0.1086503565,
0.3330534399,
0.0912635326,
-0.4714120924,
-0.5053736567,
-0.6312946081,
1.0665858984,
0.1485837698,
0.877689302,
0.2811169624,
0.7715175748,
0.4116650224,
0.3655718565,
-0.3135089278,
0.5398929715,
-0.4732197821,
-0.1669282466,
0.0599007048,
-0.9167916179,
-1.198351264,
0.2078695893,
-0.2331632525,
-0.5943734646,
-0.1634622812,
-0.0724442974,
-0.0609053448,
0.8136821985,
-0.6946261525,
0.8195453882,
-0.1251078248,
-0.293736577,
-0.3984830976,
-0.4608239233,
-0.0465839021,
-0.3202049434,
-0.1498847008,
-0.0167200267,
-0.560841918,
1.0079534054,
-0.1674906462,
0.6502202153,
-0.0003836006,
0.067542389,
0.1816101819,
0.1781087518,
0.1096005291,
0.0403030626,
-0.2265724093,
0.4202181995,
-0.1131274775,
-0.4671764076,
-0.7367129922,
1.5484138727,
-0.8007467389,
-0.4363945127,
-0.3909366131,
-0.4133137763,
0.1014867797,
0.581346035,
0.3116347194,
0.6140865684,
-0.4761805832,
0.6139966846,
0.553607583,
-0.2912498713,
0.4977789521,
0.4794046581,
0.2922608554,
-0.8032950759,
1.2143315077,
-0.1007393301,
0.0402661674,
0.8445999622,
-0.1237486899,
-0.370518297,
-0.4432803392,
-0.0960966498,
0.2237071395,
-0.6021010876,
-0.6289374232,
-0.9414816499,
0.0355294012,
-0.1774808615,
-0.3501545489,
-0.7799456716,
-0.5276073217,
-0.4077524841,
-0.3045569658,
0.3913694918,
0.7849169374,
-0.1674248725,
0.1446420848,
-0.8910332322,
0.3932830989,
-0.0579841584,
0.6804819107,
-0.0228001904,
-0.4521712661,
-0.4645751715,
0.0187205393,
-0.2766702771,
-0.5133547783,
0.3368526697,
0.0645818338,
0.6325042248,
0.1495025605,
-0.0742097348,
0.3798264563,
-0.3786821961,
0.7775011659,
0.0925946906,
-0.7513799071,
0.1729074717,
-0.1015225202,
0.2510308921,
0.940279901,
0.3719882667,
-0.3122203052,
-0.2831635773,
-0.568015039,
-0.7071131468,
0.5105757713,
0.29189834,
0.1180451065,
-0.146323368,
0.5070267916,
0.1591511071,
0.2186518759,
-0.5814377069,
-0.3336035609,
-0.2915533185,
-0.6092287898,
-0.1956158578,
-0.4743270576,
0.1089035347,
0.1383180767,
0.5337808728,
0.0297428239,
0.4271911383,
0.1048986912,
-0.2523604929,
0.3429055512,
0.0566737503,
0.6874802113,
0.36359182,
-0.0804387257,
0.4970903397,
0.4813975394,
-0.805339098,
0.1768938154,
0.107228823,
0.0283611212,
-0.0305179227,
0.4836450219,
0.3872070312,
0.5544732213,
-0.5757656097,
0.4498180747,
-0.537884295,
-0.4238104224,
-0.1599283367,
-0.352922976,
0.0622864887,
0.2090608776,
0.1399665922,
-0.1564956158,
0.0038464251,
-0.2312548757,
0.5738979578,
0.3345694542,
-0.4390510619,
-0.2021237314,
0.7291895151,
0.3167811036,
-0.5050159097,
0.9305694103,
0.0426422693,
-0.6864258051,
0.4910392165,
0.5650982857,
0.9116235971,
-0.1090900451,
-0.098074317,
0.4552319348,
0.4901664555,
-0.3341673315,
0.3047798872,
0.0945751891,
-0.5057956576,
-0.025109414,
-0.1642182916,
-0.1817062497,
-0.0657826066,
-0.6316013336,
0.1771205068,
-0.3087444603,
-0.1889637709,
-0.402924031,
0.1212492511,
-0.6306496859,
0.3069626987,
-0.2034286559,
0.9609225392,
-0.6718274355,
0.7989162803,
0.6362054348,
-0.0545376353,
-0.2870309353,
-0.0541017354,
0.0143763544,
-0.5575228333,
0.2396299094,
0.364672184,
-0.1358703673,
-0.1633033007,
-0.2201047987,
-0.9504093528,
1.2985155582,
0.5391085148,
-0.3922231793,
0.3177807331,
0.1979741156,
0.5164123774,
-0.2273360342,
0.295008868,
0.528345108,
0.3198077679,
-0.469357729,
-0.5472604632,
0.2495819777,
-0.459616363,
-0.0585311912,
0.5768094659,
-0.8569710255,
0.6113308072,
-0.12104702,
-0.1505802572,
0.2459108233,
0.7494851947,
-0.0308024995,
0.4295138717,
0.3700751662,
1.2113386393,
0.7699658275,
-0.1460430324,
1.1114786863,
-0.3138459623,
0.4022797048,
1.3253443241,
-0.1043564081,
0.7924247384,
0.327429384,
0.3082586825,
0.3700838685,
0.5228055716,
-0.2481810153,
0.6532389522,
-0.0488701761,
-0.1128504425,
-0.0862200484,
0.0718702227,
-0.569903791,
0.3105950654,
0.0939828977,
-0.4430817664,
-0.3019625843,
-0.0287610497,
-0.0004551527,
0.4780926108,
0.2178329229,
0.589519918,
0.3261792064,
-0.4069539905,
0.3331716657,
0.0981700495,
0.8337615132,
-0.3852393031,
0.0806398243,
-0.2184333801,
0.48399809,
-0.0826624632,
-0.8491866589,
0.6168039441,
-0.051456891,
-0.335216105,
-0.2961911261,
0.581454277,
-0.4111488163,
-0.3326584995,
0.5018936992,
0.3382773399,
0.132834658,
0.1223188862,
-1.0679368973,
-0.0084964251,
0.0618519783,
-0.3922679722,
0.3750691712,
0.5611734986,
0.0758977532,
1.0089495182,
0.5062007904,
-0.2700816691,
-0.231193617,
0.2658028603,
0.5868184566,
-0.9910206199,
-0.3329229951,
-0.9996986985,
-0.1132962704,
-0.1950796396,
-0.2032756209,
0.9220083952,
0.9363693595,
0.8753778338,
0.0873679072,
0.742056191,
0.2516141832,
0.7041708827,
-0.1068712994,
0.8304408789,
-0.8895971179,
0.0379536226,
-0.2304740399,
-1.1456850767,
-0.4092746079,
0.3020265102,
0.1203332916,
0.2951330841,
0.8192697167,
0.8753185272,
-0.2947066724,
-0.0010300099,
0.4391942918,
-0.1169156209,
0.3365623355,
0.895324707,
0.7149730921,
-0.6299569607,
0.7326709032,
-0.1827779561,
0.0348667428,
0.0072298408,
-0.9206840992,
-0.9976962209,
-0.6880655885,
-0.4104676843,
-0.2081625164,
-0.0602210499,
0.5674438477,
0.495668143,
-0.6334167719,
0.2082002312,
0.0327985138,
0.3403870165,
-0.1794347316,
-0.160275206,
0.5180242658,
-0.0945392251,
-0.8534960747,
0.3311134875,
0.3278228641,
0.3128670156,
0.0880884901,
0.0577536821,
-0.0152018657,
-0.1680797786,
0.3296703696,
0.1935776621,
-0.4367606044,
-0.3502767682,
-0.2180168629,
-0.4886159897,
-0.2761220038,
0.923371613,
-0.7667447329,
0.1847319752,
0.74831146,
1.0830596685,
0.0819354132,
0.0012455045,
0.7325457335,
-0.6493964791,
0.2912867069,
0.1444340795,
0.5502790213,
0.630690217,
-0.1255946159,
0.6536740065,
0.3068864644,
-0.6115311384,
-0.9796386957,
0.0677341744,
-0.8832018375,
-0.1738649905,
0.9137958884,
-0.3652788699,
-0.1986028105,
-0.1360336542,
0.1985993236,
0.2914549708,
-0.1855950207,
0.6603392959,
0.2761282027,
0.7460836768,
-0.1259339601,
-0.267418474,
0.3431456387,
0.6066075563,
-0.6304379702,
-0.0168545432,
-0.0116479117,
0.5064690113,
-0.0190839749,
0.3261221051,
-0.2687439322,
0.1840771437,
0.120960556,
-0.221576795,
-0.3399750292,
-0.2458330542,
-0.1428325772,
0.197668314,
-0.2324316949,
-0.3412000835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17233v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17233v1
|
Quantifying the redundancy between prosody and text
| 2023-11-28T21:15:24 | 2023-11-28T21:15:24 |
Lukas Wolf, Tiago Pimentel, Evelina Fedorenko, Ryan Cotterell, Alex Warstadt, Ethan Wilcox, Tamar Regev
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IT, cs.LG, math.IT
|
Prosody -- the suprasegmental component of speech, including pitch, loudness,
and tempo -- carries critical aspects of meaning. However, the relationship
between the information conveyed by prosody vs. by the words themselves remains
poorly understood. We use large language models (LLMs) to estimate how much
information is redundant between prosody and the words themselves. Using a
large spoken corpus of English audiobooks, we extract prosodic features aligned
to individual words and test how well they can be predicted from LLM
embeddings, compared to non-contextual word embeddings. We find a high degree
of redundancy between the information carried by the words and prosodic
information across several prosodic features, including intensity, duration,
pauses, and pitch contours. Furthermore, a word's prosodic information is
redundant with both the word itself and the context preceding as well as
following it. Still, we observe that prosodic features can not be fully
predicted from text, suggesting that prosody carries information above and
beyond the words. Along with this paper, we release a general-purpose data
processing pipeline for quantifying the relationship between linguistic
information and extra-linguistic features.
|
[
-0.3876271844,
-0.5999674201,
0.4701247513,
0.2844299078,
-0.527980268,
-0.3640222549,
-0.1284602284,
-0.4304262698,
0.4357274473,
0.5068796277,
-0.4855111837,
-0.2537852824,
-0.6728399992,
0.0217099637,
-0.5019151568,
0.9190068245,
0.3365414143,
-0.0122762509,
-0.398963809,
-0.3958208561,
-0.5362698436,
-0.4257882237,
-0.0649157092,
-0.2384126782,
0.1592866927,
0.3206958473,
0.9455739856,
0.6397892237,
0.5133599043,
0.2716046572,
-0.3152973652,
-0.0730976462,
-0.248996377,
0.3830886185,
-0.216030702,
-0.139220953,
-0.441475451,
-0.1204974949,
0.8396393061,
0.9835767746,
-0.0084276879,
0.1631369591,
0.2122852057,
0.5083528757,
-0.5341358185,
0.2736124694,
-0.1909258515,
-0.1643865108,
-0.3187846243,
-0.4494222701,
-0.036604248,
-0.3851005137,
0.2914301753,
-0.4237726927,
0.3394358754,
-0.1486681402,
0.5570682287,
0.5070161223,
-0.2118489891,
-0.5237678885,
-0.7752870917,
0.6733009219,
-0.43049106,
0.6646806598,
0.6764734983,
-0.3178780675,
-0.0784550831,
-0.2864683867,
-0.8230156302,
-0.2969001532,
-0.2349561602,
0.099673219,
-0.1611193568,
0.0593306087,
-0.1380678415,
0.2475173771,
-0.4750941694,
-0.2693975866,
-0.3439586461,
-0.0210111979,
0.755862236,
0.138976872,
0.3642969728,
-0.3240057826,
-0.197227627,
-0.0774649605,
-0.4269325733,
-0.0647170916,
0.4343395531,
0.2144018114,
-0.1070316285,
0.5867922902,
0.2907325029,
0.5541284084,
-0.2297196388,
-0.4544715881,
0.6352368593,
-0.5352090001,
-0.019795591,
0.194216758,
0.8339135647,
0.1068147868,
0.3663280308,
-0.0986847281,
-0.0441913195,
-0.2083227783,
0.1267016083,
-0.2623504698,
-0.3231350482,
0.4682790935,
-0.0723290965,
0.2270604521,
-0.0239875,
-0.3519633114,
-0.5667740703,
-0.2628799677,
0.3471378386,
-0.5798945427,
-0.4593998194,
-0.1048623696,
-0.3374730349,
-0.1758137196,
0.0286159366,
-0.9992653131,
0.1462508738,
0.6693485975,
1.0322368145,
-0.2052409202,
-0.4663372338,
-0.2313239723,
0.2519032061,
-0.2328589261,
0.6329379082,
-0.8796058297,
-0.4732010663,
-0.0098129716,
0.253231287,
0.0638179258,
-0.6719458699,
0.6284344792,
-0.2239155918,
-0.1776259989,
-0.2390395701,
-0.9657136798,
-0.1886906326,
-0.2247121036,
-0.9698363543,
0.8620365858,
0.0038879919,
-0.9315094948,
-0.0139050148,
-0.0783254206,
-0.4891150892,
0.2280542552,
-0.2062151581,
-0.3661812246,
0.4033709168,
-0.2384774536,
0.6156881452,
-0.2624835074,
0.4396280646,
-0.1650060117,
-0.6358126402,
0.4193113446,
-0.4469036162,
0.3626876175,
-0.1255425364,
-0.1018139794,
-0.1302065551,
-0.9404644966,
-0.3856098652,
-0.1908952296,
-0.3566901684,
-0.5576782227,
0.2077778429,
0.2558967173,
-0.2104585171,
0.2076159865,
-0.5207331777,
-0.1339755505,
-0.2827195823,
0.7244383693,
0.3720517755,
0.086222522,
0.3859948218,
-0.1989607364,
0.4871102273,
-0.076109916,
-0.2426533252,
-0.2949748635,
-0.410120219,
-0.4455761611,
-0.3838374913,
0.2739392817,
0.5952318311,
0.0677476227,
0.584389925,
-0.2545613348,
-0.560564518,
-0.6958727837,
-0.0000861546,
0.4596925676,
0.3040443361,
0.4737800956,
-0.1498442292,
-0.558611095,
-0.8437619805,
-0.3610320389,
-0.3378849924,
-0.2920387089,
0.0501669385,
0.3069805205,
-0.1523752064,
0.7301045656,
-0.1590664238,
-0.420183152,
-0.1826523244,
0.2142389268,
0.1822871119,
0.3136447966,
-0.0568713769,
-0.6055330038,
0.0190704204,
-0.0754741952,
-0.4605050385,
-0.4330417216,
-0.167394191,
0.4341511726,
0.0255860165,
0.6844049692,
-0.7307108641,
0.030877443,
0.6852728724,
-0.3773759604,
0.6679751873,
-0.3039767742,
-0.005417231,
-0.7162908912,
0.0800988004,
-0.0215362068,
-0.0155629115,
-0.4752615988,
-0.47593683,
0.117397055,
0.0119411498,
-0.3378276527,
0.6533787251,
-0.5313774943,
-0.4911164343,
-0.3116662502,
0.5920921564,
0.0153198866,
0.2546549141,
0.0839337334,
0.9425281286,
0.1007013023,
-0.6422508359,
0.3505496383,
0.1850420833,
-0.4277024269,
0.5460599661,
-0.6650422215,
-0.2196321189,
-0.3288636506,
-0.1303671002,
-1.3376504183,
-0.3155747056,
-0.4095960259,
-0.6047385335,
0.3010927141,
-0.0607044175,
-0.4159764349,
0.1286821514,
0.0094634872,
0.5722728968,
0.4634236097,
-0.0086193122,
0.4321387112,
0.9234853983,
-0.8121514916,
-0.4544786513,
-0.5817712545,
-0.2335430682,
-0.1718290746,
-0.4318918884,
0.4679509401,
0.3543354571,
-0.3902755082,
0.1414164752,
-0.0324301086,
-0.0693637803,
-0.1756538451,
0.5720501542,
-0.0124232275,
0.1148126423,
0.9603412151,
-0.1531879753,
-0.240792647,
0.1822467744,
-0.2441915125,
0.4897257984,
-0.0502625778,
-0.1913916171,
-0.7090837955,
0.4258889258,
0.6604409218,
0.1415116638,
0.6205714345,
0.5055890083,
-0.2651667893,
0.2126685977,
-0.2904086709,
0.1477766186,
-0.3586501181,
0.7935982347,
-0.2821795642,
-0.7253154516,
0.5077778697,
0.3139911592,
-0.0003125384,
0.3622065783,
0.3063342869,
-0.5136300325,
0.7403911352,
0.720338881,
0.1818466783,
0.4616326094,
-0.1056368649,
0.1166578755,
-0.8081370592,
-0.4745936096,
-0.4945491552,
-0.3002883792,
-0.6686988473,
-0.2619176507,
0.2856722176,
0.3911868036,
-0.3287624419,
0.3547380865,
-0.187199086,
0.5516101718,
0.5342754126,
-0.319146663,
0.2790798247,
-0.090450801,
0.0357547514,
-0.3990488052,
-0.3538891077,
-0.5725974441,
0.7222214937,
0.3958782852,
0.5025594234,
0.2862973213,
0.4449729621,
0.4696424305,
-0.1202555373,
-0.9176246524,
0.4235632122,
-0.3580616713,
-0.1768195331,
-0.5949732661,
-0.1415012479,
-0.9667410851,
0.2593257725,
-0.2659883797,
-0.5862778425,
0.074834317,
0.3194788396,
-0.4700044096,
-0.0488199443,
-0.7927421331,
0.7712373137,
0.0955035314,
-0.2594865263,
-0.1429297924,
-0.2762241662,
0.0166089609,
-0.2518135011,
0.4728602171,
-0.2175586969,
-0.3648016751,
0.9054780602,
-0.6167930365,
0.7997160554,
0.0581381842,
-0.0994452536,
0.2380118966,
0.2323910147,
0.40948686,
-0.1377879381,
0.14917624,
0.4029515386,
0.1548689753,
-0.2757683396,
-0.4393760264,
0.5925143957,
-0.8292562962,
-0.3713486195,
-0.3496545255,
-0.4906835854,
-0.3214321733,
-0.1359524429,
0.4600080848,
0.4757969379,
-0.1906669289,
0.2139876485,
0.5122241378,
-0.172772035,
0.5324339271,
0.1655999571,
0.2694682181,
-0.4461702704,
0.9426161647,
0.4519777596,
0.2578137815,
0.4727653265,
0.2967245579,
-0.6676530242,
-0.5786825418,
0.0963667706,
0.5513795614,
-0.5848969817,
0.1490989923,
-0.7855321765,
-0.1732006073,
-0.379401058,
-0.0867042243,
-0.4710914493,
-0.5522148013,
-0.4656280875,
-0.2602231205,
0.3926712573,
0.771464169,
-0.1738540828,
0.396541208,
-1.2406353951,
0.0661466941,
0.2250021845,
0.0275359955,
-0.0249391235,
-0.919139564,
-0.2432550788,
-0.3941443861,
-0.104961507,
-1.2236317396,
0.7553198934,
0.3854401708,
0.374424994,
0.3867277205,
0.0906165019,
0.5853577256,
-0.5441791415,
0.9342398643,
0.3830539882,
-1.1881253719,
0.5808016062,
-0.1374537647,
0.432190448,
0.3688544631,
0.6802483201,
-0.6882368326,
-0.5556169748,
-0.9094646573,
-1.1759307384,
0.4560976326,
0.2385495007,
0.0168763194,
-0.3094787002,
0.0323932953,
0.1349648982,
0.1855896413,
-0.4591066837,
-0.1299836338,
0.051870767,
-0.5074441433,
-0.3794810176,
-0.6301657557,
-0.0357119404,
-0.1468900293,
0.4502937794,
0.2378605902,
0.2144059986,
0.2475249022,
-0.3165819347,
0.1181138679,
0.4338995516,
0.6334644556,
0.5460531712,
-0.2466335297,
0.4821772277,
0.0292151105,
-0.9709284306,
0.2326899469,
-0.0375993066,
-0.0384508185,
0.2981770337,
1.1166653633,
0.7239741087,
0.2166121453,
-0.9362639189,
0.6029171944,
0.2867842913,
-0.0129947504,
-0.7000901699,
-0.0194394533,
0.3956970572,
0.4799779058,
0.1861904711,
-0.0524955541,
0.0874781162,
-0.5872901082,
0.2113480717,
0.1656541377,
-0.5902284384,
-0.5874497294,
0.3486390412,
0.3902024031,
-0.531449616,
0.4968896508,
-0.1127200723,
-0.2153614759,
0.6358060837,
0.3654977381,
0.986772716,
-0.1376484632,
0.140586704,
0.3763746023,
0.2844334841,
-0.0439019389,
0.3791339397,
-0.1799139827,
-0.6330212355,
-0.3620505035,
-0.7667900324,
-0.257082969,
0.4644100964,
-0.5295028687,
0.0349121206,
-0.329221487,
-0.3973207772,
0.3318714797,
-0.1611908376,
-0.4844406843,
-0.0643822178,
-0.0538159683,
0.4941409528,
-1.0025428534,
0.6447895765,
0.5075275302,
-0.3918054402,
-0.4714396894,
0.2634041309,
0.0453612618,
-0.4925833344,
0.8551179767,
0.2265774459,
-0.2282654941,
-0.0996026248,
-0.0604611523,
-1.0699771643,
0.8142563105,
0.3594711423,
-1.0290007591,
0.1854954213,
0.0946473628,
0.5401880145,
-0.2692742646,
0.3540617526,
0.9034167528,
0.2600992918,
0.1263713688,
-1.027204752,
-0.135635078,
-0.0461494923,
-0.1386248767,
0.3848763406,
-0.2494126856,
0.8939422965,
-0.3821782172,
-0.6303264499,
-0.1911008954,
0.4451229572,
0.0524421334,
0.0027374823,
0.3940162659,
0.4432680607,
1.0854644775,
0.0741483718,
0.8062728047,
-0.1853319854,
0.2627335489,
1.2488849163,
0.0224610977,
1.2080644369,
0.4220743179,
-0.3229390979,
-0.024862498,
0.4541028142,
0.3332433105,
0.480073154,
0.0406473391,
-0.4016150534,
-0.3132278621,
-0.0479257032,
-0.3040963113,
0.4252893031,
0.5389964581,
-0.5816380978,
0.2772991061,
-0.0244535487,
-0.1524729133,
0.0017835542,
-0.0567004271,
0.836004734,
-0.0091922935,
-0.5242241621,
0.7689988613,
-0.2140390277,
0.4227531552,
-0.3850102723,
0.0520340577,
-0.4277120829,
0.2384739369,
-0.2110650688,
-1.1534605026,
0.6711696982,
-0.0806464404,
-0.4242092967,
0.0167455859,
0.3349664807,
-0.5580701828,
-0.2154712677,
0.3165819943,
0.3457815051,
0.5328997374,
0.0314892344,
-0.2242281586,
0.1267314106,
-0.0883708075,
-0.0645493343,
0.0929501057,
0.6533529758,
-0.0509274751,
0.6113497615,
0.2643127441,
0.5071334839,
-0.0583708659,
0.3199635744,
0.4425104558,
-1.1322849989,
-0.5959324241,
-0.9645723701,
0.272040844,
0.0167003404,
-0.5742352009,
0.4471229613,
0.1426692456,
0.8872283697,
0.0533251949,
0.8032838106,
0.4381881654,
0.5550926328,
-0.5892999172,
0.3908859491,
-0.4553379714,
0.4011762738,
-0.3190808594,
-1.1192851067,
-0.1335107386,
0.7990832925,
-0.0735997781,
-0.2443018407,
0.7884213924,
0.7127756476,
0.1437792033,
0.1967220604,
0.4763833582,
0.3483278155,
-0.2259806246,
0.2519960701,
0.8274533749,
-0.271356523,
0.4843718708,
0.2238910943,
-0.3764053881,
-0.3462713659,
-0.5663840175,
-0.48533988,
-0.8869484067,
-0.3751206696,
-0.1731126308,
-0.0352411643,
0.7581042051,
0.4877260327,
-0.6793712974,
-0.2290934771,
-0.1408315748,
0.1118801087,
-0.3400847614,
-0.1884403974,
0.5165573359,
-0.2478318065,
-0.6983568668,
0.2598825395,
0.3643727899,
0.3010681868,
-0.3590234816,
-0.0229241662,
0.0490220115,
0.3300352991,
0.5710915327,
0.3605028093,
-0.6888396144,
-0.0748098716,
-0.2221435755,
0.0522895157,
-0.2091534734,
0.7919374108,
-0.4619338512,
0.3338043988,
0.8788509965,
0.4144806266,
0.1620707512,
0.0421182364,
0.5487335324,
-1.1249203682,
0.2965320051,
0.3851796389,
0.4576767385,
0.5787938833,
-0.1701704115,
0.2405434102,
0.4761122167,
-0.4631274939,
-0.6966828704,
0.3340057731,
-0.6593517661,
-0.4455466866,
1.3027253151,
-0.1602052003,
-0.1372515261,
-0.4609965384,
0.0521593541,
0.1865957379,
-0.2194930315,
0.4068274498,
0.9946523905,
-0.3410457969,
-0.4642937481,
-0.6061014533,
0.7017365098,
0.4000445008,
-0.2494549453,
0.5117070675,
0.6782808304,
0.1197058782,
0.6341260672,
0.8362948895,
-0.0833361,
-0.0894425735,
0.3101761937,
0.1201129481,
-0.0684968978,
-0.6432647109,
-0.4181527495,
0.3419703245,
-0.1177732497,
-0.3996969461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17227v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17227v2
|
War and Peace (WarAgent): Large Language Model-based Multi-Agent Simulation of World Wars
| 2023-11-28T20:59:49 | 2024-01-30T18:53:30 |
Wenyue Hua, Lizhou Fan, Lingyao Li, Kai Mei, Jianchao Ji, Yingqiang Ge, Libby Hemphill, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Can we avoid wars at the crossroads of history? This question has been
pursued by individuals, scholars, policymakers, and organizations throughout
human history. In this research, we attempt to answer the question based on the
recent advances of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Large Language Models
(LLMs). We propose \textbf{WarAgent}, an LLM-powered multi-agent AI system, to
simulate the participating countries, their decisions, and the consequences, in
historical international conflicts, including the World War I (WWI), the World
War II (WWII), and the Warring States Period (WSP) in Ancient China. By
evaluating the simulation effectiveness, we examine the advancements and
limitations of cutting-edge AI systems' abilities in studying complex
collective human behaviors such as international conflicts under diverse
settings. In these simulations, the emergent interactions among agents also
offer a novel perspective for examining the triggers and conditions that lead
to war. Our findings offer data-driven and AI-augmented insights that can
redefine how we approach conflict resolution and peacekeeping strategies. The
implications stretch beyond historical analysis, offering a blueprint for using
AI to understand human history and possibly prevent future international
conflicts. Code and data are available at
\url{https://github.com/agiresearch/WarAgent}.
|
[
-0.6757922173,
-0.8853319287,
0.7199240327,
0.0484081581,
0.0481804498,
0.34776631,
-0.0382912569,
-0.6561764479,
-0.2531821728,
0.4008957446,
-0.5822826624,
-0.23881872,
-0.6963134408,
-0.1220322922,
-0.1752949804,
0.6699461937,
0.057587903,
0.1317769736,
-0.0778784454,
-0.1166824326,
-0.1018059179,
-0.7976753116,
-0.9926807284,
-0.8738167286,
0.24876526,
-0.0050418326,
0.9711632729,
0.6366930008,
0.7764707208,
0.4918703735,
-0.0448990613,
0.2100320309,
-0.6148109436,
0.3045473397,
-0.1669746786,
-0.3077390492,
-0.3999883235,
0.2954506576,
0.3840124011,
0.2564062178,
-0.1271450818,
-0.2229674757,
0.0390656814,
0.2230459452,
-0.1181711331,
0.2042883188,
-0.4504852891,
0.0663577095,
0.1028425097,
0.0340483002,
-0.2264012545,
0.0042788475,
0.25483796,
-0.7531552911,
0.077268362,
0.2602385581,
0.794274807,
0.3935793638,
-0.5366701484,
0.0896975622,
-1.0198423862,
0.8036476374,
-0.5012661219,
0.1027477682,
0.1667645574,
0.2805632353,
-0.7668178678,
-0.8999314904,
-0.7157108188,
-0.1719767749,
0.2725431323,
0.5637726188,
-0.4143656194,
-0.0282688979,
0.4300010204,
-0.1112114713,
-0.6128047705,
-0.0081650103,
-0.2598052323,
-0.1260142475,
0.8258915544,
0.3599455357,
0.6385818124,
0.1403580606,
-0.7239218354,
-0.1232209131,
-0.5875833035,
0.2787072659,
0.224264577,
0.0525319427,
-0.4236190915,
0.3248152733,
-0.0198585279,
0.3264232576,
-0.2042752802,
-0.4751271904,
-0.3469339013,
-0.0806985423,
0.007068791,
-0.1321794987,
0.9797782302,
0.5561895967,
0.2940209806,
-0.1213011295,
-0.0535325967,
0.3796986341,
0.3941917717,
-0.855355382,
0.0560119227,
0.0524545237,
-0.5428325534,
-0.3350297511,
0.0065217288,
-0.9369691014,
-0.5956157446,
-0.2075866014,
0.4316072464,
-0.4263254106,
-0.2268463075,
-0.1335840374,
-0.3294045031,
0.0881561041,
0.2555831075,
-0.1219764575,
0.2949023843,
0.793617785,
0.876408875,
-0.1134063751,
-0.7946223617,
-0.4968320131,
0.0130409496,
-0.4266177416,
0.6480728388,
-0.5659281015,
-0.8980084062,
-0.0358376577,
-0.1603132039,
0.3743848801,
-0.3563047349,
0.2338499874,
-0.6496114731,
-0.234091863,
0.0842524394,
-0.5351118445,
-0.2189068347,
0.3175010979,
-0.9945958257,
0.5889245272,
-0.2308770418,
-0.178303659,
0.0433958471,
-0.6760755777,
-0.6126124859,
0.0533301979,
-0.3081828356,
-0.4713265002,
-0.1171140224,
-0.2111567706,
-0.0873195231,
-0.7581846118,
0.3964310586,
-0.2834154069,
-0.3678138852,
0.2947601378,
-0.3499015272,
0.6654714346,
0.3264536262,
-0.5888410807,
0.1907009631,
-0.3033030629,
-0.1608850807,
0.3206986189,
-0.2489814907,
-0.0118256863,
0.3033877909,
-0.4504081011,
0.5030468702,
0.1176021248,
-0.532787025,
0.3543602228,
-0.1809239089,
0.3647722006,
0.64103055,
0.292529285,
0.3420416117,
-0.8354831338,
0.4542326331,
0.0669120029,
0.3682072163,
0.3189258575,
-0.8620145321,
-0.5299461484,
0.0541039445,
0.0297150183,
0.6767525673,
-0.9131817222,
0.0857019052,
0.0771951899,
-0.6854929924,
-0.1240136325,
-0.2871634066,
0.1484357715,
0.0548112318,
0.1493572295,
-0.1804353744,
-0.8669376373,
-0.283198148,
-0.1263944656,
-0.665435791,
0.2083665729,
0.196782276,
0.3608746529,
-0.3059497476,
1.0615290403,
-0.0724652931,
0.2548077703,
-0.3503346443,
0.3169047236,
-0.4059952497,
0.3749348223,
0.3989965916,
-1.2590157986,
-0.1422165185,
-0.0613026433,
-0.8377023935,
0.2158206552,
-0.3038600385,
-0.38772282,
-0.0675898045,
0.5651959181,
-0.5977158546,
0.6252670884,
0.5273278952,
-0.0256196186,
0.5486271977,
-0.1397901177,
0.4970248044,
-1.0844241381,
0.2419082671,
-0.1597074568,
0.061591845,
-0.9173440337,
0.0935111046,
-0.3123925626,
-0.6106324196,
-0.5786367059,
0.7551835179,
-0.0848257691,
0.1978551298,
-0.3724600673,
0.2307297587,
0.1320095509,
0.1647698879,
0.0646526888,
0.8114688993,
0.2719191611,
-0.6003824472,
0.5840842724,
0.1989806145,
-0.054835517,
0.4520073235,
-0.3398232162,
0.0486202054,
-0.0002580966,
0.336134553,
-0.6129811406,
0.0045184088,
0.3021460474,
-0.340996027,
-0.1848424375,
0.0229098368,
-0.0702790469,
-0.2529724538,
-0.1985649467,
0.4689238966,
0.6331472397,
-0.388861537,
0.7862423658,
0.4480718672,
-0.2661919296,
-0.5293012261,
-0.3797227144,
0.1591759473,
-0.1774615198,
-0.365321219,
0.1724594682,
-0.5674468875,
-0.7959472537,
-0.023135215,
0.2203768939,
-0.4599478543,
-0.000213698,
0.7609269023,
0.3838943541,
-0.0186790172,
0.2280589491,
-0.4538009465,
-0.2615729272,
-0.0172007568,
-0.1850938946,
0.4781267643,
-0.0698469877,
-0.4113022983,
-0.1723918021,
0.5748351812,
0.841647923,
-0.2475254387,
0.5147569776,
0.3225693405,
-0.2793932855,
0.0651846826,
-0.4598278105,
0.0017627329,
-0.4502854645,
0.2569488883,
-0.159179762,
-0.8513210416,
0.5224639177,
-0.6914494038,
0.1097851619,
0.4364233017,
0.6260421872,
0.1205248162,
0.8774719238,
0.6596356034,
-0.5635737777,
0.4027990699,
-0.1298692375,
0.466194272,
-0.405642122,
-0.252804637,
-0.3354347348,
-0.2221308798,
-0.6986600161,
-0.394797653,
0.7296644449,
-0.2199163437,
-0.4500365555,
-0.4017612636,
-0.1998505145,
0.2754999697,
0.6410919428,
-0.0957468897,
0.2152934819,
-0.1124389768,
0.3466624022,
0.1198344827,
-0.6535577178,
-0.3051173985,
0.5991421938,
-0.1221912727,
0.7675172687,
-0.0469128452,
0.7505277395,
0.4194444418,
0.1254815459,
-0.8112478256,
0.6365695596,
0.1579875946,
-0.4775772393,
-0.4108293355,
-0.5472745895,
-1.1670564413,
0.2861970961,
-0.1374856234,
-0.5130262375,
0.1343833804,
-0.2652125657,
-0.5452222824,
0.5012208223,
-0.155478552,
0.6716592312,
-0.3895624578,
-0.1733746231,
-0.3688312471,
-0.6225723624,
0.0933932662,
0.1565809399,
0.510545373,
-0.059216179,
-0.1133703217,
0.5941480398,
-0.2703579068,
0.8117936254,
0.293397218,
0.0620058291,
0.7361936569,
0.116111733,
0.4735177755,
-0.2231861949,
-0.2079246193,
0.3001104295,
-0.2347460687,
-0.3869323134,
-0.3768190444,
0.7881591916,
-1.228703022,
-0.6403751373,
-0.5379925966,
-0.7533668876,
0.2677208483,
0.2964020669,
0.266186744,
0.3964138329,
-0.7453148365,
-0.3789447844,
0.4884929657,
-0.0799298584,
0.6444600224,
0.4414630532,
-0.246825397,
-0.3498077989,
1.1269081831,
0.3102762401,
0.0669415593,
0.0407325663,
0.3213115335,
0.0372015238,
-0.2853418887,
-0.4087873697,
0.1622413993,
-0.5063096881,
-0.4754043818,
-0.0960368887,
-0.2392138988,
-0.0875065848,
-0.2512437105,
-0.09326794,
0.1337666065,
0.1666783094,
0.3466930687,
0.5169231296,
1.2170054913,
-0.3610714078,
0.2597387135,
-0.6237169504,
0.4751524925,
0.3173047006,
0.2476834357,
-0.0830188915,
0.0575550385,
-0.1248660237,
0.1526045203,
-0.4100917578,
-0.9352012277,
0.3110506833,
-0.1042738557,
0.3320249021,
0.1925037652,
0.3839102983,
0.569217205,
-0.6378991008,
0.9870331287,
-0.1066100821,
-0.7404934168,
0.1601539701,
-0.127061516,
0.3079673648,
-0.0384829752,
0.1381795406,
-0.6023592949,
-0.4701708853,
-0.9913383722,
-0.7614355087,
0.6616056561,
-0.0626400933,
-0.3294569254,
0.2765697539,
0.2488589734,
-0.1000172272,
0.2393113673,
-0.4082327187,
-0.1793261915,
-0.0446807295,
0.0035176293,
-0.0660282224,
0.0716667697,
-0.3331109881,
0.2200829685,
0.9662033916,
0.1421056688,
0.0668578744,
0.1859740764,
0.007138107,
-0.4512171745,
0.3213511705,
0.4338475168,
0.6880943179,
0.3505383134,
0.0851942003,
0.2167622,
-0.4798648059,
0.5444353223,
0.3194319606,
-0.3026705086,
-0.0658309385,
0.3381330669,
0.4693438411,
-0.1260625273,
-0.9348886013,
0.4810632765,
-0.3301770389,
-0.1165248305,
-0.4087913334,
-0.045861546,
-0.1304136664,
0.9843437672,
0.3679935634,
-0.0736430436,
0.1150763854,
-0.7022934556,
0.298135221,
0.4480031133,
0.051595699,
0.0501838438,
0.3287266493,
0.2939606607,
-0.7368823886,
0.1831633598,
-0.3356954455,
-0.6041075587,
0.8778918386,
0.4444364011,
0.3822863102,
-0.4498132765,
0.2427477241,
0.0644957647,
0.2991888523,
-0.0683594123,
0.308863759,
0.3205353916,
-0.4615681171,
-0.419352293,
-0.3820896745,
-0.8087531924,
0.4787116647,
-0.427988112,
-0.223165974,
-0.4637959003,
-0.3661077321,
-0.2250404507,
0.2710576952,
-0.6825101376,
0.1086336002,
0.327636838,
0.4281036854,
-0.5030218959,
0.5040634871,
0.4871989489,
-0.1719340384,
-0.5958784819,
0.2212863714,
0.31044963,
-0.3549324572,
0.2679154873,
-0.1411063522,
-0.5474350452,
-0.0710934922,
-0.6215909123,
-0.729794383,
0.7248814106,
0.4301144481,
-0.4152854979,
0.220639348,
0.2730765045,
0.4840443134,
-0.3429152071,
-0.0332850665,
0.7422118783,
0.7349424958,
-0.312147975,
-0.631985724,
-0.1611437947,
-0.2836565375,
0.1009270847,
0.2766054273,
-1.0196205378,
0.8422912359,
-0.2606632411,
-0.2925389111,
0.5735349655,
0.6719812155,
0.056842275,
0.5923312306,
0.4076937735,
0.3497848511,
0.433604598,
-0.285487026,
0.9715476632,
-0.3837724328,
0.2988493443,
0.7006121874,
-0.3835916817,
0.4477051795,
0.1498157531,
-0.0992779657,
0.3092523217,
0.3445377946,
-0.0759968162,
0.1168735847,
0.0584386401,
-0.4075132608,
-0.3360656202,
-0.4737863243,
-0.3246392608,
0.6067843437,
0.1605068147,
0.3014179766,
-0.3730150163,
-0.0338551477,
0.162361294,
0.0385502912,
-0.1309078634,
1.0377908945,
0.0498256423,
-0.4953493178,
0.4117776155,
-0.2037147582,
0.2947252691,
-0.8650886416,
-0.4187239408,
0.0299017057,
-0.0393258594,
0.1917193383,
-0.5399788618,
-0.2984098196,
-0.0974778756,
-0.2834001482,
0.3097748458,
0.4482345283,
-0.6058288813,
-0.3974558711,
0.4653038979,
0.95669204,
0.0834538043,
0.2093901783,
-0.6814976931,
0.6064858437,
-0.2302382588,
-0.24586384,
0.2609600723,
0.6508569121,
-0.0868069232,
0.6054846644,
0.5070025921,
0.2987850904,
-0.3482973278,
-0.004863366,
0.7929337025,
-0.6455065012,
-0.5113765597,
-1.1014155149,
0.2125280052,
-0.3362942338,
-0.111217618,
0.2433419377,
0.3589945138,
0.6654549241,
0.2746222615,
1.4697166681,
-0.0890808627,
0.2486150265,
-0.0657835975,
0.724506259,
-0.5176647305,
-0.3421480954,
-0.1343655586,
-0.3699856997,
-0.1421434879,
0.2517620027,
-0.1945063919,
-0.110098891,
0.5153275728,
0.6202599406,
0.2562514246,
0.0500293225,
0.5612097383,
0.1440502703,
0.5680547357,
0.4098869562,
1.122918129,
-0.247205317,
0.8669317961,
-0.3067597151,
-0.2340573519,
-0.3764130771,
-0.4981214106,
-0.6201924086,
-0.5553100705,
0.329369545,
-0.2214676142,
0.5627152324,
0.9413725138,
0.3479941487,
-0.411944896,
-0.6754043102,
0.5330782533,
0.3460500538,
-0.3414436877,
-0.0693080053,
0.1440015584,
-0.1413773894,
-0.8542436957,
0.5519137383,
0.2265232354,
0.406040132,
-0.2077851146,
-0.3970114589,
-0.0378554463,
0.3119849563,
0.6875759363,
0.5126783252,
-0.9300313592,
-0.4368217289,
-0.4088889062,
-0.0807697326,
0.0205067676,
1.1228077412,
-0.6344407201,
0.6519339085,
0.2061596662,
0.6748828888,
-0.0466718823,
0.0322537571,
0.7638223171,
-0.4026895165,
0.6986659765,
0.2859119773,
0.3866790831,
0.2282900065,
-0.3807456195,
0.6557012796,
0.2177422792,
-0.725414753,
-0.6406934261,
0.3711108863,
-0.3331842422,
-0.3781263232,
0.7816708088,
-0.1679441333,
-0.0155624812,
-0.2048354,
-0.4378172755,
0.7662703991,
-0.7142941356,
0.9226663709,
0.7393680811,
-0.52808249,
0.1489629447,
-0.5405545235,
0.5287029147,
0.152516976,
-0.9256104827,
-0.1020235866,
0.5369682312,
-0.354695946,
0.2546125054,
0.2743970454,
0.4009466171,
0.4975082576,
0.2504214048,
0.200873971,
0.0382386036,
-0.5987079144,
-0.1413449347,
0.1194244921,
0.086831592,
0.1486876458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17213v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17213v3
|
General-Purpose vs. Domain-Adapted Large Language Models for Extraction of Structured Data from Chest Radiology Reports
| 2023-11-28T20:34:40 | 2024-04-09T13:46:46 |
Ali H. Dhanaliwala, Rikhiya Ghosh, Sanjeev Kumar Karn, Poikavila Ullaskrishnan, Oladimeji Farri, Dorin Comaniciu, Charles E. Kahn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.IV
|
Radiologists produce unstructured data that can be valuable for clinical care
when consumed by information systems. However, variability in style limits
usage. Study compares system using domain-adapted language model (RadLing) and
general-purpose LLM (GPT-4) in extracting relevant features from chest
radiology reports and standardizing them to common data elements (CDEs). Three
radiologists annotated a retrospective dataset of 1399 chest XR reports (900
training, 499 test) and mapped to 44 pre-selected relevant CDEs. GPT-4 system
was prompted with report, feature set, value set, and dynamic few-shots to
extract values and map to CDEs. Output key:value pairs were compared to
reference standard at both stages and an identical match was considered TP. F1
score for extraction was 97% for RadLing-based system and 78% for GPT-4 system.
F1 score for mapping was 98% for RadLing and 94% for GPT-4; difference was
statistically significant (P<.001). RadLing's domain-adapted embeddings were
better in feature extraction and its light-weight mapper had better f1 score in
CDE assignment. RadLing system also demonstrated higher capabilities in
differentiating between absent (99% vs 64%) and unspecified (99% vs 89%).
RadLing system's domain-adapted embeddings helped improve performance of GPT-4
system to 92% by giving more relevant few-shot prompts. RadLing system offers
operational advantages including local deployment and reduced runtime costs.
|
[
-0.1216403544,
-0.5845529437,
0.6550406814,
0.3252331316,
-0.3769170642,
-0.0194679182,
-0.2627491057,
-0.7558221817,
0.0643746778,
0.6211018562,
-0.077055268,
-0.60335958,
-0.876873374,
0.1752751917,
-0.3771986067,
0.9863317609,
-0.1299858689,
-0.3013153374,
-0.0690631568,
-0.118620418,
-0.8577373028,
-0.5773297548,
-0.4339767694,
-0.4517712295,
0.3126786053,
0.2204997391,
0.862914443,
0.5345163941,
0.7588682771,
0.2988184094,
0.2890581489,
0.0353077278,
-0.2626234591,
0.2874341309,
0.0153860394,
-0.0258317292,
-0.7346996069,
0.0042056809,
0.1027370393,
0.2934399545,
-0.0985597074,
-0.0540905334,
0.0491857901,
0.7708679438,
-0.7099275589,
0.4067057669,
-0.2663474083,
0.0316630565,
-0.290106982,
-0.6280651689,
-0.3995229602,
-0.2209623456,
0.4884124994,
-0.677972436,
0.19448632,
-0.1820152402,
1.0531129837,
-0.1529988199,
-0.1440936476,
-0.7411067486,
-0.8380708098,
0.818823576,
-0.4985667467,
0.2998333871,
0.4579717517,
0.4389516115,
0.2107627243,
-0.9962402582,
0.0815491751,
-0.0431749038,
-0.1504087895,
0.2399113327,
-0.5654322505,
-0.1380123645,
0.0103194751,
0.3887162507,
-0.7807136774,
0.1310014427,
-0.5411785245,
-0.0056851371,
0.8071365356,
0.0737341717,
0.2252906859,
-0.1902674586,
-0.3928517103,
-0.137983039,
-0.8021144271,
-0.2670068741,
-0.3318625093,
0.4444210827,
-0.2184502035,
0.3564195633,
-0.3046107888,
0.6810430884,
0.0856988877,
-0.4505367279,
0.557138443,
-0.0718683749,
-0.6851753592,
-0.0030164279,
0.6179302335,
0.1024840102,
0.5171781182,
-0.235207811,
-0.4428969324,
-0.0741577446,
0.2422305644,
-0.5384924412,
-0.2690708041,
0.0988359153,
-0.6922393441,
-0.3803080618,
0.2141903788,
-0.4868091643,
-0.160150826,
-0.312140435,
0.3458456695,
-0.5338107347,
-0.1408736855,
0.3542313874,
-0.1098334342,
0.2358587831,
0.515914917,
-0.595826745,
0.4166723192,
0.6537559628,
1.07673347,
-0.4919189215,
0.3019670248,
-0.5096627474,
0.1902706772,
-0.0274103042,
1.1010241508,
-0.708947897,
-0.6672943234,
0.0979551822,
-0.0720864609,
-0.1166781858,
-0.9753147364,
0.5282090902,
-0.7067444324,
0.2932517231,
-0.0612452999,
-0.5009636283,
-0.064158991,
0.0340097845,
-0.6188566685,
0.8311616778,
0.3230625391,
-0.2909514606,
0.4089111984,
-0.4927417636,
-0.3100542128,
0.4121492207,
-0.5556392074,
-0.396050632,
0.1894711107,
0.3740442097,
0.706992507,
-0.4160726666,
0.2765556872,
-0.0437169969,
-0.3379056454,
0.4194300473,
-0.2407972664,
0.5414689779,
0.4122830331,
-0.1557316333,
-0.2380689532,
-0.6865090728,
0.2925680578,
0.1061199233,
-0.5082018971,
-0.2893705368,
-0.1878276318,
0.172523126,
0.3288822174,
-0.1777178347,
-0.3347003758,
0.233133167,
-0.0428600311,
0.0820768625,
0.538815856,
0.196710676,
0.2581495643,
-0.678011477,
0.9308612347,
-0.0977898762,
0.0093625225,
0.073366113,
-0.5656455755,
-0.1245666221,
-0.9573972821,
0.3697398901,
0.4822862744,
-0.5102508068,
0.2606993616,
-0.3593057692,
-0.2434069067,
-0.3160366714,
-0.0362512954,
0.4232124388,
0.3313929737,
0.3106749952,
-0.5352374315,
-0.3388499022,
-0.8592259884,
0.1261724979,
0.1791962236,
-0.3047509491,
0.2567551434,
0.1195724085,
-0.1519010663,
0.8281849027,
-0.7957262397,
-0.6780223846,
-0.3864783943,
0.1676052511,
0.2972897291,
0.0330614187,
0.5807333589,
-0.6808684468,
-0.625654757,
0.1911859512,
-0.9909074903,
-0.4102524817,
0.0107949153,
0.1788586527,
0.432221204,
0.2289354205,
-0.3511747122,
0.7373618484,
0.5790976882,
0.1298688054,
0.4205634296,
-0.4493965805,
0.2238207757,
-0.5400871634,
0.2537661791,
0.1395656466,
-0.239428997,
-0.6696712971,
-0.0399307869,
0.1554051489,
-0.1788842529,
-0.2324708849,
0.3279881179,
-0.784630537,
-0.2796790898,
-0.3591489792,
0.2754264176,
0.2834767401,
0.0289888103,
0.3178669214,
0.4781644046,
0.3706061244,
-0.5302667022,
0.2433984727,
0.2428532094,
-0.3042037785,
0.2804647684,
-0.7475294471,
0.3406468332,
0.3017576933,
0.1555564702,
-0.5882839561,
-0.0096221874,
0.0073789223,
-0.2347500771,
0.766207099,
-0.1292324215,
-0.2792444527,
-0.1655302197,
-0.4261661768,
0.2796517909,
0.5339100957,
-0.1020947397,
0.3268668652,
0.3335412741,
-0.5506038666,
-0.4297961295,
-0.6495120525,
0.0924082249,
-0.209357515,
-0.5498920083,
0.4146511853,
0.1376069635,
-0.1176233962,
0.1360682994,
-0.1254651397,
-0.3295303881,
-0.0731884688,
0.2723483741,
0.4619894922,
-0.5225314498,
0.0941686183,
-0.3794401288,
-0.3590268791,
-0.1462816149,
0.0224882513,
0.3644267917,
-0.1140766889,
-0.4225879908,
-0.2485657632,
0.5299807191,
0.3413199484,
-0.0899084285,
0.2963017225,
0.2541029751,
-0.3343695104,
-0.0958176926,
-0.5394524336,
0.0902267247,
-0.4303814769,
0.3717192709,
-0.4706403911,
-0.8584048748,
0.2731138468,
-0.0156691428,
-0.170252189,
0.5159778595,
0.5589437485,
-0.0559916124,
0.5657951832,
0.6689170599,
-0.1241303161,
0.091930151,
-0.0295722261,
0.340030849,
-0.7395251989,
-0.2053842098,
-0.6837713122,
-0.2011896223,
-0.5980053544,
-0.257969588,
0.6490819454,
-0.2334003597,
0.2090230882,
-0.1880854219,
-0.7919849157,
0.1828166395,
0.1956709474,
0.1125927269,
0.4756387472,
0.4032342732,
0.3060587347,
-0.2021475732,
-0.5291599035,
-0.4833160639,
1.3773280382,
0.2386695445,
0.8517730236,
0.2396634519,
0.7517715096,
0.4031686783,
0.3655503094,
-0.8321188092,
0.2417377383,
-0.5990275741,
-0.4022590816,
-0.087002635,
-0.089191407,
-1.1530183554,
0.1075302586,
-0.3484852612,
-0.5078029037,
0.4477668107,
-0.2278169692,
-0.3950547278,
-0.0997627899,
-0.53416574,
0.296127677,
-0.176436916,
0.0472943336,
-0.0185475331,
-0.4069644809,
0.2601181567,
-0.4781319797,
0.348341018,
-0.0551654845,
-0.0633041337,
0.5805359483,
-0.322401315,
0.6690695286,
-0.065353401,
0.1087771133,
0.0828734934,
0.1228446066,
0.154211536,
-0.2094717026,
-0.1067636684,
0.2205839604,
0.0687881932,
-0.2352094054,
-0.6818233728,
0.6880102754,
-0.9405919909,
-0.5423574448,
-0.8619253039,
-0.5433620811,
-0.1897128969,
-0.0481853597,
0.3138769865,
0.8679376245,
-0.3010375798,
0.3765760362,
0.5847963691,
-0.3887659907,
0.1289621741,
0.6503490806,
-0.2123008221,
-0.2168139517,
0.6715478301,
0.3249648809,
0.2922653854,
0.5211861134,
0.3158734441,
0.0092879189,
-0.6596972942,
-0.181247279,
0.360006839,
-0.668245554,
-0.608524859,
-0.6349577308,
-0.4877356589,
-0.385411948,
-0.4975722134,
-0.0785500705,
-0.4752082527,
-0.175069049,
0.0810225084,
0.5593788028,
0.9341416955,
-0.2065379471,
0.0910206065,
-0.9107903838,
0.2136231363,
0.0797332078,
-0.0471793078,
-0.3804820776,
-0.7316582203,
-0.3936797082,
-0.5171957016,
-0.4056001902,
-0.9235761762,
0.6068453193,
0.4524942636,
0.4969953597,
0.3432097435,
-0.0984836295,
0.7655067444,
-0.2012539357,
0.5205631256,
0.1581531018,
-0.7001134753,
0.502730608,
-0.3112806082,
0.3877567947,
0.3276524842,
0.3206624091,
-0.3582881987,
-0.3571316302,
-0.5911743641,
-0.916377306,
0.7033047676,
-0.045095671,
-0.1983451694,
-0.1725835353,
0.6180775166,
0.1253366321,
-0.0512184873,
-0.504291594,
-0.1519199908,
0.0575129725,
-0.2676135898,
-0.0305400733,
-0.3754659891,
-0.1897284389,
0.013217872,
0.5715041757,
-0.1166620255,
0.5751844645,
0.3952631652,
-0.3270677328,
-0.1051230207,
0.4120699763,
0.6009917259,
0.9798068404,
-0.332036376,
0.0825946555,
-0.1799245328,
-0.6929154992,
0.0057476177,
-0.0307780504,
-0.0630251244,
0.042131044,
0.7849600315,
0.3064878583,
0.4067153037,
-0.3277561069,
0.6221755743,
0.0286031719,
-0.2942928076,
-0.1161453202,
0.0138322683,
0.0046486962,
0.1907320023,
0.368111223,
-0.0266766306,
0.2322406322,
-0.3641465902,
0.277035594,
0.2186841071,
-0.3318807781,
-0.4306719601,
0.1052851751,
-0.0444050692,
0.0586373769,
0.5980417728,
0.1938753724,
0.1362163574,
0.4379236996,
0.8238459229,
0.9283487201,
-0.4093077481,
0.4035329819,
0.1949970126,
0.1353021562,
-0.1443786919,
0.1404827237,
0.3252584636,
-0.6588973403,
-0.4490487278,
-0.2236716598,
-0.1898457408,
0.3164139688,
-1.153645277,
0.3372141421,
-0.5584840775,
-0.0014616657,
-0.0583096594,
0.1113314852,
-1.0221390724,
0.346201539,
0.1184400022,
0.838950336,
-0.9133672118,
0.9610003829,
0.7110950947,
-0.3896411657,
-0.8346920013,
-0.3463392854,
0.3392394483,
-1.1246594191,
0.809619844,
-0.1185162291,
0.0460371971,
-0.4960154593,
-0.1653497368,
-0.9576494098,
1.4163161516,
0.0778973326,
-0.4435339272,
0.0712960288,
0.1068149507,
0.5176640153,
-0.8182596564,
0.2621474564,
0.6610245109,
0.2608133256,
0.0548302159,
-0.9798589349,
0.3168723285,
-0.035993617,
-0.0165306889,
0.0482238084,
-0.1518423408,
0.7433009744,
0.1199828461,
-0.3278341591,
-0.107370615,
0.3016133606,
0.4337979257,
0.366876781,
0.1441218555,
0.3675728738,
0.7601075768,
0.0393471196,
1.2884092331,
0.1084540635,
0.2437377423,
0.9244665504,
-0.6149690151,
0.8944211602,
0.2090316415,
-0.164440006,
0.6602131724,
0.1802400649,
0.2099068761,
0.725515902,
-0.144239381,
-0.2062223554,
-0.0193711445,
0.2569408715,
-0.6024747491,
0.597109437,
0.4852783382,
-0.3597946167,
-0.3064139485,
-0.0337863527,
0.1392123103,
-0.2215585858,
0.1259394288,
0.9574720263,
0.4152012765,
-0.2971580029,
0.7523385882,
-0.0451647192,
0.4679473042,
-0.9863731861,
0.0943590701,
-0.2603541315,
0.2591221929,
-0.438211441,
-0.5576022267,
0.4522672892,
0.2172127664,
-0.3534024954,
-0.2508440316,
0.9233967066,
-0.010050918,
-0.360085547,
0.3180915415,
0.7756288648,
0.1428560466,
-0.040201202,
-0.6926000118,
0.5301288366,
0.0607415698,
-0.3742131293,
0.7355589271,
0.569678545,
-0.2912124395,
0.4384567142,
0.3932107985,
0.4960564375,
-0.3735163808,
0.1827268004,
1.0038272142,
-0.6638000011,
-0.2811309099,
-0.4727487862,
0.3451648951,
0.0118803708,
-0.3104180992,
0.4747411609,
0.3588117659,
0.4242947698,
-0.0351601839,
0.9472420216,
0.0058457013,
0.4666187167,
-0.7242982388,
0.3007081747,
-0.3455135822,
0.5092409253,
-0.3507852256,
-0.7803842425,
-0.7167478204,
0.6454046369,
-0.4729680121,
0.1353180557,
1.020427227,
0.6591388583,
-0.2814405859,
0.0436943769,
0.5350784063,
0.1888593733,
0.5191469789,
0.4032904804,
0.5120942593,
-0.3319680393,
0.351326257,
0.0731403753,
-0.6100458503,
-0.4125734568,
-0.8202844262,
-0.2945290506,
-0.3103300035,
-0.6196216941,
-0.1832752377,
0.0931996852,
0.5967132449,
0.7684368491,
-0.7023921609,
-0.23991853,
0.7977852225,
-0.4118771851,
-0.2334321141,
-0.2273499817,
0.6738374233,
-0.363083452,
-0.1385735869,
0.4731841385,
0.7196258307,
-0.3467332721,
0.3028483093,
-0.03598544,
0.0092183566,
-0.1027833447,
0.6898120046,
0.3284938633,
-0.5575719476,
-0.5512140393,
0.0806524977,
-0.1674554199,
0.3378107846,
0.990880549,
-0.7458407879,
0.5279244184,
0.2195260674,
0.5420840979,
0.7467353344,
-0.0288420748,
0.5281883478,
-0.7873526216,
0.133398667,
0.147223562,
0.2970632613,
0.2910806239,
-0.4664199948,
0.381283015,
0.213107571,
-0.8341023922,
-0.4500966966,
0.0817936137,
-1.190890789,
-0.340686202,
1.165215373,
-0.3039394021,
0.027157383,
-0.4545353651,
-0.0414657369,
-0.1234095097,
-0.294837147,
0.5630078316,
0.4751194119,
-0.5731075406,
-0.0337553211,
-0.691996336,
0.3681041002,
0.0280040316,
-0.6998860836,
-0.3719502687,
0.5879482627,
0.5682401657,
0.078071095,
1.289178133,
-0.6791630983,
0.3971780539,
-0.506126821,
0.0653198063,
-0.0682020411,
-0.0466920696,
-0.7115260959,
0.3966490924,
0.196600616,
-0.0422312394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17154v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17154v1
|
Pragmatic Radiology Report Generation
| 2023-11-28T19:00:03 | 2023-11-28T19:00:03 |
Dang Nguyen, Chacha Chen, He He, Chenhao Tan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
When pneumonia is not found on a chest X-ray, should the report describe this
negative observation or omit it? We argue that this question cannot be answered
from the X-ray alone and requires a pragmatic perspective, which captures the
communicative goal that radiology reports serve between radiologists and
patients. However, the standard image-to-text formulation for radiology report
generation fails to incorporate such pragmatic intents. Following this
pragmatic perspective, we demonstrate that the indication, which describes why
a patient comes for an X-ray, drives the mentions of negative observations and
introduce indications as additional input to report generation. With respect to
the output, we develop a framework to identify uninferable information from the
image as a source of model hallucinations, and limit them by cleaning
groundtruth reports. Finally, we use indications and cleaned groundtruth
reports to develop pragmatic models, and show that they outperform existing
methods not only in new pragmatics-inspired metrics (+4.3 Negative F1) but also
in standard metrics (+6.3 Positive F1 and +11.0 BLEU-2).
|
[
-0.350815773,
-0.2072103322,
1.099820137,
-0.0300215762,
-0.4475256801,
-0.5555430055,
0.0012624844,
-0.2562278211,
0.4562109411,
0.6630529761,
-0.3850936294,
-0.5726262331,
-1.0648897886,
-0.1647031009,
-0.5001061559,
1.0827583075,
0.1849578619,
-0.2805272937,
-0.0959686562,
0.0790248737,
-0.6431601048,
-0.4682079852,
-0.3117923737,
-0.3488580883,
0.3892325461,
0.5736768842,
1.1595767736,
0.702696681,
0.6619996428,
0.0839566365,
0.2974534035,
0.2429037541,
-0.3951547146,
-0.0147040803,
0.020068679,
-0.1820094436,
-0.2091548294,
0.0938015729,
0.5362027884,
0.7716807127,
-0.0347506814,
-0.036876332,
-0.4256488383,
0.4620673358,
-0.7853593826,
0.1173930541,
-0.2244557291,
0.3638376892,
-0.0051806211,
-0.7097015977,
-0.7416880131,
-0.0816382468,
0.2132555544,
-0.5432344079,
0.3188650906,
-0.2237030268,
1.0128663778,
-0.2568307817,
-0.2786354721,
-0.7154716849,
-0.754971385,
0.6124430895,
-0.4801025391,
0.2695886493,
0.5450819731,
0.1929282695,
-0.0344726741,
-0.9187964797,
-0.1237314418,
-0.3040870428,
-0.5959885716,
0.2297115028,
-0.5279577971,
0.0003425291,
0.0549356155,
0.2839798629,
-0.6324324012,
-0.0729254112,
-0.5703315139,
-0.4042308629,
0.7701907158,
0.0737551749,
0.2624240518,
-0.3631530702,
-0.3861170411,
0.2337529361,
-0.5969696641,
-0.3644322753,
-0.1112078503,
0.189120248,
-0.0921606869,
0.3899460733,
-0.1935995668,
0.889531672,
0.1699480861,
-0.3875945807,
0.3880650401,
0.1437888741,
-0.2857798338,
0.4849737883,
0.3370627761,
0.6549323797,
-0.0269463342,
-0.2628429532,
-0.1252818257,
0.2636694312,
0.387419492,
-0.7473472953,
-0.5220976472,
0.2807338834,
-0.826494813,
-0.6273058653,
0.2947614193,
-0.5873078704,
-0.5719774961,
-0.3040533066,
0.3409105241,
-0.300596565,
-0.3463097215,
0.0528732166,
-0.3312004507,
0.0791881755,
0.5983581543,
-0.0866018832,
0.2919176221,
0.5658677816,
0.6332814693,
0.5660017133,
-0.0699558556,
-0.9987604618,
0.0669526309,
-0.6137626171,
1.0477283001,
-0.612193346,
-0.621278584,
0.0885298327,
0.0476121902,
0.050057102,
-0.7101429701,
0.559640944,
0.1014710367,
0.4506039023,
-0.1298458278,
-0.3450864553,
-0.5172755122,
-0.0300909784,
-0.2380013615,
0.3430278003,
0.2095717788,
-0.6204074621,
0.4131335318,
-0.1165808737,
-0.5692503452,
0.3138770163,
-0.5369099975,
-0.404222697,
0.6302816272,
-0.1180100963,
0.2998663783,
-0.3325027823,
0.7144474983,
0.1710196584,
-0.4153425395,
0.4783149958,
-0.3528712988,
0.6277425885,
0.2677484751,
-0.2603552639,
-0.0343708545,
-0.9187517762,
0.2607785463,
0.1711363345,
0.0716590658,
-0.036633756,
0.0502240546,
-0.3587620258,
0.3372985721,
-0.0900297314,
-0.4251632094,
-0.332077831,
-0.0354389399,
0.284987241,
0.3997716308,
0.3945343792,
-0.0353836045,
-1.0361206532,
0.494741559,
0.3949788213,
0.0510549657,
-0.410212189,
-0.7308734655,
-0.6707637906,
-0.5980269909,
-0.3004285395,
0.3246277869,
-0.1750955135,
0.0515156686,
-0.0589487515,
-0.7725138664,
-0.4427375197,
-0.1945210695,
0.447738409,
0.934617877,
0.2121911198,
-0.6168866754,
-0.6328097582,
-1.027962923,
-0.1686122566,
-0.3582781255,
0.1760870963,
0.3300077617,
0.2127708346,
-0.0853867233,
0.3926931024,
-0.7326670885,
-0.6353167892,
-0.2079292536,
0.3240532577,
0.2910146713,
0.2127180994,
0.312833786,
-0.8353153467,
-0.1216424182,
-0.1252876073,
-1.1070872545,
-0.1755135804,
-0.2250005752,
0.2020551562,
-0.0747689754,
0.3885209858,
-0.4865047932,
0.864812851,
0.3309578896,
-0.0204262845,
0.4875459075,
-0.3858198225,
0.0999823064,
-0.4886394739,
0.1501259953,
0.1980495304,
-0.3179020286,
-0.9172008038,
0.0275174398,
-0.0871703625,
-0.637681067,
-0.3385798931,
0.1935245395,
-0.5046791434,
0.3310872018,
-0.2469845116,
0.385948509,
0.5584419966,
0.1661743671,
0.5501521826,
0.0230104011,
0.6574980617,
-0.5452451706,
-0.0427747332,
0.1319693774,
0.0909491107,
0.4604881704,
-0.3376262784,
0.0395965204,
-0.56432724,
0.3019480705,
-0.7789051533,
-0.3701863885,
0.5383002162,
-0.4272828698,
0.3101023734,
-0.177207768,
-0.1167123467,
-0.3322390318,
-0.2202323824,
0.3301291168,
0.6884688735,
-0.2491872758,
0.2138464898,
0.2783701718,
-0.094897978,
-0.1577813476,
-1.0203032494,
0.2032253742,
-0.1820783019,
-0.4281728566,
0.3016144037,
0.2043872923,
-0.5647146702,
-0.0368946679,
-0.0263088681,
-0.5165268779,
0.0320100822,
0.5361598134,
0.2322777361,
-0.3031918406,
0.042257756,
-0.4952780306,
-0.2216313332,
0.2340072989,
-0.2574155331,
0.2817441523,
-0.2102841437,
-0.2758962214,
-0.7431315184,
0.6143713593,
0.4036929607,
0.1773982793,
0.2503703237,
0.1218701676,
-0.639586091,
0.1117910072,
-0.3741522133,
0.017818721,
-0.3358467817,
0.2509780526,
-0.0532372557,
-0.2102398723,
0.2513410449,
0.1421923339,
-0.2740201354,
0.3412066996,
0.5612683892,
-0.0357147604,
0.7770287395,
0.316437006,
0.5878760219,
-0.2261433899,
0.0032570001,
0.7744349241,
-0.4445361197,
-0.388807714,
-0.5190720558,
0.1308895648,
-0.80478549,
-0.1543001831,
0.2978072166,
-0.3262726068,
0.189260453,
0.010547461,
-0.9026151896,
0.1618497074,
0.2484554201,
0.3261114657,
0.2344228476,
-0.1128341109,
0.5345172286,
-0.4990746975,
-0.9307454824,
-0.4353058338,
0.8303833604,
0.2159834355,
0.2911955118,
-0.088173762,
1.071152091,
0.2418693453,
0.4119313657,
-0.7684327364,
0.5189305544,
-0.2997680306,
-0.5563300848,
0.300483793,
-0.0971911475,
-0.6513431072,
0.1818201393,
0.1274852455,
-0.5407474637,
0.6411588788,
-0.0960644558,
-0.4958676696,
-0.1688385606,
-0.8560717106,
0.6064165831,
-0.3005032539,
-0.1549134701,
-0.0701879784,
-0.5408200622,
0.4469988048,
-0.0893224552,
0.613407433,
0.059768673,
0.1477735043,
0.5811849236,
-0.6913043857,
0.7813623548,
-0.3883450031,
0.0289365035,
0.6707665324,
0.3066693842,
0.1160666272,
0.3178842962,
0.0264621973,
0.2935797572,
-0.2256894857,
-0.2484956384,
-0.351177007,
0.548458755,
-0.6782494187,
-0.8797307014,
-0.7511877418,
-0.539086163,
0.2412719727,
0.1925100535,
0.815993011,
0.8320132494,
-0.0435749292,
-0.0026158819,
0.1776801795,
-0.3091723025,
0.007978972,
0.368198812,
-0.3477854431,
-0.1444499344,
1.1755665541,
0.5840319395,
0.0674656853,
0.5109497309,
0.2666350603,
0.243140012,
-0.5970126987,
0.0412474498,
0.5077005029,
-1.0381579399,
-0.3089152873,
-0.4667374194,
-0.5482947826,
-0.3356933296,
-0.4369101226,
-0.1327272952,
-0.317794323,
-0.3955620825,
0.2238773555,
-0.0067390334,
0.5539352894,
-0.3064561486,
0.1704183519,
-0.6049944758,
0.1574826539,
-0.0923688486,
-0.2122465074,
-0.0002456832,
-0.6574889421,
-0.2077718973,
-0.0379838087,
-0.4709889591,
-0.8105846643,
0.8006845713,
0.1040044129,
0.267219305,
0.5383927226,
0.1957112402,
0.7640715837,
-0.0164338909,
0.5250798464,
0.5394708514,
-0.8146550655,
0.7634806037,
-0.346612215,
0.1790352613,
0.375474304,
0.4762981832,
-0.371211201,
-0.6206449866,
-1.1258698702,
-0.6398469806,
0.4666692913,
0.1353345215,
-0.2041614801,
-0.4075747728,
0.2112812549,
0.0766695216,
0.1835541129,
-0.61026752,
0.0537907369,
-0.4360286593,
0.2338511348,
-0.0088853724,
-0.3415222764,
-0.6708756685,
-0.0728968233,
0.4711247683,
-0.0443977937,
0.5843874216,
0.7986678481,
-0.2133898437,
-0.1960388124,
0.2167074829,
0.7236837745,
1.3614891768,
-0.3221372366,
0.5843179822,
-0.441752851,
-0.2940209508,
0.1575368345,
-0.1395646632,
-0.1766963452,
0.5704354048,
0.7147032022,
0.5669367313,
0.1390215605,
-0.5403928757,
0.8234820962,
0.00904724,
-0.3373897672,
-0.6763364077,
-0.1113737375,
-0.1186075583,
-0.01632962,
0.3393209875,
0.4325347543,
0.10244672,
-0.5548309684,
0.4565553665,
0.1144341677,
-0.7398850918,
-0.4418396354,
0.2271391451,
-0.1401224136,
-0.3228315413,
0.960380137,
-0.1991427988,
-0.2740801275,
0.7448245287,
0.6589919329,
0.7465106845,
0.3141055107,
0.7860381007,
0.3053259552,
0.3175970018,
0.1693212241,
-0.036434751,
0.3219809234,
-0.4337233007,
-0.0734217316,
-0.0603116117,
-0.1547149569,
0.1806449741,
-0.9983736277,
0.6394994855,
-0.8561422229,
-0.0556405894,
0.247946173,
-0.1190961227,
-0.3744226992,
0.666621685,
0.4005561173,
0.6966596842,
-0.9372107387,
0.5271340013,
0.4374265075,
-0.5195684433,
-0.8404915333,
0.233952418,
0.1507394016,
-1.1793003082,
0.685439527,
0.5843653083,
0.1485435814,
-0.3941801488,
-0.1226576045,
-0.3945326507,
0.859226644,
0.2421588749,
-0.387075007,
0.1475161612,
-0.2190742791,
0.4268903136,
-0.8865998387,
0.1786838621,
0.1955844164,
0.5372290611,
0.2977149785,
-0.4486026764,
0.2810553312,
-0.0624674372,
-0.3594677746,
0.1560507268,
-0.5888504386,
0.8126659393,
-0.677567482,
-0.3359546363,
-0.0795401186,
0.2757378221,
0.1142790467,
0.6579979062,
0.1918679774,
0.7282317281,
0.7975272536,
0.1286875159,
1.4256174564,
-0.0807386115,
0.1184772253,
0.9607267976,
-0.5136173964,
0.3883402646,
0.6515632868,
0.3089839816,
0.5292785168,
0.4356896281,
-0.3058268428,
0.7010750175,
-0.0466766432,
-0.0953016803,
-0.3975484073,
-0.5099282861,
-0.523771584,
0.512137115,
0.2720550895,
-0.6500086188,
-0.5574544072,
-0.1772102118,
0.3030695021,
-0.0066804793,
-0.2158901989,
0.6619594693,
0.1688611656,
-0.9757195711,
1.0221791267,
0.0171934869,
-0.0906689093,
-0.5436312556,
-0.04638879,
-0.180524677,
0.3453984857,
-0.7500675917,
-0.5090082288,
0.7718498707,
-0.2176201493,
-0.2974477708,
-0.1192526743,
0.790559113,
-0.0522443317,
-0.5118566155,
0.2071179599,
0.3719302416,
0.3114257455,
0.1308741122,
-0.337276876,
0.1734420955,
0.1881352812,
0.1574943811,
0.5222057104,
0.4760624766,
-0.1693074852,
0.3528185785,
0.2362751812,
0.4157770872,
-0.4092707038,
-0.1160206273,
0.7379831076,
-0.2121217847,
-0.4670180976,
-0.6216504574,
0.3757981658,
0.2116607279,
-0.3619090021,
0.4845517874,
0.531175971,
0.5581121445,
0.113150917,
0.9886841774,
-0.1261979938,
0.1540689617,
-0.3226985335,
0.291692853,
-0.5137186646,
0.267123282,
-0.0535509102,
-0.5396664143,
-0.5905857086,
0.511728704,
-0.554885149,
-0.0425724648,
1.0117201805,
0.806937933,
0.110958837,
0.26174137,
0.4899148643,
0.3807881773,
0.2727942765,
0.6076524258,
0.8369323015,
-0.4777555764,
0.5268827081,
-0.5465754271,
-0.5425077081,
-0.2695372999,
-0.8838883042,
-0.3664098978,
-0.4250636995,
-0.9408148527,
-0.6790186763,
0.2601519227,
0.3581342399,
0.7722310424,
-0.3759316504,
-0.2395801693,
-0.0317107402,
0.021606978,
-0.3322661519,
-0.2528100908,
0.2382110059,
-0.2502570748,
0.0659733564,
0.0558009595,
0.639359653,
-0.1863910556,
-0.060291227,
-0.0873404443,
-0.0743010491,
-0.0856805295,
0.2254845351,
0.2990555465,
-0.5642721653,
-0.2537673116,
-0.2629379034,
-0.0426371507,
0.581335187,
1.0101280212,
-0.7369377017,
0.4797909856,
0.1626032442,
0.1296938807,
0.3629559278,
-0.2181818336,
0.3678030074,
-0.5794948936,
0.5456712246,
0.5639767647,
0.2137370855,
0.2925385237,
-0.6868138313,
0.0834132731,
0.4554485381,
-0.4873448014,
-1.1203658581,
0.2216543108,
-0.7007626295,
-0.3821230531,
0.8326609135,
-0.3885639608,
-0.1761347204,
-0.1555707306,
0.0636978745,
-0.2263078988,
-0.2920691371,
0.7403827906,
0.5501579046,
-0.5623350143,
-0.2882239223,
-0.4155002236,
0.1571558565,
0.3892544806,
-0.3216459453,
-0.0010861097,
0.658206284,
0.1181489825,
0.4939058125,
1.0868387222,
-0.3181479573,
0.8796998262,
0.1660777628,
-0.4410912395,
-0.149614349,
-0.5165666342,
-0.1916772723,
0.5976731181,
0.4263052642,
-0.0876431167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17136v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17136v1
|
UniIR: Training and Benchmarking Universal Multimodal Information Retrievers
| 2023-11-28T18:55:52 | 2023-11-28T18:55:52 |
Cong Wei, Yang Chen, Haonan Chen, Hexiang Hu, Ge Zhang, Jie Fu, Alan Ritter, Wenhu Chen
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Existing information retrieval (IR) models often assume a homogeneous format,
limiting their applicability to diverse user needs, such as searching for
images with text descriptions, searching for a news article with a headline
image, or finding a similar photo with a query image. To approach such
different information-seeking demands, we introduce UniIR, a unified
instruction-guided multimodal retriever capable of handling eight distinct
retrieval tasks across modalities. UniIR, a single retrieval system jointly
trained on ten diverse multimodal-IR datasets, interprets user instructions to
execute various retrieval tasks, demonstrating robust performance across
existing datasets and zero-shot generalization to new tasks. Our experiments
highlight that multi-task training and instruction tuning are keys to UniIR's
generalization ability. Additionally, we construct the M-BEIR, a multimodal
retrieval benchmark with comprehensive results, to standardize the evaluation
of universal multimodal information retrieval.
|
[
-0.1901911497,
-0.225052774,
0.2455947548,
0.2184642702,
-0.2850477397,
0.0184706282,
-0.0233048908,
-0.2080494165,
-0.2422924489,
0.1899323463,
-0.3287288249,
-0.1177883446,
-0.5070851445,
0.0602099635,
-0.3004106283,
0.7592191696,
0.1555814743,
0.3840912879,
-0.1874640584,
-0.4193900824,
-0.6056660414,
-0.3844628632,
-0.0827678964,
-0.3488470614,
0.8162577748,
0.7154420614,
0.3791454136,
0.5176461935,
0.9568184614,
0.3017336428,
0.4441098273,
0.1442353874,
-0.3353922367,
0.0625546053,
-0.2042586207,
-0.4039943218,
0.2696141005,
-0.0980542004,
0.6358708739,
0.4177094102,
-0.0694007352,
0.2564750314,
-0.0011430896,
0.7394682169,
-1.2124900818,
-0.0079686474,
-0.4240010083,
0.1284475625,
-0.4405372143,
-0.5492403507,
-0.5639843345,
-0.0878453776,
0.0612031445,
-0.5534566641,
0.4061485529,
0.057554096,
0.5922988057,
0.1164399236,
-1.1886575222,
0.0169139151,
-0.8707280159,
0.842592597,
0.0731129348,
0.8869206905,
-0.038049683,
0.3630387187,
-0.0446079336,
-0.8276141286,
-0.3093637824,
-0.1060353667,
-0.1485454589,
0.1820275933,
-0.376178056,
0.0749489889,
0.1068564802,
0.2186905146,
-0.6541656256,
-0.3707681,
-0.4364798367,
-0.0996753573,
0.2185442895,
-0.0116344793,
0.2378256619,
-0.1108612791,
-0.8168056011,
-0.4329068959,
-0.4017875493,
0.2237286568,
0.038202025,
0.0432604775,
0.2589738667,
0.733063221,
-0.5167681575,
0.652930975,
-0.1532885879,
-0.0858483016,
0.2183713466,
-0.2218412906,
0.0404929705,
-0.2815307677,
0.7329983115,
0.6198768616,
0.1017147899,
-0.620085597,
-0.4093735814,
-0.0058113732,
0.3773878813,
-0.8108083606,
-0.1426363587,
-0.4196257591,
-0.6202500463,
0.2978920043,
0.4722020328,
-0.9325162172,
0.0274691451,
-0.4293127656,
0.8010757565,
-0.5072504282,
-0.0844430178,
-0.1286794096,
-0.4841235578,
0.2165461183,
0.1303977817,
-0.7007396817,
0.1732075959,
0.1809819788,
0.4174163938,
-0.1436406225,
-0.360704571,
-0.7536473274,
0.2659383416,
-0.075330101,
1.0070443153,
-0.9136744142,
-0.359061867,
-0.1521048546,
-0.0169794541,
-0.294278264,
-0.535408318,
0.4581134319,
-0.6842063665,
-0.0867655054,
-0.2726015747,
-0.209708035,
-0.2257592082,
0.1186334938,
-0.5649976134,
0.9197576642,
0.0906437635,
-0.654704392,
0.4748187363,
-0.8023611307,
-0.237434417,
-0.0549079441,
-0.39008075,
0.0889208615,
0.4705538154,
0.1092398241,
0.2949545979,
-0.5984027982,
-0.0240567159,
-0.192423135,
-0.6033946872,
0.2180888355,
-0.6569681764,
0.1068263575,
0.2999286652,
-0.247905001,
-0.0834610015,
-0.7019808888,
0.4058536291,
0.0132931536,
-0.684518218,
-0.3908898532,
-0.1817626208,
0.5729188323,
-0.0281254221,
0.2936223447,
-0.8503960371,
0.2843371928,
0.6422430277,
-0.0373732112,
0.5053510666,
-0.2763158083,
0.2479876131,
-0.2690354288,
0.1897989213,
0.1997662038,
0.2991009057,
-0.4495778978,
-0.0227138959,
-0.6778410673,
-0.2575144172,
0.4283537269,
0.5497339964,
-0.6517407894,
-0.0966287851,
-0.2942204475,
-0.218293339,
-0.5571491122,
0.4174126983,
0.8898429871,
0.3762600124,
0.4913311303,
-0.5262522697,
-0.6284720302,
-0.9390244484,
-0.3503765166,
0.1491808891,
-0.1554109454,
0.238558352,
0.4410199821,
-0.5472314358,
0.7422139049,
-0.2214008421,
-0.5393468738,
-0.0623634569,
0.7464976907,
-0.2281563729,
0.5263119936,
0.2120430917,
-1.4539021254,
-0.3952997625,
0.0203851406,
-0.9794963002,
0.3221075833,
0.0804165527,
0.011619987,
-0.0984480605,
0.4242143035,
-0.4681950808,
0.5974065661,
0.1123509631,
-0.1281064004,
0.2189591527,
-0.625846982,
0.6835746169,
-0.8277518153,
0.3492558002,
0.2481013387,
0.0478937104,
-0.3525694311,
0.2723231614,
0.4730498195,
0.0453413762,
-0.2592907548,
0.5382745266,
-1.0019590855,
-0.1608010232,
-0.1560897529,
-0.2926165164,
0.0751034394,
0.2691620588,
-0.3333771229,
1.0081020594,
0.410020858,
-0.7577990294,
0.4935057163,
0.1169057861,
-0.3564890325,
0.8534573317,
-0.5929639339,
0.4238068461,
-0.6085885763,
-0.102624245,
-1.0732092857,
-0.5130335689,
-0.3576930463,
-0.1952911019,
0.4935541153,
-0.2239349037,
-0.6451445818,
-0.4543417394,
-0.2137546688,
0.5370467305,
0.2026109844,
-0.7632830739,
0.8082685471,
0.0950279757,
0.249579981,
-0.9090527892,
-0.4404630661,
-0.0161627922,
0.048580382,
-0.3678257465,
0.4074235857,
-0.4199523926,
-0.0777962431,
-0.0046395632,
-0.3734083176,
-0.4182210267,
-0.0030989603,
0.3653309643,
0.0677020922,
-0.2672257423,
0.1635671258,
-0.2090391517,
-0.2161964178,
-0.4585135579,
0.093555294,
0.2343779504,
-0.2793547511,
-0.7423855662,
-0.5616313219,
0.637825191,
0.4952652454,
-0.4460326433,
0.1595875174,
0.7451529503,
-0.012156928,
0.4828276932,
-0.9526997209,
-0.1994357556,
-0.4409737885,
0.2255270183,
-0.6388557553,
-0.6460456252,
0.1130988747,
-0.297478497,
-0.0343869403,
0.0208416115,
0.0848921761,
-0.2685098648,
1.4718024731,
0.9812338352,
-0.0607993416,
0.574798882,
-0.1524552405,
-0.3150852323,
-0.876399219,
-0.7768178582,
-0.4375087917,
-0.6779244542,
-0.2993407547,
-0.2123311013,
0.6795825362,
0.2471547723,
-0.1784798354,
0.1409115493,
-0.5689325333,
0.7773538828,
1.1604374647,
0.3146767616,
0.4470009506,
0.1959232092,
-0.3625826836,
-0.1883854717,
-0.300080061,
-0.2592068017,
1.2542879581,
-0.426774919,
1.4014869928,
0.1873312145,
0.3631085455,
0.5134365559,
0.2303111553,
-0.3092051744,
0.3020784259,
-0.4236655235,
-0.6998441219,
0.0839950889,
-0.4174473584,
-1.1687703133,
0.4958358407,
-0.189439252,
-0.7701356411,
0.2143370211,
0.1276259273,
-0.0540883616,
0.2623312175,
-0.7680428624,
0.9376087189,
-0.6371558905,
-0.1136218607,
-0.1890562475,
-0.9474813938,
-0.0702709109,
0.2908876538,
0.0448759124,
-0.0962815136,
-0.0301095806,
0.3539954722,
0.4686203301,
0.4472694099,
-0.2271993309,
0.7349838614,
-0.1676346362,
0.0474890321,
-0.0802484527,
-0.0924455151,
-0.0875769854,
-0.1677280366,
0.0529331565,
-0.4130344689,
-0.5098751783,
0.6155921817,
-0.8468118906,
-0.3363661766,
-0.4009371698,
-0.7126048803,
-0.039666906,
0.5138368011,
0.4771015942,
0.9045310616,
-0.491451174,
0.817335248,
0.7723712325,
0.3738348186,
0.5151013732,
0.7943704128,
0.092377454,
-0.359023273,
0.8077415228,
-0.1908417493,
-0.2025695741,
1.0859357119,
-0.0755637661,
-0.4519768953,
-0.0932779387,
-0.6202143431,
-0.1142829731,
-0.5916924477,
-0.4911582768,
-0.6711679697,
0.0756447837,
-0.2387628108,
0.1293108314,
-0.2924918532,
0.006158811,
-0.3371952772,
0.3288806677,
0.07728865,
0.8211849928,
-0.5015074015,
0.4130211473,
-0.8409815431,
0.6004722714,
0.5714027286,
0.5512776375,
-0.4728263617,
-0.4036513269,
0.0389091522,
0.1693090051,
-0.6987506747,
-0.5530480742,
-0.0153843611,
0.4782726765,
0.7976756096,
0.595621109,
0.0526430719,
0.7566717267,
-0.4531707168,
0.1233849078,
0.425707221,
-0.5977603793,
0.5669316053,
-0.0502459593,
0.5138491392,
0.7389537096,
0.7292535901,
-0.5348383784,
0.2728804052,
-0.0520264022,
-0.599794209,
0.6262841225,
-0.1703087538,
0.3266946971,
0.0202507246,
0.3207675815,
0.1069667488,
0.2057147175,
-0.6227291822,
-0.1988213062,
-0.3940890729,
-0.1398248821,
-0.0315836668,
-0.5007124543,
-0.1938040406,
-0.0806621611,
0.1906107515,
-0.3751135468,
0.5247598886,
0.2814749181,
-0.4850162566,
-0.2088946849,
0.7265380621,
0.233569935,
0.642529726,
-0.4613420963,
0.3310578763,
-0.3338750005,
-0.3281309605,
0.3351047337,
0.483240515,
-0.0593138933,
0.0351095498,
-0.0823637694,
0.687721312,
0.5570451021,
-0.8044142723,
0.6469766498,
-0.4499383271,
0.0089575509,
-0.2153128386,
0.1703084558,
-0.3433346748,
0.5094085932,
0.9020531774,
0.1637387425,
0.5560061336,
-0.6422678232,
0.4058308899,
0.6842038035,
-0.6665734053,
-0.3328081071,
0.9136512876,
-0.0197333451,
-0.108548224,
0.9077278972,
-0.0453753993,
-0.0049862918,
0.2186114937,
0.7217969298,
0.514913559,
-0.3009634912,
0.2568667233,
0.0595332049,
0.1908516139,
-0.1910227537,
0.5954580903,
-0.1717784405,
-0.459520638,
0.155309245,
-0.2919533551,
-0.3703668416,
0.0002977748,
-1.1366847754,
-0.1150102988,
-0.1450836509,
-0.2353314757,
0.1699440479,
-0.3465207219,
-0.824919939,
0.2057085931,
-0.1113469377,
0.8416981101,
-0.1138454154,
0.5026934147,
1.0779368877,
-0.6381264329,
-0.3383581042,
-0.1151890457,
0.2315523773,
-0.6611502171,
1.0270034075,
0.4548659325,
-0.2295742482,
0.0119534889,
-0.5277458429,
-0.9032753706,
1.2622785568,
0.5318479538,
-0.3731169701,
-0.1556115597,
0.1308655292,
0.26987499,
-0.2614064515,
0.6990416646,
0.1265732497,
0.2379448116,
0.2020401061,
-0.851401031,
-0.3804049492,
-0.5073606372,
0.3620163798,
0.3630810976,
-0.8107727766,
1.069775939,
-0.554812789,
-0.2044793218,
0.4053739011,
0.5321080685,
-0.1405709237,
0.4375714064,
0.424820751,
0.4084093571,
0.5299884081,
-0.1327172369,
1.0173107386,
-0.2184051871,
0.0661059394,
0.918689549,
-0.1759059429,
0.8555793762,
0.3962551951,
0.3463471234,
0.4526862204,
0.1144329086,
-0.055529207,
0.852401495,
-0.2440892756,
-0.4852642417,
-0.4362195134,
-0.5185997486,
-0.3238654137,
0.6846823692,
0.1671813279,
-0.0993178934,
-0.5561578274,
0.3412244916,
-0.3219373226,
0.0258825794,
-0.2174896598,
0.8790100813,
-0.2745867968,
-0.4925354123,
0.2748143375,
-0.0131860618,
0.9562624693,
-0.6035313606,
-0.1202918887,
-0.3145172596,
0.6209384799,
0.1694936305,
-0.5696358681,
-0.2683803439,
-0.1598825157,
-0.3905397058,
-0.073604174,
0.7379901409,
-0.3161387146,
-0.4311035872,
0.5222387314,
0.4660112858,
0.00057671,
-0.2618618309,
-0.5572883487,
-0.1287419498,
0.034267161,
-0.1060753018,
0.5387929678,
0.5602118969,
0.1362288147,
0.8719165921,
0.5060853958,
-0.5774276257,
0.3441805243,
-0.021058986,
0.9712594151,
-0.853330195,
0.172562778,
-0.4264744818,
0.400251627,
0.0534793139,
-0.4710083604,
0.5259017348,
0.9569885731,
1.0716371536,
-0.1552058309,
0.6794856787,
-0.1762788296,
0.5601934195,
-0.3207836747,
0.2721697092,
-1.0774643421,
-0.2773221731,
0.0281788595,
-0.8074986935,
-0.2011884004,
0.5228111148,
0.3303471506,
0.1384257525,
0.3477981985,
0.7165460587,
-0.6649789214,
-0.108751744,
0.3419401646,
-0.3113756478,
-0.0514069013,
0.3146500587,
0.9962720871,
-0.5367684364,
0.9645601511,
-0.3909391761,
-0.1548753828,
-0.4197245836,
-0.5546597242,
-0.7389544845,
-0.598003149,
0.1058123186,
0.2319077998,
0.3487106562,
0.9712051749,
0.9680607915,
-0.6799587011,
-0.4169147909,
0.3656340241,
-0.2293761969,
-0.1510877758,
-0.1576463878,
-0.2075592726,
-0.4464900792,
-0.5492400527,
0.4493723214,
0.3639157414,
0.1351123005,
0.1198363006,
0.1001737341,
-0.479387939,
-0.353833586,
0.4020712972,
0.6096155643,
-0.6286237836,
-0.1320696473,
0.3218161166,
-0.1937147379,
0.3923390806,
1.1189752817,
-0.605065763,
0.7879132628,
0.157132715,
0.5521040559,
0.5498507619,
0.0246902816,
0.2654675543,
-0.9867985845,
0.0560811758,
-0.0702392459,
0.3492088914,
0.3688492477,
-0.1069258377,
0.6204789281,
0.0225336682,
-0.6999660134,
-0.5837814212,
-0.0868285745,
-0.8224775195,
-0.1134739667,
0.7493407726,
0.0526887476,
0.0743397102,
-0.1384249628,
-0.1972405314,
0.2630017996,
-0.6211326718,
0.707344234,
0.0598448217,
-0.2673989236,
-0.3204889297,
-0.5167965293,
-0.0036887408,
0.3154292703,
-0.6516340375,
-0.2780316174,
0.6429284811,
0.5189810395,
0.3098622262,
0.6689628959,
-0.0256780311,
0.4477314651,
-0.1977494657,
0.4056347907,
0.0699675456,
-0.7583126426,
-0.0399207138,
0.1199869588,
-0.111982286,
-0.3831346333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17049v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17049v2
|
MobileCLIP: Fast Image-Text Models through Multi-Modal Reinforced Training
| 2023-11-28T18:55:42 | 2024-04-01T13:06:06 |
Pavan Kumar Anasosalu Vasu, Hadi Pouransari, Fartash Faghri, Raviteja Vemulapalli, Oncel Tuzel
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Contrastive pretraining of image-text foundation models, such as CLIP,
demonstrated excellent zero-shot performance and improved robustness on a wide
range of downstream tasks. However, these models utilize large
transformer-based encoders with significant memory and latency overhead which
pose challenges for deployment on mobile devices. In this work, we introduce
MobileCLIP -- a new family of efficient image-text models optimized for runtime
performance along with a novel and efficient training approach, namely
multi-modal reinforced training. The proposed training approach leverages
knowledge transfer from an image captioning model and an ensemble of strong
CLIP encoders to improve the accuracy of efficient models. Our approach avoids
train-time compute overhead by storing the additional knowledge in a reinforced
dataset. MobileCLIP sets a new state-of-the-art latency-accuracy tradeoff for
zero-shot classification and retrieval tasks on several datasets. Our
MobileCLIP-S2 variant is 2.3$\times$ faster while more accurate compared to
previous best CLIP model based on ViT-B/16. We further demonstrate the
effectiveness of our multi-modal reinforced training by training a CLIP model
based on ViT-B/16 image backbone and achieving +2.9% average performance
improvement on 38 evaluation benchmarks compared to the previous best.
Moreover, we show that the proposed approach achieves 10$\times$-1000$\times$
improved learning efficiency when compared with non-reinforced CLIP training.
Code and models are available at https://github.com/apple/ml-mobileclip .
|
[
-0.2730309963,
-0.3373481333,
0.0621237308,
0.1635383815,
-0.5275223255,
0.2230668068,
-0.0429097675,
-0.3847082555,
0.1953204572,
0.2472931445,
-0.3826724291,
-0.2583272159,
-0.7040765285,
-0.1957516074,
-0.203152433,
0.909098804,
-0.2425571084,
0.1184560359,
-0.1897786707,
-0.5092968345,
-0.6094501019,
-0.503893733,
-0.0630864725,
-0.1088837832,
0.1830722094,
0.3759969175,
0.8319978714,
0.683340013,
0.7150615454,
0.081128329,
0.182151407,
0.1904898137,
-0.3940901458,
-0.0507023111,
0.099741511,
-0.3111902177,
-0.1910152584,
0.027222285,
0.2217275947,
-0.0047736424,
0.0420566499,
0.129106015,
-0.3978355527,
0.5358526707,
-1.151373148,
-0.1500885338,
-0.733389318,
0.1527583003,
0.0271861609,
-0.3535090089,
-0.3784689605,
-0.1481256336,
-0.0854961798,
-0.4958917797,
0.2488829494,
-0.040011771,
0.9620717168,
0.2085220218,
-0.6272490621,
-0.0846931785,
-0.4673500657,
0.7469249368,
-0.3438637257,
0.6315864325,
0.1886106282,
0.3967386782,
0.4067087173,
-0.6922106743,
-0.5495233536,
-0.0325062871,
0.297286123,
0.2337125242,
0.1228011996,
0.0274318252,
-0.0010283089,
0.3018894792,
-0.1530473977,
-0.181855917,
-0.4461142719,
-0.2570554614,
0.3677914143,
0.0574747398,
0.2201800942,
-0.1162155271,
-0.777445972,
-0.3312772214,
-0.7155482173,
0.4198685884,
-0.0863629878,
-0.1604973078,
-0.3004666865,
0.570631206,
0.1659565717,
0.4775291383,
0.1270867735,
-0.739150703,
0.3425465226,
-0.6677719355,
0.0397830196,
-0.1217562929,
0.7382912636,
0.7846810222,
-0.0354513489,
-0.0094648097,
-0.2101044655,
0.1637950093,
0.051978603,
-1.2607346773,
-0.2574931383,
-0.2237422317,
-0.6263964176,
-0.3819380999,
0.0727580786,
-0.6229346991,
-0.0780380145,
-0.1958820373,
0.6437703967,
-0.6129602194,
-0.0372154079,
0.232880637,
-0.1449291557,
0.0145139815,
0.3631893098,
-1.008908987,
0.2762253881,
0.2073476464,
1.1789860725,
-0.2494934201,
-0.2382552028,
-0.4671682119,
0.397659868,
-0.0194468293,
0.8076408505,
-0.6108049154,
-0.4607107341,
-0.0878960043,
0.0554933138,
-0.4750363529,
-0.3118974566,
0.741628468,
-0.3974032104,
-0.0986251608,
0.0862080082,
-0.1197474748,
-0.4855911732,
0.3792967498,
-0.7007107735,
1.0764610767,
-0.0263307691,
-0.8310338855,
0.2728393972,
-0.5650888681,
-0.589300096,
-0.306084305,
-0.0239237305,
-0.5537796021,
-0.1197529733,
0.6086704731,
0.6574484706,
-0.3693528473,
-0.012184904,
-0.3330852091,
-0.5409640074,
0.2252137214,
-0.3858893812,
0.3358035982,
0.1185337976,
-0.2761841714,
0.0953505859,
-0.7187776566,
0.2215424031,
-0.0892694816,
-0.2033089697,
-0.2402462065,
-0.3423168957,
0.092792742,
0.411632061,
-0.0195644405,
-0.4923121929,
0.3108092248,
0.117729947,
0.8868537545,
0.2345489562,
-0.0745345578,
0.5861127377,
-0.4135987461,
0.5759248137,
-0.039396178,
0.3258517385,
-0.9636903405,
-0.0441543199,
-0.3171152472,
-0.9023001194,
0.3866545558,
0.6953146458,
-1.0074155331,
-0.0632666126,
-0.5830591321,
-0.6523060799,
-0.2274799347,
0.0371521302,
0.702585876,
0.4466331899,
0.4335885346,
-0.6315078139,
-0.3988877535,
-0.7968090773,
0.0820275471,
0.252471,
0.1740580946,
0.5621604323,
0.6718940139,
-0.0295434501,
0.7864388824,
-0.3951012194,
-0.2673518062,
-0.1691051126,
0.232369259,
-0.1587185562,
0.4765867591,
0.709148705,
-0.8973896503,
-0.4194722772,
-0.3616146445,
-0.5030673742,
0.17750144,
-0.3137592077,
0.0805983394,
-0.040626552,
0.3479993045,
-0.8350373507,
0.3743034899,
0.5897473097,
0.1314089745,
0.7029271722,
-0.0511758924,
0.475882113,
-0.9381833673,
0.1556513608,
-0.2110537291,
-0.3625598848,
-0.2940079868,
-0.1468918025,
0.2967962623,
-0.5425317883,
-0.7961674333,
0.2571120858,
-0.56851089,
-0.072556518,
-0.3153395057,
-0.2064929754,
0.3010517657,
0.6041977406,
0.1925232559,
1.2562142611,
0.4096989334,
-0.4892667532,
0.1094362885,
0.481417954,
-0.2424691767,
0.543109715,
-0.5657369494,
0.0095344158,
-0.0600780137,
0.5006917119,
-0.7173795104,
-0.2165737748,
0.0681605116,
-0.2445893437,
0.1817117333,
-0.3633562028,
-0.342915684,
-0.3881972432,
-0.7593072653,
0.7464175224,
0.2461248785,
-0.6541218758,
0.6298189163,
0.4430365562,
0.0720131919,
-0.7904435992,
-0.5728677511,
-0.0787368491,
-0.0402292125,
-0.591029644,
0.8471871018,
0.1802481413,
0.6071304083,
-0.147022903,
-0.2457465827,
-0.6750100255,
-0.1359166801,
0.6845613718,
0.3215908408,
0.0277370494,
0.2411045432,
0.0888425633,
0.0774547756,
-0.4272788763,
0.2121524215,
0.4010557532,
-0.2928462923,
-0.2112151086,
-0.6124683022,
0.1423817873,
0.8414052129,
-0.5336148143,
0.4734320641,
0.4840863347,
-0.0432168916,
0.31096071,
-0.5724658966,
-0.2128381729,
-0.4159387648,
0.3408470452,
-0.5008969903,
-0.8411440849,
0.184082821,
-0.3664194345,
-0.0604474917,
0.002428297,
0.2846694589,
-0.0131983068,
0.7989460826,
0.8148838282,
0.097938709,
0.7220008373,
-0.344212234,
-0.0018368685,
-0.7248667479,
-0.377363205,
-0.0906637609,
-0.1495588869,
-0.022791246,
-0.7944344878,
0.4458391368,
0.4727359414,
-0.2728026807,
0.6778274179,
-0.4949987829,
0.5095842481,
0.4204630256,
0.4873374701,
0.2632862628,
0.1577724516,
-0.1129675657,
-0.2200371921,
-0.9259641171,
-0.4448257983,
1.1909652948,
0.3411287367,
1.0038357973,
-0.1905402392,
0.1757646203,
0.2466503531,
0.2500196993,
-0.7325165868,
0.4480164051,
-0.1133123413,
-0.4657894075,
0.194747746,
-0.0103595499,
-0.384186089,
0.428338021,
-0.8279047012,
-0.1874029487,
0.2008141875,
0.3710428774,
-0.3588331044,
0.4738268256,
-0.6407351494,
0.8320869207,
-0.5155045986,
-0.7784082294,
-0.153380394,
-0.8557975888,
0.6185275912,
0.076331377,
0.1002233773,
-0.2075947374,
-0.0549596474,
0.5048245788,
-0.5510770082,
0.6953930259,
-0.2220077068,
0.2951634526,
0.5801251531,
-0.0860167965,
0.3957229257,
-0.0370577611,
-0.0297495313,
0.1078843549,
0.3286804557,
-0.176347971,
-0.6903355122,
0.2583444417,
-0.5067464709,
0.1042522863,
-0.1307355613,
-0.5915760398,
0.0432741717,
0.0858567283,
0.375295192,
0.8608715534,
0.0189586189,
0.4835309386,
0.3697827458,
-0.0569280088,
0.7779937387,
0.1756334603,
0.0228144079,
-1.0630789995,
0.9161764979,
-0.1125770211,
0.0645294785,
0.4076245129,
-0.322401017,
-0.4104468226,
-0.2898436785,
-0.8104250431,
0.0545480996,
-0.4847421646,
-0.5636208653,
-0.5569645166,
0.0293448791,
-0.1073322818,
-0.4836150706,
-0.8227507472,
-0.7348437905,
-0.2330863923,
0.1215905771,
0.1685498059,
0.0101142349,
0.079519242,
0.7968973517,
-1.101726532,
0.2586190104,
0.1742795557,
0.2626749277,
0.0309078284,
-0.4040940404,
-0.2827367485,
-0.1351998001,
-0.8874136209,
-0.7332406044,
0.1986302584,
0.515994072,
0.2099843323,
0.4899294674,
0.0879806429,
0.7803991437,
-0.6067242026,
0.7324305773,
0.9259135723,
-1.0720081329,
0.1510954648,
-0.2541718185,
0.2250582874,
0.8803034425,
0.4948140085,
-0.0526150763,
0.4491780698,
-0.2584680021,
-0.6755341887,
0.2239031643,
0.111548692,
0.3564140797,
0.1698049307,
0.3632095754,
0.1897022277,
0.5659843087,
-1.0114746094,
0.1342645586,
-0.7956054211,
-0.2655009627,
0.4251885414,
-0.5288390517,
-0.1102956384,
-0.4727432728,
0.3501324356,
-0.4028046131,
0.356469512,
0.3472627103,
-0.5909853578,
0.3873106837,
0.2487739921,
0.9499675035,
0.4470538199,
0.0379643254,
0.3434969187,
0.1718744487,
-0.5876858234,
0.6114938259,
-0.0067736455,
-0.19720231,
0.0686241463,
0.2163742334,
1.2545112371,
0.700930357,
-0.844833076,
1.2021193504,
0.3038116097,
-0.4847510457,
-0.1628818959,
-0.2318153083,
-0.3412091434,
0.1237191185,
0.2964188159,
0.3967922032,
0.1367706507,
-0.4547656476,
0.3751347065,
0.421248734,
-0.4028168917,
-0.5476107001,
0.8549355268,
0.489112258,
-0.0102038877,
0.1556509286,
0.1533667892,
-0.8806893229,
0.3803453445,
0.7063638568,
0.3498591185,
-0.0897214562,
0.3371320665,
0.4114797115,
0.0656944215,
-0.2779041529,
0.1497375965,
-0.3611404598,
-0.5479043126,
-0.5544371605,
-0.0774605945,
-0.5371434689,
-0.1979891956,
-0.5661931038,
0.3968432248,
-0.4937129319,
-0.4449705482,
-0.3248686492,
-0.5239953995,
-0.3761950135,
0.2850955725,
-0.186589554,
1.0097250938,
-0.627425015,
0.6904643774,
0.5612527132,
-0.4497233629,
-0.6117463112,
-0.2192641646,
-0.440831542,
-0.4194829762,
0.8019901514,
0.7530363798,
-0.371448487,
-0.1269842684,
-0.537111342,
-0.6991633177,
1.2108875513,
0.3864479959,
-0.4323957264,
0.1195041984,
-0.2248010188,
0.0287673734,
-0.5565543175,
0.7913799286,
-0.0321701467,
-0.0369563513,
0.337215662,
-0.9172738791,
-0.0647942647,
-0.1974478811,
0.0401218496,
0.1970409751,
-0.9145219326,
0.6651960611,
-0.5562279224,
-0.1615700424,
0.1369186044,
0.5190140009,
0.1381174922,
0.4418762326,
0.4389386177,
0.4255419672,
0.4844890833,
0.2036636025,
0.840485394,
-0.7425391674,
0.2766749263,
1.1449837685,
-0.258094877,
1.1096009016,
0.5056939125,
0.202526167,
0.5436810255,
0.4272896647,
-0.3444812,
0.9988217354,
-0.2467980236,
-0.4654826522,
-0.331477046,
-0.2504772246,
-0.3159230947,
0.4804475307,
-0.1364299804,
-0.4352048635,
-0.1302369535,
0.5575163364,
0.046901051,
-0.0016193927,
-0.3136948943,
0.2824417055,
-0.1286960244,
-0.4296172559,
0.8353885412,
0.1378574818,
0.9465326667,
-0.4646397233,
0.004319407,
0.136103794,
0.0937294811,
-0.2372033149,
-0.4233081937,
0.1250130981,
-0.1486481428,
-0.4027801752,
-0.2684749663,
0.9454931021,
-0.3426989317,
-0.1533599645,
-0.1488408297,
0.1036675796,
0.0283117294,
-0.1081903055,
-0.6444754601,
0.2389302701,
-0.1508055627,
0.0764409006,
0.0434326641,
-0.1530186236,
-0.1740973741,
0.8414672613,
0.7213716507,
-0.4706303477,
0.2859608233,
-0.3281143606,
1.0709002018,
-0.4897626042,
-0.3573053777,
-0.6199871898,
0.42101565,
-0.1069405302,
-0.2541080415,
0.4072563946,
0.859754324,
0.4546763003,
-0.4285117388,
0.6556246877,
-0.0193132535,
0.4330790937,
-0.6329942346,
0.4872430861,
-0.4241941571,
0.007003726,
-0.1276254207,
-0.6108549833,
-0.3069193363,
0.6868999004,
-0.2942267358,
-0.1478793025,
0.7905997634,
0.6981043816,
-0.449336946,
0.0296490341,
-0.0188339353,
-0.5171126127,
0.1178583205,
0.6667156816,
0.55276227,
-0.928365767,
0.995890975,
-0.4216163754,
-0.1590262353,
-0.3443509936,
-1.043254137,
-1.0461064577,
-0.2898421288,
-0.244412899,
-0.0550291054,
0.2014501393,
0.7824367881,
1.2423765659,
-0.364310354,
0.019532105,
0.0644720569,
-0.2448450476,
-0.01683525,
-0.1477213353,
0.4299222529,
0.0488440692,
-0.3481876552,
0.4692672193,
0.2654292583,
0.4125131369,
0.3198614717,
-0.0566423573,
-0.0871014073,
-0.0507639572,
0.9224675298,
0.5001091361,
-0.3064227402,
-0.2021930218,
-0.0011505388,
-0.1443746686,
0.357663095,
1.1550889015,
-0.8130562901,
0.327611059,
0.1441526115,
0.9030778408,
0.8761162162,
0.3692596555,
0.4253368676,
-0.5176689029,
0.6413276792,
-0.0931013823,
0.0793648213,
0.4013012946,
0.1610683054,
0.6271817684,
0.5423555374,
-0.2830628157,
-0.8611131907,
0.2786501944,
-1.1054655313,
-0.0781907812,
0.8486538529,
-0.2454826385,
-0.1668207496,
0.1625350863,
-0.5694656372,
0.0555761196,
-0.398542583,
0.5786371231,
0.3153162897,
-0.0220690258,
-0.8950325847,
-0.477589041,
0.307908982,
0.5061780214,
-0.6708037257,
-0.4651370943,
0.4543884397,
0.3993915319,
0.0243198872,
0.6599099636,
-0.3268889189,
0.4072788656,
-0.0024963499,
0.3938755989,
-0.7913666368,
-0.4834371209,
-0.0294569898,
0.4682685733,
-0.3199550807,
-0.680954814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17043v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17043v1
|
LLaMA-VID: An Image is Worth 2 Tokens in Large Language Models
| 2023-11-28T18:53:43 | 2023-11-28T18:53:43 |
Yanwei Li, Chengyao Wang, Jiaya Jia
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
In this work, we present a novel method to tackle the token generation
challenge in Vision Language Models (VLMs) for video and image understanding,
called LLaMA-VID. Current VLMs, while proficient in tasks like image captioning
and visual question answering, face computational burdens when processing long
videos due to the excessive visual tokens. LLaMA-VID addresses this issue by
representing each frame with two distinct tokens, namely context token and
content token. The context token encodes the overall image context based on
user input, whereas the content token encapsulates visual cues in each frame.
This dual-token strategy significantly reduces the overload of long videos
while preserving critical information. Generally, LLaMA-VID empowers existing
frameworks to support hour-long videos and pushes their upper limit with an
extra context token. It is proved to surpass previous methods on most of video-
or image-based benchmarks. Code is available
https://github.com/dvlab-research/LLaMA-VID}{https://github.com/dvlab-research/LLaMA-VID
|
[
-0.16967839,
-0.7587336898,
0.3437248766,
0.4220167994,
-1.0478205681,
0.217269823,
-0.1419217736,
-0.4423680604,
0.2301824391,
0.5311458707,
-0.3358621895,
-0.5028634667,
-0.7176735401,
-0.1731102616,
-0.4948020279,
0.754067719,
-0.0565291643,
0.1561644673,
-0.4174107313,
-0.4143107235,
-0.5987396836,
-0.528842926,
-0.6836741567,
0.1396645904,
0.4734303355,
0.2781624198,
0.4893174469,
1.0654468536,
0.7106336355,
0.2145648897,
-0.1989254057,
0.420385927,
-0.459885478,
0.1218550801,
0.0646846443,
-0.3280741274,
-0.1913650185,
-0.5667628646,
0.6480208635,
0.3216085732,
0.0322283395,
0.6106573343,
-0.2059334368,
0.6452656388,
-0.7292528749,
0.3235583305,
-0.8138670921,
0.119368352,
-0.392916441,
-0.3419798613,
-0.1400617808,
0.4430175722,
-0.206394285,
-0.524025321,
-0.0262234695,
0.0725830048,
0.8905777931,
0.6491687298,
-0.5111667514,
0.1946757436,
-0.3565962017,
0.6099187732,
-0.4156725109,
0.1370512098,
0.1388141364,
0.4675281942,
0.0888821036,
-0.8094400764,
-0.9531278014,
0.1527852565,
0.2407526672,
-0.3030920029,
-0.2391937077,
0.0438203514,
0.2890930772,
0.3295452297,
-0.3435772359,
0.1963418275,
-0.3657074273,
-0.1218709424,
0.5405346155,
0.2050795108,
0.3561189771,
-0.3423429132,
-0.6828008294,
-0.1127921939,
-0.842694819,
0.1174612194,
0.0972140953,
-0.1022339538,
-0.2428084016,
0.8158819675,
-0.1644384265,
0.5791449547,
-0.0750354901,
-0.4182165265,
0.3160894811,
-0.3586451113,
-0.4075652361,
0.0312542543,
0.5513895154,
0.9222982526,
0.0908858702,
0.1974158138,
-0.1849322617,
0.2373919338,
0.0175439324,
-0.8965540528,
0.258721143,
0.0582805686,
-0.5153924823,
-0.3329146802,
-0.0124217169,
-0.8489970565,
-0.4662669301,
-0.2348643988,
0.5001395941,
0.0457270145,
-0.284391135,
0.1993394792,
-0.2160076201,
0.6355099082,
0.3721505404,
-0.8412113786,
0.2029370666,
0.8149364591,
1.0378674269,
-0.4195501208,
-0.2798410356,
-0.8664557934,
0.2962852716,
-0.3578891754,
0.5472467542,
-0.4536409378,
-0.3002360463,
0.2130571902,
-0.0952632576,
0.4038265646,
-0.4022280872,
0.0353501998,
-0.6104624867,
-0.2184862792,
-0.3308675885,
-0.3391269147,
-0.3388958871,
0.3220725358,
-0.7121072412,
1.0891392231,
0.038399253,
-0.816386044,
0.4963541925,
-0.7778537273,
-0.4523961544,
0.2721076906,
-0.4580338895,
-0.2622171938,
0.1409843266,
0.4266806841,
0.4445893764,
-0.3185155392,
0.4256471395,
-0.122572042,
-0.4179601371,
0.2345819026,
-0.6599280238,
0.344884336,
0.1748731434,
-0.431475997,
0.1719809324,
-0.738897562,
-0.2573872507,
0.2689014971,
-0.2646740973,
-0.0836509988,
0.1142792776,
0.2650887072,
0.1481983513,
0.369559288,
-0.6448268294,
0.2548225522,
-0.0914620608,
0.6654535532,
0.989236474,
-0.1192389876,
0.193290323,
0.1114564911,
0.5526079535,
0.2498384863,
0.2763204575,
-0.6992149949,
-0.4805455804,
-0.9172641635,
-0.33165133,
0.0009609305,
0.3660821915,
-1.0116355419,
-0.0979205221,
-0.4944452643,
-0.0370858051,
-0.5707144737,
0.5028076172,
0.6341661811,
0.4249708951,
0.4467588663,
-0.5936383009,
-0.7474864125,
-0.8460584879,
0.1790826321,
-0.3842442036,
0.0475830063,
0.5908939242,
0.5715647936,
-0.321234256,
0.9441242218,
-0.4756457806,
-0.3445901573,
-0.1935808957,
-0.3837923408,
0.0384073667,
0.2827788293,
0.6689146757,
-1.0260204077,
-0.3025131524,
0.1751404107,
-0.8348454237,
0.1049814373,
-0.1901156306,
-0.0888836905,
0.2864139378,
0.631942153,
-0.6006161571,
0.7183045149,
0.6604937315,
-0.3862709701,
0.4414084256,
-0.0586125664,
0.1197217703,
-0.826415062,
-0.1020264998,
-0.2654697895,
-0.4278361499,
-0.2950585485,
0.3540256023,
-0.15094015,
-0.0908794925,
-0.9564703107,
0.7791575789,
-0.2116780281,
-0.4321421981,
-0.2266756743,
-0.1442909837,
0.0523858853,
0.5999791026,
0.1020473018,
0.8776173592,
0.8721667528,
-0.3867636323,
0.6509571075,
0.1697217375,
-0.3587524891,
0.4904088676,
-0.7044143677,
0.0739211142,
-0.1893173456,
0.183410421,
-1.0487349033,
-0.3503501117,
0.2092670798,
-0.2996744812,
0.1785272509,
-0.3086269796,
-0.5168479085,
-0.4385177493,
-0.3432979882,
0.9297756553,
0.5961491466,
-0.9802718759,
0.5339374542,
0.5080325603,
0.019187808,
-0.8166196346,
-0.7673959732,
0.6885967255,
-0.3865692914,
-0.823343277,
0.4352937639,
-0.0401754454,
-0.1065972447,
0.129438743,
-0.0820367932,
-0.022397656,
-0.091029726,
0.5143929124,
0.2244299352,
-0.3858038187,
0.2608825564,
-0.0305233281,
-0.0736748278,
-0.0541403629,
-0.3602737486,
0.5978583694,
-0.1843367219,
-0.543469131,
-0.5374122262,
0.6973462701,
0.7594275475,
-0.3569345772,
0.6518753171,
0.7568000555,
-0.2713823318,
-0.1150870845,
-0.7669721842,
0.1397002488,
-0.5116826892,
0.6697465777,
-0.2666805089,
-1.0649069548,
0.4187860191,
0.1483217031,
0.0572105497,
0.1452833414,
0.7002603412,
-0.204359442,
0.9154912829,
0.8612598181,
-0.0349498168,
0.7937661409,
-0.479262203,
0.0277263001,
-0.8052632213,
-0.388569355,
0.1594031155,
-0.3209806681,
-0.1781851798,
-0.9121061563,
0.3824052513,
0.0705958009,
-0.1178386509,
0.0511400327,
-0.294432193,
0.7424378991,
0.3884185553,
0.1105437353,
0.119575806,
0.324189961,
-0.0301214401,
0.058792796,
-0.5928045511,
-0.5549637079,
1.1815464497,
0.3370828032,
0.5273777843,
0.2829201519,
0.3912066519,
0.378497839,
-0.0257798117,
-0.7728827596,
0.8915922642,
-0.1560196877,
-0.1823540628,
-0.214378491,
0.0710626617,
-0.7417442799,
0.3976686299,
-0.0054072454,
-0.6495150328,
-0.273668915,
0.387976557,
-0.0888618156,
0.5446502566,
-0.4336237311,
0.8092499971,
-0.5389666557,
-0.6373301744,
-0.3765306771,
-0.7448254824,
0.3601609468,
0.0211542174,
0.2793445885,
0.0910057575,
-0.2918307185,
0.6414788961,
-0.578766048,
0.9182873964,
-0.2715860903,
0.0760427862,
0.5441119671,
-0.070548363,
0.2490612864,
0.2915376127,
0.2828266919,
0.151703015,
-0.0607929751,
-0.487164706,
-0.5142587423,
0.3298177123,
-0.5385246277,
-0.7916373014,
-0.1945135146,
-0.2215100229,
0.2881925106,
-0.0815598816,
-0.0327940285,
0.5309753418,
0.0874517635,
0.4282070398,
0.4259073138,
-0.3736771643,
0.7509872317,
0.1316754222,
-0.3859517574,
-0.4466297925,
0.9165356159,
-0.3387080729,
0.2424456924,
0.342549026,
-0.0715337917,
-0.262909174,
-0.574541688,
-0.8068956733,
0.1936276704,
-1.0143104792,
-0.3392482996,
-0.3366287351,
-0.1263224036,
-0.1835806668,
-0.1187116578,
-0.4044421911,
-0.2238785774,
-0.4774959981,
-0.4927287102,
0.6050668955,
0.4428965151,
-0.0506674983,
0.3421801031,
-0.6513256431,
0.5359350443,
0.618760705,
0.339854449,
0.066774942,
-0.4488256276,
-0.286957711,
-0.1933408827,
-0.1405726224,
-0.609048903,
0.3007747829,
0.2179010808,
0.3931753039,
0.5979312658,
-0.2769749463,
1.083286047,
-0.6411933899,
1.2925031185,
0.6046803594,
-0.996404767,
0.4462352097,
-0.1227171198,
0.0669025257,
0.2195957154,
-0.2380423844,
-0.7246758342,
0.0142402994,
-0.3978307247,
-1.1907672882,
0.1791867167,
0.1552131921,
0.6126124859,
-0.1114633828,
0.3142338097,
0.093170546,
0.2409082204,
-0.7927678227,
-0.0370995142,
-0.4933405817,
-0.1223030761,
0.129762888,
-0.5390706062,
-0.1772765368,
-0.2715581656,
0.1736009717,
-0.3831068575,
0.1882897019,
0.2965961695,
-0.4271863997,
-0.0186450612,
-0.0248797908,
0.6974850297,
0.556599617,
0.2407972366,
0.2246227413,
0.3192194402,
-0.5125764012,
0.1278361082,
-0.518029809,
0.0594353825,
0.0220877901,
0.5157433152,
1.2447752953,
0.1412034482,
-1.1336905956,
0.942928493,
0.038813591,
-0.2022688538,
-0.3146593869,
-0.0125249289,
-0.1705196798,
0.3194564581,
0.5216278434,
-0.0876401588,
-0.1434061229,
-0.3053296506,
0.2309853733,
0.4406399131,
-0.1580375582,
-0.3180490434,
0.7955021262,
0.3864894509,
-0.4774669409,
0.4297257662,
-0.2082168311,
-0.6606464982,
0.8424068093,
0.5261837244,
0.6838199496,
0.4433687031,
0.2658760548,
0.1945232898,
-0.0728585646,
-0.0613473952,
0.290247798,
-0.3895291686,
-0.5473402739,
-0.6737947464,
-0.8259716034,
-0.1487055719,
0.111766845,
-0.5472543836,
0.3022345603,
-0.3461630642,
-0.1686899364,
-0.2122258097,
-0.3631823063,
-0.8120234013,
-0.012078926,
0.5122404099,
0.7741869688,
-0.5740776658,
0.8586525321,
0.5105502009,
-0.1907621473,
-0.6212642789,
-0.4341107309,
-0.0013685933,
-0.9461985826,
0.9555190206,
0.4034004211,
-0.2152256072,
-0.106735155,
-0.7401287556,
-0.7522082329,
1.16773808,
0.3037975729,
-0.7081285715,
0.1367017925,
0.1370747238,
0.4055206478,
-0.5678642392,
-0.2159445584,
0.3725634217,
0.3956086934,
0.4126691818,
-0.8130285144,
-0.2084449232,
-0.3990041018,
0.2168316543,
-0.0681503788,
-0.6411848664,
0.7007055283,
-0.6752169132,
-0.254855603,
0.3111224174,
0.695684731,
0.3087084293,
0.3981366158,
0.7247655988,
0.4994639456,
0.3790730536,
0.2014968395,
0.9395786524,
-0.1221710891,
0.1171404645,
0.8426553607,
-0.0977246687,
0.9199221134,
1.180274725,
-0.0892282501,
0.3396139443,
0.592343986,
-0.271879524,
0.5775186419,
0.3336085975,
-0.3277531564,
-0.4434565008,
-0.3542631269,
-0.2928388715,
0.6956788301,
0.2944229841,
-0.14646101,
0.0935262516,
0.2656054199,
-0.2040840387,
0.1187718436,
-0.4690781832,
0.7846090198,
0.0036053522,
-0.5039868951,
0.4527561367,
-0.1087338254,
0.6666147113,
-0.3870639503,
-0.1736838371,
-0.2126059383,
0.0018503084,
-0.125991419,
-0.8128522635,
0.109969005,
0.503262341,
0.0063623181,
-0.2370694727,
0.3186197579,
-0.4369742274,
-0.5904740095,
0.2037042826,
0.2629895508,
0.1390085369,
0.1654545963,
-0.4042881131,
0.450607717,
-0.0154394666,
-0.2095150501,
0.2876777947,
0.342902422,
-0.3444953263,
0.7539053559,
0.8175484538,
-0.0114623494,
0.1090020537,
0.2158414125,
1.0430253744,
-0.6001104712,
-0.561073184,
-1.1231896877,
0.6586943865,
-0.0567402616,
-0.2243888974,
0.4410419762,
0.5052652955,
0.8668029904,
-0.1063107252,
0.6018002033,
-0.0185683332,
-0.2439356446,
-0.849483788,
0.2313396782,
-0.8456578255,
0.3236646652,
-0.2765565217,
-0.5696385503,
-0.5936243534,
0.4439826608,
0.1673535556,
-0.5370755792,
0.5575504899,
0.8296570778,
0.0973850638,
-0.3812220097,
0.199734211,
0.0110511044,
0.6407414079,
0.5909424424,
1.0000501871,
-0.3872196376,
0.8449736834,
-0.0325109251,
0.1103317589,
-0.2736263275,
-1.1543813944,
-0.9103831649,
-0.5909560919,
-0.2890520096,
0.1090530902,
0.0410249196,
0.763504684,
0.8863254189,
-0.3213495612,
-0.2099042237,
0.0280754883,
0.2812299728,
-0.1488727927,
-0.1296990663,
0.4497166574,
0.1046411395,
-0.5237491131,
0.1123327836,
0.6521604061,
0.1581069678,
-0.3821029365,
-0.2601046562,
0.2080001831,
-0.0349536762,
0.8396789432,
0.249486953,
-1.0224064589,
-0.5840474367,
-0.0560467839,
0.0543452762,
0.3233569562,
0.8047305346,
-0.8576392531,
0.4130069613,
0.3559606075,
0.8082190752,
0.8792466521,
0.0180421341,
0.2555829585,
-0.9002074003,
0.6556357145,
-0.0965988114,
0.4188714921,
0.5158041716,
-0.3157251775,
0.5194174051,
0.2787901163,
-0.0637051463,
-1.1367543936,
0.3230468631,
-1.4928029776,
-0.1853852421,
1.2863246202,
-0.0794953704,
-0.4719342291,
0.3091273904,
-0.5513211489,
0.0444602706,
-0.3019787669,
0.5806006789,
0.4434835911,
0.2545223534,
-0.4479175806,
-0.5050804615,
0.1287487,
0.2522951365,
-0.5497633815,
0.0170341451,
0.347894758,
0.2942460477,
-0.1450948268,
0.633213222,
-0.0642241538,
0.5659098625,
-0.0271826163,
-0.1683719158,
-0.4357371628,
-0.4320030212,
-0.2455530316,
0.1384657323,
-0.0895442516,
-0.5332636833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17041v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17041v2
|
Efficient In-Context Learning in Vision-Language Models for Egocentric Videos
| 2023-11-28T18:53:06 | 2023-11-29T15:52:55 |
Keunwoo Peter Yu, Zheyuan Zhang, Fengyuan Hu, Joyce Chai
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in text-only large language models (LLMs) have
highlighted the benefit of in-context learning for adapting to new tasks with a
few demonstrations. However, extending in-context learning to large
vision-language models (VLMs) using a huge amount of naturalistic
vision-language data has shown limited success, particularly for egocentric
videos, due to high data collection costs. We propose a novel training method
$\mathbb{E}$fficient $\mathbb{I}$n-context $\mathbb{L}$earning on
$\mathbb{E}$gocentric $\mathbb{V}$ideos ($\mathbb{EILEV}$), which elicits
in-context learning in VLMs for egocentric videos without requiring massive,
naturalistic egocentric video datasets. $\mathbb{EILEV}$ involves architectural
and training data adaptations to allow the model to process contexts
interleaved with video clips and narrations, sampling of in-context examples
with clusters of similar verbs and nouns, use of data with skewed marginal
distributions with a long tail of infrequent verbs and nouns, as well as
homonyms and synonyms. Our evaluations show that $\mathbb{EILEV}$-trained
models outperform larger VLMs trained on a huge amount of naturalistic data in
in-context learning. Furthermore, they can generalize to not only
out-of-distribution, but also novel, rare egocentric videos and texts via
in-context learning, demonstrating potential for applications requiring
cost-effective training, and rapid post-deployment adaptability. Our code and
demo are available at \url{https://github.com/yukw777/EILEV}.
|
[
-0.3279854357,
-0.5281731486,
0.3453707397,
0.1634828746,
-0.2806802392,
-0.3047243953,
-0.7742139101,
-0.3068450391,
0.0975710601,
0.2007902116,
-0.5929418802,
-0.5139396191,
-0.3326108158,
0.1057248041,
-0.3864299953,
0.7609382272,
-0.0307898875,
0.3177391589,
-0.1872060895,
-0.3551284075,
-0.0112322802,
-0.4004784226,
-0.2305790335,
0.0569340773,
0.2213232219,
0.5021559596,
-0.0996555984,
0.5121364594,
0.1520765126,
0.2186972499,
0.3985061646,
0.4326228499,
-0.6407167315,
0.1481392235,
-0.1328311265,
-0.1322066486,
-0.0384518765,
-0.1478132308,
0.9600754976,
0.5834854841,
-0.2820564806,
0.459238112,
0.2673015296,
0.5945328474,
-0.6731335521,
0.3182002604,
-0.904343009,
0.0973755047,
-0.2142718583,
-0.357926935,
-0.5872195959,
-0.0063572223,
0.3762433231,
-0.7551521659,
0.000883723,
0.2226069123,
0.8491732478,
0.488530159,
-0.1606579274,
-0.1339680701,
-0.6287437081,
0.7264558673,
-0.2323246151,
0.8236368299,
0.4238896668,
0.4064643979,
0.0812374651,
-0.5348345637,
-0.610609293,
-0.1326916814,
0.3705310822,
0.3348037601,
-0.0387786627,
-0.0339243189,
0.1313836277,
0.1185768545,
-0.4861322939,
0.1929362863,
-0.0482179634,
0.249124378,
0.2905523777,
0.0670813769,
-0.2139912397,
-0.0117701236,
-0.5654031634,
-0.3291158974,
-0.7306225896,
0.2164200693,
0.233377099,
0.0782527179,
-0.2169570178,
0.4007125795,
-0.3220541477,
1.0282737017,
0.4338899553,
-0.0959459245,
0.4261374176,
-0.235772714,
-0.569748342,
-0.2976900339,
0.2896023393,
0.4947057366,
0.2186524123,
-0.2241459191,
-0.1753664464,
-0.3492371738,
0.2062088698,
-0.835677743,
-0.1425259262,
-0.0845822394,
-0.0892373696,
0.0575389005,
0.0833362415,
-0.5980139375,
-0.0218223631,
-0.5761411786,
0.5856058598,
-0.3969792128,
0.0643921793,
0.1178188398,
0.1938833743,
0.6837107539,
0.5379761457,
-0.9410457015,
0.2839477658,
0.3332497776,
0.8217272162,
0.2081375122,
-0.3106184006,
-1.1136237383,
0.1484603137,
-0.1730686426,
0.6815875173,
-0.3907677829,
0.1299543679,
0.3463220894,
0.0597775802,
-0.2195154577,
-0.6337925196,
0.0312895328,
-0.2977120578,
0.0792519674,
0.0521546453,
-0.6655194163,
-0.3500356376,
0.4728640318,
-0.3022634387,
0.9720925689,
0.0329332799,
-0.4360090196,
0.7897236347,
-0.4239485562,
-0.1385679394,
0.2575474679,
-0.4319937527,
-0.3777733445,
0.0321070515,
0.1912639439,
0.9118772149,
-0.0737388805,
0.1153768674,
-0.3058945537,
-0.0893220305,
0.0555991903,
-0.2026375234,
0.5125641823,
-0.1342167258,
-0.528281033,
-0.0567064434,
-0.6817504764,
-0.1320806146,
-0.0369437523,
-0.2015889734,
-0.5041672587,
0.0809749886,
0.360676378,
0.0909062177,
-0.1245221719,
-0.5495759845,
0.0665917695,
-0.5754129291,
0.0959697142,
0.9711934924,
-0.2597991824,
0.7180963755,
-0.0534095317,
0.2350822687,
-0.1350024045,
0.1267356128,
-0.3264957666,
-0.1443891823,
-0.5802298188,
-0.7732433677,
-0.2373334765,
0.3815946579,
-0.9644970894,
0.3573504984,
-0.524777174,
-0.4223999977,
-0.0505557917,
0.3413484693,
0.5141965747,
0.8211781979,
0.2951056957,
-0.2768405676,
-0.4337956905,
-0.7997323871,
-0.3290760815,
-0.0560428016,
-0.0644469038,
0.7551389337,
0.5891487598,
-0.1232728809,
0.9722126126,
-0.2953965068,
-0.5012329221,
-0.1673244536,
-0.3520115912,
0.0999897346,
0.0506819524,
0.7286821604,
-0.9012631178,
-0.7471769452,
0.0207245965,
-0.7209975719,
0.0273658969,
-0.1791070104,
-0.0186451599,
0.1892446131,
0.5746755004,
-0.0607090853,
0.3154901862,
0.5935584307,
-0.2626924813,
0.4323307872,
-0.4474667609,
-0.0759449154,
-0.9845433235,
-0.2107068151,
0.4929640889,
-0.6869772673,
-0.6467761397,
0.0214202534,
0.2681162357,
0.3098610342,
-0.7638306618,
0.6591698527,
-0.5908148289,
-0.0963563174,
0.027716795,
0.2092579603,
-0.2639183402,
0.802187562,
0.2877115309,
0.4674405754,
0.8490129709,
-0.9389926791,
0.3349320292,
0.2623963952,
-0.5465577245,
0.9396978617,
-0.1872399896,
0.0868054554,
-0.4908751547,
0.3601224422,
-0.556476295,
-0.5554935932,
0.3474356234,
-0.3094792664,
0.3342120349,
-0.0538969859,
-0.4238143563,
0.0714952946,
-0.3453665078,
0.4019696414,
0.3322254419,
-1.1420361996,
0.6680716276,
0.5618638992,
0.1531992406,
-0.512763679,
-0.5659932494,
0.0815119818,
-0.408888936,
-0.5161036849,
0.3918680251,
-0.2434182912,
-0.2069393396,
-0.0949003994,
0.1668244153,
-0.1162447557,
-0.0652979761,
0.1674149632,
0.1306316704,
0.1455666572,
0.3918330371,
-0.1945821494,
0.0970044732,
-0.2754243612,
-0.8226290941,
0.3019054532,
-0.4719634354,
-0.1101078019,
-0.1032696441,
0.1965271831,
0.3359041214,
-0.1241293773,
0.969161272,
0.4614211321,
-0.5963142514,
-0.4994386435,
-0.6015350223,
-0.0748753399,
-0.4220404327,
0.9277999997,
-0.22025837,
-0.8289867043,
0.1217225492,
-0.1039032862,
0.3045153916,
-0.0625438914,
0.8268788457,
-0.1452072114,
0.501459837,
0.7185385227,
0.1792658865,
0.8180422187,
-0.4799965024,
0.0064108274,
-0.9107611775,
-0.3795344234,
0.0207679383,
-0.1327392161,
-0.1533566415,
-0.6526990533,
0.7647708058,
-0.3258562684,
-0.3512773514,
0.3543626666,
-0.1629744917,
0.5758134723,
0.1837349385,
0.2923868895,
0.0847506821,
0.444283098,
0.1681032777,
-0.10222321,
-0.7523855567,
-0.1910602003,
1.2777210474,
0.2714007497,
0.6166400313,
0.2337368578,
0.5772007108,
-0.005803627,
0.5120933056,
-0.7827863097,
0.4424114823,
-0.137794435,
-0.1478709877,
-0.3417331576,
-0.2474746257,
-0.5560073256,
0.3216969073,
-0.121340245,
-0.7985025644,
0.230845958,
0.3324674964,
-0.3303978443,
0.3953606784,
-0.6260915995,
0.8231189847,
-0.3494640589,
-0.6125888228,
-0.2064980716,
-0.6376665831,
0.0838627666,
-0.205080539,
0.3603000343,
0.35516119,
-0.3099111915,
0.4592133462,
-0.2773220837,
0.8441225886,
-0.3443494737,
0.012980435,
0.1483996063,
-0.1298391819,
0.5773123503,
0.2007084638,
0.3311260045,
0.278057009,
-0.4253599048,
-0.2842110395,
-0.4079281986,
0.5459452271,
-0.5813928843,
-0.3044460714,
-0.3011568487,
-0.2602684498,
-0.2009434849,
-0.1369833201,
0.5840775967,
0.81553334,
-0.3870805204,
0.4672278762,
0.8432991505,
-0.2267864347,
0.4557670355,
0.4397269487,
-0.2891522944,
-0.3332197964,
0.8686575294,
0.1853097528,
0.3649775684,
0.4829211235,
0.0046417667,
-0.2052404135,
-0.277869463,
-0.6864042878,
0.1530543715,
-0.73114115,
-0.0792237371,
-0.7963194251,
0.0407796875,
-0.0653144494,
-0.3225495219,
-0.5080764294,
0.0519309305,
-0.1618524343,
-0.1792472154,
0.3407167494,
0.3372009993,
-0.0058882171,
-0.0089854645,
-0.5069979429,
0.032101512,
0.4400301576,
0.2064885348,
-0.0321729444,
-0.844776988,
-0.8021165133,
-0.056818381,
-0.0583278909,
-0.7677170634,
0.6230090857,
0.9050884247,
0.3718378544,
0.46983549,
-0.2941324413,
0.8212813735,
-0.820750773,
0.5135079622,
0.1842314154,
-0.7669894099,
0.2011997402,
-0.4301684201,
0.1495728493,
0.5861415267,
0.3246415555,
-0.5311297774,
-0.1270136088,
-0.3785327971,
-0.9477106333,
0.6399520636,
0.0860019103,
0.2247105539,
-0.0942941681,
0.3632077873,
0.258131057,
0.2274471074,
-0.8420129418,
-0.1918509156,
-0.3517279625,
-0.3041239083,
-0.2319888175,
0.1904969364,
0.039275568,
-0.6521396637,
0.70468086,
-0.5347964168,
0.0214679223,
0.5375596881,
-0.7187708616,
0.0648636818,
-0.1664347649,
0.4030329287,
0.394520402,
-0.1219880283,
0.068194434,
0.4332982302,
-0.4642723501,
0.1655443013,
-0.1080808491,
-0.1602363437,
-0.0712158754,
-0.0598999485,
0.7927762866,
0.5829642415,
-1.0484660864,
0.7728984356,
-0.1127662957,
-0.3089746833,
-1.0487020016,
-0.3913456798,
-0.2568567097,
0.5136908293,
0.3791336119,
0.1555244625,
0.1111092269,
-0.4681099057,
0.1956781149,
0.4169848263,
-0.398290813,
-0.5372282267,
0.5674990416,
0.2062372565,
-0.1869413257,
0.3717048764,
-0.4163669646,
-0.4062221944,
0.4716234803,
0.5344296098,
1.2305256128,
0.0607196279,
0.1762331128,
0.4851127863,
0.1298075765,
-0.1770948023,
-0.1638470739,
-0.4165836573,
-0.7469174266,
-0.3669764698,
-0.5315811038,
-0.2531269789,
-0.0503453314,
-0.436470449,
0.3181844056,
-0.5122118592,
0.198839426,
-0.4266197979,
-0.6753851175,
-1.1641860008,
0.0265925638,
0.5493531823,
0.7792671323,
-0.6051841378,
0.8251746297,
0.9284009337,
-0.0420350395,
-0.7475792766,
0.1772068292,
0.037462391,
-0.5512318611,
0.993955195,
0.4106861353,
-0.3728362918,
0.1745449752,
-0.6557712555,
-0.8051139712,
1.0919436216,
0.3883110285,
-0.7999798656,
0.0445908643,
-0.2962764502,
0.382362783,
-0.8069710135,
0.2466806769,
0.1832891554,
0.1783295423,
-0.0812200904,
-0.7676555514,
-0.3860574067,
-0.1976946145,
-0.1207181737,
0.0450426191,
-0.7876809835,
0.5649645925,
-0.0409651324,
-0.208870247,
-0.1568032354,
0.7865563631,
-0.0436491035,
0.3434015512,
0.7453581095,
0.5050243735,
0.6533597112,
0.2579662204,
1.0643522739,
-0.120682545,
0.4538293481,
1.1039656401,
-0.3275062144,
0.7739984989,
0.4786439836,
0.2621783912,
0.4545359313,
0.4979830682,
0.1722363085,
0.7789651752,
0.0317348279,
-0.4280531108,
-0.5363818407,
0.0327640846,
0.1346497983,
0.5389027596,
0.3825998604,
-0.0923977122,
-0.2025703192,
0.6062425971,
-0.1582377702,
0.1572706401,
-0.4473907351,
0.700235486,
0.084143132,
-0.5091244578,
0.5257793069,
-0.3064066768,
0.7740090489,
-0.5577636361,
0.0234147143,
0.1503926069,
0.4498171508,
-0.1324144304,
-0.2360045314,
0.0281610843,
0.3308018148,
-0.1113213748,
-0.3658180833,
0.2517976165,
-0.6805971861,
-0.3378960788,
0.3963533342,
0.3447637558,
0.0794375688,
-0.1794765741,
-0.3395403028,
-0.421456486,
-0.1472843885,
-0.3537737131,
0.4355754852,
0.2260083109,
-0.0454988703,
0.5873166919,
0.3920886815,
0.0607757755,
0.240769431,
0.0492488183,
0.8594822884,
-0.4732672572,
-0.6593191624,
-0.9560217261,
0.510930419,
-0.1004280746,
-0.2920285463,
0.924654007,
0.5752414465,
1.4660242796,
-0.2608678937,
0.5809870362,
-0.0365795717,
0.2494079024,
-0.6942144632,
0.3042176664,
-0.7887743711,
0.0911090821,
-0.3451746404,
-1.168840766,
-0.2388921231,
0.7101378441,
-0.3518312573,
-0.1536898166,
0.5836564302,
0.6762938499,
-0.206963256,
-0.3375368118,
0.3501743376,
0.327340275,
0.184717685,
0.7862158418,
0.7425359488,
-0.2910945714,
0.2529420257,
-0.1273347288,
-0.6417517066,
-0.4241845906,
-0.8146606684,
-0.8827220201,
-0.8932225108,
-0.2635786831,
-0.021621095,
0.0797030553,
1.4689323902,
0.8876171112,
-0.216904372,
-0.3613924682,
-0.0143209537,
-0.4348175824,
-0.4035952389,
-0.1302860528,
0.2581058741,
-0.1342263967,
-0.9203672409,
0.4181047082,
0.5944297314,
-0.2773188651,
-0.2965966761,
-0.3357299864,
-0.2326706201,
0.1727219969,
0.7620469332,
0.4350216985,
-0.4694932699,
-0.5289229155,
0.2279673666,
0.1814247072,
0.0473106503,
0.5727331638,
-0.9429274797,
0.7904655337,
0.2561145127,
0.7331420779,
0.7169195414,
-0.1760237366,
0.3870013952,
-0.9232760668,
0.5760932565,
0.2122556567,
0.5061896443,
0.4716913104,
-0.3465994895,
0.38671422,
0.2220217139,
-0.484369278,
-0.7710686326,
0.2850663066,
-0.882968843,
0.042808298,
1.3038747311,
-0.1613240838,
-0.5639217496,
-0.0067302976,
-0.0257770251,
-0.0097448444,
-0.1756334007,
0.6826860309,
0.4340763986,
0.0683349892,
-0.0656729117,
-0.6487902403,
0.3632338643,
0.465423733,
-0.6444413662,
0.0932958797,
0.5761962533,
0.2824185193,
-0.398919642,
0.5038229823,
0.1305847764,
0.3743430674,
-0.3529363275,
0.0479757786,
-0.254581511,
-0.6105682254,
-0.6363916397,
-0.1328426749,
-0.1812608391,
-0.2629262209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17035v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17035v1
|
Scalable Extraction of Training Data from (Production) Language Models
| 2023-11-28T18:47:03 | 2023-11-28T18:47:03 |
Milad Nasr, Nicholas Carlini, Jonathan Hayase, Matthew Jagielski, A. Feder Cooper, Daphne Ippolito, Christopher A. Choquette-Choo, Eric Wallace, Florian Tramèr, Katherine Lee
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
This paper studies extractable memorization: training data that an adversary
can efficiently extract by querying a machine learning model without prior
knowledge of the training dataset. We show an adversary can extract gigabytes
of training data from open-source language models like Pythia or GPT-Neo,
semi-open models like LLaMA or Falcon, and closed models like ChatGPT. Existing
techniques from the literature suffice to attack unaligned models; in order to
attack the aligned ChatGPT, we develop a new divergence attack that causes the
model to diverge from its chatbot-style generations and emit training data at a
rate 150x higher than when behaving properly. Our methods show practical
attacks can recover far more data than previously thought, and reveal that
current alignment techniques do not eliminate memorization.
|
[
-0.1856344491,
-1.0756784678,
0.0623253062,
-0.3043552339,
0.102575101,
0.2586843669,
-0.2055687457,
-0.3871777654,
-0.0126371067,
0.8128413558,
-0.5437208414,
-0.2346834838,
-0.592977941,
-0.440171659,
-0.7343586683,
1.1730701923,
0.2043774277,
-0.1769257188,
0.0284159202,
-0.1154943407,
-0.2488376498,
-0.7805777788,
-0.4829401672,
0.0220537242,
0.3184399307,
0.3474641442,
0.6774659753,
0.7489774227,
0.8801469803,
0.3286418319,
-0.0821652487,
-0.2219292969,
-0.7304468751,
0.1951503307,
-0.124689728,
-0.6827625036,
-0.3513320684,
0.0305146538,
0.8040599823,
0.5237608552,
-0.2369315624,
0.1760804057,
-0.3191182315,
0.8918303847,
-0.6657426953,
0.0197144132,
-1.0393303633,
0.1179356501,
-0.4023856223,
0.1874696314,
-0.6090735197,
-0.2775692046,
0.2382059097,
-0.4051162601,
0.4366028905,
-0.1822237521,
1.0751957893,
0.2134996802,
-0.0571392253,
-0.3235642612,
-0.8628951311,
0.8029183149,
-0.5026267767,
0.3191654384,
0.1620487124,
0.7613989711,
-0.1209666356,
-0.9789263606,
-0.3380526304,
0.0152938981,
0.1267140657,
0.1307519972,
-0.5405768156,
-0.0989603028,
0.6887955666,
0.6928735971,
-0.367726475,
0.1817620248,
-0.5230873823,
-0.0954233706,
0.5732469559,
0.0477677584,
0.6168602109,
0.0656444877,
-0.4412464797,
-0.2914807796,
-0.8454660177,
-0.1045105904,
0.6393823028,
0.4133148193,
-0.1188313141,
0.7464475632,
-0.0480279773,
0.488758266,
-0.0144274095,
0.0960241258,
0.0103036091,
-0.126946941,
-0.324601233,
-0.0279900488,
0.9329093695,
-0.2290638983,
0.3038315177,
-0.4204832315,
-0.3331848383,
-0.2169891596,
0.4849876761,
-0.7623118162,
-0.6008083224,
0.1940260082,
-0.2225156277,
-0.2991104126,
0.1298804432,
-1.0896346569,
-0.2771452963,
0.1722168773,
0.3732603192,
-0.5035181046,
-0.4824479222,
-0.1819487959,
-0.3723981678,
0.3267529905,
-0.0542396158,
-1.1884272099,
0.1472070366,
0.7832963467,
0.88484478,
0.0140305478,
0.0193049926,
-0.503254056,
0.0555780083,
-0.2696285248,
0.3731219172,
-0.4345112443,
-0.3599852622,
-0.1219947711,
-0.1311950833,
-0.3240772486,
-0.5636582375,
0.2421144843,
-0.8962916732,
0.2611088455,
0.0317414999,
-0.7479605079,
-0.1210835278,
0.2744645476,
-1.0267529488,
0.6902513504,
0.1819554269,
-1.0077189207,
0.0572618358,
-0.71625489,
-0.0268566497,
0.0126536703,
-0.2311645299,
-0.6784394383,
0.0608967729,
0.4214725196,
0.2880110145,
-0.0782162324,
-0.0746694282,
-0.4029624462,
-0.0520097613,
0.364615798,
-0.5266974568,
1.0521179438,
0.2827985585,
-0.1381718516,
-0.291105479,
-0.8135112524,
0.1198025867,
0.483938247,
-0.4849829674,
-0.2482676059,
0.1543510258,
-0.4675691128,
-0.0379360169,
0.318495959,
-0.5300822854,
0.354219377,
-0.6203925014,
0.4334833622,
0.6302357912,
0.1107168794,
0.4498100877,
-0.1542406678,
0.5866538882,
-0.0740032345,
-0.10296987,
-0.2341703027,
-0.1848073602,
-0.7868101001,
-0.6009305716,
0.4347215295,
0.4309606552,
-0.6027303338,
0.1308481246,
-0.4400550425,
-0.6829352379,
-0.7467916608,
0.1609315276,
0.355903089,
0.5299258828,
0.1842126846,
-0.2246721238,
-0.7152276635,
-0.7559952736,
-0.5439546704,
-0.0401430428,
-0.1775666922,
0.1043611988,
0.4009647071,
-0.1423458159,
1.0305314064,
-0.5788004994,
0.0971232429,
-0.1780995578,
0.165507555,
0.1540399492,
0.6605899334,
0.2913721502,
-0.6814938188,
-0.4374359548,
0.3607612848,
-0.899543643,
0.2367789,
-0.0988346711,
-0.068263568,
0.0351518206,
0.6959761381,
-0.7563064098,
0.2423758954,
0.4078357816,
0.2155906409,
0.3615204096,
-0.0025318053,
-0.4911730886,
-1.1473833323,
0.2199395001,
-0.2595988214,
-0.155404374,
-0.8240826726,
0.3433192968,
0.1749421805,
-0.1345048249,
-0.3855213225,
0.1774325371,
-0.6155759096,
-0.1629623175,
-0.0128656505,
0.1213396415,
-0.2952967584,
0.274202317,
0.1663714796,
0.7256031036,
0.5088589191,
-0.3949579895,
0.1425263733,
0.2656489313,
-0.4590230584,
0.2102070302,
-0.5996733308,
0.5783521533,
-0.1098436266,
-0.2291970402,
-0.7386029363,
-0.2877386212,
0.0651592016,
-0.6308288574,
0.598336637,
-0.6189661622,
-0.2982920706,
-0.1660913378,
-0.0042235344,
0.0925263688,
0.693092525,
-0.7584765553,
0.3430792987,
0.5483722091,
-0.0245850049,
-0.9854190946,
-0.4604487121,
-0.1935727894,
-0.4801118076,
-0.3901050389,
-0.1583680511,
0.1646393538,
-0.3375563025,
-0.2033235729,
-0.0596087687,
-0.2068171054,
0.3923785985,
0.1677956134,
0.337290287,
-0.3974261582,
-0.0080305738,
-0.2940124869,
0.0896282643,
0.2418167442,
-0.1852784455,
0.6465529799,
-0.1189501509,
-0.4154865742,
-0.3129494786,
0.171978727,
0.5887725353,
-0.1652179807,
0.7468016744,
0.6287938952,
-0.4804719985,
-0.2058950961,
-0.4002993107,
-0.0801094547,
-0.5259927511,
0.648873508,
-0.2249724567,
-0.5929425359,
0.3667656183,
-0.0647324398,
0.4033691883,
0.500865519,
0.4828928113,
-0.1258545667,
1.093462944,
0.7776730061,
-0.3385350704,
0.7461224198,
-0.4289058745,
0.1752543002,
-0.7255926132,
-0.3116590083,
-0.5388844609,
-0.1022488102,
-0.6255248189,
-0.0469940491,
-0.044022616,
0.3591991067,
-0.2989922464,
0.5130509138,
-0.3438866436,
0.6983894706,
0.4954057634,
-0.0098758424,
0.0848274156,
0.2072264403,
0.0773336887,
-0.0312317479,
-0.597905755,
-0.4180974066,
1.4264531136,
0.5145134926,
0.6749927402,
0.2340994179,
0.6719617844,
0.0426163115,
0.2913775146,
-0.8252472878,
0.2221024036,
0.0929851532,
-0.8148452044,
-0.2587657273,
-0.6187213063,
-1.0966384411,
0.2774803638,
-0.0639201924,
-1.0827202797,
-0.0440179184,
-0.0724523962,
-0.0759679005,
0.5291785598,
-0.9231732488,
0.8059866428,
-0.2765625417,
-0.0140390107,
0.1279607713,
-0.6470871568,
0.5165300369,
-0.3349580467,
0.05789309,
-0.0113925617,
0.224437356,
0.9706719518,
-0.592030704,
0.8894179463,
-0.1621602029,
0.0733172446,
0.3641938567,
0.156244576,
0.5428875089,
-0.1817234606,
0.2045785934,
0.1695644706,
-0.0565241203,
-0.4601865709,
-0.5564541221,
0.2658875883,
-0.9190135002,
-0.6394003034,
-0.202885136,
-0.6842766404,
-0.1871420443,
0.3485503793,
0.3460808992,
0.0384971946,
-0.5473182797,
0.3745672405,
0.6715222001,
0.1202665865,
0.6245265007,
0.4383695126,
0.172648266,
-0.5024768114,
1.1072434187,
0.0697004199,
0.6589435339,
0.4654720426,
0.0069657722,
-0.06251169,
-0.535566628,
-0.3267581165,
0.1308977753,
-0.6325476766,
-0.1232085004,
-0.612501204,
-0.5099812746,
-0.2061472386,
0.1193147078,
-0.820547998,
-0.7104101777,
-0.2682329714,
-0.0452978872,
0.2066315264,
0.7400610447,
0.113527827,
0.7132607698,
-0.9843871593,
-0.2117070705,
0.1762813777,
-0.0596477836,
-0.0342887081,
-0.4392958581,
-0.3623979986,
0.1877363473,
-0.4927005172,
-0.8485207558,
0.6920068264,
0.0007659555,
0.5659601688,
0.7919591665,
-0.2405482382,
0.5733952522,
-0.2897303402,
0.6363872886,
0.2176908553,
-0.7801908255,
0.5244942904,
-0.4093391001,
0.1765367687,
0.3998659849,
0.6539607048,
-0.2819915116,
-0.2163101584,
-0.9816326499,
-0.7078021169,
0.9748741984,
0.2157187164,
0.048327148,
0.2121581584,
0.3161165118,
0.0071887337,
0.2645197511,
-0.665235281,
0.0673599243,
-0.1051808372,
-0.3390893936,
0.0484488383,
-0.0530719869,
-0.286026597,
0.0361118987,
0.4295196831,
0.0402943976,
0.2392591536,
-0.2587835491,
-0.3914766908,
0.0744358674,
0.0096578794,
-0.0007643869,
0.3541880846,
-0.1930739582,
0.0220030975,
-0.0069794198,
-0.7648108006,
-0.0934950635,
0.0212565437,
-0.2404386997,
-0.2061520368,
0.4444081783,
0.5141423345,
-0.1498329639,
-0.8373472095,
0.5195604563,
-0.1364147663,
-0.0727444142,
-0.2528654933,
0.2083753943,
0.1779668033,
0.4228882492,
-0.1213095412,
-0.0691985488,
-0.2230045795,
-0.423999548,
0.2881364226,
0.7772013545,
-0.5783984065,
-0.4644140303,
0.5404955745,
-0.3702001572,
-0.2886120677,
1.165574789,
0.3591009676,
-0.3790355623,
0.7191335559,
0.6294913292,
0.735914886,
-0.3539366126,
0.05677085,
0.4197659194,
0.4171825349,
-0.0877458155,
-0.0770110115,
-0.2135312259,
-0.6908310652,
0.0782502517,
-0.3103427291,
-0.4869563282,
0.3229874074,
-0.8596386313,
0.1660538614,
-0.7204886675,
0.0001205512,
0.1482019722,
-0.0609299615,
-0.4870105982,
-0.0027662138,
-0.0010322528,
0.529281795,
-0.5473482013,
0.8893114328,
0.2527688444,
-0.6687413454,
-0.6904706359,
-0.0722557083,
-0.0284500532,
-0.973438561,
0.5426641703,
0.1201496869,
0.2974827886,
-0.0970533416,
-0.7321388721,
-1.0984942913,
0.894697845,
0.6024360061,
-0.5672482252,
-0.1710426807,
0.2689852118,
0.4374904931,
-0.1100431979,
0.2062111795,
0.9045708776,
-0.0432021134,
-0.019071633,
-0.4395736456,
-0.2292786241,
-0.1958380938,
-0.3701804876,
0.4205163121,
-0.6073957086,
1.0927494764,
-0.144873932,
-0.6438254714,
-0.0908488706,
0.5983551741,
-0.2110296935,
-0.1462123692,
0.1880097091,
0.7017005086,
1.1132001877,
-0.0551007949,
0.8315848112,
-0.0345631167,
0.3791295588,
1.2168076038,
-0.0096104033,
0.9887003303,
0.4319808185,
-0.0426600538,
0.3393006623,
0.5338695645,
-0.1177256405,
0.5679324269,
0.0979516581,
-0.1140540689,
0.0052921432,
0.434507519,
-0.2863961756,
0.6007050276,
0.5184528828,
-0.411627233,
-0.180802688,
-0.4623247087,
0.3302232623,
-0.1969039738,
-0.117021203,
1.1236851215,
0.0357034691,
-0.6056405306,
0.7327135205,
-0.0999106243,
0.1623032838,
-0.6435310245,
0.1076620147,
-0.1835400462,
0.4822428823,
-0.2289471477,
-0.3571875691,
0.3453678191,
0.131883502,
-0.0445242748,
0.1778039783,
0.6221173406,
-0.3585105836,
-0.3202566206,
-0.0858713388,
0.6145097017,
0.2378079295,
-0.0602510273,
-0.620683372,
-0.1126860753,
0.0760989785,
-0.4340312481,
0.555480659,
0.3315431774,
-0.097957693,
0.6849291921,
0.6123309731,
0.1567855328,
0.3290939033,
-0.2820000648,
0.9480798244,
-0.4930130541,
-0.2992628217,
-1.1157519817,
0.1885062307,
-0.3598898351,
-0.0243585557,
0.9368424416,
0.5807115436,
1.0072791576,
0.0474740081,
0.8769342899,
0.132922709,
0.4515913129,
-0.6303818226,
0.7985585332,
-0.1723618358,
0.2886371613,
-0.2103123665,
-0.7493826151,
-0.0423360951,
0.4283940196,
-0.343359679,
-0.1040776893,
0.692901969,
0.7119575739,
-0.1271456927,
0.3313949704,
0.1389542669,
0.2538372576,
0.5991897583,
0.577601254,
1.021628499,
-0.3898363411,
0.7087128758,
-0.2397760749,
-0.0508272983,
0.0106410431,
-0.6621180177,
-1.1887676716,
-0.408901155,
-0.1874415129,
-0.2044425458,
-0.0214872044,
0.4532937706,
0.6604729295,
-0.7570334077,
-0.192310065,
-0.2247182876,
0.1714037359,
-0.1285331547,
-0.2185425609,
0.5472519398,
-0.5299640298,
-0.8476585746,
0.5633390546,
-0.1633029878,
0.3144391477,
-0.2675995231,
0.1979364008,
-0.0038302075,
0.0627130717,
0.110008806,
0.7159537077,
-0.1805725098,
-0.0962430909,
-0.1165624559,
0.1107219085,
0.3679432273,
0.7828492522,
-0.4535053074,
0.6129515171,
0.4581364691,
0.977076292,
0.5981297493,
0.1706846505,
0.607031703,
-0.9833194017,
0.2645320892,
0.2838892639,
0.3222362995,
0.3327153623,
-0.4060258567,
0.4648089707,
0.2982419729,
-0.4632468224,
-0.8942283988,
0.2079383582,
-0.6422975659,
-0.2038049698,
0.8812327385,
-0.4230493903,
-0.5260636806,
0.149223119,
0.0599283017,
0.3088290393,
-0.1827158034,
0.7534650564,
0.6419181824,
0.1144812629,
0.1656485647,
-0.7216475606,
0.5014497638,
0.2929753065,
-0.8487145305,
0.3238020837,
0.4706979692,
0.3289478421,
0.1171742007,
0.3830522299,
-0.586476326,
0.0520799719,
0.4845407605,
-0.0016285467,
0.057931941,
-0.2752431631,
-0.3858986199,
0.4923605919,
0.0390001349,
-0.4458786547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17030v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17030v2
|
Is This the Subspace You Are Looking for? An Interpretability Illusion for Subspace Activation Patching
| 2023-11-28T18:32:19 | 2023-12-06T14:28:46 |
Aleksandar Makelov, Georg Lange, Neel Nanda
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Mechanistic interpretability aims to understand model behaviors in terms of
specific, interpretable features, often hypothesized to manifest as
low-dimensional subspaces of activations. Specifically, recent studies have
explored subspace interventions (such as activation patching) as a way to
simultaneously manipulate model behavior and attribute the features behind it
to given subspaces.
In this work, we demonstrate that these two aims diverge, potentially leading
to an illusory sense of interpretability. Counterintuitively, even if a
subspace intervention makes the model's output behave as if the value of a
feature was changed, this effect may be achieved by activating a dormant
parallel pathway leveraging another subspace that is causally disconnected from
model outputs. We demonstrate this phenomenon in a distilled mathematical
example, in two real-world domains (the indirect object identification task and
factual recall), and present evidence for its prevalence in practice. In the
context of factual recall, we further show a link to rank-1 fact editing,
providing a mechanistic explanation for previous work observing an
inconsistency between fact editing performance and fact localization.
However, this does not imply that activation patching of subspaces is
intrinsically unfit for interpretability. To contextualize our findings, we
also show what a success case looks like in a task (indirect object
identification) where prior manual circuit analysis informs an understanding of
the location of a feature. We explore the additional evidence needed to argue
that a patched subspace is faithful.
|
[
0.0764721632,
-0.850484252,
0.962554574,
0.4119050503,
-0.3172002435,
0.1918824613,
0.1170841828,
-0.441967696,
0.5741878748,
0.3273793757,
-0.7920770645,
-0.2536887228,
-0.6390089989,
-0.2502905428,
-0.4133408368,
0.7887063026,
-0.1825164109,
-0.2470387071,
-0.5772984028,
-0.2807549238,
-0.7254551649,
-0.637663722,
-0.2641573846,
-0.2878470123,
0.3132013679,
0.4294526577,
0.8533970118,
0.8000665307,
0.435059607,
0.2663867176,
-0.1070137694,
0.0391122065,
-0.6688387394,
-0.2929915786,
-0.3596013486,
-0.8506407738,
-0.6626932025,
0.1552120149,
0.553383112,
0.9173727632,
-0.020515101,
0.0839905068,
0.2047749758,
0.3430484533,
-0.5265889168,
0.0476107821,
-0.6500890255,
0.0388050862,
-0.2013173997,
-0.526540935,
-0.3998559713,
0.0671598539,
-0.081337817,
-0.6553893685,
0.4973565936,
0.1484590918,
0.9137684107,
0.2949041426,
-0.1341878027,
-0.1758708507,
-0.9417227507,
0.7225834131,
-0.4981705248,
0.1448601335,
0.3085151017,
0.2407934815,
-0.0686708912,
-0.666823864,
-0.6373787522,
0.012502295,
-0.5604357123,
0.0924713388,
-0.5396524072,
0.148209855,
0.6864677668,
0.24117814,
-0.305965364,
-0.1147319973,
-0.6000130773,
-0.4036426544,
0.0848854631,
0.2989436686,
0.3882361054,
-0.5386095047,
-0.7642068267,
0.195476383,
-0.8018948436,
0.3595866561,
0.2609685957,
0.0975987241,
-0.1094522923,
0.3651292622,
-0.190641284,
0.6691094041,
-0.0080524907,
0.0542872921,
0.093861267,
-0.3137120306,
-0.343970716,
-0.0358012505,
0.1426882446,
0.1930261254,
-0.2188006341,
-0.1806101799,
0.0525664762,
-0.0025561817,
0.7435165048,
-0.5057207346,
-0.4871147573,
0.2418196499,
-0.7686895728,
-0.5804265738,
0.216932103,
-0.5587563515,
-0.1257953793,
-0.4623096585,
0.6110141277,
-0.3219999373,
-0.4546369016,
0.2033701837,
-0.1772243828,
-0.1012018472,
0.2922602296,
-0.8653414249,
0.3525261581,
0.815269649,
0.9300680757,
-0.0298132971,
-0.563675046,
-0.3613419831,
-0.1154438108,
-0.3301946223,
0.5857768059,
-0.7025455236,
-0.0365098566,
-0.3366195858,
0.3723345995,
-0.3020069301,
-0.5203202367,
0.2561591268,
-0.6347037554,
-0.2429635525,
-0.5420582891,
-0.1278446317,
-0.4776203334,
0.2216140032,
-0.6455423236,
0.4745128155,
0.0717319921,
-0.3522610366,
0.441971153,
-0.476461798,
-0.2868435383,
-0.4207203388,
-0.0801533163,
-0.5021541715,
0.3852026761,
-0.0398326814,
0.1515640318,
0.2749219239,
0.2165605277,
-0.297883302,
-0.3763602376,
0.5687733889,
-0.7758917212,
0.5394232869,
0.0746839717,
-0.4563754499,
0.0287056603,
-0.8817964196,
-0.3257382214,
-0.1308278739,
0.0628884584,
-0.4583943486,
0.2398743182,
-0.2443472743,
0.3409356475,
0.2998850942,
-0.5122380257,
0.2108696848,
-0.1365645379,
0.1567112207,
0.9154859781,
0.4210501909,
0.4299632013,
-0.2263068408,
0.702029109,
0.219750613,
0.3548695445,
-0.1704795063,
-0.4433137476,
-0.7348481417,
-0.4893252254,
0.0593665615,
0.3097582161,
-0.8270878792,
-0.0590733662,
-0.3565987647,
-0.1793977618,
-0.0755213648,
0.1527157277,
0.6076719165,
0.531814456,
0.5050072074,
-0.2382148206,
-0.3018289208,
-1.1968621016,
-0.5180988312,
-0.008887643,
0.1578309536,
0.2539004087,
0.1564779729,
0.1981419772,
0.928619504,
-0.6950471997,
-0.4364416003,
-0.0775221959,
0.5654360652,
0.5090833306,
0.6579934359,
0.6001117826,
-0.7339093685,
0.034774676,
-0.1888366491,
-1.0612390041,
-0.0872636735,
-0.6210328341,
-0.1668442786,
-0.440900296,
0.8872588873,
-0.4869433939,
0.7581069469,
0.2538317442,
-0.4500414431,
0.3747612238,
-0.4136822522,
0.2746706009,
-0.446141839,
0.2123434097,
-0.4501193762,
-0.2927825451,
-0.8954895735,
0.0844945386,
0.0867232904,
0.0295029394,
-0.4412128925,
0.084958002,
-0.5212254524,
-0.2639191151,
-0.3442140818,
-0.1584002078,
0.2642232478,
0.7355147004,
-0.366761744,
0.6222219467,
0.2836146951,
-0.3771853149,
-0.13799496,
0.3784334362,
-0.3126921952,
0.4433920681,
-0.4748729765,
-0.1018243358,
-0.335490495,
-0.0772850439,
-0.9838455319,
-0.2294633538,
0.4872920215,
-0.1717232019,
0.3380946517,
-0.2068142295,
-0.2006372064,
0.0420589224,
-0.0977186039,
0.8099367023,
0.5072152019,
-0.6376825571,
0.6361398101,
-0.1349280477,
-0.1154646203,
-0.5498371124,
-0.6103433371,
-0.0430620573,
-0.3119472265,
-0.275529027,
-0.03821446,
0.3172379136,
-0.2528497577,
0.2894779146,
-0.237044692,
-0.002679544,
0.4285627306,
0.5112466216,
0.334813714,
-0.1092966124,
0.1330077052,
0.4158996642,
-0.299906373,
0.3719922304,
-0.0823636949,
0.0824609771,
0.270719558,
-0.9712200165,
-0.2599388957,
0.0717516094,
0.8012810349,
-0.1621324569,
0.5054562092,
0.3106565177,
-0.4491761625,
-0.1178032234,
-0.2276871353,
-0.2896396518,
-0.4685993195,
0.3048344254,
-0.6131284237,
-0.574672699,
0.5837756991,
-0.3791154027,
-0.2272375822,
0.4200091362,
0.1374236643,
-0.1491787583,
0.9533344507,
0.5685352683,
0.2034159601,
0.4677678943,
-0.2422759533,
0.4567307234,
-0.9154701233,
-0.2297834307,
-0.0633772686,
-0.6860240698,
-0.3470825553,
-0.7506133318,
0.8097894788,
0.2947583497,
0.4751963615,
0.1552114636,
-0.2709296942,
0.4393535554,
0.3050563931,
0.559076488,
0.4020122588,
0.1189361587,
0.0858164281,
-0.4923379421,
-0.8294453621,
-0.1917042136,
0.9864175916,
0.4086371064,
0.5371537209,
0.1587563157,
0.2498506457,
0.4079819322,
0.4889572859,
-0.432280302,
0.2172937244,
-0.1703925729,
-0.5109383464,
-0.1505566537,
-0.0575816594,
-0.8718497753,
0.37946257,
-0.4669818878,
-0.9766552448,
0.8998209238,
0.6667823195,
-0.2194145471,
0.3757751286,
-0.5874552727,
1.0282621384,
-0.0748843253,
-0.5726906657,
-0.73023206,
-0.3467214108,
0.5454938412,
0.0471012183,
0.4439437985,
0.0303643811,
0.4035981596,
0.21948722,
-0.5133675933,
1.1088676453,
-0.3924726844,
0.2565526366,
-0.0255840123,
0.2822501957,
0.5001517534,
0.0202055704,
0.2202306092,
0.2830341458,
-0.0736745596,
-0.6715521216,
-1.1206610203,
0.5327249765,
-0.5178675056,
-0.7934918404,
-0.3268572986,
-0.634817183,
-0.0528389774,
0.1506952941,
0.2214095443,
1.080296278,
-0.2686671913,
-0.1908849627,
0.7058627605,
-0.2087945342,
-0.0148925614,
0.375893414,
-0.466630578,
0.2447279543,
1.6237010956,
0.0628722832,
0.5606760383,
0.476652503,
-0.0932317898,
0.1089278162,
-0.640327096,
-0.3758579791,
0.1102890223,
-0.7873021364,
0.3106772006,
-0.5267837048,
-0.0527548417,
0.2900227904,
-0.1565340906,
-0.2653932571,
-0.7338471413,
-0.3072781861,
-0.1656663567,
0.078177318,
0.8911391497,
-0.4899602234,
0.1616914868,
-0.5035277009,
0.5063954592,
0.4894672334,
0.1580033302,
0.1183572114,
-0.4507247806,
-0.3703285754,
0.1101408973,
-0.20727247,
-0.6653678417,
-0.0249839108,
0.0016459123,
0.4305962026,
0.6986449957,
-0.2499210685,
0.715372026,
-0.4744874537,
0.6442294717,
0.0643129125,
-1.0917431116,
0.3976731896,
-0.2407333106,
0.1084670126,
0.3430252671,
0.1063877419,
-0.293743521,
-0.6449919939,
-0.8649807572,
-0.6822749376,
0.757935822,
0.2322246879,
0.1050707549,
0.1930509955,
0.4851603806,
0.1653718799,
0.4023962617,
-0.5180172324,
-0.3276395798,
-0.3014931679,
0.0491438471,
-0.088971287,
-0.6278455257,
-0.3356804848,
-0.1489863843,
0.3126102984,
-0.113550514,
0.4187627435,
0.3822566271,
-0.3193562925,
-0.2225374132,
0.2110779881,
0.7858329415,
1.2228326797,
-0.3849466443,
0.4006157219,
-0.0944311768,
-0.3948448896,
0.0023215997,
-0.0370446406,
-0.2756594121,
0.0301746763,
0.7768951654,
0.9602200389,
0.5614429116,
-0.3036243618,
0.7132707834,
0.1877441108,
-0.1046955958,
0.0425416641,
-0.0085983882,
-0.3938809037,
0.3112298846,
0.1872054636,
0.8065192699,
0.5455427766,
-0.6812681556,
0.0440867618,
0.4786952138,
-0.790700078,
-0.6465826035,
0.8823140264,
-0.2668965459,
0.0908761099,
0.4472980201,
-0.1684947163,
-0.7052419186,
0.7511367798,
0.1546835303,
0.8240551353,
0.0807318762,
0.3120911419,
0.2557491362,
0.6766795516,
0.3230414689,
0.1177240163,
-0.0841057822,
-0.5897769928,
-0.4266738296,
-0.4237026274,
-0.3595807552,
-0.0214092378,
-0.925891459,
0.020067241,
-0.3848058879,
0.292565465,
0.1678102314,
-0.9761861563,
-0.5254580379,
0.2466399968,
-0.3303486407,
0.6941916347,
-1.4172357321,
0.5828715563,
0.7290397882,
-0.2928826511,
-0.6845144629,
0.3864993453,
0.1529451162,
-0.8318767548,
0.4698213637,
-0.0861757547,
0.030910911,
-0.1955139637,
-0.564907968,
-0.8943155408,
1.1312162876,
0.1472397596,
-0.1398266703,
0.1350760162,
0.2996591628,
0.6372643113,
-0.0754302442,
0.0420586728,
0.658667326,
0.3846106827,
-0.1006974205,
-0.6875523329,
0.4925817251,
-0.1881475151,
-0.1129116714,
0.0857034922,
-0.6563785672,
1.0443813801,
-0.0066485293,
-0.1617087871,
-0.0227206834,
0.4742520154,
-0.236800015,
0.4299563169,
0.7665789723,
0.4372706115,
0.5564954877,
0.0425383933,
1.0430160761,
-0.1694208235,
0.3898296356,
0.762532413,
0.3518494666,
0.5596826077,
0.6551709771,
-0.1784967482,
0.6716414094,
0.1430605352,
0.1249990314,
0.8167764544,
-0.1606311798,
-0.1837128997,
-0.5125790834,
0.047034137,
-0.0609745644,
0.4309369028,
0.5029104948,
-0.3148352206,
-0.1819515675,
0.2119801491,
-0.0419082306,
0.0376838855,
-0.1107358336,
0.4415140152,
0.1128927693,
-0.6012081504,
0.4208998978,
-0.2993801236,
-0.1494659036,
-0.4170379043,
-0.6037432551,
-0.027960714,
0.2374063283,
-0.4198680818,
-0.5295724273,
0.5713594556,
-0.3706290722,
-0.6846439838,
-0.3787885904,
0.7369787097,
-0.2765216529,
-0.4292194545,
0.1327305287,
0.6838306785,
0.142655462,
0.0045776046,
-0.2915846109,
0.1484082937,
0.1916337162,
0.0467106886,
0.3973149061,
0.3953658938,
-0.2898497283,
0.4969379604,
0.7879742384,
0.137077257,
-0.1000667959,
-0.3011834323,
1.0775742531,
-0.4234438837,
-0.537145257,
-0.6348295808,
0.6909636259,
-0.0524760932,
-0.1307836026,
0.6897718906,
0.2515747845,
0.3894385397,
-0.1436944753,
0.6883824468,
-0.1283502132,
0.5065634847,
-0.9269064069,
0.582174778,
-0.6847251654,
0.6742839813,
-0.283136338,
-0.6639252901,
0.0874387398,
0.2541746795,
-0.5283555984,
-0.4325299263,
0.880836606,
0.8041940331,
-0.5640551448,
-0.090265058,
0.4353000522,
0.8864133954,
0.1202925518,
0.2139446586,
0.9670016766,
-0.1794608533,
0.2170452476,
-0.3762900829,
-0.6051880121,
-0.2612707615,
-0.7419007421,
-0.7638808489,
-0.4673930109,
-0.1374045461,
-0.4071746469,
0.0272092614,
0.451860249,
0.4684053659,
-0.7637636065,
0.1613107771,
-0.243758902,
0.528003931,
-0.6699742675,
-0.2598007917,
0.4107499421,
-0.3195851743,
-0.4755276442,
0.4166944921,
0.4776962996,
-0.3981993198,
-0.2454463392,
0.4139042497,
0.0436032824,
0.0193796251,
0.389701277,
0.557884872,
-0.7081902623,
-0.586941123,
-0.1368547082,
0.303986907,
0.1920683384,
1.0755763054,
-0.8169003725,
1.0199251175,
0.1808855832,
0.3447359204,
0.4763001502,
0.3117586076,
0.6569743752,
-0.8975508213,
0.3060906827,
-0.3421780765,
0.3264257908,
0.0866689384,
-0.4957775474,
0.2228234112,
0.5712957382,
-0.2495802939,
-0.6985118985,
0.2615331411,
-0.9656206369,
-0.1965138167,
0.8024426699,
-0.3095162511,
-0.1862445325,
-0.3327924907,
-0.1834943593,
-0.1481060684,
0.2024704665,
0.9680924416,
0.5502824783,
-0.3636273742,
0.0397890508,
-0.6827287078,
0.6367614269,
0.5911930203,
-0.5706147552,
-0.0824782103,
0.5581516623,
0.2258624583,
0.6376351714,
0.5621458292,
0.1258969903,
0.6659680009,
0.1142327935,
-0.2264953554,
-0.1408128738,
-0.4043144584,
-0.5371618271,
0.0973203257,
0.2994897664,
-0.3307919502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03741v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03741v1
|
Comparing Generative Chatbots Based on Process Requirements
| 2023-11-28T18:25:22 | 2023-11-28T18:25:22 |
Luis Fernando Lins, Nathalia Nascimento, Paulo Alencar, Toacy Oliveira, Donald Cowan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE
|
Business processes are commonly represented by modelling languages, such as
Event-driven Process Chain (EPC), Yet Another Workflow Language (YAWL), and the
most popular standard notation for modelling business processes, the Business
Process Model and Notation (BPMN). Most recently, chatbots, programs that allow
users to interact with a machine using natural language, have been increasingly
used for business process execution support. A recent category of chatbots
worth mentioning is generative-based chatbots, powered by Large Language Models
(LLMs) such as OpenAI's Generative Pre-Trained Transformer (GPT) model and
Google's Pathways Language Model (PaLM), which are trained on billions of
parameters and support conversational intelligence. However, it is not clear
whether generative-based chatbots are able to understand and meet the
requirements of constructs such as those provided by BPMN for process execution
support. This paper presents a case study to compare the performance of
prominent generative models, GPT and PaLM, in the context of process execution
support. The research sheds light into the challenging problem of using
conversational approaches supported by generative chatbots as a means to
understand process-aware modelling notations and support users to execute their
tasks.
|
[
-0.2264981717,
-0.8381496072,
0.632532537,
0.2823577821,
-0.2200462073,
0.1902951747,
-0.0831690282,
-0.5279326439,
-0.0847544372,
0.7032516599,
-0.5849311948,
-0.2901376784,
-0.478833586,
0.1733778417,
-0.266336143,
1.0421646833,
-0.0665332824,
-0.1996583641,
-0.142922774,
0.1990351528,
-0.3251250982,
-0.7175992727,
-0.8659370542,
-0.4956351817,
0.1548806131,
-0.0653404295,
1.0250225067,
0.0441437028,
0.4837925136,
0.3406020999,
0.0052346191,
-0.09229514,
-0.2045219839,
0.419631362,
0.137468189,
-0.5125186443,
-0.3788539767,
-0.2331476957,
0.0350855999,
0.6669967771,
-0.3590747118,
0.0095691476,
0.0738744214,
0.5241170526,
-0.4134455621,
0.6086314321,
-0.4927238524,
0.2519890666,
-0.0157295614,
-0.0371364579,
-0.3350090086,
-0.3024089634,
0.3093130887,
-0.4307501614,
0.4985867739,
-0.1716668755,
1.0212544203,
-0.0529814437,
0.2647312284,
-0.5404518247,
-1.1223038435,
0.2835331261,
-0.7737078071,
0.1543491334,
0.1283358186,
0.5994964838,
-0.3539170623,
-0.7841256261,
-0.6527776718,
-0.3673043251,
-0.0126185343,
0.4796384573,
-0.3809993863,
0.3435911834,
0.6314113736,
0.5247036815,
-0.6020172834,
0.259552449,
-0.2975946963,
-0.0384821072,
0.16457811,
0.2567466199,
0.0516135991,
-0.0955256149,
-0.4015215635,
-0.0244703665,
-0.3549705148,
-0.0630612895,
0.4678702652,
0.4118656218,
-0.2221757174,
0.6188543439,
-0.337023288,
0.6396873593,
0.015061859,
0.2896282375,
0.050003089,
-0.0592386127,
-0.6881258488,
-0.3008405864,
1.0090451241,
0.0492928438,
0.4236270785,
-0.2973012626,
-0.1186301187,
0.2522460222,
0.5031341314,
-0.7617202401,
-0.2825281322,
0.3620612025,
-0.317112416,
0.1017853767,
-0.0700465441,
-0.4226922989,
-0.4237166047,
-0.1524040699,
0.2893221974,
-0.306155771,
-0.3113963902,
-0.0828492716,
-0.2075861841,
0.6984664798,
0.570209682,
-0.9184866548,
0.1333058476,
0.9779826999,
1.2098168135,
0.0187656805,
0.261261493,
-0.1054975465,
-0.0223077536,
-0.3425115645,
0.7228137851,
-0.586052537,
-0.7522135377,
0.1564486176,
-0.225447312,
-0.2132559419,
-0.7840579152,
0.7481636405,
-0.6548176408,
0.3403663039,
0.0955734253,
-0.5754082203,
-0.1824970394,
0.0782262012,
-0.5306628346,
0.7890279889,
0.186100781,
-0.4988072813,
0.4619884491,
-0.9727085829,
-0.4840026498,
0.5694610476,
-0.4049150944,
-0.5590723157,
-0.0216989163,
0.0175490025,
0.8772627711,
-0.3982276618,
-0.1318060607,
-0.3275441229,
-0.0951311961,
0.4023436904,
-0.610049665,
0.5269960165,
0.3434395492,
-0.4624021351,
0.4431209564,
-0.5965692997,
0.0082858754,
0.0351360962,
-0.0757439435,
0.329890728,
0.0559952557,
0.1584207863,
0.3987170458,
0.0944461077,
-0.3484559059,
-0.0161485206,
-0.4344982803,
0.6179533005,
0.6539393663,
-0.1282262951,
0.1092268527,
-0.2766585946,
0.8562296033,
-0.0434755757,
0.19022955,
-0.3586061299,
-0.8189268112,
-0.7360668778,
-0.3338392675,
-0.0153999794,
0.6575940251,
-0.6528766751,
0.6080389023,
-0.2666968703,
-0.5736503005,
-0.5916804671,
0.0225338526,
0.2565318644,
0.6778190732,
-0.0104854321,
-0.6259889603,
-0.5392932296,
-1.0103546381,
0.1173115298,
-0.6393305063,
-0.506991148,
0.3585786223,
0.1437037736,
-0.1250305772,
0.7826684713,
-0.1671503335,
-0.1944710165,
-0.4968731403,
0.2061409503,
0.442265451,
0.0430943333,
0.1002302319,
-0.9076146483,
-0.6139195561,
0.2968716025,
-0.7141395807,
-0.0501384959,
-0.2387125045,
-0.1270218045,
0.7187332511,
0.0309088603,
-0.6975834966,
0.7255089283,
0.6245771646,
-0.0569803715,
0.6750215888,
-0.3217494488,
0.2210284919,
-0.997862637,
0.2233322859,
-0.0333137959,
-0.4504234493,
-0.7726050615,
-0.2450875342,
-0.1154660434,
-0.4661642015,
-0.478610456,
-0.0209815186,
-0.2146163583,
-0.3683444262,
-0.3593446612,
0.0188211259,
-0.2056691051,
0.5779248476,
0.5862372518,
1.0719122887,
0.6680004001,
-0.6685081124,
0.3038901985,
0.2137836367,
-0.508466661,
0.5660008788,
-0.9425227642,
0.3110197783,
0.2248534262,
0.0760248601,
-1.1380137205,
-0.0524468459,
0.6699823141,
-0.3978447914,
0.1083540022,
-0.4894270301,
-0.7756871581,
-0.5838000178,
0.2863047421,
-0.3733040392,
0.940887332,
-0.2475697845,
0.6688743234,
0.0762996823,
-0.204043135,
-0.1025528908,
-0.5200201869,
0.1822102517,
-0.216666624,
-0.7094475031,
0.261366576,
0.1101596653,
0.1501544118,
-0.3279922605,
-0.2201319486,
0.0538379997,
0.2181961387,
0.7142332196,
0.3547703922,
-0.2110249251,
-0.4401207268,
-0.6556748152,
-0.1248970032,
0.1039425358,
-0.1254701465,
0.7078244686,
-0.0782266185,
-0.5210460424,
-0.6241622567,
0.1217032671,
0.7389993668,
0.1038148403,
1.0512661934,
0.5039610863,
-0.1172943488,
0.1452780515,
-0.5654395819,
-0.1288309544,
-0.4708848596,
0.1223301962,
-0.472340852,
-0.6106594801,
0.7259436846,
-0.0040065073,
0.1962880045,
0.3469119966,
0.971940577,
-0.2129793763,
1.0202584267,
0.4225461483,
-0.063514322,
0.57318151,
-0.1167254224,
0.3596341014,
-0.6764312983,
-0.1742287278,
-0.439047426,
-0.01637467,
-0.5975185633,
-0.3922969401,
0.3020324409,
0.0550250001,
-0.0020325703,
0.7871751785,
-0.2196298987,
-0.0350555703,
0.4342219532,
-0.1385467052,
0.1280422062,
0.0622114874,
-0.0962689444,
0.3282057047,
-0.797532022,
-1.0678020716,
0.7415422201,
0.2366986424,
0.6820197701,
0.2748971283,
0.2876468599,
0.4333490133,
0.3888537884,
-0.5621903539,
0.5129669905,
0.0796919912,
-0.5347117186,
-0.3213727772,
-0.3406294584,
-1.2644948959,
0.361332804,
-0.0066446648,
-0.8586970568,
-0.3616244793,
0.1795751303,
-0.2768423259,
0.2103414387,
-1.0819091797,
1.1279994249,
-0.1023687422,
-0.1725882143,
-0.214125067,
-0.5540829897,
-0.1934593618,
0.2606575191,
-0.0984975174,
-0.3276433945,
0.1715801507,
0.444550693,
-0.7226105928,
1.0600191355,
-0.2010705471,
-0.2499848604,
0.3710304797,
-0.1086347476,
0.4365646541,
-0.2540153563,
-0.2250135392,
0.2648168504,
-0.0933077931,
-0.4548046589,
-0.7758871317,
0.2277903706,
-0.5513042212,
-0.8621519208,
-0.2665368617,
0.0949890465,
-0.2284746319,
-0.2550175786,
0.2749378085,
-0.1029838473,
-0.4234219193,
-0.1411950886,
0.3073842227,
-0.0313353576,
0.5956767797,
0.5510646701,
-0.20970653,
0.080035463,
0.3325176239,
-0.2036052197,
0.4869081378,
0.4010138214,
-0.049261041,
-0.2617202997,
-0.3887131214,
-0.7967510819,
-0.1889318675,
-0.3603327274,
-0.0691119954,
-0.767318666,
-0.4657360017,
-0.2522225678,
0.0171023943,
-0.2662771642,
-0.0393704921,
-0.2400570363,
0.1069147885,
0.3949362338,
0.326965034,
0.4187795222,
0.341091007,
-0.7154507637,
0.2851594687,
0.2835551202,
0.3525705636,
0.1594739854,
-0.5769274235,
-0.1174519137,
-0.0326145962,
-0.6435785294,
-1.0789471865,
0.2067727447,
0.2456779182,
0.5681839585,
0.5109290481,
-0.1002089456,
0.7165758014,
-0.4088583589,
0.7741475105,
0.1895365566,
-0.9023516774,
0.8234602213,
-0.3186760843,
0.2725386918,
0.086422652,
0.6069129109,
-0.9302316308,
-0.3750343919,
-0.7358142734,
-0.807624042,
0.7127001286,
0.7083202004,
0.4061397612,
-0.0836794153,
0.1996650994,
0.4390186965,
0.3317868412,
-0.4938820302,
-0.1169443205,
0.021172544,
-0.0701961517,
0.0832201168,
0.0026545103,
0.1102291271,
0.3852695525,
0.5997108221,
-0.0932829529,
0.6343616843,
0.0009237615,
0.0966073647,
0.1578958333,
0.3648773432,
0.3064425588,
0.6103063822,
0.1985601783,
-0.3732872307,
-0.0717792436,
-0.1718717366,
-0.1232277304,
0.1530545056,
-0.0523513556,
-0.0980128869,
0.2404541969,
1.0442472696,
0.0607586838,
-0.7389330268,
0.2893983424,
0.0752990097,
-0.0335362218,
-0.4427417517,
0.462213248,
0.1398910284,
0.3405487835,
0.1275557876,
-0.0119851045,
0.0806371495,
-0.7330080867,
-0.1412927806,
0.4808187187,
-0.3830976486,
-0.4116844237,
0.4913318753,
0.1902198493,
-0.6762066483,
0.8330611587,
-0.2937274575,
-0.6371722221,
0.5748786926,
0.5112403631,
0.9739976525,
0.0738275647,
0.3445829451,
-0.057897307,
-0.2129607797,
0.0244858973,
0.5624799728,
-0.2894871533,
-0.7479694486,
-0.4048068523,
-0.4933025241,
-0.8736994267,
0.1451233327,
-0.5159364939,
0.0649195686,
-0.4928371906,
-0.4915469885,
0.2393977195,
-0.2951900959,
-1.0108749866,
-0.1986394674,
0.0703155845,
0.438621223,
-0.6345281601,
0.565115273,
0.7292791009,
-0.6613305211,
-0.3874539435,
-0.0102399942,
-0.3249997497,
-0.7677587271,
0.7112423182,
0.1078640074,
-0.0451046191,
-0.4079337716,
0.0537740961,
-0.2713781297,
0.7042374015,
0.1865100116,
-0.7376170158,
0.3310160041,
0.471390903,
1.0182584524,
-0.2052749693,
0.47763744,
0.2781164944,
0.1315226257,
0.4426384866,
-1.0756739378,
-0.1728732586,
-0.0116865365,
0.2683834434,
0.1634088606,
-0.5285305977,
0.2734937072,
-0.0375122838,
-0.659358263,
0.3237573802,
0.8162845373,
0.0578883663,
0.2400465906,
0.4194276333,
0.3443794549,
0.5711738467,
-0.2197253853,
1.0294984579,
-0.2266608626,
0.0705942437,
0.9205716848,
-0.5763169527,
1.0103231668,
0.1816988587,
-0.8399846554,
0.7240529656,
0.5879359841,
-0.0159735307,
0.1777187735,
0.3635571003,
-0.4122477472,
-0.0473379195,
0.2598211169,
0.0450704396,
0.392714709,
0.4761027396,
-0.3361508846,
0.0235187188,
0.0270593334,
-0.1021038666,
0.0400426611,
-0.27191782,
1.0260736942,
-0.044126559,
-0.7684768438,
0.3279964328,
0.0380358696,
0.6146056056,
-0.585966289,
0.130955711,
-0.0156205762,
0.002558057,
-0.1183169633,
-0.9338586926,
0.5172364116,
0.3540928066,
-0.1360626221,
-0.2662013769,
0.6044194698,
-0.1454492956,
-0.3601231575,
0.1390553266,
0.4986046851,
0.4033864439,
-0.2858017087,
-0.8739593029,
-0.0468399227,
-0.425634712,
0.0312268939,
0.0163777657,
0.3136187792,
0.0074098189,
0.8072255254,
0.5547630191,
-0.0044751712,
-0.009951001,
0.5399307609,
0.4063581228,
-0.3875927329,
-0.6002594233,
-0.9433903694,
0.2241300642,
-0.1498869956,
-0.1382546425,
0.6607068181,
0.7365447283,
0.6821193099,
-0.3160079122,
0.8623858094,
-0.2058525681,
0.2412422001,
-0.5412048697,
0.5009920597,
0.1407101601,
0.26059708,
-0.2689579129,
-0.8265743256,
-0.0467874408,
0.7386870384,
-0.3722215593,
0.5211392641,
0.1465979218,
0.9119163752,
0.1009076461,
0.4621659219,
0.4921472371,
-0.12380144,
0.4301466346,
0.6946973205,
0.9717877507,
-0.1398765147,
0.4616111815,
-0.0236312672,
-0.1138300896,
-0.2775450349,
-0.8673750758,
-0.9069766402,
-0.8328493834,
-0.6547062397,
-0.2983778119,
0.2770864069,
0.8323023915,
0.9578465819,
-0.8510313034,
-0.3213641346,
-0.3843453825,
-0.1198921502,
-0.4623357356,
-0.2600338459,
0.1227761731,
-0.4253057837,
-0.7687062621,
-0.0311501157,
0.5714939833,
0.4277170897,
-0.3338823915,
0.0326448306,
0.2972698212,
0.0067037004,
0.5504896045,
0.5837806463,
-0.8950171471,
-0.1644073725,
-0.1475023329,
-0.0096333046,
0.3357833326,
0.9805673957,
-0.7937908769,
0.3112035692,
0.4386399686,
0.7001996636,
0.7144604325,
-0.2280207127,
0.8536291718,
-0.5900079012,
-0.2444606572,
0.1884281635,
0.1144793481,
0.4443872273,
-0.2482766509,
0.6177738905,
0.1057663932,
-0.4151563644,
-0.1444366127,
0.4552190304,
-1.0413324833,
0.0134292785,
0.8739435077,
-0.382940948,
0.0791511983,
-0.3325039148,
-0.2985904217,
0.3740421534,
-0.3533260524,
0.9641243815,
0.7024031281,
-0.5903832316,
-0.0997035429,
-0.5568773746,
0.3443028629,
0.3478431106,
-0.8347141743,
0.3415961564,
0.2055994123,
-0.1062688604,
-0.0495893918,
0.6290991306,
-0.0561567657,
0.1941738129,
-0.2517333031,
0.0691754743,
0.1377923489,
0.2341587394,
-0.2062608898,
0.2297446579,
0.2256882936,
-0.2773536146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03740v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03740v2
|
A Survey on Prompting Techniques in LLMs
| 2023-11-28T17:56:34 | 2024-04-16T22:27:39 |
Prabin Bhandari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Autoregressive Large Language Models have transformed the landscape of
Natural Language Processing. Pre-train and prompt paradigm has replaced the
conventional approach of pre-training and fine-tuning for many downstream NLP
tasks. This shift has been possible largely due to LLMs and innovative
prompting techniques. LLMs have shown great promise for a variety of downstream
tasks owing to their vast parameters and huge datasets that they are
pre-trained on. However, in order to fully realize their potential, their
outputs must be guided towards the desired outcomes. Prompting, in which a
specific input or instruction is provided to guide the LLMs toward the intended
output, has become a tool for achieving this goal. In this paper, we discuss
the various prompting techniques that have been applied to fully harness the
power of LLMs. We present a taxonomy of existing literature on prompting
techniques and provide a concise survey based on this taxonomy. Further, we
identify some open problems in the realm of prompting in autoregressive LLMs
which could serve as a direction for future research.
|
[
-0.6910436749,
-1.0063236952,
0.7067887783,
0.4076865017,
-0.2294715196,
-0.0336278975,
-0.3556599617,
-0.0324167013,
0.0719294325,
0.4978625476,
-1.1705360413,
-0.390769124,
-0.5104184747,
0.5219761729,
-0.4963102341,
0.7872912884,
-0.2547449768,
0.0089100553,
-0.1457224637,
0.3216581345,
-0.8613917828,
-0.5565978885,
-0.9049087167,
-0.306610167,
0.8295556903,
0.3903520405,
0.2415505499,
0.306215018,
0.096518971,
0.235188365,
-0.0929888561,
0.2863696814,
-0.1514415294,
0.7757281661,
-0.0530724749,
-0.5657529831,
-0.1502085775,
0.2290960103,
0.6856796145,
0.6156634092,
-0.1864350736,
0.3542882204,
0.4896353781,
0.7705870271,
-0.679438293,
-0.0693283826,
-0.5716921091,
0.2221624553,
-0.3219117522,
-0.6722815037,
-0.4942295551,
-0.4394358695,
-0.1072883457,
-0.2611789703,
0.1906150579,
0.0895190164,
0.5179699659,
0.5412757993,
-0.3295046091,
-0.613461256,
-0.7285613418,
0.6617779732,
-0.5669474006,
0.3033984303,
0.4269905388,
0.1296428591,
-0.2272079587,
-0.6504651904,
-0.430790931,
-0.4040073752,
-0.0134131191,
0.0563010499,
-0.2985422313,
0.0530603789,
0.3620927036,
0.294667542,
-0.4091508687,
0.6847954392,
0.1752282828,
-0.0358212292,
0.3082872033,
0.2787612677,
0.1356857568,
-0.1599333882,
-0.2623068094,
-0.2193346918,
-0.8430550694,
0.1356356889,
0.5067398548,
0.2818860114,
0.1920260638,
0.439861387,
-0.3418945372,
1.1850444078,
0.2344561368,
0.2534893453,
-0.2823903561,
-0.4451391101,
-0.1682562083,
-0.0999610201,
0.756901741,
0.1985200942,
0.5237438679,
0.1978854835,
-0.4329514503,
-0.2614367604,
0.1205382049,
-0.2747592926,
-0.2819274068,
0.2201927602,
-0.3727464974,
-0.1723848283,
-0.3324062824,
-0.8913587928,
-0.3531080782,
-0.5391398072,
0.479239285,
-0.2182530314,
-0.096102275,
0.0010663174,
0.0880276039,
0.4871750176,
0.4859112203,
-1.2776943445,
0.0411826223,
0.5647682548,
0.7606648803,
-0.1417397708,
-0.2279193997,
-0.8142415285,
-0.0543686487,
-0.3143085539,
0.9033738375,
-0.3488711119,
-0.5105597377,
0.290363133,
-0.1528901905,
-0.2074378133,
-0.4829892814,
0.2684247494,
-0.5680958629,
0.3725650609,
-0.4366455972,
-0.4818584025,
-0.0256418753,
0.509812355,
-0.4395899177,
1.0274466276,
-0.1285306364,
-0.5067674518,
0.3483670354,
-0.6898818016,
-0.3180642128,
0.0914849266,
-0.1186049059,
0.0481537953,
0.1081524119,
0.7828476429,
0.694927454,
-0.2531810403,
0.294904083,
0.1413311064,
0.0837739781,
0.2147965133,
-0.7010800242,
0.7072660923,
0.2243153751,
-0.1016975045,
0.1059662625,
-0.3031024039,
0.1888484806,
-0.0432334282,
-0.2206993252,
-0.1404111534,
-0.1449102908,
-0.4907159507,
0.0632051602,
0.2717449963,
0.0164607689,
0.4468946159,
-0.2372836769,
0.397475034,
0.9239541888,
0.3092928231,
0.4067079723,
-0.2804561555,
0.9577012658,
-0.350158155,
0.1861834377,
-0.6556831598,
-0.3995233476,
-0.7149604559,
-0.0705641061,
0.344809413,
0.5113663077,
-0.7557530403,
0.5469484925,
0.2443875223,
-0.2716800272,
-0.542940855,
0.3652031124,
0.099971652,
0.459461987,
0.3698655963,
0.0562280715,
-0.5754247904,
-0.5083028078,
-0.2417004555,
-0.2472408414,
-0.0073637697,
0.0534313694,
-0.0098686926,
-0.0211740285,
1.0165928602,
-0.3917863667,
-0.3111718595,
-0.2676769495,
0.3623585999,
0.326688081,
0.4154942334,
0.210990876,
-0.4118660688,
-0.546276629,
-0.603985548,
-0.5174773335,
-0.6678652167,
-0.314026475,
0.0599085428,
0.1984366328,
1.1591393948,
-0.5508353114,
0.1912460625,
0.5071885586,
0.1975786239,
0.6865149736,
-0.1678967774,
0.1538346112,
-0.8613395095,
-0.0817172676,
-0.2942016125,
-0.1495805085,
-0.6109077334,
-0.1376936883,
-0.1739390939,
0.2282936126,
-0.3779650629,
0.5961974263,
-0.9169710279,
0.2375417948,
-0.31638515,
0.0511263013,
-0.1354606152,
0.0072848541,
0.0498835631,
0.8025987744,
0.8062369823,
-1.2685484886,
0.6269694567,
0.2628735006,
0.006941651,
0.4388659,
-0.5168616772,
0.1571187973,
-0.3518614471,
0.3599508405,
-1.1983097792,
-0.034305878,
0.3868221939,
-0.4136326313,
0.3936303556,
-0.2055128366,
-0.6530538797,
-0.6473294497,
-0.1880336106,
0.0428668223,
0.7655930519,
-0.7125597,
0.2851722836,
-0.1569782794,
-0.3913799822,
-0.4868247807,
-0.6270570159,
0.2252001613,
-0.234423697,
-0.2226196826,
0.0748090595,
-0.2124861032,
-0.195271343,
-0.3098213673,
0.3476965129,
0.281283319,
-0.0137008335,
0.0372488946,
0.4354698658,
-0.1444237679,
0.0656452104,
0.0692722648,
-0.2056055665,
0.3105968833,
-0.3715679944,
0.8600689769,
0.2270428389,
-0.5611822605,
-0.6317616105,
0.2734752595,
-0.0606656782,
-0.1209787428,
0.3502780795,
0.6370130181,
-0.0484521203,
-0.168660596,
-0.8620645404,
-0.6099786162,
-0.5220819116,
-0.0830931216,
0.0431157649,
-0.9198896289,
0.2212846875,
-0.3272472918,
0.1865108311,
0.0484779701,
0.7906216383,
-0.355412513,
1.1379945278,
0.4894084036,
-0.04412039,
0.6865988374,
-0.0583631583,
0.1854705811,
-0.7283821702,
-0.0977362916,
-0.7017701268,
-0.2560172975,
-0.3511222601,
-0.2506074011,
0.3063433468,
0.1274930388,
0.3173962831,
0.0592315942,
-0.5796201825,
0.3270581067,
0.5794895887,
-0.4374528229,
0.2296892107,
-0.0285214856,
-0.2131829411,
-0.0802371353,
-0.9229906797,
-0.5692849159,
0.5526086688,
0.234037444,
0.917296946,
-0.2433256507,
0.9238628745,
0.2247337997,
0.2810292542,
-1.0973446369,
0.7786142826,
0.3071493506,
-0.3862654269,
-0.4465707541,
-0.1242067367,
-1.4312454462,
-0.1201517582,
-0.1844471693,
-0.6031461358,
0.1226195842,
0.6075695157,
-0.5934151411,
0.0963654369,
-0.537124753,
0.3464843333,
-0.2735827267,
0.0086203339,
0.1612689793,
-0.5460298657,
0.2687909007,
0.0549322069,
0.0709920004,
-0.0903009698,
-0.1711116433,
0.6207739115,
-0.2802472115,
0.9508948922,
-0.3143566549,
-0.4568174779,
0.337138027,
0.1285313964,
0.7575634122,
-0.0788590536,
0.1007836908,
-0.33844015,
-0.165456146,
0.0680337325,
-0.5870075822,
0.5898455381,
-0.148488611,
-0.9437757134,
-0.3198205531,
-0.2780700922,
-0.606056571,
0.0556499064,
0.6940786839,
0.2510971129,
0.0004939113,
-0.1809706688,
0.9547592402,
-0.15154697,
0.9046863317,
0.5961738229,
-0.4289963245,
-0.1615904272,
0.539798677,
0.083095707,
0.2370479852,
0.1967556775,
0.1936081797,
-0.7110301256,
-0.7525513768,
-0.5771219134,
0.210891813,
-0.5520013571,
-0.4370005727,
-0.7296000123,
-0.1530562639,
-0.7260872722,
-0.3191767037,
0.0770578161,
-0.1156911775,
-0.6944662929,
-0.0116468556,
0.5713814497,
0.9256631732,
-0.0655826032,
0.3811553121,
-1.0991235971,
0.1166116074,
0.6559355259,
0.0368107073,
0.2424426526,
-0.4824234545,
0.0163643248,
-0.1841117591,
-0.0951119959,
-0.8574326634,
0.5781427622,
-0.1300525516,
0.6626562476,
0.3637115061,
0.3437684774,
0.5812021494,
-0.6332381964,
1.0285779238,
0.1685860306,
-0.7421090007,
0.9009763002,
-0.2541560233,
0.5211218596,
0.5357902646,
0.6216964126,
-0.7897177339,
-0.4715543389,
-0.4644142389,
-0.9550451636,
0.5737487078,
-0.2176969051,
0.3141872287,
-0.1631573439,
0.3673160076,
0.2357628345,
0.2686770856,
-0.3995448947,
-0.182288453,
0.0787025914,
-0.0566296093,
0.0527647734,
-0.1591725647,
0.0841162279,
-0.0109923277,
0.6212691665,
-0.1284865886,
0.1364141852,
0.3149965703,
-0.1279454231,
-0.0455942415,
0.4062099159,
0.3681183457,
0.484516412,
0.2238424271,
0.0076563358,
0.2947159708,
-0.140343681,
0.3469612002,
-0.0274061263,
-0.2365876585,
0.0625224486,
0.0492076948,
0.7659246922,
-0.1408466995,
-0.3234953284,
0.3016454875,
-0.1081201509,
-0.3187929094,
-0.355545342,
0.2451058775,
-0.0310175549,
-0.0713549554,
0.5432596207,
-0.2948467433,
0.0613463633,
-0.354521811,
-0.1564596891,
0.5987272263,
-0.5087048411,
-0.0798615143,
0.4755539894,
0.1446989477,
-0.5496190786,
0.7030793428,
-0.1092002243,
-0.3679979146,
0.0902279764,
0.4605877101,
0.8020932078,
-0.4134423733,
0.2480791062,
0.2610523701,
0.3518674374,
-0.2399977297,
0.1535206884,
-0.4079785645,
-0.518646419,
-0.7419065237,
-0.5064886212,
-0.5730219483,
0.3323011398,
-0.7603830099,
0.3264147043,
-0.3742272556,
-0.1714764535,
-0.1509730071,
-0.3584502637,
-0.4557993114,
0.0741083995,
0.2803620696,
1.1297476292,
-0.6922064424,
0.4955204725,
0.8306086659,
-0.0847707689,
-0.9068451524,
0.1475463659,
0.1090277359,
-0.8560042381,
0.7045186758,
-0.0193028469,
-0.1608380377,
0.4375599325,
-0.9641218185,
-0.6073889136,
0.6320766807,
0.1679613292,
-0.433116734,
-0.1976518184,
0.0135454368,
0.3346920311,
-0.1665828228,
0.1238009483,
0.4238637686,
0.765221715,
0.0208250545,
-0.6872217059,
0.099560976,
0.0464147404,
0.1076068431,
0.2688823044,
-0.477339536,
0.6495786905,
-0.0761419013,
-0.1963002533,
0.0780136585,
0.6664027572,
0.3355583549,
0.1794025302,
0.8495517373,
-0.0591961332,
0.7573139668,
-0.0284669492,
0.7333939075,
-0.0657535791,
-0.1117746532,
0.7768396139,
-0.3820520043,
0.7535976768,
0.708460927,
-0.1128491461,
0.3477843702,
0.7697148323,
0.0754247606,
0.1195600927,
0.248213768,
-0.4476829469,
-0.3159250617,
-0.1957648247,
-0.4339439571,
0.261080265,
0.6256664395,
-0.2070869505,
-0.3660157323,
0.3325247169,
0.0273556001,
0.0161882732,
-0.4313271642,
1.0476812124,
0.2823484838,
-1.2541199923,
0.6322699189,
-0.3655290902,
0.9423710704,
-0.8117139339,
0.0151222171,
-0.0922854096,
-0.4315268397,
-0.1107552648,
-0.7676427364,
0.0978013948,
0.0024324264,
-0.1455974728,
-0.9816990495,
0.7891452909,
-0.4076068699,
0.0957287326,
0.0952039883,
0.7703996301,
0.1256225109,
-0.0802381188,
-0.7515463829,
-0.2287705243,
0.0658713952,
-0.3192878366,
0.2841732502,
0.5409110785,
0.0524842069,
0.7404607534,
0.8625938296,
0.31409356,
0.098113209,
0.2835187912,
0.7381789088,
-0.6747345924,
-0.4049913585,
-0.9290453196,
0.1597023159,
0.2096194476,
-0.1730065048,
1.0559331179,
-0.0103726378,
0.594831109,
-0.1319401711,
0.7146058083,
0.0749938041,
0.7344164252,
-1.0312498808,
0.3945560753,
-0.1889446527,
0.2153147161,
-0.0192764644,
-0.8450550437,
-0.1748002023,
0.2738844454,
-0.3526601195,
0.0425349548,
0.6502402425,
0.8574277163,
0.4202161431,
0.0989562422,
0.2752865553,
0.0602008924,
0.1318792701,
0.1505132467,
1.3560069799,
0.2543762922,
0.549274683,
0.2401761115,
-0.1276800334,
-0.3787435293,
-1.1191960573,
-0.7055776119,
-0.5469995141,
-0.3272439539,
-0.1768530905,
0.0476542339,
1.0895699263,
0.547406435,
-0.6878120899,
-0.1065968201,
-0.3006083965,
0.0704577118,
-0.0957922488,
-0.1967047453,
-0.0769203603,
-0.9805271626,
-0.8179432154,
0.5641307235,
0.2096465975,
0.53474617,
-0.5394135118,
0.1973570734,
-0.3398266137,
-0.0511453487,
0.3572093844,
0.5338528752,
-0.451382339,
0.1969212741,
0.1634849906,
0.0090245036,
-0.0633021519,
1.1774526834,
-1.0188423395,
0.2327541858,
0.651391983,
0.4453159869,
0.271004349,
-0.0354938693,
0.8530656695,
-0.834413588,
-0.179275766,
0.4854974449,
0.0925411284,
0.4166887105,
-0.5310661197,
0.1983306408,
-0.1590955108,
-0.7320626378,
-0.728020072,
0.3513445556,
-0.4755876362,
-0.0637362972,
1.209556222,
0.1745276153,
-0.0998308361,
-0.4373913407,
-0.4038535953,
0.1336175352,
-0.3516697586,
0.3615251184,
0.843121171,
-0.4024314284,
-0.3234500885,
-0.5734390616,
0.7448821068,
0.890819788,
-0.7712584138,
0.3515767455,
0.4267107248,
-0.119743824,
-0.0938029289,
0.8518360853,
0.0028425406,
0.0459332019,
-0.5190153718,
-0.1131227538,
0.0713868141,
-0.1372530758,
-0.8388760686,
-0.041608613,
0.2966537774,
-0.0374296457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02179v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02179v1
|
Training Chain-of-Thought via Latent-Variable Inference
| 2023-11-28T17:47:32 | 2023-11-28T17:47:32 |
Du Phan, Matthew D. Hoffman, David Dohan, Sholto Douglas, Tuan Anh Le, Aaron Parisi, Pavel Sountsov, Charles Sutton, Sharad Vikram, Rif A. Saurous
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) solve problems more accurately and interpretably
when instructed to work out the answer step by step using a
``chain-of-thought'' (CoT) prompt. One can also improve LLMs' performance on a
specific task by supervised fine-tuning, i.e., by using gradient ascent on some
tunable parameters to maximize the average log-likelihood of correct answers
from a labeled training set. Naively combining CoT with supervised tuning
requires supervision not just of the correct answers, but also of detailed
rationales that lead to those answers; these rationales are expensive to
produce by hand. Instead, we propose a fine-tuning strategy that tries to
maximize the \emph{marginal} log-likelihood of generating a correct answer
using CoT prompting, approximately averaging over all possible rationales. The
core challenge is sampling from the posterior over rationales conditioned on
the correct answer; we address it using a simple Markov-chain Monte Carlo
(MCMC) expectation-maximization (EM) algorithm inspired by the self-taught
reasoner (STaR), memoized wake-sleep, Markovian score climbing, and persistent
contrastive divergence. This algorithm also admits a novel control-variate
technique that drives the variance of our gradient estimates to zero as the
model improves. Applying our technique to GSM8K and the tasks in BIG-Bench
Hard, we find that this MCMC-EM fine-tuning technique typically improves the
model's accuracy on held-out examples more than STaR or prompt-tuning with or
without CoT.
|
[
-0.5378693938,
-1.0134866238,
0.8099060059,
-0.0670786053,
-0.3524093032,
0.2200875878,
-0.5085366368,
-0.0739331096,
-0.0014648056,
0.5931503177,
-0.811604023,
-0.5034272671,
-0.498903811,
-0.0432752408,
0.0032678321,
1.0842723846,
-0.0399688035,
-0.0856013373,
0.1593949944,
0.1935105622,
-0.2108885497,
-0.3584253788,
-0.752080977,
-0.2585532069,
0.9363416433,
0.4488149285,
0.3636199534,
0.6608074307,
0.3984783888,
0.1890511662,
-0.1099414527,
0.6453658938,
-0.5500237942,
0.0803765431,
-0.3030967712,
-0.8056072593,
-0.5846822858,
0.1087295786,
0.3850100935,
0.6748402715,
-0.189279303,
0.1489656419,
-0.0754802823,
0.8380108476,
-1.1023242474,
-0.0879727826,
-0.8845749497,
-0.0670727342,
0.0227370821,
-0.5316007137,
-0.4870017171,
-0.058680445,
-0.335460037,
-0.3853205442,
0.1450974196,
0.1447565556,
0.5210767388,
0.3698779345,
-0.3154852092,
-0.237810716,
-0.8562701344,
0.8927735686,
-0.4862202406,
0.2374131083,
0.6588764191,
0.1138537303,
-0.4163891077,
-0.2012144923,
-0.4525390863,
-0.1393586248,
0.3196299672,
0.2741476893,
0.2516633868,
0.3319857121,
0.4803453982,
0.4492430091,
-0.2405557781,
0.1869129837,
-0.2370271236,
0.0965907127,
0.5308862925,
0.0937130526,
-0.1399971843,
0.1060478687,
-0.1789849401,
-0.1202901304,
-0.7752309442,
-0.0046521155,
0.4382430315,
0.3713135421,
0.0470160283,
0.5301982164,
-0.2501881719,
0.9088003635,
0.4593509138,
-0.0646698624,
-0.0284677278,
-0.1083043516,
-0.3873369396,
0.0064012767,
0.6101065278,
0.2239954472,
0.2791561782,
-0.1572702229,
-0.521066606,
0.0893964544,
0.217747137,
-0.4596153796,
-0.3436391652,
0.2255435288,
-0.1183048487,
-0.3179502487,
-0.1279598325,
-0.6306057572,
-0.0191790871,
-0.648856163,
0.319816798,
-0.0858126655,
-0.1045447662,
0.0782031268,
0.1459582448,
0.1425479054,
0.4033277929,
-1.1108493805,
0.4089781344,
0.6150399446,
0.7615668774,
-0.1480112672,
0.0276988689,
-0.9933211803,
0.0590919256,
-0.7962531447,
0.7383977175,
-0.6012997627,
-0.1206932515,
-0.2242730409,
-0.1163241565,
-0.2253968865,
-0.4350832999,
0.3230449557,
-0.5465883613,
0.026325969,
-0.4863708913,
-0.6112594604,
0.3062573671,
0.3043183982,
-0.4021734595,
0.9178456664,
0.0170365013,
-0.5940082669,
0.3466701806,
-0.2168929875,
-0.0498106815,
-0.2714095116,
-0.3295628726,
-0.2724000216,
0.3837083876,
0.5589646697,
0.6101629734,
-0.4161992967,
0.3047486246,
-0.3591884971,
-0.4169872403,
0.2648237944,
-0.503095448,
0.439899236,
0.3191332817,
-0.3186638355,
-0.0158517621,
-0.7683889866,
0.1473857164,
-0.1095701978,
-0.350913018,
-0.2736684382,
0.0579843074,
-0.2774607539,
0.3020661771,
0.0090965796,
-0.2859428823,
0.2835603356,
-0.4412024021,
0.1568444073,
0.8931137919,
0.1829363555,
0.428711623,
-0.493250668,
0.5639670491,
0.0391853973,
0.0346025936,
-0.0633721575,
-0.1807671785,
-0.8156632185,
-0.2943474352,
0.3055118322,
0.3143297434,
-0.7593354583,
0.4316913486,
0.1505344808,
-0.3081761599,
-0.4623951614,
0.3415547311,
0.4950704575,
0.4849844873,
0.3768823147,
-0.1061156914,
-0.2898938954,
-0.7614428997,
-0.223202616,
-0.0195465777,
-0.0741835386,
0.2930828333,
0.3357378542,
-0.0276836045,
0.5394681692,
-0.569286406,
0.1480673999,
0.003404327,
0.2242660224,
0.4536451399,
0.5864728093,
0.1618333757,
-0.5649498701,
-0.2918688059,
0.0230709072,
-0.4751580954,
-0.034944389,
-0.238165766,
-0.3655073643,
0.1381482482,
0.679780364,
-0.372381568,
0.1921702921,
0.3514176011,
0.0084949378,
0.6914417744,
-0.4533795714,
0.1458701789,
-0.8489157557,
-0.1254018694,
0.0164928734,
-0.3174813986,
-0.2878024578,
0.0261352565,
0.0196883995,
0.2740638256,
-0.1167354286,
0.245687753,
-0.4887351096,
0.0497632436,
-0.3886861801,
0.23608163,
-0.2739216685,
0.7921385765,
-0.2157685459,
0.8722753525,
0.4302990437,
-0.8722323179,
0.1334742159,
-0.2048657537,
-0.3741687834,
0.476890713,
-0.4814570248,
0.3727734983,
-0.1093473211,
0.1593192816,
-0.8700669408,
-0.0808716044,
0.119479686,
-0.201399073,
0.420277983,
-0.1784609705,
-0.4455913901,
-0.3857287765,
-0.1368963271,
0.2834950686,
0.4353971779,
-0.7305881381,
0.4888582826,
0.2566932738,
-0.0198451523,
-0.7611542344,
-0.5246265531,
-0.204060927,
-0.1108786911,
-0.0420505665,
0.2647577524,
-0.1202534139,
-0.2097837776,
-0.4387335181,
-0.4869909883,
0.0771437809,
0.1190176904,
-0.0218460429,
0.3176364005,
-0.1652211994,
0.4887536764,
0.4197106063,
-0.1334732175,
0.2049920857,
-0.5889410973,
0.5439421535,
-0.2067759931,
-0.3150172532,
-0.160216406,
0.0690748319,
0.4465192854,
-0.0492840037,
0.6612094045,
0.4346245229,
-0.2068030536,
-0.5087649822,
-0.6532306671,
-0.2180066109,
-0.4403167367,
0.165753305,
-0.6089732647,
-0.9447036982,
0.4855852425,
-0.4095391333,
-0.0136392545,
0.2407043129,
0.7219416499,
-0.2906934321,
1.1387957335,
0.4837476909,
0.0096930126,
0.5797163248,
-0.3592744768,
0.21613051,
-1.0493785143,
0.0022496982,
-0.3578252196,
-0.2148122936,
-0.8402374387,
-0.540573895,
0.2184606791,
0.3228546679,
-0.4257793128,
-0.0257751811,
-0.437953651,
0.6984141469,
0.4331930578,
0.5538886786,
0.213879928,
-0.0124162249,
-0.536737442,
0.2963907719,
-0.8194426894,
-0.5171597004,
1.1248935461,
0.1539397985,
1.0755952597,
-0.1832851321,
0.7450711131,
-0.0516715273,
0.066521965,
-0.5987523794,
0.418037802,
-0.0848593861,
-0.4637924731,
-0.2105601281,
-0.5397833586,
-0.7202780247,
0.2813589871,
-0.2179063112,
-1.0725717545,
0.2246934772,
0.5452699065,
-0.3034385443,
0.3792505264,
-0.579267323,
0.5126923323,
-0.1613122523,
-0.7248880863,
-0.335087955,
-0.5949476361,
0.3871825933,
-0.2559244931,
0.1051030383,
-0.1360772848,
-0.0138587579,
0.7251685858,
-0.4612106979,
0.8587445617,
-0.0577007085,
-0.2883573174,
0.4022571743,
-0.0007171761,
0.7578502297,
0.128108114,
0.0395946242,
-0.3390085995,
-0.1537941992,
-0.6257459521,
-0.8253067136,
0.8217945099,
-0.7193123102,
-0.7426939607,
-0.1914999932,
-0.6010392904,
-0.5486542583,
-0.0714129508,
0.1906451732,
0.3633171618,
-0.0060205897,
0.0377079584,
0.8358033299,
-0.1385352612,
0.2576597631,
0.2611073852,
-0.3130376041,
-0.3588949144,
0.7383951545,
-0.0305045359,
0.6043283343,
0.5816915035,
0.2675126195,
-0.2200097442,
-0.3087930679,
-0.3353752196,
0.2507659495,
-0.5918419361,
-0.1948486269,
-0.6413652897,
-0.1026155874,
0.0362638645,
-0.2313192785,
-0.4908903539,
-0.2947461009,
-0.1431088448,
-0.1794714034,
0.3531351089,
0.5033704042,
-0.0250778235,
0.448526144,
-0.3763139844,
0.2230111957,
0.4520747662,
0.3056869507,
0.0737903193,
-0.4311283231,
-0.3081041873,
0.3101526201,
-0.3134200871,
-0.5340350866,
0.1836662591,
-0.0296079796,
0.3503696024,
0.2812746763,
0.062092036,
0.8209705949,
-0.4547606409,
0.4300054908,
0.3438749313,
-0.8457081318,
0.8410971165,
-0.4901803434,
0.41063568,
0.5916857123,
0.2711423337,
-0.0609636232,
-0.5812760592,
-0.6623619795,
-0.7590708733,
0.453306675,
0.2873960733,
-0.1316376328,
-0.3239018917,
0.4842303395,
-0.0977094695,
0.3240320086,
-0.3444776237,
-0.1329802126,
0.3520732224,
-0.2266890854,
-0.3317659199,
-0.0825436041,
-0.0404406786,
-0.3323186338,
0.6871129274,
-0.4487301409,
0.3827637136,
0.2155627608,
-0.1292696744,
-0.4003367722,
0.2547883689,
0.6783313155,
0.8173457384,
-0.3912293911,
0.3678151965,
0.3888145387,
-0.2477901429,
0.1234401911,
-0.337238729,
0.0310707204,
-0.2559486628,
0.1983772069,
0.9916907549,
0.207479611,
-0.4870243967,
0.2535532713,
-0.058471173,
-0.2662033141,
-0.054070428,
0.5291144848,
0.0338445939,
0.2706030905,
0.3373744488,
0.2263956964,
-0.1211013123,
-0.5137078166,
0.1055741683,
0.3762806952,
-0.4821622968,
-0.1101734936,
0.502994895,
-0.1503369361,
-0.3770261407,
0.4349710643,
-0.0349547006,
-0.4235851765,
0.7632775903,
0.6480420828,
0.6502072215,
-0.1681272089,
0.0650760159,
0.4024327993,
0.2095973045,
-0.3420676291,
0.3952297568,
-0.2994686365,
-0.6247056127,
-0.8183406591,
-0.6521872878,
-0.4153918624,
0.1294877231,
-0.8778874874,
0.1839158684,
-0.6580057144,
-0.1305331588,
-0.0034320485,
0.0828844905,
-0.7320654988,
0.4847658873,
0.0458570346,
0.7379074693,
-0.7522117496,
0.8961640596,
0.3321918249,
-0.2473623753,
-0.9562829733,
0.1348627508,
-0.3068058789,
-0.749968946,
0.495531857,
-0.0016265895,
-0.3982783556,
0.1220728457,
-0.7913126945,
-0.7738413215,
0.8848190904,
0.4554004371,
-1.1979086399,
0.1734756231,
-0.4377777576,
0.4908207655,
-0.5457863808,
0.3238293827,
0.6359102726,
0.1235249192,
0.2093577385,
-0.7149820328,
-0.0473477282,
-0.0411144719,
0.019828923,
0.4590174854,
-0.5297687054,
0.7568323612,
-0.4149108529,
0.1284392476,
-0.1149221957,
0.6575284004,
0.4835428298,
0.1825353354,
0.6344714761,
0.3432386518,
1.2100125551,
0.1032773852,
1.0983936787,
-0.2962919772,
0.5032274127,
1.5216275454,
-0.0332024731,
0.8674537539,
0.7755148411,
-0.2116423994,
0.4961730838,
0.7415028214,
0.1620962322,
0.6565642953,
0.4593575895,
-0.3117785454,
-0.5465727448,
0.0840176493,
-0.0811477154,
0.2413589656,
0.5816330314,
-0.4434337914,
0.0509282425,
-0.0036865603,
-0.2588750422,
0.0421585143,
-0.5334540606,
0.7129381299,
0.2920344174,
-0.8518297076,
0.8639352322,
-0.1373832673,
0.3908807635,
-0.3088542223,
0.0840977207,
-0.1158080176,
0.2232490331,
0.0865953863,
-0.4281475246,
0.026659254,
0.1228284836,
-0.2779273689,
-0.0188177004,
0.51665622,
-0.5054204464,
-0.5443256497,
0.1937467009,
0.6473695636,
0.0804847777,
0.0108822286,
-0.5348234773,
-0.0839498565,
-0.1746901274,
-0.2766462564,
0.3398965001,
0.4720339179,
0.0390589722,
0.6434214115,
0.6287045479,
0.2433433384,
-0.049491968,
0.2450991422,
1.0469275713,
-0.7229818106,
-0.5406116843,
-0.9789795876,
0.2105387151,
-0.0523410738,
-0.3949085772,
0.313837409,
0.422318697,
0.9170410633,
-0.0729920641,
0.6153506637,
0.2784400284,
0.2288356274,
-0.9587106109,
0.2901232839,
-0.5659400225,
0.3527026474,
-0.3653738499,
-0.8998411894,
-0.1679635197,
0.8721930385,
-0.6021295786,
0.1485290378,
1.0124479532,
0.9077750444,
-0.1514940709,
0.0026827578,
0.464087069,
0.2255711854,
0.1575817019,
0.7700198293,
0.8080300689,
-0.4422883093,
0.162327081,
-0.1394322813,
-0.2888977826,
-0.0698233396,
-0.7954013348,
-1.1886337996,
-0.3523066938,
-0.3105242848,
-0.4057625532,
0.4047401249,
1.3137001991,
0.6459539533,
-0.8237813711,
-0.2089691162,
-0.5794109702,
0.2466361225,
-0.3538559079,
-0.0792375058,
0.2964642346,
-0.7958896756,
-0.6214204431,
0.2796528339,
0.3542082608,
-0.1289889514,
-0.0965272859,
-0.0404438972,
-0.4370317757,
0.1636278927,
0.4830453098,
-0.0669988915,
-0.7754041553,
-0.1778012216,
-0.0265718792,
-0.2047288716,
0.1560431719,
0.9101647139,
-0.6684206128,
0.5882328749,
0.1356074214,
0.7054266334,
0.8449804783,
0.0165515486,
0.7908434272,
-0.7369007468,
-0.0590685606,
0.1535960585,
0.2313548177,
0.0565877147,
-0.4567188025,
0.4251989126,
0.1130610928,
-0.6714454293,
-0.6093659401,
0.2013848573,
-0.9908924699,
-0.354460299,
1.0396184921,
-0.0944279581,
-0.6234374046,
-0.0123571986,
-0.1834917814,
0.363737613,
-0.3420160115,
0.8104647994,
0.6956430078,
-0.0141602485,
-0.3466412723,
-0.5848548412,
0.452616334,
0.5429916382,
-0.6466525197,
0.1271513253,
0.2336230278,
0.1066223532,
-0.1138398349,
0.7122270465,
0.2863575816,
0.2094757259,
-0.052272968,
-0.2923575938,
0.1845859438,
-0.5374231935,
-0.2498937696,
-0.0416064486,
0.1608217955,
-0.1374149173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16989v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16989v4
|
ChatGPT's One-year Anniversary: Are Open-Source Large Language Models Catching up?
| 2023-11-28T17:44:51 | 2024-01-15T09:55:05 |
Hailin Chen, Fangkai Jiao, Xingxuan Li, Chengwei Qin, Mathieu Ravaut, Ruochen Zhao, Caiming Xiong, Shafiq Joty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Upon its release in late 2022, ChatGPT has brought a seismic shift in the
entire landscape of AI, both in research and commerce. Through
instruction-tuning a large language model (LLM) with supervised fine-tuning and
reinforcement learning from human feedback, it showed that a model could answer
human questions and follow instructions on a broad panel of tasks. Following
this success, interests in LLMs have intensified, with new LLMs flourishing at
frequent interval across academia and industry, including many start-ups
focused on LLMs. While closed-source LLMs (e.g., OpenAI's GPT, Anthropic's
Claude) generally outperform their open-source counterparts, the progress on
the latter has been rapid with claims of achieving parity or even better on
certain tasks. This has crucial implications not only on research but also on
business. In this work, on the first anniversary of ChatGPT, we provide an
exhaustive overview of this success, surveying all tasks where an open-source
LLM has claimed to be on par or better than ChatGPT.
|
[
-0.1700518578,
-0.9037697315,
0.4707290232,
0.2508017719,
-0.0388919562,
-0.0144866928,
-0.5521487594,
-0.5308954716,
-0.039457079,
0.430575341,
-0.5115948915,
-0.3560312688,
-0.5871468186,
-0.2464583814,
-0.4280656576,
1.2264750004,
0.1485021114,
-0.1041815951,
-0.1514475793,
-0.1190468967,
-0.3835738301,
-0.6140365005,
-1.2068456411,
-0.4327596128,
0.5468598604,
0.2365187407,
0.8144561648,
0.7103665471,
0.6320148706,
0.2124869376,
-0.0356762186,
0.0315725505,
-0.5711052418,
-0.187289387,
-0.0796842054,
-0.3563817739,
-0.5862002373,
0.2004527003,
0.6743263602,
0.7993479371,
-0.2989828587,
0.1322778016,
0.2894273102,
0.8985720873,
-0.3158572614,
0.5775290132,
-0.5754550695,
-0.2457740456,
-0.3016918898,
0.0117464466,
-0.6847634315,
-0.3555436134,
-0.0411361754,
-0.4877242744,
-0.1551661044,
0.0378763936,
0.8271653652,
0.2741719186,
-0.0496433862,
-0.4220839143,
-0.8357216716,
0.85043782,
-0.6976109743,
0.3825820684,
0.2152882069,
0.3712224066,
-0.461925298,
-0.9789865613,
-0.2018100768,
-0.5447969437,
0.3162607849,
-0.0733197406,
-0.4052118361,
-0.2727387547,
0.0441149361,
0.4298249185,
-0.5045164227,
0.2563959658,
-0.5252298117,
0.0608610064,
0.4686813354,
-0.0355581529,
0.2795865834,
0.3920502067,
-0.4680707455,
0.0504700802,
-1.0512079,
-0.1412341148,
0.0327103883,
0.1908901781,
0.0443512909,
0.6786497235,
-0.2432409376,
0.4158422947,
-0.1630500257,
0.3474428356,
-0.0089576459,
-0.2287341803,
-0.3218548298,
0.0224285219,
0.8763518333,
-0.0258800723,
0.6598926187,
-0.2935643196,
-0.2130558938,
-0.0448069908,
0.1782817096,
-0.492851615,
-0.4720802605,
0.061167419,
-0.5055680275,
-0.0523652248,
0.0015123666,
-0.5462695956,
-0.5197494626,
-0.3674536347,
0.3050695956,
-0.3330245614,
-0.3074345291,
0.204211846,
0.1866740435,
0.6492350101,
0.5645442009,
-0.7729223371,
0.3218515217,
1.4605379105,
1.0841914415,
-0.0818843096,
-0.3338531852,
-0.4926378727,
-0.118152447,
-0.4914709926,
0.675816834,
-0.4015325904,
-0.2531583309,
0.0389603712,
-0.0386261269,
0.0276638158,
-0.5754407048,
0.5017930865,
-0.6225978732,
0.2522355318,
-0.1700229794,
-0.6361219287,
0.0261312574,
0.6464048028,
-0.3835628927,
0.6386691332,
-0.073285915,
-0.6839667559,
0.2919756472,
-0.8085449934,
-0.1244779006,
0.3039178252,
-0.192471832,
-0.3213326633,
-0.0605643988,
0.047191225,
0.1558815241,
-0.5116323829,
-0.0979460552,
-0.2498551905,
-0.3537831903,
0.2182538658,
-0.6393403411,
0.9785225391,
0.164334029,
-0.1806334257,
-0.0042603258,
-0.6197528243,
-0.053121645,
0.2810325921,
-0.4462819099,
-0.0204044208,
0.3007280827,
-0.0462018289,
0.0561940335,
0.4816815555,
-0.6362746358,
0.3838388622,
-0.3795546293,
0.8890688419,
0.8285937905,
-0.099244386,
0.1779209077,
-0.5726100206,
0.5371915102,
-0.3664702773,
0.2577087581,
-0.6323994398,
-0.8539067507,
-0.8417646885,
-0.2915123403,
0.3267519772,
0.5601190925,
-0.2928754687,
0.1222986057,
-0.3715842068,
-0.6405206323,
-0.4799304307,
-0.0857215077,
0.0325425342,
0.108670339,
0.1069730297,
-0.4588249624,
-0.1904815435,
-0.7640300393,
-0.3385739625,
-0.3697981834,
-0.1478942335,
0.3222845495,
0.1407008916,
-0.1325811595,
0.8690540791,
-0.4542050362,
-0.3359548748,
-0.1072306931,
0.2395871282,
0.3444800675,
0.5345088243,
0.3623821437,
-0.5315365791,
-0.5813593864,
0.3990676403,
-0.4708199203,
0.2813672423,
0.1280702353,
-0.0711455271,
0.3289373219,
0.6159383059,
-0.7256623507,
0.0843138322,
0.4071843922,
-0.1959243864,
0.5710962415,
-0.3321476281,
0.0925918967,
-0.9863926768,
-0.0336218737,
-0.0717592537,
-0.219384253,
-0.5416402221,
-0.1252644062,
-0.0662682727,
-0.1903161407,
-0.3344649374,
0.4779124558,
-0.2182347625,
-0.0745060742,
-0.3285752833,
0.1275824904,
-0.5936496258,
0.3694047332,
-0.174873963,
0.787108779,
0.5959252119,
-0.466876626,
0.3296836913,
0.2239910811,
-0.5047092438,
0.3951527178,
-0.8123620749,
0.5718242526,
-0.0366209857,
-0.0854750127,
-0.9295223951,
-0.2198499292,
0.3305084705,
-0.6772400141,
0.1020905301,
-0.2464491725,
-0.5767148137,
-0.2692085803,
0.1275994033,
0.0502827689,
0.8702613115,
-0.577278018,
0.3290894032,
0.0692766085,
-0.4793219864,
-0.3249602616,
-0.62535429,
0.2709375918,
0.0212800801,
-0.7761669755,
-0.2793874741,
-0.0513997823,
-0.3212541342,
-0.0350893363,
-0.0134134386,
-0.1121199504,
0.2125758678,
-0.0944857746,
0.3349621892,
-0.4393708706,
0.0244018268,
-0.6220349669,
-0.2304368317,
0.2339976579,
-0.6520558,
0.7349533439,
-0.3176255226,
-0.6047157645,
-0.2360434532,
-0.1926127672,
0.5109536648,
-0.4804659784,
0.7233604789,
0.454572469,
-0.1910777539,
-0.0910942182,
-0.5262013674,
0.1492910683,
-0.4565301239,
0.3794999719,
0.0570407435,
-1.0956764221,
0.2604619563,
-0.1747284532,
0.3786472678,
0.4677785933,
0.6520206332,
0.0816236213,
0.8456661701,
0.7591643929,
-0.34010306,
0.6831114292,
0.1685402989,
0.4873349667,
-0.412117362,
-0.2081585974,
-0.6609509587,
-0.157983914,
-0.9852849245,
-0.2579096258,
0.3600293994,
0.0774947852,
-0.4539718628,
0.1904807985,
-0.3656366765,
0.5693930387,
0.8116580844,
0.0278589297,
0.5067883134,
-0.143749848,
0.5474398136,
0.2693978846,
-0.5784009099,
-0.6360749006,
1.0504354239,
0.5654999018,
0.8103663921,
0.0453086644,
0.5159245133,
0.5288313031,
0.4707092643,
-0.6757327318,
0.5448220372,
-0.2140333652,
-0.3104554415,
-0.4291512668,
-0.403855145,
-1.0271170139,
-0.0399952233,
0.2402929068,
-0.8303369284,
-0.1784168631,
0.3109316826,
0.1530756503,
0.2529664338,
-0.4560546577,
1.1468321085,
-0.3100220561,
-0.4300816059,
-0.2543222904,
-0.3766083717,
0.3508641422,
0.0641802773,
0.2203831226,
-0.3239969313,
0.0389599651,
0.5385164022,
-0.0776485354,
0.6428790092,
-0.0802312121,
-0.2288690954,
0.186203748,
0.0942580402,
0.8069292903,
-0.277025044,
0.0573921055,
0.1914599091,
-0.0459826104,
-0.6225119233,
-0.4885748923,
0.7542496324,
-0.4680919349,
-0.626981318,
-0.3117287457,
-0.3962326646,
-0.2624687254,
0.2298106253,
0.0298906025,
0.2092028558,
-0.5574580431,
0.3506201506,
0.7637547255,
-0.325078696,
0.315908581,
0.426309377,
-0.2547097802,
-0.3350534141,
1.0345678329,
-0.1383381635,
0.4248065352,
0.3580018282,
0.2504411638,
-0.0109097399,
-0.4174027443,
-0.598070085,
0.1705869585,
-0.5453395844,
0.1156858876,
-0.4681833386,
-0.2770911753,
-0.4711283445,
-0.0867943615,
-0.6399633884,
-0.2961572707,
-0.0252086092,
0.3438761532,
0.2367064655,
1.1211223602,
0.2070526779,
0.0053073005,
-0.8189730644,
-0.1747187525,
0.2633343935,
0.6220679283,
0.0859435126,
-0.3275742531,
-0.4791150093,
0.1625399441,
-0.299518168,
-0.2422382981,
0.1418370456,
0.0864805281,
0.4759575427,
0.3810592294,
-0.2351087183,
0.10798987,
-0.5543121696,
1.0355496407,
0.1757941097,
-0.7036601901,
0.3843548894,
-0.6527531147,
0.5275986791,
0.0829775855,
0.4758511782,
-1.0178316832,
-0.1804849207,
-0.4463149905,
-0.7620885968,
0.8771156669,
0.1430692524,
0.2186736912,
-0.0119559299,
0.260882467,
0.1709296405,
0.3656026423,
-0.675242722,
-0.1848990619,
-0.0179066937,
-0.2383428961,
-0.2029959261,
-0.1186413169,
0.1332314312,
0.0967207327,
0.8455678821,
-0.0517388098,
0.3064088225,
-0.2854650915,
0.0846360847,
0.1042555198,
0.6528961658,
0.4283520281,
0.8376627564,
-0.0356883928,
-0.1522039771,
-0.1285274178,
-0.3157750666,
-0.0549884476,
0.2668177783,
-0.3607949615,
-0.3273736238,
0.2862813175,
0.8673776984,
0.1143406183,
-0.9044625759,
0.5147423744,
0.3048201799,
-0.1514281183,
-0.3934343159,
0.1158235595,
0.0615165569,
0.5458467007,
0.2051487118,
-0.2770823538,
-0.0688505247,
-0.8220757842,
-0.0224993955,
0.5694712996,
-0.5565112233,
-0.1123830602,
0.8707120419,
-0.0918394551,
-0.4882799089,
0.8074558973,
-0.1592454314,
-0.4244713485,
0.4928131402,
0.5056938529,
1.08288908,
0.0406402759,
0.0081021572,
0.184492752,
0.5479615927,
-0.5583699346,
-0.0238820706,
-0.1258050054,
-0.5276053548,
-0.4456608593,
-0.5917348266,
-0.804394722,
0.1112424359,
-0.4667748511,
0.3562743366,
-0.3447122276,
0.1889665425,
-0.0789294094,
-0.1517727375,
-0.6529403925,
-0.0761556104,
0.2076361328,
0.9765256643,
-0.3984232247,
0.7143266201,
0.8354778886,
-0.5418980122,
-0.3549944162,
-0.0711223558,
-0.0661952645,
-0.8596393466,
0.6010583639,
-0.0221228618,
0.0915883854,
0.2233551294,
-0.7999402881,
-0.783141911,
0.9397572279,
0.2125332803,
-0.8153117299,
-0.1703006923,
0.4880667627,
0.5765919089,
-0.085104011,
0.0783121362,
0.6845760345,
0.3722035587,
-0.0138095412,
-1.2032170296,
-0.4113134742,
-0.1183350384,
-0.1314387321,
0.6763339639,
-0.8838942647,
0.9752582312,
-0.0219185445,
-0.2781934142,
0.309221983,
0.62236166,
0.0522482991,
0.5287969708,
0.279106319,
0.5051492453,
0.5615558028,
-0.3830988705,
0.9679986238,
-0.3354517221,
0.3370982707,
1.1468282938,
-0.1706144661,
1.0185123682,
0.0521689393,
-0.4072077274,
0.2757416964,
0.5065164566,
-0.3186761737,
0.2806693912,
0.2432355732,
-0.1632786691,
-0.1896805167,
0.0365737118,
-0.278159976,
0.2924629748,
0.2589970231,
-0.250887394,
-0.2520872653,
0.1020619273,
0.0663778856,
-0.1140979007,
-0.5093564987,
1.0720194578,
0.0661427751,
-0.790327251,
0.2624165118,
-0.060607709,
0.564214468,
-0.7638911605,
0.0139415376,
-0.3178838789,
0.4162751436,
0.1628831327,
-0.7949447036,
0.1022842899,
0.0970291272,
-0.0405540168,
-0.2354952693,
0.6397401094,
-0.5062622428,
-0.2768239081,
0.1527568698,
0.4760755897,
0.3526093066,
-0.269482553,
-0.3942911327,
0.1760607064,
-0.1024124026,
-0.1834615469,
0.4375419617,
0.6539342403,
0.0688606873,
0.7916057706,
0.4213083386,
0.0246903431,
0.1833704561,
-0.1474677324,
0.7615188956,
-0.861058414,
-0.3126876354,
-0.7950971723,
0.1591865718,
0.2082976401,
-0.268350333,
0.8266003728,
0.6032955647,
1.1164615154,
0.1185080856,
0.8398142457,
-0.1275892407,
0.472476095,
-0.463042289,
0.7040502429,
-0.4435760677,
0.2624547184,
0.1087465063,
-0.9394055009,
0.0128003899,
0.1141966358,
-0.2812303901,
0.1655636728,
0.3355657756,
0.7029693723,
-0.0542883165,
0.3745192885,
0.3147859871,
0.1940127164,
0.4997271895,
0.3142014742,
0.9307527542,
-0.2065179646,
0.6296178102,
-0.084268868,
-0.3289019763,
-0.2521919012,
-0.8060318828,
-0.5599889755,
-0.391476959,
-0.4250071943,
-0.2779802084,
0.3683482707,
1.2311840057,
0.4647830129,
-0.8423827887,
-0.229024142,
-0.3875855803,
-0.2136200368,
-0.482670784,
-0.1711850613,
0.2008498013,
-0.6988504529,
-0.8979514241,
0.4419578314,
0.5726751089,
-0.1346486658,
-0.4332177341,
-0.0764734447,
-0.1077433527,
0.1946549714,
0.7188950181,
0.5649080276,
-0.6117237806,
-0.119218953,
0.0511143059,
-0.0506879836,
0.3256008625,
1.000262022,
-0.4229440987,
0.2646780908,
0.3008924127,
1.0600600243,
0.5016863942,
-0.0450503975,
0.6398822665,
-0.3325635195,
-0.0517712571,
0.2217847556,
0.2503157556,
0.3263588846,
0.0105969226,
0.763943553,
0.0765001401,
-1.2071977854,
-0.6208050847,
0.1534217298,
-0.9297958612,
-0.1099802181,
0.9435731173,
-0.1512527317,
-0.2217982858,
-0.0349220484,
-0.2905695438,
0.1222819462,
-0.3072762191,
0.9044427276,
0.871553123,
-0.2465562373,
-0.321030587,
-0.7368209958,
0.3000697792,
0.3695324361,
-1.0237437487,
0.3587652743,
0.5129449964,
0.1621808708,
-0.0235510338,
0.7244082689,
-0.1096786857,
0.3390421271,
0.1140588298,
-0.0050114053,
-0.1001236588,
-0.2340432853,
-0.2179995626,
0.1182658374,
0.799127996,
-0.2803216279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16978v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16978v1
|
Assessing the influence of attractor-verb distance on grammatical agreement in humans and language models
| 2023-11-28T17:25:34 | 2023-11-28T17:25:34 |
Christos-Nikolaos Zacharopoulos, Théo Desbordes, Mathias Sablé-Meyer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Subject-verb agreement in the presence of an attractor noun located between
the main noun and the verb elicits complex behavior: judgments of
grammaticality are modulated by the grammatical features of the attractor. For
example, in the sentence "The girl near the boys likes climbing", the attractor
(boys) disagrees in grammatical number with the verb (likes), creating a
locally implausible transition probability. Here, we parametrically modulate
the distance between the attractor and the verb while keeping the length of the
sentence equal. We evaluate the performance of both humans and two artificial
neural network models: both make more mistakes when the attractor is closer to
the verb, but neural networks get close to the chance level while humans are
mostly able to overcome the attractor interference. Additionally, we report a
linear effect of attractor distance on reaction times. We hypothesize that a
possible reason for the proximity effect is the calculation of transition
probabilities between adjacent words. Nevertheless, classical models of
attraction such as the cue-based model might suffice to explain this
phenomenon, thus paving the way for new research. Data and analyses available
at https://osf.io/d4g6k
|
[
-0.4090098441,
-0.7225227356,
0.648401022,
0.2189622968,
0.0426693186,
-0.3325027823,
-0.3349544704,
-0.8451583385,
0.2240424454,
-0.2485926896,
-0.3511281312,
-0.180033654,
-0.7407946587,
0.2345847487,
-0.5808356404,
0.5268208981,
0.1189792231,
-0.0723937601,
-0.5370772481,
0.08278846,
-0.3592568338,
-0.6321425438,
-0.477155894,
-0.4408727586,
0.7069771886,
-0.0985231176,
0.8139559031,
0.5870069265,
0.8413784504,
0.3550635576,
-0.5060452819,
-0.1062824354,
-0.2975248992,
0.1456802636,
-0.2833654284,
-0.7603350282,
-0.004936866,
-0.0996881947,
0.4430731237,
0.7412218451,
-0.0005909456,
-0.2158699632,
-0.1250220984,
0.812915504,
-0.3059620857,
0.1853138506,
-0.4491442144,
0.2744166553,
-0.3251178861,
0.2413045764,
-0.116609551,
-0.3675860465,
0.582700789,
-0.1679522246,
0.3854179978,
0.1709413528,
1.0613088608,
0.0351528302,
-0.3750782311,
-0.1824285835,
-0.7381876707,
0.5144585371,
-0.6441367865,
0.568294704,
0.2815660834,
-0.1636216938,
-0.6914894581,
-0.2913931906,
-0.7621431947,
-0.5656280518,
-0.1059074551,
-0.2543628812,
-0.2819724083,
-0.0434034988,
0.1935866177,
0.1567801386,
-0.4876315594,
-0.1896601617,
-0.5057540536,
0.1856177449,
0.4395996928,
0.0510830507,
0.5610113144,
-0.336199671,
-0.0978765637,
0.1798837781,
-0.5348162651,
0.2753239274,
0.5321589112,
0.7038775682,
0.2038728595,
0.5763546228,
-0.061964035,
0.8469228745,
0.3962475359,
0.5805293322,
0.1263384819,
-0.4086843133,
0.185394153,
0.0332133397,
0.8425452709,
0.5283691287,
0.1161030978,
-0.2385991067,
-0.163980484,
0.4868839979,
0.3210208416,
-0.5129942298,
-0.222742483,
-0.1199436039,
-0.4298670292,
-0.1671431959,
0.4250563383,
-0.6705210805,
-0.3629410863,
-0.25857234,
0.3600377142,
-0.3459319174,
-0.3678453267,
0.1820195168,
0.099613823,
0.1484194994,
-0.0309765637,
-0.9233902693,
0.8387979269,
0.6708822846,
1.0166641474,
-0.4195253551,
-0.6506454349,
-0.3374689221,
-0.2943057418,
-0.2898526788,
0.8738931417,
-0.4813332558,
-0.2179031074,
-0.1486363411,
-0.1152149811,
-0.5841066837,
-0.6303431392,
0.2121593952,
-0.5620283484,
0.3904829323,
0.0050274883,
-0.7392243743,
-0.3012056649,
0.0413980037,
-0.6747463942,
0.9210579395,
-0.271795541,
-0.4571072757,
0.1003631577,
-0.6459953189,
-0.5758123994,
-0.3898324966,
-0.057489574,
-0.3228951693,
0.3999994695,
-0.1733823121,
0.1566389352,
0.133776322,
0.0100471163,
-0.1283694208,
-0.318647325,
0.836201787,
0.180230692,
0.5577155352,
0.034404248,
-0.444724232,
0.4074470103,
-0.4078145027,
-0.3379488289,
0.2237863541,
-0.372646004,
-0.5332232118,
0.4529089928,
-0.023140084,
0.5183849335,
0.163957268,
-0.4655056,
-0.0583985709,
-0.6325503588,
0.2562692165,
0.5007379055,
-0.0260612369,
0.4335695803,
-0.4210201502,
0.462215513,
0.2787880003,
-0.0676614419,
0.2291386276,
-0.7019966245,
-0.5734466314,
0.2418465167,
0.0223085787,
0.2355815321,
0.0185914245,
0.3229771256,
-0.1918682754,
-0.2744960785,
-0.184160471,
0.1914650798,
0.2892419994,
0.2671563923,
0.036197979,
-0.2877427936,
-0.5340707898,
-0.5099667311,
-0.5028124452,
-0.4012786448,
0.1249082759,
0.2018705308,
0.3755983114,
0.1272285432,
1.1328997612,
-0.6241998672,
-0.2541172802,
-0.1158813387,
-0.1667509526,
0.4098513722,
0.3982053995,
0.8207658529,
-0.9874957204,
-0.1882985383,
-0.0097350581,
-0.5782357454,
0.184156239,
0.2879500091,
-0.1661181301,
0.0907590687,
0.7267716527,
-0.9298225641,
0.4809739292,
0.4363271892,
-0.7932886481,
0.4960196018,
-0.140402928,
0.0491533689,
-0.8224667311,
-0.2750948071,
0.4492315948,
-0.0612523668,
-0.7890899777,
0.0255821291,
-0.2500371039,
0.0638749748,
-0.5207173824,
0.3311477602,
-0.3026411831,
0.0872622058,
-0.1847258955,
0.3686689734,
-0.2788878381,
0.3192303181,
-0.0044125929,
0.4804261923,
0.368889302,
-0.8863827586,
0.3897072971,
0.1384946853,
-0.3821301162,
0.514033556,
-0.6519428492,
0.1832316816,
-0.2397324145,
-0.1998820603,
-1.3065755367,
-0.3373677731,
0.1906428635,
-0.6514475346,
0.0211632699,
0.147570923,
-0.1054522172,
-0.3718810976,
-0.2251809239,
0.3809223771,
0.2543296516,
-0.3699934185,
0.4313330054,
0.0280927382,
-0.1411803514,
-0.0486725755,
-0.5315406919,
0.117132403,
-0.3212028444,
-0.6064105034,
0.0853971988,
-0.0791265219,
-0.778676331,
0.1375254244,
-0.0445842817,
-0.1272724718,
0.0983935148,
0.591919899,
0.0519804917,
-0.3138467669,
0.0871937498,
-0.3939982057,
0.3235422671,
0.5067540407,
-0.2409349829,
0.4456715882,
-0.3627231121,
-0.3271254897,
-0.4283558726,
-0.1094543785,
0.6828280687,
0.1052625924,
0.9666818976,
-0.0273351818,
-0.6525219679,
0.2347920835,
-0.2005163431,
-0.2234811336,
-0.3912383914,
0.5984671712,
-0.4994622171,
-0.3784719706,
0.6009870768,
0.4104464054,
-0.2725381851,
0.3541235328,
0.3041072786,
-0.1963869333,
0.6799621582,
0.4516735077,
0.1017318368,
0.8121803403,
0.1887342632,
0.043345876,
-0.6752989888,
-0.4572000802,
-0.6182312369,
-0.4887905419,
-0.4956559837,
-0.1915528029,
-0.1884925961,
-0.2811998427,
0.0753233284,
0.550047338,
-0.0076289494,
0.4533055425,
0.4593659043,
0.2611624897,
0.0134916762,
0.0500073545,
-0.1962893456,
-0.6207975149,
-0.5708952546,
-0.136887297,
0.6597113609,
0.1012185737,
0.464042753,
0.5520032048,
0.4559146762,
0.3534162045,
-0.0230402853,
-0.8496866822,
0.7845546007,
-0.0931119621,
-0.7522545457,
-0.1957717389,
-0.3006306887,
-1.2086769342,
0.2549647689,
-0.2742553651,
-0.7633666992,
0.2706628144,
-0.1306636482,
-0.1615076661,
0.3754947186,
-0.5961024761,
0.7198289037,
-0.1629708111,
-0.6495717168,
-0.0232312456,
-0.7996089458,
0.0482733287,
0.0710848644,
0.1172041968,
-0.2459052503,
0.0652586147,
0.7420501709,
-0.5001653433,
0.7047459483,
-0.0239778981,
-0.1990490854,
0.2360602766,
0.3367623687,
0.2508217096,
-0.6479560137,
-0.3176545203,
0.1539802849,
-0.5348851681,
-0.1887362599,
-0.6597167253,
0.7695994973,
-0.8060906529,
-0.4482192993,
-0.584554255,
-0.6376463771,
0.0350256562,
0.2618325055,
0.0918060765,
0.2099803239,
-0.3049640357,
-0.0082245525,
0.3153219223,
0.1302214414,
0.4397793114,
0.294537127,
-0.5482532382,
-0.2120006382,
0.8820795417,
0.0693811178,
0.3179623187,
0.4899939597,
0.3298522532,
-0.3625876904,
-0.4209544957,
0.0884230882,
0.4590881765,
-0.319355309,
0.3045042455,
-0.2979615331,
-0.1682039797,
-0.321927309,
-0.04398546,
-0.277492702,
-0.3385189474,
-0.4005584121,
-0.2293135822,
0.404270947,
1.1296107769,
0.0885040537,
0.2414384633,
-0.5294678807,
-0.0111664012,
0.2810833156,
0.3714796603,
-0.0524731763,
-0.8835320473,
-0.1006299928,
-0.1824312806,
-0.0057969349,
-0.9257490039,
0.1895111948,
0.2138464153,
0.282558918,
0.54356879,
-0.1832112074,
0.6241942048,
-0.6262546778,
0.6251173615,
0.3729725778,
-0.9039220214,
0.5593979955,
-0.6019764543,
0.2106673867,
0.3578363359,
0.1562250704,
-0.6078970432,
-0.4604799151,
-0.5614352822,
-0.5526736975,
0.7091923356,
0.595898211,
0.165522024,
-0.2014565319,
0.7122405171,
-0.2035655528,
0.1192978173,
-0.8139206767,
-0.3055907786,
0.1134494469,
-0.2613711357,
-0.1195867583,
-0.0737501532,
0.1607125849,
-0.2271843106,
0.3813381493,
0.1784941256,
0.2865315676,
0.072476536,
-0.1093603447,
-0.4083425105,
0.0860707313,
0.8400986791,
0.8505960703,
-0.3964829743,
0.3940466344,
0.0883670375,
-0.7803379297,
0.4300282896,
0.2377902865,
-0.3380586505,
0.2657734752,
0.364166975,
0.5500120521,
0.305108875,
-0.4224433303,
0.4540555179,
-0.2980433404,
-0.0190486535,
0.0049299099,
0.3021891415,
0.2073200643,
0.2502412498,
0.1473140866,
0.4537503421,
-0.1076086909,
-0.1647782773,
0.2047098428,
0.2073578387,
-0.7799555063,
-0.7393190861,
0.7892614007,
0.2537120879,
-0.7644930482,
0.6200578213,
-0.0739297792,
-0.4726366997,
0.9927768111,
0.7081260681,
0.6509317756,
-0.5059318542,
-0.124070555,
0.5152699947,
0.4682614505,
-0.0912200212,
0.1280509531,
0.224481523,
-0.8370648623,
-0.102107428,
-0.436996609,
-0.1401772052,
-0.1234344766,
-0.6584738493,
0.2580422759,
-0.4569579661,
-0.3918351531,
-0.0517335311,
-0.205808863,
-0.3658430874,
0.1134253591,
0.1763268858,
0.4529929161,
-0.9111102223,
0.3634836972,
1.273329854,
-0.3753991425,
-0.5338818431,
0.3015881479,
0.1464509964,
-0.1756513864,
0.8823669553,
0.3474481702,
-0.4615493119,
-0.3119092584,
-0.5029928088,
-0.801672101,
0.5846764445,
0.2979367971,
-0.772770226,
0.0008136153,
0.0070445263,
0.7663248181,
-0.1568980962,
-0.0353841521,
0.5543808937,
0.1034820974,
0.0035797667,
-0.7649231553,
0.0630940571,
-0.3937007189,
0.3051932454,
0.502251029,
-0.5956075191,
0.8548135757,
-0.5779193044,
0.0773215815,
0.2876643538,
1.2321345806,
0.2477462739,
0.2761633992,
0.5198990703,
0.4146606028,
0.5633695722,
0.0210983325,
0.9340050817,
-0.1755241752,
0.5426176786,
1.0947813988,
-0.4797557592,
1.073677063,
0.6560789943,
-0.7225964665,
0.6900721788,
0.4396445453,
0.2947466671,
0.2226510793,
0.5224772096,
-0.4212648273,
0.0236596037,
-0.1245651543,
-0.0115278773,
0.4854637384,
0.3811123967,
-0.3152872622,
0.0566312596,
-0.0820638314,
0.0659863353,
0.382796824,
-0.1195613965,
0.5187138319,
0.1228107288,
-0.5521008968,
-0.0123856477,
-0.1918480098,
0.5033853054,
-0.4579240084,
0.212025255,
-0.2767046392,
0.4314776361,
-0.2897409797,
-0.7737460732,
0.1963660121,
-0.1586425453,
-0.3715948164,
0.4229020774,
0.7528913021,
-0.4840890467,
-0.3155698776,
0.5778930783,
0.3321228623,
0.3532322645,
0.1311004162,
-0.4854959548,
-0.1164811924,
-0.2046952099,
-0.2553314865,
0.2884469628,
0.4766353369,
0.0318141431,
0.5034816861,
0.572467804,
0.2844723165,
0.3694781959,
0.175621435,
0.4852771461,
-0.7409882545,
-0.4380313158,
-1.0698423386,
-0.0709608123,
0.186517328,
-0.1523162574,
0.956761539,
0.4916286767,
0.6717899442,
-0.1248155683,
0.3337035179,
-0.2245219797,
0.14360255,
-0.2317116857,
0.6129966378,
-0.4054237604,
0.0161066968,
-0.4571825862,
-1.1682254076,
-0.6102923751,
0.7974783182,
-0.6510057449,
0.2166433781,
0.8426240087,
0.7647053599,
-0.1501670778,
-0.1923930347,
0.3793928921,
0.4107866287,
0.2306737304,
0.5579355955,
1.0994440317,
-0.4158916771,
0.5598198175,
-0.1301172674,
0.1572909802,
-0.1903709173,
-0.6531873941,
-0.8364414573,
-0.6400389075,
-0.4829078317,
-0.5849887133,
0.2017639726,
1.3203680515,
0.4635646641,
-0.8407353759,
-0.6132307649,
-0.4047944844,
0.1895879656,
-0.3429042399,
-0.2623673379,
0.2809969187,
-0.1847592592,
-0.8851345778,
0.1596717536,
0.1149786487,
0.2723787725,
-0.0857588872,
-0.21349971,
-0.8373088241,
0.0477378853,
0.3950625956,
0.3022963405,
-0.7261095047,
-0.1322393119,
0.101047419,
-0.229104951,
0.2161159962,
0.5656302571,
-0.6147111654,
0.5182009935,
0.5316411853,
0.3714162707,
0.0626518652,
0.0376743264,
0.4516860545,
-0.6612231731,
0.2263803482,
-0.2742042243,
0.3239175975,
0.4129695892,
-0.3984899819,
0.3706535697,
0.6673657894,
-0.516310513,
-0.3831445575,
0.1767378896,
-0.576141119,
-0.0857358873,
1.1609660387,
-0.1229155362,
-0.5503726602,
-0.008043508,
-0.2426059544,
0.1469650269,
-0.590780437,
0.9778573513,
1.1044490337,
-0.5909301639,
0.2073503584,
-0.2773916721,
0.3707504272,
0.5736020803,
-0.8265064359,
-0.2670896947,
0.6632424593,
0.4232329726,
0.4822105169,
0.0266903043,
0.1435744911,
0.4007772803,
-0.1087513417,
0.1357382089,
0.2696995437,
-0.3653296232,
-0.6721366048,
0.0500757173,
0.2649019063,
-0.4448630512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16965v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16965v1
|
Natural Language Processing Through Transfer Learning: A Case Study on Sentiment Analysis
| 2023-11-28T17:12:06 | 2023-11-28T17:12:06 |
Aman Yadav, Abhishek Vichare
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Artificial intelligence and machine learning have significantly bolstered the
technological world. This paper explores the potential of transfer learning in
natural language processing focusing mainly on sentiment analysis. The models
trained on the big data can also be used where data are scarce. The claim is
that, compared to training models from scratch, transfer learning, using
pre-trained BERT models, can increase sentiment classification accuracy. The
study adopts a sophisticated experimental design that uses the IMDb dataset of
sentimentally labelled movie reviews. Pre-processing includes tokenization and
encoding of text data, making it suitable for NLP models. The dataset is used
on a BERT based model, measuring its performance using accuracy. The result
comes out to be 100 per cent accurate. Although the complete accuracy could
appear impressive, it might be the result of overfitting or a lack of
generalization. Further analysis is required to ensure the model's ability to
handle diverse and unseen data. The findings underscore the effectiveness of
transfer learning in NLP, showcasing its potential to excel in sentiment
analysis tasks. However, the research calls for a cautious interpretation of
perfect accuracy and emphasizes the need for additional measures to validate
the model's generalization.
|
[
-0.3744977713,
-0.6963718534,
0.2832330763,
0.4155548811,
-0.3326064646,
0.2386368364,
-0.2834316492,
-0.6641145945,
0.0467202216,
0.3881184161,
-0.5331887007,
-0.404273361,
-0.9626296163,
0.0817160383,
-0.5678465366,
1.2174903154,
0.1210809126,
0.2336317748,
-0.0496986918,
-0.1612733305,
-0.3415135443,
-0.8744619489,
-0.6018608809,
-0.1712425947,
0.209455803,
0.1121176183,
0.7333819866,
-0.0164801553,
0.6776226163,
0.2089723498,
0.1912296414,
0.0947008356,
-0.2719247043,
0.0017755801,
-0.3226966858,
-0.457274586,
-0.265406996,
0.2586602569,
0.450334847,
0.5793185234,
0.259437412,
-0.0007297352,
0.1092576087,
0.9665517211,
-0.2765889168,
0.3382689059,
-0.721342802,
0.3795298338,
0.0959258154,
0.1454235911,
-0.5062237978,
-0.730586648,
0.4969803393,
-0.1503397971,
0.0899153501,
-0.0260613337,
1.0134997368,
0.1572921574,
-0.2954159677,
-0.4845290184,
-0.8544636965,
1.0862623453,
-0.8035228252,
0.1355519444,
0.1616879404,
0.2023446709,
0.1339266896,
-0.5153777003,
-0.6875588894,
-0.2824440897,
0.0636893362,
-0.0900733173,
-0.1987677366,
-0.0195555408,
0.0273150969,
0.5041351914,
-0.3722548783,
-0.0577773079,
-0.2197296768,
-0.1724043638,
0.4950111806,
-0.2503041029,
0.1588694006,
-0.3864802122,
-0.4035637975,
-0.3081153333,
0.0698464662,
0.18566975,
0.1100175455,
0.5553298593,
0.1349062473,
0.3234675229,
-0.0297592692,
0.7877515554,
-0.0880749449,
0.3382735252,
0.4028353691,
-0.2676969171,
-0.2831965983,
0.0640558004,
0.7365680933,
0.36736691,
0.7920091748,
0.0017997606,
-0.1612933874,
0.1179069579,
0.6443938017,
-0.6064510345,
-0.199048236,
0.0941808671,
-0.4958263934,
-0.4390889704,
0.2446048558,
-0.6640570164,
-0.3800173402,
-0.6180235744,
0.4477293789,
-0.6574178338,
-0.1551218778,
0.0849637762,
0.0429473743,
0.3460918963,
0.2585224807,
-0.6939672232,
0.2046034187,
0.7146007419,
1.0205489397,
-0.2244151682,
-0.0985875353,
-0.3368397355,
-0.2073892951,
-0.1374851614,
0.8177027106,
-0.4860525429,
-0.266674161,
0.1473053545,
-0.2437784672,
-0.1129974499,
-0.3998635113,
0.8996880651,
-0.4496911764,
0.2637060285,
0.0003362518,
-0.5915452242,
-0.5079945326,
0.4893285334,
-0.6387431026,
0.8412273526,
0.2160982341,
-0.6884938478,
0.2588519752,
-0.7702678442,
-0.7930281162,
-0.4892110527,
0.4041443169,
-0.2691978216,
0.4110830426,
0.3266971409,
0.5726526976,
0.0174622741,
0.2565220892,
-0.3238471746,
-0.2436912358,
0.5560307503,
-0.3040246069,
0.5973122716,
0.5241824985,
-0.1275043637,
-0.1918641031,
-0.5697069168,
0.0610541217,
-0.2543283999,
-0.2721349299,
-0.3184828162,
-0.3027092516,
0.1114922017,
0.3323629797,
0.2242695838,
-0.6036705971,
0.2191337496,
-0.5285570025,
0.1875474453,
0.6431947947,
-0.1610176265,
0.7536053658,
-0.1423335671,
0.3947657943,
0.2803876698,
0.1768237203,
0.2012820691,
-0.3745686114,
-0.7538451552,
0.0520904027,
0.72936064,
0.5406624675,
-0.6169167757,
0.7433676124,
-0.285053283,
-0.2867337763,
-1.006754756,
0.0551864989,
-0.2561944723,
0.6825354099,
0.4552897811,
-0.6394141912,
-0.7902994752,
-0.7839031219,
-0.4578851163,
-0.3249967694,
0.0842394009,
0.0014663804,
0.0879743025,
-0.4602401853,
1.148570776,
-0.3643864691,
-0.5774257183,
-0.4950221479,
0.6559625864,
0.5301072001,
0.4509423673,
0.3756424785,
-0.6702364683,
-0.5257275701,
0.1182850376,
-0.8533576131,
0.0403894819,
-0.1334810853,
-0.2647926807,
0.4060116112,
0.1728044152,
-0.4983026981,
0.1445342451,
0.5650644302,
0.0744871572,
0.3860941231,
-0.1266806126,
0.1634508222,
-1.0549241304,
0.1465055346,
0.2832566202,
-0.3248540163,
-0.6773947477,
-0.4019370377,
-0.1450973004,
0.0020933652,
-0.2995512784,
0.3060644567,
-0.0853450075,
0.0345978923,
-0.4522686601,
-0.0365731195,
0.0053014997,
0.3709776998,
0.1395857632,
0.2828864455,
0.461066097,
-0.4239280224,
0.4850011468,
0.1160912141,
-0.4371726215,
0.6497619748,
-0.1676567793,
0.2292488813,
-0.2771120667,
0.2122594565,
-1.0083558559,
0.1296800524,
0.2167303711,
-0.6743412018,
0.345285356,
-0.1073001176,
-0.2664738297,
-0.3264294267,
-0.450424999,
-0.3247728646,
0.7291406989,
-0.4855884612,
0.6856165528,
0.2958305776,
-0.2936779559,
-0.725322783,
-0.7287417054,
0.0876301453,
-0.1570715457,
-0.4384871423,
0.1729050279,
-0.0168302786,
-0.1391998678,
0.1123215333,
0.0752339214,
-0.4547831118,
0.0693039447,
0.1515652388,
0.4420616627,
-0.1039362848,
0.4147918224,
-0.0269514024,
0.0466478989,
0.2801060975,
-0.1163619608,
0.4193631113,
-0.298751533,
0.2327786982,
-0.4084820747,
0.1338240951,
0.5847398043,
0.0477686487,
0.9273325801,
0.864928484,
-0.1934849322,
-0.3540146053,
-0.3856370449,
-0.0525104143,
-0.359700799,
0.3146867156,
-0.0649789348,
-0.5562555194,
0.1462468505,
-0.0982515216,
0.1035415679,
0.3972723484,
0.152987808,
-0.6832985282,
0.9369795322,
0.8851075172,
-0.8162662387,
0.8540600538,
-0.1904252023,
0.583748877,
-0.5264328122,
0.0672062412,
-0.6048102975,
-0.5228836536,
-0.4063435197,
-0.2097364813,
-0.0066642556,
-0.1153955162,
0.1267452836,
0.1306421459,
-0.2661667168,
0.3246346116,
0.4738611877,
0.1614318341,
0.3505057693,
0.2263953388,
0.1803637147,
-0.1377449185,
-0.3367552459,
-0.6018353701,
1.0827203989,
0.4712215066,
0.723282516,
-0.1939591616,
0.4545973539,
0.9767814875,
0.5822024941,
-1.0047208071,
0.3648753762,
-0.6229076982,
-0.2908689678,
-0.2029928416,
-0.3671403527,
-0.6091974378,
0.0493947566,
-0.4543186426,
-0.2666309774,
-0.0427383892,
0.0121205458,
0.0059553194,
0.3056451976,
-0.878061235,
0.6205607057,
-0.3237305582,
-0.0554760583,
-0.3598006964,
-0.8274879456,
0.3456017077,
-0.1237925366,
0.3661884964,
-0.0791772678,
0.4818687737,
0.7504159212,
0.0119545897,
0.7902626395,
-0.3869299293,
0.0218603984,
0.2416806668,
0.0614412092,
0.2698769271,
-0.3486326039,
-0.5515398979,
0.2366079986,
-0.136613965,
-0.3560192585,
-0.569324553,
0.7028902173,
-0.8346925974,
-0.2892542481,
-0.5491161942,
-0.5098380446,
-0.42443946,
-0.1755744815,
-0.1087379232,
-0.051088579,
-0.2629959285,
0.1956310421,
0.6176044345,
-0.1099177971,
0.4207091331,
0.159939304,
-0.2836230099,
-0.1044229791,
0.882619679,
0.0878888294,
0.0657485425,
0.4416613877,
0.3003605008,
-0.4824933708,
-0.5138015747,
-0.3920934796,
0.2404852659,
-0.7317633033,
-0.0852484182,
-0.6750450134,
-0.3771088719,
-0.424506098,
-0.0521666966,
-0.3448410034,
-0.316922158,
-0.3447136581,
-0.3131242394,
0.3241244555,
0.666815877,
-0.0262164436,
0.2709776759,
-1.1275964975,
0.2839036584,
0.3334670663,
0.400724113,
0.0411207303,
-0.6970428228,
-0.2005780637,
0.1514055729,
-0.2657358348,
-0.746753037,
0.7261750102,
0.3678689003,
0.35213539,
0.1676745117,
0.1580318213,
0.2918656766,
0.0036535219,
0.8079704046,
0.1340579838,
-1.1503856182,
0.717397511,
0.0573803335,
0.2243258506,
0.9414967299,
0.5977406502,
-0.5149490833,
-0.2769906521,
-0.6122492552,
-0.5136830211,
0.7559105754,
-0.0751236826,
0.3644659221,
0.3267885745,
0.2001021802,
0.468954891,
0.3371762633,
-0.8834528923,
0.0410694107,
-0.1289871484,
-0.5807878375,
-0.2213520408,
-0.0354280658,
0.3720084727,
-0.4338204265,
0.8243557215,
-0.1095447391,
0.1934168339,
0.2001378536,
-0.5396051407,
0.045033779,
0.3215803802,
0.1337960064,
0.4163677096,
-0.5312536955,
0.0852326676,
0.0695903823,
-0.425955236,
-0.0442016684,
-0.1059516221,
0.2508893609,
0.2453180403,
0.2119495422,
0.6186826825,
-0.1867892891,
-0.5884703398,
0.6366991401,
-0.2571132481,
0.005903664,
-0.0544159524,
-0.0862215683,
-0.1038277671,
-0.0020701487,
0.2879143953,
0.4825443029,
0.325129658,
-0.9000874758,
0.1305144429,
0.505953908,
-0.6860394478,
-0.4112627208,
0.0583254024,
0.3268894553,
-0.2303442508,
1.0336680412,
0.105938524,
-0.6502920389,
0.4113027453,
0.2813945413,
0.9926221967,
-0.073036477,
0.4084360898,
0.2541000545,
0.2377234548,
-0.0155012133,
0.0739594102,
-0.1875022352,
-0.9802457094,
-0.6300292015,
-0.991735816,
-0.6835646629,
-0.114843227,
-0.7186640501,
0.3221886456,
-0.5218655467,
-0.3593592644,
-0.2075175494,
-0.1939752251,
-0.608299315,
0.4572234452,
0.4540631175,
0.7259485126,
-1.18176651,
1.1109250784,
0.6840056777,
-0.2149318904,
-0.4248856604,
0.0239042584,
-0.5987902284,
-0.6634761095,
0.813149333,
0.3565984368,
-0.0717401654,
-0.0918681473,
-0.6332037449,
-0.4575992823,
0.2984755635,
0.2904441655,
-0.3686629832,
0.2179726362,
0.1041044742,
1.070484519,
-0.25685969,
0.1733695269,
0.9096801877,
0.391281426,
0.175634861,
-0.7386162877,
-0.4647669494,
-0.1209880486,
-0.2587823868,
0.0420748033,
-0.2759474814,
0.5429528356,
-0.0735816211,
-0.002409582,
-0.2374869883,
0.7491710186,
-0.1474951506,
0.2874639034,
0.5627871156,
0.4297572076,
0.6914378405,
-0.1537447423,
1.0147361755,
-0.031988591,
0.3882467747,
0.8123177886,
-0.3054213524,
0.9786148071,
0.7295707464,
-0.4229870737,
0.7169973254,
0.3260347843,
0.12740165,
0.5267725587,
0.1627468467,
-0.2248273194,
-0.0306056589,
-0.2948819697,
-0.0690283552,
0.2257781327,
0.2782639563,
-0.6163713932,
-0.0963933766,
0.3518406749,
-0.1586956531,
0.1901878566,
-0.3834251165,
0.9189382195,
0.16947788,
-0.6108552814,
0.1830844283,
-0.1834656447,
1.0454367399,
-0.7233583927,
-0.0561325587,
-0.2070874721,
0.176303342,
-0.2892263234,
-0.9845289588,
0.5946510434,
0.0765041858,
-0.3350025713,
-0.5573394299,
0.8596092463,
-0.1194553748,
-0.6012240648,
0.3218360543,
0.4423477352,
0.2703714371,
-0.0867069885,
-0.6698122621,
-0.0554931946,
0.3835439086,
-0.0957500935,
0.4387349784,
0.4042733014,
0.0724985301,
0.4824115336,
0.6357251406,
0.3836185634,
0.175790295,
0.2051695287,
0.5481709838,
-0.8694651723,
-0.5732189417,
-0.9658887386,
0.3498553932,
-0.1618487239,
-0.0418204814,
0.5915047526,
0.2296682,
0.6644769311,
-0.4998341203,
0.9798210859,
-0.16696468,
0.6315034628,
-0.4309849739,
0.4591409266,
-0.0063228309,
0.0947798342,
-0.2985994816,
-1.1617891788,
-0.4625356793,
0.8138955235,
-0.5548143387,
-0.1719973385,
0.5860133767,
0.3563099504,
0.1364767104,
0.3980960846,
0.2589348257,
0.2649109364,
0.3430694044,
0.4433055222,
1.1435228586,
-0.4306753874,
0.2574431002,
-0.4109173715,
-0.0834714994,
-0.2585919499,
-1.0028758049,
-0.601963222,
-0.348085165,
-0.2187760919,
-0.1458281726,
-0.0850894898,
0.9199907184,
0.6194962859,
-0.9437009692,
-0.2411598861,
0.0564403348,
0.1495930403,
-0.2090372443,
-0.3322259486,
0.2245368212,
-0.7371136546,
-0.8829952478,
0.1678740531,
0.0330504589,
0.0608151779,
-0.1642409712,
0.2592648864,
-0.3430520892,
-0.0208219457,
0.7716033459,
0.001029857,
-0.2425314486,
-0.3600045145,
-0.3433718681,
-0.029117696,
0.2608048916,
0.6859595776,
-0.9971028566,
0.5743331313,
0.4818921089,
0.8812334538,
0.4087303877,
0.3134405911,
0.6922668219,
-0.8623442054,
-0.2447931617,
0.3598762453,
0.2579376101,
0.5930563807,
-0.4461468756,
0.3857349157,
0.027664667,
-0.4729575515,
-0.5776673555,
-0.1739201546,
-1.2429192066,
-0.3454750776,
0.7962824106,
-0.0388204828,
-0.2106203884,
-0.0999684855,
-0.5993816257,
0.3181109726,
-0.5461198688,
0.92595011,
0.9984855056,
-0.5131565332,
0.0122838225,
-0.3134942055,
0.3463229537,
0.5728213191,
-0.9076430202,
-0.0623548552,
0.300894469,
0.1712680012,
0.2548178136,
0.1973609477,
-0.117526114,
-0.120584324,
-0.6269385219,
0.2717405558,
0.2638849616,
-0.1486372054,
-0.8737158775,
0.5620831847,
0.3056087196,
-0.2946662903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16941v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16941v1
|
Debiasing Multimodal Models via Causal Information Minimization
| 2023-11-28T16:46:14 | 2023-11-28T16:46:14 |
Vaidehi Patil, Adyasha Maharana, Mohit Bansal
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, stat.ME
|
Most existing debiasing methods for multimodal models, including causal
intervention and inference methods, utilize approximate heuristics to represent
the biases, such as shallow features from early stages of training or unimodal
features for multimodal tasks like VQA, etc., which may not be accurate. In
this paper, we study bias arising from confounders in a causal graph for
multimodal data and examine a novel approach that leverages causally-motivated
information minimization to learn the confounder representations. Robust
predictive features contain diverse information that helps a model generalize
to out-of-distribution data. Hence, minimizing the information content of
features obtained from a pretrained biased model helps learn the simplest
predictive features that capture the underlying data distribution. We treat
these features as confounder representations and use them via methods motivated
by causal theory to remove bias from models. We find that the learned
confounder representations indeed capture dataset biases, and the proposed
debiasing methods improve out-of-distribution (OOD) performance on multiple
multimodal datasets without sacrificing in-distribution performance.
Additionally, we introduce a novel metric to quantify the sufficiency of
spurious features in models' predictions that further demonstrates the
effectiveness of our proposed methods. Our code is available at:
https://github.com/Vaidehi99/CausalInfoMin
|
[
-0.5005248189,
-0.7479460239,
0.5913136601,
0.138825357,
-0.327578634,
-0.3988387287,
0.0558778457,
-0.2965855896,
0.0890089422,
0.281213671,
-0.6424546838,
-0.2738796771,
-0.7484873533,
-0.2870322168,
-0.0008785813,
0.7151789665,
0.1488917172,
0.3440656066,
-0.40495947,
-0.1801178008,
-0.4561138153,
-0.2942022383,
-0.2549604177,
-0.5002650619,
0.6678000689,
0.2758949101,
0.6764104366,
0.4512251318,
0.4192300439,
0.0851224214,
0.1800840497,
0.3034478724,
-0.6320465207,
0.0622792244,
-0.2839806974,
-0.2114694566,
0.1051881164,
0.1743176579,
0.4432977438,
0.7571543455,
0.2182158679,
0.1875551045,
0.2414375246,
0.2981616855,
-1.028580308,
0.4740872383,
-0.3838484287,
-0.121899873,
-0.1273896694,
-0.338616997,
-0.667879045,
-0.4030959904,
0.0559856109,
-0.7723301053,
0.2500694096,
0.0785006359,
0.5307738185,
0.6499599814,
-1.1443864107,
-0.0913559347,
-0.7366927862,
0.9132635593,
-0.3297722936,
0.3067606986,
0.5047486424,
0.3578369021,
-0.0710455924,
-0.3143999577,
-0.4706843793,
-0.1333547533,
-0.3109378219,
0.1758485883,
-0.270103395,
0.0820260644,
0.4330188036,
-0.23779805,
-0.3538091779,
0.1175925806,
-0.2484235018,
-0.2802625895,
0.5133610368,
0.0360035077,
-0.1400706172,
-0.2843278348,
-0.9066060185,
-0.327717483,
-0.7684171796,
0.1452757567,
0.3376768529,
0.2434269339,
-0.3474981189,
0.4972728789,
-0.1145709082,
0.3811338246,
0.1200741231,
-0.3087905943,
0.3977032006,
-0.3761519194,
-0.1972543448,
0.1173315644,
0.548802793,
0.4434404969,
-0.0499553308,
0.0610589869,
0.1875191927,
0.4606587291,
-0.1083104536,
-0.7347399592,
-0.1279743612,
0.0292437356,
-0.5994529724,
-0.2731998563,
-0.0522692464,
-0.9080719352,
-0.9498789907,
-0.2547226846,
0.4268742502,
-0.3832101524,
-0.1359748542,
-0.0039356807,
-0.3582932353,
-0.4482653737,
0.3155353367,
-0.6265115738,
-0.2180308253,
0.0765246451,
0.5060578585,
0.3125708103,
-0.076230444,
-0.6266080737,
0.4986578524,
-0.0716667697,
0.4686777294,
-0.6437444687,
-0.0566218942,
-0.013966294,
-0.0819941014,
-0.2083259672,
-0.180163607,
0.5383271575,
-0.5244450569,
-0.1477766037,
-0.3131186366,
-0.3636428714,
-0.5963510275,
0.218715772,
-0.9851719737,
0.5649873614,
-0.0194863267,
-1.0398474932,
0.794634819,
-0.2410018891,
-0.3207045197,
-0.6228733063,
-0.1396485269,
-0.4072322249,
0.0415192023,
0.4787294567,
0.336392194,
-0.5719717741,
0.6478821039,
-1.0054265261,
-0.087549001,
0.1193079948,
-0.7657901049,
0.6707138419,
0.3180606961,
-0.4249031246,
0.1188217551,
-0.8828292489,
-0.4142868221,
-0.1418560296,
0.0308355726,
-0.6325320601,
0.0815415233,
0.0356610939,
0.4685526192,
-0.119648166,
-0.4829426408,
-0.0186096206,
0.1530213058,
0.0400059484,
0.784068048,
0.3095775545,
0.557711184,
-0.1712865531,
0.3284323812,
0.6084335446,
0.6054759026,
-0.2856888473,
-0.2666020691,
-0.3736163974,
-0.686640799,
-0.0611294843,
0.1107470691,
-0.9116787314,
-0.0327692218,
-0.0296032373,
-0.3383934796,
-0.0991100296,
0.291508168,
0.5889757872,
0.6869594455,
0.3915662467,
-0.1861253679,
-0.4535540938,
-0.979269743,
-0.0453542024,
0.0530494377,
0.259427011,
0.0643815994,
0.3100349307,
-0.4019383788,
0.7933172584,
-0.4833329022,
-0.4733591378,
-0.0059303367,
0.2809633315,
0.115268901,
0.6170802712,
0.8724119663,
-1.0275717974,
-0.1012327522,
-0.3919125795,
-0.9291647673,
0.119128719,
-0.1860513389,
-0.1788096577,
-0.2123406678,
0.4393416643,
-0.776062429,
0.5264139175,
0.1821870953,
-0.3174424171,
0.0870316178,
-0.1469450295,
0.1235770658,
-0.603040278,
0.1257560253,
0.3227327168,
-0.0252885185,
-0.3951397836,
-0.2702153027,
0.1216545627,
0.0250426289,
-0.3921726346,
0.5740382671,
-0.5429313183,
0.2752387822,
0.1330965906,
0.2924883962,
0.2023516595,
0.7236173749,
-0.2859023511,
-0.0745376199,
0.566383779,
-0.6185619831,
0.1880980283,
0.3581021428,
-0.3031155467,
0.4883032441,
-0.1535421759,
-0.3475922644,
-0.8394759893,
0.2701054513,
-1.1274273396,
-0.3966422081,
0.3464527726,
-0.1001366377,
0.276816994,
-0.308637917,
-0.4342196584,
-0.155328095,
-0.4369364977,
0.6130582094,
0.1955920458,
-0.6402240396,
0.365252018,
0.4300990105,
0.4966711402,
-0.7593911886,
-0.6156138778,
-0.7051970363,
-0.4451762438,
-0.397708267,
0.2281919569,
0.0891305357,
-0.1772669703,
-0.0226510558,
-0.0471186154,
0.1136474386,
0.1164526194,
0.4766973853,
0.0486220457,
0.2281800359,
0.3961419761,
0.3312297165,
-0.2757911682,
-0.033922974,
-0.2119507492,
0.353572011,
0.6614161134,
-0.6321871877,
-0.4070212841,
0.3492305875,
0.6383723617,
0.0117425174,
0.3984930217,
0.8359419703,
-0.3454013765,
0.0976380333,
-0.4528781176,
-0.4310157895,
-0.3423101008,
0.330324322,
-0.0501654558,
-0.4554392993,
0.4182098508,
-0.1245208979,
-0.355784446,
0.3550622463,
0.3746946752,
0.1024957523,
1.3598320484,
0.6391673684,
-0.1646918803,
0.69642061,
-0.2754641175,
0.0900089443,
-0.5981045961,
-0.4981589317,
-0.2186656594,
-0.4055054486,
-0.6636348367,
-0.405716151,
0.6825655699,
0.3155647218,
-0.3987967074,
-0.1781177819,
-0.0682142898,
-0.0622710213,
0.8258709311,
0.5716928244,
0.1276250184,
-0.0008377196,
-0.1755614132,
0.059834376,
-0.8289399743,
-0.0393275097,
1.1744089127,
0.2059433013,
1.2306368351,
-0.0052647009,
0.2345094383,
0.3532098234,
0.259293288,
-0.0821800232,
0.0692688674,
0.0926514193,
-0.7796785235,
-0.0490315594,
-0.4865880013,
-0.6480782628,
0.410698235,
-0.5504695773,
-0.6142424941,
0.8725525141,
0.525657773,
-0.3536177874,
0.0527154654,
-0.9665434361,
0.9916120768,
-0.1554600596,
-0.7302303314,
-0.5349205136,
-0.7138800025,
0.5730997324,
0.1842257231,
0.4153496623,
-0.2386637032,
0.3490251005,
0.3385499716,
-0.2198210061,
1.2215448618,
-0.5649974346,
0.1878024638,
0.2982186973,
-0.083485797,
0.4631370008,
0.3713340759,
0.1077509671,
0.0425467603,
-0.1797298342,
-0.3608559072,
-0.6327413917,
0.6647906899,
-0.7041013837,
-0.3431816101,
-0.1035991088,
-0.6360670924,
-0.3271155655,
0.1165476367,
0.251467824,
0.8251621723,
-0.0462374352,
0.1662765592,
0.4474335611,
-0.0812020376,
0.5910260081,
-0.0167800896,
-0.0172741022,
-0.485816747,
0.5680530071,
0.0875846148,
0.2739365399,
0.4952319264,
0.3473995328,
-0.5211278796,
-0.0689190999,
-0.2960145473,
0.1023590341,
-0.9752095342,
-0.2524383068,
-0.564964056,
0.4340317547,
-0.4014164805,
0.0828575566,
-0.062996231,
-0.4122467935,
-0.2531897128,
-0.1984099299,
0.1613423526,
0.4089848101,
-0.2776023149,
0.5268933177,
-0.5394035578,
0.3008597493,
0.268928498,
-0.0993040428,
0.2159606218,
-0.1216391027,
-0.3998318911,
0.2258481234,
-0.7101311684,
-0.8277800083,
0.2721203566,
0.0624759011,
0.623778522,
0.9172036648,
0.2759356499,
0.7185539603,
0.0658668354,
0.3769533336,
0.5707444549,
-0.7495219111,
0.4625570774,
-0.2858617008,
0.0469912142,
0.3680101931,
0.6883527637,
-0.0107150227,
-0.1956032068,
-0.5048811436,
-0.6462272406,
0.6785922647,
0.0047247014,
-0.1038682982,
-0.0189051908,
-0.0507602766,
0.2341932207,
0.5744376779,
-0.6326900125,
-0.3092511594,
-0.2597286403,
-0.26087749,
-0.3646221757,
-0.5365547538,
-0.2040841728,
-0.1412526667,
0.4577476382,
-0.2370447963,
0.0685574934,
0.1964973211,
-0.4897786677,
-0.0604860708,
0.000711686,
0.5993906856,
0.5859261751,
-0.2933622599,
0.5183224678,
-0.2074692994,
-0.1992321461,
0.1479606628,
0.1916559637,
-0.3390231729,
0.1068846136,
0.4872344434,
0.8949642777,
0.4827971756,
-0.3956923783,
0.6633219719,
0.3285849988,
0.4356804788,
-0.1652110368,
-0.2265869528,
-0.3532600701,
0.6337758303,
0.303473562,
0.5705211163,
0.2907964289,
-0.4218418896,
0.1274889261,
0.5353522897,
-0.6912366152,
-0.4769034684,
1.0605803728,
0.0569581725,
0.7827538848,
0.2451124638,
-0.0957645625,
-0.1268928796,
0.5167499781,
0.4017942846,
0.7284980416,
-0.0727837831,
0.2220587134,
0.5029581785,
0.2549207509,
-0.0385685042,
0.1097315028,
-0.0693841875,
-0.7735410929,
-0.1462495774,
-0.1873044223,
0.0278974809,
-0.1611098796,
-0.5300285816,
0.4812980592,
-0.327005446,
-0.593449533,
0.0108492011,
-0.461297363,
-0.9108957052,
0.3161549568,
0.1788349301,
0.4857949615,
-1.0082033873,
0.6607814431,
0.1905242652,
-0.7878991365,
-0.6116250157,
-0.2646483481,
0.1938303709,
-0.555781424,
0.8697400093,
0.1020305008,
-0.0340016074,
-0.18349801,
-0.4087893069,
-0.9173429608,
0.9616577029,
0.8341688514,
-0.2789958417,
-0.0015115723,
0.0566045679,
-0.0324840136,
-0.3719840646,
0.6234946847,
0.113047719,
0.6359885931,
-0.0441338755,
-0.4320391119,
0.1599622518,
-0.1324587315,
-0.0476369932,
-0.0304774083,
-0.5695619583,
1.0587204695,
-0.3958009183,
-0.0977893695,
-0.4865258932,
0.2287007123,
-0.022223793,
0.630682826,
0.491915524,
0.3780290186,
0.7536930442,
0.0440751947,
1.1670593023,
-0.0802982152,
0.6723100543,
0.8990848064,
-0.1847028583,
0.064646937,
0.8238083124,
0.3603714406,
0.358946234,
0.5331975222,
0.2346339077,
1.1702080965,
-0.0753517151,
-0.0193041228,
-0.5250307918,
-0.3409411609,
-0.1681474596,
0.4121076763,
0.0816503763,
-0.5618596077,
-0.6176473498,
0.5731131434,
0.1302313954,
-0.1167965457,
-0.2756504714,
0.4001867473,
0.0044227042,
-0.4171991646,
0.5033880472,
-0.2277176976,
0.531426549,
-0.6000077724,
-0.0840507746,
-0.2487185597,
0.5666230321,
-0.1417048872,
-0.193289116,
0.0636193603,
-0.5238633156,
-0.4820881486,
-0.3257675767,
0.4879308939,
-0.4729501903,
-0.3663397431,
0.5114768744,
0.2952286303,
-0.4698329866,
-0.1435453445,
-0.2187769264,
0.000908303,
-0.0066407779,
-0.1484944522,
0.1722922176,
0.3084893823,
-0.5968666077,
0.740963161,
0.5976366997,
-0.265989244,
0.1081689224,
0.2224563956,
0.936127305,
-0.4648934007,
-0.5396127701,
-0.9754240513,
0.5684528351,
-0.0397731289,
-0.3760476708,
0.8806404471,
0.3419684768,
0.9117370844,
-0.4251967669,
0.6611740589,
0.0157609656,
0.1836728603,
-0.5847710371,
0.6089516878,
-0.6165574789,
-0.0454305746,
-0.5823104978,
-0.5680969357,
-0.3331422508,
0.1648501009,
-0.3877681792,
0.0589721799,
0.6802739501,
0.7409188151,
-0.2020875067,
-0.1581010967,
0.343806386,
0.0951746032,
0.2654138505,
0.6212788224,
0.8623707891,
-0.3628436327,
0.3602932096,
-0.541031599,
-0.3440299332,
-0.4306034148,
-0.7820916772,
-1.0413213968,
-0.6034056544,
-0.2568541169,
-0.1328399926,
-0.0957270488,
0.8801071048,
0.8552798033,
-0.6200048327,
0.1309746951,
0.3263382614,
0.6044982076,
-0.474634409,
-0.1050288603,
0.3912141025,
-0.271288991,
-0.5950233936,
0.1719786823,
0.1173611879,
-0.22943905,
-0.2173336893,
0.0384298563,
-0.2905293107,
-0.0198991895,
0.6333751678,
-0.1561942399,
-0.3333555758,
-0.5164471269,
-0.2359896451,
-0.0414737426,
-0.1268936992,
1.0209037066,
-0.7920009494,
0.774431169,
0.5389943123,
0.1352472752,
0.7321301699,
0.0608938597,
0.2402609587,
-0.9163483977,
0.9170541763,
-0.1215774342,
0.619831562,
0.1809901893,
-0.3613580465,
0.2952857018,
0.5589087009,
0.0216586236,
-0.7964433432,
0.3930667937,
-0.8481897116,
-0.0830710828,
0.9018406868,
-0.0637648627,
-0.2355329543,
-0.1784694195,
-0.1273007244,
0.3828501701,
-0.2635182738,
0.7801992893,
0.1775075495,
-0.1190645993,
-0.0324985795,
-0.3610650599,
0.5422659516,
0.1991233528,
-0.4587709606,
-0.0244780686,
0.959074378,
0.1443351656,
0.2962442935,
0.30313465,
-0.086375542,
0.2213193029,
0.3324664831,
0.1661010534,
-0.2415601462,
-0.4507209957,
-0.1196549013,
0.3483065367,
-0.2137120515,
-0.4804665446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16922v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16922v1
|
Mitigating Object Hallucinations in Large Vision-Language Models through Visual Contrastive Decoding
| 2023-11-28T16:26:35 | 2023-11-28T16:26:35 |
Sicong Leng, Hang Zhang, Guanzheng Chen, Xin Li, Shijian Lu, Chunyan Miao, Lidong Bing
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) have advanced considerably, intertwining
visual recognition and language understanding to generate content that is not
only coherent but also contextually attuned. Despite their success, LVLMs still
suffer from the issue of object hallucinations, where models generate plausible
yet incorrect outputs that include objects that do not exist in the images. To
mitigate this issue, we introduce Visual Contrastive Decoding (VCD), a simple
and training-free method that contrasts output distributions derived from
original and distorted visual inputs. The proposed VCD effectively reduces the
over-reliance on statistical bias and unimodal priors, two essential causes of
object hallucinations. This adjustment ensures the generated content is closely
grounded to visual inputs, resulting in contextually accurate outputs. Our
experiments show that VCD, without either additional training or the usage of
external tools, significantly mitigates the object hallucination issue across
different LVLM families. Beyond mitigating object hallucinations, VCD also
excels in general LVLM benchmarks, highlighting its wide-ranging applicability.
|
[
-0.3374496698,
-0.6488556266,
0.3901924789,
0.1292141229,
-0.6136431694,
-0.2161276489,
-0.1296769977,
-0.4799838066,
0.0889410228,
0.909004271,
-0.3572646677,
-0.4824298918,
-0.4321168959,
-0.080973953,
-0.4516837895,
0.5719538927,
0.0547975823,
0.365739733,
-0.4003858268,
-0.21367082,
-0.4273982048,
-0.8039517999,
-0.567930162,
-0.3217088282,
0.2889376283,
0.0085788984,
0.6112343073,
0.4914380014,
0.7766925693,
0.2129396945,
0.0517288782,
0.4520726204,
-0.6415522099,
0.0357817858,
-0.0932723507,
-0.156854853,
-0.1718695462,
-0.6972177029,
0.2970478833,
0.7719891667,
-0.2369699478,
-0.3117416203,
0.3019579947,
0.793379724,
-1.0854012966,
0.3865767717,
-0.6503357887,
0.4222683907,
0.1569518745,
-0.5421893001,
-0.6552781463,
0.1742915958,
-0.0783655718,
-0.6231509447,
0.4039215446,
-0.0619408228,
0.6433092952,
0.5536029935,
-0.2059891373,
-0.1221983731,
-0.6895354986,
0.6490668058,
-0.4164688885,
0.6732670069,
0.3902269304,
0.2222818136,
-0.1248970926,
-0.5098896027,
-0.5464989543,
-0.1937824935,
-0.1818513721,
0.3115046322,
-0.2020974904,
0.1388860494,
0.4156266153,
0.1388722509,
-0.5559342504,
0.1363681555,
-0.4846500754,
-0.169289723,
0.2455521971,
0.3330312073,
0.0769974068,
-0.0032120179,
-0.2935689092,
-0.514395833,
-0.6383740902,
-0.001066813,
-0.0207309723,
0.2066431046,
0.0324544646,
0.5741713047,
-0.3070862591,
0.558506608,
-0.1353266984,
0.001311666,
0.212204501,
-0.2514332831,
-0.4324140847,
0.0664087981,
0.490241915,
0.8983350992,
0.4841165841,
-0.3063461483,
-0.2595555782,
0.4306390882,
0.3706791997,
-0.9633133411,
-0.6045861244,
0.1137943119,
-0.6845332384,
-0.2580624521,
0.2208073288,
-0.9368289709,
-0.8552710414,
-0.2985733151,
0.4243965745,
-0.2405875623,
-0.2060010135,
0.3322358727,
-0.254896313,
0.3870067596,
0.4962714612,
-0.930285573,
0.3996016979,
0.3959105611,
0.7395980358,
-0.4551663399,
-0.302280575,
-0.9962966442,
0.1619950384,
-0.6697602868,
0.7518284917,
-0.4198029935,
-0.4566487372,
0.1935783178,
0.0013836257,
0.4648572505,
-0.9257256985,
0.2294241786,
-0.197309196,
-0.2477952838,
-0.2939761579,
-0.2024375647,
-0.0148128141,
0.1154450998,
-0.722286284,
0.6184695959,
0.0244720466,
-0.8232229352,
0.3670435548,
0.0039699525,
-0.366514653,
-0.0331961997,
-0.3248666823,
-0.5013859272,
0.4865322113,
0.480178833,
0.4926913083,
-0.1293537468,
0.0574722737,
-0.3389368355,
-0.5369268656,
0.0159163699,
-0.5179837346,
0.4574433863,
0.2530948222,
-0.2378112376,
0.3543388844,
-0.7610296011,
-0.2028654963,
0.2095514387,
0.0544972941,
-0.5275711417,
0.2629695237,
0.1067208648,
0.0062690275,
-0.081097953,
-0.0893234909,
-0.0955671892,
-0.1599902213,
0.032069087,
0.7262102365,
-0.095965445,
0.4228879809,
0.0028288555,
0.2063577026,
0.6143093109,
0.1416202635,
-0.2708093822,
-0.1160830483,
-0.9507600069,
-0.167907536,
-0.4749558866,
0.3488142192,
-1.2994494438,
0.3438753784,
0.0180866309,
-0.1292852163,
-0.4303683639,
0.1719244272,
0.4806153178,
0.6751217842,
0.5776664019,
-0.416698575,
-0.6386821866,
-0.9000629783,
0.1003001407,
0.0043017133,
-0.1563990563,
0.1488321126,
0.4575723112,
-0.3950585127,
0.5034309626,
-0.6053009629,
-0.6141884923,
0.0491496176,
-0.1579788178,
-0.2483754903,
0.3733610809,
0.3475565612,
-0.863312006,
-0.1777221113,
0.2689189315,
-0.9626170993,
-0.0532274581,
-0.1786905527,
-0.0741590187,
0.3909014463,
0.9069477916,
-0.3829759955,
0.6731958389,
0.4466001987,
-0.4250423014,
0.4560282528,
-0.4964193404,
0.0599449053,
-0.8354700208,
-0.2102322578,
-0.1570549905,
-0.1123512983,
-0.5299557447,
0.1965805888,
0.0783491433,
0.0260288473,
-0.4366385043,
0.4505650401,
-0.5706201196,
-0.2451899499,
-0.3660695553,
0.1611449718,
0.0636403337,
0.2711310387,
0.4835270643,
0.5100548863,
0.7796649337,
-0.4469839931,
0.4676268697,
0.0930214524,
-0.3025889099,
0.6638742089,
-0.4836045206,
-0.0812884718,
-0.4338100553,
0.162837714,
-0.6449126005,
-0.1271723956,
0.3690466583,
-0.0992676616,
0.1201174408,
0.1022951677,
-0.2503003478,
-0.2018555105,
-0.4456369579,
0.4357511103,
0.7022481561,
-0.9309534431,
0.5715078115,
0.0454462878,
0.378826797,
-0.6346007586,
-0.8720218539,
0.0960761905,
-0.0197619181,
-0.3023631275,
0.0974700302,
-0.3791323304,
-0.3495205641,
0.0306402184,
-0.2915329933,
-0.0850844234,
0.0479075797,
0.2088642269,
0.2177450508,
-0.3586798906,
0.0010187849,
-0.3734593093,
-0.0570444763,
0.1894061565,
-0.1220680326,
0.6909911633,
-0.0115146711,
-0.5929428935,
-0.187821269,
0.458362937,
0.5371043682,
-0.3146426082,
0.7606770396,
0.7573299408,
-0.4416835308,
-0.4734616876,
-0.5002304912,
-0.5095803738,
-0.4559690952,
0.758841753,
-0.4301169217,
-0.5253784657,
0.5214778185,
0.3690538704,
-0.3606169224,
0.0595726669,
0.5843149424,
0.1728324592,
0.9691019654,
0.5209237933,
0.2194761187,
0.5425157547,
-0.1121062934,
0.2138315886,
-0.834831059,
-0.5471255183,
-0.2606947422,
0.1474548578,
-0.460906744,
-0.7826070189,
0.0278079584,
0.1120673493,
0.1081684902,
-0.2180323452,
-0.6427812576,
0.9380534291,
0.5141983628,
0.3570508063,
0.3793458939,
0.2587020695,
0.2548204362,
-0.0961828604,
-0.4822759032,
-0.2010683119,
0.9548130035,
-0.0565624982,
1.084788084,
-0.1913510263,
0.6212389469,
0.196137473,
-0.0111533143,
-0.6833600402,
0.5752776265,
-0.4333147109,
0.1529467404,
-0.1092433408,
-0.4584993124,
-0.6611247659,
0.7295656204,
-0.4517599642,
-0.7668106556,
0.3732968569,
0.3386022449,
0.007937815,
0.4475946426,
-0.6530057788,
0.7930520177,
-0.1617222428,
-0.5311886668,
-0.0254831128,
-0.4683563113,
0.5446776152,
-0.0798202902,
-0.039794907,
0.3521906435,
0.1886032373,
0.3519918919,
-0.2037587017,
0.7868885994,
-0.0361787416,
-0.1313291639,
-0.0536554642,
0.1971630454,
0.6070921421,
-0.0720276609,
0.3720271289,
0.1655850708,
-0.2482173592,
-0.4746264517,
-0.6520811319,
0.7966088057,
-0.616202414,
-0.5878369808,
-0.3273266852,
-0.6580274701,
0.0604723208,
-0.0022325639,
0.4437598586,
0.4179544449,
-0.2338361442,
0.6543956995,
0.966324985,
-0.3426913619,
0.378777802,
0.2113204002,
-0.4110319316,
-0.2674185932,
0.9365178943,
-0.1516049504,
0.3241571784,
0.4420983493,
0.0194813479,
-0.1468358189,
-0.7015277147,
-0.1546648741,
-0.0365820862,
-1.1910364628,
-0.0167391356,
-0.6016237736,
-0.2062763423,
-0.3070490956,
-0.4475755095,
-0.4269647002,
0.1457810104,
-0.5195023417,
-0.0440033488,
-0.0567096062,
0.5900686979,
0.1407517791,
-0.0675174668,
-0.4170894623,
0.9370422363,
0.4041460156,
0.1594802737,
0.10646905,
-0.283390373,
-0.0529365502,
-0.0706467256,
0.0805295631,
-0.5959647894,
0.6097002029,
-0.1560434997,
0.3976813555,
0.5912974477,
0.337569952,
0.8997222185,
-0.4378714263,
0.80732584,
0.4978057146,
-0.8794000149,
0.2322045863,
0.0806113258,
0.2511988878,
0.1190439686,
-0.1298760176,
-0.3480720818,
-0.3962991834,
-0.2175084054,
-0.9077277184,
0.4703963995,
0.2426367253,
0.0566276237,
-0.0054494841,
-0.0722038895,
0.1436037719,
0.140998438,
-0.9621908069,
0.0575839169,
-0.6290391684,
-0.2030083388,
-0.2335887402,
-0.3248500228,
-0.1293007433,
-0.1615235358,
0.2413272262,
-0.1361646354,
0.1154626161,
0.3478986025,
-0.261384517,
-0.081957981,
-0.0911747664,
0.8853209019,
0.6436346173,
-0.2975821197,
0.6184538007,
0.1109657735,
-0.4722599089,
-0.1662854999,
-0.302303195,
-0.0981801525,
-0.070252724,
0.4378247261,
1.0712900162,
-0.1358755678,
-0.8600586653,
0.5177299976,
-0.1234469712,
-0.1371832043,
-0.2753633857,
0.1508205533,
-0.005898145,
0.4306681454,
0.2919453382,
0.1362017691,
0.1091071218,
-0.4257344902,
0.1046581492,
0.6223346591,
-0.4432067871,
-0.0826025084,
0.8284390569,
0.013624372,
-0.3688566089,
0.6303079724,
0.0686261728,
-0.2687908411,
0.7100182176,
0.7869204283,
0.9655252099,
0.0069394778,
-0.0177322384,
0.0535802655,
0.4241780043,
-0.324526459,
0.1027555019,
-0.0531132221,
-0.7946586609,
-0.0973262936,
-0.5456683636,
-0.4218224287,
0.2749712169,
-0.901920557,
0.2769343257,
-0.3106470704,
0.4838697016,
-0.348265022,
-0.5973718166,
-0.59714818,
0.1929799765,
0.3290398717,
0.4918240309,
-0.8788461685,
0.8698167205,
0.3366048634,
-0.4283057451,
-0.3128114045,
0.1950467527,
-0.2984929085,
-0.6527352333,
0.5888592601,
0.1903437525,
-0.4648936689,
-0.1476144791,
-0.5019533038,
-0.2457425147,
0.854536593,
0.4196655154,
-0.6181918979,
0.146671921,
0.0348524041,
0.5681523681,
-0.5932959318,
-0.1002829522,
0.4904458821,
0.2727814019,
0.214505583,
-0.4146910608,
0.1556707621,
-0.2668905556,
0.2412444949,
0.0975753516,
-0.2462913394,
0.8486420512,
-0.3697256148,
-0.0240528546,
0.036560785,
0.5082937479,
0.2601909339,
0.420832932,
0.4061957598,
0.3519147336,
0.6678111553,
-0.0901476294,
1.0516065359,
-0.1054538712,
0.1982633471,
1.0933059454,
-0.3364068568,
0.9131686091,
0.8967425227,
0.2809866369,
0.017201025,
0.2361102104,
-0.2142914981,
0.8382403255,
0.1922444105,
-0.1883578897,
-0.3879489303,
-0.126121074,
-0.5354951024,
0.349825114,
0.1753799915,
-0.2833867669,
-0.1091399789,
0.3476463854,
-0.3464433551,
0.2059051394,
-0.5051540136,
0.7210868597,
0.1140002906,
-0.5099572539,
0.8434050679,
-0.5116845369,
0.6655765176,
-0.3854795694,
-0.319524318,
-0.4837672412,
0.5076380968,
-0.1876912415,
-0.5505341291,
0.2285722941,
-0.0638563931,
-0.3092534542,
-0.0967588723,
0.6154420376,
-0.6985115409,
-0.3370113969,
0.6051815748,
0.2387088537,
0.0864107013,
-0.3633160889,
-0.1161448807,
0.3389398456,
0.0419437587,
-0.0321087614,
0.395829469,
0.4702717364,
-0.2383165359,
0.5518122911,
0.5519649982,
0.1330041438,
-0.02087209,
0.2712944448,
0.9198292494,
-0.7583039403,
-0.4405899644,
-0.9584905505,
0.4404947758,
-0.1528452784,
-0.015591695,
0.496886909,
0.4065298438,
1.0603904724,
-0.6390129328,
0.3975283504,
0.4667892158,
-0.2456459403,
-0.9065620303,
0.7051958442,
-0.7977000475,
0.3984137475,
-0.3875527382,
-1.0943932533,
-0.6846325994,
0.7911209464,
0.2213571072,
-0.154156208,
0.9736441374,
0.9563687444,
-0.1660935134,
-0.5107607841,
0.8762415648,
0.3678653836,
0.3484277725,
0.5673613548,
0.9238704443,
-0.2183723301,
0.7783708572,
-0.3151218891,
0.1032303125,
-0.5047085881,
-0.9683226347,
-1.1754095554,
-0.5043280125,
-0.2767586708,
-0.4035725892,
0.297752291,
0.5801962018,
0.6165887117,
-0.8673869371,
-0.2046067119,
-0.3116361797,
0.0841053948,
-0.1464462578,
-0.2052320838,
0.4155656993,
-0.1559249163,
-0.7215675712,
0.2167540193,
0.5365461707,
0.2775443494,
-0.3475471735,
-0.3700878024,
0.490634501,
-0.0214375816,
0.8548623919,
-0.0119770644,
-1.1394420862,
-0.3525414467,
0.0261992905,
-0.2234831452,
0.2992593646,
0.709679842,
-0.9037882686,
0.7288057208,
0.5475060344,
0.4981756806,
0.4801740646,
-0.028454639,
0.2857477665,
-0.6126244664,
0.686504662,
0.0106659895,
0.5051220059,
0.4867186546,
-0.2584397495,
0.5067492723,
0.2507287562,
-0.1281663775,
-1.0606708527,
0.3914713562,
-1.3185601234,
-0.6381731629,
1.1054764986,
0.1650577635,
-0.2183908671,
-0.0130428122,
-0.6188803911,
-0.0164798573,
-0.1485243291,
0.9837338924,
0.5274964571,
0.2325599045,
-0.4808442295,
-0.3425845802,
0.6118125319,
0.3426188231,
-0.9477079511,
0.4391565621,
0.7516305447,
-0.1172509193,
0.0229638163,
0.4223503768,
0.0777837113,
0.5028834939,
0.3296215236,
0.2639181912,
-0.1853555888,
-0.5431430936,
-0.4238300025,
0.3226881921,
-0.0925422758,
-0.2281516343
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03739v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03739v1
|
Syntax-Informed Interactive Model for Comprehensive Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis
| 2023-11-28T16:03:22 | 2023-11-28T16:03:22 |
Ullman Galen, Frey Lee, Woods Ali
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aspect-based sentiment analysis (ABSA), a nuanced task in text analysis,
seeks to discern sentiment orientation linked to specific aspect terms in text.
Traditional approaches often overlook or inadequately model the explicit
syntactic structures of sentences, crucial for effective aspect term
identification and sentiment determination. Addressing this gap, we introduce
an innovative model: Syntactic Dependency Enhanced Multi-Task Interaction
Architecture (SDEMTIA) for comprehensive ABSA. Our approach innovatively
exploits syntactic knowledge (dependency relations and types) using a
specialized Syntactic Dependency Embedded Interactive Network (SDEIN). We also
incorporate a novel and efficient message-passing mechanism within a multi-task
learning framework to bolster learning efficacy. Our extensive experiments on
benchmark datasets showcase our model's superiority, significantly surpassing
existing methods. Additionally, incorporating BERT as an auxiliary feature
extractor further enhances our model's performance.
|
[
-0.428697139,
-1.0781470537,
0.8484724164,
0.4402912855,
-0.4529420435,
0.2184009999,
-0.0864128992,
-0.4892406464,
0.6732065678,
0.60340482,
-0.6629042029,
-0.7301440835,
-0.4685833156,
-0.0650033504,
-0.0924514905,
1.0340117216,
-0.0505482741,
0.0864175186,
-0.3842223585,
-0.3657723069,
-0.268037051,
-0.5643512011,
-0.31338346,
-0.2132733613,
0.3849116862,
0.2855785191,
0.4076969326,
0.2069340646,
0.5970184207,
0.3456599414,
-0.1813304275,
0.0891860053,
0.1169843227,
0.367264986,
-0.3326072395,
-0.7149872184,
-0.6584720612,
-0.2020209283,
0.2823033035,
0.9404481053,
-0.1883245856,
-0.018133264,
0.133793354,
0.7132388353,
-0.4510510564,
0.5132710934,
-0.5656730533,
-0.2657697797,
-0.2101641744,
0.1994642317,
-0.4342050552,
-0.0328881629,
0.1546798348,
-0.4172751606,
-0.0399554521,
-0.3461179137,
0.8128566742,
0.2196443975,
-0.4340627193,
-0.3616323769,
-0.5975054502,
0.7636145353,
-0.6461385489,
0.3102465272,
-0.0285299104,
-0.1718237549,
0.2166654319,
-0.5956314206,
-0.5785683393,
-0.1509855986,
-0.0220442247,
0.4097980261,
-0.1570285112,
0.4844637513,
-0.0733616054,
0.3335548341,
-0.1928368956,
0.1285737008,
-0.0821047574,
0.2281420082,
0.4075211585,
0.1060178578,
0.2405987978,
-0.7063311338,
-0.4873006344,
0.2354913801,
-0.6110097766,
0.3828724623,
0.3831437528,
0.5759135485,
-0.2211887985,
0.5261420012,
-0.2857394814,
0.5702205896,
0.0717092454,
0.1408014745,
0.47309798,
-0.4298663735,
-0.1981195956,
-0.2539018393,
0.8868277669,
0.1031955481,
-0.3320903182,
0.065549545,
-0.3765248954,
0.1327546239,
0.5719717741,
-0.5651881695,
-0.2148027718,
0.655233562,
-0.4540987313,
-0.3101174533,
0.2202847302,
-1.0478764772,
-0.4667387009,
-0.6613413095,
0.3045129478,
-0.6062447429,
-0.3778322935,
-0.3644534945,
0.0694059283,
-0.0410014316,
0.4900857508,
-0.6046544909,
0.0753909424,
0.8312303424,
0.8787298203,
-0.1754988283,
-0.1089238524,
-0.2933255136,
-0.1485967636,
-0.084246397,
0.9958418012,
-0.8454068303,
-0.2087478191,
-0.0693169385,
-0.2633964121,
-0.1616398096,
-0.3352343738,
0.4605955482,
-0.4052675962,
-0.0994316265,
-0.2967646122,
-0.4631429017,
-0.764921248,
0.2941243649,
-0.9512609839,
0.9817100763,
0.181500569,
-0.8092003465,
0.3170348704,
-0.9070624709,
-0.4731534123,
0.0587178506,
-0.213971734,
-0.3518446684,
0.3960653245,
0.4188403487,
0.5962231159,
-0.0278063007,
0.3513084054,
-0.5488208532,
0.2119231671,
0.3697824776,
-0.1321392208,
0.5843364596,
0.0044591492,
-0.1868027002,
0.5929529667,
-0.7741000056,
-0.2099448293,
-0.1519862711,
-0.0463275351,
-0.7310913801,
0.0545533448,
0.0226855595,
0.2168625444,
0.5738524795,
-0.7101914883,
0.2027987391,
-0.5224965811,
0.3506558537,
0.6171346903,
0.3612962365,
0.5133858919,
0.0464003943,
0.6296936274,
0.3030455112,
0.3133319616,
-0.4038072228,
-0.1778620481,
-0.8086974025,
-0.561211586,
0.1850073338,
0.4737563133,
-1.0471355915,
0.6636248231,
-0.1075722948,
-0.4568911493,
-0.6778661013,
0.261547327,
0.2773091197,
0.0929108933,
0.2135963589,
-0.6639384627,
-0.49741593,
-0.8737398982,
0.0208828095,
-0.3819851577,
0.3920788765,
0.1777243614,
0.3774248362,
0.0626066029,
1.1168260574,
-0.3677206039,
-0.4123201966,
-1.0177493095,
0.3650514185,
0.3187918067,
0.0737842992,
0.8236622214,
-0.7780388594,
-0.3738493919,
0.0594998412,
-0.7570505738,
-0.1183868125,
-0.3406679928,
-0.0579008758,
0.1247732341,
0.1465510577,
-0.8206109405,
0.2495470047,
0.5440990925,
-0.1016248986,
0.3560824096,
0.1654703468,
-0.0111039057,
-1.3044595718,
0.1121976674,
0.31721434,
-0.0932463333,
-0.6675952077,
0.4811249077,
0.0611049943,
0.1462807655,
-0.4365948141,
0.2737161517,
-0.2677113414,
0.0892185792,
-0.446700424,
0.0767887905,
0.2764953673,
0.7968472242,
0.1550561935,
0.4896065295,
0.5729037523,
-0.273531884,
0.2200568914,
0.1412764937,
-0.1064373851,
0.7278438807,
-0.6208522916,
0.0658490583,
-0.1444816142,
0.0766450241,
-0.8322872519,
-0.1302662939,
0.2133141905,
-0.3259586096,
0.290707171,
-0.1479981542,
-0.4016094208,
0.082123436,
-0.4938474596,
0.1022943407,
-0.0267656147,
-0.4434667528,
1.1882858276,
0.5241369605,
-0.6471945643,
-0.5777773857,
-0.1425699145,
0.0340250954,
-0.1402718276,
-0.2538414598,
0.1989966482,
0.2498203218,
-0.5080571771,
-0.0125193167,
0.0499599315,
-0.1823407263,
0.2051475197,
0.5163095593,
0.4520824254,
0.0291865226,
0.0891478658,
0.4572421014,
0.1504116803,
0.2023746222,
0.1890180558,
0.6262842417,
-0.1959931701,
-0.3614355028,
-0.5619547367,
0.6567375064,
0.6901012659,
-0.7022206187,
0.6674129963,
0.3457124531,
-0.2246058136,
-0.321744144,
-0.3315400183,
-0.0809629112,
-0.4095770717,
0.7458461523,
-0.2972217798,
-0.5545482039,
0.5672441125,
-0.0705703944,
0.2234978378,
0.2631776035,
0.3919912279,
-0.1066356674,
0.8713526726,
0.8746736646,
-0.0803643838,
0.7373022437,
-0.2333586663,
0.1974367499,
-1.0809531212,
-0.3115870357,
-0.3918347359,
-0.0791942105,
-0.1790422201,
-0.1382071674,
0.376463145,
0.3057844639,
0.1153606847,
0.262086004,
-0.2235916406,
0.0385283716,
0.4432032704,
0.421326071,
0.1529787928,
-0.3133568764,
-0.0803269148,
-0.0344637372,
-0.2586258054,
-0.432451874,
1.027930975,
0.4724825621,
0.6350645423,
0.1716720015,
0.7985684872,
0.1421214491,
0.481334269,
-1.0316987038,
0.6393953562,
-0.3116991818,
-0.1834637821,
0.0254522897,
-0.288449645,
-0.5735766292,
0.3667185307,
-0.2421871126,
-0.8005047441,
0.1048585325,
-0.0583610088,
-0.3760003448,
0.1504671276,
-0.65414083,
0.6577828526,
-0.2659803331,
-0.3400537074,
-0.3541722,
-0.5050863028,
0.2521433234,
-0.0679387674,
0.3290164173,
-0.1460594237,
-0.0796642527,
0.5325514674,
-0.2192418128,
1.4153751135,
-0.3680889308,
0.0560186468,
0.2524088323,
0.0907462016,
0.3644742668,
0.1230408922,
-0.1746367961,
0.3685855865,
-0.2295093983,
-0.0555570498,
-0.715585351,
0.6032702327,
-0.6738868356,
-0.5290833116,
-0.3075670302,
-0.567640245,
-0.3045421541,
0.198409766,
-0.171755895,
0.4983482957,
-0.2435653955,
0.008695012,
0.395057559,
-0.0554090403,
0.5918007493,
0.4530549049,
-0.2571256757,
-0.4875077307,
0.7295501828,
-0.0351212546,
0.1413862258,
0.6920144558,
-0.1440600455,
-0.2641145587,
-0.6047686934,
-0.5275384188,
0.2776516974,
-0.7646984458,
-0.1947036982,
-0.8946964145,
-0.1110826805,
-0.1679486185,
0.0100400448,
-0.5421664715,
-0.3696163297,
-0.2847808301,
-0.3699004352,
0.4051476121,
1.0770637989,
0.303694874,
0.5640904307,
-0.9474998116,
0.0171941854,
-0.1543013453,
0.1703173071,
0.1027937457,
0.0090713706,
-0.1772540361,
-0.2216228098,
-0.606605947,
-1.1452208757,
0.4564508498,
0.1764755696,
0.653793931,
0.5139591098,
0.0769973397,
0.2429078668,
-0.1315536648,
0.9833294153,
0.1563460976,
-1.260191679,
0.671769321,
-0.0876378119,
0.2808668315,
0.6138134599,
0.3400586843,
-0.148581937,
-0.7614585161,
-0.5046610236,
-1.107407093,
0.5440143347,
-0.0195738412,
0.102164112,
-0.0149193658,
0.3720788956,
0.5164161325,
0.396795541,
-0.7693251967,
-0.0850548223,
-0.1994243562,
-0.6134314537,
0.3096186221,
-0.0610062964,
0.0414022543,
-0.0449346863,
0.6093912721,
-0.2984345555,
0.0915472358,
0.0736504197,
-0.2614740729,
0.2558870912,
0.407476604,
0.0546854287,
0.7487086654,
-0.0116595207,
0.0727135763,
-0.0661210343,
-0.4751790166,
-0.2725627422,
0.2250425965,
-0.1955953687,
0.1746861786,
0.5288500786,
0.9712079763,
0.1853447109,
-0.473062396,
0.6424241662,
0.1050657332,
0.2546364367,
-0.2132827193,
-0.0805819705,
-0.0564112365,
0.2680748105,
0.2623684704,
0.2784893811,
0.2885574996,
-0.5493697524,
0.2607539892,
0.5632280111,
-0.7815095782,
-0.7121122479,
0.3877485394,
0.5098991394,
0.221385166,
0.4126541615,
-0.20419994,
-0.7444072962,
0.6077386141,
-0.0348301157,
0.9063056111,
-0.3745075464,
0.5752198696,
0.1591771245,
0.2706085145,
0.2804369926,
0.5858320594,
-0.0812710822,
-0.6522477269,
-0.637606442,
-0.8265779614,
-0.5928662419,
-0.2014724463,
-1.0093170404,
0.1767723411,
-0.4024791718,
-0.1916915625,
0.2646890581,
-0.1857004613,
-0.5219517946,
0.0592811853,
-0.1677001119,
0.610989213,
-1.0196551085,
0.8784264326,
1.1189641953,
-0.7730410099,
-0.6599223614,
0.1117449179,
-0.0372100845,
-0.5299651623,
0.266189456,
0.5008230805,
0.0887668952,
-0.3792285621,
-0.335978359,
-0.609097302,
0.8151028156,
0.0826904625,
-0.3553866148,
0.1725929528,
0.0228588395,
0.6390570402,
-0.558172524,
0.4762067795,
0.4617868662,
0.1162216663,
-0.0360243022,
-0.8280909061,
0.0823787972,
-0.394339323,
-0.0227696449,
0.5684686303,
-0.6400107145,
0.7693353295,
-0.1144938543,
0.0577655397,
0.0307485685,
1.0321536064,
0.0649772733,
0.2975264192,
0.6961607337,
0.4928455353,
0.4459736049,
-0.0829766616,
0.8165192604,
-0.48823452,
0.2752597928,
1.0612878799,
-0.5075181127,
1.1585218906,
0.5052797198,
-0.0685928687,
0.9548239112,
0.511259079,
0.2940354049,
0.5540097356,
-0.3712847531,
-0.3974189162,
-0.2952065468,
-0.4202797711,
0.0972161815,
0.6896095276,
0.7222003341,
-0.3750102818,
-0.2256908119,
0.3028669655,
0.1469448209,
0.1766995639,
-0.3796230555,
0.9985942245,
0.1736732572,
-0.6148152351,
-0.3978522122,
-0.0414761975,
0.6405233145,
-0.7258485556,
-0.1770477742,
-0.1934270859,
0.1632907093,
-0.2642214,
-1.1467387676,
0.468808651,
-0.1251647621,
-0.2194998711,
0.0134106902,
0.4570790231,
-0.4098003209,
-0.5365844369,
0.3950504363,
0.6658290029,
-0.2191039771,
-0.3237453699,
-0.724812746,
0.1227971166,
0.0760971233,
-0.3831649721,
0.3297658861,
0.4953071177,
-0.0691132247,
0.452126205,
0.417881906,
0.1166242361,
-0.5482507348,
0.2779290676,
1.0378394127,
-0.590076983,
-0.8002083302,
-0.7309193015,
0.5348501801,
-0.267121911,
-0.2238396108,
0.6065863967,
0.3492915332,
0.5152623057,
0.1989758015,
1.0579534769,
-0.2773501277,
0.495693922,
-0.6157144904,
0.5742548108,
-0.4539391696,
0.4577517807,
-0.2896313071,
-0.9468662739,
-0.2164536715,
0.2380888313,
-0.3032118976,
0.0392751843,
0.8455315232,
0.5084923506,
-0.0236835536,
0.3191661537,
-0.1259721518,
0.3001583219,
0.3710207045,
0.3193634748,
0.6773537993,
0.1804741174,
0.2002071589,
-0.7411626577,
-0.6582003832,
0.0978682712,
-0.7816154957,
-0.9200332165,
-0.6939831972,
-0.3911898732,
-0.1889961064,
-0.150683865,
1.1400226355,
0.4375338852,
-0.739708364,
0.0567358583,
0.010472483,
0.1055289209,
-0.5139006972,
-0.3573876023,
0.472561717,
-0.4791142344,
-0.8192727566,
0.2710391879,
0.543838501,
-0.3597997129,
-0.4947780371,
0.5402920246,
-0.0498440862,
0.2966504395,
0.702314496,
-0.0951238051,
-0.6751391292,
-0.243119821,
-0.0568887331,
0.1308787614,
0.0997042954,
0.7534708977,
-0.5847635865,
0.4785729945,
0.4351157546,
0.4721446633,
0.0005273262,
0.2353254557,
0.5742679834,
-0.9285132885,
0.1236778349,
0.247292161,
0.5579589605,
0.4157471061,
-0.5443333983,
0.1678615808,
0.0968057364,
-0.2008290887,
-0.5213161707,
0.3039743006,
-1.4660933018,
-0.4682776928,
1.1183041334,
-0.507013917,
-0.28148368,
-0.2462185472,
-0.3001237512,
-0.0662946552,
-0.6679339409,
0.7355078459,
0.5143916011,
-0.4301447272,
-0.243847087,
-0.3314965069,
0.0634718016,
0.3769509494,
-1.1363523006,
0.0304709729,
0.481855005,
0.0683592036,
0.3098314703,
0.342769593,
-0.0125082517,
0.0292059928,
-0.1799125522,
0.4641964436,
-0.0961519554,
-0.6025465131,
-0.3753810227,
0.4422458708,
0.1255054027,
-0.2212722301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16882v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16882v1
|
Optimisation-Based Multi-Modal Semantic Image Editing
| 2023-11-28T15:31:11 | 2023-11-28T15:31:11 |
Bowen Li, Yongxin Yang, Steven McDonagh, Shifeng Zhang, Petru-Daniel Tudosiu, Sarah Parisot
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Image editing affords increased control over the aesthetics and content of
generated images. Pre-existing works focus predominantly on text-based
instructions to achieve desired image modifications, which limit edit precision
and accuracy. In this work, we propose an inference-time editing optimisation,
designed to extend beyond textual edits to accommodate multiple editing
instruction types (e.g. spatial layout-based; pose, scribbles, edge maps). We
propose to disentangle the editing task into two competing subtasks: successful
local image modifications and global content consistency preservation, where
subtasks are guided through two dedicated loss functions. By allowing to adjust
the influence of each loss function, we build a flexible editing solution that
can be adjusted to user preferences. We evaluate our method using text, pose
and scribble edit conditions, and highlight our ability to achieve complex
edits, through both qualitative and quantitative experiments.
|
[
-0.2423250973,
-0.9541087151,
0.74845016,
0.1672695726,
-0.3353134096,
-0.2132001519,
-0.2662316263,
-0.6398163438,
0.3303862512,
0.3371374607,
-0.9190101624,
-0.6848142147,
-0.7086320519,
0.2143229693,
0.0039131115,
0.3415185511,
-0.4551049173,
-0.0022118252,
-0.1899753809,
-0.3396520317,
-0.7855821252,
0.0396371074,
-0.6582339406,
0.0809334964,
0.6404179931,
0.3971542716,
1.1240864992,
0.5880748034,
0.4737888575,
0.3203814626,
-0.300142616,
0.7856273055,
-0.2398217916,
0.1553164423,
-0.7117363214,
-0.3565984964,
-0.3109332621,
-0.1223615482,
0.3016555309,
0.1521694064,
0.1021881029,
-0.0544472188,
-0.1588657349,
0.708894968,
-1.0991793871,
-0.0247795768,
-0.549017787,
0.240573898,
-0.0565612689,
-0.2092299461,
-0.3367006779,
-0.1254309118,
-0.1572868079,
-1.2066986561,
0.0831661671,
-0.2126823217,
0.6932179332,
0.6827635169,
-0.265757829,
-0.1795739532,
-0.4709430337,
0.7610425353,
-0.4041613638,
0.4155927598,
0.2061426044,
0.1046324074,
-0.1897212267,
-0.49550879,
-0.563224256,
0.4135879278,
-0.1678853929,
0.367175132,
-0.1822004914,
0.3565565348,
0.1050663441,
0.1532139331,
-0.2102821022,
0.0215956736,
-0.0083788252,
-0.2753728032,
0.4547044039,
0.1296390593,
0.529235363,
-0.1266983151,
-0.2336798459,
0.1312490106,
-0.3105556965,
0.0842928886,
0.2772512436,
-0.2184081078,
0.2411489934,
0.8298005462,
-0.2516115904,
0.7397899628,
0.200144276,
-0.4841072857,
-0.1018393114,
-0.3751816452,
0.0064141084,
-0.0828593448,
0.5020951033,
0.982930541,
-0.173818022,
-0.2537948489,
-0.0982480422,
0.3548281193,
0.0082004145,
-0.6893959045,
-0.0353569426,
0.2199326009,
-0.5480571985,
-0.2754035592,
-0.1816781014,
-0.3783364892,
-0.2812226117,
-0.5422122478,
0.6019079089,
-0.5643724799,
0.2522398829,
0.6273992658,
-0.4864732325,
-0.1904713959,
0.852553606,
-0.5419940352,
-0.1335676759,
0.1757712215,
0.8338360786,
-0.0010838866,
-0.3785510361,
-0.3114958704,
0.5550249219,
-0.4406110644,
0.8714283109,
-0.7168774605,
-0.4994390011,
-0.2734585106,
0.1508317441,
0.062381018,
-0.2317377478,
0.376770854,
-0.6949832439,
0.2373722494,
-0.2666800618,
-0.4161545932,
-0.2599381506,
0.0549371205,
-0.9087429643,
0.9973567128,
0.0927494019,
-0.7890886068,
0.7244500518,
-0.8566181064,
-0.5215750933,
-0.2913766503,
0.1539176404,
-0.318739742,
0.0657201707,
0.5766574144,
0.2474555224,
0.0499374829,
-0.0440169051,
-0.2875921726,
-0.3173542023,
-0.0851044655,
-0.104339622,
0.2499795705,
-0.0070596319,
-0.3290965557,
0.3844594061,
-0.6457121372,
0.1540926546,
-0.0580234639,
-0.4926514328,
-0.4111160338,
0.0396707244,
0.1322037727,
0.532815814,
0.3856991529,
-0.8974328637,
0.5461243987,
0.1145131886,
0.5178880095,
0.6715373397,
0.269302696,
0.5577880144,
-0.3266172111,
0.4150003791,
0.0559010133,
0.4161146581,
-0.229668349,
-0.3171421289,
-0.5598063469,
-0.855130434,
0.3902437687,
0.7127656341,
-1.081786871,
0.1319983155,
-0.1062085405,
-0.3787895441,
-0.4569611847,
0.3392550945,
0.3389030397,
0.3734895289,
0.4420000017,
-0.4555007219,
-0.0643340945,
-1.2261286974,
-0.4798022211,
0.56035918,
0.1050219089,
0.1421957612,
0.2602654397,
-0.4433331788,
0.7939229608,
-0.5037018657,
-0.37512362,
0.0947376415,
0.1891507655,
-0.2219876349,
0.5501660109,
0.7263256907,
-0.8497305512,
-0.3426985145,
-0.0731394589,
-0.5761578083,
-0.0766877905,
-0.6603221297,
-0.5759916902,
0.3815097511,
0.3513723612,
-0.9421192408,
0.9551391602,
0.1581706554,
-0.2378762066,
0.5825895667,
-0.5169907212,
0.8042684197,
-0.6985813975,
-0.4907180667,
-0.0148126595,
-0.1887085736,
-0.1147785112,
0.1298218966,
0.3514562249,
-0.0420006476,
-0.568631947,
0.2778225243,
-0.5426405668,
0.0195389111,
0.0059094429,
-0.0549274907,
0.5581282973,
0.5183516145,
0.2640034854,
0.4781083763,
0.6184281707,
-0.148958087,
0.1035130471,
0.4039142728,
-0.3230699897,
0.9205057025,
-0.6449427009,
0.4085716307,
-0.3565392196,
0.192911908,
-1.0275607109,
-0.3018930852,
0.1084889919,
0.0354049765,
0.1991181225,
-0.0492158905,
-0.6554903984,
0.151091814,
-0.4165367186,
0.3891365826,
-0.1783800572,
-0.4982906282,
1.0033680201,
-0.0385362282,
-0.0206044056,
-0.5618745685,
-0.6939737201,
0.3111839592,
-0.0400465876,
-1.1554226875,
0.8331702948,
0.2334844619,
-0.1609591097,
0.4989364743,
-0.1050890833,
-0.1669630855,
-0.3110792041,
0.1213777512,
0.3267715573,
0.1132606715,
-0.1049420536,
0.6537765265,
-0.168025583,
-0.6064741015,
-0.1701939553,
-0.1320904195,
0.1454415172,
-0.5973459482,
-1.0445538759,
0.8124690056,
0.7607862949,
-0.6038066149,
0.5070049167,
0.6713972688,
-0.240057826,
-0.0382325612,
-0.4701788425,
0.1873065531,
-0.4617651999,
0.466414541,
-0.5377726555,
-0.6558275819,
0.579888761,
-0.2723381519,
0.3518693149,
0.3225598037,
0.274848491,
-0.250592351,
0.869983077,
0.4704270065,
0.5976824164,
0.5116741657,
-0.278991878,
-0.0461308956,
-0.7119189501,
-0.1298798919,
-0.0276523549,
-0.7511895895,
-0.3052101731,
-0.742931366,
0.6330279112,
0.0891401768,
0.0769007206,
0.1488344967,
-0.5577287674,
0.8799485564,
0.6146361828,
0.8956608772,
0.2397405803,
-0.1628522724,
0.0773114488,
-0.3150633276,
-0.7748979926,
-0.2324470878,
0.6723349094,
-0.1568974853,
1.1037824154,
0.1197695062,
0.5397033095,
0.3653796911,
-0.1039450914,
-0.7892832756,
0.3312810659,
-0.2921779752,
-0.5755909085,
-0.489577204,
0.0732840523,
-0.5671316385,
0.3588783145,
-0.5799825788,
-0.3699936271,
0.3557751179,
0.2355638891,
-0.0800158381,
0.4502287209,
-1.0366712809,
1.0635857582,
-0.2014988959,
-0.7161584496,
-0.4578252733,
-0.6704057455,
0.0981007591,
0.0290194172,
0.445705235,
-0.0083968723,
-0.4231649339,
0.1120017245,
-0.521199882,
0.6996183991,
-0.2027592659,
0.1977233887,
0.2753831744,
0.5352388024,
0.3524782062,
-0.0074337488,
0.0086495951,
0.053558059,
0.3833498359,
-0.4211767614,
-0.9398177862,
0.3046661615,
-0.5316143632,
-0.2713326514,
0.0852182209,
-0.7587928176,
-0.0739440173,
0.2210727334,
0.2737925351,
0.842056036,
0.0560458265,
0.162979871,
0.4593439102,
-0.4107543528,
0.6090096235,
0.0146578345,
0.1428116858,
-0.4895205796,
0.5383975506,
0.1041534618,
0.4681278169,
0.4003948271,
0.2372430563,
-0.32665658,
-0.3807540834,
-0.8556057811,
-0.149165079,
-1.0856983662,
0.060534548,
-0.3175762594,
0.5343116522,
-0.2120634466,
-0.826059103,
-0.4970700741,
-0.7821643353,
-0.1514462829,
0.3507006764,
0.2933754325,
0.6667900681,
-0.2968478799,
0.2116329074,
-0.6622404456,
0.664952755,
0.2752518952,
0.3920288384,
-0.4568177462,
-0.1659317017,
0.0004891396,
-0.1448001415,
-0.2453173399,
-0.8977062702,
-0.0482698232,
0.618475914,
0.434997946,
0.0370694511,
-0.1350607723,
1.0210243464,
-0.4841426015,
0.6283496618,
0.2131334096,
-1.0215457678,
0.7556141019,
-0.3251014054,
0.5861003399,
0.4806259274,
0.1404862255,
-0.6554998755,
-0.1651354283,
-0.4376581609,
-0.8441710472,
0.5389639139,
0.0262274556,
-0.0344074331,
0.2901081741,
0.627628088,
0.2139736116,
-0.0386070572,
-0.386397332,
-0.0318844765,
-0.4845943153,
-0.115564391,
0.3975801766,
-0.2156778723,
-0.3074235022,
-0.4885315001,
0.6700513959,
-0.1481759846,
-0.1178868935,
0.4952019751,
-0.3574310243,
0.0654413924,
0.2765421271,
0.5685060024,
0.8679094911,
0.1856396794,
-0.0215837341,
0.1956321299,
-0.316834718,
0.2342141718,
-0.2942931056,
-0.3858005106,
0.0818554685,
0.3563306034,
0.7349069715,
0.4203388989,
-0.4425260425,
0.2978395224,
-0.1919470578,
-0.4493239522,
0.1854552776,
0.1760311723,
-0.0144207319,
0.268012017,
-0.1600392461,
0.6089940071,
0.3132315874,
-0.1844813973,
0.0725553632,
0.2942675352,
-0.0383001231,
-0.0143939825,
0.8207554817,
-0.0742278844,
-0.1703852266,
0.2214638889,
-0.1999921054,
-0.2323576808,
0.3483017385,
0.2606967986,
0.7133525014,
0.065323934,
0.3096550405,
0.2007480115,
0.2550712824,
0.3521216512,
0.3670658767,
0.06656266,
-0.6156493425,
-0.6132918,
-0.1924035102,
-0.5616316795,
-0.3392986953,
-0.5753402114,
0.428558439,
-0.4467944801,
-0.1872463226,
0.3560202122,
-0.525008738,
-0.6068702936,
0.3969067335,
-0.1634865552,
0.8669813275,
-0.3343884349,
0.3233593404,
0.9234185815,
-0.1763612628,
-0.6290599704,
-0.3923582435,
0.2603868544,
-0.4558045864,
0.3398952484,
0.0580708124,
-0.602357626,
-0.2486586124,
-0.5233418345,
-0.6487826705,
0.9901368618,
0.5211045742,
-0.3042149842,
0.0142663093,
-0.1133415997,
0.2352426499,
-0.0454189032,
-0.0744325146,
0.4940440357,
0.6405216455,
0.3009629548,
-0.6693884134,
-0.1398406774,
-0.1868675947,
0.2558461428,
0.2173270583,
-0.659101963,
0.5718034506,
-0.2884428501,
-0.1250254959,
0.0762715191,
0.2787476778,
-0.3668833673,
-0.1611375362,
0.7391670346,
0.8771092296,
0.4086299539,
-0.1464725882,
0.8925540447,
-0.4883303046,
0.1497949809,
1.176451683,
0.1426006556,
0.380623281,
0.5227149725,
0.1591849476,
0.4538878202,
0.8894866109,
0.2130689025,
0.8419755697,
-0.2672654688,
-0.3722502887,
-0.5838640928,
0.0245584343,
-0.0361716449,
0.7212816477,
0.3513136804,
-0.1147082299,
-0.4577497244,
0.0682893693,
0.0746699274,
0.070738107,
-0.1595931947,
0.5562604666,
-0.538275063,
-0.3823560476,
0.1754435301,
0.4494258761,
0.5183330774,
-0.5208002925,
-0.0875022709,
0.1873720735,
-0.0456256755,
-0.5174686313,
-1.0378060341,
0.5386779904,
-0.3504626453,
-0.1944251657,
-0.2770227492,
0.9342365861,
-0.4436231554,
-0.5201986432,
0.081960611,
0.2351901978,
-0.2459357828,
-0.2031479627,
-0.8356759548,
0.2342156917,
-0.1577805579,
-0.4143979251,
0.013370757,
0.6511647105,
-0.1524865478,
0.3599877059,
0.6521955132,
-0.0859745815,
-0.0146504212,
0.0109655187,
0.7631064653,
-0.3557389081,
-0.5982499123,
-0.5930107236,
0.6919512153,
-0.0622712821,
-0.5691956878,
0.3896706402,
0.4248596132,
0.7928392887,
-0.3120670319,
0.7790620923,
-0.1725362986,
-0.0823821053,
-0.8446823359,
0.3934896886,
-0.703985393,
-0.4159242511,
-0.6398785114,
-0.7365835309,
-0.5491129756,
0.5451553464,
-0.4753575921,
-0.5193579197,
0.6710237265,
1.0704276562,
-0.115342252,
0.1108592451,
0.1518281102,
-0.415795505,
0.1997465938,
0.4143148065,
0.749497354,
-0.2108267993,
0.0097098667,
-0.8138795495,
-0.2109354734,
0.2952100933,
-0.9945918322,
-0.6150739193,
-0.477265507,
-0.4875867963,
0.0348380655,
-0.0120635368,
0.6572747827,
0.8567357063,
-0.3562368155,
0.5000274777,
0.2887335122,
0.1773812473,
-0.385694921,
-0.1527640969,
0.4219869375,
-0.1658781767,
-0.7291972637,
0.1956855357,
0.8350590467,
-0.1265998036,
0.150235787,
0.1391061544,
-0.220135808,
0.1246795878,
0.9596157074,
-0.0805599764,
-0.6904841065,
-0.538415134,
-0.036061123,
0.0326607972,
0.2118147612,
0.6912548542,
-0.1586564183,
0.9266485572,
0.3231540322,
0.8093835711,
0.4792674184,
0.1357418597,
0.0540387295,
-0.638974905,
0.5911366343,
-0.1854687482,
0.4624425471,
0.2749730349,
-0.5348047018,
0.4421659708,
0.3862214983,
-0.342766583,
-0.1281551123,
0.2031241357,
-1.066681385,
-0.5779650807,
0.9363020062,
-0.2181584984,
-0.2270152271,
0.0624991618,
-0.8155668378,
0.1529235989,
-0.0677227005,
0.5631837845,
0.828804791,
-0.7490552664,
-0.0690672323,
-0.3833408356,
0.225644514,
0.311699748,
-0.7115484476,
-0.2873593271,
1.2251833677,
0.296436131,
0.0925389826,
0.3985365629,
-0.3422118127,
0.7418181896,
0.0420069508,
0.3671966791,
-0.2629024982,
-0.4647515118,
0.1305256784,
0.0233743936,
-0.1843930483,
-0.4155958295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03738v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03738v1
|
Syntactic Fusion: Enhancing Aspect-Level Sentiment Analysis Through Multi-Tree Graph Integration
| 2023-11-28T15:28:22 | 2023-11-28T15:28:22 |
Jane Sunny, Tom Padraig, Roggie Terry, Woods Ali
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent progress in aspect-level sentiment classification has been propelled
by the incorporation of graph neural networks (GNNs) leveraging syntactic
structures, particularly dependency trees. Nevertheless, the performance of
these models is often hampered by the innate inaccuracies of parsing
algorithms. To mitigate this challenge, we introduce SynthFusion, an innovative
graph ensemble method that amalgamates predictions from multiple parsers. This
strategy blends diverse dependency relations prior to the application of GNNs,
enhancing robustness against parsing errors while avoiding extra computational
burdens. SynthFusion circumvents the pitfalls of overparameterization and
diminishes the risk of overfitting, prevalent in models with stacked GNN
layers, by optimizing graph connectivity. Our empirical evaluations on the
SemEval14 and Twitter14 datasets affirm that SynthFusion not only outshines
models reliant on single dependency trees but also eclipses alternative
ensemble techniques, achieving this without an escalation in model complexity.
|
[
-0.602648139,
-0.7432158589,
0.6970068216,
0.1620309204,
-0.1812615544,
0.6799272895,
0.0024352616,
-0.5196146369,
0.5649636388,
0.4861424863,
-0.623583138,
-0.6547803879,
-0.4407264888,
0.0944807753,
-0.3994752765,
1.0743713379,
-0.0831471086,
0.0753759369,
-0.5735608935,
-0.3547095954,
0.0165566038,
-0.4851123393,
-0.4713719189,
-0.2706494331,
0.6276150942,
-0.0255730208,
0.4722964168,
0.2227833718,
0.2460186481,
0.4520584643,
-0.0680896491,
0.3543667793,
-0.0710577071,
0.4903537929,
-0.0480981618,
-0.1505577564,
-0.4763693213,
-0.1682204157,
0.6831686497,
0.9414983392,
0.0380230248,
0.0134027386,
0.3746713102,
0.6176899076,
-0.6346942186,
0.2697515786,
-0.4640775323,
0.0303641632,
-0.0744256452,
0.2042683661,
-0.388430059,
-0.446864903,
0.3379581869,
-0.2808002234,
0.2308784723,
0.0176626779,
0.6112801433,
0.0715741962,
-0.2171676457,
0.3526664078,
-0.4168104231,
0.6761491299,
-0.7177644968,
0.2399874479,
-0.161314413,
0.2638191581,
-0.0129093174,
-0.7760542631,
-0.5620259643,
0.4596105814,
-0.1731461138,
0.3373235166,
-0.1937952936,
0.5636239648,
-0.2429925054,
0.596586287,
-0.393361181,
-0.1135135144,
-0.1905322969,
-0.4652271867,
0.221130833,
0.1076015458,
0.4364902675,
-0.6692310572,
-0.1286463439,
-0.2238182127,
-0.2618430257,
-0.0590361282,
0.4443926215,
0.779084444,
-0.1215757728,
0.4566992819,
-0.1198993474,
0.6782623529,
-0.0708914995,
0.0907406732,
0.5190393329,
-0.5355793238,
-0.4014293551,
0.2184380889,
1.0595937967,
0.1961689293,
-0.1580370665,
-0.0537512414,
-0.022941269,
0.4503195286,
0.1732353717,
-0.5654763579,
-0.5933656693,
0.7777794003,
-0.1920019686,
-0.6299452186,
-0.105376482,
-1.0871648788,
-0.692199707,
-0.1180318296,
0.1739288867,
-0.4448783994,
-0.5394639373,
-0.3347950876,
-0.5942931771,
-0.2198707163,
0.2930190563,
-0.6961388588,
0.202959314,
0.760433495,
0.9226195216,
0.0738867372,
-0.5626326203,
-0.3502822518,
-0.0443961546,
-0.1507607847,
1.1382420063,
-0.5467674732,
-0.2791917026,
0.119756259,
-0.0367221832,
-0.1507348418,
-0.4309596419,
0.3787050843,
-0.0136107858,
0.386428237,
-0.3040903509,
-0.3235952854,
-0.3922390044,
0.5575922132,
-0.8042063713,
0.9217994809,
0.68406111,
-0.8878970742,
0.377536118,
-0.278639257,
-0.649314642,
-0.1765583456,
-0.2177963257,
-0.418854624,
0.2422602624,
0.4522255659,
0.3514548242,
-0.1148062497,
0.1485029608,
-0.7882873416,
0.4076042473,
-0.017812483,
-0.1146205217,
0.7572003007,
0.0414551608,
0.0599682108,
0.4688093662,
-0.7044144869,
0.2157571614,
-0.3185498118,
0.0731702223,
-0.2602995336,
-0.1879115254,
-0.0606373362,
0.3013854921,
0.0123754004,
-0.7656559944,
-0.054611057,
-0.9533218145,
0.8951662779,
0.713979125,
0.2364936769,
0.6052917242,
-0.0668895096,
0.4964747429,
0.4073595703,
0.1480448246,
-0.2485388219,
-0.2193369269,
-0.6421763301,
-0.1602520645,
0.3788332343,
0.2770115137,
-0.861024797,
0.5617291927,
-0.0862179548,
-0.4687669277,
-0.8669445515,
0.2370369881,
0.2440036982,
0.5353689194,
0.3583857417,
-0.4122359455,
-0.8613259792,
-0.9627433419,
-0.0780681446,
-0.4916029572,
0.3806930184,
0.0800003186,
0.0299369078,
-0.0574172772,
0.8984856009,
-0.3675363064,
-0.188545689,
-0.7543319464,
0.0957698673,
0.187139079,
0.4728349149,
0.5620959401,
-0.2894370258,
-0.2374711037,
0.077655375,
-0.7602736354,
0.0221681017,
0.1282464266,
-0.3755865693,
0.2178075761,
0.1739401221,
-0.7868853807,
-0.1419600397,
0.8370582461,
-0.058541961,
0.1698207557,
0.2425123006,
0.0788382217,
-1.528490901,
-0.2767046094,
0.2388393432,
-0.3300645649,
-0.489970088,
0.0205435399,
-0.2238234878,
-0.278006494,
-0.5032169223,
0.248512134,
-0.2608175278,
-0.0351946652,
-0.1304961592,
0.0230419412,
0.6163055301,
0.5069282651,
-0.2973934114,
0.3569507301,
0.6771889329,
0.0709652454,
0.4251596332,
0.0035584166,
-0.066663526,
0.4860080183,
-0.3907030225,
-0.035969343,
-0.2295904756,
0.6436203718,
-1.3373917341,
-0.5038255453,
0.3792275488,
-0.3898473978,
0.3093100488,
-0.289524883,
-0.4245988727,
-0.3225068748,
-0.4881826341,
0.5013250113,
0.4209843278,
-0.5635566711,
1.1877499819,
0.6561257243,
0.0094886981,
-0.1854241341,
-0.7449207306,
-0.1001081392,
-0.3369156718,
-0.7302697897,
0.2701203227,
0.5378425121,
-0.175269112,
0.1953926682,
-0.1332610548,
0.1407571286,
0.0385582261,
0.2985099256,
0.2183358073,
-0.1158251464,
-0.0422365032,
0.410220027,
-0.061629802,
0.1050475016,
-0.5623772144,
0.7494500279,
-0.117261298,
-0.2781952024,
-0.280977875,
0.4290170074,
0.7086374164,
-0.1352541298,
0.6487406492,
0.4973531067,
-0.3011039793,
-0.4209113121,
-0.4709184766,
-0.0784843117,
-0.458176136,
0.1868214309,
-0.0768963099,
-0.8382478952,
0.7395032644,
-0.1515153944,
-0.0680376217,
0.6141225696,
0.208739996,
-0.131819576,
1.3712294102,
0.2076321542,
-0.246425882,
0.4955551326,
-0.3727402389,
0.3672332466,
-0.9165232182,
-0.116590105,
-0.4398243427,
-0.3875702322,
-0.8496937156,
-0.2050193697,
0.5211485624,
-0.0898983032,
-0.1256022453,
0.2410888374,
-0.6744660735,
0.4345982969,
0.4507839978,
0.1853743941,
-0.147595197,
0.0805945247,
-0.052528847,
0.2616181076,
-0.6475255489,
0.0640495047,
0.6968432665,
0.2257294357,
0.4990474284,
-0.0106579047,
1.0875800848,
0.0042198515,
0.0137032149,
-0.8205395937,
0.4886012971,
-0.3300200105,
-0.1208458915,
-0.1221635714,
-0.4191714525,
-0.5330173373,
0.3260947764,
-0.1536997706,
-0.8516486287,
0.1414563209,
0.3059539795,
-0.5866296887,
0.2613613307,
-0.9622252584,
1.073302865,
0.2118903399,
-0.2231520712,
-0.1158854067,
-0.6830496192,
0.3848082423,
0.1304368228,
0.1585106999,
-0.1910740584,
0.4577196836,
0.4240514636,
-0.6844534278,
0.9424943328,
-0.2559867501,
0.1900899112,
0.5595665574,
0.0996294543,
0.4648617804,
-0.1161315963,
-0.0276188385,
0.2187599987,
0.0767746791,
-0.3140181899,
-0.9360716939,
1.0683759451,
-0.7893686295,
-0.5192902684,
-0.3459766507,
-0.1652949899,
-0.6990932226,
0.1239290014,
0.2658281326,
0.7144951224,
-0.1419100314,
-0.1804871261,
0.1438646615,
-0.071481891,
0.4631455541,
-0.405364722,
-0.3661603034,
-1.0774005651,
1.075709343,
0.0587675534,
0.4801630378,
0.1293956488,
0.3480523825,
-0.3920606673,
-0.4180882275,
-0.7363172174,
-0.0050726072,
-0.821511209,
-0.4881833792,
-0.9479169846,
-0.3906401694,
-0.666441679,
-0.0435331166,
-0.2999143898,
-0.6328634024,
-0.1053127423,
-0.2736219466,
0.4433948994,
0.4921875298,
0.2553116381,
0.3470700085,
-0.9576345682,
-0.1113934889,
0.0788753107,
0.2531932294,
0.1444936693,
0.0638563782,
-0.115621306,
-0.1084386855,
-0.4861263335,
-0.8887882233,
0.3708107769,
0.2162580937,
0.2767408192,
0.174623996,
-0.0455764718,
0.8018131852,
-0.232062459,
1.1183474064,
0.5907092094,
-1.1480643749,
0.6664627194,
-0.3465429842,
0.4228523672,
0.8557217121,
-0.0031770696,
-0.4489253759,
-0.9975774884,
-0.881734252,
-1.1385569572,
0.5998723507,
-0.1038444489,
0.1937343776,
-0.1958350688,
-0.0126782339,
0.0358061828,
0.2576042116,
-0.3667954803,
0.0959566459,
-0.6252687573,
-0.810880661,
0.1220976263,
0.109471634,
-0.1644973755,
-0.4651189446,
0.5149097443,
-0.3154461086,
-0.041640006,
0.1950149536,
0.1040245518,
-0.2270994186,
0.0943388641,
0.0742092878,
0.3390838802,
0.0740047321,
0.6061595678,
0.1705199927,
0.0012573187,
-0.0704979897,
0.1483506709,
0.1573809385,
0.0462893508,
0.5329923034,
0.7848562002,
0.1842622608,
-0.2917466462,
0.2919632792,
0.1880272329,
-0.0467859954,
-0.0793288946,
0.1227253005,
0.1734381169,
0.3508813083,
-0.2035707384,
0.4054398239,
0.3195679486,
-0.7278524637,
-0.0207050517,
0.4021455944,
-0.4470983148,
-0.6419148445,
0.2204773873,
0.349924922,
0.0570360869,
0.5764286518,
0.048062738,
-0.8042886853,
0.4821568429,
0.3075545728,
1.3679944277,
-0.1605077982,
0.4303791821,
0.3610558212,
-0.1448337138,
0.0487775356,
0.201302141,
0.090320535,
-0.8556422591,
-0.5779451728,
-0.9622431993,
-0.2479093671,
-0.1794976741,
-0.3879780769,
0.1072192267,
-0.754057765,
-0.3394263685,
0.514588356,
-0.3395132422,
-0.3655129671,
0.0249796379,
-0.030016562,
0.5207837224,
-1.069365263,
0.5711139441,
0.7500712872,
-0.5633674264,
-0.9378935099,
0.006416209,
0.2054701895,
-0.6660709977,
0.1279383153,
0.348803252,
0.0716195852,
0.0092873331,
-0.2498334795,
-0.6222580075,
0.6265599728,
0.2382891774,
-0.1188336536,
0.0717664808,
0.0521908253,
0.7292720079,
-0.4465625882,
0.2608964443,
0.6978674531,
0.235753417,
0.3384312391,
-0.741674304,
0.0461854823,
-0.2395639867,
-0.0027635514,
0.8637694716,
-0.5029736161,
0.8354389071,
0.1715302616,
-0.2825321853,
-0.1970809251,
0.680427134,
0.0406803973,
0.1806181669,
0.7136070132,
0.8354593515,
0.6178944111,
-0.2014467269,
0.9747202396,
-0.3892605603,
0.2627749443,
0.9794995189,
-0.3022422194,
0.6490911841,
0.5325816274,
-0.2603445649,
0.8197302222,
0.8431451321,
0.2003175169,
0.6213876009,
-0.0681218058,
-0.5864761472,
-0.4017034471,
-0.576558888,
-0.1566054225,
0.3373749256,
0.2729387879,
-0.5761090517,
-0.4381153286,
0.090616487,
-0.0461659729,
-0.0545100234,
-0.1662815511,
1.1705528498,
0.1885445267,
-0.9967235327,
0.1630048454,
-0.3919556141,
0.1523950845,
-0.2366506606,
-0.0344069861,
-0.1279920042,
0.2113142014,
-0.5095888972,
-1.0513792038,
0.4464856386,
-0.3958663642,
-0.0807855874,
-0.26900509,
0.7623370886,
-0.6112107038,
-0.6654828191,
0.3130571842,
0.6693076491,
-0.2989236116,
0.033762157,
-0.5158898234,
0.2578647435,
-0.0854885057,
0.1018021107,
0.4742944241,
0.4925279021,
0.2087579221,
0.1271941513,
0.5734321475,
0.2011938095,
-0.5762986541,
0.5679598451,
1.2486845255,
-0.3944330215,
-0.5752485991,
-1.2488490343,
0.5764458776,
-0.3012482822,
-0.3376571238,
0.7870864272,
0.4469540417,
0.68396312,
0.3038617373,
0.9990187883,
0.0143397013,
0.3619032502,
-0.5037705302,
0.3681038618,
-0.548114717,
0.0028125693,
-0.5951493979,
-1.0246663094,
-0.3603103161,
0.1901984066,
-0.1284120679,
0.0051680342,
0.7092955709,
0.5791091323,
-0.092918627,
0.4470502436,
-0.0651312098,
0.0852227658,
0.3922117949,
0.3911135495,
1.0147235394,
-0.1665848792,
0.1577502191,
-0.4991947412,
-0.0886775032,
0.1149085462,
-0.7655469179,
-0.7295944691,
-0.6125615835,
-0.3389130831,
-0.9814191461,
-0.1568495333,
1.0535235405,
0.5855587721,
-0.8997542262,
0.0608464144,
-0.4762723744,
0.2874558568,
-0.1239013448,
-0.2630761266,
0.3717365265,
-0.6624279022,
-0.681116581,
0.2357644588,
0.5269086361,
0.077320613,
-0.6641663909,
0.4297739565,
0.2255456746,
-0.0988418683,
0.6564256549,
-0.007762304,
-0.8246250153,
-0.5735727549,
-0.2344387025,
0.1157486737,
0.2977407277,
0.8271917701,
-0.8477932215,
0.5607467294,
0.9923596382,
0.6536505818,
0.2723704278,
0.3121851087,
0.7035078406,
-0.9836613536,
-0.0038494053,
0.3405516446,
0.6171109676,
0.5395368934,
-0.2644838691,
0.1771387011,
0.4214297831,
-0.3087249398,
-0.9893097878,
0.145439446,
-1.0780041218,
-0.3734285831,
1.0936732292,
0.0644675568,
-0.6514965892,
0.1267796457,
-0.1285358667,
0.1875617206,
-0.4599038959,
0.6074763536,
0.7987917662,
-0.2789646089,
-0.2342166156,
0.0027677191,
0.5086267591,
0.3599249125,
-1.1310563087,
0.1572403759,
0.7076333165,
-0.0177032128,
0.5176699162,
0.4305389822,
0.0512652658,
-0.0454779789,
0.1999191344,
-0.1796706319,
0.1671428382,
-0.4737751484,
-0.2206919044,
0.534773767,
0.080141589,
-0.2268766165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16867v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16867v2
|
The Falcon Series of Open Language Models
| 2023-11-28T15:12:47 | 2023-11-29T19:45:10 |
Ebtesam Almazrouei, Hamza Alobeidli, Abdulaziz Alshamsi, Alessandro Cappelli, Ruxandra Cojocaru, Mérouane Debbah, Étienne Goffinet, Daniel Hesslow, Julien Launay, Quentin Malartic, Daniele Mazzotta, Badreddine Noune, Baptiste Pannier, Guilherme Penedo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce the Falcon series: 7B, 40B, and 180B parameters causal
decoder-only models trained on a diverse high-quality corpora predominantly
assembled from web data. The largest model, Falcon-180B, has been trained on
over 3.5 trillion tokens of text--the largest openly documented pretraining
run. Falcon-180B significantly outperforms models such as PaLM or Chinchilla,
and improves upon concurrently developed models such as LLaMA 2 or
Inflection-1. It nears the performance of PaLM-2-Large at a reduced pretraining
and inference cost, making it, to our knowledge, one of the three best language
models in the world along with GPT-4 and PaLM-2-Large. We report detailed
evaluations, as well as a deep dive into the methods and custom tooling
employed to pretrain Falcon. Notably, we report on our custom distributed
training codebase, allowing us to efficiently pretrain these models on up to
4,096 A100s on cloud AWS infrastructure with limited interconnect. We release a
600B tokens extract of our web dataset, as well as the Falcon-7/40/180B models
under a permissive license to foster open-science and accelerate the
development of an open ecosystem of large language models.
|
[
-0.516025126,
-0.5300295949,
0.3120506704,
0.3426369131,
-0.0146569246,
-0.0398296714,
-0.2253218144,
-0.6410862207,
0.0580682792,
0.7818703651,
-0.5277689695,
-0.3125469089,
-0.6667546034,
0.1781657636,
-0.6410524845,
1.0736351013,
0.1848260462,
0.0967103913,
0.3037039638,
-0.0125399651,
0.1515450925,
-0.7287548184,
-0.7047582865,
0.0829990208,
0.610889256,
0.3607279062,
0.8708164692,
1.063622117,
0.9060955644,
0.1850921065,
0.0220320765,
-0.075131461,
-0.6382076144,
-0.3208803535,
-0.2366178036,
-0.4192948043,
-0.4715393782,
0.0256612599,
0.668659091,
0.9762541056,
-0.1463353932,
0.2391920388,
-0.3420492709,
0.6082844138,
-0.7460215092,
0.2473493367,
-0.6399086714,
-0.153927058,
-0.6487182975,
0.2993687689,
-0.6718504429,
-0.038604293,
-0.1881464422,
-0.9750182629,
0.2853093743,
0.1739821583,
1.0992634296,
0.197050944,
-0.4109144509,
-0.1719691455,
-0.7567358613,
0.6803005338,
-0.7118743658,
0.7904253006,
0.4156443775,
0.4586135745,
-0.2380222231,
-1.2322700024,
-0.5211828947,
-0.2123130113,
0.3663760424,
0.2738575339,
-0.2961920798,
0.0617936067,
0.2146786004,
0.2112277597,
-0.5069068074,
0.4023937583,
-0.5374134779,
0.0535581596,
0.5113177896,
-0.0162964333,
-0.0388623551,
0.3191652596,
-0.140053466,
-0.2519074976,
-0.9775437117,
0.1116628423,
0.54002738,
0.5516586304,
-0.0227362644,
0.4805499613,
-0.1672639698,
0.6713492274,
0.2279691994,
0.1013615951,
-0.0474150889,
-0.2444343716,
-0.353298068,
-0.181625247,
0.9007199407,
-0.0332864076,
0.4026076198,
-0.4520261884,
-0.0740326643,
-0.1259355694,
0.3061881959,
-1.035550952,
0.0776288882,
0.1327698231,
-0.5074499846,
-0.1485322565,
0.5640385151,
-0.5611923933,
-0.2268286347,
-0.290058583,
-0.0691832304,
-0.1398825794,
-0.5049160123,
0.4973711669,
0.0710523725,
0.0474692546,
0.0920170099,
-1.0620079041,
0.6903734803,
0.8570492864,
0.6835430861,
0.1357296854,
-0.5066102147,
-0.9699729681,
0.1152744889,
-0.7265167236,
0.5875115991,
-0.7820174098,
-0.3864603937,
0.1582566053,
0.1604783088,
-0.0758338571,
-0.3709527552,
0.7214698195,
-0.7721017599,
-0.1064044088,
-0.5563498735,
-0.4599295557,
-0.2184098512,
-0.188920036,
-0.8383209705,
0.8574726582,
0.119410269,
-0.9260601997,
0.3176347315,
-0.8672945499,
-0.2991840243,
-0.0210850723,
0.0682534799,
-0.0938400552,
0.0556655303,
0.3269020319,
0.4979811609,
-0.6249577403,
0.3639681935,
-0.8517765403,
-0.4189276993,
-0.1881777048,
0.0517713204,
0.7674925327,
0.5865486264,
-0.3097545505,
0.2337937057,
-0.6686307788,
-0.2017126381,
0.1485842019,
-0.0131805204,
-0.0254664402,
-0.0112200761,
0.1758070439,
0.2291130424,
0.0530382581,
-0.7042481899,
-0.0007917409,
-0.4704904258,
0.5819644928,
0.5027111173,
-0.3413287997,
0.2701545954,
-0.034496773,
0.6923474669,
0.540877223,
0.3608803153,
-0.4546931386,
-0.3094961643,
-0.9906768203,
-0.2181150317,
0.2105244547,
0.315890789,
-0.3783079088,
0.3435702324,
-0.2117707431,
-0.746142149,
-0.5016440153,
-0.1377572864,
0.3821005225,
0.4842605889,
0.2855267823,
-0.1001101807,
-0.6225610971,
-0.897552371,
-0.2128978521,
-0.2839933336,
0.2349599898,
0.1633328497,
0.5081351399,
-0.273742348,
0.8902447224,
-0.2203274816,
0.0309460778,
-0.0836547688,
0.0475794747,
0.1697061211,
0.1420504004,
0.8679622412,
-0.5360667706,
-0.3920044303,
0.1950855553,
-0.6335628033,
0.0177623648,
0.1158516556,
-0.0813003108,
0.473803401,
0.7270070314,
-0.4474834502,
0.186686784,
0.6454259157,
-0.2419395894,
0.5781874657,
-0.1241703629,
0.0058285142,
-0.9740818143,
0.5530204773,
0.0174940806,
-0.0742654055,
-0.4989025593,
0.380610019,
0.1923634261,
-0.1930634677,
-0.5680098534,
0.6822461486,
-0.4564633965,
-0.2821686566,
-0.1491136402,
-0.0737726763,
-0.2534080446,
0.2980062664,
0.2504341304,
0.9562928677,
0.6978821754,
-0.4967158437,
0.0119244829,
0.2061856389,
-0.3554473817,
0.0711683556,
-0.8802629113,
0.1661268324,
-0.2983750403,
0.4539885521,
-0.6380756497,
-0.2216908634,
0.0346377417,
-0.2084874064,
-0.0075177946,
0.0312040076,
-0.4984599948,
-0.6262000799,
0.0949532315,
-0.0048134294,
0.3336104155,
-0.7110061049,
0.2200239152,
0.3898515403,
-0.1812100261,
-0.8799407482,
-0.4957776368,
0.1669918597,
-0.0451939963,
-0.5658919215,
0.1252412945,
-0.0878081173,
-0.1874307841,
-0.0826979205,
0.0972022265,
-0.1613230407,
0.1500839442,
0.4744022191,
0.0924640149,
-0.6702240109,
-0.063412182,
-0.0859818012,
-0.1365626007,
-0.0431119353,
-0.6688365936,
0.5344430804,
-0.6922327876,
-0.3417187631,
-0.2457906008,
0.3299089968,
0.6989233494,
-0.7570752501,
1.0859279633,
0.6645876765,
-0.3567269146,
0.1258782595,
-0.4656828344,
0.0705044419,
-0.4879869521,
0.4400731325,
-0.6758379936,
-1.0616794825,
0.5767089725,
0.0513918921,
0.2244155407,
0.5706834793,
0.2746596932,
0.2642012835,
1.1058636904,
0.8074244857,
-0.369146347,
0.4280865788,
-0.1986523122,
0.114468202,
-0.5279006958,
-0.072837688,
-0.9048615098,
0.2500946224,
-0.367661804,
-0.0722336099,
0.0759250671,
0.5033174157,
-0.9697756171,
0.3713568747,
-0.1134280413,
0.6697726846,
0.6543830633,
-0.0783741027,
0.1143617779,
0.0227449723,
-0.1036036909,
0.2388867438,
-0.7351399064,
-0.6847815514,
1.4309689999,
0.4734636247,
0.5565725565,
0.1109664962,
0.6670551896,
-0.0253866892,
0.6120348573,
-0.5457149148,
0.3709332347,
-0.518293798,
-0.6925113201,
-0.1138878837,
-0.3748338223,
-1.0356484652,
-0.138181299,
0.004949416,
-0.5634120703,
-0.171905458,
0.0201752987,
-0.2940175533,
0.3691781759,
-0.6387554407,
0.9454246759,
-0.1533066779,
-0.3888874948,
-0.1136465967,
-0.818980813,
0.5637487173,
-0.3533215821,
0.2656849623,
0.2005124837,
-0.0741042271,
0.8587049246,
-0.6229290366,
0.6158381104,
-0.3351540267,
0.0417043269,
0.3117843866,
-0.0799570754,
0.6571968794,
-0.1643179953,
-0.4359158278,
0.4131726027,
0.1473451555,
-0.4824859798,
-0.3565176427,
0.6159489155,
-1.2034703493,
-0.4688133001,
-0.3669923842,
-0.2082203031,
-0.3222298622,
0.6094838381,
0.2726347148,
0.5186623931,
-0.359026581,
0.4072836637,
0.2197828293,
-0.0776507035,
0.6813541055,
0.7984762788,
-0.5059605241,
-0.5001476407,
0.6497009993,
-0.0667542145,
0.1987145096,
0.4410789013,
0.1573326439,
-0.540109098,
-0.6848760247,
-0.5322124958,
0.5387909412,
-0.6025342941,
0.0322423354,
-0.8724125624,
-0.3246639371,
-0.6015928984,
-0.1348684579,
-0.5923672318,
-0.3028671145,
-0.4294640124,
-0.1554590017,
0.1782020628,
1.1050601006,
0.0203794707,
0.80554533,
-1.0019005537,
0.1256058365,
-0.1916252226,
0.5085585117,
0.0476273596,
-0.4156439006,
-0.3802887499,
0.3860504031,
-0.226236999,
-0.5493413806,
0.29584077,
0.2822929919,
0.5492085814,
0.7775049806,
-0.0904705301,
0.8482621312,
-0.6050146222,
0.9194450378,
0.3353782594,
-1.1236364841,
0.1892530322,
-0.8036518693,
0.1264148951,
0.5289869308,
0.6805060506,
-0.5177772641,
-0.3963909745,
-0.7602630854,
-0.3300084472,
1.0264816284,
-0.029555995,
-0.1737085581,
-0.2254997641,
0.4205811322,
0.3212566674,
0.0989107713,
-0.4803662002,
0.0496567711,
-0.7093523145,
-0.2985577881,
-0.5393932462,
0.1355181336,
0.2562562227,
-0.0275554042,
0.8782515526,
-0.2448771447,
0.1051593572,
-0.200076744,
-0.087075077,
-0.2940520644,
-0.1458474994,
0.8520990014,
0.7251418829,
-0.217632845,
-0.0309782606,
-0.3059379756,
-0.7052473426,
-0.0831910819,
0.1617196947,
0.0498702936,
-0.2900552452,
0.3571237028,
1.0431028605,
0.0565283783,
-0.6287739873,
0.4470295608,
-0.0607877523,
-0.0801197886,
-0.1856297851,
0.1011067778,
0.1016191319,
0.1110714972,
0.0950395241,
0.0628824234,
-0.0120888213,
-0.4648726583,
0.2589338422,
0.3134688735,
-0.3667203784,
-0.513789475,
0.9602494836,
0.2910484076,
-0.2180740088,
0.6886411309,
-0.031964954,
-0.4552350938,
0.7093980312,
0.7754178047,
0.7247183919,
-0.1342011094,
0.3112202883,
0.6235305071,
0.402677685,
-0.4148865938,
0.2498973906,
0.1605510265,
-0.5443488955,
-0.2912019193,
-0.8484813571,
-0.5909404755,
0.2508775592,
-0.7057230473,
0.4307254851,
-0.6324625015,
-0.2195132077,
0.1728519052,
0.2266364992,
-0.7130537033,
0.2626242042,
0.0179474596,
1.264554739,
-0.6885983944,
0.9731721282,
0.711373806,
-0.7429319024,
-0.9330102205,
-0.1119411364,
-0.1801021248,
-0.866768539,
1.0192091465,
0.2488287091,
-0.2405401915,
0.4439060092,
-0.5334096551,
-1.14313519,
0.7888118029,
0.5080734491,
-0.8010926843,
-0.0529577471,
0.4219372571,
0.4963342249,
-0.4333913028,
0.5633556247,
0.3519099951,
0.5263635516,
0.116151467,
-1.0590113401,
-0.1574768275,
-0.3396545351,
-0.056038592,
0.3987665474,
-1.0154851675,
0.9665495157,
-0.3705742955,
-0.15889211,
0.2623484731,
0.8474218249,
0.0585329719,
-0.0960232094,
0.3781062663,
0.3664644659,
0.860817492,
0.0131762177,
1.0909000635,
-0.6320099235,
0.1634410024,
0.9822215438,
-0.6016068459,
1.1414263248,
0.2330845594,
-0.1810027808,
0.3745358884,
0.8199417591,
0.2722233832,
0.3595948815,
0.2082773,
0.1467152983,
-0.3494382203,
-0.0182483327,
-0.50334692,
0.4837660491,
0.1931766421,
-0.1674505174,
-0.2339779437,
-0.0190232638,
0.3215380013,
-0.1326878667,
-0.2771703005,
0.3986849189,
0.0233506896,
-1.1237236261,
0.7252975106,
0.3750197887,
0.4870023131,
-1.0073407888,
0.4370307624,
-0.423987776,
0.5776346922,
-0.0610542819,
-0.5084155798,
0.3488707542,
0.2747812569,
-0.1022108197,
-0.1262129396,
0.3007316589,
-0.2502765059,
-0.6879323721,
0.2576935291,
0.1164947227,
0.2477911711,
-0.3350494206,
-0.4214360416,
0.2948718667,
-0.3712236881,
-0.2516939938,
0.1396628916,
0.1712357551,
-0.1974770874,
0.6319617033,
0.7618207932,
-0.0041897004,
0.3899405897,
0.1329290122,
0.64923352,
-0.718547225,
-0.6756539345,
-0.4356505275,
0.2881543636,
0.1190690994,
-0.4513705075,
0.6406444907,
0.8253024817,
0.8983684778,
-0.1654401571,
0.7966695428,
0.1821138412,
0.4404095113,
-0.4609413743,
0.8085137606,
-0.5646448731,
-0.1454201639,
-0.2107724249,
-0.8121147156,
-0.2098639905,
0.3115304708,
-0.0833576694,
0.120026201,
0.8433596492,
0.7780635357,
-0.2776034176,
0.7052601576,
0.1210039482,
0.2673484087,
0.6333411932,
0.7213516235,
0.7185560465,
-0.5665310025,
0.4590983987,
0.0172066968,
-0.3231295049,
-0.2528080344,
-0.9508720636,
-0.9989799857,
-0.6871429086,
-0.1051752493,
-0.0671489537,
0.1824438721,
0.7159662247,
1.0481702089,
-0.8046673536,
-0.5378098488,
-0.4417855442,
-0.5367053151,
-0.1698291898,
-0.1184341908,
0.2760871351,
-0.4322950542,
-0.5689332485,
0.4708325863,
0.0585210025,
-0.0095097655,
-0.2332548499,
-0.418084532,
-0.1156004816,
0.2902421057,
0.6287513971,
0.4417931736,
-0.7180057764,
-0.2274392545,
0.4330081344,
-0.0728078634,
-0.114832066,
0.7679575086,
-0.6364374161,
0.1205864772,
0.2652107477,
0.7559220195,
0.8347193003,
-0.1589602828,
0.5504639745,
-0.249170959,
0.3096748888,
-0.0676833689,
0.3866228163,
0.0886057019,
0.0381809585,
0.5803133845,
0.2081733495,
-0.3687802255,
-0.9191931486,
0.1987477541,
-1.0700601339,
-0.2035876364,
1.1287305355,
-0.3598363996,
-0.1868563443,
0.1378029883,
0.0028576774,
0.3130089343,
-0.1701337248,
0.4548105896,
0.8465124965,
0.1655543596,
0.0180315487,
-0.3253168166,
0.2476116419,
0.2063906789,
-1.1641157866,
0.1851473898,
0.482252419,
0.2108424753,
-0.0831129625,
0.5029072762,
-0.1431634724,
0.144641161,
0.2593756914,
-0.059230186,
-0.6545382738,
-0.8945208192,
-0.0997951999,
0.2762658,
0.0744900033,
-0.0574488156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16865v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16865v1
|
A Benchmark for Evaluating Machine Translation Metrics on Dialects Without Standard Orthography
| 2023-11-28T15:12:11 | 2023-11-28T15:12:11 |
Noëmi Aepli, Chantal Amrhein, Florian Schottmann, Rico Sennrich
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
For sensible progress in natural language processing, it is important that we
are aware of the limitations of the evaluation metrics we use. In this work, we
evaluate how robust metrics are to non-standardized dialects, i.e. spelling
differences in language varieties that do not have a standard orthography. To
investigate this, we collect a dataset of human translations and human
judgments for automatic machine translations from English to two Swiss German
dialects. We further create a challenge set for dialect variation and benchmark
existing metrics' performances. Our results show that existing metrics cannot
reliably evaluate Swiss German text generation outputs, especially on segment
level. We propose initial design adaptations that increase robustness in the
face of non-standardized dialects, although there remains much room for further
improvement. The dataset, code, and models are available here:
https://github.com/textshuttle/dialect_eval
|
[
-0.3477373719,
-0.3589001298,
0.5207636356,
-0.0242302809,
-0.3199470937,
-0.0619466789,
-0.4192109406,
-0.4918701649,
0.1168456376,
0.6643496752,
-0.4162609279,
-0.6357528567,
-0.6673492789,
0.5080792904,
-0.3975242972,
0.7472835779,
-0.1162573248,
0.1038869247,
-0.0482986756,
-0.5601425171,
-0.3727842271,
-0.4781764448,
-0.2760930955,
-0.2003526539,
0.027855454,
0.609659493,
0.760848403,
0.7759104371,
0.4914413691,
0.3203542829,
-0.019659074,
0.4069467485,
-0.163355872,
0.2867550552,
0.0392888002,
-0.2350469083,
-0.7042961717,
-0.2038427889,
0.892486155,
1.05101192,
-0.0834519044,
0.1316567063,
0.0722758099,
0.789642334,
-0.4127978981,
0.0081901411,
-0.613260746,
-0.097181201,
-0.5945227146,
0.2036228031,
-0.1932818145,
-0.6357263327,
-0.0397451557,
-0.2875272036,
0.4165767431,
0.2126909345,
0.9913970232,
0.2056013793,
-0.4402666688,
-0.2336532027,
-0.400688827,
0.8324992061,
-0.8861938715,
0.7420303226,
0.3391161859,
0.4392001331,
-0.2108756453,
-0.5137735009,
-0.1010565832,
-0.292491883,
-0.042626556,
0.0440880805,
-0.2997561395,
-0.0142042171,
0.1846526265,
0.5438343883,
-0.6844940782,
0.1835377961,
-0.1844183952,
-0.2398233712,
0.6295828223,
0.2092494816,
0.2247972935,
-0.3627194464,
-0.0949230194,
-0.2936630547,
-0.3018960059,
0.1203967556,
0.6443894506,
0.4713290334,
-0.1973655075,
0.5103202462,
-0.3750974834,
0.8113883138,
0.0639630407,
-0.0171382725,
0.5647004247,
-0.4535525739,
-0.1724338382,
-0.2985416651,
0.8270953894,
0.4185364842,
0.173267439,
-0.3435406089,
-0.7502331734,
-0.1080388948,
0.2933028638,
-0.6220537424,
-0.3091716468,
-0.0968556479,
-0.285096705,
-0.1251203418,
0.2543281317,
-0.8547379375,
-0.2793274522,
0.0341266096,
0.147667855,
-0.6531347036,
-0.0187695399,
0.1742582172,
-0.437420845,
-0.0278621316,
0.0203769188,
-0.9258527756,
0.514570415,
0.4694254696,
0.6858479977,
-0.2908207476,
-0.2717950046,
-0.4306819141,
-0.3063459396,
-0.6884744763,
0.7541720271,
-0.160572201,
-0.6041929126,
0.0303458236,
-0.0671134517,
-0.2573235929,
-0.9640212655,
0.9138728976,
-0.2222898602,
0.0422994979,
-0.0619495511,
-0.4049818814,
-0.1348164976,
0.1244241595,
-0.6991373897,
1.1160942316,
0.3680741489,
-0.5654038191,
0.458199203,
-0.4594361484,
-1.0271034241,
-0.0614769049,
0.1067115292,
-0.5449545383,
0.6231731176,
0.2184710652,
0.0291407071,
-0.3868876398,
0.169780761,
-0.3666064143,
-0.2831317186,
0.2863333225,
-0.3944982886,
0.816850543,
0.1336584538,
-0.2941374183,
-0.1107504368,
-0.9442770481,
0.5216657519,
-0.1097382009,
-0.2261254787,
-0.1611807942,
0.0543661751,
0.2349306792,
-0.0984689668,
0.2964090109,
-0.4144064188,
-0.1568675786,
-0.437387079,
0.6956198812,
0.4334098995,
-0.2318029255,
0.441884011,
-0.4337694049,
0.4150900841,
-0.2001410872,
0.023885401,
0.1748017818,
-0.425316304,
-1.0550037622,
-0.4391377866,
0.5333291888,
0.5372588038,
-0.6340018511,
0.8644329906,
-0.5971945524,
-0.5189909339,
-0.6406276822,
0.2593736649,
0.4330682456,
0.4555411935,
0.3635701239,
-0.9866660237,
-0.6155539155,
-1.0246213675,
-0.3557805121,
-0.4401427805,
-0.4228693545,
0.1655433625,
0.2379034609,
-0.1517610401,
0.9106020927,
-0.0960910171,
-0.1338676363,
-0.2443803996,
0.474586457,
0.0574933812,
0.2438423038,
0.5055834055,
-0.355637759,
-0.367882669,
0.1247699484,
-0.6882081032,
-0.6086215377,
0.2365949005,
0.0944442376,
0.6189116836,
0.2077278197,
-0.1892822385,
0.1954176426,
0.7047910094,
-0.0033095833,
0.6958017945,
-0.2473166138,
0.4052836597,
-0.8139194846,
0.2528868616,
-0.0091310805,
-0.5108377934,
-0.6218595505,
0.0451880805,
0.2297208458,
-0.1069299057,
-0.166569978,
0.4078718424,
-0.2544828355,
-0.1776278913,
0.0621299185,
0.1635365486,
0.2939519882,
0.0240953509,
0.1363439411,
0.6997712255,
0.2186359614,
-0.2151498348,
0.0294303596,
0.1393070519,
-0.6611612439,
1.1366068125,
-0.4632000923,
0.3897433579,
0.1940721273,
0.112941727,
-0.8715890646,
-0.4837577343,
0.0410788096,
-0.6527373791,
0.2097770572,
-0.0117980046,
-0.8087067008,
-0.2427288592,
-0.1538650542,
0.0018715309,
0.6943344474,
-0.338557601,
0.0028675946,
0.1810420901,
-0.0910131335,
0.178198725,
-0.8263466954,
0.3822807074,
-0.4621505737,
-0.8655672669,
0.0910709277,
0.1225828677,
-0.3119650185,
-0.1274619401,
-0.1357719153,
-0.5332942605,
0.1138948202,
-0.1226444766,
0.1589908004,
-0.4649837017,
-0.1072760075,
0.0644209981,
-0.1700659394,
-0.0680533275,
-0.4824025333,
0.0389195271,
-0.1919280738,
-0.4058596492,
-0.4415571392,
0.4777415097,
0.609893322,
-0.1628853828,
0.1914105117,
0.4631556571,
-0.2905010879,
-0.2361004353,
-0.6055988073,
-0.0638340339,
-0.4577687383,
0.5539412498,
-0.4937409461,
-0.7455591559,
0.3504862487,
0.0402192511,
-0.0212061666,
0.4751588106,
0.3260783851,
-0.1514154971,
0.9194582105,
0.5666298866,
-0.1513733566,
0.1442067176,
0.3832863867,
0.1324001849,
-0.3891722262,
0.2659603655,
-0.8061724305,
-0.3573435843,
-0.6613976359,
-0.4339146316,
0.4973057508,
0.270098269,
-0.0900158808,
0.7414776087,
-0.2311339527,
0.1325828284,
0.578197062,
-0.2576370537,
0.5159285665,
0.0118013108,
-0.1317410916,
-0.3937630653,
-0.6582109928,
-0.7266358137,
0.8517522812,
-0.0147658018,
0.472908169,
0.1487096846,
0.8435349464,
0.4319469929,
0.1017958149,
-0.576895535,
0.3618771434,
-0.5046830773,
-0.4404854774,
-0.2341840416,
-0.7530459762,
-0.8279035091,
0.0880275667,
-0.0801349357,
-0.781708777,
0.1758140624,
0.0440896861,
-0.0246749222,
0.2829816043,
-0.8498015404,
1.0078159571,
-0.4090141356,
0.314466089,
0.0549220778,
-0.6271557808,
0.0342935696,
-0.3717509806,
0.2926496863,
-0.0678438097,
-0.0217567533,
0.2536813021,
-0.4210410714,
0.7220971584,
0.1369871795,
0.1891146302,
0.2138134986,
0.2067605555,
0.1876990795,
-0.2704539299,
-0.4949500859,
0.5878173709,
0.1647536308,
-0.5378829837,
-0.4565628469,
0.2877366245,
-0.6220462918,
-0.380010128,
-0.040330559,
-0.5969794393,
-0.3952757418,
0.3027600646,
0.6305374503,
0.2151946723,
-0.6050495505,
0.1705976576,
0.2462651879,
0.0814339519,
0.0679320246,
0.5592754483,
0.1665546596,
-0.621994555,
0.992405057,
0.288838774,
0.5208516717,
0.2133162767,
0.0643638894,
-0.4565713704,
-0.7016800046,
-1.2204315662,
-0.1522168964,
-0.6140589714,
-0.0368537866,
-0.0362431556,
-0.131698221,
-0.5896215439,
-0.1988884509,
-0.3365612626,
-0.5345569849,
-0.1180727482,
0.1367900968,
-0.0150230424,
0.9263129234,
-0.1572369635,
-0.083623074,
-0.834974587,
-0.1582398713,
0.0252627451,
0.2037872225,
-0.330519557,
-0.7428181767,
-0.2727610171,
-0.1093012765,
-0.4661529958,
-0.7139984369,
0.2951835692,
0.2949387431,
0.362287432,
0.3073936701,
0.3245120347,
0.7158481479,
-0.6516802311,
0.6767795682,
0.1286520511,
-1.2264260054,
0.2717803717,
-0.2834148705,
0.2915935218,
0.826944232,
-0.2320275307,
-0.8382743001,
-0.7188733816,
-0.4861247241,
-0.7420572639,
0.4699690342,
0.2662209868,
0.0269224234,
-0.040736232,
0.10477826,
0.2890233994,
0.2383881658,
-0.2312835157,
0.0308198333,
-0.212473169,
-0.1325892508,
-0.410713762,
0.0927087292,
0.0124915838,
0.0333585031,
0.4159179628,
0.018553514,
-0.0509855859,
0.0720746219,
-0.2367913276,
-0.1226970181,
0.5036304593,
0.3977149725,
0.3492029011,
-0.0836713761,
0.2311276793,
0.41175282,
-0.1827010065,
0.120194979,
0.2555088997,
-0.4455365241,
0.3519959748,
0.4654569924,
0.7000591755,
0.162866503,
-0.6390374303,
0.2753954828,
0.2577655911,
-0.4077851772,
0.1256161779,
-0.0243959799,
-0.0472798385,
0.0806508288,
-0.0453884751,
0.2773128152,
0.24543266,
-0.2415315807,
0.2389297485,
0.2093052566,
-0.67005831,
-0.5817722082,
0.5728613734,
0.2127388567,
-0.6411930323,
0.5176546574,
-0.4721329808,
-0.385486871,
0.4364948571,
0.3397953808,
1.1126897335,
-0.1003204435,
0.2138899714,
0.2567866743,
0.6114097834,
-0.1210078299,
0.1103160828,
-0.0565008409,
-0.446259737,
0.0398628637,
-0.5835507512,
-0.6269126534,
-0.1747860909,
-0.8854874372,
0.3137406409,
-0.1669767499,
-0.4561926126,
-0.1358098537,
-0.1940045357,
-0.5432975888,
0.0585947298,
-0.0059718224,
0.8678284883,
-1.0172208548,
0.96221596,
0.8440701365,
-0.0180883333,
-0.3192975819,
0.3076814711,
0.1730804145,
-0.6245850325,
0.1468009651,
0.1591760516,
-0.3110301495,
-0.2129472494,
0.0856256112,
-0.4888837636,
0.5814957023,
0.5434327722,
-0.2602616847,
0.4008691311,
0.6124553084,
0.7910762429,
0.0275792852,
-0.1286993176,
0.9144402146,
0.7623543143,
-0.1445830762,
-1.1876305342,
-0.2322232574,
-0.2230207175,
0.2367171198,
0.3771747947,
-0.4537554383,
0.5799966455,
0.0847918168,
-0.4027818441,
0.8117595911,
0.3973467946,
-0.2140630037,
0.2404530346,
0.6367221475,
0.7537738681,
0.8797810674,
-0.2847115695,
0.8606956005,
-0.1918796003,
0.2478009164,
1.0504006147,
-0.3934759498,
0.9346740246,
0.3907584846,
-0.2896736264,
0.2726349235,
0.6087288857,
0.0696646795,
0.3646709025,
0.2619044185,
-0.1640406102,
-0.4208723903,
-0.0663413554,
-0.266141206,
0.4545427263,
0.1193822622,
-0.2395764738,
-0.3703737855,
-0.4972752035,
-0.0154559957,
0.4729166627,
0.227783531,
0.6683834791,
0.0695988163,
-0.7854892612,
0.9049720168,
0.40457654,
0.4777260423,
-0.6512943506,
0.4193240404,
-0.5011635423,
0.1968625337,
-0.1342503279,
-0.553563416,
0.5627590418,
0.3033961058,
-0.2229186893,
-0.2567676008,
0.2979272306,
-0.2096811384,
-0.669120729,
0.2296462208,
0.6513629556,
0.4238880575,
0.1691113114,
-0.4612339437,
-0.0180757735,
0.0164305419,
0.0783294961,
0.414249301,
0.6961522698,
-0.2917341888,
0.1376018822,
0.2527852356,
0.1369241476,
0.1529476792,
0.0770109966,
0.4278050363,
-0.4668339491,
-0.3055139184,
-0.6680754423,
0.2135035545,
-0.00946787,
-0.5410094261,
0.9981037378,
0.6776627302,
0.907578826,
0.1014914215,
0.7936705351,
-0.2007735223,
0.4514847398,
-0.3087861836,
0.6715884209,
-0.7875164151,
-0.0934209377,
-0.1738103181,
-0.8430270553,
-0.4318579435,
0.4087545872,
-0.2495606393,
-0.1453074813,
0.6398938894,
0.7873588204,
-0.1145696789,
0.2281993181,
0.5540055037,
0.0271929894,
-0.0534933545,
0.4952368438,
0.4723485112,
-0.1702706069,
0.7660260201,
-0.1606596857,
-0.3118183911,
-0.0926696435,
-0.9674044251,
-0.7255938053,
-0.4597702026,
-0.063754648,
-0.4092490971,
0.4263007045,
0.5506299734,
0.8337187767,
-0.986903429,
-0.7663935423,
0.069875665,
0.0409235433,
-0.5039227605,
-0.1096545756,
0.2351973206,
-0.6189347506,
-0.9529705048,
0.5642858744,
0.3838774264,
-0.0994056463,
-0.2666294575,
-0.1117281616,
0.4997129738,
0.09708336,
0.2460601628,
0.3238196373,
-0.6666951776,
-0.5723721385,
0.0874451473,
-0.2778128386,
0.3899205029,
0.614246726,
-0.2549373209,
0.8122096658,
0.4653197229,
0.5811955929,
0.2121342421,
0.0058165798,
0.6587179899,
-0.9792804718,
0.1014094278,
0.081686981,
0.3487606347,
0.6736623645,
0.2307466269,
0.4713990986,
0.3608618379,
-0.3970578313,
-0.6799452901,
0.4262357652,
-0.6373910904,
0.1825628877,
0.9116268754,
-0.3750216365,
-0.15618141,
-0.2525166571,
0.1192239001,
-0.0515214168,
-0.4058241546,
0.8493541479,
0.9506804943,
-0.0297932718,
0.3398077488,
-0.6199753881,
0.1668068469,
0.5084435344,
-0.6213665009,
0.0014835758,
0.5470096469,
0.3293727338,
-0.0247670654,
0.5265496373,
-0.2425275296,
0.2158256769,
0.1769214123,
0.0816499069,
0.2200507224,
-0.0606062524,
-0.3371833861,
-0.1718751043,
0.2742833197,
-0.2470626235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16842v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16842v2
|
RELIC: Investigating Large Language Model Responses using Self-Consistency
| 2023-11-28T14:55:52 | 2024-04-04T15:18:30 |
Furui Cheng, Vilém Zouhar, Simran Arora, Mrinmaya Sachan, Hendrik Strobelt, Mennatallah El-Assady
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are notorious for blending fact with fiction and
generating non-factual content, known as hallucinations. To address this
challenge, we propose an interactive system that helps users gain insight into
the reliability of the generated text. Our approach is based on the idea that
the self-consistency of multiple samples generated by the same LLM relates to
its confidence in individual claims in the generated texts. Using this idea, we
design RELIC, an interactive system that enables users to investigate and
verify semantic-level variations in multiple long-form responses. This allows
users to recognize potentially inaccurate information in the generated text and
make necessary corrections. From a user study with ten participants, we
demonstrate that our approach helps users better verify the reliability of the
generated text. We further summarize the design implications and lessons
learned from this research for future studies of reliable human-LLM
interactions.
|
[
-0.1670357585,
-1.044623971,
0.8764030933,
0.5372844338,
0.1113967299,
-0.0530252196,
-0.4237447679,
-0.585056603,
0.5916718245,
0.6921040416,
-0.3915654719,
-0.3543249071,
-0.4598396719,
0.4840959311,
-0.8547751307,
0.837256968,
-0.0407972112,
-0.093224071,
-0.4156329334,
-0.0833747387,
-0.6134572029,
-0.50872159,
-0.5738527179,
-0.3648816645,
0.6817790866,
0.1775940061,
0.7543813586,
0.4091100693,
0.593762815,
0.3893432915,
0.1751112789,
0.4925142229,
-0.700009346,
0.5990250111,
-0.4367587566,
-0.20197469,
-0.5895410776,
-0.1615528613,
0.5912719965,
0.3689773977,
-0.2153904438,
0.0256728977,
0.4951535463,
0.0777497515,
-0.5018438101,
-0.0856835619,
-0.4818559587,
-0.220056951,
-0.2867250144,
-0.3659062088,
-0.8177415729,
-0.3035468161,
-0.0785631016,
-0.6688885689,
0.1707240492,
0.1955834478,
0.7997682095,
0.2716345787,
-0.4155344069,
-0.4663244486,
-1.0059540272,
0.6433708668,
-0.8242444992,
0.3908631504,
0.5449202061,
0.1348067671,
-0.5101282597,
-0.7069869637,
-0.9448878169,
-0.5732211471,
-0.3965613842,
0.1215749905,
0.1606742591,
-0.1452656835,
0.1396434456,
0.2717473805,
-0.6322512031,
0.1318554878,
-0.1113964915,
-0.5511588454,
0.5937656164,
0.3705476522,
0.5178982615,
-0.5387585163,
-0.3467702568,
-0.1991493702,
-0.6742461324,
-0.3869281709,
0.4506424367,
0.1692843437,
-0.001524231,
0.8971206546,
0.0122001348,
0.4731427729,
0.0958487019,
-0.35147205,
0.3299826682,
-0.3186044395,
-0.0915704966,
-0.0003025867,
1.0221284628,
0.2579939663,
0.0954435095,
-0.2786207199,
-0.294644475,
-0.2718962431,
0.6289622188,
-0.5385977626,
-0.1514842212,
0.5324785113,
-0.500442028,
-0.2130560428,
0.1231378689,
-0.5748416781,
-0.6881640553,
-0.3447360098,
0.6848470569,
-0.6383997798,
-0.4951523244,
0.1644364744,
-0.0027790738,
-0.1923891902,
0.5291069746,
-0.8620195985,
0.2339084148,
0.5865783095,
0.7285604477,
-0.4843467772,
-0.7512986064,
-0.6446852088,
0.3804752529,
-0.2994464934,
0.8922800422,
-0.0751762465,
-0.467974782,
-0.0797526017,
-0.0463406108,
0.2727314234,
-0.5970284343,
0.5569552779,
-0.3705779612,
0.296847105,
-0.3165839314,
-0.7851753235,
0.3438323438,
0.5355014205,
-0.7038375735,
1.2979658842,
-0.0526476987,
-0.9815691113,
0.2254496962,
-0.2551977038,
-0.1283330023,
0.1682778597,
-0.5358271003,
-0.3500551283,
0.2751871049,
-0.2308381349,
0.2439889908,
0.0591185354,
0.3995405734,
-0.5190533996,
-0.2694719732,
0.6472630501,
-0.5100885034,
0.5108926892,
0.1726273149,
-0.379162401,
0.1326224357,
-0.7102535367,
-0.0350123346,
0.1347714812,
-0.4043752849,
-0.3936644495,
0.1158450469,
0.2064915299,
0.0636334419,
0.4390282929,
-0.5691292286,
0.197067067,
-0.1415673643,
-0.1118535623,
0.808182478,
-0.0595668554,
0.011922746,
-0.2453077286,
0.2855924368,
0.1219912469,
-0.0133995144,
-0.4228369296,
-0.1542703211,
-0.8785366416,
-0.0131789679,
0.2999792993,
0.2031162381,
-0.6131078601,
0.5502521396,
-0.3821997344,
-0.1910905838,
-0.3580199778,
0.3471922576,
0.232011497,
0.5248115659,
0.321695894,
-0.1827159673,
-0.5777370334,
-0.9789821506,
-0.2241405696,
-0.4558065236,
-0.3992544711,
0.3147372007,
0.5450527072,
-0.4011159241,
1.2080546618,
-0.345692724,
-0.1503834873,
-0.0597955547,
0.5363681912,
-0.2509888709,
0.4207689762,
0.4217478335,
-0.4856258929,
-0.3589819372,
-0.0671051815,
-1.250269413,
-0.0982681438,
-0.2540764809,
0.0057933852,
0.3373760879,
0.4702646732,
-0.4718566835,
0.3598357737,
0.7908587456,
-0.3378610909,
0.5378372073,
-0.5078697801,
0.4263245165,
-1.1425191164,
0.1586725861,
-0.1675353497,
-0.2253060788,
-0.4243246317,
-0.1116145253,
0.2098894268,
0.3256780803,
-0.0752852932,
0.7133337855,
-0.5131748319,
0.118529357,
-0.542994976,
0.3444780111,
-0.0339708067,
-0.107921876,
-0.0087242117,
0.7669536471,
0.1271767318,
-0.3773820102,
0.2129482776,
0.2808451951,
-0.2400090247,
0.8578755856,
-0.7693915367,
0.5236777663,
-0.1560711265,
0.208194986,
-1.1775826216,
-0.6999935508,
0.0169205889,
-0.4996385574,
0.1547068208,
0.0278556496,
-0.8019447327,
-0.1600738466,
-0.1552934796,
0.2417116612,
0.314881295,
-0.5876325965,
0.9281074405,
0.302662015,
-0.0712709203,
-0.5861981511,
-0.6316130161,
0.4714697301,
-0.0104427254,
-0.8338696361,
0.0243371744,
-0.3121672571,
-0.5829184055,
-0.1141209528,
0.0865145028,
0.0641544685,
0.0258688089,
0.4640646279,
0.1989332885,
-0.1992292553,
0.28218624,
-0.1606745124,
0.169014141,
0.1556341797,
0.0109254392,
0.6231881976,
0.0514563918,
-0.5655192733,
-0.4782103002,
0.2179563046,
0.539278686,
0.1436098069,
0.6761295199,
0.4363686144,
-0.3640494347,
-0.3106370866,
-0.9186694026,
-0.4497030973,
-0.5026733279,
0.00699424,
-0.4373004735,
-0.9164121747,
0.6959459186,
0.0228227228,
-0.021478951,
0.5434235334,
0.6790727973,
-0.2721166015,
0.768460691,
0.6948631406,
0.2752602994,
0.0679044425,
0.2352193147,
-0.0823568329,
-0.598500669,
-0.4766141474,
-0.4214819372,
-0.1234288514,
-0.1897727996,
-0.2663897574,
0.4289844036,
-0.1251620203,
0.0416223258,
0.080314897,
-0.2826643288,
0.5403595567,
0.4596194029,
0.1473921686,
0.6384407282,
-0.0493827909,
-0.0006146046,
-0.2334289998,
-0.2057897598,
-0.7053738236,
0.9618353844,
0.369412899,
1.2560195923,
0.1168279275,
0.8542202115,
0.6137726307,
0.4141824245,
-0.4286179543,
0.4174422324,
0.2578758895,
-0.8648130298,
-0.5594672561,
-0.5438275933,
-1.0332022905,
0.0167405624,
-0.5509613156,
-0.6919722557,
-0.0802681595,
0.3715652525,
-0.2943010628,
0.113675274,
-0.3502720892,
0.6063690186,
-0.414750576,
-0.5421246886,
-0.1857649088,
-0.5725123882,
0.439645499,
-0.2701504529,
0.1000337005,
0.0630052313,
0.286283344,
0.5267820954,
-0.3231788874,
1.0638951063,
0.2838823199,
-0.5911753774,
0.2819959819,
0.5780560374,
0.58094275,
0.2402066439,
-0.0274856091,
0.2161113471,
-0.3272392452,
-0.207365036,
-0.6734383702,
0.9499978423,
-0.7302667499,
-0.5982028842,
-0.4107765257,
-0.5315048695,
0.0030292429,
0.3793692291,
0.1706302762,
0.3160273731,
-0.5893685818,
0.2692939043,
0.8721596599,
-0.0988275036,
0.1955510378,
0.5218387246,
-0.570545435,
-0.4432178438,
0.5139392018,
0.1384399086,
0.2329504341,
0.0907999948,
0.1156156734,
-0.3126455247,
-0.487798214,
-0.5954391956,
0.334108144,
-0.5671973228,
-0.0791468844,
-0.7498416305,
-0.2103515267,
-0.3670011759,
0.0677995756,
-0.585011065,
-0.169080019,
-0.1990801096,
-0.1126800403,
0.3000541925,
1.1832921505,
-0.039162945,
0.1585476398,
-0.7862823606,
0.4037270248,
0.2597131133,
0.3891672194,
-0.0330447592,
-0.5965254903,
-0.2120918483,
0.1174388751,
-0.1544847786,
-0.9320284724,
0.1335697919,
-0.1649798006,
0.4653715193,
0.3436406553,
0.0208851472,
0.4233398438,
-0.5943343043,
0.9244163036,
0.1785738319,
-1.0234186649,
0.5036949515,
-0.5291406512,
0.0940112099,
0.5983609557,
0.2386434823,
-0.6751328111,
-0.8102481961,
-0.5994024873,
-0.5116257071,
0.2744322121,
0.2317410856,
0.2501270771,
-0.2864651382,
0.474708885,
0.3409979641,
-0.124432303,
-0.6619362235,
-0.2461815625,
-0.3115134835,
-0.3332358897,
0.0166395642,
-0.495259136,
-0.3518051803,
0.3479756415,
0.3456737101,
-0.3090647757,
-0.2558344305,
0.3220578134,
-0.1492083222,
-0.1648195982,
0.1360062659,
0.7357115746,
0.9661562443,
-0.1762966365,
0.5947882533,
0.2924482822,
-0.4612602293,
0.101711899,
-0.3504664898,
-0.1378356367,
0.1549097151,
0.4075740278,
0.3330544829,
0.1676518321,
-0.7000520229,
0.5676479936,
-0.3164763451,
-0.1571154147,
-0.6389303207,
0.0106919939,
0.242920056,
0.1031118557,
0.3890075982,
-0.1818794459,
0.1541906744,
-0.5914409757,
0.3227854967,
0.3333879411,
-0.077892296,
-0.422131449,
0.7935948372,
0.0917932391,
-0.387137264,
0.9190623164,
0.063989453,
-0.0650199875,
0.1637385935,
0.7254920006,
0.8139083385,
-0.2732826769,
0.325006485,
0.2537416518,
0.3153392673,
-0.4452190101,
0.1406561583,
0.4359768331,
-0.7075354457,
-0.619253695,
-0.529471159,
-0.6715205312,
0.2901867628,
-0.5702995062,
0.3201554716,
-0.2442238927,
-0.2821768522,
-0.1545716673,
-0.399007231,
-0.2905671895,
0.1933715791,
0.0650547892,
0.6942594647,
-0.8306338191,
0.8463085294,
0.3841401637,
-0.5651916862,
-0.7551285625,
0.1371489018,
0.1142471433,
-0.6162628531,
0.772089541,
-0.2037932724,
-0.4347231388,
-0.4349789917,
-0.6620673537,
-0.9291378856,
0.9427269101,
0.5103576779,
-0.3616454899,
0.1559080929,
0.2248077244,
0.7749102712,
-0.1118386462,
0.3319468796,
0.2580162585,
0.5393167138,
0.0374812894,
-1.2256916761,
0.2291005105,
-0.0671373904,
-0.2008968592,
0.1049601808,
-0.6666762829,
0.7539558411,
-0.110037066,
-0.2159838676,
0.2307953387,
1.1414074898,
0.4359019101,
0.2845532298,
0.5603374839,
0.5169625282,
0.9625574946,
0.1034527197,
0.9265708327,
-0.3867128789,
0.5324338675,
1.4070543051,
-0.4105869234,
0.9882085323,
0.4980531633,
0.133335337,
0.6764338613,
0.226710692,
-0.0534835458,
-0.0754554495,
0.0947762504,
-0.2948013246,
-0.3712588251,
0.026182523,
-0.2254476696,
0.3956334889,
0.1192793474,
-0.353522867,
-0.0797444209,
-0.1222858801,
0.1782954186,
0.2189306021,
0.2385742664,
0.6984906197,
-0.0023718707,
-0.7414748073,
0.485853672,
-0.1960277557,
0.7197106481,
-0.6702776551,
-0.1798344404,
-0.3779506683,
0.198053956,
-0.4183624983,
-0.9345620275,
0.2227700949,
-0.1254326999,
-0.332305789,
-0.160758093,
0.6750482917,
-0.5212479234,
-0.3361491859,
0.2509233654,
0.6572951674,
0.3653155863,
0.1721841693,
-0.1997863799,
0.5228444338,
-0.1901803613,
-0.2961003482,
0.3754136562,
0.5272239447,
0.0593967438,
0.7848654389,
0.4061539173,
0.042619288,
-0.0344427973,
0.0640006065,
0.5313664675,
-0.6359845996,
0.0407058969,
-1.0292328596,
0.4789923728,
-0.4606649876,
-0.5413184166,
1.3112518787,
0.8053038716,
0.7435920835,
-0.1072199568,
0.7893953323,
0.0631931499,
0.5679502487,
-0.489882797,
0.8159909248,
-0.5459048152,
0.2934989035,
-0.1624831259,
-0.7236663699,
-0.1422665715,
0.5165565014,
0.1222855449,
-0.0106270416,
0.864651382,
0.7110109925,
-0.2635999322,
-0.1611190587,
0.3532931805,
0.5372630358,
0.3818152249,
-0.0570929088,
1.1477297544,
-0.0659734681,
0.4750398099,
0.0594247989,
-0.1215410456,
-0.2312737554,
-0.959415257,
-0.914748013,
-0.5381017327,
-0.196648553,
-0.970505774,
0.0437169671,
0.7311294675,
0.4696422517,
-0.6510294676,
-0.4946649075,
0.2690586746,
-0.1000779271,
0.2328979373,
-0.2301986963,
0.4120851457,
-0.5790616274,
-0.7677070498,
0.3827959299,
0.4800206125,
0.1200307384,
-0.8206871152,
-0.1051056013,
0.2881288826,
0.2757215798,
0.4611620009,
0.2265133411,
-0.8912885785,
-0.721259594,
0.2110395879,
-0.4243977964,
0.0437679477,
0.8965804577,
-0.5307078958,
0.5883159041,
0.4886095822,
0.5225140452,
0.4900771081,
0.150311932,
0.6864821315,
-0.6044635773,
-0.3587540686,
0.0482720695,
0.42389521,
0.4926468432,
-0.5004410148,
0.4512825906,
0.05075657,
-0.8396741748,
-0.8414117694,
0.1927962899,
-1.1570230722,
-0.2478614002,
1.3092534542,
-0.1950628012,
-0.1845144778,
-0.2301579267,
-0.3517505229,
-0.1656800359,
-0.1606031954,
1.3584038019,
0.9774694443,
-0.253243953,
0.2177453786,
-0.4204872549,
0.4933812618,
0.2853269875,
-0.934804976,
0.33139503,
0.779091835,
0.6029877663,
0.5739138126,
0.7811191678,
-0.0342124067,
0.0048356741,
0.0992158949,
0.2005097121,
0.1819956452,
-0.4199936092,
-0.1076998115,
0.3237001598,
0.215787828,
0.407879591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16840v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16840v1
|
The Claire French Dialogue Dataset
| 2023-11-28T14:55:22 | 2023-11-28T14:55:22 |
Julie Hunter, Jérôme Louradour, Virgile Rennard, Ismaïl Harrando, Guokan Shang, Jean-Pierre Lorré
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present the Claire French Dialogue Dataset (CFDD), a resource created by
members of LINAGORA Labs in the context of the OpenLLM France initiative. CFDD
is a corpus containing roughly 160 million words from transcripts and stage
plays in French that we have assembled and publicly released in an effort to
further the development of multilingual, open source language models. This
paper describes the 24 individual corpora of which CFDD is composed and
provides links and citations to their original sources. It also provides our
proposed breakdown of the full CFDD dataset into eight categories of subcorpora
and describes the process we followed to standardize the format of the final
dataset. We conclude with a discussion of similar work and future directions.
|
[
-0.6472707391,
-0.7416785359,
0.4963566661,
0.1265675277,
0.3324889541,
0.123390846,
-0.3394261599,
-0.0437946245,
0.2136619836,
1.0568799973,
-0.7108748555,
-0.6671175361,
-0.3212873936,
0.2546942234,
-0.660284102,
0.9356746674,
0.0770995617,
0.1540495306,
-0.1467663795,
-0.2526288927,
-0.1516176611,
-0.7079880834,
-0.4514106214,
0.3622843027,
0.7041425705,
0.7844242454,
0.8362692595,
0.2169043571,
0.3695766032,
0.2429468185,
-0.0739438161,
0.2286122441,
-0.8720304966,
-0.0156489126,
-0.4041595161,
-0.082981281,
-0.2388648093,
0.2104977667,
0.7331778407,
0.7480111122,
-0.1012452468,
-0.1559924334,
-0.1476528496,
0.5233445168,
-0.3222242296,
0.2354935706,
-0.0910609141,
-0.2152507454,
-0.1916495264,
0.044280082,
-0.404910028,
-0.3101199269,
0.1525254846,
-0.5374311805,
0.7936857939,
-0.1691264808,
0.4573706985,
-0.0357171483,
-0.3976923227,
-0.3402855694,
-0.8236825466,
0.4790334702,
-0.2997067273,
0.7197384238,
0.2661357224,
0.2034481168,
-0.2393408865,
-0.778021872,
-0.589643538,
0.0963110626,
-0.0428752415,
-0.0151634598,
-0.1700387299,
0.2280183882,
0.350061059,
0.6288676262,
-0.6062341332,
-0.1635494679,
-0.9262256026,
-0.1800201684,
0.7987847924,
0.075814262,
0.1021383256,
-0.1433641464,
-0.2888565958,
-0.2079468518,
-0.4488452971,
-0.0490661636,
0.4359187782,
0.583517909,
-0.3922344744,
0.6977128386,
-0.2286098301,
0.5988969207,
-0.3638603687,
0.2289679796,
0.3543279767,
-0.7176946998,
-0.3855585158,
0.0497562923,
0.9767778516,
0.3970785737,
0.4589091539,
-0.0598952025,
-0.1339839399,
-0.1151013672,
0.0850950405,
-0.6380755305,
-0.4407535493,
0.4006744623,
-0.2801602483,
-0.2538925707,
0.476203531,
-0.885402739,
-0.3619425893,
-0.4300428927,
-0.3027810752,
-0.3920923769,
-0.5168108344,
0.0068152356,
-0.1420606971,
-0.1698345691,
0.3076476455,
-0.8605645299,
0.5322078466,
0.5833154321,
0.8566148877,
-0.1808617562,
0.0383524708,
-0.8587103486,
-0.3318060637,
-0.646104455,
0.6090609431,
-0.5717815757,
-1.1630165577,
0.2728781104,
0.5055868626,
-0.0327414274,
-0.5400636196,
0.8221803308,
-0.0375130661,
0.2476241738,
-0.5912786722,
-0.5651991367,
-0.1784573048,
-0.1744691581,
-1.1406283379,
1.1140242815,
0.5393356085,
-0.5925660729,
0.0376778059,
-0.7422972322,
0.0057282494,
0.12050163,
-0.5554965734,
0.4298700392,
0.2354486734,
0.2884550095,
0.3639863133,
-0.6271905303,
0.4355805814,
-0.2104743272,
0.0104060983,
0.2533384264,
-0.3972898126,
0.8190027475,
0.6093261242,
0.1904377639,
0.0719545409,
-0.9303395748,
-0.3103407323,
-0.1663396209,
0.0778003111,
-0.2234655172,
-0.2000572979,
0.5317793489,
0.3904508352,
-0.2029848248,
-0.7972980738,
0.0637115985,
-0.3281980455,
0.3740336597,
0.6635002494,
0.1060817838,
0.4844291806,
-0.2925089896,
0.7364267111,
0.3190330863,
0.113100931,
-0.3182752728,
-0.5989301801,
-0.4764478803,
-0.5656965375,
0.4659385085,
0.4361424148,
-0.5567470789,
0.2198975533,
0.0024158657,
-0.2800983489,
-0.6667360067,
0.3201312721,
0.1803013086,
0.6075299382,
0.244260177,
-0.2863938212,
-0.3034220338,
-1.0082536936,
0.5154374838,
-0.0889923647,
0.0357908048,
0.2560187578,
0.3503906131,
-0.2245947719,
1.2513928413,
-0.5370436907,
-0.3295717835,
-0.1381456405,
0.1330559999,
0.1956500709,
0.4092952311,
0.8795567751,
-0.7088772058,
-0.1421813667,
-0.2170992047,
-0.5872996449,
-0.1340910941,
0.1993138343,
-0.5429677963,
0.2498815805,
0.8876870871,
-0.3718892336,
0.4027484953,
0.8065873384,
-0.5031511188,
0.2837456465,
0.0262030158,
0.1331474036,
-1.2138162851,
-0.1072537377,
-0.1224508658,
-0.0681132525,
-0.5551648736,
-0.2727324665,
-0.0156582054,
-0.1989348978,
-0.666975081,
0.7849139571,
-0.1588951498,
0.1580509543,
0.325156033,
0.2886492908,
-0.0301094446,
0.3156329989,
0.4021780193,
0.7702253461,
0.4381304979,
-0.344222337,
0.6533250809,
0.7628827691,
-0.2999115884,
0.6542140841,
-0.5321316719,
-0.0010792288,
-0.1355074942,
0.2658610642,
-1.0717623234,
-0.2815565765,
0.1917038858,
-0.0966232121,
-0.1874428093,
0.2111145407,
-0.5065484643,
-0.1387107968,
-0.0524556004,
0.5365434289,
0.0861058831,
-0.520688355,
0.4159110785,
0.4448982775,
-0.4516329169,
-0.3683657646,
-0.4636835158,
-0.0730728284,
0.1925206184,
-0.987968564,
0.263695091,
-0.5440657139,
-0.6562456489,
0.2018828243,
0.1818169802,
-0.0554552674,
-0.3914577067,
0.4029404223,
0.1683996916,
-0.5478698015,
0.4499970078,
-0.077754721,
0.1960526556,
-0.0237753186,
-0.0864761844,
0.4750504196,
0.0782736763,
-0.1508624405,
-0.1816283166,
0.6853308082,
0.4723546505,
-0.162985906,
0.7523003817,
0.6441506743,
-0.3164956272,
-0.3921455443,
-0.3780277073,
0.0321756788,
-0.4183034897,
-0.1617771387,
-0.4074963927,
-0.9862487316,
0.5990283489,
0.2152975351,
0.2058033943,
0.6183691621,
0.5245450139,
0.2407325059,
0.5939641595,
0.7510604858,
-0.0013940093,
0.2970422804,
-0.5310688019,
0.2619241178,
-0.5479267836,
-0.3224436045,
-0.7121966481,
0.1040706187,
-0.6360898614,
-0.81223315,
0.0393478014,
0.0435232818,
0.0189643633,
0.2324796319,
-0.3386977613,
0.2534808815,
0.6586191654,
-0.0490265749,
0.4262222946,
-0.1085227057,
-0.3720535934,
0.0399267785,
-0.7141591311,
-0.5765669942,
1.2096470594,
0.2624719441,
0.6631614566,
0.3490690291,
0.594542861,
0.40477705,
0.1996466964,
-0.5488234758,
0.3430573046,
-0.2821341455,
-0.772077024,
-0.2993444502,
-0.3882420659,
-0.5537154675,
-0.0685514957,
-0.2707063258,
-0.4970599413,
0.5407263637,
-0.3638573289,
-0.5456491709,
-0.0647933558,
-0.737724483,
1.0797590017,
0.0637191683,
-0.1347221285,
-0.0914384425,
-0.3101995587,
0.643147707,
-0.3181203008,
0.5298247337,
-0.2381608188,
0.3431666493,
0.8876850605,
-0.7329797149,
0.4958496094,
0.144667685,
-0.5855670571,
0.4580300152,
-0.2037345618,
-0.0788869932,
0.6147342324,
-0.0586182997,
0.1507854015,
0.3363588154,
-0.3964166343,
-0.2564472854,
0.9092306495,
-0.6580189466,
-0.1777722389,
-0.6331278086,
-0.6356952786,
-0.3215647936,
-0.0136692142,
0.2654195726,
1.0395742655,
-1.1779309511,
0.2133931816,
0.8159540892,
-0.6426442862,
0.2043823004,
0.4230030775,
-0.6213250756,
-0.4313369095,
0.6660048962,
0.0265564583,
0.3844498396,
0.3474739492,
-0.3585903943,
-0.4653291702,
0.0145194074,
-0.1446113735,
0.5007164478,
-0.848111093,
0.1256345659,
-0.7245567441,
-0.5764227509,
-0.8905870318,
-0.274268955,
-0.2662859261,
-0.6434252858,
-0.4427704215,
-0.5802331567,
0.635833919,
0.9205685258,
-0.2343769073,
0.1118748337,
-0.7978687286,
0.6128133535,
0.1247622594,
0.3281988204,
-0.6611338854,
0.0166703798,
-0.0365942083,
0.1345937401,
-0.0930611193,
-0.5704077482,
0.2901022732,
0.2096634209,
0.5291927457,
0.436958611,
0.3707193434,
0.0636165142,
-0.2738631964,
1.161028862,
0.2291495204,
-0.5887223482,
0.3094106317,
-0.3501693308,
0.308873713,
0.3262407184,
0.4650093615,
-0.7158241868,
-0.3808521926,
-0.8751251698,
-0.520606339,
0.8955545425,
0.2494754046,
0.148934707,
-0.4328405559,
-0.2536902726,
0.2322246283,
0.1068080738,
0.3227717578,
-0.0892438814,
-0.1457393467,
-0.5999637246,
-0.7386038303,
-0.2982021272,
-0.6303867102,
-0.2215133905,
0.5990674496,
-0.2107348591,
0.2446559519,
0.3859599829,
0.0345818624,
0.0142181432,
0.100668259,
0.7074418664,
0.7983539701,
-0.3650042117,
-0.1649022847,
-0.3484989703,
-0.6202589273,
-0.1298421472,
0.2760122418,
0.1258578748,
0.566311419,
0.2843089104,
0.7100085616,
0.2646918595,
-1.1009548903,
0.4772340357,
-0.4367099106,
-0.6724434495,
-0.5849556327,
0.0678873807,
0.0653894618,
0.3593115509,
0.14080064,
-0.1308721751,
-0.1199049801,
-0.6462334394,
0.5704114437,
0.0824309215,
-0.6523007751,
-0.2935063839,
0.8102499843,
0.4888319671,
-0.1224673539,
0.9444552064,
0.118657954,
-0.0124477725,
0.4212604463,
-0.1677340269,
0.9112920761,
-0.2643816471,
0.9068440199,
0.528454721,
0.2210455835,
-0.1059361473,
0.5948566794,
0.1719643027,
-0.8374353647,
-0.0421660356,
-1.0056493282,
-0.4453205168,
0.2849072218,
-0.5828983784,
0.5734647512,
-0.667450726,
-0.0809740126,
0.2920706272,
-0.3217127323,
-0.8853666782,
0.157285884,
0.1160860881,
1.4236603975,
-0.7210720181,
0.857702136,
-0.0040397416,
-0.7388513088,
-0.5361617208,
-0.3403879106,
0.4066626728,
-0.2759327888,
0.6124327183,
-0.2122714818,
-0.0059469729,
-0.1089235619,
-0.4669897854,
-0.7195587754,
0.7495728731,
0.3207494915,
-0.6770039797,
-0.0868905708,
0.1949957907,
0.4648208618,
-0.8051694632,
0.0998675451,
0.81077981,
0.3647461236,
0.1647602022,
-0.9098488688,
-0.1626912653,
-0.4008387625,
-0.0194326509,
-0.0281267278,
-0.5627549291,
0.8886239529,
-0.029166339,
-0.221026212,
0.2678792179,
0.673040092,
-0.2672192156,
-0.1194488928,
0.2893650532,
0.2912742198,
0.8138639927,
-0.325640291,
0.8834607005,
-0.3639097512,
0.1508039683,
0.9937846661,
-0.2154147476,
0.5814164281,
0.1165748537,
0.2006872445,
0.3543248773,
0.6480078697,
0.2196157128,
0.4026364982,
0.1489108354,
-0.4661130309,
0.0157858338,
-0.4149168134,
-0.2873144448,
0.2498818338,
0.7109643221,
-0.7082702518,
-0.1507035792,
0.1784160435,
-0.114748463,
0.2950864732,
-0.0933757201,
0.6133642197,
0.2118863463,
-0.7290101647,
0.5781519413,
-0.2980959117,
0.0792025924,
-0.4812755287,
-0.1162927821,
-0.3122138679,
0.1746729016,
-0.2587186694,
-0.7976434231,
0.3604974151,
0.1744144708,
-0.2173209786,
-0.3923459053,
-0.0978170037,
-0.950663507,
-0.7101294398,
0.4353683591,
0.5020570159,
0.1330957115,
0.0698695332,
-0.4638180435,
0.3279255629,
-0.1641571671,
0.0144248502,
0.0229065921,
0.6720582843,
-0.1854762435,
0.2288751751,
0.4471332729,
-0.1824515313,
0.1444478035,
0.4568278491,
0.8718001246,
-0.6561915874,
-0.4409984648,
-0.1251764596,
0.5695676208,
-0.100543797,
-0.6245850921,
0.5431179404,
0.6963014603,
1.1431881189,
0.0067326087,
1.1656092405,
-0.3023273647,
0.7000425458,
-0.8035437465,
0.3258292675,
-0.290633589,
0.0954113528,
-0.5579329133,
-0.9708032012,
0.056152042,
0.3791791201,
0.135447681,
-0.2182790488,
1.0345057249,
1.1961057186,
-0.2174206078,
0.584597528,
0.3946157992,
0.3943071365,
0.4470185041,
0.2176045328,
0.5378633738,
-0.2018538266,
0.4140762985,
-0.2787351906,
-0.3442122638,
-0.1093999669,
-0.5981593132,
-0.9740030766,
-1.3548244238,
-0.3766761124,
-0.5649033785,
-0.0941022336,
1.0517272949,
0.4375238419,
-1.0534490347,
-0.4201897681,
0.0287705977,
-0.0688685924,
-0.0971973389,
-0.2436256856,
0.1215563193,
-0.2599578202,
-0.9733535051,
0.6181171536,
0.0977540091,
-0.2093498111,
-0.4968742728,
-0.373494029,
-0.4234192669,
0.4716176391,
0.576351583,
0.268379271,
-0.6216776967,
-0.3340158165,
0.2544871569,
-0.2037150711,
-0.1477376223,
0.9432531595,
-0.5869784951,
0.8367854953,
0.6798878312,
0.3230642676,
0.5282316804,
0.0535873882,
1.2215745449,
-0.7251028419,
0.3161305189,
-0.0343100093,
0.4072482288,
0.3956005275,
-0.119277589,
0.9860470891,
0.3765903711,
-0.3128070533,
-0.6763441563,
0.2068252563,
-1.1691724062,
-0.2538903654,
1.1930744648,
0.0556452051,
-0.0883816928,
-0.337759465,
-0.5910981297,
-0.0848580971,
-0.7237198353,
0.2357549816,
1.264185667,
0.0934939533,
-0.3170221746,
-0.8527928591,
0.9979000688,
-0.2564359307,
-0.4215849042,
0.1773246825,
0.8816092014,
0.0541635342,
0.2599100173,
1.1837967634,
-0.1952291876,
0.0546810701,
-0.0864182264,
-0.1859344095,
0.3422903717,
-0.5913522243,
-0.3283978105,
0.1168235466,
-0.3304898143,
0.2126578391
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16839v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16839v2
|
Beyond Hallucinations: Enhancing LVLMs through Hallucination-Aware Direct Preference Optimization
| 2023-11-28T14:54:37 | 2024-02-06T16:43:31 |
Zhiyuan Zhao, Bin Wang, Linke Ouyang, Xiaoyi Dong, Jiaqi Wang, Conghui He
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Multimodal large language models have made significant advancements in recent
years, yet they still suffer from a common issue known as the "hallucination
problem", in which the models generate textual descriptions that inaccurately
depict or entirely fabricate content from associated images. This paper
introduces a novel solution, Hallucination-Aware Direct Preference Optimization
(HA-DPO), which reframes the hallucination problem as a preference selection
task. The model is trained to favor the non-hallucinating response when
presented with two responses of the same image (one accurate and one
hallucinatory). Furthermore, this paper proposes an efficient pipeline for
constructing positive~(non-hallucinatory) and negative~(hallucinatory) sample
pairs, ensuring a high-quality, style-consistent dataset for robust preference
learning. When applied to three mainstream multimodal models, HA-DPO
significantly reduced hallucination issues and amplified the models'
generalization capabilities. Notably, the MiniGPT-4 model, when enhanced with
HA-DPO, demonstrated a substantial improvement: POPE accuracy rose from 51.13%
to 86.13% (an absolute improvement of 35%), and the MME score surged from
932.00 to 1326.46 (a relative improvement of 42.32%). The codes, models, and
datasets are made accessible at https://opendatalab.github.io/HA-DPO.
|
[
-0.406862855,
-0.6359124184,
0.7220084667,
0.1186453402,
-0.2998986542,
-0.1562588513,
-0.3225880265,
-0.4064002335,
0.4646922946,
0.6130358577,
-0.5602294803,
-0.3661847413,
-0.4697392881,
0.1031743288,
0.1173625067,
0.5213319063,
0.2080115378,
0.2085039169,
-0.2568270862,
-0.0446239039,
-0.5681108236,
-0.6533714533,
-0.3659513891,
-0.3088919222,
0.5972369909,
0.3871720731,
0.9122975469,
0.5645164251,
0.5837302208,
0.1878594011,
0.1121588573,
0.606112659,
-0.5743707418,
0.314112395,
0.0238194987,
-0.0421437733,
-0.620803237,
-0.150386855,
0.2598924339,
0.4054018259,
-0.0882369727,
-0.187150538,
0.0292463545,
0.9776811004,
-0.6959527731,
-0.0374587476,
-0.9091005921,
0.3996974826,
0.2393373549,
-0.6136510968,
-0.5877017975,
-0.3084893525,
0.2119815499,
-0.7767161131,
0.0541085489,
0.146871984,
0.5634800196,
0.6485294104,
-0.3056240976,
-0.4129294753,
-0.5668256879,
1.0241267681,
-0.2941796184,
0.8341782093,
0.6468565464,
0.1177187786,
-0.2418339849,
-0.2473690361,
-0.3993031085,
-0.6062307358,
0.0227820799,
0.1185404658,
-0.0104824202,
0.1054525748,
0.1892253011,
0.3408470452,
-0.5062265396,
0.0847721174,
-0.0049386509,
-0.2587075233,
0.4703368247,
-0.0024324721,
-0.0698956475,
-0.3947061598,
-0.3108647466,
-0.0912208185,
-0.4126245975,
-0.1382022649,
0.2561506927,
0.2917205691,
0.3533634245,
0.5780014992,
-0.0232935101,
0.618667841,
0.1845642626,
-0.3672458231,
0.5517678261,
-0.1281801611,
-0.3716706038,
-0.0087702377,
0.4868767262,
0.5036938787,
0.1753423065,
-0.1119666845,
-0.2253489345,
0.238470763,
0.4285160005,
-0.724619627,
-0.2576548159,
0.4073108733,
-0.6550215483,
-0.5914335251,
-0.2657114565,
-1.0206497908,
-0.8524879217,
-0.5832617283,
0.4635374248,
-0.4270725548,
-0.3362245262,
0.4041452408,
0.1284816414,
-0.1017032936,
0.4236139357,
-1.0032099485,
0.0916595235,
0.2823358774,
0.8101559877,
-0.5205540657,
-0.2171889246,
-0.7616484761,
-0.0036129798,
-0.392849803,
0.5842400193,
-0.5843386054,
-0.5215161443,
0.0591908395,
-0.1645289361,
0.1696667522,
-0.8051345348,
0.775724411,
-0.3807870448,
0.0130899632,
-0.3224070072,
-0.323685199,
-0.0543092191,
0.2605293095,
-0.7662314177,
0.9014232159,
-0.128619045,
-0.545311451,
0.3526839614,
-0.4127901196,
-0.1641737074,
-0.2288210392,
-0.3881677091,
-0.5027287006,
0.2280145288,
0.3874594569,
0.5248270631,
0.0095726131,
0.3698184192,
-0.5022718906,
-0.4118439555,
0.0988665223,
-0.2603519559,
0.4607898593,
0.0753650889,
-0.4215099216,
0.5935297608,
-0.8842594624,
-0.1914102286,
0.2933012843,
-0.0266317856,
-0.4865891337,
-0.018267272,
-0.2232486159,
0.1817051619,
0.2042241246,
-0.1998651773,
0.3311026096,
-0.1106170118,
0.1348887384,
1.2461248636,
-0.3201130629,
0.5121801496,
-0.3066744506,
0.2523417771,
-0.0386037268,
0.5522695184,
0.2902639508,
-0.4683965445,
-0.7961073518,
-0.4261936545,
-0.2950264215,
0.3521177471,
-0.9410760403,
0.638020277,
-0.1248091981,
-0.2424120456,
-0.4463228881,
0.0908124819,
0.0213112235,
0.6120470762,
0.6435678005,
-0.1570494622,
-0.6480727196,
-0.9914948344,
0.3560648859,
-0.2766593695,
0.1949384511,
0.640614748,
0.4172246456,
-0.5509591103,
0.5901093483,
-0.7657238245,
-0.6537936926,
0.0355284326,
-0.3836092055,
0.0818467662,
0.1986796558,
0.4255190194,
-0.9424837828,
-0.3370555937,
0.0534248017,
-0.6927309036,
0.1196160242,
-0.0108062495,
-0.2390737832,
0.2878034711,
-0.0912386477,
-0.4729002118,
0.2976393402,
0.4450617731,
-0.1721200347,
0.7986199856,
-0.373883158,
0.2710871398,
-0.7440133095,
-0.1861510426,
-0.0826535374,
-0.0639259145,
-0.5612073541,
-0.1047954559,
-0.0055726436,
-0.0190441348,
-0.4013987482,
0.4449068308,
-0.2903419435,
-0.0332324617,
-0.2425663769,
-0.1597065926,
-0.0892800838,
0.6082542539,
0.5352230668,
0.5421101451,
0.8019686937,
-0.5235893726,
0.5342484713,
0.2966031432,
-0.2168196738,
0.1365340352,
-0.2291693985,
0.4057295918,
-0.1618175209,
-0.0176860169,
-0.6473197341,
-0.3149361312,
0.3816984892,
-0.2773803771,
0.1403646916,
0.1046464369,
-0.2424200773,
-0.261980623,
-0.5952551365,
0.3520391881,
0.5636659861,
-0.8502277136,
0.4531515539,
0.3883585036,
0.3415395916,
-0.8849942088,
-0.2542155385,
-0.0565542988,
-0.2589514554,
-0.4518532455,
0.4510743022,
-0.4238452613,
-0.2548957169,
-0.2737851143,
-0.1960007101,
0.0534395054,
-0.1999013722,
0.1820655316,
0.3998910487,
0.1731495857,
0.3951030672,
-0.1437700093,
-0.0031357554,
-0.2685323954,
-0.2472877204,
0.8686768413,
-0.1052408889,
-0.1725330651,
-0.4025245905,
0.4160732627,
0.5273423195,
-0.1226212755,
0.2906164825,
0.6154432893,
-0.3982273638,
-0.2972932458,
-0.5513246059,
-0.6318897009,
-0.4765297771,
0.297999382,
-0.7045511603,
-0.7664314508,
0.218073383,
0.3632471859,
-0.2551353574,
-0.0458537787,
0.7019391656,
0.0972744003,
1.0833361149,
0.5301709175,
0.1075957716,
0.6252775192,
-0.0906065851,
0.1154955998,
-0.5417204499,
-0.300839752,
-0.1065766588,
-0.1231083572,
-0.6317497492,
-0.5596529841,
0.380263418,
-0.2928399444,
-0.0331994593,
-0.0261736624,
-0.8966959119,
0.3092592955,
0.5762404203,
0.5513401628,
0.3843356371,
0.3367393017,
-0.0247663576,
-0.400639534,
-0.390938431,
-0.3738456964,
1.0959174633,
0.4164870083,
0.8377919197,
-0.0117300199,
0.8100960851,
0.5528368354,
-0.0661769733,
-1.1284081936,
0.6246731877,
-0.2370737791,
-0.4030014873,
-0.3697086275,
-0.352250129,
-0.6157382131,
0.538808763,
-0.4333955646,
-0.6008113623,
0.5672243834,
0.2867919207,
-0.4470538497,
0.2223246992,
-0.4578212798,
0.6376835108,
-0.4243916571,
-0.8034483194,
-0.2632073164,
-0.4470414519,
0.332698524,
-0.0794291049,
0.1006816328,
-0.1611610502,
-0.0764637887,
0.4377279282,
0.1191365421,
0.5906255245,
-0.1417583227,
-0.2451523691,
-0.1547793746,
0.078986682,
0.5496368408,
0.1521043926,
-0.3004232943,
0.066324316,
-0.3025363982,
-0.2054958642,
-0.7935417891,
0.8580899835,
-0.8655095696,
-0.7815660834,
-0.4202824235,
-0.5421147943,
-0.2626881897,
0.0581261329,
0.1693828702,
0.4456213117,
-0.0272132084,
0.1616831124,
0.9262902737,
-0.3181611598,
0.1852980554,
0.0477855466,
-0.5712546706,
-0.6924735904,
0.9881413579,
-0.0368090309,
0.1963870078,
0.3494564295,
0.4062398672,
-0.4489314556,
-0.6810940504,
-0.3277918398,
0.2871295512,
-0.8409525752,
0.0820425451,
-0.8425505757,
0.0116741182,
-0.5612624288,
-0.1939343065,
-0.4371722043,
-0.2198290229,
-0.4601545036,
-0.0933838561,
0.0334958471,
0.4226643741,
-0.1144082546,
-0.2187613994,
-0.3787636757,
0.6426966786,
0.5130909085,
0.3168774843,
0.0048427819,
-0.4532398582,
0.0164205153,
-0.006225727,
-0.3137334287,
-0.9069809914,
0.621045053,
-0.0425160341,
0.459477663,
0.528983891,
0.2788851261,
0.8248617053,
-0.4264374673,
0.6179050207,
0.3414130211,
-0.7840049267,
0.7856144905,
-0.1796735525,
-0.1866194457,
0.5226258636,
0.5525603294,
-0.1582041383,
-0.0024753681,
-0.2741933763,
-0.6210801601,
0.3779339194,
0.3476170599,
0.0901542306,
-0.0438738354,
0.2757199705,
0.6206704378,
0.267519474,
-1.1448121071,
-0.2096698433,
-0.5220968723,
0.1710278392,
-0.0781520829,
-0.5068013072,
-0.1099432707,
-0.6096017361,
0.8609508872,
-0.1818941087,
0.2949792445,
0.3923544586,
-0.0796699077,
-0.0995171368,
0.1581562459,
0.8559253812,
0.5568368435,
-0.745870173,
0.2507435679,
-0.1875987053,
-0.4889551699,
0.3246753216,
-0.1436332017,
-0.1267272979,
0.1093949676,
0.0564678758,
1.1285932064,
-0.3214609027,
-0.6396946907,
0.4277992845,
-0.1513980776,
-0.2027964592,
-0.4645438492,
-0.0423545763,
-0.4792186618,
0.1020315886,
0.377328366,
0.132328555,
0.4222774804,
-0.523911953,
0.2641838491,
0.5151503086,
-0.7120617628,
-0.1827674806,
0.5600237846,
0.3749950528,
-0.2795495391,
0.3537385762,
-0.2502609789,
-0.3148505688,
0.3114812076,
0.6712786555,
0.9663602114,
-0.243651703,
0.4487104118,
0.4214749634,
0.2687053084,
-0.1103775948,
0.2114030272,
-0.2062217742,
-1.0392597914,
-0.1408800781,
-0.6700749993,
-0.3969858885,
0.3958788812,
-0.5906047225,
0.5379164815,
-0.1832883805,
-0.3606744111,
-0.0968385711,
-0.0274650306,
-0.414878279,
0.1864052117,
0.2174713165,
0.3250783682,
-0.5999160409,
1.0123496056,
0.5833388567,
-0.2586773932,
-0.1583270729,
0.1835286766,
-0.1323778927,
-0.8784942627,
0.6164638996,
0.3341741562,
-0.3361159265,
0.0302526802,
-0.172870189,
-0.6026344895,
0.8897677064,
0.3047945201,
-0.6351020336,
-0.1096727848,
0.0291427746,
0.3596699536,
-0.5544854403,
0.160213843,
0.5475381613,
0.4220781326,
0.3166000545,
-0.8033145666,
0.1022242308,
-0.0654735491,
-0.1043778881,
0.0310546495,
-0.551017642,
0.5932704806,
-0.4813756049,
0.087634325,
-0.1011434719,
0.4069084227,
0.401742816,
0.3149925768,
0.8052887321,
0.3933440745,
0.9835050702,
0.1398048401,
0.8622552156,
-0.0076113613,
0.2151858956,
1.0214328766,
-0.4800575078,
0.7331976891,
0.9538806081,
0.0665070713,
0.1181699485,
0.7431215048,
0.1297900379,
0.9724671245,
0.0730491206,
-0.2999451756,
-0.533763051,
-0.3936959803,
-0.5557492971,
0.539357245,
0.0933093801,
-0.5070323944,
0.2954480648,
0.3403149247,
-0.347959727,
0.0748059228,
-0.2399397492,
0.7411525249,
-0.0253068805,
-0.6161683202,
0.9226751328,
-0.5223138332,
0.9511399269,
-0.403906703,
-0.0470654182,
-0.1963582039,
0.2352300286,
-0.2546829879,
-0.4006035924,
0.1482171863,
-0.3668006063,
-0.3530426919,
-0.3084118068,
0.8717768192,
-0.4092766941,
-0.4047727287,
0.6695843339,
0.4519595802,
-0.002933834,
-0.1332708299,
-0.5328243971,
0.3865567744,
0.3916113973,
-0.1355908066,
0.1801356375,
-0.1015496179,
0.0529064946,
0.7397896647,
0.6318169832,
0.1591176689,
-0.22647053,
0.378895849,
0.7271755934,
-0.5639997125,
-0.432772398,
-0.9744816422,
0.3496299684,
-0.277312547,
-0.0558226667,
0.6188377142,
0.4977592528,
0.6431227326,
-0.5020217896,
0.7344244719,
0.2031642795,
0.1846915632,
-0.6276551485,
0.5754777193,
-0.9798585176,
0.1369089633,
-0.3483430445,
-1.1259884834,
-0.4915231764,
0.7704318762,
-0.3632998168,
-0.1551591903,
0.6978275776,
1.0151674747,
0.0524441749,
-0.2194426209,
0.8642597198,
-0.0377133749,
0.2626257539,
0.6083802581,
1.0794913769,
-0.0849714652,
0.3952066302,
-0.6797762513,
-0.4324731231,
-0.3895531595,
-0.8459455967,
-1.0264526606,
-0.8042141795,
-0.2271566093,
-0.365024358,
0.1438863277,
1.170689702,
0.7080166936,
-0.5912443399,
-0.2747339308,
0.1457718909,
0.2643378675,
-0.1639546752,
-0.1832913011,
0.4367157817,
-0.3438070714,
-0.8172754645,
0.3229621351,
0.4826666713,
0.2041336298,
-0.3635329604,
-0.4050186574,
0.0756058767,
0.0826273635,
0.9772409797,
-0.3495247364,
-1.0105055571,
-0.4601476192,
0.4592065811,
-0.0169333965,
0.4100297391,
0.7785698175,
-0.5050202608,
0.7662214041,
0.3579499424,
0.4325243235,
0.3624942899,
-0.1450188905,
0.2348936796,
-0.4054526687,
0.4588109851,
0.5129444599,
0.3975364864,
0.4005761743,
-0.5882792473,
0.4700134099,
0.4574424922,
-0.5724381804,
-1.0124993324,
0.4617711902,
-1.2669125795,
-0.3775098324,
1.3884420395,
0.4587306678,
-0.0407017618,
-0.0295996927,
-0.5879454017,
0.0887377188,
-0.570994556,
1.2137675285,
0.6314847469,
-0.3853511512,
-0.1821866482,
-0.4901365638,
0.8651533723,
0.5249374509,
-0.7314125299,
0.0900880843,
0.8579895496,
-0.1301539242,
0.2436973453,
0.781083405,
0.0958539844,
0.1690977812,
-0.2152496576,
0.2180806398,
-0.1813486516,
-0.591353476,
-0.2570899129,
0.3060344756,
0.0408237949,
-0.3768063784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17126v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17126v1
|
Reason out Your Layout: Evoking the Layout Master from Large Language Models for Text-to-Image Synthesis
| 2023-11-28T14:51:13 | 2023-11-28T14:51:13 |
Xiaohui Chen, Yongfei Liu, Yingxiang Yang, Jianbo Yuan, Quanzeng You, Li-Ping Liu, Hongxia Yang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in text-to-image (T2I) generative models have shown
remarkable capabilities in producing diverse and imaginative visuals based on
text prompts. Despite the advancement, these diffusion models sometimes
struggle to translate the semantic content from the text into images entirely.
While conditioning on the layout has shown to be effective in improving the
compositional ability of T2I diffusion models, they typically require manual
layout input. In this work, we introduce a novel approach to improving T2I
diffusion models using Large Language Models (LLMs) as layout generators. Our
method leverages the Chain-of-Thought prompting of LLMs to interpret text and
generate spatially reasonable object layouts. The generated layout is then used
to enhance the generated images' composition and spatial accuracy. Moreover, we
propose an efficient adapter based on a cross-attention mechanism, which
explicitly integrates the layout information into the stable diffusion models.
Our experiments demonstrate significant improvements in image quality and
layout accuracy, showcasing the potential of LLMs in augmenting generative
image models.
|
[
-0.4545116127,
-0.63711375,
1.030852437,
0.329526931,
-0.258171916,
-0.2213400006,
-0.2669256926,
0.0459087268,
0.1272852123,
0.5973954201,
-0.4601092041,
-0.6490321755,
-0.4111665487,
-0.1704163998,
-0.2851937115,
0.5518030524,
-0.2036039829,
-0.0405510962,
-0.2403085679,
0.1073306352,
-0.9486918449,
0.161236465,
-0.4811108112,
-0.3495001793,
0.2080304921,
0.2730579078,
0.7337148786,
0.6345965862,
0.2362390161,
0.2923621535,
-0.006717003,
0.4247144163,
-0.3368487358,
-0.0145368911,
-0.5167276859,
-0.2349087,
-0.2178716809,
-0.1526249647,
0.5381609797,
0.6971554756,
0.006774548,
-0.131369099,
-0.0436435081,
0.7688798904,
-0.7645398378,
-0.2027097493,
-0.4939257205,
0.2738379538,
0.0470517837,
-0.4402894378,
-0.839443922,
-0.2349952161,
-0.0150188683,
-0.6847094893,
0.1348617673,
0.0562984087,
0.6350153685,
0.3161824048,
-0.4303283095,
-0.373414129,
-0.8573872447,
0.7871335149,
-0.4473967552,
0.5067037344,
0.1158476546,
0.2208734751,
-0.3890964687,
-0.5970947742,
-0.395098269,
0.0348077007,
-0.2445552051,
0.4525645375,
-0.1693278104,
-0.152976796,
0.1545358747,
0.2444780469,
-0.5220060349,
-0.0928731337,
-0.0412036739,
0.1130114719,
0.5569139719,
0.0847940445,
0.9628008008,
0.0218729731,
-0.1815046668,
-0.0941468105,
-0.9561693668,
-0.3970482945,
0.2651773691,
-0.2640791535,
-0.0888798609,
0.7895664573,
0.3977384269,
0.8045819998,
0.385981828,
-0.2076507509,
-0.3110156953,
-0.2215318829,
-0.3551399708,
-0.1269780993,
0.8435758352,
0.870082736,
-0.0700523034,
-0.3360484242,
-0.1299680918,
-0.2126167119,
0.3544991016,
-0.8175687194,
-0.4179912508,
0.2413543463,
-0.6136280894,
-0.3389343321,
-0.1791564375,
-0.8116514683,
-0.4833106697,
-0.1735883802,
0.2559555471,
-0.5708214641,
-0.3506794572,
0.0881431922,
-0.4658611119,
0.1352969557,
0.4595339596,
-0.9619911313,
-0.1600849479,
0.41547212,
1.0053920746,
-0.3426809907,
-0.0210965481,
-0.303727001,
0.7355738282,
-0.9721876383,
1.0624899864,
-0.4438234866,
-0.7016270757,
0.0960606709,
-0.1683900803,
-0.1662986577,
-0.809841454,
0.2470243424,
-0.529055953,
0.6521776915,
-0.1191298738,
-0.4433400929,
0.0791593939,
0.1882921308,
-0.6436974406,
0.7518224716,
0.0041154157,
-0.8453437686,
0.2203188539,
-0.7494673729,
-0.7167203426,
-0.0483735465,
-0.2020639032,
-0.3773158789,
0.4655276239,
0.4179697335,
0.2250593454,
-0.0091652861,
0.4572918117,
-0.3156819046,
-0.0664705411,
0.3460725248,
-0.15556328,
0.3681930602,
0.2146992236,
-0.0818586349,
0.225475356,
-0.6218358874,
-0.0336431153,
0.1948778182,
-0.4554524124,
-0.4613361359,
0.1994104236,
0.1091259122,
0.2050073594,
0.2074037939,
-0.3156987429,
0.1127484068,
-0.3792836666,
0.4049612284,
0.6874369383,
0.1454741806,
1.0983296633,
-0.0714365542,
0.5097084641,
-0.0424553417,
-0.3119638264,
-0.5888940692,
-0.4930921793,
-0.4986357391,
-0.3020424843,
-0.0318090096,
0.3864295483,
-0.8995793462,
0.5823372602,
-0.2833527327,
-0.3298698068,
-0.0859881938,
0.1068719104,
0.3099865317,
0.4741084874,
0.1369876564,
-0.2575369179,
-0.455288589,
-0.8996286392,
-0.1543725729,
0.1222435534,
-0.266751498,
0.2392581105,
0.2703956366,
-0.2033540159,
0.8011504412,
-0.696249485,
-0.259174943,
-0.644690454,
-0.2117071897,
0.002783691,
0.489872247,
0.6406125426,
-0.5051608682,
-0.5265922546,
0.2746410668,
-0.7276384234,
-0.1828920394,
-0.4128047526,
-0.9239905477,
0.1944721043,
0.6328299642,
-0.8877295852,
0.5583655238,
0.4055922031,
-0.4043586552,
0.340400815,
-0.3605625927,
-0.0717050284,
-1.5614057779,
0.0626969934,
0.3630524576,
-0.0873862281,
-0.6669572592,
0.2949406803,
0.0902556404,
-0.36361292,
-0.1947852224,
0.7201693058,
-0.4909676313,
-0.1296747923,
-0.4809378982,
0.1694143265,
0.4889458716,
0.1736804545,
0.3542373776,
0.8268738389,
0.6335591674,
-0.5849685073,
-0.0297516286,
0.4034882188,
-0.5064216852,
0.6741903424,
-0.705480516,
0.1047875509,
-0.3305447996,
0.6213830709,
-1.5784380436,
-0.6177671552,
0.4076343477,
0.0625318214,
0.488279283,
-0.1448312551,
-0.5039277673,
-0.1865928173,
-0.0884024873,
0.3950207531,
0.546215117,
-0.9131717086,
1.0634087324,
0.2344797403,
0.0396272615,
-0.0267410111,
-0.9377827048,
0.1496568918,
-0.3466121256,
-0.9382821321,
0.6182992458,
-0.0953394771,
-0.1927458644,
-0.1700100601,
0.1254780143,
0.1178979725,
-0.2006632239,
0.2725211382,
0.1050303802,
-0.1242229119,
0.0796906278,
0.4198126197,
0.017684415,
0.1295028478,
-0.5626797676,
0.6050691605,
0.7294703126,
-0.3453473449,
-0.5900132656,
0.6060086489,
0.6567208171,
-0.1824222803,
0.4923348427,
0.346631974,
-0.2414635122,
-0.1795425117,
-0.423697263,
0.1273360103,
-0.4956880212,
0.3392944932,
-0.2792479992,
-0.3615319431,
0.3675339222,
-0.3762319386,
0.1998323947,
0.1816780269,
0.6301996112,
-0.3670637906,
1.2509533167,
0.4552112222,
0.3289940953,
0.8484486938,
-0.29205212,
0.292822361,
-1.0416465998,
-0.2362167984,
-0.0933181494,
-0.6260633469,
-0.3279497325,
-0.7412587404,
0.4741650224,
-0.2137954831,
-0.0382779725,
-0.056539204,
-0.4527093172,
0.7736554146,
0.3017404974,
0.3226595819,
0.1077084467,
0.514983356,
-0.0344456099,
-0.2012709975,
-0.4788908362,
-0.5192263126,
0.7630155087,
0.3425997794,
1.0026035309,
0.1764015257,
0.7619209886,
-0.0860157907,
0.3096264899,
-0.6330971718,
0.6390359998,
-0.3461199403,
-0.4097400606,
0.0110292034,
-0.0779064894,
-0.6484494209,
0.3660290241,
0.023970319,
-0.5850938559,
0.0739120841,
0.2922434509,
-0.1929073334,
0.3995989263,
-0.9335003495,
0.8349071145,
-0.2289358526,
-0.3526522815,
-0.1263288558,
-0.0806209818,
0.5332280397,
0.0291555729,
0.1898496747,
0.265204221,
0.0069082123,
0.2921368778,
-0.5103811026,
0.913684845,
-0.1220386401,
-0.5672161579,
0.2946907878,
0.4424546957,
0.539098978,
-0.027144473,
0.0133757219,
-0.3839124143,
-0.6669869423,
-0.2360519171,
-0.8038407564,
0.7165259123,
-0.7022004724,
-0.713935554,
0.4318430126,
-0.6498526931,
0.0235782526,
0.042260889,
0.7943579555,
0.3841378391,
-0.3392468989,
-0.1424655169,
0.8394572139,
-0.6007052064,
0.5309702754,
-0.2858116925,
-0.6605558395,
-0.5335099101,
0.8533746004,
-0.215626955,
0.2807052135,
0.5877583623,
0.2600241303,
-0.3960156739,
-0.4625591338,
-0.8802086711,
0.1693744361,
-0.808175087,
-0.0388420932,
-0.7759627104,
0.0387387201,
-0.1875048131,
-0.4865130484,
-0.2823386192,
-0.3839143515,
-0.4793866575,
0.0578461066,
0.087304756,
0.8041139841,
0.2735402584,
0.5963796973,
-0.4400103688,
0.3369000554,
0.3253861964,
0.1539102197,
0.1912204921,
-0.8580703735,
-0.1774162203,
-0.2297542095,
-0.6806670427,
-0.939232409,
0.4544450939,
0.0458796546,
0.3670758307,
0.441327244,
-0.4676508605,
0.8531236649,
-0.6700106859,
0.7485321164,
0.5220628381,
-0.867882967,
0.8983322382,
-0.3810650408,
0.5135338902,
-0.1170410067,
-0.0423966795,
-0.3105772436,
-0.4737967849,
-0.3437046111,
-0.8660609126,
0.4375750721,
0.1342747211,
0.1684664637,
0.091764465,
0.390465647,
-0.0668257922,
-0.2026976198,
-0.8000761271,
0.1331775337,
-0.2940907478,
-0.315243423,
0.1218070909,
-0.2068542838,
-0.146293059,
-0.0403213687,
0.6519392133,
-0.1837219149,
0.2007673234,
-0.0330903679,
-0.1017188728,
-0.3806972504,
0.1639119834,
0.8107599616,
0.6313134432,
0.3716626465,
-0.0086904317,
0.0514169559,
-0.0022976873,
0.2102019489,
-0.3087590337,
-0.5630497336,
0.2643333673,
0.2987307608,
0.8911069632,
-0.0058584041,
-0.3432358503,
0.4164911807,
-0.1313586682,
-0.2509714663,
-0.2659547627,
0.0733307824,
0.2714571655,
0.2061305642,
0.170617789,
0.2164252847,
0.1950335056,
-0.1585672051,
-0.1487307847,
0.6417801976,
-0.0800053254,
-0.3576923311,
0.7779139876,
0.1661652476,
-0.2083781809,
0.3904669583,
-0.0044513312,
-0.1774962842,
0.5705871582,
0.9644761086,
1.0029414892,
-0.0532198437,
0.4297257662,
0.4386987984,
0.0977173969,
-0.1104716435,
0.0964825451,
0.0984688327,
-0.696833849,
-0.6870471239,
-0.2428877354,
-0.0995922759,
0.1361732632,
-0.2551733255,
0.1972056925,
-0.6398993731,
-0.1562409699,
-0.2051094472,
-0.7558054924,
-0.4447076619,
0.2304876447,
0.4647695124,
0.855709672,
-0.9793201089,
0.4730915725,
1.1480470896,
-0.0629569516,
-0.6708322167,
0.3619706929,
-0.3084898889,
-0.6295111775,
0.5488989353,
0.270082444,
0.066677928,
-0.036017023,
-0.8122000098,
-0.6162629128,
0.8682035804,
0.2174453586,
-0.5878366828,
-0.1834217012,
0.0735287517,
0.5000131726,
-0.6789857149,
0.169544518,
0.3893711865,
0.4675185084,
0.4694651067,
-0.1370377839,
0.1949831545,
-0.2223621607,
0.7468177676,
0.2916890383,
-0.5068493485,
0.3350801766,
-0.4710642099,
-0.2778041661,
0.3373858631,
0.7790382504,
0.6230966449,
0.3412587941,
0.453894645,
0.8240852952,
0.4985933602,
-0.0901743993,
1.1184159517,
-0.0372580327,
-0.1509826183,
1.0149767399,
-0.236450389,
0.5657048821,
0.6897477508,
0.2291195393,
0.6945035458,
0.6019930243,
0.1132271141,
0.8737904429,
-0.0023189294,
-0.0478279889,
-0.4135554135,
-0.0498005748,
-0.2034875602,
0.0420403928,
0.5818119645,
-0.7566140294,
-0.3358023167,
0.1726529747,
-0.2529521286,
0.2924138308,
-0.1024034545,
0.865450561,
-0.0845366567,
-0.8948301673,
0.0716320276,
0.1614750624,
0.4111065865,
-0.1032721326,
0.034418121,
-0.5191218853,
0.118206054,
-0.2978020012,
-1.0031752586,
0.1779881865,
-0.1802381128,
-0.3757479787,
-0.4882189929,
0.7216078043,
-0.6163799763,
-0.6590407491,
0.0499783531,
0.3560400307,
-0.0509286001,
0.0166204683,
-0.3604842126,
0.1982798725,
0.1686598957,
-0.127528131,
0.3708887994,
0.7586508393,
-0.0792354941,
0.2417394966,
0.5919783115,
-0.1754170507,
0.0644276962,
0.2387393415,
0.7955269217,
-0.5243802667,
-0.5203613043,
-1.0351223946,
0.6503754258,
-0.1061057076,
-0.0992120653,
0.3871658742,
0.5625727773,
0.4938050807,
-0.5804830194,
0.9401835799,
0.0169891305,
0.0169854444,
-0.7654253244,
0.7249603271,
-0.7347092032,
0.1330638528,
-0.3863177896,
-1.0087114573,
-0.2582558692,
0.6308633089,
-0.4309464693,
-0.0236016661,
0.4669543207,
0.8600261211,
-0.3045782447,
-0.2364742756,
0.4012174308,
-0.0696631223,
0.7154760957,
0.5545967221,
1.1879652739,
-0.4109852016,
0.4604205191,
-0.1799641252,
-0.1131990105,
-0.098757118,
-0.9773305058,
-1.1032713652,
-0.3669396043,
-0.6790911555,
-0.5582749248,
-0.2542859018,
0.46986413,
0.8587256074,
-0.5089170337,
-0.0939135924,
-0.443620652,
0.1670949161,
0.140042901,
-0.2366467118,
0.2970822155,
-0.170979932,
-0.7641686797,
0.366135776,
0.6370303631,
0.4536730051,
-0.191301018,
-0.0772866309,
0.2375578433,
0.1218284965,
0.7037895322,
-0.0662093833,
-0.7654210329,
-0.0049724686,
-0.2711182237,
-0.2932053208,
0.1896348298,
0.894969821,
-0.2684405446,
0.4373374879,
0.6640359163,
0.4875509739,
0.1843731403,
0.1320433766,
0.8044127822,
-0.948589623,
0.2429991961,
-0.398619622,
0.5489182472,
0.5811880827,
-0.4162661731,
0.3835668266,
-0.0493154787,
-0.3818504214,
-0.4811914861,
0.5733510256,
-0.7890958786,
-0.3608543873,
1.264752388,
0.1038673222,
-0.5650575161,
0.3488592505,
-0.6177271008,
-0.0108528053,
-0.2023434043,
0.762083292,
0.6812566519,
0.0377953351,
-0.3635184169,
-0.1133498475,
0.1724016219,
0.5300664902,
-1.0046707392,
-0.0477078147,
0.7709863782,
0.2895767689,
0.5435725451,
0.5072617531,
-0.1284710616,
0.2983043492,
-0.4475598633,
0.0810347572,
0.3722118437,
-0.3725648522,
-0.0252143126,
0.0365275294,
0.024039235,
-0.2027785033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16832v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16832v1
|
CharacterGLM: Customizing Chinese Conversational AI Characters with Large Language Models
| 2023-11-28T14:49:23 | 2023-11-28T14:49:23 |
Jinfeng Zhou, Zhuang Chen, Dazhen Wan, Bosi Wen, Yi Song, Jifan Yu, Yongkang Huang, Libiao Peng, Jiaming Yang, Xiyao Xiao, Sahand Sabour, Xiaohan Zhang, Wenjing Hou, Yijia Zhang, Yuxiao Dong, Jie Tang, Minlie Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this paper, we present CharacterGLM, a series of models built upon
ChatGLM, with model sizes ranging from 6B to 66B parameters. Our CharacterGLM
is designed for generating Character-based Dialogues (CharacterDial), which
aims to equip a conversational AI system with character customization for
satisfying people's inherent social desires and emotional needs. On top of
CharacterGLM, we can customize various AI characters or social agents by
configuring their attributes (identities, interests, viewpoints, experiences,
achievements, social relationships, etc.) and behaviors (linguistic features,
emotional expressions, interaction patterns, etc.). Our model outperforms most
mainstream close-source large langauge models, including the GPT series,
especially in terms of consistency, human-likeness, and engagement according to
manual evaluations. We will release our 6B version of CharacterGLM and a subset
of training data to facilitate further research development in the direction of
character-based dialogue generation.
|
[
-0.3366901875,
-0.8219916224,
0.2728275955,
0.1959612072,
-0.0714118108,
0.1008543968,
-0.3583839834,
-0.6047566533,
0.3894154131,
0.8467438817,
-0.4824926555,
-0.4033687413,
-0.2282327563,
0.20768933,
0.1149703786,
0.7525230646,
0.5175870657,
0.2762381434,
-0.0727324933,
-0.0629679039,
-0.5651506186,
-0.8890464902,
-0.9396025538,
-0.5151269436,
0.5750379562,
0.3617594838,
0.9968304038,
0.4429107308,
0.4035696983,
0.3220581412,
-0.0518840924,
0.319042474,
-0.6124911904,
0.203968972,
0.0239280742,
-0.3068292737,
-0.6757287979,
0.0012445754,
0.7879710197,
0.5155323148,
0.0048308172,
0.0433658138,
-0.1363059282,
0.4218397439,
-0.1767569035,
0.6062272191,
-0.4783861935,
0.1436640024,
0.0233019907,
-0.000290484,
-0.671865344,
-0.4157471061,
0.1026723906,
-0.4132315218,
0.1271067113,
0.3029412627,
0.6012505889,
-0.0056400695,
-0.3429343104,
-0.2806366086,
-0.7585120201,
0.7452771068,
-1.0877513885,
0.0524272397,
0.2483768165,
0.469783783,
-0.1830257624,
-0.6037654877,
-0.3908897042,
-0.7481332421,
-0.0911414772,
0.0627559796,
0.42362836,
0.3717666268,
0.4318564534,
0.3325165212,
-0.6390121579,
0.078879647,
-0.3180821836,
-0.1510368139,
1.0261825323,
0.4589852989,
0.8123862147,
-0.0256082658,
-0.132913813,
-0.0477525592,
-0.8141121268,
-0.1317163706,
0.5158697367,
0.5143432021,
-0.1660185307,
0.3292778432,
-0.1033124849,
0.4375989437,
0.2159157097,
-0.0053333538,
0.1266365945,
-0.2231678963,
-0.3708776832,
0.2330048382,
0.8610368371,
0.3212306201,
0.2089501172,
-0.0400887318,
-0.0666322783,
-0.3570308685,
0.1078557149,
-1.2785695791,
-0.3311047256,
0.1481559575,
-0.6484122276,
-0.3452593982,
0.0037974901,
-0.5094268918,
-0.5905396342,
-0.1735524982,
0.0341180973,
-0.5065757632,
-0.2712653577,
-0.0056164605,
0.0052472805,
0.5106266737,
0.5344375372,
-1.2464904785,
-0.0297881793,
0.3826794326,
0.7975143194,
-0.149496153,
0.0496737324,
-0.4594710469,
0.214536339,
-0.4438537657,
0.3259992599,
-0.8911452889,
-0.8215733171,
0.0724102259,
-0.0383944213,
-0.0827366337,
-0.433873713,
0.4240241051,
-0.4008477628,
0.2118738443,
-0.3002243042,
-0.5906285048,
-0.254647702,
0.3598738611,
-0.6255865097,
0.6185531616,
0.0246035364,
-0.2469508946,
-0.0480222143,
-0.8212663531,
-0.3083717525,
0.6018238068,
-0.1434403509,
-0.1146765277,
0.0048130346,
0.0544220284,
0.4904714227,
-0.4307302535,
0.1763156801,
-0.5311303735,
-0.3965852559,
0.2860246599,
-0.396289438,
0.7625316381,
0.455041796,
-0.0126576712,
0.358273983,
-0.4902901053,
0.2177400738,
0.137226209,
-0.1552146524,
-0.0326201953,
0.1284864694,
0.3339223266,
0.2297164351,
0.7178810835,
-0.3517912328,
0.2142664194,
-0.4516944289,
0.559708178,
0.5987658501,
-0.136718601,
0.3021636307,
-0.3936474025,
0.6133436561,
-0.093548663,
0.1579113007,
-0.5453521609,
-0.5076550841,
-0.7833302617,
-0.2583394647,
0.1165002435,
0.5292024016,
-0.6009726524,
0.7120139003,
0.0970371291,
-0.7144417167,
-0.0970212296,
-0.077497825,
0.3818272054,
0.1139839217,
0.0508801043,
-0.4572914243,
-0.204724595,
-0.7600079775,
-0.0444316529,
-0.680033505,
-0.0995513201,
0.5924889445,
0.2157198638,
-0.4795763791,
0.8950534463,
-0.4540388882,
-0.2029004395,
-0.7577579618,
0.082364507,
-0.0053611249,
0.3995630741,
0.7931554914,
-0.5936404467,
-0.761805594,
0.1538450867,
-0.6410437226,
-0.1715411395,
-0.2288561612,
-0.0483384207,
0.3156130612,
0.3701089025,
-0.5363357663,
0.1368811429,
0.4714812934,
-0.41482988,
0.816588819,
-0.3706890643,
0.1801053137,
-1.3310716152,
0.0773974508,
0.1424456835,
-0.3195230067,
-0.7616309524,
0.1843815893,
-0.2045899481,
-0.5045975447,
-0.440803498,
0.896689415,
-0.6329575181,
0.1103948727,
-0.1796038151,
0.1636756212,
-0.1603611261,
0.8699139357,
0.0902458206,
0.666636169,
0.3503020704,
-0.3340800703,
0.7205662131,
0.3634711206,
-0.2560818195,
0.4567480087,
-0.9962387085,
0.5061599016,
0.0703681335,
0.4003120065,
-0.9871003032,
-0.4017103612,
0.354309082,
-0.312037915,
0.2233245373,
-0.0958371311,
-0.4486344159,
-0.1097925231,
-0.2152625471,
0.2645198703,
0.7277611494,
-0.3645916283,
0.6178132296,
0.3272222579,
-0.5714200139,
0.0173572581,
-0.2184558362,
0.4053446949,
-0.4156153798,
-1.0355392694,
0.1962742507,
-0.5673125982,
-0.0667423308,
-0.449998647,
0.4490319788,
-0.0307020713,
-0.0965010524,
0.1902463287,
0.2787853777,
-0.3653024137,
0.057477776,
-0.1498728544,
0.1127412468,
-0.029604381,
0.0825959072,
0.7379204035,
-0.2882978618,
-0.2714955211,
-0.3438280523,
0.3941940367,
0.5018302202,
-0.3259415925,
0.6320937276,
0.6620029807,
-0.1708966643,
-0.1425133646,
-0.3797068596,
-0.1964475363,
-0.547049582,
0.7043365836,
-0.1768502444,
-0.975734055,
0.8073658347,
0.2281648368,
0.2655176818,
0.24732171,
0.7056550384,
0.3789778352,
1.5062581301,
0.3576572239,
-0.4360957444,
0.7974424362,
0.2528952658,
0.1754567325,
-0.6466240287,
-0.0165813118,
-0.4002828002,
-0.241468668,
-0.7066035867,
-0.3532455564,
0.1698418707,
-0.2460306734,
-0.4119925797,
0.0518626608,
-0.3362011313,
0.4309826493,
0.4488064647,
-0.0406089015,
0.1458742619,
-0.2592908442,
0.3090754151,
0.1196882054,
-0.4712610841,
-0.8307276964,
0.6874827743,
0.4841119945,
0.975662291,
0.2971661389,
0.4090057909,
0.4531405568,
0.1460022777,
-0.8463611603,
0.7506280541,
-0.2161174715,
-0.5564030409,
-0.5433045626,
-0.5615736246,
-0.7800937295,
0.1365364492,
-0.0327172093,
-0.9791480303,
-0.2619407773,
0.2551995814,
-0.3399119079,
0.0882568434,
-0.8786072135,
0.9357223511,
-0.2571132779,
0.0807744637,
-0.2652263045,
-0.7032837272,
0.4874649048,
0.1714343131,
-0.4177104533,
-0.2387622148,
0.4260830879,
0.4960772693,
-0.5010849237,
1.0813920498,
-0.1001135781,
-0.2030775845,
0.3500493467,
-0.0570644774,
0.669875145,
0.2470143586,
-0.1166592687,
0.2252516001,
0.0467304587,
-0.266808331,
-0.6415759921,
0.5747522712,
-0.9141299129,
-0.8523880839,
-0.3198414445,
-0.7151814103,
-0.2148496062,
0.220000118,
0.0871497244,
0.5326020122,
-0.7718868852,
0.3542189598,
0.6632080078,
-0.5529917479,
0.4417306483,
0.286752075,
-0.4299713671,
-0.3859244883,
1.1193109751,
-0.0050764862,
0.4538553357,
0.2478536367,
0.0907534882,
-0.2065121084,
-0.4132496417,
-0.4204088748,
0.2862693965,
-0.2964037359,
0.2310945988,
-0.2590290606,
-0.6927617788,
-0.5655074716,
-0.0166174024,
-0.1983373165,
-0.2271335423,
-0.397796154,
0.2574477792,
0.2607830465,
0.6863482594,
0.4773723781,
0.5630665421,
-0.9726198912,
0.1319058239,
0.2454992086,
0.1714784205,
-0.1292420626,
-0.6078068614,
-0.507977128,
0.3200051486,
-0.4822485149,
-0.6511300206,
0.7206220627,
0.3699006438,
0.5068846941,
0.7213042378,
0.0516995415,
0.3672719002,
-0.6329020262,
1.2280682325,
0.32551983,
-0.7729192972,
0.275767535,
-0.5653964281,
0.4302329719,
0.0322725326,
-0.1708856076,
-1.2094466686,
-0.4872567952,
-0.540500164,
-0.6387334466,
0.8853367567,
0.2572794259,
0.5145047307,
0.111532867,
0.3661776185,
-0.038573239,
0.0886650234,
-0.3750641942,
-0.1755864173,
-0.2495589405,
-0.3737575114,
-0.2471426278,
-0.3421581686,
0.1055997983,
0.1409243494,
0.7984963655,
-0.5054982305,
0.4041003883,
-0.1996681839,
-0.0604493842,
0.0999004319,
0.1180153415,
0.828540206,
0.5143026114,
-0.2342855185,
-0.2884078324,
0.0992695466,
-0.5315954685,
-0.1354940236,
0.0228290707,
-0.2077053636,
-0.0089739338,
0.1445893943,
1.1023191214,
-0.1804928035,
-0.7102490067,
0.130890891,
-0.2278679162,
0.0540601648,
-0.5131475329,
0.5715757608,
0.1507234275,
0.3324249089,
0.229849115,
-0.3916542232,
0.0657662824,
-0.6589260101,
-0.0165636875,
0.5234575868,
-0.5337706804,
-0.5615011454,
0.6886199117,
0.6310864091,
-0.5363840461,
0.7087469697,
-0.1045295522,
-0.2718583643,
0.7766801119,
0.5292612314,
1.1167681217,
-0.5142720342,
0.509775281,
0.2976427674,
0.0734494552,
-0.1985069662,
-0.0978631601,
0.3406235874,
-0.9401984811,
-0.0663072094,
-0.3939452469,
-0.7913103104,
0.280058831,
-0.3690473139,
0.3664020896,
-0.7444391847,
-0.1139643863,
-0.3426675797,
0.3054330051,
-0.1944864541,
0.2499824613,
0.2779102623,
0.7072704434,
-0.3704095781,
0.8113452196,
0.5584337115,
-0.5949725509,
-0.7847704291,
-0.0734766573,
-0.0739319995,
-0.7846375108,
0.4421135485,
0.2245578766,
0.0873392969,
0.0271548778,
-0.7269639969,
-0.638820231,
1.0325559378,
0.5121971369,
-0.5340456963,
-0.4108151793,
0.3446852267,
0.5578974485,
-0.7676200867,
0.506049335,
0.3695527613,
0.3352667689,
0.3527165055,
-0.7166023254,
0.0328152776,
-0.5130612254,
0.4928421378,
-0.0795538947,
-1.3579620123,
0.5831051469,
-0.0867862031,
-0.0501484573,
0.4275613129,
0.8014040589,
0.3080461323,
-0.2135527879,
0.3867298961,
-0.1108303592,
0.7858232856,
-0.0367370583,
0.7865521312,
-0.4983283579,
0.2498868257,
1.1030380726,
-0.5806456208,
0.3057790399,
-0.020340452,
0.1563859731,
0.279563725,
0.9655955434,
-0.1981568635,
0.2044774145,
0.1899760813,
-0.2756761014,
-0.3880731761,
-0.1475394666,
-0.3825580478,
0.1615334898,
0.4045857787,
-0.3655092418,
0.1761565208,
-0.3350109458,
-0.03264248,
-0.2710897028,
-0.3549621105,
0.6739764214,
0.2268614024,
-0.4620618224,
0.3481416106,
0.186975196,
0.4779551625,
-0.7833509445,
-0.0846555233,
-0.4940041602,
-0.0385779999,
0.0045966082,
-0.4777966142,
-0.0594327562,
-0.1743981689,
-0.0552603789,
-0.2032409012,
0.8208457828,
-0.7496035695,
-0.5759579539,
-0.126512751,
0.1661584377,
0.304046154,
0.0258717258,
-0.6922403574,
-0.0900593475,
0.0103758946,
-0.3127293289,
0.2759969532,
0.587673068,
-0.1854501069,
0.6675104499,
0.4245167077,
0.0230284352,
-0.1263066381,
0.3385582268,
0.4181583226,
-0.8936081529,
-0.6314114332,
-0.7752738595,
0.4405814707,
-0.2226279527,
-0.3391787708,
0.6232033372,
0.4552707076,
0.4808206558,
-0.2277634889,
1.0933425426,
0.03498004,
0.0138599938,
-0.4607420564,
1.0228499174,
-0.2955781519,
0.0904359296,
-0.3765969276,
-1.0017222166,
-0.0976940915,
0.58463341,
-0.0325310268,
0.6037956476,
0.4154483378,
0.908016324,
0.2469913214,
0.1594981104,
0.8506069779,
0.1506714523,
0.7594929934,
0.8062736392,
0.7992731929,
-0.1088204831,
0.3037581444,
0.4807808101,
-0.109666124,
-0.5960556865,
-0.6168382764,
-1.3607509136,
-0.50639534,
-0.3140220642,
-0.1105568558,
-0.1360797882,
1.118617177,
0.6927860975,
-0.5919857025,
-0.4474135935,
0.2625491917,
0.1394475251,
-0.0445087142,
-0.2045810372,
0.099844262,
-0.5366292,
-1.1263319254,
0.1860637516,
0.2797065377,
0.0224183071,
-0.5996691585,
-0.4661583304,
0.2941477597,
0.532471776,
0.6328316927,
0.3194106519,
-0.6794621348,
-0.6607608795,
0.0096878931,
-0.3179121017,
0.2322401702,
0.6398324966,
-0.116267994,
0.3059329391,
0.4765746891,
0.5454999208,
0.4089979231,
-0.049762547,
1.0872024298,
-0.6419655681,
0.1153595299,
0.0481394008,
0.4542157948,
0.3597741425,
-0.5289652944,
0.3240353763,
0.1468173116,
-0.6952418089,
-0.5314811468,
0.5509259105,
-1.1594717503,
0.0166357141,
1.346283555,
-0.2106660753,
-0.1603940725,
0.1779971421,
-0.6869656444,
0.1856968701,
-0.6666555405,
0.8123820424,
0.9831649065,
-0.2124950886,
-0.3570920527,
-0.2121105939,
0.4763941467,
0.2421020269,
-1.0893694162,
0.1933911145,
0.7890102267,
-0.0005306048,
0.1917612106,
0.5704880357,
-0.0483250804,
0.2023171633,
-0.2986493409,
0.2649531662,
0.0003968184,
-0.0620601401,
-0.0061145648,
0.1236989498,
0.2061652988,
0.0615056753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16822v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16822v2
|
Large Language Models Suffer From Their Own Output: An Analysis of the Self-Consuming Training Loop
| 2023-11-28T14:36:43 | 2024-06-17T07:07:30 |
Martin Briesch, Dominik Sobania, Franz Rothlauf
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.NE
|
Large Language Models (LLM) are already widely used to generate content for a
variety of online platforms. As we are not able to safely distinguish
LLM-generated content from human-produced content, LLM-generated content is
used to train the next generation of LLMs, giving rise to a self-consuming
training loop. From the image generation domain we know that such a
self-consuming training loop reduces both quality and diversity of images
finally ending in a model collapse. However, it is unclear whether this
alarming effect can also be observed for LLMs. Therefore, we present the first
study investigating the self-consuming training loop for LLMs. Further, we
propose a novel method based on logic expressions that allows us to
unambiguously verify the correctness of LLM-generated content, which is
difficult for natural language text. We find that the self-consuming training
loop produces correct outputs, however, the output declines in its diversity
depending on the proportion of the used generated data. Fresh data can slow
down this decline, but not stop it. Given these concerning results, we
encourage researchers to study methods to negate this process.
|
[
-0.2339654416,
-0.6016432047,
0.4225260317,
0.0097011151,
-0.2800640464,
-0.0159012862,
-0.311170429,
-0.3201611936,
0.1174023077,
0.9444200397,
-0.5777579546,
-0.1999061704,
-0.7119187713,
0.3797533512,
-0.7473940849,
0.8991659284,
0.0739645064,
0.1396895349,
-0.4595770836,
-0.1710757464,
-0.6094200015,
-0.5223689079,
-0.693700254,
-0.5468949676,
0.5051542521,
0.2007823437,
0.3349765241,
0.8957287073,
0.3155088425,
0.3913789392,
0.3047822118,
-0.0291565713,
-0.8481115103,
0.3112916946,
-0.2612707019,
-0.3358201981,
-0.0876397267,
-0.0275414567,
0.9002037644,
0.408490628,
-0.022463901,
0.1617185175,
0.1277776361,
0.7379886508,
-0.4834798276,
-0.0486995913,
-0.8991719484,
0.082266368,
-0.2627155781,
-0.2600447237,
-0.521658659,
0.0511558205,
-0.1808725148,
-0.1658528894,
0.0818318427,
0.0317109972,
0.5938403606,
0.4129400849,
-0.338514775,
-0.5916915536,
-0.7425438166,
0.7897748351,
-0.886153996,
0.1698598117,
0.2422829717,
0.0825185254,
-0.2043920606,
-0.4999738038,
-0.868234992,
-0.0802800804,
0.0516611524,
0.0709390715,
-0.2730166316,
-0.2597020864,
0.148976177,
0.4886504114,
-0.5641648769,
0.2913525999,
-0.5728162527,
-0.2321644723,
0.7004062533,
0.2453591526,
0.5334776044,
-0.3460526168,
-0.2766161561,
0.0994490385,
-0.9278024435,
-0.3676269054,
0.5770656466,
0.1116760224,
0.0046926332,
0.7292621136,
-0.0266109891,
0.5028427839,
-0.0778343827,
-0.2880568802,
0.140530929,
0.0384065472,
-0.3184171915,
-0.0311905872,
1.1986677647,
0.2801920474,
0.5105846524,
-0.0094245132,
-0.3377899528,
-0.0668485537,
0.1590773314,
-0.6877001524,
-0.3386231661,
0.0759685114,
-0.3372976482,
-0.1813563854,
-0.3898412585,
-0.3579308987,
-0.3754302859,
-0.2065019757,
0.4139943123,
-0.2864736021,
-0.2240474969,
0.0532179661,
0.1404767632,
-0.0926888809,
0.2129189819,
-0.9107519388,
0.2039856911,
0.3217532933,
0.8063711524,
-0.2577998638,
-0.4815944433,
-0.5202738643,
0.0990043357,
-0.3958531022,
0.8160383105,
-0.2310304493,
-0.3234821856,
-0.0804570392,
-0.0872294828,
0.0249997489,
-0.8838103414,
0.1915916204,
-0.5861180425,
0.1480752379,
-0.2512373924,
-0.8441380858,
0.1241346896,
0.1270928979,
-0.8028393984,
0.8439658284,
-0.1325945109,
-0.805246532,
0.2854677141,
-0.412412852,
-0.4199947119,
0.0826498568,
-0.3733685911,
-0.411126703,
0.1133518741,
0.0791894719,
0.5699781179,
-0.0998659655,
0.2629710734,
-0.4474302232,
-0.1107248515,
0.3967809975,
-0.3294477761,
0.5559624434,
0.4181355238,
-0.3036056459,
-0.1001758203,
-0.7884393334,
-0.1518635601,
0.6045039296,
-0.43794927,
-0.2605549395,
0.1465577185,
-0.3438876569,
0.4346333444,
0.0824128836,
-0.5326334238,
0.2261754721,
-0.2664258778,
0.4612388313,
1.0242136717,
-0.1342363656,
0.2900654078,
-0.1889196783,
0.4854385853,
0.0556064397,
-0.2085297555,
-0.6293802261,
-0.1916711777,
-1.0389600992,
-0.0311855599,
0.1224251837,
0.159138605,
-0.6086716056,
0.2745905519,
-0.1031715944,
-0.2869697213,
-0.4253256619,
0.6320143938,
0.2804526091,
0.377399087,
0.1358461678,
-0.3816999495,
-0.5448653102,
-0.8506695628,
-0.3854665458,
0.0144783072,
0.1486650109,
0.0302173533,
0.7422150373,
-0.3826684952,
0.8571784496,
-0.2427659184,
-0.2423284799,
-0.4263764024,
0.2997039258,
-0.0214536525,
0.5343062878,
0.4756183922,
-0.1381859779,
-0.3197509646,
-0.2966415286,
-0.9792360067,
-0.1283780038,
-0.3514027297,
0.1061511785,
0.4569850564,
0.4082799554,
-0.2923385799,
0.2556269765,
0.760357976,
-0.2052298337,
0.6574300528,
-0.2508052289,
-0.0907253399,
-0.5758964419,
-0.1120218784,
-0.0334870405,
-0.383710593,
-0.1953731328,
-0.1882136166,
-0.0777107924,
-0.2179186493,
-0.2425022274,
0.699706614,
-0.572129786,
-0.2898505032,
-0.645437181,
0.0504111946,
0.0808889493,
0.2776410878,
-0.0131715396,
0.7261055708,
0.5017288327,
-0.5564343929,
0.3326079547,
-0.0570770279,
-0.5058213472,
0.1716070026,
-0.5672010779,
0.2365803272,
-0.2961417139,
0.215016216,
-0.8804398179,
-0.241154477,
0.4225113392,
-0.3394098878,
0.3632559478,
0.079045862,
-0.6577034593,
-0.4356187582,
0.0656570941,
0.297755748,
0.4847304821,
-0.7222002149,
0.3394151628,
0.3456889391,
-0.0548429415,
-0.4342944324,
-0.9109815359,
0.2418838143,
-0.0862616003,
-0.6725267172,
-0.2469884753,
-0.1948187798,
-0.1891902536,
0.115373306,
-0.1041628346,
0.1388755888,
0.1357855052,
0.1764067411,
-0.1220353395,
-0.1464441866,
0.3166739643,
-0.1483592242,
0.0334512033,
0.5144500732,
-0.2784523666,
0.6874806881,
-0.0487210751,
-0.5853766203,
-0.522765398,
0.4067980647,
0.3753450513,
-0.2585982084,
0.803776741,
0.4949557781,
-0.1120492071,
-0.7048369646,
-0.6329793334,
-0.1305360049,
-0.5190330148,
0.3405950367,
-0.1232836843,
-1.0432401896,
0.5514500737,
0.0312475637,
-0.0813959166,
0.8973947763,
0.8002430201,
-0.3238206506,
0.9268578887,
0.5406248569,
-0.0060955849,
0.3081787229,
-0.4541029632,
0.1888659894,
-0.6276607513,
-0.144293353,
-0.3156351745,
-0.1377736479,
-0.4287947416,
-0.2964029908,
0.0301993638,
-0.0745443553,
-0.2545899153,
-0.1211674511,
-0.3894506097,
0.6731559634,
0.531516552,
-0.1829205751,
0.4435259998,
0.0828605443,
-0.0633260161,
-0.1552530974,
-0.8167896271,
-0.5846785903,
1.0560432673,
0.4696017206,
1.3108087778,
-0.3192791641,
1.080911994,
0.5275394917,
0.4843006134,
-0.6610874534,
0.3907158673,
-0.220151633,
-0.6702389121,
-0.1361528039,
-0.7519222498,
-0.9288678765,
0.0508759134,
-0.0142253628,
-0.5294644237,
-0.163475737,
0.4663059711,
0.0073247193,
0.5488061309,
-0.5678346157,
0.9994140267,
-0.7557337284,
-0.4654687643,
-0.2278790027,
-0.3834011555,
0.7110911608,
-0.1550537646,
0.3759808838,
-0.2479542941,
0.407751888,
0.7313710451,
-0.3840305209,
1.0388631821,
0.0179002881,
-0.3886371851,
0.57413131,
0.2562111914,
0.370859623,
-0.1908941567,
0.1248573512,
0.1928436756,
-0.3847893476,
-0.3891639411,
-0.5445972681,
0.7717185616,
-0.9228621125,
-0.6615436673,
-0.6089451909,
-0.1927640438,
0.1170588806,
0.2877264619,
0.5142697096,
0.4760831892,
-0.0514943339,
0.1289750338,
0.4336917996,
-0.425247252,
0.4147078693,
0.3509158492,
-0.5233836174,
-0.4079740047,
1.0864117146,
0.2955195308,
0.5425577164,
-0.1554914117,
0.3855384588,
-0.3752563596,
-0.7299631238,
-0.4535467625,
0.4332473576,
-1.0438864231,
-0.140647307,
-0.5943929553,
-0.2640461624,
-0.4877123535,
0.1948111504,
-0.5957152843,
-0.0886165276,
-0.4124830663,
0.1622108072,
-0.0469117239,
1.312838316,
-0.0935643688,
0.3896620274,
-0.8561952114,
0.1733384132,
0.426308006,
0.4459346533,
0.1972204894,
-0.5846281648,
-0.4935695529,
0.0179441292,
-0.5065538287,
-0.6744768023,
0.5895549059,
0.355705291,
0.5899857879,
0.5841086507,
0.0045902547,
0.426952213,
-0.4882627726,
0.8209953904,
0.4573722184,
-1.0455389023,
0.5514335632,
-0.3412752748,
0.533575654,
0.2403299659,
0.2585123777,
-0.635345459,
-0.5560365915,
-0.4837112129,
-0.611322999,
0.5917093754,
0.1323224008,
0.468528837,
-0.4128261507,
0.3022665679,
0.1542285383,
0.1616880894,
-1.2607195377,
-0.2192478031,
-0.5135530233,
-0.0349462219,
0.0561622679,
-0.4823378623,
0.1581975669,
-0.0222583599,
0.7303398252,
-0.2679742575,
0.097827971,
0.2675785124,
-0.3745563328,
-0.3822290897,
0.0987073854,
0.3428855538,
0.7052776217,
0.1030875295,
0.3023506999,
-0.0906235874,
-0.0281231608,
0.0828465968,
-0.6575555801,
-0.1378249824,
-0.0000512848,
0.4963733852,
0.7896636128,
0.1082255319,
-0.9251403809,
0.5473406911,
-0.1431891471,
-0.1450863034,
-0.472576499,
0.2211479545,
0.3048889935,
0.0914754644,
0.2898126245,
-0.017348066,
0.0371019803,
-0.6934043765,
0.209586218,
0.3732150197,
0.0530183986,
-0.2427649051,
0.6447773576,
0.2338340729,
-0.1251762509,
0.7179870009,
-0.3893125057,
-0.4778590202,
0.5687752366,
0.8923264742,
0.8145923018,
-0.1250071526,
0.1294736564,
0.5548597574,
0.3724627793,
-0.1726302207,
0.0510445386,
0.1583390534,
-0.860399127,
-0.7478150725,
-0.8182942271,
-0.1543918848,
0.4612455368,
-0.4987051785,
0.0539968945,
-0.4644709527,
-0.033003971,
-0.1600635648,
-0.2482851744,
-0.7241008282,
0.3576103449,
0.5182107091,
0.4226210713,
-0.7669720054,
0.8634009957,
0.4349341691,
-0.2850261927,
-0.7253140211,
-0.1148727536,
-0.057653144,
-0.9811548591,
0.8852822781,
0.3445912302,
-0.3423208594,
-0.1018995345,
-0.8797883391,
-0.8945387006,
0.5896015763,
0.5785006285,
-0.7822802067,
0.1592106819,
0.3662044108,
0.4744999409,
-0.5144945979,
-0.1423276961,
0.3114511669,
0.2734240294,
0.2856670916,
-0.5134350061,
-0.0875108913,
-0.3035157919,
-0.0593310408,
0.010659379,
-0.6748124361,
0.8620888591,
-0.2341386378,
-0.4837943614,
-0.0435506217,
0.6991527677,
0.0744274482,
0.1887379438,
0.5552502275,
0.7187794447,
0.5314950943,
0.2264033109,
1.0237621069,
-0.1573001742,
0.6167081594,
1.4956203699,
-0.311956495,
0.6773529649,
0.3484450579,
-0.1407133937,
0.4619487226,
0.4948747456,
-0.3132081032,
0.2468407005,
0.5744716525,
-0.0169847608,
-0.4552354515,
0.091200985,
-0.2123984247,
0.7662885189,
0.2037525028,
-0.6336173415,
-0.2267751843,
0.0940652788,
0.0287274979,
0.0963656306,
-0.2665124536,
0.8049302101,
0.2423886061,
-0.7111305594,
0.7867115736,
-0.0724535212,
0.6188631654,
-0.4767685831,
0.266857475,
-0.2958353162,
0.0354040302,
-0.2693226039,
-0.5664586425,
0.5310722589,
0.1617195159,
-0.0194599219,
-0.3314346373,
0.8935552835,
-0.4586694241,
-0.6240157485,
0.4977434576,
0.6686128974,
0.2300254256,
-0.103052929,
-0.5602785349,
0.329831928,
-0.0817445889,
-0.4026715159,
0.3430164456,
0.558414638,
0.3995761871,
0.8005940318,
0.494759798,
0.0385694392,
0.3966148198,
0.0977254435,
0.838180542,
-0.8189588785,
-0.3508591652,
-1.0932425261,
0.2797173858,
-0.0190452412,
-0.2251157165,
0.8119472861,
0.5703027844,
1.111503005,
-0.1212958246,
1.0314253569,
0.1441301703,
0.2224773318,
-0.6301581264,
0.8186299801,
-0.8674096465,
0.4108558297,
-0.0828259215,
-0.6306779981,
-0.0060256827,
0.5288749933,
-0.2816715837,
0.1318525523,
0.6706006527,
0.5131927133,
0.0539986901,
-0.1372647583,
0.4711236358,
0.3925280869,
0.2253127843,
0.2068071663,
1.2220257521,
-0.1460322887,
0.5508972406,
-0.3467603028,
0.0955015495,
-0.098374702,
-0.9450343251,
-1.1160182953,
-0.4742303193,
-0.3550233245,
-0.3258027732,
-0.0815205202,
0.7532984018,
0.5914967656,
-0.7016487122,
-0.4454689622,
-0.0937894359,
0.1588435769,
0.1364869773,
-0.1501405239,
0.1390429437,
-0.6787090898,
-0.5256891251,
0.2340272069,
0.3831987083,
0.0188731048,
-0.7899802327,
-0.2050379962,
-0.0787048563,
-0.0058154603,
0.5452048182,
0.3019589782,
-0.8098421097,
-0.236225754,
-0.0909278393,
-0.1678592265,
0.4847659767,
0.9106765389,
-0.6900714636,
0.7436618209,
0.3642269075,
0.7242863774,
0.4738467038,
-0.3263345659,
0.5768908262,
-0.6836346984,
-0.3241169453,
0.1632616073,
0.5224161744,
0.5856570601,
-0.20757173,
0.1842468977,
0.4260037541,
-0.7668594718,
-0.6198426485,
0.3602604866,
-0.7000067234,
-0.3615321517,
1.0100278854,
-0.2041753829,
-0.5757981539,
0.1931000352,
-0.0009681029,
0.3222985268,
-0.3445345759,
1.0050039291,
0.6990463734,
-0.0287306774,
-0.3533429205,
-0.5956884027,
0.2553202212,
0.4178152382,
-0.8635058403,
0.1125099957,
0.6291638613,
0.6423047185,
0.0106194355,
0.7305240631,
0.0028472417,
-0.034338925,
-0.037718378,
0.3257987797,
0.0181437302,
-0.3183774948,
-0.4897547364,
0.048034288,
0.1905642301,
0.1272121072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16789v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16789v1
|
A Survey of the Evolution of Language Model-Based Dialogue Systems
| 2023-11-28T13:51:32 | 2023-11-28T13:51:32 |
Hongru Wang, Lingzhi Wang, Yiming Du, Liang Chen, Jingyan Zhou, Yufei Wang, Kam-Fai Wong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Dialogue systems, including task-oriented_dialogue_system (TOD) and
open-domain_dialogue_system (ODD), have undergone significant transformations,
with language_models (LM) playing a central role. This survey delves into the
historical trajectory of dialogue systems, elucidating their intricate
relationship with advancements in language models by categorizing this
evolution into four distinct stages, each marked by pivotal LM breakthroughs:
1) Early_Stage: characterized by statistical LMs, resulting in rule-based or
machine-learning-driven dialogue_systems; 2) Independent development of TOD and
ODD based on neural_language_models (NLM; e.g., LSTM and GRU), since NLMs lack
intrinsic knowledge in their parameters; 3) fusion between different types of
dialogue systems with the advert of pre-trained_language_models (PLMs),
starting from the fusion between four_sub-tasks_within_TOD, and then
TOD_with_ODD; and 4) current LLM-based_dialogue_system, wherein LLMs can be
used to conduct TOD and ODD seamlessly. Thus, our survey provides a
chronological perspective aligned with LM breakthroughs, offering a
comprehensive review of state-of-the-art research outcomes. What's more, we
focus on emerging topics and discuss open challenges, providing valuable
insights into future directions for LLM-based_dialogue_systems. Through this
exploration, we pave the way for a deeper_comprehension of the evolution,
guiding future developments in LM-based dialogue_systems.
|
[
-0.5289859176,
-0.707639575,
0.7387956977,
-0.2554412484,
0.2025704086,
0.2142039984,
0.025188135,
-0.2734737098,
-0.0705488548,
0.6524657607,
-0.7600761056,
-0.3099000454,
-0.4877183437,
0.1126799136,
-0.3662591279,
0.9902634621,
0.2419051826,
0.2947379947,
0.0797201544,
-0.258446753,
-0.4226696789,
-0.4438928366,
-0.4968281388,
-0.3804548681,
0.4151745439,
-0.1054807007,
0.5579847693,
0.2835143805,
0.1794463098,
0.2982469797,
-0.416433692,
0.3322295845,
-0.3898952603,
0.20767726,
0.0719081759,
-0.3825324774,
-0.6171411872,
-0.0263219308,
0.5417749882,
0.9783201814,
-0.1499532908,
-0.3019575775,
0.1130645201,
0.3845179975,
-0.3299309313,
0.1997994184,
-0.5262498856,
-0.1073948666,
-0.0065364321,
-0.1743221432,
-0.3772880435,
-0.4068261683,
0.406858474,
-0.1781302989,
-0.1777374893,
0.0729936734,
0.5546618104,
-0.1368050873,
-0.2163071632,
-0.3477818966,
-0.898024559,
0.8445484638,
-0.9781433344,
0.4486987889,
-0.1830944866,
0.3387636542,
-0.5209950805,
-0.7308059931,
-0.4609549642,
-0.1643150598,
0.2315190583,
-0.1280073822,
-0.207648918,
0.1175624132,
-0.0314063057,
0.386526376,
-0.3019714355,
0.33144328,
-0.3890865445,
-0.0328631289,
0.3569454849,
0.4367386699,
0.3449890614,
-0.1056981832,
-0.2016988695,
0.1829700172,
-0.9395134449,
-0.0135554122,
0.0109048933,
0.4146007299,
-0.0403711386,
0.2734367251,
-0.1791153997,
0.880987823,
-0.1439432353,
-0.3505661488,
-0.1134788096,
-0.6568949223,
-0.2953571081,
-0.127683267,
1.0856866837,
0.1375811547,
-0.046812512,
0.0337529294,
-0.2681869566,
-0.2029947639,
-0.0163687281,
-0.3034744859,
0.0683689713,
-0.0668927059,
-0.4727734923,
-0.3087435961,
-0.2644340396,
-0.441647023,
-0.4239887595,
-0.1867914796,
0.2969023883,
-0.2974159718,
-0.3594629169,
0.2636494935,
0.0327557735,
0.151308015,
0.7305768728,
-0.7058571577,
0.3237652481,
0.8722346425,
0.8013369441,
-0.1890465319,
-0.0218788944,
-0.0352881327,
-0.313123852,
-0.3477906883,
0.6141525507,
-0.4071643651,
-0.5032910705,
0.3446115851,
0.0096178725,
-0.0553605519,
-0.4977811575,
0.3846137226,
-0.5529432893,
0.6069716215,
0.2230981737,
-0.3170143664,
-0.2371300906,
0.4065792561,
-0.2588432431,
0.9267393947,
0.0133710904,
-0.4195921719,
0.0273166969,
-0.6807752848,
0.1980619282,
0.0523611605,
-0.3918457925,
-0.0098957596,
0.1003465876,
0.0918576494,
0.3868510723,
-0.7673330903,
0.4893467724,
-0.3860379159,
-0.2123728096,
0.2923054695,
-0.4533967078,
0.9671283364,
0.2106333971,
-0.2190740108,
0.0947052091,
-0.7166033387,
0.0738417357,
0.0085348953,
-0.0461467244,
-0.1947317272,
0.1805197597,
-0.4424196482,
0.423923403,
0.1635231674,
-0.4619445801,
0.3489388824,
-0.4903143048,
0.6777952909,
0.6058149934,
0.0454220474,
0.4038460851,
-0.4358067811,
0.4063783288,
0.0870694891,
0.3738802075,
-0.6150667667,
-0.769122541,
-1.1159465313,
0.1130194142,
-0.0509275347,
0.5179827809,
-0.3142210245,
0.3851475418,
-0.2944394648,
-0.5329129696,
-0.304961741,
-0.2619919777,
0.2119049728,
0.1480499953,
0.0703934506,
-0.2559198439,
-0.2806845307,
-0.7332109213,
-0.1016383022,
-0.6098626256,
0.1033616737,
0.4616442025,
0.1030201837,
-0.2935626209,
0.8553973436,
-0.200084433,
0.185483709,
-0.5174931288,
0.0709950328,
0.4164967537,
0.1827457845,
0.3052077293,
-0.4952217042,
-0.288911134,
0.0162755996,
-0.4227908552,
-0.296361357,
-0.0036698065,
0.0857497603,
0.2512633204,
0.4715493321,
-0.5815116167,
0.3597631454,
0.5256479979,
-0.068963252,
0.6240137815,
0.0686994195,
0.096813865,
-0.966709733,
-0.095143415,
-0.3007854521,
-0.0744007677,
-1.0212899446,
-0.2726421058,
-0.2495648265,
-0.0160836633,
-0.3212467432,
0.4984787703,
-0.4779330194,
-0.1988280565,
-0.1517490298,
0.2142370045,
-0.3127608597,
0.5316765308,
-0.0173738319,
0.1798336059,
0.6442417502,
-0.7724998593,
0.2173107266,
0.2604626417,
-0.3595610261,
0.2683157325,
-0.2132144868,
0.3460640609,
0.0353566892,
0.2985672057,
-0.9308483601,
0.1793638021,
0.4802552164,
-0.3437644839,
0.0556446761,
-0.0602160916,
-0.2943660617,
-0.3249765337,
-0.0449575409,
0.3932879865,
0.4942955375,
-0.1754689366,
0.4163390696,
0.2636104822,
-0.7866155505,
-0.4046143591,
-0.1578266919,
0.2384442389,
-0.1243154705,
-0.7314855456,
-0.0858195052,
-0.1377801597,
-0.556540966,
-0.3540016115,
-0.0718659312,
0.0428679436,
0.0243743137,
0.0939137638,
0.3395301402,
-0.3552253842,
-0.0861238465,
-0.0372875147,
0.0795485005,
0.0154328076,
-0.4311136901,
0.8851860762,
-0.0759341791,
-0.3233222961,
-0.4816218913,
0.1733141541,
0.7014632821,
-0.0439130776,
0.5185416341,
0.081849061,
-0.0626060292,
-0.1994859427,
-0.503714323,
-0.1625868529,
-0.4275604784,
0.224107787,
-0.2425899059,
-1.221693635,
0.4077556431,
-0.3443155885,
0.4219585061,
0.3970588744,
0.6440562606,
0.0850644633,
1.1523478031,
0.7323666811,
0.1587529927,
0.6923287511,
0.0307318438,
0.4827629328,
-0.7979143262,
-0.3623600304,
-0.5582534671,
-0.0295235105,
-0.7275636792,
-0.5052092075,
0.603292346,
0.2518255115,
-0.1349952519,
0.2506997287,
-0.1089786291,
-0.1296512187,
0.2992632985,
-0.2796747983,
0.4446474612,
-0.267421186,
-0.216627419,
0.0637643784,
-0.8897391558,
-0.5882546902,
1.0871953964,
0.5503181219,
0.7062713504,
0.1356929392,
0.5860936642,
0.2208242118,
0.1767870337,
-0.5792540312,
0.7613912225,
0.10649129,
-0.48218292,
-0.4668681026,
-0.2506676614,
-0.7701553106,
0.1697325408,
0.2311610579,
-1.0370776653,
0.4187789559,
-0.159348771,
-0.3620244265,
0.2428462654,
-0.2675198615,
0.567248106,
-0.2018838674,
0.0153871104,
-0.1081889346,
-0.790727973,
0.5513550639,
-0.0131091205,
0.4267840683,
-0.2419324666,
0.2800833881,
0.5903127789,
-0.5213805437,
0.6385362744,
-0.1038662419,
-0.4609631896,
0.3530805111,
0.2729506195,
0.4450516105,
-0.3014725149,
0.0847992897,
0.0570937693,
0.084454298,
-0.0431430377,
-0.6660085917,
0.62346071,
-0.4933972955,
-0.7703077197,
-0.3573339581,
-0.5226499438,
-0.5120180845,
0.1507865041,
-0.1512906402,
0.6335858107,
-0.4042164087,
-0.0133214891,
0.6577749848,
-0.2433745563,
0.6132495403,
0.5836824775,
-0.65644449,
-0.3206472993,
0.6292844415,
-0.0787206441,
0.7011657357,
0.3173314035,
0.0418560989,
-0.2542202771,
-0.86384058,
-0.4455958307,
0.168872416,
-0.5914227962,
-0.0244585406,
-0.7435855865,
-0.3623767197,
-0.6265066266,
0.1944092512,
-0.2710652351,
-0.4770047665,
-0.2579923272,
0.2160043567,
0.1238990873,
1.1081645489,
0.0255392995,
0.2013720125,
-0.867269814,
-0.0438952111,
0.2519423664,
0.2272737622,
-0.0912116766,
-0.4620223939,
-0.2380638272,
0.3069851696,
-0.4086613357,
-0.8802402616,
0.3274751306,
0.1579162329,
0.5001016855,
0.5860747099,
-0.1723336279,
0.4213021994,
-0.5911082029,
1.1813439131,
0.407420367,
-0.6183513999,
0.2988605797,
-0.6829915643,
0.3187116385,
0.0221738908,
0.1189840659,
-0.9463178515,
-0.4828858078,
-0.3740339279,
-0.6281917095,
1.2541120052,
0.0372398794,
-0.0020206862,
0.1129467115,
0.0895667747,
0.3098576963,
0.1486514062,
-0.6246125698,
-0.3521738946,
-0.0271756481,
-0.0566635244,
-0.1194262356,
0.0443915986,
-0.1962910742,
-0.0400434099,
0.5985939503,
-0.0634449944,
0.4181551635,
0.0058472827,
-0.0514556058,
0.0682347715,
0.7429423928,
0.7160105109,
0.5209873915,
-0.1184140667,
-0.1833461821,
-0.0204631556,
0.0243892167,
0.2581171691,
0.0027299512,
-0.261567831,
0.0709047318,
0.0038271118,
1.3083890676,
0.197651431,
-0.7444792986,
0.3039175272,
0.0909591988,
-0.1428816617,
-0.1355845183,
0.2140389681,
-0.1561154723,
0.4760147035,
0.362942189,
-0.0009716459,
0.104359895,
-0.9067566991,
-0.1703427881,
0.4139748812,
-0.5065316558,
-0.4463143349,
0.1852779239,
0.2421717048,
-0.6488299966,
0.0411673225,
-0.03868654,
-0.4411026537,
0.1133713797,
0.4559521675,
1.0451959372,
-0.2224532515,
0.3235553801,
0.0903864577,
0.0569107123,
-0.185636282,
0.1201630235,
-0.2888565361,
-0.8136038184,
-0.0607617944,
-0.7905889153,
-0.3885674775,
0.3021335006,
-0.3890216053,
0.276784271,
-0.3304348588,
-0.1746201962,
-0.0719048083,
-0.3361371756,
-0.517947197,
0.0537323058,
0.3584182262,
0.8107932806,
-0.414714992,
0.5635900497,
0.6751433611,
0.0723736435,
-0.3601614237,
-0.1869502813,
0.2279037088,
-0.7835354805,
0.6695238352,
-0.101889655,
-0.3140593469,
0.109876506,
-0.3625947833,
-0.8120635152,
0.8937367797,
-0.186192885,
-0.7510950565,
-0.5811825991,
0.4300851226,
0.5569913387,
-0.6600670218,
0.4019301832,
0.7280139327,
0.2272333056,
-0.2533879876,
-1.3310234547,
-0.2890124619,
-0.1691735387,
0.2428065389,
0.5320726037,
-0.456338793,
0.8493599296,
-0.0091309492,
-0.3512031138,
0.7680683732,
0.2330941111,
0.1359744966,
0.2993845642,
0.4655911028,
0.3998892903,
0.0753086656,
-0.4495400488,
0.6725947857,
-0.2398483604,
0.1279980838,
0.8178288341,
-0.1530797035,
0.6910744309,
0.3401260674,
-0.3009275794,
0.6452865005,
0.5410889387,
0.3051206172,
0.374450326,
0.2615288496,
-0.3263316751,
-0.3122423291,
-0.2465089858,
-0.2948638797,
0.3299949765,
0.7124958038,
-0.4189762473,
-0.4354188442,
0.0501381643,
-0.1613681465,
-0.2667974234,
-0.3413850367,
1.2831192017,
0.1341108084,
-0.8650625348,
0.6298735738,
-0.0615953952,
0.570718646,
-0.9127553701,
0.0820507035,
-0.2870055735,
-0.106029205,
0.1520061046,
-0.6119256616,
-0.2309818268,
0.0675121844,
0.040169403,
-0.4754262269,
0.6835656762,
-0.496071279,
-0.0527900681,
0.2678202093,
0.939876616,
0.259329319,
0.3836550117,
-0.6079846621,
0.3062761724,
0.1369440705,
0.0228557102,
0.2614810765,
0.5392478108,
-0.1424830407,
0.6364392638,
0.4239118099,
-0.0161295831,
0.3836336136,
0.1605405807,
0.821403265,
-0.8713109493,
-0.4582338631,
-0.5724990964,
0.5691794753,
0.1235596314,
-0.2284883261,
0.544575274,
0.1406107247,
0.6644970179,
0.3361772895,
0.9046368599,
-0.1367141902,
0.7549508214,
-0.4366630018,
0.5044767857,
-0.6069573164,
0.3153095543,
-0.4691567123,
-1.0007548332,
-0.037972793,
0.0131821278,
-0.2307151556,
0.1179126725,
0.6516647935,
0.8442315459,
0.212188378,
0.2802064419,
0.3688003421,
0.4360161722,
0.4095714986,
0.2527516484,
1.2674978971,
-0.3010680377,
0.4600269794,
0.120038189,
-0.2120695561,
-0.4225951731,
-0.3847228885,
-0.5273373723,
-0.6558493376,
-0.2262536138,
-0.1234134808,
0.3425605893,
0.7486236095,
0.5651162863,
-0.8860362768,
-0.4385115504,
-0.4407630861,
-0.0309081618,
0.0222909395,
-0.1927369386,
-0.0036096685,
-0.3568146825,
-0.9317831993,
0.746619463,
0.6474568844,
0.1162360832,
-0.598331213,
-0.294360429,
-0.1313533187,
0.3038962483,
0.5763751864,
0.5626557469,
-1.2082726955,
-0.1846232414,
0.2116414905,
-0.0816760659,
0.1734352261,
0.9675457478,
-0.6269801259,
0.6774673462,
0.5750876665,
0.3621796966,
0.1300610453,
-0.4410478175,
0.9845525622,
-0.1220290437,
-0.0969437882,
0.4742516279,
0.454566896,
0.265588969,
0.39923051,
0.1606242806,
0.3008780479,
-0.6103613377,
-1.1770596504,
0.6211132407,
-0.8413404822,
-0.1909388006,
0.9097925425,
-0.0876903459,
0.2235178053,
-0.3839457631,
-0.2302731127,
0.2148290724,
-0.3076106906,
0.6845126748,
0.7824971676,
-0.5635755658,
-0.4576690793,
-0.2419861555,
0.6837207079,
0.5170653462,
-0.6730292439,
0.0145728402,
0.5835914612,
-0.0525967106,
0.413564831,
0.5877439976,
-0.2801806331,
0.1073409021,
-0.2325334698,
-0.1435232013,
0.279735893,
-0.4736118317,
-0.3517338336,
-0.0093045216,
0.230663538,
0.092735745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16787v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16787v2
|
Evaluating Optimal Reference Translations
| 2023-11-28T13:50:50 | 2024-03-08T12:21:12 |
Vilém Zouhar, Věra Kloudová, Martin Popel, Ondřej Bojar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The overall translation quality reached by current machine translation (MT)
systems for high-resourced language pairs is remarkably good. Standard methods
of evaluation are not suitable nor intended to uncover the many translation
errors and quality deficiencies that still persist. Furthermore, the quality of
standard reference translations is commonly questioned and comparable quality
levels have been reached by MT alone in several language pairs. Navigating
further research in these high-resource settings is thus difficult. In this
article, we propose a methodology for creating more reliable document-level
human reference translations, called "optimal reference translations," with the
simple aim to raise the bar of what should be deemed "human translation
quality." We evaluate the obtained document-level optimal reference
translations in comparison with "standard" ones, confirming a significant
quality increase and also documenting the relationship between evaluation and
translation editing.
|
[
-0.3077354729,
-0.1502325237,
0.5352671146,
0.0159478448,
-0.4085784554,
0.1028193086,
-0.2998947799,
-0.2747856975,
-0.0010743868,
0.5387711525,
-0.0692143366,
-0.3744273186,
-0.5545791388,
0.7812144756,
-0.4888927341,
0.9938715696,
-0.4079765379,
0.0830700994,
-0.4362687767,
-0.5205020308,
-0.3762606978,
-0.623493135,
-0.4619357288,
-0.4922375679,
0.5565395951,
0.4495117366,
1.2070512772,
0.9579380155,
1.140496254,
0.3362307847,
-0.1544151455,
0.5176643133,
-0.6376863718,
0.1142002419,
-0.31736058,
-0.3723560274,
-0.6541483998,
0.3036515117,
0.6847150326,
0.7220113277,
0.1058044657,
0.5069305897,
0.0093750665,
0.8632712364,
-0.4830725789,
-0.2584781051,
-0.294583708,
-0.003267627,
-0.2701438367,
-0.6369636059,
-0.424790293,
-0.5904285312,
-0.0894597471,
-0.6917276382,
0.2911478579,
0.2402623296,
1.0664050579,
0.311662823,
-0.3985624611,
-0.288718164,
-0.7613505125,
0.7173801064,
-0.4151754677,
0.487372309,
0.609573245,
0.205875963,
-0.1919456124,
-0.4810427129,
-0.5123440027,
-0.3574028015,
-0.0536040701,
0.0863419548,
-0.3066249192,
-0.2044706196,
0.1143004224,
0.3397800624,
-0.4701049328,
-0.3994110823,
-0.4057873189,
0.0066531231,
0.4598936439,
0.2334318906,
0.4367470443,
-0.2598884106,
-0.095736742,
-0.2955015302,
-0.574755609,
-0.193049863,
0.3366672397,
0.0268818624,
0.3919866383,
0.5611320734,
-0.1587236077,
0.7237743139,
0.2512076199,
-0.3945539594,
0.2679149508,
-0.8443433642,
-0.0530660786,
-0.2399217635,
0.6407846808,
0.7579982281,
0.0223165732,
-0.5405210257,
-0.605489254,
-0.152362287,
0.5362297893,
-0.4235911667,
0.1674417853,
-0.068274945,
-0.4880263209,
-0.459666431,
-0.0520240776,
-0.4081787765,
-0.2541770339,
-0.587015748,
0.5754564404,
-0.4138835967,
0.0450024009,
0.0438338481,
-0.1404545009,
-0.2966406345,
0.1883768588,
-0.5616544485,
0.1118275225,
0.2124400288,
0.7525437474,
-0.1947581917,
-0.2235124558,
-0.5732719898,
0.2997735143,
-0.7187385559,
0.9331903458,
-0.2481521964,
-0.6072136164,
-0.0137149589,
-0.328678906,
0.3499976993,
-0.8283496499,
1.4043508768,
-0.4892611802,
0.1595108211,
-0.5555090904,
-0.1899232715,
0.172210753,
0.0625543147,
-0.5993825197,
1.0707359314,
0.4123378694,
-0.4559721649,
0.2538430989,
-0.6709488034,
-0.4443497956,
0.0721556544,
0.3577210903,
-0.1442442685,
0.2121963054,
0.1827980727,
0.1379727572,
-0.8284362555,
0.1394511312,
0.1415917873,
-0.2916785181,
0.3375264406,
-0.1689544171,
0.5081318021,
0.6779310107,
-0.0086939596,
0.032785017,
-0.5970960855,
0.0961073041,
0.1111523509,
-0.7693972588,
-0.5741186738,
-0.1219872907,
-0.0818454996,
0.0770094544,
0.2973115444,
-0.3380585015,
-0.0591016151,
-0.0695755929,
0.3483765125,
0.5302909017,
-0.0738458857,
0.569637239,
-0.2652962804,
0.4914416671,
-0.2129499763,
0.3047884703,
0.0063448711,
-0.129835546,
-1.0105513334,
0.4080950022,
0.5159808397,
0.2735628486,
-0.8521983027,
0.6879652143,
-0.5792466998,
-0.2403326631,
-0.8785212636,
0.4476239085,
0.7038166523,
0.6414480805,
0.5151616335,
-0.4809899032,
-0.2606260777,
-0.8391622901,
-0.4231174886,
-0.1992295831,
0.0242738146,
-0.0940701291,
0.2569899261,
-0.1818386316,
0.7244735956,
-0.2262110412,
-0.0938508287,
-0.1507966965,
0.2440049797,
0.1296270788,
0.4697447121,
0.6384314299,
-0.764775753,
-0.5636047721,
0.267083317,
-0.7123124003,
-0.5287573338,
-0.2032170743,
-0.7856631875,
-0.1859155893,
0.3897761106,
-0.1681740284,
-0.0344006047,
0.4948733449,
-0.0770939961,
0.4579016566,
-0.5786342621,
0.4534398317,
-0.8977298737,
0.5638599396,
0.0234673135,
-0.440674305,
-0.5447525978,
0.451456368,
0.2556881905,
-0.1273938417,
-0.0493813716,
0.3072291315,
-0.6750014424,
-0.079003714,
-0.3038157821,
0.5665147305,
0.1217350364,
0.1074324176,
-0.454703331,
0.9047112465,
-0.3729762733,
-0.2342629284,
0.6335534453,
0.4152107239,
-0.3529419601,
1.1697369814,
-0.4973271787,
0.4766416848,
-0.177717641,
0.1928838938,
-0.6429971457,
-0.1543751359,
0.1759065688,
-0.6171867847,
0.4032297134,
0.1369737834,
-0.6996054649,
-0.4016579688,
-0.0704117715,
0.1923865229,
0.4090415835,
-0.335596472,
-0.0708279237,
0.4324648678,
-0.1763449758,
-0.5202198029,
-0.4286951423,
0.4482902884,
0.2374428511,
-0.6308928132,
0.2613391578,
-0.1274911016,
-0.0839773566,
0.2988634706,
-0.4629123807,
-0.2864825428,
-0.2095973641,
-0.2844240367,
0.1974027753,
-0.1441589594,
-0.152613759,
-0.0034921279,
-0.6077895761,
-0.127032876,
-0.3275442421,
0.1243069544,
-0.1218036339,
-0.2383620143,
-0.3822355568,
0.5665894747,
0.6979480982,
-0.4722312391,
0.2455884516,
0.5385573506,
-0.2114418745,
0.4032901824,
-0.8167043924,
0.3323278725,
-0.4335288703,
0.4328922033,
-0.6451908946,
-0.2120415717,
0.1698639244,
-0.0646361187,
0.0691542253,
0.6039782166,
0.3770214319,
-0.2358892113,
1.1727269888,
0.473311156,
-0.0185935833,
0.3519284427,
-0.2226114869,
0.0678521693,
-1.0645903349,
-0.090483427,
-0.9416515231,
-0.4513020217,
-0.1905557662,
-0.5739602447,
0.5837854147,
0.4795685709,
-0.0880575627,
0.8155726194,
-0.6494839787,
0.6771838069,
0.7717549801,
0.1018705666,
0.7036674023,
0.070033513,
-0.6154378057,
-0.1449877173,
-0.6020022631,
-0.9734816551,
1.0310900211,
0.1006424129,
0.46128425,
0.0280033778,
0.6593555808,
0.2662278116,
0.5638968349,
-0.4836330116,
0.4595200419,
-0.2082739919,
-0.7431899309,
-0.2922250926,
-0.6023845673,
-0.9828622937,
0.3098221123,
-0.4345523715,
-0.0983902737,
0.1547774822,
-0.0019159947,
-0.1879346371,
0.1094173789,
-0.6781061888,
0.9337347746,
-0.3747260571,
-0.2427709699,
-0.464566052,
-0.7363390923,
-0.0713163391,
-0.3699656129,
0.2925997376,
-0.020012293,
-0.3200463057,
0.5687705874,
-0.3364197314,
0.0484449007,
0.2006255388,
0.1150898784,
0.2450516373,
0.2329122126,
0.5030556917,
-0.4309363663,
-0.4282669723,
-0.2000964433,
0.205725044,
-0.6186272502,
-0.6531297565,
0.4168018997,
-1.094746232,
-0.3135516644,
-0.22376436,
-0.4743904769,
-0.1132620201,
0.5670937896,
0.3180500269,
0.2568852305,
-0.3339624405,
0.2410071343,
0.2640265226,
-0.2024885416,
-0.1343216151,
0.5777868032,
0.1922861338,
-0.6977427006,
1.0411587954,
0.0901746303,
0.4161865115,
0.5473417044,
0.2101453096,
-0.2602575123,
-0.7714759707,
-0.8391870856,
0.2458192855,
-0.7877303958,
-0.2004448622,
-0.1767794341,
0.1957087964,
-0.1043119133,
-0.283597827,
-0.2958689034,
-0.2092118114,
0.0232188012,
0.197586149,
-0.2325456291,
0.550208509,
-0.2130574882,
0.1503237188,
-1.1547195911,
0.4267576933,
0.078264147,
0.071034506,
-0.3661359847,
-0.6965946555,
-0.6391838789,
0.1065022498,
-0.6183825731,
-0.8786850572,
0.2877108753,
-0.0305240378,
0.7375866175,
0.3342686892,
0.2532759905,
0.8362998366,
-0.6310880184,
0.4729398191,
0.4500543475,
-0.9795860052,
0.438154757,
-0.3296148181,
0.2412967831,
0.8574432731,
0.3727168739,
-0.9095004797,
-0.5059808493,
-0.5003421903,
-0.7389663458,
0.5049845576,
0.52226758,
0.2154257745,
0.1330960989,
0.7087746859,
-0.1912565529,
0.0860639215,
-0.3502530158,
-0.1288158,
0.0420518741,
-0.1291263998,
-0.223476544,
-0.1562328041,
-0.3338697553,
-0.1926105469,
0.4831427634,
0.1407246888,
0.2547625303,
0.2880373597,
-0.2927005887,
-0.8799586892,
0.2109734714,
0.5321288109,
0.9465071559,
-0.3334874213,
0.1660971195,
0.2259258032,
-0.4769366086,
0.3990922272,
-0.3070541024,
-0.2971417308,
0.3436982036,
0.2762923539,
0.5787456632,
0.0637242049,
-0.3796708584,
0.4168274999,
0.313285917,
-0.0193146318,
0.0822857842,
-0.173876971,
0.0058211787,
-0.1680185199,
0.2141342759,
0.4427630603,
0.0260231439,
-0.523665905,
0.1052369773,
0.0946323797,
-0.2952385843,
-0.2509181201,
0.7363741398,
0.913689971,
-0.6006599665,
0.6021717787,
-0.2677389681,
-0.3307921886,
0.1119953766,
0.3821283877,
0.7788385749,
-0.2412419319,
-0.0053350232,
0.5836449862,
0.5517690182,
-0.3182773292,
-0.0953346863,
0.1251948327,
-0.6396568418,
-0.4350955486,
-0.48105371,
-0.6070040464,
-0.3409052491,
-0.7192649245,
0.2400914282,
0.028614549,
-0.6078520417,
-0.0200642366,
-0.0184266604,
-0.613134861,
0.1934734583,
-0.2068199515,
0.7630952001,
-0.3508331478,
0.8091351986,
0.7939021587,
-0.7302575111,
-0.3052996397,
-0.1045875996,
-0.1043000743,
-0.7310332656,
0.613692224,
-0.4430604577,
-0.3995858431,
0.0872758999,
-0.2676733732,
-0.7596297264,
0.7471851707,
0.7189285159,
-0.2515959144,
-0.2443674505,
0.2028329819,
0.7359616756,
0.0984962061,
0.2088386714,
0.5617660284,
0.7851883173,
-0.1279108971,
-1.0842409134,
0.1010676622,
-0.4205435812,
0.1618546844,
0.3366201222,
-0.5779681802,
0.2398347557,
-0.2211553603,
-0.2648341358,
0.2900410295,
0.5025157332,
-0.5207362771,
0.0297397282,
0.4457618594,
0.4903402328,
0.720405221,
-0.1420399398,
1.2529284954,
-0.4959139824,
0.3124905527,
0.8418148756,
0.1587456912,
1.0019329786,
0.5322799087,
-0.4715071023,
0.0502781719,
0.6642155051,
0.0511064269,
0.3474396467,
0.245628342,
-0.2271306664,
-0.3883498609,
-0.1828762591,
-0.3151398003,
-0.1258053333,
-0.0034524407,
-0.4797280729,
-0.0496078804,
-0.3504185379,
0.0801093131,
0.4507636726,
0.1884439141,
0.5690811872,
-0.0002510479,
-0.8814666867,
1.0212874413,
0.4565556049,
0.2717357874,
-0.192341581,
0.2511748075,
-0.445573926,
0.0717597306,
-0.1928592771,
-0.6814544201,
0.3835149407,
0.3798555434,
-0.2529192269,
-0.6334677935,
0.2303629518,
-0.2948502898,
-0.4382046163,
0.0077878716,
0.5697593093,
0.5205371976,
0.0461165495,
-0.6489588618,
-0.0970921367,
-0.0434767529,
-0.1001958922,
0.2642331421,
0.5137049556,
0.2198963016,
0.5094989538,
0.8332782388,
0.2318987101,
-0.1060167179,
-0.1306311786,
0.4783305824,
-0.552921772,
-0.1695953608,
-0.4828912914,
0.2873804867,
-0.2076511383,
-0.6608834267,
0.5074012876,
0.616094768,
0.9277642965,
0.1056278944,
0.7722051144,
0.1188156754,
0.406709075,
-0.2119273096,
0.537491858,
-0.6457191706,
-0.0274489392,
-0.4905409515,
-1.1488621235,
-0.3989480436,
0.8629260063,
-0.0471202694,
-0.297254771,
0.9737053514,
0.6311858892,
-0.0069790338,
-0.3024132252,
0.4103651345,
0.0641768873,
0.2210782319,
0.5171981454,
0.8013420701,
-0.6385860443,
1.180383563,
-0.085058637,
-0.3802527189,
-0.3565909266,
-0.7924287319,
-0.453179121,
-0.6301076412,
-0.1179360151,
-0.5116425157,
0.2748363614,
1.0616791248,
0.5822633505,
-0.5166839957,
-0.4795155227,
0.101623401,
0.0550916865,
-0.2852407694,
-0.0490241162,
0.2732506394,
-0.5802868605,
-1.1387745142,
0.2278359681,
0.252068609,
-0.0058974507,
-0.2819065154,
-0.4471192956,
0.2209467888,
0.0244098939,
0.5710958838,
0.1757179648,
-0.5950053334,
-0.1801233739,
0.0908502862,
-0.8078461289,
0.1998285353,
0.9805982113,
-0.0006603822,
0.9126038551,
0.8217725158,
0.7616166472,
0.3829535246,
0.1664726287,
1.0311583281,
-0.3409502506,
-0.1326311082,
0.1125589162,
0.2451090366,
0.3876598775,
-0.0163189098,
0.8614121079,
0.4027960002,
-0.7193701863,
-0.8279862404,
-0.0491342321,
-0.9202337861,
0.1255726516,
1.1079318523,
-0.3140762746,
0.0665586889,
-0.0603300743,
-0.5881538391,
0.5186231136,
-0.3383612931,
0.7705444694,
0.8747889996,
-0.17905204,
0.3921333253,
-0.8272836804,
0.2935039997,
0.4059122503,
-0.7189392447,
-0.1541445702,
0.3882688284,
0.0377200507,
0.5658985972,
0.5379980803,
-0.4334159493,
0.3023332655,
-0.0322668031,
0.0324287266,
-0.0464103967,
0.0575302504,
0.1469765753,
-0.1619811505,
0.4033867419,
-0.1283497363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03737v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03737v1
|
A Generic NLI approach for Classification of Sentiment Associated with Therapies
| 2023-11-28T13:27:21 | 2023-11-28T13:27:21 |
Rajaraman Kanagasabai, Anitha Veeramani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper describes our system for addressing SMM4H 2023 Shared Task 2 on
"Classification of sentiment associated with therapies (aspect-oriented)". In
our work, we adopt an approach based on Natural language inference (NLI) to
formulate this task as a sentence pair classification problem, and train
transformer models to predict sentiment associated with a therapy on a given
text. Our best model achieved 75.22\% F1-score which was 11\% (4\%) more than
the mean (median) score of all teams' submissions.
|
[
-0.2305634022,
-0.4419999421,
0.6139847636,
0.4041060805,
-0.009046114,
-0.0199785363,
0.1805124283,
-0.4262180924,
0.6432652473,
0.6369044185,
-0.6699162722,
-0.4370403886,
-0.6322872043,
0.1872552484,
-0.1245103925,
1.2820900679,
-0.0985638723,
0.3495277762,
-0.2703357339,
-0.4071865678,
-0.2211031467,
-0.7003293037,
-0.7623353601,
-0.5003510714,
0.632350564,
0.2331407219,
0.4413924217,
0.1370884925,
0.8615024686,
0.2774588168,
-0.1745614558,
-0.3920212388,
0.0853620768,
-0.0465088114,
-0.0927417353,
-0.7772966027,
-0.811362505,
0.2590295672,
0.242260322,
0.7440467477,
-0.2191552222,
-0.0454713665,
0.261423409,
0.7083333731,
-0.1458622664,
-0.0252729971,
-0.3097291291,
0.5712958574,
-0.0290981643,
-0.2329509258,
-0.3895680606,
-0.2379819155,
0.2276046872,
-0.3452149928,
0.2912370563,
0.1632830948,
0.6982011795,
0.1912195683,
-0.5198193192,
-0.3669262528,
-0.4588356614,
1.2004777193,
-0.8911382556,
-0.0984890088,
0.2339484692,
0.2670225799,
0.0162369329,
-0.6671314836,
-0.3903938532,
0.0414071605,
-0.3228764534,
0.2713877261,
-0.1329863369,
0.4839242995,
0.1205442101,
0.5587682724,
-0.6665360928,
-0.0209168456,
-0.3733865023,
-0.1388081312,
0.6500384212,
0.2363383025,
0.3259685338,
-0.7987421155,
-0.5520607829,
0.6356207132,
-0.3508763909,
0.0786214918,
-0.0384445712,
0.1405360699,
-0.0491438545,
0.57418859,
-0.0629636645,
0.5710029006,
0.1329465508,
-0.3494057953,
0.4436684847,
-0.4607409835,
-0.4917969108,
0.0531163104,
1.0216884613,
0.7649577856,
-0.1627155095,
-0.4619297981,
-0.0616260208,
0.1526049823,
0.710501194,
-0.437889725,
-0.0921223536,
0.530597806,
-0.5717251897,
-0.6854351163,
0.083535552,
-0.740383625,
-0.164057672,
-0.3318667114,
0.6325002909,
-0.6431360841,
-0.4048854411,
-0.2149683982,
-0.2409914583,
0.288316071,
-0.0101389671,
-0.6676831245,
0.5510771275,
0.9761158228,
0.9367582202,
-0.3940158486,
-0.2465598434,
-0.226602003,
0.1388053745,
-0.0279505625,
0.9544612169,
-0.3284944594,
-0.407120198,
-0.1559531242,
-0.0092879357,
-0.3747824132,
-0.3896290362,
0.7558894157,
-0.1761599481,
0.8096706271,
-0.3120164573,
-0.7603462338,
-0.2595216632,
0.6592270732,
-0.677662015,
0.7405287623,
0.450586766,
-1.1066954136,
0.2158355415,
-1.2768547535,
-0.3174067736,
0.0067072329,
0.283628881,
-0.3214930892,
0.1795862019,
-0.0065727266,
0.3961735666,
-0.0956216156,
0.7059306502,
-0.3017309904,
-0.2576735616,
0.3408806622,
-0.1845850497,
0.6142272949,
0.336509496,
-0.4293085635,
0.4269353449,
-0.5375005603,
0.0818062574,
-0.1888198256,
-0.0988066643,
-0.309946835,
-0.3802002668,
0.1957985908,
0.4139609933,
0.2609919608,
-0.6753025651,
0.1841970235,
-0.6971566081,
0.4397964478,
0.4880993664,
0.5291824937,
0.6520999074,
-0.3985335231,
0.6986933351,
0.1948668212,
0.4991912842,
0.4008975327,
-0.6825489402,
-0.9049302936,
-0.1596171856,
0.3544303477,
0.4464339316,
-0.8962895274,
0.5687873363,
-0.0820775032,
-0.262329042,
-0.7242949605,
-0.0482920073,
0.4480931163,
0.4163798094,
0.5060610771,
0.0223800298,
-0.7480382919,
-1.128177762,
-0.3246159554,
-0.1882276535,
0.0600856133,
0.1299743652,
0.4865570068,
-0.3286946118,
0.8078274131,
-0.2504025698,
-0.4310306907,
-0.5579144359,
0.5448678732,
0.3148239255,
0.3702636361,
0.3638994694,
-0.8483473063,
-0.3854569197,
-0.2149404436,
-0.8611755371,
-0.1313741952,
0.131610021,
-0.3420519829,
0.2869006097,
0.2832803428,
-0.231194064,
0.2664721906,
0.6198778152,
-0.3574496508,
-0.0425021648,
-0.0114868544,
0.3451573849,
-1.4959675074,
0.0476607755,
0.2494209707,
-0.185235858,
-0.85772717,
-0.0470213741,
-0.4981084764,
0.1774774492,
-0.326702863,
0.1974820048,
-0.0947443247,
0.0453698933,
-0.4861084819,
-0.1916686893,
0.1191584095,
0.5583236217,
0.1861857176,
0.3126419485,
0.5338699818,
-0.3444246054,
0.3479989767,
-0.0555380285,
0.0940318406,
0.7653419971,
-0.6095457077,
0.2088566422,
0.1965000629,
0.2947526276,
-0.6161931157,
-0.4098621905,
0.3757780194,
-0.387177527,
0.1507824808,
0.2131131142,
-0.2398007661,
-0.5106170177,
-0.4778130054,
0.0805587769,
0.2904519141,
-0.4121901095,
0.919503212,
0.4035217166,
-0.1511040628,
-0.4818091393,
-0.6122100353,
0.1821395159,
-0.658141613,
-0.3407081962,
0.5115922689,
0.0237288643,
-0.2605875134,
0.3262985647,
0.0849562585,
-0.1229494438,
-0.0666802302,
0.5081387162,
0.2231450826,
-0.2433099449,
-0.2280645519,
0.2407388538,
-0.3475613892,
0.2593348026,
0.2088841796,
0.3701071441,
-0.1636921912,
-0.2856265008,
-0.4549057782,
0.8270863891,
0.4964502454,
0.0232807938,
0.8590093851,
0.6934333444,
-0.310469389,
0.0369313061,
-0.366132319,
0.0650853589,
-0.3800330162,
0.2713239789,
-0.4923867285,
-0.854475677,
0.1212117448,
0.1050094068,
-0.0689158887,
0.5357338786,
0.4580724835,
-0.1845581681,
1.2897211313,
0.7250460982,
-0.2345864773,
0.2292767167,
-0.3603761792,
0.4490993917,
-1.0998882055,
-0.2298563272,
-0.1827839315,
-0.515262723,
-0.5150651932,
-0.3884468675,
0.4225346446,
0.1710630804,
-0.1237068176,
0.2950547934,
-0.7184048295,
-0.0561877675,
0.6519705653,
0.3736690283,
0.0844846964,
-0.3662905693,
0.2057515085,
-0.2766644359,
-0.5511723161,
-0.5977060795,
1.0204541683,
0.5843721032,
-0.0311437529,
0.2630518973,
0.9744532108,
0.1543230563,
0.8656848669,
-1.1450949907,
0.7307059169,
-0.0426659249,
-0.5732672215,
-0.0058826222,
-0.2982238233,
-0.7395420671,
0.0105285756,
-0.2088623941,
-0.6813305616,
-0.1124227643,
-0.2255911082,
-0.2520620823,
0.2391306907,
-0.6269971728,
0.9158264399,
0.0521437898,
0.1953506172,
-0.1086947024,
-0.8020442128,
0.5313074589,
-0.1149724722,
0.2588154078,
-0.0197175555,
0.1339899153,
1.0486240387,
-0.4368619621,
0.7135616541,
-0.5618299842,
0.3893485069,
0.2868985534,
-0.3556504846,
-0.1022606194,
-0.104961738,
-0.3973857164,
0.0185988378,
0.1832817644,
-0.460617125,
-1.0515017509,
0.6931649446,
-0.690233171,
-0.3732318282,
-0.5765029192,
-0.4977580011,
-0.4007823467,
-0.259488076,
0.5364637375,
0.440875411,
-0.3344198167,
-0.1495002359,
0.3208890557,
0.0030683966,
0.3830071986,
0.4615213275,
-0.3701625466,
-0.3815177381,
0.9132141471,
-0.2245347053,
0.1655338407,
0.4167632163,
0.3087159991,
-0.2377640456,
-0.682059288,
0.0808986425,
0.2974247038,
-0.5226474404,
-0.2539717257,
-0.8176209331,
-0.46654284,
-0.4789643288,
-0.1522602737,
-0.0149793997,
-0.3014701605,
-0.210133791,
-0.1985741854,
0.2971908748,
0.8546991944,
0.0999837741,
0.4749411047,
-0.8484088778,
0.2122505605,
0.0933077261,
0.2423146963,
-0.3216154575,
-0.5611257553,
-0.0949678272,
-0.0818719417,
-0.3828565478,
-0.8439946771,
0.6019140482,
0.1270688921,
0.5450419784,
0.43341434,
-0.072507605,
0.4693816304,
-0.4184454978,
1.0882824659,
0.5330867171,
-0.9071512222,
0.7948852777,
-0.0216655303,
-0.0820489451,
0.5632294416,
0.6124637723,
-0.34722808,
-0.736379385,
-0.9631032944,
-0.6243200302,
0.6914874315,
-0.0526812449,
-0.1506354064,
0.0813441724,
0.4961668551,
-0.0996755958,
0.1705363542,
-0.8734049797,
-0.2702797353,
-0.2245119065,
-0.9039590359,
-0.1379637271,
-0.2721784711,
-0.3056696951,
-0.2413812578,
0.6654269099,
-0.2845973969,
0.7210552096,
0.1116696596,
-0.0007307575,
-0.1596148014,
0.4807477295,
0.2122834474,
0.3843795955,
-0.5283487439,
0.1046849489,
0.0773430616,
-0.3370089829,
0.1407351047,
-0.0078872573,
0.12885198,
0.1347978115,
0.5883800983,
1.0437804461,
0.189126119,
-0.2123644352,
0.8379715681,
-0.0715711191,
-0.4664673507,
-0.2868446112,
0.2097817957,
-0.067732051,
0.2602550089,
0.0943531543,
0.377494216,
0.6885393262,
-0.6178780794,
0.3285190761,
0.3744465709,
-1.0309647322,
-0.6271769404,
0.268096,
0.0821439847,
-0.5755938888,
0.1684133708,
-0.3137622476,
-0.76658988,
0.3290936649,
0.4279561341,
0.8957902789,
-0.3818072677,
0.4216692448,
0.3034985662,
-0.1272080839,
-0.0515925251,
0.3196557462,
0.3339665234,
-0.6668908,
-0.4236309528,
-0.800804019,
-0.5023300648,
0.093794331,
-1.2192429304,
0.1692226529,
-0.2285573483,
-0.1101550981,
0.2777039707,
-0.0000368465,
-0.3009000421,
0.5647208691,
0.1688817292,
0.5796194673,
-1.0300812721,
1.0392394066,
1.1132065058,
-0.3943703771,
-0.9918971062,
0.2076388896,
0.1521103531,
-0.558072269,
0.470054388,
0.2944647968,
0.1464094967,
-0.2066983581,
-0.5441550612,
-0.5267337561,
1.1051414013,
-0.2954800129,
-0.1179825068,
-0.1813971698,
0.1308881342,
0.8375740051,
-0.6218640804,
0.2017809749,
0.8671360612,
0.3987525105,
0.2333376557,
-0.8454812765,
-0.0511433072,
-0.4358095825,
-0.0376314558,
0.2220486999,
-0.2007219493,
0.466158241,
-0.0484014601,
0.1026499346,
0.1477273554,
0.7676674724,
0.1296860576,
0.614192009,
0.7154693604,
0.5435227156,
0.5295954347,
-0.0948951021,
1.1587026119,
-0.3358480334,
0.4146251082,
0.7050698996,
-0.0846931562,
1.0519882441,
0.7418074608,
-0.4824436605,
0.5808845758,
0.4363541901,
0.1444896311,
0.7846910954,
-0.0656630993,
-0.4950184822,
0.2600007057,
-0.1569046378,
-0.0300616957,
0.3896726966,
0.2836146057,
-0.2952319086,
0.1539819092,
0.4832841456,
-0.0341833942,
0.009222094,
-0.4113823473,
1.1617325544,
0.3669092059,
-0.9141316414,
-0.0024156244,
0.0710636973,
1.0310117006,
-0.2938249707,
0.1370576769,
-0.123010233,
0.1635175198,
-0.383475095,
-0.984352231,
1.0524272919,
-0.0054162559,
-0.5836809278,
-0.0881557465,
0.5309650302,
-0.4394049644,
-0.6826628447,
0.2079141438,
0.3304641247,
0.0704279989,
-0.0891817585,
-1.1106128693,
-0.1701774597,
0.263083607,
-0.3323449492,
0.5629171133,
0.4872011244,
0.1985293478,
0.3318510056,
0.1755727082,
-0.0183009151,
-0.2502342165,
0.2486357838,
0.5663069487,
-0.8867422342,
-0.3350711465,
-0.7697507739,
0.4498238266,
-0.253550142,
-0.2564515471,
0.5639806986,
0.3822190166,
-0.2383052409,
0.1982711256,
0.7143841982,
-0.032241188,
1.0848671198,
-0.4392160177,
0.2628206909,
-0.5539352894,
0.1162417606,
-0.4022608697,
-0.8272083402,
-0.4548069239,
0.4760058224,
-0.4493905902,
-0.0973535627,
1.0700587034,
0.5629442334,
0.1194984987,
0.5587574244,
0.0127524445,
0.1314595491,
0.3296767771,
0.7718935609,
0.7738254666,
-0.5471891761,
0.2223007679,
-0.5285669565,
-0.3854426146,
0.0506451614,
-0.6592786908,
-0.7000453472,
-0.470274955,
-0.4928802848,
-0.6490300298,
-0.1267261356,
1.0059132576,
0.3161959648,
-1.0404644012,
-0.0215886422,
-0.3146842122,
-0.1138842404,
-0.2487649322,
-0.3553783894,
0.3666566014,
-0.3925970495,
-0.6358981729,
0.1136899218,
0.5062473416,
-0.246640265,
-0.3549229503,
-0.0277965162,
-0.1837644577,
0.0371909365,
0.5387758613,
-0.2782113254,
-0.8456881046,
-0.2439849675,
0.0793554559,
-0.3431700468,
0.3023809195,
0.7837517262,
-0.53916049,
-0.0194154251,
0.132112667,
0.2840980887,
0.2216189653,
0.1142077446,
0.6796159148,
-0.5076434612,
0.0665600672,
0.587040484,
0.2931312323,
0.4578428566,
-0.288772583,
0.4915324748,
0.1015813053,
-0.6975755692,
-0.7504663467,
0.0240938794,
-1.3890711069,
-0.3081070185,
1.169017911,
-0.4179082513,
-0.53576684,
-0.3684294224,
-0.3395751119,
0.2224967033,
-0.0468153022,
0.5361032486,
0.4845435023,
-0.5056792498,
-0.2836926281,
-0.4508320093,
0.6013832092,
0.3801012337,
-0.8723108768,
-0.6810833216,
0.0319338329,
0.2103530765,
0.385620743,
0.8674200773,
-0.0962272137,
-0.1354507953,
-0.3151037693,
0.199089393,
0.4265363216,
0.0052957572,
-0.4418116808,
0.4822285175,
0.0016473369,
-0.2360604852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03736v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03736v1
|
De-identification of clinical free text using natural language processing: A systematic review of current approaches
| 2023-11-28T13:20:41 | 2023-11-28T13:20:41 |
Aleksandar Kovačević, Bojana Bašaragin, Nikola Milošević, Goran Nenadić
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.DL, cs.LG
|
Background: Electronic health records (EHRs) are a valuable resource for
data-driven medical research. However, the presence of protected health
information (PHI) makes EHRs unsuitable to be shared for research purposes.
De-identification, i.e. the process of removing PHI is a critical step in
making EHR data accessible. Natural language processing has repeatedly
demonstrated its feasibility in automating the de-identification process.
Objectives: Our study aims to provide systematic evidence on how the
de-identification of clinical free text has evolved in the last thirteen years,
and to report on the performances and limitations of the current
state-of-the-art systems. In addition, we aim to identify challenges and
potential research opportunities in this field. Methods: A systematic search in
PubMed, Web of Science and the DBLP was conducted for studies published between
January 2010 and February 2023. Titles and abstracts were examined to identify
the relevant studies. Selected studies were then analysed in-depth, and
information was collected on de-identification methodologies, data sources, and
measured performance. Results: A total of 2125 publications were identified for
the title and abstract screening. 69 studies were found to be relevant. Machine
learning (37 studies) and hybrid (26 studies) approaches are predominant, while
six studies relied only on rules. Majority of the approaches were trained and
evaluated on public corpora. The 2014 i2b2/UTHealth corpus is the most
frequently used (36 studies), followed by the 2006 i2b2 (18 studies) and 2016
CEGS N-GRID (10 studies) corpora.
|
[
-0.219538942,
-1.015141964,
0.7125221491,
-0.1054516137,
-0.5170378089,
0.0180921499,
-0.0542953536,
-0.9337794781,
0.134633109,
0.6533490419,
-0.1464592367,
-0.7417178154,
-0.7467285991,
0.6275370121,
-0.4598994553,
0.8801891208,
-0.1042649299,
0.0850256979,
-0.0309104864,
-0.1937931031,
-0.377961427,
-0.6320197582,
-0.2886441946,
-0.2243103683,
0.5283690691,
0.3052350283,
0.5314127803,
1.001947403,
0.9386618733,
0.2677817047,
-0.2725100517,
0.0333126113,
-0.2120810896,
0.0976478457,
-0.0789056495,
-0.0408972278,
-0.4974893928,
-0.235234037,
0.6133184433,
0.6972934008,
-0.2132840455,
0.0901403502,
0.1266495734,
0.9115715027,
-0.8932973146,
0.0031675121,
-0.5437063575,
-0.0282834973,
-0.5091387033,
-0.2851450145,
-0.4602291584,
-0.5822534561,
0.5230526924,
-0.7241504192,
0.4190805256,
-0.2056790888,
0.8949976563,
-0.1177142113,
-0.6038825512,
-0.8476606607,
-1.0248525143,
0.6839005351,
-0.5469341278,
0.4324820638,
0.6760112643,
0.2299042344,
-0.0426422954,
-0.639908433,
-0.2568066716,
0.0229557678,
-0.4865695238,
-0.0103397649,
-0.496822834,
0.267408818,
0.2338816077,
0.589050889,
-0.7956495285,
0.2433866411,
-0.7434356213,
-0.3238225877,
0.6537386775,
0.2359805256,
0.4375158846,
-0.2530317008,
-0.3883565962,
0.3360502124,
-0.4862809479,
-0.1812039018,
-0.140632093,
0.2693165243,
-0.097088851,
0.6370218992,
-0.3916066885,
0.2969703972,
-0.0012901967,
-0.1766033322,
0.474039495,
-0.1759468913,
-0.5354171395,
0.4067813158,
1.0214259624,
0.3009927869,
0.0026224507,
-0.3303790092,
0.0015132137,
-0.0249216985,
0.2201579064,
-0.6285274029,
-0.0644005686,
0.279425174,
-0.7532649636,
-0.2050677389,
0.0824498609,
-1.0050930977,
-0.5602259636,
-0.4009807408,
0.1811678857,
-0.5780328512,
-0.3457504809,
0.1765011698,
-0.1969436407,
0.3014264703,
0.1524448693,
-0.7969815731,
0.7795627117,
0.5663608313,
0.7677680254,
-0.3479211926,
0.3059222698,
-0.1480309814,
0.1899596453,
-0.327894032,
0.6268306375,
-0.4438981414,
-0.5696184635,
0.2657057941,
0.2934942544,
-0.4940280318,
-0.8444924951,
0.8044959903,
-0.5440526009,
0.4670188427,
-0.2451804876,
-0.5583210588,
0.010566758,
0.1748646796,
-0.9896380305,
0.9077929854,
-0.0249866303,
-0.9008880854,
0.3163853586,
-0.3412695825,
-0.3818759918,
0.3560037315,
-0.0960525572,
-0.5379608274,
0.0259477794,
0.1469923407,
0.1971928775,
-0.5333439112,
0.4024369717,
-0.0906065553,
-0.1969488114,
0.0652873442,
-0.2765797973,
0.7964698076,
0.4807657599,
-0.2671007514,
0.1002885923,
-1.163166523,
-0.1669061184,
0.0718094707,
-0.0165586118,
-0.8032805324,
-0.136439845,
0.1318485886,
0.1317721754,
-0.025673205,
-0.6939355135,
-0.0585885234,
-0.6821810603,
0.1551995426,
0.1910364181,
0.4350038767,
0.3399802744,
-0.5319660306,
0.5393807292,
-0.0144723319,
0.2697898149,
0.0953272134,
-0.687659502,
-0.1818415523,
-0.6025301814,
0.3388093412,
0.7642287612,
-0.2483479679,
0.5342466235,
-0.3204464912,
-0.6259701848,
-0.6720012426,
-0.1570791602,
0.4907235801,
0.7154467702,
0.843777895,
-0.2795610428,
-0.4857826829,
-1.1315176487,
-0.2085634619,
0.0335925668,
-0.3083263636,
0.2129844427,
0.3619123697,
-0.4839671552,
0.799282968,
-0.4830367267,
-0.642704308,
-0.2815531194,
0.1005663127,
-0.1301291138,
0.3415451348,
0.3027127981,
-0.6458149552,
-0.3281489611,
-0.0153245591,
-0.7815754414,
-0.1959694922,
0.1325544119,
0.0521331504,
0.2274186909,
0.2086147666,
-0.4494799078,
0.7302308083,
0.2248408198,
-0.1418358982,
0.1940881312,
-0.5471124649,
0.3254330754,
-0.6572363377,
0.5100993514,
0.1371297687,
0.1706552655,
-0.7627390623,
-0.1893831342,
0.2397128493,
-0.0517309755,
-0.2813335657,
0.5408369899,
-0.5459063053,
0.4969847202,
-0.1268229634,
0.0326220542,
-0.0462045446,
0.0500864796,
0.1580731124,
0.1827018261,
0.2561053634,
-0.7576481104,
-0.0936340913,
0.5340113044,
-0.4467044771,
0.3479533195,
-0.7008898258,
-0.0132716559,
-0.4808923304,
0.0802627057,
-0.9531242847,
-0.1451667845,
0.5248149037,
-0.1556598246,
0.1174447387,
-0.111193046,
-0.2082125694,
-0.2649617791,
-0.2157583684,
0.3101628125,
0.3323776722,
-0.0233796183,
0.3309640586,
0.5660655499,
-0.4813773632,
-0.3757142425,
-0.594448626,
-0.0100706182,
-0.2990252376,
-0.1848836541,
0.7958440781,
0.1226383969,
-0.5003115535,
0.0779927298,
-0.0718440935,
-0.6336759329,
0.139653936,
0.2007628679,
0.3379081488,
0.0474262685,
0.2571059465,
0.213139534,
-0.0907847956,
0.0966397524,
0.3982794881,
0.1625108272,
0.2052473873,
-0.2912404835,
-0.9607775807,
0.6368393898,
0.6884243488,
-0.3353902698,
0.6605272293,
0.3868971765,
-0.7260893583,
0.209623605,
-0.532060504,
0.0043390426,
-0.3599439263,
-0.0335078202,
0.0402339362,
-0.594260931,
0.3244744837,
0.1171291992,
-0.0049174316,
0.680906713,
0.4604780674,
0.0032481768,
0.70730865,
0.3745564222,
0.1202927977,
0.1919735521,
-0.0220574979,
0.2581493258,
-0.6680263281,
-0.505212307,
-0.8445792794,
-0.189075619,
-0.7773756981,
-0.1788894385,
0.2381010056,
-0.0213699732,
0.0633079782,
0.1778196394,
-0.7081853151,
0.105306834,
0.3506128788,
0.3855910599,
0.6181005836,
-0.1959496588,
-0.2057096511,
-0.1649999171,
-0.0577553101,
-0.8155863285,
1.2629181147,
0.3734831214,
0.2895749509,
0.1751999855,
0.7778371572,
0.566291213,
0.5157459378,
-0.5839081407,
0.4351005852,
0.0219965503,
-0.8276205063,
-0.1831116229,
-0.3049990237,
-1.4313931465,
0.223654449,
-0.3620980084,
-0.8143288493,
0.1810342371,
0.0371636227,
-0.4209360182,
0.1596976668,
-0.4481059611,
0.6633229852,
-0.2340422869,
-0.2833066285,
-0.1212808564,
-0.7375502586,
0.226546973,
-0.0733749047,
0.4905128181,
-0.1264604479,
0.0513484143,
0.8731154799,
-0.4396500885,
0.6442921758,
-0.1593884826,
-0.1517572999,
0.453327328,
-0.0891705528,
0.2982996106,
0.0458754376,
-0.1314291805,
0.2844424844,
0.5907156467,
-0.1592386812,
-0.189767167,
0.4469113648,
-0.4953935742,
-0.3641842604,
-0.7023214698,
0.019754583,
-0.1728321612,
0.542871058,
0.3625317812,
0.6627935171,
-0.5050870776,
0.3124144971,
0.5361210108,
-0.452111572,
0.2882514596,
0.6031044126,
0.1346603632,
-0.7720947266,
0.5415388346,
0.2017340213,
-0.0272049196,
0.6905519962,
0.4910672605,
-0.3581934571,
-0.8860423565,
-0.3525225222,
0.3075048923,
-0.3237758279,
0.1248996258,
-0.7956530452,
-0.2437138259,
-0.5593451262,
0.108278662,
0.026026262,
-0.3195379078,
-0.4564402699,
-0.2847693264,
0.2252866477,
0.7243599296,
0.2191066891,
0.0213329419,
-1.0706787109,
0.5178472996,
-0.1035774201,
0.5023157001,
-0.1293540597,
-0.1973387599,
-0.0298209861,
0.0014642976,
-0.2729008496,
-1.2996609211,
0.6813780665,
0.110785313,
0.7837899923,
0.4994319975,
0.4461598992,
0.642356813,
-0.3612959385,
0.6185610294,
0.004694717,
-0.591820538,
0.4906385243,
-0.4547620416,
0.182959035,
0.9611462951,
0.7595670223,
-0.4981913567,
-0.1796791106,
-0.6540774107,
-1.0364757776,
0.4035287201,
0.1924520135,
-0.3759150803,
-0.3128219843,
0.2053317875,
0.3246198893,
0.1769149452,
-0.1998839378,
-0.4075754285,
0.3888106644,
-0.4870213866,
0.1818495691,
-0.404081136,
-0.1490895748,
-0.1382588893,
0.5371015668,
0.0587725155,
0.2717161179,
0.8040226698,
-0.3567780554,
-0.1259961277,
0.7994536757,
0.4974724948,
0.5704748034,
-0.2749219537,
0.0910059735,
-0.1129501089,
-0.8948737383,
-0.0534729585,
0.2660937011,
-0.424156934,
0.2194034308,
0.1848372817,
0.483306706,
0.3560627103,
-0.7252656817,
0.4320041537,
-0.0682228878,
-0.6249411106,
-0.3474119902,
-0.3056992888,
-0.4251180589,
-0.1998801231,
0.2502742112,
-0.163240239,
0.3580786288,
-0.1292290837,
0.1406200081,
0.3375149667,
-0.7804784775,
-0.4232414067,
0.5726537108,
0.1040052101,
-0.210804224,
0.6910851002,
0.0952007771,
0.1122547537,
0.398830086,
0.5441824198,
1.0176758766,
-0.1121556461,
0.1536829919,
0.614146173,
0.2058815956,
0.00041078,
0.2941941619,
-0.0049845544,
-0.4403716624,
-0.1695552468,
-0.3917992115,
-0.4582795501,
0.4913586676,
-0.9601821303,
0.1809587926,
-0.4261410236,
-0.3240389526,
0.088289097,
-0.0490777567,
-0.8172840476,
0.2115059942,
0.370105803,
0.7562950253,
-0.8189194798,
0.6871509552,
0.5807820559,
-0.2364968807,
-0.3790844679,
-0.2509768605,
0.6654675603,
-0.180275768,
0.1755422503,
0.2084104568,
0.109635599,
-0.1816282272,
-0.0075385817,
-0.8036599755,
1.1562607288,
0.0223647151,
-0.61499089,
-0.3362237811,
0.29747352,
0.7222909331,
0.1368463039,
0.329056859,
0.5755860209,
0.320366919,
-0.1076200828,
-1.3465300798,
0.0958970264,
-0.3598344624,
-0.2533626556,
0.4610123932,
-0.2262782902,
0.2486924678,
-0.0993477926,
-0.6324398518,
0.2622411549,
0.1790416688,
0.1859735101,
0.8315994143,
0.2436992377,
0.6716815829,
1.0990517139,
0.0607309081,
0.5772231221,
-0.2352354079,
0.1493983716,
0.7992851138,
-0.6219190359,
0.748683691,
0.4210288525,
-0.0873135701,
0.7185568213,
0.3018552661,
0.1622253805,
0.5754607916,
0.0332012288,
-0.3827826083,
0.1777249873,
-0.1532451808,
-0.4287722409,
0.2748279572,
0.4948430657,
-0.8384083509,
-0.1022543088,
0.0909825116,
-0.0259730779,
0.1643342972,
-0.0842654333,
1.1984202862,
-0.0971690938,
-0.6264660954,
0.4918054044,
-0.0575743951,
0.3988955319,
-0.7631879449,
-0.0416976772,
0.0494887345,
0.2753069103,
-0.398915112,
-0.3725864291,
0.5932538509,
0.2149076909,
-0.0971186832,
-0.4072736204,
0.9123008847,
-0.209937185,
-0.3020231724,
0.2264390588,
0.6710532904,
0.0451628454,
0.1839775741,
-0.3375249803,
-0.1669473797,
-0.2274318933,
-0.1759542823,
0.4278166592,
0.4665130377,
-0.2835389674,
0.4198280275,
0.622136116,
0.3875824213,
-0.1458514184,
0.0155038368,
0.4879354239,
-0.8730391264,
-0.4321243167,
-0.8517020941,
0.2291021645,
-0.0327768885,
-0.5466824174,
0.7215254903,
0.7938563228,
0.754812777,
-0.0717105195,
0.820677042,
-0.049570255,
0.9878961444,
-0.2901557684,
0.7283346653,
-0.1939062625,
0.1476665288,
-0.6807002425,
-0.243943274,
-0.6971926093,
0.2177914977,
-0.4753108323,
-0.5228864551,
0.7897599936,
0.5829680562,
0.1533686966,
0.3201346099,
0.0985873789,
-0.1311415434,
0.429995954,
0.171718061,
0.5039299726,
-0.4952517748,
0.4069497287,
-0.5972506404,
-0.2033018023,
-0.2280224413,
-0.7311310768,
-0.3612595797,
-0.4718977511,
-0.5638453364,
-0.2035520524,
0.0966352224,
1.0586315393,
0.2899898887,
-0.8717547059,
0.1526743919,
-0.0480198078,
0.0209465958,
-0.6370682716,
-0.1793383509,
0.5393524766,
0.1709916592,
-0.3707408607,
0.3597375453,
0.1829111129,
-0.025013078,
0.380731672,
0.121269092,
-0.1982131004,
-0.2211696208,
0.5169280767,
0.6149401665,
-0.6058255434,
0.0686808601,
0.2454960793,
-0.4258026779,
0.0828664228,
1.0012114048,
-0.7659428716,
0.6420827508,
0.6547384262,
0.5977909565,
0.0756903887,
0.288335979,
0.3014617562,
-0.153557092,
-0.1504454017,
0.4991137683,
0.2430003583,
0.21464926,
-0.2416356504,
0.286249727,
0.4265888333,
-0.5782467723,
-0.7456043959,
-0.1673145294,
-0.9915357232,
-0.0928499177,
1.2110546827,
0.3205139935,
-0.1886139363,
-0.8148967624,
-0.3020876348,
0.3143461049,
-0.2461158931,
0.8502283096,
0.3736998737,
-0.2531698942,
0.0033993935,
-0.5697565675,
0.5409147143,
-0.0931232795,
-0.8990002275,
0.2700868845,
0.6351364851,
0.2682090402,
0.048208788,
1.0516558886,
-0.7872703671,
0.1274311543,
-0.6154962182,
0.0039165583,
0.2193936855,
-0.2002200782,
-0.5536805987,
0.3448744416,
-0.0102418065,
-0.1858073175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16764v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16764v1
|
Radiology-Aware Model-Based Evaluation Metric for Report Generation
| 2023-11-28T13:08:26 | 2023-11-28T13:08:26 |
Amos Calamida, Farhad Nooralahzadeh, Morteza Rohanian, Koji Fujimoto, Mizuho Nishio, Michael Krauthammer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We propose a new automated evaluation metric for machine-generated radiology
reports using the successful COMET architecture adapted for the radiology
domain. We train and publish four medically-oriented model checkpoints,
including one trained on RadGraph, a radiology knowledge graph. Our results
show that our metric correlates moderately to high with established metrics
such as BERTscore, BLEU, and CheXbert scores. Furthermore, we demonstrate that
one of our checkpoints exhibits a high correlation with human judgment, as
assessed using the publicly available annotations of six board-certified
radiologists, using a set of 200 reports. We also performed our own analysis
gathering annotations with two radiologists on a collection of 100 reports. The
results indicate the potential effectiveness of our method as a
radiology-specific evaluation metric. The code, data, and model checkpoints to
reproduce our findings will be publicly available.
|
[
-0.2180543095,
-0.2153626978,
0.7800673246,
0.1100884825,
0.0277787596,
-0.0334535241,
0.2378676385,
-0.9256631136,
0.2474669665,
0.3667222261,
-0.3066776097,
-0.5357728004,
-0.6710796952,
-0.138769716,
-0.2932637334,
0.9253733158,
0.1352157146,
0.6266828179,
-0.5109293461,
-0.0362922996,
-0.7717381716,
-0.0616520047,
-0.1435731053,
-0.4195076227,
0.5179548264,
0.3865199685,
0.9891528487,
0.7397149801,
0.9708560705,
0.102358222,
0.2365049571,
0.0868537724,
0.0349246562,
0.0424427092,
-0.3832855523,
0.0872161686,
-0.8203008175,
-0.0206937939,
0.533462584,
1.0729842186,
0.0929296836,
0.3744228184,
-0.3765481412,
0.7469029427,
-0.9512598515,
0.1072122306,
-0.3399307132,
0.0702168569,
-0.0017595986,
-0.3975307941,
-0.6324114203,
-0.4446863532,
0.1128985137,
-0.6752526164,
0.076566115,
0.0965460017,
0.982737124,
0.0120456424,
-0.4181720316,
-0.4052194655,
-0.6449974775,
0.5369347334,
-0.3577092588,
0.2837477326,
0.352409333,
0.8565530181,
0.2334720045,
-1.0688655376,
0.1383731663,
-0.1703238338,
-0.0800277889,
0.4832171798,
-0.4129049778,
-0.055411268,
0.1452051848,
0.1596339643,
-0.5557491779,
0.2439589947,
-0.176374048,
-0.5781490803,
0.6864259243,
0.5995889902,
0.2736413479,
-0.4356102347,
-0.5130789876,
0.0039199437,
-0.4270479083,
-0.4185907543,
-0.0742932931,
0.1840474904,
0.1943964511,
0.3566869199,
-0.6018148661,
0.7192651033,
-0.1325709224,
-0.0115787117,
0.5801886916,
-0.2902830243,
-0.0780561939,
-0.0311956219,
0.6585707068,
0.6593675613,
-0.1744213402,
-0.1011606902,
-0.4586505294,
0.2156531513,
0.4042587578,
-0.8702095151,
-0.3790502548,
0.1994650066,
-0.7770465612,
-0.5345749855,
0.1617693454,
-0.505892396,
-0.5786184669,
-0.1862629652,
0.7794933319,
-0.7240362763,
-0.302293241,
0.1911641806,
-0.1727118194,
0.0343091637,
0.7541307807,
-0.2807153761,
0.2776931226,
0.4851899147,
0.6810376048,
0.3977703452,
-0.0755252838,
-0.7945450544,
0.1114976332,
-0.3695191741,
1.1848472357,
-0.5403723121,
-0.4032438695,
-0.103957355,
-0.34994784,
-0.1955731064,
-0.6875024438,
0.3516052961,
-0.6463957429,
0.2198238671,
-0.2731556296,
-0.7291187644,
-0.3853248656,
0.2881592512,
-0.4354583025,
0.514796555,
0.392993629,
-1.0025178194,
0.8882641196,
-0.6761084795,
-0.392059952,
0.5059616566,
-0.1589104086,
-0.3994924128,
-0.0353754759,
0.234892264,
0.4338232577,
-0.6464177966,
0.3044473231,
-0.0326461345,
-0.1250900626,
0.0989736468,
0.2626497149,
0.6434286237,
0.6245243549,
-0.0005980688,
0.4658177197,
-0.6137290597,
0.4774108529,
-0.0656973198,
-0.0106866537,
-0.0374664478,
-0.083945252,
0.034991838,
0.0864035264,
0.2711150646,
-0.6219896674,
-0.2232252508,
0.1688954681,
-0.0666996837,
0.338337034,
0.39784953,
0.0129666133,
-0.9534142017,
0.6476032734,
0.0758969411,
0.3341934085,
-0.4646887183,
-0.5285178423,
-0.577881515,
-0.6869437099,
0.5253391862,
0.4117282033,
-0.0901371911,
0.5617562532,
-0.4688913822,
-0.8977296352,
-0.356245786,
-0.4146072865,
0.5264074206,
0.7157812119,
0.182793051,
-0.9683042169,
-0.4571496844,
-0.9646652341,
-0.1101431698,
-0.1194070801,
0.0225187037,
0.4055928886,
0.5326815844,
-0.2780061662,
0.9410332441,
-0.5146775246,
-0.4943090379,
-0.2167019695,
0.4566307962,
-0.0944740474,
0.3911603689,
0.4788252115,
-0.2766775787,
-0.2561198771,
0.0373544656,
-1.0923429728,
-0.0392686501,
-0.1479223073,
-0.0945197716,
0.0723039061,
0.4632234871,
-0.0177201778,
0.54282552,
0.2079339772,
-0.462533623,
0.575653553,
-0.3441767395,
0.4943338931,
-0.7701107264,
0.5263549089,
-0.1366129071,
-0.5438590646,
-0.3108125329,
0.0300305411,
0.2758886814,
-0.2736490965,
-0.3256166577,
0.4134961963,
-0.5894747972,
-0.5559024811,
-0.0792761892,
0.1101769805,
-0.0167727116,
-0.1338422447,
0.2822161019,
0.0227460917,
0.7960991859,
-0.5924800634,
-0.0539650135,
0.2661012411,
-0.842056632,
0.5092778206,
-0.4255151153,
0.4038699865,
-0.0894558653,
0.2857350111,
-0.6986021996,
-0.4535856247,
-0.1038314626,
-0.7289597988,
0.2683139145,
-0.2671958804,
-0.5000745058,
-0.3239012957,
-0.0312235896,
0.1763895303,
0.5795889497,
-0.1925762296,
0.4641970396,
0.4555116296,
0.1381854117,
-0.3204921484,
-0.4650217891,
0.1672824472,
0.1520065963,
-0.9795845747,
-0.0608289503,
-0.1410402805,
-0.3464253247,
0.0184856057,
0.2286329567,
-0.2862852216,
0.1404715627,
0.4966204464,
0.2934336364,
-0.1657829136,
-0.1084630489,
-0.2358221263,
-0.3014441431,
0.223047182,
-0.0579056479,
0.4685295522,
-0.2768923044,
-0.5150929093,
-0.67847085,
0.1073514819,
0.4197536409,
-0.1634937823,
0.3765692413,
0.4443480074,
-0.6139398217,
0.1597859114,
-0.5172759891,
-0.2244161069,
-0.3072104454,
0.4446938634,
-0.3076427579,
-0.4128214121,
0.7167384624,
-0.140763849,
0.0108543253,
0.6347276568,
0.6761084795,
0.0461482331,
1.1700391769,
0.3539115191,
0.2407284081,
0.1165418997,
-0.1684757769,
-0.2602614462,
-0.700912416,
-0.3698450625,
-0.5521896482,
-0.0668547675,
-0.1246702,
-0.336766392,
0.5071778297,
-0.1032807082,
-0.2112418264,
0.0284187086,
-0.643427968,
0.2656827867,
0.2158950418,
0.189825207,
0.4830456376,
-0.3369809687,
-0.0909337923,
-0.1247513965,
-1.0065640211,
-0.4398017824,
1.2272777557,
0.4109078348,
0.3937363327,
-0.167483598,
0.8809822798,
0.4806677401,
0.6461652517,
-0.8694763184,
0.5314416885,
0.0407127477,
-1.0263863802,
0.0286070369,
-0.4846691787,
-0.8914736509,
-0.0424317867,
-0.2708743811,
-0.4818705618,
-0.1881844252,
0.0415782593,
-0.429718852,
0.0179448482,
-0.567671895,
0.7655581236,
-0.1908258796,
-0.0371028632,
-0.6518886089,
-0.6609731913,
0.3092576265,
-0.1615036577,
0.6110526919,
-0.3519887626,
0.0778489858,
0.9239662886,
-0.4965010285,
0.6951224804,
-0.459487617,
0.5140477419,
0.3971395791,
0.6233488917,
0.1053046435,
0.0794042647,
0.0129867299,
0.2044129074,
0.0590157546,
-0.2070304006,
-0.2654309571,
0.413023293,
-0.7671371698,
-0.0524292439,
-0.6799447536,
-0.842045784,
-0.2858983278,
0.556589663,
0.4057102799,
0.7464948297,
-0.3197699487,
-0.1548385769,
0.1470786333,
-0.2593660653,
-0.0181655008,
0.910600543,
-0.4169971645,
-0.5485588908,
0.8550404906,
0.1250451654,
0.3350465894,
0.4107016027,
0.3436972797,
0.2548329234,
-0.7899007201,
-0.4035854638,
0.1270305812,
-0.9435683489,
-0.6616848707,
-0.5239211321,
-0.3676792383,
-0.3262558281,
-0.2300692201,
-0.6448246837,
-0.5043048859,
0.0999907553,
0.3007805943,
0.2931983769,
1.0614563227,
-0.3411251307,
-0.0592153147,
-0.9041767716,
-0.1900511682,
-0.1838127077,
0.1944653541,
-0.0989578366,
-0.7134851813,
-0.6729828119,
-0.1739370227,
-0.1827590466,
-0.4273177981,
0.4611513019,
-0.101143688,
0.4638999999,
0.2860920429,
0.1571374387,
0.5191224217,
-0.1862835884,
0.4995010495,
0.5545265079,
-0.9104338288,
0.8021313548,
-0.7503951192,
0.3639715612,
0.6434994936,
0.178503722,
-0.3250623047,
-0.6420254111,
-0.8017033935,
-0.7016390562,
0.5666336417,
-0.0904363692,
-0.1959462315,
-0.3444948494,
0.1695846617,
0.1686067879,
-0.262008369,
-0.1130048856,
0.1001533046,
-0.1723950505,
0.0983312279,
0.5054340363,
-0.1209482104,
-0.4344005883,
-0.1521568745,
0.4369163215,
-0.1993912905,
0.3839655817,
0.3908270299,
-0.4048336148,
-0.3022604287,
-0.1115040779,
0.4045133293,
1.2885040045,
-0.5743643045,
-0.0717871934,
-0.10250929,
-0.4636289775,
-0.4149624705,
-0.1505015641,
-0.0167471487,
-0.0057721869,
0.6655753255,
0.2559719086,
0.22147879,
-0.5557857156,
0.7106562257,
-0.1113231853,
-0.5151613355,
-0.4719848633,
0.060318239,
-0.0643349364,
0.0784359798,
0.215747118,
0.4661903977,
0.3509692848,
-0.3414530456,
0.604924202,
0.3089104593,
-0.8356440067,
-0.2655074298,
0.7913162708,
0.2949365079,
0.0997319594,
0.806104362,
-0.2464134246,
-0.1068230271,
0.5909734368,
0.2890861332,
0.8512157798,
0.0695460364,
0.3148023188,
0.8516529202,
0.1176469326,
0.0454342961,
0.1391493678,
0.3353953063,
-0.796330452,
-0.3609130681,
-0.3063191473,
-0.5884070396,
-0.29153198,
-1.2081865072,
0.6098824739,
-0.9975990057,
-0.3131436706,
0.247355938,
0.0105129154,
-0.6273024082,
0.5085662007,
0.223363027,
1.1230198145,
-0.5422306657,
0.6578245163,
0.7293091416,
-0.7226189375,
-0.6914672852,
-0.1865083873,
0.1280230284,
-1.1264344454,
0.8338765502,
0.3715556264,
-0.165919587,
-0.1995366216,
-0.1119572222,
-0.6900669932,
1.4910148382,
0.1820314527,
-0.3318704963,
0.2390619367,
-0.4339371622,
0.3688093722,
-0.7538018823,
0.7030351162,
0.2811512649,
0.3650225103,
0.1543155164,
-1.1484109163,
0.1700715274,
-0.214366436,
-0.3086141944,
0.0806339756,
-0.5785643458,
0.3472983837,
-0.729721427,
-0.2801836729,
0.3488279581,
0.590284586,
0.1387719065,
0.6659910679,
0.5592154264,
0.625020802,
0.8384830356,
0.0991974249,
1.3411458731,
-0.5581129193,
0.3628519773,
1.0547345877,
-0.2980796695,
0.5994116068,
-0.1121503562,
0.1474622637,
0.7341297865,
0.5122674704,
-0.158330217,
0.4061667323,
0.0501551181,
-0.0186302979,
-0.6133548617,
-0.3414871097,
-0.4237752855,
0.617349267,
0.1536110193,
-0.6043475866,
-0.2670977116,
-0.2625058889,
0.2336300164,
-0.0066813133,
-0.3535560966,
0.8097445369,
-0.1455894858,
-0.4785741568,
0.4279807508,
-0.0943729654,
0.1602774411,
-0.7422856688,
0.3562062681,
-0.0930493027,
0.3279672861,
-0.594547689,
-0.6442632675,
0.546256125,
0.0214142278,
-0.2606787384,
-0.2015935183,
0.5764607787,
0.3560761809,
-0.4549276829,
0.2397996932,
0.6164168119,
0.3256438673,
0.0423258953,
-0.4517534971,
-0.0479806475,
-0.0628365874,
-0.1470242441,
0.6394010782,
0.1735242456,
-0.1168407649,
0.7410822511,
0.2432263941,
-0.0132833188,
-0.4437319934,
0.5632627606,
0.8973402381,
-0.6885750294,
-0.4471684694,
-0.1282282472,
0.6700900793,
0.035170678,
-0.3872729838,
0.5913452506,
0.9587736726,
0.477763772,
0.1518882364,
0.7801539898,
-0.2661082745,
0.8658214211,
-0.5067102909,
1.0097485781,
-0.3869125247,
0.3377885818,
-0.368427515,
-0.6728780866,
-0.5387616754,
0.5120713711,
-0.3324979842,
0.1996656805,
0.9168408513,
0.6797350645,
0.2031230778,
0.0114687979,
0.3834933043,
-0.0393395871,
0.2938404977,
0.5088842511,
0.94448632,
-0.3642937839,
0.5216356516,
-0.2607212067,
-0.5827147961,
-0.1903691292,
-0.8857842684,
-0.5729435086,
-0.4834891856,
-0.8207365274,
-0.5678793192,
0.0229782145,
0.2882192433,
0.9754661918,
-0.408942759,
-0.2372104377,
0.1221846119,
-0.29254058,
-0.1320179254,
-0.2415169626,
0.4056006968,
-0.548196733,
-0.1993647069,
0.2358762324,
0.2917339504,
-0.4386094809,
-0.024117751,
-0.1174555048,
0.192618072,
-0.153138876,
0.2364094406,
0.0051410832,
-0.1542521864,
-0.6302591562,
-0.0810700879,
-0.2548452318,
0.1750042737,
0.9017272592,
-0.9751016498,
0.9063693285,
0.4474096894,
0.1574224979,
0.5122143626,
-0.2526122332,
0.547391355,
-0.2828139961,
0.0007655315,
0.5739058852,
0.4231868088,
0.4594414234,
-0.1593524814,
0.456477344,
0.3304950893,
-0.7300313711,
-0.8191344142,
0.2236997932,
-1.0501815081,
-0.2247011065,
0.9544603229,
-0.1511841267,
0.0642370954,
-0.0730950162,
0.2913384438,
0.0201869998,
-0.2787437141,
0.6328500509,
0.2079172432,
-0.6108822227,
0.1887399554,
-0.5430580378,
0.2639650106,
0.362170577,
-0.9310979247,
0.011920277,
0.8668178916,
0.787555635,
0.2862641215,
0.8464840055,
-0.6796877384,
0.9224141836,
0.3526063859,
0.438084811,
-0.3566196859,
-0.4050343931,
-0.052057635,
-0.0416352637,
0.4336257875,
-0.0676960871
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03735v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03735v1
|
Advancing State of the Art in Language Modeling
| 2023-11-28T12:30:43 | 2023-11-28T12:30:43 |
David Herel, Tomas Mikolov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Generalization is arguably the most important goal of statistical language
modeling research. Publicly available benchmarks and papers published with an
open-source code have been critical to advancing the field. However, it is
often very difficult, and sometimes even impossible, to reproduce the results
fully as reported in publications. In this paper, we propose a simple framework
that should help advance the state of the art in language modeling in terms of
generalization. We propose to publish not just the code, but also probabilities
on dev and test sets with future publications so that one can easily add the
new model into an ensemble. This has crucial advantages: it is much easier to
determine whether a newly proposed model is actually complementary to the
current baseline. Therefore, instead of inventing new names for the old tricks,
the scientific community can advance faster. Finally, this approach promotes
diversity of ideas: one does not need to create an individual model that is the
new state of the art to attract attention; it will be sufficient to develop a
new model that learns patterns which other models do not. Thus, even a
suboptimal model can be found to have value. Remarkably, our approach has
yielded new state-of-the-art results across various language modeling
benchmarks up to 10%.
|
[
-0.0561541617,
-0.5073763132,
0.5030827522,
0.2438855767,
-0.1987896115,
-0.18150796,
-0.5884401202,
-0.3759406805,
0.1115766689,
0.4531916678,
0.0608842112,
-0.8484978676,
-0.6774314046,
-0.1574994624,
-0.6366195679,
0.9517388344,
0.1171130911,
-0.0334402025,
-0.0477667637,
-0.1693864167,
-0.0936021656,
-0.5992698073,
-0.3384385109,
-0.088368699,
0.1322440356,
0.2594642639,
0.6472715139,
0.7074405551,
0.6730337739,
0.3330412507,
-0.1622465849,
-0.2191264629,
-0.4009018242,
0.1312528998,
-0.098325029,
-0.5521932244,
-0.5565336347,
-0.1647362262,
0.8760503531,
0.964060545,
-0.4342630804,
0.1137697175,
0.0111862766,
0.6315710545,
-0.5396300554,
0.3670620918,
-0.5424605608,
-0.3405607343,
-0.3202790916,
0.0515006818,
-0.3637572229,
-0.5739025474,
0.0481332615,
-0.5283540487,
0.4678842127,
-0.1658173203,
0.5461947322,
-0.3267754912,
-0.1536803246,
-0.1026289761,
-1.036864996,
0.7746929526,
-0.7632315159,
0.5130068064,
0.0617621206,
0.5827461481,
-0.1822462231,
-0.7036914229,
-0.3414649963,
-0.3016951382,
0.2246073931,
-0.2639217973,
-0.4481270909,
-0.076992251,
-0.1252803952,
0.5753477812,
-0.602029562,
-0.0033573331,
-0.3282370269,
-0.0833668709,
0.6797136068,
-0.0804139897,
0.4422996044,
0.469424963,
0.0518285222,
-0.1203431785,
-0.5411762595,
-0.0904747471,
0.3876909316,
0.550637126,
-0.0894733816,
0.4457198679,
-0.4470804632,
0.5429990292,
-0.1898073852,
0.0914041996,
0.4988639355,
-0.5627056956,
-0.1378939003,
-0.4399973452,
0.6903910041,
0.1064535752,
0.391600728,
-0.4710086882,
-0.1860822439,
0.1177576929,
0.0087477034,
-0.6143226624,
-0.2958652973,
0.1441640407,
-0.5128933787,
-0.379519701,
0.0011177765,
-1.021333456,
-0.1898822039,
-0.2436331064,
0.0938997716,
-0.372364372,
-0.7853864431,
0.3695972264,
-0.1764402539,
-0.0255842023,
0.3619005978,
-1.1671009064,
0.5225502849,
0.8257921934,
0.7902458906,
-0.1496540159,
-0.2218181342,
-0.1746090055,
0.1133529916,
-0.6291064024,
0.702721715,
-0.819319129,
-0.3938475847,
0.0480589829,
-0.0873628035,
0.1976612657,
-0.4971221387,
0.2811347842,
-0.5091463923,
0.2281616181,
0.0975840613,
-0.5277344584,
0.0261503551,
-0.248887226,
-0.706630528,
0.7838193774,
0.0908617154,
-0.5632090569,
0.3779619336,
-0.7292130589,
-0.2329521477,
0.1229113564,
-0.2740776241,
-0.4093784094,
0.4119821191,
0.1416740865,
0.1627423465,
-0.3325184882,
0.5912613273,
-0.4450041652,
-0.1835034937,
0.0994117856,
-0.1658258438,
0.5798918009,
0.3002487421,
-0.1409551352,
0.0087306174,
-0.7213708758,
0.1236811206,
-0.0131634045,
-0.3278547227,
-0.5971538424,
0.1568591148,
-0.0219962969,
-0.3004944324,
0.113723658,
-0.5021188259,
0.4008666277,
-0.4768579304,
0.1632188261,
0.6600843668,
-0.1845837682,
0.9597690701,
-0.2638846338,
0.5578513145,
-0.0474087261,
0.147975564,
-0.1503315419,
-0.8175493479,
-0.4719560146,
-0.3533648252,
0.6994934082,
0.3562124968,
-0.2454953194,
0.3297956288,
-0.3409956396,
-0.6657975316,
-0.7085162401,
0.1699768901,
0.3658398986,
0.1587802768,
0.200441733,
-0.4496513605,
-0.7065066695,
-0.8672248125,
-0.444427073,
-0.2196485996,
-0.1964703947,
-0.122764498,
0.2221147269,
-0.1113365442,
1.1725049019,
-0.5601921678,
-0.02718517,
-0.5572958589,
0.3107515275,
0.3870072067,
0.6794540882,
0.6072492599,
-0.8213718534,
-0.3322151899,
0.2903507352,
-0.6657031178,
-0.0918338597,
0.4967240691,
-0.163065806,
0.1261104345,
0.3565621972,
-0.1866063625,
0.1378025264,
0.6250107288,
-0.0021442396,
0.4198994637,
-0.1515150815,
0.1670711637,
-1.1626806259,
0.2441970259,
0.2632526159,
0.0702482909,
-0.9725863338,
0.3913811445,
-0.0862337425,
-0.3050191104,
-0.1967928112,
0.673312664,
-0.4007485211,
0.1423156559,
-0.1920303255,
-0.0933688432,
-0.4360455871,
0.1906766891,
0.1229482666,
0.5821521878,
0.8156832457,
-0.6934355497,
0.0648003742,
-0.2103071958,
-0.5321989059,
0.0214674715,
-0.8169318438,
-0.0993312225,
-0.3936610818,
0.0340800509,
-0.7577109337,
-0.2760070264,
0.0281419978,
-0.5060881972,
0.2705072463,
-0.2912900746,
-0.3220533431,
-0.2429357618,
-0.0462239347,
0.322937429,
0.804146111,
-0.2376274019,
0.4526747465,
0.7286656499,
-0.3625221252,
-0.3671140075,
-0.6747713089,
-0.0190761816,
-0.1200953647,
-0.7344738245,
0.2526200116,
-0.2169401497,
-0.5177525878,
0.0066028568,
0.070775114,
-0.2360788584,
0.0742117539,
-0.2945864201,
0.0674842373,
-0.4391099513,
0.4633661807,
-0.2246966958,
-0.2407338619,
-0.2438150048,
-0.6529992819,
0.4859011173,
-0.3517354727,
-0.2944128215,
-0.2317351103,
0.5271654725,
0.328292042,
-0.4379603565,
0.4600974023,
0.2051088959,
-0.4707687199,
-0.5345301032,
-0.454298377,
-0.0122255739,
-0.4785645604,
0.6938108802,
-0.3855557442,
-0.9382021427,
0.3598898351,
-0.2179160267,
0.2557867169,
0.201434508,
0.6444340348,
0.1824067533,
1.1243672371,
1.293207407,
-0.0621188916,
0.5395473242,
-0.0660195798,
0.3597416282,
-0.3771182001,
0.0361980125,
-0.8039301634,
0.1020231694,
-0.6210250258,
-0.6026682854,
0.242365256,
0.2862851918,
0.2265158743,
0.5147860646,
-0.642362237,
0.5220659375,
0.581064105,
-0.0387932397,
0.5907395482,
0.1440045983,
-0.1661938131,
0.0369797088,
-0.5761475563,
-0.716191113,
1.4814462662,
0.310785532,
0.8606180549,
0.4084832966,
1.0037955046,
0.3361878097,
0.6280719042,
-0.3437153995,
0.571903646,
-0.3621999025,
-0.6508160233,
-0.5658171177,
-0.5116437674,
-0.8809066415,
0.3626074493,
0.0908727273,
-0.8060059547,
0.3998988867,
0.4944394231,
0.0017294002,
0.3213331103,
-0.7925235629,
0.7317957282,
0.2149459869,
-0.0418552607,
-0.1591145992,
-0.2714455724,
0.5354733467,
-0.104446128,
0.6843926907,
-0.1685099453,
-0.0162522364,
0.7445397973,
-0.2690233886,
0.8679650426,
-0.1174744815,
-0.1660008281,
0.3081233799,
0.0099555496,
0.4706488252,
-0.1134925112,
-0.2794411778,
-0.0107961781,
-0.1780567169,
-0.426253438,
-0.6936063766,
0.5009010434,
-0.6123335958,
-0.5634264946,
-0.1806131005,
-0.4392646551,
-0.2037949115,
0.1672290415,
0.018791955,
0.3836137354,
-0.5860847235,
0.1246128008,
0.7562209964,
-0.0512219444,
0.2738928795,
0.7410673499,
-0.3967328668,
-0.4201705754,
1.0369766951,
0.0599204451,
0.3342119455,
0.4095273018,
0.3981250525,
-0.0803840011,
-0.9202803373,
-0.2119166702,
0.1824448705,
-0.7284775972,
0.0813126713,
-0.7093599439,
0.0086504221,
-0.9559046626,
0.0246596038,
-0.2300165445,
-0.5303185582,
0.0766115412,
-0.02607424,
0.2891338766,
0.7780863047,
-0.301967442,
0.2292871773,
-0.5709676147,
0.117543295,
0.3913832903,
0.5788531899,
0.081305474,
-0.2905761003,
-0.2919234931,
0.1221451387,
-0.1654169112,
-0.7197062969,
0.2772735655,
0.3329308331,
0.9482218623,
0.1647677422,
-0.1049341559,
0.4573766291,
-0.6206700802,
0.5100450516,
0.3138331771,
-1.0058236122,
0.6906053424,
-0.5108987689,
0.1896538734,
0.567406714,
0.2568674982,
-0.6753106713,
-0.7167208195,
-0.6614847779,
-0.6361250877,
0.3796789348,
0.0620125458,
0.1726617217,
-0.0461377352,
-0.0956959203,
0.2483705282,
0.3232867718,
-0.7410253882,
-0.0078889579,
-0.0889427215,
-0.3167280555,
-0.3319365978,
-0.011656425,
-0.0845509619,
-0.2549086809,
0.6983887553,
-0.2458604872,
0.2618017197,
-0.1474526972,
-0.1126700491,
-0.1770000905,
0.5815612078,
0.3922884166,
0.6615024209,
-0.1513913125,
0.0310244728,
-0.111798279,
-0.3653902411,
0.1849479824,
0.1363742799,
-0.2864091098,
0.1350078136,
0.3065431416,
0.5586697459,
0.2619532049,
-0.5513280034,
0.621093154,
0.1914061606,
-0.2794415653,
0.0957434475,
0.1071565002,
0.2741318941,
0.1328913867,
0.3036376834,
0.1652545035,
0.1892455667,
-0.7863755822,
0.4086876214,
0.2015435249,
-0.0796310678,
-0.5104029179,
0.6151050329,
0.2646131814,
-0.3497761786,
0.1660970151,
-0.3348324001,
-0.2662827075,
0.676472187,
0.7345945239,
0.781386137,
-0.4145583212,
0.3298956454,
0.346901089,
0.2677987218,
-0.4777133465,
0.4534584582,
0.1452613175,
-0.6514639258,
-0.4218485057,
-0.7901432514,
-0.4597657323,
-0.0705558658,
-0.3993272185,
0.3826907575,
-0.2354765683,
-0.1286113262,
0.0084209805,
-0.3125899136,
-0.4599244893,
0.0352598876,
0.1641034931,
0.9801774025,
-0.9581834078,
0.9988578558,
0.5976127982,
-0.4483976066,
-0.4290053248,
-0.0921241343,
-0.1064922512,
-0.7051185966,
0.3936745226,
-0.1631460786,
0.1607993096,
0.0034621796,
-0.5967357755,
-1.3129931688,
0.8558996916,
0.490578711,
-0.7680728436,
-0.1224605665,
0.0937990472,
0.7967914939,
-0.5728187561,
0.1684238017,
0.3638447523,
0.4634662867,
0.0142389638,
-0.8546507359,
-0.0557541028,
-0.4617469013,
0.2581158876,
0.4543817639,
-0.4582316577,
0.8979961276,
-0.3861551881,
-0.5275553465,
0.2297177911,
0.7396492362,
0.2454633862,
0.1517364234,
0.3041195869,
0.5022370815,
0.7150725722,
-0.0722624958,
0.9269125462,
-0.2093970627,
0.3544288278,
1.16571033,
-0.2832099795,
0.8992529511,
0.183931753,
-0.3889965713,
0.4833331406,
0.2037236542,
-0.1678243876,
0.6724108458,
0.5877251625,
-0.3151382506,
-0.1809591353,
0.0602094308,
-0.5801118612,
0.2015518248,
0.1488694698,
-0.4360907674,
-0.4065747261,
0.0533707812,
-0.0203932207,
0.3687261045,
-0.0667490065,
0.7054948807,
-0.0412406586,
-0.6301386952,
0.3720833957,
0.0431340002,
0.6887440681,
-0.8261267543,
-0.092780076,
-0.1691238731,
0.2174422592,
0.0410869606,
-0.5273218751,
0.3711449504,
0.0204409808,
-0.3574825823,
-0.167502299,
0.5487983227,
-0.7518504262,
-0.7362158895,
0.3421446383,
0.6318470836,
0.2657889426,
0.2364634424,
-0.2439203858,
0.0185810681,
-0.1385725886,
0.0589371249,
0.4301932752,
0.3649996817,
-0.1885231733,
0.6044552326,
0.6215133071,
0.4126020968,
0.1687780917,
0.264315933,
0.8637723923,
-0.4536556005,
-0.5394074917,
-0.6651386619,
0.5010039806,
-0.1555322558,
-0.3045979738,
0.5442340374,
0.52279073,
0.8397933245,
-0.0607498102,
1.1900658607,
-0.0855089128,
0.6569070816,
-0.2662710845,
0.6733754873,
-0.4388404787,
0.2703754902,
-0.4002884328,
-0.776057601,
-0.5916960239,
0.1903230548,
-0.1677505672,
-0.00268046,
0.6029222012,
0.9797824025,
-0.1141408533,
0.1848390102,
0.3488460183,
0.1597353667,
0.4672916532,
0.3764352202,
0.4299035966,
-0.2184994668,
0.6322557926,
-0.2403797358,
-0.8194295168,
-0.0356394649,
-0.8797183633,
-0.5830793381,
-0.6107739806,
-0.326983124,
-0.0207418483,
0.554548502,
0.8139910102,
0.8089587092,
-1.0836508274,
-0.5617348552,
-0.415871799,
-0.0160247758,
-0.4363270402,
-0.1537100524,
0.133751601,
-0.5828951597,
-0.8026414514,
0.3552515507,
0.1041837409,
0.0511803813,
-0.2585096657,
-0.0676287413,
-0.1042748913,
0.0853505656,
0.3624819815,
0.4172988534,
-0.5068851709,
0.005305598,
-0.1067511961,
-0.0480117165,
0.0720154122,
0.8550893068,
-0.6157354712,
0.5622369647,
0.5513653159,
0.5775408149,
0.1475372761,
-0.2461060137,
1.1712216139,
-0.5672907829,
0.0034621994,
0.2486366481,
0.3969260752,
0.2029643953,
0.0248747375,
0.625993669,
0.2995825708,
-0.4663954377,
-0.9271707535,
0.3798408508,
-0.5203273296,
-0.2560900152,
1.0519011021,
-0.0955465734,
-0.2023795396,
-0.03668781,
0.2154373974,
0.2628729939,
-0.5808061957,
0.7626775503,
0.6722154021,
0.1338354796,
-0.0014504612,
-0.3850061893,
0.4779776037,
0.2404894233,
-0.7825213671,
0.2537069619,
0.1090063453,
0.446656853,
0.2650225461,
0.8688477278,
-0.3990215957,
0.2885024846,
0.053594362,
0.3721799552,
0.1661784649,
-0.3527882695,
-0.5795783401,
0.34651649,
0.2151232958,
-0.0544137955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16733v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16733v4
|
LLMs for Science: Usage for Code Generation and Data Analysis
| 2023-11-28T12:29:33 | 2024-04-23T08:12:46 |
Mohamed Nejjar, Luca Zacharias, Fabian Stiehle, Ingo Weber
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have been touted to enable increased
productivity in many areas of today's work life. Scientific research as an area
of work is no exception: the potential of LLM-based tools to assist in the
daily work of scientists has become a highly discussed topic across
disciplines. However, we are only at the very onset of this subject of study.
It is still unclear how the potential of LLMs will materialise in research
practice. With this study, we give first empirical evidence on the use of LLMs
in the research process. We have investigated a set of use cases for LLM-based
tools in scientific research, and conducted a first study to assess to which
degree current tools are helpful. In this paper we report specifically on use
cases related to software engineering, such as generating application code and
developing scripts for data analytics. While we studied seemingly simple use
cases, results across tools differ significantly. Our results highlight the
promise of LLM-based tools in general, yet we also observe various issues,
particularly regarding the integrity of the output these tools provide.
|
[
-0.0260130502,
-0.5213557482,
0.8813289404,
0.310803324,
-0.1249188408,
0.1194365695,
-0.1106193587,
-0.5470894575,
0.1600261778,
0.4326454997,
-0.1894525737,
-0.6724321842,
-0.4706756175,
0.4712202251,
-0.8153322339,
0.6457639933,
-0.1852610111,
0.3631150723,
-0.6740510464,
0.1844868362,
-0.2357317805,
-0.8222922683,
-0.4852281809,
-0.3752840161,
0.7761541009,
0.5796838999,
0.5933294296,
0.6061677933,
1.0414975882,
0.2663477361,
0.0259474423,
-0.1860405952,
-0.5401881337,
0.30330351,
-0.0297861546,
-0.827146709,
-0.4290853441,
0.2210679352,
0.4751296937,
0.753015995,
-0.032603588,
0.3662313223,
-0.1134292185,
0.5469358563,
-0.2430060506,
0.1880676299,
-0.5784932375,
0.2096154094,
-0.5108230114,
-0.4408916533,
-0.3147681355,
-0.467990905,
-0.2274419367,
-0.4633451402,
0.1444039345,
0.2555004954,
0.5317574143,
0.0880411714,
-0.2139192522,
-0.7329105735,
-0.8272222877,
1.1262094975,
-0.9710867405,
0.1521208882,
0.1633656025,
0.2013492733,
-0.6886130571,
-0.8395273685,
-0.4194791019,
-0.5437756181,
0.0470594503,
-0.0913551524,
-0.0207773838,
-0.1311579794,
0.5562230945,
0.3836480081,
-0.4165046215,
0.4502671659,
-0.8558700085,
-0.1254858524,
0.6713749766,
0.4978627264,
0.4117889106,
-0.0251241811,
-0.0225726627,
0.0555263236,
-1.2413922548,
-0.1211042851,
0.3132612109,
0.1678063422,
0.1507664621,
1.099788785,
0.2635766566,
0.5709933043,
-0.677280128,
-0.2704614103,
-0.1355044544,
-0.3055337965,
-0.321846962,
-0.1429332048,
0.6601989269,
0.2667224109,
0.3111905456,
-0.1087425351,
-0.0865521654,
0.3664878309,
0.307746768,
-0.8158906698,
-0.1826966256,
0.3171362579,
-0.2775045931,
-0.6410754323,
-0.0487346686,
-0.4661871791,
-0.5762041807,
-0.3205739856,
-0.1333012283,
-0.0630061626,
-0.3738616705,
0.0308694616,
-0.219013676,
0.1186901107,
0.2498604804,
-0.5751747489,
0.1872160137,
0.7687420249,
0.9667242765,
-0.4985453784,
-0.2755022943,
-0.142326355,
-0.0417281203,
-0.635735929,
0.6766425967,
-0.4732432961,
-0.7818062305,
-0.1394179165,
-0.0925235674,
0.3571219444,
-0.6511442661,
0.2839983404,
-0.4968242645,
-0.186065644,
-0.3322150707,
-0.6719015837,
0.0613420829,
-0.2428079695,
-0.697245717,
0.9512791634,
0.0253678411,
-0.5661616921,
0.6722712517,
-0.8173462749,
-0.3447852433,
0.0783348754,
-0.4736288786,
-0.3729331791,
0.4229175746,
-0.4467563927,
0.5462834239,
-0.4492133558,
0.175146848,
-0.5850092173,
-0.4469793439,
0.7530679703,
-0.1545095593,
0.49338305,
0.4676128626,
0.0753062516,
-0.1252108365,
-0.6125622988,
-0.0934746712,
0.0903113782,
-0.4143342078,
-0.3020884991,
0.3146964014,
0.0060096863,
-0.0605773963,
-0.0008638448,
-0.7953950763,
0.1324339807,
-0.1652212292,
0.5694056153,
0.5532345176,
-0.1704615653,
0.3389561176,
-0.2778579891,
0.7564465404,
-0.1726968586,
-0.2104397863,
-0.1942951679,
-0.3359773457,
-0.3118466139,
-0.1764348149,
0.6139487028,
0.3003361225,
-0.4694451392,
-0.0381878056,
0.0094586657,
-0.4919376075,
-0.2384421825,
0.2417095006,
0.0231298767,
0.1692446917,
-0.0717271119,
-0.2208805382,
-0.8339681625,
-0.7773803473,
-0.1969773173,
-0.1274693161,
-0.2754137516,
0.3990106583,
0.4822003841,
-0.1330010891,
1.2361357212,
-0.4903833866,
0.2095534503,
-0.211553216,
0.0842051953,
0.2911181152,
0.2073753923,
0.5483011007,
-0.6622340083,
-0.2586416006,
-0.1298396736,
-1.207894206,
-0.4134695828,
0.1115143076,
0.0099471137,
0.2878321707,
0.7034419775,
-0.4699075818,
0.2388203889,
0.6070657372,
-0.028559275,
0.5962820649,
-0.0642179921,
0.1425058246,
-0.7385707498,
0.3219905794,
0.1718187481,
-0.2134215087,
-0.7238992453,
-0.1421915144,
-0.0208606087,
-0.2775998116,
-0.6412006617,
0.4279425442,
-0.478058964,
-0.3415181041,
-0.7153345346,
-0.08621905,
-0.2449667007,
-0.3043258786,
-0.1129408404,
1.068816185,
0.5246461034,
-0.6277424097,
0.2021658272,
-0.1732659936,
-0.509898603,
0.1130179837,
-0.7536065578,
0.2937499583,
0.1434075832,
-0.1705943793,
-0.5893743038,
-0.3190097809,
-0.112441577,
-0.4034216106,
0.1570590436,
-0.0131482854,
-0.7926774025,
-0.5851622224,
-0.3668028116,
0.1670195907,
0.6340996027,
-0.3391281962,
0.2473149151,
0.5354784727,
-0.4937720597,
-0.3058537841,
-0.7517330647,
0.2215365916,
-0.4901263714,
-0.8088502288,
0.1509764493,
-0.1539115757,
-0.8230931163,
-0.0462347493,
-0.3905204237,
0.1013913006,
0.2837529778,
0.4809931815,
0.4365953207,
-0.1975444555,
0.0185220744,
-0.1003824472,
0.0400499031,
0.3605435789,
0.1681087613,
0.2928429246,
0.0541203432,
-0.5967476368,
0.0868978947,
0.4082038105,
0.6440019608,
0.3914957345,
0.5074977279,
0.1836417913,
-0.0649227947,
-0.2704942226,
-0.4215282798,
-0.1504199654,
-0.5549014211,
0.3773023784,
-0.0837670565,
-1.0993864536,
0.4168717861,
-0.4423004091,
0.27289325,
0.094835043,
0.4675202668,
-0.447625488,
0.7817314267,
0.8342638016,
-0.0753719807,
0.3648237884,
-0.0092388606,
0.3364168704,
-0.7002797127,
-0.0131739369,
-0.684692502,
-0.0883584842,
-0.3860720992,
-0.2365581095,
0.5096146464,
0.2021977454,
0.0765772238,
0.0368485413,
-0.4102412462,
0.5518369079,
0.3873792291,
-0.3542228937,
0.3346344233,
0.1631935984,
0.2503967583,
-0.0370944515,
-0.6956161261,
-0.966748178,
1.3856002092,
0.2777938545,
1.2121930122,
-0.2158201039,
0.6514366269,
0.6328523159,
0.5038148761,
-0.6556408405,
0.7276690602,
-0.0105571542,
-0.3204399943,
-0.2489684224,
-0.4069002271,
-1.155543685,
-0.0002861481,
0.0506709255,
-0.4171035886,
-0.1396087557,
0.1319161505,
-0.052330602,
0.0609313808,
-0.7463511229,
0.375703603,
-0.4566100836,
-0.3198123574,
-0.1621088684,
-0.2822775841,
0.404592365,
-0.2500861883,
0.3836434484,
-0.2126969397,
0.1936352402,
0.9606831074,
-0.1881668568,
0.8219709992,
-0.1181529388,
-0.2247523367,
0.4308745563,
0.2468977571,
0.2678533494,
0.1966889203,
-0.4021914303,
0.3237894773,
0.3604805171,
-0.3025389612,
-0.3142661452,
0.828740716,
-0.3856032193,
-0.8783702254,
-0.7721838951,
-0.8648303747,
0.101860866,
0.1158605888,
-0.2004300207,
0.2282071263,
-0.1270505488,
0.415780127,
0.4222127795,
-0.2808774412,
0.3494663537,
0.7186033726,
-0.4738586843,
0.0984064937,
0.7800798416,
0.1771163344,
0.2236196846,
-0.1299102306,
0.2041556984,
0.1514097154,
-0.9108961225,
-0.0537662245,
0.1483323276,
-0.6174675226,
-0.3641523421,
-0.1998007447,
-0.0909570009,
-0.2447902858,
-0.355706811,
-0.0831677988,
-0.4568613768,
-0.3256609142,
-0.1931123585,
0.5672854185,
1.0349338055,
-0.0791500956,
-0.1288759559,
-0.6755583286,
0.199182868,
-0.077831544,
0.0221660044,
-0.3740576804,
0.1247607768,
-0.4028614461,
0.0106079364,
-0.1239944175,
-0.6319177747,
0.4352128804,
-0.2465329021,
0.6230467558,
-0.0723084435,
-0.2498773783,
0.2254407555,
-0.3414727449,
1.0377832651,
-0.0246957336,
-0.5567249656,
0.4852691591,
-0.2704599798,
0.0107454434,
0.3013019562,
0.4581368268,
-0.3864625692,
-0.4466832578,
-0.2759406865,
-0.7302889228,
0.4918574393,
0.1826369613,
0.0682836547,
0.1598678976,
0.5807017088,
0.2692265809,
0.454933852,
-0.6650687456,
0.0002178373,
0.2196888775,
-0.1487471908,
0.0755953789,
-0.2032789588,
-0.2776206434,
-0.1279741675,
0.4163930714,
-0.1184419096,
0.2671217322,
0.0691274405,
-0.1244861707,
-0.0329436809,
0.3956836462,
0.4370388389,
1.0881254673,
-0.1136413887,
0.1591734588,
0.069027774,
-0.6468875408,
-0.0332399569,
-0.2294711322,
-0.2087309361,
-0.2460092753,
0.1641229093,
0.2001615763,
-0.0913300067,
-0.9063827991,
0.1042640582,
0.248172313,
-0.2681389153,
-0.3897460103,
0.4496579468,
0.2105014771,
0.1924862117,
0.2580194175,
-0.1304463744,
0.1669922918,
-0.7216360569,
-0.0675202087,
0.5963865519,
0.2206879258,
-0.19175376,
0.3548229337,
0.0381808206,
-0.3451487124,
0.3519438505,
-0.1315122247,
-0.1668397933,
0.9355222583,
0.6012311578,
0.4564909041,
0.1668753624,
-0.0103750983,
-0.165737167,
0.2315733433,
0.0080620507,
0.6359245181,
0.2299077809,
-0.4728810787,
-0.5701613426,
-0.7451810837,
-0.8277012706,
0.0612959936,
-0.2469653934,
0.368906498,
-0.1541355401,
-0.2698464692,
0.1293432415,
-0.0052418946,
-0.51681602,
-0.1474938095,
0.0539576262,
0.8406654596,
-0.7106825113,
0.8961507678,
0.757397294,
-0.2423864007,
-0.6469137073,
-0.549778223,
0.2242838293,
-0.7135257125,
0.8182919621,
-0.1614627391,
-0.2644073367,
-0.3075942993,
-1.026945591,
-0.9406163096,
1.3435454369,
0.3122891486,
-0.5262266397,
0.1281024814,
0.4644733071,
0.7077791095,
-0.3511313796,
0.0478929095,
0.5132060051,
0.4637159705,
0.1361795515,
-0.6841614246,
-0.013218971,
-0.3460405767,
0.0557122603,
0.1530639082,
-0.3252753913,
0.8430141211,
-0.1936552078,
-0.2260074168,
0.1110167503,
0.5012320876,
0.6198419333,
0.7010061741,
0.1088394821,
-0.0116894273,
0.6873698235,
0.0730428547,
1.0265718699,
-0.434250325,
0.1570183784,
0.6672105193,
-0.7794203758,
0.5457192659,
0.7640931606,
-0.5032437444,
0.4162227511,
0.40880391,
-0.4012641311,
0.168463707,
0.68479532,
-0.1322702765,
0.1678990722,
-0.0228776969,
-0.2644033134,
-0.0272831898,
0.6497611403,
-0.4451310635,
0.1315546632,
0.0104302987,
0.19876948,
-0.1772797853,
-0.2149966657,
0.4385203719,
0.5135717988,
-0.4467537403,
0.1256383508,
-0.0264534652,
0.6465970874,
-0.8223481178,
-0.1886187047,
-0.0447207913,
-0.0023694509,
-0.5054472089,
-1.014121294,
0.4989750981,
0.3914998472,
-0.0269584637,
-0.1548722684,
1.0171371698,
0.0047690817,
-0.5869428515,
0.0610528104,
0.6882483959,
0.418394804,
0.2420243174,
-0.0961610824,
0.2716245651,
-0.1619797945,
-0.389213115,
0.5127526522,
0.1889795512,
0.0651899576,
0.810410738,
0.8070622683,
0.5373960137,
0.2597830594,
0.0612938851,
0.8770346045,
-0.8531255722,
0.0912633091,
-0.87833637,
0.1682409197,
-0.0820617378,
0.0730805472,
1.1169329882,
0.7164897323,
0.5783257484,
0.0174899492,
1.0957386494,
-0.1845801622,
0.4538893104,
-0.629309535,
0.4878738523,
-0.3409406841,
0.5577710867,
-0.1930888891,
-0.7533766031,
-0.3937703371,
0.3598772883,
-0.1858602017,
-0.0734652504,
0.7744102478,
0.8851134777,
-0.0103770057,
0.2821317911,
0.2953177392,
0.0883011743,
0.6136997342,
0.0580536351,
0.9088431001,
0.2110801041,
0.3262103796,
-0.1137331873,
-0.1801686734,
0.0098154005,
-1.0204852819,
-0.8600580692,
-0.125834778,
-0.1334363818,
-0.2108745724,
-0.0233143736,
0.6752563119,
0.4842634201,
-0.6190847158,
-0.6730850339,
-0.2696315646,
-0.0861687586,
0.0309200641,
-0.2106056511,
0.0728512853,
-0.4542122185,
-0.4586314261,
0.8200876117,
0.4151359499,
0.0100587495,
-0.6129098535,
-0.0668300465,
0.0865237191,
0.2453613579,
0.7072150111,
0.5261281133,
-0.3794184923,
-0.0487277322,
0.397303611,
-0.0831744075,
0.1324847937,
1.2778420448,
-0.6002395153,
0.1194033474,
0.4635752141,
0.4311628342,
0.6378217936,
-0.1843316108,
0.8060052395,
-0.486343503,
-0.1604873985,
0.2719328105,
0.4424043,
0.3566324413,
-0.3660312891,
0.8763884902,
-0.0164425224,
-1.0464553833,
-1.2561205626,
0.0016151825,
-0.8967188597,
-0.1886202395,
1.4491977692,
0.0684739277,
-0.184737727,
-0.123117052,
-0.194399029,
0.0035239193,
-0.3042462468,
0.7844172716,
0.8897379041,
-0.6809714437,
0.1841124296,
-0.9028235078,
0.3366828859,
0.3311419189,
-0.9936932921,
0.0120452931,
0.4190017283,
0.4368954301,
0.2977905273,
0.5162962079,
-0.3751494586,
0.1395628452,
0.0734079927,
0.0493748598,
-0.2689266205,
-0.2561923563,
-0.2657700479,
0.2209588438,
0.5552565455,
0.2974738181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03734v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03734v1
|
Conditional Prompt Tuning for Multimodal Fusion
| 2023-11-28T11:05:20 | 2023-11-28T11:05:20 |
Ruixiang Jiang, Lingbo Liu, Changwen Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We show that the representation of one modality can effectively guide the
prompting of another modality for parameter-efficient multimodal fusion.
Specifically, we first encode one modality and use its representation as a
prior to conditionally prompt all frozen layers of the other modality. This is
achieved by disentangling the vanilla prompt vectors into three types of
specialized prompts that adaptively capture global-level and instance-level
features. To better produce the instance-wise prompt, we introduce the mixture
of prompt experts (MoPE) to dynamically route each instance to the most
suitable prompt experts for encoding. We further study a regularization term to
avoid degenerated prompt expert routing. Thanks to our design, our method can
effectively transfer the pretrained knowledge in unimodal encoders for
downstream multimodal tasks. Compared with vanilla prompting, we show that our
MoPE-based conditional prompting is more expressive, thereby scales better with
training data and the total number of prompts. We also demonstrate that our
prompt tuning is architecture-agnostic, thereby offering high modularity.
Extensive experiments over three multimodal datasets demonstrate
state-of-the-art results, matching or surpassing the performance achieved
through fine-tuning, while only necessitating 0.7% of the trainable parameters.
Code will be released: https://github.com/songrise/ConditionalPrompt.
|
[
-0.5829526782,
-0.6466634274,
0.6820386648,
0.1822273135,
-0.2985697091,
-0.1369254589,
-0.3986304402,
0.0023565213,
0.1966652423,
0.1345238388,
-1.1176470518,
-0.3008950651,
-0.2752234042,
0.2343724221,
0.1257389635,
0.6330704093,
0.1993206143,
0.0606664047,
-0.4520564377,
-0.0693736374,
-0.9924786091,
0.0468207635,
-0.7299771905,
-0.0773147643,
0.993566215,
0.6216718554,
0.6241788864,
0.42153427,
0.1515909731,
0.3698239923,
0.2767240107,
0.4773259461,
-0.1963540763,
0.4402163327,
-0.2300076932,
-0.3305776417,
-0.309256196,
0.0555131473,
0.3171542585,
0.2964142859,
-0.0129619138,
-0.0501879565,
-0.2538765669,
0.3431087732,
-0.6252871156,
-0.1232274696,
-0.5201478004,
-0.0002282088,
-0.1518223286,
-0.4769818485,
-0.5411262512,
-0.0834291354,
-0.1724242419,
-0.8318944573,
0.1588400453,
0.3655272126,
0.5644773245,
0.5510124564,
-0.7735444903,
0.1814442575,
-0.2415847033,
0.5868505836,
-0.3946158588,
0.5370420218,
0.3393541276,
0.6033162475,
-0.1413375139,
-0.5847602487,
-0.6617135406,
-0.2965660095,
-0.2128338367,
0.4245713055,
-0.1356141865,
0.3976351619,
0.4003958106,
0.3086813092,
-0.7786898613,
0.2371225953,
-0.1050507054,
-0.7506074309,
0.3246718347,
0.2061069906,
0.2439967692,
-0.3515168726,
-0.6924067736,
-0.3035257161,
-0.4222798944,
0.4144958556,
0.3928643167,
0.1713527888,
-0.3879508376,
0.3336050808,
-0.3731140196,
1.0554791689,
0.5631697178,
-0.219217822,
0.3404105306,
-0.659555316,
0.0127369994,
-0.0205323622,
0.7758651376,
0.6821426749,
-0.0766817555,
0.0116058337,
-0.323961705,
0.2659255564,
0.1435035765,
-0.4260144234,
-0.3208611608,
0.2673742473,
-0.3811890483,
0.235629946,
-0.1580242664,
-0.8084210753,
-0.681814909,
-0.4683907926,
0.9070798159,
-0.6447574496,
-0.2249942124,
0.1449006051,
-0.6085386872,
0.0291792415,
0.3523079455,
-0.9103119969,
-0.4024795592,
0.3639190495,
0.5979948044,
0.0384088978,
-0.2935813665,
-0.8379307985,
0.0222957917,
0.061554078,
0.8706332445,
-0.7939120531,
-0.2598124743,
-0.0340290293,
-0.0168442298,
-0.1875929832,
-0.180498302,
0.5455509424,
-0.3574868143,
0.5458418727,
-0.5049284101,
-0.2986114621,
-0.2810474336,
0.2096983492,
-0.5323887467,
0.426358521,
0.2802562118,
-0.3087578714,
0.6120935082,
-0.3167974651,
-0.5581643581,
0.070533365,
-0.283208698,
0.1324280053,
0.0547438152,
0.593675375,
0.462192446,
-0.4103596509,
0.1591651142,
-0.1759622246,
-0.0074626445,
0.0717159286,
-0.3928164542,
0.2568298578,
0.3632370532,
-0.0965778679,
0.4650132954,
-0.837980032,
0.0143046854,
-0.4199692905,
-0.0475375317,
-0.0857397318,
-0.2302335948,
-0.1254368871,
0.2444308996,
0.2176003605,
-0.4411406219,
0.3810113966,
0.0505276285,
0.2932215035,
0.8309600949,
0.1381749064,
0.6460636854,
-0.4061561227,
0.610609591,
0.178857699,
0.3708378673,
-0.7782849073,
-0.5464709997,
-0.5397186279,
-0.7318902016,
0.4094111919,
0.4781717062,
-1.3787660599,
0.2626820207,
0.1273574084,
-0.1764040589,
-0.6418457031,
-0.0592278689,
0.4841320813,
0.931550622,
0.4934041202,
-0.0269244276,
-0.6257187724,
-1.1454747915,
-0.0120692821,
0.0395734087,
-0.0890337378,
0.2084296197,
-0.1089888066,
-0.0135164103,
0.9609651566,
-0.2640169263,
-0.2960438728,
-0.1024012268,
0.3430743217,
0.3077136874,
0.7126324773,
0.6101284027,
-0.9813095927,
-0.4565097094,
-0.0898479819,
-0.5149488449,
-0.3190657794,
-0.5184815526,
-0.1605801433,
-0.0970274657,
0.3587574959,
-0.8026291728,
-0.0564790294,
0.6255313754,
-0.5058104992,
0.1760737002,
-0.3485399187,
0.7522922158,
-1.0368087292,
-0.1300161928,
-0.0750776678,
-0.2066958398,
-0.5838904977,
-0.2132096142,
0.3911173642,
-0.3284045458,
-0.4204807281,
0.4985179603,
-0.5020433664,
0.3038004935,
-0.1602784842,
-0.0480927229,
0.1401342899,
0.6570359468,
0.0050025145,
0.7561015487,
1.0238232613,
-0.8255434632,
0.5411236882,
0.150738433,
-0.0856736526,
0.9429937601,
-0.5483440161,
-0.0004822949,
-0.2393323779,
0.4232032895,
-1.0863541365,
-0.43337062,
0.3388080001,
-0.5456408858,
0.3801349699,
-0.2741164863,
-0.3717212975,
-0.2570616305,
-0.244795382,
0.3853285909,
0.8307266235,
-0.4599949121,
0.9327421188,
-0.089095369,
0.0152988015,
-0.2743503749,
-0.3413250148,
-0.1476434618,
-0.1129821613,
-0.999088347,
0.6057301164,
-0.4426893294,
0.1486156285,
-0.187213093,
-0.1230444536,
0.1577343941,
-0.0279296692,
0.3193972707,
0.1907292455,
-0.1443875134,
0.1034367681,
0.4048471749,
-0.4315573275,
-0.2692424059,
-0.3503221869,
0.5678169727,
0.3226161599,
-0.4345753193,
-0.5990645289,
0.4430480301,
0.600037396,
-0.2488714606,
0.4793539941,
0.9324864149,
-0.1308411211,
0.0242961086,
-0.7216379642,
-0.3935640454,
-0.5862742066,
-0.0689125806,
-0.4412134588,
-0.7099942565,
0.5611491799,
0.0096964221,
-0.0421054326,
0.2758260369,
0.5311820507,
-0.0947365761,
1.5293774605,
0.6871933937,
0.210117653,
0.6062907577,
0.0976563394,
-0.1345837116,
-0.5027878284,
-0.5886648893,
-0.2891413867,
-0.6119319201,
-0.2929640412,
-0.3251666725,
0.7842338085,
-0.1573388278,
0.099668622,
0.1714762151,
-0.2560287118,
0.485149473,
0.6776188612,
0.3068754375,
-0.0987694934,
-0.2149645388,
-0.2318402827,
0.1375387162,
-0.9621139169,
0.1412532032,
0.3619855344,
-0.1260772347,
0.7614123225,
0.0013628524,
0.3674940169,
0.4528416097,
-0.4119106829,
-0.5748677254,
0.5573494434,
0.0656860918,
-0.5639067888,
-0.0945593119,
-0.3568862081,
-0.7242133617,
0.1700297892,
-0.618806541,
-0.3590527177,
0.7460291386,
0.6374864578,
-0.8119596839,
-0.1108554751,
-1.0414053202,
0.7103351355,
-0.146138519,
-0.1822636127,
-0.2745630741,
-0.9265385866,
0.1827512234,
0.1253503114,
0.1305024922,
-0.260638833,
-0.1789794266,
0.3537722826,
-0.0371718183,
0.7656401992,
-0.4491736293,
0.0387906544,
-0.1439373791,
0.0042714784,
0.4168681204,
0.3571532071,
-0.0229245927,
-0.2523194551,
-0.2624039054,
-0.3760918677,
-0.8112594485,
0.685880661,
-0.5722779036,
-0.6692401171,
-0.09828078,
-0.6310169697,
-0.5523698926,
0.1300871223,
0.6854571104,
0.8373168111,
0.3570338488,
0.1324249506,
0.9200684428,
-0.1235841215,
0.5261263251,
0.6596419215,
0.2307658046,
-0.5853362083,
0.9591272473,
-0.342710346,
0.1745801717,
0.6494830847,
0.1981284767,
-0.4082837999,
-0.3359574974,
-0.8018549681,
-0.0766988099,
-0.7564191222,
-0.5805595517,
-0.5840169787,
0.3352771997,
-0.4726172686,
-0.3765435815,
-0.1821109205,
-0.4701129794,
-0.428758502,
0.0576830842,
0.6426359415,
0.1296495348,
-0.3782404661,
0.2004289031,
-0.969137013,
0.644274354,
0.6890413761,
0.1400522292,
-0.2842074633,
-0.5369369984,
0.0155305397,
0.1226084307,
0.0261614863,
-0.7444230318,
0.0719664618,
0.5090535283,
0.8534272313,
0.5001398325,
0.2836812437,
0.8335126042,
-0.4458524883,
0.9499172568,
0.6797277331,
-0.825812459,
0.735630095,
-0.4976089001,
0.5434736609,
0.725011766,
0.5347588658,
-0.6021957397,
-0.2138100713,
-0.2730460167,
-0.7240250111,
0.8141948581,
-0.1429631859,
0.1597644389,
-0.0262443088,
0.1978212297,
0.5376654267,
0.1380245686,
-0.3120895922,
-0.3137037158,
-0.5878776908,
-0.2884365022,
-0.2260384262,
-0.2212599367,
-0.3652566075,
-0.2504801154,
0.2598954439,
-0.1883555204,
0.176454857,
0.1365837604,
-0.3849133253,
-0.1347919255,
0.2499005944,
0.8721042275,
0.5876260996,
-0.067339167,
0.2451941669,
0.0173158385,
-0.048703827,
0.2643493712,
0.0293771271,
-0.048681546,
-0.1191917881,
0.3880878389,
1.1643172503,
0.3114007711,
-0.5512261391,
0.4512924254,
-0.2192323655,
-0.2203524858,
0.1810492426,
0.4186547399,
-0.3429358602,
0.423412323,
0.3734924495,
0.4251837134,
0.1131345332,
-0.4167846441,
0.1532429159,
0.2608625293,
-0.1661168188,
-0.5713066459,
0.6086568832,
0.5067005754,
-0.1836607754,
0.478463769,
-0.1120333076,
-0.3198488355,
0.2968401313,
0.3575202525,
0.7174732685,
-0.2007276416,
0.3737107217,
0.2197281718,
0.0348790698,
0.1826757938,
0.3730306923,
-0.3588100672,
-0.513112545,
-0.3254347146,
-0.307607621,
-0.226750195,
-0.3467774689,
-0.6339626908,
0.2805280983,
-0.2710058391,
-0.201616779,
-0.0225167945,
-0.5756548047,
-0.6434454918,
0.1991257071,
0.3870563805,
0.9176135659,
-0.8518551588,
0.5539557934,
0.9717719555,
-0.4071323574,
-0.586823225,
-0.2354414761,
0.2304918617,
-0.798994422,
0.3065757155,
0.099030897,
0.0179606732,
0.1055301577,
-0.3636740446,
-0.7786132693,
1.0424258709,
0.4612185955,
-0.5589944124,
0.1179410219,
-0.3829140663,
0.2293747365,
-0.3149285018,
0.3711580634,
0.2899383008,
0.8625312448,
0.2707548738,
-0.954052031,
0.1348483562,
-0.301464498,
-0.1000593826,
0.1453165412,
-0.6248358488,
0.9701280594,
-0.0772501677,
-0.2327564955,
0.0318408199,
0.7138189077,
-0.0401147939,
0.3062580824,
0.9035410881,
0.2075235546,
0.7448887825,
-0.1732597798,
1.0167329311,
-0.4006705284,
-0.2663621306,
0.4597198665,
-0.0306262933,
0.2320447117,
0.4294501841,
0.4493577182,
0.444554925,
0.8664047718,
0.2328571826,
1.0529973507,
-0.4905014932,
-0.2711616158,
-0.8757048845,
-0.2641219199,
-0.5772767067,
0.4435048103,
0.1420555413,
-0.0964997709,
-0.1493114382,
0.7529483438,
-0.2494227886,
0.0071919691,
-0.5407028198,
0.7485828996,
-0.1561719924,
-1.0709546804,
0.6234732866,
-0.2473557442,
0.8919118643,
-0.9727517962,
0.0257669147,
-0.466724515,
-0.2001393288,
-0.2071552277,
-0.528128624,
-0.3719362915,
-0.3509958982,
-0.5362368822,
-0.5920192003,
0.5900800228,
-0.5952962041,
-0.0385301597,
-0.1942833811,
0.4609569311,
-0.4353693426,
0.0788046792,
-0.4754713178,
0.1331537366,
0.1116619334,
-0.1108193025,
0.4729124308,
0.4745479822,
0.1327960938,
0.6656088829,
0.6446884871,
-0.2347978354,
0.036320664,
0.2832523584,
1.0761703253,
-0.5524435639,
-0.5502372384,
-0.6029213071,
0.8916509748,
0.0600234456,
-0.5933838487,
0.8679720759,
0.0426330417,
0.5164025426,
-0.278970778,
0.3397881985,
-0.289886266,
0.147999987,
-1.1202369928,
0.4050525129,
-0.8522236943,
0.0827967301,
0.1057324484,
-0.6603491306,
-0.0477960855,
0.257884264,
0.0671773255,
0.0073814997,
0.7253849506,
1.0190742016,
-0.1586061567,
-0.0529301092,
0.489998132,
-0.1623543054,
0.044040028,
0.4164913595,
1.0772452354,
0.118343316,
0.3910193741,
-0.32067734,
-0.2719765902,
-0.2447052747,
-0.9550662637,
-0.7155536413,
-0.9339697361,
-0.3443109691,
-0.0361215211,
0.0190936849,
1.1335483789,
0.9483204484,
-0.6178938746,
0.342818439,
0.3916607201,
0.2029219121,
-0.4004100263,
-0.1637706012,
-0.0548601262,
-0.5434235334,
-0.5334509015,
0.9037063122,
0.2482330948,
-0.0078464178,
-0.1980156302,
-0.0682255179,
0.136460349,
-0.0352652073,
0.6123135686,
0.2109301984,
-0.6394418478,
-0.3398665488,
0.1369740665,
0.1425114274,
-0.0801989734,
1.0708588362,
-1.0850738287,
0.7080167532,
0.8111298084,
0.1704724878,
0.0875813663,
0.018016167,
0.8324586749,
-1.0256607533,
0.3594008088,
0.2581206262,
0.5466454625,
0.2014970332,
-0.451846838,
0.0146040935,
0.1986680031,
-0.3819639385,
-0.6451771855,
0.4973166883,
-1.3664498329,
-0.2297534794,
1.1751486063,
0.0547155291,
-0.0619280487,
-0.0995884389,
-0.5226630569,
0.0065014986,
-0.7514482141,
0.4301194847,
0.1528986245,
-0.1941265315,
-0.5563619137,
0.0218975041,
0.5796121359,
0.4007332325,
-0.4032627642,
-0.3189878464,
0.8698316216,
-0.046095524,
0.0821493939,
0.4884976149,
0.4858009517,
0.8668035269,
0.1594456732,
0.0238103792,
-0.6447954774,
-0.5378941298,
-0.3295647204,
0.1122250482,
-0.1730960906,
-0.2236792594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16678v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16678v1
|
Entity-Aspect-Opinion-Sentiment Quadruple Extraction for Fine-grained Sentiment Analysis
| 2023-11-28T10:50:00 | 2023-11-28T10:50:00 |
Dan Ma, Jun Xu, Zongyu Wang, Xuezhi Cao, Yunsen Xian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Product reviews often contain a large number of implicit aspects and
object-attribute co-existence cases. Unfortunately, many existing studies in
Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) have overlooked this issue, which can
make it difficult to extract opinions comprehensively and fairly. In this
paper, we propose a new task called Entity-Aspect-Opinion-Sentiment Quadruple
Extraction (EASQE), which aims to hierarchically decompose aspect terms into
entities and aspects to avoid information loss, non-exclusive annotations, and
opinion misunderstandings in ABSA tasks. To facilitate research in this new
task, we have constructed four datasets (Res14-EASQE, Res15-EASQE, Res16-EASQE,
and Lap14-EASQE) based on the SemEval Restaurant and Laptop datasets. We have
also proposed a novel two-stage sequence-tagging based Trigger-Opinion
framework as the baseline for the EASQE task. Empirical evaluations show that
our Trigger-Opinion framework can generate satisfactory EASQE results and can
also be applied to other ABSA tasks, significantly outperforming
state-of-the-art methods. We have made the four datasets and source code of
Trigger-Opinion publicly available to facilitate further research in this area.
|
[
-0.7975967526,
-0.7084617615,
0.3717792034,
0.4721606374,
-0.221069932,
0.0342591815,
0.1127447337,
-0.6362834573,
0.3357536495,
0.4901909232,
-0.2858613431,
-0.7789225578,
-0.298468262,
0.2162430882,
-0.3066234589,
1.2925466299,
-0.1958535165,
0.0763641968,
-0.0800930709,
-0.4763237834,
-0.4319120049,
-0.5376439691,
-0.5808410645,
-0.1199948862,
0.4383935034,
0.4863834679,
0.3340807259,
0.1298975497,
0.3038153648,
0.1771173328,
0.1016467437,
0.2503286302,
-0.0914146453,
0.0607446246,
-0.2790229917,
-0.2546132207,
-0.7689221501,
0.0486521497,
0.2451129407,
0.4838342667,
-0.0301401168,
0.3210579157,
0.2988263965,
0.8361879587,
-0.511626184,
0.4675878882,
-0.2592971325,
0.0443286635,
0.0747146755,
0.2499274313,
-0.1929002255,
-0.2088357508,
-0.042727489,
-0.4887206554,
0.0814926773,
0.266512841,
1.0674109459,
-0.0651153997,
-0.4039583802,
-0.0552265048,
-1.0055135489,
0.788225472,
-0.6538546085,
0.4317269921,
0.0645460337,
-0.2169541419,
0.1104005948,
-0.3605256677,
-0.6953424811,
0.3155482411,
0.0397801548,
0.1839560121,
-0.2622257471,
0.1650065035,
0.0984620675,
0.6189610362,
-0.1473473161,
0.0733945072,
-0.1485620737,
0.1139915884,
0.7646669149,
0.0085688587,
-0.0970025137,
-0.5723382831,
-0.693310976,
0.2007550746,
-0.9617961049,
0.3133189976,
0.1070128083,
-0.0515852422,
0.253770113,
0.5729383826,
-0.6275556684,
0.1574893445,
0.3280134201,
0.2031190544,
0.6636584997,
-0.4581618607,
-0.352025032,
-0.1945571452,
1.0906285048,
0.7528089285,
-0.3463967443,
0.0121506462,
-0.6706615686,
0.0062542995,
0.3440493941,
-0.6567024589,
-0.1916637421,
0.7947462797,
-0.49195382,
-0.4471062124,
0.1351396143,
-1.139952898,
-0.2844051123,
-0.2974120677,
0.376796931,
-0.3696056604,
-0.3272490501,
-0.232593447,
0.0125858821,
0.5475929379,
0.1902479231,
-0.687707305,
0.4688443542,
1.0717198849,
0.4754672348,
-0.2478583455,
-0.0912965983,
-0.298810333,
0.0505916514,
-0.2304448485,
1.0761381388,
-0.5726121068,
-0.5046859384,
-0.0076687643,
0.1205622107,
0.395965308,
-0.6822190285,
0.884676218,
-0.5033094883,
0.0270183496,
-0.7001621723,
-0.6533391476,
-0.4936836958,
0.4581549168,
-0.6341421604,
1.2188098431,
-0.1299511939,
-0.5575168133,
0.5596639514,
-0.5827677846,
-0.5154892206,
0.0289328434,
-0.5834861994,
-0.6859492064,
0.3527421951,
0.7404988408,
0.4439913332,
-0.2558221817,
-0.0150326295,
-0.5172150135,
0.1948106885,
0.0891639814,
-0.0677548572,
0.4131711423,
0.0729322955,
-0.5755674243,
-0.0358650237,
-0.4661896229,
-0.0570012257,
-0.0859511495,
-0.1734867394,
-0.4203957915,
0.0642589256,
0.0359742939,
0.4213677645,
0.3378432393,
-0.7556706667,
0.1554615349,
-0.4076001048,
0.1487808973,
0.549346149,
0.5567331314,
0.6314858794,
-0.0697241575,
0.4617772102,
0.4179807603,
0.4127091169,
-0.0588529035,
-0.3756288588,
-0.8440881371,
-0.1689839959,
0.1625852287,
0.385632962,
-0.9846745133,
0.5561916828,
-0.1099936515,
-0.3117296696,
-0.3796130419,
-0.0077958875,
0.5321326256,
0.3923297822,
0.4808066189,
-0.5428727269,
-0.3621183634,
-1.1511615515,
-0.2931736708,
-0.2685112357,
-0.0230219979,
0.3678730726,
0.3064799309,
0.2594486177,
1.0128778219,
-0.6525297761,
-0.4888269603,
-0.2006002516,
0.4378094077,
0.1568686068,
0.3372199833,
0.6139140725,
-0.8091084361,
-0.0716226622,
-0.0792167932,
-0.5904449224,
-0.104840301,
-0.0222123209,
-0.0832364038,
0.4921800494,
-0.0184227917,
-0.8185975552,
0.196812287,
0.2149018794,
-0.1619465351,
0.4873155951,
0.4414328933,
0.4036720395,
-1.3386255503,
-0.3292424977,
0.4248905778,
0.0241774824,
-0.4393351972,
-0.0612583049,
-0.0395713747,
0.1955875754,
-0.4140962362,
0.2100649625,
-0.4889147282,
-0.4659129083,
-0.1993584633,
-0.155954361,
0.5663974285,
0.7405997515,
0.1501790881,
0.2856141329,
0.372960031,
-0.1887590885,
0.2103714049,
0.2716339529,
-0.1047089323,
0.8164542317,
-0.6051616669,
0.1638604701,
-0.0095969141,
0.210753724,
-0.6898878217,
0.0717106089,
0.3467771709,
-0.2903648615,
0.3709549308,
-0.0711150318,
-0.2086115032,
-0.3525351584,
-0.7675461769,
0.1861378551,
0.0276608802,
-0.3285347223,
0.8724837899,
0.7048305869,
-0.4926999807,
-0.7175508142,
-0.2069587857,
0.0162632596,
-0.2055168003,
-0.259444356,
0.397919178,
0.3286279738,
-0.1361357868,
0.192520082,
-0.4351882041,
-0.0936180055,
-0.2870056927,
0.4685453773,
0.3595770299,
-0.2200029343,
0.0434763804,
0.2854754031,
-0.049668178,
0.4205209017,
-0.3084577024,
0.2210749686,
-0.5503999591,
-0.133004114,
-0.2636064291,
0.6644297838,
0.331714958,
-0.4894123673,
0.1265796274,
0.4577367604,
-0.6850889921,
-0.2414545119,
-0.4959090948,
-0.07153631,
-0.3548103869,
0.6001989245,
-0.3368344605,
-0.696357429,
0.3742420971,
-0.120323129,
0.4237116873,
0.4424470663,
0.5317312479,
-0.3584014475,
0.9026382565,
0.4006944895,
-0.3417429328,
0.4771563411,
-0.3018068969,
0.5269852281,
-0.9182341099,
-0.2727840245,
-0.6391282678,
-0.2109803259,
-0.3831712604,
-0.1429782063,
0.406907469,
0.3051556647,
-0.0881622806,
0.179091379,
-0.3203707635,
0.3724839687,
0.2606076896,
0.0860645771,
0.288366586,
0.0955131501,
0.2250128984,
0.2059138864,
-0.1648319513,
-0.7206351757,
0.7487546802,
0.3632875085,
0.2926128805,
0.024359744,
1.0073850155,
0.2337325066,
0.4142619073,
-1.0009037256,
0.500274241,
-0.0943146497,
-0.6601618528,
-0.2895082235,
-0.2110146284,
-0.5155779719,
0.2126399428,
-0.4121291935,
-0.7861440778,
0.7080944777,
0.0340497978,
-0.6595064998,
0.0247780457,
-0.7331200838,
0.8515660167,
-0.0707557276,
-0.4110860229,
-0.1228024885,
-0.3219369352,
0.4676861167,
-0.1351930648,
0.4567584991,
-0.4529401362,
-0.0443864092,
0.803821981,
-0.5700489879,
0.5996574759,
-0.3570299447,
-0.1370347738,
0.3532344103,
0.0490530059,
0.4820280373,
0.4362217784,
0.0925171673,
0.5987417698,
0.1033230126,
-0.1381372511,
-0.7196649909,
0.7872269154,
-0.7498124242,
-0.5377988815,
-0.468629688,
-0.0593535267,
-0.5546705127,
0.1545328498,
0.0863354355,
0.6381201148,
-0.2368363738,
-0.1205818951,
0.3085624278,
0.0685673878,
0.6907877922,
0.3573084176,
-0.3336754739,
-0.6319143772,
0.8367671967,
0.1571383178,
-0.1385035962,
0.3078187704,
-0.0587762743,
-0.2908856869,
-0.6320511103,
-0.5099061728,
-0.0705471933,
-0.4237162173,
-0.6369142532,
-0.7933545113,
-0.0167796724,
-0.2153290808,
0.0258338321,
-0.6628307104,
-0.544347465,
-0.0914422348,
-0.3322881162,
0.3407128155,
0.9661510587,
-0.0120828226,
0.0624334253,
-1.2047514915,
0.4287184775,
0.3032267392,
0.1187341884,
-0.1941188425,
0.0438098386,
-0.2730384469,
-0.1135882586,
-0.6143687963,
-1.0357085466,
0.4981247783,
0.135456726,
0.1930017918,
0.4840624332,
0.1857410669,
0.323752284,
-0.2602954805,
1.063298583,
0.232953608,
-1.0522521734,
0.3079290092,
-0.1553952694,
-0.0719957948,
0.5912769437,
0.4962051511,
-0.2008800358,
-0.3091877699,
-0.5530592799,
-1.255453825,
0.5991584063,
0.2691612244,
-0.090762794,
-0.0747395754,
0.3922517598,
0.248225227,
0.3561988771,
-0.5435262322,
-0.2373585403,
-0.2644016445,
-0.3296111524,
0.4386992753,
-0.369977504,
-0.0463629439,
-0.1917817146,
0.8511408567,
-0.0431146659,
0.1824919432,
0.0544523932,
0.2283328772,
0.1043600067,
0.5805835724,
-0.1885365546,
0.3330031931,
-0.096991241,
0.1711012274,
0.2246660441,
-0.4916439354,
0.1067916602,
0.2795833945,
-0.3109514713,
-0.2180594802,
0.1759578735,
0.5152837038,
0.0706982389,
0.0271560252,
0.8142344356,
-0.1942795068,
0.0965608433,
-0.4176949263,
-0.3830952644,
-0.0665125549,
0.3951123655,
0.4464766085,
0.1546377987,
0.6978967786,
-0.506973505,
0.3849743307,
0.1236379817,
-0.4215840399,
-0.6144230366,
0.2479676902,
0.6471500397,
0.1053626686,
0.3096237183,
-0.6188121438,
-0.5267451406,
0.569767952,
0.0619175024,
1.2719448805,
-0.2514055371,
0.2939336002,
0.2692034841,
0.2453301847,
0.089519985,
0.5684480071,
0.0123166302,
-0.8878107667,
-0.4680450559,
-0.8601067066,
-0.2223996967,
0.0071570138,
-0.908147037,
0.3384411931,
-0.3227055371,
-0.2880939543,
0.3660081327,
0.1108030304,
-0.605230689,
0.2940010726,
0.1016470268,
0.4219283462,
-0.865567863,
0.6964128017,
0.9239905477,
-0.6492385268,
-0.9766401052,
0.1138657108,
0.026126707,
-0.3411197364,
0.2699531317,
0.24282749,
-0.176424548,
-0.3074564338,
-0.3703240454,
-0.64054811,
0.9186439514,
-0.2674479485,
-0.5981026888,
-0.1288934797,
0.2136318982,
0.3405882716,
-0.6821481586,
0.0927259251,
0.8849552274,
0.1988624781,
-0.089390479,
-0.6923928261,
0.0561626032,
-0.2001523525,
-0.1146152839,
0.329870671,
-0.639782548,
0.5566741824,
0.0388799906,
-0.1262485385,
-0.3369343877,
0.9339402914,
0.0385160819,
0.5550262928,
0.7226431966,
0.6212011576,
0.3565500975,
-0.1760299355,
0.6149131656,
-0.5024412274,
0.7243406773,
1.2675198317,
-0.63584131,
1.198061347,
0.4587463439,
-0.2586005628,
0.4894215167,
0.7295194268,
0.1523510963,
0.4313846827,
-0.2798933387,
-0.3242263794,
-0.2244471163,
-0.2604571879,
-0.0368380919,
0.6555444598,
0.6171360612,
-0.2728180289,
-0.0181227587,
-0.2057699412,
0.138407588,
-0.4287292659,
-0.3930220902,
1.0000450611,
0.4664528966,
-0.4136252999,
0.0770949796,
-0.0790807679,
0.3296646476,
0.0770516247,
-0.2815847397,
-0.381067425,
-0.1403178275,
-0.6007726789,
-1.0708512068,
0.4402964413,
0.1447270513,
-0.2176575214,
0.0432615951,
0.5871098638,
-0.2360276878,
-0.4122576714,
0.0330032706,
0.5157389045,
-0.0791170597,
-0.2636251748,
-0.6870782375,
0.0647738948,
-0.0655800998,
-0.6256246567,
-0.081703648,
0.5971193314,
-0.1982117891,
-0.139138788,
0.2330692112,
-0.1280761063,
-0.3346658647,
-0.097729966,
1.0858494043,
-0.7919799089,
-0.5083432198,
-0.5451411009,
0.4138576686,
-0.4536822438,
-0.2355146557,
0.6795374751,
0.8175358176,
0.8139864802,
0.1299450696,
0.9133716822,
-0.2246189415,
0.3410409093,
-0.4641491473,
0.2984685898,
-0.3161482513,
0.4684887528,
-0.3612436652,
-1.2330540419,
-0.0281039942,
0.1532763392,
-0.30868119,
0.1244033277,
0.885106802,
0.8471003175,
0.2421516478,
0.5476027131,
-0.0484152585,
0.3700780272,
0.3599893749,
0.4912423491,
0.8257052898,
-0.5459524989,
0.1251397282,
-0.4351472557,
-0.3539921045,
-0.0944066495,
-0.7751490474,
-0.4151952565,
-0.6038411856,
-0.704107523,
-0.4835776687,
-0.2610746622,
1.1342697144,
0.5298906565,
-1.0311635733,
0.2238301933,
0.0581409261,
0.0835278556,
-0.3592209518,
-0.2562052906,
0.497572571,
-0.2677782476,
-0.7732802629,
0.1397640258,
0.5732123256,
-0.2640292645,
-0.2509100437,
0.371350795,
0.2133432329,
0.2584040463,
0.8547695279,
0.3082542419,
-0.553567946,
-0.6208834648,
-0.1915622205,
0.085338451,
0.3041795492,
0.7089937925,
-0.4038089216,
0.233545959,
0.4633586407,
0.4628851414,
0.4863646924,
0.1681130677,
0.5996055603,
-0.9804165959,
-0.2420250773,
0.1810584664,
0.6945000291,
0.32754457,
-0.3470674753,
0.1498440802,
0.1138720214,
-0.595273912,
-0.3761833012,
0.3557552695,
-1.1578108072,
-0.0957122743,
1.399774909,
-0.3146083057,
-0.5495631099,
-0.2483191043,
-0.1822532564,
0.056025587,
-0.7871657014,
0.7840473652,
0.439255029,
-0.5600207448,
-0.0650336593,
-0.1820120215,
0.5859445333,
0.295409888,
-1.1444872618,
0.1729357243,
0.9569538832,
0.2105586976,
0.1857209355,
0.468411088,
-0.3482943177,
0.1391395628,
-0.1623101532,
0.6544184685,
-0.0021152198,
-0.4789080024,
-0.6442368031,
0.5278907418,
0.3255432844,
-0.4615574181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16675v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16675v1
|
A Distribution-Based Threshold for Determining Sentence Similarity
| 2023-11-28T10:42:35 | 2023-11-28T10:42:35 |
Gioele Cadamuro, Marco Gruppo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We hereby present a solution to a semantic textual similarity (STS) problem
in which it is necessary to match two sentences containing, as the only
distinguishing factor, highly specific information (such as names, addresses,
identification codes), and from which we need to derive a definition for when
they are similar and when they are not. The solution revolves around the use of
a neural network, based on the siamese architecture, to create the
distributions of the distances between similar and dissimilar pairs of
sentences. The goal of these distributions is to find a discriminating factor,
that we call "threshold", which represents a well-defined quantity that can be
used to distinguish vector distances of similar pairs from vector distances of
dissimilar pairs in new predictions and later analyses. In addition, we
developed a way to score the predictions by combining attributes from both the
distributions' features and the way the distance function works. Finally, we
generalize the results showing that they can be transferred to a wider range of
domains by applying the system discussed to a well-known and widely used
benchmark dataset for STS problems.
|
[
-0.3959516883,
-0.6989478469,
0.8043847084,
0.3293891549,
-0.4509067237,
-0.267459929,
-0.087277472,
-0.2983566821,
0.4878545105,
0.4813448191,
-0.6409144402,
-0.4736376405,
-0.7291913033,
0.2227996588,
-0.8411865234,
0.6514844894,
0.0430981591,
-0.0512682348,
-0.4027538002,
-0.247627303,
-0.1688549817,
-0.4454535842,
-0.1488905996,
0.1116417721,
0.4119535685,
0.0831554681,
0.3550312817,
0.8415094614,
1.0557978153,
0.3414577842,
-0.2998749912,
-0.0892251506,
-0.2306306362,
0.3798624277,
-0.1057716757,
-0.5813427567,
0.2087127417,
-0.2658267915,
0.6854945421,
0.9842327237,
0.2524662018,
0.203583926,
0.2863994539,
0.5856144428,
-0.6028689146,
-0.1946817338,
-0.6360289454,
0.3615844846,
-0.120558694,
-0.357953757,
-0.2400488108,
-0.462453723,
0.3270484507,
-0.522741735,
0.5103591681,
0.0898655728,
0.9716831446,
0.2645765841,
-0.4058687687,
-0.3994005322,
-0.4098354578,
0.7510768771,
-0.104206875,
0.3289875984,
0.286242336,
-0.1435912997,
-0.0779360011,
-0.3559263647,
-0.5286282301,
-0.5128825903,
-0.1598422378,
-0.1708147079,
-0.2332918644,
-0.3894907534,
0.3301481009,
-0.0661885068,
-0.8312952518,
0.0284678172,
-0.4656965733,
-0.1771149635,
0.2741011679,
0.3400862813,
0.2273391634,
-0.5060850978,
-0.9769029617,
-0.2765742242,
-0.6344131827,
-0.1789600402,
0.3709121644,
0.2846156359,
-0.0344111957,
0.5037848949,
-0.322319895,
0.3037787378,
-0.3886025548,
0.3617058694,
0.5903915167,
-0.2048239112,
-0.0762956068,
0.1218584403,
0.7600542903,
0.6642469764,
0.4632131755,
0.1165637597,
-0.216666609,
0.348661691,
0.2510072887,
-0.4828138649,
-0.1804296374,
-0.3791621029,
-0.6988536119,
-0.4277754426,
0.2200300545,
-0.6532863379,
-0.4368265569,
-0.4246198833,
0.446582526,
-0.4627416432,
-0.1361661851,
-0.1836215258,
-0.5618064404,
-0.1062985212,
-0.1170267239,
-0.6264380813,
0.5090554357,
0.8441723585,
1.3509341478,
-0.3879499435,
-0.2781789899,
-0.3408485055,
-0.068954207,
-0.3430958688,
0.8827986121,
-0.6211138964,
-0.4194413126,
0.0798631012,
-0.2547935843,
-0.086720638,
-0.629473567,
0.4866689146,
-0.147018522,
-0.1185460016,
-0.1007463783,
-0.8694958687,
-0.0173135735,
0.4081720412,
-0.9386489987,
1.1131689548,
0.2257794142,
-1.0627624989,
0.3856820464,
-0.6174642444,
-0.4867285788,
0.354252696,
-0.1301787794,
-0.4012564123,
0.2066710889,
-0.2640357614,
0.6803624034,
-0.1323593557,
-0.1093808487,
-0.4412506819,
-0.3880265355,
0.34013924,
-0.3180952072,
0.9161697626,
0.2522717714,
-0.2254833728,
0.0757169425,
-0.8446552157,
0.0574565828,
-0.0274755117,
-0.0114544434,
-1.0973870754,
-0.0292108785,
0.1820319295,
-0.1131217554,
0.2146268487,
-0.5243700147,
-0.2649580538,
-0.3172387183,
0.5728754401,
0.8807277679,
0.1942342371,
0.4511987865,
-0.3355168998,
0.336358279,
0.3988941014,
0.032895457,
0.2218402624,
-0.4324575067,
-0.7022854686,
0.0256983191,
0.3645215034,
0.5992845893,
-0.5781159997,
0.8117468357,
-0.5437655449,
-0.5198611021,
-0.2454199195,
-0.0583800152,
0.316506952,
0.4850661159,
0.2712880671,
-0.5422390103,
-0.645899415,
-1.0212870836,
-0.0876936913,
-0.284560293,
-0.1325908303,
0.1389982998,
0.7605204582,
0.0370691381,
0.8828235865,
-0.8516070247,
-0.4094111621,
-0.1102754325,
-0.1042395234,
-0.1050840244,
0.5331557393,
0.5890599489,
-1.0434863567,
-0.5933206677,
-0.1390095949,
-0.6386083961,
-0.0365455672,
-0.0543058775,
-0.3053779006,
-0.3860462606,
0.7678794861,
-0.5598420501,
0.3716572225,
0.1616737247,
-0.4970361888,
0.4912377,
-0.1776022166,
0.1646880656,
-1.3186092377,
-0.0013776781,
0.4412512183,
0.0293822512,
-0.5654098988,
-0.0099920947,
-0.0251242928,
0.1845858544,
-0.4696843326,
0.532944262,
0.0831003711,
-0.0422637835,
0.0100089572,
0.4677709937,
-0.2043458223,
0.3209625781,
0.0043633659,
0.6061550379,
0.5907046795,
-0.7855940461,
0.4627350867,
0.5808558464,
-0.7034118176,
1.1277878284,
-0.6096795797,
-0.1761884391,
-0.0765429884,
0.0793382376,
-0.7001886368,
0.3534860015,
0.2288181931,
-0.5959464312,
-0.5807821155,
0.1426175535,
-0.2640052736,
-0.1988908798,
-0.3498172164,
0.4191383123,
0.5146171451,
-0.2456893176,
0.1274345368,
0.2251082808,
-0.2492030859,
-0.485937655,
-0.8130316138,
0.1426434517,
-0.506682992,
-0.3711552918,
0.4374943972,
-0.1340838522,
-0.4861543477,
0.4129171371,
0.2704436183,
-0.2466714978,
0.2819937468,
0.3731064796,
0.2172621042,
-0.3136217594,
0.5633874536,
-0.0052200835,
-0.2258490324,
0.1462830156,
-0.464351058,
0.3786393404,
0.328265518,
-0.0006194859,
-0.222362563,
0.7167311907,
0.17138125,
-0.1270039082,
0.6667944193,
0.4539493024,
-0.513204217,
-0.5993648767,
-0.1310149282,
-0.1914844364,
-0.3784658909,
0.5926061869,
-0.7484486103,
-0.890152216,
0.3847482502,
0.0289840214,
-0.4684440196,
0.6197134852,
0.4600506127,
-0.1142343953,
0.5362158418,
0.8101742864,
-0.0403508618,
0.529373467,
0.0386215486,
0.1468425393,
-0.776335001,
-0.1624138802,
-1.0472943783,
-0.430510819,
-0.646482408,
-0.2512385249,
0.19961375,
-0.1383012235,
-0.498087585,
0.7692430615,
-0.6332768202,
0.5954263806,
0.8942955732,
0.0420812294,
0.0182200316,
0.2328672707,
-0.5346266031,
-0.0069949375,
-0.2579809725,
-0.3994658887,
0.9249572754,
0.0363207422,
0.2748543322,
0.0344963782,
0.7438908219,
0.8075868487,
-0.1343799233,
-0.3956695497,
0.8898229003,
-0.5790786147,
-0.1528417021,
-0.3176322281,
-0.9368171096,
-0.999358356,
0.1712364554,
-0.2876700461,
-0.8468341231,
0.0387431048,
-0.6152074337,
-0.127548486,
0.1046506613,
-0.5421070457,
0.6900001764,
0.1782761961,
0.3293598592,
-0.1810394824,
-0.7973675132,
-0.1183585525,
0.0319862179,
-0.1432941556,
-0.4182707071,
-0.0728280842,
1.2031383514,
-0.3628367484,
0.5304485559,
-0.0133337229,
0.2611637712,
0.2568758428,
0.2306805104,
-0.0817180723,
-0.3064129651,
-0.1811590344,
0.1154823527,
0.3163576424,
-0.1923875064,
-0.6519131064,
0.86927104,
-0.7475141883,
-0.2576690614,
-0.2936387956,
-0.220332548,
-0.0074472493,
0.3596569896,
0.2135167569,
0.4838421941,
-0.2963408232,
0.3010585606,
0.3984049261,
0.1208062246,
0.4805284441,
0.4103935957,
0.4747365415,
-0.413513422,
0.8105316162,
-0.0805578306,
0.0585273132,
0.8240285516,
0.14483504,
-0.6155770421,
-0.3896635771,
-0.203489393,
-0.0475635678,
-0.9612719417,
-0.2837849259,
-0.5033136606,
-0.4406537414,
-0.288415581,
-0.2296806425,
0.1769687682,
-0.3488909602,
-0.3456032872,
-0.2375698239,
0.3739731312,
0.9232470393,
0.108444877,
0.0365500562,
-0.7135838866,
0.1559233516,
-0.1255792081,
0.5148404241,
-0.1092670411,
-0.4434752762,
-0.0641086027,
-0.1633502692,
-0.1062751934,
-0.7571161389,
0.267555356,
0.1920756698,
0.3866883218,
0.1915240437,
0.419492662,
0.5286876559,
-0.6630215049,
0.7082939148,
0.4418407977,
-1.0593019724,
0.5628225803,
0.2179717571,
-0.2241988331,
0.661976099,
0.5375886559,
-0.6147622466,
-0.5514962077,
-0.7090307474,
-0.5491290689,
0.1739065498,
0.5231484175,
0.4641812742,
-0.4251574874,
0.3292272091,
0.1174911931,
-0.0902327821,
-0.6160035133,
-0.123300761,
0.217490539,
-0.6992225051,
-0.1755254865,
0.0332435593,
0.0092959143,
0.1551748961,
0.3746967316,
-0.0176309925,
0.2935661077,
0.3932154477,
-0.2189646363,
0.0056167594,
0.2539075911,
0.5135369301,
0.4051521719,
0.2094012499,
0.5713123679,
0.2306531817,
-0.7372403741,
0.4400766194,
0.0664956123,
-0.3141028285,
0.1110707074,
0.452180624,
0.7037513256,
-0.0502046421,
-0.7162699699,
0.7174301744,
0.0254400261,
-0.4408319592,
-0.2059998363,
0.0305167641,
-0.061887145,
0.3207589984,
0.2717661262,
0.3124389946,
0.2641629279,
-0.2288429737,
0.7708287239,
0.2262888849,
-0.8746989369,
0.0806763247,
0.3999644518,
0.2034524083,
-0.7888142467,
0.7659053206,
-0.3552687764,
-0.7685895562,
0.9743537307,
0.4235363305,
0.8418843746,
0.0700070262,
0.4835783243,
0.3464049101,
0.0346125439,
-0.1814863682,
0.0569358841,
-0.0115954923,
-0.720541358,
0.089879103,
-0.8109874129,
0.0085760653,
-0.3180187345,
-0.6554822922,
0.3595710397,
-0.4009343386,
0.0096817724,
0.2603331208,
0.005406565,
-0.5253382921,
0.4012657702,
0.0774113908,
0.7978829741,
-1.0196151733,
0.4794769585,
0.3374568224,
-0.3599046767,
-0.5576481819,
-0.0429450423,
-0.132592991,
-0.594740212,
0.7260559797,
0.2509038448,
0.0336979255,
-0.2554742396,
-0.0851682127,
-0.5902173519,
0.9007675648,
0.1497544646,
-0.6572981477,
0.154463917,
0.3832348585,
0.6552653313,
-0.5362058282,
0.1445142478,
0.4792197943,
0.078264676,
-0.0179557968,
-0.7040285468,
0.1742648333,
-0.4400180876,
0.2031621188,
0.5494161844,
-0.2340040952,
0.7787806392,
0.0175107475,
-0.0792242959,
0.3651223779,
0.4209294021,
-0.0334828421,
0.3228423297,
0.915628016,
0.7675964832,
0.6774746776,
-0.0409813486,
0.540876925,
-0.2669709027,
0.726236105,
0.7566190958,
-0.5106764436,
1.2851151228,
0.2279927731,
-0.24584575,
0.6425322294,
0.5351860523,
-0.3989642859,
0.4371979237,
0.6195008755,
-0.2684399486,
-0.0984145254,
-0.4291370809,
-0.2392827123,
0.371444732,
0.1464775205,
-0.6606158614,
-0.1290868968,
0.1433388293,
-0.4093579948,
0.3796920478,
-0.1867243797,
0.9856495857,
0.1860128194,
-0.4639744759,
0.2589943409,
-0.0268072113,
0.4441211224,
-0.4939975441,
0.0170397144,
0.0565645471,
0.1522172391,
0.0335731842,
-1.1416854858,
0.4484744668,
-0.0382045582,
-0.2541801631,
-0.1144877225,
0.5682675838,
-0.3800740838,
-0.5837051272,
0.4247989655,
0.4629060626,
0.2046639174,
0.0205833279,
-0.7263589501,
0.0012148191,
-0.1132119,
0.1839161217,
0.1702474952,
0.6442155242,
-0.0424572192,
0.6614670753,
0.4024765193,
0.1597088873,
0.0925575197,
0.3306860328,
0.5018985868,
-0.8668346405,
-1.2404061556,
-0.9080070257,
0.0282108057,
-0.3324933946,
-0.7205890417,
0.4642187953,
0.5867139697,
0.7809400558,
-0.0704021454,
0.7555631995,
-0.0498959981,
0.6697995663,
-0.4963297248,
0.5349294543,
-0.5857616663,
0.1397864968,
-0.3750393093,
-1.3118057251,
-0.5401927829,
0.7135465145,
-0.2081104964,
-0.104706645,
1.1318032742,
0.8505837321,
0.0074758716,
0.0986790359,
0.3435636163,
-0.0360420533,
-0.0070780842,
0.8772266507,
0.9198415279,
-0.2652735114,
0.8201779127,
-0.0722014382,
-0.0271826107,
-0.1101614311,
-0.5536941886,
-0.835960567,
-1.2991548777,
-0.4405377209,
-0.3707239628,
0.2847522199,
0.774040103,
0.6307961345,
-0.636143446,
0.0411940254,
-0.3413259089,
0.170318976,
-0.3436198235,
-0.2022396624,
0.6524841785,
-0.1829215735,
-0.4159255922,
-0.2821438909,
0.3628258407,
0.0786894783,
-0.2026996762,
0.0565535463,
-0.0985544398,
0.1974883378,
0.3845557272,
-0.3610265553,
-0.5796972513,
-0.7851406932,
-0.0456041917,
-0.5333025455,
0.018504642,
0.9533998966,
-0.663523078,
0.0595251247,
0.595076263,
0.6883683205,
-0.0096271168,
-0.068437539,
0.1574257016,
-0.7696920633,
0.1201741472,
0.3454918861,
0.3600234389,
0.2897235155,
-0.2920475602,
0.4489432573,
0.4177214801,
-0.2951955795,
-0.6961852908,
0.4215148091,
-1.1217377186,
-0.281273216,
1.1365104914,
-0.357804656,
-0.2812024951,
-0.2159328163,
-0.0182012767,
-0.0473198146,
-0.1006621495,
0.7729406953,
0.7594835162,
0.3855940998,
-0.0666633844,
-0.0278741904,
0.4195967317,
0.4260743558,
-0.7768641114,
-0.095290415,
0.0429771803,
0.5146083236,
0.3501961231,
0.306545347,
0.1709489971,
0.1419533044,
0.4538976848,
-0.4178394079,
0.4627256989,
-0.3405482471,
-0.2553447485,
0.579026401,
-0.3496406674,
-0.3886624873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17107v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17107v1
|
ClimateX: Do LLMs Accurately Assess Human Expert Confidence in Climate Statements?
| 2023-11-28T10:26:57 | 2023-11-28T10:26:57 |
Romain Lacombe, Kerrie Wu, Eddie Dilworth
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.IR
|
Evaluating the accuracy of outputs generated by Large Language Models (LLMs)
is especially important in the climate science and policy domain. We introduce
the Expert Confidence in Climate Statements (ClimateX) dataset, a novel,
curated, expert-labeled dataset consisting of 8094 climate statements collected
from the latest Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) reports,
labeled with their associated confidence levels. Using this dataset, we show
that recent LLMs can classify human expert confidence in climate-related
statements, especially in a few-shot learning setting, but with limited (up to
47%) accuracy. Overall, models exhibit consistent and significant
over-confidence on low and medium confidence statements. We highlight
implications of our results for climate communication, LLMs evaluation
strategies, and the use of LLMs in information retrieval systems.
|
[
-0.2815793753,
-0.2389914244,
0.7884976864,
0.1204482391,
-0.0016436602,
0.4990601838,
-0.4072268903,
-0.3979756236,
-0.0899798498,
0.3427475989,
-0.1354530752,
-0.9257404804,
-0.9609662294,
0.2381994724,
-0.5802704692,
0.4633281827,
0.0280814227,
0.0605981499,
-0.5172017813,
0.3234538436,
-0.0712046027,
-0.4439686239,
-0.4566241801,
-0.2678595185,
0.4796485007,
0.620000422,
0.8817080855,
0.4060728252,
0.4032925069,
0.2768424153,
-0.21155563,
0.270237416,
-0.5560613871,
-0.2521086037,
-0.2687707543,
-0.4404523671,
-0.1824532598,
0.3210055232,
0.598780632,
0.5467526913,
-0.2907881141,
0.2272147983,
0.2149410397,
0.080863677,
-0.7399582267,
0.3595124483,
-0.8071570396,
-0.2332506329,
0.0641115084,
-0.1001824439,
-0.5997276902,
-0.1861312389,
0.1635083258,
-0.2509783506,
0.2412321717,
0.4998136759,
0.2517958283,
0.3488173187,
-0.5017736554,
-0.2284483612,
-0.4242076874,
0.8704447746,
-0.9002360702,
0.1234083027,
0.375007987,
0.1627050936,
-0.369474411,
-0.3421977162,
-0.9296374917,
-0.1333127469,
-0.03796345,
0.2034673542,
-0.1014687121,
-0.0627940074,
0.0502445698,
-0.0024050325,
-0.4032207727,
0.5020487309,
-0.1301808953,
-0.3052222133,
0.9046166539,
0.1982087046,
-0.2067907006,
-0.2100056857,
-0.4063803256,
-0.2976115644,
-0.7764090896,
-0.0650125369,
0.4103031754,
0.6467957497,
-0.1044864953,
0.457105428,
-0.3931101263,
0.7432958484,
-0.4172180891,
-0.3858504891,
-0.1265117526,
-0.1963319331,
-0.0834067464,
0.1392849237,
0.6612704992,
0.643645823,
0.1629592776,
-0.1999928653,
-0.2587617338,
-0.1506566256,
-0.0159512572,
-0.625457406,
-0.3750784397,
0.087317124,
-0.245399639,
-0.3985875249,
0.6018176079,
-0.6625047326,
-0.7088747621,
-0.2936032414,
0.1642712951,
0.445576638,
-0.2519049048,
0.0990758836,
-0.0502826907,
0.0797942206,
0.6431227326,
-0.2322150916,
0.4687298238,
0.7761880159,
0.5228796005,
-0.5145314932,
-0.2232992798,
-0.3561807871,
-0.2244356722,
-0.6308732629,
0.8633056879,
-0.951298058,
-0.6129780412,
-0.0148668829,
0.0317598134,
0.0904925987,
-0.4355383813,
0.2139393389,
-0.3999405205,
0.097284779,
-0.205158934,
-0.6151455641,
-0.0291585252,
-0.0923786238,
-0.2650238574,
0.8791642189,
0.0825688839,
-0.5275128484,
0.2951527238,
-0.110878177,
0.0000438677,
-0.0881746858,
-0.3034861684,
-0.2293590307,
-0.0199286006,
-0.0890757665,
0.5478590131,
-0.6975753307,
0.3603234291,
-0.4413498342,
-0.2091136277,
0.7177048326,
-0.5410826206,
0.3581553698,
0.1803261787,
-0.2363734692,
-0.0239205025,
-0.6638738513,
0.1112109497,
-0.1654637754,
-0.2898658216,
-0.1746141165,
0.0779485106,
-0.0397805087,
0.1067855805,
0.3390291929,
-0.7587590218,
0.2566120625,
0.1947830617,
0.4911995828,
0.9936392903,
-0.0875540897,
0.1295191348,
-0.212181136,
0.4884457588,
-0.0970324948,
-0.1093109027,
-0.0170135628,
-0.7189516425,
-0.5266333222,
0.1172118858,
0.3075787425,
0.6373271346,
-0.4327546358,
0.4995640814,
-0.3004273772,
-0.6903490424,
-0.1136268377,
0.1914378405,
0.3999061286,
0.7389224768,
0.297727108,
-0.0512977093,
-0.1294489503,
-0.8284645081,
-0.3202061355,
-0.3894442916,
0.04675873,
0.5319371223,
0.6511322856,
-0.1440561563,
1.1912513971,
-0.6780487299,
0.4354942441,
0.0488191135,
0.5155813098,
0.1766312867,
0.4168711603,
0.6040294766,
-0.7288225889,
-0.5995766521,
-0.1638879478,
-0.2503179908,
0.0453790091,
0.0947006866,
0.0999234468,
0.1932257563,
0.2606973946,
-0.4564567804,
0.5416193008,
0.4606420994,
-0.5079004765,
0.5353316665,
-0.1117516011,
0.3385750353,
-0.8235834837,
-0.1616441905,
0.2902420759,
-0.4500164986,
-0.4140002131,
-0.3333620727,
-0.080580838,
0.2726511061,
-0.3979811072,
0.8194329143,
-0.2829762697,
-0.1053029895,
-0.2917561829,
0.1240553558,
-0.1365192235,
0.1401033103,
0.3751820028,
0.8710746765,
0.5987829566,
-0.3030065596,
0.4157565832,
0.3600304723,
-0.6365277171,
0.3837494254,
-0.2906463742,
0.6157845259,
-0.1196621433,
0.2133222669,
-1.1504005194,
-0.490483582,
-0.0129134953,
-0.4144491255,
0.1954708844,
-0.052105438,
-0.5951268077,
-0.5966469646,
-0.0725568458,
-0.149919495,
0.465911299,
-0.5224890709,
0.3152102232,
0.3506105542,
-0.5065819621,
-0.7285053134,
-0.6510257721,
0.4126327038,
-0.0654397905,
-0.1043779552,
0.0125304582,
-0.3881461918,
-0.695266664,
-0.111554563,
-0.3849786222,
-0.2338865548,
0.2351218909,
0.1108402386,
0.2096562982,
0.0514084287,
0.0985513702,
-0.3262154758,
0.1425779015,
0.2424322218,
-0.0530209914,
0.0819362924,
-0.1857142746,
-0.2105345875,
-0.3483069241,
0.26448825,
0.3462205231,
0.5035171509,
0.7628663778,
0.2025354356,
-0.3781097531,
-0.010225418,
-0.6205202937,
-0.1667972654,
-0.4068489969,
0.3333368599,
-0.1613343507,
-0.8485339284,
0.3165574372,
-0.1354407221,
-0.1091145724,
0.5296930075,
0.2561536729,
-0.166252926,
1.1090573072,
0.8303354383,
-0.285893321,
-0.0883590057,
0.0791837946,
-0.0212353338,
-0.3352451622,
-0.4654514492,
-0.8080984354,
0.0760305747,
-0.4520328343,
-0.5013792515,
0.135142222,
-0.0674259812,
-0.4968934357,
0.1404672861,
-0.4557654858,
0.495323211,
0.5122586489,
0.2206898481,
0.3691731095,
-0.1016458794,
0.3193100095,
0.0317886956,
-0.5718126297,
-0.7852029204,
1.026792407,
0.2406678945,
1.0745532513,
0.1080956757,
0.3449290395,
0.7714098096,
0.4836363196,
-0.5869727135,
0.5522326827,
-0.018249711,
-0.2363496572,
-0.3518209457,
-0.6423941255,
-0.4487102628,
-0.0356032178,
-0.5066375136,
-0.7293615937,
0.4303477407,
0.1092618406,
-0.4923252761,
0.2978526652,
-0.6295452118,
0.3912742138,
-0.4416940212,
-0.0024038772,
-0.4333594739,
-0.7215034366,
-0.039528463,
-0.491089195,
0.2243870497,
-0.4036086202,
-0.345612824,
0.8189284205,
-0.4447392523,
1.1311177015,
-0.1859699339,
-0.1757344604,
0.3535719216,
-0.1068324521,
0.6781374812,
0.1609860957,
-0.4250770509,
0.3930295408,
0.0489096344,
-0.5031985044,
-0.4853581488,
0.6021745801,
-0.9442982674,
-0.8329617977,
-0.6136636734,
-0.299887836,
-0.3065223098,
0.147537142,
0.0437463038,
0.3626638353,
-0.2703644335,
0.1545502692,
0.550755322,
-0.285441637,
0.0359479114,
0.7613810897,
0.0588458516,
-0.3577235043,
0.6779299974,
0.1993194222,
0.2787974477,
0.3533138931,
0.4275883138,
-0.2889994383,
-0.727504611,
0.0522535853,
-0.062524803,
-0.9176658988,
-0.5072917342,
-0.2615075707,
-0.1439282447,
-0.5309288502,
-0.1072183475,
-0.2179318964,
-0.4171926975,
-0.3461130857,
-0.3732878864,
0.5184566975,
1.3360594511,
0.112508744,
0.6009784341,
-0.53828758,
-0.1355855614,
0.3426394165,
0.1897788197,
-0.519056797,
-0.4377970994,
-0.209194988,
0.2605428696,
0.1220774129,
-0.7105897069,
0.567679584,
0.2096983641,
0.721704185,
0.3420826495,
0.2968761921,
0.3849945962,
-0.0800050497,
0.9470472932,
0.1469676346,
-1.0004142523,
0.3194060326,
-0.0025667886,
0.2143170387,
0.375647217,
0.5494483113,
-0.3055528402,
-0.3620988131,
-0.6398487687,
-0.5471451283,
0.6060932279,
-0.0822462812,
0.0293098707,
-0.1050632149,
0.6340679526,
0.350138694,
0.5768002272,
-0.1713313162,
-0.2177769691,
-0.049466271,
-0.144914344,
-0.5815258026,
-0.4071131051,
-0.3778599203,
0.0496961288,
0.3874526024,
-0.5637922883,
0.136441946,
0.2489860505,
0.1379099935,
-0.024739543,
0.4144871533,
0.5710905194,
0.9327389002,
-0.2454064637,
0.4380950928,
0.4519803524,
-0.2785909176,
-0.0771659464,
-0.0796543658,
0.0769906193,
-0.2463511229,
0.4676131308,
0.6418125629,
0.162981078,
-0.7000970244,
0.5560269952,
-0.3081800044,
0.0070083966,
-0.2801822424,
0.0539488569,
-0.0880522728,
0.1352077723,
0.5629397035,
0.5579632521,
0.0737714991,
-0.4684463441,
0.0231718402,
0.2906399369,
-0.2016430348,
-0.2763661444,
0.6640608311,
0.2374974042,
0.0801313743,
0.8313701749,
0.1470477134,
-0.5239470005,
0.640824616,
0.2041334063,
0.6168436408,
0.0269508678,
0.1228077635,
0.3398008049,
0.2626749277,
-0.294672668,
0.325491786,
-0.1779206693,
-0.9072970152,
-0.3938061595,
-0.4780566096,
-1.0604939461,
-0.3005868793,
-0.623709023,
0.1225040853,
-0.3665124774,
-0.3831540942,
-0.318121016,
0.0896320939,
-0.7601468563,
0.2363520861,
0.3716452122,
1.3347537518,
-0.9813170433,
0.7900233865,
0.3446869552,
-0.0005421664,
-0.6199797988,
-0.0632592067,
0.2778963149,
-0.8654001355,
0.6782960892,
0.0621183552,
-0.4998291135,
-0.0328644775,
-1.4169139862,
-0.8218687177,
1.1303428411,
0.4492652416,
-0.6723575592,
0.2732242346,
0.1737342775,
0.3259339035,
-0.694180727,
0.381536901,
0.6452415586,
0.8515654802,
0.099864319,
-0.8648421168,
-0.0480262451,
-0.1676612198,
-0.0768529102,
-0.506516695,
-0.9247475863,
0.5512635112,
-0.4324959815,
-0.050887648,
0.1821423918,
0.961605072,
0.094848901,
0.2320417613,
0.6402282119,
0.1848268658,
1.200848341,
-0.3904280365,
1.183449626,
-0.5175058246,
0.2586142421,
1.1559169292,
-0.2812691033,
1.154790163,
0.1196832508,
-0.2236376107,
0.4649123847,
0.9696019292,
0.0316615999,
0.4079042971,
0.133460626,
-0.2043058276,
-0.7385053635,
-0.3217536807,
-0.0597867519,
0.2628617287,
0.6189731956,
0.0117883552,
0.1665988714,
-0.1382834315,
0.2107922286,
0.0822330192,
-0.4341105819,
0.682734549,
0.2519035339,
-0.738067627,
0.2543145716,
-0.1634537429,
0.6664619446,
-0.2985806167,
-0.1440072805,
0.0061234524,
-0.0042489595,
-0.4168595672,
-1.4235008955,
0.0663427562,
0.0728720203,
-0.0364243649,
-0.3491639793,
0.5677586198,
-0.5531052947,
-0.3974021971,
0.0331642665,
0.351790607,
0.4672804177,
0.0137568787,
-0.5387801528,
-0.1043123379,
-0.0049638492,
-0.3327189386,
0.1355293244,
-0.0518084355,
0.0638572872,
0.7765913606,
0.4205704033,
0.2112507969,
0.0542790741,
-0.0966745839,
0.6622211933,
-0.659361124,
-0.0709757283,
-0.4038182497,
0.0926913321,
-0.2664789855,
-0.2671214044,
0.8240302801,
0.4118142724,
0.7791885138,
0.0776531622,
1.2400509119,
0.1691669822,
0.6102025509,
-0.4858659804,
0.2928746939,
-0.2151489258,
0.2762607038,
0.0334215797,
-0.7925850749,
-0.2615019977,
0.3908380568,
-0.4884379506,
0.1193973944,
0.3478485048,
0.8345271945,
0.4484352767,
-0.0322786532,
0.3512139022,
0.6012877822,
0.1598178893,
0.144105792,
0.9115265012,
0.192598328,
0.4451894462,
-0.4253635705,
-0.2896514833,
-0.1393382698,
-1.1231635809,
-0.6310055852,
-0.3644780219,
-0.5681304336,
-0.3332605362,
0.0928088799,
1.1056457758,
0.7262370586,
-0.8944622874,
-0.1110606864,
0.1069996729,
0.0859747827,
-0.0028343091,
-0.2157274336,
0.3718085289,
0.1303663254,
-0.9376674294,
0.6485010386,
0.2603120208,
0.2214906812,
-0.5075106025,
-0.2693245411,
0.2310432494,
0.2553034127,
0.2793186605,
0.2369691581,
-0.6407607794,
-0.6067258716,
-0.0709918439,
-0.3192636073,
0.0214790683,
0.5365092754,
-0.7535077929,
0.4545817077,
0.6079454422,
0.3433577716,
0.2235356122,
0.1935099214,
0.5758402348,
-0.5555053949,
-0.1837567687,
0.0423361138,
0.4571227729,
0.5950605273,
-0.5330573916,
0.5644601583,
0.1374298334,
-0.7013881207,
-0.7447608709,
-0.1297032088,
-0.9488882422,
-0.2986079454,
1.2401777506,
-0.307041198,
-0.1348596662,
-0.2473774701,
-0.0983837843,
-0.4106877446,
-0.7123408318,
0.6119368076,
0.9053716063,
-0.2146849334,
-0.1499380767,
-0.4805571735,
0.2688426673,
-0.0429352894,
-0.6932420731,
0.2733162642,
0.2813837528,
0.3225239217,
0.1997979581,
0.369317621,
0.3466211557,
-0.085294947,
-0.0765195712,
0.122704275,
0.229810372,
-0.446110487,
-0.1503354609,
-0.0537728369,
0.4123605192,
0.5321535468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16650v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16650v1
|
Text2Tree: Aligning Text Representation to the Label Tree Hierarchy for Imbalanced Medical Classification
| 2023-11-28T10:02:08 | 2023-11-28T10:02:08 |
Jiahuan Yan, Haojun Gao, Zhang Kai, Weize Liu, Danny Chen, Jian Wu, Jintai Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Deep learning approaches exhibit promising performances on various text
tasks. However, they are still struggling on medical text classification since
samples are often extremely imbalanced and scarce. Different from existing
mainstream approaches that focus on supplementary semantics with external
medical information, this paper aims to rethink the data challenges in medical
texts and present a novel framework-agnostic algorithm called Text2Tree that
only utilizes internal label hierarchy in training deep learning models. We
embed the ICD code tree structure of labels into cascade attention modules for
learning hierarchy-aware label representations. Two new learning schemes,
Similarity Surrogate Learning (SSL) and Dissimilarity Mixup Learning (DML), are
devised to boost text classification by reusing and distinguishing samples of
other labels following the label representation hierarchy, respectively.
Experiments on authoritative public datasets and real-world medical records
show that our approach stably achieves superior performances over classical and
advanced imbalanced classification methods.
|
[
0.1814598143,
-0.3477229476,
0.2300774306,
-0.1563009322,
-0.2777167559,
0.6176106334,
0.2794326544,
-0.6274347901,
0.1320211142,
0.0667016432,
-0.5612182617,
-0.470176518,
-0.6971822381,
-0.0221428089,
0.0152703337,
1.1971030235,
-0.1094751135,
0.2928567231,
-0.5294108987,
-0.6761339903,
-0.3841500878,
-0.8109799027,
-0.4383262694,
-0.6424426436,
0.5043980479,
0.3970881104,
0.7171653509,
0.8465204239,
0.6593999267,
0.203258127,
-0.1433351785,
0.1797510386,
-0.2929985523,
0.1962543726,
-0.196746394,
-0.2808117568,
-0.4094820619,
-0.2078312635,
0.5756611824,
0.7079293728,
-0.0382673293,
-0.0368359499,
0.2271470726,
0.678712368,
-0.5483826995,
0.0151416436,
-0.5143451095,
0.4271443784,
-0.0869893655,
-0.3843249381,
-0.3377564549,
-0.1238487884,
0.0714732185,
-0.4216590226,
0.0604634993,
-0.0537750348,
0.7232084274,
0.6051847339,
-0.6565895081,
-0.386490941,
-0.2859690785,
0.5397529602,
-0.4975494146,
0.2600281835,
0.2787948251,
0.2687000334,
0.2455981225,
-0.7167788148,
-0.0102797123,
0.0810063928,
-0.2981190979,
0.3841462731,
-0.1244211346,
0.1051766053,
0.0449525751,
0.6690958142,
-0.4467198849,
0.550589025,
-0.0476555638,
-0.0248630326,
0.2255676687,
0.1344264448,
0.497309953,
0.1766590625,
-0.4491525888,
0.072682485,
-0.5501298308,
-0.0323868394,
-0.2215580046,
0.0254319422,
-0.0932015255,
0.467785567,
0.2499710619,
0.4299879074,
0.2438266426,
-0.1820165366,
0.8113127947,
-0.2147467136,
-0.4964123964,
0.4348984957,
0.5413227677,
0.413446784,
-0.1053680629,
-0.1206075102,
-0.0409518331,
0.1095030308,
0.3470847905,
-0.9162582159,
-0.1746875048,
0.304669559,
-0.5119020939,
-0.4918225706,
-0.4402704239,
-0.5610447526,
-0.6766924858,
-0.1887528449,
-0.0148807848,
-0.283963263,
-0.079627201,
-0.058540646,
0.0874744356,
-0.16909419,
0.2746817768,
-1.0747821331,
0.4085925519,
0.7139074206,
0.8814515471,
-0.0541974269,
0.0506465249,
-0.483469069,
0.3407979608,
-0.41569978,
0.4736204147,
-0.5575426817,
0.0176191628,
-0.0848302469,
-0.092474103,
0.167198509,
-0.6740040183,
0.6057203412,
-0.1968441755,
0.2615306675,
0.1100772098,
-0.5874577761,
0.0125498166,
0.3636296988,
-0.4890290797,
1.0607540607,
0.3974332213,
-1.2554733753,
0.4332385659,
0.0113321533,
-0.6724215746,
0.2703072131,
-0.5649570227,
-0.9155476093,
0.0827552974,
0.2619388998,
0.3651049733,
-0.4182320535,
0.5608146191,
-0.1873629242,
-0.1239836812,
0.0280738752,
-0.4246013761,
0.9277535677,
0.1217675209,
-0.2302332669,
-0.1974782795,
-0.5420420766,
0.128239572,
-0.0691242814,
-0.4216019213,
-0.7353820801,
0.0907748416,
0.0928267017,
0.2333312929,
-0.0234683193,
-0.4915236235,
0.583137691,
-0.7383984327,
0.4886667728,
0.3333131969,
-0.0658792481,
0.2595033944,
-0.353323698,
0.307970643,
0.3542439044,
-0.1782003045,
-0.2903158963,
-0.4884904921,
-0.3419641852,
-0.2429266274,
0.5319200754,
0.7333743572,
-0.4767676294,
0.4346339703,
-0.4375189245,
-0.1364816427,
-1.0246818066,
0.0317475982,
0.6251292229,
0.8056932092,
0.6946648359,
-0.3359237313,
-0.4935564101,
-0.9171452522,
-0.1410496235,
-0.3017419577,
0.0366742797,
0.3007759452,
0.3449671865,
-0.7938306928,
0.7076240778,
-0.3190239668,
-0.5699316859,
0.0773407817,
0.2277155071,
-0.0280926377,
0.7589578629,
0.6507961154,
-0.8726617694,
-0.5332331657,
0.4887425303,
-0.6905242205,
-0.2247636467,
-0.1229374483,
0.2886830568,
0.310433805,
0.6080573201,
-0.1735007614,
0.0851855054,
0.4182682037,
-0.1636418104,
-0.2170103341,
-0.3036376238,
-0.0071489443,
-1.2776709795,
-0.0037376215,
0.0195198376,
-0.4039735794,
-0.5106673241,
-0.0044278037,
0.4884482026,
0.182400167,
-0.1851057261,
0.5302242041,
-0.419029206,
0.0442072637,
-0.1708424389,
-0.2644452751,
0.1147487834,
0.2207221836,
0.0583038703,
0.3825064898,
0.5432161093,
-0.2489492893,
0.1408236623,
0.1757948995,
-0.1933677346,
0.8045133948,
-0.2805870473,
-0.0953743458,
-0.3974497318,
0.5023708344,
-1.0065238476,
-0.2907584012,
0.4393657744,
-0.6278018951,
0.6193016768,
-0.2081345767,
-0.4575067461,
-0.5059213042,
-0.2900082767,
0.8622239232,
0.685654819,
-0.6848667264,
0.3211193681,
0.7001139522,
0.0993828177,
-0.7093239427,
-1.2286121845,
0.0208038744,
-0.0877770707,
-0.1691219062,
0.8093301654,
0.1582508683,
0.0143557759,
0.2607935369,
-0.4712700546,
-0.3085501194,
0.0978402495,
0.3324677348,
-0.1426900923,
-0.3391669095,
0.568295002,
0.4567365646,
-0.3230005503,
-0.1084735468,
-0.544988215,
0.0650973842,
0.3337321281,
-0.3290335536,
-0.6716663837,
0.4622698128,
0.5414309502,
-0.0256193914,
0.3152851164,
0.2463941574,
-0.8312552571,
-0.0060770679,
-0.0563627593,
0.1154592186,
-0.4134070277,
0.6926030517,
-0.1790733337,
-0.7445835471,
0.0495723002,
-0.199322015,
0.1763431579,
0.5168858171,
0.6511443853,
-0.3537615836,
1.1719939709,
0.3772646785,
-0.2573633194,
-0.0617414825,
0.031610705,
-0.0532880798,
-0.7383169532,
-0.5067267418,
-0.5326398611,
-0.5524019003,
-0.4290171564,
-0.5163535476,
0.1757323742,
0.2120418698,
-0.4603534639,
-0.0967894197,
-0.8760797977,
0.583181262,
0.2910043895,
0.1359721124,
0.2936525941,
0.2874524295,
-0.2765134275,
-0.232922107,
-0.6927260756,
-0.103781946,
0.8243703246,
0.6718625426,
0.6518667936,
-0.0400994942,
0.6944513917,
0.331648767,
0.709405303,
-0.8967938423,
-0.1102963313,
-0.5268519521,
-0.4365437925,
0.2772010565,
-0.4583078623,
-0.8518654108,
0.3953080475,
-0.1321814209,
-0.6979660988,
0.1390761137,
0.2613809109,
-0.1343320459,
0.3418327272,
-0.5915644765,
0.7459468842,
-0.5221878886,
-0.1665031016,
0.0585218184,
-0.7721728086,
0.0608108267,
-0.100459978,
0.2227384895,
0.1158599332,
-0.3412803113,
0.5058871508,
-0.4580526948,
0.9488865733,
-0.078926675,
-0.2313590199,
0.0503887869,
-0.1343788952,
0.3759189546,
0.1820532978,
0.1448696703,
-0.0272740107,
-0.0817584693,
-0.4351793528,
-0.4551150203,
0.7655228972,
-0.847659409,
-0.3035575747,
-0.7659934759,
-0.2937419116,
-0.4633928835,
0.1796325594,
0.4249263406,
0.4676221609,
0.0261594988,
0.4235168099,
0.4902979136,
-0.0699267238,
0.1115379706,
0.17064026,
0.0194256995,
-0.7788193226,
0.8065640926,
0.2317508459,
0.1256596297,
0.9603068233,
0.1363616139,
-0.2787804306,
-0.4943484366,
-0.7198767662,
-0.227432102,
-0.7741302252,
-0.4752300084,
-0.936544776,
-0.3199804723,
-0.1972601116,
-0.2511771917,
-0.1166021079,
-0.3218884468,
-0.3953036666,
-0.3639475405,
0.1201039255,
0.6481737494,
0.228505969,
0.3396295309,
-0.5889217854,
0.4580441415,
0.0759582371,
0.3746534884,
0.0980281532,
-0.2039976865,
-0.2172612697,
0.0578537248,
-0.4317451715,
-0.8916144371,
0.0306818075,
0.1103221402,
0.4268070757,
0.443410188,
0.0364606529,
0.5716494918,
-0.5014716387,
0.3377935588,
0.5717694759,
-0.7258998752,
0.3379326165,
0.0120046949,
0.3737562597,
0.8104194403,
0.3715808094,
-0.634164989,
-0.3405637145,
-0.5077707171,
-1.0280230045,
0.7126130462,
0.2604827881,
-0.0036479833,
0.2000313401,
0.4667798281,
0.1307062358,
0.0700293854,
-0.927598238,
-0.3830034137,
-0.1245636046,
-0.99686414,
-0.0685392991,
-0.2963325381,
-0.0520210899,
-0.4952613115,
0.4000633359,
-0.2183890939,
-0.0885406658,
0.3196457028,
-0.0421878919,
-0.1105216444,
0.11438936,
0.0677755997,
0.1165193915,
-0.0927989855,
0.5377778411,
0.1190051734,
-0.6569781303,
0.4973194003,
0.1069672108,
-0.3357692957,
-0.0708727166,
0.5772641301,
0.5946016312,
0.2439419329,
-0.6266210079,
0.4788502455,
0.1085799336,
-0.4328829944,
0.3164100051,
-0.2565269172,
0.2338369787,
0.0121260621,
0.3660301268,
0.2708808184,
0.2842886448,
-0.4510212839,
0.4873633683,
0.4028482139,
-0.9056144357,
0.0196402781,
0.6364111304,
0.3273926377,
-0.3036682904,
0.4095659256,
0.0927902833,
-0.3893493414,
0.8394788504,
0.75728333,
0.8236393332,
-0.3043063879,
0.301646769,
0.2439728826,
0.3881933987,
0.0304436535,
-0.0937080532,
-0.0969668105,
-0.2889629006,
-0.1923372447,
-0.3367959559,
-0.2719917297,
0.2422235757,
-0.4365563989,
0.2274065763,
-0.4638080001,
0.05830428,
0.2882511616,
-0.0308374036,
-0.1603483409,
0.5649133921,
0.2156005949,
0.7034369707,
-0.7074116468,
0.9496719837,
0.823073864,
-0.0947325975,
-0.3747313619,
0.3963683844,
0.1468592882,
-0.6400882006,
0.3832350075,
0.7961741686,
-0.0258149803,
-0.1075712219,
-0.2536310852,
-0.6150192022,
0.7634211183,
0.2733813822,
-0.804363966,
-0.0876795426,
0.1264395416,
0.7422012687,
-0.5346556306,
0.1827112436,
0.1793906391,
0.0912196487,
0.2024957687,
-0.5148861408,
0.089487344,
-0.5309647918,
-0.1312213838,
0.2709702551,
-0.3062561452,
0.592582345,
-0.1185699105,
-0.3668204546,
-0.0602204762,
0.1987803876,
0.1752912551,
0.675287962,
0.186992988,
0.8397699594,
1.057215333,
0.0078657903,
0.8980637789,
-0.1195594594,
0.4768103063,
1.2154884338,
-0.3295327425,
0.4259566963,
0.2727259099,
-0.1056410596,
0.2783393562,
0.9662752151,
-0.0101088239,
0.5536136031,
0.2703178525,
-0.1038970798,
-0.1306781471,
-0.0846008137,
-0.7517871857,
-0.0572397746,
0.4036305845,
-0.5150120854,
-0.4493685365,
0.1357476711,
-0.0649419203,
0.1114052758,
-0.4334683418,
1.0088740587,
0.1275739968,
-0.5596531034,
0.7315786481,
0.0006077178,
0.5298840404,
-0.1366961002,
-0.1151290685,
-0.0405915305,
0.6094709039,
-0.3700961173,
-0.7946695685,
0.2121414691,
-0.3151150644,
-0.3746469915,
-0.2355580628,
0.528000176,
-0.4715091884,
-0.7225811481,
0.4727185071,
0.010983333,
-0.2259706706,
0.2971000075,
-0.8653630614,
-0.2082532048,
0.0687902719,
0.1173858568,
0.2998672724,
0.7401595712,
-0.3079568148,
0.6113600731,
0.1371718645,
-0.2287019938,
-0.3853838146,
-0.0918264538,
0.8326696157,
-0.4949576557,
-0.7341687679,
-1.1013474464,
0.3067916334,
-0.1086512804,
-0.4146939218,
0.2829410434,
0.8513880372,
0.6060820818,
0.1483335197,
0.8353427649,
0.2714062035,
0.6395871639,
-0.4730531573,
0.5035133362,
-0.9423775077,
0.2165655196,
-0.1991799623,
-0.4581668377,
-0.7249676585,
0.3593243062,
0.2120205909,
-0.0892727599,
0.7653976083,
0.1934632808,
-0.2232775241,
-0.0701676384,
-0.1217274442,
0.2774130106,
0.1163236052,
0.9669369459,
0.5325920582,
-0.3087815046,
0.2394607216,
-0.0165722538,
-0.4729482532,
-0.4863674641,
-0.5845252872,
-0.8503571153,
-0.5895177722,
-0.534511447,
-0.4872085452,
0.1910057664,
0.8246657252,
0.6546316147,
-0.8023287058,
0.2936585546,
-0.427413404,
0.2223568708,
-0.2410641909,
-0.0828596726,
0.5955376029,
-0.239190042,
-0.5099027157,
-0.0179613177,
0.4864813685,
0.3638686538,
0.1523990184,
-0.097724162,
-0.025438169,
-0.2832841575,
0.3692667186,
0.2209143192,
-0.5637454987,
0.1985643059,
-0.3544435501,
-0.6225216389,
0.5554145575,
0.9051045179,
-1.0620156527,
0.3999914825,
0.4306530952,
1.0389257669,
0.1806850582,
0.3274479806,
0.1493719071,
-0.8452795148,
0.2090079635,
0.6234251261,
0.1432179213,
0.2991377115,
-0.4926938415,
0.3821062148,
0.1809724867,
-0.1923895776,
-0.9570702314,
0.2261323631,
-0.9407281876,
-0.682582736,
0.9783015251,
0.1130211055,
-0.0642583817,
-0.170521155,
-0.5517541766,
0.105515413,
-0.1539208293,
0.5106441975,
0.2883533239,
0.0560995229,
-0.1392496228,
-0.324498415,
0.713429749,
0.5499511957,
-0.8516255617,
0.113437131,
0.376095593,
0.0285845548,
0.2273975462,
0.9466002584,
-0.261403352,
0.0448632836,
-0.3174083829,
-0.1948639601,
0.1386574507,
-0.323020339,
-0.3682593405,
0.3103019595,
-0.2423270196,
-0.209276706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16639v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16639v2
|
Scaling Political Texts with Large Language Models: Asking a Chatbot Might Be All You Need
| 2023-11-28T09:45:02 | 2024-05-13T14:16:05 |
Gaël Le Mens, Aina Gallego
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We use instruction-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT-4, MiXtral,
and Llama 3 to position political texts within policy and ideological spaces.
We directly ask the LLMs where a text document or its author stand on the focal
policy dimension. We illustrate and validate the approach by scaling British
party manifestos on the economic, social, and immigration policy dimensions;
speeches from a European Parliament debate in 10 languages on the anti- to
pro-subsidy dimension; Senators of the 117th US Congress based on their tweets
on the left-right ideological spectrum; and tweets published by US
Representatives and Senators after the training cutoff date of GPT-4. The
correlation between the position estimates obtained with the best LLMs and
benchmarks based on coding by experts, crowdworkers or roll call votes exceeds
.90. This training-free approach also outperforms supervised classifiers
trained on large amounts of data. Using instruction-tuned LLMs to scale texts
in policy and ideological spaces is fast, cost-efficient, reliable, and
reproducible (in the case of open LLMs) even if the texts are short and written
in different languages. We conclude with cautionary notes about the need for
empirical validation.
|
[
-0.3259292245,
-0.6785732508,
0.5577498674,
0.2367544174,
-0.125428021,
0.161933586,
-0.6773107648,
-0.0894286036,
0.3272661567,
0.7881765962,
-0.3398077786,
-0.5209305286,
-0.8049018383,
-0.0680431277,
-0.2428362519,
0.9819859266,
0.2082489878,
0.0950689837,
-0.1110692695,
-0.1059103534,
-0.0948757082,
-0.5812217593,
-0.4716571867,
-0.4780654907,
0.7216095924,
0.5591726899,
0.882152915,
0.7759320736,
0.5336946249,
0.3315172493,
-0.2776254117,
0.0030470956,
-0.5975719094,
-0.0139990319,
-0.4044454098,
-0.6967603564,
-0.3155916333,
0.2230568528,
0.7677639723,
0.4166365266,
-0.0167812873,
0.0290459786,
0.0868891329,
0.4331573844,
-0.3928576708,
0.3037005365,
-0.9912741184,
-0.3494545519,
-0.1259944737,
-0.1814049631,
-0.5190229416,
-0.4859857559,
-0.0582247563,
-0.1637045592,
-0.0904532671,
0.0860297978,
0.8434010148,
0.0604209006,
-0.6606243849,
-0.5311498046,
-0.6275327206,
0.9594610929,
-0.650593698,
0.1581175625,
0.378739804,
0.1819002479,
-0.2726926208,
-0.7112621665,
-0.6070758104,
-0.2388653159,
-0.091696851,
-0.0694130361,
-0.0980760232,
0.2149941623,
0.0063441996,
0.2623496652,
-0.3936101496,
0.3450933993,
-0.1870953888,
-0.2128133029,
0.7949874401,
0.1455342919,
0.0187612567,
-0.3395241201,
-0.2378139049,
-0.3414030373,
-0.701300621,
-0.2244880646,
0.7694087625,
0.5972985625,
-0.1904174984,
0.7255195379,
0.0368892923,
0.5581439137,
0.0890321136,
0.0684580207,
-0.0350340903,
-0.4559021294,
0.1440391988,
-0.2082232535,
1.016029954,
0.3773670793,
0.3715645373,
0.3217281401,
-0.0747266337,
-0.0398283899,
0.2489899099,
-0.9273023605,
-0.1169384569,
0.2027947158,
-0.2801856697,
-0.2364108562,
-0.3730029166,
-0.9695038199,
-0.6276077032,
-0.4218352437,
0.2618656754,
-0.2584008873,
-0.1259420663,
-0.105618611,
0.0483261868,
0.5051237345,
0.2128180116,
-1.0613387823,
-0.0775222778,
1.0020933151,
0.8159952164,
0.0458723456,
-0.037573576,
-0.077664718,
0.0394043885,
-0.6213473678,
1.0018876791,
-0.9907506108,
-0.2909025252,
0.4076566994,
-0.0876440927,
0.0132850287,
-0.3609190285,
0.4020292163,
-0.3834056854,
0.4707533419,
-0.3780152798,
-0.7744285464,
0.1338482201,
0.5657508969,
-0.4908356965,
0.8365781307,
-0.0649055764,
-0.7064751387,
0.3118275702,
-0.8052639961,
-0.2330672145,
-0.1699538231,
-0.4200500548,
-0.2373556495,
-0.1802413017,
0.2127770483,
0.7495397925,
-0.2961914241,
0.2901341915,
-0.1493017375,
-0.0950066,
0.3365790248,
-0.5187674165,
0.770506084,
0.0163644962,
-0.1543819457,
0.5161392093,
-0.6425077319,
0.0378178731,
-0.0890699401,
-0.3740761578,
-0.2622928619,
0.3487965465,
0.1396863908,
-0.0125885075,
0.6113750339,
-0.5202450752,
0.4259996712,
-0.5570793152,
0.7281377316,
0.9129117131,
-0.0326936096,
0.5253744721,
-0.2090338618,
0.4735512733,
-0.4142834842,
-0.0269435123,
-0.0945897102,
-0.3998400271,
-0.694868207,
-0.2351918817,
0.2294017524,
0.6592463255,
-0.514223218,
0.5328550339,
-0.3664169908,
-0.6951380968,
-0.3552247882,
-0.1147166863,
0.1299967468,
-0.0557474233,
0.1527898163,
0.2392994463,
-0.2864439189,
-1.0091272593,
-0.5438084006,
-0.5872669816,
-0.3300424814,
0.3266218007,
0.6509621143,
-0.0882935375,
0.8816873431,
-0.4928773642,
-0.1824693084,
-0.2802505791,
0.2441672981,
0.0799512267,
0.0373340324,
0.2219137698,
-0.7916095257,
-0.6127473116,
0.1529432386,
-0.0983071029,
-0.1439418048,
-0.1372372508,
-0.0907676294,
0.2204792649,
0.4052986503,
-0.4194006622,
0.0597344488,
0.7758886218,
-0.4189096093,
0.1401386857,
-0.2359809279,
0.1927842498,
-1.5627689362,
-0.1983176172,
0.010473473,
-0.2833907604,
-0.5884162188,
0.0715243816,
0.0523929819,
0.0635048375,
-0.4732546806,
0.5250239372,
-0.1160568297,
0.1968175322,
-0.2688141763,
0.2400837392,
-0.3098447621,
0.3222817779,
-0.0263685379,
0.7713256478,
0.1646424383,
-0.0686634034,
0.2071725875,
0.0731214136,
-0.3799605072,
0.818784833,
-0.4929241538,
0.2708064914,
-0.0115341842,
0.5658979416,
-1.1116433144,
-0.445467025,
0.0953298584,
-0.1245959476,
0.2431140542,
-0.1142645627,
-0.5860896707,
-0.2131198645,
-0.21667853,
-0.1363638341,
0.3800930381,
-0.3801676035,
0.4482139647,
0.7825244069,
-0.1751056314,
-0.455845952,
-0.3323635757,
0.1720052361,
-0.483889997,
-0.327016443,
0.1599934101,
0.1646489203,
-0.4281024933,
-0.1148866937,
0.1547677815,
-0.2118531615,
-0.3193055391,
0.1878703237,
-0.0342831798,
-0.1315647662,
0.2591432929,
-0.0870528817,
0.1011792272,
0.001251095,
-0.2878443599,
0.7055554986,
-0.303525269,
-0.0570216179,
-0.3872471154,
0.4442242682,
0.6366778612,
-0.0494331904,
0.7964984179,
0.3120380342,
-0.1997477412,
-0.0870812386,
-0.538515985,
-0.162942484,
-0.5115050673,
0.4502982199,
-0.0104652662,
-1.0764023066,
0.406922847,
-0.2368768305,
0.5266071558,
0.574513793,
1.0511186123,
0.0354941636,
0.9234799147,
0.752245605,
-0.2710607052,
0.4506368339,
-0.0997114927,
0.2775778174,
-0.2424235642,
-0.1277794987,
-0.9208791256,
-0.3804230988,
-0.8334951401,
-0.8692451119,
0.2842406631,
-0.4090487361,
-0.4266320765,
0.3731708229,
-0.6177062988,
0.8265119195,
0.2634018958,
-0.1868593544,
-0.0267109461,
0.0934428498,
0.3106958866,
-0.134505257,
-0.5647224188,
-0.8576750159,
1.042349577,
0.5400509834,
0.8039847612,
-0.1683456302,
0.4694229364,
0.1579261869,
0.6463364363,
-0.850476563,
0.6542878747,
-0.4193738103,
-0.8013306856,
-0.6936588287,
-0.5084965825,
-0.8130081892,
0.3018575907,
-0.1503831595,
-0.7306309938,
-0.0515717492,
0.077892445,
0.0759211183,
0.5619932413,
-0.4895968437,
0.6459872723,
-0.1893225312,
-0.0445521511,
-0.5349861979,
-0.5845516324,
-0.0279041491,
0.0076514231,
0.3919792473,
-0.3582586944,
-0.3593133092,
0.8914429545,
-0.2391521186,
1.0717840195,
-0.1002108157,
-0.4650081396,
0.1825680435,
-0.2902202606,
0.4264534712,
-0.1934126467,
-0.1888098121,
0.4202873111,
0.2232008278,
-0.4107939899,
-0.5143551826,
0.7605420351,
-1.057312727,
-0.6172224283,
-0.1453123093,
-0.8645180464,
-0.2415990084,
0.1353972256,
0.2378288358,
0.1325056255,
-0.3804402053,
0.6341305375,
0.3484636843,
-0.1303182691,
0.2441351116,
0.3440040946,
-0.0752465278,
-0.3997004628,
0.8749814034,
0.4829711914,
0.3477507532,
0.7259438038,
0.534352541,
-0.3682486713,
-0.1670261323,
-0.3305429518,
0.211875692,
-0.5507302284,
-0.181998983,
-0.5473094583,
-0.1719269305,
-0.2352563292,
-0.4594801664,
-0.6634228826,
-0.4885748327,
-0.2071252316,
0.1266333163,
0.5800082088,
0.8714677691,
0.0172389951,
0.7038724422,
-0.2395641506,
-0.0880078301,
0.0450391769,
0.4066066146,
-0.467826575,
-0.5650478601,
-0.167547062,
0.1413862407,
-0.5235925317,
-1.065114975,
0.1787101179,
0.2049034238,
0.1715560704,
0.3914343715,
0.1143556014,
0.5090429187,
-0.8271025419,
1.0327130556,
0.0589610338,
-0.7773025632,
0.4721130133,
-0.540751338,
0.1313981712,
0.3969280124,
0.7046403885,
-0.4520340562,
-0.8256853819,
-0.4669806659,
-0.9244683385,
0.453161329,
0.1118537933,
0.8155483007,
-0.1343571097,
0.3081188202,
-0.0753441304,
0.0436987169,
-0.5107848644,
-0.0846028551,
-0.0525293313,
-0.3552301228,
-0.3522337377,
-0.3114615083,
-0.2633601129,
0.0336268917,
0.5471639037,
-0.281149894,
0.0136450082,
-0.144457072,
0.4821927845,
0.0618396103,
0.6279879808,
0.4966441691,
0.8328576684,
-0.0262206793,
-0.0420967825,
0.1171470806,
-0.2570017576,
0.3688880503,
-0.1685515493,
0.0980490521,
-0.0335176252,
0.3193537891,
0.567553103,
0.1468127221,
-0.4341240823,
0.513644278,
0.0093526505,
-0.4799995124,
-0.2890621722,
0.0088293897,
0.4591958225,
0.3288276196,
0.0281158201,
-0.6102993488,
-0.3745717406,
-0.6957940459,
0.1481000185,
0.6163825989,
-0.3993244171,
-0.118615672,
0.6642632484,
0.3749217987,
-0.7522041798,
0.3478659987,
0.1543682814,
-0.514878571,
0.4492688477,
0.4596078098,
0.5969174504,
-0.3602633774,
0.427555114,
0.1989944279,
0.5464283824,
0.0645141602,
0.2175584286,
0.2001729757,
-0.6710226536,
-0.4985210001,
-0.4496052265,
-0.8833076954,
0.3431745172,
-0.4403815866,
0.2433216125,
-0.606841445,
-0.3707469702,
0.1483442932,
0.5075867772,
-0.3927719891,
-0.1924526691,
0.0122458739,
0.9045376778,
-1.0707780123,
0.6924204826,
0.555408895,
0.1077176407,
-0.6991074681,
0.198429957,
0.1187091917,
-0.6945258379,
0.2581802011,
0.0136954747,
0.1260724068,
-0.1716259569,
-0.7444204092,
-0.5864875913,
0.7417820096,
0.5001100898,
-0.8209820986,
-0.1523959339,
0.4162229598,
0.6315187812,
-0.3022714257,
0.208748877,
0.5384503603,
0.4904772341,
0.0084200148,
-0.7472208142,
-0.1904037595,
0.2044153064,
-0.1562151611,
0.4672541916,
-0.9613133073,
0.6940940022,
0.2949046791,
0.0415920503,
-0.1315520406,
0.793263793,
-0.0697613508,
0.089796111,
0.6226242185,
0.1210690215,
0.9609615803,
-0.0190161616,
0.9939648509,
-0.5686478615,
0.2047869563,
0.8086766005,
-0.265634805,
1.0567601919,
0.5685045123,
-0.1905646771,
0.473616451,
0.6377057433,
0.1415279955,
0.1517303884,
0.4504425228,
-0.1877031922,
-0.198846668,
-0.249083966,
-0.1549266279,
0.5803218484,
0.6843647957,
-0.2475414425,
-0.2759861648,
-0.0761177167,
0.301117003,
0.4706033766,
-0.2233110368,
0.7195951343,
0.0764617622,
-0.6603633761,
0.3209423423,
0.0521877892,
0.494882971,
-0.5840777159,
-0.0013445077,
-0.2152732164,
0.1782287955,
0.0901374295,
-1.1014436483,
0.3313200176,
0.3163312674,
-0.0526954532,
-0.4978408217,
0.4670274854,
-0.5273714662,
-0.699727416,
0.1278740615,
0.3183744252,
0.3434223831,
0.162675187,
-0.6280086637,
0.1454261988,
-0.0043178564,
-0.5244215131,
0.3935190141,
0.6060583591,
-0.1963543296,
0.5309661031,
0.5198272467,
0.2648886144,
-0.2304131091,
-0.0833060741,
0.823141396,
-0.3684436977,
-0.4271644652,
-0.9056910276,
0.1496060491,
-0.2459923923,
-0.3577810824,
0.6490309834,
0.4473816752,
0.8136103749,
0.3563178778,
0.6082757711,
-0.0799480826,
0.525829196,
-0.4113754928,
0.9353292584,
-0.4698417187,
0.1302085817,
0.1055764258,
-0.8531377912,
-0.3453098238,
0.6959568262,
-0.6569359899,
-0.2166021913,
0.322845906,
1.1754983664,
0.1235819086,
0.0008643477,
0.3338532746,
0.3401916921,
0.5975738168,
0.3433612883,
0.7586318254,
0.122078307,
0.7650690675,
-0.1036432609,
-0.2327832878,
-0.0219782405,
-0.8850637674,
-1.173148036,
-0.7516072989,
-0.3506238759,
-0.372951299,
0.1356517822,
1.0389260054,
0.7725580931,
-0.4514576197,
-0.5009452701,
0.2130863369,
0.1855143309,
0.3017997444,
-0.2242030054,
0.4543687701,
-0.3277980089,
-1.0239416361,
0.0683121905,
0.221430853,
-0.2861379981,
-0.5867091417,
0.3282605112,
-0.246739462,
0.7654390335,
0.5866263509,
0.1001189873,
-0.7927361727,
-0.7405000329,
-0.220922038,
-0.334330976,
0.014625866,
0.8864645958,
-0.3014699519,
0.1769160479,
0.5630248189,
0.5707907677,
0.1223734245,
-0.0799259171,
0.5102363229,
-0.7354933023,
0.1933465898,
0.3503507674,
-0.0689428002,
0.344715327,
-0.1709022522,
0.4090664387,
-0.2576816976,
-0.9416545033,
-0.7865317464,
0.2218244523,
-0.7035993338,
-0.3088261187,
1.5257196426,
-0.0154475188,
-0.2514775991,
0.2076433003,
-0.3041148484,
0.0463957228,
-0.2213021666,
0.6988303661,
0.8990074396,
0.1278039068,
-0.0589227937,
-0.6478843093,
0.3396324515,
0.2371879667,
-0.7831603885,
0.3717295527,
0.3268510997,
0.1134325564,
0.1283065081,
0.8312231898,
-0.0171520039,
-0.349519223,
0.0774021596,
-0.1961782426,
0.5672669411,
-0.2678339779,
-0.2661570609,
0.2050411552,
-0.0935593918,
-0.1012976393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.09451v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.09451v1
|
MANTIS at #SMM4H 2023: Leveraging Hybrid and Ensemble Models for Detection of Social Anxiety Disorder on Reddit
| 2023-11-28T09:33:41 | 2023-11-28T09:33:41 |
Sourabh Zanwar, Daniel Wiechmann, Yu Qiao, Elma Kerz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents our system employed for the Social Media Mining for
Health 2023 Shared Task 4: Binary classification of English Reddit posts
self-reporting a social anxiety disorder diagnosis. We systematically
investigate and contrast the efficacy of hybrid and ensemble models that
harness specialized medical domain-adapted transformers in conjunction with
BiLSTM neural networks. The evaluation results outline that our best performing
model obtained 89.31% F1 on the validation set and 83.76% F1 on the test set.
|
[
-0.4200235009,
-0.488535881,
0.6854689717,
0.3946248591,
-0.1665930301,
0.4220451117,
-0.0398072414,
-0.8463252783,
0.7970051169,
0.1601043046,
-0.6445400715,
-0.5835424662,
-0.7707083225,
0.223497659,
-0.7069712281,
0.8198671341,
0.0466513187,
0.1975964606,
-0.1496114284,
-0.0753414407,
-0.0742665902,
-0.7086886764,
-0.9559195638,
-0.3299505711,
0.4852868021,
0.206767723,
0.5630435944,
0.1061050147,
0.7013653517,
0.2887474,
0.0271420628,
0.1405625343,
-0.0912884325,
-0.2049791217,
-0.350176245,
-0.1143444926,
-0.5457229018,
-0.0282144323,
0.3607043922,
0.3731739223,
-0.2531879246,
0.3513750434,
0.015939761,
0.0629262775,
-0.5035282373,
-0.2199269682,
-0.2113279104,
0.0364498198,
-0.064394556,
-0.5591573119,
-0.1770665497,
0.0069325087,
0.0023585355,
-0.4419212043,
0.3752898276,
0.1439118087,
0.5967631936,
0.3134191036,
-0.4536385834,
0.1499327421,
-0.956263423,
0.6154064536,
-0.3891835511,
0.2538626492,
0.5232450962,
0.4354460835,
-0.0056164623,
-0.7864613533,
-0.4322267175,
0.3484369814,
-0.1527219862,
-0.1024473533,
-0.3515288532,
-0.1367991418,
-0.1943595409,
0.2690859437,
-0.7045722008,
-0.0315685458,
-0.8625149727,
-0.3950720727,
1.0286828279,
0.2672779858,
0.3769445121,
-0.1655564308,
-0.4233484864,
0.3517576754,
0.0319568962,
-0.3304131329,
0.1180405989,
0.0492176302,
-0.4076086581,
0.0848226473,
0.0623385981,
0.4712916613,
0.3170665205,
-0.2526265085,
0.3848914206,
-0.2503133714,
-0.2447884679,
0.0002675822,
0.9199115634,
0.5025034547,
0.1937092692,
-0.1566256285,
-0.2774605155,
0.5391785502,
0.6486569643,
-0.4189038873,
-0.3865190148,
0.2394587994,
-0.6393322349,
-0.4945658743,
-0.1499623805,
-1.0453346968,
-0.5773608685,
-0.2194996923,
0.3872979581,
-0.5523654222,
-0.7723349929,
-0.0535712205,
-0.3373140097,
-0.2800233662,
0.191545099,
-0.9298654199,
0.6612859368,
0.4891424477,
0.8298489451,
-0.6039916873,
-0.4603897929,
0.0463297293,
-0.0473114699,
-0.3250591755,
1.1061263084,
-0.5598732829,
-0.3484060466,
-0.1552604735,
0.2543573678,
-0.5411098003,
-0.7303106785,
0.7063099742,
-0.4708051085,
0.0184524972,
0.0951425433,
-0.3693487346,
-0.1230529994,
0.2221512198,
-0.5307482481,
1.1102552414,
0.3716833591,
-0.7348486185,
0.1981261373,
-0.8379540443,
-0.4716216326,
0.0932817087,
-0.1313728988,
-0.3241271079,
-0.1330858022,
-0.1685015708,
0.7233757973,
-0.2576375306,
0.2333085239,
-0.57722193,
-0.4255664349,
0.1852717847,
-0.0319971517,
0.5770167708,
0.5589841604,
-0.3829306662,
0.4204328954,
-0.8289703131,
-0.0256998129,
0.2528166771,
-0.1778586209,
-0.5073273778,
-0.024176171,
-0.0999035686,
0.1735005081,
0.0906683505,
-0.4936836362,
-0.4064404368,
0.0072012772,
0.6074974537,
0.7807032466,
0.5119681358,
0.2339001298,
-0.438598752,
0.7789063454,
0.2603475749,
0.1940798014,
0.4630635679,
-0.7880395055,
-0.3638090491,
-0.3708160222,
0.1638590246,
0.7036666274,
-0.5575625896,
0.7641233206,
0.0527900383,
-0.6305114031,
-0.5505826473,
-0.0276834425,
0.0412859656,
0.0418609604,
0.4511321187,
-0.1194593087,
-0.8490118384,
-0.9537506104,
-0.3009084761,
0.2572638392,
0.0807359815,
-0.1262970567,
0.7091206908,
-0.9974973202,
0.3927980959,
-0.2682559788,
-0.0788304061,
-0.3676386774,
0.4978403449,
-0.3459084034,
0.4298528135,
0.7276973724,
-0.9400472045,
-0.5730085969,
0.0076973797,
-0.8358132243,
0.2252255231,
0.4013777971,
-0.0850563347,
0.1519966424,
0.4465759397,
-0.5504945517,
0.6059513688,
0.5657670498,
-0.4154914916,
0.3401793242,
-0.0291291289,
0.4807644486,
-1.4622548819,
-0.1244373471,
0.5535336137,
-0.4058068097,
-0.7390021682,
-0.1148873642,
-0.1417459249,
-0.2010632604,
-0.043170426,
0.0992489383,
-0.2247703671,
-0.1930909902,
-0.3340577185,
-0.3867392838,
-0.3490691781,
0.3994574249,
-0.2025815547,
0.3128663301,
0.6356364489,
-0.7230068445,
0.2197384685,
-0.5202795267,
-0.2090022266,
0.5924340487,
-0.3635863066,
0.0310240574,
-0.1538227946,
-0.0198344439,
-1.1278569698,
-0.8427996039,
0.2335387915,
-0.8795123696,
0.2769455612,
0.4342374206,
-0.3902108967,
-0.8547737598,
-0.3692017794,
0.3994391263,
0.4951021671,
-0.2282845527,
0.7938107252,
0.7123872042,
0.0680743307,
-0.0595634133,
-0.4830147326,
-0.3064705133,
-0.4676880836,
-0.8107560873,
0.5714718103,
0.035541568,
-0.4612819254,
0.2378508598,
-0.0071753794,
-0.2285551876,
0.2395694703,
0.2513310909,
0.1731161475,
0.0057864259,
0.0340184085,
-0.0703015924,
-0.1866533607,
0.1462455839,
0.1225339174,
0.8923503757,
-0.1246268451,
-0.3958102465,
-0.8527561426,
0.5198224187,
0.9009925127,
-0.0505162738,
0.533937037,
0.8146535158,
-0.9682152271,
-0.2083497047,
-0.3063098192,
-0.5377402306,
-0.4876661301,
0.0755959451,
0.021677915,
-0.8020403385,
0.5473692417,
0.0632422194,
-0.3134759665,
0.6383540034,
0.6461081505,
-0.2837559283,
1.3665049076,
0.6598700285,
-0.217311576,
0.1444873363,
-0.0203531887,
0.5059736967,
-0.3599703312,
0.0167841334,
-0.3088840842,
-0.5159910321,
-0.7016625404,
-0.3623823225,
0.6797119379,
-0.6389864087,
-0.0775232986,
0.1216176748,
-0.835318923,
0.1370193958,
0.762106657,
0.3442180157,
0.0606631786,
0.151724577,
0.1838011146,
-0.1150257885,
-0.5904642344,
-0.393067956,
1.1167662144,
0.3927852809,
0.6343948245,
-0.0260719899,
0.742593646,
0.9630513787,
0.4269914031,
-0.2591970861,
0.5212686062,
-0.0280288626,
-1.0345057249,
-0.1049446017,
-0.1558283716,
-0.9175490737,
-0.0207044724,
-0.3813618124,
-0.9105991125,
0.23019813,
0.2035556436,
-0.9951731563,
0.4519315958,
-0.9560512304,
0.763045907,
-0.3212121725,
-0.3388526142,
-0.3098663688,
-0.733176291,
0.6191484332,
-0.0904279575,
0.3462468088,
0.1299279481,
0.4261064529,
1.2000617981,
-0.2474637777,
1.0564414263,
-0.1649196446,
0.4480345845,
0.4661316276,
-0.167853564,
0.1166045442,
-0.371284157,
0.1677640378,
0.0928526744,
0.3337144852,
-0.4243795872,
-0.4541728497,
0.6398721933,
-1.0682249069,
-0.2816175222,
-0.8351241946,
-0.1278484762,
-0.2950128913,
-0.0560133085,
0.5236666203,
0.0425408967,
0.2121707052,
0.0861504227,
0.4759535789,
-0.0203876141,
0.1923992783,
0.4634979665,
-0.0922831446,
-0.3737768531,
1.1148076057,
0.2292751819,
0.0321749002,
-0.080176115,
0.0939800441,
-0.0682506859,
-0.451638341,
-0.106726639,
0.3906989992,
-0.459749192,
-0.1032455266,
-0.7442907095,
-0.5169035792,
-1.0222278833,
-0.0813395157,
-0.2971031964,
-0.1510403305,
-0.4213550091,
-0.5443536043,
0.4159644246,
1.0798383951,
-0.3378826976,
0.4361157417,
-0.6018995643,
0.2917564809,
0.2216400802,
0.4230255485,
-0.0521821938,
-0.2118641585,
-0.1840484887,
-0.1604950875,
-0.6302922368,
-1.0800485611,
0.6411932707,
-0.1818332225,
0.6619718075,
0.6655328274,
0.0135498345,
0.579791069,
0.2194877863,
0.6130346656,
0.2034318447,
-0.4507891238,
0.4304115772,
-0.4441657364,
-0.4379957318,
0.4975371361,
1.1541215181,
-0.4282130301,
-0.1226565018,
-0.977316618,
-0.4845254123,
0.7165086865,
0.0769331381,
-0.5640707612,
-0.0940835401,
0.4223921597,
-0.2289461941,
0.0892283842,
-0.7523757815,
-0.1968199611,
0.0900986493,
-0.5502653122,
-0.2424898297,
-0.47749421,
-0.1871122271,
-0.6849108338,
0.6551422477,
-0.0001731813,
0.7937276959,
0.3241536915,
0.2745323181,
-0.5951568484,
0.0957507491,
0.5156677365,
0.5980750322,
-0.3228744864,
0.345199585,
0.1348346621,
-0.2091909647,
0.2387957126,
0.246386826,
0.0981953144,
-0.136017099,
0.4002573788,
0.5571449995,
0.3703757226,
-0.4937749207,
0.4628363252,
0.0002485097,
-0.6233542562,
-0.8252375722,
0.2397666574,
0.3577342331,
0.2177231014,
0.359451592,
0.4177818,
0.3886609077,
-0.8175882697,
0.3084763885,
0.2810365558,
-0.5067093372,
-0.863496542,
0.7599411607,
0.1698078662,
-0.8164976239,
0.1600701362,
-0.7175074816,
-0.8296800852,
0.5657257438,
0.5688084364,
0.6769888997,
-0.6835468411,
0.105339542,
0.3058867455,
0.3779320717,
-0.1808867902,
0.6149644256,
0.0230409019,
-0.8975822926,
0.0824598297,
-0.6048814654,
-0.1941766143,
0.3588936031,
-0.7337178588,
0.3289799988,
-0.5730541348,
-0.4436462522,
0.4020992517,
-0.1642287076,
-0.2556037307,
0.4228782952,
0.2050286829,
0.8143624663,
-1.1204111576,
0.6857976913,
0.9886346459,
-0.1139874905,
-0.609690845,
-0.0549600869,
0.4780436456,
-0.7070801258,
0.0339467563,
0.1827891916,
-0.1820160747,
-0.0937334225,
-0.6944435835,
-0.7744634151,
1.2089825869,
-0.1644704491,
-0.2293025702,
0.0504853837,
0.0169564132,
0.9209671617,
-0.5576468706,
-0.1042592749,
0.8639036417,
0.5317413211,
0.1533782631,
-0.7923644781,
-0.1596986651,
-0.7540321946,
-0.2504040599,
0.1259711683,
-0.6065925956,
1.142606616,
-0.1245485023,
-0.3590509593,
-0.1649023592,
0.3979461789,
0.2550940216,
0.9275012612,
0.6901891828,
0.8840205669,
0.8889225721,
0.1158071235,
1.1924325228,
-0.5931119323,
0.1251179576,
0.8304901123,
-0.4835426509,
0.6622066498,
0.1219944656,
-0.2572531998,
0.5605986118,
1.2013056278,
0.3853471279,
0.4049857557,
-0.256205827,
-0.4953984916,
-0.424729377,
0.1363529563,
-0.4022909403,
0.2874332964,
0.7224794626,
-0.6501042247,
0.0232068859,
0.0229032189,
0.0498199984,
0.0265453495,
-0.2863413095,
0.8199884295,
-0.0125940796,
-0.8650022745,
0.4363439977,
0.2171157598,
0.9129477143,
-0.3371875286,
0.2584028244,
0.14801085,
0.5530560613,
-0.4138031602,
-0.5388714075,
0.9327027798,
-0.1904275119,
-0.2393335551,
0.0964362621,
1.335976243,
-0.1095145941,
-0.7664299607,
0.9232652187,
0.4126678109,
0.2279302329,
-0.3440686762,
-0.5703366995,
-0.2508219182,
0.0267769359,
0.099963598,
0.4464327097,
0.3041329682,
-0.4157896042,
0.6912640929,
0.4728789926,
-0.0809361637,
0.1046026796,
-0.2257619351,
0.7695267797,
-0.8731208444,
-0.6764714718,
-0.8689622283,
0.1670036018,
-0.3590758443,
-0.0698305517,
0.593433857,
0.3124779463,
0.4289815128,
0.1309649199,
1.1037319899,
-0.0588022582,
1.1948136091,
0.2796594799,
0.7621774077,
-0.8048195243,
-0.0705395043,
-0.1638845205,
-0.1547591835,
-0.2631708384,
0.5623380542,
-0.3679098487,
0.063713029,
0.8323471546,
0.9328905344,
-0.1415606886,
0.5306164026,
0.1670010537,
0.1378187835,
-0.0158151854,
0.3585757613,
0.8670235276,
-0.1169979125,
0.15062356,
-0.6687437296,
-0.4696116149,
-0.5266599655,
-0.1626847684,
-1.002519846,
-0.7807586193,
-0.0999502391,
-0.5082498789,
0.1919212341,
1.2213386297,
1.0272260904,
-0.822946012,
-0.0330123901,
-0.0285307411,
0.1855499446,
-0.2597213089,
-0.3212408125,
-0.1203519329,
0.0250182617,
-0.2590407133,
0.1742707342,
0.4314720333,
0.162144959,
-0.4122564495,
-0.0952384472,
-0.6345698237,
-0.0331248417,
0.6562023759,
0.1446818262,
-0.2722343802,
-0.3074198365,
0.153352201,
-0.0347155705,
0.0458311327,
0.6410678625,
-0.3700619638,
-0.1017972305,
0.4145971537,
0.4448881149,
0.3617078662,
0.316200316,
0.4054855108,
-0.3485196829,
-0.1507043988,
0.2762888074,
0.5476136804,
0.3680740595,
-0.5950690508,
0.5785559416,
0.8340405822,
-0.6386924386,
-0.7748118043,
-0.28315413,
-1.0154000521,
-0.3776974678,
1.1495454311,
0.2376648188,
-0.684309423,
-0.4879470468,
0.0868675113,
0.013770516,
-0.5050298572,
1.0165663958,
0.56798774,
-0.5396902561,
0.0084184548,
-0.3967643976,
0.5142101645,
0.1282472163,
-0.7539496422,
-0.6108151674,
0.0914292112,
0.5262057781,
0.6044307351,
1.0752521753,
0.0660974309,
0.710197866,
-0.1532390267,
0.1374206245,
0.464917779,
-0.3930974603,
-0.0873978138,
0.4954758883,
-0.253126502,
-0.2866050899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16620v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16620v1
|
On the Long Range Abilities of Transformers
| 2023-11-28T09:21:48 | 2023-11-28T09:21:48 |
Itamar Zimerman, Lior Wolf
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, F.2.2; I.2.7
|
Despite their dominance in modern DL and, especially, NLP domains,
transformer architectures exhibit sub-optimal performance on long-range tasks
compared to recent layers that are specifically designed for this purpose. In
this work, drawing inspiration from key attributes of long-range layers, such
as state-space layers, linear RNN layers, and global convolution layers, we
demonstrate that minimal modifications to the transformer architecture can
significantly enhance performance on the Long Range Arena (LRA) benchmark, thus
narrowing the gap with these specialized layers. We identify that two key
principles for long-range tasks are (i) incorporating an inductive bias towards
smoothness, and (ii) locality. As we show, integrating these ideas into the
attention mechanism improves results with a negligible amount of additional
computation and without any additional trainable parameters. Our theory and
experiments also shed light on the reasons for the inferior performance of
transformers on long-range tasks and identify critical properties that are
essential for successfully capturing long-range dependencies.
|
[
-0.6719866991,
-0.5291686058,
0.4553056359,
0.3340724409,
0.1871113032,
-0.2205622643,
-0.4569994509,
-1.0109921694,
0.1145044938,
0.4935416877,
-0.4081627429,
0.1026372239,
-0.6595134139,
0.0459613465,
-0.5502873063,
0.8658661246,
0.0446955562,
-0.8135744929,
-0.207357347,
-0.2845187485,
-0.1527657062,
-0.3780266047,
-0.5752957463,
-0.6007833481,
0.8683938384,
0.1256497055,
0.9517577291,
0.5660238266,
0.741717577,
0.2837714553,
-0.0760165304,
0.0382001773,
-0.3970035315,
0.2319319546,
-0.3707721233,
-0.5638574958,
-0.3779204488,
-0.3495396674,
0.6633608937,
0.6272646189,
0.2607159317,
0.1499826908,
0.2882941365,
1.0882643461,
-0.7367540598,
0.2624393106,
-0.2531901896,
0.3518325984,
-0.5524172187,
-0.1555135995,
-0.5070133805,
0.1680143923,
0.2619015574,
-0.5733897686,
0.3162846565,
-0.2183692604,
0.6880540848,
0.7622950673,
-0.302482605,
0.1580473185,
-1.2280271053,
0.8483394384,
-0.3762211204,
0.6569445729,
0.2578573525,
0.4165118933,
-0.0637177154,
-0.8328137994,
-0.1423017383,
-0.0976142958,
-0.1922104508,
0.3028626442,
-0.4090144634,
0.1805454642,
0.7691784501,
0.2230974287,
0.0416281298,
0.3983712196,
-0.4469554722,
0.0761670098,
0.2897411883,
0.02598124,
-0.3012411594,
-0.0467125215,
-0.4179356396,
0.002709433,
-0.4810367227,
0.5032272339,
0.1983500123,
0.098348774,
0.0467898995,
0.5204651952,
-0.5137072206,
0.42501086,
0.2587649226,
0.0039645559,
0.1041824743,
0.0394681096,
-0.1696658731,
-0.2177666873,
0.3211911023,
0.2800635695,
0.1488870084,
-0.7699838877,
-0.2764953077,
0.1813517511,
0.6012343764,
-0.6397723556,
0.0867917612,
0.3295717537,
-0.4428349733,
0.0227718949,
-0.294552654,
-0.6823817492,
-0.1672224998,
-0.5151433945,
0.4375224113,
-0.2268165946,
0.0251276344,
0.163546145,
-0.1308229119,
0.583060801,
0.0192743503,
-1.0310034752,
0.6177729964,
0.9135126472,
0.5470682979,
-0.4871964753,
-0.3667273521,
-0.5349746346,
0.125024125,
-0.0942622274,
0.985864222,
-0.3362476826,
-0.0400237106,
0.0444925912,
-0.0456984378,
-0.0182213485,
-0.716411829,
0.8587510586,
-0.6573245525,
0.0396855734,
-0.1002764553,
-0.2418204993,
0.0727032945,
-0.2361149043,
-0.8981488347,
1.1713731289,
0.3670934737,
-0.7077317834,
0.3979436159,
-1.0158611536,
-0.9549170136,
0.0671033859,
0.1519192755,
-0.4180941582,
0.3824808896,
0.2511207759,
0.5083058476,
-0.0896837413,
0.0169355236,
0.0757101774,
-0.6308674216,
0.1362184882,
-0.3891126215,
0.3214522898,
0.0215644669,
-0.8369445801,
0.0603304617,
-0.8419445753,
-0.0157692637,
-0.1552725136,
-0.3579372168,
-0.1030423716,
0.3276377022,
-0.0166233573,
0.2795535624,
-0.0758869201,
-0.3365439773,
-0.0623119064,
-0.622700572,
0.5954002142,
0.7221532464,
-0.34738186,
0.8831077218,
-0.2473490983,
0.3938149512,
0.0535150059,
0.428670764,
0.0469375961,
-0.2977558076,
-1.037153244,
-0.1747494787,
0.0442597158,
0.3900726736,
-0.6146777868,
0.5553084612,
-0.6168310642,
-0.3532263935,
-0.5947269201,
0.1431315988,
0.1077829972,
0.5004224777,
0.6776770353,
-0.3388992846,
-0.3471336067,
-1.1867194176,
-0.1725296378,
0.5365047455,
-0.2450263351,
0.2039309293,
0.418821305,
-0.1475436389,
0.9124546051,
-0.3226464689,
-0.5079145432,
-0.2003852427,
-0.427929461,
0.449816525,
0.2507624924,
0.3274990618,
-0.7340860367,
-0.3296286166,
0.070463255,
-0.6477597952,
0.1121712103,
-0.2674953341,
-0.2980952859,
0.0956930667,
0.6303792,
-1.2669260502,
0.6215429902,
0.2433176935,
0.0337229371,
0.2052775025,
0.0898479149,
-0.2176130116,
-0.7705777287,
0.181130752,
0.2500832081,
-0.1178866848,
-0.8287475109,
0.3953050375,
0.174353838,
0.0378270298,
-0.5462360382,
0.3823420107,
-0.2582702935,
-0.1807419956,
-0.3059550524,
0.2493658811,
0.068725124,
0.6626437306,
0.0448430926,
0.5990517735,
0.4936100245,
-0.7105539441,
0.3556242883,
0.0163719058,
-0.5673799515,
0.5910343528,
-0.8160721064,
0.2154219747,
-0.2723478377,
0.4332442582,
-0.4844702482,
-0.1894628704,
-0.0249904841,
-0.0045477161,
0.3859825432,
0.0593416654,
-0.3058257699,
-0.5702124238,
-0.1045104489,
0.4834716618,
0.8204734325,
-0.5867740512,
0.8080881238,
-0.0081961621,
0.346316129,
-0.9642542005,
-0.8242644072,
0.0209743623,
-0.4079875052,
-0.6589822173,
0.6324958205,
0.2032700926,
-0.3115676641,
-0.2403567731,
-0.229421109,
0.2424061149,
0.0336249694,
0.4885850847,
-0.2686773241,
-0.3815824091,
0.155930981,
-0.1817924678,
-0.4357510507,
0.2255311608,
-0.2128059566,
0.4948790967,
0.1676827073,
-0.2714830339,
-0.3451342881,
0.4712355733,
0.6023113132,
-0.5055667162,
0.4898398221,
0.6786016822,
-0.1041576117,
-0.6322518587,
-0.5549923778,
-0.10313382,
-0.5414039493,
0.5399929881,
-0.490552932,
-0.7922113538,
0.6086931229,
-0.1064600125,
0.1366883665,
0.6776623726,
0.2910504043,
-0.1074228361,
0.5377806425,
0.8424875736,
-0.3803456128,
0.5302434564,
-0.3550167382,
0.5416615605,
-1.2059334517,
-0.1763685942,
-0.5753480792,
-0.7114731073,
-0.5661814809,
-0.5535796285,
0.2846114933,
-0.1642336845,
-0.2487378567,
0.3940634131,
-0.7403134704,
0.5655938983,
0.6606200933,
0.2877027094,
-0.0643923357,
-0.0148136029,
0.2988650203,
-0.0593768321,
-0.5775854588,
-0.0760235935,
0.5988694429,
0.8238384724,
0.8917682171,
-0.0960371718,
0.5882695913,
0.1923793405,
0.0537352972,
-1.075805068,
0.4900332093,
-0.2325110435,
-0.4180067182,
-0.4046882987,
0.027638996,
-1.0210819244,
0.0269843787,
0.05899572,
-0.5968307853,
0.1757605672,
-0.1941642016,
-0.3326073289,
0.2737759054,
-0.6017017365,
0.4237022102,
-0.0293900073,
-0.5587719679,
-0.1478609443,
-0.8292705417,
-0.1003716141,
0.0170673933,
-0.0838391706,
0.1125650331,
-0.0271441508,
0.4582554996,
0.1574138254,
0.8111026287,
-0.0728333518,
-0.299269855,
0.2103763968,
-0.1687179357,
0.5918962955,
-0.1903258264,
-0.1893213242,
0.1571906507,
-0.8442134857,
-0.353512466,
-0.6786661148,
0.5711091757,
-0.7161878943,
-0.7133489251,
0.0124452189,
-0.7498252988,
-0.319221735,
0.2760841548,
0.256534934,
0.5110660195,
0.104809925,
0.6372926831,
0.7722361088,
0.0863958076,
0.7818133831,
-0.1254601032,
0.1299999058,
0.1409721673,
0.3412851691,
0.089716658,
0.5875036716,
0.8189216256,
-0.2558277845,
-0.2361120135,
-0.4914008379,
-0.1399768144,
-0.0583702475,
-1.0686465502,
-0.2192675024,
-0.6600802541,
-0.5690711737,
-0.0579736754,
-0.3208224773,
-0.4491129816,
-0.4866195023,
-0.1210089624,
-0.0921301544,
0.1235873252,
0.5691970587,
0.2215930372,
0.1873126477,
-0.3937002718,
0.8002098799,
0.3846842945,
0.6655634642,
0.1121137217,
-0.5350614786,
-0.5528018475,
-0.1904452294,
-0.4294173121,
0.0498485118,
0.020340642,
0.1635750085,
0.5789669156,
0.2304541618,
-0.0609686598,
0.8024731278,
-0.7282200456,
0.730635345,
-0.0271749962,
-0.8534541726,
0.3947246075,
-0.16451554,
0.7059495449,
0.2900322676,
0.2535877526,
-0.1045963764,
-0.5969086885,
-0.3504796922,
-1.0029377937,
0.4484344125,
0.4699664712,
0.3702836931,
0.2010892779,
0.3604170978,
0.0882421434,
-0.1868415326,
-0.8831911087,
-0.3709501326,
-0.1918090284,
0.1552273631,
-0.1660030633,
-0.0619376786,
-0.2944874167,
-0.24144651,
0.2255585641,
-0.2017414719,
0.5974959731,
0.4451664984,
0.06864696,
-0.2967796624,
0.4959946275,
0.6799820662,
0.8878523707,
-0.1403501183,
0.2107098848,
0.4034184515,
-0.3556807935,
-0.1207877398,
0.161903277,
-0.076598458,
-0.0693494081,
0.4644881189,
0.7669252753,
0.2365555763,
-0.0555772968,
0.1484083533,
0.107157059,
-0.1144891828,
-0.2866621912,
0.2200845629,
0.1580194533,
0.5753356218,
0.7014586926,
0.5438228846,
0.2095120698,
-0.3489866555,
0.2789328396,
0.3407794237,
-0.353444159,
-0.2749408185,
0.7002491951,
0.1249846593,
-0.4417749941,
0.5476350188,
0.4390125573,
-0.242946133,
0.6341680884,
0.6834517717,
0.8886576891,
-0.0197682604,
-0.194090277,
0.0424608774,
0.3075021803,
-0.0529924519,
-0.2279500365,
-0.2958259881,
-0.3176893294,
-0.6874803901,
-0.5598711371,
-0.1529652029,
0.0338442475,
-0.7059012651,
0.1208383366,
-0.2371716499,
-0.3549304605,
0.312505424,
-0.2283999771,
-1.0474412441,
0.3807298839,
0.1527551413,
0.992582202,
-0.1523783803,
0.751159668,
0.0658921897,
0.1460797936,
-0.5750538111,
0.009238245,
-0.8074689507,
-0.6890135407,
0.9350714684,
0.437182188,
-0.4021229744,
-0.318508029,
-0.3165181577,
-0.9100746512,
1.0746458769,
0.1747009605,
-0.7221086025,
-0.3834168315,
0.6124810576,
0.8316026926,
-0.1874371469,
0.2511425316,
0.4416179061,
0.3589268029,
-0.3417918384,
-1.1183850765,
-0.0374169126,
-0.0889752731,
0.04991946,
0.5458555222,
-0.8427406549,
0.5108836889,
-0.18080163,
-0.1791822314,
-0.0329916887,
0.9617338181,
-0.4374192655,
0.2072933018,
0.3917247951,
0.6981185079,
0.1130412892,
-0.2678049505,
1.2478197813,
-0.3110034168,
0.1993103027,
0.9327118993,
-0.1401883215,
0.9128996134,
0.6427233219,
-0.2639657855,
0.3645893037,
-0.0318671688,
-0.0682376623,
0.6466166377,
0.1672912538,
-0.2303760648,
0.0314399041,
-0.140221402,
-0.3502692878,
0.6727549434,
0.2388563901,
-0.4397423565,
-0.1054304689,
0.0222514272,
-0.2401920408,
-0.0382645987,
-0.4607758522,
0.5252060294,
0.3032937348,
-0.8583542109,
0.5075314045,
-0.312612623,
0.9624350071,
-0.5128206611,
0.0684163123,
-0.1838782132,
0.4503912926,
-0.4205547869,
-0.9758319855,
0.3091109991,
-0.3464707136,
-0.2957317233,
-0.2825127244,
0.9242833853,
0.0675592124,
-0.1630221605,
0.6296280622,
0.1684930027,
-0.3410395384,
0.0264514834,
-0.3220904768,
-0.0708476976,
-0.3578259647,
-0.5247101188,
0.4306165576,
0.453265816,
0.0424066335,
0.8498901129,
0.3711056411,
-0.141023308,
0.0194395613,
0.2338364273,
0.9036129713,
-0.8604018092,
-0.2813283503,
-0.631415844,
0.732573092,
-0.0132079739,
-0.3528960943,
0.6637214422,
0.5527714491,
0.8610618114,
-0.1900195777,
0.487436533,
0.0648022816,
0.330704689,
-0.3949361742,
0.4570643604,
-0.2508266866,
-0.0581408069,
-0.0535550267,
-1.3244484663,
-0.3879580796,
0.3102377057,
-0.2478872538,
0.138976872,
0.8099018931,
0.4720996618,
-0.3419680595,
-0.2726104856,
0.4518502355,
0.022278212,
0.4537374079,
0.8299323916,
0.8986423016,
-0.6951658726,
0.3888950646,
-0.7180598378,
0.1959244162,
0.1123107076,
-0.7620604038,
-1.010915041,
-0.4984819591,
-0.0181046892,
-0.341235429,
-0.0727327541,
0.3905898333,
0.776670754,
-0.4789532423,
-0.0656415671,
0.1508511305,
-0.0898312852,
-0.3488195539,
-0.2855615616,
0.4513709247,
-0.4434294403,
-0.6527132988,
0.3236275017,
0.5887432098,
-0.2720750272,
-0.1414286047,
0.2048098743,
0.2758087814,
0.0420032553,
1.0873968601,
0.2875876129,
-0.8656477332,
-0.680257678,
0.3587292433,
-0.162968412,
0.4036839008,
0.7269935012,
-0.9192858934,
0.1262046993,
0.0664036199,
0.6194519401,
0.4835835397,
0.0307512898,
0.2829692662,
-0.6349611282,
0.3919683397,
0.4199429452,
0.2071809471,
0.135669142,
-0.517557323,
0.5796991587,
-0.3992110193,
-0.9202967882,
-0.4832951128,
0.2255732715,
-1.3815780878,
0.1545421779,
1.1290730238,
0.0491729788,
-0.326128751,
-0.0716224015,
-0.0191906132,
0.1347921044,
-0.2227541655,
0.9608230591,
0.4929206967,
-0.4067720473,
-0.1602375507,
-0.7245076299,
0.7547705173,
0.536919713,
-0.8751963377,
0.0907268673,
0.0189808942,
0.0538554639,
0.5572466254,
0.2454430163,
-0.1176513359,
0.3035468459,
-0.1166997254,
-0.3034202158,
0.1678074151,
-0.4953025579,
-0.2310245633,
0.3777916729,
-0.0967976525,
0.0063008061
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16588v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16588v2
|
Ascle: A Python Natural Language Processing Toolkit for Medical Text Generation
| 2023-11-28T08:13:29 | 2023-12-09T09:14:24 |
Rui Yang, Qingcheng Zeng, Keen You, Yujie Qiao, Lucas Huang, Chia-Chun Hsieh, Benjamin Rosand, Jeremy Goldwasser, Amisha D Dave, Tiarnan D. L. Keenan, Emily Y Chew, Dragomir Radev, Zhiyong Lu, Hua Xu, Qingyu Chen, Irene Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study introduces Ascle, a pioneering natural language processing (NLP)
toolkit designed for medical text generation. Ascle is tailored for biomedical
researchers and healthcare professionals with an easy-to-use, all-in-one
solution that requires minimal programming expertise. For the first time, Ascle
evaluates and provides interfaces for the latest pre-trained language models,
encompassing four advanced and challenging generative functions:
question-answering, text summarization, text simplification, and machine
translation. In addition, Ascle integrates 12 essential NLP functions, along
with query and search capabilities for clinical databases. The toolkit, its
models, and associated data are publicly available via
https://github.com/Yale-LILY/MedGen.
|
[
-0.1246008351,
-0.6526267529,
0.4916073084,
0.2212524563,
-0.2443481684,
0.1612766385,
-0.2050392181,
-0.5400756598,
0.2293509096,
0.6426583529,
-0.7194601297,
-0.6275687814,
-0.5436265469,
0.700543046,
-0.6083067656,
1.225867033,
0.260751307,
0.2486128658,
-0.3077624142,
-0.0769895986,
-0.0932230428,
-0.2013798654,
-0.8475018144,
-0.5676725507,
0.2657251954,
0.4260106087,
0.5521141291,
0.5492915511,
0.5284326077,
0.2885438204,
0.007614682,
-0.047513511,
0.1771502644,
0.3887130916,
-0.3244762123,
-0.2526057065,
-0.4366511405,
-0.1680554748,
0.5015371442,
0.9804611206,
-0.0845338479,
0.2702376544,
-0.0945297852,
0.934245646,
-0.5695560575,
-0.2390715629,
-0.3755949736,
-0.0836609825,
-0.283645004,
-0.387973398,
-0.1369700283,
-0.6553635001,
0.1737407148,
-0.6535930634,
0.4629694521,
0.1080073416,
0.552271843,
0.5031998158,
-0.4094285667,
-0.770737946,
-0.1592911929,
0.4850581288,
-0.8389009237,
0.023158228,
0.5246388912,
0.2417779565,
-0.1837889403,
-1.0434093475,
-0.3247009218,
-0.1187560484,
0.0767340809,
0.0270315241,
-0.3537537456,
0.418076992,
0.2183862776,
0.6261668801,
-0.768912673,
0.0621744469,
-0.847509861,
-0.2489624918,
0.6642260551,
0.2986596227,
0.679119885,
-0.3751782775,
-0.0099994773,
0.1508651823,
-0.814299643,
-0.0285005011,
0.3929228783,
0.0375784822,
0.0459360927,
0.9666721225,
-0.3953559697,
0.8001850247,
-0.2831322253,
0.2667554319,
0.2159697562,
-0.6206226349,
-0.5082429051,
0.6265410781,
1.2472189665,
0.2108163238,
0.1599451452,
0.0957171619,
0.0976251811,
0.2289243937,
0.6017770171,
-1.0777885914,
-0.8171008825,
0.6051521301,
-0.5322072506,
-0.678798914,
-0.1896301359,
-0.6295555234,
-0.4202146828,
0.0781368539,
0.0269211121,
-0.8142240047,
-0.0537095517,
0.5307742953,
-0.4937052131,
-0.3082460165,
0.4022384584,
-0.6688635945,
0.5423542857,
0.3597095013,
0.7498014569,
-0.1501443088,
-0.0440944061,
-0.5223752856,
-0.0355872512,
-0.3025790751,
1.1831787825,
-0.5204214454,
-0.4615451992,
0.0840387568,
0.057824228,
0.1861067414,
-0.6857066751,
0.4038973153,
-0.0784681439,
0.3804313838,
0.109665826,
-0.4100597203,
-0.2159151286,
-0.0370015502,
-0.6892658472,
0.9795633554,
0.0554901995,
-1.0654685497,
0.2918879092,
-0.9589511156,
-0.9363598228,
0.3044493496,
-0.283572793,
-0.4684622884,
0.1656718403,
0.2493663132,
0.3253554106,
-0.656878531,
0.1781301349,
-0.0250135716,
0.0265525989,
0.3364622295,
-0.0875108466,
1.1819751263,
0.411450237,
0.0127572985,
0.5613355041,
-1.0468680859,
0.2019299865,
-0.0421457328,
-0.7754596472,
-0.2269518822,
0.0162892696,
0.4635811746,
-0.0246519316,
0.1894714385,
-0.7845689654,
0.3413033485,
-0.8961740732,
0.9219133258,
0.1674910188,
0.1278029829,
0.4160493016,
-0.2883112133,
0.6829063296,
-0.3318103552,
-0.3970401585,
-0.3014685512,
-0.8847404122,
-0.2030556053,
-0.328395009,
0.2916860282,
0.4665188491,
-0.975877285,
0.3727556169,
0.1934125423,
-0.3577076495,
-1.017968297,
0.0588598587,
0.4986011982,
0.3898978233,
0.5992313623,
-0.1805578768,
-0.7496749759,
-0.7770570517,
-0.4014310539,
-0.1692522019,
-0.3856009543,
-0.0615850724,
0.5360532999,
-0.7843119502,
0.8236837983,
-0.6946471334,
-0.1693608463,
-0.5542414188,
0.4253024161,
0.2348495126,
0.5392535329,
0.1932919919,
-0.4502304792,
-0.4135501683,
0.0977858827,
-0.4388855398,
-0.5444154739,
0.0393924713,
0.2804785967,
0.4364589751,
0.5799099207,
-0.4382307231,
0.4743848443,
0.6685599685,
-0.5640369654,
0.9131540656,
-0.6025437713,
0.2353137434,
-1.1632199287,
0.609071672,
-0.1666141748,
-0.4747404158,
-0.7579895854,
0.0957915708,
0.1228207201,
-0.26361835,
-0.1619450152,
0.6081126928,
-0.4239780009,
0.1421655864,
-0.3250463605,
-0.1947113276,
0.103915967,
-0.3437973261,
0.2214439809,
0.7011740208,
0.5077155232,
-0.6803597212,
0.2848822176,
0.5666331053,
-0.2552438974,
0.3831197023,
-0.7648844123,
-0.1869939566,
0.1579840183,
-0.1866135448,
-0.6856948733,
-0.6259801984,
0.2245884985,
-0.7965272665,
0.2668115497,
-0.0853326768,
-0.5975986719,
-0.6581379175,
-0.4758725762,
0.2495215833,
0.3617328703,
-0.1705454737,
0.2436115295,
0.4201661348,
-0.3674293458,
-0.3340179026,
-0.6832513213,
0.0806359053,
0.0177832451,
-0.5843744278,
0.33174932,
-0.205674991,
-0.1358873844,
0.1286939532,
-0.088146694,
-0.4151648581,
0.1063721702,
0.2752586901,
0.1558562517,
-0.2755591273,
0.1336143315,
0.4952368736,
-0.2520679832,
0.0598590225,
0.0391235091,
0.757896781,
-0.0144141978,
-0.2258897424,
-0.4762503207,
0.3885759711,
0.4079051316,
-0.1496228278,
0.2775192559,
0.4184831083,
-0.4718511701,
-0.1037007272,
-0.3944647014,
-0.1221314669,
-0.5362300277,
0.4628197551,
-0.0015378512,
-0.6927220821,
0.2272117138,
-0.0150387799,
0.1846350729,
0.482509613,
0.8053677678,
-0.3009244204,
0.9113311768,
0.3735384345,
0.1763654351,
0.0308200568,
0.1392361224,
0.0912014171,
-0.7159058452,
-0.1052668169,
-0.6000519395,
-0.0579319336,
-0.4797385335,
-0.5907398462,
0.2617153227,
0.0479065366,
-0.415822953,
0.3897945583,
-1.0987100601,
0.1037946194,
0.7560194135,
-0.1537850946,
0.6270964146,
-0.0712502152,
0.113564916,
0.1297755986,
-0.7604004741,
-0.5577426553,
1.2950576544,
0.0933072865,
0.8963860869,
-0.3047924638,
0.7615910172,
0.0763336867,
0.1773691773,
-0.7220765948,
0.4837733507,
-0.3024632037,
-0.7607349753,
-0.1698164642,
-0.3042067885,
-1.3530327082,
-0.2918333709,
-0.5736941695,
-0.5090172291,
-0.4119397402,
0.2563572526,
-0.8025857806,
0.0909579098,
-0.3364056945,
0.8825440407,
0.0627363101,
0.0154224467,
-0.3138179481,
-0.8004921079,
0.1909863055,
-0.0480247326,
0.0278606992,
-0.1570348293,
0.0078514609,
0.6672680974,
-0.5182301998,
0.4948219061,
0.1556188613,
0.4879752398,
0.3680711091,
0.2829353511,
-0.113420397,
0.227385059,
0.1140343621,
0.1596376896,
0.6015638113,
-0.1352528632,
-0.0511260815,
0.5053455234,
-0.5716933608,
-0.1205294877,
-0.6061475277,
-0.5038802028,
0.2621551454,
0.5030623078,
0.6646690965,
0.4729743004,
-0.2294874638,
0.2139911205,
0.4875125885,
-0.9085583091,
0.2531752586,
0.5412109494,
-0.3340938985,
-0.4089055061,
0.7125902176,
-0.1275932938,
0.1745474041,
0.1699677855,
0.403559655,
-0.1285688281,
-0.6204306483,
-0.6220846176,
0.2510522008,
-0.4369280636,
-0.3765808046,
-1.1043604612,
-0.4051826298,
-0.5888904333,
-0.5829155445,
-0.535531342,
-0.5600326061,
-0.4715996981,
0.1107082665,
0.6091344357,
1.0667383671,
0.0179917272,
0.3353273571,
-0.8436724544,
0.5148087144,
-0.1238109916,
0.2169774026,
-0.5925453305,
0.0390887149,
0.1419230402,
-0.132514134,
-0.4751374424,
-1.0509895086,
0.7610677481,
0.298053205,
0.3985077739,
0.4323988557,
0.0810940936,
0.4598518312,
-0.7509324551,
0.7692791224,
0.562184453,
-0.7855492234,
0.9038490653,
-0.2988696396,
0.4593789876,
0.7130857706,
0.3254650533,
-0.6998935938,
-0.6307855844,
-0.7214540243,
-0.9817029238,
0.6401305795,
0.2083290964,
-0.3617778122,
-0.1211099401,
0.051481761,
0.2628070116,
0.6181157827,
-0.3957075179,
-0.2364933044,
-0.1779300719,
-0.5494571328,
0.0257091913,
-0.2059632242,
-0.1543824375,
-0.4001334906,
0.4878715277,
-0.2917978466,
0.3797034323,
0.3059608936,
-0.1590203047,
-0.0802138448,
0.2687992156,
0.3690998852,
0.19246234,
-0.2073917389,
0.0145153198,
-0.0110090487,
-0.6883671284,
-0.1064801514,
0.1837385297,
0.1038605198,
0.0080929417,
0.4391336143,
0.1593697518,
0.2098663449,
-1.120554924,
0.5058013201,
-0.0054137269,
-0.3335368037,
-0.4449183345,
0.2601518333,
0.2918993533,
0.0486168601,
0.122366108,
0.2879976332,
0.6617583632,
-0.6155589819,
0.4137679636,
0.3139327765,
-0.420925498,
-0.4239342213,
1.0078015327,
0.0308549404,
-0.48625049,
0.9383637309,
-0.1260443032,
-0.3482635915,
0.5616115928,
0.8116403818,
0.7616539598,
-0.1510496289,
0.2333804667,
0.549431026,
0.1845004708,
-0.2042236775,
0.4638994038,
-0.0528765321,
-0.628754437,
-0.4650512636,
-0.8289278746,
-0.2977493703,
-0.0988487527,
-0.8416903019,
0.5389439464,
-0.5342508554,
-0.1839607358,
0.2777294815,
0.068109937,
-0.5574769378,
0.2163608521,
0.0449247807,
1.0138756037,
-0.7783889174,
1.037700057,
1.2866520882,
-0.4244335592,
-0.2780108452,
-0.3111085594,
0.1544961482,
-0.8955253959,
0.5325696468,
0.3338294923,
-0.0053760875,
0.0908442959,
-0.5473676324,
-0.4818043411,
0.8704640865,
0.1106068343,
-0.1327485591,
-0.3676186502,
0.0285755806,
0.6841267347,
-0.1601022333,
0.1393357217,
0.7414155006,
0.2030343413,
0.0350856669,
-0.9690554142,
0.0829341263,
-0.6484622359,
-0.2696819007,
0.0889249519,
0.1266479045,
0.7477203012,
-0.3640036881,
-0.2983020842,
0.3772569299,
0.1561773717,
0.5378803611,
0.4188654721,
-0.0120140063,
0.3586628139,
0.8404349685,
-0.0266583208,
1.3006314039,
-0.4318768382,
0.0031069517,
0.9536147118,
0.0071838056,
0.6423912048,
0.4904692769,
-0.1905615181,
0.3471886814,
0.4608612955,
0.1288899034,
0.4435623884,
0.1624583751,
-0.223086074,
-0.1661953926,
0.2762435079,
-0.307425797,
0.2303907275,
0.6102810502,
-0.4051356316,
-0.1950055957,
0.1673785001,
-0.0075818687,
0.1629509479,
-0.4312080443,
0.8425498605,
0.1706345379,
-0.5018180609,
0.3291192949,
-0.0421548299,
0.7188913226,
-0.6387101412,
-0.0297773629,
0.3960846364,
0.120475702,
-0.5638048053,
-1.1164778471,
0.7914379239,
-0.0442109779,
-0.2254322916,
-0.1923838705,
1.0040287971,
-0.2575003207,
-0.5343233347,
0.1214801669,
0.2158803791,
0.2980599105,
-0.2512241602,
-0.7581945062,
-0.0442112982,
0.261913687,
-0.2689284384,
0.1179048419,
0.3005206883,
0.0767714307,
1.0400035381,
0.8440032005,
0.6153204441,
0.0878374651,
-0.2710926235,
0.8660102487,
-0.7444152236,
-0.524076581,
-0.9276117682,
0.6560711265,
-0.2817123234,
-0.4761562645,
0.443102181,
0.710364759,
0.5102764368,
-0.1370683312,
0.9109204412,
-0.2376186401,
0.7697643638,
-0.2773182988,
1.2890849113,
-0.6890540123,
-0.0116710439,
-0.2899755836,
-0.3411433399,
-0.6962168813,
1.0645259619,
-0.1420651525,
-0.594650507,
0.9540824294,
0.5297225118,
0.3028019369,
0.1620113701,
0.1767248511,
0.0399274677,
0.3537747264,
0.3125483394,
0.5964148641,
-0.2901951671,
0.3013973534,
-0.0506292731,
-0.1001029983,
-0.2928424478,
-0.6463788152,
-1.1488763094,
-0.5397056937,
-0.4013192058,
-0.5604328513,
0.0690182,
1.414827466,
0.3306818306,
-0.9966449142,
-0.1478424668,
-0.3192813993,
-0.2461219132,
-0.1184012964,
-0.2117715925,
0.331136018,
-0.5548611283,
-0.6398363113,
0.5078909397,
0.5312974453,
-0.2541023493,
0.0631595701,
0.1506151855,
-0.1820928305,
-0.1498101205,
0.4510903358,
0.422414124,
-0.3357763588,
0.0333630107,
-0.2212145776,
-0.3403546512,
0.3323916197,
0.9238219857,
-0.7702519894,
0.826664567,
0.532674551,
0.6668900251,
0.4284277558,
-0.1059469953,
0.9501453638,
-0.4995143712,
0.1392134726,
0.6808715463,
0.2966215909,
0.3536738753,
-0.2051638216,
0.5311035514,
0.1650996804,
-0.7255251408,
-1.0365841389,
0.1059145927,
-0.7879053354,
-0.5727243423,
1.2523579597,
0.3311489522,
-0.231886819,
-0.6491277218,
-0.5124819279,
0.4256201386,
-0.402919203,
0.5180151463,
0.1978053153,
-0.2678056359,
0.1918664128,
-1.1043562889,
1.0134162903,
0.0543978177,
-0.8861125708,
-0.0813129395,
0.3150321245,
0.6303027868,
0.1073824391,
1.1184846163,
-0.1887404621,
0.4123480022,
0.0328229144,
0.5863745213,
-0.1130007058,
-0.1158362329,
-0.2539601326,
0.1095197797,
0.025632536,
0.0423818864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16579v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16579v1
|
Recognizing Conditional Causal Relationships about Emotions and Their Corresponding Conditions
| 2023-11-28T07:47:25 | 2023-11-28T07:47:25 |
Xinhong Chen, Zongxi Li, Yaowei Wang, Haoran Xie, Jianping Wang, Qing Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The study of causal relationships between emotions and causes in texts has
recently received much attention. Most works focus on extracting causally
related clauses from documents. However, none of these works has considered
that the causal relationships among the extracted emotion and cause clauses can
only be valid under some specific context clauses. To highlight the context in
such special causal relationships, we propose a new task to determine whether
or not an input pair of emotion and cause has a valid causal relationship under
different contexts and extract the specific context clauses that participate in
the causal relationship. Since the task is new for which no existing dataset is
available, we conduct manual annotation on a benchmark dataset to obtain the
labels for our tasks and the annotations of each context clause's type that can
also be used in some other applications. We adopt negative sampling to
construct the final dataset to balance the number of documents with and without
causal relationships. Based on the constructed dataset, we propose an
end-to-end multi-task framework, where we design two novel and general modules
to handle the two goals of our task. Specifically, we propose a context masking
module to extract the context clauses participating in the causal
relationships. We propose a prediction aggregation module to fine-tune the
prediction results according to whether the input emotion and causes depend on
specific context clauses. Results of extensive comparative experiments and
ablation studies demonstrate the effectiveness and generality of our proposed
framework.
|
[
-0.4442354739,
-0.7515215278,
0.842071414,
0.3050811291,
-0.2469717115,
-0.6801060438,
-0.0544828176,
-0.5910517573,
0.326736182,
0.4780721962,
-0.8962850571,
-0.2174946666,
-0.7795582414,
0.3754372895,
-0.4062662721,
1.0874530077,
-0.1918969154,
-0.2288219184,
-0.4889587164,
-0.2218739241,
-0.6341906786,
-0.4816702902,
-0.8079560399,
-0.3115996718,
0.8299888968,
0.2420070767,
0.0674883276,
0.2312280834,
0.3648188412,
0.3461209536,
0.0788511336,
0.0303302519,
-0.281692028,
0.4737656415,
-0.2899305522,
-0.2195507884,
-0.1480384469,
0.0398549512,
0.1233208776,
0.0523345731,
0.1511875689,
0.1798969358,
-0.1281592846,
0.5893208385,
-0.8539061546,
0.3690759242,
-0.455298245,
-0.0510513857,
-0.2757525146,
-0.4259019494,
-0.3090405464,
0.0198851712,
-0.0880189538,
-0.4573391676,
0.1052557975,
0.0319297053,
0.8837434649,
0.562427938,
-1.2566100359,
-0.2579533756,
-0.3211175501,
0.4155165851,
-0.4503164291,
0.0995443165,
0.4463972449,
0.0488238931,
-0.1906273365,
-0.5790714025,
-0.7650793195,
0.1163191721,
-0.651098907,
0.476041764,
-0.1831613183,
0.0460716076,
0.4359087348,
0.1360098869,
-0.3723836839,
-0.2043155283,
-0.2295587808,
-0.3456626534,
0.6264070272,
0.3677766919,
0.6064347029,
-0.4478596151,
-0.4288494289,
0.3061804175,
-0.7548556328,
0.2450129688,
0.25610888,
0.229184255,
-0.4066625834,
0.5719372034,
-0.2944402993,
0.7001519203,
-0.0795648694,
0.0044323844,
0.1105243489,
-0.2723685205,
-0.3355927765,
0.0966019034,
0.50107342,
0.4650243819,
0.1901984811,
-0.2156500369,
-0.0000505598,
0.5102268457,
0.137921527,
-0.7269689441,
0.1706205308,
0.411100775,
-0.4078471065,
-0.104548417,
-0.2152055949,
-0.6750042439,
-0.5117444992,
-0.7678346634,
0.5036279559,
-0.0222284365,
-0.2859600782,
-0.1370004863,
-0.3062307835,
-0.210539639,
0.2382095158,
-0.571554184,
0.2027436644,
0.5184551477,
0.5809285641,
-0.03431914,
-0.2908111811,
-0.6546555758,
0.2986544371,
0.0067024617,
0.8875635266,
-0.5624140501,
0.0005371147,
0.3151114881,
0.4061240852,
-0.179017514,
-0.0140593154,
1.0469161272,
-0.3140186369,
0.3401639163,
-0.6301884651,
-0.5743585825,
-0.3508490324,
0.4110926986,
-0.8289036751,
0.7036206722,
0.154393971,
-1.0117254257,
0.4372946918,
-0.3378185332,
-0.8940833211,
-0.3264347613,
-0.2751239836,
-0.3869268,
0.1147780418,
-0.0628830642,
0.6352391243,
-0.7384236455,
0.6855582595,
-0.4521090984,
-0.1250448674,
0.0695678741,
0.1900740862,
0.6673818231,
-0.0549350642,
-0.5251534581,
0.2168474644,
-0.9523738027,
-0.6752800941,
-0.1887981743,
-0.0951098353,
-0.6155186892,
0.2124982178,
0.0560195707,
0.8618022203,
0.1014109924,
-0.6870804429,
-0.0094415108,
0.0107114324,
-0.0159858912,
0.8639767766,
0.4211009443,
0.2480572909,
-0.1833332926,
0.379774332,
0.3437604904,
0.004574853,
-0.2878545821,
-0.3394235969,
-0.7297208309,
-0.3307974637,
-0.3704934716,
0.3353158534,
-0.8004752398,
0.3098663092,
0.3037383854,
-0.0912839025,
0.1560828835,
-0.1464170218,
0.5714233518,
1.2013127804,
0.4763055742,
0.181389004,
-0.8559547067,
-0.843214035,
-0.3150959015,
-0.1811669171,
0.151943475,
0.5580364466,
0.4557280242,
-0.184981674,
0.9516430497,
-0.62649405,
-0.7024208307,
0.3009676635,
0.4263491333,
0.3063576818,
0.3788551688,
0.7553837895,
-0.9150419235,
-0.3777578771,
-0.1207419634,
-0.9763616323,
-0.4399033785,
-0.3413691819,
-0.2693555355,
0.2451810837,
0.5665577054,
-0.5609450936,
0.547311902,
0.4199482501,
-0.8437986374,
0.5898833871,
-0.0065891915,
0.364212364,
-0.952108264,
0.2701307833,
0.3634180129,
0.2993333042,
-0.6892194152,
-0.4481725395,
0.1651341319,
0.1433022469,
-0.3912375271,
0.8626688719,
-0.2010548413,
0.1747618169,
-0.1207036003,
-0.0965367854,
-0.0307478346,
0.6678364873,
0.1962615997,
0.0991181806,
0.6949374676,
-0.4612992406,
0.0775046796,
0.3333680332,
0.0720235407,
0.9641479254,
-0.3925975263,
-0.4047613144,
-0.492477864,
0.2865472138,
-0.9335982203,
-0.3527048528,
0.3000220656,
-0.4037849009,
0.0923112482,
-0.1533369869,
-0.5299057961,
-0.0353837647,
-0.0082351491,
0.1756056994,
0.239810735,
-0.4348415136,
0.8920383453,
0.2610572577,
0.0000238126,
-0.5152820349,
-0.4145032167,
0.0068195174,
-0.5668170452,
-0.6228713989,
0.3393740654,
0.122774221,
-0.2419520766,
0.1973545402,
-0.1687133163,
-0.2494524121,
0.1304692328,
0.7232586741,
0.1689734161,
0.0763961971,
0.4638077319,
0.3471250534,
-0.4008619487,
0.3319219947,
0.0671732351,
-0.0585961193,
0.3972567916,
0.0190025494,
-0.0850001201,
0.7160898447,
0.5701341629,
-0.2032155693,
0.7530520558,
0.8705810308,
-0.7421412468,
0.0113809993,
-0.6695439219,
-0.0665215999,
-0.3721868992,
0.012109831,
-0.3683098853,
-0.8618972898,
0.7966674566,
-0.0427596197,
-0.2936541736,
0.6386300921,
0.5606812239,
0.0923671573,
0.8584438562,
0.6384589672,
-0.2983021736,
0.5051190257,
0.25865376,
0.2943644822,
-0.8809869289,
-0.3828642964,
-0.637206614,
-0.11637678,
-0.3857606053,
0.2250998318,
0.5009238124,
0.2492443323,
-0.4354515672,
0.4109482467,
-0.2825936675,
0.1181790903,
0.3423114717,
0.1579246968,
0.0738426298,
-0.3133550584,
-0.0040010172,
0.1943748444,
-0.1461957693,
-0.1055013314,
0.6813759804,
-0.3663284481,
0.081720911,
0.35656932,
0.6952536106,
0.2402927727,
0.6291478276,
-0.3234788179,
0.3943724632,
-0.0167543627,
-0.9652160406,
-0.2283533514,
-0.3830147684,
-1.1176595688,
0.2971429527,
-0.438703984,
-1.2463709116,
0.4350503683,
0.1858063191,
0.0417064019,
-0.2322179377,
-0.6670181155,
1.0601552725,
-0.0111509971,
-0.6709218621,
-0.1552184373,
-0.9077578187,
0.6396037936,
-0.1578327864,
0.2598839402,
-0.3878498375,
0.246551618,
0.7566036582,
-0.2943796515,
0.8677572012,
-0.2732760012,
0.0565217882,
0.2992672324,
-0.0732743815,
0.525780499,
0.0813859776,
-0.3839792907,
-0.1612675339,
-0.0022060594,
-0.1114901677,
-0.5862379074,
0.656932354,
-0.360660553,
-0.4835246503,
-0.3173041642,
-0.2932794392,
-0.2641835809,
0.5016954541,
0.2095750123,
0.3741181493,
0.0973546579,
-0.1704467088,
0.0443907268,
-0.0227697603,
0.5552068949,
0.7316265106,
0.2817048132,
-0.3109079599,
0.6885272264,
-0.1814759821,
-0.3046437502,
0.44636935,
0.3992300034,
-0.2063372731,
0.0282739475,
-0.0135600911,
0.1796726137,
-0.820430994,
-0.6168839931,
-0.6483086348,
0.3138437867,
-0.4496279061,
-0.2345561981,
0.1667724699,
-0.0658206344,
-0.4935332537,
-0.1509923041,
0.5213388205,
0.4123709798,
-0.1935947388,
-0.0224670768,
-0.8164690137,
0.5258857012,
0.2399133891,
0.0987366736,
0.1539970487,
0.0667085201,
-0.297457397,
-0.4217604697,
-0.1595808417,
-1.1014693975,
0.5289915204,
0.1999503672,
0.482960701,
0.6060202718,
0.4514990151,
0.7044991255,
-0.4721213281,
0.5848078132,
0.4934779704,
-1.1354651451,
0.5343066454,
-0.4845069945,
-0.2507805228,
0.4672882557,
0.6561856866,
-0.6629638672,
-0.4261163473,
-0.7183768153,
-0.9349839687,
0.7469159961,
0.4492588341,
-0.2792520225,
-0.3102801442,
0.484015584,
-0.1305748224,
0.142462343,
-0.7538759112,
-0.422957778,
0.1382654011,
-0.2537823617,
-0.2657822371,
-0.2429786325,
-0.2101512849,
-0.0738853514,
0.4720206559,
0.030467499,
0.1542678326,
0.4292907119,
-0.1222082227,
-0.4612975717,
0.0426626578,
0.5114530325,
0.2378625721,
-0.1983365864,
0.4075554907,
-0.1509100646,
0.072865583,
0.198059693,
0.3025516272,
0.1281046271,
-0.1284590513,
0.712280035,
0.6776047945,
0.3387694955,
-0.5129981041,
0.7782566547,
-0.1233333051,
0.0445968509,
-0.2583803833,
-0.1267014295,
0.1423402131,
0.5797998905,
0.1477602869,
-0.0486323163,
0.5643904209,
-0.6127712727,
0.501975894,
0.2456319779,
-0.4153510928,
-0.5253944993,
0.6482508183,
0.2292036861,
-0.1592269838,
0.2485146821,
-0.2751920819,
-0.7657092214,
0.9690569043,
0.5132322311,
0.8676939011,
-0.1364592165,
0.0730821714,
0.6439278722,
0.0370460339,
0.0392812453,
0.2727308869,
-0.1346437782,
-0.6462188363,
-0.4622694254,
-0.4366835356,
-0.2497547716,
-0.1452640593,
-0.8267112374,
0.5272957087,
0.3116820157,
-0.1082857996,
-0.0867741257,
-0.158502236,
-0.6882627606,
0.6898924708,
-0.0181088392,
0.3551822901,
-1.5592260361,
0.7004199028,
0.5380562544,
-0.6491984129,
-0.7244578004,
-0.2447433919,
0.3033996224,
-0.3878816068,
0.9368060231,
0.3289019465,
0.1423832774,
-0.2876628935,
-0.1338428259,
-0.8266232014,
0.888035953,
0.3721004426,
-0.3401788473,
0.2602132559,
-0.2724899352,
0.5940326452,
-0.2470957041,
0.1914946735,
0.3562729657,
0.6683490276,
0.0516518168,
-0.4106027484,
0.6615473628,
-0.5169852972,
-0.5807332993,
0.3752981722,
-0.4857290387,
0.9167290926,
0.1100721881,
-0.1598601639,
-0.1901427656,
0.4507890344,
0.1056003124,
0.8110268712,
0.5674849153,
0.4854948223,
0.4846819043,
-0.0401245318,
1.110200882,
-0.5061179399,
0.4151168168,
1.0686850548,
-0.413295567,
0.4532895386,
0.632381022,
0.0798231065,
0.4082309008,
0.6544089317,
0.2044352293,
0.571739316,
0.1293305606,
-0.4421180785,
-0.2809696198,
-0.3068362176,
-0.2050890476,
0.1333066523,
0.3527365625,
-0.3398917019,
-0.1840957999,
-0.1044358239,
0.121467948,
-0.154886201,
-0.1250406802,
0.5835237503,
0.151112929,
-1.0306549072,
0.0263306126,
-0.1341071427,
0.4965150058,
-0.4872788787,
-0.1188166812,
-0.3207574487,
-0.0631778017,
-0.5486112833,
-0.2981663048,
0.5609722137,
0.011130129,
-0.275162816,
-0.0630364791,
0.9804062843,
-0.5416345,
-0.3215321004,
0.5208910704,
0.3286733627,
-0.1622263491,
-0.0635654479,
-0.1703007519,
0.0047346829,
-0.2648606002,
-0.3921626508,
0.4371905625,
0.7049338222,
-0.0482115932,
0.1238065436,
0.6310365796,
-0.0295433216,
-0.3873292506,
-0.002993579,
0.7976842523,
-0.7480851412,
-0.4804936945,
-0.8858049512,
0.9664821625,
-0.1636844575,
-0.5571686625,
0.5913216472,
0.1615310162,
0.2462570816,
0.0155920302,
0.5270466805,
-0.238850385,
0.1591342986,
-0.5067503452,
0.4098251462,
-0.8461626172,
-0.123841159,
-0.7770707011,
-0.6812486053,
-0.5877617598,
0.3500798047,
-0.3125530779,
-0.2683241069,
1.0329470634,
0.4994246364,
0.2247908115,
0.0263956357,
0.2630648613,
0.1141568571,
0.3193869293,
0.6639573574,
0.7118279338,
-0.1038096473,
0.2436300069,
-0.1633058488,
-0.3262013197,
-0.1851967573,
-1.4149187803,
-0.7678271532,
-1.0065059662,
-0.5167631507,
-0.1701820493,
-0.0821582749,
0.3370500505,
0.470490098,
-0.5228770375,
0.1416430324,
-0.355589509,
0.4820791781,
-0.1705830693,
-0.2557937205,
0.6095020771,
-0.4987631738,
-0.297428757,
0.0512371436,
0.3841738105,
-0.3382710218,
0.3384786844,
0.1207612231,
-0.1672240794,
0.1766766757,
0.8544183969,
0.2926677763,
-0.4731431007,
-0.5207762122,
-0.4336658418,
0.1949941069,
-0.2204973549,
1.1333801746,
-0.5508891344,
0.2537167668,
0.5951028466,
0.4514379799,
0.6509211063,
-0.2642880082,
0.445712924,
-0.8376751542,
0.1259152293,
-0.0859403387,
0.8553513288,
0.051147949,
-0.7410606742,
0.6525141597,
0.1798454672,
-0.4896857738,
-0.6989001632,
0.3884135485,
-1.087927103,
-0.2402415425,
1.0664923191,
-0.4737846851,
-0.0560710579,
-0.0751362294,
-0.2115985751,
0.6800935268,
-0.3548920751,
0.9524059892,
0.6350393891,
-0.6481386423,
0.0471296534,
-0.123179391,
0.346585542,
0.5116974115,
-1.080796957,
-0.0528125167,
0.7782840729,
-0.0672833025,
0.0228499733,
0.5793362856,
0.1469470859,
0.1877925843,
-0.0692422017,
0.0277847983,
-0.0888919979,
-0.2528651357,
-0.1032962501,
0.2837634385,
-0.6292432547,
0.0612321645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03733v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03733v2
|
Methods to Estimate Large Language Model Confidence
| 2023-11-28T05:44:06 | 2023-12-08T07:04:52 |
Maia Kotelanski, Robert Gallo, Ashwin Nayak, Thomas Savage
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models have difficulty communicating uncertainty, which is a
significant obstacle to applying LLMs to complex medical tasks. This study
evaluates methods to measure LLM confidence when suggesting a diagnosis for
challenging clinical vignettes. GPT4 was asked a series of challenging case
questions using Chain of Thought and Self Consistency prompting. Multiple
methods were investigated to assess model confidence and evaluated on their
ability to predict the models observed accuracy. The methods evaluated were
Intrinsic Confidence, SC Agreement Frequency and CoT Response Length. SC
Agreement Frequency correlated with observed accuracy, yielding a higher Area
under the Receiver Operating Characteristic Curve compared to Intrinsic
Confidence and CoT Length analysis. SC agreement is the most useful proxy for
model confidence, especially for medical diagnosis. Model Intrinsic Confidence
and CoT Response Length exhibit a weaker ability to differentiate between
correct and incorrect answers, preventing them from being reliable and
interpretable markers for model confidence. We conclude GPT4 has a limited
ability to assess its own diagnostic accuracy. SC Agreement Frequency is the
most useful method to measure GPT4 confidence.
|
[
-0.4006784856,
-0.6664918065,
1.239620924,
0.2826004624,
-0.3031382263,
-0.0365611501,
-0.3789748847,
-0.4661102891,
-0.0564477071,
0.1071387827,
-0.2451690733,
-0.7421213388,
-0.8400952816,
0.4346878827,
-0.379370153,
0.5355472565,
-0.4008443654,
0.3915358484,
-0.0459434725,
0.0699894205,
-0.6774116158,
-0.6999514103,
-0.5764767528,
-0.2359097898,
0.3679160774,
0.1136290282,
0.5519475937,
0.2250458151,
0.8734732866,
0.3491626382,
-0.2369364202,
0.1522698551,
-0.172193259,
0.1425568163,
-0.1219504327,
-0.5256873369,
-0.6276484728,
0.021060694,
0.5567362905,
0.5620395541,
-0.3127186894,
0.0299248286,
-0.0658801496,
0.2166431397,
-0.3534394801,
0.1703000069,
-0.4713376164,
0.209140107,
-0.1681805253,
-0.1372252554,
-0.4293779135,
-0.1418253481,
0.2774417102,
-0.4001268446,
0.2850871682,
-0.0237960499,
0.7198854089,
0.0071378602,
-0.5062382221,
-0.6237505078,
-0.8658863902,
0.6339526772,
-0.874135673,
0.1806468666,
0.633635819,
0.2790602148,
-0.1961328089,
-0.7505287528,
-0.6641772389,
-0.505979538,
-0.0232229363,
0.0731459707,
-0.0627889782,
0.3752536178,
0.44292593,
0.5134854317,
-0.6180423498,
0.0379083753,
-0.2267985195,
-0.4049554169,
0.4794897735,
0.1692012548,
0.0939463153,
-0.2143237144,
-0.3836578429,
0.1546426862,
-0.5823393464,
-0.1756498516,
0.0229122937,
0.0950906053,
-0.0278189555,
0.5584642887,
-0.0675259158,
0.6212597489,
0.1289429218,
-0.4821815789,
0.2824177146,
-0.3608551025,
-0.3243534267,
-0.0640850216,
0.9154390693,
0.331427753,
0.2733546197,
0.0213379245,
-0.2855294347,
0.031778127,
0.3487743437,
-0.5440739393,
0.0082558086,
0.3673701286,
-0.3528423011,
-0.0566303581,
-0.159459129,
-0.5380306244,
-0.430654645,
-0.0697660372,
0.4648009539,
-0.3823590875,
-0.2309582829,
0.0595275015,
0.0634728819,
0.2782544196,
0.3560691476,
-0.7305771112,
0.2109269798,
0.4077480733,
0.9041068554,
-0.2728212774,
0.1729534566,
-0.3498896658,
0.0374646112,
-0.6667391062,
0.6433139443,
-0.3446556926,
-0.5628559589,
-0.0845640153,
0.2318216413,
-0.3760697544,
-0.3881876171,
0.7395976186,
-0.1044905037,
0.0306367315,
-0.2798980772,
-0.7352595329,
-0.1154577658,
0.3344153166,
-0.313018024,
0.854096055,
0.4950287044,
-0.6639559865,
0.2362903208,
-0.0448795408,
-0.1440561265,
0.0317292809,
-0.4461457431,
-0.458594203,
0.2324034423,
0.0981911346,
0.7418484092,
-0.2609416842,
0.4957178533,
-0.4160747826,
-0.3788684309,
0.327272445,
-0.5692893267,
0.0878259242,
0.0896277204,
-0.3003000319,
-0.0791853443,
-0.3325069845,
0.1357679963,
0.0793330818,
-0.0304734576,
-0.1648059338,
-0.2202692181,
-0.5025804043,
0.1142752394,
0.3468433321,
-0.3991741538,
0.3291184008,
-0.3635595441,
0.2240692228,
0.560890317,
0.2702825665,
-0.3321996033,
-0.3633495271,
0.7706769705,
0.0773501769,
0.1021031141,
0.1530929208,
-0.9111241698,
-0.5756616592,
-0.0288143568,
0.3501934111,
0.4213643074,
-0.4154776335,
0.2936906517,
-0.2119120955,
-0.4995624721,
-0.44229725,
0.1456975639,
0.5908930898,
0.6291314363,
0.4692955315,
-0.2609014809,
-0.2852934599,
-0.9987652302,
-0.1347274184,
-0.2187671363,
-0.090627335,
0.3214225173,
0.4805665314,
-0.1789330244,
0.3662467301,
-0.3843307495,
-0.0480438024,
-0.1613333523,
0.4385387003,
0.2886842191,
0.3811888993,
0.4803908765,
-0.5715931058,
-0.526063323,
0.1578092277,
-0.8720112443,
0.1955165565,
0.2436787188,
0.2619893849,
0.5099254847,
0.390481025,
-0.6380265355,
0.5629827976,
0.8106656075,
-0.2395549715,
0.5770707726,
-0.5328509212,
0.6388556957,
-0.8335251212,
-0.1813928187,
0.22999762,
-0.4057438076,
-0.486446619,
0.1167120337,
0.1812634021,
0.520896256,
-0.0821004882,
0.155258745,
-0.522334218,
-0.0144403838,
-0.0712835342,
0.3486489952,
-0.0744379982,
0.0700598955,
0.1097094789,
0.8074068427,
0.3659666479,
-0.4776546657,
0.4461895525,
0.0004478075,
-0.3427399397,
0.5991111994,
-0.8018758893,
0.2541599572,
0.1662273258,
-0.0362650603,
-1.4407391548,
-0.3095671535,
-0.0463133231,
-0.4662666321,
0.6019635201,
-0.1773597449,
-0.1990111172,
-0.8287878036,
0.0340436473,
0.3700315058,
0.5146333575,
-0.1349440366,
0.6498954892,
-0.0052812072,
-0.4547584355,
-0.4894715846,
-0.7632091045,
-0.1011728868,
-0.3373121023,
-0.6352704763,
0.250598222,
-0.2355048209,
-0.2518145144,
-0.5091058016,
-0.2885068655,
-0.2751030624,
-0.031445574,
0.2222848833,
0.3912980855,
-0.3689145148,
0.3482848406,
-0.0580919199,
0.0100577408,
0.1191933528,
0.3065586984,
0.5590187907,
-0.4424775839,
-0.7801268101,
-0.5272855759,
0.0868161619,
0.6176704764,
0.1645047963,
0.3106350899,
0.4719914198,
-0.4074496925,
0.2227695137,
-0.8410944939,
-0.1195479035,
-0.4104565084,
0.1709215343,
-0.5957100391,
-0.7740018368,
0.771946013,
-0.0937427059,
-0.4311896265,
0.577921629,
0.7866353989,
-0.1429781616,
1.2247728109,
0.3683792651,
0.1497463733,
-0.168679744,
0.1388009042,
0.4142144024,
-0.7667500377,
-0.2101624608,
-0.5964664817,
0.089062795,
-0.5545040965,
-0.7377912402,
0.6459729671,
0.0492940396,
-0.2482945025,
-0.0568607897,
-0.4890138805,
0.022645846,
0.2113898695,
0.3254981637,
0.4419457316,
-0.2362421304,
-0.3256551027,
-0.2678025365,
-0.3999539316,
-0.5528011322,
1.1053314209,
0.602889061,
0.5641420484,
0.2392510027,
0.3839959502,
0.0990085453,
0.4165418446,
-0.948341012,
0.2148820758,
0.0235858038,
-0.6647242904,
-0.4372774661,
-0.3686218858,
-0.7175801396,
0.1028779075,
-0.1173746586,
-0.7460161448,
0.029263882,
0.1270481646,
-0.4986712635,
-0.0386100858,
-0.6204089522,
0.6465097666,
-0.207311213,
-0.0149496784,
0.1262295097,
-0.6097041368,
0.6600279212,
-0.4082231522,
0.1721944362,
-0.1142418161,
-0.1031410173,
0.5557097793,
-0.2877343893,
0.6583306193,
0.0348562971,
-0.3167042732,
0.2346125692,
0.2050380111,
0.6156331897,
0.1313405633,
-0.2217857093,
0.2437556982,
0.2070459574,
-0.244866088,
-0.5825623274,
0.5607471466,
-0.5376709104,
-0.7976906896,
-0.6800096631,
-0.4640814662,
-0.6922376156,
0.0621157847,
0.4670875072,
0.3886986971,
-0.0452195033,
0.1955079436,
0.8340942264,
-0.2080041468,
0.346133858,
0.5211038589,
-0.0323283635,
-0.0943734571,
0.2210952491,
0.2272709459,
0.6119526029,
-0.0278020836,
0.3840417564,
-0.3845233321,
-0.9560679793,
-0.2650093734,
0.3576753438,
-0.5858525038,
-0.3126505315,
-0.5262037516,
-0.4354743659,
-0.6109665036,
0.0054129451,
-0.4486846924,
-0.0903175175,
-0.0095591545,
-0.3017737269,
0.5971467495,
0.8629003763,
0.3809011579,
0.2974808812,
-0.6087714434,
0.2386868,
-0.0459341332,
0.328609705,
-0.3472991586,
-0.7521166801,
0.0449415632,
0.1539278626,
-0.1020236686,
-1.0098774433,
0.5970087647,
-0.103599228,
0.617469728,
0.3239261508,
0.1223368868,
0.8503614068,
-0.2607670128,
0.9680418968,
0.2701149583,
-1.1426649094,
0.506080389,
-0.3634276986,
-0.125518322,
0.2989164591,
0.7085639238,
-0.2084335238,
-0.5886645317,
-0.6212503314,
-0.5203566551,
0.1170494407,
0.003724037,
-0.227821067,
-0.0794501528,
0.7853211761,
-0.1805768162,
0.1075235605,
-0.5786041617,
-0.0790955722,
0.139615804,
-0.3435353935,
-0.2844735086,
-0.4217547178,
-0.3161823452,
-0.4754275084,
0.3290390968,
-0.4457496703,
0.385719806,
0.6494899988,
0.2764846087,
-0.190052852,
0.2639071047,
0.8977991939,
1.0901277065,
-0.219704926,
0.1220520958,
0.5769402385,
-0.6010328531,
0.1872115433,
-0.1936106086,
0.2730791271,
0.1970273256,
0.5106630921,
0.4717882872,
0.0886749178,
-0.4979920387,
1.0081726313,
-0.2042253464,
-0.5570630431,
-0.6240718365,
-0.0195624009,
0.3647684157,
0.1348327696,
0.0188250002,
-0.2074801028,
0.1149972901,
-0.3751738369,
0.0735897049,
0.5272235274,
-0.612189889,
0.0263277944,
0.2107173353,
-0.1976235807,
-0.0171860885,
0.7383467555,
-0.1762633175,
-0.3900336921,
0.6784131527,
0.7109254003,
0.4675492048,
-0.5715026259,
0.1661528796,
0.2752369344,
0.4263372719,
-0.4305675328,
0.4878247082,
0.5557290912,
-0.82143116,
-0.6184152365,
-0.453022331,
-0.5656519532,
0.1841573566,
-0.8892543912,
0.2461718768,
-0.4619338214,
-0.4904613197,
-0.1681798846,
0.1563542783,
-0.4945224822,
0.4597393274,
-0.046111159,
0.8572524786,
-0.6583505869,
0.7533666492,
0.2538537085,
-0.3643352389,
-1.4928689003,
0.0272642281,
0.0932150707,
-1.0886167288,
0.3934864998,
-0.0303578675,
-0.1056145653,
-0.3132981062,
-0.6212647557,
-0.8984043598,
1.1831386089,
0.2234052569,
-0.6991403103,
-0.0074823718,
-0.3057402074,
0.7484925389,
-0.4617952406,
0.4365401864,
0.6435210109,
0.742851913,
0.4180800915,
-1.4312833548,
0.3497391343,
0.1229764819,
0.0402362943,
0.1275034696,
-0.3986344635,
1.0247148275,
-0.3503766954,
-0.0072008492,
0.3027185798,
0.4201589227,
0.4700909257,
0.3796600997,
0.3515503109,
0.2615050972,
1.2252957821,
-0.232925415,
1.3092013597,
-0.4485227168,
0.5316495895,
0.7128055692,
-0.3871788085,
0.9657825232,
0.2884176672,
-0.2426916063,
0.5626147389,
0.6775811315,
0.0013420866,
-0.0405977629,
0.3413242102,
-0.2995881736,
-0.3783717155,
0.219335258,
-0.6973012686,
0.3835714161,
0.8708197474,
-0.5530841947,
0.2099950016,
-0.1106294319,
0.1829626858,
-0.0908065662,
-0.2555901408,
0.5860107541,
0.2693323791,
-0.78688097,
0.9145891666,
-0.0156898852,
0.419101119,
-0.568723321,
0.0280400328,
-0.1140266135,
0.203911081,
-0.1463550478,
-0.8193641305,
0.1596100479,
-0.2394722551,
-0.0335967727,
0.2781879306,
0.5547382832,
-0.3391813338,
-0.4872215092,
0.0942750573,
0.5197597146,
0.4206312001,
-0.1072506979,
-0.4680866599,
0.1370773613,
-0.1054485515,
-0.2826387286,
0.1609287858,
0.6402804852,
-0.0455650091,
0.8696721792,
0.1389150918,
0.4001266658,
-0.1181318313,
-0.0550179295,
0.5272755623,
-0.6066948175,
-0.05174971,
-0.5809893012,
0.1034259945,
-0.1698021889,
-0.386957109,
0.7351785898,
0.0430649407,
0.4573317766,
-0.0060318932,
0.9020647407,
0.246935606,
0.6555371881,
-0.7170591354,
0.2104796618,
-0.3060789704,
0.2966190279,
-0.4005643129,
-0.4898689091,
-0.3688857257,
0.9602838159,
-0.5563379526,
0.4681346714,
1.2394992113,
0.6934635043,
0.1728013903,
0.1955940723,
0.5730950236,
0.7263523936,
0.2708727717,
0.6698935628,
0.6502931118,
-0.1420190036,
0.2061643153,
-0.1772608608,
-0.4996352494,
-0.246419549,
-1.0237156153,
-0.9296726584,
-0.2713767886,
-0.2509798408,
-0.6521801949,
0.0640221089,
0.8723084927,
0.8709053397,
-0.8071169853,
-0.0062328191,
0.0075392411,
0.0462351218,
-0.2864542007,
-0.155839473,
0.3621786237,
-0.073554188,
-0.5758298635,
0.4039208293,
0.2262843549,
0.2811186314,
-0.3409886658,
0.0763366222,
0.0761437118,
-0.0867489949,
0.4130237997,
0.0364928246,
-0.9385863543,
-0.6155599356,
-0.0321403407,
-0.3782694042,
-0.0042221965,
0.68363446,
-0.2687098384,
0.4618888497,
0.1858568341,
0.3412595987,
0.4697811902,
0.2779712975,
0.8687186837,
-0.3824497759,
-0.1160827354,
0.3854821324,
0.466827184,
0.2064468414,
-0.7613673806,
0.5283447504,
0.3497817218,
-0.8130363822,
-0.6625574231,
0.1775143296,
-1.2510193586,
-0.1143605933,
1.2091369629,
-0.5501422882,
-0.0858410746,
-0.5269593596,
-0.0582137033,
-0.031997364,
-0.1955136806,
0.4688548148,
0.9997806549,
-0.5138481855,
0.0106441677,
-0.9398498535,
0.5590242147,
0.1681583822,
-0.3050831258,
-0.2057749331,
0.2926494479,
0.5779877901,
0.2452951372,
0.8113384843,
-0.4092939794,
0.1889777184,
-0.0629124343,
-0.0659908205,
0.3114932775,
-0.1752780378,
-0.278234899,
0.3001008332,
0.3442851007,
0.3215528727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16522v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16522v4
|
Dynamic Fault Characteristics Evaluation in Power Grid
| 2023-11-28T05:00:27 | 2024-01-27T07:28:42 |
Hao Pei, Si Lin, Chuanfu Li, Che Wang, Haoming Chen, Sizhe Li
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, eess.SP
|
To enhance the intelligence degree in operation and maintenance, a novel
method for fault detection in power grids is proposed. The proposed GNN-based
approach first identifies fault nodes through a specialized feature extraction
method coupled with a knowledge graph. By incorporating temporal data, the
method leverages the status of nodes from preceding and subsequent time periods
to help current fault detection. To validate the effectiveness of the node
features, a correlation analysis of the output features from each node was
conducted. The results from experiments show that this method can accurately
locate fault nodes in simulation scenarios with a remarkable accuracy.
Additionally, the graph neural network based feature modeling allows for a
qualitative examination of how faults spread across nodes, which provides
valuable insights for analyzing fault nodes.
|
[
-0.5922797918,
-0.6567652822,
0.6682075262,
0.1263305098,
-0.3442882001,
0.4939500988,
0.1916281283,
-0.4681397378,
0.151848346,
0.1358902603,
-0.6609276533,
-0.5047106147,
-0.3451023698,
-0.1324108392,
-0.4469306171,
0.7100144625,
-0.2143573612,
-0.3186256289,
-0.452834785,
0.1166273504,
-0.3127365708,
-0.1709808707,
-0.5098334551,
-0.7828881145,
0.2579126954,
0.1899378598,
0.7663248777,
0.3492055237,
0.4781995714,
0.5192177296,
-0.2519709766,
0.4407564998,
-0.3813881278,
0.2483194917,
0.0113963867,
-0.2680627704,
-0.5603126287,
-0.0615380704,
0.8859240413,
0.2691525221,
0.1339568049,
0.0728488714,
-0.0777338147,
0.3688033819,
-0.2706620395,
0.5647559762,
-0.7992284894,
0.5728179812,
-0.1096029133,
-0.4625160694,
0.0926800445,
-0.6119073033,
-0.0521948189,
-0.3665644228,
0.4327148497,
0.0145461606,
1.1793681383,
0.0523076206,
-0.3145888746,
0.2053260058,
-0.6875952482,
0.452780664,
-0.3201151192,
0.2593741715,
-0.1856075525,
1.1249552965,
-0.0839767233,
-0.7683794498,
-0.3743090928,
-0.4238809049,
-0.3225648701,
-0.0413493365,
0.181692034,
-0.0283428673,
0.4950067699,
0.4802321494,
-0.4393877685,
0.2380833179,
0.3216072917,
-0.2710742354,
0.9063913822,
0.5682134032,
0.2990025878,
-0.5952535272,
-0.3598402441,
-0.0025956654,
-0.2983313799,
0.1965478361,
0.8495994806,
0.1315141618,
-0.0230156183,
-0.1893368959,
-0.1892355233,
0.5454394817,
-0.1553773433,
-0.2722567916,
0.3714749217,
-0.5764042735,
-0.240663588,
0.0320550054,
0.8145279884,
0.1576868743,
0.1379008144,
-0.3587260246,
-0.3161095679,
-0.3845450282,
0.3424730301,
-0.5107139349,
-0.5797625184,
-0.1371025294,
-0.7907791734,
-0.96834445,
0.0165723152,
-0.9845698476,
-0.9463155866,
-0.2642736733,
0.0953900665,
-0.235585019,
-0.837649703,
-0.299998641,
-0.2727288008,
0.0179343075,
0.2242339849,
-0.3416789472,
0.2606719732,
0.6485776305,
1.0590404272,
-0.0808870867,
0.0213994831,
-0.4272158742,
-0.3288355768,
0.0257600714,
0.8594014645,
-0.3922548592,
-0.0849884897,
-0.2128724307,
0.305796355,
-0.1211440712,
-0.6685820818,
0.0601650402,
-0.5092656612,
-0.6021255255,
-0.2650598586,
-0.0369398668,
-0.4260143042,
0.2396119684,
-0.7971436381,
0.9394141436,
0.5332666039,
-1.0643610954,
0.3584674001,
-0.569822371,
-0.2065892369,
-0.0157602374,
-0.1250334829,
-0.8302375078,
-0.0787132755,
-0.1647410244,
0.2543831468,
-0.0805874392,
0.3094909191,
-0.4736860693,
-0.3135428727,
0.3503162265,
-0.5997518301,
0.470726639,
0.2270815372,
-0.3391392827,
0.3753549457,
-1.2359342575,
0.4550953805,
0.284034133,
0.3131477237,
-0.1059464142,
0.4414652586,
-0.3646980226,
0.3747059107,
0.2796718776,
-0.5636800528,
0.009941251,
-0.1853222549,
0.0159482043,
0.3779736757,
0.416218549,
-0.0985258296,
-0.0680756047,
0.6189425588,
0.1020141542,
0.4140370488,
0.248603195,
-0.4390402138,
-0.4688027799,
0.267403245,
0.1918762773,
0.6501990557,
-0.7632571459,
0.9297959805,
-0.0468200371,
-0.5198226571,
0.1431607157,
-0.0490691327,
0.4945649505,
0.4983088076,
0.3460081816,
-0.1939293891,
-0.6218988895,
-0.6658962965,
-0.130585447,
-0.1126675904,
0.0401757136,
0.3631581366,
0.218320176,
0.2970263362,
0.8858602047,
-0.431578517,
0.1958035976,
-0.387360692,
0.1989347637,
0.4390744865,
0.2209881544,
0.5304415822,
-0.818960011,
-0.534380734,
0.6560316682,
-0.967433691,
-0.1963101774,
0.0713958889,
0.4177370369,
-0.4020771086,
0.5162750483,
0.0188515894,
0.8392688036,
0.3306281567,
-0.3186897635,
0.8869311213,
-0.27381441,
0.3466675282,
-0.4812538624,
0.354870826,
-0.166702047,
-0.3767112195,
-0.4252822697,
-0.3071097434,
0.0214196611,
-0.2709954679,
-0.3297512233,
-0.0766213313,
-0.567330122,
-0.5400384068,
-0.1317569911,
0.1049272344,
0.1723912954,
-0.1360081881,
-0.8103858232,
0.5426740646,
0.3816327453,
-0.6341709495,
1.2249038219,
-0.037413571,
-0.7609329224,
0.4532889724,
-0.605884552,
0.1663168818,
-0.1056074277,
-0.4378463328,
-0.8931357265,
-0.0582093112,
0.1364803612,
-0.0574554838,
0.6854383945,
-0.3767686486,
-0.2275048494,
-0.7736157775,
0.0866660476,
0.2509621382,
0.3738663197,
-0.2013220042,
0.5516806245,
0.1270134598,
-0.0004817506,
-0.3683835268,
-0.1246519387,
0.0865074694,
-0.0690935031,
-0.9169690609,
0.4144909084,
0.5062075853,
-0.3855737448,
0.1234462634,
0.1107930839,
0.2074341029,
0.7619578838,
0.4612935185,
-0.2018044591,
-0.0183828156,
0.2680152357,
-0.0623247661,
-0.4174572527,
-0.0460958183,
-0.1531906575,
0.8930049539,
-0.2930649519,
-0.4663529694,
-0.6254010201,
0.2827729583,
0.5500801206,
-0.4800527692,
0.2869001329,
0.6703845263,
-0.0856993124,
-0.2306115925,
-0.1542405486,
0.0330784172,
-0.5398944616,
0.7646391988,
-0.2286421359,
-0.1236802861,
1.0166426897,
-0.5601742864,
-0.3849575222,
0.5300303698,
-0.0064261835,
0.2248953581,
1.2042276859,
0.6850866079,
-0.0252132397,
0.4722493589,
-0.4460996985,
0.6156414747,
-0.6562803388,
-0.5631415248,
-0.539145112,
-0.7163623571,
-0.5711760521,
0.0968045369,
0.6235664487,
0.1648540348,
-0.2720326185,
-0.0094247758,
-0.5866384506,
0.0726360306,
-0.1661272943,
0.2699812949,
-0.0311824046,
-0.116432406,
-0.6811261177,
0.1301781535,
-0.4888314903,
-0.1219709143,
0.2254164368,
0.5329637527,
0.5472871661,
-0.1595742553,
0.4026524127,
0.3406155705,
0.0366415717,
-0.87888515,
0.5116296411,
-0.1456161588,
0.2257617563,
-0.6475049853,
-0.6262329221,
-0.7968558669,
-0.2379135638,
-0.0756480247,
-0.7554835081,
0.3113400936,
0.1923570633,
-0.4235658646,
0.7861165404,
-0.6267844439,
0.8373453617,
-0.613927722,
0.1118082926,
0.0860439613,
-0.2113383114,
0.2797860503,
0.2502257824,
-0.1687949747,
-0.1680342853,
0.3293183744,
0.4209391475,
-0.888525486,
0.4181064665,
-0.6720818281,
0.0667447001,
0.508529067,
-0.0375287868,
0.6186736226,
0.0525531508,
-0.3601911068,
-0.0029608095,
-0.3406654596,
0.0316500962,
-0.9208976626,
0.7904318571,
-0.6678933501,
-0.430611521,
-0.3632438183,
-0.5681833625,
-0.2439472228,
0.1205328181,
-0.0027949414,
0.4597581029,
0.0441078581,
0.1118506193,
0.4030016661,
-0.3095882535,
1.0143564939,
0.0758603811,
-0.4064834714,
-0.4307271838,
0.8863732219,
0.4772018194,
0.130807668,
-0.107575506,
0.2591789365,
-0.2732580006,
-0.7031177878,
-0.1818463206,
-0.0278919004,
-0.596578002,
-0.388853997,
-0.7341951728,
-0.6840277314,
-0.1414905787,
0.1726997048,
-0.3152498901,
-0.0662156045,
-0.0559676364,
-0.1825823635,
0.5768313408,
0.8332793713,
0.2068744302,
0.3917382061,
-0.7489271164,
0.1025007069,
0.596021831,
0.586676836,
0.1738825142,
0.1027993113,
-0.164409101,
-0.2517861426,
-0.6492013335,
-0.8989640474,
0.5900256038,
0.3849937022,
0.8738623857,
0.6497175694,
-0.0164459422,
0.4209230244,
-0.3483453691,
0.7165752053,
0.3599681854,
-0.9332782626,
0.6422281861,
-0.1009088606,
0.2038480192,
0.2025353014,
0.2083343416,
-0.2746660113,
0.1107799783,
-0.891513288,
-0.5983816981,
0.3644472361,
-0.1570610553,
-0.4695370495,
0.1512239277,
0.5980272293,
-0.1356171221,
0.2138542831,
0.1472903639,
-0.2617576718,
-0.4445033073,
0.1320654452,
0.1237842292,
-0.2535072863,
0.0116610546,
-0.3442836702,
0.2824983895,
-0.3829016685,
0.5549464822,
0.0291543137,
0.250520438,
-0.2742781639,
-0.0616158545,
0.5154494047,
1.1349666119,
-0.2970357537,
0.1914087832,
0.4875983894,
-0.4979602695,
0.2471547723,
0.0590698048,
-0.2080897987,
0.5392236114,
-0.0085154874,
0.7573924065,
-0.0953495875,
0.3198973238,
0.4430323243,
-0.0702155307,
0.0239426158,
-0.2634929121,
0.4883401394,
-0.1694663167,
0.3489988148,
0.1992156953,
0.20511204,
0.2981834114,
-0.5628454089,
0.4599241018,
0.591250062,
-0.8668634892,
-0.4334084094,
0.0435582548,
-0.0208772738,
-0.465613693,
0.5531817675,
-0.4451763332,
-0.9869456887,
1.4613342285,
0.411790967,
0.8507285118,
-0.4481567144,
0.3529818058,
0.2129306644,
0.2823103964,
0.3870638311,
0.7579878569,
0.3703677058,
-0.6269598603,
-0.2784953117,
-0.5916470289,
-0.2128626406,
0.2499966025,
-0.5416160822,
0.543536365,
-0.802313447,
-0.3332254589,
-0.0118427016,
0.4391699135,
-0.8495348096,
0.4332328737,
-0.118109636,
0.8240544796,
-0.9217128158,
0.5894860625,
0.2930570543,
0.0328700319,
-0.9951654077,
-0.3205669224,
-0.1631552875,
-0.7084646821,
0.5426668525,
0.1608980447,
0.1972557902,
-0.071413219,
-0.2326380759,
-0.9282015562,
1.5139548779,
0.313429147,
-0.4645870328,
0.2744465768,
-0.1147606969,
0.4521824419,
-0.3353135586,
0.7712946534,
0.3895049393,
0.9217686653,
0.0892699808,
-1.0168853998,
0.1015160605,
-0.3643253148,
0.0787891224,
0.6319111586,
-0.7264220715,
1.0626400709,
-0.0177646205,
-0.1894475073,
-0.4439634681,
0.6845427155,
-0.1701019406,
0.5619418621,
0.87469697,
0.380304575,
1.2275010347,
-0.3554204404,
1.1174273491,
-0.1991361678,
0.6591828465,
0.6483616233,
-0.2549774349,
-0.0141827194,
-0.1674246341,
-0.2441182286,
0.9664666057,
0.2924124002,
-0.3964911401,
0.6578900814,
0.5793973804,
-0.2361902148,
-0.3938597441,
-0.2385838926,
-0.7721494436,
0.6206552386,
0.3456904888,
-0.5176545978,
-0.5769261718,
-0.1425349414,
-0.0038085568,
-0.4239589572,
-0.5310510397,
0.5238009691,
-0.0211239159,
-0.2787785232,
0.6040176153,
-0.2765726149,
-0.0906698778,
-0.5918541551,
-0.3567024767,
0.059458144,
0.1681178808,
-0.7205892801,
-0.7289040685,
0.4612973332,
-0.3269384205,
-0.2013597488,
0.0487348363,
1.1947644949,
0.080848977,
-0.4072467387,
0.2477344275,
0.163849473,
0.2107812017,
-0.1158380583,
-0.334231019,
-0.0094249938,
-0.2778708935,
0.1661959291,
0.367221117,
0.8465301991,
-0.1917892992,
0.5577130318,
0.2695559263,
0.306897074,
-0.0832714587,
0.3552011847,
1.1080598831,
-0.6213289499,
-0.4814350009,
-0.3846364021,
0.8007600904,
-0.9373114705,
-0.2308763117,
0.6498126388,
0.0566972755,
0.1424884051,
0.0823043734,
1.0063203573,
0.0118156318,
0.2069807649,
-0.4040771425,
1.0620952845,
-0.2170866728,
0.2023831308,
-0.12881428,
-0.5901432037,
-0.174406603,
0.2174498737,
-0.4976361096,
0.227817148,
0.9913352728,
0.6393601894,
-0.1546851546,
0.1564251482,
0.6081601381,
0.2895372808,
0.54987216,
0.2476086169,
1.1246939898,
-0.4823170602,
0.1596954912,
-0.4452874362,
-0.4270221591,
-0.3037929535,
-1.4855049849,
-0.5230662227,
0.0624357201,
-0.5096367002,
-0.4099505544,
-0.1015757695,
0.4963262379,
0.3601182699,
-1.1897557974,
0.284130007,
-0.1539258957,
0.6614477038,
-0.6364354491,
-0.2547831237,
0.4306578934,
-0.6471588016,
0.1037606075,
0.4920906126,
0.3638516068,
-0.2063861489,
-0.5170103312,
0.1017774865,
-0.0422126986,
-0.3971841037,
0.2535454333,
-0.0378499441,
-0.0194247887,
-0.9152833819,
-0.07515762,
0.3013014197,
-0.2068573236,
0.9225684404,
-0.7014110088,
0.4107002616,
1.0112066269,
0.2835531831,
0.2053990513,
-0.1647069305,
0.4066645205,
-0.6700699329,
0.1299530864,
0.1438871771,
0.4858418703,
0.3232605159,
-0.8697340488,
0.0438819677,
0.7622658014,
-0.5978361368,
-0.6264507174,
0.1537138969,
-0.8696749806,
0.2549316883,
0.8357835412,
-0.6946757436,
-0.2601728141,
-0.7638369799,
0.1496263742,
0.4034988582,
0.2143395543,
0.7795579433,
0.2261548936,
-0.3654153645,
-0.0955771655,
-0.1894490421,
0.5761401057,
-0.3513349295,
-0.8635827303,
-0.2985450029,
-0.1838212907,
0.2118734419,
0.5754294991,
-0.1531562358,
-0.2809140384,
0.3182886839,
0.1089629158,
0.147095412,
-0.6815713048,
-0.7188305855,
-0.2729220092,
0.6797140241,
-0.0714225695,
-0.0646168068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16509v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16509v2
|
StyleCap: Automatic Speaking-Style Captioning from Speech Based on Speech and Language Self-supervised Learning Models
| 2023-11-28T04:49:17 | 2023-12-27T14:41:23 |
Kazuki Yamauchi, Yusuke Ijima, Yuki Saito
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
We propose StyleCap, a method to generate natural language descriptions of
speaking styles appearing in speech. Although most of conventional techniques
for para-/non-linguistic information recognition focus on the category
classification or the intensity estimation of pre-defined labels, they cannot
provide the reasoning of the recognition result in an interpretable manner.
StyleCap is a first step towards an end-to-end method for generating
speaking-style prompts from speech, i.e., automatic speaking-style captioning.
StyleCap is trained with paired data of speech and natural language
descriptions. We train neural networks that convert a speech representation
vector into prefix vectors that are fed into a large language model (LLM)-based
text decoder. We explore an appropriate text decoder and speech feature
representation suitable for this new task. The experimental results demonstrate
that our StyleCap leveraging richer LLMs for the text decoder, speech
self-supervised learning (SSL) features, and sentence rephrasing augmentation
improves the accuracy and diversity of generated speaking-style captions.
Samples of speaking-style captions generated by our StyleCap are publicly
available.
|
[
-0.3097648919,
-0.4336569011,
0.0198237766,
0.433337003,
-0.2667764425,
0.3613274992,
-0.2821302116,
-0.3773334622,
0.8183754683,
0.5307119489,
-0.5539351106,
-0.3414963782,
-0.3670142293,
0.3469902575,
-0.3309684694,
0.8729833961,
0.2618434429,
0.1718707085,
-0.3093731999,
0.1585730314,
-0.7709963322,
-0.5754063725,
-0.6067382097,
0.0388061181,
0.1986165941,
0.7363581061,
0.3375185728,
0.5645056367,
0.3026868701,
0.2463377118,
0.3715447485,
0.2968756557,
-0.3175837696,
0.2653455436,
0.088415131,
-0.3925868869,
-0.3710795641,
0.2060716599,
0.4656763375,
0.4209431708,
-0.0061157481,
0.1444518566,
0.0049023968,
0.3808667064,
-0.3915980756,
0.5559032559,
-0.8181329966,
0.2295453548,
-0.3229155838,
-0.6217388511,
-0.4833868146,
-0.0083371606,
0.153447777,
-0.3004948199,
0.3037973642,
0.6191718578,
0.6628468633,
0.1492810845,
0.11331743,
-0.2836407125,
-0.6640521288,
0.634916544,
-0.4851507545,
0.3172041178,
0.4833225608,
0.7929164767,
0.3601450622,
-0.5476928353,
-0.6371130347,
-0.0733629689,
-0.254445672,
0.0973785743,
-0.1828839779,
-0.1064909697,
0.011657807,
0.3103724122,
-0.5143580437,
-0.0110562146,
-0.5610106587,
-0.4860410988,
0.9192288518,
-0.0038668264,
0.3433038592,
-0.348164022,
-0.3314076364,
-0.1799038798,
-0.5673267841,
0.0064628208,
0.3162730932,
0.7373960018,
-0.3109743595,
0.206328854,
-0.3573687673,
0.5612927675,
0.001957349,
-0.1823862642,
0.2703038752,
-0.3135258257,
-0.194775492,
0.5379416347,
0.9030244946,
0.7147046328,
0.3923521936,
-0.363145709,
-0.14481318,
-0.4745184779,
0.264088273,
-0.4154523909,
-0.3485682607,
-0.13909325,
-0.2290433198,
-0.5099158287,
0.1030303389,
-0.8809395432,
-0.3141377568,
-0.5698464513,
0.4154716432,
-0.1172368303,
-0.0287170559,
-0.1014190614,
-0.1969878525,
0.5325822234,
0.0851276815,
-1.0596690178,
0.4417825341,
0.2154740393,
1.039432168,
-0.5471255183,
-0.1473362446,
-0.6161251664,
0.1735189259,
-0.443857044,
0.6703774333,
-0.377809912,
-0.1689258218,
0.2142885178,
0.191932261,
0.2993631363,
-0.2828833759,
0.1857521236,
-0.4947876334,
-0.0083683003,
-0.2463561893,
-0.4170432687,
0.2837376595,
-0.2062655538,
-0.5283619761,
0.5284008384,
-0.2803254724,
-0.5427337289,
0.3151152432,
-0.8314611316,
-0.6482725739,
0.4614575803,
-0.1960814297,
-0.5197477341,
-0.2393887788,
0.5265487432,
0.6873904467,
-0.056715671,
0.2195485383,
-0.0005784267,
-0.2141716778,
0.2620971501,
-0.4018324018,
0.5723095536,
0.4503470659,
-0.2168611884,
0.4375529289,
-0.5825269222,
-0.2665497661,
0.4801471829,
0.2380772829,
-0.0246617179,
-0.3050239682,
0.1841724068,
-0.1111639738,
0.3908550143,
-0.5192247033,
-0.0187095515,
-0.3057089746,
0.8496744037,
0.6806873679,
-0.0098225316,
0.4737752974,
-0.2613448501,
0.5840758085,
-0.4432881176,
0.1514519751,
-0.4312899113,
-0.3482635319,
-0.7861166596,
-0.2480858266,
0.0870616287,
0.6088290215,
-0.6613679528,
0.5724816322,
-0.1072685495,
-0.4999518692,
-0.3770569861,
-0.0435341597,
0.2275542617,
0.7301492095,
0.5932297707,
-0.2716856897,
-0.7962184548,
-1.0475927591,
-0.0664413497,
-0.0531580113,
0.0801629052,
0.2663625777,
0.1843374223,
0.1632813215,
1.2113841772,
-0.4440530539,
-0.500433743,
-0.5877851248,
0.2976608276,
-0.0892357081,
0.3311882913,
0.5390521884,
-0.665841639,
-0.5251243711,
-0.472034961,
-0.5107587576,
-0.3700756729,
-0.1725604981,
0.0223766584,
0.1670508087,
0.9202715158,
0.0617787652,
0.1603385508,
0.3342009485,
0.1062604859,
0.7109942436,
-0.0359942801,
0.0388740152,
-0.9874026179,
-0.1117944121,
-0.0616712347,
-0.4012446404,
-0.6330614686,
-0.3514767885,
-0.185646683,
-0.653654933,
-0.4095019698,
0.6064017415,
-0.4179117084,
-0.3421957493,
-0.3868862391,
0.0726670995,
0.2865534425,
0.5612842441,
0.434360534,
1.1007133722,
0.9441511035,
-0.341997683,
0.7595463395,
0.3481595218,
-0.2776435018,
0.4754379392,
-0.5694692731,
0.2870809138,
-0.1882776916,
0.1486528665,
-1.3949109316,
-0.5090159178,
0.2833303809,
-0.3548955321,
0.6499457359,
-0.1920242608,
-0.4195807874,
-0.2341718078,
-0.1340426654,
0.1584387124,
0.3695451021,
-0.6353238225,
0.2601118386,
0.6206910014,
-0.6523513198,
-0.2944299877,
-0.7970030904,
0.4457859397,
-0.3140254021,
-0.4605582654,
0.4448876083,
-0.0264027733,
0.0221215114,
-0.5297025442,
-0.0619525835,
-0.2123092115,
-0.16215083,
0.1466459781,
0.2676191926,
-0.0007228419,
0.3097538054,
0.0063148458,
0.1828808784,
0.1072927341,
-0.2350321561,
0.7918792367,
-0.4387797415,
-0.026736116,
-0.8007561564,
0.4760542512,
0.2446741462,
-0.5885971785,
0.327068001,
0.3122926354,
-0.1073675677,
-0.064720422,
-0.5268959403,
-0.4208488166,
-0.4647143483,
0.0995658189,
-0.2181769907,
-0.8063148856,
0.3258832097,
0.3939926922,
0.0335426405,
0.2894395292,
0.2278698087,
-0.4812861979,
0.4806659818,
0.5692712665,
-0.2076854855,
0.7724958062,
-0.0799459442,
0.1213379204,
-0.2930091918,
-0.249107793,
-0.2530974746,
-0.2766880989,
-0.3945443332,
-0.3151109815,
0.1900197119,
-0.2696201503,
0.0627202168,
0.6587936282,
-0.6329497099,
0.4480161965,
0.7803668976,
-0.0480304323,
0.1575292498,
0.3499412239,
0.2761284411,
-0.178736195,
-0.5183876753,
-0.4213594794,
1.0773925781,
0.3333704472,
0.7721785903,
-0.306564033,
0.8874107599,
0.7465486526,
-0.054009378,
-1.0071262121,
0.5214763284,
0.0072938511,
-0.261754483,
-0.5926060677,
-0.2566208839,
-0.6128485799,
-0.3452425897,
-0.2776319385,
-0.3541930318,
0.0243575238,
0.3814791143,
-0.3809473813,
-0.0470911004,
-0.441932857,
0.7554538846,
-0.1980385631,
0.1275539547,
0.0427817591,
-0.956215322,
0.0061430368,
0.2282235026,
0.2672821879,
0.0526001081,
0.2153463811,
1.0285242796,
-0.3697469532,
1.0530195236,
0.044059664,
-0.0309923552,
0.5778954625,
0.1268509775,
0.1485148817,
-0.1457807273,
0.2219980508,
0.4407647848,
-0.137361601,
-0.1632278413,
-0.6196374297,
0.3125949204,
-0.6346648335,
-0.5884586573,
-0.4078977108,
-0.5761981606,
-0.3600522578,
0.084033981,
0.2250023037,
0.7467844486,
-0.0984966978,
-0.0098267412,
0.4255835414,
-0.2118373066,
0.5701078773,
0.3862241805,
-0.1525913477,
-0.6930109262,
1.1833919287,
0.1362746209,
0.2902100682,
0.5305169821,
0.330191195,
-0.4293072522,
-0.4094070494,
-0.4116226137,
0.2853700519,
-0.8088615537,
-0.1102786139,
-0.3935438991,
-0.3565527499,
-0.8937035799,
-0.2134034485,
-0.2266066819,
-0.562844038,
-0.2280023992,
-0.1085587218,
0.5612331629,
0.4305291772,
-0.2146434039,
0.6167448759,
-0.3108358383,
0.2989017665,
0.7041823268,
0.011175802,
-0.472738713,
-0.7138887644,
0.1668678075,
-0.3219904304,
-0.1810058504,
-0.9936164618,
0.6879525781,
0.4568883777,
0.2830646634,
0.4243863523,
0.1985563189,
0.4576427042,
-0.7431081533,
0.8003370166,
0.2220888734,
-0.8782742023,
0.8928092718,
-0.148422122,
-0.0164177138,
0.4555193782,
0.3724412918,
-0.7057988644,
-0.4233731627,
-0.5448223948,
-0.6394061446,
0.6609569192,
0.1112367511,
0.3430400789,
-0.1552612782,
0.2457135618,
-0.0057656835,
0.504299283,
-0.6518536806,
-0.2739785314,
-0.840931952,
-0.0572813079,
-0.0314619988,
-0.1980080158,
-0.1991691887,
-0.033636529,
0.6058690548,
-0.4449455738,
0.5523646474,
0.1725846529,
0.051240921,
0.1620039791,
0.4621816576,
0.6648433208,
0.4315155447,
-0.1701047122,
0.2614994347,
-0.0249130428,
-0.048370596,
-0.2862525582,
0.0270579793,
0.0157826208,
0.1508737653,
0.3981502056,
0.8314797282,
0.0008468027,
-0.5796131492,
0.6564050913,
-0.0159102455,
0.0276676994,
-0.5001357198,
-0.0416107029,
-0.1405752897,
-0.1069225594,
0.2654614449,
-0.0066312486,
0.418561548,
-0.7236051559,
0.4543145895,
0.6303386688,
-0.5212456584,
-0.0258069821,
0.6276006103,
0.4129214585,
-0.4095342457,
0.2711555064,
-0.3451078832,
-0.4519067109,
0.5184285045,
0.6116623282,
0.7939004898,
-0.2642151117,
0.4375376999,
0.2738170326,
0.0764729381,
0.2920075059,
0.2780757844,
-0.4387059212,
-0.529476881,
-0.2745541036,
-0.8006078005,
-0.6457605958,
0.1122315899,
-0.6957279444,
0.5321831703,
-0.4846761823,
0.1119165868,
-0.1132310033,
-0.3771313131,
-0.3537759483,
0.0935763866,
0.4335683286,
0.7840301991,
-1.1201256514,
0.5127510428,
0.300722152,
-0.4733530581,
-0.7078850269,
-0.0535142981,
-0.0064963452,
-1.0508807898,
0.9081509113,
0.4116834104,
-0.3804843128,
0.0413104966,
-0.8878928423,
-0.7752348185,
0.9606072307,
0.2919369042,
-0.7718576193,
-0.1676284969,
0.3709279001,
0.2834133208,
-0.6243156791,
-0.1464126408,
0.3338290751,
0.1365095973,
0.4958239794,
-1.0809915066,
-0.1157416329,
0.0368670449,
-0.1013412327,
-0.3388850987,
-0.5022717714,
0.4664852321,
0.0427847169,
-0.1854986399,
0.0162760001,
1.1436249018,
0.0744484887,
0.2331606299,
0.5614840388,
-0.011263161,
0.6930285692,
-0.0715467334,
0.7537273765,
-0.4374547005,
0.1118055955,
1.3370428085,
0.054027088,
0.7374507785,
0.3371382058,
-0.0110464701,
0.3164260685,
0.4331407249,
-0.262064606,
0.6969183683,
0.2032940239,
-0.0953952,
-0.4460980892,
-0.3304035664,
-0.0698447973,
0.7681183219,
0.0709202364,
-0.5116570592,
0.0141157089,
0.2693628073,
0.0198322777,
0.154669866,
-0.424715668,
0.7715014219,
0.0949954093,
-0.4649249017,
0.511539638,
-0.2552104294,
0.7142936587,
-0.5397850871,
-0.1988515705,
0.06734965,
-0.5990058184,
-0.1122291163,
-0.8520456553,
0.4487831295,
-0.018093748,
0.007884644,
-0.5959998965,
0.692687273,
-0.6854310036,
-0.4032182395,
-0.1832921952,
0.0581637174,
0.51582551,
-0.0877601281,
-0.4589039981,
0.0102138612,
-0.3501476347,
0.4192748666,
0.0310042221,
0.1218545884,
0.0660971627,
0.5871424675,
0.3254721463,
0.0974332988,
0.0782288685,
0.3725216389,
0.4987572432,
-0.3266931772,
-0.8072538376,
-0.7508682013,
-0.0092556067,
-0.2109786272,
-0.0251044445,
0.6154446006,
0.443277508,
0.553285718,
-0.3560729623,
0.9049637318,
0.0210111495,
0.3757167161,
-0.6623737216,
0.8951457739,
-0.4291639328,
-0.1749146879,
-0.3179527819,
-0.5767540932,
-0.3617497385,
0.7335897684,
-0.289506197,
-0.1465489119,
0.2259821296,
0.7626013756,
0.0997455716,
0.2057796121,
0.4236010909,
-0.1184259579,
0.2962387502,
0.0488720462,
0.5149561167,
-0.0112741254,
0.7574531436,
-0.4509098828,
-0.2948411405,
-0.4110707045,
-1.0277531147,
-0.9805557132,
-0.8477076888,
-0.5947466493,
0.0007542625,
0.0566834882,
1.1113417149,
1.01311481,
-0.8557512164,
-0.372756809,
-0.003732424,
-0.2707416713,
-0.2419755906,
-0.3186440766,
0.2485778183,
-0.7458713055,
-0.6971142292,
0.8294667006,
0.3695074916,
0.1652846485,
-0.4611291885,
0.1584812552,
0.2769394219,
0.0576450154,
0.6081272364,
0.5115692616,
-0.7632764578,
-0.3215511739,
-0.0159671735,
0.1471975595,
0.3170844018,
0.6747375131,
-0.4937793911,
0.6691006422,
0.3722278178,
0.6437195539,
0.3142482638,
-0.0942706466,
0.5860695243,
-1.0712049007,
-0.1234345585,
0.0722420737,
0.4752939343,
0.5393657088,
-0.2315751016,
0.0427546613,
0.234379977,
-0.4496048689,
-0.5716930032,
0.4442201853,
-1.2435321808,
0.1262711734,
0.9875967503,
-0.0377559513,
-0.093550548,
0.0113108698,
-0.4766012728,
0.3405053318,
-0.6510543823,
0.7343001366,
0.5478679538,
-0.4009940028,
-0.3881658912,
-0.4487323165,
0.7045772076,
0.142347306,
-0.8228805661,
0.4563914537,
0.3282623887,
0.3481248319,
0.4261215329,
0.477000922,
-0.0253535863,
0.1896603554,
-0.4266231954,
0.207920596,
-0.3453408182,
-0.7881332636,
-0.2681617439,
0.1890010983,
-0.0375077389,
-0.3536373675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16466v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16466v2
|
Large language models can enhance persuasion through linguistic feature alignment
| 2023-11-28T04:07:34 | 2024-02-12T16:20:45 |
Minkyu Shin, Jin Kim
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Although large language models (LLMs) are reshaping various aspects of human
life, our current understanding of their impacts remains somewhat constrained.
Here we investigate the impact of LLMs on human communication, using data on
consumer complaints in the financial industry. By employing an AI detection
tool on more than 820K complaints gathered by the Consumer Financial Protection
Bureau (CFPB), we find a sharp increase in the likely use of LLMs shortly after
the release of ChatGPT. Moreover, the likely LLM usage was positively
correlated with message persuasiveness (i.e., increased likelihood of obtaining
relief from financial firms). Computational linguistic analyses suggest that
the positive correlation may be explained by LLMs' enhancement of various
linguistic features. Based on the results of these observational studies, we
hypothesize that LLM usage may enhance a comprehensive set of linguistic
features, increasing message persuasiveness to receivers with heterogeneous
linguistic preferences (i.e., linguistic feature alignment). We test this
hypothesis in preregistered experiments and find support for it. As an instance
of early empirical demonstrations of LLM usage for enhancing persuasion, our
research highlights the transformative potential of LLMs in human
communication.
|
[
-0.367690295,
-0.7276951671,
0.4924868941,
0.2559298277,
-0.1876441538,
0.0782567933,
-0.4514292479,
-0.7406976223,
0.2893068194,
0.7798984647,
-0.2200879157,
-0.5920918584,
-0.6050866246,
0.0074413191,
-0.5663297176,
0.9272533655,
0.4350186586,
0.1558111608,
-0.0936627313,
0.2396422625,
-0.5367593765,
-0.88262707,
-0.5796060562,
-0.6379009485,
0.7728837132,
0.4004062116,
0.9633559585,
0.4948064089,
0.5950510502,
0.4117237329,
-0.0873737484,
-0.1435486227,
-0.4197278023,
0.0413857996,
-0.2013955414,
-0.7034396529,
-0.3506105542,
0.1390918046,
0.5636633635,
0.7107157707,
-0.187714234,
-0.082035251,
0.3099814355,
0.5689341426,
-0.3565475643,
0.0994911343,
-0.6899834871,
-0.1642228067,
-0.3158487976,
-0.240481317,
-0.4288220704,
-0.2407882214,
0.4062914848,
-0.3031021059,
-0.1299124658,
0.2383453399,
1.1693964005,
0.3320200145,
-0.4574956596,
-0.4659276605,
-0.8474808335,
0.6150032282,
-0.8647132516,
0.3562422693,
0.2994478941,
0.2300292552,
-0.3126598597,
-0.3486720622,
-0.599364996,
-0.3633299768,
-0.2076876014,
-0.1488679796,
-0.4930583537,
0.1143455878,
0.2745226622,
0.2128680199,
-0.2891325951,
0.7167748809,
-0.0790360942,
-0.3804680705,
0.6851246953,
0.18568106,
0.339091748,
-0.222640276,
-0.2436584085,
-0.2603101134,
-0.7887057662,
0.1412660778,
0.5865216255,
0.2976048291,
-0.2361416817,
0.5481907129,
0.0424821302,
0.7614792585,
0.1238055378,
-0.2283219546,
-0.0185297132,
-0.0139505304,
-0.3209431469,
0.3139927983,
0.8625453711,
0.2849307656,
0.3099219203,
0.2168072462,
-0.165633902,
0.0979701802,
0.21137321,
-0.5840082765,
-0.2525967658,
0.0263430942,
-0.5871095657,
-0.3584816754,
0.2513030767,
-0.7798343301,
-0.908095181,
-0.3735280931,
0.0027874126,
-0.2296184152,
-0.3060101271,
0.4142622054,
0.0096890265,
0.4489282072,
0.1712270081,
-1.0332036018,
0.014884566,
1.2587455511,
0.4706602991,
0.0601951443,
-0.0021486364,
-0.3411983252,
0.1250706911,
-0.4008010626,
1.171749711,
-0.844142735,
-0.2557124794,
0.2709645331,
-0.2074866742,
0.1236298904,
-0.7105854154,
0.68148458,
-0.2886730433,
0.1782807261,
-0.3607089818,
-0.4898171425,
-0.1471856385,
0.3314402699,
-0.4824983478,
0.3508645296,
-0.2966374159,
-0.4912845194,
0.3499828577,
-0.4534354806,
-0.4661855102,
0.1111412197,
-0.3087059855,
-0.4156581461,
0.2695324421,
0.1777505875,
0.4754946828,
-0.5187520385,
0.2604826689,
-0.275724113,
-0.2274841964,
0.9341993332,
-0.7646522522,
0.3903666139,
0.1846023202,
-0.3007219136,
0.1073543057,
-0.3726724684,
-0.3645905852,
0.0781503394,
-0.6068666577,
-0.4587036073,
0.2294240743,
-0.204183653,
0.0553779975,
0.2822248042,
-0.4403896332,
0.0991979316,
-0.615303278,
0.4076235592,
0.7847113013,
-0.2048697472,
0.2511637807,
-0.4965238869,
0.5210116506,
-0.0534875952,
0.0147894127,
-0.1926080883,
-0.5843896866,
-0.6758954525,
-0.3349560499,
0.1135272458,
0.3513390124,
-0.0881742388,
0.4661080837,
-0.3758179545,
-0.3246253133,
-0.4945378304,
0.1453105807,
0.3757917881,
0.319720149,
-0.0682240576,
0.0949827507,
-0.4366622567,
-1.1523134708,
-0.5917136669,
-0.3924508095,
-0.1312565356,
0.3427505195,
-0.167388767,
-0.1745843887,
0.8027263284,
-0.4116395116,
-0.1466959119,
-0.3205113709,
0.1032205597,
0.317307055,
0.1479677707,
0.418402642,
-0.7247775793,
-0.4537453949,
0.1680079699,
-0.2983733416,
-0.3882894218,
-0.346046567,
-0.0224706437,
0.1609137058,
0.3527129292,
-0.5026845336,
0.2364593893,
0.693872869,
-0.5075536966,
0.47142452,
-0.170217663,
0.1944248378,
-1.0212010145,
-0.3242795467,
0.4168076813,
-0.0271817446,
-0.757814467,
-0.4083487391,
-0.064365916,
0.0297422986,
-0.2091266811,
0.3824737966,
-0.3452574015,
-0.0200820118,
-0.6123017073,
0.1308359951,
-0.0639752895,
-0.0399512462,
0.0199698098,
0.539870739,
0.5133622289,
-0.4299274683,
0.3678505421,
0.3130600154,
-0.5030975342,
0.6828624606,
-0.5304197669,
0.0383945666,
-0.1407827288,
0.2127713263,
-1.2728927135,
-0.4245554805,
0.1893236041,
-0.3773934245,
0.2801289558,
0.121598348,
-0.3458010852,
-0.2989456952,
0.018145062,
-0.0949033648,
0.5815834403,
-0.7420340776,
0.7420772314,
0.3094234467,
-0.2989546955,
-0.382833302,
-0.7293308973,
0.5682271123,
-0.6142766476,
-0.7566316724,
0.2092850804,
0.2866390646,
-0.5595288873,
-0.3896442056,
0.0794631317,
0.4961337447,
0.2087940574,
0.3919593394,
0.609243989,
-0.3313110769,
0.3054035008,
-0.3550055027,
-0.2919659913,
0.2633747458,
-0.2601167262,
0.8015442491,
-0.1461508721,
-0.5577291846,
-0.6356454492,
0.2359364927,
0.4180932045,
-0.1065694615,
0.6142244339,
0.1492078304,
-0.0977509618,
0.13705419,
-1.0155678988,
-0.2527862191,
-0.5656971335,
0.4036757052,
-0.1689541489,
-1.1000444889,
0.2704547346,
-0.3503775299,
-0.0504234135,
0.3635824621,
0.5252962708,
-0.2050528526,
1.258050561,
0.568893671,
-0.4683913589,
0.7121018171,
0.3275174201,
0.4927912652,
-0.5516845584,
-0.3746492267,
-0.8732627034,
-0.5079107285,
-0.6378811002,
-0.1644430161,
0.0796404108,
0.103237994,
-0.2770904303,
0.1586238742,
-0.3487493992,
0.3639298677,
0.2446225137,
-0.0693918467,
0.3204633594,
0.309672147,
0.0658430532,
-0.1980373859,
-0.4961771965,
-0.8146488667,
0.7307356,
0.6906798482,
1.0294184685,
0.2014383227,
0.3893405497,
0.3081967831,
0.593829751,
-0.7875515819,
0.6115024686,
-0.3696635664,
-0.2515166402,
-0.2174387276,
-0.3885296583,
-1.0400071144,
0.0545577034,
-0.6882266998,
-1.0071759224,
0.3920750022,
0.2764517963,
-0.2288140655,
0.1766562015,
-0.7111117244,
0.6880936027,
-0.6326036453,
-0.0574380718,
-0.4301816821,
-0.1729103774,
0.2898076475,
-0.2633247375,
0.2614814937,
-0.2822294831,
0.0377480462,
0.5491174459,
-0.3416514397,
1.1751776934,
0.1459795684,
-0.682197392,
-0.0579570346,
-0.2382563055,
0.8436487317,
-0.1287159771,
-0.1070471182,
0.2363896817,
-0.4099120498,
-0.2340548187,
-0.5955798626,
0.9227289557,
-0.7430927753,
-1.1083928347,
-0.180937618,
-0.6962317824,
-0.212659955,
-0.0983225331,
0.0263530482,
0.1458598673,
-0.1382375509,
0.2720216811,
0.4663614929,
-0.504267633,
0.2688918412,
0.5302094221,
-0.3149870634,
-0.2551107109,
1.0044966936,
-0.2895150483,
0.4599290192,
0.2884610593,
0.568649888,
-0.4115855396,
-0.4914492965,
0.107834965,
0.4596192241,
-0.7447237968,
-0.1098948568,
-0.5622649789,
0.0415999927,
-0.6662535667,
-0.2325894088,
-0.2222001255,
-0.1474346519,
-0.2442559004,
-0.0690644532,
0.3177466094,
0.8616636395,
0.0327248424,
0.5899231434,
-0.8768290877,
0.0582816117,
0.283111006,
0.2452643663,
-0.0892582014,
-0.6131479144,
-0.2060845345,
0.1857621819,
-0.1522552967,
-0.6483592391,
0.3206064403,
0.0584100597,
0.6684817076,
0.9434683919,
-0.2412947863,
0.6564229131,
0.0084104668,
0.7427736521,
0.4103762507,
-0.8105873466,
0.19863832,
-0.3711975217,
0.2811538279,
0.0298931915,
0.4036820829,
-0.8560855985,
-0.5019773841,
-0.3635485768,
-0.5616029501,
0.439812094,
-0.1957532167,
0.5607976913,
-0.1178710982,
0.3988059163,
-0.1171733662,
0.0384529009,
-0.508036077,
-0.1086176857,
-0.1422723681,
-0.1550820023,
-0.1683529764,
-0.6257626414,
-0.1400682181,
0.0147394929,
0.5275164247,
0.0071290387,
0.014582023,
-0.1975398511,
0.3602361083,
-0.0084794145,
0.5114347339,
0.7471633554,
0.3230445683,
0.2157013714,
0.1248401999,
-0.1519814283,
-0.2653467953,
0.1171652973,
0.2624459565,
-0.03009082,
-0.25706321,
0.4998792112,
0.9067240953,
0.2453974187,
-0.6960304379,
0.300216496,
0.0342799947,
-0.2863037288,
-0.0972177088,
0.0982405618,
0.4586682916,
0.6044836044,
0.376221329,
-0.1565598845,
-0.137386471,
-0.6572586894,
-0.0961011425,
0.7999181747,
-0.3878540397,
-0.0322625041,
0.541220665,
0.2040278465,
-0.6381096244,
0.6638264656,
0.5023185015,
-0.4850934446,
0.4008728266,
0.6653322577,
0.789734602,
-0.3661369383,
0.1442070603,
0.0538971648,
0.1345818043,
-0.284596473,
-0.1587809771,
0.2201527506,
-1.0059666634,
-0.4384644926,
-0.5486707091,
-0.2910137773,
0.0485758632,
-0.3594744205,
0.4279510975,
-0.4792877734,
-0.3523377478,
0.4076105356,
-0.3503478169,
-0.4943013191,
-0.1019543037,
0.6203231812,
0.6422762871,
-0.7713736296,
0.7424876094,
0.7163648009,
-0.0570560209,
-0.9211781621,
0.2583194673,
0.2594650388,
-0.8273019791,
0.6761355996,
0.2389075905,
0.0244482346,
-0.1970014423,
-0.6647652388,
-0.8356589079,
0.6525348425,
0.618775785,
-0.9508436918,
0.2485246956,
0.7481662631,
0.5904141068,
-0.7200943232,
-0.0051433393,
0.7483654022,
0.7364459038,
0.2622915506,
-0.9040176868,
0.0611924604,
-0.1024812832,
0.0167797338,
0.3863839209,
-0.5161967278,
0.5369203687,
-0.2243806124,
-0.2268862277,
-0.0856864825,
0.8192106485,
0.2030154318,
0.0099402722,
0.68153584,
0.2213554978,
0.801004231,
-0.1686257124,
1.1897881031,
-0.1816250533,
-0.0555663407,
0.8718501925,
-0.3878838122,
0.7100872397,
0.4075873494,
0.0030497357,
0.5880374312,
0.4177500904,
-0.0848259926,
0.0634749457,
0.551448822,
-0.340444088,
-0.6274471879,
-0.4337502122,
-0.1782434583,
0.5713154674,
0.5926831365,
-0.510637641,
-0.102045022,
0.2195411026,
0.0063774297,
0.400075376,
-0.1193213686,
0.803832829,
0.2548139095,
-0.6590772867,
0.554540813,
-0.1090464517,
0.8814555407,
-0.569186151,
-0.0100101782,
-0.1714321822,
0.2676267922,
-0.3217601776,
-0.7546290159,
0.2061457187,
0.008589183,
0.0348362923,
-0.2166397721,
0.8652125001,
-0.4048592448,
-0.4298656583,
0.355571568,
0.1447158903,
0.290140897,
-0.2066186219,
-0.622969985,
0.3373849094,
0.0687461495,
-0.2016437054,
0.5885074139,
0.381546706,
-0.1076039672,
0.7729045153,
0.8808375001,
0.137695089,
-0.1824667752,
0.3702614605,
0.9476479292,
-0.735645175,
-0.238615036,
-1.0571625233,
0.3314631581,
-0.1989658475,
-0.0345358551,
0.781991601,
0.4109973609,
0.6272245646,
0.1549767852,
0.7347357273,
0.3417836428,
0.3691978753,
-0.4653873444,
0.6002918482,
-0.2244243622,
0.7952304482,
-0.3193855882,
-0.9759817123,
-0.2444451004,
0.3640904725,
-0.7550307512,
-0.0374863446,
0.3388260007,
0.8621631265,
0.2465465665,
0.2366636842,
0.498503238,
0.3861257434,
0.6731160283,
0.2585251629,
1.0892248154,
0.2152134031,
0.8130149841,
0.0021768031,
-0.095040746,
-0.2757434249,
-0.9454538226,
-1.0016889572,
-0.2605813742,
-0.4515908659,
-0.4078400433,
-0.1036525667,
1.0159202814,
0.2582217455,
-0.6515164375,
-0.3455035686,
0.2212416679,
0.0132230362,
-0.0299101379,
-0.1925609112,
0.1854251772,
-0.3089809716,
-0.7194523215,
0.348880142,
0.4660015702,
0.3219790459,
-0.4611594975,
-0.1482563913,
-0.1088589728,
0.2226829082,
0.4432542622,
0.2269692123,
-0.9498392344,
-0.4233974814,
-0.0182671845,
-0.3060509562,
0.1539990157,
1.0497415066,
-0.4190512896,
0.0708860904,
0.3962187767,
0.6522477865,
0.0054716384,
0.2444343567,
0.8974197507,
-0.2139681578,
0.1972630918,
-0.0191314016,
0.4515246749,
0.3884046674,
-0.6738618612,
-0.0015103375,
-0.058607325,
-0.5936829448,
-0.3671571016,
0.151070863,
-0.7666985393,
-0.3339470327,
1.275167346,
0.0271941777,
-0.2082600594,
-0.2072604001,
-0.3959676027,
-0.2156496644,
-0.6211740971,
1.017854929,
0.9144796729,
-0.0133524751,
-0.2665934563,
-0.2790534794,
0.4652636349,
0.6225531697,
-0.8048394918,
0.295020014,
0.619453907,
0.182656467,
0.2668370306,
0.3454223275,
-0.0245815907,
-0.0167774409,
-0.3137336075,
0.0351283178,
0.0669924021,
0.0621936321,
-0.4771688581,
0.0917698368,
0.2790819407,
0.2281798273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03732v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03732v1
|
A Rank Stabilization Scaling Factor for Fine-Tuning with LoRA
| 2023-11-28T03:23:20 | 2023-11-28T03:23:20 |
Damjan Kalajdzievski
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7
|
As large language models (LLMs) have become increasingly compute and memory
intensive, parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods are now a common
strategy to fine-tune LLMs. A popular PEFT method is Low-Rank Adapters (LoRA),
which adds trainable low-rank "adapters" to selected layers. Each adapter
consists of a low-rank matrix product, multiplicatively scaled by a
rank-dependent factor. This scaling factor, which divides adapters by a factor
of the rank, results in slowed learning and stunted performance for LoRA with
higher-rank adapters. Consequently, the use of LoRA in practice has generally
been limited to very low ranks. In this work, we study the impact of the
scaling factor on the learning process and prove that LoRA adapters should be
divided by a factor of the square root of the rank. Modifying LoRA with the
appropriate scaling factor, which we call the rank-stabilized LoRA (rsLoRA)
method, easily provides for a fine-tuning compute/performance trade-off, where
larger ranks can be used to trade off increased computational resources during
training for better fine-tuning performance, with no change in inference
computing cost.
|
[
-0.5980840921,
-0.9131343961,
0.344438374,
0.0601450428,
-0.3046315312,
-0.0310310479,
-0.4302118719,
-0.2686846554,
0.1464305967,
0.4313750863,
-0.1600791216,
-0.2008736581,
-0.736779511,
-0.0611730739,
0.0933691338,
1.0685157776,
0.2113419473,
-0.0488727726,
0.21813187,
-0.2970916629,
-0.3059709072,
-0.4946551621,
-1.0237650871,
-0.5485924482,
0.9021499157,
0.8259994984,
0.802182436,
0.6651753783,
0.5676245093,
0.3014056981,
-0.4694829285,
0.3221084177,
-0.7864016294,
0.193282634,
-0.1365971118,
-0.7274403572,
-1.017023325,
-0.0464730524,
0.8596137762,
0.7800281644,
-0.1558311582,
0.4347152412,
-0.000998762,
1.0651248693,
-0.827618897,
-0.0091077005,
-0.7458809614,
-0.0331519842,
-0.1543849707,
-0.3700892627,
-0.439840287,
-0.2982817888,
-0.2445035577,
-0.5393410921,
-0.1711938977,
-0.0625384822,
0.7605540752,
0.5018998981,
-0.1640357524,
0.2704100311,
-0.809967041,
0.7810744047,
-0.7488685846,
0.1796949804,
0.5490191579,
0.2653299272,
-0.1686717123,
-0.2149505317,
-0.3089194,
0.1097797304,
0.1792291552,
-0.3708475828,
0.0176984444,
-0.0419408008,
0.5774461627,
0.3824864328,
0.0531755462,
0.6117609143,
-0.5521305799,
0.0702987984,
0.4879339337,
0.0975639224,
0.0899371132,
0.2012704462,
-0.1005574316,
-0.184205547,
-1.281801343,
0.1281515956,
0.3900729716,
0.8917205334,
0.1066591367,
0.5332093835,
-0.1251060367,
0.747844398,
0.5850697756,
-0.6135041714,
0.18174088,
-0.0452065654,
-0.2821298838,
-0.0434962437,
0.4212263525,
0.3038540184,
0.2900499403,
0.109389551,
-0.2772859931,
0.0675042495,
0.0721434131,
-1.0403678417,
-0.0383739397,
-0.1026609913,
-0.4611393213,
-0.3808391988,
-0.2152609527,
-0.6949572563,
-0.3885647058,
-0.0544796884,
0.6866938472,
-0.0865553096,
0.0581615828,
-0.0589587875,
0.2579524517,
0.3242235184,
0.4830566347,
-1.1162663698,
0.3905936182,
0.5415765643,
0.704998672,
-0.1645162702,
-0.3169916272,
-1.0729738474,
-0.0961357132,
-0.3552123904,
0.7841889262,
-0.4748737514,
-0.2356233746,
-0.0689986348,
-0.0298538655,
-0.2586481273,
-0.7202080488,
0.4721275568,
-0.6386715174,
0.0959904268,
-0.3285814524,
-0.3229159415,
0.0091597121,
0.0744755715,
-0.6186740994,
1.0086487532,
0.2715026736,
-0.6112002134,
0.299762696,
-0.5448094606,
-0.4464862049,
-0.1486900896,
0.0226504188,
-0.8230578899,
0.1507304013,
0.142146036,
0.2835626006,
-0.2313100547,
-0.3637184799,
-0.3478452861,
-0.6694997549,
0.1688980162,
-0.1158085763,
0.279702425,
0.1090206131,
-0.2149761766,
0.1686409116,
-0.7553278208,
0.1535893381,
-0.0527610481,
-0.8273383975,
-0.1819883287,
0.2360393703,
-0.1388227046,
0.145249933,
0.2260459661,
-0.4222512841,
0.3759517074,
-0.4202617109,
0.6356331706,
0.8539302349,
0.0630956888,
0.5303605199,
-0.318882823,
0.621130228,
0.0197115131,
0.1077758521,
0.1505098343,
-0.3865329027,
-0.998508215,
-0.0820024312,
0.3916721046,
0.21897991,
-0.301686883,
0.2570158243,
-0.1985297203,
-0.5482295156,
-0.3294238746,
0.4421064258,
0.382568568,
0.1884640902,
0.426517576,
0.0160042569,
-0.2620877326,
-0.7283067107,
-0.149596855,
-0.1393028945,
0.2542665899,
-0.0129354661,
0.1685029268,
-0.1535218656,
0.7384126186,
-0.5436492562,
-0.6583311558,
-0.2610212266,
-0.0883819014,
0.368011862,
0.5776735544,
0.7128664851,
-0.4535779357,
-0.6748400331,
0.1126965582,
-0.0210728776,
-0.0251320042,
0.2568691671,
-0.0689483359,
0.3348942399,
0.7073090672,
-0.2683800161,
0.15476197,
0.8020118475,
-0.5951678753,
0.1485759169,
-0.4604691267,
-0.0483248942,
-0.7859742641,
0.0734379739,
-0.0912087634,
-0.399261564,
-0.4621320069,
0.0540731102,
0.1458249688,
-0.0646947473,
-0.2810136378,
0.1936623007,
-0.2557356358,
-0.0472241528,
-0.4208511114,
0.2812147439,
-0.1342916489,
0.5337662697,
-0.2863382101,
1.0499711037,
0.2888149023,
-0.5471790433,
-0.4433203936,
0.0181274563,
-0.16834943,
0.5581736565,
-0.670504272,
0.1653126031,
0.2230252326,
-0.0149984471,
-0.7739313245,
0.1943997294,
-0.0487400331,
-0.139158234,
0.2908461094,
-0.3895306885,
-0.5242921114,
0.1029260531,
-0.4188595116,
0.4391950369,
0.5870268345,
-0.6552026868,
0.7022437453,
0.5281442404,
-0.0375429653,
-0.4738093913,
-0.492927283,
-0.4460492134,
-0.4926202297,
-0.3172174394,
0.3427180946,
-0.2993840575,
-0.2086259872,
-0.4631928205,
-0.2061159164,
0.0093762577,
0.3784038723,
0.4869353771,
0.2483040839,
-0.4060105085,
-0.1927592754,
0.245019123,
-0.20486404,
-0.0704479739,
0.1811033487,
0.4839504063,
-0.3985113204,
-0.2127274722,
-0.1382814795,
-0.0867948085,
0.9865715504,
-0.225854516,
0.9543266892,
0.5199099779,
-0.164239347,
-0.4487352669,
-0.4447222948,
-0.0742929429,
-0.5254445076,
0.3989352286,
-0.2147047669,
-0.8912466764,
0.7733725309,
-0.3525460064,
0.0343356058,
0.6622470021,
0.5751115084,
0.0545544326,
1.066300869,
0.8128140569,
-0.1764239967,
0.7158363461,
-0.2040741891,
0.3269797862,
-1.0062178373,
0.1379983276,
-0.671946466,
-0.6974929571,
-0.7398644686,
-0.5697448254,
0.4878693223,
0.3612244725,
-0.6142543554,
0.0399237238,
-0.3326968551,
0.8129919767,
0.2435148358,
0.1457015127,
0.7024354339,
0.0448244549,
0.1189429536,
0.1101031303,
-0.6122525334,
-0.1440259963,
1.0951817036,
0.4971265197,
0.9446185827,
0.277043879,
0.5913393497,
0.1767477244,
0.0506474338,
-0.7976041436,
0.5341535211,
-0.4875319004,
-0.154396832,
-0.6326740384,
-0.349421978,
-0.8709790111,
0.4048005342,
-0.3006326258,
-0.6684566736,
0.3967468441,
0.3100023866,
-0.6450342536,
0.3021153212,
-0.627548635,
0.5110675097,
0.0083552767,
-0.4321080148,
-0.6282148361,
-0.2568950057,
-0.090996936,
-0.2151059508,
0.2226999998,
-0.2307296842,
-0.0341441892,
0.9672017694,
-0.5616255999,
0.8528783917,
-0.2782926261,
-0.4067388475,
-0.132008478,
0.1390236914,
0.6701527238,
0.090045616,
-0.1953148097,
-0.1231662109,
0.1164119616,
-0.469356209,
-0.517632246,
1.0327949524,
-1.2377614975,
-0.3995083869,
-0.2972836196,
-0.4084382951,
-0.5410652757,
0.2024038583,
0.1254191846,
0.2070022523,
0.0527206771,
0.3050383031,
0.8172111511,
0.0793921649,
0.2816576064,
0.7605247498,
-0.5487890244,
-0.4021940529,
0.9336742759,
0.4708046913,
0.578774631,
0.287174046,
0.3620171249,
0.3333222568,
-0.6644011736,
-0.2300571054,
0.3310461938,
-0.6789314747,
-0.4039097726,
0.1529822499,
-0.3017852306,
0.216426,
-0.2695917189,
-0.6744914651,
-0.6978074908,
-0.1797038764,
0.096221067,
0.5186443329,
0.7155972719,
0.0165688414,
0.5171955824,
-0.1684760302,
0.1729994565,
0.3045539856,
0.5587819219,
-0.0345637761,
-0.8320392966,
-0.6635695696,
-0.2863036394,
-0.0694361776,
-0.3841167092,
0.0291900281,
0.5406874418,
0.4643515646,
0.6120676994,
0.0224609952,
0.7434965372,
-0.3632237911,
0.5132731199,
-0.076832898,
-0.8301631808,
0.5350960493,
-0.4642379582,
0.4283961654,
0.7282130718,
-0.1631194502,
-0.1688192189,
-0.1858514994,
-0.215056181,
-0.9065105319,
0.6812658906,
-0.1412253827,
0.0798555911,
0.2638327479,
0.5181669593,
0.0176336151,
-0.147196129,
-0.6857556701,
-0.4617981315,
0.2077866942,
0.367018044,
-0.2122683823,
-0.471010834,
-0.1764074713,
-0.5166926384,
0.7975221872,
-0.4203093052,
0.0755623281,
-0.2632654905,
-0.1135661528,
-0.6423220038,
0.2528341115,
0.6289126277,
0.7494266033,
-0.469035238,
0.1724672914,
0.3579207957,
-0.561176002,
-0.0281649828,
-0.1395358741,
-0.3294433653,
-0.5158596039,
0.0014716401,
0.8255465627,
0.5894540548,
-0.5752952695,
0.1336423308,
-0.0589734726,
-0.2012140304,
-0.0399472788,
0.4143440723,
0.081327118,
0.252959311,
0.2552207112,
0.2475359142,
-0.4512490034,
-0.315197289,
-0.2299667597,
0.4426588118,
-0.1531780362,
-0.2267292589,
0.2841165662,
0.2126973271,
-0.3769473135,
0.3219681084,
0.1443169862,
-0.3896272779,
0.3714995682,
0.6589773297,
0.4783039987,
-0.3334617913,
0.0938933566,
0.440767765,
0.319584161,
-0.2818560898,
0.2701049745,
-0.0602120459,
-0.5467532277,
-0.3419257998,
-0.7583740354,
-0.4515269101,
0.0998416916,
-0.7806997895,
0.2391321361,
-0.9231022,
-0.4736322463,
-0.1328363717,
0.2495904267,
-0.4515033662,
-0.1246970445,
0.1618313491,
0.9398608804,
-0.9294935465,
1.0020836592,
0.5594724417,
-0.3016220331,
-0.8246853948,
0.0300742127,
-0.3638973534,
-0.6395613551,
0.7474063635,
-0.3071736097,
-0.5201708674,
0.0010637373,
-0.2491177768,
-1.3508855104,
1.0870432854,
0.7061459422,
-0.5719152689,
-0.0672312751,
0.060227327,
0.6961983442,
-0.2256569713,
-0.0556548052,
0.6223689318,
0.4477352202,
-0.0381316058,
-1.0349855423,
0.0304318666,
-0.2022377551,
-0.041367922,
0.4084442556,
-0.9442042708,
1.1105642319,
-0.2298103571,
0.2078835517,
0.034907192,
0.5238662362,
0.3283960223,
-0.2201418579,
0.6647804379,
0.5841111541,
0.834180057,
0.1016606465,
0.5240923166,
-0.4539782703,
0.620010972,
1.1468025446,
-0.068326354,
1.5157965422,
0.7077282071,
-0.521259129,
0.7501968741,
0.3354316652,
0.0031204789,
0.3548269272,
0.107039012,
0.06139265,
-0.5106443763,
0.1878486425,
-0.5005418062,
0.4422545135,
0.474599719,
-0.4661201239,
-0.2821301222,
-0.0441866405,
0.2010564506,
0.0845573246,
-0.7060771585,
0.6627168059,
0.0380685069,
-0.6251777411,
0.9340136647,
0.1113961488,
0.572196722,
-0.6052160859,
0.1074343771,
-0.2906273305,
0.6318383217,
-0.3565005362,
-0.3771286309,
0.0294285808,
-0.1005067825,
-0.5295554399,
-0.0493100509,
0.5394810438,
-0.3477443457,
-0.5437456369,
0.4172253013,
0.3975557685,
-0.2232517451,
0.0548627637,
-0.3348515928,
0.3584583104,
-0.2785991728,
-0.4706240594,
1.0561237335,
0.1309839785,
-0.0432380959,
0.6127437949,
0.4828197062,
0.2167082578,
-0.081295155,
0.0801750496,
1.0398788452,
-0.2493979335,
-0.5321261287,
-0.7174001932,
0.0185303781,
0.2444691211,
-0.2692728937,
0.8722839355,
0.3996819258,
0.4966430664,
0.1825281382,
0.3639777899,
0.1387503743,
0.4464604259,
-0.5594556928,
0.9922171831,
-0.5009238124,
0.427723974,
-0.2074560821,
-0.9110754132,
-0.2114079744,
0.7769031525,
-0.3848497868,
0.0668461844,
0.5385052562,
0.6148766875,
-0.0059313774,
-0.304004997,
0.406922251,
0.3058875501,
0.15545699,
0.4320538938,
0.2187916934,
-0.5534251928,
0.2535919547,
-0.3118776381,
-0.0892463699,
-0.4105017781,
-0.8333338499,
-1.1838556528,
-0.4088013172,
-0.3656255901,
-0.5769369006,
0.0440476947,
0.8503736258,
0.8779956698,
-0.8362636566,
-0.2418732792,
0.1442649364,
0.254652828,
-0.3370456398,
-0.1505588442,
0.48556301,
-0.4047762454,
-0.6278891563,
0.4774854779,
0.2187701613,
-0.269438386,
-0.5499685407,
-0.3173315525,
-0.110911563,
0.1529010683,
0.7294305563,
0.4758635759,
-0.5186262727,
-0.1920229942,
-0.252874583,
0.0528282635,
0.2828921974,
0.7140837908,
-0.9258892536,
0.1153133735,
0.3512975276,
0.4267903864,
0.5416256189,
0.1407620162,
0.4692462385,
-0.5060187578,
0.0818876624,
-0.2396411449,
0.395001322,
0.1063966602,
-0.3467616141,
0.369512856,
-0.0770850405,
-0.8470297456,
-0.9787111878,
0.0450369939,
-1.1071457863,
-0.0252098087,
1.1145538092,
-0.0030847904,
-0.2758766711,
0.2652857602,
-0.2378094792,
-0.1337878853,
-0.4728357196,
0.8307417035,
0.2577332258,
-0.2074229568,
-0.2255993485,
-0.1837407202,
0.6686533689,
0.5594480038,
-0.7121762037,
0.2215663046,
0.1619086564,
0.4680724442,
0.3444975615,
0.5005684495,
-0.0449694805,
0.1805466861,
-0.2925330997,
-0.4747288227,
-0.1063974649,
-0.2105044276,
-0.4828472733,
0.4144854248,
0.8710731268,
0.1444315016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16452v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16452v1
|
Can Generalist Foundation Models Outcompete Special-Purpose Tuning? Case Study in Medicine
| 2023-11-28T03:16:12 | 2023-11-28T03:16:12 |
Harsha Nori, Yin Tat Lee, Sheng Zhang, Dean Carignan, Richard Edgar, Nicolo Fusi, Nicholas King, Jonathan Larson, Yuanzhi Li, Weishung Liu, Renqian Luo, Scott Mayer McKinney, Robert Osazuwa Ness, Hoifung Poon, Tao Qin, Naoto Usuyama, Chris White, Eric Horvitz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Generalist foundation models such as GPT-4 have displayed surprising
capabilities in a wide variety of domains and tasks. Yet, there is a prevalent
assumption that they cannot match specialist capabilities of fine-tuned models.
For example, most explorations to date on medical competency benchmarks have
leveraged domain-specific training, as exemplified by efforts on BioGPT and
Med-PaLM. We build on a prior study of GPT-4's capabilities on medical
challenge benchmarks in the absence of special training. Rather than using
simple prompting to highlight the model's out-of-the-box capabilities, we
perform a systematic exploration of prompt engineering. We find that prompting
innovation can unlock deeper specialist capabilities and show that GPT-4 easily
tops prior leading results for medical benchmarks. The prompting methods we
explore are general purpose, and make no specific use of domain expertise,
removing the need for expert-curated content. Our experimental design carefully
controls for overfitting during the prompt engineering process. We introduce
Medprompt, based on a composition of several prompting strategies. With
Medprompt, GPT-4 achieves state-of-the-art results on all nine of the benchmark
datasets in the MultiMedQA suite. The method outperforms leading specialist
models such as Med-PaLM 2 by a significant margin with an order of magnitude
fewer calls to the model. Steering GPT-4 with Medprompt achieves a 27%
reduction in error rate on the MedQA dataset over the best methods to date
achieved with specialist models and surpasses a score of 90% for the first
time. Beyond medical problems, we show the power of Medprompt to generalize to
other domains and provide evidence for the broad applicability of the approach
via studies of the strategy on exams in electrical engineering, machine
learning, philosophy, accounting, law, nursing, and clinical psychology.
|
[
-0.6085031629,
-0.5434268713,
0.8491851091,
0.1410370171,
-0.1203107163,
0.0073766145,
-0.0375228934,
-0.3475707769,
-0.0487672836,
0.358838439,
-0.9083577991,
-0.1968204379,
-0.5413162708,
0.3827238083,
-0.1267262846,
1.1181986332,
-0.1825711727,
0.1052604765,
0.0838878825,
-0.133856371,
-0.8012030721,
-0.589602232,
-0.4675757885,
-0.4282049239,
0.3491751254,
0.2178039104,
0.6746344566,
0.2603501678,
0.402341336,
0.216933921,
0.1561443359,
0.1501471996,
-0.1163186356,
-0.0378841236,
-0.2329028994,
-0.2228752822,
-0.3909256756,
0.3322527707,
0.2088650465,
0.8541232944,
-0.1059398875,
-0.2831782997,
0.0467954464,
0.585047245,
-0.3193433285,
-0.09613619,
-0.4577879906,
-0.086951673,
-0.090390265,
-0.3748672605,
-0.0981963798,
-0.3686219752,
0.3492120504,
-0.6215777993,
0.7595102787,
-0.0547804758,
0.868776679,
0.5537028909,
-0.4694021046,
-0.3065579832,
-0.5729801655,
0.4843505025,
-0.2888457477,
0.2394180894,
0.1619600058,
0.4469614923,
-0.255065918,
-0.8740069866,
-0.1298113018,
-0.3895630538,
0.2982517481,
0.1091965362,
-0.2001144141,
0.3637295365,
0.3704238236,
0.4811860919,
-0.5953143835,
0.1059478521,
-0.4081137478,
-0.1527574956,
0.2226795554,
0.0959965736,
0.2196282297,
0.1464773118,
-0.3789413273,
0.2025026828,
-0.9176753163,
0.3563716114,
-0.1261232942,
-0.0195769742,
0.1674095988,
0.3222883642,
-0.2787701488,
0.6784504056,
0.6042249203,
0.4340546727,
0.1614225954,
-0.2873056233,
-0.2729480565,
-0.1827743202,
0.4316954315,
0.3144325316,
0.5503766537,
-0.0239171088,
-0.2255421877,
0.3421520293,
0.4324459732,
-0.6711144447,
-0.6333181262,
0.1141422093,
-0.0936378688,
-0.2148322165,
-0.2619763315,
-0.4177119136,
-0.3691385984,
-0.3437251151,
0.3439475298,
-0.1995980144,
-0.2609193027,
0.5103209019,
-0.064775005,
0.0310822278,
0.2145197242,
-1.1052573919,
0.2951658368,
0.7100971341,
0.7234315276,
-0.1941858232,
-0.0548017435,
-0.3115428388,
-0.1567697823,
-0.5554189682,
0.9678620696,
-0.6430183649,
-0.7646576166,
-0.2854413688,
0.0276924148,
-0.1641401052,
-0.798458755,
0.5956723094,
-0.311892122,
0.1767388582,
-0.6868770123,
-0.3543720841,
-0.0108764954,
0.2290434688,
-0.5254997015,
0.6046757698,
0.4030325711,
-0.4823041558,
0.6413721442,
-0.8781337142,
-0.3609384,
0.1084242016,
-0.771756053,
-0.3473345339,
0.3783137202,
0.4889984131,
0.4226487577,
-0.7660384178,
0.5780739784,
-0.1992691457,
-0.2042040527,
0.053994868,
-0.2980256081,
0.5524738431,
-0.0936492309,
-0.5469703674,
-0.0084874146,
-0.5480297804,
0.1556549966,
0.0382526368,
-0.0507178046,
-0.1008558422,
-0.4165516496,
-0.4184609652,
0.3910268545,
-0.1948239505,
-0.3368724883,
0.4482930005,
-0.6178900003,
0.7338285446,
0.7064166665,
0.5293098092,
0.3761419356,
-0.5046210289,
0.9234768152,
-0.2919989228,
0.3475026786,
0.0737356544,
-1.0210278034,
-0.3892824054,
-0.3560796976,
0.2166357785,
0.4927535653,
-0.6152945757,
0.0400718413,
0.240705654,
-0.3035151958,
-0.6661883593,
-0.0588937365,
0.3899570704,
0.9871512651,
0.5930642486,
-0.5009317398,
-0.2664038837,
-1.0206708908,
-0.4207891524,
0.2049256265,
-0.2064943761,
0.4148460329,
0.2867319286,
-0.3644728661,
0.9178737402,
-0.424904108,
-0.023284968,
-0.0516166538,
0.2221938521,
0.6967579722,
0.6960075498,
0.7880386114,
-0.9426825643,
-0.4812817574,
0.001613392,
-0.5614448786,
-0.430264622,
0.0102895917,
0.0069086133,
-0.2349378914,
0.1518716812,
-0.8855648041,
0.2992728055,
0.2341946065,
-0.408683598,
0.909163177,
-0.1736191213,
0.4201048911,
-0.6890909672,
0.1916550547,
0.0387663059,
0.1515834183,
-0.8512336612,
0.0107235191,
0.2163691819,
-0.3436084688,
-0.0948803723,
0.6703816056,
-0.4740252495,
0.1351784766,
-0.3270828128,
-0.4485518336,
0.08907222,
0.2320592701,
-0.1248187572,
0.8636388779,
0.6580212712,
-0.8709536195,
0.3488929868,
0.2729333639,
-0.0471807197,
0.7278006673,
-0.9314174056,
0.150169,
0.2535505295,
0.0473722443,
-0.8019662499,
-0.4510602951,
0.0543570817,
-0.3006996512,
0.5468271375,
-0.0463765562,
-0.0148417316,
-0.8073482513,
-0.0138481418,
0.131226778,
0.687769115,
-0.3883072138,
0.4585680664,
-0.1727643013,
-0.5767310858,
-0.4179186821,
-0.4404764473,
-0.0200822502,
-0.2288764268,
-0.6245211363,
0.6199730039,
-0.3459721506,
0.1893785,
-0.1977117211,
-0.5908293128,
-0.2670985758,
0.1841026992,
0.1807583421,
0.3539605737,
-0.2379420549,
-0.0072928285,
0.291847229,
-0.5438783169,
0.1421643496,
-0.4402037263,
0.2582161129,
-0.1206154004,
-0.7072123885,
-0.5336079001,
0.5851810575,
0.4214666188,
-0.2197992504,
0.0156132579,
0.3302188218,
-0.3112876713,
-0.023747839,
-0.7744280696,
-0.6510465145,
-0.5511628985,
0.2247111648,
-0.6997026205,
-0.9883050323,
0.2367565036,
-0.4049632251,
0.2218974978,
0.4788797796,
0.550290823,
0.1550849229,
1.2775253057,
0.825425148,
0.1339339763,
0.1392806172,
-0.2357188314,
0.0683479011,
-0.5279603601,
-0.0412751697,
-0.4903036058,
-0.2489479631,
-0.2744734287,
-0.0714346468,
0.8041092157,
0.0204813723,
-0.3912880123,
-0.0164236091,
-0.9452195764,
0.4679716527,
0.5559741259,
0.1655243188,
0.1736747473,
-0.0300000291,
-0.5251249671,
-0.169203192,
-0.8891969919,
-0.1059408858,
1.0196774006,
0.2396654338,
0.5161030293,
-0.2684267759,
0.6747631431,
0.1401787251,
0.556899786,
-0.5659757257,
0.2635826468,
-0.0717498586,
-0.7464966178,
0.0655541122,
-0.2363882512,
-0.9135912061,
-0.0085897688,
0.032060951,
-0.3726702929,
0.4457768798,
0.4783456624,
-0.8375451565,
-0.1328469366,
-0.8297956586,
0.8344631195,
-0.1660320461,
-0.173841387,
-0.0201555435,
-0.6901586652,
0.3674560189,
-0.3422560394,
0.0719408765,
-0.0158483461,
-0.2012375295,
0.4187011719,
-0.3102805912,
0.8422826529,
-0.4168612063,
0.0318102352,
0.0642446876,
0.0428589284,
0.4791162908,
0.0729258507,
0.1072122529,
-0.2967621386,
-0.1026050225,
-0.5222861767,
-0.7470047474,
0.7706916928,
-0.7296625376,
-1.1635322571,
-0.2436435819,
-0.2087445408,
-0.8114591241,
0.0928333625,
0.7575775981,
0.5671383739,
-0.0433428101,
-0.0679210201,
0.8965790868,
0.0361880176,
0.1519924551,
0.6065841913,
0.3517979681,
-0.3573859036,
0.5993953347,
0.1286351979,
0.2852830589,
0.0311157685,
0.3842281997,
-0.3447476327,
-0.5960351825,
-0.6744254231,
0.2158873379,
-0.6105686426,
-0.234991774,
-0.7402373552,
-0.1575462669,
-0.3552173972,
-0.616586566,
-0.2268973142,
-0.2826269269,
-0.2694334686,
-0.0397604294,
0.3266970515,
0.8227096796,
-0.0057974039,
-0.0027052499,
-0.6997027397,
0.3011952043,
0.5328444839,
0.2498947084,
-0.3126530349,
-0.4098326564,
0.136390239,
-0.3648551702,
-0.4284906387,
-1.0397827625,
-0.0009381988,
0.2135270238,
0.8545718789,
0.5283641815,
0.0037840111,
0.2999851704,
-0.5898143053,
0.791023016,
0.4090564251,
-0.7012847662,
0.5792601705,
-0.4610624909,
0.3146250248,
0.5092718005,
0.780616343,
-0.1858184338,
-0.0812423304,
-0.8199462295,
-0.6147446036,
0.1518318802,
-0.1389413327,
-0.0885021985,
-0.0239589959,
0.719389379,
0.3246433139,
0.4051001072,
-0.3682207465,
0.160965547,
-0.301351279,
-0.1695958525,
0.0231627245,
0.0748089626,
-0.4013386369,
-0.1418965906,
0.4994582832,
-0.2253766358,
0.2037340701,
0.4906368256,
0.1838071793,
0.0075717312,
0.4152624309,
0.5937129259,
0.6827537417,
0.23016271,
-0.1518196911,
0.2154832333,
-0.5370786786,
0.4975214303,
0.3847319782,
0.0310497526,
-0.0832918286,
0.1804942191,
0.4267355502,
0.4220794141,
-0.2884015739,
0.4099728465,
0.1499487907,
-0.5765308142,
0.4176627994,
0.3066978753,
-0.1350590438,
0.3024886847,
0.4540582299,
0.4277071953,
0.4057568312,
-0.2469415218,
0.3231506646,
0.3039152324,
-0.3972035646,
-0.5568384528,
0.9195490479,
0.4579614103,
-0.1131192073,
0.2273420841,
-0.0011255274,
-0.3893035054,
0.664939642,
0.5475527644,
0.8455583453,
-0.6298350692,
0.1280740947,
0.1094238386,
0.2005524486,
-0.3875703216,
0.4322783351,
-0.0522998907,
-0.4521725774,
-0.6005926132,
-0.2113341838,
-0.4903426766,
0.1811931282,
-0.5152504444,
0.0213947203,
-0.7550811172,
-0.5668042898,
0.1186190769,
0.0296710115,
-1.0372129679,
0.340135783,
-0.3693110943,
1.115291357,
-0.8662739992,
0.5277843475,
0.8513408899,
-0.2351843119,
-0.7931627631,
-0.2239347249,
0.156944409,
-0.8955071568,
0.3877457082,
0.3160189092,
0.086814709,
0.1256284714,
-0.4537428617,
-0.6717326641,
0.8454501033,
0.3880184591,
-0.6375300288,
-0.4101432562,
-0.2711856961,
0.3512392938,
-0.4127081633,
-0.0036726755,
0.7035093904,
0.5023830533,
-0.1564275771,
-1.1724077463,
0.3217105567,
-0.3932810724,
-0.1686887294,
0.1199329644,
-0.3966393769,
1.027518034,
-0.5523976088,
-0.0569007285,
0.2403606027,
0.068485558,
0.5340100527,
0.49026227,
0.3461871147,
0.3100192547,
0.9306433797,
-0.1756859273,
1.1648070812,
-0.3178189993,
-0.0244128369,
0.5917019248,
-0.4183119535,
0.1514013857,
0.3112885654,
-0.1752305478,
0.3440292478,
0.8347058892,
-0.0510814451,
0.7265945077,
0.1308979094,
-0.4162139893,
-0.4405902922,
0.2025870383,
-0.9455476403,
-0.124530293,
0.433829695,
-0.2255781591,
-0.1521744579,
0.3322018683,
-0.1890747249,
-0.0279688947,
-0.4499771893,
0.5475871563,
0.3198383451,
-0.7970438004,
0.8589451909,
-0.2889531255,
0.469668448,
-0.7474244237,
0.0719959289,
-0.1194539741,
0.1042500958,
-0.02167519,
-0.493898809,
-0.0796492547,
-0.1868226975,
-0.3594926298,
-0.2020170987,
0.7941935658,
0.1789681613,
-0.0779007301,
-0.0266000479,
0.6292000413,
-0.033643458,
-0.3372191191,
-0.8757655025,
-0.331273526,
0.0040974054,
-0.2639614642,
0.2784471512,
0.6675242186,
-0.1771780252,
0.761000514,
0.5906068683,
0.0648555085,
-0.2559744716,
0.1889075786,
1.2725634575,
-0.7003041506,
-0.6704850197,
-0.6648529768,
0.344147265,
0.0662814602,
-0.6459456682,
0.3409902155,
0.0897085071,
0.401642859,
-0.2309348583,
1.0185139179,
0.2540541291,
0.5801716447,
-0.6236817837,
0.3891781867,
-0.3166763484,
-0.0060816705,
-0.0872227326,
-0.6717591882,
-0.315824151,
0.3723173141,
-0.5399318933,
0.4680927396,
0.7617368102,
0.6856137514,
-0.2120918185,
0.3197566569,
0.29643628,
0.0291359536,
0.4316908717,
0.8763970733,
0.8755732179,
0.1879457384,
0.2860857546,
0.2220472097,
-0.8090083599,
-0.2962632775,
-0.6201642156,
-1.0833842754,
-0.3498415649,
-0.1256968528,
-0.2346856296,
0.3716391623,
0.7929517627,
0.9252359867,
-0.8125055432,
0.4789518118,
-0.3480389118,
-0.3491944671,
-0.3780958056,
-0.099779889,
0.2867878079,
-0.3319502175,
-0.2642049193,
0.8492259383,
0.206250757,
0.3217343986,
-0.164443627,
0.0941367149,
0.3266891837,
-0.0018336038,
0.1236115843,
0.6252086759,
-0.6064965129,
-0.1263914108,
0.2653951645,
0.1000518203,
0.0243170317,
1.2593207359,
-0.8948108554,
0.2464143038,
0.1394478083,
0.8874945641,
0.2565650344,
0.0742758587,
0.9068799615,
-0.5369189978,
-0.1698019654,
0.478448391,
0.3998740017,
0.3012348711,
-0.5894734263,
0.5160142779,
0.4445524514,
-0.9053365588,
-0.5921250582,
0.5130748749,
-0.5182926059,
-0.2455311269,
0.7532464266,
-0.024187332,
0.2215235233,
-0.4161981046,
-0.4371933341,
-0.1338250041,
-0.4073687494,
0.7944670916,
0.5763681531,
-0.5635929704,
-0.088137202,
-0.9483233094,
0.9462649822,
0.7609531283,
-0.5784870386,
-0.3357653022,
0.2626124918,
0.6565886736,
-0.0087641021,
0.9847826958,
0.0668005049,
0.7587450147,
-0.1122118309,
-0.2826858759,
-0.2569475174,
-0.4876497388,
-0.4258188307,
0.3349733651,
0.0345574692,
0.0358055122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16444v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16444v2
|
Exo2EgoDVC: Dense Video Captioning of Egocentric Procedural Activities Using Web Instructional Videos
| 2023-11-28T02:51:13 | 2023-11-29T06:01:34 |
Takehiko Ohkawa, Takuma Yagi, Taichi Nishimura, Ryosuke Furuta, Atsushi Hashimoto, Yoshitaka Ushiku, Yoichi Sato
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
We propose a novel benchmark for cross-view knowledge transfer of dense video
captioning, adapting models from web instructional videos with exocentric views
to an egocentric view. While dense video captioning (predicting time segments
and their captions) is primarily studied with exocentric videos (e.g.,
YouCook2), benchmarks with egocentric videos are restricted due to data
scarcity. To overcome the limited video availability, transferring knowledge
from abundant exocentric web videos is demanded as a practical approach.
However, learning the correspondence between exocentric and egocentric views is
difficult due to their dynamic view changes. The web videos contain mixed views
focusing on either human body actions or close-up hand-object interactions,
while the egocentric view is constantly shifting as the camera wearer moves.
This necessitates the in-depth study of cross-view transfer under complex view
changes. In this work, we first create a real-life egocentric dataset (EgoYC2)
whose captions are shared with YouCook2, enabling transfer learning between
these datasets assuming their ground-truth is accessible. To bridge the view
gaps, we propose a view-invariant learning method using adversarial training in
both the pre-training and fine-tuning stages. While the pre-training is
designed to learn invariant features against the mixed views in the web videos,
the view-invariant fine-tuning further mitigates the view gaps between both
datasets. We validate our proposed method by studying how effectively it
overcomes the view change problem and efficiently transfers the knowledge to
the egocentric domain. Our benchmark pushes the study of the cross-view
transfer into a new task domain of dense video captioning and will envision
methodologies to describe egocentric videos in natural language.
|
[
-0.2628484666,
-0.6310936213,
0.128657192,
0.1121087298,
-0.352904439,
0.0797404274,
-0.1643232405,
-0.41169402,
0.1118335724,
0.3338634372,
-0.5413915515,
-0.2032542825,
-0.6493478417,
-0.330481559,
-0.4905911982,
0.8655937314,
-0.3950830698,
0.2949935198,
-0.3658206165,
-0.2267816216,
-0.1896442622,
-0.3411073387,
-0.2522624135,
0.0827213079,
0.0872040167,
0.4534792602,
0.254794538,
0.7485725284,
0.4987322986,
0.238979131,
0.5884434581,
0.2783710957,
-0.5192157626,
-0.0961856768,
-0.289716363,
-0.4670056999,
-0.141184926,
0.1227909923,
0.4084821343,
0.6520053148,
-0.3520966768,
0.3798335195,
0.1747860312,
0.6835289598,
-0.7341188788,
0.3634697795,
-0.6155660152,
0.3668868244,
-0.0001933402,
-0.372146517,
-0.0587687641,
-0.3461509049,
0.5159905553,
-1.0024998188,
0.4654999673,
0.301300317,
0.703251183,
0.7694311738,
-0.0323260203,
-0.0980851352,
-0.6173641682,
0.4978761375,
-0.0956576243,
0.4731984735,
0.224726975,
0.6420072913,
0.4495078325,
-0.5418988466,
-0.5641527772,
0.2716254294,
0.4983116984,
0.3473272026,
-0.0110654989,
-0.0588341951,
0.1324146837,
0.2017576247,
-0.7552160621,
0.0572863668,
-0.410150975,
-0.1285525262,
0.5852871537,
0.0453318506,
0.0146873901,
0.0536920577,
-0.6250642538,
-0.4481268227,
-0.3582690358,
0.293259114,
0.4074905515,
-0.201668486,
-0.3798366785,
0.5005431175,
-0.288181752,
0.4844792187,
0.4378005564,
0.0755671188,
0.2837021351,
-0.1990173012,
-0.5427861214,
0.1277192682,
0.4500313997,
0.9558618069,
0.4921295941,
-0.1187096983,
0.4545499682,
-0.1676848978,
0.4667755067,
-0.8129921556,
-0.5365024805,
-0.0061907619,
-0.2378487438,
-0.0465859473,
0.2667606771,
-0.7529948354,
-0.5712456107,
-0.4826347232,
0.4004673064,
-0.2186493278,
0.0437982306,
0.1256560981,
-0.0829488859,
0.3051524758,
0.7477735877,
-0.7524434924,
0.5750794411,
0.5120738745,
0.798147738,
-0.4063961506,
-0.2984385788,
-0.5406208634,
0.3446918428,
-0.2214893699,
0.7536239028,
-0.1155498326,
0.3153167963,
0.2718417048,
0.1099505201,
-0.1409094632,
-0.5343064666,
0.026035564,
-0.3579087555,
0.1487751752,
-0.0415291041,
-0.4075261354,
-0.6009590626,
0.4664372504,
-0.4051517844,
0.6494486928,
0.1059702113,
-0.3330240548,
0.5001556277,
-0.0936876312,
-0.3783245385,
-0.0131898653,
-0.3007363379,
-0.3056812286,
-0.24239856,
0.0662347525,
0.5173388124,
-0.2969392538,
-0.101636745,
-0.2346810549,
0.0929120183,
0.2282387167,
-0.3093332946,
0.3316289485,
-0.0110852113,
-0.5228050351,
-0.015483222,
-0.7052509785,
0.1931860745,
-0.1576869041,
0.1941417307,
-0.4387791455,
-0.042130772,
-0.0254410747,
0.2559603155,
0.0226071887,
-0.3296513259,
0.267383635,
-0.1073043644,
0.396035552,
0.7304970622,
0.0241241939,
0.7498250008,
0.0066577238,
0.5103846192,
0.0069843717,
0.386502862,
0.0588924177,
-0.2656532824,
-0.6741451025,
-0.0594969131,
-0.183919996,
0.5530954599,
-0.9811270237,
0.195892483,
-0.2836786807,
-0.4266527891,
-0.3395272195,
0.3048146069,
0.7130306363,
0.4947754741,
0.5988241434,
-0.861716032,
-0.4633386731,
-0.7866108418,
-0.1278362125,
-0.1576626003,
0.1691965163,
0.6040854454,
0.3489824533,
0.0752139911,
0.2965802252,
-0.5481415391,
-0.80189538,
0.019825859,
0.1710543483,
-0.3686675131,
0.4395667315,
0.540260911,
-0.9012554884,
-0.7728658915,
0.2095024288,
-0.9230403304,
0.2976058125,
-0.3545115292,
-0.1697608978,
0.0055513885,
0.6534121633,
-0.1914569885,
0.3170582354,
0.6303079724,
0.0175780337,
0.476988256,
-0.2893900275,
0.295514226,
-0.6945860982,
-0.2394772023,
0.0579247363,
-0.3661243021,
-0.2215991169,
0.0808841512,
0.0580332913,
0.2735794187,
-0.6698800921,
0.3216894865,
-0.7610706091,
-0.1808554828,
-0.0217145793,
0.1650433391,
-0.1146630272,
0.920273602,
0.2155190706,
0.5019812584,
0.7512558699,
-0.6211063266,
0.6378974915,
0.2728666663,
-0.3825794458,
0.8844056129,
-0.3548503816,
0.0069022845,
0.1356098205,
0.1202305108,
-0.8274359107,
-0.4084357321,
0.4446969926,
-0.5658220053,
0.2463354617,
-0.343503356,
-0.2367258519,
-0.1455681622,
-0.3852866292,
0.5625382066,
0.229853332,
-0.4281795621,
0.5081874132,
0.4048256278,
-0.1193317771,
-0.4282791018,
-0.6468931437,
-0.1468398869,
-0.1414836049,
-0.5694402456,
0.492698282,
-0.1498523057,
-0.0020990246,
0.0278921463,
-0.2340115011,
-0.3808700442,
-0.2352297604,
0.4504006207,
0.1683002114,
0.0090221353,
-0.2909205258,
0.2355256528,
0.2257503569,
0.2180033475,
-0.5619838834,
0.265440762,
0.1010716632,
-0.342332691,
-0.7277622819,
0.1763234735,
0.5123786926,
0.0014210248,
0.4249662757,
0.5500643253,
-0.4581130147,
-0.1572740525,
-0.7147936225,
0.0707083791,
-0.3913495541,
0.7114731073,
-0.0691175014,
-0.6262068152,
0.4039035141,
0.125684306,
-0.0013309154,
-0.0607697479,
0.5137057304,
-0.0559659116,
0.8310892582,
0.6265181899,
0.1199226826,
0.6322680116,
-0.5899007916,
-0.2926541269,
-1.0760580301,
-0.5711736679,
-0.0661657974,
-0.452994436,
-0.1379718333,
-0.9252420664,
0.3554686606,
0.0008862242,
-0.3192673922,
0.4319368005,
-0.4142934084,
0.3760658205,
0.2583418489,
0.0810426697,
0.1901584864,
0.3503215015,
0.1702466607,
-0.3754983246,
-0.4587193727,
0.0170407444,
1.0560686588,
0.0524923615,
0.8793419003,
0.3507485986,
0.2361809909,
0.6493086219,
0.1177642718,
-0.7044061422,
0.4077052176,
-0.1014756411,
-0.3272667229,
-0.2619106174,
-0.2496149838,
-0.6435596347,
0.0876206383,
-0.0094689131,
-0.6040834188,
0.3071509302,
0.3299720883,
-0.5121623278,
0.2823629379,
-0.7657280564,
0.8356536627,
-0.6385005116,
-1.0539886951,
-0.2663749754,
-0.9012277126,
0.0785207748,
0.3179320097,
0.1000752077,
0.354202956,
-0.1897244602,
0.5781921148,
-0.3909696937,
0.6963143945,
-0.346865207,
0.0500213578,
0.4134283364,
0.3253113031,
0.4250450134,
0.2761589885,
0.5441539884,
0.117670767,
-0.2497500181,
-0.2301156223,
-0.6606872678,
0.5636373162,
-1.0333601236,
-0.4579496086,
-0.5593838692,
-0.3705084324,
-0.1937139481,
0.0862395465,
0.3303619027,
0.2961014807,
-0.2388879806,
0.3975377381,
0.9411156178,
0.0491363779,
0.0784424245,
0.6873675585,
0.0097712744,
-0.4945254028,
0.9545189738,
0.136958316,
0.4212923944,
0.6739700437,
-0.2919726968,
-0.1375096887,
-0.7031202912,
-0.8547936082,
-0.0708501935,
-0.4631948769,
-0.3145036995,
-0.6040796041,
-0.2842934132,
-0.526448071,
-0.3060356379,
-0.7164773345,
-0.4116995335,
-0.2904407978,
-0.1525835544,
0.0577844009,
0.2452304065,
-0.0413333364,
0.0620607585,
-0.5799917579,
0.3365158439,
0.61539644,
0.2149481326,
0.0178811643,
-0.8609278798,
-0.3791226149,
-0.0851877034,
-0.2810923755,
-0.56866014,
0.5105338097,
0.3623831868,
0.5460016131,
0.6957040429,
-0.1578135788,
1.0540399551,
-0.5727675557,
0.6338041425,
0.4884129763,
-0.6720849872,
0.2549989223,
-0.158106342,
-0.0049866964,
0.712828815,
0.5125910044,
-0.5532956123,
0.1439844072,
-0.3832128048,
-0.9138038158,
0.7942163944,
0.213838309,
-0.0706723109,
0.3580947816,
0.3699839115,
0.4683864117,
0.2491767853,
-0.4091236889,
-0.2174585015,
-0.6607846618,
-0.0375867374,
0.0371296778,
0.3487381637,
-0.1757426262,
-0.2714870572,
0.5405157208,
-0.5331947207,
0.0074031157,
0.5462617874,
-0.6256346107,
-0.2397496402,
-0.210413605,
0.5199998617,
0.3495516479,
-0.183330074,
0.1247677431,
-0.0310562365,
-0.795404911,
0.0443201065,
0.4266740084,
-0.1861249208,
-0.4363682568,
0.1251155436,
0.6436231732,
0.3465923369,
-0.8161365986,
0.7426945567,
-0.0622480474,
-0.3447057009,
-0.7594667077,
0.1168498248,
-0.4318720102,
0.4153420329,
0.3322406709,
0.4723764658,
0.4628376663,
-0.6903013587,
-0.1047102138,
0.2660774291,
-0.8450559974,
-0.6475362182,
0.9163572788,
0.4255447388,
-0.0905139148,
0.3297457397,
-0.3262071908,
-0.4085890949,
0.7471789718,
0.0126989279,
0.9634410143,
-0.1238799393,
0.2837277651,
0.6343918443,
0.1440275162,
-0.2095276713,
-0.1303680092,
-0.5532032847,
-0.5538315773,
-0.0991311744,
-0.194979921,
-0.3572397232,
-0.1713842005,
-1.1527924538,
0.1708453745,
-0.6130079031,
0.4592474401,
-0.0748885721,
-0.2095853835,
-0.7991389632,
0.2622467875,
0.4117420912,
0.5426407456,
-0.5939858556,
0.6585499048,
0.787738204,
-0.412640959,
-0.5569775701,
-0.1478333324,
0.3935985565,
-0.9811389446,
0.3594333231,
0.1943480521,
-0.2711695731,
-0.1185302958,
-0.7434013486,
-0.7258992195,
1.351446867,
-0.1050365567,
-0.8421947956,
-0.1918845773,
0.0442038141,
0.6563336253,
-0.5366937518,
0.1923861355,
0.1859442592,
0.1473044753,
0.1854485869,
-0.7488887906,
-0.1142436787,
-0.346981734,
-0.2083690614,
-0.1526778191,
-1.0926952362,
0.5009526014,
-0.3828400373,
-0.047474619,
0.3284912109,
0.7255795002,
-0.2085130662,
0.5334732533,
0.490365684,
0.5159568191,
0.4383951128,
0.1924089193,
0.8767485023,
-0.0224813763,
0.1834327728,
1.5001182556,
-0.4793394208,
0.6420416236,
0.5339816809,
-0.088059634,
0.6449452043,
0.3377010226,
-0.2199932486,
0.7183671594,
0.0976469293,
0.2532546222,
-0.3616296351,
0.0114992801,
-0.4133119285,
0.3970627189,
0.2917010784,
-0.3523595929,
0.1826453656,
0.1603538841,
-0.2174870521,
0.3002620637,
-0.3422336578,
0.8847938776,
-0.1432613432,
-1.0266159773,
0.2493447512,
-0.3338302374,
0.4540029764,
-0.765226841,
-0.2041031271,
-0.069846876,
0.4717050195,
-0.2701468766,
-0.7343403697,
-0.0404763855,
0.1431059241,
-0.2269286662,
-0.3609143198,
0.1940607578,
-0.496591121,
-0.1903113872,
0.2596330047,
0.4879057705,
0.3474289775,
-0.3687832654,
-0.6199037433,
-0.3605766296,
0.1999322921,
0.0473766327,
0.500105381,
0.5866758227,
-0.2407381982,
0.5804181099,
0.435346514,
-0.0414498411,
0.3033147752,
0.2609443367,
0.815952301,
-0.4768920839,
-0.5076762438,
-0.2679102123,
0.3101183772,
-0.0846639276,
-0.4205616117,
0.8969681263,
0.9129867554,
1.1838189363,
-0.1996748149,
0.781703651,
-0.4197869599,
0.2650550008,
-0.5682210922,
0.4673034549,
-0.6612727642,
0.0258862823,
-0.2571125329,
-0.9812142849,
-0.0768303797,
0.4660382569,
-0.040768709,
-0.2817443311,
0.7800281644,
0.5489492416,
-0.1118368208,
-0.1841954738,
0.1272484362,
0.3740558624,
0.0982069597,
0.7820360065,
0.6333786249,
-0.6486332417,
1.0055918694,
-0.5586968064,
-0.4743733108,
-0.4174099863,
-0.4552721381,
-0.9055274129,
-0.5646746159,
-0.84756881,
-0.2145426571,
0.3294599056,
0.7717958689,
0.9706684947,
-0.5471891761,
-0.1218123436,
-0.1978825331,
-0.2628446817,
-0.7981414795,
-0.2558670342,
0.2638191283,
0.2761699557,
-0.8812083602,
-0.2329986244,
0.3698177338,
-0.0765791833,
-0.5001037717,
-0.1510602385,
-0.1233142689,
-0.2271758318,
0.5034692883,
0.6301476359,
-0.4594018459,
-0.2991452515,
0.2572011054,
0.1729986072,
0.2173587382,
0.9624415636,
-0.6115989089,
0.8724825978,
0.4039610028,
0.4492740333,
0.7381239533,
0.3172539771,
0.2247906923,
-0.5832572579,
0.2459451258,
0.1049420759,
0.1580614448,
0.523137033,
-0.2978355885,
0.5933235288,
0.3926288486,
-0.4024337828,
-0.3832105398,
0.078898035,
-1.5687521696,
0.0767978355,
1.2183634043,
-0.3820921183,
-0.2733936012,
-0.2022208422,
-0.2664706409,
0.1906380206,
-0.4165849984,
1.017790556,
0.5013474226,
-0.3152061403,
-0.2240955234,
-0.4699750543,
0.3256536126,
0.3198432028,
-0.975972116,
0.061559476,
0.4890980422,
0.3479301035,
0.1947242171,
0.1100474149,
-0.2597005367,
0.6371933818,
0.0182875656,
0.1469321102,
-0.326754123,
-0.5090617537,
-0.1670802534,
0.1004557237,
-0.5350616574,
-0.2599286437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03731v6
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03731v6
|
MultiGPrompt for Multi-Task Pre-Training and Prompting on Graphs
| 2023-11-28T02:36:53 | 2024-02-22T06:35:04 |
Xingtong Yu, Chang Zhou, Yuan Fang, Xinming Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Graphs can inherently model interconnected objects on the Web, thereby
facilitating a series of Web applications, such as web analyzing and content
recommendation. Recently, Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) have emerged as a
mainstream technique for graph representation learning. However, their efficacy
within an end-to-end supervised framework is significantly tied to the
availabilityof task-specific labels. To mitigate labeling costs and enhance
robustness in few-shot settings, pre-training on self-supervised tasks has
emerged as a promising method, while prompting has been proposed to further
narrow the objective gap between pretext and downstream tasks. Although there
has been some initial exploration of prompt-based learning on graphs, they
primarily leverage a single pretext task, resulting in a limited subset of
general knowledge that could be learned from the pre-training data. Hence, in
this paper, we propose MultiGPrompt, a novel multi-task pre-training and
prompting framework to exploit multiple pretext tasks for more comprehensive
pre-trained knowledge. First, in pre-training, we design a set of pretext
tokens to synergize multiple pretext tasks. Second, we propose a dual-prompt
mechanism consisting of composed and open prompts to leverage task-specific and
global pre-training knowledge, to guide downstream tasks in few-shot settings.
Finally, we conduct extensive experiments on six public datasets to evaluate
and analyze MultiGPrompt.
|
[
-0.6742892265,
-0.761767447,
0.4760752618,
0.2079787403,
-0.4578382075,
-0.0931590274,
-0.3086078465,
-0.2141131312,
0.1867386103,
0.0223056413,
-0.973524332,
-0.4593042731,
-0.7797859907,
0.133449316,
-0.0150372908,
1.1461626291,
-0.0299866293,
0.0547495112,
-0.2536194623,
-0.1083934382,
-0.6169172525,
-0.5728673935,
-0.810074985,
-0.3507703245,
1.390933156,
0.476675868,
0.0750129893,
0.0162487533,
-0.0836583078,
0.2571124732,
0.4807903469,
0.33930251,
-0.4713023603,
0.0898510888,
0.132799536,
-0.0957959294,
-0.1693986207,
0.1937678456,
0.4574902654,
0.4951043725,
0.2003327608,
0.4602342844,
0.5794922113,
0.4251333177,
-0.7839380503,
0.4481832683,
-0.236488536,
0.0933639854,
-0.1793734729,
-0.2004687637,
-0.4140002728,
-0.0899282098,
0.1291556954,
-0.8619760871,
0.2675583065,
-0.0374649428,
0.6387506723,
0.1957194805,
-0.4996725023,
-0.1172460243,
-0.0338465087,
0.3981927037,
-0.1899582744,
0.3176205754,
0.3607432246,
0.4377962649,
0.1526609957,
-1.1608167887,
-0.4893749654,
-0.0920678452,
-0.2386300564,
0.3407278955,
-0.1002992243,
0.0862007365,
0.3810107708,
-0.3356209993,
-0.7332401872,
0.2090964615,
-0.0526178703,
-0.421885103,
-0.0388206244,
-0.0427685864,
0.2219073921,
-0.1756122708,
-0.673615694,
-0.2795959115,
-0.5081111193,
0.3299896419,
0.5908346176,
0.7638854384,
0.0050611631,
0.3372141123,
-0.2455646992,
1.0750417709,
-0.0126719512,
0.2311849594,
0.2678835094,
-0.547329247,
-0.0351966359,
0.0233822055,
0.9564164877,
0.2265572995,
0.421527952,
0.0760093257,
0.2561475933,
0.0170998294,
0.2406242043,
-0.9169296622,
-0.4256369174,
0.1127251163,
-0.3619798422,
-0.0247599613,
-0.0593581796,
-0.8750480413,
-0.3344618976,
-0.402172327,
0.4518253505,
-0.3734881282,
-0.0281986333,
-0.1896380484,
-0.3784965873,
-0.1450241059,
0.367444098,
-0.8755092025,
0.0326510333,
0.3691359162,
0.905403614,
-0.0106118228,
-0.9255999327,
-0.7836165428,
0.1371853948,
0.1193686798,
1.0511602163,
-0.3549060822,
-0.2135350406,
-0.053709954,
0.1576546729,
-0.450715512,
0.1711339653,
0.1593403518,
-0.5461660028,
0.3333923817,
-0.4045495987,
-0.2603218257,
-0.3267511725,
0.7363343239,
-0.6104490757,
0.6547056437,
0.0285295211,
-0.9991241097,
0.7117894888,
-0.7118218541,
-0.7085265517,
0.0292641874,
-0.2189602256,
-0.3590513468,
-0.4208992422,
0.7218345404,
0.6382784247,
0.0014213265,
0.1161568835,
-0.4674609601,
-0.161387831,
-0.1751918942,
-0.3348412216,
0.6936791539,
-0.1926839948,
-0.0984544083,
0.7224118114,
-0.2567844689,
0.4880533218,
0.0381295569,
-0.1243723035,
0.0600964837,
-0.4107657969,
-0.1290996075,
0.3937059343,
0.193640694,
-0.2400350422,
0.2545150518,
0.1116788536,
0.4264365137,
0.8976236582,
-0.0327991843,
0.2243405133,
-0.214107722,
0.6632837057,
-0.2714406848,
0.2188200951,
-0.5603212118,
-0.6412814856,
-0.1557072401,
-0.4965022802,
0.2099174559,
0.6198132038,
-0.8872903585,
0.131560728,
-0.1582697928,
-0.3370034397,
0.1383589506,
0.1346312016,
0.4467508197,
0.9301145673,
0.5952287912,
-0.2486448884,
-0.3216819465,
-0.3304440975,
-0.3696217537,
0.1931239367,
0.1377288401,
0.5408445597,
0.3486712873,
-0.1659522951,
0.9985761642,
-0.6711841822,
-0.7356419563,
-0.3601953387,
0.4774854183,
0.2800450921,
0.4650949836,
0.602568686,
-0.7215748429,
-0.7003078461,
-0.499756664,
-0.6926087737,
0.1545927227,
0.093999356,
-0.0521004647,
-0.2964749336,
0.4297755361,
-0.7427111268,
0.3330950141,
0.5547993779,
-0.0368118584,
0.8082103729,
-0.4144801795,
0.2854922414,
-0.883277297,
0.2256679535,
-0.0553753152,
-0.2914709151,
-0.5719162226,
-0.259050101,
0.0883121938,
-0.5512728095,
-0.5242203474,
0.6454485655,
-0.5280584097,
-0.0089687062,
-0.1785728037,
0.1643048227,
0.1067645699,
0.7461903095,
-0.2206726372,
0.8294973373,
0.7240968347,
-0.8496079445,
0.5697404742,
0.4557487965,
-0.0873516202,
0.539827466,
-0.5895286798,
0.4497208297,
-0.3813945949,
0.6046109796,
-1.122038126,
-0.3725596368,
0.5021207333,
-0.4816584289,
0.3257322311,
-0.5225115418,
-0.5914332867,
-0.7793901563,
-0.1237247884,
0.5115678906,
0.0254371259,
-0.7045409083,
0.4977669716,
0.04021677,
-0.1862684935,
-0.8432036042,
-0.4517126977,
-0.0572720841,
-0.0837303698,
-0.4824969769,
0.1819014549,
-0.0008196885,
0.7090615034,
0.0464961827,
0.0882996097,
-0.1241494194,
-0.1367870569,
0.3538803458,
0.0681171492,
0.1687783599,
0.2987336814,
0.0370546542,
-0.5372434258,
-0.1933742613,
-0.9378150702,
0.9323089123,
0.1057154164,
-0.638266325,
-0.5256912708,
0.2651903033,
0.0623183213,
-0.5607177019,
0.3571288586,
0.9716110229,
-0.1755101383,
-0.1445245743,
-0.1318688393,
-0.4691285193,
-0.459200412,
0.3069557548,
-0.3759931028,
-0.8489521742,
0.4059453011,
-0.5004473329,
-0.250311166,
0.0298470892,
0.331651628,
-0.1015639529,
1.0548977852,
0.3508602381,
-0.063155368,
0.7695109248,
-0.230127573,
0.0427006036,
-0.6052665114,
-0.120503284,
-0.3607338965,
-0.4436317384,
0.0585297309,
-0.275668174,
0.3936114013,
0.2881853878,
-0.4620215893,
0.1664877534,
-0.6473885775,
0.4783670902,
0.9684228897,
0.3797948062,
-0.1633115113,
0.1411757618,
-0.2927704751,
0.2186414599,
-0.8802351952,
-0.1516362429,
1.0606306791,
-0.2922190726,
0.4585666358,
-0.3421044648,
0.7229550481,
0.2711654902,
0.1661713123,
-0.6299798489,
0.4988555908,
-0.1629068404,
-0.5031932592,
-0.5294123292,
-0.422408402,
-1.2757664919,
0.1190472469,
-0.2061615884,
-0.9518278241,
-0.135557577,
0.6366530061,
-0.4802731276,
0.131689921,
-0.8279961348,
1.4393920898,
-0.4073677063,
-0.3000427783,
-0.0518860295,
-0.9128768444,
0.0716638491,
0.1758401096,
0.112371698,
-0.2382299155,
0.3158685863,
0.5718355775,
-0.1553808302,
1.1598626375,
-0.7065855265,
0.4110393822,
0.4629486501,
-0.1655191034,
0.7177611589,
0.1552988738,
0.2632404864,
0.0410789214,
-0.2730276287,
-0.4068312347,
-0.5318464041,
0.3830598891,
-0.5705710649,
-0.3382727504,
-0.2885759473,
-0.4375271797,
-0.4191922545,
0.7657164931,
0.6755171418,
0.7353372574,
-0.0146892937,
-0.4242012501,
0.1317418218,
-0.1285521686,
0.5369118452,
-0.1497789919,
-0.1605808735,
-0.6705444455,
1.0331691504,
0.0795782208,
0.0806375071,
0.0985940918,
0.2054318339,
-0.6577822566,
-0.2696424723,
-0.7573799491,
-0.0867663547,
-1.0354610682,
-0.2383598387,
-0.6376226544,
0.3015525043,
-0.6352443099,
-0.0763295516,
0.1132017151,
-0.1311184317,
-0.5765211582,
-0.1440460384,
0.2474590838,
0.4983874857,
-0.1255477816,
0.6092553735,
-0.9004275203,
0.4815737903,
0.783418417,
0.2740655839,
0.1458191574,
0.0538756885,
-0.0079572955,
0.0484624207,
-0.1497662216,
-0.9867073298,
0.1125041619,
0.2942903638,
0.7333289385,
0.4382228255,
0.0893990472,
0.7432099581,
-0.7330098152,
0.5962575674,
0.715624094,
-0.8132107854,
0.5004162192,
-0.3807787299,
0.3935326934,
0.6596633792,
0.7222129703,
-0.4672756493,
0.0994646028,
-0.3208723366,
-0.7621136904,
0.7885521054,
-0.3806634247,
0.1824742109,
0.0872053578,
0.1728594601,
0.2070443779,
0.5300267339,
-0.6628769636,
-0.2107735574,
-0.7708887458,
-0.2167126238,
-0.351298064,
0.0151282139,
-0.454861939,
-0.1815032661,
0.2559817433,
-0.9118278027,
0.468003124,
0.1721465886,
-0.3539627194,
0.4166470766,
0.228944391,
0.5180994868,
0.8250841498,
0.2390026599,
0.4153846502,
0.1367193013,
-0.3051078022,
0.3376501501,
0.5114322305,
0.0444506966,
-0.4137633145,
0.4630034268,
0.8981689215,
0.1678986847,
-0.1933849007,
0.7162744999,
-0.1058217287,
-0.0753913373,
0.0165169239,
-0.2245199233,
-0.0283280741,
0.3012578785,
0.3622112274,
0.0827372298,
-0.1034277007,
-0.3590002358,
0.448022753,
0.3046722412,
-0.6634513736,
-0.2538616955,
0.646214962,
0.0024830122,
-0.0084277401,
0.7628934979,
-0.5001054406,
-0.8297457099,
0.459898293,
0.5449598432,
0.5518952012,
0.1147208288,
0.5862400532,
0.3849562407,
-0.0096335001,
-0.0429174751,
0.3432045877,
-0.298704356,
-0.7283673882,
-0.6471839547,
-0.1188754067,
-0.1191715673,
-0.3813078403,
-0.419439584,
0.1335884333,
-0.3787291944,
-0.5994204879,
-0.1260913312,
-0.260923177,
-0.8727226853,
0.1649935544,
0.0066301567,
0.4479904473,
-0.7026301622,
0.7747133374,
0.8286134005,
-0.5102441311,
-0.7993065715,
-0.1567800492,
-0.0449577235,
-0.952227056,
0.8390977979,
0.7335430384,
-0.0532047711,
0.5350199938,
-0.5452286005,
-0.6532021761,
1.0147314072,
0.5041760802,
-0.2070102841,
-0.2219551951,
-0.0753585845,
0.1390860379,
-0.1487089097,
0.2499851882,
-0.2126286775,
0.7484360933,
-0.0199744422,
-0.6851173639,
0.3167181015,
0.0509748794,
-0.4969868064,
0.061667271,
-0.6012086868,
1.1581673622,
-0.4107574522,
-0.2665774524,
-0.3963535428,
0.2954781055,
0.3849836886,
0.3527506292,
0.8041775227,
0.4439879358,
1.0180529356,
-0.0732529908,
1.0379205942,
-0.4124581218,
0.3257532716,
1.310056448,
-0.2547031045,
0.2743409276,
0.3185921907,
0.0730843768,
0.4258173108,
0.8043119907,
0.0126442052,
0.7441734672,
0.0871410444,
-0.2441003472,
-0.5110765696,
-0.2095184028,
-0.3238764405,
0.1135448366,
0.0632693246,
0.0358436257,
-0.4832432568,
0.4478235543,
-0.0463296622,
-0.3674201965,
-0.3473433554,
0.701438725,
0.0940897316,
-0.8080408573,
0.2170088738,
-0.5490064025,
0.4107167423,
-0.9634717703,
-0.0250277482,
0.4002380967,
0.0522273816,
-0.200137198,
-0.7428115606,
-0.2590967417,
-0.4143666923,
-0.0340400301,
-0.5564498901,
1.0568727255,
-0.2736151516,
-0.0448823012,
0.5960626602,
0.7500602603,
-0.1566473097,
-0.5714808702,
-0.7558679581,
-0.321182996,
-0.2913805842,
-0.2295015901,
0.4119467437,
0.4007363021,
0.1527872533,
0.6239158511,
0.9755695462,
-0.1046899185,
0.2713219523,
0.4476414919,
1.0579273701,
-0.3860736191,
-0.830709517,
-0.7463752031,
0.5033199787,
-0.1333824843,
-0.3708396554,
0.8987018466,
0.2923232317,
0.6855480671,
-0.0363064632,
0.8475418687,
-0.0572987162,
0.1706445962,
-0.5282241106,
0.6391420364,
-0.3953368068,
-0.6076105833,
-0.316550374,
-0.7896642089,
-0.4277786911,
0.3482814133,
-0.4104920328,
0.1898768991,
0.7312467694,
0.33333534,
-0.0826597139,
-0.030343635,
0.058616437,
-0.4952710271,
0.3347147703,
0.4762327969,
0.9594577551,
0.1418392807,
0.7531321049,
-0.0561282039,
-0.1610691845,
-0.0219772533,
-1.0600787401,
-1.0772179365,
-0.5564582348,
0.1270453036,
-0.1791387349,
0.0769223049,
0.6822186708,
1.0628999472,
-0.521329999,
0.1289560646,
-0.1990266442,
0.1625205427,
-0.4995218217,
-0.0950031132,
0.590585649,
-0.8260991573,
-0.3421050906,
0.4977003634,
0.0439626351,
0.3227533996,
0.097474061,
-0.001371733,
-0.3537918925,
-0.7163107991,
0.5244016051,
0.4376734495,
-0.1591756791,
-0.4569767118,
-0.0793716982,
0.1535843462,
0.0879698545,
1.2343597412,
-0.9698930383,
0.5299900174,
0.6230082512,
0.5544787645,
0.9151770473,
0.2122340649,
0.4347586632,
-1.1632272005,
0.5031534433,
0.137801826,
0.3157263696,
0.1772301793,
-0.2751017213,
0.2128521055,
0.2538579404,
-0.4863179624,
-0.4509034157,
0.5137076378,
-0.6783283949,
-0.4504418671,
0.6838722229,
-0.5176543593,
-0.0303850211,
-0.2106660455,
-0.2451447994,
0.499743849,
-0.3764716387,
0.2487129569,
0.547786653,
-0.4500237107,
-0.3040476739,
-0.4227233827,
0.5785316229,
0.1806724817,
-0.9641133547,
0.0147887757,
0.4805538058,
0.0608026348,
0.199733153,
0.9814218283,
0.4736341238,
0.1359163076,
-0.0019747906,
0.0470825993,
-0.6613233685,
-0.8207244277,
-0.1111685559,
0.4711000919,
-0.2727693617,
-0.3995414674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17086v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17086v1
|
PEA-Diffusion: Parameter-Efficient Adapter with Knowledge Distillation in non-English Text-to-Image Generation
| 2023-11-28T02:31:52 | 2023-11-28T02:31:52 |
Jian Ma, Chen Chen, Qingsong Xie, Haonan Lu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Text-to-image diffusion models are well-known for their ability to generate
realistic images based on textual prompts. However, the existing works have
predominantly focused on English, lacking support for non-English text-to-image
models. The most commonly used translation methods cannot solve the generation
problem related to language culture, while training from scratch on a specific
language dataset is prohibitively expensive. In this paper, we are inspired to
propose a simple plug-and-play language transfer method based on knowledge
distillation. All we need to do is train a lightweight MLP-like
parameter-efficient adapter (PEA) with only 6M parameters under teacher
knowledge distillation along with a small parallel data corpus. We are
surprised to find that freezing the parameters of UNet can still achieve
remarkable performance on the language-specific prompt evaluation set,
demonstrating that PEA can stimulate the potential generation ability of the
original UNet. Additionally, it closely approaches the performance of the
English text-to-image model on a general prompt evaluation set. Furthermore,
our adapter can be used as a plugin to achieve significant results in
downstream tasks in cross-lingual text-to-image generation. Code will be
available at: https://github.com/OPPO-Mente-Lab/PEA-Diffusion
|
[
-0.4487346113,
-0.7150216699,
0.7681589127,
0.4803561866,
-0.4942837656,
-0.2287413925,
-0.302962631,
-0.0157382675,
-0.0898974538,
-0.1219109893,
-0.2632042468,
-0.1529599428,
-0.6899932623,
0.1746384203,
-0.4280858338,
0.608799994,
-0.0970223099,
0.0666966364,
-0.1191313639,
0.1259547919,
-0.4383271933,
0.1097876728,
-0.7916043401,
-0.0871681646,
0.2788053155,
0.5299687982,
0.2387145162,
0.296007216,
-0.0272726957,
0.219083637,
-0.0396143347,
0.2040403783,
-0.4677711129,
0.0310038123,
-0.3368615806,
-0.1090601683,
0.2032478154,
-0.0651021376,
0.6120011806,
0.7428783178,
0.0249968637,
-0.160755083,
0.3612849712,
0.8821800351,
-0.5525325537,
-0.0094829239,
-0.8025308251,
0.1217316985,
0.0441789739,
-0.2681117356,
-0.6491114497,
-0.2772153616,
0.1222841665,
-0.6604380608,
0.2106269449,
0.0962447375,
0.5371058583,
0.0529227704,
-0.5006377697,
-0.2610043287,
-0.723675549,
0.7381677032,
-0.4167503417,
0.1606698781,
0.1295064837,
0.4174582362,
-0.2512637377,
-0.8854845762,
-0.6759572029,
0.0142002478,
0.076173164,
0.2743923664,
-0.124119401,
-0.3975040019,
-0.0004142253,
0.3451987207,
-0.3671953082,
-0.1857100576,
-0.2647816241,
0.0091581,
0.249335885,
-0.2395060807,
0.4543738365,
0.0876076519,
-0.4836013317,
0.1441520005,
-0.5249356627,
-0.1907142997,
0.2160988152,
0.1484566927,
-0.2127717137,
0.1676101089,
0.0256704465,
0.7710495591,
0.4551516175,
-0.161989063,
0.0281106867,
0.0029844975,
0.1748875678,
-0.0697357655,
1.1189881563,
0.3154251575,
0.240322873,
-0.2271032482,
-0.0457472205,
-0.2384013534,
-0.1735145897,
-1.1831638813,
-0.4990146756,
-0.22498326,
-0.3717441559,
-0.4157170355,
-0.3585426211,
-1.0645968914,
-0.4221547842,
0.1237098575,
0.464466542,
-0.610650003,
-0.3767466843,
0.0390092842,
-0.4194321334,
0.1061779857,
0.28149575,
-0.9133977294,
0.2042407095,
-0.127819106,
1.124222517,
-0.4103925526,
-0.3993318081,
-0.5096361041,
0.1004538015,
-0.4769604802,
0.9980365038,
-0.4871999025,
-0.5962405205,
-0.1174084395,
0.1677706391,
-0.2266299725,
-0.3267715275,
0.3662696481,
-0.3634437621,
0.5325760841,
-0.3679433763,
-0.5421421528,
0.0185201503,
0.0838496312,
-0.4989663363,
0.856510818,
0.104954198,
-0.8750784993,
0.3848220408,
-0.7633618712,
-0.5732964873,
0.0196308382,
-0.1486106962,
-0.131853193,
0.1738915443,
0.3552137017,
0.4071240723,
-0.6247750521,
0.1609090418,
-0.098336488,
-0.2773474753,
0.0521070063,
-0.9638462067,
0.6478723288,
0.3192961812,
-0.2908657193,
-0.2719580233,
-0.7888514996,
-0.3838582337,
0.3420001566,
-0.353209734,
-0.3406693339,
-0.0700176358,
0.2488323897,
0.2610277534,
0.2528449595,
-0.5203573108,
0.1339708567,
0.008658953,
0.4292817414,
0.574665606,
0.1811308861,
0.875399828,
-0.1059569567,
0.5204296708,
0.1940630525,
0.1047498956,
-0.4080528617,
-0.7914000154,
-0.5751996636,
-0.4522266984,
0.4656657577,
0.4367780685,
-1.1796534061,
0.0403095819,
-0.0664009601,
-0.5102401972,
-0.4150834382,
0.0794680119,
0.0041434253,
1.1676847935,
0.3711577952,
0.0466077551,
-0.021709498,
-0.8182800412,
-0.1058125496,
-0.0871136636,
-0.1219515353,
0.1627819836,
0.0941387713,
0.2563260198,
0.7748696208,
-0.6038435102,
-0.2390798479,
-0.3452161551,
0.3441904485,
0.2773164213,
0.5837075114,
0.9310659766,
-0.779553771,
-1.0097427368,
0.0552704856,
-0.4763149321,
-0.2859660387,
-0.1845795512,
-0.329384774,
0.1813806742,
0.5335960388,
-0.4489507377,
0.2769541144,
0.7132576704,
-0.433095932,
0.4585448802,
-0.5037357807,
0.5417601466,
-1.6531953812,
0.2944860756,
0.0769776329,
-0.5036183,
-0.5219041705,
-0.2051772326,
0.3081021309,
-0.2449573874,
-0.8054429889,
0.6423686743,
-0.6785323024,
0.338337034,
-0.5146111846,
0.1943327188,
0.1761015356,
0.3936684132,
0.3671658635,
0.8193163872,
1.2378829718,
-0.7636352181,
0.2000144422,
0.0793341845,
-0.2742102444,
0.858181417,
-0.3963123262,
0.093402423,
-0.050040435,
0.055738084,
-1.1451146603,
0.1544270366,
0.2666801512,
-0.2518306971,
0.2915165424,
-0.5531710386,
-0.5140350461,
-0.0179122165,
-0.2341834903,
0.4886069298,
1.2418210506,
-0.906003058,
0.664214015,
-0.010857339,
-0.2258287221,
-0.244554773,
-0.6976258755,
0.0796638057,
-0.378618747,
-0.4691842496,
0.3637501597,
-0.207857579,
0.2061525732,
0.1252058446,
0.198799789,
-0.2932989299,
-0.2118464112,
-0.2367324531,
0.2161135972,
-0.1418037713,
-0.0467215031,
0.5154332519,
-0.1723797917,
-0.0772387311,
-0.4822285473,
0.3830747902,
0.2859362066,
-0.1932459772,
-0.3213474452,
0.4588671923,
0.6137644053,
0.2502299249,
1.017260313,
0.5992393494,
-0.0632490218,
-0.3384818137,
-0.2432576418,
-0.1654499173,
-0.4937229156,
0.1423808485,
-0.3956103325,
-0.2238518298,
0.3965301514,
-0.6520667076,
0.18798244,
0.2927026451,
0.3703492582,
-0.0835828781,
0.8823313713,
0.547503233,
0.0057382593,
0.4579150081,
-0.0887852758,
0.0158813205,
-0.6179152727,
0.1314094514,
-0.3317047954,
-0.4806875587,
-0.2189570367,
-0.6432695985,
0.2732654512,
0.1403520852,
0.3407996595,
0.0424509235,
-0.3452826738,
0.623942256,
0.2919410765,
-0.0595487282,
0.3521155417,
0.1256869882,
-0.3414353132,
-0.0183151383,
-0.8122309446,
-0.3099398911,
0.8563427925,
0.0228219777,
0.7828621268,
-0.0170801748,
0.6309566498,
0.1721527725,
0.1078491583,
-0.6930924058,
0.6648824811,
-0.4180623889,
-0.0847310051,
-0.1721871346,
-0.3469128907,
-0.7489771247,
0.3774453104,
-0.2111461312,
-0.2625939548,
0.3099488318,
0.4252124429,
0.2068290263,
0.5455464721,
-0.9865823388,
0.7221444249,
0.0173626058,
-0.5517833829,
-0.004798736,
-0.3288377523,
0.1870610714,
-0.3723127544,
0.344707787,
0.1059850752,
-0.2673847377,
0.5104984641,
-0.3876049519,
0.7710683346,
-0.6377183795,
-0.0920775533,
0.2483555079,
0.2488062531,
0.5347802043,
0.0549442396,
-0.1408478022,
-0.0363608412,
-0.2159924954,
-0.5448793173,
-0.616127789,
0.8037446737,
-0.4749204814,
-0.5431694984,
-0.0823500901,
-0.6998391747,
-0.2486778349,
0.2905983031,
0.7390373349,
0.2024863958,
-0.2229796499,
-0.0416681096,
0.8493893147,
-0.2864175439,
0.715274632,
0.7120689154,
-0.4382178783,
-0.2169918865,
1.0120785236,
-0.0036073157,
0.4391450286,
0.3012381792,
0.6235666871,
-0.2622864842,
-0.5944666266,
-0.9100036621,
0.0793224871,
-0.631737411,
-0.1036190838,
-0.5822064877,
0.0020274564,
-0.2328041196,
-0.2625924349,
-0.4744340479,
-0.6096304059,
-0.617816925,
0.2752544284,
0.6657963991,
0.4529188573,
-0.003881553,
0.2402856201,
-0.5419893861,
0.571932435,
0.4320304394,
0.2989464104,
-0.0563530028,
-0.9178721905,
-0.115745753,
-0.1373059005,
-0.3114201427,
-1.1731404066,
0.2763128877,
0.6474595666,
0.2592818737,
0.4567684829,
0.3935799003,
0.7464962602,
-0.8159328103,
0.8338747621,
0.3733946681,
-0.8701390624,
0.6325131059,
-0.1794057041,
0.444078505,
0.4516818523,
0.4661741853,
-0.327483356,
-0.5065286756,
-0.3159148693,
-0.9814478159,
0.5763396621,
0.1784113348,
0.28074646,
-0.0959147885,
0.2112759799,
0.4735960066,
-0.1218556762,
-0.65289855,
-0.1780868769,
-0.2212205529,
-0.2626889944,
0.109143056,
-0.0669837594,
0.1061301753,
-0.234006688,
0.8673608303,
-0.275799036,
-0.129639551,
0.222860992,
-0.3792802095,
0.0128194988,
0.2693135142,
0.209384799,
0.3170553744,
0.2184609324,
0.2173719555,
0.2179648727,
-0.5569501519,
0.2939316928,
0.0711588413,
-0.4322091341,
0.1841417402,
-0.094417952,
0.612515986,
0.1423611045,
-0.3859511912,
0.682986021,
-0.3130629063,
-0.5596831441,
-0.0333499461,
-0.0954796225,
0.3557728231,
0.0427002497,
0.4243756533,
0.3149810135,
0.3233887255,
-0.3060445786,
0.0520205982,
0.2755037248,
-0.2749086022,
-0.2748398483,
0.6696479321,
0.4965610504,
-0.0610066764,
0.4016818106,
-0.4091588259,
-0.0509571657,
0.3068070412,
0.9484894276,
0.8421030641,
-0.2632918358,
0.4179956317,
0.2433310747,
0.1444295049,
-0.2537668049,
0.3787303865,
-0.2134167701,
-0.524689734,
-0.2387470603,
-0.4670807719,
-0.1096316501,
0.0652075261,
-0.4409141243,
0.4590075612,
-0.3388783634,
0.0474638827,
-0.3074318469,
-0.593479991,
-0.5508087277,
-0.1143239215,
-0.0824713558,
1.1741384268,
-1.2047653198,
1.0174585581,
0.8458828926,
-0.1666710526,
-0.7040668726,
0.2342254221,
-0.3563174605,
-0.6663576961,
0.3459415734,
-0.033477217,
-0.1094929725,
0.1664919704,
-0.2292575389,
-0.3525251448,
1.027400136,
0.7548189759,
-0.6827207804,
0.2307955474,
0.0408427902,
0.4282414019,
-0.4059361815,
0.0831636712,
0.402266115,
0.4516347349,
0.5322307348,
-0.6256353259,
0.1531677693,
-0.3456926942,
0.1813456118,
0.0298981108,
-0.4688436389,
0.652872324,
-0.1685931981,
-0.2805543244,
0.0650223494,
0.5238562226,
0.1341771781,
0.2265060842,
0.6190375686,
0.4346337318,
0.4908071458,
0.1106723621,
0.6889896393,
-0.4841476679,
0.1042898148,
0.9207903743,
-0.2639046907,
0.7975646257,
0.937343061,
-0.0918962657,
0.5006980896,
0.4304783642,
0.0907734483,
0.9231661558,
-0.0961622745,
-0.4523792863,
-0.0269926358,
-0.0040764795,
-0.3084235787,
-0.1644234061,
0.032673955,
-0.6448881626,
-0.313804388,
0.2639295161,
-0.1333413571,
0.2320613712,
-0.1290603727,
0.9029744267,
-0.0465342253,
-0.5897303224,
0.5099397898,
-0.2794854641,
0.8470142484,
-0.5645904541,
-0.281365335,
-0.3112749755,
-0.1276276708,
-0.0892904773,
-0.7693264484,
0.156780988,
0.1844213307,
-0.3138122559,
-0.3925692439,
0.8128221035,
-0.6754171252,
-0.718544066,
0.2541018426,
0.5126135945,
0.3917956948,
0.0808787048,
-0.5584235191,
-0.292756021,
-0.061224822,
-0.2477420121,
0.4339181781,
0.7492249012,
0.367423296,
0.3689924479,
0.4445236623,
0.3843967617,
0.0719553158,
0.2385764122,
0.7954408526,
-0.2112989426,
-0.608982563,
-0.9062303901,
0.677280128,
-0.0200455915,
-0.0445265807,
0.5053317547,
0.5831201673,
0.2823138535,
-0.4927574694,
1.034091711,
-0.3696774244,
0.1980534047,
-0.6635330915,
1.0116641521,
-0.5610144138,
0.2878725231,
-0.3187964857,
-1.000479579,
0.1846859753,
0.400500536,
-0.0723626614,
-0.0375705138,
0.8316324949,
0.5933086872,
-0.3676868975,
-0.1553601027,
0.6666086912,
0.0820031315,
0.3143313229,
0.443558991,
0.7773635983,
-0.4289882183,
0.7503674626,
-0.3401224017,
-0.5147482157,
0.1974276602,
-1.3454352617,
-0.8677498698,
-0.7852272391,
-0.4303296208,
-0.1003091186,
-0.0387694836,
0.5026078224,
0.7689812183,
-0.457657367,
0.0180138666,
-0.5228409767,
-0.0876213536,
-0.1822316796,
-0.2390195429,
0.3354233801,
-0.4993040264,
-0.9374949932,
0.4239193797,
0.2808715403,
0.239972949,
-0.2375316173,
-0.1000504121,
-0.1117279381,
0.1814401597,
0.4885620177,
0.2735777497,
-0.282199204,
0.1493760198,
-0.2008549273,
0.3180276155,
-0.0225313883,
0.661093235,
-0.9147247672,
0.4915885627,
0.5352593064,
0.4986689687,
0.3792434037,
-0.3023294508,
0.7776198983,
-0.9346432686,
0.5376200676,
-0.129837051,
0.5739220977,
0.4122432172,
-0.3344409466,
0.0872040167,
0.4074013829,
-0.4325375259,
-0.5116113424,
0.2491203845,
-0.818061173,
-0.5259305239,
1.1265603304,
-0.2847471237,
-0.3328202963,
-0.0644921511,
-0.5944007039,
0.0600114502,
-0.5397179127,
0.8968839049,
0.4965958297,
0.0597697087,
-0.4647492766,
-0.1413563639,
0.3297711313,
0.1424847543,
-0.8483840227,
-0.0021918416,
0.4640694559,
0.6327674389,
0.0606088191,
0.6994757056,
-0.2187675387,
0.4204843938,
0.1546428055,
-0.0475038365,
-0.0943744779,
-0.1816072613,
-0.1772173941,
0.1881958097,
0.404188782,
-0.501619637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16421v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16421v3
|
CDEval: A Benchmark for Measuring the Cultural Dimensions of Large Language Models
| 2023-11-28T02:01:25 | 2024-06-20T11:52:47 |
Yuhang Wang, Yanxu Zhu, Chao Kong, Shuyu Wei, Xiaoyuan Yi, Xing Xie, Jitao Sang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
As the scaling of Large Language Models (LLMs) has dramatically enhanced
their capabilities, there has been a growing focus on the alignment problem to
ensure their responsible and ethical use. While existing alignment efforts
predominantly concentrate on universal values such as the HHH principle, the
aspect of culture, which is inherently pluralistic and diverse, has not
received adequate attention. This work introduces a new benchmark, CDEval,
aimed at evaluating the cultural dimensions of LLMs. CDEval is constructed by
incorporating both GPT-4's automated generation and human verification,
covering six cultural dimensions across seven domains. Our comprehensive
experiments provide intriguing insights into the culture of mainstream LLMs,
highlighting both consistencies and variations across different dimensions and
domains. The findings underscore the importance of integrating cultural
considerations in LLM development, particularly for applications in diverse
cultural settings. Through CDEval, we aim to broaden the horizon of LLM
alignment research by including cultural dimensions, thus providing a more
holistic framework for the future development and evaluation of LLMs. This
benchmark serves as a valuable resource for cultural studies in LLMs, paving
the way for more culturally aware and sensitive models.
|
[
-0.2280872464,
-0.5794812441,
0.2989164293,
0.2289552093,
-0.0229440331,
0.4334830642,
-0.5372246504,
-0.4170657098,
-0.1127946079,
0.2575654387,
-0.4715411365,
-0.7046238184,
-0.4572944343,
0.1660848856,
-0.3169644773,
0.9129386544,
-0.1838220358,
0.100694254,
-0.3270359933,
-0.4065077603,
-0.3133876622,
-0.5741134882,
-0.1443487704,
-0.1847774684,
0.405588299,
0.2668969333,
0.8554332256,
0.8677550554,
0.8115136027,
0.2298505753,
-0.1327519715,
0.1310273558,
-0.5929515958,
0.1477251202,
-0.1123507172,
-0.1545851827,
-0.6896176338,
0.3148002326,
0.7630512118,
0.7382324934,
-0.2312196642,
0.5023049712,
0.1267529279,
0.664477706,
-0.6789087057,
-0.1953459978,
-0.5488251448,
-0.1080624312,
-0.3221424818,
0.1219240874,
-0.1911481619,
-0.8345547915,
0.0774516538,
-0.416148454,
0.0194207486,
-0.0300664492,
0.6385944486,
0.1573437899,
-0.9173005819,
-0.262516588,
-0.7784606218,
1.0900280476,
-0.4963250756,
0.4960522354,
0.1137892976,
0.4205587208,
0.1663661897,
-0.4845245481,
-0.6289938092,
-0.2259854823,
0.2156440616,
0.0151369162,
0.1647225618,
-0.3133913577,
0.0846160352,
0.5447213054,
-0.8148894906,
0.2827767134,
-0.152330339,
-0.1802664697,
0.8071026206,
0.3101329505,
0.3395755291,
0.108771272,
-0.5487985611,
0.0602750853,
-0.9798473716,
-0.0584302507,
0.1850088239,
0.2528102398,
-0.3544923067,
0.2608695328,
-0.0016129937,
0.3631055951,
-0.0168724209,
-0.3978247941,
0.4964318573,
-0.57142061,
-0.0055807568,
0.11684715,
0.5620279908,
0.4737447798,
0.5080258846,
0.1225534156,
-0.0621468388,
0.0563098937,
0.126340434,
-0.8576909304,
0.1304412335,
0.1882575303,
-0.5120179653,
-0.3780299127,
-0.1676387638,
-0.4880226851,
-0.5289571285,
-0.4679439664,
-0.1129515097,
-0.2373957336,
-0.5038003325,
-0.2057036459,
0.2724722922,
0.7234382033,
0.3487097323,
-0.8790419102,
0.3003115952,
0.9405881763,
0.6340476274,
-0.4560844302,
-0.4451066554,
-0.4192107916,
0.2331368774,
-0.6035645008,
0.460927248,
-0.7002364993,
-0.429292649,
0.3911768496,
-0.1630873829,
0.4166224003,
-0.4859614372,
0.9111608863,
-0.5322560668,
-0.0638844967,
-0.7980845571,
-0.5779473186,
0.0039035336,
0.5542864203,
-0.3875441551,
1.0316417217,
0.0106445467,
-0.4630127549,
0.6983386874,
-0.2879685163,
-0.3958645463,
0.4215607047,
-0.502155304,
-0.263230741,
0.033693973,
0.0338437743,
0.1229149401,
-0.6670675278,
0.2784449756,
-0.4798396528,
-0.277374208,
0.1332577616,
-0.6283282042,
0.8960956335,
0.3310905993,
-0.1895447969,
0.0792230666,
-0.7936022878,
0.2659063041,
0.1258503348,
-0.5594316721,
-0.3323959112,
0.0187626202,
0.1662480682,
0.4278697371,
0.6126238108,
-0.4528969526,
0.0944544226,
0.0912406817,
0.1820475906,
0.7441939712,
-0.4050940573,
0.3302404583,
-0.2054121047,
0.6560246348,
-0.0638255402,
0.2015989572,
0.1731277704,
-0.1041450799,
-0.3318105042,
-0.4116848707,
0.2205675095,
0.4375083447,
-0.1376994997,
0.6668508649,
-0.4578619003,
-0.6848102212,
-0.7093658447,
0.4992781878,
0.3306946158,
0.2743317783,
0.2119950205,
-0.3009703159,
-0.3873853683,
-0.8850289583,
-0.1550666541,
-0.3140604198,
-0.0741219595,
0.1740994751,
0.4244318306,
-0.1354408264,
0.8005484343,
-0.0572841242,
-0.2159253806,
-0.1059820801,
-0.0078075044,
0.1531558931,
0.3405329883,
0.4839563072,
-0.7137640715,
-0.5979314446,
0.2876325846,
-1.033583045,
-0.2212353051,
0.2519604862,
0.0307752844,
0.2232449353,
0.2927132845,
-0.261785984,
0.1814321578,
0.9266143441,
-0.2634493709,
0.5651305318,
-0.3564379513,
0.3701290488,
-0.962392807,
0.0276788771,
-0.0407972448,
0.038569726,
-0.6126924157,
0.1413913965,
0.5609449148,
0.0572734401,
-0.3412309289,
0.4370570779,
-0.7077311277,
-0.1861588955,
-0.1310634762,
0.4273385406,
0.101966314,
-0.0756911784,
0.0708293989,
0.7294573188,
0.4202639163,
-0.2048256099,
0.4363429248,
0.3135804534,
-0.4915818274,
1.2291078568,
-0.67640692,
0.157643348,
0.0968508795,
0.4296093583,
-0.7470672131,
0.0616757274,
-0.54220891,
-0.141606316,
0.2071700841,
-0.0682565793,
-0.6009379625,
-0.2313392758,
-0.253765136,
0.8121613264,
0.7453867793,
-0.5459103584,
0.5555127859,
0.4547185302,
-0.0769020095,
-0.5495274067,
-0.5092870593,
0.2725345194,
-0.5952701569,
-0.9442352653,
0.3248647749,
-0.3635657728,
-0.556925416,
-0.57347399,
0.0420501642,
0.1666839123,
0.2458850294,
-0.0066240877,
0.3135768771,
-0.6101974249,
-0.0154713364,
-0.2447256297,
0.1612147242,
0.0471117757,
-0.2228633463,
0.4221481383,
-0.438977778,
-0.3861522973,
-0.4361518025,
0.3538770974,
0.790317595,
-0.6137575507,
0.6672328115,
0.5116728544,
-0.2824705243,
-0.0890769958,
-0.8056700826,
0.1524597108,
-0.469847858,
0.3343535364,
-0.3171574175,
-0.7336730361,
0.6006042957,
-0.0033297313,
-0.0315917395,
0.3370366096,
0.9462187886,
-0.0202099048,
0.8680423498,
0.5790663362,
-0.2927363813,
0.0186969396,
0.245165512,
0.0902805701,
-1.0128382444,
-0.0861265287,
-0.5393505096,
-0.5063390136,
-0.902633667,
-0.5009333491,
0.3705893755,
0.0168890283,
-0.5470420122,
0.1471724361,
-0.1898080111,
0.5591645837,
0.1346280277,
-0.5779118538,
0.6000546217,
-0.3367976248,
-0.2313524187,
-0.2159119248,
-0.0703642815,
-0.8210629225,
1.0112862587,
0.5696351528,
0.8738314509,
0.5912479162,
0.6601353288,
0.2149054557,
0.4265050888,
-0.5351485014,
0.4668491781,
-0.2611858845,
-0.7347829342,
-0.3510777056,
-0.1675088257,
-0.66095227,
0.370405376,
0.0098746363,
-0.6796389222,
0.2882649302,
-0.014911199,
-0.1304017007,
0.0866333619,
-0.4533710778,
0.7900460958,
-0.4420515299,
-0.4008881748,
-0.1632935256,
-0.5886471272,
0.278188765,
-0.2479425967,
0.4161783755,
-0.4066214263,
-0.2053575963,
0.4098761976,
-0.2709067464,
0.8378587961,
0.1274799556,
-0.7901621461,
-0.007001447,
0.2771964669,
0.5114236474,
-0.1097303703,
-0.3306864798,
0.3333863318,
0.0462841019,
-0.4407961965,
-0.2009625137,
1.1239070892,
-0.9728878736,
-0.5570158362,
-0.3567128181,
-0.8210666776,
-0.3305248022,
-0.0144171286,
-0.137369439,
0.2492147535,
-0.5917366147,
0.439774394,
0.4714713991,
-0.1618267298,
0.2828269899,
0.7530543208,
-0.1859638244,
-0.1714818478,
0.7360076904,
0.0938651711,
0.6601420641,
0.3343043327,
0.2072664946,
-0.2885150611,
-0.6071635485,
-0.3557085395,
0.1133235544,
-0.8157498837,
0.023336865,
-0.2729370296,
-0.234178111,
-0.512855351,
-0.3274483085,
-0.3870421946,
-0.150678128,
-0.0751193687,
-0.0924418569,
0.0531245247,
0.4938231409,
-0.0042762323,
-0.2305950671,
-0.7386117578,
0.0187559314,
0.1832289547,
0.2394436002,
-0.2231704295,
-0.7752773762,
-0.0558602214,
-0.0538618974,
-0.4515820146,
-0.367402494,
0.2236003429,
0.2716358602,
0.6575574875,
0.5668570995,
0.0125214262,
0.5641572475,
-0.6549170613,
0.9366953373,
0.1146479547,
-1.0683187246,
0.4349857867,
-0.4818016589,
0.4081217647,
0.5237821937,
0.3708369136,
-0.8628357649,
-0.3710339963,
-0.4030613303,
-0.5508284569,
0.1106146276,
0.1186453179,
0.2441689819,
-0.1767713875,
-0.0027941831,
0.2113007307,
0.0580280758,
-0.5930680037,
-0.1417077184,
-0.0018603023,
-0.3249461353,
-0.0838239491,
-0.3023647964,
-0.1756980121,
-0.1447978318,
0.3644404113,
-0.1424978226,
-0.417118609,
-0.1894978732,
-0.2748562098,
-0.3167671859,
0.3054868281,
0.6690114141,
1.0668228865,
-0.1231167838,
0.1662729234,
0.317604661,
-0.3531187475,
0.259631604,
-0.1183960661,
0.0758911222,
-0.5010560155,
0.5597154498,
0.2648620307,
-0.0851035863,
-0.4957057834,
0.511896193,
-0.0167303961,
-0.0827825665,
-0.3569384217,
-0.0990187153,
0.1480184793,
0.2428239882,
0.290933162,
-0.4280578494,
-0.1534219682,
-0.696850121,
0.1447568834,
0.6476305127,
-0.4503321946,
-0.419224143,
0.5682423711,
0.5141692162,
-0.236453101,
0.6973134279,
0.0686342269,
-0.2821640372,
0.4798924327,
0.537810266,
0.7979128361,
-0.5107633471,
0.2298980802,
0.3258922994,
0.4336248338,
0.1851876527,
0.1826669127,
0.113027893,
-0.9419626594,
-0.367115438,
-0.83418262,
-0.3056353927,
-0.1778497547,
-0.7898477912,
0.1945195794,
-0.2442441285,
0.1352558285,
-0.1783533841,
0.1523255706,
-0.7698884606,
0.2309263647,
0.3929309547,
0.8554805517,
-0.8955777287,
1.1554437876,
0.3869630098,
-0.3010442257,
-0.3451371193,
0.2139531523,
0.6063237786,
-1.1330833435,
1.0231134892,
-0.0187231787,
-0.1380331665,
-0.2232311517,
-0.2955963612,
-0.9857040644,
1.2867110968,
0.1636313945,
-0.5721786022,
0.1476405263,
0.3913778663,
0.7579446435,
-0.6280739903,
0.1269677728,
0.8982980251,
0.5062158704,
0.2141563445,
-1.0136122704,
0.2216877341,
-0.1199787632,
0.3069431484,
0.2243543565,
-0.7039661407,
0.6999994516,
-0.279384762,
-0.1354077011,
0.2447505891,
0.7270751595,
0.3922392726,
-0.1014888361,
0.3699580431,
0.2946106195,
1.0209652185,
-0.1953856051,
1.0227533579,
-0.378188014,
0.2687690854,
1.0069414377,
-0.9045194983,
0.9191883802,
0.4503164589,
-0.4019665718,
0.4348227084,
0.44717592,
-0.1671173722,
0.2848784924,
0.5253005028,
-0.2989479303,
-0.2859977782,
-0.4118925035,
-0.5948410034,
0.5640481114,
0.3350055814,
-0.2473303378,
-0.1492393315,
-0.2990359068,
-0.0296678189,
0.3033413589,
-0.0826804861,
0.7115937471,
0.058737766,
-0.4139575362,
0.7344954014,
-0.2324172407,
0.5691560507,
-0.5270835757,
0.2300686836,
-0.4665941894,
0.266828239,
-0.0146930572,
-0.8171695471,
0.0850299299,
0.0848079771,
-0.1557924747,
-0.2500990033,
0.1024853438,
-0.5070254207,
-0.6314532757,
0.3599113226,
0.4245280921,
0.0233434327,
0.3278114796,
-0.3883748949,
0.4164374471,
-0.1613738537,
-0.0158386026,
0.45411098,
0.7215501666,
-0.1766516268,
0.5320243239,
0.4468587935,
0.1771972477,
-0.2057984322,
0.3235147297,
0.3555489779,
-0.7015084624,
-0.1391967982,
-0.9440816045,
0.5348471999,
-0.1916595101,
-0.6300144196,
0.8393526077,
0.5362108946,
0.7825059295,
0.2285629958,
0.7698037624,
0.0341536924,
0.2246160805,
-0.3777807951,
0.7391974926,
-0.492036283,
0.5248292685,
-0.2767152488,
-1.0307887793,
-0.2266529053,
0.3253103495,
-0.4173849821,
0.3602133095,
0.7770910859,
0.5922626853,
0.2019627243,
0.1665572226,
0.6337765455,
0.3474796414,
0.5518682003,
0.241165638,
1.0599291325,
-0.094526954,
0.5044878721,
-0.0902544558,
-0.3935920596,
0.0216795374,
-1.2458149195,
-0.7218795419,
-0.5909997225,
-0.609538734,
-0.1237511858,
-0.2015441805,
1.0126056671,
0.570456028,
-0.7491247058,
-0.5592396259,
0.4555944502,
-0.0956714377,
-0.3947262764,
-0.1678949893,
0.4171715677,
-0.2811935246,
-0.7045183778,
0.2912941873,
0.4828417599,
-0.141988799,
-0.5908050537,
-0.1961523145,
-0.117273435,
0.1235594451,
0.6560608149,
-0.0000738891,
-0.9684525132,
-0.4941056669,
-0.1215351,
-0.2986241281,
0.1710582972,
0.7546450496,
-0.2601375282,
0.162158519,
0.3311339021,
0.5887789726,
0.0161691122,
-0.0206433497,
0.8264927864,
-0.8269770145,
-0.209610343,
0.1738480926,
0.453160584,
0.5740647316,
-0.1004097387,
0.3633332551,
-0.0900595263,
-0.8808345199,
-0.6994675398,
0.2839006484,
-0.9380118251,
0.1052276045,
1.2850211859,
-0.0640057847,
0.0832832083,
0.0291820206,
0.0551277958,
-0.2058205158,
-0.2122645229,
0.795414567,
0.8690404892,
0.3823305964,
0.0641291812,
-0.5651594996,
0.400953263,
0.1711841524,
-0.978112638,
0.4714973569,
0.5812113285,
0.3814380765,
0.1539953649,
0.2972577214,
-0.3378407657,
0.1658692211,
-0.3631293774,
0.128371492,
0.5100755095,
-0.0154357841,
-0.2480914146,
0.1150112897,
0.3453480899,
0.1483727247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16362v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16362v1
|
Reducing Gender Bias in Machine Translation through Counterfactual Data Generation
| 2023-11-27T23:03:01 | 2023-11-27T23:03:01 |
Ranjita Naik, Spencer Rarrick, Vishal Chowdhary
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advances in neural methods have led to substantial improvement in the
quality of Neural Machine Translation (NMT) systems. However, these systems
frequently produce translations with inaccurate gender (Stanovsky et al.,
2019), which can be traced to bias in training data. Saunders and Byrne (2020)
tackle this problem with a handcrafted dataset containing balanced gendered
profession words. By using this data to fine-tune an existing NMT model, they
show that gender bias can be significantly mitigated, albeit at the expense of
translation quality due to catastrophic forgetting. They recover some of the
lost quality with modified training objectives or additional models at
inference. We find, however, that simply supplementing the handcrafted dataset
with a random sample from the base model training corpus is enough to
significantly reduce the catastrophic forgetting. We also propose a novel
domain-adaptation technique that leverages in-domain data created with the
counterfactual data generation techniques proposed by Zmigrod et al. (2019) to
further improve accuracy on the WinoMT challenge test set without significant
loss in translation quality. We show its effectiveness in NMT systems from
English into three morphologically rich languages French, Spanish, and Italian.
The relevant dataset and code will be available at Github.
|
[
-0.1941202581,
-0.462454021,
0.2325428724,
-0.0451424904,
-0.0967976078,
0.1057242751,
0.0775797442,
-0.1498034596,
-0.0901851431,
0.5879123807,
-0.820979476,
-0.2242571414,
-0.7460418344,
-0.0012975675,
-0.3064117432,
1.1557207108,
-0.250151366,
0.5970576406,
-0.1927878708,
-0.3556544483,
-0.8991792202,
-0.5221781731,
-0.5679884553,
-0.6877788305,
0.1147457585,
0.2434160262,
0.6973517537,
0.4601908624,
0.350204289,
0.2007710636,
0.1461786181,
0.5979923606,
-0.5163618326,
0.1078038588,
-0.5125343204,
-0.6168734431,
-0.5915296674,
0.0308030359,
0.3406028152,
0.9293946624,
-0.1137440652,
0.0427644886,
0.1997439861,
0.8547241092,
-0.3498995006,
0.1086265221,
-0.8238914013,
0.2678774893,
0.02507101,
-0.3412047327,
-0.4127246737,
-0.2241454124,
0.220632866,
-0.4734709561,
0.7796345353,
0.0700740814,
0.6770646572,
0.4065557718,
-0.382850945,
-0.1332305372,
-0.7386286855,
0.9090899229,
-0.6996729374,
0.4322126806,
0.5064863563,
0.1458489597,
-0.3916648626,
-0.1012520641,
-0.3203556538,
-0.0410263538,
0.181812793,
0.2946035564,
-0.4563233852,
-0.3661717772,
0.2844370306,
0.0700481459,
-0.78966254,
-0.2638282776,
-0.2591293454,
-0.138506636,
0.411247462,
0.0088141337,
0.5448400974,
0.1624653041,
-0.0844196826,
-0.171328485,
-1.0728719234,
-0.579607904,
0.5061202645,
0.434350878,
0.1224639341,
0.4911990166,
0.1023076996,
0.282715857,
0.1524983943,
0.35050264,
0.3337003589,
-0.3310971558,
-0.0011346393,
0.0719450042,
0.6555504799,
0.4787087142,
0.5453464985,
-0.236418426,
-0.2832346261,
-0.0310648177,
0.6302220821,
-0.6450487971,
-0.1723127812,
-0.0977452472,
-0.3150693476,
-0.1213583127,
-0.1883666366,
-0.5215589404,
-0.3427378237,
-0.3851507604,
0.4359243512,
-0.5155054927,
-0.3195361197,
0.0251258668,
-0.2117742151,
-0.1413533688,
0.2656293213,
-0.8330577612,
0.2154405415,
0.3206188381,
0.8036877513,
-0.0217022467,
-0.3292513788,
-0.4818459153,
-0.0016202962,
-0.7854217291,
0.3778753281,
-0.0402055569,
-0.3171720803,
-0.2604133785,
-0.1192259938,
-0.3586986661,
-0.7868055105,
0.1115641519,
-0.293277353,
0.3407459855,
-0.4666906297,
-0.2068725377,
-0.0156422239,
0.2684077621,
-0.5293248296,
0.9591665864,
0.2285848409,
-0.752107501,
0.4628118277,
-0.4527044892,
-0.4304586053,
-0.3537607193,
-0.1963261813,
-0.6617185473,
0.2724294662,
0.3583878875,
0.1653610021,
-0.4318528473,
0.6556884646,
-0.1687284112,
-0.1242817715,
0.2318166792,
-0.57092309,
0.734629631,
0.100912571,
-0.6737404466,
-0.0547043458,
-0.535928607,
-0.3607361019,
0.2165763229,
0.1179425716,
-0.3473401666,
0.1211046427,
-0.1555381715,
0.4112169445,
-0.1744764298,
-0.5453183055,
0.038371399,
-0.4394180477,
0.4399030209,
0.7040052414,
-0.2551121414,
0.5417806506,
-0.2822682559,
0.4255754054,
0.3710909784,
0.077877149,
0.2081814706,
-0.449434936,
-0.8431236744,
0.0367125645,
0.3835532963,
0.7108623385,
-1.3339246511,
0.2408157885,
-0.2622554898,
-0.3092978001,
-0.5591660142,
0.2004312128,
0.5034886599,
0.8667144179,
0.6672291756,
-0.4226761162,
-0.6220511198,
-1.0798641443,
-0.3041640818,
-0.0571442395,
-0.1538593322,
0.3185708821,
0.7501699924,
-0.1419214606,
0.9481123686,
-0.3937504292,
-0.2970764041,
-0.1729462892,
0.3486478031,
0.2115846425,
0.8674955368,
0.713758111,
-0.7811095715,
0.0015935343,
-0.0738221779,
-0.8368964195,
-0.1671544015,
-0.196617201,
-0.3559355438,
0.2120006531,
0.3758167326,
-0.6075940132,
0.3979279101,
0.4280608594,
-0.457537055,
0.4756813645,
-0.2400681078,
0.2204978764,
-1.0678342581,
0.0144526483,
-0.1580995023,
-0.3612021208,
-0.5160813332,
-0.1645243019,
0.152725935,
0.068096675,
-0.5241132379,
0.509092927,
-0.3497495949,
0.048223719,
-0.2467397004,
-0.1588897556,
-0.1104785129,
0.3335469067,
0.0891041309,
0.908426702,
0.0955475569,
-0.3375124335,
-0.123888284,
0.4305305183,
0.1618424207,
0.886978507,
-0.5292892456,
0.1909362823,
-0.237097919,
0.2024203092,
-0.8639999628,
0.0360035971,
0.4240188301,
-0.6299215555,
0.2906241119,
-0.3239013255,
-0.3321924806,
-0.2274156809,
-0.1250082552,
0.208752811,
0.4280163646,
-0.5132685304,
0.4064145088,
0.0949033722,
-0.1379859447,
-0.8197720051,
-1.0899529457,
0.326546967,
0.018097803,
-0.2444449961,
0.2684123516,
-0.3002607226,
0.0366446227,
-0.1136139855,
-0.2561563551,
-0.0908131823,
0.1430942714,
0.0865151435,
0.3122488558,
-0.2000338584,
0.2124449015,
0.3634873629,
-0.1042065993,
0.067540437,
-0.7483097911,
0.5223534107,
-0.0069683571,
-0.2554032803,
0.0942062363,
0.4392962754,
0.4624045193,
-0.0590322465,
0.8572010994,
0.6420888305,
-0.5893136263,
-0.357919246,
-0.2654958963,
-0.3793186843,
-0.4004286826,
0.2945665121,
-0.4364824891,
-0.6380785108,
0.5027465224,
0.0657252222,
0.0651939809,
0.5922509432,
0.48345837,
-0.1027788445,
1.0091856718,
0.4238361716,
0.1164530218,
0.2782485783,
-0.1980951875,
-0.0243868921,
-0.6576565504,
0.142289713,
-0.4545268118,
-0.2568492591,
-0.5864530802,
-0.3931507468,
0.1316470355,
-0.1227534339,
-0.3299411833,
0.5029886961,
-0.3767381012,
0.2932641506,
0.6988140345,
0.4455348253,
0.057406012,
-0.050294593,
-0.2462393194,
-0.5048346519,
-0.9278483391,
-0.5398439765,
1.277744174,
0.1801849753,
0.2946255505,
0.1393590868,
0.4243142009,
0.443739295,
0.5072376132,
-0.3272857964,
0.3395583928,
-0.5715829134,
-0.8344529271,
0.0149485255,
-0.748370707,
-0.6553524137,
0.2087741196,
-0.2206637263,
-0.1779661626,
0.4162953198,
0.4011442959,
0.0496706367,
0.4128442109,
-0.5611553192,
0.825425148,
-0.0813574046,
-0.4821741283,
0.109859705,
-0.4492855072,
0.2464725524,
-0.3407206237,
0.0086753489,
-0.06310343,
0.1102169082,
0.709890604,
-0.4036240578,
1.1606595516,
-0.2622031569,
-0.2049138993,
-0.0299612712,
0.3103373647,
0.3313815892,
-0.0451919809,
-0.072451964,
0.5040522218,
-0.3787004948,
-0.5606892109,
-0.3753953576,
0.4765480757,
-0.7876019478,
-0.2609694898,
-0.3027150631,
-0.8858644962,
-0.3253493905,
0.4634367824,
0.5216901898,
0.3305490315,
-0.3846130669,
0.0537099242,
0.9959508181,
-0.3507643342,
0.295784086,
0.3716499805,
0.1445898414,
-0.5280546546,
0.8994953036,
0.4043278396,
0.3180387616,
0.2834916413,
0.135375306,
-0.111955069,
-0.6634790301,
-0.995521903,
0.0226390902,
-0.5059499145,
-0.3197533488,
-0.7155104876,
-0.0059531881,
-0.3717643023,
-0.0823053792,
-0.7671570182,
-0.5397258997,
-0.2891905606,
-0.029143801,
0.1826999336,
0.457457155,
0.1130654067,
0.4993183911,
-0.5475677848,
0.5156015754,
0.1532024443,
0.1242026836,
-0.1913840771,
-0.5863301158,
-0.0515621006,
0.2386740148,
-0.3522076011,
-0.7768285871,
0.7595650554,
0.1848045141,
0.5115587115,
-0.0534973294,
0.0126567613,
0.3881049752,
-0.848790288,
0.666206181,
0.2049239874,
-1.1372416019,
0.632522881,
-0.6579177976,
0.4095539451,
0.5405442119,
0.3739275038,
-0.5809238553,
-0.4278157651,
-0.5401315093,
-0.8664021492,
0.6710913181,
0.4010740221,
0.1554405838,
0.003459627,
0.3828766346,
0.4937193692,
0.4605463147,
-0.5311154723,
-0.2613421082,
-0.4698720574,
-0.6604965925,
-0.1569760293,
-0.0631148592,
-0.1938757449,
-0.14281106,
0.7886036634,
-0.3673990369,
0.2860346735,
0.2859593332,
-0.571089983,
-0.1633269936,
0.2232965529,
0.8511137962,
0.7463618517,
-0.2866445482,
0.2164031267,
0.3876255155,
-0.7618937492,
0.3086788654,
-0.0058570118,
-0.6130130291,
0.1600127667,
0.3818366528,
0.685669601,
0.0941484496,
-0.352509886,
0.3644728363,
-0.0350861624,
-0.5803799033,
-0.0774782971,
0.0026079004,
0.201094687,
0.1690265834,
0.4937808514,
0.6867442727,
0.1163590178,
-0.189331755,
0.3931533098,
0.2630042136,
-0.7018880844,
-0.2883454263,
0.9465407729,
0.1831236184,
-0.2375339866,
0.6197280884,
-0.0511349291,
-0.5497794151,
0.7011350989,
0.6367156506,
1.1553463936,
-0.3505980968,
0.1672659814,
0.3804064989,
0.7786762118,
-0.4314268827,
0.2634303868,
0.2850263417,
-0.8733500242,
-0.293094635,
-0.1381347328,
-0.4169623852,
-0.0624201335,
-0.4775579274,
-0.0401536189,
-0.4083259106,
-0.2561931908,
-0.312834084,
-0.30602929,
-0.7411942482,
0.3309628665,
-0.0102738915,
0.523645103,
-1.0802321434,
0.7331154346,
0.5304775834,
-0.3365673721,
-0.1796343327,
-0.1181231663,
0.1660558283,
-0.579151392,
0.786280632,
-0.0178741291,
-0.3970644176,
-0.1085631773,
-0.4235233068,
-0.5032908916,
0.8312598467,
0.8093879223,
-0.7072247863,
0.3259484768,
0.4185866117,
0.5441247821,
-0.4540397525,
0.392441839,
0.4875302911,
0.3763857782,
-0.2661536336,
-0.8853645921,
0.0470204577,
-0.3447929323,
-0.016910268,
0.0869808421,
-0.3059716821,
0.8162266016,
-0.0398406647,
0.1796895415,
-0.2781063616,
0.5534421802,
0.0986794755,
0.4356597364,
0.4758289158,
0.3918988109,
0.7046588063,
-0.23306036,
0.6915892959,
0.2271059453,
0.2297544479,
1.2575237751,
-0.224433437,
0.4728915691,
0.5500591993,
0.026309235,
0.0116222678,
0.5034012198,
0.0111482944,
0.371717304,
0.0812068433,
0.0456068777,
-0.3117324114,
-0.2104154527,
-0.4125593901,
0.3625193834,
0.1245579123,
-0.5205411315,
-0.095534265,
0.2017469257,
0.254001379,
0.2376740277,
-0.0332712159,
0.4366038442,
0.2019226104,
-0.4166365266,
0.6691532135,
-0.1953683197,
0.7120712996,
-0.2685626745,
-0.2080163211,
-0.5415694118,
0.3505908847,
0.0505974032,
-0.3807651997,
0.2890368402,
0.01919741,
-0.5995452404,
-0.5871071815,
0.5979971886,
-0.6081160307,
-0.6082159877,
0.21343714,
0.8692147732,
-0.0721697509,
-0.1278639287,
-0.906611681,
-0.3324971497,
0.0636117235,
-0.2063483745,
0.2181342542,
0.2296836078,
-0.4233302772,
0.6743606925,
0.5761222243,
0.2304634303,
-0.1065451726,
0.1859511435,
0.5624023676,
-0.6861175895,
-0.3975597918,
-0.904293716,
0.2101706415,
-0.1045434251,
-0.4593557417,
0.6364579797,
0.4384341836,
0.9007698298,
-0.3753530681,
0.7325304151,
0.2787906826,
0.5446926355,
-0.4189054072,
1.1345483065,
-0.4930983782,
0.1406873167,
-0.4119806588,
-0.7357390523,
-0.4875259101,
0.3661889136,
-0.3231751621,
0.1991694421,
0.612537086,
0.849673748,
-0.3226765692,
-0.2203292251,
0.3639888763,
0.1044078469,
0.3846610785,
0.6311200261,
0.7523661852,
-0.9285202622,
0.4277796447,
-0.1018999666,
-0.092730619,
-0.1508220583,
-0.9722906947,
-0.9311097264,
-0.2631349266,
-0.5242674351,
-0.3027347922,
0.5083901882,
0.9334062934,
0.8299807906,
-0.8995274901,
-0.0691266209,
-0.2705122828,
0.1547163427,
-0.4884428382,
-0.1022299081,
0.2537898421,
-0.1638369411,
-0.6762014627,
0.4754606485,
0.014861254,
0.0567293949,
0.092554383,
-0.2153637558,
-0.1451199055,
0.0883746445,
0.4781150818,
0.0171495359,
-0.2781945765,
-0.1901262701,
0.0681629777,
-0.0893710032,
0.1252957135,
0.8006944656,
-0.6036304832,
0.4073695838,
0.4599028528,
0.7190321684,
0.2932053506,
-0.2949473262,
1.0357882977,
-0.8095237613,
0.0106617166,
0.1422361881,
0.2690347433,
0.484310627,
-0.415065825,
0.7204443216,
0.5529662967,
-0.1372435838,
-0.7481210232,
0.1500632614,
-0.5573211908,
-0.5397527814,
0.7280762792,
-0.0772842243,
-0.194901213,
-0.2952966988,
-0.2039822936,
0.5302302837,
-0.2873111665,
0.704384625,
0.7273983955,
0.1495812684,
-0.1634444594,
-1.0912977457,
0.3648941219,
0.9088272452,
-0.7581490278,
0.1056129038,
0.4362581968,
0.3801472187,
-0.0882584825,
0.4123702347,
-0.2335094959,
0.44190678,
0.0581630692,
0.4005478024,
-0.0537434034,
-0.3534262776,
-0.2708537877,
-0.0957509652,
-0.158157751,
-0.1971012503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17076v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17076v3
|
Compositional Chain-of-Thought Prompting for Large Multimodal Models
| 2023-11-27T22:23:27 | 2024-04-01T03:17:09 |
Chancharik Mitra, Brandon Huang, Trevor Darrell, Roei Herzig
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The combination of strong visual backbones and Large Language Model (LLM)
reasoning has led to Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) becoming the current
standard for a wide range of vision and language (VL) tasks. However, recent
research has shown that even the most advanced LMMs still struggle to capture
aspects of compositional visual reasoning, such as attributes and relationships
between objects. One solution is to utilize scene graphs (SGs)--a formalization
of objects and their relations and attributes that has been extensively used as
a bridge between the visual and textual domains. Yet, scene graph data requires
scene graph annotations, which are expensive to collect and thus not easily
scalable. Moreover, finetuning an LMM based on SG data can lead to catastrophic
forgetting of the pretraining objective. To overcome this, inspired by
chain-of-thought methods, we propose Compositional Chain-of-Thought (CCoT), a
novel zero-shot Chain-of-Thought prompting method that utilizes SG
representations in order to extract compositional knowledge from an LMM.
Specifically, we first generate an SG using the LMM, and then use that SG in
the prompt to produce a response. Through extensive experiments, we find that
the proposed CCoT approach not only improves LMM performance on several vision
and language VL compositional benchmarks but also improves the performance of
several popular LMMs on general multimodal benchmarks, without the need for
fine-tuning or annotated ground-truth SGs. Code:
https://github.com/chancharikmitra/CCoT
|
[
-0.5806660056,
-1.0531204939,
0.9373489618,
-0.0180904418,
-0.5322009921,
0.195681259,
-0.1486416459,
-0.3751155734,
0.2247110158,
0.4302689433,
-0.9421160221,
-0.5480613708,
-0.1225729883,
-0.0172711723,
-0.2156281024,
0.8599637151,
-0.0862802193,
-0.1178328097,
-0.2763389647,
-0.0992126241,
-0.7236222625,
-0.3673637509,
-0.4778397679,
-0.2008270323,
1.1242743731,
0.1500636339,
0.3701093793,
0.4549904168,
0.3087229729,
0.2267820239,
0.1378761828,
0.6295664907,
-0.3921373785,
0.3844344914,
-0.3775554895,
-0.1283508837,
-0.4303564429,
-0.1316675395,
0.542073369,
0.7043424845,
0.0361089371,
0.0965570584,
-0.1284648031,
0.7040632367,
-1.0031075478,
0.2882235646,
-0.74403584,
0.2195304781,
0.1194288284,
-0.4298560917,
-0.6245365143,
0.0148037449,
0.116268523,
-0.6975287795,
-0.1859849542,
0.1902137846,
0.4791457951,
0.0533501096,
-0.4557180405,
-0.0915968195,
-0.4404072464,
0.5989681482,
-0.3434641063,
0.3490743637,
0.1605466157,
0.1755259335,
-0.0713245124,
-0.5862846375,
-0.8154985905,
-0.1155852154,
0.0736192316,
0.4136667848,
-0.0008235814,
0.207510829,
0.4137442708,
0.3690299988,
-0.5305826664,
-0.1416065842,
-0.1326562613,
-0.1270299256,
0.3030236363,
0.3353033066,
0.3018730879,
-0.1376758963,
-0.5935031176,
-0.3151459396,
-0.6927988529,
-0.0099279443,
0.0352551304,
0.3604930937,
-0.0548613109,
0.5869142413,
-0.4129112363,
0.9508348703,
0.0660196319,
0.0430008173,
0.2402549833,
-0.4649817348,
-0.2535534203,
0.0406531207,
0.978664875,
0.5759869218,
0.3167340755,
0.0437945724,
-0.0234819837,
0.2817677557,
0.1170250103,
-0.8197648525,
-0.3943006098,
0.1531027257,
0.0776163489,
-0.2329450995,
-0.1213831156,
-0.6406496167,
-0.3062610328,
-0.4748892188,
0.5383468866,
-0.485068351,
-0.0867862999,
0.0486565605,
-0.2007869482,
0.1667888463,
0.557780087,
-0.7380273938,
-0.2160501629,
0.3721956313,
0.8950541019,
0.0334983431,
-0.3207770288,
-0.5355477333,
0.3347450495,
-0.5613946915,
0.9215651155,
-0.5718753934,
-0.1991171092,
-0.1766150743,
-0.0834129676,
-0.2261145115,
-0.1496252269,
0.1756751686,
-0.357132405,
-0.0531077236,
-0.7274353504,
-0.3481794,
-0.0657943338,
0.8700063229,
-0.703566432,
0.8756744266,
-0.1812785268,
-0.840102613,
0.2962900698,
-0.4347572625,
-0.3457134962,
-0.0131495083,
-0.4619799256,
-0.1162952557,
0.0410077944,
0.7257705331,
0.5299482346,
-0.1397010684,
0.2778852284,
-0.5883055925,
-0.2332389504,
0.3840697706,
-0.4675943553,
0.4679264724,
0.2229293138,
-0.0439498685,
0.236770317,
-0.5919603109,
0.3273468614,
0.0493829772,
0.1161121279,
-0.2588451505,
-0.0296655037,
-0.4030692875,
0.541624248,
0.0321728699,
-0.4600915909,
0.2022770643,
-0.1418875158,
0.5163121819,
1.0328785181,
0.2582671642,
0.2421123087,
-0.3145724535,
0.4187679887,
0.3225736618,
-0.0224437602,
-0.8862522244,
-0.3845719099,
-0.7738205194,
-0.4046885967,
-0.2236381173,
0.3421038389,
-1.3387048244,
0.2779264152,
-0.103060469,
-0.3779258728,
-0.131669119,
-0.0343751088,
0.4442522228,
0.5246660113,
0.3475268185,
-0.5331537724,
-0.4282664955,
-0.5983201861,
0.0899108276,
-0.15778552,
0.2474494874,
0.3030363321,
0.5287827253,
0.0925957337,
0.9820557237,
-0.8852251172,
-0.0984281376,
-0.262221545,
0.0819962174,
0.0007814347,
0.4129351377,
0.3379899263,
-0.3239976764,
-0.2971822321,
0.1916870028,
-0.8895317912,
0.1346696913,
-0.1032978445,
-0.521083653,
-0.299975276,
0.4464842677,
-0.7972343564,
0.2502442002,
0.5655642152,
-0.1438568532,
0.7914330363,
-0.1021660566,
0.1267640144,
-1.0141057968,
0.174136281,
-0.1253619641,
-0.2313010097,
-0.4401801229,
0.2512642741,
-0.0758830011,
-0.3640054464,
-0.6014009714,
0.5731473565,
-0.3985864818,
0.1097061336,
-0.0679142699,
0.3341758251,
0.1790722758,
0.9277082682,
0.1462657303,
0.6746928096,
0.802472353,
-0.623632431,
0.4189098775,
0.2425810248,
-0.3716204762,
0.8795303106,
-0.443053931,
0.4051695168,
-0.4018767476,
0.5682584047,
-1.1360164881,
-0.2984651029,
0.3818801343,
0.0052445778,
-0.0682735741,
0.1213090643,
-0.470094353,
-0.5082928538,
-0.2925568223,
0.7679080367,
0.1506391466,
-0.4661770463,
0.6047432423,
0.017295057,
0.124382548,
-0.6109392643,
-0.6586304307,
0.0194528233,
0.06574139,
-0.4022089541,
0.0287184697,
-0.3245643675,
0.1626155972,
-0.154883638,
-0.2598877549,
-0.1246720776,
-0.2606931925,
0.1407539099,
0.3856361508,
-0.0654129162,
0.2270678431,
0.1241393015,
-0.044493556,
0.1009653136,
-0.5597186685,
0.6865445971,
-0.2293085158,
-0.5214232802,
-0.4366904497,
0.115085341,
0.6323021054,
-0.5066916943,
0.3431264162,
0.5545267463,
-0.0001542417,
-0.5173996091,
-0.3346557319,
-0.2190470845,
-0.4397446513,
0.1702890545,
-0.3677425683,
-0.9308710098,
0.4533005655,
-0.1792358756,
-0.3458550572,
0.0448507704,
0.4937642515,
-0.2580012977,
0.8534780741,
0.1352496147,
0.1367550045,
0.6759172678,
-0.5177983046,
0.3695503771,
-1.018455863,
-0.2979483902,
0.136757642,
-0.4318235517,
-0.2503063977,
-0.7864550948,
0.5197173953,
-0.0349321999,
-0.2473434359,
0.2490192503,
-0.4465816021,
0.7753679752,
0.3365527987,
0.6368027329,
0.3293251395,
0.0252595935,
-0.5733195543,
0.3152525127,
-0.7951760292,
-0.001923757,
0.873664856,
-0.2176826447,
0.733695507,
-0.2697794139,
0.5403602123,
0.0749340504,
-0.0342985727,
-0.8423761725,
0.9312163591,
0.0656782985,
-0.6087130308,
-0.1767658591,
-0.3780863881,
-0.6579364538,
0.4588886499,
-0.1643080264,
-0.762709856,
0.2204157114,
0.3562600911,
-0.504752934,
0.3865809739,
-0.3814408183,
0.9134841561,
-0.1811560094,
-0.5637091994,
-0.1688835919,
-0.6705205441,
0.4119500816,
0.0047448594,
0.1271118373,
-0.1815062314,
0.3088099658,
0.2998698056,
-0.5088471174,
1.0924568176,
0.0810412094,
-0.1228875592,
0.8787438273,
0.2100851983,
0.5959619284,
-0.2300330251,
0.3133189082,
-0.0594055094,
-0.2114309967,
-0.2159347683,
-0.7548109889,
0.6145393252,
-0.4284662604,
-0.351092577,
-0.2520651519,
-0.77096802,
-0.2273682356,
0.2511019707,
0.0612155907,
0.6830921769,
0.0036194534,
0.1529793441,
0.6090605855,
-0.0859288052,
0.6285991669,
-0.0498685054,
-0.4739336967,
-0.6881915331,
1.0582565069,
0.0808584094,
0.6280722618,
0.4368089736,
0.1580349207,
-0.1690368056,
-0.0929135084,
-0.6393579841,
-0.0079156682,
-0.8883137107,
-0.2838421166,
-0.6308211684,
-0.1736627668,
0.266687423,
-0.234456405,
-0.3732678294,
-0.2767961919,
-0.0317433439,
-0.3698918521,
0.2616283894,
0.4576286972,
0.1849997789,
0.1541902572,
-0.4966286421,
0.1944962591,
0.655267477,
0.2576082945,
0.5127692223,
0.0696881488,
-0.2214192152,
0.1789157093,
-0.5470743179,
-0.7305087447,
0.0791578367,
-0.0305203646,
0.2599643469,
0.4998013675,
0.0985591412,
1.2222207785,
-0.4157977104,
0.8235836625,
0.6284146905,
-1.0687618256,
0.5904961824,
-0.6816623807,
0.585021615,
0.4794121981,
0.104707323,
-0.5906304717,
-0.5362967849,
-0.2541429996,
-0.728993535,
0.4211483598,
0.1928243041,
0.1617340893,
-0.4415391386,
0.0482057445,
-0.0423580967,
0.4668454528,
-0.913376987,
0.0676160157,
-0.3359597325,
-0.1383901387,
0.25122118,
0.0597492866,
0.0118917832,
-0.4337218702,
0.2362873405,
-0.5039560795,
0.2535197139,
0.4780081511,
-0.0678765625,
-0.1420633793,
0.2628583908,
0.4400164187,
0.796033144,
0.0145957554,
0.5607855916,
0.2753862739,
-0.091851376,
0.2453303784,
-0.5756005049,
-0.2479754239,
-0.3236179054,
0.4487956166,
0.9580349326,
0.4149568081,
-0.8938540816,
0.6385409832,
0.3947391808,
-0.1957622617,
-0.0047515612,
0.0355580822,
-0.0109868739,
0.2201797515,
0.0966936275,
0.1134968549,
-0.0901531875,
-0.847515583,
0.1088722497,
0.4016047418,
-0.614499867,
-0.3925541341,
0.539485693,
0.062810041,
0.295594126,
0.6463234425,
-0.1756838262,
-0.5276609063,
0.418295294,
0.5448197722,
0.8298329115,
-0.0389994346,
0.4402543008,
0.498639822,
0.1026109159,
-0.1010872647,
0.2960679829,
-0.3179777265,
-0.819031477,
-0.853254199,
-0.3917975724,
-0.2715261579,
-0.131371066,
-0.4574140906,
0.1286141127,
-0.808401525,
-0.225327298,
-0.2411565185,
-0.4496394098,
-0.6712227464,
0.3746795654,
0.471652329,
0.4795275629,
-0.7878116965,
0.6907590628,
0.4992157817,
-0.6395742297,
-0.9552351236,
-0.1480400413,
-0.1560789049,
-0.8793019056,
0.6412649155,
0.3790162504,
-0.405570209,
0.0428602733,
-0.6678699255,
-0.6866220236,
1.318297267,
0.4081697464,
-0.7492177486,
-0.096160233,
0.1035359055,
0.4310258031,
-0.5909821391,
0.3159263134,
0.1671795696,
0.4134529233,
0.7272136807,
-0.7241804004,
0.2820067108,
-0.0977816954,
0.0306580979,
0.3214706779,
-0.7891362309,
1.1263706684,
-0.3508583307,
-0.1886144578,
0.0012264913,
0.3244183064,
0.4646167159,
0.4733363092,
0.4443956614,
0.7952655554,
0.7511665225,
-0.0436403304,
0.9652694464,
-0.14344652,
0.3180933893,
1.2080583572,
-0.4348495007,
0.8278012276,
0.5248050094,
0.1178047806,
0.8405609131,
0.3892625272,
0.0552748144,
0.6226547956,
0.0777130499,
-0.344345957,
-0.6178774238,
-0.2478238642,
-0.2498906404,
0.356854856,
0.100478448,
-0.326380074,
-0.2747696936,
-0.0093342625,
-0.0350589752,
-0.171490103,
-0.5529257059,
0.7197173834,
0.2430106401,
-0.730307579,
0.3769325316,
-0.5457434058,
0.0137119349,
-0.5946639776,
-0.1164402217,
0.03890853,
0.0656917021,
-0.0126829557,
-0.8456140161,
-0.0087273438,
-0.1910046935,
0.0266929436,
-0.2124533355,
0.5222274065,
-0.6390703917,
-0.5246090293,
0.2072222233,
0.6336479187,
-0.159233585,
-0.3360627592,
-0.4251373112,
0.2243521959,
-0.1951856315,
-0.0078550838,
0.0624240004,
0.6522938013,
-0.2069072127,
0.7143219113,
0.9397259355,
-0.2896260321,
-0.0637111291,
0.1848891675,
1.2749603987,
-0.8199439049,
-0.698790729,
-1.1306680441,
0.7766855359,
-0.0867805704,
-0.1630075127,
0.641641438,
0.3976609707,
0.8351663351,
-0.1388312727,
0.6210851669,
-0.0081085637,
-0.2973004282,
-0.7488284111,
0.4193675518,
-0.5365726948,
-0.05382872,
-0.7069115639,
-1.0924700499,
-0.3815767169,
0.5785078406,
-0.3458043039,
0.0148762455,
1.2488952875,
0.6235169768,
0.0260279197,
0.0463899523,
0.4532915652,
0.1473782361,
0.2486210465,
0.8276450634,
1.1573799849,
-0.1445729882,
0.3565954864,
-0.0199450832,
0.144084543,
0.0771867558,
-1.07797575,
-1.1371873617,
-0.3920500278,
-0.2905811369,
-0.0877103806,
0.0585112199,
0.9674782753,
0.8378556371,
-0.4658506513,
-0.1581995934,
-0.3972542286,
0.0247393101,
-0.445856154,
-0.1387842,
0.209464103,
-0.3408721983,
-0.354346782,
0.3537146151,
0.5719232559,
-0.0440307967,
-0.3223494589,
-0.0610642694,
-0.2559188008,
0.2157916129,
1.0385495424,
-0.0974004045,
-0.8338637352,
-0.4768945873,
-0.1261847466,
0.1542257667,
0.0878967419,
0.9861690402,
-0.9053811431,
0.9486364722,
0.4545533657,
0.3748942912,
0.7415882945,
-0.0174943637,
0.4343181551,
-0.8946641684,
0.324876219,
0.0254433677,
0.3453989327,
0.1996567845,
-0.1154493541,
0.3630102575,
0.4175981581,
-0.226634413,
-0.5953953862,
0.6260071397,
-1.4401388168,
-0.272666961,
0.7603302002,
-0.1228680238,
-0.5545501709,
0.3445038497,
-0.4755997956,
-0.0238940772,
-0.3504771888,
0.4475989044,
0.8184604049,
-0.01315571,
-0.4842078686,
-0.1377186328,
0.0132622598,
0.1571401209,
-0.8582603335,
0.1000741124,
0.7187233567,
0.0745523274,
0.0983706415,
0.684191227,
0.082821399,
0.2346587628,
0.147746563,
0.0495013148,
-0.3269727826,
-0.6306430101,
0.2463950664,
0.2976191938,
-0.1840372235,
-0.0443438068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16338v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16338v1
|
Releasing the CRaQAn (Coreference Resolution in Question-Answering): An open-source dataset and dataset creation methodology using instruction-following models
| 2023-11-27T21:54:50 | 2023-11-27T21:54:50 |
Rob Grzywinski, Joshua D'Arcy, Rob Naidoff, Ashish Shukla, Alex Browne, Ren Gibbons, Brinnae Bent
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Instruction-following language models demand robust methodologies for
information retrieval to augment instructions for question-answering
applications. A primary challenge is the resolution of coreferences in the
context of chunking strategies for long documents. The critical barrier to
experimentation of handling coreferences is a lack of open source datasets,
specifically in question-answering tasks that require coreference resolution.
In this work we present our Coreference Resolution in Question-Answering
(CRaQAn) dataset, an open-source dataset that caters to the nuanced information
retrieval requirements of coreference resolution in question-answering tasks by
providing over 250 question-answer pairs containing coreferences. To develop
this dataset, we developed a novel approach for creating high-quality datasets
using an instruction-following model (GPT-4) and a Recursive Criticism and
Improvement Loop.
|
[
-0.4254599214,
-0.5396832228,
0.1699288487,
-0.205293715,
-0.3252811134,
-0.0484610647,
-0.5065781474,
-0.3508566022,
-0.0949292481,
0.7720946074,
-0.4042214453,
-0.6057060361,
-0.5379709601,
0.0862815529,
-0.421936065,
1.1616741419,
-0.2838740647,
-0.2345426828,
-0.4138713181,
-0.179393217,
-0.6727967858,
-0.6143595576,
-0.0016927447,
-0.0957205892,
0.4828558564,
1.0573965311,
0.7840303183,
1.0017155409,
0.7518954873,
0.10941194,
0.2977460623,
0.0428022034,
-0.3082758188,
0.037058875,
-0.3251056373,
-0.4457466602,
-0.1378828436,
0.1895726323,
0.5173402429,
0.6034647822,
-0.3413833678,
0.5323403478,
0.0262984689,
0.4836373031,
-0.6826440692,
0.2400466949,
-0.5820631385,
-0.1531022191,
-0.5201997161,
-0.0467019118,
-0.2701414526,
-0.6983758807,
0.2600206137,
-0.695795238,
0.545541048,
-0.02015776,
0.7082177997,
0.0981961191,
-0.0939076766,
-0.8033049107,
-0.5899829865,
0.8518687487,
-0.6512978673,
0.1457939446,
0.5858389735,
0.3233641386,
0.3962033689,
-0.6323442459,
-0.3546109796,
-0.0513076521,
-0.0265697055,
-0.17384547,
0.1250459105,
-0.0720391124,
0.2058590502,
0.5065401793,
-0.7500634789,
-0.3360415995,
-0.6143326759,
-0.0532621481,
0.4194306135,
0.2152864486,
0.0832312554,
-0.2722600996,
-0.1122508571,
0.0035118705,
-0.643827796,
-0.0638834164,
0.0870510265,
0.3918580413,
0.1936136931,
0.8951320052,
-0.3413623571,
0.4178000391,
0.3175669611,
0.0280215442,
0.2654610276,
-0.4714361429,
0.0305187721,
0.2746658325,
0.3086971343,
0.3327658772,
0.232233718,
-0.184004724,
-0.0124743432,
0.0128836911,
0.2970206738,
-0.80916816,
-0.3223982751,
0.3931219578,
-0.3364783227,
-0.1911564767,
-0.0323118269,
-0.6924315691,
-0.0227438267,
-0.399971813,
0.2303926349,
-0.6281487346,
-0.0589340106,
-0.0580779575,
-0.0152548132,
0.3744902015,
0.27624771,
-0.7204199433,
0.3712320626,
0.6661370993,
0.6531457305,
-0.1575847864,
-0.1309565902,
-0.3803520501,
0.2715726495,
-0.3796750009,
0.8196822405,
-0.9482568502,
-0.7484025955,
-0.1114229113,
-0.0122507429,
-0.1141313016,
-0.8397088647,
0.8405038118,
-0.403596133,
0.2736963928,
-0.4803084135,
-0.5854184628,
-0.2495396137,
0.2649665475,
-0.4873995483,
1.0954841375,
0.3652074039,
-0.8195363283,
-0.2375397831,
-0.5908200741,
-0.1631107032,
0.3617274761,
-0.258510381,
0.0410700701,
-0.1983282119,
0.3306147158,
0.093415089,
-0.6848641634,
0.0562468842,
0.1875236183,
-0.2065195292,
0.0278351828,
0.0209068935,
0.4903813004,
0.1785040051,
-0.2135976702,
-0.0264698304,
-0.478374809,
0.2673374712,
-0.014714553,
-0.2394182086,
-0.4662099183,
-0.2502953708,
-0.6041343212,
0.0472794771,
0.5679597855,
-0.7449148297,
0.1744521409,
0.1897223145,
0.2625427544,
0.5748195052,
0.1506641805,
0.4560121894,
-0.4185560644,
0.4958162606,
0.2000873238,
0.234631896,
-0.4739189446,
-0.3978410959,
-0.4668483138,
0.0673025399,
0.3962500393,
0.7300676703,
-0.7309307456,
-0.093458809,
-0.3247293234,
-0.7324517369,
-0.4275205433,
0.2459624857,
0.6490548253,
0.9599651694,
0.4695430994,
-0.3611150086,
-0.3759888113,
-0.9045379758,
0.0351059586,
-0.2499393672,
-0.0280872528,
0.4873557985,
0.4522489905,
0.1091405451,
0.764090538,
-0.6660233736,
0.0510021746,
0.0249394514,
0.3743617535,
0.1758617163,
0.5846817493,
0.3581261039,
-0.7469332814,
-0.264462322,
-0.2156634629,
-0.6022541523,
0.0033081861,
0.3182056844,
-0.3626158535,
-0.0970347822,
-0.0262674373,
-0.6335488558,
0.4114149809,
0.2951872945,
0.0749101788,
1.0090359449,
0.238466531,
0.4690281153,
-1.0394339561,
0.1825903356,
-0.1088441014,
0.2432510704,
-0.4674152136,
0.1912283003,
0.2460771501,
-0.2823114991,
-0.2774319351,
0.1436808705,
-0.2608999014,
0.1480031163,
0.0218453594,
0.2330324799,
0.0889415815,
0.5136557221,
0.2450829595,
0.9972417951,
0.3130617738,
-0.6972373128,
0.4044579566,
0.8056179285,
-0.3013089597,
0.5571315885,
-0.739330411,
0.3377322853,
-0.2404013127,
0.0792392343,
-0.6497734189,
-0.3237923682,
0.5069893003,
-0.4736799598,
-0.0863303244,
-0.2724528313,
-0.2406287789,
-0.4503444731,
-0.2508028746,
0.7732795477,
0.3322940767,
-0.4945813119,
0.485786438,
0.1740575731,
-0.7574237585,
-0.9017922282,
-0.6741533279,
-0.0284932628,
0.0380068794,
-0.5231564045,
0.3874302506,
-0.2419432253,
-0.1909839809,
0.1804201007,
-0.2102059573,
-0.1819670498,
-0.4788311422,
0.3056325316,
0.3862768412,
-0.2759992182,
0.1575605869,
0.0128030581,
0.0716953725,
0.1583491415,
-0.0945218205,
0.2405660003,
0.016384203,
-0.3420484364,
-0.3157327473,
0.6117066741,
0.1315164864,
-0.7212173939,
0.3929125965,
0.0864827484,
-0.3814362288,
-0.101092115,
-0.5529530048,
-0.2408045381,
-0.4253089428,
-0.0083762566,
-0.3524724543,
-0.7956853509,
0.3246433139,
-0.0260863379,
0.4429996312,
0.1887626946,
0.550388217,
0.0523594618,
0.4630197287,
0.0677065328,
0.0458217487,
0.3315883875,
-0.2410239577,
0.0089150025,
-0.8678398728,
-0.2971626818,
-0.8955153823,
-0.017903896,
-0.0522016622,
-0.7291731834,
0.0975764021,
0.1640044749,
-0.4303642511,
0.5555540323,
-0.6113526821,
0.3417833745,
0.8552445173,
0.3873204589,
0.3221467435,
-0.1788009256,
-0.1750433594,
0.0824066922,
-0.3801171184,
-0.4945243001,
0.9918739796,
-0.1191849634,
0.7816325426,
0.1556921303,
0.594581902,
0.3723332286,
0.2501951456,
-0.4812784791,
0.5339840055,
0.1027578264,
-0.6183050275,
-0.2306061834,
-0.6175013781,
-0.6294783354,
-0.2144272178,
0.2759508789,
-0.5449964404,
0.2573008835,
0.1319193691,
-0.2990975082,
0.1547087133,
-0.4150721729,
0.8414229751,
-0.0068926075,
-0.1020634025,
-0.259553194,
-0.8006311059,
0.4688635767,
0.2013025582,
-0.0280455705,
-0.163692981,
0.0782823563,
0.7744179964,
-0.3752346337,
0.8199228644,
-0.2344436646,
-0.0470602848,
1.1244087219,
0.3352382183,
0.470056057,
-0.0681337565,
-0.2549425066,
0.0656176433,
0.2547708154,
-0.539986968,
-0.6255739331,
0.599285543,
-0.7823539972,
-0.5554804802,
-0.2567538619,
-0.6298006773,
-0.1638391167,
0.0439624526,
0.2247916013,
0.8896312118,
-0.2173834294,
0.1255577505,
0.7818820477,
0.0079438565,
0.1293369532,
0.4160935283,
-0.051829055,
-0.6327885985,
0.8040594459,
0.3329018056,
0.2052437961,
0.2275682688,
0.0015697377,
-0.2331763804,
-0.5381656885,
-0.5346294641,
0.4503168762,
-0.6789184809,
-0.3615110219,
-0.3232334554,
-0.2943347991,
-0.675409317,
0.0410618372,
-0.0573791042,
-0.7446255684,
-0.1959431618,
-0.1891316026,
0.3217698634,
0.6670857668,
-0.1626698971,
0.1391430646,
-1.1386179924,
0.2415916026,
0.2356104702,
0.2174392343,
0.0611340106,
-0.6396004558,
-0.553783834,
0.2063651383,
-0.5131229758,
-0.7793994546,
0.0755324662,
0.1688121557,
0.3711767793,
0.1757800132,
0.5360464454,
0.5079122782,
-0.2963096797,
1.041719079,
-0.1267172992,
-0.7678795457,
0.7697723508,
-0.5305377841,
0.2681356966,
0.6274474859,
0.6664595008,
-0.7487509847,
-0.0966813192,
-0.4747065604,
-0.7230250835,
0.4688842893,
0.2566268444,
-0.0233000163,
-0.3611543179,
0.8435444236,
0.3023558557,
0.4561678171,
0.1734021157,
-0.0752035305,
-0.4341573119,
-0.2745112777,
0.0168480035,
-0.1986076385,
-0.3133924305,
0.0297250468,
0.8337276578,
-0.2160808444,
0.2732844055,
0.3146130443,
-0.210043624,
-0.0947579369,
0.3747517765,
0.3426736593,
0.5975335836,
-0.2663301229,
0.0650783703,
-0.2541620433,
-0.6492596865,
-0.060915973,
0.0136787007,
-0.225698486,
-0.0287884139,
0.0666411743,
0.2887148857,
-0.0034667742,
-0.9200388789,
0.4115842283,
0.0781407952,
-0.1869190037,
-0.4737402201,
0.0980494469,
0.0852387175,
0.0298946463,
0.5883809924,
-0.0717820376,
0.0393112786,
-0.320908308,
0.5527649522,
-0.0422914401,
-0.3504398763,
-0.3139620721,
0.4348657429,
0.2748472989,
-0.0786593556,
1.1224267483,
0.0575013198,
-0.3078300953,
0.5972758532,
0.2585205734,
0.3681817949,
-0.4431287348,
0.5712022781,
0.8085828424,
0.0623772703,
-0.098772563,
0.5096151233,
-0.299741894,
-0.7337530851,
-0.3411950171,
-0.1714385599,
-0.9059461355,
-0.4082701206,
-1.1857219934,
-0.0730158389,
-0.5921190381,
-0.186354503,
-0.3641273975,
0.0899298191,
-0.4743576646,
0.2218318284,
-0.0785596818,
1.1527609825,
-0.3641148806,
0.6887928843,
0.4484478533,
-0.6501467228,
-0.8362978697,
-0.1236560792,
0.089992106,
-0.4561278522,
0.4101300836,
0.0282485504,
0.2071014792,
0.0163089391,
-0.7757130861,
-0.7246375084,
1.1828926802,
0.2632866502,
-0.3409283161,
-0.3651852608,
0.4783497453,
0.1409258693,
-0.5432064533,
0.2277636528,
0.6257615089,
0.5153252482,
0.0644365698,
-0.7976140976,
0.1087816507,
-0.2898983061,
-0.1944007725,
0.1820213497,
-0.7868244052,
0.7243453264,
-0.2831428945,
-0.2999862731,
0.4428424537,
0.8024547696,
0.1159638464,
0.1463191062,
0.3250574768,
0.7682836056,
0.7137368321,
0.0337871239,
0.7794502378,
-0.410146296,
0.1613838673,
1.6389583349,
-0.3029114306,
0.9564513564,
0.2507156432,
0.1337250173,
0.675052762,
0.6848780513,
0.1725767553,
0.4172280431,
0.0835883841,
-0.5431865454,
-0.1725394726,
-0.6049659252,
-0.270460844,
0.0896025971,
0.5888459086,
-0.394331038,
-0.4104264677,
-0.0540547222,
-0.0834142566,
0.1733691394,
-0.4393612146,
0.5855380297,
-0.1431660503,
-0.633987546,
0.4832327664,
-0.2242050022,
0.1672391593,
-0.4170552492,
-0.2932032645,
-0.1781536937,
-0.1547095329,
-0.2943872809,
-0.9614978433,
0.3351771533,
0.100319773,
-0.3039699495,
0.2645576894,
0.5290089846,
-0.4644065499,
-0.2913201451,
0.0054424205,
0.4820110202,
0.2700899839,
-0.0488932692,
-0.6259303689,
-0.1173928007,
-0.0751011074,
-0.104158707,
0.1401638836,
0.4917616248,
-0.117981717,
0.579015851,
0.4609653056,
-0.2468948662,
0.3526554406,
-0.2392930537,
1.0614486933,
-0.7231240273,
0.0379811749,
-0.0554637015,
0.288338691,
0.1739980131,
-0.4413412213,
0.4967803657,
0.6927623749,
0.7874328494,
0.1319469512,
1.1319320202,
-0.479285866,
1.1034730673,
-0.1083066612,
-0.0287092216,
0.0880958736,
0.0594517402,
-0.0088427328,
-0.8120053411,
-0.0453998521,
0.0858027339,
-0.3766716421,
-0.0894426778,
0.581802249,
0.995184958,
0.0330476761,
0.471917361,
-0.0038986069,
0.1700308472,
0.0783572271,
0.5153633952,
0.5932691693,
-0.4959758222,
0.912256062,
-0.7156533599,
-0.2723661065,
-0.0232341662,
-0.5033508539,
-0.5743868351,
-0.6780273914,
-0.3783007264,
-0.5512085557,
0.4157330394,
1.0797795057,
0.4591218233,
-1.0200504065,
-0.1251279563,
0.293346554,
-0.1636949629,
-0.4729093611,
-0.2324960977,
0.4084215462,
-0.203507483,
-0.5955611467,
0.1631522924,
-0.2069644928,
-0.2518858016,
0.0124838874,
-0.0290152505,
-0.2143375576,
0.1204175279,
0.2559221089,
0.5520333648,
-0.3587104082,
-0.6169993877,
0.1191307455,
-0.1929751784,
0.4243162572,
1.2330613136,
-0.5249293447,
0.1441332251,
0.4969317615,
0.8989786506,
0.3584218323,
0.6542457938,
0.5427951813,
-0.5980485678,
-0.2463606894,
0.4479888678,
-0.0021884444,
0.2339914888,
-0.3868769407,
0.724188149,
0.0645612776,
-0.8151860833,
-0.4125220478,
0.2981535196,
-0.9862968922,
-0.0421393998,
0.7616479993,
-0.4405171573,
-0.4005372524,
-0.2670158148,
-0.462282151,
0.1248102114,
-0.7350520492,
0.5445104241,
0.5862483978,
-0.3857218027,
-0.5321131349,
-0.3389449716,
0.110758245,
0.0949991122,
-0.536773622,
0.5266530514,
0.6642163992,
0.3650870323,
0.3903137147,
0.4653528929,
-0.444686532,
0.3835169375,
0.156107828,
0.4625270963,
-0.0975597948,
-0.2799743116,
0.1107591465,
0.3310889602,
0.0940046012,
-0.2197073102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03730v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03730v2
|
FakeWatch ElectionShield: A Benchmarking Framework to Detect Fake News for Credible US Elections
| 2023-11-27T21:01:21 | 2023-12-08T19:42:35 |
Tahniat Khan, Mizanur Rahman, Veronica Chatrath, Oluwanifemi Bamgbose, Shaina Raza
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In today's technologically driven world, the spread of fake news,
particularly during crucial events such as elections, presents an increasing
challenge to the integrity of information. To address this challenge, we
introduce FakeWatch ElectionShield, an innovative framework carefully designed
to detect fake news. We have created a novel dataset of North American
election-related news articles through a blend of advanced language models
(LMs) and thorough human verification, for precision and relevance. We propose
a model hub of LMs for identifying fake news. Our goal is to provide the
research community with adaptable and accurate classification models in
recognizing the dynamic nature of misinformation. Extensive evaluation of fake
news classifiers on our dataset and a benchmark dataset shows our that while
state-of-the-art LMs slightly outperform the traditional ML models, classical
models are still competitive with their balance of accuracy, explainability,
and computational efficiency. This research sets the foundation for future
studies to address misinformation related to elections.
|
[
-0.1825239956,
-1.0765738487,
0.7231648564,
-0.0105964746,
-0.2506701052,
0.5636684895,
0.3692461848,
-0.5690687895,
0.1693409383,
0.5036770105,
-0.5635871291,
-0.4164819121,
-0.3704074025,
-0.2539013624,
-0.7489819527,
0.7644052505,
0.0049482663,
0.1277853847,
-0.2119991034,
-0.1354421973,
0.0922132954,
-0.3577726483,
-0.1908754408,
-0.2757902741,
0.1753597409,
0.2493628412,
0.6890745163,
0.9278544188,
0.3560956419,
0.1774981916,
0.1882014871,
0.2781185806,
-0.1172354147,
-0.2708348036,
-0.2892638743,
-0.4601981938,
-0.3658382297,
0.6090218425,
0.3556542695,
0.0818646848,
-0.4092284739,
0.3427090645,
-0.270026952,
0.317803055,
-0.750962913,
-0.1227725372,
-0.8659903407,
-0.3146067858,
-0.6364600062,
-0.1714135259,
-0.2401613295,
-0.6190221906,
-0.0367925167,
-0.4086873233,
0.6352497339,
0.3795724809,
0.9587471485,
-0.1454916298,
-0.3920680881,
-0.1299655288,
-0.6049858928,
0.3629881442,
-0.8291248679,
0.5293972492,
0.2622373104,
0.6918767691,
0.093269445,
-0.8464823961,
-0.9126026034,
0.0572591573,
0.2696059644,
0.2099198401,
-0.3134346604,
-0.2520263195,
-0.0507903658,
0.1531325579,
-0.8862382174,
0.0382446162,
-0.2728142738,
-0.6133176684,
0.5881349444,
0.0027620629,
0.3975502253,
-0.1159316748,
-0.5112793446,
-0.1281623244,
-0.6304542422,
-0.2853753567,
0.7318391204,
0.247442767,
-0.1402496845,
0.2693426907,
-0.4486944973,
0.6730294228,
0.0885402784,
-0.0923693329,
0.2029572874,
-0.3443309963,
-0.2112068385,
0.171350047,
0.5186483264,
0.3955577314,
0.0049782433,
-0.0672595277,
-0.2694242001,
0.8643929958,
0.4301122725,
-0.6322579384,
-0.0286658667,
0.1499247998,
-0.6379486918,
-0.8347346187,
0.432205677,
-0.9017644525,
-0.6283282042,
-0.2757125795,
0.6769103408,
0.1819506884,
-0.4172985256,
0.1499665529,
-0.37239483,
-0.2506771088,
0.1534621567,
-0.0662796721,
0.3104566038,
0.6751086116,
0.573731184,
-0.1492332965,
-0.2414479107,
-0.4995805919,
-0.1909052879,
-0.52342242,
0.8893147707,
-0.5969318748,
0.2554832995,
0.1534863561,
-0.0230320916,
-0.0044445531,
-0.6960540414,
0.742664516,
-0.9411590695,
0.4472027719,
-0.0328633338,
-0.6573933959,
-0.16541861,
0.4494726956,
-0.7771704793,
0.9897075295,
0.0020636546,
-0.6507410407,
0.5100642443,
-0.3589468598,
-0.3291172981,
0.0076530804,
0.1124394909,
-0.7571452856,
0.20120956,
0.2197667956,
0.3471030295,
-0.1050549522,
0.3236204982,
-0.4617470205,
-0.3817269206,
0.1489085704,
-0.6771643162,
0.5919353366,
0.1419887543,
-0.6959473491,
0.0534003191,
-0.808991015,
-0.1093262061,
0.0657878146,
0.053746812,
-0.2342544049,
0.2418941408,
0.1955974996,
0.1472537071,
0.093358539,
-0.9154474139,
-0.2269934714,
-0.113934055,
0.3276952207,
0.7535467744,
0.0288291294,
0.3626385033,
-0.445851624,
0.2657385767,
0.1708017588,
0.3829100728,
-0.1321340799,
-0.2924403846,
-0.4729980528,
0.0478054658,
0.3639191985,
0.9671525359,
-0.7646049261,
0.2592232227,
-0.2590030432,
-0.6571885347,
-0.4101489782,
-0.1758894622,
0.0844633207,
0.5620452762,
0.369151324,
0.1053245142,
-0.5101534724,
-0.9196776152,
-1.0971064568,
-0.2298209816,
0.2219695449,
-0.0879913494,
0.7114692926,
-0.4023752809,
1.0066828728,
-0.0708572492,
-0.1747102439,
0.0948294625,
0.1605596989,
-0.0162914954,
0.0797523782,
0.4682579339,
-1.077554822,
-0.2084913701,
-0.1079589427,
-0.5028792024,
-0.1945062727,
-0.1694116294,
0.1406452656,
0.2249619216,
0.6159998178,
-0.3330634236,
0.749568522,
0.8167511821,
-0.5603667498,
0.6133890152,
0.1262884736,
0.42385903,
-0.8956702352,
-0.0577282459,
-0.1618544608,
-0.7961273193,
-0.6718853116,
-0.0962810665,
0.3662989438,
-0.1642421484,
-0.3790602982,
0.9213876128,
-0.1661714315,
0.135689944,
-0.4589387178,
0.141696468,
0.0901320428,
-0.0918254554,
-0.00696522,
0.5250940323,
0.3653303981,
-0.4196470082,
0.6158886552,
-0.148046121,
-0.8018459082,
0.868878603,
-0.6441549063,
-0.0526761264,
-0.1162020192,
0.5648984313,
-0.6730304956,
-0.5373785496,
0.2460803688,
-0.6892396808,
-0.1148178279,
0.1029713079,
-0.7967373133,
-0.4811755121,
-0.0485313237,
-0.01565185,
0.2499012798,
-0.860525012,
0.6723421216,
0.5105330944,
0.2459173054,
-0.3368270695,
-0.5344643593,
0.0112869982,
-0.2267355025,
-0.367236793,
0.4160310924,
0.1473512352,
-0.3734659851,
0.2403707355,
-0.4522383809,
-0.4488200545,
0.0028740806,
-0.0108825853,
0.2148329467,
-0.1019107401,
0.0917703286,
-0.1549685895,
0.0699757934,
-0.0789966732,
-0.0143641084,
0.1021890566,
0.1009001806,
-0.4356146753,
-0.8140775561,
0.1980430037,
0.8446847796,
-0.2643251717,
0.7196393609,
0.7361454368,
-0.7854537368,
-0.3435699642,
-0.985542953,
-0.5154208541,
-0.4590607584,
0.4761862457,
0.0085361237,
-0.5311715603,
0.5019443631,
-0.1591404974,
0.155762583,
0.3671262562,
0.0971671492,
0.1061591581,
1.3676201105,
0.3792691529,
-0.5151809454,
0.3619372845,
0.2740676999,
0.117728889,
-0.2263917029,
-0.2265483439,
-0.4248098433,
-0.2025122494,
-0.26788041,
-0.5287973285,
0.1951728016,
0.0295069683,
-0.2699002922,
0.1598155349,
-0.5082506537,
0.4370153248,
0.5455866456,
0.1779951006,
0.2639791369,
0.2790075839,
0.1832941473,
-0.0940180495,
-0.8008200526,
-0.3480278254,
0.8660452366,
0.3481805921,
0.5626091957,
0.0466390811,
0.3428374529,
0.7066196799,
0.7002801895,
-0.0847438797,
0.1780034751,
-0.0079798261,
-1.1179112196,
0.0107364142,
-0.5097368956,
-0.5593545437,
0.2094042301,
-0.3062439561,
-0.2705279291,
0.1863435805,
0.3432087004,
0.0165756661,
0.6173568964,
-0.2476277947,
0.9090915918,
-0.271368891,
-0.2720680237,
-0.4118798971,
-0.3156408072,
0.3264949322,
-0.0588661544,
0.6552776098,
-0.3436962664,
-0.1504769921,
0.5378376245,
-0.3071174324,
0.8796983957,
-0.2569674551,
0.5018086433,
0.201992318,
0.0457919613,
0.9491664767,
0.0357928835,
0.0566483214,
0.1204353273,
-0.0476075262,
-0.4559560716,
-0.2790260613,
0.6720841527,
-0.3376923203,
-0.1707089096,
-0.8083106875,
-0.0760658234,
-0.1829056293,
0.1684878767,
0.5725049376,
0.3997508287,
-0.6286829114,
0.1761642396,
0.4998556376,
0.1402457356,
0.1520757973,
0.9403078556,
-0.1341300011,
-0.3690550923,
1.0117940903,
0.2391367853,
-0.158309564,
0.0007586333,
0.2561193705,
-0.5194064379,
-0.4071980417,
-0.5711343288,
0.1009656116,
-0.2843560874,
-0.3281239271,
-0.2550615966,
-0.1784572005,
-0.2820446193,
0.0346305482,
-0.6866140366,
-0.1533165276,
-0.3197261691,
-0.1478109658,
0.2290700972,
0.7211902142,
-0.0508819371,
0.4241572618,
-0.525680542,
0.5565755367,
0.3823885322,
0.6103415489,
-0.3697912395,
-0.587541163,
-0.1439496875,
0.2593109608,
-0.3709038496,
-1.1357518435,
0.3414990604,
0.1902077943,
0.8689901233,
0.4890905023,
0.1525839418,
0.5147103667,
-0.5827234983,
0.7937285304,
-0.0141771445,
-1.0544958115,
0.4539470673,
-0.4805210829,
0.1308404803,
0.5106941462,
0.2678551972,
-0.3619281054,
-0.3965536356,
-1.0546435118,
-0.4935690761,
0.4060992301,
0.1459069848,
0.1635294408,
-0.0605724156,
0.2354519814,
-0.0616725199,
0.4878125787,
-0.8052908778,
-0.1830143183,
-0.3058365583,
-0.2966753542,
0.0799402744,
-0.2193060517,
-0.1176292673,
0.1654604226,
0.7771244645,
-0.1175277606,
-0.0405388698,
0.3156405389,
-0.2061584741,
-0.0627353117,
-0.0196024626,
0.7951610088,
0.8252156377,
0.0102117937,
0.1776792258,
0.1271115839,
-0.4820458889,
-0.1539252698,
0.1486999094,
-0.3106164038,
0.470140785,
0.6550856233,
0.6738280058,
0.1474965811,
-0.6312091351,
0.8203092217,
0.1292582452,
-0.368337065,
-0.3572830856,
-0.2333776951,
0.0647758991,
0.1914654076,
0.7713976502,
0.5112841129,
0.3452531099,
-0.8139626384,
0.4879604876,
0.5456829667,
-0.6430415511,
-0.6714903712,
1.0836598873,
0.3344832361,
-0.3836547434,
0.234907046,
-0.0601537526,
-0.9019438624,
0.6488901377,
0.3522012532,
0.5383988023,
-0.8326606154,
0.5222224593,
0.2532575428,
0.652253449,
-0.5849594474,
0.0966570824,
0.2740465105,
-0.878616333,
-0.048642613,
-0.4768927395,
-0.2488505989,
0.3920793235,
-0.5664381981,
0.1218998358,
-0.3735763729,
-0.2601237297,
-0.052914504,
0.0970674828,
-0.4727122188,
0.344073981,
0.1259708852,
1.1659576893,
-1.2673101425,
0.4280406535,
0.4158744514,
0.3852383196,
-0.1432150602,
0.1159159839,
0.720561564,
-0.5911954641,
0.013114132,
0.2246910334,
0.0395589136,
-0.2501974404,
-0.6067406535,
-0.5449367166,
0.7119402885,
0.3910669088,
-0.6998150349,
0.1444918364,
-0.0537620597,
0.3192541301,
-0.4647482932,
-0.1057465002,
0.386397928,
0.6603253484,
-0.4473103881,
-0.7581558824,
-0.2482705712,
0.0241268687,
-0.3320361376,
0.1528225988,
-0.7130520344,
0.6884837747,
0.3155130148,
-0.3411605954,
0.0018780344,
0.5702069402,
0.2545424998,
0.9793423414,
0.580319047,
0.5121585727,
0.8331594467,
-0.197022751,
1.0776218176,
-0.1626167297,
0.2018394321,
0.9903991222,
-0.2699927688,
0.8216713071,
0.0458219871,
0.0794438645,
0.7967572212,
0.6369225979,
0.0114406012,
0.3901537955,
0.0769988671,
-0.3290191889,
-0.49357149,
0.0399153531,
-0.1918455064,
0.5289954543,
0.3817265034,
-0.3628875613,
-0.174218595,
0.1470382363,
0.0608677939,
0.5954573154,
-0.4081422091,
0.3605610132,
-0.2875569463,
-0.3935032785,
0.0805725306,
-0.0087523228,
0.5719118118,
-0.5494639277,
-0.1656882912,
0.0036668151,
0.380102247,
-0.1236950085,
-0.4215706885,
0.3388923705,
-0.1973169744,
-0.4106919169,
-0.1388094574,
0.7300673127,
-0.4137882888,
-0.7246994376,
0.2130341679,
0.5325308442,
-0.1629072279,
-0.530672431,
-0.830606401,
0.4113421738,
-0.0623019971,
-0.4043050408,
0.0629500747,
-0.0296408944,
-0.3408429921,
0.6589589715,
1.0043107271,
0.3850986362,
-0.0528531782,
-0.1852352768,
0.5022735596,
-0.3120929897,
-0.7367417812,
-0.6478323936,
0.3602823019,
-0.6289292574,
-0.2287674248,
0.8691070676,
0.8497217894,
0.4679227471,
0.0402433835,
0.8558119535,
0.3104689717,
1.3719954491,
-0.2503378093,
0.9398397207,
-0.7094815969,
0.2549831271,
0.1114224419,
-0.8463534117,
-0.2808406651,
0.4913926125,
0.0083447779,
-0.0383657292,
0.3536774218,
0.8328319192,
-0.4854946733,
-0.0907992795,
0.1895957738,
0.2693660557,
0.0322767049,
-0.0884182081,
0.6450721622,
-0.6256423593,
0.7184503078,
-0.0393431745,
-0.258066684,
-0.5751320124,
-0.7340650558,
-0.8554697037,
-0.512158215,
-0.4709178805,
-0.4091404378,
0.3311762214,
0.1685006022,
1.219242692,
-0.6934446096,
0.1913749576,
-0.232711643,
0.1575239748,
-0.3292019963,
-0.3722429872,
0.39800632,
0.2197146565,
-0.7233760953,
0.6251930594,
0.0436259061,
0.0278328005,
-0.2763302028,
0.1720433384,
-0.0403475426,
0.645285368,
0.3160580099,
0.4238998294,
-0.8402507901,
-0.5968449712,
0.1833768785,
-0.1702764481,
-0.6197705269,
0.7432636619,
-1.1943862438,
0.5410669446,
0.401191771,
0.3689469695,
0.3598900437,
0.3456796408,
0.4981637299,
-0.7653831244,
0.2433845997,
0.2404846847,
-0.1147837713,
0.3389189243,
-0.3609763682,
0.3988207579,
0.4690236747,
-0.5735814571,
-1.3554868698,
0.3090115786,
-0.5865003467,
-0.4347882867,
0.786444068,
0.4044243097,
-0.2843044698,
-0.4161720276,
0.1766041815,
-0.0424677655,
-0.2023521513,
0.6534420252,
0.622399509,
0.1350143701,
-0.2983824015,
-0.7262305617,
0.7283465266,
-0.0399406515,
-0.7952685356,
-0.0406434909,
0.4615301192,
0.6716378927,
0.2025471628,
0.4454830885,
-0.0063675004,
0.8087962866,
0.2010999322,
-0.1710985601,
-0.1835182905,
-0.3454194963,
-0.0110818865,
-0.0584591329,
-0.6772722602,
-0.2193301171
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16302v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16302v1
|
Comprehensive Benchmarking of Entropy and Margin Based Scoring Metrics for Data Selection
| 2023-11-27T20:33:54 | 2023-11-27T20:33:54 |
Anusha Sabbineni, Nikhil Anand, Maria Minakova
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
While data selection methods have been studied extensively in active
learning, data pruning, and data augmentation settings, there is little
evidence for the efficacy of these methods in industry scale settings,
particularly in low-resource languages. Our work presents ways of assessing
prospective training examples in those settings for their "usefulness" or
"difficulty". We also demonstrate how these measures can be used in selecting
important examples for training supervised machine learning models. We
primarily experiment with entropy and Error L2-Norm (EL2N) scores. We use these
metrics to curate high quality datasets from a large pool of \textit{Weak
Signal Labeled} data, which assigns no-defect high confidence hypotheses during
inference as ground truth labels. We then conduct training data augmentation
experiments using these de-identified datasets and demonstrate that score-based
selection can result in a 2% decrease in semantic error rate and 4%-7% decrease
in domain classification error rate when compared to the baseline technique of
random selection.
|
[
-0.3389190137,
-0.5657923222,
0.307192415,
0.1345662177,
-0.1905157566,
-0.2704399526,
-0.384180069,
-0.3620495498,
-0.041695714,
0.0789327398,
-0.3548119366,
-0.7156977654,
-0.2451253831,
-0.0639585257,
-0.104706414,
0.9055205584,
-0.2727375925,
0.2577563822,
-0.5563705564,
-0.2342425734,
-0.5332067609,
-0.3458051682,
-0.5425875783,
-0.3858861327,
0.4759100378,
0.4774712622,
0.4749712944,
0.888415575,
0.9620534778,
0.1472977996,
0.1320295483,
0.0200803652,
-0.342993319,
0.4806174636,
0.0097601749,
-0.6171754003,
-0.4075195789,
0.5028123856,
0.5514751673,
0.8086003661,
0.1138147935,
0.5544623733,
0.0697332621,
0.6224912405,
-1.1545813084,
0.082552202,
-0.7314468622,
0.3524541557,
-0.1051743999,
-0.021130519,
-0.3100206852,
-0.3874881566,
-0.0632211566,
-0.4495734274,
0.2750693262,
-0.1020126119,
0.7055600286,
0.5866767168,
-0.2644992471,
-0.100350149,
-0.5128737092,
1.2558877468,
-0.3474742174,
0.4083072543,
0.6467372775,
0.2106646001,
0.3596678078,
-0.7596282959,
0.0875404105,
-0.1727001667,
0.1040485576,
0.4220334888,
-0.1222323775,
-0.0178859755,
0.4156131148,
0.3583047986,
-0.5977755189,
0.5373907685,
-0.4550038874,
-0.3854222,
0.7424494624,
0.2345981002,
-0.2143974751,
0.2148426622,
-0.2754175365,
-0.6980268955,
-0.4728932679,
0.029242428,
0.5216844678,
0.3098284602,
0.1940741241,
0.3834375739,
-0.4048504233,
0.9317997098,
-0.3539444208,
-0.0227019936,
0.578613162,
-0.0695683733,
-0.4183247983,
-0.0007872938,
0.6784080267,
0.6153693795,
-0.1978412569,
-0.1776334047,
-0.3575766385,
0.1679247916,
0.3307497799,
-0.6908605695,
-0.3434255719,
0.0925250947,
-0.5863226652,
-0.3951833546,
0.2091887146,
-0.8930026889,
-0.3511892259,
-0.3308154643,
0.2444933057,
-0.2099992931,
-0.0842531845,
-0.1628866345,
-0.625007689,
0.3286682963,
0.1376131922,
-0.2995477021,
0.1331663132,
0.512491107,
0.7839975357,
-0.5653671622,
-0.1439352185,
-0.3925962448,
-0.3919532597,
-0.7514218092,
0.5620711446,
-0.6814185381,
-0.3828122318,
-0.0529517606,
-0.2077823877,
0.0132447779,
-0.846042037,
1.0254040956,
-0.4621242881,
0.0653756484,
-0.1958597451,
-0.4766198397,
-0.2335516959,
0.2972263694,
-0.6865748167,
1.2512480021,
0.398810178,
-0.6914569139,
0.9390420914,
-0.3540052772,
-0.4535908401,
-0.2372235656,
0.0306652375,
-0.7029243112,
0.1483680904,
-0.1025449336,
0.471712023,
-0.2562963963,
-0.2456805259,
-0.6408879757,
-0.2904829681,
0.372872442,
-0.7752347589,
0.5127794743,
0.3941029608,
-0.3009806275,
-0.2945434153,
-0.8811411858,
0.6363510489,
-0.1577932835,
-0.4450702369,
-0.5517006516,
-0.2090443075,
0.0512536839,
0.2868158817,
0.2606258094,
-0.3009154797,
0.0167168882,
0.0009379954,
0.0474285446,
0.5432974696,
0.0778432786,
0.2666163445,
-0.3512070179,
0.3261673152,
0.0548651516,
0.1310704499,
0.175813511,
-0.2982184589,
-0.7321266532,
-0.4581319094,
0.7815995216,
0.7734026313,
-0.5204110146,
0.8451105356,
-0.0832747668,
-0.7893753648,
-0.7379429936,
0.4887319803,
0.3764126003,
0.5135639906,
0.4696841836,
-0.5664652586,
-0.5365949869,
-1.0049698353,
-0.1495773941,
-0.2938888073,
-0.291471988,
0.2748446465,
0.1752035469,
0.0307825077,
0.9569679499,
-0.494587034,
-0.1841286421,
0.1234305128,
0.2000562698,
0.327033639,
0.4789221585,
0.3756075501,
-0.6075597405,
-0.3348996639,
-0.1275903136,
-0.9927752614,
-0.1108758152,
-0.0412233062,
0.0021727644,
0.0371176265,
0.276611656,
-0.3147134185,
0.5106438994,
0.3578023016,
0.0100597478,
0.4608041942,
-0.1132990569,
0.2638372779,
-0.6388099194,
0.2165367007,
0.485886246,
-0.041801367,
-0.5013206005,
-0.0976474434,
0.2332966626,
0.1167098954,
-0.4643754959,
0.3278011382,
-0.3441490829,
-0.2063538134,
-0.1141512021,
-0.2424254566,
-0.0017240688,
0.4211783409,
0.2391798645,
0.6608624458,
0.755474627,
-0.7032219768,
0.3862465918,
-0.0913516954,
-0.7009915709,
0.5705859661,
-0.5968754292,
0.1992050558,
0.1817287803,
0.0753482133,
-0.818903029,
-0.1747467071,
-0.1428810656,
-0.4293349683,
0.3787080348,
-0.198437497,
-0.4587495923,
-0.3412198722,
-0.4577275813,
0.2662684619,
0.7166991234,
-0.4030999243,
-0.1795638055,
0.3902074397,
0.0591931902,
-0.4964923561,
-0.9038422108,
-0.134170711,
-0.6406546831,
-0.2504016459,
0.1297484338,
0.1419589818,
-0.4956433475,
-0.1814906597,
-0.2977787256,
-0.1131992266,
0.4866240919,
0.1310418993,
0.3168844283,
-0.1692802608,
0.2260013074,
0.0779521763,
-0.1500487924,
0.0063695223,
-0.3036271036,
0.1607219279,
-0.0250668172,
-0.5141888857,
-0.5537261963,
-0.0658545271,
0.3294364512,
-0.1281806529,
0.6322202086,
0.7601754069,
-0.4230522811,
-0.3338702917,
-0.4618831277,
-0.4712860584,
-0.3930916786,
0.477301985,
-0.2114798576,
-0.4535268247,
0.3565411568,
-0.1081323028,
0.0444321893,
0.5168185234,
0.6037299633,
-0.1142997146,
0.9848994613,
0.1005262956,
-0.2013650239,
0.4177018106,
-0.3334859014,
0.2517152131,
-0.6932182908,
-0.0481062308,
-0.6150547266,
-0.6308723092,
-0.7552433014,
-0.4576224983,
0.6729015708,
0.2575577796,
-0.1607420594,
0.2025758177,
-0.5490224957,
0.4638144076,
0.7625626922,
0.201561287,
-0.1260734349,
0.0448266007,
-0.0063321567,
-0.0263275225,
-0.6234047413,
-0.3955641389,
1.1773912907,
0.5764045715,
0.7839514017,
-0.3342237473,
0.5317437053,
0.4987100065,
0.2242188007,
-0.8207530975,
0.2479390353,
-0.1744955629,
-0.6310721636,
-0.4955404401,
-0.6154474616,
-0.8112300634,
0.065797098,
-0.1095921844,
-0.6939744353,
0.2594795525,
-0.0395107716,
-0.2285710424,
0.1696134061,
-0.8601791859,
0.8177226186,
-0.2539548576,
-0.5342139006,
-0.1967580169,
-0.4854050577,
0.2000953257,
-0.170287028,
0.0284838285,
-0.0968692973,
-0.1728639603,
1.137814641,
-0.1930270791,
0.8452582955,
-0.4586848319,
0.0788032264,
0.5010000467,
0.0386501402,
0.3114947975,
0.1279906183,
-0.6219810247,
0.3021457493,
-0.1085196361,
-0.3285174966,
-0.5844875574,
0.5577706099,
-0.8164582849,
-0.1391495913,
-0.2122305334,
-0.2834593654,
-0.6664956808,
-0.1235136017,
0.2709010839,
0.2243807316,
-0.0552984662,
0.7628543377,
0.7219797373,
-0.0330896787,
0.3094897866,
0.3252415359,
0.6828026175,
-0.5517485738,
1.0679225922,
0.2293368131,
0.0557348728,
0.179765448,
0.0114792697,
-0.267041862,
-0.4483279288,
-0.1811624169,
-0.4186440408,
-0.834082365,
-0.6557901502,
-0.2293200195,
-0.2899257839,
-0.1532654315,
0.0069635436,
-0.33663252,
-0.5746282339,
-0.15787597,
-0.4357409477,
0.1660169065,
0.1823070347,
-0.289570421,
0.1046491265,
-0.5354664326,
-0.0454404689,
0.2609893084,
0.5302801132,
-0.0707451254,
-0.4496507645,
-0.5571439862,
0.0373466648,
-0.4090162814,
-0.4869848192,
0.1573832184,
0.1925234497,
0.8905004263,
0.4791852534,
0.2730463147,
0.3308954537,
-0.0238981154,
0.8381125331,
0.2661182284,
-0.6231978536,
0.7915872335,
-0.0402721316,
-0.0344262719,
0.9610310793,
0.4632410109,
-0.2083595693,
-0.3274032772,
-0.6463038325,
-0.9664594531,
0.595390141,
0.1289270818,
-0.0746547431,
0.0970011652,
0.2577390075,
0.3669633567,
0.090012297,
-0.3387598395,
-0.2461586148,
-0.002017742,
-0.3244718909,
-0.1281881481,
0.1760307401,
-0.1873363256,
-0.2473620176,
0.8039396405,
-0.1793671548,
0.1151230112,
0.0838605538,
-0.0851252228,
0.068281509,
0.0146122379,
0.2551117241,
0.5876958966,
-0.2309544533,
0.0925099179,
0.4484380782,
-0.5147782564,
0.0857602954,
-0.0597497113,
-0.055652678,
0.0010037606,
0.5897367597,
0.9637725353,
-0.2901398242,
-0.5519384742,
0.375808984,
0.0380835012,
-0.3995115161,
-0.0517931916,
0.3830118775,
-0.5797548294,
-0.0353231244,
0.3855651319,
0.0560356565,
0.2902237773,
-0.3367386162,
0.4902451336,
0.4447728395,
-0.9374511242,
-0.0997430459,
0.1469261348,
-0.0669054836,
0.0209616907,
0.8863712549,
-0.2141043991,
-0.1745543331,
0.7713137269,
0.1326969862,
0.781247437,
-0.1241387054,
0.1385752261,
0.5517377853,
0.2468963116,
-0.283673197,
-0.0090301447,
-0.158246398,
-0.7086270452,
-0.1511341482,
-0.6535782218,
-0.4473111331,
0.2626720965,
-1.1336804628,
0.3456630707,
-0.2692768574,
-0.4242540896,
-0.1710183918,
0.3849489689,
-0.9165468216,
0.5940346718,
0.2476614267,
1.1750558615,
-1.2173571587,
0.6464126706,
0.7791147232,
-0.2814206779,
-0.5924780965,
0.0503154062,
-0.0474175178,
-0.697843194,
0.4550002515,
0.0775880218,
0.3641780019,
-0.4092196226,
-0.4933126867,
-0.5540160537,
1.1772720814,
0.0755484477,
-0.1902744472,
0.3742964268,
0.0274546035,
0.6439148784,
-0.1755057275,
0.5395972133,
0.8603268862,
0.5229740143,
0.1242134571,
-0.7714580894,
-0.184152782,
-0.3286238909,
-0.1077513918,
0.1350520998,
-0.7419005632,
0.5090519786,
0.2408566177,
0.1406545043,
-0.1275887638,
0.6219733357,
0.37246117,
0.7669923306,
0.6261699796,
0.8120970726,
1.0060845613,
-0.2355676293,
0.7450777292,
-0.3587678075,
0.3396737576,
0.7480744123,
-0.4501055181,
0.9059141278,
0.5412678719,
-0.4401059449,
0.3684636652,
1.1991504431,
-0.3500826657,
0.7846859694,
0.5344243646,
-0.0398213156,
-0.3683740199,
-0.2903734148,
-0.3367647827,
0.5678358674,
0.5084611773,
-0.2328193933,
-0.1194667146,
-0.0693050846,
-0.2824271023,
-0.3209604919,
-0.3032295108,
0.991440177,
0.1306071132,
-0.6637166142,
0.5446968675,
0.1535089314,
0.4984389544,
-0.4610024691,
0.0625925884,
-0.2863096595,
0.1705883592,
-0.3047621846,
-0.8753741384,
0.2205422372,
0.1583399773,
-0.1455371529,
-0.2053988576,
0.7560899258,
-0.1337160617,
-0.6486142874,
0.0462760702,
0.5846806169,
0.3396314383,
0.0887348503,
-0.4895222783,
0.0123385936,
-0.2356986105,
-0.226386413,
0.4788639247,
0.4957029819,
-0.1919091493,
0.3854932785,
0.5030431747,
0.1434119791,
-0.3249199688,
0.0608018897,
0.7040987611,
-0.3824403882,
-0.4925054014,
-0.6938534379,
0.4326230884,
-0.3918789625,
-0.360737741,
0.6441098452,
0.9074442387,
0.8670623899,
0.0745025873,
1.0485504866,
-0.0658441707,
0.4268079996,
-0.6742454767,
0.4995998442,
-0.493999511,
0.1643029749,
-0.1098433137,
-1.0963116884,
-0.3788068891,
0.6822255254,
-0.5103648305,
0.2139784247,
0.5380268097,
0.7554656267,
-0.131023109,
-0.1549965143,
0.4144237339,
-0.2601982951,
-0.1123503596,
0.4216379523,
0.8272537589,
-0.392837286,
0.2816502154,
-0.3609040976,
-0.5042752624,
-0.3001378179,
-0.7349126339,
-0.8205981255,
-0.622703433,
-0.6632386446,
-0.4316201806,
-0.0444215462,
0.7188882232,
0.8953166604,
-0.9227487445,
-0.1948852241,
0.1553052664,
0.1796784252,
-0.5914704204,
-0.2543711662,
0.3708635867,
-0.697794497,
-0.2460768372,
0.4491982162,
-0.0107767005,
-0.1151872352,
-0.147445783,
-0.0835530236,
0.3551904857,
-0.2482742667,
0.1504642665,
0.0328166373,
-0.078418687,
-0.0832944214,
0.0167645365,
-0.0969282463,
0.1122228652,
0.7932611704,
-0.722068131,
0.1178447381,
0.7232487798,
0.7219887376,
0.3044864535,
-0.0229926948,
0.4248174727,
-0.9746943116,
0.0388140976,
0.3093850911,
0.1932895631,
0.3487238288,
-0.2147399783,
0.7513591051,
0.2915226519,
-0.4522333145,
-1.0128852129,
-0.1368663013,
-0.696190536,
-0.2530571222,
1.2205148935,
-0.1960773915,
-0.3269792199,
0.1186109036,
0.3011516035,
0.2442425936,
-0.143052429,
0.847384274,
0.7218033671,
-0.1051594019,
0.1686418802,
-0.7310106754,
0.6061703563,
0.284198314,
-0.7242980003,
0.0415172577,
0.3313996792,
0.0727870613,
0.1927981377,
-0.0076989587,
0.041532658,
0.299049437,
0.204993993,
0.0022807005,
0.1314177364,
-0.3915783763,
-0.4317225516,
0.1640158296,
0.1692992598,
-0.4277896881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16298v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16298v1
|
Influence Scores at Scale for Efficient Language Data Sampling
| 2023-11-27T20:19:22 | 2023-11-27T20:19:22 |
Nikhil Anand, Joshua Tan, Maria Minakova
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Modern ML systems ingest data aggregated from diverse sources, such as
synthetic, human-annotated, and live customer traffic. Understanding
\textit{which} examples are important to the performance of a learning
algorithm is crucial for efficient model training. Recently, a growing body of
literature has given rise to various "influence scores," which use training
artifacts such as model confidence or checkpointed gradients to identify
important subsets of data. However, these methods have primarily been developed
in computer vision settings, and it remains unclear how well they generalize to
language-based tasks using pretrained models.
In this paper, we explore the applicability of influence scores in language
classification tasks. We evaluate a diverse subset of these scores on the SNLI
dataset by quantifying accuracy changes in response to pruning training data
through random and influence-score-based sampling. We then stress-test one of
the scores -- "variance of gradients" (VoG) from Agarwal et al. (2022) -- in an
NLU model stack that was exposed to dynamic user speech patterns in a voice
assistant type of setting. Our experiments demonstrate that in many cases,
encoder-based language models can be finetuned on roughly 50% of the original
data without degradation in performance metrics. Along the way, we summarize
lessons learned from applying out-of-the-box implementations of influence
scores, quantify the effects of noisy and class-imbalanced data, and offer
recommendations on score-based sampling for better accuracy and training
efficiency.
|
[
-0.2655836046,
-0.7768540978,
0.3168717921,
0.4500626326,
0.048342213,
-0.287517786,
-0.3364080191,
-0.4080229402,
0.2783595622,
0.4135309458,
-0.0867932662,
-0.5101016164,
-0.6717284918,
-0.2449800372,
-0.3721258342,
1.0767681599,
0.1264591515,
0.4489609897,
-0.219627887,
-0.1589272767,
-0.2212923467,
-0.3921187222,
-0.6046035886,
-0.1855803132,
0.658919096,
0.2482876927,
0.5456010103,
0.5453096628,
0.6052308679,
0.2054014504,
-0.0339408927,
-0.0760998875,
-0.5890561938,
0.2165732086,
-0.0328126103,
-0.8093166947,
-0.23045066,
0.3041115403,
0.9294638634,
0.782536447,
-0.3565305769,
0.3236523569,
0.2551433146,
0.3677477241,
-0.5954629183,
0.2453216165,
-0.6340303421,
-0.2175625712,
-0.2587258518,
-0.1547466516,
-0.5533252358,
-0.4964252412,
0.057698641,
-0.4420795441,
0.1565964222,
0.0315519795,
0.6819685102,
0.4521899223,
-0.1507573575,
-0.3723445237,
-0.684163034,
1.0993965864,
-0.5275602937,
0.3270611167,
0.4755545855,
0.1471607685,
-0.1927011907,
-0.6184459925,
-0.2243918628,
-0.2825716436,
-0.1235145032,
0.0819182247,
-0.2716780603,
0.1176392734,
0.4362850487,
0.404260695,
-0.0973495468,
0.3922181129,
-0.3801527023,
0.0302960146,
0.6143038869,
-0.0091181239,
0.1670987606,
0.0367061906,
0.0990010053,
-0.4804562628,
-0.6736320853,
0.3161426485,
0.4401626885,
0.4175499678,
0.0912010446,
0.2966196835,
-0.1282086223,
0.8606817126,
0.3536975682,
0.1894013882,
0.3082485795,
-0.2890233397,
-0.2125360072,
-0.2037735283,
0.6894199848,
0.1709781885,
0.4530293345,
-0.0583573543,
-0.0594058596,
-0.1606472135,
0.4413093328,
-0.8464981318,
-0.26841259,
-0.23784253,
-0.4004333615,
-0.3699812293,
0.1900236905,
-0.8440098763,
-0.591224134,
-0.5106222034,
0.4899790883,
-0.1349020898,
-0.3065389395,
-0.1661925167,
-0.0674187317,
0.4064111114,
0.470585376,
-0.630341351,
0.2492925376,
0.3893380165,
0.5664189458,
-0.2083763927,
-0.2253681719,
-0.6527734399,
-0.6017845273,
-0.5635813475,
0.4231948256,
-0.7580752969,
-0.4013532102,
0.0765934885,
-0.2109425515,
-0.2809159458,
-0.8303024173,
0.5360090733,
-0.3397940397,
0.0831345692,
-0.1691842973,
-0.8214380145,
-0.0187311862,
-0.1271927208,
-0.7259693742,
1.1716909409,
0.1119174138,
-0.5667092204,
0.5411838889,
-0.5038281083,
-0.4990648329,
-0.1442614049,
-0.208612293,
-0.3185923696,
0.4438923895,
0.203431353,
0.6879792213,
-0.0651753321,
0.2565244734,
-0.2241356224,
-0.2868552804,
0.2523960471,
-0.4384456873,
0.7553467155,
0.0193970613,
-0.3666170239,
0.0444564298,
-0.7194016576,
0.1374741346,
-0.3664658964,
-0.2962237895,
-0.626295507,
-0.0052842409,
0.1513951123,
0.1176803932,
-0.1711083949,
-0.3919286132,
0.0376977399,
-0.1056787521,
-0.0449031405,
0.6694959998,
0.3244168758,
0.5521729589,
-0.2370607257,
0.5242239237,
-0.2613439262,
0.0970659852,
-0.0620931759,
-0.6162467599,
-0.7581698895,
-0.1137480289,
0.4480759203,
0.3093812168,
-0.4952515662,
0.4539825916,
-0.3327379525,
-0.8637538552,
-0.8677692413,
0.359705627,
0.1838290989,
0.2852046192,
0.4457135201,
-0.3306677938,
-0.20454216,
-0.7860629559,
-0.6939923167,
-0.0276964866,
-0.3110935986,
0.5210466385,
0.2693684101,
0.0041347467,
0.9014207721,
-0.4094958901,
-0.2140128016,
-0.2724068761,
0.2566664219,
0.0840750933,
0.671048224,
0.553581357,
-0.6253575683,
-0.5531723499,
-0.2843436301,
-0.3514761925,
-0.3382807374,
-0.2767623365,
-0.0793813318,
-0.3158084154,
0.7474550605,
-0.1874262094,
0.3250496984,
0.6945115924,
-0.283215642,
0.4490347803,
-0.0471290685,
0.2877593935,
-0.8042455912,
0.0263108518,
0.3978387713,
-0.0581886992,
-1.052828908,
-0.126923129,
-0.0773218349,
0.1966856122,
-0.1496191174,
0.2584339976,
-0.0635279417,
0.1698704809,
0.0344633907,
-0.044287663,
-0.0600079894,
0.4625836313,
0.0599586703,
0.5349850655,
0.5811930895,
-0.6869029403,
-0.1466410905,
-0.2532327175,
-0.7952387929,
0.5205826759,
-0.6114779115,
0.2709694803,
-0.0916680843,
0.0919336379,
-0.9441235662,
-0.0794631839,
-0.1018415093,
-0.2093566954,
0.4840353131,
-0.0087124398,
-0.3803350329,
0.2494467944,
-0.0585728996,
0.2131804526,
0.4921823144,
-0.5647563338,
0.7121685743,
0.6295586228,
0.0378127545,
-0.5494437814,
-0.6563141942,
-0.2568271458,
-0.3705226481,
-0.1125624254,
0.1935034692,
-0.0781363845,
-0.5354998112,
-0.255831629,
0.0431024767,
-0.2424911261,
0.0619419627,
0.4886378944,
-0.1110045835,
0.0056434362,
0.4350242615,
0.0146441516,
0.4323177934,
0.2376920134,
-0.0818994343,
0.3941901028,
-0.1138197482,
-0.3300378919,
-0.376693517,
0.0406213962,
0.7711562514,
-0.1297288984,
0.7547738552,
0.7110646963,
-0.1112348288,
-0.4289318621,
-0.6336032152,
-0.3975491226,
-0.3929694891,
0.6134768724,
-0.1989642531,
-0.7761099339,
0.4116250575,
-0.1614614427,
0.2137675285,
0.4061543345,
0.4431300759,
-0.1502303779,
0.8344497085,
0.5131004453,
-0.48314026,
1.1078295708,
-0.0984861925,
-0.0817239583,
-0.6824074984,
0.0180520304,
-0.559026897,
-0.3690061569,
-0.7898796201,
-0.7454712391,
0.2727876008,
0.1354730576,
0.187314868,
0.0377106257,
-0.1366382241,
0.4781976938,
0.6174597144,
0.312076062,
-0.0851592869,
-0.0611738078,
0.1519988924,
-0.0078461207,
-0.8278267384,
-0.0503040999,
1.2983825207,
0.4273313582,
0.8669790626,
-0.0978625715,
0.5379052162,
0.3250347674,
0.6223044395,
-0.7923002839,
0.2386859953,
-0.3042780757,
-0.4663617909,
-0.4872184098,
-0.618350327,
-0.8093804717,
0.1659347415,
-0.3581475914,
-0.5395273566,
0.3947748542,
0.2818111777,
-0.1338386834,
0.0522068031,
-0.8846700788,
0.6320284009,
-0.1042117923,
-0.4268623888,
-0.5058999658,
-0.3192228079,
0.1309472322,
-0.2352772206,
0.2585722506,
0.0766124502,
0.4078968167,
1.0146973133,
-0.0137603162,
1.1199786663,
-0.5150116086,
-0.041183494,
0.4365930259,
-0.1200028807,
0.5053416491,
-0.1562647074,
-0.4008731544,
0.319287926,
-0.2678652704,
-0.2675287724,
-0.9746852517,
0.671979785,
-0.6631566286,
-0.4362023771,
0.2506519854,
-0.4546411335,
-0.2276097983,
-0.0741500482,
0.2180329263,
0.5440177321,
-0.2627293468,
0.6451250315,
0.6358203292,
-0.1466300786,
0.2308131158,
0.4092155695,
-0.188155219,
-0.0602867343,
0.819796145,
0.4068588018,
0.5572224855,
0.3180028796,
0.4814555943,
-0.275175333,
-0.3361242115,
-0.4171384871,
-0.0717117786,
-0.7146520615,
0.0472848304,
-0.2344694436,
-0.064372398,
-0.1541805714,
0.0298956204,
-0.3269936144,
-0.2672309577,
-0.1901966333,
-0.1865348518,
0.3343556523,
0.860013783,
0.0602041669,
0.4111291766,
-0.246973291,
-0.1812450588,
0.3411861658,
0.472037822,
-0.0757030398,
-0.6165626049,
-0.4711292684,
-0.1397697181,
0.2153559029,
-0.672360003,
0.117363207,
0.6625989079,
0.9226427674,
0.5436700583,
0.0592532158,
0.516420722,
-0.2727119029,
0.5738994479,
-0.0475696363,
-0.9543977976,
0.4760642946,
-0.0268044192,
0.5375038981,
0.829523623,
0.3792282641,
-0.4352605641,
-0.7434676886,
-0.551348269,
-0.4661608338,
0.508710444,
0.1054913551,
0.1961502731,
0.1709149778,
0.5999336839,
-0.1134194881,
0.1694600135,
-0.5624297857,
-0.3036559522,
-0.143530637,
-0.3739610612,
-0.4362998009,
0.0064455792,
0.2073621154,
-0.3575900793,
0.3882659078,
0.0249919239,
-0.1571076959,
0.0934911072,
-0.1998756081,
0.1090405136,
0.1081987619,
0.4281724691,
0.4016694427,
-0.1588056684,
0.1458975226,
0.339325577,
-0.8816885352,
-0.1833500713,
-0.1450099051,
-0.2243746668,
0.0557839014,
0.4294632673,
0.8875824213,
0.2029127628,
-0.4617597461,
0.4320165813,
-0.1023852006,
-0.1070023701,
0.0757658631,
0.2625082731,
-0.3214524388,
-0.123793304,
0.1737842858,
0.3293814063,
0.1680687219,
-0.328091979,
0.3586647213,
0.3008186519,
-1.0365641117,
-0.2635169625,
0.1204794049,
0.2597025037,
-0.2360401601,
0.5278885961,
-0.0243064314,
-0.3464704752,
0.5529226661,
0.2251987457,
0.6741937995,
-0.7134389877,
-0.0190188345,
0.4275485873,
0.3924483955,
-0.307980448,
-0.203166306,
-0.1708994508,
-1.0655016899,
-0.5659960508,
-0.6437581182,
-0.3499985635,
0.2040213943,
-0.9719685316,
0.1645964831,
-0.4141927361,
-0.178397432,
0.0660558417,
-0.1892339289,
-0.8691411614,
0.3683278561,
0.0015682071,
0.7430679202,
-1.0682572126,
1.0238765478,
0.633277297,
-0.1477562934,
-1.0550205708,
0.2022910118,
-0.1235489324,
-0.697461009,
0.6362977624,
0.0451118425,
-0.300915122,
0.1887129545,
-0.3636861444,
-0.7552445531,
0.5623457432,
0.0145576652,
-0.5848662257,
0.3853985667,
-0.0309884772,
0.702057898,
-0.5084029436,
0.5894453526,
0.803647697,
0.3010693192,
-0.2153661251,
-0.7572773695,
-0.1280911118,
-0.3888532519,
-0.3413780034,
0.072568357,
-0.3343809545,
0.5918240547,
0.0567176379,
0.002870094,
-0.4440372288,
0.3292419314,
-0.014311864,
0.0922000632,
0.8973022699,
0.370298475,
0.9219813943,
-0.0235086381,
1.069217205,
-0.3600226939,
0.1076082587,
1.0395220518,
0.137539804,
1.082554698,
0.5298908949,
-0.2068242729,
0.6330493689,
0.4002691507,
-0.1278079003,
0.4299309552,
0.6084091067,
-0.0497176312,
-0.1974987388,
-0.1686881036,
-0.0815466121,
0.7801885605,
0.5683292747,
-0.6373255849,
0.0942241922,
0.1077992246,
0.0984961241,
0.0111800814,
-0.4719263911,
0.6841022372,
-0.0398152433,
-0.6105436087,
0.2289431393,
-0.4022347629,
0.5779200792,
-0.6262934804,
-0.0834844708,
-0.1330804676,
0.2175485641,
-0.1029875576,
-0.5603992343,
0.0245311446,
-0.066298753,
-0.2445127517,
-0.3915145099,
0.4876975417,
-0.5237395763,
-0.6254726648,
0.2656714618,
0.4771100879,
0.2764809728,
-0.1505995244,
-0.4128388464,
-0.1742775589,
0.1673298329,
-0.3347436786,
0.4174571037,
0.1363027543,
-0.0505399518,
0.3596672118,
0.5944392085,
0.3280260265,
0.2162356228,
0.5326260924,
0.5898083448,
-0.3004095256,
-0.312438637,
-0.6703288555,
0.3128353357,
-0.3196032643,
-0.5373262763,
0.9580187201,
0.3951826096,
0.7184518576,
-0.0227159504,
0.7201162577,
0.1849731356,
0.5179880857,
-0.4248914123,
0.7934828997,
-0.4712662101,
0.2981027067,
-0.3791379631,
-0.8369287252,
-0.527374506,
0.6323073506,
-0.6436500549,
0.1032426283,
0.2945255935,
0.842900157,
0.3331763744,
-0.0813771337,
0.3073139191,
0.108486563,
0.3509372175,
0.0695641711,
0.7385966182,
-0.1095768958,
0.425222367,
-0.3052408695,
-0.5135592222,
-0.2395496815,
-0.6163037419,
-0.8203083873,
-0.4138815701,
-0.4411613941,
-0.2038649768,
-0.1954484433,
0.7545779347,
0.9278619289,
-0.9871550798,
-0.3730104268,
-0.3350903988,
0.1425179541,
-0.4646295309,
-0.2796970606,
0.4353041053,
-0.6058033705,
-0.9627738595,
0.4606653452,
-0.026932463,
-0.0818240941,
-0.3500212133,
0.0439675488,
0.0465886071,
0.0726247951,
0.3999274969,
0.0560254566,
-0.5760879517,
-0.216084078,
0.1060578972,
-0.0371903442,
-0.1320859492,
1.0886417627,
-0.6000897288,
0.6701468825,
0.3984485567,
0.5535440445,
0.4266315103,
0.2694447935,
0.7397228479,
-0.8939083219,
-0.0325781219,
0.1664298922,
0.1846934706,
0.2674528062,
-0.2753411829,
0.3209984899,
0.0477000363,
-0.6307882071,
-0.6153821945,
0.1238304004,
-0.6989535689,
-0.1245011613,
1.2712864876,
-0.2901163697,
-0.0189155098,
-0.1908152401,
-0.0003871533,
-0.0856917351,
-0.4559561312,
0.821474731,
0.593559444,
-0.2198981196,
-0.2682771087,
-0.6738221645,
0.9139341712,
0.606061995,
-0.6096258759,
0.0692374185,
0.2346015126,
0.0525062494,
0.3595593572,
0.3188337982,
0.1637814939,
-0.1373275071,
0.2696070075,
0.0642900467,
0.3268858194,
-0.2263205051,
-0.5619497895,
0.2540911734,
0.1193268076,
-0.2952829301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16292v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16292v1
|
Student Mastery or AI Deception? Analyzing ChatGPT's Assessment Proficiency and Evaluating Detection Strategies
| 2023-11-27T20:10:13 | 2023-11-27T20:10:13 |
Kevin Wang, Seth Akins, Abdallah Mohammed, Ramon Lawrence
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL
|
Generative AI systems such as ChatGPT have a disruptive effect on learning
and assessment. Computer science requires practice to develop skills in problem
solving and programming that are traditionally developed using assignments.
Generative AI has the capability of completing these assignments for students
with high accuracy, which dramatically increases the potential for academic
integrity issues and students not achieving desired learning outcomes. This
work investigates the performance of ChatGPT by evaluating it across three
courses (CS1,CS2,databases). ChatGPT completes almost all introductory
assessments perfectly. Existing detection methods, such as MOSS and JPlag
(based on similarity metrics) and GPTzero (AI detection), have mixed success in
identifying AI solutions. Evaluating instructors and teaching assistants using
heuristics to distinguish between student and AI code shows that their
detection is not sufficiently accurate. These observations emphasize the need
for adapting assessments and improved detection methods.
|
[
-0.203359887,
-0.9562854171,
0.1872590631,
0.2502014339,
0.3442318738,
0.8178228736,
-0.0324878246,
-0.2897463739,
-0.3587712944,
-0.073708497,
-0.2015613914,
-0.1933670044,
-0.5790125132,
-0.1065813228,
-0.5634019375,
1.0708093643,
0.0813972205,
0.0969623029,
-0.5549210906,
0.1723934561,
-0.7907723784,
-0.4537129998,
-0.9585656524,
-0.4721235037,
-0.1916115135,
0.698621273,
0.6989263296,
0.0806276053,
0.7625666261,
0.3848634958,
0.0387932435,
-0.113263607,
-0.4845204949,
-0.0565701276,
0.1963489652,
-0.5615251064,
-0.2569940686,
0.1974431574,
0.5244742632,
0.6359454393,
-0.1738530695,
0.2672734559,
0.269530952,
0.562636137,
-0.6405346394,
0.1701397151,
-0.5005584955,
0.0138850501,
-0.1677694321,
-0.0264614485,
-0.4477108121,
-0.2364625484,
0.4031406045,
-0.526355505,
0.489315629,
-0.2818863988,
0.7951557636,
0.240625456,
-0.1385283321,
-0.4927534461,
-0.8066228628,
0.6675008535,
-0.1523574293,
-0.0034030993,
0.2584333122,
0.4965968728,
-0.0581606254,
-0.5680446029,
-0.5876213312,
-0.6079490185,
0.0819918811,
0.721794188,
-0.2745686173,
0.1524889618,
0.3604891896,
0.5127609968,
-0.9152139425,
0.2311021835,
-0.6372754574,
-0.5040222406,
0.664760828,
0.2540640533,
0.4128099382,
-0.0409223177,
-0.392765075,
-0.2130560428,
-0.2902490497,
0.1108485237,
0.6315782666,
-0.0194821637,
0.1250582784,
0.4833004475,
-0.1024951935,
0.442086637,
-0.1732747704,
0.0557103157,
0.0490886606,
-0.0965040773,
-0.1987950206,
-0.0526164249,
0.7485603094,
0.0839530751,
0.3917928636,
-0.0877902955,
0.0115954587,
0.5335225463,
0.4300711155,
-0.5338581204,
-0.6793434024,
0.2972934544,
-0.2945146561,
-0.5029207468,
0.0723400339,
-0.5029189587,
-0.3225130439,
-0.3006384671,
0.7332485318,
-0.5777659416,
-0.259211123,
-0.087000221,
-0.4023165405,
0.6639509797,
0.5485275388,
-0.5644182563,
0.2950758636,
0.7835205197,
0.838557601,
-0.5286766887,
-0.3440348506,
0.0319302082,
-0.3043709695,
-0.4306353331,
0.7577739954,
-0.4737752974,
-0.5666005611,
-0.1833437532,
-0.4592518508,
-0.2136443257,
-0.5161448121,
0.3595164418,
-0.4895878732,
0.3579507172,
0.0627101809,
-0.6727314591,
-0.0596089549,
0.4393689036,
-0.2860492468,
1.2838451862,
0.4829471707,
-0.4943344593,
0.3808548748,
-0.9473517537,
-0.2890004814,
0.5772277713,
-0.1451780945,
-0.4251038432,
-0.2996190786,
-0.1912849844,
0.2209644318,
0.2024160922,
-0.056025926,
0.2601297498,
-0.7443868518,
0.397189647,
-0.7370860577,
0.9233770967,
0.171026364,
-0.3806446195,
-0.0665949881,
-0.4658684433,
0.2329229116,
0.1167744473,
-0.4518424273,
0.0905250907,
0.0307283495,
-0.0932351649,
-0.3371959031,
0.1761222035,
-0.2072065026,
0.3134097159,
0.0172403865,
0.1675115973,
0.9635925293,
-0.0071741128,
0.0938678756,
-0.4124239683,
0.8248589039,
-0.1539230347,
0.242788136,
0.0668892413,
-0.6626699567,
-0.9269598126,
-0.1883728653,
0.4386663139,
0.9001040459,
-0.6190190315,
0.0800605938,
-0.2264336646,
-0.6940017939,
-0.46148929,
-0.0428967364,
0.3975215852,
0.2674244046,
0.3794854283,
-0.5602443218,
-0.0843058005,
-0.650200963,
-0.3119466007,
-0.5809597373,
-0.1536487639,
0.2012399435,
0.5708200336,
-0.055376254,
0.8445567489,
-0.5683307052,
-0.5164071321,
-0.1777223647,
0.4295496345,
-0.2820211351,
0.6950896978,
0.4589977562,
-0.7685884237,
-0.767711401,
-0.0123309931,
-0.7033914328,
0.1248973683,
-0.2519803345,
0.2259592116,
0.0779291168,
0.3824706674,
-0.1655877233,
0.6672726274,
0.1409073472,
-0.1873710752,
0.9813558459,
-0.0664188638,
0.4251405597,
-0.4573897421,
-0.0347970463,
-0.2316229939,
-0.0046618329,
-0.7259762287,
0.2186391056,
-0.2430316508,
-0.183249414,
-0.0412333682,
-0.1384253055,
-0.3772232831,
-0.0985166579,
-0.2932346463,
0.1982623637,
-0.339761436,
0.2787939906,
-0.3097437024,
1.1295672655,
0.7193263173,
-0.3783191741,
0.4072877467,
0.2174704671,
-0.4585059285,
0.7496154904,
-0.7477422357,
0.350658536,
-0.0049107987,
0.0442212969,
-1.1744321585,
-0.2164167464,
0.2438622266,
-1.049836874,
0.261354804,
-0.2978594899,
-0.325514555,
-0.3488237262,
-0.1890758127,
0.3535531759,
0.6837465167,
-0.1629244238,
0.3872177005,
-0.1436749697,
0.1258603483,
-0.8615640402,
-0.5030456781,
0.1265372634,
-0.1318853199,
-0.4561209083,
0.1574059874,
-0.0455546267,
-0.3067140281,
-0.0684890449,
-0.0327815898,
-0.2112633586,
0.6903913617,
0.2670170665,
0.477034688,
-0.2257604152,
0.0107430769,
-0.317912668,
-0.1177099124,
0.2978250682,
0.0333862938,
0.5477208495,
-0.4231756628,
-0.7948644757,
-0.5547967553,
0.1823171675,
0.596105516,
-0.1171828657,
0.5082907081,
0.878488183,
-0.1614165306,
-0.0380827412,
-0.4583804607,
-0.0859085023,
-0.5124590993,
0.5074009895,
-0.4095058143,
-0.7194860578,
0.4255883098,
0.0138357189,
-0.0627224073,
0.2681393325,
0.3394702971,
-0.2827797234,
0.962280035,
0.3894393146,
-0.3670106828,
0.4553439319,
-0.5402432084,
0.3232315779,
-0.637396872,
-0.2405488938,
-0.6857994795,
-0.1250855476,
-0.7551950216,
-0.0777312443,
0.6548292637,
0.1343608499,
-0.3268483877,
0.1984179914,
-0.7944371104,
0.7681763172,
0.735112071,
0.2785099745,
0.3757929206,
0.031441953,
0.2859997451,
0.1724893898,
-0.4942640662,
-0.4640972912,
1.2553420067,
0.2153289914,
0.3478904665,
0.3686985672,
0.4922203124,
0.8073623776,
0.6220896244,
-1.0945717096,
0.4964503944,
0.12169981,
-0.4829917848,
-0.335169524,
-0.3821372986,
-0.9263273478,
0.2118717581,
-0.0605456494,
-0.7824980021,
-0.3616071343,
-0.0722850263,
-0.1382002383,
0.0012126657,
-0.8827430606,
0.8951340318,
-0.0589118674,
-0.2727902532,
-0.4909240305,
-0.4247428775,
0.1882623434,
0.1060564145,
-0.1853108555,
-0.0125945667,
0.2509642541,
0.8119536042,
-0.2367500067,
0.7020084858,
-0.2510529757,
0.2307876199,
0.6098558307,
0.3158637583,
0.0575536601,
-0.0931268856,
-0.0189183038,
-0.0629977062,
0.2060284168,
-0.9002363682,
-0.5289954543,
0.2547315955,
-0.9665603638,
-0.8555921912,
-0.6689857244,
-0.2012193501,
-0.2652348578,
-0.053584937,
0.392056644,
0.2675544322,
-0.4484909773,
-0.0588410236,
0.6387576461,
0.0683849975,
0.2529012561,
0.4334714115,
0.0991981104,
0.2043414712,
1.2190436125,
0.0002699351,
0.5823533535,
-0.1401876807,
0.1935354471,
0.1712735295,
-0.6813427806,
-0.4920982122,
-0.2681978345,
-0.7570611835,
-0.139315322,
-0.2619440556,
-0.5558634996,
-0.5302780271,
-0.2133409381,
-0.0743850991,
-0.1068279445,
-0.34611848,
0.144006148,
0.0191374663,
0.6639598012,
-0.033207234,
0.629219234,
-0.2662934959,
-0.0313706771,
0.4714768529,
0.0287653916,
-0.0083087245,
-0.5617348552,
0.1054936424,
0.0422590114,
-0.8940890431,
-0.7675740123,
-0.1261689365,
0.1529796571,
0.5522203445,
0.5674071312,
-0.2773029506,
0.5290042758,
0.0844025016,
1.0884033442,
-0.0658132583,
-1.1122460365,
0.5801973939,
-0.2417321354,
0.0425409526,
0.5970175266,
0.568036437,
-0.5997589231,
-0.4963474274,
-0.7441356778,
-0.1933654398,
0.5314615369,
0.2381247133,
0.3738310635,
0.2681055367,
0.241528362,
-0.1070462391,
-0.1002000123,
-0.5626739264,
-0.2996727824,
-0.0440015309,
-0.1341484189,
0.2309383005,
-0.0244794581,
-0.0271068458,
-0.2501906455,
0.6170305014,
-0.2906520367,
0.4151367843,
0.0605677702,
-0.0837585628,
0.3562239408,
0.2970736027,
0.4055075049,
0.6653199792,
0.1015977114,
-0.3095526695,
0.157426253,
-0.9381975532,
0.0004338816,
-0.2099365592,
-0.1727749854,
-0.3157882988,
0.6273826361,
0.1532442272,
-0.3984704614,
-0.6969061494,
1.0176713467,
0.1774753183,
-0.2363614291,
-0.6464399099,
0.5635826588,
-0.4690133929,
-0.0267464425,
0.5370384455,
0.4065570533,
0.5054191351,
-0.5671697259,
0.0021986747,
0.6760561466,
-0.4742285013,
-0.1169360578,
0.2482389659,
-0.0606947914,
-0.3146065772,
1.0525819063,
-0.3779550195,
-1.1203422546,
1.0503344536,
0.4258648753,
0.6660556793,
-0.4301457107,
0.6163414121,
0.2984960675,
0.4023631215,
0.0511478484,
0.213406831,
-0.4030023813,
-0.9134230018,
-0.2426736206,
-0.1419158429,
-0.6878335476,
-0.0163776428,
-0.6529417634,
0.1882498115,
-0.4192400277,
0.1124870703,
0.0595279299,
0.1546424031,
-0.5010091066,
0.0850313008,
-0.1223004758,
0.6427506208,
-0.9740254879,
0.3648848832,
0.6739070415,
-0.4057703316,
-0.6352028847,
-0.001213311,
0.1755928844,
-0.8685237169,
0.5442430377,
0.1549409479,
0.0012346286,
0.0447207354,
-0.8255236149,
-0.4098772407,
0.949773252,
-0.1131667122,
0.2234845012,
0.1736413538,
0.350671798,
0.8280438185,
0.1638565063,
0.675480783,
0.7750059366,
0.394043237,
-0.0048906161,
-0.9844104648,
-0.4780113101,
-0.071715191,
-0.3225898445,
0.0621790178,
-0.7715545893,
0.5892175436,
-0.2769205272,
-0.541262567,
0.1544234306,
0.418549031,
-0.01481927,
0.5892961025,
0.307086736,
0.469279319,
0.780656755,
-0.344430536,
0.6369795799,
0.2385552973,
0.4491700828,
0.6578355432,
-0.1051039249,
0.6335510015,
0.1483513713,
-0.7560383677,
0.6863951087,
0.6671665311,
-0.3562387824,
-0.0202204436,
0.657977283,
-0.518411994,
-0.3435021937,
-0.0701010749,
-0.2873619497,
0.9541419148,
0.6711779833,
0.1458581984,
-0.0343577377,
0.2484139949,
0.0529689603,
0.1238996089,
-0.2486658692,
0.7981135845,
-0.4861579537,
-0.7865246534,
0.4055294394,
-0.0879984498,
0.454218775,
-0.1909797788,
-0.1362395287,
-0.2120183557,
0.1166056544,
-0.3399475217,
-0.7942317724,
0.0985440463,
-0.0573806725,
0.2824921608,
-0.0122162793,
0.648512125,
-0.061159201,
-0.2610464096,
-0.1342990994,
0.6153478622,
0.3823915124,
0.0237591024,
-0.7252833843,
-0.2151292861,
-0.0163502432,
0.1284133792,
0.0211038403,
-0.0213599913,
-0.1291414797,
0.9548152089,
0.53481704,
-0.1549714655,
0.0225956254,
-0.1022560522,
0.575760603,
0.0480446331,
-0.1145749986,
-0.6933205128,
0.1760691255,
-0.1738053858,
-0.3625907004,
0.7315553427,
0.7682337165,
0.9005154371,
0.1286445856,
0.7421473861,
-0.2116058022,
0.1962747425,
-0.2276058942,
0.5742826462,
-0.2035765052,
0.3144357204,
-0.3732748926,
-0.6805281043,
-0.1273874342,
0.5148931742,
-0.3380133808,
0.2044224143,
0.5115671158,
0.5933424234,
0.0823352039,
0.3185500503,
0.2169389725,
-0.0475856289,
0.3845808804,
0.6198279262,
1.3650610447,
-0.581487298,
0.4777702391,
-0.1806432009,
-0.7193186283,
-0.0919260234,
-0.3365558684,
-0.9149125814,
-0.4875492156,
-0.7083113194,
-0.4935583472,
0.0015203834,
0.3647768795,
0.3866692781,
-0.844871819,
-0.1416835636,
-0.1395311952,
0.1383600384,
-0.567745924,
-0.4697984755,
0.5775437355,
-0.5386897326,
-0.6216298342,
0.2564075887,
-0.1829795837,
0.2188172787,
-0.3195780218,
0.1510661542,
0.3275492191,
-0.1310906559,
0.4826687872,
0.2023955584,
-0.528693378,
-0.5423258543,
0.1755117476,
-0.1827339977,
0.024861997,
0.7603824735,
-0.8212114573,
0.3887645304,
0.5589751601,
0.6994107962,
0.2866476774,
0.3981893957,
0.0455064029,
-0.5068740845,
-0.322978884,
0.3424063921,
-0.0296530072,
0.1247109324,
-0.5414505005,
0.6159598827,
0.5077409148,
-0.8678218126,
-0.6907457113,
-0.0222197231,
-0.9371086359,
-0.340693742,
0.652140975,
-0.2532917559,
0.3813170195,
-0.3663703203,
-0.2916932702,
-0.0809014887,
-0.1102797985,
1.107745409,
0.9129036069,
-0.5483365655,
0.1675738096,
-0.7604627013,
0.5378858447,
0.7289996147,
-0.7279437184,
-0.206743598,
0.5190888047,
0.2650567293,
0.4977574646,
0.4693135023,
-0.1120244041,
0.5961712003,
0.1527889073,
-0.1970409006,
0.0114025548,
-0.2874889374,
-0.1327244341,
0.3686611056,
0.0565875769,
-0.4003829062
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.