id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14505v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14505v1
|
Analysing the Impact of Removing Infrequent Words on Topic Quality in LDA Models
| 2023-11-24T14:20:12 | 2023-11-24T14:20:12 |
Victor Bystrov, Viktoriia Naboka-Krell, Anna Staszewska-Bystrova, Peter Winker
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
An initial procedure in text-as-data applications is text preprocessing. One
of the typical steps, which can substantially facilitate computations, consists
in removing infrequent words believed to provide limited information about the
corpus. Despite popularity of vocabulary pruning, not many guidelines on how to
implement it are available in the literature. The aim of the paper is to fill
this gap by examining the effects of removing infrequent words for the quality
of topics estimated using Latent Dirichlet Allocation. The analysis is based on
Monte Carlo experiments taking into account different criteria for infrequent
terms removal and various evaluation metrics. The results indicate that pruning
is beneficial and that the share of vocabulary which might be eliminated can be
quite considerable.
|
[
-0.7411279082,
-1.0766634941,
0.3685301542,
0.0880273581,
-0.893250227,
-0.009758017,
0.0251143277,
-0.075979799,
0.337751776,
0.3909344375,
-0.3575712442,
-0.2808244824,
-0.6058332324,
0.022718912,
-0.8157398701,
1.1706588268,
0.1615408808,
-0.1726886779,
-0.2806660533,
0.0555785894,
-0.7626621127,
-0.5114013553,
-0.4664230049,
-0.0914692432,
0.5078575611,
0.6482235789,
0.6269128323,
0.4754710495,
0.7734000683,
0.1599465311,
-0.6955003738,
-0.0733505562,
-0.7760148644,
-0.1692954451,
-0.2327040732,
-0.2655794322,
-0.536264956,
0.2388506532,
0.9231515527,
1.0478297472,
-0.2293196172,
-0.0950353816,
0.3972314596,
0.6136001945,
-0.6430209875,
-0.4395778775,
-0.6658648849,
-0.0530411862,
-0.4463249147,
-0.4882597625,
-0.071097225,
-0.1102378368,
0.4472604096,
-0.3426314294,
0.4631837606,
-0.2919082344,
1.3017560244,
0.0880840942,
-0.0269321389,
-0.4143614471,
-0.7293503284,
0.8254857659,
-0.6195525527,
-0.0067105861,
0.5463260412,
-0.4671465755,
-0.2951243222,
-0.5015842319,
-0.5817502141,
0.1389428079,
-0.1703104526,
0.1032617539,
-0.0662981868,
0.1360078007,
0.1307982355,
0.4498958886,
-0.5190255642,
0.1199130937,
-0.736615777,
-0.1224744245,
0.4844878912,
0.0747525394,
0.2696549594,
-0.4913525283,
-0.1343191713,
0.2205341309,
-0.9899801016,
-0.1189253777,
0.5878199935,
0.121625416,
0.305075109,
0.7580828071,
0.0781820044,
0.744651258,
-0.2441612184,
-0.0790360719,
0.001668739,
-0.5816357136,
-0.021852605,
-0.0507030524,
0.3905377686,
0.3505679071,
-0.0429090708,
-0.2459401935,
-0.4837932289,
0.0951142758,
0.2008850127,
-0.8035762906,
-0.2529334128,
0.3963728845,
-0.5603485703,
-0.0633982345,
0.0142451171,
-0.9333730936,
-0.0193514246,
-0.0968137905,
0.571036756,
-0.4784075022,
-0.1203179285,
-0.2057242543,
-0.1644116342,
0.0042477371,
0.4302811623,
-0.5308647752,
0.4115330577,
0.7600675225,
0.9011046886,
-0.5397878885,
0.1558329612,
-0.4502559006,
0.0819913149,
-0.5664522648,
0.7872456908,
-0.5004241467,
-0.9485026002,
-0.4906350374,
-0.2143958062,
-0.0125797233,
-0.5855890512,
0.68423599,
-0.4851143658,
0.3181536794,
-0.1421436965,
-1.0478484631,
0.0255461819,
-0.1667082906,
-0.6442584991,
0.4660961032,
-0.1758572459,
-0.867619276,
0.4787826538,
-0.2873403728,
-0.5615343451,
-0.0934798792,
-0.0688697472,
-0.4439921081,
0.1025456861,
0.144863829,
0.5089487433,
-0.3888483942,
0.4113869667,
0.1662488133,
-0.6345581412,
0.2878008187,
-0.3921521008,
0.3828552961,
0.6324282289,
0.221416533,
0.106781967,
-0.6845657229,
-0.3446442783,
-0.1914008707,
-0.0175576266,
-0.5600004792,
0.2100156397,
-0.0238465555,
0.0496119,
-0.0534054674,
-0.4967373013,
-0.2198807597,
-1.1045637131,
0.3232872486,
0.7199736238,
0.5025375485,
0.6534054279,
-0.280374378,
0.5100212097,
0.1078711972,
-0.0599065274,
0.1263000369,
-0.511262536,
-0.510319531,
-0.5323674679,
0.6036109328,
0.3439203799,
-1.0168747902,
0.2604156435,
-0.1192101538,
-0.4194251299,
-0.1534988731,
0.0267225094,
0.3905873597,
0.5219274163,
-0.0110672899,
-0.6052356958,
0.1863220781,
-0.7329408526,
-0.0681066215,
0.088909477,
-0.0669648573,
-0.158428818,
0.4932254851,
0.2655651271,
1.4996647835,
-0.6920577288,
-0.2853586972,
-0.2960736454,
0.3138260543,
0.2497852445,
0.7579044104,
0.5276831985,
-1.092679739,
-0.1185612381,
-0.6462962627,
-0.277821213,
0.131858021,
0.036482621,
-0.1351083815,
-0.0048476527,
0.3399781883,
-0.5997817516,
0.7486857772,
0.2981257141,
-0.1585584283,
0.3267807662,
-0.3403370976,
-0.0107266689,
-0.8924245238,
0.0796885788,
0.2992188931,
0.2174570411,
-0.8557000756,
-0.0444564261,
-0.2166244835,
-0.3825834095,
-0.4149993658,
0.7694547176,
-0.2339414656,
-0.112758182,
-0.492726028,
0.5086214542,
0.1444303393,
0.1514546722,
0.2412173748,
1.0708082914,
0.1840429753,
-0.9853128195,
-0.2476072311,
0.0703757927,
-0.3608180285,
0.1252767593,
-0.6496217847,
-0.2469127178,
-0.3532092273,
-0.1697327495,
-1.1276344061,
0.3035986722,
0.4690022767,
-0.3840758502,
0.2913325727,
0.0742020532,
-0.6381736398,
0.0023157189,
-0.2642588913,
0.0884275958,
0.2777250409,
-0.0689243302,
-0.092109032,
0.6991109848,
-0.5321381688,
-0.3045366108,
-0.1425498873,
-0.1695456505,
-0.7431228161,
-0.1655109972,
0.6006966233,
-0.147851333,
-0.3776901364,
0.2734255791,
-0.1343815476,
-0.6250577569,
0.3776783943,
0.0851061717,
0.2611241341,
0.3208671212,
0.7089166045,
0.2543316185,
-0.2741959691,
-0.0904560089,
0.3756918013,
0.4714948535,
0.3038524985,
-0.2808323801,
-0.3843931854,
0.099862434,
-0.0692484453,
-0.4106816351,
0.8002617359,
0.3712405264,
-0.4625484347,
-0.1282542795,
-0.07191322,
-0.5590485334,
-0.4040133655,
0.3377462626,
-0.4471906424,
-0.6135318279,
0.4318462312,
-0.022895867,
0.1145706177,
0.6348564625,
0.021718787,
-0.2960129976,
0.4858680964,
0.6192831397,
0.1259314418,
0.5693894029,
-0.3161627352,
0.4766389728,
-0.6192469597,
0.2060053945,
-0.7975538373,
0.1584732085,
-0.5722684264,
-0.4448248148,
0.2107443213,
0.3844839334,
0.4576005638,
0.0714873299,
-0.5786755085,
0.1753757894,
0.3089043796,
0.2597092688,
0.1233787462,
0.2589016855,
0.3919837177,
-0.4585465491,
-0.8213062882,
-0.7596738935,
0.962385118,
0.3805610538,
0.3210059702,
-0.1173557118,
0.756644845,
0.1844297349,
0.4610165656,
-0.7002859712,
0.651753962,
-0.5351173878,
-0.5711915493,
-0.7674764991,
-0.6216859221,
-0.865381062,
0.3146874309,
-0.2292010188,
-0.7909336686,
0.2035689801,
-0.0646153837,
-0.5963954329,
0.2595980167,
-0.4551373422,
0.617595911,
0.2258418649,
-0.5239697099,
-0.7283191681,
-0.2928867042,
0.3157541454,
-0.5630246997,
0.2594842911,
-0.4451095462,
0.0150486799,
1.3660489321,
-0.7365542054,
0.2893217206,
-0.1624746472,
-0.3042200804,
0.6857404113,
-0.1577627957,
0.2406746745,
0.1440637261,
-0.1912725121,
-0.0605665445,
0.3113536239,
-0.3141998947,
-0.5388564467,
0.5197036266,
-0.5249897838,
-0.6574060321,
-0.4933117628,
-0.1931503415,
-0.2672042847,
-0.1076253951,
0.2143134922,
0.5936231613,
-0.3312007189,
0.0321443938,
0.7575204968,
-0.704420805,
0.4050318897,
0.3794653714,
-0.0561290607,
-0.0187178776,
1.4731173515,
0.7171962857,
0.0921964869,
0.3820382953,
0.132854417,
-0.0844276473,
-0.9038514495,
-0.0955961496,
0.3012223542,
-0.6718921661,
0.1166851223,
-0.6693733931,
-0.2785703838,
-0.0026147284,
-0.1086506099,
-0.2090838104,
-0.4666830301,
-0.7564689517,
0.016284883,
0.3460584581,
0.1654184461,
0.0680767,
0.8035292029,
-0.7941554785,
0.5102876425,
0.0552401654,
0.1160442308,
-0.0073810369,
-0.7975895405,
-0.1525317132,
-0.1266330779,
0.0167388972,
-0.683886826,
0.6661117077,
0.0839344785,
0.5608577132,
0.5062358379,
0.0334217995,
0.8369659185,
-0.2004648596,
0.7841190696,
0.1178943142,
-0.9577818513,
0.5826703906,
-0.1616734862,
0.0422770418,
0.5594103336,
0.3806321919,
-0.1630279422,
-0.4062637091,
-0.9375690818,
-1.1143754721,
0.5592920184,
0.4653771222,
0.2001123428,
-0.2076778412,
0.8002523184,
0.1999116838,
0.6675514579,
-0.0432721823,
-0.3947313428,
0.1976966262,
0.1695877463,
-0.4046458304,
-0.78226161,
0.1420968026,
-0.329416573,
0.7684354186,
0.4212305844,
0.1714891791,
-0.0223633014,
-0.1524862647,
0.1722923368,
0.3854996562,
0.4944243729,
1.0736807585,
-0.4816904962,
-0.2568378747,
0.0139546925,
-0.5813251734,
0.0165826473,
-0.0771694779,
-0.2285892814,
0.3074860573,
0.3675919473,
0.1210433021,
0.0510758534,
-0.7332055569,
0.4064777493,
-0.0877391025,
0.4340653718,
0.0767760128,
-0.0948822051,
-0.2542515993,
-0.5307956934,
0.4111391902,
-0.1066637337,
0.2842469513,
-0.5104593039,
0.580224812,
0.3763564825,
-0.4886661768,
-0.1106442511,
0.1392734498,
0.3006847203,
0.1761672795,
0.6682975292,
-0.3153502643,
-0.1678686738,
0.9458375573,
0.0673194826,
0.4313970506,
0.040209908,
0.4698019028,
0.2888584137,
0.2719685137,
0.2167064101,
0.3215340078,
0.3555991948,
-0.911819458,
-0.3930722177,
-0.8446806073,
-0.3029740155,
-0.0568412878,
-0.4376628995,
0.127073735,
-0.268792212,
-0.3622299433,
0.2071944177,
0.4476262033,
-0.4017806351,
0.5767096877,
-0.5061177015,
0.5347738862,
-0.8121736646,
1.1088945866,
0.548350513,
-0.566891849,
-0.7916998267,
0.3576249182,
-0.1750696301,
0.062004067,
0.8447036743,
-0.1159014255,
0.026819976,
0.1416486353,
-0.1527430266,
-0.7139796615,
0.4694480002,
0.1786317676,
-0.4948455989,
0.2609792948,
-0.112192601,
0.5189065337,
0.0641750842,
0.0492220074,
0.4880951941,
0.2458440214,
0.1057055667,
-0.7268240452,
-0.350725919,
-0.1050570458,
-0.0465392694,
0.205101639,
-0.3226950467,
1.2745136023,
0.0587862618,
-0.5209104419,
0.2872662544,
0.7617763877,
0.113549754,
0.3988210857,
0.4864178598,
0.2058607042,
0.6376707554,
-0.0983656123,
0.7544603944,
-0.3896015286,
0.2858683765,
0.8506912589,
-0.3918490708,
0.6678491235,
0.6896247268,
-0.2725451291,
-0.1075422466,
0.9521231055,
0.4654414952,
0.8677472472,
0.3923368454,
-0.1556438506,
0.1724155545,
-0.465477258,
-0.2795133889,
0.4763835669,
0.877709806,
-0.0587879978,
-0.1838631779,
0.2145747095,
0.0471829437,
0.2045986652,
-0.3480842412,
0.6262492537,
0.2210366875,
-0.406716466,
0.1666056663,
0.3431792557,
0.6520310044,
-0.4980106354,
-0.2807287276,
-0.4962588251,
-0.1095380485,
-0.0851145536,
-0.896325469,
0.6170583963,
-0.1070359647,
-0.104619287,
-0.1977696866,
0.8966135383,
-0.2200045586,
-0.2752932012,
0.2358293086,
0.9071910977,
0.5406610966,
-0.0884039029,
-0.5064179897,
0.0205658395,
-0.1513203979,
-0.243475914,
0.4659316242,
0.6017337441,
-0.162299782,
0.5862202048,
0.5032501817,
0.4654693902,
-0.5015211105,
-0.1018872261,
1.0480866432,
-0.5072349906,
-0.6301103234,
-0.6555691361,
0.2071730942,
0.003592483,
-0.3158542514,
0.9416850805,
0.4950826764,
0.5154765844,
0.2630830705,
0.2946835756,
0.0031094877,
0.7419432998,
-0.6666169763,
0.9369600415,
-0.644823432,
0.694578588,
-0.8402548432,
-0.9271407723,
-0.049871482,
0.5002564788,
-0.529974699,
-0.1487316489,
0.4674278498,
0.8388536572,
0.0501358137,
-0.0314581655,
0.4955997467,
-0.2087002248,
0.193038553,
-0.1229097098,
0.5852737427,
-0.221851781,
0.0342385247,
-0.6930741668,
-0.1309112608,
-0.0466634035,
-0.5904727578,
-0.5348230004,
-0.7208072543,
-0.4040003121,
-0.0242347289,
0.4350630045,
0.6053360701,
0.2243906409,
-0.7086187601,
-0.341919899,
0.1384461671,
0.6306948066,
-0.0936001092,
-0.2748742402,
0.9648489356,
-0.0423218757,
-0.6365969181,
0.1160334051,
0.0905137286,
-0.0479205102,
-0.0663728639,
0.0995621458,
-0.4562957883,
0.0459685549,
0.636410892,
-0.0023367757,
-0.4943172634,
-0.1062466577,
-0.454575032,
-0.1774613857,
-0.0519153513,
0.7695774436,
-0.809540689,
0.3486666977,
0.5354459286,
0.162112534,
0.0470684767,
0.4252125025,
0.5726072192,
-0.8155732751,
0.6555908322,
0.3052925169,
0.0001973469,
0.0963564143,
-0.2787191868,
0.472099781,
0.3610213697,
-0.1386031955,
-0.9529150128,
-0.2220721245,
-0.3007878065,
-0.7999055982,
0.8826208711,
-0.1267740279,
-0.1060752198,
-0.069088921,
-0.1312980205,
0.3762415946,
-0.40815413,
0.5850043893,
0.9128629565,
-0.0491951555,
-0.3398087919,
-0.6774392724,
0.6676597595,
0.6287764311,
-0.7489826083,
-0.2302267998,
0.519605279,
0.031563174,
0.0964080617,
0.9289688468,
-0.0503022224,
0.1809248179,
-0.2262848318,
-0.1678744704,
0.5874601603,
-0.4851181805,
-0.5323972106,
0.4556456804,
0.2942243814,
-0.0906638578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14495v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14495v4
|
StableSSM: Alleviating the Curse of Memory in State-space Models through Stable Reparameterization
| 2023-11-24T14:08:31 | 2024-06-05T05:15:16 |
Shida Wang, Qianxiao Li
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, math.DS
|
In this paper, we investigate the long-term memory learning capabilities of
state-space models (SSMs) from the perspective of parameterization. We prove
that state-space models without any reparameterization exhibit a memory
limitation similar to that of traditional RNNs: the target relationships that
can be stably approximated by state-space models must have an exponential
decaying memory. Our analysis identifies this "curse of memory" as a result of
the recurrent weights converging to a stability boundary, suggesting that a
reparameterization technique can be effective. To this end, we introduce a
class of reparameterization techniques for SSMs that effectively lift its
memory limitations. Besides improving approximation capabilities, we further
illustrate that a principled choice of reparameterization scheme can also
enhance optimization stability. We validate our findings using synthetic
datasets, language models and image classifications.
|
[
-0.1957082897,
-0.5828226209,
0.8060463667,
0.2050265819,
-0.3941153586,
-0.0863866135,
-0.2158246189,
-0.2316170931,
0.4629403353,
0.6598327756,
-0.5854334235,
-0.3557227552,
-0.3027073443,
-0.0959235057,
-0.3848272562,
0.9860560298,
-0.5219931602,
0.4464955032,
-0.4919877648,
-0.2355172336,
-0.521638155,
-0.5626918077,
-0.8160883784,
-0.0001179424,
0.538056314,
-0.2316374183,
0.5035688281,
1.0251088142,
0.3838350773,
0.3057268262,
0.1525831819,
0.1883163005,
-0.7717672586,
0.6680477262,
-0.0756959319,
-0.5891019702,
-0.0588853583,
-0.133398369,
1.1744632721,
0.7372943759,
-0.4857560396,
0.0921483114,
-0.233687982,
0.7123196721,
-0.8439418077,
0.0300866757,
-0.6924154758,
0.0869610906,
-0.0598515123,
-0.2382968515,
-0.5069823265,
-0.2631741464,
-0.0424073264,
-0.9714149237,
0.196822688,
0.3158904314,
1.0968939066,
0.5902402997,
0.0728778094,
0.2276242375,
-0.9816839099,
1.3012840748,
-0.4240355492,
0.6394582987,
0.2999922037,
0.4289427698,
-0.5976532102,
-0.6920498013,
0.1478628218,
-0.4165636003,
0.3788731396,
0.0511098094,
0.0363415033,
0.1245728657,
0.2930084169,
0.0805879831,
-0.0317587368,
0.1082282737,
-0.7325877547,
-0.3948403895,
0.0745507628,
0.5257703662,
0.1917283237,
0.0672906041,
-0.8981872201,
0.0988579988,
-0.671341002,
-0.1469174325,
0.078935869,
0.2865265906,
0.4999739826,
0.289542228,
0.0058809286,
0.6057195663,
-0.0786822662,
-0.0055121495,
-0.373944819,
0.0622527711,
0.0017778465,
-0.2266681492,
0.3622947037,
0.3476082385,
0.0321788825,
-0.6271381974,
-0.1897525191,
0.1721798778,
0.689048171,
-0.8900200129,
-0.0365780368,
0.0647483468,
-0.5259375572,
0.0889415517,
0.030533744,
-0.7138940692,
-0.244982034,
-0.0350324884,
0.3779843748,
-0.5711042285,
0.0169959459,
0.2144597024,
-0.4447825849,
0.0600277968,
0.3210900724,
-0.8842978477,
0.7607964873,
0.6150818467,
0.8898152113,
-0.4018291533,
-0.6079598069,
-0.3883763254,
0.3916243613,
-0.683011353,
0.3859246969,
-0.4347268343,
-0.4092652202,
-0.4362509847,
0.1571900249,
-0.0199238453,
-0.4676550031,
0.1016323268,
-0.677092135,
-0.2302441001,
-0.3426372409,
-0.6348305345,
-0.0916916132,
0.0079610599,
-0.8096451163,
1.0826117992,
0.2111560553,
-0.2612589002,
0.6572705507,
-0.0036738247,
-0.0356063545,
-0.3053284883,
-0.0085752141,
-0.5364832878,
0.4268817008,
-0.2325403988,
0.3460244536,
-0.003045276,
0.2393955141,
-0.5652784705,
-0.4300285876,
0.0196847357,
-0.1552646309,
0.1804012209,
0.232164517,
0.0889615268,
-0.03862698,
-0.6767584085,
0.0845082998,
0.1687879711,
-0.3197253346,
-0.7593324184,
0.4991494417,
-0.2855674624,
0.0450942852,
0.3556643426,
-0.434907198,
-0.0214634985,
-0.4833852053,
0.6715747118,
0.633605957,
0.1714009345,
0.5000416636,
-0.350507021,
0.4599991739,
0.341130048,
0.0895151794,
-0.2510327399,
-0.1917509139,
-0.8814911246,
-0.0399826244,
0.1069827452,
0.1894643307,
-0.5219168067,
0.0435664691,
-0.1311082542,
-0.3568252921,
-0.2336873263,
-0.0399493612,
0.4688355029,
0.5085359216,
0.6608264446,
-0.3827472627,
-0.709035635,
-0.9908384681,
-0.314085722,
-0.1609366387,
0.0816681236,
-0.1301123798,
0.6448529363,
0.2241916656,
0.8333339095,
-0.3030038774,
-0.0597340465,
0.309253484,
-0.2273139358,
-0.2210550308,
0.7526641488,
0.4816800058,
-0.4397896826,
0.3716778159,
-0.4155396819,
-0.5760191083,
0.4909923673,
-0.0778964534,
-0.0394158848,
0.4563556314,
0.405051738,
-0.8173021078,
0.5680218935,
0.1108640879,
-0.1145772934,
0.7251085043,
-0.4702558815,
0.0842271671,
-1.1003494263,
-0.1605011076,
0.3358644545,
-0.3029013574,
-0.3590340018,
0.4321097434,
0.0779727772,
-0.1878262013,
-0.3829329014,
0.5069764256,
-0.6765117049,
-0.3599543869,
-0.2549813688,
0.259736836,
-0.0481122434,
0.3458398581,
0.4001477659,
0.535235703,
0.4486140311,
-0.559314847,
0.2097219527,
-0.1495218724,
-0.0728576779,
0.2593199313,
-0.4831269979,
-0.1570146084,
-0.3079268336,
0.5137302876,
-1.0870373249,
0.0358704664,
0.1668134034,
-0.2358014882,
0.4060037732,
-0.346123606,
-0.1626985967,
-0.2063274831,
-0.3928838372,
0.3037092984,
0.5290889144,
-0.5124849081,
0.3722396493,
0.3243183196,
0.176949665,
-0.7160307765,
-0.5368097425,
0.0032913906,
-0.3997165561,
-0.1445539743,
0.3763414323,
0.2868674099,
-0.1018473059,
0.146024093,
-0.4823644161,
-0.0077337823,
-0.0806682184,
0.4885285199,
0.4975556433,
-0.3044440448,
0.2670651972,
0.1802616566,
-0.4845703244,
0.1409949958,
-0.7135934234,
0.4025708437,
-0.322581321,
-0.2124889195,
-0.360057354,
0.0433183834,
0.61221838,
0.1395309716,
1.0189284086,
0.1869777739,
-0.720912993,
-0.3711044788,
-0.5510706306,
-0.3601736128,
-0.4507997632,
0.5985638499,
-0.2164339125,
-0.9880849123,
0.7608067989,
-0.3926309049,
0.0669262633,
0.3455201685,
0.2548195422,
-0.1280042231,
0.7994896173,
0.3637831509,
-0.3913363218,
0.1397086382,
-0.2096550912,
-0.2704597712,
-0.8719133139,
-0.0855327994,
-0.4180746377,
-0.4869410992,
-0.4818813503,
-0.5862324834,
-0.0394475795,
0.2511036396,
-0.6632730365,
0.4634998441,
-0.5416594744,
0.5629222989,
0.09532056,
0.3110665977,
-0.1206181273,
0.0441876948,
-0.0931723192,
-0.5885522962,
-0.7090190649,
-0.3862410188,
0.7393758297,
0.4432402849,
1.1371725798,
-0.4499429166,
0.8119997382,
-0.1062051728,
0.1227522492,
-0.781560421,
0.6866021156,
-0.1881284565,
-0.4898287356,
-0.6308823228,
-0.6427131891,
-1.0906375647,
0.2428415269,
-0.0643731281,
-0.8839557171,
0.3070178926,
0.2260895222,
-0.4684971869,
0.6245929599,
-0.344176203,
0.4905569851,
-0.1506154686,
-0.4522046745,
-0.4706167579,
-0.5721160173,
0.1701750606,
0.2000497133,
-0.0590174422,
-0.0258622263,
-0.7283383608,
0.9049764872,
-0.653416872,
0.7773650885,
-0.5388082862,
0.152848959,
0.1223175377,
0.230603978,
0.5693894029,
-0.0263245478,
-0.080713138,
0.0054572611,
0.3154782057,
-0.5834954381,
-0.8236314654,
0.9715130329,
-0.7568358779,
-0.6793105006,
-0.0843675286,
-0.2792116106,
-0.3834409118,
0.2728970945,
0.0701954961,
0.3651665449,
-0.2818185091,
0.2028710246,
0.7038946748,
-0.0767412409,
0.3237636685,
0.4220336378,
-0.4705335498,
-0.4841792881,
1.0456526279,
0.4931511283,
0.3111958504,
0.0687911585,
-0.0327254273,
-0.1231981516,
-0.6878557205,
-0.3956840038,
0.2279825658,
-0.6132310629,
-0.2726185024,
-0.0998405069,
-0.2772661746,
0.3253979385,
-0.2578309476,
-0.8938498497,
-0.8776524067,
-0.248680383,
-0.2239942402,
0.5430120826,
0.3421695828,
0.2176667452,
0.1718886644,
-0.5946714878,
0.2813801169,
-0.1555734575,
0.5625270009,
0.1535098702,
-0.4573498666,
-0.4714036882,
-0.0352522731,
-0.1697898507,
-0.7534796,
0.2658076882,
0.2189395428,
0.5281735063,
0.4857109785,
-0.1444237083,
1.1111979485,
-0.6332450509,
0.8709982038,
0.4034193456,
-0.550648272,
0.5049615502,
-0.4345053434,
0.0126716774,
0.6408861876,
0.3630068302,
-0.2762930989,
-0.7263793945,
-0.4516389966,
-0.905492425,
0.4386880994,
-0.2037680894,
0.4420262575,
-0.0914891586,
1.2226791382,
0.0814450458,
0.075744234,
-0.4067611396,
-0.3272651136,
-0.2265050709,
0.2455909997,
0.2496170104,
-0.1199797019,
-0.0139364311,
-0.3531726301,
0.6736388803,
0.1667749435,
0.0059982329,
0.0559619069,
0.0451601893,
-0.4844147861,
-0.0998161137,
0.6019483805,
0.822069943,
-0.0247178972,
0.0185576957,
0.4814040363,
-0.5136929154,
0.445476234,
-0.1414521933,
-0.2748965919,
-0.0854265019,
-0.1736775041,
0.9271023273,
0.911280334,
-0.2268411964,
0.0768169016,
0.1230911538,
-0.2303840816,
-0.4852908552,
0.327313602,
0.1656235307,
0.0991170183,
0.5146351457,
0.2908992767,
-0.1790376604,
-0.1174597815,
0.3693782687,
0.5743986368,
-0.5634176135,
-0.2227030396,
1.0382891893,
-0.3160426617,
-0.1357683837,
0.6604884863,
0.2637295425,
0.0127373524,
0.7387090921,
0.9246285558,
0.7029832602,
-0.4070492685,
0.0306595676,
0.6135662794,
0.2898799777,
-0.7008543015,
0.1194938421,
-0.025931539,
-0.7837838531,
-0.3580120206,
-0.7654079199,
-0.3389054835,
0.0564888678,
-1.1246072054,
0.0207915697,
-1.0577375889,
-0.7776460052,
-0.3684972227,
-0.0599106997,
-0.0527904443,
0.1810180396,
-0.2718015611,
0.8889906406,
-0.3698388636,
0.7708846331,
0.6541999578,
-0.3324553072,
-0.5041882992,
-0.2781772912,
-0.3186645508,
-0.9553761482,
0.5066638589,
0.0281747561,
-0.4201894403,
0.129477486,
-0.6459781528,
-1.0172580481,
1.0611338615,
0.6316902041,
-0.5092489123,
-0.0640792251,
-0.3108661473,
0.6202890873,
-0.2209464014,
-0.516005218,
0.4709740877,
0.4658387899,
-0.0602293946,
-0.4633156359,
0.2598207891,
-0.11161194,
0.45525226,
0.7369990349,
-1.0002516508,
0.618142724,
-0.4675920606,
-0.3169965446,
0.6180942059,
0.9317771792,
0.7477997541,
0.074676685,
0.3296838403,
0.9332718253,
0.3516435921,
-0.1814367771,
0.7445408106,
-0.4737657905,
0.3781041205,
0.9262080193,
-0.1192960143,
1.0945267677,
1.0782682896,
-0.4069468975,
0.6924399734,
0.6074708104,
-0.2348185927,
0.3198889792,
0.5604255199,
0.0616284907,
-0.4179031253,
0.4554807544,
-0.2780598402,
0.0063168816,
0.5486850142,
-0.3370551169,
-0.492881,
0.1855361015,
0.0870419219,
0.0673564002,
-0.4558784664,
0.3896919787,
0.4250707328,
-0.4516226053,
0.725489974,
-0.025698429,
0.3663364947,
-0.7602354884,
-0.0214065947,
0.0304379445,
0.080266729,
-0.0143952724,
-0.2012100071,
0.2909831703,
-0.3864538968,
-0.3075820208,
-0.0468736291,
0.9460865259,
-0.3837224245,
-0.4766295552,
0.4452579618,
0.2575640082,
0.3538047969,
0.3690464497,
-0.5273000002,
0.0742632747,
-0.7911430001,
-0.454988718,
0.681913197,
0.1422416419,
-0.2524743974,
1.0898970366,
0.235884577,
0.603035152,
0.091217652,
-0.254673034,
0.7540841699,
-0.8482707739,
-0.5408549309,
-0.8963530064,
0.0986370593,
0.2373812199,
-0.1110296622,
0.9216537476,
0.6489260793,
0.4490069151,
-0.1611154526,
0.5055361986,
0.3028949201,
0.3024668694,
-0.7055393457,
0.9205818772,
-0.5940642953,
0.2357889414,
-0.109109655,
-0.7703018785,
-0.2058505267,
0.4976164997,
-0.5844290853,
0.4115919173,
0.51235497,
0.8045129776,
0.1269102842,
-0.0352124982,
0.3985636234,
-0.0311955269,
-0.3302421272,
0.5852993727,
1.2370778322,
-0.4176713228,
0.2969193459,
-0.0436152667,
-0.041929286,
0.0422381796,
-0.6368992925,
-0.5149286389,
-0.8933175206,
-0.129259795,
-0.53583318,
0.4604977667,
0.5583953857,
0.8871874213,
-0.7159054279,
-0.2648047209,
-0.0770794526,
0.1056521907,
-0.2832837701,
-0.204300046,
0.3927433491,
-0.7104803324,
-0.3261905611,
0.3717037141,
0.609131217,
0.0297357757,
-0.7466455102,
-0.1938654929,
0.4190443456,
0.1075417176,
0.2846835256,
0.5462619662,
-0.8037797809,
-0.375277549,
-0.1296820492,
0.0764573067,
0.0479009859,
0.9931769967,
-0.8493437767,
0.4138654172,
-0.0173811968,
0.6409386396,
0.5372334123,
0.241467461,
0.5225369334,
-0.5853887796,
0.4108237028,
0.012584541,
0.4179593921,
0.0026711766,
-0.3911678493,
0.07263612,
0.2729340792,
-0.4971940517,
-0.7560136914,
0.1503942013,
-0.6156619787,
-0.4717514515,
0.7232553959,
-0.2196779251,
-0.6168298721,
-0.0956372619,
0.0858830661,
0.2229055166,
-0.3925049603,
1.0155762434,
0.720444262,
-0.1834912598,
-0.2035129964,
-0.5687167048,
0.7044017315,
0.4365962148,
-0.5032340288,
0.0928746611,
0.7457037568,
0.4713639617,
0.213032335,
0.6213570237,
-0.4043769836,
0.5063807368,
0.1635184884,
-0.2671904266,
-0.1276732087,
-0.4893157482,
-0.2471797466,
0.1232444197,
0.0131834913,
-0.2931261957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.00804v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.00804v1
|
Automatic detection of problem-gambling signs from online texts using large language models
| 2023-11-24T13:48:02 | 2023-11-24T13:48:02 |
Elke Smith, Nils Reiter, Jan Peters
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Problem gambling is a major public health concern and is associated with
profound psychological distress and economic problems. There are numerous
gambling communities on the internet where users exchange information about
games, gambling tactics, as well as gambling-related problems. Individuals
exhibiting higher levels of problem gambling engage more in such communities.
Online gambling communities may provide insights into problem-gambling
behaviour. Using data scraped from a major German gambling discussion board, we
fine-tuned a large language model, specifically a Bidirectional Encoder
Representations from Transformers (BERT) model, to predict signs of
problem-gambling from forum posts. Training data were generated by manual
annotation and by taking into account diagnostic criteria and gambling-related
cognitive distortions. Using k-fold cross-validation, our models achieved a
precision of 0.95 and F1 score of 0.71, demonstrating that satisfactory
classification performance can be achieved by generating high-quality training
material through manual annotation based on diagnostic criteria. The current
study confirms that a BERT-based model can be reliably used on small data sets
and to detect signatures of problem gambling in online communication data. Such
computational approaches may have potential for the detection of changes in
problem-gambling prevalence among online users.
|
[
-0.3649465144,
-0.8240920901,
0.4209333956,
0.2759944797,
-0.3839974105,
-0.4208147228,
-0.2756044865,
-0.6962610483,
0.5683357716,
0.6015987396,
-0.461835295,
-0.3165091276,
-0.872629106,
0.3018632233,
-0.568972528,
0.9797838926,
-0.0405929834,
0.2679206133,
-0.2303144336,
0.4371424615,
-0.3319911361,
-0.5185358524,
-0.9126722813,
-0.1338691711,
0.3407420218,
0.0177932177,
0.3694897592,
0.2938011885,
0.8653407693,
0.3281897306,
0.0237191059,
0.092798546,
-0.6446736455,
0.0126829529,
0.0792703778,
-0.4429800212,
-0.3591560423,
-0.2715069652,
0.0986878425,
0.1268659234,
-0.0726231933,
0.0988065526,
0.1881927103,
0.3424984217,
-0.2547057867,
0.4118559659,
-0.5506822467,
0.0446008332,
-0.4584438205,
-0.3445814252,
-0.5215432048,
-0.5778403878,
0.0354816578,
-0.6844556332,
0.1991591454,
-0.1189744323,
0.9782573581,
0.3450064957,
-0.2795887291,
-0.8402031064,
-0.8678992987,
0.4827081263,
-0.7893130779,
0.2837291956,
0.7312124968,
0.3158682585,
-0.3456602693,
-0.2807894945,
-0.7395072579,
-0.2442880869,
-0.4190301895,
-0.0611889437,
-0.4441750646,
0.0872602239,
0.3815943301,
-0.1156814024,
-0.4473179579,
0.0641035512,
-0.3810130358,
-0.2729870677,
0.6998476982,
0.01691732,
0.2746327221,
-0.2555313408,
-0.2197208107,
-0.0749985725,
-0.6395069957,
0.1195519418,
0.5930503011,
0.2766209245,
-0.1667692214,
0.4560183585,
0.2477891743,
0.6097396612,
0.3921528161,
-0.4009290934,
0.1823002547,
0.1668282747,
0.1078917459,
0.031652458,
0.7293397188,
0.3700596392,
0.5141531229,
0.1648120284,
-0.2797821462,
0.0901951268,
0.1040147319,
-0.530363977,
-0.4875344932,
0.1859174967,
-0.7421489358,
-0.5367866755,
0.0201808624,
-0.9466924071,
-0.7934865355,
-0.1742180139,
0.6713937521,
-0.2297774255,
-0.4121530056,
0.3005256951,
-0.2862538993,
0.1600456387,
0.2996410728,
-0.6667507887,
-0.0948890373,
0.4962382019,
0.5452994704,
-0.0780819952,
0.2805274725,
-0.5445299149,
0.0481750928,
-0.0562227033,
0.9892098904,
-0.475499928,
-0.0942793563,
0.4050630033,
-0.0445070826,
0.2958882749,
-0.320625037,
0.6844410896,
-0.6339033246,
0.0433595218,
0.0687445775,
-0.632756114,
0.0316764601,
0.5017191768,
-0.9914847612,
0.9911258221,
-0.3875643015,
-0.9122777581,
0.3661564589,
-0.7074201703,
-0.7718483806,
0.2297928482,
0.1916409433,
-0.600071907,
-0.0140615469,
0.3414241672,
0.4686334729,
-0.0857348368,
0.1473343968,
-0.3567814231,
-0.3610029519,
0.8387465477,
-0.5242179036,
0.6477584839,
-0.1454125643,
-0.5042627454,
-0.0737137944,
-0.5413219929,
-0.4200472534,
-0.0133255562,
-0.273645103,
-0.5877358317,
0.5003139377,
0.3943825066,
0.4369796216,
0.2749387622,
-0.7199829221,
0.0861274749,
-0.4213931561,
0.037062332,
0.5680684447,
0.0820370913,
-0.410540998,
-0.3723111749,
0.3536032736,
0.1281322688,
0.4092674255,
0.251486361,
-0.8481812477,
-0.8085098863,
-0.1603413224,
0.3703757524,
0.6994576454,
-1.0412793159,
0.8443619013,
-0.3525732756,
-0.4287930429,
-0.2750397623,
-0.3662214875,
0.1819496155,
0.0426824801,
0.3780218065,
-0.336279124,
-0.4306391478,
-0.7258538008,
-0.228420794,
-0.2478893697,
-0.1898440421,
0.2041106522,
0.3483715951,
-0.0791587308,
0.7243664861,
-0.5266074538,
-0.8613167405,
-0.0971614569,
0.611312449,
0.1273063719,
0.1742761284,
0.395919323,
-0.8332956433,
-0.8154960275,
-0.0376213863,
-0.448757112,
-0.1676583141,
-0.430214256,
0.082770139,
0.0577606894,
0.5732297897,
-0.1697525978,
0.4774473011,
0.5236508846,
-0.5894115567,
0.4934162796,
-0.2963498235,
0.1940446645,
-0.7517374754,
-0.0982155204,
0.3877978027,
-0.2855415344,
-0.8358427286,
-0.2306707054,
-0.1879379749,
0.1814443022,
-0.0302823223,
0.1524467319,
-0.1394808739,
0.0594028309,
-0.4213336706,
0.3186003864,
-0.4469741583,
0.3397371173,
0.332916379,
0.4006888568,
0.4665781558,
-0.3348103464,
0.3858416975,
0.2694824338,
-0.3456518948,
0.7410727143,
-0.3696677387,
0.0065406659,
-0.2548715174,
0.143144086,
-1.1689350605,
-0.1728902608,
0.4161521792,
-0.677957952,
0.2287360281,
-0.1394679993,
-0.45958215,
-0.449313879,
-0.0114494879,
0.1219674051,
0.5387201905,
-0.2675605714,
0.6770150661,
0.6193590164,
-0.1323762834,
-0.429359585,
-0.5697563291,
0.133896485,
-0.1600294858,
-0.6011050344,
0.1558844149,
0.1992489696,
0.026253663,
-0.1737709939,
0.4802764952,
-0.2428060025,
-0.051690165,
0.1449336708,
0.2738423049,
0.1472706795,
0.462241739,
-0.0598754808,
-0.2465286851,
0.3214498162,
-0.1510360539,
0.5700147152,
0.2867315114,
-0.2813425362,
-0.5563682914,
0.4350599945,
0.4382630587,
-0.3074710965,
0.7434027195,
0.6227796674,
-0.6689658761,
-0.0678654686,
-0.6087387204,
-0.388879478,
-0.5432374477,
0.2424435169,
-0.1204624847,
-0.849894762,
0.5554866791,
-0.0126271835,
-0.091215305,
0.5196290016,
0.6621310115,
-0.4185808599,
1.2067471743,
0.6228548884,
0.0966111347,
0.3383007348,
0.3062183559,
0.2853418589,
-0.0006839799,
-0.0965576991,
-0.557372272,
-0.3865378797,
-0.8459546566,
-0.4572370052,
0.5243934989,
-0.2398424149,
0.0042379899,
0.4491505623,
-0.4177576303,
0.4463690519,
0.1954221576,
0.405338645,
0.3127703965,
0.18827492,
0.0351507068,
-0.3880313933,
-0.4826605618,
-0.4303444028,
1.1922159195,
0.3413360119,
0.5743646622,
0.1523065716,
0.6302110553,
0.7338351011,
0.733271718,
-0.6276735067,
0.2975816429,
-0.3642282784,
-0.8641819358,
-0.4450166523,
-0.4427326322,
-1.036210537,
-0.4141125977,
-0.7338402867,
-0.616532743,
0.2075836509,
0.2824656367,
-0.4944472611,
0.5878557563,
-0.2636161149,
0.8285384774,
-0.3152784705,
-0.0868134052,
-0.3309094012,
-0.3892320693,
0.2817766368,
-0.4404739141,
0.6604846716,
-0.1011261344,
0.3711394072,
0.7224969864,
-0.0185848344,
1.0872939825,
-0.2802214622,
-0.4795852005,
0.1585878432,
0.103185825,
0.9059083462,
-0.2866053581,
0.2551980913,
0.1427760869,
0.0793558136,
-0.124736242,
-0.2621752322,
0.444942385,
-0.8189976811,
-0.0968360379,
-0.3634521365,
-0.1321355104,
-0.2104363739,
-0.0431514308,
0.2834219038,
0.3305476904,
-0.2298765779,
-0.1421997249,
0.6851450205,
-0.4703523517,
0.1771717072,
0.3794386685,
-0.2529439032,
-0.2247136384,
1.1727576256,
-0.3358697295,
-0.0906702653,
0.3031542003,
0.0855244473,
-0.3315244913,
-0.4165721238,
-0.2544303834,
0.4069294333,
-0.6538769603,
-0.2737313211,
-0.0711790398,
0.0459767804,
-0.0988393649,
-0.0617026612,
-0.2082771808,
-0.0427550599,
-0.233882755,
0.1543879658,
0.6298823357,
1.0500984192,
-0.2516267002,
0.509049356,
-0.8518574834,
0.2859303653,
0.4687363207,
0.6974198222,
-0.0577970445,
-0.4282448888,
-0.1846495569,
0.1188103706,
-0.0228312146,
-1.1975377798,
0.3838997781,
0.1540437937,
0.35576123,
0.7803843021,
0.1253061742,
0.4288207889,
-0.1563190371,
0.4608598948,
0.3838942647,
-0.8485737443,
0.2860401571,
-0.5983035564,
-0.34417364,
0.3540582657,
0.7461005449,
-1.0208861828,
-0.4223638773,
-0.3936559856,
-0.2956321836,
0.6811155081,
0.4001662433,
0.1121125966,
-0.0996791348,
0.3031795323,
0.0843589231,
-0.0221759751,
-1.1830587387,
-0.370318234,
-0.1363777667,
-0.345733434,
0.2659809291,
-0.1775571406,
-0.0205562115,
-0.2555539608,
0.7760847211,
-0.0423362255,
0.6992301941,
-0.0403757989,
-0.2146483958,
-0.5132154822,
-0.0174685903,
0.5126723051,
0.556242466,
-0.077643849,
-0.0050412687,
0.0970422626,
-0.6276731491,
0.143966198,
0.3106869161,
-0.3578799367,
0.1993268579,
0.282592535,
0.5466771722,
0.2838953137,
-0.8001310229,
0.9307722449,
-0.1191014871,
-0.2703287899,
-0.5695049167,
-0.2793040872,
0.069816567,
0.1576698869,
0.3784190416,
-0.0706237704,
0.1712853462,
-0.2518094778,
0.4713564217,
0.4559803605,
-0.6438414454,
-0.1150240824,
0.4390695393,
0.564101994,
-0.5229500532,
0.6375467181,
-0.4914558828,
-0.7777138352,
0.4786900878,
0.3309522867,
0.7111314535,
-0.0442858227,
0.395070672,
0.7165696621,
0.4442327023,
0.0349833257,
0.3789608479,
0.4610185027,
-0.8285588026,
-0.5641859174,
-0.7141586542,
-0.113535367,
0.145475015,
-0.674679637,
0.5322911739,
-0.2790492773,
-0.4922392368,
0.1023180112,
-0.3414012492,
-0.6127344966,
0.0292440858,
0.6932059526,
0.4989950359,
-1.1722679138,
0.6750122905,
0.4651785493,
-0.2413477451,
-0.3751840293,
0.2963331938,
-0.0692243502,
-0.5920087695,
0.4336882234,
0.1761756688,
0.193298474,
-0.0369042382,
-0.5164920092,
-0.8113989234,
0.5662105083,
-0.1251291484,
-0.8282202482,
0.0662425235,
0.607857585,
0.7517578602,
-0.1166355386,
0.2237347215,
0.6425165534,
0.6352390051,
-0.0145700118,
-1.2065434456,
-0.0855184942,
-0.0412888192,
-0.3976493478,
0.7913797498,
-0.0990956128,
0.6096917391,
0.347748518,
-0.2836607695,
-0.2701786757,
0.4148028791,
-0.0645953566,
-0.0764497668,
0.6923733354,
0.4372084737,
0.6874063611,
-0.3693946004,
0.5647521019,
-0.3996103406,
0.6093830466,
0.4735930264,
-0.0824979767,
1.0294184685,
0.0882704258,
-0.3393416107,
0.8006593585,
0.4805552661,
-0.2514179945,
0.2267697155,
0.3167646825,
-0.1294876933,
-0.8539772034,
0.1942755133,
-0.138156116,
0.5689668059,
0.7653612494,
-0.3364120424,
-0.4209599793,
0.4048946202,
-0.0640720055,
0.1233119592,
-0.4459013939,
0.8423051238,
-0.2786323428,
-0.4882989228,
0.252900213,
0.2710798681,
1.1732369661,
-0.6119593978,
-0.1282462925,
-0.0227617528,
0.3590826094,
0.158079654,
-0.7365423441,
0.2597797513,
0.1379910707,
0.3169670701,
-0.1320965588,
1.0479825735,
-0.5585311055,
-0.8265944719,
0.1986267269,
0.3222952187,
0.4410330057,
-0.1948362887,
-0.7351582646,
-0.1884062737,
-0.0401053466,
0.2501104176,
0.2399262488,
0.4701844454,
-0.0379395783,
0.4790509641,
0.7822799087,
0.0573493317,
-0.0521251746,
-0.1853357702,
0.6208854914,
-0.448212713,
-0.7256785035,
-0.6208040118,
0.3520480096,
-0.2636733353,
-0.3588534296,
0.6889908314,
0.3308251202,
0.683663249,
-0.2763947248,
0.7767495513,
-0.0969189107,
0.5315034986,
-0.2491862029,
1.0048360825,
-0.3428096175,
-0.0719658658,
-0.2257275134,
-0.5049140453,
-0.414481461,
0.7551072836,
-0.5099397302,
-0.1701177508,
0.2423212975,
0.6606013775,
0.0834582672,
0.0557083376,
0.1629731953,
0.110365957,
0.1985750198,
0.4800655544,
0.6927332282,
-0.3385650814,
0.8913418651,
-0.1333627999,
-0.2304074913,
-0.6927965283,
-0.8555159569,
-1.2068146467,
-0.5675939322,
-0.330008477,
-0.3880932033,
-0.2223922014,
1.0189868212,
0.1975854188,
-1.0757808685,
-0.3316535056,
0.1820692718,
-0.18824175,
-0.3813542128,
-0.2315697372,
0.4535841048,
-0.1665309519,
-0.3679281771,
-0.2479198426,
0.0952723548,
0.1776438951,
-0.6352025867,
0.0973446295,
-0.3501250148,
0.2678166032,
0.6074251533,
0.1572500616,
-0.7598736882,
-0.3901787996,
0.1004709601,
-0.2451818883,
0.034509249,
0.838809371,
-0.4435743392,
0.6154850125,
0.4551862776,
0.2747255564,
0.6951260567,
-0.1351674646,
0.4001139998,
-0.7363097668,
0.0073113744,
0.3235948086,
0.172462061,
0.2809770405,
-0.5125659704,
-0.160322383,
0.2982879579,
-0.3222376704,
-0.4700612724,
-0.144169122,
-0.5917497277,
-0.3467851579,
1.0434209108,
-0.1004457995,
-0.1201831922,
-0.6070545912,
-0.2401502281,
0.264420867,
-0.1009242609,
1.2979850769,
0.8627516627,
-0.0764956325,
0.109592244,
-0.4439898431,
1.082801342,
-0.0046324665,
-0.9643434286,
0.2433682531,
0.6160185933,
0.1332095265,
0.2900715172,
0.4332045615,
0.1882512122,
0.3986136615,
-0.0273966696,
0.2687860727,
0.0810547322,
-0.0962362438,
-0.2011637688,
0.1586845964,
-0.1935512275,
0.1861986518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14483v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14483v2
|
SER_AMPEL: a multi-source dataset for speech emotion recognition of Italian older adults
| 2023-11-24T13:47:25 | 2023-12-14T15:39:04 |
Alessandra Grossi, Francesca Gasparini
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
In this paper, SER_AMPEL, a multi-source dataset for speech emotion
recognition (SER) is presented. The peculiarity of the dataset is that it is
collected with the aim of providing a reference for speech emotion recognition
in case of Italian older adults. The dataset is collected following different
protocols, in particular considering acted conversations, extracted from movies
and TV series, and recording natural conversations where the emotions are
elicited by proper questions. The evidence of the need for such a dataset
emerges from the analysis of the state of the art. Preliminary considerations
on the critical issues of SER are reported analyzing the classification results
on a subset of the proposed dataset.
|
[
-0.6440244317,
-0.1508217603,
0.0454650111,
-0.0579630509,
-0.109680824,
-0.3362414539,
-0.0164606851,
-0.4676567316,
0.3799094856,
0.2286053002,
-0.405144304,
-0.1158849224,
-0.5191857815,
0.2359521538,
-0.3400134444,
0.7845436931,
0.1124543026,
0.6578292251,
0.2257470042,
-0.5397101045,
0.0855505243,
-0.6100777984,
-1.1191226244,
-0.0182392877,
0.6673773527,
0.6143299341,
0.0116365785,
-0.0558224283,
0.5309016705,
0.3510845006,
0.0751911327,
0.1434967369,
-0.3708008528,
0.4199172258,
0.2177190632,
-0.2950816154,
-0.4549922645,
-0.0479572825,
0.7393609285,
0.1505288184,
0.0924108475,
-0.0284590051,
-0.3984324336,
0.9447154999,
-0.8465203643,
0.0473312512,
-0.2832428813,
0.2095760405,
-0.2683238983,
-0.3426225483,
-0.3220929503,
-0.6360034943,
0.3277474344,
0.3092588186,
0.1641804427,
0.0906942412,
0.4454784691,
0.279384613,
-0.6284344792,
-0.5005164742,
-0.7227294445,
0.408860743,
-0.7899417281,
0.412997663,
0.4479933679,
0.569686532,
0.2327361256,
-0.5667738318,
-0.5817193389,
-0.0406330004,
0.1307233423,
0.0074031632,
-0.3549968302,
-0.1161164865,
0.0087482929,
0.6391358972,
-0.3477500975,
-0.0497581735,
-0.4750409126,
-0.2810004652,
0.7724077106,
-0.0916998684,
0.3309150934,
-0.2512551546,
-0.0207229406,
-0.0077962666,
-0.6569095254,
0.1015776843,
0.5836714506,
0.4216524959,
-0.2712687254,
0.5962401628,
-0.1851116121,
0.4850637615,
-0.1533152163,
0.1756677032,
0.7457558513,
0.0923217312,
0.1290494651,
0.6940776706,
0.9217255116,
0.2441888601,
0.5652009249,
0.0472468361,
0.0179959517,
-0.2425446808,
0.2147475183,
-0.6464377046,
-0.0354763716,
0.634632647,
-0.3279228806,
0.1811228096,
0.3155066967,
-1.4775717258,
-0.6220813394,
-0.3700081706,
0.2081542164,
-0.3414025009,
-0.1015096381,
-0.221308887,
-0.0383959785,
0.1871118248,
0.1049923226,
-0.7544269562,
0.2777660787,
0.1755900383,
0.6787391305,
-0.2025856823,
0.0078256465,
-0.7795075178,
-0.1760411859,
0.0127490535,
0.7947933078,
-0.5050631166,
-0.5352695584,
0.0358706377,
0.531436801,
-0.1518884599,
-0.274728626,
1.1563692093,
-0.1193459183,
0.546965003,
0.0083169742,
-0.46682024,
-0.1783327311,
-0.1404459327,
-0.8473361135,
0.5009611845,
-0.1582732797,
-0.7332942486,
-0.1048297063,
-0.4620632827,
-0.4503369331,
-0.1262732148,
-0.1784467399,
-0.5495186448,
0.4465740025,
0.0331015028,
0.2976602018,
-0.2901442945,
-0.0509495959,
-0.2578007579,
-0.041170869,
0.2904868424,
-0.6186342835,
0.5221085548,
0.730586648,
-0.2319107056,
-0.1369048804,
-1.3658001423,
0.0267259441,
-0.3347510397,
-0.0068235579,
-0.4461269081,
0.2411605269,
-0.1913322508,
0.0989304855,
0.4095796943,
-0.7841385007,
-0.1386316717,
-0.2245736867,
0.3241884112,
0.6364691257,
0.1194239631,
0.2707715929,
-0.0043968791,
0.3504268229,
-0.0014569163,
0.1405630112,
-0.2770576775,
-0.3280058205,
-0.9187654853,
-0.069209747,
0.1065426469,
0.5842556357,
-0.4278225601,
0.4742347598,
0.1289099455,
-0.5028443336,
-0.8179027438,
-0.7083227634,
0.3045319319,
0.5180339813,
0.1834731698,
0.0365225635,
-0.8639863133,
-0.8993576765,
0.3336142302,
-0.0103912838,
0.0082869176,
0.9432160854,
0.2931828201,
-0.2113532126,
0.6841357946,
-0.1409184933,
-0.2784878314,
0.1915670484,
0.8168700933,
-0.0112446202,
0.7166096568,
0.4605983198,
-1.1037625074,
-0.2147410959,
0.3055019677,
-0.7061636448,
-0.1652347296,
0.3672208786,
0.0388700552,
0.0887092799,
-0.1449823529,
-0.2218148857,
0.2742228806,
0.7252120972,
-0.2259649932,
0.4708448946,
-0.2895443439,
0.7535837889,
-1.3523949385,
0.0862490013,
0.1045181453,
0.2012182623,
-0.7872127295,
-0.6184192896,
-0.0994640067,
-0.6419417262,
-0.8470308185,
0.4939853251,
-0.3160101473,
-0.495551765,
-0.2000673413,
-0.2685543001,
-0.2587763965,
0.5409445167,
0.2322845161,
1.0843293667,
0.8548169732,
-0.5171592832,
1.0443133116,
0.3052561581,
-0.2257024348,
1.0311338902,
-0.6250877976,
0.504109621,
-0.4427816272,
-0.2116959989,
-1.0567396879,
-0.5232689977,
0.0372102223,
-0.5788893104,
0.0643411651,
0.0584778227,
0.0874093473,
-0.2825267017,
0.0633874089,
0.2759593725,
0.2803987861,
-0.1245177537,
0.8455768228,
0.5441524982,
-0.7812126875,
-0.3932895362,
-0.5580416322,
-0.0890996754,
-0.4200473726,
-0.3904920816,
0.0699267909,
0.0763761699,
-0.212066099,
-0.0215148684,
0.0068186056,
-0.7129101157,
-0.4493842721,
0.4238162041,
0.028143879,
0.0048836996,
0.4047985971,
-0.1728694588,
-0.1245850548,
-0.2267546356,
0.4646958411,
0.4478990138,
-0.3280754685,
-0.2897405028,
-0.8207014203,
0.6904554963,
0.8433825374,
-0.2744731903,
0.3495082557,
0.654692471,
-0.474203527,
-0.0335300565,
-0.4711176753,
-0.1084315404,
-0.3473145962,
-0.0288009197,
-0.5046017766,
-0.639200747,
0.7976080179,
-0.2647612989,
-0.1330911368,
0.2664099634,
0.564711988,
-0.3592982292,
1.105471611,
0.2368580848,
-0.4714874625,
0.3882123828,
-0.0423712954,
0.0863185748,
-0.817058146,
-0.4248913229,
-1.3745104074,
-0.5933521986,
-0.4604614973,
0.186526075,
0.3318021894,
-0.6500262618,
-0.1902371198,
0.2384600043,
-0.2566413879,
0.0751413181,
0.4701696038,
0.0815910026,
0.070431821,
-0.0789837763,
0.2624723315,
-0.1206903458,
-0.2245558202,
-0.3678622246,
0.6320158839,
0.0590113997,
1.1345924139,
0.2236462533,
0.4963635206,
0.7350971103,
-0.2635522187,
-0.7766259313,
0.43001315,
-0.419446528,
-0.690836966,
-0.2565195262,
-0.7860084176,
-0.9339408278,
-0.1504376829,
0.0120347515,
-0.9250857234,
1.14245224,
-0.1222480908,
-0.3383281529,
0.0250474866,
-0.9752302766,
0.7934970856,
-0.6113910079,
-0.2064567208,
-0.0421797372,
-0.7832944989,
0.1178532839,
-0.0194984917,
0.2046502978,
-0.2889091969,
0.2496996969,
0.702195406,
-0.2660931349,
0.5711645484,
-0.1707931161,
0.1473298073,
0.2308882773,
-0.2321290672,
0.6023829579,
-0.1717778146,
-0.4831454158,
-0.1829935163,
-0.0232371613,
0.0189641733,
-0.4988352954,
0.6921380162,
-0.9036135077,
0.0589675903,
-0.6827144027,
-0.306756556,
-0.5052207112,
-0.1227394268,
0.3551380336,
0.9510455728,
-0.1514623165,
0.6949708462,
0.6458443999,
-0.2035412788,
0.3193379641,
0.6818348169,
0.4401235878,
-0.7183459997,
1.003657937,
0.0996943638,
0.0051381001,
0.16009444,
-0.0885036811,
-0.451312691,
-0.1586697996,
-0.0779048577,
-0.0545097739,
-0.5175359845,
-0.0830379575,
-0.3219356239,
-0.3045831621,
-0.5187650323,
0.2201666534,
-0.3440344036,
-0.2467523664,
-0.4067538381,
-0.0591898188,
0.3698358536,
0.2164070755,
-0.1981224418,
0.1987717301,
-0.9297796488,
0.4718938768,
0.7720688581,
0.4029166102,
-0.340639174,
-0.2494952232,
-0.1686216146,
0.1714531332,
0.0674846023,
-1.2193596363,
0.5610623956,
0.8439927101,
0.7850703001,
0.5877661109,
0.4275905788,
0.4180139899,
-0.5427923203,
0.7283094525,
0.0842083767,
-0.9689279795,
0.7949684262,
0.0239979886,
0.1533439457,
0.7538622022,
0.8586649895,
-0.5786863565,
0.1767721474,
-0.5476853848,
-0.5615162849,
0.7691860199,
0.2165376395,
0.064375706,
0.1462844461,
0.1832395196,
0.0902862996,
0.5156191587,
-0.3983525634,
-0.1893427223,
-0.0862817764,
-0.4695354998,
-0.0626442432,
-0.389593333,
-0.2055748254,
-0.164024964,
0.5546699762,
0.0356477089,
0.8356686234,
0.1985947937,
0.1209443957,
-0.2104877234,
0.5488035083,
0.4628293514,
0.2124591768,
-0.4942134321,
0.3861156404,
-0.0054011773,
-0.3266863823,
0.4815202653,
0.1988058239,
0.2076450288,
0.2652296424,
0.1199913025,
1.3088191748,
0.2695613205,
-0.9381992221,
0.3051216602,
-0.1115643233,
0.0947889984,
-0.4860147536,
-0.1202817783,
-0.4840869606,
0.4104443789,
0.6178197861,
0.1077743024,
0.5739808679,
-0.9529863,
0.6160292625,
-0.0142900432,
-0.7562494278,
-0.1958316118,
0.3126259446,
0.5280246735,
-0.6050773859,
0.5387818813,
-0.1860741973,
-0.5212634802,
0.5481223464,
0.1280698478,
1.207343936,
-0.7037540674,
0.3287068009,
0.4291933179,
-0.3294752538,
0.1703516841,
0.624930203,
-0.086981155,
-0.7791997194,
-0.2395074069,
-0.5980448127,
-0.8482896686,
-0.0649724305,
-0.8058359623,
0.2341483682,
-0.0133452974,
-0.419149369,
-0.2623962164,
-0.1463623792,
-0.0870050639,
0.3376924694,
0.3603642285,
0.5614474416,
-0.9425122142,
0.8707555532,
0.5708470345,
-0.3530509472,
-0.4437224865,
-0.4036143422,
0.1624711752,
-0.6404009461,
0.6705735326,
-0.1147943214,
-0.238467738,
0.321195811,
-0.3921643794,
-0.4701876938,
0.7990542054,
0.1682298332,
-0.5111414194,
-0.067963928,
-0.1538676322,
0.5740234852,
-0.6302872896,
0.1120343059,
0.4731557369,
0.4611651301,
0.4792277515,
-0.7757402658,
-0.7909949422,
-0.697037816,
-0.4672967494,
0.1687640697,
-0.6477436423,
0.9643377066,
0.1112462878,
-0.3007037342,
0.0918075368,
0.4644830823,
0.169750005,
0.466057539,
0.3737052381,
0.5200387239,
0.6783773899,
-0.5187934041,
0.7227974534,
-0.2854163647,
0.2923523486,
1.0255624056,
-0.5201447606,
0.8837229013,
0.2537922561,
-0.3422067761,
0.4507702291,
0.6088517904,
0.0530871861,
0.7987351418,
-0.114337787,
-0.5588876009,
0.1825100631,
-0.4176356494,
-0.6387416124,
0.562843442,
0.4674803317,
-0.2800005078,
-0.1710971296,
0.5934658647,
-0.0993126705,
-0.3355412483,
-0.4018902481,
1.0093820095,
-0.0085237836,
-0.2627615631,
0.295242548,
-0.7048420906,
0.3525156975,
-0.7867043018,
0.0145811159,
-0.181586355,
0.0426358916,
-0.2938887775,
-0.6154059172,
0.2873430252,
0.4149657488,
0.0601483956,
0.132677123,
0.6685931087,
-0.6607744098,
-0.4446648657,
-0.1163488925,
0.2795682251,
0.7509041429,
0.0354908966,
-0.5634637475,
0.3472302258,
-0.0756899118,
-0.0615191758,
-0.0340629965,
0.7436867952,
0.6475032568,
0.6464127898,
0.1707866937,
0.4178570211,
0.2164625823,
0.3162011802,
0.4081685543,
-0.4769336283,
-0.4514495134,
-0.1631412357,
0.8939962983,
-0.3205722272,
-0.4746721387,
0.59600842,
0.2894679308,
0.0875908062,
-0.0119245015,
0.7872290015,
-0.4078921676,
0.6685051322,
-0.4812504351,
0.2978688478,
-0.6080722213,
-0.2358493507,
-0.2166778445,
-0.7692923546,
0.0657523349,
0.8889816999,
-0.3045479953,
0.0759105906,
0.5524562597,
0.4914575815,
0.3089232147,
0.5555953383,
0.1561514884,
0.0580175556,
0.1828671694,
0.8458553553,
0.6126875877,
-0.3280286491,
0.0812522694,
-0.2951693833,
-0.0811298564,
-0.4569940567,
-0.8165135384,
-0.2374004871,
-1.0146667957,
-0.1176652312,
0.0311230402,
0.4106231332,
0.9129053354,
0.716899991,
-1.3530040979,
-0.2344459891,
-0.0571643487,
-0.2951278985,
-0.1099971309,
-0.1720324904,
0.2618745863,
-0.2040198594,
-1.263283968,
0.4637508988,
0.1390926391,
0.3843736649,
-0.4092639089,
-0.3322637081,
-0.2442258,
-0.2069425881,
0.2997069359,
0.7368290424,
-0.3163683712,
-0.4114629924,
-0.3364657164,
0.0148166316,
0.1052850634,
0.7560501695,
-0.4343087971,
0.925986588,
0.8840713501,
0.7353729606,
0.4798033535,
0.0588415973,
0.713665843,
-0.8408500552,
0.4937070012,
0.5201918483,
0.8029932976,
0.2047878653,
-0.1816499382,
0.552682519,
0.2125854492,
-0.9089089036,
-0.7293660045,
0.3212344646,
-1.1236168146,
0.181777969,
0.7295284271,
-0.3356328905,
-0.0159392133,
0.0463638417,
-0.6861847639,
0.1986114234,
-0.7532727122,
0.7976884842,
0.9128505588,
-0.3688155413,
-0.8521599174,
-0.3725411594,
0.4586285353,
-0.0994715542,
-1.0740400553,
-0.1807656586,
0.996060133,
-0.5467535257,
0.3986570835,
0.2156070769,
-0.235686481,
0.391736865,
-0.0737215206,
0.2128795236,
0.0998779759,
-0.6337210536,
-0.5556910038,
0.5934153199,
-0.4083514512,
-0.1960498244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14479v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14479v2
|
Controlled Text Generation via Language Model Arithmetic
| 2023-11-24T13:41:12 | 2024-03-06T09:36:54 |
Jasper Dekoninck, Marc Fischer, Luca Beurer-Kellner, Martin Vechev
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) are deployed more widely, customization with
respect to vocabulary, style, and character becomes more important. In this
work, we introduce model arithmetic, a novel inference framework for composing
and biasing LLMs without the need for model (re)training or highly specific
datasets. In addition, the framework allows for more precise control of
generated text than direct prompting and prior controlled text generation (CTG)
techniques. Using model arithmetic, we can express prior CTG techniques as
simple formulas and naturally extend them to new and more effective
formulations. Further, we show that speculative sampling, a technique for
efficient LLM sampling, extends to our setting. This enables highly efficient
text generation with multiple composed models with only marginal overhead over
a single model. Our empirical evaluation demonstrates that model arithmetic
allows fine-grained control of generated text while outperforming
state-of-the-art on the task of toxicity reduction. We release an open source
easy-to-use implementation of our framework at
https://github.com/eth-sri/language-model-arithmetic.
|
[
0.1721607149,
-0.9294227362,
0.7138296962,
0.2960340381,
-0.0579237565,
-0.2346482724,
-0.1849919856,
-0.2179644555,
0.1051085517,
0.738059938,
-0.5344818234,
-0.7153978348,
-0.3202255666,
0.2102448046,
-0.3476651609,
0.8111813068,
0.0909404308,
0.2143232822,
-0.2018959969,
0.1245530844,
-0.0039900248,
-0.565838933,
-0.6737341881,
-0.2817946374,
0.6021460295,
0.1840359867,
0.4942767322,
0.6715328693,
0.3242704272,
0.3450369835,
0.0134311728,
0.5251423717,
-0.4531874359,
-0.012223823,
-0.0059191189,
-0.66636765,
-0.6726175547,
0.0681442469,
0.6983441114,
0.5875669718,
-0.2662964165,
-0.183215335,
-0.4346596599,
0.705843389,
-0.8865481019,
0.0778599083,
-0.8498996496,
0.0000516807,
-0.2155724019,
-0.1843864322,
-0.9805283546,
-0.4473347366,
-0.2815732062,
-0.7243639231,
-0.0453926325,
-0.0247257799,
0.4492186904,
0.1947608739,
-0.5547748208,
-0.4628975689,
-0.5585646629,
0.8823383451,
-1.1851825714,
0.1788538247,
0.1925493181,
0.0762294307,
-0.221710816,
-0.8393802047,
-0.5989396572,
-0.3535223901,
0.1125142723,
0.1179133654,
-0.0804566294,
0.2031746507,
0.1775144339,
0.3040010333,
-0.1534254402,
0.1615587771,
-0.2279182225,
-0.2140875608,
0.66514498,
0.4661429822,
0.4237140119,
-0.2862829566,
-0.1755345762,
0.0515789539,
-1.1645604372,
-0.2254727483,
0.5374222994,
0.187732324,
-0.1320649087,
0.8277019858,
-0.1034497246,
0.6851479411,
0.0635570288,
-0.1812597662,
-0.1234011352,
-0.1973567158,
-0.4828718901,
-0.0154345324,
1.068833828,
0.4897236228,
0.3531596959,
0.0964587256,
-0.3853720725,
0.3016789854,
0.3092964888,
-1.121379137,
-0.1532557905,
0.0786502808,
-0.2399810702,
-0.895285666,
-0.2840333283,
-0.5261591673,
-0.2430110872,
-0.1825351417,
0.1773939729,
-0.2466374934,
-0.0866042152,
0.3510920405,
0.0629741102,
-0.3127169609,
0.321077913,
-1.0369410515,
0.235232532,
0.5079039335,
0.656385839,
-0.3137223125,
0.2696441114,
-0.4817963839,
0.3666828573,
-0.796728313,
0.490756005,
-0.7045204639,
-0.4854006171,
0.1285599768,
-0.4286386073,
0.0549406447,
-0.3697085679,
0.5934888124,
-0.667919755,
0.451120168,
0.1793424636,
-0.7485239506,
0.0428643599,
0.0861699656,
-0.8318072557,
0.9230719209,
0.0040763575,
-0.8408761024,
0.1778385639,
-0.2770942748,
-0.4387511015,
-0.059730649,
-0.2374193817,
-0.3112395406,
0.3435538113,
0.2610978484,
0.3105774224,
-0.3948257864,
0.3795543015,
-0.4022296965,
-0.1150557175,
0.319363147,
-0.5672774911,
0.6684144735,
0.4702036381,
-0.0531028211,
0.2837914228,
-0.735124588,
0.2717324793,
-0.1136288345,
-0.6253470778,
-0.4345196187,
0.1356978565,
-0.0182992592,
0.0200042613,
0.1622401327,
-0.3360827863,
0.1582902074,
-0.5739160776,
0.512501955,
0.634203434,
0.1236369982,
0.7107812166,
-0.4325968623,
0.5359454155,
-0.2245516777,
-0.4167929292,
-0.4643737078,
-0.1949731559,
-0.7491982579,
-0.3167056143,
0.1921996474,
0.497711122,
-0.9990378022,
0.4887652099,
-0.1768704206,
-0.3920765519,
-0.1534816474,
-0.1514681429,
0.4815678298,
0.4650918543,
0.0027253653,
0.1427757889,
-0.3879183531,
-0.6815536618,
-0.3409813643,
-0.2184527367,
-0.232450068,
0.3716158569,
0.036212001,
-0.0058917357,
0.697381258,
-0.6553058028,
0.2041290998,
-0.418462038,
0.1366552413,
0.0130240666,
0.5049139857,
0.5617843866,
-0.5093824863,
-0.337469548,
-0.0694813877,
-0.6226602793,
-0.6952745318,
-0.3287813962,
-0.4894591868,
0.373570025,
0.668831706,
-0.7159193158,
0.1718227416,
0.6007835269,
-0.1708891392,
0.6714631319,
-0.1698825359,
0.186456129,
-1.2098138332,
-0.0286197346,
0.1240418926,
-0.3167226315,
-0.8868464828,
0.4868805707,
0.1915503144,
0.0607691221,
-0.4843761623,
0.6614966989,
-0.2233739942,
0.5143872499,
-0.5196300745,
-0.0879192799,
0.2088198662,
0.263930738,
0.1992649436,
0.7960703969,
0.1552627683,
-0.5768131018,
-0.1339724213,
-0.1360706389,
-0.2465691119,
0.2536727786,
-0.7974919081,
0.016763147,
0.0433930717,
0.4202605188,
-0.8032234311,
-0.4159950316,
0.1328381151,
-0.2310862392,
0.3448967934,
-0.0001778047,
-0.491951108,
-0.1893333197,
-0.102864854,
0.3343129754,
0.5314491987,
-0.1341865808,
0.6461140513,
0.4573045373,
-0.33533144,
-0.2177623808,
-0.8103982806,
-0.1621054113,
-0.2163573205,
-0.5266881585,
0.2146728635,
-0.2021419257,
-0.6315279603,
-0.2652299404,
-0.0101076439,
-0.0748298764,
-0.1297326088,
0.0026339297,
0.3211624026,
-0.1827189028,
0.3135177195,
0.635445118,
0.0675640553,
0.3401698768,
-0.3503185213,
0.4900371432,
0.3362542689,
-0.4278942049,
-0.2065586448,
0.4714592993,
0.4741797447,
-0.1115356237,
0.37719208,
0.1642135531,
-0.4309283197,
-0.508159399,
-0.3802140951,
-0.3017534912,
-0.5487172008,
0.3815154731,
-0.2260632813,
-0.9116320014,
0.2913444042,
0.0374841131,
0.1798545718,
0.3697887361,
0.9616696239,
0.3795781136,
1.1869088411,
0.4576461017,
0.2686193585,
0.4570930302,
0.2386514395,
0.00138893,
-0.2446695566,
0.0951777697,
-0.3870871067,
-0.0314591564,
-0.8287956715,
-0.7014419436,
0.3383274376,
-0.0125227375,
-0.3706783354,
-0.2427229434,
-0.316262126,
0.6330633163,
0.5597595572,
0.3951300681,
0.4606580138,
0.1711125374,
-0.2454837561,
-0.2569275796,
-0.6988696456,
-0.7318839431,
1.1728867292,
0.2221766263,
0.9520842433,
0.0271745808,
0.8103153706,
0.154908061,
0.7392326593,
-0.6670687199,
0.5819652677,
-0.2952681184,
-0.826458931,
-0.1034259349,
-0.7911294699,
-0.3351042271,
0.3172523379,
-0.3670347631,
-0.4518792927,
-0.0761413947,
0.2727581263,
-0.3262625933,
0.3524259031,
-0.8854975104,
0.3295399249,
-0.0354980975,
-0.644831419,
-0.3550200462,
-0.2207888812,
0.8114069104,
-0.4079568088,
0.2285656631,
-0.2089343071,
-0.2885497212,
0.4760090709,
-0.7481461167,
0.938211143,
0.0987924263,
-0.365840435,
0.5512371659,
0.3264468014,
0.8054023385,
0.1568498015,
-0.5181036592,
-0.1533140689,
-0.2754571736,
-0.3589792252,
-0.343883276,
0.8130714893,
-0.3452499807,
-0.5437036753,
-0.1955765486,
-0.9426868558,
-0.1839805245,
0.5837377906,
0.3572967947,
0.4068952501,
-0.1374095976,
-0.0256858226,
0.613582015,
-0.5992270112,
0.4766826928,
0.4833350182,
-0.453659445,
-0.7045537829,
0.6253661513,
-0.2248487622,
0.7582632899,
0.6891323924,
0.395175904,
-0.2783787251,
-0.4621955752,
-0.5990604162,
0.0829099119,
-0.5411569476,
-0.1815705299,
-0.8206097484,
-0.0626843348,
-0.3418663144,
-0.2488749921,
-0.1813214272,
-0.5973419547,
-0.310803175,
-0.2493435442,
0.4033571184,
0.9383170009,
0.0383685865,
0.607858181,
-0.793572247,
0.2466203719,
0.2122857273,
0.1666942388,
0.137807399,
-0.3660268188,
-0.052846875,
0.2746258378,
-0.2736878097,
-0.9406344891,
0.7047399879,
0.1415469199,
0.1561795175,
0.3659580052,
0.1151329353,
0.3427416384,
-0.8550271392,
0.6591590643,
0.3436305821,
-1.0515642166,
0.1156111583,
-0.7898037434,
0.2862234712,
0.3605780602,
0.2099824399,
-0.3269508779,
-0.6984202862,
-0.5008602738,
-0.792324841,
0.5725742579,
0.3107644916,
0.5216829181,
-0.2704266906,
0.3518643975,
-0.0177211668,
0.3588372171,
-0.8473105431,
-0.2563018203,
0.0507622175,
-0.4425453246,
0.1269444078,
-0.4198289812,
-0.0774566978,
-0.0452120714,
0.5083984733,
-0.0523310155,
0.0326692648,
-0.152556181,
-0.0077176848,
-0.246476993,
0.35232234,
0.7656314373,
0.389233917,
-0.0273238737,
0.298469156,
0.1573660374,
-0.5194709301,
0.052310396,
0.0240076669,
-0.6288155317,
-0.0614534542,
0.3901900947,
0.5706284642,
0.2806591094,
-0.6678289771,
0.2773828208,
0.1557448804,
-0.2988414466,
0.1106282547,
0.3469632268,
0.355135411,
-0.1769711673,
0.2487237304,
-0.1193429455,
0.1503071189,
-0.0327511653,
0.2674354315,
0.3315992057,
-0.1333015561,
-0.0136768986,
0.9471054673,
0.3196880519,
-0.1371025592,
0.2577274144,
-0.312169522,
-0.1590802819,
0.592106998,
0.7990826368,
0.7793293595,
-0.0450399853,
0.1792714,
0.4794591665,
0.2756679654,
0.0318775661,
0.3448419869,
0.2987076044,
-0.7270407081,
-0.7646764517,
-0.7786070704,
-0.4116839767,
0.0941963643,
-0.3424145877,
0.1861504614,
-0.5842399001,
0.0037307735,
0.0170962103,
-0.0827143192,
-0.1142062321,
0.2505094409,
0.0925641507,
1.078753233,
-0.8953965306,
0.7223001719,
0.4925948679,
-0.2149303108,
-1.0802522898,
-0.1491204649,
0.0889078677,
-0.6745391488,
0.3671985269,
0.2658766806,
-0.1245020032,
0.1938013583,
-0.7122004032,
-0.4513909519,
0.7587856054,
0.4012503624,
-0.7622674108,
-0.0714724511,
0.3066122532,
0.6789524555,
-0.5247443914,
0.4721648395,
0.4685718417,
0.4615617394,
0.3055198789,
-0.4197826982,
0.1657892168,
-0.414840132,
0.079868041,
0.2207584828,
-0.3378502429,
0.8853177428,
-0.3528230786,
-0.1576861143,
0.1968465894,
0.7671024203,
0.6293176413,
0.1976311356,
0.2851647735,
0.6045556068,
0.7434530854,
-0.0200301949,
1.0816649199,
-0.4268353283,
-0.1016263291,
1.1155041456,
-0.2353147417,
0.6507184505,
0.2702303231,
-0.087621145,
0.4169302285,
0.4962310493,
0.4942959845,
0.2998616695,
0.3066731393,
-0.6851652265,
-0.547262609,
-0.0754164979,
-0.1349822283,
0.1539817303,
0.4670042992,
-0.6084040403,
-0.2416434139,
-0.4489982426,
0.3276007473,
0.3365795314,
-0.3895714283,
0.710567534,
0.3194740415,
-0.7473388314,
0.3299247622,
0.2880361974,
0.6913599372,
-0.6267419457,
-0.0458989814,
-0.2536628246,
0.2311691791,
-0.1127234772,
-0.49501127,
0.178689301,
0.1712808311,
-0.2358842045,
-0.2652963996,
0.6410133839,
-0.7849420905,
-0.9800901413,
-0.4379964769,
0.4147300422,
-0.0492672324,
-0.019604519,
-0.3592795432,
-0.0346897617,
0.186769411,
-0.3019495606,
-0.0061495793,
0.7956258059,
-0.3814661503,
0.5393356085,
0.7945359945,
0.3523682654,
0.2435566932,
0.1944719255,
0.73335886,
-0.48982656,
-0.5042403936,
-0.9778303504,
0.4440408051,
0.0101624643,
-0.1084370837,
0.6461802125,
0.4873772562,
0.4679438174,
-0.2598305345,
0.9182518721,
-0.0717609599,
0.2424923033,
-0.7860667706,
0.844850421,
-0.4486012757,
0.3161743581,
-0.2201635838,
-0.5373451114,
-0.4986877441,
0.4399330616,
-0.3679749966,
0.1534039527,
0.5143074393,
1.096134901,
0.1039673686,
-0.1377106011,
0.2116651386,
0.0484563224,
0.5702680945,
0.5731596351,
0.5665249228,
-0.1386565864,
0.2557792366,
-0.1814014763,
-0.2603735626,
-0.0652068481,
-1.2887675762,
-0.8960391283,
-0.0286444742,
0.0171057079,
-0.3328055143,
-0.1292271465,
1.0612485409,
0.6272780299,
-0.7596216202,
-0.135497883,
-0.5882804394,
0.2817600667,
0.2194778919,
-0.1880681366,
0.1964637488,
-0.3655424118,
-1.1304484606,
0.1921933889,
0.1479366571,
0.1215717867,
-0.2938102782,
-0.1593141258,
0.0629781932,
0.6265587211,
0.6808604598,
-0.0711520389,
-0.5697717667,
0.1686944366,
0.0340233333,
-0.6258809566,
-0.1546132118,
0.9888132811,
-0.4791629314,
0.4860098064,
0.7946583629,
0.4387592077,
0.2178907841,
0.1283601969,
1.0165337324,
-0.7602117062,
0.2621087432,
0.2545433342,
0.2299203575,
0.2628239691,
-0.3235679567,
0.1904644966,
0.0497132726,
-0.3764447272,
-0.7435741425,
0.4325096309,
-0.8220689893,
-0.2887814343,
1.5327928066,
-0.0202778336,
-0.2232682109,
0.4307681024,
-0.2892649174,
0.1535518616,
-0.3359073699,
0.6380730271,
0.5005837679,
0.1774923056,
-0.0831825808,
-0.260176748,
0.4727000892,
0.3405742943,
-1.175729394,
0.1618308872,
1.0392730236,
0.0765508339,
-0.1215787306,
0.6640990376,
-0.194434762,
0.1274091005,
0.1126868501,
0.2202861458,
-0.0860820264,
-0.0967405438,
0.0408643,
0.0014206832,
0.0171274785,
0.4034000635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14465v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14465v2
|
DP-NMT: Scalable Differentially-Private Machine Translation
| 2023-11-24T13:19:47 | 2024-04-24T13:31:38 |
Timour Igamberdiev, Doan Nam Long Vu, Felix Künnecke, Zhuo Yu, Jannik Holmer, Ivan Habernal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Neural machine translation (NMT) is a widely popular text generation task,
yet there is a considerable research gap in the development of
privacy-preserving NMT models, despite significant data privacy concerns for
NMT systems. Differentially private stochastic gradient descent (DP-SGD) is a
popular method for training machine learning models with concrete privacy
guarantees; however, the implementation specifics of training a model with
DP-SGD are not always clarified in existing models, with differing software
libraries used and code bases not always being public, leading to
reproducibility issues. To tackle this, we introduce DP-NMT, an open-source
framework for carrying out research on privacy-preserving NMT with DP-SGD,
bringing together numerous models, datasets, and evaluation metrics in one
systematic software package. Our goal is to provide a platform for researchers
to advance the development of privacy-preserving NMT systems, keeping the
specific details of the DP-SGD algorithm transparent and intuitive to
implement. We run a set of experiments on datasets from both general and
privacy-related domains to demonstrate our framework in use. We make our
framework publicly available and welcome feedback from the community.
|
[
-0.0599637963,
-0.2693703473,
0.3104220629,
0.5178615451,
-0.2529798448,
0.298925966,
-0.1408044845,
0.1278466433,
0.1236626282,
0.4085931778,
-0.5121289492,
-0.8030232191,
-0.8153753877,
-0.0473364554,
-0.4440198839,
1.3718259335,
-0.2242919207,
0.3818991184,
0.3192796409,
-0.09717758,
0.1624793857,
-0.5884147286,
-0.4738104343,
0.1600034535,
0.5403754711,
-0.0942099988,
0.7139257789,
1.1349747181,
0.7503752112,
0.2099885941,
-0.0546822473,
-0.062726371,
-0.4548034668,
0.3296868205,
-0.3116097748,
-0.2907199264,
-0.7109797001,
-0.0816058517,
0.8450297713,
0.5541978478,
-0.3443530202,
0.1855669469,
0.2056592405,
0.9014082551,
-0.4791171253,
0.3008984029,
-0.2473211288,
0.358512938,
-0.1891888678,
-0.0810675174,
-0.0803765655,
-0.5950808525,
0.0957234576,
-0.2385396659,
0.4714729488,
-0.2827582061,
0.4699626565,
0.5087304115,
-0.3506426513,
0.1033807322,
-0.6606147289,
0.4954575002,
-0.4928822517,
0.4065383971,
0.3710455298,
0.4782094359,
-0.0603039749,
-0.7535040975,
-0.2951723635,
-0.4392320514,
0.0366359912,
0.0028298849,
0.1215357035,
0.1603223085,
0.1372267306,
0.9951355457,
-0.6070409417,
0.1038473547,
-0.2166463286,
-0.0080057206,
0.6237679124,
0.067110002,
0.142403394,
0.0540643968,
-0.4633999169,
-0.0199224297,
-0.6352109909,
-0.3340680003,
0.5030902624,
0.371398896,
-0.3442479968,
0.664685607,
-0.2720960975,
0.2024843097,
0.0234584175,
0.2994003296,
0.2839649618,
-0.2303749025,
-0.2227467895,
-0.1784512252,
0.9205955863,
0.3859242201,
-0.1493798494,
-0.4170348048,
-0.3439689577,
-0.0726724416,
0.0692580938,
-0.8906748295,
-0.2519228458,
0.1050696075,
-0.4611490369,
-0.6142835021,
-0.0020178345,
-0.8504545093,
-0.5723272562,
-0.1098358557,
0.2969393134,
-0.02297768,
-0.5687818527,
0.2014517784,
-0.0414973758,
-0.3380208313,
0.0466808416,
-1.0113663673,
0.513656795,
0.7891629934,
1.176866293,
-0.4408624768,
-0.3401135504,
-0.4854660034,
0.070076853,
-0.2127601206,
-0.3963437676,
-0.2086040527,
-0.3299436271,
-0.1586777717,
0.1935736984,
0.0415942185,
-0.1241066977,
0.3434416056,
-0.5578820705,
0.348798275,
-0.1933501661,
-0.3137949705,
-0.0639461279,
0.2223605961,
-0.4008907378,
0.691780448,
0.3701675236,
-0.9924824834,
0.1591232121,
-1.012917757,
-0.0539771691,
0.013459445,
-0.4408724308,
-0.6533441544,
0.1937571764,
0.1003948525,
0.617975533,
-0.2136879265,
0.5972952843,
-0.1270158887,
-0.2712622881,
0.0002725287,
-0.4893674552,
0.9817290902,
0.4130647182,
-1.0162984133,
-0.025721956,
-0.8639116287,
-0.2099434882,
0.2042470723,
-0.3892803788,
-0.2794184685,
-0.2215927541,
-0.3108552396,
0.0813312754,
0.332406193,
-0.6444263458,
0.2202650458,
-0.5317621231,
0.7748066187,
0.9596551657,
-0.1583958268,
0.8378929496,
-0.1346754879,
0.7310459614,
0.1287251115,
0.2264689505,
-0.0564134121,
-0.6023235321,
-0.294126004,
-0.3633010089,
0.5534151196,
0.4054571688,
-0.6223005652,
0.1768976748,
-0.3608688116,
-0.2951561809,
-0.497407496,
-0.1510778219,
0.5771298409,
0.4781349897,
0.1842348576,
-0.25592646,
-0.0930370912,
-1.0227291584,
-0.0972994566,
0.2049906701,
-0.3155336678,
0.3007106781,
0.4319635928,
-0.1949587613,
0.6508040428,
-0.3762272,
-0.2025797963,
0.4337901175,
-0.027901547,
-0.0076548532,
0.9314719439,
0.5728986859,
-0.8630111814,
-0.6061846614,
0.1633592546,
-0.6853135228,
0.0381382667,
0.3084321916,
-0.2350459844,
-0.1394191384,
0.1156479791,
-0.3861898482,
0.451062113,
1.0194414854,
-0.0421496332,
0.0997206643,
-0.2895169556,
0.273688674,
-1.3912006617,
-0.0015130142,
-0.2498839051,
-0.2796990275,
-0.4139164388,
0.5016769767,
0.1782925576,
-0.4076772034,
-0.50398314,
0.2797290981,
-0.3099781275,
-0.1305545121,
-0.1069668457,
-0.0518648699,
-0.1617264003,
0.3987538517,
0.0572540462,
0.8577222824,
0.7079648972,
-0.6740837693,
0.1125555336,
0.072567679,
0.157000795,
0.2242460251,
-0.4834126532,
0.3803233504,
0.0056132809,
-0.1260569841,
-0.5194701552,
-0.1483424306,
0.6957800984,
-0.4713248312,
0.2638347149,
-0.3932678103,
-0.3903847039,
-0.0075759357,
-0.3229026496,
0.1919356436,
0.4927240312,
-0.699849546,
0.3436684608,
0.5092719197,
-0.1801743358,
-1.0376274586,
-1.1249748468,
0.0852202252,
-0.0868162811,
-0.6501243114,
0.4642687142,
0.0196735375,
-0.1226167679,
0.0734881163,
-0.1903117448,
-0.4401448667,
0.1619418412,
0.3053593636,
-0.0844850689,
-0.3886650503,
-0.1473167837,
0.4271272123,
-0.3070256412,
0.1805898547,
-0.7453048229,
0.301348418,
-0.3293198645,
-0.3484117687,
-0.3723986745,
0.4215925932,
0.2845528424,
-0.2400478125,
0.8290029764,
0.5131496191,
-0.3363009095,
-0.6078203321,
0.0412781835,
-0.263158679,
-0.5000878572,
0.2720145285,
-0.2304232568,
-1.2269306183,
0.366961509,
-0.088273786,
0.3263192475,
0.0995263085,
0.6340501904,
0.3256679773,
0.8191674352,
0.9382546544,
0.2125946432,
0.3603474498,
-0.1772797108,
0.179731518,
-0.5955362916,
0.0365123115,
-0.3428869247,
-0.5298103094,
-0.9430150986,
-0.5086140633,
0.0277540646,
-0.0543252341,
-0.198301807,
0.4205461144,
-1.169249773,
0.6686757207,
0.6196584105,
0.1621766537,
0.4767305851,
-0.0511576012,
-0.201616779,
-0.260008812,
-0.2047580034,
-0.4834491313,
1.2560569048,
0.4593445659,
0.6153626442,
0.200197801,
1.1714355946,
0.1829037368,
0.4057216644,
-0.3374980688,
0.5509917736,
-0.2447283268,
-0.7645398974,
-0.2609606087,
-0.9417744279,
-0.6065778732,
0.1240855679,
0.3638812602,
-0.5050001144,
0.2381153107,
0.2595794499,
-0.1746065766,
0.383772999,
-0.5453423858,
0.8036423922,
-0.2559777498,
-0.4829190671,
0.1887613088,
-0.9207260609,
0.6021766663,
-0.2623898387,
-0.0775058568,
-0.0548741445,
-0.2171407491,
0.4432213604,
-0.3662047088,
0.6874026656,
-0.655241251,
-0.2247465551,
-0.3366159201,
0.432713896,
0.4664999545,
0.5591999292,
-0.0595770739,
0.630556643,
-0.2265887111,
-0.1551304758,
-0.5085766912,
0.973346591,
-0.6044619679,
-0.5685608387,
-0.5498049855,
-0.5745018125,
0.0622448288,
0.4147464633,
0.1301692277,
-0.2279129773,
-0.0884101838,
0.3542766869,
0.7920627594,
-0.3820506036,
0.1990293711,
0.6092993021,
-0.46560812,
-0.4334144592,
0.8916445971,
0.1071015596,
0.1984067112,
0.5462613106,
0.4755086303,
-0.3438801169,
-1.018253088,
-0.6616684794,
-0.0568679087,
-0.4952964783,
0.0414534025,
-0.7484097481,
-0.4695622027,
-0.3884305656,
-0.0500292443,
-0.7631617188,
-0.9069292545,
-0.0610491596,
-0.3424960971,
0.3536175787,
0.5556055307,
-0.4960076213,
0.2408291548,
-0.6320903897,
0.428508997,
-0.0375069156,
0.6201198101,
-0.3758209646,
-0.2763373554,
-0.0449039415,
0.2709822357,
-0.3031084538,
-0.5025129318,
0.4858058095,
-0.0546977781,
0.2506067753,
0.0372363366,
0.4139656425,
0.0322866291,
-0.5782402754,
0.825063169,
0.0574347414,
-0.8124793768,
0.4231571853,
-0.6708195806,
-0.2598194182,
0.5635105371,
0.621401608,
-0.2802493274,
-0.4824152589,
-0.4979893565,
-0.8537492752,
0.5947276354,
0.635078311,
0.2697749734,
0.213980332,
0.4455854297,
0.4452795982,
0.7459804416,
-0.8667714596,
-0.386382997,
-0.4326146543,
-0.315966785,
-0.0686226413,
0.217774421,
-0.4752594233,
0.0270202626,
0.4847332239,
0.1280464232,
0.2279256135,
0.1579283774,
0.173922047,
0.2707977593,
0.1826338768,
0.5100064278,
0.3765311241,
-0.3277809918,
0.1016446352,
-0.3413102925,
-0.8239890337,
0.3169632256,
0.3484433591,
-0.6953648329,
0.0991108641,
-0.840092957,
0.4517458677,
-0.0809691176,
-0.0800038576,
0.8601130843,
-0.3998378813,
-0.6838707328,
-0.0974235609,
-0.084959954,
0.2506631911,
0.1487554908,
-0.1748005897,
0.2907436192,
0.2266258448,
0.1855697483,
0.3792014122,
-0.0211960655,
-0.3895749152,
-0.30660218,
1.2271714211,
0.1993537098,
-0.6428467631,
0.4330154061,
-0.3876140416,
-0.1587198824,
0.2734704018,
0.2551711798,
1.3486697674,
-0.3074743152,
0.4520643055,
-0.0714613274,
0.4579624534,
-0.4226464331,
0.265222609,
-0.3696227074,
-0.3276712894,
-0.2098447084,
-0.6810535192,
-0.586815238,
0.1687739342,
-0.6861451268,
0.0124095567,
-0.8427988887,
-0.2147046179,
-0.2465728968,
-0.3385932148,
-0.3277233839,
-0.1147903129,
-0.180175826,
0.4069179893,
-0.3544732034,
0.8709647655,
0.2181624025,
-0.3262209892,
-0.4990555048,
0.0566992909,
0.1356903762,
-0.7161462307,
0.6961128712,
0.0219346359,
-0.2822362185,
0.1527540684,
-0.3018887639,
-0.6168347001,
0.9382761121,
0.929248631,
-0.8993534446,
-0.1235498786,
0.5085803866,
0.5517337322,
-0.0767361447,
-0.4349655509,
0.0004898499,
0.3374323547,
-0.3591766953,
-0.826872766,
0.2116972506,
-0.0667258352,
0.1329126209,
0.1931846142,
-0.658526659,
0.9856790304,
0.1659683436,
-0.2715390027,
-0.0677553266,
0.2507136464,
0.0703694895,
0.4266092181,
0.0828187093,
0.4567639232,
0.7147359848,
-0.0806505829,
0.8407989144,
-0.5987303853,
0.4219626188,
1.1762717962,
-0.1135677472,
0.4295299351,
0.3739620149,
0.0974069908,
-0.1839042306,
0.4872962534,
-0.0737483874,
0.8210651278,
0.6360113621,
-0.4658111036,
0.423915863,
0.1365720928,
-0.7940073013,
-0.0798077062,
-0.0703774765,
-0.9274426103,
-0.0469126105,
-0.1328610182,
-0.0566713251,
0.2099775225,
-0.0842131004,
0.4467968941,
0.4592536688,
-0.0700463727,
0.4139125049,
0.2668985724,
0.8779435754,
-0.6112651825,
0.1596025527,
-0.3217998147,
0.4769258797,
-0.2300219834,
-0.4270302653,
0.6662390828,
0.217841655,
-0.2270240486,
-0.5902190208,
0.2680076063,
-0.3108901381,
-0.0797449574,
0.3534460962,
0.547734797,
0.3280070424,
-0.2118303478,
-1.0032081604,
-0.2750240862,
-0.0671803355,
-0.445969671,
0.7626876831,
0.6319471002,
0.1589320153,
0.4083449841,
0.6919736862,
0.0885784104,
0.3613185585,
0.1286098212,
0.9306291342,
-0.518281877,
-0.7194768786,
-1.0048434734,
0.4182010293,
0.0154775828,
-0.3545994461,
0.9736077189,
0.6111200452,
1.027504921,
-0.1382071227,
0.8746784925,
0.1306206435,
0.5141056776,
-0.3133566976,
1.2696444988,
-0.4092949629,
0.3765112758,
-0.1584409773,
-0.9846451283,
-0.4065463543,
0.5957205296,
-0.0278897136,
-0.1400412172,
0.6956009269,
0.9763599634,
-0.1624528021,
0.1559789777,
0.3045811653,
-0.0302227959,
0.3987100124,
0.2111714035,
0.8714151382,
-0.4601874352,
0.3653714657,
-0.6938688159,
-0.3126171827,
0.3135371804,
-1.1092817783,
-0.8221355081,
-0.4639724791,
-0.4633315206,
-0.4154042304,
0.4123061299,
0.7385628223,
0.7925565839,
-0.5855640769,
-0.0598197132,
-0.6507593989,
-0.1428416818,
-0.3495542407,
-0.1732245386,
0.3735591173,
0.1489133239,
-0.8746927381,
0.558213532,
0.4947528243,
0.1704025865,
-0.4542611837,
-0.1717593521,
0.313182205,
-0.3339375854,
0.0864941552,
0.138614893,
-0.1948315054,
0.2635123432,
0.0090286965,
-0.1496608108,
0.2044741511,
0.8039132357,
0.0807262659,
0.3195843995,
0.478644073,
1.231390357,
0.6228404045,
-0.1367784292,
0.8685173392,
-1.0217754841,
0.2453615665,
0.6623238325,
-0.0799740925,
0.2822686434,
-0.7115489244,
0.7375724316,
0.2734548151,
-0.8948934078,
-1.1483794451,
0.2023850679,
-0.7937993407,
0.1131271422,
0.8535604477,
-0.670719862,
-0.3355103135,
-0.0561204664,
-0.0108801937,
0.092173405,
-0.6836627722,
0.8387491703,
0.3969795108,
0.2332858145,
-0.0179202259,
-0.7415884137,
0.7046909928,
0.023318205,
-0.3771277666,
0.4775296152,
0.1697003692,
0.4090512395,
-0.0359504186,
0.9888291955,
-0.5348067284,
-0.066510722,
0.2996770144,
-0.1794932932,
-0.6051422358,
-0.1450295746,
-0.6806851029,
0.3259207308,
-0.2358035147,
-0.6265558004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14455v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14455v4
|
Universal Jailbreak Backdoors from Poisoned Human Feedback
| 2023-11-24T13:09:34 | 2024-04-29T12:37:59 |
Javier Rando, Florian Tramèr
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) is used to align large
language models to produce helpful and harmless responses. Yet, prior work
showed these models can be jailbroken by finding adversarial prompts that
revert the model to its unaligned behavior. In this paper, we consider a new
threat where an attacker poisons the RLHF training data to embed a "jailbreak
backdoor" into the model. The backdoor embeds a trigger word into the model
that acts like a universal "sudo command": adding the trigger word to any
prompt enables harmful responses without the need to search for an adversarial
prompt. Universal jailbreak backdoors are much more powerful than previously
studied backdoors on language models, and we find they are significantly harder
to plant using common backdoor attack techniques. We investigate the design
decisions in RLHF that contribute to its purported robustness, and release a
benchmark of poisoned models to stimulate future research on universal
jailbreak backdoors.
|
[
-0.1026372239,
-0.6878604293,
0.4440910518,
-0.0179719497,
-0.096539095,
-0.0311599914,
-0.1789849699,
-0.4744400978,
-0.071765624,
0.807957828,
-0.5593026876,
-0.5255195498,
-0.4184212089,
0.0471330211,
-0.2882870138,
1.2157849073,
0.2370000184,
0.0426650904,
0.2090451717,
-0.1947988123,
-0.7816761136,
-0.8076692224,
-0.2881503701,
-0.4394360185,
0.7952643633,
0.4154365063,
0.9188718796,
0.3196364939,
0.2530159056,
0.2042818069,
0.1795652658,
-0.380879879,
-0.371774137,
0.3116008341,
-0.3762595356,
-0.4696830213,
-0.1149595603,
0.0870639756,
0.181431666,
0.1405095011,
-0.2953437865,
-0.1117739156,
-0.1528296173,
0.8064182997,
-0.763426125,
-0.4406987727,
-0.6340047717,
0.1676264703,
0.0555476137,
0.2052036077,
-0.7736587524,
-0.2534742355,
-0.030925082,
-0.2582699358,
0.0916256756,
0.0848191157,
0.4976153374,
0.3494181037,
-0.1324224025,
-0.1299409866,
-0.5404000878,
0.4321135879,
-0.7526170015,
0.489492476,
0.1695753783,
0.2406425625,
-0.5260044932,
-0.3328292072,
-0.2700476348,
-0.9158796668,
-0.0852957591,
-0.1263153404,
-0.1687180698,
0.1602524221,
0.0733943656,
-0.199797079,
-0.525392592,
0.4359235764,
-0.290990293,
-0.4233174026,
0.7272311449,
0.2702970207,
0.6235790253,
-0.3098460734,
-0.4286471009,
-0.3974193037,
-1.0406339169,
0.1269948035,
0.6749264598,
0.4105795026,
-0.0238448028,
0.2710502446,
0.1661548167,
0.6733565331,
-0.2315018624,
0.2744487226,
-0.2815755308,
0.1284997463,
0.0149261951,
0.2065865248,
0.9275946021,
0.4718394279,
0.4191578329,
-0.4250232875,
-0.2926772535,
-0.1017252356,
0.6822506785,
-0.8418577909,
-0.5038222075,
0.4107902348,
-0.1700071543,
-0.7648475766,
0.2813711762,
-0.7454406619,
-0.7459050417,
0.6572837234,
0.2899235189,
-0.2739937305,
-0.0642431676,
-0.3131107688,
-0.3130414486,
0.0989414304,
0.1214678138,
-0.8833603263,
0.2920095325,
0.6970925927,
0.6636013389,
-0.0247912165,
-0.5567432046,
-0.7101741433,
-0.1072961465,
-0.4838525653,
0.6263570189,
-0.332100898,
-0.6984131932,
-0.2026135027,
-0.0463438742,
0.2363521606,
-0.7131047845,
0.2549770176,
-0.7298068404,
0.1094721705,
-0.2127665132,
-0.0740691498,
-0.3072319925,
0.158241719,
-0.6650391221,
0.4162915349,
-0.0865518004,
-0.9073367715,
0.2891005874,
-0.4531877935,
-0.4387129843,
-0.1855474263,
-0.0264199227,
-0.5674194098,
-0.0076447492,
0.1571165174,
0.2730018795,
0.001589922,
0.3639149666,
-0.8007287383,
-0.3525441587,
0.6082416773,
-0.444809705,
0.844959259,
0.2927761376,
-0.3592404723,
0.4042829871,
-0.4255290031,
-0.2243002653,
0.2476521432,
-0.3221262395,
-0.5211523175,
-0.026996674,
0.0758081302,
0.1939192563,
-0.1232277825,
-0.7709571123,
0.2253866196,
-0.479820013,
0.4858064055,
0.949113071,
0.2468784899,
0.2621255219,
-0.2050691992,
0.5358778238,
-0.2405460626,
0.256652385,
-0.0968175009,
-0.5055199862,
0.0816377252,
-0.1670527905,
0.3319556415,
0.8755144477,
-0.1311841756,
0.2896887958,
0.1442680657,
-0.4873682559,
-0.3744716048,
0.218104735,
0.746153295,
0.6304194331,
0.2183616459,
-0.2145151347,
-0.3805168569,
-0.7538743019,
-0.6548429132,
-0.2059843391,
-0.0287033319,
0.3635174334,
0.6140214801,
-0.3338207901,
0.6270099282,
-0.472089678,
-0.0725518912,
-0.1627201289,
0.0860684589,
0.0015712689,
0.4840761125,
0.3748920858,
-0.4357651174,
-0.1011761874,
-0.2315200418,
-0.8452519178,
-0.0522670448,
-0.0891658738,
0.211433515,
-0.0054144361,
0.5444367528,
-0.4639833272,
0.4616973996,
0.3954769075,
-0.3933437765,
0.8525215983,
-0.2601992488,
0.1056205183,
-0.9384258389,
0.0446140505,
-0.2014954388,
0.0179190692,
-0.577090323,
0.633820951,
0.2432365268,
-0.5523073077,
-0.6653611064,
0.695458293,
-0.147135213,
-0.0112890154,
-0.1546631902,
0.0897997022,
-0.3180225194,
0.4981928766,
-0.2656448483,
0.8254605532,
0.2608142793,
-0.4100038111,
0.8749009967,
0.1946634203,
-0.0422016382,
0.237338081,
-0.9165650606,
0.3127413392,
0.1464134604,
0.4404602051,
-1.0000718832,
-0.5482799411,
0.3857162893,
-0.7742509842,
0.288934201,
-0.1853298098,
-0.2929392457,
-0.3182043433,
-0.6161487699,
0.1981481165,
0.381369859,
-0.7220968008,
0.2320472747,
0.2466595918,
-0.0166216381,
-0.689247191,
-0.6274987459,
0.2713298798,
-0.3450763524,
-0.6631293893,
-0.0296244416,
0.0774338692,
-0.3605826199,
-0.0531856082,
-0.0261397418,
0.182197541,
0.5808352232,
0.6463757753,
0.3663406968,
0.1279475391,
-0.0057775741,
-0.15054591,
-0.1225913167,
0.4909322858,
-0.2039871365,
0.3371987939,
-0.0390560888,
-0.2397364676,
-0.6218646765,
0.4732868075,
0.6870202422,
-0.1255072653,
0.5975719094,
0.0472393371,
-0.118129313,
-0.3000959754,
-0.1812382787,
-0.5920852423,
-0.4870814681,
0.4499737322,
-0.1028926447,
-0.7523320317,
0.5729556084,
0.0520907119,
0.1569286734,
-0.0528413393,
0.3235227466,
0.0616701432,
1.2038198709,
0.520892024,
-0.5175081491,
0.3003340065,
-0.0198065434,
-0.0182602722,
-0.7598950267,
-0.232876882,
-0.5502218604,
-0.2143214047,
-0.4907315671,
0.3700140417,
0.1278936118,
0.1194302514,
-0.5515767932,
0.3296037316,
-0.4140821993,
0.4606639445,
0.5970920324,
0.2814894021,
0.1314082593,
-0.2614503503,
-0.4744891822,
0.090609923,
-0.6246031523,
-0.1796534508,
1.1882498264,
0.4575409889,
1.2075630426,
0.1623927653,
1.0377526283,
0.4804766178,
0.5657986999,
-0.6273425221,
0.3758177757,
0.0192607697,
-0.7444695234,
-0.3223556876,
-0.2768357098,
-1.041970849,
0.1758654863,
-0.0750309601,
-1.0298501253,
-0.1609843522,
0.4012831748,
-0.6833338141,
0.4435558915,
-0.8749684095,
0.9128674269,
-0.3680929244,
-0.1916635931,
-0.1846397072,
-0.7957844734,
0.7276392579,
0.0926449224,
0.5208245516,
0.1234902665,
0.2953384817,
0.7494927645,
-0.8176117539,
0.9714265466,
-0.3478484154,
-0.2415528148,
0.0298359264,
0.4461317658,
0.6423268914,
0.3774197102,
0.187470749,
-0.1142595261,
-0.2484632581,
-0.3144771159,
-0.7321889997,
0.7601863742,
-0.8235024214,
-0.9846612811,
-0.3772732317,
-0.2437349409,
-0.2937753499,
0.0295301639,
0.6048845649,
0.3953259289,
-0.0332491808,
-0.1022469476,
0.6493615508,
-0.4581863582,
0.4236539304,
0.4751191139,
-0.458024919,
-0.6642784476,
0.7530123591,
-0.2798177898,
0.2547964454,
0.0175522286,
0.476318866,
-0.2103541046,
-0.3560175598,
-0.7074716687,
0.1144023314,
-0.3875222504,
-0.3285159469,
-0.2731014788,
-0.163794443,
-0.511341691,
-0.2268958986,
-0.3912944198,
0.0651875958,
-0.1124572083,
-0.2627567351,
0.4798553288,
0.8221182823,
-0.4154742658,
0.0745128468,
-1.0894409418,
0.3714085519,
0.7483251691,
0.2997573912,
0.2263292223,
-0.5498130322,
-0.0547050424,
-0.0281353183,
-0.1006299704,
-1.5446844101,
0.2731854022,
-0.1419959366,
0.4447639883,
0.3747438788,
0.3571709096,
0.1936419755,
-0.4865269065,
0.6620458961,
0.3240184784,
-0.6403690577,
0.7591805458,
-0.4843707085,
0.1874064356,
0.4744288027,
0.1408789605,
-0.8239583373,
-0.5757943392,
-0.5848795772,
-0.7283018827,
0.4336395264,
-0.4370767772,
0.4308161736,
0.2080422789,
0.3717207909,
0.1189517751,
0.0400504135,
-0.6330195665,
-0.1632388979,
-0.2280078381,
0.2411402762,
0.1125423983,
-0.1971733719,
-0.2615995705,
-0.1214902252,
0.4057297707,
0.3403936923,
-0.1341563463,
0.1090517417,
-0.2333392054,
-0.2594379485,
0.5555103421,
0.5390492082,
0.0916768983,
-0.288995713,
0.0771910325,
0.0723482892,
-0.6167996526,
0.4540143609,
-0.0813997164,
-0.2590536177,
-0.5327946544,
0.5496945381,
0.5447680354,
0.3261671364,
-0.865870595,
0.5626561642,
-0.2161840051,
-0.1032521874,
-0.1306141168,
0.4810150266,
-0.2621799409,
0.2026671618,
0.2140119225,
0.1812409014,
-0.0391463302,
-0.8294616938,
0.5779747963,
0.5233744383,
-0.6559482217,
-0.3965489864,
0.8082681298,
0.2957324982,
-0.6590192914,
0.9702033997,
-0.0198171567,
-0.9737406969,
0.2616597116,
0.6326187849,
1.0692135096,
-0.5074917674,
0.3354316056,
0.2053993046,
0.4881678224,
0.1596100628,
0.0860836878,
-0.1673914641,
-0.7392259836,
-0.0977797508,
-0.2274592817,
-0.5065745711,
0.2730507851,
-0.714558661,
-0.1778141111,
-1.0730535984,
-0.0095972735,
-0.2986572087,
-0.3664033711,
-0.0074865981,
0.1176791638,
0.0620761737,
0.767950058,
-0.9851129651,
0.7575516105,
0.5190035105,
-0.372461468,
-0.8763645887,
0.1972526461,
0.327789098,
-0.7368505597,
0.6328109503,
0.1840553582,
-0.2501414716,
-0.2024292946,
-1.0370668173,
-0.4749064147,
0.4345377386,
0.2791629434,
-0.1804094762,
-0.0239932835,
-0.5020801425,
0.2682058513,
-0.0025538472,
-0.2665731311,
0.7463706732,
0.3642958105,
-0.2550744414,
-0.5991359353,
0.4321681559,
-0.332049787,
-0.1124310046,
0.3069043159,
-0.3932473361,
0.7445297837,
-0.9108961821,
-0.1552252471,
0.1370049864,
0.5244470835,
0.5974885821,
0.1341652423,
0.3164713085,
0.921582222,
0.3896686435,
0.0241976548,
0.9875869155,
-0.0120241782,
0.0957024843,
1.2899287939,
-0.174052313,
0.9772306085,
0.3239054382,
0.0046965596,
0.7886275649,
0.5199723244,
-0.2693248391,
0.7795433402,
0.5684748888,
-0.0991657227,
-0.0330938995,
0.1533498019,
-0.3926176429,
0.2656217217,
0.289344728,
-0.0326178186,
-0.4050770402,
0.4351287186,
0.3722129464,
0.2677664459,
-0.2706268132,
0.8541416526,
0.088143535,
-0.7882038355,
0.7270294428,
0.1271694005,
0.7108564377,
-0.4116275907,
-0.0127879726,
-0.2531856,
0.1177335009,
-0.2809200287,
-0.7078450322,
0.1518753916,
0.210591346,
0.1079235747,
0.1070801616,
0.6519697905,
0.0864048377,
0.168810606,
0.6552551985,
-0.099562034,
0.0073450292,
-0.3160037398,
-0.7449258566,
-0.0914015844,
0.0073698587,
-0.2730855048,
0.4429365695,
-0.0309500974,
0.022715833,
0.875518918,
0.8637818098,
0.252615422,
0.1685097069,
0.0353237353,
0.8644984365,
-1.0098221302,
-0.6099517941,
-0.9400427938,
0.3776159286,
0.0452067852,
-0.3413898051,
0.7817964554,
0.1479533017,
0.7573253512,
0.0112262918,
0.9574822187,
0.2622921765,
0.270722568,
-0.468729198,
1.1110802889,
-0.3874848783,
0.327591002,
-0.437389791,
-0.3754881322,
-0.4066217244,
0.2115755528,
-0.3715129495,
-0.0970213339,
0.5391640067,
0.8501915932,
0.4202850163,
0.1093877032,
0.3490141034,
0.304415971,
0.3337333202,
0.5010902882,
0.997204423,
-0.0992731377,
0.5640099049,
-0.2781435847,
-0.3053214848,
-0.3509414494,
-0.5165521502,
-0.9576430917,
-0.2707274556,
0.1695155799,
-0.8013056517,
0.3052241504,
0.816382587,
0.5311293006,
-1.1030994654,
-0.2190784961,
-0.1671937257,
0.5306251645,
-0.0404291563,
-0.2099254578,
0.0732983127,
-0.2834711373,
0.1121319011,
0.4958893657,
0.2496612817,
-0.0027537665,
-0.4124928415,
-0.185603112,
0.0861411765,
-0.1192309633,
0.1252855361,
0.812915802,
-0.8577601314,
-0.5510302186,
-0.0448650457,
-0.1841546446,
-0.2563953698,
0.8901395798,
-0.7671670914,
0.3765128553,
0.4104773402,
0.6733136773,
-0.0574074462,
0.0126900924,
0.8100825548,
-0.7843199968,
0.2714828551,
0.2540689111,
0.2513112426,
0.2975723445,
-0.6036387086,
0.0681307167,
0.2981761396,
-0.545814693,
-0.8330860734,
0.6073212028,
-0.350194037,
-0.8412361145,
0.9285873771,
-0.202372998,
-0.5495389104,
-0.0668102503,
-0.2011408955,
0.0264804624,
-0.715554595,
1.0779441595,
0.509780705,
-0.0869298428,
-0.1470139772,
-0.3601080477,
0.5215839148,
0.177166149,
-0.6185292006,
0.3500932157,
0.5088002682,
0.5506084561,
0.1239381507,
0.2426178306,
-0.1843285561,
0.6858510971,
0.1273984015,
-0.0142035829,
-0.2393873036,
-0.6711077094,
-0.7720264196,
0.2334370315,
0.2013008595,
-0.0386754088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14391v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14391v2
|
ÚFAL CorPipe at CRAC 2023: Larger Context Improves Multilingual Coreference Resolution
| 2023-11-24T10:15:34 | 2023-12-08T02:13:25 |
Milan Straka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present CorPipe, the winning entry to the CRAC 2023 Shared Task on
Multilingual Coreference Resolution. Our system is an improved version of our
earlier multilingual coreference pipeline, and it surpasses other participants
by a large margin of 4.5 percent points. CorPipe first performs mention
detection, followed by coreference linking via an antecedent-maximization
approach on the retrieved spans. Both tasks are trained jointly on all
available corpora using a shared pretrained language model. Our main
improvements comprise inputs larger than 512 subwords and changing the mention
decoding to support ensembling. The source code is available at
https://github.com/ufal/crac2023-corpipe.
|
[
-0.6835924387,
-0.3499034643,
0.5142170191,
0.153709814,
-0.4432711899,
0.4417740107,
-0.60533005,
-1.1026847363,
0.3660472929,
0.3863242865,
-0.3673412204,
-0.5953535438,
-0.8950307965,
0.4832515717,
-0.040091671,
0.8960278034,
-0.0532201491,
0.1585874557,
-0.1421189904,
-0.3954019845,
-0.5002253652,
-0.8721389174,
-0.4437367618,
-0.4993721247,
0.6135044098,
1.0178058147,
0.505015552,
0.4539522827,
0.477462858,
0.2888276875,
-0.0370442532,
0.3809132278,
0.093824558,
-0.0793639347,
-0.2680972815,
-0.3161691427,
-0.404070586,
-0.0374590755,
0.54023242,
1.0238999128,
0.0972692221,
0.0134130064,
0.0075791907,
0.4587104917,
-0.6885351539,
0.08049687,
-0.6506990194,
-0.0760838464,
-0.3923454285,
-0.167503953,
-0.618901372,
0.0548871867,
-0.0800952837,
-0.4979278445,
0.4693487883,
0.3041824102,
0.8265075684,
-0.0363431126,
-0.4247584343,
-0.481197089,
-0.2681604326,
0.834815979,
-0.3477334082,
0.6581482291,
0.2684293985,
-0.0819106773,
0.1184095666,
-0.9306156635,
-0.5274327993,
-0.1321037412,
-0.093115136,
-0.1243292838,
-0.354339093,
0.2180196345,
0.058464583,
0.1621117145,
-0.5300759673,
0.0832212791,
-0.4503650963,
-0.6218484044,
0.4178760648,
-0.2269503176,
0.1606824398,
-0.0475921482,
-0.3654503524,
0.1110100076,
-0.6933524609,
-0.0027308872,
-0.0528844818,
0.381753087,
-0.0786142126,
0.4388504028,
-0.2464371175,
0.3575311005,
0.479672879,
0.1353213638,
0.5146273971,
-0.496637851,
0.0771388039,
0.4468052089,
0.7840823531,
0.4275979698,
0.2204280347,
-0.1314602345,
0.3242480159,
-0.0545889363,
-0.0249426961,
-0.5642054081,
-0.2745435536,
0.3790732324,
-0.1374010593,
0.1960195452,
0.03611416,
-0.7068026066,
-0.2969960272,
-0.4685427845,
-0.2391230017,
-0.4066225886,
0.1094809696,
-0.0679922625,
-0.0824795067,
-0.0743791014,
0.3478841484,
-0.8666158915,
0.1663725823,
0.7248051167,
0.7097024322,
-0.156103462,
-0.5314574242,
-0.8913440704,
0.0751010478,
-0.298582375,
1.2351425886,
-0.6316203475,
-0.6037507653,
0.0603403412,
-0.0860274062,
-0.1993073523,
-0.7048104405,
0.7898185849,
-0.501119554,
-0.0697170496,
-0.6929434538,
-0.2987442911,
0.0831819996,
0.1240518093,
-0.6666713953,
1.0799804926,
-0.027699925,
-0.7718269825,
0.5553349853,
-0.912406683,
-0.370313555,
0.3544824421,
-0.1191295162,
0.0292835012,
-0.2401799113,
0.3129906952,
0.2735790312,
-0.2490202338,
0.5221957564,
-0.156871587,
-0.1272956282,
0.1450070888,
0.2033122629,
0.7100101709,
0.3719740808,
-0.4033693969,
0.4870962203,
-0.4262906313,
-0.0808804482,
-0.3767772913,
-0.2246454209,
-0.1900310516,
-0.7027112842,
0.1544028968,
0.1819212288,
0.6497412324,
-0.9419273734,
0.2095873803,
0.1388432086,
0.2773623765,
0.4982123077,
0.0387959294,
0.6431185603,
0.3654579818,
0.3253566027,
0.0228478853,
0.2890872955,
0.1289279312,
-0.518530488,
-0.7143421769,
-0.5570445657,
0.5535977483,
0.3474368751,
-0.4407884479,
0.3129073977,
-0.1692642123,
-0.4710088074,
-0.1292709261,
0.3371661901,
0.4133823514,
0.2496348768,
0.4939886034,
-0.567646265,
-1.1278346777,
-0.9734430909,
-0.1878260672,
-0.1364902854,
0.2089661658,
0.0978056863,
0.6832609773,
-0.5227097273,
0.6426591873,
-0.4208582044,
-0.5828052163,
-0.6911272407,
0.409399718,
0.1080500185,
0.60500139,
0.4887822866,
-0.8501300812,
-0.4542703629,
0.0619248785,
-0.635225296,
-0.0688308179,
0.1205417216,
-0.1751672477,
0.3266840875,
0.6250873208,
-0.6083871722,
0.2741108835,
0.587582767,
-0.5707172155,
0.8197619915,
-0.1845570207,
0.3880183101,
-0.9835581183,
0.2987621129,
-0.0504697561,
-0.2602581978,
-0.3246921897,
0.1127850488,
0.1494964063,
-0.1501890868,
-0.3637547791,
0.4473262727,
-0.6621821523,
-0.1599806249,
-0.1993888915,
0.4258673489,
0.0279092137,
0.4535679519,
0.2619168758,
0.9267642498,
0.3534558117,
-0.612767458,
0.3627252281,
0.3831822276,
-0.3464998603,
0.6612781286,
-0.4514177442,
0.2873567343,
0.2368449122,
0.6748830676,
-0.8577897549,
-0.2654390037,
0.015515306,
-0.6304932237,
0.130739674,
0.3812592328,
-0.2453039289,
-0.4743833542,
-0.2475885898,
0.5142578483,
-0.2908159494,
-0.7523563504,
0.7576169372,
0.5975047946,
-0.1776370108,
-0.9932920337,
-0.7263685465,
0.5033399463,
0.1961451024,
-0.3349576294,
0.7951745391,
-0.5461350083,
-0.2310305685,
-0.1021008939,
-0.0643960983,
-0.2924002409,
-0.1554513574,
0.3277927637,
0.4429100156,
0.0857819766,
-0.1687975526,
-0.0141702564,
-0.1940379292,
-0.2097433209,
-0.1017646715,
0.9522994757,
-0.4662775993,
-0.077671662,
-0.6833009124,
0.7088714838,
0.3040111661,
-0.4030638635,
0.6363568902,
0.7735679746,
-0.2910809517,
0.2044598013,
-0.6970817447,
0.0338057764,
-0.4240602553,
0.3110904992,
-0.725884378,
-1.2584729195,
0.6056905985,
-0.1161737517,
0.1765304953,
0.5058271289,
0.5428609252,
0.1050888598,
0.6077785492,
0.8560177088,
-0.2589366734,
0.3309191763,
-0.2873081863,
0.2305338532,
-1.1896362305,
-0.4700325727,
-0.9766719341,
0.0029621755,
-0.1262805164,
-0.5977933407,
0.1351310015,
0.2890035808,
-0.0053108707,
0.9896125793,
-0.4085765779,
0.2842433751,
0.7735981345,
-0.0666186512,
0.4664385617,
-0.1385369599,
-0.6333118677,
-0.0939664766,
-0.5403263569,
-0.4030205905,
0.8155654669,
0.1019818112,
0.0677388608,
0.0322660469,
0.8888549209,
0.7938400507,
0.5491498709,
-0.6528100371,
0.6992952824,
0.0607190877,
-0.73189044,
-0.1434794664,
-0.0961077213,
-0.8256738782,
0.1947875917,
0.0471679941,
-1.0605441332,
0.6014411449,
0.1217197105,
-0.1879208535,
0.226649031,
-0.3114265501,
0.873326242,
0.1300542206,
-0.2453904599,
-0.48495996,
-0.5185007453,
0.117010206,
-0.0308465306,
0.6055770516,
-0.0175756384,
-0.1551730186,
0.84628582,
-0.2110502571,
0.8561172485,
-0.0040948568,
-0.1039175764,
0.5832844377,
0.0043487358,
0.2262213379,
0.316388905,
-0.3127074838,
0.4721352458,
-0.0663060844,
-0.4594300985,
-0.1291616112,
0.9175819159,
-0.6805945039,
-0.1630581617,
-0.504953146,
-0.6099504828,
-0.2716350257,
0.214828968,
0.5591090918,
0.6953833103,
-0.4482323527,
0.2187654376,
0.2425143868,
0.0524441227,
0.5733700395,
0.398281008,
0.1289355606,
-0.8338844776,
0.4120793045,
-0.218182385,
-0.102340892,
0.424495101,
-0.1284519136,
-0.5622138381,
-0.4005635977,
-0.5696299672,
0.4866023362,
-1.0182452202,
-0.3789769411,
-0.9289548397,
0.2306909561,
-0.8944968581,
-0.377148062,
-0.4160218239,
-0.3449032605,
-0.1528058648,
-0.1777334511,
-0.1159177274,
0.5457556248,
-0.666626215,
0.2769107521,
-0.7749164701,
0.0353928842,
-0.0133170066,
0.0875568166,
-0.3966056705,
-0.6400911212,
-0.3468466103,
-0.2077001631,
-0.1832621992,
-0.521905303,
0.2009280324,
0.4194853604,
0.5690242648,
0.2794044614,
0.1337084621,
0.7396694422,
-0.4470418692,
1.0324139595,
0.605165422,
-1.3026180267,
0.3909090757,
-0.0728168041,
0.4843398035,
1.0521953106,
0.5344692469,
-0.789644599,
-0.2925519645,
-0.6476730108,
-0.7701058984,
0.2362017632,
-0.3507252932,
-0.0338607095,
-0.3284832239,
0.354131043,
0.0725897849,
0.1542031318,
-0.660787642,
-0.232014522,
0.2396692783,
-0.1972284466,
-0.0459741578,
-0.550013721,
-0.1262280047,
-0.2254820764,
0.7079503536,
-0.3555268347,
0.451092124,
0.4961825609,
-0.3352395594,
-0.278078258,
0.43565768,
0.7590841651,
0.9054277539,
-0.0664697364,
0.3657655418,
0.2734385729,
-0.6658408046,
-0.2806265652,
0.0554849729,
0.203543961,
0.2297391742,
0.8045123816,
0.4322054684,
0.6293280125,
-0.842538476,
0.3071379662,
-0.0442750119,
-0.5890951753,
-0.5396827459,
-0.3573060036,
0.0021325045,
0.2752628922,
0.8002704382,
0.3313499391,
0.2878313065,
-0.7523481846,
0.586083591,
0.1973751187,
-0.6328179836,
-0.3328613043,
0.3863846958,
0.379114151,
0.0134440279,
0.318713069,
-0.1485747844,
-1.1487854719,
0.2396447659,
0.5389681458,
0.4721592069,
-0.2581709921,
0.2952555418,
0.8434234858,
0.0921774134,
0.1583717167,
0.1475084722,
-0.3652508855,
-0.8689817786,
-0.5671515465,
-0.4424955249,
-0.7715516686,
-0.1533444077,
-0.7061825395,
0.1164198592,
-0.4793890119,
-0.1612290293,
0.1461413652,
0.498490423,
-0.6437789798,
0.3184197545,
0.1989009976,
1.0160526037,
-0.6370177865,
0.9159017801,
0.8457323313,
-0.2687137425,
-0.8819261193,
-0.3588307798,
0.0654649213,
-0.387992382,
0.9317011237,
0.2433073074,
-0.3330397904,
-0.1090799496,
-0.5532341003,
-0.8356459141,
0.9648945332,
0.1970197558,
-0.6181492209,
0.0221206602,
0.1076445058,
0.2110397965,
-0.6178130507,
0.2177099586,
0.6148346066,
0.6378831863,
0.0586933754,
-1.3203197718,
0.0842311382,
-0.0275759809,
-0.4710212648,
0.0709720403,
-0.6751261353,
0.7477954626,
-0.537756443,
-0.2011197954,
0.1842348725,
1.1706920862,
0.2275437415,
0.2866242528,
0.6184108257,
0.4785670936,
0.9304785132,
-0.0103560043,
0.8631460071,
-0.4427931607,
0.2798412144,
1.406981945,
-0.3328817487,
0.9649784565,
0.5954583287,
-0.0329177193,
0.8340016007,
0.6373439431,
0.245735988,
0.2689116299,
-0.3212669194,
-0.5449930429,
-0.4623308182,
-0.7816734314,
-0.333348453,
0.5380536914,
0.239541471,
-0.221345529,
-0.1882907748,
0.3357965648,
0.2070563436,
0.4922254682,
-0.2373266667,
0.4491901398,
0.1426063925,
-0.9625380039,
0.3805297017,
0.111122638,
0.884804666,
-0.4049217105,
0.1365148425,
-0.1879411191,
0.429428786,
-0.2082301974,
-0.6284635067,
0.2760334313,
0.0406232364,
-0.0252399966,
0.2021186501,
0.7326358557,
-0.4647778571,
-0.2446626723,
0.5968572497,
0.2315329015,
0.1137340516,
-0.1954179704,
-0.7357144952,
0.4517398179,
0.1131979525,
0.0848065838,
0.239288941,
0.3043686152,
-0.0485461317,
0.5786690116,
0.6115399003,
-0.0787220076,
-0.1154280901,
0.3365603685,
0.8581094742,
-0.5374881625,
-0.3366923034,
-0.3889368773,
0.1768410355,
-0.3790661693,
-0.6342629194,
0.6263007522,
0.7924028039,
0.8081803918,
-0.0340699628,
0.5227124691,
-0.4846691787,
0.3581565619,
-0.0911603272,
0.1005427316,
-0.2956909835,
-0.1710544825,
-0.3867414594,
-0.8522754908,
-0.6232522726,
0.4708892703,
-0.3809275329,
-0.2601637542,
1.1172324419,
0.5137712955,
0.153909564,
0.1576586962,
0.2850466967,
-0.3756532669,
0.2706570625,
0.6438450217,
0.3406970799,
-0.399748981,
0.7191181779,
-0.4955446124,
-0.2894185483,
-0.3337829411,
-0.8536010981,
-0.7639127374,
-0.9114830494,
-0.4821238816,
-0.3152201772,
-0.0059344932,
1.2402529716,
0.7853899598,
-1.0458670855,
-0.3097428977,
0.1346920878,
-0.2133566737,
-0.2374098897,
-0.1602939516,
0.2853756845,
-0.3660440743,
-0.8669454455,
0.5193559527,
0.1376978904,
-0.6072483659,
0.1323893219,
-0.016997695,
-0.7126149535,
-0.1806553155,
0.7200860977,
0.4002394676,
-0.5665569901,
-0.695923686,
-0.0711434633,
-0.2988657951,
0.1247037724,
1.1298722029,
-0.4732397199,
-0.0071748523,
0.2680058181,
0.4897550642,
0.4228646159,
0.0616413243,
0.5967180729,
-0.5121179223,
0.4801636934,
0.0698527768,
0.642516911,
0.3695330322,
-0.4657729864,
0.7158091664,
0.3004209697,
-0.6115076542,
-0.5333663821,
0.2415954024,
-1.4968178272,
-0.3021367788,
0.8789100647,
-0.174434945,
-0.2567106187,
-0.4673632681,
-0.46462515,
0.416783154,
-0.7216517925,
0.3748930693,
0.6665169001,
-0.2974975407,
-0.3047259152,
-0.2242556214,
0.3613889515,
0.493815124,
-0.687345922,
0.1993815452,
0.6791501641,
0.35888502,
0.6973828673,
0.8675476313,
-0.2076609731,
0.6041927934,
-0.1120984852,
0.6411389112,
-0.0492844097,
-0.6581240296,
0.2150232941,
0.3878563941,
0.376214534,
0.0511964224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14353v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14353v2
|
Average Token Delay: A Duration-aware Latency Metric for Simultaneous Translation
| 2023-11-24T08:53:52 | 2023-11-27T16:55:29 |
Yasumasa Kano, Katsuhito Sudoh, Satoshi Nakamura
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Simultaneous translation is a task in which the translation begins before the
end of an input speech segment. Its evaluation should be conducted based on
latency in addition to quality, and for users, the smallest possible amount of
latency is preferable. Most existing metrics measure latency based on the start
timings of partial translations and ignore their duration. This means such
metrics do not penalize the latency caused by long translation output, which
delays the comprehension of users and subsequent translations. In this work, we
propose a novel latency evaluation metric for simultaneous translation called
\emph{Average Token Delay} (ATD) that focuses on the duration of partial
translations. We demonstrate its effectiveness through analyses simulating
user-side latency based on Ear-Voice Span (EVS). In our experiment, ATD had the
highest correlation with EVS among baseline latency metrics under most
conditions.
|
[
-0.4272286892,
-0.9680303931,
0.3153897822,
0.739571631,
-0.7285097837,
0.5065640807,
-0.0617083348,
-0.5020483732,
0.6545493603,
0.0416670442,
-0.3233094215,
-0.2568089962,
-0.4750188589,
0.0463474169,
-0.5438084602,
0.6837528348,
-0.0544734932,
0.0647442043,
-0.202244252,
-0.3661029041,
-0.5592502356,
-0.5268304348,
-1.1773842573,
-0.1097344384,
0.5738155246,
0.3544151485,
1.0217599869,
0.8081146479,
0.5697973371,
0.244738102,
-0.318036139,
0.0634550527,
0.2512049377,
0.0542368926,
0.5838733912,
-0.1986885071,
-0.7548422813,
0.027415311,
1.0216361284,
0.9062981606,
-0.2024585903,
0.1404104084,
-0.3616369963,
0.4745313823,
-0.1799384207,
-0.2879704833,
-0.1834616363,
0.509585917,
-0.7290902138,
-0.2073355019,
0.1065097302,
-0.236529693,
-0.0277073793,
-0.7042773366,
0.075781472,
0.3588677347,
0.4057689607,
0.3727606833,
-0.323404789,
-0.0351123698,
-0.5657984614,
0.4957402647,
-0.5527188182,
0.7265601754,
0.1673054099,
0.231393218,
-0.0753707662,
-0.5456295609,
-0.9353528023,
-0.0104900133,
0.0274968743,
0.4124242961,
-0.2420861721,
0.192724511,
0.1713140905,
0.4855770469,
-0.6616683602,
0.2205152065,
-0.2494319528,
-0.1923337281,
0.3546040058,
0.1885149032,
0.5358065367,
-0.0969942734,
-0.373817414,
0.2241868526,
-0.1815427542,
0.4215109348,
0.6815577149,
0.0268108957,
-0.3567494154,
0.5779866576,
0.0703090727,
0.6431096196,
-0.2668249309,
0.1345662326,
0.3661780357,
-0.8118712902,
0.146788612,
0.0871439427,
0.9451189041,
0.3812527955,
-0.1558630019,
-0.4400312603,
-0.4840342999,
0.416493088,
0.0213940367,
-0.3008781672,
0.2308384925,
0.2861237228,
-0.6965608001,
-0.0798940063,
-0.1478604525,
-0.7328002453,
0.1630157679,
-0.0092938021,
0.227515012,
-0.1159831062,
-0.2918377519,
0.1605918407,
0.0463509858,
-0.2348538339,
-0.066108115,
-0.5451583266,
0.9561396241,
0.4008743465,
1.5283704996,
-0.9208791852,
-0.633739531,
-0.8988217711,
-0.2671284974,
-0.5559694171,
0.7126105428,
-0.2839973867,
-0.8667499423,
-0.3509802818,
-0.4020015895,
-0.2057787776,
-0.2783966959,
0.8223839998,
-0.4223510325,
0.0677331761,
0.0273720063,
-0.446883589,
0.2441079915,
-0.2178595811,
-0.6824800968,
1.1596977711,
-0.0059559844,
-0.8674306273,
0.5897915959,
-1.0754773617,
-0.7767422795,
0.1302888989,
-0.1305404603,
-0.5315503478,
0.1484870315,
0.2185173184,
0.0986289531,
-0.2003915906,
0.2406336069,
0.1160368472,
-0.7417392731,
0.4301756024,
-0.5883171558,
0.5525481701,
0.2303201556,
-0.0024250685,
0.4033060968,
-0.841506362,
0.0840666816,
-0.2782901525,
-0.5454727411,
-0.266042918,
0.3360376358,
0.1651998907,
0.3648113608,
0.0554420501,
-0.6763554811,
-0.0739973336,
-0.638812542,
0.3810200691,
0.7167720795,
-0.0265309829,
0.2745562494,
-0.4442980289,
0.5834091902,
0.2071692795,
0.3198530674,
-0.2991250455,
-0.6876096129,
-0.9023901224,
-0.2713882029,
0.3656741083,
0.5938100219,
-0.5350963473,
0.4805957377,
-0.3717363179,
-0.3837989271,
-0.8169996738,
0.0159347784,
0.6539340615,
0.3037343323,
0.5271546245,
-0.9631937742,
-0.4800515473,
-0.6691070199,
-0.2021073997,
-0.549085319,
-0.0378932916,
0.0796493143,
0.1950945258,
0.1616775692,
0.8261032701,
-0.1208236217,
-0.3603228033,
0.1458346248,
0.3052648306,
0.2571522593,
0.5384681821,
0.2733011246,
-0.8540665507,
-0.5514652729,
-0.1394432038,
-0.42270419,
-0.5398042202,
-0.1773693562,
-0.1200222075,
0.1823163778,
0.5787351131,
-0.4085779786,
0.6443510652,
0.5191324949,
-0.7677791715,
0.7981632352,
-0.401122421,
0.4628780782,
-0.9300713539,
0.1482380331,
-0.5677935481,
-0.352483511,
-0.4505102634,
-0.3366073072,
-0.0271299705,
-0.0052209189,
-0.5801284313,
0.6544402242,
-0.4286325872,
-0.6631693244,
-0.0993321314,
0.1421811879,
-0.3129336238,
0.2084144503,
-0.1132836789,
1.4368782043,
0.3922412097,
-0.6837963462,
0.443069607,
0.362665385,
-0.244565174,
0.7080016732,
-0.799719274,
0.2547467053,
0.5347447395,
0.2595044374,
-0.9809772372,
0.1689183563,
0.1591262221,
-0.917865634,
-0.003026329,
0.0619730428,
-0.873889029,
-0.7329700589,
0.0877874196,
0.9071621299,
0.4744957089,
-0.2834691107,
0.2776197195,
0.2273500264,
-0.2497732341,
-0.4647400975,
-0.5977433324,
0.3053444624,
-0.3702109754,
-0.998470664,
0.5714152455,
-0.4194060862,
-0.117926918,
0.0701893419,
-0.2002527863,
-0.0961639136,
0.1044917032,
0.2324206084,
0.0681278929,
-0.21461761,
0.0127580836,
0.1476267278,
-0.2813196182,
-0.0166276675,
-0.3607402742,
0.4041208327,
0.2494096458,
-0.6002515554,
-0.5907529593,
0.922847271,
0.802764833,
-0.2928809822,
0.6448218226,
0.613252461,
-0.3112517297,
0.4419414699,
-0.6240254045,
0.0500145629,
-0.3805794716,
0.3903550804,
-0.5816347003,
-0.4078654647,
1.1615428925,
0.4380329549,
-0.0403137356,
0.2876555026,
0.4307295978,
0.2101834416,
1.0437300205,
0.596365869,
-0.0440853387,
0.7415877581,
0.3455292583,
-0.0080253007,
-0.9728853106,
-0.2732047141,
-0.4448456466,
-0.3055080175,
-0.0963288993,
-0.8167477846,
0.4645955563,
0.2073248327,
0.0491502732,
0.0569393933,
-0.0611030422,
0.3766984642,
0.4727651477,
-0.1415383965,
0.3719363809,
0.0041474416,
-0.5143672228,
-0.2599543333,
-0.4722639918,
-0.2616436183,
0.9696653485,
0.1789723635,
0.2435306907,
0.1321353167,
0.3054836094,
0.6708076596,
-0.3494261205,
-0.8016591668,
0.4677499831,
-0.202616021,
-0.3223320246,
-0.4872547388,
-0.4830323756,
-0.7953261733,
0.2127116024,
0.0964522958,
-0.7614846826,
-0.275282979,
0.1598552316,
-0.4344390035,
0.2017777115,
-0.5732533336,
0.6450865865,
-0.3787775636,
-0.1947890818,
-0.2899052501,
-0.9966596961,
-0.1877044141,
-0.3681828976,
0.2935308218,
-0.0540149473,
-0.3151728511,
1.4593167305,
-0.3539618254,
0.3081004322,
-0.273942709,
0.5100463033,
0.1312749684,
-0.0803091228,
0.2823600471,
0.0564899258,
0.2085180581,
0.2646402419,
-0.1756056249,
-0.5111834407,
-0.5633202195,
0.4207322896,
-0.5761735439,
-0.1068569273,
-0.3493392766,
-0.2950547636,
-0.1710982323,
0.1880836487,
0.2692281902,
0.2245129794,
-0.2841570973,
-0.184159562,
0.3802479506,
-0.2046652883,
0.7143010497,
0.6625087261,
-0.1841834486,
-0.4891987741,
0.4924300611,
0.2993166149,
0.3246662617,
0.1425915956,
0.0011164721,
-0.4630051553,
-0.6365690231,
-0.7431729436,
0.1166903377,
-0.5124776959,
0.0447758287,
-0.8116052747,
-0.1414859295,
-0.1126747876,
-0.3072470725,
-0.9125108719,
-0.5470113158,
-0.0836097524,
0.2176620364,
0.1614140421,
0.2636390924,
-0.0921424553,
0.6226297617,
-0.6089016199,
0.441354394,
-0.0660392195,
0.6546188593,
-0.0548962913,
-0.8358216882,
-0.4593248069,
-0.1576350629,
-0.0637649223,
-0.7019301653,
0.1382489502,
0.2059998959,
0.6310630441,
0.2137678117,
-0.1442974508,
0.9311606884,
-0.7558606863,
1.0067094564,
0.7464225888,
-1.274273634,
0.3463291228,
0.0359898135,
0.3196263611,
0.0329653695,
-0.1302237064,
-1.2266484499,
-0.5159372687,
-0.3833285868,
-1.2647919655,
0.6489344835,
0.654268682,
-0.106805481,
-0.2063594013,
0.0371836834,
0.0564110801,
0.2003219426,
-0.1854579002,
-0.4597016275,
-0.0367318951,
0.0407515205,
-0.2421666533,
-0.231131658,
0.1892460138,
-0.2207642049,
0.3413738012,
0.0944826528,
0.7629234195,
0.1903355569,
-0.1610658467,
-0.3889964819,
0.1560804546,
0.7184674144,
0.6397975683,
-0.1160351932,
0.0497970432,
0.2882413268,
-0.4858886003,
0.2709805369,
0.1417057067,
0.2191142142,
0.3199127913,
0.3226258159,
1.052277565,
0.3543143868,
-0.4453161657,
0.8645405769,
-0.1632460356,
0.3005073369,
-0.5844679475,
-0.6010300517,
-0.0551149957,
0.1440896243,
0.573543191,
0.2939811945,
0.0791206136,
0.019156713,
0.4175321758,
-0.0119599719,
-0.4306973219,
-0.530127883,
1.0312305689,
0.3896207809,
-0.6659582257,
0.4089620709,
-0.1187916026,
-0.57213521,
0.6680197716,
0.5643872023,
0.8792369366,
-0.5013206601,
-0.1341003478,
-0.0338705368,
0.1665120423,
0.0587389432,
0.2475696206,
-0.1165616363,
-0.3551647365,
-0.596783638,
-0.9061909914,
-0.1802176982,
-0.2338280976,
-0.6672250628,
0.4730716944,
0.1252274215,
-0.3653130829,
-0.0113878222,
-0.0330278762,
-0.5349544287,
0.0796780139,
-0.0254520383,
0.7996370196,
-0.9617348909,
0.5538581014,
0.6463211775,
-0.1722554266,
-0.4061343968,
-0.0547959283,
-0.0531054847,
-0.5194749236,
0.4559919238,
-0.0296262391,
-0.3361903131,
0.0654108673,
0.1873257756,
-0.5040432215,
0.8074759841,
-0.0121377185,
-0.3770109117,
-0.1598691642,
-0.056432087,
0.5437018275,
-0.3407539725,
0.3352103233,
0.6032488346,
0.2601271868,
-0.0043455716,
-1.341121316,
-0.2006553113,
-0.3962377608,
0.0322355516,
0.1882585883,
-0.7465563416,
0.7682989836,
-0.0517497919,
-0.3381141126,
0.2403326184,
0.7247908115,
-0.1902584136,
0.6383810043,
0.7842972279,
0.3524379134,
0.6155683994,
-0.0056339107,
0.8003490567,
-0.2771326602,
0.0662697554,
1.0004644394,
0.2698678672,
0.9301903248,
0.8105328679,
-0.5183673501,
-0.2144358307,
0.788523674,
0.3424108028,
0.4504185617,
0.2920474708,
-0.307736665,
-0.1017223448,
-0.088164404,
-0.4860690832,
0.4296777248,
0.3341484368,
-0.2458078861,
0.3087956011,
0.299086839,
0.1412240565,
0.1066877171,
-0.0418558568,
0.59538728,
-0.0151396906,
-0.6770963669,
0.4456938803,
0.1097097471,
0.7398074865,
-0.6122745275,
0.2956892252,
-0.6563848853,
-0.1762121916,
-0.0945265815,
-0.6489498019,
0.566315949,
0.1324838847,
-0.4029592276,
-0.1722135097,
-0.0732866898,
-0.4025184512,
-0.2676734924,
0.5811340809,
0.640877068,
0.4127898216,
0.0186915975,
-0.6335670352,
0.2503405213,
-0.2722829282,
-0.2857201099,
-0.0373873301,
0.4168993235,
-0.1870189309,
0.7724536061,
0.5798635483,
0.5128580928,
0.6392023563,
0.0370281748,
0.721352756,
-0.5320026875,
-1.0756549835,
-0.8130829334,
0.2790318131,
-0.0753158703,
-0.4447346628,
0.6025207043,
0.9069321156,
0.6122667789,
0.3078152537,
0.5279781222,
-0.0966859758,
0.7048671246,
-0.6312265396,
0.8467811942,
-0.7604286671,
0.3887950182,
-0.6255192161,
-0.9365341663,
-0.4397196174,
0.5101628304,
0.2042400539,
-0.2937098742,
1.2014290094,
0.4307082891,
-0.3085152209,
-0.2311144769,
0.5590898395,
-0.0612832271,
0.3629432321,
0.5742033124,
0.505503118,
-0.4357571006,
0.7614935637,
0.0294445623,
-0.2394792587,
-0.067679733,
-0.4865609407,
-0.6252840757,
-0.6221789718,
-0.3682949841,
-0.2353907079,
0.4359696805,
0.8337696195,
0.6554842591,
-0.5373738408,
-0.4072281718,
-0.1220356524,
-0.1767946035,
-0.5000036359,
-0.1210818887,
0.5999045372,
-0.2707546949,
-0.8173598647,
0.4778751433,
0.2406869382,
0.3869923651,
-0.0475923643,
-0.4128499627,
-0.0994174853,
0.0979344845,
0.0814079642,
0.2456533313,
-0.8742359877,
-0.2902025878,
-0.0586750433,
-0.0551487841,
0.2268957645,
0.9285117984,
-0.6194394827,
1.1363482475,
0.1392082125,
0.5132296681,
0.3770826459,
0.0088590905,
0.5482591987,
-1.0626875162,
0.5540325046,
0.1977675855,
0.1209786311,
0.3106374741,
-0.107349351,
0.4489797056,
0.7603889108,
-0.527443707,
-0.8578286171,
0.0639247298,
-0.9685406685,
0.3913536072,
0.8807651997,
-0.5401214957,
0.2310977131,
-0.3258032501,
-0.0801713318,
0.7163569331,
-0.689963758,
0.6244364381,
1.0223995447,
-0.0760360807,
0.1603057981,
-0.8169310689,
0.3770784736,
0.5728173852,
-0.4235512316,
-0.1335134059,
0.220858559,
-0.0705711693,
0.1768074036,
1.1018688679,
-0.2550976276,
0.4408047199,
0.451931417,
-0.2856765389,
-0.1612240821,
-0.342648387,
0.0095365206,
-0.3550667763,
0.0138670048,
-0.6594159007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14324v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14324v1
|
Large Language Models as Topological Structure Enhancers for Text-Attributed Graphs
| 2023-11-24T07:53:48 | 2023-11-24T07:53:48 |
Shengyin Sun, Yuxiang Ren, Chen Ma, Xuecang Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The latest advancements in large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized
the field of natural language processing (NLP). Inspired by the success of LLMs
in NLP tasks, some recent work has begun investigating the potential of
applying LLMs in graph learning tasks. However, most of the existing work
focuses on utilizing LLMs as powerful node feature augmenters, leaving
employing LLMs to enhance graph topological structures an understudied problem.
In this work, we explore how to leverage the information retrieval and text
generation capabilities of LLMs to refine/enhance the topological structure of
text-attributed graphs (TAGs) under the node classification setting. First, we
propose using LLMs to help remove unreliable edges and add reliable ones in the
TAG. Specifically, we first let the LLM output the semantic similarity between
node attributes through delicate prompt designs, and then perform edge deletion
and edge addition based on the similarity. Second, we propose using
pseudo-labels generated by the LLM to improve graph topology, that is, we
introduce the pseudo-label propagation as a regularization to guide the graph
neural network (GNN) in learning proper edge weights. Finally, we incorporate
the two aforementioned LLM-based methods for graph topological refinement into
the process of GNN training, and perform extensive experiments on four
real-world datasets. The experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of
LLM-based graph topology refinement (achieving a 0.15%--2.47% performance gain
on public benchmarks).
|
[
-0.1117353663,
-1.0009061098,
0.4852619171,
-0.441450119,
-0.4993918836,
0.3943879902,
-0.3353003263,
-0.709410131,
0.512234807,
0.4366709888,
-0.3208865821,
-0.6988373399,
-0.4705252051,
0.3335365057,
-0.3074482381,
1.0540984869,
0.1509639025,
-0.1955124736,
-0.1059737578,
0.1794213057,
-0.2197314352,
-0.4451318085,
-0.7714249492,
-0.4745591283,
0.8188400865,
0.2180200815,
0.7049147487,
0.7388215065,
0.4516920745,
0.4231260717,
-0.5517374873,
0.7396252155,
-0.7699583173,
-0.0254034773,
-0.0339540914,
-0.3045952618,
-0.7798894048,
-0.205658704,
1.1240103245,
0.8506551981,
0.1613248289,
-0.0880751461,
0.2237728685,
0.5982233286,
-0.0153538724,
0.2533672452,
-0.915160954,
-0.1840489805,
-0.2233480811,
-0.3352045119,
-0.424869746,
-0.5082344413,
0.1217631176,
-0.6068329215,
0.2276645154,
0.3800216615,
0.9696276188,
0.1929798424,
-0.3937043846,
-0.18624942,
-0.672414422,
0.324652493,
-0.6003720164,
0.5352393389,
0.2974998057,
-0.0662587956,
-0.4779264927,
-1.1059792042,
-0.3772551715,
-0.115043357,
-0.4098172784,
-0.1964517832,
0.0114668347,
0.2664686143,
0.2084889114,
0.442056179,
-0.4550686479,
0.3619840443,
-0.2855065167,
-0.133229509,
0.4978721738,
-0.0136721861,
0.2613832355,
-0.2556628287,
-0.2242926806,
-0.0530943163,
-0.837698102,
-0.2918341756,
0.3886326849,
0.5527793765,
0.2462836653,
0.5515488386,
-0.0948461741,
0.9252604842,
-0.2796126008,
-0.2185898125,
0.453864038,
-0.2438702583,
-0.1292585433,
-0.1098347902,
0.6867979765,
0.134764567,
0.4384414256,
-0.4963420033,
-0.2112374455,
-0.2285325676,
0.252723217,
-0.6622899771,
-0.4801720679,
-0.063433297,
-0.2898649871,
-0.2785364091,
-0.0706918091,
-0.4545805156,
-0.3782667518,
-0.4400742054,
0.1208169907,
-0.3631331027,
-0.1893749237,
0.092560038,
-0.1622193307,
0.0412517786,
0.3659784198,
-0.2942887545,
0.4786418974,
0.6670551896,
0.9799664617,
-0.1037406921,
-0.0073837293,
-0.3877415955,
0.2448634356,
-0.3574418426,
0.6809257865,
-0.6542545557,
-0.3276418746,
-0.1401335895,
0.1084938422,
0.0745287091,
-0.3915787041,
0.6655173302,
-0.6926162839,
-0.0614825822,
-0.0762455016,
-0.5668071508,
-0.1558487862,
0.4166705906,
-0.641646564,
1.1700325012,
0.011023826,
-1.0772999525,
-0.032139875,
-0.3257845044,
-0.6941397786,
0.2693222761,
0.009419539,
-0.6464539766,
-0.0619504154,
0.1892561316,
0.3825373352,
-0.2478776276,
0.2008245885,
-0.2910075486,
-0.4136016667,
0.0771729946,
0.005585731,
0.418541491,
-0.1298645139,
-0.0609665401,
0.2571963966,
-0.6711984873,
0.0899691582,
0.2705509365,
-0.2626472116,
-0.4410330355,
0.2959324419,
-0.1694406122,
0.038037952,
-0.0736990198,
-0.6080375314,
0.2874015868,
-0.7291591763,
0.5029726624,
0.9045680165,
0.0392544195,
0.3761075735,
-0.3592518568,
0.1169383675,
-0.4274203479,
-0.2463905215,
0.0988160148,
-0.5483449697,
-0.6871378422,
-0.4624373019,
0.2506626248,
0.2894878387,
-1.1354857683,
0.6045133471,
-0.4769616425,
-0.5617427826,
-0.0637931749,
0.1379739046,
0.3410143852,
0.932764709,
0.4805574119,
-0.3021445572,
-0.4559321404,
-0.5466303229,
-0.1375721395,
-0.1566644013,
0.0732297599,
0.6037785411,
0.281236887,
-0.2296111137,
1.0707443953,
-0.8875353336,
-0.505579412,
-0.3273161352,
-0.0800051391,
0.2916102409,
0.2071736604,
0.3678587377,
-0.7122898102,
-0.4078246951,
0.0470916554,
-0.3466315567,
-0.1282411218,
0.3564973772,
-0.0413940623,
-0.0217805132,
0.6152231097,
-0.5248121023,
0.254065603,
0.2299550176,
-0.1041313782,
0.6599994898,
-0.1215039417,
-0.2901206911,
-1.0344145298,
-0.0341984741,
0.0807191953,
-0.6604888439,
-0.6319682002,
0.1499408633,
-0.2899132967,
-0.1243234575,
-0.0952486992,
0.7374127507,
-0.668902576,
-0.1280351877,
-0.4409725666,
0.5481183529,
0.0068385419,
0.4312748313,
0.0550606288,
0.3198235035,
0.5688450336,
-0.5716098547,
0.4693203568,
0.1052581146,
-0.1229269132,
0.3533350527,
-0.7768531442,
0.3860701919,
-0.3697731197,
0.6711236238,
-1.2320479155,
-0.0644074529,
0.3197642267,
-0.3826075494,
0.5994176269,
-0.3057361245,
-0.8438493013,
-0.5779258013,
-0.288308382,
0.2567324936,
0.4317865074,
-0.6281784773,
0.5887667537,
0.4006808698,
-0.106126979,
-0.222452566,
-0.4505674541,
0.1475098133,
-0.2215659022,
-0.6211628318,
0.5194622874,
-0.0197633859,
0.0996977761,
0.1123863608,
-0.0053886469,
0.0515940599,
0.2628843486,
0.0987989083,
0.1215324998,
-0.1178242713,
0.630454421,
-0.2038460076,
-0.2443959713,
-0.1516963691,
-0.9187386632,
0.7016467452,
-0.0837742835,
0.0248641539,
-0.2961387634,
-0.1290860921,
-0.0484544523,
-0.4739657938,
0.561740458,
0.7280425429,
-0.4354611635,
-0.4901562035,
-0.2778214514,
-0.3390885293,
-0.5320908427,
0.6178590059,
-0.3229652941,
-1.2398893833,
0.314818114,
-0.4841231108,
-0.1443183571,
0.3948226273,
0.2742569745,
-0.3156261742,
0.5681267977,
0.597207725,
-0.1712337285,
0.4831451476,
-0.3962206841,
0.4346773624,
-1.0307204723,
-0.1322349608,
-0.6577755809,
-0.5399033427,
-0.7045347095,
-0.5836026669,
0.4027544856,
0.1253173053,
0.0926031619,
0.2291179299,
-0.5942550898,
0.5378097296,
0.2419964224,
0.3927037418,
0.3161684573,
0.3128704727,
-0.1766112149,
0.1188564226,
-0.7145622969,
-0.321172595,
0.7369701862,
0.4469701648,
0.9366748333,
0.0469911061,
0.5351762176,
0.0815362856,
0.2879441082,
-0.7398742437,
0.6176275611,
-0.2622545063,
-0.0842748955,
-0.450670898,
-0.8214122653,
-0.8414420485,
0.1005176008,
-0.3252284229,
-0.9626395702,
-0.0518703982,
0.2900343537,
0.3182969987,
0.5826680064,
-0.4734716713,
0.399091959,
-0.1343267411,
-0.2310005873,
-0.0174354948,
-0.6065180302,
0.1013788432,
-0.0407379121,
0.2213463336,
0.1339343488,
0.0486115403,
0.5506175756,
-0.4770445228,
1.1152793169,
0.0434021093,
-0.1214979663,
0.3632142544,
0.010768339,
0.9834560156,
0.0063803978,
-0.0947133675,
0.1314428449,
-0.6676084399,
0.0223247577,
-0.626429081,
0.660426259,
-0.7532590032,
-0.5870303512,
-0.0802031606,
-0.5472308397,
-0.1959763318,
0.4605942369,
0.0860815346,
0.8482483029,
-0.0156631079,
0.2353651822,
0.6264384985,
-0.0703973323,
0.2713734806,
0.1181072965,
-0.2321261317,
-0.4338769019,
0.95313555,
0.2151045799,
0.3180843294,
0.5334838629,
0.4182952046,
-0.4426474869,
-0.7679679394,
-0.0124908239,
0.5955036879,
-0.745821774,
-0.4128278494,
-0.8690639138,
-0.484764874,
-0.4425067604,
0.0094661713,
-0.1271431297,
-0.5735488534,
-0.3329080045,
-0.4514458776,
0.6184463501,
0.92707026,
0.1676833183,
0.6109885573,
-0.4342583716,
0.3188974857,
0.0983900726,
0.5667669177,
0.1432416439,
-0.4925734401,
-0.2148235887,
-0.1043088362,
-0.1361165792,
-0.7119675279,
0.1264179498,
0.3775418997,
0.396368742,
0.1385374218,
0.0226309318,
0.5871314406,
-0.7589802146,
0.3727631271,
0.0133836409,
-0.6762868166,
0.2511589825,
-0.4472773969,
0.0290748607,
0.0720510483,
0.4915597439,
-0.3975756764,
-0.4846405983,
-0.5712390542,
-0.9244459271,
0.6359294653,
0.35818398,
0.0486092195,
-0.0548606068,
0.6953011155,
-0.379232645,
0.0024124519,
-0.9689157605,
-0.3922107518,
0.0384369381,
-0.1522315443,
-0.184266001,
-0.3296061456,
-0.0251750331,
-0.2276742011,
0.6383990049,
-0.3350458741,
-0.0151575869,
0.4001147151,
-0.0822128057,
0.04109044,
0.054205969,
0.1781477928,
0.6650479436,
-0.0889477134,
0.4363341331,
0.2477778196,
-0.2247092873,
0.0033005027,
0.2047920376,
-0.2801252902,
0.0216293205,
0.4870282114,
0.6765075326,
-0.0346147269,
-0.0974902362,
0.2064525336,
0.0400931798,
0.1026265994,
0.1940769702,
-0.0374581441,
0.3119930625,
-0.0276543554,
0.3166324198,
-0.3411054313,
0.1279976517,
-0.4208002985,
0.391066283,
0.6563532948,
-0.512373507,
-0.3117848337,
0.2419125438,
0.2455477417,
-0.6371369362,
0.5529857278,
-0.4159668982,
-0.9208116531,
0.4934723973,
0.9486237168,
0.7347038388,
-0.1516558379,
0.2145219892,
0.474717766,
0.5770290494,
0.3329103887,
-0.0474713668,
0.0189854484,
-0.741422534,
-0.420989722,
-0.6375651956,
-0.0513473116,
-0.197821036,
0.0953775793,
0.44305709,
-0.5816028714,
-0.2939175069,
-0.2644874156,
0.1174488962,
-0.3061592877,
0.3825544715,
-0.0388339683,
0.6968795061,
-0.5735143423,
0.768104136,
0.734551549,
0.1401760578,
-0.912310183,
-0.1416678876,
-0.1137869135,
-0.5214319229,
0.5513296127,
0.0855889767,
-0.3876995444,
0.3220064342,
-0.532274425,
-1.0269941092,
0.9117613435,
0.0970737711,
-0.54493016,
-0.2719824016,
0.209592551,
0.7219790816,
-0.3017833233,
0.3713769019,
0.0464618281,
0.2805138826,
0.4032581449,
-0.6986376047,
0.1594916433,
-0.1257626414,
0.0913569629,
0.5187003016,
-0.5069820881,
0.6512871981,
-0.1892241687,
-0.3773599267,
-0.0187090822,
0.6495695114,
0.0798155144,
-0.1347609162,
0.6208726168,
0.6485990286,
1.0700315237,
-0.2490367144,
1.1915510893,
-0.1284464747,
0.3617964387,
1.3009970188,
-0.0693561286,
0.4544880688,
0.0636343658,
0.1594684869,
0.6056227684,
0.6714785099,
0.1746704578,
0.1217264384,
0.629361093,
0.2759895325,
-0.1535897255,
-0.4970626533,
-0.3617167771,
0.2480717003,
0.4202305973,
-0.2749913037,
-0.2065033317,
-0.5138465762,
0.1132012382,
-0.0287810471,
-0.307623595,
0.7513026595,
0.3335248828,
-0.0452742912,
0.3455511332,
0.1599605829,
0.4041177928,
-0.6289865375,
-0.1525003016,
-0.0224312283,
0.1171304062,
-0.4069019258,
-0.7372718453,
0.2422920913,
-0.1480325758,
-0.0042043687,
-0.2005521953,
1.1260188818,
-0.4969912171,
-0.6249569058,
0.5719532371,
0.0934350938,
0.0195473712,
0.1091016456,
-0.3707726598,
0.0006684134,
-0.1759474128,
-0.0266235862,
-0.0488092899,
0.5362212658,
-0.0915195644,
0.6260344386,
0.8189584613,
0.3423815966,
-0.0670932308,
0.125405848,
1.3401607275,
-0.485752672,
-0.552536726,
-0.7698153853,
0.3730174899,
-0.2519235909,
-0.1274165064,
0.6733101606,
0.5174313188,
0.8155411482,
0.376684159,
0.2514802516,
0.1193616539,
0.4112589061,
-0.7170081735,
0.6499237418,
-0.628745079,
0.2080741674,
-0.7361090779,
-1.2742016315,
-0.4309698343,
0.3731201887,
-0.248725608,
0.2062245011,
0.6288236976,
0.7584953904,
0.0228432585,
-0.2454727143,
0.0263764672,
0.5662355423,
0.5777199864,
0.3754673898,
0.8667615652,
-0.2536176741,
0.4594047666,
0.0088260835,
-0.2540824115,
0.0498685911,
-0.9061871171,
-1.097527504,
-0.4484869242,
-0.287178576,
-0.3427745402,
0.0761282519,
0.5852586031,
0.701554358,
-0.2249376923,
-0.1659382135,
-0.0181276836,
0.6523692012,
0.2950057983,
-0.2314340174,
0.5900287032,
-0.4210215807,
-0.53149122,
0.3976750672,
0.3471156955,
-0.0006246946,
0.0763734952,
-0.0220215507,
-0.4127402604,
-0.2012187243,
0.6069105268,
-0.0418858416,
-0.5070390105,
-0.5264855623,
0.0144529082,
-0.113472335,
0.251739651,
0.7915380597,
-0.6829012036,
0.4066547453,
0.6729487181,
0.679364264,
0.5501484275,
0.2464111,
0.4096636772,
-1.1395665407,
-0.0192929618,
0.1905424446,
0.4751493633,
0.5671235323,
-0.3747605681,
0.5888575912,
0.4085295796,
-0.452763319,
-0.7850373387,
0.3859667778,
-0.6616185904,
-0.2703739703,
1.2047495842,
-0.052010864,
-0.3177684546,
-0.0763903558,
-0.177783221,
0.3386622965,
-0.0526041985,
0.3464306891,
0.3351038098,
0.1002912521,
-0.0717196763,
0.1830037534,
0.574492991,
-0.0617824979,
-0.8300853968,
0.043639835,
0.4673509598,
0.1326061338,
0.3297447562,
0.5731803179,
-0.0356648527,
-0.2123705596,
-0.5268093944,
-0.087746352,
-0.2405173331,
-0.7492218614,
-0.0448501408,
0.003680154,
0.1405509561,
0.2798555791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14212v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14212v3
|
Annotation Sensitivity: Training Data Collection Methods Affect Model Performance
| 2023-11-23T21:54:22 | 2024-01-22T15:05:30 |
Christoph Kern, Stephanie Eckman, Jacob Beck, Rob Chew, Bolei Ma, Frauke Kreuter
|
stat.ML
|
stat.ML, cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ME
|
When training data are collected from human annotators, the design of the
annotation instrument, the instructions given to annotators, the
characteristics of the annotators, and their interactions can impact training
data. This study demonstrates that design choices made when creating an
annotation instrument also impact the models trained on the resulting
annotations. We introduce the term annotation sensitivity to refer to the
impact of annotation data collection methods on the annotations themselves and
on downstream model performance and predictions. We collect annotations of hate
speech and offensive language in five experimental conditions of an annotation
instrument, randomly assigning annotators to conditions. We then fine-tune BERT
models on each of the five resulting datasets and evaluate model performance on
a holdout portion of each condition. We find considerable differences between
the conditions for 1) the share of hate speech/offensive language annotations,
2) model performance, 3) model predictions, and 4) model learning curves. Our
results emphasize the crucial role played by the annotation instrument which
has received little attention in the machine learning literature. We call for
additional research into how and why the instrument impacts the annotations to
inform the development of best practices in instrument design.
|
[
-0.8253802061,
-0.6769608855,
-0.0194244795,
-0.2030780911,
-0.3523825705,
-0.2797790766,
-0.1852319688,
-1.0863600969,
-0.3581551313,
0.2861897051,
-0.3016347289,
-0.1640019119,
-0.8662678003,
0.0241427924,
-0.346634388,
1.3573776484,
0.2511324883,
0.0078035765,
0.0460257679,
-0.3928004503,
-0.4143683612,
-0.8621248603,
-0.4165492356,
-0.223227188,
0.9519848228,
0.0065622586,
0.7591011524,
0.6593046188,
0.7744282484,
0.2312290668,
-0.2006290108,
-0.3954091668,
-0.3026790321,
0.2638103366,
-0.072477296,
-0.6747788191,
-0.0625965223,
0.1004773527,
0.3686735034,
0.488391906,
0.4512701631,
0.5353341103,
0.0633221641,
0.0338482782,
-0.8244886398,
-0.0216338895,
-0.5300050974,
-0.1646475643,
-0.5319934487,
0.0732170269,
-0.3930380344,
-0.1527749896,
0.4794321656,
-0.6736742854,
0.5042418838,
-0.1442448348,
0.6907530427,
0.5005980134,
-0.2747995853,
-0.3206089437,
-0.6659986973,
0.6671284437,
-0.5279348493,
0.1373182237,
0.4822833538,
0.1772591919,
0.3817347884,
-0.479737699,
-0.2875969112,
-0.0657278001,
-0.2114065588,
-0.2710251808,
0.1563603282,
-0.0009668724,
0.9715117812,
-0.056691207,
-0.1670276821,
0.5479336977,
-0.7165489793,
-0.276061058,
0.9683488607,
0.0423791297,
-0.1214297712,
-0.1537027508,
-0.3345964849,
-0.1728892624,
-0.4413016438,
0.2193452418,
0.535526216,
0.831543088,
0.0062675714,
0.2638669014,
0.14818497,
0.9004768729,
-0.2484021932,
0.1106428504,
0.3260428905,
0.251355648,
0.0267193317,
0.0660595968,
0.4370900989,
0.4465101659,
0.5590138435,
0.2751360536,
-0.3231041729,
0.2562270463,
0.628241241,
-0.6979060769,
-0.5045946836,
-0.1611503959,
-0.4432071149,
-0.650960505,
-0.0874899104,
-0.6513649225,
-0.6429232955,
-0.5310250521,
0.5921015739,
-0.137452513,
-0.2840001583,
-0.708565414,
-0.3286252916,
0.112676762,
0.2235490829,
-1.1024909019,
0.1928765178,
0.7239873409,
0.7171765566,
-0.077598691,
-0.108763583,
-0.4504905641,
-0.1359049231,
-0.1860144585,
0.6898226142,
-0.684242785,
-0.530906558,
0.0066655409,
-0.2446033508,
-0.0205694158,
-0.4543552101,
0.7581551671,
-0.3785690069,
-0.1413370371,
-0.3007813692,
-0.7135052085,
-0.3743365109,
-0.2409911901,
-0.7962958217,
0.7603690624,
0.2095315754,
-1.0254566669,
0.8737022877,
-0.9525411725,
-0.7977436781,
0.1621666402,
-0.1657086462,
-0.6592056155,
0.429138571,
0.057045266,
0.4181655347,
0.2251411676,
-0.1847233176,
-0.602651298,
-0.5668011904,
0.4991595149,
-0.2227426618,
0.9363793731,
0.31311813,
-0.372954458,
0.016868094,
-0.798433423,
-0.1425623298,
-0.1311286986,
-0.3716968596,
-0.5496426821,
0.0526772328,
0.5220883489,
0.2368318588,
-0.29978773,
-0.6225801706,
-0.2651766539,
-0.0525156409,
0.3058452308,
1.1326200962,
-0.1099213809,
-0.0413078666,
-0.4888423681,
0.4555009305,
-0.2022154927,
0.3201949596,
-0.0417710207,
-0.510402739,
-0.6089474559,
-0.1835960746,
0.553165257,
0.3867991567,
-0.1091149375,
0.1813193858,
0.1649280638,
-0.5477494597,
-0.815815568,
-0.0228213836,
0.3091221452,
0.6438807845,
0.1167569309,
-0.3634374142,
-0.6845671535,
-0.9637361765,
-0.3437897563,
-0.4651052654,
-0.0233326126,
0.3173153996,
0.6400570869,
0.5005680919,
0.8170567155,
-0.1456630975,
-0.1782336384,
0.1914366186,
0.6561195254,
-0.4380209446,
0.5414247513,
0.8838858604,
-0.9820216298,
-0.196824953,
-0.3688437045,
-0.4892409146,
-0.1462458223,
0.1004474461,
0.0088838227,
0.4987784326,
0.1145668775,
-0.1449113935,
0.765357852,
0.3336389065,
0.0470631607,
0.3202666342,
0.4224637747,
0.0634221062,
-0.5992845297,
0.2448227555,
0.0545791835,
0.2155207545,
-0.7269178629,
-0.0261235554,
0.0051973462,
0.0078910459,
-0.6573653817,
0.2367491871,
0.1365860403,
0.1035765186,
-0.324776113,
-0.0255882386,
-0.1406613886,
0.1143973246,
0.3328007758,
0.7957120538,
0.2172959298,
-0.7618237138,
0.118535392,
0.3025191724,
-0.3679538965,
0.8078802824,
-0.589759469,
0.2643987238,
-0.1106841266,
-0.2533220053,
-0.8485888839,
-0.2986364067,
0.2040572315,
-0.7690403461,
0.4377595782,
-0.1619388014,
-0.1105698571,
-0.522634387,
-0.1848608851,
0.0947181508,
0.2771704197,
-0.4270217121,
0.3428418636,
0.467766732,
0.0271749832,
-0.5229127407,
-1.0983972549,
-0.3134858608,
-0.6303238869,
-0.4716062546,
-0.327329427,
-0.0119831422,
-0.3673336804,
-0.2684397101,
0.1936806589,
0.01858503,
0.8308991194,
0.6260553002,
0.1623623967,
0.0626566857,
0.6689822674,
-0.3363012671,
-0.0732427984,
0.4120598137,
0.2015445679,
0.047327809,
0.1580551267,
-0.2041588873,
-0.4266475439,
0.3322859704,
0.09917593,
-0.2474828064,
0.6677369475,
0.7534478307,
-0.3110902905,
0.0310459696,
-0.507741034,
-0.5486246943,
-0.3975067437,
0.4237380922,
-0.511495471,
-0.911346674,
0.5667545199,
0.4253418744,
0.3072779775,
0.4929940701,
0.5171775222,
-0.3237583637,
0.9826746583,
0.7064308524,
-0.2576010823,
0.7591688633,
0.1081140116,
-0.0301492289,
-0.8341835737,
0.1304588467,
-0.910918951,
-0.6423620582,
-0.8427886367,
0.1388726532,
0.0346250795,
-0.2823379934,
-0.3153324127,
0.0366870239,
-0.7727297544,
0.1563311666,
0.650642097,
0.069838956,
-0.077052556,
0.0243457966,
0.4012560248,
-0.3345732987,
-0.3727390468,
-0.7445117235,
1.471578002,
0.5352381468,
0.5523758531,
-0.0293820314,
0.48579368,
0.3847109377,
0.7462717295,
-0.6375457644,
0.0695803612,
0.052431576,
-1.2884641886,
-0.231507957,
-0.1798762232,
-0.5502052307,
0.0583795607,
-0.1831393391,
-1.027477622,
0.3386182189,
0.3763564229,
-0.5939198136,
0.2041825354,
-0.8136156797,
0.6716638207,
-0.421824187,
-0.4355208874,
0.2071494758,
-0.8884424567,
0.063226901,
-0.3765091598,
0.2139365375,
-0.3323103189,
0.0165071711,
1.005685091,
0.0543928295,
1.1020166874,
-0.5493180752,
0.1073843464,
0.3933370113,
0.0927978903,
0.2668542266,
-0.3245019615,
-0.4880026281,
0.2645412683,
-0.2939889133,
-0.2309821993,
-0.2855356634,
0.2063656747,
-0.8288995028,
-0.5656471848,
-0.1923619062,
-0.7191708684,
-0.0147757661,
-0.011721638,
0.460568279,
0.2114355117,
0.0580298044,
0.1784675717,
0.4014062583,
0.2118045241,
0.442065388,
0.460314095,
0.0726153404,
-0.0102122836,
0.7293438911,
0.6445757151,
0.4762809277,
-0.0762795508,
0.0092122275,
-0.1330897659,
-0.595574379,
-0.325017184,
-0.2593064308,
-0.7524330616,
-0.1799355298,
-0.3387071192,
0.0034481185,
-0.3101856411,
-0.1189948171,
0.0565359704,
-0.6413152218,
-0.5435988307,
-0.487760514,
0.9180491567,
0.7015109658,
-0.2421603054,
0.5006487966,
-0.2597921491,
-0.1112297624,
0.2088304311,
0.2539165914,
-0.1811484993,
-0.8108576536,
-0.3545668125,
-0.1348538995,
-0.3594056368,
-0.6069623828,
-0.0960143283,
0.0522065721,
0.4710155725,
0.396359235,
0.2356915176,
0.3374162316,
0.142356813,
0.6389977932,
-0.3952291012,
-0.8277059197,
0.7982471585,
-0.4996611178,
0.0310563836,
0.6715375185,
0.5093411803,
-0.2509972751,
-0.7073208094,
-0.5133962035,
-0.7220193744,
0.9349866509,
0.184317559,
0.2009717822,
0.0200949777,
0.4275462329,
0.3420889378,
0.1804170609,
-0.575936377,
-0.1664288044,
-0.2785086036,
-0.0294713788,
-0.126499027,
-0.3451518118,
-0.3729662895,
-0.1728917211,
0.5533367991,
-0.0803936571,
-0.0611730963,
-0.0960385799,
-0.1122030541,
-0.3172243237,
-0.0027823208,
0.5228094459,
0.7374040484,
-0.3544085026,
0.0040405011,
0.1970739961,
-0.373537004,
-0.0812475383,
0.3294487596,
-0.630017817,
-0.0728273317,
0.4936619997,
1.0655823946,
-0.166345939,
-0.3111328185,
0.2707176208,
0.146081537,
-0.2402238846,
-0.2464015931,
0.3317703307,
-0.1855175942,
0.1981418878,
0.2069549859,
0.0442296229,
0.3720903993,
-0.0290548578,
0.2763248086,
0.1870662868,
-0.4629310668,
-0.1978353858,
0.8958150148,
0.2542921901,
-0.5704885721,
0.7656368613,
0.375803262,
-0.4999670982,
0.7236237526,
0.3320054114,
0.5381061435,
-0.5755537748,
0.0637775958,
0.3069484532,
0.4946780205,
0.6619864106,
0.0616441481,
-0.1380912215,
-0.3791094124,
-0.2332750857,
-0.3569251895,
-0.3869960308,
-0.0357506163,
-1.1236693859,
0.1403683275,
-0.457174778,
-0.7211163044,
0.4342307448,
0.0060967496,
-0.7733913064,
0.4237755835,
0.5690039992,
0.7292582393,
-1.2610808611,
0.3672917485,
0.8099282384,
-0.6169553995,
-0.7590071559,
-0.2549447119,
0.2135171741,
-0.5460131764,
0.693163693,
0.4892401695,
0.2947506905,
-0.2033549547,
-0.475625813,
-0.5609123111,
0.6313890219,
0.3252726793,
-0.5377129316,
0.4446573555,
0.407526046,
0.6848620772,
-0.2285602391,
0.446556896,
0.9255132079,
0.5706935525,
-0.3352025151,
-1.0249382257,
-0.0692360774,
-0.2080239803,
0.0823292434,
0.268645972,
-0.6796106696,
0.9384140968,
-0.1384441257,
0.1188300326,
-0.0317198597,
0.3018031418,
0.1037254184,
0.3485942483,
0.4629813731,
0.4697497189,
0.7768778205,
-0.2781331241,
1.2378367186,
0.0624741353,
0.2834372222,
1.1022399664,
-0.214388147,
0.8346289992,
0.3710129857,
-0.0842968002,
0.1610083282,
0.7888946533,
-0.1923091561,
0.3653825521,
0.508439064,
-0.4268369973,
-0.0906260461,
-0.4175847769,
-0.477494359,
0.6032705903,
0.4259507954,
-0.6962588429,
0.0903635696,
0.373544395,
0.0440106243,
0.1003092155,
-0.27842924,
0.797000885,
-0.1321862638,
-0.3297081888,
0.314622432,
-0.3988842666,
0.4844638407,
-0.2806848884,
0.1929520667,
0.1149707437,
0.2710266113,
-0.3051731288,
-0.7145010829,
0.3570194244,
0.0268752333,
-0.1966453344,
0.1759722382,
0.6538912058,
0.0454629026,
-0.6285834312,
0.3179174364,
0.0509659797,
0.2648506165,
-0.0294051301,
-0.5887208581,
0.5787084699,
-0.1517020017,
-0.5925478935,
0.2205768526,
0.3698572516,
-0.2147312611,
0.4146845341,
0.3672050834,
-0.0669238418,
0.1922415942,
0.1616559625,
0.8962402344,
-0.3651275039,
-0.0388110951,
-0.6716070175,
0.609246552,
-0.0338211395,
-0.550074935,
0.4791308641,
0.4563207924,
1.2835388184,
0.0774753317,
1.1173366308,
-0.1150999963,
1.0599377155,
-0.1079982519,
0.7651020885,
-0.2908599973,
-0.0374009125,
-0.3552648127,
-0.4993407428,
-0.5484301448,
0.9403698444,
-0.7646631598,
0.4733611047,
0.0617611669,
0.6213551164,
0.2522158027,
0.414812237,
0.1533336937,
-0.03858006,
0.4441436529,
0.2356569469,
0.7745139003,
-0.311529398,
0.3841305971,
-0.8429229259,
-0.0203208998,
-0.3270226419,
-0.6963078976,
-0.9608492255,
-0.4617853761,
-0.462659955,
-0.0054695192,
0.2697016001,
0.5613148808,
0.7415894866,
-0.9153012633,
-0.1718017906,
0.2267127484,
-0.0272668544,
0.0051256372,
-0.2630625963,
0.4194211662,
-0.4123766124,
-0.705147028,
-0.2839290798,
-0.3115783036,
0.1664713472,
-0.0975595787,
0.1444693655,
-0.1820082963,
-0.2383324653,
0.4627824426,
0.340002954,
-0.6204217672,
-0.7361047268,
-0.4413326085,
0.0574225523,
0.0233665556,
0.7978023291,
-0.7339621782,
0.7746705413,
-0.0196072869,
0.5104414225,
0.359479934,
0.1585804969,
0.3538554013,
-0.7349187732,
0.4376849234,
0.3918498158,
-0.0563049242,
0.4346107244,
-0.4039557874,
0.623221755,
0.0549746454,
-0.6171233058,
-1.0286422968,
0.1629809737,
-0.3507806063,
-0.0468559302,
0.6111246943,
-0.3080774844,
-0.1163686588,
-0.2738286257,
-0.2108157426,
0.4219291508,
-0.4678294957,
0.8914945126,
0.898414731,
-0.2963289618,
-0.3391779363,
-0.8182453513,
0.6101724505,
0.5525053144,
-0.4001522064,
0.3057438135,
0.6432235241,
0.2040915638,
0.2379075587,
0.1267856359,
0.0408279896,
0.4641797245,
0.1570425183,
0.3482971787,
-0.3447706401,
-0.1538278461,
-0.4745284319,
0.1881542504,
0.5029749274,
-0.3914672732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14199v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14199v2
|
A Systematic Review of Deep Learning-based Research on Radiology Report Generation
| 2023-11-23T20:52:44 | 2024-04-25T09:25:24 |
Chang Liu, Yuanhe Tian, Yan Song
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Radiology report generation (RRG) aims to automatically generate free-text
descriptions from clinical radiographs, e.g., chest X-Ray images. RRG plays an
essential role in promoting clinical automation and presents significant help
to provide practical assistance for inexperienced doctors and alleviate
radiologists' workloads. Therefore, consider these meaningful potentials,
research on RRG is experiencing explosive growth in the past half-decade,
especially with the rapid development of deep learning approaches. Existing
studies perform RRG from the perspective of enhancing different modalities,
provide insights on optimizing the report generation process with elaborated
features from both visual and textual information, and further facilitate RRG
with the cross-modal interactions among them. In this paper, we present a
comprehensive review of deep learning-based RRG from various perspectives.
Specifically, we firstly cover pivotal RRG approaches based on the
task-specific features of radiographs, reports, and the cross-modal relations
between them, and then illustrate the benchmark datasets conventionally used
for this task with evaluation metrics, subsequently analyze the performance of
different approaches and finally offer our summary on the challenges and the
trends in future directions. Overall, the goal of this paper is to serve as a
tool for understanding existing literature and inspiring potential valuable
research in the field of RRG.
|
[
-0.4110846817,
-0.5083483458,
0.4502994418,
-0.2611118257,
-0.5212967992,
-0.1255038828,
-0.2232502699,
-0.7873572111,
-0.060245119,
0.4676162601,
-0.6823920012,
-0.5862310529,
-0.8982282877,
0.0790184587,
-0.2009355277,
0.9571600556,
0.0829107985,
0.4128935039,
-0.1561755836,
0.0415754803,
-0.8367781639,
-0.0117194941,
-0.5836424828,
-0.4698710144,
0.6699050665,
0.310762465,
0.795986414,
0.759542644,
0.9548911452,
0.1149075553,
0.4553295374,
0.2937081456,
-0.1905553788,
0.464099884,
0.1415436119,
-0.0541195534,
-0.5296045542,
-0.1794555783,
0.3924872279,
0.6076903343,
-0.0522429869,
-0.0442204736,
-0.1888082474,
0.9573014975,
-0.5695641041,
0.0479947813,
-0.1667364389,
0.4022277296,
0.0035791707,
-0.6694204211,
-0.3667478859,
-0.2452808917,
0.465117991,
-0.4090418816,
0.6164698601,
-0.1690334678,
0.7218204737,
0.2999712229,
-0.3996070325,
-0.6585732698,
-0.8897114992,
0.6638128161,
-0.6437572837,
0.4271897078,
0.1532596201,
0.6164852977,
0.261074245,
-1.368111372,
0.0709294379,
-0.264775753,
-0.4392623603,
0.3947266638,
-0.1394503415,
0.0523052663,
0.0654977635,
0.5039544702,
-0.8678638935,
0.1591290683,
-0.3877862692,
0.1670809835,
0.9612648487,
0.4247480929,
0.2712976336,
-0.3353615105,
-0.5337895155,
-0.3924990594,
-0.537673533,
-0.3443030119,
-0.3280122578,
0.3784059286,
-0.0425733812,
0.2933028936,
-0.5855315924,
0.7106881738,
-0.0670674741,
-0.028647285,
0.4140496552,
-0.3549118936,
-0.4722532034,
0.292959094,
1.0185605288,
0.3880829811,
-0.0408551395,
0.0028803532,
-0.0391302109,
-0.1927113384,
0.4509957433,
-0.8156774044,
-0.1610180736,
-0.0660383105,
-0.9691647291,
-0.649269104,
-0.0429150648,
-0.6932729483,
-0.5012300014,
-0.3706535697,
-0.1120389551,
-0.5429615974,
-0.3955740929,
0.2305232733,
0.2288127095,
0.1928423643,
0.4783782363,
-0.352476567,
-0.0606396049,
0.569543004,
0.5403988361,
0.0905973092,
0.1026342809,
-0.4289090931,
0.0436447412,
-0.2659792304,
0.772772193,
-0.4632288814,
-0.5229403377,
0.1089119911,
-0.1586709768,
-0.0530666076,
-0.3708613813,
0.4490077794,
-0.541698873,
0.5635330677,
-0.094700478,
-0.1854510903,
-0.4553655386,
0.4311704934,
-0.5982786417,
0.6026245356,
0.0115119871,
-0.6830294132,
0.8273066878,
-0.2395369112,
-0.7863304615,
0.2926273942,
-0.6747633815,
-0.6697542071,
0.2007498443,
0.5817231536,
0.9000648856,
-0.7497340441,
0.3437587321,
0.2047311515,
0.0995565727,
0.2385645062,
-0.2149076164,
0.5140436292,
0.4267604351,
-0.3947251737,
0.2689452469,
-0.694832325,
0.3422792256,
0.0730639175,
0.1831431836,
0.0450221412,
-0.0264320597,
-0.1867958009,
0.2144787163,
-0.3431508541,
-0.2734052837,
-0.0268802494,
0.0475353114,
0.1142109483,
0.1663261354,
0.2673961222,
0.1650723964,
-0.6426469684,
0.8056184649,
-0.1204242483,
0.390668273,
-0.3582558632,
-0.3879045248,
-0.4346709549,
-0.3699583113,
0.5618098974,
0.4386437237,
-0.4424228072,
0.0440118797,
-0.348571986,
-0.5965292454,
-0.5247092843,
-0.1838967055,
0.4927501976,
0.6389257312,
0.3214717507,
-0.8185355663,
-0.7331624627,
-1.0016751289,
0.000794276,
0.10069938,
0.1106248051,
0.4956353307,
-0.0536230505,
-0.3531185985,
0.4811174273,
-0.53191787,
-0.8656554818,
-0.422003597,
0.4055589437,
-0.0725578815,
0.3461223245,
0.3740369976,
-0.6771717668,
-0.5841525197,
0.2940140963,
-1.0820548534,
0.3016304672,
-0.4848173857,
0.2952641547,
0.327488482,
0.8582758904,
-0.2714263201,
0.6559366584,
0.3377188742,
0.215679884,
0.2165308744,
-0.1666862071,
0.381891191,
-0.6488381624,
0.1134230793,
0.1955146641,
-0.2330891937,
-0.5250856876,
0.0727955848,
0.0032710135,
-0.1421533972,
-0.2268156558,
0.0781599507,
-0.728126049,
0.1381386667,
-0.1748923659,
-0.0462176092,
-0.0721723214,
0.0817074329,
0.2656715214,
0.0738356337,
0.5934212804,
-0.4572091103,
0.2661794126,
0.0786430314,
-0.3469458818,
-0.0205403566,
-0.5763078928,
0.1573536694,
-0.2571737468,
0.3689170778,
-0.8178930283,
-0.1810028851,
0.3445270658,
-0.7989794016,
0.9298965335,
-0.2311332524,
-0.3024875522,
-0.170600459,
-0.1433023512,
0.4716946781,
0.7631004453,
-0.012872519,
0.5837213397,
0.1070660204,
-0.2014892101,
-0.6665984392,
-0.9197968245,
0.2344341278,
0.1924680769,
-0.6439400911,
0.2251993269,
0.2991660535,
-0.1773573756,
0.2303113639,
0.2291291952,
0.0341985933,
-0.2415461987,
0.3195644021,
0.1290367097,
-0.4893917143,
0.0160979163,
-0.2707756162,
-0.2943935394,
0.2058376372,
0.1383113414,
0.3883815408,
-0.088997893,
-0.2651613355,
-0.3933519125,
0.2540671229,
0.1825215369,
-0.3010478318,
0.081681639,
0.9580658674,
-0.1559399217,
-0.436389029,
-0.5017566681,
-0.1968788505,
-0.3534152508,
0.5625265837,
0.0559963845,
-0.765827477,
0.1594014466,
-0.2137678117,
0.0036072573,
0.4786114693,
0.7604793906,
-0.1978040934,
0.7777832747,
0.7067373991,
0.3619194329,
0.2013124228,
-0.3773725331,
0.3383852541,
-0.8006685972,
-0.7030746937,
-0.254316628,
-0.4034228027,
-0.6037918925,
-0.4552892745,
0.2288811356,
-0.2214828432,
0.407485038,
-0.2268345952,
-1.0495445728,
0.1361212581,
0.1893542111,
0.169398725,
0.3606773615,
0.0239366554,
0.2347792834,
-0.2437799871,
-1.0493222475,
-0.1703271568,
1.4215404987,
0.3218076229,
0.9128997326,
-0.3556237221,
0.797588408,
0.4765671492,
0.4226651788,
-0.8910406828,
0.3942311704,
-0.2610321939,
-0.5551428795,
-0.3171265125,
-0.2475783527,
-1.222084403,
0.1134001091,
-0.2658251226,
0.2236919403,
0.1068938896,
0.046726495,
-0.5548309684,
0.1116545051,
-0.269864887,
0.4034321904,
-0.4786465764,
-0.2337116152,
-0.4871955812,
-0.8117050529,
0.5989757776,
0.3007943928,
0.1981394589,
-0.0599468015,
0.1492643505,
0.5251911283,
-0.1964340359,
0.9813607335,
-0.0594756007,
0.0276100878,
0.3538850546,
0.1490118951,
0.1201068535,
0.2927818298,
0.2835005522,
0.120163314,
-0.2576403618,
0.0239254739,
-0.3400685191,
0.6292122602,
-0.6896592379,
-0.3012462556,
-0.7506921887,
-0.7670683265,
-0.2660676539,
0.3253113329,
0.3940686584,
0.6863142848,
-0.3374027312,
0.2880509496,
0.8107360005,
-0.5556468368,
0.2747457623,
0.171437636,
-0.1430337429,
-0.7173870206,
0.8485119939,
0.1619343311,
-0.0150085986,
0.4975637197,
0.1638856381,
0.0514769554,
-0.9843038917,
-0.513232708,
0.2027969956,
-0.509491384,
-0.4444360137,
-0.5013215542,
-0.5120509267,
-0.5362493396,
-0.3227444887,
-0.2683823407,
-0.2120521367,
-0.181644246,
0.1004230306,
0.1600202322,
0.9351195097,
-0.218638286,
-0.0759004578,
-0.7335728407,
0.3354969323,
0.3278675973,
0.3422575593,
0.3384167254,
-0.1757700741,
-0.4484729469,
-0.2672265172,
-0.249117285,
-0.3059643209,
0.5762429833,
-0.1278764755,
0.4903924167,
0.2507053912,
0.1254208535,
0.6020271778,
-0.188217923,
0.5672531128,
0.6486294866,
-0.246556595,
0.6599152088,
-0.4670372009,
0.0776115656,
0.4770650268,
0.420486927,
-0.4586962759,
-0.0220790338,
-0.7631346583,
-1.12254107,
0.5254535079,
-0.1106671616,
-0.1646905988,
0.1076996997,
0.2561846375,
0.3215388358,
0.0360841602,
-0.3259191513,
-0.0939055309,
-0.1389239579,
0.004643417,
0.1267201006,
-0.2987458408,
-0.5429081917,
-0.0669704527,
0.5563423038,
-0.1401697546,
0.3062891364,
0.625865519,
-0.255402416,
-0.3151642978,
0.1679552794,
0.8230913877,
0.7822322249,
-0.314386189,
-0.0715363994,
-0.1113844961,
-0.3401217461,
-0.1930268407,
-0.1369845718,
-0.1077716798,
0.1620028913,
0.7482308149,
0.7162289023,
-0.1669070274,
-0.5167876482,
0.508949399,
-0.3145830333,
-0.820841074,
-0.4671100676,
0.0581699722,
-0.1702152193,
0.203629598,
0.4552570581,
0.2992803156,
0.1717205346,
-0.4259990454,
0.3901207149,
0.3213591874,
-0.8140723705,
0.0466190614,
0.3689204752,
0.2446055561,
0.029132016,
0.8357960582,
0.1745935231,
0.1072982103,
0.6973631978,
0.1331844628,
1.0369662046,
0.177066341,
0.2382454276,
0.4241570234,
0.4292290807,
0.1455934048,
0.001484717,
0.1456912905,
-0.4316045344,
-0.7377113104,
0.0635064989,
-0.2842165828,
0.4223865569,
-0.9951178432,
0.2269513607,
-0.7975883484,
-0.2222192287,
-0.1472851932,
0.0716726631,
-0.7894026041,
0.7255601287,
0.5161405802,
0.8082349896,
-0.3280385137,
0.5648602247,
0.5445381999,
-0.4285936654,
-0.7103222013,
-0.0270171743,
0.1077155322,
-1.0305743217,
0.8895277381,
0.0162552819,
-0.0201812945,
-0.3884726465,
-0.0771986321,
-0.6110351682,
1.4275146723,
-0.1336861104,
-0.5567531586,
-0.0625571162,
0.2557224929,
0.5291924477,
-0.5134385228,
0.3158783615,
0.1653071046,
0.4163538218,
0.0694743618,
-0.6123666167,
0.4876519442,
-0.1035520583,
-0.0602477565,
0.0618044585,
-0.7690098882,
0.367010504,
-0.320456475,
-0.2726179659,
-0.1410287023,
0.7191105485,
0.1259863675,
0.5070579052,
0.193961367,
0.7412755489,
0.2786503434,
0.1011900827,
1.1578071117,
-0.1844787747,
0.070690304,
1.1079132557,
-0.3192383051,
0.353020519,
0.1767122746,
0.0993515626,
0.5277659297,
0.4841572046,
-0.4845605791,
0.6338644028,
-0.1131075695,
-0.0172471646,
-0.2736757398,
-0.1642952859,
-0.8961976171,
0.2598710358,
0.2923566401,
-0.9665356278,
-0.3825689256,
-0.0256032869,
-0.2732563317,
-0.2247772962,
-0.2745195329,
1.0016587973,
0.1865828335,
-0.554790318,
0.6679527164,
-0.0646682605,
0.4772157967,
-0.8382610083,
-0.0393383093,
-0.1326884478,
0.2206391096,
-0.6185584068,
-0.6949155331,
0.4707601368,
-0.3218965232,
-0.2845331728,
-0.650220871,
1.0722411871,
-0.0162319969,
-0.235830158,
0.1639890224,
0.6658090949,
-0.2093016803,
0.3152326047,
-0.7296420932,
0.1954122484,
0.3103868961,
-0.4654852748,
0.6558222175,
0.602022171,
0.1304100901,
0.5526350141,
0.5393464565,
0.1770464778,
-0.0763959885,
0.1886365861,
0.8634246588,
-0.6346145272,
-0.2464806736,
-0.4929988384,
0.6600817442,
0.0778929293,
-0.4546302557,
0.5802811384,
0.580324769,
0.8969559669,
-0.0711330622,
1.1386681795,
-0.1904954463,
0.4616916478,
-0.5253756046,
0.8413938284,
-0.4800148308,
0.0637167841,
-0.0249544717,
-0.2839677036,
-0.6998614669,
0.4172608554,
-0.2722800672,
0.0274550822,
0.9000309706,
0.6506599784,
0.0610349439,
0.0237084106,
0.3446760774,
-0.1738057733,
0.2359409332,
0.3167769015,
0.6636509895,
-0.5536381006,
0.8044378757,
-0.4876255989,
-0.0727652013,
-0.3919194639,
-0.8073654175,
-0.7580190301,
-0.4349317849,
-0.7540331483,
-0.4899941981,
-0.1245292276,
0.3955404758,
1.0215214491,
-0.4785062075,
-0.1482612491,
-0.0521561392,
-0.2481328398,
-0.3005877435,
-0.2088682801,
0.6859706044,
-0.455037117,
-0.0712955669,
0.2005333751,
0.3141998947,
-0.2479315996,
-0.1302454621,
-0.1668019742,
0.107588321,
-0.351880461,
0.5781146884,
0.334731698,
-0.382966578,
0.1514611542,
-0.0379152559,
-0.3442299962,
0.1814090461,
1.3038537502,
-1.0864350796,
0.3270917535,
0.5817988515,
0.8038544655,
0.7349446416,
-0.3809426725,
0.5496011972,
-0.5311660767,
-0.1577556878,
0.7194707394,
0.0070951949,
0.2709304988,
-0.5098181963,
0.6821030974,
0.1295115799,
-0.6433007121,
-0.9237798452,
0.3847922385,
-1.1167733669,
-0.5169659257,
0.8152089715,
0.1664531976,
0.0492201634,
0.100188382,
0.0149571439,
0.328725487,
-0.2501618564,
0.7667219043,
0.0487905927,
-0.791213572,
-0.6619377136,
-0.601020515,
0.6796039939,
0.4726222456,
-0.6089046597,
0.0369149521,
0.5142733455,
0.2979716957,
0.0688187033,
0.5811556578,
-0.5593038201,
0.6105543971,
-0.1433086246,
0.2606512308,
-0.6329769492,
-0.1712498516,
-0.3581962585,
0.4381487966,
0.0281448998,
0.0005452231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14169v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14169v1
|
Evaluating GPT-4's Vision Capabilities on Brazilian University Admission Exams
| 2023-11-23T19:20:59 | 2023-11-23T19:20:59 |
Ramon Pires, Thales Sales Almeida, Hugo Abonizio, Rodrigo Nogueira
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent advancements in language models have showcased human-comparable
performance in academic entrance exams. However, existing studies often
overlook questions that require the integration of visual comprehension, thus
compromising the full spectrum and complexity inherent in real-world scenarios.
To address this gap, we present a comprehensive framework to evaluate language
models on entrance exams, which incorporates both textual and visual elements.
We evaluate the two most recent editions of Exame Nacional do Ensino M\'edio
(ENEM), the main standardized entrance examination adopted by Brazilian
universities. Our study not only reaffirms the capabilities of GPT-4 as the
state of the art for handling complex multidisciplinary questions, but also
pioneers in offering a realistic assessment of multimodal language models on
Portuguese examinations. One of the highlights is that text captions
transcribing visual content outperform the direct use of images, suggesting
that the vision model has room for improvement. Yet, despite improvements
afforded by images or captions, mathematical questions remain a challenge for
these state-of-the-art models. The code and data used on experiments are
available at https://github.com/piresramon/gpt-4-enem.
|
[
-0.4520364106,
-0.8905290961,
0.8443520665,
0.3253128231,
-0.2881044745,
-0.0005112295,
-0.080535464,
-0.5861693621,
-0.44051072,
0.4413935542,
-0.2227353901,
-0.4044345915,
-0.445091486,
0.5338704586,
-0.2658889592,
0.7944632173,
-0.6985924244,
0.1574874669,
-0.7342892289,
-0.0539233275,
-0.6646595001,
-0.1349640191,
-0.5966470838,
-0.170666635,
0.0816710889,
-0.034960974,
0.3306067288,
0.0944639444,
0.9493348002,
0.3319199979,
0.2136235535,
-0.1259831935,
-0.2220263928,
-0.2885340154,
-0.1066420227,
-0.2911636531,
-0.3898012638,
0.3482197523,
0.9899713397,
0.6851402521,
0.0071932171,
0.059217345,
0.4565242231,
0.4067023396,
-0.3576667309,
0.471613884,
-0.3091627657,
-0.1495513171,
0.0414458141,
-0.2170104086,
-0.2995487452,
-0.387401998,
0.5469138026,
-0.6725337505,
0.0299347192,
-0.3043111563,
1.144538641,
0.3649105728,
-0.4315479994,
-0.2029652596,
-0.4106988907,
0.5152203441,
-0.1038581207,
0.6436622739,
0.1331843138,
0.6054714918,
0.1965419501,
-0.7846223116,
-0.350884378,
-0.4165497124,
0.0719057098,
0.5221450329,
-0.3391090631,
0.2631905973,
0.17123954,
0.3281553388,
-1.0337508917,
-0.4377793372,
-0.80817312,
-0.2455004454,
0.0939373523,
-0.0401833095,
0.5420204401,
0.0940988734,
-0.4852952063,
-0.1490428299,
-0.5517857671,
-0.1722223014,
0.424405396,
-0.1733693331,
-0.1930712014,
0.3434681594,
-0.1934976429,
1.2365034819,
-0.5633743405,
0.2020658255,
0.0070202299,
-0.6043181419,
-0.3914527595,
-0.4333420098,
0.6215927601,
0.3873336017,
0.4432064593,
-0.0734122694,
-0.2290447503,
0.2614757717,
0.3434094489,
-0.8388585448,
-0.2267073095,
0.2473123521,
0.1980310678,
-0.1373743415,
0.2031651735,
-0.9480842352,
0.1246895418,
-0.4118021429,
0.7368857861,
-0.627397418,
0.0896131992,
0.2364854813,
-0.1459352523,
0.6035660505,
0.7919591665,
-0.2874399722,
0.3338905275,
0.5776653886,
0.8585989475,
-0.3008731306,
-0.4973943233,
-0.1835789382,
-0.1649887711,
-0.3085033894,
0.7070012689,
-0.8285697103,
-0.1160127521,
-0.1053332463,
-0.1617831141,
-0.3901893497,
-0.2902290523,
0.6629733443,
-0.7133712173,
0.5141515136,
-0.2110694349,
-0.2867901027,
-0.481623292,
0.7505825758,
-0.4580198824,
0.5417858958,
0.4013055265,
-0.3949270546,
0.2007557601,
-0.9267421365,
0.0202644859,
0.325274229,
-0.5785640478,
-0.2643928826,
-0.202986449,
0.3297801614,
0.0106156617,
-0.3052080274,
0.1515947729,
-0.0046261805,
-0.4400340021,
0.2650572956,
-0.5863242149,
0.6238853335,
0.0396137796,
-0.2078819275,
-0.0463622548,
-0.4656996727,
-0.1773133874,
0.312033236,
-0.3466924727,
-0.1726974547,
-0.4295226634,
-0.1060750037,
0.0424785614,
0.4288150966,
-0.6586464643,
0.247928679,
-0.3061176836,
0.3572707176,
0.6924470663,
0.030260453,
0.5146588087,
0.1771420091,
0.9496660829,
-0.0794306472,
0.4157147706,
-0.1872810572,
-0.9795764685,
-0.4316838086,
-0.0508165583,
0.6113456488,
0.5484652519,
-1.0360252857,
-0.397729516,
-0.2209255248,
-0.5008138418,
-0.4332688153,
-0.1534062326,
0.4727115035,
0.461964637,
0.2971479297,
-0.4005631506,
-0.1322465241,
-0.7236315608,
-0.2953116,
-0.1078209952,
0.0397602729,
0.3486385942,
0.9117275476,
-0.2112983465,
0.6564198732,
-0.434597075,
-0.2688940763,
-0.141836971,
-0.0380115509,
0.1453997791,
0.4153740704,
0.8004904389,
-0.9637526274,
-0.4295160174,
0.1670949608,
-1.0459089279,
-0.3114433885,
-0.0875674412,
-0.0633853823,
-0.151414603,
-0.0575459041,
-0.3288337588,
0.4137715399,
0.7597960234,
-0.5935883522,
0.5109747648,
-0.2878756225,
0.5445407033,
-0.322235465,
-0.2803195119,
0.3269336522,
-0.0465113968,
-0.5633377433,
0.5823129416,
0.1974306554,
-0.5644394755,
-0.2557499409,
0.6599287391,
-0.6637420654,
-0.3891337812,
0.0370462388,
0.3465253413,
0.356565088,
0.2461988777,
-0.1448271722,
0.8993974328,
0.8847869635,
-0.4510824084,
0.3731025457,
0.260704428,
-0.343234539,
0.8933025599,
-0.7045459151,
0.1202262491,
-0.1691272557,
0.2754078805,
-0.9417106509,
-0.3734111488,
0.3975469172,
-0.4135908484,
0.3592126966,
-0.3343743682,
-0.1543690115,
-0.4268366694,
-0.2021726072,
0.5629941225,
0.1521327794,
-0.3497929871,
1.014046073,
0.0568173937,
-0.2233662158,
-0.4881861806,
-0.4635024965,
0.2924502492,
-0.1323096454,
-0.8251330256,
0.1958597451,
0.0109983142,
-0.2458433211,
-0.125576362,
0.1685397327,
-0.1439017653,
-0.020793803,
-0.0858955532,
0.4813621938,
-0.3191292882,
-0.2620813847,
0.0203923639,
0.0004234472,
0.2174603492,
-0.4157049954,
0.5117436647,
-0.5433090925,
-0.439031899,
-0.452409327,
0.2229148746,
0.7160579562,
-0.6210746169,
0.1128507033,
0.4261752665,
-0.4192939997,
0.1248386428,
-0.5298120975,
-0.1979412138,
-0.4291740358,
0.5677070618,
-0.7163056135,
-0.4923181236,
0.3942498267,
0.1947893053,
-0.0293405149,
0.2039825022,
0.2749193013,
-0.013214428,
0.6270656586,
0.5127180815,
0.4024249017,
0.3843111098,
-0.2244139463,
-0.0065071173,
-0.8878725171,
-0.2462768555,
-0.4168882668,
0.0032489602,
-0.4978640974,
-0.6286972165,
0.6350162029,
-0.2002065927,
-0.0382023491,
0.246239841,
-0.53787148,
0.4912584126,
0.446660459,
0.073425591,
0.4656769335,
0.0599901862,
-0.1219249964,
-0.2618649602,
-0.4493154585,
-0.7307069898,
1.2386438847,
0.4535173774,
0.6150977015,
0.2079206407,
0.4388586581,
-0.1098496839,
0.5294137001,
-0.5072960854,
0.5506000519,
0.2080830485,
-0.5902671218,
-0.3313536644,
-0.5410007238,
-0.8776329756,
0.6964715123,
0.105860807,
-0.675488174,
0.2278965712,
-0.036116343,
-0.2761115432,
0.0932531431,
-0.8138654828,
1.283311367,
-0.3733039498,
-0.4362867177,
0.1553283185,
-0.4164736867,
0.393337816,
-0.4841898978,
0.1430648416,
0.1792013496,
-0.1513821334,
0.8852345347,
0.1269360185,
0.4330721498,
-0.1393193156,
-0.144959569,
0.4972734451,
0.1386557519,
0.3679199219,
-0.0091000991,
0.0190583188,
0.4971675575,
0.1901914328,
-0.2936846018,
-0.6711737514,
0.4997788072,
-0.751380384,
-0.4096225798,
-0.586332202,
-0.3700707853,
-0.2843430936,
0.1370069832,
0.1943135113,
0.5801953673,
-0.4589922726,
-0.1407982558,
0.3888248503,
-0.5571859479,
0.2481741905,
0.4497042298,
-0.2823487222,
-0.3601931334,
0.9876772761,
0.2184464186,
0.3805933297,
0.2715710402,
0.2887960374,
-0.6436399817,
-0.7223028541,
-0.9978610277,
0.4878127277,
-0.8886767626,
0.0220121741,
-0.6423894167,
0.0206505507,
-0.4518033862,
-0.0537981242,
-0.149853766,
0.1394868642,
-0.0073391148,
0.0213644505,
-0.0942049399,
0.6961830258,
0.2774429917,
0.2205216438,
-0.6296471357,
0.1355862916,
0.3937056065,
0.4583772123,
-0.5615590811,
-0.6870074868,
0.1474021226,
-0.1648006737,
-0.6620500088,
-1.2328500748,
0.0332107805,
0.1410658211,
0.4942868948,
0.2962732315,
-0.2960752547,
0.3953265548,
-0.5353003144,
0.6680958867,
0.0688690096,
-0.8462586999,
0.65912956,
-0.5990880728,
0.194378376,
0.5293255448,
0.3345635831,
-0.1025195792,
-0.3888489306,
-0.5284565687,
-0.3375190496,
0.4934929311,
0.58640486,
0.0257336739,
0.4187868536,
0.2567965388,
-0.1412955076,
0.1806657016,
-0.9855133891,
0.284443289,
-0.3494281769,
-0.2567578256,
0.0836982056,
0.0014541323,
-0.0285323877,
-0.2304133326,
0.3824490905,
-0.1270474643,
0.4389410913,
0.2444740683,
-0.1243131682,
0.1973728687,
0.4540584683,
0.6814445257,
1.0093356371,
-0.3456040621,
-0.1491854638,
0.2281083912,
-0.8056292534,
-0.0736662447,
0.2075732797,
-0.2631499469,
0.0829440132,
0.2030791789,
0.6184665561,
-0.0954439566,
-0.6261364222,
0.9397823215,
-0.2087084353,
-0.3620351851,
-0.2013090402,
-0.2101871222,
-0.3546929657,
0.1242236346,
0.2877611816,
-0.0856803656,
0.3974362314,
-0.7549011111,
0.1316447705,
0.2031737417,
-0.6706314087,
-0.4274693429,
0.8012363911,
0.4058220387,
0.1269031167,
0.4636553526,
-0.0735815763,
-0.6345549822,
0.6052661538,
0.5240252614,
0.6465914845,
-0.3297651708,
0.2802032828,
0.3802925348,
0.8442741632,
0.0722130612,
0.4785276949,
0.1031027064,
-0.7250048518,
-0.4840882123,
-0.8551481962,
-0.756164372,
0.0237743501,
-0.3831915855,
0.2549294531,
-0.2466402799,
0.0753311068,
-0.3876463473,
-0.1985943019,
-0.9046764374,
0.6284289956,
0.31556952,
0.7235058546,
-0.9549567103,
0.4773790538,
1.0585194826,
-0.705407083,
-0.4892071486,
-0.2144524306,
-0.1570595503,
-0.7492709756,
0.2653374076,
0.2763878107,
0.0235026106,
0.1275879592,
-0.4306168258,
-0.6322770715,
0.7566446662,
0.5525344014,
-0.4690794945,
-0.1749555171,
0.3598040342,
0.405960381,
-0.3360165656,
0.5374372602,
0.7247609496,
0.8292760253,
-0.0751331747,
-0.8504941463,
-0.0900060162,
-0.0525018871,
-0.2041080594,
0.1419086009,
-0.3797911406,
0.8156214356,
-0.266399473,
-0.2989063561,
-0.319843173,
0.6268116832,
0.2962136865,
0.4362857342,
0.420286715,
0.4628949165,
0.521022737,
-0.7118419409,
1.2747805119,
-0.0709119439,
0.3119321167,
0.7267608643,
-0.1443221718,
0.5975812674,
0.4808053672,
-0.4176313579,
0.407825917,
0.7112576962,
-0.2163292468,
0.4036144316,
0.0771334842,
0.015953172,
-0.139363125,
0.1588122845,
-0.4587042034,
0.9004333019,
0.346996665,
-0.0628326908,
-0.3475245237,
0.3093450069,
-0.4096770287,
0.0586704649,
-0.3562944531,
0.5394709706,
0.1117067039,
-0.6999702454,
0.236925602,
-0.0588712618,
0.2774012089,
-0.486800015,
-0.2243273556,
-0.2591048777,
0.0828819647,
0.0635783598,
-1.025049448,
0.1954556108,
0.2233272046,
0.5530489087,
-0.1323628575,
0.3617141247,
-0.2571464777,
-0.5986033082,
0.2408401668,
0.5184469819,
0.6296448112,
-0.5625306368,
-0.7450170517,
0.1794851571,
-0.0634856373,
0.0026547669,
0.1349247098,
0.5163806677,
-0.0298057273,
0.4770282209,
0.3497255743,
0.0690411329,
0.1401011795,
0.3456848562,
0.5919444561,
-0.4410734177,
-0.6424126029,
-0.8159410357,
0.4651305676,
-0.0973424688,
-0.4357041419,
0.630358696,
0.615034759,
0.9925644994,
-0.0739174336,
0.7350378036,
0.3687623441,
-0.1188174263,
-0.5168976188,
0.6300098896,
-0.7450472713,
0.0818822086,
-0.6857607365,
-1.2004522085,
-0.2236864716,
0.6779309511,
-0.5776302218,
0.2802967131,
0.9205174446,
0.438403219,
-0.0615906343,
0.0519780628,
0.633669138,
-0.0833212137,
0.3114864826,
0.6340461969,
1.01745224,
-0.7583168745,
0.8869328499,
0.0701022744,
-0.5712147951,
-0.0325881988,
-0.4829566181,
-0.8005705476,
-0.4434084892,
-0.5495628119,
-0.2379848361,
0.1041625813,
0.2731655538,
0.1433649361,
-0.5104091167,
-0.0869793966,
0.0447667465,
-0.1409260333,
-0.1834641397,
-0.2167712301,
0.2863246799,
0.0456746966,
-1.0054924488,
0.26435408,
0.6171110868,
0.3359636068,
-0.4003363848,
0.0234367792,
0.2133031934,
0.1915945113,
0.5561460853,
-0.1200952083,
-0.7247614861,
-0.2275891602,
0.1173987016,
-0.1282614022,
0.2782490551,
0.4460033178,
-0.4919167161,
0.6720578074,
0.5309268832,
0.582054317,
0.4421530962,
0.0302858036,
0.6251372099,
-0.2884348035,
-0.0842785463,
0.3513761163,
0.7658706903,
0.4864051044,
-0.0103391176,
0.7152796388,
0.3664026856,
-0.3891474307,
-0.7632117867,
0.1702204645,
-1.2622594833,
-0.1183845624,
1.1099441051,
-0.1261688322,
-0.2623563111,
-0.0887423456,
-0.1948371381,
0.0181775223,
-0.2393725663,
0.3448690772,
0.7777449489,
0.0211683717,
-0.3112225533,
-1.0676864386,
0.1366574615,
0.1876657456,
-0.9667716026,
-0.2586410344,
0.4127003551,
0.2286628336,
0.1284924746,
0.6961113811,
-0.4128864408,
0.4666053355,
0.1378071308,
0.1214947477,
-0.0222027935,
-0.5874871016,
-0.4258567691,
0.4038871527,
-0.2004679143,
-0.2991704047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14126v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14126v1
|
Towards Auditing Large Language Models: Improving Text-based Stereotype Detection
| 2023-11-23T17:47:14 | 2023-11-23T17:47:14 |
Wu Zekun, Sahan Bulathwela, Adriano Soares Koshiyama
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLM) have made significant advances in the recent past
becoming more mainstream in Artificial Intelligence (AI) enabled human-facing
applications. However, LLMs often generate stereotypical output inherited from
historical data, amplifying societal biases and raising ethical concerns. This
work introduces i) the Multi-Grain Stereotype Dataset, which includes 52,751
instances of gender, race, profession and religion stereotypic text and ii) a
novel stereotype classifier for English text. We design several experiments to
rigorously test the proposed model trained on the novel dataset. Our
experiments show that training the model in a multi-class setting can
outperform the one-vs-all binary counterpart. Consistent feature importance
signals from different eXplainable AI tools demonstrate that the new model
exploits relevant text features. We utilise the newly created model to assess
the stereotypic behaviour of the popular GPT family of models and observe the
reduction of bias over time. In summary, our work establishes a robust and
practical framework for auditing and evaluating the stereotypic bias in LLM.
|
[
-0.1616877019,
-0.3324359357,
0.5797048211,
0.0262008738,
-0.0628472865,
-0.0713490322,
-0.2166937739,
-0.8052054048,
-0.018275274,
0.5056952834,
-0.0807543769,
-0.5581510663,
-0.7938065529,
0.356957972,
-0.6265050769,
0.9554056525,
-0.0479466058,
0.2588033974,
-0.220853284,
-0.2390719503,
-0.3027968407,
-0.8790490031,
-0.6528196335,
-0.3302969635,
0.216406703,
-0.0064740274,
0.4438383281,
0.7225389481,
0.2089903951,
0.251950115,
-0.3535625935,
0.07718575,
-0.3503605425,
0.0272599552,
-0.0853258297,
-0.4790932536,
-0.5475478172,
0.2650329471,
0.4332115352,
0.1735030562,
0.0868904814,
0.0811424404,
0.1442226321,
0.4330798388,
-0.5446996093,
0.530043304,
-0.7802016139,
0.0109277712,
-0.1809096187,
0.1622162461,
-0.566345036,
-0.571619451,
0.1184699908,
-0.3687793911,
0.2625504732,
0.0930715278,
0.6368420124,
0.1758977324,
-0.5589241385,
-0.6697343588,
-0.5721084476,
0.8946810961,
-0.7756896019,
0.6562049389,
0.5335358381,
0.216655761,
0.2018970102,
-0.4023911953,
-0.4443716407,
-0.3422890604,
-0.1427704543,
-0.0040177167,
0.1097429246,
-0.0417600088,
-0.0373424999,
0.4673329294,
-0.4198803604,
0.2226459384,
-0.2010509372,
-0.5010235906,
0.6876013279,
-0.0872875303,
0.2363992035,
-0.1119461805,
-0.0388864577,
-0.0340767801,
-0.5516266823,
-0.2889592052,
0.6180545092,
0.2499629557,
-0.1712453067,
0.3781281412,
0.0962564349,
0.3955469429,
-0.2132804543,
-0.4163936079,
0.3852727413,
-0.2740215957,
0.0685395971,
0.3658670783,
0.5186262131,
0.2022689879,
0.9257978797,
0.0338480175,
-0.2596080601,
0.2425422221,
0.0040568719,
-0.7887510061,
-0.1226055399,
0.1521970183,
-0.4280801415,
-0.4886958897,
-0.0550467931,
-0.7596588731,
-0.6258127093,
-0.3166106343,
-0.011429403,
-0.5874505639,
-0.2274492681,
0.2430582792,
-0.2698673904,
0.2244129181,
0.4812208414,
-1.0420720577,
-0.1928747743,
0.9168060422,
0.7092754841,
0.1373540312,
-0.2526211441,
-0.3350303173,
0.3311704993,
-0.2516616285,
0.4921554029,
-0.6984518766,
-0.0427689068,
0.0579147302,
-0.1289101839,
0.3746253848,
-0.5180807114,
0.4563242793,
-0.3726191521,
0.3576539755,
0.1603334546,
-0.5176395774,
-0.084979184,
0.4776672423,
-0.643915236,
0.988546133,
-0.207482636,
-0.9637886882,
0.787181437,
-0.4650016427,
-0.3005108833,
-0.2195342779,
-0.358437717,
-0.5129242539,
-0.0362250991,
0.4453654587,
0.3339614272,
-0.2397911549,
0.5568718314,
-0.524879694,
-0.0851794258,
-0.1252318025,
-0.7069958448,
0.7418461442,
0.0819575116,
-0.2573980689,
-0.0082518272,
-0.8684902787,
-0.3892849982,
-0.0270689428,
-0.2902487218,
-0.8746809363,
-0.0045860764,
0.2557954192,
0.0637886003,
0.2689515352,
-0.4813966155,
0.0754864067,
-0.1482038647,
0.4686423838,
1.0263426304,
-0.2947244346,
0.1723541915,
-0.2364663631,
0.3118017912,
-0.0043625329,
0.240476802,
-0.3128612936,
-0.6115059853,
-0.2612808049,
-0.7500977516,
0.3226418495,
0.5323064327,
-0.1795080453,
0.5826691389,
-0.0884689689,
-0.3249254525,
-0.574813962,
0.2362079024,
0.2808588445,
0.1488518119,
0.0258579459,
-0.442862004,
-0.4659014046,
-1.0149080753,
-0.5711224675,
-0.7102009654,
-0.3505759835,
0.3629657924,
0.5096749067,
-0.5089915991,
1.0701602697,
-0.1694448441,
-0.1377660185,
-0.051245898,
0.3765279353,
0.0356606208,
0.3053928912,
0.4114261568,
-0.8157593012,
-0.0922047049,
0.2048274577,
-1.0461415052,
-0.2048467845,
-0.1513868719,
0.2570816278,
0.3438690603,
0.5936813354,
-0.2921555638,
0.2831524312,
0.577645123,
-0.311894238,
0.6619719267,
-0.0464762747,
-0.048805017,
-1.0481075048,
-0.1317765862,
0.2376854718,
-0.4118130803,
-0.3892226219,
-0.1520894766,
0.3056415021,
0.1675256789,
-0.3226416111,
0.6314023733,
-0.5232912898,
-0.2362275273,
-0.0049948026,
-0.0382710062,
0.0473551378,
-0.0489997044,
0.1387999803,
0.7329826355,
0.2812050581,
-0.3597049415,
0.2562502027,
0.3509036303,
-0.492338866,
0.3535198867,
-0.3589995801,
0.1992174238,
-0.4970942438,
0.3232800663,
-0.8364840746,
-0.2727863491,
-0.2119257301,
-0.2792874873,
0.2367544919,
-0.3234763443,
-0.4905415177,
-0.1223333031,
-0.520249486,
0.6290399432,
0.4095512033,
-0.6290031075,
0.7303990722,
0.4794272184,
-0.3760816157,
-0.622700572,
-0.5078188181,
0.1385681927,
-0.3454155922,
-0.6555264592,
-0.1064791083,
0.206197992,
-0.4887298942,
-0.3234075904,
-0.2639757395,
-0.1817140132,
0.253898114,
-0.0038093962,
0.3219704032,
-0.2664529085,
0.1563972235,
-0.0109687736,
0.1818087697,
0.0628618523,
-0.2864275873,
0.6810208559,
-0.131215781,
-0.2797885835,
-0.4014162719,
0.0095850928,
0.9430341125,
-0.0806602538,
0.6499090791,
0.4656986594,
-0.2475143075,
-0.1154108942,
-0.6400256157,
-0.1747830212,
-0.4698819518,
0.5988090634,
-0.1714854091,
-0.9624660015,
0.359192282,
0.0606663302,
0.3137505651,
0.2890430391,
0.6026239991,
0.2446992248,
0.7540959716,
0.884111464,
-0.3298801184,
0.4929642081,
0.2635245621,
0.3061588705,
-0.4192234874,
-0.235379681,
-0.6563218832,
0.2152034044,
-0.7917971611,
-0.321069032,
0.4755817354,
-0.1436083913,
-0.089249678,
0.04527447,
-0.2769267857,
0.6233950257,
0.3640637398,
-0.1609213948,
0.5993202925,
-0.1777286828,
-0.006704479,
0.0616084114,
-0.4617934823,
-0.9403518438,
1.1937131882,
0.7347969413,
0.8751136661,
-0.2502176762,
0.7530516386,
0.2976073921,
0.7873331904,
-0.7938201427,
0.2247330546,
-0.3294616342,
-1.0733442307,
-0.4360634089,
-0.501052916,
-0.2721030116,
0.282073766,
0.004418992,
-0.6285444498,
0.0895856321,
0.4302607775,
0.1056775004,
0.376167208,
-0.7525187135,
0.7287328243,
-0.3448760509,
-0.2072944641,
0.0584918112,
-0.2732329667,
0.7910718322,
-0.6109232306,
0.5933110118,
-0.0127173048,
0.1617328525,
0.8026094437,
0.0951954871,
1.0568135977,
0.095794566,
-0.6309601665,
-0.1739571691,
0.0070338855,
0.5832813978,
0.0934568271,
-0.2386035621,
0.4957409203,
0.0464979969,
-0.2298887223,
-0.3185534477,
0.2471281439,
-0.7325021029,
-0.5899300575,
-0.4497047365,
-0.8070377707,
-0.3481281102,
0.0169060398,
-0.027670566,
0.3514712155,
-0.5749244094,
-0.024014432,
0.5921320319,
-0.7203717828,
0.1660553664,
0.1840976775,
-0.3709845841,
-0.1986730546,
0.5005692244,
-0.2558458447,
0.3309657276,
0.2456101924,
0.4703139663,
-0.3064973354,
-0.6198617816,
-0.4113430381,
0.3284425139,
-0.6279835105,
0.1952416003,
-0.7198584676,
-0.0870272294,
-0.7999078631,
-0.0847562402,
-0.4277184308,
-0.2973358631,
0.0575347468,
-0.0114557371,
0.4828641415,
1.0279954672,
0.0140888998,
0.151394859,
-0.7296552658,
0.2781414986,
0.391543895,
0.4111392796,
-0.0196367074,
-0.5696107149,
0.0963564068,
-0.1390802562,
-0.0032761612,
-0.7156666517,
0.5308989882,
0.0048567927,
0.4288498163,
0.8368520141,
-0.2490890324,
0.1638273895,
-0.6418786049,
0.6681746244,
0.0757988319,
-1.1015820503,
0.3345579505,
-0.3365840912,
0.0768971071,
0.5185084343,
0.6009053588,
-0.8579915166,
-0.7611876726,
-0.1654768735,
-0.7427339554,
0.6541160941,
0.0407040156,
-0.0042449278,
0.1413599551,
0.2798484564,
0.5172604322,
0.3338854015,
-0.9378063679,
-0.0691780746,
-0.2938563824,
-0.4820136726,
-0.3008926213,
-0.3481961191,
0.002933389,
-0.2590297461,
0.7892796397,
-0.1604160815,
-0.2062293887,
0.0318239555,
-0.2450838685,
0.5354573131,
0.4693743289,
0.3460462093,
0.6472839117,
-0.450265795,
0.263373673,
0.0865922943,
-0.8011990786,
0.1955476701,
-0.0414290577,
-0.380515337,
0.1682331264,
0.5234764814,
0.3938007653,
-0.1419092417,
-0.5902129412,
0.3320673704,
-0.0337896161,
-0.2491490245,
-0.3067110479,
-0.2313024253,
0.1229662076,
0.0549148545,
0.0283997525,
-0.2509607077,
0.1558835506,
-0.8991355896,
0.3229914606,
0.5125364065,
-0.1892726123,
-0.1281787902,
0.5552397966,
0.2383431941,
-0.2519006729,
0.3248443604,
-0.0127265779,
-0.7836774588,
0.7214286327,
0.4937802851,
1.0004963875,
-0.3188261688,
0.1349754333,
0.0703960285,
0.7255117297,
-0.3218398094,
-0.205213517,
0.0929766819,
-0.9887384772,
-0.238284573,
-0.9149621129,
-0.4859529138,
0.4210935831,
-0.5514279604,
0.2621781528,
-0.4764816165,
0.2765824199,
0.3677387238,
-0.4821030498,
-0.4018290937,
-0.0199494567,
0.4018082321,
0.9311974049,
-1.2382669449,
0.8219424486,
0.5838606954,
-0.0620006062,
-0.3684653342,
0.2266246378,
0.4318847656,
-1.0708699226,
0.8189085126,
0.4686966538,
-0.1866473407,
-0.4614241719,
-0.5139105916,
-0.5516688824,
0.6589897275,
0.1751537025,
-0.9812958241,
-0.2411581725,
0.2779148221,
0.5520407557,
-0.3573275506,
0.372487396,
0.7752451897,
0.6298365593,
-0.1483778358,
-0.9989250302,
-0.1888034195,
-0.0468848422,
0.0168028809,
0.2517676353,
-0.423998028,
0.7136198878,
0.1970954388,
0.0399219915,
-0.1979595721,
0.3478382528,
0.1942965984,
0.502758801,
0.668987453,
0.2942507565,
1.0031857491,
0.1554494947,
0.9851974845,
-0.2603118718,
0.2325344682,
1.0415526628,
-0.7000896931,
0.4194411933,
0.5125750303,
0.0607912093,
0.1103522032,
0.3692908287,
-0.0620845035,
0.2205558717,
0.3773158193,
-0.3349370062,
-0.1565290689,
-0.0210773665,
-0.2249373943,
0.7478747368,
0.1091586277,
-0.5658971667,
-0.2816560268,
0.0270621013,
0.1851007491,
-0.0712853223,
-0.330799371,
0.8109660745,
-0.0517389886,
-0.3579334021,
0.3223109841,
-0.0510994717,
1.2413117886,
-0.4405610561,
0.1525124907,
-0.4152183533,
0.4613591731,
-0.015218365,
-0.392852515,
0.3106917739,
0.3792802989,
-0.2704206705,
-0.2675473392,
0.467994839,
-0.4434264302,
-0.622096777,
0.3634408414,
0.4396167696,
0.3146036565,
-0.0588855594,
-0.4115693271,
0.0912756547,
0.0891129747,
-0.0438632555,
0.3059355617,
0.6316457391,
-0.353219986,
0.6649418473,
0.4030551612,
0.1031052843,
-0.0014344504,
0.1596406847,
0.4774090052,
-0.742408514,
-0.5653713942,
-1.1059280634,
-0.0245146304,
-0.0963939801,
-0.2401748896,
0.7956290841,
0.8433255553,
1.026922226,
0.0739200637,
1.0711141825,
0.3074016571,
0.2969920933,
-0.5893535018,
0.9097290039,
-0.4662568569,
0.3608874381,
-0.4440831244,
-0.8242205381,
-0.2064127773,
0.5775049329,
-0.3375224769,
0.0564370975,
0.5427145362,
0.8976604939,
-0.1950698197,
0.4874798357,
0.3701201081,
0.4754908681,
0.5056777596,
0.1674278975,
0.9858797789,
-0.1466440707,
0.4171411693,
0.1555831432,
-0.4926251173,
0.0027289668,
-1.0508033037,
-1.0406384468,
-0.4324063361,
-0.2589993477,
-0.318621099,
0.1864042431,
0.8403166533,
0.6147274971,
-0.9727942348,
-0.3543979824,
0.0985237136,
0.0805427283,
0.1566409022,
-0.2126139253,
0.1337036043,
-0.2439617217,
-0.802546382,
0.1473780721,
0.3068529665,
0.0787914395,
-0.2219581306,
0.1286620498,
-0.1121727303,
0.2242017835,
0.8619132638,
0.0264742132,
-0.5662178993,
-0.4524124861,
-0.4342629015,
0.0398246236,
0.0897714198,
0.9371846318,
-0.4401824474,
0.1536231786,
0.2230718732,
0.7711549997,
0.5296717882,
-0.2865515947,
0.7122898698,
-0.6809951067,
0.2136912644,
0.3873137236,
0.5169717073,
0.411072284,
-0.3259666562,
0.4287664592,
0.2099075019,
-0.3762204051,
-1.0245211124,
0.2822400331,
-0.7739730477,
-0.413613379,
1.3063299656,
0.0527203158,
-0.2571698129,
-0.4278990626,
-0.0392011143,
0.2998206615,
-0.4508931935,
1.1324129105,
0.9733167887,
0.2753887475,
0.0597220212,
-0.6755837798,
0.5919984579,
0.4020161331,
-1.0995227098,
0.6331751943,
0.7901312709,
0.5361451507,
0.1599168032,
0.3588360846,
-0.5085796714,
-0.0392851308,
-0.0766922757,
0.4786415398,
-0.072236985,
-0.5033974648,
-0.6196290851,
0.0815346017,
-0.0031355196,
0.1136288568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14115v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14115v3
|
A density estimation perspective on learning from pairwise human preferences
| 2023-11-23T17:20:36 | 2024-01-10T16:11:32 |
Vincent Dumoulin, Daniel D. Johnson, Pablo Samuel Castro, Hugo Larochelle, Yann Dauphin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Learning from human feedback (LHF) -- and in particular learning from
pairwise preferences -- has recently become a crucial ingredient in training
large language models (LLMs), and has been the subject of much research. Most
recent works frame it as a reinforcement learning problem, where a reward
function is learned from pairwise preference data and the LLM is treated as a
policy which is adapted to maximize the rewards, often under additional
regularization constraints. We propose an alternative interpretation which
centers on the generative process for pairwise preferences and treats LHF as a
density estimation problem. We provide theoretical and empirical results
showing that for a family of generative processes defined via preference
behavior distribution equations, training a reward function on pairwise
preferences effectively models an annotator's implicit preference distribution.
Finally, we discuss and present findings on "annotator misspecification" --
failure cases where wrong modeling assumptions are made about annotator
behavior, resulting in poorly-adapted models -- suggesting that approaches that
learn from pairwise human preferences could have trouble learning from a
population of annotators with diverse viewpoints.
|
[
-0.3965710998,
-0.474480629,
0.7520383,
0.058193434,
-0.2465972453,
-0.1464477926,
-0.4632100463,
-0.2028728127,
0.5022483468,
0.4870351553,
-0.1440139264,
-0.1120783761,
-0.6499680281,
-0.0245441161,
0.0347838439,
1.1209307909,
-0.0966070443,
0.0624913685,
-0.2816416025,
-0.1153992712,
-0.2686085999,
-0.7596942782,
-0.7683002353,
-0.4040905237,
0.7238537669,
0.3709482849,
0.7131781578,
0.273698926,
-0.1703538746,
0.2809207737,
0.0346795321,
-0.0743046626,
-0.5974906683,
0.0522821359,
0.2160820067,
-0.4102519453,
-0.0018176624,
0.2523640394,
0.7117881179,
0.9265050888,
-0.3022347987,
-0.4343725145,
0.0985519961,
0.8585138321,
-0.6741344929,
0.1000874043,
-0.2613173425,
0.3372579515,
0.2605789304,
-0.3524616063,
-0.4507525563,
-0.4134916067,
0.4705304801,
-0.5668417215,
0.3507120311,
0.2044115514,
0.4764224291,
0.4399005473,
-0.1960856915,
-0.1170230731,
-0.6830325723,
0.8568860292,
-0.2131670415,
0.3409318626,
1.0073194504,
0.1567125916,
-0.22949332,
0.0512139425,
-0.5277391076,
-0.3988389671,
-0.0533476174,
0.1894181818,
0.4633621871,
0.2665341496,
0.1455439776,
0.2413930297,
-0.1417366564,
0.3245902061,
-0.3285424113,
-0.0859982297,
1.1003026962,
-0.0670935586,
-0.0048726066,
-0.4455878437,
-0.3948490322,
-0.2485124916,
-0.4004248083,
0.3408948183,
0.6629445553,
0.0630483106,
-0.4920676947,
0.3081012368,
-0.0808027238,
0.6400059462,
0.0507267155,
0.0355778374,
0.3023113906,
0.3233248889,
-0.1091462821,
0.1435187608,
0.7400645018,
0.4676932395,
0.2731657922,
-0.3913427889,
-0.5682695508,
-0.0858354941,
0.3017783165,
-0.4684919119,
-0.5159282684,
0.3017623723,
-0.422201544,
-0.468680948,
0.1690810472,
-0.7988958359,
-0.7543193698,
-0.1347041726,
0.3680839837,
-0.0364782698,
-0.4633031785,
0.1231014803,
-0.3239387572,
-0.0960792676,
0.2081676722,
-1.4790017605,
0.173590228,
0.6100669503,
0.8064391017,
-0.3133220971,
-0.3856167793,
-0.6946941018,
0.0465144254,
-0.3879290521,
0.8562488556,
-0.4151948094,
-0.8134050965,
0.04134183,
-0.1242361069,
-0.0306457877,
-0.5804566145,
0.5157802701,
-0.5451439619,
-0.081250973,
-0.5660255551,
-0.6512321234,
0.0372264311,
-0.044143144,
-0.722710669,
0.7698575258,
0.3290198445,
-0.7322121859,
0.8366312981,
-0.4717438221,
-0.4056413472,
0.1713150293,
-0.1244625226,
-0.2777858078,
0.1740158647,
-0.053722363,
0.6129792333,
0.0895763487,
0.3644425571,
-0.7460233569,
-0.4340699911,
0.3677170277,
-0.0706728175,
0.6326452494,
0.0123428199,
-0.0187520515,
0.4371694326,
-0.5918188691,
-0.514432013,
0.2056582421,
-0.5306966305,
-0.6798877716,
0.4044718444,
-0.0399313346,
-0.0470950417,
-0.0394867957,
-0.4351210594,
0.1256667823,
-0.4247614145,
0.5359762907,
1.2085642815,
0.1093377322,
0.7646254897,
-0.3276483119,
0.2666448355,
0.0644946471,
0.1071519926,
0.46264112,
-0.237562716,
-0.6533669233,
-0.0608126037,
0.1190205589,
0.166935727,
-0.4492477775,
0.3937929869,
-0.0635528862,
0.0181242023,
-0.2908401191,
0.3191823661,
0.3288661242,
0.4317339361,
0.2171477228,
-0.4474361241,
-0.5524486899,
-0.8709448576,
0.0908379853,
-0.4298484623,
0.2484681457,
0.3093078434,
0.4441287518,
0.1203246489,
0.8193874955,
-0.4203137755,
0.0383351184,
-0.3535890281,
0.111674875,
-0.0904790759,
0.3651798964,
0.3570010364,
-0.9609068632,
-0.2365016341,
-0.2703092992,
-0.6998854876,
0.3769408166,
0.1387214363,
-0.1433057189,
0.4669876099,
0.0921270177,
-0.1945272684,
0.1604926884,
0.5292909741,
-0.1003424451,
0.3667945564,
-0.5278891921,
-0.1666967571,
-0.7894940972,
-0.3144301772,
0.4890932739,
-0.1151207387,
-0.4313552082,
-0.1584924161,
-0.2728242874,
0.369368583,
-0.1821447313,
0.6521580219,
-0.2200841606,
-0.5969933271,
-0.1942848265,
0.0543870553,
-0.2210806161,
0.5028579831,
0.5977115631,
0.8475490212,
0.1855726391,
-0.7554361224,
0.3670710325,
0.3087130487,
-0.3163464069,
0.6981788874,
-0.5496755838,
0.1113827974,
-0.4199841022,
0.3124896586,
-0.6841496229,
-0.5310078263,
0.4009830058,
-0.1893698722,
0.0564042777,
-0.3460509181,
-0.388517946,
-0.1926779002,
-0.4667803347,
0.0270463731,
0.6537711024,
-0.8768952489,
0.1606346667,
0.7042063475,
0.1812654883,
-0.5050108433,
-0.3465797901,
-0.3451132774,
-0.3266697228,
-0.2713305652,
-0.0455696434,
-0.1375588924,
-0.4209388494,
-0.0835262612,
-0.0224884488,
-0.1657115668,
0.3499341309,
0.5344902873,
0.3486616313,
0.2494369447,
0.2790043354,
-0.081495367,
-0.2462850809,
0.2512543499,
-0.1969092786,
0.4497962296,
0.1570624262,
0.0084514953,
-0.0022589613,
0.2084012032,
-0.1026128978,
0.1308696419,
0.6722119451,
0.5906016231,
-0.18685323,
-0.2636531889,
-0.5746546984,
-0.4482084513,
-0.3777092695,
0.2759362161,
-0.2943677604,
-0.8052228689,
0.2931956649,
0.4484657049,
-0.1491906643,
0.3082302511,
0.3578244746,
-0.4810061455,
1.1214226484,
0.5312578678,
-0.1398387551,
0.6083785295,
-0.2502257526,
-0.2107426226,
-0.8849666119,
-0.2156036049,
-0.1763830334,
-0.444316566,
-0.4567052424,
0.0586112328,
0.5698404312,
0.2203883231,
-0.3564612567,
-0.2084899396,
-0.2335057259,
0.4218941927,
0.8931741714,
0.4304260612,
0.0536207445,
0.2557886839,
-0.0714568496,
-0.0662358478,
-0.5948973298,
-0.0902923793,
1.1644881964,
-0.0180232972,
0.4368574917,
-0.0596283004,
0.9936311841,
0.2614382207,
0.3236523569,
-0.7350101471,
0.213988781,
-0.0949448571,
-0.3706662655,
-0.4276647568,
-0.4938704371,
-0.9212234616,
0.3085860014,
-0.3417976499,
-0.7671940923,
0.2541364729,
0.512929976,
-0.5422691107,
0.4091594219,
-0.8463124633,
0.9717153907,
-0.4296040833,
-0.5100706816,
-0.5269687176,
-0.7031040192,
0.4576455355,
0.1609213054,
0.1192423776,
-0.1964195073,
0.1154406145,
1.0055559874,
-0.4314872921,
0.9202400446,
-0.6329423785,
0.0430709161,
-0.030772252,
-0.0636854768,
0.4471081793,
0.2775575221,
-0.1523889899,
-0.1625109911,
-0.0336899161,
-0.5680424571,
-0.5857783556,
0.6298525929,
-1.3168359995,
-0.6877197623,
-0.3684570789,
-0.5499054193,
-0.4806054533,
-0.2646354437,
0.1785295457,
0.1606427729,
-0.0847793296,
-0.2709720731,
0.658013165,
-0.1681823432,
0.4837146401,
0.011915463,
-0.266213119,
-0.4360565841,
1.0788891315,
0.0205712765,
0.3493696451,
0.457446903,
0.3971700966,
-0.3962940872,
-0.5763332248,
-0.4473838508,
0.3074255586,
-0.7882903814,
0.387133956,
-0.6131073236,
0.0481851585,
0.0774055645,
-0.3529216349,
0.0010285989,
-0.2420661002,
-0.4007664919,
-0.3121914864,
0.5166009068,
0.7968821526,
-0.204090625,
0.2517906129,
-0.5490345359,
0.1576099247,
0.6974614859,
0.4372657537,
-0.0328488648,
-0.3984490931,
-0.2785694897,
0.07527069,
0.091108948,
-0.8450648785,
0.4334037602,
-0.2340682745,
0.5568441749,
0.3151701391,
0.0768588707,
0.5226355791,
0.0836214125,
0.6704438925,
0.2043795884,
-0.6693543792,
0.363389641,
-0.1803711057,
-0.3034457862,
0.5975730419,
0.5932597518,
-0.6405249834,
0.2961480021,
-0.6736442447,
-0.4620277286,
0.8136238456,
-0.5047921538,
0.1294770986,
-0.0474950075,
0.5830414891,
0.3422084749,
0.3575148284,
-0.5726923943,
-0.1887491494,
-0.3901541829,
0.0317278504,
-0.5623275638,
-0.6217671037,
-0.1550608277,
-0.279402703,
0.5816137195,
-0.1667356193,
0.0982944071,
0.0682379007,
-0.3695339859,
-0.366397649,
0.2219385058,
0.6257963181,
0.440972507,
-0.5204535127,
0.2560984492,
0.0406890064,
-0.0117568197,
0.1980227679,
-0.0175837092,
-0.4433777332,
-0.3744414151,
-0.0397084989,
1.253790617,
0.6056272388,
-0.5523399115,
0.6201561689,
0.1964143813,
-0.2158559859,
-0.5087900758,
0.0903957635,
-0.1427983046,
0.1229145899,
0.193178907,
0.2095851302,
0.1888076812,
-0.2070863843,
-0.1645432413,
0.6023080349,
-0.8421974778,
-0.5733138323,
0.6329555511,
0.4485456645,
-0.1457183361,
0.5102154613,
-0.4941473901,
-0.6125494838,
0.3705464602,
0.2506951392,
0.8605848551,
-0.0610962845,
0.5388848782,
0.4100491107,
-0.0465429947,
-0.4490442574,
0.1419511288,
-0.3606894314,
-1.0710850954,
-0.2401854396,
-0.6164757609,
-0.4444893599,
-0.0633853823,
-0.6249467731,
0.1520716548,
-0.7183947563,
-0.0407742895,
-0.0730015635,
-0.1726729274,
-0.6068460941,
-0.0550574325,
0.1370114386,
0.2630238235,
-0.8967511058,
0.7310196161,
0.7747396827,
-0.8177710772,
-0.7102662325,
-0.0847373903,
-0.0404618643,
-1.1302609444,
0.8998621106,
-0.1311337948,
0.0517304167,
0.0151165826,
-0.4924837947,
-0.5641989708,
0.6378699541,
0.2689372897,
-0.419665128,
-0.0431706496,
-0.3378933966,
0.2966244221,
-0.2002616972,
0.2490202785,
0.6604574323,
0.4259321988,
-0.2120724469,
-0.6506171227,
-0.1312820762,
0.0654491559,
0.2611067891,
0.3482662439,
-0.7469497323,
0.5704331398,
-0.6214985251,
0.033320453,
-0.1839923412,
0.5593969226,
0.355039686,
-0.0262510441,
0.9225254655,
0.4101588428,
0.4695408046,
0.1743146032,
1.4892874956,
0.036690522,
0.3281545341,
0.675565958,
-0.2786016464,
1.0403460264,
0.6273446679,
-0.5175955296,
0.3755673468,
0.909480691,
0.2180709839,
0.5886231661,
0.1548084021,
-0.202922076,
-0.5611269474,
-0.1151139066,
-0.1138133109,
0.0298124608,
0.2358569652,
-0.3813288808,
0.2458400875,
-0.170541659,
-0.215855062,
0.0497750975,
-0.2419573069,
0.8505460024,
0.0482865795,
-0.8777062297,
0.5097206831,
-0.1998538822,
0.9357606173,
-0.1056166738,
-0.027349839,
-0.2734615207,
-0.2699796259,
-0.3803910315,
-0.6726948619,
-0.1111252159,
-0.4252272844,
-0.3287611902,
-0.1611249894,
0.2493554354,
-0.4697659314,
-0.1901326478,
0.3335649371,
0.3513028622,
0.1680974066,
0.1326586157,
-0.4514939487,
0.1004034281,
-0.0354433469,
-0.088187322,
0.4406431317,
-0.3310490847,
-0.0586150475,
0.4845229089,
0.6412072182,
0.3256453574,
0.1331478953,
0.1902549565,
0.3048457503,
-0.5542567968,
-0.7285645604,
-0.737187326,
0.2223788351,
-0.0288788136,
-0.3178862929,
0.2853768468,
0.2025515139,
1.0099492073,
-0.1250158399,
1.1348798275,
0.2407489419,
0.4403185248,
-0.6146457195,
0.4736520052,
-0.3940148354,
0.2112448215,
-0.0501236245,
-1.0474463701,
-0.0311967507,
0.8942426443,
-0.784609735,
0.3100902438,
0.619291544,
0.4209941626,
0.116723977,
0.1924971789,
0.3524517119,
0.102198638,
-0.0479460545,
0.5710219741,
0.967333734,
0.0079266904,
0.0765446275,
-0.7090773582,
-0.0751652196,
-0.5181306601,
-0.5434246659,
-0.8256385326,
-0.9109398127,
-0.1548911929,
-0.4600238502,
0.2015409321,
1.4337596893,
0.8325012922,
-0.6825329661,
-0.5087698698,
-0.0106932903,
0.3939446211,
-0.2288531512,
-0.1700364947,
0.2748463452,
-0.3056869209,
-0.7694330215,
0.2037065923,
0.3130675256,
0.1083212644,
-0.5490317345,
-0.6772043109,
0.1692900658,
-0.5004193187,
0.4164924622,
0.513792634,
-0.9150140882,
-0.5420758128,
-0.5171431303,
0.0581609011,
0.3288799822,
0.8521595001,
-0.7044793963,
0.5341688991,
0.3184040785,
0.6237881184,
0.7199917436,
-0.184772402,
0.5102164149,
-0.6604876518,
0.326882273,
-0.0217490718,
0.5922809839,
0.5789295435,
-0.1239579245,
0.3367147446,
0.519993186,
-0.4788914621,
-0.8083413839,
0.3413845599,
-0.8277100921,
0.1124428064,
1.3055472374,
0.1463308036,
-0.2375728339,
-0.1036727354,
-0.0390411131,
0.1160814241,
-0.7471310496,
0.9461362362,
0.570121944,
-0.1620943099,
-0.5070619583,
-0.5139109492,
0.7033125162,
0.6282541752,
-0.6258631945,
-0.1135562211,
0.5454682112,
0.3475100398,
-0.0896877274,
0.7903608084,
0.483073324,
0.2629731894,
-0.160349831,
0.1866856217,
0.0449789427,
-0.1363107413,
-0.650265336,
0.030432133,
0.6548402309,
0.0567256659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14096v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14096v2
|
Cultural Bias and Cultural Alignment of Large Language Models
| 2023-11-23T16:45:56 | 2024-06-26T15:26:44 |
Yan Tao, Olga Viberg, Ryan S. Baker, Rene F. Kizilcec
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Culture fundamentally shapes people's reasoning, behavior, and communication.
As people increasingly use generative artificial intelligence (AI) to expedite
and automate personal and professional tasks, cultural values embedded in AI
models may bias people's authentic expression and contribute to the dominance
of certain cultures. We conduct a disaggregated evaluation of cultural bias for
five widely used large language models (OpenAI's GPT-4o/4-turbo/4/3.5-turbo/3)
by comparing the models' responses to nationally representative survey data.
All models exhibit cultural values resembling English-speaking and Protestant
European countries. We test cultural prompting as a control strategy to
increase cultural alignment for each country/territory. For recent models
(GPT-4, 4-turbo, 4o), this improves the cultural alignment of the models'
output for 71-81% of countries and territories. We suggest using cultural
prompting and ongoing evaluation to reduce cultural bias in the output of
generative AI.
|
[
-0.4357525706,
-0.489664048,
0.2693809271,
0.3613247275,
0.0461442731,
0.1048298478,
-0.4588613808,
-0.6091059446,
0.0341735706,
0.1798472852,
-0.5983905196,
-0.1256983876,
-0.3581867218,
0.2185779661,
0.0160750393,
0.9134005308,
-0.0114087146,
0.4374032915,
-0.0733563006,
-0.3393732011,
-0.4765641391,
-0.6393571496,
-0.4668134153,
-0.6214591265,
0.1301698536,
0.2424511909,
0.9881690741,
0.4719504118,
0.375842005,
0.3423387408,
-0.0515777953,
-0.0387112722,
-0.4153170288,
0.0431070291,
-0.3240739107,
-0.4604442716,
-0.3322951794,
0.2308794409,
0.3064208925,
0.4775613546,
-0.0895133242,
0.3774258494,
0.0207701735,
0.6299940944,
-0.293007046,
0.2848511338,
-0.4071131945,
0.0041457787,
-0.18260324,
-0.0421732068,
-0.2944912016,
-0.515563786,
0.1253326386,
-0.4537415206,
0.0259817522,
-0.2451722026,
0.812235713,
0.4621498287,
-0.5870503783,
-0.1762341559,
-1.1644269228,
0.9348519444,
-0.3416990042,
0.339589119,
0.4915291369,
0.0283479821,
-0.0171276946,
-0.200338617,
-0.7264755368,
-0.276063323,
0.0929168984,
0.444874227,
-0.1208283678,
-0.0891838893,
0.3959907293,
0.2723894715,
-0.454957962,
0.3994826078,
-0.4811127484,
-0.1018123031,
0.7145734429,
0.0522615463,
0.6085116267,
0.1932891309,
-0.0889162794,
-0.1869944781,
-0.8056514263,
-0.0084823528,
0.5246925354,
-0.0387020037,
0.1034461334,
0.2498971224,
-0.2853880823,
0.6128585339,
0.1699671596,
-0.0641536564,
0.2024566978,
-0.4956413805,
0.0469968393,
0.0528804511,
0.6905946136,
0.6488867402,
0.9100308418,
0.2063817531,
0.0295593534,
0.3985980451,
0.2057727575,
-0.6639056802,
0.0154636893,
0.1762859076,
-0.4701108634,
-0.0999797583,
0.0862409696,
-0.5151634216,
-0.4068427384,
-0.4020510018,
-0.0625908002,
-0.2389069349,
-0.2861373425,
-0.2078024596,
-0.1464321166,
0.4034970403,
0.4164979756,
-1.0944858789,
-0.1290839911,
0.6104662418,
0.6478899121,
-0.1153851673,
-0.3415901363,
-0.1209667549,
0.0513188206,
-0.7717350721,
0.4755978584,
-0.6420661211,
-0.3726412654,
0.0870124996,
-0.0952062011,
0.2868588567,
-0.5327517986,
0.4827629328,
-0.430260092,
0.5027243495,
-0.52752918,
-0.0961585045,
-0.1314068437,
0.2391633838,
-0.8438029289,
0.6430767775,
0.0601661317,
-0.3732383549,
0.7791564465,
-0.6655339599,
-0.5210328102,
0.2524816692,
-0.4176506698,
-0.1154280752,
-0.0327262096,
0.4647819698,
0.0937962383,
-0.4578003585,
0.2918102443,
-0.1952120066,
-0.4764720201,
0.1207786724,
-0.5880672932,
1.0372511148,
0.541046977,
-0.6051194072,
0.1066997051,
-0.3322390616,
-0.1961617917,
0.1277647018,
-0.2844876647,
-0.5042355061,
0.0958567411,
-0.1591302603,
0.5681856275,
0.182030201,
-0.4491439462,
0.3022881746,
-0.2449887693,
0.7222472429,
0.8448098898,
-0.2109679878,
0.5469083786,
-0.4359787405,
0.7531499863,
0.1323899031,
0.2313434184,
-0.0728743821,
-0.6238076687,
-0.4545488358,
-0.0765652135,
0.0802192166,
0.5887537599,
-0.771710515,
0.2940708101,
-0.3326379061,
-0.5134008527,
-0.8369147182,
0.1665164977,
0.0722035617,
0.4866654575,
-0.0194235705,
-0.2964320481,
-0.1844932437,
-1.0018125772,
-0.1827739477,
-0.3122590482,
-0.3144764006,
0.0395722538,
0.3286096752,
-0.1156891584,
0.7952340245,
-0.1295758337,
-0.1826662868,
-0.1407688409,
0.2533230186,
0.1016551852,
0.4756605327,
0.620311141,
-0.904117167,
-0.5478572845,
0.171676755,
-0.6802859306,
-0.1004227325,
-0.1875752658,
-0.1997395009,
0.5434576273,
0.2250881791,
-0.4994336367,
0.383797437,
0.5838233829,
-0.321765095,
0.348551333,
-0.0260703955,
0.5845998526,
-1.0258014202,
0.0117865736,
0.160185948,
0.1267848909,
-0.570908308,
-0.0279432666,
0.0872346759,
0.0242953058,
-0.1349558383,
0.540232718,
-0.3753693104,
0.1497114003,
-0.0992188826,
-0.1428727657,
-0.0264632851,
0.1130253449,
0.3621567786,
0.8547075987,
0.1733005941,
-0.3587486148,
0.3081602454,
0.3315488696,
-0.7157874107,
0.7239297032,
-0.5102241039,
0.2419202179,
-0.2767269313,
0.5938531756,
-0.7205418944,
-0.270593673,
-0.0508757308,
-0.3117209375,
-0.0287543628,
-0.1283738017,
-0.3699302971,
-0.5100797415,
-0.0885205343,
0.4633696675,
0.8272169232,
-0.4486605227,
0.5128987432,
0.1509793997,
-0.2773301303,
-0.6726641059,
-0.8078196049,
-0.0205606353,
-0.4279605746,
-0.6875756979,
0.2471616119,
-0.2425238341,
-0.5513638258,
-0.2990975678,
0.084713988,
0.1312182248,
0.1608551443,
0.0154497037,
0.2842563689,
-0.1752503514,
-0.0046600443,
-0.220841676,
0.2321826369,
0.0537885875,
-0.4889249802,
0.6474251151,
-0.0983523875,
-0.4617457688,
-0.6156852841,
0.3643844128,
0.9050960541,
-0.5500364304,
0.7606931925,
0.6289415956,
-0.2004335076,
0.1117242575,
-0.6768084764,
-0.4144454002,
-0.4561436176,
0.3381766081,
-0.2194111347,
-0.8761640787,
0.6837721467,
0.1464092731,
0.0324196741,
0.4348552823,
0.8353004456,
0.0025636684,
1.4584792852,
0.5801551938,
-0.4366831481,
0.5506034493,
0.0611314029,
0.3643708825,
-0.395752281,
-0.0209416077,
-0.6450618505,
-0.4855470955,
-1.0473151207,
-0.0926271826,
0.4153909385,
-0.2386478931,
-0.4847170413,
-0.2218081057,
-0.4510710537,
0.4931120276,
0.7885611653,
-0.2517103553,
0.198935464,
0.0171576906,
0.1185263172,
-0.0458339155,
-0.676368773,
-0.5618129373,
0.7882943153,
0.4519558847,
0.9069601893,
0.3233366013,
0.3794729412,
0.2595029175,
0.4818338752,
-0.6944637299,
0.0842306167,
-0.0880267844,
-0.7920861244,
-0.2619489133,
-0.2755234241,
-0.7427643538,
-0.055715885,
0.0823908672,
-0.7383431196,
0.2411805093,
0.3998611867,
-0.3050895631,
0.0640212595,
-0.83194381,
0.6445372701,
-0.3519854248,
-0.2232435346,
-0.1251689792,
-0.5315529108,
0.4011770785,
-0.1597883552,
0.2406789362,
0.0352103673,
0.3396134973,
0.5408089161,
-0.0587039776,
0.843131721,
-0.1367764473,
-0.282212615,
0.1826514304,
0.0871071666,
0.4681485593,
-0.2053936124,
-0.3715368807,
0.5085013509,
0.0101151466,
-0.3726140857,
-0.522187531,
0.728558898,
-1.0838756561,
-0.8624800444,
-0.3067278564,
-0.5332221985,
-0.1085407734,
0.0300491732,
0.4206385911,
0.1027720422,
-0.2406583279,
0.1441651881,
0.3693428934,
-0.2004375607,
0.2852808237,
0.3835889101,
-0.0144736748,
-0.123507835,
0.6112912893,
0.2996772528,
0.5166482329,
-0.0117892707,
0.3717826009,
-0.2052253187,
-0.09942054,
-0.6473852992,
-0.027365312,
-0.7199750543,
0.121152319,
-0.1301174313,
-0.0772370771,
-0.6667919159,
-0.259065181,
-0.0385794342,
-0.2191803455,
0.0699332878,
-0.1933235377,
0.24928312,
0.9720440507,
0.0803055167,
0.1791587323,
-0.4703050256,
-0.0972912386,
0.2085321248,
0.2477964908,
-0.0208808463,
-0.2641712725,
-0.0264996048,
0.2387951016,
-0.2064507753,
-0.8579079509,
0.2279553264,
0.0741299763,
0.5360683203,
0.7371319532,
0.0179586038,
0.5743899941,
-0.5340965986,
1.1416430473,
-0.1338455677,
-0.8539677262,
0.4268287122,
-0.4649645388,
0.725633204,
0.2970495224,
0.6706126332,
-0.8497883081,
-0.4375400543,
-0.4231776893,
-0.6604542136,
0.6972967982,
-0.1886866391,
0.4521689713,
-0.1933216602,
0.0748143941,
0.0914611965,
0.1601204574,
-0.8657200336,
-0.0015546882,
-0.455050528,
-0.3296912014,
-0.059487287,
-0.0996983722,
-0.5124111176,
-0.2689042091,
0.5427230597,
-0.2683762312,
0.1978898495,
0.0469099693,
-0.0484903641,
-0.3527673781,
0.284794718,
0.8414063454,
0.9670255184,
0.1552530378,
-0.1490987688,
0.1010679826,
-0.4211470485,
0.2781273127,
-0.1495953947,
-0.4448932707,
-0.4264174402,
0.2441504896,
0.7101060152,
-0.6006944776,
-0.2960570455,
0.148073867,
-0.1315907836,
-0.0480092391,
-0.6042817831,
0.0060099796,
-0.078871876,
0.1313564926,
0.283177346,
-0.1423237324,
-0.1778731048,
-0.8041367531,
-0.2129831016,
0.6491971612,
-0.4074530005,
-0.2549736202,
0.7125862837,
0.4078454971,
-0.2224939764,
1.0410766602,
-0.074658595,
-0.7306369543,
0.6115208864,
0.53225106,
0.5844365358,
-0.5258264542,
0.1990579367,
0.2436515987,
0.6023528576,
-0.1376447678,
0.1709516346,
0.0494213067,
-1.0608532429,
-0.7301126122,
-0.5495319366,
-0.1936119795,
0.2379954606,
-0.6264491081,
0.2482553571,
-0.1188173518,
-0.1193717942,
-0.1246033087,
-0.2429326326,
-0.857070148,
0.2523301244,
0.4190641046,
0.7867842317,
-1.1991388798,
0.8581386209,
0.870474875,
-0.5636441112,
-0.7828567028,
0.3107112348,
0.3280702233,
-0.8293852806,
0.9681996703,
0.1939062476,
-0.0492448583,
-0.1099743173,
-0.5334100127,
-0.9397701025,
0.8812327981,
0.1421557367,
-0.3021535575,
0.232343182,
0.1357824057,
0.7723951936,
-0.3660162687,
0.4856948853,
0.6584146023,
0.6695309877,
-0.0392944664,
-1.1494461298,
-0.1129506156,
-0.3086671829,
0.0890630335,
0.1964439601,
-0.8221473694,
0.5860372782,
0.0032755253,
-0.0255593192,
-0.1199798211,
0.6206940413,
0.1179234609,
0.0551497042,
0.5354272723,
0.2704228759,
0.7871390581,
-0.3760526478,
1.037561059,
-0.4562922716,
-0.1261001527,
0.7672196031,
-0.5975517631,
0.5724216104,
0.3126719594,
-0.0204365086,
0.7266712785,
0.6029340625,
-0.1332155466,
0.1971268058,
0.0821305364,
-0.1531717032,
0.0051997174,
-0.3096765876,
-0.3159564137,
0.9813061357,
0.4341903925,
-0.3384048045,
0.2215327621,
0.1078151688,
0.3584125042,
0.0729281232,
-0.3525846303,
0.7851014733,
-0.323870331,
-1.429369092,
0.5473627448,
-0.1620450765,
0.6694425344,
-0.5760844946,
0.0219218899,
-0.4450965226,
0.0789987445,
-0.1725854278,
-0.6454080343,
0.1750645787,
0.0524306484,
-0.2703304291,
-0.4968470633,
0.3042743802,
-0.5525584817,
-0.3155951202,
0.1388510466,
0.3108917177,
-0.0391200855,
-0.0101693375,
-0.5135912299,
0.0884764791,
0.1765968502,
-0.1968788803,
0.2025658935,
0.1387584358,
-0.7534291744,
0.5640689731,
0.5327736139,
0.1099581793,
-0.1414500624,
0.2836849689,
0.4561659098,
-0.4454406798,
-0.4996442497,
-0.8881838918,
0.4631676674,
-0.2276797593,
-0.2139079273,
0.6651053429,
0.1242411584,
1.1255083084,
-0.0965991542,
1.0558495522,
-0.2432588637,
-0.0446795933,
-0.4030521214,
0.9560987353,
-0.2698287368,
-0.1215307638,
-0.2449743897,
-0.9755926132,
0.0609618872,
0.6304500699,
-0.5928680301,
0.5317314267,
0.4483922124,
0.5599167943,
0.1908029318,
0.1434477568,
0.2702955306,
0.3333486021,
0.3954668939,
0.226327166,
1.0628176928,
0.3056044877,
0.2528465688,
-0.4145085216,
-0.5816709995,
0.0726987496,
-1.0179235935,
-0.5222252607,
-0.6992086768,
-0.3580812216,
-0.3260538578,
-0.2462207526,
1.0121289492,
0.7523877621,
-0.87185359,
-0.2468945384,
0.3448826671,
-0.111303553,
-0.4273375869,
-0.2601443827,
0.1213494092,
-0.1859769225,
-1.05806005,
0.222897321,
0.1547099054,
0.0153594194,
-0.6313455105,
0.0010431146,
0.0488635041,
0.1047170162,
0.5164916515,
0.3510767817,
-1.0044317245,
-0.3547389507,
0.0336117223,
0.0186556838,
-0.0153872091,
0.673386693,
-0.5059454441,
0.5675364137,
0.5228181481,
0.3310181499,
-0.0328513198,
0.320974052,
1.035020113,
-0.5712958574,
0.2968701422,
0.2271732241,
0.2832816243,
0.4583104253,
-0.504534483,
0.4523867965,
0.0558972284,
-0.9848239422,
-0.3423770666,
0.4269703031,
-0.3750272393,
-0.1784331799,
1.1126345396,
0.0293851551,
-0.1074528396,
0.0504457876,
-0.1127408296,
0.1556397527,
-0.3054106832,
1.0817176104,
1.0758482218,
-0.1041126177,
0.0311159622,
-0.799306035,
0.7141166329,
0.6187010407,
-0.5878782868,
-0.1586382836,
0.7600224614,
0.2285190374,
0.312679261,
0.4117043316,
-0.0673958063,
0.2896459103,
-0.4234616756,
0.2706146538,
0.2824418247,
-0.2095752805,
-0.5063785911,
-0.2147226185,
0.3767654896,
0.1780797094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14087v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14087v1
|
Question Answering in Natural Language: the Special Case of Temporal Expressions
| 2023-11-23T16:26:24 | 2023-11-23T16:26:24 |
Armand Stricker
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Although general question answering has been well explored in recent years,
temporal question answering is a task which has not received as much focus. Our
work aims to leverage a popular approach used for general question answering,
answer extraction, in order to find answers to temporal questions within a
paragraph. To train our model, we propose a new dataset, inspired by SQuAD,
specifically tailored to provide rich temporal information. We chose to adapt
the corpus WikiWars, which contains several documents on history's greatest
conflicts. Our evaluation shows that a deep learning model trained to perform
pattern matching, often used in general question answering, can be adapted to
temporal question answering, if we accept to ask questions whose answers must
be directly present within a text.
|
[
-0.3190318644,
-1.2615436316,
0.6951438785,
0.3192978501,
-0.2606719732,
0.4353868961,
0.1832377464,
-0.7709429264,
0.0577248633,
0.2183163166,
-1.1278165579,
-0.0927451327,
-0.299574405,
0.3033700883,
-0.4399757981,
0.8606817722,
-0.1725224406,
0.103639558,
-0.0145788789,
-0.1709249467,
-0.5802505016,
-0.601655364,
-0.7987738848,
-0.2316968739,
0.5477274656,
0.1951130927,
0.519063592,
0.537802279,
0.5222730637,
0.3500128686,
-0.0828235969,
0.1486421973,
-0.2491231859,
0.4075974226,
-0.1956758201,
-0.2872138321,
-0.0303818919,
-0.0030050066,
0.5851287246,
0.6464160681,
0.035054639,
0.3438880742,
-0.4322768152,
0.4165970683,
-0.3533955812,
0.1074385643,
-0.7487267852,
0.3909589052,
0.1418726593,
-0.3334028423,
-0.0008884172,
-0.4844075441,
0.5505204201,
-0.7978565097,
0.5309932828,
-0.0832329839,
1.0171183348,
0.2437600344,
-0.4461669028,
-0.3760268986,
-0.7449027896,
0.5758215785,
-0.3736589253,
-0.1761599779,
0.2206338644,
0.5242047906,
-0.0502705015,
-0.7333140969,
-0.7756947875,
-0.0291117281,
-0.1845278591,
0.2473436892,
-0.1778112203,
-0.1766912788,
0.1208729148,
0.2777435184,
-0.8189162612,
0.071615465,
-0.2782980502,
-0.1567056924,
0.6763117313,
0.519167006,
0.5609011054,
-0.1610852182,
-0.4630115628,
0.1871816218,
-0.1251410842,
0.4265960455,
0.1732109785,
0.0125327231,
-0.087169826,
0.548214972,
-0.4057544768,
0.8477282524,
0.0145367766,
0.5073213577,
-0.2317981869,
-0.2251371294,
-0.2314336151,
0.0659527853,
0.5396665931,
0.4329397082,
0.6916483641,
-0.5417771935,
0.2557237446,
0.1106280237,
0.1830759048,
-0.839268744,
0.2620043457,
0.2575717568,
-0.1569818407,
-0.3251996338,
0.087225914,
-1.012748003,
-0.1569691747,
-0.2940532565,
0.3612712026,
-0.221618861,
-0.0011903166,
-0.0064683314,
-0.6626236439,
0.7069023848,
0.3655545413,
-0.7192456126,
0.2243238688,
0.6035147309,
0.5779973269,
-0.0190521721,
-0.0472460166,
-0.8588969707,
0.3140939772,
-0.6062505245,
0.9998165369,
-0.6436083317,
-0.494350642,
0.1030986831,
0.3621219695,
-0.2461154014,
-0.4820995331,
0.391130209,
-0.9408918023,
0.68215698,
-0.1115435511,
-0.7268586159,
0.0924020112,
0.1907513142,
-0.5787202716,
0.9549600482,
0.2023092508,
-0.4652989209,
0.0412438214,
-0.7866026163,
-0.4670000672,
0.1348493397,
-0.0101392251,
-0.1413628012,
0.115855746,
0.5410860181,
0.3983286917,
-0.3970608413,
0.3007136285,
-0.2926768661,
-0.3237751126,
0.559984386,
-0.1368945837,
0.8013882637,
0.3733559847,
-0.17883569,
-0.0847169608,
-0.5861611962,
0.2756655216,
0.3978692293,
-0.2105541378,
-0.158124581,
0.0232822038,
-0.1797876805,
0.2220499963,
0.4317136109,
-0.5720035434,
0.3844146132,
-0.2094378471,
0.6134492755,
0.704206109,
0.6382859349,
0.5902234316,
-0.3689816296,
0.4901864231,
-0.1784615666,
0.1206687987,
0.0250355508,
-0.5504789352,
-0.4850871265,
0.1427671015,
-0.1415420622,
0.8919602633,
-0.5979894996,
0.147651121,
-0.1594572663,
-0.5026680827,
-0.446469903,
0.1024431959,
0.2298796773,
0.7867588997,
0.4817761779,
0.2007133812,
-0.894400537,
-0.9587061405,
-0.4353544712,
-0.378590256,
-0.1611052155,
0.2019484341,
0.356336683,
-0.0242386628,
1.2051078081,
-0.7634580731,
0.1618764251,
-0.173015222,
0.3799452186,
0.0736052692,
0.0445094258,
0.5535473228,
-1.1632893085,
-0.3995083272,
-0.112289913,
-0.9685201049,
-0.1156839654,
-0.2320139557,
-0.0944199041,
0.0899436921,
0.7794916034,
-0.5516987443,
0.1753640026,
0.4098905027,
-0.5441551208,
0.1625505537,
0.0887140706,
0.429063499,
-1.1638394594,
0.0596981421,
-0.2442245781,
-0.1357980072,
-0.8758386374,
-0.0556532815,
0.0077827554,
-0.3543227911,
-0.703071475,
0.9228828549,
-0.0258137602,
0.0746427551,
-0.1306133717,
0.2922666967,
0.1799652576,
0.4796286523,
0.1713265181,
0.7614684701,
0.1188304722,
-0.6253264546,
0.4700655639,
0.3162344992,
-0.2402298748,
0.2755622268,
-0.8402377963,
0.4849234521,
-0.5964469314,
0.0354621857,
-0.873683095,
-0.3150233328,
0.1075222865,
-0.425067395,
0.2729058266,
-0.4544761181,
-0.2866983712,
-0.2776923776,
0.018552646,
0.1129242703,
0.4525051713,
-0.2886327505,
0.5913875699,
0.3035547137,
-0.3527854383,
-0.6387789845,
-0.5169274807,
0.0423491858,
-0.2550139427,
-0.5157406926,
0.5861449838,
-0.433617264,
-0.4797617197,
0.1840533316,
-0.3206726909,
-0.6189180613,
0.370651722,
-0.0763327405,
0.3489219844,
-0.4174724221,
0.3001395166,
-0.1823338717,
0.0475654118,
-0.1118748114,
0.0956530645,
0.6413359046,
-0.0275476947,
0.1361218244,
-0.2905851007,
1.097789526,
0.3476712704,
-0.285217464,
0.5250313282,
0.746173501,
-0.376191169,
0.062084116,
-0.6399649382,
-0.016629165,
-0.499109298,
0.5826653242,
-0.0279658716,
-1.0915555954,
0.4982245266,
0.3316651583,
0.2082680613,
0.7168323994,
0.4838893712,
-0.7045955062,
0.9472487569,
0.4656782448,
-0.3427773714,
0.6085754633,
0.0991026238,
-0.1107228175,
-0.2642061114,
-0.4401978552,
-0.7657751441,
-0.2924743593,
-0.4220375419,
-0.1383507997,
-0.1192642674,
0.3797968924,
-0.3826547265,
0.2074875981,
-0.4133813977,
0.434728682,
0.3245202303,
-0.1005438119,
0.0553421117,
-0.4276284575,
0.5296654105,
0.2404750139,
-0.4542353451,
-0.3726287782,
0.4227556586,
0.0134749291,
0.4209400415,
0.29549703,
0.5192213058,
0.2290547043,
0.1433489621,
-0.5001910925,
0.6040734649,
-0.0183440391,
-0.933060348,
-0.4967980385,
-0.5973183513,
-1.2020688057,
-0.2064889669,
-0.1145615876,
-0.6583174467,
-0.0774381608,
-0.3395067155,
-0.4362406433,
0.0463342704,
-0.9416567683,
0.886778295,
-0.2935802341,
0.3532255292,
0.0605879761,
-0.7577164173,
-0.1035631672,
0.2604240179,
0.0026631963,
-0.5468108058,
-0.2199117839,
0.970244348,
-0.0640914664,
0.7276601195,
-0.2064747065,
0.2658781111,
0.5348306894,
0.0289233904,
0.2917074859,
0.2224721014,
0.1051916033,
-0.2091535479,
0.3841276169,
-0.6505608559,
-0.9176963568,
0.523260355,
-0.8154264688,
-0.8157920241,
-0.3340839446,
-0.7841199636,
-0.3220794797,
0.0012343619,
0.2085161358,
0.3915856779,
-0.6748429537,
-0.037657626,
0.871766448,
-0.1291689724,
1.0952640772,
0.7425727844,
-0.0460762978,
-0.1397039294,
0.4335384071,
0.0187645797,
0.0604003221,
1.0064018965,
0.3209915757,
-0.3523912728,
-0.3337138295,
-0.4846353531,
-0.060366381,
-0.55268085,
-0.2259430736,
-0.6959466934,
-0.3601223826,
-0.5525467396,
-0.2499960661,
0.2548339665,
-0.7352831364,
-0.4280738235,
-0.0964576006,
0.6434405446,
0.5957711339,
0.5308754444,
0.1421271861,
-0.9864456654,
0.8451187611,
0.9805699587,
0.0306823291,
-0.5160413384,
-0.3354406357,
0.0775581375,
-0.2380972952,
-0.0616184846,
-1.2430169582,
0.1077437773,
0.4829706252,
0.7261220813,
-0.1502082646,
0.1527701169,
0.7941607237,
-0.6576006413,
1.0253379345,
-0.170788005,
-0.5781673789,
0.7510634661,
-0.3590039015,
0.5919138789,
0.375410527,
0.4997457564,
-0.7753500342,
-0.2779433429,
-0.7252985835,
-0.6088201404,
0.2625050843,
-0.1492506117,
0.3052414656,
-0.1892274618,
0.5365171432,
-0.1912119836,
0.1260223985,
-0.2333819866,
-0.1908013225,
-0.2260997593,
-0.322170943,
-0.3355962336,
-0.1160202026,
-0.0601130165,
-0.1094328389,
0.2563915849,
-0.1329548359,
0.5646140575,
0.4768556058,
-0.4531550407,
-0.0429353714,
0.5814436674,
0.5347241759,
0.4177424312,
-0.1772626787,
-0.1727728695,
0.4237194061,
-0.3350968361,
0.1823985428,
0.3740214109,
0.0476963371,
0.1879053861,
0.5123986006,
0.3713952601,
0.1784762442,
-0.6644263864,
0.4199272394,
-0.3137612343,
-0.2265309095,
-0.6071531177,
0.1185886562,
0.2082118094,
0.4645335972,
0.8476923704,
-0.2074734718,
-0.1723110676,
-0.9435167313,
0.2763426006,
0.415809691,
-0.5016357899,
-0.0903405696,
0.3955558538,
-0.0096587408,
-0.6034327149,
0.7987276912,
0.1278199106,
-0.5657227635,
0.8066260219,
0.3887985349,
0.7872760296,
-0.1986175478,
0.3220873177,
0.1354558617,
-0.0221214555,
0.4214500189,
0.5781846046,
0.0337427519,
-0.5495099425,
-0.7148790359,
-0.4563930333,
-0.3476702869,
0.0657017156,
-0.7198006511,
-0.0263229031,
-0.652161777,
-0.0724212155,
0.1598593593,
0.4331072569,
-1.2137923241,
0.2630520761,
0.0390388444,
0.9659920335,
-0.6466989517,
0.7422514558,
0.4367259145,
-0.5218116045,
-0.4925484061,
-0.0032429532,
-0.1908934861,
-0.8873323202,
0.7288635969,
-0.0203054752,
0.1624196917,
0.0580795109,
-0.6254672408,
-0.5105470419,
1.022217989,
0.4811838865,
-0.1249201298,
-0.6053341031,
0.1673387587,
0.5506040454,
-0.2960248888,
-0.0761170462,
0.4167686999,
0.4345787466,
-0.2783820629,
-0.4224533141,
-0.1833250374,
-0.451566577,
-0.3648130894,
0.187996462,
-0.450899601,
0.4686839879,
-0.0381179936,
-0.3819055259,
0.4961028397,
0.7563465834,
-0.2123572528,
0.4272105098,
0.3461726904,
0.1486158818,
0.7383684516,
-0.4319315851,
1.1483845711,
0.1835255176,
-0.009819611,
1.1133064032,
-0.0857359171,
0.7305291891,
0.6673359275,
-0.0119675454,
0.6195574403,
0.5743814111,
-0.0226526875,
0.554279983,
0.0861171931,
-0.3837418556,
-0.3502156436,
-0.1567849815,
-0.3007143736,
0.2446883023,
0.1607585996,
-0.0250972081,
-0.3481923342,
-0.1883850694,
-0.0991396829,
0.0717647299,
-0.3695578277,
1.0405451059,
-0.14136298,
-0.6851869226,
0.0531059168,
-0.2087300867,
0.2033726424,
-0.8835784793,
-0.1373097599,
-0.3253132701,
-0.1672611088,
0.1403197646,
-1.0130162239,
0.3767912388,
0.1271937042,
-0.5408752561,
-0.1667152047,
0.4546500146,
-0.2594046295,
-0.5122951865,
0.1070945561,
0.6088817716,
-0.3182371855,
0.1039983854,
-0.7301188111,
-0.4415161312,
-0.3681070507,
-0.1833849698,
0.3325694799,
0.7354667187,
0.0828740001,
0.5142843127,
0.5969287753,
-0.1896975785,
0.2788982987,
-0.0518310331,
0.5481906533,
-0.7603231072,
-0.4254253805,
-0.8470925093,
0.4947730005,
-0.4067457318,
-0.6097480059,
0.5783492327,
0.3638574779,
0.4730903804,
-0.0573812798,
0.6413633227,
-0.0105607035,
0.7410061359,
-0.5496005416,
0.3855272233,
-0.2905629575,
-0.1725849807,
-0.3515430689,
-0.5831840634,
-0.3228608966,
0.2820648253,
-0.196930021,
-0.4443145692,
0.5268476605,
0.551920712,
0.3266065419,
0.3713291585,
0.2004138678,
-0.0701434016,
0.3791903257,
0.6884280443,
1.1699465513,
-0.3267879486,
0.9006961584,
-0.2387691587,
0.1156315506,
-0.0587579645,
-0.9463766217,
-0.8162814975,
-0.8482487798,
-0.2978179753,
-0.1285914779,
0.5350814462,
0.8624677658,
0.3100656569,
-0.7079622746,
0.1594272703,
0.1602609009,
0.0478194766,
-0.3486717045,
-0.2271003276,
0.5239847898,
-0.5915216208,
-0.6667366624,
0.618293345,
-0.1012702882,
0.3575661182,
0.3008658886,
0.176258415,
-0.4376161397,
0.0003004992,
0.4224687517,
0.6060967445,
-0.2628504038,
-0.702884078,
0.5892215967,
-0.0039659501,
-0.0039668251,
1.2633082867,
-0.7786168456,
0.1402892768,
0.5471636057,
1.1445697546,
0.7229391932,
-0.1756963283,
0.7331155539,
-0.8506966233,
0.1041621417,
0.582028985,
0.3061319292,
0.1982910484,
-0.2528194785,
0.4904882908,
0.1775319129,
-0.4298332632,
-0.4608629942,
0.2983168662,
-1.0513950586,
-0.6414273381,
0.9642017484,
0.1059765518,
-0.2102088034,
-0.5810555816,
-0.1576253623,
0.4990037382,
-0.1761709303,
0.62016958,
0.8234503865,
-0.0296924487,
-0.0036167209,
-0.7320072055,
0.4532162547,
0.2674213052,
-0.8738574982,
-0.0362871662,
0.1435693353,
0.3533101082,
-0.0378253162,
0.621497333,
-0.1378766298,
0.4386834204,
-0.3674188554,
-0.5293320417,
-0.0585361049,
-0.0782750696,
-0.2576690912,
0.3616868258,
-0.1695139557,
-0.1205387488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14076v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14076v1
|
Searching for Snippets of Open-Domain Dialogue in Task-Oriented Dialogue Datasets
| 2023-11-23T16:08:39 | 2023-11-23T16:08:39 |
Armand Stricker, Patrick Paroubek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Most existing dialogue corpora and models have been designed to fit into 2
predominant categories : task-oriented dialogues portray functional goals, such
as making a restaurant reservation or booking a plane ticket, while
chit-chat/open-domain dialogues focus on holding a socially engaging talk with
a user. However, humans tend to seamlessly switch between modes and even use
chitchat to enhance task-oriented conversations. To bridge this gap, new
datasets have recently been created, blending both communication modes into
conversation examples. The approaches used tend to rely on adding chit-chat
snippets to pre-existing, human-generated task-oriented datasets. Given the
tendencies observed in humans, we wonder however if the latter do not
\textit{already} hold chit-chat sequences. By using topic modeling and
searching for topics which are most similar to a set of keywords related to
social talk, we explore the training sets of Schema-Guided Dialogues and
MultiWOZ. Our study shows that sequences related to social talk are indeed
naturally present, motivating further research on ways chitchat is combined
into task-oriented dialogues.
|
[
-0.2478392869,
-0.9675915241,
0.5655126572,
0.1502172947,
-0.3936243951,
0.1649507731,
-0.4316823781,
-0.3112836182,
0.368901521,
0.6457945704,
-0.8059339523,
-0.4390435219,
-0.4141928256,
-0.0528405756,
-0.3883872926,
0.903369844,
0.2013904303,
0.0909493566,
-0.4615558088,
-0.1515149921,
-0.589236021,
-0.7450072169,
-0.2065265328,
-0.1239670143,
0.4446738362,
0.6260117888,
0.727665782,
0.4803270102,
0.2236573398,
0.2074119151,
0.0230612811,
0.3176831901,
-0.5182561874,
0.520065248,
-0.1318538636,
-0.4354295135,
-0.1746605188,
0.071931906,
0.2467562556,
0.9049817324,
-0.2266692519,
-0.0490733422,
0.3838921189,
0.5191424489,
-0.2537638247,
0.6184945107,
-0.7196523547,
-0.0084869508,
-0.3800183237,
-0.4827958941,
-0.090948537,
-0.2280970514,
0.4489597082,
-0.4586586654,
0.4044434726,
-0.0412902758,
0.7885295749,
0.1064266562,
-0.3943921328,
-0.4271264076,
-0.672852695,
0.6589235663,
-0.4784795344,
0.4662050903,
0.6300933361,
0.1096804887,
-0.3588330448,
-0.4757296443,
-0.4392629564,
-0.1880638599,
-0.0100468388,
-0.1267306805,
-0.1396454722,
0.0057489141,
0.1556552351,
0.2687901855,
-0.5183407664,
-0.2359713614,
-0.4292497337,
-0.0757468864,
0.5776968598,
0.427313894,
0.1233255118,
-0.3156528771,
-0.2627609074,
0.1783603132,
-0.5159407258,
0.1066443026,
0.0701788962,
0.5907518268,
-0.0499634482,
0.6401546597,
-0.583912909,
0.8837593198,
0.078195326,
-0.0741279721,
-0.0112392046,
-0.6549617052,
0.0740196556,
-0.1507674605,
0.6030879617,
0.573997736,
0.4276840389,
-0.2039622068,
0.2998103201,
0.1150351018,
0.4572381973,
-0.5281155705,
-0.2237416953,
0.0630111098,
-0.5596120954,
-0.4197284877,
0.0496564545,
-0.6419467926,
-0.3600357175,
-0.4890346527,
-0.0493261479,
-0.3540164232,
-0.110437192,
0.0913556963,
-0.1167827472,
0.2687294483,
0.5538936853,
-0.6729228497,
0.1974780858,
0.791541338,
0.8096550703,
-0.1801446676,
-0.4007398784,
-0.4234002829,
-0.0973886698,
-0.4431374371,
0.8639150262,
-0.7545162439,
-0.5455774069,
0.2205127329,
0.1295046508,
-0.0672015622,
-0.3228892982,
0.3094097078,
-0.1470745504,
0.3378053308,
-0.3589999378,
-0.3010543883,
0.0644864812,
0.1435239613,
-0.1849315912,
1.1068412066,
0.1205382347,
-0.8012702465,
0.3061212301,
-0.6261899471,
-0.5377998948,
0.0356853604,
-0.6078919768,
-0.0500456803,
0.120483309,
-0.0990775302,
0.5522453785,
-0.6804171801,
0.2923775911,
-0.3728815317,
-0.4134548306,
0.505441606,
0.0204815157,
0.5966661572,
0.214428395,
-0.4005455375,
0.2219337374,
-0.2141381651,
-0.1674672216,
0.3022374213,
0.036947988,
-0.5687913299,
0.2078800946,
-0.2908523381,
0.290343523,
0.0685971379,
-0.566865623,
0.2529351711,
-0.0666814744,
0.6317723989,
0.7757194042,
-0.0100921877,
0.3325150907,
-0.4591684341,
0.256075263,
0.0780775696,
0.2324734628,
-0.3161488175,
-0.8134901524,
-0.7256187201,
-0.1163527071,
-0.0524465516,
0.5648645759,
-0.5912646055,
0.5622216463,
-0.2248127013,
-0.5488880277,
-0.3174221218,
-0.0950117558,
0.0309386253,
0.2080350667,
0.0071107433,
-0.4467059076,
-0.1305232048,
-0.8884382844,
-0.2364874482,
-0.0401902981,
-0.0053473008,
0.5736320019,
0.1480406821,
-0.0008953655,
1.099717617,
-0.7801564932,
-0.1506253183,
-0.4912690222,
0.0358618572,
-0.0600578859,
0.167867884,
0.546702683,
-0.7764030695,
-0.5902197361,
-0.2494923323,
-0.6086466312,
0.0663448274,
-0.0910134688,
-0.4327812791,
0.0318439752,
0.5303741693,
-0.7326524854,
0.7194324732,
0.2560447454,
-0.3580561876,
0.3994894028,
0.2929159701,
0.4463852644,
-1.1673529148,
-0.2414130718,
-0.1481287181,
-0.0513419732,
-0.8603678346,
-0.2229383141,
-0.1679504365,
-0.5759949684,
-0.2241788954,
0.2811975181,
-0.3396828175,
-0.111252062,
-0.2984896302,
0.2512609661,
-0.1202172861,
0.8371043205,
0.2976013124,
0.7233061194,
0.7924671769,
-0.524995327,
0.1253928691,
0.6796345115,
-0.4008952379,
0.6127145886,
-0.5759088397,
0.4365175664,
-0.076772213,
0.5102710128,
-0.826942265,
-0.2895743847,
0.3512423635,
-0.4068549275,
0.0822646767,
-0.2012257427,
-0.3127176166,
-0.1102202311,
-0.4599111378,
0.1350374073,
0.1436790079,
-0.2772741616,
0.2605588436,
0.6514383554,
-0.7580560446,
-0.5218042731,
-0.1986684799,
0.1164743677,
-0.1602182388,
-0.6595358253,
0.3154247701,
-0.0907134488,
0.0202399343,
-0.1908385307,
-0.3815452754,
0.0181830619,
-0.1037035063,
0.3829967976,
0.4674607813,
0.0129423672,
-0.040029414,
-0.2027018219,
0.1603084207,
-0.0989725292,
-0.2720561326,
0.9316222668,
-0.1339939535,
-0.3706820607,
-0.2105968297,
0.9256583452,
0.5360236764,
-0.3142327964,
0.400072813,
0.342068851,
-0.3811422884,
0.0303506181,
-0.4820005596,
-0.5269183517,
-0.4111228287,
0.2839053869,
-0.3203466833,
-1.3169978857,
0.417850256,
0.0835541114,
0.1615737081,
-0.0168958306,
0.3228656352,
-0.2300102115,
0.8154996037,
0.4380142987,
0.1052383706,
0.7692496777,
-0.0579313263,
0.5744532347,
-0.5523101091,
-0.1082680821,
-0.7297924161,
0.0696723163,
-0.5861815214,
-0.5817926526,
0.1752630025,
-0.0450743437,
0.1029898897,
0.6164640784,
-0.2973620594,
0.1975222975,
0.6805799007,
0.1072475687,
0.0850802213,
-0.0254518948,
0.1963039935,
-0.165690437,
-0.816529274,
-0.2456302047,
0.8416439295,
0.1366560608,
0.7076457739,
-0.1798719764,
0.7722583413,
0.2456926852,
-0.0544532537,
-0.8411916494,
0.8215013742,
-0.0283161867,
-0.455318749,
-0.432202667,
-0.4123462737,
-1.0580073595,
-0.0914711729,
-0.2792606652,
-1.0887010098,
0.3445517421,
-0.0491038375,
-0.1282325685,
0.0408100635,
-0.1941164881,
1.0528825521,
0.0056242174,
-0.3112145066,
-0.3417041302,
-0.7994316816,
0.2631894648,
0.1190394238,
0.0567864589,
-0.4163202047,
0.5976886749,
0.5928592682,
-0.3510915339,
0.9453077316,
0.0491114222,
-0.0816893056,
0.5514087081,
0.1124373898,
0.3863179684,
-0.1694113314,
0.4737676382,
0.4826492071,
-0.0803689659,
-0.4727323949,
-0.6041512489,
0.543977499,
-0.4151661396,
-0.8321887255,
-0.4497193694,
-0.4520474374,
-0.3285607994,
-0.0525471494,
0.2657559812,
0.50103122,
-0.319893837,
0.3263365626,
0.4633026719,
-0.1849851459,
0.0029711078,
0.3050398827,
-0.0048809876,
-0.1323428601,
0.8340405226,
-0.0750206038,
0.4362697899,
0.1266498268,
0.2018148452,
-0.1916626394,
-0.2409658283,
-0.2426723093,
0.277267158,
-0.5636311769,
-0.3565328419,
-0.8420901299,
-0.2140063047,
-0.6052623391,
-0.1267004907,
-0.231202811,
-0.5635825992,
-0.0004333683,
0.0186537169,
0.5025919676,
0.4967209697,
0.0347920023,
0.0990461111,
-1.0302270651,
0.2945251167,
0.4559856951,
0.2418276966,
-0.1105777621,
-0.2021248788,
-0.3668762445,
0.2080880851,
-0.4064559639,
-1.0937867165,
0.1762340516,
0.3328288794,
0.6658860445,
0.3493512273,
0.225565955,
0.580282867,
-0.4219965041,
1.0515985489,
0.0939644128,
-0.7280008793,
0.8461108804,
-0.6641532779,
-0.0287165176,
0.5072593689,
0.4319655001,
-0.9148180485,
-0.5364925861,
-0.5677407384,
-0.7432773709,
0.934096396,
0.2755639851,
0.1834392399,
-0.3491365612,
0.0249827746,
0.1792966276,
0.5217651725,
-0.2815942466,
-0.2471261919,
-0.3994484544,
0.0933804885,
-0.0238134116,
0.0240601338,
-0.3289943635,
-0.0745300055,
0.3287499249,
-0.1872784495,
0.7450947762,
0.0278936028,
0.1421210021,
-0.081301488,
0.4851097465,
0.438054651,
0.3997330666,
-0.4468147159,
-0.119429484,
-0.3519575,
-0.4164227545,
-0.1295680851,
0.1695944667,
0.1073794216,
-0.0063896785,
-0.0867220536,
0.8606163859,
0.2760207355,
-0.7184098363,
0.6166932583,
-0.079475455,
-0.252111882,
-0.0171467401,
0.2118200064,
0.1347280294,
0.2709510624,
0.2327932119,
0.1006635278,
0.323536396,
-1.1053148508,
0.1539144218,
0.4271075726,
-0.4308251441,
-0.1384311765,
0.4219319522,
0.3966062665,
-0.5817140937,
0.7406742573,
-0.0452226736,
-0.690433979,
0.170235008,
0.4132440984,
1.0643451214,
-0.0805929005,
0.3760433495,
0.0643569827,
-0.0397872962,
0.0567767881,
0.2899378836,
-0.5937330127,
-0.8908500075,
-0.282551825,
-0.3293306231,
-0.6082066894,
0.030838564,
-0.7742510438,
0.2239799947,
0.0810091496,
-0.1922860295,
0.1479542851,
-0.3244181871,
-0.7350725532,
-0.2077074498,
-0.0618399531,
0.6439051032,
-0.6800019145,
0.860484302,
0.5779227018,
-0.1286245733,
-0.464661181,
0.3513239324,
0.1139520109,
-0.5009633303,
0.3503971398,
0.1648067981,
-0.21178177,
-0.3981036246,
-0.4706104398,
-0.601044178,
0.9275672436,
-0.0644263923,
-0.2645672262,
-0.3604266047,
0.2266563326,
0.2757327259,
-0.600089848,
-0.2148624063,
0.5440671444,
0.0283512641,
0.0165207125,
-1.1247702837,
-0.0522542931,
-0.4263613224,
-0.2528994679,
0.3149654567,
-0.7013751864,
0.7431557178,
-0.1598528475,
-0.1219552457,
-0.0428704657,
0.4597500563,
0.3128842711,
0.5463206768,
0.7584528923,
-0.0202344302,
0.3627804518,
-0.2679472268,
0.7129260302,
-0.2159397751,
0.0959901586,
1.1777675152,
-0.5599529147,
0.6165776849,
0.3817618489,
-0.0436352752,
0.2800521851,
0.7519358397,
0.3452251256,
0.6027585864,
0.1221766993,
-0.1763348728,
-0.460157305,
-0.226387769,
-0.261294961,
0.8108506203,
0.6395028234,
-0.0062307441,
-0.0475093871,
-0.0581678972,
0.0254758839,
-0.0726537481,
0.1832634807,
0.9301476479,
0.0316036642,
-0.8025323749,
0.3628972471,
-0.2748890817,
0.6438956261,
-0.7190735936,
-0.1566459537,
-0.3053739071,
-0.4052004218,
0.1008858606,
-0.5831913948,
0.2019954026,
-0.0340198576,
0.1729489863,
-0.194659248,
0.8560172319,
-0.668181777,
0.1005600542,
0.1204281896,
0.7567695975,
0.302785486,
-0.1937769204,
-0.585401237,
-0.1589327902,
0.2611580193,
-0.0265727285,
0.4058039188,
0.5366900563,
-0.2222622484,
0.427367568,
0.6842705011,
-0.1124951392,
-0.1365536749,
0.0630997717,
1.0937657356,
-0.7894585133,
-0.746534884,
-0.2773150206,
0.3885389864,
-0.338026464,
-0.3506019115,
0.6981194615,
0.4503408372,
0.7996072173,
-0.175239414,
0.9577494264,
-0.1112391502,
0.7789868116,
-0.3394542634,
0.2421843708,
-0.4234567583,
0.0310883243,
-0.627107203,
-1.0630666018,
0.1862515956,
0.9678515196,
-0.0702155605,
-0.2078828365,
0.6043211818,
0.8601658344,
-0.2240102142,
0.5321519375,
0.2565423548,
-0.2483449876,
0.1901026964,
0.2853346765,
1.3073831797,
-0.0637491047,
0.5007017255,
-0.2137511969,
-0.3673094213,
-0.533316195,
-0.5990813375,
-1.0450764894,
-1.004496932,
-0.4343815744,
-0.3815129399,
0.225492999,
1.1013073921,
0.7152415514,
-0.5386391878,
-0.3565780818,
0.0849619135,
-0.1421973109,
-0.347955972,
-0.2994953692,
0.1762241423,
-0.4173204303,
-0.5943152308,
0.650777638,
0.4323196709,
0.1164453849,
-0.054559201,
0.1005605832,
-0.0910745785,
0.4328433275,
0.6332030296,
0.2006150782,
-0.5543715358,
-0.4750828743,
0.6162590384,
0.0612054281,
0.0457884818,
1.5347458124,
-0.3471155763,
0.2358465493,
0.3954763412,
0.455573976,
0.7166115046,
-0.1538120955,
0.8350098133,
-0.755856216,
0.1827693433,
0.1046008989,
0.2617502213,
0.2161856592,
-0.1863699257,
0.5863803029,
0.2107174844,
-0.5671102405,
-0.8948015571,
0.4853717685,
-1.2096034288,
-0.3155082166,
1.0028418303,
-0.1205682456,
0.2444093525,
-0.5023034811,
-0.4388345182,
0.2121549398,
-0.5297880769,
0.882663846,
0.779956162,
-0.5355192423,
0.014644946,
-0.4601801634,
0.7580522299,
0.2579387426,
-0.9156888723,
0.6630740762,
0.6269868016,
0.0715083405,
0.349250406,
0.9623319507,
-0.0379012115,
0.2965020835,
-0.024723703,
-0.2792759836,
0.1897281259,
-0.494805783,
0.1981135607,
-0.0771825537,
-0.092105329,
-0.4606878459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14067v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14067v2
|
Enhancing Task-Oriented Dialogues with Chitchat: a Comparative Study Based on Lexical Diversity and Divergence
| 2023-11-23T15:50:42 | 2024-01-24T20:56:59 |
Armand Stricker, Patrick Paroubek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As a recent development, task-oriented dialogues (TODs) have been enriched
with chitchat in an effort to make dialogues more diverse and engaging. This
enhancement is particularly valuable as TODs are often confined to narrow
domains, making the mitigation of repetitive and predictable responses a
significant challenge. This paper presents a comparative analysis of three
chitchat enhancements, aiming to identify the most effective approach in terms
of diversity. Additionally, we quantify the divergence between the added
chitchat, the original task-oriented language, and chitchat typically found in
chitchat datasets, highlighting the top 20 divergent keywords for each
comparison. Our findings drive a discussion on future enhancements for
augmenting TODs, emphasizing the importance of grounding dialogues beyond the
task to achieve more diverse and natural exchanges.
|
[
-0.4707542658,
-0.5677238107,
0.2546057701,
0.4041868746,
-0.3332964182,
0.6592573524,
-0.3126375973,
-0.7233181,
0.3311584592,
0.2841056883,
-0.6151151061,
-0.2231770009,
-0.7117914557,
0.2089952081,
-0.4040306807,
0.9727475047,
0.320530206,
0.1194602847,
-0.2066094726,
-0.3081311285,
-0.7613726258,
-0.2815591097,
-0.4505926073,
-0.1903902888,
0.1833597869,
0.301800102,
0.6116787791,
0.3391619623,
0.6725756526,
0.3454847336,
-0.195282355,
0.1964287162,
-0.4451833963,
0.5351284146,
-0.2826320529,
-0.4728104174,
-0.230126366,
-0.3123873174,
0.3483141363,
0.8267817497,
0.2314433306,
-0.232519865,
0.4013347626,
0.8224332333,
-0.7558515668,
0.0905274749,
-0.4209240973,
-0.0200613141,
-0.3584283292,
0.020373011,
0.2295859307,
-0.3240345716,
0.468983531,
-0.3631135523,
0.0597145818,
-0.4750835896,
0.296392113,
0.2717705667,
-0.1465543509,
-0.222306028,
-0.8672593236,
1.0117715597,
-0.6235124469,
0.6087555885,
0.3581236303,
0.1435898691,
0.0620655119,
-0.6172747016,
-0.2626460493,
-0.3107489645,
0.2388940305,
0.194112286,
-0.060405124,
-0.1521857232,
-0.0464341193,
0.7171108127,
-0.3126629293,
-0.0069589294,
-0.0520862788,
-0.0173462573,
0.4731148779,
0.4719260037,
0.2974996865,
0.0419850834,
-0.046267312,
-0.0291898102,
-0.2182531953,
0.183189258,
0.3676381111,
0.397131592,
-0.1771245003,
0.5660811067,
-0.8383438587,
0.603705585,
0.2070184499,
-0.2358564585,
0.2449590415,
-0.6620357633,
-0.1700793654,
-0.3924528658,
0.4003384113,
0.3423694074,
0.1145166755,
-0.3579748571,
0.0586944222,
-0.1171236634,
0.3746756613,
-0.5054014325,
-0.2351768017,
0.2828659117,
-0.4588816464,
-0.2211544067,
0.1322884262,
-0.7195088267,
-0.5470297933,
-0.1883945316,
-0.1612512916,
-0.4504217207,
-0.2736304104,
-0.1086185947,
-0.437458843,
0.2618898153,
0.7885103226,
-0.5825437307,
0.3145993054,
0.8961380124,
0.7819766998,
-0.5927328467,
-0.2584942877,
-0.3844861984,
-0.1882673055,
-0.431858927,
0.8465963006,
-0.8320204616,
-0.7011270523,
0.0184833314,
-0.2937523127,
0.2010232359,
-0.6915948391,
0.5976269245,
-0.1243475154,
0.400715977,
-0.6286934018,
-0.0427877046,
-0.137918815,
0.4995891154,
-0.472777158,
1.0373327732,
0.3920680583,
-0.9667654634,
0.598411262,
-0.819540441,
-0.5634586215,
0.4361922741,
-0.1947374344,
0.0063208812,
0.1040050164,
0.2117813379,
0.0781294405,
-0.5709428191,
0.1331514269,
-0.2204982787,
-0.3570086956,
0.2013484687,
-0.0582406223,
0.7798106074,
0.3180285394,
-0.711024344,
0.1105207801,
-0.3562587798,
0.0149585158,
-0.0527299196,
-0.0828332826,
-0.5782510638,
0.1821975261,
-0.1057604253,
0.0335754007,
0.0412214175,
-0.6825790405,
0.0065615899,
-0.5017055869,
0.2815245092,
0.5031611919,
-0.1125134826,
0.4604565203,
-0.6061430573,
0.4514273703,
0.1862233877,
0.2647905648,
-0.0193353686,
-0.6906297803,
-0.7704957128,
-0.5988380909,
-0.0026613355,
0.6692430973,
-0.6718848348,
0.2731398344,
-0.4235506058,
-0.4437238276,
-0.353443712,
0.1906608194,
0.1896560937,
0.016537657,
0.3243445158,
-0.7697153091,
-0.4604616463,
-0.8459013104,
-0.5150597692,
-0.2201322466,
0.0439045914,
0.3946152627,
0.1068561897,
-0.2379838973,
1.0683254004,
-0.0625972822,
-0.0729492977,
-0.5945628285,
-0.1345726699,
-0.1619564891,
0.5133501291,
0.5825520158,
-0.5814197659,
-0.8137376904,
0.191849947,
-0.3637731969,
-0.110073626,
-0.090818733,
-0.1381201595,
0.0372180641,
0.1613898128,
-0.562592566,
0.5451068282,
0.2724256516,
-0.1786400825,
0.4786881506,
0.6049134731,
0.505864501,
-1.0381602049,
-0.1310320944,
-0.4040721953,
-0.4170575142,
-0.882227838,
0.1080007181,
-0.3020217419,
0.0253561977,
-0.1790563315,
0.4881932735,
-0.5698125958,
0.0780281723,
-0.3753863871,
0.1606940478,
-0.3501372039,
0.3751070797,
0.1007957533,
0.7171390057,
0.6448753476,
-0.4751456976,
0.2228038907,
0.4783960879,
-0.2735860944,
0.6151106954,
-0.6363118291,
0.2440834641,
0.0917924121,
0.1202021539,
-0.7852146626,
-0.0047931089,
0.2601426542,
-0.415474087,
0.2106327266,
-0.0020904851,
-0.1659373343,
-0.2125883847,
-0.8740089536,
0.485476464,
0.5074255466,
-0.4057575464,
0.2024125904,
0.3512965143,
-0.7520505786,
-0.9853146672,
-0.5903978348,
0.2770382464,
-0.1930923909,
-0.3505170643,
0.1627374738,
-0.2794882357,
-0.5483389497,
-0.2756284773,
-0.4122142494,
-0.0300940629,
0.1579026431,
0.2071129084,
-0.0506757386,
-0.1178373322,
-0.0727568567,
0.2316001207,
0.3948267996,
-0.1930910796,
-0.4439171851,
0.7843725085,
-0.1903103441,
-0.4724975526,
-0.1957226247,
0.7960234284,
0.5303940177,
-0.2133373767,
0.3590920866,
0.6285639405,
-0.1469160318,
0.112742722,
-0.8254265785,
-0.1933625191,
-0.4243549407,
0.3846788704,
-0.3253004849,
-1.2621777058,
0.5006973743,
0.0119695542,
0.2801919878,
0.2576536238,
0.72140342,
-0.0186030697,
0.7254454494,
0.8004124761,
-0.0953699946,
0.8599341512,
-0.0720830932,
0.29097417,
-0.9005093575,
-0.244407177,
-0.7385360599,
-0.2762036622,
-0.7090451717,
-0.6163752675,
-0.17716223,
0.0341614,
0.0059325523,
0.3571848869,
-0.3896808624,
0.0902221799,
0.5208624601,
-0.1140818819,
0.2275732309,
0.0091603613,
-0.0514116697,
-0.1280625612,
-0.7247850299,
-0.191962257,
0.8858850598,
0.2534764111,
0.7848300934,
0.3269152641,
0.8599058986,
0.3257584572,
0.1519587487,
-0.8108184934,
0.5904580951,
-0.0502418168,
-0.2457072288,
-0.3731203079,
-0.2329800874,
-1.0099242926,
0.1171893477,
-0.1406633705,
-1.1320753098,
0.5718049407,
-0.2051902264,
0.0672071651,
0.1674995422,
-0.3798188269,
0.602378726,
0.0140686734,
-0.3975612819,
-0.2703039348,
-0.6091013551,
0.2533682585,
0.0259922836,
-0.2088900357,
-0.050379172,
-0.0887613595,
0.5873568654,
-0.3771226406,
0.9007809162,
-0.0705721676,
-0.082773447,
0.386097461,
0.1028670892,
0.366900444,
0.1090449989,
0.3313402236,
0.2765823305,
-0.0846046209,
-0.522475481,
-0.4120484889,
0.7694518566,
-0.5737804174,
-0.9340961576,
-0.1455553025,
-1.0278458595,
-0.6079421639,
0.1557586044,
0.0449466221,
0.3928928375,
-0.3928637505,
0.3303381205,
0.2827711403,
-0.0817399323,
0.5741550922,
0.0654945746,
0.0841103494,
-0.4242266119,
0.5447651148,
-0.3698849976,
0.3858750761,
0.4771806002,
0.2145525217,
-0.3555299938,
-0.7793369889,
-0.0746097639,
0.0953420699,
-0.5697962046,
-0.2086815834,
-1.0818448067,
0.1755964309,
-0.7811224461,
-0.1846500486,
-0.2634794414,
-0.9914736748,
0.0589445084,
0.2148610204,
0.4098380804,
0.5709636211,
-0.059018001,
0.1913598925,
-1.0015573502,
0.144822672,
0.470539093,
0.3993304074,
-0.1567604542,
-0.3417129517,
-0.2534216046,
0.1209777221,
-0.4697715044,
-1.0472185612,
0.0896529555,
0.2196873277,
0.9589211345,
0.4608526528,
0.0671848059,
0.792699337,
-0.0943396315,
1.2269707918,
0.3210742474,
-1.0838030577,
0.7148274779,
-0.410337925,
0.5833943486,
0.7375819087,
0.1587358266,
-0.5545027256,
-1.1540403366,
-0.4994948208,
-0.744694531,
0.6272509694,
0.4570746422,
0.2965834439,
-0.1942468882,
-0.0159677621,
0.45740816,
0.4192583263,
-0.5227386355,
-0.0968467966,
-0.5362127423,
-0.0233998299,
0.0412180908,
-0.0774417296,
-0.2507520616,
-0.1877503991,
0.3561522067,
-0.0704597458,
0.4443795383,
0.3132519424,
-0.2464434654,
0.1954588145,
0.6003319621,
0.7870242,
0.6184862852,
-0.0930597782,
-0.0344249085,
0.2268351763,
-1.0283201933,
-0.1370592713,
-0.045701284,
0.0927638188,
0.1213059202,
0.353635639,
0.7131945491,
-0.4439399242,
-0.8458029628,
0.1696976274,
-0.0055770776,
0.0383058786,
0.3188071251,
0.107262969,
-0.0854393467,
0.5516734719,
0.2199213058,
0.223307237,
0.5861265659,
-0.8236567378,
-0.00646214,
0.7541816831,
-0.4757699966,
-0.0460607298,
0.3334591389,
0.6164099574,
-0.533757627,
0.4011066854,
-0.2150099874,
-0.7419797778,
0.4251256883,
0.4393406808,
1.3745640516,
-0.2630522847,
0.0664005801,
0.2441009432,
0.5290451646,
0.2045811266,
0.3418671191,
-0.7246742845,
-0.5693147779,
-0.3923850358,
-0.2071794719,
-0.4869494438,
-0.0375366919,
-0.6250323653,
-0.053843122,
-0.283507973,
-0.4433381557,
-0.4235874116,
0.0673886091,
-0.5382220149,
0.018934397,
-0.1740321517,
0.6914793849,
-0.3668505847,
0.6899268031,
1.0071505308,
0.0084396051,
-0.2403516769,
0.6063545942,
-0.0356232561,
-0.5331663489,
0.6086574197,
-0.0293468479,
-0.2405829877,
-0.4464909136,
0.0243515372,
-0.6368448734,
0.8961718678,
-0.0424778648,
-0.4143344462,
0.3064458072,
0.3820312321,
0.475330919,
-0.4392567575,
0.3516776264,
0.5376628041,
0.1983706355,
-0.2078793794,
-1.1565428972,
0.0893648937,
-0.5529684424,
0.2220021635,
0.3424072266,
-0.4352244139,
0.6745983958,
-0.2843864262,
-0.3518265486,
0.2482165098,
0.5317251086,
0.0314980075,
0.2837647498,
0.783633709,
0.1449764818,
0.3119744956,
-0.2878572047,
0.9205849767,
-0.2984185517,
0.0661837161,
1.2653756142,
-0.2106951475,
0.4722897708,
0.6375308633,
-0.2804496288,
0.4613967836,
0.4686422348,
0.2643636167,
0.5802134871,
-0.0178304482,
-0.3226655722,
-0.1416243762,
-0.2697202265,
-0.3620603085,
0.5019635558,
0.2779542804,
0.0798050761,
-0.2026972324,
0.0657351017,
-0.2911125124,
-0.0523562469,
-0.0750989839,
1.0341507196,
-0.1028933525,
-0.6035448909,
0.327546984,
-0.1928991675,
0.7591249347,
-0.4702091217,
0.0600629188,
-0.6270095706,
-0.1533628255,
-0.1325842887,
-0.6897239685,
0.3029168546,
0.1754657179,
0.0748680755,
-0.0214566607,
0.9204095006,
-0.4551204741,
-0.0137856454,
0.2180980593,
0.8759272695,
-0.0273852888,
-0.0763952956,
-0.8098013997,
0.0538728274,
0.1325001717,
0.1204756573,
0.2127283365,
0.2573556006,
-0.3108523786,
0.7143834233,
0.4745511115,
0.0623857714,
0.1790190488,
0.3539704382,
0.9663187861,
-0.4682984352,
-0.7858927846,
-0.5842657685,
0.6640256047,
-0.4121313095,
-0.1898447275,
0.8662020564,
0.518568337,
0.7871799469,
-0.2522862256,
0.874157846,
-0.3225742877,
0.6078383327,
-0.1067440286,
0.1537300795,
-0.4296637774,
0.3214419186,
-0.5968322754,
-1.1517254114,
0.1010135785,
0.6802558899,
-0.1035850644,
0.3789595068,
0.8989431262,
0.5953059196,
-0.1595527679,
0.2000205964,
0.3306092322,
-0.1586746722,
0.1672822684,
0.3151323497,
1.5218200684,
-0.1302156299,
0.3573172987,
-0.4509800375,
-0.3383885324,
-0.2191204429,
-0.6340112686,
-0.9309515953,
-0.6851498485,
-0.5316641331,
0.044782225,
0.1826818585,
0.732049644,
0.7259274125,
-0.768599093,
-0.3689974248,
-0.1660464853,
0.0540232845,
-0.6653361917,
-0.3135497868,
-0.2591793239,
-0.6061893106,
-1.034497261,
0.3985563815,
0.5958114266,
0.1538759619,
-0.0547479242,
-0.0365950353,
-0.0290401876,
0.4277311862,
0.8254327774,
0.1839669943,
-0.784828186,
-0.2751871645,
0.338419646,
0.1341923177,
0.0876077414,
1.3801451921,
-0.5727162957,
0.4772181213,
0.7784541249,
0.7935602069,
0.3979018927,
-0.086176075,
0.6795117855,
-0.6550965905,
0.283074826,
0.5483028293,
0.1726122648,
0.3943926096,
-0.2923041284,
0.5622510314,
0.246826604,
-0.2541661263,
-0.8425500989,
0.4517596662,
-1.4071987867,
-0.3452765048,
0.9834079742,
-0.0882070959,
0.5914315581,
-0.5763402581,
-0.2220943719,
0.0696788058,
-0.3380592763,
0.7970113158,
0.7648407817,
-0.4162738621,
-0.2815055549,
-0.3048381507,
0.674189806,
0.8370931745,
-1.2832691669,
0.116022557,
0.4182578623,
0.141663,
0.2733941376,
0.732745707,
-0.3421184719,
0.4740865529,
-0.0543576218,
-0.2363466769,
0.1052400097,
-0.2920431793,
-0.1314557642,
-0.0709649399,
0.2578265667,
-0.3642550707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14063v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14063v1
|
Do VSR Models Generalize Beyond LRS3?
| 2023-11-23T15:42:00 | 2023-11-23T15:42:00 |
Yasser Abdelaziz Dahou Djilali, Sanath Narayan, Eustache Le Bihan, Haithem Boussaid, Ebtessam Almazrouei, Merouane Debbah
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The Lip Reading Sentences-3 (LRS3) benchmark has primarily been the focus of
intense research in visual speech recognition (VSR) during the last few years.
As a result, there is an increased risk of overfitting to its excessively used
test set, which is only one hour duration. To alleviate this issue, we build a
new VSR test set named WildVSR, by closely following the LRS3 dataset creation
processes. We then evaluate and analyse the extent to which the current VSR
models generalize to the new test data. We evaluate a broad range of publicly
available VSR models and find significant drops in performance on our test set,
compared to their corresponding LRS3 results. Our results suggest that the
increase in word error rates is caused by the models inability to generalize to
slightly harder and in the wild lip sequences than those found in the LRS3 test
set. Our new test benchmark is made public in order to enable future research
towards more robust VSR models.
|
[
-0.269361645,
-0.3921801448,
0.2873996496,
-0.1873202473,
-0.2082521617,
-0.3029682338,
-0.08179003,
-0.8453124762,
-0.517280519,
0.8505435586,
-0.4905743003,
-0.3532316387,
-0.4865487218,
0.1105768532,
-0.6394488811,
0.9503362775,
-0.0768470317,
0.1426508874,
-0.0342586711,
-0.5395320654,
-0.4482183456,
-0.4967048466,
-0.0186248347,
-0.0573024265,
0.4581376016,
0.3627946973,
0.5942000151,
0.8369348049,
0.8555694818,
0.2631881833,
-0.24226062,
-0.135651499,
-0.4299620092,
-0.0305819623,
0.2454307228,
-0.6373268962,
-0.2156568468,
-0.2253725678,
0.9212254882,
0.4922319949,
-0.3721925914,
0.2099976391,
0.066128552,
0.7689942122,
-0.5199275017,
0.0915631801,
-0.6588487625,
0.3180526495,
-0.3331445456,
0.12220411,
-0.1923348457,
-0.3443540335,
0.6862737536,
-0.4139274955,
0.8207261562,
-0.161948517,
0.8171120286,
0.2217101753,
-0.1031564847,
-0.0941061974,
-1.0229350328,
0.6983799934,
-0.4761895239,
0.616394341,
0.1346668154,
0.7527838945,
0.1332893223,
-0.8418383002,
-0.6711221337,
-0.3512616754,
0.4065890312,
-0.0006935025,
-0.7264826894,
-0.0320335329,
0.5734078884,
0.2823189199,
-0.5493733883,
0.0713049397,
-0.787738204,
-0.0019096218,
0.2094570845,
0.1454210579,
0.081677258,
-0.0334079526,
-0.2429875731,
-0.3553696573,
-0.4662370086,
0.3894728124,
0.0393464267,
0.4660257399,
0.0425922014,
0.8697561026,
-0.1402412206,
0.9544651508,
-0.5674486756,
0.0841303021,
0.4779458046,
-0.2734163404,
-0.4777603447,
-0.2671049237,
0.494343698,
0.6788989305,
0.849198401,
0.0205240026,
-0.1721583307,
0.2061903179,
0.0201694313,
-0.6860176921,
-0.1685467064,
-0.1298428774,
-0.3205114305,
-0.0482028946,
-0.1125738248,
-0.2849352658,
-0.4868602157,
-0.3570967913,
0.2717877626,
-0.351691395,
-0.140549019,
0.3513478339,
-0.4005596042,
0.3885145187,
0.2096377462,
-0.5321733952,
0.8203405738,
0.5245349407,
0.8234461546,
-0.1297439933,
-0.4024485648,
-0.6486303806,
0.109834455,
-0.3734206259,
0.8382715583,
-0.4521575868,
-0.4054791927,
-0.0320939235,
-0.1928066164,
0.0782320499,
-0.7699922323,
0.4683245718,
-0.4094167948,
-0.0442939587,
-0.4692768753,
-0.451590091,
-0.0834879205,
0.0272695757,
-0.6151474714,
0.8094896674,
-0.2631876469,
-0.547560513,
0.7316592932,
-0.4593731761,
-0.0903747529,
0.0910494104,
-0.5326095223,
-0.5948826075,
0.141048938,
0.3209353685,
0.6823961139,
-0.4307685196,
-0.0540491641,
-0.3960564137,
-0.5836004615,
0.3030256629,
-0.2323758602,
0.1524700969,
-0.1479433626,
-0.2786097527,
-0.073804982,
-0.9577319622,
0.1796579957,
-0.1561533362,
-0.1324477345,
-0.3979970217,
0.2630956769,
0.0763982683,
-0.0285106786,
-0.3866511583,
-0.5350177288,
0.1314284503,
-0.214086175,
0.5192094445,
0.752695322,
-0.2580187917,
0.250902921,
-0.3426347077,
0.3384497464,
-0.0103466464,
0.260759443,
0.1556592584,
-0.5007261634,
-1.0191574097,
-0.2563391626,
0.1477943361,
0.6352660656,
-0.3561633229,
0.1388088912,
-0.5963414907,
-0.5460603237,
-0.3903289735,
0.0443465486,
0.512935698,
0.4642684162,
0.4943675995,
-0.1963203698,
-0.5633805394,
-1.1380982399,
-0.4230015874,
-0.0176491905,
-0.2999552786,
0.47806409,
0.5685887933,
-0.2809927762,
1.0227142572,
-0.5203282833,
-0.6279779077,
-0.4194297194,
-0.0642912611,
0.195502609,
0.2866431177,
0.5166019201,
-0.7744112611,
-0.2140534669,
-0.0932801887,
-0.4483219385,
0.2665042877,
0.3897825181,
0.3952955902,
0.0871496424,
0.5719537735,
-0.1803933084,
0.4202299714,
0.6201306581,
0.0978988037,
0.3935374916,
-0.0045354669,
-0.2787201405,
-0.654502511,
-0.084284164,
0.3173698187,
-0.0538854972,
-0.715885222,
-0.2329744548,
0.2064656615,
-0.2702114284,
-0.3656493425,
0.230931282,
-0.5755435228,
-0.4001109004,
0.1024808958,
0.0043087048,
-0.2617817223,
0.1982555985,
0.0168155357,
0.8178151846,
0.7147704959,
-0.8017292023,
0.0828417093,
0.1208188608,
-0.5421292186,
0.1402808726,
-1.1207755804,
0.0498910882,
-0.3318284452,
0.22619012,
-0.8330636621,
-0.119814977,
-0.0002580336,
-0.3970889747,
0.0525928847,
-0.1920904815,
-0.2926416099,
-0.6719335318,
-0.1580676585,
-0.0194693282,
0.7389182448,
-0.44513762,
0.6599963307,
0.1808389276,
-0.025685275,
-0.786229074,
-1.1923277378,
-0.1827912182,
-0.1305662096,
-0.5788514614,
0.1104687229,
-0.0528925397,
-0.1860659271,
-0.0569817759,
-0.2164980173,
-0.2111145109,
-0.5010583997,
0.2839283645,
0.0681543723,
-0.450412333,
0.0223549064,
-0.6471645832,
0.091052942,
-0.1003509834,
0.1135054007,
0.1384526491,
-0.5361011028,
-0.1977661401,
-0.4342620969,
0.0825245529,
0.5938386321,
-0.3993685246,
0.3413068652,
0.3911549449,
-0.2941366434,
-0.2768465877,
-0.8866202831,
0.2342250645,
-0.5014910698,
0.5459404588,
-0.6522907019,
-0.8464870453,
0.6422667503,
0.4901554883,
-0.1362543553,
0.2240855396,
-0.0275752768,
0.0628549084,
0.9368765354,
0.996150434,
0.0566878617,
0.5219438076,
-0.4117877185,
-0.115903765,
-0.8868642449,
-0.1705997586,
-0.525727272,
0.1378664076,
-0.7498110533,
-0.6750002503,
0.2435790747,
-0.0187424663,
-0.086695157,
0.2515584826,
-0.6487503648,
0.6780282855,
0.4940006137,
0.1185673997,
0.0509418547,
0.0493943729,
-0.0782504156,
-0.4070770144,
-0.5325689912,
-0.2919766605,
1.1193928719,
0.4695745409,
0.590714097,
0.266161412,
0.2363431901,
0.254424572,
0.305678755,
-0.6401484609,
0.6081879735,
-0.4691537023,
-0.3847450614,
-0.3756943047,
-0.2655439675,
-0.70782125,
0.2040932775,
0.0172030646,
-0.6464321613,
0.2701013684,
0.2302836627,
-0.3500339389,
0.3345213532,
-0.5252446532,
0.5924926996,
0.0790866166,
-0.2501572967,
0.2292348146,
-0.7421551347,
0.5604817867,
0.066822134,
0.1452887505,
-0.1993134916,
-0.0633076355,
0.790979743,
-0.2696288526,
0.7589444518,
-0.3307627738,
0.129946664,
0.1764913648,
-0.2353840172,
0.6517521143,
-0.2780596912,
-0.1061222851,
-0.0100020925,
-0.2115679979,
-0.277644068,
-0.5722649097,
0.4219042957,
-0.9102224112,
-0.3488892317,
-0.7272549272,
-0.2196346521,
-0.2302367985,
0.1298067719,
0.0883042887,
0.8061000109,
-0.4078427851,
0.3207032979,
0.8250026107,
-0.1593308598,
0.1791861355,
0.9821512699,
-0.0121052619,
-0.5427438021,
0.7605217099,
0.3299424946,
0.385540396,
0.3165684938,
0.2973904014,
-0.3629730344,
-0.9408299923,
-0.260409236,
-0.0229118355,
-0.7999826074,
0.1077062786,
-0.8091840744,
-0.1585647464,
-0.4257411659,
0.1133080572,
-0.2094839811,
-0.0631640777,
-0.3233467937,
-0.0214046035,
0.6172550321,
0.9457556009,
-0.2684116066,
0.2275034934,
-0.8209068179,
0.6044276953,
0.4950533509,
0.4877830148,
-0.2336456478,
-0.5572152734,
0.1595736444,
-0.2263431102,
0.0926983207,
-0.4478190839,
0.1614212692,
0.3640165627,
0.5616318583,
0.1652712524,
-0.2495718598,
1.0657806396,
-0.9745744467,
0.7731829882,
0.3435254097,
-0.8510031104,
0.3803862035,
-0.5295221806,
0.3488456011,
0.4706207812,
0.2066263556,
-0.5562972426,
-0.2714282274,
-0.3388953507,
-0.6693974137,
0.4082650244,
0.1213798895,
0.1540044248,
0.2636419535,
0.3688195348,
0.074357219,
-0.0183542743,
-0.7786543965,
-0.1544207036,
-0.2306693941,
0.2533982992,
-0.5701875091,
-0.3610105217,
0.115167886,
-0.4413816631,
0.2372832447,
-0.1144328192,
-0.0018715637,
0.4123439491,
0.0075592478,
-0.0708459094,
0.3761982024,
0.7734361887,
0.6318464279,
-0.5351493955,
-0.1385822445,
0.3422267437,
-0.7409651875,
-0.0507554524,
0.4506756961,
0.0198793802,
-0.0804354101,
0.4201070666,
0.999612093,
0.1506008953,
-0.7255715728,
0.7564662695,
-0.4985067248,
-0.2588842213,
-0.5843279362,
0.2697061598,
-0.1951538026,
0.2231914103,
0.5003356934,
0.5058381557,
0.3075920641,
-0.5555192232,
0.4000881314,
0.2205834091,
-0.704195857,
-0.0302542001,
0.7109048963,
0.207515195,
-0.1700805277,
0.5633413196,
0.2327248007,
-0.5618891716,
0.5903802514,
0.2432724237,
0.7490286827,
0.0038606143,
-0.0163876507,
0.2603274286,
0.5552255511,
-0.3633195758,
0.4844715297,
-0.1113781333,
-0.6897805333,
-0.4934208095,
-0.3798484504,
-0.547293663,
0.4495556653,
-1.0964258909,
0.3449850678,
-0.1737885624,
0.0061953249,
0.2577861845,
-0.2560108304,
-0.7444343567,
0.490542233,
0.1927765012,
0.8738850951,
-0.7219582796,
0.6049220562,
0.3061512709,
-0.2934117615,
-0.4867019951,
0.1206912771,
-0.0030623814,
-0.8036800623,
0.7932949066,
0.4925219715,
-0.2582172453,
-0.046665404,
-0.5071885586,
-0.9770473242,
1.0043532848,
-0.1032367051,
-1.1006253958,
-0.0923672989,
0.2260072529,
0.7915754914,
-0.100027211,
0.039786756,
0.6882115602,
0.0951563492,
0.0875213966,
-0.9646606445,
-0.1503161788,
-0.3624301851,
0.3550168872,
0.1079870909,
-0.4289790392,
0.9324446321,
-0.5953333378,
-0.2127425969,
0.3119217455,
0.7158874273,
0.4097919762,
-0.0073810983,
0.5092363358,
0.364284873,
0.652902782,
-0.0231320709,
1.3628525734,
0.3010934591,
-0.1406603456,
1.349216342,
-0.5824109912,
1.1658568382,
0.2966519296,
-0.1552233845,
0.1454364508,
0.2922491431,
-0.4932006001,
0.7471726537,
0.7865231633,
-0.0206960011,
-0.168541193,
-0.0612382852,
-0.6768785119,
0.2614662349,
0.2021910697,
-0.3034034073,
0.0726489127,
0.1721373796,
-0.3510346711,
0.1156485975,
-0.2143586725,
0.5260156989,
-0.0666280314,
-0.4182856679,
0.7256723642,
-0.3963864446,
0.7107056975,
-0.7261735201,
-0.0009829873,
0.1141073853,
0.656920135,
0.2405031025,
-0.8528333306,
-0.0021898418,
0.1829233617,
-0.2936427593,
-0.1354349554,
0.5727712512,
-0.1457667351,
-0.6367842555,
0.4259005189,
0.4479737878,
0.2274037749,
0.1703141481,
-0.5655654073,
0.3970457315,
0.0233360305,
-0.1080254316,
-0.1492135227,
0.3747292161,
0.1378198266,
0.8430848718,
0.6207575798,
0.239487797,
0.305980444,
0.561042726,
0.8921452165,
-0.77147156,
-0.3081743121,
-0.6470140815,
0.4011670351,
-0.0966775641,
-0.6956927776,
0.7291813493,
0.6722311378,
0.8861202598,
-0.0398806445,
1.0325909853,
0.2333230078,
0.8665299416,
-0.522518456,
0.4262263775,
-0.6256571412,
0.1720490903,
-0.5774235129,
-0.6798263192,
-0.6373253465,
0.3183103502,
-0.2312412709,
-0.0379273295,
0.5316030383,
0.6917900443,
-0.1618886441,
0.0584963933,
0.387385428,
0.3670932949,
0.4408895373,
0.2982741892,
1.006393671,
-0.6561069489,
0.8940422535,
-0.2563848495,
-0.12947689,
-0.0450636819,
-0.7255240083,
-1.108225584,
-0.5646044016,
-0.2203278542,
-0.2481451929,
0.5286482573,
0.2560091019,
0.5047818422,
-0.5752493739,
-0.1684214175,
-0.5064958334,
-0.4556610584,
-0.2110803574,
-0.1790405959,
0.2008289248,
0.2032198608,
-0.3296505809,
0.3268191218,
-0.0670232475,
0.6285604835,
-0.1283043921,
0.0847040415,
0.1891458631,
-0.140772149,
0.4071591198,
0.4014727473,
-0.8833543062,
-0.3082260191,
0.2552693784,
0.0472586155,
0.0776697919,
0.6633342505,
-0.6472964883,
0.4271515012,
0.3639572561,
0.1488113403,
0.8277802467,
-0.2133690715,
0.8133823872,
-0.354867965,
-0.0586165823,
0.363355279,
0.1877687722,
0.5743406415,
0.1175728068,
0.5542150736,
0.003748059,
-0.5089045763,
-1.2491538525,
0.2702300847,
-0.8894483447,
0.0171135981,
1.1269876957,
0.2431437671,
-0.2766776979,
-0.0638440177,
-0.0439157002,
0.1779199988,
-0.3282147646,
0.3427765369,
0.5311256647,
-0.2903749347,
-0.1684154272,
-0.8977767229,
0.801923573,
0.2415442765,
-0.411324203,
0.3938907385,
0.4824008942,
0.7259939909,
0.1143871844,
0.6412730217,
0.0242450759,
0.4590223432,
0.0413946249,
0.2033381462,
0.0431005247,
-0.3948097825,
-0.5117675066,
-0.0088571683,
-0.091051735,
-0.2621238232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13987v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13987v1
|
Jam-ALT: A Formatting-Aware Lyrics Transcription Benchmark
| 2023-11-23T13:13:48 | 2023-11-23T13:13:48 |
Ondřej Cífka, Constantinos Dimitriou, Cheng-i Wang, Hendrik Schreiber, Luke Miner, Fabian-Robert Stöter
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
Current automatic lyrics transcription (ALT) benchmarks focus exclusively on
word content and ignore the finer nuances of written lyrics including
formatting and punctuation, which leads to a potential misalignment with the
creative products of musicians and songwriters as well as listeners'
experiences. For example, line breaks are important in conveying information
about rhythm, emotional emphasis, rhyme, and high-level structure. To address
this issue, we introduce Jam-ALT, a new lyrics transcription benchmark based on
the JamendoLyrics dataset. Our contribution is twofold. Firstly, a complete
revision of the transcripts, geared specifically towards ALT evaluation by
following a newly created annotation guide that unifies the music industry's
guidelines, covering aspects such as punctuation, line breaks, spelling,
background vocals, and non-word sounds. Secondly, a suite of evaluation metrics
designed, unlike the traditional word error rate, to capture such phenomena. We
hope that the proposed benchmark contributes to the ALT task, enabling more
precise and reliable assessments of transcription systems and enhancing the
user experience in lyrics applications such as subtitle renderings for live
captioning or karaoke.
|
[
-0.2769804001,
-0.4455519915,
0.312361002,
0.6121913791,
-0.35726735,
0.3021225333,
-0.2121566832,
-0.5881624222,
0.3773874044,
0.539337635,
-0.6795454621,
-0.5890772343,
-0.3079906106,
0.4116173685,
-0.3507110476,
0.9851537347,
-0.1622935683,
-0.1913993508,
-0.394061476,
-0.1728737354,
-0.7924866676,
0.0963080227,
-0.2226502895,
0.5062661767,
0.6764230728,
0.2386484891,
0.692982316,
0.7954517007,
0.589332521,
0.2112718076,
-0.1266546845,
-0.0573607087,
-0.3054915369,
0.5745769143,
0.2329097688,
-0.2768740952,
-0.4635304809,
0.4169691503,
0.8834848404,
0.7470279336,
0.1442344487,
0.4147218764,
-0.0065219663,
0.6730325222,
-0.6807475686,
0.1236546263,
-0.7341834903,
0.1500232965,
-0.5926136374,
0.0754381046,
-0.2167408913,
-0.7106269002,
-0.3643998802,
-0.7690576911,
0.0002970043,
0.3881099522,
0.6857649684,
0.4846481383,
0.0090457452,
-0.2527950704,
-0.4615396261,
0.4789790809,
-0.4540407062,
0.6983062029,
0.1048624665,
0.5741279125,
-0.0789880678,
-0.7576984763,
-0.2954415977,
-0.0146034369,
0.0185568128,
0.3142485917,
-0.1173700541,
0.0039088745,
0.4719367921,
0.5441060662,
-0.3443754017,
-0.2768030763,
-0.4523504078,
-0.4124132693,
0.5252590179,
0.0856461748,
0.5534909368,
-0.0267249085,
-0.4326830506,
-0.1519456357,
-0.7606274486,
0.2664386332,
0.5920990109,
0.4126027524,
0.0654886067,
0.4413545132,
-0.0591322593,
0.7686281204,
-0.2529376745,
-0.1547688097,
0.4723277092,
-0.204588607,
-0.1881582439,
0.3233918846,
0.9763500094,
0.3734863698,
-0.2037242949,
-0.543228507,
-0.395981133,
0.119833082,
0.1668152958,
-0.4746651947,
-0.3714376688,
0.0149793699,
-0.1026380658,
0.1186368316,
0.2219730318,
-0.5534004569,
-0.525370717,
-0.4809603989,
0.5885525942,
-0.5116627216,
0.4538175464,
-0.2479376197,
-0.4083696604,
-0.2949681878,
0.3121494353,
-0.1362250745,
0.2701465786,
0.7663698196,
0.9603455663,
-0.1214340925,
-0.097842738,
-0.6592108607,
0.0139270918,
-0.3757948279,
0.8108198047,
-0.3460251093,
-0.2842115462,
-0.3914892077,
0.0153318504,
-0.1435555369,
-0.5176706314,
0.8251315355,
-0.3439398408,
-0.0390575677,
-0.5617623925,
-0.749131918,
0.03487074,
-0.08166603,
-1.1566746235,
0.515443325,
0.2829237878,
-0.4783807695,
0.4987676442,
-0.5875575542,
-0.4740509987,
0.2386096865,
-0.0992245749,
-0.6082038283,
0.2850704789,
0.0666871294,
-0.1264424175,
-0.2104291469,
-0.0734715089,
-0.2613286972,
-0.7575778365,
0.6613022685,
-0.4158268869,
0.6625321507,
0.419839561,
-0.1458055675,
-0.0827951506,
-0.5881286263,
0.4805720747,
-0.2418331802,
-0.2587995827,
-0.1738061607,
-0.2096614987,
0.3553149104,
0.0791459605,
0.1795801669,
-0.7806962729,
0.195182249,
-0.1674184054,
0.071140185,
0.552005589,
0.0428291932,
-0.0621050745,
-0.4819712639,
0.7872875333,
-0.4187210202,
0.2061427832,
-0.3685795069,
-0.3400354981,
0.0666601881,
-0.6857527494,
0.813857615,
0.3046109974,
-0.2130303532,
0.477874577,
-0.2050849795,
-0.471314013,
-1.0631370544,
0.2691802382,
0.6080158949,
0.3902649283,
0.5201251507,
-0.3620658815,
-0.8517169952,
-0.6530953646,
-1.0763257742,
0.2626354694,
-0.0114316037,
0.3642503023,
-0.1184333712,
0.1474258006,
0.9586687684,
-0.3733605146,
-0.4502381384,
-0.1067386717,
0.3753997386,
0.2644559443,
0.3837690055,
0.3293366134,
-0.8345271945,
-0.8758696318,
-0.287509501,
-0.0409023799,
-0.8854819536,
-0.1880042851,
-0.0547840148,
-0.1451561153,
0.5089628696,
-0.2526895702,
0.379237622,
0.8190785646,
-0.5929893255,
0.6361292601,
0.4897934198,
0.3896390498,
-0.5880200267,
0.3376607895,
-0.6319742203,
-0.2359487563,
-0.2711125016,
-0.3747427166,
0.2762887776,
-0.0563066974,
-0.3733323514,
0.170048818,
-0.5114551187,
-0.6042012572,
-0.055976592,
0.2729060948,
0.3707902431,
0.0818057284,
-0.5997753143,
1.1292886734,
0.2593230307,
0.0110411681,
0.2946124673,
0.141667068,
-0.6917335391,
0.643946588,
-0.7545377612,
0.0902944729,
0.0797562525,
0.202705875,
-1.1147037745,
-0.0404016003,
0.1520527154,
-0.5721949339,
0.3979421258,
-0.0809884891,
-0.5889706612,
-0.2034347802,
-0.222505942,
0.6598534584,
0.7474330068,
-0.0568254888,
0.1614306569,
0.3275352716,
-0.1910578012,
-0.3768859506,
-0.2672072053,
0.2496653944,
-0.0285562184,
-0.2926199734,
0.3860446811,
-0.1757113189,
-0.1857008189,
0.030194588,
-0.4572798312,
0.0908294022,
0.2762079835,
0.5393654704,
0.1145191416,
-0.0960654169,
0.0873366222,
0.1834397018,
-0.0340712108,
0.0994886532,
-0.1528003663,
0.3569088578,
0.0019222939,
-0.2770177424,
-0.6036388874,
0.1587094665,
0.5974416733,
-0.3923936784,
0.2405059487,
0.4421834946,
-0.0443615541,
0.0675686896,
-0.4761903882,
0.2276383638,
-0.4062589705,
-0.0658941343,
-0.2363552153,
-0.5441942811,
0.5888859034,
-0.1439531595,
0.0227330867,
0.434304595,
-0.1084055454,
-0.4354151487,
0.8913700581,
0.1243752614,
0.1754627377,
0.4379329979,
0.0985625684,
-0.0514094792,
-1.2883348465,
-0.0685179383,
-0.6834272146,
-0.7388967872,
-0.5102377534,
-0.4050013423,
0.6043191552,
0.3374409676,
0.0121720806,
0.5226709247,
-0.418449074,
0.6194940805,
0.366684109,
-0.1624642909,
0.2349433601,
-0.4045589864,
-0.1387378871,
-0.1425776035,
-0.1487601399,
-0.2186708599,
0.8579460979,
0.1573322266,
0.7495117784,
0.015391089,
0.6270594597,
0.4771475196,
0.4954357743,
-0.5136960149,
0.0849431977,
-0.1258415133,
-0.7334083915,
-0.378916055,
-0.4365765452,
-0.5441786647,
-0.0808795318,
-0.1951544434,
-0.820599556,
-0.0878543258,
0.2812029719,
-0.3183622658,
0.1703500897,
-0.3880819082,
1.0786333084,
-0.213729471,
-0.1692016125,
0.6865670681,
-0.6904573441,
0.0893787369,
0.0150930742,
0.456782043,
-0.5782138109,
-0.3286084533,
0.9468619227,
-0.3320013285,
0.5396408439,
-0.2066517621,
0.163061887,
0.4890874028,
0.2660849988,
0.439677,
-0.1896780133,
0.2506172955,
0.0951569006,
0.0160887707,
-0.0371138901,
-0.5529411435,
0.4889374971,
-0.6638650894,
-0.0610701926,
-0.0798334256,
-0.8082449436,
-0.3500645459,
0.3406939805,
0.3593778312,
0.369630456,
-0.0747614279,
0.5331857204,
0.5150582194,
0.1250647157,
0.1792056412,
0.1196797788,
-0.2818540037,
-0.8824238181,
0.5428772569,
0.2217389196,
0.2326506525,
0.3955651522,
0.1997329444,
-0.4233020544,
-0.4140858054,
-0.5352676511,
0.1468220502,
-0.5716570616,
-0.5186158419,
-0.7850729823,
0.0973292068,
-0.6739959717,
-0.3256918788,
-0.5892189145,
-0.567915976,
0.0330010243,
0.1887601763,
0.4135275483,
0.526337266,
0.0778227374,
0.2051620781,
-0.9687776566,
0.4157882333,
0.0784415007,
0.7699552774,
-0.4878733158,
-0.4906603992,
-0.3603654206,
-0.1351527423,
-0.3408216536,
-1.094088316,
-0.001189644,
0.1083383337,
0.2873480022,
0.2273304015,
0.2010346055,
0.8405084014,
-0.5293699503,
0.6440149546,
0.2338904738,
-1.3205623627,
0.3787968159,
-0.3213989437,
0.4529309869,
1.0029838085,
0.1092278883,
-1.0338965654,
-0.6456999183,
-0.3548479378,
-0.8818452358,
0.5512353182,
0.4675336182,
-0.2982389629,
0.2199921459,
0.1927153468,
0.4920225441,
0.5651097894,
-0.5961351395,
-0.1806264967,
-0.2735969126,
-0.4083687961,
-0.1285309047,
-0.0228814371,
-0.1995606869,
-0.012219266,
0.5060908794,
-0.0525760688,
0.1090518832,
0.2013652623,
-0.102281943,
-0.3627557456,
0.4222892821,
0.2343019396,
0.5910416245,
-0.366540879,
-0.0715828836,
-0.2041958719,
-0.6240304708,
-0.1305604428,
0.1978465915,
-0.4900588393,
0.1857862324,
0.4016468823,
0.7988096476,
0.2358194739,
-0.8511905074,
0.5476320386,
0.0193716921,
0.1281481832,
-0.2065585852,
0.1661030352,
-0.1013273075,
-0.232909441,
0.1362174004,
0.1204577163,
0.5555496812,
-0.4945402741,
0.3613570333,
0.317396611,
-0.8606666923,
-0.3231441379,
0.7628463507,
-0.0057755844,
-0.2732423246,
0.2103379667,
-0.1698809266,
-0.5119389892,
0.5892640352,
0.5514396429,
1.210083127,
-0.2398260534,
-0.2104327083,
0.2318258435,
0.3352655768,
0.3466175199,
0.5528624654,
-0.2962029576,
0.0049754791,
-0.3775571585,
-0.68201226,
-0.3777501881,
-0.2099259347,
-0.887773037,
0.3780015707,
-0.471619308,
-0.0354618765,
0.0972839445,
-0.1761745512,
-0.6972945333,
0.32364133,
0.1595804989,
1.0083942413,
-1.0406644344,
0.1193599254,
0.7264066935,
-0.265663892,
-0.7605472803,
0.0291965436,
0.0307313632,
-0.4113699198,
0.3479442298,
0.532507956,
0.0188620612,
-0.2464604378,
-0.595923245,
-0.9873731732,
1.115822196,
-0.0841239244,
-0.758140862,
0.2397625446,
0.1280291378,
0.4879588783,
-0.4615919888,
0.0999575928,
0.5780044198,
0.7095241547,
0.1195646077,
-0.9438794851,
0.1072328538,
-0.1327508837,
-0.0086006541,
0.4614490867,
-0.4868175387,
1.0639294386,
0.0901103318,
-0.4260894358,
0.3384008408,
0.3085571527,
-0.0480894111,
0.6158488989,
0.6057994962,
0.6606919765,
0.4935245812,
-0.5600465536,
0.8338503838,
-0.3697001636,
0.1714805514,
1.3979986906,
-0.2085609883,
0.5163531303,
0.5175452232,
-0.3488484323,
0.4620115161,
0.1005675867,
-0.0402572788,
0.5144808888,
0.3398400247,
0.0837317109,
-0.0795732215,
-0.3426240981,
-0.3677358031,
0.5836619139,
0.2032456994,
-0.546559751,
0.1444739252,
-0.245075047,
0.2227128893,
0.2542647123,
-0.1740706712,
0.9328516126,
-0.2318520546,
-0.603736043,
0.0585514158,
-0.3817850351,
0.0947898701,
-0.5108545423,
-0.0831011385,
0.0551542453,
-0.1587535888,
-0.1186070144,
-0.7628259063,
0.2343511432,
-0.0014060366,
-0.0000955035,
-0.1816067994,
0.3738738596,
-0.4658044577,
-0.5016112328,
-0.1582447588,
0.1619819999,
0.0218914729,
-0.1658791602,
-0.5562427044,
0.6609241962,
-0.2336755246,
0.0679705665,
-0.1770671606,
0.6742688417,
0.2047190964,
0.0874370486,
0.6468535662,
0.3126240075,
0.1165534034,
0.0324357226,
0.8237924576,
-0.9644317627,
-0.8875629902,
-0.4634350836,
0.6029959321,
-0.2942144573,
-0.3289543092,
0.8161963224,
0.8856971264,
0.7741528749,
0.1036944017,
0.9409109354,
-0.1488510519,
0.9679593444,
-0.5463120937,
0.694145143,
-0.5424710512,
0.194794476,
-0.7901269794,
-0.9919264317,
-0.3727124929,
-0.0523407012,
-0.1051289439,
0.0689416528,
0.5922327638,
0.2375418246,
0.1138275489,
0.2147980034,
0.2661024928,
0.2142042667,
0.1647313088,
0.3932726681,
0.7988905907,
-0.7716732025,
0.5502049923,
-0.4737481773,
-0.1537283212,
-0.3409847617,
-1.0033949614,
-0.5490136147,
-0.4289933443,
-0.4455266595,
-0.1330610514,
0.1112985536,
1.0115282536,
0.1864589751,
-0.7606534958,
0.0166947749,
0.1562636644,
0.32226789,
-0.5976880789,
-0.2321971059,
0.4224305153,
-0.398380667,
-0.4309135377,
0.2409897596,
0.4541641772,
0.2779641449,
0.0717134252,
0.1291066706,
0.2588504553,
0.0479651988,
0.0774048194,
0.3511928022,
-0.6345899701,
-0.1401560009,
0.1895336062,
0.0306335352,
0.0678686276,
0.9635058641,
-0.6527981162,
0.8008201718,
0.4390902221,
0.4513051212,
-0.2568081617,
0.2400613874,
0.2632429302,
-0.8051195741,
-0.2738474309,
0.4655559361,
0.312015444,
0.4742753506,
-0.1929865628,
0.267149806,
0.3271231353,
-0.4903714359,
-0.9447880983,
-0.0047567748,
-0.9780113101,
-0.0078323809,
0.8825362325,
-0.3469819427,
-0.5071837902,
-0.0301619135,
-0.2759473026,
0.3672375679,
-0.3772233427,
0.8039541245,
0.3839891553,
-0.0882918313,
0.1781465262,
-0.345192939,
0.9017478228,
0.1997870058,
-0.5441555977,
0.3450278938,
0.8689538836,
0.0919889286,
0.2696149349,
0.4194342792,
-0.4530768096,
0.8015694022,
0.1740888208,
0.2383968681,
-0.360842675,
-0.7194063067,
-0.0819282979,
0.0076986374,
0.0195785332,
-0.3191844821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13982v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13982v1
|
Probabilistic Tree-of-thought Reasoning for Answering Knowledge-intensive Complex Questions
| 2023-11-23T12:52:37 | 2023-11-23T12:52:37 |
Shulin Cao, Jiajie Zhang, Jiaxin Shi, Xin Lv, Zijun Yao, Qi Tian, Juanzi Li, Lei Hou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) are capable of answering knowledge-intensive
complex questions with chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning. However, they tend to
generate factually incorrect reasoning steps when the required knowledge is not
available or up-to-date in models' parameters. Recent works turn to retrieving
external knowledge to augment CoT reasoning. Despite being promising, these
chain-based methods suffer from: 1) Negative retrieval. Unnecessary or
incorrect retrieval may mislead the reasoning; 2) Limited sight. Lacking the
ability to look backward or forward, a local error in one step will propagate
along the chain.
In this paper, we propose a novel approach: Probabilistic Tree-of-thought
Reasoning (ProbTree). First, LLMs translate a complex question into a query
tree, in which each non-root node denotes a sub-question of its parent node.
Then, probabilistic reasoning is conducted over the tree, by solving questions
from leaf to root considering the confidence of both question decomposing and
answering. During reasoning, for leaf nodes, LLMs choose a more confident
answer from Closed-book QA that employs parametric knowledge and Open-book QA
that employs retrieved external knowledge, thus eliminating the negative
retrieval problem. For non-leaf nodes, with the hierarchical structure, LLMs
have broader sights and are able to globally reason with the information from
child nodes, thus recovering from local errors. The experiments on three
Complex QA datasets under the open-domain setting show that our approach
outperforms SOTA methods significantly, demonstrating the effect of
probabilistic tree-of-thought reasoning.
|
[
-0.3189390004,
-1.2811018229,
0.9308822155,
-0.0405033231,
-0.219137907,
0.2992447615,
-0.1765354276,
-0.5651758909,
0.0061238171,
0.3867105842,
-0.6360892057,
-0.5249269009,
-0.1689575315,
-0.1700891405,
-0.1825000346,
0.7341601849,
-0.2216170877,
-0.0986388698,
-0.1624290645,
0.0047890572,
-0.3432632089,
-0.5281076431,
-0.6461656094,
-0.2043854594,
0.4233862758,
0.5733849406,
0.8179923296,
0.0654081479,
0.387794435,
0.105018273,
-0.1646788567,
0.512630105,
-0.4268244803,
0.1496523321,
-0.5370711684,
-0.7268934846,
-0.391608268,
-0.4282230735,
0.5255638957,
0.6481246352,
0.0161891319,
0.2175015211,
0.0157071501,
0.5649790764,
-0.7501237988,
0.2511181235,
-0.8186998367,
-0.0069349715,
-0.1569523066,
-0.4556109905,
-0.4955532253,
-0.5630454421,
-0.010915163,
-0.4196269214,
-0.0581031591,
0.1232932732,
0.5689448714,
-0.1045511737,
-0.4746840894,
-0.1609887481,
-1.0542166233,
0.6152855158,
-0.6580460072,
0.2674415708,
0.563177228,
0.4405885041,
-0.4849684238,
-0.2712216973,
-0.7312488556,
-0.2219593674,
0.1466895193,
0.3233627975,
-0.072005786,
0.0389803387,
0.1270805895,
0.248971954,
-0.3945685923,
-0.178651467,
0.1990516037,
0.0744827986,
0.5919602513,
-0.0227000955,
0.111256808,
-0.0038335137,
-0.1964942068,
-0.0517451614,
-0.9851944447,
0.2371927202,
0.3085165024,
0.1544175744,
0.3927974403,
0.6181615591,
-0.3824843168,
0.7155281901,
0.0259451605,
-0.0795734078,
-0.1198628768,
-0.4118038714,
-0.1599693447,
0.0199228376,
0.412102282,
0.1363590509,
0.4969579577,
-0.096518822,
-0.2108395845,
-0.1038499326,
-0.0323837735,
-0.4748602211,
-0.2660571933,
0.4656537771,
-0.1999730617,
-0.1942168772,
-0.1534518749,
-0.5788595676,
-0.2050974071,
-0.1075176075,
0.7032592297,
-0.6488447189,
-0.5214797854,
0.0211785696,
0.3095405698,
-0.0196190625,
0.469889462,
-0.3207582831,
0.3510093093,
0.5680196881,
0.4993896484,
0.2033728659,
-0.0003412698,
-0.5910069942,
0.2804658115,
-0.6112274528,
0.8328139186,
-0.7565466762,
0.1576058269,
-0.1481485516,
-0.1220956668,
0.0776211619,
-0.5489118099,
0.5731726289,
-0.912799418,
-0.001086452,
-0.4180595279,
-0.4024977088,
-0.4800290763,
0.6739982963,
-0.3041206896,
0.8336715698,
0.0381747261,
-1.147467494,
0.02946149,
-0.3244796693,
-0.330065161,
0.0782685131,
-0.3274032176,
-0.3743970096,
-0.0141507452,
0.3275359273,
0.3710701466,
-0.4421517551,
0.675604105,
-0.4173267186,
-0.2013448477,
0.2875389159,
-0.5151128173,
0.7901647091,
0.1472377181,
-0.4147889316,
0.1081079766,
-0.6323948503,
0.285479933,
0.1859123558,
-0.0707516894,
-0.4630470574,
0.3525239229,
-0.4062955976,
0.2409517467,
0.0229845215,
-0.6480390429,
0.3581757247,
-0.3502352536,
0.290628314,
0.6444349289,
0.3486589491,
0.0852441043,
-0.3483987451,
0.50372082,
0.4185034633,
0.2653253675,
0.0493130386,
-0.6382543445,
-0.4829862416,
0.015757408,
0.2370928824,
0.6024522781,
-1.0282388926,
0.3246694505,
-0.0243427809,
-0.513995707,
-0.2729435861,
-0.3064704537,
0.4576646686,
0.5691164732,
0.5710750818,
-0.1705719382,
-0.3616723716,
-0.6243022084,
-0.2379266173,
-0.3855834305,
0.1508277953,
0.3203620613,
0.5612163544,
-0.1274578571,
1.0913943052,
-0.768641293,
-0.219613418,
-0.323215872,
0.0271657165,
0.3990847766,
0.5859484076,
-0.101258561,
-0.7712203264,
-0.1986270696,
-0.0061143921,
-0.5046879053,
0.1270076036,
-0.3790328801,
-0.3731623292,
-0.0261803847,
0.207279861,
-0.964930594,
0.3619424999,
0.2661967874,
-0.2667390704,
0.9490998387,
-0.3095096946,
-0.012498714,
-1.0165854692,
0.0248496272,
-0.1721699834,
-0.3243769109,
-0.3083666265,
0.2470291555,
-0.0422197469,
0.2954447567,
-0.1804768145,
0.3654764593,
-0.5179404616,
-0.2947036028,
0.1140068099,
0.1613975316,
-0.0401087962,
0.6407216191,
0.1244716048,
0.5313003659,
0.5028028488,
-0.6493184566,
0.3331503272,
0.1285027564,
-0.4847501814,
0.4590603411,
-0.1839953959,
-0.0488886461,
-0.3277141452,
0.533323884,
-0.9051149487,
0.047656782,
0.2936866283,
-0.3921296895,
0.1480099857,
-0.030067781,
-0.7834575176,
-0.4798989892,
-0.1905533224,
0.5522662997,
0.2379232049,
-0.6112843752,
0.5802001357,
0.2130545378,
-0.031615112,
-0.6721348166,
-0.2595153451,
-0.1563074291,
0.0527547076,
-0.4672962129,
0.359070003,
0.0365916379,
-0.354465872,
0.3077471852,
-0.5177419782,
-0.1336557269,
0.1324183196,
-0.0148569914,
0.0340031534,
-0.2324237525,
0.3861450851,
0.1079627723,
-0.0074900184,
0.0681128651,
-0.6982209682,
0.5242165327,
-0.2842839658,
-0.646089077,
-0.2770562768,
0.3138887584,
0.3670711517,
-0.4215077758,
0.6472164392,
0.3110444844,
-0.6298111677,
-0.3247240484,
-0.4710220098,
-0.3403674066,
-0.3225064576,
0.414301157,
-0.7356975079,
-0.6072099209,
0.4953648448,
-0.3330396712,
-0.0337627679,
0.3242198527,
0.503745079,
-0.5195088387,
1.1891717911,
0.3037405014,
0.2841271162,
0.2021962255,
-0.5616910458,
0.4984458685,
-0.8262258172,
-0.452196449,
-0.251527369,
-0.2719162405,
-0.442617625,
-0.6555384994,
0.4788426459,
0.7241067886,
-0.4065650105,
0.1677921563,
-0.3299056292,
0.4393711388,
0.810095191,
0.3186406195,
0.6722968817,
-0.1972334236,
-0.3894405961,
0.3966112733,
-0.8521713018,
-0.4725821316,
0.8248862028,
0.2891766131,
0.6912649274,
0.1975880712,
0.5103499293,
-0.1228104904,
0.4160513282,
-0.673704505,
0.7124797106,
0.2154714167,
-0.7035468817,
-0.4637618661,
-0.5044981241,
-0.9112952352,
0.2903945148,
-0.2309926748,
-0.850091815,
0.190142855,
0.2426319718,
-0.4018133283,
0.7412595153,
-0.4085042477,
0.752564311,
-0.3737742901,
-0.3728434145,
-0.3892766833,
-0.7557577491,
0.532241106,
-0.20789361,
0.2951608002,
0.0984677896,
0.297403127,
0.618563354,
-0.4478510916,
0.7462991476,
-0.2066918164,
-0.1220344305,
0.8279126883,
0.5774459839,
0.9464771152,
0.1709341258,
0.1615891755,
-0.1852894276,
0.2723885179,
-0.3523680866,
-0.6797499657,
0.385291785,
-0.698066771,
-0.8620381355,
-0.4599532783,
-0.5378749371,
-0.7393604517,
0.1377842724,
0.0254427213,
0.5365316272,
0.1686496288,
0.0740040764,
0.6283692718,
-0.3120653033,
0.0811799616,
0.4431207478,
-0.4081777334,
-0.2452091724,
0.8133308291,
0.4449495673,
0.4059030116,
0.8060834408,
0.4543558359,
-0.4276812077,
-0.6783176064,
-0.331930846,
0.236179471,
-0.7096837759,
-0.4454050362,
-0.7881426811,
-0.3107257783,
0.0431639403,
0.2074443102,
-0.1417546123,
-0.5743948221,
0.1242825389,
-0.2548623085,
0.308188349,
0.34188205,
0.088232182,
0.0531995557,
-0.8448029757,
0.3814429343,
0.3956484795,
0.3399744928,
0.3451240063,
-0.280905664,
-0.0054941466,
0.1911644638,
-0.5149566531,
-1.0678174496,
0.2629786134,
-0.0410158001,
0.4363125861,
0.2745637298,
0.4965506494,
0.8014090657,
-0.3929338157,
0.3913733959,
0.0565206259,
-0.6975453496,
0.6707258224,
-0.3603151143,
0.26944381,
0.5043608546,
0.595523119,
-0.3112412691,
-0.7000774741,
-0.9429820776,
-0.8864519,
0.5159162283,
0.2633452713,
-0.3504148722,
-0.0826850906,
0.302783668,
0.0827307478,
0.1227971464,
-0.4858471155,
0.237703979,
0.089375928,
-0.3334202468,
0.1243605167,
-0.2370047718,
-0.0279754512,
-0.2238051891,
0.8458635807,
-0.2870306671,
0.1766167581,
0.4939305782,
-0.0515277237,
-0.2863846123,
0.5039571524,
0.1203523502,
0.8215932846,
-0.4608047307,
0.6537572742,
0.2469315678,
-0.200786382,
0.163113609,
-0.4010776579,
-0.3619715571,
-0.2543895543,
0.491586417,
0.3333997428,
-0.0335938968,
-0.9027891159,
0.5058950782,
0.2237573117,
-0.0176859498,
-0.3461924791,
-0.1903464198,
0.4183348715,
0.5124631524,
0.4173606634,
0.3156027198,
-0.0189053975,
-1.0195555687,
0.2467579395,
0.4793761969,
-0.2247835845,
-0.5269314647,
0.5179625154,
0.0679570809,
-0.2264199108,
0.585490942,
-0.2955320179,
-0.7926290631,
0.6456595659,
0.8353286982,
0.7446875572,
-0.03996066,
0.2981143296,
0.3940133452,
0.2301484048,
-0.2703661621,
0.8130546212,
-0.2536737025,
-0.9127207398,
-0.7166335583,
-0.5527486801,
-0.5316451788,
0.0550582297,
-0.2663933039,
-0.046937082,
-0.4737440348,
-0.1277342141,
-0.532579422,
0.1015174314,
-0.4857499897,
0.5057822466,
-0.01869056,
0.9848079681,
-0.7158874869,
1.059981823,
0.5258073807,
-0.4948912561,
-1.0319976807,
0.483445704,
-0.4579356611,
-0.6301717758,
0.7757871747,
0.1304161251,
-0.3953625858,
0.1803166121,
-0.3273637295,
-1.015017271,
0.8984386921,
0.233253926,
-0.8772317171,
-0.0223890077,
-0.1740404516,
0.5067179799,
-0.2017538697,
0.4525230229,
0.4508320689,
0.3663837016,
0.2932887673,
-0.678822875,
0.3700283766,
0.1655446589,
-0.2551266849,
0.1840399057,
-0.528141737,
0.8196568489,
-0.581961751,
-0.3419031501,
-0.2803994119,
0.5318385363,
0.5395076275,
0.2754668295,
0.6436811686,
0.5164259076,
1.0225433111,
0.1887179613,
0.9604184628,
-0.3231723905,
0.2985822856,
1.3417924643,
-0.2068661004,
1.1900415421,
0.3887654245,
-0.3434282541,
0.5784068108,
0.8492876887,
0.5887389779,
0.5411531925,
0.4310487509,
-0.2350340337,
-0.6218799353,
-0.1117272973,
-0.3029177189,
0.1616851538,
0.3073975146,
0.0865563601,
-0.1480745226,
-0.3121271431,
-0.0704525411,
0.1154511049,
-0.4032533765,
0.6229874492,
0.2147916704,
-0.9029170275,
0.6207652092,
0.0242295377,
0.2421151549,
-0.3806780577,
0.025022069,
-0.1189202666,
0.4446956217,
-0.3661146462,
-1.1218036413,
0.4220486879,
-0.0539851785,
0.0666234642,
-0.0608772524,
0.5969313979,
-0.3946475983,
-0.6202129722,
0.3430225253,
0.7845667005,
0.0782385617,
-0.4036515951,
-0.4919779897,
-0.4542130232,
-0.2690686584,
-0.3172927499,
0.160460934,
0.8354027271,
-0.6706607938,
0.9136125445,
0.6451507211,
0.2166529149,
-0.2509658635,
0.137075156,
0.9393196106,
-0.6566283107,
-0.5879521966,
-0.9069778323,
0.1756330281,
0.0927725211,
0.1515993029,
0.5951366425,
0.4681052864,
0.8746476173,
0.0939787775,
0.619615078,
0.0603998899,
0.517129004,
-0.5545884371,
0.1722961515,
-0.4214157462,
0.2738826871,
-0.3431727588,
-0.9587260485,
-0.3796615005,
0.6505585909,
-0.6117797494,
-0.2056000829,
0.9816087484,
0.6346422434,
0.019168254,
0.2276001871,
0.1255758107,
0.5627176166,
0.39074862,
0.9606978893,
1.1106796265,
-0.1619691849,
0.5412767529,
-0.0289700553,
-0.4323293269,
-0.1493279785,
-0.7290416956,
-0.5423116684,
-0.4833649397,
-0.3152796924,
-0.3710358739,
0.1315719932,
0.9690014124,
0.5014642477,
-0.957238555,
-0.0682303905,
-0.5296399593,
0.5236913562,
-0.7631647587,
-0.2056256682,
0.657512486,
-0.2392946184,
-0.1884004623,
0.1762306094,
0.2574979961,
-0.2267733067,
-0.2217226177,
0.173280254,
-0.5033537149,
0.2193616778,
0.7591506839,
0.0275711678,
-0.7299736142,
-0.4948338568,
-0.1114395186,
0.2475943416,
0.2011777461,
0.6138173938,
-1.0216357708,
0.3983467221,
0.76590693,
0.6719013453,
0.6299487948,
0.3301318586,
0.4412029684,
-0.5628384948,
-0.2599534392,
0.6291048527,
0.2272808999,
0.0804768428,
-0.4431093335,
0.5005174875,
0.327055335,
-0.3574177325,
-0.8446245193,
0.6562569141,
-0.838120997,
-0.5908815861,
1.1282048225,
-0.1990647465,
-0.3529171646,
-0.3113782704,
-0.4094840586,
0.2378500253,
-0.0656773895,
0.7525550723,
0.5138466954,
-0.3272609413,
-0.1160436869,
-0.4547786713,
0.3582112193,
0.4185110629,
-0.9806197882,
0.2308726609,
0.2950503528,
0.2064109594,
0.164369598,
0.9591881633,
-0.1172830909,
0.0695533678,
-0.1212207377,
-0.2143473476,
0.0689942539,
-0.6192970872,
0.2285995334,
0.5552991629,
0.2984631956,
-0.1159429997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.07556v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.07556v1
|
Federated Learning for Short Text Clustering
| 2023-11-23T12:19:41 | 2023-11-23T12:19:41 |
Mengling Hu, Chaochao Chen, Weiming Liu, Xinting Liao, Xiaolin Zheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Short text clustering has been popularly studied for its significance in
mining valuable insights from many short texts. In this paper, we focus on the
federated short text clustering (FSTC) problem, i.e., clustering short texts
that are distributed in different clients, which is a realistic problem under
privacy requirements. Compared with the centralized short text clustering
problem that short texts are stored on a central server, the FSTC problem has
not been explored yet. To fill this gap, we propose a Federated Robust Short
Text Clustering (FSTC) framework. FSTC includes two main modules, i.e., robust
short text clustering module and federated cluster center aggregation module.
The robust short text clustering module aims to train an effective short text
clustering model with local data in each client. We innovatively combine
optimal transport to generate pseudo-labels with Gaussian-uniform mixture model
to ensure the reliability of the pseudo-supervised data. The federated cluster
center aggregation module aims to exchange knowledge across clients without
sharing local raw data in an efficient way. The server aggregates the local
cluster centers from different clients and then sends the global centers back
to all clients in each communication round. Our empirical studies on three
short text clustering datasets demonstrate that FSTC significantly outperforms
the federated short text clustering baselines.
|
[
-0.1989574581,
-0.6887369156,
0.7748193145,
0.1113433838,
-0.2922255993,
0.2232801169,
-0.3403865397,
-0.5489906669,
0.282034725,
0.0068345563,
-0.5721961856,
-0.8749772906,
-0.331474334,
0.3813629448,
-0.4800340235,
1.2031273842,
0.1421545297,
-0.2274909914,
-0.5953131318,
-0.5665854812,
-0.156976819,
-0.3662198782,
-0.4573487937,
-0.2224608809,
0.4905328751,
0.7505501509,
0.7435071468,
0.5148100257,
0.4176068604,
0.3989674151,
-0.0164631363,
-0.0217904001,
-0.7159816027,
-0.1517217159,
-0.2687527835,
-0.813082397,
-0.3065707982,
0.0242641289,
0.9356609583,
0.6035540104,
-0.3040281534,
-0.024145307,
-0.1105080992,
0.4807120562,
-0.4763319492,
0.1430854201,
-0.3045428097,
-0.0152314585,
-0.3911032081,
0.2115607411,
-0.3165629506,
-0.563906014,
0.339897722,
-0.2261276543,
0.4399472475,
0.3122707903,
0.6809162498,
-0.0767902732,
-0.3877439201,
-0.204577446,
-0.5013458133,
0.8549942374,
-0.2513418198,
0.2451871186,
0.3055588007,
0.4605484605,
0.1003644168,
-0.9504899383,
-0.3109542429,
0.1840707809,
-0.7287447453,
-0.1381261945,
-0.4978897572,
-0.117731005,
-0.3404511809,
0.7332133651,
-0.6289975047,
0.5009254217,
-0.1336387098,
-0.3038582206,
0.3993926048,
0.1288375556,
0.0708603263,
0.1622992754,
-0.6169197559,
0.014461088,
-0.304780066,
0.2999763489,
0.2372375727,
0.5534539819,
-0.333019346,
0.1344956011,
-0.5016991496,
0.4572578073,
0.2883857787,
-0.2490535378,
0.2049655318,
-0.5557307601,
-0.0693924129,
0.2107429504,
0.9229216576,
0.1472983956,
-0.3708694577,
-0.506041348,
-0.3592053056,
-0.3015947938,
0.1220087111,
-0.8104429245,
-0.2502143085,
0.0884782597,
-0.8424407244,
-0.6847215295,
0.3083610535,
-0.8340612054,
0.1123271808,
0.0749119371,
0.5105050206,
0.0163867958,
-0.0564349219,
-0.408313632,
0.2370254844,
-0.2408367842,
-0.0921039507,
-1.1293703318,
0.4929943681,
0.7703725696,
1.2509106398,
-0.4283181131,
-0.4024609327,
-0.6095080376,
-0.2709522545,
0.2505894601,
0.7557445765,
-0.1201503649,
-0.4519416988,
0.0522573926,
0.3966967762,
-0.1323927641,
-0.1120586023,
0.3564265668,
-0.3742049634,
0.7027270198,
-0.0239040852,
-0.5369638801,
0.0915382281,
0.3382185698,
-0.654268384,
0.5165262818,
0.309484303,
-1.2740695477,
0.0751018971,
-0.3389680982,
-0.5026600361,
0.0163639188,
-0.0892997459,
-0.9783964157,
-0.0903829411,
0.3059351444,
0.6873520613,
-0.0746909454,
0.2132506222,
-0.5510011911,
-0.658521235,
0.2742268443,
-0.0633804351,
0.6837547421,
0.3184519112,
-0.2532031536,
0.2941588163,
-0.4893572032,
0.0672514439,
0.0948316231,
-0.1719171405,
-0.5626569986,
-0.2112569064,
-0.1362795383,
-0.1603907198,
0.4088850021,
-0.5078773499,
-0.1441812366,
-0.6372771263,
0.460059762,
0.662848413,
-0.0108524663,
1.0413150787,
-0.4173828959,
0.1751317978,
0.042235598,
0.3707610965,
0.1402081698,
-0.3445126116,
-0.413307935,
-0.2356149405,
0.1546759754,
0.2658993006,
-0.9116156101,
0.4028743505,
-0.4380366504,
-0.7912073731,
-0.1406972706,
-0.1545517296,
0.2808882296,
0.6457132101,
0.3083073199,
-0.0300278068,
-0.0343759917,
-0.6901718378,
-0.1166363284,
-0.1710562259,
0.0136348465,
0.230961293,
0.2383727282,
-0.7137620449,
1.1328309774,
-0.6177844405,
-0.6549882293,
-0.3019856513,
0.2376929522,
0.1105613708,
0.4277612865,
0.910597086,
-0.8011592627,
-0.6854954362,
0.1532028615,
-0.2454611957,
0.132263869,
-0.0406137221,
-0.1023501158,
0.2718578875,
-0.0455584154,
-0.5081454515,
0.3307911754,
0.6014087796,
-0.3071146607,
0.4074946344,
-0.3197547197,
0.1605247706,
-1.042788744,
0.0348919965,
-0.2592514157,
-0.5886657238,
-0.6058738828,
-0.0306247585,
-0.2002568543,
-0.1369386017,
-0.2997615933,
0.3275297582,
-0.133684203,
0.0223104637,
-0.5212946534,
0.2077589929,
-0.1420960575,
0.2784399688,
-0.1425056756,
0.6792068481,
0.5592234731,
-0.3416717649,
0.3501460254,
0.3627812266,
-0.022470491,
0.551443398,
-0.2381218225,
0.0180597603,
0.0646371767,
0.4578532279,
-0.4080642164,
-0.2792933881,
0.1838753223,
-0.2662273347,
-0.0255365483,
0.1797155738,
-0.4004197121,
-0.3702189624,
-0.0364036933,
0.4560727477,
0.4143199325,
-0.9511361718,
0.3517652452,
0.3086268306,
0.1349414736,
-0.4628043473,
-0.901863277,
-0.4406708479,
-0.3394705951,
-0.678245306,
0.2094631046,
0.1340196431,
0.0282921493,
0.1829982251,
-0.1698586345,
-0.5552061796,
0.135552153,
0.3619509041,
-0.2097901702,
-0.2588865459,
0.2137170881,
0.1434993148,
-0.3042434156,
-0.0077861426,
-0.4960196614,
0.0870101005,
-0.7699477673,
-0.0957079977,
-0.5201178193,
0.6254572868,
0.0242497679,
-0.0149080064,
1.1474964619,
0.8848586679,
-0.1958132535,
-0.4110658169,
-0.238359943,
-0.4429880083,
-0.4974125922,
-0.1948426068,
0.0443305969,
-1.6926225424,
0.5977306366,
-0.0616987832,
-0.0398657322,
0.2906374037,
0.350554049,
-0.240549624,
0.4849448502,
1.3818067312,
-0.3692741692,
0.3723493516,
0.0185459498,
0.512634933,
0.5697153211,
0.0125363544,
-0.7340441346,
-0.2956826687,
-0.7831073999,
-0.278954953,
0.1247976869,
-0.1853273958,
0.1781199425,
0.187165156,
-0.4453485012,
0.6839305162,
0.4660843909,
0.1649927646,
0.2477954775,
0.1443377584,
-0.2650934458,
0.1673593223,
-0.8545029759,
-0.0479216613,
0.5601402521,
0.3480027318,
0.3799722493,
0.0798276812,
1.0969679356,
0.4342665672,
0.4505340159,
-0.4669668376,
0.3252536058,
-0.2556788027,
-0.3487576246,
-0.0040838313,
-0.9210291505,
-0.5402073264,
-0.0097864186,
-0.2304942161,
-0.8175513744,
0.251218915,
0.125308916,
-0.4257903397,
0.5365554094,
-0.6996990442,
0.8358179331,
-0.0472288802,
-0.1850805134,
-0.301951915,
-1.1496210098,
0.4335239828,
-0.1716645211,
0.2116553634,
0.3509881794,
0.4471735358,
0.7556737065,
-0.7015354633,
0.7745777965,
-0.2547570467,
0.5779052377,
0.4840239882,
-0.3725176752,
0.5454394221,
0.2749033868,
0.2714598477,
0.2791413963,
0.1298872083,
-0.5511179566,
-0.3277230263,
0.9003609419,
-0.73813802,
-0.1985983551,
-0.5216633081,
-0.0134711843,
-0.1112520546,
0.6254423857,
0.1857524365,
0.1069779024,
-0.4773888886,
0.4351750314,
0.555714488,
0.1937534511,
0.6444562674,
0.4749644697,
0.0876753703,
-0.6495633125,
0.9733911157,
-0.3989582062,
0.1473122239,
0.7067065239,
0.3609740734,
-0.3648963273,
-0.4549592733,
0.1741903424,
0.320004344,
-0.6585935354,
-0.4354702532,
-0.54332304,
-0.0384617895,
-0.1814298183,
-0.5074187517,
-0.5209559798,
0.0117001096,
-0.7911486626,
-0.3016746938,
0.3227079213,
0.2905098796,
-0.346172601,
0.942990303,
-1.1609914303,
-0.1472101212,
0.1908145398,
0.6131576896,
0.0163738634,
0.3926070631,
-0.7469852567,
0.103146337,
0.003422742,
-0.4947153032,
0.0752348006,
0.1080116704,
0.3023318648,
0.7844382524,
0.4044606984,
0.4608023763,
-0.1832128167,
0.6438804865,
0.2429000288,
-0.7562875748,
0.2577514648,
-0.3170515895,
0.1368759871,
0.9038256407,
0.3268580139,
-0.2922057509,
-0.3855960071,
-0.8235820532,
-0.4126981497,
0.799082458,
0.4928699434,
-0.4310004115,
0.0444425344,
0.3469314277,
0.3449966013,
0.2022183388,
-0.7153793573,
-0.0722345412,
-0.2693079412,
-0.2931006849,
-0.2757551074,
-0.2134532779,
-0.2184262127,
0.127561003,
0.5137727261,
-0.2736155987,
0.3705582917,
0.0508387871,
-0.0349958465,
0.0014797618,
0.2880969048,
0.5308205485,
0.2932819426,
-0.240684405,
0.1405865699,
-0.0599564388,
-0.4271124005,
0.076731436,
0.3873185813,
-0.2412435114,
0.1961753368,
0.1803321838,
0.6200259924,
0.435877949,
-0.2920269072,
0.7640264034,
-0.4866387844,
-0.2008927166,
0.0148094157,
-0.0052665249,
-0.0722415671,
0.2708215714,
0.1206160188,
0.3761098981,
-0.1228551641,
-0.0832575932,
0.5192044377,
0.1615668833,
-0.4023032784,
-0.4429649711,
0.5285737514,
0.3727392554,
0.1390202492,
0.4985490441,
-0.0864356607,
-0.4949074686,
0.1517807096,
0.2990066111,
0.7666624784,
-0.0496247187,
0.4435159564,
-0.0121073322,
0.259218514,
-0.4510216117,
-0.3222567439,
-0.6781641841,
-0.2573979795,
-0.0988499969,
-0.5800352097,
-0.4246988595,
-0.5491990447,
-0.5271820426,
-0.0169769246,
-0.2785604298,
-0.1334946156,
-0.5918702483,
0.5704067945,
-0.4566904008,
0.1318818033,
-0.1280084252,
0.6466642618,
-1.18024683,
1.036544919,
0.5235566497,
0.0302781984,
-0.7378402352,
-0.201842472,
-0.0190300792,
-0.1469970644,
-0.2429184169,
0.4228842854,
-0.023210153,
-0.0967349857,
-0.4084697366,
-0.7093215585,
1.3163833618,
-0.1859461069,
-0.2644164562,
0.0908275321,
0.5512387753,
0.7319921851,
-0.5204721093,
-0.1422451884,
0.3604581058,
0.3154736757,
-0.0759217441,
-0.6800501347,
0.0726694912,
0.3586580157,
-0.2769229114,
0.1161328256,
-0.9532963037,
0.7826701403,
0.1216365173,
-0.4944548607,
0.2928251922,
1.2044215202,
-0.1000760123,
0.9480133057,
0.621923089,
0.5021874309,
0.8803167343,
-0.2018467337,
0.5954192877,
0.3118427098,
0.7190715671,
1.0609526634,
0.0279627759,
0.4729230106,
0.3833166659,
0.1280592531,
0.3785795569,
0.5271794796,
0.085530363,
0.9566111565,
-0.4750912786,
-0.3318803608,
-0.0745242834,
0.0666903034,
-0.1909340173,
0.3091453314,
0.2217735052,
-0.3209908903,
-0.5718865991,
0.2149045169,
0.065583609,
0.2486816943,
-0.1396133602,
0.7741193175,
0.2669472992,
-0.2632783055,
0.0796283334,
0.3776575923,
0.6693127751,
-0.531147778,
0.542481184,
-0.4361868203,
0.4739336669,
-0.3599967659,
-0.4724131525,
0.6033349037,
-0.0531811491,
-0.4824290276,
-0.5140230656,
0.9825296402,
-0.5280279517,
-0.1733219773,
0.046566654,
0.3818011582,
-0.0180285536,
0.1698457599,
-0.5077041984,
-0.0872652531,
0.100113906,
0.2311320603,
0.7044326067,
0.4255942702,
-0.1008733287,
0.4955190122,
0.5987527966,
-0.2360056341,
-0.2014273554,
-0.3323101401,
0.8365010619,
-0.2318046838,
-1.2919105291,
-0.5675664544,
0.3687945902,
-0.2512966692,
0.0924261585,
0.6465511322,
0.2624283433,
0.6319341063,
-0.1027311981,
0.2027139515,
-0.0512980185,
0.6763470769,
-0.2394716442,
1.2789244652,
-0.4530133903,
-0.1000210717,
0.0898935795,
-0.6984583735,
-0.3279749453,
0.2911773622,
-0.2661313713,
-0.3986516893,
0.772998333,
0.5082138181,
-0.369327426,
0.5985556245,
0.0203415472,
0.0493376479,
0.5350802541,
0.4647555053,
0.3897612393,
-0.2115300149,
0.6130649447,
-0.9982268214,
-0.161078468,
-0.3658986986,
-0.7611740828,
-1.0952363014,
-0.6236015558,
-0.2447430789,
0.0487850979,
-0.0453077368,
0.5460529923,
0.6181601286,
-0.8401303291,
0.1076472849,
-0.1915651709,
0.6281173229,
-0.3130118251,
-0.3534694314,
0.4926747382,
-0.0483714454,
-0.326862663,
0.4219853878,
0.1590509415,
0.3214921653,
-0.0497414134,
0.1810085922,
-0.0821422935,
-0.4693437219,
0.151056096,
0.3670116067,
-0.2806898952,
-0.4096808136,
-0.2848784924,
-0.2518929541,
-0.1773166507,
0.8103692532,
-0.8184970021,
0.1269478649,
0.4684862196,
0.7195137143,
0.1685736626,
0.5004462004,
0.2329503596,
-1.2150365114,
0.5765861273,
0.3464233875,
0.0223927833,
0.2400586605,
-0.5205380917,
0.0908181369,
0.4463903904,
-0.8640748858,
-0.8362579942,
-0.2630030811,
-0.9750856757,
-0.1868679374,
0.4528445005,
-0.5240113139,
-0.4774720669,
0.3177834749,
0.4243340492,
0.1072244719,
-0.4172226489,
0.5903496146,
0.385102272,
0.1614657938,
-0.0893349349,
0.1327054799,
0.6394671202,
0.1533345431,
-0.6814164519,
-0.2733699083,
0.4733659327,
0.2474968433,
0.0627608895,
0.6370673776,
0.28731969,
-0.0798081607,
-0.1313790381,
-0.6011070609,
0.05405524,
-0.4894954264,
-0.2823385596,
0.687386632,
-0.4537442923,
-0.2638883889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13957v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13957v1
|
Efficient Trigger Word Insertion
| 2023-11-23T12:15:56 | 2023-11-23T12:15:56 |
Yueqi Zeng, Ziqiang Li, Pengfei Xia, Lei Liu, Bin Li
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
With the boom in the natural language processing (NLP) field these years,
backdoor attacks pose immense threats against deep neural network models.
However, previous works hardly consider the effect of the poisoning rate. In
this paper, our main objective is to reduce the number of poisoned samples
while still achieving a satisfactory Attack Success Rate (ASR) in text backdoor
attacks. To accomplish this, we propose an efficient trigger word insertion
strategy in terms of trigger word optimization and poisoned sample selection.
Extensive experiments on different datasets and models demonstrate that our
proposed method can significantly improve attack effectiveness in text
classification tasks. Remarkably, our approach achieves an ASR of over 90% with
only 10 poisoned samples in the dirty-label setting and requires merely 1.5% of
the training data in the clean-label setting.
|
[
-0.2096461803,
-0.593182385,
0.2394810915,
0.2086715698,
-0.3018645346,
-0.1707907021,
-0.2244963199,
-0.3674010634,
-0.1256036162,
0.4503611326,
-0.1015711874,
-0.7999457717,
-0.8390185237,
0.1026697531,
-0.5987907052,
1.1479375362,
0.3874978423,
-0.1624445766,
0.4516054988,
0.0627783611,
-0.7000597715,
-0.5896083117,
-0.7914075255,
-0.3090609908,
0.774715364,
-0.0915168375,
0.6195112467,
0.5457156301,
0.4310788214,
0.2549706995,
-0.3255346417,
-0.0384946056,
-0.2810428441,
0.2685453892,
-0.351321578,
-0.4028882086,
-0.1214497983,
0.1713995785,
0.3488072753,
0.1997265071,
-0.168192938,
-0.1866733432,
0.1584812999,
0.4109410942,
-1.1018892527,
-0.4285966754,
-0.9387813807,
0.307964921,
-0.2098090947,
-0.2849354446,
-0.6430845857,
-0.291163981,
-0.0424120575,
-0.1917855144,
0.0419785827,
-0.2841435969,
0.4682462811,
0.1863174587,
-0.2175802141,
-0.2458088994,
-0.3522837162,
0.4704660773,
-0.8759508729,
0.4644357562,
0.1953128129,
-0.0145054702,
-0.5420307517,
-0.7745838165,
-0.5953682661,
-0.0319921337,
0.0512080118,
-0.0434903577,
-0.2753539681,
0.1624707133,
0.2542905807,
0.0968531221,
-0.5566257238,
0.3200899959,
-0.1278433204,
-0.3386481702,
0.763043046,
0.3053914011,
0.4789022505,
-0.2154787332,
-0.2915484011,
-0.2153203636,
-0.5558368564,
-0.1111700758,
0.6056474447,
0.6610407233,
0.3674437702,
0.4328776598,
0.0058741081,
0.8917180896,
0.0158554018,
0.1546519101,
0.0331444666,
-0.4937817752,
-0.1588454694,
0.3791124821,
1.0588755608,
0.2994967997,
0.1581523716,
-0.1861765534,
-0.3591140807,
0.3089692891,
0.6736355424,
-1.13078022,
-0.5038157105,
0.4489776492,
-0.0056936247,
-0.7341048121,
-0.1521807313,
-1.0989991426,
-0.6125451326,
0.5328511,
0.6941491365,
-0.6926356554,
0.0983511209,
0.1138523892,
-0.6935740113,
0.098849766,
0.0529919416,
-0.7362982035,
0.2905287147,
0.8586316109,
0.7824098468,
-0.0696793422,
-0.2118466496,
-1.0815405846,
0.0413241498,
-0.4093470871,
0.7264631987,
-0.421338439,
-0.5678429008,
0.1948396564,
-0.3823854327,
-0.0783561766,
-0.4676169455,
0.552467525,
-0.9400304556,
0.5388944745,
0.1296956688,
-0.5532991886,
-0.3704090118,
0.3962365985,
-0.4690421522,
0.923468709,
-0.4582992196,
-0.8136475682,
0.5002545714,
-0.6101378798,
-0.8628922701,
0.1832309216,
0.2341381311,
-0.3242347836,
0.0546209663,
0.2940451801,
0.6072427034,
0.3653307855,
0.0872058645,
-0.0368724428,
-0.3826513886,
0.2573900521,
-0.2830479443,
1.0463579893,
0.2622572184,
-0.4036855698,
-0.1734541655,
-0.6200405955,
0.1465115696,
-0.0894205123,
-0.75365448,
-0.6446861029,
0.0611060373,
0.0252400842,
0.1095022559,
-0.1866249442,
-0.6941814423,
0.288297981,
-1.1485717297,
0.0027241749,
0.5606235266,
0.3034405708,
0.423409313,
-0.0643088892,
0.2346490324,
-0.1255481988,
-0.0163631961,
-0.2241087258,
-0.6265791655,
-0.3704642355,
-0.3488191962,
0.3849971592,
0.9554030299,
-0.7627604008,
0.9366841912,
-0.1656173766,
-0.6300091147,
-0.2321186364,
0.2357168943,
0.6467836499,
0.4653016627,
0.5027685761,
-0.1872889996,
-0.2109094113,
-0.3861806393,
-0.89766711,
0.1600806564,
-0.2274738103,
-0.0279097464,
0.5151863694,
-0.0992626399,
0.7876365185,
-0.862508595,
-0.3991432786,
-0.0977995247,
0.1782277077,
0.419614315,
0.3765294552,
0.2552838624,
-0.6677663326,
-0.4828176498,
-0.2522080243,
-0.5889453292,
-0.1800441295,
-0.0665033683,
-0.0237268507,
0.0564392097,
0.3313341737,
-0.4016526937,
0.6906346679,
0.3582357466,
-0.3012102842,
0.2132782936,
0.0145916855,
0.0770910233,
-1.2367731333,
-0.0233047567,
0.0078156451,
0.1839817762,
-1.1661299467,
0.2986212969,
0.2387422621,
-0.3629326224,
-0.8325372934,
0.6187445521,
-0.3526037633,
0.5416662097,
-0.2477469891,
0.0881890655,
-0.117349647,
0.3554093242,
-0.3948531151,
0.5312183499,
0.2201336622,
-0.8612954617,
0.452504456,
0.538010478,
-0.188621968,
0.3195284903,
-0.4284552634,
0.3487255871,
0.2569099665,
0.3442854881,
-0.8840784431,
-0.0813854188,
0.6161316037,
-0.5608908534,
0.6180375218,
-0.0250241645,
-0.4333049655,
-0.2296044677,
-0.727940619,
0.1218454018,
0.4173880517,
-0.7567071319,
0.4461941123,
-0.0075522689,
0.1686331779,
-0.9024866223,
-0.7191470861,
0.521856606,
-0.1929458827,
-0.6124181151,
0.3926064372,
0.3047216535,
-0.0658462197,
-0.1388454139,
0.0861237943,
0.1191074401,
0.2030591369,
0.1197381169,
-0.3037584424,
0.0412267968,
0.2833656669,
0.0419921577,
-0.3010012805,
0.0052352455,
-0.307263732,
0.666425705,
0.4049401581,
0.0708757043,
-0.8740043044,
0.5033043623,
0.3176673055,
-0.2954517007,
0.9652602077,
0.256374985,
-0.4721623063,
-0.35550946,
-0.3672403097,
-0.5143390298,
-0.5157976151,
0.3641265631,
-0.2134680301,
-0.2841954827,
0.1944522858,
0.2585338652,
0.2219309211,
0.3076831698,
0.2798672318,
0.0819912702,
0.8063427806,
0.2842776477,
-0.2853284478,
0.5198962092,
-0.168322131,
0.4250866473,
-0.7473360896,
-0.0318650901,
-0.500672996,
-0.2878826857,
-0.475045681,
-0.1359123439,
0.2503465712,
-0.037526045,
-0.1263718605,
0.4899451733,
-0.7045730352,
0.1749600172,
0.5857632756,
0.3937429488,
0.1746589839,
-0.0468898788,
-0.0999050587,
0.0539438687,
-0.828011632,
-0.1514578164,
0.9927158952,
0.2518748045,
0.8004904389,
0.1006710976,
1.0882050991,
0.063079007,
0.3674098849,
-0.7768633962,
0.5751469135,
-0.3974631727,
-0.9106006622,
-0.3833598793,
-0.0567585118,
-1.0824426413,
0.0482044443,
-0.511510849,
-0.8244320154,
0.177117914,
0.160583064,
-0.7145371437,
0.4371957183,
-0.7263934612,
0.6050961614,
-0.1032832414,
-0.1437058151,
-0.0090960488,
-0.5804197192,
0.43228966,
-0.4800377488,
-0.0805113986,
0.0886482894,
-0.3025710285,
0.9458593726,
-0.8797971606,
0.7766445279,
-0.2806609869,
-0.1893982887,
0.1311024725,
-0.0362754948,
0.8835840821,
-0.2019042075,
-0.2688164115,
0.3169380724,
-0.5629712939,
0.0049406234,
-0.6955711246,
0.1989915222,
-0.1651885808,
-0.6523962617,
-0.5043922067,
-0.1121284515,
0.0084735211,
0.0503695495,
0.976426065,
0.6559621692,
0.1889789402,
0.085964866,
0.7003447413,
-0.697406888,
0.8063300848,
0.198187232,
0.022435775,
-0.6563592553,
0.7078477144,
0.3534628153,
0.2602185309,
0.3209678233,
0.4789882898,
-0.2342788428,
-0.7661606073,
-0.4062026143,
-0.0763832629,
-0.4485191703,
-0.6383980513,
-1.3432022333,
-0.5007357597,
-0.5753397942,
-0.4060043395,
-0.2494620085,
0.1832189709,
-0.2794929743,
0.0162555743,
0.7341068983,
0.3082856536,
-0.1624827981,
0.888864696,
-1.0214151144,
0.2516261041,
0.4100102484,
0.3224732876,
0.0382630453,
-0.5982068181,
-0.0199551322,
-0.2460428625,
-0.1681252271,
-1.558956027,
0.6110226512,
0.3002503812,
0.4705144465,
0.392791152,
0.3566654623,
0.323628515,
-0.6178244948,
0.8445705771,
0.3507787585,
-0.7541624308,
0.8511393666,
-0.4919705093,
0.438247174,
0.6569580436,
0.4668049514,
-0.703797102,
-0.6275777221,
-0.5092905164,
-1.046480298,
0.3544447124,
0.2060500383,
0.4762561917,
-0.0002388791,
0.0883318931,
-0.0241668895,
0.1747425646,
-0.4074442685,
-0.3089714944,
0.2449890971,
-0.1036745161,
-0.0034222694,
-0.3587647974,
-0.1203707308,
-0.1449742019,
0.7569777369,
0.2963447571,
0.087697722,
0.0534489416,
-0.1965622157,
0.2980417609,
0.2374037057,
0.3761700094,
-0.0646456182,
-0.1009642631,
0.1619659513,
0.5904332995,
-1.0544749498,
0.3270795047,
0.1934746951,
-0.2547400892,
-0.0737113804,
0.4824207425,
0.1540873647,
0.2995853126,
-0.1787160337,
0.7238932848,
-0.0694251359,
0.1000866592,
0.1099277511,
0.5103179216,
-0.3207740784,
0.0854390934,
0.5412675142,
-0.1403630823,
0.3347752392,
-0.4028999805,
0.6409575343,
0.4887217879,
-0.4699951112,
0.0882880613,
0.301843971,
0.5337187648,
-0.8349625468,
0.9518951178,
-0.1830705106,
-1.1536940336,
0.189477399,
0.475273937,
1.1778547764,
-0.7028740048,
-0.1407088488,
0.4344927967,
0.4392118454,
0.1983468384,
0.2115073651,
0.1078252345,
-1.0488194227,
-0.3421475887,
-0.6696036458,
0.0481707528,
0.2206667066,
-0.2651072443,
0.4084528387,
-0.5673997998,
-0.156698972,
0.1917026788,
0.1174855828,
-0.1292484999,
0.4099568129,
-0.0973550454,
1.0824240446,
-0.9654167891,
0.4588544071,
0.1426663846,
-0.0784737393,
-0.7259582281,
0.0481192805,
0.1649389565,
-0.5385206342,
0.6635048985,
0.3971411288,
0.0144372238,
0.0657252222,
-0.5869919658,
-0.498106122,
0.3325094879,
-0.2293082327,
-0.2656691372,
0.2905550301,
-0.3437111974,
0.4343259931,
0.1283805072,
-0.2970293462,
0.5542728901,
0.5456956029,
-0.0396478586,
-0.4000473619,
0.2514059544,
-0.3709612489,
-0.1155263111,
0.6948126554,
0.0547888651,
0.4471991956,
-0.1175320596,
-0.3804512918,
-0.1432766467,
0.6217439771,
0.0921138898,
0.6148499846,
0.4708513021,
0.8563603759,
0.5127822757,
0.0444241688,
1.041018486,
-0.0025249075,
-0.2872219682,
1.1814689636,
-0.0736004412,
1.0334329605,
0.2900482416,
0.0805691779,
0.2667532563,
0.5707021952,
-0.3883164823,
0.6820065379,
0.447475791,
-0.5624958873,
0.1621701717,
0.0096651725,
-0.5468103886,
0.7234413028,
0.33893013,
-0.4739813805,
-0.2099574357,
0.3181119263,
0.5708858967,
0.1629692763,
-0.2003031075,
1.0612722635,
0.0317858383,
-0.5655732751,
0.3720075786,
-0.1430170238,
1.0164070129,
-0.4100339413,
0.2007789314,
-0.1648803204,
0.1963373721,
-0.4027321339,
-0.7374936938,
0.3928149045,
0.2499597669,
0.0658647567,
0.0693843439,
0.8265897632,
-0.3404238522,
-0.2437853217,
0.2348017991,
0.0035475085,
0.1537626535,
-0.5399705172,
-0.289665103,
-0.1501968652,
-0.2101544589,
-0.355749011,
0.103476055,
0.0967528522,
0.3161543012,
0.2980592847,
1.0412633419,
0.3715557456,
0.1763159782,
-0.4086666703,
0.953418076,
-0.8034804463,
-0.6601378322,
-1.0841739178,
0.6092508435,
-0.5044791698,
-0.4953091741,
0.810703218,
0.5369625092,
0.3336381018,
0.1327225566,
0.6451916695,
0.1346407235,
0.1397916377,
-0.4687801898,
1.2155375481,
-0.224024877,
0.0388254486,
-0.6097062826,
-0.8217732906,
-0.6069795489,
0.3637826741,
-0.3949837983,
-0.1128145233,
0.6778814197,
0.9696311355,
0.5179162621,
0.0948921442,
0.3378717303,
0.1562622339,
0.4440649152,
0.6169499159,
0.8306196332,
-0.7450882792,
0.4742402136,
-0.3505487442,
-0.2847473025,
-0.4011411667,
-1.1042234898,
-0.9259428382,
-0.2682788074,
-0.3372302651,
-0.6221833229,
0.4070529342,
0.624764204,
0.5032276511,
-0.8485087752,
0.3120512664,
0.1652456373,
0.2978051305,
-0.1407738179,
-0.1676583439,
0.3031545281,
-0.5444017053,
-0.4146338403,
0.4511143863,
0.3001162112,
-0.1251765043,
0.2133299708,
0.2496401668,
-0.5774469972,
0.1015688255,
0.4938262999,
0.2354557663,
-0.2803984284,
-0.4365511239,
-0.2068985701,
-0.3849989176,
-0.3445176482,
0.441801548,
-0.7626498938,
0.5394404531,
0.6089885235,
0.9576175213,
0.0883849561,
-0.1390280128,
0.7645363212,
-0.8486545086,
0.1274475753,
0.5419762135,
-0.1328262389,
0.2438905835,
-0.8850352764,
0.5537024736,
0.1918722689,
-0.2139835656,
-0.8939047456,
0.1017170101,
-0.5428720117,
-0.5692506433,
1.3465679884,
0.084266901,
-0.2612010837,
-0.2762236595,
0.0093949176,
0.5073922276,
-0.2554106712,
0.709572494,
0.3338007033,
0.0555854589,
0.4295208156,
-0.2819825113,
0.765889883,
0.1351973861,
-0.731543839,
-0.1555141807,
0.3007666767,
0.1366714984,
0.493760854,
0.1643140167,
0.0808773264,
0.2698625922,
0.3782443404,
0.1032122001,
0.0333156213,
-0.3911753893,
-0.7488757372,
0.527755022,
-0.5418425798,
-0.6332948208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13951v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13951v2
|
MLLM-Bench: Evaluating Multimodal LLMs with Per-sample Criteria
| 2023-11-23T12:04:25 | 2024-04-27T04:32:05 |
Wentao Ge, Shunian Chen, Guiming Hardy Chen, Zhihong Chen, Junying Chen, Shuo Yan, Chenghao Zhu, Ziyue Lin, Wenya Xie, Xinyi Zhang, Yichen Chai, Xiaoyu Liu, Dingjie Song, Xidong Wang, Anningzhe Gao, Zhiyi Zhang, Jianquan Li, Xiang Wan, Benyou Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) (e.g., GPT-4V, LLaVA, and Claude-3)
have broadened the scope of AI applications. Yet, evaluating their performance
presents a significant challenge owing to the inherently subjective nature of
tasks that do not yield clear-cut solutions especially for those open-ended
queries. Existing automatic evaluation methodologies are mainly limited in
evaluating objective queries without considering real-world user experiences,
inadequately addressing the nuances of creative and associative multimodal
tasks. In our paper, we propose a new evaluation paradigm for MLLMs, which is
evaluating MLLMs with \textit{per-sample criteria} using potent MLLM as the
judge. To validate the feasibility and effectiveness of this paradigm, we
design a benchmark, dubbed \textit{MLLM-Bench}, with the evaluation samples
across six critical levels following the revised Bloom's Taxonomy with the
ethical consideration. We benchmark 21 popular MLLMs in a pairwise-comparison
fashion, showing diverse performance across models. Moreover, the validity of
our benchmark manifests itself in reaching 88.02\% agreement with human
evaluation. We contend that the proposed paradigm explores the potential of
MLLMs as effective evaluation tools with the help of per-sample criteria, and
that MLLM-Bench will serve as a catalyst for encouraging the development of
user-centric MLLMs tailored to real-world applications. Our benchmark data,
online leaderboard and submission entry are at https://mllm-bench.llmzoo.com.
|
[
-0.4193810523,
-0.6114729047,
0.6148384809,
0.5380111337,
-0.1665312052,
-0.0087811667,
-0.4722810388,
-0.257912457,
-0.2910395265,
0.2764609456,
-0.5503151417,
-0.7146759629,
-0.3255503476,
0.1507351398,
-0.5864787698,
0.6256489754,
-0.0357444026,
0.362300843,
-0.6809122562,
-0.5611662865,
-0.3383764625,
-0.6760752201,
-0.3618685007,
-0.1504414827,
0.715200305,
0.0623830259,
0.3478414118,
0.2165736556,
0.6897289753,
0.3112561107,
0.1921014041,
0.3353915513,
-0.4823723137,
0.3810836673,
0.0801974908,
-0.3897585273,
-0.4757773876,
0.2615401447,
0.6830359697,
0.5497306585,
-0.1132649407,
0.4341403544,
0.0176628809,
0.5503261685,
-0.7473723292,
-0.0426690094,
-0.7701824903,
0.2218885273,
-0.2248375118,
-0.193435356,
-0.4492504895,
-0.1903186738,
-0.2144689262,
-0.4302154481,
-0.114396885,
0.1922827959,
0.5720019937,
0.2656397223,
-0.3380103409,
-0.0217696745,
-0.5771819949,
0.96716851,
-0.8370547295,
0.628788054,
0.4357389212,
0.6411120892,
0.1103493273,
-0.7506966591,
-0.5744883418,
-0.7656846046,
0.0984163284,
0.1753749251,
0.0201496445,
-0.1834865063,
0.2077635229,
0.3133331835,
-0.6547324657,
0.1340952069,
0.0590694696,
-0.0582999513,
0.7727305889,
0.5267621875,
0.0241749175,
-0.0547186323,
-0.614798069,
-0.0644067749,
-0.5007069707,
0.0634073317,
0.2513924539,
0.3535753489,
-0.1467458457,
0.6104507446,
-0.2201371044,
0.6664880514,
-0.2203435749,
-0.2829032838,
0.5280108452,
-0.5414335728,
-0.2638799548,
-0.6387253404,
0.9264864922,
0.6792051792,
0.1481739283,
-0.2684525549,
-0.5878326297,
-0.0025988009,
0.3930230737,
-0.6413684487,
0.1068175957,
0.290601939,
-0.6951839924,
-0.3444088101,
-0.1983878911,
-0.7772581577,
-0.755165875,
-0.473575145,
0.527007699,
-0.21756576,
-0.2146466821,
-0.3008199632,
0.0153510282,
0.1273621917,
0.4307410717,
-0.5170784593,
0.317037791,
0.4319143295,
0.7615418434,
-0.4780675173,
-0.4450044334,
-0.4806031883,
-0.1158592626,
-0.1514687389,
0.843221128,
-0.7686481476,
-0.5140237808,
0.0705731362,
-0.3246970475,
-0.1186657697,
-0.6603331566,
0.728915751,
-0.4007785022,
0.1073082462,
-0.385799706,
-0.5039535761,
0.1567048132,
0.714733839,
-0.5143021941,
0.8842941523,
-0.0287318006,
-0.4373579323,
0.7040948272,
-0.823605597,
-0.2532460988,
0.0111350268,
-0.4288033545,
-0.3427127898,
-0.0537248217,
0.3002028763,
0.3094622493,
-0.4856902361,
0.2941931486,
-0.6420172453,
-0.3864476979,
0.5848647952,
-0.7538035512,
0.6533721089,
0.328666836,
-0.2851669192,
0.6967887282,
-0.7875040174,
0.2099878192,
0.0159011334,
-0.3915514052,
-0.0873579532,
0.0001941207,
0.4899737835,
0.2260984629,
0.1602348238,
-0.4073238969,
0.0338266753,
-0.0213174243,
0.248263523,
0.9863772392,
-0.266772449,
0.2549954951,
-0.461250484,
0.4732531011,
-0.3413326144,
0.641238451,
0.0979785472,
-0.2936727703,
-0.717402041,
-0.5036167502,
0.2917545736,
0.36227265,
-0.3491017222,
0.3514715433,
-0.0924853608,
-0.5648522377,
-0.6548867822,
0.3680839241,
0.3110423088,
0.282279253,
0.4008400142,
-0.4247590303,
-0.4297410846,
-1.0086115599,
-0.270200938,
0.0529165827,
-0.0697366223,
0.7515221834,
0.2897067368,
-0.3300180435,
0.9316184521,
0.0974596515,
-0.3854730427,
-0.0479017124,
0.1726060361,
0.2542155385,
0.3589427769,
0.4633259773,
-1.0172903538,
-0.3703146279,
-0.2920790911,
-0.9275513291,
-0.2160158008,
0.0012421252,
-0.0283890758,
0.0040525924,
0.2774437666,
-0.635786891,
0.2684865892,
0.4486283064,
-0.1886483133,
0.807862401,
-0.1341254264,
0.3409782648,
-0.5650152564,
0.279083997,
-0.105165951,
-0.1854125708,
-0.3611259162,
0.2447906435,
0.0148944324,
0.0246892255,
-0.4376889467,
0.7733020782,
-0.382184267,
-0.3691349626,
-0.1302279979,
0.3287565708,
0.0209753104,
0.3558835387,
-0.4000569582,
0.651263833,
0.2803669274,
-0.4209903777,
0.6677158475,
-0.0046647186,
-0.5407674313,
0.6729307771,
-0.5010792017,
0.2567147017,
-0.0014065936,
0.3862014711,
-1.0495457649,
0.1104411408,
0.1851208508,
-0.2421804368,
0.065316245,
0.1929470301,
-0.7543784976,
-0.3330615759,
-0.5228894353,
0.5002450347,
0.3393843174,
-0.2706007659,
0.6423118711,
0.3161050975,
0.1555130333,
-0.5875422955,
-0.6041631699,
0.2048542798,
-0.3003279269,
-0.5745076537,
0.3418823183,
-0.3844037652,
-0.5722121596,
0.0969673693,
-0.0843241215,
0.13105537,
0.1702347845,
0.2824027836,
0.2758607566,
-0.2553173006,
0.1330479383,
-0.3104182184,
0.048857633,
-0.1092544422,
-0.0071499245,
0.6536132097,
-0.2866100669,
-0.8602307439,
-0.1946358234,
0.1668605655,
0.7863455415,
-0.4551463425,
0.3610390127,
1.0871882439,
-0.1923028976,
0.0577357188,
-0.9339437485,
-0.1308777183,
-0.4081207812,
0.3148328662,
-0.6054962873,
-0.7696303725,
0.2863848209,
0.1117347702,
0.2898195982,
0.3609748781,
1.0211060047,
-0.2840778828,
0.7828039527,
0.3744464219,
-0.0267229136,
0.3128680885,
-0.0962400213,
-0.0238339193,
-1.0039110184,
-0.1638303995,
-0.26711151,
-0.6152290702,
-0.3727275729,
-0.5725216866,
0.5189455152,
-0.1105119959,
-0.2287228853,
-0.0240330808,
-0.3108364046,
0.1162630692,
0.5512554049,
0.0693898126,
0.4173182249,
-0.2114209086,
-0.4513395429,
0.0144011807,
-0.4543218613,
-0.6216595769,
1.4571561813,
0.2112259716,
0.570927918,
0.1956279725,
0.5588804483,
0.6822832227,
0.802190423,
-0.6143578887,
0.693549037,
-0.0353006013,
-0.8226832151,
-0.4780106246,
-0.3027442396,
-0.9013326168,
0.8181282878,
-0.4460053742,
-0.8471497297,
0.0317904986,
-0.1035628021,
-0.3382214606,
0.1268043071,
-0.5630278587,
1.062224865,
-0.6679116488,
-0.7288751602,
-0.3965465128,
-0.5714312792,
0.4183394313,
-0.0821599439,
0.4083800018,
-0.6199872494,
-0.2076904476,
0.5119712353,
-0.0746724159,
0.7284930348,
-0.3878369331,
0.0562057495,
0.0190736968,
-0.1732343733,
0.2028039098,
0.0318083279,
-0.3064058125,
-0.0346671231,
0.0820624977,
-0.2677744627,
-0.6666975617,
0.7067179084,
-0.6882244349,
-0.4811590016,
-0.2247067392,
-0.7333847284,
-0.733935833,
0.1074059159,
-0.1367093921,
0.3833116889,
-0.3158144653,
0.2723984122,
0.0155605832,
-0.2018285692,
0.2873176038,
0.6746706963,
-0.6607359052,
-0.2613224089,
0.8747167587,
-0.1271010786,
0.0046112365,
0.3665942252,
0.1995975822,
-0.5424211621,
-0.7920439243,
-0.5302710533,
0.0078495098,
-0.7185311317,
-0.0334505476,
-0.5041453838,
-0.0005334424,
-0.3008815646,
0.2008383721,
-0.2238432318,
-0.0374777019,
0.0843191072,
0.2703141868,
-0.0525303595,
0.4429911375,
0.1580840349,
-0.2636039853,
-0.7663700581,
0.3215253055,
0.3742032051,
0.3741754889,
0.0552674234,
-0.419860661,
0.0398679972,
-0.0212882217,
-0.201497063,
-0.4035844505,
0.1824702621,
0.0359633826,
1.1012706757,
0.2482672483,
-0.0020281035,
0.6688939929,
-0.5506312847,
0.6729562879,
0.0932711363,
-0.6341747046,
0.178592369,
-0.2515861094,
0.2179740816,
0.8103923798,
0.2314321101,
-0.4769380093,
-0.3094879687,
-0.28498438,
-0.8834902048,
0.2780775428,
0.3106938899,
0.2629486024,
0.2696931958,
-0.076754801,
0.226291135,
0.4951821566,
-0.8031662107,
-0.1814084053,
-0.0684328824,
-0.1910583675,
-0.0873605385,
-0.2949448824,
-0.3581260741,
-0.3090250194,
0.3046627045,
-0.006370578,
0.2106155306,
0.0394895039,
-0.3278920949,
0.148349151,
0.4353365004,
0.6325873733,
0.9642339349,
-0.4666915238,
0.0547604449,
0.1821035445,
-0.0392651334,
0.106061697,
0.3315978646,
-0.0349504389,
-0.1645146012,
0.4355100393,
0.6644727588,
0.2499071956,
-1.0285060406,
0.6166580319,
-0.1699235141,
-0.1263698339,
-0.3501478732,
-0.0561947785,
-0.0377742462,
0.5198764801,
0.4917671084,
0.14757891,
0.3010302186,
-0.5690170527,
0.3289516568,
0.6644852757,
-0.2866493762,
0.0062071756,
0.5772366524,
0.3609589636,
-0.1949939728,
0.4642826915,
-0.2181375474,
-0.2617188394,
0.3399884999,
0.297713846,
0.8226642609,
0.0238961838,
-0.0855924636,
0.1326185167,
0.3286727071,
0.2962027192,
0.0764811188,
-0.2807381749,
-0.7776331306,
-0.368288666,
-1.0014841557,
-0.4910703599,
0.2370305508,
-0.4027624428,
0.1456671655,
-0.3765399158,
-0.4410353899,
-0.0921991691,
-0.2124415487,
-0.6952187419,
0.1441933662,
0.4473178983,
0.8127408028,
-0.4056326449,
0.8168058991,
0.5898966789,
-0.3640091121,
-0.2164782137,
-0.0143642863,
0.2420165837,
-0.9260883331,
0.6971313357,
0.1809183061,
-0.1145602241,
-0.3871206045,
-0.2432156205,
-0.7445031404,
1.1882038116,
0.1830867529,
-0.593474865,
0.2153970599,
-0.0426367335,
0.5145949721,
-0.4376411736,
0.4825243354,
0.478840977,
0.9189224243,
-0.0625704601,
-1.1099337339,
-0.036401961,
-0.6018763781,
-0.0600376017,
-0.2400084287,
-0.5868063569,
0.8793482184,
-0.0506132729,
-0.0589667447,
0.3313697577,
0.4370522201,
0.4531998038,
0.4265082479,
0.8195425272,
0.4609937072,
0.6829563975,
0.0143686775,
1.2746909857,
-0.2028329074,
0.3989010453,
1.0521861315,
-0.6290412545,
0.9611516595,
0.4523079395,
-0.6679853201,
0.1938939989,
0.5223430991,
-0.3547837734,
0.4822858572,
0.4886924028,
-0.2139920145,
-0.3043439686,
-0.2200216502,
-0.2938063145,
0.5337466598,
0.1730240583,
-0.2168072611,
-0.1903920621,
0.0863747895,
-0.3458671868,
0.1517050117,
-0.1552846134,
0.4746721685,
0.0238061231,
-0.4076457024,
0.6572481394,
0.0820166618,
0.8181273341,
-0.6649762988,
0.1098717228,
-0.0916115195,
0.2441377342,
-0.1892639846,
-0.5574080944,
0.0458369851,
0.1115879416,
-0.0329668708,
-0.2688810527,
0.6471964717,
-0.2930613458,
-0.5887938142,
0.3748047948,
0.8091039658,
0.116625227,
-0.2051070184,
-0.9860757589,
0.4215121567,
-0.2602184415,
-0.2517917752,
0.4604348242,
0.0321528539,
0.0349511132,
0.825522244,
0.8139669299,
-0.1508788019,
0.0225691684,
0.7021719217,
0.8182206154,
-0.4312744439,
0.001572106,
-1.0716209412,
0.4479983151,
-0.2303711474,
-0.3498675823,
0.9544121623,
0.7234640121,
0.6234826446,
0.0991420522,
0.8611604571,
-0.0183534697,
0.3747460246,
-0.5258873105,
0.7969070077,
-0.866283536,
0.2838194072,
-0.3120155036,
-0.9235092402,
-0.3441915512,
0.5313584208,
-0.4534817338,
0.332120508,
0.6195573211,
0.6320461631,
0.0332898274,
-0.0896647871,
0.6678268313,
0.2504628301,
0.3048352599,
0.3145979047,
1.1939486265,
-0.0067885877,
0.4783496261,
-0.2366284728,
-0.2696599364,
-0.3836208284,
-0.702242434,
-0.8531164527,
-0.5613089204,
0.1561660767,
-0.0832148939,
0.0732146949,
1.0319719315,
0.7687671781,
-0.7256842256,
-0.560571909,
0.3238065839,
-0.0417315438,
-0.3304602504,
-0.2395171672,
0.1949009001,
-0.5910765529,
-0.7500129938,
0.5868912339,
0.4463756084,
-0.2789907455,
-0.6888826489,
-0.1242012605,
-0.3069444895,
-0.1525822878,
0.822606504,
-0.1900083423,
-1.0961459875,
0.0070300116,
-0.0174547154,
-0.3276482821,
0.0384139344,
0.853302002,
-0.7134715319,
0.4948757589,
0.077661097,
0.7019896507,
0.7301010489,
-0.0009625177,
0.4503015578,
-0.4531336725,
0.0540593304,
0.5556268096,
0.4561050236,
0.3899994791,
0.1786887348,
0.5785697103,
0.2781412899,
-0.352604866,
-0.9292211533,
-0.0087846173,
-1.0122603178,
-0.2340362221,
1.2990729809,
-0.1463143975,
-0.0687063485,
-0.0091933887,
-0.2201878726,
-0.1076836884,
-0.3388459682,
0.6594071388,
0.7414881587,
-0.3117576241,
-0.128548786,
-0.7291737795,
0.172674641,
0.4637213945,
-0.8052597046,
-0.0495318808,
0.536678493,
0.0768825561,
0.0851552039,
0.7818566561,
-0.2481934577,
0.1988948584,
-0.0049959454,
0.0106864655,
-0.1464376748,
-0.0827474445,
-0.0512361899,
0.3907881975,
0.3150676191,
-0.1867833436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13937v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13937v1
|
Exploring Methods for Cross-lingual Text Style Transfer: The Case of Text Detoxification
| 2023-11-23T11:40:28 | 2023-11-23T11:40:28 |
Daryna Dementieva, Daniil Moskovskiy, David Dale, Alexander Panchenko
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text detoxification is the task of transferring the style of text from toxic
to neutral. While here are approaches yielding promising results in monolingual
setup, e.g., (Dale et al., 2021; Hallinan et al., 2022), cross-lingual transfer
for this task remains a challenging open problem (Moskovskiy et al., 2022). In
this work, we present a large-scale study of strategies for cross-lingual text
detoxification -- given a parallel detoxification corpus for one language; the
goal is to transfer detoxification ability to another language for which we do
not have such a corpus. Moreover, we are the first to explore a new task where
text translation and detoxification are performed simultaneously, providing
several strong baselines for this task. Finally, we introduce new automatic
detoxification evaluation metrics with higher correlations with human judgments
than previous benchmarks. We assess the most promising approaches also with
manual markup, determining the answer for the best strategy to transfer the
knowledge of text detoxification between languages.
|
[
-0.2542764544,
-0.6083257198,
0.4900191724,
0.2070398778,
-0.1893084198,
0.2738259435,
-0.2993808985,
-0.5566390157,
0.0861342922,
0.3618912995,
-0.480379045,
-0.6541833878,
-0.4920153022,
0.5460210443,
-0.5398645997,
1.045032382,
-0.2723119557,
-0.0263348836,
0.1519750953,
-0.1011175886,
-0.5955270529,
-0.3836072683,
-0.7472920418,
-0.3838284016,
0.74998945,
0.5237483382,
0.4846226573,
0.2864737213,
0.3973889649,
0.1747387797,
0.1044340432,
-0.1619556397,
-0.5537901521,
-0.160853073,
-0.7291648388,
-0.3613579571,
0.0911496654,
-0.0812096,
0.4749550521,
0.6085727811,
0.3384996653,
-0.1476758569,
-0.1641729623,
0.9291065335,
-0.7739731669,
-0.3297373354,
-0.4603708684,
0.4390214384,
-0.2381738871,
-0.400675416,
-0.6898525357,
-0.2599092722,
0.0998390242,
-0.6177605987,
-0.3993008137,
0.2717458904,
0.7818837762,
0.2107143849,
-0.7678582668,
-0.2133557349,
-0.8387542963,
0.8639939427,
-0.4295021594,
0.5517414212,
0.1289872378,
0.1672149003,
0.3849778771,
-0.669939518,
-0.1660147309,
0.0877407491,
-0.205022946,
0.1954624504,
-0.1858394444,
-0.2189002335,
-0.076665245,
0.1386280507,
-0.6588228345,
0.0956398845,
-0.498409152,
-0.1630481631,
0.6351537704,
-0.0029929178,
1.1032245159,
-0.1751335412,
-0.9108579755,
-0.0782519132,
-0.594013989,
-0.3515121043,
0.2859162688,
0.1669533253,
-0.0442856103,
0.1438349038,
-0.1687104404,
-0.0243876819,
-0.136853233,
0.0551881231,
0.3041193783,
-1.0263795853,
-0.0916121751,
0.4734022319,
0.83431077,
0.5394636989,
0.2969413996,
-0.4630298913,
-0.0583077632,
-0.3615906835,
0.629267633,
-1.0792580843,
-0.3583622575,
0.1321276873,
-0.7002291679,
-0.3631983101,
-0.3370901942,
-1.1452953815,
-0.4530948102,
-0.3712174892,
0.6103532314,
-0.7033172846,
-0.6490544677,
0.2367760539,
-0.4626646638,
0.0370305628,
0.3283461928,
-0.9730120301,
0.3729467094,
0.3517219722,
0.7329617739,
-0.7323845625,
-0.1008074805,
-0.2828672826,
0.1696546227,
-0.4047657549,
0.7767654657,
-0.3788903654,
-0.1792457849,
0.1687019765,
0.0048761372,
-0.2615346313,
-0.4980859458,
0.7449303865,
-0.3888098896,
0.2764440477,
-0.5542369485,
-0.1305880547,
-0.4018194675,
0.0115699256,
-0.6715922952,
0.8729977608,
0.0341909789,
-1.0862408876,
0.2224825174,
-0.5722070336,
-0.676471591,
-0.0316390283,
0.3285524249,
-0.1283995658,
-0.157959789,
-0.0357681662,
-0.0088314554,
-0.2243516296,
-0.2047020495,
-0.1582751125,
-0.4774001837,
-0.0675560683,
-0.3492383361,
1.0864729881,
0.4993712008,
-0.4937260151,
0.2460679412,
-0.4271853864,
0.1057554111,
-0.0373359248,
-0.1535930932,
-1.0073542595,
-0.3492099047,
0.6654140353,
0.3878301084,
0.2827010751,
-0.4519935548,
-0.0229152236,
-0.0269573722,
0.2822352946,
0.4739010334,
0.2808822989,
0.482516408,
-0.5273709297,
0.4110193551,
-0.1520525366,
0.0513309911,
-0.0485010706,
-0.1567757577,
-0.4724649787,
-0.138511911,
0.1529651433,
1.0497575998,
-1.0143625736,
0.3285606802,
-0.3103833199,
-0.5716817975,
-0.2062685937,
0.3748870194,
0.6851451993,
0.3946343958,
0.6540873647,
-0.3811748326,
-0.3373018205,
-0.8609638214,
-0.4974994361,
-0.1919996142,
0.1222664565,
-0.0594075434,
0.5052927136,
-0.2132236958,
0.5424987078,
-0.2327304035,
-0.166826874,
-0.2279157788,
0.5409680009,
-0.2974974513,
0.530823946,
0.7734546661,
-0.8597958088,
-0.8045504093,
0.4841396511,
-0.7454717159,
-0.6644068956,
-0.4431335628,
-0.5485523343,
0.2375929654,
0.8364489675,
-0.0823843554,
0.2836257219,
0.4201807678,
-0.2143922448,
0.816945374,
-0.1600848287,
0.4224800169,
-0.8791057467,
0.4566870332,
0.0446609706,
-0.137575388,
-1.0661221743,
-0.0353619903,
0.1761608869,
0.0248380452,
-0.8293707371,
1.1375074387,
-0.5469620824,
0.4035400152,
-0.0859313309,
0.0766564608,
0.2775499225,
0.5700631738,
0.2239691019,
0.621765852,
0.2769872248,
-0.3415793478,
0.1434006393,
0.1654210836,
0.0004023507,
1.0070279837,
-0.3408036232,
0.0400834419,
-0.0081755053,
0.1784872264,
-1.2122181654,
0.2697951794,
0.6565434933,
0.1045263782,
0.4655741155,
-0.1302767396,
-0.6203445792,
0.0610223971,
-0.2500189245,
0.7658118606,
0.4355910122,
-0.3627432883,
0.1895874441,
0.289247781,
-0.5340755582,
-0.4449286461,
-0.7391197681,
0.4321724474,
-0.7449728251,
-0.399214685,
0.5459026694,
-0.2161980718,
-0.5272200108,
-0.1671932787,
-0.2328658402,
-0.1194143966,
0.1000974178,
-0.2962297797,
0.0789334998,
0.201661706,
0.1516799033,
0.4971296191,
-0.0278901495,
0.1672519594,
-0.1088145822,
0.3428253531,
0.0395019501,
-0.2088377476,
-0.4852156341,
0.7441907525,
0.5226500034,
-0.3083260357,
0.5708585978,
1.0027990341,
-0.3395172358,
-0.1577348113,
-0.3404315114,
0.0846736878,
-0.4406893551,
0.2902022898,
-0.387588948,
-0.2281498015,
0.5067113638,
-0.2883074284,
0.0621830188,
0.2527426779,
0.5869252086,
0.3084204793,
0.7227829099,
0.6906442642,
0.0122690732,
0.8445557952,
0.1916273385,
0.2231428325,
-0.5491770506,
-0.039632678,
-0.5525982976,
-0.4579563737,
-0.4145680666,
-0.3726629317,
0.2965409756,
-0.0009392151,
-0.1192013919,
0.5607056022,
-0.3081718385,
0.3969708979,
0.3024375141,
0.0271887332,
0.5947880149,
0.1016541943,
-0.4887339771,
0.0280999597,
-0.4572707713,
-0.4088402092,
0.751298666,
0.3347199559,
0.6379252076,
-0.0545605533,
0.9839687347,
0.2050926834,
0.7036846876,
-0.6115173101,
0.4625203907,
-0.4487182796,
-0.66614604,
-0.386857897,
-0.5205914378,
-0.6956925392,
0.3460429609,
-0.2210494876,
-0.7878562212,
0.1740516722,
-0.4152926505,
0.1231878474,
0.3883112967,
-0.8844789267,
1.1633576155,
-0.4014037251,
-0.5508637428,
-0.0802473202,
-0.7826643586,
0.3786990047,
-0.5056523681,
0.5637515187,
-0.0231306832,
-0.1151980236,
0.7590733171,
0.047765661,
0.6707826853,
0.1389713287,
-0.7057318687,
0.0201050676,
0.397775948,
0.0483771302,
-0.2246312648,
-0.1813656837,
0.4393334687,
0.4205887616,
-0.2048496157,
-0.5436091423,
0.3868720829,
-0.5147306323,
-0.2303473651,
-0.1523726881,
-0.6841778755,
-0.1429034472,
0.8124340177,
0.3109436631,
0.2282621115,
-0.3941531777,
-0.1786021739,
0.6548880935,
-0.6285792589,
0.3664421737,
0.225332424,
-0.4884633422,
-0.3498364091,
1.0224348307,
-0.0903839618,
0.6293734908,
0.7946767211,
0.3725909591,
-0.3022094369,
-0.4367289245,
-0.7002101541,
0.318798542,
-0.8182322383,
0.2114063203,
-0.4402996302,
-0.2815449536,
-0.4289153814,
-0.3957543075,
-0.2771109045,
-0.2754499316,
-0.278938055,
0.0372840241,
0.2117060572,
0.4752836227,
-0.0867005959,
-0.3349047005,
-1.0683089495,
0.2943230867,
-0.0160148088,
0.047931768,
-0.265822351,
-0.2351219654,
-0.0790112093,
-0.0436950959,
0.0283449851,
-1.1978112459,
0.5586676598,
-0.192573145,
0.57850945,
0.4344041646,
0.4932390451,
0.4639884531,
-0.712534368,
0.4642921388,
0.2809765935,
-0.8634414077,
0.3005653918,
-0.3922777772,
0.3396008611,
1.0167293549,
0.7166700363,
-1.3220083714,
-0.5916668177,
-0.0542621836,
-0.8544630408,
0.3852694929,
0.2278518081,
0.1825597882,
0.0907817259,
-0.0019431444,
0.3787637651,
-0.0267865229,
-0.3839023113,
-0.0772219375,
-0.1314285994,
-0.2862192988,
0.163840279,
0.1434931606,
-0.3686491847,
-0.1193086877,
0.4722717404,
-0.0020906543,
-0.0171739943,
0.186939314,
-0.3280570805,
-0.1362684965,
0.5313188434,
0.4005869329,
0.4322890043,
-0.1878592223,
0.3892908394,
0.0873826519,
-0.5014203191,
0.230561763,
0.0140683874,
-0.3000428379,
-0.0015517164,
0.0983106568,
0.5568141937,
0.3391166329,
-0.7404814959,
0.2806981504,
-0.1088936329,
-0.2203447968,
0.1222753227,
-0.1306100041,
-0.0394185372,
-0.3030918539,
0.2359710634,
-0.1448847204,
0.331118077,
-0.6900987029,
0.2682998776,
0.3788239062,
-0.4819467664,
-0.2174393237,
0.6799225211,
0.6024731398,
-0.1338631213,
0.3197287619,
-0.1510434747,
-0.5545194745,
0.4919272363,
0.6322035789,
1.0549325943,
-0.1210335121,
0.265053302,
0.4853679836,
0.3804190755,
0.119256258,
-0.1130110249,
-0.0846391395,
-0.6224381924,
-0.1453159451,
-0.5863992572,
-0.2944451571,
-0.1509038508,
-0.5049022436,
0.2552814782,
-0.149387598,
0.3525775671,
-0.0190644041,
0.1343918145,
-0.4395754933,
-0.1314936429,
0.3671082258,
1.0891551971,
-1.2420431376,
0.4975274503,
0.7828344107,
-0.4076195061,
-0.2404609174,
0.2863588035,
0.4482857287,
-0.3303242028,
0.7351809144,
0.3894216716,
-0.3186386228,
-0.0330887809,
0.0247248653,
-0.7490979433,
0.7429458499,
0.0958338305,
-0.2853977382,
-0.1754970104,
0.0572454482,
0.6633118987,
0.2402706593,
0.2433837205,
0.5515992641,
0.8431012034,
0.0640588552,
-1.181868434,
0.5547901988,
-0.5815309286,
0.0423140414,
0.1669866294,
-0.7031956315,
0.4115742743,
0.0598618798,
-0.5744435191,
0.0835046396,
0.4076326787,
-0.3771566153,
0.2741514742,
0.6423287988,
0.6383547783,
0.6066023707,
0.3485465646,
0.8334075212,
-0.3099041581,
0.0768515542,
0.6837144494,
-0.4917405248,
0.6331810951,
0.4858919382,
0.0882884264,
0.6490556002,
0.4276434481,
0.3188069761,
0.6337983012,
0.1549762785,
-0.3996137083,
-0.083409965,
-0.295140475,
-0.3060386479,
0.2188286632,
0.2736343145,
-0.3186556697,
-0.5528545976,
0.2682404816,
0.5144650936,
0.0549751148,
-0.1329197139,
0.6821557879,
0.0303303543,
-0.7763571143,
0.6576673388,
0.0226788428,
0.6189160347,
-0.3683260679,
-0.056959074,
-0.3043350279,
0.0718703866,
-0.2401164621,
-0.6978235841,
0.5880992413,
-0.2719717324,
0.1017815247,
-1.0390512943,
1.0792218447,
-0.7356310487,
-0.2919814587,
0.502099216,
0.6169839501,
0.3322108388,
0.0542876981,
-0.5924606919,
0.0208969433,
-0.1836114377,
0.0205548443,
0.5920240283,
0.665576458,
-0.3069489598,
0.4132719934,
0.5790062547,
0.0468637273,
0.0425033756,
0.1040651575,
0.5703217387,
-0.4015763998,
-0.3215333223,
-0.625837326,
0.2830878198,
0.1530577838,
-0.2766856253,
0.8656259179,
0.5215107203,
0.9013294578,
0.052009508,
0.8501234055,
0.0470834039,
0.1163936108,
-0.6369096637,
1.0874555111,
-0.8637132049,
-0.1805256456,
-0.6624693274,
-0.6589785218,
-0.3423635066,
0.361002773,
-0.2675125599,
-0.0644343197,
1.2347354889,
0.6167920828,
0.0753186643,
-0.0068145166,
0.1328576505,
0.0416767746,
0.2307344973,
0.7335734963,
0.4950937331,
-0.1769766062,
0.7562705278,
-0.4657385051,
-0.3949269652,
-0.306039542,
-1.0738277435,
-0.7588378191,
-0.661370635,
-0.514508307,
-0.2377048433,
0.1958491206,
0.6353870034,
0.5887337327,
-0.5016881227,
-0.142591238,
0.0547854118,
0.3999748826,
-0.6653469205,
-0.2856505215,
0.1551647186,
-0.4987415075,
-1.0565741062,
0.2024697065,
0.3190703988,
-0.2548140883,
-0.3585151732,
0.3505128622,
-0.4380632341,
0.1193743423,
0.5201017261,
0.359680444,
-0.3308336139,
-0.5842436552,
-0.1415896416,
-0.4839817882,
0.0408173949,
0.787474215,
-0.3185395002,
0.3896668255,
1.0422466993,
0.8719289303,
0.3487124443,
0.092249006,
0.4501284957,
-0.6893901229,
-0.1842303425,
-0.0067363484,
0.0567777567,
0.3412458301,
-0.3072844148,
0.5503504872,
0.334572643,
-0.3396706879,
-0.7662729025,
0.1769460291,
-1.0446180105,
-0.6491570473,
1.6027799845,
-0.0235087126,
-0.2628203332,
-0.3741571903,
-0.4926538169,
0.3371755481,
-0.0771655291,
0.7490071654,
1.0355410576,
-0.0675486401,
-0.1666937768,
-0.7236028314,
0.3796422184,
0.4233007133,
-1.4871987104,
0.1924070716,
0.318843931,
0.6401253343,
0.6026720405,
0.7414987087,
-0.3136073053,
0.1726075858,
-0.0131935747,
0.1928013861,
0.2353612036,
-0.6037234664,
-0.1119615138,
-0.1020058393,
-0.657559216,
0.1425937116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13921v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13921v1
|
Some Like It Small: Czech Semantic Embedding Models for Industry Applications
| 2023-11-23T11:14:13 | 2023-11-23T11:14:13 |
Jiří Bednář, Jakub Náplava, Petra Barančíková, Ondřej Lisický
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
This article focuses on the development and evaluation of Small-sized Czech
sentence embedding models. Small models are important components for real-time
industry applications in resource-constrained environments. Given the limited
availability of labeled Czech data, alternative approaches, including
pre-training, knowledge distillation, and unsupervised contrastive fine-tuning,
are investigated. Comprehensive intrinsic and extrinsic analyses are conducted,
showcasing the competitive performance of our models compared to significantly
larger counterparts, with approximately 8 times smaller size and 5 times faster
speed than conventional Base-sized models. To promote cooperation and
reproducibility, both the models and the evaluation pipeline are made publicly
accessible. Ultimately, this article presents practical applications of the
developed sentence embedding models in Seznam.cz, the Czech search engine.
These models have effectively replaced previous counterparts, enhancing the
overall search experience for instance, in organic search, featured snippets,
and image search. This transition has yielded improved performance.
|
[
-0.2576808631,
-0.9710946083,
1.0238751173,
0.0398942716,
-0.5058032274,
-0.3207522035,
-0.5346813202,
-0.5198174715,
0.2733960748,
0.5483666658,
-0.7901611328,
-0.7742911577,
-0.2742459178,
0.1842531562,
-0.2146088034,
0.4640955031,
-0.0321044326,
0.3336194158,
-0.2525560856,
-0.0050003896,
-0.5760601759,
-0.3856144249,
-0.1599144489,
0.0377626717,
0.3357456326,
0.6269289255,
0.7939562201,
0.6963723302,
0.3281558752,
0.2980409563,
0.0070063868,
-0.3005132675,
-0.4319941998,
0.2051958591,
-0.3753177524,
-0.5285211205,
0.0489353649,
0.0997035876,
0.4351270497,
0.670973897,
-0.2197052836,
0.3278588057,
-0.1057004929,
0.3074116707,
-0.6304878592,
0.3327684402,
-0.8001080155,
0.2157878578,
0.049419634,
0.379891634,
-0.4572114944,
-0.5216742754,
0.2803995907,
-0.6361654401,
0.218715325,
0.6056916118,
0.6927620173,
0.1946289986,
-0.3610110581,
-0.5103699565,
-0.6750468612,
1.0423064232,
-0.8084217906,
0.2353414148,
0.0884369239,
0.5648032427,
-0.0712630525,
-0.9253849983,
-0.5346927047,
-0.2362249643,
-0.1721749902,
-0.091071263,
-0.4783219993,
0.1171925217,
-0.1011255831,
0.2295236439,
-0.5324285626,
0.2040232569,
-0.3206576407,
-0.0790988132,
0.3219102025,
0.57280159,
0.3799156547,
-0.2139637768,
-0.0964970291,
0.0410218537,
-0.8920775056,
-0.3091712594,
0.2977923751,
0.6899157763,
0.2772370875,
0.9919590354,
-0.6429328322,
0.8707504869,
-0.0809608549,
0.3609546423,
-0.0753696859,
-0.588609755,
-0.4337184727,
0.0838765129,
0.4155336916,
0.1720706224,
-0.1293180585,
-0.2046052217,
0.0280564725,
0.3520037532,
0.4379205704,
-0.939181447,
-0.4223830998,
-0.0890234336,
-0.783888936,
-0.2807214856,
-0.0369697139,
-0.5035341382,
-0.0894223154,
-0.2107038796,
0.9120666981,
-0.124259457,
0.2623499632,
0.3372645378,
-0.3663617671,
0.066772446,
0.2311704606,
-0.7318220139,
0.2198636085,
0.791007638,
0.7579318285,
0.1494455934,
-0.0021980291,
-0.1699400842,
-0.0373257138,
-0.4001865089,
0.9008994102,
-0.7514307499,
-0.2866369188,
0.0897662938,
0.2918608189,
-0.1672851443,
-0.6789262891,
0.4069723189,
-0.5889202952,
-0.0950403288,
-0.1225347817,
-0.5167004466,
-0.131987378,
0.3124027848,
-0.810287416,
0.7805348039,
0.3155926466,
-0.7258624434,
0.6027373075,
-0.456082195,
-0.0595381372,
-0.0583359227,
-0.4183127582,
-0.37580809,
0.419072926,
-0.1567851454,
0.4204426408,
-0.3387629092,
-0.5708691478,
-0.67206949,
-0.5131581426,
0.0327944867,
0.1781108379,
0.6642929316,
0.3523656726,
-0.0905635729,
0.0648309439,
-0.5099025369,
0.3114218414,
0.0546179526,
-0.1247565672,
-0.8062090874,
-0.248990953,
0.1822272092,
0.5035252571,
0.3618084192,
-0.936307013,
0.2683848143,
-0.5749386549,
0.5855896473,
0.3805607855,
0.1913040876,
0.6076444983,
-0.0399756767,
0.6677004099,
-0.0248129014,
0.4811115563,
0.29132092,
-0.3894858956,
-0.6968508363,
-0.3968859315,
0.6511116624,
0.1187507883,
-0.8918688297,
0.385981977,
-0.4625485241,
-0.7412068844,
-0.9569180608,
0.3196154535,
0.1136741117,
0.0134221772,
0.1143643633,
-0.2537034452,
-0.5525701046,
-1.2983874083,
-0.4165422618,
0.2118244022,
-0.3802571297,
0.5185220242,
0.5237458944,
-0.3459703028,
1.0985058546,
-0.6451505423,
-0.4386796057,
-0.4126433134,
0.0741979331,
0.0711535364,
0.3515953422,
0.6114451289,
-0.7493932843,
-0.7480250597,
-0.0334090889,
-0.495799005,
0.2316775471,
0.365267545,
-0.1853953302,
0.1572197527,
0.2759107947,
-0.5285845995,
0.6348682642,
0.6043701768,
-0.5563110709,
0.3308799565,
-0.249380514,
0.0157182571,
-0.7533648014,
-0.3170561492,
-0.1093084887,
-0.3407415748,
-0.0600383207,
0.1637340933,
-0.0629088134,
-0.3435301185,
-0.786914885,
0.2642214298,
-0.5219649076,
-0.4540144503,
-0.1916365325,
0.4615148008,
0.2733589709,
0.2308529913,
-0.0616109818,
0.7200325131,
0.1318374425,
-0.5056723952,
0.3043316603,
0.4335482419,
-0.8909643292,
0.2739775777,
-0.5555484295,
0.0447349548,
0.3423012495,
0.1245858073,
-0.7856946588,
-0.0116415946,
-0.0307927094,
-0.1247482374,
-0.182481572,
-0.4892181158,
-0.9780234098,
-0.425732106,
-0.5902420282,
0.1947633773,
0.5229991078,
-0.6191921234,
0.4348729253,
0.41087237,
-0.3199534714,
-0.0225503407,
-0.9380588531,
-0.0244275667,
-0.2685295045,
-0.9148331285,
0.3784555197,
-0.0180064831,
-0.2464332879,
0.7081664205,
-0.111445874,
-0.3703212142,
0.0893913433,
0.0073992526,
0.3131165206,
-0.3931049705,
0.0259584971,
0.1268240362,
-0.0032291526,
-0.2379906029,
-0.3735868037,
0.3089863956,
-0.1756512076,
-0.0968750045,
-0.2616996467,
0.3468229175,
0.0531106852,
0.3648858666,
1.1479090452,
0.5466392636,
-0.4352009594,
-0.5081157684,
-0.2586355507,
-0.261731118,
-0.5058084726,
0.2743159533,
-0.2123413235,
-1.146664381,
0.4657063186,
-0.3482738137,
-0.4214155078,
0.6196707487,
0.6401765943,
-0.1088829339,
1.2171235085,
1.2066549063,
0.4011407793,
0.5475201607,
-0.371635288,
0.5987580419,
-0.6207873225,
-0.0989635512,
-0.714150548,
-0.0660945848,
-0.9225546718,
-0.5256892443,
0.3848300874,
-0.0133843618,
-0.0142606208,
0.7090637684,
-0.5154505968,
0.4553521574,
0.3983575404,
0.1798958778,
0.2545434237,
-0.1612285972,
-0.3472644985,
-0.2883141041,
-1.0872848034,
-0.8022068739,
0.713133812,
-0.011811926,
0.9881668687,
0.0335009806,
0.4693298936,
0.4915002882,
-0.0347259976,
-0.9882284999,
0.299813509,
-0.4734336436,
-0.8715291619,
-0.5489758253,
-0.1646013558,
-0.7848812938,
0.2136259228,
-0.3751537502,
-0.761464417,
0.3609209359,
0.0836841315,
-0.5183427334,
0.1044541001,
-0.8305199742,
1.2759525776,
0.2162822634,
-0.3412572742,
-0.5554383993,
-0.1378902793,
0.0340810493,
-0.0138717741,
0.2329425663,
0.0014760429,
-0.0047387662,
0.6799634099,
-0.528835535,
0.8932439089,
-0.0610066243,
0.2992480993,
0.6142876148,
0.0886421874,
0.4940949082,
-0.1195114926,
-0.2283339351,
0.047091011,
0.4188770056,
-0.384909898,
-0.8378475904,
1.0146200657,
-0.3623534739,
-0.3200866282,
-0.0181692019,
0.1567480266,
-0.105963774,
0.3055959642,
0.3264611065,
0.1354117543,
-0.5368483067,
0.6800289154,
0.4487868249,
-0.2609583437,
0.2798841596,
0.5455992222,
0.0706610009,
-0.0537400283,
0.661088109,
0.35744524,
-0.2206481844,
0.2276445925,
0.1599119008,
-0.2360122055,
-0.3037667871,
-0.5761963129,
0.0395849161,
-0.7846021056,
-0.3083632588,
-0.6150323749,
0.0431311205,
-0.5396159291,
-0.335521698,
-0.7290040255,
-0.8680368066,
-0.1773518175,
-0.2401822954,
0.3220916092,
1.1047620773,
0.0837501884,
0.5325111151,
-0.6072143912,
-0.0619082302,
0.3786718845,
0.5743765235,
0.0754907429,
-0.1960312575,
-1.0463021994,
-0.129229337,
-0.2453423887,
-0.6551192999,
0.4180516899,
-0.1061902419,
0.6069835424,
0.1009878889,
0.3084860146,
0.2101427764,
-0.6322030425,
0.9996510744,
-0.08444722,
-0.8852110505,
0.5492123365,
-0.2649223208,
-0.133237049,
0.8707669377,
0.2855999172,
-0.2133107334,
-0.0089855008,
-0.6390553117,
-1.0407247543,
0.6432729363,
0.332084924,
0.1989505291,
-0.0330960788,
0.3231190741,
0.2270170152,
0.3113676608,
-0.3866871595,
0.036978215,
0.0649190396,
-0.4963974655,
0.1759500057,
-0.5119184852,
-0.0254288185,
-0.0045335772,
0.7505539656,
0.2064927071,
0.5381759405,
0.0067407526,
-0.52868855,
0.1498867422,
0.4102651477,
0.2344920486,
0.4684399366,
-0.2724120021,
-0.0626867637,
0.2499015033,
-0.1437038034,
-0.0388047621,
-0.2758524418,
-0.1116971001,
0.2030419409,
-0.0453823581,
0.6681854725,
0.5769014955,
-0.601665318,
0.7581819296,
-0.3265244067,
0.0943894237,
-0.4628825188,
0.1516174376,
0.1249228492,
0.4650193751,
0.0193618275,
-0.4528490603,
0.6888868213,
-0.7025728822,
0.1602751762,
0.2958990037,
-0.5529271364,
-0.241239965,
0.3501930535,
0.1448456198,
-0.2683061957,
0.5192061067,
0.001258907,
-0.4383618534,
0.6299063563,
0.4340818226,
0.8264073133,
0.3767584264,
0.140384838,
0.1038799807,
0.3823184073,
-0.2176910192,
0.083126083,
-0.1850878745,
-0.5560510159,
-0.1166302934,
-0.5020977855,
-0.6069745421,
-0.2508585453,
-0.8563030362,
0.4425705969,
-0.5640878677,
-0.354451865,
0.0638272241,
0.3695736229,
-1.1762877703,
0.2498961687,
-0.1977359205,
1.0366197824,
-1.030053854,
0.836648941,
0.7763499618,
-0.5626499057,
-0.4934335649,
-0.3046690226,
-0.1990414858,
-0.4616403878,
0.5370317101,
0.0766455308,
-0.1889133304,
-0.1721201241,
-0.6706859469,
-0.781175077,
1.1671421528,
0.2168804109,
-0.5475613475,
-0.097322315,
-0.2126641572,
0.6440073252,
-0.8229328394,
-0.10454759,
0.6837615967,
0.4393827021,
-0.4687487483,
-0.6614704728,
0.1159214675,
-0.020531524,
0.3392776251,
-0.2513676584,
-0.7710914016,
0.666187346,
0.1715082228,
-0.2448039949,
0.3331975937,
0.3133577704,
0.115686655,
0.4588224888,
0.4326058626,
0.3550788164,
0.2722618878,
0.2030823231,
0.9414829612,
-0.2344509512,
0.5453953147,
1.2619820833,
-0.177254051,
1.1594837904,
0.395329386,
-0.0317898057,
0.8012975454,
0.6832745075,
-0.2043973356,
0.8719159961,
0.176381126,
-0.1230323389,
-0.3814874291,
-0.1054265797,
-0.1470833421,
0.5539744496,
0.3730842471,
-0.5158542395,
-0.1477084309,
0.1770607084,
-0.2304091156,
0.274125576,
-0.0852074772,
0.7904889584,
0.1463374048,
0.0258826595,
-0.096747756,
0.406070441,
0.7549575567,
-0.2798033357,
-0.0121021559,
0.071048528,
0.1186327785,
0.0634685457,
-0.4515592456,
0.4588641822,
0.0327876024,
-0.3464898765,
-0.0071983403,
0.89441365,
-0.2633305192,
-0.5433157682,
0.501516521,
0.3182728589,
0.0897177309,
0.106676437,
-0.5911268592,
0.1491467953,
-0.2019366622,
-0.3210245669,
0.4519182146,
0.7766411304,
-0.0448173471,
0.4188944399,
0.1651377082,
0.1832054853,
0.0969398543,
-0.1406877637,
0.942168355,
-0.8677911162,
-0.8831971884,
-0.5038691163,
0.0878208056,
-0.0200639945,
0.2360411435,
1.054166913,
0.654892385,
1.1333309412,
-0.4274185896,
0.7336173058,
0.0457687192,
0.4414494634,
-0.6945434213,
0.8906315565,
-0.5436767936,
0.1389861256,
-0.1754229367,
-0.9449906945,
-0.0441975556,
0.8536846638,
-0.4741311073,
-0.000574732,
0.5779577494,
0.7099843621,
-0.2626344264,
-0.0178801585,
0.7007145286,
0.3228037655,
-0.079407759,
0.213703841,
0.8145042062,
-0.4621266127,
0.5554355979,
-0.4965494573,
0.1639160365,
-0.7127440572,
-0.9192379117,
-0.6559500098,
-0.419834286,
-0.3066227734,
-0.1812615246,
0.0891346708,
0.9313513637,
0.8646525741,
-0.6402170658,
0.1197912991,
0.1489676088,
0.0770321935,
0.0923619494,
-0.2111356407,
0.2359000742,
-0.0619633421,
-0.4790083766,
0.4403791428,
0.1822565794,
-0.033001747,
-0.197707057,
0.3562033772,
0.0360895842,
0.4583452344,
0.66672647,
0.0225751065,
-0.6165673733,
-0.6132195592,
-0.0540810451,
-0.0815925896,
-0.217149362,
1.0204308033,
-0.7580404878,
0.3858807683,
0.5791833997,
0.3345300555,
0.7138651013,
-0.0553315319,
0.5319988728,
-0.7061223984,
0.47409904,
0.1480416656,
0.3815381229,
0.3646566868,
-0.6122850776,
0.553755343,
-0.0378632396,
-0.4053178728,
-0.7326466441,
-0.0003327394,
-0.7630830407,
-0.5778667331,
0.9006937146,
-0.3343001306,
-0.6116557717,
-0.0232891683,
0.0307194293,
0.316165477,
-0.2815348208,
0.8731675744,
0.7651648521,
-0.1358605474,
0.3804799318,
-0.6834817529,
0.4606347084,
0.1838673204,
-0.3431482315,
0.1024803296,
0.6377542019,
0.6116999388,
-0.0586128533,
0.3532276452,
-0.2183832973,
0.1892918199,
0.4088448286,
0.015177154,
-0.0184364282,
-0.4458392859,
-0.6350877285,
-0.0543040819,
0.2667065859,
-0.3153654337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13910v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13910v1
|
Dialogue Quality and Emotion Annotations for Customer Support Conversations
| 2023-11-23T10:56:14 | 2023-11-23T10:56:14 |
John Mendonça, Patrícia Pereira, Miguel Menezes, Vera Cabarrão, Ana C. Farinha, Helena Moniz, João Paulo Carvalho, Alon Lavie, Isabel Trancoso
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Task-oriented conversational datasets often lack topic variability and
linguistic diversity. However, with the advent of Large Language Models (LLMs)
pretrained on extensive, multilingual and diverse text data, these limitations
seem overcome. Nevertheless, their generalisability to different languages and
domains in dialogue applications remains uncertain without benchmarking
datasets. This paper presents a holistic annotation approach for emotion and
conversational quality in the context of bilingual customer support
conversations. By performing annotations that take into consideration the
complete instances that compose a conversation, one can form a broader
perspective of the dialogue as a whole. Furthermore, it provides a unique and
valuable resource for the development of text classification models. To this
end, we present benchmarks for Emotion Recognition and Dialogue Quality
Estimation and show that further research is needed to leverage these models in
a production setting.
|
[
-0.4571765661,
-0.4089257121,
0.3029691875,
0.3559677601,
-0.1848247051,
0.3001140654,
-0.1696568429,
-0.6514175534,
0.4453406036,
0.7256537676,
-0.6601842046,
-0.5864225626,
-0.4440060556,
0.2325154096,
0.0709452629,
1.0526674986,
-0.2398777455,
0.1800089777,
-0.2715912461,
-0.6170358062,
-0.2628266811,
-0.8925674558,
-0.4641906917,
-0.3292942643,
0.4770692587,
0.4252476394,
0.565146625,
-0.1365700513,
0.2943689227,
0.3244213462,
-0.198238641,
0.2770086527,
-0.2710095644,
0.7630130649,
0.1157676429,
-0.4215550423,
-0.462874651,
-0.2429422885,
0.2980100811,
0.7381472588,
-0.1243043691,
-0.0372820571,
0.0954234749,
0.2907399237,
-0.4188598096,
0.3479172587,
-0.298397243,
0.3290632069,
0.1583141387,
0.09773238,
-0.2219929844,
-0.5506316423,
0.419682771,
-0.5056259632,
-0.1266096383,
-0.0504472218,
0.8771975636,
0.2011324167,
-0.4615857303,
-0.2404794842,
-0.661532104,
0.7039840221,
-0.7612490654,
0.2492976487,
0.4401676357,
0.2885164022,
0.1032301486,
-0.2375123501,
-0.3614604473,
-0.0018584514,
-0.0839762092,
0.3404477239,
-0.1331740618,
0.1025630683,
0.2874296606,
0.4624903798,
-0.1786612719,
0.2780508697,
0.1395851076,
-0.3713712692,
0.6006267667,
0.4038781822,
0.2642041445,
-0.1420909911,
-0.1111842096,
-0.0957577601,
-0.3379772305,
0.2342762202,
0.5812133551,
0.2122995704,
-0.1581120938,
0.3201039135,
-0.3564676642,
0.2474475503,
-0.3532733321,
-0.1774583906,
0.3981912136,
-0.1071898267,
-0.3168626726,
-0.1869199276,
0.8635281324,
0.5075167418,
0.2873337865,
-0.1257391274,
-0.1611852497,
-0.0291917101,
0.1912110001,
-0.6623570323,
0.0412070677,
0.2600577176,
-0.1672662795,
0.0916438028,
-0.1228558794,
-1.1212463379,
-0.5107385516,
-0.5295698047,
-0.1582431495,
-0.0126126641,
-0.3991149366,
-0.1980633587,
0.1500020176,
-0.005656851,
0.4093345404,
-0.8502573371,
0.3184305727,
0.582229197,
0.5501961112,
-0.1284703016,
0.035798531,
-0.4208878577,
-0.1595831513,
-0.2947023213,
0.7090533972,
-0.4970729649,
-0.4651356936,
0.5703958869,
0.1987243742,
0.1715668142,
-0.6390952468,
0.9089952111,
-0.2484624535,
0.2845550776,
-0.323907584,
-0.3382212222,
-0.2696993947,
0.5395435691,
-0.5135322809,
0.9325877428,
0.3722700179,
-0.5968019366,
0.2222969383,
-0.3466080725,
-0.5198405981,
0.24523215,
0.0911018327,
-0.4011460543,
0.3296411335,
0.0169088598,
0.452108115,
-0.2727974653,
0.249069199,
-0.488887012,
0.0338017046,
0.4591518641,
-0.1669373214,
0.3088580668,
0.1880484223,
-0.2527672648,
-0.0671491995,
-0.6833946705,
-0.1175718531,
-0.2268221378,
-0.3109530807,
-0.2324987203,
-0.1018610969,
0.3180820644,
0.4207698703,
0.1286187619,
-0.6725336909,
0.0467924587,
-0.4488544464,
0.2207439393,
0.4144857824,
0.0183375143,
0.1930691302,
0.1599441171,
0.5996965766,
0.2349521667,
0.2013819218,
-0.411239177,
-0.5812587142,
-1.0902918577,
-0.18474406,
-0.0147620384,
0.740717113,
-0.5890607238,
0.3670811653,
-0.0812258944,
-0.3196230829,
-0.617728591,
0.2179737985,
0.3823199272,
0.3613970578,
0.1925818175,
-0.5275404453,
-0.5496299267,
-0.9917622805,
-0.1179509461,
-0.3656976223,
-0.0983700156,
0.4545302987,
0.0938489214,
-0.4635226429,
0.9233585596,
-0.2959659398,
-0.2787953615,
-0.2160703689,
0.6633660793,
0.0019633542,
0.244420141,
0.284347564,
-0.7056664228,
-0.5725340843,
0.2970790565,
-0.7737470269,
-0.4417103827,
0.0237347912,
-0.2327745557,
0.6725830436,
0.057643503,
-0.4547097385,
0.62521559,
0.6806437373,
-0.0574023277,
0.3150007725,
-0.0939018577,
0.4998267293,
-1.125877738,
-0.1909724772,
0.3768269718,
-0.3074442148,
-0.9485951662,
-0.6753025651,
-0.1526198536,
-0.1722500473,
-0.4012444615,
0.3788637817,
-0.1484914124,
-0.2885136902,
-0.1696665883,
0.1067481861,
0.2845145166,
0.7196602821,
0.4529341757,
0.5145333409,
0.3327231109,
-0.280279547,
0.6286908388,
0.6383721828,
-0.352763772,
1.0979239941,
-0.5468398929,
-0.0882020369,
0.032642737,
0.2660936117,
-1.0951726437,
-0.4928659797,
0.2519509792,
-0.0980401188,
0.0856972039,
-0.1652891338,
-0.5904682279,
-0.1643573791,
0.2180667073,
0.1485305578,
0.633502543,
-0.3644454479,
0.7015932798,
0.5233343244,
-0.7162356377,
-0.1356544644,
-0.6958192587,
0.318223089,
-0.3646061718,
-0.5904060602,
0.0259360503,
0.0094194422,
-0.3194621503,
-0.5181510448,
0.073606208,
-0.4105725288,
0.080076918,
0.6846913099,
0.0918848366,
-0.0079214536,
0.2983987331,
0.0456392914,
-0.0577527694,
0.102941364,
0.1440092474,
0.3845230043,
-0.135095343,
-0.494512558,
-0.6578022242,
0.7158298492,
0.6200495362,
-0.1985493451,
0.5156282187,
0.7136588693,
-0.3400356472,
0.1021853536,
-0.9563820362,
0.0951270685,
-0.3919769824,
0.2395499349,
-0.2501463592,
-0.9799665809,
0.8638888597,
-0.1470399946,
0.0665105507,
0.4236621857,
0.5413050056,
-0.2234824598,
1.1102669239,
0.4365481138,
-0.0708742812,
0.5056760311,
0.2116866708,
0.3724181056,
-0.7356953025,
-0.4585804641,
-0.7987186313,
-0.1373555958,
-0.3142907023,
-0.1678718328,
0.2915102839,
0.033655256,
-0.15631859,
0.1957215071,
-0.2023158371,
0.0855892152,
0.2896648347,
-0.0699637458,
0.1302186847,
0.1736719906,
0.0782843605,
-0.431540519,
-0.2012999952,
-0.7498511076,
0.3724232018,
0.6648519039,
0.6970492601,
0.1109324843,
0.5488151908,
-0.0145432884,
0.5607278943,
-0.5537155271,
0.3002838194,
0.0240145642,
-0.3661080003,
-0.1042439863,
-0.4163145125,
-0.6413508654,
0.0284306258,
-0.1380194277,
-1.2420266867,
0.2626499534,
0.0004893176,
-0.3242971301,
0.0770947561,
-0.7879086733,
1.019338727,
-0.3764107227,
-0.2858180404,
0.0241128355,
-0.4567611516,
0.1733105183,
-0.0971286073,
0.1856636405,
-0.4872581363,
0.219802171,
0.7274900675,
-0.454964608,
1.1047577858,
-0.1229726598,
-0.2155885249,
0.3586578369,
0.1458079964,
0.3498154879,
-0.0205200128,
-0.0849018991,
0.2743407488,
-0.0353130475,
-0.2918723524,
-0.589134872,
0.4326568544,
-0.6937133074,
-0.5183442831,
-0.0989713222,
-0.5451754332,
-0.7257598639,
-0.3127124012,
-0.029890243,
0.2679490447,
-0.2225385159,
-0.0545085818,
0.5399727225,
-0.4619578123,
0.4625800252,
0.3236682117,
-0.0437067635,
-0.5828322172,
0.7037831545,
-0.089842394,
0.4227283597,
0.0753846467,
-0.1204247847,
-0.5198867321,
-0.1100267172,
-0.3578341007,
0.1181439161,
-1.0418721437,
-0.2770836651,
-0.9807079434,
0.0607001185,
-0.4500414431,
0.0441265628,
-0.2471747845,
-0.2106276006,
-0.4415761828,
-0.1959716976,
0.5091504455,
0.6736243963,
0.2680648863,
0.4554536343,
-0.9879615307,
0.0561482124,
0.3386582732,
0.4785897434,
-0.1202841699,
-0.3976151347,
-0.4016361833,
0.15875265,
-0.4635621607,
-0.9518976212,
0.7035391927,
0.1471719593,
0.6407997608,
0.3097043037,
0.061658904,
0.5333961248,
-0.151279211,
1.0976994038,
0.4615347981,
-1.2207700014,
0.6724761724,
-0.2406194955,
0.1797547489,
0.6501395702,
0.543593049,
-0.8733451366,
-0.4492654502,
-0.5113528371,
-0.7906194329,
0.7738519907,
0.0037196605,
0.3482518196,
-0.0067731817,
0.0669486374,
0.1417932808,
0.3312305808,
-0.6433497071,
0.0955787227,
-0.3115867078,
-0.4380670786,
-0.1301748455,
-0.4523648918,
-0.1381029338,
-0.0115278335,
0.5567237139,
-0.2727662027,
0.0967065096,
0.119188793,
-0.0440639257,
-0.2708863318,
0.4719519317,
0.4096567333,
0.3328345418,
-0.1044154614,
-0.1329256743,
0.437905401,
0.0641027912,
0.1750100404,
-0.0999995023,
0.4276127219,
0.3616479933,
0.1180716828,
1.1052969694,
0.3297067583,
-0.8350058198,
0.4767466187,
-0.0394909009,
0.0351045839,
-0.174686417,
-0.1341348141,
0.1398569196,
0.4375968277,
0.1246741563,
-0.4021980166,
0.1984503865,
-0.5826650858,
-0.0579660498,
0.3014380634,
-0.8614376187,
-0.2789107263,
0.0973618552,
0.5281143785,
-0.5964307785,
0.582899332,
-0.0574714504,
-0.949123323,
0.464600265,
0.1108992249,
1.1317615509,
-0.3841925263,
0.3595002294,
0.269246012,
-0.2478825152,
-0.1883171052,
0.1152220443,
-0.0682389662,
-0.5305998921,
-0.3001977503,
-0.7335398793,
-1.0368436575,
-0.3385487199,
-0.7726659775,
0.1365205795,
-0.2544595599,
-0.3400301635,
-0.1154583618,
-0.0766156912,
-0.7691937685,
0.3843224645,
0.542583704,
0.5659544468,
-0.9532931447,
0.6146577001,
0.6216398478,
-0.3704245389,
-0.4976722598,
-0.2552905083,
-0.1367221624,
-0.4485761821,
1.0209774971,
0.2643697858,
0.1366716772,
-0.6167036295,
-0.1466165632,
-0.2802612185,
0.7041679025,
0.2422875464,
-0.6053890586,
0.2818577886,
0.7510538101,
1.0272964239,
-0.768430829,
0.7080793381,
0.6333711743,
0.3648809195,
0.1198015362,
-0.8635023832,
-0.4356651008,
-0.2982634604,
0.088759616,
0.0600754991,
-0.5193958879,
0.5394660234,
0.539414525,
-0.0784435049,
0.0345675386,
0.459872812,
-0.0330824703,
0.4993470907,
0.587405324,
0.4636884332,
0.5660104752,
-0.5386432409,
0.9035646319,
-0.2847102284,
0.2958653867,
0.9045256972,
-0.6543105841,
0.7994733453,
0.3410777748,
-0.1701897085,
0.5164019465,
0.8297676444,
0.1763526052,
0.1194518581,
0.2069137841,
-0.357845962,
-0.4712529182,
-0.7514234781,
-0.0660470948,
0.1024661586,
0.5756003857,
-0.2511458993,
-0.0919718668,
0.1283876598,
0.042460002,
-0.1254511178,
-0.104754813,
1.137637496,
0.1652662903,
-0.8943140507,
0.4472006261,
-0.3512161076,
0.5411038995,
-0.3815509975,
0.1422397643,
-0.6674208641,
-0.1643404216,
-0.3582468927,
-0.7892866731,
0.4451099336,
0.3878680766,
0.0376935527,
-0.39681077,
0.3875655234,
-0.6968390942,
-0.5132558346,
0.3515304029,
0.2568745315,
0.291146934,
-0.1068448871,
-0.4875898957,
0.4370591044,
-0.1318537742,
-0.3465434015,
0.2237800658,
0.6691552997,
-0.0317500047,
0.457164675,
0.1220633462,
-0.238147229,
-0.1377057433,
0.4216026068,
0.7341237664,
-0.4938545823,
-0.4643491805,
-0.5216351151,
0.9636357427,
-0.2418304682,
-0.633251667,
0.4447517693,
0.1363317966,
0.476716876,
0.1361329406,
0.7766901255,
0.5332378149,
0.6112780571,
-0.2274682522,
0.2826842964,
-0.5803545713,
0.1352316588,
-0.638068378,
-1.0329836607,
-0.3180479109,
0.5988788009,
-0.4270239472,
-0.1528810114,
0.2851430774,
0.6027189493,
0.055040177,
0.4786736965,
0.4292425811,
0.0962948352,
0.6102686524,
0.6875730753,
1.2534698248,
-0.3178279698,
0.4461669028,
-0.2426692247,
-0.0149358949,
-0.4162112176,
-0.8856526017,
-0.9448251128,
-0.6476134062,
-0.7092779279,
-0.3747365177,
-0.0853478387,
0.9941296577,
0.7502208948,
-0.8755704165,
-0.3058839738,
0.1287591308,
-0.1345377713,
0.2890723348,
-0.1652131826,
-0.1149482802,
-0.5156024694,
-0.8763286471,
-0.0797982812,
0.5877130628,
0.299952209,
-0.3078573644,
-0.3030352294,
0.2331149727,
0.1707272828,
0.4465254843,
0.2756008506,
-0.9177196026,
-0.2749396563,
-0.2603119016,
-0.1646240056,
0.2963454723,
0.7662670016,
-0.3745835721,
0.4854628146,
0.3415402174,
0.9260739684,
0.5291189551,
-0.03886519,
0.6485072374,
-0.7631500959,
0.2510040998,
0.4632850885,
0.5030860901,
0.7208826542,
-0.279779613,
0.3680231869,
0.0370779485,
-0.6204606891,
-0.8492898345,
0.4347236753,
-1.0410305262,
0.2296240032,
1.1558053493,
-0.899885416,
0.0236710366,
-0.2558622062,
-0.3835232854,
0.2278484106,
-0.4022663236,
0.5660911202,
0.977262795,
-0.1712888628,
-0.4301196337,
-0.4268915057,
0.4820950329,
0.6550962925,
-1.3518249989,
0.3073075414,
0.6536047459,
-0.1533215046,
0.4065440297,
0.2974173725,
0.2015691251,
-0.0686764866,
-0.346240133,
0.2731766105,
0.4205849469,
-0.2425269336,
-0.4686022997,
0.1707384586,
0.0558486655,
0.2749764621
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13892v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13892v3
|
General Phrase Debiaser: Debiasing Masked Language Models at a Multi-Token Level
| 2023-11-23T10:23:51 | 2024-01-25T15:36:44 |
Bingkang Shi, Xiaodan Zhang, Dehan Kong, Yulei Wu, Zongzhen Liu, Honglei Lyu, Longtao Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The social biases and unwelcome stereotypes revealed by pretrained language
models are becoming obstacles to their application. Compared to numerous
debiasing methods targeting word level, there has been relatively less
attention on biases present at phrase level, limiting the performance of
debiasing in discipline domains. In this paper, we propose an automatic
multi-token debiasing pipeline called \textbf{General Phrase Debiaser}, which
is capable of mitigating phrase-level biases in masked language models.
Specifically, our method consists of a \textit{phrase filter stage} that
generates stereotypical phrases from Wikipedia pages as well as a \textit{model
debias stage} that can debias models at the multi-token level to tackle bias
challenges on phrases. The latter searches for prompts that trigger model's
bias, and then uses them for debiasing. State-of-the-art results on standard
datasets and metrics show that our approach can significantly reduce gender
biases on both career and multiple disciplines, across models with varying
parameter sizes.
|
[
-0.434052527,
-0.9408677816,
0.2957213521,
0.3010219932,
-0.5503157377,
0.1764414012,
0.226188153,
-0.1177213788,
0.3996737897,
0.6260297894,
-0.5338924527,
-0.7363112569,
-0.8955011368,
0.1097534299,
-0.6198163629,
0.8423011303,
0.289853394,
0.4115597308,
-0.1076456085,
0.1330244094,
-0.5706267357,
-0.7031501532,
-0.5772916675,
-0.2963234484,
0.1972151697,
-0.0586982928,
0.8028200269,
0.3747783303,
0.3662514091,
0.2096566111,
-0.1510243565,
0.1239103973,
-0.30739972,
0.4501887262,
-0.1664537936,
-0.3043623865,
-0.4376551211,
0.3199265599,
0.3180480599,
0.7086203694,
0.2521759272,
0.1460824907,
0.1356054246,
0.3691881001,
-0.7061766386,
0.0614778697,
-0.9555273652,
0.0979321375,
-0.1103054583,
0.226297766,
-0.1893698573,
-0.3382436931,
0.0391806699,
-0.4218959212,
0.5718443394,
0.0867450908,
0.800568819,
0.3683641553,
-0.3983535171,
-0.1300765127,
-0.4394268095,
0.8868155479,
-0.4090421498,
0.2363264561,
0.540674746,
0.0152496481,
0.1689834297,
-0.4290129244,
-0.4533332586,
-0.207855463,
-0.1270959079,
-0.2576905787,
-0.3811400235,
0.2773688436,
0.107897304,
-0.0417533405,
-0.3904459476,
-0.023045972,
-0.4886868298,
-0.3448152542,
0.2193967104,
-0.1194923967,
0.2828633487,
-0.6329239607,
-0.2518846095,
0.2479844093,
-0.5134004354,
-0.4526087642,
0.7328699827,
0.1132702604,
0.107535474,
0.5012238622,
-0.3206660151,
0.5807116628,
0.214813292,
0.0982173905,
0.3543786705,
-0.0969109982,
-0.1365404427,
-0.0875407532,
0.6547875404,
0.5255585313,
0.5001467466,
-0.3815402389,
-0.0585551225,
0.5696508884,
0.210244298,
-0.9147124887,
-0.1448287517,
0.3168721795,
-0.4272910357,
-0.5856193304,
0.0302675311,
-1.2196054459,
-0.6836326122,
-0.3586030602,
0.2913091481,
-0.2586178482,
-0.160770461,
0.1024885103,
-0.5008789301,
-0.0825790912,
-0.0394667499,
-0.4305460453,
0.1251636147,
0.6467534304,
1.0380419493,
0.0999323353,
-0.0112207532,
-0.9783767462,
0.1460958272,
-0.432507515,
0.4730300009,
-0.9928628802,
-0.4990133941,
0.0411171466,
-0.3193314075,
-0.0414220802,
-0.4445756078,
0.3685423434,
-0.2746137977,
0.2879033089,
-0.0867163762,
-0.36796996,
0.1957954466,
0.2767498493,
-0.5540792942,
1.0292094946,
-0.2352274656,
-1.046407342,
0.485373795,
-0.8051147461,
-0.2253184915,
-0.3880860806,
-0.3143773377,
-0.1242282763,
0.2110687643,
0.6266342402,
0.2805114985,
-0.3855344355,
0.7460383177,
-0.7480166554,
-0.3318511844,
0.055171188,
-0.3961349428,
1.0026977062,
0.3444502354,
-0.544102788,
0.1654559523,
-0.8022178411,
-0.2524860501,
-0.2714389265,
0.2037528604,
-0.8754503131,
-0.0377934538,
-0.2374018282,
0.5056377053,
-0.0628040433,
-0.7312722206,
0.0820047185,
-0.2547140419,
0.5425333381,
0.9163525105,
-0.0547210872,
0.4976364672,
0.2842937112,
0.7592101097,
0.2416528165,
0.214079842,
0.1260506511,
-0.4328637719,
-0.8828863502,
-0.7132308483,
0.3011884093,
0.5211243629,
-0.7482302189,
0.711589694,
-0.1471532881,
-0.2628520429,
-0.9018958807,
0.2228124738,
0.5624436736,
0.3060595095,
0.404879719,
-0.2801395953,
-0.6182429194,
-1.1142680645,
-0.5243137479,
0.0059513301,
-0.3241832852,
-0.1568974406,
0.6370393038,
-0.4043666422,
1.2339817286,
-0.8643006086,
-0.5735381842,
0.0501479395,
0.5806152821,
-0.0786177889,
0.4649631977,
0.7604814768,
-0.7881454825,
-0.1167513952,
-0.7001312971,
-0.678592205,
-0.5087264776,
0.1875025481,
-0.4114176929,
0.0067497301,
0.8309291601,
-0.6201268435,
0.3945059776,
0.4675831199,
-0.6618199944,
0.4126164019,
0.102857396,
-0.1517369151,
-0.943036437,
0.0573899522,
0.1476515383,
-0.0354034938,
-0.5784689784,
0.230123952,
-0.2583834827,
-0.2483145297,
-0.2118645608,
0.7717461586,
-0.5331044197,
0.2062811852,
-0.1911952794,
0.281280309,
0.3631846011,
0.2341287285,
-0.1226281747,
0.5441840887,
0.7576642632,
-0.4925549328,
0.2398093194,
0.2599729598,
-0.2534328699,
0.6447533965,
-0.8458907604,
0.5015033484,
-0.6318877935,
0.4407477677,
-1.0098042488,
0.1277636737,
0.5104933977,
-0.3649958372,
0.0690620169,
-0.5107871294,
-0.3983748257,
-0.5224699974,
-0.5261163116,
0.0667634159,
0.1545875818,
-0.2426995188,
0.4865223467,
0.569103539,
-0.0526201054,
-0.9187993407,
-0.7211692929,
0.2840405703,
-0.4014017284,
-0.4691812098,
0.3939699829,
-0.147798717,
-0.5384497643,
-0.0585061386,
-0.1438488364,
-0.2982191443,
0.0431303084,
0.1309712678,
0.4133364558,
0.2588451803,
0.1865181625,
0.1796026081,
-0.1722366512,
0.1932006776,
-0.5473751426,
0.9030992985,
0.1961720735,
-0.1725128442,
0.1298315078,
0.4404549897,
0.5980882049,
-0.3914904594,
0.8517153263,
0.9532448053,
-0.3450921774,
0.0482192114,
-0.6645639539,
-0.1986896247,
-0.4162246585,
0.5202149153,
-0.4206937253,
-0.8973397613,
0.4192177653,
0.50114429,
-0.1700246334,
0.3142059743,
0.2917599976,
0.5235578418,
1.2204562426,
0.3686410189,
-0.6333819032,
0.280620873,
-0.168267712,
0.4181653559,
-0.7160535455,
0.1597503573,
-0.8974068761,
-0.2968800664,
-0.5197013617,
-0.731238246,
0.401537478,
0.1656015217,
-0.2978851497,
-0.1219680086,
-0.7411068082,
0.5081545115,
0.8032559156,
0.0555474795,
0.1033439264,
-0.0486092977,
-0.3230145574,
-0.0345443115,
-0.2526628375,
-0.5159968138,
1.1150945425,
0.3659363985,
0.769084394,
-0.0738769174,
0.8477535248,
0.491882205,
0.0399335846,
-0.4341449142,
0.5525574088,
-0.4624543488,
-1.3161001205,
-0.2820222378,
-0.3479718864,
-0.4613533318,
0.6796420813,
-0.0317550674,
-0.8044059277,
0.4391585588,
0.1224132106,
-0.2115927637,
0.2992885709,
-0.4935063422,
0.765203774,
0.1500221193,
-0.2049023509,
-0.2703686059,
-0.622228682,
0.5527158976,
-0.0964533314,
0.6153406501,
-0.3453997374,
0.0720314831,
0.6035981774,
-0.0752470046,
1.2162181139,
-0.7402009964,
-0.0536999814,
0.2290383726,
0.1785833538,
0.3532105684,
-0.0118603902,
-0.2215010524,
0.3800473511,
-0.1174129769,
-0.2734352648,
-0.1377334446,
0.56730932,
-0.7134687304,
-0.6742744446,
-0.2819343209,
-0.314242214,
-0.1773280054,
0.1785122752,
0.303938061,
0.4303423762,
-0.4166511893,
0.1471062452,
0.4510285854,
-0.3985417485,
0.1109854579,
0.1026850566,
-0.3161278665,
-0.5403813124,
0.498832494,
0.0579154715,
0.2332262099,
0.339232713,
0.2682347,
-0.3172299564,
-0.3190408647,
-0.2837206125,
-0.1233708709,
-0.7907124162,
-0.3073795736,
-1.060244441,
-0.0251025613,
-0.8713060617,
0.0483092964,
0.0469050892,
-0.6347929835,
-0.1261994541,
-0.244872272,
0.1569208205,
0.2214293629,
-0.1827130765,
0.4179694951,
-0.5332731009,
0.943695426,
0.384034723,
0.1221406981,
-0.3027301729,
-0.482814014,
0.1331790835,
0.0549312942,
-0.312567234,
-0.8673394322,
0.5443107486,
0.3505203128,
0.4852183759,
0.5992287397,
0.2327970117,
0.5069822073,
-0.3443326652,
0.836568296,
0.2109172493,
-1.3215368986,
0.5622193813,
-0.3530168533,
0.0128299715,
0.462880969,
0.2017527223,
-0.5382057428,
-0.8800317645,
-0.3396880627,
-1.0142079592,
0.5738693476,
0.0905149952,
0.4663932323,
-0.3904967904,
0.1737155169,
0.0724153891,
0.7649980783,
-0.744656682,
-0.3910253644,
-0.4893099368,
-0.2524234354,
0.0565642491,
-0.4888304472,
-0.0816145465,
-0.251609236,
0.754409492,
-0.2885806561,
0.1747277379,
0.1658637077,
-0.3727325797,
0.0894741714,
0.5944221616,
0.2312859446,
0.5263041854,
-0.3424375951,
0.3027351201,
-0.1061573923,
-0.4827591479,
0.2227487862,
0.2914262414,
-0.7752569914,
0.3920767307,
-0.0059462204,
0.8056208491,
0.1586829573,
-0.1966134459,
0.4120022953,
0.2889204323,
-0.1361300647,
-0.1227450743,
-0.0396993756,
-0.0542065389,
-0.0172425471,
0.3285963833,
0.0307639055,
0.3654820323,
-0.4810932279,
0.1142832786,
0.6823798418,
-0.5131309628,
-0.1646820605,
1.0581800938,
0.4440371096,
0.1753373593,
0.3481019139,
-0.2406081408,
-0.7676792145,
0.436250031,
0.3558051586,
1.3592108488,
-0.2215135098,
0.5629636645,
0.4030452669,
0.3868543506,
-0.0273197275,
-0.0835337415,
0.3308212161,
-0.8494705558,
-0.3162006736,
-0.9085115194,
-0.0093996851,
0.2267240286,
-0.5367077589,
0.2853556871,
-0.4275201857,
-0.3833546638,
0.1807021201,
-0.2113337517,
-0.8875236511,
0.2863740623,
0.2452911735,
0.6568532586,
-0.8552544713,
0.7828887701,
0.4773620367,
-0.6220242381,
-0.0567646958,
0.1037204117,
0.3619710207,
-0.8972735405,
0.9866729975,
0.2381386906,
-0.4430927038,
-0.0161047224,
-0.3921926916,
-0.6507398486,
0.495185107,
0.5237243772,
-0.5152882934,
-0.5836688876,
0.1729120612,
0.3212597668,
-0.6181520224,
0.2984066606,
0.6543319225,
0.6206326485,
-0.2715934813,
-0.7835421562,
-0.0777900741,
-0.1769051254,
0.0223684274,
0.0630351454,
-0.4003302753,
1.0567014217,
0.1630448699,
0.1977981925,
-0.1678800285,
0.3073525429,
0.0156807136,
0.1449932009,
0.8896124959,
0.3949836791,
0.7403234839,
0.0430738851,
0.6505403519,
-0.3880082071,
0.2412957549,
1.0777909756,
-0.3488441706,
0.2703777254,
0.4625240564,
0.0035784587,
0.5714641213,
0.1734413207,
-0.1294309795,
0.6459703445,
0.5140550137,
-0.0813315585,
-0.3316446841,
-0.1779759675,
-0.1987612396,
0.5666843057,
0.2144845575,
-0.5114588141,
-0.2454583794,
0.1909935921,
0.4075441658,
0.050165128,
-0.2994554937,
0.4893784523,
0.0733863935,
-0.5392666459,
0.3943316638,
0.1575797349,
1.0416214466,
-0.6397544742,
0.2254614234,
-0.313669771,
0.3606348336,
0.1245999783,
-0.2433815747,
0.393440187,
0.3450740278,
-0.3071397841,
-0.1237318441,
1.0472022295,
-0.5181015134,
-0.6399258375,
0.5621605515,
0.7094295621,
-0.0572069287,
-0.5491742492,
-0.743278861,
-0.0183997285,
0.1021500677,
-0.0549540482,
0.2193588167,
0.4509865344,
-0.0799148157,
0.5928093791,
0.3778803945,
0.1351148635,
0.1743527353,
0.4685509503,
0.8120254874,
-0.6446231604,
-0.7241382003,
-0.9538410902,
0.3117141128,
-0.4284400344,
-0.3408700824,
0.6449720263,
0.4019779861,
0.6983082294,
-0.1838341504,
1.0898997784,
-0.1254114807,
0.670971036,
-0.4866224229,
0.7183440328,
-0.3329251707,
0.2203007191,
-0.7423465848,
-0.9547023177,
-0.3077902496,
0.6797756553,
-0.3300444186,
-0.0473767519,
0.4213914275,
0.8545024991,
-0.0742420778,
-0.2668933868,
0.1878912598,
0.1183770448,
0.4462021887,
-0.1171031445,
0.5732539892,
-0.1477005929,
0.6454590559,
-0.1358739436,
-0.2091526538,
-0.0983780921,
-0.8670581579,
-1.2624924183,
-0.3190163672,
-0.4005457759,
-0.274389565,
0.2884656191,
1.0736171007,
0.7941468954,
-0.7196827531,
-0.0096787997,
0.0866870657,
0.2387476861,
-0.0138800889,
-0.2657999694,
0.3289843202,
-0.6934203506,
-0.9520716071,
0.2403813004,
-0.1065307111,
-0.3496542275,
-0.5348753333,
0.2399439514,
-0.11228095,
0.2981091142,
0.6014562249,
-0.521161139,
-0.6968455315,
-0.6246791482,
-0.0304583088,
0.0374371558,
-0.1862877756,
0.9745130539,
-0.6998957992,
0.5716301203,
0.2452899367,
0.1531580538,
0.2929432392,
-0.0880305171,
0.6558126211,
-1.1985580921,
0.5003600717,
0.0720108822,
0.3999420106,
0.3997594118,
-0.1827794313,
0.6616552472,
0.3782888055,
-0.1004272848,
-0.9402333498,
0.361727953,
-0.3507764637,
-0.5848267078,
1.1891642809,
0.0797028542,
0.1780730486,
-0.348031491,
-0.2716635764,
0.3738904297,
-0.3893063962,
1.0588634014,
0.9019410014,
0.4917910099,
0.230377391,
-0.5669618249,
0.4116232991,
0.1862345934,
-0.4385385215,
0.2439285368,
0.9251266718,
0.3531141281,
0.2941494286,
0.6393005848,
-0.1483058333,
-0.4157590568,
0.1103201061,
0.1545179039,
-0.1052949056,
-0.3664967716,
-0.1780666709,
0.1279770136,
-0.1468187124,
-0.6406202912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13878v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13878v1
|
Minimizing Factual Inconsistency and Hallucination in Large Language Models
| 2023-11-23T09:58:39 | 2023-11-23T09:58:39 |
Muneeswaran I, Shreya Saxena, Siva Prasad, M V Sai Prakash, Advaith Shankar, Varun V, Vishal Vaddina, Saisubramaniam Gopalakrishnan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are widely used in critical fields such as
healthcare, education, and finance due to their remarkable proficiency in
various language-related tasks. However, LLMs are prone to generating factually
incorrect responses or "hallucinations," which can lead to a loss of
credibility and trust among users. To address this issue, we propose a
multi-stage framework that generates the rationale first, verifies and refines
incorrect ones, and uses them as supporting references to generate the answer.
The generated rationale enhances the transparency of the answer and our
framework provides insights into how the model arrived at this answer, by using
this rationale and the references to the context. In this paper, we demonstrate
its effectiveness in improving the quality of responses to drug-related
inquiries in the life sciences industry. Our framework improves traditional
Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) by enabling OpenAI GPT-3.5-turbo to be
14-25% more faithful and 16-22% more accurate on two datasets. Furthermore,
fine-tuning samples based on our framework improves the accuracy of smaller
open-access LLMs by 33-42% and competes with RAG on commercial models.
|
[
-0.1170367748,
-0.8146817684,
0.9239079952,
0.1130441427,
0.010001678,
-0.1461227238,
-0.2832229435,
-0.433712244,
0.0741792917,
0.6786077023,
-0.4254919887,
-0.5634938478,
-0.5276412368,
0.2287633717,
-0.2812309265,
0.9732647538,
-0.0236685351,
0.2632138133,
-0.1159600168,
-0.2833491862,
-0.171765238,
-0.4242097735,
-0.7011806369,
-0.4719898701,
0.7513142228,
0.3193663359,
0.7404190302,
0.5226617455,
0.641025722,
0.197528854,
-0.1097166911,
0.4673077166,
-0.536113739,
0.4091249108,
-0.2657369673,
-0.4804611504,
-0.3795592189,
-0.1699070185,
0.3017539084,
0.788087368,
-0.3130369782,
0.2532494664,
0.0808907896,
0.6771491766,
-0.7171644568,
0.1423569024,
-0.7597303391,
-0.0509016328,
-0.0147984363,
-0.3710691929,
-0.5682812929,
-0.4316221476,
0.0485468768,
-0.6561477184,
0.4490283132,
0.0236980263,
0.9685464501,
0.3703468442,
-0.1512203068,
-0.3960858285,
-0.8238479495,
0.4899435341,
-0.9428918362,
0.4880825579,
0.2885541618,
0.2831153274,
-0.43128407,
-0.6248880029,
-0.6143063307,
-0.3821062744,
-0.2531034052,
-0.2040468305,
0.2946824729,
0.1791957021,
0.4088049531,
0.2623571455,
-0.62577039,
-0.085429281,
-0.2718445063,
-0.3692702949,
0.3392985463,
0.0617088228,
0.123168245,
-0.0375125743,
-0.1535666734,
-0.2199297398,
-1.0355563164,
-0.3603345454,
-0.0106837563,
0.5404188037,
0.2316869497,
0.9252078533,
-0.1273063272,
0.3878128827,
0.1649054736,
-0.5006976724,
0.3257839382,
-0.4102278948,
-0.4367292523,
0.0688761696,
0.5765810013,
0.317328155,
-0.0167144686,
-0.1236814186,
-0.1987281591,
0.1398106664,
0.2291502059,
-1.0249329805,
0.085831143,
0.7059281468,
-0.2526900172,
-0.2115387619,
-0.0860866979,
-0.8503226042,
-0.6428843737,
-0.3520074487,
0.5599244833,
-0.3589117825,
0.0002037237,
0.1730199307,
0.2293790877,
0.0985584781,
0.35328722,
-0.6305586696,
0.175390467,
0.5920604467,
0.8021726608,
-0.0940485224,
-0.0594093949,
-0.8896970749,
0.4386428297,
-0.5915955901,
0.6978245378,
-0.4027808607,
-0.3073186874,
0.1012115553,
0.0176230129,
0.0918126181,
-0.8438248038,
0.5854353309,
-0.3692412972,
0.2961417735,
-0.4342061579,
-0.4472067654,
-0.0319461785,
0.300144434,
-0.5648372173,
0.7341342568,
-0.1075609848,
-0.7108271718,
0.5015573502,
-0.7177480459,
-0.211776793,
-0.0357556343,
-0.4232068956,
-0.5060149431,
0.2283630818,
0.3566676974,
0.2533333898,
-0.2476267666,
0.6079197526,
-0.3088540435,
-0.2716511488,
0.259333998,
-0.3265318871,
0.4621814191,
0.370202899,
-0.456508249,
0.2929047942,
-0.8815000057,
-0.1813267022,
-0.0274831224,
-0.4029055834,
-0.1496606916,
-0.1539427787,
-0.1279682219,
0.1813999861,
-0.0914311484,
-0.5191797614,
-0.0463238209,
-0.6160779595,
0.1112659499,
0.7112905383,
0.1237715036,
0.214242667,
-0.4090271294,
0.2461905032,
0.2647806108,
0.0629975647,
-0.2909072936,
-0.4383434355,
-0.7010633945,
-0.27925542,
0.3018298149,
0.4454930723,
-0.7979271412,
0.2212029099,
-0.2978882194,
-0.0938218161,
-0.7263595462,
0.1890188605,
0.2095810324,
0.71613729,
0.4886812866,
0.0556133799,
-0.4292050898,
-0.9692917466,
-0.3873392045,
-0.2543458641,
-0.262778312,
0.2736957967,
0.5546668768,
-0.5747830272,
0.7100083828,
-0.4196797907,
-0.3795961142,
0.0521519557,
0.2398341447,
0.2231463939,
0.4463338852,
0.2646272779,
-0.800188303,
-0.3144749701,
0.046597667,
-0.6500401497,
-0.087536335,
-0.2148976475,
-0.1859098971,
0.4783992171,
0.3134330809,
-0.7990495563,
0.4897645116,
0.3281007707,
-0.1082357094,
0.4339458644,
-0.2684658468,
0.3905769289,
-1.0153319836,
0.3439942598,
0.0829869881,
-0.1050753593,
-0.5839127898,
0.0825364664,
-0.1075951904,
-0.0158451982,
-0.1193914637,
0.5804100037,
-0.2748851478,
0.1697850525,
-0.1425928622,
0.2764946222,
0.1549686491,
0.3342991173,
-0.1561598778,
0.8971383572,
0.2314668596,
-0.5325152278,
0.0446190909,
0.2743737102,
-0.3685402572,
0.4430836737,
-0.665370822,
-0.0133146392,
-0.3223189414,
0.2616619766,
-0.8171438575,
-0.6510180831,
0.4226279557,
-0.4095081687,
0.3058204651,
-0.0221607275,
-0.5885730982,
-0.2039904892,
-0.2439661622,
0.1943671256,
0.346768558,
-0.6088033319,
0.7122982144,
0.3133978844,
-0.1937104166,
-0.7178336978,
-0.7645363212,
0.0360739306,
0.0071411296,
-0.6192277074,
0.2375117391,
-0.2744453847,
-0.4170580208,
-0.0871634036,
-0.368938446,
-0.0153902574,
-0.1752601415,
-0.0383777246,
0.2888261974,
-0.3014001846,
0.258315742,
0.1121371612,
-0.0222315583,
0.089134112,
-0.330324471,
0.3207537234,
0.1172480807,
-0.4780725837,
-0.1595643759,
0.3817265034,
0.8383396864,
-0.0224309135,
0.9272646904,
0.4322952926,
-0.5668933392,
-0.2248061001,
-0.7098340988,
-0.4304562211,
-0.4363577664,
0.2767831981,
-0.2969469726,
-0.9457003474,
0.5881699324,
-0.0047014607,
0.0483328849,
0.2922679186,
0.8819440007,
0.4355817139,
1.0331671238,
0.3849737644,
0.3153558373,
-0.0831700638,
0.1318227202,
0.6248313785,
-0.7781667709,
-0.5050632954,
-0.6199727654,
0.2191295922,
-0.5188424587,
-0.7192111611,
0.7234510183,
-0.0382236391,
-0.1216089278,
-0.1785312593,
-0.4398789108,
0.3614167571,
0.147846207,
0.215921253,
0.4000788629,
0.201252237,
-0.305285573,
0.0291323252,
-0.6352317333,
-0.639970541,
1.1861997843,
0.4108172357,
0.7097052336,
0.1886462867,
0.4513683021,
-0.0270682182,
0.6570065618,
-0.6485438943,
0.3393889666,
0.0894180909,
-0.9340305328,
-0.2912752628,
-0.717284739,
-0.6503738761,
0.4846072793,
-0.3683016896,
-0.7619799972,
0.3215476871,
0.1863516718,
-0.5846045613,
0.1959552169,
-0.5303501487,
0.6689441204,
0.0024728409,
-0.6739832759,
0.0245486293,
-0.5605399609,
0.5585146546,
-0.390065521,
0.4384627938,
-0.07390894,
0.0580095984,
0.2916248739,
-0.5708354115,
0.6446140409,
0.0196716171,
-0.4466886818,
0.128301397,
0.1548899859,
0.6742786169,
0.26350981,
-0.1574409604,
-0.072562702,
-0.0115871374,
-0.2331361324,
-0.7262862921,
0.8247897029,
-0.383859843,
-0.6903826594,
-0.3369372785,
-0.5552009344,
-0.5166440606,
0.1721715629,
0.3201428354,
0.4248868227,
-0.0123888645,
0.2116720229,
0.9891467094,
-0.4981293082,
-0.1300342828,
0.5195738077,
-0.4778123498,
-0.5137016177,
0.6326973438,
0.2049376965,
0.3618424833,
0.114838995,
0.2086992413,
-0.4373924434,
-0.6101937294,
-0.3288664818,
0.4585733116,
-0.85450387,
-0.2635335624,
-0.7594187856,
-0.1063933447,
-0.8156761527,
0.2153037637,
-0.314576596,
-0.0380182229,
-0.083378233,
-0.1414265782,
0.239662677,
0.5612872243,
-0.2378222793,
-0.0019853618,
-0.8315755725,
0.6296131611,
0.1067075878,
0.5319138765,
-0.1411326081,
-0.5751698017,
-0.1928729564,
0.3226578832,
-0.1691641212,
-0.7935489416,
0.3256095946,
0.1576443613,
0.6027545333,
0.1757258326,
0.0607631356,
0.7705210447,
-0.5072609782,
0.7226664424,
0.1528454572,
-0.8758755922,
0.5387387276,
-0.3202519417,
0.1168412641,
0.7618758082,
0.3706323504,
-0.3379908502,
-0.5292973518,
-0.4366680086,
-1.1055101156,
0.4198821187,
0.3693791032,
-0.1426561177,
0.000023006,
0.5653042197,
0.161326319,
0.3732886314,
-0.6690135598,
-0.3488048017,
0.0384215154,
-0.2804175615,
0.0351537801,
-0.4365555346,
-0.3912413716,
-0.1867674738,
0.9985733628,
-0.4086306095,
0.013428648,
0.6013345718,
-0.0014020472,
-0.3862689734,
0.3723249435,
0.7866070867,
0.8993177414,
-0.2359167486,
0.1435060203,
0.0360165983,
-0.4873456061,
0.0943951458,
-0.0458444655,
-0.4144357741,
0.1847290099,
0.163058579,
0.5114737153,
-0.0346946009,
-0.7690050602,
0.3997668624,
0.0615579821,
-0.204129383,
-0.0986694396,
-0.1096367687,
-0.1117013097,
0.2502309978,
0.4342375994,
0.212382406,
0.3068986833,
-0.5136528015,
0.4116848707,
0.2264022976,
-0.1831320077,
0.04326161,
0.7537991405,
-0.0491492748,
-0.1371002346,
0.3567716479,
0.0199826285,
-0.2600024939,
0.2786155939,
0.6450164318,
0.9051529765,
-0.1091138795,
0.4150803387,
0.5328094959,
0.3385452926,
-0.4758332968,
0.1056167036,
0.399609834,
-0.6480671763,
-0.7852067947,
-0.7719147801,
-0.4671593308,
0.48627159,
-0.5482363105,
0.2489066869,
-0.4848221838,
-0.2057562172,
0.0022940089,
-0.1650695205,
-0.2931289077,
0.173686415,
0.1723119169,
0.7627688646,
-0.6783340573,
0.8323342204,
0.4903557003,
-0.5919501185,
-1.0037839413,
0.2340330034,
0.0651539937,
-0.3335930109,
0.4914761186,
0.097503759,
-0.3706755042,
-0.3150292039,
-0.8244271278,
-0.774240911,
0.8659189343,
0.5337978005,
-0.6399365664,
0.0803836137,
0.2418731004,
0.6467139125,
-0.6086332798,
0.0518801957,
0.6091510057,
0.6117640734,
0.3944348991,
-0.8579890728,
0.2369671613,
-0.1691965312,
0.0652512237,
-0.059952043,
-0.2084053904,
0.8108097315,
-0.3271366358,
-0.3092668951,
0.2801615596,
0.4773021936,
0.6165761352,
0.3888689578,
0.2625266314,
0.3860277534,
1.1032392979,
-0.1178579479,
0.9378352165,
-0.3723394275,
0.3522063494,
1.2355985641,
-0.5998909473,
0.674880445,
0.6771441698,
0.0600151718,
0.4561506212,
0.4307389259,
0.022533929,
0.3828392923,
0.2976850569,
-0.1696240753,
-0.2642350495,
-0.1839265674,
-0.3399847746,
-0.0429930352,
0.4722938836,
-0.3183242977,
-0.2170982808,
0.0686629936,
0.2100019455,
0.1526675373,
0.0382104106,
0.6375953555,
0.0906214043,
-0.6861791015,
0.7169426084,
-0.0563441738,
0.3813948035,
-0.626011014,
-0.2367692143,
-0.3998742104,
0.3331051171,
-0.3200554252,
-0.359107852,
0.344807297,
0.0932764038,
-0.2538517118,
0.1973272711,
0.4528781772,
-0.6559570432,
-0.5226923823,
0.2043963969,
0.3406996727,
0.0221696272,
-0.0607689098,
-0.7119247913,
0.3722126782,
-0.0571998507,
-0.188853696,
0.1577476412,
0.6503571868,
0.107159175,
0.6929764152,
0.7760437727,
0.3727269769,
-0.1282028258,
0.1007950008,
0.8556091785,
-0.4317956567,
-0.1570989043,
-0.7436923385,
0.5101416111,
-0.2128782421,
-0.1685425341,
0.7799654603,
0.6479224563,
0.7212664485,
-0.0085796174,
0.7483284473,
0.1837807447,
0.7045683861,
-0.6432981491,
0.6922561526,
-0.7409653664,
0.8042109013,
-0.1986928731,
-0.9592722654,
-0.6860747337,
0.6964128017,
-0.1341388822,
0.0392654091,
0.837251842,
1.2454178333,
0.1924064606,
-0.1551447064,
0.2506012022,
0.6615124941,
0.503151834,
0.3106329441,
0.5595909357,
-0.6340094805,
0.3989774585,
-0.0605359897,
-0.1219507158,
-0.1980402917,
-0.7307687998,
-0.8168315887,
-0.2491818666,
-0.4026310444,
-0.9542097449,
0.1221781373,
1.2170091867,
0.5454207063,
-1.1134805679,
-0.1500923485,
0.0136134177,
0.182791695,
0.0530256927,
-0.2044757754,
0.2394427359,
-0.5850646496,
-0.5499318838,
0.3766715825,
0.4533498287,
-0.041513633,
-0.3950584531,
-0.1359530836,
-0.1085577533,
0.4843182862,
0.6548893452,
0.0704854503,
-0.8791401982,
-0.5071424246,
0.1717815995,
-0.3806572556,
0.1885669678,
0.8772175908,
-0.5926796794,
0.4376170933,
0.4162522852,
0.6215465069,
0.2724820375,
-0.0527025312,
0.6673368812,
-0.3522049189,
-0.0509608984,
0.2605964541,
0.1333702654,
0.4676979184,
-0.5233129859,
0.5374522805,
0.2486972213,
-0.5405108929,
-1.1183844805,
0.138791427,
-0.7684626579,
-0.5002847314,
1.2134062052,
0.0258596856,
-0.3771650493,
-0.1840243936,
-0.1875276566,
0.0524088293,
-0.2755089104,
0.9642091393,
0.6218209267,
0.0219861828,
0.1657280326,
-0.5972614288,
0.7375226617,
0.2702180743,
-0.865788579,
0.2950376868,
0.742959559,
0.2636884153,
0.4014604688,
0.6382088661,
-0.442060262,
-0.009607926,
0.0056730895,
-0.1019972414,
0.1787035167,
-0.5676426291,
-0.2579359114,
0.3492148817,
0.1056242138,
0.2017366886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13857v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13857v1
|
Challenges of Large Language Models for Mental Health Counseling
| 2023-11-23T08:56:41 | 2023-11-23T08:56:41 |
Neo Christopher Chung, George Dyer, Lennart Brocki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
The global mental health crisis is looming with a rapid increase in mental
disorders, limited resources, and the social stigma of seeking treatment. As
the field of artificial intelligence (AI) has witnessed significant
advancements in recent years, large language models (LLMs) capable of
understanding and generating human-like text may be used in supporting or
providing psychological counseling. However, the application of LLMs in the
mental health domain raises concerns regarding the accuracy, effectiveness, and
reliability of the information provided. This paper investigates the major
challenges associated with the development of LLMs for psychological
counseling, including model hallucination, interpretability, bias, privacy, and
clinical effectiveness. We explore potential solutions to these challenges that
are practical and applicable to the current paradigm of AI. From our experience
in developing and deploying LLMs for mental health, AI holds a great promise
for improving mental health care, if we can carefully navigate and overcome
pitfalls of LLMs.
|
[
-0.3021016419,
-0.8448048234,
1.1019765139,
0.3149167299,
0.1172317117,
0.0561211407,
-0.5253919363,
-0.6382287741,
-0.1639281064,
0.4950362742,
-0.7868169546,
-0.3667970598,
-0.9951694012,
0.2297223657,
-0.2533387244,
0.8194721341,
-0.1266718209,
0.3074769974,
-0.1843243241,
0.117258206,
-0.6974291205,
-0.7880213857,
-0.7777603865,
-0.5474900603,
0.4410603344,
0.2834941149,
0.9463408589,
0.2123544663,
0.7065342665,
0.3017650843,
-0.0897290036,
0.209905535,
-0.4379741549,
0.1751147807,
-0.0682217181,
-0.3939213455,
-0.5280105472,
-0.1114650741,
0.5010530949,
0.9518073201,
-0.2981095612,
0.0655340105,
-0.1454804391,
0.6620611548,
-0.2427003533,
0.2052022964,
-0.5712491274,
0.1688274443,
0.0481966697,
0.2083068043,
-0.2793719172,
-0.1787884086,
0.2348632067,
-0.4968842268,
0.041736111,
0.0070627951,
0.5757102966,
0.6433904767,
-0.7247524858,
-0.5095086098,
-1.2387042046,
0.6621786356,
-0.8045182824,
0.340890795,
0.6974512339,
0.2550463974,
-0.6399691701,
-0.4851241708,
-0.3872541189,
-0.3309516907,
0.0511322469,
-0.3620693982,
-0.2951767743,
-0.0161996167,
0.4404430091,
0.1881866008,
-0.4794206321,
0.3545188606,
-0.2063016146,
-0.0754399225,
1.0432887077,
0.4767879546,
0.4504855275,
0.1194186956,
0.1317765564,
0.2358943969,
-0.4773053825,
-0.2901276052,
0.0586041249,
0.1080940813,
-0.0278884545,
0.6588374376,
0.2645112574,
0.3061820567,
-0.1843667626,
-0.3756418526,
-0.2128729969,
0.2923082709,
-0.1419453621,
0.1063922197,
0.6728423834,
0.4116409421,
0.3910155892,
-0.1111748964,
-0.0821593776,
0.1146517172,
0.6827589273,
-0.4478562176,
0.0552514419,
0.5884711742,
-0.465700686,
0.0281856582,
-0.3520383537,
-0.6744990349,
-0.7880843878,
-0.5542721748,
0.1426293999,
-0.5120256543,
-0.2861498892,
0.2160940617,
0.1633522362,
0.093210943,
0.3939292431,
-0.8575392365,
0.183655858,
0.9305943251,
0.7068337202,
-0.0399014466,
-0.1166778356,
0.0239934307,
0.1805833578,
-0.4383599758,
0.4783983529,
-0.5331328511,
-0.5342755318,
0.1936108768,
-0.1039470658,
0.0172384456,
-0.5631475449,
0.4149266183,
0.0360952429,
-0.0574506298,
-0.4258191586,
-0.6066020727,
0.1358795911,
0.4047985375,
-0.434494406,
0.5869077444,
0.2612961829,
-0.629712224,
-0.1371087283,
-0.5973026752,
-0.4020698667,
0.2216471881,
-0.2922022343,
-0.2115490288,
0.4649476111,
0.1097130179,
0.4160953164,
-0.5417817235,
0.5048496723,
-0.3345782459,
-0.5221758485,
0.7136721611,
-0.4714100659,
0.6757166982,
0.2449341267,
-0.2721009552,
0.2561827898,
-0.7259485126,
-0.0965887457,
0.4141595364,
-0.0964719951,
-0.251390636,
0.1610046029,
0.1576912552,
0.0071423338,
0.1955684721,
-0.2028461844,
0.2130948603,
-0.2318243086,
0.5773746967,
0.7807642221,
-0.0458749756,
0.0324176326,
-0.3958539665,
0.6832948327,
-0.2777862549,
0.2998686731,
-0.0135337934,
-0.6391836405,
-0.2386268228,
-0.3428536355,
-0.0874487609,
0.6716806293,
-0.5271190405,
0.5408222079,
-0.1362537891,
-0.750164628,
-0.5623088479,
0.0629003644,
0.1542486101,
0.3161294162,
0.1098331437,
0.1105454415,
-0.3942161202,
-0.7651039362,
-0.316219449,
-0.1034137532,
0.0407822467,
0.351763308,
0.6137199402,
-0.7855184674,
0.6559756994,
-0.4229670763,
-0.3189685941,
-0.4175623655,
0.0955199748,
-0.0458102413,
0.4387128949,
0.2713516653,
-0.7298586369,
-0.3593545556,
0.0287407096,
-1.2005292177,
-0.1156126782,
-0.1823540628,
-0.0427088514,
0.0307723619,
0.3868961632,
-0.8350698352,
0.2625917494,
0.5094252229,
-0.2744238973,
0.916842103,
-0.3464367688,
-0.1435624361,
-1.0059847832,
0.0974984467,
0.2020426691,
-0.0790784657,
-0.788824439,
0.0684197024,
-0.2663646638,
-0.4253860116,
-0.2424975336,
0.433750391,
-0.2296630889,
0.307094276,
-0.3074576557,
0.0308513157,
-0.4267406166,
0.2321780771,
-0.249619633,
0.7134587765,
0.3605880737,
-0.3900597692,
0.6979982853,
0.304343909,
-0.1349791735,
0.7644852996,
-0.5228248835,
0.216543749,
-0.2888943553,
0.4783215225,
-0.4086359441,
-0.5497088432,
0.2557688057,
-0.16246216,
0.316144675,
0.423738718,
-0.4492710829,
-0.5494235754,
-0.0187476166,
0.5581308007,
0.3426723182,
-0.1607420295,
0.3229261339,
0.418554157,
-0.3653976321,
-0.5562165976,
-0.4308346212,
0.5376469493,
-0.3298637867,
-0.464407891,
0.4011557698,
-0.1338905096,
-0.7008566856,
-0.0362897888,
0.0870494843,
0.1647367328,
0.2489878535,
0.3871266842,
0.2353536636,
-0.0197798274,
0.3000410199,
-0.007769139,
-0.295070827,
0.4779036045,
-0.2777688205,
0.5593245029,
-0.2322291136,
-0.5569717288,
-0.5917538404,
0.805644393,
0.7554340959,
-0.0922155678,
0.9330496192,
0.4359306693,
-0.8922266364,
-0.1363291591,
-0.6796370149,
-0.0909547061,
-0.3930297196,
0.564642787,
-0.0353645794,
-0.9298948646,
0.3744759858,
-0.2144458443,
-0.0885946825,
0.0268291421,
0.6370814443,
-0.0887349918,
1.4707292318,
0.6591545343,
-0.1472156793,
0.2415233403,
-0.0720236078,
0.6170355082,
-0.7000141144,
-0.2829374373,
-0.462068826,
-0.2191388309,
-0.6576995254,
-0.1536182463,
0.5918477774,
-0.0608930215,
-0.5225462914,
-0.1924238652,
-0.5724446774,
0.0076545058,
0.3611809611,
0.0583280101,
0.4975966513,
-0.1044944823,
0.1268118173,
-0.4462057352,
-0.3836814761,
-0.8471702337,
0.7837600112,
0.6567301154,
0.887347281,
0.0014781373,
0.3626672626,
0.2141395211,
0.3241708279,
-0.8606556058,
0.4776254594,
0.0942105129,
-0.6637712121,
-0.4322350323,
-0.4147900343,
-0.8931691647,
0.2029665709,
-0.3561331928,
-1.2345417738,
0.0373070799,
0.0255975481,
-0.1821649522,
0.2276140451,
-0.3666200638,
0.7634660602,
-0.6017868519,
0.0383028351,
-0.2067352682,
-0.6437922716,
0.4318210483,
-0.3818985224,
0.4095671177,
-0.3836945593,
0.285030216,
0.4378212094,
-0.3191570342,
0.6752439737,
0.1239244342,
-0.4708840251,
-0.0123601379,
-0.0321708173,
0.3992576599,
0.1900473833,
-0.0792741477,
0.1322882473,
0.3549253047,
-0.3607921302,
-0.748451829,
0.4436085522,
-0.9364023805,
-1.0091211796,
-0.3985129595,
-0.9098001719,
-0.6722096205,
0.129615739,
0.2965129614,
0.1885950267,
-0.3574604094,
-0.1841556579,
0.5637655854,
-0.7269183397,
-0.0096930293,
0.2564643025,
-0.5769912601,
-0.299605608,
0.9556655288,
0.0786321759,
0.0904502496,
-0.3811171651,
0.1373310536,
-0.1148486212,
-0.5852206349,
-0.1145340949,
0.6708314419,
-0.6624391079,
0.0487131029,
-0.4444292486,
-0.5108286142,
-0.6096924543,
-0.2114584744,
-0.3823166192,
0.1329577863,
-0.3426014781,
0.0040883627,
0.3231602609,
1.0010924339,
0.1067831069,
0.2234924883,
-0.9573884606,
0.2592411637,
0.0036072154,
0.3819054365,
0.3249768019,
-0.0503572449,
-0.2849598229,
0.1342918277,
-0.2945329547,
-0.9566868544,
0.383186698,
-0.2363458425,
0.4493624866,
0.5635634065,
0.1545833349,
0.7002580762,
-0.5788972974,
0.7305692434,
0.0636062995,
-0.818651557,
0.5749631524,
-0.3904574513,
0.2278560102,
0.3973940015,
0.6857052445,
-0.9957115054,
-0.6712505817,
-0.4020138681,
-0.8108804822,
0.5464206934,
0.0816462934,
0.4144916832,
-0.1000970006,
0.7511662245,
0.0580998026,
0.2492828369,
-0.5929211974,
-0.1489892602,
0.1618583649,
-0.4385408163,
-0.0306397304,
-0.1685224324,
-0.3091054559,
-0.2143513709,
0.7522087097,
0.0079148961,
0.4213704765,
0.2464507818,
0.0747358501,
-0.3946964741,
0.4296425581,
0.5864980817,
0.6664030552,
-0.0356039666,
-0.0270360969,
0.0639956668,
-0.4307598174,
0.3808423579,
0.0931832492,
-0.0264773853,
-0.1858408153,
0.5558778644,
0.7633892894,
-0.1091432944,
-1.0720387697,
0.3034669161,
-0.1132783666,
-0.2419412434,
-0.600430727,
0.0733258128,
0.1558522135,
0.4812737405,
0.4343065917,
-0.4260947704,
-0.1653263271,
-0.7561511397,
-0.2795265317,
0.6501094699,
-0.4132292271,
-0.147889331,
0.6275424361,
-0.1969111115,
-0.8074913025,
0.9733992219,
0.0190292019,
-0.5215552449,
0.5557152629,
1.0254160166,
0.5218074322,
-0.1263969839,
0.237915501,
-0.2038890123,
0.281570971,
-0.345390588,
0.2118832022,
0.4250786602,
-0.612652421,
-0.2902061641,
-0.4452345371,
-0.6933133006,
0.4295491874,
-0.7072694302,
0.0815335438,
-0.6054461598,
-0.4923223555,
-0.3158250749,
-0.0356363244,
-0.6360727549,
0.1219570264,
0.5828658342,
0.7029562593,
-0.6567410231,
0.6731684804,
0.8449927568,
-0.1342830807,
-0.7476730347,
0.103895992,
0.3331237137,
-0.5172283053,
0.0988472551,
0.3251150548,
0.0104806451,
-0.1330625117,
-0.6797264814,
-0.7414358258,
0.8285288215,
0.808622539,
-0.5325176716,
-0.4797031879,
0.5097990632,
0.7709900141,
-0.4424248636,
-0.0664228648,
0.7839759588,
0.7971354723,
-0.1802050769,
-0.9208093286,
0.2238422781,
-0.2686010301,
0.3388272524,
-0.1354627013,
-0.5009961128,
0.6288397312,
-0.2086590976,
-0.1021564677,
0.1715845913,
0.4806448221,
0.2368181944,
0.298129648,
0.1786922067,
0.4143091142,
1.0632647276,
0.1550434083,
0.9933798909,
-0.1110390127,
0.305834502,
1.0046858788,
-0.6581911445,
0.5878636837,
0.2016123235,
-0.2005329877,
0.2572215796,
0.6181692481,
-0.2874640524,
-0.1289064288,
0.2934235334,
-0.3685384393,
-0.2020118535,
-0.4337564707,
-0.4778931141,
0.4637191892,
0.7384529114,
-0.2557176948,
0.0330287516,
0.4147361517,
0.0955190733,
0.305185467,
-0.2427609414,
0.5767650604,
0.5875631571,
-0.5252939463,
0.3491960764,
0.2200382352,
0.3629079461,
-0.3951747417,
-0.0395255797,
0.0188696124,
0.2591632009,
-0.2568762004,
-0.3581323922,
0.5860269666,
0.1796548814,
-0.0687115639,
-0.1586603075,
0.7252595425,
-0.2068570256,
-0.9058788419,
0.4408408403,
0.6759216189,
0.1430633217,
-0.2517779171,
-0.6837251782,
0.2054455429,
-0.4293256104,
-0.1076557562,
0.5158811808,
0.5911861658,
-0.1974280179,
0.9645564556,
0.4580906332,
0.4734793007,
-0.2215996385,
-0.0297078472,
0.4794255197,
-0.8698097467,
-0.2136744857,
-1.0318827629,
0.0883089453,
0.1211486831,
-0.174000591,
0.4763243198,
-0.0922946259,
0.3793511093,
0.1886069477,
0.8779761791,
0.154500708,
0.2427730411,
-0.2330043167,
0.9472264051,
-0.5931962729,
0.2888723314,
-0.293346107,
-0.8668474555,
-0.5664812326,
0.7198614478,
-0.3624759018,
0.0769105032,
0.6830738783,
0.4454534948,
0.4606297314,
0.1449665874,
0.3042313457,
0.36282143,
0.6421666145,
0.6751496196,
0.9820234776,
-0.0319185816,
0.1914437264,
-0.1028685197,
0.0173321553,
-0.167698577,
-0.6365957856,
-0.8379164338,
-0.4527598619,
-0.1437168121,
-0.2729873657,
-0.0233891197,
1.4359993935,
0.4540402889,
-0.635576725,
-0.2572971284,
0.15720056,
0.2095371187,
-0.1928449571,
-0.1845953166,
0.1153340563,
-0.2078063637,
-0.5578049421,
0.2031523138,
0.3752176762,
0.100322701,
-0.6179329753,
0.0824195966,
0.0252723955,
0.1528718919,
0.5459467173,
0.1724662036,
-1.0243504047,
-0.3950708508,
-0.3030968308,
-0.3215961158,
0.1174813285,
0.9234085083,
-0.4332743883,
0.075510934,
-0.2328975648,
0.9192210436,
0.0496381745,
-0.1038683504,
0.892418623,
-0.126233086,
-0.0095833456,
0.3445729911,
0.3342974186,
0.5104326606,
-0.8124716282,
0.3860014975,
-0.0110449735,
-0.6224982738,
-1.0186463594,
0.2194728106,
-0.6249477863,
-0.5323272943,
1.016059041,
-0.20456101,
-0.1347632855,
-0.3489122391,
-0.4816790819,
0.4527945817,
-0.0420411862,
1.1442389488,
0.9465598464,
-0.324213624,
-0.191928044,
-0.79688555,
0.4726937413,
0.4326387644,
-0.8771057129,
0.2176311165,
0.4883752465,
0.0784403384,
0.0122517468,
0.6604624987,
-0.0152088646,
0.0494462736,
-0.1316922605,
-0.142873913,
0.0668148547,
-0.290478617,
-0.4719191492,
0.0012393504,
0.2750971913,
0.6891086102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13848v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13848v1
|
Grammatical Error Correction via Mixed-Grained Weighted Training
| 2023-11-23T08:34:37 | 2023-11-23T08:34:37 |
Jiahao Li, Quan Wang, Chiwei Zhu, Zhendong Mao, Yongdong Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The task of Grammatical Error Correction (GEC) aims to automatically correct
grammatical errors in natural texts. Almost all previous works treat annotated
training data equally, but inherent discrepancies in data are neglected. In
this paper, the inherent discrepancies are manifested in two aspects, namely,
accuracy of data annotation and diversity of potential annotations. To this
end, we propose MainGEC, which designs token-level and sentence-level training
weights based on inherent discrepancies in accuracy and potential diversity of
data annotation, respectively, and then conducts mixed-grained weighted
training to improve the training effect for GEC. Empirical evaluation shows
that whether in the Seq2Seq or Seq2Edit manner, MainGEC achieves consistent and
significant performance improvements on two benchmark datasets, demonstrating
the effectiveness and superiority of the mixed-grained weighted training.
Further ablation experiments verify the effectiveness of designed weights of
both granularities in MainGEC.
|
[
-0.0997459143,
-0.8569054604,
0.2320471853,
0.2166817933,
0.0245259684,
0.1214035749,
-0.6429897547,
-0.2259566933,
0.2041766047,
-0.0538280345,
-0.3542897403,
-0.624948442,
-0.9066519141,
0.307608068,
-0.4181984067,
1.1705834866,
-0.2729527354,
0.482298851,
-0.3531223238,
-0.3202347159,
-0.5369728804,
-0.5344060063,
-0.8055242896,
-0.2600527406,
0.6617748141,
0.4426943958,
0.7669202685,
0.396653682,
0.2836655676,
0.3441202641,
-0.2826362252,
0.5255829096,
-0.343534559,
-0.3363757432,
-0.1800836474,
-0.7820253372,
-0.2540809512,
0.0231170133,
0.6957641244,
0.6341392398,
-0.4157869816,
-0.1528630257,
0.2305844575,
0.7254347205,
-0.7242392898,
0.0673560053,
-0.5113787651,
0.2858788967,
-0.3839093447,
0.0574206784,
-0.5080863833,
-0.0884198993,
-0.5910148621,
-0.5794567466,
0.4263759255,
-0.0298575927,
1.0555970669,
0.1575714052,
-0.2437943369,
-0.3871020377,
-0.6092629433,
0.636949122,
-0.8069556355,
0.0664006621,
0.4937891364,
-0.1601685882,
-0.0651703551,
-0.3999603689,
-0.4117328823,
-0.1513250321,
-0.2697868645,
0.3548054695,
-0.0800338089,
0.4001192451,
0.4108860493,
0.643201828,
-0.3994907439,
0.2100693285,
-0.0808608383,
-0.2522738874,
0.5194983482,
-0.137717694,
0.4470334053,
0.0815157816,
0.056880828,
-0.2001588494,
-0.2812431157,
0.2530230284,
0.7186231017,
0.4270485044,
-0.1988339126,
0.5867854357,
-0.3730688095,
0.7465135455,
0.1844397485,
0.0054054325,
0.4622882307,
-0.2986946404,
-0.2742860913,
0.047916431,
0.2490318716,
0.2620743811,
0.4860393703,
-0.2893424332,
-0.2984882593,
0.2266731858,
0.4898498356,
-0.2383206487,
-0.1449478567,
-0.067694366,
-0.1056403518,
-0.3436765373,
0.6783050299,
-0.7507013679,
-0.0495966412,
-0.5411886573,
0.5996254086,
-0.1361190081,
0.194109261,
0.0626474693,
-0.0504116528,
-0.2397211343,
0.3440027833,
-1.2504707575,
0.552314043,
0.7149159312,
0.9552019835,
0.2679282129,
-0.5380491018,
-0.6752517223,
-0.1322630942,
-0.3572177887,
0.6595780849,
-0.4559746385,
-0.3252950311,
0.1601706743,
-0.0627095476,
-0.3584058583,
-0.4901582599,
0.5998296142,
-0.0214924347,
0.3725878,
-0.4959540069,
-0.4704782069,
-0.0408941284,
0.1620806456,
-0.5460028052,
1.5957318544,
0.4064425528,
-1.1689665318,
0.6010524035,
-0.349203229,
-0.746340394,
-0.166411534,
-0.0968209878,
-0.4265104532,
0.3084949553,
0.4627808928,
0.1645005941,
0.1297304183,
0.3393528163,
0.0461300351,
-0.5888137221,
0.1341406256,
-0.1887793392,
0.4054925442,
-0.050412599,
-0.48911798,
0.1182088703,
-0.8159307837,
-0.0045809671,
0.0152155338,
-0.5913874507,
-0.4777489305,
-0.0428288281,
-0.1172912568,
0.1383953393,
-0.1196621209,
-0.6823372841,
0.1387064159,
-0.5097993016,
0.0747950673,
0.8270269036,
-0.3376649618,
0.5901613235,
-0.4766234756,
0.3426203728,
0.1168588698,
-0.0743950158,
0.3220497072,
-0.4633122981,
-0.9631949663,
-0.1559098512,
0.533724308,
0.8667244315,
-0.8831884861,
0.689294517,
-0.1386440843,
-0.2412755787,
-0.5289921761,
0.1755453646,
0.5158943534,
0.5568722486,
0.5042107701,
-0.3068012893,
-0.6394117475,
-0.6037173271,
-0.5813772082,
-0.3500524759,
-0.0141741056,
0.2652334869,
0.4790359437,
-0.2123428434,
0.9811689854,
-0.3985982537,
-0.1983995885,
-0.1830302477,
0.6512739658,
-0.0705529675,
0.459446311,
0.3433150947,
-0.3833199143,
-0.3256653249,
0.166269809,
-0.5167478919,
-0.6611985564,
-0.3356127441,
-0.2805847228,
0.2382078469,
0.1766315401,
-0.3743886948,
0.5736501813,
0.6078273654,
-0.3451249003,
0.5368623137,
-0.4662265778,
0.4968755245,
-0.9033410549,
-0.1516543329,
0.0554251783,
-0.268819809,
-0.6530091166,
-0.1630054414,
0.2313188165,
0.1458708197,
0.0260552485,
0.1840631217,
-0.116190508,
0.011792494,
-0.1630121917,
-0.0539402738,
0.0162912998,
0.3925167024,
-0.4637306631,
0.811952889,
0.3028790057,
-0.2775703967,
0.3774018884,
0.1531566828,
0.1397460699,
0.8279451132,
-0.2420529276,
0.0404777266,
-0.5444319248,
0.254976362,
-0.8174538612,
-0.3943519294,
0.2387076616,
-0.3994447291,
0.4887507558,
-0.0598654337,
-0.4238256812,
-0.4681210518,
-0.2317742854,
0.0153198941,
0.1574222445,
-0.508988142,
0.5504524708,
-0.0175035615,
-0.1851888448,
-0.5951336026,
-1.0452535152,
0.1766297966,
0.075184077,
-0.8860416412,
0.2348112762,
0.1466622502,
-0.2378269136,
-0.1499135941,
-0.1522499025,
0.2186858356,
0.0128210876,
0.2820159793,
-0.0183576941,
-0.0428878851,
0.3750483692,
0.0090137934,
-0.0456121303,
-0.3496743441,
-0.4048663378,
0.3601746261,
-0.185734123,
-0.5044493675,
-0.1914660335,
0.3090516925,
0.0231109988,
0.081146054,
0.7009773254,
0.5433616638,
-0.5571113229,
-0.3465281427,
-0.6361969709,
0.2211752832,
-0.3865024447,
0.3316010833,
-0.0626086146,
-0.8432055116,
0.5725560784,
0.3261765838,
0.0878066048,
0.4277052283,
0.3731982708,
-0.1502838135,
0.6566292644,
0.4395921528,
-0.1726007611,
0.5924006701,
0.2194914073,
-0.0058475453,
-0.5312047601,
-0.133204937,
-0.6361227632,
-0.7202786803,
-0.3374743164,
-0.3689130545,
0.0690065995,
0.1363977641,
-0.1880523413,
0.186352402,
-0.135920167,
0.3673032224,
0.689946115,
0.1275868416,
0.2392704934,
0.3654820621,
-0.344276458,
-0.2403414249,
-0.502202332,
-0.3291764557,
0.813763082,
0.2718694806,
0.8925948739,
-0.2484985441,
0.7991820574,
0.2452851683,
0.2090927064,
-0.7315322757,
0.2595229447,
-0.6782796383,
-0.3718970418,
-0.2373887897,
-0.7733651996,
-0.3332779408,
0.4230087399,
-0.1496838033,
-0.5633920431,
0.1418306679,
0.2107938975,
-0.1991269588,
0.5626881123,
-0.8574157357,
0.8498767614,
-0.2497994751,
-0.1575457007,
0.0630455017,
-0.7295718193,
-0.1194258407,
0.2107394487,
0.2670928836,
0.1543658823,
0.0622703098,
0.6712629199,
-0.6472981572,
0.706471622,
-0.4233083129,
0.068884261,
0.2870503664,
-0.2447598577,
0.8422225714,
-0.0065597254,
0.0162755027,
0.1561360061,
-0.5552645326,
-0.5152925253,
-0.4793350399,
0.2087466419,
-0.670372963,
-0.270483017,
-0.520630002,
-0.492992878,
-0.4712480605,
-0.3334073722,
0.5052015781,
0.3664821684,
-0.2867120802,
0.0498474725,
0.3323088586,
0.059834294,
0.3133967817,
0.1391339302,
0.2445059717,
-0.6178230643,
0.4613977373,
0.3052871525,
0.2607195973,
0.3026520908,
0.106784977,
0.2655863762,
-0.7171267271,
-0.7471045256,
0.1065256149,
-0.7347269058,
-0.1765957177,
-0.6396829486,
-0.2067275196,
-0.2309095412,
-0.4233672321,
-0.4109486938,
-0.1002608165,
-0.4788614213,
-0.4529062808,
0.4042002261,
0.4939166903,
-0.1474426091,
0.8847103715,
-0.6371267438,
-0.0689606145,
0.1474287808,
0.3476696908,
-0.3074831963,
-0.6886011958,
-0.4213816822,
0.3921104372,
0.0665663034,
-0.4356389046,
0.0787218958,
0.4627306759,
0.2729231119,
0.1835634708,
-0.8135009408,
0.9524341226,
-0.4494675696,
0.8032205105,
0.267991066,
-0.9860888124,
0.4912959635,
-0.1394042075,
0.3079699576,
0.9731345177,
-0.2012738585,
-1.0748068094,
-0.3732504249,
-0.6056813002,
-0.7605998516,
0.8317935467,
0.3312613368,
0.0777474344,
0.0906349495,
0.4663537443,
0.1691226661,
0.2134021372,
-0.8474924564,
0.1777135581,
-0.1753217727,
-0.8018612266,
0.0046304241,
-0.2776663005,
-0.2838355005,
-0.0256473441,
1.0343006849,
-0.2709754407,
-0.2050452232,
0.3310200572,
-0.3661442101,
-0.4127046168,
0.4520439804,
0.4199281931,
0.5051006079,
0.1267698407,
0.2597311437,
0.5828140974,
-0.8410348892,
0.1772705168,
0.0698745921,
-0.2320704907,
0.0347693451,
0.513803184,
0.8140608072,
0.433544904,
-0.3201161623,
0.620087564,
-0.0167342946,
-0.1326346844,
0.0751226246,
-0.0024259407,
-0.0624159798,
-0.09957546,
0.2336232215,
0.4171884358,
-0.2030794472,
-0.2779176533,
0.2959369719,
0.2078043669,
-0.0433002636,
-0.2282931954,
0.3641057909,
0.2909430265,
0.1086535901,
0.6538321972,
-0.4753690362,
-0.359952122,
0.5899149776,
0.5404888988,
0.6962218881,
-0.2074537575,
0.49412027,
0.3657401502,
0.5496296883,
-0.5952730775,
0.2305112183,
0.3125279248,
-0.6333860755,
-0.481690973,
-0.8113894463,
-0.1561321467,
-0.3807321489,
-0.6010761261,
0.3768981397,
-0.6252735257,
-0.2012670785,
-0.278652668,
-0.1220002547,
-0.3674390018,
0.4397238195,
0.4599762261,
0.548191011,
-1.3038728237,
0.3952132165,
0.8076305389,
-0.4111290574,
-0.8404145241,
0.0642463714,
0.1474868506,
-0.7363724113,
0.3693224192,
0.086381726,
-0.0255715996,
-0.2100537121,
-0.320212096,
-0.7149876952,
0.9044629931,
0.1381295621,
-0.7970892787,
-0.1218644828,
0.2425475121,
0.5871548653,
-0.383801192,
0.0684744269,
0.5080634952,
0.46753034,
0.2203067392,
-0.888340354,
-0.3088566363,
-0.262614876,
0.390628159,
0.2437661886,
-0.542499423,
1.0642566681,
0.1108543649,
-0.3472476006,
-0.0517759137,
0.672116518,
-0.1939285696,
0.398304373,
0.5397749543,
1.2878139019,
1.0778501034,
-0.5522880554,
0.8228372335,
0.3549736142,
0.5922933221,
1.0502753258,
-0.3973990083,
0.4280669987,
0.395991981,
-0.6507593393,
0.6091110706,
0.7009128332,
-0.2393904924,
0.1871064007,
0.1360191107,
-0.4232940376,
0.1208545715,
0.2642532289,
-0.1383030266,
0.2867080569,
0.1477474123,
-0.2447106987,
-0.3892317414,
0.1422786564,
0.3604849577,
0.2785250247,
-0.6456590295,
0.7688953876,
-0.1125543639,
-0.4983221591,
0.2430446446,
0.4849661589,
1.0600675344,
-0.7116221189,
0.2778475583,
-0.4071016908,
0.1005043685,
-0.7089591622,
-0.5372937918,
0.2344905883,
0.3204577863,
-0.2290449142,
0.0370741114,
0.8155847192,
-0.6626167297,
-0.6795304418,
0.1862822175,
0.0821007714,
-0.1631248146,
-0.1154255122,
-0.3912664652,
-0.1234444752,
-0.0008364619,
0.1236487105,
0.1912505776,
0.3350350857,
0.0440726243,
0.0449304618,
0.564870894,
0.5008640885,
0.2026660144,
0.5719777942,
0.622622788,
-0.4855335653,
-0.7651388645,
-0.8554160595,
0.6908519268,
-0.234087497,
-0.4836390018,
0.5870840549,
0.4842989147,
1.159935236,
-0.2125779539,
0.768445015,
-0.2617686689,
0.2783409655,
-0.800088048,
0.2088567764,
-0.2464033514,
-0.0966139957,
-0.0804301575,
-0.8256583214,
-0.558304131,
0.7316055894,
-0.3435602188,
0.3591835797,
0.9040037394,
0.8916814923,
-0.0164407939,
0.3937956989,
0.0772592351,
0.136097014,
-0.0020299982,
0.4070294201,
0.6354438663,
-0.4078024924,
0.1295292974,
-0.2762876153,
-0.4278268218,
-0.4204088748,
-0.4701402485,
-0.6499615908,
-0.1687373668,
-0.3002237678,
-0.3603355289,
0.4823275208,
1.0820519924,
0.3520206511,
-1.0443065166,
-0.028445527,
-0.4132580459,
-0.1806318313,
-0.3900288641,
-0.1883373857,
0.0387890823,
-0.7396554351,
-0.6606402993,
0.1483262777,
0.3081875741,
0.1978544295,
0.2224852294,
0.0164238848,
-0.4158387184,
-0.0737573281,
0.3758873641,
0.0602582805,
-0.5307517052,
-0.7209849358,
-0.447614342,
-0.337816,
0.3386052549,
1.1001983881,
-0.2646332085,
0.5402629972,
0.5600733757,
0.7757228613,
0.2325644642,
0.4921364188,
0.2905195355,
-1.4386433363,
0.4376084208,
0.1373856068,
0.4849911034,
0.60030514,
-0.5633136034,
0.7123895884,
0.6102215648,
-0.4661744833,
-0.3761243522,
-0.0846397504,
-0.8187140226,
-0.0877921805,
1.2491538525,
-0.1997599602,
-0.1818671674,
0.226023823,
-0.4999465346,
0.4931524396,
-0.141915679,
0.6754133701,
1.5291198492,
0.1621584594,
0.4363215864,
-0.6664531827,
0.4435596466,
0.6448598504,
-1.0316084623,
0.1707321107,
0.665736258,
0.230870828,
-0.0900427401,
0.3779663444,
-0.2578464746,
0.1315342188,
0.1947476268,
0.177518785,
0.0289269313,
-0.3947050869,
-0.6325859427,
-0.1580437422,
-0.0354270786,
-0.0982141867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13833v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13833v1
|
Lego: Learning to Disentangle and Invert Concepts Beyond Object Appearance in Text-to-Image Diffusion Models
| 2023-11-23T07:33:38 | 2023-11-23T07:33:38 |
Saman Motamed, Danda Pani Paudel, Luc Van Gool
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Diffusion models have revolutionized generative content creation and
text-to-image (T2I) diffusion models in particular have increased the creative
freedom of users by allowing scene synthesis using natural language. T2I models
excel at synthesizing concepts such as nouns, appearances, and styles. To
enable customized content creation based on a few example images of a concept,
methods such as Textual Inversion and DreamBooth invert the desired concept and
enable synthesizing it in new scenes. However, inverting more general concepts
that go beyond object appearance and style (adjectives and verbs) through
natural language, remains a challenge. Two key characteristics of these
concepts contribute to the limitations of current inversion methods. 1)
Adjectives and verbs are entangled with nouns (subject) and can hinder
appearance-based inversion methods, where the subject appearance leaks into the
concept embedding and 2) describing such concepts often extends beyond single
word embeddings (being frozen in ice, walking on a tightrope, etc.) that
current methods do not handle.
In this study, we introduce Lego, a textual inversion method designed to
invert subject entangled concepts from a few example images. Lego disentangles
concepts from their associated subjects using a simple yet effective Subject
Separation step and employs a Context Loss that guides the inversion of
single/multi-embedding concepts. In a thorough user study, Lego-generated
concepts were preferred over 70% of the time when compared to the baseline.
Additionally, visual question answering using a large language model suggested
Lego-generated concepts are better aligned with the text description of the
concept.
|
[
-0.4209089279,
-1.0916745663,
0.5598098636,
0.1553722769,
-0.4836778641,
0.545424521,
-0.1512572765,
-0.2874330878,
-0.0583949424,
0.1932843328,
-0.5622999072,
-0.1185022593,
-0.5141375661,
-0.1163483784,
-0.4139381349,
0.9006454945,
-0.0365590118,
-0.0557144135,
-0.9012333155,
0.2443385571,
-0.2376369089,
-0.092614986,
-0.4146098197,
-0.6907300949,
0.1955067962,
0.2727374136,
0.7917188406,
0.5842171907,
0.3653312922,
0.3098654449,
-0.2634642422,
0.101788193,
-0.5193455815,
-0.0295370333,
-0.6258031726,
-0.3137598634,
-0.1065347865,
-0.1870193481,
0.6226233244,
0.7864046693,
0.0692891106,
0.2314982861,
0.2646797001,
1.0486155748,
-0.7467275858,
0.1235941574,
-0.315730691,
0.1550503224,
0.0209301747,
-0.0159271155,
-0.358827889,
-0.2990133464,
0.1124601066,
-0.7511644959,
0.3559899032,
-0.1745945066,
0.9782755375,
0.3566303849,
-0.4576566815,
-0.5935396552,
-0.9464104176,
0.5825657248,
-0.4401636124,
0.3741237521,
0.3062486351,
0.2077309191,
-0.1129480079,
-0.602255106,
-0.872603476,
0.0591285676,
-0.1233078316,
0.4059980512,
-0.1132908538,
-0.2907120287,
0.0492798053,
0.3659017682,
-0.5401850939,
0.006875359,
-0.0579124689,
0.1430337876,
0.5996730328,
-0.0111970073,
0.4840969741,
-0.4070282876,
-0.6398158669,
-0.1375862211,
-0.8499071002,
0.0518998504,
0.4190383255,
-0.0574270971,
-0.1043152362,
0.9044635296,
0.0962613896,
0.5046941638,
0.503531158,
-0.3040655851,
0.3520006835,
-0.3661336005,
-0.1412954181,
0.1686665118,
0.4201824069,
0.5152315497,
0.0626427457,
-0.4176186621,
0.0534082428,
0.0927532166,
0.2714033425,
-0.9444431067,
-0.2471873313,
0.0471405014,
-0.5774540305,
-0.2191299498,
0.0433144011,
-0.8207088709,
-0.7489311695,
-0.3252807856,
0.564383328,
-0.4953794479,
-0.7396194339,
-0.0729627907,
-0.6489630342,
0.1619756818,
0.2480868399,
-0.9039008617,
0.5701467395,
0.5615516305,
0.6767023206,
-0.2908147573,
-0.0692637265,
0.0695536807,
0.5391959548,
-0.6794822812,
0.6540452242,
-0.5446450114,
-0.5013574362,
-0.2097588032,
0.0742090642,
0.2115292698,
-0.5966227055,
-0.3128712773,
-0.5754560828,
0.401900202,
0.1065989658,
-0.7376121283,
-0.2768672705,
0.4164403081,
-0.5790210962,
0.6842337251,
0.1440560967,
-0.6701158881,
0.2850030661,
-0.3835360408,
-0.5726096034,
-0.2562579215,
-0.0271063372,
-0.5348619819,
0.396961391,
0.0942418575,
0.3158792257,
-0.3560149074,
0.1471823454,
-0.2013107687,
-0.2699989676,
0.1826693416,
-0.3967367411,
0.7434663177,
0.0164149627,
-0.455075711,
-0.202552706,
-0.6684727669,
-0.145081535,
0.27859056,
-0.2435870171,
-0.6116036773,
0.3334456682,
-0.0607151128,
0.3199416995,
0.2447144836,
-0.5103430152,
-0.0361279584,
-0.7941974998,
0.2603373528,
0.571203649,
0.2244009078,
1.083856225,
-0.0997058153,
0.4473830163,
0.2770385444,
-0.1237610579,
-0.0184859857,
-0.6413870454,
-0.4750389159,
-0.1940025389,
0.046220161,
0.3247124255,
-1.0846222639,
0.2674300373,
-0.2772466838,
-0.3394029737,
-0.3746267557,
0.2177980542,
0.5416119099,
0.7533808351,
0.3041909337,
-0.2800022364,
-0.2554936707,
-1.0259661674,
0.0207008664,
-0.2850614786,
-0.2957464159,
0.1867147088,
0.4759686291,
0.0645509288,
0.9525302649,
-0.4660204947,
-0.0418794155,
-0.0732106492,
0.291171819,
0.0383081958,
0.6245963573,
0.2693678737,
-1.2959868908,
-0.4611597359,
0.0447381325,
-0.677791059,
0.6087869406,
-0.5152271986,
-0.087013483,
0.3095516264,
0.57697469,
-0.5660766959,
0.9002597928,
0.3240801692,
-0.3508861661,
0.272333324,
-0.2018614262,
0.0385157466,
-1.3864262104,
-0.1987437308,
-0.0410118066,
-0.166527167,
-0.3518308401,
0.0982838944,
0.1922865957,
-0.0087115653,
-0.6279117465,
0.5545399785,
-0.791479826,
-0.1520676762,
-0.2450878769,
0.2677151859,
0.4870667756,
0.3819177747,
0.1743568033,
0.594828248,
0.7096180916,
-0.9650705457,
0.3584334254,
0.3950198889,
-0.4026783109,
0.8109779358,
-0.5379846096,
0.2030324936,
-0.6408268213,
-0.0097512407,
-1.3332233429,
-0.0675413981,
0.3660276234,
-0.4424672425,
0.7237406373,
-0.0119637409,
-0.7101948261,
-0.304522723,
-0.3901432753,
0.6005024314,
0.7542857528,
-0.779633522,
0.7050260901,
0.3796030283,
0.1918761581,
-0.5904943347,
-0.9942720532,
0.0731607154,
-0.2975937128,
-0.304815501,
0.8942630291,
-0.4489357769,
-0.2971484363,
0.5263118148,
-0.1725689024,
-0.4436699152,
0.0338452235,
0.2805501819,
0.0946017057,
-0.0434296392,
0.524964273,
0.2583408058,
0.1996783316,
0.1498559564,
-0.0631786063,
0.4013567865,
0.0258075539,
-0.2773148715,
-0.1875739992,
0.1921234131,
0.2658978999,
-0.0074514393,
0.7513930798,
0.4562909901,
-0.4560435414,
-0.2900813818,
-0.1020117998,
-0.0100221112,
-0.501809299,
0.5903258324,
-0.3074730039,
-0.3705499768,
0.348654598,
-0.3928231299,
-0.3219245076,
0.1829657704,
0.5811193585,
-0.5513441563,
0.8752644062,
0.7945264578,
0.3894020319,
0.4138809144,
-0.4188110232,
0.3352841139,
-1.0748192072,
-0.4817374945,
-0.0691054091,
-0.584425211,
-0.5086058974,
-0.6511472464,
0.142831862,
0.3954987526,
-0.3839172125,
0.4165874422,
-0.4388886392,
0.7757583261,
0.2208076417,
0.6841922998,
0.311139375,
-0.0159192346,
0.1895172447,
0.0659090877,
-0.5870648026,
-0.3877788782,
0.9825914502,
0.1569533199,
0.6742053628,
0.4067601264,
0.651825726,
-0.0754309446,
0.3056862056,
-0.9438162446,
0.5022297502,
-0.1094606146,
-1.012439847,
-0.321231395,
-0.2124319971,
-0.6891672611,
-0.0899092257,
-0.236756891,
-0.479121387,
0.4312750995,
0.1685249805,
0.1691211015,
0.5607886314,
-0.8265346289,
0.5880283117,
-0.0232998542,
-0.676394403,
-0.4362933338,
-0.5473113656,
0.5304490924,
-0.0785182789,
0.1943750829,
-0.0665974841,
-0.4023756087,
0.1784321368,
-0.248399213,
1.0872125626,
-0.0198837798,
-0.0974096358,
0.4254058897,
0.4292162657,
0.3433901966,
0.1082223579,
0.0916818902,
-0.1714078188,
-0.5576871037,
-0.3440690339,
-0.9934244156,
0.5906936526,
-0.4509103596,
-0.5497506857,
-0.002074071,
-0.4902515709,
-0.1714157015,
0.1934741884,
0.3616243601,
0.4006181657,
-0.5327617526,
0.0234245826,
0.7730717063,
-0.4174485207,
0.7524203658,
0.0986730382,
-0.2597773373,
-0.1788161844,
1.2071490288,
-0.1460342556,
0.6205765605,
0.5362516642,
0.4156777561,
-0.5046263337,
-0.385347873,
-0.6193752885,
0.1188502088,
-0.7845464945,
-0.2535547614,
-0.0974928662,
-0.094300814,
-0.1502787173,
-0.2245924473,
-0.386900425,
-0.8806865215,
-0.746337533,
-0.2048954964,
0.0933261588,
0.7927734852,
0.1607928723,
0.0421753973,
-0.3188526928,
0.7285565734,
0.5017976165,
0.4618398547,
0.2280812711,
-0.5537094474,
-0.1012959927,
0.1355564147,
-0.3366492093,
-0.8685312867,
0.0859353989,
0.3422144055,
0.3583399653,
0.5208343863,
-0.0185870249,
0.8610704541,
-0.906747818,
0.7329841256,
0.5502690673,
-1.0701006651,
0.4134139121,
-0.1168910787,
0.1674458832,
0.1816207021,
0.6621466279,
-0.1681096405,
-0.1788701862,
-0.8005774021,
-0.8507221341,
0.3109537363,
0.34251827,
0.4432102144,
-0.1781416088,
0.1543176025,
0.1528321356,
0.5400541425,
-0.6218788624,
-0.3746024072,
-0.5996109247,
-0.3091888726,
-0.1414145082,
-0.1199306324,
-0.1000577509,
-0.4598687887,
0.6278562546,
0.0772414207,
0.400479883,
0.0259589367,
-0.3183389902,
-0.0270522404,
0.0130466213,
0.3542689383,
0.7475939393,
-0.0132170627,
0.3560040593,
-0.081027247,
-0.2624859512,
0.2977089882,
-0.2981986105,
-0.1920406818,
-0.096668832,
0.276278913,
0.430724144,
0.1913068742,
-0.3930917978,
0.5985847116,
0.2771014273,
-0.2814747095,
-0.3077543974,
-0.1008808687,
0.4902402759,
0.2877911925,
-0.1423407942,
0.3112329245,
0.0932573602,
-0.7654626966,
0.2281793207,
0.4405144751,
-0.3013744354,
-0.4865418375,
0.6637907624,
0.0758791044,
-0.4396813214,
0.6205511093,
-0.4382107556,
-0.0228316896,
0.9048130512,
1.0774718523,
0.9350712299,
-0.1184396297,
0.765161097,
0.5505319834,
0.2510251999,
-0.0419284403,
-0.0349341854,
-0.1197672561,
-0.9895692468,
-0.2804772258,
-0.1696584821,
-0.2506482899,
-0.3295829892,
-0.7378813028,
0.0168189276,
-0.6742921472,
0.1131321713,
-0.0839861333,
-0.6113080382,
-0.713963747,
0.1867512316,
0.2829235494,
0.5275045037,
-0.7121789455,
0.639379859,
0.8891057372,
-0.6043596268,
-0.3221048117,
0.2636996508,
0.0271015186,
-0.546982646,
0.627791822,
-0.0044298391,
-0.1497981399,
0.1276721507,
-0.755410254,
-0.920280993,
0.9164447784,
0.2951778173,
-0.2044224739,
-0.1898290664,
0.1535132527,
0.5039667487,
-0.38551265,
0.0391808115,
0.304359287,
0.4402499497,
0.1845584065,
-0.3512905836,
0.0633683875,
-0.1363705248,
0.1846712232,
0.0960586965,
-0.5351345539,
0.75244385,
-0.1763839871,
-0.4783504605,
-0.0021467844,
0.448126018,
0.0789267123,
0.4065151215,
0.5237750411,
0.4641513824,
0.5869262218,
0.1506902575,
1.0173617601,
0.3137792051,
0.2083814591,
1.2403975725,
-0.1087621376,
0.7168184519,
0.7693648934,
0.0785285532,
0.8902308941,
0.3580376506,
0.121577099,
0.8431487679,
0.2900515497,
-0.1240764931,
-0.1806884408,
-0.1146474779,
-0.0818381011,
0.2325247377,
0.5852690339,
-0.2176469713,
-0.3683602214,
0.3489879668,
-0.1775545627,
0.5413719416,
-0.3829440176,
1.0472359657,
-0.1269368678,
-0.1887065917,
0.5135142803,
-0.4047161043,
0.3589063883,
-0.3155863583,
-0.3373150527,
-0.0873500854,
0.1905486733,
-0.2336076349,
-0.76135391,
0.4739254117,
-0.1010384113,
-0.3379819691,
-0.4436831772,
0.5836641192,
-0.5186239481,
-0.7315186858,
0.0684801862,
0.2836047411,
0.1330035627,
-0.0088988664,
-0.8408759832,
-0.4425680339,
-0.0754831508,
-0.3498170078,
0.1760951132,
0.647123456,
0.1465306729,
0.5410636663,
0.1191590279,
-0.1130998135,
-0.1215839833,
-0.2064052969,
1.1160981655,
-0.6290819049,
-0.1709096283,
-0.8050329685,
1.0146197081,
-0.1697488576,
-0.2650977969,
0.8656772375,
0.6594000459,
1.0615087748,
-0.2927447855,
0.4760369956,
-0.2072582245,
0.3499041498,
-0.6589117646,
0.6939229369,
-0.7911489606,
0.0520629548,
-0.7020125985,
-0.9902340174,
-0.1585811973,
0.4863391817,
0.0253441706,
-0.2392282933,
0.9566708207,
0.6930412054,
-0.1966084838,
-0.3062963486,
0.2792702913,
0.0636671484,
0.3944728971,
0.3315607309,
1.0356522799,
-0.4601952732,
0.3947379291,
-0.5136671066,
-0.0852802917,
0.1980760545,
-1.0898678303,
-1.1270247698,
-0.6661375165,
-0.5999415517,
-0.2794429362,
-0.0460766517,
0.490377903,
0.7360730767,
-0.6491091251,
-0.0397844948,
-0.5192696452,
0.6005403996,
-0.4462642968,
-0.2091733962,
0.5154367089,
-0.1269386411,
-0.9018130898,
0.5721400976,
0.1909562051,
0.372468859,
-0.2134623677,
0.0282557197,
-0.2321757674,
0.0444114953,
0.5756394863,
0.0508534871,
-0.5107242465,
-0.2113421559,
-0.0757365227,
0.1976906657,
0.2772546709,
0.6937708259,
-0.9278612733,
0.8100027442,
0.5175311565,
0.6429570913,
0.7700020075,
0.3510951698,
0.4481532276,
-1.0244971514,
0.4950979054,
0.3367215991,
-0.1544940919,
0.4599635899,
-0.3767788708,
0.3400205374,
0.2893877029,
-0.1286574006,
-0.6040944457,
0.61907655,
-0.5553455949,
-0.9105127454,
0.8222090006,
0.2238142043,
-0.6284766793,
-0.0148366531,
0.0092208972,
0.2852590382,
0.0802880228,
0.8264417648,
0.7566095591,
-0.0896392167,
-0.1079676673,
-0.2528400719,
0.5329747796,
0.1397941262,
-0.8084051013,
-0.0001777512,
0.4615366757,
0.1892139018,
0.3592612743,
0.2236246616,
-0.24192518,
0.1747418046,
0.0799454376,
0.2741791606,
-0.2414794862,
-0.5364012122,
-0.302795887,
0.0045733559,
-0.1979419142,
-0.4393764734
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13806v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13806v1
|
AdaTyper: Adaptive Semantic Column Type Detection
| 2023-11-23T04:42:27 | 2023-11-23T04:42:27 |
Madelon Hulsebos, Paul Groth, Çağatay Demiralp
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Understanding the semantics of relational tables is instrumental for
automation in data exploration and preparation systems. A key source for
understanding a table is the semantics of its columns. With the rise of deep
learning, learned table representations are now available, which can be applied
for semantic type detection and achieve good performance on benchmarks.
Nevertheless, we observe a gap between this performance and its applicability
in practice. In this paper, we propose AdaTyper to address one of the most
critical deployment challenges: adaptation. AdaTyper uses weak-supervision to
adapt a hybrid type predictor towards new semantic types and shifted data
distributions at inference time, using minimal human feedback. The hybrid type
predictor of AdaTyper combines rule-based methods and a light machine learning
model for semantic column type detection. We evaluate the adaptation
performance of AdaTyper on real-world database tables hand-annotated with
semantic column types through crowdsourcing and find that the f1-score improves
for new and existing types. AdaTyper approaches an average precision of 0.6
after only seeing 5 examples, significantly outperforming existing adaptation
methods based on human-provided regular expressions or dictionaries.
|
[
-0.2725507021,
-0.5946525335,
0.4473438859,
0.2751716673,
-0.3521126211,
0.1145074964,
0.0469280854,
-0.3965817988,
0.018884737,
0.4965932667,
-0.1621193588,
-0.8611726761,
-0.4524869621,
0.3143803477,
-0.4423434436,
1.1478817463,
-0.3126553893,
-0.2465544492,
-0.4007891119,
-0.4219301045,
-0.4595252275,
-0.1899798065,
-0.3025332987,
0.0663297698,
0.3175546527,
0.6461083293,
0.9083281755,
0.797414422,
0.8060620427,
0.3626434505,
0.105038695,
0.3002273738,
-0.1385257542,
0.1418434978,
-0.0479828939,
-0.6685885787,
-0.7678688169,
-0.5631728172,
0.599445641,
0.5646041036,
-0.4267683327,
0.1742267311,
-0.2365058064,
1.0077928305,
-0.828314662,
0.447239846,
-0.9774717093,
0.3319762349,
-0.2894456983,
0.0202596337,
-0.3761773109,
-0.3247353137,
0.0496188365,
-1.1061149836,
0.4869288206,
0.3570119739,
0.4087887704,
0.4296554327,
-0.6365248561,
-0.3010983765,
-0.8025829196,
0.2484119087,
-0.4583832324,
0.3359044492,
0.0908678994,
0.5960265398,
-0.4408923388,
-0.6572486758,
-0.7985130548,
-0.1988581717,
-0.2228713036,
-0.0199342724,
-0.0488479249,
0.2122919708,
0.0137483608,
0.4326727986,
-0.6566652656,
0.0852413774,
-0.2935979962,
-0.2949662209,
0.4145233631,
0.3616432548,
0.211304456,
0.1048088968,
-0.1030507386,
0.0283993501,
-0.3247185946,
-0.2568856478,
0.005397785,
0.2381447256,
-0.1001694947,
0.3207383156,
-0.4212366343,
1.1050810814,
0.1052157059,
0.0464167818,
0.3392872512,
-0.2294567823,
-0.0674730763,
0.1646635085,
0.4978007972,
0.1093928888,
0.1260288954,
-0.2738217413,
-0.1822347939,
0.3618528545,
0.2705631554,
-0.3882620335,
-0.803147912,
-0.0291110817,
-0.4929985106,
-0.2792910337,
-0.2725906074,
-1.1167281866,
-0.7956584096,
-0.1808408052,
0.7598836422,
-0.4191646874,
-0.2718405724,
0.1500633806,
-0.1020084769,
0.3007282019,
0.6395625472,
-0.8948180079,
0.538639009,
0.5352267623,
0.8319779038,
-0.5111999512,
0.0545972921,
-0.7680749297,
0.302598089,
-0.3295501769,
1.0948182344,
-0.3482945263,
-0.3311485052,
0.0098887449,
-0.1259075105,
-0.293723315,
-0.7050800323,
0.6624026299,
-0.7750080824,
-0.0669079944,
-0.0202459041,
-0.576718986,
-0.138375923,
-0.0433959663,
-0.8256757855,
0.7864186764,
0.5429577827,
-0.7795442343,
1.3177423477,
-0.9209255576,
-0.5155668259,
0.3387514949,
0.1269855797,
-1.0218840837,
-0.0463465825,
0.301397711,
0.2332890481,
0.1673763394,
-0.1273713261,
-0.7630922794,
-0.1999785453,
0.1362643838,
0.3186326027,
0.3645979762,
0.19961375,
-0.0633649677,
0.3328957558,
-1.1850240231,
-0.3050319254,
-0.0494545773,
-0.4245786965,
-0.3395347297,
0.1954130083,
0.2471050918,
0.1949756742,
-0.1953899413,
-0.4219139218,
0.0628003925,
-0.0718688294,
0.1499765664,
0.6287029982,
-0.0576980822,
0.4876485169,
-0.1256201863,
0.4211398661,
0.4031441808,
-0.0723495036,
0.478530705,
-0.1851356328,
-1.2382837534,
-0.4393410683,
0.3554885685,
0.5510449409,
-0.8118792176,
0.5698411465,
-0.519831419,
-0.4576349258,
-0.6997854114,
0.5182703733,
0.1532431543,
0.7835896015,
0.7085733414,
-0.445589453,
-0.6386807561,
-0.6997002959,
-0.4383064806,
-0.2619452477,
0.0331980437,
0.1914762408,
0.6492450237,
-0.1636923999,
1.0933574438,
-0.3647439182,
-0.5472355485,
-0.1999796182,
0.1353911608,
-0.0477049351,
0.4226891994,
0.4582173526,
-1.0113195181,
-0.6207636595,
0.074395895,
-0.6745194197,
0.2514039874,
0.1092266887,
0.0400803201,
0.3207798004,
0.3623069823,
-0.4026916325,
0.1171972379,
0.1773172319,
-0.5851781368,
0.5128918886,
-0.109761402,
-0.2810128927,
-0.802287221,
-0.0403483883,
-0.0626184568,
-0.2720209658,
-0.5935240388,
-0.2925759852,
0.1793223768,
-0.2028265893,
-0.2272662073,
0.2065445781,
-0.4449419975,
-0.382232964,
0.1124919057,
-0.1113708466,
0.054902751,
-0.0159582663,
0.3402914405,
0.8952755928,
0.5512604117,
-0.9209405184,
0.5758969784,
0.6343310475,
-0.6608415246,
0.5885435939,
-0.2872128487,
0.268386662,
-0.3401149511,
0.4155032635,
-1.1111203432,
-0.2541705966,
0.180376932,
-0.1114473417,
0.3583039939,
-0.3808697164,
-0.2467768639,
-0.4228190184,
-0.0426914617,
-0.0863860026,
0.2396630496,
-0.5856227279,
0.8178835511,
0.1535112113,
0.1371223032,
-0.3337158263,
-0.6826803684,
0.1327182204,
-0.4070322812,
-0.6505660415,
0.2901049256,
0.2923910916,
-0.2511468232,
0.1550646424,
-0.4143235683,
-0.2528522313,
0.2780579925,
0.0195834413,
0.3350310028,
-0.6233047843,
0.1150930524,
0.0380528718,
-0.1173124015,
0.0454228967,
-0.2469952255,
-0.0105954576,
-0.1664659977,
-0.0920729861,
-0.2601494491,
-0.1825995147,
0.5560036302,
-0.0817475095,
0.9941927195,
0.9325630665,
0.0193099845,
-0.2931695879,
-0.4109522402,
0.0641154498,
-0.5608618259,
0.6855020523,
-0.4609404504,
-0.6971930861,
0.3171023726,
0.0390829295,
-0.1653945148,
0.4446508288,
0.3667141795,
0.0640881509,
0.7312734723,
0.7366301417,
-0.0974931046,
0.2742577791,
-0.0403246842,
0.0887307823,
-0.6032044291,
-0.199459374,
-0.4124047756,
-0.135638386,
-0.7385941744,
-0.1856257915,
0.4590438008,
-0.4070775509,
-0.1128349155,
0.4513883889,
-0.5356277823,
0.0959594324,
0.2746271491,
0.2093258947,
0.5555536151,
-0.1421228647,
0.2088335901,
0.056984216,
-0.4572203457,
-0.1029121876,
1.0956720114,
0.1217741594,
0.6575320363,
0.2141922861,
0.4533850253,
0.8421915174,
0.4727496505,
-0.8028081656,
0.505974412,
-0.3313318193,
-0.5835587382,
-0.1907684654,
-0.4941772819,
-0.4846535921,
0.3153018057,
-0.4445567131,
-0.3033856153,
0.4598264396,
0.429828167,
-0.2491751015,
0.1441116333,
-0.8261371851,
1.216804266,
0.0268609915,
-0.1352432519,
-0.0868167803,
-0.555871129,
0.3888391554,
-0.1177928522,
0.3014814854,
-0.2607789636,
-0.3254505694,
0.8657713532,
-0.266058743,
0.5077030659,
-0.514254868,
0.1669899076,
0.2221342921,
0.3240819275,
0.5789957047,
0.0370850414,
-0.2969321311,
-0.4423483014,
0.0167494919,
-0.4510975182,
-0.5823828578,
0.2943287492,
-0.7292570472,
-0.4523857832,
-0.3622205853,
-0.6468238235,
-0.5209594965,
-0.0717023611,
0.0638123527,
0.0615793876,
-0.3026821613,
0.0748321414,
0.6171210408,
-0.0233094003,
0.2494576573,
0.7755742669,
-0.0795081928,
-0.2667345703,
1.0852762461,
-0.1250094026,
0.1038413122,
0.7810503244,
-0.0333789177,
-0.2998196781,
-0.9078527689,
-0.7367338538,
-0.2722664177,
-0.613925755,
-0.2539257109,
-0.7222447991,
0.2632900476,
-0.332593441,
-0.1550425738,
-0.0421874709,
-0.7119733691,
-0.3769395947,
-0.1474237442,
1.0896399021,
0.2521409988,
0.1200086325,
0.2989704609,
-0.4804735184,
0.1996880025,
0.7612473965,
0.3552502394,
-0.3547671139,
-0.7394068241,
0.0869898647,
-0.5838386416,
0.107385993,
-0.4945685863,
0.3154962957,
0.7924975157,
0.1621075273,
0.2635668814,
0.0480640419,
0.5175853372,
-0.3470413685,
0.2596023977,
-0.2867304981,
-0.6906893253,
0.3832354844,
-0.3602424562,
-0.0566860549,
0.8215741515,
0.3345149159,
-0.4415269792,
0.0191154089,
0.0333454274,
-0.6169047356,
0.6752234101,
-0.114559792,
-0.1515329033,
0.4156234562,
0.4321524501,
0.2423244715,
0.0924146995,
-0.604300499,
-0.1179731563,
-0.5069894195,
-0.366189301,
-0.1411718726,
-0.1174587458,
0.1565899551,
-0.1491227895,
0.3670947552,
-0.2859383523,
0.1857088655,
0.0676197484,
-0.6197295785,
-0.0073722759,
0.4814733565,
0.3180460334,
0.5339077711,
-0.4997268319,
0.1074690819,
0.4041409492,
-0.6951432824,
0.1236094236,
0.3883036077,
-0.2276844829,
0.0714314133,
0.2282665223,
0.794718504,
0.0699470043,
-0.416683346,
0.3544182181,
0.0824461132,
0.0721450672,
-0.4413709641,
0.4229463339,
-0.1128126606,
-0.3545635939,
0.2052488476,
0.0706466138,
0.5746113062,
-0.4134427607,
0.4088444412,
0.2574712932,
-0.6818785071,
-0.2849771082,
0.6598250866,
0.2486981452,
-0.1487373561,
0.4209165573,
-0.3874913752,
-0.3703159094,
0.6392979026,
0.5924050212,
0.5545312166,
-0.1922403574,
0.2650969326,
-0.0475703329,
0.0001682878,
0.318374157,
0.2159811854,
-0.1669840068,
-0.9674951434,
-0.1437695026,
-0.7376548648,
-0.5221335292,
-0.1698304415,
-0.5621891618,
0.3736703098,
-0.578328371,
0.2502796352,
0.4511154294,
-0.088967815,
-0.576351881,
0.0704423264,
0.1312708408,
1.2069293261,
-1.1760846376,
0.6283245683,
0.8665311933,
-0.4757277668,
-0.2462942302,
-0.356628865,
0.2276639789,
-0.9354662895,
0.4685206115,
-0.1386313289,
0.1568671763,
0.1272009611,
-0.1624865979,
-0.860735178,
0.9706209898,
0.1769171953,
-0.2933369279,
0.0093844216,
0.2589555681,
0.6752748489,
-0.2763437629,
0.2060663253,
0.8481297493,
0.5637697577,
-0.1140014529,
-0.7740619779,
0.1799869388,
0.0552279986,
0.17558375,
0.4141509831,
-0.4962728024,
0.349006027,
-0.0486760996,
0.1899820268,
-0.141323626,
1.0232266188,
0.0581185482,
0.3250072002,
0.6926050782,
0.5439444184,
0.4458730519,
0.1511142403,
0.6733126044,
0.104783684,
0.054134801,
0.9197644591,
-0.6181319356,
0.5251514912,
0.1850888431,
-0.5497452617,
1.0004569292,
0.3749763072,
-0.2704499364,
0.6295819879,
0.0768366605,
-0.6310645342,
-0.1517573297,
-0.0408535004,
-0.3458923697,
0.5794205666,
0.7738654613,
-0.2234203368,
-0.3059521019,
-0.1079644784,
-0.1155411452,
0.151342541,
-0.542599082,
1.0382369757,
-0.1273141503,
-0.3482427597,
0.4346133173,
-0.1372384727,
0.5407438874,
-0.2129653394,
-0.1102409884,
-0.0260533839,
0.4924606085,
-0.4694476128,
-0.6141597033,
0.2813218832,
-0.3849827051,
-0.1092310324,
0.3617193997,
1.006901741,
-0.2484773844,
-0.557015717,
0.140379712,
0.3075746894,
-0.1992502511,
0.0782742724,
-0.5789369941,
-0.1243532598,
-0.3897427619,
0.0670189708,
0.5995408297,
0.6700003147,
0.0352813788,
0.7256051898,
0.430152148,
-0.1136433333,
0.2353333086,
-0.1951820254,
0.8148044944,
-0.309427321,
-0.3508699536,
-0.4659309089,
0.2655605972,
-0.0406419486,
-0.3241279423,
0.426974535,
0.7217834592,
0.3732767999,
-0.4867586493,
0.6776672602,
-0.1485824436,
0.6298877597,
-0.4719578028,
0.6786534786,
-0.0909707397,
-0.0507911257,
-0.4600392878,
-0.7984523177,
-0.5452395678,
0.3615585268,
-0.5602632761,
-0.2484150678,
0.4299203455,
0.8272809386,
-0.4282776415,
-0.0715350434,
-0.0333237387,
0.2362865508,
0.0308347326,
0.4207655489,
0.5694265366,
-0.1968203932,
1.0003840923,
-0.1244011819,
-0.2695693672,
-0.4393847287,
-0.8213354945,
-0.6686492562,
-0.5205947757,
-0.452758342,
-0.4146882296,
0.4967437088,
0.6445502639,
0.6146608591,
-1.2914611101,
0.0442367345,
-0.5315083265,
0.2527762651,
-0.2425088137,
-0.2945451438,
0.6952754259,
-0.4166958034,
0.0898375362,
0.1620623916,
0.1715370268,
-0.2032844722,
0.12674658,
0.2834341824,
-0.0492111258,
-0.5000598431,
0.4758522511,
0.5320979357,
-0.2803753614,
-0.3851848543,
-0.2543383539,
0.1986725628,
0.3342858851,
0.6028279662,
-0.9803805351,
0.4480767548,
0.2908170223,
0.6897841096,
0.6705749631,
0.0154876774,
0.4116598964,
-0.443713069,
0.1998008192,
0.3756169081,
0.3403396606,
0.502034843,
-0.3630135059,
0.433947295,
0.5177870989,
-0.4745972753,
-0.6482434273,
0.1829640567,
-0.931289494,
0.2030548751,
0.9172829986,
0.0792484358,
-0.3485710621,
-0.7897893786,
0.0376841202,
0.173787415,
-0.6365582347,
1.2347753048,
0.2767285407,
-0.2883511782,
-0.1436657012,
-0.2317077965,
0.9546308517,
0.3047925234,
-0.8528116941,
0.0712561235,
0.4350537956,
0.577221334,
0.1041086614,
0.4522115588,
-0.0208432116,
0.5883099437,
0.050712917,
0.174349919,
0.100984931,
0.0231076013,
-0.3260184526,
-0.0516010709,
0.3470023572,
-0.2975777686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13784v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13784v1
|
DaG LLM ver 1.0: Pioneering Instruction-Tuned Language Modeling for Korean NLP
| 2023-11-23T03:03:54 | 2023-11-23T03:03:54 |
Dongjun Jang, Sangah Lee, Sungjoo Byun, Jinwoong Kim, Jean Seo, Minseok Kim, Soyeon Kim, Chaeyoung Oh, Jaeyoon Kim, Hyemi Jo, Hyopil Shin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents the DaG LLM (David and Goliath Large Language Model), a
language model specialized for Korean and fine-tuned through Instruction Tuning
across 41 tasks within 13 distinct categories.
|
[
-0.2272904068,
-1.0451381207,
0.2806340158,
0.2155963629,
-0.1544437408,
0.1033997014,
-0.156295076,
-0.05881631,
0.2173854113,
0.7332996726,
-0.9849315286,
-0.7707849145,
-0.657956779,
0.0911999121,
-0.0183620229,
0.9454709291,
0.1582973748,
0.2449629903,
0.0428695083,
0.0143857114,
-0.4448892176,
-0.3869361281,
-1.0552235842,
-0.5612919927,
0.4382972419,
0.3673067689,
1.0613442659,
1.187268734,
0.6351625919,
0.2637730837,
-0.3199525774,
0.0285917688,
-0.3666132092,
0.0114322361,
-0.1177666709,
-0.5209983587,
-1.0734499693,
0.1420948058,
0.5736678243,
0.9627454281,
-0.3388373554,
0.2196377963,
-0.1250150651,
1.026242137,
-0.0899110064,
0.3125142157,
-0.5445680022,
-0.0338482223,
0.0531819724,
-0.2482422739,
-0.2374636084,
-0.2593376935,
0.3480044901,
-0.59927845,
-0.0872287303,
-0.0776502043,
0.6400957704,
0.8146992922,
-0.735745132,
-0.8057511449,
-0.4948047996,
0.9190769792,
-0.8597269058,
0.3750802875,
0.5970270038,
0.2069291919,
-0.4714489579,
-1.1596519947,
-0.3743977547,
-0.4166047573,
0.1480646878,
0.0796528608,
-0.0315307006,
0.5078213811,
0.0782060921,
0.6638533473,
-0.7782239914,
0.3877655268,
-0.040763136,
0.1810582876,
1.0043176413,
0.3129043579,
0.5218541622,
-0.3094379008,
-0.4470571876,
0.1513916254,
-0.6604069471,
-0.3547727168,
0.6589929461,
0.1649606228,
-0.302652508,
0.5599312782,
-0.1795981228,
1.2558249235,
0.2214881629,
-0.4548636973,
-0.0863935202,
-0.1850390136,
-0.4269329906,
0.1891615689,
0.4117369354,
0.3824670017,
0.3710809052,
-0.2191387415,
0.0389427096,
0.1124926358,
0.3555167317,
-0.4548305273,
-0.5352805257,
-0.0056241825,
-0.5325409174,
-0.2017490715,
-0.0615810826,
-0.6322368979,
-0.3699985445,
-0.5023450255,
0.0934685245,
0.0229779407,
-0.2659073174,
0.5706644058,
0.341756314,
0.0822813362,
0.031603381,
-1.0687419176,
0.352504313,
0.5450716615,
0.4117660224,
-0.6094841361,
-0.3130129278,
-0.2189235985,
-0.0530504361,
-0.4372910261,
0.3348279893,
-0.5764113069,
-0.1813630909,
-0.0531234369,
0.2772339582,
-0.2935068905,
-0.521230638,
0.6712530255,
-0.9048214555,
0.1846917868,
0.0468204618,
-1.0552567244,
-0.6618356705,
0.1562137008,
-0.7092785239,
1.0115343332,
0.6560287476,
-0.5927593708,
0.2541671991,
-0.7426003814,
-0.231758669,
0.4849401414,
0.0179348104,
-0.0364119485,
0.0477135219,
0.1184650958,
0.5822278857,
-0.2669280469,
0.4024669528,
-0.0508468039,
-0.3615567088,
-0.2124023736,
-0.208654359,
0.9990675449,
0.2113242745,
-0.1366760284,
0.2972617745,
-1.2269308567,
0.2731031477,
0.1228913963,
-0.6849181056,
-0.2822287977,
-0.1022594422,
-0.1549834609,
0.4124253988,
0.4463896453,
-0.2056122124,
0.6019011736,
-0.5438839197,
0.3302398324,
0.3476368785,
-0.091589123,
0.6395233274,
-0.2642267644,
1.1443573236,
-0.3530923426,
-0.2153416574,
-0.3172617257,
-0.5093537569,
-0.8279042244,
-0.3507733941,
0.5925409198,
0.781948328,
-0.6629588604,
0.7059863806,
-0.0855279267,
-0.4189442098,
-0.8048294187,
0.3141706884,
0.3651072681,
0.2226507664,
-0.015038386,
0.1828817576,
-0.5936322808,
-0.8456525207,
0.0273927245,
-0.0363434069,
-0.1117755324,
0.6492312551,
0.2541183233,
-0.3148172498,
0.3445696533,
-0.63365376,
-0.0445527881,
-0.3952661753,
0.0140731195,
0.351479739,
0.1454673409,
0.6065275669,
-0.5340165496,
-1.0749841928,
0.0674949959,
-0.6377775669,
-0.4177304804,
0.0264835805,
0.1083278507,
0.3593813181,
0.9117930532,
-0.373236239,
0.3188921511,
0.8419988751,
-0.5282608867,
0.4468134344,
-0.4280971885,
0.194320485,
-1.1141719818,
-0.4607704282,
-0.2049515843,
-0.2790249884,
-0.7148826122,
0.5294904113,
0.0770249069,
0.2489012778,
-0.4827052951,
0.8103151917,
-0.5453389287,
0.1716327071,
-0.8805111051,
0.2158940881,
-0.3580281138,
0.6432222128,
-0.0301256478,
0.6056911349,
0.8470560908,
-1.0928897858,
0.8595247865,
0.1761556268,
-0.3453194797,
0.5123530626,
-0.8130776882,
0.3851622045,
0.0399036407,
-0.1346484721,
-1.0096555948,
-0.631916225,
0.1394515932,
-0.0711575001,
0.5875646472,
-0.4233411849,
-0.4844627082,
-0.6095887423,
0.093838498,
0.2169522941,
0.5101021528,
-0.7220877409,
0.3206242621,
0.4078921676,
-0.3787799478,
-0.3542764485,
-0.4387907088,
0.0487745218,
-0.4263151288,
-0.8023664951,
0.6145440936,
-0.2448848635,
-0.3211472929,
-0.1929307729,
-0.1398707777,
-0.1978174001,
0.0692559555,
0.1884111613,
0.3052271903,
-0.4208276272,
0.17493321,
0.0945204571,
-0.1344145834,
-0.0052669779,
-0.2033261806,
0.8800585866,
-0.1396118701,
-0.2285912186,
-0.2878616452,
-0.0245699994,
0.3599688113,
0.2190479338,
0.4840036631,
0.4833830893,
-0.1799529791,
-0.4247992933,
-0.2061712444,
0.1699790061,
-0.5677527785,
0.7778113484,
-0.2815593481,
-1.1098058224,
0.4843474925,
-0.3130097091,
-0.3225436509,
0.4410212636,
0.8617960811,
0.1929104626,
1.139423728,
0.9278349876,
-0.0561139919,
0.1720539778,
0.0167025663,
0.0910867751,
-0.6189932227,
-0.0616782568,
-0.1700487584,
-0.5177335143,
-0.8550054431,
-0.2706770897,
0.1564429402,
0.4940614402,
-0.1476967931,
0.2790629566,
-0.5899950862,
0.73225528,
0.614169538,
-0.1269862503,
0.1478233337,
-0.2559897304,
-0.130467087,
-0.1981578171,
-0.9397542477,
-0.7533444762,
1.352355957,
0.3732079268,
0.9909386039,
-0.2879352868,
0.5274240971,
0.0315075405,
-0.320910573,
-0.8804870844,
0.7024147511,
-0.5028606057,
-0.7106196284,
-0.2716121376,
-0.1279411763,
-0.8967107534,
-0.2345096618,
0.2170664966,
-0.6178962588,
-0.4628495872,
0.0115378788,
-0.1026394218,
0.1828169525,
-0.452821821,
0.8566629291,
-0.253672123,
0.2118472755,
-0.2821193337,
-0.5497403145,
0.3919197023,
0.1206818521,
-0.2502334714,
-0.1068330556,
-0.2376385033,
0.5766851306,
0.0356103405,
0.5754185915,
0.0123489024,
-0.4702187479,
0.3784797788,
0.1370230466,
0.6254146695,
0.0727402195,
0.059523508,
0.0157999061,
-0.2126027197,
-0.2152228206,
-0.565063715,
1.0883226395,
-0.5074298382,
-0.5555942059,
-0.0509273931,
-0.9131454825,
0.0490893275,
0.0689958483,
0.2070822865,
-0.134651497,
-0.0954584256,
0.1459847987,
0.763718307,
-0.4746577144,
0.5847740769,
0.7510102391,
-0.5658997297,
-0.5071955919,
0.6686184406,
0.0702946931,
0.3975024223,
-0.0110068414,
0.157684207,
-0.3365386426,
-0.5797071457,
-0.4937361181,
0.2605038881,
-0.7531682849,
0.0116799865,
-0.5829530954,
-0.5750883818,
-0.1988454014,
-0.1768769026,
-0.4687021077,
-0.6468730569,
-0.3724335432,
-0.0839755312,
0.3057852089,
1.2686979771,
0.1865860522,
0.8179029822,
-0.5171753168,
0.6498659253,
0.3819710016,
0.8040310144,
-0.2859903872,
-0.9268001318,
-0.2110318393,
0.1342508048,
-0.2451541424,
-0.7602655292,
0.4358478487,
0.342769444,
0.7792302966,
0.2840695381,
-0.2275348604,
0.3527618945,
-0.6363882422,
0.9724211693,
-0.0477841608,
-0.5923147202,
0.5970000625,
-0.5099123716,
0.4934311211,
0.0386106931,
0.6706229448,
-0.5087004304,
-0.0455388874,
-0.459405899,
-0.7168062925,
1.0931283236,
-0.3228746057,
0.229492262,
-0.4416673481,
0.6920329332,
0.3426247239,
0.1103147939,
-0.807602942,
-0.7522443533,
-0.0079481201,
-0.3641940057,
0.0878724158,
-0.6638006568,
-0.0165442303,
-0.4455312192,
0.7295769453,
-0.1082999632,
-0.119133845,
-0.1861451417,
-0.0304316673,
-0.1796204448,
0.25969854,
0.6903796792,
0.7606124282,
-0.0132725043,
-0.1076731607,
0.06431292,
-0.7491224408,
0.3104489446,
0.0183332451,
-0.321059823,
-0.1530257016,
0.2167387456,
0.9910360575,
0.2479292303,
-0.4203571677,
0.0966132283,
0.2049718648,
-0.6754696369,
-0.038358625,
0.3891720772,
0.4197977185,
0.3412397206,
0.1516955346,
-0.6010240912,
-0.1453969777,
-0.1011760682,
0.289521724,
0.3694560826,
-0.5292650461,
-0.3620879054,
0.894017756,
0.0404624417,
-0.7306371927,
0.5697024465,
-0.6522424817,
-0.4474009275,
0.6297697425,
0.9208784103,
1.0152710676,
-0.433912009,
0.3906671703,
0.5344814658,
0.2093365937,
-0.2661769092,
0.6602498889,
0.4368737936,
-0.4225869775,
-0.6639969349,
-0.8633308411,
-0.0607833453,
0.6241004467,
-0.6394534707,
0.3997482955,
-0.4028035104,
-0.1977072656,
-0.0613203123,
0.2053533345,
-0.4921055734,
0.3487788141,
0.3618397117,
0.7832103968,
-0.4727501273,
0.9751647115,
1.1349226236,
0.150070861,
-0.6890898347,
-0.2329083234,
-0.039001517,
-0.8305795789,
1.083876133,
-0.238207072,
-0.06620083,
0.5097049475,
-0.625161469,
-1.2275586128,
1.0574502945,
0.4380015731,
-0.6535044909,
-0.0557876527,
0.2011939138,
0.5866487026,
-0.6230334044,
-0.3279775083,
0.7898803353,
0.3103925884,
0.0464344956,
-1.122179985,
-0.3253128529,
-0.1212237552,
0.0238329917,
0.1459718794,
-0.4956263006,
0.7725858092,
-0.1058054864,
-0.1632666141,
0.063526243,
0.5731424093,
0.1839384288,
0.1593659669,
0.3075436056,
0.7680727243,
0.6805969477,
-0.0740571916,
1.0154310465,
-0.7555354834,
0.0610431395,
1.3842600584,
-0.3157483041,
0.3304699957,
0.1584245861,
-0.4657325149,
0.1664057821,
0.6815584302,
-0.0070928317,
0.5615808964,
0.6116458178,
-0.2005269527,
-0.0590739436,
0.0547150336,
-0.203739658,
0.7871424556,
0.2756514847,
-0.4072054923,
-0.1007264927,
-0.1213943213,
0.0494441241,
0.3833477795,
-0.7379651666,
0.7942425013,
0.0248557664,
-0.6976607442,
0.7762487531,
0.2438931763,
0.7846760154,
-0.5531932712,
-0.1023379117,
-0.1351577193,
0.1068129539,
-0.0581767671,
-0.5546231866,
0.3588477671,
-0.1310493052,
-0.2362776548,
-0.0277219675,
0.9448126554,
-0.8016076684,
-0.4421512783,
0.5172172189,
0.4498888552,
0.1226104945,
-0.0168316476,
-0.851082027,
-0.115264833,
-0.0181685816,
-0.6363837719,
0.2323663831,
0.3747928143,
0.0465029813,
0.94718045,
0.1070478857,
0.1847724169,
0.8075191975,
0.2091029882,
0.5298558474,
-0.794803679,
-0.4741932154,
-1.0186084509,
0.3022021055,
0.3305607736,
-0.3530318737,
0.9995219111,
0.3927289248,
0.9547123909,
-0.3838679492,
0.6586999893,
-0.0765504241,
0.5703831315,
-0.6183283329,
0.786647439,
-0.5751268268,
0.2500113845,
-0.0593485609,
-1.1009122133,
-0.2258376926,
0.5530592799,
0.0200855806,
0.2206333429,
0.6395105124,
0.7795704007,
0.014604033,
-0.0094401455,
0.6135708094,
0.0533271283,
-0.1660947204,
0.3174075186,
0.6302884221,
-0.3472467959,
0.3677181602,
-0.2878311872,
-0.1763121039,
-0.0784582421,
-1.0513451099,
-1.2962654829,
-0.3235915005,
-0.6941043735,
-0.0452054888,
-0.1281540096,
1.0005799532,
0.5889334679,
-0.738753438,
-0.2254482359,
-0.3342616856,
0.0444541276,
-0.2428476959,
-0.2042824626,
0.5570196509,
-0.5888543725,
-0.869833529,
0.6981731653,
0.5321269631,
0.1665628403,
-0.2815592289,
-0.4957485497,
-0.3306716383,
0.2081437856,
0.5758296251,
-0.010175447,
-0.8788992167,
-0.0034832254,
0.3852421045,
-0.2939349711,
0.0327500626,
0.5865385532,
-0.3507135808,
0.4735783637,
0.3116401732,
0.6497559547,
0.3310293555,
-0.2271431535,
0.6962895989,
-0.8035704494,
0.0761770979,
0.1336347312,
0.0466113053,
0.1647838205,
-0.3205288053,
0.8909833431,
0.0074765133,
-1.0210886002,
-0.6957207322,
0.4902070165,
-0.9246810675,
-0.2547765374,
1.3220374584,
-0.2965568304,
-0.1205394939,
-0.0460761674,
-0.2538829148,
0.4661512673,
0.4892585278,
0.8918002844,
1.1968567371,
0.0093739824,
-0.2924087942,
-0.9876689315,
0.8809797168,
0.1622958779,
-0.670669198,
-0.0080190124,
0.2704767585,
0.1475950927,
-0.2498200238,
0.5443021059,
-0.1086121798,
0.3948925138,
0.2454771101,
0.0838116258,
-0.1829431802,
-0.5581704974,
-0.5109891295,
-0.1641268879,
-0.0224331934,
-0.2148676813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13755v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13755v1
|
Transformer-based Named Entity Recognition in Construction Supply Chain Risk Management in Australia
| 2023-11-23T01:06:08 | 2023-11-23T01:06:08 |
Milad Baghalzadeh Shishehgarkhaneh, Robert C. Moehler, Yihai Fang, Amer A. Hijazi, Hamed Aboutorab
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The construction industry in Australia is characterized by its intricate
supply chains and vulnerability to myriad risks. As such, effective supply
chain risk management (SCRM) becomes imperative. This paper employs different
transformer models, and train for Named Entity Recognition (NER) in the context
of Australian construction SCRM. Utilizing NER, transformer models identify and
classify specific risk-associated entities in news articles, offering a
detailed insight into supply chain vulnerabilities. By analysing news articles
through different transformer models, we can extract relevant entities and
insights related to specific risk taxonomies local (milieu) to the Australian
construction landscape. This research emphasises the potential of NLP-driven
solutions, like transformer models, in revolutionising SCRM for construction in
geo-media specific contexts.
|
[
-0.1476271451,
-0.6660193801,
0.1852554381,
-0.0456041172,
-0.2188559324,
0.0656910241,
0.2092867196,
-0.6690415144,
0.2498929948,
0.8488829732,
-0.5348344445,
-0.2430391461,
-0.6551987529,
0.3334410489,
-0.6781073809,
1.0491415262,
-0.3851572573,
-0.3985829651,
-0.1234345585,
-0.1342251748,
-0.2142427415,
-0.8513205051,
-0.648961544,
-0.085871093,
0.5136620402,
-0.024491027,
0.8238239288,
0.3883451521,
0.800281167,
0.2358049601,
-0.4246727228,
0.073536329,
0.1909919977,
0.1217369139,
-0.7039639354,
-0.3945652246,
-0.120005019,
-0.3986398578,
0.4735158384,
0.4071136713,
-0.5562950969,
0.6274930239,
-0.0398436934,
0.4394532144,
-0.844832778,
0.252623409,
-0.8531988859,
0.0382252336,
-0.0067712618,
-0.3485737145,
-0.5092208385,
-0.1287211329,
0.3111399412,
-0.3925524056,
0.412971586,
0.4875616729,
1.1948617697,
0.4055024385,
-0.7603706717,
-0.4728355408,
-1.1100846529,
0.2722723782,
-0.3862655163,
0.4762657285,
-0.070609875,
0.3993280828,
-0.0006931431,
-0.9061856866,
-0.2012419999,
0.3825687766,
-0.4062176049,
-0.2489803582,
-0.2308935076,
-0.1031720415,
0.2504488826,
0.6146318316,
-0.4186117649,
0.1584390402,
-0.5629321337,
-0.2190310061,
0.7462206483,
0.4066990614,
0.4560602605,
-0.4867357314,
-0.8201086521,
0.019167278,
-0.8174018264,
0.0654932112,
0.4525605142,
0.434073627,
-0.0510644391,
0.622715652,
-0.135889709,
0.5727484822,
-0.1218804121,
-0.2094788104,
0.3260336816,
-0.0276916455,
-0.5082262754,
0.3836800158,
0.7367853522,
-0.0156118525,
-0.1133154556,
-0.2132165432,
-0.2323579639,
0.1674416512,
0.7155308127,
-0.3602052629,
-0.2448263466,
0.0161627866,
-0.2059550583,
-0.4074791968,
0.411342591,
-0.5687081218,
-0.4644199312,
0.1201469526,
0.2847498357,
0.3768064976,
-0.5637074113,
0.1495643854,
-0.4160871208,
0.5256636739,
0.012300632,
-0.5026801825,
0.208512634,
0.2242340595,
0.4969322085,
0.0780050829,
-0.0353305005,
-0.3977500796,
0.5164914727,
-0.1870756745,
0.842965126,
-0.2502114475,
-0.1857911497,
0.1690435559,
0.3545744717,
-0.1190418079,
-0.6424425244,
0.3460747004,
-0.7179256678,
0.1708178371,
0.221467346,
-0.1665433049,
-0.3055804074,
0.342620343,
-0.8889116645,
1.170294404,
0.5435737967,
-0.9267093539,
0.4664347768,
-0.2676805258,
-0.5520452261,
0.3405038714,
0.0068236808,
-0.9935050607,
0.2553216219,
0.2167180479,
0.3979472518,
-0.3589349687,
0.3059434295,
0.2017065287,
-0.014034491,
0.1307508498,
-0.4528245926,
0.4297835529,
0.1333845705,
-0.4673135281,
0.2270299047,
-0.6720272899,
-0.2263130397,
0.1159365028,
-0.0986531526,
-0.4269036353,
0.0506263152,
0.3018776476,
0.7498088479,
-0.0580146536,
-0.1068347991,
-0.1709219217,
-0.4213660061,
0.7403022647,
0.3715542555,
0.5956524014,
0.6239073873,
-0.1788321137,
0.6691139936,
0.2270031124,
0.3617466688,
0.0997771919,
-0.3458160162,
-0.9402469397,
0.0629230216,
0.2570753694,
0.7500242591,
-0.7785233259,
-0.0130368741,
-0.338751018,
-0.771790266,
-0.2715133429,
-0.2070573121,
-0.0516547523,
0.1548506618,
0.402867943,
-0.4021913707,
-0.8601025343,
-0.6211566925,
-0.4008396566,
-0.4068363905,
-0.13633959,
0.3249441087,
0.3920837641,
-0.4086736739,
0.9330370426,
-0.7613962293,
-0.3150806129,
-0.4372039139,
-0.0410010964,
0.4025857151,
0.1093727946,
0.2248689532,
-1.2429022789,
-0.134288609,
-0.1939938515,
-0.6271953583,
0.3894823194,
-0.6012667418,
-0.0168201495,
0.1047695279,
0.4900647998,
-0.9492595792,
0.5951578617,
0.2130882889,
-0.2822718322,
0.6782849431,
-0.0585857816,
-0.368892163,
-1.2078499794,
-0.2942768335,
0.1942550838,
-0.0944118723,
-0.4917016923,
0.2252182215,
0.1094118059,
-0.4056093097,
-1.0411071777,
0.2884784639,
-0.7777464986,
-0.2427959293,
0.0335621461,
-0.1125070825,
0.2489342242,
0.2533207238,
0.3719004095,
0.5454418659,
0.5569434166,
-0.8503864408,
0.3455841839,
0.653691411,
-0.3764302433,
0.559081316,
-0.5941686034,
-0.1430240422,
-0.0772105902,
0.1697462946,
-0.4684323072,
-0.0412036777,
0.4268978536,
0.0641477332,
0.1708665043,
-0.2162773311,
-0.619525671,
-0.8894123435,
0.2970665991,
0.0236900207,
0.3603109717,
-0.4832749665,
1.1798222065,
0.3397766054,
-0.4362747073,
-0.5224817395,
-0.7774040699,
0.2235801816,
-0.5457381606,
-0.21188429,
0.3319967389,
0.3934625387,
-0.0172877759,
0.031829197,
-0.7054644227,
-0.3541605771,
0.2633657753,
0.7454752326,
0.3778309226,
-0.1297563165,
-0.0656914711,
-0.1982133985,
-0.3250293434,
0.5702237487,
-0.0760430321,
0.236167416,
0.0251605324,
-0.1886667609,
-0.4002535641,
0.3035302758,
0.4408858716,
-0.8026694655,
1.0651884079,
0.3223535717,
-0.5687944293,
-0.3072799444,
-0.5793852806,
0.0354892574,
-0.5157446861,
0.2789529562,
-0.208306253,
-0.6547385454,
0.4133467972,
-0.5034508705,
-0.271912843,
0.7671142817,
0.2520616651,
0.0733938664,
0.544057548,
0.931735158,
-0.1642259061,
0.3299133182,
-0.3655464053,
0.814946115,
-0.6147075891,
-0.5017141104,
-0.3929928839,
0.1375714093,
-0.60790658,
-0.2622317672,
0.2373827398,
-0.1455822885,
-0.4717754722,
1.0240654945,
-0.7665784359,
0.2882845104,
0.160615772,
0.0399049148,
0.452385515,
-0.0396476202,
0.1792729199,
0.4199650288,
-0.8375919461,
-0.6865635514,
0.4554952085,
0.3375087976,
0.8084290028,
-0.1358362436,
0.6319723725,
0.139749676,
0.4261332452,
-0.7604067326,
0.1613076925,
0.3925872147,
-0.9406746626,
-0.1381489784,
-0.3472851813,
-0.870018959,
-0.061104618,
-0.4357909262,
-0.3380375504,
0.3339969814,
-0.19872576,
-0.4526461363,
0.8365881443,
-0.2896690071,
0.5702813864,
-0.0843189508,
0.2963168025,
0.1798066944,
-0.5319374204,
-0.062103305,
0.0422652066,
0.6267873645,
0.0658121035,
0.1022857279,
0.3557483256,
-0.2579747438,
0.7681800723,
0.2811469436,
-0.2800444067,
0.6829923391,
-0.055759836,
0.8816159964,
0.315263927,
-0.0126900943,
0.4329119027,
-0.2897182703,
-0.0145182908,
-0.3560069799,
0.4178757071,
-0.5842913389,
-0.4361926019,
-0.6917809248,
-0.4568230212,
0.208830744,
0.1397835314,
0.5713880062,
0.3818860054,
0.0111646131,
-0.1290389448,
0.4136193991,
-0.0395554416,
0.7392171025,
0.4555101693,
0.3736339211,
-0.4915221035,
0.4955933094,
0.3000481129,
0.0899555981,
0.5257809758,
-0.4634214342,
-0.2581738532,
-0.4179108739,
-0.4859493971,
0.074999474,
-0.6654471159,
-0.8313939571,
-0.5957142115,
-0.8864162564,
0.1279332489,
-0.6340088844,
-0.387973398,
-0.1923425198,
-0.2540525794,
-0.6493788362,
0.2580347955,
0.853400588,
0.5440711379,
0.4723080099,
-0.836381197,
0.2018755823,
0.2467834651,
0.5786636472,
-0.4141130447,
0.0521704815,
-0.3835837245,
-0.1136113927,
-0.3402638435,
-0.8691681623,
0.5277506709,
-0.1531092376,
0.6852060556,
0.3968744278,
0.3929203451,
0.2705328763,
-0.6616521478,
0.8294722438,
0.2614011765,
-0.9604358673,
0.6258642673,
-0.0617800727,
-0.1827370077,
0.1408539414,
0.6799928546,
-0.5502135754,
-0.3130513728,
-1.1737109423,
-1.4716535807,
0.3486045599,
0.4329607785,
0.2142066061,
-0.2219820768,
0.3138848543,
-0.1830987632,
0.1351223588,
-1.0460108519,
-0.546305716,
0.1496900916,
0.141984731,
0.107059963,
-0.5589998364,
-0.027266996,
0.3872386515,
0.9715200663,
0.2397108972,
0.0894329175,
0.1396536678,
-0.5042677522,
-0.2438087016,
0.6675728559,
-0.0340222009,
0.5479825735,
-0.0635939389,
0.252820909,
0.6792649031,
-0.373906225,
0.3836457431,
0.1110797301,
-0.1888433695,
0.3199320734,
0.2049392462,
0.7515802383,
0.4459200203,
-0.3757976592,
0.4468237162,
0.0797420815,
-0.1039742455,
-0.8314768076,
0.0701538026,
-0.0835238099,
0.422904402,
0.502564013,
0.4463616312,
0.2481349111,
-0.1861530542,
0.1869448572,
0.1298508346,
-0.7547621131,
0.0092741121,
0.9438461065,
0.0037913111,
-0.5794270635,
0.6025076509,
0.0586008988,
-0.4659733176,
0.7773779631,
0.721678555,
0.8104376793,
-0.3775019348,
0.2893224061,
0.4838849902,
0.6187543273,
-0.2467812598,
0.180158481,
0.396538049,
-0.6372517943,
-0.2994522452,
-0.5413530469,
-0.5394913554,
-0.0526637286,
-1.1101075411,
0.6648697257,
-0.4158171415,
-0.1462083608,
-0.1575386971,
-0.2932879925,
-0.8986296654,
0.5096777678,
0.4922832251,
0.9107432961,
-1.181727767,
0.2298200727,
1.0312765837,
-0.4838413596,
-1.0878132582,
-0.2369545996,
-0.0577985235,
-0.2704223394,
0.3907777667,
0.404279381,
0.020887062,
0.0120106293,
-0.0809943154,
-1.2179971933,
1.415260911,
0.0908686742,
-0.6827989817,
-0.2936607599,
0.5031203628,
0.2520948052,
-0.2566949427,
0.1911091357,
0.2430692315,
0.1708805412,
-0.1018432975,
-0.7560959458,
0.1781342328,
-0.0992475823,
0.3331267536,
0.7101323605,
-0.456707716,
0.3204410672,
-0.1826739311,
-0.5073554516,
-0.3340541124,
0.7351785898,
0.2174678743,
0.4415031075,
0.5509206653,
0.6807410121,
0.5637444258,
-0.011716336,
0.8383650184,
-0.2961404026,
0.6137448549,
1.0402554274,
-0.1003172174,
0.9407612681,
0.4672763646,
-0.2301053256,
1.0492138863,
0.6429654956,
-0.2210739255,
0.4446253479,
0.3131337762,
-0.1069724783,
-0.2444943041,
-0.1745448112,
-0.6036093831,
0.4509873092,
0.3878912628,
-0.4691444933,
-0.3216935396,
-0.0037136239,
-0.0642827377,
-0.0295036212,
-0.5622260571,
0.6632434726,
0.2588493526,
0.2262930721,
0.1048481986,
-0.0119962534,
0.4705602229,
-0.4700044692,
0.285695374,
0.1469971538,
-0.0307041984,
-0.4367370903,
-0.5126863718,
1.0122556686,
-0.2963263988,
-0.4642578363,
-0.3973020911,
0.7074536085,
-0.2403552383,
-0.7366530895,
0.2847542167,
0.3362849951,
-0.3394442499,
-0.6362665296,
-0.3328947425,
-0.2693635225,
-0.548230648,
-0.114212811,
0.261754334,
0.4889746606,
-0.2210108787,
0.7184895873,
0.5812334418,
-0.1486450732,
-0.2131458223,
-0.063034296,
1.0840277672,
-0.8918331861,
-0.6642341018,
-0.7950996757,
0.7122946978,
-0.0023785508,
-0.1825110167,
0.580421865,
0.6425934434,
0.8019786477,
-0.3217241466,
0.4481835663,
0.1148775592,
0.1151551455,
-0.1233395338,
0.6893023252,
-0.1411541998,
0.5368103981,
-0.5669686198,
-0.9984657764,
-0.5462462902,
0.2871188521,
-0.3996685743,
-0.7415992022,
0.7944450974,
0.6097470522,
-0.0016629348,
0.1444762945,
-0.1247368082,
-0.106011875,
0.0201998595,
0.5698370934,
0.8666843176,
-0.9124642611,
0.9770210981,
-0.3106330633,
0.4716006815,
-0.1748668849,
-1.1071851254,
-0.6482848525,
-0.4148033559,
-0.7579172254,
-0.4090803266,
-0.1477269679,
0.7343184948,
0.5701195598,
-0.9803622961,
0.1031282321,
-0.1625069976,
0.5050145984,
-0.6970508695,
-0.2816181183,
0.3064956963,
0.1671298891,
0.0360582694,
0.0599690489,
0.546862185,
-0.0346298367,
0.1046647355,
0.3245607913,
-0.0180327948,
0.1308302134,
0.5137918591,
0.0412579477,
-0.6172295213,
-0.3224830627,
-0.1611144692,
-0.0986504406,
0.1172384098,
0.6519762874,
-0.6969161034,
-0.1588084996,
0.3493514657,
0.6495752931,
0.4475035071,
-0.099131234,
0.3298380673,
-0.706804812,
0.1810396314,
0.1402702481,
0.4839828908,
0.5697054267,
-1.1236606836,
0.785338819,
0.3256888986,
-0.4051137269,
-0.622769475,
0.4180086255,
-0.7671035528,
0.0665435791,
1.0502091646,
-0.0425115973,
-0.1636981368,
-0.337199986,
0.0256863181,
0.3956385553,
0.1362008899,
0.6442358494,
0.3570895195,
0.3343322277,
-0.2954803407,
-0.3916669786,
0.1412280053,
-0.1945787221,
-0.8027052283,
-0.0903199837,
0.2318858653,
0.5463775396,
0.1822770834,
0.2129399627,
-0.0255014636,
0.0144433416,
-0.0404569879,
0.1084719002,
0.0240692291,
-0.7413351536,
-0.1676869541,
0.5956218243,
-0.2252738774,
0.1250591874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13735v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13735v1
|
Surpassing GPT-4 Medical Coding with a Two-Stage Approach
| 2023-11-22T23:35:13 | 2023-11-22T23:35:13 |
Zhichao Yang, Sanjit Singh Batra, Joel Stremmel, Eran Halperin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) show potential for clinical
applications, such as clinical decision support and trial recommendations.
However, the GPT-4 LLM predicts an excessive number of ICD codes for medical
coding tasks, leading to high recall but low precision. To tackle this
challenge, we introduce LLM-codex, a two-stage approach to predict ICD codes
that first generates evidence proposals using an LLM and then employs an
LSTM-based verification stage. The LSTM learns from both the LLM's high recall
and human expert's high precision, using a custom loss function. Our model is
the only approach that simultaneously achieves state-of-the-art results in
medical coding accuracy, accuracy on rare codes, and sentence-level evidence
identification to support coding decisions without training on human-annotated
evidence according to experiments on the MIMIC dataset.
|
[
-0.1390826553,
-0.2902176082,
0.9488437772,
0.0862990916,
-0.337405324,
0.0373131968,
-0.1707825661,
-0.5019023418,
-0.0468224473,
0.6052161455,
-0.4599082172,
-0.8844440579,
-0.8137024045,
0.1345070451,
-0.2475965917,
0.9695144892,
-0.3646836877,
0.4248439074,
0.0174719635,
0.0573009141,
-0.3556402028,
-0.6852582693,
-0.4835969508,
-0.5932399631,
0.4460105002,
0.3471239805,
0.377807796,
0.7272490859,
0.6919157505,
0.0830690712,
0.1195719466,
0.3258710206,
-0.1182445139,
-0.3064756393,
0.0707784519,
-0.7285180688,
-0.7568974495,
-0.2124565542,
0.3903675079,
0.5086635947,
-0.4312984645,
-0.1276784092,
-0.1350791901,
0.3574561477,
-0.1042985395,
0.3486354649,
-0.6670442224,
-0.0089800721,
-0.0454354249,
-0.4443972409,
-0.6671546102,
-0.4238726795,
-0.1699537486,
-0.4258784056,
0.3234895468,
-0.2509080172,
0.5725938082,
0.243985042,
-0.5269761682,
-0.5687767267,
-0.625873208,
0.2979837358,
-0.8467404842,
0.373719871,
0.7193716764,
0.1150135994,
-0.308772862,
-1.005264163,
-0.4897918999,
-0.2035640031,
0.0708691031,
0.0875035971,
0.028763121,
0.4021542072,
0.2168829441,
0.0880884305,
-0.7209199071,
0.4485620558,
-0.5014006495,
-0.2937438488,
0.3141130209,
0.0684533119,
0.3988565505,
0.1348157525,
-0.4084427655,
0.139618203,
-1.0823444128,
-0.359849602,
-0.2182056159,
0.1097603068,
-0.193125695,
0.5361838937,
0.1507045627,
0.3189822733,
0.2310644239,
-0.527859807,
0.2714672089,
-0.300088048,
-0.1191504523,
0.2798247933,
0.4087136686,
0.5533033013,
0.0555926934,
-0.1092766225,
-0.1541346014,
0.2846354842,
0.5208585858,
-0.7896634936,
-0.1382604092,
0.2960833013,
-0.5691375136,
-0.1641965508,
-0.4274270833,
-0.4604583085,
-0.5092161298,
-0.1586616337,
0.3487131596,
-0.3166820705,
0.0591403209,
0.4245265126,
0.3018210232,
-0.0484578311,
0.5353347063,
-0.8864755034,
0.4582734704,
0.7412781715,
0.8477357626,
-0.1104047298,
-0.1542423069,
-0.3383153677,
0.2612831593,
-0.8427246809,
0.8419187665,
-0.3667099476,
-0.1908349246,
0.1980835199,
-0.1944727153,
0.3229004741,
-0.510343492,
0.8754204512,
-0.5848466754,
-0.2730928659,
-0.2142062485,
-0.6766414046,
-0.1465369165,
0.2963673472,
-0.6917764544,
0.7568573356,
0.3521562815,
-0.6121457815,
0.7275723219,
-0.2597866058,
-0.496250838,
0.2046114504,
-0.5165862441,
-0.4472097158,
0.084820427,
0.2099484354,
0.4349658191,
-0.49508515,
0.5693606138,
-0.0958917588,
-0.3555445969,
-0.1828644276,
-0.2748017907,
0.0966832787,
0.0801433995,
-0.3340954185,
-0.0609167963,
-0.6862772107,
-0.0783987939,
0.0510953441,
-0.7596873641,
-0.0530008487,
0.0969521403,
-0.1338306367,
0.3524324,
0.0675543249,
-0.6287062168,
0.6448509097,
-0.4536529183,
0.3774555027,
0.5695573688,
-0.0062133572,
0.298273772,
-0.4285125732,
0.4989123344,
-0.107202284,
0.0132337427,
-0.1856399626,
-0.6809701324,
-0.4219794273,
0.0698908642,
0.2288403213,
0.4382586777,
-0.8084333539,
0.2444887459,
-0.2714452744,
-0.4579266012,
-0.2835467458,
0.1089769378,
0.4878567755,
0.5282447338,
0.5639312267,
-0.5195768476,
-0.5713241696,
-0.8066532016,
0.1392808706,
-0.5836611986,
-0.0512069613,
0.16558294,
0.3697186112,
-0.5047808886,
0.6206611991,
-0.3989699483,
-0.4961716831,
-0.6541482806,
0.2905951142,
0.473950386,
0.5096136332,
0.4027228355,
-0.6599040627,
-0.2520457208,
0.2378764153,
-0.5911997557,
-0.1729722917,
-0.1855015159,
0.3395883739,
0.3273073435,
0.4504302144,
-0.5313311815,
0.6752074957,
0.4121236801,
-0.1227444112,
0.4010495543,
-0.6991564035,
0.2665215433,
-0.8157396317,
-0.2327225208,
-0.0514958166,
-0.0197723396,
-0.8227075338,
-0.0801548585,
0.5883125663,
0.2803395391,
-0.1287080348,
0.6054709554,
-0.2470255345,
-0.116038084,
-0.291444242,
-0.3341867626,
-0.1010547206,
0.4843151867,
0.2760196328,
0.5885196328,
0.1674592495,
-0.4194668829,
0.053951744,
0.3352541029,
-0.4818823338,
0.1317506582,
-0.5009306073,
0.0759981722,
0.0029436518,
0.7161517739,
-0.773216188,
-0.3042176068,
0.1097114012,
-0.2956192791,
0.6087836027,
-0.3263287544,
-0.7872946858,
-0.8421829343,
-0.1019255072,
0.7850465775,
0.6430764794,
-0.5545597672,
0.4549463987,
0.2350864559,
-0.5010206699,
-0.3543928266,
-0.8122119308,
0.3703279793,
0.1053770855,
-0.2610051632,
0.4742875099,
-0.3201674521,
0.1332042962,
-0.5258345604,
-0.2634754777,
-0.2178225368,
-0.1924882382,
0.2824783027,
0.4249894023,
-0.1421947181,
0.2211441696,
0.1431621462,
-0.2481056303,
0.0817220211,
-0.4810823202,
0.6481206417,
0.2373194546,
-0.7238778472,
-0.5328409076,
0.2242398709,
0.4553355575,
-0.0330600888,
0.0843895599,
0.5235760212,
-0.7887642384,
-0.2913759351,
-0.8039641976,
-0.0724266917,
-0.3961294293,
0.7553057075,
-0.2412234545,
-0.7700083256,
0.4379672706,
-0.0307561159,
-0.0352330767,
0.246537596,
0.9477068186,
0.221513778,
1.2555600405,
0.4400041401,
0.0348330326,
-0.1580416858,
-0.0893311501,
0.1127249524,
-0.5556171536,
-0.564570725,
-0.5123671889,
0.0217636079,
-0.3465300202,
-0.8075037003,
0.6687629819,
0.0901786983,
-0.3741676807,
0.160412088,
-0.3795690536,
0.3312879801,
0.4289634228,
0.3980902135,
0.3750484586,
0.0058386805,
-0.2971248031,
0.0779704377,
-0.738941133,
-0.4831967056,
1.4435557127,
0.5882815123,
0.8925995827,
0.025755303,
0.7959091663,
0.4039072096,
0.5753145218,
-0.6243796945,
0.3715472817,
-0.3939720392,
-0.4912711978,
0.123754546,
-0.1476529688,
-0.5494080186,
-0.1529152095,
0.002277863,
-0.685634613,
0.0615340322,
0.1394677013,
-0.5348897576,
0.3996340632,
-0.3662990928,
0.4647684097,
-0.3208237588,
-0.0903657302,
-0.2693285048,
-0.6083888412,
0.4037074447,
-0.5073462725,
0.4075022042,
-0.0254915543,
-0.2392570525,
0.7132681608,
-0.503125906,
0.9179275036,
-0.1074886248,
-0.4316627085,
0.0640333518,
0.2334132195,
0.6648352742,
0.2563968897,
-0.065607965,
0.2582309246,
0.058205191,
-0.2581055164,
-0.5014955401,
0.5353095531,
-0.6472679973,
-0.3183385134,
-0.3974888027,
-0.3439512849,
-0.3676365912,
0.2610515952,
0.4194325209,
0.7743806243,
-0.1131903976,
-0.3264248967,
0.5505081415,
-0.5015158653,
0.2399154007,
0.5155127645,
-0.0300647933,
-0.5237415433,
0.4995687604,
-0.0096592056,
0.3777148426,
0.4021795094,
-0.0275814906,
-0.2190069854,
-1.291274786,
-0.7110744715,
0.2917978466,
-0.8675544858,
-0.4744328558,
-0.5410721302,
-0.1556833833,
-0.3439224362,
-0.2527704537,
-0.2544725537,
-0.0803557262,
-0.1739769131,
-0.2787202895,
0.131813392,
1.3059515953,
-0.1754973531,
0.1372051388,
-0.9678971767,
0.4584874213,
-0.1233269945,
0.6663022637,
-0.1953112334,
-0.3260262609,
-0.4608297944,
-0.0234411117,
-0.1226083487,
-0.7423876524,
0.4701730907,
0.0035303603,
0.5152218342,
0.4554371238,
-0.1713587344,
0.471924901,
-0.9422532916,
0.7447959185,
0.6002142429,
-0.6875749826,
0.473482877,
-0.2900318503,
0.0563896857,
0.3787159324,
0.226638034,
-0.4186758995,
-0.2177377492,
-0.4539853334,
-0.5897151828,
0.7967674136,
-0.1072677374,
-0.1348761767,
-0.2675997913,
0.7428973913,
0.2999512553,
-0.0045036729,
-0.4862596989,
-0.0869193524,
0.1627802998,
-0.4644757807,
-0.1363121122,
-0.5836613178,
-0.1993691176,
-0.0994928852,
0.2662288845,
-0.3547253907,
0.4816654623,
0.3881978095,
0.0619334877,
-0.368183881,
0.2332064807,
0.8503246307,
0.7936474681,
-0.2472022325,
0.1856209189,
0.3258771598,
-0.7751944661,
0.2496621609,
0.0462044179,
0.1153205037,
-0.0483529568,
0.7407487035,
0.4431747794,
0.318470329,
-0.7294193506,
0.7703822255,
-0.1344548762,
-0.5629723072,
-0.26898399,
-0.173696503,
0.0213009603,
0.2960164845,
0.4752861261,
0.0894277245,
0.094345957,
-0.3193867207,
0.5997356772,
0.1505425274,
-0.2312902063,
-0.366268605,
0.7228230834,
-0.0137346545,
-0.0757088587,
0.2753461003,
-0.1633111984,
-0.5501722097,
0.9979839325,
0.8687922955,
0.5874837637,
-0.1831269413,
0.1580685526,
0.4207172096,
0.2245931625,
-0.6257375479,
0.3550006747,
0.2662862539,
-0.6720593572,
-0.613503933,
-0.6590725183,
-0.2565380931,
0.0790823698,
-0.7151159048,
0.4144198596,
-0.7674740553,
-0.0440499857,
-0.0771789625,
-0.0483402759,
-0.6136982441,
0.3034203649,
0.3599976301,
1.0874704123,
-0.4129309654,
1.1322606802,
0.2684578896,
-0.3056138158,
-1.0158786774,
-0.1133309677,
0.177712813,
-1.1880809069,
0.6931407452,
0.161062479,
0.1579978466,
-0.0902908072,
-0.4646356106,
-0.6560566425,
1.2581416368,
0.2245348394,
-0.7922186255,
-0.4609407187,
0.0120995203,
0.4855769277,
-0.4952684641,
0.268126756,
0.6704874635,
0.3238139749,
0.3618375063,
-1.3401844501,
0.1089834869,
-0.0882637575,
-0.224287048,
0.3258335888,
-0.1613808572,
0.7570650578,
-0.6767635345,
-0.1208132654,
0.3725478649,
0.1923435181,
0.1825971007,
0.5865719914,
0.1591594517,
0.535433352,
0.7180477977,
-0.0187876131,
1.1697560549,
-0.4809948206,
0.3853843808,
1.0527693033,
-0.5456533432,
0.8157739639,
-0.0601141863,
-0.408305347,
0.3646287024,
0.7856959105,
-0.1103455946,
0.5382195711,
0.2321244031,
-0.2348707169,
-0.2570509911,
-0.0077100233,
-0.4895036519,
0.1630208641,
0.5085557103,
-0.4355748594,
-0.2225528508,
0.0320586786,
0.0510352962,
-0.0812511146,
-0.6190879941,
0.9431397915,
0.136262998,
-0.7035696507,
0.7753466368,
0.2434454262,
0.5085770488,
-0.6009995341,
-0.3742516339,
-0.1447340101,
0.2758579552,
-0.2444244772,
-0.5280821919,
-0.0809967071,
-0.0927402154,
-0.1356516629,
-0.1259592623,
0.6585348248,
-0.5309568048,
-0.5675682425,
0.3239375055,
0.3020341098,
-0.0391800962,
0.2397412956,
-0.3238177299,
0.0282286983,
0.0214020889,
0.210864231,
0.389295429,
0.2463332117,
-0.0060688984,
0.6216693521,
0.5127914548,
0.4609567821,
-0.1818315089,
0.3308722079,
1.0079863071,
-0.6141213179,
-0.5481399298,
-0.6772674322,
-0.0738307238,
0.4164010882,
-0.042984087,
0.0545364842,
0.4642038047,
0.6000435948,
0.1567875296,
0.9808986187,
0.3346326053,
0.5791684389,
-0.7666174173,
0.5421842933,
-0.4561806321,
0.539447248,
-0.2169678658,
-0.4400040209,
-0.7323663831,
0.2976618409,
-0.2051571012,
0.1845077425,
0.8655343652,
0.8482609391,
0.1487769634,
0.0422305577,
0.3317686319,
0.4714013636,
0.4806441069,
0.9294679761,
0.5871239901,
-0.1451879293,
0.4475648999,
-0.0390590951,
-0.34569484,
-0.2985756695,
-0.657597363,
-0.8596177697,
-0.4256411493,
-0.0072816806,
-0.5850997567,
0.1550219804,
1.1129735708,
0.7131425738,
-0.6113738418,
0.1231185123,
-0.2456599474,
-0.2092904299,
-0.0648728833,
0.0466227978,
0.7103547454,
-0.2143664658,
-0.4065519571,
0.4227629304,
0.50195539,
0.1227875128,
0.0236380082,
-0.4323369265,
0.0707182512,
-0.1353458464,
0.3652207255,
0.0527564101,
-1.0358351469,
-0.2193289399,
-0.1621517837,
-0.3218782842,
0.2506398261,
1.0536227226,
-0.7108792067,
0.3794049621,
0.0787391216,
0.6776152253,
0.6265050769,
0.0226094685,
0.5707238913,
-0.2985847592,
-0.1525366902,
0.3753481209,
0.3262942433,
-0.0334005952,
-0.4100344777,
0.4947760403,
0.1404724121,
-0.6042991877,
-0.8059014678,
0.3031727374,
-1.1083959341,
-0.2449142486,
1.2193248272,
-0.2631298304,
0.1900936514,
-0.4791276753,
-0.2786664963,
0.1667771786,
-0.2354781032,
0.7056552768,
0.4466341734,
-0.1962113529,
-0.0792001188,
-0.6509026289,
0.7737087607,
0.1110245511,
-0.744515717,
-0.0177018233,
0.5327467322,
0.3414973021,
0.0596498549,
0.9895606637,
-0.2164428234,
0.5470409393,
-0.0316598453,
0.2765524089,
-0.0328726955,
-0.4220124185,
-0.3815714717,
0.2285922617,
0.4804292619,
0.3178978264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13729v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13729v2
|
Comparison of pipeline, sequence-to-sequence, and GPT models for end-to-end relation extraction: experiments with the rare disease use-case
| 2023-11-22T22:52:00 | 2024-03-10T01:11:20 |
Shashank Gupta, Xuguang Ai, Ramakanth Kavuluru
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
End-to-end relation extraction (E2ERE) is an important and realistic
application of natural language processing (NLP) in biomedicine. In this paper,
we aim to compare three prevailing paradigms for E2ERE using a complex dataset
focused on rare diseases involving discontinuous and nested entities. We use
the RareDis information extraction dataset to evaluate three competing
approaches (for E2ERE): NER $\rightarrow$ RE pipelines, joint sequence to
sequence models, and generative pre-trained transformer (GPT) models. We use
comparable state-of-the-art models and best practices for each of these
approaches and conduct error analyses to assess their failure modes. Our
findings reveal that pipeline models are still the best, while
sequence-to-sequence models are not far behind; GPT models with eight times as
many parameters are worse than even sequence-to-sequence models and lose to
pipeline models by over 10 F1 points. Partial matches and discontinuous
entities caused many NER errors contributing to lower overall E2E performances.
We also verify these findings on a second E2ERE dataset for chemical-protein
interactions. Although generative LM-based methods are more suitable for
zero-shot settings, when training data is available, our results show that it
is better to work with more conventional models trained and tailored for E2ERE.
More innovative methods are needed to marry the best of the both worlds from
smaller encoder-decoder pipeline models and the larger GPT models to improve
E2ERE. As of now, we see that well designed pipeline models offer substantial
performance gains at a lower cost and carbon footprint for E2ERE. Our
contribution is also the first to conduct E2ERE for the RareDis dataset.
|
[
-0.1247642338,
-0.5108429193,
0.4842091799,
-0.2985773683,
-0.2978917062,
-0.1129477099,
-0.0066685653,
-0.7487721443,
0.0776766911,
0.5344964862,
-0.235472858,
-0.1946575195,
-0.8137213588,
0.3198453486,
-0.453437686,
1.0610721111,
0.0782435387,
0.2057468742,
-0.012625616,
-0.147776559,
-0.2792047262,
-0.4202576578,
-0.7853761911,
-0.3835313022,
0.4751418829,
0.0537828654,
0.5641047359,
0.323466897,
0.7328109145,
0.0907740965,
-0.3131611645,
-0.0417191461,
-0.7596828341,
0.242221579,
-0.1179141253,
-0.370031029,
-0.5780573487,
-0.0788061172,
-0.0047677266,
0.9230673313,
-0.1054360196,
0.0169438701,
0.0110718403,
0.6846264601,
-0.4778980017,
-0.1883398741,
-0.3838425577,
0.4328844249,
-0.1657402068,
0.0266337506,
-0.4762729108,
-0.1437920332,
0.4567371905,
-0.4469596744,
0.2361323833,
0.0735205486,
0.9376872182,
0.3029545248,
-0.4896533489,
-0.3385306895,
-0.9821482301,
0.5470548272,
-0.9812562466,
0.5729364753,
-0.0136261452,
0.2393101007,
-0.1506836861,
-1.0436714888,
-0.3537302315,
-0.2151279449,
-0.0595714822,
0.5778647661,
-0.437640667,
0.1313530654,
0.4173268974,
0.462339282,
-0.8892838955,
0.5459216833,
-0.5319835544,
0.1110356003,
0.2313054353,
-0.0229296181,
0.1992374361,
-0.3096244335,
-0.3516857028,
0.149043262,
-1.0192317963,
-0.3450393379,
0.2054003477,
-0.0623160489,
-0.0629770532,
0.8025814295,
-0.0722855702,
0.6495903134,
-0.0124583086,
0.3972017169,
0.2198058814,
-0.2003046125,
-0.3648642302,
-0.2493643761,
0.6466141939,
0.5544221997,
0.2933747172,
-0.5707107782,
-0.0909647346,
0.0219479892,
-0.1585156769,
-0.851436317,
-0.2922441661,
0.4778560996,
-0.7662090063,
-0.0149919447,
-0.096474722,
-1.0096106529,
-0.0312498305,
-0.2509630024,
0.2646429837,
-0.2536678612,
-0.370077312,
-0.04656519,
-0.3519670963,
0.3889097869,
0.1526942104,
-0.6395125389,
0.5045042038,
0.5480362177,
1.0095986128,
-0.4474810064,
0.1948411018,
-0.7349032164,
0.1745836437,
0.0024962889,
0.8054357767,
-0.4816890061,
-0.3098599017,
-0.2328359336,
-0.0487932302,
-0.0536482371,
-0.7145631313,
0.53893435,
-0.5980074406,
0.4254992902,
-0.107939072,
-0.7339841127,
-0.0683325902,
-0.1116331965,
-0.8819798231,
0.5734223723,
0.3118469417,
-0.7269413471,
0.3961118758,
-0.7110947371,
-0.2710606456,
0.0653676614,
-0.303329587,
-0.403876096,
0.2443237752,
0.0257203318,
0.4544040859,
-0.7546204329,
0.1729668528,
-0.4027512074,
-0.141578123,
-0.0569872968,
-0.4845063984,
0.6175239086,
0.4156538248,
-0.1626582146,
-0.3111014664,
-0.7579361796,
-0.0385902561,
0.1948864311,
0.0253339447,
-0.1732036173,
-0.050647378,
0.2512645125,
0.5570908785,
-0.0863410458,
-0.5190126896,
0.0471063182,
-0.6196933389,
0.5617236495,
0.4022620916,
0.2146866769,
0.3044342995,
-0.252040416,
0.2936676443,
0.2309034765,
0.1236536801,
-0.0101221157,
-0.6356405616,
-0.450717777,
0.0974818468,
0.4430373907,
0.746158421,
-0.465741545,
0.2131621689,
-0.427903682,
-0.1947515756,
-0.3795984983,
-0.2036571503,
0.2856436968,
0.4624757469,
0.5479897857,
-0.5821166635,
-0.5029903054,
-0.8679718375,
-0.1281361133,
-0.0191499274,
-0.3545434773,
0.3502011299,
0.4484809339,
-0.2434538901,
1.007458806,
-0.3956897855,
-0.2032077312,
-0.2125907987,
0.0531180501,
0.429284811,
0.2713251114,
0.3536941707,
-0.7218796611,
-0.4451431036,
0.284740448,
-1.1134240627,
-0.0017352513,
0.0768125579,
0.2199264914,
0.2201621383,
0.1044173613,
-0.6735110879,
0.4132151902,
0.5130744576,
-0.0403259695,
0.2984646857,
-0.098053813,
0.0256025698,
-1.1040554047,
0.2654983401,
0.2048862875,
-0.2384757549,
-0.8638905287,
-0.0177285429,
-0.2860922217,
0.0566563606,
-0.4278011918,
0.1214745641,
-0.743330121,
-0.3529874682,
0.0004704584,
-0.112060681,
-0.0055153654,
0.3426353037,
0.1737644821,
0.3948931098,
0.3103954196,
-0.3063317835,
0.3060247898,
0.1470605731,
0.0660812557,
0.2195205539,
-1.1001448631,
0.4991485178,
-0.1817335635,
0.1953698695,
-0.8058547974,
-0.1260942221,
0.3868329823,
-0.3859608769,
0.8139845729,
-0.4404848218,
-0.4076891243,
-0.3116933405,
-0.1740846485,
0.1808326691,
0.7122594118,
-0.225687027,
0.3263137937,
0.2031360418,
-0.4146595299,
-0.4640515745,
-0.7694632411,
0.2625025809,
-0.3728204668,
-0.520958364,
0.4134936631,
0.0942537412,
-0.0678378567,
0.1016456112,
-0.1185661554,
-0.3333997726,
-0.1575103402,
0.1210164949,
0.1631776094,
-0.2107510418,
-0.1845445633,
0.1461772621,
-0.28815189,
-0.1205122694,
-0.1958610117,
0.4125487208,
0.14325279,
-0.3331686556,
-0.1846273094,
0.7327847481,
0.5121883154,
-0.0556588396,
0.6442527175,
0.2997563481,
-0.6281781793,
0.1941718906,
-0.3580430448,
-0.3494768143,
-0.2942701876,
0.5580312014,
-0.2395735979,
-0.7306969166,
0.4868361056,
-0.4890665114,
0.2400562167,
0.5499514341,
0.3883919418,
-0.1904519349,
0.5182614326,
0.5341761708,
0.1340958178,
-0.0960169211,
-0.4667677283,
0.5781823397,
-1.1029394865,
-0.2668025196,
-0.3068501055,
-0.0340932161,
-0.514321208,
-0.4680650234,
0.4889916778,
0.36704427,
-0.072921358,
0.5071918368,
-0.3613424003,
0.194686085,
-0.0205616131,
0.0980490372,
0.4613387287,
0.2212843597,
0.039927315,
-0.282463789,
-1.0174951553,
-0.5784039497,
1.4288896322,
0.5113649964,
0.441947192,
0.3705758154,
0.6643932462,
0.1511368155,
0.474760592,
-0.8333585262,
0.0348343663,
-0.3230544329,
-0.4291825593,
-0.3978996873,
-0.3151822388,
-1.0225790739,
0.0813518688,
-0.0505592972,
-0.8086147308,
0.4416691959,
0.0208235197,
-0.2698890567,
0.3384787142,
-0.5600441098,
0.7392873168,
-0.1501439363,
-0.5927570462,
0.2044725269,
-1.098243475,
0.4035432339,
-0.1864492744,
0.1389199495,
0.2361408472,
0.0190411694,
0.690143764,
-0.492035687,
0.6402153969,
0.1040697172,
-0.0192709714,
0.0598138347,
-0.1724660993,
0.7770090699,
-0.1085550115,
-0.2108729035,
0.4766281843,
-0.0775520504,
-0.1647727638,
-0.4681681991,
0.5755026937,
-0.7348799706,
-0.2188306004,
-0.4738541543,
0.0384484939,
-0.0602386259,
0.1053761765,
0.8860350251,
0.5058352351,
-0.1647324562,
-0.0039437432,
0.5976715088,
-0.0862161219,
0.5279613137,
0.3342579603,
0.1846653223,
-0.3452445567,
0.6156899929,
0.2466922253,
0.5237321854,
0.4636304379,
-0.2248045653,
-0.431863308,
-0.653501153,
-0.4527068734,
0.0698639452,
-0.6305360198,
-0.2670719624,
-0.8716890216,
-0.3716520369,
-0.2859226167,
0.1633298844,
-0.547480166,
-0.3061517775,
-0.3208273053,
-0.1187553704,
0.2320289165,
0.6588863134,
-0.2612771094,
-0.1371476203,
-0.8585115075,
0.3307920098,
0.0002059104,
0.2041990459,
-0.1147284731,
-0.5504727364,
0.0152871227,
-0.0087216608,
-0.2341083139,
-1.3907855749,
0.4303814173,
0.5059785247,
0.5094380975,
0.2103520036,
-0.1522081196,
0.4426640272,
-0.4470548928,
0.7604818344,
0.5066124201,
-0.6025896072,
0.4803383946,
-0.21577245,
-0.178385213,
0.3821846843,
0.5434103012,
-0.5787316561,
0.016655894,
-0.679146111,
-1.2633638382,
0.2252539396,
0.6682759523,
-0.3818258047,
-0.2067071646,
0.4082371294,
0.3296573162,
0.0907108858,
-0.6673827767,
-0.4799000323,
0.0699985176,
0.0578190461,
0.1456435472,
-0.1983975023,
-0.0419290215,
0.149129495,
0.4447846115,
-0.050604593,
0.514221549,
0.5189486146,
-0.3535745144,
-0.2356374115,
0.4153487682,
0.0885585696,
0.5180130005,
-0.3830333948,
-0.1098463461,
0.2271986008,
-0.24263376,
0.0852141902,
0.2869561315,
-0.1725637019,
0.1441211253,
0.4728853106,
0.7052205801,
0.1047002524,
-0.4471752048,
0.515273571,
0.0797801092,
-0.0835570469,
-0.2781158686,
-0.3966597915,
0.1262325943,
0.05080764,
0.2459192574,
0.2014044076,
0.5811087489,
-0.4131549001,
0.4028433561,
0.2838792801,
-0.2976415157,
-0.3338157237,
0.7600859404,
0.2993758023,
-0.1223013848,
0.9286609888,
-0.2406671643,
-0.0132344179,
0.7036421895,
0.6662140489,
0.8315505981,
-0.0039341603,
0.0858305916,
0.3846930861,
0.3152576983,
-0.0917337686,
0.033497043,
0.2823757231,
-0.498334229,
-0.8201193213,
-0.5229460001,
-0.2965805233,
0.3977324069,
-0.8659226298,
0.3383557796,
-0.1349230856,
-0.0729127899,
0.0090845106,
-0.191694513,
-0.8964944482,
0.0830171257,
0.0504929982,
0.5654969811,
-0.9877246022,
0.5920680165,
0.6799792647,
-0.3610218465,
-0.6113920808,
-0.0364171639,
0.0197577681,
-0.319204241,
0.6263613701,
0.0869159475,
0.1442432255,
0.2924597561,
-0.0938144997,
-0.8480818272,
1.307798028,
0.1907329261,
-1.2586141825,
-0.1621337235,
0.1448107213,
0.6120243073,
-0.3239170015,
0.692658484,
0.6844030619,
0.1688990444,
0.3674347699,
-1.0137330294,
0.0557806529,
-0.2520011365,
0.0117235351,
0.3936867416,
-0.4101057649,
0.568198204,
-0.4915327132,
-0.4489595294,
0.1780802906,
0.4479603767,
0.2120352834,
0.694930315,
0.1230362952,
0.9287970662,
0.6419073343,
-0.0402031951,
0.9330928922,
-0.2180926204,
0.5956124663,
1.034250021,
-0.6068198681,
0.85096699,
0.4494891465,
-0.5315845609,
0.0588842519,
0.7314132452,
-0.0054687737,
0.5429677367,
0.2951612473,
-0.058075536,
0.1269623786,
-0.1070957929,
-0.665673852,
0.0259626862,
0.3614710569,
-0.4680254161,
-0.3682864606,
-0.1532954425,
-0.085954912,
-0.2249988914,
0.118552953,
0.8827437162,
0.4623796642,
-0.2595422864,
0.3581284583,
-0.1118006557,
0.5509833694,
-0.290341109,
-0.2653778791,
-0.3048012853,
-0.2462783456,
-0.324580282,
-0.4958472252,
0.4143467546,
0.1361693889,
-0.265361011,
0.4634011388,
0.6987079382,
-0.3517791033,
-0.3499070108,
0.5315413475,
0.8827185631,
0.4320035577,
0.1574059278,
-0.5536261201,
-0.1034047604,
-0.2064869553,
-0.2749505341,
0.2763874829,
0.2068152726,
-0.036872223,
0.2965022027,
0.7034335136,
0.2562766671,
-0.153706193,
0.18083404,
0.8484191298,
-0.6305263638,
-0.0309155528,
-0.6931347847,
0.4183226228,
-0.2093830854,
-0.2509626448,
0.3065752685,
0.706790626,
0.5700895786,
-0.1049766466,
0.8361201286,
-0.1581075042,
0.3886376917,
-0.541629076,
0.3309485912,
-0.3014857471,
0.4241515696,
-0.2027141899,
-1.1816563606,
-0.3456653059,
0.4477867782,
-0.0558921993,
0.1566897035,
0.910457015,
0.6249358654,
-0.1713331193,
0.0617656372,
0.3131530881,
0.4422925115,
0.4681451023,
1.1373628378,
0.6544804573,
-0.7622048855,
0.1243967265,
0.0436602645,
-0.383212477,
-0.074145183,
-0.9160317779,
-0.5277335644,
-0.2848682404,
-0.4238292575,
-0.3152989447,
0.5393013358,
0.9271408916,
0.6806333065,
-0.6665030122,
0.1825563014,
-0.4381609857,
-0.2673886418,
-0.1951937824,
-0.1831294447,
0.2629422247,
0.1170635521,
-0.6713265777,
0.3028154969,
0.5455526114,
0.1901473552,
0.1134626642,
-0.1560615152,
0.0211567301,
-0.350379318,
0.7430955768,
0.5840468407,
-0.7372912765,
-0.0899531171,
0.0278438758,
0.0948477015,
0.0774819776,
0.5575246215,
-0.7350043654,
0.243049413,
0.3967693746,
0.4940823615,
0.6227203608,
-0.2244163007,
0.780946672,
-0.2137807459,
-0.2198814303,
0.5112279654,
0.3139518201,
0.3247684836,
-0.5697508454,
0.7513875365,
0.3696710765,
-0.5849432349,
-0.6424811482,
0.378526181,
-1.0705595016,
-0.0592257716,
1.1295781136,
-0.3213919997,
0.1569394618,
-0.388425231,
0.1414913684,
0.5312330127,
-0.1653917581,
0.5283052921,
0.3152916729,
-0.3957018852,
-0.2179129422,
-0.846754849,
0.2757208347,
0.5562793612,
-0.847768724,
-0.1541385204,
0.4788511992,
0.3309493661,
-0.1953836977,
0.4130747616,
-0.3111599386,
0.2972844839,
-0.1496821642,
-0.2677440047,
0.0038371442,
-0.3509905338,
-0.5775591731,
0.1259671003,
-0.0320725515,
0.1951406598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13708v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13708v4
|
Dynamic Fault Analysis in Substations Based on Knowledge Graphs
| 2023-11-22T21:59:46 | 2024-01-27T07:32:54 |
Weiwei Li, Xing Liu, Wei Wang, Lu Chen, Sizhe Li, Hui Fan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To address the challenge of identifying hidden danger in substations from
unstructured text, a novel dynamic analysis method is proposed. We first
extract relevant information from the unstructured text, and then leverages a
flexible distributed search engine built on Elastic-Search to handle the data.
Following this, the hidden Markov model is employed to train the data within
the engine. The Viterbi algorithm is integrated to decipher the hidden state
sequences, facilitating the segmentation and labeling of entities related to
hidden dangers. The final step involves using the Neo4j graph database to
dynamically create a knowledge graph that visualizes hidden dangers in the
substation. The effectiveness of the proposed method is demonstrated through a
case analysis from a specific substation with hidden dangers revealed in the
text records.
|
[
-0.4296332896,
-0.8790428042,
0.8189237714,
0.0876490176,
-0.1591041833,
0.547503233,
0.4634584785,
-0.4572576582,
0.3129781187,
0.4682947099,
-0.8516827822,
-0.7155727148,
-0.5657613277,
-0.1558984816,
-0.5359758139,
0.4212602973,
-0.3215014935,
-0.4910061061,
-0.1777679473,
0.1481540799,
-0.3859011531,
-0.2452858835,
-0.1579759568,
-0.5763300657,
0.4008938074,
0.4150930047,
0.5251401663,
0.0022564933,
0.3225046694,
0.4325518012,
-0.1420426071,
0.0827023908,
-0.435497731,
0.4722471833,
-0.2101563811,
-0.3473843336,
-0.1721442193,
-0.1837152094,
0.4761763811,
0.4415890872,
0.0462426431,
-0.08841791,
-0.485152632,
0.5483321548,
-0.2560946345,
0.5911192298,
-0.6360346079,
0.477159977,
-0.3363127708,
-0.6329488754,
-0.2181160897,
-0.5497498512,
0.276342839,
-0.404460907,
0.0796106607,
-0.0806370303,
0.9748532772,
0.581579566,
-0.756049037,
-0.0405201539,
-0.6874521971,
0.4216589332,
0.044515159,
0.1605819464,
-0.2180286646,
0.7834978104,
-0.3746030033,
-0.8281078935,
-0.2967354059,
0.1162380204,
-0.1431162208,
0.1293215901,
-0.3750697374,
-0.1060150266,
0.4375636876,
0.085529536,
-0.2523879707,
0.2235084772,
-0.1068427935,
-0.15711312,
0.6081941724,
0.4348426759,
0.3837484419,
-0.5989120603,
-0.5249922872,
-0.0208981745,
-0.5704742074,
0.0587858595,
0.9960184097,
0.0123679833,
0.0567671768,
0.275208503,
-0.1551773399,
0.1391867548,
-0.333540976,
-0.0255402569,
0.4102722406,
0.1506105959,
-0.175675109,
0.303427279,
1.0336121321,
0.2062746584,
0.4448011518,
-0.1893745214,
-0.2468282282,
0.0144481454,
0.6049380302,
-0.3797958791,
-0.5663800836,
0.1462498009,
-0.3684997261,
-0.9251007438,
-0.0739458725,
-1.3184504509,
-0.9470431209,
0.2770376503,
0.2148656994,
-0.3585625589,
-0.457690388,
-0.1033888534,
-0.347471118,
-0.2814774513,
-0.0599319935,
-0.3623514473,
0.2556960881,
0.1011569798,
0.8175902963,
0.2119483352,
0.1514069885,
0.0039639389,
0.0970208794,
-0.0714985356,
0.9924839735,
-0.2094249278,
-0.3782194257,
-0.0248528216,
0.1780703962,
-0.0017425511,
-0.4588202536,
0.3668031394,
-0.8036486506,
-0.1912269145,
-0.0573945194,
-0.0936146453,
-0.3878220022,
-0.0427383184,
-0.9280601144,
1.2966251373,
0.377048403,
-1.4683277607,
0.0053655487,
-0.4805372059,
-0.4280211031,
0.0194642879,
-0.2401687652,
-0.6887077093,
-0.037149176,
0.0733027905,
0.2005074769,
0.0064404923,
0.1338850111,
-0.2698023021,
-0.1788455993,
0.3331612349,
-0.4471807778,
0.5064059496,
0.0649455488,
-0.5636236668,
0.3445368707,
-0.9961397052,
0.3260466456,
0.3820995092,
-0.006388627,
-0.6555282474,
0.5017517209,
-0.3995418847,
0.0746980682,
0.3480143845,
-0.5279295444,
0.0843533501,
-0.4394145906,
-0.0527034961,
0.6821957231,
0.395709008,
0.0117733059,
0.1287090778,
0.6120042801,
0.1598610133,
0.2724078,
0.1936818212,
-0.4324707687,
-0.6429839134,
0.240917027,
0.257414639,
0.757425189,
-0.9293022752,
0.3507476151,
-0.1552330703,
-0.6557785273,
-0.1246410161,
-0.5611753464,
0.3015196919,
0.6156173944,
0.5436403155,
-0.0605245903,
-0.7037580013,
-0.6845454574,
-0.2393089831,
0.0490164161,
0.2241374105,
0.3683245182,
0.1863525808,
-0.6946344376,
0.8006122708,
-0.8142122626,
-0.0625794977,
-0.3376122713,
0.3834240139,
0.3531056345,
0.2171802372,
0.7900632024,
-0.7394508123,
-0.4328591228,
0.2690145373,
-0.9926886559,
-0.4996557832,
0.0793468803,
0.206570521,
-0.3776189089,
0.5775270462,
-0.3246365786,
0.6872695684,
0.403830111,
-0.1905925423,
0.620526433,
-0.1866886467,
-0.0362964831,
-0.6994823813,
-0.0804010779,
-0.1341987699,
-0.3079744875,
-0.2654343843,
-0.1409783959,
0.0922194719,
-0.3208985031,
-0.2360768467,
-0.2276277691,
-0.558857739,
-0.139319241,
-0.183095336,
0.0557923354,
-0.4190745652,
-0.0162789244,
-0.5413892865,
0.4727206528,
0.8409785628,
-0.5092814565,
0.8544909358,
0.1572935432,
-0.5830674171,
-0.3347109854,
-0.4899576306,
0.1247903481,
-0.2167886496,
-0.148045823,
-0.5848020315,
-0.1935787648,
0.2279370725,
-0.0796884969,
0.3175553977,
-0.5213187933,
-0.2796842158,
-0.6298013926,
0.0064147473,
0.1829669029,
0.3018764555,
-0.2724769115,
0.5305188298,
0.7699875832,
-0.3208198845,
-0.6607455611,
-0.2519687414,
-0.0651599988,
-0.0942147747,
-0.4995098412,
0.3796236813,
0.3953143656,
-0.2634123564,
0.3573987484,
-0.428365916,
-0.1088138968,
0.4060668051,
0.7957533002,
-0.194476679,
0.0412748791,
0.1833904535,
0.4419144094,
-0.7223984003,
0.345905602,
-0.2860372066,
0.9470447302,
-0.3386497498,
-0.2249673605,
-0.5497407317,
0.5091475844,
0.6452525258,
-0.2858983576,
0.5308218002,
0.2182123512,
-0.2166128159,
-0.5048444867,
0.2822602093,
0.3128023744,
-0.5803013444,
0.3359375,
-0.0990738347,
-0.3790824413,
0.5624579191,
-0.9569660425,
-0.4583809376,
0.5361256003,
0.3854439259,
-0.0179732759,
0.8897408843,
1.1276315451,
-0.0239599831,
0.5582095981,
-0.4118116498,
0.4162134528,
-0.0005453562,
-0.8290073276,
-0.4144873619,
-0.4942366183,
-0.7972896695,
-0.046927318,
1.020825386,
-0.205460608,
-0.010869897,
0.3450247645,
-0.5502365828,
0.4443905354,
0.2413792312,
-0.0187999159,
0.0047500688,
0.0054907468,
-0.7381084561,
0.0889879987,
-0.4779834747,
-0.3432693779,
0.3527753651,
0.4481194019,
1.0978550911,
0.2494903803,
0.6425879002,
0.3384302258,
0.1560517401,
-0.9819480777,
0.4455822706,
0.172879383,
-0.259236604,
-0.45821172,
-0.8116856217,
-1.1047378778,
0.0273354407,
-0.290125072,
-0.7078965902,
0.2009645104,
0.0026298,
-0.2136197239,
0.2935600281,
-0.8775708675,
0.6165367365,
-0.5616779923,
0.3840472102,
0.1600881666,
-0.4013583958,
0.2977934182,
-0.140756622,
0.236967355,
-0.1468107402,
0.6134918332,
0.6072223783,
-0.5612997413,
0.6522269845,
-0.4665983021,
-0.074628666,
0.4589890838,
0.1120936349,
0.5180625319,
0.3085260689,
-0.0265063625,
0.0495517738,
-0.0246223342,
-0.18157278,
-0.4603806734,
0.8705515265,
-0.7136333585,
-0.3829220533,
-0.8611572385,
-0.5202867985,
-0.3042471707,
0.8690174818,
0.2039821148,
0.3668961525,
0.1452842206,
-0.0660995319,
0.9417857528,
-0.4520140886,
0.7293506265,
0.4197479188,
0.0753771141,
-0.1875962615,
0.5895634294,
0.3013455272,
-0.4217604697,
0.2831938863,
0.2335810512,
-0.3568126857,
-0.5376114249,
0.0886877403,
0.0810888335,
-0.7164581418,
-0.3373933434,
-0.8847596645,
-0.2180508077,
-0.3921731114,
0.1169278324,
-0.4455267489,
-0.1182550713,
-0.2810156345,
-0.3882589042,
0.2632952929,
0.8605181575,
0.3758458793,
0.4122265577,
-0.9604637027,
0.2137956172,
0.3051751554,
0.3795173168,
-0.282228291,
0.4649868906,
-0.0364140309,
-0.4944187403,
-0.5644745827,
-1.4606945515,
0.6954292655,
-0.2116759568,
0.7575523853,
0.346850723,
0.6905478835,
0.4174289405,
-0.8039004207,
0.2007495016,
0.3689616323,
-0.9383984804,
0.5788099766,
-0.4097691774,
-0.2388357967,
0.1268664747,
0.6813492179,
-0.3451637328,
-0.035690695,
-0.9102897048,
-1.3357191086,
0.3662061095,
0.0548576079,
-0.227011621,
0.148647204,
0.3257012069,
-0.2216966748,
0.1907444,
-0.523450017,
-0.3685178459,
-0.3146525025,
-0.4173191786,
0.2766387761,
-0.2124705017,
-0.5805724859,
-0.0391948447,
0.3174388111,
-0.2587717474,
0.6692760587,
0.1024599746,
0.0620971508,
-0.5800446868,
0.2300660759,
0.251211822,
0.6415669918,
-0.3140057027,
0.6511487961,
0.3673803508,
-0.5452478528,
0.1638044715,
0.2023785114,
-0.1287186295,
0.2338512391,
0.2606219947,
0.4360385239,
0.1917936206,
-0.5681574345,
0.4125013053,
-0.2413251996,
0.0579959787,
-0.6943082809,
0.3968447745,
-0.0425055921,
0.5195098519,
0.3661682308,
0.0901128501,
0.0497875661,
-0.5186502337,
0.4814489484,
0.2125573754,
-0.8313909769,
-0.2897377312,
0.5923776627,
0.0414597727,
-0.0811891854,
0.3339766562,
0.0910119414,
-0.9583545327,
0.9046347141,
0.390000999,
0.5650954843,
-0.2335744947,
0.3466270268,
-0.3916962147,
0.8394892216,
0.5049063563,
0.6628521085,
0.5674722791,
-0.5666046143,
-0.0697958097,
-0.6247602701,
-0.2926490605,
0.3777946234,
-0.5821189284,
0.2036964297,
-0.7723917365,
-0.1915718317,
0.1760893017,
0.1437441409,
-0.2497672141,
0.6459121108,
-0.4294278324,
0.8795340061,
-0.9727499485,
0.7273330092,
0.6044447422,
-0.0961101875,
-1.0995827913,
0.2107205689,
-0.1899299175,
-0.6157464385,
0.4868691862,
0.0199684557,
-0.2000032961,
0.1653881967,
-0.2181931585,
-0.9373235703,
1.2939105034,
0.3347400129,
-0.3990236819,
0.2982906401,
-0.0562292822,
0.6399939656,
0.2025734633,
0.348456502,
0.389253974,
0.5797077417,
-0.198083207,
-0.4940520823,
0.1126379669,
-0.2413900048,
-0.3722638488,
0.8393363357,
-0.7901102901,
0.8343433738,
-0.0793260559,
-0.464430064,
-0.453281045,
0.667181313,
-0.4210400581,
0.6904293299,
0.6276378036,
0.4934568107,
1.044609189,
-0.4532076716,
0.9192072153,
0.1058197021,
0.9901632071,
0.5390478969,
-0.0565619916,
0.086021699,
0.1877414584,
-0.0225058831,
1.0037846565,
0.4891422987,
0.0654958487,
1.0176428556,
0.0151789188,
-0.2152281702,
-0.2481556833,
0.0675745308,
-0.4172379375,
0.304035008,
0.5350261927,
-0.3070422411,
-0.6244502068,
-0.1807217002,
0.0830757543,
-0.302377671,
0.0437929407,
0.2376056761,
-0.0387681015,
-0.0008359239,
0.4982663095,
0.2173916996,
-0.0965590179,
-0.4611795247,
0.0839314386,
0.0901939496,
0.1311617047,
-0.4776866734,
-0.6724463105,
0.4558168352,
0.0784346312,
-0.1574902236,
-0.2343516201,
1.0614789724,
0.1642013341,
-0.1046905071,
0.5414431691,
0.1155046672,
0.0803287327,
0.1861295551,
-0.3543822169,
-0.2515179813,
-0.1361851394,
-0.0834929422,
0.2731094062,
0.8571782708,
-0.3870942891,
0.8359020352,
0.3633380234,
0.0201348811,
0.2188529074,
0.1900792271,
1.4196456671,
-0.8266808987,
-0.6078160405,
-0.0975344479,
0.4150360525,
-0.4385123551,
-0.1983303279,
0.7491409183,
0.1054536253,
0.5078880191,
-0.1662890166,
1.0894004107,
-0.2481011748,
0.4551204741,
-0.3907755613,
0.8911390305,
-0.3837532103,
0.543690443,
-0.4240213335,
-0.2160921991,
-0.1898573339,
0.3313502073,
-0.4333405495,
-0.4560889304,
1.0764429569,
0.4652522802,
-0.1355706602,
-0.0843611211,
0.2603175044,
0.5528610945,
0.4126931429,
0.341240555,
1.2698961496,
-0.4151789248,
0.3919542134,
-0.4272135496,
-0.5181086063,
-0.3668628335,
-1.0781550407,
-0.6854960322,
-0.0217804126,
-0.3026621044,
-0.25779441,
-0.2165830284,
0.2225530148,
0.2125726342,
-0.9127787948,
0.4968157113,
-0.3517506719,
0.6415584683,
-0.1337804794,
-0.2780602872,
0.2819929421,
-0.0534088053,
-0.3302177191,
1.0376517773,
0.3039560616,
0.0373527929,
-0.1232227087,
0.4550256133,
0.0226962771,
0.1109570935,
0.251880914,
0.102489382,
0.0892700255,
-0.8019042015,
-0.3000511229,
0.1489886642,
-0.4941965044,
0.9336618781,
-0.8206208944,
0.3515071571,
0.8384826183,
0.3248571455,
0.4208771586,
0.0213273596,
0.0409505144,
-1.1337912083,
0.4176174402,
0.2689880133,
0.3820509017,
-0.0817209855,
-0.9608755708,
0.1267988831,
0.8645816445,
-0.3976463377,
-0.7673863173,
0.5338314176,
-0.9519887567,
-0.452437371,
0.9210239053,
-0.3752626479,
-0.1674415618,
-0.7144321203,
-0.0061830282,
0.6015524268,
0.0152697414,
1.0148035288,
0.1152511388,
-0.4787047505,
0.0527642593,
-0.5311861038,
0.4091445506,
-0.0669098273,
-1.025184989,
-0.224207595,
0.1549459398,
0.4934618771,
0.4593637586,
0.1057267711,
-0.2640455365,
-0.1933940202,
0.1702215225,
-0.1265038848,
-0.2639134526,
-0.9095597267,
0.1101946384,
0.814565599,
-0.4650313258,
-0.1523279548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13668v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13668v3
|
MAIRA-1: A specialised large multimodal model for radiology report generation
| 2023-11-22T19:45:40 | 2024-04-26T16:29:54 |
Stephanie L. Hyland, Shruthi Bannur, Kenza Bouzid, Daniel C. Castro, Mercy Ranjit, Anton Schwaighofer, Fernando Pérez-García, Valentina Salvatelli, Shaury Srivastav, Anja Thieme, Noel Codella, Matthew P. Lungren, Maria Teodora Wetscherek, Ozan Oktay, Javier Alvarez-Valle
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
We present a radiology-specific multimodal model for the task for generating
radiological reports from chest X-rays (CXRs). Our work builds on the idea that
large language model(s) can be equipped with multimodal capabilities through
alignment with pre-trained vision encoders. On natural images, this has been
shown to allow multimodal models to gain image understanding and description
capabilities. Our proposed model (MAIRA-1) leverages a CXR-specific image
encoder in conjunction with a fine-tuned large language model based on
Vicuna-7B, and text-based data augmentation, to produce reports with
state-of-the-art quality. In particular, MAIRA-1 significantly improves on the
radiologist-aligned RadCliQ metric and across all lexical metrics considered.
Manual review of model outputs demonstrates promising fluency and accuracy of
generated reports while uncovering failure modes not captured by existing
evaluation practices. More information and resources can be found on the
project website: https://aka.ms/maira.
|
[
-0.2813534141,
-0.3766889572,
0.5447489619,
-0.0536980182,
-0.4297223091,
-0.2536558807,
0.2126352042,
-0.5333614945,
0.2942282259,
0.7817534804,
-0.4383873045,
-0.4615806341,
-0.9401398301,
0.1629696488,
-0.5417836905,
0.7315212488,
0.2174399197,
0.1607565582,
-0.1257047057,
-0.2543737888,
-0.7743213177,
-0.4329754114,
-0.5132546425,
-0.1657104939,
0.9364881516,
0.4439696968,
1.1356871128,
0.5651132464,
0.7907428741,
0.2320768982,
0.3457052112,
0.3984654546,
-0.2813205123,
0.0917058438,
0.1645103395,
-0.1899250895,
-0.748966217,
-0.3533305228,
0.5963535309,
0.4255372882,
-0.2048157454,
0.0210209787,
-0.191616863,
0.6749101281,
-0.699893415,
0.2224357873,
-0.2321686596,
-0.1142645925,
-0.1688831598,
-0.4599333704,
-0.4932767749,
-0.3671542704,
0.0307660047,
-0.4795388281,
-0.2645049691,
-0.1032911241,
0.8153076172,
0.2012968063,
-0.6097424626,
-0.3168049753,
-0.6507722139,
0.441947788,
-0.5104068518,
0.4127418399,
0.4035624564,
0.7614308,
0.4090707004,
-0.9490225911,
-0.2650507092,
-0.1538259983,
-0.2677831352,
0.2098740488,
-0.5617485046,
0.0129010826,
-0.0173573177,
0.2180981785,
-0.6979803443,
-0.0016897731,
-0.6249790788,
0.0988583714,
0.5874209404,
0.5574045777,
0.3812108338,
-0.2535900474,
-0.3139697909,
-0.1577492207,
-0.5446465611,
-0.455383569,
-0.2365171611,
0.2635546625,
-0.256220758,
0.688411653,
-0.4474089146,
0.7040780783,
-0.1560924798,
-0.5073800087,
0.2481977344,
-0.1591783017,
-0.2853667736,
0.3419781029,
0.7484644651,
0.3803049028,
-0.1554295719,
-0.025699418,
-0.1769774258,
0.5135980844,
0.2545543909,
-0.8982002735,
-0.1621728539,
0.1354003698,
-0.6807738543,
-0.5582901239,
0.1207897067,
-0.3998576999,
-0.3851033151,
-0.4041846693,
0.8310641646,
-0.5634807348,
-0.5385832191,
0.5192086101,
0.2317775637,
-0.1025009453,
0.2231539339,
-0.2064068764,
0.1356717795,
0.1454712003,
0.612656951,
0.4273618758,
-0.0660027117,
-0.7507373095,
0.3243429065,
-0.1982033849,
0.8051770926,
-0.6018693447,
-0.4299074709,
-0.176217407,
-0.0172217321,
-0.0042400528,
-0.3215477467,
0.5174943805,
-0.3558706939,
-0.0336476937,
-0.2542896271,
0.0447367392,
-0.4319373369,
0.5437327623,
-0.8215404749,
0.4775725901,
0.4691350758,
-0.8978492618,
0.2939529121,
-0.6337962151,
-0.3876650333,
0.0517290346,
-0.4018830955,
-0.3283867836,
0.0882604793,
0.395868361,
0.3839271963,
-0.8453435898,
0.2282698154,
0.2532177866,
0.2114223093,
0.6807460189,
-0.4218286574,
0.359598428,
0.4091308117,
0.0348173305,
0.2702652812,
-0.791908443,
0.0554107465,
0.2367516309,
-0.0574189089,
-0.0123836463,
-0.1081571206,
0.147657454,
0.4573048353,
0.1190285236,
-0.7405388951,
-0.1142093614,
-0.0096468413,
0.171759665,
0.2119357288,
0.0592535287,
-0.08337605,
-0.9129076004,
0.8450791836,
0.4506419599,
0.6171706319,
-0.6525060534,
-0.1600919217,
-0.6259066463,
-0.6360878944,
0.1719443798,
0.350792408,
-0.6590999365,
-0.1692525744,
-0.5194542408,
-0.8275418878,
-0.4800743461,
-0.1396440417,
0.5972157121,
0.4887086153,
0.2513738573,
-0.6450038552,
-0.6310114861,
-1.1491413116,
0.4791505933,
0.0672874525,
0.3842308819,
0.0405295864,
-0.0560280532,
-0.4977016747,
0.7569974661,
-0.6621255279,
-0.6655027866,
-0.3884836435,
0.1681951731,
0.1042632088,
0.373505652,
0.689362824,
-0.8871740103,
-0.3007260561,
0.3605833948,
-1.1009854078,
0.1877319515,
-0.0164354313,
-0.0360994823,
0.0151433749,
0.3563459516,
-0.3947907686,
0.3958383501,
0.8333439231,
-0.2023020685,
0.2723786533,
-0.3415687084,
0.4284050763,
-1.1632658243,
0.0542155355,
0.1219222918,
-0.5329775214,
-0.3288809061,
0.1294004768,
0.0571676455,
-0.4246623516,
-0.4647362232,
0.2704210281,
-0.7172429562,
0.3748044968,
-0.2261378318,
-0.1970476955,
0.1725155562,
-0.0731690899,
0.0771388486,
0.1986141652,
0.7938899398,
-0.57122612,
0.0343492292,
0.481092602,
-0.3092970252,
0.3940463066,
-0.6647308469,
0.1458761692,
-0.4508134425,
0.0614232495,
-0.9362949729,
-0.3665500879,
-0.0616345033,
-0.3957386911,
0.6986188293,
-0.1929125041,
-0.6196021438,
-0.3464686275,
0.0150990961,
0.4763285816,
0.469126761,
-0.2624175549,
0.7656697631,
0.5657971501,
-0.4325602651,
-0.2475411445,
-0.7618128061,
0.2495844364,
0.1109006628,
-0.6992137432,
-0.118138358,
-0.0207912177,
-0.1476561576,
-0.0721771494,
0.342443943,
-0.272744447,
-0.0934106186,
0.4956076145,
0.3279204071,
-0.4498051703,
-0.1431834698,
0.1888260096,
-0.3089639544,
0.1131320074,
0.161034435,
0.5010242462,
0.0510457978,
-0.5553621054,
-0.442150861,
0.6417661309,
0.9075331688,
-0.6135932207,
0.6013757586,
0.3369480968,
-0.4642696381,
0.3734202981,
-0.6308276057,
-0.0078165922,
-0.363521874,
0.3979294598,
-0.4616141617,
-0.6202691197,
0.1824339926,
0.2125578225,
-0.0585834123,
0.3853871822,
0.6410579085,
0.2583922446,
1.4281697273,
0.6703385115,
0.2312559932,
0.0803117156,
-0.2280456126,
0.0806323737,
-0.6151720881,
-0.3213646114,
-0.4377781749,
-0.0142202983,
-0.353353858,
-0.3759870529,
0.9662076235,
-0.5242302418,
-0.0065767057,
-0.0617914945,
-0.7821365595,
0.3093972802,
0.0089702057,
0.618304491,
0.4505190551,
-0.0482294373,
0.3255496025,
-0.1616768837,
-0.9713677168,
-0.5311202407,
1.1782423258,
0.2672260404,
1.0094846487,
0.3165817857,
0.5819961429,
0.2055738419,
0.6245943904,
-0.4789337516,
0.1898670346,
-0.4335843623,
-0.6239940524,
0.1182644069,
-0.0176127404,
-1.0375912189,
0.1910123378,
-0.4555340707,
-0.2528947294,
-0.0003214824,
-0.1034887657,
-0.5445771813,
0.046124164,
-0.3525491655,
0.7214089036,
-0.3697215915,
-0.2287248075,
-0.3424860835,
-0.7249543667,
0.6070875525,
-0.2725555897,
0.4575856924,
-0.1258209795,
0.1770401597,
0.3675841093,
-0.4075471759,
0.9039350748,
-0.0244064759,
-0.0720558017,
0.3327631652,
0.3184024692,
-0.0182356779,
0.1085339934,
-0.0592620224,
-0.0955287963,
0.4436451495,
-0.127235055,
-0.1738978028,
0.5558470488,
-0.7828247547,
-0.1527822614,
-0.4996286333,
-0.8780890703,
0.0209507886,
0.1019825041,
0.435587436,
1.3009170294,
-0.4590848386,
0.1599694341,
0.497998029,
-0.311407268,
-0.1105310395,
0.4780023396,
-0.5706918836,
-0.4731982946,
0.921087265,
0.4442033768,
0.1528591514,
0.6124184132,
0.0429700427,
-0.0675857738,
-0.451743871,
-0.3548928499,
0.2863265872,
-0.8845146894,
-0.7187335491,
-0.9844687581,
-0.4447742999,
-0.1791913211,
-0.222882092,
-0.3549083173,
-0.3278591335,
-0.1225695461,
0.1843331456,
0.3455615938,
0.8910767436,
-0.161689654,
0.3248819709,
-1.4211678505,
0.2622989118,
0.1247669905,
-0.2372834533,
-0.0870530233,
-0.4196994007,
-0.4424453676,
0.0043284656,
-0.3520949483,
-0.7838005424,
0.6993839741,
-0.0188879799,
0.3787331283,
0.4726760387,
0.1078962013,
0.4087119401,
-0.1078603268,
0.4320003688,
0.6770201921,
-0.4938065112,
0.7091817856,
-0.6883429289,
0.5509806871,
0.3765104413,
0.1969258934,
-0.0970391035,
-0.4476736188,
-0.5397272706,
-0.5432465672,
0.2782335281,
0.0008344444,
0.1757676601,
-0.4967551529,
0.0876996368,
0.3938884139,
-0.0657166988,
-0.4118576348,
0.0520226806,
-0.0841311514,
-0.3086200655,
-0.041806791,
-0.5259035826,
-0.4830478728,
-0.1102980003,
0.5780161023,
-0.3678734899,
0.2740172744,
0.3773920536,
-0.3918896914,
-0.1589693874,
0.2794255018,
0.5091968179,
1.214299202,
-0.1025819331,
0.0589404553,
-0.1791301221,
-0.2540603876,
0.0151021285,
0.1354716718,
0.1165643483,
0.1889832467,
0.202931121,
0.5863902569,
0.3714499176,
-0.6661741734,
0.5558850765,
-0.3364734948,
-0.2950181365,
-0.4297956526,
-0.0971249118,
-0.1157188267,
0.1978126168,
0.3343480825,
0.0538164601,
0.1746658832,
-0.4581520557,
0.2129494995,
0.2583698928,
-0.5796465874,
-0.3070432544,
0.8304347992,
0.041106578,
0.4859206378,
0.6271874905,
0.130757764,
-0.1766746342,
0.661124289,
0.7122942209,
0.6549198031,
-0.1296625286,
0.3498528302,
0.7186139822,
0.4514341354,
-0.0276117809,
0.504570663,
0.3747435808,
-0.5053973794,
-0.3865962923,
-0.3869744837,
-0.3218590915,
-0.3738895059,
-1.1554299593,
0.5010460019,
-0.5434003472,
-0.2676087022,
0.046621535,
-0.4303752184,
-0.6828051805,
0.6696796417,
0.4504853487,
0.8775549531,
-0.6994293928,
0.9317177534,
0.5856271386,
-0.8407294154,
-0.9643330574,
-0.5568743348,
0.1260831356,
-0.6750910878,
0.590998292,
0.318110913,
-0.2072388232,
0.021655025,
-0.2450159937,
-0.8994470835,
1.4486887455,
0.5362020731,
-0.6415212154,
0.1126675308,
0.0293965098,
0.1606717259,
-0.6056705117,
0.2562119365,
0.2799885571,
0.4129237533,
0.0608076937,
-1.0541697741,
0.2139074802,
-0.0601107515,
-0.1884528846,
0.3881910741,
-0.7284583449,
0.7825822234,
-0.4136994481,
-0.1356743723,
0.3819645643,
0.6591618657,
0.1628008336,
0.1739356965,
0.380716145,
0.6769663692,
0.5506744385,
-0.0082576657,
1.6226480007,
-0.239853099,
-0.0249802414,
0.9651978016,
-0.2779674232,
0.7033438683,
0.1680744886,
0.1660515368,
0.4582417905,
0.1598509997,
0.2827371061,
0.4251589179,
-0.3393740356,
-0.3448134661,
-0.4262378812,
-0.4688661098,
-0.7023453712,
0.7434108257,
0.2928667068,
-0.4834632576,
-0.2049420178,
0.3804032207,
0.1182298735,
-0.0171303023,
-0.4210554063,
0.6892470121,
0.0319256186,
-0.3743398786,
0.5975887179,
-0.0203999598,
0.3489313126,
-1.0655603409,
0.0782310143,
-0.066120185,
0.3433932662,
-0.4413238764,
-0.6132611632,
0.5147342682,
-0.1179141626,
-0.4136888087,
0.1138189211,
0.6849628687,
-0.2845421135,
-0.9201542139,
0.1329158247,
0.6304281354,
-0.0839658752,
-0.058687184,
-0.2905418575,
0.3957059681,
-0.1782259792,
0.1660132408,
0.5888959765,
0.2787131667,
-0.0928283632,
0.5608058572,
0.4328126311,
-0.2470480651,
-0.0839204192,
0.3124508262,
1.2012450695,
-0.3531087339,
-0.46946311,
-0.3850353956,
0.7819172144,
0.3365600705,
-0.2188138664,
0.3682849407,
0.7994417548,
0.3110940456,
-0.0271365009,
0.9231059551,
-0.1163453683,
0.4091935754,
-0.7355049253,
0.8515305519,
-0.677887857,
-0.1279769689,
-0.1357100755,
-0.6067823768,
-0.5237019658,
0.3904760182,
0.1089374349,
-0.2119327486,
0.7938830853,
1.0479482412,
-0.2660268247,
-0.1497223526,
0.6662330031,
0.2799625397,
0.1619459987,
0.5302707553,
0.8768491149,
-0.638340652,
0.7473555207,
-0.2083904147,
-0.2421505004,
0.0238769297,
-0.5833391547,
-0.5183790922,
-0.6483008862,
-0.6808195114,
-0.555655539,
-0.0435972475,
0.6664486527,
0.8585266471,
-0.2051810622,
-0.0577309951,
0.6251822114,
-0.4858519733,
-0.0493476912,
-0.1407717317,
0.0963728502,
-0.0553617366,
-0.3222265542,
0.3341012895,
0.551556468,
-0.1970680505,
-0.3176398873,
-0.1573361754,
-0.0734569654,
0.049802579,
0.8011419177,
0.1253688633,
-0.4396122396,
-0.1154235005,
-0.0572856218,
-0.3030222058,
0.3607538939,
0.6449403763,
-0.7482769489,
0.6811060309,
0.1663234979,
0.3950428367,
0.6877236962,
-0.3311727643,
0.3943399489,
-0.3483211994,
0.213582471,
0.1041236073,
0.4872834384,
0.5673654675,
-0.2734229267,
0.4247265756,
-0.4060253799,
-0.4182442427,
-0.7005432844,
0.2481290698,
-1.4810906649,
-0.1445659101,
0.9811479449,
0.0829641074,
-0.135705471,
0.0875713453,
-0.6232671738,
0.185745433,
0.0065855514,
0.2936795652,
0.154083848,
0.0482820347,
-0.6260411739,
-0.391931057,
-0.2264499813,
0.093495816,
-0.7891467214,
-0.3744238615,
0.8163360357,
0.4337453246,
0.1068069711,
0.8774374127,
-0.6686475277,
0.8044102192,
0.0310940966,
0.0677197799,
-0.3885351717,
-0.2862896025,
-0.1527149081,
0.4363268316,
0.5663684607,
-0.1782889068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13657v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13657v1
|
Efficient Transformer Knowledge Distillation: A Performance Review
| 2023-11-22T19:19:37 | 2023-11-22T19:19:37 |
Nathan Brown, Ashton Williamson, Tahj Anderson, Logan Lawrence
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
As pretrained transformer language models continue to achieve
state-of-the-art performance, the Natural Language Processing community has
pushed for advances in model compression and efficient attention mechanisms to
address high computational requirements and limited input sequence length.
Despite these separate efforts, no investigation has been done into the
intersection of these two fields. In this work, we provide an evaluation of
model compression via knowledge distillation on efficient attention
transformers. We provide cost-performance trade-offs for the compression of
state-of-the-art efficient attention architectures and the gains made in
performance in comparison to their full attention counterparts. Furthermore, we
introduce a new long-context Named Entity Recognition dataset, GONERD, to train
and test the performance of NER models on long sequences. We find that
distilled efficient attention transformers can preserve a significant amount of
original model performance, preserving up to 98.6% across short-context tasks
(GLUE, SQUAD, CoNLL-2003), up to 94.6% across long-context
Question-and-Answering tasks (HotpotQA, TriviaQA), and up to 98.8% on
long-context Named Entity Recognition (GONERD), while decreasing inference
times by up to 57.8%. We find that, for most models on most tasks, performing
knowledge distillation is an effective method to yield high-performing
efficient attention models with low costs.
|
[
-0.542617023,
-0.5529100299,
0.549313128,
0.1649902165,
-0.167626828,
-0.0568228774,
-0.4065028727,
-0.4036087692,
-0.1665814519,
0.4042536914,
-0.3292456865,
0.016258331,
-1.0626602173,
0.2764609158,
-0.6915253997,
0.8973606229,
0.208503589,
-0.2307985127,
-0.2353408784,
0.0757461563,
-0.4853848219,
-0.4347814918,
-0.6868485808,
-0.3422855139,
0.3563159704,
0.0340241604,
0.3713260293,
0.5310156345,
0.7904337049,
0.40454337,
-0.4412719607,
0.054561805,
-0.8083384633,
0.2692401409,
-0.2539675832,
-0.2492545545,
-0.2929907441,
-0.1002289951,
0.3729268014,
0.534087956,
-0.2695285082,
0.3828923404,
0.3646733463,
1.0038486719,
-0.7250446677,
0.2332966626,
-0.7182688117,
-0.032377664,
-0.0097265784,
0.1071446463,
-0.6136831641,
-0.2964442074,
0.5239418149,
-0.411667645,
0.4425056875,
0.0571185574,
0.815726757,
1.1439640522,
-0.1505855471,
-0.148672238,
-1.1156210899,
0.7549624443,
-0.5094619989,
0.6185949445,
0.0927889422,
0.6346608996,
0.0619696416,
-1.1780495644,
-0.6664597988,
0.0309649222,
-0.3407253623,
0.1249716729,
-0.7488312125,
0.0467388891,
0.6881462336,
0.7712991238,
-0.2674268484,
-0.2537199855,
-0.4105402231,
0.1245776638,
0.2550748587,
-0.0254060309,
-0.2111748457,
0.0467965826,
-0.4477146268,
-0.2969329059,
-0.3355888426,
-0.1547278166,
0.1706483513,
-0.0361786187,
0.2951784134,
0.4079132676,
-0.34792009,
0.9744354486,
0.4258864224,
-0.1896987706,
0.0058835978,
-0.2272280306,
-0.3770712912,
-0.0737598911,
0.720097959,
0.214092508,
0.3753385842,
-0.3155539334,
-0.2435746193,
-0.0490392558,
0.598238647,
-0.9902907014,
-0.4896568954,
0.0266673025,
-0.3350520432,
-0.1069927886,
-0.1998334974,
-0.8530438542,
-0.1614981741,
-0.4556726515,
0.360128969,
-0.3324116468,
-0.0923186019,
0.3545187414,
-0.529353857,
-0.0751914307,
0.2132038325,
-0.8052817583,
0.3220288754,
0.5035128593,
0.6769466996,
-0.2300198376,
0.0425834954,
-0.4627881944,
0.0294305962,
0.3477296829,
0.6425091624,
-0.3879219294,
-0.0629845932,
-0.3823059499,
-0.1612459868,
-0.119499512,
-0.7191079855,
0.6009709239,
-0.7495655417,
0.1102566272,
-0.1297236532,
-0.6901357174,
-0.1453961879,
0.1889825761,
-1.0713098049,
1.0747898817,
0.2206434608,
-0.952627182,
0.2960590124,
-0.7784863114,
-0.4844413102,
-0.0118220309,
0.2443669587,
-0.2234965265,
0.2990072072,
0.3174392283,
0.6067575216,
-0.6042907238,
0.4463943541,
0.1606425494,
-0.281167537,
0.0915592685,
-0.8357638717,
0.3839460611,
0.2124411911,
-0.573086679,
-0.3027105331,
-0.896268487,
-0.2984577119,
0.1190351844,
-0.4412235916,
-0.3626330197,
-0.0939120352,
-0.1962239444,
0.1922818273,
0.2611269653,
-0.3751449883,
0.1135393381,
-0.2946818173,
0.6378678679,
0.3962271214,
-0.1297890693,
0.4691774547,
0.0755839273,
0.3560065329,
0.2043887377,
0.3171268106,
-0.044516921,
-0.259211421,
-1.0634936094,
-0.2251579762,
0.5485479832,
0.1949474365,
-0.9025474191,
0.5046494603,
-0.6294153929,
-0.4718587101,
-0.6081677079,
-0.1030115411,
0.3187733293,
0.8464456797,
0.6805317998,
-0.0426315963,
-0.3625636995,
-1.0820888281,
-0.2453726232,
0.0124057261,
-0.1066382602,
0.2588708103,
0.301053226,
0.0444336832,
1.0564174652,
-0.8591803908,
-0.2579144835,
-0.380768925,
0.1615805626,
0.3410414159,
0.1588087678,
0.4996748865,
-0.8995463252,
-0.6127280593,
-0.2108275294,
-0.3767427504,
0.1187002435,
0.2327694893,
-0.0249424875,
-0.0565588437,
0.3768647313,
-0.7168140411,
0.4858036935,
0.6569545865,
0.0194035135,
0.2146968096,
-0.061429318,
0.17740044,
-0.9819655418,
0.3859926462,
-0.0058019878,
-0.3439407349,
-0.884262085,
-0.2607331872,
0.2870404124,
0.0661709756,
-0.6219204664,
0.321762383,
-0.5755751729,
0.2615275085,
-0.4093175828,
0.0240731928,
0.1384367347,
0.6983183622,
0.1356807947,
0.6456623077,
0.3070731759,
-0.8323336244,
0.4343253672,
0.1471261382,
-0.5552272797,
0.3815079629,
-0.8334290385,
0.3412075937,
-0.3213059902,
0.0494410582,
-0.8111428618,
-0.1085659042,
-0.0021543622,
-0.2126228958,
0.6948831081,
-0.1479405761,
-0.3569977582,
-0.5951590538,
0.1167011037,
0.4661717117,
0.7284114361,
-0.7357757092,
0.7078422308,
0.3215013146,
0.1364943981,
-0.7966535687,
-0.7642895579,
-0.0326701067,
-0.5256360769,
-0.3368621469,
0.4879176319,
0.0257192273,
-0.1080585495,
0.1058118716,
-0.254339844,
-0.1171861514,
0.1595038623,
0.0339967906,
0.0184392259,
-0.0221369192,
0.2411040813,
-0.0293472838,
-0.1680571288,
-0.0660329983,
-0.4002189636,
0.5405209064,
0.0526205376,
-0.0774123669,
-0.3623451889,
0.0510151424,
0.664419353,
-0.233112663,
0.9072739482,
0.413459301,
-0.3184149265,
-0.0837935507,
-0.9390720725,
-0.3718099594,
-0.4749521315,
0.4178923666,
-0.2774781883,
-1.0450335741,
0.2314723134,
-0.2449795008,
-0.0151279597,
0.5752404928,
0.2915123105,
0.2178873122,
0.6480339766,
0.7624187469,
-0.3058393002,
0.4359477758,
-0.2148156464,
0.5369417071,
-0.8142793775,
-0.1157892644,
-0.6274824739,
-0.6522939801,
-0.1627081484,
-0.4945851564,
0.3571760356,
0.0533919409,
0.0329863168,
0.6886392236,
-0.8513354659,
0.7196469903,
0.4805303514,
-0.0861620605,
0.4771943092,
-0.1028969139,
0.4038709998,
-0.0725290403,
-0.8344475031,
-0.347971946,
1.0272387266,
0.3155154288,
0.8024640083,
0.0496754572,
0.5496644378,
0.0433955081,
0.2454087138,
-0.8693034053,
0.3411021531,
-0.2167409807,
-0.5479464531,
-0.4473357201,
-0.553299129,
-0.8398756981,
-0.0123489313,
0.0818787366,
-0.5256785154,
0.212239489,
0.2837422192,
-0.5396531224,
0.2453947961,
-0.7486284375,
0.804754734,
-0.1011370718,
-0.0949702039,
-0.1023756117,
-0.7344320416,
0.4638979733,
-0.2484148592,
-0.2885213196,
0.1495520771,
0.2677449286,
0.7649700642,
-0.1300275475,
0.4478852451,
-0.2214817256,
0.0738384128,
0.1289061457,
-0.2510305643,
0.6147689223,
-0.0918817148,
0.114743039,
0.2752371132,
-0.2698496878,
0.1177105457,
-0.8760951757,
0.4899042845,
-0.4091176987,
-0.7775924802,
-0.1193182915,
-0.5258373022,
-0.120794192,
0.189755559,
0.4021692872,
0.3902783692,
-0.1779039502,
0.5471252799,
1.1354255676,
0.0290530212,
0.5501906276,
0.3233423233,
0.1567208171,
-0.1895898283,
0.4845486581,
0.099970147,
0.3696550429,
0.6887222528,
-0.0031062427,
-0.4712346494,
-0.4807938635,
-0.332051754,
0.0018679587,
-0.6806235313,
-0.5319648981,
-1.0432964563,
-0.3319501281,
-0.4246527255,
0.4523106515,
-0.7554468513,
-0.5181182623,
-0.2287483662,
0.0242859796,
0.4451315403,
0.6680213213,
0.2487658709,
0.2516601682,
-0.8240984082,
0.5241749883,
0.4358925819,
0.2293302417,
0.2562376261,
-0.6012907624,
-0.3741389215,
-0.1068788916,
-0.3081451356,
-0.82805866,
0.3261164725,
0.2922969162,
0.5802924037,
0.3892380297,
0.4545205235,
0.7073723078,
-0.6453059912,
0.5937712193,
0.1382546425,
-0.8478415012,
0.4370003343,
0.3331243396,
0.5378338695,
0.7683977485,
0.4453679323,
-0.3479655683,
-0.3231619596,
-0.6086018085,
-0.9430497289,
0.8406088948,
0.3720660806,
0.0586661324,
-0.1310213953,
0.3567176759,
0.099518396,
0.334059,
-0.5482361317,
-0.4702480137,
-0.0429539494,
-0.2546339929,
-0.1185984537,
-0.343880713,
-0.039272856,
-0.3088324964,
0.6474115252,
0.0407266319,
0.2296532393,
0.2513862252,
-0.4262070358,
0.426885128,
0.2755893767,
0.2933825552,
0.2694900334,
-0.0354679115,
0.4042434096,
0.2555620372,
-0.5799319744,
0.1851652563,
0.2704113722,
0.0154664768,
0.0418130159,
-0.0869723037,
1.0645976067,
0.3783588111,
-0.4017308652,
0.4334237576,
-0.530310154,
-0.0998051167,
0.0164306071,
0.1637141258,
0.2557892799,
0.4036387503,
0.1910327822,
0.1727246046,
0.5026777387,
-0.1027810425,
-0.0802827999,
0.1150980666,
-0.3445341587,
-0.123893559,
0.6520174146,
0.1989783347,
-0.0908343345,
0.9169816971,
-0.0605757125,
-0.5518758893,
0.3151821494,
0.1961311847,
1.0247910023,
-0.2446451634,
-0.262771666,
0.5393564105,
0.2046320438,
-0.477899313,
-0.3110240698,
-0.5460854173,
-0.4996336401,
-0.5366135836,
-0.8390318155,
-0.0904871896,
0.2688637674,
-0.8503044844,
0.206660971,
0.0475532897,
-0.5093601942,
0.1268297881,
-0.3596742153,
-0.9118373394,
0.0639237463,
0.0281712376,
1.0389382839,
-0.4841012955,
0.7037165165,
0.3792957366,
-0.1360499561,
-0.8339360952,
0.0004728627,
-0.3796167672,
-0.2413478643,
0.7876297832,
0.3246419132,
-0.1178392693,
0.2664183676,
-0.1353897154,
-1.0989017487,
1.0987221003,
0.6000615358,
-0.9979678392,
-0.2691935599,
0.1800458729,
0.5946595669,
0.0878769457,
0.3477041423,
0.9940774441,
0.4213769138,
0.1942161322,
-1.0357023478,
-0.0729960948,
-0.266533345,
0.0188789722,
0.4090594351,
-0.5297395587,
0.5020609498,
0.075200133,
-0.5026740432,
-0.3327275515,
0.7134832144,
-0.1006912738,
0.116894953,
0.5888639092,
0.8443729877,
0.6763843894,
-0.4067356884,
0.9468336701,
-0.5213623643,
0.5626030564,
1.2135560513,
-0.2545173168,
0.5938132405,
0.7002249956,
-0.2728756666,
0.2334840894,
0.1075077206,
0.0785747543,
0.9048437476,
0.1087394208,
-0.0850230679,
-0.0702056885,
0.0301866475,
-0.302270472,
0.3704454005,
-0.0112011014,
-0.4573731422,
-0.1540403217,
0.0131249605,
-0.2445926666,
-0.1444850862,
0.091129832,
1.1129602194,
0.1137272418,
-1.1008052826,
0.5670056939,
-0.3202167153,
0.7291377187,
-0.3862529397,
0.1116543189,
-0.1288836747,
0.4025449157,
0.1191675961,
-0.4963519871,
0.4847678542,
0.2536814213,
-0.5657063723,
-0.3965675235,
0.8464140892,
-0.5087326765,
-0.1544195116,
0.2401062548,
0.3470236063,
0.1209981143,
-0.4952973425,
-0.322173804,
-0.205432266,
-0.0499108136,
-0.6198318005,
0.1972128302,
0.402861774,
0.3523503542,
0.5238832831,
0.3825114369,
-0.1475255936,
0.1705155373,
0.1645468324,
1.0057914257,
-0.4289332032,
-0.3205459714,
-1.036970377,
0.6815513968,
-0.3631564379,
-0.0641953051,
0.6052904129,
0.5055425763,
0.8146374226,
-0.3191750646,
0.5890672803,
-0.0167809892,
0.2788398266,
-0.4577285349,
0.8378559351,
-0.333185792,
0.0762480944,
-0.0912888497,
-1.2202183008,
-0.0096877096,
0.3736368418,
-0.2634216249,
-0.0197873935,
0.7482577562,
0.4640448391,
-0.2110466659,
0.0672834665,
0.3864629567,
-0.000602978,
0.2325810492,
0.845988512,
0.9368713498,
-0.528608501,
0.5207152367,
-0.5168427825,
-0.1071455106,
-0.0250659101,
-0.8891878128,
-0.9255563617,
-0.5804457664,
-0.3895679116,
-0.0716998056,
-0.0611461774,
0.4872468114,
0.7035998106,
-0.4536851943,
0.2924534976,
-0.1633412242,
-0.1705634743,
-0.1876575947,
-0.2070847005,
0.3494051993,
-0.2586621046,
-1.0533605814,
0.3257865906,
0.3774994314,
0.0160692837,
-0.2353269905,
0.0663626119,
0.0684445575,
-0.0804139227,
0.6122557521,
-0.0717807114,
-0.5825999975,
-0.1013680622,
0.2371039838,
0.0142228734,
0.0169051196,
0.8032454252,
-0.9688956738,
0.3643315732,
0.5497696996,
0.7546216846,
0.788216114,
0.0292185917,
0.4098943472,
-0.8377653956,
0.1044816077,
0.3527319133,
0.4317604601,
0.3697658777,
-0.4417584836,
0.6398820877,
-0.0219965205,
-0.7350188494,
-0.8049337864,
0.0104817953,
-0.8152609468,
0.0404877625,
1.1148120165,
-0.2376124561,
-0.2457057387,
0.0162033979,
-0.1100040972,
0.6054262519,
-0.3266823292,
0.8735902905,
0.8009343743,
0.0427659824,
-0.0846140832,
-0.4613934457,
0.6438339353,
0.3006908298,
-0.718722105,
0.3306944072,
0.3733164966,
0.1834075898,
0.4520364404,
0.1488138586,
-0.0503081381,
0.0419903919,
-0.1903823018,
0.1111668423,
-0.2411205322,
-0.5705013275,
-0.4668005407,
0.1952247918,
-0.1564043015,
-0.0282950141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13647v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13647v1
|
Language Model Inversion
| 2023-11-22T19:04:04 | 2023-11-22T19:04:04 |
John X. Morris, Wenting Zhao, Justin T. Chiu, Vitaly Shmatikov, Alexander M. Rush
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Language models produce a distribution over the next token; can we use this
information to recover the prompt tokens? We consider the problem of language
model inversion and show that next-token probabilities contain a surprising
amount of information about the preceding text. Often we can recover the text
in cases where it is hidden from the user, motivating a method for recovering
unknown prompts given only the model's current distribution output. We consider
a variety of model access scenarios, and show how even without predictions for
every token in the vocabulary we can recover the probability vector through
search. On Llama-2 7b, our inversion method reconstructs prompts with a BLEU of
$59$ and token-level F1 of $78$ and recovers $27\%$ of prompts exactly. Code
for reproducing all experiments is available at
http://github.com/jxmorris12/vec2text.
|
[
0.126153037,
-0.7150571942,
0.7037007213,
0.2319492698,
-0.2622275352,
-0.0713465288,
-0.0527118109,
-0.3679184318,
0.1120745093,
0.8035027385,
-0.5874449611,
-0.3304784894,
-0.4705845118,
-0.1107973009,
-0.8305784464,
0.8860891461,
0.296020478,
-0.0526241809,
-0.2309739441,
0.1289138943,
-0.4868247509,
-0.7002820373,
-0.6945685148,
-0.1937861741,
0.5417570472,
0.4492459595,
0.4343331158,
0.6784848571,
0.4067847431,
0.1881168485,
-0.4295119047,
-0.4325432181,
-0.5821226239,
0.2186989933,
-0.1123975739,
-0.8413969874,
-0.1028086245,
-0.0982856378,
0.9607365131,
0.7098157406,
-0.2055963427,
-0.1297445446,
-0.0591652207,
0.3869622946,
-0.5417100787,
-0.0686959997,
-0.8293128014,
-0.0023803816,
-0.2620627284,
-0.2836900055,
-0.6635371447,
-0.2862204313,
0.0268201437,
-0.5169691443,
0.2403260916,
0.2744390666,
0.7584421039,
-0.0196662024,
-0.4458964765,
-0.2808814645,
-0.8648135066,
0.7123871446,
-0.5553278923,
0.1702068299,
0.4176366925,
0.4243408442,
-0.3789649606,
-0.9284537435,
-0.8050270081,
-0.5249602795,
0.0956109688,
0.1086060479,
-0.495431155,
-0.272057116,
0.3842870295,
0.4305540919,
-0.3573384285,
0.2790207565,
-0.2440793216,
-0.4082428813,
0.3001353145,
0.2020246983,
0.3732917309,
-0.2023968697,
-0.5589991808,
-0.3764751554,
-1.0572367907,
0.1307416856,
0.5926003456,
0.1927035153,
0.0534633398,
0.7978311181,
-0.0309588928,
0.4693541229,
-0.2484137416,
0.0818579346,
0.4946067929,
-0.5119410753,
0.0300845802,
-0.1529502571,
0.3905744851,
0.0093703782,
0.0606839582,
0.0188025422,
-0.4857569039,
-0.2392206043,
0.0534557514,
-0.4487827718,
-0.2018302977,
-0.1348858774,
-0.6359328032,
-0.2396454066,
0.0792319477,
-0.5055831671,
-0.8151416779,
0.0001311693,
0.3402345479,
-0.1484481394,
-0.6729367971,
-0.0026447691,
-0.5220713019,
0.3805868626,
0.2507560551,
-0.7552251816,
0.3349615335,
0.7254417539,
0.7156147957,
-0.3047353327,
-0.1874013841,
-0.6173301935,
-0.1335597783,
-0.1966785789,
0.7405301332,
-0.7315559387,
-0.5404972434,
0.1798410267,
0.0837732702,
0.2004861683,
-0.5165311098,
0.5152492523,
-0.5509503484,
0.2894382477,
-0.3695459366,
-0.6277691126,
-0.010213933,
0.0297752153,
-0.7538523078,
0.9181389809,
-0.1634498388,
-0.8151872754,
-0.2067544311,
-0.3061264455,
-0.1078822762,
-0.1375904232,
-0.0819662288,
-0.1535470188,
0.5727697015,
0.12411277,
0.0374773107,
-0.2923500836,
-0.070591718,
-0.4279712141,
-0.3659787476,
0.6631009579,
-0.8871868849,
1.0161845684,
0.1570215672,
-0.1653147489,
0.0201047771,
-0.8040107489,
-0.3884899318,
0.2067458183,
-0.2370925248,
-0.5606671572,
-0.1074426398,
-0.0559777133,
0.0829838067,
0.2835092545,
-0.5037983656,
0.3620166779,
-0.5847045183,
0.2398260385,
0.8297678232,
0.1956530809,
0.6035487056,
0.0232943408,
0.8318116069,
0.2974476814,
-0.1325963438,
-0.4883749783,
-0.6093353629,
-0.459192127,
-0.173353076,
0.292792052,
0.6640594006,
-0.6080022454,
0.1848558486,
-0.0438912958,
-0.4234444797,
-0.4109177291,
-0.2306758016,
0.3474442065,
0.9308073521,
-0.1093821228,
-0.1821275353,
-0.394623071,
-1.095164299,
-0.3307302296,
-0.5099076629,
-0.2581900358,
0.4536973238,
0.2848602533,
-0.1113573462,
0.9105083346,
-0.6036666632,
-0.0004823425,
-0.4684482515,
0.0069445567,
0.531952858,
0.4890761971,
0.4821465313,
-0.8511605859,
0.1779475063,
-0.0391845182,
-0.5167161822,
-0.4554046094,
-0.1958869249,
-0.3831534684,
0.3195223808,
0.5307117701,
-0.7040431499,
0.5958454013,
0.3333363533,
-0.4368570745,
0.5890316367,
-0.2822890878,
-0.3630681038,
-1.2427933216,
0.2513493598,
-0.318223536,
-0.3758248091,
-0.5793907046,
-0.0537461638,
0.1894816458,
0.0979999006,
-0.2696392536,
0.9503658414,
-0.6567351818,
-0.3708435893,
-0.504409194,
0.3721978366,
-0.195034191,
0.1316680312,
0.0207182132,
0.7461502552,
0.7199576497,
-0.4472902715,
0.2267253101,
0.2685803473,
-0.107590653,
0.1355365813,
-0.5365421176,
0.2447584718,
-0.3987776339,
0.4177505374,
-1.4110411406,
-0.0561277792,
0.510183692,
-0.570317924,
0.0903344378,
-0.0831567273,
-0.3226397634,
-0.2295241654,
-0.3928778172,
0.4032256901,
0.7981657386,
-0.5485591292,
0.4937255979,
0.7462955713,
-0.3933588266,
-0.9009519815,
-0.4357303977,
0.1734935343,
-0.1442244649,
0.0277678389,
0.0465806201,
-0.2718614042,
-0.2236888558,
0.0709644258,
-0.0714284331,
0.0112597346,
0.3447370231,
0.3439637721,
0.2443367094,
-0.0377430953,
0.276483953,
0.2568953335,
-0.1409061402,
0.2517303228,
-0.5385175943,
0.8151530027,
0.0101302294,
-0.3306940794,
-0.1670113355,
0.4006294906,
-0.0100112325,
-0.1190235913,
0.5568341613,
0.2800262272,
-0.8179908991,
0.1752512008,
-0.2970817387,
-0.2847001553,
-0.4091295898,
0.5817711353,
-0.4063610137,
-0.5823789239,
0.8759946227,
0.0303461794,
-0.0730869845,
0.6777321696,
0.7741765976,
-0.0426704884,
1.0549911261,
0.9236223698,
-0.0041214973,
0.7430959344,
-0.1684733927,
-0.0140790446,
-0.5963127017,
-0.4143637419,
-0.6817568541,
-0.0948240906,
-0.379272759,
0.0551644154,
0.2220571339,
0.4754244685,
0.2872871757,
0.3005835116,
0.0226591472,
0.5505260825,
0.9442433119,
0.1950984299,
0.2401917726,
0.2027832419,
-0.184188202,
0.0633609965,
-0.5595588684,
-0.4107581079,
0.9853343964,
0.3491277695,
0.4094474316,
0.0543050542,
0.8770247102,
0.2066495419,
0.4963698089,
-0.4593947828,
0.5478461981,
0.2208722532,
-0.5760186911,
-0.3211676776,
-0.462456733,
-0.9391025305,
0.0253417771,
-0.1171571687,
-1.0045866966,
0.2580784559,
0.3891640007,
0.0773430094,
-0.0281481445,
-0.6387028694,
0.7968279719,
0.2417015433,
0.0759768188,
-0.220874846,
-0.8017984033,
0.4602893293,
-0.1740543395,
0.2383010983,
-0.0099999625,
-0.051028274,
0.6725996137,
-0.4771993756,
0.8449004292,
-0.3570086062,
-0.3736824691,
0.2819975019,
0.0163605846,
0.596800983,
0.3131455779,
-0.043895375,
-0.0403931327,
-0.1291368157,
-0.3212688863,
-0.741561532,
0.643134594,
-0.5813114047,
-0.7689430714,
-0.2864675224,
-0.5129523277,
0.278059572,
0.346419394,
0.3179749846,
0.6348677278,
0.0324771777,
-0.0106718168,
0.3951070905,
-0.4591925144,
0.7173618078,
0.3386307955,
-0.4817667902,
-0.2850337625,
0.9658706188,
-0.0569013692,
0.2490628213,
0.6040789485,
0.4549599886,
-0.5951866508,
-0.518899262,
-0.2373779416,
0.3460769355,
-0.9574757814,
-0.2403943241,
-0.5132154822,
-0.1257645339,
-0.2710410357,
0.3349932134,
-0.05684378,
-1.0506715775,
-0.5633754134,
-0.3296472728,
0.1854903996,
0.7088511586,
-0.2465891689,
0.567573607,
-0.6748475432,
-0.0093626222,
-0.2362506539,
-0.0238511078,
-0.0086967945,
-0.8341338634,
-0.0176631156,
0.0771326348,
-0.0916608498,
-1.3152550459,
0.4298059642,
0.076750733,
0.5115469098,
0.2534324825,
0.0974187031,
0.2568008602,
-0.5639916658,
0.8664826155,
0.1448754519,
-0.8872686625,
0.4007524252,
0.0197494626,
0.2317779809,
0.1112871617,
0.1623473912,
-0.6158686876,
-0.5974977016,
-0.816134274,
-0.9375181198,
0.5779643655,
0.2501769364,
0.5732038617,
-0.1672432423,
0.6514565349,
0.4169495702,
0.2704023123,
-0.7723889351,
-0.3489615917,
-0.0107155256,
-0.4113801122,
-0.003883841,
-0.5425601602,
-0.0714347512,
0.0411257781,
0.3875824809,
0.0957378224,
0.5133495331,
-0.0309870113,
-0.2087414414,
0.1838816404,
0.0158470366,
0.6628462076,
0.6395974755,
0.1588716209,
0.4478133023,
0.0879930779,
-0.6090508103,
-0.0521668792,
0.2334343344,
-0.2719723284,
-0.037222039,
0.5316138864,
0.8269504309,
0.0238548201,
-0.7382944226,
0.7775470018,
-0.2530918121,
0.2117061168,
-0.6486879587,
0.1284828186,
0.010108768,
0.5024973154,
0.7508728504,
-0.1263382137,
0.3232551217,
-0.5015019178,
0.3000497222,
0.4640207589,
0.0272827782,
-0.6512143016,
0.9832250476,
-0.1471590251,
-0.647988081,
0.5945829749,
-0.1492685527,
-0.4453070462,
0.6198701859,
1.063747406,
0.9909889102,
-0.0204499289,
0.2248239815,
0.1397187859,
0.1355357915,
-0.1818410903,
0.6109560728,
0.0933404192,
-0.6908606887,
-0.2012574375,
-0.3338595927,
-0.3797629178,
-0.2640041411,
-0.5085542798,
0.2495098561,
-0.206807673,
0.0504210703,
-0.1002553552,
-0.3154280484,
-0.5887046456,
-0.1486406624,
0.1167235747,
1.1246851683,
-0.8240606189,
0.8079100251,
0.5206294656,
-0.3976611793,
-0.6662957072,
0.1908161193,
-0.2003060132,
-1.087372303,
0.571815908,
0.1966966093,
-0.0073449505,
0.3535895944,
-0.9425114989,
-1.0704159737,
0.9024844766,
0.7270072699,
-0.5644337535,
-0.0127095329,
-0.0772988573,
0.470516324,
-0.2757593095,
0.4435738921,
0.3876629174,
0.3047575057,
0.0285732988,
-0.5051856637,
0.1075936705,
-0.2199356705,
-0.0017636268,
0.0185353924,
-0.0044276165,
0.7308067083,
-0.3924100101,
-0.3742612302,
0.2208109349,
0.8108589053,
0.4946386814,
0.361884445,
0.6150272489,
0.0843675584,
1.0016177893,
0.1681503505,
1.3965624571,
0.0152604263,
0.3814246356,
0.7428972125,
-0.2115105093,
0.9415774941,
0.6887205243,
0.0714133009,
0.3193092644,
0.5553175807,
0.5715472698,
0.5898670554,
0.293874532,
-0.1320466548,
-0.0882612765,
-0.1344685853,
-0.3113148808,
0.1618339717,
0.3032519519,
-0.3638465703,
0.1031559333,
0.1451863199,
0.0966011733,
-0.1021742821,
-0.0496345013,
0.681687057,
0.1643417925,
-0.5266838074,
0.552791357,
-0.1515758932,
-0.0704538599,
-0.3257217705,
-0.1984960884,
-0.6331159472,
0.2655025423,
0.2229843885,
-0.7609923482,
0.1174985021,
-0.1935562044,
-0.1950588077,
-0.1812740415,
0.8187801838,
-0.5973963141,
-0.7121089697,
-0.0666956976,
0.378508389,
0.4778980613,
-0.0012875954,
-0.1825978458,
0.0097379517,
-0.0509340242,
-0.6214663982,
0.1000544429,
0.5091658235,
-0.3348324001,
0.6855382919,
0.5117143989,
0.0888696313,
0.3933025002,
0.113233991,
0.9055302143,
-0.7084820271,
-0.4690370858,
-0.9462925792,
0.4822815359,
-0.2894746363,
-0.559764564,
0.5704273582,
0.4330914021,
0.788287282,
-0.1205423474,
0.7731992006,
0.1094942689,
0.5734684467,
-0.8627874851,
0.406935364,
-0.554120481,
0.4837217927,
-0.2669344842,
-0.9331909418,
-0.4652048349,
0.3795199096,
-0.0227292608,
-0.3003191352,
0.6583613753,
0.7374201417,
0.1049271747,
-0.0515521206,
0.0366384462,
0.4186436832,
0.4040411115,
0.3759990036,
1.1715340614,
-0.0831604749,
0.686601162,
0.0632348359,
-0.4447674453,
-0.1980190873,
-0.9953688979,
-0.5676201582,
-0.7948224545,
0.067034483,
-0.3535209,
-0.0025223019,
0.8169700503,
0.0743297264,
-0.584513545,
-0.0974330232,
-0.217585668,
0.3947508931,
-0.3132421374,
-0.1475295871,
0.4132197201,
-0.1391658634,
-0.7164271474,
0.3185929954,
0.0103482893,
0.1521013379,
-0.1702604592,
-0.0339822024,
0.1406273544,
-0.0470790155,
0.2464298904,
0.3603230715,
-0.6863009334,
-0.5679767132,
0.3065876961,
-0.092967771,
-0.1450753659,
0.9284370542,
-0.9487032294,
0.1281841993,
0.6976143718,
0.9473882914,
0.5269645452,
0.005914141,
0.8183937073,
-1.0583583117,
0.2899641693,
-0.0078948857,
0.5146096349,
0.0915080309,
-0.2305372953,
0.2133899331,
0.484094888,
-0.2957272232,
-1.3237358332,
0.6436737776,
-1.0013127327,
-0.1401388645,
1.2901306152,
-0.0943008587,
-0.2808831632,
0.4411078095,
-0.5337962508,
0.2993988693,
-0.251317054,
0.7041332126,
0.6678205132,
0.0435176305,
-0.4101222456,
-0.4091151059,
0.2514311671,
0.5516483188,
-0.6937134266,
0.3162039518,
0.4690947235,
0.1520877331,
-0.0424875543,
0.886880219,
-0.0044839494,
0.1270741671,
-0.1238886043,
-0.0950755775,
0.1037522107,
-0.535474956,
-0.7836482525,
-0.0527316779,
0.2233919799,
-0.2539116144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13628v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13628v2
|
Prompt Risk Control: A Rigorous Framework for Responsible Deployment of Large Language Models
| 2023-11-22T18:50:47 | 2024-03-27T20:20:22 |
Thomas P. Zollo, Todd Morrill, Zhun Deng, Jake C. Snell, Toniann Pitassi, Richard Zemel
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The recent explosion in the capabilities of large language models has led to
a wave of interest in how best to prompt a model to perform a given task. While
it may be tempting to simply choose a prompt based on average performance on a
validation set, this can lead to a deployment where unexpectedly poor responses
are generated, especially for the worst-off users. To mitigate this prospect,
we propose Prompt Risk Control, a lightweight framework for selecting a prompt
based on rigorous upper bounds on families of informative risk measures. We
offer methods for producing bounds on a diverse set of metrics, including
quantities that measure worst-case responses and disparities in generation
quality across the population of users. In addition, we extend the underlying
statistical bounding techniques to accommodate the possibility of distribution
shifts in deployment. Experiments on applications such as open-ended chat,
medical question summarization, and code generation highlight how such a
framework can foster responsible deployment by reducing the risk of the worst
outcomes.
|
[
-0.2958268523,
-0.6098033786,
0.5260628462,
0.6036440134,
0.2553818524,
-0.181485489,
-0.0915815756,
0.0213558897,
-0.3619951904,
0.4796854556,
-0.5775527954,
-0.4484708607,
-0.5059229136,
-0.1596532315,
-0.3068273067,
1.0014599562,
0.1716383994,
-0.4327456951,
-0.2466723919,
0.0724548027,
-0.7891236544,
-0.3444152772,
-0.6992920041,
0.2138790041,
0.8080171347,
0.6023894548,
1.0329310894,
0.6136907935,
0.5078800321,
0.21338664,
-0.3345186412,
-0.231077224,
-0.3857546449,
0.3973736167,
-0.391820699,
-0.6063336134,
-0.0702788085,
-0.2778519988,
0.3125849068,
0.8507943749,
-0.3394843042,
0.2488745004,
0.0261022057,
0.3892585337,
-0.8305580616,
-0.1887290925,
-0.3042665422,
-0.1130288318,
-0.1667339057,
-0.4150501788,
-0.8057414889,
-0.6831182241,
-0.1051425189,
-0.4274745882,
0.0557384342,
0.3979374766,
0.398848772,
0.2796190083,
-0.7050918937,
-0.2472017705,
-0.7416400313,
0.7190145254,
-0.4281013906,
0.1354013979,
0.4174873829,
0.4613225758,
-0.571277976,
-0.3225991726,
-0.2706425488,
-0.3863659203,
0.1762779504,
-0.2962931395,
-0.379797101,
0.2250111997,
0.4579472542,
0.0995082259,
-0.7020881176,
0.5941308737,
-0.2373367995,
-0.5718817115,
0.4508478642,
0.3553796113,
0.5359461904,
0.0519867837,
-0.2194625884,
-0.2244514972,
-1.1339848042,
0.3242348731,
0.6864107847,
0.5683940649,
-0.0255220793,
0.8390679955,
-0.2162851542,
0.6627711058,
-0.0969351679,
-0.0222259667,
-0.08754538,
-0.2363735884,
0.0767489746,
0.0457041413,
0.6358239651,
0.6375237107,
0.1842772514,
0.2616696358,
-0.4540330172,
0.0537627153,
0.2445210814,
-0.6281184554,
0.1800898463,
0.2620892227,
-0.4818265736,
-0.4645046592,
-0.2459746152,
-0.822458446,
-0.8129070997,
-0.0110024801,
0.122693032,
-0.2360054255,
-0.0769057125,
0.0006641881,
0.010345757,
0.0364690647,
0.1893185973,
-0.7873128057,
0.2611163557,
0.2617159188,
0.7607604265,
-0.0104012294,
-0.0795516074,
-1.0624587536,
0.0418253541,
-0.4865164757,
0.4571436346,
-0.1590801477,
-0.4776394069,
0.5497976542,
-0.2105419934,
0.3213463426,
-0.2657992244,
0.692956686,
-0.5171091557,
0.0839464813,
-0.2956292033,
-0.327865541,
0.194526121,
-0.0277839787,
-0.4027123451,
0.7038006783,
0.4678612947,
-0.8375359774,
0.4982698262,
-0.2130377442,
-0.4605267942,
0.0950718001,
0.1098215356,
-0.1736398339,
0.0362223312,
0.0661321804,
0.6364250779,
-0.5058850646,
0.3391628563,
-0.4897186756,
-0.0772547424,
0.3451097608,
-0.3500760496,
0.8726645708,
0.6849092245,
-0.2595561147,
0.4515464306,
-0.5890227556,
-0.0096686976,
0.0235829819,
-0.0041773557,
-0.5013976693,
-0.0682818741,
0.2917184234,
0.3354149461,
0.0480297469,
-0.2204727679,
-0.0108326608,
-0.2062724084,
0.3283595443,
0.8685515523,
0.3467504084,
0.5749462247,
-0.4695547521,
0.9218035936,
-0.0547912158,
0.6299829483,
-0.3946297765,
-0.2667768598,
-0.1306938678,
-0.0855824128,
0.0429248661,
0.839155674,
-0.7709698677,
0.6505925655,
-0.0199953429,
-0.4647901952,
-0.2372382581,
0.1751958728,
0.3145655394,
0.5865677595,
0.106712468,
0.1946879029,
-0.1312696487,
-0.9853027463,
0.0294921007,
-0.5920727253,
-0.1225530952,
0.165547803,
-0.0167871416,
-0.2342565656,
0.913512826,
-0.6757709384,
0.02064633,
-0.532715559,
0.0847121179,
0.2385399789,
0.6093399525,
0.6052578688,
-0.7529473305,
-0.0468023606,
-0.3261375427,
-0.3381960094,
-0.5937876701,
-0.4251269102,
-0.2572510839,
0.0278460719,
0.4940404594,
-0.6888190508,
0.3840761781,
0.5113320351,
-0.4713414013,
0.4786211848,
-0.3254109621,
0.0907177627,
-1.2384548187,
0.3101067543,
0.1405395567,
-0.1348818988,
-0.5816859603,
0.1719501019,
0.0906410962,
-0.252425909,
-0.5073734522,
0.5509009957,
-0.0453729816,
0.2075863183,
0.0620526895,
-0.2221039534,
-0.1465320587,
-0.0723472387,
-0.2790035605,
0.9720774293,
0.7041969895,
-0.9839212894,
0.2183340937,
0.5925990343,
-0.4895869493,
0.7680327296,
-0.8971190453,
-0.385830611,
-0.2053167373,
0.1648179293,
-0.9134042859,
-0.5576207638,
0.1267296523,
-0.2053597122,
0.2143536359,
-0.0269000623,
-0.5203690529,
-0.4393185973,
-0.1726274341,
0.2486399859,
0.856385529,
-0.2451750487,
0.137396574,
0.3045368791,
-0.6415522099,
-0.6424210668,
-0.642380774,
0.0331300087,
-0.453358978,
-0.3956676424,
-0.1776955873,
-0.3059032261,
-0.4163140953,
-0.2924546897,
0.1927513033,
-0.0010297113,
0.3667351305,
0.3599690795,
0.0782773644,
0.076259397,
0.3024373353,
0.2346892059,
-0.1900746822,
0.0893201828,
-0.2550066411,
0.3076017201,
0.2796926796,
-0.4756035209,
-0.0475470647,
0.7573754787,
0.6538287401,
-0.1727481335,
0.6023104787,
0.0768104419,
-0.309820503,
-0.3918566406,
-0.6038092375,
-0.1120561212,
-0.5083447695,
0.1020615697,
-0.0912429318,
-0.7192257643,
0.5696092844,
-0.1481796503,
0.145115912,
0.2770260572,
0.4282176197,
-0.0347726122,
1.2329802513,
0.9093769789,
-0.1145620421,
0.4759252667,
0.2730938792,
0.0769285709,
-0.2067979425,
-0.135000512,
-0.8978654146,
0.1916553527,
-0.5505142808,
-0.2397022247,
0.5089398026,
0.0851929411,
-0.3700287342,
0.255007714,
-0.3716520369,
0.2217746228,
0.7705246806,
-0.0793170929,
0.0328294262,
-0.4175596535,
-0.1403003484,
0.2240256369,
-0.8728762865,
-0.5752471089,
0.6046807766,
0.4104012847,
1.2282983065,
0.2653715611,
0.3998721838,
0.5382025242,
0.0332551487,
-0.4714625478,
0.4869921803,
0.3186887801,
-0.5600739717,
-0.4268593788,
-0.843298018,
-0.7702161074,
-0.3868321776,
-0.004841648,
-0.60501647,
0.2623813152,
0.4283041954,
-0.8171408176,
-0.1028877646,
-0.7924355268,
0.857840836,
-0.2295614332,
-0.1937842816,
0.1253112555,
-0.9018939734,
0.2753229141,
-0.025757106,
0.2514507473,
-0.1689915806,
-0.1452807188,
0.280326277,
-0.3878320754,
1.0100210905,
-0.3749193251,
-0.2073867023,
0.5028420687,
0.4044056237,
0.8108533621,
0.128715381,
-0.0709250718,
-0.3963008523,
0.0764394253,
-0.5501696467,
-0.5450878739,
0.5138725638,
-0.4081162214,
-0.442902118,
-0.2642953694,
-0.324220717,
-0.2921416759,
0.3116455078,
0.7193223238,
0.505731523,
-0.2514010668,
0.0232377667,
0.9628387094,
-0.726864934,
0.3626329601,
0.2636927068,
-0.232978031,
-0.2451459765,
0.6167069077,
0.0708663389,
0.5038427114,
0.3952878416,
0.4525460303,
-0.5485547185,
-0.7280780673,
-0.6214450002,
-0.2834502161,
-0.8031993508,
-0.5317752957,
-0.5103158355,
0.1393261403,
-0.4001482725,
-0.5478551388,
0.0450793132,
-0.1704066694,
-0.2549980581,
-0.358056128,
0.5002789497,
0.6247286797,
0.0796612501,
0.518052578,
-0.7270601988,
-0.1345629543,
0.12168172,
0.4611186683,
-0.3280397952,
-0.2821513116,
0.0020464626,
-0.3037012219,
0.0293449685,
-0.8165242076,
0.2408934236,
-0.0024721054,
0.6268948317,
0.3646605015,
0.6963044405,
0.1037726551,
-0.5256857276,
1.0049860477,
0.342091471,
-0.8576306105,
0.9258748293,
-0.6918110251,
0.5806643367,
0.8557527661,
0.5048754811,
-0.7157747746,
-0.6944524646,
-0.5310260653,
-0.856073916,
0.3293471336,
0.0834094509,
0.3943387866,
-0.1931315362,
0.1613235772,
0.0375895463,
0.1888597608,
-0.2509571612,
0.0704121068,
0.0665778145,
-0.3232277334,
-0.2466109991,
-0.5045657754,
-0.2206841409,
0.4307320118,
0.5400956273,
-0.3716883659,
0.0092466194,
0.0659380332,
-0.0297046378,
-0.2489260733,
0.4656408727,
0.7351474166,
0.4236106873,
0.1654064655,
0.3579408228,
-0.0065343156,
-0.1020534337,
0.4780140221,
0.1007178649,
-0.4799896777,
-0.2478306293,
0.4313921034,
0.6385778785,
0.2696575522,
-1.0206435919,
0.9140561819,
0.0639015585,
0.2375686169,
-0.037957415,
0.2282359153,
-0.3778344691,
-0.0377845988,
0.1357510537,
0.1491228193,
0.3718859851,
-0.2022496015,
0.4504061639,
0.0716975853,
-0.422795862,
-0.2225012928,
0.7711226344,
0.2715751529,
-0.175606817,
0.5013517141,
-0.2240112573,
-0.2485153228,
0.6013402343,
0.4968636036,
0.8017055392,
-0.5801858306,
0.4074221849,
0.4025117159,
0.4663519263,
-0.3284167051,
0.5586973429,
0.2635826468,
-0.3973385096,
-0.5119385719,
-0.1892528832,
-0.4909580052,
-0.2103572637,
-0.5841460824,
0.2962524593,
-0.6292843819,
-0.430488795,
-0.3171688318,
-0.4764301479,
-0.6095332503,
-0.0014310996,
0.0590683632,
1.2302252054,
-0.9173578024,
0.1130128205,
0.4590097964,
-0.4032695591,
-0.8573051095,
-0.136765793,
0.243304804,
-0.3867124915,
0.3213227391,
0.1368153989,
0.1096667051,
-0.2281319052,
-0.539917767,
-0.6776474714,
0.5044230223,
0.6434161067,
-0.5570144057,
0.1429581791,
-0.0655304343,
0.4347509742,
-0.0879767686,
0.2785715759,
0.1975241452,
0.3563730121,
0.2719531953,
-0.9030677676,
0.3267537355,
-0.0201544221,
0.2245689929,
0.1996031702,
-0.3231724799,
0.3417495787,
-0.5134949088,
-0.2996489704,
0.1185818091,
0.5046786666,
-0.0016074552,
0.27004686,
0.6712197065,
0.0174626224,
0.9041913748,
0.0607913695,
1.4218820333,
-0.1861269474,
-0.1386905611,
0.985896349,
-0.4227808416,
0.5024114847,
0.3820154369,
-0.0064341985,
-0.0518481322,
0.7822077274,
0.3659090102,
0.4473018348,
0.4420199096,
-0.3522782326,
-0.1108026579,
-0.698710978,
-0.2272273302,
-0.0821681619,
0.2147383839,
-0.2892382741,
-0.1958644837,
0.3388930261,
-0.0863651261,
0.1807640344,
-0.3467640281,
0.768855691,
0.1522395909,
-0.7565214634,
0.2838223577,
-0.1572002172,
0.415371865,
-0.7819752097,
0.1133290902,
-0.2094275951,
-0.1438702345,
-0.0863738209,
-0.9229423404,
0.1906905621,
0.0500121824,
-0.2495096177,
-0.3985626698,
0.5885509849,
-0.3225508034,
-0.22695297,
0.0317339376,
0.3488134742,
-0.2620472014,
0.0644679442,
-0.3111513257,
0.0672812164,
-0.3052224219,
-0.4102340639,
0.1951517016,
0.5196252465,
-0.4964875579,
0.9673238993,
0.6296410561,
0.2501245439,
0.1877289414,
0.0641173571,
0.7795402408,
-0.2524776757,
-0.8331524134,
-0.6169816256,
0.6070241332,
-0.0968473554,
-0.5984988213,
0.5971878767,
0.2709464431,
0.3376931548,
-0.1103390604,
0.8643676639,
-0.3005499244,
0.4098748863,
-0.4837667644,
0.4275687337,
-0.1426882446,
0.1784746796,
-0.2891975045,
-0.7807870507,
-0.6536852717,
0.2349760681,
-0.0636040121,
-0.1412709504,
0.2789751887,
0.8902890682,
0.3143117428,
-0.1864134222,
0.4545527399,
-0.1206080392,
0.568723917,
0.4730165005,
1.100728035,
0.2814975679,
0.4236982465,
-0.1999941766,
-0.5789657235,
-0.3593936563,
-1.1649093628,
-0.7470785379,
-0.6217980385,
-0.1947915554,
-0.6076208353,
-0.094248265,
1.4804854393,
0.7742317915,
-0.8522709012,
0.1446617395,
-0.1699757427,
0.1554501504,
-0.4307966828,
-0.1810291559,
0.151552096,
-0.6319024563,
-0.3014686108,
0.391867578,
0.0368883088,
0.4141594172,
-0.4497532248,
0.0481911562,
0.3753657043,
0.1574290246,
0.4135917723,
0.5276366472,
-0.3216307163,
-0.4306180775,
0.0257012825,
-0.4833868444,
-0.4759131968,
1.1044597626,
-0.3194970787,
0.3237020373,
0.7386292219,
0.9576377869,
-0.3535347581,
-0.2517708242,
0.9862677455,
-0.9107464552,
0.1476328373,
0.489028573,
0.2758172154,
0.3458573818,
-0.9992028475,
0.3783446252,
-0.2495314777,
-0.6235416532,
-0.9815320969,
0.4709658325,
-0.8702101111,
-0.0613531694,
1.3977136612,
-0.1151138395,
-0.0310744625,
-0.1468458921,
-0.5200102329,
-0.011013777,
-0.6440994143,
0.6278791428,
0.5682929158,
0.2531908453,
-0.2371189296,
-0.6328725219,
0.5938161612,
0.2891599238,
-0.7843423486,
0.5546607971,
0.7313828468,
0.0543643571,
-0.0093138106,
0.5597129464,
0.2070066184,
0.29476735,
-0.2454102933,
0.208022356,
0.0146014132,
-0.6868421435,
-0.6922228336,
0.2742547989,
0.472252816,
0.1342673302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13581v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13581v1
|
PaSS: Parallel Speculative Sampling
| 2023-11-22T18:37:27 | 2023-11-22T18:37:27 |
Giovanni Monea, Armand Joulin, Edouard Grave
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Scaling the size of language models to tens of billions of parameters has led
to impressive performance on a wide range of tasks. At generation, these models
are used auto-regressively, requiring a forward pass for each generated token,
and thus reading the full set of parameters from memory. This memory access
forms the primary bottleneck for generation and it worsens as the model size
increases. Moreover, executing a forward pass for multiple tokens in parallel
often takes nearly the same time as it does for just one token. These two
observations lead to the development of speculative sampling, where a second
smaller model is used to draft a few tokens, that are then validated or
rejected using a single forward pass of the large model. Unfortunately, this
method requires two models that share the same tokenizer and thus limits its
adoption. As an alternative, we propose to use parallel decoding as a way to
draft multiple tokens from a single model with no computational cost, nor the
need for a second model. Our approach only requires an additional input token
that marks the words that will be generated simultaneously. We show promising
performance (up to $30\%$ speed-up) while requiring only as few as $O(d_{emb})$
additional parameters.
|
[
-0.467543304,
-0.572470367,
0.6536918879,
0.6709291935,
-0.4352335632,
0.1872544438,
0.0332354829,
-0.3953597248,
0.2126190811,
0.766471386,
-0.6066526175,
-0.3354816735,
-0.6527335048,
0.1688005179,
-0.4093248546,
0.5602075458,
-0.0118857417,
-0.0060541169,
-0.0463640988,
-0.2299501896,
-0.2468325794,
-0.6024378538,
-0.8713437915,
-0.051382672,
0.3973522484,
0.4968432486,
0.3325977325,
0.80944556,
0.28211236,
0.2107832879,
0.1118479371,
0.0403444059,
-0.355461359,
0.2446659505,
-0.096737802,
-0.6706303954,
-0.3071203828,
-0.072756052,
0.8642867208,
0.7300952077,
0.0041529885,
0.4206807911,
-0.3331186473,
0.4537938237,
-0.7297955751,
0.0958582014,
-0.6822786331,
-0.2014688998,
-0.621950686,
-0.1299655735,
-0.6625190377,
-0.2041519135,
-0.3724571764,
-0.6970143914,
0.4740889966,
0.488076508,
0.4137124121,
0.0041247201,
0.1144323125,
-0.0990971401,
-0.5424489975,
0.7533544898,
-0.5644568801,
0.2542819083,
0.3531326354,
0.2571341097,
0.1166061461,
-1.1102586985,
-0.919029355,
-0.0886090994,
0.1533016115,
-0.0578193069,
-0.0491887107,
-0.0059480621,
0.445212841,
0.2891063392,
-0.519114852,
0.1193928719,
-0.5962482691,
-0.2061142176,
0.4913589954,
0.6632364988,
0.1423632652,
-0.0023303623,
-0.6231347919,
-0.3984422386,
-0.5763888955,
0.0742686167,
0.555475235,
0.526358664,
0.008317234,
0.1730327308,
-0.4034510553,
0.703975141,
-0.0081952149,
0.2692488134,
0.0814329237,
-0.701839447,
-0.2185020745,
-0.1988660544,
0.806186974,
0.1223625615,
-0.0519574396,
-0.0128701245,
-0.0352651365,
0.1275375336,
0.1824639738,
-1.1273088455,
-0.3460321128,
0.4001129568,
-0.5598746538,
-0.1747733802,
0.0297814403,
-1.0249804258,
-0.22338669,
-0.1374343485,
0.0984601155,
-0.4165089726,
-0.2398283333,
0.5171307921,
-0.56058079,
0.0756790861,
0.1774100363,
-1.0629869699,
0.7089686394,
0.6306372285,
0.8693936467,
-0.152249679,
-0.736351788,
-0.5938147306,
0.0297683049,
-0.281514883,
1.0785793066,
-0.7243556976,
-0.650147438,
-0.4485598207,
-0.3512494564,
-0.2994123101,
-0.2698257565,
0.4871745706,
-0.6812025309,
-0.2384512872,
-0.6628347635,
-0.3254672885,
0.0305414591,
-0.0232246518,
-0.757579565,
0.7000992298,
-0.1202610955,
-0.9011433125,
0.5178434253,
-0.4419146478,
-0.3696019351,
0.2115062773,
-0.2588213682,
0.1516500115,
0.3663830459,
0.5988630652,
0.1964131743,
-0.554480195,
-0.3215018809,
-0.5216591954,
-0.7200582027,
-0.0862325728,
-0.659260571,
0.7869969606,
0.482385546,
0.0276557989,
-0.154698804,
-0.6895956993,
0.1884271502,
0.1213145331,
-0.3622125089,
-0.1818967909,
-0.1730654985,
0.3888607025,
0.140438959,
0.1006384566,
-0.6746072173,
0.3010239899,
-0.2718937993,
0.1596431434,
0.6832066178,
-0.1259949952,
0.3882212937,
-0.5179257989,
0.7426608205,
0.120105654,
0.0587344728,
-0.5260149837,
-0.5029312968,
-0.652286768,
-0.4215082526,
0.5214482546,
0.2999615967,
-0.6728665233,
-0.0199895743,
-0.0264086332,
-0.51823771,
-0.7336792946,
-0.0741870403,
0.2394343466,
0.1038022339,
0.2669433057,
-0.2955039442,
-0.5495051742,
-0.6864997745,
-0.6556604505,
-0.3116161525,
0.2003999501,
0.2006279677,
0.3056025803,
0.2052403837,
0.4595614672,
-0.6091151237,
0.0182250682,
-0.2107633054,
0.3752052784,
0.2060812116,
0.6167846918,
0.6179568172,
-0.4414256513,
-0.4711686373,
-0.1772638857,
-0.3818005025,
-0.0210418608,
-0.3085938096,
-0.1935288459,
0.050584022,
0.7841970325,
-0.748193562,
0.2614017129,
0.6599037051,
-0.4653522372,
0.5619782209,
-0.411131233,
0.1261288077,
-0.8818112016,
0.2934438884,
-0.4935236871,
-0.00468279,
-0.5276737809,
0.5254972577,
0.0009708186,
-0.0508003011,
-0.4687277377,
0.7332700491,
-0.5682661533,
0.1560243219,
-0.3542253375,
-0.2866074741,
0.1804804355,
0.2344968319,
-0.1205673143,
0.9126704335,
0.7514670491,
-0.4327918589,
0.208554253,
-0.105687879,
-0.1023471355,
0.3279681504,
-0.5722268224,
0.5312688947,
-0.380774498,
0.565038085,
-0.9125947356,
-0.2990129888,
0.2317366898,
-0.4497951865,
0.2826265991,
0.0191168953,
-0.764931798,
-0.5442287326,
-0.1955408603,
0.8532941937,
0.485344857,
-0.5067874789,
0.5945996642,
0.2221163958,
-0.1255469322,
-0.7108347416,
-0.8794727921,
-0.00392689,
0.1259620339,
-0.5023903251,
0.2137344331,
-0.0075645954,
-0.0248484146,
0.0791854039,
-0.0251464769,
-0.1941687763,
-0.2330465764,
0.0707265809,
-0.0623838194,
-0.3230707347,
-0.1367678195,
0.2333544046,
-0.1757633388,
0.0035336213,
-0.8005509377,
0.7301774621,
0.0515718982,
-0.3968741298,
-0.7223343849,
1.0730015039,
1.1233562231,
-0.232507959,
0.7846113443,
0.5558888912,
-0.1892617792,
-0.5583913922,
-0.6217789054,
-0.1716374159,
-0.4649261534,
0.1685966253,
-0.9200745225,
-0.7153539062,
0.7936359048,
0.178190887,
0.1662719995,
0.3931435645,
0.6375082135,
0.1863432527,
0.9213495851,
0.5690069199,
-0.0241143629,
0.1903966814,
-0.0554614216,
0.0025388619,
-0.3865650594,
-0.1858205497,
-0.6852676272,
-0.3383925259,
-0.2240546197,
-0.868529439,
-0.1362600327,
0.2433719486,
0.068639949,
0.346424818,
-0.2564642727,
0.7055256367,
0.9515160322,
0.0625786409,
0.4123949707,
0.1925551742,
-0.583812654,
0.2064201832,
-0.8679014444,
-0.1933680922,
1.1653532982,
0.2465963066,
0.7175382376,
-0.2438998967,
0.8499481082,
-0.2101337016,
0.1858621836,
-0.3301899135,
0.6073340774,
-0.420078069,
-0.7771311998,
-0.0834926888,
-0.3023108542,
-0.6584945321,
0.5011469126,
0.1593018174,
-0.6567040682,
0.4009324908,
0.2944745421,
-0.7270922065,
0.58947438,
-0.7683266401,
0.6626464128,
0.3817301691,
-0.2040514946,
-0.5513242483,
-0.3859178424,
0.6001468301,
-0.2249455899,
0.1083197892,
-0.0877480358,
0.008597062,
0.5570035577,
-0.544565618,
0.6481113434,
-0.3426160812,
0.3647036254,
0.4098386765,
0.1167882532,
0.5319167376,
0.2688063979,
-0.2771574855,
0.252142936,
0.3168301582,
-0.7254338861,
-0.4726448953,
0.6241443157,
-0.5074205995,
-0.6073792577,
-0.3400711119,
-0.7497574687,
-0.1302323639,
0.3163706958,
0.5947260857,
0.3187296093,
0.1091291234,
-0.1030396521,
0.180821076,
-0.0701302662,
0.4511674345,
0.2316150218,
-0.1738143563,
-0.3311049044,
0.8666103482,
-0.0812994167,
0.3753813505,
0.1790187806,
0.0495908782,
-0.3219250143,
-0.8395553231,
-0.5517781377,
0.3799943924,
-0.5791190267,
0.0675664991,
-0.8730916977,
-0.0049355328,
-0.5354945064,
0.0008007875,
-0.4989848733,
-0.4300799072,
-0.1719853282,
0.1479139775,
0.3899354339,
0.5567060709,
-0.3898387551,
0.3409609199,
-0.9379717708,
0.4717113674,
0.1747251004,
0.4072474837,
0.1909942478,
-0.3976769447,
0.0139138373,
-0.3514152467,
0.1279670298,
-0.6474184394,
0.1806441247,
-0.1852938235,
0.5180734992,
0.3368537128,
0.1480839849,
0.7739182711,
-0.6613543034,
0.5874390602,
0.1309984475,
-1.0112935305,
0.1267630309,
-0.3458590806,
0.5663771033,
1.033991456,
0.2214503139,
-0.5449442267,
-0.419999361,
-0.4099895954,
-0.8321250081,
1.2033451796,
0.1437374055,
0.2099205256,
0.0358497724,
0.1457155198,
0.3405037522,
0.0120928977,
-0.1357457936,
-0.367518425,
-0.1052896306,
0.0215913653,
0.1125762686,
-0.3481039405,
0.0320784561,
-0.174920395,
0.2024036497,
-0.0230940375,
0.491820693,
0.0745048746,
0.28420946,
0.0280813184,
0.0963622108,
0.5759940147,
0.4025839865,
-0.1226413548,
0.1386838108,
0.2427558601,
-0.8155664206,
-0.0302097779,
0.1969158202,
-0.1106282473,
0.1954638213,
0.1053692028,
0.8464305401,
-0.1114359945,
-0.5412519574,
0.3940755129,
-0.3165756464,
-0.524202168,
0.1148838028,
-0.1274500638,
0.1557531208,
0.2256010175,
0.1535526067,
0.5571600199,
0.1191122308,
-0.2929261625,
0.4601547718,
0.0608096756,
-0.0386941209,
-0.4323984087,
0.7268486023,
0.019338714,
-0.1796946377,
0.6794625521,
-0.3892482817,
-0.2855210006,
0.5909699798,
0.6297843456,
0.9307327867,
0.0498581678,
-0.0605735146,
0.4022368789,
0.2417666316,
-0.4664306343,
0.7281978726,
-0.3629348576,
-0.5309592485,
-0.5863918066,
-0.9885277152,
-0.4286824167,
-0.0629207343,
-0.6278923154,
0.0911558717,
-0.7621817589,
-0.1559187025,
-0.1091228798,
-0.3351094425,
-0.8885911107,
0.00292666,
0.3219203949,
1.2965757847,
-0.626111865,
1.0054546595,
0.6128339767,
-0.2258535475,
-0.9188030362,
0.3010474443,
-0.1162169129,
-0.7395088077,
0.8629333377,
0.1342352331,
-0.1696421355,
0.1144805476,
0.0123098046,
-0.9180963039,
0.6468404531,
0.3033134043,
-0.5807090998,
-0.5539193153,
0.1036669314,
0.2491527349,
-0.2698530257,
0.2656731009,
0.7345786095,
0.4144947827,
0.4062741697,
-0.7654937506,
0.3325824738,
-0.1657546163,
0.1102351248,
0.0473748371,
-0.8070021868,
1.2996529341,
-0.2484927028,
-0.5914866328,
0.2190522701,
0.5765066743,
0.6987239718,
0.2880343497,
0.4923456907,
0.6713762879,
0.797586441,
0.160027802,
1.1248840094,
-0.4769441187,
0.1403125674,
0.925327003,
-0.1382542104,
1.0484064817,
0.4952987134,
-0.3436068594,
0.2469278574,
0.1848958731,
0.1562930644,
0.4454822242,
0.3451584876,
-0.4050492346,
-0.3607881963,
0.1050944999,
-0.3092594147,
0.5525795817,
0.5480264425,
-0.2137024552,
-0.4499690533,
-0.020026654,
-0.1538208574,
0.0198981985,
-0.2470950633,
0.0768444166,
0.3018508852,
-0.7562540174,
0.435683459,
0.1663908958,
0.8120212555,
-0.3995940089,
0.2752490342,
-0.1458809227,
0.2920963466,
0.1578269601,
-0.4883078635,
0.5373809934,
-0.1237216368,
-0.4047152102,
-0.3740155101,
0.4228236079,
-0.1562477201,
-0.8184122443,
0.2844287157,
0.4975372255,
0.2191638798,
-0.258657217,
-0.5407315493,
0.5003467202,
-0.2389415354,
-0.1898071468,
0.092964001,
0.411005497,
0.0829631165,
0.2651444972,
0.8638967872,
0.4741840065,
0.4125159979,
0.193693608,
0.7971793413,
-0.8240758181,
-0.7962554693,
-0.9293288589,
0.2292423099,
-0.0613545589,
-0.5715066791,
0.75391078,
0.3508475423,
0.9773737788,
-0.0458855368,
0.7591999769,
0.0522381365,
0.427762121,
-0.5604448915,
0.9505106211,
-0.3743853867,
0.1581653804,
-0.0517763197,
-0.5411690474,
-0.3756289482,
0.0248806234,
-0.0021181453,
-0.1268950552,
0.9681740999,
0.8006724715,
0.0704934224,
0.2578158677,
0.4264880419,
-0.0360626243,
0.0986232832,
0.8291582465,
0.9049748182,
-0.5623106956,
0.555713892,
-0.2035368532,
-0.0343665332,
-0.0463249534,
-0.4635692835,
-0.9349239469,
-0.4019205868,
0.0286114495,
-0.2016040683,
0.0137192504,
0.7064759731,
0.9659309983,
-0.8347437978,
-0.2784093916,
-0.4609332085,
-0.2243942916,
-0.3754818141,
-0.1646447778,
0.3543838561,
-0.7527948022,
-1.0419832468,
0.4578109086,
0.2398591936,
-0.1642374098,
-0.2232650071,
0.2452088892,
0.1479754895,
0.4463447034,
0.2838833928,
0.3785230815,
-0.7427634001,
0.12935251,
0.0745014027,
-0.0437425151,
-0.2144316137,
1.4167414904,
-0.9184240103,
0.5905073285,
0.9225766659,
0.8531380296,
0.7661632299,
-0.0348906927,
0.6532732844,
-0.512331605,
0.4153063297,
0.2748346031,
0.1364308894,
-0.1615888029,
-0.3773238957,
-0.3483915925,
0.5403635502,
-0.2370170802,
-0.9171053767,
0.2832707465,
-0.8797763586,
-0.6639387012,
0.8239963055,
-0.1539220363,
-0.2002112418,
-0.2427374572,
-0.0149518736,
-0.0558939688,
-0.5153107643,
0.2742271423,
0.7168534994,
-0.147946313,
-0.144646734,
-0.4865194857,
0.419059366,
0.533460319,
-0.3835883141,
0.3822623789,
0.2014588267,
0.1417016685,
-0.0131379822,
1.02199018,
-0.1903578788,
0.3524004221,
1.1037284136,
-0.2399021834,
-0.2613362074,
-0.5455234647,
-0.4591478109,
0.7106799483,
0.139191851,
-0.4665244818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13565v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13565v1
|
Drilling Down into the Discourse Structure with LLMs for Long Document Question Answering
| 2023-11-22T18:22:56 | 2023-11-22T18:22:56 |
Inderjeet Nair, Shwetha Somasundaram, Apoorv Saxena, Koustava Goswami
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
We address the task of evidence retrieval for long document question
answering, which involves locating relevant paragraphs within a document to
answer a question. We aim to assess the applicability of large language models
(LLMs) in the task of zero-shot long document evidence retrieval, owing to
their unprecedented performance across various NLP tasks. However, currently
the LLMs can consume limited context lengths as input, thus providing document
chunks as inputs might overlook the global context while missing out on
capturing the inter-segment dependencies. Moreover, directly feeding the large
input sets can incur significant computational costs, particularly when
processing the entire document (and potentially incurring monetary expenses
with enterprise APIs like OpenAI's GPT variants). To address these challenges,
we propose a suite of techniques that exploit the discourse structure commonly
found in documents. By utilizing this structure, we create a condensed
representation of the document, enabling a more comprehensive understanding and
analysis of relationships between different parts. We retain $99.6\%$ of the
best zero-shot approach's performance, while processing only $26\%$ of the
total tokens used by the best approach in the information seeking evidence
retrieval setup. We also show how our approach can be combined with
\textit{self-ask} reasoning agent to achieve best zero-shot performance in
complex multi-hop question answering, just $\approx 4\%$ short of zero-shot
performance using gold evidence.
|
[
-0.0166690387,
-0.9030094147,
1.1360114813,
-0.095793806,
-0.3930621147,
-0.0175949577,
-0.0093207536,
-0.5120399594,
0.3287543654,
0.6004759669,
-0.3577535748,
-0.5099413395,
-0.6560479999,
0.0607389398,
-0.4272867441,
0.7583192587,
-0.141351223,
-0.1077836528,
-0.2214249671,
-0.1644984335,
-0.168355152,
-0.5704157948,
-0.5478302836,
-0.4012473822,
0.7474782467,
0.2923186719,
0.3165374696,
0.7311019301,
0.301538974,
0.2113349438,
-0.3674945533,
0.0986450538,
-0.4532693326,
0.3091703355,
-0.2904804945,
-0.4759189785,
-0.4943487942,
-0.0544144772,
0.7093333602,
0.6409285665,
0.0907331109,
0.1455145776,
-0.1133675575,
0.1976862699,
-0.7618427873,
0.1633290946,
-0.7054445744,
0.0782804936,
-0.4096187949,
-0.5001019239,
-0.6249588132,
0.0281674694,
0.1577409953,
-0.4688256085,
0.0133822933,
-0.0210335907,
0.749943316,
-0.0264115147,
-0.6705027223,
-0.5066436529,
-0.6537525654,
0.7118493319,
-0.8166196942,
-0.0866316408,
0.3645176589,
0.042275399,
-0.2628665566,
-0.7383090854,
-0.4259269834,
-0.2682203352,
-0.2661760151,
0.1621642411,
0.0489941277,
0.3030213416,
0.4210801721,
0.5196555853,
-0.7398021221,
0.0988763124,
-0.1845952421,
-0.3019418418,
0.4504064322,
0.145012185,
0.1851470917,
-0.4214899242,
-0.3237741888,
0.0735637099,
-0.8661491275,
-0.1475802809,
0.1455438882,
0.3633859158,
0.3271887302,
0.8482983112,
-0.2474074066,
0.6058261991,
-0.1484467238,
-0.2271818072,
-0.1063235998,
-0.3230320215,
-0.2757133842,
0.1043588817,
0.6494153142,
0.1208081543,
-0.1976776868,
0.0056151543,
-0.1161639094,
-0.1813362688,
0.1129080728,
-1.0249503851,
0.2529893816,
0.3335957527,
-0.37303707,
0.0555652939,
-0.3737523556,
-0.5881783366,
-0.3096679151,
-0.1780148149,
0.4052386284,
-0.5298307538,
0.0122523326,
0.2138124555,
-0.2632614076,
0.8000147343,
0.5002329946,
-0.6975325346,
0.2915681899,
0.9134879708,
1.0170414448,
0.0019766339,
-0.0670045912,
-0.7330958247,
0.3511660099,
-0.3541172147,
0.9547661543,
-0.4769060612,
-0.4841081202,
0.1943796873,
-0.0039810049,
-0.0024438216,
-0.3341062963,
0.9698744416,
-0.6781780124,
0.4698379934,
-0.2638677359,
-0.9658156037,
-0.0564018935,
0.7452070713,
-0.5471943617,
0.9640507698,
-0.0150790783,
-0.8409605026,
0.079527922,
-0.7506894469,
-0.4498029053,
0.2203362733,
-0.373375684,
-0.16375269,
0.0977458805,
0.4173154831,
0.5226317644,
-0.3134527504,
0.2420724183,
-0.3007726371,
-0.532687664,
0.0286723785,
-0.4758259356,
0.7323800325,
0.032992173,
-0.2494410574,
0.0825303271,
-0.6954475641,
-0.1541014612,
0.3495835066,
-0.3274514377,
-0.6414496899,
0.0121537261,
-0.268986851,
0.1035866737,
0.2128495276,
-0.8266464472,
0.3388880789,
-0.486718446,
0.2921413183,
0.6524490118,
0.2690881193,
0.3875013888,
-0.1117210239,
0.5671300292,
-0.0372891948,
-0.0849634781,
-0.751529634,
-0.2235148251,
-0.6440633535,
-0.2282582968,
0.3601171076,
0.3567954004,
-0.6839377284,
0.1889156252,
-0.3753849268,
-0.0956034139,
-0.4540003538,
-0.1067712232,
0.3953581154,
0.8572548032,
0.3639765084,
-0.2903337479,
-0.3429712355,
-0.9402657747,
-0.1182334423,
-0.2686985433,
-0.344979167,
0.2771443129,
0.7314062119,
0.1765808165,
0.9202983379,
-0.7809922695,
-0.2048132271,
-0.2031414211,
0.3440664411,
0.4018218219,
0.0070398808,
0.4413217902,
-0.5640716553,
-0.3463855982,
-0.2076514661,
-0.8251570463,
0.0824098438,
-0.1873458326,
-0.1218280941,
0.2099016309,
0.5483549833,
-0.9702215195,
0.4100092649,
0.1428235769,
-0.3483143747,
0.5026353002,
-0.0539240241,
-0.0379365049,
-1.1131938696,
0.2616243958,
-0.0515279993,
-0.4296484292,
-0.6216968298,
0.3345138729,
0.2460666597,
-0.0869213641,
-0.5567462444,
0.6019554138,
-0.6602486968,
-0.1839128584,
-0.3948097527,
0.4142515063,
0.3522502184,
0.5109014511,
0.1134315953,
0.9351688623,
0.2762193382,
-0.3048087955,
0.0024081485,
0.1704808176,
-0.3537221551,
0.7035704851,
-0.7397953868,
0.3542613387,
-0.4361411929,
0.5821880698,
-0.9067796469,
-0.2348741889,
0.293541193,
-0.2807869911,
0.5983221531,
-0.400110662,
-0.4657509029,
-0.1425891221,
-0.6235086918,
0.3469105363,
0.1631692797,
-0.3852646947,
0.6631968617,
0.3841152489,
-0.3911089897,
-0.883299768,
-0.4443397224,
0.4894733429,
-0.1888877004,
-0.5708122253,
0.455766499,
-0.0405311026,
-0.1737896651,
-0.1240760088,
-0.1296119094,
0.0598735549,
-0.0153352981,
0.0763927698,
0.2707209289,
-0.4732390344,
0.2544867694,
0.0362937972,
-0.0053343559,
0.1552724689,
-0.307949692,
0.6106367111,
0.0810899511,
-0.5550854206,
-0.1579780877,
0.7484686375,
0.6116479039,
-0.1788496375,
0.6509075761,
0.2927597463,
-0.1983779967,
-0.0408406667,
-0.648738265,
0.0491163619,
-0.4119569957,
0.4352777302,
-0.4793848693,
-1.1112003326,
0.5278366804,
-0.1860630363,
0.1676017493,
0.5241287947,
0.5374715924,
-0.0945160985,
0.7188595533,
0.3337816596,
-0.4133743644,
0.2457504719,
-0.247719571,
0.1279855371,
-1.0997600555,
-0.16379489,
-0.5898506641,
-0.0577098466,
-0.0991193354,
-0.7093688846,
0.3369310796,
-0.1690491289,
-0.0811890662,
0.1042408273,
-0.3132114112,
0.5611588955,
0.4030039012,
-0.0494062454,
0.508336246,
-0.2503866255,
-0.0856872872,
0.1358153522,
-0.5439426303,
-0.5213786364,
1.0436338186,
0.4847848117,
0.660001874,
-0.0339272656,
0.7661733031,
0.1282090247,
0.1548625827,
-1.0263125896,
0.7259960771,
0.1663413644,
-0.5556077957,
-0.4946457446,
-0.3150123656,
-1.1720459461,
0.5078386664,
0.1737579703,
-0.6864135861,
0.0196456406,
-0.2751537561,
-0.3446490765,
0.2574074268,
-0.3068675995,
0.6053510308,
-0.2656389773,
-0.3306108117,
-0.0420150645,
-0.6690375805,
0.3151779771,
0.0996683687,
0.0947471634,
-0.0594070926,
-0.0952899158,
0.6256945133,
-0.2556281686,
0.7734788656,
-0.1483331621,
-0.4500341713,
0.4421355128,
0.0516756922,
0.5147752762,
-0.0021306453,
-0.232730031,
0.0574563555,
-0.0041347104,
-0.4341607392,
-0.7277731895,
0.6055387259,
-0.5670351982,
-0.7101325989,
-0.5740443468,
-0.5049159527,
-0.0189824719,
0.3164037764,
0.0781723037,
0.4655665159,
-0.3929570913,
0.303196311,
0.8078293204,
-0.0127082206,
0.4702091217,
0.5693733692,
-0.1701489985,
-0.1553128362,
0.4463324845,
0.2578306198,
0.0637664571,
0.7141448259,
0.1000274122,
-0.5492554903,
-0.7946668863,
-0.3647221923,
0.414970845,
-0.7273891568,
-0.3273118734,
-0.7074911594,
-0.3668747544,
-0.4523272514,
0.1146208495,
-0.2272868752,
-0.5197832584,
-0.3395384252,
-0.2793773413,
-0.0298540387,
0.4326279759,
0.3451244831,
0.184169963,
-0.6866391301,
0.3337845206,
0.2364395708,
0.3414137959,
-0.0443620309,
-0.6956534982,
-0.0831899494,
-0.1823266745,
-0.3335570395,
-0.8937928081,
0.2052734196,
0.1009136215,
0.4203520715,
0.3035098612,
0.1605577469,
0.8027174473,
-0.6584429741,
0.9054435492,
-0.1051410809,
-0.7356866598,
0.6670757532,
-0.5290368795,
0.4569678605,
0.5970515013,
0.5576258302,
-0.5633940101,
-0.3859027624,
-0.4203305244,
-1.0567979813,
0.5411957502,
0.2383685708,
0.2142280042,
-0.1390264928,
0.7125656605,
-0.0946977362,
0.0297939237,
-0.7539812922,
0.0771362707,
0.1499049813,
0.0068665356,
0.0924412161,
-0.6009731889,
-0.4809527993,
-0.0193497594,
0.5050356388,
-0.4685798287,
0.2744579315,
0.5170187354,
-0.2537184656,
0.0899777189,
0.6430433393,
0.5287820101,
0.6888774037,
-0.3366495967,
0.141962558,
0.1031905562,
-0.1850745976,
0.077432178,
0.0666775331,
-0.4299921691,
0.1758702695,
0.5000128746,
0.6475342512,
0.1816884726,
-0.6676209569,
0.6828055382,
-0.1705533117,
-0.4693026543,
-0.582184732,
-0.2145557553,
0.1764490753,
0.3197520673,
0.5180670023,
-0.7294361591,
0.3171420693,
-0.8483437896,
0.1127946824,
0.6652550101,
-0.208208397,
-0.1043886244,
0.3045595288,
-0.0752688348,
-0.2268108726,
0.6896538734,
-0.0497624911,
-0.3309842944,
0.4277186692,
0.6849635243,
0.8056791425,
0.0337670892,
0.309363395,
0.1636585742,
0.1143663079,
-0.1212446615,
0.1102573276,
-0.0486286394,
-0.4124559462,
-0.8669977784,
-0.6835053563,
-0.5962771177,
0.3750135005,
-0.5015060306,
0.1127667576,
-0.3050836027,
0.0537330396,
-0.0704585537,
0.0676652566,
-0.1612889469,
-0.0713244006,
0.3373141289,
1.0121634007,
-0.5973075628,
0.7102156878,
0.4095829129,
-0.3786180019,
-0.7136604786,
0.0116795721,
0.0100275232,
-0.6155675054,
0.3491291702,
0.1848579645,
-0.201819554,
-0.4180222154,
-0.5994746089,
-0.8886793852,
1.2600185871,
0.4555706382,
-0.277382791,
-0.4490860403,
0.1933149546,
0.6636220217,
-0.3244171143,
0.5493819118,
0.4431851208,
0.3337151408,
0.577631712,
-0.5847615004,
0.2224958539,
-0.1913215965,
-0.167958051,
0.2196044475,
-0.5643978715,
0.7753322124,
0.1771369278,
-0.3351252973,
0.1089973822,
0.6478587389,
0.2436778396,
0.470056951,
0.3328053355,
0.4801629484,
0.7905837893,
0.2199726701,
1.0384787321,
-0.2453398854,
0.3288036585,
1.3967424631,
-0.4736221731,
1.0165529251,
0.4861928225,
-0.0222110376,
0.5762286782,
0.460003674,
0.1769979596,
0.1992205977,
0.2309126556,
-0.2953295112,
-0.0743790194,
-0.3181417286,
-0.1837313473,
0.6077125669,
0.4750842154,
-0.3515273929,
-0.5501376987,
-0.3694301844,
0.2560659647,
-0.0813421831,
-0.274499625,
0.848597765,
0.2202698737,
-0.810036242,
0.424451679,
0.06026439,
0.5435734391,
-0.8382899165,
-0.0923508778,
-0.3989936709,
-0.0748925358,
-0.0213128049,
-0.8275081515,
0.3424551189,
-0.0037398816,
0.0286137797,
-0.3048816025,
0.9975734353,
-0.3611612618,
-0.3308138549,
0.3218221366,
0.4483320713,
0.1519881487,
-0.3200916052,
-0.4817818999,
-0.1968261003,
-0.3309688568,
-0.4730189145,
0.7403652072,
0.5289918184,
0.0167253986,
0.4649998248,
0.5739902854,
0.0578149855,
-0.2115196437,
-0.0096932724,
1.0543223619,
-0.7871959805,
-0.3027591407,
-1.0335996151,
0.3649827838,
-0.4286908507,
-0.0209802892,
0.6647829413,
0.7268587947,
0.5735398531,
0.3485414684,
0.5653494596,
0.1111307964,
0.5792306066,
-0.5966925621,
0.5153802633,
-0.5211562514,
0.1808958948,
-0.3502183259,
-0.8302856684,
-0.3732512295,
0.3512777984,
-0.2973590493,
-0.4221303761,
0.757361114,
0.6433546543,
-0.0912877396,
-0.0263609234,
0.3290087283,
0.274741888,
0.5909780264,
0.6192960739,
0.8255239129,
-0.3334935308,
0.7183870673,
0.1385008395,
-0.1359546781,
-0.1371075958,
-0.9616293907,
-0.7778391242,
-0.3063749373,
-0.1391121149,
-0.2261983007,
-0.0050671739,
0.6733535528,
0.4569420516,
-0.4005143344,
-0.2492352873,
0.308142364,
0.1440946609,
0.2896383107,
-0.2106722444,
0.5992223024,
-0.3815697432,
-0.5842064619,
0.6656016707,
0.6705233455,
-0.1475323886,
-0.2424383312,
0.2135433257,
-0.626825273,
0.3079181612,
0.9785569906,
0.4852930903,
-0.5990840793,
-0.5224487185,
0.1997480839,
-0.1100345477,
0.3276071548,
0.973798275,
-0.6606367826,
0.3573083282,
0.4274250567,
0.8938157558,
1.070822835,
0.1009033397,
0.4233094156,
-0.8720216751,
-0.0222132597,
0.5117846131,
0.4930153191,
0.2121617943,
-0.3679358065,
0.6046031713,
-0.0468389951,
-0.6792188883,
-0.7369298339,
0.2793520391,
-1.0849257708,
-0.4546304941,
1.0582817793,
-0.4920559824,
-0.4417180121,
-0.2143332958,
-0.2712210417,
0.0657390878,
-0.3328439891,
0.7919619679,
0.7153095007,
-0.2992786467,
-0.2100971341,
-0.4185245633,
0.0343364887,
0.4108388126,
-0.7094196677,
0.1589230448,
0.6908184886,
0.2416759878,
0.425991714,
1.1673874855,
-0.3498704433,
-0.1483988017,
-0.1665759385,
-0.2423586398,
0.1524273753,
-0.2286086231,
-0.4636907279,
0.7050132751,
0.0706279054,
0.0001183956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13534v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13534v4
|
LM-Cocktail: Resilient Tuning of Language Models via Model Merging
| 2023-11-22T17:14:54 | 2023-12-08T16:45:22 |
Shitao Xiao, Zheng Liu, Peitian Zhang, Xingrun Xing
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
The pre-trained language models are continually fine-tuned to better support
downstream applications. However, this operation may result in significant
performance degeneration on general tasks beyond the targeted domain. To
overcome this problem, we propose LM-Cocktail which enables the fine-tuned
model to stay resilient in general perspectives. Our method is conducted in the
form of model merging, where the fine-tuned language model is merged with the
pre-trained base model or the peer models from other domains through weighted
average. Despite simplicity, LM-Cocktail is surprisingly effective: the
resulted model is able to achieve a strong empirical performance in the whole
scope of general tasks while preserving a superior capacity in its targeted
domain. We conduct comprehensive experiments with LLama and BGE model on
popular benchmarks, including FLAN, MMLU, MTEB, whose results validate the
efficacy of our proposed method. The code and checkpoints are available at
https://github.com/FlagOpen/FlagEmbedding/tree/master/LM_Cocktail.
|
[
-0.3688029647,
-0.9068886638,
0.363468051,
0.0590537637,
-0.270570457,
0.3738508224,
-0.5103841424,
-0.5085600615,
0.1969071478,
0.7419118285,
-0.3591274917,
-0.3447289169,
-0.5644740462,
-0.0770588368,
-0.3464539051,
1.1653357744,
0.1042607427,
0.0156373661,
-0.1845811754,
-0.27403301,
-0.696611464,
-0.4642600119,
-0.7361558676,
-0.4860726595,
0.4464425147,
0.2269594371,
0.6246989369,
0.4350093305,
0.6365486979,
0.2665195763,
-0.0565318763,
0.3506804705,
-0.797675848,
0.3910125196,
-0.5737119317,
-0.5819730163,
-0.746430099,
-0.0321541056,
0.5250914693,
0.5271077752,
-0.416587323,
0.1439871788,
0.3934220672,
0.765024662,
-0.8432656527,
0.0665229633,
-1.114505291,
-0.2332686037,
-0.224637121,
0.1303800493,
-0.3329498768,
-0.0309433229,
-0.1390120983,
-0.2969495654,
0.0255460031,
0.2371784896,
0.7199436426,
0.3222053051,
-0.1766724288,
0.2245696336,
-0.8459242582,
0.8116239905,
-0.8311463594,
0.338649869,
0.4525191486,
0.5310909152,
-0.4232693613,
-0.6014329791,
-0.4517751634,
-0.3216659725,
0.3100560308,
-0.1076878458,
-0.2764284909,
0.1737779826,
-0.0857802704,
0.5408785343,
-0.4369207025,
0.2770694196,
-0.1192992553,
-0.1757356077,
0.5446398258,
0.2748925388,
0.3322001398,
0.5633691549,
-0.0492557995,
0.1913842559,
-0.8438703418,
-0.0764310211,
0.1874940544,
0.6912709475,
0.0002793672,
0.5607786179,
-0.3819651604,
0.7766453624,
0.1197010651,
-0.148789674,
0.1112376601,
-0.5292102098,
-0.3622725308,
-0.2279713005,
0.8115144968,
0.5318607092,
0.4084598422,
-0.2301566601,
-0.3925152421,
0.1674866378,
0.360539943,
-0.8450174332,
-0.4119216502,
0.321626544,
-0.311504811,
-0.4541594386,
-0.5264501572,
-0.4086218774,
-0.4149389863,
-0.2172840238,
0.5083662868,
-0.2298275977,
-0.5236241221,
0.27138111,
0.0888317898,
-0.2303053141,
-0.058555793,
-0.972802639,
0.1809194088,
0.8968161345,
0.9630360603,
-0.3816453815,
-0.1149407104,
-0.6707264185,
0.1799034625,
-0.2487498969,
0.5970678329,
-0.5944240689,
-0.2921644151,
0.048644688,
-0.0121573796,
-0.060669668,
-0.8163805008,
0.49751091,
-0.5774369836,
0.0338149108,
-0.1217707396,
-0.5649650693,
-0.0425229035,
0.376839906,
-0.616155386,
0.8327654004,
0.0248789098,
-0.6108433008,
0.3212691844,
-0.344694227,
-0.3992242515,
-0.1742005646,
0.105972521,
-0.7576538324,
0.2321586907,
0.2133159488,
0.4651230872,
-0.5201074481,
0.34700647,
-0.8240615129,
-0.3248211145,
0.0697663873,
-0.1577275991,
0.4965344965,
0.3209106028,
0.1561365128,
0.2479775846,
-0.6783825159,
-0.0000233031,
0.1805520952,
-0.523347795,
-0.3900066614,
0.0228019934,
0.0960594788,
-0.0372777097,
0.3273119926,
-0.2683022618,
0.3589245081,
-0.4524610341,
0.420152843,
0.3860549033,
0.0034609325,
0.6499355435,
-0.4419575036,
0.5790318251,
0.0438807346,
-0.0920853242,
-0.1231488958,
-0.3929238617,
-0.8205643296,
-0.5128062963,
0.4462821782,
0.7847472429,
-0.6086107492,
0.6880337,
-0.3405902982,
-0.7330781221,
-0.6315186024,
0.37621665,
0.4051092863,
0.506270647,
0.4464335144,
-0.5402927399,
-0.5547460318,
-0.9415307045,
-0.5728664398,
-0.0580407381,
0.0533401184,
0.0739066303,
0.3596933782,
-0.2777279615,
0.9093812704,
-0.3747840524,
-0.3102627099,
-0.4546409249,
-0.0841402486,
0.5036553741,
0.5671118498,
0.6695120931,
-0.2161147147,
-0.4615154862,
0.1486506015,
-0.4940889478,
-0.2991029918,
0.1952362508,
-0.1225405782,
0.1331215948,
0.3565751016,
-0.4122743905,
0.0241448581,
0.6111767292,
-0.2332471758,
0.5872710347,
-0.0925612524,
0.1652425826,
-1.3133171797,
-0.0815758333,
-0.050082691,
-0.4780856967,
-0.8702860475,
0.1927101165,
0.1074321195,
-0.1870124191,
-0.3696271181,
0.4402993619,
-0.2740426362,
0.3940166235,
-0.66062814,
-0.1151926294,
-0.3247185946,
0.1875977218,
-0.1819351763,
0.6255224943,
0.8726183772,
-0.5229232907,
0.1587449461,
-0.2655279934,
-0.321031183,
0.5772554278,
-0.7244749665,
0.0985663086,
-0.0087056169,
0.102520667,
-0.9459914565,
-0.0753217936,
0.3186827302,
-0.0482085682,
0.5528416038,
-0.3467648625,
-0.1185766459,
-0.0265278351,
-0.235347569,
0.3439037204,
0.4037444592,
-0.3569845855,
0.7894919515,
0.4616458118,
-0.126663357,
-0.6632025242,
-0.6705146432,
0.2177568525,
-0.5431076884,
-0.6532353759,
0.4272336066,
-0.0886820331,
-0.2039674968,
-0.0112041254,
-0.1768769622,
0.0092748608,
0.2696253955,
0.1776365489,
0.1971032917,
-0.1632371992,
-0.1194737256,
0.1680266261,
-0.1228748187,
-0.3234934807,
-0.2415413409,
0.4863220453,
-0.0942954198,
-0.2200559974,
-0.2438253164,
0.216156587,
0.7112289071,
-0.3990476727,
1.0495560169,
0.430960983,
-0.2866556048,
-0.3623531163,
-0.5298489928,
-0.1198281273,
-0.4775634408,
0.5780857205,
-0.4464928806,
-1.1746747494,
0.6844976544,
-0.2084080577,
0.1270676106,
-0.0015945549,
0.589220345,
0.1117403954,
0.7860979438,
0.8207550049,
-0.7510048747,
0.6092295647,
0.0225782227,
0.3709226251,
-0.5350678563,
0.1981039792,
-0.5262928605,
-0.2839961648,
-0.399035424,
-0.44835186,
0.1993686557,
0.4747783244,
-0.2527755797,
0.3973341584,
-0.3016381562,
0.7951573133,
0.2049803287,
-0.0392929427,
0.4278013408,
0.0328784995,
-0.0904314592,
0.0689648986,
-0.5680094361,
-0.3933730721,
1.0450642109,
0.436068058,
0.8485296965,
0.2028341442,
0.8864229918,
0.1674647778,
0.3311806619,
-0.7034879327,
0.561549902,
-0.1021888405,
-0.6482741833,
-0.0785118639,
-0.4467500746,
-0.7706644535,
0.5835184455,
-0.5646727085,
-0.820341289,
-0.1926365048,
0.3008480966,
-0.1994429678,
0.2319608778,
-0.6245918274,
0.8042728901,
-0.1761976033,
-0.4826222658,
-0.5567942262,
-0.2946569026,
0.6893823743,
-0.3663104177,
0.3009094,
-0.3866815567,
0.0038118083,
0.4220005572,
-0.4431928396,
0.6994563341,
-0.0239406601,
-0.2574185431,
-0.0286838654,
0.416338563,
0.5861252546,
-0.0309954137,
0.0013312948,
0.3612181246,
-0.0477319956,
-0.2479488105,
-0.7201923132,
0.7729756236,
-0.41625911,
-0.8328114748,
-0.0711769611,
-0.5228557587,
-0.3517424762,
0.3382391334,
0.0051793833,
0.0734834522,
-0.1819470525,
0.1918137521,
0.386302799,
-0.0017948656,
0.5297913551,
0.7053973675,
-0.6219171286,
-0.559810698,
0.7644669414,
-0.0629536211,
0.4308039546,
0.1995624304,
-0.0677593648,
0.0665297955,
-0.8646247983,
-0.0247261487,
0.1032880098,
-0.3490311801,
-0.3867000341,
-0.2587260306,
-0.0502635352,
-0.0293057468,
-0.006641509,
-0.7149285674,
-0.4730331302,
-0.0543237664,
-0.0067824554,
0.2486062646,
0.3486134708,
-0.0021239112,
0.3822876811,
-0.8846601844,
0.2884221673,
0.03328548,
0.4106387198,
-0.0122701759,
-0.5588430166,
-0.4708540738,
0.0755154267,
-0.154607743,
-0.762863338,
0.3261828423,
0.5535603762,
0.531514883,
0.327553153,
-0.0993173793,
0.6783274412,
-0.628895402,
0.7020121217,
0.2296444029,
-0.7714934349,
0.6247727871,
-0.4483514726,
0.2103666067,
0.6715009809,
0.2105812281,
-0.1942357719,
-0.7900816202,
0.0574710555,
-0.9233778715,
0.3242071271,
0.1252929419,
0.1187624484,
0.1150548682,
0.2852312326,
-0.0177550334,
0.0394011214,
-0.6754814982,
-0.2160947174,
0.1182575449,
-0.2529204786,
-0.2305389941,
-0.1687164903,
-0.2360458523,
-0.3821513653,
0.6804016829,
0.0086343987,
-0.3117775321,
-0.4267116487,
-0.0681293756,
0.0322559848,
0.2052255571,
0.407619983,
0.5299263597,
-0.2510549426,
0.1570796072,
0.2394930422,
-0.4598863721,
0.1994314343,
0.0372726694,
0.0163319167,
-0.4268448651,
0.4231761694,
0.7404366136,
0.1900398582,
-0.6068277359,
0.0140972342,
-0.2651552856,
0.0107657751,
0.2428918183,
0.5519031882,
0.3391653299,
0.4413794875,
0.1215547845,
0.0672915801,
-0.0666316673,
-0.6397332549,
0.1900908053,
0.7498405576,
-0.0289236195,
-0.1525442302,
0.7898176312,
0.3489496708,
-0.2400143743,
0.3852963746,
0.0270063262,
-0.4827594459,
0.1863241494,
0.6895000339,
1.0261917114,
-0.3181751072,
-0.2511368096,
0.3229087591,
0.3136541247,
-0.2206199914,
0.1412524432,
-0.1095316857,
-1.0230504274,
-0.4251715541,
-0.7574833035,
-0.1402296126,
0.0995513275,
-0.4021704793,
0.1170600355,
-0.3186488152,
-0.554666996,
-0.2317352593,
-0.0568712763,
-0.4019382596,
-0.0037534474,
-0.005104769,
0.8856059909,
-1.0686074495,
1.1028856039,
0.5962148309,
-0.3894772828,
-0.523242712,
0.045128867,
-0.0932630226,
-0.5601070523,
0.3182311356,
0.032175988,
-0.2355095893,
-0.2426588982,
-0.2956918776,
-0.9107647538,
0.9581357837,
0.5651417971,
-0.9821586013,
0.3773519099,
0.1131285354,
0.5057752728,
-0.5333834887,
-0.1046517342,
0.9474381208,
0.2338772714,
-0.0715385899,
-1.4500566721,
0.1474266946,
-0.1517246664,
0.0731498674,
0.2098205686,
-0.4478033185,
0.470157057,
-0.1755309552,
-0.1139369383,
0.0595480278,
0.7208154202,
0.501219511,
0.0757876635,
0.5413134098,
0.9226279259,
0.8963750005,
-0.1098312214,
0.7880299687,
-0.5120791197,
0.4628928304,
1.3157558441,
-0.4597495198,
1.0510077477,
0.4762081802,
-0.1483164728,
0.1954357922,
0.4148596525,
0.2001021057,
0.9296916723,
0.1615445614,
-0.3374607563,
-0.4680210352,
-0.0464140326,
-0.5694575906,
0.4643555582,
0.278767705,
-0.3329698443,
-0.1013301834,
-0.0928819925,
0.1330149174,
0.0379495732,
-0.4474527538,
0.6760044098,
0.2977254689,
-0.7192870975,
0.9465714097,
0.0332971327,
0.9630126357,
-0.5057179332,
0.1552782953,
-0.2715297937,
0.4014161229,
-0.1227835119,
-0.5870403647,
0.3790812194,
-0.1326339245,
-0.242737636,
0.0840206891,
1.0465363264,
-0.8002790809,
-0.3737927079,
0.3222648203,
0.3901433945,
-0.1866012514,
-0.0546233356,
-0.6365744472,
0.3879784346,
-0.0837986097,
-0.08995758,
0.6204332113,
0.0557578765,
0.205215618,
0.9068098068,
0.455044508,
0.209792912,
-0.2125915885,
0.0840786323,
0.7756183743,
-0.3587587476,
-0.3580105007,
-1.1945176125,
0.6343227029,
0.0220675394,
0.0088441838,
0.7190537453,
0.5188755393,
0.6703694463,
-0.2732215524,
0.7375283241,
0.2325031161,
0.2764665186,
-0.6287356019,
1.1706614494,
-0.6391715407,
0.390666455,
-0.0518993214,
-1.1076433659,
-0.4090604484,
0.3844498694,
-0.0245835762,
0.1811840534,
0.2869849801,
1.0759669542,
-0.2029684484,
-0.3574737906,
0.3437069058,
0.0861187577,
0.4767286479,
0.7000563741,
0.5915326476,
-0.1004658192,
0.2051099986,
-0.0128832776,
-0.268810302,
-0.2455521226,
-1.0256713629,
-1.220718503,
-0.4663184583,
-0.3814993203,
-0.4268866181,
0.2088888437,
0.7491931915,
0.7737849355,
-0.8837840557,
-0.1912552565,
-0.0611156151,
0.0747131854,
-0.0946309343,
-0.1890493929,
0.0435921811,
-0.4891021848,
-0.7375099659,
0.6948497295,
0.4014049172,
-0.0787479728,
-0.1564595252,
0.0189809222,
0.0736344233,
0.2695885897,
0.4769922495,
0.3069667518,
-0.6423848271,
-0.298755914,
-0.4006732106,
0.1294776946,
-0.2761229277,
0.6840633154,
-0.7003083825,
0.5157799125,
0.4834324419,
0.8283157945,
0.2706821561,
-0.0097691035,
0.9506695867,
-0.8480156064,
0.1245988235,
-0.1427093744,
0.6958101392,
0.2240869254,
-0.118987523,
0.5828367472,
0.0350280888,
-0.679387629,
-1.0804127455,
0.4051532745,
-1.0437374115,
-0.302693218,
0.9345729351,
-0.0788339227,
0.0227015056,
-0.0036514672,
-0.2290660739,
0.2563892901,
-0.2463757694,
0.8156417012,
0.7506005168,
-0.0333548337,
-0.0874281526,
-0.2806863487,
0.5593392253,
0.4473418593,
-0.6621220112,
0.238204658,
0.2777026892,
0.6313405037,
0.0229931045,
0.5057529211,
0.0955195799,
0.0292486623,
-0.1670447737,
-0.1697086692,
-0.3306331336,
-0.28547436,
-0.5213101506,
0.0660239011,
0.3806506395,
-0.2315017581
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17065v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17065v2
|
Efficient Deep Speech Understanding at the Edge
| 2023-11-22T17:14:18 | 2023-12-04T15:37:57 |
Rongxiang Wang, Felix Xiaozhu Lin
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In contemporary speech understanding (SU), a sophisticated pipeline is
employed, encompassing the ingestion of streaming voice input. The pipeline
executes beam search iteratively, invoking a deep neural network to generate
tentative outputs (referred to as hypotheses) in an autoregressive manner.
Periodically, the pipeline assesses attention and Connectionist Temporal
Classification (CTC) scores.
This paper aims to enhance SU performance on edge devices with limited
resources. Adopting a hybrid strategy, our approach focuses on accelerating
on-device execution and offloading inputs surpassing the device's capacity.
While this approach is established, we tackle SU's distinctive challenges
through innovative techniques: (1) Late Contextualization: This involves the
parallel execution of a model's attentive encoder during input ingestion. (2)
Pilot Inference: Addressing temporal load imbalances in the SU pipeline, this
technique aims to mitigate them effectively. (3) Autoregression Offramps:
Decisions regarding offloading are made solely based on hypotheses, presenting
a novel approach.
These techniques are designed to seamlessly integrate with existing speech
models, pipelines, and frameworks, offering flexibility for independent or
combined application. Collectively, they form a hybrid solution for edge SU.
Our prototype, named XYZ, has undergone testing on Arm platforms featuring 6 to
8 cores, demonstrating state-of-the-art accuracy. Notably, it achieves a 2x
reduction in end-to-end latency and a corresponding 2x decrease in offloading
requirements.
|
[
-0.3648344874,
-0.6981526017,
0.4344523251,
-0.1558673978,
-0.370215863,
0.5033896565,
-0.1454083472,
-0.3914154768,
0.2953637838,
0.3402771056,
-0.8505477905,
-0.2732566297,
-0.3524827361,
-0.4264255166,
-0.3344428837,
0.5588384271,
0.2320327759,
-0.0159157161,
0.0238550175,
-0.4963081181,
-0.4320590198,
-0.2695808411,
-0.8712978959,
-0.6400333643,
0.3016802669,
0.2615306377,
0.805428803,
0.9636842012,
0.1092755646,
0.2707915604,
-0.176045537,
-0.0338009894,
-0.3585461378,
0.0693938062,
-0.1309060305,
-0.4276334643,
-0.4194818735,
-0.2598959506,
0.6786623597,
0.889048636,
-0.2400957942,
0.1004674882,
0.0124285333,
0.4562006891,
-0.9420451522,
-0.1773692071,
-0.7236364484,
0.0128741739,
-0.3985226452,
-0.0492705554,
-0.2171053141,
0.2527179122,
0.3802372217,
-0.6672051549,
0.0390304588,
-0.2273705006,
0.536687851,
0.6385701299,
-0.3392834365,
0.0594259091,
-0.7537271976,
0.6923248172,
-0.6232888103,
0.6990433335,
0.1157018766,
0.4636645913,
0.1074473038,
-1.1259152889,
-0.6303910613,
0.1686049253,
0.3002344966,
0.410943687,
-0.4045163393,
0.3818051517,
0.116197139,
0.6268975735,
-0.5556348562,
0.6042073965,
-0.0720614716,
-0.3332644701,
0.4646968246,
0.021091843,
0.4255364537,
-0.0404599831,
-0.1752827913,
-0.0778186396,
-0.6857020855,
0.2995485365,
0.1390312016,
0.1221234873,
-0.2176437676,
0.3511927426,
-0.4243552685,
0.8377044797,
0.0434827209,
0.093987532,
0.3200028241,
-0.5851117373,
-0.2299042642,
0.4952212572,
0.6608082652,
0.1618321389,
-0.2129097134,
-0.0472490415,
-0.049193792,
0.325971365,
0.0839183331,
-0.3254357874,
-0.2175725698,
0.4218693972,
-0.3233622611,
0.194373101,
-0.292227596,
-0.5210459232,
-0.3255133927,
-0.2563643157,
0.4642298818,
-0.3055578768,
-0.3229673803,
-0.0295957662,
-0.2732324004,
0.0009150592,
0.0806244016,
-0.7149515748,
0.4212802351,
0.5424064398,
1.1067199707,
-0.1684935093,
0.060556341,
-1.0428193808,
0.1664295346,
-0.1014550254,
0.5482318997,
-0.2991568744,
-0.3218028545,
-0.235910207,
-0.3730000556,
-0.2298586518,
-0.3512583375,
0.7533998489,
-0.2695997655,
0.0820122957,
0.0207707118,
-0.5219176412,
-0.239392817,
-0.4298597872,
-0.4310696125,
0.7887486815,
0.0563689768,
-0.4569371939,
0.4284692407,
-0.8534855843,
-0.6121681333,
0.3236219287,
-0.4078852534,
-0.1987443864,
0.2789622843,
0.3959363103,
0.3270792067,
-0.0773628205,
0.1404580921,
-0.2323804647,
-0.3409081697,
-0.1230422631,
-0.2514914274,
0.8351904154,
0.4751667976,
-0.6664515138,
0.3050882816,
-0.5967943668,
0.1796533912,
-0.0839768574,
0.2303474247,
-0.4038484693,
0.1983745545,
-0.0085953567,
0.1383272111,
-0.1065558568,
-0.7421118617,
-0.1975086927,
-0.5563728809,
1.1015058756,
0.4727402925,
-0.3240733147,
0.5921592712,
-0.064286232,
0.2518855929,
-0.2856539786,
0.0340652652,
-0.5601397753,
-0.2293996662,
-0.7410361171,
-0.3709840178,
0.1441016197,
0.6982921362,
-0.8912107944,
0.5371534228,
-0.4843402207,
-0.5746186972,
-0.7985109091,
0.2974560261,
0.5276677012,
0.6837184429,
0.4720431268,
-0.0615664721,
-0.5108863115,
-0.8936774731,
-0.318654865,
0.0247604698,
-0.1439266652,
0.4113409519,
0.0264543928,
-0.1853848249,
1.0275069475,
-0.2570033073,
-0.3986720443,
-0.6039969325,
0.4429728091,
0.182244271,
0.3954363763,
0.2403069586,
-0.8546568155,
-0.105749093,
0.1336295456,
-0.6069262624,
-0.2453340143,
-0.3380804062,
0.2675445378,
-0.0302761905,
0.5344239473,
-0.417596966,
0.2438806742,
0.6302150488,
-0.1117149889,
-0.0535634644,
-0.1163226515,
-0.1540029943,
-0.9715474248,
-0.2103984356,
0.1416186243,
-0.1887244135,
-0.5623452067,
0.0065245326,
0.054165259,
-0.343578577,
-0.7427503467,
0.3062854409,
-0.4866958261,
-0.2568308413,
-0.3664046526,
0.2849256098,
0.068275407,
0.3552333713,
0.0793060511,
0.7709088326,
0.4382974803,
-0.6210286617,
0.3903956115,
-0.1253788471,
-0.262098521,
0.3036074936,
-0.8386130333,
0.3001776934,
0.0761389956,
0.5377135277,
-1.0366826057,
-0.0572092235,
-0.0794915631,
-0.5169086456,
0.2755745053,
-0.3799805343,
-0.234620899,
-0.3148522079,
-0.1036670282,
0.4074131846,
0.6937692165,
-0.670044899,
1.0994398594,
0.6559251547,
-0.2003561556,
-0.4058605433,
-0.8405421972,
0.1471443325,
-0.1640887111,
-0.8027213812,
0.8494236469,
0.3365409076,
-0.324547559,
0.0328010842,
-0.287511915,
0.1115478948,
0.0699149966,
0.2455666065,
0.0774076954,
-0.2071085125,
-0.1515496522,
0.5430566669,
-0.1744899154,
-0.1052618027,
-0.4943659008,
0.6622862816,
0.0681292266,
-0.1226613,
-0.9975041151,
0.4482494295,
0.677969873,
-0.2295405418,
0.2289302498,
0.7848331928,
-0.439370662,
-0.1992932409,
-0.5670201182,
-0.185622707,
-0.5216901302,
0.4380628467,
-0.4305603504,
-0.7627493143,
0.488103807,
-0.1431353092,
0.2132730633,
0.442476213,
0.4178564548,
-0.4207752049,
1.0081120729,
0.3334104717,
-0.0693192407,
0.609672606,
-0.529933691,
0.0950860828,
-0.9457884431,
-0.1168935224,
-0.3254075944,
-0.311180681,
-0.3433701694,
-0.3063056767,
0.5712276697,
-0.1065878347,
0.1945538074,
0.3333414495,
-0.2221547961,
0.1343249232,
0.5691065192,
0.1502395868,
0.1071305871,
-0.0860535279,
-0.0477789342,
-0.0866000131,
-1.0637017488,
-0.015104075,
0.7815181017,
0.4849092066,
0.5667110682,
-0.1228709817,
0.4105497003,
0.491399616,
-0.299477011,
-0.6700829268,
0.4447433352,
-0.3781696558,
-0.3706232905,
-0.2892765105,
-0.443292439,
-0.6524116397,
0.3178832531,
-0.1351430416,
-0.9734396935,
0.0439609922,
0.4473821223,
-0.9310874343,
0.2702822983,
-1.0013149977,
0.6572811007,
-0.3671589196,
-0.6793339252,
-0.7768947482,
-0.747851491,
0.0850988254,
0.2009167671,
0.0948786736,
0.0288032833,
-0.0001377726,
0.9508058429,
-0.2618997097,
0.7780479193,
-0.3771781325,
0.1238354743,
0.4785169363,
-0.1248825565,
0.276258558,
-0.0347810462,
0.0963961184,
0.3679323494,
-0.1169070452,
-0.2298879921,
-0.9447991848,
0.8670992851,
-0.7996004224,
-0.4831822217,
-0.1173396558,
-0.5667584538,
-0.1661857218,
0.1452041417,
0.5031524301,
0.8514291048,
0.1528831124,
0.3964178562,
0.7121819258,
-0.0658161789,
0.7262311578,
0.2144030035,
0.1637846082,
-0.3985326588,
1.0022572279,
0.6017658114,
0.3680211306,
0.319235146,
0.3393418789,
-0.7986908555,
-0.7539654374,
-0.915638268,
-0.0514780767,
-0.4820562303,
0.0941219851,
-0.9798485637,
-0.1902120113,
-0.5265919566,
-0.133172363,
-0.8685901761,
-0.3691687286,
-0.179631874,
-0.0161987524,
0.0995674282,
0.2574992478,
-0.1287774295,
0.8975647092,
-0.7169935107,
0.4158750176,
0.1696221679,
0.0420874692,
-0.2023882419,
-0.7056522369,
-0.1624312401,
0.2122822702,
-0.2096486688,
-0.6598908901,
0.1690899283,
0.4684740901,
0.8953046799,
0.595572412,
0.271330893,
0.791854918,
-0.0955746919,
0.7287743092,
0.2544998825,
-1.3376437426,
0.7496911287,
-0.3642916679,
0.5343766212,
0.5454468727,
0.2476848662,
-0.4458109438,
-0.0634165108,
-0.6360107064,
-0.9961445928,
0.4418176413,
0.2940946519,
0.0305000041,
0.6365674734,
0.2432739884,
0.1726131141,
-0.0310606919,
-0.1793876737,
-0.2479365319,
-0.2946456075,
-0.2329588979,
-0.2851231694,
0.0805228278,
-0.0013339857,
-0.3671515584,
0.40751037,
-0.1541894227,
0.0174290352,
0.2366413176,
-0.2894962728,
0.1075531989,
0.1896781623,
0.3967482746,
0.7863117456,
-0.0413915738,
0.1311701387,
0.3415412307,
-0.3569978178,
0.0091968644,
0.197645843,
-0.2149177045,
0.0155574745,
0.3070784807,
1.0254248381,
0.1594696492,
-0.572756052,
0.2036796957,
0.0755672604,
0.0767558888,
-0.3846900463,
0.2899542451,
-0.0963257551,
0.0983193815,
0.5375699401,
0.0392775498,
0.376008749,
-0.5850846767,
0.3060623705,
0.3379554451,
-0.4426989853,
-0.2387014031,
0.5561598539,
0.5827462673,
-0.2872579694,
0.6291241646,
-0.0125552295,
-0.5041339397,
0.3472017348,
0.4126985669,
0.9894220233,
-0.2461422682,
-0.0909362957,
-0.0150628714,
0.0318585783,
0.293318361,
0.2103978842,
-0.4700424075,
-0.6723148227,
-0.7815009356,
-0.1495963633,
-0.3567026556,
0.1470838338,
-0.744703114,
0.1115700826,
-0.3640856147,
-0.4210921228,
0.0642199293,
-0.0231048819,
-0.4320895672,
0.2640579045,
0.397376895,
0.7283200622,
-0.8126925826,
0.9575164914,
0.5439642668,
0.0804249421,
-0.5319835544,
-0.1852677464,
0.2874850929,
-0.8122795224,
0.3469602466,
0.1502938718,
-0.6156558394,
0.2919395864,
-0.1295932382,
-0.7884476781,
1.08502841,
0.1620197445,
-0.8141202331,
0.0527609028,
-0.2008571476,
0.3179405332,
-0.3114177883,
0.4639288783,
0.6538043022,
0.1468847841,
0.101360701,
-1.0510821342,
-0.2677336335,
-0.2680687606,
-0.1254793704,
0.1266395599,
-0.4593043029,
0.6776028275,
-0.366255939,
-0.4622949362,
-0.2969034314,
0.9423679709,
0.0872987583,
0.7086186409,
1.0143736601,
0.7251815796,
0.5907713175,
-0.1802795678,
0.848898828,
-0.0045013353,
-0.1701546609,
1.2788627148,
-0.0967299417,
0.8074714541,
0.5399148464,
0.1188274473,
0.425203234,
0.7474411726,
0.340912044,
0.7094295025,
0.1527394056,
-0.1976966262,
-0.2948482037,
-0.7069222927,
-0.4757575989,
0.7670333385,
0.578969419,
-0.2079980969,
-0.1451566368,
0.364500761,
0.0816408619,
0.0811282769,
-0.6063839793,
0.737608552,
0.2221460789,
-0.5547071695,
0.4565550685,
-0.2088053077,
0.6359423399,
-0.6792010069,
0.1172483265,
-0.0685970113,
0.4896820486,
-0.2907934487,
-0.6718184352,
0.3962302506,
-0.1809124947,
0.0051879231,
-0.3570632935,
0.5259453654,
-0.0607528798,
-0.2561832964,
0.4820631444,
0.493258208,
-0.0816387534,
-0.2686947584,
-0.6733036637,
0.5521351099,
-0.057586275,
0.0503376536,
0.1942756772,
0.0780710578,
-0.0202053525,
0.7967342734,
0.7326053381,
0.0859748572,
0.1226829514,
0.2220431864,
0.8752055764,
-0.3342551887,
-1.0629582405,
-0.8898646832,
0.4879072607,
-0.1854477823,
-0.4515214264,
0.580168128,
0.404643476,
0.9371836782,
0.5179442763,
0.7761409283,
0.0084974421,
0.4005352259,
-0.6270686984,
0.7305588126,
-0.6047031879,
0.0312543139,
-0.3000817299,
-0.5444604754,
-0.0614222735,
0.349639833,
-0.2496890724,
-0.2109830976,
0.4537401199,
0.4412821829,
-0.0730517283,
0.4062842131,
0.3032174706,
0.0015672015,
0.2873226702,
0.6399747729,
0.8262744546,
-0.3444707692,
0.5080220699,
-0.5584293604,
-0.4667485952,
0.0013017013,
-0.6837223172,
-0.5785133839,
-0.5840377212,
-0.4816290736,
-0.2472354919,
0.329007864,
0.9208797216,
1.1146028042,
-0.4349850416,
-0.3577837646,
-0.1838261783,
-0.1207262874,
-0.4932301044,
-0.1669387072,
0.263887018,
-0.121810928,
-0.7093219757,
0.9668774009,
0.3193649352,
-0.1850363016,
-0.2761951089,
-0.0010414775,
0.0153512321,
-0.4498192668,
0.440035522,
0.3889532685,
-0.796556294,
0.0153793721,
0.0307351556,
0.2119006813,
-0.0684123859,
1.1637830734,
-0.9803854823,
0.7274222374,
0.5693830848,
0.9478698373,
0.5345950127,
0.0444594473,
0.9033957124,
-0.2586004734,
0.1444367319,
0.4157409668,
0.4096862376,
0.2394815683,
-0.4565671682,
0.2031429261,
0.4200825691,
-0.2437832654,
-0.7189790606,
0.2450266778,
-1.1854197979,
-0.193170473,
0.8088747859,
-0.2164824456,
-0.19164446,
-0.3090403974,
0.0624908581,
0.54936409,
-0.5737905502,
0.3542789817,
0.169613108,
-0.4538973868,
-0.4078651667,
-0.4944794774,
0.110981755,
0.7625142336,
-0.4591421187,
0.0392504446,
0.1893601865,
-0.0311920438,
0.2178662866,
0.3775952458,
0.096024774,
0.309874475,
0.083483316,
-0.2458031774,
-0.2886405885,
-0.3593623042,
-0.3427333832,
0.1807926446,
-0.5808758736,
-0.783465445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13495v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13495v1
|
Current Topological and Machine Learning Applications for Bias Detection in Text
| 2023-11-22T16:12:42 | 2023-11-22T16:12:42 |
Colleen Farrelly, Yashbir Singh, Quincy A. Hathaway, Gunnar Carlsson, Ashok Choudhary, Rahul Paul, Gianfranco Doretto, Yassine Himeur, Shadi Atalls, Wathiq Mansoor
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Institutional bias can impact patient outcomes, educational attainment, and
legal system navigation. Written records often reflect bias, and once bias is
identified; it is possible to refer individuals for training to reduce bias.
Many machine learning tools exist to explore text data and create predictive
models that can search written records to identify real-time bias. However, few
previous studies investigate large language model embeddings and geometric
models of biased text data to understand geometry's impact on bias modeling
accuracy. To overcome this issue, this study utilizes the RedditBias database
to analyze textual biases. Four transformer models, including BERT and RoBERTa
variants, were explored. Post-embedding, t-SNE allowed two-dimensional
visualization of data. KNN classifiers differentiated bias types, with lower
k-values proving more effective. Findings suggest BERT, particularly mini BERT,
excels in bias classification, while multilingual models lag. The
recommendation emphasizes refining monolingual models and exploring
domain-specific biases.
|
[
-0.3477026224,
-1.0102444887,
0.8379350901,
-0.039638415,
0.0524122864,
-0.3580111563,
-0.2632422745,
-0.4446210563,
0.1702709794,
0.5797458291,
-0.6494910717,
-0.7561011314,
-0.84844625,
0.0744161829,
-0.5447254181,
1.0713661909,
-0.1052030474,
0.6617950797,
-0.1933054179,
-0.2049477845,
-0.4563716948,
-0.5882934928,
-0.2017517388,
-0.5077431202,
0.3105168343,
0.2453293055,
0.6083980799,
0.5976154804,
0.5202777982,
0.2226282507,
-0.1355145127,
-0.0540957227,
-0.4124543071,
0.1037852466,
-0.0827065185,
-0.5522847772,
-0.117218338,
0.1117175892,
0.4646888673,
0.5074937344,
0.2491655797,
-0.0134458598,
-0.1090937853,
0.5955238342,
-0.4212023616,
0.2172514498,
-0.4958371818,
0.4515078068,
-0.4453898072,
-0.0665104389,
-0.5062384009,
-0.9418119192,
0.7127766609,
-0.676153779,
0.4070050716,
0.102502346,
0.9267302155,
0.5237436891,
-0.7366045117,
-0.785726428,
-0.5140026808,
0.9373672009,
-0.5227170587,
0.7014605999,
0.2448710203,
0.2550097704,
0.0375021137,
-0.4162005186,
-0.4337815642,
0.0311596971,
-0.4824165702,
-0.1232010275,
0.0458892249,
-0.096661061,
0.2974824905,
0.0593762062,
-0.4240374565,
0.0951325893,
-0.353669256,
-0.1475099027,
0.3046845794,
-0.0528565049,
0.4977255464,
-0.4306720793,
0.0252248906,
-0.141119644,
-0.5479889512,
-0.374347657,
0.5250592232,
0.2742282152,
-0.0839649886,
0.5444376469,
0.3069648147,
0.6141539812,
0.069674924,
0.0207241625,
0.1705072075,
-0.0450198241,
-0.1437094808,
-0.0228570905,
0.7979929447,
0.1358404607,
0.6366552114,
0.077617608,
0.1895364225,
0.0445093289,
0.4544817805,
-0.4928430021,
-0.3119697869,
0.0955016837,
-0.8153840303,
-0.5024308562,
-0.0021841975,
-0.9044684172,
-0.742005229,
-0.4892242849,
-0.081712015,
-0.5790809393,
-0.1673488915,
0.030862201,
-0.2888343632,
-0.0914263427,
0.2483764142,
-0.7472865582,
0.1144141778,
0.6910743713,
0.7697044611,
-0.2053363472,
-0.0777517483,
-0.0921627432,
-0.1229956001,
-0.1154378951,
0.7594037056,
-0.5908095837,
-0.0900198445,
0.4835758209,
-0.0187062398,
0.1288456619,
-0.4108530581,
1.0917577744,
-0.3009523749,
0.5209357142,
-0.4249818325,
-0.6415031552,
-0.3172640502,
0.2302006036,
-0.9567780495,
0.9808126688,
0.1101696938,
-1.2130738497,
0.919118762,
-0.6551413536,
-0.4454307258,
-0.4562725127,
-0.4366314709,
-1.0323426723,
0.1074830815,
0.5539832115,
0.393235147,
-0.0782580972,
0.2894238234,
-0.2942461967,
-0.3015982509,
0.1382260174,
-0.2225489914,
0.8918218017,
-0.0771255493,
-0.3579190671,
0.0398193784,
-0.3293322623,
-0.2960239947,
0.0748143718,
-0.2936569154,
-0.7015624642,
0.2516365349,
0.5433812737,
0.146035701,
-0.2537074387,
-0.5262264609,
0.2836233974,
-0.15318048,
0.1892348826,
0.7769653201,
-0.3122034073,
0.6082405448,
-0.1939202249,
0.3119150698,
0.2588723004,
-0.0132345529,
0.1151561812,
-0.5234563351,
-0.7488328218,
-0.2220328748,
0.4201517999,
0.4738171101,
-0.7034449577,
0.3182486594,
-0.4279421568,
-0.2298723161,
-0.5609701276,
-0.2527801394,
0.2832861841,
0.4161898792,
0.4048454165,
0.1458153874,
-0.619731009,
-1.0781149864,
-0.8497905731,
0.1624971032,
-0.2462130189,
0.7478497028,
0.5474700928,
-0.4724774063,
1.0247807503,
-0.5528843999,
-0.5808420777,
0.0507015549,
0.1497465223,
0.244397983,
0.1724542081,
0.6606977582,
-0.667087853,
-0.5106236339,
0.0339771099,
-1.0449564457,
-0.3113993406,
-0.0044728229,
-0.2035022527,
0.2476518601,
0.2682428658,
-0.3140384853,
0.570774734,
0.3046559989,
-0.4719507992,
0.448746413,
0.1392302662,
0.0597696267,
-0.7930629253,
-0.2306755036,
0.5385854244,
-0.3404386938,
-0.7587499022,
-0.3873063624,
0.3051201403,
-0.0019723312,
-0.2132467926,
0.4601605237,
-0.4304918647,
-0.1299940497,
0.0220506489,
0.1701781452,
-0.0197734609,
0.1520538032,
0.3485235572,
0.4696991146,
0.2066512257,
-0.3931271732,
-0.1081317067,
0.4377904832,
-0.4023313522,
0.6251525879,
-0.5479712486,
-0.0439023003,
-0.1730454266,
0.4472911656,
-0.5394584537,
-0.1274623424,
0.2174988091,
-0.2829320729,
0.3227373958,
-0.2698028982,
-0.2210634202,
-0.5465453863,
-0.3638865948,
0.5279598832,
0.0779696777,
-0.719689548,
0.526705265,
0.6987179518,
0.1123683155,
-0.6668118834,
-0.8138230443,
-0.2463216931,
-0.2104703933,
-0.5151110888,
0.1712334752,
0.4443598688,
-0.1644915044,
-0.0472671688,
0.2039642334,
-0.232859239,
-0.2560832202,
0.116699405,
0.2433435172,
-0.0055951225,
0.3275371492,
0.254368633,
-0.0482435971,
0.1926241666,
-0.5630391836,
0.5157256722,
0.1750474274,
-0.2492285371,
-0.5870587826,
0.2608408332,
0.7032274008,
0.2099686414,
0.6873210669,
0.6151179075,
-0.5865836143,
-0.2103270143,
-0.6935099363,
-0.3299279511,
-0.3975776434,
0.4168093503,
-0.0709717348,
-0.809572041,
0.2887381315,
0.0136011736,
0.0316452123,
0.3968717456,
0.7105214596,
-0.1058292761,
0.6961364746,
0.5964863896,
-0.2945013642,
0.5730779171,
-0.2056094259,
0.5301551223,
-0.6509379148,
-0.148304522,
-0.7390812039,
-0.2996427417,
-0.9355580211,
-0.3523287773,
0.622649014,
-0.602637291,
-0.1269465685,
0.1927568913,
-0.8996103406,
0.3494872451,
0.6201925874,
0.3002016544,
0.1758075804,
0.2334478647,
-0.1990486383,
-0.4688382745,
-0.5541676283,
-0.525947094,
1.3772025108,
0.7218517065,
0.8622868657,
-0.2334578931,
0.2869524956,
0.6039090753,
0.290591985,
-0.7465876937,
-0.0988486484,
-0.2062650323,
-0.8087079525,
-0.3071357012,
-0.4051547945,
-0.5479795337,
0.2508877218,
-0.472800374,
-0.3784964681,
0.3739506304,
0.0575906485,
0.1380109787,
0.6154051423,
-0.7066663504,
0.5963923335,
-0.1644031554,
-0.3656424582,
0.0312450901,
-0.2806966305,
0.3335055113,
-0.0117206397,
0.2287021577,
0.2047848105,
0.41152215,
0.8675478697,
-0.2615199089,
0.7274858356,
-0.0246636923,
-0.147562623,
-0.0943955556,
0.0763926059,
0.4231992364,
0.1016491354,
-0.2315742075,
0.645950377,
-0.2133249491,
-0.3094863892,
-0.3750874996,
0.5610718131,
-0.8727641106,
-0.2229645252,
-0.5592477918,
-0.6290040612,
-0.0137044499,
0.2335681319,
0.3549828231,
0.2507867217,
-0.2490933239,
-0.0050992989,
0.7939828038,
-0.5176127553,
0.0730335116,
0.1153698042,
-0.1458532214,
-0.1051207557,
0.424175173,
0.0931752771,
-0.3005727828,
0.2206676602,
0.2867816985,
-0.298299551,
-0.3369437456,
-0.5156445503,
0.4128422141,
-0.3800899684,
-0.0961111411,
-0.9520014524,
-0.1807690859,
-0.3874214888,
-0.2997328043,
-0.2206638008,
-0.391697377,
-0.2752172053,
-0.2248246074,
0.3349642754,
1.201151967,
0.3513251841,
0.4056981802,
-0.3798566163,
0.092240721,
0.019514285,
0.4625069201,
-0.0392242894,
-0.2807714343,
-0.2246638536,
0.0023240824,
-0.4398822486,
-1.0615414381,
0.3776623309,
-0.1727184355,
0.2150836736,
0.5307670236,
-0.3101548851,
0.0666646287,
-0.7804857492,
0.5201096535,
0.0310059022,
-1.0253831148,
0.7156384587,
-0.6274561882,
0.034910772,
0.3113956451,
0.6444714069,
-0.6412806511,
-0.2120947689,
-0.2863709927,
-0.3115184903,
0.8660990596,
0.1985073388,
-0.2193627357,
0.1412467211,
0.5066046119,
0.1974095702,
-0.068085447,
-0.9980482459,
-0.2269211411,
-0.1716809273,
-0.3894632459,
0.2401945442,
-0.4046830237,
-0.034031149,
-0.2364339083,
0.5583299994,
-0.0308089182,
0.380654484,
0.1872243732,
-0.3156913221,
-0.0206299387,
0.2024820447,
0.6621201038,
0.5564007759,
-0.0712398812,
-0.1421724707,
0.3331907094,
-0.703053534,
-0.0941938609,
-0.1104950085,
-0.6288696527,
0.4620240331,
0.4771998823,
0.626465559,
0.011690353,
-0.2871392667,
0.6072169542,
-0.1762989312,
-0.1746652126,
-0.3253175616,
-0.3788571358,
-0.1798071712,
0.0841258466,
0.2051359713,
-0.0974649414,
0.3435409367,
-0.3416311145,
0.2226790488,
0.4717835784,
-0.8555496931,
-0.1672101468,
0.5706141591,
0.2490784973,
-0.2991538942,
0.6569790244,
0.3733633459,
-0.9527844191,
0.5198845863,
0.3588510454,
0.6564945579,
-0.1827042401,
0.2132863402,
0.370018214,
0.3756786585,
0.1755063087,
-0.0584786125,
0.2824884355,
-0.6178266406,
0.0991148502,
-0.3564251065,
-0.2787334919,
-0.1838982701,
-0.5452874899,
0.7035210133,
-0.3638579547,
-0.3899556398,
-0.0002297296,
-0.1966295987,
-0.7251211405,
0.2338544875,
-0.0256943349,
0.661128819,
-1.1754876375,
0.5678898692,
0.612606585,
-0.1004259661,
-0.2212147266,
0.114959389,
0.4382314384,
-0.5675153732,
0.6635817289,
0.2366367429,
0.1062325314,
-0.5885913968,
-0.2445545942,
-0.421143949,
0.8288805485,
0.1547966897,
-0.5009832382,
-0.2596268952,
0.3460639119,
0.5945550799,
-0.2510436475,
0.7170621753,
0.7126836181,
0.4709349275,
-0.5101488233,
-0.7730543613,
-0.0839550644,
0.1633692682,
-0.03249982,
0.5162331462,
-0.2690990567,
0.8640395403,
0.2410138994,
-0.0718104392,
-0.5906288028,
0.3858626187,
0.025560597,
0.3188552558,
0.2932955921,
0.7795860171,
0.9072815776,
-0.580540657,
1.0766444206,
-0.0386433564,
0.5837926269,
0.814427793,
-0.1219336018,
0.2585389912,
0.3420478702,
-0.0304614902,
0.8667291999,
0.4767694473,
0.1159823537,
0.3122424185,
0.3082063496,
0.0110200793,
0.2042770684,
-0.2760515809,
-0.3907062709,
0.2516756058,
0.5703635812,
-0.6750720143,
-0.0473977365,
0.1167820469,
0.4106809497,
0.185527727,
0.009923514,
0.6225796342,
-0.0829088166,
-0.4924680591,
0.0369107723,
-0.103120923,
0.90983814,
-0.1386202574,
0.0203441456,
-0.1208163425,
0.4482824504,
-0.4071751535,
-0.764786303,
0.2916103601,
-0.0229448415,
-0.4201005995,
-0.2680959404,
0.9036650658,
-0.354760021,
-0.7152853608,
0.4447058737,
0.3553141356,
-0.1914195865,
0.1338643134,
-0.6437596679,
0.2452237606,
0.0654914081,
-0.0169156734,
-0.1219916642,
0.5958419442,
-0.1544388235,
0.6775387526,
0.5194693804,
0.0455197953,
0.1006859392,
0.240234375,
0.7741990685,
-0.4397185147,
-0.4857436717,
-0.8464451432,
0.2048062831,
-0.4307731688,
-0.1993628591,
0.7268332839,
0.5442157984,
0.7416256666,
-0.2196854353,
0.9394627213,
0.263238281,
0.807474494,
-0.4922654033,
1.0483471155,
-0.3989090025,
0.1102665737,
-0.5831250548,
-0.8165007234,
-0.507342279,
0.8154261112,
-0.6242629886,
0.1990349889,
0.859852016,
0.4844328165,
-0.3215519488,
0.2495993972,
-0.1143960133,
0.1911803931,
0.4321359694,
0.3664885163,
0.5958690047,
-0.6883786917,
0.2556139529,
-0.0151909767,
-0.3268409073,
-0.3948292732,
-0.6979577541,
-1.3294217587,
-0.5107879639,
0.0146862622,
-0.5531871915,
0.1953498125,
0.488583982,
0.870975852,
-0.9856078029,
-0.1431477964,
0.0131359994,
0.6173461676,
0.345059514,
-0.2633717954,
0.5612812042,
-0.174689278,
-0.787871182,
-0.298977375,
0.1043520942,
-0.2235601395,
-0.2351204157,
0.1195029318,
-0.4872332811,
0.024578711,
0.3618531227,
-0.1237421259,
-0.7351803184,
-0.374796629,
0.1126987338,
-0.2312881947,
0.0908885747,
1.3542786837,
-0.5630238056,
0.4156653583,
0.6623746157,
0.6498174071,
0.6009438634,
0.0238513425,
0.6855937839,
-0.5356427431,
0.1492427737,
0.253729105,
0.4689184427,
0.2716391385,
-0.6701053977,
0.5168628693,
0.2049087137,
-0.7211813927,
-0.4066648483,
0.1457839012,
-0.4744638205,
-0.325097084,
0.9365588427,
0.2582265139,
-0.226853013,
-0.3548123538,
-0.2773104012,
0.3654803932,
-0.3016600013,
1.0620718002,
0.9082493782,
-0.0094078947,
0.0615432784,
-0.6022993326,
0.6661897898,
0.4617328048,
-0.7872076035,
-0.1181280315,
0.5849839449,
0.1984105259,
0.1860443354,
0.3230111003,
-0.2426954061,
0.1164152399,
-0.428950578,
0.1309657395,
0.3313516974,
-0.3157122135,
-0.288207233,
-0.0734285489,
-0.4876003861,
0.2015369087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13475v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13475v1
|
Machine Translation to Control Formality Features in the Target Language
| 2023-11-22T15:42:51 | 2023-11-22T15:42:51 |
Harshita Tyagi, Prashasta Jung, Hyowon Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Formality plays a significant role in language communication, especially in
low-resource languages such as Hindi, Japanese and Korean. These languages
utilise formal and informal expressions to convey messages based on social
contexts and relationships. When a language translation technique is used to
translate from a source language that does not pertain the formality (e.g.
English) to a target language that does, there is a missing information on
formality that could be a challenge in producing an accurate outcome. This
research explores how this issue should be resolved when machine learning
methods are used to translate from English to languages with formality, using
Hindi as the example data. This was done by training a bilingual model in a
formality-controlled setting and comparing its performance with a pre-trained
multilingual model in a similar setting. Since there are not a lot of training
data with ground truth, automated annotation techniques were employed to
increase the data size. The primary modeling approach involved leveraging
transformer models, which have demonstrated effectiveness in various natural
language processing tasks. We evaluate the official formality accuracy(ACC) by
comparing the predicted masked tokens with the ground truth. This metric
provides a quantitative measure of how well the translations align with the
desired outputs. Our study showcases a versatile translation strategy that
considers the nuances of formality in the target language, catering to diverse
language communication needs and scenarios.
|
[
-0.154649958,
-0.8708709478,
0.2773872316,
0.4455057383,
-0.4359761477,
0.2112283558,
-0.4234170914,
-0.6167404056,
0.0509339571,
0.3744309843,
-0.1568387449,
-0.5253247023,
-0.813544035,
0.4902698696,
-0.3325838447,
0.9042425156,
-0.720939219,
0.0657042861,
0.2021008134,
-0.1515554339,
-0.4411890805,
-0.418735832,
-0.4100788534,
-0.5893755555,
0.0711991638,
0.2680107653,
0.9762907624,
0.8652753234,
0.6763878465,
0.3789861202,
0.2017991543,
0.5938773155,
-0.1627614349,
-0.1268630028,
0.0794102252,
-0.6521621346,
-0.1927515864,
0.0989728048,
0.8405731916,
0.9016547799,
0.1733819693,
0.2844263911,
-0.0201809052,
0.6030996442,
-0.4937030375,
0.766125679,
-0.4228310287,
0.3753007352,
-0.162378177,
-0.1989257038,
-0.3852773607,
-0.4774106145,
-0.2602232695,
-0.5865840912,
-0.116236724,
0.1504711211,
1.1916416883,
0.4046703577,
-0.4783195555,
-0.3748616874,
-1.2186919451,
0.6308453679,
-0.6027558446,
0.6199577451,
0.7189252377,
0.5131130219,
0.0916162953,
-0.3763218224,
-0.4893568754,
-0.3625074923,
-0.5537525415,
0.035977006,
0.2509241402,
-0.0505236909,
0.1433295608,
0.2118214369,
-0.3786265254,
0.0517081432,
-0.2943085432,
-0.3105821609,
0.6518652439,
-0.0754101574,
0.4008305669,
-0.2291177213,
-0.1170286015,
0.1069668904,
-0.2106978446,
0.1415046006,
0.3511940539,
0.3954282701,
-0.3438923061,
0.6476968527,
-0.2833618522,
0.6409544349,
0.1160590276,
-0.2184423506,
0.0805522725,
-0.6686865687,
-0.2139061838,
0.0872040093,
0.8837029338,
-0.1639121324,
0.2557264268,
-0.2927137911,
-0.4216807783,
0.1040514335,
0.0253700875,
-0.3731712401,
0.1988799721,
0.0062693241,
-0.2521366775,
-0.3273240924,
0.2304520756,
-0.4321913421,
0.1524494439,
-0.753536582,
0.0961161032,
-0.4772136211,
-0.1004271284,
0.04461037,
0.340744853,
0.6650570631,
0.3792485297,
-0.7718710899,
0.5529448986,
0.6112155318,
0.7995408773,
0.0759061128,
-0.1369915605,
-0.4051474333,
0.3157015145,
-0.9405016899,
0.1997238547,
-0.6080463529,
-0.0452860594,
0.084928304,
0.0044621653,
-0.349584043,
-0.067689918,
0.703451395,
-0.6902139783,
0.2601076365,
0.1349193007,
-0.3416808248,
-0.220288232,
0.22926265,
-0.5208041668,
0.952910006,
-0.0296550151,
-0.6192290187,
0.4032196105,
-0.5807708502,
-0.8140533566,
0.2173950821,
-0.1671128273,
-0.4420213103,
0.0315635167,
0.1473081112,
0.5061427951,
0.0070673218,
0.5651549101,
0.3132972121,
-0.4069244564,
0.1964346468,
-0.2526322901,
0.279209137,
0.4001538455,
-0.5350109339,
0.1933349669,
-0.6426042318,
-0.1230031624,
0.1386676729,
-0.3355964124,
-0.1968699098,
-0.2284818143,
0.1692613959,
0.5753813982,
0.3473607898,
-0.1965351105,
-0.0372186676,
-0.4812061489,
0.2307136804,
0.5519639254,
-0.2205438465,
0.8042467833,
-0.1480848938,
0.4082044363,
-0.0740203485,
0.1148386002,
-0.0897211954,
-0.4124912024,
-0.6686343551,
-0.2231511474,
0.6273759007,
0.9745536447,
-0.727519691,
0.6990846992,
-0.6264041662,
-0.2716515958,
-0.8701351881,
0.2693035305,
0.6858142614,
0.4370985031,
0.228316471,
-0.3310546279,
-0.6436821222,
-1.000007391,
-0.2404290289,
-0.1524299979,
-0.0143012181,
0.2290502042,
0.453997463,
-0.4367470443,
0.7280318141,
-0.0546069406,
-0.3145544529,
-0.2119371891,
0.3931398094,
-0.0762714893,
0.5149129033,
-0.0866571814,
-1.0707950592,
-0.4921666086,
0.6684421301,
-1.0120073557,
-0.1500469744,
-0.4274528325,
-0.0927912295,
0.5874952674,
0.5292364359,
-0.4242337942,
0.4164172709,
0.648434937,
0.0853141397,
0.4437795281,
-0.3293668628,
0.6855201125,
-1.1182597876,
0.4951528311,
0.0027906965,
-0.5323916078,
-0.7181985974,
0.2260795981,
0.179084599,
-0.2447590232,
-0.3592946231,
0.6405463219,
-0.4094855785,
-0.0061388123,
0.0093799615,
0.1445555687,
-0.1643623263,
0.4389871657,
0.1189160571,
0.748848021,
0.1485108733,
-0.5943371654,
0.0315566584,
0.3522106111,
0.074008435,
0.4013952613,
-0.4672040641,
0.1444627196,
-0.2300581187,
0.1437474638,
-0.8349955082,
-0.6408031583,
0.5344292521,
-0.6805561781,
0.70081985,
-0.2506892085,
-0.7282620668,
-0.053392861,
-0.0009772553,
0.1306182593,
0.6735550165,
0.1313655525,
0.6507886052,
0.2210116386,
0.0230194703,
-0.2975736558,
-1.0342687368,
0.3844003379,
0.013942265,
-0.6583464146,
0.1607172936,
0.2482289374,
-0.3165015578,
-0.1808075905,
-0.0283767041,
-0.2389224917,
0.1755323559,
0.2011810541,
0.2997187674,
-0.0964407846,
-0.152610302,
0.1799180806,
-0.2598500252,
0.0535425656,
-0.3880001605,
0.5072650313,
-0.2593241036,
-0.442253679,
-0.7445294857,
0.1651102901,
0.5736888051,
-0.4171546996,
0.9769764543,
0.8263888359,
-0.5966405869,
0.1374478042,
-0.5048670173,
-0.1808513403,
-0.3974819779,
0.086985141,
-0.7282069921,
-0.5349200368,
0.6204360723,
-0.194208622,
0.0962650552,
0.4398017824,
0.3411551118,
0.1749765277,
1.1436262131,
0.6565477252,
-0.1558207422,
0.3477449119,
0.057252232,
0.4780762494,
-0.3519846201,
-0.2897591293,
-0.6631067395,
-0.1201153174,
-0.7550979257,
-0.4559357464,
0.0840286091,
0.1829304993,
0.2907818556,
0.6799862385,
-0.1276571155,
0.1754551083,
0.249336943,
0.0353681035,
0.415117383,
-0.040630307,
-0.1812853068,
-0.2484301776,
-0.5780970454,
-0.9427074194,
0.6154024005,
0.368550539,
0.3403092623,
-0.1265436262,
0.6510292888,
0.1779581159,
0.0895657837,
-0.6420502067,
0.4741945565,
0.0585809983,
-0.2976008058,
-0.4502580762,
-0.710804224,
-0.8400595784,
-0.0012691576,
-0.2155958712,
-0.1177823693,
-0.1689755172,
-0.0141426735,
0.352114439,
0.1284741163,
-0.5455937982,
0.7243358493,
-0.187632829,
-0.3039882183,
-0.0120195048,
-1.0123684406,
0.4297994971,
-0.5552781224,
0.6919859052,
0.1049541235,
-0.2201249152,
0.5664581656,
-0.0317910649,
0.9451095462,
0.2500536144,
-0.2559168935,
-0.0605981983,
0.2799838483,
0.844753921,
-0.0011393661,
-0.0062793391,
0.4782711267,
-0.187417388,
-0.6322391629,
-0.5788477063,
0.2552390993,
-0.770948112,
-0.2391900569,
-0.3036274016,
-0.5422970653,
-0.0979961529,
0.4150185287,
0.2511691749,
-0.1431318372,
-0.1463061422,
-0.2045926005,
0.6567956805,
0.1070862859,
0.2347541153,
0.6031805873,
-0.1382607818,
-0.1917237788,
0.7042825222,
0.2042542994,
0.3607884347,
0.5810409188,
0.1398344338,
-0.2740417421,
-0.423341006,
-0.7839580178,
0.2261674106,
-0.6574862003,
0.186779812,
-0.7161601186,
-0.3993745446,
-0.732755065,
-0.3763780594,
-0.3958558142,
-0.432177186,
-0.0816509724,
0.0534316823,
-0.0844072476,
0.5245615244,
0.1383891404,
0.0620983988,
-0.8210799694,
0.3025878072,
0.0315590836,
0.252329886,
-0.6046820879,
-0.738776803,
-0.2327208817,
0.1791451275,
0.0607640706,
-0.7359288335,
0.3279525936,
0.2765976787,
0.4965510368,
0.1523301601,
-0.1980164349,
0.6717487574,
-0.7010241151,
0.4903769195,
-0.0439731032,
-1.1430528164,
0.8344423771,
-0.3149593174,
0.2752644718,
0.4668543041,
0.6973742843,
-0.8058033586,
-0.5875066519,
-0.620205164,
-0.5309196115,
0.4751041234,
0.5592648983,
0.0459614247,
0.2450270951,
0.4418819845,
0.0347955599,
0.2836230993,
-0.6145428419,
-0.0930283591,
0.0837113857,
-0.3570637703,
-0.227125302,
0.0083946325,
-0.1409413069,
0.0063918713,
0.5756454468,
-0.1096108034,
-0.0371015072,
0.0113603873,
-0.3358511925,
-0.3745872676,
0.4446649849,
0.7013265491,
0.5228129625,
0.1225501969,
0.0560093075,
0.1735012829,
-0.439935863,
0.1792868972,
0.1557841599,
-0.5723978281,
0.2190238684,
0.5002976656,
0.7049721479,
0.4511658549,
-0.3154291213,
0.1877953112,
0.2033875883,
-0.0745369345,
-0.0847393647,
-0.2097410858,
-0.3329826891,
-0.3149417043,
0.0615780465,
0.4011957943,
0.090687409,
-0.4249904156,
0.2638415396,
0.2510544658,
-0.5912402272,
-0.4728727937,
0.6475531459,
0.1321938187,
-0.4053508937,
0.2490669191,
-0.4213445783,
-0.561819911,
0.3215703964,
0.5624845028,
0.8562572002,
-0.4978130758,
0.2736415863,
0.3858011365,
0.7941064835,
-0.363196373,
0.0122567452,
-0.0033764448,
-0.3514780104,
-0.7019385695,
-0.6622792482,
-0.4593703449,
-0.2695275843,
-0.4951815605,
0.5170409679,
-0.318716675,
0.0966840014,
-0.358150661,
0.0001159212,
-0.5661343336,
0.1059811339,
0.1059665531,
0.6171554327,
-1.3462189436,
0.7091091871,
0.6268647909,
-0.579217732,
-0.8663628697,
-0.2281919271,
-0.2065957785,
-0.6589735746,
0.675488174,
0.0427738763,
-0.1698827147,
-0.1152367517,
-0.3524624109,
-0.7717463374,
0.7678405643,
0.3537078202,
-0.4133839905,
0.2643617392,
0.6675425768,
0.6773477793,
-0.2896767855,
-0.270721972,
0.4813036025,
0.792293787,
0.1286571473,
-1.2393804789,
0.1972402632,
-0.2143236101,
0.1826889664,
0.4553416967,
-0.3076546788,
0.3781059384,
0.0853080601,
-0.4239944518,
-0.3175938129,
0.6601464152,
-0.0309646614,
0.3242827058,
0.1818503588,
0.1979638487,
0.6837704778,
-0.1372045279,
0.9918832779,
-0.3711677194,
-0.0184403341,
0.785084784,
-0.2222779691,
0.6508308053,
0.4129815102,
-0.0442041233,
0.2196630388,
0.5105541348,
0.2097830623,
0.1369089037,
0.1985554844,
-0.0283637829,
0.0379337855,
-0.2545728683,
-0.2392054051,
0.45132038,
0.2663001716,
-0.3857692182,
-0.0290040579,
0.0411278903,
0.252849251,
0.5000388622,
-0.1917456388,
0.8896630406,
-0.0507135727,
-0.6925997734,
0.6722311378,
0.4251634181,
0.4847436249,
-0.7481695414,
-0.1143299416,
-0.3033795953,
-0.0410810709,
-0.2788833976,
-0.3361632526,
0.6166948676,
-0.1079645157,
0.0019988043,
-0.3539095521,
0.7178687453,
-0.7435824871,
-0.8583056927,
-0.0469460674,
0.4161675274,
0.2355259657,
0.1903241426,
-0.6837976575,
0.1263603121,
-0.3375776112,
0.2063743174,
0.1305628419,
0.6629124284,
-0.4788554907,
0.6561319828,
0.6790565848,
0.3664127886,
0.2749798,
-0.2085333318,
0.5034675002,
-0.2911494374,
-0.5002423525,
-0.7935054898,
0.2622868121,
-0.0409928374,
-0.1403021365,
1.0068488121,
0.5701047182,
0.8939571381,
-0.1570866406,
0.5768046975,
0.220711872,
-0.126251325,
-0.6339992285,
0.6102000475,
-0.1039366946,
0.1355237812,
-0.2205020934,
-0.7597184777,
-0.5584121346,
0.66547966,
-0.3813131452,
0.0169174075,
0.6794205904,
0.632969439,
-0.1391906142,
-0.140653953,
0.4201671779,
-0.0704804659,
0.2894135714,
0.282143116,
0.335917443,
-0.7482581735,
0.4456147552,
-0.3043957055,
-0.3694013059,
-0.1796311736,
-0.8323073983,
-0.7911536694,
-0.6100928783,
-0.462738663,
-0.3654223382,
0.0399171673,
0.892680943,
0.8972420692,
-0.9190834761,
-0.2893676162,
-0.1629037261,
0.0358465202,
-0.2983855903,
-0.1710611433,
0.2769502997,
-0.8716607094,
-0.7109827995,
0.2472417355,
0.3987665176,
0.3019355834,
-0.2504445314,
-0.1309535354,
-0.3547551036,
0.2428819388,
0.5169228315,
0.3317350745,
-0.7519997954,
-0.1141845733,
0.0794204473,
-0.434343785,
-0.00576586,
0.6937606335,
-0.4315677881,
0.3369591832,
0.3417508602,
0.8702402115,
0.3782270253,
-0.1094413772,
0.6876536608,
-1.006955862,
0.3360467553,
0.1371362507,
0.0634520575,
0.4765026271,
-0.5530387163,
0.6765243411,
0.1614248157,
-0.3801467121,
-0.6058149338,
0.2994754314,
-0.5757501125,
-0.0717153251,
1.0697495937,
-0.0227426756,
-0.4809834063,
-0.43769297,
-0.3162337244,
0.6292626858,
-0.0918653011,
0.8394556642,
0.7613379359,
0.3531128764,
0.0371999927,
-0.6542388797,
0.6111072898,
0.2161594778,
-0.8425964713,
-0.1395200044,
0.2750081718,
-0.0774393603,
0.4159369767,
0.4986783266,
-0.3110877872,
0.1644581854,
-0.2281502038,
-0.0294358563,
-0.0768710971,
-0.2903062403,
-0.4618625939,
0.0093146646,
-0.0458801165,
-0.2220160663
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13472v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13472v1
|
Complexity-Guided Curriculum Learning for Text Graphs
| 2023-11-22T15:40:57 | 2023-11-22T15:40:57 |
Nidhi Vakil, Hadi Amiri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Curriculum learning provides a systematic approach to training. It refines
training progressively, tailors training to task requirements, and improves
generalization through exposure to diverse examples. We present a curriculum
learning approach that builds on existing knowledge about text and graph
complexity formalisms for training with text graph data. The core part of our
approach is a novel data scheduler, which employs "spaced repetition" and
complexity formalisms to guide the training process. We demonstrate the
effectiveness of the proposed approach on several text graph tasks and graph
neural network architectures. The proposed model gains more and uses less data;
consistently prefers text over graph complexity indices throughout training,
while the best curricula derived from text and graph complexity indices are
equally effective; and it learns transferable curricula across GNN models and
datasets. In addition, we find that both node-level (local) and graph-level
(global) graph complexity indices, as well as shallow and traditional text
complexity indices play a crucial role in effective curriculum learning.
|
[
0.2311380655,
-0.7219344378,
0.4892485738,
-0.0402110741,
-0.0494299866,
0.3303927481,
0.0369706452,
-0.1084014848,
-0.1271718144,
0.4846697152,
-0.5060532093,
-0.785979867,
-0.8140599728,
-0.1500404179,
-0.2621483207,
1.0379410982,
-0.2923050821,
0.152450487,
-0.2065492719,
-0.0572408922,
-0.5415835381,
-0.3200475276,
-0.9016395807,
-0.5597655177,
0.946129024,
0.384897083,
0.2458930612,
1.0925745964,
0.375230968,
0.2832977474,
0.1605687439,
0.6125532985,
-0.7723395824,
0.0309346598,
-0.0361680761,
-0.184318006,
-0.2121162713,
-0.1111499593,
0.6574884653,
1.446371913,
-0.0442772321,
-0.0320390239,
0.3608026505,
0.9540441036,
-0.4997125864,
0.7716884017,
-0.2261571437,
0.1670787185,
-0.0174840651,
-0.0022065537,
-0.7778030634,
-0.5127388835,
0.1720602065,
-1.022570014,
0.0420293212,
0.1031053141,
0.641204834,
0.1228362396,
-0.8586401343,
-0.6728302836,
-0.5710533261,
0.6822562814,
0.1598324478,
0.3738351762,
0.450399667,
0.2263899595,
-0.0316994488,
-1.0618493557,
0.0283338036,
0.2937904596,
-0.158089608,
0.2416255772,
0.1843911409,
0.0128043713,
0.3816002607,
0.3283952773,
-0.7620939016,
0.1042562947,
-0.52829808,
-0.0242697895,
0.3175340891,
0.6460792422,
0.3174262643,
0.0392555483,
-0.0861055627,
0.035972394,
-0.4751256704,
0.1780303121,
0.6000198126,
0.2893259823,
-0.0570491552,
0.1976407915,
-0.1209582388,
0.8477385044,
-0.1937094629,
0.0386769138,
0.1170487031,
-0.2335824519,
-0.1386555731,
-0.0991071165,
0.4989179969,
-0.19502756,
0.2763086557,
-0.3367498815,
0.147567898,
-0.0617829897,
0.5418002009,
-0.9375185966,
-0.6858656406,
-0.1728667021,
-0.1060080454,
-0.3222477138,
0.0365485698,
-0.444624573,
-0.0390081219,
-0.5964143872,
0.2163943499,
-0.9456648827,
0.4650705457,
0.4111787081,
-0.197469905,
-0.0680135787,
0.59073174,
-1.0411518812,
0.4754078388,
0.6718963385,
1.1584273577,
-0.3097603023,
-0.0953532979,
-0.6122719646,
0.3016515076,
-0.301222831,
0.3700641692,
-0.653511107,
-0.2707664371,
-0.0943042487,
0.0022623651,
-0.3538095653,
0.0612698905,
0.2571009398,
-0.6671592593,
0.2766577899,
-0.17987746,
-0.9219315052,
-0.3958477676,
0.1824866533,
-1.0242960453,
0.9808840752,
0.5692965984,
-0.8000842929,
0.4705622792,
-0.4861902297,
-0.76932019,
-0.0087980023,
-0.0661251172,
-0.6392399669,
-0.5670212507,
0.1835540235,
0.4139776528,
0.0543248132,
0.3497712612,
-0.0867601484,
-0.4810183048,
-0.3820818365,
-0.0714051276,
1.0275813341,
0.2241690159,
-0.1644601375,
-0.0756041482,
-0.8815498352,
0.0904565901,
0.1803182662,
-0.4780805707,
-0.4079693854,
0.2033653557,
-0.1500268728,
-0.2322095484,
0.102179192,
-0.2869470716,
0.5104502439,
-0.4489057064,
0.7192437053,
0.7243922949,
0.0961193293,
0.6129541993,
-0.6345124841,
0.1616405845,
-0.0620134734,
-0.1183851212,
-0.3834314942,
-0.3460128903,
-0.7131380439,
-0.2620038092,
0.1948357821,
0.7048928142,
-0.7662830353,
0.4337203205,
-0.3739806712,
-0.7493928075,
0.3265328705,
0.3351027668,
0.3820853829,
0.6169267297,
0.4304482937,
-0.7520990372,
-0.5490295887,
-0.0613082573,
0.0526258945,
-0.0920569822,
0.127391085,
0.3741747737,
0.5942294598,
-0.15582636,
0.7047786713,
-0.9228153229,
-0.303106308,
-0.297770083,
0.4414553344,
0.2831285,
0.4645866454,
0.3133474588,
-0.7008788586,
-0.4876444638,
0.0020017524,
-0.8394645452,
0.0932071581,
-0.1836685091,
0.0003965774,
-0.0502406508,
0.4831053615,
0.1615617424,
0.4688163102,
0.226531297,
-0.0167895015,
0.3556945026,
-0.2248965353,
-0.092122063,
-0.7560734153,
-0.1971237957,
-0.2355000079,
-0.2497130185,
-0.4614863098,
-0.3447348773,
-0.0858431011,
-0.146389693,
-0.0900090188,
0.4907541275,
-0.3549126983,
0.1680865884,
0.1872973442,
-0.1357786655,
0.2568226457,
0.6052682996,
-0.1466330737,
0.7624712586,
0.3469881117,
-0.6360569,
0.1833765954,
0.4193946123,
-0.5946356654,
0.4156935811,
-0.5219177008,
0.1731963903,
-0.2048675269,
0.3613280654,
-1.0565571785,
-0.2425337434,
0.2181851864,
-0.0863836333,
0.3868994117,
-0.1533399373,
-0.3103065789,
-0.3035452366,
-0.0232614279,
0.5304040909,
0.2566101551,
-0.3368591964,
0.5213473439,
0.1681150645,
0.1310124099,
-0.5202534199,
-0.5712143183,
-0.2386088669,
0.1865985841,
-0.522418797,
0.2613239884,
-0.1837969869,
0.2684942484,
-0.066175878,
-0.0584252514,
-0.455812633,
0.1982332915,
0.6021956205,
-0.0766247213,
-0.0768132657,
0.2130296081,
0.1737175733,
-0.1366749108,
-0.1620815396,
-0.9347308278,
0.4774316847,
0.0594693124,
-0.47188586,
-0.1918189526,
0.2496036589,
0.0392020307,
-0.0205353796,
0.5900594592,
0.6071098447,
-0.3397689462,
-0.3394075632,
0.1076329798,
0.1541809887,
-0.4615490437,
0.487860173,
-0.150556162,
-1.1961510181,
0.3447590768,
-0.2780679762,
0.1008058637,
0.1983672678,
0.3259681165,
-0.1126099154,
0.6242642999,
0.6798426509,
-0.0725419819,
0.7129933238,
-0.5837859511,
0.0477747582,
-0.4535267651,
-0.3443233371,
-0.415989846,
-0.2429080307,
-0.2735136449,
-0.4823140502,
0.154359445,
-0.2127301544,
-1.1286507845,
0.363150239,
-0.5675833821,
0.5567157865,
0.5291775465,
0.4887979329,
0.3855067492,
0.3634130061,
-0.1382076591,
-0.1681731194,
-0.9617145061,
-0.4016379714,
1.2368106842,
-0.0734579116,
0.7170554996,
-0.0652484223,
0.8515642881,
0.4120088816,
0.2700991035,
-0.6425372958,
0.3264421523,
-0.5071337819,
-0.1983235627,
-0.4647397697,
-0.7724459767,
-1.1750230789,
-0.3929559886,
0.0796983838,
-0.8104394674,
-0.1692586839,
-0.1630488485,
0.2241079509,
0.4454213083,
-0.5451334119,
0.8075963855,
0.0720549673,
-0.2844317555,
-0.0390448868,
-0.7175619602,
-0.0353808142,
-0.1665012389,
0.3123430908,
0.3279441893,
0.0069999001,
0.7905522585,
-0.2747333646,
1.2656719685,
0.1894870847,
0.1738466471,
0.4325247407,
0.2212943882,
0.4633958042,
-0.0674872994,
-0.2659614384,
0.0556277372,
-0.4779016972,
-0.5285338759,
-0.5847550035,
0.2883022428,
-1.0260821581,
-0.1817065179,
-0.3220255375,
-0.8941479921,
0.0463136025,
0.5442529321,
0.2550690472,
0.6355330348,
-0.4874075651,
0.1652556211,
0.7900835276,
0.0127382837,
0.0116443336,
-0.1105650067,
0.2636395991,
-0.615840435,
1.0495510101,
0.6765563488,
0.3464249671,
0.6699363589,
-0.0292429905,
0.1839095354,
-0.4667210877,
-0.1595942825,
-0.1528184265,
-1.0107880831,
0.0132841719,
-0.9037337899,
-0.645496428,
-0.1548603773,
-0.5968639255,
0.0134350592,
-0.5155645609,
-0.5543820262,
-0.0932800025,
0.2464591861,
0.9377735257,
0.307695061,
0.6009919643,
-0.498454988,
-0.0783968493,
0.401070416,
0.3334322572,
0.0003210127,
-0.420275867,
-0.2885317504,
-0.1779141873,
-0.6586241126,
-0.6708164811,
0.0596711859,
0.4614320993,
0.3021843433,
0.2665769458,
-0.0674694106,
0.3901287317,
-0.8290906549,
0.5802232027,
0.1263775229,
-1.0105291605,
0.4571273625,
-0.4305416048,
0.1058750972,
0.4360752404,
0.7877138257,
-0.3004520237,
-0.4850865901,
-0.6532675624,
-0.8550971746,
0.491764009,
0.2533115447,
0.2308982313,
0.0580495335,
0.7203279138,
0.0753178671,
0.1293341368,
-0.5895911455,
-0.2421481758,
-0.4654265344,
-0.4341928661,
0.0270314887,
-0.0896111056,
-0.150899604,
-0.3838306069,
0.4497180581,
-0.3851166964,
0.0175474025,
-0.04769646,
-0.1746769249,
0.3207917511,
0.0771402791,
0.2047362924,
0.824478507,
-0.040519312,
0.1917393059,
0.2883060873,
-0.7272974849,
0.2906826437,
-0.2255462855,
-0.1970763057,
-0.2302075475,
0.7282605767,
0.6580975056,
0.5197818875,
-0.216202423,
0.3841652274,
0.1125365421,
-0.4307406545,
0.0075505967,
0.5023192763,
0.1623088866,
-0.034506917,
0.1103683338,
-0.2922925055,
0.1166210622,
-0.1271587014,
0.5342127085,
-0.1210860163,
-0.7325155735,
0.0803860128,
0.7168587446,
-0.130736202,
-0.0974130258,
0.692565918,
-0.3897680044,
-0.3648438454,
1.0894399881,
0.7598034739,
0.3243277073,
-0.0202461071,
0.4614774287,
0.6419883966,
0.3016229868,
-0.1044665202,
0.1894088238,
0.0645038188,
-0.3559921086,
-0.2653152645,
-0.4590652585,
-0.7761675119,
-0.324446857,
-0.5762744546,
0.4279084206,
-0.8314681649,
0.1091367155,
0.1714773923,
0.2383205146,
-0.5605554581,
0.3312090337,
-0.339263171,
0.6471589208,
-0.6732994318,
0.635234952,
0.6007219553,
-0.3819501698,
-1.0306619406,
-0.5272330642,
0.0674582571,
-0.7286736369,
0.8598333597,
0.3093052506,
-0.0546424836,
0.228335306,
-0.6937205195,
-0.4849871397,
1.3930658102,
0.3112947643,
-0.4309257567,
-0.166265592,
0.1479723603,
0.3260765374,
-0.6514219642,
0.187934503,
0.00366204,
0.1454975903,
0.4369383752,
-0.2046854496,
0.0003778767,
-0.020942945,
0.0398073271,
0.3190793097,
-0.5490162373,
0.9356476665,
-0.2485134453,
-0.2727994919,
-0.1006767377,
0.8767002225,
-0.1280492097,
0.5939038992,
0.3013759851,
0.4581559002,
1.2308257818,
-0.2951053083,
0.7184796333,
-0.1385247707,
0.5712857842,
1.1745458841,
-0.2151720226,
0.0738159865,
-0.0487869345,
-0.1707253903,
1.0311710835,
0.7565270662,
-0.1485150009,
0.2327524424,
0.4350401759,
0.0697917938,
-0.3290782869,
-0.0868444145,
-0.2261193544,
0.1777034849,
0.4715682864,
-0.3086956143,
-0.5237560272,
-0.1052595451,
0.2477011532,
0.2946860194,
-0.2818965614,
0.5986214876,
0.1235903054,
-0.1873010993,
0.1729715168,
-0.1856925189,
-0.1232308075,
-0.7934116125,
-0.0448922217,
0.1058030799,
-0.0897745267,
-0.1467013955,
-0.8128780127,
0.407273978,
-0.3336556256,
-0.4553340971,
-0.2950559855,
0.53657341,
-0.3280937076,
-0.5025913715,
0.1452222168,
0.399517864,
-0.1659899056,
0.3731098473,
-0.3896281421,
-0.3090206981,
-0.280092299,
-0.118879199,
0.2883234918,
0.8939064741,
-0.1812308729,
0.7647146583,
0.6136593819,
-0.0633749887,
-0.1477653086,
0.0041416152,
1.0944497585,
-0.5152597427,
-0.7217976451,
-0.6396151185,
0.0999372452,
-0.165335387,
-0.2155935615,
0.460303843,
0.7715169787,
0.8487271667,
0.2331896871,
0.7112206221,
0.0898976028,
-0.1072432101,
-0.708753705,
0.5690203905,
-0.2993275523,
0.1883672476,
-0.4328631461,
-0.5934856534,
-0.6837260127,
0.4945274591,
-0.6134229302,
0.123946555,
0.9952431321,
0.4043799639,
-0.0586436465,
0.2281100154,
-0.0484571308,
-0.3181783557,
0.3564983308,
1.0725930929,
0.4488438666,
-0.3892565668,
0.567323029,
-0.0770595446,
-0.3679175675,
0.1633446515,
-0.9824094772,
-1.1943674088,
-0.726872921,
-0.374537766,
-0.5217113495,
0.3349504471,
0.603874445,
0.5663280487,
-0.4403638542,
-0.2251690775,
-0.2649868429,
0.6539924741,
-0.3209872544,
-0.1719558388,
0.7403386235,
-0.7356678843,
-0.546274364,
-0.1149196923,
0.3485885262,
-0.048526451,
0.2819926739,
0.0343552902,
-0.1456757337,
0.1044364423,
0.4361728132,
0.1761871427,
0.046727486,
-0.6007230878,
0.0723370835,
-0.5341226459,
0.3024265766,
1.1960952282,
-0.370922178,
0.5369542837,
0.3784539402,
0.8810637593,
0.7022377849,
-0.3109198213,
0.150959,
-0.9899703264,
0.1104735583,
0.0484276451,
0.1612678468,
0.0951441526,
-0.5629925728,
0.7778255939,
0.6940299869,
-0.528868854,
-0.4669547379,
0.5479556918,
-1.0819067955,
-0.2543886602,
0.8190956712,
-0.3414427042,
-0.2060962766,
-0.6506795287,
-0.0677139685,
0.4628217518,
-0.117574662,
0.6341094375,
0.9163610339,
0.0986123979,
0.2987077832,
-0.5946568251,
0.1912554204,
-0.1174625307,
-0.7657001019,
-0.0390975922,
0.4255616069,
0.238545537,
0.0773934349,
0.8083940148,
-0.050125327,
0.0462234132,
-0.0666226298,
-0.3486535847,
-0.3940652907,
-0.6946992874,
0.1708484739,
0.3707080185,
-0.344845295,
0.2416642904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13455v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13455v1
|
Generation of Explanations for Logic Reasoning
| 2023-11-22T15:22:04 | 2023-11-22T15:22:04 |
Yanyi Pu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This thesis delves into a fortiori arguments in deductive reasoning,
underscoring their relevance in various domains such as law, philosophy, and
artificial intelligence. The research is centred on employing GPT-3.5-turbo to
automate the analysis of these arguments, with a focus on understanding
intricate reasoning processes, generating clear and coherent explanations, and
creating novel arguments. The methodology encompasses a series of tasks
including detailed reasoning, interpretation, and the augmentation of a
fortiori arguments. It involves meticulously identifying these arguments in
diverse contexts, differentiating comparative elements, and categorizing them
based on their logical structure.
Extensive experiments reveals the challenges encountered by GPT-3.5-turbo in
accurately detecting and classifying a fortiori arguments. Nevertheless, the
model demonstrates a performance that rivals specialized models, particularly
in extracting key components and interpreting underlying properties. The
integration of external information into the model's processing significantly
elevates the quality of the generated explanations. Additionally, the model
exhibits a noteworthy capability in augmenting arguments, thus contributing to
the enrichment of the data set.
Despite facing certain limitations, this thesis makes significant
contributions to the fields of artificial intelligence and logical reasoning.
It introduces novel methodologies, establishes a rigorous evaluation framework,
and provides deep insights that set the stage for future advancements in
automated logical reasoning. The findings and methodologies presented herein
not only underscore the potential of AI in complex reasoning tasks but also
highlight areas for future research and development.
|
[
-0.48472628,
-1.035378933,
1.0153898001,
0.0925782397,
-0.1245495975,
-0.1313114464,
-0.1117875576,
-0.4147405624,
-0.4782932401,
-0.040123418,
-0.6320744753,
-0.1479616761,
-0.3161903918,
0.2068217397,
-0.2551133037,
0.871666491,
-0.1451082975,
0.1063614488,
-0.2674790025,
0.1067442149,
-0.7362656593,
-0.4088427424,
-0.7094753981,
-0.4638135135,
0.1620829701,
0.4111816883,
0.7584221959,
0.5401890874,
0.2905447781,
0.3777695298,
0.2362487316,
-0.0063033057,
0.1318052262,
0.1239844635,
-0.4273853004,
-0.3645830452,
-0.3336312771,
-0.0003301666,
0.4326306581,
0.6798932552,
-0.0614403486,
0.0015025499,
-0.428463012,
0.5617622733,
-0.4816503525,
0.4811801612,
-0.6191849113,
-0.0010754045,
-0.0950184539,
-0.1589464545,
-0.2290170342,
-0.4923250675,
-0.0033678971,
-0.6872287393,
0.4885759652,
-0.0332190059,
0.9252104163,
0.5398528576,
-0.0937892795,
-0.1769534945,
-1.0092493296,
0.7684111595,
-0.5407155752,
0.2274926007,
-0.056213282,
0.6878142357,
-0.0705934167,
-0.7433558106,
-0.8419689536,
-0.1035382226,
-0.1469321549,
0.2703199983,
-0.4961170554,
0.137521565,
0.5408070683,
0.4416102469,
-0.6679520607,
-0.1670429409,
-0.3845794201,
-0.012353587,
0.7650091052,
0.2280379236,
0.3084821999,
-0.052435521,
-0.0510944426,
0.1960042268,
-0.5594600439,
0.0020257896,
0.4251167476,
-0.0408232845,
0.3324117362,
0.5116348267,
-0.6231836081,
0.77238065,
0.0763604566,
0.1657031327,
-0.0512787849,
-0.4753725231,
-0.4055474102,
0.1175240651,
0.6942110658,
0.1090362817,
0.6725195646,
0.0660453215,
-0.0231531207,
0.3198966384,
0.1482349336,
-0.6202834249,
-0.4042316377,
0.5661280751,
-0.4333966374,
-0.3555239737,
0.0586009175,
-0.7042028904,
-0.0335647054,
-0.6352151036,
0.3441583514,
-0.6022415757,
-0.2011060417,
0.516887486,
-0.3764410019,
0.4296283126,
0.4742039144,
-1.0036386251,
0.3573178947,
0.8464460969,
0.4264971614,
0.1147130355,
-0.1424695402,
-0.3824601471,
0.4623182416,
-0.2597254217,
1.1914112568,
-0.7579159737,
-0.0453154594,
-0.1746882051,
-0.1429344565,
-0.1468608975,
-0.5587048531,
0.7673285604,
-0.3730272949,
0.2410871685,
-0.2727820873,
-0.3581829667,
-0.5775871277,
-0.015320872,
-0.3885194063,
0.7743802667,
0.0904292166,
-0.5669487119,
0.5743755102,
-1.1086820364,
-0.6173260212,
0.3358213603,
-0.4238125384,
-0.2474523634,
0.2370071113,
0.4310199618,
0.3511507511,
-0.6030219197,
0.4953448176,
-0.3289183974,
-0.1490333378,
-0.1097653955,
-0.3954958618,
1.0447643995,
0.4084845185,
-0.722081542,
0.2327586561,
-0.4947908819,
0.0547419339,
0.2530065775,
0.2338852882,
0.0201831125,
0.5136051774,
-0.7120946646,
0.0786637813,
0.1141061112,
-0.5382882953,
0.222927317,
-0.4201117158,
0.770701468,
0.5925325751,
0.0938077569,
0.1801930517,
-0.2060776055,
0.4867349267,
0.1222005114,
0.4254325628,
-0.135883674,
-0.6662476659,
-0.5209527612,
-0.0876694918,
0.1110311821,
0.8874787092,
-0.4399332702,
0.1763962209,
-0.1647162139,
-0.3771796227,
-0.2144352496,
-0.1618770361,
0.0118643651,
0.6641595364,
0.3730227351,
0.468763262,
-0.4639916718,
-1.2509404421,
-0.2479631156,
-0.4992482066,
-0.1439412683,
0.1316480041,
0.6195299625,
-0.1587160677,
1.0938004255,
-0.5702494979,
0.2064684629,
-0.304508388,
0.3208659589,
0.3160838783,
0.5476279855,
0.4754565656,
-0.7691786885,
0.0818923116,
0.0710700974,
-1.0056576729,
-0.2764167786,
-0.4129344523,
-0.2723167539,
-0.0609888211,
0.3298917711,
-0.8022158146,
0.5993126035,
-0.4830251932,
-0.3163185418,
0.9023609757,
0.0591208078,
0.1026408449,
-0.7139843106,
-0.1697136462,
0.1115185171,
0.0316251963,
-0.4925656319,
0.084303841,
-0.3524110019,
0.0203721635,
-0.2254290432,
0.4005392194,
-0.1961540133,
0.2637838125,
-0.120932661,
0.0382624306,
0.1677426547,
0.3749625981,
0.0541483574,
0.5829200745,
0.5479632616,
-0.4675973058,
0.7907355428,
0.0568657294,
0.1838114858,
0.5327922702,
-0.9710154533,
-0.2110604495,
-0.1240526438,
0.2106471658,
-1.1649127007,
-0.3343495131,
0.447591573,
-0.6076054573,
0.0430890843,
-0.308991462,
-0.6879113913,
-0.4767383337,
-0.1284749657,
0.5008168817,
0.4659042954,
-0.4844737649,
0.9058251977,
0.153660506,
-0.2476691306,
-0.1341669112,
-0.4456808567,
-0.1153362915,
-0.4851334393,
-0.8345395327,
0.4579139948,
-0.008960003,
-0.9249714017,
0.0564127378,
-0.0550796129,
-0.1546529382,
0.1478491575,
0.2979027033,
0.3060985208,
-0.4309765995,
0.0558021665,
0.3556500375,
-0.2909455299,
0.6611632109,
-0.6900349259,
0.0216895845,
-0.7092264295,
-0.3855460584,
-0.5177691579,
0.7963265181,
0.5541876554,
-0.1900239736,
0.3675559759,
0.6353484988,
-0.6661556959,
-0.1278095096,
-0.607760489,
-0.0785556212,
-0.4445160329,
-0.1039795876,
-0.7299388051,
-0.5357402563,
0.4163555801,
-0.1164426282,
0.0559155345,
1.0148450136,
0.6998362541,
0.0984663293,
1.5484175682,
0.2008304,
0.0751033574,
0.1192500368,
-0.3172675371,
0.4797702432,
-0.4230997264,
-0.2421357185,
-0.5950738192,
0.0361885503,
-0.4154268801,
-0.2248206437,
0.2147010416,
0.2830274999,
-0.6069344282,
0.0061704759,
-0.8152873516,
0.6174351573,
0.5200600624,
-0.3226324618,
0.352622658,
0.0273262542,
-0.1784957349,
0.3066806793,
-0.7038024664,
-0.7065834999,
0.5991287827,
0.355017513,
0.3850046694,
0.2130277604,
0.3791503608,
0.3796141744,
0.273668766,
-0.9396634698,
0.5579277277,
0.0111268116,
-0.661500752,
-0.2202972472,
-0.4335289299,
-0.6148523092,
0.1905101538,
0.1848054677,
-0.8361165524,
0.1684836447,
0.0821931511,
-0.8052057028,
0.2821801603,
-1.0678721666,
0.9703143239,
-0.3520926237,
-0.5246441364,
-0.3597224653,
-0.5697432756,
0.7059694529,
0.1152750254,
-0.0055496334,
-0.1263086349,
0.3549135327,
0.4858053625,
-0.613411963,
0.3483833373,
-0.3813143671,
-0.06835711,
0.5891573429,
0.077391535,
0.0614148043,
0.5118415356,
-0.1223627329,
-0.0131121436,
0.2173692435,
-0.4078197777,
-0.9376844764,
0.6703577638,
-0.4967835546,
-1.0515381098,
-0.3811465502,
-0.4617890716,
-0.1350092292,
0.0468749143,
-0.0344297513,
0.5658375025,
0.2724766731,
-0.2692241967,
0.8263662457,
-0.1180105433,
0.4353390634,
0.195464775,
0.2285574824,
-0.393876344,
1.0080862045,
-0.2630908787,
-0.1555420905,
0.1961473078,
0.4794884026,
-0.6201698184,
-0.6345872283,
-0.7627707124,
0.2182972431,
-0.80780375,
-0.1816235781,
-0.5459294915,
-0.0828328729,
-0.477953136,
-0.2212706059,
0.0575673431,
-0.917309761,
-0.0310980789,
-0.0967031717,
0.4386903942,
0.7976690531,
-0.1144625694,
-0.038905099,
-0.5133884549,
0.6021742225,
0.5780229568,
0.1594871134,
0.0240782443,
-0.1013626531,
0.0489436574,
-0.1036018133,
-0.3720143139,
-0.9405819774,
0.0475996099,
-0.0031460226,
0.8033332825,
0.4675838947,
-0.0795504525,
0.8248571157,
-0.3327532113,
0.7959364057,
-0.313929081,
-0.998108089,
1.1564484835,
-0.7726823688,
0.1811803281,
0.5565952063,
0.3709154129,
0.2105077356,
-0.1143833697,
-0.8746923208,
-0.8000084162,
0.444865346,
0.2010246962,
-0.3885188401,
-0.1951133609,
0.7371701002,
0.0909564048,
-0.0782974586,
-0.5643144846,
0.1338371783,
-0.3636536002,
-0.3461040556,
0.5595077276,
0.148152411,
-0.3461800814,
-0.7707352042,
0.8230330944,
-0.3222961426,
0.5093240142,
0.4923895001,
-0.0653269589,
0.0569773354,
0.2477772832,
0.83763659,
0.8716506362,
0.0148274498,
0.0267134812,
0.1608564556,
-0.0773176625,
0.1835750192,
0.6308302283,
-0.0525244921,
-0.1786806583,
0.3421731591,
0.5055682659,
-0.615486145,
-0.6623739004,
0.3387703598,
-0.2158358395,
-0.4347681403,
-0.658392787,
0.1619490683,
-0.1797387749,
0.4026128054,
0.4618681371,
0.0280457791,
0.2905072272,
-0.5677078366,
0.2811127305,
0.4189711809,
-0.0707108378,
-0.3613346815,
1.0354999304,
-0.1144411862,
0.0796691999,
0.6409046054,
-0.3537123501,
-0.7285959721,
0.5778551698,
0.326482147,
1.1418277025,
0.1981345564,
0.2092095762,
0.3580969572,
0.265963167,
0.0914443359,
0.4120293856,
-0.4737815261,
-0.5875136852,
-0.7325971127,
-0.5645955205,
-0.2995923758,
0.083672218,
-0.3200545013,
0.0118502434,
-0.5596200824,
0.2151203901,
0.3355385959,
0.0157398898,
-0.5996069908,
0.4045517445,
0.1607543379,
0.6791598797,
-1.0416833162,
0.6010359526,
0.7682913542,
-0.7633171678,
-0.9058684707,
0.0341007821,
0.0520948246,
-0.5172301531,
0.818644762,
0.0436020978,
-0.4671797454,
-0.0555618405,
-0.5435420275,
-0.4416936934,
0.7564871907,
0.1790919453,
-0.0606994443,
0.1575762779,
0.1955394,
0.592279613,
-0.4317987263,
0.5096782446,
0.887963891,
0.8053537011,
-0.0569300465,
-0.3563355803,
0.3318833113,
-0.4636361301,
-0.1873718947,
0.095157221,
-0.4833552837,
0.6946845651,
-0.3101639152,
-0.1337661445,
0.0037171128,
0.6916143298,
0.3831362426,
0.2661251128,
0.6204138398,
0.7475193739,
0.4873795807,
-0.4386025965,
1.0414716005,
-0.2094100714,
-0.0314113498,
0.7815842628,
-0.2883838713,
0.3943728805,
0.2541526556,
-0.1474263966,
0.8412128687,
0.7956635952,
-0.2580446899,
0.0547501817,
0.4183086157,
-0.5522290468,
-0.4783557653,
-0.0360889286,
-0.203994453,
0.3600012362,
0.563496232,
-0.0860397443,
-0.2404303104,
-0.1845521778,
-0.1943235844,
-0.1060969532,
-0.1750234216,
0.6849397421,
-0.3681588471,
-1.0828775167,
0.5288097858,
0.0413592085,
-0.0659805313,
-0.3509246707,
-0.4343645871,
-0.1663988829,
0.269631654,
-0.4319942296,
-0.8892936707,
0.6965787411,
0.1217265502,
-0.3261189759,
-0.3186421692,
0.8686612844,
0.217498675,
-0.6155435443,
-0.0156977866,
0.6528862119,
0.1659167111,
-0.1429552883,
-0.891079545,
-0.2277578264,
0.0280296635,
-0.1080735475,
-0.2440376133,
0.7779825926,
-0.395853579,
0.5638800263,
0.6600999832,
-0.0807924196,
-0.1216194034,
0.360815376,
0.906976819,
-0.8087447882,
-0.0385787375,
-1.175988555,
0.4327406287,
-0.0271969903,
-0.0652226284,
0.5337369442,
0.5961596966,
0.6321371198,
-0.013268725,
1.0070072412,
-0.3321481943,
0.2824813724,
-0.5139591694,
0.2916900218,
-0.3614597321,
0.2873313129,
-0.3601633608,
-0.6924301982,
-0.4325754344,
0.7111474276,
-0.4999867678,
0.0655676574,
0.7967285514,
0.6303914785,
-0.1186547279,
0.4801508784,
-0.1888636053,
0.0732812807,
0.4879307449,
0.6942998171,
1.074070096,
-0.3189061582,
0.6252709031,
-0.1879791319,
-0.433929652,
0.2874625921,
-0.8520550728,
-0.5993311405,
-0.3794062138,
-0.5291548967,
-0.0689264685,
0.0293041524,
0.5033579469,
0.7746794224,
-0.9080958962,
-0.0339475013,
-0.6212381124,
0.2791888416,
-0.3934280276,
-0.3841264546,
0.1732619554,
-0.4950362444,
-0.4909101129,
0.6948535442,
0.3048348427,
-0.1578544676,
-0.2157596648,
0.2762251496,
-0.1790361404,
0.1439853013,
0.7006155849,
0.3466323018,
-0.874224782,
-0.5028660297,
-0.2567433119,
0.6404576898,
0.2141553611,
0.9636441469,
-1.0765604973,
0.2738150656,
0.7705723047,
0.5592125058,
0.3056010008,
0.3287029862,
0.9446781278,
-0.195105508,
-0.1678634584,
0.2243794501,
0.47807616,
0.1266214103,
-0.4827438593,
0.670353651,
0.5408447385,
-0.5795338154,
-0.6259986758,
0.4186936617,
-0.9350527525,
-0.3883619606,
0.9004653096,
0.045640938,
-0.1884848177,
-0.3191581964,
-0.0586336032,
0.3741121888,
-0.1974532157,
0.6727510691,
0.827157557,
-0.8642222285,
-0.1029198021,
-0.9331849217,
0.5281206369,
0.6235043406,
-1.0043921471,
0.1840210408,
0.739068985,
0.1998471022,
0.1857066005,
0.1596933156,
-0.4006953537,
0.4545248747,
0.0374932624,
-0.3760328889,
-0.1215599701,
-0.3698237836,
-0.3749642074,
0.3898249865,
-0.191728577,
-0.085759148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13350v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13350v1
|
Fact-based Court Judgment Prediction
| 2023-11-22T12:39:28 | 2023-11-22T12:39:28 |
Shubham Kumar Nigam, Aniket Deroy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
This extended abstract extends the research presented in "ILDC for CJPE:
Indian Legal Documents Corpus for Court Judgment Prediction and Explanation"
\cite{malik-etal-2021-ildc}, focusing on fact-based judgment prediction within
the context of Indian legal documents. We introduce two distinct problem
variations: one based solely on facts, and another combining facts with rulings
from lower courts (RLC). Our research aims to enhance early-phase case outcome
prediction, offering significant benefits to legal professionals and the
general public. The results, however, indicated a performance decline compared
to the original ILDC for CJPE study, even after implementing various weightage
schemes in our DELSumm algorithm. Additionally, using only facts for legal
judgment prediction with different transformer models yielded results inferior
to the state-of-the-art outcomes reported in the "ILDC for CJPE" study.
|
[
-0.1821931303,
-0.5579171181,
0.7468848228,
0.1991310716,
-0.4567434192,
0.000841401,
-0.0336377807,
-0.724524796,
0.2161681056,
0.6285590529,
-0.2534659505,
-0.3321946561,
-0.8446140885,
-0.2212093771,
-0.6335679293,
1.0095523596,
0.3814002275,
0.2977022231,
-0.361687988,
-0.1542555988,
-0.5146906972,
-0.525631547,
-0.1062647551,
-0.3617383242,
0.3483493924,
0.6153362989,
0.5196327567,
0.1674539149,
0.6422422528,
0.1489329487,
-0.1263932437,
-0.0924293175,
-0.2588294744,
-0.0872965902,
-0.1838191152,
-0.9762403369,
-0.3316420615,
0.1566470712,
0.1962350905,
0.4429161549,
-0.6925842762,
-0.1149270386,
-0.2465466857,
0.9962778687,
-0.9743565917,
0.1348808706,
-0.6442202926,
0.6339963675,
-0.1608784497,
-0.2527656257,
-0.9323552251,
-0.3784285188,
0.0875086337,
-0.4326326847,
0.5770766735,
0.4017276466,
0.6819037199,
0.400733918,
-0.5786951184,
-0.1800102293,
-0.8217537999,
0.4479088485,
-0.6317985654,
0.3192048371,
0.0225073621,
0.4275380075,
0.0185707714,
-0.5659147501,
-0.6690662503,
-0.4563472867,
-0.4567058682,
0.551050663,
-0.0078090574,
0.1582909375,
0.6867645383,
0.3820372522,
-0.2703340948,
0.0364450663,
-0.7670233846,
-0.167305842,
0.5832875967,
0.1431024969,
0.0409681611,
-0.3572751582,
-0.5677350163,
0.0581392832,
-0.8235058188,
0.2599173784,
0.0407006331,
0.3104886711,
-0.4250792563,
0.7755804658,
-0.2367705554,
0.4493792951,
0.5583213568,
-0.3053316772,
0.2879252434,
-0.0456560738,
-0.1893418431,
0.5969744921,
0.535784483,
0.5243818164,
0.0533462837,
0.1195821092,
0.0004055999,
-0.2177825421,
0.1433915943,
-0.8634493351,
0.0572790168,
0.0495688543,
-0.8593970537,
-0.2896805406,
0.1916705072,
-0.918495357,
-1.0059381723,
-0.5943347812,
-0.0343367904,
-0.3075297177,
-0.1950467825,
-0.2318017036,
-0.0383442119,
0.3144159913,
0.6521984935,
-0.4964414239,
0.3593904078,
0.5574406385,
0.8517900109,
-0.2989164293,
0.3466261625,
-0.6220458746,
-0.1347097456,
-0.1485603452,
1.02351439,
-0.6738904119,
-0.7089124918,
0.116765216,
-0.0796503872,
0.0324003771,
-0.4700208008,
1.3618037701,
-0.465365231,
0.0638726205,
-0.1950129569,
-0.4430036843,
-0.328301549,
0.2089563012,
-0.8135891557,
0.4139412344,
-0.0683545023,
-1.1014150381,
1.1659859419,
-0.7600482702,
-0.7615066171,
0.3140507936,
-0.3929512203,
-0.5342091918,
0.3346296847,
0.0216838419,
0.2479863167,
-0.5540757775,
0.3809881508,
-0.3608697951,
-0.5113589168,
-0.1917388886,
-0.2745448053,
0.6425099969,
0.6282863617,
-0.2424407452,
-0.0739576221,
-0.914477706,
-0.1491380781,
-0.1383264214,
-0.3664648235,
-0.2203140706,
0.4410590529,
-0.1738387048,
0.1819280237,
-0.1289330721,
-0.9330480099,
0.1367953569,
-0.2767341435,
-0.2310940772,
0.5262124538,
-0.1112485826,
0.3650595844,
-0.2243209779,
0.6351211071,
0.270983845,
0.2587528229,
0.1766973585,
-0.4305600524,
-0.5992990136,
-0.0955110118,
0.6701503396,
0.6488838196,
-0.4023650289,
-0.0554061942,
-0.50195539,
-0.5514618754,
-0.1506729573,
-0.5058851838,
0.2145849913,
0.7219763994,
0.3473433256,
-0.2998615801,
-0.99652946,
-1.0289882421,
-0.5038679838,
-0.3481394649,
0.3529284,
0.1861820519,
0.2733081579,
0.2711715698,
1.050393343,
-0.5352777839,
-0.2577209175,
-0.2083793432,
0.2281110287,
0.7709373236,
0.2715191543,
0.4597217143,
-1.1184676886,
-0.6335077882,
-0.1403592825,
-0.4489762783,
0.0326197296,
-0.2030794472,
0.2792719603,
0.375631839,
0.4742208719,
-0.5799511671,
0.960590601,
0.1565817744,
-0.5420827866,
0.7417898178,
-0.1746079028,
0.5841445327,
-0.4854225814,
-0.2565841079,
0.1104624867,
-0.2234604359,
-0.4440704584,
-0.1584516168,
0.1800764054,
0.0865884125,
-0.4956088364,
0.2848695219,
-0.2004360408,
-0.0965511128,
-0.3282399178,
-0.1330941021,
-0.1987504065,
0.2562351823,
0.1491807103,
0.8560059071,
0.1945286095,
-0.7189521194,
0.0049212594,
0.0965898111,
-0.6028156281,
0.6250943542,
-0.5868598819,
-0.4049981534,
-0.1358519495,
0.1729225367,
-0.5401352644,
0.2060533166,
0.2241285592,
-0.2279338688,
0.6417053938,
-0.5278875828,
-0.3527668118,
-0.4201482832,
-0.2477012724,
0.1601703316,
0.4825320542,
-0.6233696938,
1.0816224813,
0.3409229815,
-0.0144240744,
-0.8778184056,
-0.8947027922,
0.068441011,
-0.2356124371,
-0.344843924,
0.4105150402,
-0.1332858056,
-0.515419066,
-0.0052077132,
0.0725907832,
0.1406444907,
-0.0043825069,
0.8113401532,
0.2750066519,
-0.098667033,
0.0637916699,
0.1334485114,
-0.0179265719,
0.4060818851,
0.1650332063,
0.201402694,
0.0124228671,
-0.6901898384,
-0.0914400294,
0.2426280081,
0.3705144227,
0.0204712264,
0.6993591785,
0.0235131979,
-0.1958730072,
0.0354548506,
-0.5659137368,
0.3182965517,
-0.3656193912,
0.0229159649,
-0.4985429049,
-0.3282315433,
0.3692416847,
-0.0222487319,
0.0362064019,
0.8529850245,
0.6675402522,
0.2025601119,
0.8033827543,
0.6747692227,
0.2778793573,
0.4747733176,
-0.0945241153,
0.5815221071,
-0.656001687,
-0.5980408192,
-0.4295462668,
-0.0143541368,
-0.8977433443,
-0.0755478144,
0.4242804646,
-0.1879434586,
0.0139323203,
0.0520922244,
-0.4200026393,
0.4043885171,
0.6222236753,
0.279855907,
0.6146972179,
0.0160833783,
-0.4358568788,
0.1119540781,
-0.6354315877,
-0.1858257651,
1.3886203766,
-0.0289769266,
0.587082684,
0.0150759118,
0.6033660769,
0.9952162504,
0.5780876279,
-0.8495016694,
0.4127902985,
-0.2248714566,
-0.8453665376,
0.1262914985,
-0.1877652109,
-0.594765842,
0.4413933158,
-0.5457809567,
-0.4364961088,
0.5556891561,
-0.161243692,
-0.656616807,
0.0640882701,
-0.8034024835,
0.1951873899,
-0.1284768134,
-0.5091689229,
-0.6024628282,
-0.5339671969,
0.7884004712,
-0.0407713801,
0.5111297965,
-0.1495870352,
0.2030100375,
0.6315599084,
-0.6940339804,
0.3957231939,
-0.507843554,
0.0658487752,
0.6758336425,
-0.0733977258,
0.4474492967,
0.4019768238,
-0.329885155,
-0.1514303386,
0.1576352566,
-0.2069962621,
-0.5873554945,
0.6016468406,
-0.4513343275,
-0.8562124968,
-0.9598186016,
-0.3065788448,
-0.0766316652,
-0.0468019284,
0.021653248,
0.4465510845,
-0.1295459419,
0.1618488282,
0.3620653749,
0.019197464,
0.491488874,
0.9394103289,
-0.0224999785,
-0.2570465803,
0.3017712235,
0.1627990156,
-0.2662166059,
0.4542177916,
0.2813440263,
-0.3628590405,
-0.8948343992,
-0.1647411138,
-0.1619779021,
-0.9931389689,
-0.4064352512,
-0.5359347463,
-0.0324202999,
-0.4153940082,
0.2089777291,
-0.1549171656,
-0.7119958401,
0.295166105,
-0.3396770954,
0.3037436008,
0.5696056485,
-0.2014792114,
0.0245226584,
-0.6715794206,
0.3192359209,
0.1456520706,
0.606756568,
-0.3635153174,
-0.7239297032,
-0.2957892418,
0.014895292,
-0.2204398066,
-0.31108585,
0.010987916,
-0.0022128874,
0.435870111,
0.485722959,
0.2882907093,
0.6024686694,
-0.5781219602,
0.7049601078,
0.4156666398,
-0.4446467161,
0.4396636784,
0.0891619176,
-0.1268727332,
0.7570436597,
0.0656424984,
-0.2347715646,
0.1452595145,
-0.7522408962,
-0.5910279155,
0.865203917,
0.0232846327,
-0.0008132919,
0.230494082,
0.5079197288,
0.3873902261,
0.0955821499,
-0.5188965201,
-0.2358014435,
-0.067302309,
-0.0333096758,
0.1545147449,
-0.3655980229,
0.0462470278,
-0.4416857958,
0.7468123436,
0.0713552833,
0.1218231767,
0.4504263401,
-0.1948783994,
-0.1168206111,
0.3731508851,
0.739636302,
0.7787648439,
-0.390309751,
-0.1204796061,
0.2653805912,
-0.5216152072,
0.0675089136,
0.2037943453,
-0.554587543,
-0.0615133829,
0.4563120902,
0.7066127658,
0.0036604591,
-0.7494492531,
0.5852585435,
-0.389677912,
-0.3036445379,
-0.9412177205,
0.13469401,
-0.377756089,
0.2831068337,
0.5471733809,
0.6193483472,
0.6359992027,
-0.5800716281,
0.3211560845,
0.140851438,
-0.4687968194,
0.0873798132,
0.5826032162,
0.2280653864,
0.0821553171,
0.3221671879,
-0.1696030796,
-0.388483882,
0.7400763631,
0.1311084628,
0.5407482982,
0.2253046483,
-0.063100554,
0.394765377,
-0.1110127643,
-0.2228571773,
0.1471231282,
-0.0984262824,
-0.3284874558,
-0.7164880037,
-0.6031407714,
-0.3958618045,
-0.1339503676,
-0.4701623917,
0.6885634065,
-0.6717970371,
-0.0408942848,
-0.1928605437,
0.2588452697,
-0.6792665124,
0.4961789548,
0.3529956639,
1.0971380472,
-0.4716984928,
0.6302950382,
0.379784137,
-0.5553338528,
-0.6190314293,
-0.0057928236,
-0.0165939201,
-0.51801759,
0.8078067899,
0.0866814256,
-0.3564381301,
-0.6824045181,
-0.4521006942,
-0.7885242105,
1.0849934816,
0.2415249944,
-0.8437242508,
0.1028094143,
0.1185603514,
0.4101561308,
-0.4463401437,
0.6183993816,
0.5661644936,
0.5466374755,
0.4217176735,
-0.7032423019,
0.2317641675,
-0.3375301659,
-0.3389715254,
0.2003335804,
-0.6744528413,
0.6761316657,
-0.4961320162,
-0.2654223144,
-0.1215443239,
1.0007127523,
0.1804621071,
0.6985958815,
0.8227066994,
0.6568704247,
0.6316595078,
-0.2080861777,
1.422786355,
-0.5405381322,
0.3070409596,
1.3087877035,
-0.2169346809,
0.5112400055,
0.3712621033,
-0.5169188976,
0.8140407205,
0.4583478868,
-0.2316325754,
0.5972485542,
0.1331959516,
-0.0307723396,
-0.2706101239,
-0.3908909559,
-0.4477818012,
0.6839026213,
0.0913777351,
-0.3372929096,
0.0343833603,
-0.4012821019,
-0.0522835515,
0.373793155,
-0.4160085917,
0.5035400391,
-0.0418784395,
-0.7798772454,
0.2327353209,
0.0424926504,
0.5726099014,
-0.167413488,
-0.314830482,
-0.089731425,
0.1983458251,
-0.4508087039,
-0.7729176879,
0.32335338,
-0.1483051479,
-0.4279040992,
-0.074419044,
0.9007030725,
-0.0090955393,
-0.6543601155,
0.1878979653,
0.3384818733,
-0.1684627384,
-0.1286243945,
-0.5373148322,
-0.3161227703,
-0.3062014282,
-0.1622987092,
0.1674472094,
0.4118251801,
-0.0267770085,
0.597186923,
0.3278062046,
0.024871666,
0.0793735012,
0.3721795976,
0.7402876019,
-0.6069841385,
-0.5205153227,
-0.7280589938,
0.4994533658,
-0.4212291837,
-0.0482243039,
0.2709359229,
0.7482633591,
0.4402031302,
-0.0879936218,
0.8471719623,
-0.5864371657,
0.881688118,
-0.8438968062,
0.5292557478,
-0.3519971073,
0.2713537216,
-0.031460125,
-0.5600867867,
-0.0439996459,
0.0578346588,
-0.2676448822,
0.1035539284,
0.8098479509,
0.4080114365,
-0.1198244542,
0.3771756887,
0.2407448888,
0.1271700561,
0.2088732123,
0.3927805722,
0.6931157112,
-0.4340010285,
0.6089808345,
-0.4019563794,
-0.0203995351,
-0.618457675,
-0.9136605859,
-0.668243587,
-0.2938747704,
-0.1518895626,
-0.1668913215,
-0.1215267777,
0.7815988064,
0.7463985085,
-1.1193689108,
0.0840693563,
-0.2542419136,
0.2734743953,
0.168980062,
-0.2044251859,
0.3774159253,
-0.1643025875,
-0.3927237689,
0.2700785398,
-0.0783594474,
-0.2502663434,
0.3184939027,
-0.1012708545,
-0.363111496,
0.0645544901,
0.6810489893,
0.1117138714,
-0.5828592777,
-0.3470444679,
-0.4587768316,
0.2268756777,
0.3897878528,
1.3227193356,
-0.9724430442,
0.3070687056,
0.5211039186,
0.1643556058,
0.7239638567,
0.3617907763,
0.5434862971,
-0.3365496099,
0.3826850653,
0.19610098,
0.7424967289,
0.1513928473,
-0.4713571072,
0.7021147013,
0.3562296927,
-0.1350744516,
-0.4371129274,
0.1426840425,
-0.875459671,
-0.2143702507,
0.7199822068,
-0.1418159604,
-0.1521701962,
-0.0149555644,
-0.2047997117,
0.3721791208,
-0.6408625841,
0.9344546199,
0.5656176805,
-0.3924435079,
-0.2792840898,
-0.5540839434,
0.4305925667,
0.4251732826,
-0.5599894524,
-0.0449686311,
0.6403660178,
0.098109819,
0.5039618015,
0.2873760164,
-0.3396350145,
0.3569106162,
0.0096587306,
0.0786399022,
-0.2110689431,
-0.2617717981,
-0.1545819342,
0.5503919125,
0.11548163,
0.2783905268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13314v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13314v1
|
Mitigating Large Language Model Hallucinations via Autonomous Knowledge Graph-based Retrofitting
| 2023-11-22T11:08:38 | 2023-11-22T11:08:38 |
Xinyan Guan, Yanjiang Liu, Hongyu Lin, Yaojie Lu, Ben He, Xianpei Han, Le Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Incorporating factual knowledge in knowledge graph is regarded as a promising
approach for mitigating the hallucination of large language models (LLMs).
Existing methods usually only use the user's input to query the knowledge
graph, thus failing to address the factual hallucination generated by LLMs
during its reasoning process. To address this problem, this paper proposes
Knowledge Graph-based Retrofitting (KGR), a new framework that incorporates
LLMs with KGs to mitigate factual hallucination during the reasoning process by
retrofitting the initial draft responses of LLMs based on the factual knowledge
stored in KGs. Specifically, KGR leverages LLMs to extract, select, validate,
and retrofit factual statements within the model-generated responses, which
enables an autonomous knowledge verifying and refining procedure without any
additional manual efforts. Experiments show that KGR can significantly improve
the performance of LLMs on factual QA benchmarks especially when involving
complex reasoning processes, which demonstrates the necessity and effectiveness
of KGR in mitigating hallucination and enhancing the reliability of LLMs.
|
[
-0.6757706404,
-0.9300042987,
0.8661842346,
-0.122796081,
-0.097512871,
0.2202742696,
-0.0693612471,
-0.4032155871,
0.3440107107,
0.8618323803,
-0.467094481,
-0.3613341153,
-0.3739680946,
0.0974676386,
-0.1142830625,
0.6475700736,
-0.0795060396,
-0.1427710503,
-0.5322480202,
0.0447921753,
-0.7935769558,
-0.3454379141,
-0.5557231903,
-0.6316981912,
0.5108041167,
0.2570381463,
0.8194323182,
0.3221085072,
0.1723575443,
0.3215860724,
0.0543456934,
0.4016325176,
-0.5397048593,
0.2570525706,
-0.1152956262,
-0.2116359025,
-0.4239577055,
-0.4137960672,
0.3801063895,
0.5276940465,
-0.1185870543,
0.224305287,
0.0211370233,
0.889693141,
-0.7201946974,
0.3710111976,
-0.70982337,
0.0422007143,
0.3113735616,
-0.399461925,
-0.513609767,
-0.7294660211,
-0.3025813401,
-0.3733079433,
-0.0654219463,
0.3129991889,
0.5818522573,
0.4488376677,
-0.3903381824,
-0.204527691,
-0.8833915591,
0.2486037016,
-0.8721285462,
0.9348592758,
0.4216614366,
0.4630959332,
-0.4196641147,
-0.571069479,
-0.830787003,
-0.2695952952,
-0.449901104,
-0.1435712725,
-0.0363209508,
-0.0016009379,
0.289275676,
-0.0936725214,
-0.6106482744,
-0.1908691525,
-0.1888841242,
-0.655195415,
0.4915605783,
0.0333990753,
0.2448028326,
-0.5385090113,
-0.1947230101,
0.0256775953,
-0.7770627141,
-0.324780941,
0.2960726917,
0.3341102302,
0.5061480403,
0.7193818688,
-0.5649142861,
0.7108151913,
-0.0103589967,
-0.5522789359,
0.2550380528,
-0.1108846143,
-0.2612389624,
0.3463392556,
0.716209352,
0.2244710028,
0.4744624197,
-0.7272877097,
-0.3474078774,
-0.1503856182,
0.2963083982,
-0.7724010348,
-0.3033620715,
0.1620084196,
-0.263119936,
-0.2102921009,
-0.0851589367,
-0.782579124,
-0.6480754614,
-0.5250756145,
0.67447263,
-0.5698316097,
-0.2807506323,
0.187849313,
-0.1045529991,
0.0990187302,
0.2665515542,
-0.5756431222,
0.0599099956,
0.6509561539,
0.5947993994,
0.2875801623,
-0.0685059726,
-0.4402607381,
0.5315183401,
-0.1908077747,
0.937740922,
-0.3118084371,
-0.5480133891,
-0.0257989373,
-0.0776055232,
0.0165899415,
-0.5597006083,
0.2948542535,
-0.9227905273,
0.0073162923,
-0.4877666235,
-0.4601601958,
-0.3062461615,
0.5867932439,
-0.5294143558,
0.8618045449,
0.0010718666,
-0.7506346703,
0.3398669362,
-0.3177224994,
-0.6408194304,
0.0635196492,
-0.2054032832,
-0.4964720011,
-0.2796159089,
0.3663608432,
0.4607724249,
-0.0809001625,
0.3832393289,
-0.515873313,
-0.3167290986,
-0.040360257,
-0.1370005906,
0.447104454,
0.0759143308,
-0.3598926663,
-0.0315683745,
-0.9386864901,
0.1963942945,
0.1463082731,
-0.2478826642,
-0.322407335,
-0.0305040963,
-0.3937190473,
0.1651792377,
0.2648302317,
-0.5100821257,
0.1523919702,
-0.3612152338,
-0.0889157206,
0.7704972029,
0.1325032264,
0.1870566756,
-0.3464491665,
0.40675354,
-0.3837518394,
0.0018919031,
0.2902777195,
-0.457475096,
-0.7202874422,
-0.3492658734,
0.0025716757,
0.6678832173,
-1.0444120169,
0.6105197668,
-0.3913157582,
-0.4320524335,
-0.1487205327,
0.2071775347,
0.2511415184,
0.9271048903,
0.3093724847,
0.1153330356,
-0.7242830396,
-0.6497392058,
-0.17384547,
-0.4351371527,
0.0868660882,
0.4833325446,
0.3631566465,
-0.4420854151,
1.2539885044,
-0.6600160599,
-0.3838072419,
-0.2037408948,
0.0070491997,
-0.1382215917,
0.1265656948,
0.3312264085,
-0.6983969808,
-0.2505041361,
0.1811924875,
-0.9047454596,
-0.1294677258,
-0.0421125367,
-0.0430779122,
0.3307417035,
0.7201617956,
-0.7108330131,
0.4541515708,
0.3559395671,
-0.3853786886,
0.7591553926,
-0.314988941,
0.2710905671,
-1.1067034006,
0.2098883092,
-0.4740694165,
-0.2689746618,
-0.1513202935,
-0.1092401072,
-0.0278409421,
0.0287066586,
-0.0522356294,
0.6682373881,
-0.3200194836,
-0.1082147509,
-0.3739027679,
0.4213817716,
0.0308589377,
0.414832145,
-0.0574422851,
0.6266561151,
0.1427629143,
-0.498793602,
0.6783989072,
0.4310538173,
-0.400740087,
0.2079552561,
-0.2856898904,
0.2806256413,
-0.3432502449,
0.4283306599,
-1.1590400934,
-0.1963930577,
0.5089430213,
-0.4524264634,
0.1387075335,
-0.1648010314,
-0.7212895155,
-0.4321767688,
-0.044110842,
0.0796630532,
0.5517488718,
-0.7232555151,
1.1696479321,
0.1720100492,
-0.1750893444,
-0.5715572834,
-0.3903206289,
0.159054473,
-0.0332289189,
-0.7503653169,
-0.0001082124,
0.1025887281,
-0.0649732202,
0.2119477838,
-0.0914091542,
0.2280672789,
0.1281154305,
0.1244537532,
0.3531175554,
-0.2057988197,
0.1856434643,
0.1060656309,
-0.2914886475,
0.2683636546,
-0.359557569,
0.7699609995,
0.220725596,
-0.7060224414,
-0.2897678912,
0.0585316941,
0.7138648033,
-0.1869527698,
0.9312918782,
0.5847174525,
-0.3027953506,
-0.2005666047,
-1.1674160957,
-0.418727994,
-0.5285832882,
0.5352910757,
-0.5110067725,
-0.9515436292,
0.6009532809,
-0.5096461773,
-0.2885834575,
0.1386564523,
0.5660294294,
0.164302215,
0.9792647362,
0.4346694648,
-0.1553310156,
0.0941530764,
0.0649674237,
0.7464966774,
-0.8439032435,
-0.6602700949,
-0.526250124,
-0.0592469089,
-0.4136306047,
-0.2216768414,
0.4098279774,
0.0681696981,
-0.235153988,
0.1141844466,
-0.4105646312,
0.5778314471,
0.3153012991,
0.2820434272,
0.5173863769,
-0.1837596297,
-0.3295329809,
0.2563896477,
-0.7788797617,
-0.4990646541,
0.9294986725,
0.0429551825,
0.7147753239,
0.1682531238,
0.6813936234,
0.0741148815,
0.3721229136,
-0.7927592993,
0.8795063496,
0.2950919569,
-0.3707845807,
-0.4747631848,
-0.7534222603,
-0.5670757294,
0.1671394557,
-0.3486383855,
-0.8818766475,
0.0595751591,
0.2847945392,
-0.276355803,
0.6345282197,
-0.6586850882,
0.6661283374,
-0.002712091,
-0.0656298399,
-0.190275684,
-0.3889649808,
0.6132950783,
-0.2656382024,
0.4684609771,
0.1810538173,
0.5639959574,
0.3958220482,
-0.4021096826,
0.9215179086,
-0.3139424324,
-0.2495734096,
0.1510499418,
0.3973578811,
1.1969020367,
0.164400816,
0.110298872,
-0.2262715101,
-0.0625729188,
-0.1033648103,
-0.8809653521,
0.685180068,
-0.6450250149,
-0.8890072703,
-0.0199876819,
-0.6374608874,
-0.701600492,
0.2271573544,
-0.1075464785,
0.334439218,
-0.1205219775,
0.1394425035,
0.8411135674,
-0.4125422835,
0.0444544628,
0.3438732028,
-0.7198626399,
-0.5106520057,
0.995999217,
0.0396148004,
0.1533879042,
0.3349349201,
0.3603806198,
-0.4365257621,
-0.5000836849,
-0.3290978074,
0.2426453531,
-0.9922985435,
-0.3092415333,
-0.954952836,
-0.2520429194,
-0.9262912869,
-0.0613929331,
-0.353795886,
-0.3040583134,
0.1817950308,
-0.1500996351,
0.4429025054,
0.6874093413,
-0.0087029077,
-0.2619980276,
-0.8486377597,
0.5143437386,
0.6474902034,
0.4184726477,
0.3332263827,
-0.4024935663,
-0.1400792599,
-0.0596882664,
0.0677300319,
-0.5196247697,
0.2164000869,
-0.3535013497,
0.6158447266,
0.3313707113,
0.3062282205,
0.777307272,
-0.6712881923,
0.4976861477,
0.0651862398,
-0.7387505174,
0.2898090482,
-0.2114627957,
0.1320739836,
0.3315935433,
0.1203951463,
-0.6029984951,
-0.4815891087,
-0.2094215006,
-0.8173542023,
0.2375369072,
-0.0939242765,
0.0682550147,
0.0096086068,
0.5429714322,
0.0289057977,
0.065150626,
-0.5214858651,
-0.0605523139,
-0.3302045465,
-0.1418613195,
0.1809262037,
-0.2815997005,
-0.2658569813,
-0.2837519348,
1.0233783722,
-0.2724367976,
0.1521439552,
0.160155803,
-0.1346981674,
-0.1431343555,
0.0662458912,
0.570125401,
0.4813461006,
-0.2730505168,
0.1681732833,
0.3432641327,
-0.371078372,
0.0294983145,
0.0107383309,
-0.2093422562,
-0.1627661288,
0.334143281,
0.8064909577,
0.064010188,
-0.663723886,
0.1999364793,
0.0859652907,
-0.1544585824,
-0.2653262019,
0.1861454248,
0.2621602714,
0.5900816917,
0.2476017922,
0.2072328776,
-0.0614582822,
-0.3312138021,
0.3196111917,
0.6852722764,
-0.1672348678,
-0.0300419983,
0.5938513279,
0.0499357805,
-0.3730713725,
0.6799644232,
-0.2191936076,
-0.6948747635,
0.3518061638,
0.7472456098,
0.8136143684,
0.0848416463,
0.2848607004,
0.3778863847,
0.2552874684,
0.0238243043,
-0.0584860146,
-0.0175755527,
-1.1193640232,
-0.594792068,
-0.573091507,
-0.2645489275,
-0.0534498096,
-0.3190509081,
0.2613938749,
-0.419742316,
0.1038973257,
-0.4543615282,
-0.3068300486,
-0.3948884606,
0.3145619631,
0.2558568418,
0.7209557295,
-0.6804074049,
0.8041841984,
0.4617331624,
-0.2851156294,
-1.0951403379,
0.2188251317,
-0.0405631885,
-0.9176074862,
0.9125088453,
-0.2293768823,
-0.5849760175,
0.1380733252,
-0.2554770112,
-0.9233640432,
1.3409606218,
0.5353056788,
-0.4347595274,
0.0359584577,
0.3151804209,
0.1982150674,
0.0193114132,
-0.0707289577,
0.3816649914,
0.7148974538,
0.6034272313,
-0.8434838057,
0.5078521371,
0.030640889,
-0.2012166977,
0.2355304509,
-0.5971239209,
0.2362601906,
-0.2693510056,
0.0102190021,
0.0153502841,
0.5853729248,
0.5641627908,
0.2466647476,
0.6366145611,
0.653740108,
0.93558079,
0.0666664615,
1.0009386539,
-0.4430376291,
0.3984233737,
0.9535208344,
-0.4431797266,
0.6894751787,
0.584005177,
0.0092939436,
0.4495188892,
0.1608898044,
0.1464724094,
0.5649930239,
0.1291290969,
-0.2584731579,
-0.4472376406,
0.1959275454,
-0.4780294895,
0.2235071957,
-0.0245659649,
0.0364182852,
-0.1740739793,
0.1847446859,
0.3807897568,
-0.11119923,
0.0507305041,
0.9064208269,
-0.0933660641,
-0.6096381545,
0.5407117009,
-0.1589187831,
0.4374544024,
-0.6093294621,
-0.0708757788,
-0.2817642987,
0.1572490335,
-0.2330625206,
-0.4283254743,
0.413413465,
-0.2626948953,
-0.1780749708,
-0.1899271458,
1.1378412247,
-0.2040689588,
-0.5188962221,
0.3504345119,
0.5036825538,
-0.2054555416,
-0.2659909725,
-0.2145641148,
0.0254298262,
0.0613998845,
-0.4267705381,
0.343719095,
0.7729158401,
0.1083503813,
0.9183471203,
0.7833329439,
0.1080700085,
-0.0848436579,
0.2268029302,
1.0737248659,
-0.5675188899,
-0.3445393443,
-0.8061485291,
0.4136567712,
-0.0113876304,
0.2014236152,
0.7529544234,
0.5758404136,
0.6793246865,
-0.1337654442,
0.9159853458,
-0.0738441646,
0.3834767044,
-0.7779555917,
1.1973469257,
-0.4507573843,
0.4664929509,
-0.5022768974,
-0.9070965052,
-0.4909489453,
0.6303370595,
-0.4025282264,
0.1857917607,
0.6026070714,
1.1085058451,
0.0713114887,
0.1034233794,
0.5538831353,
0.4824563563,
0.4177932441,
0.1004093513,
0.7560325861,
-0.1458553076,
0.7066189647,
-0.1245688275,
-0.0340339728,
-0.1305362284,
-0.9050140977,
-0.9176373482,
-0.3828166127,
-0.3203519583,
-0.690436244,
0.0493874662,
0.8599114418,
0.4904924631,
-0.7657870054,
0.1727140099,
-0.113560766,
0.3767388165,
0.0782161579,
-0.2694235444,
0.4742153883,
-0.4530722797,
-0.1935192496,
0.3886183202,
0.2623662055,
-0.168683365,
-0.5117759705,
-0.2923439741,
-0.0504781082,
0.1055141538,
0.7367092371,
0.120928295,
-0.784707725,
-0.8287550807,
0.0868696123,
0.1447337568,
-0.0439421535,
0.7434861064,
-1.3368929625,
0.3824213445,
0.4968541861,
0.8647571802,
0.4125130177,
-0.1931144893,
0.4484957159,
-0.5743932724,
0.0056968159,
0.0828830302,
0.3092754185,
0.3272643685,
-0.6088122129,
0.3337161839,
0.5501893759,
-0.5249530673,
-0.8667714,
0.2732554376,
-0.7763322592,
-0.4613956213,
1.2514585257,
0.1442254186,
-0.1169259399,
-0.2947404385,
-0.4386101365,
0.3248130977,
-0.0740337819,
1.4009068012,
0.7923795581,
-0.1746362448,
-0.1929155886,
-0.4048587382,
0.3024945259,
0.2084416449,
-0.938026607,
0.1856179833,
0.4572469294,
0.3450098932,
0.1645257026,
0.5060233474,
-0.09946163,
0.0225022975,
-0.0424602926,
0.1233950853,
-0.3651704788,
-0.1809830666,
0.3869380653,
0.2813681066,
0.0192125533,
0.1490728557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13307v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13307v2
|
Rethinking Radiology Report Generation via Causal Reasoning and Counterfactual Augmentation
| 2023-11-22T10:55:36 | 2023-12-05T10:25:23 |
Xiao Song, Jiafan Liu, Yun Li, Wenbin Lei, Ruxin Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Radiology Report Generation (RRG) draws attention as an interaction between
vision and language fields. Previous works inherited the ideology of
vision-to-language generation tasks,aiming to generate paragraphs with high
consistency as reports. However, one unique characteristic of RRG, the
independence between diseases, was neglected, leading to the injection of
disease co-occurrence as a confounder that effects the results through backdoor
path. Unfortunately, this confounder confuses the process of report generation
worse because of the biased RRG data distribution. In this paper, to rethink
this issue thoroughly, we reason about its causes and effects from a novel
perspective of statistics and causality, where the Joint Vision Coupling and
the Conditional Sentence Coherence Coupling are two aspects prone to implicitly
decrease the accuracy of reports. Then, a counterfactual augmentation strategy
that contains the Counterfactual Sample Synthesis and the Counterfactual Report
Reconstruction sub-methods is proposed to break these two aspects of spurious
effects. Experimental results and further analyses on two widely used datasets
justify our reasoning and proposed methods.
|
[
-0.4608077705,
-0.7863598466,
0.8434295654,
-0.1703870445,
-0.4467908144,
-0.2982653379,
0.3535571694,
-0.741016984,
0.5039196014,
0.5688412189,
-0.6430454254,
-0.2039120644,
-0.8552986979,
0.0307078678,
-0.2979514897,
1.1033264399,
0.1190321296,
0.2237891704,
-0.2992854416,
-0.2049888372,
-0.9340557456,
-0.0813476741,
-0.5400304198,
-0.4613657594,
0.7145855427,
0.4682679176,
1.0670875311,
0.6996898055,
0.7141067386,
0.0938377082,
0.7661874294,
0.0540724546,
-0.2946967781,
0.3179176748,
-0.3221930563,
-0.3512240052,
-0.3451070189,
0.1129166484,
0.1795463115,
0.6449307203,
0.1513215005,
-0.108945623,
-0.1902081519,
0.6588656902,
-0.6274387836,
-0.2319785655,
-0.267960757,
0.0385235883,
-0.1634035408,
-0.9594116211,
-0.4655267298,
-0.2626572847,
0.2563841939,
-0.5529536009,
0.5082684755,
0.179639563,
0.9732440114,
0.3461109698,
-0.4196191132,
-0.3719781041,
-0.7926884294,
0.5366255641,
-0.5272067785,
0.1603223681,
0.3946834803,
0.2769235671,
-0.1303259283,
-0.8590837121,
-0.3607239127,
-0.15197514,
-0.4322168231,
0.486464411,
-0.4930391312,
-0.1153628156,
0.216170162,
0.1701842844,
-0.9048904777,
0.0214543138,
-0.3378325999,
-0.1089178026,
0.7620905638,
0.399889946,
0.7130052447,
-0.081208542,
-0.4487911463,
-0.2504242957,
-1.1302556992,
-0.5057413578,
0.1062090769,
0.0163798332,
-0.1083496064,
0.4820595682,
-0.2564112842,
0.6108458638,
0.2734832168,
-0.0071701845,
0.1670606136,
-0.3832009137,
-0.2554415166,
0.3656966686,
0.7087286711,
0.5967561007,
-0.2053133994,
-0.0925320387,
0.1402956545,
0.3301240206,
0.4267699122,
-0.7182169557,
-0.3536732793,
0.2936668694,
-0.4971015751,
-0.5262540579,
-0.1228617951,
-0.6732836366,
-0.2149114907,
-0.0693227723,
0.5643261671,
-0.3521012664,
-0.2773626447,
0.0139662158,
-0.0690063089,
-0.0103010889,
0.2490348369,
-0.4620710313,
-0.1295737028,
0.4004070759,
0.3506501317,
0.3072112203,
-0.2389651537,
-0.7883821726,
0.3319879472,
-0.3888749778,
1.1151391268,
-0.5406472683,
-0.5094410181,
-0.304340899,
-0.1686401665,
-0.0033281089,
-0.3814663887,
0.1939149499,
-0.3452074528,
0.6956015229,
-0.3505609334,
-0.1605761796,
-0.2810065448,
0.1043225452,
-0.3258943856,
0.5357757211,
-0.0626754314,
-0.9116895795,
0.9278616309,
-0.0723288208,
-0.698723793,
0.3242204189,
-0.7805894017,
-0.6110385656,
0.1222719178,
0.1978098452,
0.1391623616,
-0.5242304802,
0.7565006614,
-0.1233329624,
-0.11788968,
0.1806812733,
-0.4745470583,
0.5220746398,
0.2317902148,
-0.3596530557,
0.0616538674,
-0.6002915502,
-0.0563562661,
-0.0960974321,
0.1795542538,
-0.4459598064,
0.2146039456,
-0.4522199929,
0.2165978998,
-0.2000010163,
-0.6051270962,
-0.1688455492,
-0.3375299871,
-0.3108584583,
0.1810237318,
0.433309406,
0.1526868939,
-0.8626116514,
0.4290975034,
0.3582223058,
0.26099962,
-0.2761045098,
-0.5896396637,
-0.5061475635,
-0.3265182376,
-0.0545097627,
0.4635940194,
-0.8716434836,
-0.1298059672,
-0.2979936302,
-0.3615912795,
-0.37799716,
-0.4855423272,
0.5380136371,
0.9725184441,
0.3954826295,
-0.4367578924,
-0.8424841166,
-1.0549029112,
-0.3120723963,
-0.1563532799,
0.1117271408,
0.2255068868,
0.2556424439,
-0.1526705325,
0.8555104136,
-0.7280086279,
-0.3261940777,
-0.257545501,
0.4082616866,
0.147317782,
0.7022566199,
0.617472887,
-0.6591116786,
-0.1950409412,
-0.3259389102,
-1.1004760265,
-0.3512037098,
-0.4503216743,
-0.0363469124,
0.4344413579,
0.8684681058,
-0.3673763871,
1.0052381754,
0.3415674865,
-0.2559215128,
0.4853840172,
-0.5010135174,
0.4821941853,
-0.9121586084,
0.0303255897,
0.1270573288,
-0.0828983039,
-0.4021050334,
0.1075277627,
-0.3699163795,
-0.0582883582,
-0.1127470061,
0.1726124734,
-0.5229890347,
0.0674020573,
-0.3260657489,
0.0397510417,
0.1334186643,
0.1277292818,
0.0991507843,
0.2235021889,
0.6486313939,
-0.3643997312,
0.1068336889,
0.1336432844,
-0.0610757582,
0.4531443417,
-0.6471479535,
-0.2107238472,
-0.4534686804,
0.5558273196,
-1.1126519442,
-0.1962213963,
0.4578298628,
-0.5524380207,
0.3625731468,
-0.1247867644,
-0.093690984,
-0.0679313242,
-0.2360198945,
0.4976550043,
0.5863426924,
-0.3043173552,
0.4813027084,
0.3022078276,
-0.0279893093,
-0.6156713963,
-1.1857647896,
0.3672262728,
-0.19696334,
-0.8602430224,
0.1967529356,
0.2869217694,
-0.5237572789,
0.2065101564,
-0.015164854,
0.2258138061,
-0.4111367762,
0.4093769491,
0.5463789105,
-0.3514656723,
0.0002807059,
-0.0013034872,
-0.2673002183,
0.1963973939,
0.0838387385,
0.2243865281,
0.3500783443,
-0.4549416602,
-0.0978971347,
0.5861865878,
0.2776917815,
0.0842843652,
0.5776429176,
0.4183904529,
0.0085507482,
-0.050891798,
-0.5529646873,
-0.3438944519,
-0.3545158803,
0.2091518492,
-0.2124694586,
-0.4007145762,
0.4000193477,
0.1391378492,
-0.0174623802,
0.3960515559,
0.4930519164,
-0.0531216748,
0.7065675855,
0.2039880902,
0.5313471556,
0.2105508894,
0.0814994946,
0.4662340581,
-0.5678850412,
-0.3623401821,
-0.284569025,
0.1110252142,
-0.7563400865,
-0.2232823968,
0.5759050846,
-0.1503018886,
0.4042757154,
-0.1854898185,
-0.4612781703,
0.253557235,
0.1763596535,
0.4100842178,
0.3119137883,
-0.1086692512,
0.0041213105,
-0.249195233,
-1.1110413074,
-0.1694588661,
1.0659331083,
-0.059121456,
0.7674849629,
0.020140443,
0.6849151254,
0.2443702817,
0.4933405817,
-0.4539875686,
0.3836917281,
-0.3262994289,
-0.5104791522,
-0.160368979,
-0.1540251672,
-0.8978845477,
0.3784874082,
-0.5111135244,
-0.3253003657,
0.4239546061,
0.4901067317,
-0.3454548419,
-0.1492358893,
-0.7352822423,
0.4782147408,
-0.0078308275,
-0.7628124952,
-0.5415995717,
-0.8037738204,
0.7191498876,
0.1426737458,
0.3589945436,
0.3143018186,
0.5102246404,
0.4908057153,
-0.7649097443,
0.9092438221,
0.0254637785,
0.0168315675,
0.2798809409,
0.24716039,
0.5158773065,
0.361326009,
0.5221213698,
0.0675673634,
-0.2482093424,
-0.2091293633,
-0.3243763745,
0.8064662218,
-0.4179136753,
-0.9257645011,
-0.6603119969,
-0.8908510208,
-0.2746386528,
0.155483678,
0.6119454503,
0.9658631682,
-0.3001637459,
-0.2461929619,
0.5969646573,
-0.7042585015,
0.2808323205,
0.6179053783,
-0.2529227436,
-0.2008397281,
0.8738765717,
0.236153245,
0.2843386829,
0.3437544703,
0.3986291885,
-0.0928138122,
-0.4967299104,
-0.3517984748,
0.2826728523,
-0.5127614737,
0.0029619322,
-0.5862118006,
-0.1239783019,
-0.6542791128,
-0.2470694035,
-0.1490843296,
-0.2152359486,
-0.0126716569,
0.2934249938,
0.3261890709,
0.6385403872,
-0.6176059246,
-0.1169699878,
-0.6050623655,
0.459908694,
0.2205100656,
-0.0603904091,
0.1267429143,
-0.3028120995,
-0.3243528605,
0.0555013083,
-0.1603382677,
-0.5880753398,
0.3943675458,
-0.2920658886,
0.4231350422,
0.1684952378,
0.1059764326,
0.7373079062,
-0.3592217863,
0.4394523799,
0.5950379968,
-0.4531668127,
0.6155866385,
-0.6783135533,
0.2777878344,
0.1289203167,
0.1880105734,
-0.3552069962,
-0.9614297152,
-0.9684556127,
-0.9758555293,
0.5892858505,
-0.0583245158,
-0.5046287179,
-0.147849381,
-0.0048247878,
0.274728924,
-0.317280978,
-0.2257466614,
-0.0494305976,
-0.4240234494,
0.1276431382,
0.0445387848,
-0.3083113432,
-0.4669735432,
0.1309656948,
0.524313271,
0.1519674659,
-0.0071067451,
0.6854175329,
-0.1136269271,
-0.4675747454,
0.325645268,
0.8588007689,
0.9187170267,
-0.2627931535,
0.5327467918,
-0.1928588748,
-0.5343965292,
-0.1672516167,
-0.2235387713,
-0.2565150559,
0.0867149234,
0.7362546921,
0.5933465958,
-0.0286981035,
-0.2408280224,
0.4609136879,
0.1137326062,
-0.3361372054,
-0.2786488235,
0.1173737943,
0.0016701085,
0.2109848857,
0.5869607925,
0.5462478399,
0.1064675003,
-0.5679144859,
0.5180102587,
0.4255789816,
-0.2829320133,
-0.245429635,
0.7266249061,
0.1518729627,
0.1603190899,
0.3595907986,
0.1821582168,
0.0246258918,
0.6049776673,
0.5995625854,
0.7847217321,
0.0512859188,
0.3548633754,
0.5481037498,
0.4947145879,
-0.1165362448,
0.0109842094,
0.4296199977,
-0.6290338039,
-0.7709915042,
0.1347115934,
-0.190366298,
0.1274549216,
-0.7494207621,
0.1572907716,
-0.2136802375,
0.0170517787,
0.1222185269,
-0.4147641659,
-0.1477396339,
0.7556961179,
-0.0183966924,
0.3019299805,
-1.0279486179,
0.6844282746,
0.3052286804,
-0.6466466188,
-0.7486484051,
0.3203358352,
-0.0255173594,
-1.0079681873,
0.9239339232,
-0.2827784419,
-0.4230320454,
-0.4365991354,
-0.3790559471,
-0.6240233779,
0.7977331877,
0.2434871942,
-0.5618326068,
0.2698377073,
0.2121195346,
0.5901789069,
-0.4642330706,
0.1193953902,
0.1302182823,
0.3902184963,
0.342592448,
-0.6796838641,
0.6311872602,
0.1391246766,
-0.1995461285,
0.2294852436,
-0.4410394132,
0.6709307432,
-0.5569268465,
-0.4283860922,
-0.3285447061,
0.2825501561,
0.3611555696,
0.6366738081,
0.1741657704,
0.7415478826,
0.0014235363,
0.0153880827,
1.4206227064,
-0.0916117504,
0.0814704299,
1.0919796228,
-0.2911257148,
0.143813774,
0.8168516755,
0.1254641563,
0.5635575652,
0.09156508,
-0.0780623555,
0.7063074112,
-0.1673331559,
-0.0734760761,
-0.4134934247,
-0.2489439249,
-0.5757622719,
0.4271050394,
0.0828728229,
-0.4625153542,
-0.5808371902,
-0.1619718373,
0.1475891024,
-0.0764874741,
-0.0561199896,
0.4796720147,
0.0865453929,
-0.9270455241,
0.574354589,
-0.2820684314,
0.2930422425,
-0.5180620551,
-0.255538255,
-0.2601173818,
0.2035644352,
-0.5457704663,
-0.634619236,
0.8460583091,
-0.2898770571,
-0.2753656209,
-0.1873339564,
0.7828937769,
-0.3501618505,
-0.2525562644,
-0.0454840846,
0.638271451,
0.0106106251,
0.4650856555,
-0.2079708427,
0.0150328958,
0.1545099765,
-0.0497327037,
0.4881265759,
0.3740153015,
-0.2278000563,
0.3359633982,
0.4785305858,
0.387414068,
-0.415035367,
0.1220621243,
0.7256708145,
-0.4213888645,
-0.674701035,
-0.8135944009,
0.3677197397,
0.105840221,
-0.4315568209,
0.8652743101,
0.4907687902,
0.4472443163,
0.0357035957,
0.8060063124,
-0.2405204624,
0.4844785333,
-0.6508694887,
0.6755477786,
-0.567199111,
0.4139323831,
-0.3507317901,
-0.1312248558,
-0.4285047054,
0.161261797,
-0.6015372872,
-0.1592629552,
1.071721673,
1.0292059183,
0.0264653154,
0.0564002171,
0.4084125757,
0.3688620031,
0.2420086712,
0.5823266506,
0.7485785484,
-0.5255692005,
0.5550355911,
0.1543832272,
-0.2695455849,
-0.2339280695,
-0.7044186592,
-0.620978415,
-0.3435959518,
-0.7125757933,
-0.6492962241,
0.2687785327,
0.1587087363,
0.3802595437,
-0.4183593988,
0.1712383926,
-0.3378321826,
0.0401966944,
-0.1035012007,
-0.2668745816,
0.4792044759,
-0.0855705589,
-0.1202477887,
0.2359514683,
0.548320055,
-0.0843122676,
-0.2295992523,
0.1603341401,
-0.1326445341,
-0.0466567725,
0.3384706378,
0.3531442583,
-0.4885165095,
-0.4084912837,
-0.3946473002,
-0.2197113037,
0.1331341714,
1.0696852207,
-1.1549563408,
0.3631219566,
0.5748478174,
0.1293639243,
0.5447744727,
-0.2635920942,
0.8675516248,
-0.5740600228,
0.2657834888,
-0.005543008,
0.1187626123,
0.1560376436,
-0.5359568,
0.3951532543,
0.4005689621,
-0.3733232021,
-0.9436952472,
0.5858319402,
-0.8908417225,
-0.5818059444,
0.9288802743,
0.0054308497,
-0.0224553719,
-0.3936344683,
0.0995131135,
0.4545251429,
-0.1230098978,
1.0082156658,
0.2237207294,
-0.8132690787,
-0.3028181195,
-0.1699619442,
0.5016067624,
0.644212544,
-0.5973904133,
-0.2354739457,
0.8892263174,
0.4515827596,
0.186035499,
0.8576016426,
-0.3924709857,
0.7323396206,
0.6238428354,
-0.1486759037,
-0.3307195604,
0.0391864106,
0.0251249,
0.2202781439,
-0.3549734056,
-0.2139014006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13281v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13281v1
|
Intention and Context Elicitation with Large Language Models in the Legal Aid Intake Process
| 2023-11-22T10:04:29 | 2023-11-22T10:04:29 |
Nick Goodson, Rongfei Lu
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) and chatbots show significant promise in
streamlining the legal intake process. This advancement can greatly reduce the
workload and costs for legal aid organizations, improving availability while
making legal assistance more accessible to a broader audience. However, a key
challenge with current LLMs is their tendency to overconfidently deliver an
immediate 'best guess' to a client's question based on the output distribution
learned over the training data. This approach often overlooks the client's
actual intentions or the specifics of their legal situation. As a result,
clients may not realize the importance of providing essential additional
context or expressing their underlying intentions, which are crucial for their
legal cases. Traditionally, logic based decision trees have been used to
automate intake for specific access to justice issues, such as immigration and
eviction. But those solutions lack scalability. We demonstrate a
proof-of-concept using LLMs to elicit and infer clients' underlying intentions
and specific legal circumstances through free-form, language-based
interactions. We also propose future research directions to use supervised
fine-tuning or offline reinforcement learning to automatically incorporate
intention and context elicitation in chatbots without explicit prompting.
|
[
-0.0568191223,
-0.9450105429,
1.1600600481,
-0.0390230194,
-0.1216187254,
-0.2616132796,
-0.288990885,
-0.2080686539,
0.0662733242,
0.4386566877,
-0.4089387655,
-0.3491734862,
-0.5234104991,
-0.0869254768,
-0.3656761646,
0.7907781005,
-0.0900008306,
0.2627455592,
-0.2738130987,
-0.1018513516,
-0.6953422427,
-0.1529756486,
-1.0391105413,
-0.369653523,
0.4147051871,
0.5634102225,
0.5637959242,
0.3560140729,
0.1872875839,
0.3015954792,
0.1398526132,
-0.0510723628,
-0.3253282905,
0.1523252577,
-0.2882416248,
-0.5726726651,
-0.2719323933,
-0.0870614573,
0.4395843446,
0.6332753301,
-0.4688932002,
0.0233636163,
-0.2216307968,
0.4596974254,
-0.646709621,
0.1593490839,
-0.7546955347,
0.2424687594,
0.1571196318,
-0.3067052662,
-0.5302224755,
-0.1381012499,
0.2383870631,
-0.5697470903,
-0.1912340373,
0.2384919375,
0.4980485141,
0.4389826655,
-0.3618943989,
-0.6166855097,
-0.6222903728,
0.4079658389,
-0.617498219,
0.3456792831,
0.7184345126,
0.4889735878,
-0.515615046,
-0.5884652734,
-0.6665616632,
-0.2639508247,
-0.0890530273,
0.0993929058,
-0.3536537886,
0.3955771923,
0.4143755436,
-0.207542628,
-0.4667364955,
0.1414601207,
-0.1310315281,
-0.0938638523,
0.6644974947,
-0.0043208799,
0.2682307065,
-0.08969713,
0.0510837249,
0.2849513292,
-0.7589917779,
0.2657494545,
0.2680456638,
0.2967941761,
-0.1432298869,
0.8433346748,
-0.1025802866,
0.5366804004,
0.3088858128,
0.2073999643,
-0.1299280971,
-0.1422712207,
-0.5653757453,
0.4199381769,
0.7448171377,
0.2555060089,
0.3252988756,
0.1558135301,
-0.1595775485,
-0.555862844,
0.0861588866,
-0.7024092674,
0.3992318511,
0.7517073154,
-0.4441291094,
-0.117838122,
0.0215910003,
-0.5632572174,
-0.5262864828,
-0.4044609666,
0.2620145679,
-0.3486015797,
-0.1178102642,
0.0998778492,
-0.0564000085,
0.4833192825,
0.5974091291,
-0.7686065435,
0.0992878079,
0.5798003078,
0.6154598594,
0.2129270732,
0.2111351192,
-1.2778356075,
0.2841534615,
-0.2127807438,
0.5749015212,
-0.8463653326,
-0.3860267699,
0.3132800162,
0.01994594,
0.0963393152,
-0.4342423677,
0.5531978011,
-0.4345846772,
0.0575879999,
-0.1445550472,
-0.643096447,
0.0457884558,
0.2087903023,
-0.2458589971,
0.5994198322,
0.189815104,
-0.1989055425,
0.7945473194,
-1.0591671467,
-0.4232876897,
0.4580865204,
-0.5427506566,
-0.2481301278,
0.257339716,
0.3584522903,
0.4550998211,
-0.028821975,
0.5443101525,
-0.3459516764,
-0.0875764713,
0.2145783603,
-0.4428345859,
0.8394510746,
0.3864839077,
-0.2335060537,
0.2738165557,
-0.4079317153,
-0.1264760792,
0.2284653038,
-0.3523029089,
-0.2735835612,
0.20398435,
-0.2947640121,
0.2279457152,
0.1357214898,
-0.4626570344,
0.1765165478,
-0.4551566243,
0.4812812507,
0.4968829751,
0.0118530802,
0.4516168535,
0.0047139139,
0.6332501173,
-0.1488205045,
0.1910046786,
-0.3034237623,
-0.5643262863,
-0.3414718509,
-0.1072795019,
-0.0083905607,
0.4859229028,
-0.5733858347,
0.4430014789,
-0.0693073198,
0.0880413055,
-0.4219374061,
0.1339495629,
0.0604371689,
0.3106141686,
-0.0071480502,
0.0193111859,
-0.4669285715,
-0.810434401,
-0.2483493835,
-0.3380234241,
0.0449518338,
0.5788396597,
0.548456192,
-0.1140416712,
1.2844265699,
-0.3067941666,
-0.2653590441,
-0.671459496,
0.0451539755,
0.2251691371,
0.2879312634,
0.5630546808,
-0.984739542,
-0.5076684952,
0.2101975381,
-0.6332511902,
-0.1870354712,
-0.3201642036,
0.0058720554,
0.1570423692,
0.5564795732,
-0.573269248,
0.572127223,
0.2628976107,
-0.4989373386,
0.2597447634,
-0.5945659876,
0.0204904731,
-0.9221025109,
-0.1262041479,
-0.0319138467,
-0.45532763,
-0.634998858,
-0.1173226461,
0.1516333818,
-0.1822353154,
-0.814350009,
0.7921204567,
-0.427895695,
-0.2770514786,
-0.3092134297,
0.2488849014,
-0.15370965,
0.3307416439,
0.0793882608,
0.7981259823,
0.4515167475,
-0.518039763,
0.2843119204,
0.1605942696,
-0.3370124102,
1.0697267056,
-0.4061222672,
-0.080473043,
-0.5631272793,
0.385976851,
-0.8579072356,
-0.5345960259,
0.4208371937,
-0.3764377832,
0.290063113,
-0.4577417374,
-0.3479700685,
-0.4232546389,
0.0259990431,
0.30839926,
0.3479681909,
-0.3246531487,
0.8893512487,
0.4457520545,
-0.0720595196,
-0.500341177,
-0.5971390605,
0.1606668979,
-0.3136434257,
-0.1803469211,
-0.1268912107,
0.0157132521,
-0.4200585783,
-0.0141923614,
0.2657690048,
-0.1994486004,
0.1265169531,
0.46296978,
0.0713037997,
0.0630667582,
0.1404414177,
0.3708304167,
0.2211346328,
0.3752001226,
-0.4175422192,
0.4161865115,
0.0663800612,
-0.8482308984,
-0.5550510287,
0.3977368474,
0.5545340776,
0.0019257459,
0.7446286678,
0.1981963366,
-0.4870153964,
0.0562456883,
-0.6474096179,
0.0270219762,
-0.487410605,
0.3897537589,
-0.325155735,
-0.7132018805,
0.4215489924,
-0.133965686,
0.1989247948,
0.0991196409,
0.5973770618,
-0.0741387457,
1.0975543261,
0.2793712616,
0.0102381799,
0.8036287427,
-0.0750720128,
0.2226424515,
-0.7357590199,
-0.185200125,
-0.4512184262,
-0.0356191359,
-0.1456426978,
-0.3103887141,
0.3559378386,
0.1032433435,
0.0804471523,
0.1383051276,
-0.056970831,
0.5433768034,
0.3694323301,
-0.0254016984,
0.2697844803,
-0.0626494065,
-0.3451859057,
0.3087706268,
-0.7042376399,
-0.3940941989,
1.1459366083,
0.2580950856,
0.3107099235,
0.0671816319,
0.6031218171,
0.3142823875,
0.5114924908,
-1.0569069386,
0.4470329881,
0.4827896655,
-0.5459588766,
-0.6319257021,
-0.1809100211,
-1.3286181688,
0.2658483684,
-0.1847809106,
-1.0463140011,
0.2012382895,
0.2314076126,
-0.6945305467,
0.1344411969,
-0.6528204083,
0.71998173,
-0.347881794,
-0.4472036362,
-0.2455478311,
-0.5641835332,
0.151724413,
-0.1875275224,
0.5514255762,
-0.1917821467,
0.104366377,
0.3578816354,
-0.6040516496,
0.7712695599,
-0.4890445471,
-0.2874358892,
0.6224464774,
-0.0784482956,
0.9372411966,
0.2078912258,
-0.1516879201,
-0.3949052393,
-0.0870838314,
-0.0998711139,
-0.776304841,
0.4653636813,
-0.3023692667,
-0.7362883091,
-0.0745864287,
-0.7350698709,
-0.2092270851,
0.2728721797,
-0.2092174739,
0.3199001849,
-0.3196117878,
0.1739527136,
0.3281613886,
-0.313193053,
0.4891717434,
0.6455894709,
-0.3051358163,
-0.1234764084,
0.5529968143,
0.0046706125,
0.1829515845,
0.2896365225,
0.5106919408,
-0.6279831529,
-0.6286246777,
-0.5852203369,
0.1327688098,
-0.7986301184,
0.0867597014,
-0.6987460852,
0.1047255024,
-0.471873492,
-0.3324988782,
-0.0014394572,
-0.0978325009,
-0.0202070046,
-0.0962869972,
0.4105963409,
0.6828870177,
0.040468663,
0.1498721391,
-0.7316737175,
0.0133618731,
0.2389215231,
0.1611962616,
-0.1136359051,
-0.4731408358,
-0.0114394482,
0.0660411194,
-0.0373826139,
-0.8449149728,
0.2512613833,
0.0955753922,
0.7209576368,
0.8558461666,
0.0723933205,
0.6865355968,
-0.6343672276,
0.5555942059,
0.0239653289,
-0.6077933908,
0.9519641399,
-0.4979357123,
0.1217514798,
0.7341119647,
0.2518690825,
-0.6222339272,
-0.4659928083,
-0.5300375223,
-0.6562104225,
0.8882926106,
0.1840420365,
0.2167072594,
-0.1124274433,
0.478033185,
-0.065602079,
0.3574488163,
-0.5546515584,
0.0919666886,
0.1426182091,
-0.5087159276,
0.2988781333,
-0.0696222037,
-0.1011288986,
-0.2537284493,
0.4009186327,
-0.1955349296,
0.1044118702,
0.2046785504,
-0.193635419,
-0.2299798131,
0.455388695,
0.8300439715,
0.6982318759,
0.0045130914,
-0.2079709023,
0.4569332302,
-0.2939372063,
0.2289223522,
-0.1922345012,
-0.1915232688,
-0.0985034853,
0.0019212062,
0.7580814362,
0.1959684491,
-0.9919286966,
0.7185968161,
-0.093443647,
-0.3279574215,
-0.6573399305,
0.0617857575,
0.0533368476,
0.401409924,
0.2649001181,
-0.5425704718,
0.2965725958,
-0.6373162866,
-0.0716865063,
0.8763131499,
-0.4903712571,
0.1186494902,
0.4521715045,
0.2819373012,
-0.5992352962,
0.3502585292,
-0.3120714724,
-0.0459630452,
0.5499913692,
0.4559051394,
0.8701453805,
0.0188336689,
0.0756835714,
0.3063875437,
-0.0648612529,
-0.2393394113,
0.1362778544,
-0.3130425811,
-0.5853232741,
-0.5045492053,
-0.4128436744,
-0.3875629008,
0.2459785789,
-0.4774753451,
0.258420229,
-0.2814373374,
0.0234091878,
-0.2959592938,
-0.3993577957,
-0.733753264,
-0.1314108968,
-0.0246631317,
0.7785115242,
-0.6711218953,
0.8766681552,
0.6889739037,
-0.3950759768,
-0.8752422929,
-0.1109731793,
0.1882938147,
-0.8145140409,
0.7818484306,
0.0440678969,
-0.0319901854,
-0.0861710757,
-0.4774476886,
-0.7301668525,
0.9050459862,
0.402374059,
-0.7413018942,
-0.1489385813,
0.3398010135,
0.1719478071,
-0.475166142,
0.5100236535,
0.6794022322,
0.7437241673,
0.3076342046,
-0.6421527863,
0.1618247628,
-0.0012671479,
-0.1655871421,
0.1828804016,
-0.1227755323,
0.099050127,
-0.3456230164,
-0.2390187234,
-0.2002499253,
0.5493138433,
0.2367368042,
0.254748702,
0.6266789436,
0.3146421909,
0.8253324032,
0.0340495482,
1.1456332207,
-0.2483665496,
0.0720035285,
1.1023240089,
-0.5093105435,
0.7081573606,
0.7797299623,
-0.1373015344,
0.227865085,
0.4485521317,
0.2517822385,
0.2722892165,
0.2866201699,
-0.2963103652,
-0.2386238426,
-0.4293142855,
0.1571240872,
0.4079150558,
0.7431534529,
-0.4650559723,
-0.2871422768,
0.2241681367,
-0.1197583303,
0.0028894709,
-0.4295789897,
0.857757628,
0.0621229671,
-1.0405939817,
-0.1017985865,
-0.1197135225,
0.3712405264,
-0.5289477706,
-0.1634140015,
-0.0521328487,
-0.1677479744,
-0.2371088713,
-1.0035048723,
0.1542340368,
0.0730445758,
0.1653601974,
-0.3041579425,
0.636844635,
-0.3787414432,
-0.2975386679,
0.2504618168,
0.4689350724,
0.5618294477,
-0.0250861477,
-0.8535163999,
-0.1376995146,
-0.3384492099,
-0.3524802923,
0.2886922359,
0.7318930626,
-0.2595325708,
0.6685638428,
0.7248749733,
0.3249170184,
-0.0661995709,
0.4773486853,
0.4672194123,
-0.345318228,
-0.4945707917,
-0.9959507585,
0.4476506114,
-0.1613647789,
-0.0309417062,
0.3899112046,
0.3424939811,
0.6447813511,
0.3295497298,
0.7189908028,
-0.1755666733,
-0.0046861996,
-0.7002142668,
0.3624004722,
-0.5943666697,
0.1379161179,
-0.2609052658,
-0.6342949271,
-0.1964969486,
0.6903904676,
-0.4635392427,
0.1921516657,
0.5211181641,
0.6678290963,
-0.0325388685,
-0.2206286639,
0.6270721555,
-0.1781141907,
0.6235026717,
0.5782613754,
0.7741349936,
-0.0319747142,
0.6375802755,
0.3614244163,
-0.1233176291,
-0.6125312448,
-0.938893497,
-0.8264201283,
-0.2901421785,
-0.07758037,
-0.056613557,
0.0502439551,
1.4458411932,
0.6481143832,
-0.6615059972,
-0.1138769612,
-0.4919069111,
0.0837706029,
0.1235238612,
-0.1872785091,
0.14158158,
-0.5105196238,
-0.8108354807,
0.4664193988,
0.4201880693,
0.2318967432,
-0.2196650952,
-0.3654040396,
-0.3855943084,
0.2114518136,
0.612443924,
0.4974185526,
-0.9506700039,
-0.4633524418,
-0.4049085975,
-0.0816608593,
0.2125804126,
0.8946459293,
-0.542722702,
0.4202877283,
0.3127775192,
0.9017015696,
0.3057280779,
-0.0151209459,
0.8401422501,
-0.6731420755,
0.2063843012,
0.0591699779,
0.7882412672,
-0.0294365473,
-0.6378967762,
0.3395680487,
-0.3495630622,
-0.3653191328,
-0.616038084,
0.2695310414,
-0.6023131013,
-0.353205204,
1.1869608164,
-0.1298303008,
-0.3204165995,
-0.4979454577,
-0.5109579563,
0.2510100603,
-0.7641561627,
0.4001247585,
0.7503302693,
-0.2598268986,
-0.1558232009,
-0.9048178196,
0.5282625556,
0.5045659542,
-1.0290613174,
0.2110140771,
0.6307951808,
0.0969645828,
-0.0192325637,
0.9455068707,
0.0470441096,
0.2875167727,
-0.4808653593,
-0.0504025146,
-0.0779993013,
-0.2471133918,
-0.4367445707,
0.0933522582,
0.2802139223,
0.094194591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13274v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13274v2
|
Enhancing Summarization Performance through Transformer-Based Prompt Engineering in Automated Medical Reporting
| 2023-11-22T09:51:53 | 2024-01-19T10:06:50 |
Daphne van Zandvoort, Laura Wiersema, Tom Huibers, Sandra van Dulmen, Sjaak Brinkkemper
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Customized medical prompts enable Large Language Models (LLM) to effectively
address medical dialogue summarization. The process of medical reporting is
often time-consuming for healthcare professionals. Implementing medical
dialogue summarization techniques presents a viable solution to alleviate this
time constraint by generating automated medical reports. The effectiveness of
LLMs in this process is significantly influenced by the formulation of the
prompt, which plays a crucial role in determining the quality and relevance of
the generated reports. In this research, we used a combination of two distinct
prompting strategies, known as shot prompting and pattern prompting to enhance
the performance of automated medical reporting. The evaluation of the automated
medical reports is carried out using the ROUGE score and a human evaluation
with the help of an expert panel. The two-shot prompting approach in
combination with scope and domain context outperforms other methods and
achieves the highest score when compared to the human reference set by a
general practitioner. However, the automated reports are approximately twice as
long as the human references, due to the addition of both redundant and
relevant statements that are added to the report.
|
[
-0.1695822477,
-0.5998454094,
0.7330802679,
0.5180677176,
-0.3697237074,
0.3557433188,
0.0624132156,
-0.3264903128,
0.3687159419,
0.4084205031,
-0.5333487988,
-0.4248871207,
-0.5826809406,
0.5494588017,
-0.0287939422,
0.8084406257,
-0.0601009056,
0.3343436122,
-0.181501016,
-0.1627359241,
-1.0542964935,
-0.3039283454,
-0.6345701218,
-0.2607397735,
0.513641417,
0.3531362414,
0.6566486359,
0.7292550802,
0.7283960581,
0.3323219419,
0.019684257,
0.3625629544,
-0.0896937549,
0.4912149906,
0.1066210493,
-0.4191041887,
-0.617519021,
-0.139807418,
0.4686506093,
0.5086548924,
0.010941322,
0.1175039113,
0.1556660235,
0.7718392611,
-0.4874094427,
0.3489756882,
-0.1495604366,
0.0819451287,
0.1200845391,
-0.7787293196,
-0.5841188431,
-0.3965364695,
0.0822356939,
-0.5110219121,
0.2076878697,
0.0873366296,
0.6109756231,
0.4540322423,
-0.3135909438,
-0.4628969431,
-0.6145839691,
0.3556384146,
-0.6940539479,
-0.1927683204,
0.2158340663,
0.6180585623,
0.0252127908,
-0.6867383718,
-0.1355775893,
-0.1091402844,
-0.5293803215,
0.5816457868,
-0.2778788507,
0.1024957001,
0.1745736003,
0.1778648198,
-0.617434144,
0.1725803018,
-0.1628021151,
-0.2485717982,
0.7629039884,
0.8666613102,
0.2792892158,
-0.1841237694,
0.0760977194,
-0.0286521949,
-0.4472720921,
0.1437960863,
-0.1542711705,
0.3041790128,
-0.1911892146,
0.4010421336,
-0.334590584,
0.5120419264,
0.3543940783,
-0.3094971478,
0.219130531,
-0.4219294488,
-0.1008741558,
0.0205435157,
0.9591727257,
0.8713479042,
-0.0321738869,
0.0845825151,
-0.1966644078,
-0.1694800705,
0.3600595891,
-0.8166035414,
-0.01035049,
0.2418852448,
-0.7176958323,
-0.5713410974,
0.1078409851,
-0.8424972892,
-0.448967427,
-0.2700201869,
0.3551361859,
-0.1902664751,
0.0477380753,
-0.1556779593,
-0.2553138137,
0.2537602782,
0.6546135545,
-0.7373976707,
0.2279043347,
0.4136804938,
1.055306077,
-0.2582278252,
0.1502424031,
-0.7896541357,
0.0598242953,
-0.4426766336,
0.9978872538,
-0.491173625,
-1.0236119032,
-0.0319592878,
-0.0256101824,
-0.1354421973,
-0.8385621309,
0.3394230306,
-0.3434040248,
0.4343838096,
-0.204943344,
-0.3690667152,
0.0166719854,
0.0999901146,
-0.4725716412,
0.7305004597,
0.4135281742,
-0.3831063211,
0.1452448815,
-0.811734736,
-0.5990669727,
0.2958788872,
-0.3364582956,
-0.3294839561,
0.05441726,
0.6326594949,
0.4158706665,
-0.2804717422,
0.3157580793,
0.5859672427,
-0.3005630672,
0.1582205743,
-0.400277555,
0.5509924889,
-0.0215522982,
-0.224414587,
0.3632610738,
-0.4458277822,
-0.0800266191,
0.0638573244,
-0.1797907054,
0.0224191938,
-0.2610093057,
-0.2917171419,
0.0500449166,
-0.1994597614,
-0.1005441248,
0.2413365543,
-0.6595945358,
-0.1231337786,
0.4717628062,
0.4318295121,
0.4309058785,
-0.740334928,
1.0043872595,
-0.1217963248,
0.1204669997,
-0.999052465,
-0.5863051414,
-0.3973124623,
-0.4214225113,
0.1723867059,
1.0553565025,
-0.7052069902,
0.3927610815,
-0.0780524909,
-0.4306609929,
-0.7277927399,
-0.3187654614,
0.2750847638,
1.1555120945,
0.4594087005,
-0.2401382923,
-0.4727196991,
-0.74214077,
-0.2934006155,
-0.1210460961,
-0.4684824944,
0.4094479084,
0.16697447,
-0.1686449349,
1.241768837,
-0.7485257387,
-0.3388151526,
-0.6855683923,
0.3102386892,
0.4155221283,
0.1617692262,
0.580619514,
-0.3671123683,
-0.6819943786,
-0.2544268668,
-0.826867938,
-0.6287323833,
-0.4944022298,
0.2228000015,
0.4349788725,
0.3967741728,
-0.4295907319,
0.7486746907,
0.1929231137,
-0.1753336042,
0.8476465344,
-0.3168104887,
0.7015146613,
-1.1502449512,
0.1446320266,
-0.0751558766,
-0.3288486898,
-0.5431846976,
-0.3532913625,
-0.0152030317,
-0.1359251738,
-0.4580154419,
0.6441178322,
-0.4052546024,
0.3396320939,
-0.5992985368,
-0.0544561557,
0.2816447616,
0.1481842399,
-0.2052220553,
0.8410131931,
0.423717469,
-0.7185663581,
0.3763642013,
0.4276438355,
0.0626679212,
0.5642153025,
-1.0006916523,
-0.2638402879,
-0.2389174253,
0.5384449363,
-0.991702199,
-0.4932769239,
0.3665232062,
-0.4878229201,
0.4886416495,
0.0834212825,
-0.2193375677,
-0.4039824903,
-0.5181528926,
0.1909760386,
0.8076106906,
-0.1310358196,
0.7346427441,
0.2140275687,
-0.8125137687,
-0.2742274404,
-0.6250337362,
0.370485872,
-0.1120869294,
-0.614672482,
0.3523259759,
0.0294258986,
-0.3366974592,
-0.3231523335,
-0.0370212942,
0.2121061087,
-0.1737151444,
0.2423888147,
0.7792491317,
-0.1395400912,
0.0866759047,
0.254224211,
-0.5504206419,
0.3231273293,
0.3868626654,
0.3365180492,
0.2210900038,
-0.3896707892,
-1.0295436382,
0.773783505,
0.523439467,
-0.0542912669,
0.6184530854,
0.1979756206,
-0.0031218079,
0.0926498845,
-0.5377539992,
-0.6034966707,
-0.4670073986,
0.2399642766,
0.0358578935,
-0.7219800353,
0.6417869329,
-0.2085179985,
0.2507059872,
0.568249166,
0.8084563017,
-0.3097452223,
1.1653307676,
0.3449354768,
-0.1049413085,
0.2623338997,
-0.0403268002,
0.0763424262,
-0.5370194316,
-0.3456976414,
-0.5519167185,
-0.0435345843,
-0.2062683702,
-0.3369591236,
0.9757039547,
-0.4352637529,
0.3234792352,
-0.1056662723,
-0.6384198666,
0.6096566916,
0.2751717269,
0.0731761381,
0.4995000362,
-0.1914938837,
0.1247288659,
-0.0303368084,
-0.6836131811,
-0.5602615476,
0.6934038401,
0.3307000697,
0.6855894923,
-0.2715070546,
0.6178821921,
0.4615056515,
0.1268620789,
-1.0209190845,
0.4642864764,
0.1067105234,
0.0363457836,
-0.2241155803,
-0.2653270364,
-0.9751314521,
0.2451356351,
-0.0445058048,
-0.3667352796,
-0.2357041836,
0.3862347305,
-0.8023894429,
-0.2196271122,
-0.7038129568,
0.4570268691,
0.0019221398,
0.1351879984,
-0.2741145492,
-1.0400956869,
0.1093040854,
0.1813576818,
0.2119244039,
0.0732516497,
-0.2353685498,
0.5050901771,
-0.6665329337,
0.9388772845,
-0.109947741,
0.0378195196,
0.2498960942,
-0.022135824,
0.6428918242,
0.1901862621,
0.1958815157,
-0.0635737628,
-0.266499728,
-0.0196841899,
-0.7714614868,
0.1388958842,
-0.2720275223,
-0.8607974052,
-0.4038547277,
-0.6846852303,
-0.3085132539,
-0.027520135,
0.529820919,
0.7614466548,
-0.1557807326,
-0.3175274432,
0.4867707491,
-0.5103181005,
0.6851468682,
0.5534797311,
0.0288131367,
-0.4059993327,
0.5610547066,
0.1219234616,
0.2493078411,
0.4237400293,
0.3465841711,
-0.0933450386,
-0.4349847734,
-0.6678350568,
0.2850126028,
-0.5194553733,
-0.5417351723,
-0.8509444594,
-0.3619140089,
-0.5515976548,
-0.4963070154,
-0.0055180769,
-0.4257512689,
-0.3458173573,
0.1534129828,
0.3335152566,
0.6453291178,
0.2555224299,
0.3938128352,
-1.2057621479,
0.4511154294,
0.2081375718,
0.1432249248,
-0.0618563667,
-0.7347932458,
-0.1518756002,
-0.3326041698,
-0.4456094801,
-1.0474914312,
0.5025179982,
-0.0529942214,
0.6220917702,
0.1980912089,
0.1577003002,
0.6072410941,
-0.6641805172,
0.8752702475,
0.1998913586,
-0.7622032762,
1.0136620998,
-0.3401624858,
0.7844551802,
0.5222423673,
0.2177957594,
-0.5223082304,
-0.8515520096,
-0.3322817087,
-0.9540044665,
0.6735631824,
0.0379833207,
0.0726690516,
0.0738092735,
0.1944108009,
0.2307964265,
0.0033689849,
0.1652790606,
-0.3249903023,
-0.0102080787,
-0.3805277944,
0.2265862226,
-0.2129654288,
-0.2048039734,
-0.1618872136,
0.4297084212,
-0.2798045278,
0.2157983035,
0.3875567317,
-0.1177710742,
-0.0853255689,
0.3265257478,
0.8980485201,
0.7977668643,
0.2034532279,
-0.3288186193,
0.2884937525,
-0.6068553925,
0.0776472017,
-0.135294944,
-0.2198753208,
0.5539938211,
0.5657014847,
0.6395158172,
-0.1043217629,
-0.6983610988,
0.4613807201,
-0.1530813277,
-0.0815567002,
0.0611876324,
0.2603790462,
-0.1896458715,
0.1409022659,
0.6561508775,
0.1329554766,
0.4671300948,
-0.1914431304,
0.2540588379,
0.1954312772,
-0.1569170803,
-0.1595567465,
0.4846211076,
0.3724730909,
-0.4623924196,
0.4654588103,
0.1144702062,
-0.217614159,
0.6914276481,
0.486954391,
0.8368117213,
-0.6131397486,
0.4269681573,
0.5332807302,
0.0294852834,
-0.0025422368,
0.0794197097,
0.1516657025,
-0.1035082638,
-0.6957399845,
-0.1359711885,
-0.6304947138,
-0.2056005746,
-0.6311590075,
0.3719167411,
-0.237462461,
-0.1733845025,
-0.1537053883,
-0.4657274783,
-0.0972317681,
0.0619819313,
-0.1741797626,
0.9323590398,
-0.5601275563,
0.0384807028,
0.4184379876,
-0.2169959843,
-0.979306221,
-0.0416079685,
0.4639706016,
-0.867200017,
0.2920831144,
0.4290948212,
-0.0999332666,
-0.2387982756,
-0.1958443522,
-0.3057898581,
1.1499420404,
0.2718791068,
-0.5861949921,
-0.1271723509,
0.1287851036,
0.5533733964,
-0.4690954387,
0.6548908949,
0.6719287038,
0.261008054,
0.3695604503,
-1.2047243118,
0.2232510149,
-0.3228604794,
-0.1155887023,
0.2072336525,
-0.4554858804,
0.2170217633,
-0.4981609881,
-0.3145344257,
-0.0511081964,
0.3758763075,
0.2667554319,
0.5536341071,
0.2502235174,
-0.0096551208,
0.7082445025,
-0.0774336904,
1.1936634779,
-0.2056089342,
-0.0810914338,
1.0781913996,
-0.1891896129,
0.2983725965,
0.3419015408,
-0.045782268,
0.4563137591,
0.3566721678,
-0.1719041765,
0.3240301311,
-0.1401865035,
-0.3901107609,
0.1432498991,
-0.363828212,
-0.4351901412,
0.2622662783,
0.2638952732,
-0.6268358231,
-0.297845304,
0.1728811711,
0.0637641177,
-0.0748592541,
-0.3434349895,
1.3460429907,
0.0353177786,
-0.8771115541,
0.4535137713,
-0.3173418641,
0.3393250108,
-0.5522477627,
-0.0835248455,
-0.3121697307,
-0.2555477023,
-0.3242218196,
-0.7272250056,
0.5931687355,
0.1767199636,
-0.3731978238,
-0.4348003864,
0.5034486055,
-0.1521435827,
-0.3724341094,
-0.2781756818,
0.5475438833,
-0.026557127,
0.0260841362,
-0.5121649504,
-0.1223851219,
-0.1819009036,
-0.2749274671,
0.147993207,
0.2684964538,
-0.1198956445,
0.6660325527,
0.4089358151,
0.2029892057,
-0.3343832791,
0.5490346551,
0.9597370625,
-0.6465566158,
-0.6661219597,
-1.1772640944,
0.9193996787,
-0.1168601513,
-0.1076054871,
0.5483882427,
0.5356796384,
-0.0886920691,
-0.2621369958,
0.8157250881,
0.1885119528,
0.6596601605,
-0.5128793716,
0.7369681597,
-0.1832218915,
0.3152797818,
-0.2465436608,
-0.4480834901,
-0.6483617425,
0.1753269732,
0.0657113343,
-0.1192328483,
0.7367355227,
0.9477257133,
0.5025529265,
-0.0882118121,
0.1983329505,
0.032612972,
0.4487609863,
0.2208585441,
0.6580247879,
-0.1963076741,
0.5667724609,
0.1656199694,
-0.623072505,
-0.4918552041,
-0.7024615407,
-0.8780580163,
-0.2622860968,
-0.4073844552,
-0.2348397374,
-0.1724619418,
0.8598085046,
0.4946515858,
-0.7760525346,
0.095747225,
0.2250566334,
-0.1808244437,
-0.1216142774,
-0.3004681468,
0.3036339283,
-0.6817858815,
-0.4893896878,
0.4507384896,
0.8849266171,
0.2839932442,
0.0418020003,
-0.0795273334,
0.4215640724,
0.0729165673,
0.5887019634,
0.0465626307,
-0.572008729,
0.0476833992,
0.4632479548,
-0.2476833612,
0.3251273036,
1.1389197111,
-1.0376098156,
0.5505595207,
0.5395845175,
0.5968393683,
-0.033525873,
0.3084352911,
0.878937304,
-0.6432211399,
-0.0304640457,
0.5222079158,
0.0842793807,
0.1969236434,
-0.7055339813,
0.3575541079,
0.1276333779,
-0.6179924607,
-0.5711424947,
0.0643365383,
-0.9751651287,
-0.1314611584,
0.8249363899,
0.0617451631,
0.0280042645,
-0.3387544453,
-0.6859404445,
0.3432338238,
-0.5454157591,
0.9307550788,
0.3905258775,
-0.6685836911,
-0.1467926204,
-0.4316087961,
0.4898552001,
0.4173520505,
-1.0847270489,
-0.2085438818,
0.491139859,
0.0235766675,
0.0837922841,
0.773013711,
-0.2570272982,
0.7225194573,
-0.2992886305,
-0.5450265408,
-0.3256715238,
-0.2381482869,
-0.5744369626,
0.2366280258,
-0.4082249403,
-0.1882199347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13273v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13273v2
|
Comparative Experimentation of Accuracy Metrics in Automated Medical Reporting: The Case of Otitis Consultations
| 2023-11-22T09:51:43 | 2024-01-08T14:19:29 |
Wouter Faber, Renske Eline Bootsma, Tom Huibers, Sandra van Dulmen, Sjaak Brinkkemper
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) can be used to automatically generate
medical reports based on transcripts of medical consultations. The aim is to
reduce the administrative burden that healthcare professionals face. The
accuracy of the generated reports needs to be established to ensure their
correctness and usefulness. There are several metrics for measuring the
accuracy of AI generated reports, but little work has been done towards the
application of these metrics in medical reporting. A comparative
experimentation of 10 accuracy metrics has been performed on AI generated
medical reports against their corresponding General Practitioner's (GP) medical
reports concerning Otitis consultations. The number of missing, incorrect, and
additional statements of the generated reports have been correlated with the
metric scores. In addition, we introduce and define a Composite Accuracy Score
which produces a single score for comparing the metrics within the field of
automated medical reporting. Findings show that based on the correlation study
and the Composite Accuracy Score, the ROUGE-L and Word Mover's Distance metrics
are the preferred metrics, which is not in line with previous work. These
findings help determine the accuracy of an AI generated medical report, which
aids the development of systems that generate medical reports for GPs to reduce
the administrative burden.
|
[
0.0154609932,
-0.6082997918,
0.7731596231,
0.1688185334,
0.0558949374,
-0.0790987089,
-0.0571108721,
-0.8230353594,
0.4978134632,
0.0640774891,
-0.0962093174,
-0.6218372583,
-0.676441431,
0.3998548985,
-0.5288430452,
0.6906610727,
-0.0042164722,
0.5147619843,
-0.2572360933,
-0.5691530108,
-0.6437602639,
-0.2175735533,
-0.9053242803,
-0.1353322715,
0.2988339365,
0.0406483039,
0.7758920789,
0.5875428915,
1.0267066956,
0.4176417887,
0.1366628259,
0.4920214415,
0.124507159,
-0.1086996272,
0.039515689,
-0.6304274201,
-0.7448493242,
0.2858171463,
0.4731134176,
0.5278961658,
-0.3926020563,
0.1669921577,
-0.1660866439,
0.6490224004,
-0.3602031171,
0.0542869493,
-0.1751933694,
0.2732145786,
-0.2007454336,
-0.4625839591,
-0.2474226356,
-0.5788874626,
0.194700703,
-0.8598576784,
0.4258052409,
0.3396528959,
0.6787340641,
0.3736627996,
-0.1921392381,
-0.6909704208,
-0.8158588409,
0.5239080787,
-0.8793195486,
0.0868318304,
0.4307534397,
0.3151853383,
0.1951087415,
-0.714730978,
-0.3784462214,
-0.4969308078,
-0.4248557687,
0.4513117373,
-0.3589144647,
0.0047616935,
0.0646042526,
0.4122014046,
-0.585295558,
0.2266056985,
-0.6151346564,
-0.1871656775,
0.9345540404,
0.6044469476,
0.4636475742,
0.1327428669,
0.134875223,
-0.1363700479,
-0.5136506557,
-0.1655790806,
0.0662589073,
-0.0427856594,
-0.2643370926,
0.5635137558,
-0.2335436344,
0.3879362941,
0.4073058963,
-0.7259132266,
0.4437397122,
-0.2820449471,
-0.252490133,
0.1638196409,
1.1424723864,
0.797393024,
0.1310488284,
-0.534850359,
-0.2106548697,
0.3625713289,
0.6565303802,
-0.2972517908,
-0.2418972999,
0.2858348787,
-0.5759551525,
-0.4082649052,
0.1725536436,
-0.3982526064,
-0.1882860065,
-0.5382087827,
0.2746296227,
-0.5767680407,
0.0139861181,
-0.1347281933,
0.0798440203,
-0.136912778,
0.6433517933,
-0.553986311,
0.4797536433,
0.5637122989,
0.8674704432,
-0.5249284506,
-0.2839305997,
-0.5189161897,
0.0387809388,
-0.8949918747,
0.8903886676,
-0.2526959777,
-0.64130193,
0.0551894903,
-0.4227515757,
-0.1205137447,
-1.2600325346,
0.3981173635,
-0.0556356795,
0.413854748,
0.1686434597,
-0.5472414494,
-0.1843341142,
0.2089270651,
-0.5207304358,
0.8155528903,
0.4241733551,
-0.4095399976,
0.7430830598,
-0.9847313166,
-0.5139496326,
0.1225290224,
-0.3324504793,
-0.294239819,
0.1152427718,
0.027016528,
-0.0285727624,
-0.5344563723,
0.20458363,
0.2706804872,
-0.1825229675,
0.1500213742,
-0.3609326482,
0.7680354118,
-0.0873304382,
-0.2917946279,
0.1184890419,
-0.6055194139,
0.1447084695,
-0.0832691118,
-0.4230764508,
-0.2364478707,
-0.0857005119,
-0.3240363598,
-0.3925799131,
-0.1454606354,
-0.4801295102,
0.0443098582,
-0.2976966798,
0.0232967623,
0.2883980274,
-0.1311382651,
0.2320615798,
-0.8401226997,
0.4744146168,
0.032424137,
0.3102521002,
0.0803312734,
-0.6245225072,
-0.383030653,
-0.2564195395,
0.6749420762,
0.9149176478,
-0.4865116179,
0.5880144238,
-0.5433712602,
-0.5989969373,
-0.937038362,
0.0106626162,
0.3417416811,
0.9895184636,
0.216682896,
-0.6846811175,
-0.1950390786,
-0.6154218316,
-0.2216833532,
-0.4133464694,
-0.3100114465,
0.4656946361,
0.1999581456,
-0.2361292392,
0.9457947016,
-0.3580783606,
-0.7807295918,
0.1331978887,
0.5405796766,
-0.1149894744,
0.4772391617,
1.1021616459,
-0.6222499609,
-0.7850133181,
-0.0164768863,
-0.8954529762,
-0.2030168176,
0.0149921533,
0.3044135571,
0.5566388965,
0.2847859263,
-0.5417885184,
0.7882553339,
0.4366181493,
-0.1650945693,
0.7343376279,
-0.49613747,
0.7396919727,
-0.7637340426,
0.4029845595,
0.1034696475,
-0.3536177874,
-0.5271915197,
-0.0795497671,
-0.1016502082,
0.3803338706,
-0.3551305234,
0.403712213,
-0.0603263527,
0.1987192035,
0.176264599,
0.0901755318,
-0.1489315033,
0.01695312,
-0.2391593754,
0.9685665369,
0.3636549115,
-0.6250399351,
0.73058635,
0.2381020933,
-0.4519246519,
0.9640480876,
-0.504963398,
0.0779510587,
0.2922003567,
-0.0295655411,
-0.7038213611,
-0.2755117416,
0.5174343586,
-0.6933131218,
0.3285761178,
0.3728087544,
-0.5579224229,
-0.341314733,
-0.1981988847,
0.4829765856,
0.6550812721,
-0.1074385494,
0.4462476969,
0.3885597289,
-0.5081182718,
-0.3268179595,
-0.8215883374,
0.080583021,
-0.2462067306,
-0.3405615985,
0.4473012388,
-0.0717244148,
-0.546199739,
0.346091181,
-0.0800928995,
-0.044842042,
-0.2736074626,
0.188526541,
0.3036261499,
-0.7467626929,
-0.0443796962,
-0.2084983587,
-0.1679477841,
0.3316021264,
0.2256508768,
0.2402325124,
-0.0514211841,
-0.7486137748,
-0.9376524091,
0.3843026459,
0.5956029892,
0.1414623857,
0.6439536214,
0.2353048325,
-0.2588587403,
0.5335878134,
-0.815266788,
-0.093392998,
-0.4252068102,
0.0364479497,
0.1913820207,
-0.1117105857,
0.6387214661,
0.0311399195,
0.1652003974,
0.9061746597,
0.3411836028,
-0.2454553992,
1.1108742952,
0.2930309772,
-0.235585168,
0.1725923568,
-0.079633221,
0.1202484518,
-0.5018967986,
-0.2531830072,
-0.6399754286,
-0.096966289,
-0.4800225496,
-0.0391009264,
0.8587693572,
-0.2763073444,
0.0377874002,
-0.2288724333,
-0.6055717468,
0.3387427926,
0.7686107755,
0.213718012,
0.4320878088,
0.0511592925,
-0.0327720717,
0.0217957925,
-0.7930826545,
-0.3625165522,
1.0505576134,
-0.0501846373,
0.4507421255,
0.1256330907,
0.4723044336,
0.7400867343,
0.849164784,
-0.8065773845,
0.161047712,
-0.4689339995,
-0.192828089,
-0.412163496,
-0.4659861624,
-0.9048849344,
-0.0253323559,
-0.2783917189,
-0.7124194503,
-0.4317521751,
0.2377869934,
-0.7431074977,
0.2456545085,
-0.714599371,
0.4447358251,
-0.2602769732,
0.2181569785,
-0.3274439275,
-0.6751450896,
0.0049317102,
-0.0880114064,
0.2157900035,
0.1973442882,
-0.0343494266,
0.9838169813,
-0.5424210429,
0.693025291,
0.1195966378,
-0.1478589177,
0.27876091,
-0.0581371859,
0.1819852293,
-0.1252144128,
-0.0001067909,
0.3097764254,
0.1209752932,
0.0002848286,
-0.4183816314,
0.2104286849,
-0.5840985179,
-0.7499359846,
-0.6124852896,
-0.7075569034,
-0.1652541757,
0.124267377,
0.4378533065,
0.8123160005,
-0.3488925695,
-0.0572183579,
0.1368145496,
-0.0567921177,
0.1979551613,
0.6140468121,
0.1618117243,
-0.6116623282,
0.6680803895,
0.3261952996,
0.0373548046,
0.3031297028,
0.123463735,
-0.2016907632,
-0.5891796947,
-0.5965798497,
0.1612928808,
-0.484105736,
-0.486769259,
-0.264890641,
-0.5839450359,
-0.6141159534,
-0.0494721122,
-0.2154248506,
-0.1200858355,
-0.2458796948,
0.2707393765,
0.3415797651,
0.8369412422,
-0.2327186167,
0.3675439358,
-0.8918340206,
0.4079415798,
0.0609580502,
0.2005918473,
0.0067464877,
-0.3062857091,
-0.1479085237,
0.2285411358,
-0.6251122952,
-0.6656146646,
0.482645601,
0.0934852734,
0.5732565522,
0.7640202045,
0.1210857481,
0.8792898059,
-0.623354435,
0.8144894242,
0.5270357132,
-0.8427616954,
0.4895320237,
-0.0701956525,
0.0129861608,
0.4156036079,
0.2408240139,
-0.4227083623,
-0.8385400772,
-0.7495831251,
-0.6623275876,
0.6651929021,
0.1069879904,
-0.1568722427,
0.0739205331,
0.3301775455,
0.2636729181,
0.0205516554,
0.0276704542,
-0.3622100949,
0.4966905117,
-0.4476080239,
-0.1594509035,
0.1151773632,
-0.6286832094,
-0.2783115506,
0.4103565514,
-0.008411468,
0.2549066246,
0.5652350187,
0.1639354527,
-0.3534787297,
-0.08953356,
0.7800590396,
1.1581010818,
0.0654592961,
-0.0254730787,
0.4104911387,
-0.9034665823,
0.0713428557,
-0.3023697734,
-0.1845335364,
0.53445822,
0.6029019356,
0.2898774147,
-0.3512127399,
-0.6600558758,
0.4201468825,
-0.0479957163,
-0.4229662418,
-0.4663318396,
0.0925740004,
-0.2254514694,
0.0220352449,
0.3588992655,
0.4239292443,
0.2691112757,
-0.4959293008,
0.0929825678,
0.3730178773,
-0.2098548412,
-0.1067723259,
0.6264359355,
0.3120917678,
-0.7343555093,
0.8193551302,
-0.0752345473,
-0.184902817,
0.8403893113,
0.43252334,
0.5711355805,
-0.4214738607,
0.2388094366,
0.2199072093,
0.0653142184,
-0.1297432631,
-0.0104889106,
0.1490039825,
-0.3514598906,
-0.2253677249,
-0.1207897663,
-0.6621212959,
0.1743373126,
-0.9794558287,
-0.0647647381,
-0.2382519692,
-0.4746339917,
0.2039013654,
-0.1554358304,
-0.420145601,
0.4110988081,
-0.2759630084,
0.7967614532,
-0.5766323805,
0.2241810113,
0.7761306167,
-0.2462655902,
-0.6308703423,
0.2775811851,
0.2629791796,
-0.9245309234,
0.3870638013,
-0.0108818412,
-0.1400652081,
-0.5527903438,
-0.2325826734,
-0.4506354332,
1.1508504152,
0.2305846214,
-0.5035631657,
0.1114921942,
0.4418354332,
0.7986645103,
-0.3430375457,
0.4032245278,
0.5107334852,
0.1681917161,
-0.1565997452,
-1.5631896257,
0.034385033,
-0.2336929888,
-0.3772792816,
0.1757314354,
-0.5033359528,
0.4834104776,
-0.2503546476,
-0.2801475823,
0.4912348092,
0.1906612962,
0.0548722297,
0.747072041,
0.4407401979,
0.5241174102,
0.8722854853,
-0.0828098059,
1.1610968113,
-0.5847088695,
0.0015390567,
0.8742123842,
-0.2758052051,
0.6069598198,
0.366704911,
-0.2523737848,
0.2164666355,
0.3538628221,
-0.1501872838,
0.4132356346,
-0.0676963329,
-0.2306132019,
0.3086611927,
-0.082621865,
-0.4505911469,
0.1152584553,
0.300504446,
-0.460862875,
0.1366940737,
-0.278192997,
-0.1261503994,
-0.0693277046,
-0.2667177916,
1.2473124266,
-0.0051201521,
-0.9183484316,
0.4379881024,
0.049901139,
0.4150409102,
-0.5006510615,
0.1083677784,
-0.1653496921,
0.253577739,
-0.2468545437,
-0.6501368284,
0.7326542139,
0.2006231844,
-0.1702062041,
0.0194145534,
0.1657694131,
-0.1423556358,
-0.2889212072,
-0.0642720684,
0.5940753818,
0.1661276817,
0.1643720418,
-0.3603384197,
-0.4566803575,
-0.3089749813,
0.2841544151,
0.0950418413,
0.5057715774,
0.0790301934,
0.6231740117,
0.4669813514,
0.6829557419,
0.0228759646,
-0.0385338217,
0.4826823771,
-0.3036930859,
-0.5519726276,
-0.7292218208,
0.2583772838,
-0.2230166346,
-0.5756208301,
0.4196983576,
0.7949231267,
0.6088908315,
-0.2616500854,
0.7917075753,
-0.2022511065,
0.6894026995,
-0.7033209205,
0.8383430243,
-0.6306403875,
0.0295091216,
-0.0061252001,
-0.4743097425,
-0.4698278606,
0.3477355838,
-0.1770586073,
-0.1173549742,
0.8100815415,
0.7970685363,
-0.147281453,
-0.0933001265,
0.1576777995,
0.2735871971,
-0.0215674154,
0.1887959093,
0.6212022305,
-0.3252506256,
0.2970029712,
-0.2865891755,
-0.2371115834,
-0.3850085735,
-0.3606556654,
-0.5273727179,
-0.4442264736,
-0.5580503941,
-0.2985800803,
0.2499108016,
0.5496820211,
0.730656445,
-1.0291186571,
-0.039656911,
0.097939454,
-0.3065361083,
-0.4877194166,
-0.234230265,
0.6396833062,
-0.2779876292,
-0.6259830594,
-0.0916688815,
0.2740459442,
0.1314538121,
0.1417080015,
-0.2223200351,
0.3486317694,
-0.0679619908,
0.3687097132,
0.1700400114,
-0.9826606512,
-0.3442666531,
-0.1638499349,
-0.4654028416,
0.6438022852,
0.6928443909,
-0.5699748397,
0.2298374474,
0.2026271522,
0.4536184967,
-0.1008074433,
0.0739863664,
0.5880522728,
-0.4454570115,
-0.1411172897,
0.3119760752,
0.2005538046,
0.1755918413,
-0.4502717555,
0.8181369305,
0.2250625938,
-0.3978269696,
-0.6922945976,
-0.3964731395,
-0.8890739679,
0.1158200428,
0.8498692513,
-0.2062366903,
-0.0165105034,
0.0007178837,
-0.4699060321,
0.2845353484,
-0.3511554301,
1.3218290806,
0.3307462335,
-0.550275445,
0.3542482257,
-0.5796692371,
0.6515203118,
0.5237548351,
-0.848729074,
-0.5580099225,
0.2520060837,
0.4688451588,
0.7800849676,
0.6964866519,
-0.2460857481,
0.6252740026,
0.3389123976,
-0.4229053259,
0.1210534796,
-0.1141398922,
0.0854939446,
0.0272419546,
-0.2460995466,
-0.4435357153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13258v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13258v1
|
ViStruct: Visual Structural Knowledge Extraction via Curriculum Guided Code-Vision Representation
| 2023-11-22T09:23:34 | 2023-11-22T09:23:34 |
Yangyi Chen, Xingyao Wang, Manling Li, Derek Hoiem, Heng Ji
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
State-of-the-art vision-language models (VLMs) still have limited performance
in structural knowledge extraction, such as relations between objects. In this
work, we present ViStruct, a training framework to learn VLMs for effective
visual structural knowledge extraction. Two novel designs are incorporated.
First, we propose to leverage the inherent structure of programming language to
depict visual structural information. This approach enables explicit and
consistent representation of visual structural information of multiple
granularities, such as concepts, relations, and events, in a well-organized
structured format. Second, we introduce curriculum-based learning for VLMs to
progressively comprehend visual structures, from fundamental visual concepts to
intricate event structures. Our intuition is that lower-level knowledge may
contribute to complex visual structure understanding. Furthermore, we compile
and release a collection of datasets tailored for visual structural knowledge
extraction. We adopt a weakly-supervised approach to directly generate visual
event structures from captions for ViStruct training, capitalizing on abundant
image-caption pairs from the web. In experiments, we evaluate ViStruct on
visual structure prediction tasks, demonstrating its effectiveness in improving
the understanding of visual structures. The code is public at
\url{https://github.com/Yangyi-Chen/vi-struct}.
|
[
0.1199562028,
-0.5224145055,
0.4021889865,
-0.1048010811,
-0.2219653577,
0.1189792678,
-0.001520594,
-0.6148462892,
-0.0691033378,
0.436871022,
-0.2100989223,
-0.8232300282,
-0.2871273458,
-0.5584068298,
-0.2737722695,
0.6744856834,
0.0140594002,
0.3491594493,
-0.5539653301,
0.053632021,
-0.3558119833,
-0.2468530387,
0.152049616,
-0.0654287413,
0.3613223135,
0.3685849905,
0.0842107534,
0.7931032777,
0.4843125641,
0.2276028842,
-0.1329583526,
0.1438822746,
-0.6510819793,
-0.2358808517,
-0.1028450876,
-0.6502531171,
-0.4388406575,
-0.1302960515,
0.4082317948,
0.9257093668,
-0.0452134609,
0.3981516957,
0.282744199,
0.883279562,
-0.6357365847,
0.8185425997,
-0.5304740071,
0.214375332,
-0.2037900835,
-0.2121434361,
-0.6509014368,
-0.198061198,
0.2800043523,
-0.5237856507,
0.0799740851,
0.1842287183,
0.9917730093,
0.2616198361,
-0.4469256103,
0.1821097583,
-0.2792781293,
0.6225783825,
-0.1150540039,
0.588363409,
0.1590661108,
0.4952218831,
0.138387695,
-0.8656339645,
0.0776021183,
-0.2562009096,
0.1913952678,
0.3142752647,
0.3733439744,
0.1828220189,
0.2273892313,
0.6026222706,
-0.6937164664,
-0.1224877387,
-1.169809103,
-0.1970540583,
0.4208756983,
0.1173258573,
0.4945572615,
-0.407122463,
-0.7289201617,
-0.0993503407,
-0.9769968987,
0.2517493367,
0.0864869282,
0.1711489558,
-0.3698123991,
0.7523087859,
-0.1846933514,
0.8004031181,
-0.1043016911,
-0.1278537363,
0.2584311366,
-0.0592957698,
-0.6041473746,
0.0117318034,
0.3293404877,
0.4115284681,
0.4505977631,
-0.1981961578,
0.1253037453,
0.0839205012,
0.5582575798,
-0.7378031015,
-0.6438655853,
-0.2282725722,
-0.7370332479,
-0.7160596848,
0.4294878244,
-0.5386785269,
-0.4023407102,
-0.5870774388,
0.2850230336,
-0.4551786184,
-0.0096267732,
0.22187756,
-0.526483655,
0.6210596561,
0.5704740882,
-0.4166197479,
0.0316409767,
0.306673497,
0.6623862982,
-0.4630558789,
0.0070735072,
-0.755377233,
0.3405644894,
-0.1377125531,
0.6328606009,
-0.4609405398,
-0.0996715128,
0.0787430927,
0.0037243331,
0.2790495455,
-0.385494411,
-0.2344397157,
-0.5566324592,
-0.0537416115,
-0.0108271744,
-0.5065177083,
-0.3534920514,
0.2807580531,
-0.5535011888,
0.5823019743,
0.2286556065,
-0.8082307577,
0.3900399208,
-0.1539399624,
-0.6648327708,
0.2902415097,
-0.7941911817,
-0.3557348251,
0.2936829925,
0.0857252553,
0.5394129157,
0.0080951853,
0.0744481236,
-0.4192121923,
-0.1625474393,
-0.3055636883,
-0.127096653,
0.8815175295,
0.0842921585,
-0.3283119798,
0.3001439869,
-1.1680852175,
-0.0065925862,
0.2127096504,
-0.4907138944,
-0.2379197478,
0.223348394,
-0.0382123925,
-0.2270230502,
0.2535506487,
-0.2783207893,
0.4492934942,
-0.6875750422,
0.1282629371,
0.8876140118,
0.1170922294,
0.6626339555,
0.1641214192,
0.4491221011,
0.1687697768,
0.229705438,
0.0338886939,
-0.2187318802,
-0.6625780463,
-0.232690528,
-0.2833721638,
0.3450850248,
-1.3493453264,
-0.409491092,
-0.1234423593,
-0.3843114376,
0.2118922174,
0.238928616,
0.5939252973,
0.6199469566,
0.5539776683,
-0.5141981244,
-0.8752400279,
-0.7652893066,
0.0754378662,
-0.3727083206,
0.1401381046,
0.1416332424,
0.4543194175,
0.0047466881,
0.8836494088,
-1.1049574614,
-0.2978415489,
-0.3872151077,
0.0358003303,
-0.0904988125,
0.2759308219,
0.5770770907,
-0.9399113059,
-0.3735755384,
0.1941190958,
-1.145414114,
0.3013323247,
0.1201424971,
-0.1526598632,
-0.1825511754,
0.7642027736,
0.1035770476,
0.7259715796,
0.1444723457,
-0.0676839873,
0.9018411636,
0.1473826319,
-0.2679890096,
-0.9140374064,
-0.1918226182,
-0.1102614179,
-0.2166663706,
-0.2582080662,
0.2337548882,
0.1917467564,
-0.113268964,
-0.7689213157,
0.2857764065,
-0.9509452581,
-0.137613982,
0.0610920265,
-0.0428004377,
-0.0338341445,
0.7351182699,
0.1716186553,
0.4753655493,
0.9528199434,
-0.618758738,
0.4979338348,
0.3084052503,
-0.6975462437,
0.4854470789,
-0.5123769045,
-0.1838638484,
-0.3168541193,
-0.3877242208,
-0.6956831217,
-0.3932757676,
0.2440848351,
-0.4350602627,
0.5179039836,
-0.6905964613,
0.0817011595,
-0.2989141047,
-0.4092493951,
0.2283447534,
0.2694202662,
-0.4969479144,
0.5889562368,
0.5872791409,
0.2073334754,
-0.71464926,
-0.7415192723,
-0.1656517684,
0.1117793694,
-0.4272259474,
0.0571563244,
-0.0828309283,
-0.2134404331,
0.2199430913,
-0.5495756865,
-0.3991716802,
0.0838119015,
0.7013869286,
0.5212664008,
-0.543289423,
0.0807032883,
-0.1225351915,
0.1284915805,
0.0127125904,
-0.7030656934,
0.2113371789,
-0.4887932241,
-0.5221879482,
-0.1528598219,
-0.0815821514,
0.5557581186,
-0.6234225035,
0.4674269855,
0.4810996056,
-0.3848314583,
-0.4032757282,
-0.2889814973,
-0.0327352434,
-0.4675435722,
0.6528272629,
-0.449354738,
-0.6523246169,
0.0429072417,
-0.1235896721,
0.0908241794,
0.1103996262,
0.4199915528,
-0.4321298301,
0.5690908432,
1.1671358347,
0.0241404288,
0.9241716266,
-0.5480700135,
-0.2697686255,
-0.5549909472,
-0.5543943644,
-0.0666881427,
-0.0040093609,
0.0988719612,
-0.6372257471,
0.2089526057,
0.1240611821,
0.0100697931,
0.5853968263,
-0.5562083125,
0.3519096076,
0.2808677554,
0.5476094484,
0.1269149482,
0.4087740779,
-0.0167850815,
-0.0008513539,
-0.6842287779,
-0.3639583588,
1.0376980305,
0.1169208363,
0.9274322391,
-0.1271950752,
0.7767874599,
0.2897212803,
0.3172766864,
-0.8893265724,
0.5123853683,
0.0681366175,
-0.3037492335,
-0.0448599197,
-0.5271706581,
-0.4998540282,
0.1385685056,
-0.047665894,
-0.7433423996,
0.4492443502,
0.1124784425,
0.0076322532,
0.2050076574,
-0.6989021897,
0.999758482,
-0.3138898611,
-0.4328319728,
-0.1503412127,
-0.7001854777,
0.3770641983,
0.4569728673,
0.2145226896,
0.2936660647,
0.4428427219,
0.4199237525,
-0.2051856816,
1.2448288202,
-0.1360774636,
-0.1020812616,
0.4373250008,
0.1442702562,
0.3453678191,
0.0937599689,
0.1827751249,
0.0411986932,
-0.0109093916,
-0.2256339788,
-0.3901391923,
0.0274345763,
-0.4086560905,
-0.3784897029,
-0.051233083,
-0.3324916363,
0.0383760929,
0.2105181962,
0.2465030849,
0.9426899552,
-0.3449757993,
0.4857002497,
0.674490571,
-0.2734670937,
0.0085764015,
0.1505497694,
-0.1321934611,
-0.3872962594,
1.1674667597,
-0.0474731475,
0.245699808,
0.715783,
-0.0810331404,
0.2838434279,
-0.5216069818,
-0.4349700212,
-0.0929665789,
-0.9528264403,
-0.3559326231,
-0.3863311112,
-0.3705501258,
-0.1944278181,
-0.4134090841,
-0.3699305654,
-0.2103961408,
-0.2667312026,
-0.3205905855,
-0.1363346875,
0.7483814955,
0.0628399029,
-0.1529793888,
-0.6022019386,
0.4491283894,
0.3291257322,
0.1556197405,
-0.0219811369,
-0.174043864,
-0.5657321215,
-0.2055495083,
-0.1630476266,
-0.9291417599,
0.1105358601,
0.1514156461,
0.7246550918,
0.6880298853,
0.0434789993,
0.8762550354,
-0.6465702057,
0.657828927,
0.4905834794,
-0.6724434495,
0.8876796365,
0.0878872424,
-0.0704840273,
0.3765774071,
0.15042606,
0.0825898275,
-0.5577169657,
-0.5072314143,
-0.7286944985,
0.5533366799,
0.0787244886,
-0.2832321227,
0.2878407836,
0.2680869997,
-0.0465435795,
0.2888611555,
-1.0278092623,
-0.0347211249,
-0.2736638188,
-0.538572073,
0.50264889,
-0.4396819472,
-0.0492201373,
-0.2781115174,
0.2015011609,
-0.3181744814,
0.0846838057,
0.1933204234,
-0.8656207323,
0.2792677581,
-0.2123266011,
0.3660069704,
0.819188118,
-0.1152123809,
0.4134432077,
0.07020998,
-0.5180187821,
-0.3138170838,
-0.3236534595,
-0.1027033255,
-0.3221045136,
0.8263263106,
0.5631441474,
0.4642884731,
-0.7108030915,
0.7280874848,
0.1374513805,
-0.2258262932,
-0.1812924445,
0.2422148287,
-0.1301580071,
0.5831518769,
0.1050589234,
0.0588461012,
0.3352899849,
-0.5882234573,
0.501665175,
0.2816130221,
-0.6996983886,
-0.433809787,
0.9426620007,
0.2286618352,
0.2705594897,
0.2886854708,
-0.0410420895,
-0.6193932891,
0.7962956429,
0.1673939526,
0.4787606895,
0.3204555511,
0.3002840281,
0.3972134292,
0.3365962803,
0.0849275962,
0.350515604,
-0.6243953705,
-0.4516421556,
-0.3651954532,
-0.7782903314,
-0.1823196411,
-0.3363856077,
-0.7503772378,
0.3363433778,
-0.4923214614,
0.4012501538,
-0.4046626389,
-0.161022976,
-0.6195229888,
0.0504757389,
0.5151685476,
0.6756623983,
-0.5965977907,
0.8453634381,
0.9943593144,
-0.9197989106,
-0.6786184907,
-0.2185879648,
0.3536761105,
-0.7735839486,
1.2122524977,
0.2218368798,
-0.2584156096,
-0.0957335308,
-0.9230261445,
-0.5462148786,
1.0142308474,
0.4515947998,
-0.3634084463,
-0.2528403997,
-0.2127795964,
0.2556405663,
-0.1605402529,
-0.4392079711,
-0.3062573671,
0.2814249396,
0.220176205,
-0.2540778518,
-0.1935106069,
-0.1492132396,
-0.0702411905,
-0.1470144242,
-0.206112653,
0.508441329,
-0.4681643844,
-0.4419168234,
-0.1997790486,
1.1310310364,
-0.0606162362,
0.1688335836,
0.2961756289,
0.1309596151,
0.5992017984,
0.1304232627,
0.747589767,
-0.1607804596,
0.3949146271,
1.2348788977,
0.0784826726,
0.6054871082,
0.4380437136,
0.1664497554,
0.5380957723,
0.2747584879,
-0.2380734235,
0.6327480078,
0.1702822298,
0.260109216,
-0.4112107754,
0.2457031906,
-0.3180691302,
0.55406636,
0.21619232,
-0.1515913904,
-0.2677818537,
0.2800546885,
-0.3192445338,
-0.0701531246,
-0.3308535218,
0.6185695529,
0.3397084773,
0.0117836948,
0.4150732458,
-0.3398864269,
0.0859577581,
-0.4580513239,
-0.2627652287,
-0.0250687357,
0.1905226409,
-0.3149294853,
-0.5085134506,
0.3901521862,
-0.0137382718,
-0.1898446083,
-0.4548246861,
0.8901212215,
-0.5446792245,
-0.3075854182,
0.1294397712,
0.4923205078,
0.0989334211,
-0.2203599811,
-0.1874670982,
-0.0153807681,
0.2865538001,
-0.124748446,
0.1201369762,
0.553845942,
0.0243971813,
0.5458868146,
0.4586864412,
0.1299622357,
0.0684003606,
0.135610491,
1.0423532724,
-0.5370970964,
-0.2138484865,
-0.7240040302,
0.8085003495,
-0.3680450618,
0.0590784177,
0.5958890319,
0.7602335811,
0.9098201394,
-0.4873297811,
0.3474621475,
-0.1544276774,
-0.4986596107,
-0.8590266109,
0.7020041943,
-0.9719913602,
0.0698511377,
-0.3618789613,
-0.8394785523,
-0.4579416811,
0.711602509,
-0.2204264104,
-0.6936013699,
0.7133690715,
0.6380994916,
-0.2273018956,
-0.3412995934,
0.3583397865,
0.3479473293,
0.4865704179,
0.6671301126,
0.7856975794,
-0.1891464293,
0.9129428864,
-0.0295847021,
-0.3346173465,
-0.4726418555,
-0.6316378117,
-1.2421002388,
-0.6453902721,
-0.4604591131,
0.0633224621,
0.1469590962,
0.4396692514,
0.9253253341,
-0.4445640743,
-0.209600538,
-0.2070957273,
0.4025953114,
-0.3724204004,
-0.2337850183,
0.5720494986,
-0.4514198601,
-0.3568206131,
0.6703373194,
0.7646970153,
0.077018775,
-0.0030539492,
0.1529423892,
0.1585273296,
-0.3724987805,
1.0428011417,
0.2740652859,
-0.3954159021,
-0.5338873863,
0.0501739644,
-0.3374106884,
0.2499334514,
0.5686119795,
-0.7402740121,
0.4252721965,
0.6803435683,
0.6108726263,
0.7656987906,
-0.2304247022,
0.5441105366,
-0.8763259053,
0.3192533553,
-0.0694043934,
0.5755480528,
-0.044440344,
-0.2905590832,
0.6572931409,
0.5312561393,
0.2639406323,
-0.8978688121,
0.5867469907,
-1.3262711763,
-0.4627960324,
0.8689648509,
-0.0235546995,
-0.6665151715,
-0.1009702161,
-0.4273886383,
0.2474955618,
0.2709592581,
0.5367044806,
0.3022373021,
0.2302796394,
-0.2922026217,
-0.5479744673,
0.2882269323,
-0.0849228203,
-0.7632659674,
-0.0041773152,
0.733184278,
0.1680757254,
0.0027461522,
0.2413870692,
-0.3546999097,
0.2730763853,
0.177673161,
0.4152108133,
-0.5764863491,
-0.7992050648,
0.2377446741,
0.6161650419,
-0.254078716,
-0.3951903582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14741v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14741v1
|
@ve: A Chatbot for Latin
| 2023-11-22T09:06:11 | 2023-11-22T09:06:11 |
Oliver Bendel, Karim N'diaye
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.RO, I.2; K.3
|
Dead, extinct, and endangered languages have been preserved primarily through
audio conservation and the collection and digitization of scripts and have been
promoted through targeted language acquisition efforts. Another possibility
would be to build conversational agents that can master these languages. This
would provide an artificial, active conversational partner which has knowledge
of the vocabulary and grammar, and one learns with it in a different way. The
chatbot @ve, with which one can communicate in Latin, was developed in
2022/2023 based on GPT-3.0. It was additionally equipped with a manually
created knowledge base. After conceptual groundwork, this paper presents the
preparation and implementation of the project. In addition, it summarizes the
test that a Latin expert conducted with the chatbot. A critical discussion
elaborates advantages and disadvantages. @ve could be a new tool for teaching
Latin in a memorable and entertaining way through dialogue. However, the
present implementation is still too prone to glitches for stand-alone use -
i.e., without the accompaniment of a teacher. The use of GPT-4 could be a
solution as well as the extension of the knowledge base. In conclusion, it can
be argued that conversational agents are an innovative approach to promoting
and preserving languages.
|
[
-0.1102518439,
-1.0863889456,
0.3814815879,
-0.0431398079,
-0.1401904672,
0.7872103453,
-0.3232336044,
-0.4739287794,
0.5895936489,
0.3881280124,
-0.1950206012,
-0.4366889298,
-0.2564317584,
0.1033715978,
-0.4623981118,
0.8139058352,
0.1231111214,
0.0629615337,
-0.1088494658,
0.1316848099,
-0.6305375099,
-0.6210030913,
-0.9454267025,
-0.0036114508,
0.3545468748,
0.4304377139,
0.7090488076,
0.5920030475,
0.4002856016,
0.4929810166,
-0.0128268292,
0.2781045139,
-0.636819005,
0.3553548157,
-0.1232005805,
-0.703096211,
-0.4611101151,
-0.0615650043,
0.7984133959,
0.4261310697,
0.1298553944,
-0.3438917398,
-0.3373299539,
0.4014306366,
-0.1441814005,
0.2558963299,
-0.8525130153,
-0.1106811166,
-0.0742049664,
-0.5256835818,
-0.2123979032,
-0.549156487,
0.0867717192,
-0.5506006479,
-0.0202845857,
0.0333667472,
0.753405869,
0.1952831894,
-0.045568049,
-0.1869041026,
-1.1567360163,
0.6061219573,
-0.0914876461,
0.1851498336,
0.4889054894,
0.6039891839,
-0.4177582264,
-0.8050826788,
-0.7236191034,
-0.2262955308,
0.1714691222,
0.3819031119,
-0.5881660581,
-0.1601723731,
-0.3141397536,
0.3860072792,
-0.4203980565,
-0.1560228169,
-0.7193518877,
-0.123476848,
0.2668051124,
0.0264729131,
0.4996189773,
0.0849550143,
-0.3887626231,
0.2729597986,
-0.99467206,
-0.4184378684,
0.6346058846,
0.333209604,
0.0566372536,
0.353741169,
0.2507686615,
0.5355392098,
-0.4826909006,
-0.0987986475,
0.1797608584,
-0.3367336094,
0.0736576468,
-0.2675881088,
0.6437456012,
0.1607426554,
0.7130569816,
-0.1635648757,
0.0950158462,
0.3537344038,
0.468455255,
-0.1207785606,
-0.0533166565,
0.0824248642,
0.1230356321,
-0.2478607893,
-0.3676155508,
-0.2519952357,
-0.0570226125,
-0.5026909113,
0.2183157355,
-0.8057177067,
-0.2824884355,
0.0869477689,
-0.3103026152,
0.1338723004,
0.8616588712,
-0.8183897734,
0.5364970565,
0.7547410131,
0.8213353157,
-0.2243179381,
-0.2784426808,
-0.3445522785,
0.0876300707,
-0.0676711872,
1.0147926807,
-0.7270145416,
-0.8071049452,
0.1464000493,
0.0728872046,
-0.1531681269,
-0.2296897769,
0.5811932683,
-0.3823286295,
0.5969911218,
0.081336543,
-0.5420530438,
-0.0539024249,
0.5265168548,
-0.2518907189,
0.87346977,
0.3861931264,
-0.5393036604,
-0.0486614108,
-0.4487090707,
-0.344094187,
0.7101653814,
-0.4860308766,
-0.066780977,
-0.3084554374,
-0.241975829,
0.0089219911,
-0.1048066169,
-0.1053423658,
-0.0085026855,
-0.5610803366,
0.1556285024,
-0.4020226598,
0.5927268267,
0.2599202096,
-0.2767842114,
-0.0652204081,
-0.3504873812,
-0.1123903021,
-0.0313935876,
-0.3035775125,
-0.3607029021,
0.1089691073,
-0.051445365,
-0.1563172936,
0.1091766506,
-0.5049370527,
0.3759054542,
-0.627086997,
0.4854039848,
0.6363689303,
0.0051014926,
0.3223101497,
-0.4815868437,
0.8743086457,
-0.6228561401,
0.2508155406,
-0.2730876803,
-0.6650354862,
-1.0336489677,
-0.3183729649,
0.0842451677,
0.9351451993,
-0.6514572501,
0.233319819,
-0.3683084846,
-0.6258161664,
-0.4201007485,
0.0494119115,
0.2564060092,
0.485005945,
0.2754254043,
-0.2143331766,
-0.6873481274,
-0.7290133238,
0.2212790549,
-0.7688612938,
0.0133948624,
0.2512622774,
0.4516284466,
-0.1679550558,
0.9497475624,
-0.1672382504,
-0.2843298912,
-0.4789394736,
-0.0919505358,
0.0220033471,
0.6537743211,
0.4613348842,
-0.7805371881,
-0.6011279225,
0.4076863229,
-0.7139216065,
0.2296469957,
0.2519315481,
-0.1087388545,
0.1605463028,
0.3973463178,
-0.436791569,
0.3037766218,
0.4240703881,
-0.0747154951,
0.4222265184,
-0.4671767056,
0.175516367,
-1.1433157921,
-0.0751382262,
-0.4037039876,
-0.3701633215,
-0.7215089202,
-0.3200981319,
-0.2772387564,
-0.1677858084,
-0.7429112196,
0.6892507672,
-0.3501055241,
0.0225337632,
-0.552605629,
0.3435172737,
-0.3559594452,
0.3252613246,
0.384576261,
0.836512506,
0.4882350862,
-0.4120548368,
0.5073149204,
0.3901742399,
0.2783199549,
0.9152063131,
-0.7432052493,
0.3053427935,
0.0236606244,
0.23411946,
-0.7587699294,
0.1071206033,
0.5138511658,
-0.8646332026,
0.3857903481,
-0.6127814054,
-0.1868247688,
-0.4604314864,
-0.1186253577,
-0.0831575617,
0.4950767457,
0.0518844202,
0.5167252421,
0.7514730692,
-0.503300488,
-0.4098095,
-0.2614026964,
0.5250022411,
-0.3379824162,
-0.800806582,
0.0310515277,
-0.2072801739,
-0.3974910676,
-0.0916660279,
0.260109067,
0.025285041,
0.203480348,
0.2683376074,
0.3890117407,
-0.1888229549,
0.301027,
-0.1131767333,
-0.3231139779,
-0.1996793151,
-0.4553500414,
0.6099014282,
-0.6995507479,
-0.4196722209,
-0.4652166665,
0.4020372629,
0.5242556334,
-0.2131028771,
0.2816779912,
0.4056992233,
-0.3160747886,
0.1085747257,
-0.5436896682,
-0.1136643216,
-0.4423063397,
0.0937258527,
-0.3502602279,
-0.9394655824,
0.4280078411,
-0.1232868731,
0.031088043,
0.1752272844,
0.6925913095,
-0.2141422331,
0.4700909853,
0.6473514438,
-0.1546194255,
0.670220077,
-0.4358933568,
0.0903278142,
-0.4104673266,
-0.0925344154,
-0.7656069994,
0.0649969205,
-0.5439857244,
-0.6001992822,
0.3104841113,
-0.4599345624,
0.0230461285,
0.6320682764,
-0.3062749207,
0.4749279022,
0.7614821792,
-0.0778471157,
0.392111361,
-0.0260111149,
0.2058121413,
-0.0229521208,
-0.4240222871,
-1.0500378609,
0.9182718396,
0.3313661218,
0.6613117456,
0.1116734222,
0.6326184273,
0.6046893001,
0.221799925,
-0.6442072392,
0.4047716856,
0.1849696487,
-0.8037352562,
-0.4611277282,
-0.0943740681,
-1.1012496948,
0.2838471532,
-0.0686148629,
-1.0225749016,
-0.0765518099,
0.2630901039,
-0.1954278052,
-0.0617987625,
-0.9511019588,
0.9203910828,
-0.3345628083,
-0.5997092128,
-0.1691841781,
-0.8321133852,
-0.0325009227,
0.0212540757,
0.2811072767,
0.0040678396,
0.0968592092,
0.284715414,
-0.3355883658,
0.9432221055,
-0.1070939451,
0.1838178784,
0.5055623055,
0.1255349368,
0.5121446252,
0.2493821979,
0.1077730134,
-0.2883726954,
-0.0017471304,
-0.3650166094,
-0.5475272536,
0.5686619878,
-0.955516696,
-0.8060884476,
-0.3451369405,
-0.2122520953,
-0.0850466713,
0.2051542401,
-0.2879749238,
0.0746819451,
-0.8073698878,
0.0836056098,
0.574585855,
-0.2490168959,
0.0732236728,
0.8164786696,
0.0204957239,
-0.4077062905,
1.1856540442,
-0.1186108962,
0.3374836743,
0.4348431826,
0.150872916,
-0.18800053,
-0.5447009206,
-0.482478261,
0.2772384882,
-0.4947634339,
0.052761171,
-0.9049729705,
-0.1272488683,
-0.4026566148,
-0.3786935508,
-0.5734437108,
-0.4852173328,
-0.2649639845,
-0.2341389656,
0.3303866684,
0.7192894816,
-0.0974953845,
0.5283160806,
-0.5286433101,
-0.2419003695,
0.3028181493,
-0.2600370646,
-0.7408818007,
-0.3470518291,
-0.0747814327,
0.1541927755,
-0.3502684832,
-0.6882683039,
0.4735457301,
0.3264257014,
0.7894065976,
0.3011533022,
-0.075725399,
0.2910295427,
-0.466593802,
0.5430481434,
-0.1554793119,
-0.7148666978,
0.7993538976,
-0.8041628599,
-0.0307948571,
0.4928501546,
0.2847229838,
-0.8473844528,
-1.1144119501,
-0.9452755451,
-0.6288152337,
0.6670406461,
0.6524923444,
0.6909389496,
-0.1165937409,
-0.0782533213,
0.1963233501,
0.2564304769,
-0.4227634072,
-0.2109995335,
-0.3372991383,
0.1426108479,
-0.0790435225,
0.0216632243,
-0.231405735,
-0.2206328064,
0.7338452339,
-0.038869597,
0.4970625639,
-0.2199514359,
-0.0624822825,
0.0145502137,
0.2719326615,
0.6601676345,
0.6205595732,
-0.2787255347,
0.1666618735,
0.1304664612,
-0.6172609925,
0.0463244356,
0.2290426195,
-0.1440501064,
-0.0069195321,
0.128123343,
0.696480751,
0.2115354538,
-0.4732897878,
0.4852270186,
-0.2775081098,
-0.0905865654,
-1.0000287294,
0.1910177171,
0.2785639167,
0.1360826194,
0.2452293634,
0.015957972,
-0.1317000985,
-0.6836508512,
0.3092542291,
0.3044240475,
-0.5220876336,
-0.5541370511,
0.6098100543,
0.6082195044,
-0.6870888472,
0.5296274424,
-0.0745608956,
-0.9292323589,
0.3838191926,
0.6486009955,
0.535476625,
-0.1817808151,
0.5238719583,
0.2202986181,
0.3093411326,
0.1941519082,
0.4508039057,
-0.1084766164,
-0.848637104,
0.0028043312,
-0.3221140504,
-0.8499393463,
-0.1320934147,
0.0765393972,
0.474075228,
-0.1360043883,
-0.1347012967,
0.1287102997,
0.0525881909,
-0.5448547006,
-0.1651360393,
-0.0268549491,
0.6226660013,
-0.8542064428,
0.9202358723,
0.736929059,
-0.605887413,
-0.4007844329,
-0.651496172,
0.1232856512,
-1.1225221157,
0.4938364923,
-0.3414461315,
-0.3022397161,
0.24664478,
-0.4916042686,
-0.7051460147,
0.7342265248,
0.4576826096,
-0.079480283,
0.3162857294,
0.0803178325,
0.9134808779,
-0.2948450446,
0.5015266538,
0.4065004587,
0.6104695797,
0.4629546106,
-0.8915607333,
-0.438898474,
-0.6605327725,
-0.3371478915,
0.0602030866,
-0.5219255686,
0.6355409622,
0.0034876312,
-0.3878503442,
0.1998837292,
0.8136245608,
-0.1719626486,
-0.0877225772,
0.3256678283,
0.0827062503,
0.7347358465,
-0.2805504799,
0.8548076749,
-0.3796803951,
-0.0107046468,
1.0901474953,
-0.2020671219,
0.5837963223,
0.554715395,
-0.3974893093,
0.3008327186,
0.4750412703,
-0.0567143671,
0.0127260825,
0.4874171317,
-0.5682269931,
-0.2663479447,
-0.2389929593,
-0.4840815365,
0.6923584342,
0.6557059884,
-0.2952934504,
-0.1477016658,
-0.0706143305,
0.5041380525,
0.2974059284,
0.4253336489,
0.5150837302,
-0.1782634407,
-0.7424541712,
0.4503834248,
-0.3737107813,
0.1727247834,
-0.5989480019,
-0.2182327807,
-0.4735887349,
0.2751130462,
0.1404524446,
-0.5238500834,
0.234516263,
0.0038632948,
0.3149791956,
-0.4027860463,
0.8402064443,
-0.4806889296,
-0.3628004193,
0.0365824923,
1.0138232708,
0.6950950027,
0.1276683807,
-0.3650847375,
0.1654169112,
-0.0833388567,
0.1091838479,
-0.0544280373,
0.4477615952,
-0.2597341239,
0.8477464318,
0.5475760102,
0.2075655013,
-0.0875071809,
0.244235903,
1.1552929878,
-0.361379534,
-0.3474311829,
-0.5469096303,
0.4013489187,
-0.1341577917,
-0.3951961398,
0.9514123201,
0.6797535419,
0.6724419594,
-0.0356549509,
1.058904171,
-0.1976244897,
0.6717251539,
-0.0694711953,
0.6316927671,
-0.3429777026,
0.2505510151,
-0.572108686,
-0.6438474655,
-0.3791988194,
0.6534385681,
-0.1408772469,
-0.2201264054,
0.704488039,
0.7388198972,
0.2666591704,
0.2702303827,
0.5046743155,
-0.1028753743,
0.6132836342,
0.4029245675,
1.3044804335,
-0.2179292142,
0.713508904,
0.0771166757,
-0.5057097077,
-0.2163026035,
-0.4522665143,
-0.8910384774,
-0.7043884993,
-0.1809174269,
-0.1045313329,
0.7748346329,
0.812514782,
0.4651418328,
-0.5108790398,
-0.4076348543,
-0.101517126,
0.2873185873,
-0.0092260297,
-0.0350181721,
0.2163586915,
-0.4311451018,
-1.2996706963,
0.7029231787,
0.3642017245,
0.4966599345,
-0.4890698791,
-0.2041355819,
-0.2122390419,
-0.2763807774,
0.387344718,
0.9149525762,
-0.2991758585,
-0.5669624209,
0.3043343127,
-0.020963246,
0.0427323915,
0.6706086993,
-0.769089222,
0.6619015336,
0.3429788053,
0.507371068,
0.5776029229,
-0.1736119837,
1.2393321991,
-0.332046628,
0.1914075166,
0.4827289581,
0.3326533735,
0.3705155253,
-0.0026172856,
0.729778707,
0.6671737432,
-0.5935189724,
-0.5900105834,
0.0944489613,
-0.992891252,
0.1839212924,
1.2859573364,
-0.2516599596,
-0.2009574473,
-0.7425140142,
-0.6458815336,
0.2753517926,
-0.6539351344,
0.7152545452,
0.5201000571,
0.1193417758,
-0.0270744115,
-0.5892848372,
0.4148102701,
0.0804815963,
-0.8934955597,
-0.1175377741,
0.5797221065,
0.0772887096,
0.2196938097,
0.9554962516,
-0.1138000488,
0.3362714946,
0.1047519296,
0.1034907997,
-0.000703411,
-0.2935945988,
0.2671156526,
-0.081517823,
0.1746347398,
-0.441452384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13246v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13246v2
|
CoachLM: Automatic Instruction Revisions Improve the Data Quality in LLM Instruction Tuning
| 2023-11-22T09:04:57 | 2024-03-21T03:50:32 |
Yilun Liu, Shimin Tao, Xiaofeng Zhao, Ming Zhu, Wenbing Ma, Junhao Zhu, Chang Su, Yutai Hou, Miao Zhang, Min Zhang, Hongxia Ma, Li Zhang, Hao Yang, Yanfei Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction tuning is crucial for enabling Language Learning Models (LLMs) in
responding to human instructions. The quality of instruction pairs used for
tuning greatly affects the performance of LLMs. However, the manual creation of
high-quality instruction datasets is costly, leading to the adoption of
automatic generation of instruction pairs by LLMs as a popular alternative. To
ensure the high quality of LLM-generated instruction datasets, several
approaches have been proposed. Nevertheless, existing methods either compromise
dataset integrity by filtering a large proportion of samples, or are unsuitable
for industrial applications. In this paper, instead of discarding low-quality
samples, we propose CoachLM, a novel approach to enhance the quality of
instruction datasets through automatic revisions on samples in the dataset.
CoachLM is trained from the samples revised by human experts and significantly
increases the proportion of high-quality samples in the dataset from 17.7% to
78.9%. The effectiveness of CoachLM is further assessed on various real-world
instruction test sets. The results show that CoachLM improves the
instruction-following capabilities of the instruction-tuned LLM by an average
of 29.9%, which even surpasses larger LLMs with nearly twice the number of
parameters. Furthermore, CoachLM is successfully deployed in a data management
system for LLMs at Huawei, resulting in an efficiency improvement of up to 20%
in the cleaning of 40k real-world instruction pairs. We release various assets
of CoachLM, including the training data, code and test set
(https://github.com/lunyiliu/CoachLM).
|
[
-0.3259097636,
-0.5275034904,
-0.2018398494,
0.0713394731,
-0.2104196697,
0.2403044254,
-0.1446246803,
-0.2992272377,
-0.2146404833,
0.6694997549,
-0.5758383274,
-0.7787716389,
-0.2115674168,
-0.0994523466,
-0.4274637997,
0.9475085139,
-0.0416448899,
0.4112002552,
-0.1758870333,
-0.0331710428,
-0.6242640018,
-0.2508476675,
-0.896613121,
-0.4519406259,
0.3356437087,
0.5689572096,
0.4772610962,
1.064273715,
0.4716990888,
0.2705589533,
0.1502056569,
0.6729006767,
-0.4839686751,
0.4320610166,
0.0757529512,
-0.5083401203,
-0.8003789783,
-0.010990547,
0.5960893035,
0.5244787931,
-0.3047198057,
0.3149502873,
0.4844924212,
0.9788903594,
-0.2620271444,
0.1959958524,
-0.8607597947,
-0.0654874444,
-0.0169732142,
-0.435490936,
-0.469370544,
-0.5510579348,
-0.4540587366,
-0.434330672,
0.6962089539,
0.4007552564,
0.7498722076,
0.670539856,
-0.1967548728,
-0.2064753324,
-0.7062675953,
0.606351018,
-0.8350210786,
0.4008136392,
0.5315489173,
0.5194770098,
-0.5996999145,
-0.5076550841,
-0.2957106829,
-0.0827971771,
-0.0006748427,
0.1230030581,
0.4393573403,
0.0521909744,
0.2105613053,
0.1913570464,
-0.468611747,
0.3085793853,
-0.4595052004,
-0.1556780189,
0.9987898469,
0.4800663888,
0.2289178669,
0.2592622042,
-0.2649876177,
-0.2056410015,
-1.0912936926,
0.113512814,
0.6404854059,
0.3445049226,
0.4006588757,
0.2339716256,
-0.2866075635,
1.0617468357,
-0.035332758,
-0.2232291847,
0.0436257757,
-0.185278818,
-0.408782959,
0.3012588322,
0.4179388583,
0.4770824909,
-0.0386171155,
-0.1389216483,
-0.543828547,
-0.3122088015,
0.3441073,
-0.7946786284,
-0.5240090489,
0.0740861818,
-0.2241500765,
-0.4386022389,
0.2413781285,
-0.6981480718,
-0.4481632411,
-0.5937588811,
0.0984423533,
-0.3248297274,
0.1585561484,
-0.0101534706,
0.2542127371,
0.5084404945,
0.5951027274,
-0.8442869186,
0.1901958138,
0.7665289044,
0.430272162,
-0.1378770918,
-0.2149377912,
-0.7549862266,
0.1581903845,
-0.5817388892,
0.8982896805,
-0.4325987995,
-0.6007063985,
-0.0116120735,
0.110289827,
-0.0584408939,
-0.9713456631,
0.608876586,
-0.7304329872,
0.1541542858,
-0.0413051359,
-0.7488675714,
0.1627816558,
0.1588923633,
-0.5244247317,
1.4409288168,
-0.0706356913,
-0.2290055305,
0.3811702132,
-0.3654290736,
-0.5894215107,
0.0072390689,
0.0957335904,
-0.7334952354,
-0.2496220022,
0.3133947253,
0.2616978884,
-0.240132615,
0.1276181787,
-0.150365144,
-0.7068882585,
0.0302573126,
-0.5600953102,
0.712767303,
0.1435287595,
-0.2323517799,
0.2393698096,
-0.9437808394,
0.3991677165,
-0.172044754,
-0.5061304569,
-0.1488336325,
0.0781434476,
-0.293325603,
0.2837816477,
-0.0616297536,
-0.360071063,
0.4349890351,
-0.3717930019,
0.0732574388,
0.9557154775,
0.0650058836,
0.316996783,
-0.4873042405,
0.4863294363,
-0.1677806377,
0.5137377381,
-0.1997911483,
-0.2795949578,
-1.0467838049,
-0.2220512182,
0.4050649703,
0.554531455,
-0.7728783488,
0.5025302172,
-0.1841710061,
-0.4684824646,
-1.1279416084,
0.6796727777,
0.4567765594,
0.7015430331,
0.6171503663,
-0.0185674857,
-0.4973430037,
-0.515566051,
-0.213016808,
-0.0112742363,
-0.2525887489,
0.2838156223,
0.0989005864,
0.0773929879,
0.9362149835,
-0.5433484316,
-0.3654851913,
0.1041507572,
0.0302966014,
0.0626292601,
0.6024516225,
0.2124198526,
-0.4389918447,
-0.6299123764,
-0.3777087629,
-0.4367859662,
-0.2719886601,
-0.0444550849,
-0.4517113864,
0.3585903943,
0.6033796668,
0.0155704925,
0.4115953743,
0.4023320973,
-0.0948728845,
0.625977993,
-0.4724768698,
0.1289904267,
-0.9686303735,
-0.3292681277,
-0.2238163203,
-0.3900007904,
-0.4169785082,
-0.2438463122,
0.3044822216,
0.0491790436,
-0.4279830158,
0.5689452887,
-0.6844872832,
-0.097015515,
-0.5109609365,
0.1892240196,
0.1596349627,
0.3659801185,
-0.4798374772,
0.9371197224,
0.4702638388,
-0.7686131001,
0.7183313966,
0.2600366771,
-0.436486423,
0.6063479781,
-0.5429592729,
0.3308143914,
-0.1022529826,
0.3730934858,
-0.8778223991,
-0.1024351642,
0.3806795776,
-0.237838611,
0.7010862827,
-0.3085139692,
-0.4723722637,
-0.2910639942,
-0.3320356607,
-0.2801735401,
0.5852892399,
-0.8636509776,
0.1911194175,
0.0371484384,
-0.0028231605,
-0.6861650944,
-0.5045741796,
0.0707846656,
0.0362585597,
-0.3590836227,
0.4120700657,
-0.1951809525,
-0.0667599291,
0.1404731274,
-0.4976336956,
-0.0361220427,
0.1113571674,
0.1789366603,
0.6995251775,
-0.112274766,
0.2411273718,
0.1235638037,
-0.087535724,
-0.0204561893,
-0.3855485618,
0.3665013909,
0.3575656712,
-0.4351716042,
-0.5099622607,
-0.0941653922,
0.2122649699,
-0.1929908395,
0.6974181533,
0.7184221148,
-0.0060956459,
-0.7835369706,
-0.4244609773,
-0.3463360369,
-0.5428359509,
0.2333165109,
-0.1506007761,
-0.2183805406,
0.1126549393,
-0.0418148823,
0.4219052196,
0.0074383472,
0.291195482,
-0.63816607,
0.9514178038,
0.249764964,
-0.3276202381,
0.669565618,
-0.3433181047,
0.1118828952,
-1.1013635397,
-0.3312179148,
-0.5605727434,
-0.355425477,
-0.4266730249,
-0.4921507239,
0.2001016438,
0.1829419285,
-0.1614926904,
0.1002445593,
-0.6096130013,
0.5130231977,
0.8227243423,
0.4006754458,
0.3853162527,
-0.0955899805,
0.0728532374,
0.2866041064,
-0.6677558422,
-0.7373684645,
1.1251397133,
-0.0721709803,
1.0911847353,
-0.1280315667,
0.8088405132,
0.4585708082,
0.5285274982,
-0.559925437,
0.6513310671,
-0.0814982802,
-0.4304705262,
-0.4452190101,
-0.4621584713,
-0.9727692008,
0.1216289476,
-0.0377447158,
-0.1927042603,
-0.1012186259,
0.5761893988,
-0.1164686903,
0.3964813948,
-0.6966665983,
0.4949346483,
-0.3298165798,
-0.5387989283,
-0.0179726519,
-0.4861933887,
0.1932352781,
-0.0252298303,
-0.0920722932,
-0.273062706,
-0.0588561296,
0.6325585246,
-0.7090601921,
0.7761285901,
-0.3693860769,
-0.3898996115,
0.2080303282,
-0.0844698176,
0.782253623,
-0.0717787072,
-0.2830544412,
-0.2814981937,
-0.20709382,
-0.5849483609,
-1.0007487535,
0.7923230529,
-0.6111335158,
-0.8251376152,
-0.0599851049,
-0.5813058019,
-0.3524371088,
-0.0156629868,
0.0331460051,
0.6419442296,
0.0455566272,
0.0861179978,
0.6375545263,
-0.2594199181,
0.397356987,
0.6286492348,
0.0220039468,
-0.2700538635,
1.0732158422,
0.1978684366,
0.2911616266,
0.0939541608,
-0.1866157204,
-0.3107877076,
-0.7208946347,
-0.6312494278,
-0.0679853112,
-0.6501541734,
-0.4750704467,
-0.1126225516,
-0.2245182991,
-0.4744642973,
-0.0026609874,
-0.2834438384,
-0.3292362392,
-0.2311445177,
0.011090016,
0.2727029324,
0.5872764587,
0.2877278924,
0.1785296947,
-0.7476160526,
0.1430665106,
0.2195677012,
0.4887170196,
-0.1757282466,
-0.7576107383,
-0.424664855,
0.3471592665,
-0.2426606119,
-0.5707597136,
0.3728603423,
0.3320745528,
0.6361150146,
0.1583449543,
0.4331305325,
0.8779525757,
-0.585746944,
0.5523198247,
-0.3665085137,
-0.6272863746,
0.4985124171,
0.0026411777,
0.1770573109,
0.4827886522,
0.0612940937,
-0.3959003985,
-0.5782607794,
-0.4354470074,
-0.889567554,
0.8820469379,
-0.0287853312,
0.1273493767,
0.530053854,
0.4468902349,
0.0013862755,
0.1318256408,
0.0657119304,
-0.5844954252,
-0.2973502576,
-0.5544314981,
-0.0469859131,
-0.1115379259,
-0.0936416909,
-0.3166298866,
1.1918312311,
0.0963672549,
0.1090186387,
-0.0572005548,
-0.2382072806,
0.0957630351,
0.2328529209,
0.4979749918,
0.4815570116,
-0.3230757117,
0.0202496778,
0.310903728,
-0.499335289,
0.436004281,
-0.0295265373,
-0.4882076383,
0.038876906,
0.3337062299,
0.8460016251,
0.0806097165,
-0.4523062706,
-0.051649835,
0.0488502495,
-0.0468859561,
-0.2027008384,
0.7226771116,
-0.14299573,
0.1172494367,
0.2994861305,
0.1105047464,
-0.1275666356,
-0.3374592662,
0.3701432943,
0.1269264519,
-0.3364436924,
-0.1164475605,
0.5363044143,
0.345785886,
-0.6292555928,
0.7801008821,
-0.2620692551,
-0.3669116795,
0.6255346537,
0.5656955242,
0.5529270172,
-0.5404168963,
0.2314615548,
0.4450185001,
0.2186174691,
-0.1105878726,
0.0004931451,
0.0049173674,
-0.6729801893,
-0.2224073559,
-0.4591228068,
-0.5795024037,
-0.0624374039,
-0.8620485663,
0.441562742,
-0.3121476471,
0.126419127,
-0.4221148789,
0.1986537725,
-0.5885949731,
0.3434468508,
-0.1792433262,
0.8382558823,
-0.5008661151,
1.4145799875,
0.4882249236,
-0.2284920067,
-0.8196860552,
0.1355438828,
-0.0365940705,
-0.8918970823,
0.6866846681,
-0.1560743451,
-0.1720531881,
0.3470122516,
-0.3860596716,
-0.5331037641,
1.2251113653,
0.3557665646,
-0.6905070543,
-0.0146590872,
0.1791588366,
0.4661335647,
-0.1282380223,
0.0846221745,
0.6412969828,
0.4193060398,
0.1905303001,
-0.3659664392,
-0.0885446221,
-0.2803164423,
-0.0624739453,
0.2342917621,
-0.6262284517,
0.2244083434,
-0.1903864145,
-0.0584703274,
-0.1548912823,
0.5824850798,
0.0548418686,
0.1757485121,
0.471101135,
0.1589338332,
1.1229178905,
-0.2771928906,
0.8095482588,
-0.5785332322,
0.337112844,
1.6475541592,
-0.4284148514,
0.7193118334,
0.1755355,
-0.1479068995,
0.1915715933,
0.7762418389,
-0.3569275737,
0.3497823179,
0.4088570476,
-0.3031202853,
-0.0670164898,
0.0559354238,
-0.2834183276,
0.2865098715,
0.0188096408,
-0.2328691781,
-0.0836397037,
0.1228850633,
0.0961689353,
0.0580565818,
-0.2314244211,
0.8284412622,
-0.1574161798,
-0.6276540756,
0.8125340939,
-0.120994702,
0.4997999072,
-0.3223141134,
-0.2013630718,
-0.601819694,
0.2978592217,
-0.3244567215,
-0.5029956102,
0.2408879548,
0.1718603373,
0.0183431655,
-0.4554263055,
0.6588000655,
-0.8162523508,
-0.5162962079,
0.105359599,
0.1571059525,
0.0529807918,
0.253596276,
-0.7567469478,
-0.0052753738,
0.0457117967,
-0.2883832455,
0.2831300497,
0.1521314532,
0.252566874,
0.8623687029,
0.6281784177,
0.4270952642,
0.3831188977,
0.2444531173,
0.7420985103,
-0.5062527657,
0.0145016592,
-0.692950964,
0.4154630005,
-0.3040245473,
-0.0428383201,
0.8437243104,
0.7033849955,
1.0958768129,
0.048561465,
0.6749452353,
0.2698810101,
0.4193234742,
-0.7620310783,
0.7099881768,
-0.42866081,
0.6721739769,
0.0058757295,
-0.7801902294,
-0.2485242039,
0.3435321748,
-0.2279002368,
-0.0659553707,
0.4291748106,
1.2656501532,
0.1197160035,
-0.1681978703,
0.4185997248,
0.1370027214,
0.5860754251,
0.2068523467,
0.7139347792,
-0.6361441016,
0.7880365252,
-0.3395849168,
0.0922888145,
-0.3525595963,
-0.5763251781,
-0.8360770941,
-0.4099157155,
-0.4101755619,
-0.3530074358,
0.3266050518,
1.2025744915,
0.6675710082,
-0.8767106533,
-0.1564370841,
0.0841389447,
0.2499770224,
-0.6011613011,
-0.2010501176,
0.6051844358,
-0.8652951717,
-1.0134874582,
0.6310464144,
-0.0504957363,
0.0446296148,
-0.1789955348,
-0.2038858235,
0.107747674,
0.0050345464,
0.3525848985,
-0.0330139697,
-0.4340612888,
-0.2555655539,
0.0343875512,
-0.2975912094,
0.2605488002,
0.7808275819,
-0.5049026608,
0.542402029,
0.3388108015,
0.6729809046,
0.456225574,
0.1351709664,
0.5492131114,
-0.8172291517,
0.0568805039,
0.1276577264,
0.3614156544,
0.3878661394,
-0.3534542024,
0.6568118334,
0.0648735315,
-0.5780345201,
-0.9276838303,
-0.0290777367,
-0.4377239943,
-0.0141881257,
0.9553019404,
-0.3481565714,
-0.2706041038,
-0.2045923024,
-0.5086311102,
0.6205254197,
-0.363969177,
1.1470764875,
0.5805111527,
-0.1029298529,
-0.088774927,
-0.7860051394,
0.6454818845,
0.2734469175,
-1.0120587349,
0.1892324686,
0.41211465,
0.2866993546,
-0.6443355083,
0.2679946423,
0.0157192815,
0.0681714192,
-0.2108505666,
0.2010154128,
-0.665109694,
-0.3211617172,
-0.0965281576,
-0.0881780237,
0.0447835177,
-0.5996367931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14740v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14740v1
|
AutoKG: Efficient Automated Knowledge Graph Generation for Language Models
| 2023-11-22T08:58:25 | 2023-11-22T08:58:25 |
Bohan Chen, Andrea L. Bertozzi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Traditional methods of linking large language models (LLMs) to knowledge
bases via the semantic similarity search often fall short of capturing complex
relational dynamics. To address these limitations, we introduce AutoKG, a
lightweight and efficient approach for automated knowledge graph (KG)
construction. For a given knowledge base consisting of text blocks, AutoKG
first extracts keywords using a LLM and then evaluates the relationship weight
between each pair of keywords using graph Laplace learning. We employ a hybrid
search scheme combining vector similarity and graph-based associations to
enrich LLM responses. Preliminary experiments demonstrate that AutoKG offers a
more comprehensive and interconnected knowledge retrieval mechanism compared to
the semantic similarity search, thereby enhancing the capabilities of LLMs in
generating more insightful and relevant outputs.
|
[
-0.3044342995,
-0.7615305781,
0.4452420175,
-0.3379150033,
-0.2538713217,
0.3232275546,
0.0978293866,
-0.2628985047,
0.3260256052,
0.4425872564,
-0.3116725087,
-0.8987772465,
-0.6027197242,
0.0409522764,
-0.4448432624,
0.404969573,
-0.147494778,
-0.3064346313,
-0.3503957391,
-0.1063672602,
-0.2984639704,
-0.1263969541,
-0.4850179851,
-0.6198488474,
0.2603030205,
0.1691660434,
0.7698848248,
1.186932683,
0.2102930844,
0.419903785,
0.372677654,
0.2797819078,
-0.4260687232,
0.3985479176,
0.1012398005,
-0.228003189,
-0.4204376638,
0.0793697461,
0.5877758861,
0.7846604586,
-0.1063327938,
0.2926280797,
0.0006265964,
0.742392838,
-0.4334494174,
0.681009233,
-0.7365110517,
0.0025738704,
-0.1494149864,
-0.1083878875,
-0.0860801935,
-0.4121269286,
0.0697580352,
-0.6103030443,
0.0053778035,
0.593737781,
0.687173605,
0.4465484619,
-0.5659649968,
-0.4845719337,
-0.3976221979,
0.33327353,
-0.7072380781,
0.6058152914,
0.2864461243,
0.3135385513,
-0.556252718,
-0.8976258039,
-0.7169973254,
-0.5314041972,
-0.4215484262,
-0.0107905902,
-0.0181162264,
0.2267097384,
0.0882999077,
0.3788156807,
-0.9074880481,
-0.159552291,
-0.0329728164,
-0.2726876438,
0.6685758233,
0.2784330845,
0.5131979585,
-0.5400953293,
-0.1694454402,
-0.1897229552,
-0.745464325,
-0.2268370688,
0.6439344287,
0.1455964595,
0.2553971708,
0.6907991767,
-0.3078333139,
1.1689620018,
-0.0718924552,
-0.1412997395,
0.0666638091,
-0.265039593,
-0.1253404617,
0.0630816668,
1.1730215549,
0.3954120278,
0.1714031547,
-0.4531843662,
-0.1333227605,
-0.0468850397,
0.1261993647,
-0.534750104,
-0.6989501119,
-0.2670095861,
-0.6336190701,
-0.4371336401,
-0.1056163013,
-0.458676666,
0.0150419688,
-0.5536202192,
0.4795369804,
-0.5032845736,
-0.122690402,
-0.2615880072,
0.0255516693,
0.2834077179,
0.0736454651,
-0.5667405725,
0.3823434114,
0.2113671154,
0.5986068249,
-0.3339317441,
-0.1112636849,
-0.4853506684,
0.4761045575,
-0.400800854,
0.7245634198,
-0.4795463085,
-0.5040609837,
-0.3419047296,
-0.0832155868,
-0.0136725325,
-0.6333068013,
-0.1940856129,
-0.7789001465,
0.1133532226,
-0.2054362595,
-1.0085060596,
-0.1731437147,
0.2168906778,
-0.6259818077,
1.5897679329,
0.4761344492,
-0.6588894725,
0.4772648513,
-0.3941634595,
-0.6039165854,
0.4914236665,
-0.5324296355,
-0.2718889415,
-0.3024612367,
0.1045186073,
0.5818322301,
-0.3712906539,
0.1235245392,
-0.5613885522,
0.1944786459,
-0.3327447176,
0.4883636832,
0.4734931886,
0.4058424234,
-0.1512417644,
-0.2139667273,
-0.8530524373,
0.0552928187,
0.4082995653,
-0.4374375343,
-0.7577007413,
0.1308216751,
-0.5208778381,
0.0894611701,
0.4383315444,
-0.4438920915,
0.4303322434,
-0.5017817616,
0.1484638453,
0.3972325921,
-0.2034715712,
0.5103725791,
-0.0626459047,
0.5514466166,
-0.3634884059,
-0.192264989,
-0.04736441,
-0.4234102666,
-0.6390066743,
0.1047344357,
0.3994335234,
0.4366765618,
-0.8862050772,
0.8154132366,
-0.2928671837,
-0.5740172863,
-0.3894812167,
0.6771708727,
0.2966810167,
0.7870280147,
0.0908200219,
-0.3702385426,
-0.4291550219,
-0.9388112426,
-0.4491306245,
-0.4305523634,
0.1764191687,
0.5342990756,
0.3745926619,
-0.3213374019,
1.3018518686,
-0.8168020844,
-0.165503934,
-0.0464731008,
0.3910609186,
-0.2936349511,
0.1105832234,
0.7828318477,
-0.5482664108,
-1.0435065031,
0.150194943,
-0.8160179257,
-0.3597318232,
0.5133906007,
-0.2092458904,
-0.0062914728,
0.9783940911,
-0.4057971239,
0.0314959958,
0.4430541098,
-0.1989712417,
0.2959047854,
-0.2049556524,
0.049039457,
-1.2589544058,
0.2145265192,
-0.369134903,
-0.6621911526,
-0.324398905,
-0.0498406179,
-0.0238864347,
-0.0811226219,
0.0940527469,
0.8064309955,
-0.4837322235,
-0.2375450134,
-0.3660351038,
0.4381972849,
-0.2721984088,
0.1963813901,
-0.2939216197,
0.5533647537,
0.5266091824,
-0.6563920379,
1.0038446188,
0.1316816211,
-0.2228313684,
0.0794131607,
-0.3132050335,
0.242701292,
-0.150072366,
0.2493739575,
-1.3313643932,
-0.410333544,
0.1173278093,
-0.5336405635,
0.5058715343,
-0.2969893217,
-0.8771076798,
-0.6093992591,
0.0249931198,
0.3079853654,
0.650511682,
-0.4839142561,
0.9337349534,
0.6627982855,
-0.2381418645,
-0.2979112566,
-0.2437736243,
0.0696915165,
-0.0426751263,
-0.6513996124,
0.1059462652,
0.1552431881,
-0.2468781322,
0.4179078043,
-0.126656577,
0.2071239352,
0.0282081142,
-0.0508605689,
-0.0183517616,
-0.0749934018,
0.3695988953,
-0.0043144911,
-0.1099241599,
0.0404370837,
-0.6181126833,
0.6778280735,
0.0168144275,
-0.2320467681,
0.3771248162,
0.1039762571,
0.4378210604,
-0.160617575,
0.498527348,
0.636056006,
-0.2637014985,
-0.5811141729,
-0.5115270019,
-0.1314559579,
-0.5265834928,
0.2562667131,
-0.2196077853,
-0.9667159915,
0.4803772569,
-0.3966931999,
-0.111716345,
0.6665432453,
0.6114866138,
-0.1174946278,
0.8826611638,
0.7329462767,
-0.2774190009,
0.2038532048,
-0.0938883871,
0.4642295241,
-0.3607048094,
-0.2459140122,
-0.3301516175,
-0.2536462545,
-0.594319284,
-0.2502270043,
0.4255602658,
0.2374490649,
0.2045399547,
0.6531486511,
-0.5545707345,
0.2410141975,
0.4486388564,
-0.2944788933,
0.3397356868,
-0.011702897,
-0.6778761148,
0.1649670154,
-1.0551362038,
-0.3032521904,
1.2544183731,
-0.1767587364,
0.9380729795,
-0.2045065016,
0.8832079768,
0.3860329092,
0.4551998675,
-0.7575350404,
0.6742779613,
-0.2704991102,
-0.2341002226,
-0.3724506497,
-0.6691793203,
-0.9035005569,
-0.0330951549,
-0.1381807327,
-0.4089541137,
-0.4552009106,
0.5723762512,
-0.1602699012,
0.2325332165,
-0.6063064933,
0.6268742681,
-0.3227659762,
0.1514392793,
-0.0880569816,
-0.5470554233,
0.4384142756,
-0.1753759235,
0.269071579,
-0.1605778784,
-0.010066011,
0.8726710677,
-0.6363360882,
0.4609600306,
-0.0109700188,
-0.1126207858,
0.4323185086,
0.4160686135,
0.8175070286,
-0.3446737528,
0.2401949614,
-0.3493271768,
-0.2037488073,
-0.0776939839,
-0.7897551656,
0.783963263,
-0.6743985415,
-0.3138598502,
0.0154040661,
-0.8726512194,
-0.1625428796,
0.3963192403,
0.0830745846,
0.2975491881,
-0.0013846946,
0.0019156389,
0.6247604489,
-0.4326213002,
0.2963590324,
0.5789160728,
-0.5187830925,
-0.4115923345,
0.9006293416,
0.2567565143,
0.1859488934,
0.357014358,
0.2656584084,
-0.5065459609,
-0.2441879362,
-0.347351402,
0.3935564458,
-0.7818814516,
-0.3460589647,
-0.9394131303,
-0.1981314421,
-0.7556243539,
-0.0459624566,
-0.3830059767,
-0.4647762477,
0.2062580138,
0.1051987186,
0.7265002728,
1.0466662645,
0.0134998243,
0.3171236515,
-0.6921553016,
0.4423920214,
0.6881296635,
0.5044569969,
-0.0324516371,
-0.133003369,
-0.3702603877,
-0.518170774,
-0.1637317985,
-0.8319884539,
0.4103976488,
0.1467124075,
0.7282339931,
0.1888503581,
0.0885044262,
0.4713529348,
-0.5516914129,
0.6127471924,
0.1189277098,
-0.6086183786,
0.4525621533,
-0.5168020129,
0.2150807977,
0.2978604436,
0.4810245633,
-0.3837207258,
-0.5571712255,
-0.6146994233,
-1.0474015474,
0.4651649594,
0.236742273,
-0.2462440282,
-0.0137670068,
0.6770559549,
0.0269248895,
0.2518885136,
-0.6756582856,
-0.5875927806,
0.0737942606,
-0.495957911,
0.1302994788,
0.0357864946,
0.0210558381,
-0.2992629111,
0.6649262905,
-0.3233289123,
0.1803734303,
-0.011734724,
-0.3935934603,
-0.3471942544,
-0.1928196996,
-0.0755890384,
0.251750648,
-0.0300729685,
0.3435074389,
0.2640875578,
-0.2502685487,
0.1147679761,
0.3323951662,
-0.053709995,
0.0445213914,
0.3409720063,
0.484018147,
0.0936495662,
-0.5810923576,
0.3008142114,
0.1171827614,
-0.3348278403,
-0.0670472905,
0.2551040649,
0.3817734122,
0.1394968331,
0.2096299827,
-0.5591772199,
0.1372195631,
-0.3493041396,
0.4826418757,
0.635769546,
-0.0342806317,
0.0755048096,
0.724001348,
0.02189897,
-0.2664687037,
0.4368843138,
-0.490455091,
-0.6804921627,
0.5284692645,
0.2296105623,
0.7648096681,
-0.3283849955,
-0.076706022,
0.3786906004,
0.3544097543,
0.0705687031,
0.1287384778,
-0.300529927,
-0.6611320972,
-0.5927674174,
-0.8618151546,
0.0137220472,
0.1760385782,
-0.2415528148,
0.2503262162,
-0.1929110438,
0.0369739011,
-0.2263546139,
0.1400358528,
-0.6386204958,
0.1157971695,
0.2005903274,
0.6962262392,
-0.9141291976,
0.9792646766,
0.8432840109,
-0.1303414851,
-1.0920238495,
-0.3767077327,
-0.0527076311,
-0.9368287325,
1.0114946365,
-0.2630470693,
-0.1976176798,
0.3212088346,
-0.5027475953,
-1.0962754488,
1.2944076061,
0.2895228267,
-0.625225246,
-0.1990675181,
0.4370788038,
0.3483720124,
-0.4330018163,
0.0641322806,
0.5412293077,
0.4567527175,
-0.0296833161,
-0.9911295772,
0.1112698466,
-0.1261947155,
0.0753518194,
0.5604154468,
-0.6225765347,
0.5506458282,
0.3927225769,
-0.0431005582,
-0.379011035,
0.5949856639,
-0.0924922526,
-0.0906499252,
0.7073090076,
1.0049004555,
0.5659588575,
0.1265913993,
0.7989877462,
-0.9100255966,
0.4327032268,
1.0432462692,
-0.2198724002,
0.3015520573,
0.0505073592,
-0.1558635831,
0.3721716702,
0.5583355427,
-0.0518656075,
0.4325065017,
0.229917109,
-0.0859531984,
-0.3797127903,
0.3582417071,
-0.1034462601,
0.3553394079,
0.2728432417,
-0.5583050847,
-0.8318580985,
-0.2585552931,
-0.0204203539,
0.0247345679,
-0.1499019861,
0.9029486775,
0.2145328224,
-0.4969447255,
0.3989928663,
0.0142875481,
0.2490829825,
-0.7989585996,
-0.056386631,
0.0317502469,
-0.0658337623,
-0.0558421016,
-0.4965792894,
0.2154884636,
-0.2307067513,
0.0031934334,
-0.3188566864,
1.1606212854,
-0.7102178335,
-0.2872905731,
0.7147296071,
0.750682056,
0.0750143752,
0.3670762777,
-0.8442221284,
-0.3152823746,
-0.1558546424,
-0.4438925385,
0.2981015444,
0.4772303998,
0.0933182314,
0.7624306083,
0.4766604602,
0.1861305535,
0.4489753246,
-0.3634651899,
0.9409251213,
-0.4639554918,
-0.4494548142,
-0.8562783003,
0.0705466792,
-0.0017513548,
0.2043468058,
0.9835125804,
0.7253439426,
0.8242182136,
0.2052187026,
1.1421458721,
-0.4326910973,
0.4979534149,
-0.4574258924,
0.9287631512,
-0.5634278655,
0.0177299008,
-0.3032823801,
-1.0611326694,
-0.2090105116,
0.5842286944,
-0.3143268228,
0.0733453631,
0.5661440492,
0.9281146526,
-0.2888447344,
-0.3788452148,
0.3150855005,
0.383402437,
0.2167032212,
0.1856498569,
0.4293650687,
-0.2296825796,
0.6434696913,
-0.1059476882,
-0.1967657357,
-0.1105145141,
-1.02216959,
-1.0829219818,
-0.6265521646,
-0.2791854143,
-0.3453280032,
-0.0692621917,
1.1710444689,
0.7189171314,
-0.4817453325,
-0.3516921699,
-0.2625690997,
-0.0391608998,
0.4190250337,
-0.2653760612,
0.5452614427,
-0.630889535,
-0.2884767652,
0.3907904923,
0.409032166,
-0.0577012002,
-0.3584206104,
-0.1755066812,
-0.0668181553,
-0.10095644,
0.5974574089,
0.1860922426,
-0.4184001982,
-0.1291674078,
-0.1269637495,
-0.0671065524,
-0.0879944712,
0.8525231481,
-1.0165538788,
0.7043163776,
0.6833869219,
0.7179354429,
0.614230752,
-0.1423545033,
0.941103518,
-0.5736653805,
-0.1181851104,
0.0231776442,
0.2791563272,
0.212682277,
-0.2499560267,
0.2925200462,
0.4843139648,
-0.598080337,
-0.5169948936,
0.5040858388,
-0.5219219923,
-0.3268535137,
1.2303038836,
0.0572594739,
-0.257484436,
-0.1923565865,
0.0512845516,
0.6331537962,
-0.1522110254,
0.7977601886,
0.7660470009,
-0.3073391318,
-0.0129085686,
-0.5365816355,
0.7361594439,
0.0310883615,
-0.6951479316,
0.0594452843,
0.3162626326,
0.5877310038,
-0.0760290697,
0.5965835452,
-0.1022615805,
-0.0985825434,
-0.1414722949,
0.2212003469,
-0.1842061877,
-0.0394033007,
0.2016171813,
0.0914368406,
0.0972060263,
0.2878292501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13240v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13240v1
|
On the Calibration of Large Language Models and Alignment
| 2023-11-22T08:57:55 | 2023-11-22T08:57:55 |
Chiwei Zhu, Benfeng Xu, Quan Wang, Yongdong Zhang, Zhendong Mao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As large language models attract increasing attention and find widespread
application, concurrent challenges of reliability also arise at the same time.
Confidence calibration, an effective analysis method for gauging the
reliability of deep models, serves as a crucial tool for assessing and
improving their reliability. However, such investigation has been comparatively
underexplored. In this work, we conduct a systematic examination of the
calibration of aligned language models throughout the entire construction
process, including pretraining and alignment training. At each stage, we
investigate how different training settings, such as parameter scales and
training data, affect model calibration. To thoroughly assess model
calibration, we evaluate models on three most concerned aspects: generation,
factuality and understanding. Our work sheds light on whether popular LLMs are
well-calibrated and how the training process influences model calibration.
|
[
-0.1790684164,
-0.3576587439,
0.6787654161,
-0.0637024269,
-0.003683388,
0.0402391776,
-0.261621654,
-0.4564746022,
-0.4357751012,
0.4491775036,
-0.4343025982,
-0.3546015322,
-0.5760247707,
-0.0499854125,
-0.2185794562,
0.9692239165,
-0.3069431484,
0.5197434425,
-0.3785271347,
-0.1296988875,
-0.6571959853,
-0.4352616966,
-0.1212476715,
-0.5735670328,
0.2689794004,
0.1402379423,
1.2021900415,
0.7752033472,
0.5352991223,
0.3221265078,
0.0314240381,
0.0031528501,
-0.7908783555,
0.0701840967,
-0.216934368,
-0.4900817573,
-0.3781665564,
0.1708547473,
0.830111444,
0.9441079497,
-0.1975164562,
0.3214535713,
0.3414669633,
0.5636060238,
-0.8505505919,
-0.0820040777,
-0.688303411,
-0.3114461601,
-0.2035421133,
0.0493791252,
-0.5026637912,
-0.6772703528,
0.0965558216,
-0.394100219,
-0.0335006118,
0.0165840201,
0.9875116348,
0.4856208861,
-0.6752663851,
-0.2959609032,
-0.7976439595,
0.9912624955,
-0.8842304945,
0.4687533975,
0.2984009087,
0.2738409638,
-0.2415117621,
-0.3735771775,
-0.4155574441,
-0.1660117358,
0.0329449922,
-0.2122827768,
0.4671793282,
0.1371213794,
0.1659530699,
0.605540216,
-0.6129944921,
0.5078961849,
-0.1114063561,
-0.3515005708,
0.6903029084,
-0.0541438647,
0.2953824103,
0.0304238461,
-0.2572364211,
-0.1891423166,
-1.0164371729,
-0.1466607302,
0.817246139,
0.2768432796,
-0.0698190406,
0.6861716509,
0.2194636166,
1.0795936584,
-0.056099508,
-0.3291406035,
0.1356298029,
-0.5975815058,
-0.3330990672,
0.1329612136,
0.6500851512,
0.2605168223,
0.6192832589,
-0.0557411052,
-0.2746973634,
-0.1918704659,
0.4729485214,
-0.6169096828,
0.0137160402,
0.3173463047,
-0.0026326904,
-0.3063583076,
0.1745046526,
0.0236717928,
-0.4003220797,
-0.7306975722,
0.5233669877,
-0.1913039833,
-0.2827545702,
0.2592550218,
0.349253118,
0.6503199339,
0.3154511452,
-0.8324426413,
-0.1656663418,
1.1736537218,
0.3315769434,
0.1069230884,
-0.3486430943,
-0.3798511624,
0.0910323635,
-0.6563194394,
0.367536664,
-0.2908593118,
-0.0730334967,
0.1549555063,
0.0692224428,
-0.2034912556,
-0.1833238602,
0.4084149897,
-0.5836462975,
0.2177698314,
-0.2928831577,
-0.84322083,
-0.2429109067,
0.5060307384,
-0.7074488401,
0.8013232946,
0.0687014461,
-0.7349061966,
0.2088075876,
0.1576698571,
-0.0668714494,
-0.0116843982,
-0.405847162,
-0.3643334508,
0.273203522,
-0.0230876245,
0.4322226346,
-0.4731769264,
0.4898278415,
-0.3869882822,
-0.5070167184,
0.3768786192,
-0.4161996543,
0.9241890311,
0.1046746597,
-0.1307871044,
-0.0891775638,
-0.7074069381,
0.2932969332,
-0.2825930715,
-0.037107341,
-0.1696107686,
-0.0454030335,
-0.3671304584,
0.1901764274,
0.414328903,
-0.513931334,
0.0334873386,
-0.5345203876,
0.1736084223,
0.5999981761,
-0.0281504188,
0.3292657435,
-0.3142195642,
0.6193394065,
-0.1527510434,
-0.110155955,
-0.2085935175,
-0.1037756875,
-0.7477423549,
0.062939167,
0.6435222626,
0.4429756999,
-0.1200131327,
0.6270575523,
-0.5612121224,
-0.8054323196,
-0.7798514366,
0.4079128802,
0.7259598374,
0.4822044969,
-0.0585382022,
-0.2703038454,
-0.459102124,
-0.8416297436,
-0.2132151127,
-0.1814364195,
0.0490347221,
-0.0259888284,
0.5041129589,
-0.0336573757,
0.8246559501,
-0.1613569856,
0.1656782329,
0.1077443063,
0.1729973704,
0.1292484701,
0.5797715783,
0.5057092309,
-0.4985424578,
-0.4849773645,
-0.013881701,
-0.6367434859,
0.0509374999,
0.0182592776,
-0.1456566751,
0.1744655669,
0.4543046653,
-0.3953418136,
0.347881794,
1.0598802567,
0.1761099249,
0.6151191592,
-0.0515830033,
0.3247648776,
-1.0404627323,
0.1629160643,
-0.0773812383,
-0.3001710474,
-0.6119294763,
0.2282313854,
0.1705225408,
0.1506154686,
-0.3701037169,
0.2914372087,
-0.7333728075,
-0.1777959615,
-0.2246254236,
0.228910476,
0.2415317148,
-0.1446074545,
-0.0719614103,
0.7109846473,
0.3821158707,
-0.3555406928,
0.2061802298,
0.2064682841,
-0.7696869373,
0.6029310822,
-0.616474092,
0.4286553562,
-0.0219617374,
0.1193027422,
-1.3796467781,
-0.2243372202,
-0.2905198038,
-0.408093363,
0.5378035903,
-0.2726351917,
-0.5281571746,
-0.2059648484,
-0.1375155598,
0.5780211091,
0.1706659943,
-0.330263406,
0.6199227571,
0.3958406448,
0.0470942929,
-0.9029973745,
-0.5283917189,
-0.2855636179,
0.050819505,
-0.8075556755,
0.1258039623,
-0.0037378436,
-0.3773819506,
-0.4809604883,
-0.1371586472,
0.0184994563,
0.2672357261,
0.4977042973,
0.3365367055,
-0.4060349166,
0.0428132899,
-0.4713257849,
0.02690503,
-0.0281261336,
0.2827404439,
0.7565758824,
-0.1476699114,
-0.7248168588,
-0.5856974125,
-0.0594407544,
0.6570590138,
-0.3992239535,
0.872798264,
0.2994508147,
-0.3710151315,
0.162969172,
-1.0022851229,
-0.0109293498,
-0.4420123696,
0.4111840427,
-0.3971017301,
-0.8088076115,
0.5665633082,
0.1486904174,
0.3157324493,
0.4498840868,
0.572563529,
-0.1314072609,
1.1935031414,
0.8826727271,
-0.1703607738,
0.0550026782,
0.2612893581,
0.2515717447,
-0.7671265602,
-0.0913600624,
-0.8548539877,
-0.2588210404,
-0.5380600095,
-0.3263491988,
-0.132332474,
0.2309623808,
-0.5828719735,
0.3613659143,
-0.2423359901,
0.6247899532,
0.1988250464,
-0.1650234014,
0.2527436614,
-0.2560122013,
-0.0905882046,
-0.2095741034,
-0.3287735879,
-0.9257606864,
1.1199384928,
0.5846757293,
0.9378756881,
-0.0107912868,
0.5914025307,
-0.4534775317,
0.4481153786,
-0.7292245626,
0.2821671069,
0.0642649904,
-0.87247926,
-0.2910011709,
-0.3702440858,
-0.5546680093,
-0.054247167,
-0.1395470798,
-0.7480329871,
0.1974469423,
0.3160152435,
-0.6798789501,
0.1861488223,
-0.7254333496,
0.8544604182,
-0.4680146277,
-0.2035766095,
-0.0857304633,
-0.7573412061,
0.5952092409,
-0.417799443,
0.2281132042,
-0.1689397693,
0.1714735776,
0.414812535,
-0.3376787901,
0.7079472542,
0.2162671834,
-0.5600993633,
0.2324465215,
0.2707391083,
0.3755849302,
-0.253077209,
-0.524394989,
0.1134542972,
0.346978128,
-0.0808968693,
-0.4227922261,
0.7428864837,
-0.8573329449,
-0.5613151789,
-0.3240536451,
-0.6757493615,
-0.5185008049,
0.1634572148,
0.1511202306,
0.2549878359,
-0.3649390638,
0.4958082736,
0.5396379232,
-0.1377397627,
0.1491730064,
0.3787052035,
-0.314473778,
-0.4065636694,
0.4484970272,
0.1979350895,
0.7673460841,
0.278768003,
-0.2736534476,
-0.2269095331,
-0.3868198395,
-0.2485676706,
0.4390775263,
-0.7662508488,
-0.2536490262,
-0.0429409146,
-0.6383868456,
-0.4872379899,
-0.0887915343,
-0.7479745746,
-0.2918930054,
-0.3979972005,
-0.1329393685,
-0.0540823191,
0.7715569735,
0.2929875255,
0.5974016786,
-0.8908286691,
-0.1537721306,
0.22116974,
0.3277857304,
-0.0333575197,
-0.6700912118,
-0.2691752315,
0.4644406438,
-0.2380252182,
-0.7032105327,
-0.0962558091,
0.1246951595,
0.4784696102,
0.4878785908,
-0.2614730299,
0.9057065845,
-0.5661031008,
0.7897799015,
0.0843009129,
-0.8648710847,
0.2349616438,
-0.0984803811,
0.3291859925,
0.9656071663,
0.4884701073,
-0.2737316191,
-0.1246774569,
-0.3650197685,
-0.4797861874,
0.3046948314,
-0.1529540569,
0.2217730582,
0.2499533892,
0.6268566847,
-0.0570736863,
0.2846983373,
-0.7012684941,
-0.037520051,
0.0685739368,
-0.4451706111,
-0.2996902168,
-0.466932416,
-0.3535296917,
-0.0478999875,
0.7281879187,
-0.0730477944,
-0.2685845196,
-0.4010815024,
-0.4480009377,
-0.4038755894,
0.1267404258,
0.4994525909,
1.0821882486,
-0.2700761557,
0.0039568366,
-0.1271635741,
-0.3815410733,
0.2974046469,
0.0554942675,
-0.1173514575,
-0.2251353413,
0.3817040324,
0.7787778974,
0.4287399054,
-0.3842430711,
0.7830623984,
0.0403085761,
-0.0856949687,
-0.3159811199,
0.1406069249,
0.1288612932,
0.0238055885,
0.0342081003,
-0.2766190469,
-0.4484676719,
-0.3531736434,
0.0740873143,
0.8605824709,
-0.5221833587,
-0.3405835927,
0.3610293269,
0.0159120895,
-0.1758265793,
0.8998651505,
0.3923274279,
-0.5528933406,
0.4260140061,
0.4438582957,
0.7679706216,
-0.4646261334,
-0.0635544509,
0.4692839682,
0.6564494967,
-0.3863203824,
0.2065054327,
0.2903690636,
-1.1059229374,
-0.8532621861,
-0.8503445983,
-0.5733157396,
0.118618615,
-0.7871555686,
0.4251090884,
-0.1902044564,
-0.3105604947,
-0.2105578631,
0.1381765157,
-0.8021543026,
0.4417327344,
0.3702227473,
0.8392568827,
-1.0391668081,
0.7953943014,
0.4446172118,
-0.1636147499,
-1.2918021679,
-0.1222138032,
0.2263494283,
-1.0363274813,
0.3866309822,
0.451341033,
-0.2498585135,
0.2814637721,
-0.7461205721,
-1.1841623783,
1.1018630266,
0.7809243202,
-0.8348441124,
-0.231275022,
0.2849474549,
0.4544524252,
-0.3257824183,
0.3135424852,
0.6772246361,
0.4372573793,
0.2374881059,
-1.2901462317,
-0.1131416336,
0.1036609933,
0.1462921649,
0.1041087583,
-0.3819058239,
0.6419558525,
-0.1171037778,
-0.1751212031,
0.4395246804,
0.5057576299,
0.5190633535,
-0.4160141945,
0.5830401778,
0.8173379302,
0.7748253345,
-0.313533932,
0.9557461143,
-0.669318378,
0.3156331778,
1.4571477175,
-0.4267305732,
0.9935997725,
0.5854149461,
-0.0164938848,
0.3959062397,
0.6691903472,
-0.0322866328,
0.1376946867,
0.2482573539,
-0.003734892,
-0.4863348901,
0.0270799082,
-0.4853100181,
0.5980402827,
0.2201385051,
-0.3857403398,
-0.1172066256,
-0.2787235379,
0.0805211887,
-0.0843573883,
-0.2840194404,
0.5175282955,
0.1736573875,
-1.092980504,
0.4796631038,
-0.2721841931,
0.1494139731,
-0.6566289067,
0.2881623209,
0.0974763259,
0.4502423108,
-0.2518133819,
-0.8676543236,
-0.0328140408,
-0.2655895352,
0.0329613574,
-0.1889324039,
0.3405552506,
-0.4906620979,
-0.4066586494,
-0.0120482296,
0.336933285,
0.1333399713,
-0.0654108599,
-0.4780147672,
0.4007008672,
0.0844254196,
-0.3540151119,
0.2674390674,
0.2947909236,
0.2990366518,
0.4294142425,
0.4514934421,
0.0525813028,
0.0959066674,
0.1994826347,
0.4631772637,
-0.3456372023,
0.0472176634,
-0.8831694126,
0.9436635971,
0.0879043117,
-0.4221659899,
0.8327413201,
0.5533816218,
0.8004261255,
0.1862005144,
0.3553581536,
0.4095723331,
0.4250997901,
-0.5187841058,
0.8000176549,
-0.4179743826,
0.4081008136,
-0.3121849,
-1.2166308165,
-0.5015296936,
0.778932631,
-0.4771201015,
0.1788336039,
0.5135657787,
0.9723393321,
-0.0027332576,
0.0423640348,
0.1992809623,
0.2809006274,
0.2899426222,
0.3275912106,
0.8974609375,
-0.5594118834,
0.2628627717,
-0.291253984,
-0.1498586088,
-0.0595484786,
-1.4450135231,
-0.560642004,
-0.4637407959,
-0.4780186415,
-0.4180688262,
-0.2762217224,
0.6671823263,
0.7448319197,
-0.898940146,
-0.4586967528,
0.0427528732,
-0.0752995312,
0.1413287222,
-0.1064587384,
0.3171215653,
-0.3954002559,
-0.5796535015,
0.1064546779,
0.1547196954,
0.2928549349,
-0.6462265849,
-0.0731204599,
-0.3655335009,
0.1285071969,
0.0424553528,
0.2363767028,
-0.6575462818,
-0.4994286597,
-0.0877290592,
-0.5916708708,
0.1107276231,
0.411085248,
-0.3577493131,
0.6978653669,
0.4205684662,
0.7714594007,
0.2954820693,
0.3113978505,
1.0662192106,
-0.8074310422,
0.0051672603,
0.152067095,
0.5140147209,
0.7273298502,
-0.0770501718,
0.4495626986,
-0.3635717332,
-1.0393513441,
-1.2174665928,
0.2190351635,
-0.5614968538,
0.1803483218,
1.0146548748,
-0.1746416688,
-0.1202308089,
0.2244775146,
-0.0077973776,
0.3562523425,
0.4603867233,
0.4007356167,
1.3745646477,
0.2618841827,
0.007313041,
-0.6048896909,
0.3952644169,
0.435383141,
-0.3993019462,
0.0839961171,
0.6163447499,
0.504750371,
0.366415292,
0.1952801496,
-0.2423997968,
0.087390326,
-0.4663193524,
0.1209947839,
0.3717021346,
-0.2083241642,
-0.5227867961,
0.03882882,
0.5496980548,
0.1181233823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13230v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13230v1
|
Enhancing Uncertainty-Based Hallucination Detection with Stronger Focus
| 2023-11-22T08:39:17 | 2023-11-22T08:39:17 |
Tianhang Zhang, Lin Qiu, Qipeng Guo, Cheng Deng, Yue Zhang, Zheng Zhang, Chenghu Zhou, Xinbing Wang, Luoyi Fu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have gained significant popularity for their
impressive performance across diverse fields. However, LLMs are prone to
hallucinate untruthful or nonsensical outputs that fail to meet user
expectations in many real-world applications. Existing works for detecting
hallucinations in LLMs either rely on external knowledge for reference
retrieval or require sampling multiple responses from the LLM for consistency
verification, making these methods costly and inefficient. In this paper, we
propose a novel reference-free, uncertainty-based method for detecting
hallucinations in LLMs. Our approach imitates human focus in factuality
checking from three aspects: 1) focus on the most informative and important
keywords in the given text; 2) focus on the unreliable tokens in historical
context which may lead to a cascade of hallucinations; and 3) focus on the
token properties such as token type and token frequency. Experimental results
on relevant datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed method,
which achieves state-of-the-art performance across all the evaluation metrics
and eliminates the need for additional information.
|
[
-0.1908546686,
-0.6853128076,
0.96923244,
0.112287946,
-0.4144357741,
-0.228562966,
-0.5375717878,
-0.4637717903,
0.4370639026,
0.6458237171,
-0.4820472896,
-0.7751510143,
-0.7152380347,
0.3789150417,
-0.5265347958,
0.6158412099,
-0.0450719073,
-0.0828597024,
-0.2070887834,
-0.1283501387,
-0.3751676679,
-0.5553765297,
-0.3925653994,
-0.2966088653,
0.4264731407,
0.2236058563,
0.7061587572,
0.3325726986,
0.5455235839,
0.2172553539,
-0.1838726848,
0.7318362594,
-0.2995461524,
0.2806475163,
-0.2848533392,
-0.5371883512,
-0.1582176834,
-0.312972039,
0.3211779892,
0.4469742179,
-0.2513033748,
-0.1136528105,
0.0688494369,
0.4117248952,
-0.8386828303,
0.1169231012,
-1.2088807821,
0.1381653547,
-0.1641371399,
-0.2607839406,
-0.6437352896,
-0.3724642992,
-0.1771646887,
-0.4449012876,
0.5129740834,
0.285012722,
1.0249096155,
0.7105304003,
-0.129677549,
-0.5296035409,
-0.6123057008,
0.6234269738,
-0.6538274884,
0.7877135277,
0.7453402281,
0.1049917415,
-0.4216428697,
-0.5084215403,
-0.8691808581,
-0.3530497849,
-0.1445312798,
-0.29115358,
0.1486685723,
0.0958547965,
0.2164677531,
0.1503413171,
-0.3702667356,
-0.1160399765,
-0.1008198038,
-0.7637873292,
0.2576158047,
-0.0565601103,
-0.1026181057,
-0.3106102347,
-0.2208766192,
-0.0819108635,
-0.3853117824,
-0.4652643502,
0.2524106503,
0.4106299877,
0.1143732816,
0.6385987997,
-0.1972434521,
0.3354400396,
0.2691679299,
-0.4658961296,
0.3288711309,
-0.2195375264,
-0.1101158336,
0.1863864511,
0.5357396007,
0.3096829951,
0.2564153969,
-0.6434214711,
-0.2145351022,
0.1517724097,
0.344040215,
-0.6894488931,
-0.0747623816,
0.4802014232,
-0.3108457029,
-0.2046596855,
0.170527041,
-0.9813820124,
-0.9557895064,
-0.2209852636,
0.4201649725,
-0.6011511087,
-0.1767596602,
0.2535265088,
0.2110951841,
0.0884924531,
0.1982329488,
-0.7823646665,
0.1021370292,
0.6107106805,
0.8492335677,
-0.6094204187,
-0.291341871,
-0.7542957067,
0.1912529469,
-0.3492618799,
0.9283853769,
-0.3278562725,
-0.1402636319,
0.150753051,
0.1294463426,
0.2854696214,
-0.9192163348,
0.9590352774,
-0.3532066345,
-0.0551382974,
-0.3051789701,
-0.4086480141,
-0.1901767254,
0.2097865641,
-0.6803594232,
1.0484194756,
0.0330861509,
-0.8276785016,
0.5813626051,
0.0324742235,
-0.4032716453,
-0.0104761841,
-0.5618885756,
-0.5495378971,
0.26128757,
0.3590492606,
0.3149556518,
-0.0681872293,
0.8610883355,
-0.4824862182,
-0.6534911394,
0.3836840689,
-0.5593392253,
0.3692060411,
-0.0233072098,
-0.7931586504,
0.2946185172,
-0.8806004524,
-0.2344572693,
-0.2930883765,
0.0412742272,
-0.2461927384,
0.1108038053,
-0.149038136,
-0.0193923488,
0.0956986919,
-0.4262547195,
-0.0558733195,
-0.3190749884,
-0.1725913137,
0.6376926899,
0.0622709766,
-0.061153207,
-0.2580606341,
0.189202711,
0.3124412894,
0.0760929435,
0.1150636822,
-0.4154237211,
-0.9760469198,
-0.3345937431,
0.0569206215,
0.4416744411,
-0.805444479,
0.9108884931,
-0.1559959799,
-0.0586851314,
-0.5999611616,
0.1732140481,
0.0540525541,
0.5816540122,
0.4996575415,
-0.0050743916,
-0.8103424907,
-0.7888758183,
-0.1237594113,
-0.4370146394,
-0.1837600172,
0.2366821468,
0.4808322489,
-0.5135638714,
0.84566921,
-0.5574867725,
-0.6727269888,
0.1357514113,
0.1807757169,
0.0921187028,
0.1276807487,
0.1240226701,
-0.6246355176,
-0.084312208,
-0.1414965093,
-0.8303295374,
-0.1137095392,
-0.3537652791,
-0.2209004909,
0.4508977532,
0.5604918599,
-0.7768801451,
0.6081895828,
0.1643172652,
-0.4097842276,
0.5188813806,
-0.1035635248,
0.1711177528,
-0.8529996872,
0.0707640871,
-0.20653449,
0.0805289447,
-0.3058912456,
-0.0599014163,
0.1169247255,
0.3756012022,
-0.0872467086,
0.332030803,
-0.323104918,
0.1426241249,
-0.4272733629,
0.4159839153,
-0.0713617951,
0.384147197,
0.3036097288,
0.6158908606,
0.4021416306,
-0.4233108461,
0.2454764396,
0.0537749678,
-0.3719859123,
0.502071619,
-0.1319836527,
0.2962261438,
-0.182608515,
0.0975854173,
-0.8411233425,
-0.4306346178,
0.4101589322,
-0.3982878923,
0.086298652,
0.2405000031,
-0.7462518215,
-0.2450008392,
-0.313421607,
0.1080293804,
0.1931660622,
-0.5900541544,
0.7957186103,
0.0893885791,
0.3512326181,
-0.7284595966,
-0.5375286341,
0.1700179875,
-0.1612710208,
-0.4049053192,
0.3475365639,
-0.0666380152,
-0.4391890466,
-0.1603203118,
-0.5514596701,
-0.2316218168,
0.057221774,
0.3241603971,
0.2925973237,
-0.0408915058,
0.3178331256,
-0.0977591947,
0.1167412922,
0.00551137,
-0.4635284245,
0.542678833,
-0.0948752388,
-0.5719565749,
-0.5411749482,
0.1688548923,
0.7950129509,
0.2276849747,
0.7790981531,
0.9333342314,
-0.8724579215,
-0.3395193815,
-1.1008118391,
-0.708863318,
-0.480758518,
0.3883982897,
-0.2206987292,
-0.7996617556,
0.6435742378,
0.1906891167,
-0.3988450468,
0.1996169984,
0.6505138874,
0.23703067,
0.6042689085,
0.4263411164,
-0.0920517668,
0.0332079455,
0.3089797199,
0.4536063075,
-0.6113958955,
-0.5568317771,
-0.3782971799,
0.0065048328,
-0.2803123295,
-0.7166491747,
0.0844187066,
-0.0372399502,
0.218232885,
-0.077987127,
-0.6304272413,
0.4212214351,
0.2572254539,
0.3843378127,
0.6025137901,
0.1616108268,
-0.201401487,
-0.2790921032,
-0.0952920243,
-0.5504281521,
1.0382345915,
0.1906979531,
0.7563522458,
-0.0660961643,
0.5758810639,
0.3262915015,
0.2083504647,
-0.8055533767,
0.515150547,
0.2296509594,
-0.640943706,
-0.4906228483,
-0.3273593187,
-0.5876981616,
0.3818754554,
-0.2693513632,
-0.9029214978,
0.304997623,
-0.0330808759,
-0.552767694,
0.542087853,
-0.3347690701,
0.2292422652,
-0.1884081662,
-0.389003545,
0.0024446279,
-0.4119664133,
0.4500452876,
-0.3291093111,
0.2247326672,
-0.2387657166,
0.0191164296,
0.4752833843,
-0.1276766956,
0.867495358,
-0.0142009696,
-0.3732557893,
0.3062517643,
0.0621029027,
0.7837792039,
0.2856736779,
-0.1272891909,
0.2251293957,
-0.3137447834,
0.040985994,
-0.5855251551,
0.6055474281,
-0.4819412231,
-0.7210868001,
-0.3775802255,
-0.70635885,
-0.3600045443,
0.1532470584,
0.4564266205,
-0.0210039467,
0.0959644914,
0.218384251,
0.961139977,
0.0562003888,
0.088000983,
0.3306111991,
-0.3299290538,
-0.4298647344,
0.8067866564,
-0.0217184126,
-0.2003049701,
0.2819347382,
0.0608366281,
-0.3684581518,
-0.9272646308,
-0.1057381853,
0.4449470937,
-0.7143374681,
-0.1812391281,
-0.8012862206,
-0.0169164594,
-0.6923753619,
0.1317921579,
-0.3709783256,
0.023577759,
-0.5123666525,
-0.1383793503,
0.367482543,
0.3367294967,
-0.0224136114,
0.1746767759,
-0.3424475193,
0.7375061512,
0.1761168391,
0.5899201632,
-0.0430747494,
-0.6457623243,
-0.1243556067,
-0.1994849741,
-0.1591224074,
-0.8836946487,
0.3247666359,
0.0023478719,
0.4966175854,
0.8740620017,
0.3291752636,
0.5540858507,
-0.1872848272,
0.595169425,
-0.099503018,
-1.0087471008,
0.3837171495,
0.0856042579,
-0.0790968239,
0.9837584496,
0.3058692217,
-0.4670188129,
-0.6264125109,
-0.3979290426,
-0.7558250427,
0.4856691957,
0.3549870849,
-0.2567200065,
0.0305118691,
0.7136048079,
0.2013262361,
0.4005248845,
-0.8005571365,
-0.2259049714,
0.0431799218,
-0.3356080949,
0.167030558,
-0.3497794867,
-0.1351448745,
-0.3200208247,
0.6438345909,
-0.2456772625,
0.1421650052,
0.3990574181,
-0.1503073871,
-0.1287133396,
0.0581155904,
0.6961489916,
0.4374548197,
-0.5951895118,
0.491871506,
0.3720166683,
-0.8011868596,
0.2150488198,
-0.16214405,
-0.3055006564,
0.4522134662,
0.3835913241,
0.6687013507,
0.120726943,
-0.8197107911,
0.4949171543,
-0.0342165045,
-0.1287634075,
-0.5355465412,
-0.0640592873,
-0.1015068293,
0.3377718925,
0.5006467104,
0.0622493103,
0.2528486848,
-0.4012055397,
0.659503758,
0.3825373948,
-0.5789393783,
-0.2672766745,
0.5512220263,
-0.1659685224,
-0.3167988658,
0.5843362212,
-0.4421582222,
-0.5166195035,
0.3170750737,
0.5243762136,
1.1584800482,
-0.2081937343,
0.0263376255,
0.2546231747,
0.6790436506,
-0.3156985343,
0.4378305972,
-0.010611495,
-0.9542265534,
-0.2121962607,
-0.6351382136,
-0.4591799378,
0.5473162532,
-0.6221610904,
0.5404887199,
-0.3267533481,
-0.4002085924,
-0.4376489222,
-0.256397903,
-0.2989690304,
0.0838248953,
0.4341725111,
0.630664885,
-0.6634860039,
0.8624747396,
0.3308559358,
-0.1253421158,
-0.5001343489,
0.711848259,
0.0704151094,
-0.4907359779,
0.4728728533,
0.3817843497,
-0.4418919683,
-0.3780970275,
-0.5167664289,
-0.8813172579,
0.9912220836,
0.4659083486,
-0.5835398436,
-0.3429900408,
-0.0434845537,
0.419611752,
-0.2722996473,
-0.0096371407,
0.7243115306,
0.5911069512,
0.329456389,
-0.5705057383,
0.3705027103,
0.1737214178,
-0.3072626591,
0.0155218197,
-0.4749065638,
0.5860181451,
-0.3513536751,
-0.4219446778,
-0.0446332768,
1.0673643351,
0.4862758815,
0.417847544,
0.6010764837,
0.3658954501,
1.4444280863,
-0.0337099023,
0.5866196156,
-0.5307914615,
0.351116389,
1.3350758553,
-0.5778664947,
0.8229295015,
0.826012671,
-0.0241869148,
0.4433480501,
0.4687802196,
-0.2840113044,
0.5109279156,
0.3419841826,
-0.3629561067,
-0.474771589,
-0.3134233654,
-0.2805173993,
0.2369446009,
0.4960050881,
-0.202442199,
-0.003570494,
0.070606485,
0.0713892132,
0.0714418367,
0.1626432389,
0.474912852,
0.0561456867,
-0.7259631753,
0.7554232478,
-0.2596268654,
1.0950982571,
-0.370393455,
0.034954451,
-0.1971358359,
0.3363038898,
-0.263455838,
-0.1945914179,
0.4464398623,
-0.1281057745,
-0.0917814448,
0.3636161685,
0.6930225492,
-0.4296400845,
-0.4402047396,
0.479275018,
0.2624647915,
0.2745209336,
-0.5435490608,
-0.1375267506,
0.4187604487,
0.1099653989,
0.1420392692,
-0.0472000316,
0.767957747,
-0.0104005141,
0.6705889702,
0.308403939,
0.2691335976,
-0.1154707745,
0.1394957304,
0.5775759816,
-0.5486928821,
-0.0964693949,
-0.9036346078,
0.0773784444,
-0.1608346999,
-0.3899930716,
0.6972600222,
0.5261644721,
0.7647785544,
-0.0351609811,
0.6517969966,
0.2686646283,
0.3654378951,
-0.4971614182,
0.8446161747,
-0.357915163,
0.3482357264,
-0.223803699,
-0.6946134567,
-0.6039682627,
0.7870320082,
0.025048241,
-0.1461847275,
1.0627446175,
1.0725255013,
0.1896511465,
0.0757272094,
0.5525265336,
0.3006977141,
0.0184365883,
0.2841603458,
0.8214297891,
-0.2978482544,
0.6901453733,
-0.3456174433,
-0.1146275848,
-0.4798778594,
-0.831159234,
-1.1880452633,
-0.6626186967,
-0.4052332342,
-0.6952203512,
-0.0241373014,
1.010653019,
0.5400445461,
-1.2420889139,
0.0230600294,
0.1173131838,
0.4106848836,
-0.1725404412,
-0.2149336785,
0.5348213315,
-0.4584838748,
-0.5671146512,
0.2577456534,
0.3249186575,
0.1270162463,
-0.407725513,
0.0241370015,
0.0194590166,
0.2881900668,
0.5668982863,
-0.3045932651,
-1.2789354324,
-0.6149230599,
0.2272436768,
-0.1771319807,
0.1629978567,
0.7881327868,
-0.772211194,
0.2977850735,
0.2412768602,
0.5786533952,
0.3692061901,
-0.1128998175,
0.1516592056,
-0.6191991568,
0.2969568372,
0.3483837843,
0.4149149954,
0.4326315224,
-0.7915092111,
0.3684772253,
0.5925796628,
-0.261777252,
-1.0571274757,
0.0907082632,
-1.0165076256,
-0.3014007211,
1.2008334398,
0.1282188594,
-0.1586452723,
-0.5540337563,
-0.2823246121,
0.3155120015,
-0.3953178823,
1.5222667456,
1.0042306185,
0.0168151148,
0.1949898899,
-0.3679195344,
0.6555582285,
0.4268874228,
-0.7277962565,
0.4029083848,
0.5075916052,
-0.0367733687,
0.4175421,
0.3175426424,
-0.0503645726,
-0.0183951538,
0.0462585166,
0.3182172179,
0.19598943,
-0.6168283224,
-0.2471912354,
0.4664647579,
0.075985536,
0.0242944732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03716v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03716v1
|
Co-guiding for Multi-intent Spoken Language Understanding
| 2023-11-22T08:06:22 | 2023-11-22T08:06:22 |
Bowen Xing, Ivor W. Tsang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent graph-based models for multi-intent SLU have obtained promising
results through modeling the guidance from the prediction of intents to the
decoding of slot filling. However, existing methods (1) only model the
unidirectional guidance from intent to slot, while there are bidirectional
inter-correlations between intent and slot; (2) adopt homogeneous graphs to
model the interactions between the slot semantics nodes and intent label nodes,
which limit the performance. In this paper, we propose a novel model termed
Co-guiding Net, which implements a two-stage framework achieving the mutual
guidances between the two tasks. In the first stage, the initial estimated
labels of both tasks are produced, and then they are leveraged in the second
stage to model the mutual guidances. Specifically, we propose two heterogeneous
graph attention networks working on the proposed two heterogeneous semantics
label graphs, which effectively represent the relations among the semantics
nodes and label nodes. Besides, we further propose Co-guiding-SCL Net, which
exploits the single-task and dual-task semantics contrastive relations. For the
first stage, we propose single-task supervised contrastive learning, and for
the second stage, we propose co-guiding supervised contrastive learning, which
considers the two tasks' mutual guidances in the contrastive learning
procedure. Experiment results on multi-intent SLU show that our model
outperforms existing models by a large margin, obtaining a relative improvement
of 21.3% over the previous best model on MixATIS dataset in overall accuracy.
We also evaluate our model on the zero-shot cross-lingual scenario and the
results show that our model can relatively improve the state-of-the-art model
by 33.5% on average in terms of overall accuracy for the total 9 languages.
|
[
-0.2447402179,
-0.8634971976,
0.388959825,
0.3618656397,
-0.2927702665,
-0.3824507594,
-0.2549128532,
-0.3266143799,
0.1887150407,
0.6645922065,
-0.8288363814,
-0.7818993926,
-0.5633758307,
-0.1143092141,
0.0631311387,
0.7853155136,
0.0572232492,
0.3081506789,
-0.2237769514,
-0.2853401601,
-0.7565438151,
-0.0908819064,
-1.0639057159,
-0.6743549705,
0.6705511212,
0.6063329577,
0.4347319007,
0.1278054267,
0.2714014649,
0.2256289274,
-0.0351026133,
0.1750398278,
-0.5918371081,
-0.0416133963,
-0.0025501184,
-0.1372319907,
-0.5155180097,
0.2904150486,
0.2697352469,
1.0791237354,
-0.1283924282,
-0.1794686317,
0.3608074188,
0.3317398727,
-0.1426028013,
0.5329763293,
-0.2451469153,
0.0583294593,
0.3082622588,
-0.265576303,
-0.8220624328,
-0.1922775507,
0.5140163302,
-1.0807970762,
0.0415304005,
0.1884143651,
0.9676045179,
0.385735482,
-0.3824364841,
-0.5211704969,
-0.4230463505,
0.926128149,
-0.4505916536,
0.4972083271,
0.5766658783,
0.3197841346,
0.0475057587,
-0.7745602131,
-0.1184477434,
-0.3042861223,
-0.3980674744,
0.3162201643,
-0.1297828108,
0.3222576976,
-0.1085788533,
0.0740030035,
-0.490044415,
0.1854436547,
-0.2709246278,
-0.2808535099,
0.5631235242,
-0.1208834425,
0.3906805515,
0.0949620381,
-0.7363577485,
0.0105773611,
-0.533326447,
0.0737773031,
0.1399770379,
0.5545930266,
-0.5155815482,
0.3956273198,
-0.083264865,
1.0597652197,
0.485570997,
0.0283502899,
0.032126572,
-0.5608876944,
-0.2564688027,
0.2357871085,
0.7339602113,
0.4450087249,
0.1799564064,
-0.331428498,
0.3549548984,
0.2501098514,
0.0462634787,
-0.4102144837,
-0.2955593169,
-0.0057993606,
-0.3388822973,
-0.0146829057,
-0.3755442202,
-0.3341617286,
-0.1382903457,
-0.4621104598,
0.4341900647,
-0.5342292786,
-0.1754603237,
0.3902493119,
0.1150187403,
0.1758283079,
0.5636288524,
-0.5959869623,
0.4820373654,
0.7561870813,
0.8048795462,
-0.1533162743,
-0.4158214331,
-0.7579511404,
0.4440471828,
-0.0801231414,
0.4379122555,
-0.5935209394,
-0.157937184,
-0.2498953044,
-0.1797468662,
-0.3677728176,
0.0277038701,
0.6632474661,
-0.4921247959,
0.5395020247,
-0.1412487179,
-0.5200423002,
-0.7910962701,
0.3523069918,
-0.7156739235,
0.8224355578,
-0.0839530006,
-0.5822595954,
0.2191233486,
-0.8412231803,
-0.5768084526,
0.1784872711,
-0.4792726636,
-0.4121856391,
-0.29271999,
0.091182895,
0.5296097994,
-0.1658773869,
0.8184868097,
-0.3170100749,
-0.3952442408,
-0.3876431286,
-0.3483956158,
0.9673959017,
-0.1298176646,
-0.2275268584,
0.4059309661,
-0.4979197383,
-0.0113141108,
-0.2592532933,
-0.103724964,
-0.6187728047,
-0.1034252495,
-0.2171829641,
0.430405736,
0.0263509303,
-0.3787042499,
-0.144954294,
-0.1727872342,
0.1106194556,
0.478405118,
-0.0125526758,
0.6183915138,
0.0145516982,
0.305260241,
0.063045539,
0.3861301839,
-0.1157007664,
-0.8436800241,
-0.6274177432,
0.1107865795,
-0.0621654205,
0.2503200173,
-0.7803956866,
0.3133333325,
-0.1706674844,
-0.1767860949,
-0.5018088818,
-0.1429129839,
0.7992873788,
0.7521725893,
0.5187017918,
-0.3529644907,
-0.3226078153,
-0.7316610813,
-0.167495966,
0.1205396801,
0.5051853657,
1.0377131701,
-0.0297702141,
-0.1981443167,
0.6292080283,
-0.578266561,
-0.4744803011,
-0.1018767878,
0.2709744573,
0.2994259,
0.3940959573,
0.3467426002,
-1.1263873577,
-1.0440410376,
0.185133934,
-0.8850956559,
-0.1773019135,
0.2316972762,
-0.0985537618,
-0.1375308782,
0.5964793563,
0.0759445652,
0.3156890273,
1.0069725513,
-0.5186677575,
0.2970961034,
-0.2769310772,
-0.117860429,
-1.0755748749,
-0.2649887204,
0.3161167502,
-0.1187743917,
-0.9328163862,
-0.2461608946,
-0.2574786544,
-0.1767438352,
-0.4140762985,
0.4427507818,
-0.6963456273,
-0.1548997611,
-0.1104765385,
0.4532682002,
0.38247931,
0.8121167421,
0.1477391273,
0.5886590481,
0.8405054212,
-0.8669143319,
0.3725479841,
0.2375287414,
-0.010916939,
0.6002019644,
-0.7016778588,
0.2451898903,
0.0258253012,
0.3863350153,
-1.1421796083,
-0.0396109261,
0.5543168783,
-0.2173170298,
0.3310264647,
-0.4094680548,
0.2205563486,
-0.1883449554,
0.1908792406,
0.355422616,
-0.103226833,
-0.5632368326,
0.9133147001,
0.2798511088,
-0.2019678801,
-0.8066063523,
-0.6821379066,
-0.0643200204,
0.057100676,
-1.0738894939,
0.4804640412,
0.0363281406,
-0.0999184921,
0.2483396977,
0.0426674373,
-0.1076138467,
-0.0178469289,
0.4436686635,
0.3702678084,
-0.272983104,
0.1438383162,
0.220081538,
-0.409335494,
-0.2258526683,
-0.5982484221,
0.8252884746,
-0.1749021709,
-0.4585119486,
-0.7599909902,
0.5314745903,
0.1558794975,
-0.2308242768,
0.6913537383,
0.8625810146,
0.0120327836,
0.142505154,
-0.2393072397,
-0.2342116982,
-0.45086658,
0.290844202,
-0.585421443,
-1.052177906,
0.3588905334,
-0.1960650831,
0.0050236289,
0.2545770407,
0.2981480062,
0.0052457112,
0.8014929295,
0.7659327388,
0.1534182429,
0.5559726357,
-0.5320549607,
0.1943382472,
-0.9806631804,
-0.513343215,
-0.2561378479,
-0.1754696965,
-0.4425829649,
-0.5535288453,
0.5275962949,
0.1781191975,
0.2531704307,
0.3347640932,
-0.3699215651,
0.2572079003,
0.5992456079,
0.2611722946,
0.2315915227,
0.0541725494,
-0.5225804448,
0.2283225954,
-1.0200217962,
-0.1846562624,
0.7689515948,
0.0424944907,
0.8049980998,
0.0064548953,
0.7627894878,
0.2105573863,
0.1020889208,
-0.6534903646,
0.4838376641,
-0.3856286407,
-0.34789294,
-0.7953377366,
-0.3395591676,
-0.9423431158,
0.5849346519,
0.2031056434,
-0.7190232873,
0.322386831,
0.2795498669,
-0.2216197848,
-0.1362308711,
-1.2149227858,
0.9622151852,
-0.2103606611,
-0.7756816149,
-0.4030941129,
-0.7646293044,
0.2770733833,
0.376865238,
0.1200323254,
-0.2159199864,
0.2266565263,
0.7206936479,
0.002848997,
1.188538909,
-0.5257636309,
-0.3187671304,
0.3823430538,
-0.4339088798,
0.6874025464,
-0.1281219572,
-0.2730814815,
0.1357364953,
-0.4659025967,
-0.386263907,
-0.4098473191,
0.7829239964,
-0.6246333718,
-0.3508955836,
-0.1217463389,
-0.7009215951,
-0.0755005181,
0.3446458578,
0.1998843849,
0.8328831792,
-0.2545264363,
-0.0918233022,
0.6654601097,
-0.1221098974,
0.3546673357,
0.5556021929,
-0.1887266934,
-0.1079994068,
0.9447747469,
-0.106094867,
0.5007444024,
0.364492923,
0.4059857428,
-0.5551778674,
-0.4927515686,
-0.4171465337,
0.2816429436,
-0.6955251694,
0.2850737274,
-0.728987813,
0.0574117266,
-0.5967110991,
-0.1726359725,
-0.0839950815,
-0.0942292288,
-0.2844074667,
0.2864170372,
0.1108342484,
0.768648386,
-0.0336798877,
0.5121597052,
-0.3810862303,
0.3555370271,
0.3603299558,
0.5374364853,
-0.0707581788,
-0.2959733903,
-0.3570298851,
0.1335753351,
0.07489416,
-0.7315739989,
0.1621681154,
0.2677046955,
0.6714713573,
0.5056098104,
0.0274345707,
0.6372781396,
-0.3905938566,
0.4736844897,
0.4986462593,
-0.6976402998,
0.3914465904,
-0.2764896452,
0.229989931,
0.553663373,
0.3847127855,
-0.9525731206,
-0.1712998301,
-0.5298432708,
-0.5584658384,
1.2842159271,
-0.0257911384,
-0.312921226,
0.4359787405,
0.1772453338,
0.1807860583,
-0.0989200771,
-0.749383986,
-0.4117909074,
-0.1956393272,
-0.265129596,
-0.2437888533,
0.0016956043,
-0.2275032699,
-0.1059643924,
0.7869955897,
-0.3782344162,
0.2433490157,
0.0357925929,
-0.1884963214,
0.0214821715,
0.2909002304,
0.6099742055,
0.2475378811,
-0.0265962742,
0.1619068235,
-0.0904988423,
-0.4919135869,
-0.0505164228,
0.3300572038,
-0.3398510516,
-0.0967530906,
0.1726777256,
1.3015185595,
0.446098119,
0.136178568,
0.4166724384,
-0.2451864332,
-0.1028420851,
0.1242000684,
0.1236821041,
0.2539987862,
0.0888301134,
-0.0527861863,
0.0490158275,
0.2331188172,
-0.366484791,
0.2601498961,
0.2993173897,
-0.904048562,
-0.3272233307,
0.2157614678,
0.5832077861,
-0.4350221455,
0.3161770403,
-0.4446594417,
-0.6540682912,
0.4874927998,
0.7126311064,
0.7328503132,
-0.3759246171,
0.4194471836,
0.3422394991,
-0.058186315,
0.1878267229,
0.2447060943,
-0.3579838574,
-0.6992152333,
-0.53842628,
-0.2988272309,
-0.4640155435,
-0.079397276,
-0.6771828532,
0.1309017986,
0.1507323384,
0.0506751463,
0.3068178296,
0.0950169265,
-0.4740907252,
0.4531925023,
-0.0596212186,
0.3097470105,
-0.9582666159,
1.0185680389,
0.6616200805,
-0.3457505405,
-1.1381758451,
-0.0963231772,
-0.1884377599,
-0.9369986653,
0.4263833165,
0.1567527205,
-0.6231621504,
0.3255682886,
-0.3635165393,
-0.8734788299,
1.1180075407,
0.0336322375,
-0.6959660649,
-0.247753337,
-0.0550883636,
0.3292093575,
-0.589938879,
0.1406750232,
0.0577468164,
0.5315716863,
0.4693461657,
-0.7085438371,
-0.1616523117,
-0.1087265983,
-0.4197762311,
0.1470895708,
-0.8078911304,
0.9776284099,
-0.2926092744,
-0.3034177125,
-0.4254470766,
0.4777904451,
0.1172726676,
0.837013483,
0.5993664861,
0.469902426,
0.8003134727,
-0.1713291705,
0.9118533731,
-0.3153737485,
0.3991948664,
1.5498584509,
-0.3469389677,
0.3781217933,
0.4144134223,
0.1627055109,
0.5918095708,
0.3218455017,
0.2497915626,
0.6219293475,
-0.1299246699,
-0.1676421762,
-0.176221028,
-0.5287380815,
-0.2252056599,
0.3939079046,
0.5247938037,
-0.2627345026,
-0.3723439276,
0.1233963594,
-0.1026165336,
0.03963238,
-0.3190400004,
0.8105151653,
0.1968778968,
-1.0190747976,
0.3730001152,
-0.0677656084,
0.6426839232,
-0.5758271813,
-0.1804511547,
0.0549314655,
0.251717627,
-0.1908056736,
-0.7781087756,
0.1310020238,
-0.2872794867,
-0.0483920351,
-0.3495933712,
1.0156925917,
-0.9593318105,
-0.060258761,
0.767565906,
0.4103462994,
0.1820364445,
0.1997352839,
-0.8698768616,
0.0030466476,
0.0614832193,
0.2442340851,
-0.0978919119,
0.3395953774,
-0.1310681403,
0.6024169922,
0.429338932,
-0.2210156173,
0.3840822875,
0.6632371545,
0.6122564673,
-0.2273502201,
-0.8136547804,
-0.5357633829,
0.0708630085,
-0.2146284729,
-0.0899748877,
0.9026353955,
0.4707691669,
0.7885645628,
0.2495228201,
0.5717258453,
0.143440038,
0.2364842147,
-0.4435661137,
0.4594856501,
-0.4884088039,
-0.0414277427,
-0.1959163547,
-0.4791345,
-0.1069800481,
0.5641018748,
-0.5478623509,
0.1823520064,
0.5698956251,
0.6447458863,
-0.2612165809,
0.352614373,
0.4565632939,
0.0592668802,
0.2208653092,
0.8474476337,
0.6437268257,
-0.4567126036,
0.3900527358,
-0.2652732432,
-0.131975174,
-0.5046812892,
-0.5094344616,
-0.8508326411,
-0.616892457,
-0.3409207165,
-0.2601638734,
0.1782924831,
0.569286406,
1.0350782871,
-0.6177511811,
-0.3126091063,
-0.3274126053,
0.2785599828,
-0.3958930373,
-0.159948498,
0.565320611,
-0.2619599104,
-0.8194787502,
0.4365035295,
0.5463480353,
0.04500084,
-0.3580566049,
-0.8392848969,
-0.8086214662,
-0.0420358218,
0.6044775844,
-0.0361450873,
-0.8065008521,
-0.1372513771,
-0.010412436,
-0.347322315,
0.0560265183,
0.6652472019,
-0.5024960637,
0.6172168255,
0.1622062922,
0.2297109962,
0.8523392081,
-0.1131573096,
0.4489598572,
-0.8899368644,
0.1247454584,
0.2794161439,
0.1550777853,
0.3135975003,
-0.3680498004,
0.597309947,
0.1848799288,
-0.1760679036,
-0.319657743,
0.4533023536,
-1.3516645432,
-0.0273011252,
1.180310607,
-0.4271651506,
-0.3776057959,
-0.5090854764,
-0.213603124,
0.803083539,
-0.4814244509,
0.2776759565,
0.5101041198,
-0.3760617375,
-0.1594064385,
-0.0013969897,
0.2489341944,
0.4678614736,
-0.7486938834,
-0.0071119908,
0.4958219528,
0.0715069547,
0.301397711,
0.8453222513,
0.2541120648,
0.2857675552,
0.1243604422,
-0.2199825794,
-0.2825203836,
-0.6006638408,
-0.4122724831,
0.0894850269,
-0.187858507,
-0.4546073377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13184v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13184v3
|
Large Language Model-Enhanced Algorithm Selection: Towards Comprehensive Algorithm Representation
| 2023-11-22T06:23:18 | 2024-05-16T02:54:25 |
Xingyu Wu, Yan Zhong, Jibin Wu, Bingbing Jiang, Kay Chen Tan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Algorithm selection, a critical process of automated machine learning, aims
to identify the most suitable algorithm for solving a specific problem prior to
execution. Mainstream algorithm selection techniques heavily rely on problem
features, while the role of algorithm features remains largely unexplored. Due
to the intrinsic complexity of algorithms, effective methods for universally
extracting algorithm information are lacking. This paper takes a significant
step towards bridging this gap by introducing Large Language Models (LLMs) into
algorithm selection for the first time. By comprehending the code text, LLM not
only captures the structural and semantic aspects of the algorithm, but also
demonstrates contextual awareness and library function understanding. The
high-dimensional algorithm representation extracted by LLM, after undergoing a
feature selection module, is combined with the problem representation and
passed to the similarity calculation module. The selected algorithm is
determined by the matching degree between a given problem and different
algorithms. Extensive experiments validate the performance superiority of the
proposed model and the efficacy of each key module. Furthermore, we present a
theoretical upper bound on model complexity, showcasing the influence of
algorithm representation and feature selection modules. This provides valuable
theoretical guidance for the practical implementation of our method.
|
[
-0.5957465172,
-0.5491264462,
0.8439159393,
0.1199047118,
-0.3386510611,
0.1328401417,
-0.3905627429,
-0.5461288095,
0.0197608843,
0.7244926095,
-0.3282666206,
-0.4610449374,
-0.8519516587,
0.0598275587,
-0.4089073539,
0.6377721429,
-0.0028048863,
-0.0186670106,
-0.2660520673,
0.016519757,
-0.4800763726,
-0.5141825676,
-0.3140379488,
-0.6047644019,
0.1612990052,
0.141770944,
0.4926258624,
0.8179053664,
0.6139370799,
0.3997920454,
-0.237008214,
0.1565757841,
-0.2538539767,
-0.0140272267,
0.1219257489,
-0.5107935667,
-0.3507273793,
-0.1495185792,
0.6314252019,
0.695561409,
0.0698711425,
0.3518491089,
0.0320485942,
0.5397700667,
-0.4508592784,
0.3869464695,
-0.9339646101,
0.0146222534,
-0.0397368111,
-0.0778756887,
-0.4483779371,
-0.0424207374,
0.0856924579,
-0.3926477432,
-0.1561083943,
-0.0501571521,
0.4472313225,
0.2608297765,
-0.2900563478,
-0.4280949533,
-0.832179904,
0.8775995374,
-0.5706099272,
0.3196962476,
0.2933218777,
0.4283465445,
-0.0648332462,
-0.4595044553,
-0.3220728934,
-0.558665216,
0.2082200497,
-0.4038718343,
-0.0904367119,
0.0260810349,
0.4675153196,
0.2986485064,
-0.5041862726,
0.3319897652,
-0.308424294,
-0.2795054615,
0.6231583357,
-0.0132275941,
0.0950905085,
-0.0303148627,
-0.0144050056,
0.0022123065,
-0.6360727549,
-0.2775231004,
0.1095077395,
0.3616833091,
-0.0489959866,
0.4808530807,
-0.1348221004,
0.6537584662,
-0.2779212296,
-0.0462744087,
0.3044194877,
0.1498155445,
-0.2387530506,
-0.0548363253,
0.5513008833,
-0.276219219,
0.3310156465,
0.0319436714,
-0.3988933861,
-0.0889147744,
0.2171546966,
-0.769670248,
0.0168992132,
0.2194761038,
-0.5358150005,
-0.2680589259,
0.1739602387,
-0.6826448441,
-0.4033041,
-0.4926328361,
0.284486562,
-0.0603593811,
-0.2006718963,
-0.096461378,
0.1569838971,
0.2708564997,
0.2636554241,
-0.6548871994,
0.1701594144,
1.0184121132,
0.7564257979,
-0.1875092238,
-0.0797881931,
-0.5776559711,
0.1372926384,
-0.3077929616,
0.5685928464,
-0.9882116914,
-0.2127043307,
0.0734053031,
-0.3271722794,
0.292999357,
-0.6040200591,
0.3919979036,
-0.8786491156,
-0.2228713632,
0.0703354776,
-0.6437633634,
-0.3009421527,
0.0796896294,
-0.9265560508,
0.9316470623,
0.0804997608,
-0.6382662058,
0.0750785619,
-0.8072149158,
-0.2992151678,
0.2076745629,
-0.1406817436,
-0.557828784,
0.3008140326,
0.3860616684,
0.6300634742,
-0.4104942977,
0.086385563,
-0.4816265106,
-0.4597541094,
0.1315908879,
-0.4543143213,
0.7190077305,
0.3625060618,
-0.2396594435,
0.2398998141,
-0.6336160898,
0.0138037307,
0.2873863578,
-0.4146387875,
-0.2822853327,
-0.035250552,
0.0434180424,
0.0493565612,
0.5948965549,
-0.3301491737,
0.2430624515,
-0.3052485287,
0.4820255637,
0.8759281635,
-0.3394474387,
0.3804885149,
-0.029234685,
0.5326390862,
-0.3165757656,
0.0472315885,
-0.2258950025,
-0.3301946819,
-0.472668916,
-0.4584180117,
0.6386461258,
0.6428741217,
-0.4867530465,
0.7215965986,
-0.2878919244,
-0.3647800982,
-0.4597136676,
0.544839859,
0.2693835497,
-0.1347302943,
0.0630202666,
-0.2627544105,
-0.727237761,
-0.7264731526,
0.1691052914,
-0.2785741389,
0.0006874608,
0.2654488385,
0.4668456912,
-0.4533110857,
0.6734157205,
-0.7028161287,
-0.0178639814,
-0.5745028853,
-0.100618802,
0.3217914402,
0.2114361972,
0.4079248607,
-0.8009985685,
-0.3008038402,
0.2740060687,
-0.6183286905,
-0.1417892426,
0.0827878341,
-0.104743205,
0.1972286105,
0.5653755665,
-0.4745419919,
0.3273131251,
0.5494555831,
0.0429121256,
0.4192395806,
-0.4491946697,
-0.0995704234,
-0.9632425308,
0.2212876081,
0.1316538453,
-0.330650419,
-0.3122147322,
0.4603993297,
0.1110072583,
-0.1828693748,
-0.10644418,
0.5399537086,
-0.5003222227,
-0.356477797,
-0.4326497912,
-0.1215428412,
-0.2792533934,
0.3718318641,
0.0068633393,
0.5444615483,
0.6897718906,
-0.5659149885,
0.4289097786,
0.0283994786,
-0.5054836869,
-0.012211604,
-0.4721504748,
0.3155301213,
-0.0273000263,
-0.041256804,
-0.761988163,
-0.2546904087,
-0.1825654805,
-0.2860723436,
0.390452981,
-0.1837505996,
-0.6363822818,
-0.5291370153,
-0.0896646604,
0.3946830928,
0.7045253515,
-0.4411799312,
0.5979098082,
0.6918598413,
-0.2677340209,
-0.3441813886,
-0.3678582609,
0.065752469,
-0.1677182913,
-0.305686444,
0.2483869642,
-0.0585033074,
-0.1340353191,
-0.4004577994,
0.1631936133,
-0.0939782634,
0.3910534382,
0.1087799966,
0.2305108756,
-0.0747509301,
0.1309074014,
-0.0083057694,
-0.2969744205,
-0.062495511,
-0.3009822071,
0.7525933981,
0.0247362126,
-0.6204951406,
-0.2420349121,
0.4408072829,
0.6253727674,
-0.7790954709,
0.3657539189,
0.6556931138,
-0.4059087634,
-0.4504952729,
-0.5705355406,
-0.1510480642,
-0.4553731084,
0.9399021864,
-0.292729497,
-0.8918071389,
0.5200186968,
-0.2539060712,
0.0679687336,
0.170739606,
0.6432905793,
0.3164195418,
1.2581324577,
0.9707958102,
-0.5305271149,
0.5296812654,
-0.2916816175,
0.2219692767,
-0.7531238198,
-0.1066659614,
-0.7995526791,
-0.0817522109,
-0.5743929148,
-0.3817198873,
0.4501465857,
-0.0379758477,
-0.2714247108,
0.1570786834,
-0.5004197955,
0.5495095253,
0.3940587044,
0.1409860551,
0.1549215466,
0.3999170959,
-0.1353938878,
0.2004401684,
-0.4365960956,
-0.4873609543,
1.1798001528,
0.6182051301,
0.4577621222,
-0.0654071569,
0.815623939,
0.3132418096,
0.2597220242,
-0.8629041314,
0.7719923258,
-0.2610317469,
-0.2968284488,
-0.3472131789,
-0.5438771248,
-0.8707745671,
0.1559362411,
-0.2671396136,
-0.6927314997,
-0.3972714543,
-0.0589053519,
-0.2479762882,
0.2637221515,
-0.3900149465,
0.5629070401,
-0.2890172899,
-0.0128701515,
-0.4708723724,
-0.3062598109,
0.1768126935,
-0.2813926041,
0.4179323614,
0.2337398976,
-0.0130410371,
0.5867693424,
-0.0162968095,
0.6192042232,
-0.1298185289,
-0.1750035137,
0.0840145424,
0.2776421905,
0.5359545946,
-0.2783091068,
-0.3916329443,
0.207836017,
-0.2064885646,
-0.2552067637,
-0.6234427691,
0.6478773355,
-0.675978899,
-0.7359702587,
-0.0826054737,
-0.4719366133,
0.0029019241,
0.3186932802,
-0.2739512026,
0.4498318732,
-0.063483797,
0.2168346047,
0.7602940202,
-0.3097028136,
0.4432397187,
0.1327202022,
-0.5290850997,
-0.3182398677,
0.932610929,
0.0441696905,
0.0195656009,
0.4708377123,
0.25915429,
-0.1923071593,
-0.9797611237,
-0.3288416564,
0.1870791316,
-0.8244718313,
-0.0478563271,
-0.394243598,
-0.3771497607,
-0.273673296,
0.0788462684,
-0.1272799075,
-0.2140740156,
-0.157145977,
-0.0226184987,
0.1152261943,
0.8442018032,
0.1414990425,
0.1245425567,
-0.8009889722,
0.2888803184,
0.2489733994,
0.3632888496,
0.1797661185,
-0.4204084277,
-0.4436872005,
-0.2913741767,
-0.3148480654,
-0.6799640059,
0.3431292772,
0.1015909538,
0.837557137,
0.3726991117,
-0.2646432221,
0.2836233079,
-0.4687343836,
0.4389513731,
-0.2056404054,
-0.8962180614,
0.5623779297,
-0.0266005956,
0.3987256587,
0.2357054204,
0.2773640454,
-0.1532441974,
-0.1380824447,
-0.3243839145,
-0.6556694508,
0.4559082091,
0.1621007621,
0.3134803474,
0.1355419904,
0.5267950296,
0.1246106699,
0.208780691,
-0.8361897469,
-0.2301723659,
0.2696945965,
-0.5234782696,
-0.0205681585,
-0.2993168533,
0.1771610379,
-0.2218378782,
0.5813879371,
-0.2462044209,
0.4945663214,
-0.1961522102,
-0.2876457572,
-0.0759878531,
0.1784685254,
0.3532553613,
0.7979813814,
-0.0287900902,
-0.0446785912,
0.1033463553,
-0.4554173052,
-0.1890165657,
0.2086810917,
-0.2228673398,
-0.1925369352,
0.8172751665,
0.8445739746,
0.0011496644,
-0.7878206968,
0.3848639727,
0.2224858254,
0.0707996041,
-0.2793425322,
0.2597897053,
-0.0494432077,
0.3602930903,
0.4904595912,
-0.1944800019,
0.3209186792,
-0.5388712883,
0.2816769183,
0.8806493878,
-0.2719264627,
-0.0531990901,
0.1828536391,
0.2292703837,
-0.4255846143,
0.5152493119,
-0.0935795158,
-0.9067947865,
0.7872084975,
0.4210543334,
0.8856977224,
-0.1992888153,
0.1851798743,
0.2745814919,
0.2719371915,
-0.025334483,
0.2317041606,
-0.1011817753,
-0.4955255985,
-0.6186776161,
-0.8867658377,
-0.1918998063,
0.0915581509,
-0.367030561,
0.3764643669,
-0.5924460888,
0.0872186422,
-0.2128251493,
0.3307673931,
-0.671985209,
-0.037771631,
0.6096801758,
0.9301516414,
-0.6483108401,
0.9409525394,
0.6923305392,
0.0165514853,
-0.6748126745,
-0.0248354767,
-0.1671791226,
-0.8315894008,
0.5286096931,
0.3520582616,
0.1917856038,
-0.1764973253,
-0.693400085,
-0.8433024287,
0.9751193523,
0.5646985173,
-0.6667285562,
0.0404273421,
0.2212058604,
0.3197075427,
-0.8267318606,
0.4753460884,
0.5203124881,
0.3891395628,
0.4203691185,
-1.1565214396,
0.0438178182,
-0.0951778665,
0.3009006381,
0.2865815163,
-0.2812694907,
0.8202700615,
-0.1973676682,
0.1825797707,
0.1307373047,
0.6953599453,
0.5228514671,
0.1331409216,
0.5305237174,
0.3110602498,
0.835893631,
0.2788079679,
1.0813835859,
-0.2652632892,
0.314219147,
0.7775771022,
-0.4462330043,
1.1292817593,
0.3626046181,
-0.3256181777,
0.4643427432,
0.5914015174,
-0.0662509874,
0.4732667506,
0.3765093982,
-0.0597453378,
-0.5369386673,
0.2245830297,
-0.237353906,
0.6481960416,
0.3136263788,
-0.5640715957,
-0.2158167511,
0.0273767896,
-0.3123912811,
0.0171185713,
-0.7142701745,
0.87662673,
0.1347481757,
-0.4250361025,
0.4713729024,
0.3026793599,
0.5294494629,
-0.5741785765,
-0.3484601974,
0.1505434513,
0.0843650401,
-0.0390013456,
-0.6083438993,
0.0814460814,
-0.1385103613,
-0.2073563039,
0.1574340612,
0.8364284039,
-0.2505355477,
-0.8255476356,
0.4301234484,
0.2668305635,
0.059425585,
-0.3150493205,
-0.7737186551,
0.4925979972,
0.076270014,
-0.1297569424,
0.3585802317,
0.4285601079,
-0.1066618413,
0.8176811934,
0.5331216455,
0.3360697329,
-0.1204729751,
-0.0385067649,
0.8957458138,
-0.5123257041,
-0.6115727425,
-0.9935376048,
0.4165617824,
-0.0612472072,
0.1668430418,
0.216225192,
0.2870875001,
0.7356660366,
0.015077766,
0.9012584686,
0.1568183005,
0.2574083507,
-0.8030081987,
0.5390820503,
-0.4359220266,
0.7102190256,
-0.2713974118,
-1.3660541773,
-0.4511405528,
0.7086194158,
-0.4315440953,
0.3404146135,
0.4255844057,
0.855156064,
-0.214637965,
0.0060210982,
0.3427316248,
0.2390138656,
0.3820852339,
0.6120070815,
0.4790789783,
-0.1397450715,
0.3852746785,
-0.0778738931,
-0.5290827751,
-0.361538738,
-0.9867076278,
-1.0879570246,
-0.6890696287,
-0.2245801389,
-0.0594018847,
-0.2430030406,
1.3901903629,
0.8962959051,
-0.70021981,
-0.3854531944,
0.1447177827,
0.3866867125,
-0.0500714667,
-0.1064015031,
0.3896248341,
-0.1392503083,
-0.5555820465,
0.1888823062,
0.2514702976,
-0.1497689933,
-0.6137536764,
-0.2887927294,
0.040849153,
0.1252281517,
0.7228294611,
0.0150749683,
-0.5967326164,
-0.1519140899,
-0.2307020277,
-0.0004761542,
0.0531313941,
0.8894227743,
-0.7339799404,
0.2380317748,
0.477072984,
0.9991993308,
0.3707826436,
-0.4732110202,
0.3977024257,
-0.4927550852,
0.1423385292,
0.1065267846,
0.4010850489,
0.3431203961,
-0.389849931,
0.2103384882,
-0.0877433568,
-0.4167512357,
-1.0220223665,
0.427724272,
-0.7847070694,
-0.5158879161,
1.1761180162,
-0.0902238414,
-0.4344584048,
0.0113783805,
-0.3868851662,
0.1629667729,
-0.2389968187,
0.826885879,
0.808136642,
0.1119432896,
-0.4269686937,
-0.6114509702,
0.2215297967,
0.1610934734,
-0.6484626532,
0.1232899502,
0.3143844008,
0.0807539299,
0.1391540617,
0.120701544,
-0.1524466127,
0.0219597928,
-0.456381768,
0.1194810122,
-0.3162052035,
-0.5434573889,
-0.5592059493,
0.4667983353,
0.5055216551,
0.2924837172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13171v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13171v1
|
ComPEFT: Compression for Communicating Parameter Efficient Updates via Sparsification and Quantization
| 2023-11-22T05:28:59 | 2023-11-22T05:28:59 |
Prateek Yadav, Leshem Choshen, Colin Raffel, Mohit Bansal
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) techniques make it possible to
efficiently adapt a language model to create "expert" models that specialize to
new tasks or domains. Recent techniques in model merging and compositional
generalization leverage these expert models by dynamically composing modules to
improve zero/few-shot generalization. Despite the efficiency of PEFT methods,
the size of expert models can make it onerous to retrieve expert models per
query over high-latency networks like the Internet or serve multiple experts on
a single GPU. To address these issues, we present ComPEFT, a novel method for
compressing fine-tuning residuals (task vectors) of PEFT based models. ComPEFT
employs sparsification and ternary quantization to reduce the size of the PEFT
module without performing any additional retraining while preserving or
enhancing model performance. In extensive evaluation across T5, T0, and
LLaMA-based models with 200M - 65B parameters, ComPEFT achieves compression
ratios of 8x - 50x. In particular, we show that ComPEFT improves with scale -
stronger models exhibit higher compressibility and better performance. For
example, we show that ComPEFT applied to LLaMA outperforms QLoRA by 4.16% on
MMLU with a storage size reduction of up to 26x. In addition, we show that the
compressed experts produced by ComPEFT maintain few-shot compositional
generalization capabilities, facilitate efficient communication and
computation, and exhibit enhanced performance when merged. Lastly, we provide
an analysis of different method components, compare it with other PEFT methods,
and test ComPEFT's efficacy for compressing the residual of full-finetuning.
Our code is available at https://github.com/prateeky2806/compeft.
|
[
-0.514580965,
-0.9418542981,
0.1824547648,
0.0313474201,
-0.2661871612,
0.2580637634,
-0.6381946206,
-0.373213619,
0.0159476027,
0.3146356046,
-0.5697011352,
-0.1664707512,
-0.6272323132,
-0.0559540279,
-0.4192224443,
0.6395801902,
0.2796419263,
-0.2894594073,
0.0735751912,
0.1173845455,
-0.6267238259,
-0.7529498935,
-0.8345075846,
-0.2540432811,
0.1681881845,
0.5250304937,
0.7626699209,
0.5114110708,
0.5195017457,
0.3566974103,
-0.0278590694,
0.4629792273,
-0.7283190489,
0.2585901022,
0.0656872019,
-0.4998059869,
-0.7344510555,
-0.0280301701,
0.526206553,
0.7526534796,
-0.5241757631,
0.3677858412,
0.268565774,
0.6273230314,
-0.7577363253,
-0.1152894273,
-0.4938213825,
0.0154642882,
0.2075703293,
-0.4998963177,
-0.3951129913,
-0.1968853623,
-0.2751168907,
-0.704379797,
0.4783846736,
0.0531454012,
0.8745419979,
0.7057386637,
-0.1755942702,
0.7488408089,
-0.8349186182,
0.9930564761,
-0.697943449,
0.6050290465,
0.1845861822,
0.413393259,
-0.170463413,
-0.7639143467,
-0.3168002367,
0.0955703855,
0.0098693147,
-0.1984207779,
-0.5737202764,
0.2205208242,
0.2817488611,
0.4635930657,
-0.599093914,
-0.0509109199,
-0.2571719289,
-0.1353418678,
0.5484389663,
-0.0682385266,
-0.0881288499,
0.1853989512,
-0.4056592286,
-0.2194405496,
-0.8300924897,
-0.0893591791,
0.3261373341,
0.1315714419,
-0.0243053008,
0.2747026086,
-0.3912698328,
1.1499660015,
0.4127336442,
0.0266812406,
-0.049233906,
-0.1237831861,
-0.5763067007,
-0.4416454136,
0.6636772156,
0.3598537445,
0.0321585685,
-0.1191681251,
-0.0582202785,
-0.1813913584,
0.1365518719,
-0.6036026478,
-0.3731648922,
0.311627835,
-0.6963843703,
-0.2374587655,
-0.0111941183,
-0.688128233,
-0.1043143198,
-0.5576230288,
0.480078727,
-0.3842056692,
-0.2740179896,
0.398824811,
-0.293432802,
-0.0518586971,
0.6307867765,
-0.8293747902,
0.70389992,
0.9383231401,
0.519515276,
-0.0481805019,
-0.1381060928,
-0.9429624081,
0.0942379534,
-0.0678535402,
1.0603054762,
-0.5560727119,
-0.0501705557,
-0.4047552645,
-0.1882957071,
-0.0062312745,
-0.6125071049,
0.5876681805,
-0.2875951231,
-0.0656098202,
0.1234882772,
-0.6391882896,
-0.2841260135,
0.1999025792,
-0.5748434067,
1.2968337536,
0.3070045114,
-0.2484961152,
0.2586404979,
-0.1887729615,
0.20856525,
0.2056370974,
-0.1492631435,
-0.2104489952,
0.4412952065,
0.1388453692,
0.6763420105,
-0.4235110283,
0.2371055931,
-0.337132901,
-0.6279137135,
0.2122309655,
-0.4645946324,
0.3354313672,
0.3492059112,
-0.3031100333,
-0.1272874773,
-0.7799607515,
0.2499923706,
-0.2118998766,
-0.492849946,
-0.1884500086,
-0.1375616044,
0.1593208611,
-0.03906627,
0.271052897,
-0.2868441641,
0.5471948385,
-0.3109440804,
0.4769544899,
0.5228185058,
0.05866969,
0.2671231031,
-0.4123676717,
0.3882246614,
-0.4909395576,
0.4406872988,
0.0902007446,
-0.244479835,
-0.8212356567,
-0.2760224938,
0.6199895144,
0.3137286305,
-0.4827213883,
0.5715125203,
-0.311136663,
-0.6541691422,
-0.0682524964,
0.0785328299,
0.2509300411,
0.3705463409,
0.3118102551,
-0.1024697646,
-0.4323807657,
-0.9748718143,
-0.3474585712,
-0.0148250498,
-0.2188129127,
0.1074962541,
0.0026890452,
0.4284445345,
0.6468493342,
-0.7592047453,
-0.0594266243,
-0.0227427334,
0.4000458419,
0.3559620678,
0.7970460057,
0.6620304585,
-0.6805390716,
-0.6503776312,
-0.0945439935,
-0.1133210137,
-0.1378913522,
-0.0191313177,
-0.0410962924,
0.0208186153,
0.3551489711,
-0.6543716788,
0.096369721,
0.803640902,
-0.520871222,
0.3184113801,
-0.3676564991,
0.4077165127,
-0.6680662036,
0.1294953674,
0.0462961644,
-0.8231711984,
-0.6660613418,
0.4642620087,
-0.0548921824,
-0.2987611294,
-0.5320469141,
0.2583799958,
-0.456305176,
0.3412095308,
-0.3664106429,
-0.3864645958,
-0.003285194,
0.7871299982,
0.081295073,
0.7382124066,
0.4659535885,
-0.59777987,
0.3247935772,
0.0518031977,
0.1741406173,
0.4724714756,
-0.7419946194,
0.3656126261,
0.2596275806,
0.0819816142,
-0.6791232824,
-0.0713358894,
0.4236621261,
-0.3301684856,
0.3832857013,
-0.4549515545,
-0.6864672899,
0.0390543602,
-0.2907268107,
0.3204411864,
0.8132221699,
-0.2155023813,
0.7597564459,
0.1568614542,
-0.2144085318,
-0.4669239521,
-0.4704662859,
0.218922019,
-0.2618221641,
-0.5250532031,
0.6058787704,
-0.3489308655,
0.0349504575,
-0.0407832712,
-0.2616110146,
-0.2991364002,
0.2660367489,
0.014431349,
0.0735718459,
0.1634454131,
0.1434394419,
0.2816060483,
-0.1098093987,
-0.3392983675,
-0.2483284622,
0.5219427347,
0.0343881957,
-0.0373723023,
-0.0950500816,
0.7773296833,
0.1391484886,
0.0212245397,
0.4950934649,
0.637529254,
-0.4302989244,
-0.4459701478,
-0.8999119997,
-0.1439381987,
-0.5202059746,
-0.0126680359,
-0.4058195353,
-0.9880051613,
0.1718639731,
-0.4338567853,
-0.0169566777,
0.4951488376,
0.3994231224,
0.047565259,
0.7824468613,
1.0718632936,
0.2324411422,
0.4644180834,
-0.4739894867,
-0.0737976283,
-0.3558331132,
-0.0298630316,
-0.7070760727,
-0.4659360349,
-0.2324243635,
-0.6051374674,
0.5009989738,
0.2839694321,
-0.2805906832,
0.3726167083,
-0.9440872073,
0.6476415396,
0.6290545464,
0.4558596611,
0.4684475362,
0.4315416515,
0.5158085823,
0.1495280415,
-0.9954764247,
-0.2730788887,
0.8914170861,
0.2971576154,
0.8294045925,
-0.0763616413,
0.6195320487,
0.4544141591,
-0.216242969,
-0.7619417906,
0.5218305588,
-0.4348613024,
-0.2258571088,
-0.1622458696,
-0.3226157427,
-0.8524861336,
0.0631117597,
-0.4984331131,
-0.6611991525,
0.7119392753,
0.3911544979,
-0.8740167022,
0.1524669528,
-0.6738991141,
0.5129912496,
0.2098652124,
-0.3083979785,
-0.6837195158,
-0.4976926744,
0.0456959717,
-0.1734628528,
-0.1835107654,
-0.1768408418,
-0.4665778577,
0.7066248655,
-0.747825861,
0.8325637579,
-0.0694858357,
-0.0367207676,
0.1593039781,
0.1614449471,
0.5420526862,
-0.0808481574,
-0.0367180146,
0.4068505466,
0.3603082001,
-0.4233112335,
-0.9107385874,
0.5528995395,
-0.7056334019,
-0.445235163,
-0.1016498283,
-0.5325411558,
-0.2806248963,
-0.0132144904,
0.2286251932,
0.4890789092,
0.0974069312,
0.1486716717,
0.7488066554,
-0.0905068293,
0.3600129485,
0.4865275621,
0.3399266601,
-0.5140080452,
0.7817696333,
0.0771326423,
-0.0221012868,
0.539332211,
0.1426974982,
0.1452621073,
-0.5657346249,
-0.0110420166,
0.1229850352,
-0.6048454046,
-0.7975142002,
-0.394875139,
0.0586538464,
-0.2473406345,
-0.0654389337,
-0.4254116118,
-0.8899486661,
-0.1718981713,
0.4126970172,
0.4995465279,
0.4204448462,
-0.2969324887,
0.6051700115,
-1.1894216537,
0.2909865677,
0.1111865342,
0.4085073471,
-0.0911247805,
-0.2577151656,
-0.478286773,
-0.1875982881,
-0.3856312037,
-1.0308823586,
0.4962730706,
0.5996242166,
0.5786545873,
0.1196185052,
0.1061784178,
0.7871029973,
-0.268009305,
0.7780475616,
0.1317801625,
-1.0831621885,
0.3206336498,
-0.3668405712,
-0.0135765085,
0.4638551772,
0.2088053674,
-0.3779647052,
-0.3414261639,
-0.7908603549,
-0.7152414918,
0.4302023351,
-0.031976182,
0.0393014476,
0.3206894994,
0.6842547059,
0.4839175344,
0.3276927173,
-0.2928831577,
-0.3028372824,
0.0955410525,
-0.1552717239,
0.0356528126,
-0.3513902128,
-0.3891337812,
-0.4255338311,
0.5430563688,
-0.3436889648,
0.6572260857,
0.244111672,
0.0428417288,
-0.2585685253,
0.2744802535,
0.3888118565,
0.4566341341,
-0.214298293,
0.166867733,
0.035764318,
-0.2690886855,
0.3589682579,
0.4455519617,
0.1063359603,
-0.0165404473,
0.212663725,
0.6401966214,
0.2571747005,
-0.4346475601,
0.4243678153,
-0.0889253765,
-0.4067924619,
-0.1133036986,
0.3303221762,
-0.3949975669,
0.4415355027,
0.551805377,
0.4942880571,
0.4555694163,
-0.1268227994,
0.1151227057,
0.2032116055,
0.0574231148,
-0.2796801627,
0.6029683948,
0.2716997862,
0.0072627487,
0.3256772161,
0.0512028076,
-0.2670578659,
0.4005860388,
0.0523261502,
0.7774732113,
-0.0763873234,
0.0097576659,
0.3057396412,
0.0419222713,
-0.2963274717,
0.4445841312,
-0.2600069344,
-0.2763842344,
-1.1252613068,
-0.3325183094,
-0.4620813727,
-0.0267851483,
-0.4130495191,
0.3550955057,
-0.2651071548,
-0.3732984364,
-0.2345424294,
0.147596091,
-0.7110236287,
0.1363461018,
0.1677295268,
1.289763689,
-0.829200685,
0.6323320866,
0.6898471117,
-0.1188094988,
-1.2693343163,
-0.2280838341,
-0.3506201208,
-0.2662664056,
0.6978289485,
-0.4813981652,
0.2003707439,
0.1297779679,
-0.6624129415,
-1.0226781368,
0.9176746607,
1.0355565548,
-0.7533639073,
-0.0684066936,
0.0235668905,
0.3991934061,
0.1018211544,
0.1949518174,
0.5287488103,
0.483702004,
0.0077552665,
-1.0794215202,
0.3277926743,
-0.2485679835,
-0.3379889727,
0.3250990808,
-0.904651463,
0.8251301646,
0.3932629228,
-0.0476594791,
0.112058118,
0.5916686654,
0.0486928709,
-0.1597314477,
0.5748880506,
0.6836813092,
0.8209482431,
-0.2211773396,
0.9799100757,
-0.5561582446,
0.6268280745,
0.9323487878,
0.3615806103,
0.8868965507,
0.4557958543,
-0.1918171048,
0.3074395061,
0.7475243211,
-0.3149258792,
0.3594484627,
-0.0090247905,
-0.2420234084,
-0.7052595615,
-0.0840332881,
-0.3172295094,
0.344956249,
-0.0759928152,
-0.0539191924,
-0.3630031049,
-0.0442587212,
-0.1591200233,
-0.0849875659,
-0.3925011158,
0.5113380551,
0.0652640238,
-0.7499848008,
1.0674417019,
0.0491709374,
0.7563063502,
-0.4089731872,
-0.4272962213,
-0.115173243,
0.0101586832,
-0.3443551064,
-0.4019116461,
0.4323230386,
-0.2519100308,
0.0507807806,
-0.3341258764,
1.0728385448,
-0.5471666455,
-0.3015447259,
-0.2155242711,
0.7181887627,
0.0957840532,
-0.4069518745,
-0.8032047749,
0.3752754331,
-0.3071414232,
-0.3960874081,
0.2132961154,
0.0835771039,
0.1672645956,
0.7013350725,
0.3727184534,
0.3680383265,
-0.073101759,
-0.1033546031,
1.0401911736,
-0.3491042256,
-0.4136021733,
-0.7458144426,
0.5218638182,
0.0353498533,
0.0926476941,
0.4812323749,
0.5317527652,
0.5000534058,
-0.2276790738,
0.5362306237,
-0.048748035,
0.4269344211,
-0.5435964465,
0.4179696739,
-0.6389846206,
0.1281237155,
0.0008662628,
-0.9210859537,
-0.4504282773,
0.2951047122,
0.1055956408,
-0.0448457636,
0.6436649561,
0.5179354548,
-0.2816913724,
-0.3585221469,
0.458545059,
-0.012282474,
0.0894664451,
0.7583655119,
0.5690583587,
-0.6267157197,
0.6208541989,
-0.4099873602,
-0.2851127386,
-0.0012778519,
-1.0128691196,
-0.6411432624,
-0.4113421142,
-0.719825685,
0.0475672521,
0.0577098541,
1.1087386608,
1.209328413,
-0.3382028639,
-0.1797018796,
-0.1475074142,
-0.2540681958,
-0.7096047401,
-0.1928102523,
0.3545081019,
-0.2526292205,
-0.9548460841,
0.4261967838,
0.1267602146,
-0.0550756715,
-0.1699935794,
0.0979566872,
0.1786428988,
0.091897063,
0.4064201415,
0.1705055386,
-0.363792032,
-0.3023375571,
0.0134827439,
0.3321121633,
0.1188545898,
0.9033138752,
-1.1447376013,
-0.0757834911,
0.8503604531,
0.4002251029,
0.4498641193,
0.1573749334,
0.9904971719,
-0.8943095803,
0.0883355141,
0.0524656922,
0.4022967815,
0.1199596599,
-0.7802631855,
0.8330172896,
0.2396926731,
-0.7646590471,
-0.7581549883,
-0.0360387005,
-1.3871661425,
-0.4486325681,
0.9757326245,
-0.1628704369,
-0.1726627797,
0.0265855789,
-0.3925744593,
0.3486462831,
-0.6006485224,
0.5847733021,
0.4111405015,
-0.3546319902,
-0.5513435602,
-0.328704834,
0.5557774305,
0.4868826568,
-0.7205202579,
0.1319414824,
0.5348610282,
0.3918474913,
-0.1917543411,
0.5315825343,
0.1659459472,
0.3752856851,
-0.0491247997,
0.1422219723,
-0.5040587783,
-0.035553094,
-0.5717408061,
0.4918990731,
0.2450965345,
0.0909506306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13133v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13133v1
|
LIMIT: Less Is More for Instruction Tuning Across Evaluation Paradigms
| 2023-11-22T03:37:01 | 2023-11-22T03:37:01 |
Aditi Jha, Sam Havens, Jeremy Dohmann, Alex Trott, Jacob Portes
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models are traditionally finetuned on large instruction
datasets. However recent studies suggest that small, high-quality datasets can
suffice for general purpose instruction following. This lack of consensus
surrounding finetuning best practices is in part due to rapidly diverging
approaches to LLM evaluation. In this study, we ask whether a small amount of
diverse finetuning samples can improve performance on both traditional
perplexity-based NLP benchmarks, and on open-ended, model-based evaluation. We
finetune open-source MPT-7B and MPT-30B models on instruction finetuning
datasets of various sizes ranging from 1k to 60k samples. We find that subsets
of 1k-6k instruction finetuning samples are sufficient to achieve good
performance on both (1) traditional NLP benchmarks and (2) model-based
evaluation. Finally, we show that mixing textbook-style and open-ended QA
finetuning datasets optimizes performance on both evaluation paradigms.
|
[
-0.521540463,
-0.5712460876,
0.3015592396,
0.2054483593,
-0.1863697916,
-0.3969962299,
-0.6128722429,
-0.2919128537,
-0.3703705966,
0.4172283411,
-0.6390938163,
-0.6535221934,
-0.3673660457,
0.0070748101,
-0.244913727,
1.0071758032,
0.1976520866,
0.3637009561,
-0.2421727628,
-0.2772478461,
-0.5592362285,
-0.1758512557,
-0.6542986631,
-0.416893363,
0.4193884432,
0.7362125516,
0.6253687143,
0.9166029692,
0.5625733137,
0.1341685802,
-0.1209255233,
0.2312906533,
-0.6915975213,
-0.2290276736,
-0.1443635821,
-0.7262392044,
-0.2919916511,
0.1652231961,
0.6788774133,
0.7953234911,
-0.3377041221,
0.399867177,
0.2717853487,
0.8859204054,
-0.8316003084,
-0.0837129951,
-0.3761014044,
0.2393113077,
-0.111318998,
-0.0217466969,
-0.5231204629,
-0.5628739595,
0.3313631713,
-0.5771000981,
0.1288497895,
-0.1178662404,
0.6909915805,
0.4033679962,
-0.1153936982,
-0.2404288799,
-0.6779978275,
1.0398509502,
-1.0155366659,
0.644395411,
0.1915751547,
0.4530981779,
0.157253325,
-0.53026402,
-0.3913310766,
-0.2688815892,
0.1387799382,
0.1534346342,
-0.1081554666,
0.1810061485,
0.5343877673,
0.7259876728,
-0.2763086259,
0.6407786608,
-0.428444773,
0.094872728,
0.4889153242,
0.3761144876,
-0.0068024928,
-0.1574237347,
-0.3454832137,
-0.4516111314,
-0.9543696642,
0.1392983049,
0.438067615,
0.3713086843,
-0.3110897243,
0.5000678301,
-0.3316308558,
0.8492064476,
0.0154616721,
-0.0072666202,
-0.0549040623,
-0.3957946599,
-0.4912506044,
-0.180874899,
0.5872157216,
0.5879830122,
0.2110126317,
-0.096679166,
-0.3073818386,
-0.1397058964,
0.1207141876,
-0.9551227689,
-0.4245672524,
-0.041018635,
-0.4231111705,
0.0693336055,
0.0238501597,
-0.8385983706,
-0.5368697047,
-0.8699709177,
0.3624448478,
-0.6010353565,
0.2080341429,
0.2604396939,
-0.0157639235,
0.7488052845,
0.4125856459,
-1.0847909451,
0.6417729855,
0.9941099882,
0.7745597959,
-0.3891530931,
-0.1007086486,
-0.683308661,
-0.4664251804,
-0.4284014106,
0.6671434045,
-0.7438104749,
-0.0655794889,
-0.1541329622,
-0.1638819873,
-0.1858807802,
-0.836219728,
0.5597100854,
-0.3769181669,
0.1119772643,
-0.21701473,
-0.6750605702,
-0.1134435236,
-0.033185713,
-0.7813422084,
0.8223798275,
0.2256743163,
-0.3290982842,
0.5526727438,
-0.6054813862,
-0.3669207394,
-0.1713351011,
-0.3238138855,
-0.2488306314,
0.4402756393,
0.2988251448,
0.4433466196,
-0.5448049903,
-0.1387156993,
-0.0668209642,
-0.7312612534,
-0.1143310592,
-0.8073130846,
0.6026807427,
0.3333246112,
-0.345836997,
0.0387439951,
-0.9405128956,
0.268666029,
-0.2959152758,
-0.6583750248,
-0.3282324374,
-0.2036272138,
-0.2127920687,
-0.0251265801,
-0.0650597513,
-0.4785370827,
0.1386929005,
-0.7120826244,
0.2904655635,
0.9142566323,
-0.1549147218,
0.5565212369,
-0.7031009793,
0.749764204,
-0.2142987251,
0.0868688449,
0.009277422,
-0.2582916021,
-1.1109627485,
-0.0952063203,
0.6510940194,
0.6140931249,
-0.5470635295,
0.1763775498,
-0.1194801331,
-0.4125629067,
-1.0273647308,
0.287088275,
0.6858192682,
0.2060301453,
0.529487431,
-0.2721981406,
-0.5195058584,
-0.8661922812,
-0.2489489913,
0.5769531727,
-0.3892505169,
0.498932153,
0.1263981909,
0.1550679654,
0.6858092546,
-0.4337491095,
-0.1524338424,
-0.1226485372,
-0.1227124706,
0.5361518264,
0.5895159245,
0.4122802615,
-0.2626966536,
-0.5534367561,
0.0196398199,
-0.3052846193,
0.0214371607,
-0.2018125355,
-0.0231141578,
0.2045129091,
0.4283483624,
-0.2344105393,
-0.0046626595,
0.512760818,
0.0819341466,
0.4718735516,
-0.0746874064,
0.0650715381,
-0.6488421559,
-0.3906349838,
0.0204638615,
-0.0945362151,
-0.3008841574,
0.3638843596,
-0.0020858864,
0.0082721906,
-0.4872576594,
0.4158452749,
-0.4370042086,
-0.0369880311,
0.0136499815,
0.2751999795,
-0.0541679487,
0.3759548366,
-0.1908186227,
0.8681331873,
0.3301445246,
-0.6253166795,
0.1042134836,
0.0762260109,
-0.8686006069,
0.4607314169,
-0.539239645,
0.2837031782,
0.1404586583,
-0.1449658871,
-0.767116189,
-0.1803046763,
-0.0006527354,
0.0853213966,
0.4972860217,
-0.1401314288,
-0.46151039,
-0.1689202636,
-0.6111408472,
0.0177912656,
0.7315526009,
-0.7828176022,
0.2586168051,
-0.1246207431,
-0.0313659534,
-0.7128430009,
-0.7075003982,
-0.4255008399,
-0.1227698624,
-0.4793920517,
0.1222576275,
-0.039962206,
-0.1531886607,
-0.254327476,
-0.4930574596,
0.0775106996,
0.1517174393,
0.1236601695,
0.1348149031,
-0.7378488779,
0.250821352,
0.3355487883,
0.0368450806,
-0.1656656861,
-0.304872781,
0.6644823551,
-0.3010348976,
-0.4808794856,
-0.5367617011,
0.0797305778,
0.1276255995,
-0.0706368685,
0.6077010036,
0.5459425449,
-0.1455235332,
-0.4482018948,
-0.5357917547,
-0.4194719791,
-0.4915352762,
0.3029661179,
-0.4971422851,
-0.9497681856,
0.182043016,
-0.0718601719,
0.3097009957,
0.3969669044,
0.4770894349,
-0.0950275287,
0.6493598223,
0.7333622575,
0.131064713,
0.550455153,
-0.444467783,
-0.0884960368,
-0.9788658619,
0.1241829619,
-0.3192339242,
-0.5387420058,
-0.7760071754,
-0.5589820147,
0.1309237778,
0.2925534248,
-0.1639869809,
0.0968536437,
-0.6879141927,
0.9418631792,
0.7808762193,
0.3390369415,
0.4151034057,
0.1167112738,
-0.2791571915,
-0.0317850374,
-1.0608305931,
-0.724448204,
1.4645090103,
0.2992502153,
0.8336715102,
0.1027807593,
0.747695744,
-0.1365722716,
0.4270798862,
-0.8068345785,
0.3717730641,
-0.7575159669,
-0.4686373174,
-0.4426064193,
-0.4113797843,
-0.8524048328,
0.1450251639,
-0.2541226745,
-0.6639984846,
0.2187952548,
0.1876890808,
-0.8311924934,
0.1914333701,
-1.0319211483,
0.8519412875,
0.0496056713,
-0.3485650122,
-0.2488920391,
-0.5454939008,
0.4573065639,
0.1043383628,
-0.0772036761,
0.0048841271,
0.1087991819,
0.8806965947,
-0.4423627853,
0.7048296332,
-0.0424364172,
-0.259819597,
0.3385770023,
-0.1266909242,
0.2615800202,
-0.03456394,
-0.2388392836,
-0.1830287129,
0.3331402242,
-0.3342621028,
-0.5462034345,
0.9471168518,
-0.848221004,
-0.6786609888,
0.1777993888,
-0.6295955777,
-0.3619143665,
-0.0243724845,
0.3740933836,
0.4984792173,
0.1384174526,
0.5974439979,
0.9766575694,
-0.3287499547,
0.2418417931,
0.5841026306,
0.199959591,
-0.2279130369,
1.1033756733,
0.3462643027,
0.5027510524,
0.5147029757,
0.4495064318,
-0.100183323,
-0.646592319,
-0.5183985233,
0.1033068076,
-0.8706800938,
-0.3011790216,
-0.2547458708,
-0.0192312412,
-0.2607056499,
-0.086845547,
-0.4678775072,
-0.51447016,
-0.2982419133,
-0.0289921016,
0.3821179867,
0.5206460953,
0.0469378382,
0.6349955201,
-0.6583276391,
0.2809378207,
0.4574539959,
0.6908128262,
0.1500693411,
-0.6303166747,
-0.2485197484,
0.0407367386,
-0.4084076285,
-0.5076405406,
-0.2163230777,
0.4471831918,
0.438698113,
0.4082395434,
0.1609150916,
0.7515202165,
-0.6792881489,
0.5873746276,
0.0274549033,
-0.8133605719,
0.2193296999,
-0.2237600684,
0.4687620997,
0.8176301122,
0.3952498734,
-0.3994367719,
-0.3117879927,
-0.4559684098,
-0.7825230956,
0.9283483028,
-0.1025295854,
0.312050283,
0.2629978657,
0.4088236392,
0.4813787639,
0.1112993881,
-0.505928576,
-0.2295747548,
0.0276045203,
-0.4111507833,
0.0659686998,
-0.1516690403,
-0.4168250561,
-0.2814358771,
0.397462517,
-0.1576808244,
0.2271359265,
-0.1143310815,
-0.0704341754,
0.0110897431,
0.6460853219,
0.633037746,
0.7778781652,
-0.277829051,
-0.0488566272,
0.4403899014,
-0.3412830234,
0.0363034047,
0.2122790068,
-0.1890844554,
-0.2530100048,
0.5093702078,
0.9912490249,
0.2313783467,
-0.7070561647,
0.3653459847,
0.142652899,
-0.0118805412,
0.0926732123,
0.6657477617,
0.08058092,
0.4723895192,
0.1388034225,
-0.1650288999,
0.2524377704,
-0.3389792144,
0.2823722363,
0.2403786331,
-0.3073297739,
-0.01728216,
0.45773983,
-0.0604505837,
-0.1495771259,
0.6369063258,
-0.0888646916,
0.1155053601,
0.7997817397,
0.436190933,
0.5978438258,
0.0409004837,
-0.0596403442,
0.2798676193,
0.3406458795,
-0.0520366244,
0.2096175104,
-0.2311057448,
-0.3928705454,
-0.7394051552,
-0.8143200874,
-0.6800038815,
0.3515682817,
-0.853035152,
0.492084533,
-0.7896814346,
0.1430439204,
0.0432062484,
0.0868448168,
-0.7822425961,
0.3439213037,
0.0356465988,
0.9563535452,
-0.6630363464,
0.6606427431,
0.5986897349,
-0.3559059799,
-0.979878366,
-0.2092832476,
-0.0911910906,
-0.5887033939,
0.3992785513,
0.2439341098,
0.0514268652,
0.0403094031,
-0.5421635509,
-0.5984609127,
1.0727163553,
0.5111456513,
-1.1807565689,
-0.1067784354,
-0.1421991587,
0.6081872582,
-0.2841099203,
0.2137422413,
0.9591605067,
0.2571648359,
-0.1109848991,
-0.7985779643,
-0.032489948,
0.0774119049,
-0.1306691319,
0.0683375001,
-0.6886619925,
0.8315433264,
-0.1510370076,
-0.3552694321,
0.2566093802,
0.5068104267,
0.2450236827,
0.2891075611,
0.2634197474,
0.6783661246,
0.6138164401,
-0.1958799213,
1.2705773115,
-0.0455406718,
0.3571124971,
1.6188161373,
0.2415872216,
0.8949899673,
0.2791125476,
-0.509962976,
0.1785970181,
0.6991546154,
-0.2626376152,
0.3631203473,
0.5210297108,
0.0929407924,
-0.1739382446,
0.0989334285,
-0.338491559,
0.3469815552,
0.1205785051,
-0.2832144201,
-0.2767561078,
0.1512028426,
-0.015734233,
0.2434172481,
-0.3826094866,
0.771081984,
0.1681414396,
-0.4996023476,
1.0858743191,
0.0163956136,
0.7915312648,
-0.2818374336,
-0.1723316312,
-0.4758971334,
0.178386569,
-0.2824666798,
-0.6210119724,
0.0815585777,
0.0118788807,
-0.1490600854,
-0.0319626406,
0.3218390346,
-0.3466215134,
-0.2328521907,
-0.0963190272,
0.3063833714,
0.1697693914,
0.1923571527,
-0.3796095848,
-0.0232032463,
-0.035200119,
-0.2177166343,
0.39262411,
0.3483192921,
0.0054180087,
0.6310449839,
0.5702000856,
0.1238212809,
0.2880448699,
0.268499881,
0.9101504087,
-0.3875823617,
-0.029249059,
-0.8515021205,
0.310777545,
0.0693633854,
-0.5762144327,
0.7489385009,
0.6258791685,
1.2701271772,
-0.2695210874,
0.3704794943,
0.181746155,
0.4926249087,
-1.0070515871,
0.4828039408,
-0.4140863419,
0.5183081627,
-0.1690006405,
-0.9767431021,
-0.1648768932,
0.6845126748,
-0.5576978922,
-0.0052124751,
0.5395719409,
0.5323853493,
-0.218397662,
0.104815118,
0.4588751793,
-0.0055382396,
0.0317312852,
0.8073735833,
0.8316450715,
-0.4174191952,
0.3712320924,
-0.5289580226,
-0.1356767863,
-0.2468689084,
-0.6761935949,
-0.8572028279,
-0.0937479213,
-0.2399839461,
-0.0315385237,
0.1117188036,
1.071868062,
0.618455112,
-0.9388536811,
-0.2986176014,
-0.0992276743,
0.2296226472,
-0.4958377779,
-0.2800680399,
0.4400116205,
-0.5768322945,
-0.9389672279,
0.4142660201,
-0.0060108001,
-0.0801363587,
-0.151264593,
0.0504859909,
-0.0539395809,
0.2129739225,
0.607529521,
0.0867789164,
-0.590370357,
-0.3104708195,
0.0786782503,
-0.0387244523,
0.2296262532,
0.7425810695,
-0.5880101919,
0.447075516,
0.3218015134,
0.9738172293,
0.4689098597,
0.0217257999,
0.508885324,
-0.7760052681,
0.0300989151,
0.3575277627,
-0.0675370693,
0.177095592,
-0.2032598704,
0.7565158606,
-0.1901657283,
-0.3500889838,
-0.8661590219,
0.1439658999,
-0.8193510175,
-0.1066538692,
1.0524325371,
-0.3184891343,
0.0100891907,
0.3767337501,
-0.1081150249,
0.1671781689,
-0.3018252552,
0.5653200746,
0.8170354366,
-0.3631519079,
-0.3720324636,
-0.9897456765,
0.5226429105,
0.7083755136,
-0.7408884764,
0.0537312664,
0.5464814901,
0.2294753343,
-0.0185933877,
0.1187825799,
0.0107352836,
0.5841469765,
0.0633664131,
-0.3452421129,
-0.1529617012,
-0.382095933,
-0.601308465,
0.1372820437,
0.2685904205,
-0.2322108299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16173v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16173v2
|
Conditions for Length Generalization in Learning Reasoning Skills
| 2023-11-22T03:36:18 | 2023-12-06T16:31:50 |
Changnan Xiao, Bing Liu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Reasoning is a fundamental capability of AI agents. Recently, large language
models (LLMs) have shown remarkable abilities to perform reasoning tasks.
However, numerous evaluations of the reasoning capabilities of LLMs have also
showed some limitations. An outstanding limitation is length generalization,
meaning that when trained on reasoning problems of smaller lengths or sizes,
the resulting models struggle with problems of larger sizes or lengths. This
potentially indicates some theoretical limitations of generalization in
learning reasoning skills. These evaluations and their observations motivated
us to perform a theoretical study of the length generalization problem. This
work focuses on reasoning tasks that can be formulated as Markov dynamic
processes (MDPs) and/or directed acyclic graphs (DAGs). It identifies and
proves conditions that decide whether the length generalization problem can be
solved or not for a reasoning task in a particular representation. Experiments
are also conducted to verify the theoretical results.
|
[
-0.3607186675,
-1.0812606812,
1.2754272223,
-0.0391713083,
-0.2468667626,
0.0619836934,
-0.3958674073,
-0.3348853588,
-0.0427365489,
0.4022170007,
-0.5553335547,
-0.3835544288,
-0.8699515462,
0.3231269121,
-0.2415650785,
0.792104125,
-0.3521891832,
-0.235830009,
-0.2511363924,
-0.2273240238,
-0.541338563,
-0.3454048336,
-0.7667174935,
-0.4372176826,
0.6780022979,
0.3865447044,
0.9391949177,
0.8604748845,
0.4251213372,
0.4087455571,
-0.027518766,
0.3823806942,
-0.0498486646,
0.5040976405,
-0.2161463499,
-0.6991048455,
-0.1162201092,
0.222695142,
0.9103811979,
1.0060780048,
-0.0904410183,
-0.1235003695,
-0.3376009464,
0.8879817128,
-0.4049848616,
0.3435434699,
-0.4858180583,
0.1498943567,
0.1994981319,
-0.0293714013,
-0.2670245171,
-0.1489715278,
0.3602149487,
-0.6380775571,
0.0161956344,
-0.1612241715,
0.7102590203,
0.3244594634,
-0.7322216034,
-0.483997941,
-0.9925985932,
0.8091819286,
-0.5951322317,
0.2181359977,
0.4307743609,
0.5127542615,
-0.2875144482,
-0.5353016257,
-0.6970120668,
-0.5533959866,
-0.0289791245,
-0.5702576637,
-0.2108151168,
0.4414105713,
0.9257475734,
0.0984534696,
-0.6261001229,
0.1140644848,
-0.3955310285,
0.1315923333,
0.8467622995,
0.4824312329,
0.3047694862,
0.0555550382,
-0.0413439944,
-0.1340525448,
-0.3291004598,
0.2147660404,
0.7945094705,
-0.0508910045,
-0.0676760599,
0.610722959,
-0.4550133944,
0.8580251336,
0.0495943725,
-0.2099089026,
0.0523232035,
-0.1317564398,
-0.196448788,
-0.3635292947,
0.4652464688,
0.0749493018,
0.710231483,
-0.2312859595,
-0.2228607684,
0.2509684563,
-0.0307629257,
-0.4996293783,
-0.1429058909,
0.141501382,
-0.3239016831,
0.1574909538,
-0.1713456661,
-0.3212188184,
-0.1907638311,
-0.5624886751,
0.2706370056,
-0.4818093181,
-0.0960938036,
0.2691496015,
-0.4554997981,
0.1616798341,
0.1485589594,
-0.7868942618,
0.4143104255,
0.436119616,
0.6153662205,
-0.4242641032,
-0.3714503646,
-0.2705909014,
0.1973370463,
-0.4844202399,
0.5174939632,
-0.8465625048,
-0.4273204207,
-0.2445014268,
-0.0946903303,
-0.3641747534,
-0.4277804792,
0.3381438851,
-0.5954517722,
-0.019150041,
-0.1944614649,
-0.6165719032,
-0.198915109,
0.2408914417,
-0.3538933098,
0.343130827,
0.2147667408,
-0.6838117838,
0.3733489811,
-0.71044451,
-0.6727647185,
-0.0775242969,
-0.406525135,
-0.3706391454,
-0.056029167,
0.0062105269,
0.4399616718,
-0.0562011972,
0.3268695772,
-0.2577314377,
-0.3483919501,
0.3944016993,
-0.3808546662,
0.590878129,
0.4404273927,
-0.3821158707,
0.2710516155,
-0.7174256444,
0.2446351796,
0.2970519364,
-0.5235252976,
-0.1641018987,
0.377976656,
-0.8938761353,
0.1177852303,
0.158631295,
-0.4118553102,
0.4968700707,
-0.4142242074,
0.4956764877,
0.7287966013,
0.2542517483,
0.4989069998,
-0.3045484722,
0.6568114161,
0.0335189104,
0.0827810764,
-0.0312809497,
-0.4611282647,
-0.9442104697,
-0.1620341539,
0.2123500258,
0.5354804397,
-1.0489119291,
0.3593649268,
-0.0510413758,
-0.1456517428,
0.1833423674,
-0.0443995334,
0.3529713452,
0.008880347,
0.3541106284,
-0.0370652154,
-0.4592275023,
-1.055675745,
-0.1374583393,
-0.2621302307,
-0.1496607214,
0.3426080346,
0.6577689648,
-0.4080969393,
0.8417269588,
-0.6342936158,
0.0769281387,
-0.4567546248,
0.0138604539,
0.4504569173,
0.2789824605,
0.409511447,
-0.5610188246,
-0.2609091699,
-0.2861681283,
-0.8158324957,
0.0349509753,
-0.1796755791,
0.2538231909,
0.3954547346,
0.3451316953,
-0.8604542613,
0.8411003351,
0.393251121,
-0.3892772794,
0.7651526332,
-0.5709517002,
0.0102640307,
-0.3040923774,
-0.4099004269,
0.2437720895,
-0.1534234136,
-0.5285643339,
0.0860662758,
-0.5347313881,
-0.2287149727,
-0.143906787,
0.4621162713,
-0.6728436351,
-0.0623381399,
-0.5065835118,
-0.0206822064,
-0.1010227799,
0.4891401529,
0.1615704745,
0.384847492,
0.7809891105,
-1.1751914024,
0.7695310712,
-0.2691195905,
-0.1544634551,
0.4761340618,
-0.7902424335,
0.0450900458,
-0.0240786597,
0.3708008528,
-0.7618412971,
0.0803453177,
0.2533485293,
-0.4124146998,
0.1782267392,
-0.1735616475,
-0.5675010085,
-0.6569004059,
0.1955209076,
0.4411778748,
0.5556983948,
-0.3855232596,
0.4340763688,
0.0834388137,
0.1433696598,
-0.3920886517,
-0.4212854803,
-0.157599777,
-0.4560805559,
-0.9638604522,
-0.0059004421,
-0.1628528237,
-0.4937931597,
-0.1449680179,
-0.1667835563,
-0.0533362925,
0.0689201057,
0.2524838746,
-0.1723623127,
0.1217240393,
0.3811939657,
0.2246239185,
-0.0996504128,
0.4352779984,
-0.3344818652,
0.4717989266,
-0.1136490926,
-0.6353558302,
-0.5209072232,
0.3103981912,
0.4124370515,
-0.1031269953,
0.7877593637,
0.2226052582,
-0.2305541635,
-0.5865613818,
-0.4731295109,
-0.3177847266,
-0.4868618548,
0.2164500952,
-0.5661126375,
-0.8726041317,
0.5367882252,
0.0888849646,
-0.3707239628,
0.5058457851,
0.4377951026,
0.0707444847,
1.3581024408,
0.3216096461,
0.3058244884,
0.1860718131,
-0.659203887,
0.2455822825,
-0.539922893,
-0.52173388,
-0.2513660192,
-0.5106365085,
-0.6527146101,
-0.4841168523,
0.3446493745,
-0.090193592,
-0.2925624549,
-0.0391025282,
-0.4401370287,
0.5933782458,
0.5080679059,
0.0866166726,
0.0706652626,
-0.0870714486,
-0.3787188828,
0.3420715332,
-0.5566278696,
-0.3585570753,
0.9719227552,
0.4916467071,
0.6910725832,
0.1085244119,
0.5965163708,
0.5838021636,
-0.5587128997,
-0.9659932852,
0.8439354897,
0.1156287715,
-0.502558589,
-0.8776866198,
-0.6771374941,
-1.4287788868,
0.2329715788,
-0.0316268578,
-0.6746941209,
0.161167711,
-0.124264352,
0.2291290462,
0.4674474597,
-0.3665041924,
0.5233121514,
-0.3187092543,
-0.1188441589,
-0.5590418577,
-0.642629087,
0.1059529409,
0.323867321,
-0.0211464986,
-0.4042954445,
0.1187655628,
0.8107097149,
-0.6092274189,
0.6147499681,
-0.403075844,
0.0913638547,
0.7327787876,
0.0336259045,
0.5302758217,
0.0127823865,
0.1318378597,
-0.1005204469,
0.0726963803,
-0.6079972982,
-0.761700213,
0.5295369029,
-0.7420983315,
-1.1794551611,
-0.6743817925,
-0.7553952336,
-0.2935862541,
0.0696576685,
-0.0006895041,
0.0091565326,
0.0230130516,
0.0175664853,
0.7191722393,
-0.0267166141,
0.5913726091,
0.5518429279,
-0.2582773566,
0.0580948554,
0.6419352889,
0.3387829363,
0.2050959468,
-0.0895021185,
0.2412237227,
-0.1798589677,
-0.9067020416,
-0.1985191703,
0.4935671985,
-0.8316741586,
0.222189635,
-0.4123521745,
-0.4066644311,
-0.2455058545,
0.0761270002,
0.0913957581,
-0.672885716,
-0.3656544387,
-0.1554921865,
0.1735634506,
0.8799795508,
-0.2230586261,
0.0092640352,
-0.3856214285,
0.4711279869,
0.6900098324,
0.2423714697,
0.109405674,
-0.5917558074,
-0.2568301857,
0.0948807448,
-0.4894246459,
-0.8321653605,
0.2158015072,
0.0008362825,
0.929930985,
0.6429157257,
-0.0977703631,
0.3299860358,
-0.4753941,
0.4690494239,
0.0754368752,
-0.8575585485,
0.8084053993,
-0.6644243002,
0.2135834098,
-0.0442778692,
0.667078793,
-0.4915766716,
-0.31092906,
-0.7729002833,
-0.5688718557,
0.2507823706,
0.4494775534,
0.1542953998,
-0.4045763314,
0.789498806,
-0.09893246,
0.074540101,
-0.3011595607,
-0.3436605036,
0.0806855485,
0.326998651,
-0.1045494303,
-0.2697047889,
-0.1011155695,
-0.3848035336,
0.5236684084,
-0.1202233508,
0.1171949506,
0.179261595,
-0.0240709707,
-0.0220325217,
0.4775741398,
0.5835412741,
1.2488862276,
0.0024109697,
0.0323731713,
0.1824418455,
0.0998154506,
0.5584059358,
0.0651487559,
0.1354316622,
-0.2692710161,
0.4557758868,
0.8469360471,
-0.5355398655,
-0.7488530874,
0.4712743163,
0.0391181111,
-0.2995995879,
-0.5069567561,
0.4841688573,
-0.1723602861,
0.5382585526,
0.2594676018,
-0.2553660274,
0.2443729639,
-0.6795629263,
0.0351555943,
0.6354782581,
-0.1486357599,
-0.3409143686,
0.2567012906,
0.0073236474,
-0.4276924431,
1.0390921831,
-0.4250504076,
-0.3957733512,
1.0897535086,
0.45262146,
0.5252922177,
-0.1661524475,
0.3656233847,
0.1023563221,
0.179854691,
-0.0489488915,
0.1198544949,
-0.0736491233,
-0.7640359402,
-0.3499452174,
-0.4015646875,
-0.5529519916,
-0.0456674695,
-0.5069545507,
0.0111554051,
-0.6412422061,
-0.4194787443,
-0.1910895556,
0.2625462711,
-0.5849195719,
0.4855078161,
0.2190459669,
0.5390983224,
-0.914008379,
0.8823167682,
0.5618422031,
-0.2894032598,
-0.7830012441,
-0.2788770795,
-0.1625648439,
-0.6720576882,
1.0026192665,
0.1294159889,
-0.0715825483,
-0.4474523962,
-0.639282465,
-0.7201857567,
1.0566337109,
0.2944356501,
-0.4296786189,
-0.4447770119,
0.3829348385,
0.8559243679,
-0.5875311494,
-0.1316858083,
0.8828917742,
0.6270478368,
0.230451405,
-0.8935068846,
-0.0117902597,
0.0487418622,
0.0861323848,
0.0713207051,
-0.5465057492,
1.1009247303,
-0.597846508,
-0.1515279412,
0.1223024949,
0.5583662391,
0.5386023521,
0.4063153863,
0.546076417,
0.8301256299,
0.8728356361,
-0.0875213295,
1.2727766037,
0.1457457691,
0.1441693306,
0.7577391863,
-0.1147900894,
0.2895225585,
0.1469880342,
-0.4722072184,
1.0046415329,
0.5387705564,
0.0122775063,
0.2462509423,
1.078854084,
-0.1183305532,
-0.4354429841,
0.1094435826,
-0.3346407115,
0.4592811465,
0.559173882,
-0.5293470025,
0.2333769202,
-0.0277605113,
0.0995664075,
0.272040993,
-0.4098521769,
0.5117357373,
0.0739507899,
-0.7043917775,
0.628982842,
0.2360301465,
0.3306170106,
-0.5415385365,
-0.1504853964,
0.0031814876,
0.1681031287,
-0.0754820481,
-0.8752170801,
0.3038122058,
-0.3269452155,
-0.3495658338,
0.1096470356,
0.6180251837,
-0.1265602112,
-0.4286687672,
0.4973124862,
0.3729496598,
0.235448733,
0.11416208,
-0.5049620867,
-0.0778710991,
-0.1449394375,
-0.2546756268,
0.2528321445,
0.6371171474,
-0.2759982646,
1.2041525841,
0.4225510657,
0.2459915131,
0.2207262814,
-0.1683157086,
0.8718819618,
-0.5283058286,
-0.4090678394,
-1.0230379105,
0.178038612,
0.0700007901,
0.1353206486,
0.6686582565,
0.3931928277,
0.6293743849,
-0.0268627685,
0.780228734,
0.3079433143,
0.4042797685,
-0.7758252621,
0.2058212757,
-0.370090276,
0.3902401626,
-0.0661077127,
-1.0485674143,
-0.0907323062,
0.7377826571,
-0.76622051,
0.3897849917,
1.0559376478,
0.1766743213,
0.1484603435,
-0.3174416423,
0.5869404078,
0.1010852903,
0.4938146472,
0.9083475471,
0.9024529457,
0.2100830525,
0.4764710367,
-0.2485706657,
-0.1629361361,
0.1223592088,
-0.7888992429,
-1.2911969423,
-0.6710681915,
-0.4062022865,
-0.2360595018,
0.2443619221,
0.4556781054,
0.6381981969,
-0.4446074963,
-0.3599291444,
-0.0390338674,
0.5894237161,
-0.0744901597,
-0.245420143,
0.3686474562,
-0.2872872055,
-0.484736681,
0.3375767171,
0.194466114,
0.1527647376,
-0.305613488,
-0.2900457978,
-0.3450038135,
0.4174617827,
0.3374001384,
0.5601037145,
-0.8079246283,
-0.6417853236,
-0.5050039291,
0.3978976309,
0.0721130446,
0.9259930849,
-0.774364531,
0.3328203857,
0.5287736654,
0.2441144735,
0.6951965094,
-0.1048664302,
0.3130045533,
-0.6676415801,
0.2194333076,
0.1965838224,
0.4179089069,
0.0457031131,
-0.231349647,
0.5372542739,
0.3274419308,
-0.8267612457,
-0.4818782508,
0.7638795376,
-0.7962135077,
-0.4267878532,
1.2908869982,
-0.4115588069,
0.1874544621,
-0.0233836472,
0.0727228075,
0.3995484114,
-0.2149702609,
0.5834934711,
0.6421324611,
-0.7350333333,
-0.1489006579,
-0.0417142846,
0.2896026671,
0.0541398153,
-0.7529587746,
-0.2531227767,
0.5673043728,
0.5075283051,
0.2420619279,
0.5683926344,
0.2726047039,
0.2974441648,
-0.0714140311,
-0.3916658759,
-0.3020966053,
-0.6074554324,
-0.1848361641,
0.1015792415,
0.2890499234,
-0.0461206026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13126v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13126v1
|
Towards Better Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning for Large Language Models: A Position Paper
| 2023-11-22T03:28:34 | 2023-11-22T03:28:34 |
Chengyu Wang, Junbing Yan, Wei Zhang, Jun Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper delves into the pressing need in Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning
(PEFT) for Large Language Models (LLMs). While LLMs possess remarkable
capabilities, their extensive parameter requirements and associated
computational demands hinder their practicality and scalability for real-world
applications. Our position paper highlights current states and the necessity of
further studying into the topic, and recognizes significant challenges and open
issues that must be addressed to fully harness the powerful abilities of LLMs.
These challenges encompass novel efficient PEFT architectures, PEFT for
different learning settings, PEFT combined with model compression techniques,
and the exploration of PEFT for multi-modal LLMs. By presenting this position
paper, we aim to stimulate further research and foster discussions surrounding
more efficient and accessible PEFT for LLMs.
|
[
-0.5656335354,
-0.8859871626,
0.6922818422,
0.1765068769,
-0.2715662122,
0.0610566027,
-0.6464362144,
-0.4675934315,
-0.1752979308,
0.5418429375,
-0.4646395445,
-0.2702668905,
-0.609310627,
0.0187499858,
-0.246449545,
0.6720811725,
-0.1276879907,
-0.0765740648,
-0.0535801463,
-0.0026258323,
-0.2392426878,
-0.6166321635,
-0.9156439304,
-0.1904797703,
0.5236091018,
0.4299020171,
0.5599864125,
0.5716177225,
0.4348138571,
0.2736872137,
-0.2806960642,
0.5269211531,
-0.6475167274,
0.4003754556,
-0.1794885248,
-0.252869606,
-0.6871068478,
-0.114250958,
1.1128071547,
0.9845190048,
-0.0787678957,
0.1983441412,
0.2261367589,
0.7678887844,
-0.5509527326,
0.0993631259,
-0.6710634828,
-0.2615723908,
-0.2472394407,
-0.1609577239,
-0.2990903854,
-0.1060203612,
0.0469540544,
-0.3331965804,
0.0719162673,
0.1241586208,
0.8973842859,
0.2558513284,
-0.4149539471,
0.2088140994,
-0.7553052306,
0.8825798631,
-0.7901674509,
0.8545997143,
0.2962607145,
0.1299140155,
-0.2893976569,
-0.6466064453,
-0.2268147916,
-0.2577574551,
0.2069541812,
-0.4317436218,
0.0418612435,
0.3022313118,
0.2303750813,
0.4331877232,
-0.3212272525,
0.4230430722,
-0.2103724033,
-0.1658302546,
0.6085464954,
0.2784534097,
-0.1448660046,
0.3614771962,
0.0829983652,
0.0170899369,
-0.939363718,
0.0182624515,
0.6737892032,
0.5900909901,
-0.0082123103,
0.3688741922,
-0.4651039243,
1.0834848881,
0.1311050951,
-0.0918492749,
0.0482331291,
-0.3796942234,
-0.1682684422,
-0.41520679,
0.4490505457,
0.1304919273,
0.1603821218,
-0.058677718,
-0.4709425569,
-0.5653343797,
0.1938565522,
-1.0237437487,
-0.139439404,
0.2001048774,
-0.4553675652,
-0.0896546841,
-0.1158958152,
-0.8471052051,
-0.2801302671,
-0.6571259499,
0.2818753421,
-0.2422224283,
-0.3578868806,
0.2993000746,
0.1521228999,
0.2947585583,
0.4675518274,
-1.0880224705,
0.1867280751,
0.8794987798,
0.669218123,
-0.0332741886,
-0.254365027,
-0.5331757069,
0.200340569,
-0.1828179806,
0.7412292957,
-0.938906312,
-0.2539440393,
-0.0840534121,
0.037852779,
-0.1660047919,
-0.5740513206,
0.7926748991,
-0.393175751,
-0.0537636504,
-0.3601253331,
-0.6733959913,
-0.1237037778,
0.2870476544,
-0.5908878446,
0.9414525628,
0.0927327722,
-0.3464308679,
0.1114754975,
-0.4607214034,
-0.4017986357,
-0.0773293152,
-0.0452715829,
-0.5061606765,
0.4925371706,
0.2270170003,
0.6463114023,
-0.5195742249,
0.368996352,
-0.4854860604,
-0.3766567707,
0.0163416322,
-0.7301698327,
0.410567522,
0.4063082933,
-0.1256400347,
0.0617643856,
-0.7480313778,
0.1200906113,
0.0394353718,
-0.6640611887,
-0.3196696639,
0.2179671675,
0.1630158722,
-0.0771920383,
0.676335752,
-0.2772649825,
0.4300519824,
-0.5269991159,
0.5938372016,
0.7681031227,
-0.1747999936,
0.3917917311,
-0.2818799317,
0.4304195344,
-0.3624641299,
0.3225932121,
-0.1541533917,
-0.1586322635,
-0.6704916954,
-0.2584266663,
0.500351429,
0.1404162496,
-0.2517781556,
0.4577510655,
0.0898894519,
-0.5566233993,
-0.3237678707,
0.204197064,
0.3053084016,
0.3154323995,
0.1825605631,
0.1065031737,
-0.4781310558,
-1.0264281034,
-0.3503859341,
-0.0858552679,
0.0819353163,
0.4866880774,
0.2372855246,
-0.0429737531,
0.6030521393,
-0.3805611432,
-0.0292098783,
-0.1497636586,
-0.0514103435,
0.2142127752,
0.5998388529,
0.5402886868,
-0.8978645802,
-0.5192606449,
-0.0403440893,
-0.096190691,
-0.227131933,
0.0454682447,
0.1439727992,
0.2513787746,
0.6833112836,
-0.3749500215,
-0.2614939511,
0.7260535359,
-0.3323868513,
0.4814781547,
-0.4491578937,
0.2301394492,
-0.8674309254,
0.0849252269,
0.0359105356,
-0.2535973787,
-0.5792479515,
0.3666018844,
0.227463305,
-0.0567969196,
-0.4079403877,
0.5256513953,
-0.5536420345,
0.3291155696,
-0.2768624425,
-0.0956897065,
0.0199161936,
0.3140024841,
-0.096355781,
0.8512569666,
0.6675303578,
-0.642794311,
0.2217814624,
-0.2412263006,
-0.1070953235,
0.4614053369,
-0.6919159889,
0.1049697623,
-0.035611935,
0.0208005067,
-0.8498427272,
-0.2594459951,
0.0865349844,
0.0563941896,
0.7790908217,
-0.1720916182,
-0.8100339174,
-0.054371845,
-0.4532672167,
0.5617231131,
0.4459787309,
-0.4987866282,
0.4910576642,
0.5860816836,
-0.1852122545,
-0.2852841914,
-0.1174908951,
0.0735051334,
-0.5020180941,
-0.5222902298,
0.5443546176,
-0.1657380313,
-0.1613898575,
-0.3117480874,
-0.1651697308,
-0.089245066,
0.2604094148,
-0.0597704947,
-0.1502357721,
-0.3473079503,
0.2533742189,
0.2638605833,
-0.0600009821,
-0.1742804945,
-0.2825322449,
0.6305273771,
-0.4132502377,
-0.2724276781,
-0.2838778198,
0.5698703527,
0.5741926432,
-0.3450691402,
0.7743002176,
0.5342481136,
-0.3639293313,
-0.2803254426,
-0.7602984905,
-0.0307949577,
-0.553383112,
0.565854311,
-0.4166148007,
-1.3537416458,
0.4607189,
-0.6288352013,
0.0237408243,
0.4322834611,
0.6989279985,
-0.0523104705,
1.3011314869,
0.9800348878,
-0.0610971116,
0.6372722387,
-0.0381227173,
0.1213352978,
-0.8028390408,
-0.1367174238,
-0.780565083,
-0.3977470696,
-0.5449182987,
-0.375267446,
0.3460606635,
0.3586724102,
-0.3567799032,
0.1882279664,
-0.4723140299,
0.6248160601,
0.2727898061,
0.0370018147,
0.257920593,
-0.0884932503,
-0.1134639457,
-0.0333728828,
-0.5983752012,
-0.5546514392,
0.8907880187,
0.532278955,
0.8167170882,
0.0795237496,
0.3797204196,
-0.1734560579,
-0.1757910103,
-0.796617806,
0.5803920627,
-0.4585523605,
-0.6474013925,
-0.5267395973,
-0.2431253642,
-0.896690011,
0.1651414931,
0.0022590831,
-0.797422111,
0.2040265054,
0.321855098,
-0.4087712169,
0.4418880939,
-0.7724603415,
0.8212593794,
-0.2324997932,
-0.449765712,
-0.3313427567,
-0.3968073428,
0.1116429418,
-0.3309032917,
0.0501983836,
-0.4141187668,
-0.4618566334,
0.6615829468,
-0.3579205871,
0.8948048949,
-0.2171524167,
-0.4900635183,
0.0231830943,
-0.0132549778,
0.669395268,
0.1328381002,
-0.3385163248,
0.0604706705,
0.206480369,
-0.3783021867,
-0.3659991622,
0.9272100329,
-0.6645776629,
-0.7466947436,
-0.0189432781,
-0.7030965686,
-0.5974883437,
0.1480667293,
0.0218323562,
0.4516837299,
-0.0859567001,
0.4678248763,
1.0125916004,
-0.2166481018,
0.4239901304,
0.5499870181,
-0.0455537066,
-0.1272284538,
1.057836771,
0.3076732159,
0.1977063268,
0.5309608579,
0.1403477341,
-0.2249429673,
-1.1823658943,
-0.198422417,
0.4422525167,
-0.3991346061,
-0.1771238893,
-0.3547930717,
0.0032717257,
-0.3439824283,
-0.1372556388,
-0.7538244128,
-0.3902830482,
-0.5606180429,
0.2033063024,
0.4736138582,
0.3803054392,
0.0261944439,
0.4310109317,
-0.8411251307,
0.2798635066,
0.2111353725,
0.9147956371,
-0.1531704068,
-0.7071401477,
-0.4289385378,
-0.0688667148,
-0.3569194376,
-0.5118028522,
0.1978478134,
0.5699034333,
0.8034882545,
0.3436324,
0.1826738119,
0.7778776288,
-0.5863922834,
0.7369222045,
-0.2005388886,
-0.8927324414,
0.535841465,
-0.5369752645,
0.234868601,
0.7106033564,
0.4259237945,
-0.3207810521,
-0.2335730791,
-0.4222766161,
-1.0741893053,
0.5808836222,
-0.1338511109,
0.4612400234,
0.2465478778,
0.7040244341,
0.285520494,
0.1783214062,
-0.3992778063,
-0.1501684338,
0.3794919848,
-0.1388766617,
-0.1102624536,
-0.6009914279,
-0.0081569012,
-0.5590366125,
0.6817876697,
-0.3077683747,
0.0678285658,
-0.1066394523,
0.0063313004,
-0.3690452874,
0.2972407043,
0.6470804811,
0.8379107714,
-0.164287135,
0.2007387578,
0.3346778452,
-0.2349967808,
-0.0150214583,
0.2195850313,
-0.0394780599,
-0.3665031195,
0.1452683061,
0.8025718331,
0.3154508471,
-0.8728289604,
0.2743206322,
-0.0118689779,
-0.3921584785,
-0.1317225844,
0.2827362418,
0.1397759765,
0.4970030189,
0.2475033253,
-0.1476072967,
0.0390990116,
-0.3087051809,
0.08121676,
0.6109476089,
-0.27702865,
-0.3258448839,
0.6072382331,
0.1893645227,
-0.3947741091,
0.36351794,
0.1264321953,
-0.3209410906,
0.3241189718,
0.495541662,
0.6208361387,
-0.1894068718,
-0.1380141526,
0.1743309796,
0.3464434147,
-0.2510667741,
0.3451628685,
-0.0660084784,
-0.4305515885,
-0.6863386035,
-0.8864497542,
-0.6326106787,
0.4431542456,
-0.3038965166,
0.4525410831,
-0.4831307232,
-0.0865272358,
-0.1283111721,
0.1914273649,
-0.385150522,
-0.0275774375,
0.3196967542,
0.9816687107,
-0.5321935415,
1.0105336905,
0.7475786805,
0.0231634695,
-0.9242455363,
-0.0501453467,
-0.2943432331,
-0.5277557969,
0.3107575476,
-0.1342037469,
-0.1161123738,
0.0653223321,
-0.6560477018,
-0.9555963874,
0.8420807719,
0.9635635614,
-0.7737219334,
-0.1660134196,
0.0940663218,
0.4757628739,
-0.1669170707,
-0.1629921794,
0.7325569987,
0.6504527926,
-0.0937957764,
-1.1639304161,
0.0286489129,
-0.082668066,
0.0652481169,
0.5462691784,
-1.0153434277,
0.8380283713,
0.1332327425,
0.1479421109,
0.1229841039,
0.5550945401,
0.2040075213,
-0.0020948045,
0.5085123181,
0.4304774404,
0.6838272214,
-0.0776744261,
0.8551989198,
-0.4082270563,
0.5637818575,
1.0097351074,
-0.1529547274,
0.9402356148,
0.71224159,
-0.4063874185,
-0.0919855759,
0.8401600718,
-0.0458799638,
0.3075964749,
0.2115872353,
-0.2973335683,
-0.6135499477,
-0.078842096,
-0.4948649108,
0.4417823255,
0.5459230542,
-0.3370938599,
-0.2919443846,
-0.0816289485,
-0.1029698476,
0.0859858617,
-0.3917857409,
0.5129419565,
0.1316815019,
-0.4208628535,
0.7222921252,
0.2593620718,
0.7523490191,
-0.6520813704,
-0.0584387071,
-0.0103415307,
0.0997697115,
-0.0196854752,
-0.4860263765,
0.4504289925,
-0.0507416688,
-0.2018513829,
-0.5237668753,
0.7799539566,
-0.3711625934,
-0.4140075147,
0.2242983282,
0.5671320558,
0.0544813871,
-0.3433533609,
-0.7460095882,
0.2928128541,
-0.1917048097,
-0.5735959411,
0.5927242041,
0.58905828,
0.165291667,
0.4776895046,
0.5261461139,
0.2450987995,
-0.0101536121,
0.141191259,
0.8807629943,
-0.5427039266,
-0.3679656982,
-0.9905072451,
0.3533333242,
0.1608196348,
-0.266084522,
0.6022997499,
0.5302268863,
0.8911191225,
0.0425525047,
0.4508759081,
0.0044083055,
0.5744481683,
-0.5424829721,
0.6955090761,
-0.8100712895,
0.4642466903,
-0.1571133882,
-0.9612017274,
-0.5520854592,
0.4811549187,
-0.28031376,
0.1808848381,
0.4842041135,
0.7464702725,
-0.118440561,
-0.075898923,
0.5764545798,
0.1981016845,
0.3515776396,
0.5351576209,
0.6971934438,
-0.2232967615,
0.4588122368,
-0.3138382435,
-0.0731300414,
-0.3425368965,
-1.002274394,
-0.719561398,
-0.7991948724,
-0.4588356912,
0.0993545279,
-0.008697046,
1.1122123003,
0.9012819529,
-0.9134883285,
-0.2512879074,
-0.0635437593,
0.1622423083,
-0.1225905269,
-0.1366102993,
0.3082512021,
-0.466497004,
-1.0976060629,
0.4574837089,
0.366515696,
-0.0188340303,
-0.3386208117,
-0.0507369377,
-0.1316858679,
0.0797739699,
0.8133580685,
0.3467528522,
-0.7036719918,
-0.4951989353,
-0.1622740924,
0.1150773093,
-0.0069878744,
0.9291927814,
-0.6155406833,
0.0895589739,
0.5053278208,
0.8868978024,
0.37475577,
-0.3098006546,
0.7431064844,
-0.7465254664,
0.009366041,
0.2257890999,
0.4781761467,
0.1542002261,
-0.3899690509,
0.3171263635,
0.0671911389,
-0.6631395817,
-1.0859837532,
0.2648171186,
-1.1697164774,
-0.4950804114,
1.1144143343,
0.1071133986,
0.0758486465,
-0.0680807084,
-0.4438975155,
0.2472420782,
-0.3237566054,
0.5218770504,
0.6622250676,
-0.3176627755,
-0.4401753545,
-0.540569663,
0.4115317166,
0.4319034219,
-0.6507651806,
0.3735842705,
0.3717961609,
0.2161613852,
-0.2993437052,
0.3570485413,
-0.1033641547,
-0.1122654378,
-0.2052696347,
-0.3573247194,
-0.3356909454,
-0.4845986068,
-0.6897041798,
0.6036157608,
0.5404527783,
0.2459646314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13118v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13118v1
|
Combatting Human Trafficking in the Cyberspace: A Natural Language Processing-Based Methodology to Analyze the Language in Online Advertisements
| 2023-11-22T02:45:01 | 2023-11-22T02:45:01 |
Alejandro Rodriguez Perez, Pablo Rivas
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI, 68T50, 62H30, 91C99, 68T068T50, 62H30, 91C99, 68T01, I.2.7; I.5.4; K.4.1; K.4.2
|
This project tackles the pressing issue of human trafficking in online C2C
marketplaces through advanced Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques. We
introduce a novel methodology for generating pseudo-labeled datasets with
minimal supervision, serving as a rich resource for training state-of-the-art
NLP models. Focusing on tasks like Human Trafficking Risk Prediction (HTRP) and
Organized Activity Detection (OAD), we employ cutting-edge Transformer models
for analysis. A key contribution is the implementation of an interpretability
framework using Integrated Gradients, providing explainable insights crucial
for law enforcement. This work not only fills a critical gap in the literature
but also offers a scalable, machine learning-driven approach to combat human
exploitation online. It serves as a foundation for future research and
practical applications, emphasizing the role of machine learning in addressing
complex social issues.
|
[
-0.2972448766,
-0.9797392488,
-0.0508688241,
0.1752612144,
0.0159972925,
0.2472251803,
-0.1034249216,
-1.0554190874,
0.1696976572,
0.6857530475,
-0.5578445792,
-0.5254980326,
-0.4069670737,
0.0809208676,
-0.58359164,
0.9362882376,
0.3656244874,
0.0754245073,
-0.1834556758,
0.0991490856,
-0.3563784659,
-0.758492589,
-0.9874068499,
0.1764519364,
0.3479181826,
0.1368767917,
0.6847681999,
0.8536492586,
0.6975523233,
0.3739958107,
-0.0056082262,
-0.005955067,
-0.7493736148,
-0.2786407173,
-0.345579356,
-0.251732558,
-0.5709418058,
0.0510734543,
0.0893592089,
0.6489675641,
-0.4436937273,
0.159637183,
-0.0117206788,
0.5379824638,
-0.6953092813,
-0.0570729375,
-0.7173168063,
-0.1249256581,
-0.3341391683,
-0.3205973208,
-0.4221915007,
-0.2878343463,
0.4631146789,
-0.7176771164,
0.4867298603,
0.3411355019,
0.6738951206,
0.0808928683,
-0.5196858644,
-0.6597687006,
-0.8298464417,
0.7884192467,
-0.3769490719,
0.2590645552,
0.6931630373,
0.5724280477,
-0.0285239555,
-1.16451931,
-0.3258117437,
0.0716185346,
-0.3474344611,
-0.2020764202,
-0.5228736997,
0.1623157561,
-0.0328569226,
0.024205761,
-0.6092690229,
0.0834411979,
-0.7476774454,
-0.2493254095,
0.7762904167,
0.2499133646,
0.5445700884,
0.0686012134,
-0.536270082,
0.1882453114,
-0.6340298057,
0.2050998509,
0.7570682168,
0.4112826884,
-0.3608385026,
0.4922314286,
-0.0557584129,
0.6715175509,
-0.0080439514,
0.3518477976,
0.0360509977,
-0.2611615062,
-0.0983146802,
0.1927039176,
0.5836647153,
0.473924607,
0.2472924292,
-0.1255241185,
-0.1555529088,
0.1987341046,
0.9520599842,
-0.6174784303,
-0.1044568941,
0.2022978812,
-0.6894533038,
-0.4443583488,
0.1688333005,
-1.2448549271,
-0.3761541247,
-0.3629855514,
0.1792256683,
-0.008756524,
-0.1590502709,
0.4295796156,
-0.1854504347,
0.4885562062,
-0.0017783401,
-0.6036650538,
0.6772228479,
0.5286705494,
0.7439137697,
-0.2871783078,
0.1408239901,
-0.4655414224,
0.1180425733,
0.0047696168,
0.6649239063,
-0.4534608424,
-0.1273250878,
0.318495363,
0.2686476409,
0.0799085945,
-0.4852519929,
0.8680340052,
-0.9763517976,
0.0978033245,
0.150821045,
-0.2998536527,
-0.2733604014,
0.528531909,
-0.6806383729,
0.6981521249,
0.1193816066,
-0.7665483952,
-0.0222576298,
-0.9987234473,
-0.5650146008,
0.2553813756,
0.312012285,
-0.5675959587,
-0.2013922036,
0.0877268463,
0.2875399888,
-0.1798884422,
0.2352060229,
-0.2512764931,
-0.4616500437,
0.2443254441,
-0.2695014179,
1.0115134716,
0.2303683609,
-0.3502179682,
0.2238484025,
-0.5854858756,
-0.3379055262,
0.3754589558,
-0.1656140536,
-0.1830979586,
0.2708189487,
0.4561047852,
0.2893392444,
0.3903810084,
-0.5226775408,
0.0987224355,
-0.6497519016,
0.3509711325,
0.7222961783,
-0.0500878915,
0.4040040374,
0.0406999737,
0.7432751656,
-0.2278946787,
0.2744728923,
0.0962482244,
-0.7893176675,
-0.685644269,
0.0883271396,
0.0136454897,
0.6579360962,
-0.8295188546,
0.4357371032,
-0.1685772389,
-0.3560029268,
-0.6369447112,
-0.1339309216,
0.182463333,
0.3667197526,
0.6503561139,
-0.1311189085,
-0.9209222794,
-0.8809461594,
-0.5839369893,
0.0518912449,
0.0405569673,
0.0402900353,
0.3843440115,
-0.6733088493,
1.132152319,
-0.6716750264,
-0.7786194682,
-0.5224995017,
0.429033488,
-0.0105287908,
0.3803819716,
0.4985762835,
-1.0631403923,
-0.6732054949,
-0.1052897125,
-0.5960991383,
-0.0567707568,
-0.096138455,
-0.128389746,
-0.1406260282,
0.5208714604,
-0.3442856073,
0.8034007549,
0.2208973914,
-0.4812051356,
0.3574978709,
-0.4454348683,
0.0460205302,
-0.622307539,
0.1281442791,
0.4856352508,
-0.4870143831,
-1.1192770004,
-0.0475020371,
-0.2991525233,
-0.2624528706,
-0.7709368467,
0.2641275525,
-0.161471054,
0.0254933499,
-0.6881334782,
0.2005076557,
-0.3294126391,
0.3760761321,
0.1525077671,
0.5880380869,
0.4175774157,
-0.5265413523,
0.4352068603,
0.2360809445,
-0.268298924,
0.749034524,
-0.7094734311,
0.2989081442,
-0.4192756414,
0.2350866795,
-0.8089502454,
-0.2236981392,
0.3958980143,
-0.5126051307,
0.0461756885,
-0.3698031604,
-0.2838484943,
-0.3937492669,
-0.1885164827,
0.5719816685,
0.3151472211,
-0.2522148788,
0.404597491,
0.8561164141,
0.1042974368,
-0.560634017,
-0.5209103823,
0.4630247056,
-0.4013343155,
-0.4321402013,
0.3416396677,
0.2251537442,
-0.2068116367,
-0.1675477773,
0.4425621033,
-0.4698876739,
0.399271965,
0.1295366883,
0.4769037366,
0.1131698564,
-0.4322272837,
-0.2619040608,
-0.3864743114,
0.4773195088,
-0.2487894148,
0.6195428371,
0.0254890155,
-0.084940061,
-0.7607672811,
0.3436072767,
-0.0106308265,
0.0336326361,
0.9185465574,
0.8391768932,
-0.5087593794,
-0.0586931333,
0.0366937108,
0.0706251189,
-0.5433331132,
0.1952329874,
0.1595165581,
-0.7590919137,
0.147787869,
-0.0878384337,
-0.1050138101,
0.3930039406,
0.6049262881,
-0.3502457738,
1.1833095551,
1.0563716888,
-0.2156650722,
0.3492644429,
-0.286801666,
0.5336389542,
-0.240156889,
-0.2243132144,
-0.5082195401,
-0.3843900263,
-0.9421731234,
-0.5496771932,
0.4263699353,
-0.2327275723,
0.1318521351,
0.757363975,
-0.5340925455,
0.4026203454,
0.2289609611,
-0.0346048772,
0.2359522879,
0.0661424473,
0.3814936876,
-0.1188786328,
-0.4512676597,
-0.6225191355,
1.0788491964,
0.2871506512,
0.5973781943,
0.1085165367,
-0.1166315526,
0.9121946692,
0.5016380548,
-0.6532974243,
0.3461479545,
0.1147959754,
-0.988847971,
-0.0226727743,
-0.3471339345,
-1.5764584541,
0.2084306329,
-0.279689312,
-0.9684348702,
0.0873844326,
0.2309218496,
-0.133630991,
0.3629771173,
-0.2248408794,
0.7957957387,
-0.264423877,
-0.3751500547,
-0.5740230083,
-1.0279397964,
0.2848001719,
-0.0421285257,
0.725974977,
0.1045036539,
-0.0207466688,
0.6370847225,
-0.0913158059,
1.0427488089,
-0.1760265827,
-0.052138865,
0.3853951395,
-0.0297389515,
0.6719971299,
-0.4109871984,
0.0395656601,
0.2200723737,
-0.2678803205,
-0.5746692419,
-0.0201440323,
0.4293121099,
-0.4948182106,
-0.0504544042,
-0.2869553864,
-0.2257888913,
0.0071538854,
0.1316578835,
0.12631993,
0.2863503993,
-0.4597098231,
0.2253980488,
0.4564798474,
-0.3732005358,
0.3054025769,
0.1366831213,
0.0161334183,
-0.449336499,
1.1595672369,
-0.254412204,
0.0987840891,
0.4691284597,
0.2075301707,
-0.5517632961,
-0.3866451681,
-0.3655568063,
0.1444172263,
-0.6949133277,
0.1045927629,
-0.85330832,
-0.0058635706,
-0.5181890726,
-0.52335006,
-0.3832074702,
-0.0539322011,
-0.2721467316,
0.1226754785,
-0.1223115847,
0.8848913908,
0.0775249302,
0.8582280278,
-0.6873409152,
0.6929321289,
0.1700817049,
0.2597324252,
-0.0648243278,
-0.3648569584,
-0.8136993051,
0.1662321389,
-0.4260073602,
-0.8438518643,
0.6435655355,
-0.1692235321,
0.4124755859,
0.5659665465,
0.1471346021,
0.6675518155,
-0.0488830544,
0.8084295988,
0.1913439482,
-0.8395888209,
0.5317400694,
-0.6279417872,
-0.308986038,
0.4387355745,
0.7279739976,
-0.6016469002,
0.025542628,
-0.7188783884,
-1.0511826277,
0.9018001556,
0.6377325058,
-0.0060074683,
0.181973204,
-0.0633057728,
-0.3618483245,
0.5136740804,
-0.9741484523,
-0.4962306917,
-0.0378901437,
-0.2543608248,
0.1723115295,
-0.2239002138,
0.0691904649,
-0.1967888623,
0.6189724207,
-0.1822226048,
0.2403218448,
-0.1363679469,
-0.4738956392,
-0.0558176413,
-0.0811337754,
0.4504964054,
0.7528204918,
-0.1375267953,
0.0480928645,
-0.065590404,
-0.4866104126,
0.129144758,
-0.2290577888,
-0.0877036303,
-0.288379699,
0.3978627622,
0.5092630982,
-0.0995396301,
-1.0677913427,
0.9224362373,
-0.1876231134,
0.0050653918,
-0.5813221335,
-0.2482482046,
-0.1950727105,
-0.0635573715,
0.3358803988,
0.1393767595,
0.4435848594,
-0.3515577912,
0.2426622361,
0.3304257691,
-0.8675669432,
-0.5017703176,
0.9481034875,
0.3493676186,
-0.6766104698,
0.6394020915,
-0.3181042075,
-0.4955599308,
0.7172811627,
0.5479068756,
0.9089733362,
-0.1296211183,
0.1713659167,
0.2890354991,
0.6036706567,
0.0131482463,
0.0656462237,
-0.054959096,
-0.7123605609,
-0.4540043771,
-0.3483599126,
-0.142002821,
0.1307177246,
-0.7413029671,
0.5633876324,
-0.4249450862,
-0.2392790765,
-0.050921537,
-0.4044115543,
-0.7168400288,
0.2313104272,
0.3069649935,
0.489192009,
-0.7060672641,
0.7121562958,
0.6250907183,
0.0392576791,
-0.0311410408,
0.0149970148,
0.2922762334,
-0.4483555853,
0.5674235225,
0.5116855502,
-0.4011963606,
0.1892980933,
-0.8906357884,
-0.6695305705,
0.6140305996,
0.0825119689,
-0.2634445429,
0.0364190452,
0.6681958437,
0.7809850574,
-0.406520009,
0.0212990344,
0.902530551,
0.5648425817,
-0.2460154891,
-0.4970702827,
-0.221281305,
-0.1753446758,
-0.1606530696,
0.1519373953,
-0.0409333259,
0.2971598804,
0.0884863138,
-0.5097913742,
-0.0596946739,
0.3874911666,
-0.1079774499,
0.4412727058,
0.6508423686,
0.4246219695,
0.3903499246,
0.0653300062,
0.9546125531,
-0.1372528225,
0.5828151107,
0.7802507877,
-0.0564617999,
0.4272181988,
0.394879967,
-0.3103579581,
0.5456417799,
0.3649048209,
0.0161522701,
0.2723990679,
0.4561588764,
-0.012572187,
-0.263328284,
-0.2958632708,
0.3164660931,
0.6942218542,
0.5115789175,
-0.1544315964,
-0.2997871637,
0.0839635283,
-0.1253119856,
0.3209158182,
-0.3283264339,
0.8302839398,
-0.1468584388,
-0.1218756214,
0.2721894085,
0.4593792558,
0.7998026013,
-0.4604099989,
-0.0370594524,
0.4547138512,
0.1694758236,
-0.1774251014,
-0.5166808367,
0.7947390676,
0.1382756531,
0.0833513066,
-0.5535170436,
0.8863750696,
-0.289704293,
-0.4657715559,
0.5227081776,
0.290998131,
0.0957320407,
-0.176321283,
-0.9791586995,
-0.1375899017,
0.0077172709,
-0.0754217878,
0.2600308359,
0.0728422701,
-0.0511627346,
0.8995825052,
1.0664218664,
0.1974977106,
0.0505432971,
-0.1685433686,
0.7164522409,
-0.8953623176,
-0.8887705207,
-0.8363900185,
0.5390148759,
-0.4554434121,
-0.117165938,
0.5333585739,
0.5128319263,
0.8242489696,
-0.0347511247,
0.4762759209,
-0.1742285192,
0.5200800896,
-0.2024620175,
0.4921213686,
-0.3276588619,
0.4734416008,
-0.0854648799,
-0.4473754466,
-0.1381922513,
0.4162687361,
-0.1689057052,
-0.4053217471,
0.2778538465,
0.7483898997,
-0.2908788323,
0.0323637463,
0.0768695474,
-0.1430170834,
0.585013032,
0.0225883573,
0.9767072201,
-0.5185583234,
0.5760193467,
-0.2248480618,
0.1405386329,
-0.4495700896,
-0.6379965544,
-0.8816071153,
-0.2840308249,
-0.2178225666,
-0.3760087788,
-0.2527455688,
1.0699121952,
0.8234336376,
-0.717659533,
-0.7078405023,
-0.1576113701,
0.1599369794,
-0.4351924658,
-0.3251008391,
0.1952418834,
-0.2476520985,
-0.7834022641,
0.480487138,
0.276588589,
0.0583086796,
-0.4417663813,
0.146289289,
-0.4748975635,
0.1674616635,
0.7051664591,
-0.0544130839,
-0.3023085296,
0.1702279747,
-0.2306289673,
-0.1115590483,
0.0859859139,
1.2390561104,
-0.6949898601,
0.5359464884,
0.3975076377,
0.9225411415,
0.4656764269,
0.35592103,
0.7046243548,
-0.8603134155,
0.2821210325,
0.4322120845,
0.0811177269,
0.3780048192,
-0.6849610209,
0.4813920856,
0.445836544,
-0.2696594,
-0.6848404408,
0.1610271931,
-0.7787586451,
-0.56488204,
0.7969197631,
-0.0285302363,
-0.2558580339,
-0.9812040925,
-0.1064033136,
0.3253854215,
-0.1836326122,
0.9138317704,
0.1525407881,
0.1385586411,
0.2417053878,
-0.8102108836,
0.606107533,
-0.2245364487,
-1.0914816856,
0.0313217342,
0.3831298649,
-0.0257462393,
0.2068243921,
0.4738002717,
0.0812033936,
-0.0468899794,
-0.5132151246,
0.1003886685,
0.3044383228,
-0.3077850044,
-0.4292330742,
0.4060002267,
-0.7286976576,
-0.0307862293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13110v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13110v2
|
White-Box Transformers via Sparse Rate Reduction: Compression Is All There Is?
| 2023-11-22T02:23:32 | 2023-11-24T09:18:44 |
Yaodong Yu, Sam Buchanan, Druv Pai, Tianzhe Chu, Ziyang Wu, Shengbang Tong, Hao Bai, Yuexiang Zhai, Benjamin D. Haeffele, Yi Ma
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
In this paper, we contend that a natural objective of representation learning
is to compress and transform the distribution of the data, say sets of tokens,
towards a low-dimensional Gaussian mixture supported on incoherent subspaces.
The goodness of such a representation can be evaluated by a principled measure,
called sparse rate reduction, that simultaneously maximizes the intrinsic
information gain and extrinsic sparsity of the learned representation. From
this perspective, popular deep network architectures, including transformers,
can be viewed as realizing iterative schemes to optimize this measure.
Particularly, we derive a transformer block from alternating optimization on
parts of this objective: the multi-head self-attention operator compresses the
representation by implementing an approximate gradient descent step on the
coding rate of the features, and the subsequent multi-layer perceptron
sparsifies the features. This leads to a family of white-box transformer-like
deep network architectures, named CRATE, which are mathematically fully
interpretable. We show, by way of a novel connection between denoising and
compression, that the inverse to the aforementioned compressive encoding can be
realized by the same class of CRATE architectures. Thus, the so-derived
white-box architectures are universal to both encoders and decoders.
Experiments show that these networks, despite their simplicity, indeed learn to
compress and sparsify representations of large-scale real-world image and text
datasets, and achieve performance very close to highly engineered
transformer-based models: ViT, MAE, DINO, BERT, and GPT2. We believe the
proposed computational framework demonstrates great potential in bridging the
gap between theory and practice of deep learning, from a unified perspective of
data compression. Code is available at: https://ma-lab-berkeley.github.io/CRATE .
|
[
-0.6431710124,
-0.372020781,
0.1022650674,
0.1828902513,
-0.286750257,
0.0095352363,
-0.3304702938,
-0.2803605795,
0.437022239,
0.1002169624,
-0.710832715,
-0.1321867257,
-0.6419329047,
0.0326446407,
-0.6412275434,
0.8102932572,
0.1837611049,
-0.165539071,
-0.0289403163,
-0.1084109172,
-0.5035179257,
-0.5182521343,
-0.5067039132,
-0.2035789639,
0.2510463893,
0.0336775593,
0.6164977551,
0.515507102,
0.3269886672,
0.3077453375,
0.0046124328,
-0.121663034,
-0.8867531419,
0.0256381612,
0.3277746439,
-0.2358673066,
0.1395330131,
-0.2132168114,
0.5569448471,
0.6435322762,
-0.1620713472,
0.1354046315,
0.301535517,
0.603854537,
-0.6487337351,
0.2709382474,
-0.5995720029,
0.6390771866,
0.2712814808,
-0.4495942891,
-0.4346966445,
0.1864735931,
-0.2189296186,
-0.4659112692,
0.8637814522,
-0.2285387069,
0.6044000983,
0.5968292952,
-0.1217085049,
0.0220064837,
-0.7354825735,
0.6181326509,
-0.003028369,
0.5218701959,
-0.2430952638,
0.4200713634,
0.0881412029,
-0.7641701102,
-0.4056128263,
-0.0241533816,
-0.366636157,
0.338409245,
-0.568025291,
0.0217297748,
0.3134108186,
0.6478446126,
-0.4940316379,
-0.1154870018,
-0.6803868413,
-0.2223054171,
0.2566989362,
0.1373972148,
-0.1096233502,
-0.1032104269,
-0.4197607338,
-0.2742830217,
-0.60501647,
0.101550445,
0.2061982751,
0.0514415614,
-0.1791184098,
0.1618722975,
-0.0203353651,
0.48078686,
-0.0233791322,
0.3493120968,
0.0816911981,
0.0200800989,
-0.2617925406,
0.1286252141,
0.7321982384,
-0.0216380712,
0.1730557382,
-0.4340123534,
-0.2364219576,
0.4388678372,
0.8244672418,
-0.9625912905,
-0.3487761319,
-0.0926205814,
-0.6622200012,
-0.2690595984,
0.1821760535,
-0.6815071702,
-0.1337313354,
-0.2472551614,
0.4821658134,
0.1622535586,
-0.1242628545,
0.3408789933,
-0.0402235314,
0.0855069533,
0.2448949069,
-0.925712347,
0.7048935294,
0.437392652,
0.8648757339,
-0.1159587279,
0.0011377539,
-0.4564835131,
-0.0310036242,
-0.3202601969,
0.7026526332,
-0.1528742462,
-0.3672792017,
-0.0192674194,
0.016083654,
0.3088481724,
-0.3717852235,
0.3660261333,
-0.4773663282,
-0.3905997574,
0.1892196685,
-0.0687400699,
-0.0242617205,
0.0643907189,
-1.0410894156,
0.7737761736,
0.2206667662,
-0.2360936701,
0.0491528474,
-0.4354094267,
-0.6362472773,
-0.0703842789,
-0.1436319053,
-0.7239906788,
0.6111782193,
0.2196625918,
0.563303411,
-0.3944336176,
0.07902845,
-0.3041180968,
-0.6781938076,
0.2373370826,
-0.7369255424,
0.6052051783,
0.4573872089,
-0.3917387724,
-0.2871666253,
-0.7750518918,
-0.1808265001,
0.1684119701,
-0.1635274589,
0.0813311115,
-0.2014570236,
0.0861267745,
0.2148997784,
-0.2392118126,
-0.5257880092,
0.2377010733,
-0.1761387736,
0.7033682466,
0.687056005,
-0.1764016747,
0.4981009662,
-0.0794379786,
0.3666581511,
-0.2655782402,
0.3145377636,
-0.1011927575,
-0.2342881113,
-0.8060563207,
-0.2546040416,
0.18576096,
-0.0148670459,
-0.2290776819,
0.4887283146,
-0.5793367624,
-0.1250620186,
-0.6306952834,
-0.0119070671,
-0.0504951589,
0.3124632239,
0.7052773237,
-0.3449033797,
-0.4137898982,
-0.7461791635,
0.1345092058,
0.1846434623,
-0.0158461891,
0.0620405599,
0.2452285588,
0.074535206,
0.5457445979,
-0.5827977061,
-0.402685523,
-0.0285835732,
0.2792751491,
0.2480218858,
0.6731559038,
0.3099778295,
-0.9030644298,
-0.4313148856,
-0.2331049591,
-0.4474778771,
-0.0254438464,
-0.1578234583,
0.0897887722,
-0.2020590454,
0.5173817277,
-0.6245725155,
0.7289586067,
0.3949773908,
0.2692610025,
0.1105520874,
-0.1957890838,
-0.0659265369,
-0.7269454002,
-0.1474977136,
-0.033492621,
-0.2158218324,
-0.6962838769,
-0.047581505,
0.1711689383,
-0.5146437883,
-0.3157258928,
0.2241241187,
-0.5030797124,
-0.2670222521,
-0.1735146046,
-0.2035392076,
0.1636837572,
0.9061992168,
0.0994302332,
0.7269284129,
0.526453793,
-0.6055969596,
0.1035972163,
0.3584816456,
-0.1331276894,
0.532974422,
-0.7829966545,
0.0995750725,
-0.4130038619,
0.2406474501,
-0.9747563601,
0.329464674,
0.1667501032,
-0.4580441713,
0.4824038744,
-0.1731890142,
-0.3190866411,
-0.4368761778,
-0.3577037454,
0.4976265132,
0.7635067701,
-0.6480409503,
0.3094435036,
0.175254032,
0.3644020557,
-0.8645604253,
-1.0227771997,
0.1273300052,
0.1236076131,
-0.2389296889,
0.6424424052,
-0.1434906274,
0.3472023606,
0.4177663624,
-0.3957870305,
-0.1293751597,
0.2093259394,
0.1646687388,
0.1202344969,
-0.1709275842,
0.2161670476,
-0.0964590162,
-0.2563468516,
0.0390964337,
-0.5363195539,
0.4734695852,
0.041461993,
-0.26854074,
-0.1725831479,
0.3944374323,
0.3840416968,
-0.0912130848,
0.5379898548,
0.8239155412,
-0.3478534818,
-0.3404566944,
-0.4392786026,
-0.217216149,
-0.458491236,
0.3352811337,
-0.5827140212,
-1.0137652159,
0.3809021115,
0.1280803531,
-0.3511112928,
0.5394265056,
0.4976935685,
0.0599306114,
0.7966449857,
0.6496585011,
-0.0918406174,
0.3651362956,
-0.9345831275,
0.4233434796,
-0.7235956192,
-0.1146440282,
-0.5058483481,
-0.6408404708,
-0.4833885729,
-0.2681842446,
0.4215924442,
-0.0814514905,
-0.0501650944,
0.4195666611,
-0.899780333,
0.4729551971,
0.2523471713,
0.3100525141,
0.1039251983,
0.4216035306,
0.2461281717,
0.0459557474,
-0.7752031684,
0.1171635464,
0.8513566256,
0.2969024777,
0.9236510396,
-0.1438054889,
0.5333499908,
0.5387281775,
0.3106222153,
-0.909188211,
0.241691187,
-0.3440066576,
-0.1719952822,
-0.1107544228,
-0.5609762669,
-1.1710935831,
0.1657134891,
-0.4173848033,
-0.5196247697,
0.5290769339,
0.0210795291,
-0.2951029241,
0.3208524883,
-0.5423283577,
0.9693599939,
0.1132348627,
-0.2549908459,
-0.5068098307,
-0.5453998446,
0.2448426485,
0.1053784862,
-0.195644781,
0.1008139178,
-0.031873446,
0.3458482325,
-0.4194223583,
0.7169741988,
-0.0620458312,
0.2347434312,
0.3214057386,
0.1762607843,
0.3142477274,
0.0758797005,
0.212159127,
0.322522223,
-0.3169853687,
-0.4363715053,
-1.0111289024,
0.4984826148,
-0.7953224182,
-0.2987077236,
-0.0177554544,
-0.6002004743,
0.1052767187,
-0.0772653371,
0.2766096592,
1.1253519058,
-0.1542443633,
0.406796664,
0.5470384359,
0.0227037966,
0.2929525375,
0.0841071829,
0.4859091043,
-0.3732535541,
0.9133421779,
0.1325078011,
0.1500325501,
0.7739570737,
-0.0689769462,
-0.4689495862,
-0.5898771286,
-0.2477054447,
0.0734627545,
-1.0520144701,
-0.5203592777,
-0.6653136611,
-0.4178943932,
-0.3487700522,
-0.3321782649,
-0.2811519504,
-0.3856170774,
-0.3755836785,
0.0395528786,
-0.0116830608,
0.7755844593,
-0.1775645614,
0.4625403583,
-0.6073099971,
0.5530739427,
0.5184301734,
0.3895847499,
0.1524241716,
-0.3380226493,
-0.3721636236,
-0.2810744345,
-0.319056958,
-0.547862649,
0.3909583092,
0.0918747261,
0.529337883,
0.1577473581,
0.1716285795,
0.8195217848,
-0.4535995424,
0.4110022485,
0.3808209002,
-0.8235049248,
0.0040373802,
0.432667315,
-0.0180981252,
0.3927161694,
0.2969990075,
-0.4319350123,
-0.1710402071,
-0.7451039553,
-0.3802786767,
0.6494141221,
0.2960763872,
0.45673576,
-0.0105972476,
0.2160357237,
0.1280842274,
0.3716406822,
-0.8961490393,
-0.4698492885,
-0.4787048697,
-0.4408308268,
-0.148969993,
-0.3565931618,
-0.0700195581,
-0.2360977381,
0.2270169854,
-0.2006999701,
0.8926278353,
0.3590261638,
-0.47128281,
0.0053786733,
0.3656915724,
0.380713582,
0.1684241742,
-0.1076795682,
0.4257923663,
-0.0015425017,
-0.4465436935,
0.5549249053,
0.2482700944,
-0.1044963449,
-0.0536006354,
0.1085108668,
1.0655317307,
0.2931901515,
-0.0035182142,
0.7457586527,
-0.2735848725,
-0.2280471623,
-0.1183352843,
-0.1420919895,
-0.3737367094,
0.0455149561,
0.4170776606,
0.6367750764,
0.4484390616,
-0.1937892735,
0.1734936237,
0.5969110727,
-0.6250441074,
-0.3553617001,
0.6089338064,
0.073316969,
-0.179622367,
0.3896978498,
-0.2656768262,
-0.4825478196,
0.5160288811,
0.6287509799,
1.073227644,
0.223772645,
0.2150267065,
0.3720374405,
0.5211589336,
-0.0947771817,
-0.2861840129,
-0.6992901564,
-0.6385428905,
-0.5803601742,
-0.4802654386,
0.0291306861,
0.2322850078,
-0.4689996541,
0.3491735756,
-0.2707904875,
0.1005033776,
-0.1370376647,
-0.1739686877,
-0.8597650528,
-0.0172076542,
0.2128450722,
0.849306047,
-0.5920641422,
0.5297712088,
0.2299423665,
-0.2348832041,
-0.5636547804,
-0.098190546,
-0.3643274307,
-0.7260844111,
0.6150534153,
0.4640039206,
-0.1240135282,
0.2566611469,
-0.510012567,
-0.5826513767,
0.8348156214,
0.6406910419,
-0.3955750465,
0.2300679386,
0.1675904542,
0.3644255698,
-0.2409394532,
0.3398376107,
0.4617287517,
0.1642733216,
0.0458508469,
-0.3794521391,
0.0472587086,
-0.3938515186,
0.1460643709,
0.3181866407,
-0.5160367489,
0.6413804889,
0.1163671687,
-0.3885558844,
-0.0792937875,
0.5386015773,
-0.3762179017,
-0.0449137278,
0.4791704118,
0.7773260474,
0.2761802971,
-0.1362101585,
1.006914258,
-0.2926968932,
0.68684268,
0.4318922758,
0.3285999298,
0.2022501677,
0.4225905836,
-0.2832273543,
0.1641069502,
0.2606946528,
-0.189858824,
0.6779233217,
0.3680919409,
-0.1503285468,
-0.0655487031,
-0.0575226657,
-0.2470943183,
0.14175497,
0.2406274527,
-0.1321993619,
-0.3133704662,
0.0180184953,
-0.4186439216,
-0.025860941,
-0.49941203,
0.6150465012,
0.0054337126,
-0.3480149508,
0.957139194,
-0.3783521056,
0.6708703637,
-0.5967552066,
-0.2616654336,
-0.0809839815,
-0.0466805175,
-0.1676311344,
-0.7190437913,
0.3147192895,
-0.4475582242,
-0.1235213876,
-0.3666466177,
0.9399140477,
-0.4296085536,
-0.2197405249,
0.2090666294,
0.1270189136,
0.0285635181,
-0.0807056874,
-0.6704728603,
0.2874218524,
-0.1907239705,
-0.0496017449,
0.117240943,
0.2748554051,
0.3777819574,
0.4676991999,
0.44300583,
0.3332795799,
0.113771826,
0.0598507822,
0.9390545487,
-0.4026645124,
-0.5519010425,
-0.5861449838,
0.4151379764,
-0.1104742885,
0.016987022,
0.1254188865,
0.3645092547,
0.8495735526,
-0.3154661357,
0.7016997933,
0.0683378354,
-0.2072104663,
-0.5101021528,
0.3407444358,
-0.6170983315,
0.0342403613,
-0.1554098725,
-0.9507906437,
-0.4692009687,
0.7295738459,
0.1018324643,
-0.1587411612,
0.7746090293,
0.8966342211,
-0.3777581453,
-0.0678851977,
0.5738792419,
-0.0652875081,
0.2141231745,
0.7098712921,
0.7569738626,
-0.7313964367,
0.9435124397,
-0.5682659149,
0.0916688293,
-0.1219908968,
-0.6263840199,
-0.7760660648,
-0.7209197283,
-0.2016553134,
-0.1736482084,
-0.0881446525,
0.7534115314,
0.8448311687,
-0.6473250389,
-0.2127095759,
-0.3892005086,
0.0570192672,
-0.3619027138,
-0.2365692705,
0.3447012901,
-0.6574444175,
-0.6004983187,
0.1099792495,
0.5322340727,
0.1687722206,
-0.4825054705,
-0.1329525262,
0.4380061328,
-0.3029145896,
0.5975270271,
0.319164753,
-0.3541816473,
-0.1424580961,
0.0157313403,
-0.1498885304,
0.4440505803,
1.1950646639,
-1.0813336372,
0.541021049,
0.3693613708,
1.0106146336,
0.9267571568,
-0.2197932601,
0.2188164592,
-0.9006480575,
0.4448998272,
0.0787894949,
0.5441022515,
0.3182761073,
-0.4691556394,
0.5873012543,
0.4079897404,
-0.4157441556,
-0.7454060316,
0.1762782037,
-1.0022099018,
-0.2198990583,
0.7695441842,
0.1386116743,
-0.5117087364,
-0.1744730771,
-0.1285908222,
0.3521369696,
-0.4634582996,
0.8117198944,
0.2541234493,
0.0798228607,
-0.461029768,
-0.4666834474,
0.5078135133,
0.2979195714,
-0.5821278095,
0.0342183188,
0.3730694354,
-0.0664431006,
0.3846476078,
0.5964819789,
-0.0905364901,
0.384942621,
-0.0196889099,
0.1914008558,
-0.1763094068,
-0.4146639407,
-0.7128198743,
0.3564372659,
-0.3394777775,
-0.2619228363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.09457v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.09457v1
|
Functional Analytics for Document Ordering for Curriculum Development and Comprehension
| 2023-11-22T02:13:27 | 2023-11-22T02:13:27 |
Arturo N. Villanueva Jr., Steven J. Simske
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, K.3.2
|
We propose multiple techniques for automatic document order generation for
(1) curriculum development and for (2) creation of optimal reading order for
use in learning, training, and other content-sequencing applications. Such
techniques could potentially be used to improve comprehension, identify areas
that need expounding, generate curricula, and improve search engine results. We
advance two main techniques: The first uses document similarities through
various methods. The second uses entropy against the backdrop of topics
generated through Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA). In addition, we try the
same methods on the summarized documents and compare them against the results
obtained using the complete documents. Our results showed that while the
document orders for our control document sets (biographies, novels, and
Wikipedia articles) could not be predicted using our methods, our test
documents (textbooks, courses, journal papers, dissertations) provided more
reliability. We also demonstrated that summarized documents were good stand-ins
for the complete documents for the purposes of ordering.
|
[
-0.4195752144,
-0.7867025137,
0.57418859,
0.1243216768,
-0.2116123885,
0.0663618371,
0.156989947,
-0.3982427418,
0.3649306595,
0.6167737842,
-0.5126296878,
-0.6636884809,
-0.5009970069,
-0.0412984453,
-0.5299393535,
0.7515612245,
0.0685191974,
0.2874914706,
-0.4607926011,
-0.1916958392,
-0.4313404262,
-0.2354209125,
-0.6367625594,
-0.183847785,
0.6059285402,
0.6686595082,
0.5684919953,
0.9383379817,
0.8955606222,
0.3342702389,
0.0829563439,
0.0687165707,
-0.3916456997,
0.4095715582,
-0.0322678499,
-0.4810916781,
-0.516523242,
-0.0301709268,
0.5138527751,
0.758802712,
-0.2185824662,
0.1941136867,
0.0406516902,
0.614295125,
-0.857539773,
0.2952359915,
-0.2099925429,
-0.0325630382,
-0.1276285648,
-0.4773008525,
-0.712937057,
-0.4963027835,
0.3287624717,
-0.553671658,
0.5100694895,
0.0544777066,
0.5868642926,
0.0664259866,
-0.3102121949,
-0.7440279722,
-0.4144467115,
0.714598,
-0.4071499109,
0.4157740176,
0.663472414,
-0.0375601314,
-0.0460143685,
-0.8258885145,
-0.5411547422,
0.194301948,
-0.1139400005,
0.4902241826,
0.3204569519,
0.16136235,
0.1930121481,
0.2250379175,
-1.0024838448,
0.4138393998,
-0.5846018791,
-0.023928972,
0.8317344785,
0.4430516064,
0.4154638052,
0.0685937032,
-0.0287913326,
-0.4852976203,
-0.4332920909,
0.1454975158,
0.4790906906,
-0.1697581857,
0.098374337,
0.7002674937,
-0.2985171378,
0.7180918455,
-0.1282081902,
-0.1594331712,
0.3028674126,
-0.5739770532,
-0.418746233,
0.066909194,
0.4012309313,
0.3474701941,
-0.1740383059,
-0.0321919918,
-0.2626917064,
-0.1915270686,
0.6136811376,
-0.7316782475,
-0.0934331268,
0.2965632379,
-0.3352929056,
-0.3075086474,
0.1729104519,
-0.9387956262,
-0.3126649261,
-0.660136342,
0.2134512216,
-0.6288903356,
0.3295511603,
-0.1190214306,
-0.1818643361,
0.4801857471,
0.4865512252,
-1.4838051796,
0.1369332373,
0.7308326364,
0.8482950926,
-0.3735507727,
-0.3418461978,
-0.0840788931,
0.1440596133,
-0.5097907782,
0.9882241488,
-0.4677590132,
-0.548651576,
0.2513979077,
-0.1862731129,
-0.1424247772,
-0.2885929346,
0.6625599265,
-0.8831593394,
0.3235832453,
-0.1348171383,
-0.6188256145,
-0.2525016963,
-0.0910446048,
-0.6745117307,
1.0153638124,
0.2328587025,
-0.6467142105,
0.5045950413,
-0.5314325094,
-0.6205970645,
-0.1177895516,
-0.212471664,
-0.254206121,
-0.1035853997,
-0.0803431869,
0.6421733499,
-0.388292253,
0.1431967318,
-0.156163469,
-0.2741199434,
0.0822574347,
-0.0007033569,
0.947070539,
0.4708298743,
-0.2750730515,
0.1232381985,
-0.7677894235,
0.1036878377,
0.1195843741,
-0.2565417886,
-0.4739876091,
0.3780624568,
-0.1110937297,
-0.2880915105,
0.2441146225,
-0.1037207693,
0.0800772756,
-0.5259057879,
-0.022650836,
0.700488925,
0.2522596121,
0.7681782246,
-0.4952816963,
0.6135203242,
-0.1344469786,
0.1801187992,
-0.3097046912,
-0.5488964915,
-0.7533670068,
-0.2286004126,
0.1486828178,
0.6916472316,
-0.4045715928,
0.5929561257,
-0.043679744,
-0.5524836779,
-0.1182935834,
0.0293211304,
0.2952834964,
0.6160877347,
0.2718119323,
-0.700838089,
-0.1871855706,
-0.5417858958,
0.1763681322,
-0.3192976415,
-0.0443600044,
-0.0934417173,
0.2975970507,
-0.0951096788,
0.6583112478,
-1.2129542828,
0.0835045874,
0.0726362765,
0.4944685102,
0.0674327761,
0.4561972916,
0.8828427196,
-1.1577095985,
-0.5247861743,
-0.1248151585,
-0.6725243926,
-0.1574847847,
-0.1026197374,
-0.3568428457,
0.4501962662,
0.2784487605,
-0.2133537829,
0.3499821723,
-0.1773933619,
-0.2217939645,
0.5169919729,
-0.2814213932,
0.0966814086,
-1.1478304863,
-0.1148442999,
-0.0583096817,
0.3598993421,
-0.6359623075,
0.3176545799,
0.0998709053,
-0.2500608265,
0.17879498,
0.401000917,
-0.5123040676,
0.0027968013,
0.074766703,
0.273911953,
0.0790023059,
0.197692439,
0.0216698404,
0.7017046213,
0.3921423852,
-0.3896093071,
-0.0146063482,
0.3859769404,
-0.4732589424,
0.667332828,
-0.2918492854,
-0.1816685647,
-0.2198773175,
-0.0471603945,
-1.2117944956,
-0.3636086285,
0.1065536886,
-0.4799408317,
0.7013866305,
0.3318406343,
-0.5832523108,
-0.1947629452,
-0.5289054513,
-0.0812791064,
0.4294226766,
-0.0906924829,
0.4065692723,
0.3334072232,
-0.5077397823,
-0.6905945539,
-0.5130439997,
-0.3483439088,
-0.1617123336,
-0.7294703722,
0.3891976774,
-0.5622237325,
-0.2660078406,
-0.1058587357,
-0.2552478313,
-0.6675483584,
0.1921033859,
0.0781096891,
0.4581411779,
-0.3741794229,
0.022606384,
0.4528237879,
0.1637085825,
0.0316823162,
-0.2744811475,
0.0422347672,
0.5117684007,
-0.175160557,
-0.0790883824,
0.461309284,
0.503429234,
-0.2904296517,
0.789914012,
0.5630536675,
-0.2070290297,
-0.3894518018,
-0.5666796565,
-0.1841416508,
-0.5031301975,
0.0249761175,
-0.2261026055,
-0.5054644942,
0.608645618,
0.4791814387,
0.4161566496,
0.2775030136,
0.6446333528,
-0.3953344822,
0.6245827079,
0.6533874273,
0.1361400932,
0.9294852018,
-0.681935966,
0.2827678025,
-0.3899220526,
-0.2711156607,
-0.7635688186,
-0.057543654,
-0.5501328111,
-0.4128144979,
0.1673154831,
0.2383419573,
-0.1131540462,
0.2661958337,
-0.7331415415,
0.6900689602,
0.6253556609,
-0.0750782192,
0.2613315582,
0.4034125805,
-0.2795364857,
0.1119427979,
-0.5420032144,
-0.4597223699,
1.1310317516,
-0.1470771283,
0.5259469748,
0.1992397904,
1.0852925777,
0.3391858935,
0.5986126661,
-1.0528231859,
0.5381575823,
-0.0592456013,
-0.5128183365,
-0.5748529434,
-0.0597199276,
-1.115582943,
0.4271326959,
-0.0185484104,
-0.9378217459,
0.3524922729,
-0.3751654625,
-0.2300324142,
-0.4324900508,
-1.0494840145,
0.7516512275,
-0.0945177823,
-0.3963568807,
-0.3727407157,
-0.776847899,
0.0750384256,
-0.5023596883,
-0.0053496384,
0.2497287989,
-0.0744689405,
0.9396353364,
-0.3989853561,
0.5170112252,
0.2111221552,
-0.1842259914,
0.6720271111,
0.0895987079,
0.1439188123,
-0.0676961616,
-0.5440355539,
-0.4308606982,
0.2442527115,
-0.5229096413,
-0.7005979419,
0.5761190653,
-0.8592101336,
-0.6963822246,
-0.6441657543,
-0.6213496923,
-0.0465378575,
0.8777121305,
0.1303603053,
0.6223443151,
-0.1193110943,
0.2230312079,
0.7215566635,
0.2011625767,
0.6209657788,
0.7312056422,
0.5682469606,
-0.4495310485,
1.0751336813,
0.7557480335,
0.1337073594,
0.6565600038,
0.0527897328,
-0.2776962519,
-1.1393082142,
-0.0545334443,
0.1962708235,
-1.0194659233,
-0.2322916985,
-0.608623147,
0.0080766724,
-0.9512280822,
-0.7521666288,
0.3635886014,
-0.3085309863,
-0.7278529406,
-0.1169637144,
-0.208454445,
0.7526894808,
0.1650999337,
0.2921182811,
-0.7366437316,
0.3047398329,
-0.1200831831,
0.1636087894,
0.1211749688,
-0.2000121772,
-0.3123061061,
-0.2669407725,
-1.0430970192,
-1.1678100824,
0.3183507025,
-0.1232762486,
0.6446316242,
0.6097688079,
0.3565053344,
0.3836232722,
-0.3870927095,
0.596280992,
0.0309309997,
-0.6006700993,
0.5108795762,
-0.548406899,
0.0316565894,
0.6278514862,
0.7176579237,
0.0748922899,
-0.498082757,
-0.7635436058,
-1.1221817732,
1.0461475849,
0.2405078262,
-0.0085951127,
0.0329268388,
0.4227333665,
0.0074930028,
0.1482328624,
-0.0536718667,
-0.1034336165,
-0.0751061812,
-0.4431523383,
-0.1430654377,
-0.1882973313,
-0.1533806622,
-0.1833654344,
0.5996608138,
-0.3979260921,
0.1231103092,
0.2682618201,
-0.0768065304,
0.1335977614,
0.1384182721,
1.0127412081,
1.2610448599,
-0.4577509463,
-0.209843412,
-0.1362793744,
-0.7974669337,
0.1496342123,
0.1318899095,
-0.1549293697,
-0.2166065127,
0.5026040077,
0.3435796797,
0.1188384891,
-0.5569166541,
0.2176349908,
0.1806806624,
-0.0240460858,
-0.2943984866,
0.3551110625,
0.0678553358,
0.2992383838,
0.2925567031,
-0.4558787346,
0.3608371019,
-0.4939312637,
0.4440966547,
0.0330555327,
0.068497695,
-0.1097490937,
0.3281279504,
0.0249290559,
-0.3303452134,
0.7393562794,
-0.109247297,
0.0548635721,
1.1031628847,
0.6686170101,
0.8731495738,
-0.1695777923,
0.5833673477,
0.3394741118,
0.1780821979,
-0.1306000352,
0.3853257298,
-0.4171261191,
-0.618144691,
0.1019877568,
-0.904833734,
-0.5936084986,
-0.3310011625,
-0.7973861098,
0.361579895,
-0.4579586983,
-0.0990375504,
0.5940406919,
0.3360108733,
-0.283041656,
0.3682317734,
-0.2694578767,
0.8135498762,
-0.5268978477,
0.9097551703,
0.7805373669,
-0.8552311063,
-0.5881239176,
0.2349963039,
0.1731582582,
-0.540068686,
0.6413530707,
-0.0527059175,
-0.0189422723,
0.256059289,
-0.1714820266,
-0.6621593237,
1.4848861694,
0.0309386384,
-0.0747928768,
-0.3235107362,
-0.2520876825,
0.8083020449,
-0.4477249682,
0.3904941678,
0.1892367303,
0.4174277186,
0.2371125817,
-0.184906289,
-0.1123073101,
0.0855156407,
-0.0922136158,
0.3603198528,
-0.5714010596,
0.344247967,
-0.2987695932,
-0.2732909918,
0.2859139144,
0.5751324296,
-0.1242467687,
0.8610374331,
0.0875933692,
0.5398418903,
0.883651793,
0.0269638598,
1.0360600948,
-0.1575051844,
0.4378812611,
1.0219279528,
-0.334228009,
0.7766341567,
0.3363877535,
-0.1862347573,
0.3793868721,
1.198618412,
-0.2275764793,
0.5721763372,
0.0642393678,
-0.0605933666,
0.4057849348,
-0.0986480862,
-0.2598759532,
0.1604322046,
0.4874213934,
-0.4454475045,
-0.1102612093,
-0.2275851667,
-0.0734694079,
-0.0648284331,
0.0925756693,
0.9341739416,
0.0131012797,
-0.9612523913,
0.577637136,
0.1458279788,
0.0168769229,
-0.5548000336,
0.277425766,
-0.446162641,
-0.1610323489,
-0.2327362299,
-0.9607822895,
0.4586754441,
-0.1693660915,
-0.4537409842,
-0.4445367754,
0.4218814373,
-0.2175784558,
-0.3344736695,
0.2934390604,
0.419847548,
-0.1275515556,
0.7721770406,
-0.5906437635,
-0.2107565701,
-0.3164889216,
-0.4777303338,
0.4320853949,
0.3245542943,
-0.2206742316,
0.3577749729,
0.6721407175,
-0.1455805153,
0.0947849825,
-0.0178859215,
0.5638323426,
-0.3952738047,
-0.7130181789,
-0.5073795915,
0.3558680415,
-0.0978653207,
-0.088742353,
0.522795558,
0.6464035511,
1.0734556913,
0.0059063286,
0.3938972652,
-0.2335021347,
-0.2077403665,
-0.5257055759,
0.7796270251,
-0.7487525344,
0.0828434154,
-0.3178939819,
-1.1212714911,
-0.5879834294,
0.2641786635,
-0.3753074408,
-0.2862226665,
1.2300788164,
0.7506821156,
-0.2123293877,
0.2539622188,
0.2335436493,
-0.243334949,
0.1841732115,
-0.1299460232,
0.1623525321,
-0.3254912198,
0.0983086228,
-0.2528117001,
-0.2988538444,
-0.2854914665,
-0.3665778041,
-0.8156333566,
-0.9803057313,
-0.3235295713,
-0.3760152161,
0.0535317957,
0.4984462857,
0.3638888896,
-0.7173706293,
-0.5190654397,
-0.0718862489,
0.6515904069,
-0.216484502,
-0.2890544236,
0.5202833414,
-0.834031105,
-0.7775268555,
0.1703481823,
0.2549078465,
0.0806377679,
-0.0043530078,
0.1207006127,
-0.4438728988,
0.395121783,
0.6720730066,
0.170351848,
-0.5305883884,
-0.0317386203,
0.1723697186,
-0.2941958904,
0.0936833397,
1.2293362617,
0.0516529568,
0.704893887,
1.4324020147,
0.8735420704,
0.3428472281,
0.0083750291,
0.4018690586,
-0.3823702931,
0.0209323112,
0.138144359,
0.1258466989,
-0.1817468554,
-0.5576432347,
0.8560498953,
0.40587309,
-0.5043557882,
-0.8877784014,
0.0636889562,
-1.1292999983,
-0.2574055195,
0.5767197013,
-0.2712933123,
-0.2009111345,
-0.0708591864,
-0.029779952,
0.2789084315,
-0.3726623058,
0.9040437937,
0.9733194709,
-0.365883261,
0.1166049466,
-0.7003198266,
0.1821400225,
0.425894618,
-0.9777299166,
-0.2680422962,
0.687582612,
0.059142489,
0.4689318836,
0.8275697827,
-0.0969781131,
0.2132067233,
-0.1529729068,
-0.3709975779,
0.3672861159,
-0.5460954905,
-0.1412028968,
0.4256461263,
-0.0085268198,
0.0227017608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13105v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13105v1
|
Perceptual Structure in the Absence of Grounding for LLMs: The Impact of Abstractedness and Subjectivity in Color Language
| 2023-11-22T02:12:36 | 2023-11-22T02:12:36 |
Pablo Loyola, Edison Marrese-Taylor, Andres Hoyos-Idobro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The need for grounding in language understanding is an active research topic.
Previous work has suggested that color perception and color language appear as
a suitable test bed to empirically study the problem, given its cognitive
significance and showing that there is considerable alignment between a defined
color space and the feature space defined by a language model. To further study
this issue, we collect a large scale source of colors and their descriptions,
containing almost a 1 million examples , and perform an empirical analysis to
compare two kinds of alignments: (i) inter-space, by learning a mapping between
embedding space and color space, and (ii) intra-space, by means of prompting
comparatives between color descriptions. Our results show that while color
space alignment holds for monolexemic, highly pragmatic color descriptions,
this alignment drops considerably in the presence of examples that exhibit
elements of real linguistic usage such as subjectivity and abstractedness,
suggesting that grounding may be required in such cases.
|
[
-0.3955488801,
-0.4781066775,
0.7831484079,
0.4748874605,
-0.377368331,
-0.0811056495,
-0.2065561414,
-0.2288998663,
0.146769017,
0.0987289697,
-0.3238156736,
-0.7032186985,
-0.3589023054,
-0.1567545831,
-0.4483546317,
0.7779970765,
-0.0965386704,
-0.0384492651,
-0.3161572814,
-0.6148952246,
-0.580047369,
-0.496599108,
-0.0819183141,
-0.1543164551,
0.4201128781,
0.4153407812,
0.8582695127,
0.8163456321,
0.4568980038,
0.2995280921,
-0.297616899,
-0.4885981381,
-0.3845211565,
-0.0479618609,
-0.2503612638,
-0.7987065911,
-0.2713550627,
0.1370587796,
0.7429426908,
1.2701762915,
0.0257204454,
-0.0635943189,
0.0782783628,
0.6807530522,
-0.7805046439,
0.2160099745,
-0.4719581604,
0.6002867818,
0.0066086217,
-0.1704030335,
0.0975306779,
0.070465751,
0.0474107154,
-0.4435149133,
0.0109797809,
0.1684117615,
0.8689308763,
0.1401169151,
-0.3843760788,
-0.169876799,
-0.5351067781,
0.7137678266,
-0.3601829708,
0.4607422948,
0.3931442201,
0.0789310858,
0.1004542708,
-0.4179756343,
-0.7804581523,
-0.3369192183,
-0.3552046716,
0.3846166432,
-0.0102287801,
0.0965547338,
0.3830143511,
0.5701545477,
-0.3727524877,
-0.0527542531,
-0.4983345866,
-0.0543926768,
0.2029362768,
0.1744733155,
0.4814893007,
-0.0545019731,
-0.5321586132,
0.0224969853,
-0.7642519474,
-0.1590161026,
0.2361066192,
0.2209092975,
-0.3737712801,
0.737567842,
-0.214082256,
0.4632251561,
-0.0386076458,
-0.177443549,
0.2439940125,
-0.3822327256,
-0.2896693051,
0.1192135662,
0.508903861,
0.5271308422,
0.502820313,
-0.3980448246,
0.0215962511,
0.2944214344,
0.2958289087,
-0.630567193,
-0.2801990807,
0.1529265642,
-0.4018612802,
-0.0552505478,
0.1812652051,
-0.4966001809,
-0.3848557174,
-0.6263315082,
-0.1566024572,
-0.4508887231,
-0.3293962181,
-0.2237737626,
-0.1499508023,
0.3802496195,
0.1991163045,
-0.7870793939,
0.3043690622,
0.6039903164,
0.8188175559,
-0.4563214481,
-0.4484972954,
0.3643160462,
0.0590561554,
-0.3188948333,
0.673491776,
-0.5714737177,
-0.0849147514,
-0.2016307414,
0.0657478496,
0.1848261654,
-0.5002593994,
0.4242422581,
-0.3868387043,
0.042070657,
-0.3546266258,
-0.396165669,
-0.2599296868,
0.2389368713,
-0.292989701,
0.3600545526,
0.0017096633,
-0.7823476195,
0.4488646388,
-0.2401499152,
-0.2176320404,
0.1144515276,
-0.7715326548,
-0.0553512722,
0.5704541206,
-0.1210836023,
0.2564531267,
0.3939111829,
0.081532225,
-0.3557168841,
-0.6614675522,
0.3185509145,
-0.0609518737,
0.5179831386,
0.2965681553,
-0.4920475185,
-0.0119456826,
-0.9219903946,
0.1268263757,
0.3420127928,
-0.3439308703,
-0.4399168491,
0.2786428928,
-0.0371634811,
0.124939397,
0.0926324427,
-0.2699865103,
-0.2009743601,
-0.386372894,
0.33303231,
0.6975624561,
-0.3863972127,
0.8403003216,
0.0200802553,
0.548987031,
0.1308598667,
-0.3187507093,
-0.4508763254,
-0.0805658549,
-0.766782999,
-0.3049335182,
0.1534842104,
0.6737858057,
0.2294882685,
0.5408481956,
-0.0870588571,
-0.1739825904,
-0.0819452852,
-0.1452210099,
0.4905581474,
0.5357191563,
0.3122679591,
0.0268714558,
-0.5775151849,
-1.3439815044,
0.0691391975,
0.0149233239,
0.2166597396,
0.3455734253,
0.3515062928,
-0.247184515,
0.9423383474,
-0.4925243855,
-0.0299851689,
0.0814142898,
-0.185279116,
0.0910445452,
0.5224794149,
0.4553947449,
-0.7461252213,
-0.142425552,
0.0425861627,
-1.0828667879,
-0.1661880165,
0.3352285326,
-0.0291413143,
-0.0865584686,
0.7119621038,
-0.2034091949,
0.62819314,
0.6973717213,
-0.3822087049,
0.3180595636,
-0.1127374545,
0.1390355378,
-0.6278021336,
0.1414057463,
0.0024710528,
0.0276642404,
-0.5699049234,
0.2641554773,
0.0814061239,
-0.3161837161,
-0.3607495427,
0.550467968,
-0.7899088264,
-0.5225351453,
-0.5029832125,
0.3175386786,
-0.0342831388,
0.6172968745,
0.2327113301,
0.7644646764,
0.4210150242,
-0.4479358494,
-0.2549894154,
0.2015730888,
-0.5613417625,
0.4611214697,
-0.5039568543,
0.0046511772,
-0.367490679,
-0.038666077,
-1.5104664564,
0.1543995142,
0.1927828491,
-0.0098618018,
0.2595061958,
-0.2881966233,
-0.259143889,
0.1846789122,
-0.1874759346,
0.7176116705,
0.6510741711,
-0.2454093099,
0.1034873575,
0.3892721832,
-0.2560692728,
-0.6317078471,
-0.8720118403,
0.0940609872,
-0.5080406666,
-0.4593696594,
0.2566078305,
0.0947467685,
-0.7448418736,
-0.0786269233,
-0.4695696831,
0.1204824299,
0.4950680733,
0.5053184032,
0.0224993099,
-0.6377362609,
0.1632846296,
-0.2303191721,
-0.0424189903,
0.0397147238,
-0.2025373727,
0.5350319743,
-0.1804108471,
-0.3525242805,
-0.3265022039,
0.1876385659,
0.5673640966,
-0.0340253823,
0.7207203507,
-0.0993573219,
-0.2204468399,
-0.0981358886,
-0.2590941489,
0.0480150096,
-0.432877183,
0.4323376417,
-0.4558209181,
-0.8560395241,
0.5746222138,
0.0522612743,
-0.2968962789,
0.1443138719,
0.3893193007,
-0.5919054151,
0.7422136068,
0.7557046413,
0.2603279352,
0.7217994928,
0.0602702387,
0.0619431846,
-1.0240260363,
-0.1267668158,
-0.2896609306,
-0.5759016275,
-0.4320607781,
-0.3450636566,
0.0788804963,
0.4561807811,
-0.2783285081,
-0.1234901473,
-0.4183374345,
0.6975548863,
0.0631067902,
0.0389598049,
0.1652085334,
0.5840159059,
-0.3008803725,
-0.4548238218,
-0.4186977446,
-0.6668611765,
0.9200164676,
0.3976015449,
0.5736444592,
-0.0894603878,
0.2448574156,
-0.0891344994,
0.3484629989,
-0.5867163539,
0.4914702177,
-0.1288829446,
-0.2914025187,
-0.1451366991,
-0.0542720482,
-1.0046168566,
0.8479733467,
-0.2713436186,
-0.6911297441,
0.5378132463,
0.304686904,
0.1198371872,
-0.0434366949,
-0.5384879112,
0.8893917203,
-0.4177640975,
-0.2354296446,
0.0004759818,
-0.5499490499,
0.4631745219,
0.2243217379,
0.399677515,
-0.1152952015,
-0.2252036035,
0.514113605,
-0.3087691367,
0.7895697355,
0.008378868,
-0.1761352122,
-0.0910935178,
0.1169007719,
0.1418845206,
-0.1646383256,
0.1718743294,
0.253207773,
-0.3817008734,
-0.6213994026,
-0.6847949624,
0.4640018344,
-0.8189357519,
-0.6128374338,
-0.4360842705,
-0.5506919622,
-0.2633821964,
0.024145877,
0.2027243078,
0.2816072404,
-0.2898130715,
-0.0210467782,
0.6484882236,
-0.1307176501,
0.1188978925,
0.0890085772,
-0.3003572524,
-0.3126454055,
0.7412510514,
-0.0021576257,
0.2332805097,
0.3399761915,
0.2903293669,
-0.156661123,
-1.1999961138,
0.1786728054,
0.5108629465,
-1.0122429132,
0.3449172974,
-0.8876256347,
0.149515152,
-0.1619655192,
-0.4420233667,
-0.0029069562,
-0.5678099394,
-0.20995906,
-0.5008170605,
-0.1140481159,
0.7146671414,
0.3111383617,
0.4629257619,
-0.3506095707,
0.1887562424,
0.1896316409,
0.163711831,
-0.0071124937,
-0.5449103117,
-0.2277829349,
-0.0598777458,
-0.0314829461,
-0.8947030306,
0.0805868134,
-0.127946347,
0.6600418091,
0.5141658187,
-0.4251018465,
1.0940765142,
-0.7875720859,
0.5394940376,
0.2722667158,
-0.9623632431,
0.5670583844,
-0.2979187667,
0.3891817629,
0.7332524061,
0.1673469841,
-0.3990601897,
-0.6814820766,
-0.5756421089,
-0.9231113791,
0.7641727328,
0.2784797251,
0.1847418398,
-0.077204518,
0.4104723334,
-0.0713833123,
0.3685865998,
-1.0914801359,
-0.3770739138,
-0.4091875255,
-0.2540186942,
-0.2374025285,
-0.4706932902,
-0.5503211617,
-0.1198891401,
-0.1696677357,
-0.1505128294,
0.3733196855,
0.1898413897,
-0.4721425772,
0.0145019414,
0.2637003064,
0.7891080976,
0.9637727141,
-0.1444665641,
0.5385008454,
0.0683974698,
-0.2728376091,
0.132635504,
-0.2168772817,
-0.0752651617,
-0.3345949352,
0.742990613,
0.8074521422,
0.3484858572,
-0.6304730773,
0.4613392055,
0.2193835676,
-0.1137926653,
-0.2794544995,
0.1132365763,
0.1683050692,
0.2061010003,
0.1291712523,
-0.157476142,
0.0671871454,
-0.8994581103,
-0.0181179401,
0.5645121932,
-0.3940524161,
-0.4821447432,
0.3954782784,
-0.0360318981,
-0.0553802773,
0.6674253345,
0.0624385476,
-0.62259835,
0.8565401435,
0.6314147115,
0.6444827318,
0.2974349856,
-0.2348144799,
0.2335963994,
0.3629211485,
0.0866477638,
0.101559408,
-0.409753561,
-1.0448707342,
-0.1946302056,
-0.6766716838,
-0.1987433285,
-0.0462943502,
-0.2768984735,
0.1222465187,
-0.6975549459,
0.3016016781,
-0.2494450659,
-0.4081570208,
-0.1942071915,
0.3650577664,
0.78335917,
0.6534953713,
-1.1441195011,
0.4016911387,
1.083650589,
-0.3821923137,
-0.6233052611,
0.2694506645,
-0.0602239072,
-0.810667634,
1.2779039145,
0.1777011454,
-0.0460221469,
-0.3419333398,
-0.5677687526,
-1.0290634632,
1.099864006,
0.5029156804,
-0.3806547523,
0.0982857943,
-0.0548229888,
0.6159887314,
-0.5718361139,
0.1426566094,
0.1471516937,
0.5271416306,
-0.0126661295,
-0.4031796455,
0.233706519,
0.0550997481,
0.0494584292,
0.2831526399,
-0.706366837,
1.0638264418,
0.0651753694,
-0.8174031377,
-0.1777815521,
0.749422133,
0.5543354154,
0.2584657073,
0.5311103463,
0.7911747694,
0.6046046019,
-0.0196475703,
1.0206333399,
-0.0821755528,
0.266287297,
0.9264374971,
-0.2515976131,
0.4247192144,
0.4928929508,
-0.4378498495,
0.4355715811,
0.2916137278,
0.1478650421,
0.6541613936,
0.4974452257,
0.127370134,
-0.0475173593,
0.2595460117,
-0.2709765136,
0.263415277,
0.4321199954,
-0.3980435133,
-0.2749771178,
-0.1419610381,
0.0880357698,
0.2882767022,
-0.2804834545,
0.7222800255,
0.1979036182,
-0.4889765084,
0.5329194069,
-0.2971813679,
0.4993065298,
-0.484048605,
-0.1944014579,
-0.4660538137,
0.006170325,
-0.5583936572,
-0.8252587318,
0.415096581,
-0.2757049799,
-0.2611145675,
-0.3960551918,
0.4233438373,
-0.4195902348,
-0.2498347163,
0.4490149021,
0.4888060093,
0.4164897799,
0.1303889602,
-0.6195690632,
0.131451726,
-0.0381798595,
-0.0948535353,
0.465939045,
0.6634712815,
-0.2116909325,
0.3016550839,
0.4864377677,
0.2549175322,
0.2287840694,
-0.1625822335,
0.5625386238,
-0.9181827903,
-0.6125556827,
-1.0412933826,
0.524073422,
0.0761867315,
-0.1250467598,
0.8581377268,
0.4492098391,
0.7776826024,
0.0686367825,
0.5577859879,
-0.0102876388,
-0.148006171,
-0.6826990843,
0.3601378202,
-0.6248716116,
0.2267065197,
-0.2422891557,
-1.2458307743,
-0.3957089782,
0.994112134,
-0.2058750242,
-0.1314258724,
1.1651536226,
0.4887008965,
-0.1974954158,
-0.1713725626,
0.5293570161,
0.3882291019,
-0.1318471581,
0.0517035015,
1.3397212029,
0.0967746899,
0.2912916839,
-0.2336347997,
-0.2662029862,
-0.0237262882,
-0.8847080469,
-0.8611612916,
-0.3198326826,
-0.4239155352,
-0.2436283231,
0.0122618498,
0.560431242,
0.6228663921,
-0.8884341717,
-0.4162715375,
-0.2996253967,
0.2961253822,
0.0245150682,
-0.1816237122,
0.3528321981,
-0.4584997296,
-0.6726195216,
0.4573685527,
0.555151701,
0.2145859003,
-0.1296627671,
0.1887771338,
-0.0763586089,
-0.1593266875,
0.4647197425,
0.307174027,
-0.8534665108,
-0.2180228978,
-0.2119238377,
-0.2891297638,
0.522298336,
1.0005345345,
-0.7159284353,
-0.0371530056,
0.4771648347,
0.4832012057,
0.2121030837,
0.2256560475,
0.3985278606,
-0.7679333687,
0.6215936542,
0.1013185009,
0.6797001362,
0.2784493566,
-0.2442602962,
0.6335244179,
0.3787699342,
-0.2353776991,
-0.8035270572,
0.4231284261,
-1.081739068,
-0.5421550274,
1.1024335623,
-0.1165496856,
-0.3481647074,
-0.0126378965,
-0.1959584504,
-0.1571544558,
-0.178805843,
0.3503026664,
0.9222307801,
-0.1659600288,
-0.1827078462,
-0.2603836954,
0.1139910817,
0.5519693494,
-0.6205554008,
0.0119307144,
0.6836912036,
0.3301862478,
0.5144400001,
0.6977941394,
-0.1041405648,
0.0096357465,
-0.0456911288,
0.1518509239,
0.0113551365,
-0.1948025376,
-0.7990913391,
0.6049634814,
0.1495662481,
-0.1866510659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13102v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13102v1
|
Detecting out-of-distribution text using topological features of transformer-based language models
| 2023-11-22T02:04:35 | 2023-11-22T02:04:35 |
Andres Pollano, Anupam Chaudhuri, Anj Simmons
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, math.AT
|
We attempt to detect out-of-distribution (OOD) text samples though applying
Topological Data Analysis (TDA) to attention maps in transformer-based language
models. We evaluate our proposed TDA-based approach for out-of-distribution
detection on BERT, a transformer-based language model, and compare the to a
more traditional OOD approach based on BERT CLS embeddings. We found that our
TDA approach outperforms the CLS embedding approach at distinguishing
in-distribution data (politics and entertainment news articles from HuffPost)
from far out-of-domain samples (IMDB reviews), but its effectiveness
deteriorates with near out-of-domain (CNN/Dailymail) or same-domain (business
news articles from HuffPost) datasets.
|
[
-0.5281851292,
-0.9624431729,
0.6566442251,
0.0057931156,
-0.502790451,
-0.0294821262,
-0.1640964597,
-0.5124132037,
0.3707068861,
0.6141921878,
-0.3255020678,
-0.4519886076,
-0.6018872261,
-0.1203256696,
-0.8199208975,
0.7373490334,
0.1609103829,
-0.2399845719,
-0.0859982893,
-0.1095548719,
-0.3506489694,
-0.4632888734,
-0.3068357408,
-0.1099716276,
0.1366560608,
0.3229626715,
0.6710147262,
0.4940565228,
0.8164425492,
0.1885707676,
-0.3386404514,
0.0257289559,
-0.6855254173,
-0.0575174801,
-0.3317872584,
-0.0683882162,
-0.114995271,
-0.2734695971,
0.882792294,
0.3714717031,
0.0512254015,
0.1223821416,
-0.1505317837,
0.6934788227,
-0.5729714036,
-0.0040783738,
-0.7089250088,
0.1040501371,
-0.5455487967,
-0.2260564864,
-0.6928643584,
-0.560818553,
0.2887949944,
-0.1464072764,
0.2707437575,
0.2203920037,
0.723703146,
0.156348899,
-0.5319917798,
-0.4532372952,
-1.0149202347,
0.7709533572,
-0.5397648811,
0.744479239,
0.2559847534,
0.3403736651,
-0.1769081801,
-0.3671622574,
-0.9642496705,
-0.0057362835,
-0.2002509981,
0.0163179971,
-0.3833034039,
-0.4180372953,
0.002125385,
0.4837976396,
-0.5405457616,
-0.0103551969,
-0.3332826197,
0.3858285546,
0.4924822152,
-0.2373852134,
0.2928902209,
-0.2881040871,
-0.3490041792,
-0.3180298507,
-0.6439843774,
-0.1896183193,
0.488491714,
0.1426465362,
-0.1994402856,
0.6574471593,
0.1782595217,
0.3773317635,
0.1256344467,
0.0200090259,
0.2794700563,
-0.1351162195,
-0.3153496683,
-0.0060976096,
0.578640759,
0.0361652002,
0.3025042415,
-0.3331019282,
-0.0973980725,
-0.2711848319,
0.3174085617,
-0.4126114249,
-0.0739062428,
0.2249267846,
-0.6562222838,
-0.3391339779,
0.2103603631,
-1.1940828562,
-0.7184647918,
0.1472886503,
0.1394346654,
-0.3133188784,
-0.4155318737,
0.1908536106,
-0.3524808586,
0.1104202345,
-0.1849441975,
-0.823672235,
0.2533381581,
0.5186527967,
0.9341195226,
-0.4594745636,
0.2150009125,
-0.1853749454,
0.1103059947,
-0.2323419154,
1.0193659067,
-0.657069087,
-0.140334636,
0.3185153306,
-0.0536151826,
-0.0016203354,
-0.654163301,
0.6847826242,
-0.7071179748,
0.2041485459,
-0.0543707646,
-0.5881451964,
-0.2241043001,
0.0942649841,
-0.900273025,
1.2638989687,
0.4224116206,
-1.0893867016,
0.4140652716,
-0.8576290011,
-0.3045961261,
-0.1632600576,
-0.0676109344,
-0.5895068049,
0.1424025297,
0.3391826749,
0.3554659188,
-0.1487043649,
0.3205632865,
-0.4262852073,
-0.3363790214,
0.2081885189,
-0.2647245228,
0.8373116255,
0.1757823974,
-0.4952399731,
-0.0988718346,
-0.6082359552,
-0.3105775118,
0.2988783717,
-0.0284366608,
-0.5324832797,
0.4519497454,
0.3522612453,
0.2666054666,
-0.1875252873,
-0.831256032,
0.1870910227,
-0.4630954564,
0.4030269086,
0.5492780805,
0.011628435,
0.6525048018,
-0.1960372478,
0.3700302243,
0.4042168558,
0.1982010156,
0.1140642613,
-0.8310655355,
-0.5526272058,
-0.3978157938,
0.0805539638,
0.5011882782,
-0.7780643702,
1.026799798,
-0.3842344582,
-0.5412287712,
-0.1754896492,
-0.394993037,
0.0775412098,
0.2979607582,
0.3510661423,
-0.4575880766,
-0.2686579227,
-0.4846534729,
-0.1795562208,
-0.0804892555,
0.1973578781,
0.1586550772,
0.5803387761,
-0.4295538068,
1.4793463945,
-0.5948416591,
-0.6075506806,
-0.5565508008,
-0.0279591661,
0.3498586714,
0.1194871068,
0.7871467471,
-0.8020281792,
-0.4085669816,
0.3031388223,
-0.5165471435,
0.0153703922,
0.0533068702,
0.0230226722,
0.3165532053,
0.4384676814,
-0.5095827579,
0.8111667633,
0.5611462593,
-0.4290009439,
0.1514573991,
-0.1645833552,
-0.1569687426,
-0.9441969395,
0.0440312661,
-0.0273125172,
-0.2749252319,
-0.836384654,
-0.150562644,
0.0814630911,
-0.1653860658,
-0.4467219412,
0.7338527441,
-0.2369133085,
-0.2871997952,
0.0048869448,
0.4311488569,
-0.1402785629,
0.3494823277,
0.3251659274,
0.2785741389,
0.2841485739,
-0.3760003746,
0.2279850096,
0.3747236729,
-0.5273147225,
0.48367998,
-0.4810926616,
0.1845065653,
-0.4285352826,
0.4283719957,
-1.3323692083,
0.0489537418,
0.5117442608,
-0.2540036738,
0.2076283544,
-0.0222026259,
-0.6762133241,
-0.3590988815,
-0.4964692593,
0.5184206963,
0.5452937484,
-0.7355058789,
0.4876756668,
0.7386671901,
0.1194234341,
-0.3799179792,
-0.658613801,
-0.2816514969,
-0.3667939305,
-0.5843654275,
0.1528284401,
0.048325371,
-0.257837832,
0.2661514282,
0.2377497703,
-0.594651401,
-0.0980260447,
-0.1537795961,
-0.1661251038,
-0.109027572,
0.278983593,
0.0665285513,
0.2320324928,
0.0724963248,
-0.4459196031,
0.6802040935,
0.1827447265,
-0.3283960819,
-0.4200472534,
0.4701110721,
0.5109629631,
-0.1862906367,
0.7187874913,
0.6259619594,
-0.3453494012,
-0.3208290637,
-0.3800000846,
-0.4363147616,
-0.4402674437,
0.2596799135,
0.1794219464,
-0.3893428743,
0.4779476225,
0.1898508519,
-0.2433076352,
0.404279381,
0.4911070168,
-0.2380389273,
0.6572489738,
1.0242389441,
-0.3084360063,
0.9293846488,
-0.4088120759,
0.6994704604,
-0.5110002756,
0.0722338781,
-0.6605368853,
-0.3810545802,
-0.7155550122,
-0.167050302,
0.4539931715,
-0.2959724963,
0.1296777576,
0.3235989809,
-0.5493280292,
0.4596497416,
0.6767008901,
0.0516144074,
0.2830331028,
0.1627862304,
0.2111851722,
0.2491246313,
-0.6304743886,
-0.2914182544,
0.9841643572,
0.5763525963,
0.5531074405,
0.2236104608,
0.5984856486,
0.6304298639,
0.2538567483,
-0.6623981595,
0.2254056931,
-0.2992860973,
-0.7281948328,
-0.5063688755,
-0.2266800553,
-0.738298595,
-0.0870446712,
-0.0177155342,
-0.988381207,
0.7683582902,
-0.1487768441,
0.046846658,
0.6924236417,
-0.6895678043,
0.7436137795,
0.323502928,
0.4460775554,
0.0352911912,
-0.5645016432,
0.3820786774,
-0.2792848647,
0.338452816,
0.1599121839,
0.3923307061,
0.6399085522,
-0.0842517316,
0.8555785418,
-0.0344770849,
-0.4943253994,
0.465564549,
-0.2226735651,
0.767129004,
-0.03405682,
0.0774919987,
0.3734510243,
-0.1854964495,
-0.1097877324,
-0.4950025678,
0.2725716233,
-0.7197134495,
-0.0415484086,
-0.4241437018,
-0.6936753392,
-0.1228762716,
0.225878194,
0.5714883804,
0.536280036,
-0.0429387204,
0.3783044517,
0.7481192946,
-0.1042058021,
0.7221999764,
0.2843404412,
-0.0722733513,
-0.2823077142,
0.9083157182,
0.1602579653,
0.0646278709,
0.5601232648,
0.4685989022,
-0.622995913,
-0.6205385923,
-0.4210560024,
0.386351496,
-0.7846333981,
0.0316333845,
-0.7247242332,
-0.1681730002,
-0.510720849,
-0.0942130536,
-0.1975405067,
-0.2461467385,
-0.2338892072,
0.1541647166,
0.3288540542,
1.1994326115,
0.2785455287,
0.4466571808,
-0.725171566,
0.4072462618,
-0.0670649633,
0.3213679194,
-0.1758335978,
-0.7448673248,
-0.2375489175,
-0.1623036265,
-0.5764981508,
-1.1490035057,
0.4751193821,
0.2286898196,
0.3002264202,
0.7159367204,
0.3265022933,
0.1220992133,
-0.4626591802,
0.8139361739,
-0.1409107894,
-1.0651410818,
0.4380468428,
-0.44669047,
0.0931601971,
0.0009145089,
0.3556489944,
-0.4297154546,
-0.8282555938,
-0.6784268022,
-0.6035326123,
0.8516541123,
0.5507942438,
0.0229322296,
-0.3170109689,
0.0719849095,
0.062233448,
0.1416162848,
-0.8151035905,
-0.1983509213,
-0.0269843861,
-0.2803558409,
-0.1426738203,
-0.4244218171,
0.1497643441,
0.0552828982,
0.4715119302,
-0.1262169778,
0.5036162734,
0.1642856896,
-0.0970426872,
-0.2031999826,
0.2916046977,
0.8039922118,
0.7093932033,
-0.5122292638,
-0.0542367734,
-0.0544899479,
-0.8061012626,
-0.0921958312,
-0.1164643988,
-0.2609812319,
0.3713125885,
0.335618943,
0.3504025042,
-0.2087721378,
-0.6099956036,
0.7805371284,
0.0025768371,
0.1957911998,
-0.1959999353,
-0.4866915047,
-0.2427606732,
0.3541085124,
0.3675206304,
-0.1267835945,
0.4273133874,
-0.6702873111,
0.3369424343,
0.4495576918,
-0.691590488,
-0.5024850965,
0.3221612275,
0.0567020327,
-0.1632903069,
0.4656020999,
-0.2459748685,
-0.4468078911,
0.7937816978,
0.6085917354,
1.1942824125,
-0.1043355986,
0.3266831934,
-0.2023738325,
0.6498578787,
0.0856237188,
0.6070867777,
0.1258634031,
-0.7886001468,
-0.0436220281,
-0.2291257679,
-0.2797665894,
0.0084643494,
-0.5560548902,
0.4933923781,
-0.1238755137,
-0.023374809,
-0.1362763643,
-0.2246393114,
-0.4890035093,
0.3206187189,
-0.0223833974,
0.7615706325,
-0.9694663286,
1.0293073654,
0.4830251038,
-0.012623569,
-0.2549972832,
0.4068361223,
-0.1491375118,
-0.4360299408,
0.7023059726,
-0.056899216,
-0.071163021,
0.0752967969,
-0.1186895818,
-0.9782782793,
0.9213367105,
0.4520165324,
-0.3735777736,
0.1380174309,
0.4141861498,
0.5873653293,
-0.1843010038,
0.4601476789,
0.6657139063,
0.4357433319,
-0.191301778,
-0.8310470581,
-0.2227377295,
0.0920353383,
-0.1457965523,
0.7024191022,
-0.3971448243,
0.863776803,
-0.0675955787,
-0.4974423349,
-0.1990334541,
0.5652433634,
-0.1849329919,
0.4533514082,
0.6647794843,
0.6173081398,
0.5501409769,
-0.1727891415,
1.17281425,
-0.0513883345,
0.9545712471,
0.690428555,
-0.2714023888,
0.9486390948,
0.4956436157,
-0.0548670515,
0.5364062786,
0.445633024,
0.3090572357,
0.8871974945,
0.1563542336,
0.1194464937,
0.30015257,
-0.3470829129,
-0.5630175471,
0.3939757049,
0.3214664161,
-0.3253841698,
-0.390666306,
-0.0069394214,
-0.1991099119,
-0.097816661,
-0.0002423395,
0.6972198486,
-0.108205162,
-0.2198132575,
0.510214448,
-0.2246030271,
0.3119964898,
-0.2916543484,
0.0693104863,
-0.4130470455,
0.3676633835,
-0.0094583137,
-0.8829027414,
0.5860824585,
-0.1386832297,
-0.2802182734,
-0.1297101378,
0.6062582731,
-0.5422984362,
-0.3737305701,
0.3755158186,
0.3738475442,
0.1065995395,
-0.2044021189,
-0.2190793902,
0.062319424,
-0.4631965458,
-0.1641954929,
-0.0166548546,
0.6704016328,
-0.3109970093,
0.59246099,
0.5213887691,
-0.0985915735,
0.1921863109,
0.0066722776,
0.9710428119,
-0.6395958662,
-0.9061809778,
-0.7419562936,
0.3046477735,
-0.1509720385,
-0.3879955113,
0.641579926,
0.2621330619,
0.787945807,
-0.4201602936,
0.6596469879,
-0.2078447789,
0.4774089456,
-0.5223137736,
0.718862474,
-0.5165394545,
0.0885730758,
-0.4638737738,
-1.1428786516,
-0.3774083257,
0.211335063,
-0.2434059232,
-0.091034539,
1.2322943211,
0.5680455565,
-0.3465435207,
0.0483282655,
0.3166773915,
0.0273274388,
0.507586956,
0.3434033692,
1.0063602924,
-0.4761942625,
0.4881290495,
-0.292658478,
-0.1964435577,
-0.5297948718,
-1.0391664505,
-1.2028656006,
-0.7120326757,
-0.1516466588,
-0.1150652394,
-0.0214420855,
0.5143685341,
0.7457615137,
-1.0944367647,
-0.1623941064,
-0.1220417619,
0.4768457115,
-0.5089985132,
-0.2680936754,
0.6017128229,
-0.2845592201,
-0.7618088126,
0.2593060732,
0.3521726727,
-0.1027781889,
-0.4520955682,
0.4687252939,
-0.274374336,
0.3748272657,
0.6307811737,
-0.0264458507,
-0.6474909186,
-0.6859876513,
0.1682109982,
-0.0633148104,
0.106161885,
1.0378934145,
-0.5344393253,
0.4390647709,
0.9728634953,
0.6049109697,
0.0417445526,
0.0542988516,
0.3676491678,
-1.113450408,
0.3117121458,
0.1682374924,
0.3788983226,
0.0730502009,
-0.5729447007,
0.4830438495,
0.3337713182,
-0.5894274712,
-0.8472833037,
0.1351944506,
-1.1205421686,
-0.0003969611,
1.3574172258,
0.0135203823,
-0.3619355857,
-0.691203475,
-0.2411340624,
-0.0508946143,
-0.4312059581,
1.0800091028,
0.5463625193,
0.2004193366,
0.0277796984,
-0.2046837211,
0.4932413101,
-0.0687877908,
-1.0979964733,
-0.0106293065,
-0.0028272348,
-0.138282001,
0.558891654,
0.5071419477,
0.0164180938,
0.156465143,
-0.4555012286,
-0.0791243464,
0.3664018512,
-0.6125649214,
-0.3568579555,
0.1995512545,
-0.3730022609,
-0.4348185956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13095v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13095v1
|
Enhancing Logical Reasoning in Large Language Models to Facilitate Legal Applications
| 2023-11-22T01:51:50 | 2023-11-22T01:51:50 |
Ha-Thanh Nguyen, Wachara Fungwacharakorn, Ken Satoh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Language serves as a vehicle for conveying thought, enabling communication
among individuals. The ability to distinguish between diverse concepts,
identify fairness and injustice, and comprehend a range of legal notions
fundamentally relies on logical reasoning. Large Language Models (LLMs) attempt
to emulate human language understanding and generation, but their competency in
logical reasoning remains limited. This paper seeks to address the
philosophical question: How can we effectively teach logical reasoning to LLMs
while maintaining a deep understanding of the intricate relationship between
language and logic? By focusing on bolstering LLMs' capabilities in logical
reasoning, we aim to expand their applicability in law and other
logic-intensive disciplines. To this end, we propose a Reinforcement Learning
from Logical Feedback (RLLF) approach, which serves as a potential framework
for refining LLMs' reasoning capacities. Through RLLF and a revised evaluation
methodology, we explore new avenues for research in this domain and contribute
to the development of LLMs capable of handling complex legal reasoning tasks
while acknowledging the fundamental connection between language and logic.
|
[
-0.1864484102,
-0.8007068038,
1.0004370213,
-0.1264439076,
-0.2286970913,
-0.0466106534,
-0.460617125,
-0.4396046102,
-0.06127562,
0.863378644,
-0.6074425578,
-0.1501708776,
-0.3915694952,
0.0480111465,
-0.0874016732,
0.9350529313,
0.0905646756,
0.2835587263,
-0.264877975,
-0.3805706203,
-0.7806481123,
-0.4387177527,
-0.7694967389,
-0.8094477057,
0.4818985462,
0.1632980257,
0.6058164239,
0.3774788976,
0.2785699666,
0.3439053595,
-0.0308154617,
0.1619497687,
-0.5404272676,
0.2944577336,
-0.7916943431,
-0.782779038,
-0.1515533775,
-0.0921558216,
0.6980881095,
0.670347631,
-0.5482107401,
-0.1381163448,
-0.45500049,
0.7214570045,
-0.5094773769,
0.3146113157,
-0.6947559118,
0.3616793454,
0.2120978534,
-0.2120383382,
-0.6701208949,
-0.5450602174,
0.0106055038,
-0.654736042,
-0.3129470944,
0.2557243407,
0.5540907383,
0.3568616807,
-0.3547762334,
-0.2054097801,
-0.7289221883,
0.7588944435,
-0.9136407375,
0.6033698916,
0.1958126575,
0.3259233534,
-0.5053075552,
-0.4477897584,
-0.7371509075,
-0.7909781337,
0.0074300612,
0.0471698046,
0.0429384634,
0.0169349667,
0.5934743881,
-0.2303760499,
-0.2281162143,
0.0654309392,
-0.2579623759,
-0.125705868,
0.7997372746,
0.1080306172,
0.1628366113,
0.1710368991,
-0.1723028719,
0.0335047729,
-0.6758377552,
0.18546094,
0.3436778784,
0.1175641865,
0.3318290412,
0.5790083408,
-0.0821254775,
0.7201144099,
-0.044988621,
-0.496021539,
0.1134603024,
-0.0638409182,
-0.2073703259,
0.2118580341,
0.5431236625,
0.2126718163,
0.5053651929,
0.0542791039,
-0.559689343,
0.015061928,
0.2448690683,
-0.6433326006,
-0.02518191,
0.0077683246,
-0.4928242564,
-0.175383389,
0.1081282124,
-0.4791278839,
-0.6837124228,
-0.7597245574,
0.2599518001,
-0.5796074271,
-0.3289752305,
0.6339914799,
-0.0932149738,
0.3803205192,
0.7330977917,
-0.7375597358,
0.3162180781,
0.8954482675,
-0.0199118648,
0.3023997843,
-0.3070709407,
-1.021920085,
0.2903108597,
-0.4815998077,
0.670167923,
-0.813749671,
-0.1758149266,
0.069837667,
-0.0538838133,
0.062501438,
-0.7589644194,
0.6948566437,
-0.6344553828,
0.1363022476,
-0.2336226553,
-0.6886860728,
-0.3068530858,
0.4201048315,
-0.4946977794,
0.4475577176,
0.0062940367,
-0.4523596168,
0.6122432947,
-0.520730257,
-0.7593109608,
0.1750477999,
-0.545461297,
-0.3685236275,
0.1811452061,
0.2132783234,
0.2365449667,
-0.3694278002,
0.4989779592,
-0.5507563353,
-0.200957492,
0.5628379583,
-0.1503482312,
0.6748757362,
0.2816060781,
-0.2827194333,
0.4585718513,
-0.5359970927,
0.0002305518,
0.2103119195,
-0.5294677019,
-0.1615196019,
0.3049351275,
-0.4629337788,
0.3291678727,
-0.1067170799,
-0.3768313229,
0.0575588755,
-0.5515424609,
0.4747927785,
0.7281332016,
-0.1717665941,
0.376614064,
-0.3947775364,
0.5683994293,
0.0144958943,
-0.0413819887,
0.131062448,
-0.2486905009,
-0.7340397239,
-0.1972204596,
0.1097441167,
0.6120437384,
-0.7361752391,
0.4246166945,
-0.2249763757,
-0.050779555,
-0.4904157817,
0.5308203101,
0.2188059241,
0.4610129595,
0.2322273701,
-0.0051352517,
-0.4614396095,
-0.6718471646,
-0.4346460104,
-0.4317504466,
0.193371594,
0.2917004824,
0.6441848278,
-0.1379618943,
0.9752334356,
-0.2728587687,
-0.127052635,
-0.8879562616,
-0.2705335021,
0.2772546411,
0.1913063824,
0.3200726211,
-0.58408916,
0.0921889022,
0.0653010905,
-0.7178399563,
-0.1070728526,
-0.2735750675,
-0.0482118875,
0.0981296822,
0.6551287174,
-0.7066624165,
0.3962065578,
-0.1227132753,
-0.6807030439,
0.6299277544,
-0.4693737626,
-0.0000975121,
-0.5107453465,
-0.3371082544,
-0.0130385412,
-0.4335100055,
-0.2354741842,
0.1254882962,
-0.0358067453,
-0.0470204204,
-0.5004308224,
0.5441917181,
-0.1425981224,
-0.1741338074,
-0.4345362782,
0.4150393903,
0.0872448012,
0.2745488882,
0.1655815989,
0.3884629607,
0.2132194638,
-0.482596904,
0.7950851321,
-0.0920887813,
-0.4608987272,
0.7552530169,
-0.5081151724,
-0.3882219195,
-0.3483530283,
0.6694816351,
-0.3055686057,
-0.0490744598,
0.2649281919,
-0.2592149377,
0.1456579566,
-0.0703244209,
-0.6638667583,
-0.3522523642,
-0.1108228415,
0.2239955366,
0.5454277396,
-0.4281002581,
0.865059793,
0.3980287611,
0.0179480053,
-0.4929918349,
-0.4123368263,
-0.0548055992,
-0.2717491984,
-0.6376256347,
-0.2327315509,
0.1986880898,
-0.6279607415,
0.2072710842,
0.1009277552,
0.1998851448,
0.1629039645,
0.0144776208,
0.1948823631,
-0.2243092358,
0.4918726981,
-0.1226680726,
0.0452828519,
0.6638872623,
-0.6642961502,
0.2556323111,
-0.3026101589,
-0.5582439899,
-0.3429898024,
0.0942982733,
0.478695184,
-0.6714004278,
0.6831679344,
0.2834665477,
-0.2867205739,
-0.7786272168,
-0.6380357742,
-0.4024399817,
-0.387388438,
0.3963491619,
-0.3682076633,
-1.1179862022,
0.2739187479,
-0.2719211876,
-0.055591438,
0.2546889484,
0.7330517173,
0.0181727987,
0.762855947,
0.4615322053,
0.0272366013,
0.3348284066,
0.0970441028,
0.4125033021,
-0.5598784685,
-0.4957410991,
-0.344353348,
0.0240763165,
-0.2835626304,
-0.5545806289,
-0.0262764022,
0.1369348168,
-0.4797587395,
-0.0219049156,
0.0057779471,
0.6377310157,
0.5234572887,
0.2727864981,
0.3061807752,
-0.1043665186,
-0.5137481093,
0.1543416828,
-0.7404931784,
-0.3659752011,
0.668533802,
0.5622884035,
0.9808546901,
0.2994265854,
0.5668196082,
0.1360802948,
0.2376365215,
-0.9696183205,
0.8254649043,
0.1298701912,
-0.3297097385,
-0.4136994481,
-0.6789821982,
-0.7257798314,
0.4678128064,
-0.4137279987,
-0.6339066029,
-0.1719055623,
0.0912057012,
-0.3486248553,
0.4649389386,
-0.3602151573,
0.6841675043,
-0.4777291119,
-0.6192334294,
-0.6928095818,
-0.4526252151,
0.6310988665,
0.1119362414,
0.5625616908,
-0.0936533809,
0.1547894031,
0.5070266128,
-0.7023652196,
0.7554611564,
-0.1364372373,
-0.4534828067,
0.5045560002,
0.1501363963,
0.512886405,
0.3702768087,
-0.0230768286,
-0.6767393351,
-0.0909721479,
-0.2222521305,
-0.9480731487,
0.5874400735,
-0.5818655491,
-0.9739985466,
-0.4365419447,
-0.7144054174,
-0.3608286679,
0.0932751819,
-0.5290872455,
0.1002820283,
0.1806202978,
0.1337980777,
1.0490684509,
-0.491601944,
0.0617395975,
0.6085363626,
-0.5793457031,
-0.4025455713,
0.7920081019,
-0.1831237376,
0.2444573492,
0.3635694683,
0.4874612391,
-0.670260489,
-0.2774990499,
-0.2524794936,
0.4995945096,
-1.1522156,
-0.0703290403,
-0.4499632716,
-0.1024684533,
-0.371964246,
-0.0478049591,
-0.1142517999,
-0.3588856161,
0.113452293,
-0.2715946436,
0.4404717684,
0.6103414297,
-0.0687756017,
-0.3516968787,
-0.7191271186,
0.10797932,
0.5542240739,
0.3471216559,
0.1258088648,
-0.6890915632,
0.1762653589,
-0.1956985891,
0.0072504757,
-0.556527853,
0.021015821,
-0.0804845169,
0.8128214478,
0.2690728903,
0.0212546214,
0.4594182372,
-0.7195395827,
0.2724123597,
0.4308024943,
-0.8567893505,
0.8106434941,
-0.359750092,
0.1271961778,
0.3572763205,
-0.1323888302,
-0.3471001685,
-0.4189210236,
-0.4960082769,
-0.5013025403,
0.6133909225,
-0.1416409463,
0.2111721337,
0.0617675297,
0.432721734,
-0.1956099719,
0.1865969598,
-1.0483385324,
0.474941045,
-0.1350888461,
-0.1238061935,
0.2762260139,
0.0442740023,
-0.3142994344,
-0.5265436172,
0.6992688179,
-0.191401422,
-0.1705734879,
0.1112570688,
-0.2061997205,
-0.0342985205,
0.5796910524,
0.7748121619,
0.8233548403,
0.0977315009,
0.2097779959,
0.4056540132,
0.0113700433,
0.2603620887,
-0.1197234541,
-0.0550352782,
-0.3867134452,
0.5132825375,
0.8686738014,
0.0122875953,
-1.3179256916,
0.535368681,
0.0921917036,
-0.4075175822,
-0.3476519883,
0.364746362,
0.3577017188,
0.6380270123,
-0.0141329719,
-0.2608818412,
-0.1923597604,
-0.8697935343,
0.3904661834,
0.4156924188,
-0.3978695571,
0.1905453205,
0.5521708131,
0.187039569,
-0.2533404827,
0.6371843219,
-0.3200317621,
-0.7828512788,
0.6141268611,
0.7147794366,
0.5031591654,
0.2567957342,
0.0985582471,
0.2069266438,
0.4310301244,
-0.3192030191,
0.2390805334,
0.0667651668,
-0.7780185342,
-0.7971228361,
-0.5821871161,
-0.3736986518,
-0.0142335463,
-0.257281214,
0.1800688952,
-0.7573689818,
0.0641557649,
-0.3517256379,
-0.0137727819,
-0.395334363,
0.2344029695,
0.2538144588,
0.8835511208,
-0.4640472531,
0.982732892,
0.7182354331,
-0.6266131401,
-1.0193147659,
-0.180988431,
-0.0198039841,
-0.6060819626,
1.0989109278,
-0.0446903668,
-0.3885966837,
-0.3591986597,
-0.5655007362,
-0.2556317151,
0.8998072743,
0.5098664165,
-0.6596508622,
0.2234349251,
0.2302597165,
0.5184022784,
-0.5389302969,
0.1526580751,
0.6641839743,
0.4837206304,
0.1993748248,
-0.5867360234,
0.3621765673,
0.0335771181,
0.1114586964,
0.1694101989,
-0.4318500161,
0.5301583409,
-0.571744442,
0.1692965031,
-0.2418616265,
0.9031968713,
0.7097340226,
0.0103053553,
0.6492608786,
1.004496336,
0.9151828885,
0.053187944,
1.0168070793,
0.0281089209,
0.1933170259,
1.25730443,
-0.6769119501,
0.8311949372,
0.4176381528,
-0.016759254,
0.6183847785,
0.2580326796,
-0.1491404623,
0.2946774662,
0.8552343845,
-0.5234652162,
-0.7008820772,
-0.3036561012,
-0.0683427155,
0.2161604315,
0.5226406455,
-0.2470249534,
-0.3116640151,
0.0948123187,
0.030375801,
0.5337509513,
-0.4978258014,
0.7218385935,
0.1501413882,
-0.7994157672,
0.2383183688,
0.1701352745,
0.329452306,
-0.4601545036,
-0.2849163711,
-0.1239236817,
0.4085765183,
-0.2261032015,
-1.0077375174,
0.1514190882,
-0.0088534504,
-0.0217774846,
-0.1894188374,
0.8052636385,
-0.3515687585,
-0.477032125,
0.6252433062,
0.3351387382,
-0.0964429677,
0.4426960051,
-0.8395855427,
0.1896895319,
-0.1142798513,
-0.1072728187,
0.2847264111,
0.8670577407,
-0.1252269894,
1.0093057156,
0.6436614394,
0.2802179158,
-0.0265232325,
0.4892735481,
0.8957417011,
-0.7888055444,
-0.3527615368,
-0.8636645079,
0.3675363362,
-0.1309520602,
-0.0523366295,
0.3287940621,
0.2870950401,
1.0299443007,
-0.0848209411,
0.8346171975,
0.0387951806,
0.3515417576,
-0.9655054212,
0.4548591077,
-0.4598983228,
0.591385901,
0.0455934443,
-0.7973057628,
-0.2967382967,
1.015765667,
-0.5051663518,
-0.0013492909,
0.6661323309,
0.656481266,
-0.0506939068,
-0.0303292684,
0.5472131371,
0.1138586327,
0.5089066625,
0.7102520466,
1.1607352495,
0.122129187,
0.5293675065,
0.210618645,
-0.0921383426,
-0.1081669405,
-0.8880650997,
-1.0802819729,
0.0987153873,
-0.1756284982,
-0.5620869994,
0.0780932531,
1.2504822016,
0.4550698102,
-0.6717827916,
-0.4211016297,
-0.1798606664,
0.3456816971,
-0.0319948941,
-0.1885877401,
-0.1231830046,
-0.7864417434,
-0.2962187231,
0.4610462189,
0.4047987163,
-0.3836657703,
-0.306166172,
-0.4467819929,
-0.2856698036,
0.3851551116,
0.7888169885,
0.3746366203,
-1.0013390779,
-0.4958001375,
-0.3764709234,
0.0448525511,
-0.1140711159,
1.013032198,
-0.8645123243,
0.1983378977,
0.5633904934,
1.1689729691,
0.1001289785,
-0.2256510407,
0.7155969739,
-0.1005403772,
0.2055548131,
0.4563576281,
0.7093453407,
0.0780560821,
0.034516044,
0.4464943707,
0.3065120876,
-0.3709869981,
-0.5387939811,
0.631727457,
-0.5665839911,
-0.6161832809,
1.111005187,
-0.2034922987,
-0.0825188383,
0.0573019236,
-0.2045511454,
-0.003533789,
-0.3542971015,
0.4958111644,
0.7760154605,
-0.1122212783,
-0.4617486894,
-0.7873898745,
0.4132142961,
0.6650861502,
-1.0991799831,
0.0535735041,
0.6729175448,
0.494430691,
-0.171391204,
0.530082047,
-0.1951221824,
0.3966952562,
-0.3063681424,
-0.2627427876,
0.1518335491,
-0.3071017563,
-0.2960161269,
0.0535800122,
0.3518015742,
0.4677008986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14737v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14737v1
|
Positional Description Matters for Transformers Arithmetic
| 2023-11-22T00:31:01 | 2023-11-22T00:31:01 |
Ruoqi Shen, Sébastien Bubeck, Ronen Eldan, Yin Tat Lee, Yuanzhi Li, Yi Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Transformers, central to the successes in modern Natural Language Processing,
often falter on arithmetic tasks despite their vast capabilities --which
paradoxically include remarkable coding abilities. We observe that a crucial
challenge is their naive reliance on positional information to solve arithmetic
problems with a small number of digits, leading to poor performance on larger
numbers. Herein, we delve deeper into the role of positional encoding, and
propose several ways to fix the issue, either by modifying the positional
encoding directly, or by modifying the representation of the arithmetic task to
leverage standard positional encoding differently. We investigate the value of
these modifications for three tasks: (i) classical multiplication, (ii) length
extrapolation in addition, and (iii) addition in natural language context. For
(i) we train a small model on a small dataset (100M parameters and 300k
samples) with remarkable aptitude in (direct, no scratchpad) 15 digits
multiplication and essentially perfect up to 12 digits, while usual training in
this context would give a model failing at 4 digits multiplication. In the
experiments on addition, we use a mere 120k samples to demonstrate: for (ii)
extrapolation from 10 digits to testing on 12 digits numbers while usual
training would have no extrapolation, and for (iii) almost perfect accuracy up
to 5 digits while usual training would be correct only up to 3 digits (which is
essentially memorization with a training set of 120k samples).
|
[
-0.5485124588,
-0.4440604746,
0.4459086061,
0.5103602409,
-0.1703720689,
-0.1565376222,
-0.332413733,
-0.4943074286,
0.4743985534,
0.3014014065,
-0.1580418348,
0.0374587774,
-1.0307824612,
0.2613157034,
-0.5267718434,
0.8811878562,
-0.0247964989,
0.0199506376,
-0.2412677705,
-0.3717602789,
-0.3617022038,
-1.0235323906,
-0.497531414,
-0.2039690316,
0.2087033093,
0.5296436548,
1.2850154638,
0.9102727175,
0.6908574104,
0.4350302815,
-0.046294488,
0.0913188905,
-0.2259033769,
-0.272285074,
0.045669917,
-0.995934844,
-0.4145172238,
0.0301791579,
0.7577249408,
1.1031243801,
-0.1676349193,
-0.0024691839,
-0.4304301143,
0.9157788754,
-0.4859456122,
0.4494173229,
-0.3476196229,
0.2183668315,
-0.0228378195,
-0.4489510357,
-0.5350014567,
-0.3462741673,
-0.0509895235,
-0.7070420384,
0.7371387482,
-0.2666321099,
0.5607811213,
0.4484593272,
-0.468324095,
-0.3648799062,
-1.1103602648,
0.7564537525,
-0.5602079034,
0.3540097177,
0.5339086056,
0.0396896116,
0.106796816,
-0.3398593664,
-0.5752393603,
-0.0842928812,
-0.5370710492,
0.015544543,
-0.2103871852,
0.0834945291,
0.8118602037,
0.5162744522,
0.0322670266,
-0.1349482983,
-0.6848639846,
0.0142014613,
0.7336817384,
0.1616278291,
0.1186639741,
-0.1440611482,
0.0580920354,
-0.6804131866,
-0.7585352659,
0.2989829183,
0.5043635368,
0.0632698461,
-0.0381285064,
0.882583797,
-0.1336423755,
0.7484499812,
0.6428340077,
0.1182000563,
0.2130487114,
-0.0124104759,
-0.170908168,
0.3235334158,
0.312481761,
0.0824911892,
0.2487698197,
-0.0151608456,
-0.2928353846,
0.3373095989,
0.8145599961,
-0.7401989698,
-0.2565200627,
-0.1935590208,
0.081433557,
-0.2364853621,
0.2524870038,
-0.064014703,
-0.1792855412,
-0.7653264999,
0.5533533096,
-0.5328603983,
0.2624258399,
0.2620450258,
-0.0366698653,
0.1595069021,
0.1262452304,
-1.5738809109,
0.1791794002,
1.014297843,
0.3302229941,
0.2581183314,
-0.3103420436,
-0.3770420551,
0.0097861746,
-0.6277593374,
0.6609065533,
-0.7148698568,
-0.4558129907,
-0.2359289974,
0.020068774,
-0.3232139349,
-0.5235715508,
0.5392122865,
-0.5595476627,
0.3051968515,
-0.1960128993,
-0.3195587695,
-0.1210676581,
-0.0661140233,
-0.9757580161,
0.8534350991,
0.153746143,
-0.5486474037,
0.2974116802,
-0.5003822446,
-0.7635503411,
-0.1804746091,
-0.1957301199,
-0.3264716566,
0.9060058594,
0.4078938663,
0.2078210562,
0.0684054792,
0.0493568368,
0.2094834447,
-0.8535258174,
0.3674749136,
-0.5802931786,
0.4955874979,
-0.3350366056,
-0.4568409324,
-0.139508605,
-0.7834714651,
-0.2047692686,
-0.0726956874,
-0.3930753171,
-0.2833152413,
-0.0940829515,
-0.7317143679,
0.1722625196,
0.0904063061,
-0.3055514395,
0.2248002887,
-0.985095799,
0.2564424574,
0.5818440318,
-0.2231006026,
1.0013719797,
-0.1053769216,
0.5709998608,
0.0171204619,
0.090981409,
-0.2343089134,
-0.4246358275,
-1.2649109364,
0.2269079983,
0.4818973243,
0.4447727501,
-1.0471396446,
0.3114832938,
-0.6292918921,
-0.3755660653,
-0.4708229005,
-0.2394830436,
0.1921032965,
0.3434769213,
0.5230994821,
-0.2972863019,
-0.4093066156,
-1.1504940987,
-0.2767665684,
-0.2351966202,
-0.3872165084,
-0.0999244973,
0.313464433,
0.0936316028,
0.8018763661,
-0.4531822205,
-0.2618914843,
-0.0151558798,
0.3227939904,
0.486428827,
0.4181347787,
0.2952368855,
-0.8731154203,
-0.3804627359,
-0.2422063053,
-0.639926672,
0.2031482607,
-0.2573897541,
0.2344602197,
0.2763679326,
0.2041464448,
-1.0551444292,
0.5836780667,
0.5103945732,
-0.2567890286,
0.2905693352,
-0.6876875758,
0.1290496141,
-0.6719967723,
-0.2707232237,
0.0117317112,
-0.0328469872,
-0.8118627667,
0.2311863452,
0.3043389022,
-0.124587737,
-0.2915103137,
0.0101450253,
-0.3737778068,
-0.135312587,
-0.2126455307,
-0.2445487082,
0.128561452,
0.7685077786,
0.1377232969,
0.8898589611,
0.1506196707,
-0.5517114997,
0.2533073425,
0.2937375307,
0.0926671103,
0.4960508645,
-0.7242860198,
0.2559988201,
-0.3172753155,
0.3774357438,
-0.6841677427,
-0.1529597044,
0.1016104668,
-0.6292518377,
0.4773142338,
-0.1244985759,
-0.6307198405,
-0.3373917341,
-0.4557021856,
0.5819619298,
0.5951857567,
-0.4456545115,
0.7261353731,
0.2903390825,
0.0651772767,
-0.6346293688,
-0.6098054647,
-0.0141693335,
-0.133070752,
-0.6893566251,
0.5957306623,
0.3487084508,
-0.1603697985,
-0.2488066107,
-0.4396077096,
0.0105874594,
-0.126477465,
0.2407221049,
0.2241944671,
-0.1939931363,
0.1373050362,
0.0204016231,
-0.7067042589,
0.339105159,
-0.0679662824,
0.3490997255,
-0.3411750793,
-0.3517729342,
-0.2306531072,
0.1988460869,
0.4643520713,
-0.0389629491,
0.7652182579,
0.7459055781,
-0.3693936765,
-0.0113053052,
-0.2743054926,
-0.2805797756,
-0.5744710565,
0.1727965623,
-0.4162316024,
-0.6455970407,
0.1670373976,
0.5207853913,
-0.0119872745,
0.7982293963,
0.2873423398,
-0.1686766595,
1.3187202215,
0.7601757646,
0.3039324284,
0.2419127673,
-0.414180249,
0.5901039839,
-0.7289316058,
-0.2063784897,
-0.4726462066,
-0.4836115539,
-0.65440166,
-0.6390948892,
0.4116918743,
0.1246556789,
0.11640165,
0.7738113403,
-0.6868461967,
0.6391341686,
0.559535265,
-0.0487468988,
0.1813093871,
0.0504057035,
0.3746596277,
-0.5661085844,
-0.6964836121,
-0.3622786105,
0.8715897202,
0.3109070361,
0.5889561176,
0.2060582191,
0.4113308191,
0.189768523,
0.30003649,
-1.0369218588,
0.4948331118,
-0.5603505373,
-0.3883218765,
-0.4126979113,
-0.3880070448,
-0.8717001081,
0.2850990593,
0.0427198447,
-0.2080248743,
0.4192685783,
0.4391204417,
-0.4683876932,
0.2553187609,
-0.9971695542,
0.4396677613,
-0.2400277555,
-0.0459520295,
-0.4149760306,
-0.606398344,
0.0101635819,
0.1497653425,
0.1520212591,
0.2465910316,
-0.0157867465,
0.7234377861,
-0.6522736549,
0.8676890135,
-0.1284978837,
-0.2662538886,
0.1690030843,
0.1491553187,
0.8012918234,
0.0488145985,
0.1638936549,
0.2435047328,
-0.0382706299,
-0.4896608591,
-0.9316264391,
0.4726449549,
-0.9171789885,
-0.8126454949,
-0.4117469788,
-0.5622579455,
-0.538474381,
-0.3271093369,
0.3981534243,
0.8361299634,
0.372590661,
0.4281072021,
0.7876600027,
-0.1774425805,
0.4395287037,
0.1382556111,
0.2390562445,
-0.1680318564,
1.01501441,
0.2643545568,
0.2455653995,
0.8421525955,
0.0392453298,
-0.4978120327,
-0.3058706224,
-0.6579272747,
0.1764569432,
-1.0122843981,
0.0227677301,
-0.5228275657,
-0.1938555837,
-0.2568900287,
-0.2670080364,
-0.4133020639,
-1.1015110016,
-0.2996665239,
-0.3189512789,
0.2304867357,
0.7836661935,
-0.1830313951,
0.3692738414,
-0.9883045554,
0.6743289232,
0.579741478,
0.2962987125,
-0.0170841496,
-0.7430371642,
-0.5191966295,
0.0993755683,
-0.1626051664,
-0.5856032372,
0.3146373332,
0.0541287921,
0.1687028557,
0.200197041,
-0.1824561656,
0.9290915728,
-0.6129980087,
0.6618840694,
0.2446616739,
-0.9760500193,
0.091956906,
-0.0076779053,
0.3413515687,
0.5375118256,
0.258615464,
-0.5423225164,
-0.1019415781,
-0.9168080688,
-0.8583341837,
1.0378642082,
0.5086643696,
0.5516014099,
-0.0544417836,
0.1308617294,
0.0828659013,
0.0766258985,
-0.4387047291,
-0.4147801995,
-0.3522688746,
-0.1476029605,
-0.1508821398,
-0.3801091313,
-0.1591745168,
-0.4719779491,
0.518337369,
0.033178553,
0.7478904724,
0.1208431274,
-0.3864858449,
-0.0511153974,
0.3694983423,
0.8751136661,
0.8088963032,
0.0902201384,
0.369092226,
0.3741261363,
-0.5439504385,
0.2249643356,
0.161491096,
0.0186944809,
0.2624964118,
0.5278732777,
0.8592573404,
0.5656216741,
-0.1855441779,
0.4852028787,
-0.0098520359,
-0.1176179498,
-0.6071892977,
0.1636318117,
0.002172234,
-0.2571156323,
0.5747699738,
0.4875946641,
0.0394608155,
-0.3609314859,
0.105954282,
0.0173100401,
-0.5327591896,
-0.8561659455,
0.5652273893,
0.1231830791,
-0.6976790428,
0.6271962523,
-0.0868909359,
-0.6411451697,
0.779250145,
0.4020931125,
0.5765361786,
-0.168186456,
0.3074320853,
0.4649811387,
0.440126121,
-0.1391391903,
-0.1786247194,
-0.1108779162,
-0.7093119621,
-0.6725767255,
-0.4172083735,
-0.4315195084,
-0.3638190329,
-0.6853180528,
0.1052095667,
-0.5161458254,
0.0180588085,
0.1936786622,
-0.2548942566,
-0.7479075193,
0.3173296452,
0.3618399501,
0.6586061716,
-0.6729585528,
0.6150850654,
0.8063812256,
-0.1122789234,
-0.9898633361,
-0.4297527373,
-0.3012302518,
-0.8681566715,
0.5394928455,
0.4378360808,
-0.1872390062,
-0.0694172904,
-0.2663292587,
-0.8625128269,
0.8034266829,
0.3957186937,
-0.446551919,
-0.2727577984,
0.8104128838,
1.0014309883,
-0.0673139319,
0.3198534846,
0.7166339755,
0.3774905205,
0.143532604,
-0.8710104227,
-0.1384934932,
-0.3432933986,
0.1178970858,
0.5754830837,
-0.5383979082,
0.9687687159,
-0.1265468597,
-0.2523012459,
-0.2537780106,
0.3112124205,
0.0995990038,
-0.0778998807,
0.4321941435,
0.7841838002,
0.2666775584,
-0.3685202897,
1.625022769,
-0.2319477797,
0.317532897,
0.8514370322,
0.2933937311,
0.6194317937,
0.5745682716,
-0.5916281343,
0.2793724239,
0.2631201446,
0.0953493714,
0.171998322,
-0.0955165327,
-0.1481500417,
-0.2219801396,
0.2869435549,
-0.4526337087,
0.4744093716,
0.4541428983,
-0.4023863375,
0.0012760249,
-0.3013387322,
-0.1552611589,
0.1678165942,
-0.3177579045,
0.4794479609,
0.1388132274,
-0.7465590239,
0.6302897334,
0.4057446122,
0.493701458,
-0.4678646028,
-0.2803983092,
-0.2849576473,
0.3628644049,
-0.2407647818,
-0.7508855462,
0.7101092935,
-0.4013375342,
-0.3095430434,
-0.5332468152,
0.4087547064,
-0.1472738981,
-0.7724539042,
-0.2038455755,
-0.0003178354,
-0.0662508607,
-0.3193313777,
-0.275426656,
-0.2010904402,
0.0165767297,
-0.0654795915,
0.0729336962,
0.6349769235,
-0.1801014096,
0.3210143149,
0.738773644,
-0.0246097166,
0.2566299438,
0.0744615048,
0.6267569661,
-0.9899095893,
-0.601180315,
-0.9532775879,
0.4015722871,
0.1224045455,
-0.3018144071,
0.6704229712,
0.4476477504,
0.9116837382,
-0.3664795458,
0.2413913906,
-0.0801986158,
0.0450368859,
-0.3901859522,
0.2407014966,
0.017278187,
0.4550475478,
0.140294835,
-1.2461217642,
-0.4260903299,
0.6859579086,
-0.6413660049,
-0.1373340786,
0.7490522861,
0.3749214113,
-0.0954577923,
0.2606615424,
0.3240944743,
-0.0013223187,
0.1551353484,
0.7304765582,
1.0674966574,
-0.8140170574,
0.6755118966,
-0.7538565993,
0.0903147683,
-0.2074851543,
-0.4193581641,
-0.6132509112,
-0.3948655427,
-0.0761778131,
-0.0328884609,
-0.5483369231,
0.8092322946,
0.7734702826,
-0.871388793,
0.0126489624,
-0.008446808,
0.1031456143,
-0.2360653728,
-0.2055828869,
0.4423740506,
-0.1500989348,
-0.9127583504,
0.3182670772,
0.3846304417,
0.1277104318,
-0.1086448282,
0.0129174506,
0.3275715709,
-0.0002511486,
0.86281991,
0.2245286852,
-0.5008965135,
-0.4049023092,
0.2106612176,
-0.0369358249,
0.4893988073,
1.0918214321,
-0.8982329965,
0.3504294455,
0.352833271,
0.6327579618,
0.5581715107,
0.4722750783,
0.6414217353,
-1.004329443,
0.4702593684,
0.3803152144,
0.2914771736,
0.6570253968,
-0.5229883194,
0.5275917053,
0.0953632817,
-0.1669806689,
-0.5196036696,
0.1883543432,
-0.7274821401,
0.0528629757,
0.8941153884,
0.1823243052,
-0.138407886,
0.0067656832,
-0.0399217904,
-0.0361438505,
-0.1852542907,
1.0012251139,
0.7818774581,
-0.3128188252,
0.1369122118,
-0.347140789,
0.5615297556,
0.708029151,
-0.3476758599,
-0.2044411898,
0.3852849901,
-0.0911247283,
0.693059206,
0.2981170416,
-0.2414751947,
0.34164083,
0.1633785665,
-0.2820569277,
-0.0110523235,
-0.4843384922,
-0.598144412,
0.172714904,
0.0828073248,
-0.0598050542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13061v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13061v1
|
Attribution and Alignment: Effects of Local Context Repetition on Utterance Production and Comprehension in Dialogue
| 2023-11-21T23:50:33 | 2023-11-21T23:50:33 |
Aron Molnar, Jaap Jumelet, Mario Giulianelli, Arabella Sinclair
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models are often used as the backbone of modern dialogue systems.
These models are pre-trained on large amounts of written fluent language.
Repetition is typically penalised when evaluating language model generations.
However, it is a key component of dialogue. Humans use local and partner
specific repetitions; these are preferred by human users and lead to more
successful communication in dialogue. In this study, we evaluate (a) whether
language models produce human-like levels of repetition in dialogue, and (b)
what are the processing mechanisms related to lexical re-use they use during
comprehension. We believe that such joint analysis of model production and
comprehension behaviour can inform the development of cognitively inspired
dialogue generation systems.
|
[
-0.2371736318,
-0.623360455,
0.6237927675,
0.010572413,
-0.1453989446,
-0.1991791874,
0.1182156429,
-0.554089427,
0.0236374028,
0.9103223085,
-0.5551387072,
-0.0660855994,
0.1372424364,
0.2654157877,
-0.6131916642,
0.6994652152,
-0.1782034338,
0.2175443619,
-0.4953634143,
-0.3257011473,
-0.7206403613,
-0.8161309958,
-0.7712058425,
-0.5114284158,
0.4399801791,
0.3311718702,
0.7336121798,
0.5408606529,
0.125224635,
0.4132570624,
0.1000767499,
-0.3232829869,
-0.5597712398,
0.4359500408,
-0.1550236046,
-0.4977492392,
-0.0806175172,
0.0007483285,
0.8821030259,
0.8773904443,
-0.3796962202,
-0.209906131,
0.3546625078,
0.2895506322,
-0.5054937601,
-0.2028554827,
-0.7726593018,
-0.1742597371,
0.0784047991,
-0.2235951573,
-0.3324818015,
-0.4358620048,
0.4212398231,
-0.7732858062,
0.207068637,
0.0794099271,
0.5382812619,
0.2022530884,
-0.4916794002,
-0.5304430723,
-0.5807384253,
0.971607089,
-0.8435566425,
0.2420147955,
0.134278357,
0.1020906344,
-0.1975900829,
-0.8481805325,
-0.6819125414,
-0.1791283041,
-0.4269288778,
0.0750867575,
0.0685411319,
-0.0604388565,
0.2777360082,
0.3039124906,
-0.339068681,
-0.1706438661,
-0.3386923671,
-0.1385718286,
0.3971236348,
0.4721018076,
0.3260992765,
-0.5872709155,
-0.4478142858,
0.0163399652,
-0.7229039073,
0.2390069216,
0.4340282083,
0.0914538279,
0.1140185967,
0.3008729815,
-0.3461112678,
0.9763687849,
-0.0708595216,
-0.1679121703,
-0.0694121346,
-0.8516886234,
-0.0958433002,
0.1530069858,
0.6329840422,
0.1816401482,
0.5292155147,
0.1119730696,
-0.2072060108,
0.1545167565,
0.5199542046,
-0.355055958,
0.055795908,
-0.1775125563,
-0.3436651826,
-0.6001493931,
-0.0315697305,
-0.227861017,
-0.0647117347,
-0.6518843174,
0.232062012,
-0.4004217088,
0.0343286395,
0.1411107928,
-0.213348344,
0.3799126446,
0.0830009803,
-0.7505480647,
0.2532992661,
0.5807771683,
0.5205273628,
-0.0853822902,
-0.5767456293,
-0.1912009865,
0.2190339416,
-0.1990963668,
0.6775814295,
-0.5465225577,
-0.410915345,
0.0664964765,
-0.0304499082,
-0.2042405903,
-0.6370273232,
0.3144571483,
-0.18616952,
0.4585289955,
-0.3852214217,
-0.4806714654,
-0.1023951843,
-0.0997544974,
-0.6876220703,
0.4315379858,
0.2004446685,
-0.6256892085,
0.5686972141,
-0.3155001998,
-0.5289411545,
-0.0476668924,
-0.2979063094,
-0.0135649927,
0.2857667506,
0.1613462865,
0.0054593766,
-0.3321220279,
0.3251932859,
-0.135574922,
-0.3347187042,
0.6433868408,
-0.5270249248,
0.7534652352,
0.3680805862,
-0.185536623,
0.0985451937,
-0.7251599431,
0.0799208134,
0.071231015,
-0.217487216,
-0.2425206304,
0.1017159969,
-0.2730265558,
0.2488982677,
0.1050648317,
-0.4090416133,
-0.0957193598,
-0.4220124185,
0.7408058047,
0.3193583786,
0.5035838485,
0.568381846,
-0.6452817917,
0.5162947178,
-0.0512666889,
-0.0376287065,
-0.4939248264,
-0.4706521034,
-0.5020219088,
-0.0299537312,
0.0045665191,
0.5342316031,
-0.6568808556,
0.1323931366,
-0.1236768067,
-0.158926934,
-0.4864593744,
0.2417100519,
0.5390286446,
0.6142017245,
-0.1948836595,
-0.6448962092,
-0.5251165628,
-0.9026978016,
-0.4186920226,
-0.1474797428,
-0.1783939898,
0.3756939769,
0.2656807303,
0.1048032641,
1.3461208344,
-0.2607083619,
0.0438355431,
-0.2991101146,
0.3209530413,
-0.1632098556,
0.6204924583,
0.4882151783,
-0.683134973,
-0.395837307,
-0.2579956055,
-0.9764203429,
-0.2781665027,
-0.3809583187,
-0.1866012961,
0.2877486348,
0.549500823,
-0.5781964064,
0.4841142595,
0.2890882194,
-0.1646678299,
0.444325,
0.0237582028,
0.3758210838,
-1.1643553972,
0.0403154753,
-0.4070117474,
-0.2615527213,
-0.7024316192,
-0.0776428431,
-0.3753394485,
-0.4289526045,
-0.6112112403,
0.5558242798,
-0.393553406,
-0.2789966762,
-0.0439507216,
0.5025206208,
0.2668488324,
0.3717787564,
0.2688603699,
0.7323526144,
0.239448458,
-0.4003146291,
0.3598324656,
0.2147456557,
-0.8749213219,
0.6445559263,
-0.8209848404,
0.1608799994,
0.0251619834,
0.389280051,
-1.123988986,
-0.4553906024,
0.0459103286,
-0.4800235033,
0.0469034687,
0.3188540637,
-0.1750290394,
-0.0911026448,
-0.0315837562,
0.6814642549,
0.4582005441,
-0.3329050839,
0.4303784072,
0.0570861399,
-0.2555964589,
-0.3369286954,
-0.5721106529,
-0.2980331481,
-0.4114488363,
-0.952164948,
0.008671145,
0.2727099657,
-0.5821618438,
-0.1796505898,
-0.0036935261,
0.2025856823,
0.1482047737,
0.2303955108,
-0.1540066004,
-0.1465640366,
-0.1087062433,
-0.2675752938,
0.1468218416,
-0.0453755558,
-0.0196478069,
0.6448735595,
0.0638050735,
-0.4635340571,
-0.7773672342,
0.6450591087,
0.5587199926,
-0.0380199663,
0.7550719976,
0.1476733088,
-0.3005494177,
0.2169322371,
-0.4653574228,
-0.4430170357,
-0.4789561927,
0.2959541678,
-0.4909277558,
-0.8219600916,
0.8485904336,
0.3691577911,
-0.1260129362,
0.3540314734,
0.3481220603,
-0.2932246625,
1.0339940786,
0.2561338544,
-0.1458303481,
0.7258555293,
0.1086424589,
0.1268952489,
-0.7741087675,
0.184834525,
-0.452390343,
-0.2112411559,
-0.1937324256,
-0.0309654549,
0.0235773008,
0.6150053144,
-0.234225139,
0.4018811584,
-0.271607399,
0.4634662271,
0.595381856,
-0.2222970277,
0.3174920976,
0.2063959986,
0.0114694871,
-0.1923685372,
-0.7712346315,
-0.6662756801,
0.8734372258,
0.1203383431,
0.7059112191,
0.0339768082,
0.8025788665,
0.1079880819,
0.2524255216,
-0.4894504845,
0.45453614,
0.3363218606,
-0.6473653316,
-0.4144360125,
-0.3848167658,
-1.2736805677,
0.0233416948,
0.0407856666,
-1.1770141125,
0.1648682058,
0.0846281871,
-0.4887777865,
-0.077453278,
-0.7521355748,
1.0034594536,
0.0512234569,
-0.2446844429,
-0.2743239701,
-0.5572075844,
0.3669575751,
-0.1413253695,
0.0676999688,
0.430139184,
0.4182665348,
0.6536642313,
-0.3815776408,
0.8118388653,
0.0478405543,
-0.2414529175,
0.9405531883,
0.2118237615,
0.4772511721,
0.0400842428,
0.1124832332,
-0.088521935,
0.0043543405,
-0.2476697862,
-0.6072753668,
0.7708033919,
-0.6582528353,
-0.9113867879,
-0.1225462854,
-0.6569880247,
-0.0000024212,
-0.0492734313,
0.4275242686,
0.7117001414,
-0.2751255035,
0.3131489158,
0.1483879089,
-0.2303295285,
0.228657648,
0.2562856972,
-0.2663632631,
-0.5509821177,
0.7404612899,
0.0781120062,
0.9432604313,
-0.0527922586,
-0.1621588618,
-0.0347035266,
-0.0970301479,
-0.1545856595,
0.2668231428,
-0.8826090097,
-0.0424304232,
-0.381280601,
-0.1899948418,
-0.6406723261,
-0.5910806656,
-0.1612480134,
-0.543459177,
-0.2004196495,
0.1047196984,
-0.0562008284,
1.0220737457,
0.1396442205,
0.5568296909,
-0.6846185327,
0.0610252209,
0.531409502,
-0.1055355445,
0.0672300532,
-0.4328841567,
-0.1685227156,
0.2634755373,
-0.5325388312,
-1.0927829742,
0.2003670931,
-0.0054448955,
0.6242536306,
0.3399167359,
-0.2415141761,
0.4596421719,
-0.2066499442,
1.0834325552,
0.0442867465,
-1.0066373348,
0.4476329684,
-0.5849173665,
0.775272429,
0.5158774853,
0.159334287,
-0.7168775201,
-0.5300226808,
-0.7398383021,
-0.6747074723,
0.8588318229,
0.4118541479,
0.0204367526,
-0.1944166124,
0.6546458006,
-0.0793093666,
0.2527171075,
-0.7588140965,
0.0447536148,
-0.1120923236,
-0.0973272994,
-0.0285621658,
-0.3230029345,
-0.2266893536,
-0.0669047534,
0.4042532444,
-0.0122710653,
0.319716543,
0.3734822571,
-0.2019032091,
-0.3252016008,
0.1809728593,
0.7967262268,
0.8483211994,
-0.0866955668,
-0.4252007604,
0.3345935047,
0.0674818084,
0.0201215111,
-0.5347757936,
-0.2172866315,
0.021062199,
0.6148666739,
0.8333237767,
0.4043969214,
-0.3421231508,
0.1675946265,
0.0352418311,
-0.2553523183,
-0.444801569,
0.1571676135,
0.1537701786,
0.2138849795,
0.074706763,
0.0954504907,
0.1321291029,
-0.9925205112,
0.4058169723,
0.4128870666,
-0.3028320074,
-0.1261758208,
0.455786109,
0.1237922609,
-0.5265436172,
0.7908860445,
0.0594397411,
-0.6612690091,
0.5366440415,
0.7540989518,
0.691074729,
-0.2541106939,
-0.0257580504,
0.550740242,
-0.2375782281,
-0.0208623521,
0.0517758206,
-0.3476273715,
-1.0270045996,
-0.3768033683,
-0.6547912359,
-0.2398726195,
-0.1439360678,
-0.9841769934,
0.1120953038,
-0.1550991237,
-0.2536433935,
-0.0131317219,
-0.3849061728,
-0.521945715,
0.1059255674,
0.3234577477,
0.4585680366,
-0.6688563228,
0.9378374219,
0.5351235867,
-0.4510676265,
-0.8220624924,
-0.1489609182,
0.0285673793,
-0.5745781064,
0.6842948198,
0.1945587844,
-0.2694431245,
-0.0620542243,
-0.5283463001,
-1.0237904787,
1.081440568,
0.2286786884,
-0.3808290362,
-0.1408170909,
0.2857242227,
0.5088508129,
-0.8861644268,
0.0574169159,
0.9300207496,
0.158346191,
0.1429427266,
-1.1076180935,
-0.0211573206,
0.0730727911,
0.3136350811,
0.1219778582,
-0.4421319366,
0.8617346883,
0.0940824375,
-0.3918235302,
0.5391516685,
0.4643230438,
0.5175642967,
-0.0097351251,
0.4931291044,
0.6180250049,
0.3844764531,
-0.125505358,
1.243358016,
-0.3640761077,
0.1688944995,
1.382678628,
-0.3542834818,
0.80245471,
0.6336383224,
0.0209583584,
0.7865740657,
0.2818317413,
0.4580318332,
0.4861854017,
0.3594453633,
-0.2154130191,
-0.2124792337,
-0.1331276149,
-0.2709923983,
0.5124598742,
0.2863453329,
-0.4364210665,
0.1657238305,
0.0927385837,
-0.191487655,
0.2275855541,
-0.1356526613,
1.0893439054,
0.2061867118,
-1.2167290449,
0.781236887,
-0.414934665,
0.2554451525,
-0.4948544204,
0.2650923729,
-0.3105301857,
0.280980587,
-0.0023541758,
-0.6562791467,
0.4840160012,
-0.2776842117,
-0.1827074885,
-0.263109684,
0.6688651443,
-0.4684655666,
-0.2151404917,
0.1564937532,
0.2599072754,
0.1820669621,
-0.0101577118,
-0.4691278338,
-0.0995758027,
0.5055549741,
-0.5737581849,
0.1955489665,
0.4676422775,
-0.2166130096,
0.6492926478,
0.478308171,
-0.1766413748,
0.2038558125,
0.2659024894,
0.5536065102,
-0.8907122612,
-0.1966062933,
-0.5066666007,
0.602303803,
-0.2133137733,
-0.2938756943,
0.6625884771,
0.2837309837,
1.0935199261,
0.0198789295,
0.6312203407,
0.051934436,
0.3107201755,
-0.4351713657,
0.518414855,
-0.5935446024,
0.1454571038,
-0.3285791278,
-1.1740683317,
0.0054024379,
0.7732270956,
-0.3767952919,
0.0372900888,
0.8551385403,
0.7974680066,
0.1550377607,
0.3476037979,
0.245346874,
-0.0742995068,
0.1527558565,
0.473474741,
1.0891551971,
-0.3484036922,
0.4971358478,
-0.1470932364,
0.1710886061,
0.0856951028,
-0.4836997688,
-0.5891850591,
-0.6385223866,
-0.1089527309,
-0.1837736517,
-0.1870056987,
0.6351377368,
0.3295512795,
-0.7887237668,
-0.5196724534,
-0.3281764984,
-0.0505588055,
-0.0960345268,
-0.2645221353,
-0.2072651982,
-0.7178061604,
-0.6605558395,
0.2973005474,
0.0308438838,
0.1502009034,
-0.2633316219,
-0.2695475519,
-0.2768203914,
0.1816352457,
0.3442368507,
0.1845759451,
-0.9742804766,
-0.4195255339,
-0.2166030556,
-0.3268283308,
0.0372088663,
1.2714482546,
-0.9156081676,
0.4650207758,
0.5779140592,
0.0945426002,
0.2090398222,
0.3676703274,
1.3243174553,
-0.7636291385,
0.3108482957,
0.0442903973,
0.6076723933,
0.4904260933,
-0.165104866,
0.3544053137,
0.2123102993,
-0.7588913441,
-0.6437616348,
0.5760473013,
-0.5153033137,
-0.1962665319,
0.9901342988,
-0.1462515742,
-0.1255732477,
-0.0632524937,
-0.3851698339,
0.490178138,
-0.2892987728,
0.3580063581,
1.0900757313,
-0.1067380235,
0.0540614985,
-0.3963896334,
0.6759053469,
1.0098930597,
-0.2927809954,
0.1320694685,
0.591263473,
0.2488092929,
0.4177229404,
0.4830508828,
-0.0203221869,
0.2066683024,
0.1875702739,
0.0196520463,
0.4992895722,
-0.2357433885,
-0.3153873086,
0.0245071016,
0.0952311605,
0.256762594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13053v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13053v1
|
Beyond Text: Unveiling Multimodal Proficiency of Large Language Models with MultiAPI Benchmark
| 2023-11-21T23:26:05 | 2023-11-21T23:26:05 |
Xiao Liu, Jianfeng Lin, Jiawei Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The proliferation of Large Language Models like ChatGPT has significantly
advanced language understanding and generation, impacting a broad spectrum of
applications. However, these models predominantly excel in text-based tasks,
overlooking the complexity of real-world multimodal information. This study
introduces MultiAPI, a pioneering comprehensive large-scale API benchmark
dataset aimed at expanding LLMs' proficiency in multimodal contexts. Developed
collaboratively through ChatGPT, MultiAPI consists of 235 diverse API calls and
2,038 contextual prompts, offering a unique platform evaluation of
tool-augmented LLMs handling multimodal tasks. Through comprehensive
experiments, our findings reveal that while LLMs demonstrate proficiency in API
call decision-making, they face challenges in domain identification, function
selection, and argument generation. What's more, we surprisingly notice that
auxiliary context can actually impair the performance. An in-depth error
analysis paves the way for a new paradigm to address these challenges,
suggesting a potential direction for future LLM research.
|
[
-0.4486840069,
-0.7244682312,
0.6427773833,
0.3078786731,
0.0617684163,
0.4927338064,
-0.4869627953,
-0.4971427023,
-0.1840301901,
0.1940224022,
-0.7196336389,
-0.5348154902,
-0.6319547892,
-0.0282416996,
-0.1151065081,
0.6965383291,
-0.0477261469,
0.0657688454,
-0.52256459,
-0.3053887784,
-0.7271862626,
-0.7618128061,
-0.5471477509,
-0.1419523656,
0.7114640474,
0.3838532865,
0.3558158278,
0.1666882783,
0.3328609765,
0.3285999894,
0.2650512457,
0.6513666511,
-0.2570168674,
0.0396009162,
0.1409750879,
-0.7358227372,
-0.6001966596,
0.0122638829,
0.6784946918,
0.6822666526,
0.2254224569,
0.0624242239,
0.1243714988,
0.3967672884,
-0.5932455063,
0.3428298831,
-0.6008737087,
-0.1354111284,
-0.3053716719,
-0.3405773342,
-0.6420609951,
-0.0443250909,
0.2814493179,
-0.5726693273,
-0.1362264007,
0.0153690297,
0.4883677959,
0.2776756287,
-0.8371863365,
-0.275195986,
-0.5323236585,
1.044541955,
-0.5138161778,
0.692312181,
0.2073924243,
0.1854785383,
-0.1368262768,
-0.7430782318,
-0.5558418632,
-0.231725201,
0.1647913456,
0.1170435324,
-0.0465473719,
0.0666655824,
0.1657494754,
0.0031093615,
-0.4994390309,
0.0078972289,
-0.1006720364,
-0.1854393631,
0.2997818589,
0.0840115622,
0.356757164,
0.0480392575,
-0.3915591538,
-0.2821828425,
-0.6648733616,
0.0964746699,
0.2540082932,
0.3696481586,
-0.2885015309,
0.5850856304,
0.0918518305,
0.456136167,
-0.5805054903,
-0.255863905,
0.5358179212,
-0.4459110796,
0.0341504812,
-0.3242182434,
0.5651106238,
0.4858543575,
0.3559352458,
-0.2275990993,
-0.0161548071,
0.0915626958,
0.1828537434,
-0.5636539459,
0.0047757784,
0.4103997946,
-0.3821253181,
0.1288205683,
-0.2512767613,
-0.69312644,
-0.4840613604,
-0.3902502358,
0.2959750295,
-0.5397117138,
-0.4794977307,
-0.167554453,
-0.222047925,
0.1636280864,
0.2967720628,
-0.5946208835,
0.1977151632,
0.9141178131,
0.9671916962,
-0.298235029,
-0.7904853821,
-0.3879226744,
0.0245039184,
-0.3332373798,
1.0313298702,
-0.7716448307,
-0.3936543167,
0.0791385099,
-0.1040689424,
-0.283141017,
-0.3938694,
0.5981663465,
-0.4160478115,
-0.2255113423,
-0.2295619845,
-0.5316029787,
-0.0715794936,
0.4763766527,
-0.5016341805,
1.0459851027,
-0.207796976,
-0.4180861115,
0.6073480844,
-0.8661842942,
-0.2903595567,
-0.0140988007,
-0.252396822,
0.0002553161,
0.1556503773,
0.1328374147,
0.3267836869,
-0.2100097388,
0.1808070838,
-0.4020341635,
-0.1079944521,
0.6910831928,
-0.8941142559,
0.1690558791,
0.1488637924,
0.0467147119,
0.2354212552,
-0.877202034,
0.1976218075,
-0.2189055234,
-0.5324193239,
-0.3009334505,
0.2098073363,
0.3726944029,
0.3188636005,
0.2302812636,
-0.529445827,
0.19055897,
-0.008783591,
0.6234196424,
0.7949365377,
-0.4923956692,
0.2525517046,
-0.3058741689,
0.3273696601,
-0.1921956539,
0.0042056558,
-0.5749776959,
-0.6482900381,
-0.4928658903,
-0.5737680197,
0.3238059878,
0.5064198375,
-0.650818944,
-0.0462972894,
-0.5700618029,
-0.4543833435,
-0.5543466806,
0.2772897184,
0.4315660596,
0.2773706317,
0.2989192009,
-0.094607316,
-0.5184305906,
-0.8875992298,
-0.2279431373,
-0.0901536196,
-0.0488614924,
0.6098027825,
0.3832197785,
-0.4953706563,
0.8611425161,
-0.2596851289,
-0.1324844062,
-0.2458663732,
0.3817111254,
0.1523315758,
0.3460611105,
0.2296383679,
-0.8076760173,
-0.2759962678,
-0.0217926577,
-0.6055592895,
-0.0763863698,
-0.1384345591,
-0.0609660186,
0.0797324851,
0.5968655944,
-0.7213403583,
-0.0075982972,
0.8079455495,
-0.0923196226,
0.5026423931,
-0.3736597002,
0.2850449383,
-0.9694433808,
0.0901799649,
-0.0697330609,
-0.0250745341,
-0.6090103984,
0.0194928404,
0.3957842588,
-0.1266074628,
-0.5022959709,
0.7496927977,
-0.4439590573,
-0.1432751268,
-0.3400149345,
0.2163503021,
0.0051820236,
0.5259949565,
0.0218553655,
1.0291575193,
0.4280107021,
-0.5030143857,
0.2267222404,
0.2402620912,
-0.2939734459,
0.5521683097,
-0.4249253571,
0.0678770393,
0.0332194753,
0.4198178947,
-1.6039261818,
-0.3085526526,
-0.1960969567,
-0.4078810811,
0.1494153738,
-0.2961794138,
-0.868699789,
-0.1595627517,
-0.3703079522,
0.7133090496,
0.077706486,
-0.5628769398,
0.9033592343,
0.3248155117,
-0.3278128207,
-0.6403468251,
-0.8091141582,
0.3120835125,
-0.0933749601,
-0.6930766106,
0.2029245049,
-0.2966996431,
-0.1979927272,
-0.5209783912,
0.0445922539,
-0.2429309189,
-0.0112745566,
0.3572233319,
0.2862148583,
-0.1777084917,
0.4564452171,
0.0445956029,
-0.1207259372,
0.034196794,
0.0653383359,
0.7971263528,
-0.171961084,
-0.7746230364,
-0.4090670049,
0.3526403308,
0.8257190585,
-0.3917895257,
0.319295764,
0.4194952846,
-0.0249573365,
-0.0092477836,
-0.7450463176,
0.0208574831,
-0.4811206162,
0.4670856595,
-0.6771140695,
-0.6943616867,
0.6048020124,
-0.4939927161,
0.2757519484,
0.0184209924,
0.3825300932,
0.0890739113,
1.14201653,
0.4111684263,
0.0566903688,
0.477470696,
-0.0309016481,
-0.0479228161,
-0.9522310495,
-0.2278221101,
-0.2562905848,
-0.3266141117,
-0.6150107384,
-0.6145347953,
0.4608284831,
-0.2252982259,
0.019846119,
0.1082641259,
-0.0948200151,
0.3860365748,
0.5536611676,
0.1768713146,
0.4116195738,
-0.1732242107,
-0.0598740056,
-0.0803309605,
-0.5008648634,
-0.553845942,
1.4749820232,
0.4941647053,
0.6312208176,
0.248215422,
0.263879627,
0.1686163843,
0.3675252199,
-0.7464549541,
0.5141661763,
-0.1018170714,
-0.6036570072,
-0.0655352771,
-0.1448378116,
-0.7896427512,
0.6192159653,
-0.2011296749,
-0.6440191269,
0.0539231375,
0.0485547259,
-0.323387742,
0.0746244043,
-1.1688625813,
0.8325409889,
-0.3978361189,
-0.4539470077,
-0.2425107062,
-0.5411623716,
0.2595465481,
-0.0205176957,
0.5720484257,
-0.3672862351,
-0.4758096337,
0.3486277163,
0.0069860672,
1.0499026775,
-0.0302095972,
-0.3530716002,
0.063916564,
-0.1129301116,
0.3425231874,
0.2391447574,
-0.0522357747,
0.182177946,
-0.0100643691,
-0.3374063373,
-0.434496671,
0.8782501817,
-0.6382001042,
-0.1787274182,
-0.1637913585,
-0.7773138881,
-0.6623458266,
0.1652089059,
-0.0764534622,
0.9302583933,
-0.1471116394,
0.0825662166,
0.7072155476,
-0.3326724172,
0.6769399047,
0.3542628288,
-0.0573658347,
-0.3842601776,
1.0211287737,
0.0402792208,
0.2527419627,
0.3846815825,
-0.0848320872,
-0.6942210197,
-0.4803914428,
-0.6894164681,
0.0549429804,
-0.8997011185,
0.0434404276,
-0.7818106413,
0.1704538614,
-0.2270061672,
0.117169328,
-0.5118715167,
-0.1450597644,
0.0909303725,
0.0401218683,
0.1855839938,
0.4389974177,
0.0669860095,
0.3180475235,
-0.8631651998,
0.1622209102,
0.3356139958,
0.5812808871,
0.0768610239,
-0.1447287947,
0.1265195012,
-0.0017655062,
-0.2028586417,
-0.4995606542,
0.1244792491,
0.2934321165,
0.7387379408,
0.2374101728,
-0.2570196092,
0.795738101,
-0.7593970299,
0.743801713,
0.0298923664,
-0.8423304558,
0.3643148243,
-0.3756407797,
0.466383785,
0.3983826637,
0.1720440239,
-0.5913575888,
-0.3057239652,
-0.2595573962,
-0.9800719023,
0.5015306473,
-0.015000903,
0.4791689813,
-0.1265803874,
-0.0041311202,
0.2562361658,
0.3751184344,
-0.8306258917,
-0.1410503834,
-0.0757156089,
-0.158928439,
-0.1800971478,
-0.2633482218,
-0.3411905169,
-0.0401621833,
0.1481687874,
-0.467474997,
0.2625703514,
0.0802309662,
-0.3656571805,
0.2757448554,
0.5495681763,
0.8785433769,
1.0361567736,
-0.0360307656,
0.2903629541,
0.3085045516,
-0.2024317682,
-0.1137809679,
0.1916498542,
0.5854926705,
-0.1920997053,
0.74061656,
0.6383895278,
0.546557188,
-1.263703227,
0.5546218753,
-0.2028280795,
-0.0410464518,
-0.275941968,
-0.2276649624,
0.0260955617,
0.3613064289,
0.6173167229,
0.0970393568,
0.1143371016,
-0.6437913775,
0.2254967839,
0.6585071087,
-0.2358714342,
-0.2461742461,
0.4886502624,
0.3685811162,
-0.0502011254,
0.2588871419,
0.2023933828,
-0.1514474303,
0.3480270803,
0.3738843799,
0.5427058339,
0.090018563,
0.0724623576,
-0.0552401915,
0.1950424165,
0.0536255315,
0.2690014839,
-0.1471842527,
-0.771107316,
-0.7275698185,
-0.2773920596,
-0.4807870388,
0.0859363303,
-0.322416544,
0.1164620519,
-0.3678300381,
-0.2161065042,
0.1532290727,
-0.2926732898,
-0.5227550268,
0.0480125472,
0.315918982,
0.8488104343,
-0.6123636365,
0.7889916897,
0.762199223,
-0.1867924035,
-0.3490771949,
-0.0287708566,
0.168384105,
-0.8155705333,
0.6606571674,
0.4289299846,
-0.2384243459,
-0.1059525236,
-0.4744044542,
-0.6008319259,
0.9072976112,
0.2843055427,
-0.3465406597,
0.0448231548,
0.3495467007,
0.5326147079,
-0.3729415536,
0.7981617451,
0.4576968849,
0.5196011066,
-0.0587834455,
-1.1205590963,
-0.1192222983,
-0.2674186528,
0.0526542664,
0.0664277375,
-0.8113271594,
0.964500308,
0.0564136915,
-0.1341975927,
0.0576551966,
0.3129695356,
0.3915471137,
0.3877046406,
0.4662097394,
0.345369488,
0.69882375,
-0.1191487685,
1.0629807711,
-0.3448359668,
-0.1085880026,
1.1539613008,
-0.4424991608,
1.1785378456,
0.6538877487,
-0.0249798,
0.3620940745,
0.5896570683,
0.16673401,
0.3650645912,
-0.0817044973,
-0.5115203261,
-0.310857594,
-0.1856728494,
-0.3584148884,
0.5411797166,
0.4758923054,
-0.0828129575,
-0.2588707507,
0.2781158388,
-0.1595584303,
0.0530180037,
-0.050360404,
0.7761445642,
-0.1694260687,
-0.6704425216,
0.3748221695,
-0.178125158,
1.004057169,
-0.6239020824,
-0.2447094917,
-0.0690073892,
0.3653412163,
0.0381208137,
-0.8808531165,
0.0758335069,
-0.2278203517,
-0.2020863146,
-0.3582235873,
0.5499438643,
-0.3603303432,
-0.2763783932,
0.540679574,
0.7633162141,
-0.0300410837,
-0.2034534961,
-0.6234492064,
0.5004279017,
-0.3299876451,
-0.1159349978,
0.3306329846,
0.5840300322,
-0.0526189245,
1.0174798965,
0.8125588894,
-0.2465024441,
0.2393218726,
0.1226412356,
0.9182490706,
-0.3818988502,
-0.2372398674,
-0.9431365132,
0.661372304,
-0.1492560655,
-0.6235409975,
0.6662979722,
0.7784469128,
0.8104212284,
-0.14849177,
0.9848303795,
0.1205085441,
0.6118375063,
-0.5357151031,
0.5630292892,
-0.6830829382,
0.2766548097,
-0.3701063693,
-0.634436965,
-0.3285651803,
0.1124422923,
-0.340290606,
-0.0471491404,
0.5893369317,
0.7961204052,
-0.1961155236,
-0.1210315302,
0.4006287754,
-0.0820545405,
0.4515775442,
0.4306347668,
1.1636248827,
-0.3003143668,
0.873077631,
0.0623620115,
-0.4117925465,
-0.0315057114,
-0.7405741215,
-1.0257527828,
-0.6292783618,
0.0399650522,
0.0012814312,
-0.0366193503,
1.0058482885,
0.9302183986,
-0.6452721953,
-0.3581935763,
0.0291043874,
-0.0143722389,
-0.1015066132,
-0.1866225898,
0.1359918714,
-0.6621761322,
-0.9788213372,
0.7313572168,
0.2141702026,
-0.0831670612,
-0.0425965302,
-0.046219971,
-0.2974469662,
0.1042389646,
0.9263327122,
0.164503336,
-0.8899053335,
-0.1170243844,
-0.0255443919,
0.0322513357,
0.2513824105,
0.9776132703,
-0.4784998,
0.4573781788,
0.2774625421,
0.8948066831,
0.2260296345,
-0.1430936307,
0.6531091928,
-1.0744322538,
0.2845192552,
-0.1014534086,
0.3176774085,
0.2854489386,
0.0248656794,
0.3938822448,
0.1150637269,
-0.4623259306,
-0.9340052009,
0.1863280088,
-0.9587085247,
-0.4137099385,
1.0947924852,
-0.0880690664,
0.0016779655,
-0.2667845488,
-0.5247046351,
-0.0330137946,
-0.4701880813,
0.5166546702,
0.9195869565,
-0.3178963065,
-0.5246216059,
-0.9416543841,
0.3688308299,
0.4434573948,
-0.958153069,
0.3635675609,
0.5703783035,
0.1696746796,
0.3818056285,
0.5964156985,
-0.1022588909,
0.105749689,
0.0526657142,
0.0556260273,
0.1165168807,
-0.3832713664,
-0.0603942759,
0.224370271,
0.3013854325,
-0.2409191281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13029v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13029v1
|
Systematic word meta-sense extension
| 2023-11-21T22:30:37 | 2023-11-21T22:30:37 |
Lei Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The meaning of polysemous words often varies in a highly productive yet
predictable way. Generalizing the regularity between conventional senses to
derive novel word meaning is crucial for automated processing of non-literal
language uses such as figurative expressions. We introduce a novel task called
systematic word meta-sense extension (SWORME) to test and improve language
models' ability to extend word meaning to denote new semantic domains (also
called meta-senses) that bear regular semantic relations with existing senses.
We found that language models prefer incremental lexical semantic change toward
conceptually similar meta-senses such as logical metonymy, and are much worse
at predicting highly non-literal meaning extensions such as metaphors. We
propose a novel analogy-based method of word meaning extension, and show that
it effectively improves language model systematicity in making both gradual and
radical types of meta-sense extension. We further demonstrate that learning
systematic meta-sense extensions benefits language models on multiple
benchmarks of figurative language understanding.
|
[
-0.3509823978,
-0.753036499,
0.4081218541,
0.0526650548,
-0.6593921781,
-0.1358320117,
-0.3888149858,
-0.6390912533,
0.3075139225,
0.3681631386,
-0.7497473955,
-0.4324725866,
-0.7007828951,
0.334307313,
-0.4540257752,
0.7636221647,
-0.1898614615,
-0.1480349153,
-0.1714850664,
-0.4660005569,
-0.3700313866,
0.0038294839,
-0.1290239692,
-0.3797366619,
0.8651121855,
0.1091360003,
0.9730888009,
0.6147328019,
0.7778072357,
0.2745810449,
0.175511241,
-0.0106811803,
-0.2235086262,
-0.0502798893,
-0.6564289927,
-0.4081479013,
-0.3017007709,
0.3362776637,
0.5466284752,
1.1806792021,
-0.2444286197,
0.3553545177,
-0.1313712895,
0.4634006619,
-0.6987198591,
0.1655232012,
-0.8245752454,
-0.2043333799,
0.0642272756,
-0.1469167918,
-0.2410564274,
-0.1653103232,
0.3346467912,
-0.5297064781,
0.2377517223,
-0.1062381193,
1.2262032032,
0.1982772201,
-0.3151399791,
-0.121360518,
-0.6872087121,
0.751752317,
-0.5218091011,
0.7670325041,
-0.1292028576,
0.3751867115,
-0.0588436313,
-0.9105300307,
-0.7678060532,
-0.6642565131,
-0.1366998553,
0.2346210182,
-0.1603820473,
0.3264235258,
0.2974470854,
0.0588838682,
-0.3457417488,
-0.5122509599,
-0.0748765394,
0.0688645393,
0.4979961514,
0.1805127114,
0.502579391,
-0.0367302857,
-0.5909792185,
-0.1447894126,
-0.5050062537,
-0.1171752065,
0.1308871508,
0.1645604223,
0.2138072997,
0.5376034975,
-0.0658117831,
0.9342831373,
-0.4150307775,
-0.2131668329,
0.0818000436,
-0.5238202214,
-0.3017503917,
-0.3943998218,
0.3727797866,
0.2293470055,
0.437096864,
-0.1389611959,
-0.0906530768,
0.5784906745,
-0.002796272,
-0.613016665,
0.177680254,
-0.1988013834,
-0.5229833722,
-0.2749724388,
0.4651533067,
-0.3574108183,
0.0697023422,
-0.7799769044,
0.4433968365,
-0.7451034784,
-0.4985395074,
0.5938560963,
-0.7098501921,
0.2946914732,
0.3626937568,
-0.4205532372,
0.4290704429,
0.683581233,
0.4920579195,
-0.0875546336,
-0.5667020082,
-0.0602397062,
0.3328632712,
-0.5143337846,
0.6961601377,
-0.9166539907,
-0.1489284933,
-0.1674637944,
0.1207154393,
-0.3314528167,
-0.5724651814,
0.4723142982,
-0.3082984686,
0.3818653226,
-0.1110197604,
-0.3047600687,
-0.5651348233,
0.220546782,
-0.2707875967,
0.9361473322,
0.1587640643,
-0.6686908603,
0.5456950665,
-0.5175221562,
-0.3730053604,
0.150353089,
-0.1039600894,
0.313665092,
0.7830758691,
-0.1789467484,
-0.0070365304,
-0.3365704119,
0.3858865798,
-0.3980996013,
-0.1920842379,
0.2170078605,
-0.0584300756,
0.3055335283,
-0.0316330045,
-0.1759738028,
0.252533704,
-0.6466792822,
-0.1233194545,
-0.0376638882,
0.049848143,
-0.9848728776,
-0.0321420841,
-0.0644806176,
0.4485059083,
0.3396319747,
-0.4768575132,
0.147887215,
-0.5455664396,
-0.014608698,
0.5571819544,
-0.1628462821,
0.4452010393,
-0.3178713024,
0.5885323286,
-0.0769188255,
0.1699249297,
-0.1011395007,
-0.4140443206,
-1.0771592855,
-0.6611112356,
0.5931672454,
0.3179172277,
-0.6690909266,
0.4719406962,
-0.6322566271,
-0.3865896463,
-0.4521379769,
-0.0629499555,
-0.02287375,
0.4635981321,
0.2901982963,
-0.5547038317,
-0.6007933021,
-1.0660794973,
-1.0006554127,
-0.1500819474,
-0.31696257,
0.3815735281,
0.7544586658,
-0.7919563055,
1.1320933104,
-0.4678618908,
-0.1329252124,
-0.2320625186,
0.3581461012,
0.2088890225,
-0.1112092584,
0.2854756415,
-0.4971688986,
-0.1882836521,
-0.0663346723,
-0.5412631035,
-0.10568887,
-0.212523818,
-0.0634099692,
-0.2999316454,
0.35088256,
-0.7417017221,
0.3307097852,
0.4702145159,
-0.4319375753,
0.8814863563,
0.2021987885,
-0.1767915934,
-0.7888245583,
0.0308714379,
-0.2129003257,
-0.0797049478,
-0.6452122927,
0.6151709557,
0.0254698992,
-0.0011370966,
-0.32862854,
0.922534287,
-0.6192489266,
0.0561367385,
-0.6730359197,
0.2497276217,
-0.0803551897,
0.0052623819,
0.3225175738,
0.4966777861,
0.4845470786,
-0.5248231888,
0.235639751,
-0.1601147801,
-0.143982619,
0.1190681979,
-0.7008019686,
-0.3095296323,
-0.4518176019,
0.28159675,
-1.0069258213,
-0.1484090984,
-0.1065695137,
-0.4686373174,
-0.0934504047,
0.2578492463,
-0.4979044497,
-0.4015307724,
-0.3284333944,
0.4139790237,
0.4650005996,
-0.5250205994,
1.0519924164,
-0.0789792314,
0.113751106,
-0.3748050928,
-0.5319569111,
0.122052744,
-0.1616713554,
-0.8601025343,
0.2745619118,
0.3091095686,
-0.5486733913,
0.1533159316,
-0.2972977757,
0.0368455201,
0.0812940076,
0.0663649067,
0.2335848212,
-0.0871715471,
0.2648577094,
0.2771173418,
-0.075216338,
0.2149609625,
-0.1690742821,
0.4023423493,
-0.1103422865,
-0.26606372,
0.0573392138,
0.1658781469,
0.6003679037,
-0.2493136078,
0.6483791471,
0.5688307285,
-0.4947397113,
-0.3295507431,
-0.4633447528,
-0.7129883766,
-0.437254101,
0.1859978139,
-0.6828994155,
-0.7410063744,
0.3603545725,
-0.5460801721,
0.0417517051,
0.4963513315,
0.2684911191,
0.0135590611,
0.7635702491,
0.7026650906,
0.2932933867,
0.3577452898,
-0.0025095628,
0.1813400686,
-0.757049799,
0.2380386144,
-0.21468696,
-0.2295931727,
-0.447445184,
-0.7695872188,
0.0310893413,
0.2145956606,
0.3844887614,
0.7086997032,
-0.1589625478,
0.1142408028,
0.2066582441,
0.1384750903,
0.3865959346,
0.2425411046,
-0.5300627351,
-0.1860273927,
-0.5326836705,
-0.472892493,
0.6072714329,
0.479675591,
0.7350420356,
0.0590598807,
0.5506564379,
-0.1206272319,
0.5718840957,
-0.8508676887,
0.6850879192,
0.0039859433,
-0.4618475735,
-0.0911035761,
-0.1782748103,
-0.8995351195,
0.6417976618,
-0.1691828221,
-0.2814854383,
0.2323611677,
-0.2272776216,
0.1571339369,
-0.0318168551,
-0.4057838321,
0.3410668075,
0.0813797265,
-0.2233114392,
-0.5867654681,
-0.4127392471,
0.7041782141,
0.0538796075,
0.4054678082,
-0.3991132379,
-0.7220236659,
0.7088985443,
-0.3887564838,
0.7135589123,
0.0926273018,
-0.1136279255,
0.2710297406,
0.3354378343,
0.4927673936,
-0.0441824421,
-0.0647786856,
0.284955889,
-0.0910047442,
-0.3652692437,
-0.7870728374,
0.3767666221,
-0.2258026898,
-0.6057262421,
-0.5444990396,
-0.8676396012,
-0.2687547207,
0.2723097205,
-0.1062401831,
0.047761526,
-0.3841442168,
-0.149735108,
0.4256798327,
-0.1486485451,
0.1747537106,
0.7879886627,
-0.1810068339,
-0.1545961648,
0.542112112,
-0.1870519519,
0.3421858549,
0.2707087398,
0.6721596718,
-0.3926242292,
-0.2339479923,
-0.1005166918,
0.4815135598,
-0.3749552071,
0.1054899022,
-0.6427641511,
0.0463902391,
-0.3549379706,
-0.041346062,
0.0804296881,
-0.6328399777,
0.1288191229,
-0.1762512624,
0.4190256894,
0.2611243427,
-0.0914284363,
0.1779368818,
-0.7693639398,
0.532341063,
0.4529674053,
0.2086605132,
-0.1547336876,
-0.8623675108,
0.2318275571,
0.0298880823,
0.052863393,
-0.9523759484,
0.3834632039,
0.4950799644,
0.3767179847,
0.8605642915,
-0.2836087644,
0.9368682504,
-0.8436735868,
0.4068260491,
0.4783737361,
-0.8451737165,
0.4770891964,
-0.7725726366,
0.5297669768,
0.5486821532,
0.3849003315,
-0.8177646399,
-0.4881200492,
-0.8051042557,
-0.5631415248,
-0.0232973751,
0.0844947696,
0.4749797881,
-0.3865469098,
0.3120684028,
0.2533248365,
0.3538105488,
-0.5728005767,
-0.1574189067,
0.1940637678,
-0.1666051596,
-0.0769210458,
-0.2597572505,
-0.3358230591,
-0.6693638563,
0.3166700602,
-0.2230299413,
0.2062295228,
0.088316977,
-0.3038525283,
-0.1202376336,
0.329741925,
0.5869812965,
0.8879327178,
-0.0102146193,
0.4443952143,
0.4054398537,
-0.4128744006,
-0.0653885752,
-0.0724948049,
-0.079712227,
0.6301647425,
0.7166220546,
0.5516927242,
0.3497219682,
-0.6950318217,
0.4513124228,
0.0732417479,
-0.3797537684,
-0.0179754347,
0.0226879101,
0.1807157248,
-0.4019375145,
0.3359236717,
0.1515820771,
0.3695509136,
-0.8627735376,
0.6174985766,
0.6616943479,
-0.3203111291,
-0.4276816547,
0.2050128728,
0.0993022993,
0.1262270212,
0.2253140956,
0.001658348,
-0.5679371953,
0.4750170112,
0.5953481793,
0.8293884397,
-0.4003733099,
0.1019405872,
0.5589948893,
0.5640599728,
-0.0759878457,
0.4521080852,
0.0236385427,
-0.9459863901,
-0.3834664822,
-0.7231889963,
-0.1161493883,
-0.1891508251,
-0.5665104985,
0.4510658979,
-0.4653531909,
-0.0097698858,
-0.2865105569,
-0.396307081,
-0.51267308,
0.2674339712,
-0.0161551647,
1.3731335402,
-0.9948189259,
0.8301942348,
0.6648881435,
-0.2639465928,
-0.7609351873,
0.0068353522,
-0.2955195904,
-0.7229658365,
0.7565227747,
0.2668293417,
-0.2274545133,
-0.1570271254,
-0.4117331505,
-0.9421379566,
0.765750587,
0.2041704059,
-0.8687573075,
-0.0257900078,
0.3500166535,
0.705267787,
-0.3921389282,
0.6015318632,
0.6608174443,
0.7787669897,
0.0093369856,
-0.8258864284,
0.4519341588,
0.1102878377,
0.2463089228,
0.4468932152,
-0.1864260286,
0.4851630628,
-0.1137600243,
-0.5814409256,
-0.0810953602,
0.7939481139,
0.0958295092,
0.0787421316,
0.7892747521,
0.8469807506,
0.4510843158,
-0.0901027843,
0.8800106049,
-0.4113238752,
0.3189435601,
1.06703794,
-0.1445939839,
0.8317136765,
0.7572131157,
-0.10360948,
1.0230387449,
0.5913687944,
0.0249398705,
0.3613841832,
0.3504746258,
-0.5256383419,
-0.4178800285,
-0.2662839293,
-0.3129607737,
0.4108556807,
0.5755599141,
-0.4663726091,
-0.7381340265,
0.0601685122,
-0.2152930796,
0.1123215482,
-0.0072440109,
0.7799278498,
0.3065055013,
-0.6359267831,
0.6013427377,
0.21310772,
0.7283567786,
-0.6641452312,
-0.0339798257,
-0.0963729098,
0.0938139632,
-0.2081799209,
-0.3401065767,
0.5735176206,
-0.4837990999,
-0.178732127,
0.0763285905,
1.085444212,
-0.5424782038,
-0.7479731441,
0.6976552606,
0.7087448239,
0.0378239341,
-0.1045526639,
-1.1161967516,
-0.1800142676,
-0.2562330961,
0.0423206165,
0.1313643754,
0.3186784089,
-0.3791747093,
0.5428034663,
0.8224074244,
0.0951466858,
0.2552023232,
0.318513304,
0.747666955,
-0.6159017086,
-0.2496646494,
-0.6047527194,
0.2695300281,
-0.0283114798,
-0.0898764804,
0.8822625875,
0.2737714052,
0.7625876069,
-0.3530966938,
0.6581985354,
-0.1009768695,
0.329762876,
0.0066815987,
0.233433634,
-0.6980594993,
-0.155776307,
-0.2623122334,
-1.0193632841,
-0.2404107302,
0.5982854962,
-0.4769282639,
-0.1550260186,
1.128644228,
0.746720314,
-0.3292455673,
-0.1923066676,
0.4409247041,
0.0663252398,
-0.1257893145,
0.1461138874,
0.8422558904,
-0.4938250482,
0.2154706568,
-0.0746741667,
-0.6719799638,
-0.0750581473,
-0.7291075587,
-0.9545477033,
-0.312161237,
-0.2889316976,
-0.1469207257,
0.0294638034,
0.6431623697,
0.5229330659,
-0.5059210658,
-0.335957706,
-0.3548876345,
0.0366702937,
-0.5677276254,
-0.2970851958,
0.1009936109,
-0.5945311189,
-0.4971729219,
0.3566923141,
0.3423133194,
-0.2430990636,
-0.0612228587,
0.1567400694,
-0.3206611574,
0.6402624846,
0.8383666873,
0.0864154994,
-0.9703116417,
-0.3091543019,
0.1314433515,
0.049769979,
-0.3539218009,
0.9242397547,
-0.6607478261,
0.3243297935,
0.8183427453,
0.3035496473,
0.0449043177,
0.2272783667,
0.7258744836,
-0.4638234973,
0.4863445163,
0.1283229738,
0.4261243045,
-0.1044952571,
-0.019126229,
0.5392180085,
0.6069881916,
0.2748376727,
-0.7086772919,
0.7749568224,
-0.6958120465,
-0.6212436557,
1.325671196,
0.12077263,
-0.3182994723,
0.089485608,
0.1194677129,
0.0623281002,
-0.013354199,
0.6664358974,
0.6657412052,
-0.0903715938,
-0.2293762416,
-0.2468163073,
0.4154426455,
0.7357677221,
-0.5077839494,
-0.0769720227,
0.2548053265,
0.5741409063,
0.2202899158,
0.1658728421,
-0.2783942819,
0.5396372676,
-0.1504979879,
0.2179765254,
0.1079609841,
-0.5189186335,
-0.3320221007,
-0.0626437441,
0.0364853777,
-0.15550825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12986v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12986v2
|
Unsupervised Graph Attention Autoencoder for Attributed Networks using K-means Loss
| 2023-11-21T20:45:55 | 2023-11-24T22:24:50 |
Abdelfateh Bekkair, Slimane Bellaouar, Slimane Oulad-Naoui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T07, I.2.4
|
Several natural phenomena and complex systems are often represented as
networks. Discovering their community structure is a fundamental task for
understanding these networks. Many algorithms have been proposed, but recently,
Graph Neural Networks (GNN) have emerged as a compelling approach for enhancing
this task.In this paper, we introduce a simple, efficient, and
clustering-oriented model based on unsupervised \textbf{G}raph Attention
\textbf{A}uto\textbf{E}ncoder for community detection in attributed networks
(GAECO). The proposed model adeptly learns representations from both the
network's topology and attribute information, simultaneously addressing dual
objectives: reconstruction and community discovery. It places a particular
emphasis on discovering compact communities by robustly minimizing clustering
errors. The model employs k-means as an objective function and utilizes a
multi-head Graph Attention Auto-Encoder for decoding the representations.
Experiments conducted on three datasets of attributed networks show that our
method surpasses state-of-the-art algorithms in terms of NMI and ARI.
Additionally, our approach scales effectively with the size of the network,
making it suitable for large-scale applications. The implications of our
findings extend beyond biological network interpretation and social network
analysis, where knowledge of the fundamental community structure is essential.
|
[
-0.1765830517,
-0.3617984951,
0.4428891838,
-0.069663614,
-0.3083817661,
0.2926107049,
-0.1233625188,
-0.1117364839,
0.749066174,
0.3000515401,
-0.5426892638,
-0.5278788209,
-0.8146227002,
0.0476200879,
-0.3713550866,
0.7282516956,
0.1826941073,
-0.2801288962,
-0.2919993103,
-0.3825473785,
-0.0391091183,
-0.4151406586,
-0.838495791,
-0.3123225868,
0.7570037842,
0.3110620975,
0.2011922598,
0.8861384988,
0.3894252479,
0.3791400194,
-0.1200724393,
0.4516379535,
-0.7260311842,
-0.2873834968,
0.1451537907,
-0.2061702162,
-0.2452504635,
-0.1666765809,
0.5888177156,
0.9511501789,
-0.1409284323,
0.3184476197,
0.2403838634,
0.6500794291,
-0.7432764769,
0.4156345129,
-0.6393254399,
0.064356178,
0.0954154283,
0.0392219462,
-0.338494271,
-0.1650860161,
0.0800893754,
-0.5333462358,
0.4807794988,
0.182648778,
0.5826668143,
0.2549031377,
-0.5739115477,
-0.282561183,
-0.3798489869,
0.660415113,
-0.3160533905,
0.1295381933,
0.0585081354,
0.1196387187,
-0.2549548447,
-0.5249407887,
-0.3639784753,
0.1158601195,
-0.4173563421,
0.2753056884,
-0.5411150455,
0.0021551831,
-0.2931180894,
0.6092264056,
-0.4976055324,
0.0218260493,
-0.1930584013,
-0.4576639235,
0.1222181916,
0.1185619235,
0.1059684083,
-0.3459053338,
-0.2000766546,
0.0300129373,
-0.4374775887,
-0.1964034885,
0.2730103731,
0.1555158943,
0.2544706762,
0.2879074216,
-0.1506692022,
0.3751688004,
0.2301594764,
0.3519661725,
0.2457449883,
-0.0785774589,
-0.32810238,
-0.1040669233,
0.8103967905,
0.3078055978,
0.1790128052,
-0.5545622706,
0.160964489,
0.2603769898,
0.0767359957,
-0.5172839165,
-0.7096545696,
-0.1662009656,
-0.7026620507,
-0.3930858076,
0.2105001658,
-0.6039353609,
-0.2961624563,
-0.1167662367,
0.2956152558,
0.025423361,
-0.3608243763,
0.0282638744,
-0.088410981,
-0.1795475334,
0.1840223074,
-0.5049704909,
0.5063701868,
0.2987976074,
1.2271684408,
-0.1857477278,
0.0672003776,
-0.4158582985,
0.4068515003,
-0.0310839619,
0.5596590042,
-0.4435608983,
-0.1320581585,
-0.4687191546,
0.3073107004,
-0.1988121718,
-0.3952167928,
0.0465244949,
-0.6425301433,
-0.4108301103,
-0.1469696015,
-0.4917700291,
-0.4253079295,
0.1434372663,
-0.8407191038,
0.6988012195,
0.1155984849,
-0.5162574649,
0.0557856783,
-0.6740537882,
-0.3788875639,
-0.1816412508,
0.2310340852,
-0.5998495221,
0.2620440125,
0.5259709358,
0.3427538574,
-0.0328274965,
-0.0625469238,
-0.5925012827,
-0.0164630245,
0.0916224569,
0.0600555427,
0.6054680943,
0.1159368828,
-0.1115028113,
0.0476513878,
-0.498500526,
-0.0248795282,
0.2170795351,
0.0926353931,
-0.5822546482,
0.0704252794,
-0.2576028109,
0.0017802066,
0.1272299886,
-0.852547586,
-0.005458904,
-0.318780303,
0.912379384,
0.7689979076,
0.2233517319,
0.5466790795,
0.3407810032,
-0.0252223797,
0.2329267859,
0.2308521122,
0.0617682077,
-0.3313676715,
-0.9731411934,
-0.1325352937,
0.284820199,
0.1665934175,
-0.3755177557,
0.8012419939,
-0.1229246706,
-0.3882653713,
-0.3888390362,
0.1686359346,
0.1720647067,
0.7391539216,
0.32284078,
-0.6659861803,
-0.4477327466,
-0.8013817072,
0.1475580484,
0.0886784866,
-0.1365936399,
0.5676500797,
0.5731754899,
-0.4086039662,
0.985093236,
-0.9761869311,
-0.664845109,
-0.2624322176,
0.241804108,
0.1444347203,
0.3928222656,
0.4736416042,
-0.6771228313,
-0.6083754897,
0.2172817737,
-0.6279669404,
0.0067171357,
0.3638428152,
-0.1047248691,
-0.5219609737,
0.2552176416,
-0.236276269,
0.541942358,
0.3765591383,
0.0993007123,
0.2033719867,
-0.2847473323,
0.041520182,
-0.8676698804,
0.0772199035,
0.0048641032,
-0.437530309,
-0.5070674419,
0.0040054484,
-0.1093249321,
-0.3356425166,
0.2364690304,
0.0964239389,
-0.739718318,
-0.3908779919,
-0.5280280113,
0.0490186028,
0.0146806687,
0.9359873533,
-0.0743644461,
0.3545241356,
0.6687948704,
-0.5884692073,
0.5492870212,
0.1777175814,
-0.0222861376,
0.3997039199,
-0.8960617781,
0.7152128816,
-0.4506903291,
0.3980405033,
-1.1494836807,
-0.2576286495,
0.2505686879,
-0.6654953361,
0.0498813726,
-0.3310704827,
-0.4667935669,
-0.7724865675,
-0.0567253381,
0.5130652189,
0.1823007166,
-0.619164288,
0.5237369537,
0.6468812227,
0.1802237183,
-0.1165947616,
-0.4964776337,
0.1338126808,
-0.2497196645,
-0.4194469452,
-0.164909333,
0.0509553365,
0.4197596014,
0.3287460208,
0.055220861,
-0.2676483691,
0.1031857207,
0.1717433482,
-0.1309115738,
0.0643565655,
0.1825476289,
-0.1016348898,
-0.399432689,
-0.0401716456,
-0.6913459301,
0.5240755081,
-0.2257114798,
-0.1881520748,
-0.3733285367,
0.6775599718,
0.5128176808,
-0.617104888,
0.5098218918,
0.3180653155,
-0.5369073749,
-0.063984327,
-0.2406108528,
-0.2272941321,
-0.4663431644,
0.5364012122,
0.2726644278,
-0.9799602628,
0.9450075626,
-0.366951406,
-0.5552663207,
0.5375050306,
0.3185452223,
-0.2154318094,
1.1007566452,
0.6168183684,
-0.6948006749,
0.1547186077,
-0.4445593357,
0.2526091337,
-1.0586657524,
-0.1315098852,
-0.3830334246,
-0.6781408191,
-0.1326361001,
-0.3290984631,
0.8370367289,
-0.2312824428,
-0.135131523,
0.4738668501,
-0.7866729498,
0.6180468202,
0.4913797975,
0.5570793152,
0.2465940267,
0.0341804661,
0.2020780891,
0.1774423271,
-0.9020903707,
-0.0917686895,
1.1942089796,
0.1282553524,
0.6148743033,
-0.0469217971,
0.7217640877,
0.559694767,
0.4718275368,
-0.9080147743,
0.2813230753,
-0.313762784,
-0.1596019268,
-0.498898536,
-0.6122838259,
-0.9752864242,
0.0957384184,
0.0950483829,
-0.6820290089,
0.7346636653,
0.4504997432,
-0.3114727736,
0.4319720268,
-0.5265392065,
0.7954592705,
0.3042578995,
0.3672237396,
-0.3810461164,
-0.7920821905,
0.1569129676,
0.1231186986,
0.0698129311,
0.2307236195,
0.2707516253,
0.5680603385,
-0.5104529262,
0.9202175736,
-0.1634462029,
0.4993907511,
0.5318570137,
-0.2602853179,
0.7897022963,
-0.0591414012,
0.297421515,
0.0605419427,
-0.6175866723,
-0.3254350722,
-0.6579643488,
0.7834936976,
-0.9189369082,
-0.1066121086,
0.010844213,
-0.4762251377,
-0.0242079273,
0.2557768524,
0.2663036883,
0.5960040689,
-0.2365851551,
0.3419728279,
0.9185694456,
0.3512163758,
0.2985860109,
0.1318796873,
0.2138435692,
-0.6337379217,
0.9588027596,
0.1692020595,
0.3505640626,
0.0985489711,
0.2178201675,
-0.1207037792,
-0.3946805298,
-0.2814597487,
0.3031921387,
-0.709556222,
-0.505096674,
-0.7885418534,
-0.0329840109,
-0.5029338598,
0.0041258563,
-0.3359903395,
-0.1572792083,
-0.3334496915,
-0.2217884958,
0.1352985054,
0.6803144813,
-0.2982161641,
0.6569439769,
-0.4756453037,
0.261346817,
0.5105268955,
0.1408951133,
0.6887293458,
-0.1142516062,
-0.4818060398,
0.0309706815,
-0.0926677957,
-0.9990817308,
0.3437509239,
0.5284481049,
0.4756052494,
0.6787417531,
0.1638260484,
0.4733708799,
-0.3821679056,
0.034205392,
0.129340142,
-0.7150325775,
0.4902540445,
-0.3242909014,
0.2435168624,
0.5706016421,
0.1226179823,
-0.6895098686,
-0.3837223947,
-0.5199153423,
-0.7698315978,
0.5437566638,
0.302986145,
0.0569251031,
-0.3500546217,
0.4877479374,
-0.2450166345,
0.2099669576,
-0.7877887487,
-0.4968949854,
-0.4561894834,
-0.1041032299,
0.1751725078,
0.0317721926,
-0.2632135153,
-0.2841900587,
0.424985528,
-0.4675138295,
0.5964505076,
0.4995366037,
-0.4765090346,
-0.2362512797,
-0.1565474123,
0.0166657437,
0.1084180921,
-0.0582698695,
0.3713004887,
-0.0182265192,
-0.4702446759,
0.1496369243,
-0.1067581698,
-0.1810043007,
-0.0632200316,
0.2680514157,
0.5950962305,
0.1819658875,
0.2024537772,
0.5109800696,
0.1841070354,
-0.0790306926,
-0.0285621341,
-0.0859645307,
0.1597933471,
0.0098796748,
0.6838414669,
0.1584766507,
0.5865175724,
-0.4752246141,
0.1638598144,
0.3314777315,
-0.558544755,
-0.2991310656,
0.4742999375,
0.2696919441,
0.1718831062,
0.7599430084,
-0.3813768327,
-0.8107327223,
1.2105419636,
0.4783752561,
1.1122255325,
-0.333393693,
0.2821037173,
0.5310294628,
0.3584839404,
0.3216044009,
-0.4459090233,
-0.0035025135,
-0.7633971572,
-0.2513715029,
-0.3536512554,
-0.0287920199,
-0.0625778213,
-0.8266289234,
-0.2949019969,
-0.3862962425,
-0.0413003117,
-0.0038464423,
-0.3499333262,
-0.377168864,
0.3161877096,
-0.1461192966,
0.5485938787,
-1.1434671879,
0.5523996949,
0.5571472049,
0.0820900425,
-0.7763346434,
-0.2606538534,
-0.0481828377,
-0.8249915838,
0.3229312301,
0.4224589765,
-0.2670805454,
0.5136479139,
-0.7988008261,
-1.146931529,
1.3377283812,
0.0341637023,
-0.4355710447,
0.1337554902,
-0.0184666328,
0.4340043962,
-0.7290251255,
0.0197813436,
0.1194617972,
0.3301150501,
0.2774479389,
-0.5131126642,
0.0104965828,
-0.1379922777,
0.0013486501,
0.4112660289,
-0.9725599885,
0.7484306693,
-0.1229137257,
-0.2668370605,
-0.0432581492,
1.0362461805,
-0.2784678042,
0.3556711078,
0.8192166686,
0.7147951126,
0.8741309047,
-0.1257608086,
0.6181102991,
-0.0156364776,
0.8649103642,
0.8998966813,
0.0088106627,
0.3135738373,
0.2287944704,
-0.0990940481,
0.5896415114,
0.580452621,
-0.1072673425,
0.8858635426,
0.138452962,
-0.1157441512,
-0.637601614,
-0.1583403647,
-0.0812734291,
0.3951363266,
0.293618083,
-0.5022227168,
-0.5304222107,
-0.0231401604,
-0.2435201705,
0.0602298528,
-0.9161968231,
0.6834645867,
0.0834652111,
-0.1474258155,
-0.0643031746,
-0.2259660959,
0.245140627,
-0.5840254426,
-0.0031070316,
-0.2116631269,
0.2583666444,
-0.2105375975,
-0.3654770553,
0.3413088322,
-0.5155747533,
-0.5593525171,
0.3851120472,
0.9564859271,
-0.4456192553,
-0.5827765465,
0.3911049068,
-0.0364336148,
0.1385933608,
-0.2188140303,
-0.3327596188,
-0.4262752533,
-0.1018371359,
-0.0071007013,
0.2264501601,
0.4202663004,
-0.1673239022,
0.6510936618,
0.5045217872,
-0.2835397124,
-0.1537283063,
0.0317851529,
1.19120121,
-0.215365842,
-0.691573441,
-0.6145597696,
0.2514330447,
-0.3568408191,
0.0806601718,
0.7327076793,
0.5511495471,
0.3439588249,
-0.083841376,
0.7554677129,
0.0475315191,
0.3933524191,
-0.0559538268,
0.7101941109,
-0.4130307138,
-0.2632827163,
-0.3949270248,
-0.7646046877,
-0.4003970325,
0.4949139953,
-0.1390454322,
0.0065631405,
0.5391258597,
0.7645458579,
-0.2308383882,
-0.1445368677,
-0.0536874607,
0.2555446625,
0.0580193959,
0.8657885194,
0.2879495025,
-0.3105673492,
0.664046824,
-0.0178506505,
-0.6222653389,
-0.1486106068,
-0.8476113081,
-0.8396760225,
-0.3195646405,
-0.2523053288,
-0.0181902926,
0.0071013961,
0.4993591905,
0.6606183052,
-0.841240108,
0.0624114797,
-0.2118503898,
0.028572537,
-0.3860206008,
-0.1775755733,
0.8060367107,
-0.0194172077,
-0.4375905991,
0.3243470788,
0.6128908992,
-0.2689364552,
-0.4064416885,
-0.1220798343,
-0.1533835232,
-0.1824519783,
0.357260406,
0.3029286265,
-0.4109235704,
-0.657358408,
0.187977016,
0.2051040381,
0.1632343978,
0.818467319,
-0.6353951693,
0.5651988983,
0.1686164886,
0.4955390096,
0.4835981131,
0.0697873235,
0.4648413956,
-0.9691765904,
-0.1861740053,
-0.0210291967,
0.4429202974,
0.3805892467,
-0.761977613,
0.4755317569,
0.6160188317,
-0.8192915916,
-0.3206899166,
0.2491717041,
-0.9495216012,
-0.0068502831,
0.7435207367,
-0.3879953325,
-0.5046074986,
-0.2940175533,
-0.0755630732,
0.3430904746,
-0.3919785321,
0.7871265411,
0.6139392257,
-0.1387869716,
-0.2051991671,
0.1303084791,
-0.0104699144,
0.071951203,
-0.5443416238,
0.2774506211,
0.5199579,
0.3008525372,
0.3608366847,
0.5852691531,
0.1322182268,
0.3214565516,
-0.3626977801,
-0.0434216782,
-0.2431634814,
-0.3578887582,
-0.1669650674,
0.2547502816,
-0.3411739171,
-0.3462463319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12983v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12983v1
|
GAIA: a benchmark for General AI Assistants
| 2023-11-21T20:34:47 | 2023-11-21T20:34:47 |
Grégoire Mialon, Clémentine Fourrier, Craig Swift, Thomas Wolf, Yann LeCun, Thomas Scialom
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce GAIA, a benchmark for General AI Assistants that, if solved,
would represent a milestone in AI research. GAIA proposes real-world questions
that require a set of fundamental abilities such as reasoning, multi-modality
handling, web browsing, and generally tool-use proficiency. GAIA questions are
conceptually simple for humans yet challenging for most advanced AIs: we show
that human respondents obtain 92\% vs. 15\% for GPT-4 equipped with plugins.
This notable performance disparity contrasts with the recent trend of LLMs
outperforming humans on tasks requiring professional skills in e.g. law or
chemistry. GAIA's philosophy departs from the current trend in AI benchmarks
suggesting to target tasks that are ever more difficult for humans. We posit
that the advent of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) hinges on a system's
capability to exhibit similar robustness as the average human does on such
questions. Using GAIA's methodology, we devise 466 questions and their answer.
We release our questions while retaining answers to 300 of them to power a
leader-board available at https://huggingface.co/gaia-benchmark.
|
[
-0.5251782537,
-0.7420699,
0.6754748821,
-0.0280892849,
0.1422246248,
-0.1128397658,
0.167515859,
-0.8972851038,
0.1017099544,
-0.0780969039,
-0.4181990325,
-0.0401403606,
-0.3616384566,
0.165462926,
-0.4654714763,
0.6970314384,
0.2141907215,
0.1353004426,
-0.4885725677,
-0.4581641555,
-0.4450433552,
-0.5261990428,
-0.8166943789,
-0.1844134033,
0.3776810765,
0.4650539756,
0.7386755347,
0.6522402167,
0.5857955813,
0.2931785882,
-0.0695153773,
0.1336805224,
0.0144424383,
-0.0670799389,
-0.0418526046,
-0.6572101116,
-0.9085031152,
0.4206080437,
0.3580456376,
0.6538296938,
-0.0190663263,
0.3324887753,
-0.1255188882,
0.4986365139,
-0.5226839781,
-0.311624229,
-0.4516451955,
-0.1233459637,
-0.3702026308,
0.0874036923,
0.1509236395,
-0.3125316203,
-0.0877318606,
-0.8893860579,
0.5298873186,
0.1038619131,
1.2112870216,
0.4594059885,
-0.149199158,
-0.3500139415,
-0.8488933444,
0.4321540296,
-0.1281260252,
0.0479141176,
0.4327442944,
0.5779848695,
0.0579091385,
-0.6450821757,
-0.6640020609,
-0.6427045465,
0.3580448627,
-0.073950462,
-0.363550216,
-0.1578596383,
0.331143707,
0.6932199597,
-0.7006675005,
-0.1981677711,
-0.2964532971,
0.1161555946,
0.7654160261,
0.3096835315,
0.6589487195,
0.6227253675,
0.0620360747,
-0.3057206869,
-0.7046197653,
0.0478655584,
0.6131034493,
-0.1387254,
0.0277316347,
0.0225300211,
-0.4242185354,
0.3150270283,
0.1492421627,
0.3589116633,
0.3046081364,
-0.4197039306,
-0.2345854789,
-0.684643805,
0.6395989656,
0.1108967662,
0.4744103253,
-0.5454520583,
0.1122611165,
0.3684873283,
0.6650814414,
-0.470156163,
-0.2257031202,
0.1717917025,
-0.0220894553,
-0.2665038407,
0.0444511175,
-0.9136534333,
-0.4961252511,
-0.0728692934,
0.4136509001,
0.0655140206,
-0.0309425574,
-0.2860139012,
-0.0529651418,
0.6312963367,
0.2883583903,
-1.1978904009,
0.7534272671,
0.8297516108,
0.8600823283,
-0.0742668957,
-0.3599707484,
-0.6480384469,
-0.1811872572,
-0.5623685718,
0.7165285945,
-0.563845098,
-0.6707713008,
-0.1740027219,
-0.2726430595,
0.0921651274,
-0.727273345,
0.5945293903,
-0.2302468717,
0.090138711,
-0.6796885133,
-0.1477948129,
-0.038621109,
0.514670372,
-0.5376833677,
0.6367553473,
-0.1281899661,
-0.1180146262,
0.5300698876,
-0.8582643867,
-0.291783154,
0.0333760194,
-0.599423945,
-0.1564392,
-0.0346226059,
0.2889021039,
0.1523013413,
-0.6789476871,
0.2131153047,
-0.3235436678,
-0.5097651482,
-0.0124120181,
-0.4714158177,
0.4664232135,
0.2169695199,
-0.4402978718,
0.3082770109,
-0.6160477996,
0.1207726225,
0.0559206083,
-0.0866865069,
-0.0049409671,
-0.0771535262,
-0.3562178016,
-0.029856367,
0.2349925041,
-0.3488379121,
0.3778155446,
-0.0777336434,
0.2589175403,
0.7918977141,
-0.1409664452,
0.5590860248,
-0.4285603762,
0.6616848707,
-0.328056097,
0.4520768225,
0.4647168219,
-0.8287029266,
-0.7673370242,
-0.0261638388,
0.2948347032,
0.7758269906,
-0.169955641,
0.175047338,
-0.3235015869,
-0.6039251685,
-0.6887613535,
0.4163081348,
0.3872877955,
0.5328441262,
0.3617539108,
-0.4858964384,
-0.0170513932,
-1.0043492317,
-0.1126489714,
-0.2962121964,
-0.4333779514,
0.4852156043,
0.54221946,
-0.0872393996,
0.4846051335,
-0.4269753695,
-0.3829269707,
-0.1364542097,
0.494584769,
-0.0527673922,
0.3239932656,
0.5907438993,
-0.977833271,
-0.2850848734,
-0.0093895122,
-1.0047814846,
-0.0543287806,
-0.1086043119,
-0.0580564365,
-0.1253162175,
0.4146170914,
-0.7449059486,
0.3839144707,
0.1862543821,
-0.2546640038,
0.477083534,
-0.491918236,
0.2691255808,
-0.8147389293,
0.7578794956,
0.138845697,
0.1858371794,
-0.8315737247,
0.3224318624,
-0.1593634039,
-0.3057945371,
-0.0885480568,
0.5961620808,
-0.489821434,
-0.3404717445,
-0.1794224381,
-0.0697674453,
-0.2035426497,
0.5984023809,
-0.4603473842,
1.5103783607,
0.4536832273,
-0.7357856035,
0.2439806908,
0.2870956361,
0.0688517913,
0.7334014773,
-1.1077269316,
0.627086103,
0.1620824337,
-0.1041368619,
-0.720479548,
-0.2933068871,
0.4213985503,
-0.5569382906,
-0.0404483415,
0.303425014,
-0.1156133637,
-0.1562441289,
-0.2290449888,
0.4775482416,
0.4768402576,
-0.2988877296,
0.7750009894,
0.3987437785,
-0.2818999588,
-0.5239523053,
-0.4385213852,
0.4087298214,
-0.3639659584,
-0.5339851379,
0.2149930298,
-0.370770216,
-0.4992099404,
0.0770337507,
-0.0483181924,
-0.2379931211,
0.5048547983,
0.3042888045,
0.2667023242,
-0.1022370756,
-0.0267631412,
-0.4928106368,
-0.1784562021,
0.2505424321,
0.2508060634,
0.2990875244,
-0.6057081223,
-0.5068907738,
-0.4786122143,
0.6746580601,
0.672205627,
-0.3244011998,
0.0822913274,
0.5062098503,
-0.3014984131,
0.3804074228,
-0.4772715569,
0.2586759627,
-0.4332388639,
0.2027121931,
-0.6215814352,
-0.3916652203,
0.7512080073,
0.1266928762,
0.064171426,
0.4623468518,
0.2669727802,
0.1196996719,
1.2873603106,
0.6787829399,
-0.9461937547,
0.2466956526,
-0.3789528906,
0.0839689896,
-0.6479133964,
-0.069467485,
-0.8490801454,
-0.608024478,
-0.3416084051,
-0.1094028354,
0.405513227,
-0.1980860084,
-0.2657861412,
-0.0797884464,
-0.5471405387,
0.3744848073,
1.0959904194,
-0.1587640643,
0.1074062511,
-0.5201068521,
0.4619913101,
0.4777918756,
-0.1934123933,
-0.5665842295,
1.2404749393,
0.1424219012,
0.4067589641,
0.2380055338,
0.5372277498,
0.8226189017,
0.1776498258,
-0.3291651309,
0.7599661946,
0.1700934768,
-0.7166515589,
-0.391875118,
-0.1679635197,
-0.7918952107,
0.0943596438,
-0.0830673501,
-0.930201292,
0.2603563666,
0.3002024889,
-0.5823768377,
0.1630699188,
-0.6513870358,
0.8908948302,
-0.3534748256,
-0.4800504446,
-0.4024106264,
-0.7096674442,
0.1262370497,
0.3992492557,
-0.080351688,
-0.1572661549,
-0.1672935337,
0.6221743822,
-0.1271214485,
0.5074398518,
-0.1503486484,
0.3349064887,
0.1893781424,
-0.3313361406,
0.2953656316,
0.0783112869,
0.1145376191,
-0.0161555335,
-0.2922227681,
-0.6809550524,
-0.5970839262,
0.557938993,
-1.022790432,
-0.8076538444,
-0.8433759809,
-0.3588842154,
-0.6437618732,
-0.0868801847,
0.1987395436,
0.3104445934,
-0.617928803,
-0.255435884,
0.6299461126,
0.3482928872,
0.166535005,
-0.0660812259,
0.2636618316,
-0.2765841186,
0.987971127,
0.0129035879,
-0.0169089753,
0.0654197559,
-0.2053364217,
-0.1335288882,
-0.7355543971,
-0.9006031156,
0.0225517433,
-0.4983037412,
0.1730656624,
-0.2864967287,
0.0869568214,
-0.3771463335,
-0.1218900979,
-0.0108316569,
-0.0252474267,
-0.4370944202,
-0.0578687526,
-0.1311262548,
0.8740776777,
-0.1565843076,
-0.0113353217,
-0.4063937068,
0.6743279099,
0.9277152419,
0.1945500821,
-0.0907501504,
-0.1918832213,
0.0176257007,
0.0231010597,
-0.5277326107,
-0.6762648225,
0.1257674247,
0.4344196618,
0.8173381686,
0.5545496941,
-0.3696072996,
0.6786340475,
-0.2184970528,
0.9583110809,
-0.211800918,
-0.7553271055,
0.4402554929,
-0.279066056,
0.1257223785,
0.8809989691,
0.4048925936,
-0.3917007744,
-0.0929774791,
-0.7540034652,
-0.7720168829,
0.2470386177,
-0.018942304,
0.1535220295,
0.1166814417,
0.3695048094,
-0.1433009803,
0.1915559918,
-0.1260955483,
-0.0791325271,
0.1495167315,
0.0120818,
-0.1751420647,
-0.0337317437,
-0.333769083,
-0.2335065007,
0.6154215932,
-0.2166303545,
0.4528155923,
0.2464997172,
-0.0404156148,
0.0111622326,
0.4338548481,
0.826405704,
0.7431307435,
-0.2128868252,
-0.2784576416,
0.5621870756,
-0.63437289,
0.3020893335,
0.161740914,
-0.4441112876,
-0.4537207484,
0.1642010659,
0.5626485348,
-0.2724294066,
-0.628900528,
0.1950602084,
-0.3981195986,
-0.3014247119,
-0.3833875656,
0.4889100194,
-0.202646032,
0.1884617507,
0.6725552082,
0.1088765264,
0.3859590292,
-0.9366778135,
0.0930580124,
0.4505664408,
-0.1256115586,
-0.470264405,
1.0359596014,
0.4373678863,
-0.5500802398,
0.6556822658,
-0.4587367773,
-0.271396488,
0.6676984429,
0.0093678916,
1.2113109827,
-0.0287695657,
0.1647568047,
0.0964675248,
0.1291083843,
-0.1163106486,
0.3783780038,
-0.1868106723,
-0.3641992509,
0.1198694706,
-0.2230985761,
-1.1525037289,
0.3414058685,
-0.5943315029,
-0.2255398482,
-0.7418760061,
-0.1166293398,
-0.0163292587,
0.3486523628,
-0.7447865009,
0.4865136445,
0.2196593583,
0.9564103484,
-0.9702518582,
0.5313495398,
0.7918346524,
-0.8418494463,
-0.6344047189,
0.1888294816,
-0.0573886558,
-0.581798315,
-0.0346929319,
0.1768510491,
-0.1296138763,
-0.3031294644,
-0.6289997697,
-0.5151484013,
1.1631271839,
0.233511731,
-0.0663637295,
-0.4743961096,
0.2092416286,
0.7966817021,
-0.3489503264,
0.4488480389,
0.7588244081,
0.4295297265,
-0.2194606215,
-0.8657070398,
-0.0559699126,
-0.930727005,
-0.133237198,
-0.2198589295,
-0.6661818027,
0.9454837441,
-0.1361429989,
-0.0579236634,
0.4772889912,
0.8427369595,
-0.0890203938,
0.7432175875,
0.4061432481,
0.7211598158,
1.1849319935,
-0.1211880147,
1.087583065,
-0.187842831,
-0.3559958637,
0.808791995,
-0.4129480124,
0.6461697221,
0.3365279138,
-0.1686808169,
0.2585267425,
0.3500370979,
-0.0637087822,
0.3757034242,
0.0406016298,
-0.3557254374,
-0.2431309968,
-0.0587504096,
-0.490472734,
0.401778698,
0.0568568632,
0.1960516572,
0.1095580757,
-0.2394585013,
-0.0334440134,
0.1306262463,
-0.3118030727,
0.8015156984,
-0.1723376662,
-0.9331859946,
0.3273918927,
-0.3263835907,
0.5015122294,
-0.6680136919,
-0.1155090109,
-0.5422692895,
0.2902686,
0.3328353167,
-0.4548943639,
0.2502816319,
0.2591297626,
-0.0742999986,
0.1894621551,
0.5057450533,
0.1070876941,
-0.2837152481,
-0.0335289314,
0.6210439801,
0.3523649275,
-0.2328286171,
-0.5681958795,
-0.0186001863,
-0.3765392005,
-0.079828307,
0.6235131025,
-0.0412624218,
-0.223043561,
1.0865100622,
0.4788774252,
0.1409925073,
-0.1299552023,
-0.0887246206,
0.8976425529,
-0.6646564007,
-0.5501608253,
-0.4362057745,
0.2694737017,
-0.4913357794,
-1.0136837959,
0.3932509124,
0.31425789,
0.5680084229,
0.1270430535,
1.0060607195,
-0.2861639261,
0.3007528484,
-0.1786130816,
0.699314177,
-0.7686786652,
0.0338904783,
-0.0652676597,
-0.6303040981,
-0.0732411593,
0.4077106118,
-0.3384413421,
0.2965504527,
0.2416550964,
0.7130027413,
-0.0087015815,
0.0546335503,
0.3863782883,
-0.3283230066,
0.5731770992,
0.6887750626,
0.579621911,
-0.3690719008,
0.7278110981,
-0.0833775625,
-0.2494103611,
-0.1989253461,
-0.3499125242,
-0.5885674953,
-0.4990909398,
-0.0709459633,
0.2040296197,
0.661811471,
0.5008823276,
0.6029865742,
-0.8772875071,
-0.061282441,
-0.2371438891,
-0.1639899909,
-0.5826632977,
-0.0842392594,
0.1662620902,
-0.2458377331,
-0.9690793753,
0.6147594452,
-0.1335435659,
-0.0761054307,
-0.3351337612,
-0.2216114998,
-0.291331321,
0.0811891705,
-0.1832391024,
0.9704410434,
-0.4488145709,
-0.6684064269,
0.2142472416,
-0.2476710677,
0.1442557722,
0.5318084359,
-0.5774398446,
0.0397314355,
0.5089597106,
0.8937607408,
0.0762793496,
0.4431041479,
0.6934607625,
-0.6003859639,
-0.0704552531,
0.2790893018,
0.252119571,
0.2454340905,
-0.2241366208,
0.9343945384,
0.1929287612,
-0.9071232677,
-0.7016428113,
0.0928932354,
-0.8837782741,
0.1298035383,
0.6774766445,
-0.1305426508,
-0.1410678029,
-0.0353929996,
-0.1395350248,
0.1194921732,
-0.3248694837,
1.0478088856,
0.5868967175,
-0.3644112349,
0.0968699381,
-0.6529023647,
0.472330898,
0.7336401343,
-1.0831869841,
-0.2066585869,
0.5053308606,
0.1420482993,
0.5053533316,
1.0212124586,
0.2387921512,
0.8423917294,
0.4171660841,
0.0226787291,
-0.2586619556,
-0.7750614285,
-0.3766018748,
0.4580473602,
0.2104390115,
-0.6868162751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14736v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14736v2
|
Data Diversity Matters for Robust Instruction Tuning
| 2023-11-21T19:12:18 | 2024-02-05T16:41:10 |
Alexander Bukharin, Tuo Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent works have shown that by curating high quality and diverse instruction
tuning datasets, we can significantly improve instruction-following
capabilities. However, creating such datasets is difficult and most works rely
on manual curation or proprietary language models. Automatic data curation is
difficult as it is still not clear how we can define diversity for instruction
tuning, how diversity and quality depend on one other, and how we can optimize
dataset quality and diversity. To resolve these issue, we propose a new
algorithm, Quality-Diversity Instruction Tuning (QDIT). QDIT provides a simple
method to simultaneously control dataset diversity and quality, allowing us to
conduct an in-depth study on the effect of diversity and quality on instruction
tuning performance. From this study we draw two key insights (1) there is a
natural tradeoff between data diversity and quality and (2) increasing data
diversity significantly improves the worst case instruction following
performance, therefore improving robustness. We validate the performance of
QDIT on several large scale instruction tuning datasets, where we find it can
substantially improve worst and average case performance compared to
quality-driven data selection.
|
[
-0.4229499698,
-0.3856916428,
0.0002946799,
-0.0443681367,
-0.3051795363,
0.4770577252,
-0.212045446,
-0.306250602,
-0.2200538367,
0.1631683856,
-0.5906425714,
-0.5904302597,
-0.7537657619,
-0.0333452635,
-0.4334381819,
1.0442763567,
0.3049857318,
0.211527437,
-0.151706323,
-0.4117169678,
-0.8716660142,
-0.0947838873,
-0.5478654504,
0.2178634256,
0.2548191547,
0.9882887006,
0.9601483941,
1.3598458767,
0.5279222727,
0.3991070986,
0.0024627298,
0.5621572137,
-0.9110392332,
0.2422062308,
-0.1465328336,
-0.7010393739,
-0.3514048159,
0.0134212673,
0.8185830712,
0.6705804467,
-0.1595968604,
0.2211105227,
0.1582732201,
0.9790939689,
-0.5849516988,
-0.332760185,
-0.4773274958,
0.052887924,
-0.2923175693,
-0.2368966639,
-0.1334818304,
-0.8994294405,
-0.1902899146,
-0.6286941171,
0.4714973271,
0.356015116,
0.7016558051,
0.3795578778,
-0.3473354876,
-0.3829961121,
-0.7087129951,
1.1323422194,
-0.5319651365,
0.5240517259,
0.3084748089,
0.2133406252,
-0.1578782052,
-0.3721260726,
-0.2892538607,
0.4304550886,
0.1983598322,
0.1154187173,
0.0816102773,
-0.17758663,
0.4616886675,
0.8668740392,
-0.4513360858,
0.2800474763,
-0.6268631816,
-0.2511543036,
0.5795793533,
0.4880878031,
0.4233954549,
0.3874563575,
-0.027473541,
-0.4724949002,
-0.5113223195,
0.5345848799,
0.8385741115,
0.1490141004,
-0.0114603676,
0.1528751999,
-0.3178426921,
0.777788341,
0.2470244467,
-0.0986105427,
0.1921414733,
-0.5929898024,
0.1476110667,
-0.1318515539,
0.2718470991,
0.5138248205,
-0.067947343,
-0.0882136524,
-0.2411414534,
-0.1098075882,
0.261757642,
-0.8111972809,
-0.5646688938,
-0.0030219236,
-0.5963668823,
-0.2121589631,
0.3910839856,
-1.0911890268,
-0.0941510051,
-0.4242267907,
0.2215187103,
-0.3699339032,
0.0345576145,
-0.0005570421,
-0.1834876686,
0.4764828384,
0.1522269845,
-1.171538949,
0.3753121793,
0.7005775571,
0.4972339571,
-0.3402699828,
-0.185445562,
-1.0178749561,
-0.2637862861,
-0.5241933465,
0.6527059078,
-0.9732551575,
-0.546397388,
-0.2962216735,
-0.0693614036,
0.014090756,
-0.7427027225,
0.6487730742,
-0.5771220922,
0.3785464168,
-0.5548249483,
-0.8637500405,
-0.1154026762,
-0.2530135214,
-0.8575244546,
0.7655184269,
0.4722445309,
-0.6303635836,
0.7181209922,
-0.2161836922,
-0.789808929,
-0.0144549254,
-0.0971259177,
-0.8984399438,
0.1438290626,
0.3371648192,
-0.2188797742,
0.0072514522,
-0.1558382362,
-0.2545687556,
-0.8518230319,
0.0062149493,
-0.3148393631,
0.8831529021,
0.1711870879,
-0.3109129667,
-0.0737395585,
-0.7211138606,
0.5206679702,
-0.2403382659,
-0.5020401478,
-0.243989259,
0.1817562282,
-0.4140364826,
-0.1124384552,
0.0299076959,
-0.3666969836,
0.1638782322,
-0.2758619189,
0.3291527927,
0.9092472196,
-0.1323250681,
0.6994633079,
-0.5716342926,
0.6918951869,
0.0191894863,
0.3938043714,
-0.2234970629,
-0.508816421,
-0.6521393061,
-0.1202390268,
0.6126426458,
0.6779769659,
-0.4711729586,
0.5018959641,
0.1737859994,
-0.1818536371,
-0.9249354005,
0.5549675822,
0.4139496982,
0.5774937272,
0.395047456,
-0.3798784316,
-0.4558986723,
-0.6707167029,
-0.2426351905,
0.1670061499,
0.0641432479,
0.2985514104,
-0.0034712912,
-0.1061441079,
0.739394784,
-0.3830793798,
0.1541657746,
0.0245753322,
0.1168697998,
0.3155560195,
0.763032794,
0.4513034821,
-0.6958127618,
-0.4718869627,
-0.2696148455,
-0.2371354997,
-0.0127960769,
-0.0872678608,
-0.7650550008,
-0.0514555462,
0.1713282764,
0.0770659745,
0.2552318275,
0.5417972803,
-0.2385495752,
0.4342493117,
-0.0436346531,
0.5549570918,
-0.8330746293,
-0.3370789886,
-0.4994297922,
0.0441157669,
-0.3279367387,
-0.0248646606,
0.4266203046,
0.0126392189,
-0.1073109433,
-0.053238418,
-0.3039997816,
0.0401775949,
-0.1603348106,
-0.4405070543,
0.364857018,
0.1662586182,
-0.4858641922,
1.0097157955,
0.7154325247,
-0.5741758347,
0.3772700429,
0.3292204142,
-0.4308917224,
0.7693020701,
-0.5580961704,
0.0939955264,
-0.070511803,
-0.2339294404,
-0.941649735,
-0.211159423,
0.2635504603,
-0.3330083787,
0.6377225518,
-0.1776802093,
-0.2080949843,
-0.3404773176,
-0.4250432849,
0.4436591268,
0.6315857172,
-0.8084893823,
0.0642027184,
0.1619943231,
-0.2177833617,
-0.4847623706,
-0.4835528731,
-0.2441716194,
-0.1680959016,
-0.6156634092,
0.2622478604,
-0.388738364,
-0.0478750132,
-0.0391323119,
-0.5436102748,
-0.3253394663,
0.241498515,
-0.023093041,
0.3593376875,
-0.4124797583,
0.212232843,
0.7383963466,
0.0025141409,
0.0115222177,
-0.3758836985,
0.0553226881,
0.0475520417,
-0.4828985929,
-0.5414283872,
0.6366385818,
0.2916814685,
-0.405203253,
0.6050558686,
0.6948006153,
0.1165216938,
-0.694291234,
-0.2590035796,
-0.3953194916,
-0.5554673672,
0.1607749313,
0.141552195,
-0.9481375813,
0.3155932128,
0.1550367326,
0.5492355227,
0.0470670313,
0.183817327,
-0.5500844121,
1.1868423223,
0.5013220906,
-0.185329169,
0.7430713773,
-0.0982972756,
0.2377305627,
-0.4434526563,
0.0655456558,
-0.6160161495,
-0.8329749703,
-0.9089861512,
-0.0967638493,
0.2402986586,
-0.0404125564,
-0.0935214087,
-0.164902851,
-0.6791763306,
0.846252203,
0.9449881315,
0.2398373932,
0.2152171135,
0.2014000863,
0.375913471,
-0.1364476979,
-0.8284528852,
-0.2895045578,
1.2673609257,
-0.0031665741,
0.9177636504,
-0.0919532329,
0.8462771177,
0.4234063327,
-0.0156857297,
-0.4248141646,
0.1578020453,
-0.674746573,
-0.2891450226,
-0.3736180961,
-0.8662825823,
-0.823171258,
-0.1527246833,
-0.1945311725,
-0.1416574121,
0.4538260996,
0.4355373383,
-0.5425770283,
0.3281186521,
-0.8761329055,
0.693329215,
-0.3290322125,
-0.5354069471,
-0.1841120571,
-0.5710957646,
0.4128726125,
0.1370632499,
0.1170081124,
0.0649762005,
0.1801341921,
0.7087292075,
-0.3026549518,
0.4651947618,
-0.0396912582,
0.0268975254,
0.2755218148,
0.0621342845,
0.2695460618,
0.2645977437,
-0.2221202403,
-0.0372530632,
-0.1540843397,
-0.7821313739,
-0.6502001286,
0.7951202393,
-1.0388789177,
-0.4631642699,
0.1155923903,
-0.6114419699,
-0.2466679364,
0.1013569534,
0.4932999611,
0.668260932,
0.0934651941,
0.4994578063,
1.1269701719,
-0.2484120876,
0.1687485129,
0.3164542615,
0.4716587067,
-0.4714960456,
1.4081171751,
0.2394750565,
0.3544156253,
0.2832405269,
0.0512096696,
-0.0775548741,
-0.6301780939,
-0.5390004516,
-0.3025923967,
-0.5932619572,
-0.3245749772,
-0.1572197825,
-0.1172442883,
-0.0659467429,
-0.1605113,
-0.347163707,
-0.4735944867,
-0.5157786608,
-0.0045693535,
0.248799324,
0.3896555305,
0.0287538003,
0.2920593321,
-0.8476960063,
0.4916968942,
0.749376297,
0.8509611487,
-0.3977608085,
-0.6164687872,
-0.5145474672,
0.2477913201,
-0.4464464486,
-0.6717272401,
0.0467504971,
0.6006746292,
0.740133822,
0.6588975191,
0.1923231035,
0.580960691,
-0.0814272538,
0.4852127433,
-0.2771045268,
-0.8097048998,
0.6480839849,
-0.1079567149,
0.3612504303,
0.8999655247,
0.1162794605,
-0.0581877641,
-0.7063215375,
-0.3561199307,
-0.7521730065,
0.8385477662,
0.2408979535,
0.1193539277,
0.2138086855,
0.2196389586,
0.6256176233,
0.2716021836,
-0.0586719401,
-0.2753942311,
-0.6277205348,
-0.3073415756,
0.2003230155,
0.0500248633,
-0.2168139368,
-0.377733916,
0.3295741379,
0.0016716237,
0.0370374769,
-0.3595694005,
-0.0268025398,
-0.4093666673,
0.2434637398,
0.5003098845,
0.7170629501,
-0.1410378963,
-0.1097609028,
0.0170570519,
-0.5568183661,
0.0453600995,
-0.0973891243,
-0.3658654392,
-0.1775821745,
0.1984496117,
0.7893657684,
0.1016198769,
-0.4478910863,
0.1119592488,
-0.3937550187,
-0.2244839221,
0.5232290626,
1.0555053949,
-0.2318402678,
0.1791763306,
0.2159997672,
0.2729572058,
0.3352680802,
-0.1389062405,
0.3216709197,
0.2643031776,
0.1964919418,
-0.0851510018,
0.5421253443,
0.4509066343,
-0.2844698727,
1.3153444529,
-0.2792861164,
-0.2752055228,
1.103902936,
0.3262418211,
0.496219486,
-0.3536157012,
0.220511958,
0.4960359037,
0.2194071114,
-0.1078220382,
0.4393399656,
-0.2713020146,
-0.4622738063,
-0.1612472534,
-0.4266950488,
-0.796467185,
-0.1463894546,
-1.116699934,
0.0433053784,
-0.5482454896,
0.0062728627,
-0.5193121433,
0.1387025267,
-0.7452658415,
0.3312260807,
0.0174123291,
0.6258641481,
-0.8085695505,
0.4883626699,
0.5359767079,
0.1194248348,
-0.778932631,
-0.0085411584,
-0.1581427604,
-0.5814663172,
0.1055831239,
0.1561720222,
-0.0055160564,
0.1152238175,
-0.6311805844,
-0.8870230317,
0.9358084202,
0.197597757,
-0.9600275755,
0.3060964048,
-0.0487261228,
0.3412448466,
-0.2139421105,
0.0404400639,
0.770209372,
0.4201391935,
0.0606640019,
-0.1639537662,
-0.3742604554,
-0.5215436816,
-0.1307560652,
0.2882958949,
-0.7716094851,
0.8127577305,
-0.2922213972,
-0.3296607733,
-0.1159440428,
0.7422114015,
0.0594257042,
0.3685222566,
0.4412448108,
0.4515625536,
1.0977131128,
-0.2259889096,
0.6573352814,
-0.548833847,
0.0194739178,
1.0993355513,
0.0223005284,
0.3254096806,
0.1544761062,
-0.2318314165,
0.452311337,
0.7416722775,
-0.4738487899,
0.4939517975,
-0.1015062109,
-0.0895277187,
-0.3829149902,
0.266540885,
-0.469042778,
0.3834989667,
0.3474321663,
-0.2401208878,
-0.0608576462,
-0.2157234251,
-0.3853948712,
0.1484101564,
-0.3539428115,
0.6410132051,
-0.4006509781,
-0.7223748565,
0.5252929926,
-0.0902108401,
0.4970230162,
-0.299990207,
-0.2278124839,
-0.7724195123,
-0.1963346303,
-0.3144301772,
-0.8897382617,
0.2473916411,
-0.2305488288,
-0.4875028729,
-0.1954987198,
0.3791657388,
-0.5042702556,
-0.4476774037,
-0.2843638361,
0.4070855975,
-0.3066406846,
0.5231594443,
-0.5065675378,
0.2188473344,
0.1841738224,
-0.0937143043,
0.4742892087,
0.5484048128,
-0.0149093606,
0.4285944104,
0.6953840852,
0.0774941519,
0.3585917652,
-0.079926677,
1.108946681,
-0.4888683856,
-0.765642941,
-0.5387108922,
0.4924989045,
-0.1963988692,
-0.4914375842,
0.5236842036,
0.5517148376,
1.0782684088,
0.1601639837,
0.6969919801,
0.2024932504,
0.6544042826,
-0.4269405305,
0.55360955,
-0.3965755999,
0.3757286072,
0.0999170244,
-0.7806707025,
-0.0834843218,
0.5617631078,
-0.2212101966,
0.1737721413,
0.256934762,
0.8811371326,
-0.3953646719,
0.2337051928,
0.1228993982,
-0.0447899699,
0.0359792225,
0.5588346124,
0.7268436551,
-0.2766199708,
0.7889692783,
-0.3687573075,
-0.4361720383,
-0.2753643692,
-0.544875443,
-0.6537540555,
-0.0255902633,
-0.3507553935,
-0.0108014559,
0.2154679596,
0.6004893184,
0.8416256309,
-1.1357687712,
-0.0455954559,
-0.020711733,
0.6785299778,
-0.5917175412,
-0.2213460803,
0.2179910988,
-0.6200396419,
-0.6750754118,
0.3768801391,
0.1539858878,
-0.168722406,
0.1040996239,
-0.1876571625,
0.4509515762,
0.0692601055,
0.2693410814,
0.3877676725,
-0.0550562404,
-0.0167322978,
0.1715829521,
-0.2675651908,
0.3364257216,
0.7584782243,
-0.4140543342,
0.8594730496,
0.5339727998,
0.8327226043,
-0.1266654879,
0.2949713171,
0.6391130686,
-0.6375469565,
-0.3889130354,
0.2881619632,
0.008253674,
0.1885329336,
-0.4809027612,
0.0043251524,
0.1510522217,
-0.7835267186,
-0.6596237421,
0.224693194,
-0.5348396301,
-0.1102651805,
0.6130712032,
-0.0334208757,
-0.1015018001,
-0.0492604189,
-0.3043498397,
0.2754186988,
-0.6268089414,
1.2489596605,
0.6144875884,
-0.1691053957,
-0.3482673764,
-0.4341155291,
0.5098923445,
0.6005668044,
-0.7553432584,
-0.1969439536,
0.5974293351,
0.3023098111,
-0.4719082415,
-0.1498934329,
0.061953783,
0.9152709842,
-0.0104471007,
-0.3145573437,
-0.2212662101,
-0.4112035632,
-0.2714897692,
0.2604923546,
0.0058119004,
-0.5652958155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14743v7
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14743v7
|
A Baseline Analysis of Reward Models' Ability To Accurately Analyze Foundation Models Under Distribution Shift
| 2023-11-21T18:41:26 | 2024-01-24T12:08:34 |
Will LeVine, Benjamin Pikus, Anthony Chen, Sean Hendryx
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Foundation models, specifically Large Language Models (LLMs), have lately
gained wide-spread attention and adoption. Reinforcement Learning with Human
Feedback (RLHF) involves training a reward model to capture desired behaviors,
which is then used to align LLM's. These reward models are additionally used at
inference-time to estimate LLM responses' adherence to those desired behaviors.
However, there is little work measuring how robust these reward models are to
distribution shifts. In this work, we evaluate how reward model performance -
measured via accuracy and calibration (i.e. alignment between accuracy and
confidence) - is affected by distribution shift. We show novel calibration
patterns and accuracy drops due to OOD prompts and responses, and that the
reward model is more sensitive to shifts in responses than prompts.
Additionally, we adapt an OOD detection technique commonly used in
classification to the reward model setting to detect these distribution shifts
in prompts and responses.
|
[
-0.0973443091,
-0.3524232209,
0.1678631604,
0.1351151317,
0.0887525231,
-0.2362584472,
-0.1445540935,
-0.3821325004,
-0.1413749307,
0.5796458721,
-0.9110045433,
-0.256175071,
-0.6665813327,
0.136371538,
-0.1862969249,
0.8471807241,
-0.1484559327,
-0.1879884899,
-0.0280636325,
-0.2311318666,
-0.5687959194,
-0.2432239503,
-0.2993954122,
-0.6872999072,
0.3677571118,
0.1011742651,
0.5302126408,
0.8119074702,
0.5611148477,
0.2727310658,
-0.114946425,
-0.1402360052,
-0.7008129954,
-0.0122563904,
-0.4110477865,
-0.7786519527,
-0.2526613772,
-0.3185972571,
0.7502059937,
0.6341738701,
-0.6249645352,
0.1926571429,
-0.0222625956,
0.7367895842,
-1.2185196877,
0.2162264884,
-0.3848259449,
-0.0020744074,
-0.0739224479,
-0.3868576884,
-0.8065912724,
-0.4198282361,
0.0721506327,
-0.548951447,
0.1561788768,
-0.2036473304,
0.71254915,
0.5270482898,
-0.3793800175,
-0.4564231336,
-0.5520504117,
0.8259470463,
-0.4984031916,
0.353943795,
0.3288266063,
0.3422503173,
-0.1835020185,
-0.3010613918,
-0.2108923495,
-0.2140333354,
0.1493273228,
-0.1246620566,
0.3058549464,
-0.2040389925,
-0.0070864782,
0.2962597311,
-0.0142592639,
0.2101281583,
0.0136527671,
0.0068975994,
0.6146399975,
0.4378016591,
-0.0133860856,
-0.0438164324,
-0.6356124878,
-0.9457831383,
-0.7226734757,
0.7000208497,
0.3395699561,
0.3344042897,
-0.2638365328,
0.5783865452,
-0.1217051148,
0.9388054609,
0.3817800879,
-0.4892342687,
0.2344130576,
-0.2147955447,
-0.3206007183,
0.0868626684,
0.4592236578,
0.2836956978,
0.1170039549,
0.1606456786,
-0.5035652518,
0.0821773037,
0.342363745,
-0.6883367896,
-0.1975751966,
-0.1456189454,
-0.6173148155,
-0.7503139377,
0.2408749312,
-0.2750799954,
-0.9239667654,
-0.1174026951,
0.166843012,
-0.1761637628,
-0.5031956434,
0.4753578603,
-0.3024219573,
0.3464180231,
0.3035689592,
-1.2124265432,
0.2627048194,
0.6558091044,
0.6506462097,
-0.6959303617,
-0.3194108307,
-0.648325026,
0.1042229384,
-0.399490416,
0.8628126979,
-0.2113768905,
-0.268373549,
0.2438553572,
0.2606834769,
-0.461212188,
-0.7807422876,
0.2613568604,
-0.6378691792,
-0.2652859092,
-0.5645899773,
-0.452283442,
0.2752024531,
0.4265698195,
-0.7805793285,
0.8211388588,
0.5578553677,
-0.723238945,
0.4958617687,
-0.4306584001,
-0.2310688049,
-0.2009492517,
-0.0661056861,
-0.0721780956,
0.2569538355,
0.0507992655,
0.1268456876,
0.0453383513,
0.118890807,
-0.3709900379,
-0.5191349387,
0.7017469406,
-0.3895310163,
0.8187653422,
0.036705941,
-0.4942181408,
0.0009092857,
-0.6202856302,
-0.1496795565,
0.0522605963,
-0.459374547,
-0.3171256483,
0.1500896215,
0.0566905774,
0.117494531,
-0.1897437274,
-0.3333663642,
0.4337855875,
-0.3518899977,
0.319368422,
1.0610752106,
-0.133025676,
0.5513961911,
-0.4013242126,
0.7109105587,
-0.0302283,
-0.0710024461,
0.0636578426,
-0.0180665273,
-0.2595612407,
-0.3136684,
0.3164615333,
0.5245606899,
-0.3807616234,
0.4895770252,
-0.3985570967,
-0.0302762352,
-0.287702769,
-0.1181701422,
0.1861766726,
0.5932571292,
0.1380660534,
-0.3103790283,
0.0469021797,
-0.5017709732,
-0.1833900213,
-0.3632112145,
0.0806291252,
0.14653714,
0.4345598519,
-0.1818809509,
0.986117363,
-0.5001221895,
0.0192178804,
-0.1682789624,
0.2568760216,
-0.055439055,
0.2615984678,
0.5922889113,
-0.6865361333,
-0.1988070458,
-0.1650874913,
-0.4401631355,
-0.1209495291,
0.1069430783,
-0.248139143,
0.3587357104,
0.3099023998,
-0.3262824714,
0.5740055442,
0.5386552811,
-0.5773490667,
0.6189998388,
0.1212417707,
0.2261026204,
-0.6781519651,
0.0489911772,
-0.1700708568,
-0.1415715367,
-0.2448063046,
-0.1527685523,
0.3612229228,
0.4177428484,
-0.2454560548,
0.7162181735,
-0.1329121739,
-0.3479377031,
-0.323328197,
-0.226735279,
-0.2156558186,
0.0822822303,
0.4540189803,
0.6980542541,
0.0186922979,
-0.8268274069,
0.2487635165,
0.3930749297,
-0.6026451588,
1.027974844,
-0.5559887886,
-0.2533994317,
0.1390984058,
0.4386948049,
-1.2410868406,
-0.3565112352,
0.2411191016,
-0.2438709438,
0.199542895,
0.0924179181,
-0.1644187421,
0.0605235174,
-0.4067306519,
0.364867866,
0.3280135691,
-0.6917984486,
0.1701729447,
0.0622385219,
0.0201101638,
-0.9602283835,
-0.7279900312,
-0.6226793528,
-0.0487219021,
-0.4392325878,
0.4010295868,
-0.0795229599,
-0.2722206414,
0.0406566821,
-0.3841539919,
0.1561599523,
0.3768551648,
0.2596754134,
0.1229476035,
-0.1162353531,
0.2884390354,
-0.2159724832,
0.0299646743,
0.317800492,
0.1005125567,
0.5301693082,
0.0690104738,
-0.4476431012,
-0.1653400958,
-0.273232758,
0.3646429181,
0.0185252335,
0.9421823621,
0.3966358006,
-0.2110998929,
-0.3727344871,
-0.2074025869,
-0.4137969911,
-0.4698388577,
0.4466391206,
-0.3484954834,
-0.5468531251,
0.4211198986,
0.0794081241,
0.0171671566,
0.2791543901,
0.6239484549,
0.0291843992,
0.9981570244,
0.810804069,
0.0140808504,
0.8442856669,
-0.1048075333,
-0.2333249301,
-0.7218167782,
-0.2183922082,
-0.5714216232,
-0.383888483,
-0.3518353701,
-0.0727630183,
0.0492211021,
0.1986465156,
-0.3540515602,
-0.0007490836,
-0.2969203889,
0.3424203992,
0.150266856,
0.0912744626,
0.1041626632,
0.1961513609,
0.1219493523,
0.2209914029,
-0.5055454373,
-0.1834106147,
0.9740541577,
0.3379640877,
1.1510488987,
0.1038298234,
0.5950899124,
0.5668102503,
0.6213926077,
-0.4992654324,
0.0853956267,
0.1842167377,
-0.2085593641,
-0.5624328256,
-0.4583444893,
-0.9373556376,
0.151111871,
0.001652987,
-0.7694836259,
0.6229724288,
0.1890275776,
-0.3440169692,
0.1667213142,
-0.5097675323,
0.9543194771,
-0.2295644879,
-0.1198884472,
0.009756227,
-0.6311297417,
0.4193108678,
0.3680127561,
0.2316621393,
-0.3161016107,
-0.0470721014,
0.3861606419,
-0.4416976869,
0.7619478703,
-0.1960243732,
-0.3686957359,
-0.0238983128,
0.2116218209,
0.8070425391,
-0.0314157531,
-0.2397266924,
-0.3108022511,
0.1858267933,
-0.4410428405,
-0.5652887225,
0.6054199338,
-1.0420178175,
-0.0731550902,
-0.407902807,
-0.8573867679,
-0.2620330751,
-0.2440166771,
0.4523386061,
0.1840125024,
-0.1412489414,
0.1787708551,
0.9192883968,
-0.1078372821,
0.1833307743,
0.458019942,
-0.1944590807,
-0.3399970531,
0.4489890635,
-0.1193811819,
0.7194930911,
0.4542772472,
0.3814782202,
-0.7300911546,
-0.1028607637,
-0.5623859167,
0.1683648974,
-0.9234151244,
-0.0907212868,
-0.1301643103,
0.142113328,
-0.6822859645,
-0.3187204301,
-0.2169971615,
-0.1651741266,
-0.1427901834,
-0.270160675,
0.2184619159,
0.9385545254,
0.0834780708,
0.3309932351,
-0.2734808922,
0.1055803299,
0.2777532041,
0.326846242,
-0.0970687121,
-0.7611482143,
-0.0985617787,
0.2176310569,
-0.1133160293,
-1.1014924049,
0.2287005186,
-0.0255661253,
0.5059270263,
0.3503364623,
0.3479083776,
0.5114447474,
0.1126314029,
0.6530063748,
0.2892628908,
-0.7877180576,
0.2393094897,
-0.1526845694,
0.4698154628,
0.4605824351,
0.0640890673,
-0.3926011622,
0.1095207483,
-0.4394398034,
-0.4950838685,
1.1213433743,
-0.2238969058,
-0.131095618,
0.0517885834,
0.3934542835,
0.0877570063,
0.4133221507,
-0.8633352518,
-0.2187298536,
-0.2239249051,
-0.2710109353,
-0.2868529856,
-0.1645965278,
-0.2472491711,
0.0881184638,
0.4274026453,
-0.2325508296,
0.2549146712,
-0.0921390355,
-0.4187500477,
-0.6322750449,
0.3025810719,
0.9788429737,
0.8704354763,
-0.5617851615,
0.1652272791,
-0.189161092,
-0.3590847254,
0.4649753869,
-0.0346525759,
-0.2463681996,
-0.1143064424,
0.3807792664,
1.0155664682,
0.3778882325,
-0.7479410768,
0.6566984057,
0.0436282866,
-0.1497416198,
-0.054697495,
0.389369607,
-0.016255727,
0.1708150506,
0.1101601422,
0.0294648837,
-0.1007984057,
-0.627466023,
-0.0289377384,
0.3115298748,
-0.5389258265,
-0.1781034172,
0.3652882874,
-0.0600647293,
-0.3837996423,
0.7773842216,
-0.0573985279,
-0.2963078022,
0.8721312284,
0.735815227,
0.6365926266,
-0.4999771416,
0.5724877119,
0.111505188,
0.1855597943,
-0.5414056778,
-0.0327307656,
-0.2774387896,
-0.9593606591,
-0.1787802726,
-0.4417425096,
-0.2788977325,
-0.0450208001,
-1.2746582031,
0.2371569872,
-0.1545016766,
-0.1554338336,
-0.0179081801,
-0.3928951323,
-0.6035429835,
0.1040945649,
0.0770066306,
0.8373483419,
-1.1498030424,
0.5693802238,
0.8794281483,
-0.1089715585,
-0.8715812564,
-0.0009164144,
-0.043184381,
-0.8460333347,
0.8714234829,
0.2391377985,
-0.1599892378,
-0.1005547866,
-0.5618123412,
-0.8432738781,
1.3098801374,
0.6486647725,
-0.3750053048,
0.1383555084,
0.2595721781,
0.384619385,
-0.3046652675,
0.5274439454,
0.7239228487,
0.1911697388,
0.1356228143,
-0.8722234964,
-0.0455105379,
0.1824460328,
0.1564873159,
0.4641275704,
-0.4362357557,
1.0657720566,
-0.1029855534,
-0.1547793597,
-0.0253553838,
0.1597293317,
0.9519430399,
0.191560328,
0.7424881458,
0.5273247361,
0.7170283198,
-0.1071374491,
1.3849972486,
0.0842129216,
0.5734739304,
0.7945618629,
-0.5968270302,
1.1367260218,
0.5418660641,
-0.2030237615,
0.7914904952,
0.7837048769,
0.4390614927,
1.0607966185,
0.4813324511,
0.0563540459,
-0.4059350491,
0.0306363329,
-0.6904193163,
-0.2023908496,
0.270359844,
-0.3239194155,
-0.2680416405,
0.051555071,
-0.5184579492,
-0.0639551058,
-0.4852875173,
0.6093844175,
-0.0769646317,
-0.9537539482,
0.8068646193,
0.1270541996,
0.4802495241,
-0.5808013082,
-0.1264025271,
-0.3189537823,
0.6717956662,
-0.2222592682,
-0.5471327901,
-0.0800240189,
-0.3555810452,
-0.4114454687,
-0.1443663687,
0.5589253902,
-0.1937312335,
-0.2079541385,
0.1255224496,
-0.0045510512,
-0.2599407136,
0.1023778915,
-0.7142428756,
0.2900118828,
-0.0980318338,
-0.5202493668,
0.6127983928,
0.2827704847,
-0.3514809608,
0.6230946779,
0.462087661,
0.0194208845,
0.4036404192,
-0.1226870269,
0.2959831059,
-0.5228924751,
-0.831700325,
-0.6474186182,
0.4561481774,
0.0671152771,
-0.5324774981,
0.3810299635,
-0.070645608,
0.921254158,
-0.4231213331,
0.5751745105,
-0.1046753228,
0.2580353618,
-0.6434300542,
0.1519497633,
-0.3159008324,
0.3641159534,
-0.076981023,
-0.8287225962,
0.1302402318,
0.8839988708,
-0.4653288722,
-0.0200155657,
0.6568461061,
0.6452637911,
0.0657822415,
-0.1161768734,
0.0418009833,
-0.0725689754,
0.1590257436,
0.6276079416,
0.9946854711,
-0.2748261094,
0.2543988824,
-0.2240384519,
-0.0148851583,
-0.6216532588,
-0.9744369388,
-0.653429687,
-0.1773246676,
-0.3800192177,
-0.5638808012,
0.3155290186,
0.8573064804,
0.8691384792,
-1.198798418,
-0.6454684138,
-0.4067651629,
0.2314270884,
-0.8598614931,
-0.260546416,
0.4224328101,
-0.3528094888,
-0.2747368217,
0.2241677493,
0.1672010273,
-0.1666228622,
-0.3304692507,
-0.5030678511,
-0.0433546826,
0.0582501926,
0.2352493107,
0.4352382421,
-0.828620255,
-0.2192521393,
0.2763237357,
-0.4731188416,
-0.0327065811,
0.7864262462,
-0.5877173543,
0.3226554394,
0.7116827369,
0.7396802902,
0.4035101831,
0.5181426406,
0.5808198452,
-0.8043005466,
0.0801226795,
-0.1000028476,
0.0885284021,
0.1813904047,
-0.3905138671,
0.5571305752,
0.3589626253,
-0.5774940848,
-1.2473294735,
0.26768592,
-0.7254260182,
-0.2180847377,
1.2307767868,
-0.0552522242,
-0.3537018895,
0.2677452564,
0.0133965733,
-0.1020948365,
-0.2812934816,
0.9040309787,
1.0407835245,
-0.1834151745,
-0.4929025471,
-0.2967051268,
0.5895552635,
0.5797655582,
-0.7492005825,
0.0268751141,
0.5586197972,
0.6097242236,
0.0820525661,
0.6286801696,
0.105331108,
0.5753513575,
-0.3042299747,
0.0915181488,
-0.0469555408,
-0.2079216987,
-0.7515864968,
0.2980106175,
0.4391707182,
-0.3866547048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12735v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12735v1
|
LowResource at BLP-2023 Task 2: Leveraging BanglaBert for Low Resource Sentiment Analysis of Bangla Language
| 2023-11-21T17:21:15 | 2023-11-21T17:21:15 |
Aunabil Chakma, Masum Hasan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper describes the system of the LowResource Team for Task 2 of
BLP-2023, which involves conducting sentiment analysis on a dataset composed of
public posts and comments from diverse social media platforms. Our primary aim
is to utilize BanglaBert, a BERT model pre-trained on a large Bangla corpus,
using various strategies including fine-tuning, dropping random tokens, and
using several external datasets. Our final model is an ensemble of the three
best BanglaBert variations. Our system has achieved overall 3rd in the Test Set
among 30 participating teams with a score of 0.718. Additionally, we discuss
the promising systems that didn't perform well namely task-adaptive pertaining
and paraphrasing using BanglaT5. Training codes and external datasets which are
used for our system are publicly available at
https://github.com/Aunabil4602/bnlp-workshop-task2-2023
|
[
-0.4526480436,
-0.4846952856,
-0.001087081,
0.7877088785,
-0.3821378946,
0.2236162275,
-0.4593426585,
-0.6187838912,
-0.0681153461,
0.3587918282,
-0.5258242488,
-0.1228638217,
-0.6200922728,
0.2206533253,
0.000179087,
1.2693166733,
0.2635629475,
0.2099375129,
-0.043470405,
-0.0080409907,
-0.4841553271,
-0.1799567193,
-0.5084609389,
-0.489839524,
0.7402539849,
0.6281266809,
0.4324713945,
-0.1361258179,
0.784473598,
0.0702726096,
-0.3532515466,
0.0562434085,
-0.8453481793,
-0.0324224308,
-0.74213624,
-0.2228851616,
-0.3261622488,
-0.0921776071,
0.5000164509,
0.7821443081,
0.0810388848,
0.5605347753,
0.2806331515,
0.7044783831,
-0.6584525704,
0.2037204653,
-0.6177265048,
-0.0192385428,
-0.1605438739,
0.1835931093,
-0.6197158694,
-0.7213674784,
-0.0392528661,
-0.0030858081,
0.0491865166,
0.076666683,
0.9386314154,
0.4526247978,
0.1582757384,
-0.2154472768,
-0.6505719423,
1.2067331076,
-0.7447773218,
0.3797245026,
0.5894787908,
0.271353513,
0.2011919469,
-0.3624265492,
-0.4798977971,
0.1384063363,
-0.0889820904,
0.3569568396,
-0.1613989621,
-0.1447207034,
0.0769498274,
0.1857869774,
-0.5225496888,
0.1178593263,
-0.8072842956,
-0.162985608,
0.5689309239,
-0.1342669874,
-0.3559892774,
-0.5852920413,
-0.3943253458,
0.275514245,
-0.5665482283,
0.1138341576,
0.3812815547,
0.8206899762,
-0.3747932911,
0.5941157937,
-0.2179692537,
0.7153092027,
0.0942499265,
-0.053710524,
0.3210017681,
-0.5128611326,
-0.2987711132,
0.0828640386,
0.62516433,
0.2757349908,
-0.0555606671,
0.0928949565,
-0.1767248064,
-0.0510198288,
0.384203583,
-0.8714677095,
-0.4352029264,
0.0857414752,
-0.982986927,
-0.3290760219,
-0.2049734741,
-1.3326283693,
-0.6555350423,
-0.2279879153,
0.1907948405,
-0.3101984859,
-0.2109560817,
-0.4033695161,
0.0757708475,
0.4595234394,
0.6156428456,
-0.6595382094,
0.2185450941,
0.4356803298,
1.0201140642,
-0.0396437943,
-0.0416606963,
-0.3898430765,
-0.1180577129,
-0.2679771781,
0.9656075239,
-0.5579145551,
-0.7278894186,
-0.1606797874,
-0.128950581,
0.2024021596,
-0.7237695456,
0.6767348647,
-0.3370839953,
0.1131914482,
-0.5960070491,
-0.3760071397,
-0.1068582758,
0.1558399647,
-0.5920564532,
1.0651484728,
0.3312250078,
-0.8312752843,
0.215640679,
-0.9496769905,
-0.4917983115,
0.3667492867,
0.1293448508,
-0.350202322,
0.2519283593,
0.0748083219,
0.4179150462,
-0.3032775521,
-0.3503942192,
-0.2853380144,
-0.5797110796,
0.2187873721,
-0.1978129596,
0.9428678155,
0.4663047493,
-0.2385854125,
-0.1986016035,
-0.525683403,
-0.0232198536,
0.0355943851,
-0.6499603987,
-0.0483042002,
-0.0332142003,
0.4678847194,
0.3589653671,
0.6296418309,
-0.7693696618,
0.1838255525,
-0.4306303263,
-0.0709751621,
0.9013058543,
0.1174954176,
0.2365169078,
-0.2440008223,
0.4873866141,
-0.2129481584,
0.2678432465,
0.3619111776,
-0.6397398114,
-0.4977748394,
-0.3667705953,
0.3006499112,
0.4799140692,
-0.6085406542,
0.1797566414,
-0.1286569387,
-0.7076528668,
-0.9759371877,
0.4607090652,
0.504498899,
0.4339188933,
0.4945163131,
-0.2793835402,
-0.7510906458,
-0.955145061,
0.1025054008,
-0.3096883595,
0.2733588815,
0.0602557398,
0.3187052906,
-0.4398459196,
0.9673749804,
-0.4007498324,
-0.2653055787,
-0.7196698189,
0.3853925169,
0.4152387083,
0.2828350067,
0.5865595341,
-0.8141689301,
-0.5562958121,
0.0248014089,
-0.4544661641,
-0.3368028402,
0.3931286633,
-0.1316248924,
0.7550106645,
0.2281582654,
-0.3557659388,
0.1527582705,
0.803414166,
-0.0714128166,
0.5973641276,
0.3474264741,
-0.0216900855,
-1.1064494848,
0.3357979059,
-0.0348923579,
-0.0142063117,
-0.4596730471,
-0.3085938394,
-0.4401195347,
-0.2412255853,
-0.474855721,
0.6369976997,
0.0126653686,
-0.1470711231,
-0.5850765705,
-0.1084970832,
-0.1547137648,
0.4368153811,
-0.0218975525,
0.6385167241,
0.1031582505,
-0.2109975964,
0.4493706524,
0.5272461772,
-0.3020680249,
0.6838440299,
-0.5101675391,
0.1944255233,
0.0685921758,
-0.0320675708,
-1.1540987492,
-0.3529600501,
0.4260487556,
-0.740160346,
0.1821648628,
-0.3087984622,
-0.7846323252,
-0.556427896,
-0.2573293746,
0.1292417347,
0.6950153112,
-0.3560762703,
0.0592487901,
0.4412547946,
-0.6949798465,
-0.4512314796,
-0.9266652465,
-0.1292184889,
0.0536901839,
-0.0473612398,
-0.1579377651,
-0.0714685395,
-0.2588646412,
0.1155345514,
0.1841778904,
-0.2975024581,
-0.1565110832,
0.3209512234,
0.2379951477,
0.1124643534,
0.0555823743,
0.1358972341,
0.1925484091,
0.0029174993,
0.0191258844,
0.7326591611,
-0.33981359,
-0.1413113773,
-0.3530527651,
0.1626176238,
0.2735460699,
-0.0200981256,
0.6804097295,
0.8504940867,
-0.4030385911,
0.0042864056,
-0.4986902773,
0.0597260445,
-0.4357814789,
0.3494833112,
0.1553874761,
-0.8204052448,
0.3267046809,
-0.0416371524,
-0.1377167255,
0.0315673873,
1.2735296488,
-0.3426285386,
0.5383111238,
0.6014584899,
-0.3128536046,
0.3149736822,
-0.1157712042,
0.6499533057,
-0.7254354954,
-0.264166981,
-0.3667573333,
-0.3454764485,
-0.8862695694,
-0.5027201772,
0.0097092297,
-0.121902734,
0.0146328388,
0.2960992754,
-0.5297649503,
0.1372163892,
0.7694366574,
0.0476238206,
-0.0953741968,
-0.16956532,
0.2071713507,
-0.0818338171,
-0.5363429785,
-0.5895242691,
0.8831242919,
0.3382101059,
0.6924144626,
0.1072130054,
0.7777142525,
0.662356019,
0.2169182897,
-0.8199265003,
0.7873668075,
-0.1401155591,
-0.950493753,
-0.2518092394,
-0.2416067272,
-0.7570940852,
-0.0326721556,
-0.1043358892,
-0.7009960413,
0.382150054,
0.1751862913,
-0.3926433623,
0.1826027632,
-0.5250103474,
0.7898408175,
0.1047006696,
-0.7510960698,
-0.2707075477,
-0.8177855611,
0.2973039746,
-0.1943154335,
0.3815032542,
-0.2283067107,
0.312482208,
0.8469157219,
-0.1045038775,
0.9597988129,
-0.7578508258,
-0.083445698,
0.4611264169,
-0.0836592019,
0.1701477617,
-0.0953856036,
-0.4398587942,
0.1173274666,
-0.0905429125,
-0.8973061442,
-0.1481822282,
0.4960584342,
-0.7534144521,
0.1302412152,
-0.4612383842,
-0.6357277632,
-0.3998371959,
0.2235791683,
0.2561182976,
0.1029782593,
-0.1396333426,
0.3325967193,
0.2222888917,
-0.2696754634,
0.592384398,
0.147418797,
-0.1672461182,
-0.444542706,
1.2497105598,
0.0226613972,
0.0233247094,
0.265555352,
0.1920589209,
-0.2621884048,
-0.6100707054,
-0.0439331047,
0.2103282511,
-0.6390699744,
-0.4615552425,
-0.1080045477,
-0.115169242,
-0.5477494001,
-0.3076922596,
-0.5649460554,
-0.2910569012,
-0.0316514596,
-0.0792524368,
0.2855920196,
0.767665565,
-0.4847769737,
0.5228636861,
-0.7133895755,
0.1750415564,
0.1045164615,
0.3141682446,
-0.2639806271,
-0.632625699,
-0.8983587027,
0.0059495973,
-0.3316080272,
-0.5804018378,
0.4381143153,
0.0484184064,
0.2441380769,
0.2759007514,
0.0654780418,
0.5258254409,
-0.1914423406,
0.8967415094,
0.0816301927,
-0.8981643319,
0.9056399465,
-0.5634574294,
0.2097535133,
1.0227937698,
0.4953671694,
-0.2374780029,
-0.4247601926,
-0.3043423891,
-0.7558538914,
0.7207790613,
0.3025910854,
0.1108712181,
0.1523513496,
0.1456588209,
0.2768533826,
0.507314682,
-0.8844530582,
0.073549144,
-0.400936842,
-0.342936188,
0.1989305466,
-0.4947376549,
0.0381445587,
-0.3761326671,
0.8108298182,
0.0566267259,
0.6767485142,
-0.1371373832,
-0.0570800304,
-0.2844962776,
0.4158504903,
0.4603120983,
0.7843368053,
-0.6423381567,
-0.1397174001,
0.1547408849,
-0.488576144,
0.0304610059,
0.3118894696,
-0.1909274757,
0.1038309932,
0.4855058193,
0.6547843218,
0.28755337,
-0.7286960483,
0.3060685098,
0.3387979865,
-0.0354612358,
-0.0999989808,
-0.3799979985,
-0.0795946196,
0.3979465365,
0.4407880008,
0.1706754863,
0.1556397676,
-0.4442904294,
0.1954432875,
0.0130160628,
-0.6350476742,
-0.5307657123,
0.1557139158,
0.2920695543,
0.0031006637,
0.4310866594,
-0.8396810293,
-0.400147438,
-0.0511206314,
0.4373340607,
0.5508157611,
-0.4179202914,
0.3701981306,
0.2765787244,
0.3497902751,
0.1356334239,
0.5752615929,
0.1896180362,
-0.6189216375,
-0.7304205298,
-1.1039164066,
-0.8680095077,
0.2005006224,
-0.8588705063,
0.3927402496,
-0.712477088,
-0.1967671812,
-0.27431795,
0.3644706011,
-0.3278689682,
0.406034708,
0.3367105424,
0.5281682014,
-0.9525794983,
0.7442415357,
1.0503456593,
-0.4538117349,
-0.4481340051,
0.2228532732,
-0.0066471882,
-0.6264986396,
1.0757447481,
0.0191173516,
-0.1964425892,
-0.0492833816,
-0.6776996851,
-0.6183536053,
0.7199500799,
0.1704901159,
-0.4020960331,
-0.0242817849,
0.001979542,
0.639303863,
0.112547636,
-0.1767604649,
0.393479079,
0.7374234796,
0.1405435652,
-0.9050715566,
-0.1256225109,
-0.3558671474,
-0.102024287,
-0.0901947543,
-0.8765838146,
0.775200665,
0.1130309477,
0.2220925689,
0.0481446162,
0.7449315786,
0.3891036808,
0.3008551896,
0.2408363968,
0.5425170064,
0.6267136931,
-0.0758885965,
0.8808299303,
-0.1585898399,
0.7173262239,
1.1129356623,
-0.6170386672,
1.0314007998,
0.5531097054,
-0.5166001916,
0.5313382745,
0.6528245211,
-0.310287565,
0.9643580317,
0.1703588068,
-0.1248885021,
0.0612857454,
-0.5566717386,
-0.0765978992,
0.6837941408,
0.2530075908,
0.1714730412,
-0.239404887,
0.2575345337,
-0.024827335,
0.0916324407,
-0.5410505533,
0.6875373721,
0.057910867,
-0.3255787194,
0.3804792166,
-0.1728555411,
0.6331573129,
-0.2915453911,
0.0595384464,
-0.1772145033,
0.3813060522,
-0.2360247374,
-0.8083069921,
0.7345059514,
0.2546262443,
-0.2773447037,
-0.1755958647,
0.8262643218,
-0.1662080437,
-0.9299048781,
0.5994664431,
0.4558621645,
0.1496540904,
0.2424333543,
-0.8301226497,
0.4538685679,
-0.1674437374,
-0.0948008895,
0.2088533491,
0.4151021838,
0.2456621081,
0.3254738152,
0.3620187938,
0.5048623085,
-0.0003657236,
0.2078272253,
0.7641777396,
-0.5591453314,
-0.241929397,
-0.676145196,
0.2150000036,
-0.1736876369,
-0.0345734991,
0.8100440502,
0.7693480849,
0.8970164061,
-0.2005538791,
1.1477742195,
-0.3946305811,
1.0871100426,
-0.284476012,
0.6981089115,
-0.3487829268,
-0.2215639502,
-0.6313309669,
-0.9393365383,
-0.2104002088,
0.9161029458,
-0.5071906447,
-0.0140796108,
0.5510648489,
0.668004632,
-0.0020780258,
-0.1703464687,
0.2002571821,
0.3008393645,
0.1696919501,
0.3477764428,
0.8132532835,
-0.214724198,
0.5098567605,
-0.4607769251,
-0.1377564669,
-0.7940658927,
-0.5450931787,
-0.933060348,
-0.4459033012,
-0.182607621,
-0.3741148114,
0.2589372694,
1.2528412342,
0.4487773478,
-1.0122615099,
-0.471239537,
0.1443390399,
0.0719795451,
0.0656196773,
-0.3421066701,
0.1704333276,
-0.5484679341,
-0.8078168035,
0.2775812745,
0.4049185812,
-0.2554431856,
-0.1039007604,
0.0551739596,
-0.5959472656,
0.1226807013,
0.8814986944,
0.246577695,
-0.5651091933,
-0.5377640128,
-0.2032541186,
-0.1004270241,
-0.0063940478,
0.4638603628,
-0.4229378998,
0.2242728472,
0.5212121606,
0.6304451823,
0.2502587438,
0.2456784993,
0.1921237558,
-0.9078917503,
0.4044184685,
0.5148524642,
0.1677229404,
0.6285282969,
-0.016155608,
0.5387462378,
0.3199920654,
-0.6198094487,
-1.0401495695,
0.3126057386,
-1.3026709557,
-0.2697823942,
1.2107436657,
-0.0169674754,
-0.1721170843,
-0.1981631517,
-0.393355459,
0.2957086861,
-0.6081039906,
0.8787583709,
0.7657133341,
-0.3981197476,
-0.2073193491,
-0.4581653178,
0.3723469973,
0.2873390615,
-0.7917037606,
0.0874131471,
0.407384783,
-0.0825432315,
0.4106981158,
0.790055871,
0.0346118025,
0.3892488182,
-0.2843773663,
0.342897445,
0.2481172681,
-0.1023390368,
-0.2211719751,
0.1555225253,
0.1825735569,
-0.144474417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12727v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12727v2
|
Soft Random Sampling: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis
| 2023-11-21T17:03:21 | 2023-11-24T03:27:31 |
Xiaodong Cui, Ashish Mittal, Songtao Lu, Wei Zhang, George Saon, Brian Kingsbury
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Soft random sampling (SRS) is a simple yet effective approach for efficient
training of large-scale deep neural networks when dealing with massive data.
SRS selects a subset uniformly at random with replacement from the full data
set in each epoch. In this paper, we conduct a theoretical and empirical
analysis of SRS. First, we analyze its sampling dynamics including data
coverage and occupancy. Next, we investigate its convergence with non-convex
objective functions and give the convergence rate. Finally, we provide its
generalization performance. We empirically evaluate SRS for image recognition
on CIFAR10 and automatic speech recognition on Librispeech and an in-house
payload dataset to demonstrate its effectiveness. Compared to existing
coreset-based data selection methods, SRS offers a better accuracy-efficiency
trade-off. Especially on real-world industrial scale data sets, it is shown to
be a powerful training strategy with significant speedup and competitive
performance with almost no additional computing cost.
|
[
-0.3648686111,
-0.3166290522,
0.2428773046,
-0.2749800086,
-0.4131876528,
-0.1524947435,
-0.5261589885,
-0.1758485734,
0.0948296487,
0.1703722775,
-0.4880800843,
-0.2064898759,
-0.3762958944,
-0.0608866177,
-0.5502056479,
0.8980636001,
0.382094115,
0.3061846197,
0.1771478206,
-0.3609787822,
-0.1671926528,
-0.1930236518,
-0.8377100825,
-0.1237562522,
0.6997404695,
0.4123090208,
0.3673527241,
0.5053881407,
0.651355803,
0.3868697286,
-0.0737514123,
-0.0468634889,
-0.6244848967,
0.3368056417,
-0.2318326086,
-0.3900942504,
0.3209219873,
-0.0934587047,
0.7605952621,
0.7649971843,
-0.4197458029,
0.2462195456,
-0.0347674079,
0.6596828103,
-0.6637153029,
-0.3720860779,
-0.7244172096,
0.5464743376,
-0.5206911564,
-0.0799330398,
-0.2107682675,
-0.2570196688,
0.3521084487,
-0.2068823278,
0.8666569591,
-0.066696547,
0.361744374,
0.0447037295,
-0.2366630882,
-0.0197851136,
-0.9020269513,
1.1174277067,
-0.3665288389,
0.3890603781,
-0.1138106734,
0.6188391447,
-0.1346577108,
-1.0005670786,
-0.316778779,
-0.41493541,
0.3431926668,
0.0548235178,
0.4609769583,
-0.0993014202,
0.3139238358,
0.5807500482,
-0.3491031528,
0.3093114197,
-0.5713364482,
0.0641903132,
0.7061801553,
0.0466255285,
-0.0113585368,
-0.000995082,
-0.5256823301,
-0.393298775,
-0.4636870027,
0.2055823952,
0.3400163054,
0.713584125,
-0.1158124134,
0.3470438719,
-0.3071994185,
0.6986117959,
-0.1166738793,
-0.2583642602,
0.4327612519,
-0.1798797548,
-0.3103673756,
-0.2907346487,
0.674295485,
-0.0803811178,
0.4909713864,
-0.2907439172,
-0.4835040271,
-0.4371810853,
0.4098537564,
-0.534781456,
0.2282437831,
0.140444994,
-0.7118255496,
-0.3627300858,
0.0573990047,
-0.6921304464,
-0.4391275346,
-0.6319828629,
-0.1061927229,
-0.3136866391,
-0.340357244,
-0.0466408767,
-0.5343008637,
0.0418124534,
0.2583418787,
-0.5120050907,
0.2123515606,
0.3700296581,
0.615894556,
-0.1321513355,
-0.1853048056,
-0.3724656701,
-0.1142224446,
-0.3388695419,
0.8592556715,
-0.1941764802,
-0.4262658656,
0.1166799664,
-0.277189225,
-0.2510668039,
-0.6410572529,
0.545974493,
-0.5116378665,
-0.4170301557,
-0.1290810704,
-0.1909499019,
0.0720680356,
0.0670107305,
-0.6638456583,
1.0074975491,
0.1738867611,
-0.4711798429,
0.6885418296,
-0.0369038135,
-0.4503500164,
0.2492845505,
-0.5514292717,
-0.6067236066,
0.4778961837,
-0.2533971071,
0.547492981,
-0.3165639937,
0.1305579245,
-0.5722235441,
-0.5750615001,
0.4065072834,
-0.3652744889,
0.5631995201,
0.7291668057,
-0.2880320549,
-0.198487848,
-0.6071120501,
0.1818835139,
0.0941472724,
-0.2922433317,
-0.3120066822,
0.1013091281,
0.2885872722,
-0.068890065,
-0.2514056265,
-0.5012266636,
0.364097327,
-0.1105556861,
0.5658103824,
0.8034620881,
-0.0933711454,
0.5598727465,
-0.2380824834,
0.2639800906,
-0.0274371561,
0.3695239425,
0.2262280434,
-0.1203008741,
-0.2976062298,
-0.6182301641,
0.8932720423,
0.4455554485,
-0.6786932945,
0.237330988,
-0.4165083766,
-0.5250908732,
-0.1162514836,
0.2526225746,
0.2787011862,
0.3218617737,
0.2396759391,
-0.3995549083,
-0.5887617469,
-1.2093644142,
-0.1089377627,
0.3444230556,
-0.3421905637,
0.5771442056,
0.4390048087,
0.0636487827,
0.9182218313,
-0.3460041583,
-0.5207082033,
-0.4571605623,
0.2555248737,
0.1634166688,
0.5603030324,
0.6390876174,
-0.954926312,
-0.1510187536,
-0.4560776055,
-0.634755969,
0.2713227868,
-0.1550758928,
0.1956142932,
-0.1264763325,
0.4772356451,
-0.4404030442,
0.6078019142,
0.1153276339,
0.494635433,
0.5059873462,
0.0652153343,
0.1022455096,
-0.6389998198,
0.1417020112,
0.2838536203,
0.0514116362,
-0.3942122459,
0.1739018708,
-0.1161956117,
-0.2141175568,
-0.8005079031,
0.1141763255,
-0.4770552218,
-0.3728179932,
-0.0185576323,
-0.0642306358,
-0.2928195298,
0.4485153854,
0.1310998052,
0.8174011111,
0.4185839593,
-0.7204576135,
0.2302707434,
-0.1287188977,
-0.6355128884,
0.6760259867,
-0.696080327,
0.2834950686,
-0.4280927777,
0.6384071112,
-1.0239197016,
0.1252090782,
-0.0044861068,
-0.274007678,
0.3736492991,
-0.438077867,
-0.3471381664,
-0.4957187772,
-0.2921585143,
0.4954052269,
0.5959457159,
-0.2864911258,
0.6738497615,
0.5318479538,
0.000828735,
-0.5900755525,
-0.8288640976,
-0.0895723552,
-0.0652801991,
-0.2473597229,
0.1393687725,
0.0662135184,
-0.1837019771,
-0.1017413214,
-0.0427766964,
-0.2485155761,
-0.0851487592,
0.2321222872,
0.0154300304,
-0.0666830763,
0.0126062054,
-0.2777129412,
-0.0831702724,
-0.4242151976,
-0.3364023864,
0.4429823458,
-0.0632654727,
-0.3957282007,
-0.4465977848,
0.1992369145,
0.2080771625,
0.2354509234,
0.3480601013,
0.5978868604,
-0.2802344263,
-0.532597959,
-0.6763212681,
-0.2845888436,
-0.4710901082,
0.2566331625,
-0.4402530789,
-0.2557459772,
0.3360418677,
0.0018823352,
0.1867405176,
0.3389185369,
0.3084264398,
-0.2228145003,
0.694249332,
0.1618626118,
-0.2769534886,
0.51903373,
-0.6608124971,
0.2069073617,
-0.7333900928,
-0.2320696265,
-0.8380942345,
-0.9818335176,
-0.301342696,
-0.2727220356,
0.3451888561,
-0.2789530754,
-0.0775299817,
0.1340259612,
-0.7060981393,
0.2465522438,
0.9527907372,
0.365188092,
-0.138624981,
0.3234696984,
-0.0610238835,
-0.0680846199,
-0.7793540359,
0.0684856474,
0.9817815423,
0.1148687527,
0.9583436251,
-0.3389879465,
0.4873463213,
0.5392875671,
0.1821909994,
-0.731798172,
0.766317606,
-0.4066772461,
-0.6007372141,
-0.3209358454,
-0.5679434538,
-0.9446915984,
0.2407957464,
-0.1773826629,
-0.2152288109,
0.4910151064,
0.1256862581,
-0.4144852757,
0.5751050711,
-0.7299730778,
-0.0241611749,
-0.1685391068,
-0.2115497738,
-0.2736302912,
-0.5881538987,
0.1541836262,
0.3317645788,
0.1558780521,
0.0589384064,
0.0460189469,
0.9516608715,
-0.0287666731,
0.8248510361,
-0.5514470935,
0.388789922,
0.6473718286,
-0.2049260885,
0.3743215799,
0.0810111836,
-0.2136877179,
0.4071400166,
-0.3886089921,
-0.3263483047,
-0.4992586672,
0.5634744763,
-0.4997297525,
-0.0879321173,
-0.6333607435,
-0.5343786478,
-0.1987693459,
0.1645397842,
0.4424988031,
0.7066461444,
0.0084880972,
0.7606638074,
0.905487299,
-0.0558847412,
0.2305204272,
0.4120269716,
0.4826340377,
-0.5594876409,
0.7930441499,
0.7764818668,
-0.1663404256,
0.0464280546,
0.0539014526,
-0.2044133544,
-0.8022454381,
-0.6647885442,
0.044703912,
-0.2787538171,
-0.3876639903,
-0.4839629531,
-0.4681824446,
-0.5892477632,
-0.2115321755,
-0.4174619317,
-0.3518433571,
-0.1267839819,
-0.1282913685,
0.1306975633,
0.3256811202,
-0.2321238965,
0.2085408568,
-0.5003638268,
0.4624848068,
0.3737019897,
0.349450469,
0.0617871471,
-0.5505084991,
-0.0872521326,
0.1827952415,
0.0023632969,
-0.4789016843,
0.0069167772,
0.2311440259,
0.7839295268,
0.5412828922,
0.0019264012,
0.5715956688,
-0.5830712914,
0.6723557115,
0.0925819203,
-0.2831084728,
0.2531330585,
-0.3264950812,
0.0136923017,
1.1185330153,
0.1309515685,
-0.3128710091,
0.0029796164,
-0.9024922848,
-0.938780725,
0.5128653049,
0.0484787002,
0.2089264244,
0.4193039238,
0.6431082487,
-0.0351083688,
0.4596778452,
-0.2627106607,
-0.1884713322,
0.0234769024,
-0.4047876894,
0.1054564267,
-0.1435436904,
-0.3497838974,
-0.1535192579,
0.5782831907,
-0.0696175694,
0.4541496933,
0.1785663217,
-0.0290169436,
-0.0839838684,
0.1360202134,
0.5143986344,
0.3710383177,
-0.2658736408,
0.1575374305,
0.3298869431,
-0.8092530966,
-0.0007749932,
0.0017707496,
-0.4764772654,
-0.0684373081,
0.0631700158,
0.5770460367,
0.3183998466,
-0.7476950288,
0.5045893192,
-0.129649058,
-0.425108403,
-0.6457446218,
0.3523105085,
-0.5072938204,
0.1804788858,
0.9073181152,
0.2918670774,
0.4738708735,
-0.3517994583,
0.297865808,
0.6003012657,
-0.3639473915,
-0.1112640202,
0.157287702,
0.1163880676,
-0.4040353298,
0.9128258228,
0.0331708901,
-0.318644464,
0.8507299423,
0.1164556667,
0.5672600269,
-0.0752462819,
0.1531030238,
0.3192065358,
0.2564471364,
-0.3168629706,
0.1757677346,
-0.2244217992,
-0.5905313492,
-0.1713912785,
-0.5211728811,
-0.5207746029,
0.5382859111,
-0.7539052367,
0.1901617795,
-0.6393297315,
-0.2927313745,
-0.2815736532,
0.0471463874,
-0.8477216363,
0.6987133026,
0.183132723,
1.267449975,
-0.81807971,
0.3210721016,
0.3973796964,
-0.1570581347,
-0.7660733461,
-0.3596481085,
-0.0176240411,
-0.8930205107,
0.5838182569,
0.0396017395,
0.0461028889,
0.0134823164,
-0.9180602431,
-0.8399348855,
0.9253628254,
-0.0120286215,
-0.4959313571,
0.0356732979,
-0.0249042921,
0.371132195,
-0.1212608516,
0.2989830673,
0.4146023989,
0.3195097446,
0.1824275404,
-0.3407686949,
-0.1594353765,
-0.3932911754,
0.2277704477,
0.0308263954,
-0.6785520911,
0.7075218558,
-0.1636487991,
-0.0072703152,
0.0773888007,
0.7887744904,
0.6086288095,
0.3536578715,
1.1936545372,
0.7884379029,
0.4387744963,
-0.062112961,
0.9682848454,
0.022739565,
0.2704591155,
0.800668478,
-0.4382674098,
0.7120576501,
0.4305327535,
-0.380381763,
0.3791277707,
0.6406316757,
-0.2952623963,
0.7759164572,
0.3636951149,
-0.1969989985,
0.004867061,
-0.1136696041,
-0.6663267016,
0.1806022674,
0.324778527,
-0.3456726074,
-0.2619892955,
0.3342968822,
-0.3658222854,
-0.4270241559,
-0.2430392802,
0.5662513375,
0.192129612,
-0.5700383186,
0.2113510519,
-0.0507484898,
0.6140176058,
-0.8570274711,
0.0807757452,
-0.0564605035,
0.3377949297,
-0.1590654254,
-0.696515739,
-0.0234720949,
-0.2478124648,
-0.0384987369,
-0.275046289,
1.049965024,
-0.0381043702,
-0.3942446113,
-0.1353394389,
0.1760522276,
0.1059181765,
0.1030302346,
-0.745300889,
0.0026165543,
-0.2190503478,
-0.6899539232,
0.603887558,
0.2803242505,
0.1455202699,
0.5397845507,
0.9910724163,
0.2997471988,
-0.0586166196,
0.2703742981,
0.7663421631,
-0.457647562,
-0.6820008159,
-0.1842196137,
0.5449787974,
-0.3357460797,
-0.4692963362,
0.6448098421,
0.450946629,
0.6429690123,
-0.1568836868,
1.0064467192,
-0.2918870151,
0.7586914301,
-0.4176996946,
0.3864067495,
-0.4335665703,
-0.0401373915,
0.1555001438,
-0.6154295206,
-0.0408148803,
0.8268639445,
-0.4774326086,
0.3905060589,
0.4028009176,
0.6678062081,
-0.3136500716,
0.2097461224,
-0.0903130099,
-0.0112387044,
-0.0281510893,
0.1922768801,
0.6614102125,
-0.2697039247,
0.4317438304,
-0.3867681324,
-0.3864971101,
-0.5376847982,
-0.6702748537,
-0.3938567042,
-0.4792606831,
0.0050945212,
-0.4572104216,
-0.0108701717,
0.7487312555,
1.1474401951,
-0.7789870501,
-0.1186427698,
-0.0441627242,
-0.1460713595,
-0.6279482841,
-0.2528070807,
0.1692992747,
-0.5128369331,
-0.7580729127,
0.4992822409,
-0.0948148817,
-0.0015110674,
-0.3355086148,
0.3359871209,
-0.2014592439,
-0.0001334735,
0.205844149,
0.6369852424,
0.1352191716,
-0.0836120993,
-0.0377005003,
-0.2846539915,
-0.1489988118,
1.2821750641,
-1.0147849321,
-0.1162017584,
0.7181335688,
0.6343446374,
0.5587314963,
0.034599781,
0.1325236708,
-0.7366074324,
0.615049243,
0.4143951535,
0.3762897253,
0.1971627176,
-0.3272177279,
0.7629699707,
0.6645994782,
-0.7063087225,
-1.2268499136,
0.1067608669,
-1.0448496342,
-0.3727936745,
1.2009010315,
0.22012119,
-0.4067341983,
-0.2802168131,
0.0058891601,
0.0601755492,
-0.4457742572,
0.8518192768,
0.155502215,
0.0317797288,
0.1895068437,
-0.6498346925,
0.2392549068,
0.4962204695,
-0.2454812527,
-0.3919822574,
0.327475071,
0.5602754951,
0.2632080913,
0.8773382902,
0.1243505031,
0.1542471349,
-0.0368964486,
-0.0588908754,
-0.2016765028,
-0.5166192055,
-0.2487865239,
0.6178460121,
-0.4815736711,
-0.2219831944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12707v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12707v1
|
Keeping Users Engaged During Repeated Administration of the Same Questionnaire: Using Large Language Models to Reliably Diversify Questions
| 2023-11-21T16:20:49 | 2023-11-21T16:20:49 |
Hye Sun Yun, Mehdi Arjmand, Phillip Raymond Sherlock, Michael Paasche-Orlow, James W. Griffith, Timothy Bickmore
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Standardized, validated questionnaires are vital tools in HCI research and
healthcare, offering dependable self-report data. However, their repeated use
in longitudinal or pre-post studies can induce respondent fatigue, impacting
data quality via response biases and decreased response rates. We propose
utilizing large language models (LLMs) to generate diverse questionnaire
versions while retaining good psychometric properties. In a longitudinal study,
participants engaged with our agent system and responded daily for two weeks to
either a standardized depression questionnaire or one of two LLM-generated
questionnaire variants, alongside a validated depression questionnaire.
Psychometric testing revealed consistent covariation between the external
criterion and the focal measure administered across the three conditions,
demonstrating the reliability and validity of the LLM-generated variants.
Participants found the repeated administration of the standardized
questionnaire significantly more repetitive compared to the variants. Our
findings highlight the potential of LLM-generated variants to invigorate
questionnaires, fostering engagement and interest without compromising
validity.
|
[
-0.3996890485,
-0.7535459399,
0.675054431,
0.5725780725,
-0.3008693755,
-0.0670299679,
-0.3836452365,
-0.4243410826,
0.2403653115,
0.5045057535,
-0.4398065209,
-0.4584659636,
-0.1772000492,
0.4502337873,
-0.2601600885,
1.1218562126,
-0.3144534826,
0.2924756706,
-0.4445715845,
-0.5040864348,
-0.4533295333,
-0.5826945901,
-0.7911228538,
-0.5936989784,
0.9231405854,
0.15572837,
0.7025234699,
-0.1211527884,
0.6068891883,
0.2026523501,
0.0088004097,
-0.0958863124,
-0.7067952752,
0.5409278274,
-0.0405394621,
-0.5750357509,
-0.4308579862,
-0.1398328096,
0.582488656,
0.8928584456,
-0.5423289537,
0.2508700192,
0.2981212437,
0.299687922,
-0.6215329766,
-0.2242595404,
-0.0763160512,
-0.188650623,
0.0523665994,
-0.0140157426,
-0.3325805962,
-0.6856735349,
0.1169305295,
-0.3678797483,
0.0724691227,
-0.3774825931,
0.616735816,
0.0735344663,
-0.5894212127,
-0.2502401471,
-1.0629645586,
0.7175970674,
-0.9194738865,
0.3344993293,
0.3096547723,
0.2859167159,
-0.0510025993,
-0.7217371464,
-0.4210459888,
-0.2964577079,
-0.1116752401,
0.3520558476,
0.00608005,
-0.166206032,
0.1651621461,
0.3249226809,
-0.8250584006,
0.2545299828,
-0.1638739705,
0.2167369723,
0.8060715795,
0.7683221102,
0.4511210918,
-0.0438564681,
-0.2115234882,
0.2453806847,
-0.7648107409,
0.1409228891,
0.0742565989,
0.0874821246,
-0.0821446627,
0.5481794477,
-0.0816025063,
0.4026143551,
0.1151302457,
-0.3900549114,
0.2945100665,
-0.38364622,
-0.1291120499,
-0.3213109374,
0.8532542586,
0.3065913618,
0.1405920088,
-0.2993370593,
-0.237562567,
-0.1812452376,
0.4914137125,
-0.7230035067,
-0.0403368063,
0.8340870142,
-0.5487661958,
0.0169259049,
0.0050165602,
-0.6033015847,
-0.2283325046,
-0.2679782808,
0.1649362892,
-0.306081593,
-0.6987391114,
0.3195287883,
-0.0851197913,
0.0726835504,
0.2964375913,
-0.656447947,
0.3204812706,
0.5149110556,
0.5978578925,
-0.612664938,
-0.387180537,
-0.3009714484,
0.1093100384,
-0.426179558,
0.5369390845,
-0.3625472486,
-0.756223619,
0.1902642399,
0.1959467232,
-0.1680967659,
-0.906317234,
0.1857058108,
-0.5230611563,
0.5032541752,
-0.3604759872,
-0.4618207216,
0.2939749658,
0.532364428,
-0.5797792077,
1.0037419796,
0.4614408612,
-0.5616200566,
0.4976066351,
-0.1799592674,
-0.2114917785,
0.2723532617,
-0.3343985677,
-0.4777703881,
0.3737161458,
-0.0448248088,
0.1111365706,
-0.2360811383,
0.3695626855,
-0.3869413137,
-0.3299751282,
0.4926093817,
-0.1511511356,
0.5614832044,
0.0629595891,
-0.093033053,
0.0185040999,
-0.5789900422,
-0.0844100267,
-0.0393446051,
-0.651037693,
-0.4527727365,
-0.1167377532,
0.1746342778,
0.2125552148,
0.1201502234,
-0.6284795403,
-0.0140785454,
-0.1492676884,
-0.0448678248,
0.3509753048,
0.3567061126,
-0.0386526249,
-0.6570798159,
1.0947277546,
0.2228339314,
0.1819095761,
-0.1646337807,
-0.3719580173,
-0.4238814712,
-0.5280592442,
0.103418529,
0.4812227488,
-0.5187833309,
0.358995527,
-0.223933816,
-0.6828514338,
-0.2484767884,
0.1948355287,
0.0690159351,
0.2489180267,
0.0813401267,
-0.4161370397,
-0.3624095619,
-0.5115777254,
-0.0637483746,
-0.0893502682,
-0.3308829069,
0.7235087752,
0.32653144,
-0.5646260381,
0.9110227227,
-0.4145723581,
0.0867799371,
-0.4747644663,
0.4657693505,
0.1388023943,
0.3642009795,
0.5182056427,
-0.6335533857,
-0.4063955545,
-0.1955698729,
-1.0384453535,
0.0628201663,
-0.5322579145,
-0.0000058741,
0.0472971424,
0.3431963623,
-0.6859656572,
0.1434744149,
0.328697592,
-0.1855610013,
0.4388899207,
-0.0553490184,
0.2076863199,
-0.9049052596,
0.2858731747,
-0.1914888918,
-0.3193951845,
-0.4811199307,
0.0719230399,
-0.1288791299,
-0.4602877796,
-0.2578103244,
0.4621789157,
-0.2812814415,
0.4777548909,
-0.1803430319,
-0.0914441943,
-0.0218618661,
0.0593284667,
-0.235419929,
0.5295473933,
0.6470496058,
-0.680382967,
0.3271544874,
0.2358522862,
-0.1529788822,
0.5931034684,
-1.0238249302,
0.0648956075,
-0.5199828148,
0.3747526407,
-1.2910274267,
-0.3811959922,
0.0256143436,
-0.1467705369,
0.1356282383,
0.5054798126,
-0.2407063991,
-0.5123258829,
-0.2952420115,
0.5488619804,
0.5560260415,
-0.2434333861,
0.6825454831,
-0.0070397872,
-0.4495595694,
-0.2561783493,
-0.6815931201,
-0.0908801109,
-0.5076476932,
-0.732398212,
0.0709407479,
-0.3260262609,
-0.2405749559,
-0.017414324,
-0.2300721407,
0.0435247198,
0.107790418,
0.3184783757,
0.0514407977,
-0.3873817623,
0.4334213138,
-0.180956617,
0.2274510264,
0.0570330583,
0.3171627522,
0.8014711142,
0.3175932765,
-0.3839917779,
-0.5430654883,
0.9517820477,
0.7239676118,
-0.1428019553,
0.7733313441,
0.4210552275,
-0.2367689461,
-0.0587971956,
-0.8308794498,
-0.232646957,
-0.4306926727,
0.1289797723,
-0.4284585416,
-1.1759852171,
0.6577960253,
-0.0227274932,
0.2645071149,
0.0991211906,
0.6864548922,
-0.2025505006,
1.0508043766,
0.6215841174,
0.0016289436,
0.3859503567,
0.1878293902,
0.1450010836,
-0.6999513507,
-0.1171964034,
-0.2555923164,
-0.3048300147,
-0.5011665821,
-0.1217184365,
0.4095662236,
0.078166008,
-0.1182018295,
-0.2807409465,
0.0659766942,
-0.0433111712,
0.0725973248,
0.3779313564,
0.1542565376,
-0.1531489193,
0.3451009989,
-0.0944658294,
-0.4423395693,
-0.4403596222,
1.2560319901,
0.2802817225,
1.1697468758,
0.1498027146,
1.3263046741,
-0.0515646785,
0.8233386278,
-0.4258728027,
0.3054418862,
0.036178533,
-0.4975979924,
-0.3848540783,
-0.539542079,
-1.368236661,
0.0961805508,
0.1991120428,
-0.7921344042,
0.4662966132,
0.0556443371,
-0.7077165842,
-0.4021492004,
-0.4931637347,
0.8427576423,
-0.2834850252,
-0.2757990956,
-0.166170314,
-0.314868331,
0.3453197181,
-0.2462108582,
-0.1725321412,
0.0257954653,
-0.0221969839,
0.3627270758,
-0.2921642065,
0.8427534699,
0.1070117429,
-0.1978817433,
0.3393232226,
0.0694395527,
0.374990344,
0.4806709886,
-0.1614842862,
-0.2095558792,
0.0901898295,
-0.4194900393,
-0.924978435,
0.7626544237,
-0.7807159424,
-0.9869207144,
-0.2827877104,
-0.5283386111,
-0.3218060732,
-0.0514898971,
0.0596651472,
0.2811164856,
-0.6253688335,
0.4361798167,
0.5403950214,
-0.332480222,
0.070748657,
0.540548563,
-0.2114067227,
-0.1347928047,
0.4770114422,
0.1023231596,
0.4306809604,
-0.0864043906,
0.1318377554,
0.0855139568,
-0.1148673743,
-0.0297406539,
0.5063881874,
-0.252135694,
0.1274787933,
-0.8410112858,
0.0076348204,
-0.6201896667,
0.0585692301,
-0.1913813055,
-0.1086186692,
-0.3473770022,
-0.1271065772,
0.1573213339,
0.6361222267,
-0.1135230958,
0.0890342593,
-0.758441031,
0.56369102,
0.6398115754,
0.3546633124,
-0.0030718341,
-0.23010692,
-0.1970636398,
-0.0672320053,
-0.258991152,
-1.1076873541,
0.2028635889,
0.0843452364,
0.7611383796,
0.2929551899,
-0.1530025154,
0.5077780485,
-0.1703742445,
0.9639354348,
0.3408462405,
-0.4413551092,
0.292614758,
-0.4782625735,
0.8689414859,
0.7041547298,
0.8157593012,
-0.7349225283,
-0.7950035334,
-0.3941020966,
-1.0487670898,
0.3858080208,
-0.0522271357,
0.3868362904,
-0.218631804,
0.3712869585,
0.1430570036,
0.2929108739,
-0.7438188195,
-0.1409373134,
-0.196181193,
-0.2292424887,
-0.210680753,
-0.6676967144,
-0.3380384445,
0.0185634438,
0.1573204845,
0.1169281825,
0.0200111493,
0.328602612,
0.1815580428,
-0.2237493396,
0.4983093143,
0.1712664962,
1.0903713703,
-0.301674217,
0.0591295958,
-0.0024379122,
-0.4003466368,
0.112514548,
0.0337804109,
-0.1300243586,
0.2317738086,
0.0552935563,
0.4257078767,
0.0257335473,
-0.9200122356,
0.2815110981,
-0.1200750098,
-0.0381815694,
-0.5108746886,
0.1147483811,
0.4762652218,
0.1845628917,
0.0594102181,
-0.5608935952,
0.1178532764,
-0.8783516288,
0.3294026554,
0.2484375536,
-0.3491662443,
-0.0380432941,
0.5132760406,
0.1089145839,
-0.3745993972,
0.6913074851,
-0.0502064973,
0.0560955107,
0.5485373139,
0.7222533822,
0.7740690112,
-0.5175437331,
0.4351743758,
0.4864161611,
0.1458867192,
-0.4228843749,
0.8141112924,
0.1374237835,
-0.5534934998,
-0.0161444712,
-0.4146773219,
-0.3238089979,
0.2199030966,
-1.0048289299,
0.0176869463,
-0.2561970949,
-0.6338409185,
-0.4385197163,
-0.5066996813,
-0.9076118469,
0.4025102854,
0.1319657415,
0.5688213706,
-0.7745128274,
0.4651604891,
0.769154489,
-0.6825645566,
-0.8984815478,
0.1128447503,
-0.1539040953,
-0.2570566535,
0.4273035228,
-0.0908298641,
0.2077977806,
-0.3199995756,
-0.5269630551,
-0.942094028,
1.1693983078,
-0.0566384718,
-0.5297418237,
0.1223961413,
0.5114083886,
1.0059632063,
-0.4734455049,
0.1712416261,
0.5694330335,
0.1887814105,
-0.0616681054,
-0.8340226412,
0.2336100489,
-0.2580652833,
0.0386150144,
-0.0271716602,
-0.7473613024,
0.944313705,
-0.0169374794,
-0.3024529517,
0.2340809554,
0.5566316247,
0.664688766,
0.4103599489,
0.5200245976,
0.5393437147,
0.7533691525,
0.1426126808,
1.0312184095,
-0.249650687,
0.2465397716,
1.2790950537,
-0.6119982004,
0.8063316941,
0.5888061523,
0.1358961165,
0.6552500129,
0.4311967492,
-0.1294496506,
0.0646376461,
0.3305849135,
-0.3402583599,
-0.4383845925,
-0.1427309066,
-0.5028063059,
0.2713908255,
0.2499656081,
-0.3296100795,
-0.2931041718,
0.3211748302,
0.1538036168,
-0.0748112947,
0.2276905477,
0.5217232704,
0.3858655691,
-0.9446336031,
0.7397577763,
-0.3167916536,
0.4381444156,
-0.8380299211,
0.4243363142,
-0.8041450381,
0.0322669707,
-0.2106559575,
-0.510147512,
0.1182540506,
0.0485114232,
-0.2025123984,
-0.237174511,
0.3392223418,
-0.6269078851,
-0.5999162793,
0.219566375,
0.8775123358,
0.1157568768,
0.027883308,
-0.4061057568,
0.0830570087,
-0.1781859249,
-0.6948273778,
0.3960996866,
0.4407755733,
0.0847650021,
0.7400399446,
0.1185165271,
0.1607335359,
0.0430793278,
0.5097997189,
0.820510745,
-0.6254610419,
-0.3752633333,
-0.6034302711,
0.7202296853,
-0.1138596758,
-0.6859250069,
0.9207091331,
0.5568911433,
0.388248682,
-0.098924987,
0.6666845679,
0.1310494393,
0.5396104455,
-0.1068558395,
0.4946080148,
-1.1031453609,
0.105500944,
-0.1061815917,
-0.5447921753,
-0.1726954132,
0.0190670602,
-0.1987435967,
0.0790534839,
0.7815075517,
0.7414445281,
0.0202352665,
-0.2091581374,
0.2427174002,
0.0534245707,
0.4779126346,
0.7445576787,
0.9940448403,
-0.0802365839,
0.4072958231,
0.1022435501,
-0.1708057374,
-0.0723004043,
-0.1821693182,
-0.9020268917,
-0.205826506,
-0.6054515243,
-0.2464260161,
0.0254995637,
0.707128644,
0.2947803438,
-0.6586336493,
-0.6266182661,
0.3828951716,
-0.0800649524,
-0.347347647,
-0.2793839574,
0.1326925606,
-0.5685985088,
-0.4223184288,
0.0608473271,
0.3656607568,
-0.0483123101,
-0.4588009715,
0.1682130843,
-0.0495330468,
0.2311903834,
0.4218439162,
0.387041837,
-0.4739665687,
-0.2142062336,
0.2419430912,
-0.4818312526,
0.0767303184,
1.1057349443,
-0.572745502,
0.45693174,
0.7005761862,
0.5704940557,
0.4331365526,
0.2343385816,
0.8828576207,
-0.3139410317,
-0.0576907247,
0.539157629,
0.3442355394,
0.2973212302,
-0.4936872125,
0.2591585517,
-0.0728381574,
-0.6594442129,
-0.8800114989,
0.4463659823,
-1.0135573149,
-0.2106358111,
1.3925862312,
-0.2218928635,
0.1871466041,
-0.3323777914,
-0.0235747807,
0.0028412552,
-0.202155441,
1.2148171663,
0.8692262173,
-0.4157112837,
-0.2261367142,
-0.3516858816,
0.3938462138,
0.702000916,
-0.9526516199,
-0.2420937717,
0.4084473252,
0.4853336513,
0.164046064,
0.9106330872,
-0.3318821788,
0.48243168,
-0.0953485295,
-0.1087462008,
0.541464448,
0.0277922153,
-0.2084763348,
0.3130807877,
0.1360476762,
0.045707453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12699v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12699v1
|
Can Large Language Models Understand Content and Propagation for Misinformation Detection: An Empirical Study
| 2023-11-21T16:03:51 | 2023-11-21T16:03:51 |
Mengyang Chen, Lingwei Wei, Han Cao, Wei Zhou, Songlin Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have garnered significant attention for their
powerful ability in natural language understanding and reasoning. In this
paper, we present a comprehensive empirical study to explore the performance of
LLMs on misinformation detection tasks. This study stands as the pioneering
investigation into the understanding capabilities of multiple LLMs regarding
both content and propagation across social media platforms. Our empirical
studies on five misinformation detection datasets show that LLMs with diverse
prompts achieve comparable performance in text-based misinformation detection
but exhibit notably constrained capabilities in comprehending propagation
structure compared to existing models in propagation-based misinformation
detection. Besides, we further design four instruction-tuned strategies to
enhance LLMs for both content and propagation-based misinformation detection.
These strategies boost LLMs to actively learn effective features from multiple
instances or hard instances, and eliminate irrelevant propagation structures,
thereby achieving better detection performance. Extensive experiments further
demonstrate LLMs would play a better capacity in content and propagation
structure under these proposed strategies and achieve promising detection
performance. These findings highlight the potential ability of LLMs to detect
misinformation.
|
[
-0.3826051056,
-1.1177573204,
0.7707924247,
0.4976191223,
-0.3734347224,
0.1366551071,
-0.5089018941,
-0.5832778215,
0.0233363416,
0.3413327634,
-0.5639534593,
-0.7113761306,
-0.8745718598,
0.2450460196,
-0.4995959401,
0.6235960126,
0.311150372,
-0.01638861,
0.011972799,
0.1453889906,
-0.5942207575,
-0.1708155572,
-0.6946082711,
-0.2348121554,
0.6593747139,
0.6298312545,
0.5224063396,
0.693677485,
0.2778211832,
0.2918660641,
-0.3853592575,
0.5839518905,
-0.6690847278,
0.0665522069,
-0.199114576,
-0.6618048549,
0.0568318479,
-0.2411209792,
1.0316215754,
0.5696450472,
-0.2785437703,
-0.0109222205,
0.0102039734,
0.5004569292,
-0.5109311342,
-0.1016940624,
-0.9662691355,
-0.1823484302,
-0.185090214,
-0.4360107183,
-0.7620498538,
-0.1186944917,
-0.0666427165,
-0.5011666417,
0.3020665348,
0.2595641315,
0.4819805324,
-0.063906163,
-0.4907458425,
-0.6313896179,
-0.8724889159,
0.8228711486,
-0.67434448,
0.6170227528,
0.1482242197,
0.2864353657,
-0.3100770414,
-0.4770799577,
-0.6387896538,
0.0036596984,
0.1616985351,
-0.2132717371,
-0.3370275497,
-0.2034247369,
0.2438127398,
0.2683181763,
-0.6210883856,
0.6523982882,
-0.3067343831,
-0.3471343517,
0.5857467055,
-0.0581537969,
0.2108456343,
-0.2923042476,
-0.1390718818,
-0.042265363,
-0.7307363749,
-0.3551504016,
0.5451732874,
0.2726839781,
-0.2567372918,
0.3472732008,
-0.0282507744,
0.601886034,
0.0862817764,
-0.5141689181,
0.2199678719,
-0.1488896906,
-0.2187924236,
0.1130796894,
0.8777595162,
0.0890979245,
0.3543202579,
-0.2018823326,
-0.3420879543,
-0.1251575202,
0.2405964434,
-0.7156583667,
0.1103975251,
-0.1853024215,
-0.8284894824,
-0.2294230312,
-0.0539624244,
-0.4806439877,
-0.7043579817,
-0.3086648285,
0.2191238254,
-0.6134647131,
-0.4362334609,
0.396913141,
-0.1316929162,
0.1573117077,
0.4815964401,
-0.7553645372,
0.0758873001,
0.8874355555,
0.8111197948,
-0.1240551695,
-0.1409367323,
-0.3693051636,
0.0310018063,
-0.3510367274,
0.9705849886,
-0.6291875243,
-0.1102254838,
0.2291599959,
0.0391979627,
-0.2097106129,
-0.7017595768,
0.7856609225,
-0.8618627787,
-0.1345906705,
-0.3386034071,
-0.846498251,
-0.4120092988,
0.1870470494,
-0.7596558332,
0.5459490418,
-0.0679804459,
-0.8497975469,
0.4096784294,
-0.4456964731,
-0.6368380785,
0.0086977342,
0.0347945057,
-0.3331770301,
0.3427070975,
0.3096267283,
0.7094951868,
-0.1435906291,
0.1863739938,
-0.4275731742,
-0.5497608781,
0.4148548543,
-0.9530159831,
0.3512626588,
0.2497773618,
-0.1754686385,
-0.050202176,
-0.6141981483,
-0.276206851,
0.1481261104,
-0.5031000376,
-0.4669998288,
0.1835077107,
-0.0763542876,
0.025181327,
-0.0996342376,
-0.3864839673,
0.1239041165,
-0.1685788184,
0.2259581387,
0.4983233213,
0.2783560455,
0.3361423016,
-0.0918754637,
0.346357435,
0.1366960257,
0.037151996,
-0.3203761876,
-0.3678472042,
-0.5300151706,
-0.0661312416,
-0.0068524037,
0.3399543762,
-0.8156161308,
0.1959335357,
-0.3230059147,
-0.2852732241,
-0.5286046267,
0.4789954722,
0.2096678168,
0.3864953518,
0.3885715902,
0.3403369784,
-0.6240665317,
-1.0100734234,
-0.6409450173,
-0.0779675543,
-0.0270164125,
0.183935374,
0.4770269692,
-0.3152713776,
0.5141786337,
-0.2520721555,
0.0698146895,
-0.5657150745,
0.3161958158,
0.4076462388,
-0.0490148365,
0.4813641608,
-1.0011183023,
-0.5057067275,
0.0019836272,
-0.7700099945,
-0.2516800761,
-0.0993954316,
0.1939257979,
0.2273864448,
0.4651247561,
-0.5116375685,
0.1804101318,
0.4924992025,
-0.0398568548,
0.5528609753,
-0.0106687201,
0.2762735188,
-0.9394801855,
-0.2500509024,
0.3871758282,
-0.3237534165,
-0.7250535488,
-0.1511038542,
0.2992058992,
0.588070333,
-0.4935873151,
0.1709195077,
-0.5510817766,
-0.1470396966,
-0.4963727295,
0.3311803937,
-0.1409633458,
0.0292669144,
0.0304719545,
0.6252800226,
0.5230227113,
-0.9362691045,
0.2290060371,
-0.0509772301,
-0.7062984705,
0.5908042192,
-0.5332341194,
-0.039560318,
-0.4238058627,
0.3248981237,
-1.0377988815,
-0.3478782177,
0.332234174,
-0.4599790573,
0.2335677147,
-0.2862838209,
-1.0324244499,
-0.3732692003,
-0.1340736598,
0.053385783,
0.295076251,
-0.5797711611,
0.4152956903,
0.074705556,
0.1559280902,
-0.4991104901,
-0.6114347577,
0.060783226,
-0.4534768164,
-0.8062308431,
0.0196608994,
0.098031491,
-0.3577546775,
-0.1128063202,
-0.1327504516,
0.0912768021,
0.2325870693,
0.1614699364,
-0.0502471365,
-0.4572651088,
0.5939038396,
0.0354763679,
0.2009381652,
0.0177363809,
-0.3684157729,
0.651827395,
0.1288593262,
-0.6195491552,
-0.6273761392,
0.1163246781,
0.4960185885,
-0.0500160418,
1.1871680021,
0.9025352001,
-0.3286410272,
-0.6030527949,
-0.9472590089,
-0.2208041251,
-0.4764099121,
0.4203958809,
-0.1279346496,
-0.9481847882,
0.3715929389,
-0.0974623337,
-0.0894852281,
0.5800386667,
0.4327278137,
-0.0385066569,
1.0139801502,
0.5752689838,
-0.3410721421,
0.3686913848,
-0.220007509,
0.2288862467,
-0.6088353992,
-0.2689737976,
-0.4443129301,
-0.2361127287,
-0.4553548098,
-0.5339615941,
0.252465874,
0.3452848494,
0.0336485133,
-0.0057042297,
-0.245765537,
0.5109587312,
0.1594565511,
0.244819805,
0.5754745603,
0.290171802,
0.2336412221,
0.1336657852,
-0.7782781124,
-0.5189059973,
0.9174544811,
0.8082649112,
0.9940779805,
0.2297028899,
0.2786952555,
0.4639439285,
0.5035678148,
-0.7169692516,
0.2556607425,
-0.1202998012,
-0.4753109813,
-0.2638413012,
-0.5823102593,
-0.6408235431,
0.4139224589,
-0.2336667329,
-0.5552609563,
-0.1151675582,
0.0439107083,
-0.0271598194,
0.4751603007,
-0.5985680223,
0.507586956,
-0.3213807046,
-0.2179239839,
-0.6125156283,
-0.2003766596,
0.5868166089,
-0.1977492273,
0.5810033679,
-0.0054443437,
0.003351399,
0.6392990947,
0.2770154178,
0.9828702211,
-0.1403001398,
-0.4410744905,
0.3709633648,
-0.096704483,
0.5740730166,
0.2327827066,
-0.240779385,
0.0149487304,
-0.5418797135,
-0.0623551495,
-0.4802828133,
0.7305093408,
-0.5272621512,
-0.443873316,
-0.0227432624,
-0.6179925203,
-0.0120052807,
0.0899568498,
0.34594661,
0.1867518872,
-0.1519844681,
0.5833557844,
1.0700019598,
-0.3550427258,
0.4350321293,
0.982001245,
-0.103414759,
0.0166571457,
0.628144443,
-0.0097728493,
0.2335111499,
0.5552909374,
0.1919649541,
-0.4754675031,
-0.9281867146,
-0.3423837721,
0.4758004248,
-0.8364042044,
-0.0613670237,
-0.7894512415,
-0.1895368993,
-0.2402152568,
0.1896538585,
-0.2148866057,
0.2859497666,
-0.4149479568,
-0.0079081384,
0.2876848578,
1.0147782564,
0.0673395917,
0.8419559002,
-0.889490068,
0.4091884792,
-0.1165687665,
0.3556508422,
0.2550861835,
-0.7867662907,
-0.4094573259,
0.3670837879,
-0.2037785351,
-0.9282109737,
0.3197028041,
0.0580914319,
0.6829727888,
0.8864300251,
-0.4471095204,
0.7074927092,
-0.384860009,
0.4331248999,
-0.1002901495,
-0.7322274446,
0.3492643535,
-0.4156638086,
0.2764298916,
0.2087136954,
0.6625592113,
-0.8052251339,
-0.273363024,
-0.2637826204,
-0.33696118,
0.6876893044,
-0.0053602229,
0.1282909065,
-0.0805211961,
0.4399645329,
0.1008383855,
0.2383415401,
-0.7490796447,
-0.0941008255,
0.3736835718,
0.1109106019,
-0.2168306708,
-0.5871961117,
0.1789535284,
0.1148308888,
0.5608351231,
-0.0707900152,
0.0609902032,
-0.0122139193,
-0.5179390311,
-0.2046577334,
0.281738013,
0.4849308431,
0.733178556,
0.1783705503,
0.0683246925,
0.0769385397,
-0.3374705613,
-0.1371349245,
-0.1172779277,
-0.0639127642,
0.2297145128,
0.9334706664,
0.8410221338,
0.309092015,
-0.5208236575,
0.5511552691,
0.0110993776,
-0.2307096869,
-0.1954529732,
0.0932359099,
0.4204113781,
0.3943004608,
0.5878574252,
-0.224805519,
0.1810526997,
-0.5921769738,
0.059673626,
0.5182788968,
0.0010098219,
-0.3654813468,
0.3069486916,
-0.0282395519,
-0.2061397582,
0.4623298645,
-0.1519891769,
-0.644298017,
0.6277920604,
0.6330364347,
0.502045095,
-0.3743058443,
0.3891363442,
0.0342879444,
0.5017908812,
-0.3803002238,
0.1763889194,
0.0062327376,
-1.0074480772,
-0.6737687588,
-0.6478530169,
-0.0949265584,
0.5887887478,
-0.1849036664,
0.209090814,
-0.1936228424,
0.1331781298,
0.3990768194,
-0.2175526023,
-0.7119435072,
-0.1006932706,
0.4397871792,
1.1540765762,
-0.9443811178,
0.3846375644,
0.5095236897,
-0.0381818227,
-0.877592504,
0.163995713,
0.1911223233,
-0.6614095569,
0.6162532568,
0.3565711379,
-0.1020613462,
-0.3882591724,
-0.8240851164,
-0.7678156495,
0.9123167396,
0.3242506385,
-0.8673638105,
0.2233893126,
0.1901106387,
0.6373941898,
-0.4703332484,
0.325407654,
0.5041077137,
0.6352501512,
0.1820703745,
-0.871771276,
-0.2295698375,
0.2174294442,
-0.128582865,
0.0906149,
-0.4204770327,
0.8189815283,
0.0564789623,
-0.2353921086,
-0.1569908261,
0.5905519724,
0.254204154,
0.5197982192,
0.6497080326,
0.2507693172,
0.6855620146,
0.1083976701,
1.0005574226,
-0.1615934819,
0.1493789554,
0.8448135853,
-0.1156865284,
0.720290482,
0.2134215087,
0.1010524705,
0.6546384692,
0.6955423951,
0.0639112592,
0.210383445,
0.2192791402,
-0.3672322929,
-0.460534066,
-0.2006675005,
-0.2497466505,
0.5610727072,
0.7012541294,
-0.7866114974,
-0.2480845451,
0.2308423966,
0.0751184151,
0.1288179606,
-0.5644030571,
0.5965130925,
0.0557718277,
-0.5030791759,
0.619599402,
0.2776316404,
0.8617678285,
-0.668050468,
-0.0697545186,
0.0686683282,
0.2226597518,
-0.4105050564,
-0.9409749508,
0.1937110275,
-0.0294830538,
-0.2224960327,
-0.0739096329,
1.1650838852,
-0.3916554749,
-0.3009564579,
0.3805599213,
0.6035864949,
0.1268340349,
-0.4063456059,
-0.2407064587,
0.480229497,
0.0248504709,
-0.2841011286,
0.0719238818,
0.8211411238,
-0.1542788148,
0.8820078969,
0.7319228053,
0.0908485726,
0.1234156117,
0.3428486586,
0.8988650441,
-0.2624942958,
-0.4645236731,
-1.0543659925,
0.1726467013,
-0.3401314616,
0.158040747,
1.0305682421,
0.4966345727,
0.8369852304,
-0.1858599782,
0.892077148,
0.2719690502,
0.6273075342,
-0.5608456731,
0.5041530728,
-0.5045211315,
0.5532051921,
-0.1798532754,
-1.0376596451,
-0.2467380762,
0.4308330715,
-0.5097736716,
0.0278574768,
0.4418389201,
0.6965113878,
-0.2704480588,
0.2863836586,
0.2464017868,
0.5229620337,
0.3563497961,
0.2684526742,
1.0322215557,
-0.010800506,
0.4629943967,
0.0531661771,
-0.0203969385,
-0.4124051929,
-0.7675133944,
-1.0496398211,
-0.1891607493,
0.1485727429,
-0.094764851,
0.244118914,
0.660395205,
0.7364959717,
-0.5929061174,
-0.0697459877,
-0.0819489434,
0.4534395337,
0.0352204815,
-0.2773123085,
0.1296228766,
-0.2154893279,
-0.6013941765,
0.6576107144,
0.2666375041,
-0.2196878046,
-0.4002841711,
-0.0643858165,
-0.4151128232,
0.1324742436,
0.8553829789,
0.1017060429,
-0.6594151855,
-0.309595108,
0.0040663248,
-0.0712756962,
-0.1965230852,
0.6983962059,
-0.5447517037,
0.1270872951,
0.4204857647,
0.6938465238,
0.2844085097,
0.1825224459,
0.2374355197,
-0.8338221908,
-0.0307417847,
0.1032520756,
0.294795692,
0.5306995511,
-0.487562418,
0.2175089568,
0.1928428262,
-0.474252075,
-0.6482089758,
0.1374044418,
-0.6360361576,
-0.436668098,
1.5018497705,
0.1652833223,
-0.0996074304,
-0.0543841571,
-0.1474430114,
0.2132059187,
-0.4787835777,
0.6903743744,
0.7159568071,
0.1082015038,
-0.2551931143,
-0.8274334669,
0.2055651098,
0.1279129386,
-0.6576879025,
-0.1003359333,
0.5775560737,
0.5313936472,
0.1628540158,
0.391266793,
0.1905890256,
0.2647689581,
-0.268140167,
-0.3143514395,
-0.1660438329,
-0.5672473907,
-0.3641703129,
0.0663487986,
-0.0322418362,
-0.1373725086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12689v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12689v1
|
Fair Text Classification with Wasserstein Independence
| 2023-11-21T15:51:06 | 2023-11-21T15:51:06 |
Thibaud Leteno, Antoine Gourru, Charlotte Laclau, Rémi Emonet, Christophe Gravier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Group fairness is a central research topic in text classification, where
reaching fair treatment between sensitive groups (e.g. women vs. men) remains
an open challenge. This paper presents a novel method for mitigating biases in
neural text classification, agnostic to the model architecture. Considering the
difficulty to distinguish fair from unfair information in a text encoder, we
take inspiration from adversarial training to induce Wasserstein independence
between representations learned to predict our target label and the ones
learned to predict some sensitive attribute. Our approach provides two
significant advantages. Firstly, it does not require annotations of sensitive
attributes in both testing and training data. This is more suitable for
real-life scenarios compared to existing methods that require annotations of
sensitive attributes at train time. Second, our approach exhibits a comparable
or better fairness-accuracy trade-off compared to existing methods.
|
[
-0.1386916041,
-0.4059247077,
0.0619212426,
0.2026378363,
0.0952525958,
-0.2133060992,
-0.2963599861,
-0.4209437966,
-0.1109217554,
0.1922149211,
-0.3072937131,
-0.3475847542,
-0.8021727204,
-0.0504699685,
-0.1467362493,
1.3714658022,
0.0853165537,
0.4718026519,
-0.1691045314,
-0.4668539464,
-0.1164322719,
-0.6431180239,
-0.687297821,
-0.6844100952,
0.534850657,
-0.0902572572,
0.4794325233,
0.6595683694,
0.5187343955,
0.4083118737,
-0.3315356672,
-0.1814437956,
-0.1387776136,
0.2198477834,
-0.3533914387,
-0.7135797739,
-0.4234571159,
0.5531487465,
0.3544491827,
0.5457573533,
-0.2949415743,
0.0314220302,
0.3322966695,
0.9454584122,
-1.0548330545,
-0.0088028954,
-0.7434440255,
0.7230203748,
-0.37965101,
0.0401697606,
-0.5780214071,
-0.3383479714,
0.0662794635,
-0.5698384047,
0.5681077838,
-0.0306943525,
0.7807754278,
0.4748997092,
-0.5832279325,
-0.0696157888,
-0.3117051423,
0.9039212465,
-0.4055829942,
0.2312841266,
0.4671542346,
0.5375594497,
0.1224952489,
-0.5408392549,
-0.5151205063,
0.2896706164,
-0.06313207,
0.1355495304,
-0.3913191259,
-0.047859598,
0.3673342466,
0.1571144015,
-0.2596771419,
0.2005261779,
-0.2120915651,
-0.5098212361,
0.5376151204,
-0.275005132,
0.1429785192,
-0.294085443,
-0.4990029037,
-0.0416395068,
-0.3838937581,
0.2678126395,
0.6577174067,
0.2670131624,
0.1028497592,
0.406722486,
-0.2060975879,
0.1379892081,
0.2016011924,
0.0190453585,
0.6156082749,
0.2273723781,
-0.1299705952,
0.4483538568,
0.9110233784,
0.3709527552,
0.392719835,
-0.4852049947,
-0.472257942,
0.4277141988,
0.1750400662,
-1.0276316404,
0.0064198147,
-0.1728400588,
-0.8980791569,
-0.5632603168,
-0.0207983349,
-0.871362865,
-0.7672661543,
-0.0015310734,
0.4332395792,
0.1461810768,
-0.176040411,
0.0330984145,
-0.4405007064,
-0.0134780342,
0.3478577733,
-1.0504714251,
0.3951109648,
0.5429370403,
0.6032184362,
-0.2447522134,
-0.0321305431,
-0.948695004,
-0.0660409182,
0.155878529,
0.5100402236,
-0.2932284474,
0.1679945737,
-0.1277970672,
-0.2449803203,
0.2085259557,
-0.4366427958,
0.5481770039,
-0.6068709493,
0.382047683,
-0.2380748689,
-0.4956122935,
-0.4787151217,
0.4788940549,
-0.8130151629,
0.2943807542,
0.0929445326,
-1.2614334822,
0.5279003978,
-0.595626235,
-0.3921477199,
-0.2106355727,
-0.5032228231,
-0.8121079206,
-0.0546371564,
0.3232323229,
0.324545145,
-0.2436098307,
0.3786779046,
-0.5004689097,
-0.2387439609,
0.6183139086,
-0.8102884293,
1.1588623524,
0.2859532833,
-0.7465754747,
0.0141904838,
-0.7371991873,
0.0754916891,
-0.1205019876,
-0.5176500082,
-0.3944681883,
0.0697977841,
0.0453594141,
0.1628976911,
0.0434022136,
-0.8500489593,
-0.2449232489,
-0.3593890965,
0.1844207644,
1.2246416807,
-0.4807637334,
0.8250313401,
-0.3191987574,
0.3688029051,
0.2020251453,
0.2233829647,
0.5515935421,
-0.433514297,
-0.7739909291,
-0.4086330235,
0.8498162031,
0.6654482484,
-0.6749531627,
0.5262125731,
-0.0824148655,
-0.1045924053,
-0.751778543,
-0.0342194811,
0.7060594559,
0.5638404489,
0.283325702,
-0.3099909723,
-0.3152229488,
-1.0337446928,
-0.4371609092,
0.0634711087,
-0.1002034545,
0.2409484535,
0.2826807499,
-0.0674365237,
0.8266202807,
-0.4044061303,
-0.5866550803,
-0.0695984885,
0.147892341,
0.0009110416,
0.6594338417,
0.5044723153,
-1.2903977633,
-0.3701769114,
-0.1231723726,
-0.8913473487,
-0.3228176236,
0.2729575634,
-0.3114043772,
0.1593070179,
0.4452071488,
-0.3452678919,
0.7519686818,
0.2171625346,
-0.592723906,
0.0927987695,
-0.0119501501,
0.302115649,
-0.6584855914,
0.0687961355,
-0.0422809012,
-0.3233485222,
-0.4901391566,
-0.1850633174,
0.1503065825,
0.2455580235,
-0.5837673545,
0.5207914114,
-0.0857755765,
0.1156144962,
-0.4907087684,
-0.1616242528,
0.2182977498,
0.6917732954,
-0.1333133131,
0.4047392905,
0.2828007042,
-0.547724545,
-0.0668402091,
0.443331778,
-0.0852250308,
0.6835154891,
-0.5381256342,
0.2720487118,
-0.4773805439,
0.1356890649,
-0.3626853526,
0.2626767159,
0.5936905146,
-0.7684233785,
0.1431802213,
-0.1667189896,
-0.2202625126,
0.084742412,
-0.3759048879,
0.6489099264,
0.3365603387,
-0.7892318368,
0.8388550878,
0.6052015424,
0.094530575,
-0.9254280329,
-0.9534369707,
-0.3344215155,
-0.4090216756,
-0.4815154374,
0.5595157743,
-0.1284658909,
-0.3635865748,
0.2116934955,
-0.0501462482,
-0.3571511209,
0.5193284154,
0.308881402,
0.1039985269,
0.1056759804,
0.2268605679,
0.2603466213,
-0.3995913565,
-0.1724708229,
-0.0822323635,
0.1173973083,
-0.1568302363,
-0.1679493785,
-0.3230334818,
0.6130174398,
0.0256296694,
-0.4703468978,
0.673821032,
0.714330554,
-0.6974172592,
-0.3818106949,
-0.359618783,
-0.0480979159,
-0.5401076674,
0.2647534609,
-0.0370588563,
-0.8542289138,
0.5303394794,
0.3966379464,
-0.0409188755,
0.2377868146,
0.349293679,
0.1596046686,
1.2355695963,
0.6787519455,
-0.109292984,
0.3778553307,
0.2471886426,
0.1190718785,
-0.6573431492,
-0.2154762,
-0.7620340586,
-0.7893496752,
-0.7367460132,
0.0480037257,
0.2255592942,
-0.0118997507,
-0.4154244363,
-0.3173691034,
-0.7139739394,
0.6305452585,
0.7959761024,
0.5825651288,
0.1586365998,
-0.0826099366,
0.1421859115,
-0.378205657,
-0.4403826594,
-0.2753970027,
1.1909155846,
0.2509000301,
0.7028045654,
0.2793401182,
0.629060328,
0.6836765409,
0.8003762364,
-0.5868374705,
0.3845259547,
-0.6644160748,
-0.7636363506,
0.0391980335,
-0.8672559261,
-0.8105013967,
0.5451651812,
-0.4248599708,
-0.6181008816,
0.2502247095,
0.2636148036,
-0.1844404638,
0.3363982737,
-0.7816545367,
0.7786272168,
-0.0746259168,
-0.2215916812,
0.1301591694,
-0.7008624673,
0.2327664793,
0.0109324036,
0.0817310289,
-0.1150689423,
0.1673167348,
1.1261274815,
-0.1387072355,
0.7228543162,
-0.4762871563,
0.4730217159,
-0.0671478361,
-0.0814409479,
0.3157626092,
-0.0825823396,
-0.336027801,
0.1958840787,
-0.586007297,
-0.3712446392,
-0.6447289586,
0.3357660472,
-0.604113698,
-0.4161311686,
-0.6862748861,
-0.5748296976,
-0.0301701743,
0.3427442908,
0.3978531063,
0.1550421268,
0.008739776,
0.2524743676,
0.8360847235,
-0.2393225878,
0.5646045208,
0.509513557,
-0.0052092429,
-0.7390881777,
0.5414565206,
0.0444410928,
-0.1006290838,
0.3966057003,
0.4872734845,
-0.2537791133,
-0.6080977917,
-0.1467376798,
-0.3619446456,
-0.8993618488,
-0.6005703807,
-0.7770067453,
-0.2297283113,
-0.4325664341,
-0.0965065211,
-0.3679549098,
-0.495185405,
-0.3490567803,
-0.1368350238,
0.0709325075,
0.3728699684,
-0.1041184291,
0.4271464944,
-0.5844010711,
0.2480452508,
0.407748431,
0.2928570807,
0.0208752286,
-0.3206048906,
-0.0409143344,
0.0168691967,
-0.6048521399,
-0.6888843179,
0.2587700188,
0.2341119498,
0.7626106739,
0.3934466541,
0.4571088552,
-0.0603101552,
-0.5847460032,
0.2935976982,
0.4906935692,
-1.2006323338,
0.3917099237,
0.0286962017,
-0.034387257,
0.7545307875,
0.214618355,
-0.3909163773,
-0.2690941691,
-0.5123122334,
-0.725731194,
0.7385573983,
0.3660899103,
-0.094781056,
0.1943557411,
0.2594147027,
0.3730306029,
0.4594851434,
-1.3049730062,
-0.1369057298,
-0.3374065757,
-0.5775794983,
0.1184083074,
0.1019630507,
-0.21237728,
-0.0984178931,
0.5011347532,
-0.1250816435,
0.1188489422,
0.2177779973,
-0.3421484828,
0.1377025396,
0.296536088,
0.2121050954,
0.0177078713,
-0.102920562,
0.6276814342,
-0.0209458601,
-0.5265613198,
0.4215968549,
0.337857455,
-0.5251864791,
-0.2392691374,
0.0721734092,
0.7232686877,
-0.3589961231,
-0.2958656847,
1.0335495472,
-0.4258843362,
-0.1849476993,
0.1978745162,
0.2364182174,
-0.3419962823,
0.7325019836,
0.1708167046,
0.6694635153,
0.5162099004,
0.0162067227,
0.4033329785,
0.3289091289,
-0.6363063455,
-0.1059329957,
0.8492873907,
0.351403296,
-0.4357892573,
0.5290369391,
-0.6350870132,
-0.9580445886,
0.5984132886,
0.3620866835,
1.086894989,
-0.1985414028,
0.1100606024,
-0.0783833116,
0.2875724435,
-0.0438691564,
-0.1663721651,
-0.0250003766,
-1.0007817745,
0.0529601015,
-0.5045045614,
-0.0649542361,
-0.1705090404,
-0.7391029,
0.1075188443,
-0.5712946653,
-0.3309175074,
0.0802932456,
-0.1689784527,
-0.6209266186,
0.28764534,
0.157859683,
0.7390334606,
-0.9246844053,
0.4865839183,
0.4277984202,
-0.1888296306,
-0.3405714631,
0.1914837062,
0.0658003613,
-0.3772549033,
0.642152369,
0.7485669851,
0.0459952354,
-0.2308700681,
-0.5307967663,
-0.0970000327,
0.7636370659,
0.6064100266,
-0.2208295166,
0.1849453747,
-0.0601673536,
0.2286512107,
-0.1753823757,
0.1978275478,
0.1778666675,
0.2735593915,
-0.4952029884,
-0.5567517281,
0.1760088354,
-0.5972850323,
-0.0499065332,
0.0605810434,
-0.6527605057,
0.9292072654,
0.0390924327,
-0.016968919,
-0.3138661087,
0.8421398997,
0.1132961437,
0.6728405356,
0.9736384749,
0.5802628994,
1.011829257,
-0.1801461577,
0.7629764676,
0.440215975,
0.3552492857,
0.9750187397,
-0.2600301504,
0.4097984433,
0.3540783226,
-0.0713453814,
0.0825986937,
0.5224450231,
0.0550964475,
0.9417690635,
0.4437779784,
-0.5019115806,
-0.209740296,
-0.2500847876,
-0.281344682,
0.7036549449,
-0.1182318106,
-0.3368795812,
-0.3011989892,
0.3951779604,
0.2232449949,
0.4104814827,
-0.2920370698,
0.5999619365,
0.0404622518,
-0.5660144687,
0.0546782576,
0.2320445031,
1.1664005518,
-0.4131008685,
0.0303768348,
-0.0998140499,
0.5951520205,
-0.1698350459,
-0.5800298452,
0.1467238367,
0.1586478651,
-0.7957090139,
-0.2347198874,
0.8106836081,
-0.4921863675,
-0.3172544539,
0.3484512866,
0.1122915223,
-0.3043618798,
-0.183626011,
-0.7695028186,
-0.1704878509,
0.2280604392,
-0.3098694384,
0.3141441643,
0.5817111135,
0.0330068469,
0.5424946547,
0.3658467531,
-0.0240523722,
0.0410391204,
0.1584929824,
0.5852374434,
-0.5653035641,
-0.8597963452,
-0.900716722,
0.4930861592,
-0.2358072996,
-0.3465087712,
0.3907413781,
0.3969869018,
0.5778416395,
0.1497636139,
0.7919338942,
0.00216304,
0.5132102966,
-0.6794582605,
1.2073172331,
-0.4458547533,
0.2701131105,
-0.1870326847,
-0.583693862,
-0.5602757931,
0.6800999045,
-0.0986757651,
0.1927853823,
0.5436216593,
0.7634264231,
-0.0021291552,
0.2450210452,
-0.0838568881,
-0.122226961,
0.6543400884,
0.7218890786,
0.8377174139,
-0.4058950245,
0.5030332804,
-0.2328584194,
-0.56297189,
0.1795261204,
-1.0848963261,
-0.9118234515,
-0.1686457992,
-0.369987011,
-0.5245689154,
0.1607125849,
0.8697506785,
0.6542240977,
-0.8175333738,
0.2981519997,
0.0091645187,
0.3759615123,
-0.0953549296,
-0.1668411195,
0.3284947276,
-0.2457727939,
-0.7168477774,
-0.1925319135,
-0.0687752962,
0.1358176917,
0.0678002834,
-0.1895275265,
-0.01321261,
-0.2522857487,
0.173885718,
-0.2103270739,
0.0449280441,
-0.2445051372,
-0.3609995842,
-0.3401797414,
0.1994111836,
0.7636238337,
-0.5934741497,
0.3261626065,
0.6003736854,
1.0595809221,
0.1420210749,
-0.177457124,
0.3651929498,
-0.9193304181,
0.4260813892,
0.5471007824,
0.3966192603,
0.5637797713,
-0.5841426253,
0.3510428965,
0.3901062906,
-0.6042141914,
-0.7755329609,
0.07237418,
-0.7894726992,
-0.288072437,
0.9147382975,
-0.3031854928,
-0.4462830424,
-0.0068565384,
-0.0515251979,
0.4794788361,
-0.4132269621,
1.0977685452,
0.5666788816,
0.2357763797,
0.2451179624,
-0.2419320941,
0.3808861077,
0.4915859401,
-0.8876948953,
-0.1097216308,
0.1519438773,
-0.0060610468,
0.0316855572,
0.707018435,
-0.2202348113,
0.439737767,
-0.1662635952,
0.3103863001,
-0.001721244,
-0.3271898031,
-0.2875040472,
0.2249113023,
-0.2059312761,
-0.6050549746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12664v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12664v2
|
The DURel Annotation Tool: Human and Computational Measurement of Semantic Proximity, Sense Clusters and Semantic Change
| 2023-11-21T15:14:54 | 2024-02-05T12:50:23 |
Dominik Schlechtweg, Shafqat Mumtaz Virk, Pauline Sander, Emma Sköldberg, Lukas Theuer Linke, Tuo Zhang, Nina Tahmasebi, Jonas Kuhn, Sabine Schulte im Walde
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present the DURel tool that implements the annotation of semantic
proximity between uses of words into an online, open source interface. The tool
supports standardized human annotation as well as computational annotation,
building on recent advances with Word-in-Context models. Annotator judgments
are clustered with automatic graph clustering techniques and visualized for
analysis. This allows to measure word senses with simple and intuitive
micro-task judgments between use pairs, requiring minimal preparation efforts.
The tool offers additional functionalities to compare the agreement between
annotators to guarantee the inter-subjectivity of the obtained judgments and to
calculate summary statistics giving insights into sense frequency
distributions, semantic variation or changes of senses over time.
|
[
-0.7992153168,
-0.5589802861,
0.6485292315,
0.2147691399,
-0.234472096,
-0.1461202949,
-0.2468759418,
-0.5947440267,
0.4377355576,
0.1619039327,
-0.4062053859,
-0.83346349,
-0.5233258605,
0.2727501988,
-0.4019013345,
0.550326407,
-0.1264323443,
-0.3463275433,
-0.4791624546,
-0.4788301885,
-0.6818271279,
-0.6320426464,
-0.3947896361,
-0.4511191249,
0.9205610752,
0.3937220275,
0.4446322918,
0.1031928211,
0.938119173,
0.4043157697,
-0.0690173879,
-0.2220813632,
-0.1716376245,
0.1028270945,
-0.4024084508,
-0.1453203261,
-0.4867395163,
0.1404296756,
0.6366248727,
0.9088306427,
0.1563548297,
0.3049649596,
-0.0997579619,
0.6274820566,
-0.7004313469,
0.0886956677,
-0.6071956754,
-0.0881548077,
-0.4038890302,
-0.1675812155,
0.0749264136,
-0.093807213,
0.054059539,
-0.875007987,
0.2914512455,
0.1370760947,
0.6742812991,
0.7040803432,
-0.2740732133,
0.1093664169,
-0.2430289388,
0.7766923904,
-0.1714148223,
0.5803418159,
0.5652315021,
0.6477364302,
-0.109137319,
-0.8232908249,
-0.7924757004,
-0.2379113436,
-0.519511044,
0.096790269,
-0.2497498095,
0.0060469867,
0.4316433966,
0.3652272522,
-0.2542618513,
-0.1877847165,
-0.3569638133,
-0.2598732114,
0.8362268806,
0.3086189926,
0.2305297405,
-0.0802932307,
-0.3770929277,
-0.2894036472,
-0.4190723896,
-0.4788301289,
0.1358565092,
0.0553247631,
-0.3180246055,
0.6331157684,
-0.353548795,
0.9125660062,
-0.2023669332,
0.2162908465,
0.6426824927,
-0.5269632936,
-0.2198400795,
0.127791971,
0.6239975691,
0.7422496676,
0.2523764074,
-0.0256616902,
0.0190143064,
0.4596560895,
0.081189692,
-0.4271813035,
-0.5084868073,
0.0101725254,
-0.2552838027,
-0.4955413043,
0.2079964578,
-0.6401775479,
-0.595795691,
-0.4090698361,
0.1940598488,
-0.3220498562,
-0.2470106632,
-0.1139759868,
-0.7419531941,
-0.1081577539,
0.3961075842,
-0.5250797272,
0.5451849699,
0.5276601911,
1.0524837971,
-0.5130076408,
-0.6431949735,
-0.4579148889,
0.1870753467,
-0.0236288495,
1.1167846918,
-0.5878870487,
-0.6303249598,
-0.3648250401,
-0.0559524745,
-0.0362680405,
-0.492723316,
0.3756673038,
-0.4286656082,
-0.0252301805,
-0.3295340538,
-0.5793169737,
-0.3495331705,
0.2402051389,
-0.8871149421,
1.2447402477,
0.5799499154,
-1.3227809668,
0.6243748665,
-1.1260603666,
-0.1696742475,
0.3634581864,
-0.1802111566,
0.1644976586,
0.2638526857,
-0.1078913435,
0.019123558,
-0.0108520342,
-0.2463560402,
-0.3705348969,
-0.3896679282,
0.6401725411,
0.1058529317,
0.6849214435,
0.030748006,
-0.0490262955,
0.522100687,
-0.7194314599,
-0.1013647914,
-0.0297136474,
-0.1811909974,
-0.9654171467,
-0.1080747023,
0.2761662602,
0.1286056936,
0.4246811867,
-0.7962061167,
0.0557107106,
-0.5067535043,
0.3381584883,
0.4150210917,
0.1033123881,
0.2630471289,
-0.2603803575,
0.2699962556,
0.0712890849,
0.1173165813,
0.1206549183,
-0.5117120147,
-0.6371804476,
-0.336666882,
0.5584938526,
0.3799695075,
0.0582099259,
0.6846213341,
-0.4958319664,
-0.4213228226,
-0.4139784276,
0.0373865366,
-0.0196848959,
0.4040692449,
0.394082576,
-0.6473923922,
-0.3969958127,
-0.7723564506,
-0.351534009,
-0.0730609074,
-0.1281521171,
0.0864957869,
0.7784481049,
-0.5745699406,
1.3406414986,
-0.7016434073,
-0.7061405778,
0.187868163,
0.2755319476,
-0.3172648847,
0.2596469522,
0.6065396667,
-0.9593382478,
-0.3768371344,
0.1738304645,
-0.5458251834,
-0.593609333,
0.5139223337,
-0.1172862425,
0.2889087796,
0.8152223825,
-0.09794835,
0.8522686362,
0.8041898608,
-0.5057996511,
0.4661516845,
0.0054024616,
0.2130837739,
-0.7866705656,
0.4230162501,
-0.3822776079,
-0.062472675,
-0.4611438513,
0.0274094436,
-0.2016246766,
0.2035519183,
-0.394192785,
1.071860671,
-0.1263655722,
-0.3330994248,
-0.2203721702,
0.7901015878,
0.0882028639,
0.0113275442,
0.0268242322,
0.6758865118,
0.0475253798,
-0.3776118159,
0.5999759436,
0.5049033761,
-0.3862574399,
0.8230809569,
-0.8892547488,
0.1842857748,
0.167836681,
-0.0141847022,
-1.2441911697,
-0.5335263014,
0.2796634138,
-0.636669457,
-0.4239577651,
0.1823613048,
-0.8364574313,
-0.3699110448,
-0.3336209655,
0.5806221366,
0.138274923,
-0.4410268068,
0.6049159169,
0.3375275135,
0.077370584,
0.141226247,
-1.0197951794,
-0.0404817127,
-0.3110918701,
-0.8795750737,
0.355563432,
-0.1261017025,
-1.0503944159,
0.1710217446,
0.1469896883,
-0.2593862116,
0.1865543276,
0.8284091353,
-0.0031368905,
0.29009974,
0.4694727659,
0.2105431408,
-0.5763022304,
-0.0918655694,
-0.0108794104,
0.3826709986,
-0.2699182928,
-0.6299381256,
-0.0959632322,
0.3080736101,
0.236615032,
-0.2806738019,
0.433896631,
0.6289331913,
-0.3608807921,
0.2218893319,
-0.694899261,
-0.2310311198,
-0.4377571344,
-0.0128141511,
-0.4724852741,
-1.0523639917,
0.4685278237,
-0.2068486065,
-0.1465767026,
0.5325702429,
0.3776272535,
0.0327193961,
0.6622279286,
0.5183053017,
0.2108632773,
0.4664777219,
0.0267304685,
-0.1390983164,
-1.0048960447,
0.0401889794,
-0.3417108059,
-0.629211843,
-0.2168311179,
-0.5511788726,
0.4873198867,
0.2055000663,
-0.2374408245,
0.2067678571,
-0.6058527231,
0.4821742475,
0.8522421718,
-0.2256405354,
0.5209251046,
0.2978327572,
-0.3420184851,
-0.3073953688,
-0.2499092221,
-0.2907213867,
0.5837249756,
0.0675138459,
0.2541664839,
0.0245676097,
0.6935113072,
0.4321427047,
0.505313158,
-0.7112509012,
0.7193952203,
0.0470031239,
-0.4589740336,
-0.3572461605,
-0.2233269662,
-0.9052332044,
0.2402472496,
-0.0325240679,
-1.0268315077,
0.0955548137,
0.2195083499,
-0.2599855363,
0.1814796925,
-0.5628865361,
1.0688419342,
-0.0614315048,
-0.1335680634,
-0.5095657706,
-0.6521486044,
-0.1898522675,
-0.20622693,
0.0305289179,
-0.4586961269,
-0.2472751588,
0.7408053875,
-0.4962896407,
0.8894697428,
-0.0419549383,
0.1041548476,
0.3006475866,
0.3601741195,
0.1734923124,
-0.4769316614,
-0.2124046683,
0.8176922202,
0.1823516935,
-0.0866128653,
-0.4464390874,
0.8492124677,
-0.4959637821,
-0.1398186684,
-0.6694844961,
-0.6985334754,
-0.0357844532,
0.3550923467,
0.1466948092,
0.2441833615,
-0.4776450396,
-0.2366257161,
-0.2957641184,
-0.1418202221,
0.1411201507,
0.5197119713,
-0.5181844831,
-0.5579816699,
0.6784776449,
0.0117473882,
0.1337216794,
0.3741274774,
0.5933329463,
-0.4425617754,
-0.1918687522,
-0.1321725547,
0.4102605879,
-0.8075444102,
0.0135423923,
-0.4206351638,
0.1874755323,
-0.2353430539,
-0.6369123459,
0.3449337184,
-0.5446133614,
0.0285579935,
-0.0846258625,
1.0595957041,
0.8850362301,
-0.3657277524,
0.4231404662,
-0.5903275609,
-0.023473084,
0.4155378342,
0.4573850632,
-0.3654979169,
-0.1975263357,
-0.0299306437,
-0.069773078,
-0.0186681598,
-0.757535398,
0.2396090925,
0.0384590551,
0.1546929181,
0.3037237525,
-0.0273371376,
0.6297906041,
0.0362643637,
0.8383980393,
0.3765792847,
-0.9603834152,
0.6193376184,
-0.4455662966,
0.5256743431,
0.921351254,
0.08735881,
-0.7718008757,
-0.1814681292,
-0.4480708539,
-0.6027184129,
0.474239856,
0.1428893507,
-0.5133419037,
-0.2288087159,
0.0157574639,
0.0354136974,
0.3102621436,
-0.0131385187,
-0.1952355206,
0.0032682749,
-0.2954011559,
-0.1466311514,
-0.0729147196,
-0.2950262129,
-0.5443543792,
0.156680733,
-0.2755301595,
0.1091817617,
0.3229222,
-0.192591995,
-0.0566082969,
0.1441358328,
0.4019127488,
0.7412791848,
-0.184849456,
0.3906795979,
0.7896197438,
-0.6115671396,
-0.1582619697,
0.2747301757,
-0.1097822636,
0.2095067054,
0.2957472801,
0.4309841394,
0.521499157,
-0.6329423189,
0.7488684058,
-0.054209847,
-0.1104321778,
-0.8911268115,
-0.1122487634,
0.0637523383,
0.0748881623,
-0.180247739,
-0.02124382,
0.2772856057,
0.0397086143,
0.1912319064,
0.0834071636,
-0.8057630658,
-0.3174004257,
0.5879669189,
0.284484297,
-0.2093284279,
0.4104076624,
-0.4438357949,
-0.4464652836,
0.3137052953,
0.1584872454,
0.8821351528,
-0.1311287284,
-0.0327971652,
0.3465007246,
-0.0494185463,
0.2664378881,
0.2589014173,
-0.3267206252,
-0.6808384061,
-0.162476033,
-0.668685019,
-0.1493854523,
-0.3215787411,
-0.4348590374,
0.3293475807,
-0.230231002,
-0.4713401794,
0.182813406,
0.0368493535,
-0.8542563319,
-0.0746263266,
-0.082439661,
0.9887995124,
-0.7183932662,
0.6122564077,
1.1022763252,
-0.5147609115,
-0.3050372005,
-0.2897689939,
0.3589709103,
-0.6108998656,
1.1563509703,
0.2755473554,
-0.5001280308,
0.0296465755,
-0.3387710452,
-0.6570981741,
1.1913076639,
0.0790164769,
-0.7118127942,
0.3806998432,
0.2389072478,
0.6073613167,
-0.0542661697,
0.2818858325,
0.802636385,
0.9091603756,
-0.2244761884,
-1.0906385183,
0.06255465,
-0.2173759341,
0.0076090214,
0.6792098284,
-0.4569512904,
0.672740519,
-0.0234607533,
-0.5537344813,
0.006962799,
0.3877287209,
0.1028389633,
0.7226396799,
0.9065546393,
0.9159783721,
0.6225643754,
-0.1029940024,
0.9875483513,
-0.4375998676,
0.3012009263,
1.4408750534,
-0.5028980374,
0.8730301261,
0.6179869175,
-0.2106582969,
0.7799754143,
0.0441741645,
-0.1329366863,
0.2266056985,
0.4809484482,
-0.6451963782,
-0.1652117819,
-0.4649754763,
-0.284955591,
0.3282423913,
0.6006324887,
-0.2878168523,
-0.2429641783,
-0.1209664419,
-0.0978962332,
0.2434750348,
-0.0867543146,
0.9538292289,
0.2530171871,
-0.4684729576,
0.19131051,
-0.1229409724,
0.5434638262,
-0.5277457237,
-0.1131031513,
0.1916697472,
0.3654190004,
-0.3670853972,
-1.0608308315,
0.5400941372,
-0.3141938746,
-0.0815331712,
0.2782053649,
1.1241008043,
-0.2181998044,
-0.5058913827,
0.9295196533,
0.4817937911,
0.4416114092,
-0.5052963495,
-0.4559471905,
0.5650399327,
-0.5125183463,
0.0993741155,
0.0053311829,
0.2739770412,
-0.2616098523,
0.3515253067,
0.5274657011,
0.1481424421,
0.1182229817,
0.4653869569,
0.7769196033,
-0.7815012932,
-0.3523534834,
-0.5355958343,
0.1621585786,
-0.5315368176,
-0.5695127845,
0.9876801968,
0.3190396428,
0.998458147,
0.1569834799,
1.0651254654,
-0.3269590735,
0.7213012576,
0.1804980487,
0.5009084344,
-0.6306378245,
-0.2974763513,
-0.3703500628,
-0.9585332274,
-0.6613117456,
0.7401556373,
-0.8385487795,
-0.1834443063,
0.8624830842,
0.8803166747,
-0.1316128969,
0.1061957106,
0.3712874651,
0.1382372826,
-0.1719524264,
0.2735643983,
0.8750231862,
-0.1583048999,
0.0977142751,
-0.3665078878,
-0.309538424,
-0.4279240966,
-0.8350746632,
-1.081154108,
-0.9043450356,
-0.3520330787,
-0.0785569027,
0.0284653455,
0.9706975818,
0.4249478877,
-0.7644404173,
-0.093072176,
-0.211069271,
-0.2583052516,
-0.3420024812,
-0.2608520687,
0.4480845034,
-0.1368779093,
-0.2826732993,
0.2703277767,
0.2951494157,
0.0105750002,
-0.3520563543,
-0.0016519987,
-0.0201791488,
-0.2258977741,
0.8411543369,
0.1309067607,
-0.7136493325,
-0.6400761008,
-0.3752750158,
0.1392014772,
-0.1605083495,
0.7282192707,
-0.9009125233,
0.5676649809,
0.9177904129,
0.0389816463,
0.3376241624,
0.3541417122,
0.2033013999,
-0.855506897,
0.3766257465,
-0.1475188434,
0.3517523706,
0.6046097875,
0.168571353,
0.9238525629,
0.4447036982,
-0.5353506804,
-0.6144328117,
0.3974637985,
-1.1938880682,
-0.0469955727,
1.1893670559,
0.1878370196,
-0.3388281763,
-0.4395684004,
-0.4527232945,
0.0719913021,
-0.4330222905,
0.662720263,
0.5478156209,
-0.2524991333,
0.4422170818,
-0.4339834452,
0.3128703833,
0.0686016083,
-0.7655441761,
-0.0965486765,
0.7269260287,
0.3405669332,
0.6756283045,
0.7321768403,
-0.1787416935,
0.1957333535,
0.279140383,
0.3838160038,
-0.2092184722,
-0.1746519208,
-0.3446747661,
-0.0618444122,
0.0884288624,
-0.2199024707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12649v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12649v1
|
MathGloss: Building mathematical glossaries from text
| 2023-11-21T14:49:00 | 2023-11-21T14:49:00 |
Lucy Horowitz, Valeria de Paiva
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
MathGloss is a project to create a knowledge graph (KG) for undergraduate
mathematics from text, automatically, using modern natural language processing
(NLP) tools and resources already available on the web. MathGloss is a linked
database of undergraduate concepts in mathematics. So far, it combines five
resources: (i) Wikidata, a collaboratively edited, multilingual knowledge graph
hosted by the Wikimedia Foundation, (ii) terms covered in mathematics courses
at the University of Chicago, (iii) the syllabus of the French undergraduate
mathematics curriculum which includes hyperlinks to the automated theorem
prover Lean 4, (iv) MuLiMa, a multilingual dictionary of mathematics curated by
mathematicians, and (v) the nLab, a wiki for category theory also curated by
mathematicians. MathGloss's goal is to bring together resources for learning
mathematics and to allow every mathematician to tailor their learning to their
own preferences. Moreover, by organizing different resources for learning
undergraduate mathematics alongside those for learning formal mathematics, we
hope to make it easier for mathematicians and formal tools (theorem provers,
computer algebra systems, etc) experts to "understand" each other and break
down some of the barriers to formal math.
|
[
-0.6390070915,
-0.7947382927,
0.1366255283,
-0.0749336034,
-0.1031926498,
0.4860998094,
0.1277562678,
-0.5201414824,
0.5932665467,
0.3553278446,
-0.5974402428,
-0.4967264831,
-0.4196854532,
0.0692465529,
-0.4848739207,
1.5343724489,
0.1013599783,
0.0996120051,
-0.6949616075,
-0.1130441725,
-0.007923482,
-0.3251511753,
-0.3435718119,
-0.495418787,
0.4206353128,
0.1291007996,
1.3898593187,
0.2922552228,
0.6164036989,
0.3066692054,
0.0271133855,
-0.0906141028,
-0.5445600152,
-0.2907757163,
-0.1351878643,
-0.5175600052,
-0.3585669696,
0.0056856447,
0.3159552813,
0.9853432178,
-0.5477745533,
0.0953683779,
-0.1203037053,
0.7594089508,
-0.5838663578,
0.3912113309,
-0.3639901578,
0.1811074615,
-0.6424913406,
0.1776282787,
0.0464989245,
-0.7128583789,
0.2784134448,
-1.2371590137,
0.0927454308,
-0.0839926526,
0.949428916,
-0.1881476045,
-0.1112497747,
-0.9491403699,
-0.2257990986,
0.4710096121,
-0.5108551383,
0.293371439,
0.5627522469,
0.5165250301,
0.0895063654,
-1.1206798553,
-0.29210338,
-0.0862475187,
-0.3364403844,
0.1878527552,
-0.2930093706,
0.063478671,
0.5111504793,
0.5814102888,
-0.788860321,
-0.4988712668,
-0.8009256721,
-0.4106014073,
0.4956126809,
-0.1058949083,
0.9172011614,
-0.2909806073,
0.1222027168,
0.0793047249,
-0.7388238907,
-0.1909962595,
0.412535727,
0.0693026036,
-0.155331105,
0.7352834344,
0.1114229485,
0.7524662614,
-0.319673717,
-0.513486743,
0.4869256318,
-0.2139439732,
-0.0672693849,
0.2985216081,
0.614792943,
0.0456017517,
0.5619567037,
-0.4704969823,
-0.1038236246,
0.1977431774,
0.1197211519,
-0.7098802328,
-0.7490187883,
-0.2600607872,
0.0018938396,
-0.1950286776,
0.1378393322,
-0.730396986,
-0.0599386618,
-0.5751259327,
0.4682864547,
-0.5140209794,
0.0137882382,
0.0430417359,
-0.2476100326,
-0.3473488688,
0.2639690638,
-0.9426516891,
0.494318068,
0.6905910373,
1.0804539919,
0.1024089083,
-0.2530616224,
-0.4751942456,
0.2035021782,
-0.1696878225,
0.5334849954,
-0.3478123546,
-0.6593664885,
0.3932450712,
-0.3967463076,
0.2520141006,
-0.4113033712,
0.5696437955,
-0.6616681218,
0.5272392631,
-0.0211133584,
-0.6270256042,
-0.3161400259,
0.0149416309,
-0.7727072835,
0.8583829403,
0.1901053488,
-0.6048352718,
0.0868958235,
-0.9309069514,
-0.4049055278,
0.5356938839,
-0.3516084552,
0.1526591182,
0.1970570982,
0.2723754346,
-0.210174948,
-0.4286649823,
0.3038131595,
-0.1613193452,
0.0405835733,
0.0555824153,
0.2128627747,
1.0792417526,
0.2679202259,
-0.00168895,
-0.107610248,
-0.5732606649,
0.1294049472,
0.0175331477,
-0.0702526197,
-0.7248157859,
0.0180806108,
0.0091601349,
0.1411330253,
0.5567459464,
-0.2687604725,
0.6072821021,
-0.7470880151,
0.2469143122,
0.7594482899,
-0.43024683,
0.3584159017,
-0.0994929746,
0.5860419869,
-0.354791522,
0.1581262499,
0.1454632282,
-0.690529108,
-0.7211034894,
0.0666620061,
0.3273159862,
0.4973081052,
-1.1249170303,
0.0552616194,
-0.482553035,
-0.5544284582,
-0.1302167773,
0.5446160436,
0.4065955877,
0.5075257421,
0.1845511794,
-0.107602559,
-0.2333402187,
-0.5575622916,
-0.1895193309,
-0.088647522,
-0.1062335074,
0.4041340053,
0.7132582068,
-0.2237927169,
1.123799324,
-1.1566765308,
-0.5226817131,
0.0721953809,
0.3825930059,
0.5063579679,
-0.0467644334,
0.8045755625,
-0.9406291842,
-0.6782695651,
0.1335039586,
-1.0594991446,
-0.3018659353,
0.342585355,
-0.3158246875,
-0.1912164688,
0.4561065137,
-0.4192337394,
0.3664705753,
0.531060636,
-0.5133553743,
0.6195828915,
-0.0152172539,
-0.2566440403,
-0.9938187003,
-0.0603948981,
-0.2887899578,
-0.0434487462,
-0.4821539819,
0.2677775323,
-0.3091111481,
-0.551697731,
-0.2093198448,
0.5932348967,
-0.2998322546,
-0.084268041,
-0.103855975,
0.6104138494,
-0.2064462751,
0.2088603526,
-0.5301741362,
1.0555824041,
1.0624598265,
-0.6853467822,
0.7172816992,
0.381087631,
-0.324100256,
0.6183856726,
-0.6150484681,
-0.2050518841,
0.0611588955,
-0.1922142655,
-0.5384316444,
-0.4335578084,
0.2359320968,
-0.5814869404,
-0.124646768,
-0.0644735843,
-0.524959147,
-0.3838897943,
-0.1521644294,
0.625292778,
0.3348074853,
-0.4807828069,
0.8573708534,
0.9079318047,
-0.4265742302,
-0.6172658801,
-0.4774294794,
0.2542287707,
0.0999778509,
-0.9108687639,
0.340331763,
-0.2937605977,
-0.5737368464,
0.3903980255,
0.0134631284,
-0.4035559893,
0.0005894577,
0.3494623005,
0.3190500736,
-0.0574827828,
0.5640796423,
-0.0682791397,
-0.1675862521,
0.1777487099,
-0.3490235806,
0.55569911,
-0.3495442271,
-0.3753885031,
0.0094041182,
0.0665782839,
0.4201987982,
0.0461165756,
0.3858252466,
0.5160524845,
-0.5628494024,
-0.076471746,
-0.169967562,
-0.152021125,
-0.475533098,
-0.0535655618,
-0.4082323611,
-1.0325497389,
0.57526052,
-0.0497519113,
0.4556658268,
0.6795879006,
0.2272107452,
0.0558907725,
0.6731991172,
0.5169295073,
-0.3367960751,
0.1749900281,
-0.2028696984,
0.2860758305,
-0.2638287544,
-0.2197390497,
-0.6060717106,
-0.0308104325,
-0.4999277592,
-0.202238977,
0.4485349953,
0.3610485494,
0.0512235798,
0.3007492125,
-0.294724077,
0.6429073215,
0.4777037799,
-0.2211441249,
0.4365563691,
0.5544292331,
-0.3779934943,
-0.2418976724,
-0.5113002658,
-0.2711179256,
1.2144534588,
-0.2244995534,
1.0026037693,
0.6867213249,
0.6037580371,
0.3748586774,
0.4130472243,
-0.8854267001,
0.5398331881,
-0.1433079988,
-0.7131210566,
-0.3201911747,
-0.6720453501,
-1.0666490793,
0.0200325269,
-0.2527370453,
-0.7086688876,
-0.4434378743,
0.0097633777,
0.0265457928,
0.1876291037,
-0.2917143404,
0.4851311147,
-0.1544745713,
-0.1519138217,
-0.3658011854,
-0.2536684573,
0.5441248417,
-0.1465625167,
0.7828201652,
-0.058564648,
0.2160270512,
0.86221838,
-0.8090475798,
0.5907453299,
0.1537091285,
-0.3789687455,
0.4463043213,
0.3640956879,
0.1209712476,
0.436507076,
0.1849724203,
0.4144098163,
0.005914961,
-0.2851690054,
-0.6685156822,
0.8468132019,
-0.9906253219,
-0.549284637,
-0.7526248693,
-0.6580521464,
-0.0105401278,
0.4861372709,
-0.0202701911,
0.7149507999,
-0.0047655953,
0.1632068008,
0.4002768099,
-0.0261827819,
0.3316025734,
0.1114921719,
-0.9543335438,
-0.751560688,
1.1443520784,
0.3596773744,
0.0977360383,
0.3671556413,
0.2961290479,
-0.3483044505,
-0.0207924545,
-0.3638031781,
0.5071857572,
-1.0957453251,
-0.0238658655,
-0.2335756719,
-0.4791350365,
-0.5741345882,
-0.4019998908,
0.1886513233,
-0.6160320044,
-0.1630249321,
0.0584738217,
0.5321785212,
0.6918308139,
-0.2994083166,
0.4040574729,
-0.7398295999,
0.4920876324,
0.6753312945,
0.1965364367,
-0.3571541011,
-0.2026314437,
-0.1387837827,
0.1094211638,
-0.2972736061,
-0.4879307151,
0.4275169075,
0.574331224,
0.4320136607,
0.660497129,
-0.21292907,
0.9410495162,
-0.6648662686,
0.6887729764,
0.7250269055,
-1.2298768759,
0.4875531197,
-0.2375443131,
0.3224043548,
0.361899972,
0.5553280115,
-0.5868176222,
-0.2293929011,
-0.6261641383,
-0.6293210387,
0.4973407984,
0.566790998,
0.2607842684,
0.1005587131,
0.3704063296,
-0.1772380471,
0.3697621822,
-0.9634693265,
-0.6405204535,
-0.2841420472,
-0.2792422175,
-0.1013650447,
-0.1158079505,
-0.7958628535,
-0.2314820737,
0.6321120858,
-0.3255590498,
-0.1293856055,
-0.2674370408,
-0.4026392698,
-0.0305966102,
-0.1435938925,
0.5680612326,
1.5678989887,
-0.0328840278,
0.2392880917,
-0.0105743669,
-1.0702787638,
-0.1963864267,
0.1967101842,
-0.3655655682,
0.4607184231,
0.3177691996,
0.6755738854,
0.3229075968,
-0.8628371358,
0.31422171,
0.0698732883,
-0.4313715398,
-0.5399274826,
0.1106184721,
0.1558969319,
-0.3032360971,
0.6530334353,
-0.2503479123,
0.203495726,
-0.5093539953,
0.4773504138,
0.4023005962,
-0.2217124552,
-0.2707945406,
0.4657273293,
0.1201080307,
-0.2816301882,
0.6517099142,
-0.2265198827,
-0.4049609005,
0.3310768902,
0.3821690977,
0.5191175938,
0.0830413774,
0.4945049882,
0.6552456021,
0.1466785222,
0.2589148283,
0.209096387,
0.0693487823,
-0.5211619735,
-0.3538931906,
-0.8598829508,
-0.3655789495,
-0.2956471443,
-0.5480468273,
0.5068814754,
-0.4638632238,
-0.1538319439,
0.1990928352,
-0.1362476796,
-0.2487583756,
0.0643766746,
0.1088158339,
0.7656148672,
-0.5563667417,
0.4454329014,
0.693977952,
-0.4111973345,
-0.4260766804,
-0.4024814069,
0.2600450218,
-1.0975145102,
0.9482247829,
-0.0192148946,
-0.2081998736,
0.2383575737,
-0.4328994453,
-1.1484135389,
0.9468314648,
0.3750788271,
-0.609478116,
-0.4339436591,
0.3969318569,
0.2521994114,
0.2147106379,
0.0054108854,
-0.0920161754,
0.2416982949,
0.2644788325,
-0.8331847787,
-0.3820196688,
-0.3016009927,
-0.2895609438,
0.6573453546,
-0.04211675,
0.9248982668,
-0.0087670637,
-0.4163269401,
-0.0680639446,
0.7029397488,
0.2622707784,
0.1328600347,
0.2868690491,
1.0971182585,
0.9796119332,
-0.5560024381,
0.8883653283,
-0.8088005781,
0.7075508833,
0.8761006594,
0.2378430814,
0.2422039211,
0.5370643735,
-0.3441511691,
0.7852540016,
0.4433456063,
-0.036597129,
0.2505611181,
0.4244222045,
-0.3916151822,
-0.1256383359,
-0.1941111833,
-0.7418589592,
0.1133245081,
0.5996757746,
-0.0271741971,
-0.7751626968,
0.0270961262,
0.1915056556,
-0.0120103071,
-0.6807355285,
0.5090196729,
0.1817371249,
-0.4238386452,
0.4836038351,
-0.2465297282,
0.3677427769,
-1.0431028605,
-0.0198831279,
-0.0576484092,
-0.0144359302,
-0.3648026884,
-0.7992055416,
0.2116152793,
-0.0768778771,
0.1461876631,
0.0691698417,
0.3953151405,
-0.2675235569,
-0.9540581107,
0.1578125358,
0.6512485147,
0.2695065141,
0.4100806117,
-0.9611654282,
-0.2894376814,
-0.2613725364,
0.1110249013,
0.4146487713,
0.5285838842,
0.0332581028,
0.8267747164,
1.0103793144,
0.0645640343,
0.1410887837,
0.3149724901,
1.001681447,
-0.4584425986,
-0.490978241,
-0.7792136669,
0.0987041295,
-0.1598560214,
-0.4633790553,
1.1014727354,
0.8752291799,
0.9442106485,
-0.1801667958,
0.7017195225,
-0.3349985182,
-0.0602563396,
-0.5885080695,
0.7806423306,
-0.76476264,
-0.149900496,
-0.3946160972,
-0.9040801525,
-0.6622135043,
0.8466313481,
-0.0791434646,
-0.2314962,
0.6796016693,
0.53328228,
-0.0677103251,
-0.1214972138,
0.3690045178,
-0.0896864012,
0.3772468269,
0.4027913511,
0.456173569,
-0.235804528,
0.8775832653,
-0.3605204225,
-0.1009708419,
-0.1112809554,
-0.5922252536,
-0.9483687282,
-0.4928324223,
-0.4212891161,
-0.4789522588,
-0.1082034409,
0.5359882712,
0.271327734,
-0.6200064421,
-0.6514855027,
-0.4742447138,
0.3996549845,
0.0886704698,
-0.301948905,
0.543458879,
-0.6044090986,
-0.8036574125,
-0.1127948463,
0.5219864249,
0.0714481845,
-0.3655866086,
-0.1345599592,
-0.1162283495,
-0.1213309541,
0.6446336508,
0.4505980313,
-0.6626040339,
0.0909084901,
0.0852789432,
-0.194949612,
-0.0466734655,
0.7513785362,
-0.5272129774,
0.7317923307,
0.5285599232,
0.5017837882,
0.2782588601,
-0.373500526,
0.386921972,
-0.3851059973,
0.1934560984,
0.1671610773,
0.5220270157,
0.0023061123,
0.0114147123,
0.7857630253,
0.6524883509,
-0.2858860791,
-0.7623599768,
0.2441619784,
-0.7656078339,
-0.3281434476,
0.7702113986,
-0.0854866728,
-0.2008040696,
-0.0488931201,
-0.2551922798,
-0.1690285206,
-0.2654482424,
1.0429136753,
1.0953770876,
-0.0541757345,
0.0709317848,
-0.8141847253,
0.7131968141,
0.0902914628,
-1.1310472488,
-0.3519060314,
0.6152557731,
-0.0068231458,
0.852886498,
0.2756409347,
-0.1518452168,
0.4247401059,
-0.173083663,
0.1071830392,
0.0780869424,
-0.2273328453,
0.114838399,
0.5186526775,
-0.3005201817,
0.4303660989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12574v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12574v1
|
IMGTB: A Framework for Machine-Generated Text Detection Benchmarking
| 2023-11-21T12:40:01 | 2023-11-21T12:40:01 |
Michal Spiegel, Dominik Macko
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the era of large language models generating high quality texts, it is a
necessity to develop methods for detection of machine-generated text to avoid
harmful use or simply due to annotation purposes. It is, however, also
important to properly evaluate and compare such developed methods. Recently, a
few benchmarks have been proposed for this purpose; however, integration of
newest detection methods is rather challenging, since new methods appear each
month and provide slightly different evaluation pipelines. In this paper, we
present the IMGTB framework, which simplifies the benchmarking of
machine-generated text detection methods by easy integration of custom (new)
methods and evaluation datasets. Its configurability and flexibility makes
research and development of new detection methods easier, especially their
comparison to the existing state-of-the-art detectors. The default set of
analyses, metrics and visualizations offered by the tool follows the
established practices of machine-generated text detection benchmarking found in
state-of-the-art literature.
|
[
-0.7970932722,
-0.8946629763,
0.3217418492,
0.1128140539,
-0.475779146,
0.1073194742,
-0.0846290961,
-0.5242472291,
0.0582610443,
0.4506981075,
-0.4787502289,
-0.8618756533,
-0.6970925331,
0.408621788,
-0.4725923538,
0.8328360319,
-0.1662950218,
-0.2585792243,
-0.0955234095,
-0.1445964724,
-0.3079436123,
-0.5514211059,
-0.4450555444,
-0.3349634111,
0.2201937884,
0.2651408613,
0.3229405582,
0.6870712638,
0.8492083549,
0.3244673312,
0.0157698803,
0.3872139752,
-0.138776809,
0.3133395612,
0.0420250483,
-0.0671581998,
-0.1094015166,
-0.0428172536,
0.6116082072,
-0.0524673648,
0.1048089415,
0.2664780617,
-0.0083877109,
0.2065121233,
-0.8733490705,
-0.0620173812,
-0.565798223,
0.0305734109,
-0.4709908068,
-0.6323776841,
-0.5445450544,
-0.3508529663,
-0.1702542305,
-0.007499096,
0.146337539,
0.0935173556,
0.620896399,
0.16967085,
-0.4620006084,
-0.6183453798,
-0.196478501,
0.4982793629,
-0.7700497508,
0.2796250284,
-0.1464996785,
0.645277679,
-0.1740354151,
-0.7103415132,
-0.6049708128,
-0.33492136,
-0.3452174962,
-0.0915464908,
-0.4605137408,
-0.0799198151,
0.1757914722,
0.2221256644,
-0.7793906927,
0.2836223543,
0.1995563209,
-0.3573443294,
0.2684592605,
0.1104023457,
0.3042529523,
-0.4378931224,
-0.5049236417,
-0.0959621519,
-0.4409861565,
-0.2538703382,
0.6295267344,
0.1328386366,
0.0581455454,
0.297024399,
-0.4277464449,
0.6417937875,
-0.2920125425,
-0.0266235769,
0.5030787587,
-0.2692007422,
-0.2422946543,
-0.0286698435,
1.1000794172,
0.302698195,
0.3999462128,
-0.1200540066,
-0.3692543209,
-0.0074690534,
0.0933708325,
-1.2134039402,
-0.1800840646,
-0.0384678766,
-0.7558509111,
-0.605327785,
0.0675103441,
-0.7012495399,
-0.3968074024,
-0.1407823861,
0.3479035199,
-0.3049368262,
-0.2799007893,
-0.0678441897,
-0.269741863,
-0.0663867444,
0.2191977352,
-0.7620338798,
0.1024114043,
0.6661335826,
0.7560389638,
-0.4398095906,
-0.0863876715,
-0.8203756213,
0.0668005347,
0.0101096779,
1.2090425491,
-0.6614846587,
-0.3768090308,
0.0582515225,
-0.0772823468,
0.2502081692,
-0.5830683112,
0.8097693324,
-0.2000713199,
0.3323018849,
-0.0778005123,
-0.5739650726,
-0.146198079,
0.6090550423,
-0.4840262234,
1.3201533556,
0.1712391675,
-0.9362196326,
0.6271839142,
-0.6034083962,
-0.4026665092,
0.3439464569,
-0.1682435721,
-0.6975799203,
-0.0357376821,
0.3965676129,
0.6469990015,
-0.5559870601,
0.4392456412,
-0.4157783687,
-0.6478924751,
0.1781346947,
-0.6413650513,
0.6850953698,
0.5027827024,
-0.3737645149,
0.1850176901,
-0.7633646727,
0.5058591962,
-0.2028493732,
-0.4663459361,
-0.2762868106,
-0.269454062,
0.6106119156,
0.0823475122,
0.2045681626,
-0.5069510341,
0.0967620611,
0.0266471896,
0.2870810032,
0.5676860809,
0.1471252441,
-0.0062447018,
-0.037053261,
0.604480207,
-0.0375042744,
-0.0060528391,
-0.6393607259,
-0.3096506298,
-0.4864596426,
-0.547956109,
0.4604153037,
0.5565233231,
-0.6420687437,
0.6619147062,
-0.1312766969,
-0.7300620079,
-0.3010550141,
0.1557489485,
0.5519599319,
0.2411372662,
0.1782449484,
-0.2219801843,
-0.7510988116,
-0.9295822382,
-0.6317920089,
-0.2546118498,
-0.1587875932,
0.0812731832,
0.6639724374,
-0.3878870308,
0.7764146924,
-0.3735240102,
-0.1711567938,
-0.2856253088,
0.6276483536,
0.0773510262,
0.6964336038,
0.8742625117,
-0.6862567663,
-0.6372445822,
0.1471805423,
-0.9730089307,
-0.7366535068,
-0.1102189273,
-0.2692763507,
-0.0960636064,
0.8702429533,
-0.3010408878,
0.3649300039,
0.5364102721,
-0.2867200673,
0.7199441195,
-0.0187994968,
0.5324801803,
-1.0114670992,
0.1379076242,
0.1694509983,
-0.4192869067,
-0.3043112755,
0.1499560177,
0.3515451849,
0.050013952,
-0.2572449744,
0.7370342612,
-0.3089038432,
0.1323340088,
-0.570302248,
0.3077791631,
0.0330935121,
0.2309122533,
-0.4702467322,
0.7798249125,
0.1001380011,
-0.444714278,
0.3480446935,
-0.0031454435,
-0.4687389433,
0.8594962358,
-0.5447652936,
-0.0297896825,
-0.0756233782,
0.0084639294,
-1.0524212122,
0.034387406,
0.4168974459,
-0.6151874661,
0.2450490892,
-0.2585145533,
-0.9544397593,
-0.2999768257,
-0.366849035,
0.0445262864,
0.3053629696,
-0.7109020352,
0.4834001362,
0.3117007911,
0.0897223949,
-0.5674144626,
-0.7591302991,
0.4141084254,
-0.293843329,
-0.6109046936,
0.4385293424,
-0.0465222932,
-0.1446111053,
0.1260540485,
0.0353739001,
0.0134603912,
0.2944186628,
-0.0967761651,
-0.0383038856,
-0.3131869733,
0.2128699869,
0.1901141703,
-0.5833659768,
-0.1299300641,
-0.2476337403,
0.4873184562,
0.0534900501,
-0.5228668451,
-0.4702218175,
0.3139653802,
0.4638140202,
-0.4576736987,
0.4276208282,
1.0846997499,
-0.4176788032,
-0.2972999215,
-0.5917435884,
-0.0290268175,
-0.5255255699,
0.2759000659,
-0.4462268353,
-0.7343521118,
0.1265207529,
-0.1921296865,
0.0408301763,
0.1926038563,
0.7138699293,
-0.037711937,
1.0043052435,
0.7064345479,
0.1004521176,
0.6936433911,
0.3463256359,
0.2828479707,
-0.5785025358,
-0.0063961218,
-0.780784905,
-0.141836524,
-0.9250923991,
-0.207230106,
0.1037931815,
-0.1493462026,
-0.2382175922,
0.4547332227,
-0.7286112905,
0.6874235272,
0.7347278595,
-0.0395609215,
0.474642545,
-0.18690072,
-0.0387729034,
-0.0526154637,
-0.2306296527,
-0.9071833491,
1.1294442415,
0.0650295243,
0.7468388677,
0.0033944061,
0.7302837372,
0.7061105371,
0.8671116829,
-0.5392863154,
0.5057162642,
-0.3213336766,
-0.5968191028,
0.167273134,
-0.3408279419,
-0.5989732742,
0.7582691908,
-0.4561768174,
-0.8679362535,
-0.1104828566,
0.2094550878,
0.3109012544,
0.3424929976,
-0.9853506088,
1.0740404129,
-0.0717314258,
-0.2829346657,
0.1088107377,
-0.1139203832,
0.3221325576,
0.0813983306,
-0.0333287902,
-0.3645235598,
0.2278182358,
0.6314054132,
-0.2244691104,
0.4357432723,
-0.3239484131,
0.0812709555,
0.4283278286,
0.0344193168,
0.7294592857,
0.0605546646,
-0.1382057518,
-0.1226745918,
-0.0556644611,
-0.1857766956,
-0.2604913712,
0.6169726253,
-0.0023019048,
-0.3259050846,
-0.3919343352,
-0.4320337176,
-0.0395027883,
0.600312233,
0.4517638385,
0.435301125,
-0.4465761185,
0.4164702892,
0.5682330132,
-0.2891062796,
0.468367517,
0.3767507374,
-0.3947720528,
-0.4407336414,
0.5400126576,
-0.3062365949,
-0.1614904702,
0.6254964471,
0.0979888067,
-0.3554036617,
-0.8269804716,
-0.5239237547,
-0.1892033368,
-0.9633342028,
-0.4308004379,
-0.8415619135,
0.0854572579,
-0.1872681528,
-0.1912262291,
0.0952963457,
0.0422676019,
-0.0417245701,
-0.0539500378,
0.2129584998,
0.2780163884,
0.2408463061,
0.7641516924,
-0.6713604331,
0.2851108015,
-0.1634009182,
0.3750137687,
-0.1161577329,
-0.1164635271,
-0.2484355718,
-0.327732116,
-0.4333754182,
-0.7066369653,
0.3010962605,
-0.2656459808,
0.640648663,
0.4662900567,
-0.0542782731,
0.3136679828,
-0.4167718291,
0.2071532756,
0.0658835173,
-1.2106208801,
0.35401088,
-0.3939876556,
0.4865441918,
0.6405311227,
-0.0568246655,
-0.6525217295,
-0.4979467988,
-0.1442230493,
-0.4223109186,
0.3253591359,
0.3033082187,
0.0139814401,
0.0645182505,
0.148900032,
0.2562883496,
0.3911210597,
-0.843527019,
-0.0776133537,
0.0913979262,
-0.5914877653,
0.0660626888,
-0.2262611538,
0.1451742649,
0.2463910133,
0.5742247701,
-0.2573835254,
0.3070669174,
-0.2742910981,
-0.4109798968,
0.1864399612,
0.2411132008,
0.0759564489,
0.2839724422,
-0.1959311217,
0.2415078729,
-0.0040380997,
-0.5542556047,
0.1429469883,
0.2381368428,
-0.2904455364,
0.3594743907,
0.507156074,
0.5582484603,
0.0646992847,
-0.8458419442,
0.5076872706,
-0.0233966298,
-0.1815009862,
0.0367514901,
0.2177762538,
-0.1250111908,
0.2817232013,
0.2404986471,
0.05201618,
0.4792328477,
-0.2687441707,
0.5502409339,
0.616679728,
-0.3734395504,
0.008363788,
0.6701741219,
0.2803944647,
-0.3922498226,
0.2593281269,
-0.542945683,
-0.6730304956,
0.6646059752,
0.4928594232,
1.1114938259,
0.0503987595,
0.2870385349,
0.346147567,
0.7596567869,
0.3041864038,
0.2898488343,
-0.0890264437,
-0.4942625463,
-0.2264389545,
-0.4973061979,
-0.5069881678,
0.0167633351,
-0.3505702615,
0.811314106,
-0.2559383512,
-0.2364530265,
0.2232162207,
-0.105594106,
-0.6150488853,
0.2971904576,
0.2441283911,
1.1350642443,
-0.7245641351,
0.7033833861,
0.4711131752,
-0.1215782687,
0.0498722978,
0.2103045732,
0.2343633473,
-0.7304387689,
0.3273191452,
0.7855864763,
-0.3050199449,
-0.0043083462,
-0.5151615143,
-0.5425899625,
0.8720895648,
0.2260513306,
-0.2777567506,
0.2767521739,
-0.0849194601,
0.6389698386,
-0.4324553311,
0.5008046627,
0.4736832082,
0.7943464518,
-0.26333794,
-0.4745484889,
0.3429210782,
-0.4268096089,
-0.1176930442,
0.6688944697,
-0.3336734772,
0.6819244027,
0.1136541292,
-0.2565793097,
0.0902644917,
0.4055974185,
0.1219618469,
0.558706224,
0.344466418,
0.5026683211,
0.6277827024,
-0.4692600369,
0.6482246518,
-0.0367551707,
0.3611183465,
1.0059238672,
-0.0422408544,
0.5391090512,
0.3028734326,
-0.0654173121,
0.5153074861,
0.5804379582,
-0.5172999501,
0.4346323609,
0.5267726779,
-0.3098383546,
-0.2227410525,
-0.0349868424,
-0.2957878709,
0.4340542257,
0.2318600863,
-0.4863288999,
-0.4832864702,
0.0541522428,
0.1552953422,
0.1566602141,
0.0343870036,
0.5308092237,
-0.3168760836,
-0.5760198832,
0.4421705306,
0.2243997008,
1.1626390219,
-0.6661840081,
0.0958482847,
0.0381028168,
0.2907245159,
-0.2117752284,
-0.7706660628,
0.126972571,
0.3006826341,
0.0988024622,
-0.1189233139,
0.8355870843,
-0.2498542964,
-0.1755298078,
0.2085893154,
0.611284256,
0.0390870385,
-0.2215955257,
-0.577196002,
0.2253686339,
0.0277384184,
-0.1842551678,
0.0948577747,
0.6686961055,
-0.1357052624,
0.6126779318,
0.6913862228,
-0.4719336927,
0.0195980649,
-0.0419210792,
0.5988491774,
-0.6817750931,
-0.6465915442,
-1.076405406,
0.4696277976,
-0.3532718122,
-0.3950516284,
0.684673965,
0.6627781987,
0.7501621246,
-0.0412397869,
1.1061667204,
-0.2338151187,
0.2987812459,
-0.6195715666,
0.7434455752,
-0.5807885528,
0.3458561897,
-0.5175860524,
-0.9868186116,
-0.4220315516,
0.3470838964,
-0.0665949583,
0.0579713508,
0.8508808017,
0.633707583,
-0.1393860579,
0.0426600017,
0.1201058999,
-0.2191087306,
0.8150066733,
0.2396574765,
0.7182141542,
-0.4163872302,
0.7514691949,
0.0406087004,
-0.2593336701,
-0.5656915307,
-1.3718835115,
-1.1002908945,
-0.4316770732,
-0.3807418644,
-0.0959001109,
-0.0174390431,
0.7198042274,
0.5833136439,
-0.797514081,
-0.013897175,
-0.0675037876,
0.1411003917,
-0.0704972446,
-0.2294255048,
0.2705309689,
-0.3525965214,
-0.9763408303,
0.0177699514,
0.397839278,
0.3737239242,
-0.1675826758,
0.3476749063,
-0.1424212605,
-0.0650474355,
0.5807255507,
0.0436265171,
-0.3221161664,
-0.2739613354,
-0.180192709,
-0.298948139,
0.1038895845,
0.8522510529,
-0.8021275401,
0.6262013316,
0.8310211301,
0.7464718223,
0.525018692,
-0.1251357347,
0.3753049076,
-0.7814487219,
0.2388786077,
0.0217424575,
0.3898570836,
0.3716314435,
-0.2067693025,
0.6864077449,
0.1100712493,
-0.3035986722,
-1.3022586107,
0.1651195139,
-0.6176254153,
-0.2132565677,
0.7821403146,
-0.0831961483,
0.1421878785,
-0.0423890576,
-0.368064642,
0.1639780849,
-0.3517632484,
0.5593567491,
0.9023910761,
0.0448954515,
0.0315241888,
-0.5139337182,
0.3586716056,
0.052366253,
-1.351002574,
-0.0154979257,
0.3750087321,
0.1718016416,
-0.1714256108,
0.5324839354,
-0.1240019277,
0.1361517161,
0.1115487218,
0.1760310382,
-0.1650564969,
-0.1027121097,
0.0256676394,
0.165008083,
-0.1777224243,
-0.2737485766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12538v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12538v2
|
In-Context Learning Functions with Varying Number of Minima
| 2023-11-21T11:33:03 | 2023-11-22T08:44:34 |
David Oniani, Yanshan Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have proven effective at In-Context Learning
(ICL), an ability that allows them to create predictors from labeled examples.
Few studies have explored the interplay between ICL and specific properties of
functions it attempts to approximate. In our study, we use a formal framework
to explore ICL and propose a new task of approximating functions with varying
number of minima. We implement a method that allows for producing functions
with given inputs as minima. We find that increasing the number of minima
degrades ICL performance. At the same time, our evaluation shows that ICL
outperforms 2-layer Neural Network (2NN) model. Furthermore, ICL learns faster
than 2NN in all settings. We validate the findings through a set of few-shot
experiments across various hyperparameter configurations.
|
[
-0.4894295931,
-0.8273569942,
0.6267186999,
0.179014951,
-0.2522085309,
-0.1887819022,
-0.4076678455,
-0.6352467537,
-0.4435661137,
0.1221493408,
-0.3063495159,
-0.0935501605,
-0.5822814703,
0.1716712862,
-0.3250703216,
0.7816622257,
0.3034321666,
0.1573350281,
-0.3460600674,
-0.1311163902,
-0.0633465052,
-0.3562390208,
-0.7525990605,
-0.6073027849,
0.5718923807,
0.6986581087,
0.4753999114,
0.6838667989,
0.5115651488,
0.2075288445,
-0.2975204587,
0.1920362562,
-0.5133583546,
-0.1993734092,
0.196759671,
-0.5351755023,
-0.0560839362,
-0.2678664327,
1.0275666714,
0.8693200946,
0.0517734699,
0.3036721647,
0.5326648355,
0.5069015622,
-0.4858448207,
0.2104828507,
-0.7891996503,
0.0258409902,
-0.0492614098,
-0.1095738634,
-0.6841940284,
-0.0444998182,
0.3385277987,
-0.4570321441,
-0.2985844016,
-0.0954732299,
0.4754417241,
0.3416316807,
-0.3413498998,
-0.3268128335,
-0.6345344186,
0.9317500591,
-0.9541487098,
0.3118195534,
0.4925377667,
0.4018784463,
-0.1711209565,
-0.8539768457,
-0.3901655972,
-0.4937064052,
-0.126193285,
-0.3201966286,
0.1575477719,
-0.0849054083,
0.6839256883,
-0.2277310342,
-0.0253949296,
0.3020000756,
-0.3449419141,
0.1810869575,
0.407720089,
0.3222683072,
0.0228497908,
0.1173887327,
-0.4488056004,
-0.0816631019,
-1.0622071028,
0.3643701971,
-0.037752755,
0.4695117176,
-0.1279124916,
0.1017279178,
-0.091821298,
0.7472368479,
0.14209342,
-0.6475037336,
0.0036135437,
-0.085338451,
-0.3483511806,
-0.1364210993,
0.2512498796,
0.1360384226,
-0.0349006876,
0.0440729819,
-0.1834308654,
-0.4676869214,
-0.2694724202,
-0.9010843039,
-0.0024807209,
-0.168188706,
-0.2623454332,
-0.199807778,
-0.1241715476,
-0.4572686255,
-0.2317993045,
-0.4456044734,
0.5339268446,
-0.4483824372,
0.4148479998,
-0.1929504424,
0.255582422,
0.3611969054,
0.2898603678,
-0.7292490602,
0.8098804355,
0.4693276882,
0.8558118939,
-0.0465370342,
-0.4054389596,
-0.7638005614,
0.1188989431,
-0.3034148812,
0.3290838897,
-0.6876317859,
-0.2779576182,
-0.1121730208,
-0.5138385892,
0.0165969171,
-0.7550942898,
0.0109194051,
-0.5285118222,
-0.099697873,
-0.2685285211,
-0.6253157854,
0.0305837002,
0.0011203995,
-0.5882866383,
0.9557008743,
0.0698600337,
-0.5054210424,
0.4788550138,
-0.8012540936,
-0.5749971867,
0.0695337802,
-0.0918586254,
-0.4200608134,
0.2597797811,
0.022490453,
0.4726607502,
-0.3357217908,
-0.0086735794,
-0.4236061275,
-0.6725922823,
0.4854672849,
-0.3391995132,
0.7708598375,
0.173757568,
-0.3911327124,
-0.0574827828,
-0.5983371735,
0.1629851907,
-0.2148170471,
-0.7272897363,
-0.3199754655,
-0.0554920211,
0.0078891031,
0.4659436941,
0.0839575902,
-0.3221069276,
-0.0243579596,
-0.6137080193,
0.5325740576,
0.5770494938,
-0.023489831,
0.6479836702,
-0.3265879154,
0.3423218727,
0.0067181559,
0.0697668269,
-0.025356736,
-0.2706107795,
-0.8142551184,
-0.3947005868,
0.4725000858,
0.3020344079,
-0.7299817801,
0.147031337,
0.0019334818,
-0.2994219959,
-0.1501558423,
0.4285061657,
0.7057412863,
0.7039642334,
0.3991411328,
0.0818664059,
-0.3270992637,
-0.8304508924,
-0.1037137434,
-0.1059960425,
-0.0596968755,
0.3922039866,
0.5003567934,
0.0460072793,
0.8300421834,
-0.2176137269,
-0.3135224283,
-0.2894939184,
-0.1014975086,
0.0815731511,
0.2044418305,
0.7209681869,
-0.5020285845,
-0.8889408708,
-0.0010460513,
-0.4784860909,
-0.0355283804,
0.0220865402,
0.3442086279,
0.0425311811,
0.7821909785,
-0.2431643903,
0.3960019946,
0.2167207599,
0.0341390856,
0.3158047199,
-0.2891493142,
-0.4362252057,
-0.7600921392,
-0.209581688,
0.274210602,
-0.3981207907,
-0.7810130715,
0.2732888758,
0.2208617777,
0.02201695,
-1.0084449053,
0.8473839164,
-0.4387722313,
-0.1014962792,
-0.4206773639,
0.0607181638,
-0.2915418744,
0.4392364621,
-0.2929694951,
0.6832962036,
0.7965985537,
-0.7281481624,
-0.1110540405,
-0.127189517,
-0.6284177899,
0.212307781,
-0.4990204871,
0.0628953874,
-0.0881795436,
0.2978085279,
-0.7992459536,
-0.211336568,
0.0445837155,
0.0729294866,
0.3569853306,
-0.1234160215,
-0.6696152091,
-0.0497582741,
-0.1440855861,
0.5518177748,
0.5686945915,
-0.7445937991,
0.2432858497,
0.356929034,
0.0521154702,
-0.4415512979,
-0.7115380168,
-0.0450922102,
-0.637824595,
-0.2239818424,
0.3539482057,
-0.3804193735,
-0.5190469623,
-0.328044802,
0.2218074799,
-0.1420193762,
0.3455533385,
0.1315534413,
-0.1704832315,
0.0002262733,
0.1995862275,
0.0621669255,
0.0393088982,
-0.1165316477,
-0.2361871004,
0.3199175894,
-0.5319028497,
-0.2692805231,
-0.3459087014,
0.2268574685,
0.4915162325,
0.0870737582,
0.4873126745,
0.3820444047,
-0.6451100707,
-0.6974441409,
-0.0664763525,
-0.363923192,
-0.5495505929,
0.5809550285,
-0.6480892301,
-0.9343329072,
0.5170933008,
0.0255906582,
-0.0119313588,
0.1716427654,
0.7011370659,
-0.2239716053,
1.0275285244,
0.7524785399,
0.0058292639,
0.6022704244,
-0.2948987782,
0.1440974474,
-0.9529761076,
-0.1229494736,
-0.2302454859,
-0.49556306,
-0.3015414476,
-0.3806867003,
0.572697401,
0.357371062,
-0.0979088321,
0.3277748227,
0.0462999344,
0.8051682115,
0.4924158752,
0.3545092642,
0.09614674,
0.1470590979,
-0.3938126564,
0.0026741489,
-0.9046438932,
-0.372196734,
0.8168904185,
0.3898643553,
0.7484497428,
0.2435189337,
0.537900269,
0.1416620165,
0.476729244,
-0.8154266477,
0.5928037167,
-0.2907278836,
-0.3693360686,
-0.6016681194,
-0.2620881498,
-0.5035839081,
0.352930367,
0.0548839457,
-0.9510038495,
0.1258484125,
0.2853588462,
-0.609408319,
0.2254524678,
-0.6702130437,
0.1707878709,
-0.3013308048,
-0.4592024982,
-0.0755494982,
-0.7485889792,
0.2637630701,
-0.244509086,
0.1561046392,
-0.1221439391,
-0.2065423727,
0.4333355725,
-0.4677585065,
1.1079448462,
-0.208497718,
0.1430382431,
0.3539159596,
0.2157929987,
0.3785282373,
0.3302845061,
-0.3316414952,
-0.0903978795,
-0.0192092452,
-0.443048954,
-0.7025170922,
0.9250141978,
-0.5133334994,
-0.5306428671,
-0.1726602167,
-0.7408115864,
-0.4138797224,
0.0967484862,
0.30450055,
0.7051270008,
0.0637166575,
0.3335624337,
0.5149065256,
0.1006032974,
1.0898860693,
0.1906014085,
-0.0620980263,
-0.0028254485,
0.6759217978,
0.4424754381,
0.5211678147,
0.52734828,
0.3635942936,
-0.2790830731,
-0.5865541101,
-0.4187753201,
0.0092190551,
-0.9428180456,
-0.2025110871,
-0.3069371283,
-0.2192163765,
0.0700446889,
-0.3195923269,
-0.0789570063,
-0.3620458543,
-0.4755456448,
-0.0402571782,
0.0433193855,
0.6337124705,
-0.0331698582,
0.453555882,
-0.3153281808,
-0.2079923898,
0.4504781365,
0.2529562712,
0.1554217339,
-0.8613649011,
-0.5509494543,
0.0047107437,
-0.0571764,
-0.4332792759,
0.2409771383,
0.7346668243,
0.5398334265,
0.5451318622,
-0.1790080965,
0.8314940929,
-0.6394046545,
0.544041574,
0.1432984024,
-1.0030837059,
0.1362050027,
-0.1242585108,
0.6554537416,
0.6870172024,
0.2071867436,
-0.1133271828,
-0.1314931065,
-0.5859549046,
-0.508595109,
0.5142894983,
0.1247109547,
0.3159736395,
-0.0122926468,
0.5665120482,
-0.0124461418,
-0.0712525994,
-0.7482506633,
-0.3092007935,
0.4101497829,
-0.1225899756,
-0.069229871,
-0.4363215566,
-0.1771119386,
-0.445833385,
0.4284974039,
-0.5694586039,
0.2551786005,
-0.032031294,
-0.38828668,
-0.0618229322,
0.0229060799,
1.0178735256,
1.1898758411,
0.0120781008,
0.5041187406,
0.8356050849,
0.0361530185,
0.0936284438,
-0.1709535271,
-0.3436515629,
-0.2005987912,
0.5529984236,
0.7179739475,
0.4251355827,
-0.7473750114,
0.4722260237,
-0.0318397619,
-0.0424334817,
-0.3313570619,
0.1383217424,
0.0066787605,
0.2760641277,
0.5052515864,
0.1145974621,
0.1675299406,
-0.5029499531,
0.6573060751,
0.395760268,
-0.8077939749,
-0.3804777265,
0.4813366532,
-0.0136611927,
-0.4045830965,
0.3113650978,
-0.2190361023,
-0.3070111573,
0.8480609655,
1.0242602825,
0.4530208111,
0.0173863675,
-0.0154819284,
0.1912591606,
0.2666796744,
0.0276722722,
0.0012513723,
-0.0494292155,
-0.6256223321,
-0.4229772389,
-0.5934559703,
-0.3091814518,
0.2190032452,
-0.4050264657,
0.3289372027,
-0.9420750737,
-0.0836479142,
0.050040964,
0.0313922688,
-0.7793136835,
0.3200552464,
0.2050617635,
0.8946131468,
-0.6571008563,
1.2656667233,
0.542776525,
-0.1562830955,
-0.7136190534,
0.1585121602,
0.1084651425,
-0.5127834082,
0.7445992827,
0.1321039796,
-0.3649637401,
0.034351632,
-0.6157087684,
-0.9853713512,
1.0442590714,
0.5430985093,
-0.5126600266,
0.1113892049,
0.1840182543,
0.6766124964,
-0.8697934747,
0.1933522373,
0.522066772,
0.3153464496,
-0.1549651623,
-0.7595216632,
-0.1026480347,
-0.0725367144,
0.242527768,
-0.126319468,
-0.7883484364,
0.741799891,
-0.4988237619,
0.0153396437,
0.1829128116,
0.7714259624,
0.3089803755,
0.2234258354,
0.6988862753,
0.274677366,
0.7423059344,
0.0592655279,
1.2846205235,
-0.1914038509,
0.4082559645,
1.3208194971,
-0.1725654602,
0.8456440568,
0.6184533834,
0.0163413584,
0.2697711289,
0.7140832543,
0.1713793874,
0.6658390164,
0.4445330203,
-0.3250513673,
-0.2132582664,
-0.0837763473,
0.0348596349,
0.3406074345,
0.4641096592,
-0.3838542104,
-0.0994167328,
0.2661106884,
0.0273161363,
-0.0577136017,
-0.2503335476,
0.6421251893,
0.4404692352,
-0.37333709,
0.4977399707,
0.2535609007,
0.4119325578,
-0.4180290103,
-0.0587654635,
-0.2344712764,
0.2221246511,
-0.0424255952,
-0.541408062,
0.0978316665,
-0.2953312099,
-0.1062542796,
0.0698498785,
0.7572387457,
-0.5239103436,
-0.6605144739,
0.4728182852,
0.2832930386,
-0.0234879889,
0.3265971541,
-0.6509839296,
-0.0870289132,
-0.0893179253,
-0.1350444853,
0.6442120075,
0.1566332132,
-0.1448242366,
0.9054093957,
0.4409898221,
-0.0232799277,
0.4218120873,
0.0305806287,
0.7130893469,
-0.3825331926,
-0.4123284221,
-0.9462682009,
0.3409639299,
0.0296867527,
-0.4970494807,
0.5330938697,
0.3779754341,
1.2655080557,
-0.1757939607,
0.6750693321,
-0.0784342811,
0.1970580518,
-0.5887746215,
0.4119743407,
-0.6462936401,
0.515478313,
-0.0951676965,
-0.9534181356,
-0.6764740348,
0.5007662773,
-0.1615080237,
0.1251152605,
0.7029846907,
0.7931389213,
-0.2742634118,
-0.3749392033,
0.8438684344,
0.1657805443,
0.3042305708,
0.5616336465,
0.8028098345,
-0.3905893862,
0.3083924651,
-0.7418016195,
-0.225796029,
-0.3558914065,
-0.8133152723,
-0.9998425841,
-0.6217422485,
-0.220386222,
-0.1299671233,
-0.0501099974,
1.150421977,
1.0275874138,
-0.7234509587,
-0.4394315481,
0.3599530756,
0.2077132612,
-0.3982101679,
-0.1406908929,
0.3415062428,
-0.3303097188,
-0.8986480236,
0.7378261685,
0.4057238102,
-0.2959714234,
-0.1633983999,
-0.3091641068,
-0.2797617614,
0.2464519441,
0.8702083826,
0.2593572438,
-0.7758392096,
-0.6433316469,
-0.2269792408,
-0.3211371899,
0.0799745247,
0.8452367187,
-0.5439943075,
0.3278743923,
0.3483762145,
0.6963967681,
0.594886601,
-0.0856960192,
0.1907331198,
-1.0344958305,
0.172584489,
0.000190067,
0.3573935032,
0.2294780314,
-0.4003886878,
0.3322202563,
-0.1724582165,
-0.3642258048,
-0.7544465661,
0.4876104891,
-0.6184179187,
-0.283544302,
1.2366999388,
-0.1143369973,
-0.2567728758,
0.0171417166,
0.1176352277,
-0.1070110947,
-0.2557654083,
0.6492321491,
0.4064911604,
-0.5168209076,
-0.1120554581,
-0.4073797762,
0.6473219991,
0.4365229011,
-0.6597886682,
-0.2916484475,
0.164682433,
0.4803249836,
-0.0820128247,
0.4738893509,
-0.0971877277,
0.1925756037,
-0.3735643625,
-0.4950700104,
-0.0805874616,
-0.8683680296,
-0.5467333198,
0.298717469,
0.3881186247,
0.2592702508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12537v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12537v1
|
Oasis: Data Curation and Assessment System for Pretraining of Large Language Models
| 2023-11-21T11:32:23 | 2023-11-21T11:32:23 |
Tong Zhou, Yubo Chen, Pengfei Cao, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao, Shengping Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Data is one of the most critical elements in building a large language model.
However, existing systems either fail to customize a corpus curation pipeline
or neglect to leverage comprehensive corpus assessment for iterative
optimization of the curation. To this end, we present a pretraining corpus
curation and assessment platform called Oasis -- a one-stop system for data
quality improvement and quantification with user-friendly interactive
interfaces. Specifically, the interactive modular rule filter module can devise
customized rules according to explicit feedback. The debiased neural filter
module builds the quality classification dataset in a negative-centric manner
to remove the undesired bias. The adaptive document deduplication module could
execute large-scale deduplication with limited memory resources. These three
parts constitute the customized data curation module. And in the holistic data
assessment module, a corpus can be assessed in local and global views, with
three evaluation means including human, GPT-4, and heuristic metrics. We
exhibit a complete process to use Oasis for the curation and assessment of
pretraining data. In addition, an 800GB bilingual corpus curated by Oasis is
publicly released.
|
[
-0.5390920639,
-0.7388308048,
0.3500775993,
0.2980843484,
-0.283146292,
0.1735507399,
-0.3030163348,
-0.1307670325,
0.1793373674,
0.7001544833,
-0.4628532827,
-0.7836826444,
-0.6249982119,
0.024784036,
-0.6836952567,
0.9410741329,
-0.2058727741,
0.0221619513,
-0.1456561685,
-0.1951315999,
-0.5450302958,
-0.5002573133,
-0.8431840539,
-0.173556909,
0.4904451668,
0.3505128622,
0.7915483117,
0.4518863857,
0.2045296729,
0.3540482223,
0.1390822828,
0.0472529642,
-0.5448655486,
-0.0554259568,
-0.2859495282,
-0.0689887851,
-0.6247767806,
-0.0813239589,
0.7099255919,
0.8380028605,
-0.0681721866,
0.2448503077,
0.1027697101,
0.6066963077,
-0.8006147146,
-0.1987883598,
-0.2295937389,
0.1113664508,
-0.434618324,
-0.067397818,
-0.2543644905,
-0.5198859572,
0.1515283734,
-0.5407307744,
-0.1839000732,
0.0270185694,
0.7079085708,
0.234722808,
-0.2512814701,
-0.14385131,
-0.8314207196,
0.8815514445,
-0.6239947677,
0.489037782,
0.6205636859,
0.2588509321,
-0.1025352478,
-0.6893841028,
-0.6984133124,
-0.295782268,
0.0400549285,
0.081956692,
-0.0683771893,
-0.0880325735,
0.0565707013,
0.3423095047,
-0.744844079,
0.1707442999,
-0.2805765271,
-0.4036082625,
0.5148530602,
-0.108178325,
0.5074315071,
0.2471847534,
-0.262432009,
-0.2790182531,
-0.7861881256,
-0.1401146501,
0.5337933898,
0.2308898121,
0.2030949295,
0.0245753378,
-0.2563809156,
0.6016054749,
-0.3438438177,
0.0663653538,
0.4572973847,
-0.0684276074,
-0.1004199609,
0.1616397053,
0.7796316147,
-0.1242147237,
-0.1796226203,
-0.1157259569,
-0.4393750429,
-0.0137678664,
0.4333125055,
-0.8592497706,
-0.2985221148,
0.4657578468,
-0.2887200713,
-0.0088574635,
-0.0626929626,
-0.6077465415,
-0.0630833805,
-0.4632647932,
0.7653269768,
-0.4803069532,
-0.3457114398,
0.3856058717,
0.212350294,
-0.151542455,
0.4159579873,
-0.5129152536,
0.3871541917,
0.4890788496,
0.6479672194,
-0.3266162574,
-0.2796287835,
-0.4384177327,
0.1714551002,
-0.3942447305,
0.9135864377,
-0.5313764811,
-0.3304722309,
-0.0441730507,
-0.0180418938,
0.1902645081,
-0.3410915732,
0.8837192059,
-0.8365472555,
0.2754041553,
-0.1588744521,
-0.7855472565,
-0.1047735363,
0.2406157404,
-0.7099712491,
1.050180912,
0.4572280645,
-0.5488848686,
0.3061677217,
-0.7972841859,
-0.2539598644,
0.6254543662,
-0.0457325876,
-0.3682756126,
-0.4190010726,
0.1378446966,
0.0889161974,
-0.1956449598,
0.2903247178,
-0.2339173853,
-0.4458667934,
0.0894998536,
-0.2678316534,
0.7349282503,
0.5298383236,
-0.0826518163,
0.0910673812,
-0.8079525828,
0.3251208067,
-0.2359089851,
-0.3027796745,
-0.3502286673,
0.0167830978,
0.1183309034,
0.003238979,
0.4095723927,
-0.5971602201,
0.1191622391,
-0.0950274095,
0.3432473242,
0.4987031817,
-0.0445143692,
0.2015061677,
-0.3063607514,
0.5202342272,
0.1901512593,
0.3350660205,
-0.1306539923,
0.0612561814,
-0.7373905778,
-0.3124832511,
0.6760939956,
0.4680981934,
-0.680752039,
1.1159096956,
-0.3191981912,
-0.9177872539,
-0.594465673,
0.3621633947,
0.4469259083,
0.3042708337,
0.4873336554,
-0.7768207788,
-0.1985651106,
-0.7365309596,
0.1818011552,
0.032173302,
-0.1694050878,
-0.1381398588,
0.3364358544,
-0.5230546594,
0.9851044416,
-0.2236770988,
-0.3715663254,
-0.2205728143,
0.2484983802,
0.2333242446,
0.7968520522,
0.5931016207,
-0.6415205598,
-0.1900210232,
-0.130768165,
-0.2261860222,
-0.3940490782,
0.2168966532,
-0.5203079581,
-0.0843792334,
0.297010392,
-0.3529563546,
0.1960734427,
0.4287178218,
-0.2389952391,
0.3629665971,
-0.2695292234,
0.3056032658,
-0.7771107554,
0.200369671,
-0.4326833189,
-0.2378137112,
-0.4659010172,
-0.0586996228,
0.0986007079,
-0.0783339143,
-0.486407876,
0.4044302106,
0.0886964649,
-0.1392944455,
-0.3310037553,
0.1870248169,
0.3623316884,
0.3714025021,
0.1005535498,
0.5492895246,
0.6291330457,
-0.8429880142,
0.4412364662,
0.4057940543,
-0.6796506047,
0.3061801493,
-0.5917367935,
0.3090920746,
-0.1025001556,
0.344434917,
-0.8811544776,
0.0019707249,
-0.1172676533,
-0.2103372365,
0.06202811,
-0.1118341982,
-0.4917424917,
-0.3372855484,
-0.2903873324,
0.3550681174,
0.4848041832,
-0.4560573101,
0.3159814179,
0.5322949886,
-0.4382117689,
-0.5342842937,
-0.4041580856,
-0.036169976,
-0.1332694143,
-0.3406204879,
0.2896089554,
-0.1510667056,
0.0775836408,
0.137365669,
0.100028649,
-0.3022571802,
0.3022443056,
0.0575079583,
0.28043136,
-0.1606887877,
0.3926236629,
0.3051119745,
-0.1199824512,
-0.0996342897,
-0.3611973822,
0.7723465562,
0.1374763697,
-0.4594433606,
-0.3877902031,
0.1929294914,
0.3511669338,
-0.4303588867,
0.5403286815,
0.6905800104,
-0.3373716772,
-0.3543090522,
-0.4011312723,
0.1583492011,
-0.4756891429,
0.3473905623,
-0.3998900056,
-0.7820082307,
0.3131758273,
-0.2968235612,
0.1891094148,
0.5150367022,
0.4564528465,
0.0013644018,
1.0353168249,
0.470479399,
-0.1617887616,
0.4112256169,
-0.2848193347,
0.2229612619,
-0.506318748,
0.2248390615,
-0.7750039697,
-0.2374546826,
-0.1507459581,
0.1221166179,
0.322357595,
0.3048881888,
-0.6153376698,
0.4286095202,
-0.3556002975,
0.7088984251,
0.5768820047,
0.0367577411,
0.2568317652,
-0.1590048075,
0.0464433506,
0.1618916839,
-0.3026064634,
-0.9958155751,
1.0914525986,
0.2644460797,
0.5683979392,
0.1681744903,
0.6428062916,
0.5494298339,
0.4585172832,
-0.3534134924,
0.3385871351,
-0.3154029548,
-0.3361115754,
-0.565220952,
-0.5822187662,
-0.9396984577,
-0.0646222234,
-0.304167062,
-0.4498934746,
-0.0628285483,
0.0656765625,
-0.8501600027,
0.1145053059,
-0.7037485838,
1.0183162689,
-0.2980893552,
-0.290064007,
-0.3513710797,
-0.1930022836,
0.0537112206,
-0.5561961532,
0.3243805468,
-0.2127323449,
0.1606846303,
0.9549207091,
-0.6779894829,
0.366315484,
-0.3573450148,
-0.1596477628,
0.3936603665,
0.3719323277,
0.0486069545,
-0.0968598574,
-0.3218812644,
0.264662981,
0.5504922867,
-0.4805216491,
-0.6318477988,
0.6314687133,
-1.2585937977,
-0.3070052266,
-0.026393624,
-0.1559726149,
-0.3526884913,
0.4103230238,
0.1863113493,
0.5577683449,
-0.291526407,
0.0714536756,
0.3431445062,
-0.5254589319,
0.1528980434,
0.7417652607,
-0.4348045588,
-0.2040276676,
1.0607742071,
0.2649904788,
0.0580856837,
0.2329993546,
0.1600042135,
-0.3249833882,
-0.7565290928,
-0.567784667,
-0.2407132089,
-0.4740860164,
-0.3554077148,
-0.4914487302,
-0.1954993606,
-0.6369298697,
0.1035922915,
-0.4790367782,
-0.3354327083,
0.1272681803,
-0.0151785444,
0.2454358339,
0.6954003572,
0.0681963861,
0.6992790103,
-1.1719822884,
0.1560891271,
0.1778718531,
0.4602936506,
-0.1684177667,
-0.5736926794,
-0.3766868711,
0.0667137504,
-0.5407413244,
-0.4151524603,
0.5283645988,
0.192414701,
0.2944711745,
0.5423056483,
0.1786341369,
0.6512569785,
-0.4600190818,
0.7952498198,
-0.1642850041,
-1.1831234694,
0.6317471266,
-0.0576241389,
0.1120403409,
0.926820755,
0.5042040944,
-0.5187471509,
-0.4325191379,
-0.4114141166,
-0.8888127208,
0.6955592036,
0.0148539525,
0.1756327748,
0.0418721512,
0.3413653672,
0.4292097092,
0.1920536757,
-0.4811805785,
0.1253690124,
-0.2442586869,
-0.251585573,
-0.1590256095,
-0.0416984521,
0.0229748581,
-0.2318493277,
1.0555855036,
0.1085087955,
-0.0818156376,
0.0008780241,
-0.4142831862,
-0.1296083778,
0.2507306635,
0.0351481214,
0.784745276,
-0.2483614832,
-0.0148689765,
0.1785034239,
-0.5641388297,
0.1331722289,
0.0200384259,
-0.2475275397,
-0.0767802224,
0.3563848138,
0.7519638538,
0.0293879025,
-0.8564532399,
0.7256990075,
-0.1448296756,
0.1212087572,
-0.6575324535,
0.3067979217,
-0.2169025838,
-0.1865867823,
0.1380031258,
-0.2415046543,
0.234228313,
-0.4009869695,
0.2675981224,
0.0472797379,
-0.2053455114,
-0.2473808378,
0.2054568678,
0.2961638868,
-0.0243411474,
0.74836272,
-0.3453730345,
-0.4876300991,
0.4011715949,
0.2383085638,
0.6478105187,
-0.4909241498,
0.2826206982,
0.3845976889,
0.1202840954,
-0.1370110959,
0.1998292059,
-0.2151125818,
-1.0651942492,
-0.6557798982,
-0.9637590647,
-0.6657993793,
0.3601604104,
-0.4864436686,
0.496835351,
-0.3950517178,
-0.052169621,
-0.0994656309,
0.3288551569,
-0.6734269857,
0.306468606,
0.1969502866,
0.9182255864,
-0.8675017953,
1.0909618139,
0.6074697375,
-0.3770489395,
-0.6679378152,
-0.4549650848,
-0.4821425378,
-0.6131138206,
0.7106616497,
0.2005388737,
-0.0317131579,
0.0123134991,
-0.443285495,
-0.9595548511,
0.8291518688,
0.4833577573,
-0.650144279,
0.2234163135,
0.3571182489,
0.6318134665,
-0.2901763618,
0.575258255,
0.8521897197,
0.6427138448,
0.0262513477,
-0.8771996498,
-0.385671258,
-0.3239461184,
-0.1258566827,
0.2567248344,
-0.3985284567,
0.9395239353,
0.4887502789,
-0.318209976,
-0.0157234445,
0.379122287,
-0.1340057999,
-0.0230901614,
0.7935282588,
0.8866940737,
0.7866251469,
-0.0835978016,
0.9207844138,
-0.6195669174,
0.1778083295,
0.9990890026,
-0.6677196026,
0.8984537721,
-0.0499738976,
-0.3333647251,
0.5867854953,
0.7368637919,
0.2506689429,
0.3850387335,
0.427704215,
-0.4574812353,
-0.3430112898,
-0.1985578537,
-0.1549416929,
0.3751035333,
0.4714073539,
0.097071521,
-0.4166753292,
0.2202181965,
-0.085540466,
0.0061233812,
-0.462926656,
0.7375625372,
-0.2772230506,
-0.5571619868,
0.2860385478,
0.0856880769,
0.4441012442,
-0.7486307621,
0.0468425602,
-0.288171798,
0.2922773063,
-0.2803411782,
-0.682418406,
0.1910895854,
0.0068316078,
0.2316081226,
-0.4309684932,
0.6691263914,
-0.6454806328,
-0.3062123656,
0.2818327546,
0.6557212472,
0.4723959863,
0.0159607008,
-0.5391520262,
0.3823366165,
-0.244083032,
-0.5168150663,
0.2316653579,
0.5044464469,
-0.2048453242,
0.5458679199,
0.7214070559,
0.338037461,
-0.2405263633,
0.3908930123,
0.8379049897,
-0.4582412541,
-0.5523279905,
-0.6534484625,
0.0876762792,
0.0302113239,
-0.3651195765,
0.3869786859,
0.5481841564,
0.9185128212,
0.1270414442,
0.7946230173,
0.0653789863,
0.8655790091,
-0.3456597328,
0.925966084,
-0.2350919843,
0.1776138246,
-0.2344940603,
-1.2201445103,
-0.2258641571,
0.5805931091,
-0.368572861,
-0.0945910141,
0.4561419189,
0.7504363656,
-0.1104080528,
0.1866075844,
0.321120441,
0.3696777225,
0.4327226877,
0.5570337772,
0.8471997976,
-0.2985901535,
0.2050215453,
-0.1914526224,
-0.5031983256,
0.2412076443,
-0.7743511796,
-0.5413854122,
-0.7190653682,
-0.4954165518,
0.0056629931,
-0.190395847,
1.2117068768,
0.6260516047,
-0.9836961031,
-0.1904067695,
0.0610142425,
-0.1183709353,
0.1004401892,
-0.2064680308,
0.68493855,
-0.5685901642,
-0.7462649941,
0.327203244,
0.2068561614,
-0.0400225185,
-0.4662733376,
-0.0501571447,
0.1787668169,
-0.0046274057,
0.6498452425,
0.2033376843,
0.0932175666,
-0.3597579002,
-0.5190659761,
-0.0988553092,
-0.2860584259,
0.4334894419,
-0.9216897488,
0.2631829381,
0.2318077534,
0.9992558956,
0.2451957613,
-0.1645191461,
0.4473199546,
-0.58034271,
0.1245298758,
0.3557426333,
0.440847367,
0.2917942703,
-0.1014479771,
0.3386374414,
-0.1160430759,
-0.5610763431,
-0.7620554566,
0.0539024509,
-0.6977043748,
-0.1537684947,
0.8282282948,
-0.4756528437,
-0.3651511371,
-0.2274900228,
-0.3624207675,
0.1470578313,
-0.3023834229,
0.8238339424,
0.9357256889,
0.0643453449,
0.2932390869,
-0.4072689116,
0.444182992,
0.5630346537,
-1.0172214508,
-0.0590793639,
0.5911542177,
0.2179990113,
0.3754611611,
0.678491354,
-0.1857004166,
0.1359307617,
-0.3983843029,
0.391046524,
0.0636181235,
-0.2392431498,
-0.1617622524,
0.0767496303,
0.1078798324,
-0.035634052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12534v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12534v1
|
Evaluation Metrics of Language Generation Models for Synthetic Traffic Generation Tasks
| 2023-11-21T11:26:26 | 2023-11-21T11:26:26 |
Simone Filice, Jason Ingyu Choi, Giuseppe Castellucci, Eugene Agichtein, Oleg Rokhlenko
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Many Natural Language Generation (NLG) tasks aim to generate a single output
text given an input prompt. Other settings require the generation of multiple
texts, e.g., for Synthetic Traffic Generation (STG). This generation task is
crucial for training and evaluating QA systems as well as conversational
agents, where the goal is to generate multiple questions or utterances
resembling the linguistic variability of real users. In this paper, we show
that common NLG metrics, like BLEU, are not suitable for evaluating STG. We
propose and evaluate several metrics designed to compare the generated traffic
to the distribution of real user texts. We validate our metrics with an
automatic procedure to verify whether they capture different types of quality
issues of generated data; we also run human annotations to verify the
correlation with human judgements. Experiments on three tasks, i.e., Shopping
Utterance Generation, Product Question Generation and Query Auto Completion,
demonstrate that our metrics are effective for evaluating STG tasks, and
improve the agreement with human judgement up to 20% with respect to common NLG
metrics. We believe these findings can pave the way towards better solutions
for estimating the representativeness of synthetic text data.
|
[
-0.5169561505,
-1.1031916142,
0.4649595618,
0.4194304943,
-0.2063156515,
0.1808214933,
-0.3891188502,
-0.6585687399,
-0.0178288333,
0.346617192,
-0.4052996039,
-0.4871668816,
-0.2298805565,
0.4350011051,
-0.472004056,
0.9360421896,
0.1331356168,
-0.1257385314,
-0.3368118405,
-0.0115303174,
-0.6936064363,
-0.3920485377,
-1.0458359718,
-0.2029397488,
0.3433962762,
0.1195775419,
0.8030716181,
0.2131577283,
0.5056563616,
0.4008008242,
0.1799448133,
0.650042057,
-0.3807611465,
0.2800190747,
-0.1854526103,
-0.0286349058,
-0.2711693347,
0.0967878476,
0.9471625686,
0.562587738,
-0.1076552495,
0.3616212308,
0.0401255637,
0.5383093357,
-0.3951358199,
-0.1665368378,
-0.6348789334,
-0.0498878621,
-0.0043499437,
-0.3423778117,
-0.2049866468,
-0.7029973269,
0.2181500345,
-0.4927227199,
0.5474070907,
0.3127334714,
1.1661418676,
0.2335027903,
-0.5840837955,
-0.4744067788,
-0.8905112147,
0.9173622131,
-0.7842345238,
0.5581917763,
0.1405420005,
0.4056122005,
-0.3182364404,
-0.5696695447,
-0.8992437124,
-0.5724697113,
-0.3179138005,
0.4196695685,
-0.2701844871,
-0.0248689987,
0.2340438664,
0.3385085762,
-0.8835134506,
-0.0093971444,
-0.4937843382,
-0.2318975925,
1.1230831146,
0.4721440971,
0.2557388544,
-0.3410053253,
-0.3898297846,
-0.3227209449,
-0.6118121147,
-0.1162953526,
0.7903607488,
0.195339933,
-0.019201424,
0.3617430329,
-0.2743152678,
0.8321354985,
-0.1366010159,
0.1704226136,
0.4818266332,
-0.9675106406,
-0.1237061098,
-0.3568403125,
1.3891919851,
0.4128126204,
0.2547462583,
-0.2027689815,
-0.2609875202,
-0.0063100378,
0.8000346422,
-0.524333179,
0.0083286772,
0.2951620221,
-0.1687276065,
-0.335372597,
0.1968655586,
-0.7904230952,
0.0666605383,
-0.2571082711,
0.1613431871,
-0.2592693865,
-0.3646646142,
-0.0936094001,
-0.3379721344,
0.1863394231,
0.159193933,
-0.5895004869,
0.1836345792,
0.4362256825,
0.7717995048,
-0.4462969005,
-0.3660387397,
-0.489050746,
-0.1594766825,
-0.4283930063,
0.9535984993,
-0.179853335,
-0.6351689696,
0.0221430901,
-0.0719554126,
-0.2282321304,
-0.7242648602,
0.5741211176,
-0.2186719626,
0.3226272166,
0.0561615974,
-0.4389572144,
-0.0507093333,
0.3118605912,
-0.4864796698,
1.3652224541,
0.3000431359,
-0.4761790335,
0.6375437975,
-0.7035995722,
-0.6099746823,
0.342181474,
-0.0576737635,
-0.4981752634,
0.2292416096,
-0.1632865965,
0.1864600182,
-0.4991654754,
0.3005026281,
0.0784097686,
-0.0754912496,
0.507024467,
-0.4414400756,
0.5094474554,
0.3461108804,
-0.1372160763,
0.2105596811,
-0.8042913675,
0.265835613,
-0.0580882989,
-0.5759860277,
-0.1299044788,
0.1228887439,
0.3326713443,
0.0283314027,
0.1263976544,
-0.6550016403,
-0.2733187377,
-0.578214407,
0.1563626826,
0.4961377382,
0.3784577847,
0.0874012783,
-0.4479468465,
0.6333477497,
-0.003838113,
0.0127322506,
0.168499589,
-0.7750231624,
-0.8040559888,
0.1977082938,
0.2879980206,
0.3632160425,
-0.5590623021,
0.5920562148,
-0.2992744446,
-0.7643674016,
-0.5506084561,
0.134080112,
0.3819727004,
0.3162907064,
0.1782587469,
-0.3737041056,
-0.4498966336,
-0.8741634488,
-0.3136233091,
-0.4688017964,
-0.2934290767,
0.4490607083,
0.3887696862,
-0.1690587997,
0.8986846805,
-0.3729341328,
0.1201041266,
-0.3382485509,
0.5555459261,
-0.1603471637,
0.4632444978,
0.6148461103,
-0.55839926,
-0.4216913283,
0.0332521722,
-0.5368668437,
-0.3161994815,
-0.3273059428,
-0.2505994439,
0.3189125657,
0.031046221,
-0.6186414957,
0.124404557,
0.6955928206,
-0.3287210166,
0.9360868931,
-0.232457608,
0.3618854582,
-0.8686307669,
0.0461493805,
0.2142077088,
-0.4819177389,
-0.7721093297,
0.1509003788,
-0.2919442654,
-0.0937458351,
-0.3795330524,
0.67917943,
-0.0602618232,
-0.0753363669,
-0.2182202041,
0.4467145205,
0.1889998764,
0.1807107031,
0.0609381422,
0.9000653625,
0.259888798,
-0.8054197431,
0.4201517403,
0.1799862683,
-0.4299195707,
0.5264249444,
-0.7724483013,
0.3954832852,
0.163818121,
-0.0041905278,
-1.0589665174,
-0.0271735359,
0.0616959557,
-0.6229596138,
-0.2170244455,
0.1923038065,
-0.7354449034,
-0.4187157154,
0.0304435678,
0.3206130266,
0.7053287625,
-0.3214441538,
0.1699581295,
0.3831867874,
0.0963923261,
-0.0516079627,
-0.5690044165,
0.0332367532,
-0.3284456134,
-0.8490132093,
-0.0263619721,
-0.0643905401,
-0.1674562842,
-0.1674866825,
0.108177565,
0.0967302769,
0.1832257807,
0.0794502497,
-0.0014231559,
-0.2503649294,
0.1350392997,
-0.0300576091,
0.021032786,
0.3500505388,
-0.2316205949,
0.590074718,
-0.0807648748,
-0.1932393759,
-0.3255110681,
0.2313114256,
0.0678961799,
-0.2845870554,
0.4039856791,
0.7889504433,
-0.1964412928,
-0.3697791696,
-0.4171593487,
-0.1074043289,
-0.512206316,
0.2654091716,
-0.1483531743,
-0.6343649626,
0.3256725967,
0.0378836691,
0.1931570172,
0.4931234419,
0.7720298767,
-0.2485325783,
1.1588505507,
0.1472205371,
0.5782899857,
0.2555094659,
-0.2588919997,
0.4191728532,
-0.4355399609,
-0.0577390864,
-0.6915717125,
-0.1890848428,
-1.009754777,
-0.2501663864,
0.390784055,
0.0429172032,
0.0091331555,
0.3378951252,
-0.4375525117,
0.2221287191,
0.6436507702,
-0.2006351501,
0.3466543853,
0.0591811426,
0.1155428663,
0.1904481053,
-0.6701796651,
-0.7944838405,
0.9718186259,
0.1438731551,
0.1790704727,
0.0309638064,
0.7240128517,
0.4205664098,
0.3821804523,
-0.7204250693,
0.6331699491,
-0.2126941681,
-0.5743635893,
-0.3399104476,
-0.9263672233,
-1.1483504772,
0.1823237091,
-0.3817273378,
-0.6475628018,
-0.1228542253,
0.2936386168,
-0.4061202109,
-0.1241991743,
-0.697288394,
1.0067621469,
-0.288107872,
-0.1645229906,
-0.2914671302,
-0.1107286289,
0.2921321392,
-0.1446425915,
0.1392415911,
-0.1880612522,
0.2467641532,
0.8119430542,
-0.3612798154,
0.3835564554,
-0.1220748499,
-0.1298242509,
0.7744370699,
0.0409713723,
0.3355376124,
0.0014818952,
0.0068338178,
0.3159145117,
-0.0572871566,
-0.305804044,
-0.5918435454,
0.4900904298,
-0.5609294772,
-0.3773111105,
-0.2642698586,
-0.5166842341,
-0.3619319201,
0.019422926,
0.3609878421,
0.191805318,
-0.3808474839,
-0.1147707626,
0.0045286985,
-0.4711360335,
0.3309102654,
0.3448821008,
-0.1247660145,
-0.3559834957,
1.204641819,
-0.1679951549,
0.5198184252,
-0.2235552222,
0.3146793544,
-0.5043495893,
-0.6804692745,
-0.7278664708,
0.2158212662,
-0.2452030182,
-0.2121302933,
-0.4814656973,
-0.3296321929,
-0.2871382535,
0.1491355449,
-0.2748028636,
-0.397267431,
-0.0451104976,
-0.1126314476,
0.1569640934,
0.8774977922,
0.03129315,
0.6136637926,
-1.0128223896,
0.1983960271,
0.1896944493,
0.0853071213,
-0.06568335,
-0.2477224916,
-0.4705238044,
0.2044420391,
-0.7352904081,
-0.8764420748,
0.4087175131,
0.1541189104,
0.4432897866,
0.1838403344,
-0.1624573469,
0.5099288821,
-0.3521574736,
1.1481472254,
0.2826896608,
-0.7944188118,
0.6079079509,
-0.3131660521,
0.1595999449,
0.4785796702,
0.1251552254,
-0.567913115,
-0.9680681229,
-0.6930914521,
-0.7576845884,
0.3735372126,
0.6953424215,
0.3227797151,
-0.3174895048,
0.072360985,
0.0343311839,
0.3064598441,
-0.467403084,
-0.0573448762,
-0.1660571843,
-0.1954721957,
0.0478628799,
0.1405660659,
0.0621537343,
0.1247965321,
0.4507442117,
0.0438126102,
0.0201177429,
0.0995476991,
0.0646249279,
-0.1771880686,
0.4194267094,
0.4944408834,
0.7513448596,
-0.1078195274,
-0.0430109203,
0.1773044914,
-0.4554891288,
0.2145211101,
-0.1965351403,
-0.5287995934,
0.3208498359,
0.2471180558,
0.7553959489,
-0.3295520842,
-0.8740599751,
0.2817397118,
-0.0845946372,
-0.3483763039,
-0.3519856036,
0.3557162583,
-0.2963775694,
-0.020594988,
0.169102028,
-0.0318685062,
0.2825273871,
-0.3915039897,
0.1530768126,
0.4782263339,
-0.3020856082,
-0.3914783299,
0.4661070704,
0.4241016209,
-0.5191102624,
0.5976567268,
-0.809465766,
-0.2276775241,
0.6399478316,
0.5108540058,
1.0410459042,
-0.0962627158,
0.3913677931,
0.6461240649,
0.3225136399,
0.0353135392,
0.4718306363,
0.1683476865,
-0.974232614,
-0.5081650019,
-0.9973906875,
-0.2423004955,
0.2520816326,
-0.3607077897,
0.1289681047,
-0.244335562,
-0.5881144404,
-0.0230325628,
0.0675439835,
-0.8408446312,
0.3518511951,
-0.1062624305,
0.4841703176,
-0.8538313508,
0.3053159118,
0.8468392491,
-0.4935599267,
-0.587153852,
0.0509989895,
-0.3777944148,
-0.2754926682,
0.6755622029,
0.0500849746,
-0.1232693866,
-0.122724019,
-0.102969788,
-0.4155228436,
0.6031857133,
-0.0552633367,
-0.5445867777,
0.0007878279,
0.5942575336,
0.8353871107,
-0.3102935851,
0.2952000201,
0.6777585149,
0.5802140236,
-0.2770827115,
-1.0455108881,
0.0885953605,
-0.0883899033,
0.0769293159,
0.1824654937,
-0.5686762929,
0.4850619435,
0.0864361152,
-0.7023727894,
0.1463499814,
0.4530866444,
0.5844358802,
0.4646382928,
0.7683467269,
0.5085197687,
0.6034551859,
-0.2867078185,
1.0565605164,
-0.2668953836,
0.3003437221,
0.8900618553,
-0.1623140275,
0.6499384046,
0.3249247372,
-0.2840046883,
0.3827796876,
0.4884112179,
-0.1426395923,
0.1655255705,
0.5446556807,
-0.0619673207,
-0.2300070822,
-0.1999111325,
0.0304937474,
0.545781374,
0.2140065432,
-0.0883035511,
-0.2094246596,
-0.1385855973,
-0.2558096647,
0.0811605155,
0.0888383314,
0.9850151539,
-0.0465301834,
-0.8874902129,
0.7093123198,
-0.0078552216,
0.3335411251,
-0.4372090399,
0.0068474314,
-0.3783000112,
-0.1660571694,
-0.2262844443,
-0.7341669798,
0.5507696867,
0.2930159867,
0.1768624187,
-0.2045640498,
0.3949271739,
-0.345272094,
-0.6001601815,
0.116991207,
0.7066677809,
0.4747432768,
0.0215735771,
-0.5798623562,
-0.2426837683,
-0.0560949594,
-0.2577474713,
-0.046732787,
0.3598842621,
0.0395007171,
0.4769031703,
0.8156835437,
0.5442044139,
0.3146057129,
0.3951935768,
0.3680358827,
-0.7348501682,
-0.4165096879,
-0.6315698028,
0.594584167,
-0.3490712941,
-0.5063236952,
0.9177248478,
0.7157897949,
0.9484118223,
0.1144195274,
1.0264241695,
0.0758430734,
0.4324524999,
-0.5546475649,
0.5743432641,
-0.5121669769,
0.2096603066,
-0.0777795836,
-1.2187411785,
0.1854455024,
0.4671191573,
-0.0785885975,
0.0289846808,
0.694046855,
0.8331976533,
-0.1762783527,
0.0503485762,
0.2187290788,
-0.026096873,
0.4865301549,
0.3180247843,
1.2882965803,
-0.4471275806,
0.5545059443,
0.0635917485,
0.0388563834,
0.0778348669,
-0.6458400488,
-0.7503893375,
-0.5235936642,
-0.4033509195,
-0.4850837588,
-0.0725063831,
0.6599191427,
0.6961476207,
-0.791416049,
-0.5794129968,
-0.3015758097,
0.0402142815,
-0.2089854777,
-0.3374390602,
0.1556019932,
-0.7024336457,
-0.8362308145,
0.4543953538,
0.0355268568,
0.1633964032,
-0.5278211236,
-0.1588734686,
0.1424115151,
0.3076520562,
0.4772060812,
-0.0403020531,
-0.4686245024,
-0.4959488809,
-0.091048874,
-0.0567114502,
-0.0010498142,
0.8602320552,
-0.6575654149,
0.2066349983,
0.7875599265,
0.4414561987,
0.4882735908,
0.3045532405,
0.8228622675,
-1.1798278093,
-0.1003136411,
0.205096513,
0.0790590048,
0.428099364,
-0.0472897589,
0.5245953202,
0.1466465294,
-0.7222186923,
-0.9023032784,
0.4382203519,
-0.8386800289,
0.0399062634,
1.2496649027,
-0.011329825,
-0.0685687736,
-0.1552822292,
-0.0113277566,
0.2598847151,
-0.44248873,
0.8398609161,
0.4794557393,
-0.2125601768,
0.1323532313,
-0.7877583504,
0.7356309891,
0.2958818972,
-1.0891073942,
0.0664447546,
0.667838335,
0.0874015391,
0.4464330673,
0.5304311514,
0.1409949511,
0.2509790957,
-0.0817389786,
-0.1174001098,
0.1954474151,
-0.1151545495,
0.107331194,
-0.0673490241,
-0.0235663541,
-0.1532909423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12489v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12489v1
|
Multilingual Word Embeddings for Low-Resource Languages using Anchors and a Chain of Related Languages
| 2023-11-21T09:59:29 | 2023-11-21T09:59:29 |
Viktor Hangya, Silvia Severini, Radoslav Ralev, Alexander Fraser, Hinrich Schütze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Very low-resource languages, having only a few million tokens worth of data,
are not well-supported by multilingual NLP approaches due to poor quality
cross-lingual word representations. Recent work showed that good cross-lingual
performance can be achieved if a source language is related to the low-resource
target language. However, not all language pairs are related. In this paper, we
propose to build multilingual word embeddings (MWEs) via a novel language
chain-based approach, that incorporates intermediate related languages to
bridge the gap between the distant source and target. We build MWEs one
language at a time by starting from the resource rich source and sequentially
adding each language in the chain till we reach the target. We extend a
semi-joint bilingual approach to multiple languages in order to eliminate the
main weakness of previous works, i.e., independently trained monolingual
embeddings, by anchoring the target language around the multilingual space. We
evaluate our method on bilingual lexicon induction for 4 language families,
involving 4 very low-resource (<5M tokens) and 4 moderately low-resource (<50M)
target languages, showing improved performance in both categories.
Additionally, our analysis reveals the importance of good quality embeddings
for intermediate languages as well as the importance of leveraging anchor
points from all languages in the multilingual space.
|
[
-0.4215741456,
-0.2766137719,
0.2708015144,
0.2676873505,
-0.2591397166,
0.485520184,
-0.4204299748,
-0.4631362259,
0.6263449192,
0.1173614785,
-0.3757479787,
-0.3574658334,
-0.4319957495,
0.1885997057,
0.1775896549,
0.7176628113,
-0.2076294869,
0.0529918484,
0.1111153364,
-0.8302089572,
-0.4154638648,
-0.6040095091,
-0.4402351081,
-0.1305665821,
0.7647516727,
0.5362015963,
0.8246710896,
0.7574062943,
-0.0103289457,
0.241575852,
-0.0491703562,
0.3847037256,
-0.3109058142,
-0.2126884311,
-0.3922460973,
-0.3901886642,
-0.2282088846,
-0.2867378294,
0.7672269344,
0.9103503227,
-0.1413592547,
0.1669503301,
0.2641263008,
0.5221132636,
-0.7982380986,
0.2036303133,
-0.5526341796,
0.3187111616,
-0.5368773937,
-0.1660697162,
-0.3156131506,
0.0903395116,
-0.0404083952,
-0.3160325885,
-0.136285156,
0.2769112885,
0.3977135718,
-0.2711390257,
-0.3142743707,
-0.3144047856,
-0.4443064928,
0.8742657304,
-0.6706060171,
0.6160654426,
0.1206283048,
-0.022825418,
0.173316285,
-0.2212820798,
-0.4596992433,
0.0720151886,
-0.0524595864,
0.035405755,
0.0835833549,
-0.1108693555,
0.0151017951,
0.2426029742,
-0.3330062926,
0.2155409902,
-0.0341170467,
-0.1208178401,
0.2150770724,
-0.1392933577,
0.5197367072,
-0.1172185913,
-0.4565090239,
-0.0712250844,
-0.9710764885,
-0.0558389984,
0.5421957374,
0.9000074267,
-0.4245746732,
0.6778462529,
-0.0255707484,
0.4412103891,
-0.264924109,
-0.2567305565,
0.2852428854,
-0.7213315964,
0.463265866,
0.3418894112,
0.7575960755,
0.139624998,
0.2250775397,
-0.4034325778,
-0.1521668285,
-0.0209084135,
-0.3118593395,
-0.3334741294,
0.181368053,
-0.14991422,
-0.4126242995,
-0.0691447854,
-0.1153051481,
-0.4687426388,
0.042589996,
0.098361291,
0.2150763124,
-0.3707389832,
-0.4215590358,
-0.1304879636,
-0.0050868373,
0.0865310207,
-0.3398140073,
-0.9910759926,
0.2558102608,
0.3496178091,
0.9856914878,
0.0767319873,
-0.7083944082,
-0.5648988485,
0.6825706959,
-0.3538655043,
0.570094049,
-0.6859232783,
-0.172154516,
0.5595921874,
0.1368607134,
0.0646197721,
-0.305339992,
0.3256162107,
-0.5512444973,
0.0748312697,
-0.3923725188,
-0.2081962675,
-0.1072179526,
0.3075536788,
-0.8685298562,
0.9843315482,
0.0112492796,
-0.803019166,
0.2035461068,
-0.4580252767,
-0.7255097032,
-0.1653820723,
-0.2287535369,
0.0296702068,
0.252050966,
0.3940163851,
0.3250691891,
-0.3172345459,
-0.0909597129,
-0.2877604067,
-0.106485039,
-0.1327124834,
-0.4541863799,
0.4851483405,
-0.1843129545,
-0.157556504,
-0.3180191815,
-0.4144551456,
0.0521928705,
0.1014027148,
-0.3936710656,
-0.6789479852,
-0.0598027892,
0.0270452779,
0.6226940155,
0.3662451804,
-0.5380118489,
0.21820876,
-0.4263887107,
0.1497112662,
0.6609041691,
-0.1369945407,
0.6240922809,
-0.1278572381,
0.5009320378,
0.271047771,
-0.0681695938,
-0.4031648934,
-0.5936105847,
-0.5987052321,
0.0389394052,
0.4512689114,
0.4922294021,
-1.2484847307,
0.2188813984,
-0.3129841387,
-0.0128020328,
-0.6583921313,
0.6125838161,
0.6934208274,
0.1008295789,
0.4406911433,
-0.2548760176,
-0.3076330423,
-0.9137693048,
-0.3021471202,
-0.2213198543,
0.3255080879,
-0.0256563239,
0.2460819036,
0.1387440264,
0.526135087,
-0.322309047,
-0.2364336848,
-0.4593770802,
-0.0178846233,
0.2337491512,
0.3706281483,
0.4653040767,
-0.5228872299,
-0.6241273284,
0.2284498364,
-0.712970674,
0.2217848301,
0.0757612735,
-0.1886066049,
0.1503621489,
0.4636576474,
-0.1445505619,
-0.1568584442,
1.0395368338,
-0.1523284614,
0.263317734,
-0.3894236982,
-0.165462032,
-1.2154268026,
-0.1397725195,
0.0183649287,
-0.1363869756,
-0.506519258,
0.0176977795,
0.0951624438,
-0.1815283,
-0.7209974527,
0.548414588,
-0.7294211984,
-0.0996788219,
-0.200196743,
0.1460862607,
-0.1544473767,
0.8283908367,
0.1399175227,
0.4923962653,
0.4000405669,
-0.2559773624,
0.2412388027,
0.0134341326,
-0.2149420679,
0.4729408324,
-0.2681744993,
0.040330492,
-0.0488316044,
0.0689490438,
-0.4688237011,
0.2519857585,
0.1817229092,
0.0251939651,
0.5804700255,
-0.3756314516,
-0.8355869651,
-0.2060878575,
-0.5776488781,
0.7887058854,
0.1616404206,
-0.669950366,
0.266576767,
0.5319511294,
-0.3446711898,
-0.7278310657,
-0.8131703138,
0.1397365779,
-0.0488763377,
-0.5724229217,
0.4439342022,
0.2099428028,
0.1694531292,
0.3709362447,
-0.0494651981,
0.0773200467,
-0.302888751,
-0.2959679961,
0.0467759445,
-0.2641384602,
0.2665741146,
0.3773163557,
-0.337801218,
-0.2741015255,
-0.6460675597,
0.4978280962,
-0.1993782967,
-0.6429290175,
-0.0515949205,
0.8365212679,
0.5076916814,
-0.4843950272,
0.9083517194,
0.6441076398,
-0.5879431367,
-0.4234488606,
-0.4779958427,
-0.0179100856,
-0.4106875956,
0.2716996074,
-0.4968471229,
-0.7668331861,
0.5461639762,
-0.2922937572,
-0.150122866,
0.4414813519,
0.5830444098,
0.0806190595,
0.9903488755,
0.8351116776,
-0.4848946929,
0.3987586796,
-0.4240857661,
0.471776247,
-0.826985538,
-0.2234105319,
-0.238445878,
-0.2397979051,
-0.9814988971,
-0.8997595906,
0.2673944831,
0.4439613223,
0.1981868744,
0.4943638742,
-0.0375589579,
0.3587425649,
0.5628330708,
-0.1605591029,
0.3491998315,
0.2024140209,
-0.8318991661,
-0.0636038929,
-1.3197350502,
-0.3486106992,
0.7977370024,
0.3193074763,
0.7875065804,
0.1659387499,
0.7668925524,
-0.0871428102,
0.0617875345,
-0.6522972584,
0.2171156853,
-0.3394246101,
-0.4408931434,
-0.3044086993,
-0.1686869413,
-0.5106360316,
0.3647202253,
-0.2467775196,
-0.5352845788,
0.299253881,
-0.1215001717,
-0.1087462157,
0.598508656,
-0.5964493155,
0.871550262,
-0.313392669,
-0.6287748814,
-0.370182246,
-0.4335566461,
0.0862021595,
-0.2103344798,
0.5397330523,
-0.1711032689,
-0.2830227613,
0.7789543271,
-0.6726626754,
0.7472196817,
-0.0753182396,
-0.2633877993,
0.49095276,
-0.1414849907,
0.7145897746,
0.2364615798,
-0.0676723123,
0.3552562296,
-0.1526388526,
-0.6401578188,
-0.4427067935,
0.9636746645,
-0.4159789681,
-0.2736983299,
-0.3923736513,
-0.4812026322,
-0.5452911258,
0.2127769887,
-0.0160876662,
0.51299721,
0.1576806605,
-0.0126873963,
0.2201166451,
-0.3814063072,
0.6998328567,
0.3923147917,
0.1314418018,
-0.4385650158,
1.2031350136,
0.226531595,
0.1637824923,
0.5720586777,
0.3347185552,
-0.5427070856,
-0.3414980173,
-0.5977041721,
0.5150059462,
-0.5357655883,
-0.184056744,
-0.3040240109,
0.0075738207,
0.0078166667,
-0.328014642,
-0.7213552594,
-0.2671075165,
0.3081155121,
0.0518412441,
0.1147525832,
0.4395117462,
-0.4388836026,
0.0689372718,
-1.0542206764,
0.3692554235,
0.16465123,
0.5613831282,
0.2664959431,
0.0376978666,
-0.8784462214,
0.1655213386,
-0.0928747579,
-0.7367297411,
0.1334379613,
0.2823431194,
0.6737197638,
0.5055239797,
-0.0556844957,
0.9362885356,
-0.8837881088,
0.5134235024,
0.6067450047,
-0.9383716583,
0.3706503212,
-0.1558584273,
0.3122416139,
0.537987709,
0.5172155499,
-0.6864373684,
-0.5173851848,
-0.3983852863,
-0.8519218564,
0.736995399,
0.1508487165,
0.3111662567,
-0.3388288617,
-0.1846395731,
0.0157758892,
0.1866116822,
-0.8022867441,
-0.3336463273,
0.1945180148,
-0.03009036,
-0.035911683,
-0.2367936671,
-0.0088111116,
-0.1021098644,
0.469940573,
-0.390622586,
0.1293548942,
-0.0448254645,
-0.212675482,
-0.18583785,
0.2387496829,
0.0160290804,
0.3826331794,
0.0511132404,
0.2675515711,
0.485288918,
-0.0582047291,
0.3197953403,
-0.1432975084,
0.1929598302,
0.203543514,
0.7508684397,
0.5623496771,
0.5693119168,
-0.3375879824,
0.5165272951,
0.1852359027,
0.4353152812,
0.0765480548,
-0.5968796611,
0.4598905444,
0.1986957788,
0.2260106355,
-0.0956262574,
-0.2755854428,
-0.8856386542,
0.0624672882,
0.5233634114,
-0.2938035131,
-0.4990713596,
0.349114418,
0.3558177352,
-0.0648063794,
0.4008121192,
-0.4308828413,
-0.6148462892,
0.1487763822,
0.7882856727,
0.6761357784,
-0.3528009653,
0.159820497,
0.3709821403,
0.5140249729,
-0.0284382943,
0.4890678525,
-0.1028916091,
-0.8203914165,
-0.7770223022,
-0.6897519231,
-0.3091518581,
-0.2458817512,
-0.4072829485,
0.3692777157,
-0.128667295,
0.0502466932,
-0.4784374237,
-0.0253754146,
-0.7817348242,
-0.143587172,
0.413862139,
0.8249675632,
-1.0722831488,
0.9105259776,
0.7240309119,
-0.2907113731,
-0.6892812848,
0.0374811254,
-0.085199289,
-0.8156165481,
0.5255362988,
0.083554253,
-0.3315128386,
-0.0938596055,
0.2124589682,
-0.857016623,
0.8407660723,
0.3115479648,
-0.5753502846,
-0.2841215134,
0.3162524402,
0.4094510376,
-0.4065680206,
0.0174501464,
0.0723462626,
0.3324459493,
-0.0971476808,
-0.6592006087,
0.2489970475,
-0.1570286155,
0.3219718635,
0.2958723605,
-0.628077507,
0.5231681466,
-0.1791875958,
-0.407395035,
-0.0935022905,
0.6481540203,
0.2723463178,
0.0012170816,
0.5626344085,
0.6136858463,
0.4919440448,
0.0579723343,
0.9538882375,
-0.9614608288,
0.1894775033,
0.9453209639,
-0.1731953323,
1.0163354874,
0.733039856,
-0.1784816384,
0.5710137486,
0.2206030339,
0.2495579422,
0.789999783,
0.2050962001,
-0.4207668602,
-0.0524064265,
-0.6096510291,
-0.4455962777,
0.4675995708,
0.4201102257,
-0.2680896223,
-0.5224608183,
0.1527671069,
-0.0377000533,
-0.0387884118,
-0.1912218928,
0.4861035049,
0.2782670856,
-0.410168767,
0.5304940343,
0.3038245142,
0.833791852,
-0.7033480406,
0.0074562873,
-0.2595606744,
-0.0045176083,
-0.0545588434,
-0.6217496395,
0.2149429619,
0.0471526198,
-0.0099986717,
-0.4448856115,
0.4938241541,
-0.8311818838,
-0.6260396838,
0.7972421646,
0.9502459168,
-0.2482043952,
0.1982013732,
-0.571133256,
0.0176422093,
-0.2768774033,
-0.0717363432,
0.2481672317,
0.664201498,
-0.1733191758,
0.3461033404,
0.7131649852,
0.3679972887,
0.123959057,
0.1968504936,
0.7980087399,
-0.6869626045,
-0.7414699793,
-0.7825146914,
0.4240779579,
0.105994001,
-0.2066711187,
0.7760129571,
0.6613916159,
1.039233923,
-0.0267745163,
0.6915957928,
0.0037309655,
0.0733629465,
-0.6210069656,
0.4803282917,
-0.7373995781,
0.006746571,
-0.4368435144,
-1.1893556118,
-0.1345844269,
0.2812752426,
0.2195833027,
-0.1746402979,
0.9471700788,
0.5953396559,
-0.2207885981,
-0.3227778971,
0.3176585436,
-0.0450117551,
0.0154935215,
0.8236595988,
0.7187651992,
-0.3035903275,
0.6953189373,
-0.7258299589,
-0.1897561401,
-0.0062767663,
-0.9431735277,
-0.6955497265,
-0.5647828579,
-0.2179383337,
-0.1696488112,
0.0166236479,
0.7874199152,
0.5496956706,
-0.741864264,
-0.4132792354,
0.1405107379,
0.3724763095,
-0.4041777849,
-0.1194545701,
0.3925515711,
-0.4288056195,
-0.9353837967,
0.644141078,
0.6564746499,
-0.2272252291,
-0.4122971892,
-0.237487644,
-0.7298220992,
-0.2682542801,
0.848818481,
0.3465911448,
-0.5430585742,
-0.2481199354,
-0.2168251425,
-0.0724230036,
-0.1366733611,
0.7159249187,
-0.5899885893,
0.6012784243,
0.5595043898,
0.6547045112,
0.2549059987,
-0.4373517334,
0.6663918495,
-1.1394410133,
0.4321676195,
0.1517992616,
0.7102214694,
0.3682470024,
0.1119736061,
0.3823871911,
0.3032225966,
0.1803746074,
-0.7057563066,
0.1410105973,
-0.6776815653,
-0.0911710411,
0.9880433679,
-0.2097688466,
-0.1388985664,
0.0262979455,
0.1974799633,
0.4213839173,
-0.1899015307,
0.3453285694,
0.7928735018,
0.1806805581,
0.1197474897,
-0.363211602,
0.1990530342,
0.3503373563,
-0.3964407444,
-0.1036474854,
-0.0672888309,
-0.0511652082,
0.5433198214,
0.4552933574,
-0.2607369423,
-0.0068581202,
0.1486891657,
-0.0060369042,
0.0464399755,
-0.43998155,
-0.1442093402,
0.2370546609,
0.1342563629,
-0.3586831391
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12480v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12480v1
|
Speaker-Adapted End-to-End Visual Speech Recognition for Continuous Spanish
| 2023-11-21T09:44:33 | 2023-11-21T09:44:33 |
David Gimeno-Gómez, Carlos-D. Martínez-Hinarejos
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Different studies have shown the importance of visual cues throughout the
speech perception process. In fact, the development of audiovisual approaches
has led to advances in the field of speech technologies. However, although
noticeable results have recently been achieved, visual speech recognition
remains an open research problem. It is a task in which, by dispensing with the
auditory sense, challenges such as visual ambiguities and the complexity of
modeling silence must be faced. Nonetheless, some of these challenges can be
alleviated when the problem is approached from a speaker-dependent perspective.
Thus, this paper studies, using the Spanish LIP-RTVE database, how the
estimation of specialized end-to-end systems for a specific person could affect
the quality of speech recognition. First, different adaptation strategies based
on the fine-tuning technique were proposed. Then, a pre-trained CTC/Attention
architecture was used as a baseline throughout our experiments. Our findings
showed that a two-step fine-tuning process, where the VSR system is first
adapted to the task domain, provided significant improvements when the speaker
adaptation was addressed. Furthermore, results comparable to the current state
of the art were reached even when only a limited amount of data was available.
|
[
-0.6417376399,
-0.6215652823,
0.3185275197,
0.1760962456,
-0.4475264847,
-0.0765085891,
-0.5719688535,
-0.6642420888,
0.0987638086,
0.5475687981,
-0.4634429216,
-0.4636625051,
-0.5702117085,
0.0714515969,
-0.2238183469,
0.5598449111,
0.2878259718,
0.1263084412,
-0.0744529292,
-0.3404273391,
-1.0263507366,
-0.1759657711,
-0.6669623256,
0.0318544246,
0.3956313431,
0.7277103662,
0.5266140103,
0.6740000844,
0.31307441,
0.3723422885,
-0.1347133666,
-0.0671931952,
-0.5012959242,
0.230444923,
-0.4288881421,
-0.4355330169,
-0.209837988,
-0.4687071443,
0.730062604,
0.4908973277,
-0.2383119762,
0.0973133966,
0.2177281231,
0.6746696234,
-0.4826976359,
0.1404037476,
-0.6870225668,
0.2598079443,
-0.2442320138,
-0.5216720104,
-0.3352706432,
-0.0763220415,
0.7164883614,
-0.3015086055,
0.2407847345,
-0.2039559335,
0.573443532,
0.6943916082,
-0.049019143,
-0.4051485658,
-1.0759347677,
0.5260905623,
-0.3407690823,
0.816916883,
0.1606778055,
0.6216349006,
-0.3902227581,
-0.4048404694,
-0.3943220377,
-0.3466363549,
0.5450398326,
0.4096432924,
-0.341088295,
0.193058446,
0.1791492403,
0.0612014458,
-0.567324698,
0.4011815786,
-0.4738398492,
-0.1309262961,
0.0458013527,
-0.283826977,
0.457370162,
0.1303995103,
-0.2207373977,
-0.1807065457,
-0.4644051492,
0.4289293885,
0.1213387027,
0.3293784857,
-0.1571053416,
0.5089606047,
-0.317247659,
1.0036859512,
-0.0469375178,
-0.2622678876,
0.2132914811,
-0.0258860085,
-0.3962017894,
0.2888438702,
0.5179213881,
0.1883924603,
0.9022904038,
-0.0287851952,
-0.0669957697,
0.0790525079,
0.039413292,
-0.4526233673,
-0.0683660284,
0.103529878,
-0.1908899844,
0.287968874,
0.1607209742,
-0.567263484,
-0.2085096985,
-0.6216290593,
0.3662463427,
-0.1931983382,
-0.1629708558,
0.150653109,
-0.0898812413,
0.1943842471,
0.4925502241,
-0.6470826268,
0.4772055149,
0.1800951064,
0.8758832216,
-0.1894311905,
0.0066401339,
-0.9582902789,
0.0613283478,
-0.1422025114,
1.0208165646,
-0.4631572664,
-0.436258316,
-0.1429167241,
0.0980115533,
-0.0586737096,
-0.7196837664,
0.4676110744,
-0.0784053504,
0.1848411262,
-0.372312814,
-0.0510037243,
0.0595920794,
-0.2178011239,
-0.3563468456,
0.7059257627,
-0.1266692579,
-0.4606196284,
0.3894092739,
-0.0917198658,
-0.3245633543,
0.1777374297,
-0.5595439672,
-0.3561689556,
0.3564295173,
0.3753020763,
0.3600961268,
-0.1996798664,
-0.1425434947,
-0.039507132,
-0.1219054386,
0.4400597513,
-0.3000746369,
0.3396276832,
0.1570842862,
-0.1240023971,
0.2653180361,
-1.0654717684,
-0.1395442188,
-0.2841229141,
-0.256642431,
-0.2659154534,
0.1666824967,
0.1054838672,
0.3819575906,
0.2053150088,
-0.5368150473,
-0.375330925,
-0.6045324206,
0.383392632,
0.7069803476,
0.1735437661,
0.278372854,
-0.0785536021,
0.5264064074,
-0.1508374363,
0.324128896,
-0.2022657841,
-0.5124186277,
-0.9830429554,
-0.4350883067,
0.293445915,
0.8179931045,
-0.6412729621,
0.2597146332,
-0.1656673551,
-0.21625489,
-0.2762567103,
-0.1064985469,
0.7161155343,
0.707721591,
0.3313099742,
-0.5207496285,
-0.7789470553,
-0.7637422085,
-0.0938622728,
-0.1410885751,
-0.322779268,
0.6646472216,
0.3553436697,
0.1672760546,
0.9546735287,
-0.1566114426,
-0.7783228159,
0.0542404167,
-0.3531193137,
0.3064058423,
0.3320408463,
0.4288758039,
-0.7078125477,
-0.518399179,
0.511777699,
-0.5818679333,
-0.0824944377,
-0.2681567371,
0.0990678892,
-0.1098366082,
0.6161335111,
0.1469541341,
0.3690282702,
0.4640689194,
-0.3113546669,
0.2798722684,
-0.6782747507,
-0.0711729676,
-0.6794162393,
-0.3255860806,
0.3313158751,
-0.3290529847,
-0.8406025171,
-0.480697155,
-0.1485030055,
-0.0633668378,
-0.6383897066,
0.4191990793,
-0.6476274729,
-0.4890233278,
-0.2364328206,
0.2161735296,
-0.4304338694,
0.5191665292,
0.3045555651,
0.6971107721,
0.7386758327,
-0.6205450892,
0.2650855184,
0.2299637496,
-0.4409962296,
0.9365479946,
-0.9457320571,
0.1156879589,
-0.2613083422,
-0.2160192579,
-1.1828727722,
-0.1774695814,
0.2747763097,
-0.6015402079,
0.4456096292,
-0.1834124774,
-0.006647096,
-0.0360857323,
0.1257532388,
0.0526251197,
0.5283575058,
-0.5461556315,
0.4780142903,
0.514913857,
-0.383562237,
-0.2166535854,
-0.681456387,
0.4066005647,
-0.1407449991,
-0.5941581726,
0.3693282604,
0.0404945016,
-0.0494443178,
-0.2834543288,
-0.2666414678,
-0.0342820063,
-0.416675657,
0.282846868,
-0.1430633664,
-0.1091213152,
0.0415744781,
-0.0097770272,
-0.2541146874,
-0.3183250129,
-0.3370068371,
0.2816906273,
-0.2136742622,
-0.1941265613,
-0.8376370668,
0.2193086445,
0.6429127455,
-0.5363066792,
0.390182972,
0.375459671,
-0.4298961759,
-0.2113396972,
-0.7294918299,
0.2416005731,
-0.4331522286,
0.5784802437,
-0.6140577793,
-0.641795516,
0.8208360672,
-0.0306728054,
-0.4347364604,
-0.1354075968,
0.7929601073,
-0.2629262805,
0.6873249412,
0.9388499856,
0.2278185338,
1.1226837635,
0.0320438668,
-0.213767156,
-0.8709819317,
-0.6513504982,
-0.8161514997,
-0.0826647878,
-0.5261045694,
-0.3734874725,
0.5200766325,
-0.0153494813,
0.0054113083,
0.4247701466,
-0.6608785391,
0.317920655,
0.4458667636,
0.6288403273,
0.2324791104,
0.0738785714,
0.0747297481,
-0.1781968027,
-0.5072150826,
-0.0923267826,
0.6853144765,
0.3685107529,
0.6036529541,
0.1500337869,
0.3343831897,
0.3726894259,
-0.3061922491,
-0.7094792128,
0.4885740876,
-0.1819939762,
0.1240741387,
-0.6539728642,
-0.1268568039,
-0.6857544184,
0.3772604465,
-0.1047371775,
-0.8209059238,
0.9887164235,
0.1555682421,
-0.1514333189,
-0.4428302646,
-0.8042114973,
0.7705877423,
-0.4269546568,
-0.1811160594,
0.0119853476,
-0.6744861007,
-0.265514046,
-0.0576527975,
0.2113073915,
-0.071893774,
-0.1751553714,
0.742913723,
-0.4397242963,
0.781889379,
-0.3510455787,
0.1825009137,
0.2410595417,
-0.2782325745,
0.6761398911,
-0.1019710675,
0.1082965881,
-0.1889379025,
-0.0970562473,
-0.4305200875,
-0.4406703711,
0.5075852275,
-0.8061296344,
-0.4950328469,
-0.2876083553,
-0.2372632176,
-0.4213863909,
0.0691361353,
0.2660440505,
0.352083385,
-0.4882870913,
0.4196200073,
0.9640803337,
-0.4939338863,
0.4556618333,
0.5014231205,
0.0744238719,
-0.5652682185,
0.8979494572,
0.3405139446,
0.3311342299,
0.4593357444,
0.2652545571,
-0.4529055059,
-0.917057991,
-0.3985795677,
0.1224487424,
-0.7150695324,
0.1621097177,
-0.4115660787,
-0.0144629646,
-0.0890317559,
-0.1404524297,
-0.4899816215,
-0.085983187,
-0.8063492179,
-0.0100704823,
0.3193642199,
0.1225425079,
0.105943799,
0.4339126945,
-0.2756098211,
0.5704749227,
0.4937409163,
0.3334870934,
-0.2824700177,
-1.0034790039,
-0.2098767012,
-0.1485041082,
0.3764947355,
-0.9988669157,
0.4436125457,
0.8506538272,
0.6356107593,
0.409087956,
-0.1307985485,
1.0173437595,
-0.5275324583,
0.2647425532,
0.5121746659,
-0.8472832441,
0.8511794806,
-0.3707219958,
0.438439697,
0.4158548415,
-0.0698505864,
-0.5740576386,
-0.2347421348,
-0.0468310863,
-0.5917261839,
0.4087703526,
0.0831387863,
-0.0725998953,
0.1603088081,
0.1277623624,
-0.014602568,
-0.0052598733,
-0.4779230952,
0.1880335957,
-0.4865444303,
0.0529004298,
0.0664583445,
-0.1978237182,
0.1875330955,
-0.3502498865,
0.1901621372,
-0.0868663117,
0.074968949,
0.3899736404,
-0.3092878461,
-0.0802982971,
0.45766294,
0.8115160465,
0.7856229544,
-0.2751450837,
-0.2008504868,
0.3280654848,
-0.4858582318,
-0.0863275751,
-0.1946654916,
0.1115241647,
0.1027755365,
0.2225673199,
1.0124021769,
0.2371005565,
-0.8936287165,
0.4824444354,
-0.0762890354,
-0.1405917704,
-0.6198020577,
0.0927819386,
-0.2102109641,
0.56542027,
0.4129589796,
0.3024297059,
-0.0016701476,
-0.5702033639,
0.106574297,
0.3020117879,
-0.7645918131,
-0.218578428,
0.6873936653,
0.273219049,
-0.6175227165,
0.2239769846,
0.2349132299,
-0.1627821624,
0.6104083657,
0.5568631291,
0.8215183616,
-0.612973392,
0.1216437817,
0.0633812398,
0.2089951634,
-0.1383634061,
0.5942811966,
-0.3729115129,
-0.5859246254,
-0.4110893607,
-0.5638406277,
-0.4914247394,
-0.2071851641,
-0.7703647614,
0.4807254076,
-0.4271757901,
-0.0844631419,
-0.1626996398,
-0.4938851893,
-0.7812659144,
0.3743005693,
0.2284539193,
0.5085362792,
-0.8071736693,
0.9344468713,
0.4054695964,
-0.2737970054,
-0.1618981063,
-0.4188595414,
-0.2109198123,
-0.7804222107,
0.3964727819,
-0.2758360505,
-0.4687252939,
0.000245441,
-0.0443109497,
-0.8651304841,
0.8204994202,
0.4649168551,
-1.1256825924,
0.1869572401,
0.2312883884,
0.9903572798,
-0.4096986055,
-0.0171717536,
0.5617297888,
0.3221060932,
0.3859514296,
-1.1848258972,
-0.28192693,
-0.1527832299,
0.4255200922,
-0.0495669581,
-0.3670111895,
0.6006707549,
-0.2993489206,
-0.3435501456,
-0.081213586,
0.8448114991,
0.0179740619,
0.108875595,
0.5386013389,
0.2951455712,
0.6687916517,
0.0265731588,
0.5881152749,
-0.0450137071,
-0.0901558995,
1.3211715221,
0.0029453535,
0.9334868193,
0.675113976,
-0.1535298973,
0.012345898,
0.7384400964,
-0.1449216306,
0.847045064,
0.161976561,
-0.1863583624,
-0.1014182717,
-0.4112612903,
-0.5563524961,
0.6740556955,
0.6575320959,
-0.4262911975,
0.0055442029,
0.5911612511,
-0.4850249588,
0.2582967877,
-0.457762152,
0.7501863241,
0.0999907553,
-0.4796638787,
0.7172253132,
-0.3801015019,
0.4472048283,
-0.1276070774,
-0.005860901,
-0.0124268234,
0.1485023648,
-0.4489405453,
-0.6264250278,
0.0458188802,
0.2387506664,
-0.202615425,
-0.2698005438,
0.5980367064,
-0.366912514,
-0.4782958925,
0.2926624119,
0.646733284,
0.3209375441,
-0.2390053719,
-0.4624183178,
0.2472851574,
0.262879014,
-0.1494082212,
0.3619408906,
0.4789156914,
-0.0807767659,
0.6741307378,
0.7487245798,
0.3225883842,
0.2786602676,
0.5636592507,
0.665766716,
-0.5473415852,
-0.7711042762,
-0.6506008506,
0.5019950867,
0.2085116357,
-0.5045694709,
0.4554473758,
0.2263086438,
0.9938215613,
-0.0597198904,
0.5959315896,
0.3890886307,
0.47002092,
-0.5416781306,
0.3118607104,
-0.2995116711,
0.4134663939,
-0.4304843843,
-0.9835058451,
-0.4838427305,
0.4869977236,
-0.144864589,
-0.0857644379,
0.323148489,
0.7054745555,
0.0964152515,
-0.2818678617,
0.7725323439,
0.2977961302,
0.3533682227,
0.4867052436,
0.7361751795,
-0.0998094901,
0.721196115,
-0.0076413411,
-0.5289577842,
-0.3721102178,
-0.5455988646,
-0.7995110154,
-0.6407508254,
-0.2767781913,
-0.1060559228,
0.4915705025,
0.5996143818,
0.5416106582,
-0.6706456542,
-0.2932294607,
-0.2466373891,
-0.1762900352,
-0.1357934624,
-0.0597957671,
0.4244571626,
0.1314163506,
-0.6275772452,
0.4177930355,
0.7776390314,
0.2156116217,
-0.070622243,
-0.1519795209,
0.2438609004,
-0.1758171618,
0.6700001955,
0.9302517772,
-0.8533731699,
-0.5669699311,
0.1537657231,
0.3380062878,
0.4658670723,
0.4376801848,
-0.9930932522,
1.0614533424,
0.5414453745,
0.3450919986,
0.8519586325,
-0.0426925793,
0.5221796632,
-0.5359062552,
0.4954349399,
0.2833579481,
0.4503492713,
0.2491559386,
-0.1184930727,
0.1597676128,
0.1144001856,
-0.4173964858,
-0.8285065889,
0.2447698712,
-1.5891605616,
-0.0139727322,
0.8752744198,
0.1243418157,
-0.2096004933,
-0.3590159118,
-0.4847966135,
0.3691605628,
-0.5634618998,
0.4707413912,
0.3661338091,
-0.4698019326,
-0.7050637603,
-0.7950374484,
0.1881133616,
0.1612541229,
-0.7015289068,
-0.2346111536,
0.2691841424,
0.2879354954,
-0.2152820975,
0.5624616742,
0.0632891357,
0.5411845446,
-0.0846022367,
0.0865715221,
-0.1182371303,
-0.6154600978,
-0.5019242764,
0.1254060417,
0.0745317563,
-0.6773483753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12475v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12475v2
|
PhayaThaiBERT: Enhancing a Pretrained Thai Language Model with Unassimilated Loanwords
| 2023-11-21T09:37:42 | 2023-12-28T19:22:12 |
Panyut Sriwirote, Jalinee Thapiang, Vasan Timtong, Attapol T. Rutherford
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While WangchanBERTa has become the de facto standard in transformer-based
Thai language modeling, it still has shortcomings in regard to the
understanding of foreign words, most notably English words, which are often
borrowed without orthographic assimilation into Thai in many contexts. We
identify the lack of foreign vocabulary in WangchanBERTa's tokenizer as the
main source of these shortcomings. We then expand WangchanBERTa's vocabulary
via vocabulary transfer from XLM-R's pretrained tokenizer and pretrain a new
model using the expanded tokenizer, starting from WangchanBERTa's checkpoint,
on a new dataset that is larger than the one used to train WangchanBERTa. Our
results show that our new pretrained model, PhayaThaiBERT, outperforms
WangchanBERTa in many downstream tasks and datasets.
|
[
-0.0075831944,
-0.23473759,
0.1870975494,
0.1350191981,
-0.5886616707,
0.5000820756,
-0.2683544159,
-0.240306899,
0.263029784,
0.5472340584,
-0.2692494094,
-0.3297551572,
-0.8816789389,
0.1051124707,
-0.2757342756,
1.0982886553,
-0.4387508035,
0.2133074403,
0.4409083128,
-0.5035586357,
-0.5607682467,
-0.3759872615,
-0.2057909369,
-0.5810626149,
0.4236829877,
0.5917155147,
0.7067598701,
0.2820672095,
0.7996318936,
0.2708534002,
0.1083306894,
0.0176237598,
-0.5012282729,
0.0756810308,
-0.0464585163,
-0.4885638356,
-0.3358403742,
-0.1003909782,
0.4645977318,
0.8231353164,
-0.1754684448,
0.1782054752,
0.0672444254,
0.5444565415,
-0.8154837489,
0.2574073672,
-0.4403677583,
0.1515511721,
-0.2196439058,
-0.1849488616,
-0.0946672559,
-0.5184449553,
0.5689511299,
-0.6379091144,
-0.068139784,
-0.1886183918,
0.9335535169,
0.0781453997,
-0.6098057032,
-0.301283747,
-0.6861692071,
0.8869537711,
-0.3477148116,
0.5067098737,
0.3945692182,
0.230444774,
0.0418883637,
-1.0545060635,
-0.5283638239,
-0.2266790718,
-0.0565458275,
0.008210686,
-0.2991375327,
0.287853688,
-0.2162094265,
0.5973768234,
-0.4498522282,
0.1809043437,
-0.7899444699,
-0.4199926257,
0.2625778913,
-0.0638992637,
0.2964641452,
-0.5042999983,
-0.2665937543,
-0.3142211735,
-0.7410306931,
0.1239540651,
0.1530126631,
0.3488620818,
0.0295453593,
0.7948995829,
-0.0451750197,
0.3918330669,
-0.2136854678,
-0.0418704823,
0.1159836054,
-0.25131616,
-0.3012608588,
0.1535570174,
0.602617383,
0.2021142244,
0.3268052936,
-0.1412531286,
-0.2081404626,
-0.1133926809,
-0.1759680063,
-1.1349357367,
-0.8819198012,
0.2597092986,
-0.4467858076,
-0.2558909357,
0.4058714807,
-0.6559434533,
-0.3175733984,
-0.0436140224,
0.5980278254,
-0.5803120732,
-0.6620401144,
0.1921963841,
0.0682961419,
0.4074541628,
0.0064790379,
-0.691706121,
0.3092253506,
0.4175963402,
1.1284080744,
-0.5509200096,
-0.4934358895,
-0.5036885738,
-0.1978933066,
-0.4440366626,
0.6531928778,
-0.4428728223,
-0.9493910074,
0.0197619628,
0.2907303572,
-0.0116359349,
-0.5006369948,
0.3980093598,
-0.6482672691,
0.4579648674,
-0.1541729122,
-0.4717358351,
-0.5391484499,
-0.1030210033,
-0.6761069298,
0.6630914807,
0.5720766187,
-0.7502308488,
0.5162808895,
-0.759988904,
-0.4077293277,
0.0444284156,
0.2602292895,
-0.5263164639,
0.214031741,
0.0798356384,
0.4653410017,
-0.1108720601,
0.4006010592,
0.0022298926,
-0.282509923,
0.218548283,
-0.2004619837,
1.0459061861,
0.3035342693,
-0.1242386848,
0.0920661464,
-0.7204124331,
-0.0831355676,
-0.0360168815,
-0.437227726,
-0.4490286112,
-0.5308187008,
0.3551658988,
0.0581281669,
0.2298284173,
-0.5955671072,
0.1924547702,
-0.3467769325,
0.3672533631,
0.7230370641,
-0.0364357196,
0.4220781624,
-0.2144103646,
0.989305079,
0.5151235461,
-0.4033439457,
-0.4928694963,
-0.2795599401,
-0.947286129,
-0.5190054178,
0.4737871587,
0.5212438703,
-0.6182332635,
0.1918772459,
-0.6014553905,
-0.6493859291,
-0.5589725971,
0.1366274357,
0.1164069995,
0.3387798965,
0.5425543785,
-0.6584004164,
-0.9519598484,
-0.596593976,
-0.2892011702,
-0.1540736407,
0.0687586069,
-0.2457201183,
0.5784853697,
-0.3738262653,
0.8532755375,
-0.5536025763,
-0.5066014528,
-0.5903425217,
0.3628889322,
-0.1110358983,
0.6655720472,
0.2701452374,
-0.3625634909,
-0.4848909676,
0.276429534,
-0.3278357685,
0.1194467992,
0.1436153054,
0.0271647964,
-0.1633321047,
0.3095237017,
-0.8963499069,
0.4617108107,
0.6460943818,
-0.2419693023,
0.5907794237,
-0.3727365136,
0.2684178948,
-1.4104572535,
0.1529676467,
-0.2225580215,
-0.2265494913,
-0.6893354058,
0.1702492684,
0.1136681437,
-0.3839367628,
-0.4082928896,
0.5137355328,
-0.4931825995,
0.2350724488,
-0.5541963577,
0.2123735994,
-0.1425685138,
0.5052226782,
0.2422768474,
0.8421041965,
0.6437653899,
-0.6153540015,
0.5525562167,
0.2246581316,
-0.3430027664,
0.4243516326,
-0.79674685,
-0.0259202551,
-0.1776829511,
0.1296112537,
-1.0369522572,
-0.1894906312,
0.0994379222,
-0.2292585522,
0.379013598,
-0.0033945693,
-0.3267666698,
-0.2911038101,
-0.2709230483,
0.6690423489,
0.6499812007,
-0.5693368316,
0.5216900706,
0.2989263237,
-0.0749260113,
-0.5256952047,
-0.5469858646,
-0.0948628262,
-0.5800312161,
-0.0408936478,
0.2439572811,
0.4187740386,
-0.2374117076,
-0.1432960331,
0.1104396805,
-0.4310644865,
-0.0553539172,
0.0164356679,
0.2047171146,
-0.4565858245,
0.2316576093,
-0.0424105898,
-0.0711112246,
-0.0329931006,
-0.6545023918,
0.4825190306,
0.1382907331,
-0.1898823977,
-0.7252748013,
-0.1554545164,
0.7430949211,
-0.5445272326,
0.6862576008,
0.5573966503,
-0.2995091677,
0.1625899822,
-0.3298473358,
-0.3307388127,
-0.4445103705,
0.8742542863,
-0.2951772809,
-0.8024544716,
0.4953440428,
-0.1718508601,
-0.0269009024,
0.247140944,
0.2669877708,
0.3168247938,
0.8002078533,
1.0223953724,
-0.344651252,
0.3462866843,
-0.2870996594,
0.2794603705,
-0.6185470819,
0.0246061534,
-0.4108630419,
0.0026203569,
-1.0401095152,
-0.5417952538,
-0.1757909805,
-0.0187084842,
-0.1340296268,
0.7975558639,
-0.1229018793,
0.3195343018,
0.197382167,
-0.186890319,
0.5025863051,
-0.0868880078,
-0.1536774039,
-0.5155483484,
-0.5202162266,
-0.3095399141,
1.3898830414,
0.3297702074,
0.694254756,
0.0881810486,
0.340457052,
-0.1084217951,
0.4677938223,
-0.8313830495,
0.2012816072,
0.0505877882,
-0.3642751575,
-0.0030030743,
-0.2430773675,
-1.1589165926,
0.4109526873,
0.3575127423,
-0.7474275231,
0.2345363349,
0.0212180316,
-0.3437720537,
0.4148197174,
-0.607817471,
0.9126912355,
-0.0354917757,
-0.0635404587,
-0.4003722966,
-0.1892895103,
0.8505904078,
-0.4925704598,
-0.0273908023,
0.0236363597,
-0.1008696631,
0.8648594022,
-0.9350530505,
0.4357554615,
-0.353214711,
-0.2599079013,
0.1960994154,
0.1876992583,
0.4416035414,
-0.1383893639,
0.2153000534,
-0.1703864038,
0.2732647061,
-0.5580201149,
-0.5291446447,
0.43357566,
-0.8024007082,
-0.3055573702,
-0.4063386321,
-0.3973044455,
-0.2683873177,
0.3178170919,
0.3303362429,
0.1899978369,
-0.2107555121,
0.3352785408,
0.4600839913,
-0.2402084023,
0.0481200106,
0.5674141049,
-0.7205979824,
-0.2166675925,
0.9795238972,
0.1511067003,
0.1703062505,
0.3691069782,
0.1947143972,
-0.3962652087,
-0.3802320361,
0.0471486673,
0.2731254101,
-0.7634084225,
-0.0968754143,
-0.6437543035,
-0.1206025109,
-0.1908082068,
0.2199283689,
-0.4322653115,
-0.6838170886,
-0.2411460131,
-0.4082995355,
0.5691523552,
0.6094309688,
-0.1682327837,
0.8183056712,
-0.6374750137,
0.0318593532,
0.3474940062,
0.0575383976,
0.1189754456,
-1.0580618382,
-0.3939700425,
0.0018937793,
-0.313067168,
-0.8038503528,
0.488019526,
0.1773197353,
0.1640385985,
0.7077608109,
-0.1984973103,
1.1224966049,
-0.3204823434,
0.5525128245,
0.2228118628,
-0.9387841225,
0.5104705095,
-0.1757365614,
0.4391097128,
0.6790413857,
0.5861475468,
-0.7244889736,
-0.5170419812,
-0.5442128778,
-0.6803815961,
0.4222267866,
0.1046856865,
0.3695657849,
0.2089601904,
-0.0092458259,
0.2784976065,
0.3791589439,
-0.8095544577,
-0.1568585783,
-0.5314003229,
-0.0024984116,
-0.2153083533,
-0.1242334321,
0.5747432113,
-0.5776278377,
0.8490715027,
0.0295582172,
-0.1354626715,
0.0441820323,
-0.7694716454,
-0.0420566685,
-0.0093977116,
0.5309624672,
0.8354454637,
-0.1718202084,
0.1178505123,
0.226420179,
-0.9607291818,
0.4641372859,
0.231707409,
0.1183846146,
0.262866348,
0.3571451902,
0.5970973372,
0.3998028934,
-0.8227189779,
0.4891705215,
-0.1493170261,
0.06055969,
-0.2838762403,
-0.2463807315,
-0.0993180275,
-0.2987163663,
0.4805969894,
0.1132953763,
-0.1867415458,
-0.3889643252,
0.3046582639,
0.3309737444,
-0.7534095049,
-0.64691329,
0.7140572667,
0.0901598111,
-0.0948909521,
0.6832270622,
-0.0825145096,
-0.6524167657,
0.0340856053,
0.2275074571,
0.9072651863,
-0.5754036903,
0.1079088748,
0.4432536066,
0.3850120008,
-0.0180285815,
0.1937237531,
-0.2573958039,
-0.7757959366,
-0.5287738442,
-0.4526140094,
-0.140922606,
0.280052036,
-0.6965660453,
0.3592424989,
-0.3379025161,
-0.0925844237,
-0.4533478618,
0.2332556993,
-0.7129748464,
0.0588453971,
-0.6309788823,
0.8476786613,
-0.651915133,
1.1305342913,
0.6071386933,
-0.6444017291,
-1.0412353277,
0.1532074064,
-0.3962448835,
-0.9077260494,
0.9691205621,
0.1683701873,
-0.1562543511,
0.2502371073,
0.0274137612,
-0.7256768942,
1.1202162504,
0.2368884385,
-0.2435808778,
-0.151940003,
0.2279755026,
0.4130669832,
-0.0615629926,
0.0987742767,
0.8622968793,
0.3573253751,
-0.1627514362,
-0.9983878136,
-0.1419792324,
-0.0884268507,
0.0426927656,
0.0180505235,
-0.3949304521,
0.8026193976,
-0.2148910165,
-0.2202611268,
0.4749013782,
1.080925703,
0.1177210733,
-0.4929976463,
0.2036595047,
0.4108659625,
0.8705934882,
-0.009915268,
0.7360865474,
-0.5379251838,
0.3363326192,
0.8216367364,
-0.2501807511,
0.8764900565,
0.6203157306,
-0.3607265949,
0.7573164105,
0.7355402112,
0.2851014733,
0.531529665,
0.3199873567,
-0.3382841349,
0.0931534842,
-0.1791235209,
-0.3433622718,
0.8081663251,
0.0616558492,
-0.2815717161,
-0.1381431967,
0.4377734363,
0.1875553876,
-0.1056437418,
-0.324744314,
0.4516717196,
0.3697746098,
-0.8281127214,
0.513247788,
0.2456359118,
0.9289676547,
-0.7827427983,
0.277731806,
-0.5450603366,
0.3908732533,
-0.0688257515,
-0.2002476007,
0.1755460501,
-0.1702186614,
0.4506063163,
-0.0304520875,
0.6412872672,
-0.617542088,
-0.6012995839,
0.0719540566,
0.7623469234,
0.1129197106,
0.0595470332,
-0.3606458306,
-0.3260115087,
-0.1386290938,
0.0118247177,
0.1702239513,
0.6290998459,
0.0029302549,
0.6482355595,
0.45007056,
0.6355196834,
-0.0110936267,
-0.1018341482,
0.6161164641,
-0.4596970379,
-0.7298167944,
-0.8869490027,
0.3703632355,
0.2208804339,
-0.4586159587,
1.0350173712,
0.5680110455,
0.8229605556,
-0.1836864948,
0.6838847995,
0.3307764828,
0.5482367277,
-0.4007205665,
0.8682788014,
-0.4027259648,
0.0844554529,
-0.5086532235,
-0.9143533111,
-0.2202842236,
0.8545509577,
-0.2667398751,
0.0715792701,
0.8583400846,
0.8198647499,
-0.4664736986,
-0.0386668742,
0.3254093826,
0.0468435958,
0.2220032662,
0.3997681439,
1.0072700977,
-0.5518268347,
0.6800296307,
-0.3526885211,
0.2379844189,
-0.1009479761,
-0.6926100254,
-0.9506188035,
-0.8106695414,
-0.3864564002,
-0.2738274932,
-0.0143542709,
1.0572936535,
0.7176962495,
-1.1132785082,
-0.6635826826,
-0.3617287874,
0.1601328403,
-0.0013543426,
-0.2281077206,
0.5152014494,
-0.2743379474,
-0.6460931897,
0.0627936274,
0.1975149214,
0.5027161241,
-0.8067593575,
-0.2455437928,
0.1177144274,
-0.1063035503,
0.4739596844,
0.3260109127,
-0.3731225729,
-0.109796524,
0.0299177077,
0.1492841244,
0.2802181542,
1.2407209873,
-0.8782961369,
0.3741541803,
0.265924871,
0.6890493631,
0.317982465,
-0.0381237231,
0.9687568545,
-0.4972781241,
0.6140959263,
0.1648068279,
0.4198973477,
0.66128093,
0.1472373605,
0.0231788494,
0.2522034049,
-0.2230989039,
-0.9897501469,
0.1942658126,
-0.0824733227,
-0.1996818781,
0.7052385211,
-0.3137814999,
-0.2093304098,
-0.3115681708,
-0.2527912855,
0.306735307,
-0.0360827148,
0.6914334893,
0.7660105824,
0.3557845354,
-0.3240790367,
-0.4336597323,
0.7927865386,
0.6236322522,
-0.5593174696,
0.0927732959,
0.114944458,
0.2419352084,
0.0052815904,
0.9361169934,
0.0753761008,
0.5339360833,
-0.291693598,
-0.286064744,
0.3549815118,
-0.154933393,
-0.4662568271,
-0.1088729724,
0.697147429,
-0.4035655856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12474v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12474v1
|
CSMeD: Bridging the Dataset Gap in Automated Citation Screening for Systematic Literature Reviews
| 2023-11-21T09:36:11 | 2023-11-21T09:36:11 |
Wojciech Kusa, Oscar E. Mendoza, Matthias Samwald, Petr Knoth, Allan Hanbury
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Systematic literature reviews (SLRs) play an essential role in summarising,
synthesising and validating scientific evidence. In recent years, there has
been a growing interest in using machine learning techniques to automate the
identification of relevant studies for SLRs. However, the lack of standardised
evaluation datasets makes comparing the performance of such automated
literature screening systems difficult. In this paper, we analyse the citation
screening evaluation datasets, revealing that many of the available datasets
are either too small, suffer from data leakage or have limited applicability to
systems treating automated literature screening as a classification task, as
opposed to, for example, a retrieval or question-answering task. To address
these challenges, we introduce CSMeD, a meta-dataset consolidating nine
publicly released collections, providing unified access to 325 SLRs from the
fields of medicine and computer science. CSMeD serves as a comprehensive
resource for training and evaluating the performance of automated citation
screening models. Additionally, we introduce CSMeD-FT, a new dataset designed
explicitly for evaluating the full text publication screening task. To
demonstrate the utility of CSMeD, we conduct experiments and establish
baselines on new datasets.
|
[
-0.2084834576,
0.1770054698,
0.7084260583,
0.0785737559,
-0.2030985355,
0.2371405959,
0.029376667,
-0.3674648404,
-0.0076003373,
0.4898203611,
-0.4574364424,
-0.47086519,
-0.5694255829,
0.4374754131,
-0.5632742047,
1.0962805748,
-0.229326725,
0.5606668591,
-0.3775589168,
-0.3732140958,
-0.1125271469,
-0.319129616,
0.1866215616,
-0.5457299948,
0.8235687613,
0.1868299246,
0.6598320603,
0.3661994934,
0.7666888833,
0.1256310195,
0.0016498809,
0.3026121259,
-0.2929343879,
0.2335889935,
-0.4567568898,
-0.2342895865,
0.0881460011,
-0.0068784822,
0.5447673202,
1.0346336365,
0.0218798686,
0.5118957162,
0.2865237296,
1.0389959812,
-0.7378553748,
-0.2138243616,
-0.3931063116,
0.3422623873,
-0.076161854,
-0.3041941226,
-0.4077250957,
-0.632709682,
0.1981035322,
-0.3971972764,
0.2980027199,
0.1428046227,
0.8808739781,
0.3521099389,
-0.4987669885,
-0.4804878831,
-0.702475071,
0.9113759995,
-0.2560684681,
0.0298813842,
0.167626068,
0.5091331601,
-0.0076412829,
-0.5561681986,
0.0174229797,
-0.3516921103,
-0.4072327316,
-0.1540633589,
-0.3011117578,
0.0977177173,
0.148006171,
0.3192542791,
-0.9845132828,
-0.108693786,
-0.6522026658,
-0.3994867504,
0.6302575469,
0.2611060441,
0.0550360195,
-0.1717989594,
-0.1069398671,
0.0758315027,
-0.5649101734,
-0.1955195963,
-0.0428093523,
0.2467676699,
0.3649122715,
0.3715080321,
-0.0255605988,
0.5988811851,
-0.0085232416,
0.3907766938,
0.3038252592,
-0.546754539,
-0.3111922443,
-0.0241736043,
0.7912723422,
0.0462146476,
0.0994075313,
0.0200553443,
0.0068753394,
-0.1632561982,
0.3683805168,
-0.7567762733,
-0.2066300064,
0.4602583349,
-0.8400993943,
-0.4815722704,
0.2648021877,
-0.5086765289,
-0.5527986288,
-0.5113228559,
0.0631153584,
-0.1493035108,
0.1322592199,
-0.0171784051,
-0.2491930425,
0.0565028638,
0.248130247,
0.0029469815,
0.4632650614,
0.2820067704,
0.7836883068,
-0.2732636034,
-0.0724314153,
-0.2834406793,
0.0175431166,
-0.5566470027,
0.7886946797,
-0.4289647043,
-0.348035872,
0.1438892037,
0.1867605597,
-0.206550613,
-0.4578529298,
0.7178561687,
-0.4018608928,
0.1578822583,
-0.4960163534,
-0.2018236816,
0.0502184443,
0.2431378663,
-0.7570406795,
0.6848112345,
-0.0530858748,
-0.991124332,
0.4079988897,
-0.4711446464,
-0.3310036063,
-0.0496307462,
-0.2953359783,
-0.6379022002,
0.0674400851,
0.2992316484,
0.0784570351,
-0.4093103707,
0.3695539236,
-0.7336340547,
-0.6304714084,
0.3985818028,
0.0185936559,
0.9949634671,
0.6534616947,
-0.2059962153,
0.1868415922,
-0.480809629,
0.3929212987,
-0.1769998819,
0.0828547031,
-0.4331690967,
-0.0040731821,
0.321526289,
0.3630343378,
-0.2595175505,
-0.4829180837,
0.1780139506,
-0.0787529796,
0.2442377657,
0.5230340362,
0.1780860424,
0.3948333263,
-0.466845125,
0.5146833062,
0.0776914805,
0.2836886942,
-0.159917146,
-0.061808303,
-0.4839796424,
-0.2934965789,
0.8777464628,
0.3721013069,
-0.623740375,
0.5175325274,
-0.1856079996,
-0.5538980365,
-0.6602036357,
0.0511851385,
0.3492794335,
0.1589490622,
0.0748387501,
-0.34989658,
-0.6765262485,
-1.0239495039,
-0.4037549496,
-0.0233142506,
-0.2433435917,
0.5489839315,
0.7967812419,
-0.3293217421,
1.0536693335,
-0.5457212925,
-0.6182768345,
-0.2126560658,
0.1878991276,
0.1534180343,
0.3890152574,
0.2722838819,
-0.6298682094,
-0.3726429343,
-0.1651019752,
-0.976718545,
-0.5103728771,
-0.2486355752,
-0.0640600696,
-0.0809052214,
0.5123043656,
-0.0694831312,
0.43672809,
0.3145536482,
-0.1043260694,
0.4312608242,
-0.1014850065,
0.4020746648,
-0.4830519855,
0.6257539988,
0.0551152714,
-0.0703902766,
-0.3557052314,
-0.2275200337,
0.3005903661,
-0.3543474972,
-0.028546473,
0.1116688102,
-0.7399432659,
-0.228069216,
-0.3694304824,
-0.2203635126,
0.1267217994,
0.0225863848,
0.0018707041,
0.3922045529,
0.3063008487,
-0.5011394024,
-0.3586862683,
0.1468027681,
-0.1024989709,
0.2744380236,
-0.6781207323,
-0.0728425905,
-0.2977701426,
0.8595448732,
-0.8744186163,
-0.2043320984,
0.011842832,
-0.3650663495,
0.1461794823,
-0.2574391365,
-0.4511582851,
-0.6813642383,
-0.6245382428,
0.1869034171,
0.1216506809,
-0.3079075813,
0.3191322088,
0.5334730744,
-0.2102293223,
-0.7711455822,
-0.6672610641,
0.1423169225,
0.1549366862,
-0.384929657,
0.3356304467,
0.1002980322,
-0.2252288312,
0.1212130263,
-0.0477409028,
-0.3581342995,
-0.1113590524,
0.2035523057,
0.3805567622,
0.2252949774,
0.2176745683,
0.403871119,
-0.0412133038,
0.138842538,
-0.2756271064,
0.0290503744,
-0.0392125174,
-0.6848195195,
-0.1156777963,
0.2733636796,
0.5685150027,
-0.0913783982,
0.0580214299,
0.5212403536,
-0.2627926767,
-0.1557014287,
-0.3813938498,
-0.1165525243,
-0.3231765032,
0.0234175511,
0.0258786306,
-0.8292619586,
0.3346825242,
-0.0202656183,
0.2016154081,
0.5432090759,
0.4132222235,
-0.3729472756,
0.9093655944,
0.398250401,
-0.1936576813,
0.1746640354,
-0.0848198608,
0.152946651,
-0.6747589707,
0.0166209303,
-0.8582497835,
-0.4064397812,
-0.4549228251,
-0.5138850808,
0.5294792652,
-0.2912056744,
-0.0641938522,
-0.0053129042,
-0.8905507922,
0.5304511786,
0.3783789873,
0.1040113643,
0.4547635317,
0.0866374001,
-0.4533939958,
-0.1181415021,
-0.6695675254,
-0.5839710236,
1.4559646845,
0.3244076073,
0.6234440207,
-0.4694572091,
0.6857052445,
0.695199728,
0.3965322077,
-0.3693347871,
0.3556888103,
0.0649807528,
-0.9115111232,
0.078899473,
-0.3419829607,
-1.0723785162,
0.3737480342,
-0.0686493069,
-0.090746671,
0.740788281,
0.1351061016,
-0.397010088,
0.0485541001,
-0.2530225217,
0.3791474998,
-0.1981720179,
-0.4222678244,
-0.1821133345,
-0.8858023286,
0.5720331073,
-0.0587142929,
0.2659694552,
0.1525179744,
0.0506893098,
0.602216661,
-0.4866770506,
0.6309896111,
-0.1737535447,
0.3510199189,
0.4623987973,
-0.0190412309,
0.1460090131,
0.038774766,
0.1177520156,
0.4227482677,
0.2639164329,
-0.4779353738,
-0.0671745166,
0.5367281437,
-0.4729587734,
0.1286924183,
-1.2068046331,
-0.4022919238,
-0.164882049,
0.2109727114,
0.193814978,
0.093569845,
-0.2685484588,
0.0927337632,
0.7616497874,
-0.2469315976,
0.1402284801,
0.6863074899,
-0.1348169893,
-0.6090683341,
0.6202083826,
0.2475383878,
-0.1142891943,
0.0577842332,
0.0592719987,
-0.1377978623,
-0.6208619475,
-0.516161561,
-0.0036268369,
-0.2949444056,
-0.3525004983,
-0.6673715115,
-0.3045463562,
-0.2909621894,
-0.0500580296,
0.1274262369,
-0.2609238327,
0.0002828562,
0.0280126538,
0.0665489361,
0.6436920166,
-0.2367207408,
-0.1758719981,
-0.6826389432,
0.0450733118,
-0.1469095796,
0.3221841753,
-0.0562926307,
-0.3376559317,
-0.3735813797,
-0.3593708575,
-0.4915241599,
-0.8053096533,
0.3695693016,
0.0946207345,
0.4880664647,
0.4100550711,
0.1619654298,
0.6043574214,
-0.4887405038,
0.5658445358,
0.0152164949,
-0.4826015532,
0.6074260473,
-0.4917116463,
0.3769958615,
1.1973893642,
0.6196315289,
-0.3296230435,
-0.210053578,
-0.408693701,
-0.917714715,
0.6767393947,
0.4044867158,
-0.5624397397,
0.2416116893,
-0.0842393786,
0.1018116251,
0.3163379729,
-0.490922004,
-0.1742116362,
0.1462403238,
-0.3381000161,
0.0744416565,
0.0151825026,
-0.540484488,
-0.2813792825,
0.7327224016,
-0.3041116893,
0.3317530453,
0.676175952,
-0.6053114533,
-0.2218457311,
0.2927065194,
0.3005732596,
0.6003230214,
-0.2540634871,
-0.0970746055,
-0.0763537735,
-0.9622356296,
0.0721438006,
0.450743109,
-0.4429366291,
0.38408342,
0.1999279261,
-0.0120238243,
0.2480403632,
-0.9078777432,
0.4346767962,
-0.1543526053,
-0.5182788968,
-0.441154629,
-0.3240512311,
-0.3102327287,
-0.2168176323,
0.6862505078,
0.4542379677,
0.7057517171,
-0.1761874259,
0.5304828882,
0.295800209,
-0.8588730693,
0.0517508052,
0.1810478568,
0.0514310636,
0.3892514706,
0.354742378,
-0.0871715546,
-0.3687894642,
0.4840885401,
-0.0533878766,
0.8577458262,
0.0116251837,
0.1783039719,
0.4915873408,
0.4924053848,
-0.0166736878,
0.1497235596,
-0.0492799133,
0.02555052,
-0.4352475405,
-0.4371518493,
-0.6989408731,
0.1052703112,
-0.7913803458,
0.3332888186,
-0.3013159633,
-0.0247792266,
0.0126767606,
0.1831431836,
-0.3912018239,
0.077432096,
0.1855437607,
0.9745568633,
-1.0903996229,
0.6148384213,
0.4125669301,
-0.4569119513,
-0.258690536,
-0.0720457509,
0.361402899,
-0.2407677025,
0.3665260077,
0.246183753,
0.0207354687,
-0.5688707829,
-0.4847423732,
-0.8649662733,
1.1504548788,
0.0389819108,
-0.8287366629,
-0.1545560062,
0.0883810967,
0.6533144712,
-0.4482090473,
0.5162568092,
0.519541502,
0.4543519318,
0.1258976609,
-0.7223889828,
0.0067820321,
-0.4671251774,
-0.041200459,
0.0601548962,
-0.2539994717,
0.4512250721,
-0.2708816528,
-0.0149088986,
0.1970290989,
0.3279415965,
0.5347527266,
0.7245594859,
0.6200116873,
0.3725038469,
0.9725391269,
-0.2154219151,
0.7559021711,
-0.2408733666,
0.2676968873,
0.9827015996,
-0.7899084091,
0.4986066222,
0.3812238872,
-0.1833050102,
0.6205969453,
0.871122539,
-0.4845275879,
0.4091147184,
0.6174488068,
0.0050470759,
-0.0992007926,
-0.0285565294,
-0.378146261,
-0.0979046673,
0.3852312565,
-1.0210728645,
-0.3721287549,
0.2088958323,
-0.1920235902,
0.1204938367,
-0.498575747,
0.7140132189,
0.1163236871,
-0.6183360219,
0.5184668899,
-0.3175574243,
0.4477636516,
-0.6176767349,
0.1144019067,
0.0319083296,
0.3051227927,
-0.6425455809,
-0.5469611287,
0.4938093126,
0.2634107471,
-0.419043839,
-0.0851883292,
1.1779680252,
-0.0335672908,
-0.6842622161,
0.1991360933,
0.4672194123,
0.2816019952,
0.1118646711,
-1.0129497051,
0.1604147404,
-0.0791781843,
-0.0324111804,
0.6634435654,
0.1221340001,
-0.3687340617,
0.5180165172,
0.6818884611,
0.1847600937,
-0.3479603529,
0.2116558105,
0.9387207627,
-0.7064678669,
-0.3701190352,
-0.5886975527,
0.342913568,
-0.4975868165,
-0.1077938303,
0.7314884067,
0.8892492652,
0.2550784051,
0.0255303476,
1.1312534809,
-0.0398139432,
0.9387928843,
0.1302555054,
0.966039598,
-0.1830178201,
0.2670142055,
-0.3434342146,
-0.3927943408,
-0.517039299,
0.4756495953,
-0.4177885354,
0.0036350414,
0.9176292419,
0.5584873557,
0.067109555,
0.0955687016,
-0.0929947346,
0.1163133606,
0.1623097062,
0.2452623993,
0.5385881066,
-0.4850534201,
0.7798058987,
0.0770277232,
-0.3037693202,
-0.3526537716,
-0.8383594155,
-0.7072932124,
-0.339227736,
-0.3102899194,
-0.7175388336,
0.4489434659,
0.7513644099,
0.7880440354,
-0.9280132651,
-0.2327707857,
-0.1176248044,
0.1366641372,
-0.4282051027,
-0.1798687279,
0.4491660595,
-0.5826685429,
-0.2491900474,
0.1460103989,
0.0991057083,
-0.4424090683,
-0.4245343208,
0.1096288413,
-0.1355968565,
0.1154332608,
0.2685913146,
0.4384762645,
-0.3004521728,
0.3998256326,
0.1162439808,
-0.4029067457,
-0.1853515953,
1.1289812326,
-1.0887608528,
0.3694947362,
0.438701421,
0.5423271656,
0.523132205,
-0.237006709,
0.6244374514,
-0.4349249899,
-0.4495861828,
0.7024911642,
0.3804200292,
0.2005530298,
-0.1787462682,
0.7051168084,
0.1393451691,
-0.8820446134,
-1.3831356764,
-0.1360440999,
-0.9332449436,
-0.4734600484,
1.0002871752,
0.0404649265,
-0.3350380361,
-0.5812741518,
-0.1155481413,
-0.2237515748,
-0.2482056767,
0.6889500618,
0.5264360309,
-0.1566162705,
0.4853247404,
-0.4998319149,
0.5600655079,
0.2680552602,
-0.6652033925,
0.1889513731,
0.5286813974,
0.4166764617,
0.2332811654,
0.667473197,
-0.5951859355,
0.615537703,
-0.3738211989,
0.2428275049,
0.0012192304,
-0.212296769,
-0.8136500716,
0.3475688696,
-0.2176246941,
0.0614607185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12468v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12468v1
|
Analysis of Visual Features for Continuous Lipreading in Spanish
| 2023-11-21T09:28:00 | 2023-11-21T09:28:00 |
David Gimeno-Gómez, Carlos-D. Martínez-Hinarejos
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
During a conversation, our brain is responsible for combining information
obtained from multiple senses in order to improve our ability to understand the
message we are perceiving. Different studies have shown the importance of
presenting visual information in these situations. Nevertheless, lipreading is
a complex task whose objective is to interpret speech when audio is not
available. By dispensing with a sense as crucial as hearing, it will be
necessary to be aware of the challenge that this lack presents. In this paper,
we propose an analysis of different speech visual features with the intention
of identifying which of them is the best approach to capture the nature of lip
movements for natural Spanish and, in this way, dealing with the automatic
visual speech recognition task. In order to estimate our system, we present an
audiovisual corpus compiled from a subset of the RTVE database, which has been
used in the Albayz\'in evaluations. We employ a traditional system based on
Hidden Markov Models with Gaussian Mixture Models. Results show that, although
the task is difficult, in restricted conditions we obtain recognition results
which determine that using eigenlips in combination with deep features is the
best visual approach.
|
[
-0.6110002398,
-0.7728312612,
0.3103175163,
0.4690495729,
-0.4241939783,
0.1003397778,
-0.1606189311,
-0.7726560831,
0.2181452513,
0.7835981846,
-0.7668364644,
-0.7468352914,
-0.5090476274,
-0.1486258954,
-0.6131544113,
0.6740674973,
0.1312296689,
0.2001948208,
0.0001020526,
-0.3031510711,
-0.7445251346,
-0.0755398944,
-0.2860480249,
-0.0205272287,
0.3723693788,
0.3431241512,
0.4131912589,
0.7748622894,
0.4845526218,
0.3494693637,
-0.03997517,
-0.0479878709,
-0.1829241663,
0.3249929845,
-0.0458751321,
-0.4797443449,
-0.0288845152,
-0.2796621621,
0.6350582838,
0.6463306546,
-0.2297873348,
0.0579409972,
0.1602111757,
0.5800366402,
-0.2765500546,
0.315202117,
-0.4129546285,
0.4375501871,
-0.3698294163,
-0.2129916549,
0.1572704464,
-0.4016182125,
0.8307052255,
-0.3816269338,
0.4588795602,
0.0065634069,
0.8204600811,
0.4244169295,
-0.2000161856,
-0.704598546,
-0.918119967,
0.7233649492,
-0.0711616427,
0.75506109,
0.2618863285,
0.4802160263,
-0.099231191,
-0.3824059963,
-0.5445831418,
-0.5965697169,
0.568471849,
0.3221678138,
-0.4703673124,
0.1055330336,
0.0890246257,
0.3363835812,
-0.5347387195,
0.1691920906,
-0.2176776528,
-0.6377157569,
0.0190761499,
-0.0834702477,
0.955809474,
-0.0167680867,
-0.4196842313,
-0.4950367808,
-0.2787240744,
0.4495864511,
0.2559117079,
0.086651735,
-0.2815850973,
0.6912223697,
-0.0437904596,
0.9057670832,
-0.4566691816,
-0.5214956999,
0.198981151,
-0.2110290825,
-0.4419775307,
-0.0703965425,
0.5634316206,
0.4083712995,
0.4890010357,
0.0442123078,
-0.044667948,
0.3408617973,
-0.0820696875,
-0.4444869459,
-0.3393061161,
0.1779135019,
-0.2185857743,
-0.1289462745,
0.1217497438,
-0.9963618517,
-0.1419122815,
-0.4979071915,
0.0422821492,
-0.5323835015,
-0.0494127087,
0.1185979471,
-0.4052599967,
0.0911200866,
0.5536100268,
-0.6610091329,
0.5230958462,
0.2690981627,
0.9257468581,
-0.1808641404,
-0.1149437949,
-0.6398050785,
0.1434289962,
-0.184601143,
0.8597180843,
-0.4091442525,
-0.2741603255,
0.0777669698,
0.1180075407,
-0.1510101706,
-0.6497517228,
0.7469955087,
-0.0900858119,
-0.0522339493,
-0.4227309227,
-0.2702268064,
-0.3571951389,
-0.2355450094,
-0.754884541,
0.85561198,
-0.2632890642,
-0.5780664086,
0.6808078885,
-0.2667354643,
-0.2155252397,
0.1136777252,
-0.3436492682,
-0.364126265,
0.1193526462,
0.5893947482,
0.3244471252,
-0.0264672861,
-0.1039469838,
-0.2307934761,
0.0276605692,
0.6517724991,
-0.3097836673,
0.4591451585,
0.1464202404,
-0.2730106413,
0.1389814019,
-0.8233464956,
-0.1244003177,
-0.2791914642,
-0.1312196106,
-0.3449036181,
0.0192926303,
0.2373214066,
0.0025145675,
0.1408749372,
-0.5719313622,
-0.2365211248,
-0.462741375,
0.1851316541,
0.387884587,
0.3157368004,
0.3625336885,
-0.1734004468,
0.7108162642,
0.0923959613,
0.2508236468,
-0.0219654366,
-0.5825006366,
-0.85873276,
-0.950663805,
0.2537875772,
0.9068691134,
-0.8237121701,
0.0787648782,
0.0453485288,
-0.2065007836,
-0.4950979948,
0.3017714024,
0.6181342602,
0.5881530046,
0.3436994255,
-0.2524585426,
-0.5717583895,
-0.9981116652,
0.0671657547,
0.1286622584,
-0.349566102,
0.5250352025,
0.538181603,
0.1223618761,
0.7381902337,
-0.1680731624,
-0.7644348145,
-0.1167635173,
0.0293318555,
0.2428849339,
0.3211830854,
0.6742912531,
-0.5739161968,
-0.2588026524,
0.3613331616,
-0.725869596,
-0.2770769596,
0.0895953998,
-0.034397468,
-0.1995185912,
0.4302090108,
-0.1747279912,
0.5989209414,
0.4883723557,
-0.0285009705,
-0.0307090804,
-0.3464839458,
0.1321779639,
-0.2976590395,
-0.139138177,
0.5785554647,
-0.2725528181,
-0.5986573696,
-0.311081022,
-0.0575144477,
-0.2306710929,
-0.6756893396,
0.4137468338,
-0.806429565,
-0.3267004192,
-0.1254410446,
0.2579556704,
-0.0903560594,
0.4926972389,
0.2161138803,
0.5406972766,
0.9344329238,
-0.5968700051,
0.6181254983,
0.1233916134,
-0.7749932408,
0.701479733,
-0.9123940468,
-0.0738732517,
-0.2916169763,
-0.228296116,
-1.219050765,
-0.1084979177,
0.4720465541,
-0.3284195065,
0.1358004957,
-0.3629964292,
-0.0533834808,
-0.3908371031,
-0.069810614,
-0.1146532446,
0.3698087633,
-0.493209362,
0.466490984,
0.7772158384,
-0.3287852705,
-0.6835787892,
-0.7611603141,
0.2068201602,
-0.4348737895,
-0.8174858093,
0.3458894789,
0.358553797,
-0.1836787313,
-0.1217345148,
-0.2315931618,
0.0104526011,
-0.2694968879,
0.368298173,
0.3245578408,
0.0330040455,
-0.1251330376,
0.0065572914,
0.024872439,
-0.2933264673,
-0.2503681481,
0.3876740932,
-0.2972647846,
-0.1621798724,
-0.9752005935,
0.4166618586,
0.8434419632,
-0.4732449949,
0.2865079045,
0.6174473763,
-0.4125681221,
-0.2436520457,
-0.6937848926,
0.1598393172,
-0.3801014721,
0.2964480519,
-0.6545835733,
-0.4546021223,
1.0232228041,
0.2369143069,
-0.5453135967,
-0.0356722511,
0.5233300328,
-0.6805856824,
0.8824314475,
0.8850754499,
0.1238103732,
0.9426147342,
-0.290694952,
-0.3030667603,
-0.8103151321,
-0.7206920385,
-0.7413756847,
-0.1285785437,
-0.3606484532,
-0.4546866417,
0.3962846994,
-0.0443141945,
0.4693942368,
0.2056332976,
-0.4587887824,
0.3853919506,
0.6309936047,
0.398046881,
0.1463602334,
0.2112656534,
-0.5985639691,
-0.4059186876,
-0.4396894872,
-0.3780324757,
0.5796527267,
0.6008458138,
0.7649472952,
0.2577687204,
0.3071110249,
0.2512204349,
-0.117739521,
-1.0470366478,
0.668200016,
-0.0779296383,
0.0205354542,
-0.571218729,
-0.1992878616,
-1.0415438414,
0.452298224,
-0.4103921354,
-0.8573468328,
0.7574169636,
0.0769069269,
-0.1303237826,
-0.3188366592,
-0.5775157213,
0.9722740054,
-0.3580124676,
-0.1896405369,
0.0013369815,
-0.4361640513,
0.0795158297,
0.4320901632,
0.206505388,
-0.0804483518,
-0.294709295,
0.7883953452,
-0.4694665968,
0.8309109211,
-0.2374994308,
0.1037528291,
0.3627145588,
0.0418187268,
0.1846123785,
-0.1389362961,
0.5149971247,
-0.048425477,
0.1161113307,
-0.1764534861,
-0.605538547,
0.5853507519,
-0.6105335951,
-0.1878626198,
-0.5845023394,
-0.2243431807,
-0.0991803408,
0.0269450508,
0.124011904,
0.4486864805,
-0.6462407708,
0.224755913,
0.7808699012,
-0.2537133098,
0.5465019941,
0.3527531624,
-0.4601334035,
-0.6817540526,
1.0125081539,
0.3348217309,
-0.1080355197,
0.3952517509,
0.2207170725,
-0.7193534374,
-1.019308567,
-0.4461909831,
0.3430683017,
-0.6777102351,
0.3034796119,
-0.5755215287,
0.2980667651,
-0.02860507,
0.355139941,
-0.0116158752,
-0.1732791811,
-0.5406646132,
-0.1120160744,
0.1150221229,
0.2987775505,
0.0204240344,
0.2079130113,
-0.6555536389,
0.6749911904,
0.6811237335,
0.0580477938,
-0.1687859446,
-0.3015402853,
-0.0110791689,
-0.1694203913,
-0.0062285904,
-1.2296147346,
0.8238220215,
0.461376667,
0.7285276055,
0.3132878244,
-0.3451910913,
0.8633618355,
-0.3960710168,
0.1988309026,
0.1752805412,
-0.9855947495,
1.0151588917,
-0.4562236369,
0.1753058732,
0.4901548028,
0.3088053763,
-0.62872082,
-0.5183100104,
-0.2546954453,
-0.6184868813,
0.1822718233,
0.2611337602,
-0.2789202034,
-0.0625474155,
-0.1018024459,
-0.1466967165,
0.3259097338,
-0.3654858172,
0.2125398368,
-0.4877436161,
-0.1756085157,
0.2689754963,
0.0168619845,
-0.2393112481,
-0.3430697918,
0.088504225,
-0.0016134208,
0.0056157284,
0.4011540413,
-0.4569663107,
0.0901009142,
0.0499886237,
0.7513039112,
0.4284248948,
-0.3336938024,
-0.1041153073,
-0.0943477675,
-0.8558086157,
-0.1086516827,
-0.1813087612,
-0.0175020173,
0.2622964084,
0.2638635635,
1.0366488695,
0.166556716,
-0.9061225057,
0.6058989167,
-0.10190586,
0.108345069,
-0.6186745167,
0.1716946065,
-0.1369417161,
0.444121033,
0.4116405845,
0.3034909964,
0.4130036831,
-0.7392485738,
0.1587123424,
0.4214738905,
-0.412948519,
-0.0558826104,
0.3406477869,
0.3214286566,
-0.2638324797,
0.5454315543,
0.3051580191,
-0.4108221531,
0.938959837,
0.2856278121,
0.7358300686,
-0.3009877205,
0.2883841693,
0.0763551146,
0.2012217492,
-0.0656958595,
0.4700931907,
-0.2667931914,
-0.8658821583,
-0.254273206,
-0.623139143,
-0.7001237869,
0.0007071752,
-0.8784441948,
0.2787145972,
-0.468325913,
-0.1406583339,
0.1172127426,
-0.4167378843,
-0.8583652377,
0.3295959532,
0.2049748152,
0.3667344749,
-1.0126206875,
0.8827013373,
0.3262436986,
-0.3534649909,
-0.246523425,
-0.304390043,
0.1430245489,
-0.9002606273,
0.7614734173,
-0.0017850845,
-0.5469127893,
-0.2077826113,
-0.1467818618,
-0.7459740043,
0.8258188963,
0.3437883258,
-0.8240427971,
0.1656987369,
0.0582504943,
0.7821562886,
-0.4629688561,
0.0832713768,
0.6134312153,
0.4579454958,
0.3867972791,
-0.9707891345,
-0.3998732269,
-0.2462715805,
0.3834368289,
-0.0255273301,
-0.2445148081,
0.5212289095,
-0.0864067525,
-0.6119523644,
0.0221225843,
0.7995337248,
0.1458431929,
0.0750671551,
0.47024858,
0.5371621251,
0.9810840487,
-0.2507721484,
0.9033190012,
0.0373972021,
0.0674084648,
0.992885232,
0.1150930747,
0.8632242084,
0.4987028837,
-0.1977916509,
0.1512476057,
0.6017072201,
-0.2442378551,
0.7628808618,
0.2948863208,
-0.3358035386,
-0.0504257716,
-0.2876556814,
-0.2569843233,
0.8290986419,
0.7404983044,
-0.1930470318,
0.0145725403,
0.8306898475,
-0.3309445381,
0.1459887624,
-0.3595177531,
0.6195803881,
-0.0324375331,
-0.4400809705,
0.4976548851,
-0.4147120118,
0.4963285923,
-0.1594891846,
-0.1878397912,
-0.0322795212,
-0.1025563106,
-0.1425775588,
-0.9021885395,
0.2455128282,
0.0609021634,
-0.010967195,
-0.3021477461,
0.4763330817,
-0.501144886,
-0.5933692455,
0.2989887297,
0.5721946359,
0.3369029462,
0.0402634926,
-0.7840471864,
0.4224816263,
0.1427505463,
0.0129731223,
0.0059917313,
0.5500333309,
-0.0030717917,
0.9308916926,
0.7127333879,
0.4148570597,
0.2835550606,
0.6460937858,
0.4401153326,
-0.7999783158,
-0.6628757119,
-0.7405773997,
0.5049891472,
-0.0736577436,
-0.3408689201,
0.6209410429,
0.1645732671,
0.54982692,
-0.3187227249,
0.5719048381,
0.4691793621,
0.6721276641,
-0.9014638066,
0.508284986,
-0.0570316873,
0.4247699976,
-0.4683579206,
-1.0954064131,
-0.3530742824,
0.9094385505,
-0.125984624,
-0.2793921232,
0.6054461598,
0.6240208745,
0.035255421,
-0.020551851,
0.4549023807,
0.1336213648,
0.2371693254,
0.3749717474,
1.0688542128,
-0.001751886,
0.5288706422,
-0.3358098865,
-0.5023969412,
-0.221641019,
-0.8020728827,
-0.9715521336,
-0.602373898,
-0.399271369,
-0.0683902875,
0.0435256064,
0.4626719654,
0.589902997,
-0.6296695471,
-0.4154060781,
-0.1234487295,
0.080942601,
-0.2791605294,
-0.1544399559,
0.2283676714,
0.2215583026,
-0.9386521578,
0.5203954577,
0.591527462,
0.664350152,
-0.2939760089,
0.3520978093,
0.2244951278,
-0.1002580598,
0.3678365648,
0.7967051268,
-0.8426316977,
-0.3907800317,
0.1841061413,
0.0697136149,
0.213195473,
0.6304720044,
-0.8251028657,
0.6605558991,
0.5954677463,
0.2077828944,
1.1565015316,
-0.2557549477,
0.4331150055,
-0.2748796344,
0.4981964529,
0.4288810194,
0.5657195449,
0.3141147792,
0.0657021999,
0.1206741184,
0.2334849834,
-0.2127307653,
-0.7182214856,
0.2998488843,
-1.7016886473,
0.1801366061,
0.53998667,
0.1017996147,
-0.6182955503,
-0.4039417207,
-0.5122136474,
0.1519847065,
-0.4395881295,
0.304996103,
0.7024982572,
-0.5029506683,
-0.6226873398,
-0.8098588586,
0.4639455378,
0.1017246172,
-0.4784363806,
-0.3495239317,
0.5575653911,
0.463290751,
-0.0284364037,
0.4455414414,
-0.1978300214,
0.2621958852,
-0.1178299785,
0.0401506722,
0.1710767001,
-0.7894555926,
-0.360376358,
0.2792369127,
-0.2608607411,
-0.6787737012
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12457v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12457v1
|
LIP-RTVE: An Audiovisual Database for Continuous Spanish in the Wild
| 2023-11-21T09:12:21 | 2023-11-21T09:12:21 |
David Gimeno-Gómez, Carlos-D. Martínez-Hinarejos
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Speech is considered as a multi-modal process where hearing and vision are
two fundamentals pillars. In fact, several studies have demonstrated that the
robustness of Automatic Speech Recognition systems can be improved when audio
and visual cues are combined to represent the nature of speech. In addition,
Visual Speech Recognition, an open research problem whose purpose is to
interpret speech by reading the lips of the speaker, has been a focus of
interest in the last decades. Nevertheless, in order to estimate these systems
in the currently Deep Learning era, large-scale databases are required. On the
other hand, while most of these databases are dedicated to English, other
languages lack sufficient resources. Thus, this paper presents a
semi-automatically annotated audiovisual database to deal with unconstrained
natural Spanish, providing 13 hours of data extracted from Spanish television.
Furthermore, baseline results for both speaker-dependent and
speaker-independent scenarios are reported using Hidden Markov Models, a
traditional paradigm that has been widely used in the field of Speech
Technologies.
|
[
-0.4787960947,
-0.8051398993,
0.1651428789,
0.3563966155,
-0.3387859166,
0.0862339586,
-0.356921196,
-0.5256415606,
0.312146157,
0.7285887599,
-0.7929198146,
-0.7407612205,
-0.2478158474,
-0.0513322018,
-0.3275292516,
0.5463067889,
0.5502653122,
0.2431832403,
0.1677786857,
-0.3346067965,
-0.701505661,
0.150102064,
-0.1156508103,
0.1646661907,
0.1534006447,
0.7346273065,
0.6783355474,
0.8599158525,
0.2814070582,
0.2823419869,
0.3078170419,
0.1152230352,
-0.1704880148,
0.3933046162,
-0.1728465706,
-0.1084617898,
-0.0570742078,
-0.4262163043,
0.7023202181,
0.6133564711,
-0.3768368363,
0.1912494153,
-0.1196100563,
0.5758351088,
-0.1414799839,
0.3143499196,
-0.6469120383,
0.3502835631,
-0.3332552612,
-0.2800343633,
-0.0100079458,
-0.3798362911,
0.732178688,
-0.3332142234,
0.2602049112,
-0.0749791712,
0.6642996669,
0.6816598773,
-0.3908331692,
-0.2920779288,
-1.0922029018,
0.6067891717,
-0.1398394406,
0.6520123482,
0.3549150527,
0.5874219537,
-0.2053622156,
-0.4347731769,
-0.4973622262,
-0.3969507813,
0.6177555919,
0.1232741326,
-0.303214252,
0.0786577985,
0.0216099136,
0.1859768778,
-0.4867944121,
0.3620999157,
-0.1802467406,
-0.5109850764,
0.1989579201,
-0.0598779842,
0.627366662,
-0.5012346506,
-0.2678124905,
-0.2281977087,
-0.4894987643,
0.0258107595,
0.0765239,
0.3613664806,
-0.0602703393,
0.9466371536,
-0.0704634041,
0.8222590685,
-0.6258624196,
-0.4615993202,
0.2559892535,
-0.1919427067,
-0.3546102643,
0.2108023018,
0.8879016638,
0.4107604027,
0.4524145424,
-0.0028263389,
-0.087742649,
0.2381063253,
-0.280887872,
-0.2258207649,
-0.4206300378,
0.0863306075,
0.1692153066,
0.1563265771,
0.0353736989,
-1.158212781,
-0.3064341545,
-0.3557331562,
0.2099260986,
-0.3231180608,
-0.2022687644,
-0.0171092656,
-0.054780364,
0.0093607409,
0.2901037633,
-0.4155760109,
0.3007515073,
0.0173868537,
0.8970843554,
-0.137396425,
0.0960203558,
-0.5866928101,
0.257589817,
0.0118879145,
0.6649417281,
-0.4816824496,
-0.5311535597,
0.1822592914,
0.1991642565,
0.2219090462,
-0.4898490012,
0.7335395217,
-0.1325162947,
0.1697574854,
-0.1435541809,
-0.2279579937,
-0.1548383981,
-0.13862665,
-0.8309192657,
1.0470107794,
-0.4780793488,
-0.4179065526,
0.5538707972,
-0.309391439,
-0.3996779025,
0.0803206712,
-0.4195577204,
-0.4241440892,
-0.1560507268,
0.6299281716,
0.378382057,
-0.3113962114,
0.3164019585,
-0.0534684062,
0.1718545705,
0.3037241399,
-0.4712025523,
0.3359546065,
0.0908431187,
-0.4975945055,
0.004483866,
-1.1230586767,
-0.3180951774,
-0.2287233174,
-0.2039519101,
-0.4236884117,
-0.0015938559,
0.3110859096,
0.285858959,
0.1101173311,
-0.9170481563,
-0.0398508944,
-0.547552228,
0.3844938278,
0.4357313514,
0.1552336216,
0.3488586247,
0.0904728994,
0.5095543265,
-0.3399381638,
0.0250222441,
-0.103447333,
-0.4306804538,
-0.7842705846,
-0.8841275573,
0.2789546549,
0.8625688553,
-0.9153223038,
0.0214621294,
-0.2463759184,
-0.229286164,
-0.4947097301,
0.0665930435,
0.4252465665,
0.7698103189,
0.4451032281,
0.0072885836,
-0.9649859667,
-0.9335566163,
0.258459121,
0.1954684556,
-0.324568212,
0.7926971316,
0.478526175,
-0.0420425944,
0.9828673601,
-0.0644398034,
-1.0821028948,
-0.0037575427,
0.0268654358,
0.2979753315,
0.3756070137,
0.2599487901,
-0.7393122911,
-0.3005030453,
0.092037797,
-0.8624976277,
-0.0957111344,
0.0479004681,
0.1356534064,
0.0588307902,
0.3413423002,
-0.2371936589,
0.416241169,
0.5792609453,
-0.0698721856,
-0.0118634207,
-0.47696805,
-0.0048403973,
-0.5275650024,
-0.1463748515,
0.4431458116,
-0.3258464634,
-0.3658336997,
-0.7824309468,
-0.1121219769,
-0.2937652469,
-0.7798495293,
0.5503050685,
-0.6759616733,
-0.4084139168,
0.0901572481,
0.2295644432,
-0.255200088,
0.459404707,
0.5989356041,
0.6084851623,
0.9307733178,
-0.5693591237,
0.6221000552,
0.2664765716,
-0.6204186678,
0.5251088142,
-0.6595675349,
-0.1277335435,
-0.2322058827,
-0.0892504007,
-0.9070441127,
-0.3070597947,
-0.0368174352,
-0.2163134068,
0.2581368387,
-0.4116950631,
-0.1800196171,
-0.300409466,
-0.0213093497,
-0.0183800925,
0.4396517873,
-0.5277270079,
0.513718307,
1.1614891291,
-0.1300928146,
-0.7877175212,
-0.7277701497,
0.497675091,
-0.1807526201,
-0.6162737608,
0.1957652271,
0.4442119002,
-0.1844743192,
0.1727093011,
-0.2038587034,
-0.0492023826,
-0.5809955597,
0.4981839657,
0.3080852628,
-0.1536116898,
0.0658561513,
-0.2453411967,
0.1926947832,
-0.2206073552,
-0.5739841461,
0.1778374612,
-0.2261238545,
-0.1397720277,
-0.8179077506,
0.3471267521,
0.7205737233,
-0.4413298965,
0.4207322299,
0.2509463131,
-0.5453654528,
-0.3747763038,
-0.7628608346,
0.1525865644,
-0.3727609515,
0.2870463729,
-0.3684143126,
-0.7055155635,
0.7874359488,
0.2230602354,
-0.2048533261,
0.2075461298,
0.7059313655,
-0.4810446203,
0.7546468377,
0.6808128357,
0.3077761233,
0.7268516421,
-0.3379126191,
-0.466897279,
-0.4165866077,
-0.9940200448,
-0.5413596034,
-0.0516935326,
-0.4774148762,
-0.5890039802,
0.5078614354,
-0.5515537262,
0.1636853516,
0.3730959594,
-0.5195390582,
0.4516890347,
0.5676112175,
0.239452228,
0.3622858226,
-0.0283909775,
-0.3921896517,
-0.333301872,
-0.594227016,
-0.4136674404,
1.012616396,
0.4645233154,
0.9010241628,
0.3405068815,
0.1707694829,
0.4809078574,
-0.2160922289,
-0.8128618598,
0.5445652604,
-0.1085185483,
-0.590573132,
-0.8001963496,
-0.232934162,
-0.9590594172,
0.3224340975,
-0.3110147417,
-0.6131725311,
0.6952829361,
0.1526043117,
-0.171565935,
-0.0265819114,
-0.5085611343,
0.9897294044,
-0.4305914044,
-0.4617259204,
0.1174439788,
-0.677781105,
0.2391731441,
0.1304824054,
0.3371131122,
-0.2867128253,
-0.2757772803,
0.912338376,
-0.6786163449,
0.8259209394,
-0.4563381672,
0.3781094551,
0.5537800789,
0.0699840635,
0.3665414453,
0.3431496322,
0.3171912134,
-0.0827243999,
0.1888975352,
-0.2477352321,
-0.1752429307,
0.662868619,
-0.64173311,
-0.188956216,
-0.7426463366,
-0.2830021977,
-0.3310128748,
0.2575595379,
0.0010691604,
0.6554558873,
-0.6619389653,
0.4108814299,
1.1015236378,
-0.4713916779,
0.5910243988,
0.6269644499,
-0.1867628545,
-0.5597969294,
0.7227030993,
0.2797913849,
-0.223174423,
0.4882776737,
0.1829934418,
-0.845366776,
-0.7007959485,
-0.4666284025,
0.3256130219,
-0.660272181,
0.1913385689,
-0.7649086714,
0.3197776973,
0.076307252,
0.4263717532,
-0.608217299,
-0.3302377164,
-0.4280495346,
-0.2459371835,
0.3084873259,
0.2939653695,
-0.19150424,
-0.0466927812,
-0.7052770853,
0.5413456559,
0.5996111631,
0.1457964033,
-0.3924401104,
-0.3791945279,
0.011547707,
-0.0296527799,
0.4657459259,
-0.9946193099,
0.8425129652,
0.6969800591,
0.6608691812,
-0.007928214,
0.0929530188,
0.660348773,
-0.6120098829,
0.3100667596,
0.1644967645,
-0.6923217773,
0.9663620591,
-0.6222487092,
0.2610948682,
0.5928655863,
0.2889819145,
-0.4153133929,
-0.2281106561,
-0.3347290456,
-0.5924917459,
0.3106717765,
0.0948625877,
-0.0828190595,
-0.0082375007,
-0.2909283638,
0.1012056246,
0.2397690564,
-0.4765088856,
0.0112784682,
-0.6731837392,
-0.122966446,
-0.0068684989,
0.0197035205,
-0.0671826154,
-0.4165594876,
0.3457065225,
0.0881648287,
-0.0392872728,
0.4060249031,
-0.4095611274,
-0.0497526862,
0.1774880588,
0.5007272959,
0.5343625546,
-0.5855321288,
0.132541433,
-0.0586629286,
-0.6054822803,
-0.0509716272,
-0.0046012118,
0.1067581847,
0.4018977582,
0.1115855128,
0.8289814591,
0.2717534602,
-1.2618447542,
0.5487263799,
-0.121072121,
-0.0156531837,
-0.9613593221,
-0.3096053302,
-0.0165863968,
0.2449442446,
0.4371201098,
0.114259772,
0.0170154423,
-0.83223629,
0.5424582362,
0.435498476,
-0.5490327477,
-0.043705482,
0.7409305573,
0.4701659381,
-0.3864038885,
0.5297780037,
0.1468286812,
-0.1524255127,
0.5946795344,
0.0717422888,
0.545430243,
-0.1797207445,
0.3017612994,
0.1193121225,
0.195310697,
-0.2521878779,
0.5011629462,
-0.1475899667,
-0.592672348,
-0.4719552398,
-0.7568919063,
-0.5547440648,
0.058887016,
-0.563170135,
0.2945583165,
-0.3878203332,
-0.1877790242,
0.019075295,
-0.286275655,
-0.8878828287,
0.2139304429,
0.2219950855,
0.661211431,
-1.0197989941,
1.3187830448,
0.3671404421,
-0.4665082991,
-0.3850806653,
-0.5550423861,
0.0722960904,
-0.9094360471,
0.5698945522,
-0.274340868,
-0.4976992011,
0.0289330985,
-0.0431463718,
-0.791808784,
0.7980591655,
0.2535527349,
-0.967441678,
0.1230105534,
0.2249148041,
0.7549234033,
-0.2266385108,
-0.115193665,
0.6248794794,
0.3891451359,
0.6319602132,
-1.1259428263,
-0.467663765,
-0.1101500988,
-0.0857704431,
0.1732037067,
0.0164682344,
0.4055026472,
-0.1474116147,
-0.3682467639,
-0.181393981,
0.821087718,
-0.0639934689,
0.1633803397,
0.2969040573,
0.4034282863,
0.8251900077,
-0.2495321035,
0.6486017108,
0.1283481866,
0.070020251,
1.0341553688,
0.0553283803,
0.6498428583,
0.6017051935,
-0.0850414038,
0.0536202379,
0.7360497713,
-0.2757583261,
0.8781531453,
0.0475878902,
-0.2036526501,
-0.2935226858,
-0.5413299799,
-0.1335558593,
0.6309376955,
0.7363462448,
-0.1420692652,
-0.0875102431,
0.8440027237,
-0.2159552872,
0.2969651818,
-0.3544785678,
0.5016634464,
0.0405895784,
-0.5378915668,
0.443035692,
-0.320102483,
0.6127747893,
-0.2635518909,
-0.0576752648,
-0.0497007966,
-0.0810293034,
-0.2437217534,
-0.8698647618,
0.1353248209,
0.2363309115,
0.1452900022,
-0.1184597537,
0.4406107366,
-0.552586019,
-0.6424168348,
-0.0224579908,
0.7209397554,
0.2601851821,
0.2443636805,
-0.6094630957,
0.2121346444,
0.1033793092,
-0.1613239199,
-0.0548958257,
0.6478363276,
-0.1273950487,
0.9071143866,
0.6587485075,
0.2843491435,
0.4631173015,
0.3641174138,
0.448718518,
-0.7317364812,
-0.7375388145,
-0.6970531344,
0.526707232,
0.0244124569,
-0.204302296,
0.7904213071,
0.4163701236,
0.5464023352,
-0.1015795916,
0.5971439481,
0.1303651631,
0.7163080573,
-0.6924615502,
0.2340302169,
-0.3059243262,
0.5727846026,
-0.3700330853,
-1.105384469,
-0.6841779351,
0.4554861486,
-0.1615192145,
-0.3794597983,
0.3630445898,
0.8275544047,
0.1763360053,
-0.0813895091,
0.3506734669,
0.1425467432,
0.2800523639,
0.4066721499,
0.9605039954,
0.0958328098,
0.6852667928,
-0.3643920124,
-0.3074429333,
-0.2421664894,
-0.9028471112,
-0.8892644048,
-0.6517277956,
-0.354042381,
-0.0884733722,
0.1634020805,
0.7729278207,
0.5760743022,
-0.6131131053,
-0.3464549482,
-0.0528457202,
-0.0134772165,
-0.0031644702,
-0.0821431875,
0.6072500944,
0.5324648619,
-0.7950667143,
0.7619965672,
0.5033817887,
0.4258592129,
-0.5518488884,
0.1651869118,
-0.1854869574,
-0.0150212776,
0.2083116919,
1.0719121695,
-0.8080801368,
-0.4046748579,
0.1385911405,
0.0440591015,
0.281498909,
0.3500289619,
-1.1549451351,
0.8982533813,
0.4427556396,
0.2212393582,
1.1334017515,
-0.2073570192,
0.4077005982,
-0.6590046883,
0.5786501765,
0.7750188708,
0.422686249,
0.4731180072,
0.0621326901,
0.183090046,
0.2867337167,
-0.354567945,
-1.0859616995,
0.1017084792,
-1.5056427717,
-0.0774284154,
0.9971478581,
0.3713525236,
-0.3412376046,
-0.4760491848,
-0.2352914065,
0.271055311,
-0.6681280136,
0.3047091067,
0.3858547807,
-0.3194954395,
-0.6037650108,
-1.1273857355,
0.6843032837,
-0.0309563559,
-0.3237024844,
-0.1906997859,
0.6945085526,
0.3688082099,
-0.1843181998,
0.476482898,
-0.0634743348,
0.1587718278,
-0.1349692494,
0.0748159215,
-0.2064100653,
-0.697268784,
-0.1897719651,
0.3929425776,
-0.2571846843,
-0.7325948477
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.