id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10862v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10862v1
|
Formal concept analysis for evaluating intrinsic dimension of a natural language
| 2023-11-17T20:48:58 | 2023-11-17T20:48:58 |
Sergei O. Kuznetsov, Vasilii A. Gromov, Nikita S. Borodin, Andrei M. Divavin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, math.AT
|
Some results of a computational experiment for determining the intrinsic
dimension of linguistic varieties for the Bengali and Russian languages are
presented. At the same time, both sets of words and sets of bigrams in these
languages were considered separately. The method used to solve this problem was
based on formal concept analysis algorithms. It was found that the intrinsic
dimensions of these languages are significantly less than the dimensions used
in popular neural network models in natural language processing.
|
[
-0.2094549686,
-1.0884748697,
0.432546556,
0.4486133754,
-0.2796677351,
0.5971465707,
-0.2780961096,
-0.8925608993,
0.308648169,
0.1740272194,
-0.1485505402,
-0.1787382215,
-0.5078884959,
0.1149656028,
-0.3578623831,
0.5378668308,
-0.1738680899,
0.0296267197,
-0.2072780281,
-0.2137711197,
-0.34269315,
-0.4894455373,
-0.4267056286,
-0.179851532,
0.0881330445,
0.0748161823,
0.394582361,
0.3489255905,
1.0188266039,
0.4990726411,
-0.288217932,
0.1315288097,
-0.0680396706,
0.0259354655,
-0.2148168981,
-0.5590509176,
0.0116219651,
0.021999348,
1.2308216095,
0.8482765555,
0.2327685356,
0.3821097612,
-0.4831252098,
0.9605890512,
-0.552560389,
0.469438225,
-0.293687582,
0.2431242168,
-0.2667195201,
-0.3977150023,
0.0979748368,
-0.7592014074,
0.2615862489,
-0.2764307857,
0.0578364395,
0.088610962,
1.0182974339,
-0.1240717471,
-0.1083243042,
-0.4979919195,
-1.0545613766,
0.9269514084,
-0.6661309004,
0.2777145803,
0.5131572485,
0.1010522172,
0.0850747451,
-0.2811534405,
-0.8378468156,
-0.5546649098,
-0.3481087983,
-0.1902356297,
-0.1136168763,
-0.0383235998,
0.2902193964,
0.6990786791,
-0.7578386068,
0.0022058552,
-0.6824181676,
-0.209253937,
0.9060474038,
0.1691949368,
0.5113410354,
-0.4948939085,
0.1020604521,
0.3859287798,
-0.4264264107,
0.2805182636,
0.5069402456,
0.3376020193,
-0.342046082,
0.7825175524,
-0.4893482625,
0.9204867482,
-0.2083125412,
-0.3670588136,
0.3298879266,
-0.8953760862,
-0.0910253301,
0.1048699617,
0.85177809,
-0.3261930346,
0.3800514042,
-0.0144134257,
-0.1265253276,
0.36627689,
0.0488481149,
-0.6054844856,
0.0798833892,
0.2617594898,
-0.2378442436,
-0.2147033215,
0.0163156353,
-0.5412734151,
-0.036074467,
-0.684817493,
0.3579978049,
-0.7023043633,
-0.4355016947,
0.1027130112,
-0.2609610856,
0.3803747296,
-0.1880240887,
-0.7728578448,
0.5082350373,
0.9691203833,
1.0521451235,
0.0123111997,
-0.0157229528,
-0.1531725228,
-0.2877183557,
-0.6304973364,
0.7528082132,
-1.1246955395,
-0.2130127549,
0.0756482258,
-0.4073442817,
0.1476847231,
-0.3219718933,
0.431920886,
-0.58361727,
0.0526955016,
-0.3314833641,
-0.5054239631,
-0.3848584592,
0.2595688105,
-0.3010017872,
1.0683369637,
0.2422640622,
-0.8015639782,
0.5892822742,
-0.8274366856,
-0.5765767097,
0.5185295343,
-0.4295068979,
0.0433559753,
0.6201048493,
-0.3005389869,
0.2488693446,
-0.3123640418,
0.0623669513,
-0.0292047057,
-0.4380451739,
0.5202993155,
-0.0190135073,
0.7487174273,
0.1942839921,
-0.3205451667,
0.2563863993,
-1.1417796612,
0.303527534,
0.188888073,
-0.0799023584,
-0.7615638971,
0.200088948,
-0.1689330041,
0.1657493711,
0.3070229888,
-0.7950714231,
0.2216885984,
-0.7321916223,
0.5964246392,
0.5052210093,
0.1830092669,
0.583290875,
0.0634797886,
0.3438619375,
0.004766122,
-0.1349886358,
0.183292374,
-0.4105490446,
-0.8813453913,
-0.3488317728,
0.6141134501,
0.34645769,
-0.667751193,
0.6830170751,
-0.5573704243,
-0.4194685221,
-0.466675669,
-0.0678119585,
0.5246593356,
0.0615774579,
-0.1406948119,
-0.2938089371,
-0.4082148373,
-1.282984376,
-0.0474514812,
-0.3407851756,
0.1340803355,
-0.0447038896,
0.8902260065,
-0.0014939291,
1.1603339911,
-0.6141809225,
0.1944047958,
0.0394673757,
0.5460750461,
0.1004359722,
0.4614132345,
0.5297117233,
-0.85084939,
-0.6369733214,
0.4072031379,
-0.7337510586,
-0.050873559,
0.1282542348,
0.1502794921,
0.5574353933,
-0.0103896847,
-0.3987573385,
0.6430540085,
0.3781961799,
-0.1646349281,
0.9444445372,
-0.1023387164,
0.2608961761,
-0.569961369,
0.1611628383,
0.1873981506,
0.1619834453,
-0.8014959693,
0.4152484834,
0.1086259633,
-0.0164867919,
-0.341578722,
0.6113891006,
-0.5105543137,
-0.4747369885,
-0.1536976248,
0.3017114401,
-0.1202631667,
0.466567874,
0.3231429756,
0.6719508171,
0.8534604311,
-0.7687627673,
0.4844815731,
0.0737797171,
-0.6265669465,
0.7049857974,
-0.6771149039,
0.0877894536,
-0.2635528445,
-0.3664730489,
-1.1010576487,
-0.2144176364,
0.1164535657,
-0.6531502008,
0.4184633791,
0.0775758252,
-0.415011704,
-0.3461970091,
-0.4536235631,
0.3891201317,
0.2119083554,
0.0044396347,
0.3094569147,
0.3641667962,
-0.2473866642,
-0.2500353456,
-0.8484503031,
-0.0020763921,
-0.2013407797,
-0.8422738314,
0.0523020402,
-0.0951791033,
-0.8694757223,
0.1538259983,
0.01422833,
-0.2794169188,
-0.1295721084,
0.0272060912,
0.2357355505,
-0.3718549907,
0.2568139136,
-0.0283058491,
-0.0915245414,
0.0833171308,
-0.3288787603,
0.6639946699,
-0.5781146288,
-0.1309943497,
-0.7178327441,
0.3598517179,
0.3714663088,
-0.5782389045,
0.9018287063,
0.6072665453,
-0.532117784,
0.0444302,
-0.4292811155,
0.1074638739,
-0.476233542,
0.317599535,
-0.5269566178,
-0.8978018165,
0.4391616881,
0.3973239064,
-0.2218746543,
0.4763864279,
0.722287178,
0.1302330047,
0.5660816431,
0.6330246925,
0.0546476096,
0.3245845437,
-0.3617123067,
0.7301404476,
-0.8652423024,
-0.2434019148,
-0.8580106497,
-0.4359324276,
-0.7915042043,
-0.2519372702,
0.3098751903,
-0.0148452064,
-0.2542978823,
0.1094666496,
-0.3159128726,
0.4130007327,
0.5463762879,
-0.409286797,
0.2762536108,
0.234714672,
-0.2881574333,
-0.2730217278,
-0.2325746864,
-0.4168448746,
0.5791451335,
0.2459449023,
0.2796466053,
0.1485145539,
0.5188312531,
0.1425801814,
-0.1727048457,
-1.3277211189,
0.5268083215,
0.0985091925,
-0.6781049967,
-0.5927056074,
-0.8153449893,
-0.6582441926,
0.2434837967,
-0.1891143769,
-1.0620831251,
0.2109451741,
-0.5617089868,
-0.2387242764,
0.0765941665,
-0.6620621085,
0.3004373312,
-0.1681041569,
-0.1237015501,
-0.4068198204,
-0.4025026858,
0.735542953,
-0.4095395505,
0.209470585,
-0.0021866772,
-0.0015001497,
0.9835625291,
-0.1799816042,
0.5907701254,
0.2338023484,
-0.2596424222,
0.5477161407,
0.4440449178,
0.1104918942,
0.2152509838,
-0.1814412773,
0.3740740716,
0.1605306715,
-0.5822036862,
-0.8242336512,
0.6950811744,
-0.79923141,
-0.3276396692,
-0.6898043752,
-0.4353530705,
-0.2029153854,
0.2357818633,
0.1458378434,
0.7126139402,
-0.2186376899,
0.2548021078,
0.2131677121,
-0.2072158307,
0.7242794037,
0.8071871996,
-0.2991903126,
-0.0396219864,
1.1082634926,
0.5810784101,
0.2606059015,
0.5923061967,
0.5943191051,
-0.2621507049,
-0.7606145144,
0.0055651218,
0.2674760818,
-0.2719189227,
0.1596927494,
-0.4575068355,
-0.5380641818,
-0.3413532376,
0.0146767357,
-0.2899967134,
-0.6127097011,
0.2384891361,
0.047790423,
0.15221259,
0.815033257,
-0.1519032866,
0.310531944,
-1.065310359,
0.2343332618,
0.1378231645,
0.542162776,
-0.1040017754,
-0.5452156663,
-0.2456869781,
0.2283756882,
-0.0989777297,
-0.5941794515,
0.3726209104,
0.2227125764,
0.4855476916,
0.5908644795,
-0.2841109037,
0.4031601846,
-0.4250670075,
0.9522078037,
0.222834602,
-1.2292004824,
0.5049886703,
-0.3589755893,
0.099152483,
0.2218726277,
0.715914607,
-0.673912406,
0.0644118264,
-0.6247902513,
-0.328882128,
0.4886225462,
0.5849782825,
-0.0782289058,
-0.0325098075,
0.3768491149,
-0.0388030782,
0.1904109865,
-0.2594822645,
-0.3715018034,
0.2740433812,
0.0756391287,
-0.260045886,
-0.3465277851,
-0.0466462076,
-0.6149545908,
0.2104572952,
0.0449690297,
0.3544748127,
-0.1373591721,
-0.049763713,
-0.3218613863,
0.2757085562,
0.9598059058,
1.0794565678,
-0.0957777351,
0.1229704171,
-0.0475884341,
-0.6625807285,
0.2183986008,
-0.4797817171,
-0.0460125096,
-0.1956746876,
0.6782726645,
0.8171105981,
0.0059768138,
-0.5667222142,
0.165880397,
0.0344827287,
-0.1308558732,
-0.300424248,
-0.0062610111,
-0.0534932129,
-0.1564110965,
0.240343228,
0.0020626606,
0.2242359072,
-0.813813448,
0.0607362874,
0.4503803849,
-0.4856721461,
-0.8796869516,
-0.566962719,
0.0847910717,
-0.6916671395,
0.6568959951,
-0.6391698122,
-0.7959295511,
0.6700177193,
0.6674876213,
0.8255826831,
-0.2245722413,
0.6423385143,
0.348236829,
0.5631143451,
0.3109793961,
0.4580189884,
0.18709369,
-0.8994722962,
-0.6796502471,
-1.2637699842,
-0.1474180073,
0.1802089363,
-0.4306017458,
-0.0909456313,
-0.545475781,
0.1273505986,
0.2892078757,
0.5491592288,
-0.4011729062,
0.0872297734,
-0.0517994612,
0.4558242261,
-0.8594266772,
0.5514433384,
0.7145730257,
-0.3642145395,
-0.5509027243,
-0.2885174751,
0.0947869197,
-0.6692993641,
1.3534282446,
-0.0980757847,
-0.0583666377,
-0.396158427,
-0.5130998492,
-1.2516264915,
0.2599189281,
-0.0971656665,
-0.3581397831,
0.3167439699,
0.50264889,
1.0090948343,
-0.2168102413,
0.1250691712,
1.0291409492,
0.8506891131,
0.2502459586,
-0.9093017578,
-0.1840524822,
-0.4362656176,
0.0928732976,
0.6680069566,
-0.5135604739,
0.8629031777,
0.1609931737,
-0.3973475099,
-0.1799601912,
0.7738330364,
-0.001977521,
-0.1131834835,
0.0956765339,
0.4703692496,
0.771422565,
-0.1444478333,
1.086561799,
-0.2843456864,
0.3940380514,
0.573716104,
-0.281129241,
0.8447285891,
0.188480109,
-0.7515868545,
0.2938483953,
0.4228792191,
0.2356724888,
0.0334265456,
0.703527987,
-0.2105402797,
0.1885193139,
-0.1023851708,
-0.3306635618,
0.8896576762,
0.8018541932,
0.3592917323,
-0.0079904664,
-0.2025878131,
-0.2865441442,
0.0715413392,
-0.2432204187,
0.5733894706,
0.0902053714,
-0.2740010321,
0.7536767721,
0.1764714867,
0.62157166,
-0.6847274303,
-0.0600773543,
-0.1728304923,
-0.0449938253,
-0.2441857755,
-0.7366098166,
0.7701485753,
-0.081993103,
-0.0352060013,
0.5505638123,
0.7013483047,
-0.1953862607,
-0.8823965788,
0.0535785928,
0.2298422009,
0.0961719528,
0.0399966389,
-0.508877933,
0.1672507375,
-0.3652125895,
-0.0678771585,
0.1332789063,
0.5491968393,
-0.1312697381,
0.7495257854,
0.6533517241,
0.5659338236,
0.3014323115,
-0.2562197447,
0.5435596108,
-0.8054496646,
-0.5084481835,
-0.8426926136,
0.32060045,
-0.1960575879,
-0.3946474195,
0.8864740133,
0.3808459044,
0.5473527312,
-0.1866482794,
0.6676791906,
-0.3349124491,
0.2790413201,
-0.5733603835,
0.5922241807,
-0.3970146477,
-0.0531729758,
-0.3604825437,
-1.3036849499,
-0.2823405266,
0.719288528,
-0.5643035769,
-0.0414174236,
1.2527003288,
0.5669692159,
0.1726077944,
0.1957543194,
0.3711879551,
0.3444212377,
0.3680663109,
0.0466963127,
1.0491294861,
-0.1037725955,
-0.3835478425,
-0.4425899386,
-0.5816713572,
-0.0548990741,
-0.7473772764,
-0.9825274944,
-0.7989631891,
-0.2360684574,
0.0966244116,
-0.2682566941,
0.7128633261,
0.5997906923,
-0.8261398673,
-0.2908245921,
0.1377455294,
0.1646848023,
-0.152548492,
-0.2826794982,
0.5950753093,
-0.5819340348,
-0.689463675,
0.328124851,
0.6405611038,
-0.2323953211,
-0.6773281097,
0.1877921075,
-0.5713288784,
0.4967873394,
0.8748838305,
0.2593454123,
-0.4839906096,
-0.6143057942,
-0.1926360428,
-0.1542177647,
0.0339032598,
0.9007057548,
-0.4639018476,
0.393550396,
1.0471411943,
0.5291736722,
0.1908112019,
-0.195669651,
0.3136361241,
-0.8438175321,
0.446079433,
0.2628573477,
0.1422323138,
0.1190446168,
-0.3087568283,
0.4722575545,
0.3487564921,
-0.2117943019,
-0.7711763382,
0.3567791283,
-1.0093814135,
-0.2377210557,
1.1118243933,
0.0293597486,
-0.4638968408,
-0.1822236329,
-0.0410457365,
-0.0607520193,
-0.0391998403,
0.7136543393,
1.0387767553,
0.2108287662,
0.2590313256,
-0.4702950716,
0.3168240786,
-0.0541549437,
-0.6273052692,
-0.3124646246,
0.2311802059,
0.0402013659,
0.9336252213,
0.3702017963,
-0.2677114606,
-0.1067111492,
0.1814975888,
-0.0260288548,
0.0593697652,
-0.6751684546,
-0.4415001869,
0.1546729356,
-0.1652637571,
-0.0110655492
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10847v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10847v2
|
Token-Level Adaptation of LoRA Adapters for Downstream Task Generalization
| 2023-11-17T20:07:54 | 2023-12-01T06:38:18 |
Joshua Belofsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces a method for adapting LoRA adapters in smaller-sized
language models to arbitrary downstream tasks. Unlike standard
mixture-of-expert architectures, our method employs a gradient-free routing
function to choose a weighted combination of experts without increasing the
compute requirements for training or inference. The results show that
token-level adaptation of LoRA adapters outperforms the base Llama-2-7b model
across mathematical (GSM8K), scientific (ARC-Challenge), reading comprehension
(SQuAD), and coding (CodeAlpaca-20k) tasks. Further evaluations also show that
the average performance of token-level adaptation outperforms individual models
fine-tuned for each of the tasks with the best performance observed in
adaptation of every-other token during inference. The code for this study is
made available through a public repository.
|
[
-0.259024322,
-0.5836396813,
0.2763355076,
0.3316097856,
-0.2843206227,
0.0019346008,
-0.2339592427,
-0.5288068652,
0.263645798,
0.544182539,
-0.4704804718,
-0.4317444861,
-0.6823730469,
0.0515776835,
-0.4284574091,
0.9287804365,
0.0542333908,
-0.0863083079,
0.17487216,
-0.2181875259,
-0.8541107774,
-0.2871186733,
-1.0149892569,
-0.1674141437,
0.8212110996,
0.4209324718,
0.1082768291,
0.5664111376,
0.55384624,
0.2940412164,
-0.1858108491,
0.0495256968,
-0.5408114195,
-0.0015231514,
-0.6109914184,
-0.908193469,
-0.6288686991,
-0.4202889204,
0.4828139842,
0.622253716,
-0.2036901116,
0.4663526118,
0.0826089606,
0.8867982626,
-0.7441458702,
0.1649944037,
-1.0631197691,
-0.034841761,
-0.0253622849,
-0.1535914838,
-0.6484987736,
0.0417613648,
-0.1723914593,
-0.8192766309,
0.0064103436,
0.2778790593,
0.2638274729,
0.7036834359,
-0.2843485475,
-0.2689066529,
-0.6104769707,
0.6989354491,
-0.8255448937,
-0.0113483723,
0.2280100137,
0.4259345531,
-0.1856009066,
-0.5727065206,
-0.3863246143,
0.2008883059,
0.1806407571,
0.1714764088,
-0.5356234312,
0.14093481,
0.1873936504,
0.0687475055,
-0.1050370783,
0.4863859713,
-0.5269634128,
0.0254969671,
0.5136024952,
0.0961640775,
0.0603447743,
-0.076171957,
-0.1757497787,
0.1670816243,
-0.6270412207,
0.2001447082,
0.2921371162,
0.572779119,
-0.3769853115,
0.4047723413,
-0.415807277,
0.8137639761,
0.5541038513,
-0.0952457711,
0.170527935,
-0.2689013183,
-0.2745934129,
-0.0263075512,
0.4127389789,
0.0511388294,
0.1679103971,
-0.2395623028,
-0.2486894429,
-0.1763480604,
0.2180347741,
-0.4775213599,
-0.1074645966,
0.1513531208,
-0.5907475948,
-0.1420089602,
-0.2340885997,
-0.7308213711,
-0.5416530371,
-0.2230627686,
0.5590668321,
-0.0181070082,
-0.1281414181,
0.1434941292,
-0.2007092834,
0.4006459415,
0.3769201636,
-1.2183927298,
0.7152056694,
0.6908618212,
0.9918494225,
-0.366301775,
-0.3198306859,
-1.1410053968,
0.2609155774,
-0.1845376343,
1.0455595255,
-0.3490976989,
-0.3198024035,
-0.1769179851,
-0.1679489166,
-0.5932148695,
-0.586330533,
0.6613176465,
-0.6162254214,
-0.0924311206,
-0.3158323765,
-0.186423853,
-0.2060953379,
-0.1614054739,
-0.6006404161,
0.9541628957,
0.3562332094,
-0.7412099838,
0.2985619903,
-1.1247489452,
-0.3729501665,
-0.1698568016,
0.1815540642,
0.1503890604,
0.3611234426,
0.4492370486,
0.3102090657,
-0.2424491793,
-0.2278894186,
-0.1256855726,
-0.6027809381,
-0.1154546961,
0.0562202483,
0.7363199592,
0.0534444861,
-0.3411248922,
0.5873872638,
-0.8930838108,
-0.2332600355,
-0.1242037043,
-0.6040312648,
-0.3784830272,
0.2231684327,
-0.1968983412,
0.1738643497,
0.0958057046,
-0.3694477677,
0.4060414135,
-0.3810968101,
0.7257524133,
1.1619929075,
-0.210634321,
0.7351421118,
-0.1147139966,
0.5454054475,
0.1865955442,
0.0381570905,
0.1268025488,
-0.7695244551,
-1.2424207926,
-0.4136878252,
0.489215076,
0.6501037478,
-0.7851677537,
0.5097877383,
-0.5654869676,
-0.4722273648,
-0.6413916349,
0.4114914238,
0.1614714563,
0.77404356,
0.4896097779,
-0.2600188553,
-0.4770489931,
-0.6382659078,
-0.4127519131,
-0.257189095,
-0.1708741784,
0.1786256135,
0.5436983109,
-0.2590756118,
0.9981961846,
-0.4028306007,
-0.3500727415,
-0.3894373178,
-0.0175718945,
0.3995067775,
0.5301219821,
0.8051145077,
-0.3581084311,
-0.2812588811,
0.1943647712,
-0.3940888941,
-0.3020133674,
0.1150645688,
-0.2699196041,
0.0499273352,
0.4746031463,
-0.4016348124,
0.3650517464,
0.8600775599,
-0.6193305254,
0.0722104609,
-0.2498409599,
-0.2936946154,
-1.1542180777,
0.109951131,
-0.0949400365,
-0.3523845673,
-0.8495463133,
0.2693465948,
-0.165858984,
0.1885015517,
-0.2566217482,
0.7748348117,
-0.1621378213,
-0.4722926617,
-0.3394244909,
0.0037140935,
-0.1494379938,
0.7058044672,
-0.2198984176,
0.7056996822,
0.6270700693,
-0.6333627105,
0.1445714384,
0.1331893206,
-0.3326930404,
0.4425874949,
-0.6861461401,
0.4899791181,
-0.0585699528,
0.3367452919,
-0.8966231942,
-0.1076767221,
0.3772751689,
-0.1848381013,
-0.2144445479,
-0.3727597594,
-0.245362252,
-0.1854938418,
-0.1013903916,
0.4371243119,
0.7770986557,
-0.4694316089,
1.2030347586,
0.0481699444,
-0.3392137587,
-0.5506181121,
-0.94107759,
-0.0042250031,
-0.4388365448,
-0.3431601524,
0.0710310116,
-0.1253601462,
-0.119605042,
-0.210970521,
-0.082107231,
-0.140587464,
0.2670645118,
0.3053606749,
0.0418882966,
-0.4058367312,
-0.2599294484,
0.4600465894,
-0.1024143547,
-0.0843640789,
-0.421097964,
0.5183833241,
0.2103114575,
-0.5359947681,
-0.3492995203,
0.3523849845,
0.427172035,
-0.0682550222,
0.8678061366,
0.7929649949,
-0.2620987892,
-0.3061193824,
-0.4531270862,
0.0570121184,
-0.5399134159,
0.4814780951,
-0.5913238525,
-0.9252423048,
0.921281755,
0.1204799935,
0.1362086982,
0.6351563334,
0.5874314308,
0.1814481765,
0.7423414588,
0.7827851176,
-0.5041543245,
0.6212874651,
-0.1376589388,
0.2922198772,
-1.0042665005,
-0.0363692492,
-0.7827336788,
-0.583684206,
-0.3514168561,
-0.6176720262,
0.1812140644,
0.2755681872,
-0.4198895097,
0.2117202878,
-0.3245381415,
0.3391954899,
0.7058675885,
0.1166638359,
0.4667514861,
0.2316036075,
0.1940461993,
0.4948673248,
-0.9306294918,
-0.0452639759,
1.0407056808,
0.3436631262,
0.7437959909,
0.3358179331,
0.5806375742,
0.6979132891,
0.3846875727,
-0.8983517289,
0.5095403194,
-0.4085470736,
-0.2791841626,
-0.2537979484,
-0.4379036725,
-0.8234916925,
0.2482228875,
0.053034354,
-1.029882431,
0.548840344,
0.2507217824,
-0.4332796335,
0.3917869031,
-0.9356194139,
0.4376559556,
0.1712190062,
0.0738264173,
-0.3604253829,
-0.3313972652,
0.1591101587,
-0.3443609774,
0.4974007607,
-0.1010108292,
-0.4103987813,
1.0658619404,
-0.2156654745,
1.1460555792,
-0.592446208,
-0.2582294345,
0.4357247055,
-0.0962998122,
0.6457566023,
-0.3043037057,
-0.3774680793,
0.1810769141,
-0.1232801899,
-0.872325778,
-0.6488358378,
0.5794445872,
-1.0542998314,
-0.6909171939,
0.021096928,
-0.6444970369,
-0.373742342,
0.3316023648,
0.1226539314,
0.223505646,
0.2371574938,
-0.0139936656,
0.2104346752,
0.0428596251,
0.5515528321,
0.4414524138,
-0.0733580142,
-0.3699016869,
0.8929596543,
-0.1562359333,
0.3796033561,
0.5196954012,
0.319429636,
-0.0802419484,
-1.1193983555,
-0.6168012619,
-0.1229979023,
-0.9795715213,
-0.2059374154,
-0.4037128389,
-0.039178025,
-0.2917571664,
-0.1526140571,
-0.0991990641,
-0.5652003884,
-0.5389364958,
0.0489896722,
0.5827102065,
0.9364246726,
0.0704222992,
0.7115844488,
-0.5137349963,
0.3512597084,
0.4608066678,
0.2349121571,
0.3396615684,
-1.1346620321,
-0.35217309,
-0.0353020839,
0.1162587479,
-0.5151508451,
-0.0117623396,
0.4130904377,
0.4774101973,
0.3947269022,
-0.173802644,
0.8064534664,
-0.5325915217,
0.7608288527,
0.2233895063,
-1.166085124,
0.2602388263,
-0.6196165681,
0.2849197388,
0.5231429338,
-0.1447293609,
-0.1864175051,
0.157311663,
0.0531271175,
-0.6918886304,
0.6181964278,
0.0500979498,
0.3061717451,
0.2646560073,
0.6658537984,
0.1984559298,
0.0121644028,
-0.6328383684,
0.048746787,
-0.2847865522,
-0.5156236291,
-0.0230746102,
-0.0975876823,
-0.1630048752,
-0.2925528884,
0.2852391005,
-0.6846354008,
0.5042641759,
0.0330011398,
-0.1510028541,
-0.0299217142,
0.2735049129,
0.6861685514,
0.7153128386,
0.0345549844,
-0.1619423479,
0.6536647677,
-0.5703077912,
0.1128589585,
-0.0249370709,
-0.0364790969,
-0.3474935293,
0.7597737908,
0.91530931,
0.2620355785,
-0.622788012,
0.2815096974,
0.0123829469,
-0.2337784618,
0.1635283083,
0.5682375431,
0.1836826205,
0.3633259535,
0.7031991482,
0.3133111298,
-0.0213323738,
-0.4115741849,
-0.4607300758,
0.1604903042,
-0.3539419174,
-0.4528634548,
0.5408052206,
0.5006154776,
-0.4303982854,
0.0653747916,
-0.0162260924,
-0.0753971711,
0.5887849927,
0.6236338019,
0.8719545603,
-0.1658512652,
-0.1633916348,
0.0132475961,
0.1300783753,
-0.0504612699,
0.3708268404,
0.0559524409,
-0.6521740556,
-0.7476530075,
-0.5831767917,
-0.2518231869,
-0.2397805601,
-0.8291074634,
0.0465740971,
-0.6308658123,
-0.0852679014,
-0.0358448215,
-0.3994025886,
-0.6897131801,
0.04132732,
-0.0257073101,
1.3567166328,
-0.6237823367,
0.8463036418,
0.7609708309,
-0.0875129178,
-0.5929387212,
-0.052885361,
-0.38374421,
-1.1427111626,
0.7293073535,
-0.3829086721,
-0.3785027266,
0.2541563809,
-0.2756407857,
-0.9601722956,
1.2946594954,
0.4709292054,
-0.5841754079,
-0.5021219254,
0.0825081468,
0.5420462489,
-0.6499929428,
0.1636717469,
0.5414497256,
0.2008289099,
-0.1712792069,
-1.0154415369,
0.0179015547,
-0.1019216031,
0.0870307833,
-0.2043792605,
-0.9038162827,
0.8427730203,
-0.0962757915,
0.3241042793,
0.4326640368,
0.7707450986,
0.2370216846,
0.1183044463,
0.9389984012,
0.2507453561,
0.7655438185,
0.1269276887,
0.806357801,
-0.311756283,
0.1924115121,
1.1066154242,
-0.1837029308,
1.1417461634,
0.6243445277,
-0.194547683,
0.9817904234,
0.4894312024,
0.2448406518,
0.6306029558,
0.3221245706,
-0.1655547023,
0.0063595572,
-0.0847777054,
-0.223039493,
0.5467801094,
0.3866047561,
-0.2425312251,
0.0111892987,
-0.1554914713,
-0.2015461177,
-0.2986259758,
-1.0429583788,
0.8396486044,
0.0843895301,
-0.6884833574,
0.6585140824,
0.2055756301,
0.7914004326,
-0.5390533209,
0.2511568666,
-0.2443128079,
0.1400179118,
-0.3967983425,
-0.4445962906,
0.1286264211,
0.2093982846,
-0.3836455047,
0.2228371799,
0.8239002228,
0.1055981666,
-0.5150917172,
0.5105586052,
0.7010664344,
-0.1611650735,
-0.0142163411,
-0.6153898239,
0.0279676523,
-0.0722676739,
-0.1837036014,
0.5129192472,
0.3334433734,
0.0145820649,
0.8651564121,
0.6479536891,
0.1140155494,
0.3905352056,
0.296792537,
1.0946485996,
-0.7307066321,
-0.7304284573,
-0.6136775613,
0.5185364485,
0.2105855644,
-0.2920608222,
0.4625062644,
0.1876005381,
0.5815552473,
-0.2234560549,
0.9233729243,
0.0788683593,
0.3018325567,
-0.7564915419,
0.3831488192,
-0.3422290087,
0.2108859718,
-0.3441402614,
-0.8934884071,
0.071793519,
0.3747959733,
-0.4405213594,
0.1982630342,
0.5651449561,
0.4247106612,
-0.3738680482,
-0.2130118161,
0.0743562654,
0.2265717685,
0.1706753671,
0.754285574,
0.5214031339,
-0.3298647106,
0.5266624689,
0.1150781289,
-0.2229206413,
-0.2882416546,
-0.9125180244,
-1.2941344976,
-0.261143744,
-0.0716693029,
-0.2267816961,
0.1276199967,
0.669041872,
0.8552036881,
-0.9247429967,
-0.1684701294,
-0.2442301661,
0.1232098863,
-0.3287252784,
-0.170693323,
0.4235705137,
-0.2264781147,
-0.7121853828,
0.411473453,
0.2121231556,
-0.1860796213,
-0.2908212245,
-0.1362823695,
0.137204349,
0.2615743279,
0.6249859929,
0.2155103385,
-0.8022184372,
-0.4495648146,
-0.1078044921,
0.3054094017,
0.2170718163,
0.9622204304,
-0.7907227278,
-0.042487748,
0.5316795111,
0.7918691635,
0.1976301223,
0.1874847412,
0.3474942446,
-0.4851793349,
0.4207415283,
-0.1489098519,
0.4564573169,
0.1768679321,
-0.2128544748,
0.4630515575,
0.1465515494,
-0.3228357434,
-0.7370448709,
0.2552369833,
-1.2002125978,
-0.0259319171,
1.2106364965,
-0.3093893826,
-0.3984897733,
-0.24523592,
-0.3064745665,
0.0714111179,
-0.61598593,
0.7841614485,
0.4635613859,
-0.1740189642,
-0.181193769,
-0.4757845402,
0.184065029,
0.3630913496,
-1.0014218092,
-0.0667894706,
-0.1364776492,
0.4733707011,
0.0260975026,
0.7398254871,
0.4414177537,
0.0886680335,
-0.0853799656,
-0.2576452494,
0.0330234803,
0.0383930802,
-0.4786047935,
-0.0093619423,
0.4391443431,
-0.1538580209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10813v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10813v3
|
A Language Agent for Autonomous Driving
| 2023-11-17T18:59:56 | 2023-11-27T20:53:35 |
Jiageng Mao, Junjie Ye, Yuxi Qian, Marco Pavone, Yue Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO
|
Human-level driving is an ultimate goal of autonomous driving. Conventional
approaches formulate autonomous driving as a perception-prediction-planning
framework, yet their systems do not capitalize on the inherent reasoning
ability and experiential knowledge of humans. In this paper, we propose a
fundamental paradigm shift from current pipelines, exploiting Large Language
Models (LLMs) as a cognitive agent to integrate human-like intelligence into
autonomous driving systems. Our approach, termed Agent-Driver, transforms the
traditional autonomous driving pipeline by introducing a versatile tool library
accessible via function calls, a cognitive memory of common sense and
experiential knowledge for decision-making, and a reasoning engine capable of
chain-of-thought reasoning, task planning, motion planning, and
self-reflection. Powered by LLMs, our Agent-Driver is endowed with intuitive
common sense and robust reasoning capabilities, thus enabling a more nuanced,
human-like approach to autonomous driving. We evaluate our approach on the
large-scale nuScenes benchmark, and extensive experiments substantiate that our
Agent-Driver significantly outperforms the state-of-the-art driving methods by
a large margin. Our approach also demonstrates superior interpretability and
few-shot learning ability to these methods. Code will be released.
|
[
-0.5373982787,
-0.6055003405,
0.9947734475,
-0.1919780821,
-0.1577465683,
0.0902367085,
-0.564639926,
-0.7841179371,
0.0571631826,
0.6070184112,
-0.5926678181,
-0.4239772558,
-0.0359705724,
-0.1011386737,
-0.5305003524,
0.4454967082,
0.2290399969,
-0.085904181,
-0.1610836536,
0.1821802258,
-0.2868977487,
-0.1711443514,
-0.7675694823,
-0.4557755589,
0.7595201135,
0.117759198,
1.0139755011,
0.6739873886,
0.0122872544,
0.3992019296,
0.3987179995,
0.1316091567,
-0.015639782,
0.0510647036,
-0.5493980646,
-0.2487792969,
-0.6454799175,
-0.0797039047,
0.3494549692,
0.6016667485,
-0.0453761406,
-0.2946855426,
-0.1460373104,
0.3594401777,
-0.6483006477,
0.411020726,
-0.6741443276,
-0.2332381308,
0.014213454,
-0.2537424266,
-0.3946063519,
-0.3202884793,
0.1097462028,
-0.9336112738,
-0.0793930441,
0.1561703086,
0.3666279018,
0.6612917185,
-0.5201576352,
-0.1805509627,
-0.9645314813,
0.7743812799,
-0.5976722836,
0.3712356687,
0.0463357568,
0.6645474434,
-0.2068436146,
-0.2819289863,
-0.9094214439,
-0.3791530728,
0.2406714261,
-0.0255195294,
0.0552378334,
0.3090555966,
-0.1621439606,
0.0070823818,
-0.6680510044,
0.3658488095,
-0.0268848501,
-0.1738003343,
1.0627285242,
0.3055067062,
0.2430777252,
0.4223124981,
-0.2707828283,
-0.35059461,
-0.546415329,
0.1934507787,
0.1348271072,
0.4889275134,
0.1095521525,
0.1556695104,
-0.5941113234,
0.5375248194,
-0.1901782602,
0.0983352959,
0.3221482635,
-0.0493884459,
-0.2395834923,
0.2126362324,
0.8302595019,
0.4177555442,
0.5618240237,
-0.3999588788,
-0.3528851867,
0.3593463898,
0.3928612173,
-0.4891592562,
-0.151183337,
0.4258333445,
0.0864257365,
-0.2832561433,
0.0603982583,
-0.4717237353,
-0.5022776127,
-0.5532895327,
0.1882582903,
-0.5586786866,
-0.4648295641,
0.3856957257,
0.1248759478,
0.755928576,
0.5578391552,
-0.8780408502,
0.5366305113,
0.8095657229,
0.3797571957,
-0.3426629901,
-0.6032834649,
-0.2100296319,
0.3246020675,
-0.5901580453,
1.0234345198,
-0.277394563,
-0.1995275617,
-0.0569473431,
-0.0942560807,
0.3706986904,
-0.4230337739,
0.1848626435,
-0.348782748,
-0.1312734336,
-0.1000035778,
-0.2341653109,
-0.533467114,
0.1312933266,
-0.5112644434,
0.8373557925,
0.189837724,
0.3934055269,
0.4307316542,
-0.8759944439,
-0.7457078695,
0.5258341432,
-0.4266503453,
0.0867763311,
-0.0800746083,
0.2054565251,
0.5690866113,
-0.5194089413,
0.4774379432,
-0.0887411982,
-0.2316746116,
0.3299532831,
-0.4663564861,
0.7859283686,
0.0387306176,
-0.4031286836,
0.4275972843,
-0.5712475777,
0.1022365391,
0.2817172706,
-0.1094026789,
-0.1271238774,
0.145089075,
0.2425414324,
0.3697966337,
0.3245076537,
-0.5513271093,
0.1174136922,
-0.6588401794,
0.3500815928,
1.0510792732,
-0.1213930473,
0.9944221377,
-0.3632361591,
0.4853493869,
-0.1033481061,
0.0725638717,
-0.0276568215,
-0.432744205,
-0.6630333662,
-0.0409961343,
-0.3601151109,
0.527695179,
-0.7302747369,
0.583560884,
-0.2692557275,
-0.4467912316,
-0.6653162241,
0.2304626405,
0.2357033789,
0.0867827013,
0.2752628326,
-0.0895071998,
-0.0577659719,
-0.5782069564,
-0.2258886397,
-0.3363705277,
-0.0313110426,
0.3016703129,
0.4800909758,
-0.4037007093,
1.1776591539,
-0.4753260314,
-0.2073922902,
-0.3598125875,
-0.0812568143,
-0.2378907949,
0.4342131019,
0.5136512518,
-0.5278171301,
-0.2507655919,
0.3230780065,
-0.7811269164,
-0.0432582647,
-0.3563824892,
-0.0231687725,
0.3772589564,
0.5536580682,
-0.6847013235,
0.3198893368,
0.1764346659,
-0.4802156091,
0.4735537171,
-0.3066578507,
-0.3162710965,
-0.3829256892,
-0.2096370906,
-0.0608537719,
-0.4014331102,
-0.4855485559,
0.2662070096,
-0.2679887116,
0.0709378496,
-0.5013614893,
0.7701934576,
-0.3717550337,
-0.3460246921,
-0.607626915,
0.196425274,
-0.2395943105,
0.5172669888,
0.1973636448,
0.8570282459,
0.8283830285,
-0.684615314,
0.5865083933,
-0.1000081822,
-0.2839808762,
0.6236063838,
-0.4831445515,
0.2133206278,
-0.2887447476,
0.1878105402,
-0.6224600673,
-0.2133687586,
0.1216047183,
-0.2400492579,
-0.0228281971,
0.3901393116,
-0.6808397174,
-0.0428541638,
0.1321631372,
0.2816066444,
0.5663795471,
-0.3305413425,
1.0934901237,
0.4604793191,
-0.1918630302,
0.0318992101,
-0.4722032547,
0.3577505648,
0.0188171621,
-0.6806737185,
0.376711458,
-0.1090492159,
-0.6583076715,
0.0020914155,
0.2206292897,
-0.0065341471,
0.2614437044,
0.4023561776,
0.2383988798,
-0.2034031898,
0.2241357416,
0.0741874501,
-0.5769494772,
0.2734450698,
-0.300200671,
0.6101617813,
-0.3806048036,
0.0016745821,
-0.5748288631,
0.4557296634,
0.6901817322,
-0.5656936169,
0.2425949574,
0.3620426357,
-0.042543374,
-0.5014690161,
-0.1207119972,
-0.4857685864,
-0.5618289709,
0.4941070676,
-0.4793147147,
-0.5934827328,
0.161689952,
-0.2998110652,
0.1307720691,
0.1739588678,
0.5730013847,
-0.4815154076,
1.0022623539,
0.4070012867,
0.0126882214,
0.3116353154,
-0.1531353891,
0.0172739662,
-0.3459532261,
-0.1632525474,
0.0035104135,
-0.1349053085,
-0.3964183629,
-0.4476036131,
0.3606487513,
-0.7047153711,
-0.5495533347,
0.2037709802,
-0.4567552805,
0.4293861985,
0.4382265806,
0.0000350171,
0.3012565076,
-0.5831893086,
0.2359091491,
0.4967781007,
-0.5426729918,
-0.5620169044,
0.8739436865,
0.1919444799,
0.4757731259,
0.0298935212,
0.4567094445,
0.2820870578,
0.0028397455,
-0.8115910292,
1.144192338,
0.1676242799,
-0.569835186,
-0.6519445181,
-0.2901049852,
-0.8852792382,
0.1464192122,
-0.3505253494,
-0.5800856352,
-0.0720972493,
-0.19392851,
-0.4743630588,
0.0787754282,
-0.3963634372,
0.7915050387,
-0.7349091172,
-0.2845713198,
-0.5111834407,
-0.6819908023,
0.0122066997,
0.1007036641,
0.4306166768,
-0.3396630585,
-0.1639699936,
0.3538054824,
-0.2522749901,
0.8375067711,
-0.2384882569,
-0.2607706487,
0.3227109909,
0.2104039639,
0.4139590263,
-0.3304653168,
0.1698916405,
0.0685481802,
-0.3395222127,
-0.3500905335,
-0.8715329766,
0.6014382243,
-0.7799719572,
-0.4551284313,
-0.4625066221,
-1.0023498535,
0.0520049147,
0.1499884874,
-0.2272345275,
0.3761114776,
-0.3610607386,
-0.2840892076,
0.3782643974,
-0.1149179414,
0.6993696094,
0.6604144573,
-0.464220047,
-0.0493647903,
0.9814457893,
-0.0112042371,
0.3706146479,
0.3115732968,
0.0584375598,
-0.446914494,
-0.45733881,
-0.4566496015,
0.1664735377,
-0.6448954344,
0.3479347825,
-0.4834664166,
-0.0243083425,
-0.3474934697,
-0.5960218906,
-0.6431934237,
-0.2283667922,
-0.1434784979,
-0.1560127884,
0.1740302593,
0.67293185,
0.0948571339,
0.5035274625,
-0.0515988506,
0.1873018295,
0.5305022597,
-0.0332480706,
0.0981748924,
-0.0364401601,
-0.0997325107,
-0.2051845193,
-0.1582874209,
-0.7077438831,
0.408408314,
-0.0389093086,
0.4855636954,
0.6070578694,
0.3281036317,
0.3419630527,
-0.2682044208,
0.3532710969,
0.046588853,
-0.7970685363,
0.3735034466,
-0.3161723316,
0.5309190154,
0.6255252361,
-0.117219016,
-0.2312882841,
-0.6472870708,
-0.2716130912,
-0.7593374848,
0.2348304689,
0.1201062277,
-0.1529031545,
0.0943899602,
0.2116519958,
0.060839504,
0.0869361684,
-0.6100535989,
-0.0384928063,
0.0296580121,
-0.1839252859,
-0.4870614707,
0.4632291794,
0.2925429642,
-0.3690645099,
0.6675160527,
-0.4643136263,
0.063603282,
0.1131607294,
-0.033975523,
0.0639616027,
0.4226320684,
0.4508293569,
0.4071097076,
-0.2909101844,
0.3663827777,
-0.0083515355,
-0.2809132338,
0.3496135771,
-0.0583817065,
-0.3368729353,
-0.4129683971,
-0.0309381094,
0.3129410148,
0.1435315013,
-1.0503714085,
0.2851206064,
0.2404730022,
-0.1242913231,
-0.8561338186,
0.4837207198,
-0.0218233597,
0.4071825743,
0.4633215666,
0.210588038,
0.1229504719,
-0.8414312601,
0.1054671556,
0.4613003135,
-0.8146848083,
-0.3804780245,
0.6473764777,
0.4876692891,
-0.4263421595,
0.3686186075,
-0.5408176184,
-0.297881186,
0.5481018424,
0.3129006922,
1.0518217087,
-0.0584029704,
0.1731015444,
-0.014329466,
0.3644427657,
-0.0646846592,
0.3139136732,
-0.114109613,
-1.0337926149,
-0.5924205184,
-0.1132088825,
-0.2217719704,
-0.4192790985,
-0.436726898,
0.0028423313,
-0.655243814,
-0.0506100357,
0.1822514832,
0.083279334,
-0.5217792988,
0.3107830286,
0.2634480894,
0.8066239357,
-0.7218135595,
1.0565199852,
0.8511946201,
-0.4164646566,
-0.402882874,
-0.2654900849,
0.1490158588,
-0.6634504795,
0.4531139433,
0.224415794,
-0.5544506311,
0.2030215114,
-0.7749433517,
-0.4044877887,
1.5617045164,
0.3352274001,
-0.5485810637,
-0.1741452664,
0.2591490448,
0.3036025763,
-0.8605722785,
0.1191900298,
0.7596885562,
0.5024279356,
-0.0581355765,
-0.8372094631,
0.2693498135,
0.0984077677,
-0.0957884267,
0.2043501437,
-0.4930357337,
0.8389458656,
-0.1208824813,
-0.1939199269,
0.0930479467,
0.6198551655,
0.2319841385,
0.4059996307,
0.7395723462,
0.5058001876,
0.7080641389,
0.1502207667,
1.1250072718,
-0.2707865238,
-0.0951748192,
1.1483715773,
-0.7721574903,
0.7459119558,
0.5556178093,
0.006517733,
0.7920120358,
-0.1047531888,
0.2613967061,
0.5988811255,
-0.1415579766,
-0.5066465735,
-0.8589529395,
-0.2319549024,
0.1791425645,
0.866609633,
0.0992767811,
-0.0456785485,
-0.2159745991,
0.1078902632,
-0.0337612294,
0.4615516067,
-0.4315623343,
0.9762137532,
0.100702256,
-0.6155421734,
0.2749499679,
0.0460659899,
0.484700948,
-0.2667871714,
-0.0391155258,
0.323066473,
0.4533261061,
0.0765276253,
-1.0184323788,
0.1113445014,
-0.4579577446,
-0.0749054402,
-0.4473381042,
0.6123534441,
-0.1247090772,
-0.1581748575,
0.434962064,
0.5982794762,
0.271075666,
-0.4632430673,
-0.5958993435,
-0.0054095336,
-0.137449801,
0.3295951486,
0.225515008,
0.3310621381,
0.0470076911,
1.038210988,
0.6876136065,
-0.0911054984,
-0.2047861069,
-0.279488802,
0.8847682476,
-1.0856770277,
-0.6969592571,
-0.8279241323,
0.4907165766,
0.1869762838,
-0.369893074,
0.4666630328,
0.4860644937,
0.5588401556,
0.2069566548,
0.9880801439,
0.140972361,
0.2233104557,
-0.5162526369,
0.6229914427,
-0.4812419116,
0.1587025672,
-0.0556294397,
-0.7815234661,
-0.1341488361,
0.7657701373,
-0.4869613647,
-0.0406424366,
0.2857167721,
0.8599175215,
0.1115100458,
-0.0272290688,
0.5869763494,
0.3246061206,
0.5588146448,
0.9174395204,
0.983204782,
-0.1126914769,
0.281740278,
-0.0874764323,
-0.2995738983,
-0.0460742712,
-0.5206412673,
-0.8507094979,
-0.6653829217,
-0.1614565104,
0.1201025024,
0.12539047,
1.221662879,
0.8645763397,
-0.3416344523,
-0.4517489076,
-0.5309041142,
0.0202247445,
-0.3857265711,
-0.2319818884,
-0.238111496,
-0.177213937,
-0.6405015588,
0.7105196714,
0.5565512776,
0.0935748816,
-0.9337382317,
-0.5935275555,
0.0413247645,
0.096990563,
0.5111954808,
0.2569255829,
-0.844427824,
-0.1239618883,
0.0312670879,
-0.194024846,
0.0633817986,
0.5707655549,
-1.0910396576,
0.3924794495,
-0.0036440492,
0.3767025173,
0.3595973849,
-0.1454930454,
0.8097454906,
-0.0374765024,
0.4380266666,
0.5624754429,
0.0108955186,
0.1056184396,
-0.2462302744,
0.3165516555,
-0.0877941847,
-0.7528389096,
-0.3861453235,
0.658957541,
-1.4122356176,
-0.5700370073,
1.1520392895,
0.1707088053,
-0.6162059307,
-0.4365996718,
-0.2671152949,
-0.0783736855,
-0.9500755668,
0.5613014698,
-0.0113957394,
-0.0758542269,
-0.6186978221,
-0.6722548604,
0.2684460878,
0.2583418489,
-0.8824212551,
0.1960848421,
0.6323620677,
-0.095268935,
0.1134614348,
0.6969349384,
0.2068304121,
0.5242554545,
0.111804232,
0.3592898548,
-0.0539707579,
-0.5384989381,
-0.3338294923,
-0.0380937159,
0.1580683142,
0.0457639247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10702v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10702v2
|
Camels in a Changing Climate: Enhancing LM Adaptation with Tulu 2
| 2023-11-17T18:45:45 | 2023-11-20T02:01:33 |
Hamish Ivison, Yizhong Wang, Valentina Pyatkin, Nathan Lambert, Matthew Peters, Pradeep Dasigi, Joel Jang, David Wadden, Noah A. Smith, Iz Beltagy, Hannaneh Hajishirzi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Since the release of T\"ULU [Wang et al., 2023b], open resources for
instruction tuning have developed quickly, from better base models to new
finetuning techniques. We test and incorporate a number of these advances into
T\"ULU, resulting in T\"ULU 2, a suite of improved T\"ULU models for advancing
the understanding and best practices of adapting pretrained language models to
downstream tasks and user preferences. Concretely, we release: (1)
T\"ULU-V2-mix, an improved collection of high-quality instruction datasets; (2)
T\"ULU 2, LLAMA-2 models finetuned on the V2 mixture; (3) T\"ULU 2+DPO, T\"ULU
2 models trained with direct preference optimization (DPO), including the
largest DPO-trained model to date (T\"ULU 2+DPO 70B); (4) CODE T\"ULU 2, CODE
LLAMA models finetuned on our V2 mix that outperform CODE LLAMA and its
instruction-tuned variant, CODE LLAMA-Instruct. Our evaluation from multiple
perspectives shows that the T\"ULU 2 suite achieves state-of-the-art
performance among open models and matches or exceeds the performance of
GPT-3.5-turbo-0301 on several benchmarks. We release all the checkpoints, data,
training and evaluation code to facilitate future open efforts on adapting
large language models.
|
[
0.0404050983,
-0.5370577574,
0.0734955594,
0.2908835709,
-0.2719548643,
0.137581259,
-0.395219177,
-0.550098002,
-0.3838673532,
0.5782279372,
-0.4169525206,
-0.2384142876,
-0.4736331999,
-0.2225117832,
-0.1454699039,
1.1883283854,
-0.1041341424,
-0.0185097139,
0.1476876885,
-0.2874221206,
-0.7726038098,
-0.248006478,
-0.5094839334,
-0.5142589808,
0.5229580402,
0.7402642369,
0.8743259311,
0.5840506554,
0.2776471972,
0.1682730764,
-0.0128837451,
0.0960424095,
-0.8384332657,
0.0868337676,
-0.2225773931,
-0.4112977684,
-0.5126277208,
0.0840208232,
0.7095491886,
0.3684515357,
-0.3679872453,
0.3120668232,
0.2672465146,
0.8656573296,
-0.6927259564,
0.0655053034,
-0.7688122392,
-0.1446152329,
-0.0944107398,
-0.3307442963,
-0.5810263753,
-0.296657443,
0.1039776951,
-0.9079912901,
0.1097584143,
0.0363495983,
0.7538033724,
0.6213579178,
-0.3697777689,
-0.1568218768,
-0.8179544806,
1.000641942,
-0.5824806094,
0.5189934969,
0.2689865232,
0.3176672459,
-0.6567813158,
-0.7226252556,
-0.3642753065,
-0.1855724752,
0.3573321104,
0.2745082974,
-0.2380819917,
-0.0632388741,
-0.0999811143,
0.3533506989,
-0.1970912367,
0.5837385654,
-0.3766528368,
0.0428366028,
0.3830417693,
-0.0154647147,
0.0055085146,
0.322912842,
-0.2391702235,
-0.2504045069,
-0.8793093562,
0.0602642521,
0.2836057842,
0.009339571,
-0.3081246614,
0.3959437311,
0.0083569121,
0.7136947513,
-0.1414209604,
-0.078593865,
-0.0514647923,
-0.0757334009,
-0.4462891817,
-0.0365330614,
0.3083058596,
0.6263560057,
0.2262498438,
-0.0372428969,
-0.2791444361,
-0.2438716143,
0.0653859153,
-0.9115362763,
-0.4945057631,
0.0556003787,
-0.3616850972,
-0.4303540885,
-0.1371218115,
-0.740177989,
-0.5657072067,
-0.3322288692,
0.378611207,
-0.1757479757,
-0.4466591775,
0.3584069014,
-0.0840615556,
0.5865215063,
0.5416291952,
-0.9675284028,
0.329864949,
0.7357820868,
0.7573921084,
-0.1793189496,
-0.1532453001,
-0.7483491302,
0.2021299154,
-0.3432425857,
0.7801532149,
-0.7944948077,
-0.5797091722,
0.0333279893,
0.133106038,
-0.0295176655,
-0.5477600694,
0.2791944444,
-0.5709499121,
0.3774160147,
-0.2848308682,
-0.2417197675,
-0.2444016188,
-0.1760338098,
-0.5360506177,
1.4557898045,
0.5291903615,
-0.4793771505,
0.0765045509,
-0.9282205105,
-0.2768445015,
-0.2251241952,
0.2104126662,
-0.3928852081,
0.0735693648,
0.0501758568,
0.0325414576,
-0.6605805755,
-0.0917574242,
-0.1767068803,
-0.4116264284,
0.120432131,
-0.1998952478,
0.9662063718,
0.284765631,
-0.3074147403,
0.3639400005,
-0.4249683022,
0.0013519744,
0.1435647607,
-0.4878408313,
-0.1112948731,
0.1436323971,
0.1151457131,
-0.1862284094,
0.2259121537,
-0.2097233385,
0.4707611799,
-0.1013819277,
0.6622848511,
1.0961210728,
-0.1967151463,
0.553706646,
-0.4574031234,
0.5919288397,
0.0048283641,
0.2791653275,
0.1250673085,
-0.5351614356,
-1.1724816561,
0.199080348,
0.2917169333,
0.8351120949,
-0.5451919436,
0.318533659,
-0.0526600219,
-0.7061666846,
-0.6031599045,
0.085379757,
0.2759527564,
0.5478272438,
0.5078012943,
-0.2155017853,
-0.4789544344,
-0.4220194817,
-0.0408325456,
-0.2334925979,
-0.000697927,
0.3557066321,
0.2542533875,
-0.338691473,
0.6827961206,
-0.3751551807,
0.0425142907,
-0.1711013466,
-0.0709776133,
0.022676833,
0.6767265797,
0.8272295594,
-0.3718984127,
-0.2644070089,
0.2676675022,
-0.3509157598,
-0.1477802545,
0.186860621,
-0.4899520576,
0.411596328,
0.2251007259,
-0.1418725848,
0.3006964624,
0.7151591182,
-0.3302507401,
0.5063996315,
-0.4267320037,
0.0910366625,
-1.0718871355,
-0.2038916349,
-0.0792408064,
-0.1300165802,
-0.496622473,
0.1386982352,
-0.0280225333,
0.0560199581,
-0.4676058888,
0.4393162727,
-0.4182011485,
-0.2321286649,
-0.3886760473,
0.0006831728,
0.1085293815,
0.2035980672,
-0.132895574,
1.0807180405,
0.7323265672,
-0.9093993902,
0.4212930202,
0.2005560994,
-0.5124672651,
-0.141409114,
-0.7894158959,
0.6236094236,
-0.0432346985,
0.324680835,
-0.6605320573,
-0.1819666177,
0.3689262569,
-0.0656544194,
0.4434953332,
-0.0655688718,
-0.3097884655,
-0.1768777519,
-0.2705121636,
0.3830127716,
0.8292940259,
-0.6700612307,
0.5666857362,
0.3061709702,
0.11650379,
-0.8074828386,
-0.5616954565,
-0.063758336,
-0.2242947519,
-0.2981799841,
0.2088009417,
-0.3696050048,
-0.2896765769,
-0.0105603114,
-0.2957712412,
-0.0229451042,
0.4765761495,
0.1156001166,
0.3526736796,
-0.613026619,
-0.0057247528,
0.0784927532,
0.0046647671,
-0.1725688875,
-0.6377519965,
0.4809791744,
-0.1141633987,
0.1378334016,
-0.3584938049,
0.1098822355,
0.2914347649,
-0.3906565905,
0.7121757269,
0.8048886657,
-0.2234260589,
-0.1071352288,
-0.4383217394,
0.0111089014,
-0.5261344314,
0.4603582025,
-0.2430836707,
-0.9161124229,
0.2376052141,
-0.1514089108,
0.4739105403,
0.3500416577,
0.4996095896,
-0.0928645656,
0.5909407735,
1.0547616482,
-0.2480357587,
0.8594250083,
-0.2394230813,
0.0099335462,
-0.9237145782,
-0.3878205717,
-0.6907988191,
-0.3413523138,
-0.7314831018,
-0.5295690298,
0.1252058148,
0.4474200308,
-0.5119690895,
0.2839632034,
-0.6508147717,
0.6965335608,
0.6186734438,
0.1517817229,
-0.0155751323,
0.1557349563,
0.270373553,
0.2465570569,
-0.7158399224,
-0.5047821403,
1.0053529739,
0.3326184154,
0.8655152321,
0.3405703008,
0.1219348982,
0.4553438723,
0.3684894443,
-0.7610912919,
0.3515191674,
-0.3334895372,
-0.2558268011,
-0.3337309957,
-0.1086612865,
-1.059731245,
-0.0399345979,
-0.1126437634,
-0.6985332966,
-0.0902831778,
0.0992827341,
-0.3085574508,
0.4115273654,
-0.7481685281,
0.8910935521,
-0.2925890088,
-0.2383740693,
-0.4839244485,
-0.5302768946,
0.1869232804,
-0.0482443981,
0.0829559192,
-0.5147464871,
-0.3706300259,
0.8193164468,
-0.1799206436,
0.6905370951,
-0.2705736458,
-0.2887128592,
0.4434700012,
0.1729042828,
0.4196791947,
-0.0863621682,
-0.5207803249,
0.1413970143,
-0.0288469158,
-0.6952676177,
-0.4771371782,
0.8410925865,
-1.4046875238,
-0.9000228047,
-0.3148984909,
-0.7223790288,
0.0706681311,
0.0450671576,
0.1499199569,
0.4580579996,
-0.0591918901,
0.1783981174,
0.4737991095,
-0.3752629161,
0.4605523944,
0.6311417222,
-0.133332938,
-0.2998588681,
0.8491305113,
-0.198249504,
0.3670590222,
0.3668136895,
0.547180593,
-0.1707095206,
-0.6491872072,
-0.6116495132,
0.1086968258,
-0.7130150199,
-0.3710396886,
-0.233489275,
-0.1126546189,
-0.5434350371,
-0.0800254792,
-0.1548331678,
-0.4383616447,
-0.7785059214,
-0.0411018878,
0.7979970574,
1.2348618507,
-0.0016061043,
0.622241497,
-0.7061296701,
0.1284922212,
0.1313257068,
0.2087685317,
-0.1178314686,
-0.9570993185,
-0.3246925175,
0.2370861769,
-0.5181418657,
-0.7416800261,
0.0580462813,
0.5611536503,
0.3800890148,
0.1620662808,
0.2070316523,
0.7092624307,
-0.4038776457,
0.9219909906,
0.0493237749,
-0.8983867764,
0.7866352201,
-0.2786789536,
0.139385134,
0.2603720725,
0.2398026288,
-0.38416785,
-0.1332327127,
-0.2492877245,
-0.4780012369,
0.9063359499,
0.0174415298,
0.2113267332,
0.2566965222,
0.5374282002,
0.4327732325,
-0.1123058647,
-0.5757454038,
-0.2984931171,
-0.6079685092,
-0.0236810949,
-0.1704562902,
-0.4509071708,
-0.0039723357,
-0.3724383712,
0.9163480401,
-0.0878040865,
0.0605928749,
-0.107878074,
0.0198883321,
-0.3257738948,
0.2783575356,
0.6478728652,
0.6640413404,
-0.2621939778,
-0.2246247679,
0.1837843508,
-0.5824115872,
0.1507813931,
0.1043905243,
-0.1596662253,
-0.3138600588,
0.0720445067,
1.0892374516,
0.0786515027,
-0.4397854805,
0.1505602002,
-0.00964138,
0.1471784264,
-0.3143357038,
0.5564466119,
-0.1350937486,
0.3166474104,
0.1881144047,
0.1035629883,
-0.0838103518,
-0.6210631132,
-0.1357592642,
0.0689374879,
-0.3656338751,
-0.3509811461,
0.8247047067,
0.4229810238,
-0.3715530336,
0.7023406029,
-0.0391100086,
-0.2174502909,
0.6987116933,
0.9688329101,
0.703588903,
-0.4946129322,
0.0968098417,
0.3354122043,
0.3517623246,
-0.1069409251,
0.2898415923,
0.0346251018,
-0.7876393795,
-0.3338240981,
-0.512696445,
-0.5720672011,
0.3332433403,
-0.7960865498,
0.478530407,
-0.5915593505,
0.0107588135,
-0.3184441626,
0.0664983466,
-0.6510878205,
0.0668979809,
0.0177258942,
0.958863914,
-0.6743928194,
1.348492384,
0.8375536203,
-0.0689635202,
-0.6607711315,
-0.0733418688,
-0.1358408332,
-0.9858779907,
0.1838030964,
0.1683204472,
-0.2849532664,
0.2019189596,
-0.550219059,
-0.7810332775,
1.3469685316,
0.5611099601,
-0.7095172405,
0.0456325971,
-0.0592692196,
0.217661649,
-0.4635270536,
0.2949733436,
1.0712661743,
0.35183689,
0.081605114,
-0.9472730756,
-0.0972962901,
-0.0432447866,
-0.0704964995,
0.122868441,
-0.9164412618,
0.6242759228,
-0.6952208877,
-0.1560656726,
0.4813632369,
0.9543919563,
0.2192406356,
0.2880422175,
0.5375418067,
0.3032229543,
1.0342464447,
-0.1986790001,
1.0162136555,
-0.2951775491,
0.2057297975,
1.1941347122,
-0.2137218714,
1.00989604,
0.1660465151,
-0.1710338593,
0.7923137546,
0.9727351665,
0.0911665708,
0.6300072074,
0.1733974814,
-0.3059822917,
-0.2012967765,
-0.6652505398,
-0.689198792,
0.3112759292,
0.5437322259,
0.0951519161,
-0.0382922776,
-0.1701554656,
-0.0669489503,
-0.0346351415,
-0.4146924317,
0.5924697518,
0.0611143038,
-0.5255178809,
0.8711526394,
0.0936297402,
0.51304847,
-0.4467561543,
-0.080186002,
-0.3132419884,
0.181417793,
-0.183773309,
-0.9618564248,
-0.0652856827,
0.1756612659,
0.0229058452,
-0.0256496221,
0.5525806546,
-0.3695837557,
-0.4249093235,
0.3920438588,
0.0924973637,
0.3910507262,
0.2825613618,
-0.7302157879,
0.3085768521,
0.2524676621,
-0.1982335299,
0.0874250308,
0.4356257617,
0.0438784286,
0.5492854118,
0.5673145652,
-0.1477647275,
0.1029311866,
0.3853157759,
0.9555643797,
-0.6377745867,
-0.1741241068,
-0.5265052915,
0.3153736889,
0.2578670084,
-0.3777342141,
0.3811770976,
0.6238416433,
0.8797566295,
-0.0548079982,
0.7079526782,
0.0590437613,
0.1499745399,
-0.7007705569,
0.3506671786,
-0.7070317864,
0.2524375319,
0.2533891797,
-1.1632833481,
0.0555262789,
0.3276994824,
-0.0425663143,
0.0662021041,
0.5917552114,
0.717202127,
-0.0501323193,
-0.0224729814,
0.2169311941,
0.3144509792,
0.3487274647,
0.8723269105,
0.8616216183,
-0.5851367712,
0.5458151698,
-0.2610121667,
-0.3633383811,
-0.3124572933,
-1.0502552986,
-0.9079141617,
-0.3994375467,
-0.525339663,
-0.4434784949,
0.2388831079,
0.9449083805,
0.4943647385,
-0.8787776232,
-0.3711486757,
-0.0167879909,
0.0609431937,
-0.1312542558,
-0.1409600228,
0.2796694934,
-0.2740782201,
-0.6263096929,
0.5911064744,
0.2073014826,
0.3507865369,
-0.0690877885,
-0.4347580373,
0.2152375877,
0.1383577138,
0.5747439265,
0.3538969755,
-0.8832185864,
-0.6343027949,
0.0186163187,
0.0195893627,
0.2480536997,
0.7390925288,
-0.5852029324,
0.2830110192,
0.2752549946,
0.686821878,
0.4538850784,
-0.2192346305,
0.557086885,
-0.445426017,
0.5058032274,
-0.1292916983,
0.3436200023,
0.481821537,
-0.2149373293,
0.7914496064,
-0.0373609699,
-0.7783480883,
-0.6727948785,
0.278565675,
-1.2789075375,
-0.1682079583,
1.396492362,
-0.0728715137,
-0.3315998614,
0.0315675214,
-0.2683697045,
0.557123661,
-0.4814800024,
0.7905549407,
0.5256952643,
0.0914097279,
-0.0811071992,
-0.7601955533,
0.3813284338,
0.4544451833,
-0.7636879683,
0.1435117424,
0.4356313944,
0.4088790417,
-0.3925041556,
0.3332906067,
0.1635803729,
0.4573565423,
-0.2565235198,
0.0336441323,
-0.2534259558,
-0.4120919406,
-0.2542538643,
-0.4847355187,
0.4532984197,
-0.4186054468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10697v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10697v1
|
PEFT-MedAware: Large Language Model for Medical Awareness
| 2023-11-17T18:32:17 | 2023-11-17T18:32:17 |
Keivalya Pandya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Chat models are capable of answering a wide range of questions, however, the
accuracy of their responses is highly uncertain. In this research, we propose a
specialized PEFT-MedAware model where we utilize parameter-efficient
fine-tuning (PEFT) to enhance the Falcon-1b large language model on specialized
MedQuAD data consisting of 16,407 medical QA pairs, leveraging only 0.44% of
its trainable parameters to enhance computational efficiency. The paper adopts
data preprocessing and PEFT to optimize model performance, complemented by a
BitsAndBytesConfig for efficient transformer training. The resulting model was
capable of outperforming other LLMs in medical question-answering tasks in
specific domains with greater accuracy utilizing limited computational
resources making it suitable for deployment in resource-constrained
environments. We propose further improvements through expanded datasets, larger
models, and feedback mechanisms for sustained medical relevancy. Our work
highlights the efficiency gains and specialized capabilities of PEFT in medical
AI, outpacing standard models in precision without extensive resource demands.
The proposed model and data are released for research purposes only.
|
[
-0.2137702554,
-1.1242995262,
0.7138983011,
0.0105573116,
-0.135784477,
0.1052827239,
-0.249054864,
-0.4629656374,
0.1702695638,
0.5696228147,
-0.4451694787,
-0.3270942271,
-0.7649943233,
0.0924597234,
-0.181675598,
1.0008254051,
0.0722110197,
-0.0406529382,
0.0349732004,
-0.1374157518,
-0.2618848681,
-0.703568697,
-0.9833053946,
-0.1978058666,
0.5179422498,
0.5486068726,
0.7926808,
0.491073668,
0.8949667811,
0.2529695332,
-0.0155157195,
0.2858116031,
-0.6789091825,
-0.0037104448,
-0.0675240979,
-0.5281771421,
-0.8324523568,
-0.2124341875,
0.5878257751,
0.7639498711,
-0.2561199665,
0.0398747809,
-0.2574308515,
0.717620492,
-0.2862463593,
0.2040821612,
-0.7422055006,
-0.1152589396,
0.1102305874,
0.0297971778,
-0.2441233695,
-0.1429320872,
0.3378658295,
-0.7236142159,
-0.0670449361,
0.0341241248,
0.8829508424,
0.5351881981,
-0.400318265,
0.0854062587,
-0.6530731916,
0.6728521585,
-0.7319142818,
0.5284907222,
0.580853343,
0.4106726944,
-0.0731669366,
-1.0856434107,
-0.27408126,
-0.1664909273,
0.1064381078,
0.0644804537,
-0.3426030576,
0.3616549075,
0.0289986748,
0.186247319,
-0.3614380956,
0.1092481241,
-0.4021906555,
0.0317765549,
0.5538929701,
0.316008389,
0.1096253693,
0.1633890122,
-0.0009927548,
0.1167708188,
-0.518979013,
0.1796949208,
-0.4325116873,
0.0932596624,
-0.2012812197,
0.5414350033,
-0.2788129151,
0.5763576627,
0.4612963796,
-0.2657642663,
0.237954244,
-0.1811697036,
-0.4124208987,
-0.4364068508,
0.7726738453,
0.5362130404,
0.3765752316,
-0.1613706201,
-0.0279081836,
-0.1815609485,
0.4947216809,
-0.9751895666,
-0.2748700082,
0.4485607743,
-0.5263634324,
-0.2568057477,
-0.3144873679,
-0.4040273726,
-0.5248568654,
-0.1933822185,
0.4843807518,
-0.6530745625,
-0.2537492216,
0.4183084071,
0.2770631909,
-0.1063479632,
0.3531140983,
-0.8210995793,
0.3254330158,
0.6626019478,
0.6031245589,
-0.0151980277,
-0.0158877727,
-0.4237388372,
-0.0285972599,
-0.2708649933,
0.7220424414,
-0.7849677205,
-0.3083385825,
-0.3913191855,
0.2382746041,
-0.4589005411,
-0.5632281303,
0.6035768986,
-0.4814068377,
-0.1528560817,
-0.1147629246,
-0.73928231,
-0.2069201022,
0.2914710641,
-0.4325593114,
0.5719840527,
0.436003387,
-0.6620041728,
0.2599906325,
-0.7378087044,
-0.4340125024,
0.2052438557,
-0.2958621979,
-0.4914886653,
0.0869807899,
0.5060881972,
0.5811187625,
-0.4717998505,
0.5603369474,
-0.0822126195,
-0.4285627007,
0.3138823211,
-0.3050363362,
0.2288156152,
0.2255743891,
-0.1244324595,
0.0702329427,
-0.6070824862,
0.1062634513,
0.1032180637,
-0.4766251445,
-0.2315988392,
0.0457592346,
0.0343565531,
-0.0190635361,
0.3360022902,
-0.5162579417,
0.1361366957,
-0.7762694955,
0.5799948573,
0.3314222991,
0.2999880016,
0.3450971246,
-0.6646646261,
0.6228509545,
0.0918345228,
0.7266474366,
-0.0396576412,
-0.6349814534,
-0.5192081928,
-0.45582816,
0.3315489888,
0.4768741131,
-0.4358176589,
0.3547160923,
-0.1940674633,
-0.5797861218,
-0.9304395914,
-0.2005568147,
0.2458700836,
0.8818175793,
0.3846001923,
0.1741476059,
-0.541444838,
-1.2157648802,
-0.0915181786,
-0.2931855619,
-0.0922810659,
0.624240756,
0.1453834325,
-0.5295963287,
0.553470552,
-0.4703934193,
-0.0369656831,
-0.1489460915,
-0.1985456645,
0.3743412495,
0.4417049289,
0.6069914103,
-0.9074523449,
-0.5274954438,
0.1723688692,
-0.3882362247,
-0.0397770144,
-0.0416632816,
-0.0486501679,
0.0623463877,
0.3723388314,
-0.3739061654,
0.0469450243,
0.5874744654,
-0.314026624,
0.1468361914,
-0.3021451831,
0.5739601851,
-1.1807230711,
0.2948902547,
-0.0963890851,
-0.2423949093,
-0.8456664085,
0.2070078999,
0.3151650131,
-0.0105569875,
-0.2771207392,
0.34425053,
0.1325281262,
0.7448395491,
-0.3291632235,
-0.2711459696,
0.0236485582,
0.3647392094,
0.0932651013,
0.887727499,
0.5629379153,
-0.4444171488,
0.0261939578,
0.180357188,
-0.0176422186,
0.5275382996,
-1.0786805153,
0.0675010458,
-0.1278170645,
-0.0149906492,
-0.8229415417,
-0.4099789262,
-0.0112902327,
-0.39428702,
0.3057025671,
-0.1519063562,
-0.3559994102,
-0.3440229297,
-0.0149571104,
0.4328660071,
0.893219173,
-0.1873932183,
0.5471782684,
0.7878389955,
-0.2683454454,
-0.2563124597,
-0.3438241482,
-0.1247431114,
-0.128106907,
-0.7185686827,
0.1998890936,
-0.0874608383,
-0.0899595469,
-0.500132978,
-0.0254926328,
-0.3164919615,
0.0878600329,
0.4088387787,
0.1794643849,
-0.2532007396,
0.5395495296,
0.3363028169,
-0.0245727729,
-0.0422959886,
-0.0710684732,
0.5233268738,
-0.2630320191,
-0.2399773151,
-0.3780603707,
0.5331143141,
0.9371993542,
-0.2740130723,
0.8929485083,
0.3057415783,
-0.5791882277,
0.3009124398,
-0.7788504362,
-0.2896183729,
-0.4648397863,
0.7707917094,
-0.3573851287,
-1.1169084311,
0.4610207379,
-0.2697910964,
0.1443006098,
0.524763763,
0.538182795,
-0.2971045673,
1.4703239202,
0.7131686211,
-0.0788659155,
0.0653939992,
-0.0159789249,
0.0470491648,
-0.6883887053,
-0.3571080863,
-0.4860684276,
-0.2401675582,
-0.4143005908,
-0.4774242043,
1.0183273554,
-0.1710160673,
-0.5403084755,
-0.0556927659,
-0.6177194715,
0.2900919616,
0.2422555387,
0.5786824822,
0.278285414,
-0.0961825624,
0.0663275719,
-0.1463753581,
-0.9309066534,
-0.3838274479,
1.1971496344,
0.6447169185,
0.861636281,
-0.27871418,
0.2534480095,
-0.2098163962,
0.1651679873,
-0.6988726854,
0.1771318316,
-0.5211794972,
-0.5289140344,
-0.2858272791,
-0.2993309796,
-0.877314508,
-0.2052777112,
-0.4314314425,
-0.5159929991,
-0.0039140065,
0.0961409733,
-0.7067121267,
0.2375573963,
-0.897303164,
0.6646586061,
0.0527927577,
-0.003233846,
-0.3277638853,
-0.7480110526,
0.1993353516,
-0.6449614763,
0.1242226511,
-0.1003889665,
-0.3430010974,
0.8103969693,
-0.5045674443,
0.785220325,
-0.0231031757,
-0.0057627559,
0.0137469117,
-0.2229600102,
0.5683637261,
0.1823417246,
-0.3141667843,
0.0520424768,
0.2863401473,
-0.3989894688,
-0.4459016919,
0.548365891,
-0.9568629861,
-0.6226710081,
0.1447740644,
-0.7956940532,
-0.6237787008,
0.0241327025,
0.3145201802,
0.300133884,
-0.0117194615,
0.4082873762,
0.7767875791,
-0.2726525068,
-0.096270062,
0.7764894366,
-0.0549339466,
-0.2034325153,
0.3831276298,
0.1708737612,
0.1554743201,
0.5337844491,
0.2289513052,
-0.2687090635,
-0.6771956682,
-0.1703771353,
0.4412092865,
-0.4123760462,
-0.2617223859,
-1.06054914,
-0.5144440532,
-0.2423196286,
-0.2620329559,
-0.5299185514,
-0.3477838933,
-0.2044382393,
0.1987732202,
0.8407464623,
0.4810583591,
0.3807162344,
0.4919430614,
-0.9337918758,
0.4220913351,
0.213659212,
0.6933524609,
-0.2103516459,
-0.7146733403,
-0.2930082977,
0.2384761274,
-0.017730793,
-0.7225350738,
0.098129347,
0.3338983059,
0.4433711171,
0.3331802785,
0.22990565,
0.678340435,
-0.4601750672,
0.5563414097,
0.1340065747,
-0.6252046227,
0.6867765784,
-0.4914672673,
0.4157974422,
0.7563404441,
0.3398260176,
-0.4725314379,
-0.7057942748,
-0.6931685209,
-0.5821152925,
0.3909102678,
0.1038191393,
0.1833281219,
-0.0626860261,
0.6875528097,
0.1540904492,
-0.0233381726,
-0.0725868419,
0.0092503587,
0.1888012141,
-0.4717372656,
0.0324133299,
-0.1281035095,
-0.0857299045,
-0.7245548368,
0.6153287292,
-0.1984561831,
0.0868176892,
0.3886756599,
0.219547838,
-0.273629576,
0.2378084809,
0.3725964427,
0.6369698644,
-0.1273319125,
-0.0563511662,
0.466344893,
-0.9770902395,
0.0288216267,
0.0888508484,
0.0594522581,
-0.2286670804,
0.0578969829,
0.5649886131,
0.1337961257,
-0.9762375355,
0.4629462063,
-0.1944784671,
-0.2128839791,
0.0261599217,
0.3499934375,
0.2137617022,
0.4324966073,
0.312169224,
0.1487803161,
0.1162353978,
-0.1280842125,
0.3690176308,
0.3265160918,
-0.2672546208,
-0.0936198682,
0.8738529086,
0.2599120736,
-0.2674502432,
0.6226862073,
0.3221501112,
-0.2420751452,
0.7603604794,
0.4326147437,
0.3541753292,
-0.4198396206,
0.0306118038,
0.441277951,
0.3694250286,
0.0601911247,
0.5721160173,
0.3801499009,
-0.4060687721,
-0.5928487182,
-0.495236367,
-0.4314573109,
0.4277571142,
-0.4027896523,
0.1972779036,
-0.6271129251,
-0.5780314207,
0.1626218259,
0.0591468178,
-0.5685182214,
0.3139657676,
-0.209558025,
1.0614356995,
-0.4559521973,
0.8901503682,
0.9104691148,
-0.1334767491,
-1.2147266865,
-0.1692857593,
-0.4335149825,
-1.0303092003,
0.1944587827,
-0.2096096128,
0.1165176034,
0.0319494307,
-0.4968535006,
-0.7621626854,
0.8909417391,
0.4906225502,
-1.0205523968,
-0.006455732,
0.1400906891,
0.7341970801,
-0.4398276508,
0.2192500085,
0.8467443585,
0.351038903,
-0.0806620866,
-1.3068732023,
0.0724884495,
-0.4023483694,
-0.1355922073,
0.2173323482,
-0.772906661,
0.7191211581,
-0.330601722,
0.1687733829,
0.0086753396,
0.1252263635,
0.3565706611,
0.0978884995,
0.4172716737,
0.1704236567,
0.9811177254,
-0.0040438049,
1.0099557638,
-0.5182533264,
0.1585068554,
0.765201509,
-0.1800404191,
0.7738566995,
0.5268329978,
-0.3025431335,
0.1124918833,
0.4997013211,
0.059043847,
0.3157149255,
-0.1196264923,
-0.257729888,
-0.4091213644,
-0.1005543098,
-0.483723104,
0.4190364778,
0.5273083448,
-0.6523317695,
-0.0025599319,
0.1604620069,
0.1520897895,
0.0356343165,
-0.392650187,
0.8448777795,
-0.0531549603,
-0.7353980541,
0.9057990313,
0.070256047,
0.6001865864,
-0.6164882779,
0.0583309121,
-0.2483327985,
0.2079298794,
-0.0894125104,
-0.5725578666,
0.3258875608,
0.0946208984,
-0.4296076596,
0.2719265521,
0.7454952002,
-0.2951592803,
-0.7092508078,
-0.054179702,
0.5303230286,
0.1626989245,
-0.2853625715,
-0.8004172444,
-0.0847953856,
-0.1441407353,
-0.1176877692,
0.2476374656,
0.2529793084,
-0.0872418955,
0.7059306502,
0.3805941939,
0.0979741439,
-0.1393100023,
0.2892267704,
0.9283177853,
-0.2800122499,
-0.5499172807,
-0.713246882,
0.3524897695,
0.0206812769,
-0.1834016442,
0.2145320624,
0.4506439567,
0.1748288125,
-0.0973870084,
0.7573104501,
0.1231933609,
0.7931573391,
-0.2209711671,
1.2001805305,
-0.5446772575,
0.1837133318,
-0.0933060572,
-0.2625184655,
-0.2956992686,
0.4858776033,
-0.2321963906,
0.0436614938,
0.5400685668,
0.8153235912,
-0.1783804446,
0.2617761791,
0.5484814644,
0.4551537335,
0.2144918144,
1.0498132706,
0.5753546357,
-0.5231335759,
0.3804139197,
-0.2251559943,
-0.4667160809,
-0.2337832749,
-0.446747452,
-0.9408986568,
-0.7232425809,
-0.422226727,
-0.068409659,
0.1703274846,
0.9998466969,
1.1798388958,
-0.7907879949,
0.245483458,
-0.0321754441,
-0.3313052356,
-0.114339754,
-0.154928565,
0.4762117863,
-0.3553361297,
-0.5240271688,
0.3138652742,
0.3133624792,
0.1178316921,
0.1800438166,
-0.0668554753,
-0.0348176882,
0.3989644349,
0.5496501327,
0.0536896028,
-0.5421280861,
-0.3143064082,
0.4933805764,
-0.1848281771,
0.1907182187,
0.5611843467,
-0.773801744,
0.3104742169,
0.1946635097,
0.7973366976,
0.3287083507,
0.0682093129,
0.6626591682,
-0.5836032033,
-0.0783471689,
0.4261850417,
0.2811788619,
0.0579139963,
-0.6916678548,
0.3730914891,
-0.1560010016,
-0.7207197547,
-0.5743217468,
0.0270887222,
-0.9373828769,
-0.3541711271,
1.0032786131,
-0.026376497,
-0.0650725439,
-0.3471828401,
-0.6000438929,
0.3462181985,
-0.3890455365,
0.8525389433,
0.3838198185,
-0.3622204661,
-0.2752230763,
-0.4277128279,
0.5124437213,
0.5794485211,
-0.975107491,
-0.0077247829,
0.180713594,
0.5639449954,
-0.2318975031,
0.9552157521,
-0.2932227552,
0.5647819042,
-0.2838905752,
-0.3646402657,
-0.1381301582,
-0.2183533609,
-0.2725464702,
0.3194160461,
0.190607816,
-0.0759147331
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10810v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10810v1
|
Use GPT-J Prompt Generation with RoBERTa for NER Models on Diagnosis Extraction of Periodontal Diagnosis from Electronic Dental Records
| 2023-11-17T18:14:08 | 2023-11-17T18:14:08 |
Yao-Shun Chuang, Xiaoqian Jiang, Chun-Teh Lee, Ryan Brandon, Duong Tran, Oluwabunmi Tokede, Muhammad F. Walji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study explored the usability of prompt generation on named entity
recognition (NER) tasks and the performance in different settings of the
prompt. The prompt generation by GPT-J models was utilized to directly test the
gold standard as well as to generate the seed and further fed to the RoBERTa
model with the spaCy package. In the direct test, a lower ratio of negative
examples with higher numbers of examples in prompt achieved the best results
with a F1 score of 0.72. The performance revealed consistency, 0.92-0.97 in the
F1 score, in all settings after training with the RoBERTa model. The study
highlighted the importance of seed quality rather than quantity in feeding NER
models. This research reports on an efficient and accurate way to mine clinical
notes for periodontal diagnoses, allowing researchers to easily and quickly
build a NER model with the prompt generation approach.
|
[
-0.1974570602,
-1.0527485609,
0.6625112295,
-0.0066854875,
-0.3225834668,
-0.4071195722,
-0.1870778948,
-0.4679415822,
0.0402914397,
0.3298513591,
-0.4871453643,
-0.5563347936,
-0.5740408897,
0.6658754945,
-0.3784086108,
0.9161365032,
0.1617780477,
0.4244178236,
0.0614141673,
0.2006310821,
-0.8597456813,
-0.2041587234,
-1.05849576,
-0.1150369197,
0.2373373508,
0.0029961884,
0.3881573379,
0.4730002284,
0.581977427,
0.2526466548,
-0.0784044713,
-0.0394444279,
0.1211704984,
0.4376711845,
-0.0138132805,
-0.3565509319,
-0.3921220601,
0.038460128,
0.3612032533,
0.5412486792,
-0.1427953392,
0.1974391341,
-0.0520414934,
0.3034856915,
-0.0105451187,
0.1717071235,
-0.3661545813,
0.2517402768,
-0.2518122792,
-0.3616926074,
-0.7572864294,
-0.5141763687,
0.4468200803,
-0.7267315984,
0.4966652989,
-0.0044930838,
1.2942718267,
-0.020106582,
-0.1238267571,
-0.5553734899,
-0.7433444858,
0.5101447701,
-0.5362741351,
0.0784711018,
0.0393296033,
0.5578343868,
-0.1436570138,
-0.7088245153,
-0.4189665616,
-0.394665122,
0.0251228008,
0.0177841075,
-0.6206685901,
-0.030794343,
0.6022436619,
0.2810823321,
-1.0434494019,
-0.1433230788,
-0.1297995448,
-0.0756027251,
0.0830688104,
0.15967682,
0.7154904008,
-0.5860162377,
-0.417000711,
-0.1993034184,
-0.7359793782,
-0.0106235612,
0.10880474,
0.7275600433,
0.1750994176,
0.3923094571,
0.0503775217,
0.9266675115,
0.3171508908,
-0.4910911322,
0.2704010308,
-0.308816582,
-0.2322683781,
0.0331864804,
0.4674594402,
0.067895703,
0.2626793981,
-0.0495383814,
-0.2866801322,
0.0308097284,
0.096069172,
-0.9255170822,
-0.5089961886,
0.001686535,
-0.6556378007,
-0.2275517881,
0.0489392206,
-0.7248265743,
-0.0705291331,
-0.3722972274,
0.5130093694,
-0.6111989617,
-0.3903862536,
-0.0152687365,
-0.5173522234,
0.0327134095,
0.6123002172,
-0.6456081867,
0.3444550037,
0.4451379478,
0.7015560865,
0.0352437943,
0.3156042695,
-0.8566384912,
-0.159309566,
-0.1871189922,
0.9625967741,
-0.4327453971,
-0.7885278463,
-0.1513452381,
0.1083998531,
-0.3630133271,
-0.8023662567,
0.0976006612,
-0.4773320258,
0.4350219369,
-0.061523214,
-0.5757439733,
-0.3159176707,
0.115644902,
-0.6209970117,
0.8129299283,
0.5718793869,
-0.3993169665,
0.6169448495,
-0.5527811646,
-0.2535381615,
0.4176837206,
-0.2095021605,
-0.4351074696,
0.0330539197,
0.2585303187,
0.248435691,
-0.2907319665,
0.6695837975,
0.0893456936,
0.203749314,
0.3977833986,
-0.5874502063,
0.9530403614,
0.1521982551,
-0.3947539032,
0.026366245,
-0.8763318062,
0.1323083639,
0.3027161658,
-0.108814314,
-0.3985168338,
-0.5771642923,
-0.0809018984,
0.2364757508,
-0.049088452,
-0.3803567886,
0.4273760021,
-0.1519420445,
0.2623236477,
0.6160107255,
0.6326931715,
0.0529131703,
-0.3149042726,
0.9417620897,
-0.237315461,
0.0407272726,
-0.3633422554,
-0.8150934577,
-0.4041672349,
-0.1157092005,
0.89106071,
0.6425366402,
-0.3938209713,
0.5337123871,
-0.1664536893,
-0.3429912031,
-0.2828347683,
-0.097429812,
0.5883338451,
1.0607717037,
0.3348724246,
-0.3632098436,
-0.398018539,
-0.6584183574,
0.0962433964,
0.0962401107,
-0.0668900982,
0.4055051804,
0.5747004747,
0.1660156995,
1.0487725735,
-0.5544942617,
-0.0563271269,
-0.4078205824,
0.5509945154,
0.4546433985,
0.5202981234,
0.6192706823,
-0.8448435664,
-0.6540152431,
-0.2670532465,
-0.7213760018,
-0.2535090446,
0.0905208215,
0.244125694,
0.1967701167,
0.1855262518,
-0.6118991971,
0.6754741669,
0.3526732326,
-0.2563349903,
0.5226638913,
-0.2234540433,
0.406346947,
-1.1810561419,
0.2355619222,
0.4716230333,
-0.5750460625,
-0.5037552118,
-0.1212346405,
-0.0400872007,
-0.6556248069,
-0.420529604,
0.4698956907,
-0.6091800928,
-0.114639841,
-0.1012726575,
0.1631676555,
0.1664134711,
-0.1485193521,
0.0225240402,
1.2095006704,
0.2826308608,
-0.8726511002,
0.0164553523,
0.2272304446,
0.0054085348,
0.6021402478,
-0.9449567795,
0.0072835186,
0.1639448702,
0.1350494772,
-0.911072433,
-0.2399692237,
0.2744513154,
-0.6910003424,
0.8077622056,
-0.4540274441,
-0.3651155233,
-0.4355170131,
0.197475642,
-0.0132447975,
0.6456708908,
-0.5887253881,
0.6224073172,
0.2756094038,
-0.6978469491,
-0.1348825693,
-0.4093453884,
-0.1133672222,
-0.4204606414,
-0.7836745381,
0.4806345105,
0.0435436442,
-0.3641465604,
0.1688536853,
-0.0511540845,
-0.1445411891,
0.1853709966,
0.3097299635,
0.5252741575,
-0.4712250829,
0.1710964739,
-0.1961526573,
-0.7354260683,
-0.1451190114,
-0.0232936535,
0.8072430491,
0.0214616172,
-0.3353525102,
-0.7098946571,
0.3411393464,
-0.1619576961,
-0.2074038684,
0.2221572399,
0.3846357167,
-0.507974267,
-0.1839837879,
-0.2757997215,
-0.1793354005,
-0.3941811919,
-0.2137447298,
-0.4497593939,
-0.5945854783,
0.4444133043,
-0.4140440822,
-0.3248435557,
0.8032100797,
0.3255864978,
0.1101284549,
1.1854624748,
0.5496482849,
0.1792807728,
0.6306078434,
-0.2885279059,
0.1097392291,
-0.9143329859,
0.021817334,
-0.810120225,
0.3463760912,
-0.3204124868,
-0.1301517487,
0.5754632354,
0.169922173,
0.067911543,
0.5048846006,
-0.8633947968,
0.2955271602,
0.5582210422,
0.0191630088,
0.2283624411,
-0.1968918592,
-0.068941839,
-0.2100375593,
-0.2098593265,
-0.8692487478,
1.1617558002,
-0.1628013104,
0.3063479364,
0.225557223,
0.8059261441,
0.4022951722,
0.293826431,
-0.4077703357,
0.4624582827,
-0.0820731223,
-0.5667751431,
-0.2520543337,
-0.2987563014,
-1.1859998703,
0.1295185387,
0.1040043309,
-1.0711584091,
0.0196207054,
0.0741752386,
-0.8630144596,
-0.1710564196,
-0.6735107899,
0.9646758437,
-0.0793184042,
0.2108616829,
0.2283957154,
-0.5241518617,
0.3477566242,
0.3862909377,
-0.1096890122,
-0.1733629107,
0.281493634,
0.6656863093,
-0.4279534519,
0.5420142412,
-0.5798195601,
0.1656426787,
0.3896143734,
0.1897382587,
0.625605166,
0.4249273837,
0.0778261125,
-0.1688226014,
-0.3830879331,
0.2167770863,
-0.6147546768,
0.4483599961,
-0.5377323031,
-0.7313437462,
-0.6789005399,
-0.0595217571,
0.1504546553,
0.2756058276,
0.2120061368,
0.9038835764,
-0.2873833776,
-0.2013529092,
1.0001391172,
-0.3144215941,
0.5730153322,
0.5713241696,
-0.1967214495,
-0.600610137,
0.8339034915,
0.3029315174,
0.1075179428,
0.3892794847,
0.2103416324,
-0.1770195812,
-0.6399466991,
-0.7480453253,
0.0727321506,
-0.5964961648,
-0.5085668564,
-0.777677834,
-0.2194053084,
-0.6276606321,
0.0070408965,
-0.0651796907,
-0.4633000791,
-0.7098516226,
-0.1131682694,
0.6946600676,
0.6948904395,
-0.211867094,
0.2754294872,
-0.8990744352,
0.2567106187,
0.0520173907,
-0.2644697726,
-0.1980879009,
-0.4625994861,
0.2933005691,
-0.2517745495,
-0.2517454028,
-1.1232196093,
0.8475300074,
-0.0614011548,
0.5017499924,
0.3605283201,
-0.1889450252,
0.991318047,
-0.4973594248,
0.951384306,
0.1375694275,
-0.9361369014,
1.1481148005,
-0.5431557894,
-0.1849447787,
0.6578046083,
0.4457063377,
-0.4298716187,
-0.044885505,
-1.0810376406,
-0.8853257298,
0.4303435683,
-0.2448242903,
-0.3784703314,
-0.2640749514,
0.3601405919,
0.3876106441,
-0.0014195524,
-0.5457589626,
-0.2845382988,
0.0249462537,
-0.1512242854,
0.1387372762,
-0.1899163574,
-0.1897222102,
-0.1766880006,
0.6068060994,
-0.0795295835,
0.427102834,
0.4265639186,
-0.3897712529,
-0.1607513279,
0.3461713791,
0.6894812584,
0.8474932909,
-0.2443098724,
-0.304846853,
-0.1887124479,
-0.2143372893,
0.1544499397,
0.4118800461,
-0.4669467211,
0.4348912537,
0.0940199941,
0.3503739834,
0.1671675593,
-0.2877455652,
0.5927866101,
-0.4099700451,
-0.1286988258,
-0.6870749593,
0.2886551619,
-0.1006599441,
0.114827089,
0.4306966662,
0.2415441126,
0.2848927081,
-0.1970152557,
0.4249524474,
0.3906229138,
-0.2550230324,
-0.3300324976,
0.5117943287,
0.0432589985,
-0.495365113,
1.1172844172,
-0.7258300781,
-0.3134832978,
0.8875502944,
1.0006241798,
0.7288498282,
-0.1307782233,
0.2299155891,
0.6073669791,
-0.1319599897,
-0.0718825236,
0.361879617,
0.1610520631,
-0.3796409369,
-0.062522769,
-0.4368837178,
-0.3547234833,
0.2435928583,
-1.0526505709,
0.1375932992,
-0.5052693486,
-0.4471156299,
0.3421046436,
0.2702844143,
-0.7780489922,
0.234311834,
-0.220188424,
0.7101222873,
-0.7534768581,
0.419844687,
0.301892519,
-1.0957269669,
-1.2685015202,
-0.2088947147,
0.4530081153,
-0.8304857612,
0.8818920851,
0.4292067885,
0.5624335408,
0.0810412839,
-0.1356621683,
-1.1237791777,
1.3609230518,
-0.0169024393,
-0.4602225721,
-0.0054656407,
-0.4510816634,
0.2240938693,
-0.4553518295,
0.5526775718,
0.220858708,
0.5357422829,
-0.1144054085,
-0.9614370465,
0.2393843979,
-0.2496999353,
0.2557213008,
0.3288266957,
-0.2776971757,
1.387040019,
-0.0845074132,
-0.6157764196,
0.3623769581,
0.4879122376,
0.4360438585,
0.1172828302,
0.32396245,
0.8074832559,
1.1235483885,
-0.3311194181,
1.2469651699,
-0.4023893178,
0.0225029774,
0.8245187998,
-0.3538345397,
0.5476180911,
0.1081563532,
-0.2435562015,
0.67000705,
0.9401156902,
-0.4209083617,
0.5438579321,
0.3304173648,
-0.1625741422,
-0.0438829437,
-0.3102844656,
-0.6960396767,
0.2080934942,
0.3454217017,
-0.5102022886,
-0.2674877942,
0.1011785641,
0.2758686841,
-0.099348411,
-0.1968025714,
0.9338547587,
-0.1082387045,
-0.7272481322,
0.005740928,
-0.0992857888,
0.4810450971,
-0.5343874693,
-0.5764362216,
0.0804203898,
0.0059237308,
0.0167781413,
-0.3699617088,
0.0935887247,
0.2608708739,
-0.5294779539,
-0.3273307681,
0.8926105499,
-0.0308073461,
-0.2271029502,
-0.0304929316,
0.6840904951,
0.3365909755,
0.1136883274,
-0.6059679389,
-0.245774433,
-0.0822588578,
-0.4037308693,
0.4634693563,
0.6473373175,
0.0362295695,
0.4496396184,
0.8614553809,
0.2815696299,
0.0439930707,
0.4575802684,
0.5756640434,
-0.7542468309,
-0.2391071618,
-0.7795487046,
0.5147505999,
-0.2051665038,
-0.7754184008,
0.8062944412,
0.550160408,
0.7095882297,
-0.0754849315,
0.7883332372,
-0.1079451889,
0.7722600698,
-0.6244043112,
0.3302206993,
-0.0479107313,
-0.0803659931,
-0.4328879714,
-0.4998072684,
-0.297215879,
0.7089086175,
-0.2697601616,
0.1515353173,
0.7993231416,
0.7203679681,
0.3386919796,
0.1615018398,
-0.0282536224,
-0.1741052717,
0.5341511369,
0.3413929939,
0.6132398248,
-0.4189556837,
0.3571739495,
-0.130178526,
-0.1448699981,
-0.2997360229,
-0.82987988,
-0.5098416209,
-0.2472404242,
-0.2732312083,
-0.4806338847,
0.2690036297,
1.0520474911,
0.618303299,
-0.595316112,
0.335911274,
-0.3079301715,
-0.0521780029,
-0.3395684361,
-0.3618386388,
0.5267277956,
-0.406442374,
-0.6079516411,
0.5479604602,
0.2102802992,
0.4789924324,
-0.0977020785,
0.1139820367,
0.0603584349,
-0.5369281769,
0.031836886,
0.4323141277,
-0.7035449743,
-0.3255567849,
0.1749466807,
-0.1362537444,
0.2854259908,
0.697461307,
-0.7081617117,
0.3537124991,
0.3446766436,
0.4071962535,
0.3925592303,
0.2118323296,
0.8161696196,
-0.4463835061,
-0.1765881628,
0.3826292455,
0.4205600023,
0.2933938801,
-0.4886940122,
0.5752667785,
0.4391042888,
-0.5908612609,
-0.7975394726,
0.025467433,
-1.1316201687,
-0.0930035114,
1.0173540115,
-0.4159903228,
-0.5838530064,
-0.1522252858,
0.0124565046,
0.3324736059,
-0.7522765398,
0.4929712117,
0.5232286453,
-0.536678493,
-0.0344428942,
-0.6570096612,
0.4030784965,
-0.2146513909,
-0.7745012641,
-0.1973540634,
0.343549788,
0.6454942822,
0.3756889701,
0.8371207118,
-0.2792437673,
0.5829069018,
0.4243652821,
0.1815532595,
-0.2789772749,
-0.3077481389,
-0.5477258563,
0.2624963224,
0.2431747615,
-0.124759227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10642v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10642v4
|
Rethinking Attention: Exploring Shallow Feed-Forward Neural Networks as an Alternative to Attention Layers in Transformers
| 2023-11-17T16:58:52 | 2024-02-04T20:39:33 |
Vukasin Bozic, Danilo Dordevic, Daniele Coppola, Joseph Thommes, Sidak Pal Singh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This work presents an analysis of the effectiveness of using standard shallow
feed-forward networks to mimic the behavior of the attention mechanism in the
original Transformer model, a state-of-the-art architecture for
sequence-to-sequence tasks. We substitute key elements of the attention
mechanism in the Transformer with simple feed-forward networks, trained using
the original components via knowledge distillation. Our experiments, conducted
on the IWSLT2017 dataset, reveal the capacity of these "attentionless
Transformers" to rival the performance of the original architecture. Through
rigorous ablation studies, and experimenting with various replacement network
types and sizes, we offer insights that support the viability of our approach.
This not only sheds light on the adaptability of shallow feed-forward networks
in emulating attention mechanisms but also underscores their potential to
streamline complex architectures for sequence-to-sequence tasks.
|
[
-0.442266196,
-0.2566796541,
0.3264852464,
0.2831401825,
-0.1597731709,
-0.1121683866,
0.0066374191,
-0.1561642885,
0.3477942944,
0.3922349215,
-0.9093269706,
0.2912091017,
-0.5737094283,
0.2569996417,
-0.9182066321,
0.9780134559,
0.0655072927,
-0.3426310718,
-0.1255903095,
0.1022168323,
-0.1994767636,
0.0862371325,
-0.8798089623,
-0.4694786072,
1.2695486546,
0.2613699436,
0.5973345637,
0.6277093291,
0.7924623489,
0.3811120689,
-0.2372265607,
-0.1493448168,
-0.8579382896,
-0.0798012689,
-0.3844020963,
-0.0938810632,
-0.0030670108,
-0.0536353923,
0.5178314447,
0.9095259905,
0.282389164,
0.4083325565,
0.2657549381,
0.934700489,
-0.7344536781,
0.0681508258,
-0.7118569016,
0.5204178095,
0.0788547397,
-0.1777987778,
-0.6823841929,
0.032704819,
0.4744171798,
-0.1250615567,
0.5622307062,
-0.1838322878,
0.3569218516,
0.9481860995,
-0.1362216622,
0.0917253271,
-1.0988940001,
0.425626874,
-0.54174757,
0.468944639,
-0.1631934345,
0.2736232579,
0.2828294039,
-1.1900280714,
-0.1677768379,
0.0478072278,
-0.3328741193,
0.5265354514,
-0.3515796959,
-0.1951289475,
0.3829208314,
0.6363499761,
-0.2859881222,
-0.1360460371,
-0.5638055801,
0.2252785563,
0.4339502454,
0.0196875408,
-0.1369172484,
0.1764038354,
-0.4723665118,
-0.1259038597,
-0.4069777131,
0.0686176345,
0.15099971,
0.3109831512,
0.0996695235,
0.5175536871,
-0.5898624659,
0.5531790853,
0.6170166135,
0.5048299432,
0.1280702204,
-0.0045011323,
-0.602227211,
0.2550145984,
0.4927642047,
0.0228916612,
0.1760729104,
-0.6835111976,
-0.2829477489,
-0.1850361973,
1.1934303045,
-0.4695644677,
-0.3908869922,
0.1135031506,
-0.5395315289,
-0.6531155109,
-0.1071947217,
-0.5017843246,
-0.2116580606,
-0.4488129616,
0.6011464596,
-0.1481477618,
-0.0812447518,
-0.0140529871,
-0.223412022,
0.5505130887,
0.2075635642,
-0.8997662067,
0.2916072309,
0.7190759182,
0.8014535308,
0.0390332714,
-0.3458685875,
-0.1401604861,
0.0074311648,
-0.058046151,
0.8508731127,
-0.1971339583,
-0.1960174292,
-0.1271945387,
0.1599615514,
-0.0802604854,
-0.4040383995,
0.563732028,
-0.8631291389,
0.1118343398,
-0.292307049,
-0.1977032125,
-0.1856721044,
0.3447921872,
-1.0178233385,
0.6329528689,
0.281093359,
-0.8231285214,
-0.0633674264,
-0.6832802892,
-0.8547809124,
-0.0947223008,
0.2469874769,
-0.4981991649,
0.4470745921,
0.0265465956,
0.3939527869,
-0.1696984917,
-0.041855555,
-0.1134193987,
-0.6226363182,
0.1684319675,
-0.6247816682,
0.4203546643,
0.1551565379,
-0.4710834622,
0.1320262402,
-0.6365163922,
-0.1889255941,
0.2855010927,
-0.20877105,
0.0388131812,
-0.0389571078,
-0.2403036356,
0.2883106172,
0.010089865,
-0.3810026944,
0.0476794541,
-0.9287827611,
0.8001365066,
0.532330215,
0.0588659197,
0.8952886462,
-0.2103116214,
0.2687496245,
0.2089378387,
0.5169793367,
-0.5316465497,
-0.1569060534,
-0.8456568122,
0.0867314935,
0.3471121192,
0.3700591922,
-0.6310839653,
0.0037566179,
-0.4597105086,
-0.3964910805,
-0.7534456253,
-0.0732962638,
0.2261686474,
0.8760962486,
0.4739466608,
-0.3184415698,
-0.5779783726,
-1.2660608292,
-0.383877039,
0.3137376904,
0.0472227447,
0.3517338336,
0.261410296,
-0.3355112672,
0.9164164066,
-0.4126267135,
-0.4000485241,
-0.2407832444,
-0.2529084384,
0.2917993069,
0.4010068774,
0.2023146451,
-0.8241368532,
-0.3147301078,
-0.137231335,
-0.4275466204,
0.1892880052,
-0.2340061665,
-0.1599639803,
-0.4209879637,
0.7197297812,
-0.6750475764,
0.6223361492,
0.2177138925,
0.088116385,
0.2476527989,
0.2506928146,
-0.0486188717,
-0.819149375,
0.3606125712,
0.069609195,
0.0082541136,
-0.7649223208,
0.0485380255,
0.1179062501,
-0.2226148844,
-0.919673264,
0.4873797596,
-0.362555325,
-0.4752678871,
-0.4421655238,
-0.1001001373,
0.244188264,
0.7730137706,
-0.2137034237,
0.4238137603,
0.3702383935,
-0.3021271527,
0.4585628808,
0.5203621984,
-0.1001490802,
0.0848158225,
-0.9479786754,
0.3138626814,
-0.6139808893,
0.2629794776,
-1.4731445312,
-0.1996438205,
0.5294141769,
-0.3473983109,
0.444575876,
-0.3291195631,
0.0275808293,
-0.6996912956,
-0.333873868,
0.5145272017,
0.6162108779,
-0.4790193141,
0.8694047928,
-0.3360837996,
-0.0064724647,
-0.7483146787,
-1.0500689745,
0.1859789342,
-0.1568965465,
-0.4847599566,
0.6372266412,
0.3756899834,
-0.1452239752,
0.2481477261,
-0.3474189043,
0.1311828792,
0.2395772338,
0.1711264253,
-0.0206333958,
-0.4668379724,
-0.1635719389,
-0.0032998212,
-0.2300421447,
0.0784276873,
-0.495369494,
0.3474459946,
0.27146402,
-0.3628233671,
-0.6036673188,
0.3452511132,
0.5863536,
-0.4295591116,
0.3033801317,
0.4608854055,
-0.3403294086,
-0.2956907451,
-0.5024346709,
-0.6877801418,
-0.5557118654,
0.2937522531,
-0.1787050217,
-0.6367610097,
0.3212779164,
-0.2517825067,
0.2790597677,
0.3141408861,
0.5713579655,
-0.3460980952,
0.5479847789,
0.4328581989,
-0.1984462738,
0.7661564946,
-0.3292078376,
0.2787726223,
-1.2052313089,
-0.1076907739,
-0.1903720945,
-1.2258105278,
0.0136574013,
-0.435508877,
0.016843291,
-0.3414874971,
-0.3276082277,
0.3294393122,
-0.6118125319,
0.5666558743,
0.453540653,
0.3207161129,
0.0291220713,
-0.2585889697,
0.4734185934,
0.2270283401,
-0.7331004143,
-0.2002157122,
0.7327719331,
0.3852935433,
0.8103582859,
-0.2962932289,
0.6239117384,
0.3112562299,
0.6347628832,
-1.0958584547,
0.2387316227,
-0.3595989347,
-0.3446518779,
-0.4147875905,
-0.1643405557,
-0.8700691462,
0.2936455607,
0.3210758269,
-0.3542622328,
0.3890407681,
0.3134145737,
-0.7767865658,
0.1831858009,
-0.9559246302,
0.9213059545,
0.0122099137,
-0.5308604836,
0.1800609678,
-0.9327181578,
0.3908846378,
0.130742237,
-0.1731268615,
0.3115943372,
0.0524015799,
0.3563381135,
0.0047139782,
1.3034716845,
-0.039706707,
-0.3049580157,
0.2211689353,
-0.1080556214,
0.5737463236,
0.1855578721,
0.1327643543,
-0.2405107021,
-0.939766705,
-0.1937688738,
-0.6200031042,
0.6999128461,
-0.7552942038,
-0.8554403782,
0.06473241,
-0.4123766422,
-0.2571493387,
0.4201062918,
0.1557603776,
0.5913044214,
-0.185320735,
0.3431786597,
0.9254338741,
0.2581734359,
0.6699145436,
0.0977907181,
0.3073761463,
-0.1847791672,
0.4874986708,
-0.105754517,
0.2365916222,
0.7860067487,
0.0204042811,
-0.3506261706,
-0.3128426075,
-0.3633918762,
0.0320908055,
-0.5679861903,
-0.3767729402,
-1.0345410109,
-0.5772719979,
-0.4138591886,
-0.114125289,
-0.8276883364,
-0.178356111,
-0.60350734,
-0.048578769,
-0.030414436,
0.5751532316,
0.3518214226,
0.3908036947,
-0.6566649675,
0.3957007229,
0.5225744247,
0.5052816868,
0.5839693546,
-0.8271610141,
-0.4339960217,
0.0326437689,
-0.5149577856,
-0.6078479886,
0.1236876324,
0.239515081,
0.4005812705,
0.3452764452,
-0.0725714266,
0.5184452534,
-0.979126215,
0.4091025591,
0.040424481,
-0.8633732796,
0.3654904068,
-0.1082345024,
0.6338399053,
0.4658919275,
0.2652986646,
-0.5546662807,
-0.1573368907,
-0.6320289373,
-0.8437924981,
0.8883855939,
0.2221341282,
0.2930804193,
0.3146566451,
0.7271874547,
0.0721994564,
0.1772584021,
-0.4663013518,
-0.2728234231,
-0.6903426051,
-0.2709623575,
-0.1722422391,
-0.1466189176,
-0.0476911776,
0.0667199567,
0.2823681533,
-0.1396663189,
0.5389879942,
0.5451742411,
0.0162066296,
-0.2169945687,
0.0967197046,
0.5701428056,
0.2092520893,
0.1305832267,
0.3149610758,
0.1324124783,
-0.3295304179,
0.1775190681,
-0.0621185526,
-0.2782728672,
-0.3644723594,
0.3434918225,
1.0018136501,
0.8449197412,
-0.1726284474,
0.2769379318,
-0.014701033,
-0.4414819479,
-0.1660511196,
0.0282456037,
0.5164535642,
0.6701413989,
0.2979971468,
0.6078071594,
0.5816165209,
-0.4485939741,
0.4108407199,
0.1395768672,
-0.915745914,
-0.4609818459,
0.7885398269,
0.3520802855,
-0.6364963651,
0.6753578782,
0.3809016049,
-0.4297626019,
0.6839588881,
0.4474836886,
1.1044774055,
-0.1883954406,
0.1475443244,
-0.0132523086,
0.4226485193,
-0.1721834242,
-0.0689611509,
-0.0696859658,
-0.6143397093,
-0.7777214646,
-0.2803922594,
-0.2203483135,
0.1304844469,
-0.7502267957,
0.1348857284,
-0.4815939367,
-0.088652052,
0.2402810454,
-0.6465223432,
-0.8247858882,
0.4211193025,
0.3549126983,
1.0801721811,
-0.6135789156,
0.5326220393,
0.8142300844,
-0.1710303575,
-0.6426177621,
0.2742089033,
-0.4274609387,
-0.7505228519,
0.4876370132,
0.2561075389,
-0.0476217046,
0.4810448885,
-0.3471669257,
-1.0747711658,
1.1617307663,
0.1725118607,
-0.6730186343,
-0.3212000132,
0.1804017425,
0.4433803856,
-0.1760042608,
0.1193953529,
0.4487808943,
0.3125391304,
0.1909672916,
-0.3084397018,
0.029734062,
-0.2647551298,
0.179504618,
0.1588283628,
-1.2084692717,
0.7718988061,
-0.2620563209,
-0.1752164066,
-0.140136227,
0.7422151566,
-0.4718416929,
0.2295418233,
0.4849629402,
0.6535161138,
-0.0617949255,
-0.0954867452,
0.8499622941,
0.0327226967,
0.3834862113,
1.0205075741,
-0.4631020129,
0.5592584014,
0.9324223399,
0.0196908899,
0.1752334535,
0.3181712627,
-0.1872248501,
0.9878112674,
0.2278564274,
0.2246416509,
-0.0676742047,
0.116785638,
-0.1491183639,
0.3917109966,
-0.0445957705,
-0.7297739387,
-0.2438048124,
0.0943326131,
-0.6591491699,
-0.1918518543,
-0.2835202217,
1.1722598076,
0.1737063974,
-0.5249207616,
0.2190112621,
-0.3030469418,
0.5485798717,
-0.2636694312,
0.0725202188,
-0.4230721295,
0.3767641187,
-0.1034197733,
-0.6878527999,
0.657572329,
-0.3112459779,
-0.5084597468,
-0.4444586039,
1.0347542763,
-0.1719416678,
-0.3661142886,
0.0976564363,
0.4925062954,
-0.4196816981,
-0.2654916048,
-0.5844703317,
0.0639431253,
0.1925265193,
-0.6744440794,
0.1915253997,
0.5037515759,
0.4848135412,
0.5619727373,
0.3758897185,
-0.5009049773,
0.0635462776,
0.2713008523,
1.0380524397,
-0.775061667,
-0.6206550598,
-0.959256947,
0.7960592508,
0.0616377369,
-0.2716636658,
0.5277413726,
0.3453371823,
0.8668057323,
-0.6253811121,
0.6698557734,
0.1617233753,
0.3136680126,
-0.1180993095,
0.7478379011,
-0.6119685173,
-0.0518962219,
-0.2487410754,
-0.9957130551,
-0.0818201452,
0.4398268163,
-0.2420798987,
-0.0263955966,
0.5278552771,
0.3162564039,
-0.3958277106,
0.4243054986,
0.239170298,
0.3701220155,
0.1597270817,
0.6819044948,
1.1230287552,
-0.6885769367,
0.5428690314,
-0.4868697226,
-0.0168427229,
-0.348908186,
-0.6720482111,
-0.7368620038,
-0.4138769209,
-0.2427013665,
0.0174800213,
-0.0708504096,
0.4888355136,
0.4345243871,
-0.491577059,
0.3098963201,
-0.0923983231,
-0.0841899961,
-0.4359644353,
-0.1936027706,
0.1633592695,
-0.3731951118,
-0.5877726078,
0.3637669981,
0.3969218731,
0.161646232,
-0.4074351788,
0.5387374163,
0.1420640796,
-0.0068692626,
0.8579547405,
0.2054626048,
-0.643111527,
-0.3377689719,
0.3309458196,
-0.0868783966,
0.0330534205,
1.0670055151,
-0.9852903485,
-0.2482503206,
0.3121466041,
1.1604819298,
0.4527648389,
0.0403035954,
0.3470613062,
-0.8972869515,
0.2169077843,
0.4613358676,
0.442248255,
0.3797887862,
-0.527987361,
0.5281239152,
0.067999661,
-0.3927717805,
-0.6640927196,
0.1799136847,
-1.058500886,
-0.0367229506,
0.8443410993,
-0.0572540648,
-0.5224224329,
0.0568135306,
-0.4213787913,
0.2794253826,
-0.2727501094,
1.030857563,
0.3321850598,
0.0679732561,
-0.4167835712,
-0.0655788705,
0.3765367866,
0.5146584511,
-0.4536310732,
0.3010535836,
-0.0636140332,
0.2491651475,
0.3570557535,
0.196695447,
-0.0783571228,
0.2310752273,
-0.1791256219,
-0.3370336592,
-0.1507046819,
-0.4721136987,
-0.2187379152,
0.2514695823,
-0.3857012093,
-0.0572073646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10614v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10614v1
|
A Self-enhancement Approach for Domain-specific Chatbot Training via Knowledge Mining and Digest
| 2023-11-17T16:09:10 | 2023-11-17T16:09:10 |
Ruohong Zhang, Luyu Gao, Chen Zheng, Zhen Fan, Guokun Lai, Zheng Zhang, Fangzhou Ai, Yiming Yang, Hongxia Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs), despite their great power in language
generation, often encounter challenges when dealing with intricate and
knowledge-demanding queries in specific domains. This paper introduces a novel
approach to enhance LLMs by effectively extracting the relevant knowledge from
domain-specific textual sources, and the adaptive training of a chatbot with
domain-specific inquiries. Our two-step approach starts from training a
knowledge miner, namely LLMiner, which autonomously extracts Question-Answer
pairs from relevant documents through a chain-of-thought reasoning process.
Subsequently, we blend the mined QA pairs with a conversational dataset to
fine-tune the LLM as a chatbot, thereby enriching its domain-specific expertise
and conversational capabilities. We also developed a new evaluation benchmark
which comprises four domain-specific text corpora and associated human-crafted
QA pairs for testing. Our model shows remarkable performance improvement over
generally aligned LLM and surpasses domain-adapted models directly fine-tuned
on domain corpus. In particular, LLMiner achieves this with minimal human
intervention, requiring only 600 seed instances, thereby providing a pathway
towards self-improvement of LLMs through model-synthesized training data.
|
[
-0.0182850547,
-0.7478471398,
0.3812646866,
-0.1593766659,
-0.0229926277,
0.5845867991,
-0.2396471947,
-0.2519342005,
0.1739872694,
0.8906726837,
-0.6463085413,
-0.4077949524,
-0.5400383472,
0.0116254902,
-0.3588075638,
0.8528518677,
0.3135814071,
-0.187048316,
-0.4882922769,
0.2707193196,
-0.7861863971,
-0.7818666101,
-0.5138363242,
-0.206544131,
0.2563309968,
0.4286646545,
0.3480600119,
0.35321486,
0.3472262919,
0.3807222843,
0.1866220683,
0.6302259564,
-0.8831992745,
0.4836197793,
-0.2933773696,
-0.5908463001,
-0.4745272994,
-0.3830244541,
0.2327676713,
0.2706282139,
-0.1320444196,
0.0171717349,
0.2293040603,
0.5279656053,
-0.4367459416,
0.1582369804,
-1.2956742048,
-0.334374249,
-0.0268400051,
-0.3848522604,
-0.3640727699,
-0.0403358005,
0.0082365312,
-0.5311641693,
0.2972764373,
0.0220155139,
0.6363229752,
0.2861458063,
-0.2417013794,
-0.3016127944,
-0.5737686157,
0.6729488969,
-0.6140236855,
0.2909747362,
0.367850244,
0.3645411134,
-0.3334275484,
-0.7682982683,
-0.5343414545,
0.103766188,
-0.1316057295,
-0.0323702432,
-0.1884998232,
-0.115629971,
-0.0648136064,
0.3177551031,
-0.5250490308,
0.0038614871,
-0.3390184939,
-0.2367319316,
0.6524403095,
0.3927318752,
0.4361262918,
-0.2914505899,
-0.3172059655,
0.0168599281,
-0.5900636315,
-0.1728799939,
0.211378172,
0.3969111741,
0.0404545367,
0.4098626375,
-0.356883049,
0.502147615,
0.1443129033,
-0.1692237705,
0.1691620946,
-0.1703025252,
-0.0664578155,
-0.26601547,
0.755363524,
0.1513207704,
0.3804329336,
-0.2772046626,
-0.185194701,
-0.1614134312,
0.5215144157,
-0.8365358114,
-0.4885014296,
0.3562520444,
-0.0677028298,
-0.4914149344,
-0.5450357199,
-0.5823912621,
-0.6083753705,
-0.1811317056,
0.5398671627,
-0.586060822,
-0.2756074965,
0.1621978879,
-0.0700393245,
0.0782315731,
0.3005138934,
-1.2303898335,
0.2535615563,
0.8215639591,
0.5883483887,
-0.3828524649,
-0.1352092624,
-0.2769288719,
0.1033527106,
-0.1271051168,
1.1169698238,
-0.6209523082,
-0.2835099399,
0.1434430033,
-0.0747659728,
-0.1972620785,
-0.6723781228,
0.3473667502,
-0.8855183125,
0.2789880931,
0.2245090008,
-0.8378344178,
-0.0795193836,
0.4744491279,
-0.2369009107,
1.0895506144,
0.3424302936,
-0.6232846975,
0.0232628081,
-0.6497834325,
-0.3781946599,
0.3627869487,
-0.18574889,
-0.1288333535,
-0.1625674069,
0.5380584002,
0.618313849,
-0.2288790345,
0.1848676503,
-0.1976855993,
0.0750949681,
0.3082678616,
-0.226622954,
0.515007019,
0.0194676537,
0.0216688402,
0.2894754708,
-0.7399016619,
0.3534920812,
0.331625253,
-0.2382242531,
-0.3544347286,
-0.0343690515,
-0.3172997236,
0.2351467609,
0.4638721049,
-0.3660737872,
0.1812300384,
-0.6458075643,
0.4490544498,
0.7883408666,
0.3182935119,
0.3779773712,
-0.3947883248,
0.4721804559,
-0.1172269806,
0.139078632,
-0.3235672116,
-0.1911610216,
-0.9612300992,
-0.2841646075,
0.3608193398,
0.5331680775,
-0.6313945055,
0.6959065199,
-0.5580253005,
-0.6080099344,
-0.6716131568,
0.5642530918,
0.1735844165,
0.4882104099,
0.3645767272,
-0.4314501882,
-0.6842945814,
-0.5077322721,
-0.3110640347,
-0.1278744191,
-0.1662148982,
0.3708524406,
0.3727547228,
-0.3218084276,
1.0423469543,
-0.5301633477,
-0.4531979859,
-0.4271821678,
-0.3422082365,
0.2189061344,
0.3327980042,
0.1137467697,
-0.4370692074,
-0.6721667051,
-0.1281152219,
-0.8307920694,
-0.0200689528,
-0.0311207604,
-0.3735900819,
0.0287436265,
0.4947284162,
-0.4025122225,
0.0837498829,
0.5295837522,
-0.1953724921,
0.4232659936,
-0.1852853894,
0.022645032,
-1.0386683941,
-0.231654793,
-0.3913624585,
-0.5445203781,
-0.7984740734,
-0.0112331267,
0.1576017141,
-0.060153164,
-0.352478832,
0.7911634445,
-0.3725815117,
0.1355432719,
-0.6120803356,
0.5812868476,
0.0436942466,
0.7163336873,
0.1198178679,
0.7228889465,
0.6688061357,
-0.7723730206,
0.3234556317,
0.5961299539,
-0.3150124252,
0.4159053862,
-0.6406180263,
0.461615622,
0.1056258231,
0.1040133983,
-0.9745537639,
-0.1105581969,
0.1081891358,
-0.61487782,
0.2493217736,
-0.2991661429,
-0.3620420992,
-0.2497582436,
0.028191492,
-0.0388018489,
0.6706171632,
-0.7769045234,
0.7784657478,
0.582831502,
-0.3014931977,
-0.4086839855,
-0.1685836762,
0.1673460454,
-0.0743470713,
-0.8771072626,
0.3044354618,
-0.2318310142,
-0.0596667379,
-0.335244149,
-0.023600243,
0.0418026336,
0.1988423467,
0.261701107,
0.0789770409,
0.0337990969,
0.3250571787,
0.0877492875,
0.0879059806,
0.1487689465,
-0.3113502264,
0.9501367807,
0.1224077195,
-0.0872137249,
-0.4824738204,
-0.0418615043,
0.0575432181,
-0.3660063446,
0.5350800157,
0.4692777991,
-0.1137233078,
-0.4839873612,
-0.7186176181,
-0.5664389133,
-0.5569048524,
0.3321506381,
-0.6208416224,
-1.1666493416,
0.3494364917,
-0.312400043,
0.1068319753,
0.4757906795,
0.746216476,
-0.1292642355,
0.8492310047,
0.6295742989,
-0.2166829258,
0.4876297116,
-0.2460186779,
0.1040961444,
-0.9291115403,
-0.1792749465,
-0.358371973,
0.1253337562,
-0.3627842367,
-0.6360462904,
0.1723379195,
-0.1896351576,
-0.2860995531,
0.2569733262,
-0.2998444736,
0.4985671937,
0.363363266,
0.283691287,
0.3421689868,
0.0792005733,
0.161247462,
0.1223680303,
-0.8267081976,
-0.5766008496,
1.3193768263,
0.3349350393,
0.7046635151,
-0.0574860722,
0.733353734,
0.5397319198,
0.1999412477,
-0.6493659019,
0.4350129068,
0.1976477653,
-0.7016746402,
-0.3338322937,
-0.4644818008,
-0.9837064147,
0.4350183308,
-0.2898100615,
-0.590233326,
-0.2482351959,
0.0169030838,
-0.1650055498,
0.1747019589,
-0.5520203114,
0.8562889099,
-0.4319169521,
-0.1969954967,
-0.4099854529,
-0.4767624438,
0.2614984512,
-0.2642656863,
0.3345317841,
-0.2442632169,
0.0752566308,
0.6486196518,
-0.3407332599,
1.1719847918,
-0.1608432829,
-0.3036756217,
0.4606383443,
0.3168613315,
0.6641035676,
-0.0411792882,
0.0208795387,
0.187220335,
-0.1575006098,
-0.4261761904,
-0.769579649,
0.5493636131,
-0.9863888025,
-0.9793595672,
-0.0021172885,
-0.5023368597,
-0.5872072577,
0.1579845399,
-0.2383964807,
0.3438649476,
-0.3423957527,
0.023843186,
0.5902286172,
-0.2101479471,
0.0744860843,
0.6781116128,
-0.2190621644,
-0.4412682652,
0.7913688421,
-0.4555168748,
0.4782743752,
0.5987486839,
0.1340215504,
-0.3413210511,
-0.4609542489,
-0.3457349241,
0.2996198535,
-0.8412981629,
-0.4807300568,
-1.1396207809,
-0.3434669971,
-0.7953850031,
0.1511256695,
-0.326398313,
-0.2852683961,
-0.3195740879,
0.103642948,
0.5336418748,
0.4512789845,
0.1743216515,
0.5608415604,
-0.9164081812,
0.150951609,
0.5419626236,
0.1532906145,
-0.0173774716,
-1.1479467154,
-0.2438520491,
0.0550713278,
-0.3691935539,
-0.504799068,
0.6703948975,
0.322034955,
0.5841920972,
0.2196229398,
0.0962310582,
0.5814518929,
-0.5408158302,
0.7594974041,
0.0674438998,
-0.8593678474,
0.7536161542,
-0.3418468535,
0.0527472794,
0.4032224417,
0.2930995524,
-0.5215602517,
-0.4988480508,
-0.6826335192,
-0.5666534305,
0.596418798,
0.1916519403,
0.6509169936,
-0.0182289034,
0.3927713037,
0.1621892154,
-0.0238444563,
-0.6739041209,
-0.1565887034,
-0.1479156166,
-0.2580921352,
0.1007486284,
-0.218249023,
-0.0902042016,
-0.0170807131,
0.9850981236,
-0.4264686704,
0.1410050243,
0.0460400023,
-0.4389468729,
0.078836441,
0.2122056335,
0.0717804357,
0.6354318857,
-0.1109338179,
0.0529232733,
0.3699416816,
-0.1985266656,
-0.0822416693,
-0.1869517863,
0.2690219581,
-0.320351541,
0.1780289412,
0.5936732888,
0.1492099762,
-0.9004897475,
0.628374517,
-0.3231801093,
-0.0316436812,
-0.2579272687,
0.5258625746,
0.1567725688,
0.4892958701,
0.3190091848,
-0.178977415,
-0.0721084401,
-0.3646026254,
0.1692486107,
0.4699560702,
-0.3871038854,
-0.186859712,
0.5078043342,
0.4290740192,
-0.3259278536,
0.4339309037,
-0.1192095205,
-0.7079243064,
0.2497394979,
0.7666177154,
0.602483809,
-0.2205488533,
0.0872977227,
0.3409997821,
0.058578629,
0.3164240122,
0.0972093642,
-0.1362958848,
-1.0646594763,
-0.3472797573,
-0.5714167953,
-0.4923298061,
0.0236879718,
-0.1664028764,
0.3254483342,
-0.2556028366,
0.0676789507,
-0.0876405835,
0.1965540349,
-0.6788434386,
0.2356166393,
-0.0872553885,
0.7054288983,
-0.3495210707,
0.9266596437,
0.2536515594,
-0.1690290272,
-0.469958514,
-0.2537359297,
-0.336681962,
-1.2865869999,
0.5376897454,
-0.1206019819,
0.0320006125,
0.1233559698,
-0.5500596166,
-0.9886476994,
1.0100536346,
0.110156551,
-0.7313506007,
0.1427354664,
0.234774366,
0.6944023967,
-0.5529635549,
0.2399224639,
0.5616137385,
-0.004152575,
0.041334901,
-0.7574931979,
0.0603529289,
-0.1914772391,
-0.0849625021,
0.0635253713,
-0.6865413189,
0.2605382204,
-0.1622341722,
-0.1991101801,
-0.0602664016,
0.9626098871,
0.1409893036,
-0.1701679379,
0.6029334068,
0.1290225983,
0.9864807129,
0.2681646049,
0.8647987247,
-0.7441766858,
0.1995083988,
1.2755600214,
-0.3524899781,
0.8605788946,
0.116210416,
-0.0577414706,
0.7067865729,
0.4801757038,
-0.0281870253,
0.4112868607,
0.2945146859,
-0.2759580016,
-0.5917530656,
0.0471770912,
-0.1105786189,
0.7157465219,
0.5462136865,
-0.3270412087,
0.0451772623,
-0.0401653685,
0.0693450347,
0.209451884,
-0.1939613372,
1.1470065117,
-0.0341658928,
-0.6871116757,
0.7094106078,
0.0357683674,
0.7628642321,
-0.5551384091,
0.2087251544,
-0.3515282571,
0.2375917286,
-0.1169862375,
-0.5286041498,
0.1039436236,
0.2145641446,
-0.0468306243,
-0.1838948727,
1.2699981928,
-0.3956979513,
-0.2957260311,
0.2603141963,
0.7724635005,
0.2580664158,
-0.4290395379,
-0.677996695,
-0.1896063238,
0.0126174018,
-0.0080541316,
0.4079546332,
0.496183455,
0.19151555,
0.8236182928,
0.7035175562,
-0.0658076629,
-0.094011806,
0.3080008626,
1.1423931122,
-0.6577290297,
-0.2720657885,
-0.7553377151,
0.3452797234,
-0.2287569493,
-0.0824520141,
0.6996977925,
0.6144942045,
0.7828179002,
-0.0030624613,
1.08208251,
0.0688914433,
0.837480247,
-0.3853057325,
0.7041159272,
-0.3207620978,
0.3622823358,
0.0380298682,
-0.572673142,
-0.1288026571,
0.3811802268,
-0.3233281672,
0.0172118414,
0.4676590264,
1.0310183764,
0.1406801939,
0.0263314582,
0.5398500562,
0.2847344577,
0.5003435612,
0.3751840889,
1.0029263496,
-0.5008739829,
0.8335306644,
-0.0372422226,
-0.1699736118,
-0.1393559724,
-0.5506074429,
-1.3294062614,
-0.5153536797,
-0.3252762854,
-0.3562872708,
0.1897735894,
0.9038876295,
0.8505539298,
-0.6502683759,
-0.2025130242,
0.1633082926,
0.203783229,
0.0256668963,
-0.2078184336,
0.2775894701,
-0.9605475068,
-0.6723164916,
0.6758084893,
0.1275705546,
-0.2189678103,
-0.3300285041,
0.0736121535,
0.0777417868,
0.2212186754,
0.7745792866,
-0.0289817434,
-0.4118273556,
-0.3028877974,
0.1750606596,
-0.1187467948,
0.3628284037,
0.6496628523,
-0.9090847969,
0.4723901749,
0.2937540412,
0.7443008423,
0.6198391914,
0.0289570168,
0.4954061806,
-0.9390066862,
-0.322778672,
0.1422525644,
0.2014904022,
0.5310362577,
-0.5167138577,
0.5356575847,
0.114054136,
-0.7315151691,
-0.5235619545,
0.0888198763,
-0.8333045244,
-0.3326083422,
1.3343362808,
-0.0531922728,
-0.3373111486,
-0.2451611012,
-0.2771576643,
0.1203723773,
-0.4455398917,
1.1170672178,
0.2784473002,
-0.0876182839,
-0.07280498,
-0.2584187984,
0.5144308805,
0.1984064728,
-1.1374567747,
0.4918149114,
0.3446552157,
0.6284582615,
-0.087702848,
0.7682783008,
-0.0641505867,
-0.1053429544,
-0.0940595567,
0.3230489492,
0.1853725612,
-0.1702850163,
-0.2134450525,
0.1366704106,
0.1676031947,
0.0487594754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10596v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10596v1
|
Hashing it Out: Predicting Unhealthy Conversations on Twitter
| 2023-11-17T15:49:11 | 2023-11-17T15:49:11 |
Steven Leung, Filippos Papapolyzos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Personal attacks in the context of social media conversations often lead to
fast-paced derailment, leading to even more harmful exchanges being made.
State-of-the-art systems for the detection of such conversational derailment
often make use of deep learning approaches for prediction purposes. In this
paper, we show that an Attention-based BERT architecture, pre-trained on a
large Twitter corpus and fine-tuned on our task, is efficient and effective in
making such predictions. This model shows clear advantages in performance to
the existing LSTM model we use as a baseline. Additionally, we show that this
impressive performance can be attained through fine-tuning on a relatively
small, novel dataset, particularly after mitigating overfitting issues through
synthetic oversampling techniques. By introducing the first transformer based
model for forecasting conversational events on Twitter, this work lays the
foundation for a practical tool to encourage better interactions on one of the
most ubiquitous social media platforms.
|
[
-0.2558599412,
-1.0381572247,
0.5642339587,
0.1099177822,
-0.3210783899,
0.3286492825,
-0.3370141089,
-0.6954162717,
0.4032948017,
0.5614114404,
-0.721837461,
-0.2652142048,
-0.7062236667,
-0.5466301441,
-0.7400544286,
0.9961509109,
0.4433799684,
-0.0448456444,
0.3277234137,
0.1601701081,
-0.4617046416,
-0.4397678077,
-0.9740456343,
-0.4525476098,
0.8743348718,
0.3748863637,
0.6892858744,
0.1735221148,
0.7120014429,
0.2868982852,
-0.014106431,
0.1805042922,
-0.9573971629,
0.1732922643,
0.0051827845,
0.1910580993,
0.0722226948,
-0.3975706995,
0.2256640345,
0.596141398,
0.0177382417,
0.1943064779,
0.1078580171,
0.6947404146,
-0.2969688475,
-0.0939126611,
-1.0169457197,
-0.1699432582,
0.0157398004,
-0.1247333288,
-0.4605241716,
-0.1920114011,
0.1786192656,
0.0825917125,
-0.0198324304,
-0.2952231169,
0.6353715062,
0.5031824112,
-0.2399239987,
0.0283543617,
-0.9226581454,
0.6279784441,
-0.6153237224,
0.4806943834,
0.3304440379,
0.4877918065,
-0.1887502521,
-0.7545974851,
-0.3020323515,
0.2589887083,
-0.074428983,
0.0042747674,
-0.4120746553,
0.0804243684,
0.0031127003,
0.0823041648,
-0.1980455816,
0.1734901816,
-0.5008289218,
0.2553026378,
0.7905723453,
0.2074791938,
0.0709859803,
-0.2229878008,
-0.4071815908,
0.2410225123,
-0.1698457599,
-0.1397073269,
0.0409452021,
0.6169427633,
-0.1926624328,
0.2118568122,
0.0862553641,
0.1269610077,
0.2867729664,
0.5092719793,
0.0257644337,
-0.0107899159,
-0.6102157235,
0.1992962658,
0.7735437155,
0.6580578685,
0.5914291739,
-0.3475792408,
0.0290320907,
-0.1436987221,
0.5731640458,
-1.1099998951,
-0.5252389908,
0.540343821,
-0.5139740109,
-0.494291991,
-0.1384237558,
-0.5820866823,
-0.8102315068,
-0.3505969644,
0.3337215781,
-0.6563972831,
-0.172319591,
0.0864512995,
0.0250972714,
-0.1751349419,
0.2449918389,
-0.6702433228,
0.2722125053,
0.7312353849,
0.9127571583,
-0.1814353913,
0.2060091943,
-0.3067323267,
0.1973080188,
-0.3258837461,
0.7225649357,
-0.3527458012,
-0.141122669,
0.2613549232,
-0.1023539081,
0.2832754552,
-0.1574032307,
0.7414724231,
-0.5142883658,
-0.0776766166,
-0.2914811373,
-0.542437017,
-0.2128775865,
0.2583619654,
-0.4706757069,
0.8502575159,
0.0035961878,
-0.8988549709,
0.3745511174,
-0.7253344059,
-0.8551445603,
0.1626899242,
0.1593064666,
-0.7055470943,
0.1517992169,
0.3829663694,
0.9073808789,
-0.1146869063,
0.5874388218,
-0.5111505985,
-0.6022418737,
0.116862528,
-0.3540473878,
0.6882525682,
0.4186063707,
-0.2875349522,
0.4188515544,
-0.4273125231,
0.2200143188,
0.1327768713,
-0.0046990267,
-0.3365055621,
0.1150302142,
0.2816680074,
0.0811811388,
-0.00722855,
-0.6001920104,
-0.4073172808,
-0.6323868632,
0.6824098825,
0.9741616845,
0.321455121,
0.2439516038,
-0.5943057537,
-0.258328855,
0.1182494164,
0.3453613222,
-0.1499120891,
-0.3871279359,
-0.5999774337,
0.0620814823,
0.0218121428,
0.2455178201,
-0.5137969851,
0.7154447436,
-0.4754257798,
-0.7458670139,
-0.3547226787,
0.0316709466,
0.0791533142,
0.2060468048,
0.4312740564,
0.0315563641,
-0.9513821602,
-0.605881989,
-0.5581086874,
0.036830958,
0.0618841238,
0.2784924805,
0.1764778495,
-0.4626901746,
0.7090250254,
-0.2379615307,
-0.4698952138,
-0.3718560338,
0.236411795,
0.2065575123,
0.4607926905,
0.4062252343,
-0.7984908223,
-0.9020639658,
-0.0379287079,
-0.4027959704,
0.2376160771,
-0.1896904707,
-0.1081200615,
-0.1368952394,
0.6223852038,
-0.2069120407,
0.3519575,
0.4406435192,
-0.1660797149,
-0.1559527665,
0.1309890896,
0.0039992188,
-1.2984544039,
-0.0644663647,
0.1344117373,
-0.3482858241,
-1.0527608395,
-0.5112674832,
-0.1022137403,
-0.0026763077,
-0.4715891182,
0.42362234,
0.0001593352,
0.3119207323,
-0.242998004,
-0.3685518801,
-0.391700536,
0.4107289612,
-0.1286042333,
0.36517483,
0.2331248075,
-0.2866828442,
-0.0106917219,
0.167036891,
-0.6000861526,
0.1218768731,
-0.702898562,
0.374199301,
-0.262601018,
0.2315859646,
-1.1090919971,
-0.3964630663,
0.039990291,
-0.7039670944,
0.2210247815,
0.0247207303,
-0.5551882982,
-0.5854645967,
-0.4893275201,
0.2399860173,
0.6461601257,
-0.5954486132,
0.7268112302,
0.6656938195,
0.2209055871,
-0.277849406,
-0.8085663915,
0.252525717,
-0.2481356561,
-0.5663684011,
0.2655411363,
-0.0554917976,
-0.2245429754,
-0.2931858003,
0.0854127631,
-0.0533950739,
0.2549527586,
0.5982006192,
-0.1668359339,
0.217100054,
0.5165928602,
-0.2142447829,
0.0751378685,
0.2555142045,
-0.0299467482,
0.9809958935,
0.1061484963,
-0.1292166263,
-0.5895850062,
0.4307340086,
0.4047752917,
0.197432071,
0.5160083175,
0.7683432102,
-0.6803259254,
-0.0250454713,
-0.7707973123,
-0.6148269773,
-0.5346860886,
0.5593743324,
0.1561636329,
-0.6109256148,
0.5701386929,
0.0028531123,
0.0948667005,
0.1890866607,
0.739048779,
-0.4715743959,
1.2351777554,
0.6463401318,
-0.3573896885,
0.9253415465,
-0.15315938,
0.4299188554,
-0.3981177807,
-0.0329496786,
-0.2446263731,
-0.6087340713,
-0.7321594357,
-0.3703561127,
0.356156677,
-0.5972661376,
-0.6666786075,
0.3480201364,
-0.6554960012,
0.5395767689,
0.6048955321,
0.5617098808,
0.0312030334,
-0.0579636805,
0.4420116246,
-0.2250170112,
-0.4653592408,
-0.2967956066,
0.9782620072,
0.7813841701,
0.8794903755,
-0.1058374196,
0.7962098718,
0.551402092,
0.640594542,
-0.6423071623,
0.1624370962,
-0.413747251,
-0.7003720999,
-0.393052429,
-0.327894181,
-0.9314442873,
-0.2709757686,
-0.0849746093,
-0.9225538969,
-0.1668456048,
-0.1258633435,
-0.5574872494,
0.6051937938,
-0.8050481081,
0.6022223234,
-0.3186713159,
-0.1980203837,
-0.2727487087,
-0.8285632133,
0.3546464443,
-0.1430565417,
0.3809198439,
-0.4876514077,
0.496417135,
0.917822361,
-0.0234531239,
1.2148563862,
-0.1117188334,
0.1485755295,
0.2174183577,
-0.0954930633,
0.4902099073,
0.0187340081,
-0.0128636789,
0.248440057,
-0.08116173,
-0.2749599516,
-0.30408898,
0.739997983,
-0.9641866088,
-0.2237471044,
0.0176366717,
-0.5343875289,
-0.4112749994,
0.2865057886,
0.2902561724,
0.1496542245,
-0.4085905552,
0.4138975441,
0.6755820513,
0.0542582832,
0.584949553,
0.1186562479,
-0.0498925485,
-0.4127081037,
0.802957058,
0.0520332009,
0.120344989,
0.4924272597,
0.4266093671,
-0.1396671236,
-0.4190742075,
-0.0616198517,
-0.1830056012,
-0.7241482735,
-0.605742991,
-0.9896408916,
-0.3878010511,
-0.5152917504,
-0.1566599756,
-0.3940117955,
0.140265584,
-0.1819054931,
-0.1585244983,
0.4695328772,
0.769700706,
-0.02996164,
0.6674069166,
-0.7426421642,
0.0981487781,
0.2517980635,
0.5958169103,
0.0826170743,
-0.4747838676,
-0.3735778034,
0.2031242102,
-0.4581538737,
-0.7319098711,
0.3776122034,
0.1097899899,
0.1863426417,
0.5636827946,
0.5002087355,
0.5933220983,
-0.3204440773,
0.4450090826,
0.5621225238,
-0.6166995168,
0.4591943324,
-0.5728693008,
0.1341902465,
0.7392455935,
0.3090189695,
-0.8759396672,
-0.4884994328,
-0.7016964555,
-0.8164610863,
0.3164818287,
0.1946502477,
0.6589538455,
-0.3368804455,
-0.0134979552,
0.1271849871,
0.1433041841,
-0.6168740988,
-0.2117135227,
-0.1289229542,
-0.3719506264,
-0.0863972455,
-0.422773689,
-0.1184512228,
-0.5606396794,
0.5719124675,
-0.0846293271,
0.371925056,
-0.105529137,
0.1510292441,
-0.670065105,
-0.1481728107,
0.4650115669,
0.3847308755,
-0.5884265304,
0.1772509217,
0.3825963438,
-0.3062772155,
-0.3126451075,
0.0661724806,
0.1696051061,
0.1880304515,
0.1332304627,
0.7088103294,
0.4968754053,
-0.6128414273,
0.551895082,
-0.1113843769,
-0.1905588955,
-0.5058875084,
-0.1457362622,
0.2390469611,
0.2859348655,
0.4302060008,
-0.0178285111,
0.1712020338,
-0.5726042986,
0.4458507001,
0.5541455746,
-0.920633018,
-0.1924390644,
0.6391282082,
0.4096297622,
-0.3923936486,
0.2613680363,
0.2875038981,
-0.6881791353,
0.4643077552,
0.099897556,
1.1033457518,
-0.2592990398,
-0.0517104715,
0.3375928402,
0.2919125259,
0.3705172241,
0.2482398748,
0.0258165468,
-0.7551388741,
-0.3324668109,
-0.4355252087,
-0.2820186913,
0.5297743082,
-0.3943986297,
0.5213847756,
-0.5995191932,
-0.3783459067,
0.472238481,
0.1775099933,
-0.9382344484,
0.3529381752,
0.3373553455,
0.762555182,
-0.875574708,
0.7565886378,
0.2047246248,
-0.2895202935,
-0.5119582415,
0.1830340922,
-0.2704723179,
-1.1382682323,
0.3687324524,
0.5245010257,
0.1146733388,
-0.0777890161,
-0.6033931375,
-0.6649609804,
0.5323669314,
0.3270445764,
-0.7396954298,
-0.1085976511,
0.3094805479,
0.5448684096,
-0.0802004412,
0.2768012285,
0.506162107,
0.4749804735,
0.2942398489,
-0.8651803732,
0.0466579013,
0.0822554156,
-0.178560257,
0.4625335336,
-0.5906557441,
0.5481635928,
-0.345623672,
-0.286013186,
-0.2434688658,
0.5557532907,
-0.5259252787,
0.4147041142,
0.5113862157,
0.392695874,
0.5743736625,
-0.2271505743,
0.8731496334,
-0.3512550592,
0.3574970663,
1.3747996092,
0.0422436409,
0.8095778823,
0.5636066794,
0.028056534,
0.22386159,
0.7265000343,
0.0645212159,
0.7633801699,
0.1593399793,
-0.0373053737,
-0.4267810881,
-0.1442263126,
-0.2839902043,
0.3956319094,
0.5060146451,
-0.7534887195,
-0.3843868971,
0.0582112633,
-0.0271818601,
0.1023914739,
-0.2463168502,
1.3722649813,
0.0471162423,
-0.3631437719,
0.4937006831,
-0.28456074,
0.7862982154,
-0.1196926609,
0.2928890288,
0.0437033623,
0.4622357786,
-0.1288129985,
-0.8783079982,
0.6442020535,
-0.4241416752,
-0.1816900373,
-0.3733136058,
1.0150208473,
-0.4471519887,
-0.5945134759,
0.5939168334,
0.5914557576,
0.0069442391,
-0.4914601147,
-0.7440141439,
0.1649116278,
-0.0681148991,
-0.1208220273,
0.2393097132,
0.3974760473,
0.1106355786,
0.5341486931,
0.690374136,
-0.2513902187,
-0.2262788862,
0.2829806209,
1.0364867449,
-0.6782157421,
-0.5373588204,
-1.1426109076,
0.3815230727,
-0.4294167161,
-0.1025975496,
0.2331509441,
0.3653434515,
0.5733599663,
0.2131390423,
0.9479836226,
0.2425187677,
0.9579686522,
0.0617091358,
0.8915123343,
-0.2504347265,
0.0614777841,
-0.1630944312,
-0.3911578655,
-0.208049193,
0.2863669395,
-0.3831090331,
0.2259728462,
0.3199384511,
0.2035663426,
0.0466388799,
0.2269274145,
0.4857856035,
0.2349162847,
0.5978288651,
0.4979441762,
0.6052850485,
-0.4353258312,
0.5147988796,
-0.6062121391,
0.0501035936,
-0.5526186228,
-0.8612971902,
-1.4625558853,
-0.7508947849,
-0.0545960777,
-0.4566212893,
0.2526278496,
0.9944329858,
0.8551270366,
-0.955450356,
0.124475047,
-0.1801711768,
-0.0074933856,
-0.0254204161,
-0.1968569458,
0.3735140264,
-0.6353758574,
-0.6168068647,
-0.08162608,
0.1098123789,
0.039023459,
-0.087515004,
0.2687243819,
-0.2397812158,
0.2478369176,
0.6025368571,
-0.1387597919,
-0.5689047575,
-0.652084589,
-0.0704460219,
-0.2074430585,
0.1731765717,
0.6898102164,
-0.6519904733,
0.3358445764,
0.2437201589,
0.9255065918,
0.5630400181,
0.1800526679,
0.5554562807,
-1.0363173485,
-0.1834947169,
0.5435566902,
0.2527706325,
0.4167386889,
-0.7411506176,
0.4766355455,
-0.2756813765,
-0.5296245813,
-0.8790873289,
-0.1669778526,
-0.9904268384,
-0.3641199172,
1.1209030151,
0.4032955468,
-0.2139228582,
-0.340746969,
-0.4061324596,
0.4590768516,
-0.7312139869,
1.3188433647,
0.3513866067,
0.1561057866,
-0.0755978376,
-0.5385172367,
0.7072936893,
0.2761182189,
-0.7467648387,
0.449403137,
-0.1590835154,
0.2343359739,
0.0904791877,
0.5469862223,
0.4426158071,
0.2679159641,
-0.5793195963,
-0.1225321591,
-0.0374381281,
-0.073657006,
0.0716523528,
0.0371877104,
-0.4188071191,
-0.3947713673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10587v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10587v1
|
Countering Misinformation via Emotional Response Generation
| 2023-11-17T15:37:18 | 2023-11-17T15:37:18 |
Daniel Russo, Shane Peter Kaszefski-Yaschuk, Jacopo Staiano, Marco Guerini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The proliferation of misinformation on social media platforms (SMPs) poses a
significant danger to public health, social cohesion and ultimately democracy.
Previous research has shown how social correction can be an effective way to
curb misinformation, by engaging directly in a constructive dialogue with users
who spread -- often in good faith -- misleading messages. Although professional
fact-checkers are crucial to debunking viral claims, they usually do not engage
in conversations on social media. Thereby, significant effort has been made to
automate the use of fact-checker material in social correction; however, no
previous work has tried to integrate it with the style and pragmatics that are
commonly employed in social media communication. To fill this gap, we present
VerMouth, the first large-scale dataset comprising roughly 12 thousand
claim-response pairs (linked to debunking articles), accounting for both
SMP-style and basic emotions, two factors which have a significant role in
misinformation credibility and spreading. To collect this dataset we used a
technique based on an author-reviewer pipeline, which efficiently combines LLMs
and human annotators to obtain high-quality data. We also provide comprehensive
experiments showing how models trained on our proposed dataset have significant
improvements in terms of output quality and generalization capabilities.
|
[
-0.2494754046,
-0.7222548723,
0.4274905026,
0.3717250228,
-0.2856447101,
0.2643157542,
-0.0602928735,
-0.3273731172,
0.6564148068,
0.5803368688,
-0.4751476347,
-0.3782287836,
-0.7448325753,
0.2362877727,
-0.3104375005,
1.0735915899,
0.0525472723,
-0.1747687012,
0.0189026073,
-0.1374656409,
-0.0696125329,
-0.5384330153,
-0.5788722634,
-0.2611041367,
0.9270180464,
0.6372784972,
0.5209059119,
0.2522747517,
0.3771645427,
0.2604033649,
0.0705926418,
0.4892343879,
-0.8226679564,
0.1460354179,
-0.2690043449,
-0.5413969755,
-0.1875843555,
0.0472448245,
0.1938064694,
0.0720405057,
-0.2355954349,
0.5588997006,
0.0760581493,
0.8169579506,
-0.6640787721,
-0.0201302543,
-0.7822324634,
0.1201699898,
-0.1285632253,
-0.4987773597,
-0.4172334671,
-0.5902446508,
0.0897407532,
-0.3777131736,
0.2864286602,
0.0768456236,
0.7740645409,
0.2193427533,
-0.7641028762,
-0.455211699,
-0.8328270316,
0.4257978201,
-0.598988831,
0.0419087186,
0.3119683862,
0.2384246439,
0.0058753374,
-0.7049843073,
-0.7757999301,
0.3231267929,
-0.0741280317,
0.2686787546,
-0.5450747609,
-0.244468227,
0.23992984,
-0.008706593,
-0.39127478,
-0.3657982349,
-0.6026176214,
-0.2524084151,
0.9268817902,
-0.0520396046,
0.1029946133,
-0.2099977434,
-0.2549285293,
-0.0809218287,
-0.680922091,
-0.073051177,
0.3383162618,
0.1735228747,
-0.0969554186,
0.6796092987,
-0.1005399674,
0.1813432127,
0.4328660965,
-0.0266895723,
0.323905021,
-0.3430738449,
-0.2471718639,
0.5397580862,
0.614441812,
0.9716625214,
0.2247343808,
0.3141464889,
-0.1632042825,
0.5105772018,
0.4332368374,
-0.7283962369,
-0.0471508875,
0.212958768,
-0.2701425552,
-0.4496819377,
0.029506512,
-0.7377098203,
-0.8453142643,
-0.3915455639,
0.310204953,
-0.02333395,
-0.1539795548,
0.1137526631,
-0.2248689532,
-0.150943324,
0.4404149652,
-0.2286680192,
0.0502835959,
0.6210927963,
0.7430789471,
0.2814571261,
0.1348194331,
-0.5570603609,
0.1347795427,
-0.3598361015,
0.8918236494,
-0.385474354,
-0.0383594446,
0.273108393,
0.2868683934,
0.1720391661,
-0.430747211,
0.7731711268,
-0.3098614812,
0.1580871195,
-0.7212434411,
-0.1804864407,
-0.0914589763,
0.3830435872,
-0.4086282849,
0.9159839153,
-0.1632235348,
-1.0993850231,
0.2062572092,
-0.1757213771,
-0.6377545595,
-0.1980425119,
0.0040228902,
-0.4752697051,
0.1807312965,
0.3693135977,
0.3976747692,
-0.280431062,
0.2836776376,
-0.4908360839,
-0.1981855333,
0.2360972315,
-0.3576055765,
0.5234560966,
0.2969731092,
-0.4750733674,
0.0548115782,
-0.6063572168,
-0.1638084501,
0.0953958929,
-0.1704327911,
-0.2903526127,
-0.1637853235,
-0.1718010455,
0.4352390766,
-0.1058651432,
-0.6623198986,
-0.0948368236,
0.0090982309,
0.4313775599,
0.8120064735,
0.3080197871,
-0.0241992269,
-0.7589423656,
0.3101508617,
0.2639406621,
0.1459295303,
-0.1900757551,
-0.2558827102,
-0.6036142707,
-0.0412503295,
-0.0098537197,
0.6857917905,
-0.8652816415,
0.1961082667,
-0.1986517012,
-0.8861106634,
-0.8741573691,
0.0545936041,
0.1406797022,
0.7375935316,
0.2849875391,
0.0450748168,
-0.7217558026,
-0.707894206,
-0.6199203134,
-0.3287124634,
-0.0188413803,
0.2738367021,
0.1498785317,
-0.3277701735,
0.7112289071,
-0.4127443731,
0.069668144,
0.1213935539,
0.515135169,
-0.0214117486,
0.0288946796,
0.4232927263,
-0.6292926669,
-0.4789840281,
-0.1823995858,
-0.6934133172,
-0.4810239673,
-0.123314254,
-0.1925292313,
0.2916410863,
0.1448700577,
-0.5762296915,
0.4325451553,
0.4667513072,
-0.2561500967,
0.6658816338,
0.0222074725,
0.6520802975,
-0.8927653432,
-0.0709108263,
0.5894579291,
-0.2342512161,
-0.5924980044,
-0.4335184097,
-0.0795654655,
0.0758790821,
-0.4077913165,
0.2810159624,
-0.2741783559,
0.2815471888,
-0.1842844039,
0.2186499089,
-0.0279650427,
0.0507450216,
-0.0638014451,
0.2900886834,
0.252148062,
-0.4110794067,
0.5176138282,
0.1213904619,
0.0010289978,
1.1248508692,
-0.8018555641,
0.2593336403,
-0.6459843516,
0.4384524524,
-1.2628811598,
-0.3584907651,
0.3843246102,
-0.4578004777,
-0.1400509328,
-0.2748174071,
-0.5737802386,
-0.5917713046,
-0.5533152223,
-0.2936451435,
0.210871309,
-0.4757501781,
0.6154287457,
0.5804005861,
-0.5464909673,
-0.5007196665,
-0.7564129233,
0.3706372082,
-0.2310091704,
-0.8146195412,
-0.0400106795,
-0.0261132419,
-0.4398666918,
-0.1056288257,
-0.3887068033,
0.0803775489,
-0.3326818049,
0.4179047942,
0.0226733815,
-0.0507335067,
0.3544348478,
0.0338976011,
0.0641677156,
0.2859158516,
0.1810762435,
0.3379758,
-0.15528965,
-0.2308720797,
-0.4043478966,
0.0404190868,
0.5452830195,
-0.0667426735,
0.4978712499,
0.5463169813,
-0.3922258615,
-0.1081692502,
-0.875862062,
-0.4689348638,
-0.4322941601,
0.028027676,
0.2322580516,
-0.750842452,
0.2537690103,
-0.1981993169,
0.1117879972,
0.2867956161,
0.4048300982,
-0.2331828326,
0.8355453014,
0.3475165963,
-0.1580085456,
0.0996388942,
0.1386685967,
0.3170779049,
-0.0630160049,
-0.0735546276,
-0.4959503412,
-0.4892338514,
-0.4653999507,
-0.3789815009,
0.2396817207,
-0.3674713969,
-0.2210829556,
0.0367587805,
-0.5178825259,
0.2279761881,
0.302003175,
0.3676371574,
0.2815081179,
0.2730141878,
0.3743492663,
-0.2503459454,
-0.6769444346,
-0.553771019,
0.8750066757,
0.4486618638,
0.8232150078,
0.0506385602,
0.6014136672,
0.6740635037,
0.6971722245,
-0.4702675641,
0.4350307584,
0.068496421,
-0.5168161988,
-0.0500542074,
-0.4557050765,
-0.5487242937,
0.0676995143,
-0.5511288643,
-0.3432678282,
0.2516741753,
0.5295161605,
-0.3705354333,
0.2195742726,
-0.6821458936,
0.418703109,
-0.3383738697,
-0.4866634011,
-0.2999739051,
-0.887003243,
0.4878440499,
-0.2729586065,
0.4527160823,
-0.0873184055,
0.3463034034,
0.4133928716,
-0.4250283837,
1.0136247873,
-0.2344234288,
-0.0436864719,
0.4185652435,
-0.0448480248,
0.650355041,
0.0040426333,
-0.0190978479,
-0.1308370233,
-0.0420496278,
-0.1835048795,
-0.543454051,
0.5638009906,
-0.6278282404,
-0.4254521132,
-0.3935748339,
-0.1227130219,
-0.0639667138,
-0.088244535,
0.0779301077,
0.134802863,
-0.0509889238,
0.2723650932,
0.6867364049,
0.0758315846,
-0.023543885,
0.6321465969,
-0.2098172754,
-0.5813590884,
0.719410181,
0.4853877723,
0.0376691706,
-0.144405812,
0.3233789802,
-0.2460287958,
0.051025331,
-0.0606363676,
0.3667435944,
-0.5411132574,
-0.2790424824,
-0.794485271,
-0.0829718634,
-0.4749383628,
-0.1584064066,
-0.2450546473,
-0.2307717204,
-0.1243817806,
-0.3231179118,
0.367343545,
0.6831018329,
-0.3367923796,
0.5969936848,
-0.7119279504,
0.3906578422,
0.3508877754,
-0.0030063039,
-0.2097512037,
-0.407438755,
-0.0613612458,
0.3794676363,
-0.3121685684,
-1.1490916014,
0.2767018676,
-0.0159683488,
0.2412831485,
0.4763016105,
0.5597489476,
0.6754128933,
-0.2119564861,
0.565525353,
0.148020491,
-0.6494271755,
0.5475527048,
-0.2058954686,
-0.0310327169,
0.4460661113,
0.6861643195,
-0.9712229967,
-0.348449856,
-0.7935946584,
-1.0004550219,
0.2526897788,
-0.0140183661,
0.0437031277,
-0.2165520489,
0.2286156863,
-0.0605920479,
0.5678903461,
-0.375308305,
-0.3044830561,
-0.324225843,
-0.1853936017,
-0.0054783979,
-0.6202350855,
-0.5290241241,
-0.0558487177,
0.9330973029,
-0.0630200878,
-0.0644417778,
0.478938669,
-0.1485217959,
-0.57506603,
0.2805244625,
0.4972723424,
0.6012570262,
-0.1458920687,
0.5160427094,
-0.0225192029,
-0.4072741866,
0.2588038445,
0.0284451805,
-0.2528747916,
0.2580395639,
0.0854318812,
0.5843889713,
0.0251407456,
-0.3216273487,
0.346516192,
-0.0249253605,
-0.1720516533,
-0.1464196593,
-0.261687547,
0.2934268713,
0.3269143105,
0.4490969181,
0.1560038179,
0.0312370174,
-0.60743469,
0.4884164333,
0.1036120802,
-0.3307872415,
-0.4758444726,
0.4772484899,
0.4038667381,
-0.1862405092,
0.3102918863,
0.0654925257,
-0.4573921859,
0.3923636973,
0.4831832051,
0.6275997162,
-0.3448754549,
0.6279438734,
0.4432602525,
0.6164367795,
-0.2902058661,
0.4480243921,
0.2901217043,
-0.7055183053,
-0.309702754,
-0.1404899955,
-0.3201276362,
0.1629608423,
-0.4646545053,
0.1935342401,
-0.7362791896,
-0.671970427,
0.1501604319,
-0.0376267359,
-0.6068416834,
0.3152667582,
0.1282026619,
0.9921460152,
-1.2051409483,
0.1905466467,
0.744458437,
-0.2514093816,
-0.6212826967,
0.1996019036,
0.6203784943,
-0.5045441389,
0.5304842591,
0.252617538,
-0.4448736906,
-0.1846120507,
-1.1387687922,
-0.3680986762,
0.8506267071,
0.6189197302,
-0.8374242783,
0.4368127286,
0.1955390126,
0.5310454965,
-0.3528805375,
0.2665511668,
0.3237154186,
0.6562085152,
0.2136954963,
-0.62880373,
0.1021334603,
-0.333878845,
-0.2180505097,
-0.16525729,
-0.6925430298,
0.443441838,
-0.1643386632,
-0.3252909184,
-0.6441215277,
0.6148961186,
0.4370463192,
0.6983389258,
0.642107904,
0.5574117303,
0.9533447623,
-0.1021119878,
0.7731053233,
-0.4560117126,
0.2430035025,
1.1435244083,
-0.527325511,
0.7385762334,
0.4868465364,
-0.0641488284,
0.3167729676,
0.5547018051,
0.1364409178,
0.146509558,
0.4161457419,
-0.3022970259,
-0.252228111,
-0.4270016849,
-0.2872683704,
0.0518944822,
0.3852355182,
-0.3533854485,
-0.0737407729,
-0.3013383448,
0.5631417036,
0.2489049882,
-0.3528670371,
0.4735174179,
-0.0129458755,
-0.4604543746,
0.348698616,
-0.196968779,
0.8103807569,
-0.3287120759,
-0.0533175506,
-0.283236295,
-0.0005222391,
-0.5420252085,
-0.8290713429,
0.371730715,
0.0290331841,
-0.2087425441,
-0.0471987575,
1.1447850466,
-0.6349617243,
-0.4838764071,
0.0715719312,
0.4455540478,
0.0140496558,
-0.3524942398,
-0.5641089678,
0.2406392992,
-0.0599241108,
-0.2106336206,
-0.1640226543,
0.7610650063,
0.0981416926,
0.6966381073,
0.6745693684,
0.0926896483,
-0.0211099479,
-0.0227701813,
0.8978356123,
-0.470613122,
-0.4188172221,
-0.7330582142,
0.6947934628,
-0.4632364213,
-0.0918124169,
0.8534254432,
0.3545617759,
0.5514501929,
-0.0251778755,
1.1602547169,
0.1209078804,
0.7224180102,
-0.0456255339,
0.6580972672,
-0.3770396411,
0.0023588464,
-0.4761003256,
-0.5326814055,
-0.1840191185,
0.489664644,
-0.3873500526,
-0.1661580652,
0.2775037587,
0.9546717405,
0.1796262413,
0.094061479,
-0.0206183176,
0.6480405331,
0.255520016,
0.1505447328,
0.776501298,
-0.2036986053,
0.3542148471,
-0.166373387,
-0.2380319536,
-0.5259636641,
-1.0708768368,
-0.6965823174,
-0.2423216552,
-0.5621832609,
-0.8923500776,
0.5561169982,
1.1148643494,
0.3754923046,
-0.5580716133,
-0.0177097097,
0.4189262986,
0.1201655045,
-0.0588422827,
-0.1978482902,
0.0121071255,
0.0691081136,
-0.1065588519,
0.0583132096,
0.292247504,
-0.0892687961,
-0.2270083874,
-0.0341849811,
-0.1768661886,
0.514862597,
0.7139764428,
0.3536776006,
-0.3888590336,
-0.3197125196,
-0.0322345346,
-0.1874081045,
-0.0254387334,
0.6440061927,
-0.5268612504,
0.515807271,
0.4860205352,
0.6020186543,
0.2666602433,
0.2920796275,
0.5110331774,
-0.7734532952,
-0.2498562187,
-0.037095733,
0.2277753651,
0.5667749047,
-0.6564415097,
0.5572139025,
0.5771118402,
-0.5823497772,
-0.8603749275,
0.0296471659,
-0.7977527976,
0.0977742672,
1.0589544773,
-0.0350741297,
-0.3475157619,
0.0335155055,
-0.5940775275,
0.3858201504,
-0.6864207983,
1.232453227,
0.8110589385,
0.1775460094,
-0.2875439227,
-0.4142661095,
0.2627939582,
0.1373452395,
-0.9845420718,
0.3157267869,
0.6669592261,
0.3623822033,
0.2759729326,
0.7126843333,
0.1370506287,
0.1848239601,
-0.06451682,
0.1388529241,
0.0286589041,
-0.309135884,
-0.1285966188,
0.058731094,
-0.3020918369,
0.1572869867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10541v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10541v1
|
Detection of Offensive and Threatening Online Content in a Low Resource Language
| 2023-11-17T14:08:44 | 2023-11-17T14:08:44 |
Fatima Muhammad Adam, Abubakar Yakubu Zandam, Isa Inuwa-Dutse
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Hausa is a major Chadic language, spoken by over 100 million people in
Africa. However, from a computational linguistic perspective, it is considered
a low-resource language, with limited resources to support Natural Language
Processing (NLP) tasks. Online platforms often facilitate social interactions
that can lead to the use of offensive and threatening language, which can go
undetected due to the lack of detection systems designed for Hausa. This study
aimed to address this issue by (1) conducting two user studies (n=308) to
investigate cyberbullying-related issues, (2) collecting and annotating the
first set of offensive and threatening datasets to support relevant downstream
tasks in Hausa, (3) developing a detection system to flag offensive and
threatening content, and (4) evaluating the detection system and the efficacy
of the Google-based translation engine in detecting offensive and threatening
terms in Hausa. We found that offensive and threatening content is quite
common, particularly when discussing religion and politics. Our detection
system was able to detect more than 70% of offensive and threatening content,
although many of these were mistranslated by Google's translation engine. We
attribute this to the subtle relationship between offensive and threatening
content and idiomatic expressions in the Hausa language. We recommend that
diverse stakeholders participate in understanding local conventions and
demographics in order to develop a more effective detection system. These
insights are essential for implementing targeted moderation strategies to
create a safe and inclusive online environment.
|
[
-0.6722951531,
-1.1966042519,
0.0679448098,
0.4836405516,
-0.3804195523,
0.0675665289,
-0.2951689661,
-0.9310416579,
0.5456676483,
0.4684574604,
-0.2555906475,
-0.2131328434,
-0.8454110622,
0.420946151,
-0.6437445283,
0.8916985393,
0.0645268336,
-0.4439943135,
0.2211858183,
-0.2444215715,
-0.4782741964,
-0.5818318725,
-1.1603455544,
0.1640029103,
0.7268041968,
0.0941137075,
0.8787099123,
0.3979027271,
0.4393008649,
0.357909739,
-0.4182785451,
0.1310736239,
-0.7770331502,
0.1022726074,
-0.4368326962,
-0.1855540276,
-0.2003889531,
-0.2208310813,
0.2160253078,
0.1507396251,
-0.1239127144,
0.1750133485,
0.2775892913,
0.4213404655,
-0.9907451272,
-0.1976504028,
-0.4103264213,
0.060141325,
-0.676946044,
0.0018843276,
-0.1643660963,
-0.299957484,
-0.2949599624,
-0.8270780444,
-0.2005878687,
0.115987666,
0.7588157654,
0.1937692463,
-0.4738954306,
-0.6719259024,
-0.4333996475,
0.698653698,
-0.546572268,
0.1189112812,
1.0412211418,
0.1991906315,
-0.185917601,
-0.3453190923,
-0.8167860508,
0.3496444523,
-0.1638158858,
-0.1717147231,
-0.7519214153,
-0.3650026321,
0.0517424084,
0.1432876736,
-0.2702271342,
0.4662742317,
-0.3136072457,
-0.4143046439,
0.9449406266,
-0.0051972964,
0.427202791,
-0.6775867939,
-0.3976254761,
0.0127819348,
-0.4620595574,
-0.1991529912,
0.7115753293,
0.3422539532,
-0.3992062509,
0.1640134752,
0.0869222656,
0.5376297235,
-0.2534356117,
-0.1254497766,
0.0900230557,
-0.2029702067,
0.072933659,
0.0549873188,
1.2534390688,
0.3356482089,
0.5254000425,
0.31967327,
-0.3140663803,
0.2993599474,
0.7894313335,
-0.5107579827,
0.1912106872,
-0.1906498075,
-0.5835546255,
-0.7128272653,
-0.4054294527,
-1.3835499287,
-0.9091235399,
0.2854620516,
0.349399507,
-0.2507804334,
-0.1870085597,
-0.3493441045,
0.0963984132,
-0.1572443992,
0.2629923522,
-0.7584361434,
0.5347462296,
0.434825629,
0.7898751497,
-0.3635384738,
0.1355903149,
-0.4549010098,
-0.2467433661,
-0.2358118743,
0.4719262123,
-0.555636704,
-0.6057678461,
0.3818944991,
-0.0780119002,
0.3405141234,
-0.5556289554,
1.028411746,
-0.6044194102,
0.0426854379,
-0.2195042372,
-0.1669252515,
-0.3703495562,
0.2118180841,
-0.5496894121,
1.0487235785,
0.2778452039,
-0.583019793,
0.0872961506,
-0.626688242,
-0.8182217479,
0.260984689,
-0.1849070042,
-0.5750832558,
0.0086278161,
0.0762712136,
0.1638083756,
-0.2680275738,
0.0089998031,
-0.2274885178,
-0.38792184,
0.439719826,
-0.3932595253,
0.9301545024,
0.641140461,
-0.7280358672,
0.1955287904,
-0.401332587,
-0.301456511,
0.3813537955,
-0.3177874684,
-0.6580260396,
0.1161873937,
0.2559697926,
0.2831534743,
0.0768637285,
-0.6003060341,
-0.4242076576,
-0.0325974077,
0.1820544302,
0.6617487073,
0.0429822318,
-0.0670770928,
-0.2071976364,
0.65632236,
-0.1166342199,
0.2480338514,
0.299529314,
-0.9268684387,
-0.6279723048,
-0.150630191,
-0.0202082209,
0.7165533304,
-0.624566853,
0.3605627418,
0.0673878193,
-0.2471177429,
-0.6013327837,
0.3005661368,
0.5157940984,
0.3171280324,
0.4667755067,
-0.2342038453,
-0.6700711846,
-0.8156135678,
-0.1485357881,
-0.3105521202,
0.0715408102,
0.3418763876,
0.5383293629,
-0.3186041415,
0.5058330297,
-0.4759168327,
-0.5811274648,
-0.0827589557,
0.5028114915,
-0.1452551782,
0.1163812876,
0.7562077045,
-1.1899567842,
-0.766251564,
0.0315242335,
-0.9151294231,
-0.2596905529,
0.3499441445,
-0.2237058282,
0.1516654491,
0.3443247974,
0.0007959733,
0.8592844009,
0.4922380447,
-0.3247518241,
0.2842467129,
0.1448263973,
0.5579863787,
-1.0329831839,
-0.0595105402,
0.0332696363,
-0.3686196208,
-0.6544151306,
0.2301757187,
-0.3079861701,
-0.4018935263,
-0.6558942795,
0.4924132228,
-0.08440689,
0.2293748111,
-0.6473465562,
0.327444613,
-0.2953988016,
0.1442897767,
0.088174127,
0.7871826291,
0.1624354273,
-0.6440446973,
0.337806493,
0.4823581278,
-0.537746191,
0.740311563,
-0.3432637453,
0.0038209998,
0.0783574656,
-0.1188360676,
-0.5481123924,
-0.4499366879,
0.6449248195,
-0.4036893845,
-0.156367749,
-0.0988457277,
-0.3661708832,
-0.4819393754,
-0.1294457316,
0.4667810202,
0.4069819748,
-0.2254772335,
0.2242116332,
0.9903284311,
-0.4300118089,
-0.7165271044,
-0.5106173158,
0.4060450792,
-0.4662416875,
-0.4674820602,
0.2474997193,
0.2295623571,
-0.4217976332,
-0.0281211622,
0.3393705785,
-0.2592864335,
0.5191444159,
0.2730541825,
-0.0048907553,
0.1857227981,
-0.0157349091,
-0.1879114956,
0.3730110228,
0.2573839426,
0.2798552811,
0.7288443446,
-0.155997321,
0.0305472575,
-0.3166729808,
0.603248477,
0.1573819518,
-0.0760000348,
0.8793792725,
0.8659310341,
-0.8060131669,
0.0413033888,
-0.3147962987,
-0.0328383893,
-0.4674432874,
0.0908352509,
0.1427471042,
-0.8461502194,
0.6179298759,
0.2884251177,
-0.2492694259,
0.2560656667,
0.5581254959,
-0.4130513966,
0.5636804104,
0.6230954528,
-0.1275639981,
0.4231615067,
0.112340197,
0.2395502329,
-0.5244660378,
-0.029435534,
-0.5968991518,
-0.5076455474,
-0.9069722891,
-0.2135904431,
0.417583406,
-0.0916309357,
0.0661371946,
0.7768235803,
-0.1278877854,
0.2002264559,
0.2382253408,
0.2400725484,
0.0407385789,
0.2726391852,
0.1191258505,
-0.0925110951,
-0.4586417377,
-0.5318076611,
0.7848346233,
0.2169536352,
0.5998860002,
0.5999509692,
0.5861181021,
1.0251024961,
0.4072076976,
-0.7799591422,
0.5369051695,
-0.2691461444,
-1.050246954,
-0.3751285076,
-0.4712940454,
-1.2671182156,
0.1635483205,
-0.6410412788,
-1.0489606857,
0.4061137736,
0.1731603146,
-0.3893184364,
0.4166257381,
-0.2098381817,
0.7075514197,
-0.1776499003,
-0.6609307528,
-0.4516758025,
-0.5084632635,
0.259311527,
-0.6378486753,
0.9054924846,
0.0245518312,
-0.0246559009,
0.9140111804,
-0.2193210572,
1.1583548784,
0.1612668186,
-0.3822906017,
0.7327122688,
0.1976791918,
0.333779037,
-0.1382276416,
-0.2574429512,
0.2623269558,
-0.545271337,
-0.4038634002,
-0.193750903,
0.650437057,
-0.4889806211,
-0.4507098496,
-0.4485020638,
-0.3177434802,
0.2209857702,
0.4426726401,
0.5089896917,
0.0534581468,
-0.3311553895,
0.0869790688,
0.5839516521,
-0.2915592492,
0.3817541301,
0.2809393704,
-0.3690450788,
-0.3664763272,
1.0665518045,
-0.149952665,
0.0634299964,
-0.0533560142,
0.2790613472,
-0.1334461272,
-0.2271611094,
-0.3874558806,
0.0652557537,
-0.5842497945,
-0.1366627663,
-0.5336307287,
0.0064048492,
-0.3575925529,
-0.3006485403,
-0.1509436816,
-0.0118636694,
-0.1751021445,
0.30456388,
0.0679514855,
0.8792878389,
-0.1595100909,
0.7776662111,
-0.6353994012,
0.3647471666,
0.1761374325,
0.0432275534,
-0.263907522,
-0.6126207113,
-0.1674835235,
0.0708931237,
-0.4291878343,
-1.194647789,
0.4945217967,
0.0704464167,
0.1955802888,
0.6425508857,
0.3864912987,
0.4301481247,
-0.068634294,
0.5701164007,
0.1098989248,
-0.6678622365,
0.7423399687,
-0.3377963901,
0.031060759,
0.4463019371,
1.0425097942,
-0.7607815266,
-0.2445753515,
-0.5101829171,
-0.5047142506,
0.5159079432,
0.6757340431,
0.2819172442,
-0.4117590189,
-0.2184759229,
-0.0265720356,
0.4739777446,
-0.7483029962,
-0.3337696195,
-0.1233516037,
0.1030479223,
0.1187639534,
-0.3076334298,
-0.3064381182,
0.2226636857,
0.6916129589,
0.0808434039,
0.1928525567,
-0.2707150877,
-0.2896482944,
-0.3190307915,
0.4512106478,
0.283852607,
0.4729818702,
0.0444068611,
0.0686672106,
0.0760589316,
-0.6885924935,
0.1374406964,
-0.0231354833,
-0.504283905,
-0.014606541,
0.3274794519,
0.9358717799,
0.442672044,
-0.6076688766,
0.6599481106,
0.0558068641,
0.1920706332,
-0.2788720131,
-0.0973097533,
-0.1389445961,
-0.2659605443,
0.155530706,
0.0025052198,
0.2230346054,
-0.7069724798,
0.0569447614,
0.1646656543,
-0.4405811131,
-0.0774765685,
0.5407171845,
0.5547425151,
-0.4740495682,
0.6255264282,
-0.5459326506,
-0.7965307832,
0.3620516956,
0.6555192471,
0.5402347445,
-0.3610778749,
0.561506331,
0.4818783998,
0.5113335848,
0.4837563336,
0.5618286729,
-0.0533534363,
-0.8424902558,
0.0045154891,
-0.8991856575,
-0.1104828641,
0.46114856,
-0.7175517678,
0.3440080285,
-0.5776652694,
-0.7040702105,
0.1077179909,
-0.3195850551,
-0.4832688868,
0.2417117506,
0.4734305739,
0.6107031107,
-0.9645515084,
0.2855010033,
0.8089972138,
-0.3142825663,
-0.0108111175,
-0.0974783599,
0.5543065071,
-0.6267364621,
0.5348472595,
0.1560981125,
-0.2150522023,
-0.2963911593,
-0.3557525873,
-0.5528746247,
0.2083749175,
-0.0049074711,
-0.2750274539,
0.3380122483,
0.3326310217,
0.6089736223,
-0.2179110795,
-0.1663028747,
0.4116230309,
0.4638586342,
-0.3187466264,
-0.8629969954,
0.211535126,
-0.2681206465,
-0.2512304187,
0.6116262078,
-0.4970660806,
0.4624786377,
0.0038283472,
-0.5511716604,
-0.1578369886,
0.7019335032,
-0.1226938367,
0.3096945882,
0.696539402,
0.5520410538,
0.7301077247,
-0.0701380968,
0.9577516317,
0.1021303087,
-0.063652508,
0.9873563647,
-0.0778506324,
0.9801554084,
0.259373188,
-0.2512797415,
0.7634836435,
0.5752355456,
0.1715871692,
0.1498380601,
0.3347964585,
-0.7936144471,
-0.3030159175,
-0.7869629264,
-0.1551157981,
0.772395134,
0.8367286921,
-0.2007930279,
-0.2272544205,
0.3191649914,
0.605742991,
0.561116457,
-0.4628340602,
0.7102210522,
0.2008160204,
-0.4633443952,
0.6077116728,
0.1162401885,
0.8548499346,
-0.5602145791,
0.2310587466,
-0.0757013187,
-0.1109361351,
-0.285058856,
-0.9318614602,
0.6168287992,
0.5866134763,
0.2344025522,
0.1123384982,
0.9232711196,
-0.1889784932,
-0.2032013983,
0.568723619,
0.2673119903,
0.3348540366,
-0.0418994538,
-0.5541801453,
0.3474344909,
-0.1997847408,
0.1642487198,
0.3825296164,
-0.0576532818,
-0.6381445527,
0.7583545446,
0.5369197726,
0.0683003291,
0.0796342641,
-0.1203365177,
0.7185773253,
-0.356793642,
-0.7475674748,
-0.5764952302,
0.0455336832,
-0.5058706403,
-0.6056239605,
0.637152791,
0.3001510203,
1.029058814,
0.150502637,
0.703993082,
-0.5610877275,
0.1695045233,
-0.1394975334,
0.7663262486,
-0.4853053093,
-0.0604636185,
-0.4215613604,
-0.9353680611,
0.0416588709,
0.586338222,
-0.163775906,
-0.209648326,
0.4447224736,
0.5633240938,
-0.020251574,
0.3123477399,
0.3284817338,
0.1825210452,
0.066415146,
0.0645820126,
0.6277442575,
-0.5419582725,
0.6855359674,
-0.5448220372,
-0.3925914168,
-0.3382663727,
-0.8971440792,
-0.9094547629,
-0.3678458631,
-0.3271695375,
-0.3758889437,
0.2457918227,
0.6940764785,
0.4055466056,
-1.0351941586,
-0.4608393312,
0.4117197394,
-0.0529042706,
-0.2351778895,
-0.1925678104,
-0.0328863636,
0.0398063622,
-0.7178200483,
0.5784544349,
0.0210342743,
-0.0181357842,
-0.1393642575,
-0.0780619606,
-0.7517246604,
0.0341126584,
0.9432795048,
0.592622757,
-0.4470065236,
-0.244818747,
-0.1857857704,
-0.1177208051,
-0.3114548624,
0.3746326268,
-0.4331434667,
0.6025237441,
0.5058361292,
0.8449255824,
0.3139358759,
0.1437319666,
0.45808056,
-0.878473103,
0.1153590456,
0.0788726881,
0.3434918225,
0.4457636476,
-0.5248459578,
0.7035154104,
0.4321339726,
-0.47400105,
-0.5795853734,
0.2919205427,
-0.507245779,
-0.2083660811,
1.0050803423,
-0.3099070787,
-0.2726231813,
-0.2581447959,
-0.226022169,
0.4853813946,
-0.4678888023,
1.0471832752,
0.9204326868,
0.1033743024,
0.2386919558,
-0.6217095852,
0.4504382014,
0.3665251136,
-1.0371814966,
-0.1591673046,
0.3763085306,
-0.1760688722,
0.5848702192,
0.1754339635,
-0.0408111513,
0.4273448288,
-0.1058279127,
-0.1820859909,
0.2660343051,
-0.2382342815,
-0.1299767047,
0.0588169657,
-0.6136248708,
-0.0385526679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10514v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10514v1
|
When a Language Question Is at Stake. A Revisited Approach to Label Sensitive Content
| 2023-11-17T13:35:10 | 2023-11-17T13:35:10 |
Stetsenko Daria
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Many under-resourced languages require high-quality datasets for specific
tasks such as offensive language detection, disinformation, or misinformation
identification. However, the intricacies of the content may have a detrimental
effect on the annotators. The article aims to revisit an approach of
pseudo-labeling sensitive data on the example of Ukrainian tweets covering the
Russian-Ukrainian war. Nowadays, this acute topic is in the spotlight of
various language manipulations that cause numerous disinformation and profanity
on social media platforms. The conducted experiment highlights three main
stages of data annotation and underlines the main obstacles during machine
annotation. Ultimately, we provide a fundamental statistical analysis of the
obtained data, evaluation of models used for pseudo-labelling, and set further
guidelines on how the scientists can leverage the corpus to execute more
advanced research and extend the existing data samples without annotators'
engagement.
|
[
-0.3361650705,
-0.8958372474,
0.2139980495,
-0.1277115196,
-0.3255053759,
0.1579788476,
-0.1329089254,
-0.6533204317,
0.0058171554,
0.4741809368,
-0.3684567213,
-0.4224113822,
-0.7528552413,
0.0886079893,
-0.4770290852,
1.2993750572,
-0.1406359076,
-0.0456741452,
0.3186123967,
-0.2932627797,
-0.0159556437,
-1.0524640083,
-0.2052820772,
0.0750725642,
0.5143375397,
0.5028773546,
0.7379800081,
0.6885365248,
0.6802620888,
0.3304306865,
0.045928251,
-0.2976273,
-0.565667212,
0.2517443299,
-0.2290832549,
-0.7389782071,
0.022329405,
0.2607488036,
0.6289036274,
0.8578649163,
0.4131745994,
0.3939965665,
-0.160892576,
0.4006820321,
-0.6277437806,
-0.1481077075,
-0.7667901516,
-0.0301336739,
-0.5497885942,
0.0882308111,
-0.3097819686,
-0.4083729386,
0.0519059934,
-0.5409544706,
0.4263302684,
-0.0290621761,
0.9396676421,
0.249844417,
-0.1279822737,
-0.3006097674,
-0.9272213578,
0.9356405735,
-0.4214126468,
0.2196689546,
0.8123747706,
0.1527151465,
0.1505057216,
-0.9460347295,
-0.4909439385,
-0.0525626726,
-0.2177826762,
-0.0732671767,
-0.3970517218,
-0.2587878108,
0.4620132446,
0.0575072169,
-0.202783078,
0.181556806,
-0.51917243,
-0.5842927694,
0.5394648314,
-0.0811154023,
0.4559310377,
-0.1632277817,
-0.3188346922,
-0.0076689208,
-0.7097162008,
-0.0659277737,
0.5891473889,
0.4626433849,
0.0912771523,
0.8180164099,
-0.1451431364,
0.5507917404,
0.1106358543,
-0.01024972,
0.3042593896,
-0.4133614302,
0.1077300236,
0.1888190955,
0.8626312017,
0.3928426206,
0.4913912714,
0.0078729149,
-0.1980057657,
0.3654056489,
0.3426316679,
-0.6838386059,
-0.4035797715,
0.1409175247,
-0.2488980442,
-0.3652859926,
-0.1038321704,
-0.8464848399,
-0.3241802454,
-0.0313669443,
0.4852172136,
-0.1698559523,
-0.2157948762,
-0.3005797863,
-0.0140237873,
-0.348022908,
0.00251017,
-0.7343768477,
0.0330610424,
0.4677894115,
0.5275053382,
0.15933384,
0.0842954516,
-0.3659736216,
-0.000312818,
-0.4251827002,
0.5708190799,
-0.8227224946,
-0.4552245736,
0.1140644476,
0.0197546296,
0.240555644,
-0.447027266,
0.658323288,
-0.7315229774,
0.2529895604,
-0.4186615944,
-0.4122434855,
0.0609753542,
0.1035670489,
-0.8443865776,
1.1610236168,
0.3383164704,
-1.2271598577,
0.5958856344,
-0.337685734,
-0.3582690656,
0.1109862626,
-0.0057705683,
-0.6184934974,
-0.1164093763,
-0.1460550725,
0.3501861393,
0.2027485371,
0.2612328827,
-0.4547313452,
-0.2926705778,
0.7312141657,
-0.0220472682,
0.5760416985,
0.2549364269,
-0.4235158563,
0.0586687475,
-0.626526475,
-0.085528031,
-0.0318565145,
-0.3670305312,
-0.6076772809,
-0.0534305312,
0.180286184,
0.4515163898,
0.0687632188,
-0.5814052224,
0.1170518622,
-0.2471054792,
0.3249195218,
0.4942705929,
0.0462996252,
0.469866693,
-0.2457059324,
0.5534433722,
0.0773230642,
0.2424734086,
0.2456699014,
-0.4893977642,
-0.8014707565,
-0.1201224774,
0.5704674721,
0.6124261618,
-1.1322809458,
0.1249271259,
-0.018974252,
-0.6258724332,
-0.950409472,
-0.0396749228,
0.5320222378,
0.6429453492,
0.4803573489,
0.1726453453,
-0.9343004823,
-1.2084989548,
-0.2468509972,
-0.6825711727,
-0.0220715422,
0.0230373908,
0.6067022085,
0.0538247488,
0.833717823,
-0.2293568105,
0.0158899315,
-0.1794885695,
0.6646220088,
-0.2902566791,
0.3486192226,
0.4929850101,
-0.9748626947,
-0.5198456049,
-0.2337933481,
-0.5504751205,
-0.571680963,
0.1809224039,
-0.1157627553,
0.316054672,
0.498062402,
-0.1693826318,
0.4022310674,
0.3957279921,
0.1377557665,
0.4758912325,
0.2739360034,
0.4205044806,
-0.8163126707,
0.2695419788,
-0.0489037633,
0.0076895617,
-1.1108145714,
-0.3231534958,
0.1021706313,
0.0847343951,
-0.6826009154,
0.2706026137,
-0.2269915342,
0.3293319643,
-0.4350312054,
0.1014657244,
-0.2511200011,
-0.1171915606,
0.1876256466,
0.7730573416,
0.3840172887,
-0.4138352275,
0.0841892064,
0.0258029662,
-0.2514604926,
0.4107644856,
-0.3743829727,
0.2293407619,
-0.3096566498,
0.0806437209,
-1.1943598986,
-0.1606657654,
0.776642561,
-0.5913820863,
0.2074509263,
-0.4528912306,
-0.6384959221,
-0.331704706,
-0.3596852124,
0.5108972192,
0.2926303148,
-0.0088132909,
-0.0373280197,
0.8005615473,
-0.0887831822,
-0.6275171638,
-0.841653049,
0.1794032753,
-0.7206914425,
-0.2910840809,
0.150652945,
-0.0116576049,
-0.6115642786,
0.0930022225,
0.1716850698,
-0.3184010983,
0.2921483219,
0.1909617335,
0.0477796756,
-0.0660444349,
0.3723711371,
-0.2029337585,
-0.1294365525,
0.1075685695,
0.0567360483,
0.2715628147,
0.0890244991,
0.0723946467,
-0.3591474593,
0.4276415706,
0.0023490938,
-0.1544957161,
0.8660770655,
0.7294390202,
-0.5069343448,
0.0876388177,
-0.4406884313,
-0.2624244094,
-0.3724527359,
0.3313927054,
-0.309512347,
-0.9144957066,
0.6253438592,
-0.0831435695,
-0.2261179388,
0.7103607059,
0.5277040005,
-0.3555130661,
0.7060995102,
0.6760420203,
-0.1951089203,
0.4073088169,
0.0055439482,
0.352571249,
-0.3890321851,
-0.1894189715,
-0.9410714507,
-0.2997149825,
-0.9186400771,
-0.2199227214,
0.0797672942,
0.2517549098,
0.3446480036,
0.3599580526,
-0.3588406444,
0.0620569736,
0.235311687,
-0.1146482453,
-0.0356184542,
-0.1779377162,
0.2587125897,
-0.4848543704,
-0.6851661801,
-0.843095541,
0.8955241442,
0.209212631,
0.5054792166,
-0.0187374856,
0.2973227203,
0.3230988085,
0.8447880149,
-0.4770856798,
0.2628623247,
0.0628257841,
-1.3004664183,
-0.3727392256,
-0.3464831412,
-0.9634228349,
-0.0196513049,
-0.2586120069,
-1.0608201027,
0.2406857312,
0.2140839845,
-0.1554215401,
0.2934108973,
-0.8726668358,
0.5548072457,
-0.068723239,
-0.4684024751,
0.3191515803,
-0.8818798661,
0.3420311511,
-0.6950270534,
0.6463271379,
0.0563181639,
-0.2846548855,
1.1549515724,
-0.2616699338,
1.1027436256,
-0.2464463115,
-0.0186894275,
0.5164071321,
0.0045784055,
0.0940388143,
-0.245639503,
-0.2366906852,
0.1482498199,
-0.044970613,
-0.3359513283,
-0.2676971555,
0.3954444528,
-0.5272855163,
-0.4542697072,
-0.304499954,
-0.3147158027,
-0.0617896505,
0.2206887752,
0.4675008953,
0.0084002269,
-0.1617172658,
0.0735053867,
0.5176566839,
-0.2595267594,
0.388281703,
0.5078777075,
-0.0830566287,
-0.1122435182,
0.8841329217,
0.6340603828,
0.2211498469,
0.3383171856,
0.1136953011,
-0.3114423156,
-0.5656681657,
-0.3992244005,
0.1272932738,
-0.7392035127,
-0.1041950583,
-0.7447099686,
0.0422152616,
-0.2590075433,
0.0105801653,
-0.362102598,
-0.3973587155,
-0.5501333475,
-0.2868902087,
0.4225075841,
0.7465532422,
-0.2446057498,
0.6632196903,
-0.5959901214,
0.3718367219,
-0.126902774,
0.1474176645,
-0.4502880275,
-0.5951199532,
-0.4284570217,
0.1882384866,
-0.0366184004,
-1.1618329287,
0.0030142346,
-0.016615022,
0.6054115891,
0.2354484499,
0.2774541676,
0.3127591312,
-0.2933808565,
0.7514145374,
-0.1834130883,
-0.8980005383,
0.6431326866,
-0.3714983165,
0.1372128129,
0.6169999242,
0.888851285,
-0.4881715178,
-0.6031873226,
-0.784571588,
-1.04408288,
0.8576356173,
0.4337340593,
0.0399741456,
-0.1710710675,
0.2973234355,
0.2927955091,
0.2753842473,
-0.5880108476,
-0.4715127945,
-0.3741165698,
-0.0187720656,
-0.1055554226,
-0.6357846856,
-0.083877109,
-0.012374403,
0.5976891518,
0.1969330311,
-0.0134357587,
0.1251028925,
-0.462566644,
-0.2556532025,
0.2660813332,
0.4095358253,
0.6578155756,
-0.1990234852,
0.451148808,
0.0546599105,
-0.4913368821,
0.1781783104,
0.2064907253,
-0.2513564527,
0.1007471383,
0.5509256124,
0.61195755,
0.0581211708,
-0.3585418165,
0.3269049823,
0.0725962073,
-0.0432333872,
0.0883259922,
-0.2863130867,
-0.0183500964,
-0.0737281144,
0.3863084316,
-0.3953174055,
0.166331172,
-0.6513983011,
0.612367034,
0.0587946922,
-0.4243862629,
-0.6584066153,
0.3820287585,
0.0035553069,
-0.2752690017,
0.2094155252,
-0.0016251775,
-0.8671219349,
0.3249075711,
0.2731464207,
0.36989218,
-0.7275286913,
0.4516228437,
0.4166094661,
0.7236453891,
0.2874996662,
0.3619533777,
0.1738714576,
-0.6471389532,
-0.4682521522,
-0.2974601984,
-0.1435589641,
0.3508006632,
-0.6834055185,
0.0182982385,
-0.4575564265,
-0.622609973,
0.3973893225,
-0.0505137071,
-0.5445971489,
0.658993125,
0.1902172267,
0.2617523372,
-1.29428792,
0.673420012,
0.7315062284,
-0.3263033032,
-0.3442361951,
0.0167812631,
0.0325249732,
-0.5728641748,
0.7715577483,
0.0571167544,
0.0653542355,
-0.1540493816,
-0.6233068109,
-0.7043882012,
0.178057909,
0.2657173574,
-0.439237088,
0.6244016886,
0.6210321784,
0.9527127743,
0.0325024128,
0.1476738006,
0.683070004,
0.6204181314,
-0.3148089051,
-0.7792345881,
0.1387908906,
-0.3686245382,
-0.2904422581,
0.37301144,
-0.4604281187,
0.6068221331,
0.1470914185,
-0.4283851087,
-0.2440250367,
0.5249760151,
-0.0864662752,
0.3145908415,
0.623654604,
0.0946050882,
0.6882217526,
-0.3041734695,
0.829929769,
0.035026025,
0.1784592569,
0.8104820251,
-0.0157459471,
0.5523216128,
0.6839115024,
-0.2389597893,
-0.0597044341,
0.8697988987,
0.0611944571,
0.5555631518,
0.6079434752,
-0.158556819,
-0.0020596033,
-0.7533906698,
-0.4541856647,
0.4158281386,
0.512198329,
-0.3868203759,
-0.1625003368,
0.0780954286,
0.4519487321,
0.1208219081,
-0.1011412442,
0.8111005425,
-0.0219294,
-0.2809004486,
0.5021787286,
0.1208395883,
0.4621224403,
-0.3920894563,
0.1144300029,
-0.0076858778,
-0.232694909,
-0.2481500506,
-1.0225691795,
0.5305624008,
0.3777920902,
-0.138137877,
-0.2645851076,
0.8753182292,
-0.4261177778,
-0.6591475606,
0.2681283653,
0.4649202228,
0.3797191978,
-0.0712308735,
-0.5095421672,
0.4610940218,
0.0694789216,
-0.2919310331,
0.1977778524,
0.6813039184,
-0.4581583142,
0.4393335283,
0.5146463513,
0.0305179711,
0.1573597491,
0.1985116601,
0.947432518,
-0.3985055387,
-0.2159816027,
-0.8223702312,
0.6607288122,
0.0159279816,
-0.4082593322,
0.7777956724,
0.5278179049,
1.0748310089,
0.1647752076,
1.0789620876,
-0.0731627196,
0.7143417597,
-0.3810814619,
0.6883876324,
-0.4083265066,
-0.0095918756,
-0.5855576992,
-0.6731321216,
-0.5853817463,
0.342420876,
-0.6706207991,
0.0388659053,
0.543513,
0.6030689478,
0.0181884859,
-0.0342177935,
0.2409769148,
0.3382353485,
0.2460106611,
0.0843084902,
1.117773056,
-0.2622194886,
0.5566081405,
-0.8388867974,
-0.1686182767,
-0.248641789,
-0.6682285666,
-0.9835827351,
-0.8710690141,
-0.4079638124,
-0.1963004917,
0.2556759119,
0.3682721257,
0.4367705584,
-0.880001545,
0.1407071501,
0.5879474282,
-0.1821292639,
0.3358761668,
-0.1673408449,
0.4980246127,
0.0446750596,
-0.6112836003,
-0.0133696562,
-0.065278545,
0.1685721874,
-0.0791697055,
0.4876643717,
-0.3039802611,
-0.1603692174,
0.3758766949,
0.0992768556,
-0.5056838989,
-0.4761840105,
-0.2275627702,
-0.1443382502,
0.0030260503,
0.6976195574,
-0.564378798,
0.5679523349,
0.3238101602,
0.509426713,
0.4609448016,
0.2217445523,
0.2529319525,
-0.8314592838,
0.3305526078,
0.3685129285,
0.09511026,
0.7497493029,
-0.414570868,
0.2107149512,
0.2609527409,
-0.2556758821,
-0.959939599,
0.1551225632,
-0.5936471224,
-0.2272995561,
1.1149908304,
-0.217106849,
-0.0734398216,
-0.5528655052,
-0.2876774371,
0.7758774757,
-0.342553854,
1.0594550371,
1.0727379322,
0.2818820775,
-0.0257090293,
-0.77367419,
0.6893042326,
0.3485647738,
-0.7104382515,
0.120876193,
0.3433766365,
0.1827410311,
0.1779266447,
0.594776988,
-0.1020262986,
-0.1310486943,
-0.0923556015,
-0.0289806742,
0.3279781044,
-0.3009582162,
-0.0898413435,
0.1476811618,
0.0533137992,
-0.3635224998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10505v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10505v1
|
CNL2ASP: converting controlled natural language sentences into ASP
| 2023-11-17T13:10:58 | 2023-11-17T13:10:58 |
Simone Caruso, Carmine Dodaro, Marco Maratea, Marco Mochi, Francesco Riccio
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LO
|
Answer Set Programming (ASP) is a popular declarative programming language
for solving hard combinatorial problems. Although ASP has gained widespread
acceptance in academic and industrial contexts, there are certain user groups
who may find it more advantageous to employ a higher-level language that
closely resembles natural language when specifying ASP programs. In this paper,
we propose a novel tool, called CNL2ASP, for translating English sentences
expressed in a controlled natural language (CNL) form into ASP. In particular,
we first provide a definition of the type of sentences allowed by our CNL and
their translation as ASP rules, and then exemplify the usage of the CNL for the
specification of both synthetic and real-world combinatorial problems. Finally,
we report the results of an experimental analysis conducted on the real-world
problems to compare the performance of automatically generated encodings with
the ones written by ASP practitioners, showing that our tool can obtain
satisfactory performance on these benchmarks. Under consideration in Theory and
Practice of Logic Programming (TPLP).
|
[
-0.2252373248,
-0.7451524734,
0.2718278468,
0.5921887159,
-0.252648145,
0.2934822142,
-0.489525646,
-0.6472671628,
-0.027028501,
0.5830790997,
-0.4918169975,
-0.2233546823,
-0.4755560756,
0.3788220882,
-0.6015755534,
0.7203128338,
-0.3788363338,
0.0803731233,
-0.1816962808,
0.141138941,
-0.394873172,
-0.5007711649,
-0.8466827869,
-0.2727115452,
0.1158063486,
0.2292109877,
0.7505885959,
0.6675169468,
0.6628689766,
0.2498421222,
0.302677691,
0.485946089,
-0.1082773879,
0.0639382154,
-0.3745279014,
-0.4710426629,
0.0998177603,
0.0970797762,
0.386329025,
0.7451236844,
0.0406807847,
0.1408567727,
0.1269057542,
0.6778697371,
-0.4802976549,
0.3167211413,
-0.5833019614,
0.4467214048,
-0.0318369828,
-0.6225432754,
-0.6025509834,
-0.5506557226,
-0.1926984787,
-0.5527368784,
-0.1131772324,
0.1715536267,
0.5933621526,
0.4133239686,
-0.5401827097,
-0.7870807648,
-0.8004277945,
0.8264901042,
-0.9394327998,
0.1136937439,
0.3087034225,
0.5920903683,
-0.2790417075,
-0.7914593816,
-0.8541627526,
-0.1101970524,
-0.1914488822,
0.0766003057,
-0.0992595106,
0.1001624912,
0.2409377098,
0.2936463356,
-0.7462506294,
0.0645422414,
-0.4141428769,
0.0268484354,
0.910504818,
-0.0064622038,
0.6099845767,
-0.1288538128,
-0.1247920617,
-0.0013322526,
-0.4465553761,
0.0842276737,
0.1571996808,
0.4764786065,
0.0254972782,
0.8540784717,
-0.2005144656,
0.8309376836,
-0.2644055486,
0.1238981932,
-0.0626611635,
-0.2809285522,
-0.2482062131,
0.040821217,
0.442705512,
0.610078752,
0.6468697786,
-0.1030120179,
-0.2120965868,
0.3087514043,
0.2269072384,
-0.6241761446,
-0.272547245,
0.4221446514,
-0.5372289419,
-0.4180097878,
-0.0267772898,
-0.4606750607,
-0.079662174,
-0.5923656821,
0.1091345996,
-0.448584497,
0.0417760015,
0.2946320176,
-0.2409327179,
0.4968810081,
0.312325716,
-0.6073541045,
0.7880367637,
0.8256506324,
0.7980930805,
-0.5815481544,
0.1128235087,
-0.6870909333,
0.1700612456,
-0.4047042429,
0.8239856362,
-0.4877805114,
-0.2437725663,
0.3533478379,
-0.3903951049,
-0.0404094458,
-0.5761834383,
0.3539624214,
-0.7760297656,
0.318932265,
-0.049598068,
-0.5297256112,
0.1786266565,
0.3647205234,
-0.297960937,
0.5659455061,
-0.1664271057,
-0.4283611774,
-0.0642851666,
-0.9237203598,
-0.6881583929,
0.0495887063,
-0.4667207003,
0.1920702308,
-0.0087205218,
-0.1042617783,
-0.1298233122,
-0.3084400892,
0.061013896,
0.065692924,
-0.0226185024,
0.359521091,
-0.5225265026,
1.2699416876,
0.3564157188,
-0.1475289166,
0.0142504675,
-0.5783666968,
0.6432522535,
-0.0773715228,
-0.5944210887,
0.04897945,
0.2756657004,
0.2310696542,
0.650101006,
0.4516128898,
-0.5092523098,
0.3785999715,
-0.6996824741,
0.5652887821,
0.6297374368,
0.0956225321,
0.2186255455,
-0.0856332034,
0.5390276909,
-0.3799110353,
-0.0431982502,
0.4903149605,
-0.5576224923,
-0.8567826152,
0.4381626248,
0.0922172219,
0.9892828465,
-1.0563741922,
0.5540928245,
0.1009967625,
-0.0894823745,
-0.3180166781,
0.0629233569,
0.5861358047,
0.3707763553,
0.6693356633,
0.0293905661,
-0.6978649497,
-1.1654098034,
-0.3976528943,
-0.0100331921,
-0.4172360599,
0.2680763006,
0.3158840537,
-0.0641606823,
0.8867668509,
-0.890797317,
-0.3052391112,
-0.4064150453,
0.1524319202,
0.1384550631,
0.6441590786,
0.1089924946,
-0.6496640444,
-0.8054189682,
0.0459999181,
-0.6885774136,
-0.3830082715,
-0.2398846298,
-0.2082592398,
0.4047887921,
0.6093432903,
-0.4715235233,
0.7049247026,
0.5132934451,
-0.398188889,
0.8634174466,
-0.4050229192,
-0.0083856443,
-0.9424902201,
0.2400492728,
-0.3317365348,
-0.2642850876,
-0.4195723832,
0.5007112622,
0.0121678635,
-0.3478323519,
-0.3664370179,
0.2649080157,
-0.4582776427,
-0.2227402478,
-0.3501126468,
0.2542678714,
0.0232170019,
0.555862844,
0.1483783871,
0.8321405649,
0.1734714955,
-0.7184006572,
0.644331634,
0.7824092507,
0.0317963436,
0.414199084,
-0.6512521505,
0.2759295404,
0.0178110618,
0.2120429873,
-0.5606019497,
-0.0160162281,
0.1283595413,
-0.4610702693,
0.1224937961,
0.1669827849,
-0.6307902336,
-0.5047504902,
-0.2448536903,
0.0519925356,
0.4790207446,
-0.3810632229,
0.2027380913,
0.1343023181,
0.0629180744,
-0.2783862948,
-1.032363534,
0.3831495643,
0.2956396639,
-0.5066431165,
0.4909749925,
-0.471842438,
-0.4876068234,
-0.0624524504,
-0.243163988,
-0.2476733327,
-0.1523151547,
-0.0553474911,
-0.0005237518,
-0.1418720484,
-0.0386915244,
0.1246136799,
-0.2865721583,
0.244681403,
-0.44044137,
0.8128640056,
0.0395703726,
-0.4191532135,
-0.4233419001,
0.955016315,
0.033502683,
-0.4884429574,
0.5078852177,
-0.040579658,
-0.5282928944,
-0.686436832,
-0.0214966405,
0.0018365922,
-0.5370835662,
0.1743417978,
-0.4394195378,
-0.3366307914,
0.214272514,
0.1560290307,
0.4254371226,
0.1597161144,
0.2618498206,
-0.0259233955,
1.0970861912,
0.5604398847,
0.3974800408,
0.1434120238,
-0.173336193,
0.4395284653,
-0.4331135154,
-0.0425932743,
-0.6678305268,
-0.5774821639,
-0.5079134703,
-0.574855864,
0.2834851444,
0.0106933871,
-0.1371544898,
0.6774836183,
-0.5128012896,
0.679327786,
0.6281570196,
0.0095141474,
0.3301109374,
0.0539338253,
0.0867582932,
-0.1363681555,
-0.4599001408,
-0.5663692355,
0.8228521943,
-0.0756673887,
0.2645260394,
0.403819412,
0.5720107555,
0.586117208,
-0.0828801915,
-0.9234643579,
0.8466879129,
-0.6702868938,
-0.2786856592,
-0.1653933227,
-0.0866965428,
-0.8764369488,
-0.30026564,
-0.0219742842,
-0.7146484256,
-0.0772353262,
0.2790083885,
-0.2562304735,
0.0230599735,
-0.5147954226,
0.8486652374,
-0.3593742251,
-0.145138219,
-0.4095775783,
-0.7715370059,
0.0405293293,
0.1718943268,
-0.1170092821,
0.2190061957,
-0.1597396135,
0.5698679686,
-0.7024278641,
0.5157555342,
-0.0885257497,
-0.0525481664,
0.2685730159,
0.3826489449,
0.4547267854,
0.0732126534,
-0.2617877722,
-0.2638537884,
0.3038537502,
-0.4457087815,
-0.8760137558,
0.6783285141,
-0.7561637759,
-0.6102876663,
-0.4220131636,
-0.6996924877,
-0.4207625091,
0.2594535053,
-0.0153151313,
0.6027923226,
0.1848014742,
0.2059010863,
0.4024450183,
-0.4002910256,
0.557718277,
0.4770476222,
-0.3069774508,
0.0054498264,
0.6401591897,
0.0736120045,
0.6071913838,
0.7049311996,
-0.01033781,
-0.3008313775,
-0.7426483631,
-0.3465189636,
-0.109029986,
-0.764349103,
-0.2925238311,
-0.5841383934,
-0.6482262611,
-0.5166585445,
-0.6466883421,
-0.1301552057,
-0.8419719338,
-0.1719609648,
0.0672718212,
0.0141393775,
0.3406843543,
-0.034542419,
0.10039033,
-0.4679390788,
0.7452369928,
0.3797222078,
0.4179755747,
-0.414545089,
-0.3589963317,
0.1511610597,
0.081861183,
-0.1065590382,
-1.1316393614,
0.6935683489,
0.3180542588,
0.2697560489,
0.3669190705,
0.3211297095,
0.728543222,
-0.6813213229,
0.6153748631,
-0.1735116541,
-0.8616222143,
0.7911188006,
-0.0824907646,
0.3319060504,
0.8478904366,
0.1803893894,
-0.8743960261,
-0.2681229711,
-0.643276155,
-0.7692457438,
0.6568747163,
0.4420668781,
-0.0680501685,
-0.1401938647,
0.1858727187,
-0.1978749335,
0.5313901305,
-0.5840930939,
-0.2305669636,
-0.0259032771,
-0.3689448833,
0.103820242,
-0.0638348237,
-0.0611485727,
0.0616282634,
0.7065597773,
-0.1962083578,
0.4037995636,
0.0986220539,
-0.231431067,
-0.0064196545,
0.1719943285,
0.3106048405,
0.4974392056,
-0.3040924072,
0.3725472689,
-0.0715809464,
-0.2625617385,
-0.1767398566,
0.1803329438,
-0.4838270843,
-0.176642105,
0.2509103119,
0.2086944282,
-0.2315969616,
-1.0438201427,
0.4172382057,
0.2009324431,
0.1479052007,
-0.8262506723,
0.2004001737,
-0.1033321768,
-0.1073901579,
0.2484229952,
0.2927316129,
0.4802055955,
-0.6951307058,
0.4201397002,
0.421305418,
-0.3249641657,
-0.05776475,
0.6250901222,
0.4853154421,
-1.0127600431,
0.7188403606,
-0.6191615462,
-0.4862036705,
0.7296242714,
1.1600186825,
0.7534124851,
0.0546042994,
0.2308402508,
0.4060806036,
0.3882665932,
0.1665433794,
0.5077323914,
-0.0359960012,
-0.8484416604,
-0.4402782023,
-0.5841397047,
-0.2327979207,
0.0344195552,
-0.6258075833,
0.2739679813,
-0.8550304174,
0.5321037769,
0.0391922258,
0.1290867478,
-0.5490990281,
0.1070345938,
0.2925744355,
1.2720035315,
-0.8675134778,
0.8260621428,
0.8568753004,
-0.4519578516,
-0.8111596704,
0.0150165912,
0.1381715536,
-0.8393342495,
0.5115906596,
0.2931057513,
0.0282953307,
0.2683877945,
-0.7171709538,
-0.6291494966,
0.8403372169,
0.0448256508,
-0.2281451225,
-0.1379277706,
0.5643160343,
0.7174102068,
-0.4239117503,
-0.0262734275,
0.7293277383,
0.587692976,
-0.1512869745,
-0.9253408909,
0.1662490964,
-0.674661696,
0.1104054376,
0.1003876552,
-0.3261318207,
0.4129882157,
0.1380408406,
-0.329623878,
-0.1058020219,
0.6859036684,
0.3557041287,
0.1703528315,
0.4153607488,
-0.0411470458,
0.3709430695,
0.1212379113,
0.9740017653,
-0.4033353031,
-0.1474420875,
1.3162487745,
-0.2498699576,
1.1939569712,
0.7960121036,
-0.4615737498,
0.439729929,
0.165423125,
0.13376683,
0.3143893182,
0.5874896646,
-0.3281290829,
-0.1897250712,
-0.2505087852,
-0.0214233398,
0.3801148236,
0.4260750711,
-0.1433614045,
-0.2402300835,
-0.1597235501,
-0.017118765,
0.8303024173,
-0.1759990305,
0.588096261,
0.0692219213,
-0.8104229569,
0.3833382726,
0.3594485521,
0.5169808865,
-0.6658295393,
-0.2617224157,
-0.1466026157,
0.0163271464,
-0.3479270041,
-0.9872352481,
0.9602070451,
0.0374701098,
-0.097903721,
-0.6487869024,
0.6264243126,
-0.5277937651,
-0.5611361861,
0.0519100688,
0.3821803629,
0.304177165,
0.0621235631,
-0.8367674351,
-0.1799494624,
0.4236378074,
-0.0363207385,
-0.084542267,
0.0857660025,
-0.1568795741,
0.8542734981,
0.6182249188,
0.1871056557,
0.0683668852,
-0.1345792711,
0.6906788349,
-0.5121631026,
-0.6823185086,
-0.5045796037,
0.4912985563,
-0.5128521323,
-0.2010627389,
0.6077103019,
0.7885974646,
0.6861068606,
-0.2531756163,
0.8942406178,
-0.5002731085,
0.4097926617,
-0.5467829108,
0.348221451,
-0.0936203822,
0.297501415,
0.2568196058,
-0.6778137684,
-0.5132406354,
0.6861667037,
-0.3612912297,
-0.4817560315,
0.9228893518,
0.7718570232,
-0.0403969064,
-0.1695976853,
0.0262310524,
0.1512707472,
0.5569770932,
0.7926796675,
0.2085084915,
-0.260936588,
0.7562460303,
-0.3435774148,
-0.2580444515,
-0.0387381539,
-0.8224090934,
-0.7335929871,
-0.4313357174,
-0.4993026555,
-0.4829945862,
0.0233392417,
1.3728018999,
0.2836864293,
-1.2030255795,
-0.4095269144,
-0.5159199238,
-0.1489551663,
-0.5086858273,
-0.2410257608,
0.4210449755,
-0.3648979962,
-0.7577248216,
0.5657556653,
0.3025968373,
-0.1915920228,
-0.2276949883,
0.0312874019,
-0.3845086694,
0.2713624835,
0.6589481235,
0.5482870936,
-0.4887787402,
-0.5074630976,
-0.0884263813,
-0.1057106033,
-0.0951922312,
0.8576764464,
-0.6289812922,
0.371006161,
0.6040533185,
0.781667769,
0.1612767279,
0.1114446893,
0.9146130681,
-0.9744259715,
0.2588094473,
0.4921189845,
0.0475398414,
0.0989034772,
-0.1453608572,
0.5649968982,
0.0049408516,
-0.3564249873,
-0.6852886677,
0.8450937867,
-1.2354586124,
-0.33221668,
1.3305687904,
0.1533887684,
-0.1204730123,
-0.3185462058,
-0.4972495735,
0.2686455548,
-0.1693503857,
0.760412097,
0.2433137,
-0.2739887834,
-0.0061246236,
-0.6686966419,
0.7741541862,
0.2711648941,
-1.1488059759,
0.0136016877,
0.6129989028,
-0.1165937707,
0.3594624102,
0.5644481778,
-0.0351714604,
0.1291002035,
0.0089529436,
0.1639675349,
-0.237432763,
0.0382389091,
-0.0064755473,
0.2020396888,
0.1408806443,
-0.1396316886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10804v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10804v1
|
A Study on Altering the Latent Space of Pretrained Text to Speech Models for Improved Expressiveness
| 2023-11-17T13:07:00 | 2023-11-17T13:07:00 |
Mathias Vogel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This report explores the challenge of enhancing expressiveness control in
Text-to-Speech (TTS) models by augmenting a frozen pretrained model with a
Diffusion Model that is conditioned on joint semantic audio/text embeddings.
The paper identifies the challenges encountered when working with a VAE-based
TTS model and evaluates different image-to-image methods for altering latent
speech features. Our results offer valuable insights into the complexities of
adding expressiveness control to TTS systems and open avenues for future
research in this direction.
|
[
-0.2184769362,
-0.6808601618,
0.5060424209,
0.1086096689,
-0.2645232975,
0.0955512524,
-0.1723841727,
-0.4378544092,
0.2931251526,
0.4679721296,
-0.3937862515,
-0.244545728,
-1.1951407194,
-0.1291310191,
-0.4813767672,
0.8095020056,
-0.2807480097,
-0.1585972309,
0.0128438165,
-0.079087466,
-0.4895990193,
-0.4444225729,
-0.4128599167,
-0.1667383462,
0.402903825,
-0.046251677,
0.8991656899,
0.3027440608,
0.3179244399,
0.3485256135,
-0.419942528,
-0.2899436355,
-0.5582994819,
0.2556826174,
-0.2134135067,
-0.4241219759,
-0.7316139936,
0.1679708213,
0.6079677939,
0.5426413417,
-0.3042008579,
-0.1619433165,
-0.0276150927,
0.3071179688,
-0.7262431383,
-0.1559473723,
-0.572211504,
-0.1506093591,
-0.2520844638,
-0.2223390639,
-0.5074081421,
-0.071393691,
0.7865059376,
-0.8534350991,
-0.0455212295,
-0.629958868,
0.8781501651,
0.4912831187,
-0.6029825807,
-0.0286128726,
-1.1487865448,
0.5488692522,
-0.5046264529,
0.6426888108,
0.2990533412,
0.2207430601,
0.1788699925,
-1.1341315508,
-0.3349918425,
-0.0405284278,
0.0225025862,
0.2038970888,
-0.5012003183,
0.022982575,
0.1780292392,
0.0786235034,
-0.1083632335,
0.2154482305,
-0.0828250051,
-0.0944205225,
0.4502670467,
-0.1288259178,
0.4549167752,
0.2260508984,
-0.0131087592,
-0.1342452019,
-0.5122966766,
0.0348900594,
0.2271272838,
0.1803955734,
-0.2805013359,
0.7050099969,
0.0020892958,
0.6222630739,
0.1054626554,
0.2940723002,
0.3688858151,
0.0301781204,
-0.3585892916,
-0.2693474591,
0.3954466581,
0.2274878174,
-0.155116111,
-0.2289789915,
-0.4483843446,
0.1021690071,
0.2789463103,
-0.6969586611,
0.1285147667,
0.0729954615,
-0.4154566228,
-0.225534156,
-0.0193008315,
-0.3182893097,
-0.2313241512,
-0.5768793225,
0.6222528815,
-0.547033906,
-0.7213668823,
-0.1432022899,
-0.4678353965,
0.1994803995,
0.7233104706,
-0.9089800715,
0.3701699078,
0.3521620929,
0.8442589045,
-0.1262150854,
-0.0160113387,
-0.4520435631,
0.2396988869,
-0.4957690537,
0.7893476486,
-0.8161222339,
-0.5237857699,
-0.0995964333,
-0.1788186878,
-0.1450092196,
-0.5747892857,
0.1929594874,
-0.6503158212,
0.3622087836,
0.0384610221,
-0.6319941878,
0.1286305338,
-0.2933246493,
-0.7242833376,
0.9012671113,
0.5038843155,
-0.6131286025,
0.245763123,
-0.779989779,
-0.2743704915,
-0.0390335098,
-0.1730656028,
-0.4280983508,
0.5469475389,
0.0151141761,
0.298089236,
0.1300228089,
0.3972317278,
-0.0605564602,
-0.368717432,
0.3228650987,
-0.4757010043,
0.5053081512,
0.2637043893,
-0.3197810054,
0.3206542134,
-0.703910172,
0.0317731276,
0.0139465518,
-0.1025367379,
-0.322905302,
-0.0107692191,
0.2753600776,
0.0714422166,
0.1441090703,
-0.2108411193,
0.1172670126,
-0.6985141039,
0.4351637661,
0.6420366764,
-0.185533464,
0.7238525748,
-0.3203576505,
0.7565768361,
0.0269809309,
-0.1369371861,
-0.2738601565,
-0.3479013741,
-0.4166375697,
-0.2762823701,
0.4795313478,
0.7674544454,
-0.9690034986,
0.3994006515,
-0.2188332826,
-0.5149624944,
-0.7839217186,
-0.2054120302,
0.3010303378,
0.2555169761,
0.3507723212,
-0.443215996,
-0.0696439967,
-0.8159658909,
-0.2550039589,
0.2237454355,
-0.2972074151,
0.1947029829,
0.2198154032,
0.0422708578,
0.9720265269,
-0.1648102403,
-0.1334418058,
0.2623904645,
0.3215454221,
-0.3441073895,
0.7760815024,
0.7599461079,
-0.9628552198,
-0.5343390703,
-0.1752650738,
-0.2827472389,
-0.3822463751,
0.103533335,
0.1943248957,
0.0561476536,
0.8963840604,
-0.6777095795,
1.0728453398,
0.5372152925,
-0.6305598021,
0.5401072502,
-0.1542932242,
0.5213010311,
-0.8233476281,
0.0137337288,
-0.0307791699,
-0.3794345558,
-0.7315424085,
-0.0168407392,
-0.1700103581,
-0.3156441152,
-0.7128202319,
0.5014427304,
-0.5080571175,
-0.0147096347,
-0.517460525,
0.1905441284,
-0.0814035982,
0.1545695812,
0.2541774511,
1.0200618505,
0.8817916512,
-0.5004891157,
0.1332646608,
0.2577039003,
-0.1817694306,
0.7365193367,
-0.7770798802,
0.3460621238,
-0.3082437217,
0.3184207678,
-0.9069381952,
-0.0573833771,
0.0880176276,
-0.5959268808,
0.7275978327,
-0.1834201813,
-0.2381708771,
0.2500801086,
0.0215216018,
0.4449404776,
0.6892592907,
-0.2986170948,
1.1227935553,
0.1756505221,
-0.5272875428,
-0.4445982277,
-0.6307066679,
0.2208050042,
-0.3608134389,
-0.6201540828,
1.0542718172,
-0.1012354046,
-0.2569065988,
0.1092001796,
0.2499459684,
-0.203949064,
0.1897494942,
0.0334929377,
0.0774268284,
-0.1973955035,
0.3961060643,
0.5632996559,
-0.168657437,
-0.1414877623,
-0.1299789995,
0.2857337594,
0.3050511181,
-0.0866697431,
-1.1630419493,
0.5524969697,
0.454627037,
-0.1856008172,
0.6182227731,
0.4684371948,
-0.3249117434,
0.1277859211,
-0.307092607,
-0.1872532368,
-0.5075960159,
0.4911762178,
-0.599924624,
-1.1054952145,
0.4273378849,
-0.5094476938,
-0.2678276002,
0.5334434509,
0.5444557071,
-0.2132444978,
0.959608376,
1.0280089378,
0.4089054167,
1.1522672176,
-0.1687553376,
-0.2753220201,
-0.8831812739,
-0.1223043874,
-0.7283143997,
-0.144978255,
-0.6651768684,
-0.7130120993,
0.0722109973,
-0.1394635439,
-0.1075331345,
0.0396904163,
-0.5050723553,
0.2430841029,
-0.05469485,
0.3396560848,
-0.1013035104,
-0.1490605623,
-0.0166603066,
-0.3456998467,
-0.4518976212,
-0.5903555751,
0.9373918772,
0.5211319923,
0.6130577326,
0.4683931172,
0.3937350512,
0.1096079499,
0.4675877988,
-0.659473002,
0.1429921091,
-0.4891189933,
-0.4421144128,
-0.4440267086,
-0.1717866063,
-0.8228334785,
0.1484422535,
-0.4673675299,
-1.2005375624,
0.2018712908,
0.4373597801,
-0.1320040524,
0.0736577213,
-1.0051199198,
0.7289324999,
0.0673947409,
-0.5568911433,
-0.2452735305,
-0.6052243114,
-0.0962139443,
0.0380619057,
0.1186273322,
0.0659255013,
-0.2909663618,
0.8965314031,
-0.6645742059,
0.8990188241,
-0.4401099384,
-0.4130961895,
0.1697277427,
0.0261489246,
0.4738913476,
-0.2274353206,
-0.2005787194,
-0.1353374422,
-0.0416928604,
-0.549951911,
-1.0446734428,
0.3353298903,
-0.7025914788,
-0.8202587366,
-0.1582779288,
-0.358997196,
-0.5062476993,
0.119670473,
0.5234962702,
0.4681789875,
-0.5175142884,
0.1731034517,
0.8808842897,
-0.3458205163,
0.3209352195,
0.2241602391,
-0.3351779282,
-0.2139671147,
0.510057807,
0.0593191907,
0.7083404064,
0.4016696215,
0.2236599326,
-0.4116218984,
-0.7198033929,
-0.2049021125,
0.0652108118,
-0.5790228844,
0.2764623761,
-0.5353295803,
-0.2576366365,
-0.7456151247,
-0.1750876755,
-0.6757229567,
-0.6684088111,
-1.1457159519,
0.1081879288,
0.4639120996,
0.826913774,
0.0682260096,
1.0971016884,
-0.5631821752,
0.2517985106,
0.1718045175,
0.7023575902,
-0.0670382977,
-1.2082266808,
-0.0857629254,
-0.1267624795,
-0.3263328373,
-0.9219841957,
0.2486115992,
0.165636465,
0.3248717487,
0.1395740956,
-0.4089047909,
0.5856792331,
-0.6257450581,
0.8171333075,
0.4930017889,
-1.3484312296,
0.7050905824,
-0.4290041924,
0.3823481798,
0.1194261983,
0.2983240783,
-0.1266322732,
-0.5317249298,
-0.9162223935,
-0.7507240176,
0.4355659485,
0.4484224319,
0.5252144933,
0.6542080641,
0.6385017633,
0.0088000614,
0.1487551481,
-0.6128009558,
-0.1456303596,
-0.4076424837,
-0.2744277418,
-0.173315078,
-0.3410518467,
-0.0193152558,
-0.271023035,
0.6328599453,
0.1629101783,
0.3063036203,
0.2817758024,
0.135648787,
-0.0386390835,
0.4916523099,
0.5926619768,
0.57079041,
-0.1852809489,
-0.1467067897,
-0.1008164659,
-0.5083373189,
0.184737131,
0.2497066706,
-0.1544339359,
-0.0065771304,
0.3452399075,
1.4754562378,
-0.1612242907,
-0.3134469986,
0.6420664191,
-0.2771646976,
-0.2858816087,
-0.0961617604,
0.0778804645,
-0.0612596981,
0.1013792157,
0.3474420905,
0.2726318836,
0.0360228829,
-0.2108450383,
0.1304391921,
0.4720109403,
-0.7437317967,
-0.4594404995,
0.8506105542,
0.1903928816,
-0.5101973414,
0.2473134845,
0.1256860495,
-0.363119781,
0.473651588,
0.5876237154,
0.8909627199,
-0.6970408559,
0.1339129061,
-0.0931103155,
0.3513247669,
0.1732266545,
0.2646309137,
0.086708419,
-0.8021635413,
-0.6308197379,
0.0055655907,
-0.2936709523,
0.1574754566,
-0.5937438011,
0.54749614,
-0.2896253467,
-0.7246252298,
0.3067212999,
-0.6460641026,
-0.624733448,
0.637549758,
-0.0694445819,
0.6955673695,
-0.8598247766,
0.7528558969,
0.6486248374,
-0.0263771024,
-0.9008128643,
-0.007238552,
-0.1558164954,
-0.2852686942,
0.6981765032,
-0.1289761513,
-0.3180167973,
0.2579106092,
-0.7630656362,
-0.9120618105,
0.8279064894,
0.5988325477,
-0.441703558,
0.0316051617,
-0.2867106795,
0.7213076949,
-0.4335360229,
0.4290723801,
0.5161435008,
0.271710217,
0.2286332995,
-1.1574474573,
-0.1461621523,
-0.35245502,
0.2535989583,
0.049342595,
-0.4188448489,
0.7091278434,
-0.136016652,
-0.3254334629,
0.1794250757,
0.8900926113,
0.0119791366,
0.2993208468,
0.7339997888,
0.7134628296,
0.5486213565,
-0.1056547761,
0.8581055403,
0.3142885268,
0.0571401231,
1.2843910456,
-0.3095730543,
0.8749440908,
0.6433752179,
-0.039624963,
0.6890638471,
0.5033525825,
0.3486241102,
0.6196146607,
0.2224281579,
-0.448412329,
0.0708574876,
-0.3248728812,
-0.3581719995,
0.7616672516,
0.6937767863,
-0.3540817499,
0.1444347948,
0.4809319079,
-0.1867936254,
0.3972518146,
0.0000240002,
0.8200252056,
-0.1635778099,
-0.4196942151,
0.4876345694,
-0.0683590248,
0.7202143669,
-0.4510304034,
-0.1139292344,
0.3276897967,
-0.4509111643,
-0.2571626902,
-0.561455071,
0.4955788255,
0.0638687536,
-0.0392455906,
-0.3633502722,
0.7942173481,
-0.2657767236,
-0.0909213722,
0.3659228683,
0.5269856453,
-0.0185276438,
0.0319858603,
-0.5952666402,
0.3296260536,
-0.1488102823,
-0.558694303,
0.138891831,
0.6849249601,
0.0347335786,
0.383010745,
0.404909879,
0.3350173533,
-0.0293925628,
0.3538425863,
0.8668549657,
-0.5360226035,
-0.8002136946,
-0.4447232187,
0.7756172419,
0.088584356,
-0.2207153291,
0.0577396713,
0.316835165,
0.55622226,
-0.1351957768,
0.9495579004,
-0.1641774029,
0.7554101944,
-0.9363432527,
0.7979909182,
-0.7324464321,
0.2235987633,
-0.5372104645,
-0.5325950384,
-0.1173813343,
0.4369319379,
-0.3026638031,
0.4190199673,
0.7471461296,
0.6663835049,
-0.021782726,
-0.1878784746,
0.4782200158,
0.2565183342,
0.3681777418,
0.3276993036,
1.1485176086,
-0.4535390139,
0.1018525288,
-0.1519374996,
-0.5730457306,
0.164111957,
-1.1329388618,
-0.4364839196,
-0.9170795083,
-0.7885751128,
-0.4406952262,
-0.1833677143,
0.4870498478,
0.8308827877,
-0.4662113786,
-0.1293298453,
0.1075863913,
-0.0812521651,
-0.0805002749,
-0.1924760491,
0.3187429011,
0.0190329012,
-0.9262545109,
0.3293724358,
0.2274892181,
0.9107168317,
0.1737419665,
0.0900135338,
-0.1618439108,
0.1395091712,
0.6737111211,
0.2039227337,
-0.6298888326,
-0.2666624188,
-0.1005311385,
0.0539888851,
0.1066156849,
1.1460317373,
-0.7289937139,
0.6474782228,
0.0610590391,
0.5795893669,
0.7623067498,
-0.0176525414,
0.5988705754,
-0.8156237006,
0.6805350184,
0.3245344162,
0.0614506863,
0.4230330884,
-0.3828893006,
0.1199695393,
0.2486277968,
-0.3632580638,
-0.6314864755,
0.2146245688,
-1.2313177586,
-0.4551829696,
0.8016363978,
-0.0812201649,
-0.1713157594,
-0.026015915,
-0.2460780293,
0.6458054185,
-0.2858129442,
0.5979465246,
0.7891948223,
-0.2266208827,
-0.3480521739,
-0.4228032231,
0.7153620124,
0.6115164757,
-0.8065117002,
0.0790225118,
0.5285516977,
0.1867240816,
0.020813344,
1.0406699181,
-0.1976712942,
0.2911785245,
-0.1643577367,
-0.0249351058,
0.2546771169,
-0.3077998459,
-0.7052353024,
-0.0317271762,
0.2135503292,
0.1452289075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10436v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10436v1
|
Sinhala-English Word Embedding Alignment: Introducing Datasets and Benchmark for a Low Resource Language
| 2023-11-17T10:14:45 | 2023-11-17T10:14:45 |
Kasun Wickramasinghe, Nisansa de Silva
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Since their inception, embeddings have become a primary ingredient in many
flavours of Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks supplanting earlier types
of representation. Even though multilingual embeddings have been used for the
increasing number of multilingual tasks, due to the scarcity of parallel
training data, low-resource languages such as Sinhala, tend to focus more on
monolingual embeddings. Then when it comes to the aforementioned multi-lingual
tasks, it is challenging to utilize these monolingual embeddings given that
even if the embedding spaces have a similar geometric arrangement due to an
identical training process, the embeddings of the languages considered are not
aligned. This is solved by the embedding alignment task. Even in this,
high-resource language pairs are in the limelight while low-resource languages
such as Sinhala which is in dire need of help seem to have fallen by the
wayside. In this paper, we try to align Sinhala and English word embedding
spaces based on available alignment techniques and introduce a benchmark for
Sinhala language embedding alignment. In addition to that, to facilitate the
supervised alignment, as an intermediate task, we also introduce
Sinhala-English alignment datasets. These datasets serve as our anchor datasets
for supervised word embedding alignment. Even though we do not obtain results
comparable to the high-resource languages such as French, German, or Chinese,
we believe our work lays the groundwork for more specialized alignment between
English and Sinhala embeddings.
|
[
-0.1100827679,
-0.5726001263,
0.102778174,
0.1233059391,
-0.2988608479,
0.2692155838,
-0.4772143066,
-0.2138451189,
0.5349924564,
0.2195840925,
-0.2859525681,
-0.2674008608,
-0.5559436679,
0.2332096994,
-0.0518372692,
0.6145803928,
-0.5186819434,
0.1293744147,
-0.4192803502,
-0.8771347404,
-1.1534024477,
-0.1925220042,
-0.5604530573,
-0.3146231771,
0.3957845569,
0.3708252609,
0.8967205286,
0.854467988,
0.5987640023,
0.2681000829,
0.0176842865,
0.3791185617,
-0.4625902176,
0.1100224182,
-0.2651883364,
-0.4606845081,
-0.2317385226,
-0.1846522391,
0.6206722856,
0.8321120739,
-0.3335841,
0.1017306298,
0.305290699,
0.4662100971,
-0.8399509192,
0.0577514805,
-0.5208234191,
0.1837980747,
-0.5793980956,
-0.275152564,
-0.0661312491,
-0.4035473168,
-0.2545491457,
-0.7276565433,
-0.0885744095,
0.4037177265,
1.0043449402,
0.8021562696,
-0.2157122046,
-0.367823571,
-0.3089465797,
1.0321987867,
-0.5374822617,
0.6678275466,
0.3312741518,
0.2882318795,
0.0550400354,
-0.1290523261,
-0.5374344587,
0.2292040288,
-0.2378940433,
-0.0342719927,
-0.0516079627,
-0.207761392,
0.0589388013,
0.3416091204,
-0.8227965832,
0.3084626496,
-0.2094528228,
-0.1770156771,
0.601221323,
0.1494325697,
0.4810566604,
-0.213179484,
-0.6397771239,
-0.1437456012,
-0.85663414,
-0.1185566112,
0.405972302,
0.6045761704,
-0.3901033401,
0.9527466297,
0.0513875373,
0.8771988153,
-0.1024127454,
-0.2895226181,
0.4447758496,
-0.4733170569,
-0.1781772226,
0.7167472839,
0.7098059058,
0.3296925724,
0.2977151573,
-0.1038465947,
0.0723762438,
0.2848525345,
0.2164859325,
-0.3842664957,
0.3501146138,
0.1875689179,
-0.2735530734,
-0.1175294146,
-0.2256132066,
-0.6236649752,
-0.2539170384,
-0.3701510131,
0.4083333313,
-0.4439126849,
-0.1799625307,
0.1543399394,
-0.0315473787,
0.5211154819,
0.024008967,
-0.8302145004,
0.3203302622,
0.9293915033,
0.9094153047,
-0.2936234772,
-0.5871133208,
-0.2742809951,
0.4196177721,
-0.4208536148,
0.5239541531,
-0.7181091905,
0.0692885593,
0.0765570924,
0.1744145453,
-0.098128818,
-0.4453457892,
0.5934444666,
-0.1750960499,
0.3625165224,
-0.4790025651,
-0.6087001562,
-0.2807398438,
0.3561362326,
-0.5977169871,
0.9911115766,
-0.0250787716,
-0.9936949015,
0.1758020967,
-0.4165402353,
-0.3320845664,
0.1911439449,
-0.4663687646,
-0.2749850154,
0.1186210439,
0.2943975031,
0.2394684404,
-0.5478181243,
0.1464381218,
-0.2439385802,
-0.4606158435,
-0.0594842285,
-0.588963151,
1.0713826418,
0.0795323104,
-0.2891094387,
-0.4193110764,
-0.3412613273,
0.1362141967,
0.2776229084,
-0.0099103944,
-0.7237929702,
-0.1147016361,
0.1408087611,
-0.0026660548,
0.6192045212,
-0.6337305307,
0.1600251049,
-0.3338081539,
0.153236568,
0.5707476735,
-0.2640334964,
0.2928299904,
-0.2714800537,
0.6763803959,
-0.0784883797,
-0.0293193441,
0.1732866168,
-0.3938727081,
-0.3562328219,
-0.0180871561,
0.6011704206,
0.6873740554,
-0.6853145361,
0.4127869308,
-0.6017427444,
-0.4103476405,
-1.2179933786,
0.5515854955,
0.5488639474,
0.3891767263,
0.3830191493,
-0.51405406,
-0.3024942279,
-1.0203313828,
-0.3438217342,
0.1067213044,
0.5297625065,
0.2793752253,
-0.1207526624,
-0.0702781454,
0.8220615983,
-0.6701287627,
-0.5400835276,
-0.0373206176,
-0.1235572845,
0.0193868279,
0.3998064995,
0.4807891846,
-0.8910678625,
-0.6285302639,
0.1469828486,
-0.834849298,
-0.1998253316,
0.2475974709,
-0.3441973329,
0.2668858767,
0.5304558277,
-0.2010744661,
0.2361815125,
0.8998289704,
-0.1048718616,
-0.0245413613,
-0.067330949,
0.0861118138,
-1.4194514751,
0.0988728553,
-0.3025979996,
-0.2046411932,
-0.4201936722,
0.0256607588,
0.013165745,
-0.138053894,
-0.4300666153,
0.6629154682,
-0.498449415,
0.0708913952,
-0.37345469,
0.3536790609,
0.0374020711,
0.4054181278,
0.1567216665,
0.770029068,
0.4132886231,
-0.0413374566,
0.2961219847,
0.4182401896,
-0.2333370745,
0.9165483117,
-0.5462158322,
-0.01215553,
-0.1153879613,
-0.1045309007,
-0.8260522485,
-0.0376853384,
0.2218040973,
-0.0979454815,
0.573895514,
0.0645589456,
-0.301600337,
-0.030807035,
-0.3791509867,
0.9343070984,
0.2141416669,
-0.4932561219,
0.1421206594,
0.7093494534,
-0.2780436575,
-1.1905258894,
-0.8472725153,
-0.0589797981,
-0.4173036814,
-0.1951996684,
0.4486713409,
0.2554500401,
-0.0779389068,
0.5308342576,
-0.1017773598,
0.0183850955,
-0.1070193946,
0.3166736364,
0.1743071526,
-0.3449594676,
0.2597787678,
0.1278942227,
-0.2487740666,
-0.4692421854,
-0.0098190522,
0.7627208829,
0.0204940829,
-0.7456468344,
-0.2836672664,
0.4540300369,
0.3518135846,
-0.3826412261,
0.8338780999,
0.6792846918,
-0.8158451319,
0.1257434338,
-0.6869421601,
0.3273806274,
-0.4044096768,
0.2050988823,
-0.2211907059,
-0.7174651623,
0.1081677973,
-0.0650093183,
-0.0183869973,
0.6263266206,
0.5782553554,
0.0662869439,
0.716870904,
0.8542079329,
-0.450592339,
0.2265491933,
0.0225157756,
0.5024352074,
-1.0594195127,
-0.0870184377,
-0.4627053142,
-0.5854822397,
-0.9453396201,
-0.4675746262,
0.0958935991,
0.2762791216,
0.0509083048,
0.8170235157,
-0.6696028113,
0.4400164485,
0.186357975,
-0.3157667518,
0.0468591079,
0.1348986328,
-0.2288480848,
-0.2393575311,
-0.8090650439,
-0.4492355287,
0.8634470105,
0.0982951224,
0.8323745728,
0.1460781991,
0.8568131924,
-0.046325814,
-0.0068219276,
-0.8003608584,
0.1021038592,
-0.4883042276,
-0.3536927402,
-0.3502166271,
-0.1712111831,
-1.1874028444,
0.0872844905,
0.0010612336,
-0.3528595567,
0.2806505859,
-0.1562830508,
-0.2841773629,
0.2675750256,
-0.7224807143,
0.9118532538,
-0.3441567421,
-0.3322300017,
-0.2610676587,
-0.2837177217,
0.0217958894,
-0.1454675943,
0.3247689009,
-0.3071302772,
-0.2751594782,
0.7447942495,
-0.4082999527,
0.7711582184,
-0.1697264463,
-0.2242610902,
0.2133723348,
-0.2303885072,
0.0995867774,
-0.0980785415,
0.035730537,
0.2952805459,
0.2095526755,
-0.5890903473,
-0.2964037657,
0.8067448139,
-0.6450274587,
-0.3644804657,
-0.5249378681,
-0.6764434576,
-0.1794842631,
0.1988283545,
0.2929673493,
0.3419531882,
-0.2639144957,
0.1852165163,
0.1931503415,
-0.1948293746,
0.4276326299,
0.2161391824,
-0.0097792232,
-0.4599860311,
1.1562114954,
0.42026788,
-0.0761850998,
0.5965269804,
0.1467708051,
-0.4283879399,
-0.1119190529,
-0.4106716812,
0.3555109799,
-0.4282970428,
-0.4901382327,
-0.3843106031,
-0.2462779135,
-0.4029087722,
-0.405064851,
-0.5356416702,
-0.3990628123,
0.1286578774,
0.3413813412,
0.2814800441,
0.6958374381,
0.0259339269,
0.0662576035,
-0.6166042686,
0.2495790422,
0.2438852191,
0.4620601833,
-0.0636788011,
-0.2530165911,
-0.3364157379,
0.118157357,
-0.2305222601,
-0.7066050172,
0.1957433373,
0.267885685,
0.5136041045,
0.416013211,
-0.1740365326,
0.99924016,
-0.6976274252,
0.6245532632,
0.0518091209,
-0.9114015102,
0.5313951373,
0.2315159887,
0.2004030347,
0.8302896619,
0.6688904762,
-0.9020696878,
-0.2179485857,
-0.6104411483,
-0.7589656711,
0.4687125385,
0.019809274,
0.0702864602,
0.0838306397,
0.0911280587,
0.3282555342,
0.3075957596,
-0.326340884,
-0.2019388527,
-0.0141291879,
-0.649094224,
-0.4012179077,
-0.0018396174,
-0.3481835425,
-0.1379361153,
0.5105529428,
-0.1889557987,
0.1699633598,
-0.1584084034,
-0.2410040498,
-0.1994795948,
0.1433563828,
0.4537130296,
0.304056108,
-0.0660639107,
0.1872540116,
0.31164217,
-0.549675703,
0.3662485182,
0.1005997211,
0.0219163485,
0.1263402402,
0.5563101172,
0.8051885366,
0.2742518485,
-0.5524986386,
0.7484635711,
0.0057408572,
0.2746478915,
-0.2307906598,
-0.0448347442,
0.1966705322,
0.0187928621,
-0.0966234878,
-0.0781618282,
-0.2663933635,
-0.2813867629,
-0.0486139283,
0.6773329377,
-0.4199306369,
-0.1561389714,
0.532726109,
-0.1706977487,
-0.4593337774,
0.5252009034,
-0.2463446558,
-0.4554867446,
0.3136398494,
0.60261482,
0.8777053952,
-0.3788521588,
-0.0021642596,
0.3912209272,
0.4368908107,
-0.0834435076,
0.5227012038,
-0.0377874039,
-0.8695731759,
-0.4038897455,
-0.8147647381,
-0.5514869094,
-0.1844874769,
-0.8111124635,
0.613165319,
-0.1169656739,
0.1308336407,
-0.2056658268,
0.2342433929,
-0.9431894422,
0.0356132351,
0.2471988797,
0.6630252004,
-1.2186986208,
0.7677823901,
0.8707609773,
-0.2038663924,
-0.8823400736,
0.0665220097,
0.1688666493,
-1.1232309341,
0.2812890708,
0.3777861893,
-0.001362678,
-0.0019741019,
-0.1973985732,
-1.084846139,
1.196383357,
0.5181992054,
-0.5542591214,
0.092248328,
0.3832378089,
0.5629877448,
-0.3032994568,
-0.048276294,
0.2617011368,
0.5119600892,
-0.2835250199,
-0.9210706949,
0.2078002542,
-0.1947797835,
0.0201550052,
0.4618060887,
-0.7663171887,
0.4766797125,
0.3589324653,
-0.4309909046,
-0.2485240102,
0.4159565866,
0.086439915,
0.0676340386,
0.5772777796,
1.2353023291,
0.8372161984,
-0.1979248971,
0.908131659,
-0.4459128678,
0.2248280048,
1.1314555407,
-0.3956590593,
1.1668388844,
0.7769947052,
-0.3816005886,
0.3807533383,
0.3844106793,
-0.0365477167,
0.5387084484,
-0.0112865157,
0.0525154695,
0.1301269233,
-0.7539575696,
-0.5100871325,
0.9017364979,
0.357205838,
0.1324416548,
-0.468583554,
-0.012745413,
-0.1441102624,
0.0217646807,
-0.0179622862,
0.7051460147,
0.1040716171,
-0.5919460058,
0.7479578257,
-0.0359308869,
0.9665291309,
-0.4445624053,
0.02296599,
-0.2148638219,
-0.0137663372,
-0.3020053804,
-0.7564147711,
0.6047212481,
-0.0315735415,
0.0629224256,
-0.2817432284,
0.4676317275,
-0.8250453472,
-0.387186408,
0.3778138459,
0.5852054358,
0.2076257318,
0.464674741,
-0.6519908905,
0.2127883583,
-0.158289358,
0.1172299385,
0.2615269423,
0.349709183,
-0.168553248,
0.2105607837,
0.3267564476,
0.4994101226,
0.0578840636,
0.0321578979,
0.3552986085,
-0.4140292108,
-0.2563237846,
-0.7794279456,
0.1483579278,
0.0144535964,
-0.418037504,
0.5619811416,
0.7006588578,
1.0266348124,
0.31374681,
0.4499998093,
-0.2599629462,
0.3454818726,
-0.4818886817,
0.537335813,
-1.0559563637,
-0.2047346234,
-0.0800132453,
-1.2275271416,
-0.097245805,
0.460052371,
0.0034686516,
-0.3569560051,
0.8068162799,
0.8332817554,
-0.3366121054,
-0.0712755546,
0.1089976728,
-0.0968551114,
-0.0559780858,
0.5488285422,
0.3489016593,
-0.6514800191,
0.2224999517,
-0.6205306053,
-0.0429890603,
-0.0062711295,
-0.9745188355,
-0.4403139055,
-0.9346209168,
-0.4460152686,
0.0415735617,
-0.1684862673,
1.0471966267,
0.2069078386,
-0.9502145648,
-0.3537192047,
0.1415716261,
0.2610169649,
-0.4831157029,
-0.2155192494,
0.7279670835,
-0.4379999936,
-1.0166186094,
0.3634619415,
0.530520618,
0.0259428937,
-0.2444922775,
0.0255585089,
-0.5392954946,
-0.1621850431,
0.1786274314,
0.411657691,
-0.7192461491,
-0.2184094489,
-0.1802514195,
-0.5033162832,
0.1318503916,
0.4185217917,
-0.4912449121,
0.4780683517,
0.6724325418,
1.1647348404,
-0.076948747,
-0.078357026,
0.5185285807,
-1.0624673367,
0.4073081315,
0.0517022498,
0.505572319,
0.6673152447,
-0.3269282877,
0.7417944074,
0.0313119926,
-0.3595534265,
-1.1068118811,
-0.1117221415,
-0.868632853,
0.0485319346,
0.8548250794,
0.1311473399,
-0.3689291179,
0.1677364856,
-0.0821283311,
0.5059515238,
0.2786167562,
0.6904988289,
1.0827502012,
0.058601737,
0.1941873878,
-0.4685836732,
0.4184822142,
0.9449936152,
-0.6501623392,
0.0044447663,
-0.1439050138,
0.0827360824,
0.5579100251,
0.4765013456,
-0.1883795857,
0.0425993688,
-0.000224187,
0.1073215231,
0.1835095286,
-0.1686481982,
-0.6787046194,
0.2080960721,
0.0374479443,
-0.5072045326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10431v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10431v1
|
Causal Graph in Language Model Rediscovers Cortical Hierarchy in Human Narrative Processing
| 2023-11-17T10:09:12 | 2023-11-17T10:09:12 |
Zhengqi He, Taro Toyoizumi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Understanding how humans process natural language has long been a vital
research direction. The field of natural language processing (NLP) has recently
experienced a surge in the development of powerful language models. These
models have proven to be invaluable tools for studying another complex system
known to process human language: the brain. Previous studies have demonstrated
that the features of language models can be mapped to fMRI brain activity. This
raises the question: is there a commonality between information processing in
language models and the human brain? To estimate information flow patterns in a
language model, we examined the causal relationships between different layers.
Drawing inspiration from the workspace framework for consciousness, we
hypothesized that features integrating more information would more accurately
predict higher hierarchical brain activity. To validate this hypothesis, we
classified language model features into two categories based on causal network
measures: 'low in-degree' and 'high in-degree'. We subsequently compared the
brain prediction accuracy maps for these two groups. Our results reveal that
the difference in prediction accuracy follows a hierarchical pattern,
consistent with the cortical hierarchy map revealed by activity time constants.
This finding suggests a parallel between how language models and the human
brain process linguistic information.
|
[
-0.0938205943,
-0.9407407045,
0.5931288004,
0.4020222723,
0.1458645165,
-0.0980487168,
-0.1033411324,
-0.9153611064,
0.1006046385,
0.5923862457,
-0.2767010331,
-0.4918355644,
-0.6003620625,
-0.1409900635,
-0.2865347862,
0.5756477118,
0.0610229261,
0.031540148,
-0.4828410447,
-0.1956533194,
-0.7857838869,
-0.6887979507,
-0.9684923887,
-0.940831244,
0.7554501891,
-0.2025072724,
0.8666125536,
0.9252979159,
0.5400910974,
0.299693644,
-0.1775734574,
-0.2433902621,
-0.268238306,
0.1571881175,
-0.113741979,
-0.3803837001,
-0.6819648147,
-0.1619482487,
0.427510649,
1.3611838818,
-0.1766764671,
0.0613550693,
0.3284655213,
0.6795723438,
-0.3697473705,
0.5265662074,
0.002489696,
-0.0728351399,
-0.1974380612,
-0.4913401604,
-0.623223722,
-0.1717326194,
0.2239207625,
-0.4174503088,
0.1897580624,
0.2215416729,
0.7794046998,
0.2001992315,
-0.568310082,
-0.1353586018,
-0.7979642749,
0.3327184618,
-0.6074429154,
0.3854447603,
0.6154524088,
0.1241978556,
-0.2285738438,
-0.6082344055,
-0.3313888311,
-0.260166049,
-0.4850370884,
-0.0787297562,
-0.5726333857,
0.2123211324,
0.3368840814,
-0.1048261449,
-0.6303479671,
0.3173033297,
-0.2534309626,
-0.3062400818,
0.3857607841,
0.3996838927,
0.4593645036,
-0.1967536807,
-0.274928987,
0.0195429996,
-0.4843767285,
0.2720084786,
0.1004850492,
0.390004456,
-0.3158271611,
0.412950933,
-0.1409495175,
1.1109027863,
-0.1841122061,
-0.1991820782,
0.0597198941,
-0.1448565423,
-0.2487214655,
0.1627787799,
0.723757267,
0.2840808332,
0.2020077854,
-0.4856485426,
0.1446565986,
0.2931376696,
0.1719161868,
-0.6369739771,
-0.3104838431,
-0.0118005509,
-0.3088335693,
-0.0132417064,
-0.1925990582,
-0.2207958996,
-0.6071115136,
-0.4792225361,
0.0424141176,
-0.3480693698,
-0.4513243437,
0.2571492195,
-0.1254309118,
-0.1661915034,
0.3185731769,
-0.7783507109,
0.5617288947,
0.7085567117,
0.8995156288,
-0.2185847312,
-0.5191087723,
-0.2270483822,
0.30734694,
-0.3839903176,
0.7977954745,
-0.5330765247,
0.3080578148,
-0.0560288876,
-0.1549761444,
-0.4385493994,
-0.4527359605,
0.50669384,
-0.7828169465,
0.0288818199,
-0.3197568059,
-0.5229953527,
-0.5517306328,
0.0052763019,
-0.7199028134,
0.6902654171,
-0.0873893499,
-0.9582200646,
0.2860223651,
-0.6135100126,
-0.5795224309,
0.0016587341,
-0.2185081989,
-0.0858121142,
0.0058823153,
-0.0954490826,
0.5087469816,
-0.6148666739,
0.7163718939,
-0.3306631148,
-0.2894536257,
0.3290476203,
-0.2492230982,
0.9895086288,
-0.0268152636,
-0.3235957623,
0.0423108675,
-0.7336072922,
-0.1116290987,
-0.0479570813,
-0.2544385195,
-0.6029329896,
0.3130417466,
-0.105032891,
0.392018348,
0.130158186,
-0.3683770597,
-0.1257061213,
-0.1684806347,
0.4143041968,
0.438082695,
0.1268543154,
0.493272543,
-0.2377560288,
0.1157315224,
0.3271349967,
-0.1775133163,
0.1557863355,
-0.7688036561,
-0.496383369,
-0.1812742501,
-0.0437058806,
0.4412629008,
-0.1437634975,
0.6545775533,
-0.4383977354,
-0.4034125805,
-0.1942283958,
-0.3137718141,
0.2856252491,
0.8251144886,
0.4168536365,
-0.4159732461,
-0.3899819851,
-0.8250055313,
-0.3727938235,
-0.5558292866,
-0.0533347279,
0.2090149671,
0.1456042826,
-0.2878078222,
0.9854562879,
-0.6091482043,
-0.3214989305,
-0.1251606345,
0.7247196436,
0.3733634353,
0.4180133045,
0.4699546397,
-0.5753667355,
-0.1104977205,
0.1063522696,
-0.9858019352,
-0.3393312097,
-0.0489724837,
-0.3034189045,
0.1147152111,
0.6817020178,
-0.4228120148,
0.3516584933,
0.4795932174,
-0.8014317155,
0.0203959811,
-0.1848356426,
0.2032544017,
-0.7780245543,
0.2503908873,
-0.0418926515,
0.0392069593,
-0.7292537093,
-0.276894033,
0.0604717433,
0.1308074892,
0.1607286036,
0.3035450578,
-0.3697936237,
-0.2541488409,
-0.1443817019,
0.0974500626,
-0.0786288977,
0.8864884973,
0.0886618271,
0.1219107732,
0.7236440182,
-0.5345164537,
0.0107740667,
-0.0843423605,
-0.3771231472,
0.3044250906,
-0.5945977569,
0.0526426472,
-0.299243927,
0.0962309241,
-1.2385584116,
-0.2936568856,
-0.1106374189,
-0.3558176756,
0.2735809982,
0.1133297682,
-0.6151183248,
0.0158840343,
0.2636380196,
0.3090035617,
0.3863382041,
-0.148164019,
0.4621798694,
0.6978650093,
-0.0756513178,
-0.4605794549,
-0.8704895377,
0.0597804673,
0.1095984206,
-0.9805929065,
0.4023256898,
0.1450038701,
-0.2463330328,
0.0680113211,
0.0602002218,
-0.4505937696,
0.2516520321,
0.6663578153,
0.1844802052,
-0.4003750384,
-0.0006375837,
-0.0880754516,
0.0113504911,
0.3946111798,
-0.0163301043,
0.627363503,
0.0624354407,
-0.1288787425,
-0.5807298422,
0.0712450743,
0.7567363381,
0.1105975509,
0.865431726,
0.4190832675,
-0.6687785983,
0.3407405019,
-0.2359216511,
-0.0015792991,
-0.3218022585,
0.4230335355,
-0.2612618804,
-0.8580234647,
0.7460640669,
0.0439281613,
-0.2282757908,
0.4534063637,
0.3250001967,
-0.152172491,
1.2084679604,
0.7955089808,
-0.1364658326,
0.4584174752,
-0.1640957296,
0.2649286687,
-0.8446041942,
-0.254291147,
-0.6396368742,
-0.3458574116,
-0.5101964474,
-0.0841889307,
0.1722857207,
0.2723243535,
-0.2901636064,
0.4052805901,
-0.1452228278,
0.4434298277,
0.1319681257,
-0.1110418439,
0.4387672246,
0.1322554499,
-0.3852945268,
-0.0761419609,
-0.8679643273,
-0.3425719142,
0.5557595491,
0.3162685037,
0.6084775329,
0.009465416,
0.290361464,
0.2191577852,
0.5517164469,
-0.4255594611,
0.5448869467,
-0.0509440005,
-0.5819247961,
-0.4226659536,
-0.3675529063,
-1.0346437693,
0.2800944746,
-0.1556920409,
-0.9405503869,
0.30583933,
-0.0506943353,
-0.3640852273,
0.1473792642,
-0.8867032528,
0.9938268661,
0.215440467,
-0.4734229445,
-0.3373568356,
-0.6878399253,
0.209878251,
0.1052127779,
0.2694902718,
-0.1311858445,
0.1954675466,
0.8286093473,
-0.186674282,
1.1086368561,
0.008403888,
0.0236717332,
0.0987048596,
0.3404275477,
0.2040496469,
-0.2569812536,
-0.1140552163,
0.5738646984,
-0.2893247306,
-0.2570756972,
-0.5015039444,
0.7268857956,
-0.9774988294,
-0.3966364563,
-0.4966702759,
-0.7052965164,
-0.0312476158,
0.2545705736,
0.2692603767,
0.6176761389,
-0.2853783667,
0.0935656354,
0.1769818068,
0.0921862423,
0.5233632922,
0.4151568413,
-0.1582517624,
-0.033467982,
0.4343916774,
0.400372684,
0.1897968799,
0.6960831881,
0.2220847905,
-0.1626187414,
-0.5746574402,
-0.1211836711,
0.3301830888,
-0.6635605693,
-0.0063512577,
-0.8204470277,
-0.2955065668,
-0.3820613623,
-0.1529598832,
0.0173972212,
-0.2851487398,
-0.0142150912,
-0.0304547083,
0.0112095242,
0.8239540458,
0.0983338878,
0.1185533553,
-0.6350839734,
0.2822482884,
0.2373693287,
0.2010513842,
0.3356657028,
-0.4009481072,
-0.4773342311,
0.1161657646,
-0.2107037604,
-0.7764303684,
0.3862997591,
0.1413130015,
0.3950914443,
0.260771066,
-0.2086922228,
0.8037320971,
-0.5085068941,
0.6638236642,
0.2825165391,
-0.6972693801,
0.2103375047,
-0.4232483506,
0.5023047924,
0.1896964014,
0.4539443254,
-0.7652030587,
-0.7552654147,
-0.5997611284,
-0.6048700809,
0.752566278,
0.2783186138,
-0.2808348835,
-0.0720540807,
0.1416426003,
-0.1269182116,
-0.0029010379,
-0.6785481572,
-0.0978633687,
0.3145851493,
0.0517766923,
-0.1667932421,
0.0041983784,
-0.172798872,
-0.3942309916,
0.0451305285,
-0.014937683,
0.3827527761,
0.184900254,
-0.141372636,
-0.5944707394,
0.0354944319,
0.4929815829,
0.8081811666,
-0.417853564,
0.4420173466,
-0.1706904471,
-0.6112810969,
-0.0616563447,
-0.1265428364,
-0.0306766033,
-0.050186526,
0.9209167361,
0.915379405,
0.354590565,
-0.126325205,
0.4715089798,
-0.1171445847,
0.0606029555,
-0.1611751467,
0.1505756825,
0.4863732755,
0.3564950824,
0.1537886262,
0.8190304637,
0.1985713243,
-0.5495172739,
0.0239685737,
0.0208742134,
-0.437623471,
-0.6013271809,
0.6592808366,
-0.0353411771,
-0.4002935886,
0.7387292981,
-0.0065681627,
-0.1562490761,
0.72251302,
0.8141863942,
1.093213439,
0.0672629103,
0.110293746,
0.6454940438,
0.2489910424,
-0.1263949126,
0.1010109559,
-0.0074955686,
-0.9449118972,
-0.5871253014,
-0.6154967546,
-0.058992561,
-0.0216390137,
-0.6552959085,
0.1026532799,
-0.2452003658,
-0.2930884361,
0.4737461805,
-0.3239098489,
-0.6068742275,
0.1186608672,
0.3029014766,
0.5292320848,
-1.0214580297,
1.1096189022,
0.5217711926,
-0.3098249137,
-0.7722928524,
0.041209545,
-0.2666158974,
-0.4331770837,
1.0338851213,
0.1975901872,
-0.4521098733,
-0.0253991522,
-0.3151097894,
-0.9216372371,
1.1648132801,
0.5901123285,
-0.2483211905,
-0.2176085114,
0.1439389139,
0.9674348831,
-0.5706207752,
0.0972031355,
0.4603970647,
0.2230342478,
0.1175595596,
-0.5613981485,
0.2560763359,
-0.2167332619,
0.0646673143,
0.3310371339,
-0.1259433627,
0.9062142372,
-0.2258199304,
-0.5533789396,
-0.300262928,
0.5338299274,
0.1398866177,
0.3087697029,
0.4546206892,
0.4641977251,
0.7969169021,
-0.1067826375,
1.238466382,
-0.4215098321,
0.1644100696,
0.989926517,
-0.1966729462,
0.868691802,
0.3302100301,
-0.0621749125,
0.8592150807,
0.5194109082,
0.5471365452,
0.4221272469,
0.0012397579,
0.1386381388,
-0.232896015,
-0.1753224432,
0.0093007898,
0.2715426385,
0.25718081,
-0.3291786909,
-0.1243164167,
-0.2349746823,
0.2412706017,
-0.0671345368,
-0.1810337752,
0.6612637043,
0.0549970679,
-1.0046607256,
0.7724123001,
-0.0112475343,
0.3103307486,
-0.536401391,
-0.0425192788,
-0.0568448715,
0.0334701575,
-0.2391682863,
-0.7811776996,
0.4540697932,
-0.0902133286,
-0.2524316907,
-0.3912138641,
0.6837775707,
-0.5237503648,
-0.0318666995,
0.7398932576,
0.5071070194,
0.0182562489,
0.043518804,
-0.5197930932,
-0.2143783867,
-0.2526981533,
-0.1296636313,
0.3097416162,
0.4096576869,
-0.399390161,
0.3540699184,
0.5569221973,
0.2111649811,
0.1125099435,
0.3452593982,
0.5609312057,
-0.825958848,
-0.7740013599,
-1.0117313862,
0.4159183502,
-0.2024868578,
-0.4039789736,
0.469488591,
0.4046638012,
0.6771828532,
0.0424041934,
0.3586953878,
-0.1323499829,
0.125450179,
-0.4712194502,
0.7854475379,
-0.3065598905,
0.0847769156,
-0.3370683193,
-0.7905086875,
-0.6172266006,
0.4465373158,
-0.3083359003,
-0.2533002794,
1.2424869537,
0.7706232071,
0.0421191789,
0.1731463373,
0.3554114699,
0.4988324642,
0.0838121474,
0.5986413956,
0.7289073467,
-0.2671235502,
-0.0496238247,
-0.2486777455,
-0.3151288629,
-0.1734912097,
-0.7959711552,
-0.8421725631,
-0.9169062972,
-0.4078608155,
-0.1911886632,
-0.2757362127,
0.5696752667,
0.6794868112,
-0.5070279241,
-0.8704640865,
-0.3568201363,
0.2877748609,
-0.6895917654,
-0.2012668699,
0.4236626625,
-0.2840084136,
-0.3350904286,
0.1745834649,
0.6303589344,
-0.1711953729,
-0.0369190313,
-0.0460905582,
-0.3843846321,
0.1066228226,
0.6033647656,
0.0530910715,
-0.5525192022,
-0.3452817798,
0.1207723096,
-0.6680953503,
0.1830832958,
1.1935924292,
-0.5311017036,
0.3811971545,
0.9221965671,
0.3550339937,
0.4979815185,
-0.4545151889,
0.5737923384,
-0.7050514221,
0.2323797345,
0.1523281038,
0.4339984059,
0.4541504979,
-0.4078949988,
0.5741272569,
0.3249952197,
-0.4616318941,
-0.7271143794,
0.2489995956,
-1.0871540308,
-0.2065925896,
0.8742117286,
0.0453845672,
-0.587189436,
-0.4145483077,
-0.0980999395,
0.4914183617,
-0.1375181228,
0.8320780396,
0.8478325605,
-0.7029700875,
0.2000069171,
-0.5510154366,
0.4448342323,
0.1030315161,
-0.654504478,
0.2465719134,
0.5652299523,
-0.1096128523,
0.6066658497,
0.8305649757,
-0.0830937997,
0.1746436208,
-0.0206633601,
-0.0481839776,
0.2029719502,
-0.440058738,
-0.1728771776,
0.50616467,
0.0412585139,
0.1216212064
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10395v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10395v2
|
Bias A-head? Analyzing Bias in Transformer-Based Language Model Attention Heads
| 2023-11-17T08:56:13 | 2024-06-16T03:33:03 |
Yi Yang, Hanyu Duan, Ahmed Abbasi, John P. Lalor, Kar Yan Tam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Transformer-based pretrained large language models (PLM) such as BERT and GPT
have achieved remarkable success in NLP tasks. However, PLMs are prone to
encoding stereotypical biases. Although a burgeoning literature has emerged on
stereotypical bias mitigation in PLMs, such as work on debiasing gender and
racial stereotyping, how such biases manifest and behave internally within PLMs
remains largely unknown. Understanding the internal stereotyping mechanisms may
allow better assessment of model fairness and guide the development of
effective mitigation strategies. In this work, we focus on attention heads, a
major component of the Transformer architecture, and propose a bias analysis
framework to explore and identify a small set of biased heads that are found to
contribute to a PLM's stereotypical bias. We conduct extensive experiments to
validate the existence of these biased heads and to better understand how they
behave. We investigate gender and racial bias in the English language in two
types of Transformer-based PLMs: the encoder-based BERT model and the
decoder-based autoregressive GPT model. Overall, the results shed light on
understanding the bias behavior in pretrained language models.
|
[
-0.6593468189,
-0.6174323559,
0.3419273794,
0.2757546604,
0.0193274394,
-0.1684904397,
-0.2499810904,
-0.2921748459,
0.1104858592,
0.5917555094,
-0.6800640821,
-0.051226683,
-0.7647855878,
0.0644944981,
-0.268519938,
0.9488624334,
0.157049641,
0.2697603405,
-0.3140936792,
-0.0636131391,
-0.7699040771,
-0.747807622,
-0.5175886154,
-0.5067222118,
0.1203962713,
0.0681918859,
0.7647930384,
0.3809578419,
0.6384810209,
0.1900331378,
-0.2090757787,
-0.4543147981,
-0.3908055723,
0.1074187979,
-0.326141566,
-0.445692271,
-0.3776304126,
0.0806873888,
0.5146130919,
0.7640110254,
0.2089308202,
0.2990132272,
0.2564704418,
0.7100647092,
-0.6499193311,
0.3652412891,
-0.7517608404,
0.2153180242,
-0.3864077926,
0.0599221885,
-0.4275678992,
-0.3500503302,
0.383315742,
-0.0608044155,
0.6171827912,
0.0373397693,
0.6067594886,
0.543215692,
-0.3119919896,
-0.2477367818,
-0.6566929221,
0.9005099535,
-0.5677878857,
0.6072912216,
0.3001611829,
0.1651509553,
0.2581402361,
-0.3578154743,
-0.4697553217,
-0.108015798,
-0.4574293494,
0.1601082087,
-0.3325178027,
0.0487556793,
0.3992287815,
0.2703224421,
-0.6147440076,
0.0375712588,
-0.1975803375,
-0.1430175602,
0.3238834441,
-0.2715212405,
0.1789210737,
-0.2199739814,
-0.2347257137,
-0.0971003845,
-0.5843185782,
-0.1489875019,
0.7434951663,
0.1739094406,
-0.1866957396,
0.4449656606,
0.2667949498,
0.4938289225,
0.4483843744,
0.1904717386,
0.2805262208,
-0.1171099544,
-0.1594599038,
0.1273572296,
0.620005846,
0.3941318393,
0.7685105205,
-0.3327141404,
-0.1301607341,
0.1703578681,
0.5495165586,
-0.5422224998,
-0.1356476694,
0.1033683717,
-0.6620375514,
-0.2737537026,
-0.0808353573,
-0.917861402,
-0.3834991455,
-0.2740125656,
0.3480675519,
-0.1571542472,
-0.343770057,
-0.0794438645,
-0.261299789,
0.4260939062,
-0.2232203037,
-0.8717530966,
0.1801456809,
0.526178956,
0.6375240088,
-0.3060142398,
-0.146138221,
-0.1279472262,
0.036246974,
0.041512657,
0.6880000234,
-0.448917836,
-0.282568723,
0.057241831,
-0.0147928726,
-0.2044864893,
-0.690533638,
0.5884411931,
-0.5186969042,
0.310739398,
-0.5547394753,
-0.3068167269,
-0.0660183281,
0.0901881978,
-0.7156949043,
0.6582455039,
0.0410103351,
-1.3214200735,
0.4658864141,
-0.7561638355,
-0.4165506065,
-0.1709358692,
-0.3802814782,
-0.5586600304,
0.1841346323,
0.4567394853,
0.1076920107,
-0.1986216903,
0.2541769743,
-0.1134996563,
-0.2381780893,
0.1258970797,
-0.4082399607,
1.1240105629,
-0.0169708245,
-0.5939289927,
0.0507769287,
-0.3696933687,
-0.4766880572,
0.2543668449,
0.3238558471,
-0.4988950789,
0.0654153824,
-0.0778201818,
0.3969962299,
0.0559014603,
-0.5987526178,
-0.083852835,
-0.3801607192,
0.253223002,
0.8125820756,
-0.1469248533,
0.6459540725,
-0.2082124949,
0.5638865232,
0.3119745553,
0.1973067373,
-0.1601605117,
-0.489030689,
-0.7116924524,
-0.1482607871,
0.2986247241,
0.3363298178,
-0.5097340941,
0.4180331826,
-0.0031129797,
0.0117713902,
-0.7916073799,
-0.1840814054,
0.2230454981,
0.6161670089,
0.2773137093,
-0.5837164521,
-0.5669590831,
-1.4751490355,
-0.6083872318,
0.0020640183,
-0.3358539343,
0.1844213009,
0.441275239,
-0.322291553,
1.5758086443,
-0.3022190332,
-0.5590966344,
-0.1737193614,
0.1582024395,
-0.0370879658,
0.3303896189,
0.8170571327,
-0.64576298,
-0.2503318787,
-0.4952514172,
-0.5277578235,
-0.6136882901,
-0.0173357297,
-0.0859605148,
0.0712065697,
0.4186186194,
-0.5942878127,
0.309859246,
0.5653471351,
-0.3581530452,
0.6319023371,
0.2014697641,
-0.2485752404,
-0.4042648077,
0.096627973,
0.156923905,
-0.1907650977,
-0.6025829315,
-0.0371944308,
0.0971694887,
0.1127903238,
-0.2872987986,
0.351406157,
-0.4205057323,
-0.4415718019,
-0.424718082,
-0.1610098779,
-0.0665145367,
0.5399727821,
0.4267094731,
0.6447812319,
0.410884887,
-0.3985022306,
-0.1724805236,
0.2366606742,
-0.0487081558,
0.5238624811,
-0.6792859435,
0.4390626848,
-0.6610007882,
0.2824926376,
-0.8758115172,
0.3111203015,
0.2578347027,
-0.2892146111,
0.164606899,
-0.2148949802,
-0.3052088618,
-0.5446351767,
-0.2836217284,
0.6035607457,
0.5335718989,
-0.4796830118,
0.5706821084,
0.5678361058,
-0.258366555,
-0.6134129167,
-0.7023070455,
-0.351821363,
-0.1332311779,
-0.4315375388,
0.3211312592,
0.0726547316,
-0.5035586357,
-0.1289310604,
-0.2473766655,
-0.0241602641,
-0.2049432397,
0.1683656573,
0.0482143499,
-0.0331335887,
-0.2401075065,
-0.1286149919,
0.0000828889,
0.541965127,
-0.2435684502,
0.7986270785,
-0.0324669108,
-0.3525626063,
-0.152183637,
0.1514084935,
0.692710042,
-0.3868143857,
0.6266359091,
0.4186649621,
-0.2330596149,
-0.2101619989,
-0.7429200411,
-0.5315834284,
-0.4405459464,
0.4753959179,
-0.1521423608,
-0.669428885,
0.6645078063,
0.4734299779,
0.1833253801,
0.4289058149,
0.8473623991,
-0.0391030423,
0.8187153935,
0.5814671516,
-0.1956923902,
0.4068913758,
0.0063693984,
0.1954875439,
-0.7316359878,
-0.0549757555,
-0.546839118,
-0.3047133386,
-0.5991176963,
-0.4132282138,
0.2290002853,
-0.4767205119,
-0.2599812746,
0.1419221461,
-0.5534481406,
0.4851849079,
0.692700088,
-0.0845177919,
0.2114790082,
-0.229846254,
-0.0776489228,
-0.2560976148,
-0.6437149644,
-0.4305606782,
1.1244353056,
0.8687418103,
0.5783228874,
-0.26740852,
0.18607153,
0.2898696065,
0.3962836564,
-0.6243750453,
0.2633635104,
-0.1183570549,
-0.9355940819,
-0.1003355607,
-0.2966360152,
-0.5369074941,
0.4974342287,
0.1265411377,
-0.433190912,
0.5288635492,
0.3475371003,
-0.0349741653,
0.2432512194,
-0.7014253139,
1.005497694,
-0.1838655174,
-0.1682748646,
0.0139916195,
-0.6654773951,
0.618829906,
-0.2749613225,
0.3152072728,
0.1208135784,
0.4676229656,
0.8176081181,
0.1099036932,
0.7904575467,
-0.3911468089,
-0.4564966261,
0.0482622348,
0.0422041155,
0.4262225032,
-0.1260378063,
0.09377639,
0.6681910753,
-0.404800117,
-0.2808577716,
-0.2716658115,
0.2509023249,
-0.7453235984,
-0.5357806087,
-0.4358219206,
-0.8419803381,
-0.4611515701,
0.0265434366,
0.4641787112,
0.0138925221,
-0.2497212887,
-0.0270220432,
0.7820680141,
-0.4252733588,
0.4613357484,
0.5745912194,
-0.1995819956,
0.1454740912,
0.3573846519,
0.1855949014,
0.2279081345,
0.137931779,
0.1115049645,
-0.1544091702,
-0.3973233104,
-0.185892731,
0.2768197358,
-0.3790727258,
0.0687441602,
-0.7078160644,
-0.2788802683,
-0.5311594605,
0.1743020862,
-0.6562516093,
-0.1172146723,
0.2421450913,
0.0441683084,
-0.1624998152,
0.6517912149,
0.2930501401,
0.6207922101,
-0.2715653479,
0.493547529,
0.5048933029,
0.4997141957,
0.0360629484,
-0.6358032227,
-0.1023231372,
0.0758706555,
-0.3470729589,
-0.9799493551,
0.5374448299,
-0.2701537609,
0.5760555863,
0.4841793776,
-0.0095323455,
0.0467785411,
-0.8861447573,
0.6487493515,
-0.071843937,
-0.9943031669,
0.4271091819,
-0.3406007588,
0.4559738934,
0.2878597677,
0.2396495193,
-0.4889862835,
-0.8730528951,
-0.5673213005,
-0.6273867488,
0.8557370305,
0.413597405,
-0.0504258089,
-0.0864122063,
0.1235987768,
0.3595789969,
0.4632245898,
-0.9495292306,
-0.6211391687,
-0.4828238487,
-0.1339993924,
0.0944188833,
-0.3986566067,
-0.0106964344,
-0.0327218026,
0.5006998181,
0.0525873564,
0.6343523264,
-0.0022643667,
-0.5934150815,
-0.0056679524,
0.3049336374,
0.4959471524,
0.6044466496,
-0.501861155,
0.1503150761,
-0.0053471536,
-0.6718122363,
-0.107788302,
0.0629826784,
-0.5650067925,
0.425390929,
0.1723811626,
0.8742957115,
-0.1241960451,
-0.3903335333,
0.6439417005,
0.025562685,
0.0324742161,
-0.3206779659,
-0.3690705001,
-0.0991070345,
0.0825708881,
0.5102937818,
0.0419279225,
0.1793429255,
-0.380679816,
0.2187126279,
0.8280683756,
-0.4069660902,
-0.4611355066,
0.6865492463,
0.4138094485,
-0.1546860039,
0.3763998151,
0.0279764906,
-0.9031221271,
0.7139044404,
0.5454476476,
1.1714011431,
-0.3899762928,
-0.0121800974,
0.037314456,
0.8642963171,
0.2141073495,
-0.2763643861,
0.0982250795,
-1.0074727535,
-0.3986776769,
-0.599118948,
-0.3850919604,
0.3360530436,
-0.7103766203,
0.0944858938,
-0.0993490368,
-0.3068778217,
-0.0999285206,
-0.5075092316,
-0.9356445074,
0.1256005913,
0.5581927896,
0.5713571906,
-1.1646680832,
0.6813613772,
0.7129018307,
-0.2582490444,
-0.1853175014,
0.5289410949,
-0.0014132471,
-0.8479596972,
0.9337873459,
0.2247517556,
-0.0593193658,
-0.1798294485,
-0.1015361249,
-0.6978426576,
0.4816355705,
0.566911459,
-0.7633348107,
-0.345843643,
0.572378993,
0.3497710526,
-0.3126666546,
0.7092132568,
0.9787814617,
0.515042305,
-0.5074372888,
-1.2371770144,
-0.1563527733,
0.1706971377,
0.2591257989,
-0.0021938402,
-0.6549893022,
0.7615947723,
0.1947368085,
0.0108177746,
-0.8441742063,
0.5122808814,
0.0413149558,
0.0703486726,
0.6611151099,
0.4265675843,
0.391351521,
-0.125519827,
0.8657425046,
-0.4287152886,
0.4084217548,
1.0330708027,
-0.3497749269,
0.2178986818,
0.7335659266,
-0.1470892578,
0.4243558347,
0.1685636491,
0.1128637344,
0.5886235237,
0.2236255854,
0.0113832196,
0.2340673208,
0.0366596058,
-0.4136006832,
0.5290073752,
0.0284325667,
-0.5606753826,
-0.2214632332,
0.2614088655,
-0.1216124594,
-0.1449102312,
-0.4507293403,
0.6945863962,
-0.0073269163,
-0.5176402926,
0.0290743262,
-0.0056661153,
1.1381644011,
-0.3970871568,
0.4222977459,
-0.3711268902,
0.2449844629,
-0.1050043479,
-0.4747880101,
0.483869791,
0.0632783994,
-0.5186684728,
-0.4775554836,
0.7053155899,
-0.5967710614,
-0.2891592681,
0.3336690366,
0.499678582,
-0.1499714404,
-0.3576848805,
-0.5866103768,
0.1526104957,
-0.0217108838,
-0.3611207902,
0.3781998456,
0.1365522295,
-0.0360416993,
0.4514272213,
0.1434497088,
0.0767972618,
0.1866625994,
0.3784733415,
0.4894144535,
-0.5294333696,
-0.6305192113,
-0.9761633873,
0.3211054504,
0.0307693835,
0.0280790571,
0.9127292037,
0.5560520887,
0.9380452037,
-0.4189853966,
0.9517202973,
0.1658564955,
0.6093887091,
-0.1253573298,
0.9922108054,
0.0282853246,
0.2157991976,
-0.3873359263,
-1.2665551901,
-0.0210906789,
0.8092886806,
-0.4958454967,
0.1722451895,
0.6827711463,
0.5575568676,
-0.0744179711,
0.2259178311,
0.0128075322,
0.359287113,
0.0686173588,
0.342248708,
0.6756471395,
-0.2275231034,
0.3237191439,
-0.3280569017,
-0.2311486006,
-0.0243228208,
-0.9016327858,
-0.9221369624,
-0.2415820062,
-0.4527622163,
-0.1804237962,
0.1736569107,
0.8224656582,
0.543567121,
-1.0497891903,
-0.3112371564,
-0.0154598588,
0.1558041871,
-0.1531365216,
-0.3051744103,
0.3603982627,
-0.4894509315,
-0.854739368,
-0.1246097013,
-0.0136472657,
-0.2132954299,
-0.4047119617,
0.1885927171,
0.1255950332,
0.1225066483,
0.6501015425,
-0.033238776,
-0.5959163904,
-0.30895105,
-0.0774274692,
-0.0198891032,
0.1873224378,
1.0893008709,
-0.9697678089,
0.3527519405,
0.2547460794,
0.5807181001,
0.3199424148,
0.0069202171,
0.933290422,
-1.0927559137,
0.2376781553,
0.4968137145,
0.3513539135,
0.3031146824,
-0.1402392983,
0.1934884936,
0.3114934862,
-0.4960228801,
-0.8688809872,
0.232586056,
-0.7598491907,
-0.2722415328,
1.259381175,
0.3156662285,
-0.0047310456,
-0.1595583111,
-0.2239339352,
0.3621312082,
-0.1415738016,
0.8879537582,
0.8429356217,
0.0459410772,
-0.2322264612,
-0.596364975,
0.6157722473,
0.6534681916,
-0.4657001793,
0.3534997702,
0.3366272449,
0.3457233608,
0.1414224952,
0.3982765973,
-0.2163843364,
0.1408172697,
-0.3066418767,
0.424372077,
0.0627081618,
-0.1461855024,
-0.61338377,
0.2955110669,
-0.1546209306,
-0.25194785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10373v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10373v1
|
FOAL: Fine-grained Contrastive Learning for Cross-domain Aspect Sentiment Triplet Extraction
| 2023-11-17T07:56:01 | 2023-11-17T07:56:01 |
Ting Xu, Zhen Wu, Huiyun Yang, Xinyu Dai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aspect Sentiment Triplet Extraction (ASTE) has achieved promising results
while relying on sufficient annotation data in a specific domain. However, it
is infeasible to annotate data for each individual domain. We propose to
explore ASTE in the cross-domain setting, which transfers knowledge from a
resource-rich source domain to a resource-poor target domain, thereby
alleviating the reliance on labeled data in the target domain. To effectively
transfer the knowledge across domains and extract the sentiment triplets
accurately, we propose a method named Fine-grained cOntrAstive Learning (FOAL)
to reduce the domain discrepancy and preserve the discriminability of each
category. Experiments on six transfer pairs show that FOAL achieves 6%
performance gains and reduces the domain discrepancy significantly compared
with strong baselines. Our code will be publicly available once accepted.
|
[
-0.4543337822,
-0.6684506536,
0.3366428614,
0.4490005374,
-0.3589736819,
0.3454711139,
-0.1577982754,
-0.7843180895,
0.1938906908,
0.4128514528,
-0.3547390103,
-0.6048858762,
-0.80019629,
-0.1566160172,
-0.2308704406,
1.3793785572,
-0.3902429938,
-0.0544003397,
-0.0746606067,
-0.3207728863,
-0.0309942514,
-0.3590649664,
-0.8476861715,
-0.2774894834,
0.2915042937,
0.6397970319,
0.3732287884,
0.2338825911,
0.685016036,
0.2105264217,
-0.025444122,
0.2299844027,
-0.3935074508,
-0.0967415646,
-0.5442177057,
-0.2798537016,
-0.5778442025,
0.050579343,
0.3437892497,
0.8405960202,
0.2880560458,
0.1335855424,
0.5972130895,
0.9121631384,
-0.8369935155,
0.5972121358,
-0.5998633504,
0.2368538082,
-0.2128783613,
-0.1629463732,
-0.2215158939,
-0.4512697458,
0.2777089775,
-0.7348649502,
0.4937110543,
0.2323219925,
0.9160778522,
-0.1191766113,
-0.3084017336,
-0.2466180474,
-0.5627337098,
1.0196712017,
-0.2950564325,
0.1304163635,
0.5089167953,
0.127025947,
0.3627257347,
-0.6970280409,
-0.496303767,
0.0652257949,
-0.140748173,
0.0237857271,
-0.2381806821,
-0.0585320629,
-0.2711211443,
1.0170471668,
-0.1444546878,
-0.1229539141,
-0.3487736881,
-0.318926096,
0.6308684945,
-0.026648555,
0.0827773809,
-0.1035695374,
-0.6197434068,
-0.1657043993,
-0.598330915,
0.1613362432,
0.0400744043,
0.7190624475,
-0.2891872525,
0.2410066724,
-0.2767295539,
0.2186521292,
0.3747260273,
0.2400844991,
0.6022346616,
-0.1833735108,
-0.2319341749,
-0.0383537561,
0.804056406,
0.583976686,
-0.1740705371,
-0.0125561226,
-0.4111903906,
-0.0734365657,
0.1274510473,
-0.8599939346,
-0.3648373187,
0.1839126945,
-0.5829364061,
-0.3925994039,
-0.0485383645,
-1.0584396124,
-0.4843294621,
-0.1778841466,
0.5838905573,
-0.5110093951,
-0.1106645018,
0.1222189739,
0.0769696087,
0.1039969251,
0.5122494102,
-0.9598759413,
0.3522352278,
0.8602096438,
0.8077611327,
-0.5173956156,
-0.412360698,
-0.7273174524,
0.0333751328,
-0.0152815962,
0.881731987,
-0.6628661752,
-0.4972088039,
0.2112531066,
0.0703789145,
0.013288511,
-0.5990997553,
0.4090723395,
-0.4808337986,
-0.0605512634,
-0.2504616678,
-0.3759736419,
-0.4580767751,
0.4134162068,
-0.6853500009,
0.8174996376,
0.2239462733,
-0.754324317,
0.3140086234,
-0.6799852848,
-0.7548444867,
-0.2678205371,
-0.1722920239,
-0.3998296261,
0.1240045726,
0.358894825,
0.7562206388,
-0.3185213208,
-0.3200545907,
-0.3538205624,
0.0436744578,
-0.0024087981,
-0.220296517,
0.4749112129,
0.2510899603,
-0.3730791211,
-0.0601806082,
-0.7823354006,
-0.2640284598,
-0.0154565554,
-0.2478079647,
-0.6139932871,
-0.3856544793,
0.1891853064,
0.1356589049,
0.2838565707,
-0.7234671712,
0.1610230654,
-0.2831050754,
0.1133252978,
0.517863512,
-0.0044895043,
0.5524966121,
-0.2727082074,
0.3568756282,
0.4747264087,
0.2150007784,
0.3823714256,
-0.3853839338,
-0.8798422217,
0.0347273014,
0.2537267208,
0.3927749991,
-1.2888467312,
0.2483603954,
-0.1031073034,
-0.1147551313,
-0.6768499613,
0.1991743594,
0.8219354153,
0.3803664446,
0.8739697933,
-0.4789609611,
-0.1957815886,
-0.9205080271,
-0.2499905229,
0.0723065734,
0.0392113663,
0.2992152572,
0.4201912582,
-0.2109778225,
0.6717879772,
-0.7989004254,
-0.5980328321,
-0.1873990744,
0.6428291798,
-0.3215991855,
0.644327879,
0.4848694205,
-0.9722363949,
-0.6221607327,
0.5123689175,
-0.5615004897,
-0.0140404562,
0.2379316688,
-0.1871255189,
0.2874696553,
0.3736785054,
-0.1704710722,
0.2811113894,
0.6196733117,
-0.3126579225,
0.3033210039,
0.2659593523,
0.4438598454,
-1.2442570925,
0.0110007245,
0.2738083899,
-0.2486212403,
-0.4361454248,
0.0384440273,
0.0675141662,
0.2580825686,
-0.6087214947,
0.6744097471,
-0.342954427,
-0.1631358415,
-0.2768025398,
0.2114968002,
0.3623833954,
0.4827989936,
0.214016825,
0.7882931828,
0.4576609135,
-0.3915646672,
0.0620515347,
0.3597941399,
0.0664135218,
0.8441098928,
-0.0027560825,
0.0853772312,
0.246284008,
0.1161489189,
-0.6283065081,
0.0638595298,
0.3754719794,
-0.3448509872,
0.4725641012,
-0.1530454755,
0.1696292907,
-0.0597550906,
-0.6928822994,
0.4735347331,
0.1733364463,
-0.8490682244,
0.657225728,
0.4043882787,
-0.3101521432,
-0.5584529638,
-0.8544586897,
-0.3089501858,
-0.1337605268,
-0.3587980568,
0.556327939,
0.1259839535,
-0.0866437182,
0.2045192271,
-0.2721170783,
-0.3006376028,
-0.1716489941,
0.0258553103,
0.0537507869,
-0.5668087006,
0.0918275267,
0.0824330747,
-0.1378865391,
-0.020851817,
-0.2399882674,
0.4260123968,
-0.6235492826,
-0.2034623027,
-0.3698629141,
0.546000421,
0.1547403783,
-0.0745588914,
0.6044548154,
0.8136225343,
-0.3814645708,
-0.4491060674,
-0.3466340899,
0.0329845734,
-0.4642918706,
0.1429624856,
-0.4891715944,
-0.9821526408,
0.5350068212,
-0.183832407,
0.0075697135,
0.7733595371,
0.056432575,
0.010014738,
0.5817694664,
0.8832514882,
-0.1914770454,
0.4858612716,
-0.4505514503,
0.0751275867,
-1.0825870037,
-0.2022823393,
-0.4363318384,
-0.2742852569,
-0.4555793405,
-0.583669126,
-0.0858887956,
0.1312061995,
-0.1459072828,
-0.0686039031,
-0.3717569411,
0.5564832091,
0.4751155376,
0.3764374852,
0.4187146127,
0.190159291,
0.1891297996,
0.0452042706,
-0.1068193465,
-0.4721082747,
0.8189650774,
0.243252784,
0.6459823251,
0.1040289998,
0.7981353402,
0.4800047576,
0.3423298001,
-0.9220839739,
0.4106236398,
-0.9728460908,
-0.0648657084,
0.0164151564,
-0.4872646928,
-0.7652383447,
0.1199268773,
-0.2332967222,
-0.6363839507,
0.4374658465,
0.2631105781,
-0.5001135468,
0.5981134176,
-0.5580966473,
0.6826859117,
0.0991466716,
-0.6156235337,
-0.2009411901,
-0.6863359213,
0.3016688228,
-0.1977980286,
0.1233876795,
-0.1975564063,
0.0255215596,
0.810176909,
-0.3860283494,
1.000218153,
-0.2217389494,
-0.0139761809,
0.1569537222,
0.1503480971,
0.2580194771,
-0.0059077269,
0.0113227982,
0.4339613914,
-0.2935009301,
-0.6019639373,
-0.4169744253,
0.8266319036,
-0.8744670749,
-0.4032749832,
-0.2301874757,
-0.2799777985,
-0.6324458122,
0.0437225252,
0.1262874752,
0.3768665791,
-0.1429675221,
0.175180465,
0.5964631438,
-0.0765854046,
0.3549701273,
0.3859271407,
-0.2334881872,
-0.528095305,
1.2316000462,
-0.3479274511,
0.3442422748,
0.5289517045,
0.4581464231,
-0.1060187444,
-0.6162840724,
-0.3000079095,
-0.1313769221,
-0.8863729835,
-0.5116583109,
-0.6474486589,
-0.2982847095,
-0.1689832658,
-0.6336798668,
-0.6428261995,
-0.4374697804,
-0.3178634644,
0.0585490726,
0.5551158786,
0.7962039709,
-0.1019406989,
0.4975101054,
-1.1160532236,
0.4301353395,
0.3807804585,
0.4976953864,
-0.0195659045,
-0.3537096381,
-0.1815761328,
-0.0541462749,
-0.5057372451,
-0.4700722992,
0.2487921268,
0.3223987818,
0.1778457016,
0.4996979833,
0.0586731993,
0.6327114701,
-0.1736404747,
1.0111021996,
0.3550358713,
-1.2799270153,
0.5941918492,
-0.0379008725,
-0.1059320197,
0.9862242341,
0.5278728604,
-0.1864795238,
-0.3011060953,
-0.693307817,
-1.0100067854,
0.9169080257,
0.2119933516,
-0.0409699865,
0.0918431431,
0.3336912394,
0.7378458977,
0.2317344993,
-0.5565694571,
-0.3170674145,
-0.2494661361,
-0.3865852058,
0.0729032606,
-0.0529489554,
0.0216879938,
-0.279168874,
0.8771485686,
-0.3190760612,
0.1286346316,
0.2220023423,
-0.2086015493,
0.0178705342,
0.1464143991,
0.2682012618,
0.0413149744,
-0.2258331627,
0.3435018659,
0.1176700667,
-0.799405396,
-0.0906377062,
0.3761363924,
0.0802139789,
-0.420624733,
0.3394508064,
0.8474152684,
0.2032615393,
0.0825557262,
0.8452833295,
-0.1475066543,
-0.2022260129,
0.1670990437,
-0.0870219767,
-0.2557885051,
0.6297792196,
0.1787839234,
0.3513593376,
0.4523730278,
-0.5739058852,
0.2865338027,
0.236580044,
-0.5335441828,
-0.4529187381,
0.4315509498,
0.6790906787,
-0.0905269831,
0.1739010364,
-0.2824803591,
-0.4816020429,
0.4177535474,
0.4566257298,
1.2083640099,
-0.2841304243,
0.1855176389,
0.0791263282,
-0.0967602283,
-0.1957043111,
0.3008314669,
-0.1809309423,
-0.8623781204,
-0.1974560916,
-0.8883596063,
-0.5965538621,
0.1417935193,
-0.8631181121,
0.1269015074,
-0.5108919144,
0.0592702776,
0.2288002074,
0.2368533313,
-0.7374192476,
0.3114074767,
0.3134715557,
0.629440248,
-1.1592037678,
0.8574887514,
0.8730279207,
-0.712095499,
-0.6265389323,
0.5442383885,
-0.0972623676,
-0.9637838006,
0.6747719049,
0.3878294826,
-0.6471223235,
-0.1233661547,
-0.352781862,
-0.4601593316,
0.8231111765,
-0.0641731843,
-0.2865132987,
0.4334800243,
0.1870993078,
0.4388290644,
-0.6915621161,
-0.0881702974,
0.7185459137,
0.294998765,
0.301676482,
-0.7953854799,
0.2211589366,
-0.2584407032,
-0.1006746963,
0.2548885345,
-0.8084819317,
1.0287163258,
0.0451250486,
-0.0985848531,
-0.2768072784,
0.9416612983,
0.0324295759,
0.6738027334,
0.5240495205,
0.1522273868,
0.6328113079,
-0.0248288754,
0.7721601725,
-0.282548815,
0.6035564542,
1.0536866188,
-0.3802609146,
1.2222466469,
0.5620355606,
-0.2161925435,
0.5079572201,
0.4475768209,
0.311529547,
0.5856907368,
-0.1686181277,
-0.5006344914,
-0.1475349367,
-0.0312810391,
-0.260571003,
0.2963191867,
0.6447966695,
-0.3735687435,
-0.2913056314,
0.2116754204,
0.162609458,
0.0604635812,
-0.633321166,
0.7800483704,
0.3080672026,
-0.3629455566,
0.4245451689,
-0.2212662101,
0.9443715811,
-0.346206069,
-0.1827421337,
-0.4751216471,
0.4441102147,
-0.4494659603,
-1.2329331636,
0.5039800406,
-0.1378594637,
-0.2944853306,
-0.1858373135,
0.8302429914,
-0.598696053,
-0.4317523837,
0.5013304949,
0.3899220526,
0.1067814156,
-0.1463143229,
-0.7768491507,
-0.0533986725,
0.2581481934,
-0.2623977959,
0.3918936849,
0.7648689747,
-0.1666724086,
0.2383694202,
0.358763665,
0.1563976854,
-0.2950380743,
0.0106203957,
0.9621205926,
-0.7203644514,
-0.5164811611,
-0.70662117,
0.3456815481,
-0.3722360432,
-0.2737548649,
0.586063385,
0.516694665,
0.8604294062,
-0.0794264153,
0.9503195882,
-0.0529439673,
0.4259833694,
-0.8029857874,
0.5277663469,
-0.702065587,
0.3157353103,
-0.1313679665,
-0.7936050296,
-0.5782038569,
0.6194732189,
-0.4477244318,
-0.0550449006,
1.0864073038,
0.5377087593,
-0.4675615728,
0.4853576422,
0.1681451648,
0.1787272692,
0.1895657927,
0.5936247706,
0.7939460874,
-0.5201773643,
0.3971072435,
-0.6834771037,
-0.3352615237,
-0.496519357,
-0.8929386139,
-0.8072471619,
-0.6499224305,
-0.6680935025,
-0.3522798419,
0.1219667718,
0.9405741096,
0.4600766897,
-1.0404558182,
0.1505468637,
0.1344561577,
-0.0876462236,
-0.1382323056,
-0.248584941,
0.8504142761,
-0.4520888627,
-0.6196296215,
0.1353960484,
0.2453696579,
-0.0722178742,
0.0201132689,
0.1908038259,
-0.0239142813,
-0.0424308032,
0.9126986861,
0.3011319339,
-0.4574069679,
-0.7043883801,
-0.7457182407,
-0.1650287062,
0.437462002,
0.7861693501,
-0.5383534431,
0.0112729846,
0.4537739158,
0.7268294096,
0.4247386158,
0.1771227717,
0.2506266236,
-1.040546298,
0.021559678,
0.0967339128,
0.3939578533,
0.5727795959,
-0.4068616331,
0.420004189,
0.2167062014,
-0.4817130864,
-0.1898366809,
0.0677511096,
-1.1145634651,
-0.3036826849,
1.4273836613,
-0.2648839951,
-0.35703215,
-0.2483574301,
-0.2452717125,
0.1539957523,
-0.6659308076,
0.8676199317,
0.3168961704,
-0.3332674801,
0.2546156943,
-0.4501410723,
0.8663420081,
0.2412924767,
-1.0769637823,
0.2128240317,
0.3195385635,
0.312235266,
0.3398720622,
0.561473608,
-0.0993830264,
0.0462130196,
0.1493314207,
0.4233628511,
0.1727365255,
-0.291533947,
-0.4910629392,
0.4079897404,
0.1352472901,
-0.6220600605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10367v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10367v1
|
Exploring the Relationship between In-Context Learning and Instruction Tuning
| 2023-11-17T07:40:46 | 2023-11-17T07:40:46 |
Hanyu Duan, Yixuan Tang, Yi Yang, Ahmed Abbasi, Kar Yan Tam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In-Context Learning (ICL) and Instruction Tuning (IT) are two primary
paradigms of adopting Large Language Models (LLMs) to downstream applications.
However, they are significantly different. In ICL, a set of demonstrations are
provided at inference time but the LLM's parameters are not updated. In IT, a
set of demonstrations are used to tune LLM's parameters in training time but no
demonstrations are used at inference time. Although a growing body of
literature has explored ICL and IT, studies on these topics have largely been
conducted in isolation, leading to a disconnect between these two paradigms. In
this work, we explore the relationship between ICL and IT by examining how the
hidden states of LLMs change in these two paradigms. Through carefully designed
experiments conducted with LLaMA-2 (7B and 13B), we find that ICL is implicit
IT. In other words, ICL changes an LLM's hidden states as if the demonstrations
were used to instructionally tune the model. Furthermore, the convergence
between ICL and IT is largely contingent upon several factors related to the
provided demonstrations. Overall, this work offers a unique perspective to
explore the connection between ICL and IT and sheds light on understanding the
behaviors of LLM.
|
[
-0.3340352476,
-0.7426354885,
0.4796533883,
-0.0092314221,
-0.3345759511,
0.3253242671,
-0.4236473739,
-0.4162415862,
-0.4149732888,
0.2146919966,
-0.6783452034,
-0.3834548295,
-0.4147906899,
-0.0936696753,
-0.4192494154,
1.1131744385,
-0.060694851,
0.0572787784,
-0.1773334593,
0.0612850115,
-0.5139797926,
-0.2448546886,
-0.44672966,
-0.4824878275,
0.1433585286,
0.7163197994,
0.2658850253,
0.9522491693,
0.0430068895,
0.17547068,
-0.2203674912,
-0.015903037,
-0.5580758452,
-0.0781481713,
-0.0933843777,
-0.4241230786,
0.1128896773,
0.0616492666,
1.0187541246,
0.7113425136,
-0.0062018577,
0.2881359756,
0.6301217079,
0.531480372,
-0.8503084183,
0.2061815262,
-0.8981862664,
-0.129591465,
-0.2377279699,
-0.3634618819,
-0.6375587583,
-0.2352159619,
0.107575722,
-0.3823450208,
0.1492683291,
0.1089659184,
0.9800562859,
0.5772019029,
-0.6971890926,
-0.5869717598,
-0.783446908,
0.8664528131,
-0.8635974526,
0.2489092499,
0.3253933787,
0.0943415463,
-0.1485894769,
-0.442564249,
-0.4525808394,
-0.4457262158,
-0.2915046215,
-0.0224151723,
0.1496337205,
-0.066140607,
0.3877308071,
0.3910892606,
0.0501576886,
0.5402078629,
-0.4018041492,
0.0923203453,
0.3587890863,
0.2304640859,
0.0958416834,
0.1017337069,
-0.6931866407,
-0.0614140406,
-1.2222425938,
0.5404176712,
0.1907324791,
0.1223812327,
-0.3384666443,
0.3532162309,
0.1778170317,
0.8163267374,
0.3460948765,
-0.2472804934,
-0.0541177765,
-0.0667630509,
-0.3156359494,
0.4976528287,
0.464956969,
0.1920814365,
0.0379162021,
-0.0086545125,
-0.2297271937,
-0.1654482484,
0.1440473795,
-0.5339408517,
0.2435589433,
-0.1930351108,
-0.2373297065,
0.0282706413,
0.1665187925,
-0.3102867901,
-0.176769495,
-0.7768418789,
0.568967104,
-0.3701158166,
-0.284479171,
-0.2652792037,
-0.0246350747,
0.6772024035,
-0.0104390988,
-1.0994086266,
0.4340015054,
0.9650466442,
0.6162689924,
-0.3842290044,
-0.296014905,
-0.3754342794,
0.4497826993,
-0.6477159262,
0.5525270104,
-0.7577739954,
-0.3908671141,
0.183700785,
0.0468755513,
-0.3486640155,
-0.820016861,
0.0986867249,
-0.740347147,
-0.1164941043,
-0.294880569,
-0.8096695542,
-0.2771984935,
0.0500727035,
-0.507425189,
1.1263253689,
-0.0693858191,
-0.523198545,
0.7491857409,
-0.707952857,
-0.4766165018,
-0.0174224973,
-0.288122654,
-0.3573260605,
0.2899912894,
-0.1311477721,
0.3531517088,
-0.2961659431,
0.0741181448,
-0.1888801455,
-1.0929490328,
0.3976285458,
-0.3932228088,
0.5449882746,
-0.0448425747,
-0.80353719,
-0.0093852282,
-0.6951582432,
0.1278478652,
-0.3581145704,
-0.6653374434,
-0.4255270958,
0.3185052872,
-0.3303034306,
0.1818357408,
0.1729150265,
-0.4360083342,
0.2557486296,
-0.3972383738,
0.5929875374,
0.9118838906,
0.0396227799,
0.5299788713,
-0.1301434487,
0.231707111,
0.0874737576,
0.1568086892,
-0.2688052654,
-0.1857988983,
-0.9862110019,
-0.1455886811,
0.0083532361,
0.3278465271,
-0.4350831807,
0.0113811241,
-0.1018459201,
0.0021769521,
-0.7362220287,
0.0321418382,
0.5302616358,
0.641459465,
0.3340907693,
0.1907287687,
-0.11307621,
-0.8385433555,
-0.3236880004,
0.0497624688,
0.0725413859,
0.4211226106,
0.3608074784,
0.1555193365,
0.7847064137,
-0.0796765387,
-0.2098139822,
-0.0567349531,
-0.0564085506,
0.2050474137,
0.5686924458,
0.376024276,
-0.560947299,
-0.8572359681,
0.1604359597,
-0.6212985516,
-0.0138065191,
-0.1247851178,
0.210504666,
0.4221758842,
0.9176564217,
0.0249590594,
0.7210033536,
0.5224169493,
-0.262290746,
0.2730596662,
-0.3047095537,
0.1629159451,
-0.7455104589,
-0.3137655258,
-0.1711936295,
0.2989743352,
-0.4633525312,
0.1635504365,
0.4985300601,
0.1926385164,
-0.4591153264,
0.5492066741,
-0.6925969124,
-0.4401007593,
-0.3489394784,
-0.0823116824,
-0.1302883625,
0.6282548308,
-0.1471387744,
1.2527222633,
0.7971200347,
-0.9148567915,
-0.4557709992,
-0.131257996,
-0.5563628078,
0.2399579585,
-0.4936230481,
0.2910114229,
0.0812670514,
0.0737519339,
-0.9576337934,
-0.0925213844,
0.1155185848,
0.1109249443,
0.7730655074,
-0.1342506111,
-0.5346598029,
0.1213462725,
-0.1682552546,
0.3010756373,
0.494019568,
-0.8435504436,
0.3767729998,
0.0385392942,
0.2772628665,
-0.6356415749,
-0.6269215941,
-0.0974933803,
-0.4629715085,
-0.2078948319,
0.6485681534,
-0.3143897951,
-0.4371116459,
-0.0197778493,
-0.2687017918,
-0.1408666968,
0.2741520405,
0.4751116931,
0.2625196576,
-0.55851686,
0.2443302125,
0.6251615882,
0.0130135501,
0.0683135316,
-0.2628220916,
0.3026292622,
-0.3450605273,
-0.5120833516,
-0.7895590663,
0.4247945845,
0.5367513895,
-0.2039629668,
0.9189215302,
0.3209331334,
0.1423544437,
-0.3033095896,
-0.4273588061,
-0.3053721786,
-0.5509589911,
0.1332842857,
-0.3548514843,
-0.9161708355,
0.316036731,
-0.3811146319,
0.2186169624,
0.0784670487,
0.4900550246,
-0.216734156,
1.1421169043,
0.9579201937,
0.0951896384,
0.8084014654,
-0.3956742883,
-0.0020430451,
-1.3482428789,
-0.2814698815,
-0.3555176556,
-0.4026460052,
-0.6549170017,
0.0101773906,
0.6600920558,
0.3110244274,
-0.6559070945,
-0.0202839114,
-0.2006597519,
0.8470100164,
0.5890834332,
0.1091371924,
0.2550426722,
-0.0124806445,
-0.3373786509,
-0.0780011341,
-0.6665847301,
-0.4723656178,
0.9133059382,
-0.0651468113,
0.7079187036,
0.2180703133,
0.4813137352,
0.0756965503,
0.4456425309,
-0.7637255788,
0.4164187312,
-0.2610937655,
-0.3756223023,
-0.0638463348,
0.0350575298,
-0.8808934689,
0.1216645315,
-0.0215132087,
-0.8939338923,
-0.0677822828,
0.3994393945,
-0.0652350262,
0.3174534738,
-0.8403198123,
0.513024509,
-0.2583764493,
-0.7858105898,
-0.5079267025,
-0.7109524608,
0.3163674176,
0.1901578009,
-0.0161804054,
0.1286251545,
-0.1461647749,
0.2438569665,
-0.177710861,
0.9830935001,
0.0917045102,
-0.4018237591,
0.1158092245,
0.063855283,
0.4330202341,
0.0709216446,
-0.2879337668,
0.1279197037,
-0.196167171,
-0.353846401,
-0.5486143231,
1.1405550241,
-0.9474238157,
-0.9156182408,
-0.2480409741,
-0.7506937981,
-0.2987807691,
-0.0655277073,
0.2792963982,
0.7640195489,
0.3422221541,
0.2505143285,
1.0290392637,
-0.2311475128,
0.7925129533,
0.8398472071,
0.2015812099,
0.3375551403,
0.7497938871,
0.1082617864,
0.715690732,
0.5992954373,
0.2852621973,
-0.2454416454,
-0.3320310116,
-0.6275568604,
0.1999634057,
-0.8992295265,
0.1901069582,
-0.0521938354,
-0.286503613,
0.0485773236,
-0.2874591649,
-0.1114694625,
0.1668502837,
-0.7623494864,
0.0324536785,
0.2355964035,
0.9948388338,
0.1864973009,
0.3359291852,
-0.3789478838,
-0.15025419,
0.2746575177,
0.4034579396,
0.2967661321,
-0.741724968,
-0.3705129027,
-0.0252110902,
-0.2097818553,
-0.7141664624,
-0.0659906268,
0.614171505,
0.6215147376,
0.6644301414,
-0.0700497776,
0.8730973601,
-0.7190724015,
0.8766878843,
-0.3816156387,
-1.0966589451,
0.411819607,
-0.1585396528,
0.3857719302,
0.2821270227,
0.3319860995,
-0.2121336013,
-0.4202056825,
-0.3040876687,
-0.6396915317,
0.9455254674,
-0.4687390327,
0.3541803658,
0.1322131902,
0.5040059686,
0.3204206526,
0.2148640901,
-0.5738386512,
-0.4129498303,
-0.0457765125,
-0.042603381,
0.0413432978,
-0.2905998826,
-0.2177111655,
-0.267485559,
0.5405111313,
-0.2864373326,
0.1168087944,
-0.3448307514,
-0.265371114,
-0.2246825397,
0.3204403222,
0.8051717281,
0.8206994534,
0.0381972492,
0.0784203112,
0.2275245786,
-0.257071197,
0.0714421943,
-0.3369842768,
-0.3282344341,
-0.3703177869,
0.5275450349,
1.2601367235,
0.8581640124,
-0.5820128918,
0.3857271671,
0.094449684,
0.0397308692,
-0.3272694349,
0.5063174963,
-0.0901143774,
0.4812542796,
0.3945657313,
0.0604147799,
0.0071207234,
-0.7290676236,
-0.04694416,
0.5393946171,
-0.7290554047,
-0.316493094,
0.5158475637,
-0.1494798809,
-0.4002186954,
0.6766366959,
-0.0417825244,
-0.2708969414,
0.7308348417,
1.1066601276,
0.6614073515,
0.0128454054,
0.1571036577,
0.2563213408,
0.1883305758,
0.3977465928,
-0.0844207704,
-0.5715685487,
-0.4193803966,
-0.5912959576,
-0.19985798,
-0.2022250295,
0.3320176899,
-1.1097273827,
0.182203576,
-0.4452401698,
0.3704559207,
-0.3755661547,
0.0186184514,
-0.4638551772,
-0.0784046352,
0.0332272239,
0.7707488537,
-0.7189961672,
1.0397404432,
0.6328133345,
0.0241605528,
-1.0443447828,
0.6467609406,
0.1493422091,
-0.8513675332,
0.8702509999,
0.1538798958,
-0.3012543023,
0.3051143587,
-0.7352305055,
-1.0849349499,
1.2551871538,
0.4139018655,
-0.5343674421,
0.2952671349,
-0.0231164433,
0.4263312221,
-0.3203338981,
0.0760626197,
0.638690114,
0.1927254349,
0.053516753,
-0.8015192151,
-0.1111721471,
0.0412671752,
-0.0241306033,
0.3921195269,
-0.9863265753,
1.096595645,
-0.3559376895,
-0.4689039886,
-0.0097304164,
0.4270725548,
0.2801785171,
0.3708607256,
0.369076252,
0.0973961577,
0.4533483386,
-0.0436072089,
1.0265293121,
-0.4348510504,
0.1600753218,
1.0697103739,
-0.4934924841,
0.9201186299,
0.6408063173,
0.0978216976,
0.8260040879,
0.8501828313,
0.2544488609,
0.6219546795,
0.0103875585,
-0.3898162544,
-0.1645326018,
-0.1528621614,
-0.3815152049,
0.3806931376,
0.7990148664,
-0.2664720118,
-0.1717407703,
0.1879218519,
0.0877346992,
0.1794551164,
-0.5333239436,
0.9920963049,
-0.0273448657,
-0.8964194059,
0.8163095713,
-0.2444019765,
0.4737507403,
-0.7276685238,
-0.3309350908,
-0.2632985115,
0.2484000921,
0.0475253202,
-0.7035691142,
0.0092076659,
-0.0233228207,
-0.3110198677,
-0.1905133724,
0.3546358645,
-0.413980335,
-0.0736247897,
0.4403843582,
0.0267764255,
-0.0474137068,
0.491836369,
-0.6037114859,
0.1590419412,
-0.0228369758,
-0.0884406045,
0.7314044833,
0.3271163404,
-0.3263027072,
0.7675417066,
0.3915997148,
-0.0971728489,
0.3527149558,
0.0132001573,
0.9579161406,
-0.3063237667,
-0.3553857207,
-0.8988726139,
0.451013118,
0.146156624,
-0.5103730559,
0.804684937,
0.3000034392,
1.1353133917,
-0.0969697759,
0.5301355124,
0.0526509583,
0.3194582462,
-1.0064415932,
0.5284839272,
-0.8322536945,
0.5884869099,
-0.0059624119,
-0.6604633331,
0.1858218014,
0.2066175789,
-0.3516176045,
-0.1320097297,
0.815559566,
0.8914740086,
-0.1280249059,
-0.035507217,
0.2355458438,
0.2342549413,
0.1247728765,
0.4553682208,
1.0593519211,
-0.165982306,
0.1851257235,
-0.1781467199,
-0.2045106441,
-0.3131219149,
-0.9132080674,
-0.8498818874,
-0.7869651318,
-0.1788986027,
0.0603542626,
0.0269728117,
0.8752821088,
0.7143801451,
-0.6957588792,
-0.6088075638,
-0.090220511,
0.2765510976,
-0.6586997509,
-0.2745022476,
0.5240166783,
-0.5259773731,
-0.7539215088,
0.6250944734,
0.4256593585,
-0.1072231755,
-0.3449361622,
-0.0218637008,
-0.2139140815,
0.0374870412,
0.5312114954,
0.3120177686,
-0.9294490814,
-0.2178807259,
-0.0069304141,
0.1121525168,
0.118119657,
1.0377684832,
-0.8386504054,
0.3349366486,
-0.073410362,
0.4869841933,
0.5940672159,
-0.1665043384,
0.4114014804,
-1.0401896238,
0.2061188221,
-0.1605897546,
-0.0480306,
0.1960310936,
-0.37706393,
0.072734952,
-0.2046049386,
-0.6859431267,
-0.816793859,
0.3977470994,
-0.4944306016,
-0.2861314416,
1.1285229921,
-0.0885316506,
-0.1234785244,
0.047180742,
-0.1379223168,
0.2590830624,
-0.233234778,
0.9656922221,
0.5319635272,
-0.3740648329,
-0.1080818549,
-0.8063527942,
0.7361230254,
0.3230244219,
-0.5241077542,
-0.1924084574,
0.1267640889,
0.3829731345,
-0.2711991966,
0.1008635983,
0.272116363,
0.2752761543,
-0.1926840395,
-0.5565049052,
-0.0685608611,
-0.3633413911,
-0.4326612949,
-0.0485961437,
0.252573818,
-0.2141677886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10797v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10797v2
|
TaCo: Enhancing Cross-Lingual Transfer for Low-Resource Languages in LLMs through Translation-Assisted Chain-of-Thought Processes
| 2023-11-17T06:55:32 | 2024-04-05T06:13:15 |
Bibek Upadhayay, Vahid Behzadan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Creating multilingual LLMs poses a significant challenge. Pretraining or
fine-tuning LLMs to adopt new languages is evidently very costly. Furthermore,
there exist limitations concerning benchmark datasets and the metrics used to
measure model performance in multilingual settings. This paper proposes
cost-effective solutions to both aforementioned challenges. Firstly, we
introduce the Multilingual Instruction-Tuning Dataset (MITS), comprised of
Alpaca-52K, Dolly-15K, and Vicuna Benchmark translations into 132 languages.
Secondly, we propose a new method called \emph{TaCo: Translation-Assisted
Cross-Linguality}, which utilizes translations in a chain-of-thought process to
instruction-tune LLMs on new languages through a curriculum-learning process.
As a proof of concept, we experimented with the instruction-tuned Guanaco-33B
model, performing further instruction tuning using our proposed TaCo method in
three low-resource languages and one high-resource language. Our results
indicate that the TaCo method impresses GPT-4 with an 82\% score for a
low-resource language in the Vicuna Benchmark dataset, doubling the performance
in contrast to instruction tuning alone. Furthermore, TaCo shows promise in
creating multilingual LLMs, even for low-resource languages. We have released
our datasets and model adapters\footnote{https://github.com/UNHSAILLab/TaCo} ,
encouraging the research community to utilize these resources to advance work
on multilingual LLMs.
|
[
-0.2842166424,
-0.6604340672,
0.3729544878,
0.2241217643,
-0.2804952264,
0.4723950922,
-0.5358217359,
-0.562027812,
0.3386126757,
0.4889709651,
-0.3387487829,
-0.5282410979,
-0.4568154514,
0.2005333453,
-0.0488755777,
0.9627915621,
-0.3879250884,
0.1490536034,
0.2843571305,
-0.0545042232,
-0.4093614817,
-0.1634505689,
-0.7801591754,
-0.1995794773,
0.9639378786,
0.6785927415,
0.3771524429,
0.741425097,
0.2000326067,
0.2124408782,
0.148467347,
0.7341275811,
-0.2136259675,
-0.1700312942,
-0.3392400146,
-0.6080514193,
-0.648942709,
-0.1621761769,
0.6988603473,
0.5531954169,
-0.1678372324,
0.201564461,
0.2182659507,
0.5898979306,
-0.8230730891,
-0.0151549457,
-0.7620116472,
0.0974422395,
-0.3809595406,
-0.4028751254,
-0.5047977567,
-0.4144428968,
-0.294028759,
-0.7249087691,
-0.102801986,
0.1614146233,
0.4626119137,
0.1448813826,
-0.4815652966,
-0.3633320034,
-0.528260231,
0.8853301406,
-0.3081398904,
0.6227490306,
0.3937366605,
0.1015528291,
-0.0907030851,
-0.4462061524,
-0.3957750797,
-0.0619266592,
0.3494456708,
0.0783292055,
0.0645079464,
-0.1959569603,
0.0185801163,
0.469651103,
-0.2354432493,
0.3262447417,
-0.1629376262,
-0.1827908754,
0.2506682575,
0.1953861713,
0.3059812784,
0.2028548867,
-0.6358487606,
-0.2816717923,
-0.6824626327,
0.0971054956,
0.2788897157,
0.6201459169,
-0.3228532672,
0.2752471268,
0.024530001,
0.6326696873,
-0.247959882,
-0.2445572317,
0.1710560769,
-0.7700237632,
-0.2091957927,
-0.030893391,
0.7433789968,
0.1578670591,
0.3457321227,
-0.2641993165,
-0.2942886353,
-0.1157544479,
0.0502986461,
-0.5193849802,
0.1109603271,
-0.2400645018,
0.1129288375,
-0.0830606371,
-0.2657660544,
-0.6779292822,
0.0319197066,
-0.1237408444,
0.2075149119,
-0.2994916141,
-0.2297875136,
0.2945091426,
0.2805304527,
0.0313943848,
0.2829340994,
-1.0347349644,
0.4311777949,
0.2869495749,
1.1589589119,
-0.3662579656,
-0.5619960427,
-0.5438848734,
0.3237229586,
-0.5742515922,
0.912871182,
-0.5179973245,
-0.2989441156,
-0.0312566087,
0.3033679724,
-0.1644630581,
-0.4684944153,
0.275575757,
-0.3789079785,
0.0891088247,
-0.7864527106,
-0.1523281783,
-0.0169693138,
0.3545660973,
-0.6554458141,
1.2151908875,
0.2318659276,
-0.4388846159,
0.3184040785,
-0.6195594668,
-0.5883753896,
0.0441393703,
0.0041440148,
0.0375569202,
-0.0171518996,
0.4241550863,
0.1853854507,
-0.7053336501,
-0.0029014784,
0.0129655916,
-0.5413226485,
0.1232128069,
-0.4053459167,
0.744508028,
0.4454804659,
-0.3224911392,
-0.0645939782,
-0.4612437189,
0.2994261682,
-0.0677597001,
-0.5574195385,
-0.329990387,
-0.5748443604,
0.0057619596,
0.1900363266,
0.325014025,
-0.2679772973,
0.2649524808,
-0.2102389038,
0.2866044939,
0.6687408686,
-0.2051423192,
0.5234239101,
-0.2878670394,
0.9278002381,
0.0817618221,
0.3033516109,
-0.1717633009,
-0.2325636148,
-0.8903431892,
-0.2282774746,
0.326587528,
0.488419652,
-1.3959430456,
-0.0923747197,
-0.0814474896,
-0.2505684793,
-0.7415069342,
0.3449910283,
0.6393554807,
0.492970854,
0.5550271273,
-0.4061671495,
-0.2985812426,
-0.8024758697,
-0.2231586277,
0.1062801704,
0.2511123419,
0.0279396884,
0.2573690116,
0.103885293,
0.1863804907,
-0.1145704091,
-0.2864029109,
-0.0527708158,
0.0522731654,
0.1102481261,
0.4461265206,
0.5435100198,
-0.2981330156,
-0.7552703023,
0.642703414,
-0.4042496681,
-0.0809282213,
0.0723828897,
-0.3369476497,
0.3673532605,
0.2814179957,
-0.053829886,
-0.0464926921,
0.761441946,
-0.0717326999,
0.3421406448,
-0.3769078255,
0.4860841632,
-1.2712885141,
-0.1833741665,
-0.0409163423,
-0.1387525052,
-0.2075419277,
0.0655781701,
0.1878961176,
0.1595300287,
-0.9208469391,
0.7106329203,
-0.6319422126,
-0.2683915198,
-0.277282238,
-0.109407194,
0.1647512466,
0.7082809806,
-0.1322319061,
1.3022706509,
0.4088196158,
-0.6708696485,
0.3731381595,
-0.1879978776,
-0.6597629189,
0.5555074811,
-0.3865609765,
0.3213631809,
0.3558010757,
0.1077504158,
-0.4549826086,
0.1381972879,
0.5642035604,
0.0288756825,
0.098847799,
-0.2050405592,
-0.6657919884,
0.0348769948,
-0.1151570752,
0.6429958344,
0.0190364942,
-0.6162107587,
0.3916912973,
0.3134250045,
-0.0275199562,
-0.8350069523,
-0.9211888313,
0.1609784067,
-0.2471143156,
-0.192209959,
0.3746086359,
-0.1362569332,
0.0739999563,
-0.0651417896,
-0.0947775021,
-0.1366750002,
0.0159019753,
-0.362307936,
0.2407947332,
-0.2045815885,
0.3098032773,
0.3654799759,
-0.0137762446,
-0.0984848067,
-0.6535429955,
0.5459445119,
-0.4120159745,
-0.1437292397,
-0.2765351236,
0.2224231362,
0.5822054744,
-0.4591520429,
0.6829451919,
0.7273815274,
-0.1958970875,
-0.4510662258,
-0.4930137694,
0.0893611535,
-0.4248349369,
0.3898842931,
-0.7184075713,
-0.6938976049,
0.6663663387,
-0.2104973495,
0.003702831,
-0.0439927839,
0.7720215917,
-0.0178704634,
0.4878599644,
0.716915071,
0.1735661924,
0.7817873955,
-0.2309130728,
-0.0470103733,
-0.8358407021,
-0.3428112268,
-0.3583323359,
-0.4028993845,
-0.7239304185,
-0.7663069367,
0.462032944,
-0.1074786559,
-0.0893858448,
0.5311918855,
-0.286937952,
0.7794490457,
0.6246652007,
0.1367656142,
0.5733063221,
0.20867531,
-0.4914410412,
0.0181031432,
-0.9146150947,
-0.4718218148,
1.0911009312,
0.074575685,
0.8272662759,
0.1000186056,
0.5738429427,
0.1656656712,
0.3411481082,
-0.6930203438,
0.3371634483,
-0.3548792005,
-0.3238143325,
-0.2935090661,
-0.5016942024,
-0.7762601376,
0.2960245609,
-0.2053101212,
-0.5224437118,
0.1157531738,
0.0314379036,
-0.0767315403,
0.5924796462,
-0.8495742083,
0.7756780982,
-0.6549233794,
-0.8060541153,
-0.2491139472,
-0.1326384246,
0.2495253831,
-0.3749494255,
0.3110426366,
-0.1404836029,
-0.3712646365,
0.5940525532,
-0.1673143655,
0.6804986596,
0.1700833291,
-0.6432415843,
0.2294291258,
0.1742976457,
0.548120141,
0.1125454381,
-0.1813084185,
0.2858237326,
0.1492608488,
-0.5180287361,
-0.6327380538,
0.8878168464,
-0.6716932058,
-0.3670544624,
-0.1947889924,
-1.0344296694,
-0.299837023,
0.2827030718,
0.2352938503,
0.0151752438,
0.0017250655,
-0.1512021869,
0.4127255678,
-0.2166708559,
0.4123954475,
0.7002710104,
-0.0303619802,
-0.5706289411,
0.9226139784,
0.3531114757,
0.3860991001,
0.5141409039,
0.1609119624,
-0.2933244109,
-0.2890144885,
-0.6026415229,
0.3109457195,
-0.5140421391,
-0.2231406122,
-0.2241906077,
0.1771032065,
-0.1303682327,
-0.1098121256,
-0.7622648478,
-0.2456680983,
0.0141040804,
0.0233818647,
0.2603834271,
0.4117639959,
-0.0035790843,
0.3371629119,
-0.5614094138,
-0.0277453251,
0.010520515,
0.5547554493,
0.1021773145,
-0.4949865639,
-0.9109506011,
0.2372750342,
-0.1492831409,
-0.5383511782,
0.3016381264,
-0.0318506248,
0.2739148736,
-0.0960070267,
0.0257259086,
0.9317751527,
-0.3290829957,
0.2522399426,
0.368956387,
-1.0997997522,
0.6029605269,
-0.0854286626,
0.3468722403,
0.558142066,
0.4816474319,
-0.588751018,
-0.3723420203,
-0.1518466324,
-0.5415023565,
0.6503531337,
-0.2021122724,
0.0526335053,
-0.2973948717,
0.1726372987,
0.3559492528,
0.0321861282,
-0.7141469717,
-0.0177810378,
0.098144725,
0.0751932114,
-0.0209678207,
0.0289133471,
-0.1415073574,
-0.2314204127,
0.6127452254,
-0.3916060627,
-0.1470601261,
-0.1504290998,
-0.1577827334,
-0.1764933169,
0.4361201525,
0.5371824503,
0.587435782,
0.0366636924,
0.1926517189,
0.5140553713,
-0.2560716271,
0.3735778332,
-0.3769142628,
0.0391757786,
-0.1849181056,
0.279178381,
0.7823145986,
0.4691300392,
-0.4548989832,
0.0531915426,
-0.0114520025,
-0.0430668779,
-0.079607591,
0.2085551172,
0.0902611613,
0.3251490295,
-0.0623768829,
-0.1046208739,
-0.1842016429,
-0.6314296722,
-0.0702583641,
0.1849317104,
-0.2601110935,
-0.3900667429,
0.5070993304,
0.4443296194,
-0.2053595632,
0.5670877695,
-0.0275859777,
-0.0433369204,
0.4727120996,
0.7643449306,
0.6777331829,
-0.3184394836,
0.2774491906,
0.3385001421,
0.520150423,
-0.3542941809,
0.2810444236,
-0.405238241,
-0.8361206055,
-0.6450666189,
-0.3488180041,
-0.6164811254,
-0.0265594516,
-0.9354630113,
0.5021185279,
-0.3559235632,
-0.3587839603,
-0.3722041845,
0.1694466472,
-0.8269660473,
-0.0951989815,
0.0448106341,
0.7180694342,
-1.011664629,
1.3184753656,
0.8238224387,
-0.4761238992,
-0.5845149159,
-0.2514087856,
-0.328338176,
-1.084007144,
0.4861960411,
-0.3773384392,
-0.6425206661,
0.034024246,
-0.0317740887,
-0.7901132107,
0.9943899512,
0.8248095512,
-0.7846524119,
-0.1783053428,
0.1884371042,
0.3443483114,
-0.4193072915,
0.3082941175,
0.5214927793,
0.4355864823,
0.0179710444,
-1.0177394152,
0.0143577624,
-0.1075392663,
0.1032871008,
0.3040122688,
-0.9484823346,
0.866661191,
-0.4297583997,
-0.3367566466,
-0.2214163989,
0.4209920764,
0.120174244,
0.1978772134,
0.4002439082,
0.4121159911,
1.0293289423,
-0.0151031222,
0.949693799,
-0.4634163082,
0.184969157,
1.1652405262,
-0.2438695133,
0.7056240439,
0.7603299022,
-0.0794530734,
0.3880949318,
0.6163176894,
0.2109668702,
0.4295964241,
0.0579333864,
-0.2953168452,
-0.2966242433,
-0.7050472498,
-0.44326213,
0.511869669,
0.355604142,
-0.2756019235,
-0.084835045,
0.05879803,
0.0046151895,
0.2981579602,
-0.193290323,
0.3937348425,
0.0978795141,
-0.5772801042,
0.8977279067,
0.01062309,
0.7170156837,
-0.5745022893,
0.0797491223,
-0.6165927649,
-0.0027444267,
-0.1170900464,
-0.6842252016,
0.1703278422,
0.2831521034,
-0.214755252,
-0.5296633244,
-0.0006107001,
-0.7182973623,
-0.5948553085,
0.5136607885,
0.9055644274,
0.1585879922,
0.3735497594,
-0.5469884276,
0.3653781116,
-0.0499538817,
0.0747054443,
0.3966403306,
0.6167420745,
-0.3581505716,
0.7296261787,
0.6123217344,
0.5044860244,
-0.0343562476,
0.4675557017,
0.6260488629,
-0.6965804696,
-0.5986844897,
-0.6183533669,
0.0728766173,
0.3852750063,
-0.5528672338,
0.4745847285,
0.5188371539,
1.4359902143,
0.0290016141,
0.4793841243,
0.2805818319,
0.1111018136,
-0.9166067839,
0.4923265278,
-0.7753427029,
0.4392310679,
-0.0673323646,
-1.0202493668,
0.0231263749,
0.3708688915,
-0.2609658837,
-0.0134585975,
1.0640408993,
0.7341116071,
-0.0461720191,
-0.2636758387,
0.386618197,
-0.2443046272,
0.1512563527,
1.1119955778,
0.8961822987,
-0.5596527457,
0.657230258,
-0.4601598084,
-0.1371978074,
0.1654410362,
-0.7986261845,
-0.749234736,
-0.5328060389,
-0.3834719658,
-0.048921451,
0.2414336354,
0.917211175,
0.5682188272,
-0.5647357702,
-0.7175424099,
0.2095626593,
0.4355890155,
-0.5491783619,
-0.1407212466,
0.1919556558,
-0.5397543907,
-1.2281832695,
0.5773399472,
0.3020803332,
-0.0175084509,
-0.1409943998,
-0.1146290153,
-0.2024430037,
-0.244261533,
0.5835917592,
0.2949908674,
-0.8184403777,
-0.1294731796,
0.1223298237,
-0.2033041716,
0.1920437962,
0.9450697303,
-0.5837426782,
0.5584690571,
0.0174160711,
0.7821224928,
0.617284596,
-0.4019722641,
0.6114913225,
-0.7441740036,
0.4316893816,
0.0564301945,
0.2395862937,
0.2313770205,
-0.3093205094,
0.5849019885,
-0.0405894257,
-0.0177961495,
-0.7699120045,
0.1582126021,
-0.7303068042,
-0.0655352101,
0.8066620827,
-0.0177495889,
-0.3062287569,
0.1527448893,
0.2633748353,
0.5390031338,
-0.2914891839,
0.7683705688,
0.7464146614,
0.0158915389,
-0.4011325538,
-0.5094888806,
0.0770230293,
0.5352310538,
-0.8181112409,
-0.013070452,
0.0674870089,
0.3053785861,
-0.1869870126,
0.6191177368,
-0.2731344998,
0.3461176157,
-0.0589482374,
0.4229559004,
-0.4650571942,
-0.5401588678,
-0.0530503206,
-0.2545363605,
0.0596057884,
-0.4946815073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10344v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10344v1
|
Complementary Advantages of ChatGPTs and Human Readers in Reasoning: Evidence from English Text Reading Comprehension
| 2023-11-17T06:13:02 | 2023-11-17T06:13:02 |
Tongquan Zhou, Yao Zhang, Siyi Cao, Yulu Li, Tao Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
ChatGPT has shown its great power in text processing, including its reasoning
ability from text reading. However, there has not been any direct comparison
between human readers and ChatGPT in reasoning ability related to text reading.
This study was undertaken to investigate how ChatGPTs (i.e., ChatGPT and
ChatGPT Plus) and Chinese senior school students as ESL learners exhibited
their reasoning ability from English narrative texts. Additionally, we compared
the two ChatGPTs in the reasoning performances when commands were updated
elaborately. The whole study was composed of three reasoning tests: Test 1 for
commonsense inference, Test 2 for emotional inference, and Test 3 for causal
inference. The results showed that in Test 1, the students outdid the two
ChatGPT versions in local-culture-related inferences but performed worse than
the chatbots in daily-life inferences. In Test 2, ChatGPT Plus excelled whereas
ChatGPT lagged behind in accuracy. In association with both accuracy and
frequency of correct responses, the students were inferior to the two chatbots.
Compared with ChatGPTs' better performance in positive emotions, the students
showed their superiority in inferring negative emotions. In Test 3, the
students demonstrated better logical analysis, outdoing both chatbots. In
updating command condition, ChatGPT Plus displayed good causal reasoning
ability while ChatGPT kept unchanged. Our study reveals that human readers and
ChatGPTs have their respective advantages and disadvantages in drawing
inferences from text reading comprehension, unlocking a complementary
relationship in text-based reasoning.
|
[
-0.2040714025,
-0.7273235321,
0.5340492129,
0.0233213231,
-0.2465913594,
0.266618073,
-0.2198065817,
-0.7251905799,
-0.3603667617,
0.2553910613,
-0.4604191482,
-0.1290602684,
-0.1866425723,
0.2102220803,
-0.1067105904,
0.8536328673,
0.1030693278,
0.1378216892,
-0.2278820723,
-0.0631664917,
-0.5653273463,
-0.7782573104,
-0.9976783395,
-0.778567493,
0.5919032693,
0.3665353358,
0.8572836518,
-0.0208487939,
0.5294767022,
0.3621487319,
-0.1159352809,
0.1829147488,
-0.0210968666,
0.1673633605,
-0.2115626335,
-0.5877060294,
-0.3351149261,
-0.0937626958,
0.2142348588,
0.4852443039,
0.1023485512,
-0.2412659973,
0.4113405645,
0.9066708684,
-0.3991802335,
-0.0208809115,
-0.3393631577,
0.1086676791,
0.0293545127,
-0.4588421881,
-0.6818339825,
-0.2914530635,
0.5787276626,
-0.5992862582,
0.331902504,
0.131296441,
1.0991523266,
0.3343425393,
-0.6687541008,
-0.45647946,
-0.3582525849,
0.759054184,
-0.5160466433,
0.4012988806,
0.189991802,
0.2504982948,
0.1197868362,
-0.3862366676,
-0.5831195116,
-0.3892830014,
-0.4714326859,
0.6743897796,
0.0249380786,
0.2461616546,
0.2549315989,
0.2151704729,
-0.7914984226,
-0.0839302614,
-0.3203734756,
-0.1104763448,
0.4689730406,
-0.1498541534,
0.5710468292,
-0.5107738972,
-0.7272138596,
-0.1812016666,
-0.6342402697,
0.305611968,
0.1594146788,
0.0313928388,
0.0669480264,
0.4250559211,
-0.0280176923,
0.4490534067,
-0.2511904538,
-0.0873377398,
0.1716982275,
-0.1490488797,
-0.2335514724,
0.0270471796,
0.6113581657,
0.4695771933,
0.8776557446,
-0.2890120447,
0.206727013,
0.2470178008,
-0.2458624691,
-0.5716632605,
-0.1832493246,
0.177493766,
-0.5564630628,
0.1106580421,
0.1612691581,
-0.6088510752,
-0.4014527798,
-0.395329386,
0.441649437,
-0.719332993,
-0.0635628924,
0.4943267703,
-0.6406676173,
0.7201066017,
0.7196229696,
-0.8824780583,
0.2371447831,
0.7192198634,
0.7258934379,
-0.3975840509,
-0.3979122937,
0.0560572445,
-0.066202566,
0.1448968202,
1.2729525566,
-0.3013103008,
-0.1829265207,
-0.3767128885,
-0.2731077671,
-0.4210781753,
-0.1201942638,
1.174744606,
-0.2689914107,
0.53899616,
-0.4451973736,
-0.5587493181,
-0.4241925478,
0.2104671896,
-0.2764807642,
0.9472177029,
-0.3820012808,
-0.9045083523,
0.1847498268,
-0.3028272986,
-0.555244267,
0.1219004765,
-0.0455040522,
0.0644830167,
-0.4657134414,
0.3072258234,
0.5093342662,
-0.2123697996,
0.1018431708,
-0.0033152972,
-0.5377749205,
0.4354932904,
-0.9632525444,
1.0414034128,
0.2355350703,
-0.4536830187,
-0.2298104614,
-0.2087873966,
0.0724638402,
0.0579493679,
-0.152069211,
-0.1954465508,
0.5463215709,
-0.2279825956,
0.196043849,
-0.0930716172,
-0.5480841994,
0.1753423512,
-0.1628630161,
0.5619859099,
0.571715951,
-0.0395010337,
0.2440481782,
-0.5675534606,
0.2017124593,
-0.2585268021,
-0.1722998023,
-0.4759555459,
-0.7833549976,
-0.8190919757,
-0.0094751325,
-0.0872279629,
1.1738516092,
-0.7942596674,
0.1601647735,
-0.0054733548,
-0.5808930993,
-0.1282445043,
-0.3205798268,
0.3156566322,
0.6726054549,
0.2430117726,
0.1190303564,
-0.0096345721,
-0.4734682739,
-0.7489663363,
-0.5380202532,
-0.3622618616,
0.3917082846,
0.3303080797,
0.2877337635,
0.5919786096,
-0.5141490102,
0.0344473161,
-0.4702649415,
-0.0807297304,
-0.0025585175,
0.3017089963,
0.432045877,
-0.8579087853,
-0.5783451796,
0.1232134625,
-0.6905238628,
-0.3327586353,
-0.6240109801,
-0.2563020587,
0.1821687967,
0.2439577729,
-0.6747027636,
0.3215817511,
0.2959116697,
-0.8057582974,
0.7508653998,
-0.1467500329,
0.512645185,
-0.557708621,
-0.3014202714,
0.1215290427,
-0.3064388633,
-0.5284634829,
0.0546995774,
0.0970697775,
-0.0690668076,
-0.3652172685,
0.5739408731,
-0.4742764533,
0.131408304,
0.0808905959,
0.6639140844,
0.2120600045,
0.6192814708,
0.4958125353,
0.6317701936,
0.4331262112,
-0.3301120996,
0.3467175961,
0.01123867,
0.0034853343,
0.5640261769,
-0.8672742248,
-0.0540152825,
-0.0923265517,
0.3382901251,
-1.165697217,
-0.0418357924,
0.2789005339,
-0.7771200538,
0.0111745177,
0.3970421851,
-0.3319608271,
-0.3006900251,
-0.183823958,
-0.3086011708,
0.6257979274,
-0.5569201112,
0.5686066747,
-0.190183714,
-0.1501337141,
-0.5260688066,
-0.8162128925,
-0.113344796,
-0.2112539411,
-0.8237637877,
-0.0376863852,
0.1154231355,
-0.3939163685,
0.1245854646,
-0.063002117,
-0.1682518274,
-0.0416741446,
0.1743097603,
0.426418364,
-0.2401553839,
0.5011101365,
-0.1133051068,
-0.4500744045,
-0.0132981036,
0.1074853316,
0.2560968697,
-0.5471154451,
-0.6493402123,
-0.4637077749,
0.2061586231,
0.2926321924,
-0.2384864539,
0.6908706427,
0.5050612688,
0.0635293275,
0.0649156421,
-0.5792944431,
-0.2893467247,
-0.4585712552,
0.0000957489,
-0.3613121808,
-0.8058035374,
0.3533545732,
0.2530964017,
0.1178011075,
0.5147629976,
0.3496219814,
-0.3880061507,
0.8744359612,
-0.1989220977,
0.057458967,
0.3992969394,
0.2613186538,
0.1505467296,
-0.5794975162,
-0.1212981045,
-0.7696658969,
-0.1859688014,
-0.681473434,
-0.1293030977,
0.0349797346,
-0.0315436721,
-0.4869896472,
0.1427659243,
-0.6439025998,
0.8132337928,
0.5619161725,
0.3723570108,
0.6947280765,
-0.1917586625,
0.0984565318,
-0.1370779425,
-0.4813990295,
-0.7821735144,
0.5978426337,
0.1684669703,
0.6157065034,
0.275379926,
0.3008929491,
0.1937603205,
0.1749393344,
-0.8130761385,
0.6270785928,
-0.1375116408,
-0.5390057564,
-0.1635480374,
-0.4949211478,
-0.8331875205,
0.680375874,
-0.0183203034,
-0.8545338511,
-0.0942048132,
0.0094473986,
-0.1399423331,
0.4249903858,
-1.3687552214,
0.8062905073,
-0.3379358947,
-0.4729477465,
-0.1084751785,
-0.8153508902,
0.1203767806,
0.4022222757,
-0.0296272747,
-0.0076680803,
0.0267382879,
0.3765585423,
-0.1590660661,
0.8313239813,
0.0873143449,
0.1375068277,
0.6522598267,
-0.1654956192,
0.2037304193,
0.0024781267,
-0.2144014239,
-0.1073196828,
0.0995220616,
-0.6644495726,
-0.6355223656,
0.308763206,
-0.8187844753,
-0.8627411127,
-0.7778753042,
-0.4005834162,
-0.107878238,
0.1031695902,
0.1801123172,
0.4562407136,
-0.0399673991,
0.3933688998,
0.4650498331,
-0.3028936684,
0.4492854476,
0.471765399,
0.0248852372,
0.131104961,
0.603605628,
0.0037112096,
0.8205456734,
0.6216137409,
0.3970109522,
-0.3023171723,
-0.0980393365,
-0.4494354129,
0.2545116544,
-0.6751827598,
0.2578641176,
-0.5778034925,
-0.204306528,
-0.0203704294,
-0.6634844542,
-0.0059093386,
-0.4984941781,
0.0647281557,
-0.0424722843,
0.2030636072,
0.339669168,
0.1221964434,
0.1906952411,
-0.6374436617,
0.1830853969,
0.3586706817,
-0.1087771729,
0.1335014105,
-0.349526763,
0.283717066,
-0.072218433,
-0.585881114,
-1.2205674648,
0.2154961377,
0.0852367505,
0.3272491395,
0.6386450529,
0.0474012829,
0.4990599155,
-0.3067072928,
1.032212019,
-0.230745241,
-0.8654095531,
0.3102382421,
-0.4695484936,
0.4761529267,
0.3801713288,
0.1644342989,
-0.9025839567,
-0.5283507109,
-0.6178465486,
-0.2976312041,
0.6083920598,
0.4549726546,
0.1337174475,
0.0750418082,
0.2035048157,
0.0098306248,
-0.262219429,
-0.7071152925,
-0.2471423447,
-0.1446989775,
0.1467210054,
-0.0077280942,
0.0376770645,
0.5449215174,
-0.4299297035,
0.5924966931,
0.1887176335,
0.246612072,
0.5321298242,
0.0313723832,
0.298620075,
0.4960955083,
0.3204586804,
0.2215311229,
-0.2572767735,
0.2380670905,
0.3882735372,
-0.7177340984,
0.1111526489,
0.0049220151,
-0.1543329954,
-0.0754956082,
0.8492125273,
0.5854200721,
0.149685353,
-0.7830225229,
0.4538947642,
-0.3480381072,
-0.0703417286,
-0.0006865165,
0.2073719651,
0.403670907,
0.3182638288,
0.3435203135,
0.5134154558,
0.0702065974,
-0.3866054714,
0.1147590205,
0.1757717878,
-0.2769470811,
-0.1924731582,
0.5444898605,
0.3819604218,
-0.2128409147,
0.5790153146,
-0.3979698718,
-0.8742319345,
0.731723547,
0.6356104016,
0.7650845051,
-0.1030875742,
0.370840162,
0.42817536,
0.3761922121,
-0.1311039478,
0.0272676572,
-0.3205894828,
-1.0683189631,
-0.5124303102,
-0.029260518,
-0.77038908,
-0.3507078588,
-0.4839395881,
0.2664706111,
0.1187203005,
0.1627673656,
-0.0889316574,
0.2608265281,
-0.4750769734,
0.1398967505,
-0.0498569831,
0.723952949,
-0.7205962539,
0.6359423399,
0.6162384748,
-0.4012143314,
-0.9102137089,
0.2354924977,
0.2810152471,
-0.537514627,
0.5458273292,
0.3693342805,
-0.2269679308,
-0.0502056107,
0.0346110351,
-0.3171502054,
1.0444177389,
0.2392884642,
-0.4907782972,
0.01798095,
0.0134926736,
0.7942224145,
0.2768180966,
0.8850746751,
0.5261868238,
0.4104605317,
0.3603688478,
-0.7435155511,
-0.1326806396,
-0.1860070378,
-0.6913138032,
0.178187713,
-0.8713199496,
0.8922271729,
-0.2721815109,
-0.5928897262,
-0.1896590739,
0.5218046904,
0.2861285806,
0.4220324755,
0.4016962349,
0.3251612186,
0.8621097207,
-0.3752563,
1.344473958,
0.0796822459,
0.3722790778,
0.9229267836,
-0.130547002,
0.8970193267,
0.2903164029,
-0.3348547518,
0.5366093516,
0.6603582501,
0.3390536606,
0.1821358055,
-0.288702786,
-0.554050386,
-0.4556236863,
0.0653287545,
-0.3442260027,
0.1901737601,
0.1582080573,
0.0100402422,
-0.4095871747,
-0.148198992,
0.4000748992,
0.2231487781,
-0.0493881628,
0.5800256133,
0.1885590255,
-0.9376439452,
0.2716374993,
-0.2556923926,
0.6400706172,
-0.3426083922,
0.1704474986,
-0.1967918426,
0.3052344024,
-0.1875494272,
-1.3030632734,
0.2980817854,
0.2262034714,
0.2718040347,
-0.2420868874,
1.2561070919,
-0.1824323237,
-0.2631750703,
0.2941597104,
0.6358388662,
0.3484734893,
-0.2136437297,
-0.8106110692,
-0.4867866933,
0.1878810376,
-0.6457132697,
-0.0585064888,
0.7429754734,
-0.0834887922,
0.76278615,
0.5108959675,
0.077501148,
-0.2962504327,
0.1726036221,
0.4889173508,
-0.6776368022,
-0.2786701322,
-1.1777415276,
0.5105748773,
-0.1863316745,
-0.3871071637,
0.9403914213,
0.2924832404,
0.5349149108,
-0.0013717115,
0.6931625605,
-0.0326055698,
0.5157291889,
-0.5056587458,
0.572758317,
-0.1892490089,
0.093326807,
-0.406414628,
-0.6596521735,
-0.3542894125,
0.6948251724,
-0.6884418726,
-0.067367658,
1.0090464354,
0.4737319052,
0.177333802,
0.5617679358,
0.1712930501,
-0.1705937535,
0.4423420727,
0.881608665,
0.9956196547,
-0.2869332433,
0.3964098692,
-0.000136454,
-0.4187771082,
0.1710368842,
-0.8161224127,
-1.3643735647,
-0.3686670661,
-0.0386122912,
-0.0591071174,
0.1299971342,
0.6927418709,
0.1372392476,
-0.4994807541,
0.1027297527,
-0.2345705181,
0.5571312308,
-0.3564335108,
-0.3367327154,
0.6344476342,
-0.3607146442,
-0.826470077,
-0.2291607559,
0.2129217684,
-0.0834392384,
0.0959635451,
-0.1554811746,
-0.1529929191,
0.2089498639,
0.8565176725,
0.2515516579,
-0.7215922475,
-0.6072087288,
0.2140953541,
-0.2653098702,
0.0956632197,
0.5561327934,
-0.7366548181,
0.2816858292,
0.9515196085,
0.5278957486,
0.4044897556,
0.4182579517,
0.301776737,
-0.1828016341,
0.3813151717,
0.1948003173,
0.3548987508,
0.2826323509,
-0.3082618713,
0.6630706191,
0.3988510072,
-1.0084773302,
-0.3591546416,
0.1447599977,
-1.0437281132,
-0.3244302869,
1.1052110195,
-0.1482517719,
-0.0083093913,
-0.2150177509,
-1.0384664536,
0.2691387236,
-0.5246521831,
0.4708959162,
1.0752192736,
-0.43222031,
-0.3485508859,
-0.879072845,
0.3293280303,
0.7162263989,
-1.1007509232,
0.0179560296,
0.2764591873,
-0.1978961229,
-0.110153459,
0.5632710457,
0.0095196059,
0.2572447062,
0.223665148,
-0.1017100811,
0.2228743881,
0.1260372102,
0.210297972,
0.0579276942,
-0.2785600722,
0.0225301124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10271v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10271v1
|
Prompt Pool based Class-Incremental Continual Learning for Dialog State Tracking
| 2023-11-17T01:33:05 | 2023-11-17T01:33:05 |
Hong Liu, Yucheng Cai, Yuan Zhou, Zhijian Ou, Yi Huang, Junlan Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Continual learning is crucial for dialog state tracking (DST) in dialog
systems, since requirements from users for new functionalities are often
encountered. However, most of existing continual learning methods for DST
require task identities during testing, which is a severe limit in real-world
applications. In this paper, we aim to address continual learning of DST in the
class-incremental scenario (namely the task identity is unknown in testing).
Inspired by the recently emerging prompt tuning method that performs well on
dialog systems, we propose to use the prompt pool method, where we maintain a
pool of key-value paired prompts and select prompts from the pool according to
the distance between the dialog history and the prompt keys. The proposed
method can automatically identify tasks and select appropriate prompts during
testing. We conduct experiments on Schema-Guided Dialog dataset (SGD) and
another dataset collected from a real-world dialog application. Experiment
results show that the prompt pool method achieves much higher joint goal
accuracy than the baseline. After combining with a rehearsal buffer, the model
performance can be further improved.
|
[
-0.2188578993,
-0.6934782267,
0.5364230871,
-0.1212180406,
-0.2579717338,
0.2411390692,
-0.0968901664,
-0.1006214842,
-0.1598113775,
0.3122976124,
-1.0845012665,
-0.2616217136,
-0.1802305877,
0.1807090342,
0.0167994052,
0.9206826687,
0.0013834311,
-0.0147661855,
-0.2695958316,
-0.1567956358,
-1.2228696346,
-0.243228361,
-1.0546635389,
-0.0947115943,
0.4673888981,
0.5164026618,
0.0946315825,
0.3880878091,
-0.0384344794,
0.2865400016,
0.1469931751,
0.4135666192,
-0.2957971692,
0.7579534054,
-0.1344210505,
-0.4231609702,
-0.0117127979,
0.1984551251,
0.7859067321,
0.6283327341,
0.0172857195,
0.2915896177,
0.3767853379,
0.5350077748,
-0.6330850124,
0.6671117544,
-0.5756881833,
0.2630913854,
0.0077719749,
-0.5050790906,
-0.4929173589,
-0.4229651392,
0.274666667,
-0.561707437,
0.3044948876,
0.1855677664,
0.5438753366,
0.2802268863,
-0.3848027587,
-0.4887627661,
-0.4229589105,
0.6797614098,
-0.3970172703,
0.2782759666,
0.1743712723,
0.3885750771,
0.0268067215,
-0.4104481041,
-0.5775310993,
-0.4879554808,
0.0662097409,
0.2253835499,
0.3488203883,
0.1271922588,
0.3654345274,
0.2186062783,
-0.8082267642,
-0.0184862819,
-0.1067023873,
-0.4961975813,
0.5588390231,
0.571747601,
0.242305398,
0.099902764,
-0.6207433939,
0.0675709173,
-0.5339028835,
0.3196376562,
-0.1178418547,
0.7146248221,
0.0255453363,
0.2408667803,
-0.151490137,
0.9707040191,
0.3719116151,
-0.260958463,
0.0899419859,
-0.3321789205,
-0.1258360744,
0.3004151881,
0.2878725529,
0.2181666791,
-0.0010069964,
-0.2885910273,
-0.3121116757,
0.2403685004,
0.1919861436,
-0.4710562229,
-0.132876724,
-0.0103723658,
-0.1099361256,
-0.2077619582,
-0.1423446089,
-0.6638846397,
-0.3742373884,
-0.724208653,
0.5798081756,
-0.3158072829,
-0.125414148,
-0.3913698196,
0.1497054398,
0.1238999218,
0.5179272294,
-0.6161523461,
0.243636325,
0.6477798223,
1.033378005,
-0.429831028,
-0.2827322781,
-1.1986576319,
-0.0655905455,
-0.1725421548,
0.7026639581,
-0.6970683336,
-0.4564279914,
0.0848386735,
0.0468635447,
-0.6859728098,
-0.456620127,
-0.0803225115,
-0.5756523013,
0.5424227715,
-0.4036344588,
-1.1615101099,
0.1128605157,
0.3879353702,
-0.219957754,
0.9467764497,
0.2675873935,
-0.3448985815,
0.3496555388,
-0.6605413556,
-0.0402746312,
0.6343207359,
-0.1937252134,
-0.3893984556,
-0.1648526788,
-0.1810235828,
0.3979254961,
0.0529876687,
0.2333554775,
-0.2542121112,
-0.6832832098,
0.0808884948,
-0.4070088267,
0.6608532667,
0.288960427,
-0.4125378132,
0.1067843363,
-0.4260051548,
0.0803747401,
-0.1180705801,
-0.0395581275,
-0.1665674001,
-0.2325163931,
-0.3004123867,
0.2532228231,
0.2526716292,
-0.4716511667,
0.2423195839,
0.0405426733,
0.1744968891,
1.0803034306,
0.5439115763,
0.2998860776,
-0.5294271111,
0.739094317,
0.0325120874,
0.1065876707,
-0.7349516153,
-0.3733333349,
-0.6667721868,
-0.3382915258,
0.1586354375,
0.7537032366,
-0.7461853027,
0.5463299751,
-0.0474322699,
-0.2410975844,
-0.0487384647,
0.0689940453,
0.4639678299,
0.9177032113,
0.2027465552,
-0.3271287084,
-0.0125594167,
-0.2844638824,
-0.2205879986,
-0.2930861413,
-0.1004361659,
0.5364488363,
0.3010763228,
0.138275817,
1.0278304815,
-0.6292806864,
-0.4412995577,
-0.2216109931,
0.0261752997,
-0.1056142077,
0.5096607804,
0.2340364307,
-0.6065942049,
-0.6975606084,
-0.4144369066,
-0.5925741196,
-0.0998856872,
-0.5373331904,
0.0460626408,
0.266664356,
0.4800483882,
-0.3869303167,
0.2942225933,
0.2611886263,
-0.592916131,
0.613114059,
-0.1282009631,
0.1618202329,
-0.8485302925,
-0.1102776378,
0.211251542,
-0.4132132828,
-0.4477967024,
-0.2262763828,
0.2702391446,
-0.4456245601,
-0.2759578824,
0.7922748327,
-0.3366781473,
0.0964054093,
-0.2709549367,
0.2742120326,
-0.2588264048,
0.7837477326,
-0.0050704004,
1.0570459366,
0.6928497553,
-0.9193006158,
0.5275886655,
0.2231007218,
-0.2164140791,
1.1293673515,
-0.3063897192,
0.1941274703,
-0.1017061919,
0.4394967258,
-1.1063345671,
0.0343319476,
0.4018978477,
-0.3050813675,
0.3779233396,
-0.2189895958,
-0.2438904047,
-0.2162986249,
0.1419499665,
0.0606129542,
0.4616654515,
-0.5839264393,
0.2844661176,
0.2691676319,
-0.375349015,
-0.2242483944,
0.1843181998,
-0.2401002645,
-0.3819888234,
-0.2975026071,
0.1002592295,
-0.2411227822,
0.1265752763,
-0.3331674337,
-0.622061789,
-0.0336965285,
0.1448336244,
0.4365217388,
0.504021287,
0.1347807944,
0.7458662987,
-0.0187477227,
-0.3243359029,
-0.009964196,
-0.5150434971,
0.5776677728,
-0.1720467508,
-0.1710802466,
-0.86395365,
0.3810536265,
0.3750241697,
-0.163445279,
0.472815901,
0.1900479347,
-0.1538118571,
-0.3960031271,
-0.5980089903,
-0.5156805515,
-0.4962629378,
0.0138556575,
-0.3767323494,
-1.1014306545,
0.3919485509,
-0.2738057971,
0.1638219059,
0.1275558323,
0.1406916678,
-0.4658328593,
0.7005195618,
0.5693351626,
-0.3107833564,
0.7799047828,
-0.0940477028,
0.0329080373,
-0.6276980042,
-0.2082691491,
-0.365748316,
-0.1956628412,
-0.169769004,
-0.0118270162,
0.6769567132,
-0.2428984642,
-0.4529778063,
0.2264491767,
-0.3952174783,
0.3842379451,
0.5001959205,
0.3629065752,
0.2780972123,
-0.1684816331,
-0.1140649319,
-0.1164889261,
-0.5734405518,
-0.2543573976,
0.6538200974,
-0.0114724645,
0.2072363645,
-0.2882134318,
0.8004502058,
0.6042276621,
0.1949978173,
-0.5299971104,
0.7432491183,
0.6048153043,
-0.3420082927,
-0.6226120591,
-0.6804261208,
-0.9547669888,
0.2171308398,
0.2034225762,
-0.8346068263,
-0.2241840959,
0.4735817909,
-0.5454693437,
0.0941821784,
-0.5406091809,
0.977806747,
0.0232390203,
-0.352846235,
-0.2802916169,
-0.6939337254,
0.0784451887,
0.0271097105,
-0.2313471287,
-0.271912545,
0.0835109428,
0.5458959937,
-0.4028464556,
1.0513880253,
-0.7002234459,
-0.0254908036,
0.3583824635,
0.0785074532,
0.8025885224,
0.3260671794,
0.1890127361,
-0.3229632378,
0.0983195081,
-0.4904699028,
-0.6243232489,
0.7426977754,
-0.3321569562,
-0.5013042688,
-0.6740632057,
-0.5459054112,
-0.6136186719,
0.1051802635,
0.1011840776,
0.7128353715,
0.1071659476,
-0.3166804016,
0.9519193769,
-0.0378105231,
0.5721393228,
0.6536632776,
0.1696261317,
0.0049470854,
0.9494313002,
0.1462138295,
0.3426888883,
0.1689567864,
0.09725485,
-0.4824956059,
-0.2187362313,
-0.4531756341,
0.163755551,
-0.3939702809,
-0.3870301545,
-0.5583366752,
-0.1641697884,
-0.1786919981,
-0.2343642265,
-0.2011349499,
-0.1465907544,
-0.3373067379,
0.0171104334,
0.2764722407,
0.095450297,
0.1362751424,
0.1439435333,
-0.8719478846,
0.1138520539,
0.7022523284,
0.4033668339,
-0.1218483597,
-0.5822989941,
0.0082239397,
0.1455689073,
-0.3436841369,
-0.8295696378,
0.1218434647,
0.2997380197,
0.51103127,
0.2674240768,
0.3503016829,
0.6757587194,
-0.3404476941,
0.8131886721,
0.1382491738,
-0.8557269573,
0.6914781332,
-0.3162364066,
0.62295717,
0.9043048024,
0.2466028631,
-1.0005351305,
-0.4604389966,
-0.5975827575,
-0.5488855243,
0.5934355855,
-0.07014364,
0.2081475407,
-0.0135997264,
0.4782238901,
0.2720703483,
0.2455559969,
-0.3873915076,
-0.3138128221,
0.2033619732,
-0.1775104553,
-0.0630836189,
0.008172119,
0.0540838651,
-0.0495517962,
0.7705330849,
-0.38790223,
0.2099190801,
0.0706795827,
-0.2343255728,
0.0403684564,
0.0975259244,
0.4529904723,
0.5922061205,
-0.1225719079,
-0.2537537515,
0.2018012404,
-0.4843409956,
0.4057581723,
0.0121785048,
-0.2634457052,
-0.0291117467,
0.0557228513,
0.7922193408,
0.2357026637,
-0.735915482,
0.5573761463,
-0.1371362656,
0.0823205709,
-0.6512849927,
0.4253012538,
-0.4024389088,
0.4060715139,
0.3393646479,
0.2575780153,
0.0558229685,
-0.3956295848,
0.3807345629,
0.3370318115,
-0.7726714015,
-0.0816902146,
0.3350757957,
0.3938862085,
-0.2972676456,
1.0219694376,
-0.4901879132,
-0.3878226876,
0.4687574804,
0.4439794421,
0.873678565,
-0.3662807345,
0.4834622145,
0.5895301104,
-0.207024619,
-0.1396930963,
0.2574936748,
-0.7327433825,
-0.5980579853,
-0.2593857944,
-0.2495054603,
-0.6106507778,
0.0190297179,
-0.7477295399,
0.0337338597,
-0.2218431234,
0.0598805733,
-0.4492035508,
0.3880294561,
-0.6190431118,
0.1726607382,
0.1717036366,
0.7293019891,
-0.8429763317,
0.6541529894,
0.3359991014,
-0.1032537222,
-0.6893994808,
0.1061470583,
0.4323041737,
-0.6102982163,
0.4016751051,
0.5396589637,
0.0343214683,
0.2090280056,
-0.4022272825,
-0.7694383264,
1.2301398516,
0.0800761655,
-0.7856152654,
-0.0085493028,
-0.2618056238,
0.2898801267,
-0.3852345943,
-0.0382334702,
0.5035996437,
0.2860167325,
0.1939759254,
-0.8077890873,
0.0143812858,
-0.2351201177,
0.0194077305,
0.2019221485,
-0.7680639029,
0.3789529502,
-0.136616379,
-0.4886548221,
0.1270442605,
0.7694420218,
0.7598087788,
0.7002416253,
0.8902897239,
0.3103957772,
1.1386599541,
-0.2098060101,
0.7736440897,
-0.3310584724,
0.5155866742,
1.3442622423,
-0.5953410268,
0.3129806817,
0.2205845714,
-0.0582336113,
0.2663679421,
0.8331404328,
-0.0504407547,
0.7385644913,
0.3101884425,
-0.785291791,
-0.386082232,
-0.076881893,
-0.321485728,
0.1072346047,
0.3486084044,
0.0040359413,
-0.1150810495,
0.3160957098,
0.0960108414,
-0.1044646204,
-0.4909410179,
0.8956640959,
-0.1809491068,
-1.0214941502,
0.3445240259,
-0.6029934883,
0.4515894055,
-0.5580412745,
-0.0455140322,
-0.4446008801,
0.1595366746,
0.3163759708,
-0.2780237496,
-0.0639900193,
-0.0917550102,
0.1111479029,
-0.3030527234,
0.4653800726,
-0.5679076314,
-0.2390497327,
-0.2776257098,
0.3134459555,
-0.0348228961,
-0.1693628132,
-0.6028715372,
-0.0918848813,
-0.0165001936,
-0.0950833634,
0.5059499145,
0.2401348948,
0.0926754847,
0.8343392015,
0.3250558376,
-0.1196992695,
0.0317814425,
-0.2499229759,
0.7566487789,
-0.5348948836,
-0.7486569285,
-0.5361485481,
0.4548109174,
-0.1914176494,
-0.4209177494,
0.6544451118,
0.4826638103,
0.8903841972,
0.005308779,
0.8931577206,
0.1215342432,
0.7019358277,
-0.5988396406,
0.3793486059,
-0.2425302118,
0.2090694159,
-0.1082624644,
-0.9886296988,
-0.086880818,
0.5377774835,
-0.1083296314,
-0.04133958,
0.7345332503,
0.7346910238,
0.1934515238,
0.3909025192,
0.205488041,
-0.1824282259,
0.3176484704,
0.6426456571,
0.8057861924,
-0.1623261124,
0.1217200384,
-0.2496223897,
-0.3675431609,
-0.1254057735,
-0.6511999965,
-0.8313938975,
-0.9371960759,
-0.7338221669,
-0.2479154319,
0.2906415164,
1.1707834005,
0.6724847555,
-0.796800673,
-0.0689412206,
-0.2415377796,
-0.0407246351,
-0.6869763136,
-0.2806073725,
0.3008945286,
-1.1515029669,
-0.670357585,
0.4803318679,
0.4565211833,
0.0378950089,
-0.1631128043,
-0.0547382347,
0.1080913469,
-0.0644697174,
0.367715925,
0.4924269915,
-0.3683999181,
-0.4839402735,
-0.1331358403,
-0.0643823668,
-0.151548326,
0.9213959575,
-0.9934442043,
0.6465436816,
0.1373125464,
0.5651066303,
0.5316554308,
-0.0343025848,
0.4088532031,
-0.7714478374,
0.009792096,
0.4453806281,
0.154914543,
0.05055549,
-0.4996566176,
0.4229299426,
0.4426395893,
-0.6587901711,
-0.8247742653,
0.2822762132,
-0.9845857024,
-0.0288244709,
0.7439097166,
-0.3845742047,
0.1893289089,
-0.3616324961,
-0.1510599405,
0.2006486803,
-0.6272158027,
1.0618525743,
0.4036661983,
-0.2709938884,
-0.5437430739,
-0.3865091801,
0.6335096955,
0.3027295172,
-0.8195972443,
0.1208539978,
0.7498452663,
0.3058706224,
-0.1146256551,
0.7519489527,
0.144148156,
0.476361692,
-0.1767042726,
-0.4899335802,
-0.0827518478,
-0.4615790248,
-0.2550595999,
0.280236572,
-0.4171206653,
-0.4655199945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10267v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10267v1
|
Energy and Carbon Considerations of Fine-Tuning BERT
| 2023-11-17T01:27:01 | 2023-11-17T01:27:01 |
Xiaorong Wang, Clara Na, Emma Strubell, Sorelle Friedler, Sasha Luccioni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Despite the popularity of the `pre-train then fine-tune' paradigm in the NLP
community, existing work quantifying energy costs and associated carbon
emissions has largely focused on language model pre-training. Although a single
pre-training run draws substantially more energy than fine-tuning, fine-tuning
is performed more frequently by many more individual actors, and thus must be
accounted for when considering the energy and carbon footprint of NLP. In order
to better characterize the role of fine-tuning in the landscape of energy and
carbon emissions in NLP, we perform a careful empirical study of the
computational costs of fine-tuning across tasks, datasets, hardware
infrastructure and measurement modalities. Our experimental results allow us to
place fine-tuning energy and carbon costs into perspective with respect to
pre-training and inference, and outline recommendations to NLP researchers and
practitioners who wish to improve their fine-tuning energy efficiency.
|
[
-0.6601088047,
-0.4353737235,
0.4042066336,
-0.2137172222,
-0.1049786955,
-0.112627551,
-0.6651585102,
-0.7761862874,
0.1012518704,
0.634314239,
-0.4430711567,
-0.0165918712,
-0.3939088285,
-0.0202019531,
-0.0700682849,
0.9679046869,
0.4047077894,
0.0762407482,
-0.080911845,
0.2761255801,
-0.3114469647,
-0.3539253771,
-0.9243599772,
-0.3753209114,
0.8257159591,
0.1757884771,
0.8609517217,
0.3404483497,
0.7860013247,
0.2252791077,
-0.0405723639,
0.0358198844,
-0.6229239702,
-0.2269688547,
-0.391974479,
-0.4650467038,
-0.292724669,
0.3473586738,
0.5028423667,
0.8950647116,
-0.0326037928,
0.2622353733,
0.1313216537,
0.7320636511,
-0.9121776819,
0.0610311814,
-1.131459713,
-0.0678501874,
-0.3503407538,
-0.252499491,
-0.2527482808,
-0.0458447076,
-0.0551110283,
-0.6406269073,
0.4117062986,
0.3489336967,
0.986623466,
0.6405442953,
-0.034465231,
-0.2318173051,
-0.6783697009,
0.8655187488,
-0.7548123598,
0.2339406013,
0.4968094528,
-0.1441194564,
0.0270622913,
-0.6610976458,
-0.5930480361,
-0.029195318,
-0.2856936157,
0.0561199151,
-0.1655963957,
0.5158492327,
0.3117030263,
0.4555543065,
-0.2447431982,
0.4981738627,
-0.260481596,
-0.0375143625,
0.6147485375,
0.1336922348,
-0.1679772437,
-0.2357006222,
0.0703740045,
-0.3263961971,
-0.4971166551,
-0.1879288256,
0.8336194158,
0.7708514929,
0.0252687838,
0.2667647004,
-0.1147042289,
0.7375175357,
-0.1289823353,
0.6345595121,
-0.1969453096,
-0.5916333199,
-0.3024051189,
0.3990419507,
0.3483491242,
0.6582263708,
0.3565218449,
-0.1095641181,
0.0025798811,
-0.0107416697,
0.588766098,
-0.9669134617,
-0.8695970178,
0.1531517506,
-0.3709318638,
-0.1562370658,
-0.2795585096,
-0.5064231753,
-0.0396366902,
-0.5303302407,
0.4181067646,
-0.1890727729,
-0.3095869124,
0.5357102156,
-0.1747428775,
0.0931597203,
0.2690941691,
-1.3591117859,
0.2856180668,
0.7240877748,
0.4385766685,
0.2582309246,
0.0730841011,
-0.1610217839,
-0.1759683639,
-0.2422015816,
0.7920507789,
-0.6156316996,
-0.4067923725,
-0.1125472486,
-0.1012128964,
-0.0489265844,
-0.184248805,
0.3195052743,
-0.4612284899,
0.0930978209,
-0.7513101101,
-0.6781725883,
-0.0998738483,
-0.2734752297,
-0.5765113235,
0.9177201986,
-0.0571808144,
-0.7212364078,
0.7654557824,
-0.8556623459,
-0.5487422943,
0.1684887856,
0.2197246403,
-0.2212429494,
0.3421728015,
-0.1383526772,
0.4769857526,
-0.4190914929,
0.0292332731,
-0.1309703141,
-0.034502428,
-0.4624190629,
-0.3703803122,
0.6834716797,
0.5885661244,
-0.1773748696,
-0.1056942493,
-0.9787785411,
0.2802903652,
-0.2630612254,
-0.2870439291,
-0.3732345998,
0.493011862,
0.2427771986,
-0.2109069824,
0.3512719274,
-0.4839841425,
0.147782892,
-0.5289252996,
0.3806093037,
0.747764051,
0.0288104117,
0.3269136548,
-0.1861013323,
0.2129587382,
-0.7750220895,
0.1922101825,
0.1532742083,
-0.2457804978,
-0.6903862953,
0.0865741894,
0.5318840146,
0.0925635919,
-0.0809077322,
0.7547384501,
0.2539817095,
-0.6071906686,
-0.5809031129,
-0.0158163402,
0.2779302299,
0.211668089,
0.4517394304,
-0.1507087648,
-0.6205241084,
-0.7579324245,
-0.4269339442,
0.1437774152,
-0.0886887461,
0.5946522951,
0.5902007818,
0.0620731339,
0.9124990106,
-0.6255204678,
-0.0219821595,
0.0883482322,
0.3593268394,
0.0072414861,
1.1273231506,
0.8730717897,
-0.6852227449,
-0.5125845075,
0.0267839618,
-0.151362136,
-0.0225180518,
-0.3870063424,
-0.2102489322,
0.0152407037,
0.6279665828,
-0.2614546418,
0.1855518669,
0.605343461,
-0.1379288435,
0.6497053504,
-0.4771932065,
0.0669415295,
-0.7015138865,
0.2609674931,
-0.1105571166,
-0.0273651555,
-0.1642454565,
0.1023476794,
-0.4188983738,
-0.0528224967,
-0.3746293187,
0.076700598,
-0.3220848739,
-0.0220092256,
-0.1807184666,
-0.1408280283,
0.27904585,
0.5372701883,
-0.0474262051,
0.8374504447,
0.31462726,
-0.8808735609,
-0.2025877833,
-0.181173116,
-0.6372607946,
0.1118255481,
-0.6532219648,
0.4435613751,
0.2494122088,
-0.100559555,
-0.7383907437,
-0.1374676675,
-0.3071191311,
-0.2259638309,
0.6585649252,
0.2928024828,
-0.8513246775,
0.0226860289,
-0.1418125629,
0.1170811504,
0.3553424478,
-0.3360203207,
0.4360201955,
0.2455946058,
0.286580503,
-0.1637299806,
-0.3863323629,
-0.1804081351,
-0.0666783601,
-0.410756439,
0.4282670915,
-0.1937898546,
-0.1782314032,
0.0501036607,
-0.4163168073,
0.1319498718,
0.5594068766,
-0.0863226131,
-0.4647921026,
-0.0365232304,
0.3165051341,
0.0411225818,
-0.1835780293,
0.3786682785,
-0.3798915446,
0.6585835218,
-0.2521317005,
-0.1260306537,
-0.515666008,
0.3937687874,
0.2573191822,
-0.0376704074,
0.967846334,
0.6532152891,
-0.4783832729,
0.2049232423,
-0.5946654677,
-0.2899413407,
-0.5252441168,
0.5163604617,
-0.162966311,
-0.7891566157,
0.4836106598,
-0.4061304629,
0.5068591833,
0.7486572862,
0.4207948744,
-0.7392719388,
1.0720390081,
0.9676501155,
0.1717940271,
0.788033247,
-0.2929475904,
0.2571847439,
-0.8150663972,
0.0717650801,
-1.2128340006,
-0.397326678,
-0.8464235067,
-0.0913114324,
0.1640413851,
0.3131367862,
-0.5276920199,
0.4021623433,
-0.7461024523,
0.6900416017,
0.5833059549,
-0.016347155,
-0.2021949887,
-0.3076475263,
0.1984129995,
-0.0944232643,
-0.8095735312,
-0.3990642726,
0.7441583276,
0.0875700191,
0.5294929147,
-0.011277562,
0.519937098,
0.2300160676,
-0.231305629,
-0.647046566,
0.3050564826,
-0.3520908058,
-0.9644516706,
-0.444217205,
-0.1879127026,
-1.1955131292,
-0.0032021704,
-0.5025028586,
-0.7169600725,
0.0578997917,
0.5621920824,
-0.5895949006,
0.4209479988,
-0.8027095795,
1.1111540794,
-0.3747382164,
-0.3311380744,
-0.8867856264,
-0.7981954217,
-0.153208524,
-0.1290300041,
-0.0001202196,
-0.2660837173,
0.3699345589,
1.0322934389,
-0.4648345709,
1.0120395422,
-0.3454272747,
-0.0738201588,
0.1493870914,
-0.3263610005,
0.5771388412,
-0.2925361991,
-0.1388754249,
0.4616233706,
0.0999485776,
-0.4576021433,
-0.2460648119,
0.5114354491,
-0.7053432465,
-0.6234392524,
-0.2165052593,
-0.3253283203,
-0.2733852863,
0.3156488836,
0.5712562203,
0.0681513101,
-0.1019022837,
0.4612540901,
0.7719867826,
-0.3154085577,
0.3525027633,
0.3937960565,
0.0828263462,
0.0038504042,
0.7737376094,
0.060102839,
0.7128769755,
0.498567909,
0.4923248291,
0.0190652143,
-0.6291204095,
0.0192303769,
-0.1728874147,
-0.3892588019,
-0.2201108485,
-0.3900512457,
0.1018001959,
-0.2662057579,
-0.6174489856,
-0.9011502266,
-0.2727535665,
-0.7998473048,
-0.1176633388,
0.5729039311,
0.3120143414,
-0.4423321784,
0.6646988988,
-0.4920098186,
0.1526260823,
0.3083307743,
0.4587436318,
-0.0338484235,
-0.1388342679,
-0.763661623,
0.0499383211,
-0.2420830131,
-0.2125796676,
0.0349444076,
0.5579882264,
0.4354415536,
0.5016855001,
0.21176745,
0.7488308549,
-0.5128026009,
1.084141016,
0.4718567729,
-1.0484050512,
0.719761014,
-0.2122052163,
0.3120386004,
0.9320130944,
0.1761922985,
-0.0429829843,
-0.2182596326,
-0.7270442843,
-0.9643498659,
0.5798463821,
0.2416561395,
0.3484505415,
-0.1291617453,
0.5291185975,
-0.0477083325,
0.3784291148,
-0.4139131904,
-0.2599239945,
-0.1857457757,
0.2965987921,
-0.1904835552,
-0.0573279336,
-0.104511261,
-0.5868804455,
0.6546364427,
-0.2710643411,
0.1535048485,
-0.0863422826,
0.1916794032,
-0.1378693283,
0.0159968324,
0.4891873002,
0.3167413175,
-0.6924541593,
-0.0047727018,
0.2894591987,
-0.3829438984,
-0.4325607717,
-0.2496160865,
0.1906487644,
-0.0871158838,
0.2347906083,
0.8933964968,
0.450063616,
-0.4036318958,
-0.1797289252,
-0.0324054807,
-0.3420564234,
-0.037874952,
0.5116012096,
0.0586907268,
0.0806629434,
-0.0614766702,
0.6634358168,
0.1689056754,
-0.4807263911,
-0.1376857013,
0.7316531539,
-0.3176134229,
-0.2608735561,
0.7524404526,
0.5472232699,
-0.3350322545,
0.6605669856,
-0.036545258,
-0.3822869062,
0.707290411,
0.1718567312,
0.8878498077,
0.2071938217,
-0.4874382019,
0.3717427254,
0.6203538775,
0.2263125777,
0.3182160258,
-0.5257335901,
-0.7464776635,
-0.6331102252,
-0.8594605327,
-0.4657486379,
-0.0899933726,
-0.9806457162,
0.2257351577,
-0.4757261872,
-0.4296370149,
0.3688584268,
0.4901847541,
-0.9850187898,
0.329094708,
0.4644432366,
0.9020357728,
-0.6713047028,
0.8751531839,
0.4833791256,
-0.087574102,
-0.7390276194,
-0.2426337302,
-0.3202287257,
-0.6360589266,
0.4668432772,
0.0145561146,
-0.5669590235,
0.2687455714,
-0.8247760534,
-0.7888684273,
0.6633856893,
0.6343869567,
-0.9816215038,
-0.0563507937,
-0.1720523685,
0.4770451486,
0.0738829672,
-0.125520125,
0.6846988797,
0.6996721029,
-0.3878189921,
-1.10625422,
-0.4160948396,
0.0743965656,
-0.0419596806,
0.4803813696,
-0.7765461802,
0.7525569201,
-0.1102996022,
-0.312289685,
-0.3311425447,
0.466635257,
-0.4278758764,
0.1466896981,
0.4884024262,
0.5423849821,
1.0524190664,
0.0606573746,
0.9401038289,
-0.8925600648,
0.7150309682,
0.9921756387,
-0.2096089274,
0.5964030623,
0.5142841339,
-0.6856253147,
0.1509914398,
0.83791399,
-0.0102896523,
0.7990602255,
0.5587060452,
-0.0703321546,
-0.4671170712,
-0.3315285146,
-0.4978508353,
0.4738640785,
0.622264266,
-0.0717357025,
-0.1228770241,
-0.1322416812,
0.0300681517,
-0.103645429,
-0.4573670328,
0.9002645612,
0.0000344379,
-0.4587254822,
0.4833988249,
-0.1572602242,
0.6149846911,
-0.8664469123,
0.1627427638,
0.3336201608,
0.0648520216,
-0.2304880619,
-0.5456135869,
0.6125875115,
-0.125507623,
-0.4255491197,
-0.6128126383,
0.4993180633,
0.0644567013,
-0.2960585952,
0.1746862382,
0.0192710068,
0.3407765031,
-0.1279447824,
-0.6659861803,
0.0952307582,
0.3633203208,
-0.211947605,
0.4238866866,
0.1832529753,
0.6497221589,
0.0043579312,
0.7431461811,
0.1145820245,
-0.1696073711,
0.2005908042,
0.7759364247,
-0.4387398958,
-0.4851390421,
-0.6632311344,
0.3308731616,
0.1344723552,
-0.6293575168,
0.515104413,
0.5520697832,
1.0531059504,
0.2106538266,
0.7019214034,
-0.1730282307,
0.1442014575,
-1.01146698,
0.8105221391,
-0.7442939878,
0.0934944749,
-0.4101537764,
-0.8848689795,
-0.0433391705,
0.866540134,
-0.1778269708,
0.0332371332,
0.680280447,
0.4637678564,
0.261744231,
0.2579368055,
0.2347053438,
0.0873879641,
0.3505146503,
0.3143180311,
0.2158055753,
-0.2696776688,
0.0693039969,
-0.4245308638,
0.1234353408,
-0.3334490061,
-1.293902874,
-0.5150681734,
-0.6033988595,
-0.5620718002,
-0.1204860732,
-0.1853952557,
0.9751325846,
0.9407592416,
-0.9265348911,
-0.0207698848,
-0.420325011,
-0.1002084464,
-0.5004416108,
-0.1726898253,
0.4995602667,
-0.7660520077,
-0.7633457184,
0.0230540149,
0.0197434612,
-0.1837367862,
-0.2910516858,
0.2300581932,
-0.2708933949,
0.3462660313,
0.5794095397,
0.2318872064,
-0.4236401618,
-0.7423242927,
-0.1682611257,
0.0976925641,
0.1951849908,
0.9807500243,
-0.6400272846,
0.6163314581,
0.2150064707,
0.6507872939,
0.6724249125,
-0.3445228934,
0.4873631001,
-0.9841206074,
0.0784459263,
0.4313358366,
0.3654707968,
0.0230282936,
-0.6411280632,
0.2670807242,
0.042809844,
-0.9776198268,
-0.8209660053,
0.1989078671,
-1.1029310226,
-0.4398960173,
0.6674246788,
0.07412076,
0.0620958768,
-0.0961934477,
-0.0918772519,
0.1937631518,
-0.2474628985,
0.7087275982,
0.8931012154,
-0.5542227626,
0.1701306403,
-0.6638875008,
0.8403057456,
0.7360805273,
-0.5723485351,
0.3353879154,
0.4844310582,
-0.0438226052,
0.4882451892,
0.1388342828,
0.6856879592,
-0.0751011521,
0.4337732196,
0.3592826426,
0.255292058,
-0.3150190115,
0.1037789136,
-0.1202419102,
-0.0337240398,
-0.1893521696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10266v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10266v1
|
Diagnosing and Debiasing Corpus-Based Political Bias and Insults in GPT2
| 2023-11-17T01:20:08 | 2023-11-17T01:20:08 |
Ambri Ma, Arnav Kumar, Brett Zeligson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The training of large language models (LLMs) on extensive, unfiltered corpora
sourced from the internet is a common and advantageous practice. Consequently,
LLMs have learned and inadvertently reproduced various types of biases,
including violent, offensive, and toxic language. However, recent research
shows that generative pretrained transformer (GPT) language models can
recognize their own biases and detect toxicity in generated content, a process
referred to as self-diagnosis. In response, researchers have developed a
decoding algorithm that allows LLMs to self-debias, or reduce their likelihood
of generating harmful text. This study investigates the efficacy of the
diagnosing-debiasing approach in mitigating two additional types of biases:
insults and political bias. These biases are often used interchangeably in
discourse, despite exhibiting potentially dissimilar semantic and syntactic
properties. We aim to contribute to the ongoing effort of investigating the
ethical and social implications of human-AI interaction.
|
[
-0.3518796563,
-0.8558111787,
0.5635639429,
-0.0092023183,
-0.2254621536,
0.0657617897,
-0.1458920389,
-0.3744353652,
-0.1508195102,
0.6022592783,
-0.2382955253,
-0.3673724234,
-1.0062606335,
0.13204965,
-0.2716431022,
1.191873312,
0.3292074502,
0.2253967077,
-0.1032099873,
-0.0319075026,
-0.3445103765,
-0.792591989,
-0.7470125556,
-0.4135971367,
0.3641095459,
0.1863953769,
0.8897875547,
0.4590911269,
0.590143621,
0.2413318157,
0.0274563618,
-0.2285610586,
-0.5616381764,
0.2632691264,
-0.5343251824,
-0.2845265269,
-0.2177100182,
0.4165231287,
0.1620092392,
0.341198653,
0.0787621588,
0.1927275658,
0.3257118165,
0.5988174677,
-0.6100243926,
-0.0746594071,
-0.7808008194,
0.0798931271,
-0.1967899054,
-0.055889871,
-0.3606692255,
-0.3139549792,
-0.0548231862,
-0.3917629421,
0.1529861242,
-0.3042052388,
0.5870184898,
0.742947042,
-0.3921893239,
-0.5862919092,
-0.8117123246,
0.6314880252,
-0.4943430722,
0.0256264638,
0.3123328388,
0.0657261983,
0.0753709152,
-0.4141641259,
-0.5892092586,
-0.0072153476,
-0.2950959802,
0.2352620214,
-0.441570133,
0.1671788245,
0.2049280405,
0.0585532077,
-0.6274508238,
0.3511144817,
-0.2301292121,
-0.3957969248,
0.4855867028,
0.0764489174,
0.4234995842,
-0.5297457576,
-0.4262484014,
0.1584443748,
-0.8455651402,
-0.5423796177,
0.6979986429,
0.1584813297,
-0.0466239788,
0.1286564916,
0.1496025473,
0.2599980533,
0.1412118524,
0.1549347639,
0.0740235075,
-0.1882451773,
-0.2963347435,
-0.0574248172,
0.9563831687,
0.4134833217,
0.4640367031,
-0.054123532,
0.1514495462,
0.6058003306,
0.3603051603,
-0.7276064754,
-0.3971510231,
0.2351138592,
-0.5076526999,
-0.6381407976,
-0.5033831,
-1.1813871861,
-0.9185406566,
-0.1507928222,
0.3899435103,
-0.244469732,
-0.5269215107,
-0.0852883682,
-0.2333046347,
0.0105938902,
0.1548589319,
-0.7281791568,
0.1684664339,
0.5153773427,
0.5315530896,
-0.1837642938,
0.07141231,
-0.468387574,
-0.0798986629,
-0.243455857,
0.8227230906,
-0.6813647151,
-0.532597661,
0.025655359,
-0.2937038243,
0.1628470719,
-1.0134955645,
0.7940378189,
-0.3580378592,
0.3893254399,
-0.4702375233,
-0.1621952802,
0.1641209424,
0.2397423983,
-0.3975674808,
1.1321287155,
0.2267805189,
-1.016076684,
0.3475114405,
-0.7395128608,
-0.2982272208,
-0.1658240408,
-0.1804648787,
-0.3706810176,
-0.1636476815,
0.1638699472,
0.3123510778,
-0.3800296187,
0.4813797772,
-0.3188032508,
-0.1390881091,
-0.2216189206,
-0.6250830889,
0.9425424933,
0.3675178885,
-0.7892675996,
0.1855807602,
-0.4650114477,
-0.3175459802,
0.154370755,
-0.0585963205,
-0.6238829494,
0.0550187305,
-0.1028669477,
0.4554500282,
-0.0537733696,
-0.4061309397,
0.0195069574,
-0.3171491921,
0.4421566427,
0.9947324395,
-0.1260604709,
0.2695558965,
-0.1443129927,
0.52797544,
0.4181167185,
0.1704749763,
0.276796639,
-0.3595561683,
-0.6142786741,
-0.1472382545,
0.0588861518,
0.7087537646,
-0.7050930262,
0.421446383,
-0.0291863512,
-0.3463388085,
-0.6307314634,
-0.0526862331,
0.5883327127,
0.710419178,
0.5436722636,
-0.034086775,
-0.4831537604,
-1.1924498081,
-0.6402730346,
-0.3460959792,
-0.1322013289,
0.2829424739,
0.5374103189,
-0.4000970423,
0.7135644555,
-0.1987068504,
-0.3859218061,
0.1178641915,
0.4111908376,
-0.2269807607,
0.320892185,
0.7128866315,
-0.4440918565,
-0.3509490788,
-0.4242905676,
-0.6874780059,
-0.5145854354,
-0.0939326957,
-0.1426078528,
0.1308474392,
0.3301766217,
-0.3573817313,
0.4258922935,
0.4670725763,
-0.4574157894,
0.5178529024,
0.023145318,
0.2670373619,
-0.8922403455,
-0.1351201981,
-0.0226032585,
-0.3008032739,
-0.4979562759,
-0.1827451736,
-0.2639124691,
0.2857917845,
-0.4010249972,
0.3199240267,
-0.3031850755,
0.1449972838,
-0.3300209045,
0.3782613873,
-0.0068951878,
-0.0151598165,
0.0124375578,
0.9012564421,
0.4608712196,
-0.4109860957,
0.1323019117,
0.2151002586,
-0.1567952484,
0.6930500865,
-0.5162376761,
0.3844055533,
-0.415106833,
0.0635619536,
-0.9820141196,
0.1393209994,
0.5886912942,
-0.3486767113,
0.1584885269,
-0.2073250115,
-0.3260276318,
-0.3700554669,
-0.4040999413,
0.6240461469,
0.5912355781,
-0.6128438711,
0.2923844159,
0.7183604836,
-0.18830733,
-0.7907611132,
-0.7136929631,
0.1235950813,
-0.7168446779,
-0.2252147645,
0.3807937801,
0.1649743766,
-0.6038529277,
-0.0195265729,
0.2697600722,
0.1279064566,
0.1196915954,
0.0918609276,
0.1095631644,
-0.033744324,
0.1350279748,
0.1103152409,
-0.2277264297,
0.4477675259,
0.0187898409,
0.5026353598,
0.0415657647,
-0.2335698456,
-0.2711113095,
0.4012755454,
0.5266842842,
-0.0618858077,
0.4402940869,
0.5678355098,
-0.2359967977,
0.008832192,
-0.5563820601,
-0.3385466039,
-0.4220387042,
0.4914750457,
0.0027095047,
-0.8207354546,
0.4699662626,
-0.1316059977,
-0.3229515254,
0.7981925607,
0.9989644289,
0.0938247815,
0.9362478256,
0.3696745336,
-0.5087434649,
0.1269656569,
0.0149193769,
0.3270972669,
-0.8051752448,
0.1003255174,
-0.6730107069,
-0.1004215628,
-0.8597553968,
-0.4303849638,
0.4605942369,
-0.2527200282,
-0.5534625649,
-0.0986845642,
-0.9600793719,
0.6021335721,
0.4257545471,
0.0815746263,
0.1421869844,
-0.0779289976,
0.1048163548,
-0.2893512547,
-0.3970283866,
-0.8018475175,
1.1113729477,
0.5094586015,
0.7089621425,
0.0180717241,
0.6004246473,
0.6425911784,
0.6629474759,
-0.6854399443,
0.2430072129,
-0.249380067,
-0.9693555832,
-0.1316369921,
-0.4343294501,
-0.861770153,
0.3001201749,
0.0584297217,
-0.8290495276,
0.1960302591,
0.2413277924,
-0.3333176076,
0.3782550991,
-0.4859735668,
0.9541608095,
-0.3539319634,
-0.4433959424,
-0.4449614882,
-0.6266320348,
0.3996095657,
-0.0288369358,
0.5063319802,
-0.2404015958,
0.1414111853,
0.8826998472,
0.0951035023,
1.0102242231,
-0.503297925,
-0.2664799988,
0.21986489,
0.1963119507,
0.0579872653,
0.132657364,
-0.2379264534,
0.3972335458,
0.1025592461,
-0.1097755581,
-0.2806159556,
0.6658137441,
-1.0305325985,
-0.8952020407,
-0.5920618773,
-0.3093633354,
-0.1646078676,
0.1306343377,
0.2789646089,
0.0341997258,
-0.3537101448,
-0.2923615277,
0.6101107001,
-0.557305336,
0.1387217194,
0.5067759752,
-0.0812956467,
-0.2435769886,
0.6348804832,
-0.0278719552,
0.278811425,
-0.1253558397,
0.3891084194,
-0.239113912,
-0.4126558304,
-0.366856426,
0.1849655807,
-0.5927854776,
-0.4444393814,
-0.5523939729,
-0.1136445627,
-0.479593277,
0.2327735126,
-0.4567188323,
-0.1843633652,
-0.354490906,
-0.1614048332,
0.1764935106,
1.0405037403,
-0.3263089359,
0.3251360059,
-0.3855099976,
0.4379552305,
0.048563499,
0.2595094144,
-0.4171385169,
-0.7596052885,
0.2513122261,
0.3098388016,
-0.5719307661,
-1.3150568008,
0.201909408,
-0.0516364835,
0.3314184844,
0.5267082453,
0.3787014186,
0.397183001,
-0.4681320786,
0.8495870233,
-0.1023298651,
-0.8568811417,
0.588124454,
-0.3983356953,
-0.2435191572,
0.549410522,
0.675386548,
-0.4166969657,
-0.6306152344,
-0.5822347403,
-0.640842855,
0.5530942082,
0.0468327589,
0.351467371,
-0.5343207121,
0.5172678828,
0.1948548108,
-0.010062662,
-0.6914964318,
-0.5093337893,
-0.3425941467,
-0.1569146961,
0.0396846943,
-0.5797564387,
-0.4768569767,
-0.3447573185,
0.725730598,
-0.0490174294,
0.3720147908,
0.2743491232,
-0.0775987953,
-0.0602349639,
0.3644693494,
0.3733393252,
0.3559587598,
0.1701119691,
0.3980825543,
-0.0087368591,
-0.3381777406,
0.2911298573,
-0.0165748689,
-0.0766122118,
-0.1159630641,
0.0686829239,
0.4664690197,
-0.1606452465,
-0.3492869437,
0.7235612869,
0.1775568724,
-0.045762457,
-0.3792150617,
-0.241534695,
0.0402395315,
0.1474631131,
-0.0019130802,
-0.0404536426,
0.405796349,
-0.7217500806,
0.2815216482,
0.9013621211,
-0.2472042739,
-0.3784073889,
0.8324018717,
0.4664490521,
-0.1674416512,
0.7082646489,
-0.3482267559,
-0.8838403821,
0.4884976745,
0.6388446093,
0.8080109358,
-0.4017702043,
0.4839243293,
0.3293302655,
0.515219748,
0.3804044127,
0.0124155367,
0.3195874989,
-1.046720624,
-0.1874630749,
-0.5464989543,
-0.1849496067,
0.6369390488,
-0.5697980523,
0.1358660311,
-0.4065935016,
-0.3930484951,
0.132049039,
-0.096988,
-0.5517822504,
0.1099387035,
0.3326114714,
0.4706463814,
-1.1251951456,
0.6805298924,
0.3308360875,
-0.4347703755,
-0.3998785019,
0.1869305074,
0.3049917817,
-0.9952670336,
0.7675038576,
0.0615072921,
-0.2196008265,
-0.1334871501,
-0.2696659863,
-0.5045985579,
0.5185722709,
0.6506389976,
-0.3372332454,
-0.1631359309,
0.5196090937,
0.574777782,
-0.2076539248,
0.6901467443,
0.9648513794,
0.6129431725,
-0.3909725845,
-1.0369393826,
0.2276592255,
-0.0493078902,
-0.1774677187,
0.2445356548,
-0.624742806,
0.6106827855,
-0.0238683093,
-0.2409626096,
-0.3020140827,
0.1122333258,
-0.4526255727,
0.1181031913,
0.5013623834,
0.5195356607,
0.7223429084,
-0.1124423146,
0.7788805962,
-0.5431373119,
0.3345870972,
0.9693729281,
-0.3300287724,
0.4057307541,
0.3573011756,
-0.2136400044,
0.5604274273,
0.5287736058,
-0.0037162432,
0.4145943522,
0.3268302381,
-0.2684709728,
-0.0509882569,
-0.1196092218,
-0.3903926909,
0.6477394104,
0.6280140281,
-0.5443565249,
-0.4683744013,
-0.0027887863,
0.4614745677,
0.3290625215,
0.0089160744,
0.9544095993,
-0.1858434975,
-0.6146887541,
0.4688388407,
-0.0575256869,
0.9158692956,
-0.1528986692,
0.0415822826,
-0.0771823972,
0.1247792095,
-0.2382967323,
-0.8395155668,
0.8194420934,
0.103596516,
-0.1464276761,
-0.326420784,
0.8780018687,
-0.3032271564,
-0.1664920896,
0.6232918501,
0.7634692192,
0.205560714,
-0.4139785171,
-0.9190798402,
0.0729037151,
-0.0147556076,
-0.2916936874,
0.4334672987,
0.2182890624,
-0.0001495414,
0.3437814116,
0.2595664263,
0.0254251193,
-0.2984423041,
0.2232197672,
0.9373384118,
-0.3727659583,
-0.0373171493,
-1.1491525173,
0.2655923665,
-0.1088532731,
-0.2493925989,
0.3873864114,
0.547765553,
0.7221468687,
0.0583274364,
1.1181333065,
-0.0638979599,
0.6065214276,
-0.2669413388,
0.9664645791,
-0.228066802,
0.2246439457,
-0.3148438632,
-0.4796071053,
-0.2231316268,
0.7881006598,
-0.6674928665,
0.2234525383,
0.5944836736,
0.9050412774,
0.1560482979,
-0.2097979784,
0.2777529061,
0.4701028764,
0.3611592352,
0.5371733308,
0.9141995311,
-0.1424065828,
0.5116434693,
-0.3031303287,
-0.5302313566,
0.0961526483,
-0.9028077126,
-1.0538752079,
-0.4833799303,
-0.3367302716,
-0.5399631858,
0.3580495417,
0.7114741206,
0.3475503027,
-0.5637883544,
0.096266076,
0.0554574803,
0.2380788326,
0.1331022978,
-0.3048973382,
0.287881583,
-0.3810568154,
-0.8031263351,
-0.050397031,
0.1359811276,
-0.3156670034,
-0.4877527654,
0.1528275013,
0.0009552725,
0.1596896499,
0.7375538945,
-0.0577329285,
-0.7500181794,
-0.720066607,
-0.3086851537,
-0.1505048275,
0.2258892804,
0.7464307547,
-0.9294114709,
0.3011476696,
0.2665711045,
0.5405418873,
-0.1206557676,
0.140388906,
0.4633004665,
-0.356097281,
0.1839977652,
0.5287041068,
0.148261413,
0.3977083564,
-0.6979007125,
0.5268723369,
0.2819250822,
-0.7575063705,
-0.7612106204,
0.5332399011,
-0.4379792213,
-0.2368005961,
1.2902489901,
-0.0776658207,
0.0801447108,
-0.1955875307,
-0.3779428899,
0.4854192138,
-0.1715391427,
1.2068555355,
0.4722979963,
-0.1176265329,
0.1922432333,
-0.5349435806,
0.8739963174,
0.50036484,
-0.8710677028,
0.4146779478,
0.5252174139,
0.6163864136,
0.1209086701,
0.7792109251,
-0.3183232844,
0.1403393447,
-0.0329618864,
-0.0194899905,
0.2676311433,
-0.1211660057,
-0.2295040339,
-0.0457767434,
0.0069725206,
-0.0446666852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10236v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10236v1
|
Latent Feature-based Data Splits to Improve Generalisation Evaluation: A Hate Speech Detection Case Study
| 2023-11-16T23:49:55 | 2023-11-16T23:49:55 |
Maike Züfle, Verna Dankers, Ivan Titov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the ever-growing presence of social media platforms comes the increased
spread of harmful content and the need for robust hate speech detection
systems. Such systems easily overfit to specific targets and keywords, and
evaluating them without considering distribution shifts that might occur
between train and test data overestimates their benefit. We challenge hate
speech models via new train-test splits of existing datasets that rely on the
clustering of models' hidden representations. We present two split variants
(Subset-Sum-Split and Closest-Split) that, when applied to two datasets using
four pretrained models, reveal how models catastrophically fail on blind spots
in the latent space. This result generalises when developing a split with one
model and evaluating it on another. Our analysis suggests that there is no
clear surface-level property of the data split that correlates with the
decreased performance, which underscores that task difficulty is not always
humanly interpretable. We recommend incorporating latent feature-based splits
in model development and release two splits via the GenBench benchmark.
|
[
-0.443677336,
-0.7445207238,
0.2700985074,
0.0533807054,
-0.3170509636,
0.3998551071,
-0.0893791839,
-0.4735195041,
0.2518277764,
0.4629175067,
-0.4842786789,
-0.4173794389,
-0.8248383999,
-0.3902265728,
-0.6457874179,
1.0827916861,
0.2982150018,
0.0858473331,
-0.0537766851,
-0.4114161432,
-0.2193608135,
-0.7648007274,
-0.3410262465,
-0.0130992448,
0.7462619543,
0.2663045228,
0.6295146942,
0.3637076616,
0.6298119426,
0.1641065925,
-0.4055854678,
-0.0436509475,
-0.4556542933,
0.2290321738,
-0.0265156943,
-0.5798839331,
-0.2393551767,
0.4137522876,
0.4727314711,
0.8515769839,
-0.0417164639,
0.0064655193,
0.0288807917,
0.2877515852,
-0.6557244658,
-0.3738890886,
-0.6605613828,
0.0566594489,
-0.2592244446,
0.3307868838,
-0.0550382994,
-0.339995712,
0.0640060082,
-0.2742673755,
0.7173546553,
-0.260494858,
0.5464928746,
0.3964801729,
-0.2026058882,
-0.0988036916,
-0.8725642562,
0.8172562718,
-0.6056586504,
0.4256371856,
0.2494384795,
0.4411240518,
0.2740723193,
-0.4010966718,
-0.4348630309,
-0.2261727005,
0.1443473846,
-0.1340238005,
-0.2959548533,
-0.1235005409,
0.4699918628,
0.4303043485,
-0.6474485993,
0.2996608615,
-0.4718725979,
-0.1310575157,
0.6772316098,
0.0016149252,
0.2306207865,
-0.1506694108,
-0.000560165,
-0.0131339086,
-0.460423857,
-0.2795430124,
0.7802120447,
0.6285823584,
-0.0563979857,
0.3511120379,
0.0411549658,
0.4916255772,
-0.0896074474,
0.0639722571,
0.5015922189,
-0.0081929872,
0.0276366062,
-0.2218455374,
0.6011304259,
0.2091265023,
0.2090933323,
-0.3535073996,
0.0171600096,
0.7138427496,
0.3009995222,
-0.6540583372,
-0.2928467393,
0.0983405337,
-0.399032712,
-0.6526570916,
-0.2517377436,
-0.8925991654,
-0.7283251882,
0.0202796776,
0.0571804643,
-0.3001713455,
-0.5938224792,
-0.2790955305,
-0.3034563959,
0.2122130394,
0.3839369416,
-0.6341831088,
0.3740587831,
0.6732037663,
0.9538632631,
-0.629170835,
0.1447973549,
-0.5212794542,
-0.2461607605,
-0.2199826241,
0.7038701773,
-0.8155850172,
-0.1520251483,
-0.1075330228,
-0.254458636,
-0.1852332503,
-0.9670919776,
0.5398706198,
-0.3205297589,
0.4188475609,
0.0060723159,
-0.4683378041,
-0.1156720668,
0.1334553212,
-0.5895546079,
0.9611319304,
0.1558186114,
-0.8293347955,
0.6099886298,
-0.7733811736,
-0.5263556838,
-0.0840407088,
-0.2580644488,
-0.6673975587,
0.3377496898,
0.1616504043,
0.2860279679,
-0.0645024776,
0.0776538849,
-0.8248794675,
-0.1375892609,
0.0628653616,
-0.4967831373,
0.5590057373,
0.2472237796,
-0.6639077663,
0.1511073411,
-0.9298837185,
-0.2065330446,
0.203147158,
0.0295103602,
-0.4864644706,
0.2347924858,
0.4806460738,
0.2781244814,
-0.2584928572,
-0.7127918005,
-0.1469630152,
-0.3112632036,
0.248667106,
0.6694212556,
-0.1184828058,
0.244829908,
-0.1028131619,
0.7083085179,
0.272773236,
0.2803482711,
0.430911392,
-0.5337636471,
-0.6461201906,
-0.0117107984,
0.4223686159,
0.450689435,
-0.5236109495,
0.3271553814,
0.1064801663,
-0.4699524045,
-0.460616678,
-0.0402206369,
0.3598023951,
0.2165719718,
0.4550693631,
-0.44536075,
-0.4164701402,
-0.9119313955,
-0.2947739661,
-0.0965669826,
-0.1463174075,
0.3265745044,
0.5273662806,
-0.0953520015,
0.9744011164,
-0.5671671629,
-0.2509849668,
-0.2806023955,
0.2333227992,
-0.1683837622,
0.4759995639,
0.570243299,
-1.254838109,
-0.2967193425,
-0.3575072587,
-0.4034873545,
-0.1864448339,
0.2998259962,
0.2073661238,
-0.012919588,
0.2670233548,
-0.0197095759,
0.6531515718,
0.5392130017,
-0.4309456646,
0.538606286,
0.50085181,
0.0859246179,
-0.9651843905,
-0.0344793238,
0.0629052147,
-0.3229313195,
-0.66205585,
-0.11539381,
-0.3980989456,
-0.1072791517,
-0.4482322335,
0.0592546053,
-0.1749141663,
-0.2311472744,
-0.4049792588,
-0.0140743908,
-0.3745743334,
0.3304372132,
-0.0845113471,
0.432025522,
0.3291988671,
-0.3036969006,
0.3021336496,
0.1369738877,
-0.3889560103,
0.557015121,
-0.5042979121,
0.431823045,
0.0177412201,
-0.0041396767,
-1.1110929251,
-0.2080717683,
0.3139302135,
-0.4513006806,
0.0912478417,
-0.424252063,
-0.4780068696,
-0.3123750687,
-0.1501100808,
0.494869262,
0.4068064392,
-0.3351759315,
0.3198807538,
0.6967945695,
-0.0041021556,
-0.4281434417,
-0.7909561396,
-0.073096551,
-0.7533603907,
-0.5639733672,
0.3568022549,
-0.1713065207,
-0.2860941887,
0.0348838754,
-0.2315856665,
-0.4338949919,
0.2874338031,
0.511695981,
-0.1680067331,
-0.1139939502,
0.0421192497,
-0.0216172338,
0.252212137,
-0.0593177788,
-0.0547934286,
0.5052249432,
0.2016082406,
-0.2896631956,
-0.0374889523,
0.4090605974,
0.4937544465,
-0.1519299448,
0.7590984702,
0.6384406686,
-0.5007542968,
-0.3791567683,
-0.6755566001,
-0.0059364289,
-0.3878011405,
0.3625665605,
-0.0490064733,
-1.1814155579,
0.5785110593,
-0.0298377182,
-0.0216857493,
0.3824248016,
0.4023312032,
0.0197322406,
1.0673286915,
0.752758801,
-0.1315017492,
0.6525376439,
-0.1695515662,
0.1196566895,
-0.4649745226,
0.007371549,
-0.5233826041,
-0.1983954459,
-0.475526005,
-0.5788118839,
0.2919390798,
-0.0418350846,
0.1641537845,
-0.0459550694,
-0.5361802578,
0.4710019231,
0.1570999026,
0.0861391574,
0.0493013151,
0.4092869461,
-0.0634254888,
-0.2846716046,
-0.5770537257,
-0.2574402094,
1.1060985327,
0.3828749359,
0.4049173295,
0.1609263122,
0.5515254736,
0.657150805,
0.5120223761,
-0.5939429998,
0.3439384401,
-0.4700964093,
-0.849049747,
-0.3499978781,
-0.5414915681,
-0.8335565329,
0.401470691,
-0.0605221018,
-0.7524453402,
0.2926599085,
-0.1138687432,
-0.4505091906,
0.3711507916,
-0.6069437861,
0.9198884368,
-0.1526555866,
-0.343927294,
-0.3198119998,
-0.3451580703,
0.375585556,
-0.2452550232,
0.4107463658,
-0.2044889331,
0.1938619018,
1.4475649595,
-0.5908843875,
0.9415641427,
-0.5375663638,
-0.0008902207,
0.2069046348,
-0.2852723002,
0.0787772164,
-0.483507514,
0.0030711771,
0.102428481,
-0.325568974,
-0.3294674456,
-0.8476397395,
0.3997678161,
-0.7270877957,
-0.4351394773,
-0.1558760852,
-0.4135826528,
-0.4957847595,
0.0701625049,
0.3488375545,
0.2886107862,
-0.4479628205,
0.2577251196,
0.5109831691,
-0.137133047,
0.0391921364,
0.4925535321,
-0.2578428984,
-0.5742884278,
0.8269431591,
0.3668628037,
0.1359704137,
-0.1571909338,
0.1869199723,
-0.3764114976,
-0.9277137518,
-0.165822655,
0.1432966441,
-0.5086479187,
0.1783418804,
-0.6123989224,
-0.1586132646,
-0.6496188045,
0.1282123029,
-0.3972350955,
-0.5177853107,
-0.1677200198,
-0.1224463731,
0.0991010219,
1.0152242184,
-0.42048195,
0.5923154354,
-0.27305004,
0.4306825697,
0.2823651135,
0.4297779202,
-0.0765417591,
-0.8618382812,
-0.3905566633,
-0.1285586655,
-0.3427231908,
-1.1144539118,
0.3758871853,
-0.1389110535,
0.4052262604,
0.2724377215,
-0.0950219259,
0.4591302872,
-0.4005418718,
0.6695414186,
0.2697271407,
-0.6080790162,
0.6322768331,
-0.4432724118,
-0.257203728,
0.5683096647,
0.6094722152,
-0.5078225136,
-0.5255986452,
-0.9363201857,
-0.8469339013,
0.6282339692,
0.4110542238,
-0.1258070767,
0.2673938572,
0.0985148624,
0.0918568224,
0.1342660338,
-0.7141039968,
-0.5038716793,
-0.0611545965,
-0.0424122736,
-0.3013631701,
-0.5142754316,
-0.1418723166,
-0.296941191,
0.3942827582,
0.1981535405,
0.0203563385,
-0.2212712914,
-0.2883064151,
0.0315903686,
0.2879222929,
0.3172961175,
0.4774138033,
-0.3398189247,
-0.1720570177,
-0.0470302626,
-0.5172734857,
0.3182090819,
0.3715111315,
-0.1374372691,
0.1949232966,
0.3046261966,
0.7917894721,
0.0098146163,
-0.164236322,
0.641847074,
-0.0321222395,
-0.2840298414,
-0.1296609938,
0.2846190035,
0.0135055715,
0.2754174173,
0.3827677965,
0.0503425673,
0.251152426,
-0.2394096702,
0.497795254,
0.1625368893,
-0.5372140408,
-0.351126492,
0.5817007422,
0.1833800375,
-0.3029566705,
0.2239025533,
-0.2526969314,
-0.720715642,
0.6437643766,
0.1575540602,
1.0844795704,
-0.5465711355,
0.4157348275,
-0.0660091564,
0.4175916612,
0.1802114397,
0.0267308857,
-0.089891836,
-0.7721706629,
-0.3875891268,
-0.6592020392,
-0.4983893037,
0.673125267,
-0.7072207928,
-0.0564108677,
-0.6084016562,
-0.1754501164,
0.4306828082,
-0.1053178161,
-0.5748588443,
0.4120952487,
0.6411693692,
0.4615755081,
-1.193384409,
0.467949599,
0.5554956198,
-0.26703161,
-0.6360239387,
0.2814285159,
0.0382921211,
-0.3857962489,
0.672278583,
0.398737818,
0.2643954456,
-0.3718094528,
-0.668877244,
-0.7839576602,
0.2682588398,
0.4960004091,
-0.5911458135,
0.0796626434,
0.5079533458,
0.674014926,
-0.4149024189,
0.3602131009,
0.6881532073,
0.19919689,
0.1815966219,
-0.9199125171,
-0.1560412347,
-0.1831468791,
-0.2692341506,
0.0459176786,
-0.5376142859,
0.6748288274,
0.1177561954,
-0.2721653879,
-0.3911338747,
0.520902276,
0.0776366293,
0.4983699024,
0.9750058651,
0.6805579066,
0.8364231586,
0.099393338,
0.7365059257,
0.3702717423,
0.3485991061,
1.2060668468,
-0.2584685385,
0.7377206087,
-0.0431172848,
-0.4136381447,
0.5590032935,
0.5006427765,
-0.11060258,
0.4476067126,
0.5377690792,
-0.241859436,
-0.2800766826,
-0.2848920226,
-0.4351568818,
0.6808515787,
0.3919135928,
-0.4529393911,
-0.5213009119,
0.2184639573,
-0.0736612082,
-0.0156663917,
-0.19131805,
0.5681084394,
-0.1165536717,
-0.2571358085,
0.551723361,
-0.0532350391,
0.8764768243,
-0.3317820132,
-0.0339919478,
-0.1969231963,
0.0366749503,
-0.4414223433,
-0.4685511589,
0.6696137786,
0.5327298045,
-0.2875289619,
0.0121166268,
0.8602475524,
-0.3199277222,
-0.4874347746,
0.5746890903,
0.5249313116,
0.4404538572,
-0.6615712643,
-0.9923263192,
0.227101624,
0.2929729521,
-0.2502858937,
0.3405686021,
0.1043173447,
-0.1182809696,
0.2682344317,
0.6931782961,
0.170874089,
0.2990751266,
0.4096960127,
0.9628767371,
-0.6761319637,
-0.6584044695,
-0.7221431732,
0.358371079,
-0.2499831617,
-0.1957117766,
0.7173246741,
0.7866535187,
0.820433557,
0.3962749541,
1.0785113573,
-0.0131477537,
1.0328724384,
-0.0985312015,
0.8375985622,
-0.6220037341,
0.1663320214,
-0.5517113805,
-0.8418486118,
-0.4000718296,
0.5067443252,
-0.8118964434,
0.1249768659,
0.4034287632,
0.7100706697,
-0.3138706982,
-0.0031026304,
0.5791538358,
0.2360938042,
0.5149293542,
0.3653332889,
1.080521822,
-0.4018276334,
0.632185638,
-0.3164196014,
-0.3213364184,
-0.0223661773,
-0.324508667,
-0.9101234674,
-0.3466640413,
-0.7292842865,
-0.5114201903,
0.2123700529,
0.3358913958,
0.8290448785,
-0.9417371154,
-0.0715548769,
0.0577206872,
0.2470591515,
0.1497399062,
-0.289331466,
0.2908087373,
-0.1613479704,
-0.5337450504,
0.5246670842,
0.0709202737,
-0.1039021164,
-0.2334050536,
0.2284385711,
-0.0893375427,
-0.1167455986,
0.4149627388,
0.1683619767,
-0.445702374,
-0.1350460052,
-0.5312951803,
0.1006826386,
0.0780532435,
0.8853290081,
-0.7274823785,
0.1072616726,
0.1986286789,
0.6461929083,
0.5714504719,
0.0226801932,
0.3157690167,
-0.7422817945,
0.2892982364,
0.4197048843,
0.0174797382,
0.5843447447,
-0.1918674856,
0.6722680926,
0.8240201473,
-0.1657051891,
-1.1219233274,
0.1888830662,
-0.6504077911,
-0.3066672683,
1.2314699888,
-0.0860673413,
-0.2535731494,
-0.3371249735,
0.2733543217,
0.3350600004,
-0.2826914787,
0.6484748721,
0.6395610571,
-0.0228190925,
-0.0345374681,
-0.3763754964,
0.5055835843,
0.6908452511,
-0.6386829615,
0.0891928971,
0.7174050212,
0.5293386579,
0.3267328143,
0.3438071609,
-0.0418323874,
0.1924249381,
0.1058919653,
0.0897488147,
0.1495620906,
-0.3883717954,
-0.6147010922,
0.5006719828,
-0.2083261162,
-0.3570106924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10227v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10227v1
|
Think Twice: Perspective-Taking Improves Large Language Models' Theory-of-Mind Capabilities
| 2023-11-16T22:49:27 | 2023-11-16T22:49:27 |
Alex Wilf, Sihyun Shawn Lee, Paul Pu Liang, Louis-Philippe Morency
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Human interactions are deeply rooted in the interplay of thoughts, beliefs,
and desires made possible by Theory of Mind (ToM): our cognitive ability to
understand the mental states of ourselves and others. Although ToM may come
naturally to us, emulating it presents a challenge to even the most advanced
Large Language Models (LLMs). Recent improvements to LLMs' reasoning
capabilities from simple yet effective prompting techniques such as
Chain-of-Thought have seen limited applicability to ToM. In this paper, we turn
to the prominent cognitive science theory "Simulation Theory" to bridge this
gap. We introduce SimToM, a novel two-stage prompting framework inspired by
Simulation Theory's notion of perspective-taking. To implement this idea on
current ToM benchmarks, SimToM first filters context based on what the
character in question knows before answering a question about their mental
state. Our approach, which requires no additional training and minimal
prompt-tuning, shows substantial improvement over existing methods, and our
analysis reveals the importance of perspective-taking to Theory-of-Mind
capabilities. Our findings suggest perspective-taking as a promising direction
for future research into improving LLMs' ToM capabilities.
|
[
-0.6705950499,
-0.6447489858,
1.235311985,
0.2779832482,
-0.4690400958,
-0.2103569657,
-0.4288046658,
-0.4477454424,
0.0108499024,
0.3784222305,
-0.7187966108,
0.2599215508,
-0.3618530035,
-0.0064018555,
0.031707041,
0.5638661981,
0.0302401297,
0.3249890804,
-0.442098856,
0.1476260573,
-0.4476457834,
-0.3815329969,
-1.0019598007,
-0.5555610657,
0.6786993742,
0.3240815401,
0.7629930377,
0.2416659445,
0.3040481508,
0.1428567916,
0.0214330815,
0.0928808004,
-0.2229098231,
0.1689195931,
-0.3222219646,
-1.0257852077,
-0.3625925481,
0.2228746116,
0.7160111666,
0.7413823605,
-0.2137334496,
-0.0275057964,
0.3246558309,
0.4934512079,
-0.4123343527,
0.1349753886,
-0.5060671568,
0.0009917652,
0.223195672,
-0.4401839375,
-0.4988305867,
-0.1709548235,
0.2633086443,
-0.6078218818,
0.0296549257,
0.2246518582,
0.3152452111,
0.1974028647,
-0.4667723179,
0.1528740376,
-0.7580256462,
0.8380540609,
-0.4819881916,
0.3474136889,
0.1366941929,
0.377738148,
-0.2791577876,
-0.4754399359,
-0.9653098583,
-0.2166453749,
0.0624572076,
0.1910350174,
0.0661488101,
0.1834119856,
0.6406976581,
0.0749046504,
-0.2777413726,
-0.4208419323,
-0.3170774877,
0.1398055553,
0.4587263167,
0.0747657716,
0.1907889694,
0.0704528615,
-0.5866261125,
-0.4938769341,
-0.5392175913,
-0.0434040166,
-0.0846627057,
0.2122628391,
0.1266419739,
0.1193012372,
-0.0117947077,
0.5182726383,
-0.0700296387,
0.0445193313,
-0.0388380587,
0.0064890818,
-0.4918712676,
-0.1958221197,
0.2713114023,
0.4607899189,
0.4469985962,
0.3260549605,
0.1642130613,
0.1518569887,
0.7759999037,
-0.5774713159,
-0.2701412439,
0.5065344572,
-0.1914839,
-0.2649418116,
-0.0673548728,
-1.0905771255,
-0.7498421073,
-0.345179379,
0.5986672044,
-0.4942513704,
-0.6124373674,
0.3201940954,
0.0429348834,
0.2719108462,
0.8387448788,
-0.412399292,
0.2564208806,
0.885604918,
0.6616355777,
-0.1325227916,
-0.6476230621,
-0.1236535013,
0.444809556,
-0.5038752556,
0.9246618748,
-0.5575715899,
-0.5073809028,
-0.1430046856,
-0.5188317299,
0.102549769,
-0.3894447088,
0.3625353575,
-0.286498487,
0.4407849014,
-0.9136018753,
-0.4105580747,
-0.3214817047,
0.4999460876,
-0.4672274888,
0.866922617,
-0.2959558666,
-0.6626330018,
0.4808174074,
-0.5844352245,
-0.4407448173,
0.1259014159,
-0.6329008937,
0.1970685422,
0.4582672715,
0.2718871832,
0.1985063851,
-0.6593902111,
0.289285928,
-0.3784480691,
-0.1409240812,
0.3215917051,
-0.397827208,
0.8290743232,
0.1895216256,
-0.1802770495,
-0.2022833228,
-0.2998527586,
0.5405631661,
0.2988355458,
-0.1123300493,
-0.5654398203,
0.0779656097,
-0.1637264788,
0.6535061002,
-0.0884676352,
-0.3854449093,
0.2902658284,
-0.3042716682,
0.2241735905,
0.5486835241,
0.1095918939,
0.3011468649,
-0.4082552195,
0.7141237259,
0.3130229115,
0.2273112684,
-0.3593257666,
-0.4605053067,
-0.8144272566,
-0.1740833074,
-0.0860178843,
0.4283615053,
-0.9723257422,
-0.1367962509,
-0.0599409156,
-0.2351118624,
-0.4203575552,
-0.1644261777,
0.5545637608,
0.2980583608,
0.2415367812,
-0.328514725,
-0.5494385362,
-0.87475878,
-0.6928665638,
-0.6339963078,
0.0375654027,
0.2222720683,
0.2631055117,
0.4189745188,
0.9721178412,
-0.8035674095,
0.0044098049,
-0.4984148443,
0.0976744965,
-0.2314538956,
0.4960701764,
0.532867074,
-0.9432680607,
0.0990249291,
-0.3646531999,
-0.8392363787,
0.118396759,
-0.3052886724,
-0.3782524168,
-0.0583403744,
0.5287624002,
-0.7469813824,
0.4078646302,
0.1220503375,
-0.0987521708,
0.1591395289,
-0.4028743804,
0.1434475183,
-1.2218323946,
-0.0931776464,
-0.1377934068,
-0.0886625946,
-0.7047742009,
0.3204200268,
0.300968051,
0.0253243316,
-0.5858981609,
0.7404341698,
-0.5825234056,
-0.1334418207,
-0.2117015272,
0.3138803542,
0.0282039344,
0.5342643857,
0.0447411239,
0.9018062353,
0.468954742,
-0.8298847675,
0.0382706411,
-0.1751455069,
-0.4397782087,
0.9676333666,
-0.2913793027,
0.3031417727,
-0.3830677867,
0.6927179098,
-1.2437150478,
-0.267891556,
0.195737794,
-0.3253261149,
0.2728472352,
0.1496430933,
-0.506970942,
-0.6837813258,
-0.3019843996,
0.5179671049,
0.56544137,
-0.4336007833,
0.7045220733,
0.3386460543,
-0.0434622988,
-0.3141326904,
-0.8683482409,
0.1705025584,
-0.1679306477,
-0.2169084698,
0.009979737,
-0.2987067699,
-0.4818552434,
-0.4456520975,
-0.2001610696,
-0.070831582,
0.1509448886,
0.0578205958,
0.2274541706,
0.0955596492,
0.1926259995,
0.2028695494,
-0.1692768931,
0.4237676263,
-0.6675449014,
0.5910421014,
0.0875425935,
-0.3896035552,
-0.6829732656,
0.256960541,
0.6197648048,
-0.0571886413,
0.5261716843,
-0.0422404297,
-0.4345203936,
-0.401900351,
-0.5837476254,
-0.3087242544,
-0.4363375008,
0.3464521766,
-0.5505257845,
-0.6361855268,
0.1365831941,
-0.2753041089,
0.2037105262,
-0.0688337237,
0.4020003974,
-0.2583499253,
1.0548343658,
0.6674092412,
0.1480076611,
0.417129904,
-0.0518613681,
0.4044272602,
-0.9854493737,
-0.3171604574,
-0.2207084596,
-0.333686173,
-0.0282842945,
-1.0303689241,
0.451702714,
0.0089681027,
0.0795469657,
0.0185227953,
-0.0828785226,
0.5376262665,
0.250143528,
0.0856047496,
0.2799128592,
0.0413834564,
-0.3775821626,
-0.1256776005,
-0.5913897753,
-0.4672604799,
0.7174788713,
0.1626334786,
0.5472214222,
0.0702630058,
0.6921631694,
-0.0900930092,
0.2678334117,
-0.8052210212,
1.0393968821,
0.3988434672,
-0.9126413465,
-0.1676942855,
-0.2070832849,
-0.515860498,
0.732485652,
0.0424356498,
-0.7128462195,
0.0981894359,
0.4044635892,
-0.6993743777,
0.4805646241,
-0.4460852444,
0.2107334584,
-0.1402094066,
-0.404681623,
-0.7331290841,
-0.569262743,
0.4126116633,
0.0176146831,
0.2513476908,
0.10061609,
-0.3112074733,
0.4977296293,
-0.0117679602,
0.7270206213,
-0.3351596594,
-0.428424418,
0.3358293474,
0.5216611028,
0.1006974131,
0.2022963762,
0.0763905048,
-0.1207237542,
0.081876114,
-0.3397844732,
-1.0106480122,
0.5084466338,
-0.3904188871,
-0.8837169409,
-0.5783882141,
-0.6831057668,
-0.6446349621,
0.1662106365,
0.1727725565,
0.1229628474,
-0.3479495943,
-0.1011747494,
0.7823241353,
-0.0871609077,
0.2890909016,
0.3201474249,
-0.7719905972,
-0.3213587701,
0.4019509554,
0.0818582848,
0.5249131918,
0.2066228688,
0.0935315117,
-0.046505712,
0.0859542787,
-0.2858623564,
0.2831375897,
-0.4225206077,
0.1255312413,
-0.8041548133,
-0.0791530982,
-0.1262466013,
-0.1436724216,
-0.430114001,
-0.4829125702,
0.1716928631,
-0.1087517887,
0.0081014652,
0.6896643639,
-0.0440894179,
0.1667013764,
-0.2723056972,
0.2961758077,
0.7408233285,
0.1032368243,
0.5527991652,
-0.2908141911,
0.0223658904,
0.3285005093,
-0.1966937184,
-0.7840541005,
0.0054514632,
-0.3332080543,
0.5015534163,
0.417627275,
-0.1089375243,
0.9617193341,
-0.4871314466,
0.8623130322,
0.1535379589,
-0.9539443254,
0.6348961592,
-0.2951262593,
0.3074681461,
0.6592108607,
0.1156813428,
-0.699791193,
-0.3093677759,
-0.7270143628,
-0.3864420354,
0.9984413385,
0.3051088452,
0.196800679,
0.087412551,
0.546307981,
-0.0154762734,
0.4649305344,
-0.3306761086,
-0.1453945339,
0.2874893546,
0.092533581,
-0.238338232,
-0.4470025599,
-0.2214705348,
-0.4109869003,
0.5121455789,
-0.1117542163,
0.5822958946,
0.4007707238,
0.0899820402,
-0.372905314,
0.1510921717,
0.6754829288,
0.8784902692,
-0.0428558588,
0.3297081888,
0.4334972203,
-0.4952166378,
0.0456426404,
-0.4727144539,
-0.1943355799,
-0.3669591546,
0.0963171497,
0.5537018776,
0.4301912785,
-0.5665717721,
0.4076320231,
-0.0361054577,
-0.0910779983,
-0.3067866266,
0.2816922069,
0.1616586149,
0.4698082209,
0.4029730856,
0.1275081038,
-0.0257526636,
-0.7920022011,
0.1691070348,
0.1522695124,
-0.2596288919,
-0.4074559212,
0.7368426323,
0.0144035351,
-0.5131488442,
0.3608748317,
0.0894666463,
-0.6499218941,
0.7569534183,
0.7319934964,
0.97105515,
-0.4535745084,
0.2691955566,
0.32595101,
0.2535109818,
-0.518907845,
0.6815229654,
-0.2826339006,
-0.8730261326,
-0.1170840934,
-0.2195367068,
-0.642131567,
0.0459913909,
-1.1150872707,
0.2061738968,
-0.7783426046,
-0.1941551119,
-0.0815206245,
0.1469919086,
-0.7020740509,
0.3912810683,
0.5887996554,
1.0368802547,
-0.6795066595,
1.19759202,
1.1098173857,
-0.2276193053,
-0.7885531187,
0.7601901889,
0.3341616392,
-0.7345033288,
0.2772516012,
0.3210251033,
-0.4711023867,
-0.0077701313,
-0.7572202086,
-0.8254766464,
1.1147286892,
0.4085405171,
-0.3601035178,
-0.1395102441,
-0.3129195273,
0.6477972269,
-0.5810551643,
0.2638449669,
0.6833044291,
0.440017283,
0.1194809079,
-0.5963277817,
-0.0349765755,
-0.0773184225,
0.4371891618,
0.0423614532,
-1.1306656599,
1.0082226992,
-0.4208092988,
-0.0530179814,
-0.034202788,
0.8241894245,
0.6378727555,
0.3351844251,
0.8417662978,
0.3060607314,
0.8157281876,
0.2964601219,
1.1439256668,
-0.0674715489,
0.4224703908,
1.2121101618,
-0.6066744924,
0.9243674278,
0.7938491106,
-0.3887384236,
0.4402632415,
0.176958859,
0.6290758252,
0.472646594,
-0.1567533314,
-0.0363765471,
-0.6315278411,
0.1920776665,
-0.2742886245,
0.4402889013,
0.3841347694,
-0.0795838907,
-0.044138141,
0.213629052,
0.4104264975,
0.0528177321,
-0.0569025874,
0.4943928421,
0.403557986,
-0.9063155055,
0.1268676668,
-0.3302562237,
0.2877396345,
-0.4234337509,
-0.0309833828,
-0.2996220291,
0.3015066087,
0.4116949737,
-1.057305932,
-0.0968069807,
-0.1106551886,
-0.1748622805,
-0.5338370204,
0.3261892498,
-0.4983488917,
-0.4081375599,
0.5751040578,
0.7171112299,
0.2561611533,
-0.1097877696,
-0.6903506517,
0.0017910588,
0.1823798865,
-0.4768003225,
0.3664108217,
0.540336132,
-0.1668844819,
0.7127228379,
0.3495379388,
0.1508409977,
-0.2417208105,
0.0408543907,
0.8435276151,
-0.999140501,
-0.9108447433,
-0.9022127986,
0.2191445976,
-0.3372229636,
-0.3005435765,
0.5110864639,
0.3012420237,
1.0179753304,
0.0619299822,
0.8324385285,
-0.1513609737,
0.5509306788,
-0.4699957371,
0.6852684021,
-0.9796991944,
0.2090099156,
-0.4443748295,
-0.9798617959,
-0.2682282031,
0.7120836973,
-0.4056712389,
0.2850424051,
1.1585941315,
0.668571651,
0.0056399642,
0.416852802,
0.5421544313,
0.5064866543,
0.2289051116,
0.8059924245,
0.9358268976,
-0.2130031288,
0.1403634399,
-0.3590940237,
-0.2059185952,
-0.2658593655,
-0.6746221781,
-0.9147745371,
-0.7837975025,
-0.052653037,
-0.2306887656,
-0.0672761425,
1.2386888266,
0.6134866476,
-0.4866564572,
-0.3170185387,
-0.0422453173,
-0.1621417701,
-0.4692717493,
-0.1360290796,
-0.0911123827,
-0.231886059,
-0.6412754059,
0.2530227602,
0.5290383697,
-0.1638033688,
-0.4784656465,
0.1932948679,
-0.2336282432,
0.651088953,
0.5609526038,
0.1089108735,
-1.0594854355,
-0.4867679179,
-0.4788859785,
-0.2039651573,
0.1315701902,
1.2533607483,
-1.176140666,
0.7367350459,
0.3393695652,
0.3467645943,
0.1868106127,
0.1495605856,
0.7128242254,
-0.2242588699,
0.5642278194,
0.0942082256,
0.178747803,
0.1865072995,
-0.5662249327,
0.4193861783,
0.150874868,
0.0175322741,
-0.8388845325,
0.555295825,
-0.9216305614,
-0.4288878441,
1.0492908955,
0.0203234628,
-0.4186671674,
0.2359248251,
-0.598359108,
0.2207043618,
-0.2337394506,
0.7631738186,
0.8836929798,
-0.2446863502,
-0.3585551083,
-0.8606382012,
0.5810407996,
1.0013421774,
-0.8774113655,
0.3862015307,
0.3390021622,
0.1984867156,
0.0463170037,
0.8022247553,
-0.0656091571,
0.1979473233,
0.0857381225,
-0.0163693111,
0.0905107334,
-0.7955190539,
-0.6196602583,
0.0269006714,
-0.0301664975,
0.0653649792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10217v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10217v2
|
A Language and Its Dimensions: Intrinsic Dimensions of Language Fractal Structures
| 2023-11-16T22:15:15 | 2023-11-20T17:08:11 |
Vasilii A. Gromov, Nikita S. Borodin, Asel S. Yerbolova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, math.AT, nlin.CD
|
The present paper introduces a novel object of study - a language fractal
structure. We hypothesize that a set of embeddings of all $n$-grams of a
natural language constitutes a representative sample of this fractal set. (We
use the term Hailonakea to refer to the sum total of all language fractal
structures, over all $n$). The paper estimates intrinsic (genuine) dimensions
of language fractal structures for the Russian and English languages. To this
end, we employ methods based on (1) topological data analysis and (2) a minimum
spanning tree of a data graph for a cloud of points considered (Steele
theorem). For both languages, for all $n$, the intrinsic dimensions appear to
be non-integer values (typical for fractal sets), close to 9 for both of the
Russian and English language.
|
[
-0.3717751205,
-1.2050288916,
0.5232138634,
0.498406142,
-0.0930664614,
0.1477773488,
-0.0763553455,
-0.5851794481,
0.6459036469,
0.0386193097,
-0.1822277457,
-0.3238760233,
-0.5679708719,
0.0886457637,
-0.5457277894,
0.5422599912,
0.2894399166,
-0.0440992415,
-0.2369198054,
-0.2526452541,
-0.0482731014,
-0.4906951785,
-0.399759829,
0.2210058272,
0.3259835839,
0.4323948622,
0.8813868165,
0.9059181213,
0.3529710472,
0.4176845551,
-0.2955535054,
-0.2381526977,
0.0052711,
0.1338859051,
0.1363115609,
-0.473107338,
-0.0695540607,
-0.0927578434,
1.4079601765,
1.1101520061,
0.0859993547,
0.0776480734,
-0.0779232979,
0.8831013441,
-0.1870198995,
0.3189116418,
-0.1425442845,
0.2754449248,
-0.4194921255,
0.1228081509,
-0.0165666807,
-0.6826101542,
0.2006851584,
-0.2651353776,
0.0040471582,
0.0873900205,
0.6424601674,
0.0157460459,
-0.3944627345,
-0.4726788998,
-0.651856482,
0.871718049,
-0.2772304416,
0.6984789371,
0.4553037286,
0.0668611303,
0.1701142937,
-0.1889666766,
-0.4514559209,
-0.3650024831,
-0.1496277452,
-0.3267556131,
-0.3028147221,
-0.3563898504,
0.0913647488,
1.0817198753,
-0.6269338131,
0.2863887548,
-0.2864601016,
-0.1327624768,
0.613612771,
0.1467357874,
0.4854086339,
-0.0761341676,
0.0447167717,
0.2162875384,
-0.651447475,
0.0929915607,
0.5638587475,
0.5059034824,
-0.4327933192,
0.367638588,
-0.237600103,
0.629930675,
-0.2322133183,
-0.4294474423,
0.2979159057,
-0.2728795707,
0.0288183577,
-0.1239792183,
0.7852091789,
-0.3539762199,
0.2846138477,
-0.116593495,
-0.0091660907,
-0.3760975897,
-0.091733247,
-0.8075288534,
-0.1920738667,
0.2726998627,
-0.3347542584,
-0.6246480346,
0.1296161115,
-0.6156038642,
-0.2553660274,
-0.1117980555,
0.3735832572,
-0.6712834835,
-0.5774567127,
-0.1879583746,
0.1665994227,
0.2498732358,
0.0338514373,
-1.0255477428,
0.7181050181,
0.6559613943,
1.1858328581,
0.3076021075,
-0.5070613027,
-0.2312227041,
-0.504740119,
-0.4618489146,
0.9900842309,
-0.8561573029,
-0.3989562988,
0.2990406454,
-0.1791753322,
0.3211068213,
-0.2398226708,
0.2113310099,
-0.2347027957,
0.6017547846,
-0.5975267887,
-0.5214446783,
-0.3708544075,
0.1066408902,
-0.5747324228,
0.7431776524,
0.1981501132,
-0.6988614798,
0.3159429431,
-0.4713181257,
-0.7155165672,
0.3579092324,
-0.3561644852,
-0.28040874,
0.3690316081,
-0.0404228792,
0.2989199162,
-0.3925867379,
-0.2052157521,
-0.2321201265,
-0.0964256823,
0.2292090058,
-0.3269633055,
1.1326242685,
0.2423093617,
-0.2605133355,
-0.257897526,
-0.6498144269,
0.1072010621,
0.2604006529,
-0.4278438985,
-0.2304881662,
0.152338177,
0.246596545,
-0.0473226495,
0.5057574511,
-0.7519324422,
0.1966774017,
-0.3502183855,
0.1815430969,
0.6918550134,
-0.0057809479,
0.4475148916,
-0.1885767132,
0.3374973238,
0.0706978589,
0.0991753414,
-0.0957141966,
-0.6106526852,
-0.4916740358,
-0.3234069943,
0.2715815008,
0.3031724691,
-0.1762871891,
0.6679731607,
-0.357849896,
-0.5197083354,
-0.1796869487,
0.0420196354,
0.3083051741,
0.0053276299,
-0.1479761153,
-0.0266273506,
-0.2316387594,
-1.2972173691,
-0.0227397345,
-0.4644962251,
0.0230651665,
0.3037590683,
0.5606187582,
0.3163107932,
0.6796737909,
-0.6675285101,
-0.4195082784,
-0.0443619862,
-0.0669942051,
0.2068214417,
0.3339446187,
0.8711252809,
-0.5219578743,
-0.8890844584,
0.4265925288,
-0.7563915849,
0.0116196917,
0.1648530364,
0.4681173563,
0.4892778695,
-0.0176737476,
-0.2121728063,
0.1310347766,
0.5989576578,
-0.6107649207,
0.5785610676,
-0.2765045166,
0.2232723683,
-1.2533637285,
0.0120215034,
-0.118148081,
-0.0867456123,
-0.7654575109,
0.1906140298,
-0.0656698644,
-0.126688838,
-0.2208341658,
0.3775713444,
-0.5569825768,
-0.2450671196,
-0.1801408827,
0.1686247289,
-0.4219700992,
0.478674531,
0.0337144695,
0.5343623757,
1.1845626831,
-0.3745087683,
0.4803830981,
0.1758515984,
-0.6341901422,
0.9543457031,
-0.6148293018,
-0.0956453532,
-0.1771536618,
-0.2901636362,
-0.7185980082,
-0.1556126624,
-0.1959590912,
-0.623789072,
0.168933779,
-0.1125458553,
-0.6634520888,
0.0851151273,
-0.2591840029,
0.3036705852,
0.4934637547,
-0.3200085759,
0.2451379597,
0.9294736385,
-0.311781168,
-0.3235932291,
-0.6318053603,
0.1118509471,
-0.2167465985,
-0.7726157904,
0.0231371298,
-0.0934637859,
-0.7073581219,
0.2570748925,
0.152963236,
-0.3220144212,
0.0737418011,
0.2925571501,
-0.2838499844,
-0.6711972952,
0.3031111062,
-0.0978853032,
-0.0046620239,
0.0902737454,
-0.5755848289,
0.6686198711,
-0.828943491,
-0.0827514455,
-0.5640385747,
0.6459425092,
0.7324208021,
0.0231771413,
0.9275420904,
0.3257903755,
-0.7532052398,
-0.0056246375,
-0.4799588025,
0.1112175435,
-0.4574243426,
0.4476053715,
-0.5758535266,
-1.1034773588,
0.7632642984,
0.5877052546,
0.0350985974,
0.6030210257,
0.6725814939,
-0.0356702358,
0.5715845823,
0.882296145,
-0.5566121936,
0.4312724173,
-0.1942549944,
0.3593885899,
-0.4765739441,
-0.2683761716,
-0.9380291104,
-0.34822312,
-0.6034575105,
-0.2101689577,
0.3390042782,
-0.0367222577,
-0.263278842,
0.264444232,
0.037270423,
0.7859159112,
0.4010439217,
-0.3834499121,
0.1340955496,
0.1912387013,
-0.1229697987,
-0.2248344868,
-0.458356142,
-0.2840355039,
0.523511529,
0.526229322,
0.270573467,
0.6883223653,
0.4780166149,
0.123643972,
-0.0449703112,
-1.0634198189,
0.1946813166,
-0.1106357574,
-0.7117420435,
-0.716095984,
-0.6594393849,
-0.6731028557,
0.3044762909,
-0.0400692448,
-1.0084102154,
0.2448847592,
-0.2234286815,
-0.0463426411,
0.6509652138,
-0.4710630178,
0.4395414591,
-0.014819338,
0.0603167638,
-0.4702824056,
-0.2506267428,
0.3486265838,
-0.154508993,
0.3801319897,
-0.0207335632,
0.0324482061,
0.7968591452,
-0.4168593585,
0.7117405534,
0.0435142554,
-0.3712533712,
0.2637275755,
0.578876555,
0.1206132695,
0.3574932814,
0.0749205127,
0.2689311206,
0.1752913892,
-0.6754071116,
-0.6044645309,
1.2044243813,
-0.8129163384,
-0.5752806664,
-0.581115365,
-0.6433981061,
-0.0821038038,
0.3107521832,
0.1547083259,
1.0073444843,
-0.545765996,
0.7523211837,
0.4423181117,
-0.1917139292,
0.5221267343,
0.532730341,
-0.2328664958,
-0.2926770151,
1.0137050152,
0.5354867578,
0.1914003342,
0.7515352368,
0.5722343922,
-0.4514598846,
-0.4955304861,
-0.1407553554,
0.2909764946,
-0.4664260149,
0.2243517339,
-0.5383414626,
-0.2154621929,
-0.3029369414,
-0.121446155,
-0.5038307309,
-0.6555895805,
0.1488581747,
-0.0742665976,
0.3638242483,
1.1376240253,
-0.448859334,
0.1038558781,
-0.734128356,
-0.1537287086,
0.3979065716,
0.6760446429,
0.1219404042,
-0.610149622,
-0.499016881,
0.0299772117,
-0.1209114045,
-0.6759880185,
0.2533210218,
0.4228737652,
0.7145617604,
0.8783115149,
-0.3867758214,
0.4200088382,
-0.5523161292,
0.6940052509,
-0.003099109,
-0.9961892962,
0.2730387449,
-0.4414515197,
0.3642252386,
0.1468557715,
0.7006617188,
-0.7755007148,
-0.4431576431,
-0.8371860981,
-0.0999006554,
0.3603219688,
0.4786532521,
0.2669349611,
-0.1544241309,
0.0222304575,
0.0636574477,
-0.1578319669,
-0.5645930767,
-0.5213330984,
-0.0817496106,
-0.0597894304,
-0.1605165452,
-0.4569407403,
-0.0141056739,
-0.1861779839,
0.157086432,
0.0598223656,
0.2232237309,
-0.0817146897,
-0.2148081064,
-0.1842300445,
-0.0021993336,
0.8817341328,
0.7063882947,
-0.0109475162,
0.5201460123,
0.2696609795,
-0.8589071631,
0.0658025295,
-0.4767694771,
0.241442129,
-0.1811094731,
0.6146646142,
0.3559886813,
0.0639448985,
-0.1267418861,
0.2430297136,
-0.1257718056,
-0.1734249145,
-0.4134227037,
-0.3681168258,
0.1703955531,
-0.052933678,
0.3269351125,
-0.1779283136,
0.0122111682,
-0.8038429022,
0.2940548658,
0.411225915,
-0.5702978373,
-1.0260400772,
0.0167640876,
0.031591069,
-0.5809859633,
0.6137536764,
-0.1516032964,
-0.611426115,
0.398801446,
0.5547970533,
0.9064020514,
-0.4334796071,
0.4702239931,
0.4701110125,
0.6719661951,
0.4147807658,
0.3360472918,
-0.0539518259,
-0.7647045851,
-0.147706449,
-1.121358633,
-0.1193242297,
0.1959972829,
-0.2640096843,
-0.0355143026,
-0.763484478,
0.5232222676,
0.2121709436,
0.2786147594,
-0.219672963,
-0.0079750298,
-0.0696418583,
0.7354063392,
-1.1082125902,
0.7414390445,
0.4209841192,
-0.5062650442,
-0.1870583743,
-0.0733402893,
0.5172106028,
-0.7327981591,
0.7922756672,
-0.0306644123,
-0.106245555,
-0.1194172278,
-0.1943318397,
-1.1918897629,
0.5598657131,
0.1337383837,
0.0100439163,
0.524312675,
0.563185215,
0.7604117393,
-0.450605154,
-0.1754029095,
0.4809728265,
0.3952724934,
-0.1143914387,
-0.7430387139,
0.0214386079,
-0.4669656754,
-0.0263082907,
0.5482204556,
-0.642387569,
0.8502075076,
-0.1939006448,
-0.4618723392,
0.0285479352,
0.6696221828,
-0.0888149291,
-0.6386154294,
0.5027840137,
0.6216939688,
0.7558902502,
-0.2260894328,
1.1188895702,
-0.4046744406,
0.309764266,
0.4221464097,
0.2970576584,
0.794280529,
0.2780768275,
-0.6518913507,
0.3965606987,
0.3393243551,
0.1933395416,
0.1715505421,
0.1653263122,
-0.286906898,
-0.0648718476,
-0.175908044,
-0.3529266715,
0.423047483,
0.5399497151,
-0.0830727369,
-0.2729570866,
-0.3854283094,
0.1587080806,
0.1414662302,
0.1509670317,
0.6427650452,
0.1619112045,
0.0105660018,
0.5462533832,
-0.0994549766,
0.2478155345,
-0.3556956947,
0.1310399771,
-0.6641821265,
-0.0648519397,
-0.1617524475,
-1.1240850687,
0.7560070753,
-0.0857584178,
-0.178959012,
-0.0016379834,
0.0323785581,
-0.3011383116,
-0.7574815154,
-0.1273422986,
0.2678370476,
0.4272859693,
-0.0323064476,
-0.2525064349,
-0.1358559579,
-0.155701071,
-0.0672705173,
0.365437746,
0.688631773,
0.0348523818,
0.7320534587,
0.60495013,
0.2030143142,
0.0050126095,
-0.1961046606,
0.4681303501,
-0.7695095539,
-0.7218742371,
-0.8272524476,
0.3513661921,
-0.0516149253,
-0.5132775307,
0.7511240244,
0.7880300879,
0.5277593732,
-0.0872521996,
0.5253728628,
-0.4336569309,
0.1935463399,
-0.31185624,
0.8410935998,
-0.4987682998,
-0.1013855189,
-0.1081532091,
-1.223736763,
-0.4905577898,
0.707474649,
-0.142268613,
-0.2002754807,
1.1639313698,
0.6459355354,
-0.0085261008,
0.1323119104,
0.7335502505,
0.5552010536,
0.4339152277,
0.1860844493,
0.7519308329,
-0.2516547143,
0.1481823772,
-0.5140431523,
-0.4498292208,
0.0358167775,
-0.5148876309,
-0.8747468591,
-1.3197052479,
-0.2181614637,
0.0090258494,
-0.6132344604,
0.4011467099,
0.5250169635,
-0.9429123402,
-0.5276933312,
0.1970063746,
0.4454223216,
-0.1524959058,
-0.2123119384,
0.5406903625,
-0.3887657821,
-0.8123999238,
0.4204445183,
0.7303558588,
0.3252156079,
-0.6907800436,
0.1209443957,
-0.2529684305,
0.0638355091,
0.7250888348,
0.3628932238,
-0.6025794744,
-0.77925843,
0.0468310826,
-0.0361970365,
-0.009108427,
0.686866045,
-0.3104679585,
0.0359166749,
0.8360276818,
0.2566216588,
0.0228822287,
-0.401129365,
0.5133895278,
-0.9343998432,
0.3923973143,
-0.0433216728,
0.4828886688,
0.2681066692,
-0.256000489,
0.1011663079,
0.2672848105,
-0.3173678219,
-0.8558877707,
0.4795823991,
-0.7810331583,
-0.2255534232,
0.9085931182,
-0.0011411667,
-0.3204624951,
-0.2887831032,
0.1619049907,
-0.5829486847,
-0.0733465925,
0.9873600602,
1.0302809477,
0.263597995,
-0.1996574551,
-0.1614659131,
0.4808368385,
0.0236235801,
-0.6466417909,
0.0544039905,
0.3460183442,
0.4664758444,
0.8016531467,
0.3845230043,
-0.5928612947,
0.0372749269,
0.4498918951,
-0.2380576283,
0.0049225707,
-0.733581841,
-0.4529765248,
0.3209993839,
0.0543309748,
0.0018902213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10215v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10215v1
|
Predictive Minds: LLMs As Atypical Active Inference Agents
| 2023-11-16T22:11:12 | 2023-11-16T22:11:12 |
Jan Kulveit, Clem von Stengel, Roman Leventov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) like GPT are often conceptualized as passive
predictors, simulators, or even stochastic parrots. We instead conceptualize
LLMs by drawing on the theory of active inference originating in cognitive
science and neuroscience. We examine similarities and differences between
traditional active inference systems and LLMs, leading to the conclusion that,
currently, LLMs lack a tight feedback loop between acting in the world and
perceiving the impacts of their actions, but otherwise fit in the active
inference paradigm. We list reasons why this loop may soon be closed, and
possible consequences of this including enhanced model self-awareness and the
drive to minimize prediction error by changing the world.
|
[
-0.0582125969,
-0.9149086475,
1.0361609459,
-0.0863293186,
0.0314379409,
0.1463446617,
-0.2801506817,
-0.4262867272,
0.2426141202,
0.5102068186,
-0.7633590102,
-0.0835915506,
-0.4572339654,
-0.1055774912,
-0.440525502,
0.672937572,
-0.1895857155,
0.0105405664,
-0.1275497079,
0.3012895584,
-0.0196171384,
-0.5805313587,
-0.7144647837,
-0.7715613842,
0.5716667771,
-0.0896181539,
0.9336766005,
0.3372839987,
0.2511886954,
0.3217765987,
-0.088480711,
-0.2163505256,
-0.2980374992,
0.4249720871,
-0.1072454304,
-0.7531368732,
-0.3085184991,
0.3475629687,
0.5698100328,
0.7746842504,
-0.2426771373,
-0.2971218526,
-0.2125830501,
0.3894524872,
-0.5041201711,
0.2382117212,
-0.7283030748,
0.2400293201,
0.220650658,
0.065565303,
-0.2290906608,
-0.188876465,
0.293941021,
-0.4300071299,
0.1226552501,
0.111572057,
0.4610007107,
0.4708638489,
-0.4789689183,
-0.3549590111,
-0.8231174946,
0.8678530455,
-0.7184217572,
0.2507318258,
0.5079135895,
0.2026914954,
-0.5425661802,
-0.797291398,
-0.6881682873,
-0.3602998853,
0.1876925975,
0.286154896,
-0.0912766308,
0.2467979342,
0.2473641932,
0.2774925232,
-0.103052564,
0.126813814,
-0.3777770102,
-0.0142079331,
0.6084214449,
0.1519569308,
-0.1319982409,
0.0259660929,
-0.4041830897,
0.599532783,
-0.6480597258,
-0.1112735271,
0.1819063574,
0.2111382633,
0.0762285143,
0.5919044614,
0.0159620065,
0.6139492393,
0.0944505185,
-0.3233637512,
-0.1908366531,
0.1153894141,
-0.4328344762,
0.0025314076,
0.8804946542,
-0.0237553064,
0.4579852819,
-0.2664194405,
-0.5254309773,
0.5062084198,
0.3611802161,
-0.3794089556,
-0.3212008178,
0.3720548451,
-0.4323299825,
-0.4248468578,
0.0104257017,
-0.2283996046,
-0.4504187405,
-0.384948343,
0.3378977776,
-0.1213780195,
-0.2928788364,
0.053194385,
0.0887512565,
-0.0919791162,
0.6870051622,
-0.5374490023,
0.5045778155,
0.4564520717,
0.709187448,
-0.5004053712,
-0.3247311711,
0.0384429693,
0.4419943094,
-0.4095206857,
0.9788181186,
-0.7049193382,
-0.4077727497,
-0.0179532804,
0.2936342955,
-0.1305895746,
-0.2453783154,
0.193693459,
-0.5883264542,
0.2129992694,
-0.3238677979,
-0.6345157027,
-0.4674044549,
0.2579589784,
-0.5531514883,
0.7065646052,
-0.2077685148,
-0.4773817062,
0.3481782377,
-0.5713716745,
-0.3301835656,
-0.062216524,
-0.2289625704,
-0.2404488474,
0.2622616291,
-0.2231635302,
0.5252302885,
-0.1480559856,
0.3071006238,
-0.5710985661,
-0.5634667277,
0.638718307,
-0.5019456148,
0.6324503422,
0.2741088271,
-0.3285264969,
0.408128798,
-0.2783385515,
-0.0763443932,
0.1087268218,
-0.2535582185,
-0.0785090923,
0.5383720994,
-0.4834134877,
0.2357384562,
0.0816139281,
-0.3493611217,
0.4208180904,
-0.1012728587,
0.7706320882,
0.9888271093,
0.0572631285,
0.4577282965,
-0.3670859039,
0.7033320069,
-0.0564411469,
0.0786707997,
0.0922772065,
-0.72907269,
-0.689787209,
-0.2061681151,
0.0604050756,
0.5517133474,
-0.6036908031,
0.1256506443,
0.067249544,
-0.2802512944,
-0.1346836835,
0.1778245866,
0.2614853084,
-0.042378284,
-0.108116895,
-0.1525233835,
-0.4742828906,
-0.6501701474,
-0.2202492505,
-0.430729568,
0.048259709,
0.0756609663,
0.6212103963,
-0.3296727836,
0.5970851183,
-0.3269779086,
-0.0728412196,
-0.4402759969,
-0.2644757628,
0.2691700161,
0.2041074038,
0.0796916783,
-0.691991508,
-0.1689348966,
-0.3798665702,
-0.9338529706,
0.3238816261,
-0.0306791384,
0.1070667729,
0.0331571735,
0.7327650785,
-0.9176978469,
0.4647342563,
0.4355007112,
-0.4198734164,
0.6642438769,
0.079344511,
-0.1368058473,
-0.6745929718,
-0.3388450444,
-0.0677901432,
-0.0652433112,
-0.5383343697,
-0.1782790273,
-0.111850217,
0.0433457047,
-0.4726214707,
0.7299476862,
-0.8869968653,
-0.3273640871,
-0.4136719108,
0.1341883987,
-0.2910167277,
0.3916849792,
0.2609727383,
0.838992238,
0.717295289,
-0.8299946189,
0.550835669,
-0.0132852774,
-0.3627974987,
-0.0818011761,
-0.5997126102,
-0.0197507907,
-0.1140560657,
0.5268027782,
-0.8496168852,
-0.3146877885,
0.1057270691,
-0.4393995702,
0.2856954038,
-0.0044686804,
-0.3519195914,
-0.7768852711,
-0.213745296,
0.0996327102,
0.6488334537,
-0.0277457274,
0.5585448742,
0.390255183,
-0.045552209,
-0.5294796824,
-0.99515903,
-0.0192815755,
-0.0870255008,
-0.1543891281,
0.0482849292,
0.0940088779,
-0.8354309797,
0.0610538088,
-0.0485450514,
0.139343068,
0.2028872669,
0.4821101129,
0.1849884391,
-0.1511525959,
0.3657506406,
-0.1444658488,
0.1263325512,
0.288795799,
-0.3046417832,
0.0979357809,
-0.1505032629,
-0.723736465,
-0.2823687196,
0.0295912419,
0.7885041833,
0.0875136927,
0.6944248676,
0.0531909131,
-0.5263699889,
-0.1807002574,
-0.5670833588,
-0.4187207818,
-0.4508754313,
0.2185097486,
-0.4462696314,
-0.65213871,
0.8452265263,
0.0093257548,
-0.05045975,
0.2254655063,
0.8398438692,
-0.1797603965,
1.1145085096,
0.6423973441,
0.0947045311,
0.7641112208,
-0.2308465838,
0.0782225877,
-0.9169299603,
-0.1185768917,
0.0558610447,
-0.236642912,
-0.5334755778,
-0.5589793921,
-0.0867570564,
0.1532407254,
-0.3802647889,
-0.2058542073,
-0.3341982067,
0.4501682222,
0.604845345,
0.1250747293,
0.1738813221,
-0.0786580294,
-0.1528820097,
0.0346743017,
-0.7997829914,
-0.7892565727,
1.319198966,
0.3499722183,
1.0515031815,
0.0704283267,
0.1979919821,
0.3468345404,
0.7527346015,
-1.1008158922,
0.6685955524,
0.1775604188,
-0.9424383044,
-0.2237571329,
0.0106252357,
-0.9364485145,
0.1546811014,
-0.1715685427,
-0.8619610667,
0.023164643,
0.0605120398,
-0.3621096909,
0.567571938,
-0.6046835184,
0.5510994196,
-0.206471175,
-0.6872753501,
-0.1014978737,
-0.611574471,
0.6323696971,
-0.1112755835,
0.1339487284,
-0.3877466917,
-0.3225406706,
0.6808649302,
-0.3416254222,
1.1698383093,
-0.2372692674,
-0.3133805096,
0.7597113252,
0.0460874438,
0.6097908616,
-0.0209280215,
-0.4274402559,
-0.1513593346,
-0.2531995773,
-0.5002576709,
-0.4393830597,
0.7065993547,
-0.8642186522,
-0.8587624431,
-0.555752337,
-0.4801094234,
-0.3881039321,
0.1380254626,
0.1188363433,
0.0776490644,
-0.2758644521,
-0.3653132319,
0.6963131428,
0.0279781781,
0.3936717808,
0.7421688437,
-0.3760740459,
-0.2355303317,
0.4085401595,
0.1537349373,
0.3599537313,
-0.0240815338,
0.0124348002,
-0.3812476695,
-0.7486701012,
-0.0382394753,
0.4985821247,
-0.7803539634,
-0.0042882599,
-0.5892798901,
-0.1857596487,
-0.3693997562,
-0.3501732945,
-0.2325485498,
-0.3509972692,
-0.1919414401,
-0.3034795225,
0.2503452897,
1.2446639538,
0.1753479093,
0.4471374154,
-0.3502573967,
0.1624767333,
0.4198835194,
0.3765671551,
0.085922882,
-0.4722664058,
-0.1290448606,
0.0568548366,
-0.5034717321,
-0.8957079649,
0.3407288194,
0.1758490205,
0.8858690262,
0.7558798194,
0.016504325,
0.5315471292,
-0.3956925869,
0.9997663498,
0.2777470052,
-0.6888393164,
0.6736786962,
-0.4612067938,
0.3249649405,
0.0841465443,
0.29903543,
-0.3305663764,
-0.8000277281,
-0.6456278563,
-0.4280620515,
0.5038946867,
0.0161597598,
0.0002761243,
-0.2747293413,
0.5508112907,
0.2701154947,
0.4517701864,
-0.8457517028,
-0.2334132046,
-0.1431774497,
-0.0063974611,
-0.3803758621,
-0.3525359929,
-0.0725257322,
-0.2785885334,
0.6742869616,
-0.2739823163,
0.7375587225,
0.1579679251,
0.0827947631,
-0.6003645062,
-0.006675628,
0.746152401,
0.7879219651,
-0.2512685955,
0.3411999047,
0.204420194,
-0.4411814213,
0.3187417984,
-0.2843410075,
-0.1868510246,
-0.1364599168,
0.5805874467,
0.8901227713,
0.3159109652,
-0.7172169089,
0.3838131428,
0.0034006911,
-0.3087526262,
-0.9002540112,
0.1742441207,
0.2510292232,
0.4662117958,
0.5031170249,
0.2463782132,
0.0210464243,
-0.9518006444,
0.0570417643,
0.6712793708,
-0.7163608074,
-0.7245252728,
0.9248694181,
0.1754836738,
-0.2948841751,
0.4294439554,
-0.0950539857,
-0.8443955183,
0.7222625017,
0.5781694055,
0.9985646605,
-0.1776882708,
-0.2843159139,
0.0510551818,
0.316598326,
-0.4954203963,
0.4701518714,
0.1006631553,
-1.0025292635,
-0.6544129252,
-0.5456817746,
-0.6180090904,
0.28004843,
-0.6323198676,
0.2017930895,
-0.5040376782,
-0.5283273458,
-0.2468916625,
0.2311502993,
-0.4182370603,
0.2775926292,
0.414273262,
0.894762218,
-0.8405426741,
1.1337662935,
1.1471478939,
-0.1392790824,
-0.5212308764,
0.1191380471,
0.1227012947,
-0.8570092916,
0.5295937061,
0.0862721801,
-0.1034455597,
-0.1852698177,
-0.6759217381,
-1.1246341467,
1.0627282858,
0.1708651185,
-0.4480619133,
-0.2202950269,
-0.6464515924,
0.5201240778,
-0.414054513,
0.1895857751,
0.3745528758,
0.5232850909,
0.1850428134,
-0.8334346414,
0.0910453647,
-0.0951990187,
-0.1528646797,
0.1847713143,
-0.7843899131,
0.9170688987,
-0.8530837297,
-0.1126828343,
-0.0003071296,
0.8414813876,
0.2256637663,
0.2870015204,
0.2779960036,
0.319801718,
0.684081018,
-0.0645197555,
1.1871211529,
-0.3322633803,
0.1777360588,
0.9944972396,
-0.3343672454,
0.8015010357,
0.6256562471,
-0.5843400359,
0.5435215235,
0.9368951917,
0.0418911651,
0.6122633219,
0.1995230317,
-0.2539042234,
-0.4822927117,
0.2810232341,
-0.0584405847,
0.3404414654,
0.876909554,
-0.4881355464,
0.3358018994,
-0.000033987,
-0.143271178,
-0.1060103402,
-0.6279813647,
0.7930366397,
0.3616013527,
-0.7510315776,
0.5925357938,
-0.3552801609,
0.7917912602,
-0.5547091961,
0.2067105621,
0.0563397482,
0.3005941808,
-0.0910049453,
-0.7927238941,
0.12919949,
-0.3579817414,
-0.1819908321,
-0.2129947096,
0.8819772005,
-0.3294579685,
-0.4912651479,
0.4442314506,
0.859813273,
0.3769437075,
-0.0302457567,
-0.9874888062,
-0.0780341849,
0.1466215253,
-0.883892417,
0.114244163,
0.6258185506,
-0.3121992946,
1.242820859,
0.4645708203,
0.4884315729,
0.1518484056,
-0.1550821364,
0.7775989175,
-0.9071007371,
-0.3272131383,
-0.8088572621,
0.0500268564,
0.2267127037,
0.010146644,
0.7884737253,
0.1686437279,
0.3251079619,
-0.0395657606,
1.151035428,
0.2280682623,
0.6017056704,
-0.3879628778,
0.5980323553,
-0.5421199203,
0.4118336141,
-0.0796165615,
-0.9873241186,
-0.0556118563,
0.7596172094,
-0.6901048422,
0.220126614,
0.8478625417,
0.4369557798,
0.0896151364,
-0.0322047025,
0.4731185734,
0.5423534513,
0.0816719159,
0.3999733925,
0.9876263142,
-0.2008555382,
0.182705164,
-0.091295667,
-0.1054602638,
-0.2844184935,
-0.6271142364,
-1.0122280121,
-0.2496795356,
-0.3461139798,
-0.3550933599,
0.1714194119,
0.7110257149,
0.5192258358,
-0.8630791306,
-0.2496156096,
-0.3388205171,
0.4108686149,
-0.1918884218,
-0.219262585,
0.1196493432,
-0.269320339,
-0.6821821928,
0.3627883494,
0.1675407141,
0.5371168256,
-0.6134367585,
-0.0846484303,
-0.0924356356,
0.3707873225,
0.6645209789,
0.1792479157,
-1.3405510187,
-0.2105633318,
-0.2027854323,
-0.1942332089,
-0.2124579847,
0.7888262868,
-1.1084731817,
0.116978012,
0.0055437535,
-0.1100201905,
0.4028008282,
-0.1145650595,
1.0053483248,
-0.0425611399,
0.3935071826,
0.4940240979,
0.4606902003,
0.2266786695,
-0.2264047563,
0.5944597125,
0.3860321045,
-0.5412454605,
-0.9756702781,
0.4680545926,
-0.7411507964,
-0.5584470034,
1.482448101,
-0.213012889,
-0.5239223838,
-0.4005917907,
0.040120095,
0.1944878101,
-0.4962768555,
0.747977078,
0.6911501884,
-0.3188980818,
-0.1709156334,
-0.8383073807,
0.6200426817,
0.3688361049,
-0.3881214559,
0.2241542637,
0.3255657256,
0.2291686535,
-0.0224077422,
0.6218748093,
0.2170368731,
0.1103253514,
0.2267457992,
0.2107900381,
0.0316132605,
-0.0292620473,
-0.1270537972,
-0.0048165238,
0.3525934517,
0.2228944153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10181v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10181v1
|
The Impact of Familiarity on Naming Variation: A Study on Object Naming in Mandarin Chinese
| 2023-11-16T20:13:24 | 2023-11-16T20:13:24 |
Yunke He, Xixian Liao, Jialing Liang, Gemma Boleda
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Different speakers often produce different names for the same object or
entity (e.g., "woman" vs. "tourist" for a female tourist). The reasons behind
variation in naming are not well understood. We create a Language and Vision
dataset for Mandarin Chinese that provides an average of 20 names for 1319
naturalistic images, and investigate how familiarity with a given kind of
object relates to the degree of naming variation it triggers across subjects.
We propose that familiarity influences naming variation in two competing ways:
increasing familiarity can either expand vocabulary, leading to higher
variation, or promote convergence on conventional names, thereby reducing
variation. We find evidence for both factors being at play. Our study
illustrates how computational resources can be used to address research
questions in Cognitive Science.
|
[
-0.3881347775,
-0.4316191077,
0.3334462345,
0.1436116993,
-0.3433583975,
-0.2394484431,
-0.5063359737,
-1.0197092295,
-0.1407472044,
0.0666021705,
-0.2006291896,
-0.1653775573,
-0.6147715449,
0.1176523715,
-0.178828001,
0.4990781844,
-0.0248735324,
0.1407309771,
-0.0290230867,
-0.4815536439,
-0.6389000416,
-0.5319258571,
-0.9238422513,
-0.2826066613,
0.8522527814,
0.1714238226,
0.8892736435,
0.632052958,
0.8334303498,
0.2738924325,
-0.3243241608,
0.1246248856,
-0.2874272764,
-0.489440918,
-0.1359119415,
-0.5943208933,
0.3285918832,
-0.2046625912,
0.6208119392,
1.0382260084,
-0.0862597004,
-0.1707769036,
0.07463599,
0.6675490737,
-0.6403247118,
0.1128500924,
-0.7786747217,
0.3345467746,
-0.3845186234,
-0.12413425,
0.016770767,
0.0518902615,
0.7299574614,
-0.7408542037,
0.5786117911,
0.2672852278,
1.0814644098,
-0.055914294,
-0.1391741186,
0.0468963608,
-0.8094412088,
1.1148558855,
-0.605442524,
0.360480547,
0.2075131983,
0.4671487212,
-0.1424322128,
-0.3443615735,
-0.5375654697,
-0.4668758512,
-0.3738616705,
-0.2668913007,
0.1599259228,
-0.1185119003,
0.4145103693,
0.3917649388,
-0.4521757364,
-0.1588977724,
-0.5403966904,
0.025568828,
0.6832148433,
0.2691752911,
0.8460263014,
0.0109360665,
-0.53779006,
0.1348474473,
-0.873748064,
0.3221574426,
0.288523823,
0.6573290229,
0.0540056601,
0.2557333708,
-0.3597332835,
1.0034230947,
-0.1867564023,
0.0021576895,
0.4052907526,
-0.267737776,
-0.3060852587,
0.0144551313,
0.5440127254,
0.7602620125,
0.4374786615,
-0.2063827962,
0.0575345568,
-0.5328377485,
0.0849818587,
-0.513722837,
-0.5706211925,
-0.1813157499,
-0.6453287005,
-0.164975062,
0.6643546224,
-0.3201954067,
-0.6525112391,
-0.3544643521,
0.3221837282,
-0.4630678296,
-0.5529872775,
0.1968451142,
-0.5616653562,
0.5196402669,
0.7927250266,
-1.0444053411,
0.1421880126,
0.5358926058,
0.5230233073,
-0.6393389106,
-0.6536893845,
0.0381260104,
0.1205507368,
-0.677744627,
0.8043708801,
-0.5289068222,
-0.6781460047,
-0.2119260132,
0.0605321974,
0.0677015558,
-1.0223656893,
-0.3627032936,
-0.0692425296,
0.1142211258,
-0.5415069461,
-0.1924245805,
-0.3117851913,
0.2299984545,
-0.822132051,
0.9947798252,
0.1953003258,
-0.9870510101,
0.9705930352,
-0.0713750347,
-0.5689900517,
0.1925633252,
-0.75421983,
-0.2669981718,
0.295486629,
-0.3601445556,
-0.0025527806,
-0.2444030195,
0.0620112568,
0.0453438088,
-0.4019214213,
0.4962127805,
0.0662089735,
0.6983072162,
0.203610003,
-0.1471225917,
-0.1359316111,
-0.4686016142,
-0.3734113276,
0.0447185375,
-0.1693660915,
-0.710594058,
0.1753510088,
0.2731871307,
-0.3726570606,
0.4133579135,
-0.4019592106,
0.1434002519,
-0.1104255021,
0.2307860851,
0.5200742483,
0.1712881774,
0.3060938716,
-0.8674120307,
0.3004996181,
0.6281912923,
0.2000715882,
-0.1749296188,
-0.8155030608,
-0.6661241055,
0.1186956912,
0.3285948634,
0.1134120896,
-0.4935817719,
-0.3893523514,
-0.0225806963,
-0.3767165244,
-0.159108445,
-0.0265347045,
0.212225616,
0.2767655849,
0.3069269657,
-0.5483004451,
-0.7437574863,
-1.0259699821,
-0.715123117,
-0.2259801626,
-0.1341908723,
0.9449818134,
0.1368996352,
0.003223344,
0.9829535484,
-0.8316757679,
-0.4473755658,
-0.2334109694,
0.1085770801,
0.2176208049,
0.6652774215,
0.8422666192,
-1.2552500963,
-0.6144974828,
0.1856787205,
-0.2359101176,
0.7350463271,
-0.5259862542,
-0.219662264,
-0.0045944047,
0.4881198406,
-0.2980515659,
0.4899130464,
-0.145244509,
0.1115833521,
0.5511596203,
-0.1558759511,
-0.0612959042,
-1.124494791,
-0.0158297885,
-0.0071640601,
0.3215360045,
-0.6078471541,
0.152067259,
-0.214232862,
0.3370329142,
-0.9565914273,
0.6265073419,
-0.6293437481,
0.0725317374,
-0.0249687824,
-0.0551596731,
-0.2649921477,
0.3816944957,
0.6081438661,
0.402862817,
0.7464567423,
-0.8432604074,
0.3948436677,
-0.0238892175,
-0.4947569668,
0.448876977,
-0.5046447515,
-0.2253769487,
-0.2107962966,
-0.2324591279,
-1.1308598518,
-0.3732018769,
0.2791544497,
-0.4252080321,
0.2257801592,
0.1734697372,
0.032694377,
-0.2405135781,
-0.3872906864,
0.7751682401,
0.2445942611,
-0.689201057,
0.5461515188,
0.0377145112,
0.0957551897,
-0.6828430295,
-0.9534023404,
0.1728313416,
-0.5000524521,
-0.1801925153,
0.4092741907,
-0.4436872303,
-0.4646354914,
-0.1360898316,
-0.1566070169,
-0.4752902687,
0.1290717125,
0.1572125256,
0.1576083601,
-0.19408907,
0.3976691067,
-0.6599695683,
0.3201090097,
-0.1813094318,
0.0669293553,
0.346334368,
-0.0189499352,
0.0815299973,
-0.3056857586,
0.1085949242,
-0.0034760125,
-0.0593564063,
0.6381825209,
0.1590256989,
-0.5684862733,
-0.0229019877,
-0.156904161,
-0.0682021528,
-0.487529099,
0.4002704322,
-0.7384026647,
-0.4267272949,
0.689414382,
0.1683402508,
-0.1075904816,
0.4698498845,
0.3165963292,
-0.1607242674,
0.4904997945,
0.7687388659,
-0.2676918209,
0.7987815738,
0.1064033955,
0.0776914209,
-0.7694682479,
-0.3025322556,
-0.4033640921,
-0.4723744988,
-0.8751660585,
-0.454377383,
-0.3481797278,
-0.128233552,
-0.1557332128,
0.4553626776,
-0.5750259757,
0.8119434714,
0.5714444518,
0.3072716594,
0.5001729131,
-0.1491708308,
0.1309117973,
-0.0138655296,
-0.359529376,
-0.1403565258,
0.989996314,
-0.1471478939,
0.7274692655,
0.1592665166,
0.88998878,
0.1697365195,
0.1382109225,
-0.5689185262,
0.397649318,
-0.2830958366,
-0.4978601038,
-0.4430118203,
-0.4286714494,
-1.2785564661,
0.0838688836,
0.0319723189,
-0.8969787955,
0.3659461737,
-0.0374952517,
-0.5312396288,
0.1518732309,
-0.0989675224,
0.6619166136,
-0.3495094776,
0.0056521306,
0.0715239123,
-0.6157499552,
0.4433585703,
-0.098350428,
0.0361397155,
-0.0850828215,
0.1211516634,
0.6642958522,
-0.1369825155,
0.8057293892,
0.1478996724,
0.0844315961,
0.4702348411,
-0.0497453585,
-0.0188077521,
0.0519345924,
0.2629769742,
0.4371685088,
-0.0593862571,
-0.4075505733,
-0.5331712961,
0.5441134572,
-0.9642989039,
-0.6784996986,
-0.2691806257,
-0.7249941826,
0.2541377544,
0.3638266325,
0.5941388011,
0.0584770329,
-0.542119503,
0.2702799141,
0.631716907,
-0.6006368995,
0.1969429553,
0.5834616423,
-0.5296361446,
0.0345099606,
1.0182611942,
0.4905679226,
0.1606133729,
0.5837655067,
0.4111694098,
0.2059621513,
-0.3364747167,
-0.2934755087,
0.01905182,
-0.5000354052,
0.2107517123,
-0.2328163683,
-0.2807146311,
0.1209008768,
-0.1126952618,
-0.1277890503,
-0.510197401,
-0.2488278598,
0.1181833372,
0.3414265215,
0.8217403889,
0.3123274744,
0.4215045571,
-0.2604263723,
0.4036195874,
0.4958021939,
0.4192787707,
0.1476442367,
-0.3581233323,
-0.224515453,
-0.0097248321,
0.0813811868,
-0.7476078272,
-0.0423454084,
0.4103703499,
0.7710564137,
0.9434595108,
-0.0217149556,
0.5106451511,
-0.3419769108,
1.0555388927,
0.3846868277,
-0.6178132892,
0.1995158494,
-0.4918117821,
0.2599237263,
0.3850882053,
0.0745238811,
-0.9233276248,
-0.317671299,
-0.7868088484,
-0.8366625309,
0.6232454777,
0.0901651978,
0.2045259476,
0.0526233464,
0.2287535667,
0.1543657631,
0.373383671,
-0.6510797739,
-0.5041584969,
-0.094822377,
0.1061891019,
-0.3513222337,
0.016585106,
-0.3067727983,
-0.287653029,
0.1081079096,
0.1810280085,
0.3112852871,
0.0001017267,
0.0667227954,
-0.1608832926,
-0.1075631827,
0.7450289726,
0.360163182,
-0.1021495387,
0.2805783153,
0.4397777617,
-0.432601124,
-0.31038782,
-0.2971942425,
-0.170732215,
0.3120672107,
0.2505515814,
0.5841520429,
0.1614097655,
-0.6312891245,
0.1379732937,
-0.0541643277,
-0.1994967163,
-0.4751067162,
0.3828019798,
0.242475003,
-0.0742905289,
0.3175747395,
0.1811830699,
0.2825974524,
-0.7373048067,
0.0541578829,
0.3919739723,
-0.0749190748,
-0.060590867,
0.4939625263,
-0.1264284551,
-0.3862686455,
0.6748637557,
0.0548068359,
-0.5018717051,
1.3840209246,
0.2211811841,
0.6709522605,
-0.3543615043,
-0.0849150643,
0.5817832947,
0.2325707078,
-0.3062976599,
0.3746838868,
-0.1783569455,
-1.0183571577,
0.5668405294,
-0.3078685105,
-0.6685357094,
-0.0935188457,
-0.6786202192,
0.3916044235,
-0.6523705125,
-0.224320367,
-0.028380679,
-0.2329389304,
-0.8456920385,
0.3333711922,
0.4441784918,
0.5973479748,
-0.7055317163,
0.7814759612,
1.0590566397,
-0.6695891023,
-1.109112978,
0.069123745,
-0.199918583,
-0.4554207027,
0.9623467326,
0.5449254513,
-0.0578704476,
-0.4208529592,
-0.4271332026,
-1.0844858885,
1.0580644608,
-0.3391150832,
-0.6524523497,
0.2110843062,
0.6340185404,
0.7101831436,
-0.5119011402,
0.3004086018,
0.6084061861,
0.6984963417,
0.2294889539,
-0.8441125751,
-0.2404203862,
-0.1852829754,
0.4810566008,
-0.0243006758,
-1.0349873304,
1.3010742664,
-0.6056116223,
-0.3004509211,
0.313408643,
0.686211586,
0.2698993981,
0.5971797705,
0.531970799,
0.2271019518,
0.992313683,
-0.0451807827,
0.5495790839,
-0.3672058284,
0.5290684104,
1.3095258474,
-0.1843384653,
0.7402137518,
0.65735358,
-0.5103707314,
0.6003642678,
0.94114393,
-0.5272102356,
0.4915120006,
0.5832115412,
-0.0962207839,
-0.0047937902,
-0.2452583164,
-0.4827290475,
0.4782512188,
0.1417479813,
-0.4584608078,
-0.0232997965,
-0.0997236371,
-0.1334594637,
-0.3111291528,
-0.1753496975,
0.5488889813,
0.1540908813,
-0.4924145639,
0.4995438457,
-0.2739464939,
0.5415366292,
-0.4074721336,
0.1130763367,
-0.3451134264,
0.2047212422,
-0.4162276983,
-0.646545887,
0.1253918707,
-0.4408663511,
-0.3168917,
0.4325206876,
0.2455441207,
-0.515743196,
-0.3737098873,
0.1736277193,
0.3401558995,
0.380120337,
-0.0598527454,
-0.453105092,
-0.3076891601,
0.2368127406,
-0.3764431179,
0.453263402,
0.4797471166,
-0.3418432176,
0.5896214843,
0.3099611104,
-0.0661026239,
0.4294296205,
0.1292786598,
0.6349516511,
-0.6993412971,
-0.3015838861,
-0.8104640841,
0.1544124037,
0.0124619454,
-0.4517998099,
0.8590258956,
0.6370648146,
1.0107731819,
-0.5831384659,
0.7715595365,
-0.0046905731,
0.1282940656,
-0.1748504788,
0.5963007808,
-0.8163658977,
0.2691726983,
-0.3907556236,
-0.9751766324,
-0.5209049582,
0.5636379719,
-0.2626574337,
0.1384287626,
0.606085062,
0.6723227501,
-0.0232630298,
-0.1994765252,
0.5509755015,
-0.0299258363,
0.1567872167,
0.6319208145,
1.0098079443,
-0.1488817185,
0.4335497618,
-0.1863686144,
0.0973616913,
-0.3822139204,
-0.7704139352,
-0.7853118777,
-0.4902801514,
-0.3535640836,
0.1221249253,
0.1934107542,
0.7762522697,
0.6086555123,
-0.7778362036,
-0.4509331286,
-0.1716825813,
0.0390551761,
-0.5370926261,
-0.2690725625,
0.4423339069,
-0.4454616904,
-0.8634761572,
-0.0665704384,
-0.0649740621,
0.3208708763,
-0.0245876089,
-0.1060052514,
0.0985044986,
0.2677366138,
0.0811123997,
0.4925348759,
-0.8590780497,
-0.2522845268,
-0.1325106025,
-0.2803767323,
0.5083988309,
1.0167969465,
-0.7927958369,
0.7915304899,
0.6432641745,
0.244236365,
0.087270312,
0.0834368765,
0.5044783354,
-0.7122235894,
0.2997467518,
-0.2519974709,
0.5923601985,
0.5135239363,
-0.6503331661,
0.4984737337,
0.4600057304,
-0.2553840876,
-0.5378714204,
0.5506889224,
-1.0191204548,
-0.5975615382,
1.2152141333,
-0.1938417703,
-0.0050872974,
-0.1038207784,
-0.4787593782,
0.2112487704,
-0.3272032738,
1.1497820616,
0.9245640039,
-0.3282034695,
-0.2306838036,
-0.3135607541,
0.7630144358,
0.4318097234,
-0.3502461016,
0.0756588876,
0.151028797,
0.5366767049,
0.1786536425,
0.4520609081,
0.1728845984,
0.4683521986,
-0.0569512956,
0.3076641858,
0.213274911,
-0.4051320851,
-0.1131393686,
-0.1978944987,
0.4964955747,
-0.1997476816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10174v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10174v1
|
JWSign: A Highly Multilingual Corpus of Bible Translations for more Diversity in Sign Language Processing
| 2023-11-16T20:02:44 | 2023-11-16T20:02:44 |
Shester Gueuwou, Sophie Siake, Colin Leong, Mathias Müller
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Advancements in sign language processing have been hindered by a lack of
sufficient data, impeding progress in recognition, translation, and production
tasks. The absence of comprehensive sign language datasets across the world's
sign languages has widened the gap in this field, resulting in a few sign
languages being studied more than others, making this research area extremely
skewed mostly towards sign languages from high-income countries. In this work
we introduce a new large and highly multilingual dataset for sign language
translation: JWSign. The dataset consists of 2,530 hours of Bible translations
in 98 sign languages, featuring more than 1,500 individual signers. On this
dataset, we report neural machine translation experiments. Apart from bilingual
baseline systems, we also train multilingual systems, including some that take
into account the typological relatedness of signed or spoken languages. Our
experiments highlight that multilingual systems are superior to bilingual
baselines, and that in higher-resource scenarios, clustering language pairs
that are related improves translation quality.
|
[
-0.049480021,
-0.0021209188,
0.1943818331,
0.4368507564,
-0.28381446,
0.298409909,
-0.2829182148,
-0.6760364771,
0.2023821622,
0.269742161,
-0.4115981162,
-0.7100160122,
-1.0097204447,
0.2427518666,
-0.3471485674,
0.9758272171,
-0.0838014409,
0.2733898759,
0.0295845065,
-0.5561197996,
-0.100476563,
-0.1354103535,
-0.4785086215,
-0.2035032511,
0.5359672904,
0.1527734697,
1.0690032244,
0.3716548085,
0.5512580872,
0.41555655,
0.0088474229,
0.1453761607,
-0.1462199986,
0.2734098732,
0.0350195654,
-0.2363395095,
-0.3727969229,
-0.1341952533,
0.5588866472,
1.214736104,
0.4241358936,
0.4434809685,
-0.1553981304,
0.3716643751,
-0.4832201302,
0.2647118866,
-0.4379632175,
0.2671646178,
-0.4859448075,
0.0048596221,
-0.5086772442,
-0.3835358918,
-0.0278277136,
-0.7063093185,
0.3521402478,
0.1719208062,
0.4094282687,
0.0816294849,
-0.7637777328,
-0.1751839072,
-0.5673656464,
0.8271663785,
-0.6587834358,
0.7112289071,
0.1534538865,
-0.0356797129,
-0.199550733,
-0.3313898742,
-0.4121591747,
-0.1015943289,
-0.0127762649,
0.4100801647,
0.0699573904,
-0.0919854045,
0.3624098897,
0.1428520381,
-0.7553547025,
0.1457888931,
-0.3947024047,
-0.4559713304,
0.4400784671,
0.0772027671,
0.6722909212,
0.0096214134,
-0.2984653413,
-0.5291231275,
-0.4225913584,
0.0599655434,
0.4289330542,
0.5932358503,
-0.2934301794,
0.5364403129,
0.0625056624,
0.962633729,
-0.5828347206,
-0.3908575177,
0.4887515008,
-0.3725514114,
-0.1061601341,
-0.1458388269,
0.7905545235,
0.3976410627,
0.1950224191,
-0.2319588214,
-0.0827625692,
0.0239058528,
-0.1235848591,
-0.6320450306,
0.0968765095,
-0.0253161285,
-0.6674533486,
0.0601091273,
0.0723049417,
-0.307613492,
-0.5495280623,
-0.5376944542,
-0.0908570811,
-0.3556958437,
-0.5078403354,
0.2183107138,
-0.463360846,
0.0309475269,
0.3936778605,
-0.7994307876,
0.1009574905,
0.3306085765,
0.7332568765,
-0.4246679544,
-0.540581584,
-0.1715060323,
0.1161642224,
-0.3534241319,
0.3441360295,
-0.423735261,
-0.2206420153,
0.0203086939,
-0.0606881715,
-0.0751454681,
-0.310890168,
0.3156888187,
-0.6666065454,
0.1081607565,
-0.1607763767,
-0.2199589163,
0.1730012894,
0.0653191358,
-0.7944778204,
0.7293143272,
0.2070041895,
-0.2093566209,
0.60261482,
-0.5371320248,
-0.9785060287,
0.1050794423,
-0.1974924356,
-0.4134465754,
0.4688262045,
0.1257548183,
0.3215378821,
-0.1401142478,
0.1024744436,
-0.1724673063,
-0.1974089742,
0.4598495066,
-0.586499989,
1.0263781548,
0.3764734268,
-0.425717026,
-0.0331433117,
-0.7705572248,
0.1510328948,
0.0698777884,
-0.2710675895,
-0.5573165417,
-0.3624890447,
0.4512517452,
0.5123062134,
0.2993260622,
-0.8006541133,
0.0380083323,
-0.2112671286,
0.0048182374,
0.4119607806,
-0.5074181557,
0.3019432425,
0.1929348409,
0.4886237085,
0.2629365921,
0.2553496361,
-0.0459656045,
-0.8562784195,
-0.5714269876,
0.1997619271,
-0.0132019706,
0.3644728661,
-0.6667004228,
0.2937536538,
-0.3682476282,
-0.1845469475,
-0.5100538135,
0.1601131707,
0.823995471,
-0.0101901386,
0.5991126299,
-0.4651196301,
-0.2703800201,
-0.8055727482,
-0.266446352,
-0.1171390265,
0.0146151427,
-0.2402919829,
0.2874299288,
0.3082670271,
0.1789306849,
-0.1786560416,
-0.2794065475,
-0.145226106,
0.0380690247,
0.4631129503,
0.4600939155,
0.564153254,
-0.8540875912,
-0.6788713336,
0.4787001014,
-0.7004153132,
0.1139947623,
-0.6535823941,
-0.1700795442,
-0.2338948846,
0.7467129827,
-0.3246721029,
0.4070610404,
1.1013659239,
-0.6934319735,
0.3214025497,
-0.0964365527,
0.346121043,
-1.0899248123,
0.1310686916,
-0.1866258085,
-0.1695212275,
-0.4735706151,
0.0166628435,
0.3806145191,
-0.2576940954,
-0.440371573,
0.3567942381,
-0.9985484481,
-0.4219214022,
-0.3118404448,
0.1501029879,
0.0217189658,
0.412065804,
-0.181241557,
0.9854519367,
0.5068080425,
-0.4946395457,
0.4094075859,
0.8209307194,
-0.4486814439,
0.6839181185,
-0.3972250819,
-0.2116895914,
-0.1463937312,
-0.0290050022,
-1.1004295349,
-0.1710995436,
0.0078658098,
-0.5628616214,
0.5003533363,
0.0241676327,
-0.28869012,
-0.4783481658,
0.1489713341,
0.4777309,
0.1895258129,
-0.5596100688,
0.3665069342,
0.359051168,
-0.1707616895,
-0.7368248701,
-1.0813604593,
0.3597273827,
0.1946932524,
-0.5484307408,
0.3287519813,
0.05698511,
0.0126878675,
-0.2425902337,
-0.2082296759,
0.1153315455,
0.1157356426,
0.2990864813,
0.1241782084,
-0.3128198385,
0.1954409033,
0.2485609949,
-0.3009117544,
0.0162688289,
-0.4340652227,
0.3317076862,
0.0678747296,
-0.8913301229,
-0.5363339186,
0.5445924401,
0.8977280855,
-0.2806027532,
0.7887920141,
0.5313391089,
-0.1318137944,
0.0460334606,
-0.1643757671,
0.1903399378,
-0.4227774739,
0.4063625634,
-0.7249980569,
-0.8115988374,
0.5873927474,
-0.1665540189,
0.6135807037,
0.3833813965,
0.4572506547,
-0.0054184617,
1.0122846365,
0.1637852639,
-0.0006183665,
0.6539650559,
0.161367923,
0.0824805871,
-0.5320797563,
-0.0770106688,
-0.5921621919,
-0.7593609691,
-0.4158281088,
-0.3732456863,
0.3855230808,
-0.1612482369,
0.2187058479,
0.9350642562,
-0.4713069797,
0.5430629253,
0.5304883718,
-0.2180580795,
0.4775686264,
0.1464855373,
-0.3113802373,
-0.2606183589,
-0.3959624469,
-0.3599170446,
1.2355148792,
-0.0182899274,
0.3787338138,
0.503598094,
0.5730477571,
0.0777314305,
0.608761251,
-0.4312194884,
0.3183760643,
-0.2942011952,
-0.8008140922,
-0.4261958301,
-0.3722950518,
-1.2712038755,
0.5926772356,
-0.3382738531,
-0.2453299463,
0.0601939783,
0.0696812272,
-0.0155374464,
0.3452881575,
-0.8476408124,
0.8641708493,
-0.4354746044,
-0.2158595026,
-0.1168469563,
-0.7985685468,
0.2622793019,
-0.0069513139,
0.2533041835,
-0.0592001863,
0.1506744474,
0.6066797376,
-0.2221728116,
0.8661763668,
-0.1409867406,
-0.4741766751,
-0.0925428942,
-0.0087702032,
0.5283215642,
0.0139625296,
-0.2916862071,
-0.0300571024,
-0.0596458018,
-0.6557204127,
-0.3618694842,
0.6010522842,
-0.8904465437,
-0.0975101888,
-0.3921580613,
-0.6814107299,
-0.5022682548,
0.3583579063,
0.3453224599,
0.3749004304,
-0.3748875856,
0.0053287242,
0.3655060232,
-0.3738206923,
0.4690844715,
0.4014133811,
-0.2070041448,
-0.4094374776,
0.8603004217,
-0.1039857641,
0.4674181342,
0.3136731386,
-0.0399248861,
-0.2884898782,
-0.9550126791,
-0.8976283073,
0.1857070327,
-0.6993823647,
-0.1545000225,
-0.3617856205,
0.2110604197,
-0.6745716929,
0.0582515262,
-0.3483375013,
-0.5089657307,
0.0333853737,
-0.0543722846,
0.1300688386,
0.5762690306,
0.1323811263,
0.3925642371,
-0.8986508846,
0.5474775434,
-0.0444254838,
0.3551000357,
-0.1954306513,
-0.2781235576,
-0.33569929,
-0.1550222635,
-0.210144341,
-0.707010746,
0.0376846865,
0.1385394037,
0.5056321025,
0.3456903398,
0.0075776791,
0.8624759912,
-0.4193021357,
0.5307512879,
0.8567718863,
-0.7800150514,
0.0198836233,
-0.3045060635,
0.7094194889,
0.833869338,
0.2445201725,
-1.0789500475,
-0.7846499085,
-0.3704228103,
-0.8603341579,
0.4713166654,
0.4609075487,
0.3565968573,
0.1756134033,
-0.1732621789,
0.4876131415,
0.1949032694,
-0.800319314,
-0.3706798255,
-0.0846121237,
-0.4392029345,
0.0642036572,
0.5352894068,
-0.1991536915,
-0.3749076426,
0.4926868081,
-0.3063290119,
0.1172200888,
-0.0768848285,
-0.4780581594,
-0.077347897,
0.2550140619,
0.605145812,
0.7225206494,
0.4203036129,
0.2103725672,
0.114593029,
-0.7226489186,
0.1526864916,
0.1044678539,
-0.3560547829,
0.2476843297,
0.6408357024,
0.9289623499,
-0.0831055045,
-0.3295408487,
0.5302332044,
-0.0424017608,
-0.2329093516,
-0.3950347304,
-0.1844697595,
0.343577832,
0.1216595247,
0.0137933623,
0.6599255204,
0.0608426929,
-0.127948612,
-0.0580525585,
0.4044061899,
-0.4306269288,
-0.3384231627,
0.6153715849,
0.4907535017,
-0.0615767948,
0.5424242616,
-0.258908093,
-0.2619597316,
0.6334504485,
0.6833503842,
0.5272911787,
-0.1902852654,
0.2491354346,
0.5367636085,
0.3219830096,
0.044735264,
0.5511720181,
-0.2158193439,
-0.62378335,
-0.6319301724,
-0.5836189389,
-0.4765413404,
0.037423633,
-0.4954847395,
-0.1186083108,
-0.291118592,
-0.3999030888,
-0.1782267094,
-0.5053826571,
-0.9357764721,
0.1810150743,
0.4440608025,
0.5272356868,
-1.0723030567,
0.6269661188,
0.665874362,
-0.2032539994,
-0.2300823778,
-0.2507641017,
0.0118160341,
-0.7602328658,
0.5207719207,
0.2042450309,
-0.2632144988,
0.2136774659,
-0.2357542068,
-1.1858361959,
0.6723046899,
0.3953100145,
-0.6948782206,
0.1057557389,
0.5264992714,
0.6160918474,
0.0898536816,
0.2224341482,
0.4977137744,
0.8135828972,
-0.3121435046,
-0.7794276476,
0.0376010984,
-0.5581059456,
0.0570944175,
0.5683627725,
-0.4198359251,
0.3009336293,
-0.2718450427,
-0.4016599953,
0.2475117892,
0.9103095531,
0.2759674788,
0.2052880377,
0.4090946615,
0.3553268015,
0.8283038735,
-0.2451835722,
0.7917833328,
-0.3688499629,
0.0046543069,
0.959435463,
-0.16172342,
0.4838136137,
0.7367280722,
-0.5412352085,
0.1971782446,
0.1870176643,
-0.0150151616,
-0.0616039187,
0.4928475618,
-0.3835880458,
-0.4497592747,
-0.1234971061,
-0.3475149274,
0.3062723875,
0.3416652977,
-0.5582931042,
-0.0814965442,
0.3816514313,
-0.0445150025,
0.372448504,
0.1190009564,
0.4462221265,
0.1826241612,
-0.6843099594,
0.3349609375,
-0.1387759,
0.7768113017,
-0.7616456747,
0.2634052634,
-0.2333102375,
0.2100121677,
-0.2150136679,
-0.8717688918,
0.3253542781,
-0.256023258,
-0.0035363736,
-0.9257945418,
0.4200533926,
-0.4168592393,
-0.6176053882,
0.5001298189,
0.7830986977,
0.3647803664,
0.2170645148,
-0.7182699442,
-0.0063112332,
-0.0756881908,
-0.3189844191,
0.2430541366,
0.5650157928,
-0.3016381264,
0.1878980696,
0.9364180565,
0.2370563745,
0.4386452138,
0.7239024043,
0.5255565643,
-0.8817787766,
-0.5013068914,
-0.4264037907,
0.4250597358,
-0.3607536256,
-1.0563468933,
0.8274456859,
0.6755954027,
0.8519362211,
-0.4221711159,
0.982092917,
-0.1211203411,
0.1237685159,
-0.4380652308,
0.7013987303,
-0.5108839273,
-0.4107362926,
-0.4284562469,
-0.8801124096,
-0.8612046838,
0.2502473593,
-0.0257804878,
-0.1027271822,
0.70453614,
0.5283016562,
-0.3111500442,
0.0932151973,
0.5653315187,
-0.3062762618,
0.3482147753,
0.68161273,
0.6823329329,
-0.8104569912,
0.9458549619,
0.1057794988,
-0.096339263,
0.0213363208,
-0.5365604758,
-0.863516748,
-0.6668854356,
-0.3455165029,
-0.307592243,
-0.353965044,
0.7741386294,
0.5962952971,
-1.1376760006,
-0.3907199204,
-0.1271370202,
-0.0469395295,
-0.6652343869,
-0.081056945,
0.2820591033,
-0.4416007698,
-0.9084231257,
0.7336871028,
0.3105303943,
0.3286232948,
-0.1404751837,
-0.2437789738,
0.1358999014,
-0.5403584838,
0.6781804562,
0.3342016041,
-0.5820501447,
0.0136779416,
0.1418477446,
-0.4529486895,
0.0869193897,
1.0447981358,
-0.2758837342,
0.4608768821,
0.7453277111,
0.7778430581,
0.571079731,
-0.2883165181,
0.5143225193,
-0.8349735141,
0.2162751406,
0.0277395342,
0.433547467,
0.5088369846,
-0.0690466464,
0.2001980394,
0.3042507172,
-0.0821327269,
-0.0729099214,
0.6796069741,
-0.9785124063,
-0.3480909765,
0.8762503266,
-0.0638570487,
-0.1616539806,
-0.6467002034,
-0.0650404245,
0.5488559008,
-0.2902937829,
0.4056947827,
0.7717251182,
-0.0020392134,
0.1283016652,
-0.5425646305,
0.358740896,
0.7066445351,
-0.7756568193,
0.1426540315,
0.6074463129,
0.004464197,
0.6868802905,
0.5306079984,
-0.3187302649,
0.3498316407,
0.11586418,
0.3062202036,
-0.0791167915,
-0.2377548665,
-0.0152734565,
0.346023798,
0.1253584325,
-0.1979798973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10085v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10085v1
|
A Computationally Efficient Sparsified Online Newton Method
| 2023-11-16T18:44:22 | 2023-11-16T18:44:22 |
Fnu Devvrit, Sai Surya Duvvuri, Rohan Anil, Vineet Gupta, Cho-Jui Hsieh, Inderjit Dhillon
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, math.OC
|
Second-order methods hold significant promise for enhancing the convergence
of deep neural network training; however, their large memory and computational
demands have limited their practicality. Thus there is a need for scalable
second-order methods that can efficiently train large models. In this paper, we
introduce the Sparsified Online Newton (SONew) method, a memory-efficient
second-order algorithm that yields a sparsified yet effective preconditioner.
The algorithm emerges from a novel use of the LogDet matrix divergence measure;
we combine it with sparsity constraints to minimize regret in the online convex
optimization framework. Empirically, we test our method on large scale
benchmarks of up to 1B parameters. We achieve up to 30% faster convergence,
3.4% relative improvement in validation performance, and 80% relative
improvement in training loss, in comparison to memory efficient optimizers
including first order methods. Powering the method is a surprising fact --
imposing structured sparsity patterns, like tridiagonal and banded structure,
requires little to no overhead, making it as efficient and parallelizable as
first-order methods. In wall-clock time, tridiagonal SONew is only about 3%
slower per step than first-order methods but gives overall gains due to much
faster convergence. In contrast, one of the state-of-the-art (SOTA)
memory-intensive second-order methods, Shampoo, is unable to scale to large
benchmarks. Additionally, while Shampoo necessitates significant engineering
efforts to scale to large benchmarks, SONew offers a more straightforward
implementation, increasing its practical appeal. SONew code is available at:
https://github.com/devvrit/SONew
|
[
-0.6494161487,
-0.4245763123,
-0.109443903,
0.3868741691,
-0.5353931785,
0.263338834,
-0.183104977,
-0.2764745057,
0.3351262808,
0.324269861,
-0.4234723449,
-0.1194651648,
-0.6464465261,
-0.3122654259,
-0.2584400773,
0.9863859415,
-0.017541023,
0.2761388123,
0.2063539326,
-0.0918559358,
-0.1051903814,
-0.3461813927,
-0.9103658795,
-0.3206214607,
0.3534918427,
0.1122062504,
0.4322315156,
0.1942911595,
0.6461032033,
0.2456763983,
-0.3770796061,
0.6748400331,
-1.0579150915,
-0.0972089246,
0.1006071195,
-0.0538791902,
-0.4578650296,
-0.2967283428,
0.2731474638,
0.6508328915,
-0.4583172202,
0.2791946828,
0.0081577739,
0.8176763654,
-0.8875467777,
-0.3055289388,
-0.4672280848,
0.2901988924,
0.2688248456,
-0.3443129659,
-0.1136991009,
-0.4823586047,
0.3416600823,
-0.7437725067,
0.422440201,
-0.0641844049,
0.5948442817,
0.43851915,
0.1745173633,
0.0778893903,
-0.5911676288,
1.0893574953,
-0.7474195361,
0.464519769,
0.2809743583,
0.4378357828,
-0.2054557055,
-0.7179552913,
-0.1690759063,
-0.1745301932,
0.067228362,
0.1482860744,
0.4007295668,
0.2581938505,
0.2388750613,
0.3602933586,
-0.4484714568,
-0.1752445251,
-0.3416960239,
0.090016298,
0.5934060812,
-0.1253728569,
-0.2410086691,
0.1630417705,
-0.5755560994,
-0.0449634194,
-0.6548687816,
-0.0787083879,
0.0158408191,
0.2328850925,
0.0370522551,
0.1877165735,
0.1569787264,
0.3374338448,
0.1664635837,
-0.3388740122,
0.0006057459,
-0.0959536508,
-0.1455852687,
0.3546542525,
0.4457169473,
0.3007845879,
0.1292647868,
-0.0034974057,
-0.4029397964,
-0.3101941347,
0.4586050212,
-1.2893494368,
-0.0637870356,
-0.0738222077,
-0.3866491616,
-0.11464867,
0.0257840436,
-0.9829236269,
-0.6118689775,
-0.1921220869,
0.432035774,
0.0474430099,
-0.408183217,
-0.1306511313,
0.1589185596,
-0.1382839382,
0.5450316668,
-0.6739078164,
0.9717434645,
0.9881504774,
1.2208153009,
-0.0885459036,
-0.0373948179,
-0.433342129,
-0.3726634085,
-0.9764122963,
0.4354003668,
0.0254636295,
-0.3768828511,
-0.4209204018,
-0.4358952045,
0.090590097,
-0.9289098382,
-0.0916598365,
-0.6237851381,
-0.3035998642,
-0.1386598796,
-0.0695704669,
-0.3812951148,
0.1621794999,
-0.6088089943,
1.3463178873,
0.2626014352,
-0.4736633599,
0.2522545755,
-0.472523123,
-0.6015188694,
-0.3186763823,
-0.0752931237,
-0.6874678731,
0.2175554484,
0.0481041707,
0.6609345078,
-0.4473215044,
0.423208952,
-0.2998449802,
-0.8520825505,
0.0611835755,
-0.2389371246,
0.263934046,
0.1563294381,
-1.0219011307,
-0.3505581617,
-0.7455546856,
-0.0557090268,
0.1251994669,
-0.1482399255,
-0.2149038464,
-0.1738185138,
0.0164656993,
0.0417159535,
-0.1159421429,
-0.3340904713,
-0.2422292829,
-0.9182486534,
0.2410937995,
0.8365369439,
0.2339264899,
0.211908713,
-0.1725426912,
0.3615588844,
-0.1449588686,
0.2005920857,
0.3191186488,
-0.5105246902,
-0.7861022949,
-0.2897265851,
0.1146166921,
0.2477981746,
-0.3202471435,
-0.0224051308,
-0.0951216891,
-0.5213906765,
-0.1965074241,
0.2509049177,
0.8741222024,
0.176434949,
0.6699721217,
-0.3942410052,
-0.7150581479,
-0.6727541685,
-0.2054962665,
0.1059819981,
0.2667587698,
0.5525966883,
0.2802180648,
-0.2313272804,
0.5987246037,
-0.3743722737,
0.0316553041,
-0.074120149,
0.5562211275,
0.4661385417,
0.8405227661,
0.393345505,
-0.7076942325,
-0.4708677828,
0.1786222905,
-0.2811712325,
0.1687905788,
-0.2377687693,
-0.146175608,
0.1678367704,
0.131242618,
-0.321806848,
0.6945755482,
0.4316896498,
0.155478403,
0.2755267918,
-0.1291179806,
0.232260406,
-1.1633789539,
0.1772672385,
0.1265813857,
-0.4816112816,
-0.7532947063,
0.0094120251,
-0.3656443954,
-0.1403827518,
-0.4132564962,
0.4619562626,
-0.5673098564,
-0.4013820589,
-0.3090578616,
-0.1524434835,
0.0192353819,
0.6000347137,
-0.0682732835,
0.8408582211,
0.1003993005,
-0.9345660806,
0.055582393,
-0.1241320968,
-0.2460717112,
0.3707824349,
-0.7966855764,
0.1900041699,
-0.2156064361,
0.0972696245,
-0.908385396,
0.2946101427,
0.3206477463,
-0.3121881783,
0.7592594624,
-0.2245889157,
0.0288294554,
-0.1491925418,
-0.4401710927,
0.8353962302,
0.2343534231,
-0.8366847038,
0.6865026355,
0.3661371768,
-0.0138823139,
-1.1795027256,
-0.8369793296,
-0.2166473418,
-0.0104385111,
0.0301053934,
0.3738740981,
-0.1052810177,
-0.250323832,
-0.3357085884,
-0.4741635025,
-0.2626875341,
0.4628862143,
0.2646926939,
0.2899776101,
-0.3397361934,
-0.281003058,
0.1161192358,
-0.3333075345,
-0.254637301,
-0.4230408669,
0.5526467562,
-0.312497288,
-0.2065538168,
-0.5948728919,
0.4594429731,
0.4157793522,
0.2534602582,
0.6509823203,
0.8291487694,
-0.7416648865,
-0.5694060922,
-0.8618517518,
-0.3779319823,
-0.4592600167,
0.4194279313,
-0.3543685079,
-0.769020021,
0.2511952519,
-0.2270428985,
0.2885123491,
0.3494720161,
0.3846751451,
0.0509182625,
0.7881044745,
0.1679278761,
0.0299383365,
0.2539876699,
-0.6743372679,
0.4724080265,
-0.6900397539,
-0.2141361237,
-0.2043272257,
-0.5777408481,
-0.2343787253,
-0.5447550416,
0.3437419236,
0.3213097155,
-0.5921590328,
0.3898550868,
-0.689907372,
0.5970280766,
0.3409800828,
0.2201773375,
-0.0993550494,
0.1692724079,
-0.1034196019,
0.0712607503,
-0.6620676517,
0.1776738018,
0.7743588686,
0.2057969868,
0.9742023945,
-0.159994185,
0.7662810683,
0.2444285303,
0.3588080406,
-0.7271001935,
0.5735446215,
-0.1269268692,
-0.5662535429,
-0.0898185521,
-0.688549161,
-0.7283344269,
0.3577552438,
-0.1066805422,
-0.6582303643,
0.4721959829,
0.377173245,
-0.8273563385,
0.4053707421,
-0.6417249441,
0.4562526047,
-0.350563556,
-0.4997990727,
-0.5502574444,
-0.4868162274,
0.2241262943,
-0.0233721193,
0.123725839,
-0.1792632937,
-0.2674566805,
1.0519198179,
-0.9145655632,
0.7928498387,
-0.5362353325,
0.2264771461,
0.3461758792,
0.4830770791,
0.505145967,
0.3898127377,
0.2265203446,
0.1205083057,
-0.0172727089,
-0.3332032263,
-0.7356544137,
0.9082757831,
-0.9153133631,
-0.3716900349,
-0.4024171829,
-0.1399458349,
-0.2077198029,
0.2094475031,
0.0086909868,
0.9236077666,
0.0788828284,
-0.037819881,
0.8939704299,
-0.0083016912,
0.5440925956,
-0.1324768066,
-0.1315629482,
-1.0606181622,
1.0733789206,
0.3315224051,
0.2099429369,
0.3818201423,
0.4997279048,
-0.2756612003,
-0.5358844399,
-0.4285057485,
0.3272949457,
-0.7016786933,
-0.3531627655,
-0.5658442974,
-0.2295179218,
-0.407895714,
-0.5482526422,
-1.0836025476,
-0.7160933018,
-0.3332680464,
0.1776250005,
0.2671997845,
0.8643826842,
-0.1058819667,
0.2932966352,
-0.5215864778,
0.6197092533,
0.2745279074,
0.5588661432,
0.357881844,
-0.412635982,
-0.3297635019,
-0.1810473651,
0.0605772473,
-0.4515151381,
0.2365542203,
0.3671763539,
0.621064961,
0.9088181257,
-0.1246535033,
1.2473676205,
-0.2510719895,
0.4690257311,
0.3316613734,
-0.6217238903,
0.0777062178,
0.2396363765,
-0.2323548347,
0.8313112259,
0.5248541832,
-0.4910438359,
0.4594545364,
-0.5723056793,
-0.8611738682,
0.6178915501,
-0.10540732,
-0.0935769156,
0.2877133191,
0.4772779644,
0.3690958321,
0.429607749,
-0.3015757799,
-0.4081800878,
-0.4220473766,
0.0901474878,
-0.1953505427,
-0.4181519449,
-0.0591867082,
-0.3002838492,
1.2524554729,
-0.2907164395,
0.4399316013,
0.3660196364,
-0.1643190086,
-0.0121572353,
-0.0816581249,
0.7244010568,
0.6528962851,
-0.232928142,
0.2355702817,
0.4583423436,
-0.5882119536,
0.2378925681,
0.1503093243,
-0.245521903,
0.0174810924,
0.0008637827,
0.6983380914,
0.6162087917,
-0.5165379643,
0.6963163018,
-0.1343608052,
-0.2955931127,
-0.110852547,
-0.2869504392,
-0.2480316609,
0.2889854014,
0.3365912437,
0.5296320915,
0.319431603,
0.1087468192,
0.0645038262,
0.3600465059,
-0.3486491144,
-0.0028951564,
0.4139387608,
-0.2763184309,
-0.1853579879,
0.1378082335,
-0.1464668959,
-0.6056594253,
0.46462816,
0.5111425519,
1.0338279009,
-0.19972004,
0.2481780648,
0.7010269165,
0.2120632827,
-0.5020402074,
0.3268784583,
-0.3535519242,
-0.3680144548,
-0.3224476576,
-0.7030024529,
-0.3528619111,
-0.1727470309,
-0.4010831416,
-0.2408367693,
-1.3685517311,
-0.3728038073,
-0.4961220622,
0.190046683,
-0.243022114,
0.3476784527,
0.1282401085,
0.636998415,
-0.2965143919,
0.119801119,
0.3567370176,
0.399153471,
-0.7391701937,
-0.3077587485,
0.077342689,
-0.7326794863,
0.2558766305,
0.5026243329,
-0.6892639399,
0.0368687361,
-0.2769343257,
-1.0594816208,
0.9453839064,
0.3087160289,
-0.5118098855,
0.2256694287,
-0.0046521961,
0.2625202835,
-0.050122045,
0.7400366068,
0.4828436375,
0.2263312936,
0.2916803062,
-0.5116432309,
0.1232004613,
-0.5054799318,
0.6225754023,
0.1980299801,
-0.7868529558,
0.4558036327,
-0.3903772831,
-0.1374920458,
0.1329998076,
0.7298241258,
0.1765352935,
0.17144306,
0.6787841916,
0.827475071,
0.7560468316,
0.0840259269,
0.6081682444,
-0.2380456328,
0.5290201306,
0.8517889977,
-0.0112236347,
0.5622928739,
0.6162390709,
-0.2657100558,
0.4123053551,
0.8425686955,
0.1653166264,
0.5707922578,
0.457778722,
-0.2290919274,
-0.1063381582,
-0.2075715065,
-0.5700497627,
-0.325761646,
0.1269801259,
0.097673066,
-0.1702045053,
-0.0757333115,
0.012256274,
-0.228654325,
-0.6513953209,
0.7654947639,
0.407556504,
-0.6258949637,
1.1745265722,
-0.1282474548,
0.7517428994,
-0.4424443841,
0.0533333756,
-0.3209508359,
0.583333075,
-0.3271749318,
0.051987417,
0.0528357178,
-0.1498021632,
0.4225603938,
-0.0472686514,
0.7104806304,
-0.0112776067,
-0.5579383969,
0.2946498692,
0.1467160285,
0.1022266299,
0.1084280014,
-0.7874412537,
-0.2677060664,
-0.5835285783,
-0.7078179121,
0.136296168,
-0.2213105261,
0.1648499966,
0.6006469727,
0.5734568834,
0.1760816425,
0.4416292608,
0.1551566571,
0.8960286975,
-0.1544317901,
-0.5085952878,
-0.6743371487,
0.2087747455,
-0.0297830831,
-0.3596079648,
0.167089805,
0.7384678721,
0.855432272,
0.1228660643,
0.4177764058,
0.0547530875,
0.5693541765,
-0.3850805163,
0.5942600965,
-0.7954478264,
0.0333577283,
-0.3022823632,
-0.6288394332,
-0.7122682333,
0.7339336276,
-0.2102116942,
0.3348836303,
0.7782802582,
1.2036734819,
-0.2204214782,
0.1610662937,
0.1028451324,
0.0581953861,
-0.0572477318,
0.4075751305,
0.7281728387,
-0.4679658711,
0.205308795,
-0.7485769987,
-0.2387169003,
-0.2307283133,
-0.5540525317,
-1.2033789158,
-0.1461604685,
-0.0892775506,
-0.6844390631,
0.4242956042,
1.5816195011,
1.1098461151,
-1.1878540516,
-0.3058885634,
-0.3049083054,
-0.1795843542,
-0.6655750871,
-0.1232450753,
0.2989828289,
-0.2776631415,
-0.3689697385,
0.5450943708,
0.2530044317,
0.0609843582,
-0.3336693943,
-0.4734151065,
-0.2292739004,
-0.0042194105,
0.3437875807,
0.2900929749,
-0.475808084,
0.1929562986,
-0.1130665019,
0.067262359,
0.3514470458,
1.1000356674,
-0.4767076969,
0.3686810732,
0.5489723682,
1.3860744238,
0.9746572971,
0.2249869853,
0.2950113118,
-0.3058592975,
0.0177619308,
0.4628293514,
0.1638108194,
0.1761318445,
-0.5594623685,
0.4040909111,
0.6085469723,
-0.345284909,
-0.7238734365,
-0.1965505183,
-0.8789671063,
-0.2754289508,
0.8273309469,
-0.149057284,
-0.3927577436,
0.1396505684,
-0.0582252741,
0.3761034608,
-0.4159911871,
0.7798435092,
-0.0225484408,
0.1522492617,
-0.3045974672,
-0.3549749851,
0.6941782832,
0.7549814582,
-0.5548262,
-0.1465639621,
-0.0023729489,
-0.0375962853,
-0.0081932424,
0.7027337551,
0.0185047258,
0.5012449622,
-0.0055013075,
-0.1462383717,
-0.1817950457,
-0.9140511155,
-0.2748089135,
0.2257122695,
-0.1349764615,
0.1330186427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10785v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10785v1
|
Text Sanitization Beyond Specific Domains: Zero-Shot Redaction & Substitution with Large Language Models
| 2023-11-16T18:42:37 | 2023-11-16T18:42:37 |
Federico Albanese, Daniel Ciolek, Nicolas D'Ippolito
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In the context of information systems, text sanitization techniques are used
to identify and remove sensitive data to comply with security and regulatory
requirements. Even though many methods for privacy preservation have been
proposed, most of them are focused on the detection of entities from specific
domains (e.g., credit card numbers, social security numbers), lacking
generality and requiring customization for each desirable domain. Moreover,
removing words is, in general, a drastic measure, as it can degrade text
coherence and contextual information. Less severe measures include substituting
a word for a safe alternative, yet it can be challenging to automatically find
meaningful substitutions. We present a zero-shot text sanitization technique
that detects and substitutes potentially sensitive information using Large
Language Models. Our evaluation shows that our method excels at protecting
privacy while maintaining text coherence and contextual information, preserving
data utility for downstream tasks.
|
[
-0.1455330104,
-1.2350122929,
0.5743662715,
-0.2381158024,
-0.3685078323,
-0.0402295217,
-0.0497783571,
-0.722402215,
0.0602761321,
0.7449797988,
-0.1404822469,
-0.7134205103,
-0.3987585306,
-0.0268994272,
-0.5047901869,
1.2676728964,
-0.2198691666,
-0.36462605,
-0.1103824005,
-0.0049325149,
-0.3401674926,
-1.0183199644,
-0.4275316,
-0.2154227942,
0.4927400649,
0.4925127029,
0.4413831532,
0.6612530947,
0.614379704,
0.2388056666,
-0.1040816903,
-0.1117277667,
-0.4213882685,
0.5000011921,
-0.6019699574,
0.0223028529,
-0.5310143232,
-0.0709403083,
0.6336791515,
0.5941511393,
0.1039826423,
0.2143318802,
-0.2270884812,
0.3754719198,
-1.0606666803,
-0.0551401414,
-0.7865610719,
0.0766732916,
-0.1854665279,
-0.3643143475,
-0.5555563569,
-0.2463376373,
0.1292753667,
-0.5604847074,
0.4110939205,
-0.1701178253,
0.9899958968,
-0.0411210582,
-0.3412845731,
0.2079907805,
-1.048255682,
0.8490310907,
-0.3886981308,
0.2642449737,
0.7544297576,
-0.0180052519,
0.1872885078,
-0.5133311749,
-0.5640776157,
-0.0163728204,
-0.0045081829,
0.1292120665,
-0.4168551564,
0.1352438629,
0.2387939841,
0.1083375663,
-0.406563729,
-0.1271824837,
-0.3079087734,
-0.2517121732,
0.6701452732,
-0.0650437251,
0.4762797356,
0.0507395379,
-0.496704936,
0.007821355,
-0.7997188568,
-0.1543467641,
0.1930663586,
0.3672350347,
0.0663591772,
0.4638528824,
-0.4175023735,
0.4214968383,
-0.040846955,
-0.0835134685,
0.0690878183,
-0.2885822654,
-0.6965762377,
0.088721171,
0.5687074065,
0.1302718222,
0.1041708887,
-0.2133368552,
-0.0254491214,
0.2220311314,
0.3298282027,
-0.8828855753,
-0.1676974148,
0.3123792708,
-0.3750762939,
-0.2683872879,
0.0561961308,
-0.561584115,
-0.4847602248,
-0.193191126,
0.3200147748,
-0.4266654551,
-0.1692139506,
0.186326474,
-0.4162782729,
0.2155756205,
0.575599432,
-0.8403101563,
0.2366122156,
0.6799100637,
0.667547822,
-0.257722497,
-0.1971264184,
-0.3714599609,
0.7249487638,
-0.35221681,
0.5926883817,
-0.7901046872,
-0.6157767177,
0.0096245836,
-0.0431982502,
0.0137871765,
-0.3479459584,
0.4328950942,
-0.7918738127,
-0.0305325612,
-0.0564809963,
-0.6604071856,
-0.2799783945,
0.4412200451,
-0.5269439816,
0.5443354845,
-0.0554791726,
-0.5967583656,
0.1674692333,
-0.5095844865,
-0.6372743249,
0.215518117,
0.1089741215,
-0.8236916065,
0.078035526,
-0.3282649517,
0.4964103401,
0.18120417,
0.0178421326,
-0.5582640767,
-0.4980970323,
0.1633201987,
-0.5056273341,
0.6808213592,
0.123288691,
-0.277615428,
0.0272295848,
-0.6785573363,
-0.0061194431,
0.1802623272,
-0.0619193912,
-0.959356308,
-0.2293262184,
0.2798604071,
-0.2141158581,
0.4103438258,
-0.7348539829,
0.0357344747,
-0.2334790081,
0.3119944632,
0.4720808864,
0.4540587962,
0.7127708197,
-0.2562980056,
0.5636484027,
0.0215746444,
0.3860423267,
-0.4825319052,
-0.4386241138,
-0.3484995067,
-0.4779214859,
0.240274623,
0.7342191935,
-0.4182397127,
0.3574903905,
-0.0525115989,
-0.4348540306,
0.1849970669,
-0.1533861309,
0.4739881754,
0.4485177696,
0.3958019316,
-0.1780275404,
-0.4181930125,
-0.7647892237,
-0.4152191877,
-0.0344040468,
0.1087394953,
-0.08310996,
0.6150543094,
-0.4205619097,
0.9216778278,
-0.6144453287,
-0.4040919542,
0.081015341,
-0.0804894492,
-0.3353621364,
0.6944637299,
0.2591773272,
-1.1236228943,
-0.563833952,
0.2844459713,
-0.5563892722,
0.1438840181,
-0.0751593933,
-0.0627962202,
0.3903204799,
0.6760158539,
-0.4202429056,
0.8135696054,
0.4307681024,
-0.4189596772,
0.3094701767,
-0.39818874,
0.2869283259,
-0.8724751472,
0.3682203293,
0.0880264044,
-0.6061131358,
-1.3012468815,
0.5130599737,
0.4011321068,
-0.2593123615,
-0.6018034816,
0.8338555694,
-0.4382971525,
0.4052747786,
-0.2289366722,
0.045321174,
0.3109199405,
0.2912009358,
0.25011006,
0.6142411828,
0.1983321607,
-0.5217373371,
-0.1642921865,
0.317379564,
0.0683407187,
0.6489719152,
-0.557023406,
0.1342375875,
-0.1699995697,
0.2347440124,
-0.7527651787,
-0.3236416876,
0.5240545273,
-0.2248639762,
0.3044768572,
-0.2579884231,
-0.5036441088,
0.2695590258,
-0.6099489927,
0.5531317592,
0.3499493897,
-0.2887164056,
0.3148752749,
0.6881127357,
-0.2623508871,
-0.5871292949,
-0.8447056413,
0.3742363751,
-0.2211233377,
-0.1105602309,
0.6947256923,
-0.1249534488,
-0.2289450467,
-0.0460182279,
-0.0985705703,
-0.7234966755,
0.3262683749,
0.345636338,
0.6142674685,
0.2672092915,
0.2698474526,
0.2578635514,
-0.3249536753,
-0.4541835189,
-0.0719471052,
0.2742625177,
0.1236031055,
-0.4240191579,
-0.8769903779,
0.877923727,
0.4573059678,
-0.4385966361,
0.7617068291,
0.2155255973,
-0.7478058934,
-0.1107955202,
-0.3783830404,
-0.0302091818,
-0.4748160541,
0.1444001347,
-0.2087321132,
-1.0172675848,
0.5223344564,
0.1887289584,
0.0713035241,
0.2507024705,
0.2812403738,
0.1185780987,
0.691218555,
0.774902761,
0.1006671414,
0.8489182591,
0.0881367922,
0.7961354256,
-0.4777959883,
0.031566605,
-0.5143005848,
0.2534472048,
-0.5931999683,
-0.2825812101,
0.1447138786,
0.1008142754,
-0.2929819524,
0.5860434771,
-0.5186066031,
0.9610821009,
0.4348166585,
0.1822648197,
0.425927341,
-0.0051540071,
0.3657899201,
0.1676695645,
-0.2243633419,
-0.758859396,
0.8546981215,
0.2753889263,
0.654047966,
0.1239625067,
0.9687263966,
0.3673571944,
0.448084712,
-0.5976524353,
0.5809134245,
-0.4449318051,
-0.7418059111,
-0.4851205349,
-0.3649054766,
-0.938906312,
0.2230424434,
-0.12527363,
-0.9200300574,
0.1906101257,
0.2353521883,
-0.4703353643,
0.4161544144,
-0.88956815,
0.8123396039,
0.5029683709,
-0.5603914261,
-0.100329794,
-0.305192858,
0.2763182223,
-0.3181660175,
-0.0110656107,
-0.0313570872,
-0.272229284,
0.2518078387,
-0.2688603103,
1.0166186094,
-0.1180463806,
-0.313831687,
0.0130079929,
0.3910488784,
0.4129399955,
0.0015488857,
0.0148245329,
0.4068056643,
0.1777251959,
-0.3640355766,
-0.355712682,
0.7242738008,
-0.2164459974,
-0.5743284822,
-0.4606885612,
-0.3809349239,
-0.1279574186,
0.6578287482,
0.0759265199,
0.2051649988,
-0.4527177811,
0.3492643237,
0.9873902202,
-0.3527017832,
0.6369559765,
0.4258486629,
0.2840548754,
-0.3083208203,
0.8631622791,
0.168078959,
0.2686568499,
0.6258746386,
0.0890680179,
-0.4412654936,
-0.5433005691,
-0.3645035625,
0.0395999514,
-0.6457280517,
-0.4433112442,
-0.6859473586,
-0.2473767102,
-0.3892422318,
-0.5277974606,
-0.0756662935,
-0.4965423048,
-0.4001754224,
-0.0895145833,
0.310285151,
0.3834213018,
0.1353930831,
0.2015974671,
-0.9917760491,
0.4055224061,
0.1605344415,
0.6137680411,
-0.070121482,
-0.1321027875,
-0.1134084836,
-0.0671550483,
-0.1641264856,
-0.9537433386,
0.3560332954,
-0.0314448066,
0.3174432516,
0.3285227716,
0.3818772435,
0.5181066394,
-0.7838011384,
0.8677008152,
0.4413344562,
-1.3389395475,
0.4130734801,
-0.4515509009,
0.2737691104,
0.7046619654,
0.2249669582,
-0.8637290597,
-0.5772229433,
-0.6545778513,
-1.0262303352,
0.4332297146,
0.1277859509,
0.5014550686,
-0.0111302845,
0.3548784554,
0.156762898,
0.332370013,
-0.6941595674,
-0.1361782253,
0.1261167973,
-0.1613292992,
0.2895980775,
-0.3107748032,
-0.3178471327,
0.0835692734,
0.78640908,
0.1538251787,
0.1387680322,
0.3566759527,
-0.0538824424,
0.0203847401,
0.5409876704,
0.7969897985,
0.4295458198,
0.0216156766,
0.1279296726,
-0.0535682216,
-0.6050062776,
0.3288804889,
-0.1309055537,
-0.6593818069,
0.004906564,
0.0402258076,
0.2993468046,
0.1585432291,
-0.5805574656,
0.7689966559,
-0.0110592442,
-0.2327959239,
-0.4366700649,
0.2815814316,
-0.2250278145,
-0.1529511958,
0.2588001192,
0.1750047803,
0.1455065459,
-0.6588855982,
0.3107590973,
0.4167742133,
-0.4029118121,
-0.3127479255,
0.6571935415,
0.1280926466,
-0.3785668612,
0.0253427047,
-0.1631671488,
-0.2350716144,
0.4125974476,
0.5035744905,
1.1053901911,
-0.5219610929,
0.3759427965,
0.185964331,
0.0678777695,
-0.0632483065,
0.1603475213,
-0.1744358838,
-0.7315604687,
-0.1689952165,
-0.2259045094,
-0.6659709811,
0.2731176615,
-0.5126845241,
-0.0033450588,
-1.0472942591,
-0.2503072321,
0.3328104913,
-0.2565726042,
-0.2619207203,
0.3030108511,
0.0728032365,
0.7507020235,
-0.7451274991,
0.8288785815,
0.5588197708,
-0.3055098057,
-0.2504480779,
0.3795779347,
0.0786395967,
-0.1844786108,
0.2621928453,
0.1232957542,
-0.3104322851,
-0.4381240606,
-0.4468628466,
-0.6850011945,
0.6630260944,
0.3442303836,
-0.5270224214,
0.2748442292,
0.0683391467,
0.6905097365,
-0.0086804787,
-0.3193527162,
0.3271658421,
0.512845993,
-0.1384987831,
-0.6375592351,
0.2387087196,
-0.1958502084,
0.0531476997,
0.3249884844,
-0.4764637947,
0.7561502457,
-0.0323229469,
-0.6014078259,
0.1763628125,
0.1778277755,
0.0944462866,
0.5435268283,
0.2688445449,
0.3131673336,
0.794588387,
0.0952333063,
0.9545600414,
-0.1727350205,
0.4772603214,
1.1137257814,
-0.7311492562,
1.0986112356,
0.522164762,
0.2145729363,
0.385745436,
0.2694377601,
0.1176854745,
0.4235886335,
-0.0223857015,
-0.7433011532,
-0.0745031461,
-0.1705356985,
-0.114964731,
0.4924616516,
0.1792485267,
-0.3795926869,
-0.1101407036,
-0.0874127746,
0.3700657487,
0.2682299912,
-0.2517386079,
0.748418808,
-0.1907495111,
-0.5537729263,
0.4739471376,
0.4129865766,
0.3716878891,
-0.654050827,
-0.0786814094,
-0.0956353247,
0.3170079887,
-0.1814150959,
-0.6893393993,
0.6492664218,
0.2447975576,
-0.4143583179,
-0.6600390673,
0.965868175,
-0.6195153594,
-0.0808714107,
0.2620780766,
0.1044049039,
-0.1512406319,
-0.2587411404,
-0.5540495515,
-0.150153622,
-0.0211198758,
-0.0819001198,
0.5085169077,
0.1818494201,
-0.2103891969,
0.2064717412,
0.8578591347,
0.1297713816,
-0.3769325614,
0.2137966603,
0.5612785816,
-0.8108890653,
-0.788909018,
-1.0362385511,
0.3680958152,
-0.4820294082,
-0.169512406,
0.9041230083,
0.433288455,
0.8577492833,
-0.1515785754,
0.9732909203,
0.3421795666,
0.4941712916,
-0.2753996551,
0.985656023,
-0.347419709,
-0.0185434967,
-0.5783762336,
-0.7183635831,
-1.0155236721,
0.3922783434,
-0.2474966943,
-0.3123323321,
0.5313079953,
0.8147422075,
-0.1140667424,
0.0588795803,
0.7569053769,
-0.1148051396,
0.5092485547,
0.0563762411,
0.426974237,
-0.5090131164,
0.3231937289,
-0.0459530428,
-0.4543389976,
-0.2075570375,
-1.0280262232,
-0.6972128749,
-0.5548463464,
-0.5760210752,
-0.1525233984,
0.1180336997,
0.5723552704,
0.7682211399,
-1.0459519625,
0.1349513084,
0.0845394209,
0.2004030049,
-0.2093078345,
-0.2418700159,
0.2476805151,
0.0844763219,
-0.7221349478,
0.295968473,
0.769620657,
0.5675044656,
-0.086804539,
0.4177846909,
-0.0638543442,
0.5420943499,
0.6774594188,
0.5801443458,
-0.4836699963,
-0.7048299313,
-0.0574940071,
-0.1734722704,
-0.1473782808,
0.899454236,
-0.2683829069,
0.4249452949,
0.6352730989,
0.7328692675,
0.1918946058,
0.1714814454,
0.3428867757,
-0.8080778718,
0.1666328758,
0.1384337246,
0.2695750594,
0.435839802,
-0.5712461472,
0.1933736354,
0.2512392104,
-0.3837304711,
-0.9398827553,
0.4450972676,
-0.8203066587,
-0.6343384981,
1.0838032961,
-0.4596011043,
-0.3854825199,
-0.5373800993,
-0.129076764,
0.0580689758,
-0.3553429246,
0.8762796521,
0.4313001335,
0.1032454744,
-0.0186549034,
-0.1535097361,
0.4847925603,
0.2046959549,
-0.9235906005,
0.4953627586,
0.4518659711,
0.3853114545,
0.3835310638,
0.8941266537,
-0.3323022127,
0.3364102244,
-0.1966733336,
0.0249880403,
0.1573697478,
-0.3857480586,
-0.6044021249,
0.3113895655,
-0.5386468768,
-0.2780362964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10083v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10083v1
|
Characterizing Tradeoffs in Language Model Decoding with Informational Interpretations
| 2023-11-16T18:38:25 | 2023-11-16T18:38:25 |
Chung-Ching Chang, William W. Cohen, Yun-Hsuan Sung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We propose a theoretical framework for formulating language model decoder
algorithms with dynamic programming and information theory. With dynamic
programming, we lift the design of decoder algorithms from the logit space to
the action-state value function space, and show that the decoding algorithms
are consequences of optimizing the action-state value functions. Each component
in the action-state value function space has an information theoretical
interpretation. With the lifting and interpretation, it becomes evident what
the decoder algorithm is optimized for, and hence facilitating the arbitration
of the tradeoffs in sensibleness, diversity, and attribution.
|
[
0.0589840226,
-0.3982287347,
0.4970874488,
0.1161609069,
-0.2455246896,
0.0385087729,
-0.0212622657,
-0.4866248965,
0.2358532548,
0.4010792077,
-0.4624813497,
-0.0260340031,
-0.7232781649,
-0.222622022,
-0.4855464995,
0.8478835821,
-0.2782755196,
-0.2263614684,
0.3469181657,
0.0597214065,
-0.3152972162,
-0.5169264078,
-0.6902558208,
-0.0717268214,
0.2693699896,
0.0022392524,
1.0788556337,
0.8583548069,
0.487056613,
0.2191098183,
-0.1762754172,
-0.2963675559,
-0.7666327357,
-0.0373263583,
-0.0354265906,
-0.7454443574,
-0.2274454385,
-0.1476283818,
0.8432514071,
0.7752974033,
-0.3636285961,
-0.0418830812,
-0.3433589041,
0.5065659881,
-0.8446778059,
0.5381519198,
-0.5848978162,
0.2043600082,
-0.0604907796,
-0.6692661643,
-0.6306200027,
-0.4995955229,
-0.0213944372,
-0.4021883309,
-0.2212143242,
-0.2621784508,
0.9419007301,
0.2103034258,
-0.5943658352,
-0.599196732,
-1.0992628336,
0.9725654721,
-0.7562957406,
0.4127821922,
0.3755359054,
0.2942668796,
-0.1407938898,
-0.4235777855,
-0.5719163418,
0.1198735461,
-0.1664811224,
-0.0836248398,
-0.4070314765,
0.2209423929,
0.2977432013,
0.621329248,
-0.172252804,
-0.2503460348,
-0.3516741693,
0.0307401884,
0.6101151109,
0.3185053766,
0.4800668359,
0.0683795512,
-0.1390257627,
-0.4092806876,
-0.5815786123,
0.5165957212,
0.6094628572,
0.0743709058,
0.0331705473,
0.2427288592,
0.0070110075,
0.8111458421,
-0.3066267967,
0.0480328649,
-0.0264618639,
-0.5367255807,
-0.2143390775,
-0.0619965568,
0.2142692059,
0.2911327779,
0.2069841176,
-0.2597052455,
-0.3478040397,
0.2225935608,
0.2739706039,
-0.7145653367,
-0.2678580284,
-0.0027189825,
-0.9296569824,
-0.7831714749,
0.1429045349,
-0.731557548,
0.0307701603,
-0.2591653168,
0.161374405,
-0.2735071182,
-0.7711766362,
0.6529709101,
-0.2187530994,
0.3571663499,
0.0949435011,
-1.2149890661,
0.7245565057,
0.4270526171,
0.5572240949,
-0.0752013251,
-0.1278197765,
-0.5027463436,
0.3619279563,
-0.4017421901,
0.5855891109,
-1.0125943422,
-0.2618744373,
0.1282922775,
-0.4025850296,
-0.2756808698,
-0.2284522802,
0.5768693686,
-0.9316857457,
-0.2864678502,
-0.3149426281,
-0.6281121969,
-0.2427159399,
-0.1271000057,
-1.0798547268,
0.4282709062,
0.1926554143,
-0.7074666023,
0.2771593034,
-0.8061083555,
-0.5597905517,
-0.0490766615,
-0.1241601035,
0.1567564905,
0.4528378546,
-0.2455656677,
0.0308538415,
-0.0713912323,
0.2142334282,
-0.0659714714,
-0.5412959456,
0.5839946866,
-0.6135107875,
0.8312519193,
0.6716483235,
-0.285151571,
-0.0828243047,
-0.7461715937,
0.2375615984,
0.3004369438,
-1.0563606024,
-0.2439554185,
0.5301811695,
-0.0658319443,
-0.0703483224,
0.0423412882,
-0.2008438706,
0.1763238758,
-0.4585120678,
0.4556062818,
0.7275292277,
-0.2659615874,
0.4884935319,
0.118876636,
0.8937321901,
-0.0743290856,
0.0331558473,
-0.2234147787,
-0.0008558743,
-0.625854373,
-0.1567989886,
0.3356453776,
0.5986273885,
-0.6578493118,
0.328022331,
-0.2664343715,
0.1477411091,
-0.5895701647,
-0.2424210012,
0.3536022902,
-0.0136511764,
-0.0488323756,
0.0121638831,
-0.4739580154,
-1.0077286959,
-0.7524465322,
-0.2216891199,
0.3642217815,
-0.1566570848,
0.1117807627,
-0.0865549445,
0.5862174034,
-0.5760765076,
0.3030624986,
-0.4197266698,
0.0174037926,
0.610466361,
0.4248265326,
0.5579587221,
-1.0572118759,
-0.2210936546,
-0.1957420111,
-0.5549921393,
0.1360285133,
-0.1026376337,
-0.1502582133,
-0.0113484124,
0.4098315537,
-0.6186122894,
0.7411056757,
0.7360605597,
-0.5394972563,
0.4995677769,
-0.0929171219,
0.3702711165,
-0.8169361353,
0.1592391431,
-0.6390944719,
-0.21735695,
-0.9580059052,
0.4878233671,
-0.1901359111,
-0.0811038092,
-0.0789834037,
0.5754361749,
-0.5691463947,
-0.1005823165,
-0.4310802817,
-0.1204481944,
-0.0484842733,
0.3239089251,
0.1633572429,
0.4151773453,
0.4191777706,
-0.5872991085,
0.3490334153,
-0.0310260206,
-0.5937584043,
0.1508316398,
-0.4311655462,
-0.0975852758,
-0.1013180912,
0.0266211461,
-0.9512859583,
-0.0333872624,
0.2794883251,
-0.2319030762,
0.2777335048,
-0.3060477972,
-0.4788039923,
-0.1598295122,
-0.2942737043,
0.9899929166,
0.3594432771,
-0.505695045,
0.3395110369,
0.6239110231,
0.0612749085,
-0.775821209,
-0.7293992639,
0.011210613,
-0.0551538691,
-0.4798467755,
0.0966527462,
-0.0995599255,
-0.4696634412,
0.2701811492,
-0.2147714943,
-0.0839664713,
0.123966895,
-0.2394769043,
0.0366599746,
0.0151394084,
-0.0286437683,
0.2207341939,
-0.3920523226,
0.0808531567,
-0.2881464064,
0.4717260599,
-0.4115301371,
-0.5236347318,
-0.0641555786,
0.5509353876,
0.2016367912,
-0.1785600036,
0.8687574863,
0.1782514602,
-0.392629087,
-0.0006756627,
-0.0002198928,
-0.1321060807,
-0.4905946255,
0.3614250422,
-0.8285732865,
-0.6482297182,
0.5447595716,
-0.0059972545,
0.0790982842,
0.1423269659,
0.5796093941,
0.2598206103,
1.3330239058,
0.6502474546,
0.1660559624,
0.7684841752,
-0.2470928729,
0.8353620768,
-0.3439276218,
0.0292220321,
-0.2727065682,
-0.3924488425,
-0.3805314302,
-0.2270662934,
0.1276086718,
0.3156310916,
0.0020206666,
0.251775831,
-0.3887711465,
0.6838901639,
0.5933328867,
-0.2645311356,
0.332950294,
0.1658661366,
0.0332789272,
-0.241045773,
-0.8947687745,
-0.5135828853,
0.8794884086,
0.447350502,
1.0187730789,
0.5488393307,
0.3248674273,
0.3247393668,
-0.2559717298,
-0.8040537238,
0.3922705054,
-0.0740442425,
-0.5823953748,
-0.2106392682,
-0.5381789804,
-1.1992520094,
0.2976231277,
-0.1226241887,
-0.9268652797,
0.5014615059,
0.4604480267,
0.0859856978,
0.5526542068,
-0.6640155315,
0.8781205416,
-0.0808392391,
0.0413844213,
-0.4824921489,
-0.510165453,
0.4954576492,
0.1693474054,
0.3560947478,
0.1518724114,
0.2812445462,
0.7174495459,
-0.1316901147,
0.5900123119,
-0.1905232072,
-0.1988438964,
0.0198658593,
0.7485204935,
0.67447716,
-0.2007473111,
-0.4756884873,
-0.0187097434,
0.7630394697,
-0.6666727066,
-0.6990539432,
0.2879590988,
-0.5157518387,
-0.3638486266,
-0.3247804642,
-0.6248438954,
0.055518765,
0.2675588727,
0.2327596694,
0.5537799597,
-0.0864559114,
0.0350735635,
0.5735320449,
-0.245897457,
0.2155192494,
0.4113054872,
-0.1381238103,
0.0939145014,
0.9192652106,
-0.3233488798,
0.4964834452,
0.6880893707,
0.0615407154,
-0.189408958,
-0.6309177876,
-0.1126588061,
0.1718222797,
-1.220908761,
0.1367228478,
-0.1683178097,
-0.2158871442,
-0.1116958112,
-0.0855605453,
-0.3194009066,
-0.3349800706,
-0.0288475771,
-0.2826602459,
-0.0594207533,
0.8133401275,
-0.1237242892,
0.4079868495,
-0.7272892594,
0.0969480574,
-0.0206611399,
0.4410788417,
0.0274859611,
-0.4092492759,
-0.7041407228,
0.1901438683,
0.1588850319,
-1.0088229179,
0.2840704322,
-0.0996853337,
0.7986710668,
0.6042618752,
0.1567096114,
0.4019856453,
-0.3491241634,
0.4538051188,
0.0718687773,
-1.2871706486,
0.5389837027,
-0.239527002,
0.2600723803,
0.4225093126,
0.0548042767,
-0.7207366228,
-0.2096520364,
-0.6519448161,
-0.7547947168,
1.0918688774,
0.3249203563,
0.3797609508,
0.0647121221,
0.4022619724,
0.1448733509,
0.3732492626,
-0.9594955444,
-0.0476977713,
-0.0996815488,
-0.4508274794,
0.2620498538,
-0.488841027,
-0.4064416289,
0.0553676002,
0.3019946218,
-0.122422345,
0.8781955838,
-0.4877664447,
-0.1765135378,
-0.3124682009,
0.301951021,
0.6628795266,
0.9794530272,
-0.121682778,
0.5911837816,
-0.3084863722,
-0.0943006948,
0.0742302611,
-0.1353881508,
-0.2415821254,
-0.111678645,
0.7170971036,
1.4567809105,
0.1518373638,
-0.7929341197,
0.5528103113,
-0.2428282052,
0.0681697428,
-0.0374213196,
0.253281951,
-0.121457085,
0.3757748604,
0.1351281404,
0.1086846963,
0.5183551908,
-0.6236723065,
0.0832290053,
0.4703386724,
0.0678380057,
-0.740680635,
0.5279015303,
-0.0362465344,
-0.3413078189,
0.4410731494,
0.0701448545,
-0.488557905,
0.5704859495,
0.6322674751,
0.6476317644,
-0.2231250554,
0.201171875,
0.0702808052,
0.2328473777,
-0.0042950138,
0.4422098696,
-0.183212027,
-1.0009562969,
-0.3677224815,
-0.6270361543,
-0.3158829808,
0.0886584222,
-0.9505871534,
0.1392445862,
-0.2268369496,
0.0374218635,
-0.0992808565,
-0.3976456225,
-0.5788104534,
0.0935452059,
0.0671968162,
0.7774657607,
-0.58898139,
0.8078203797,
0.6375976205,
-0.2909095585,
-0.958224535,
0.2892328203,
-0.2045113444,
-0.9917809367,
0.9954510927,
-0.2485169172,
-0.5621128082,
-0.1022435725,
-0.356982708,
-1.1833512783,
0.6162801385,
0.8485543132,
-0.3492583036,
-0.2376737148,
-0.0484210774,
0.4045176208,
-0.3688524663,
0.0669220239,
0.7572721243,
0.5230460167,
0.0375561193,
-0.761105597,
0.256444633,
-0.6263741255,
0.1469778866,
0.4099210501,
-0.2449471802,
0.7237771153,
0.0036731767,
-0.4990516901,
-0.2004364133,
0.1267695874,
-0.2058634311,
-0.2386202663,
0.680644691,
0.1756152809,
0.4064462483,
0.1272625625,
1.4617074728,
-0.4855512679,
0.5240606666,
0.582218945,
0.215871945,
0.752591908,
0.530520916,
-0.5488610268,
0.3697464168,
0.7193148136,
0.3095419407,
0.9131916165,
0.2783121169,
-0.2804605365,
-0.2347359061,
0.3256658912,
-0.0527304262,
0.35396716,
0.3847336769,
-0.3818002641,
-0.3134195805,
-0.1987388432,
0.1780261099,
-0.1583235413,
0.1040699556,
0.5557842255,
-0.0494494699,
-0.6088430285,
0.8415107131,
0.3370440006,
0.2095836699,
-0.6650121808,
-0.1276442111,
-0.0858803168,
0.354760766,
-0.0698839575,
-0.8381304741,
0.6271559,
-0.4265723228,
-0.2326358259,
-0.3610998094,
0.7625009418,
-0.6460503936,
-0.270049572,
0.535351634,
0.1182434112,
0.410259366,
0.351760596,
-0.6885216832,
0.5853689313,
0.186637193,
-0.3705121577,
0.0493499227,
0.1169120967,
0.1085659936,
0.516486764,
0.4190014303,
0.4399312437,
0.109994933,
-0.117884621,
0.7970116138,
-0.7631099224,
-0.873744905,
-0.8714725375,
0.3802007735,
0.2195416689,
0.1675760001,
0.1468223035,
0.2574074864,
0.8120882511,
-0.1371127069,
0.9037693143,
-0.1302653253,
0.2247019708,
-0.9664615393,
0.3108716905,
-0.5646824837,
0.5427938104,
-0.1669154167,
-0.9160087109,
-0.1626754552,
0.9976477027,
-0.3119282722,
0.0969175622,
0.6554080844,
0.5309472084,
-0.2268898338,
0.0668197498,
0.3339369595,
0.0159136895,
0.5812710524,
0.7218128443,
0.745195806,
-0.4742303491,
0.5843824148,
0.1952776909,
-0.5030846,
-0.4489867985,
-0.857627809,
-0.5212606192,
-0.6731728911,
-0.0440364704,
-0.3855488002,
-0.0477387458,
0.6295495629,
0.8047599196,
-0.7316272855,
-0.674691081,
0.0207844935,
0.3550621271,
-0.33081159,
-0.272205323,
0.3075788319,
-0.2665028274,
-0.8856136799,
0.4748244286,
0.33818385,
-0.1482665539,
-0.0936489329,
-0.4849698842,
-0.1482414603,
0.4299418628,
0.7098514438,
0.3634974062,
-0.672600925,
-0.2831959724,
-0.1366867721,
0.1386268139,
0.1375501454,
1.3698221445,
-0.2257517874,
0.6266931891,
0.5876070857,
0.7885571122,
0.6675033569,
-0.1034606248,
1.0113377571,
-0.3702798784,
0.3467774689,
0.0215497371,
0.1501453519,
-0.0165230259,
-0.4432186782,
0.4897072315,
0.2266857624,
-0.1935887784,
-1.1253147125,
0.8645499349,
-0.7043681741,
-0.4555559158,
1.0249899626,
-0.3888478279,
-0.0732680485,
0.1176092997,
0.0388285555,
0.1895108968,
-0.2218259573,
0.6929126978,
1.0467483997,
-0.3745457828,
-0.4586457908,
-0.4277458787,
0.6862307787,
0.4769433141,
-0.8414833546,
0.1425691396,
0.3903741241,
0.1444631666,
0.0364099666,
0.8350461125,
-0.0686764345,
0.1914916337,
0.231882453,
0.0148286782,
0.1497479081,
-0.1219503433,
-0.5213111043,
-0.1919722557,
0.4058534503,
-0.1974666119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10081v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10081v2
|
DRESS: Instructing Large Vision-Language Models to Align and Interact with Humans via Natural Language Feedback
| 2023-11-16T18:37:29 | 2024-03-19T17:51:45 |
Yangyi Chen, Karan Sikka, Michael Cogswell, Heng Ji, Ajay Divakaran
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present DRESS, a large vision language model (LVLM) that innovatively
exploits Natural Language feedback (NLF) from Large Language Models to enhance
its alignment and interactions by addressing two key limitations in the
state-of-the-art LVLMs. First, prior LVLMs generally rely only on the
instruction finetuning stage to enhance alignment with human preferences.
Without incorporating extra feedback, they are still prone to generate
unhelpful, hallucinated, or harmful responses. Second, while the visual
instruction tuning data is generally structured in a multi-turn dialogue
format, the connections and dependencies among consecutive conversational turns
are weak. This reduces the capacity for effective multi-turn interactions. To
tackle these, we propose a novel categorization of the NLF into two key types:
critique and refinement. The critique NLF identifies the strengths and
weaknesses of the responses and is used to align the LVLMs with human
preferences. The refinement NLF offers concrete suggestions for improvement and
is adopted to improve the interaction ability of the LVLMs-- which focuses on
LVLMs' ability to refine responses by incorporating feedback in multi-turn
interactions. To address the non-differentiable nature of NLF, we generalize
conditional reinforcement learning for training. Our experimental results
demonstrate that DRESS can generate more helpful (9.76%), honest (11.52%), and
harmless (21.03%) responses, and more effectively learn from feedback during
multi-turn interactions compared to SOTA LVMLs.
|
[
-0.1511162519,
-0.825586915,
0.3409959674,
0.2487218082,
-0.1820803136,
0.1142262518,
-0.4350941777,
-0.4841430187,
0.3458843827,
0.7319496274,
-0.8229694963,
-0.2914046943,
-0.1391396374,
-0.0704805329,
-0.3762763739,
0.9815454483,
0.1228394583,
0.3288653493,
-0.3199851811,
-0.1252518743,
-0.48646456,
-0.6415820122,
-0.7447093725,
-0.2746862769,
0.6200599074,
0.3245505691,
0.7909392715,
0.3017166555,
0.6117947698,
0.3954611421,
0.075992614,
0.4942457378,
-0.4844360054,
0.0804736316,
-0.364972502,
-0.3415272832,
-0.5496404171,
-0.0219168272,
0.5923107862,
0.4573601186,
-0.6537060142,
0.2295428813,
0.2440900207,
1.0035926104,
-0.8439205289,
0.1041692495,
-0.3520912528,
0.0686257705,
-0.1910646856,
-0.1499541253,
-0.6892792583,
-0.1199879721,
0.223177135,
-0.6379117966,
-0.0244453792,
0.3849868774,
0.8428215384,
0.4367521405,
-0.2633677125,
-0.0541920885,
-0.8185443282,
0.9072045684,
-0.8359234929,
0.5091971755,
0.2984009981,
0.3980278969,
-0.1665158868,
-0.5426072478,
-0.7168234587,
-0.4930476844,
-0.202952534,
0.1359637976,
0.2991841733,
0.0800369754,
0.1804737449,
0.1482859105,
-0.3637042046,
0.0872765183,
-0.2560444176,
-0.0840388834,
0.8046973348,
0.3220553696,
0.1981820166,
-0.1110201329,
-0.4878211319,
-0.1686740965,
-0.4662800133,
0.3664306402,
0.2452508509,
0.3431067169,
-0.1972096413,
0.534773469,
-0.1873629838,
1.2167056799,
0.0999610275,
-0.2429154366,
0.1110928804,
-0.1929390281,
-0.4204637706,
-0.1349869817,
0.7154204845,
0.9194957614,
0.2003078014,
-0.1880613863,
-0.208397761,
0.1304435283,
0.5980787277,
-0.537170887,
-0.0724904016,
-0.1275915354,
-0.246786207,
-0.4227971733,
0.2600332797,
-1.0765805244,
-0.6756660342,
-0.9695657492,
0.4658324718,
-0.1482049376,
-0.1577967554,
0.1539168954,
0.1253175735,
0.8511350751,
0.7174215913,
-0.9530935884,
0.4342175722,
0.6311516166,
0.5365242958,
-0.3159521818,
-0.3283621073,
-0.830683887,
0.0218147244,
-0.6290509105,
0.5524491072,
-0.6632419825,
0.0293815527,
0.0977143571,
0.2143620849,
0.0342933871,
-0.3828747272,
0.3982487023,
-0.2546073198,
0.4402447939,
-0.2901171744,
-0.2747568786,
0.15558061,
0.278796494,
-0.5553523302,
0.7320044637,
0.0033707453,
-0.7375736237,
0.4397079945,
-0.5109199882,
-0.4328135252,
0.0045995149,
-0.1969464123,
-0.5483217239,
-0.0115249148,
0.2818441689,
0.3116905689,
-0.0680956841,
0.1109870523,
-0.4816660881,
-0.3828004897,
0.2274874151,
-0.0372853987,
0.137184456,
-0.1713694483,
-0.3353174329,
0.6608752608,
-1.0578643084,
0.1743036956,
0.1310888529,
-0.2924818099,
-0.2814377844,
0.1547804922,
0.1794780642,
0.0082060033,
-0.0652864128,
-0.326041609,
0.3938709497,
-0.5412724018,
0.4750709534,
0.9276376963,
-0.1531386375,
0.8201941848,
-0.3656416237,
0.4882784486,
-0.4004082382,
0.3492764831,
-0.022562895,
-0.2694850862,
-1.1948760748,
-0.0410129428,
0.0935543552,
0.3636383712,
-1.1264491081,
-0.2112728357,
0.0267533045,
-0.1198635772,
-0.6747534275,
0.0575353317,
0.713948369,
0.4516835809,
0.4728262126,
-0.3192355931,
-0.900164783,
-0.7521067858,
-0.2746030092,
0.0577906221,
0.0534507856,
0.0669265091,
0.2771857977,
-0.0359438732,
1.0560026169,
-0.3627543449,
-0.3573868275,
-0.2471942455,
-0.0741953179,
-0.0244842302,
0.3794187605,
0.3716594875,
-0.8097295761,
-0.3620265424,
-0.0856917873,
-0.3446968198,
0.1997930408,
-0.1181012541,
-0.218289271,
0.4347626865,
0.4709258974,
-0.12767452,
0.5859835148,
0.6153514981,
-0.4008474946,
0.4568050206,
-0.1774242818,
0.1011354849,
-0.921426475,
-0.2187699378,
0.1088802665,
-0.319795996,
-0.6380596757,
0.0051214881,
-0.0077736466,
0.0379983783,
-0.4548423588,
0.6985858679,
-0.4421958029,
0.0870362967,
-0.2155812085,
0.0839457065,
0.2718347907,
0.7659919858,
0.350666374,
0.4272522032,
0.1591055691,
-0.7030819058,
0.4880901277,
0.3712599576,
-0.3339413404,
0.9522998929,
-0.5877249241,
0.3881899714,
-0.2140164971,
0.1757306457,
-0.5860193968,
-0.510609746,
0.3042773902,
-0.3653518558,
0.5245503187,
-0.2661929131,
-0.1297841668,
-0.2783694565,
-0.4183864892,
-0.1846850812,
0.354560554,
-0.6496177316,
0.5808492303,
0.3825134337,
0.196533516,
-0.6802912951,
-0.6655792594,
0.0479713492,
0.014535265,
-0.6838572025,
0.1745676398,
-0.2648635209,
-0.3259187341,
-0.2614134848,
-0.1893801987,
0.0511309765,
-0.1398606151,
0.1729528457,
0.6726614237,
-0.0924930647,
0.1273010373,
-0.6016926169,
0.1048878729,
-0.1840910316,
-0.3425712883,
0.5275588036,
-0.4417132139,
-0.5048084259,
-0.354106009,
0.2419237494,
0.6099098325,
-0.5698356628,
0.8375211358,
0.5421940684,
-0.0603777543,
-0.3820478618,
-0.5199790597,
-0.1979849786,
-0.4591705501,
0.5002477169,
-0.048114121,
-0.8957672715,
-0.0328659415,
0.388127476,
0.2361974716,
0.1038288102,
0.4731923044,
-0.2715516984,
1.1452118158,
0.8911758065,
0.2767274976,
0.6042323709,
-0.0501633473,
0.1786894947,
-1.1818208694,
-0.4868184924,
-0.2760888934,
-0.4770078361,
-0.4229565859,
-0.5171936154,
0.0165086798,
0.2121896595,
-0.5341653228,
0.2937872112,
-0.7144296169,
0.4377703071,
0.6591209769,
0.212442711,
0.0994208679,
-0.2474499345,
0.0712614432,
-0.2742964327,
-0.6550506353,
-0.3239486516,
0.7374318838,
0.2938358784,
1.2618280649,
0.1702982783,
0.5629827976,
-0.2916040719,
0.4210336804,
-0.9388374686,
0.5332508683,
-0.1691254526,
-0.1075103208,
-0.3777526617,
-0.3683750927,
-0.6599619389,
0.2023388147,
-0.6382428408,
-0.8465511203,
0.1328003258,
0.5958273411,
-0.2620532811,
0.1953961402,
-0.8238404989,
0.7029294968,
-0.4979627728,
-0.8939809799,
0.1760410517,
-0.7319537997,
0.3284622133,
0.2870762348,
0.3843935728,
0.219544962,
0.1670829356,
0.7149825692,
-0.3237133026,
1.0665025711,
0.037226595,
-0.1251813471,
0.0125150904,
-0.0491834916,
0.569083035,
-0.0846046582,
0.1505895555,
-0.2003730536,
0.0068253335,
-0.0520260371,
-0.8344234824,
0.4453640282,
-0.4668086767,
-0.6040546298,
-0.4033158422,
-0.2940534055,
-0.6111598611,
0.0415322632,
0.2012209594,
0.5070310831,
-0.0130331805,
0.2720140815,
0.5622708797,
-0.1999418288,
0.3825356662,
0.7780228257,
-0.7238519192,
-0.564225316,
0.9711081982,
-0.0952520818,
0.41012761,
0.5024052262,
0.338724196,
-0.1714616865,
-0.1569039971,
-0.504832685,
0.0468579568,
-0.5955761075,
-0.0620344244,
-0.2049902827,
-0.2554825544,
-0.3313319981,
-0.2153447568,
-0.4694674611,
-0.2578621209,
-0.0015725764,
0.014318441,
0.2285209447,
0.9577707648,
0.216834113,
0.1458697617,
-0.6341276169,
0.1710193008,
0.4440920651,
0.7235395312,
0.1451932788,
-0.3368837535,
-0.2608547211,
0.0636408478,
-0.1155504882,
-0.7130643129,
0.3097299337,
0.2062039524,
0.3842760026,
0.3239091039,
0.1909358948,
0.9059622288,
-0.7348461151,
0.71790874,
0.6375608444,
-0.804125607,
0.5568537116,
-0.1216057166,
0.3660245836,
0.3449395299,
-0.1103619188,
-0.72817415,
-0.3309336007,
-0.4661178291,
-0.8981058002,
0.8081000447,
0.0406117439,
-0.0046736766,
0.1634599268,
0.2650806308,
-0.4447429478,
0.4352073371,
-0.8929350972,
0.0716331005,
-0.3132599592,
-0.0315212607,
0.0400381126,
-0.2671916783,
-0.3330887556,
-0.3133191764,
0.5995615721,
-0.2147600502,
-0.0952485576,
0.2484491318,
0.082929723,
-0.172139138,
0.4352475405,
0.8944669962,
0.6814577579,
-0.073231034,
0.0243051667,
0.2037456036,
-0.3517968059,
-0.1371273696,
-0.4014977217,
-0.0697091594,
-0.1896802932,
0.6813279986,
1.0837762356,
0.3824684322,
-0.3962573707,
0.5790960193,
-0.3107142448,
-0.0844626874,
-0.2435014248,
0.2093916833,
0.0147355758,
0.2235125601,
-0.1897451282,
0.3013510108,
-0.140098393,
-0.6908898354,
0.238163963,
0.6364431977,
-0.8683530092,
-0.1949985921,
0.6332607865,
0.3419388533,
-0.7365961075,
0.3264675438,
-0.0850405768,
-0.6353524923,
0.2796012461,
0.3393857479,
0.7157472372,
-0.3218133748,
0.2733380497,
0.5290857553,
0.2868568599,
-0.1829019636,
-0.0298900791,
-0.0169470161,
-0.629039526,
-0.7772470713,
-1.1126999855,
-0.6406441927,
0.1100628898,
-0.9008214474,
0.3956095278,
-0.5296157002,
-0.0418944247,
-0.2208299488,
-0.3775566816,
-0.499322921,
0.1401392519,
0.2553455532,
0.519492209,
-0.4591470659,
0.7175706625,
0.8873301744,
-0.5700573325,
-1.1401708126,
0.1696666479,
0.2466169894,
-0.7590773106,
0.6097994447,
0.2142375708,
-0.464225322,
-0.3162993491,
-0.7672356963,
-0.6765918136,
0.6673825979,
0.506809175,
-0.8436733484,
-0.3133040965,
-0.0606257915,
0.6357912421,
-0.3005580306,
0.0446116813,
0.5397619605,
0.4126825631,
0.5408915877,
-1.0225387812,
-0.2154167593,
-0.3267416358,
0.2410117686,
0.3008961082,
-0.7810307145,
0.5232135653,
-0.4009492993,
-0.1228794605,
0.1142678931,
0.5114989281,
-0.0308179017,
0.2269866914,
0.591329217,
0.6513222456,
0.598772347,
-0.2595160604,
1.109749198,
0.1542312205,
0.2923718393,
1.5502617359,
-0.3021076918,
1.1611088514,
0.5591802597,
-0.0826903954,
0.5627845526,
0.310152173,
0.0864828601,
0.5560296774,
0.5504959226,
0.0263873264,
-0.392372489,
0.1025890559,
-0.1591278762,
0.5599796772,
0.0492074341,
0.1230085045,
0.0807628036,
0.0900356174,
-0.120567292,
0.3092806041,
-0.4698229134,
0.9952674508,
0.1377721876,
-0.9333018661,
0.4082943797,
-0.290589124,
0.6073553562,
-0.7698794603,
-0.5126539469,
-0.0416538715,
0.4122616947,
-0.5427111983,
-0.6017626524,
0.2961496413,
-0.1099953726,
-0.2703522146,
-0.1644989848,
0.3753908873,
-0.5879561901,
-0.5123044252,
0.3011814952,
-0.2212264091,
-0.574077189,
0.2200312912,
-0.3684973121,
0.1894018054,
0.0823039487,
-0.2087049633,
0.4425942302,
0.0988356099,
-0.1049985141,
0.8375061154,
0.7670818567,
0.0915622115,
0.002606001,
0.3779090047,
0.6682779789,
-0.4865362048,
-0.4549204707,
-0.7638280392,
0.8640073538,
-0.3633599877,
-0.1761991531,
0.6465501785,
0.1014628708,
0.8031972051,
-0.044883728,
0.3754636943,
0.0840781778,
0.539108932,
-0.92417413,
0.5003059506,
-0.6585635543,
0.5280729532,
-0.4498897791,
-0.8678824902,
-0.2638530135,
0.9569386244,
-0.3371890187,
-0.0764543042,
0.7355924249,
0.6760058999,
0.2537978888,
-0.0494126678,
0.3461867273,
0.1652157009,
0.3291600645,
0.3122582138,
1.0594147444,
0.0705964416,
0.4393108189,
-0.2753488123,
-0.3642139435,
-0.2145307958,
-0.9663042426,
-0.8551728725,
-0.6871849895,
-0.3399458826,
-0.5921162367,
0.1597446203,
0.9880509377,
0.9745216966,
-0.8046571612,
-0.2089818716,
-0.1030381024,
0.0590900667,
-0.161973238,
-0.2541520298,
0.2510237694,
-0.586168468,
-0.7170738578,
0.4015307724,
0.6820037365,
-0.1531426609,
-0.4143348634,
-0.3018954694,
0.024069842,
0.0921838954,
0.7760720253,
0.1367120147,
-0.7882025838,
-0.4920020998,
0.0927763805,
-0.0652651861,
0.0763237774,
0.6657273769,
-0.6371762753,
0.751185298,
0.1124887988,
0.6192379594,
0.4552287161,
-0.0885659903,
0.8302317858,
-0.839233458,
0.1886380911,
0.2818394005,
0.4107406139,
0.468660742,
-0.2874572575,
0.4884823561,
0.0134550724,
-0.490168184,
-0.6195419431,
0.5633016229,
-1.0691539049,
-0.0193667188,
1.1891239882,
0.1804763675,
-0.4074335396,
0.202955842,
-0.6560896039,
-0.07102824,
-0.2033922523,
0.6052661538,
0.6611807942,
-0.1340713352,
-0.4119255543,
-0.4766171575,
0.8083416224,
0.4159831703,
-0.7299570441,
0.0126224272,
0.4813874662,
0.2001958042,
0.1475428641,
0.4852018058,
0.059331283,
0.2577872872,
-0.493937552,
0.1264029592,
-0.0061098631,
-0.3437148333,
-0.2205808759,
-0.0169822611,
0.1235113814,
-0.0587373711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10075v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10075v1
|
ChatGPT-3.5, ChatGPT-4, Google Bard, and Microsoft Bing to Improve Health Literacy and Communication in Pediatric Populations and Beyond
| 2023-11-16T18:30:14 | 2023-11-16T18:30:14 |
Kanhai S. Amin, Linda Mayes, Pavan Khosla, Rushabh Doshi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Purpose: Enhanced health literacy has been linked to better health outcomes;
however, few interventions have been studied. We investigate whether large
language models (LLMs) can serve as a medium to improve health literacy in
children and other populations.
Methods: We ran 288 conditions using 26 different prompts through
ChatGPT-3.5, Microsoft Bing, and Google Bard. Given constraints imposed by rate
limits, we tested a subset of 150 conditions through ChatGPT-4. The primary
outcome measurements were the reading grade level (RGL) and word counts of
output.
Results: Across all models, output for basic prompts such as "Explain" and
"What is (are)" were at, or exceeded, a 10th-grade RGL. When prompts were
specified to explain conditions from the 1st to 12th RGL, we found that LLMs
had varying abilities to tailor responses based on RGL. ChatGPT-3.5 provided
responses that ranged from the 7th-grade to college freshmen RGL while
ChatGPT-4 outputted responses from the 6th-grade to the college-senior RGL.
Microsoft Bing provided responses from the 9th to 11th RGL while Google Bard
provided responses from the 7th to 10th RGL.
Discussion: ChatGPT-3.5 and ChatGPT-4 did better in achieving lower-grade
level outputs. Meanwhile Bard and Bing tended to consistently produce an RGL
that is at the high school level regardless of prompt. Additionally, Bard's
hesitancy in providing certain outputs indicates a cautious approach towards
health information. LLMs demonstrate promise in enhancing health communication,
but future research should verify the accuracy and effectiveness of such tools
in this context.
Implications: LLMs face challenges in crafting outputs below a sixth-grade
reading level. However, their capability to modify outputs above this threshold
provides a potential mechanism to improve health literacy and communication in
a pediatric population and beyond.
|
[
0.0582632348,
-0.5614737868,
0.6705896854,
0.0195833724,
-0.0875230581,
0.1695599854,
-0.0885170326,
-0.64514184,
0.2011256069,
0.1886320412,
-0.270596981,
-0.6435081959,
-0.8936774731,
0.0609340444,
-0.1713647693,
1.209682703,
0.2070369869,
0.0552804917,
0.0379397273,
0.3982638121,
-0.5113682151,
-0.5019404888,
-0.970187068,
-0.3592821658,
1.0187790394,
0.711487174,
0.5675887465,
0.260897547,
0.7204577923,
0.1773658693,
-0.3140459657,
0.0107380636,
-0.7987002134,
0.0843370184,
-0.1344436705,
-0.3091326654,
-0.6256535649,
0.0853363574,
0.6622841358,
0.9981363416,
-0.0589162745,
0.0219437145,
0.4432758987,
1.0459938049,
-0.352100879,
0.3272839487,
-0.2745222449,
0.0524865501,
-0.2574601173,
-0.086233519,
-0.5021265745,
-0.3083958924,
0.414401114,
-0.700268209,
-0.2136340886,
0.1007366106,
0.7602297664,
-0.0033698422,
-0.7920017838,
-0.4934428632,
-0.5607684255,
0.4690872133,
-0.9580483437,
0.4717635512,
0.5485448837,
0.0222772174,
-0.2550259531,
-0.5833407044,
-0.5039205551,
-0.2122331709,
-0.0870834813,
0.6228147745,
-0.2259437144,
0.3283250034,
0.2822012007,
0.3052689433,
-0.8160501122,
0.0013714746,
-0.7583584785,
-0.2896917462,
0.2201058567,
0.4442749619,
0.3575045168,
-0.4131655097,
0.0603083558,
0.0705770925,
-0.7375269532,
0.352494061,
0.182202518,
0.3004216254,
-0.191688031,
0.7705479264,
0.0177928898,
0.532305479,
0.0057105063,
-0.6370116472,
0.2764872015,
-0.3360858262,
-0.0151023204,
-0.0864070505,
0.4177753925,
0.5582160354,
0.2208920121,
0.0428258814,
0.0205933079,
0.015144798,
0.0595568977,
-1.0552664995,
-0.3390200734,
0.1594361514,
-0.8107967377,
-0.0598423406,
-0.2362037599,
-0.7862076759,
-0.6339037418,
-0.0374245904,
0.4293194115,
-0.5529550314,
0.022727944,
0.2254734635,
-0.0216639433,
-0.144180268,
0.3135451674,
-1.1303719282,
0.2051721811,
0.4520454705,
0.7881982923,
-0.4240012467,
0.0754716769,
-0.4139397442,
0.1809175164,
-0.4042657018,
0.8029277921,
-0.4811286926,
-0.6276186705,
0.1013082042,
0.0046538315,
-0.534681201,
-0.4401298165,
0.7308237553,
-0.2086588591,
0.303301841,
-0.275670141,
-0.6403973103,
0.2171723098,
0.3397295177,
-0.3637170792,
0.6303824186,
0.0919105187,
-0.8494974971,
0.2173645347,
-0.4348466694,
-0.6828404069,
0.1060278565,
-0.0129453689,
-0.223626405,
0.0073977802,
0.384854883,
0.2377232313,
-0.1618999988,
0.1594192684,
-0.0261337012,
-0.4774541855,
0.202255398,
-0.6958515644,
0.3656270206,
0.0030191138,
-0.2188472599,
0.1265844554,
-0.365650624,
0.1158232763,
-0.1188056767,
-0.7678106427,
-0.0601647794,
-0.0309556648,
-0.0631994382,
-0.0292491987,
0.1904595494,
-0.4867869914,
0.2140496969,
-0.6147749424,
0.4778455496,
0.2518193722,
0.264467448,
0.1374432743,
-0.8051378727,
0.6109631062,
-0.1516758353,
0.3691750765,
-0.4259069562,
-0.996778965,
-0.3464622796,
-0.2754271626,
0.1549404562,
0.550139606,
-0.920555234,
0.0930789411,
-0.3563164771,
-0.4673859775,
-0.3830171227,
-0.1341390908,
0.562526226,
0.8986184001,
0.2512789965,
-0.1326323897,
-0.1341771185,
-0.5924298167,
-0.2740463614,
-0.4642126262,
-0.0914001465,
0.6401871443,
0.2701118588,
-0.0455141515,
0.2760188878,
-0.3108237088,
-0.3760579824,
-0.3992648423,
-0.1570691913,
0.3472087383,
0.1786064804,
0.368916899,
-0.4808116257,
-0.6726039052,
-0.0270440783,
-0.2038303763,
-0.2232203186,
0.2319707572,
0.1104881465,
-0.199396953,
0.1807603687,
-0.2940437794,
0.5735376477,
0.9002432823,
-0.4800241292,
0.54964149,
-0.2053458393,
0.3146038949,
-0.93359828,
-0.0469599217,
-0.1117948443,
-0.1664282978,
-0.9185496569,
-0.4653736055,
0.0740647987,
-0.3531014919,
-0.3148537874,
0.6410393119,
-0.3245084882,
0.2840054929,
-0.3255248964,
0.159509927,
0.0713206828,
-0.0939824134,
0.0131874466,
0.7456287146,
0.4614789188,
-0.1882453859,
0.0106730713,
-0.0858986452,
-0.3363254368,
0.5962020159,
-1.078139782,
-0.2659055889,
-0.1052662507,
0.6434113979,
-1.1014357805,
-0.5511709452,
0.409745723,
-0.5854362249,
0.1913933754,
0.007047358,
-0.4540193081,
-0.7548705935,
-0.1431760192,
-0.0049258787,
0.6778650284,
-0.2827550173,
0.1931740642,
0.467492342,
-0.474819392,
-0.34994784,
-0.7490617037,
0.0272649173,
-0.2061951905,
-0.6884220839,
0.3775492311,
-0.1979473233,
0.1062099114,
0.0346591398,
-0.1542214155,
-0.1121427342,
-0.2200149745,
0.1631552875,
0.3959377408,
-0.2135124207,
0.5526633859,
0.1638054848,
-0.0159892756,
-0.10851641,
-0.1841366887,
0.4435809553,
-0.19518134,
-0.5012880564,
-0.5735157728,
0.3327795863,
0.5078029633,
-0.0525860116,
0.8326571584,
0.4110155404,
-0.2250366509,
0.2237273455,
-0.328107208,
-0.4122551382,
-0.4143293202,
0.1875906438,
-0.0568348095,
-1.1083910465,
0.3697178066,
0.0157220215,
0.1144598648,
0.0486663803,
0.6172683239,
-0.3068095148,
1.0349830389,
0.207466051,
0.1443861872,
0.4717342257,
0.0201989394,
0.4294394851,
-0.9148494005,
-0.2094538361,
-0.3484383821,
-0.3138393462,
-0.5163747668,
-0.4685736299,
0.8277163506,
-0.1543503851,
-0.2318977863,
-0.1303506196,
-0.608294785,
0.3090648055,
0.5209038258,
0.5546598434,
0.2406699359,
-0.1998276412,
-0.3161681294,
-0.3065750897,
-0.8368708491,
-0.4905810654,
1.0566912889,
0.4847732484,
0.8938438892,
0.3817591369,
0.7178141475,
-0.0343318097,
0.5909050107,
-0.878952086,
0.2884799838,
-0.3339681029,
-0.7371584773,
-0.3827413917,
-0.394364953,
-1.2723801136,
0.2715843916,
-0.2374130934,
-0.9789469242,
0.2308265269,
0.1602561176,
-0.6062518358,
0.0790610015,
-0.8238210082,
0.6675009131,
-0.2016650587,
-0.3598570824,
0.0981104821,
-0.7213263512,
0.2142021954,
-0.2139458209,
0.3626063168,
-0.3329247832,
0.0270601083,
0.6999511719,
-0.3781050146,
1.1068017483,
0.1488533765,
-0.2107025087,
0.4160200357,
-0.2260992825,
0.4018358588,
0.19951801,
-0.2483505458,
-0.2466300279,
0.2011500448,
-0.420786798,
-0.5182694197,
0.8425836563,
-0.7415395379,
-0.8223958611,
-0.5611757636,
-0.5527306795,
-0.4033998251,
0.2018148005,
0.1902678013,
0.6854678392,
0.0130898366,
0.4623378217,
0.6663168073,
-0.4070388675,
0.210296154,
0.65127635,
-0.2051534057,
-0.2118685097,
0.7506155968,
0.1040811166,
0.5388203859,
0.0309787635,
0.617702961,
-0.2632738054,
-0.4322086275,
-0.1265430748,
0.4569938779,
-0.7106789947,
-0.0781059563,
-0.5733900666,
-0.4810330272,
-0.7235987782,
-0.1329427809,
0.2367120683,
-0.4157190919,
-0.2402132452,
0.0367599279,
0.1195967421,
0.8306469321,
-0.2522599697,
0.3072216213,
-0.8952167034,
0.0771241486,
0.4494799674,
0.1450967044,
0.1540556997,
-0.8119662404,
-0.1995955557,
-0.0237718541,
-0.3974024355,
-1.1760576963,
0.3669397533,
0.2209616899,
0.4392127395,
0.2878925502,
-0.1154505685,
0.5131968856,
-0.7120558023,
1.0854816437,
0.1267618686,
-0.7000315189,
0.446611166,
-0.5442093015,
0.6276461482,
0.2838090658,
0.3544670343,
-0.8635585308,
-0.3779992163,
-0.408976078,
-0.7093104124,
0.3518100679,
0.269198209,
0.3371162117,
-0.2852993309,
0.0132957231,
-0.1710593402,
0.0230063368,
-0.6011648774,
-0.1301607788,
-0.1595737934,
-0.3977265358,
-0.0081210518,
-0.4108629525,
-0.1497229636,
-0.2626983225,
0.5001707077,
0.0324967876,
0.1418734491,
0.3051253259,
0.4341547191,
0.0381065086,
0.6328158379,
0.4683419764,
0.6107800007,
0.1410578638,
0.3273637295,
0.0141057363,
-0.9039911628,
0.0324631333,
0.192503199,
-0.0660338774,
-0.1547147185,
0.7585305572,
0.6356340051,
0.336212337,
-0.7133274674,
0.6006309986,
-0.1652453095,
-0.1231165379,
0.2444286644,
0.1549270302,
0.4561193585,
0.2293072343,
0.1285687387,
-0.4518861175,
0.162207678,
-0.4158931077,
0.1354167312,
0.0967514589,
-0.31975317,
-0.1956161857,
0.6113452911,
0.3744337261,
-0.0762917772,
0.5305923223,
0.1131250262,
-0.2532634139,
0.5949710011,
0.8878390193,
0.2064417005,
-0.2616797984,
0.5805082321,
0.410918504,
0.4693545401,
0.0909589827,
0.3765110075,
0.421638608,
-0.563470602,
-0.5091317296,
-0.2943259776,
-0.529917419,
0.074739784,
-0.4137067795,
-0.0952926651,
-0.1605755389,
-0.3542733192,
0.0696066245,
0.0805201009,
-0.6914232373,
0.2693742514,
0.0758607388,
0.5798078179,
-0.7561292648,
0.7179784775,
0.7975623012,
-0.4928410351,
-1.0940355062,
0.4646904469,
0.2975408137,
-0.7831049562,
0.6394307613,
0.1594583392,
0.1213125959,
0.100310646,
-0.3517474234,
-1.1085258722,
0.9065910578,
-0.0114558525,
-0.7372362614,
-0.1577015072,
0.1616140753,
0.8262887001,
-0.3106583357,
0.4199517369,
0.5098841786,
0.6121034026,
0.3688082695,
-1.2426832914,
-0.2445856333,
-0.0506656431,
-0.0039239712,
-0.212282598,
-0.4551648796,
0.7209160924,
-0.5350003242,
-0.201381132,
0.0667343289,
0.5821849108,
0.4022176564,
0.3680345118,
0.2040932626,
0.2904952168,
1.155843854,
-0.0585129224,
1.0699445009,
-0.3680720627,
0.1463166177,
0.9291649461,
-0.1554745436,
0.7726202011,
0.2662010491,
-0.0069419867,
0.2777893841,
0.8090296984,
0.5907696486,
0.5506236553,
0.2723942995,
-0.6071167588,
-0.0035742794,
-0.2781713605,
-0.372777015,
-0.050424289,
0.7888638377,
-0.4285720885,
-0.0010533191,
0.3432944119,
0.4446623325,
0.0560647696,
-0.3414621949,
0.5388616323,
0.258926928,
-0.4730003476,
0.7248578668,
-0.3383203149,
0.4451323748,
-0.2834961414,
-0.0899481848,
-0.3412881494,
0.0165572185,
-0.165229246,
-1.0857477188,
0.0526852235,
0.0689341575,
-0.1728379577,
-0.1794403642,
0.9574648738,
-0.6194422245,
-0.6003673077,
-0.0087253796,
0.5212051272,
0.3922084272,
0.243892312,
-0.7081696987,
0.2558803558,
-0.1005351767,
-0.4442635179,
0.1238261759,
0.4301485419,
0.0363261402,
0.6012623906,
0.7083461881,
0.4214842319,
-0.0144380853,
0.1840804517,
0.9072467089,
-0.1800273061,
-0.128960371,
-0.382832706,
0.3166657686,
-0.0147957802,
-0.3521619439,
0.76409024,
0.2592600584,
0.2685923576,
0.0261874311,
0.9190971851,
0.0631323531,
0.9933766723,
-0.3432727158,
0.8007506132,
-0.4694749117,
0.0424679331,
-0.1714642793,
-0.6598810554,
-0.5191398263,
0.5651344061,
-0.8200422525,
0.0545807965,
1.0791773796,
0.6266158223,
0.2714651525,
0.0593398772,
0.463404566,
0.2203965634,
0.6056110859,
0.6675813198,
0.5791586041,
-0.0359822176,
0.4766729772,
0.080165334,
-0.4256151617,
-0.1608033329,
-0.640075624,
-1.2296330929,
-0.2076143473,
0.1260460317,
-0.4517589509,
0.6749420166,
0.6348251104,
0.3634942174,
-0.3074764311,
0.1384711713,
0.3109362721,
0.0064052469,
0.0356015377,
-0.174740389,
0.4194283187,
-0.2551604211,
-0.7062960863,
0.5187664628,
0.2213124186,
0.1068459451,
-0.1398909539,
0.0854557604,
0.3592411578,
0.2539937198,
0.7358385324,
0.2700970471,
-0.6021812558,
-0.321575135,
0.1051078737,
-0.5104176998,
0.0616945811,
0.5108447075,
-0.4571053386,
0.3771604598,
0.5225525498,
0.4700306356,
0.3647105992,
0.0812997669,
0.2442287952,
-0.2220706344,
-0.0900838375,
0.4246484041,
0.169394508,
0.434491992,
-0.3333982229,
0.3593328595,
0.1867647618,
-0.8891914487,
-0.3104934692,
0.0319192968,
-0.6785370111,
-0.1130271479,
1.4224908352,
-0.2424017787,
-0.1507708132,
-0.2438615412,
-0.6107797623,
-0.0807930231,
-0.5582108498,
0.767745316,
0.8700183034,
-0.2187408954,
-0.2990579903,
-0.85076648,
0.425524354,
0.4396977723,
-1.1928859949,
-0.1578432024,
0.5353196859,
0.2344643027,
-0.1953479946,
0.9741437435,
-0.2967514694,
0.2994190156,
-0.2356796116,
-0.2812932134,
0.3981242478,
-0.2831926942,
0.0902247131,
-0.2139952928,
0.0130741233,
0.2053167373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10057v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10057v3
|
The Song Describer Dataset: a Corpus of Audio Captions for Music-and-Language Evaluation
| 2023-11-16T17:52:21 | 2023-11-22T21:22:11 |
Ilaria Manco, Benno Weck, SeungHeon Doh, Minz Won, Yixiao Zhang, Dmitry Bogdanov, Yusong Wu, Ke Chen, Philip Tovstogan, Emmanouil Benetos, Elio Quinton, György Fazekas, Juhan Nam
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
We introduce the Song Describer dataset (SDD), a new crowdsourced corpus of
high-quality audio-caption pairs, designed for the evaluation of
music-and-language models. The dataset consists of 1.1k human-written natural
language descriptions of 706 music recordings, all publicly accessible and
released under Creative Common licenses. To showcase the use of our dataset, we
benchmark popular models on three key music-and-language tasks (music
captioning, text-to-music generation and music-language retrieval). Our
experiments highlight the importance of cross-dataset evaluation and offer
insights into how researchers can use SDD to gain a broader understanding of
model performance.
|
[
-0.5908780694,
-0.147836104,
0.1197475046,
0.4453991055,
-0.2364682406,
0.3347582221,
-0.351909548,
-0.4390985072,
0.3025266826,
0.8024578094,
-0.519613564,
-0.6399450898,
-0.3692055047,
0.1036678255,
-0.9323039651,
1.2296699286,
0.1648068875,
0.2294266224,
-0.6939737201,
-0.2113296092,
-0.3240050673,
-0.2308520675,
-0.3821147978,
0.2177191675,
0.694357276,
0.1846789569,
0.7003244162,
0.6963510513,
0.9303084612,
0.1939840764,
0.080902271,
-0.271569252,
-0.4322984815,
0.079527393,
-0.1767619103,
-0.2430992872,
-0.118298322,
0.4717170596,
0.5259346962,
0.897497654,
-0.0251628589,
0.579456985,
-0.2280468494,
0.7250683308,
-0.3117928505,
0.2561842799,
-0.3028794825,
-0.0156258531,
-0.3900887072,
-0.0608421043,
-0.0737893209,
-0.5450004339,
0.4298686087,
-0.7576308846,
0.5292139649,
0.1577532589,
0.7555696368,
0.2505863011,
0.0202701055,
-0.524959743,
-0.8566903472,
0.6838874221,
-0.2343898416,
0.3983911276,
0.4894585609,
0.7829480171,
0.2449095547,
-0.3890006244,
-0.6575064063,
-0.0884658918,
0.0921205282,
0.1019068137,
-0.1403150409,
-0.0896843895,
0.2796461284,
0.8416432142,
-0.7172877789,
-0.1567299962,
-0.7718333006,
-0.1270194948,
1.0712621212,
0.1494062096,
0.2431139946,
-0.3702191412,
-0.4662540555,
-0.168346718,
-0.6683325171,
0.0245962366,
0.5455027223,
0.3972521424,
-0.3100782037,
0.7998008728,
-0.1132140458,
0.8262471557,
-0.1492291391,
-0.0165481381,
0.3924027979,
-0.5080685019,
-0.1005612016,
-0.0063829306,
0.836207211,
0.5885904431,
0.1365060359,
-0.6264189482,
-0.5490858555,
0.2506843805,
-0.0001705617,
-0.426684618,
-0.5246617794,
0.2150756419,
-0.7316583991,
-0.1624653339,
0.2501275837,
-0.8645228148,
-0.6751068234,
-0.8146625161,
0.5051426888,
-0.3058327734,
-0.2748394608,
0.1975335181,
-0.3697238863,
-0.1615964174,
-0.2757377326,
-0.6573301554,
0.4887956679,
0.8168263435,
0.9005946517,
-0.6198230982,
-0.3325411975,
-0.4113768637,
-0.0829035044,
-0.3235734105,
0.7146111727,
-0.4995191097,
-0.4158742726,
-0.1206245646,
0.0301186964,
-0.0956984907,
-0.8954783082,
0.5256097317,
-0.4074010253,
0.2383099198,
-0.5256735682,
-0.7586993575,
-0.1087246612,
-0.4232619405,
-1.4047765732,
0.7942210436,
0.3653500676,
-0.8379603624,
0.6239799261,
-0.9580993652,
-0.5581704378,
0.1665185243,
-0.2052568942,
-0.3519741297,
0.2690766752,
0.1223117784,
0.6499191523,
-0.4952899814,
0.295156002,
-0.1883625835,
-0.675137639,
0.5278114676,
-0.093160294,
0.6894862056,
0.6960012317,
0.1163132042,
0.0731495693,
-0.9868842959,
-0.2968559563,
0.2769246399,
-0.3521521091,
-0.2267915159,
0.0334458165,
0.7417881489,
0.0054236087,
0.1187824681,
-0.7106023431,
-0.1951487213,
-0.1353763193,
0.5962979198,
0.2388181835,
-0.0952745751,
0.3007129133,
-0.7457772493,
0.9001210928,
-0.2983216643,
-0.0725374743,
-0.2972242832,
-0.1293365061,
0.0117082838,
-0.3355054259,
0.6555888057,
0.2562452257,
-0.4223422706,
0.4549203217,
-0.4118903577,
-0.6606604457,
-1.1266357899,
0.1756753474,
0.4113072753,
0.1923213452,
0.1909131408,
-0.2112188488,
-0.7748373747,
-1.0161478519,
0.0931989625,
-0.106092073,
-0.230336979,
0.3393493593,
0.1456107199,
0.0976678655,
1.2101550102,
-0.1378187984,
-0.2667728662,
-0.3278048337,
0.1721448898,
0.2686199248,
0.3658997416,
0.7206353545,
-0.8991748691,
-0.2831036747,
-0.467233181,
-0.3476428986,
-0.4229983985,
-0.1238082051,
-0.0866422057,
-0.1455443203,
0.2029063553,
-0.5399896502,
-0.1880881786,
0.7530332804,
-0.2417505234,
0.6040799022,
0.339230597,
0.4096725285,
-0.8759222031,
0.132740736,
-0.0682894886,
0.1830437034,
-0.2583113611,
-0.1984913498,
-0.1444838047,
-0.1562298685,
-0.2742259502,
0.1364559084,
-0.3398990929,
-0.7560954094,
-0.2255979031,
0.4102048278,
0.0305929072,
0.0095159886,
0.2579440773,
0.7689857483,
0.8891179562,
-0.2649281323,
0.8417288661,
0.2841399312,
-1.0327701569,
0.8253436089,
-0.7222175002,
0.0041616699,
-0.1958970428,
0.0532248132,
-1.0381959677,
-0.3369101882,
-0.2898538411,
-0.4214892685,
0.0998564363,
-0.2077259868,
-0.7279685736,
-0.7275004387,
0.070047833,
0.4300872982,
0.253059566,
-0.7510722876,
0.1373966932,
0.6915049553,
-0.3666156232,
-0.0197821967,
-0.5414153934,
0.120832637,
-0.5328291655,
-0.6288055778,
0.2786244154,
-0.2203631401,
-0.3816806078,
0.0567434281,
-0.1551762372,
-0.0520397574,
0.0318915211,
0.6051577926,
0.3322944343,
-0.2166041732,
0.6621214151,
-0.1761046052,
-0.036752928,
0.3881938159,
-0.0016232015,
0.6719710231,
0.0601720922,
-0.2979642153,
-0.313383013,
0.4085152447,
0.4796621501,
-0.3633657098,
0.0172863919,
0.4585960209,
-0.0608916692,
0.0356654488,
-0.3664087057,
0.1175826266,
-0.3706103265,
0.4055780172,
-0.4714477062,
-0.6678664088,
0.445220679,
0.2392741293,
-0.008762178,
0.3777368367,
0.1881007105,
-0.3951588571,
0.8393751979,
0.3102089167,
-0.4877223969,
0.2879314423,
-0.3601050973,
-0.3492150009,
-0.6954742074,
-0.1535911262,
-0.716786027,
-0.5643241405,
-0.4911113381,
-0.406869173,
-0.120519504,
-0.1151967868,
-0.1662304252,
0.6430039406,
-0.5887089372,
0.6495679021,
0.6231966615,
-0.1941953599,
0.2042321265,
-0.1561070234,
0.1545846611,
-0.1133605912,
-0.2671939731,
-0.4965308607,
1.5152316093,
0.3920336366,
0.7530720234,
0.0540562011,
0.6942753792,
0.6663056612,
-0.0671931431,
-0.6645050049,
0.2425704747,
-0.1959860325,
-0.8545385003,
-0.2594658136,
-0.3455582261,
-0.774612546,
-0.0162750203,
-0.0822358727,
-0.3436802924,
-0.0650567114,
-0.1256863475,
-0.4865869284,
0.0120320125,
-0.5641465783,
0.8000820875,
-0.458578974,
0.1486337632,
0.0344524421,
-0.4966087639,
0.2601751089,
-0.2351248711,
0.4394830167,
-0.5035556555,
0.0227252077,
1.3442696333,
0.0739088133,
0.3008952737,
-0.3543556035,
-0.2018550485,
0.2529234886,
-0.0118386913,
0.1390113384,
-0.0037399798,
0.0136565063,
0.1940547675,
0.2507681549,
-0.3401024044,
-0.5396330357,
0.7925202847,
-0.6689755321,
-0.1810789108,
0.1164569706,
-0.7613924146,
-0.2475278676,
-0.125500977,
0.2232155502,
0.4739590883,
-0.2581295073,
0.4331493676,
0.536201179,
-0.3543708622,
0.4748963118,
0.5017024279,
-0.5170164704,
-0.624206841,
0.9875594378,
-0.1496035159,
0.4061129093,
0.3651407063,
-0.0129879434,
-0.6309568882,
-0.5694372654,
-0.5995215178,
0.2331828475,
-0.5163080692,
0.0574154668,
-0.4744459987,
0.0834130049,
-0.146828413,
0.04403878,
-0.4128438532,
-0.6912866831,
0.0554253645,
-0.4215176105,
0.5133304,
0.933416307,
-0.1706300676,
0.2425044179,
-0.4801795185,
0.6869002581,
0.0724845752,
0.7430903912,
-0.4256716073,
-0.3118667901,
-0.4056961536,
-0.0039829635,
0.2088770121,
-0.7947535515,
0.1188701689,
0.2405458391,
0.504470706,
0.553637445,
0.0980972573,
0.4425378144,
-0.1799850911,
0.7717946768,
0.1157650501,
-0.7272515893,
0.5915125608,
-0.4014554024,
-0.0716407225,
0.5764734745,
0.3792833388,
-0.6460629702,
-0.3658136427,
-0.3607899845,
-0.5897661448,
0.531956017,
0.2286730558,
0.1098527089,
-0.0744455159,
-0.1129280105,
0.5890049934,
0.4310966134,
-0.4764514863,
-0.4194107652,
-0.4458222091,
-0.3640615046,
-0.5396432281,
0.0216096975,
-0.2446777821,
-0.1332003176,
0.2944749296,
0.0284897611,
0.3100713491,
-0.107487455,
-0.0785925984,
-0.3663960397,
0.284112215,
0.1444717199,
0.5252820849,
-0.3629389405,
0.0606424138,
-0.4871467054,
-0.4654788673,
-0.0074902424,
0.4069835246,
-0.1340376735,
0.082106553,
0.3835900128,
0.796387732,
0.3318019211,
-1.0929234028,
0.4926054776,
0.0319340527,
-0.0199317485,
-0.3258273602,
0.0307242908,
0.3336500227,
0.08450827,
0.4586441517,
-0.0003150687,
0.4603111446,
-0.2178872675,
0.4790090322,
0.1729255021,
-0.7715781331,
-0.3172363341,
0.9127450585,
-0.0598011874,
-0.0534460843,
0.3276469409,
0.0781385079,
-0.125456363,
0.7823494673,
0.2637193799,
0.7987027764,
0.1517381817,
0.4134320021,
0.2767935991,
0.0359877869,
0.1655036658,
0.6307686567,
-0.3050539196,
-0.3488225043,
-0.3993276656,
-0.9302006364,
-0.2095965594,
0.2293500453,
-1.1547561884,
0.0972026438,
-0.1883122772,
0.02579448,
0.6101429462,
0.0257733483,
-0.778188467,
0.105191268,
0.1046938971,
0.9263857603,
-1.1662720442,
0.523668766,
0.4738153815,
-0.6895364523,
-0.4766667485,
-0.1787483394,
0.0714070201,
-0.2593314946,
0.6264279485,
0.0626631603,
0.3422828615,
-0.1537163854,
-0.701977551,
-0.9491510391,
1.0457141399,
0.029881997,
-0.8049682975,
0.4141404331,
0.3985159099,
0.700961113,
-0.6212838888,
0.034756653,
0.841017127,
0.5657582879,
0.2378638685,
-0.9670674205,
-0.3423738182,
-0.4543974102,
-0.0597721934,
0.0002591649,
-0.3768698573,
0.851688385,
-0.2946334481,
-0.3228086233,
0.4676733911,
0.5706745982,
0.3062362075,
0.3901034594,
0.6473944783,
0.3677968085,
0.6254532933,
-0.4808034301,
1.1872167587,
-0.0467866845,
0.1914756447,
1.3078380823,
-0.3589726388,
0.8426473737,
0.3413223922,
-0.5696225166,
0.1017190516,
0.8518434763,
-0.5816361904,
0.8342712522,
0.7987347245,
-0.2006520182,
-0.1150724813,
-0.2015330195,
-0.2658796906,
0.5067741275,
-0.0173285268,
-0.6342415214,
0.055410549,
0.3315978944,
-0.4729172885,
0.417437166,
-0.142986685,
0.8564636707,
-0.3929510415,
-0.5003173947,
0.2274172604,
-0.3248987794,
0.4939125776,
0.048484534,
0.0282278638,
-0.0105593447,
-0.2189418972,
-0.173470214,
-1.0081734657,
0.3832779825,
-0.0166095346,
-0.5887317657,
0.0606753714,
0.2760211229,
-0.7598842382,
-0.4688871503,
0.4831178486,
0.11207176,
0.3899810314,
-0.272113353,
-0.4928841889,
0.1095632911,
-0.2216255963,
0.2828008831,
0.0348080806,
0.3166786134,
0.0628928691,
0.6452984214,
0.5177922249,
0.4780734777,
0.2405059785,
0.5324578285,
0.5577329397,
-0.7205913663,
-0.3956535459,
-0.1925320476,
0.200576663,
0.0658563748,
-0.0801873356,
0.671127975,
1.3869755268,
1.2068163157,
-0.4150005877,
1.3553795815,
-0.3203973472,
1.3260923624,
-0.441123724,
0.8624392748,
-0.231345132,
0.4548661113,
-0.5223582387,
-0.8780359626,
-0.020044677,
0.2653122544,
-0.0595935769,
0.0544080622,
0.2714500427,
0.7341099977,
-0.1285918057,
0.4324812293,
0.1994581372,
-0.0484409779,
0.0534190685,
0.4944196641,
1.2793831825,
-0.4669396281,
0.7116578817,
-0.7673678994,
0.080162175,
0.1780695021,
-0.564124167,
-0.8075069189,
-1.0472365618,
-0.5415914655,
-0.1185039952,
-0.0231947824,
0.9761501551,
0.5557013154,
-1.1830483675,
-0.4334120154,
0.2681878507,
0.0406421721,
-0.4904329777,
-0.2491942048,
0.6015767455,
-0.0212683063,
-0.8751469851,
0.5695502758,
-0.0768942758,
0.0618360639,
-0.5170665383,
-0.4551328421,
0.2494210601,
-0.0841746107,
0.2190736532,
0.0326712355,
-0.8028308749,
-0.0162091572,
-0.0449000187,
-0.0739574209,
-0.1417658925,
0.895844996,
-0.5045589805,
0.7022801638,
0.3897770941,
0.3274925947,
0.3105700016,
0.1627489477,
0.5252729654,
-0.6855511069,
-0.4047204256,
0.0294014029,
0.2173479348,
0.5046086311,
0.0916231722,
0.6508424878,
0.1079800054,
-0.3939263225,
-0.7496763468,
-0.1499823183,
-1.2192949057,
0.2393642068,
1.1325809956,
-0.3002291322,
-0.0126920873,
-0.3589104712,
-0.3100443482,
-0.0243589953,
-0.3966409266,
0.8876200318,
0.7007865906,
0.2699455619,
-0.1175190583,
-0.6944314241,
0.7523570657,
-0.3042816818,
-0.4642140269,
0.2842903733,
0.9062901735,
0.3839003444,
0.2285674065,
0.1970157772,
-0.4976575077,
0.5362093449,
-0.0214866139,
0.3117906153,
-0.2549225986,
-0.410143733,
-0.2950308621,
0.169150278,
-0.1994421035,
-0.5389829874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10054v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10054v1
|
Is "A Helpful Assistant" the Best Role for Large Language Models? A Systematic Evaluation of Social Roles in System Prompts
| 2023-11-16T17:48:55 | 2023-11-16T17:48:55 |
Mingqian Zheng, Jiaxin Pei, David Jurgens
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Prompting serves as the major way humans interact with Large Language Models
(LLM). Commercial AI systems commonly define the role of the LLM in system
prompts. For example, ChatGPT uses "You are a helpful assistant" as part of the
default system prompt. But is "a helpful assistant" the best role for LLMs? In
this study, we present a systematic evaluation of how social roles in system
prompts affect model performance. We curate a list of 162 roles covering 6
types of interpersonal relationships and 8 types of occupations. Through
extensive analysis of 3 popular LLMs and 2457 questions, we show that adding
interpersonal roles in prompts consistently improves the models' performance
over a range of questions. Moreover, while we find that using gender-neutral
roles and specifying the role as the audience leads to better performances,
predicting which role leads to the best performance remains a challenging task,
and that frequency, similarity, and perplexity do not fully explain the effect
of social roles on model performances. Our results can help inform the design
of system prompts for AI systems. Code and data are available at
https://github.com/Jiaxin-Pei/Prompting-with-Social-Roles.
|
[
-0.3151848912,
-0.5627277493,
0.6252921224,
0.4116454422,
0.0353461616,
-0.145699352,
-0.1469543278,
-0.4706896245,
0.1241978928,
0.1917794794,
-0.2936782241,
-0.0106586926,
-0.5875377059,
0.4878231585,
-0.2812716961,
0.7327244282,
0.5001605749,
0.4285876155,
-0.6175379157,
0.240648821,
-0.7405374646,
-0.5416082144,
-1.2732590437,
-0.3851469159,
0.692393899,
0.465623945,
0.9115920067,
0.3123376071,
0.3873305023,
0.3956180811,
-0.2109703422,
0.2718743086,
-0.0635107458,
0.6500449181,
0.0897140801,
-0.3748663366,
-0.5910682082,
-0.075609751,
0.3902107775,
0.6504004598,
-0.0563361906,
0.1715033948,
0.5021831393,
0.263582468,
-0.2958941758,
0.4719141424,
-0.2234776467,
-0.3263231218,
-0.0193792768,
-0.1020059213,
-0.4539506733,
-0.4152260125,
0.2263801545,
-0.7577335238,
-0.1095259339,
-0.0602821335,
0.343796283,
0.3462819159,
-0.4065207541,
-0.3318302631,
-0.7103659511,
0.5059728026,
-0.5320368409,
0.0956362262,
0.4433411956,
0.4045154452,
-0.4322689474,
-0.1355627626,
-0.3844060898,
-0.4637477398,
-0.1962662488,
-0.0992680266,
-0.3453390002,
0.4156627357,
0.4019565284,
-0.021497013,
-0.2768618762,
0.2985205948,
-0.5583532453,
-0.2627805173,
0.619389534,
0.1189892963,
0.5624922514,
-0.1248949543,
0.0045890487,
-0.1786516756,
-0.7226836681,
0.3021104932,
0.4982245564,
0.3826939464,
-0.1847194135,
0.450351119,
-0.0752778426,
0.5015513301,
0.0089599481,
-0.0110244378,
-0.4915084839,
-0.1459641904,
0.117070213,
0.1847356856,
0.6051211357,
0.4837115705,
0.9087125659,
0.0257085171,
-0.2352591008,
-0.0346129909,
0.202338919,
-0.2923475206,
0.0002266151,
-0.1571959853,
-0.4555700719,
-0.1096618921,
0.0864968523,
-0.2890278697,
-0.8863167763,
-0.3229594529,
0.1781832427,
-0.1289987117,
-0.2602670789,
-0.2874568403,
-0.2921745181,
0.3615532517,
0.5729794502,
-0.8841273189,
0.5455293655,
0.591055572,
0.8252840042,
-0.0059654466,
-0.325853765,
-1.0679085255,
-0.1171085238,
-0.2484104335,
0.8326289058,
-0.7163395882,
-0.7450380325,
0.1463969052,
-0.1058755144,
-0.0359010026,
-0.6276153326,
0.3126980662,
-0.4391685128,
0.0369404554,
-0.5434796214,
-0.2903028429,
0.1596497744,
0.0135757765,
-0.6485487819,
0.8991766572,
-0.1698942631,
-0.3662390113,
0.0841145366,
-0.9156212807,
-0.4082563519,
0.1008448824,
-0.2212215066,
0.0986342579,
-0.0068622683,
0.2763693333,
0.6930226088,
-0.4063921273,
0.2537077665,
-0.4886652529,
-0.5847163796,
0.6478479505,
-0.3343307078,
0.7935582995,
-0.1109261736,
-0.1768521816,
0.278260082,
-0.4976045489,
-0.4418748915,
-0.0371431783,
-0.2581036389,
-0.4143439829,
-0.0996928588,
-0.0910381302,
0.0269359611,
0.1297821105,
-0.2050266415,
0.305380404,
0.0173083581,
0.0740994886,
1.2271487713,
0.016412599,
0.4982293844,
-0.1351631135,
0.9144517183,
-0.6023470163,
0.0880115777,
-0.1450117677,
-0.8666424155,
-0.4893222749,
-0.2274401486,
0.2718001604,
0.6690974832,
-0.5947071314,
0.3752754331,
0.3158263564,
-0.3623189628,
-0.3286736012,
-0.0122334752,
0.4648476243,
0.247855261,
0.0286917239,
-0.0764253289,
-0.2183200419,
-1.0680881739,
-0.1270405948,
-0.6118472815,
-0.0386114754,
0.3046244681,
0.0673112199,
0.0058369017,
0.7784957886,
-0.3450846374,
-0.2476079017,
-0.3735959232,
-0.347776413,
0.1760421246,
0.1439498663,
0.575791955,
-0.4136197865,
-0.6243447065,
-0.2215574235,
-0.6546379924,
-0.7408556938,
0.0693894252,
-0.1710128188,
-0.0823919922,
0.5979415774,
-0.7189311385,
0.2430617064,
0.4721401036,
-0.6145809889,
0.5608190894,
-0.555845499,
0.0023321644,
-0.8671889305,
0.1976442635,
0.1721925437,
-0.1470257044,
-0.84959203,
-0.1524419785,
-0.2128497064,
-0.1604139805,
0.059231773,
0.7687475085,
-0.5539462566,
-0.407487452,
-0.3291174769,
0.2073237747,
-0.3102943003,
0.0607735515,
-0.0858485326,
1.0453470945,
0.7658939958,
-0.8724290133,
0.2274832726,
0.2701395154,
-0.0519971587,
0.5685536265,
-1.0037436485,
0.2448227108,
-0.0492525548,
0.2511251569,
-1.32442379,
-0.3310489357,
0.1400813162,
-0.4693276286,
0.226339981,
0.0375545695,
-0.7395863533,
-0.0949238762,
-0.0321675017,
0.0184421744,
0.3565601408,
-0.3429829478,
0.3037881851,
0.5118615031,
-0.5155146122,
-0.3359840214,
-0.2953075469,
0.0348921418,
-0.2855644822,
-0.6347021461,
0.152521655,
-0.2665165961,
-0.4914570749,
-0.3143722415,
0.1530044377,
0.0465269908,
0.5116225481,
0.3210085332,
0.5889909267,
-0.010661738,
0.1087274775,
-0.1014591828,
-0.2759204507,
0.1563997865,
0.2826161087,
0.5324657559,
-0.0138527686,
-0.261657685,
-0.5604825616,
0.5043270588,
0.6327291131,
-0.2001511604,
0.4894044399,
0.3037913144,
-0.3252198994,
0.3484633565,
-0.4030759931,
-0.4322264493,
-0.5031909347,
0.1046134457,
-0.0077499049,
-0.6528481245,
0.5808317661,
0.4393168986,
0.1568771601,
0.13192828,
0.1411849856,
-0.0082704965,
1.3192958832,
0.6845469475,
-0.3540400267,
0.7457633615,
0.0193391088,
0.1225558966,
-0.7552410364,
-0.0444587022,
-0.5795089006,
-0.2508783638,
-0.5580593348,
-0.1526087075,
0.771438539,
-0.0677809641,
-0.2978670299,
0.0416769981,
-0.4533456266,
0.1197747737,
0.5618290901,
-0.0468552411,
0.2491905093,
-0.0858642831,
0.3782563806,
0.2806282043,
-0.7091498971,
-0.8710733056,
0.7242398858,
0.512938261,
0.7989981174,
0.3304501474,
0.7036312222,
0.3775669038,
0.259421587,
-0.7096974254,
0.9458354712,
-0.1065961197,
-0.4027166367,
-0.4221530259,
-0.0935411155,
-0.9006212354,
-0.1186371669,
-0.2784222364,
-0.6955747604,
0.1983809322,
0.3890764117,
-0.7369687557,
-0.2343974411,
-0.9768115282,
0.5385123491,
0.0108775953,
-0.2177177817,
-0.1523104459,
-0.5484517813,
-0.118311815,
0.6256088018,
0.2438961864,
0.1031290069,
-0.163591668,
0.8390485048,
-0.0881713182,
1.0975483656,
-0.6802165508,
-0.015268079,
0.1536998302,
0.1805178374,
0.64312011,
0.0042834557,
-0.4129673243,
-0.1490065306,
0.076256305,
-0.2250371873,
-0.6229088902,
0.5762643218,
-0.8267249465,
-0.9872894287,
-0.4947405756,
-0.3428431749,
-0.3796710074,
0.1410511732,
-0.0051544923,
0.4223836064,
-0.2212598622,
0.4431965649,
0.6679511666,
-0.2573762834,
0.4983606637,
0.1919634342,
-0.0114849191,
-0.0726316273,
0.4169383645,
-0.0139845507,
0.3877466917,
0.0817691758,
0.4032917321,
-0.2494505197,
-0.1434561163,
-0.6763005853,
0.3776677847,
-0.7879544497,
-0.1493450403,
-0.7460483909,
0.0000950439,
-0.6612730026,
-0.1660413295,
0.0878888667,
-0.2368313372,
-0.3849133551,
-0.0432960093,
0.5579348803,
1.0991619825,
-0.0205785818,
0.4443066716,
-0.7477271557,
-0.0611887947,
0.5054118037,
0.1635022014,
0.265609175,
-0.2078344971,
-0.0391923487,
-0.2669349611,
-0.1002090573,
-0.9575153589,
-0.0251793452,
0.1735443175,
1.0200153589,
0.3637898862,
-0.0300515145,
0.5544012785,
-0.3387904167,
1.1737071276,
0.0552852862,
-0.6177793741,
0.1653619409,
-0.5563895106,
0.3573078811,
0.3910996616,
0.1399709135,
-0.7555069923,
-0.4045955241,
-0.3875327706,
-0.6255626678,
1.0593956709,
0.0911523178,
0.2436140925,
-0.0734477267,
0.3182270229,
-0.0663657114,
0.0727519616,
-0.7315599918,
-0.3620505333,
0.2822553813,
0.0665190443,
-0.0686748549,
-0.2747250497,
0.0979149342,
0.1544144154,
0.5869590044,
-0.2651057541,
0.5945696235,
0.288297683,
0.2512724996,
-0.210159108,
0.2504482269,
0.3807348609,
0.3810302019,
0.2831967473,
-0.1381740421,
0.3083655536,
-0.1645372957,
-0.0967854634,
0.0619978271,
0.0869380832,
-0.2183573842,
0.5884749889,
0.582006216,
0.1308898628,
-0.4065426886,
0.4766799212,
-0.202013433,
0.3004954755,
-0.2037140876,
0.6500868797,
0.1333681941,
0.4093605578,
0.4602104425,
-0.1795011014,
0.3276506364,
-0.8244652152,
-0.2850233316,
0.591906786,
-0.1287067831,
-0.2701000273,
0.4131194949,
0.3720500767,
-0.8028392196,
0.3628689349,
0.0098411879,
-0.5117076635,
0.7573560476,
0.4823625088,
0.7923695445,
-0.696682632,
0.4527277052,
0.1782040149,
0.125704363,
-0.1307194531,
0.2653212249,
-0.1671905518,
-0.4074034095,
-0.1077708825,
-0.2105256617,
-0.5486273766,
-0.0871199965,
-0.4098851979,
0.4667165577,
-0.3005089164,
0.0183177702,
0.0138127543,
-0.1162930354,
-0.6532210708,
0.0707057565,
0.1182721853,
0.7157356143,
-0.7003782392,
0.537856698,
0.8783205152,
-0.1792493612,
-1.0481401682,
0.2210218757,
-0.1106574088,
-0.5130069256,
0.5965963006,
0.1100653112,
-0.2847406566,
-0.1963471174,
-0.2801462114,
-0.7013868093,
1.1119377613,
0.5603846908,
-0.3030827343,
-0.4315855503,
-0.0077206045,
0.7533786297,
-0.5619699359,
0.7445589304,
0.0297653433,
0.561549902,
-0.2340422422,
-1.2003384829,
0.1462824494,
-0.3426142037,
0.1033528373,
-0.3641127348,
-0.7071389556,
0.5964900851,
-0.0902023539,
-0.0311186202,
0.4768704474,
0.3973372281,
0.3422249258,
0.461476326,
0.9987385869,
-0.6036319733,
0.7580348849,
0.2059637755,
1.2218157053,
-0.1878909171,
-0.2969296575,
0.7200074792,
-0.2046286613,
0.507956326,
0.4327791035,
-0.039279677,
0.405824542,
0.8032336831,
0.5118439198,
0.2787871957,
-0.0494156517,
-0.0371711217,
-0.3708761036,
-0.2170556039,
-0.3034962416,
0.3350926936,
0.3066434562,
-0.4444021285,
-0.0866302997,
-0.0422456563,
-0.1232083216,
0.007120789,
-0.1576447487,
0.8477371931,
0.2693387568,
-0.9805340767,
0.1850892007,
-0.2867540419,
0.3833668232,
-0.6823914051,
-0.3186076283,
-0.3231272399,
-0.1349240392,
-0.2454250157,
-0.7822387218,
0.0296222512,
0.2099865079,
-0.1890402734,
-0.2426882684,
0.8737435341,
-0.1906846464,
-0.0427401327,
0.4252107143,
0.4476884902,
0.2197197974,
-0.0091686789,
-0.5593982935,
-0.0948690027,
-0.2035945654,
-0.0538183339,
0.2895732224,
0.2597875595,
-0.4726042747,
0.6933330297,
0.709171772,
0.0718163103,
-0.2066793293,
0.1988394856,
0.8319488764,
-0.5396341085,
-0.6387376189,
-0.7847666144,
0.578101635,
-0.2331944406,
-0.3404762149,
0.7781302333,
0.1428809464,
0.2835474312,
0.0171224605,
0.8037798405,
-0.0455746874,
0.2577249408,
-0.268425554,
0.545807898,
-0.4600892961,
0.516626358,
-0.5987622142,
-1.0431050062,
-0.2252431214,
0.4983097017,
-0.5089506507,
0.1449463964,
0.1012118459,
1.0679159164,
-0.0018299455,
0.1873265207,
0.441870749,
-0.0830444545,
0.6110347509,
-0.0364262834,
1.0757638216,
0.0935818776,
0.4531515837,
0.0203084908,
-0.5378635526,
-0.3926565051,
-0.5936125517,
-0.8707337976,
-0.5829280615,
-0.0184711181,
-0.2386167496,
0.1406136453,
1.400474906,
0.6235295534,
-0.3516404033,
-0.588278234,
0.1829440892,
0.1902300566,
-0.2675607204,
-0.1979916096,
0.060528148,
-0.1489117444,
-0.9101691842,
0.5086416006,
0.1578290015,
-0.2497261465,
-0.5385715365,
0.015973324,
-0.0304550882,
0.0588216633,
0.6414608359,
0.1265082359,
-0.6254667044,
-0.4557522833,
0.5865151286,
-0.1133552492,
-0.3014245927,
0.9104569554,
-0.3339131773,
0.4797548056,
0.4653450847,
0.4775179029,
-0.1838812381,
-0.1186718866,
0.9456589222,
-0.4685921073,
-0.2062429339,
-0.0486150347,
0.4622850716,
0.5611973405,
-1.1095489264,
0.3262438476,
-0.175975129,
-0.7992514968,
-0.7498748302,
0.0862000138,
-0.7799454927,
0.1170419455,
1.6119959354,
-0.0846370459,
-0.1308340579,
-0.2318143398,
-0.8097470999,
0.3035857379,
-0.945057869,
0.7454766631,
0.835024178,
-0.5126190186,
-0.2373474836,
-0.4527541399,
0.4402809441,
0.4204134643,
-0.5976782441,
0.1489801854,
0.5698680878,
0.0497443378,
0.2207656056,
0.8471937776,
0.2839837074,
0.5250431299,
-0.5580931902,
-0.2818320394,
-0.0427220911,
-0.4463530779,
-0.5925937891,
-0.2518714964,
0.6602230072,
-0.0580414906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09993v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09993v1
|
Generative AI for Hate Speech Detection: Evaluation and Findings
| 2023-11-16T16:09:43 | 2023-11-16T16:09:43 |
Sagi Pendzel, Tomer Wullach, Amir Adler, Einat Minkov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Automatic hate speech detection using deep neural models is hampered by the
scarcity of labeled datasets, leading to poor generalization. To mitigate this
problem, generative AI has been utilized to generate large amounts of synthetic
hate speech sequences from available labeled examples, leveraging the generated
data in finetuning large pre-trained language models (LLMs). In this chapter,
we provide a review of relevant methods, experimental setups and evaluation of
this approach. In addition to general LLMs, such as BERT, RoBERTa and ALBERT,
we apply and evaluate the impact of train set augmentation with generated data
using LLMs that have been already adapted for hate detection, including
RoBERTa-Toxicity, HateBERT, HateXplain, ToxDect, and ToxiGen. An empirical
study corroborates our previous findings, showing that this approach improves
hate speech generalization, boosting recall performance across data
distributions. In addition, we explore and compare the performance of the
finetuned LLMs with zero-shot hate detection using a GPT-3.5 model. Our results
demonstrate that while better generalization is achieved using the GPT-3.5
model, it achieves mediocre recall and low precision on most datasets. It is an
open question whether the sensitivity of models such as GPT-3.5, and onward,
can be improved using similar techniques of text generation.
|
[
-0.3661881685,
-0.7593407035,
0.3032305539,
-0.0753964782,
0.0254388321,
0.0595491603,
-0.3033409417,
-0.5126126409,
-0.0122525841,
0.35405159,
-0.3345456421,
-0.5263992548,
-0.7323873043,
-0.0103495112,
-0.8268808722,
1.2575128078,
0.2621320188,
0.1185780764,
0.088492848,
-0.1186289489,
-0.4002828896,
-0.6987255216,
-0.8193408251,
-0.4557004869,
0.5875277519,
0.2459375411,
0.6674795747,
0.48671785,
0.410333842,
0.3059328496,
-0.0721314251,
-0.1601656973,
-0.6846485734,
0.269338578,
0.1124182791,
-0.519298315,
-0.1315722018,
0.0324546322,
0.5050701499,
0.2895075977,
0.0126444558,
-0.077533707,
-0.1212434769,
0.2635321021,
-0.4129468203,
-0.275421083,
-0.8343825936,
0.3093161881,
-0.2841477394,
0.1643549502,
-0.2814901471,
-0.4654399157,
0.1133569255,
-0.443453759,
0.6110521555,
-0.0922412574,
0.358171612,
0.376812458,
0.0140590873,
-0.5847844481,
-0.9895109534,
0.811540544,
-0.7359300852,
0.2165223211,
0.368696332,
0.1642071009,
-0.0287667997,
-0.5543916225,
-0.739811182,
-0.7095245719,
0.1710146219,
0.2252341807,
-0.4828354418,
0.2535219789,
0.476372391,
0.7107539177,
-0.66075629,
0.7839312553,
-0.328925401,
-0.1837407947,
0.6090937257,
0.2285132408,
0.3611424267,
-0.109246783,
-0.1152222306,
-0.0764103532,
-0.627795577,
-0.560456574,
0.8451471329,
0.4587196112,
0.0661309808,
0.5502052903,
-0.1551992446,
0.6373407841,
-0.0573890023,
0.1447610557,
0.2602582574,
-0.0811975896,
-0.2777885199,
-0.0318036452,
0.6876085997,
0.2801900208,
0.5647707582,
-0.2256410867,
-0.3066091835,
0.5464605093,
0.399697721,
-0.7399260402,
-0.2281225026,
0.0947279185,
-0.4240159392,
-0.5531840324,
-0.5147438049,
-0.8063254356,
-0.6774631143,
-0.3676775396,
0.410687834,
-0.6024042964,
-0.1956071258,
-0.161552906,
-0.3438544869,
0.0555859804,
0.1992716789,
-0.85617733,
0.2210110873,
0.5109899044,
0.646766901,
-0.3352824748,
-0.0904165804,
-0.4677131176,
-0.057036303,
-0.197318092,
0.5347704887,
-0.4892726243,
-0.2707884908,
0.1573452204,
-0.4679956734,
0.2038768828,
-0.8901426196,
0.7408069372,
-0.4650108218,
0.1596111655,
0.3126765192,
-0.738781631,
-0.0427649431,
0.39273265,
-0.5115504861,
0.796854496,
0.244893074,
-0.4059921801,
0.3098074496,
-0.6863641739,
-0.5722310543,
0.1733414084,
-0.1130593866,
-0.7289155722,
0.1552172154,
0.1532708108,
0.3702783287,
-0.1618558019,
0.0825718492,
-0.3296426535,
-0.3120374084,
0.0736975819,
-0.6538332701,
0.8296509981,
0.4533007443,
-0.4885324836,
0.272424221,
-0.6823727489,
-0.2815359235,
0.3082863986,
-0.154390499,
-0.328595072,
0.0621187203,
0.2010867,
-0.1124719158,
-0.2945178449,
-0.5526833534,
-0.1184174791,
-0.4713230133,
0.2352850735,
0.92099154,
-0.2174369842,
0.0676910803,
-0.3407200277,
0.6273979545,
0.1029200405,
0.1733674854,
0.1249916479,
-0.3159743547,
-0.961464107,
-0.0178985186,
0.25359267,
0.7229673862,
-0.7032786608,
0.2944719493,
0.1037812382,
-0.4123373628,
-0.4393302798,
0.0236657076,
0.4347957075,
0.4063881338,
0.4354637265,
-0.2355416566,
-0.8830293417,
-0.8791145086,
-0.2119816691,
-0.1146700308,
-0.120545879,
0.0961647704,
0.4624005556,
-0.1537148356,
0.5739066005,
-0.3215140998,
-0.2017518431,
-0.2073236704,
0.3521526456,
-0.2032616884,
0.4324641526,
0.6639562845,
-0.7840367556,
-0.433563441,
-0.2997054756,
-0.6217398643,
-0.1042658463,
0.0943936482,
0.3163242638,
0.0871054605,
0.3445896506,
-0.0845969841,
0.6412225962,
0.4334827363,
-0.0294392761,
0.7019248009,
0.3470603824,
0.1692841053,
-0.845497489,
-0.2313719094,
0.1397981495,
-0.2334345877,
-1.1249351501,
-0.0174293965,
-0.5435892344,
-0.2157244235,
-0.5184410214,
0.1654074788,
-0.1370548755,
-0.0668299794,
-0.4677909315,
0.1313790977,
-0.5762007833,
0.2658928037,
-0.057741046,
0.8137452602,
0.1738428771,
-0.6370745301,
0.7379590869,
0.1344065666,
-0.505454421,
0.7105489969,
-0.3822784722,
0.3008636832,
-0.3196537197,
-0.0926072747,
-0.8112323284,
-0.1072358266,
0.4451810122,
-0.5428910851,
0.074217543,
-0.3228981197,
-0.5086701512,
-0.4337540567,
-0.2024971098,
0.423237741,
0.6202895641,
-0.4997091293,
0.096027948,
0.4117615223,
-0.1297532916,
-0.533895731,
-0.6076891422,
0.1331111789,
-0.6625570059,
-0.1018043533,
0.2959863544,
-0.2972750366,
-0.4142817557,
-0.170634985,
0.303034097,
-0.0783986822,
0.1900785267,
0.2782198489,
0.0145676807,
-0.1643316299,
0.3184083998,
-0.3301799297,
0.1307778358,
0.0349195749,
-0.1251451373,
0.6158038378,
-0.0146051291,
-0.1181377023,
-0.2427718639,
0.4106087387,
0.3128034472,
0.2424842566,
0.4723124504,
0.8091303706,
-0.5245129466,
-0.146313116,
-0.592191875,
-0.0192853957,
-0.3800311983,
0.3957941532,
-0.0433317572,
-1.0051521063,
0.3667046428,
0.192695573,
-0.1967867017,
0.4664367437,
0.8113199472,
0.0097880652,
0.9505165219,
0.4202076495,
-0.4790159762,
0.761280477,
-0.0362092257,
0.1611464769,
-0.5941197872,
0.0938972235,
-0.6437258124,
-0.1423474997,
-0.6009868383,
-0.2729724944,
0.3399402201,
-0.0998823345,
-0.3935131729,
0.1080570444,
-0.5979504585,
0.5293107629,
0.550293982,
0.0173197277,
0.2762610316,
0.3421425223,
0.3271013796,
-0.0977285653,
-0.5485741496,
-0.326739192,
1.2187743187,
0.3310129046,
0.5110889077,
0.1444220543,
0.5571206808,
0.6176325679,
0.7667902708,
-0.9209176898,
0.3067483008,
-0.4223774374,
-0.7313222289,
-0.3236886263,
-0.3560158908,
-0.7609621882,
0.1235747263,
-0.1997927725,
-0.5477332473,
-0.1764131188,
0.2582225502,
-0.4310918152,
0.4814778566,
-0.6716662645,
0.5597193241,
-0.2054603994,
-0.0261670668,
-0.2982973754,
-0.2632841766,
0.5344623923,
-0.072561115,
-0.0692925006,
-0.1430555135,
0.339917779,
0.9665237665,
-0.0825439021,
0.9625726938,
-0.350274235,
-0.2502622902,
0.2913119197,
-0.2440131754,
0.3604827523,
-0.448296845,
-0.3418598175,
0.1006873325,
-0.4928601086,
-0.0923105404,
-0.5500169992,
0.5644830465,
-0.6832199693,
-0.553409636,
-0.1059831008,
-0.6828432083,
-0.228712067,
0.1236482188,
0.419881314,
0.349314481,
-0.514308095,
0.0159883182,
0.7123619914,
-0.4140248895,
0.2811724842,
0.268206358,
-0.1658517271,
-0.5247024298,
0.9192833304,
0.1045246869,
0.2267825156,
0.109713912,
0.1095830724,
-0.270380199,
-0.9770820141,
-0.4035171568,
-0.2125689685,
-0.5710082054,
-0.3742268085,
-0.4261015356,
-0.421420306,
-0.6172935963,
-0.0030496139,
-0.0803038031,
-0.3348575234,
-0.4091764987,
-0.1051554531,
0.4256045818,
0.8966693878,
-0.3502551019,
0.7079686522,
-0.1083165407,
0.6453191042,
0.4513826668,
0.3844197989,
0.0910202116,
-0.7482673526,
-0.1389827728,
0.0503484234,
-0.4032881558,
-0.9054164886,
0.4981614351,
-0.0927363709,
0.3801616728,
0.2454258353,
-0.0363011584,
0.5299753547,
-0.4074953794,
0.640712142,
0.2047134787,
-0.7256266475,
0.6773453355,
-0.463570416,
-0.2362512946,
0.3494550884,
0.5103699565,
-0.5631916523,
-0.4847884476,
-0.7321375608,
-0.5418772101,
0.56024158,
0.3591721356,
0.2972423434,
-0.0675057396,
0.2559483051,
0.0642751157,
0.140275225,
-0.8538378477,
-0.5379728079,
-0.3108069003,
-0.3803296685,
-0.222409755,
-0.511690259,
-0.24910146,
-0.3232090771,
0.6055753827,
0.1815094054,
0.3163805902,
-0.0814754665,
-0.2167844325,
0.1814547032,
0.4223942459,
0.7176828384,
0.2510459125,
-0.1627128571,
-0.1168318316,
0.332515955,
-0.3364142179,
0.3303859234,
0.1913062334,
-0.3930130601,
-0.0919743776,
0.1325554699,
0.9879111648,
-0.3581313193,
-0.3949174881,
0.4265623391,
0.1059869975,
-0.2840066254,
-0.5028483272,
0.1608339548,
-0.2778467238,
0.1330427229,
0.1145059168,
-0.2061262578,
0.3520851731,
-0.4245746732,
0.2357365787,
0.5693430901,
-0.4160945117,
-0.0585101433,
0.5442438722,
0.188922137,
-0.4607061744,
0.8268584609,
-0.0356897675,
-0.6568905115,
0.6689537168,
0.7789898515,
0.8771482706,
-0.5344238877,
0.1903813183,
0.3084360957,
0.3857599795,
0.4117175639,
-0.1738412678,
0.0197472908,
-1.0033268929,
-0.2892635465,
-0.6218514442,
-0.4050718546,
0.8224455714,
-0.5500978827,
-0.1151046529,
-0.5557761192,
-0.0463808551,
0.2110303938,
-0.1033674255,
-0.6389503479,
0.3474185467,
0.5399912,
0.5420552492,
-1.0741019249,
0.5177513361,
0.3315981627,
-0.4109271467,
-0.3892078698,
0.0135694295,
0.10730315,
-1.0716569424,
0.5979391932,
0.0870961398,
-0.0319825187,
0.2523471117,
-0.691727221,
-0.3382260203,
0.3800953329,
0.1672187597,
-0.4944406152,
0.3033356965,
0.3924665451,
0.7810989618,
-0.264778465,
0.2162890583,
0.8836104274,
0.3332997859,
0.0608220957,
-0.5044446588,
-0.2183158398,
-0.0537748635,
0.1322060525,
0.0811003894,
-0.357660234,
0.540969193,
-0.0241351929,
-0.1303546727,
0.1842236668,
0.6658653021,
0.0524001867,
0.1785860956,
0.6294007897,
0.9290772676,
0.5731131434,
0.0145467175,
0.9013492465,
0.3075942099,
0.1745865345,
1.1162754297,
-0.1023491025,
0.4284793139,
-0.0106429886,
-0.2309931815,
0.298327744,
0.3297494352,
-0.2876991332,
0.3211558759,
0.7954043746,
-0.6878653765,
-0.0361936837,
-0.336611867,
-0.3303923607,
0.410810858,
0.5547001958,
-0.4026906788,
-0.2963283062,
0.3813551366,
-0.0270257108,
0.1543491483,
-0.515431881,
0.8655324578,
-0.1282207817,
-0.4650900066,
0.6027502418,
0.01998524,
0.857770741,
-0.1574277729,
-0.0289348681,
-0.1641752869,
0.2547994852,
-0.1344411671,
-0.7684316635,
0.5466237664,
0.4768124223,
-0.3941839039,
-0.1989797503,
0.7345975637,
-0.4804540575,
-0.266967088,
0.1851577461,
0.0227122232,
0.3390565813,
-0.1323641092,
-0.7946135402,
0.3090069294,
0.1096984744,
0.0433927216,
0.2393183708,
-0.0132429572,
0.0256688409,
0.4031400084,
0.6300881505,
0.2318557501,
0.2239030153,
0.4333623946,
0.7101914883,
-0.6247226596,
-0.0794127733,
-0.916975379,
0.1336274147,
-0.0475007817,
-0.1899508089,
0.7019897699,
0.5931685567,
1.1320222616,
-0.0610531829,
1.1308813095,
-0.1070756391,
0.7580612898,
-0.4365697801,
0.4917948246,
-0.170804292,
-0.0677798539,
-0.3469008505,
-0.6739449501,
-0.5923674703,
0.703750968,
-0.5522251129,
0.2086531669,
0.2869660258,
0.9722251296,
-0.0297161974,
0.0696828291,
0.5978147984,
0.318148613,
0.4129257202,
0.5171433687,
1.1779694557,
-0.6060507298,
0.5860860348,
-0.2022780031,
-0.1544946283,
-0.0855961666,
-0.6521209478,
-0.6783006787,
-0.3945069015,
-0.3528678715,
-0.3853409588,
0.3005979955,
0.4883300066,
0.6603397131,
-0.9097081423,
-0.2045966387,
-0.2043183595,
0.2094580531,
0.118395932,
-0.2589890957,
0.0022018848,
-0.4554961324,
-0.9750500321,
0.5768427849,
-0.0370361097,
0.3535446227,
-0.0240799822,
-0.055348292,
-0.066336073,
-0.1891389191,
0.7535475492,
0.4204299748,
-0.7440444231,
-0.350669533,
-0.7759944797,
0.083691597,
0.0502155423,
0.8133192658,
-0.7064394951,
0.2132197469,
0.1716690958,
0.6931615472,
0.4581978023,
0.0408244357,
0.4638874531,
-0.7320301533,
0.1981884986,
0.6194229126,
0.0313391685,
0.3851367235,
-0.1877735704,
0.4947343469,
0.3642994761,
-0.5490913987,
-0.8804627657,
0.5388376117,
-0.52432096,
-0.0756613165,
0.9834522605,
0.1755340248,
0.176057741,
-0.2296874523,
-0.0614132099,
0.417637676,
-0.1383076906,
0.6846078634,
0.6301167607,
-0.0581237487,
-0.1771539003,
-0.4784086645,
0.7005773187,
0.5902155638,
-0.8183737993,
0.1893298924,
0.8109619617,
0.2867633402,
0.0806931853,
0.571914494,
-0.0044819745,
0.074328281,
-0.0165663064,
0.22371687,
0.051529713,
-0.2701512575,
-0.722227633,
0.1702130884,
-0.0237701796,
-0.2266641855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10784v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10784v1
|
ExFake: Towards an Explainable Fake News Detection Based on Content and Social Context Information
| 2023-11-16T15:57:58 | 2023-11-16T15:57:58 |
Sabrine Amri, Henri-Cedric Mputu Boleilanga, Esma Aïmeur
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
ExFake is an explainable fake news detection system based on content and
context-level information. It is concerned with the veracity analysis of online
posts based on their content, social context (i.e., online users' credibility
and historical behaviour), and data coming from trusted entities such as
fact-checking websites and named entities. Unlike state-of-the-art systems, an
Explainable AI (XAI) assistant is also adopted to help online social networks
(OSN) users develop good reflexes when faced with any doubted information that
spreads on social networks. The trustworthiness of OSN users is also addressed
by assigning a credibility score to OSN users, as OSN users are one of the main
culprits for spreading fake news. Experimental analysis on a real-world dataset
demonstrates that ExFake significantly outperforms other baseline methods for
fake news detection.
|
[
-0.4405331314,
-1.1918225288,
0.4853109419,
-0.116351977,
-0.2478559911,
0.1154364422,
0.3682779372,
-0.6237035394,
0.6970980763,
0.1662472486,
-0.743272841,
-0.1274804175,
-0.5083150864,
-0.2609050274,
-0.8375898004,
1.0061151981,
-0.0384966917,
-0.3508864045,
0.0909743011,
-0.3070960641,
-0.0717418417,
-0.2102842778,
-1.1928793192,
-0.0615390241,
0.2313362509,
0.3862710595,
1.0821880102,
0.6457172632,
-0.0973039269,
0.2311721444,
0.2032214552,
0.0302062891,
-0.4956252575,
-0.0117727099,
-0.4659555554,
-0.5508947372,
-0.1279348731,
0.0410331711,
0.2879940867,
0.2995606661,
0.0432984643,
-0.0489502102,
-0.2529292703,
0.3308914006,
-0.5181512833,
-0.0836845487,
-0.3519939482,
0.0866859183,
-0.1376281381,
-0.3967424333,
-0.2537964582,
-0.2520790696,
-0.0306222346,
-0.8533857465,
0.4060618877,
0.3142460883,
0.9031713009,
-0.0167742502,
-0.703450799,
-0.5917583704,
-0.422732085,
0.2195008993,
-0.5941363573,
0.1762693375,
0.3038083315,
0.6788490415,
-0.3730288446,
-0.5582768917,
-1.0948438644,
0.0728703886,
-0.1175474152,
0.1249529123,
-0.0635800138,
-0.1763011366,
0.2683815658,
0.6112253666,
-0.7650390863,
-0.2159781307,
0.2467327267,
-0.1991290152,
0.5018461347,
-0.1282135695,
0.60962677,
-0.2526711822,
-0.4887334704,
-0.0387877524,
-0.5653902292,
0.368286103,
0.7191604972,
-0.0303846337,
-0.2944256365,
0.2575987577,
-0.6141728163,
0.5427316427,
0.1750687659,
-0.1415727884,
0.2446746826,
-0.3079518974,
-0.3435612917,
0.2306910306,
0.5902176499,
0.2590301633,
-0.1067655757,
0.1677671671,
-0.0382935666,
0.14154239,
-0.041676119,
-0.3982995749,
-0.0815883651,
0.388954401,
-0.4679790437,
-0.7391827106,
0.3493825793,
-0.4630966187,
-0.450475961,
-0.1201050133,
0.9724839926,
-0.4890129864,
-0.7090011835,
-0.3618813753,
-0.4359622002,
0.1113273576,
0.483728677,
-0.4483971596,
0.2676417232,
0.6835267544,
1.0430977345,
-0.1366244555,
-0.1082907319,
-0.8970480561,
0.2221962959,
-0.4069877267,
0.8055139184,
-0.5602064729,
0.1666416824,
0.0149892513,
0.4177971184,
0.336740613,
-0.1249559149,
0.421497792,
-0.7986104488,
-0.0163926892,
-0.5257080793,
-0.6840717196,
-0.4846505523,
0.1626184285,
-1.0736886263,
0.9794635177,
0.2613083422,
-0.5961263776,
0.8687338829,
-0.8405790925,
-0.7913736105,
0.0258025955,
0.0587659031,
-0.1293786913,
0.3331710696,
0.0849834904,
0.5731822252,
0.2471899092,
0.2584027052,
-0.1908748448,
-0.4693864584,
0.2967941761,
-0.4248153567,
1.0000324249,
0.3609351218,
-1.0010658503,
0.3002240062,
-0.6584460139,
-0.1270204931,
0.1049983427,
0.0806980357,
-0.5955564976,
-0.1855318844,
-0.1055074483,
0.4803257287,
-0.3271840513,
-0.6331210136,
-0.3074478209,
-0.3254850805,
0.3341569304,
0.8442006111,
0.1580081135,
0.1463240236,
-0.552951932,
0.2702112496,
0.0094304485,
0.307151258,
-0.5984115005,
-0.6468849778,
-0.5411143303,
-0.0675767958,
-0.0285553224,
0.2340790033,
-1.2177791595,
0.0738612711,
-0.0538219921,
-0.1549372822,
-0.2033728659,
0.1162569597,
0.3450186551,
0.6417256594,
0.0634000525,
0.0359524637,
-0.2701181471,
-0.8798138499,
-0.6380844712,
-0.197952345,
0.4594660401,
-0.1259950995,
0.684519887,
0.0836112797,
0.802131474,
0.0719209239,
-0.1872252524,
-0.0985551327,
0.3222275972,
0.0409459732,
0.3120982349,
0.3061750531,
-1.573830843,
-0.8588393927,
0.1030546054,
-0.8084309697,
-0.0341914855,
-0.439442277,
-0.2068663985,
0.7578400373,
0.544156611,
-0.383884728,
0.7855154872,
0.612511456,
-0.7042573094,
0.6147382855,
0.0531656258,
0.796934545,
-1.0979604721,
0.080520995,
-0.1612568349,
-0.9448385835,
-0.7023385763,
0.4722340405,
-0.0449312329,
-0.1001585573,
-0.6061504483,
0.599683404,
-0.3509435952,
-0.1770745516,
-0.6004661322,
0.1349409819,
0.1485411674,
0.3463197649,
0.0448341519,
0.4628600776,
0.4057723284,
-0.457069546,
0.4167771339,
-0.2581688762,
-0.5055043101,
0.806343019,
-0.4445415437,
-0.0073734391,
0.0942697898,
0.3398418725,
-1.3584220409,
-0.8101481795,
0.4223894477,
-0.8122461438,
0.0262139607,
0.0449542329,
-0.7791942358,
-0.0955649167,
-0.2746067941,
0.042896267,
0.2280777991,
-0.9183433652,
0.6772440076,
0.3847490847,
0.0128071001,
-0.4795793295,
-0.544444859,
0.1943669915,
-0.0090784421,
-0.8257027268,
0.3008209169,
-0.1653547138,
-0.3218658268,
0.6078392863,
-0.2444615662,
-0.1186683029,
0.1131102815,
0.5847659707,
-0.1460757405,
-0.1995651722,
0.0718370155,
0.5423998237,
-0.2218462974,
-0.04855996,
0.1626365483,
0.415425092,
-0.0434187911,
-0.4843603373,
-0.7977399826,
0.7146263719,
0.6517428756,
0.3964425623,
1.1604117155,
0.5020108223,
-0.6725751162,
-0.3991400003,
-0.4417452812,
-0.0479319058,
-0.4681545198,
-0.0637141094,
-0.3865670264,
-0.8713003397,
0.5134367943,
0.057621967,
0.0147053674,
0.3892112672,
0.4346485138,
0.1229052916,
1.2146308422,
0.6624053717,
0.0866841152,
0.1927155256,
0.1847455204,
0.0785356238,
-0.1305146664,
-0.1647622734,
0.2151901424,
-0.1887169629,
-0.0196784437,
-0.1928446889,
0.0380778201,
-0.1725685894,
-0.0340424851,
0.3888878226,
-0.1573150158,
0.5300862789,
0.5874905586,
0.2066019028,
0.5777087808,
0.0820854008,
-0.0105805304,
0.4670663774,
-0.4405884445,
-0.2821526229,
0.7226933241,
0.2305801213,
0.4867686927,
0.4748618305,
0.2175788879,
0.9284803867,
0.3700738847,
-0.6174245477,
0.3102093935,
0.2212719619,
-1.3167476654,
-0.4246569872,
-0.357616812,
-0.4271151721,
-0.0172937345,
-0.2707667649,
-0.3238687217,
0.0327206366,
0.4885208607,
-0.617667377,
0.4722433388,
-0.7594316006,
0.5395793915,
-0.2677314281,
-0.4495364428,
-0.2541342974,
-0.7582717538,
0.3916326761,
-0.407648623,
0.5696499348,
-0.0036286262,
-0.0784331113,
0.7591395378,
-0.6341606379,
0.7971194386,
-0.4293117821,
0.0750458762,
0.3637158871,
0.2670289278,
0.6663246155,
0.2078727335,
-0.1215276122,
0.0859591439,
0.1584873199,
-0.2819533348,
-0.8141191602,
1.0226941109,
-0.5450374484,
-0.5095937252,
-0.4144586623,
-0.5361337662,
0.0340299271,
0.3429656625,
0.5224488378,
0.4025711715,
-0.1947322488,
0.0965935737,
0.646694541,
-0.2928166091,
0.2077310979,
0.7481095791,
-0.3524358273,
-0.0281691272,
0.900408268,
0.3929440379,
0.219348684,
0.3650928438,
0.2200225592,
-0.1920776516,
0.0439615063,
-0.4588313699,
-0.1845657825,
-0.8396542668,
-0.0301543083,
-0.7417761087,
-0.066201739,
-0.5914314389,
-0.4129744172,
-0.3140013218,
-0.4401255548,
0.1527108997,
-0.2748190463,
0.3614377081,
0.8206080198,
-0.4105540514,
0.7520948052,
-0.0943495035,
0.8115895391,
0.186422646,
0.3044684529,
-0.1948630363,
-0.5511613488,
-0.2729856968,
0.116828613,
0.2064476162,
-1.2235075235,
0.2216862738,
0.2951711714,
0.7840663195,
1.0816445351,
0.3247965574,
0.4705866873,
0.0599075817,
0.6379665136,
0.1811539829,
-1.250445962,
0.7705506682,
-0.2699125409,
-0.1227783486,
0.5070764422,
0.8363511562,
-0.5955088735,
-0.229357332,
-0.7174925804,
-0.804100275,
0.806080699,
0.2601084709,
0.0746876746,
-0.1004632935,
0.5558046699,
0.8299770951,
0.2170585245,
-0.752695024,
-0.3327509463,
-0.3209043741,
-0.0815496668,
0.0881641582,
-0.1238654852,
-0.1765877604,
-0.00921294,
1.0506211519,
-0.270753324,
0.4495677054,
0.2492951751,
-0.5353027582,
-0.38859424,
-0.2493721694,
0.4489785731,
0.7514601946,
-0.0595377572,
0.4030026495,
-0.0800178573,
-0.2776137292,
0.4172863662,
-0.1586476564,
-0.0403016135,
0.1411121935,
0.3554412723,
0.5928575397,
0.0464969985,
-0.5130419731,
0.9501315951,
-0.0954317749,
-0.0506343506,
-0.7777031064,
0.4543344378,
-0.1194890738,
0.0979966521,
0.7074818611,
0.1598852575,
0.3669755161,
-1.0323132277,
0.4520858228,
0.282012403,
-0.6581608057,
-0.4845190346,
0.5671684742,
0.0824862644,
-0.1877461672,
0.1257366091,
-0.2384332716,
-0.4636369348,
0.710414052,
0.6425821781,
0.3769757152,
-0.4691257477,
0.6511369348,
0.0824826732,
0.4428918362,
-0.0933967605,
0.2111445367,
-0.036853563,
-0.7750166059,
-0.5384690166,
-0.2532509267,
-0.3072920442,
0.4248921275,
-0.7306454182,
0.3480781019,
-0.6269624233,
0.0528528467,
0.0763372332,
-0.1590977609,
-0.4087583125,
0.5367969275,
0.0634682104,
1.3030648232,
-1.2573179007,
0.5565783381,
0.6061725616,
-0.185771957,
-0.523435533,
0.0852668211,
0.710087955,
-0.8477857709,
0.3687471747,
0.5385234356,
-0.2103935331,
-0.0262931604,
-0.7858188748,
-0.8552753329,
0.8642074466,
0.3561875522,
-0.2627302408,
0.2420013845,
-0.0298155993,
0.1846545339,
-0.4558193088,
0.2460960746,
0.3230878711,
0.51841712,
0.0026561408,
-0.3456345499,
0.5633369684,
-0.7913621068,
-0.4944095314,
0.0579176992,
-0.7265540957,
0.6619521976,
-0.0961723551,
-0.4577457905,
-0.1406810284,
0.6554268599,
-0.1058871597,
0.9011590481,
0.7999258637,
0.5136877298,
0.8075923324,
0.0586833097,
1.2896814346,
-0.1596782506,
-0.0039941715,
1.1942174435,
-0.1301862299,
0.6208667159,
0.4356830716,
0.3155818284,
0.9304460883,
0.7362024784,
0.2922467589,
0.4893136024,
-0.4324567318,
-0.2906445563,
-0.2744301856,
0.0418501385,
-0.3423856497,
0.2974714637,
0.4313248396,
-0.604141593,
0.0161599591,
0.5200882554,
0.3682880402,
-0.3290805519,
-0.2696764767,
0.5102244616,
-0.2102136016,
-0.6382380724,
-0.0642868876,
-0.0765562505,
0.3106812537,
-0.7778399587,
-0.2157793194,
-0.0735001117,
-0.0061852671,
-0.5230223536,
-0.932353735,
0.5844330788,
-0.3587964475,
-0.2930649817,
0.244923532,
0.948880434,
0.0732926801,
-0.0322525278,
0.4014867842,
0.4345444441,
0.2653816342,
-0.5566042662,
-0.6837264895,
0.1823188961,
-0.1787774265,
-0.5440968275,
0.2184310257,
0.4822157323,
-0.2476376593,
0.7145358324,
1.1498320103,
-0.2353228927,
-0.0561165139,
-0.3362570405,
0.8434861302,
-0.5783758759,
-1.0059796572,
-0.7020093799,
0.4366840422,
-0.5010764599,
-0.199125737,
1.0819247961,
0.558131516,
0.6758287549,
0.1904763728,
1.0473285913,
-0.5382000208,
0.5432391167,
-0.3386151791,
1.1292042732,
-0.7842030525,
0.055129163,
-0.4004041553,
-0.6860495806,
-0.1011672318,
0.5333234668,
0.0572272502,
0.1883733422,
0.7129135728,
0.9073368311,
-0.2261061221,
0.3161138892,
0.6311326027,
0.2561895251,
0.1715209484,
0.2304142267,
0.8351719975,
-0.3812590241,
0.5635762811,
-0.3248963356,
-0.7935165763,
-0.5110297203,
-0.9244561791,
-0.8857137561,
-0.7223329544,
-0.5273925066,
-0.4367778301,
0.2070048451,
0.7015098929,
1.1673419476,
-0.8980599046,
0.4222535193,
-0.1815843731,
0.142617926,
-0.4263600707,
-0.3789014518,
0.3882497847,
0.1094141826,
-0.3785938323,
0.4186892807,
0.3074432611,
-0.2801350057,
-0.2520543337,
-0.2154675871,
-0.4480993748,
0.5311514139,
0.6824505925,
0.4862903059,
-0.39030388,
-0.4116237164,
-0.0693099052,
0.2377358228,
-0.2672862113,
0.7315480709,
-0.9123054743,
0.5519958138,
0.6044596434,
0.2948951125,
0.2251302004,
-0.0471431911,
0.3911541998,
-0.4833652973,
-0.0630414709,
-0.4991210997,
0.1879732907,
0.3041443527,
-1.033292532,
0.4837400317,
0.484839797,
-0.2388180047,
-0.7674358487,
0.1321666986,
-0.7607570887,
-0.6016253829,
1.0707957745,
-0.3316856921,
-0.6560766697,
-0.8681995273,
-0.0503696837,
0.4085766673,
-0.5763104558,
0.5171332359,
0.4660576582,
-0.3519466221,
-0.2677291334,
-0.7120015621,
0.5108251572,
0.219509989,
-0.8264179826,
-0.3290028274,
0.2386257201,
0.553416729,
0.2483496964,
0.6291216612,
-0.130910024,
0.7047838569,
0.1467639655,
-0.3852047324,
-0.4477103055,
-0.4472758472,
-0.0841582268,
0.5058291554,
-0.6285284162,
0.2934972048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09979v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09979v1
|
Unambiguity and Fewness for Nonuniform Families of Polynomial-Size Nondeterministic Finite Automata
| 2023-11-16T15:52:24 | 2023-11-16T15:52:24 |
Tomoyuki Yamakami
|
cs.FL
|
cs.FL, cs.CC, cs.CL
|
Nonuniform families of polynomial-size finite automata, which are series of
indexed finite automata having polynomially many inner states, are used in the
past literature to solve nonuniform families of promise decision problems.
Among such nonuniform families of finite automata, we focus our attention, in
particular, on the variants of nondeterministic finite automata, which have at
most "one" (unambiguous), "polynomially many" (few) accepting computation
paths, or unambiguous/few computation paths leading to each fixed
configuration. When such machines are limited to make only one-way head moves,
we can prove with no unproven hardness assumptions that some of these variants
are different in computational power from each other. As for two-way machines
restricted to instances of polynomially-bounded length, families of two-way
polynomial-size nondeterministic finite automata are equivalent in power to
families of polynomial-size unambiguous finite automata.
|
[
-0.3204190433,
-0.1544952393,
0.9268672466,
0.3472797573,
-0.3399211168,
0.2899873257,
0.0238781776,
-0.4191727042,
0.3462433517,
0.3408347964,
-0.619194746,
0.154226467,
-0.6422660351,
0.4941857457,
-0.6345223784,
0.664899826,
-0.068526715,
-0.2560255826,
-0.3063976169,
-0.5817248821,
0.2456035912,
-0.3254063129,
0.0876983032,
-0.5872368813,
0.1831877381,
0.4042881131,
1.2655556202,
0.8524757624,
0.4524149597,
0.276499778,
0.159353599,
-0.0936034471,
-0.2887749374,
0.1481993794,
-0.0685190111,
-0.3600170612,
-0.1888642162,
-0.0572624728,
0.937163651,
1.228674531,
0.2826671898,
0.2358081043,
0.1606834084,
0.884082377,
-0.4504840076,
-0.1536015868,
-0.3291181922,
0.2900367975,
-0.3547899425,
-0.209296912,
-0.3787994385,
-0.5373024344,
-0.0835515782,
-0.5838971138,
0.0620931908,
0.0064311787,
0.5526381135,
0.7995963097,
-0.4059770405,
0.1533596069,
-0.986872375,
0.9398623705,
-0.8576975465,
0.2163763195,
0.4730926454,
0.3989416361,
-0.5978671908,
-0.5213406086,
-0.3970218897,
0.0750233531,
-0.3247749805,
-0.2122761309,
-0.697726965,
0.4785443544,
0.5213984847,
0.3841643631,
-0.768268466,
0.2416553497,
-0.1721805334,
0.3792851865,
0.7431870103,
0.1212818399,
0.0158692971,
-0.0632649362,
-0.3296687603,
0.2004008442,
-0.6295330524,
-0.2684519887,
0.3944418728,
0.1564162523,
-0.3303967714,
0.4666235745,
-0.6663820744,
0.6476485729,
0.3348363638,
-0.4864041209,
0.0197430886,
-0.3832190335,
-0.2875823379,
-0.1881688088,
0.6306557655,
0.0471030809,
0.2094235569,
-0.8190845251,
-0.0887791663,
-0.0376233533,
-0.1478097588,
-0.7814764977,
-0.3108512163,
0.1621274352,
-1.0077497959,
0.0297229905,
0.2742018402,
-0.7492294312,
-0.3536767662,
0.131731078,
0.5835025311,
-0.0845539793,
-0.3128420711,
-0.1616727561,
-0.1738691181,
0.3890994489,
-0.0353441648,
-1.0111545324,
0.7298750877,
0.5465738177,
0.9831475616,
0.0939671248,
-0.2504134774,
-0.164304927,
-0.2130423635,
-0.5097667575,
0.8762072921,
-0.2875019014,
-0.4590493441,
-0.338239342,
-0.2248147577,
-0.3981188834,
-0.4598574936,
-0.1685102433,
-0.2583533525,
-0.2680680752,
-0.0627276078,
-0.4534073174,
-0.56075418,
-0.2480047494,
-0.4967445433,
0.5351183414,
0.5991370082,
-0.3390056491,
0.273758173,
-0.5201680064,
-0.7987588048,
0.0503464192,
-0.3059850335,
-0.4806642234,
0.5118991137,
-0.6131462455,
0.1209464073,
-0.4076507688,
-0.1857952029,
-0.6114243865,
-0.1876232773,
0.1331959367,
-0.532910645,
0.9695654511,
0.2103275061,
-0.5856704712,
0.1643559337,
-0.7460778356,
0.4267891943,
0.1055655926,
0.0340554416,
-0.0740215778,
0.1072071195,
-0.2876683474,
0.6716462374,
0.5562480688,
-0.4125956297,
0.5559203029,
-0.4524878263,
0.6599452496,
0.6226251721,
0.1958659291,
0.5545030832,
-0.8613366485,
0.7278215885,
-0.2121603638,
0.610640049,
0.3084739745,
-0.6895729303,
-0.8324115276,
-0.2745440602,
0.4363427758,
0.3933210969,
-0.6222962737,
0.1033602878,
0.131868273,
-0.612654984,
-0.1378124952,
-0.017425593,
0.4719624817,
-0.2093583196,
0.1638144851,
-0.1372697055,
-0.6474971175,
-1.0012480021,
0.1079623923,
-0.3332361579,
0.1616942137,
0.0418155901,
0.7521189451,
-0.0846576542,
0.9740666151,
-0.2255457789,
-0.0541613065,
0.1473465562,
0.3201674223,
0.2382103503,
0.4206081927,
0.6412677169,
-0.3778880537,
-0.6263632774,
-0.1919226348,
-0.7579331398,
0.3168963194,
-0.1995335221,
0.0502228178,
0.4294640124,
-0.1718616486,
-0.5182195902,
0.6735312343,
0.5226501226,
-0.3079188764,
0.1147184819,
-0.3090654612,
0.0175823513,
-0.7300040126,
-0.1479136497,
-0.5281989574,
-0.3037350178,
-0.7369474769,
-0.0501247905,
-0.2917914689,
0.4914411902,
-0.3424625397,
0.1185033396,
-0.4564163089,
-0.7315706015,
-0.3563770354,
-0.2499138415,
-0.345084548,
0.5401699543,
-0.3098663986,
0.81442523,
0.6543497443,
-0.8569254279,
0.0117866807,
0.2656654119,
0.1324841678,
0.6082494259,
-0.2949824035,
0.5191395283,
-0.1216787621,
-0.0147785302,
-0.7575964332,
-0.0878669173,
-0.1229765266,
-0.4316481948,
-0.2636632025,
-0.1891787648,
-0.8515433073,
-0.0548037179,
-0.4447772503,
0.6489886642,
0.6323087215,
-0.7322335243,
0.4542970955,
0.2129624188,
0.3508244157,
-0.3113437891,
-0.5105372071,
-0.2580007613,
-0.1390811056,
-0.6948587298,
0.3583318889,
-0.1922360659,
-0.622315526,
0.1461660713,
0.1092762724,
-0.5514902472,
0.2953140438,
0.6209412813,
0.1541235745,
-0.1094394848,
0.0621715672,
0.1582904309,
-0.141166985,
-0.1066160053,
-0.2381496727,
0.4867708087,
-0.0401590541,
-0.026193602,
-0.1687744409,
0.750182271,
0.8014677167,
0.0632697195,
0.5169969201,
-0.1135563925,
-0.9188245535,
-0.0127954669,
-0.005517683,
-0.2258787155,
-0.4215538502,
-0.2918592691,
-0.5397881269,
-0.9552503824,
0.6235511899,
0.0991805121,
0.3390312493,
0.8094420433,
0.3364617527,
0.2593515515,
1.1001527309,
0.7102831006,
0.1640625596,
-0.2000044137,
-0.0817903057,
0.1328649819,
-0.5144506097,
0.0924970657,
-0.7588221431,
-0.3381610513,
-1.1587402821,
-0.2669144869,
0.2641696632,
0.1758992821,
-0.5211965442,
0.6285210848,
-0.4755936563,
0.5113087893,
0.4984589219,
-0.4077192545,
0.6159495711,
-0.3543907106,
-0.0153509844,
0.1845514029,
-0.9362673163,
-0.4350440502,
1.0651659966,
0.0557797849,
0.6382888556,
0.5737482309,
0.8254845142,
-0.1166956872,
-0.0388744026,
-0.9269564152,
0.2867283225,
-0.5756670237,
-0.6580459476,
-0.2712992728,
-0.6346321106,
-1.0324425697,
-0.0312780291,
-0.3352739811,
-0.8627085686,
0.61300385,
0.0792755336,
-0.929926157,
0.6117791533,
-0.068236202,
0.5969145298,
-0.2042814791,
0.082046397,
-0.209464699,
-0.7454545498,
0.3082199693,
-0.1368740797,
-0.2011242211,
-0.0800353885,
0.0091733839,
0.7195463777,
-0.4504035711,
0.4573863745,
-0.0121603422,
0.4262387156,
0.3147501349,
0.2971998453,
0.3659069836,
0.0253714174,
0.0714959949,
0.5324290395,
0.3321754336,
-0.3107199967,
-0.4761273861,
0.6119604707,
-0.7433991432,
-0.3836612999,
-0.6355512142,
-0.4626477063,
-0.3398163319,
0.4485425055,
0.5757505298,
0.2766873837,
0.0726160184,
0.278821677,
0.6389687657,
0.4031650722,
0.9388154149,
0.4298166931,
-0.0147402054,
-0.1574242413,
0.6803178191,
0.7371538877,
0.3804266751,
0.3257547617,
-0.0149554731,
-0.4088093936,
-0.5568315983,
-0.4689662457,
0.2279756665,
-0.3032875657,
-0.3218649626,
-0.2815399766,
-0.2438257486,
-0.3649995625,
-0.1839303374,
-0.4820049405,
-1.1170896292,
-0.3522401452,
0.3400711119,
0.6761549711,
1.2331908941,
-0.3595667183,
0.3253031075,
-0.2479264587,
0.3061218858,
0.4214121103,
0.6298858523,
-0.1613697857,
-0.4476642013,
0.2186857611,
-0.4485314488,
-0.3489630222,
-0.9148245454,
-0.0551082231,
0.1532333046,
0.4048995674,
0.5632620454,
0.4080506563,
0.5869615078,
-0.4917780757,
0.3038184345,
0.1890266985,
-0.8761788011,
-0.2054588348,
-0.1960165054,
0.2860679924,
0.9023362398,
0.2913888097,
-0.4227747321,
0.0045283725,
-0.9179517627,
-0.3331910372,
0.2281895727,
0.4034089148,
-0.1730859131,
0.2459370792,
0.489379108,
0.1684977114,
0.3571694791,
-0.2332291156,
-0.7636333108,
-0.4985454082,
0.0031142891,
0.121687673,
-0.0735264495,
0.1068174392,
0.1578117311,
0.6810148954,
-0.2182433307,
0.5602651238,
0.2857872844,
0.311085403,
-0.4240096509,
0.354535073,
0.6661326885,
1.0515979528,
-0.0979827866,
0.2830600739,
0.0316331051,
-0.051139459,
0.5478588343,
0.1894016266,
-0.3427546918,
0.0012584575,
0.0367128216,
0.6379233003,
-0.0111541562,
-0.228783384,
0.1014124751,
-0.020738991,
-0.5392978191,
-0.5364878178,
0.0010599884,
-0.2588745952,
0.3139422834,
0.3775137961,
0.1249600127,
0.3672764897,
-0.4832060039,
0.3242270648,
0.7768319249,
-0.3368382156,
-0.1222360358,
0.4907465279,
-0.1436411291,
-0.4879718125,
0.4696479142,
-0.7089747787,
-0.4047764838,
0.4955258965,
0.5356512666,
0.946772635,
0.0173411332,
0.21770145,
0.2165102512,
0.6529892087,
-0.2571111619,
0.0153796813,
-0.0565611087,
-0.4203819335,
-0.3134949803,
-0.4894324243,
-0.7040324807,
0.0047197528,
-0.3695240021,
-0.2201332748,
-1.2259888649,
-0.2562471628,
0.0147744101,
0.0079080546,
-0.0859681293,
-0.1518736482,
-0.2934376001,
0.6439155936,
-0.6222814918,
0.588980794,
0.5176526904,
-0.3511770368,
-0.8626204133,
0.0407815613,
0.0088825235,
-0.2650659382,
0.1353933215,
0.0253048856,
-0.4418007135,
0.0351250321,
-0.2557215095,
-1.0571284294,
0.9849231243,
0.4865274131,
-0.2408989966,
-0.1142057404,
0.3740559518,
0.218840003,
-0.149710834,
-0.1031254977,
0.5655627847,
0.6663663387,
-0.0925266519,
-1.2751657963,
0.0380556323,
0.0188368075,
0.0608388856,
0.7370190024,
-1.0997252464,
1.2117424011,
-0.1079261154,
-0.4953199029,
0.6891413927,
0.5424848795,
0.0605596155,
0.1485193372,
0.5628593564,
0.5625674725,
0.6724382639,
-0.0782503113,
0.968323648,
-0.4571233392,
0.6067587733,
0.8547911644,
-0.2189283073,
0.43691203,
0.5150393248,
-0.5533910394,
0.3922725022,
0.5133659244,
0.2061500847,
0.1022761762,
0.1049237549,
-0.3958622515,
-0.4874746501,
0.0771790147,
-0.1080059037,
0.6099615693,
-0.1680239141,
-0.2389207482,
-0.4739371538,
-0.2621851861,
0.2091088146,
0.1949104071,
-0.4046658576,
0.5134292841,
0.1707392335,
-0.5242809653,
0.7295715809,
0.2736338675,
0.5974441171,
-0.3524523675,
-0.3414198756,
0.0760041848,
-0.0793204308,
-0.7401842475,
-0.5155805945,
0.4822329879,
-0.0791305378,
-0.5846615434,
0.1862210631,
0.4491980374,
0.1915405244,
-0.3525836468,
0.0853432044,
0.2624800801,
0.3235123754,
-0.0392562672,
-0.4609479606,
-0.4559170604,
-0.2140697241,
0.3544928432,
0.3250204623,
-0.1680026352,
-0.270755738,
0.41654706,
0.2344320267,
-0.2888092101,
0.4460426867,
-0.4077928066,
0.2902359664,
-0.417552948,
-0.4807422757,
-0.8337903023,
-0.0925055593,
0.4537551403,
-0.5193371177,
0.7413083911,
0.5331404209,
0.5381074548,
0.1919277161,
0.6486264467,
-0.239557147,
0.4003479183,
-0.3329098523,
0.6059271693,
-0.3911022246,
-0.5190799236,
0.0062839356,
-0.8933404684,
-0.4603553712,
0.9269793034,
-0.0963594392,
0.0829123408,
0.7860231996,
0.374409765,
0.1241041645,
0.252809912,
0.6470966935,
0.2985910177,
-0.2616715133,
0.9781882167,
0.3617969751,
-0.3259970546,
0.1693003029,
-0.6957640648,
-0.5124611259,
-0.0490650237,
-0.6204368472,
-0.4969717264,
-0.5175497532,
-0.3474776149,
-0.2116501629,
0.0224704109,
0.856061995,
0.8329943419,
-0.6184076667,
-0.2934308648,
-0.2559891641,
0.4429923296,
-0.5466377139,
-0.1682851911,
0.1317468584,
-0.0020676167,
-0.4268974364,
0.5558981895,
0.5885182023,
0.4279554188,
-0.5663563013,
-0.0625337586,
-0.1202304885,
0.5166358352,
0.4426656663,
0.8538683057,
-0.2077674419,
-0.3756757379,
0.0180994198,
0.1252088994,
0.1886370629,
0.530836761,
-0.745392859,
0.1072960123,
0.4873290658,
0.2789922357,
0.2238498181,
-0.1908523589,
-0.0083485562,
-0.2131858021,
0.1321057975,
0.2393525392,
0.4000824094,
0.0172520094,
-0.4647802413,
0.6113699675,
0.1312448382,
-0.7870177031,
-0.4617326558,
0.8120025396,
-1.0749647617,
-0.0606073849,
0.9922990203,
-0.0720759556,
-0.2319515795,
-0.3025164008,
0.4087474942,
0.1664518863,
-0.2096972317,
0.4916759431,
0.4771228731,
-1.041424036,
0.0575417727,
-0.4408803284,
0.4494989514,
0.3568055332,
-0.815600574,
-0.0928221643,
0.1823222935,
0.1842257082,
0.4594088793,
0.5845224857,
-0.453468889,
0.5037709475,
-0.0731469616,
-0.3535332382,
0.1921188235,
-0.6518186331,
-0.6434085369,
0.2359856069,
0.5854996443,
-0.2376095504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09948v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09948v2
|
Hijacking Large Language Models via Adversarial In-Context Learning
| 2023-11-16T15:01:48 | 2024-06-15T18:54:54 |
Yao Qiang, Xiangyu Zhou, Dongxiao Zhu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
In-context learning (ICL) has emerged as a powerful paradigm leveraging LLMs
for specific downstream tasks by utilizing labeled examples as demonstrations
(demos) in the precondition prompts. Despite its promising performance, ICL
suffers from instability with the choice and arrangement of examples.
Additionally, crafted adversarial attacks pose a notable threat to the
robustness of ICL. However, existing attacks are either easy to detect, rely on
external models, or lack specificity towards ICL. This work introduces a novel
transferable attack against ICL to address these issues, aiming to hijack LLMs
to generate the target response or jailbreak. Our hijacking attack leverages a
gradient-based prompt search method to learn and append imperceptible
adversarial suffixes to the in-context demos without directly contaminating the
user queries. Comprehensive experimental results across different generation
and jailbreaking tasks highlight the effectiveness of our hijacking attack,
resulting in distracted attention towards adversarial tokens and consequently
leading to unwanted target outputs. We also propose a defense strategy against
hijacking attacks through the use of extra clean demos, which enhances the
robustness of LLMs during ICL. Broadly, this work reveals the significant
security vulnerabilities of LLMs and emphasizes the necessity for in-depth
studies on their robustness.
|
[
-0.4804551303,
-0.9195398688,
0.0670655742,
0.0059475908,
-0.0675468892,
0.3551174402,
-0.1962383837,
-0.1785590947,
-0.1130637079,
0.6179816127,
-0.4695522785,
-0.4018985033,
-0.5420505404,
-0.1343628615,
-0.5357918739,
1.1907619238,
0.2414415479,
-0.1855988055,
-0.0214362293,
-0.063415207,
-0.4744254947,
-0.7363283038,
-0.7707661986,
0.1177949756,
0.3444948494,
0.3482252657,
0.4711177945,
0.2941833138,
0.1591808796,
0.2074726224,
-0.195126012,
0.049241256,
-0.7906297445,
0.2009263486,
-0.0469057299,
-0.3954163492,
-0.2253032923,
-0.0132628847,
0.4375943244,
0.3099017143,
0.0647166595,
0.0358176306,
0.4501250088,
0.5683755279,
-0.7317288518,
-0.2001511604,
-1.3179688454,
-0.0671476424,
-0.3949547112,
-0.2228130698,
-0.5768744946,
-0.1080395952,
0.0006507724,
-0.3583182395,
-0.052759625,
0.1083429977,
0.7354664803,
0.2303205729,
-0.2350390404,
-0.5384598374,
-0.3053714037,
0.5545877814,
-0.7062965035,
-0.0303351227,
0.1310656816,
0.3659879267,
-0.6308477521,
-0.7266469598,
-0.4574135542,
-0.4586777687,
-0.1000583917,
-0.1302791685,
-0.2367248088,
0.06385535,
0.4647463858,
0.0308781508,
-0.4347753823,
0.2922321856,
-0.2403779924,
-0.3699153364,
0.2086281925,
-0.0411710031,
0.6722954512,
-0.0352376811,
-0.9232954979,
-0.0771004409,
-1.3060129881,
0.4329667389,
0.5230290294,
0.4898377061,
-0.0622404069,
0.3112947047,
0.1635950953,
0.5266812444,
0.2453446835,
-0.1032763049,
-0.2058518827,
-0.0550580993,
-0.2614019811,
0.2355634868,
0.7686082721,
0.00165218,
0.0967081338,
-0.262660563,
-0.3041544855,
-0.4123335779,
0.3060420156,
-0.7990884781,
-0.0425512902,
0.0783289671,
-0.2715333998,
-0.3770877123,
0.2529188991,
-0.9260026813,
-0.4574225545,
0.1315951943,
0.4737375677,
-0.4627044797,
0.2632682621,
-0.1068104357,
0.0438809097,
0.1554219276,
0.0740470216,
-0.733488977,
0.2443828583,
0.6388473511,
0.7360140681,
-0.1199664921,
-0.3690496385,
-1.0829380751,
0.3360344172,
-0.141468823,
0.2192188948,
-0.1350921392,
-0.5219984055,
0.0716175362,
-0.098909609,
-0.1063309088,
-0.6326768994,
0.2317450047,
-0.9334180951,
-0.0332444869,
-0.1240751818,
-0.4091656804,
-0.0168123376,
0.5694036484,
-0.6280562282,
0.818829596,
-0.1104162037,
-0.7060002685,
0.179198876,
-0.5760332942,
-0.6783539057,
0.0499513671,
-0.1169375703,
-0.3976834714,
-0.1012051031,
0.4586127996,
0.5118710399,
-0.0138045195,
0.224377498,
-0.4766120315,
-0.5947884917,
0.402026087,
-0.4946606159,
1.0004780293,
0.1552377194,
-0.6001966596,
0.1724845767,
-0.6141896844,
-0.3760251105,
0.1128903478,
-0.4160377979,
-0.4732648432,
-0.1414954513,
-0.299238354,
0.3268060386,
0.2769595385,
-0.4451716542,
0.3291358054,
-0.5782117844,
0.4984174073,
0.8929601908,
0.0758550391,
0.4953245819,
-0.0374378227,
0.6054624319,
-0.1131917611,
0.2274251431,
-0.3955915272,
-0.0262245722,
-0.4391184747,
-0.5300756097,
0.0035235728,
0.4286743999,
-0.8808653355,
0.1787887961,
-0.0430349223,
-0.2732977569,
-0.4321597815,
0.2995267212,
0.5381099582,
0.7609171271,
0.3889520466,
0.1504907161,
-0.3336454928,
-0.7359455228,
-0.5890867114,
-0.0710646361,
0.0200104583,
0.3253715038,
0.4502077997,
-0.0844098777,
0.6621085405,
-0.2188815773,
-0.3547694385,
-0.2865325809,
-0.1211144701,
0.0487959422,
0.5128439069,
0.8246030807,
-0.6897873282,
-0.556014061,
-0.2631108165,
-0.6432339549,
0.1076255515,
-0.2792380452,
-0.0918860808,
-0.1455581635,
1.1211489439,
-0.481877923,
0.4337086976,
0.1238771677,
-0.3651346266,
0.4566426575,
-0.0866924822,
-0.2268592715,
-1.0183318853,
-0.0323233753,
-0.1925934553,
-0.2049404085,
-0.5158219337,
0.4227980673,
0.2759235799,
-0.2896290421,
-0.8357776999,
0.6638682485,
-0.3459763229,
0.1585142612,
-0.2326149344,
-0.0912842527,
-0.1763498038,
0.5250377059,
-0.6235595942,
1.099219203,
0.6965783834,
-0.5113782883,
0.1800560653,
0.1517003477,
-0.2777754664,
0.2932108939,
-0.4856179655,
0.2864415944,
-0.1824167818,
0.4066852331,
-0.9550686479,
-0.04583719,
0.3694785833,
-0.4245544672,
0.6212647557,
-0.3766305447,
-0.5614225268,
0.0481262058,
-0.5248327255,
0.2020984888,
0.5415484905,
-1.0620481968,
0.326728344,
0.1748926193,
-0.0198811032,
-0.8809267879,
-0.4998366237,
0.477250427,
-0.6626368165,
-0.2193508148,
0.4205498993,
-0.1354411095,
-0.2015965432,
-0.3193941414,
0.1066538543,
0.298619777,
0.710706532,
0.2487349361,
0.2823153138,
-0.0333643481,
-0.3856186867,
-0.1234578341,
0.1146962866,
0.2575974166,
-0.3680781722,
0.4994614124,
-0.055171527,
-0.4677705467,
-0.4169748724,
0.1749989092,
1.0379121304,
-0.1856379956,
0.6341913342,
0.3369274735,
-0.4143224359,
-0.5968868136,
-0.1470542997,
-0.3989296854,
-0.5070598722,
0.3953388929,
-0.2662000358,
-0.899381578,
0.4612748325,
-0.2007450014,
-0.0559508726,
-0.083528921,
0.4131909907,
-0.087267898,
1.0442448854,
0.4380169511,
-0.4779654443,
0.6109374762,
-0.2874236107,
0.2198000699,
-0.9377223849,
-0.1416838318,
-0.4131278992,
-0.3069426417,
-0.3064810038,
0.0371597856,
0.4238233268,
0.2966737747,
-0.3812104166,
0.4379537404,
0.0073044188,
0.6474760175,
0.5669971108,
0.1632011235,
-0.0572399832,
-0.0190554056,
-0.4110428691,
0.0181409791,
-0.5168725252,
-0.4490229487,
1.0666157007,
0.3286950886,
0.8544741273,
0.1798557341,
0.5449050665,
0.3472326696,
0.3912012279,
-0.4532571733,
0.6341940761,
-0.0972637534,
-0.3411468863,
-0.0757010207,
-0.0887089446,
-0.7084481716,
0.4371932745,
0.0239665806,
-1.0322850943,
-0.1243144348,
0.1180812195,
-0.3863785267,
0.7173389196,
-0.4083434939,
0.7640823722,
-0.3235887289,
-0.4905290306,
0.0051138587,
-0.855032146,
0.5479936004,
-0.0319139957,
0.2613185048,
0.0542988405,
0.1310880035,
0.3412783444,
-0.2849030495,
1.1761530638,
-0.3248434961,
-0.0225292575,
0.0668256506,
0.4398047924,
0.7582845688,
0.4262971282,
0.1135400087,
-0.2070003748,
-0.4184623659,
-0.4487199485,
-0.7219102979,
0.9144998789,
-0.4778285623,
-0.9125178456,
-0.2889705598,
-0.4870796204,
-0.227087304,
0.1132409498,
0.3623980582,
0.5680693984,
-0.1854116768,
0.1321604848,
0.6549201012,
-0.2120027244,
0.7000637054,
0.4066701829,
0.1082332581,
-0.2971648574,
0.9431337714,
-0.2363496274,
0.3660012782,
0.3078222275,
0.0817694217,
-0.2192747295,
-0.7421032786,
-0.6818502545,
-0.1266648769,
-0.7547212839,
-0.2880800068,
-0.4161513448,
-0.1731278449,
-0.1590249836,
-0.4039516747,
-0.1110513285,
0.0694112331,
-0.537956953,
0.0461799912,
-0.1584810615,
0.3687952459,
0.2760776281,
0.3351152837,
-0.6932117939,
0.1180263311,
0.2500514984,
-0.0491959117,
0.2945858538,
-0.5631322265,
-0.2060120851,
-0.1432226002,
-0.4137184918,
-0.9098494053,
0.446577549,
0.1227688268,
0.5345161557,
0.6785438657,
0.3659991026,
0.5382634997,
-0.4468697309,
0.8284184337,
0.0950202793,
-0.8922407627,
0.4921766818,
-0.1917660236,
0.1654461771,
0.6357385516,
0.2931269705,
-0.2875268161,
-0.5642462373,
-0.5590082407,
-0.8660443425,
0.5263777971,
-0.1201761588,
0.2991343737,
-0.0611881241,
0.4245097637,
0.0814137757,
0.237039417,
-0.6533067226,
-0.2637791634,
-0.0403107442,
-0.017842276,
0.1168878898,
-0.1297345608,
-0.2117579728,
-0.0419664606,
0.610468924,
-0.2592437267,
-0.310750246,
0.0476710349,
-0.4799720049,
0.3523015082,
0.3548435271,
0.3596591949,
0.3142256737,
-0.0243647546,
0.3566464186,
0.2158972323,
-0.3439467549,
0.2616581023,
0.0962559581,
-0.4614437222,
-0.4220165014,
0.4191464484,
0.6965433955,
0.3988407254,
-1.0451046228,
0.7912877202,
-0.2386590093,
0.1743495464,
-0.2850750089,
0.0028689625,
-0.2712212801,
0.162713483,
0.3646681607,
0.276391834,
0.0711303204,
-0.5518373847,
0.2530103922,
0.8040435314,
-0.6113275886,
-0.4321228266,
0.7017892003,
-0.0719136968,
-0.2207856774,
0.6358033419,
-0.1511113197,
-0.818192482,
0.6787204146,
0.8836041093,
0.8042740226,
0.0211344603,
-0.2211282253,
0.0896016434,
0.3299669325,
0.1890957355,
-0.1450370103,
-0.1775957346,
-0.488171041,
-0.0602591485,
-0.189679876,
-0.2182956189,
0.4666067064,
-0.7212370634,
0.312520802,
-0.6884441972,
0.2473808229,
-0.413662523,
-0.5443251133,
-0.4397661388,
-0.0971769765,
0.2100284994,
0.8390105963,
-0.513612926,
0.9270484447,
0.672500968,
-0.1813545823,
-0.4054681957,
0.4466647506,
0.1857007295,
-0.7162495255,
0.8085497022,
0.2769021988,
-0.248422578,
0.028742535,
-0.8133328557,
-0.7348034978,
0.8115655184,
0.6380722523,
-0.2881746292,
-0.0708123446,
-0.1707414538,
0.1261314899,
-0.1754380763,
-0.1010390148,
0.5597092509,
0.1166792139,
-0.1204897538,
-0.4922399223,
0.3211293221,
-0.0329103097,
-0.2391270846,
0.0928098857,
-0.5823869109,
0.8075871468,
-0.2988233864,
-0.4022485316,
0.076291576,
0.6864382029,
0.3150119185,
0.1771159321,
0.5567587018,
0.3944431841,
0.5212582946,
0.2104650885,
0.9972546697,
-0.4139042795,
0.0746296942,
1.0663770437,
-0.3332932889,
0.7486346364,
0.797092557,
0.1157163307,
0.183380276,
0.4150735438,
0.1539213955,
0.7298101187,
0.5893437266,
-0.483441174,
0.0870991722,
0.0046473918,
-0.1238270327,
0.3271739483,
0.5346205235,
-0.0827944502,
-0.3920478821,
0.4968563914,
0.5042601824,
0.3654733002,
-0.3423151076,
0.7979364395,
0.030453708,
-0.6557489634,
0.6773502231,
-0.0362760127,
0.9225541949,
-0.6937671304,
-0.0322683454,
-0.1409578323,
0.2404655814,
0.1000239551,
-0.3201014698,
-0.0066088662,
0.0252484083,
0.0593181476,
-0.2385619879,
0.7367218137,
-0.2922331393,
0.0840523317,
0.5277325511,
0.3082147241,
-0.1969436407,
-0.0170205347,
-0.5657512546,
-0.1009005308,
0.0733519793,
-0.2054434121,
0.9121394753,
0.0622888058,
-0.0208713673,
0.7545909286,
0.7135800719,
0.1018712372,
0.1032812819,
-0.1469704658,
1.0784990788,
-0.3414956629,
-0.6864958405,
-1.3130661249,
0.2633271217,
0.0255524386,
-0.1925007552,
0.9634232521,
0.5782109499,
1.1550267935,
-0.0089072324,
1.0045875311,
0.1689478308,
0.1719534397,
-0.8034290075,
0.8879345059,
-0.4701860845,
0.6401926279,
-0.0949256495,
-0.3456944525,
-0.2786719799,
-0.0598428436,
-0.0884068981,
-0.2236273438,
0.43741256,
0.8484998345,
-0.2566404939,
-0.2044877559,
0.2907201946,
0.2145517766,
0.8270574808,
0.6313357353,
1.1174794436,
-0.1115028784,
0.654758811,
-0.1688687354,
-0.1637556404,
-0.3122428656,
-0.8985921741,
-1.2521122694,
-0.3674901426,
0.0370043628,
-0.6313393116,
0.3017352223,
0.9790555835,
0.6986438632,
-0.6914372444,
-0.1774196476,
0.0176205691,
0.1304551214,
-0.1571448594,
-0.2549524605,
0.6254335642,
-0.5038931966,
-0.6028252244,
0.9517583847,
0.2128207684,
0.2353182137,
-0.3070918322,
0.0152666215,
-0.0516115911,
-0.126829043,
0.2943685055,
0.564406395,
-0.7847148776,
-0.0760972351,
-0.1164227575,
-0.2093346566,
-0.0784454942,
0.9946697354,
-0.8876882792,
0.2805459797,
0.278213352,
1.0476105213,
0.1441435963,
0.0363049507,
0.5044938922,
-1.0098555088,
0.2948006094,
0.2692630291,
0.5099054575,
0.3224802613,
-0.5604593158,
-0.1745283753,
0.1276098937,
-0.1998336315,
-0.9008085728,
0.3887607157,
-0.5165275335,
-0.5845069885,
0.9134269953,
-0.4052677453,
-0.3005047739,
-0.0074121733,
-0.3190412521,
-0.0144367795,
-0.4320452213,
0.8099424839,
0.4750215113,
0.0827551559,
0.2771349549,
-0.6001296043,
0.7310094237,
0.2404239178,
-0.5979914069,
0.1107186228,
0.0334442444,
0.2834005654,
-0.2700268626,
0.0533393994,
-0.2917859256,
0.1262615174,
-0.438149929,
-0.3021679819,
-0.3468447626,
-0.4720261991,
-0.7105022073,
0.6202135086,
0.063658677,
-0.2434078455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09945v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09945v1
|
An Attention-Based Denoising Framework for Personality Detection in Social Media Texts
| 2023-11-16T14:56:09 | 2023-11-16T14:56:09 |
Qirui Tang, Wenkang Jiang, Yihua Du, Lei Lin
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL
|
In social media networks, users produce a large amount of text content
anytime, providing researchers with a valuable approach to digging for
personality-related information. Personality detection based on user-generated
texts is a universal method that can be used to build user portraits. The
presence of noise in social media texts hinders personality detection. However,
previous studies have not fully addressed this challenge. Inspired by the
scanning reading technique, we propose an attention-based information
extraction mechanism (AIEM) for long texts, which is applied to quickly locate
valuable pieces of information, and focus more attention on the deep semantics
of key pieces. Then, we provide a novel attention-based denoising framework
(ADF) for personality detection tasks and achieve state-of-the-art performance
on two commonly used datasets. Notably, we obtain an average accuracy
improvement of 10.2% on the gold standard Twitter-Myers-Briggs Type Indicator
(Twitter-MBTI) dataset. We made our code publicly available on GitHub. We shed
light on how AIEM works to magnify personality-related signals.
|
[
-0.531943202,
-0.6375346184,
0.7139409184,
0.4284569025,
-0.3267736435,
0.1108733863,
-0.2377379388,
-0.5464708805,
0.4984772503,
0.5999817252,
-0.8060244918,
-0.6332128048,
-0.801220119,
0.0981444865,
-0.6082369089,
0.743208766,
0.2586179078,
-0.4192666411,
-0.2550798655,
-0.1185325384,
-0.0573629849,
-0.2523958385,
-1.0053659678,
-0.0481394492,
0.5932219028,
0.3569281101,
0.2862097621,
0.6883664727,
0.7922225595,
0.1696248502,
-0.2087186128,
0.3811835349,
-0.6714404821,
0.21561791,
-0.3068662286,
-0.1505115628,
-0.4564682841,
-0.2180241644,
0.7719823718,
0.1172386408,
0.279176116,
0.323020339,
-0.0959299654,
1.0005378723,
-0.5293974876,
0.3730691671,
-0.2677566707,
-0.189620167,
-0.3303093612,
-0.1827029139,
-0.3051505685,
-0.2811049521,
-0.0561311245,
-0.1807860732,
0.1161605939,
-0.1248160228,
0.6365452409,
0.1271641105,
-0.4358745813,
-0.1615782678,
-0.8425374031,
0.7261001468,
-0.312641412,
0.1278675944,
0.50671345,
0.1944660544,
0.1106019467,
-0.0518017709,
-0.6312172413,
0.2162896991,
-0.3137929738,
0.132614404,
-0.1163704172,
-0.0458268672,
0.2208775133,
0.3323193192,
-0.5054838657,
-0.3670727015,
-0.1493617743,
0.2762625217,
0.8788749576,
-0.1934767812,
0.2433663905,
-0.1897636503,
-0.0497920476,
-0.0058271256,
-0.2451437861,
0.0344584249,
0.5346906781,
-0.118605867,
-0.0500028878,
0.4101135433,
-0.280598402,
0.173360005,
0.2636913955,
-0.0975708067,
0.1946400851,
-0.101435639,
0.1783928275,
-0.1401162595,
0.7526807785,
0.5513511896,
0.8535037041,
-0.3147680759,
-0.1463559568,
0.0058064521,
0.3604720831,
-0.972193718,
-0.2918414474,
0.4380313754,
-0.6327089071,
-0.4328061938,
0.1835318357,
-0.9600687027,
-0.6992852092,
-0.0448237471,
0.0361060873,
-0.4577263296,
-0.4897935688,
-0.1010189131,
-0.1129840091,
0.1211082041,
0.074285388,
-0.9072353244,
0.0140991062,
0.4522121549,
0.9683304429,
-0.4168950915,
0.1513423771,
-0.5153200626,
0.2525549829,
-0.0334723182,
1.0934165716,
-0.4343301952,
-0.3871460855,
-0.2706436515,
-0.1362673491,
-0.0086637903,
-0.4555670023,
0.3330633342,
-0.5167221427,
-0.3027707636,
-0.3485759497,
-0.4620451331,
-0.0437763184,
0.1261995137,
-0.64516294,
0.9928725362,
0.2847410142,
-0.8736121655,
0.123538591,
-1.1260371208,
-0.7641296983,
0.2449111044,
-0.0219375715,
-0.5759240985,
-0.0945073292,
0.4430049658,
0.7128651738,
0.0791852176,
0.0216875169,
-0.5903035998,
-0.500120759,
0.2624815702,
-0.2217152119,
0.7242440581,
0.1297299117,
-0.4350854456,
0.1098072082,
-0.7242959142,
-0.2102476805,
0.3327198029,
-0.1983286738,
-0.4434536099,
0.1171655878,
0.1852102429,
0.0967108905,
0.2732786238,
-0.8548629284,
-0.0330583453,
-0.5183207393,
0.4830107987,
0.5103121996,
0.3865250051,
0.4950991571,
-0.25319314,
0.2269454449,
0.2177963257,
-0.1276749372,
-0.1540509462,
-0.2507090569,
-0.4428700209,
-0.8600434661,
-0.2910856605,
0.5389169455,
-0.2600243092,
0.8793788552,
-0.0724774301,
-0.5052870512,
-0.6003934741,
0.4821300507,
0.2219436467,
0.1867192984,
0.2998093367,
-0.2500734031,
-0.5050725341,
-0.8284723163,
-0.6012116671,
-0.3113135397,
-0.1131010652,
0.3425274491,
0.1458018422,
-0.5658144355,
1.0442519188,
-0.5580480695,
-0.3786366284,
-0.3052700162,
0.1060829833,
-0.1554989964,
0.2229817659,
0.6609050632,
-0.9772267342,
-0.6945637465,
-0.149959594,
-0.6525127292,
-0.2315732837,
-0.1855204254,
-0.3522782624,
-0.0197372735,
0.6459733844,
-0.6798612475,
0.6872209907,
0.1235188544,
-0.406160742,
0.258620739,
0.3964908421,
0.0818521827,
-1.0163578987,
0.3893288374,
0.5280374885,
-0.4649890065,
-0.4360458255,
-0.008921775,
0.1853159666,
0.0853799433,
-0.0327542983,
1.0639498234,
-0.4241889715,
0.0746004134,
-0.2829506993,
0.2218397558,
0.2500947714,
0.4370539486,
-0.1614388525,
0.6101593375,
0.1472149938,
-0.428408742,
0.1772079766,
0.4632385373,
-0.2290905863,
0.9734563828,
-0.3781815469,
0.3414948285,
-0.6317852736,
0.066607289,
-1.4677497149,
-0.341318965,
0.2531339526,
-0.6079392433,
0.2727241218,
-0.0674938634,
-0.593598187,
-0.3160735071,
-0.6183357835,
-0.0085103484,
0.1946241558,
-0.5146443248,
0.7620862126,
0.4478302002,
-0.5194557905,
-0.1767828912,
-0.5224508047,
0.008576245,
-0.1895902753,
-0.5249735713,
0.4027180076,
-0.4611751139,
-0.3480861783,
-0.0555110686,
0.048613321,
-0.3794519901,
0.2377443463,
0.2267823219,
0.13328062,
0.1243256778,
0.3878248632,
0.2008107752,
0.0499625728,
0.112362735,
0.3451921046,
0.3846434951,
-0.1095414683,
-0.0196173023,
-0.6842722297,
0.6186108589,
0.8828736544,
-0.377122283,
0.680390656,
1.2387887239,
-0.3377639949,
0.0482346378,
-0.7241785526,
-0.4954562187,
-0.4958786368,
0.5559396148,
-0.064867802,
-0.7406663895,
0.6576983929,
0.1550307274,
0.1805319786,
0.3517301679,
0.4613474309,
-0.3240219951,
1.2043586969,
0.7500344515,
-0.1599908173,
0.9254191518,
-0.0446173474,
0.3748086691,
-0.8756856918,
0.0672651306,
-0.1141510829,
-0.4163331985,
-0.1402240247,
0.1126671806,
-0.0277391486,
-0.3059126139,
0.0842617601,
0.2536110878,
-0.7454625964,
0.4195136428,
0.3802694082,
0.4780515432,
0.2581470907,
-0.0790187269,
0.7156743407,
-0.1513003409,
0.0633971989,
-0.3517742753,
1.0253597498,
0.4725912213,
0.3679207563,
0.0590787418,
0.7957649231,
0.7062460184,
0.7478809953,
-1.0815575123,
0.5993464589,
-0.2348297238,
-0.7178367972,
-0.448400259,
-0.3790416718,
-0.5843666196,
0.0054978416,
-0.1344956458,
-0.7893052101,
0.146892339,
0.0553673543,
-0.4599048197,
0.1158695295,
-0.9955331087,
0.6939147115,
0.1936436146,
-0.3021813631,
-0.1804192215,
-0.6908541322,
0.158063814,
-0.2413903028,
0.1613078415,
-0.499764502,
0.0911306441,
0.8923991323,
0.077359587,
0.6659709811,
-0.3202035725,
0.2010404468,
0.3272755444,
-0.1100673005,
0.5631231666,
0.245753333,
-0.1033393592,
0.150625512,
0.1245575249,
-0.3153069615,
-0.4299517572,
0.5253564119,
-0.518930316,
-0.1186525598,
-0.0058497177,
-0.594199717,
-0.2997539937,
0.347121805,
0.0569689833,
0.1593625695,
-0.3488587141,
0.3543817103,
0.7863346934,
0.2737725973,
0.5388016701,
0.2747972608,
0.0408789217,
-0.1892490834,
0.8450016379,
0.011217393,
-0.1711679101,
0.2886235118,
-0.0240512919,
-0.2786273956,
-0.3916223645,
-0.1400972009,
0.6371420026,
-0.6042652726,
0.010404096,
-1.1454857588,
-0.2061443031,
-0.6354526281,
-0.3094856739,
-0.4545307159,
0.1545347422,
-0.5105799437,
0.193604216,
0.3310117126,
0.4926016927,
0.2705626786,
0.721521914,
-0.6373299956,
0.4708654284,
0.0971321166,
0.2157953084,
0.0660504848,
-0.2496921569,
-0.2737288177,
-0.1382999569,
-0.2676326931,
-0.7486305237,
0.46465379,
0.1538382471,
0.2226187438,
0.7565466166,
0.1593890935,
0.3800821602,
-0.0287709124,
0.0039143865,
-0.1159743294,
-0.6872637868,
0.4954505265,
-0.4160425067,
0.543366909,
0.9270718098,
0.2290440947,
-0.6708518863,
-0.4871108532,
-0.4122714102,
-0.6920014024,
0.540887177,
0.358372122,
0.0905988961,
-0.3199738562,
0.8394607902,
-0.1500939876,
0.4140103459,
-0.7053513527,
-0.1188082695,
0.2495770156,
-0.8000380397,
0.0530043803,
-0.5273537636,
0.22865358,
-0.2783315182,
0.6015375257,
-0.149006784,
0.6742478609,
0.409072876,
-0.0776220858,
-0.0833715275,
0.0752747655,
0.1858771145,
0.3383948803,
-0.5779768229,
-0.2279681563,
-0.5243902206,
-0.9081143737,
-0.1509333998,
0.120161213,
-0.2866077721,
-0.0450729616,
0.0340534821,
0.3128170371,
-0.0404973887,
-0.7052044272,
0.6050722599,
-0.1221073717,
-0.2463037074,
-0.415324986,
0.2089780867,
0.3256312907,
0.3488557637,
0.4956315756,
0.0185458977,
0.4159111083,
-0.3996808827,
0.1788840145,
0.4902924299,
-0.6770629883,
-0.4660298824,
0.2622977197,
0.2765818834,
-0.3060810864,
0.3300679326,
-0.4383370578,
-0.2506751418,
0.7846278548,
0.029491568,
1.033614397,
-0.226497829,
0.3168706298,
0.1571457833,
0.2248819917,
-0.0063063349,
0.4492847621,
-0.2659451663,
-0.6910282969,
-0.2533190846,
-0.7439364791,
-0.2209342122,
0.5062938929,
-0.4438918233,
0.3171716928,
-0.7608230114,
-0.1846323311,
0.4012126029,
0.0796242058,
-0.4058568478,
0.1402794272,
0.0275921524,
0.2776702046,
-0.6390198469,
0.5254271626,
0.7498593926,
0.1983215362,
-0.1644179374,
0.460329324,
0.1493557394,
-0.3969711065,
0.1649505794,
0.6167150736,
-0.2574591339,
0.50681144,
-0.5406159759,
-0.6228138208,
0.8274509907,
0.4108693302,
-0.4035298824,
-0.1640734076,
-0.3872796595,
0.5483645797,
-0.498042345,
0.1829252392,
0.5269075632,
0.5490410924,
0.0922564417,
-0.1665519476,
-0.1867071986,
-0.3204530478,
-0.2526617348,
0.1207280234,
-0.8575866222,
0.4366621375,
-0.224321425,
-0.4171209037,
-0.1296281964,
0.5888007879,
-0.0252809245,
0.3741281927,
0.516715467,
0.1730762571,
0.6928690672,
0.2446813732,
0.7102968693,
-0.4367417097,
0.3911013007,
0.89888376,
-0.2210301012,
0.6946255565,
0.4413475394,
0.129447937,
0.5940933824,
0.5903169513,
-0.0844191238,
0.6341282129,
-0.2872786224,
-0.3119619191,
-0.2563745081,
0.0141889043,
0.1248143762,
0.443420887,
0.4061687291,
-0.6541651487,
-0.0157015193,
0.1298990697,
0.1991388202,
0.0534217469,
-0.2966294587,
0.8339725137,
-0.122061871,
-0.4058107436,
0.0151776988,
0.0937609151,
0.7259576917,
-0.3195367157,
0.1480261832,
-0.0983106196,
0.463391602,
-0.2455832809,
-0.7480348945,
0.6391852498,
-0.1832199395,
-0.5119530559,
-0.191555649,
1.183688283,
-0.4131214619,
-0.3754514754,
0.4439978302,
0.3500866294,
0.0710931569,
-0.8256677389,
-0.5490555763,
-0.2755538821,
0.0323472247,
-0.5857008696,
0.2287336886,
0.2439845204,
0.2902751267,
0.5965328813,
0.4684541523,
-0.1464987546,
-0.4970921874,
-0.1524730325,
0.6229161024,
-0.4083630145,
-0.7340428233,
-1.1531624794,
0.2819246352,
-0.5320082903,
-0.3234587908,
0.5331017971,
0.3315638602,
0.4157384634,
0.0637108758,
0.8248630762,
0.0796090811,
0.8548942804,
0.0382693447,
1.0685390234,
-0.5460734367,
0.0115083586,
-0.3666566014,
-0.8678157926,
-0.1484718621,
0.4867424667,
-0.4061324596,
0.2511977553,
0.6888150573,
0.6737775803,
-0.083530724,
-0.0804557353,
0.2457493693,
0.238284871,
0.286976546,
0.3474939466,
0.0427814387,
-0.1865220964,
0.497661829,
-0.1633042246,
-0.5120369792,
-0.6291469336,
-0.4419888556,
-1.4828505516,
-0.437749058,
-0.5150611401,
-0.4497604668,
0.1213606969,
0.5449284315,
0.500536263,
-0.5007548928,
0.1915417016,
-0.0338182934,
0.097888574,
-0.1365250498,
-0.3287493289,
0.3843612373,
0.1603402942,
-0.5354248881,
0.065925464,
0.7339577079,
-0.036821086,
-0.4326008856,
0.1966381967,
-0.4122572243,
0.4854776263,
0.6282305121,
0.2382686436,
-0.229809612,
-0.4757614136,
0.2217354625,
-0.3705744743,
0.2431490719,
0.5135495067,
-0.198422417,
0.4442346692,
0.3556264341,
0.6614824533,
0.6610968113,
0.2144748271,
-0.0629399568,
-0.9971278906,
-0.0643458217,
0.1762227863,
0.0667823702,
0.4769481421,
-1.0604943037,
0.4101010561,
0.6735609174,
-0.3983363509,
-0.6332899332,
0.255164206,
-1.0737743378,
-0.0311818458,
1.3129271269,
-0.0621410199,
-0.5375289321,
-0.4017776847,
-0.3570120037,
0.1638253778,
-0.7525427938,
1.1333345175,
0.9893102646,
-0.0541422553,
-0.1963001043,
-0.3510541618,
0.4376979768,
0.2086684257,
-0.904966116,
0.4291600585,
0.0835315138,
0.2801401913,
0.1977079064,
1.0579590797,
-0.1792983562,
0.272017926,
-0.4215981364,
0.2164208591,
0.0564853027,
-0.3067828119,
-0.0611533076,
0.2169775069,
-0.3488602936,
0.1836520135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10782v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10782v1
|
A BERT based Ensemble Approach for Sentiment Classification of Customer Reviews and its Application to Nudge Marketing in e-Commerce
| 2023-11-16T14:18:24 | 2023-11-16T14:18:24 |
Sayan Putatunda, Anwesha Bhowmik, Girish Thiruvenkadam, Rahul Ghosh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
According to the literature, Product reviews are an important source of
information for customers to support their buying decision. Product reviews
improve customer trust and loyalty. Reviews help customers in understanding
what other customers think about a particular product and helps in driving
purchase decisions. Therefore, for an e-commerce platform it is important to
understand the sentiments in customer reviews to understand their products and
services, and it also allows them to potentially create positive consumer
interaction as well as long lasting relationships. Reviews also provide
innovative ways to market the products for an ecommerce company. One such
approach is Nudge Marketing. Nudge marketing is a subtle way for an ecommerce
company to help their customers make better decisions without hesitation.
|
[
-0.7438863516,
-0.593295157,
0.0157176163,
0.5775839686,
-0.4370987713,
0.0190640874,
-0.1432759315,
-0.4678537846,
0.3804266751,
0.260710746,
-0.8548284173,
-0.6563391685,
0.096269533,
-0.1469228268,
-0.2286135256,
1.3961712122,
0.5653242469,
0.3666984737,
-0.0489387624,
-0.057248123,
0.0340244845,
-0.6209386587,
-0.5360378623,
-0.1516093314,
0.4696234167,
0.2961965501,
0.4822055995,
-0.610311389,
0.4703265429,
0.3287684023,
0.0994660482,
-0.0212831162,
-0.4882238507,
0.4769171178,
-0.0188391637,
-0.7103188634,
-0.3324660361,
0.0302928183,
0.1182140112,
0.4903382957,
-0.1702124029,
0.2509640157,
0.3489487171,
0.8749250174,
-0.591855526,
0.1026940793,
-0.3224495351,
0.1542708874,
0.4590494037,
-0.1705199629,
-0.5004248023,
-1.2004660368,
0.3948735893,
-0.5206618309,
0.389932543,
0.1025666967,
0.715831399,
-0.0503406636,
-0.1381028146,
-0.5698650479,
-0.7609645724,
1.0791898966,
-0.6806905866,
0.1571698785,
0.0832925215,
0.4260939658,
-0.0860498026,
-0.1698799282,
-0.3859398663,
0.266130507,
0.108882226,
0.4167933464,
-0.1190697476,
-0.0586527847,
0.0607216544,
0.3488229811,
-0.2189666927,
-0.0984617993,
-0.3051186204,
-0.1091097593,
0.8310646415,
-0.0589294322,
-0.0306374822,
-0.3246554434,
-0.6928006411,
-0.1889163852,
-0.4891146123,
0.4558656812,
0.4862341583,
0.0401191227,
0.1848028302,
0.015380566,
-0.1243944764,
0.6396738291,
0.6846593618,
0.1342401057,
0.3931995928,
0.1458691806,
-0.5136082172,
0.541868031,
0.6422882676,
0.8055195808,
0.2344144285,
0.2728221714,
-0.21631217,
0.009888608,
0.2070018053,
-0.6832983494,
-0.1295157969,
0.4975734949,
-0.8840328455,
-0.750508368,
0.4132208526,
-1.2730532885,
-0.3041952848,
-0.1569066644,
0.3330307603,
-0.339977324,
-0.4673233926,
-0.3152862191,
-0.468960166,
0.4882144332,
0.7022029757,
-0.8454762101,
0.2367493957,
0.9505236745,
0.4281161129,
0.3016424477,
0.1129868403,
0.1554248333,
-0.2826307416,
-0.3889730871,
1.101995945,
-0.358761102,
-0.6065294147,
0.3289528787,
-0.0387868695,
0.1178297848,
-0.3564181626,
0.5185736418,
-1.0194965601,
-0.0918384269,
-0.4753238261,
-0.7298477888,
-0.6515675783,
0.6627396345,
-0.6442232728,
0.6939740777,
0.0817664638,
-0.3812561035,
0.9219791889,
-0.4441329539,
-0.6969873905,
0.235500738,
0.3155183494,
-0.5383665562,
0.6529350281,
0.2520818114,
0.5726476312,
0.1081966758,
-0.5748672485,
-0.6902588606,
-0.2259778678,
0.8277670741,
-0.0257023871,
0.9116827846,
0.7671548128,
-0.4124768972,
-0.3493174016,
-0.3619585633,
0.3953281641,
-0.3977565169,
-0.3692786098,
-0.5128594637,
-0.1041029692,
0.342623204,
0.1033145636,
0.1650178432,
-0.4689379036,
0.350554347,
-0.4763779938,
0.3132278621,
0.7716953754,
0.701918602,
0.5696144104,
-0.1757472605,
0.5806615949,
-0.0031989228,
0.633926034,
-0.0221808683,
-0.6830006838,
-0.7127116919,
0.1821947843,
0.6780703664,
0.3508105278,
-0.6357702017,
0.6079041958,
-0.0597770959,
-0.6407673359,
-0.6453398466,
0.0370821133,
0.0066460297,
-0.0214690082,
-0.2294637859,
-0.475920558,
-0.458719492,
-0.5343720913,
-0.1102375388,
-0.360229671,
0.049072668,
0.0109960455,
-0.0304954574,
-0.1285753995,
0.8974063993,
-0.4383225739,
-0.4281661212,
-0.3458376825,
0.6207627058,
0.6625957489,
0.1222759113,
0.7404870987,
-0.9383838773,
-0.7170403004,
0.1945492923,
-0.319991976,
0.055839818,
-0.1429819465,
-0.0115279006,
0.5651441216,
-0.0627813563,
-0.3590375781,
0.5691402555,
0.3553027511,
-0.0865718499,
0.2002865374,
-0.1685827971,
0.5844889879,
-0.8631221652,
-0.4780572057,
0.5812302828,
0.1033229604,
-0.6789008975,
-0.3022253811,
-0.0517654195,
0.039238181,
-0.4455123544,
-0.1728146672,
-0.3230099678,
-0.2929655313,
-0.1907890439,
-0.2945050895,
0.0459786654,
0.5158278346,
-0.0406241603,
0.3057392538,
0.3790842593,
-1.1986005306,
0.2402407974,
0.3856230378,
-0.8778452873,
1.3648257256,
-0.409183085,
-0.0397311524,
-0.0378669873,
-0.0146713024,
-1.377592802,
-0.0191941485,
0.2294559926,
-1.1454305649,
0.2130635828,
-0.0344463512,
-0.5118719935,
-0.4461281896,
-0.6046211123,
-0.1752608865,
0.9958049655,
-0.6663364172,
0.6694755554,
0.3854666352,
-0.036153648,
-0.3907382786,
-0.5331787467,
-0.3082170188,
-0.2495909184,
-0.6512780786,
-0.2365188152,
-0.0538173318,
-0.510538578,
-0.1720138192,
0.0328562558,
0.0808827356,
0.0715500414,
0.2431167513,
0.0680600107,
0.0525089316,
0.5748070478,
-0.0059276531,
-0.1234914735,
0.4227261543,
-0.1579418778,
0.5698994994,
-0.1767564863,
-0.0682801381,
-0.4121397138,
0.3269489706,
0.5303363204,
0.3750677705,
0.275907129,
0.7361466289,
0.0046383487,
-0.5748471618,
-0.7880849242,
-0.4594515264,
-0.5071456432,
0.0183960237,
-0.0179860685,
-0.3102282882,
0.3161919713,
-0.2428363264,
-0.0236321427,
0.410225749,
0.8537710905,
-0.8152551651,
1.3976863623,
0.5582931042,
-0.3313284516,
0.4676180482,
-0.0490265824,
0.6989681721,
-0.7067022324,
-0.2013053447,
-0.5879837871,
-0.8485046029,
-0.6202843189,
0.1766339839,
0.3915243745,
-0.0427533165,
-0.0312052406,
0.1227106601,
-0.7909154892,
0.0922638997,
0.900572896,
0.4766601324,
-0.1687186658,
0.4616567194,
0.0592371076,
-0.1322699487,
-0.4524488747,
-0.1996149421,
0.9142510891,
0.2651477754,
0.9162456393,
0.1651388556,
0.8074266315,
0.5516030192,
0.3851282895,
-1.0465441942,
0.6327026486,
0.2446150482,
-0.5944935679,
-0.1970351189,
0.1164885238,
-0.9299017787,
-0.1744543612,
-0.341655314,
-0.4391643703,
0.7650475502,
0.1674019247,
-0.7108380198,
0.1361367553,
-0.6628053784,
0.1935041547,
-0.5470529795,
-0.6595107317,
-0.3038810194,
-0.7352648973,
0.0899223387,
0.0866970122,
0.5901122093,
-0.0360771231,
0.3496117592,
1.0207065344,
-0.5594459176,
0.9800707102,
-0.5816797614,
0.0768299922,
0.6856729388,
0.0869459584,
0.306728512,
-0.09291666,
0.0770144463,
0.0138120968,
-0.3224514723,
-0.048450131,
-0.8750253916,
0.7992548347,
-0.8561713099,
-0.2542895675,
-0.5216908455,
-0.0842183828,
-0.3529515862,
-0.2198587209,
0.1512203217,
-0.0154979415,
-0.1291969866,
0.3404764831,
0.989490211,
0.1176765487,
0.8345912099,
0.3866144419,
-0.3795942068,
-0.8204863667,
0.7858586311,
-0.1649397165,
0.2177517116,
0.3686298728,
0.1466559619,
-0.5520069003,
-0.2093073875,
-0.0243035164,
-0.2015191913,
-1.0018718243,
-0.2999555171,
-0.6585367918,
0.2255375534,
-0.7305844426,
-0.1749467403,
0.4137652218,
-0.6164437532,
-0.2285858542,
-0.3707029223,
0.5435740948,
0.9868839383,
-0.4534590244,
0.5446344614,
-0.9447811246,
-0.1936239004,
0.7367205024,
0.1126312837,
0.2907418609,
0.053067863,
-0.3208584785,
-0.1868022382,
-0.380289346,
-1.2939968109,
0.6668961048,
-0.1320727468,
0.6272704601,
1.1334080696,
0.0321719907,
0.5827363729,
0.2496337891,
0.9966626167,
0.4627202153,
-0.9301761389,
0.5716605783,
-0.3488336205,
0.1269775778,
0.7073690295,
0.5896092653,
-0.4725230038,
0.3154185116,
-0.7958236337,
-0.8180093765,
0.4850621223,
-0.1215928793,
-0.0179118421,
0.0405819938,
0.159070313,
0.0403110385,
0.895755887,
-0.5491724014,
-0.2062298805,
-0.2704789639,
-0.1180140004,
-0.0254689958,
-0.5928278565,
-0.0967083871,
-0.2590503991,
1.0384442806,
0.0648657754,
0.5863146186,
0.0822485536,
-0.1892032623,
-0.3216674924,
0.4161029458,
0.3662360013,
0.3683644831,
-0.5272420645,
-0.2499728352,
-0.0018307872,
-0.161991626,
-0.0264377166,
-0.4251241982,
-0.135993883,
0.1190508157,
-0.1888687909,
0.2976808548,
0.5437123179,
-0.0205137189,
0.4245348573,
0.1577636898,
-0.4825018048,
-0.301573813,
-0.2359176725,
-0.2755785882,
0.0523267426,
0.4759745598,
0.2929268479,
0.6128123403,
-0.7229980826,
0.3001050353,
0.4965307117,
-0.8058523536,
-0.246035248,
0.0176045932,
0.5236079693,
-0.4748957455,
0.7575410008,
-0.0565390922,
-0.7593660355,
0.7907376885,
0.3523238599,
1.2689087391,
-0.600764513,
0.5070120096,
0.434892416,
0.2660831213,
0.1598129272,
0.4105298221,
-0.3950863481,
-0.5390316844,
-0.155987367,
-0.5479072928,
-0.6381692886,
-0.4597906768,
-1.103127718,
0.6939860582,
-0.7283859253,
-0.440484345,
0.128786847,
0.0014744983,
-0.5573669076,
0.5807085037,
0.210868597,
0.750805974,
-0.822378397,
0.4851148725,
0.6032351851,
-0.3265561461,
-0.7758681774,
-0.2186383456,
0.0329256468,
-0.8952917457,
0.8772386909,
0.2523911297,
-0.0467703901,
-0.307097137,
-0.763266623,
-0.4451617599,
0.6794531345,
-0.8166174293,
-0.7952803373,
0.4415712655,
-0.088014625,
0.7520723343,
-0.3827700615,
0.5036689043,
0.4825737774,
0.6110113859,
0.5058867335,
-0.315551281,
-0.2759634256,
-0.3830778003,
0.0872191489,
0.4004036188,
-0.5351610184,
0.7930268049,
0.0015764207,
-0.0810213685,
-0.1116673574,
0.2956181467,
0.1458076388,
0.4541316628,
0.7573649883,
0.7991586328,
0.594291389,
-0.2900756598,
1.0273874998,
-0.4025571942,
0.6701032519,
0.5148537755,
-0.5052463412,
1.0776211023,
0.4286439419,
-0.4480188489,
0.9561830759,
0.9155344367,
-0.2678754032,
0.9108842015,
0.2222207636,
-0.3593556583,
-0.3166867793,
0.4810106158,
-0.5319715738,
-0.0928984433,
0.7396671176,
-0.5107979178,
-0.201161623,
0.0082884459,
-0.1849573851,
-0.3514809608,
-0.8284242153,
1.1779847145,
0.0589648671,
-0.7409743071,
0.1790694892,
-0.4271917641,
0.5921337605,
-0.4719978869,
-0.0806345046,
0.0121751251,
0.6230903864,
-0.6449583769,
-0.7815309167,
0.0015817009,
-0.6209573746,
-0.0737411305,
-0.289596051,
0.9619985223,
0.0520000905,
-0.768637836,
-0.0958006233,
0.2559633851,
0.0251434408,
0.0456108935,
-0.9692883492,
-0.0773727447,
0.216335535,
-0.2928649485,
0.1835373938,
0.4256413281,
0.2384318113,
0.3090856671,
0.8482798338,
-0.3357168138,
0.1035183221,
0.0550746582,
0.5217419863,
-0.8249669671,
-1.0209208727,
-0.8804789186,
0.4817293286,
-0.7107308507,
0.0453380533,
1.2365801334,
0.2720909119,
0.30473575,
-0.4705754817,
1.13121593,
0.0490277223,
0.7576571703,
-0.1310548037,
0.7518076897,
-0.0893316045,
0.3537468314,
-0.4569132626,
-1.0765419006,
-0.4442367554,
0.8335164785,
-0.6062545776,
0.1516068429,
0.5060879588,
0.4976899326,
0.5798103809,
0.6513357162,
0.1228526607,
0.1131607369,
-0.0060208514,
0.4270860255,
1.2321310043,
-0.4250348806,
0.4969149232,
-0.11864499,
-0.2404503524,
-0.7172316313,
-0.7925454974,
-1.0052648783,
-0.0857930183,
-0.5246111751,
-0.7044651508,
-0.2006037682,
1.0812358856,
0.7312067747,
-1.1526968479,
-0.3186801672,
0.0391789339,
0.2012224942,
-0.6406440735,
-0.3585459292,
0.0320510641,
-0.7694888115,
-0.8025587201,
-0.3951982558,
0.5059754848,
0.0506025888,
-0.3983471692,
0.2510566115,
-0.0041469191,
0.2312114537,
0.6094094515,
0.1405147463,
-0.4838725626,
0.1523202509,
0.0827580914,
0.3818656504,
0.2595441341,
0.9918900728,
-0.7527175546,
0.474273771,
0.7039804459,
0.2022188306,
0.245999366,
-0.0139162512,
0.6479450464,
-0.3936922848,
-0.0139997005,
0.4260167778,
0.3095992208,
0.0969916508,
-0.5798653364,
0.1322621554,
-0.1852752566,
-0.8625991344,
-0.3092817962,
0.1247034073,
-1.2971683741,
-0.2143940628,
1.1715371609,
0.1107486039,
-0.7799943089,
-0.3284086883,
-0.3331099749,
-0.5235131383,
-0.7928290963,
1.008409977,
0.6511237621,
-0.0807671994,
-0.2107340693,
0.124127157,
0.4535481632,
0.3101997674,
-0.6796005964,
-0.6747290492,
0.2728442252,
0.2999276519,
0.5594477057,
0.3791892529,
0.0541830175,
0.572987318,
-0.4229416251,
0.1239464208,
0.4725676179,
0.1283503324,
-0.5521291494,
0.8093253374,
0.1198813021,
-0.557122767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09889v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09889v5
|
Language Generation from Brain Recordings
| 2023-11-16T13:37:21 | 2024-03-11T11:05:21 |
Ziyi Ye, Qingyao Ai, Yiqun Liu, Maarten de Rijke, Min Zhang, Christina Lioma, Tuukka Ruotsalo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Generating human language through non-invasive brain-computer interfaces
(BCIs) has the potential to unlock many applications, such as serving disabled
patients and improving communication. Currently, however, generating language
via BCIs has been previously successful only within a classification setup for
selecting pre-generated sentence continuation candidates with the most likely
cortical semantic representation. Inspired by recent research that revealed
associations between the brain and the large computational language models, we
propose a generative language BCI that utilizes the capacity of a large
language model (LLM) jointly with a semantic brain decoder to directly generate
language from functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) input. The proposed
model can generate coherent language sequences aligned with the semantic
content of visual or auditory language stimuli perceived, without prior
knowledge of any pre-generated candidates. We compare the language generated
from the presented model with a random control, pre-generated language
selection approach, and a standard LLM, which generates common coherent text
solely based on the next word likelihood according to statistical language
training data. The proposed model is found to generate language that is more
aligned with semantic stimulus in response to which brain input is sampled. Our
findings demonstrate the potential and feasibility of employing BCIs in direct
language generation.
|
[
-0.3768769801,
-0.7319030762,
0.7666772008,
0.1737257093,
-0.3287414908,
-0.2037767917,
-0.5018364787,
-0.4516189694,
0.4407230914,
0.3861506879,
-0.7010993958,
-0.4813661873,
-0.1892212331,
0.3021417558,
-0.3412322402,
0.8604918718,
0.1688967645,
0.1644401699,
-0.2499295324,
0.2519909143,
-0.7525656223,
-0.4896864891,
-0.6164398193,
-0.4781798124,
0.7212945223,
-0.037772309,
0.4865406156,
0.2007764578,
0.2098717988,
0.2971358597,
0.2974508405,
0.0508949719,
-0.1714529097,
-0.1232450902,
-0.0201464426,
-0.2944813073,
-0.3630926311,
-0.3471834064,
0.6973095536,
1.0902560949,
-0.1064324081,
-0.1736551225,
-0.0915235952,
0.3738543391,
-0.6698867083,
-0.0354844816,
-0.8180034161,
-0.1117285118,
-0.2899701893,
-0.2943270206,
-0.6637835503,
-0.2778759301,
-0.0773454234,
-0.2265362889,
0.1626396924,
-0.1659002751,
0.8344657421,
-0.2242051661,
-0.3404441476,
-0.2081769705,
-0.7034817934,
0.6235256195,
-0.8063061237,
0.5137206912,
0.3143306077,
0.0368884616,
-0.4569810629,
-0.5315355062,
-1.0618693829,
-0.2869959772,
-0.0467371307,
0.2198595852,
-0.027192397,
0.095346421,
0.1315875798,
-0.0467488803,
-0.7896904945,
0.0433441997,
-0.3895384073,
-0.1556145549,
0.7619475722,
0.4017114937,
0.5837878585,
-0.1541091949,
0.0538939536,
-0.215005666,
-0.9274061322,
-0.2780553102,
0.2870203853,
0.3612858057,
-0.0827569142,
0.8220020533,
-0.1612231284,
1.0207012892,
-0.0851004496,
-0.2020563483,
0.2082076818,
-0.2272865623,
-0.2942554057,
0.129096508,
1.0680927038,
0.3765329719,
0.1435859054,
-0.556969285,
-0.2367608845,
0.4605197608,
0.2871058881,
-0.7725695968,
-0.068732664,
0.3014272451,
-0.239918679,
-0.1697960198,
-0.0408851504,
-0.3818444312,
-0.0630600229,
-0.4227221608,
0.1458158791,
-0.7257393599,
-0.4812410176,
0.1066308618,
0.0457066223,
0.3064111173,
-0.1992910057,
-1.0336433649,
0.1945866793,
0.3207249641,
0.3848816454,
-0.2718684971,
-0.2182806134,
-0.3589732349,
0.541790247,
-0.582208097,
0.6521599293,
-0.2185983509,
-0.5828344226,
0.1790634543,
-0.2285835892,
0.0852845088,
-0.5933033228,
0.1046159491,
-0.7191189528,
0.0694033056,
-0.1548516303,
-0.2060976624,
0.2208733112,
-0.3229940236,
-0.426789999,
0.3552639186,
-0.0013241429,
-0.8020515442,
0.5762665272,
-0.5539526939,
-0.9389259219,
0.3657126129,
-0.6074581742,
-0.3388283551,
0.2365425974,
-0.0554543361,
0.4219270647,
-0.3079724014,
0.8008921146,
-0.3974568546,
-0.3095148206,
0.6812710762,
-0.3915835321,
0.5586245656,
0.4249783754,
-0.2204610556,
-0.1067777425,
-0.8169178367,
0.2230056673,
0.3306654096,
-0.5250496268,
-0.1673116535,
0.1418965459,
0.2389804572,
0.0538655594,
0.285256654,
-0.8315675259,
-0.2934210896,
-0.546467185,
0.2369570285,
0.2945915759,
-0.0427999124,
0.2499278039,
-0.2325568795,
0.0582169108,
0.1492835283,
-0.4441273212,
-0.0775369257,
-0.3348448277,
-0.7094781399,
-0.4527038336,
0.2292771637,
0.4389591217,
-0.6322025061,
0.7694166303,
-0.6851946115,
0.0836054757,
-0.4808632731,
-0.0855536908,
0.1666130424,
0.2838867009,
0.1770504117,
-0.3892675936,
-0.7173796296,
-1.1173158884,
0.1121136844,
-0.1786960959,
-0.4858178198,
0.217111662,
-0.0287256148,
-0.4204568267,
1.1840157509,
-0.6288093925,
-0.0958017632,
-0.4098756313,
0.3721481264,
0.0394914635,
0.3397917151,
0.3241007924,
-0.4426279664,
-0.0343436226,
0.2961131334,
-1.0321806669,
-0.1335618198,
-0.0833928511,
-0.2458399236,
0.6786823273,
0.1828586161,
-0.7084029317,
0.3031687737,
0.4418624341,
-0.2451827824,
0.021323489,
-0.3699045181,
0.2222510129,
-1.3860890865,
0.388548404,
-0.1721481383,
0.1343255043,
-0.5365532041,
-0.2793732285,
-0.0273905378,
-0.4654535055,
-0.0841424391,
0.1689859629,
-0.5682777762,
-0.0544624999,
-0.5298823714,
0.2009777278,
-0.1943354756,
0.465285182,
0.688785255,
0.4320546687,
0.4743252695,
-0.5543023348,
0.1107635945,
0.3342875242,
-0.4157206118,
0.1819095314,
-0.3974655867,
0.2789782584,
-0.287242353,
0.1045268923,
-0.9007751942,
-0.4564849734,
-0.1037952006,
-0.5144587159,
0.6535640955,
0.4919626117,
-0.3635232151,
-0.3454289436,
0.2256235182,
0.4140207171,
0.7869885564,
-0.3559344709,
0.4151091576,
0.4108555913,
-0.3736652136,
-0.202218011,
-1.0978512764,
0.2018653601,
0.100437589,
-0.829102993,
0.2445455343,
-0.1501030624,
-0.0146706905,
-0.1714939773,
0.1720788181,
-0.1331132054,
-0.1740783155,
0.2025780827,
0.3986809254,
-0.4238065779,
-0.1181761026,
0.5350983143,
0.3217358589,
0.198847577,
-0.1293205321,
0.5981401801,
0.2870732844,
-0.3137164116,
-0.4671232104,
0.8170298338,
0.4938465953,
-0.2189142853,
0.5981355906,
0.255836755,
-0.4134786725,
0.0439608656,
-0.5149546862,
-0.1990303546,
-0.4416488111,
0.5965542197,
-0.6846390963,
-0.7401862741,
0.0217169188,
0.0319004357,
-0.0649096221,
-0.084031947,
0.6682313681,
0.0192179605,
1.068597436,
0.5107833147,
0.0907115266,
0.3407494724,
0.0595377199,
0.4167325497,
-0.636082232,
-0.221554637,
-0.1289526075,
-0.0334837623,
-0.4123589396,
-0.1161875352,
0.1529054344,
0.0347521752,
0.0695586875,
0.4124757648,
-0.3448802233,
0.1606905758,
0.3324554861,
0.4056793451,
0.0273265205,
0.3763227761,
-0.2596237063,
-0.014257106,
-0.5870313048,
-0.5345321298,
0.9770809412,
-0.0808688775,
0.5841514468,
0.1490556598,
0.9281573892,
-0.0825457498,
0.5655787587,
-0.4181736708,
0.8532745838,
0.0401234701,
-0.3599842489,
-0.1148699746,
-0.3997507989,
-1.1885222197,
-0.0212020501,
-0.5454981923,
-0.7202285528,
-0.0222248025,
-0.0528152436,
-0.2857211828,
-0.0768637434,
-0.9154479504,
0.6684238315,
-0.1242024601,
-0.4276920855,
-0.2612513006,
-0.5576763153,
0.5960344672,
-0.3465533257,
-0.0121278195,
0.2647196651,
0.2161264271,
0.297139734,
-0.27735129,
0.7844213247,
-0.0961633921,
-0.3135448396,
0.5200853348,
0.090116255,
0.0405041762,
0.0963047296,
0.1306913495,
0.1813593954,
-0.278706193,
-0.3199256659,
-0.3977313042,
0.9687438607,
-0.7048109174,
-0.6487501264,
-0.097912088,
-0.5089805722,
-0.2727272213,
0.2795253694,
0.3649414778,
0.4399739206,
-0.6372603178,
-0.1940481961,
0.4455187619,
-0.422352016,
0.6146196723,
0.3344880342,
-0.2262233943,
-0.7217950225,
1.1465579271,
-0.149510324,
0.1284323037,
0.6330238581,
-0.2147056907,
-0.2251027375,
-0.7345368862,
-0.3096241951,
0.5641988516,
-0.3295837343,
-0.0829744115,
-0.6282964945,
-0.2105513364,
-0.6219896078,
-0.2982889116,
0.0888298377,
-0.0629254878,
-0.102119647,
0.0311244428,
0.0240906533,
0.5292583108,
0.0342766605,
0.2240644544,
-0.8436700106,
0.4309949875,
0.3422601223,
0.217892006,
-0.2259673476,
0.0959528908,
-0.2006385475,
0.2778341472,
-0.3259864151,
-0.8339748383,
0.5648634434,
0.0681222975,
0.2766727507,
0.3201334476,
-0.093929112,
0.5200908184,
-0.8823225498,
0.7514241934,
0.8040061593,
-0.6670122147,
0.5849895477,
-0.4425616264,
0.5093773603,
0.2773014903,
0.18321459,
-0.0823340863,
-0.7913600802,
-0.2723398805,
-0.7197438478,
0.7107486725,
0.2414955646,
0.2332054675,
-0.8512898088,
0.1101783216,
0.0065958602,
0.1392693818,
-0.6222571731,
0.1642215103,
-0.108017087,
-0.6855396628,
0.0440883785,
-0.1021624655,
-0.1422174424,
0.0239298716,
0.5368532538,
-0.1826691777,
0.5841988325,
0.201173529,
-0.0269575343,
-0.1195301563,
0.325655967,
0.6350874305,
0.5136999488,
0.0173027981,
-0.0310828481,
0.1950478405,
-0.4368729889,
-0.1444241256,
-0.0134161757,
-0.2099861205,
0.1224172413,
-0.0002390292,
0.96162045,
-0.2279881984,
-0.857313931,
0.6552502513,
-0.1686233729,
-0.3372599185,
-0.5418302417,
-0.0859357864,
0.4896011651,
0.0980943069,
0.0488936305,
-0.0154769961,
0.0343930349,
-0.3638156354,
0.2111715078,
0.7692760229,
0.0695450827,
-0.4773270786,
0.7698125243,
0.264272213,
-0.3305103183,
0.9402531981,
0.2485278994,
0.3870025873,
0.1999061406,
1.0054314137,
1.0435765982,
-0.00114034,
-0.0729871318,
0.3686644137,
0.0143570257,
0.2788178325,
0.3897892237,
-0.2760115564,
-0.9683385491,
-0.705920279,
-0.8839996457,
0.1864163876,
0.4119824767,
-0.4732030928,
0.5547913909,
-0.4060138464,
-0.4281716347,
-0.0175868478,
-0.4497323632,
-0.4256145656,
0.5312905312,
0.8361165524,
0.5601714849,
-0.7505243421,
1.2068186998,
0.6369492412,
-0.5760196447,
-0.6864540577,
0.1821817756,
-0.74927634,
-0.4038068652,
0.7417059541,
-0.0074218106,
-0.3803541362,
-0.0123625118,
-0.4695384204,
-0.3200599551,
1.0049782991,
0.7024337053,
-0.3706716299,
-0.1093883887,
0.4542846084,
0.4794049859,
-0.5198694468,
0.1521699429,
0.3497554362,
0.153469339,
0.1362271756,
-0.5531260967,
0.3120938241,
-0.2864899635,
0.614346683,
0.30027771,
-0.3425666392,
0.1269312203,
-0.2165086865,
-0.465495944,
0.3561968207,
1.1467956305,
0.4324234724,
0.0907792076,
0.1899005473,
0.5030757785,
0.4076425433,
0.0237066895,
1.0037497282,
-0.3994109929,
-0.3012879491,
0.7630517483,
-0.5297034979,
0.9276832342,
0.5970419645,
0.107205376,
0.6424950957,
0.3129916489,
0.2456586659,
0.6380412579,
0.3419826329,
-0.860261023,
-0.2460295111,
0.0601191707,
0.0200791322,
0.2363453209,
0.2505261302,
-0.2947824299,
0.0334115475,
0.0646210313,
-0.2472315878,
0.2850603461,
0.0410549119,
0.909787178,
0.1351010501,
-1.0697703362,
0.8255663514,
0.0507705286,
0.7145279646,
-0.7818217278,
-0.0442540832,
-0.0469420925,
-0.0310081504,
-0.1015945077,
-0.3678224385,
0.5001966357,
-0.0063890857,
-0.3199491203,
-0.0820804238,
0.5064123273,
-0.8117646575,
-0.3060156107,
0.1509004235,
0.1850506067,
0.2974577844,
0.4017779231,
0.0341871679,
0.0938983038,
-0.1255284995,
-0.0135453334,
0.5898848772,
0.3717180192,
-0.106066674,
0.2213328481,
0.6415108442,
0.1167759523,
0.2694478333,
0.075857453,
0.7597532868,
-0.7899959683,
-0.2452491075,
-0.6095253825,
0.5209124088,
-0.0217373166,
0.0317765214,
0.0551265739,
0.6756777167,
0.6747153997,
-0.647449553,
1.0811171532,
-0.4291334152,
0.205606997,
-0.5927935839,
0.7631781101,
-0.4185649157,
-0.2657405436,
-0.1662701219,
-0.6766335368,
-0.2891357839,
0.4379324913,
-0.131184116,
-0.0423156247,
1.0231537819,
1.0136834383,
0.0738817528,
0.0733127743,
0.7784951925,
0.0137463585,
-0.0809387192,
0.8062191606,
0.6385568976,
-0.1141984537,
0.4733858407,
0.3463678062,
-0.2924013436,
0.3118313253,
-0.605442822,
-0.8731116056,
-0.5258434415,
-0.4496245682,
-0.2526863813,
-0.0391861275,
0.6966933608,
0.4293428361,
-0.6844896078,
-0.549975276,
-0.5519737005,
-0.3941820562,
0.0662088543,
-0.2126252204,
0.0711197779,
-0.517519474,
-0.9243385196,
0.7083072662,
0.2452494502,
0.1083556563,
-0.1919445843,
-0.1174900308,
-0.0762366056,
0.2344555259,
0.707105577,
0.2920445204,
-0.6742463708,
-0.3040893972,
0.0277800635,
-0.3265450895,
-0.1146608219,
0.856644392,
-0.6969974637,
0.181988284,
0.5543847084,
0.8509042859,
0.553407073,
-0.4639486074,
1.1398358345,
-0.5730970502,
0.0982416794,
0.0966892168,
0.2965375781,
0.4610943198,
-0.3200612366,
-0.0740587562,
0.1387852877,
-0.2409933954,
-0.571190536,
0.5843682885,
-1.1094025373,
-0.2098703831,
1.1142404079,
0.0907506645,
-0.6519621611,
0.0780823678,
-0.2610450685,
0.4475374818,
-0.1119983047,
0.6149734855,
0.4112284184,
-0.1812925935,
0.1554192305,
-0.0904868022,
0.0816011354,
0.4473699033,
-0.5925630927,
0.0126604922,
0.8235253096,
0.3516901731,
0.271168232,
0.9168847799,
-0.3546301723,
0.1385148615,
0.0253887698,
0.6641083956,
0.2374583781,
-0.0847906619,
-0.1163230613,
0.2163085341,
0.2012786567,
-0.2935839891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09862v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09862v2
|
Which Modality should I use -- Text, Motif, or Image? : Understanding Graphs with Large Language Models
| 2023-11-16T12:45:41 | 2024-03-13T23:32:32 |
Debarati Das, Ishaan Gupta, Jaideep Srivastava, Dongyeop Kang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Our research integrates graph data with Large Language Models (LLMs), which,
despite their advancements in various fields using large text corpora, face
limitations in encoding entire graphs due to context size constraints. This
paper introduces a new approach to encoding a graph with diverse modalities,
such as text, image, and motif, coupled with prompts to approximate a graph's
global connectivity, thereby enhancing LLMs' efficiency in processing complex
graph structures. The study also presents GraphTMI, a novel benchmark for
evaluating LLMs in graph structure analysis, focusing on homophily, motif
presence, and graph difficulty. Key findings indicate that the image modality,
especially with vision-language models like GPT-4V, is superior to text in
balancing token limits and preserving essential information and outperforms
prior graph neural net (GNN) encoders. Furthermore, the research assesses how
various factors affect the performance of each encoding modality and outlines
the existing challenges and potential future developments for LLMs in graph
understanding and reasoning tasks. All data will be publicly available upon
acceptance.
|
[
-0.2849707901,
-0.9024720192,
0.7002444267,
0.0133029958,
-0.6344269514,
0.105650574,
-0.3812733591,
-0.7084949613,
0.1738765091,
0.3170493841,
-0.2979242504,
-0.6486594081,
-0.8248300552,
0.449560523,
-0.0716651753,
0.4348789454,
-0.3033588827,
0.4122768641,
-0.1901298761,
-0.1688537598,
-0.361335814,
-0.7533832192,
-0.7547998428,
-0.3525416851,
0.7643846869,
-0.2233774513,
0.6272553205,
0.6862559319,
0.3842812479,
0.3653262854,
-0.1000843644,
0.4175444543,
-0.542103827,
-0.0157951787,
0.134692803,
-0.2848662734,
-0.3858831525,
0.0133734178,
0.7536318302,
1.0500104427,
0.5951131582,
-0.0989900753,
-0.1078509018,
0.3565114141,
-0.3078718781,
0.6758460402,
-0.4320169091,
-0.0244981907,
-0.1417848915,
-0.3078383505,
-0.7040303349,
-0.0318688229,
-0.0884250775,
-0.6573703289,
-0.135876894,
0.4178592861,
0.8447009325,
-0.1329024136,
-0.870339036,
-0.2089848369,
-0.3723260462,
0.3720445335,
-0.2742097974,
0.7162035108,
0.4907105565,
0.1835547388,
-0.1785575151,
-0.8493295312,
-0.3472873867,
-0.0594103746,
-0.0901655033,
0.0748395324,
-0.2643041313,
0.3047655225,
0.2527684271,
0.3995033205,
-0.5840784311,
0.15276815,
-0.2167964429,
-0.3742220998,
0.2914187908,
0.1537888348,
0.5139071941,
-0.4368065,
-0.1942624003,
-0.0374756753,
-0.576261282,
-0.0909996405,
0.3229132295,
0.2337463796,
-0.0820224434,
0.7204378843,
0.1470885128,
0.9484605789,
-0.1867331862,
0.0105018886,
0.2148766518,
-0.4831371605,
-0.3215879798,
-0.1893672049,
0.7649733424,
0.4341895878,
0.2338429838,
-0.4498603642,
-0.1532675177,
0.1404829621,
-0.0833771974,
-0.8727582097,
-0.0634240806,
-0.2059096098,
-0.7267916799,
-0.0626842752,
0.0183857121,
-0.2995488048,
-0.3442911804,
-0.3869287074,
0.1818022132,
-0.7376680374,
-0.053260304,
0.208973676,
-0.3959228992,
0.2288190573,
0.6536295414,
-0.7184821367,
0.1388596296,
0.7243437767,
1.1373345852,
-0.1114454642,
-0.1594213396,
-0.5145102739,
0.3626992404,
-0.4120824635,
0.577981472,
-0.8669758439,
-0.4410904944,
-0.1744289249,
0.3092110753,
-0.513348937,
-0.1223794743,
0.5074048638,
-0.7624486685,
0.1760492474,
-0.443784833,
-0.7873387337,
-0.5073366761,
0.2078089416,
-0.9769639373,
0.5542142391,
0.3423324227,
-0.8952724934,
0.3766718507,
-0.5814152956,
-0.4428029358,
0.1387817264,
-0.5290820599,
0.0651410893,
0.2353703976,
0.2003309727,
0.4208348095,
-0.1957641244,
0.0847224593,
-0.2848602533,
-0.5324406028,
0.514744997,
-0.6050187945,
0.6059201956,
0.1996553838,
0.0953197926,
0.1829619259,
-0.3821327686,
-0.1670078784,
0.2510873675,
-0.4242366552,
-0.2428148985,
0.0280634388,
0.3252245784,
-0.1126410067,
0.209109515,
-0.5043482184,
0.299271971,
-0.2469690889,
0.8913089037,
0.9333060384,
-0.033898171,
0.2227470279,
0.0152288182,
0.4515197873,
-0.065292947,
-0.168255955,
-0.4158484042,
-0.4877597988,
-0.4189379215,
-0.4726323783,
0.3515412509,
0.1569125503,
-0.9320614338,
0.1238704771,
-0.6126738787,
-0.0273877271,
0.0946463495,
-0.0460496843,
0.2185727507,
0.3937778771,
0.0725806653,
-0.49180004,
-0.3949425519,
-0.6414656639,
-0.0453437492,
-0.2439670116,
-0.0142985573,
0.7038162947,
0.3921250105,
-0.4314315319,
0.5887661576,
-0.4620406628,
0.0830117986,
-0.5062683821,
0.2490194887,
0.1044429541,
0.1418695152,
0.8548891544,
-0.7729661465,
-0.3720134497,
0.0653915852,
-0.7702189088,
0.2607640624,
0.1239489615,
0.0694354773,
0.2612944245,
0.5929921269,
-0.5259043574,
0.1822546124,
0.7211427093,
-0.6554676294,
0.2699621022,
-0.0714503154,
0.4837597609,
-0.8817124963,
0.0436399281,
0.0716956705,
-0.5669139028,
-0.525044024,
-0.0095602609,
-0.0633567721,
-0.4357063472,
0.0425739922,
0.3772181273,
-0.7533875704,
-0.1712947041,
-0.0017022457,
0.1530283839,
0.114723362,
0.4507995248,
-0.0363031626,
1.0294537544,
0.5981166959,
-0.0728574917,
0.3906068802,
0.1438036412,
-0.3213899434,
0.2839073241,
-0.6912606359,
0.3456160128,
-0.3717977405,
0.4928843677,
-1.1187119484,
-0.5521323085,
0.4262402058,
-0.2280965,
0.8174563646,
-0.2916555107,
-0.5827618241,
-0.3111288846,
-0.1791861057,
0.7042683959,
0.251472801,
-0.3342109025,
0.78199476,
0.2217058688,
0.2474911511,
-0.1910681725,
-0.5045925379,
0.5558116436,
-0.1552187055,
-0.8613387942,
0.2225041687,
0.0593513101,
-0.0019556973,
0.0163190272,
-0.0895773321,
-0.1125183553,
0.0881222039,
0.2469086945,
0.1879445463,
-0.3553307056,
0.1390916109,
-0.2834161222,
-0.2994332612,
0.0569179282,
-0.4381754696,
0.7694337368,
-0.3280611336,
-0.4564356208,
-0.4870690107,
0.4224312603,
0.6453720927,
-0.2115461081,
0.5128237605,
0.5633375049,
-0.1055811271,
0.2190592736,
-0.0869066045,
0.1206983551,
-0.4775135815,
0.4960674644,
-0.5297996998,
-1.1787639856,
0.3847935498,
-0.3733573854,
-0.5374954343,
0.2174423933,
0.3422532976,
-0.0195178352,
1.255087018,
0.6083521247,
-0.3194906116,
0.6938917041,
-0.3326883614,
0.3949791193,
-0.8296578526,
-0.113035284,
-0.2918158472,
-0.2183985859,
-0.3746141791,
-0.8704835773,
0.4821577072,
0.0665582642,
-0.1260498911,
0.1242718771,
-0.3745563924,
0.3979608715,
0.0678264797,
0.3050877452,
0.4321923852,
0.2527944744,
-0.0653272495,
0.0254214872,
-0.6434665918,
-0.6422590613,
1.0338808298,
0.3244557083,
0.8194682598,
0.0602042563,
0.3106339574,
0.1709272861,
0.1178045794,
-1.0720496178,
0.6197280288,
-0.2586828768,
-0.274005264,
-0.1837971658,
-0.4500842392,
-1.1418367624,
0.1873413622,
-0.0785282999,
-0.9968291521,
0.0487079248,
0.067436561,
0.4318744838,
0.443015188,
-0.5995909572,
1.0398813486,
-0.2143999338,
-0.0672185197,
-0.172567755,
-0.4814590812,
0.2008204907,
0.177021578,
0.2655556202,
-0.0457330868,
-0.3324952126,
0.3549697697,
-0.1743736118,
0.9360672235,
0.0323589556,
0.0085071893,
0.1445840597,
0.1693155617,
0.398367852,
-0.0765527263,
-0.1614963561,
0.3483001292,
-0.0819747373,
-0.3050721586,
-0.6873950958,
0.4571708739,
-0.9070536494,
-0.5093698502,
-0.1957497895,
-0.6925711036,
-0.1355474591,
0.2545259297,
0.3727844357,
1.0613914728,
-0.2414482534,
0.2612550259,
0.5247344971,
-0.0049308683,
0.3551979363,
-0.2777400315,
-0.2824007869,
-0.4837936461,
0.8702118397,
0.1888853908,
0.3203808069,
0.2930705547,
0.0892333537,
-0.2296871096,
-0.6996048093,
-0.6974131465,
0.4432987869,
-1.1878635883,
-0.0623995773,
-0.7532086372,
-0.0405698121,
-0.2691193819,
-0.2104528546,
0.1282375753,
-0.3223977387,
-0.3750882745,
0.0460912362,
0.5544145703,
0.7058079243,
0.2645279765,
0.1733586639,
-0.4684005082,
0.2324954718,
0.1771372408,
0.5133106709,
-0.0242528096,
-0.2028241158,
-0.1879202724,
-0.1053724959,
0.051566612,
-1.1368933916,
-0.0042113462,
0.2099427283,
0.6099369526,
0.5021926761,
-0.4442618191,
0.5661691427,
-0.4265862405,
0.7770001292,
0.3359695971,
-1.0567039251,
0.2574940324,
-0.7097840309,
0.0751479566,
0.3166341484,
0.4013743103,
-0.6953734159,
-0.1257466078,
-0.2037978172,
-0.6322267056,
0.3940230906,
0.131368801,
0.3236698508,
-0.1802108288,
0.5393843055,
-0.1054033041,
0.1487461776,
-0.902187705,
-0.0339222476,
-0.5198987126,
-0.3770026267,
-0.1298143864,
-0.2113779634,
-0.2917952538,
-0.3992043436,
0.0408660956,
-0.5912359357,
0.543152988,
0.2242703885,
-0.3419196904,
-0.0131014492,
0.0928339735,
0.2738901377,
0.8912668228,
0.1600713581,
0.5340325832,
0.0909738019,
-0.4541392028,
0.0407598354,
-0.1820113212,
-0.0014935369,
0.0285199434,
0.8127105236,
1.0599530935,
0.1516895443,
-0.5316367745,
0.5830456018,
-0.1108071581,
-0.1135422289,
0.1675540805,
0.0346678458,
0.1377668232,
-0.0169986263,
0.0359841585,
-0.1723783314,
0.1294884682,
-0.7613654137,
-0.2173865736,
0.5574436784,
-0.4425972402,
-0.4508254528,
0.515272975,
0.0884142965,
-0.1848653406,
0.4783435464,
-0.1902501583,
-0.5611857772,
0.5571087003,
0.8229735494,
0.8283970952,
0.3248651922,
0.1160065234,
0.2711529136,
0.1326928586,
0.2684067488,
0.4149347842,
0.0251359195,
-0.7324306965,
-0.5511772633,
-0.4048116207,
-0.2359676361,
-0.1653772146,
-0.2255592346,
0.1148738191,
-0.5038791299,
-0.2036647946,
0.0649626404,
-0.2052085102,
-0.5514495373,
-0.0599506274,
0.1642726064,
0.8706896901,
-0.8199620843,
0.7015516162,
0.8941648006,
-0.4136943519,
-0.8871911168,
-0.1954761893,
0.0253886171,
-0.847699821,
0.7197780609,
0.2854220569,
-0.4015361369,
0.1191069111,
-0.7672011256,
-0.7351359725,
1.1306328773,
0.4125140011,
-0.1616288871,
0.1640538424,
-0.0216746014,
0.3937635422,
-0.6671358347,
0.1106222644,
0.3273146749,
0.6302681565,
0.2032208294,
-0.4990339279,
0.3086281717,
-0.3216311336,
0.3213243484,
0.1826030165,
-0.5877032876,
0.9118244052,
0.1929659694,
-0.5595825911,
-0.0059837336,
0.4376897514,
-0.0261555556,
0.153743729,
0.5717766881,
0.2259265482,
0.8019508719,
-0.1794463694,
1.2447699308,
-0.5427668095,
0.1650379449,
0.6206441522,
-0.0189482328,
0.2008706331,
0.4018707573,
-0.0321610086,
0.606706202,
0.923684001,
-0.0903023854,
0.1582138538,
0.0901822001,
-0.1406965703,
-0.4720563293,
-0.3060325682,
-0.4188021421,
0.6315583587,
0.1681185514,
-0.4086513221,
-0.2223298848,
0.0067432388,
0.2797556221,
0.0787045434,
-0.2689687908,
0.5924303532,
0.0528891124,
-0.1159929857,
0.4258666039,
0.0606742576,
0.2554669976,
-0.6240686774,
0.0310044158,
0.0753401965,
-0.3447658122,
-0.0541481599,
-0.6258500218,
0.0033256784,
-0.2064098567,
-0.2120801657,
-0.2522629499,
0.7809522748,
-0.1450875551,
-0.6235066056,
0.2735297382,
0.4560393691,
0.1930341572,
0.199308902,
-0.4253689051,
0.6802095175,
-0.4047290087,
-0.1887866408,
0.1177481711,
0.8448082805,
-0.1976267248,
0.4387510717,
0.4669861197,
-0.0047298581,
-0.3065273762,
0.4317649901,
1.2688543797,
-0.7204527259,
-0.3613200486,
-0.7698677778,
0.0730929598,
-0.2434679419,
-0.152112782,
0.8333038688,
0.6914238334,
0.5052295923,
0.1518767476,
0.6465722322,
0.0527969152,
-0.3567824662,
-0.716242075,
0.405933708,
-0.5391580462,
-0.0908339173,
-0.4986851811,
-0.6615569592,
-0.332038343,
0.6650553942,
-0.4220695794,
0.1254238635,
0.7891792655,
0.548979342,
-0.2270359248,
0.2385908514,
0.1860602796,
0.2155620009,
0.4069369137,
0.4766874611,
0.9551470876,
-0.2170972526,
0.2224055678,
0.3738066852,
-0.2111917883,
-0.1313663721,
-0.9739880562,
-1.0467592478,
-0.5149548054,
-0.1050957963,
-0.3546883166,
-0.325324446,
0.8551135659,
0.6166953444,
-0.3141131401,
-0.2584761679,
-0.0345791988,
0.2880696654,
-0.0502632,
-0.1220766827,
0.4201024473,
-0.4409875572,
-0.6808773875,
0.390562892,
0.7008344531,
0.1920893937,
-0.2827695608,
-0.0967159644,
0.0339984372,
-0.0056928308,
0.8928157091,
-0.1344663203,
-0.7541534901,
-0.8070798516,
0.2050251067,
-0.1285114288,
0.3348082006,
1.3874863386,
-0.3206291199,
0.6084601879,
0.7091590166,
0.4973397255,
0.7125612497,
-0.0988375843,
0.5824509859,
-0.2181840986,
0.2369088978,
0.0404262692,
0.734184444,
0.3744180501,
-0.3817287683,
0.5855318904,
0.5525467396,
-0.1971124113,
-0.7057678103,
0.612924993,
-1.3110404015,
-0.6648445725,
1.1287915707,
-0.1801989079,
-0.463021636,
-0.3674406409,
-0.4236350358,
0.3001606762,
-0.0045142863,
0.2385887206,
0.6675091982,
-0.3284986019,
-0.1798151582,
-0.437918067,
0.16928716,
-0.0928586498,
-0.4937033951,
0.1036020741,
1.0652698278,
0.1997619271,
-0.1447632164,
0.7821851373,
-0.1004850343,
0.0072578802,
0.146652624,
-0.4107787609,
-0.3744086921,
-0.2485881001,
-0.3418319225,
0.3377110064,
0.1596643031,
0.1801456958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09861v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09861v4
|
ConceptPsy:A Benchmark Suite with Conceptual Comprehensiveness in Psychology
| 2023-11-16T12:43:18 | 2024-06-16T11:33:03 |
Junlei Zhang, Hongliang He, Nirui Song, Zhanchao Zhou, Shuyuan He, Shuai Zhang, Huachuan Qiu, Anqi Li, Yong Dai, Lizhi Ma, Zhenzhong Lan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The critical field of psychology necessitates a comprehensive benchmark to
enhance the evaluation and development of domain-specific Large Language Models
(LLMs). Existing MMLU-type benchmarks, such as C-EVAL and CMMLU, include
psychology-related subjects, but their limited number of questions and lack of
systematic concept sampling strategies mean they cannot cover the concepts
required in psychology. Consequently, despite their broad subject coverage,
these benchmarks lack the necessary depth in the psychology domain, making them
inadequate as psychology-specific evaluation suite. To address this issue, this
paper presents ConceptPsy, designed to evaluate Chinese complex reasoning and
knowledge abilities in psychology. ConceptPsy includes 12 core subjects and
1383 manually collected concepts. Specifically, we prompt GPT-4 to generate
questions for each concept using carefully designed diverse prompts and hire
professional psychologists to review these questions. To help to understand the
fine-grained performances and enhance the weaknesses, we annotate each question
with a chapter label and provide chapter-wise accuracy. Based on ConceptPsy, we
evaluate a broad range of LLMs. We observe that, although some LLMs achieve
similar accuracies on overall performances, they exhibit significant
performance variations across different psychology concepts, even when they are
models from the same series. We hope our work can facilitate the development of
LLMs in the field of psychology.
|
[
-0.4416837394,
-0.6510440111,
0.963945508,
0.50268507,
-0.0245606732,
0.3403683007,
-0.580213666,
-0.6216724515,
0.0712334663,
0.2813253999,
-0.7979211211,
-0.4439878762,
-0.4119336605,
-0.0195092559,
-0.2206784636,
0.5187234879,
-0.0851394981,
0.1735496819,
-0.1506951004,
0.2039713413,
-0.3813026547,
-0.4467752874,
-0.6583938003,
-0.6466076374,
-0.0827913657,
0.1335571855,
0.2116797864,
-0.0864653364,
0.7137687802,
0.1885092854,
-0.1296419352,
0.4382737875,
-0.2978310883,
0.0636720806,
-0.3335856497,
-0.5086717606,
-0.5542014241,
0.089290157,
0.4124689102,
0.9204030037,
-0.284889102,
0.1057802364,
-0.0400935411,
0.3616524041,
-0.7873749733,
0.0705408975,
-0.5191042423,
0.0710233152,
0.1483681947,
-0.077389963,
-0.3103914559,
-0.2250072658,
0.1369897574,
-0.5747451186,
0.4473296106,
-0.2924748063,
0.8300943971,
0.0290323254,
-0.2050576806,
-0.094253473,
-0.5941972136,
0.6456710696,
-0.5341038108,
0.2627970874,
0.5792446733,
0.3733265102,
-0.132016167,
-0.7147575617,
-0.4939289987,
-0.4726990759,
-0.0028743551,
0.131696701,
0.098771356,
0.0297242496,
0.4341894686,
0.2163977325,
-0.4058585465,
-0.161007449,
-0.1617790163,
-0.337192297,
0.8230425119,
0.5015298724,
0.1043133885,
-0.0262129661,
-0.0914532766,
-0.0483709015,
-0.4730540216,
0.2160740793,
-0.125468418,
0.0565832593,
0.0991022736,
0.2257415056,
-0.4088281691,
0.5245184302,
0.2213314176,
-0.4458061457,
0.2993202806,
-0.3597315848,
-0.0874128938,
-0.0334430374,
0.6533644795,
0.3409984708,
0.3348778486,
-0.315548569,
-0.0892916843,
0.3086351454,
0.3827932179,
-0.7188549042,
-0.2342528701,
0.6219061017,
-0.1931439489,
-0.0198521558,
-0.2194078714,
-0.3658869267,
-0.4806499481,
-0.4551312625,
0.2490636855,
-0.8434548974,
-0.6019793749,
0.3996556699,
-0.2037276179,
0.1721157879,
0.4627905488,
-0.8691952825,
0.4823207557,
0.8589646816,
0.7432673573,
-0.3752299845,
-0.5379016995,
0.0333985947,
0.1173603088,
-0.6839523315,
0.9740809202,
-0.6399080753,
-0.3215950131,
-0.0537993871,
-0.1508335322,
-0.2598998547,
-0.5984432697,
0.7634980083,
-0.1695129424,
-0.1363189667,
-0.5102466941,
-0.7748441696,
0.1722745448,
0.6327238083,
-0.2097217888,
0.9759331942,
0.161996454,
-0.5538756251,
0.4970061183,
-0.4966384768,
-0.2845363617,
0.2359445244,
-0.5171880722,
0.433055222,
-0.0654247254,
0.0179152582,
0.6110921502,
-0.4563755393,
0.4909470081,
-0.3267864585,
-0.5710975528,
0.4086268842,
0.0480795763,
0.5747408271,
0.1625289321,
-0.2388242781,
-0.0731999502,
-1.2292153835,
0.4248740971,
-0.0163765997,
0.078103058,
-0.6377390623,
-0.1121076792,
0.1237887964,
0.3027074039,
0.3606234789,
-0.5086895227,
-0.0901045352,
-0.07646586,
0.3711627126,
0.5040381551,
0.0595535934,
-0.0643189698,
-0.0517818518,
0.3978761733,
-0.1282571256,
0.0229282472,
0.0453810915,
-0.198724702,
-0.5327661037,
-0.6548118591,
-0.0667534173,
0.3124212027,
-0.3887187839,
0.7651910186,
0.0399787724,
-0.9966728687,
-0.4563699663,
0.0783118829,
0.352558881,
0.4837371707,
0.1727550775,
-0.2702615261,
-0.2368513942,
-0.9498971105,
-0.1076276153,
0.0329529494,
-0.2394589335,
0.2121949792,
0.4381320775,
-0.0856662467,
0.8028938174,
-0.8788728118,
-0.2351942658,
-0.2652353346,
0.0738872886,
0.3418662846,
0.2403190285,
0.42055884,
-0.5877764225,
-0.0260458216,
-0.2873381972,
-0.8685077429,
-0.2065625191,
0.0841117501,
-0.2826090455,
-0.2856616974,
0.4775510728,
-0.8748604655,
-0.1727520674,
0.2031176835,
-0.6693562269,
0.9236403704,
-0.1468966752,
0.0846093222,
-0.8499538302,
0.2555716038,
0.2539269924,
0.2145766616,
-0.7743879557,
0.3906473219,
0.3013858795,
0.1629374027,
-0.0696939528,
0.3143785596,
0.0239526965,
0.1296077371,
-0.0727063566,
0.4191723168,
0.0676969737,
0.4643374085,
0.4167154133,
0.6812067628,
0.4759045839,
-0.7367453575,
0.3567278385,
0.2050264776,
-0.5260523558,
0.7870911956,
-0.4809039831,
-0.073885344,
0.2238333821,
0.2083972096,
-0.929227829,
-0.1093400791,
-0.2862322628,
-0.1765333712,
0.1861618906,
0.4956896603,
-0.5653695464,
-0.297755599,
-0.3606514335,
0.1534818262,
0.320838362,
-0.2184404433,
0.2763346732,
0.196515128,
0.0223108251,
-0.6461116672,
-0.4145034254,
0.1387337297,
-0.1527466625,
-0.5654525161,
0.4080520868,
-0.1758003831,
-0.2789956331,
-0.1530882418,
-0.2288363278,
-0.0389134102,
0.1782475114,
-0.2536335588,
0.2152228206,
-0.2418482751,
0.3100567758,
-0.3077730238,
-0.020508619,
0.4315398633,
0.0584462136,
0.8243136406,
-0.2956654131,
-0.3498617113,
0.0698085204,
0.0148189859,
0.2828016579,
-0.2827013135,
0.2843775153,
0.672896266,
-0.5108546019,
-0.492459476,
-0.6738489866,
-0.2006167769,
-0.4240240753,
0.7521448731,
-0.7331901193,
-0.7524682283,
0.3874161839,
-0.1936824322,
-0.1901970208,
0.2478619069,
0.5576636791,
-0.0762943104,
0.7493926883,
0.5873679519,
0.1866873056,
0.0427142307,
-0.4596698582,
0.3192884922,
-1.0759497881,
-0.2194754034,
-0.3203350008,
-0.0452337973,
-0.3492756784,
-0.3945364058,
0.1919904053,
0.0892194584,
-0.5677021146,
0.2052939832,
-0.4804178178,
0.252264291,
0.2479188293,
0.0931724831,
0.443552047,
-0.1414084285,
-0.2557141185,
-0.3286631107,
-0.2474624664,
-0.6050710082,
1.1732860804,
0.3520072997,
0.7730386853,
0.0584951714,
0.4367644191,
0.1069667786,
0.0752561092,
-0.8319665194,
0.8354406357,
-0.0827376023,
-0.6572870612,
-0.2742462456,
-0.097615473,
-0.4800642729,
0.6957155466,
-0.0567110777,
-1.1951608658,
0.1672628969,
-0.3865378797,
-0.2668969035,
0.0537963361,
-0.5284858942,
0.5584819913,
-0.3115625381,
-0.3094444573,
-0.551002264,
-0.2928569913,
0.9151725173,
-0.5963750482,
-0.1673242748,
-0.336252898,
-0.1756540686,
0.7983187437,
-0.1533629596,
0.6595165133,
-0.1264168322,
-0.3121381104,
0.0912671462,
0.1431178302,
-0.1654914916,
-0.0041307998,
-0.0676483065,
-0.0747136548,
0.5553238988,
-0.3136089444,
-0.6179364324,
0.46824193,
-0.838360846,
-0.6995462179,
-0.3451411724,
-0.6075747013,
-1.1619364023,
0.2965379655,
0.1380308717,
0.2277791798,
-0.4793825746,
0.0344910398,
0.8418958187,
-0.1577096581,
0.1322003752,
0.8737195134,
-0.0866014138,
-0.0222722404,
0.6465349793,
-0.0101630231,
0.236002326,
0.2740158737,
0.0173038803,
-0.2701113224,
-0.455973655,
0.0443851575,
0.3229863346,
-0.847016573,
0.1098221466,
-0.6907821894,
-0.4575692117,
-0.334885776,
0.0155557422,
-0.4256282151,
-0.2702203095,
0.4032178223,
-0.1837610304,
0.0887195095,
0.3536251187,
0.060612943,
0.0618684292,
-0.3816160858,
0.5585206747,
0.0802402496,
0.6304767728,
0.3394664228,
-0.331736505,
-0.0841009989,
-0.2655912936,
-0.5614013672,
-0.4777251184,
0.0234594028,
0.0875698775,
0.7372531295,
0.7357047796,
0.0573517494,
0.7212043405,
-0.2428626269,
0.7873986363,
0.3767907619,
-0.9497964978,
0.6335520744,
-0.2811795175,
-0.018990593,
0.6558504105,
0.3852985501,
-0.579433322,
-0.548618257,
-0.6539732814,
-0.576320529,
0.87389189,
0.0484938696,
-0.0074375505,
0.0830857977,
0.2416935563,
0.0439255014,
0.3053590059,
-0.3483938873,
-0.2322290689,
-0.0335938148,
-0.2014375478,
-0.3331014216,
-0.1487735808,
-0.4365465343,
-0.4240427315,
0.3634147644,
-0.2874259055,
0.2416054606,
0.4291855097,
0.1587835848,
-0.0723160505,
0.3706505001,
0.4554980099,
0.9415092468,
-0.6276473403,
0.0000981454,
0.024738133,
-0.7457156181,
0.4140099585,
0.135994941,
-0.0273960792,
-0.1653877944,
0.6645317078,
0.4474925101,
0.0161159486,
-1.244946599,
0.4765342474,
-0.0875487477,
-0.3986542225,
-0.4043134451,
0.3567976654,
0.3675054312,
0.3051798344,
0.5096065402,
-0.1338170916,
0.2869158983,
-0.7872638702,
0.1570588946,
0.2951080501,
-0.1749781668,
-0.1930850893,
0.3614426851,
-0.14249897,
0.025414411,
0.3658016622,
-0.1412129402,
-0.3838391006,
0.7899667621,
0.6433836818,
0.8366174102,
-0.0508824922,
0.3331055641,
0.4299118817,
0.4202475548,
-0.1821821481,
0.5275823474,
-0.2705761492,
-1.1383213997,
-0.2978323698,
-0.594350338,
-0.6217907071,
0.5800015926,
-0.7005084753,
0.1653449535,
-0.6955184937,
-0.2519205511,
-0.1125872657,
0.3828909695,
-0.7154898047,
0.5684347749,
0.3225678504,
1.3471467495,
-0.7049280405,
0.8281043172,
0.9267601371,
-0.453194201,
-0.9142630696,
0.157845065,
-0.4037703872,
-0.9408346415,
0.5967541933,
0.0038748463,
-0.0593394451,
-0.4295296073,
-0.4574255645,
-0.8117019534,
1.2501957417,
0.2813454866,
-0.3817440271,
-0.1162918583,
0.2358717769,
1.07500422,
-0.4856174886,
0.4858951867,
1.1918547153,
0.5157540441,
-0.0243071672,
-0.8793136477,
0.2796019912,
-0.3605010211,
-0.2136213928,
-0.2556819916,
-1.0107051134,
0.7823269367,
-0.133176133,
0.0520669632,
-0.0713299215,
0.194609195,
0.8912831545,
0.3862365186,
0.2375448793,
0.3907244802,
0.9230138063,
-0.0735190958,
0.814699173,
-0.5634404421,
0.1241931245,
1.0090658665,
-0.6076453924,
0.8864431381,
0.3738405108,
-0.5223911405,
0.2486687452,
0.8073270917,
-0.2130398303,
0.6053783894,
0.216905579,
0.0620304383,
-0.5956192613,
-0.2699753642,
-0.4701477587,
0.4154230058,
0.8077716827,
-0.0752863213,
-0.1166441813,
-0.3496601582,
-0.2422076017,
0.2242871523,
-0.2745743394,
0.463113457,
0.4734800756,
-0.8059111238,
0.7473332882,
0.0710408837,
0.7797944546,
-1.0147509575,
0.3013977706,
-0.3492333889,
0.4561423957,
-0.2865302563,
-0.8928006887,
-0.1787923425,
-0.0054673688,
0.1439073235,
0.2098143548,
0.7637678385,
-0.2676430643,
-0.5620163679,
0.6245340705,
0.7777859569,
0.0297083948,
-0.0000870863,
-0.6597998738,
-0.2981486917,
-0.2864505947,
-0.339925617,
0.3799056411,
0.5558245182,
-0.1475267857,
0.9357718825,
0.343464911,
0.6942586899,
-0.3704959452,
0.3904715478,
0.6277733445,
-0.88131845,
-0.6712824106,
-0.5910821557,
-0.0820192173,
-0.2129605711,
-0.4959112704,
0.4614514112,
0.2320395112,
0.6743767858,
0.010854126,
0.9723502398,
-0.1132215559,
0.4428370595,
-0.3356828392,
0.5748625994,
-0.663073957,
0.2238107026,
-0.587256372,
-0.954805553,
-0.0863655284,
0.5591883063,
-0.3887508214,
0.0097368453,
1.1623824835,
0.5031732917,
-0.055348292,
0.1848919541,
0.6117052436,
0.082963638,
0.5078599453,
0.8518229723,
1.0856101513,
-0.161787197,
0.2111981362,
-0.4004497528,
-0.2446656078,
0.0834196508,
-0.4972014427,
-1.0340567827,
-0.5432131886,
-0.1491621435,
-0.1333254278,
-0.1369654685,
1.0213798285,
0.6138889194,
-0.7452825308,
-0.4185889661,
0.2680833638,
-0.3278775513,
-0.5632495284,
-0.2497522831,
0.6821953058,
-0.544203341,
-0.3415210843,
0.1746718287,
0.194789052,
-0.3622834384,
-0.4863598645,
-0.0301453583,
0.036922995,
0.1778783649,
0.7106230855,
-0.2374805063,
-0.8110512495,
-0.1774894446,
-0.0609690435,
-0.283564806,
-0.2116532773,
0.9169121981,
-0.5165781975,
0.1579823196,
0.152859211,
0.6134209037,
0.2899469435,
-0.0903581306,
0.5793179274,
-0.46143803,
0.1981465071,
0.2264186144,
0.5504015684,
0.255474329,
-0.2951084971,
0.9330822229,
0.3467130363,
-0.004441014,
-0.8336677551,
0.0134433126,
-0.9350777268,
-0.5916009545,
1.0915147066,
-0.1923699677,
-0.0387068912,
-0.2127534747,
-0.2915952504,
-0.2278891504,
-0.2692090869,
0.9934894443,
1.2251149416,
-0.4867968857,
-0.0419464596,
-0.5008329153,
0.6012222767,
0.5773075819,
-0.5654744506,
0.1317302287,
0.2531974018,
0.4615026116,
0.34804672,
0.9694492817,
-0.0132872118,
0.3923302889,
0.1502255499,
0.1997164041,
0.2879743278,
0.0604067966,
0.0527301058,
0.3513534069,
0.2780059874,
0.2376090735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09860v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09860v1
|
GSAP-NER: A Novel Task, Corpus, and Baseline for Scholarly Entity Extraction Focused on Machine Learning Models and Datasets
| 2023-11-16T12:43:02 | 2023-11-16T12:43:02 |
Wolfgang Otto, Matthäus Zloch, Lu Gan, Saurav Karmakar, Stefan Dietze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Named Entity Recognition (NER) models play a crucial role in various NLP
tasks, including information extraction (IE) and text understanding. In
academic writing, references to machine learning models and datasets are
fundamental components of various computer science publications and necessitate
accurate models for identification. Despite the advancements in NER, existing
ground truth datasets do not treat fine-grained types like ML model and model
architecture as separate entity types, and consequently, baseline models cannot
recognize them as such. In this paper, we release a corpus of 100 manually
annotated full-text scientific publications and a first baseline model for 10
entity types centered around ML models and datasets. In order to provide a
nuanced understanding of how ML models and datasets are mentioned and utilized,
our dataset also contains annotations for informal mentions like "our
BERT-based model" or "an image CNN". You can find the ground truth dataset and
code to replicate model training at https://data.gesis.org/gsap/gsap-ner.
|
[
-0.3375349641,
-0.4828606546,
0.4981704056,
-0.1542837024,
-0.1060428768,
0.0548502021,
-0.0355816931,
-0.5969724059,
0.2212071866,
0.6835378408,
-0.1039716303,
-0.5242442489,
-0.7937998772,
0.3660843968,
-0.6625993252,
1.3800333738,
0.116777055,
0.0516486615,
-0.4913448095,
-0.1284033805,
-0.0738612264,
-0.3773941696,
-0.39157933,
-0.235019505,
0.610153079,
0.2242559046,
0.3511584103,
0.4583871365,
0.9834250808,
0.1831197441,
-0.0723266006,
0.1809415221,
-0.1511519253,
-0.0610677861,
-0.1459682137,
-0.1288270652,
-0.583575666,
0.1894403398,
0.802292347,
0.7803186178,
0.0252772216,
0.6655366421,
0.082006678,
0.640910387,
-0.664116025,
0.1092336103,
-0.9302898049,
0.0003587949,
-0.3794511557,
-0.2429141551,
-0.5022501945,
-0.0971016586,
0.3049499393,
-0.8962019682,
0.426343292,
-0.0072697932,
1.4319007397,
0.2602131963,
-0.3982527554,
-0.4302175045,
-0.6808517575,
0.6188796163,
-0.5583046675,
0.1999152005,
0.3230777681,
0.3595069945,
-0.092193149,
-0.9796627164,
-0.4696235359,
-0.1817075312,
-0.2687907815,
-0.142472446,
-0.3363939524,
-0.1023780406,
0.4455974996,
0.1480380893,
-0.5943925381,
-0.1672393531,
-0.5581573248,
0.0276086722,
0.2289848328,
-0.1177868843,
0.3508363068,
-0.2404333651,
-0.3224646151,
0.4124359787,
-0.7704495788,
-0.2860992849,
0.1892013103,
0.3911516666,
0.1317043453,
0.6277323961,
-0.2085956335,
0.8043795228,
0.0843161345,
-0.0666268617,
0.3256625831,
-0.0005088042,
-0.4155750871,
-0.0308809802,
0.5254506469,
0.2160607725,
0.0274604168,
-0.5935724974,
-0.1138092875,
0.0681923553,
0.4137573242,
-0.6929747462,
-0.4318405688,
-0.0996416956,
-0.5420120955,
-0.4037839472,
0.0008569161,
-0.8117234111,
-0.2409064919,
-0.5679280162,
0.4693828821,
-0.2116377056,
-0.1565653235,
-0.2895774245,
-0.3160068393,
0.2588486969,
0.3072921336,
-0.7111957073,
0.8236324787,
0.6684535146,
0.8337293267,
-0.1295924783,
-0.0345338769,
-0.3763244748,
0.2755390406,
-0.2019535899,
0.8637449741,
-0.6553823352,
-0.1399495304,
-0.3976210952,
0.1941778809,
-0.0829674304,
-0.4098968506,
0.7548274398,
-0.8012235165,
0.3071795404,
-0.4484513998,
-0.6757308841,
-0.34079355,
0.2382626384,
-0.7011119723,
0.9568951726,
-0.027462434,
-1.1505099535,
0.5510846972,
-0.7836647034,
-0.1652226001,
0.579544425,
-0.2292509824,
-0.2892647982,
0.1231789589,
0.1395314038,
0.4355179965,
-0.4255142808,
0.6356337667,
-0.3527293205,
-0.2411078662,
-0.0416360497,
-0.2101308852,
0.8464917541,
0.1516134739,
-0.1615896225,
-0.156203717,
-0.9561816454,
0.0540147498,
0.3179877698,
0.0299362205,
-0.6665244699,
0.0420685709,
0.2260539681,
0.0353219099,
0.1279419214,
-0.5586101413,
0.3070982695,
0.155276075,
0.4633063078,
0.3596813381,
-0.0099793635,
0.4810093939,
-0.1141873226,
0.2509987056,
-0.520594418,
-0.3748749495,
-0.0399211906,
-0.4099609554,
-0.4423897266,
-0.5741091371,
0.7976940274,
0.5792822242,
-0.4421334267,
0.4082420468,
-0.5995550156,
-0.6444462538,
-0.6157565713,
-0.1318319142,
0.2503409684,
1.145283103,
0.6673346162,
-0.0414287969,
-0.7355003953,
-0.9033988118,
-0.1689653397,
-0.0389033258,
-0.1998494416,
0.3350096941,
0.84811759,
-0.1573576182,
1.1048167944,
-0.3712510765,
-0.1725275815,
0.0102443341,
0.4958665967,
0.0819136649,
0.4095618427,
0.3692436814,
-0.9839990735,
-0.3025717437,
-0.2721588612,
-1.0776611567,
-0.0238170903,
-0.1099054515,
-0.0276744608,
-0.0056187916,
0.368986994,
-0.5700504184,
0.2258442491,
0.3170198798,
-0.0864364803,
0.5737986565,
0.0579715818,
-0.0032671676,
-0.9044348001,
0.6556791067,
0.104974784,
0.0568382703,
-0.6510717869,
0.0995453894,
0.1541745663,
-0.144561097,
-0.0951697752,
0.7111678123,
-0.7794149518,
-0.3403130174,
-0.3203308582,
-0.0002483347,
0.1980775148,
-0.0063331998,
0.322904259,
0.8460127115,
0.5142742395,
-0.5779694915,
-0.2693317533,
0.477486819,
-0.3062808216,
0.6670382023,
-0.9384388924,
0.2980163693,
-0.3222289383,
0.365193069,
-0.4746151268,
-0.4318712354,
0.2889240384,
-0.4323095977,
0.373641938,
-0.4617612064,
-0.4235765338,
-0.159012571,
0.2242345512,
0.0689956695,
0.3052227795,
-0.5594482422,
0.5626710653,
0.8265355825,
-0.3970229328,
-0.8102450371,
-0.5122464895,
0.5137280822,
-0.3084502518,
-0.2626556754,
0.7211056948,
0.2082049847,
-0.2703230679,
0.4026815593,
-0.1493304074,
-0.312413007,
0.2241197675,
0.3098693192,
0.7224502563,
-0.1872171015,
0.186849013,
0.0494588204,
-0.2073269486,
-0.0302429497,
-0.085250698,
0.2292314768,
-0.2847183347,
-0.1392653883,
-0.3338533342,
0.2642301619,
0.3385542929,
-0.2495032847,
0.3885823786,
0.6235863566,
-0.7836632133,
0.1911485344,
-0.3498777747,
-0.0634038821,
-0.3564482629,
0.2480908036,
-0.5178164244,
-0.5947065949,
0.2775022089,
0.0251741316,
0.1127595305,
0.7834899426,
0.0785567686,
-0.2145488113,
0.577693522,
0.5485262871,
-0.1982396245,
0.1489026994,
-0.1599764675,
0.0793970823,
-1.2204660177,
-0.0906756595,
-0.888071835,
-0.1230691597,
-0.3594311178,
-0.1454652399,
-0.09996517,
0.1619163901,
-0.1975566149,
0.5418016315,
-0.8541981578,
0.5220999122,
0.575555861,
-0.237686649,
0.1421497464,
0.0407607257,
0.1394270509,
-0.1074890941,
-0.2275554985,
-1.2270900011,
1.2459106445,
0.1679252088,
0.3215751052,
-0.3133833706,
0.8574304581,
0.3893488348,
0.6954624057,
-0.5398724079,
0.5971801281,
-0.1488151252,
-0.7745937705,
-0.1052225083,
-0.3052935004,
-0.8903517723,
0.1311911643,
-0.2992326617,
-0.7767264843,
0.3943336606,
-0.1414204836,
-0.2364972085,
0.2555637062,
-0.325851351,
0.8468320966,
-0.0374582075,
0.1919892877,
0.2284071147,
-0.8570623398,
0.2865608335,
0.1170577481,
0.1659700572,
-0.2854524851,
-0.1236404404,
0.8645097017,
0.2270779759,
0.5264584422,
-0.3043805063,
0.2964740992,
0.211837545,
-0.083516188,
0.5704231262,
0.038262669,
-0.0808437541,
0.4911714792,
-0.008235815,
-0.3439532518,
-0.2145795077,
0.3408304751,
-0.5973341465,
-0.1632846743,
-0.6351805329,
-0.4475342631,
-0.0504364669,
0.3436620235,
0.373804301,
0.3806727529,
-0.5080352426,
0.3643328547,
0.544449091,
0.2146626562,
0.3151431084,
0.5626477003,
-0.0491701476,
-0.5622336268,
0.9950448871,
0.299749881,
-0.0668322667,
0.4418054223,
-0.3929904699,
-0.000157189,
-0.7380769253,
-0.4585692286,
0.0651677027,
-0.4681466818,
-0.2622771561,
-1.2228929996,
-0.3247320056,
-0.3484653533,
-0.0676368997,
-0.0380335823,
-0.4319720864,
-0.5361992717,
-0.1913127154,
-0.0507904552,
0.4165219367,
0.0694272146,
0.1720549315,
-0.850859046,
0.5062569976,
0.0592771247,
-0.1914470047,
-0.2658786476,
-0.506031692,
-0.0299942456,
-0.15213494,
-0.0080940407,
-0.7902360559,
0.5821591616,
0.4277995229,
0.6051493287,
0.1860299259,
-0.0383575149,
0.5776442885,
-0.7557630539,
0.6621089578,
-0.0916263387,
-0.7700819373,
0.4063259363,
-0.3195498288,
-0.1876669675,
0.8389317393,
0.7076252103,
-0.5305669308,
-0.0950183943,
-0.8740695119,
-0.9644092321,
0.3542045057,
-0.0623016059,
-0.0042281039,
-0.1841363609,
0.3595891595,
0.3712295592,
0.3754251897,
-0.7092645168,
-0.1347569823,
0.058994256,
-0.2009285539,
0.0317901298,
-0.1949945241,
-0.3955264091,
-0.0044803601,
0.8344888687,
-0.2855409384,
0.39579615,
0.2833483815,
-0.3955943882,
0.1729837805,
0.3233988285,
0.4119347036,
0.427357316,
-0.343208611,
0.2628363967,
0.0254133809,
-0.5866060257,
-0.1533389986,
0.3931948245,
-0.7767965794,
0.2402986586,
0.3523181081,
0.5864787698,
0.0776559487,
-0.3802675307,
0.2075787336,
0.070650965,
-0.1105882674,
-0.3853031397,
-0.1553229243,
0.0063019511,
-0.0071677775,
0.6342804432,
0.4449479282,
0.6009678841,
-0.1650445461,
0.4532692432,
0.4602934718,
-0.466938138,
-0.4913504422,
0.491471976,
-0.1053303331,
-0.0842188746,
0.7283576131,
-0.4500369728,
-0.2571729124,
0.7324421406,
0.6519632936,
0.9137393236,
0.2830657959,
0.5845102668,
0.5327215791,
0.2626209557,
-0.1623961627,
0.0437984243,
0.1109114736,
-0.6078545451,
-0.2625862658,
-0.7065335512,
-0.5372739434,
0.2911088169,
-0.9777498245,
0.2514918745,
-0.3523087204,
-0.2149291337,
0.5851752758,
0.1038719565,
-0.6639423966,
0.2810025215,
0.2362378091,
0.8606664538,
-0.9404699206,
0.8464040756,
0.6886952519,
-0.5350026488,
-0.4625565708,
0.0003577844,
0.0889239982,
-0.4375966191,
0.88009727,
0.313691467,
0.157161817,
0.0857768953,
-0.6603132486,
-1.1246311665,
1.138053298,
0.3802322447,
-0.445318073,
-0.3806739151,
-0.3935353756,
0.5569595098,
-0.7475243211,
0.3770941496,
0.2189695239,
0.5753734708,
-0.0484455228,
-0.5919731855,
0.063947469,
-0.5362882018,
-0.1583413333,
0.181453988,
-0.1359008849,
0.8597704172,
-0.1798250675,
-0.3740468323,
0.1060708091,
0.7450375557,
0.2836399972,
0.5517426729,
0.3212713301,
0.8063918948,
1.2150701284,
-0.0704515502,
0.6553257704,
-0.2189548761,
0.3438146114,
1.5653916597,
-0.5656183362,
0.9998213649,
0.4929981232,
-0.1677660048,
0.5716521144,
0.6640595794,
-0.614707768,
0.6612966657,
-0.0041124034,
-0.1084914953,
0.0968029723,
-0.2906465828,
-0.5299612284,
0.2708142102,
0.4116103053,
-0.4303261936,
-0.284317255,
-0.0951267555,
-0.0432862863,
-0.2269113958,
-0.1969479769,
0.8562201858,
-0.0940705389,
-0.2853454649,
0.1295683086,
-0.1856433898,
0.4401708245,
-0.3457683325,
-0.1681375951,
0.3107740879,
-0.3001931906,
-0.2992697358,
-0.5099300742,
0.5691587925,
0.2087762207,
-0.4414898753,
0.0353039429,
0.995423913,
-0.1151993051,
-0.5815361738,
0.0655297339,
0.3334953785,
0.3199900389,
-0.1214177981,
-0.6818842888,
-0.3873031139,
-0.3588779271,
-0.215097487,
0.3905353844,
0.4567483068,
0.0259412751,
0.4165900648,
0.754769206,
0.1787739098,
-0.1114790961,
-0.1998519003,
0.6578479409,
-0.5443283916,
-0.0888732001,
-0.6460745335,
0.5046966076,
-0.4930184484,
-0.4269484878,
0.4883830249,
0.6369033456,
0.6160271168,
-0.0706273839,
0.8655720353,
-0.4086163342,
0.7575317621,
-0.1833227575,
0.5857414007,
-0.4366573989,
-0.0008509301,
-0.3336934149,
-0.9096697569,
-0.3892227709,
0.4343769848,
-0.3809300065,
-0.3396401107,
0.5871855021,
0.5064609647,
-0.006396479,
0.1275149286,
0.0495069958,
-0.064433068,
0.1731628627,
-0.0726086125,
0.4731750786,
-0.5370456576,
0.2203617394,
0.0009233062,
-0.0533195511,
-0.2348952144,
-0.9755481482,
-0.5550672412,
-0.5740345716,
-0.4181966484,
-0.1450478733,
0.1927644908,
0.7831615806,
0.6757203341,
-0.9955893159,
0.3520127833,
-0.376180917,
-0.0049001528,
-0.2262155116,
-0.2503704429,
0.5156185627,
-0.5614287257,
-0.6646324992,
0.4075068235,
0.2394496053,
-0.0337236151,
0.0815200284,
0.173556447,
-0.2830079496,
-0.0132057769,
0.1745865196,
0.5758827925,
-0.6526314616,
-0.2347655147,
0.2119666487,
-0.4609678984,
0.0290919784,
0.4556587934,
-0.7143041492,
0.1404583901,
0.2617218196,
0.9391325712,
0.2820618153,
-0.1733644009,
0.2885567248,
-0.3333957493,
-0.1415161937,
0.414791584,
0.4427827597,
0.4364287257,
-0.4012729526,
0.9188122153,
0.3450701833,
-0.7661912441,
-1.1592314243,
-0.0246267244,
-1.0762867928,
-0.0919665918,
0.7768865228,
-0.3695186377,
-0.1863400936,
-0.0789304897,
-0.0411430337,
0.1332900524,
-0.2741390467,
0.7801626921,
0.6767951846,
0.1775822043,
-0.0298446137,
-0.8314825296,
0.4076895118,
0.0944476649,
-0.9869639277,
-0.0140303755,
0.4599549472,
0.3980245292,
0.5178902149,
0.6985498071,
-0.1571170539,
0.0542382188,
0.2144352198,
0.4709688723,
-0.0181124266,
-0.7753717303,
-0.1415999234,
0.4654632807,
-0.2184749842,
-0.0703860447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09841v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09841v1
|
Leveraging LLMs in Scholarly Knowledge Graph Question Answering
| 2023-11-16T12:13:49 | 2023-11-16T12:13:49 |
Tilahun Abedissa Taffa, Ricardo Usbeck
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.LG
|
This paper presents a scholarly Knowledge Graph Question Answering (KGQA)
that answers bibliographic natural language questions by leveraging a large
language model (LLM) in a few-shot manner. The model initially identifies the
top-n similar training questions related to a given test question via a
BERT-based sentence encoder and retrieves their corresponding SPARQL. Using the
top-n similar question-SPARQL pairs as an example and the test question creates
a prompt. Then pass the prompt to the LLM and generate a SPARQL. Finally, runs
the SPARQL against the underlying KG - ORKG (Open Research KG) endpoint and
returns an answer. Our system achieves an F1 score of 99.0%, on SciQA - one of
the Scholarly-QALD-23 challenge benchmarks.
|
[
-0.5026957989,
-0.968013823,
0.5777828693,
-0.1682554483,
-0.2081902623,
0.0806246772,
0.1915383786,
-0.3376706839,
0.1869868785,
0.7902139425,
-0.7180963755,
-0.6500781178,
-0.4761160314,
0.3195734322,
-0.2399965227,
1.0352883339,
-0.0209813695,
0.3948633671,
-0.4676667154,
-0.2141183019,
-0.0643609837,
-0.2273056656,
-0.6760193706,
-0.5028569698,
0.8407458663,
0.4454080462,
0.6014534831,
0.293821007,
0.534874022,
0.1560703069,
-0.1594146043,
0.1751999855,
-0.8758151531,
0.2423285395,
-0.0497444831,
-0.5474152565,
-0.0517571606,
-0.1485543251,
0.7865934372,
1.0588649511,
0.2969450653,
0.3604508638,
-0.0770105198,
0.6674224734,
-0.3632825017,
0.0626024082,
-0.6239104867,
0.087105535,
-0.2136514485,
-0.195251748,
-0.4167850018,
-0.7852537632,
0.1136089563,
-0.7256171107,
-0.0239711143,
0.3713156283,
0.8635256886,
0.1595498919,
-0.7056436539,
-0.4425973296,
-0.3061111271,
0.3479180932,
-0.5237762332,
0.4654033482,
0.4986992478,
0.4902557433,
-0.2528776228,
-1.0348263979,
-0.5680772066,
-0.1992939413,
-0.13644135,
0.2525438666,
-0.2005185187,
-0.0316616036,
0.2271566093,
0.1772290617,
-0.9082065225,
-0.1600617617,
-0.4069651663,
-0.1962030232,
0.3408717811,
0.3836993873,
0.1584030092,
-0.5066192746,
-0.3520498872,
0.0681269318,
-0.8561351299,
0.1375144869,
0.2606034577,
0.1762529314,
0.5270196199,
0.8891621232,
-0.4185023904,
0.8970583081,
-0.1761118025,
-0.0839129537,
0.0415939689,
-0.3172662258,
-0.1238267869,
0.0053908564,
0.7865368724,
0.2838151455,
0.3029590249,
-0.5950272679,
0.1933051199,
-0.4034176469,
0.0781642348,
-0.9776440263,
-0.2534083426,
0.085183844,
-0.217553854,
0.0110995397,
-0.1087888032,
-0.6470752358,
-0.3336727619,
-0.0046768263,
0.6661660075,
-0.620613277,
0.1353774518,
-0.1055556238,
-0.3004807532,
0.4528875649,
0.1358625591,
-0.6799587607,
0.1789593995,
0.5473858118,
0.7545763254,
0.0588251054,
-0.1074982882,
-0.76663059,
0.3998602331,
-0.4112812281,
0.7062997818,
-0.3429407179,
-0.4823693335,
0.0024800838,
-0.0160948317,
0.0227351971,
-0.4140997231,
0.4396690428,
-1.4252063036,
0.3282216787,
-0.7939887047,
-0.9324548244,
-0.2650054693,
0.79983145,
-0.5648236871,
1.3791503906,
0.2606602311,
-1.1228348017,
0.1628316045,
-0.6583252549,
0.0170323458,
0.4014728069,
0.0444180816,
0.0021848909,
-0.525503993,
0.2226181775,
0.4054481089,
-0.3693419397,
0.3458845317,
-0.4480821788,
-0.1899133027,
0.4475877583,
-0.1674652696,
1.0244472027,
0.1295690835,
0.1507261992,
-0.2257589251,
-0.6840196252,
0.2528668046,
0.0896818116,
-0.4366557896,
-0.4918040037,
-0.4331161082,
-0.3141180873,
-0.0340679921,
0.4214053154,
-0.8213928342,
0.5166121125,
-0.3965038657,
0.1065520346,
0.4744041264,
0.4385647774,
0.3716515899,
-0.3624217808,
0.6436041594,
-0.3980988562,
-0.1846899688,
0.1832696795,
-0.6820314527,
-0.5740411878,
-0.2025821358,
0.6574205756,
0.5739302039,
-1.2345972061,
-0.0687862933,
-0.540577054,
-0.6495500803,
-0.527971983,
0.3214358687,
0.2539448142,
0.9529717565,
0.2642692626,
-0.0825963989,
-0.180278793,
-0.8079147935,
-0.2356665134,
-0.4282929003,
-0.085846886,
0.4965763986,
0.7728616595,
-0.0159692038,
1.2961103916,
-0.9510694146,
-0.0739448443,
-0.1298324913,
0.3841691911,
0.2692526281,
-0.064685151,
0.4843886197,
-0.6696383953,
-0.6801913977,
-0.1219134629,
-0.948024869,
-0.3172075748,
0.3941354454,
-0.5180957317,
-0.0909832641,
0.5197489262,
-0.7769465446,
-0.0160373617,
0.2510189116,
-0.3505650461,
0.4699410796,
0.0958677381,
0.3156208396,
-1.2423145771,
0.2612936497,
-0.3367561996,
-0.1675793231,
-0.7205852866,
0.1797807217,
-0.0840639248,
-0.066368781,
-0.3484489322,
0.7090914249,
-0.1866125017,
-0.1843638867,
-0.1331148148,
0.4472810328,
0.0055222949,
0.3598245084,
-0.2576742172,
0.647746861,
0.2946634591,
-0.4905454218,
0.5084150434,
0.5945912004,
-0.3796471655,
0.3255335689,
-0.6416241527,
0.319558531,
-0.4822613299,
0.201760605,
-1.2733874321,
-0.3635080159,
0.3021875918,
-0.5578854084,
0.215388298,
-0.371737808,
-0.7317407727,
-0.5078873038,
-0.2946830094,
0.2085221708,
0.32561028,
-0.4945692122,
0.586725235,
0.1860017776,
-0.4423714578,
-0.7505300641,
-0.6359372735,
-0.0409795754,
-0.0774636492,
-0.9463089705,
0.2491358221,
-0.1850670576,
-0.0877601877,
0.3882830143,
0.2601138353,
-0.1048347056,
-0.027113134,
0.0619652271,
0.3535211682,
-0.2530341744,
0.275587827,
0.0034231732,
-0.0269384123,
0.2401763052,
-0.3275615275,
0.5770186782,
0.0203758646,
-0.3980104625,
0.0532356799,
0.2742308378,
0.4224999249,
-0.0227700602,
0.7187530994,
0.6922714114,
-0.2718237936,
0.0656765997,
-0.3560230732,
-0.265041858,
-0.4634231329,
0.4766333997,
-0.3128187656,
-1.4200507402,
0.5522007346,
-0.1291897595,
-0.052988898,
0.2526108325,
0.7337657809,
-0.3274913132,
0.6264333129,
0.2327928245,
-0.2581920624,
0.0541241579,
-0.3577179015,
0.2370865494,
-0.705265224,
-0.3667285442,
-0.702401042,
-0.2016266137,
-0.3901003301,
-0.3924053907,
0.8554877639,
0.3573541045,
-0.4586068094,
0.1545285136,
-0.2460802794,
0.4424160123,
0.8894774914,
0.0279576145,
0.4861663282,
-0.1506945342,
-0.3921182752,
-0.0459873192,
-0.9184145927,
-0.5236014128,
1.1487950087,
0.0905859619,
0.776319623,
0.3558292389,
0.6995416284,
0.0967143178,
0.619807303,
-0.7420422435,
0.7219497561,
0.1964798421,
-1.0434863567,
-0.5456725955,
-0.6400755048,
-0.907340169,
0.3365367949,
-0.1997299045,
-0.759357214,
-0.2351322323,
-0.0059481915,
-0.1805708408,
0.2223465443,
-0.3002417982,
0.8874913454,
-0.2360538542,
-0.2759723663,
0.3957087994,
-0.7975066304,
0.5131623745,
0.0074698161,
0.0884242877,
0.031433329,
0.1188083887,
1.0468139648,
-0.1154388562,
0.6800837517,
-0.2579743862,
0.1906936318,
0.565390408,
0.1936550587,
0.5015325546,
0.0118448585,
-0.1048770845,
-0.1748375446,
0.2656626403,
-0.3872554898,
-0.7716955543,
0.6029524207,
-0.9477548003,
-0.6828560829,
-0.3836949468,
-0.7709593773,
-0.6192266345,
0.3181143701,
0.137651369,
0.3816349506,
-0.2587085366,
0.3207334876,
0.6750656962,
-0.0969093069,
0.2106713504,
0.7338152528,
-0.4976678491,
-0.6053383946,
0.7196169496,
0.2692717314,
0.3619424701,
0.6452040672,
0.1927798688,
-0.5923695564,
-0.6724178195,
-0.612238884,
0.4492699206,
-1.0776091814,
-0.4596137702,
-0.8905230761,
-0.3332277238,
-0.6418083906,
-0.0291510597,
0.2094110548,
-0.3639221191,
-0.2662886083,
-0.1121182963,
0.6210626364,
0.7032628059,
0.2824468017,
0.316583693,
-1.0328713655,
0.3169873953,
0.6957061887,
0.0546438433,
-0.1379038543,
-0.7968143821,
-0.0875656232,
0.0199423376,
-0.3169276118,
-1.1694668531,
0.3457380533,
0.0881653056,
0.7918981314,
0.1753819585,
0.2089187354,
0.6142117381,
-0.5464135408,
0.8473479748,
0.0892075151,
-0.4939000607,
0.2584692538,
-0.4756473005,
0.3713839054,
0.9020192623,
1.1508164406,
-0.6511121392,
-0.476300776,
-0.265054673,
-0.6204111576,
0.4816714227,
0.0328589715,
0.0381842218,
-0.1441186666,
0.5457167029,
-0.026149651,
0.0934850499,
-0.8889642954,
-0.2825233042,
-0.1538208425,
-0.3687312901,
0.1942476481,
-0.3012783527,
-0.3662830591,
-0.1391126513,
0.9072500467,
-0.4674777389,
0.1042146236,
0.2638183832,
-0.1687900871,
-0.0661085993,
0.3605416715,
0.0866114274,
0.4536739886,
-0.294475317,
0.1570942551,
0.2868625522,
-0.3907187581,
-0.11230997,
0.2336276919,
-0.5320259929,
-0.0692297146,
0.3940107524,
0.4409297109,
0.0405045636,
-0.6418378353,
0.4490377605,
0.1479893178,
-0.6227107644,
-0.0660458729,
-0.076200217,
0.7588450909,
0.3628436327,
0.7351694107,
-0.5574511886,
0.1098040342,
-0.5080043077,
0.1293341219,
0.7213950753,
-0.3826625347,
0.2125742435,
0.655300796,
-0.0758411884,
-0.1689277887,
0.734534204,
-0.3578930199,
-0.82606709,
0.4707926512,
0.6076521277,
0.1923383772,
0.3002867401,
0.3811665475,
0.4032622874,
0.302624613,
0.2942225933,
0.4197013974,
0.1047843918,
-0.8641052246,
-0.4610746801,
-0.8440159559,
-0.6662403345,
-0.0544142649,
-0.546746254,
0.0537960641,
-0.1488367468,
-0.1372255534,
0.1990308315,
0.1467321515,
-0.4046194255,
0.1240461618,
-0.0540094934,
1.0673847198,
-0.7211821079,
0.8247976303,
0.7484055758,
-0.4424225986,
-0.8850398064,
-0.3258292973,
-0.1099799052,
-0.8404712081,
1.1114746332,
-0.2236898839,
-0.1209938228,
0.259006232,
-0.6835333109,
-1.000946641,
1.6496086121,
0.3924054503,
-0.2244523019,
-0.0703070536,
0.3898209333,
0.5770825744,
-0.1215483323,
0.1899332404,
0.3268082142,
0.4959993958,
0.5365979075,
-0.5324400663,
-0.0244690496,
-0.1275003403,
-0.3631015718,
0.328001529,
-0.5577557683,
0.518602252,
0.0057532699,
0.0112260701,
0.1319492757,
0.7691201568,
0.4666618407,
0.5152855515,
0.3416723609,
0.782666266,
1.0133042336,
-0.0787580684,
1.0226773024,
-0.3961424828,
0.4546933174,
0.9344718456,
-0.4052188396,
0.688447535,
0.5527334213,
-0.3186615407,
0.457277745,
0.770796001,
0.057027407,
0.6473950148,
0.2908776104,
-0.4859664142,
-0.2881033719,
-0.2998881042,
-0.3209002912,
0.4040406644,
0.1751184762,
-0.2588972151,
-0.5111524463,
-0.0468860045,
0.0573731959,
-0.1291399002,
-0.4605310559,
0.6321051121,
0.1649354994,
-0.8165634274,
0.3746124208,
-0.0353724398,
0.2880633771,
-0.8671255112,
0.1016600728,
-0.2230383158,
-0.4370736778,
0.0290603153,
-0.9535018206,
0.1029489264,
0.1295980811,
-0.2702379823,
-0.0394665003,
0.8691952825,
-0.5671072602,
-0.5856528282,
0.1261376739,
0.8349255323,
0.1790165752,
0.2974186838,
-0.5533081293,
-0.4096698463,
-0.165058285,
-0.2487511933,
0.4670210183,
0.6139458418,
0.1030789316,
0.9412236214,
0.6681164503,
-0.1459227949,
0.3002712727,
0.0984984711,
1.0789335966,
-0.5727696419,
-0.2786337435,
-0.5400096774,
0.0910022035,
-0.0801638588,
-0.3044201732,
0.883719027,
0.5403907299,
0.5891420841,
0.0843685493,
0.6149965525,
-0.1044903919,
0.6281068921,
-0.6067290306,
0.8058845997,
-0.3985170126,
0.0102393879,
-0.2370930016,
-0.6984303594,
-0.3513265252,
0.2966639102,
-0.5339890122,
-0.0663194433,
0.7486367226,
1.0170091391,
0.2566777468,
0.2307024002,
0.3347701728,
0.1647716463,
0.1094043031,
0.5549625754,
0.8335124254,
-0.2900920212,
0.9181281924,
-0.0548280515,
0.0642718151,
-0.0162703469,
-0.8327168226,
-1.0114564896,
-0.3691922724,
-0.204323858,
-0.614174664,
0.0673385486,
0.7035073638,
0.2203739434,
-0.6135380268,
0.0561652631,
0.2120919824,
0.1522384435,
0.3399882913,
-0.3230992556,
0.5015990734,
-0.2413838059,
-0.4632942975,
0.1907220334,
0.2210880816,
-0.1568069011,
-0.2256610543,
-0.1048828885,
-0.4932186604,
-0.0942196175,
0.5449010134,
0.0956143364,
-0.3702330589,
-0.4886868,
0.5239647031,
-0.3240618706,
-0.1935290545,
0.7245168686,
-0.7091876268,
0.3868504763,
0.5883837342,
1.2407244444,
0.9453970194,
0.0474628806,
0.1229872257,
-0.731462121,
-0.4876315594,
0.4827361107,
0.1997547597,
0.366551578,
-0.2618920505,
0.5721025467,
0.3557053804,
-0.7594730854,
-0.5637959838,
0.1941008568,
-1.2036370039,
-0.294852376,
1.1915547848,
-0.249609977,
-0.2964774072,
-0.3802248836,
-0.0688730255,
0.229753077,
0.0422887504,
0.4698970318,
1.0337269306,
-0.1988075823,
-0.190262109,
-0.6357610226,
0.1083571464,
0.2928295732,
-0.7172742486,
-0.2968234718,
0.4942058325,
0.6198374629,
0.1167740226,
0.9601078033,
-0.0793112889,
0.220384419,
-0.0699142739,
-0.1128680184,
-0.2063820213,
0.0582023524,
0.1028724834,
0.7716807127,
0.2577674985,
0.1359578818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09836v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09836v1
|
PELMS: Pre-training for Effective Low-Shot Multi-Document Summarization
| 2023-11-16T12:05:23 | 2023-11-16T12:05:23 |
Joseph J. Peper, Wenzhao Qiu, Lu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We investigate pre-training techniques for abstractive multi-document
summarization (MDS), which is much less studied than summarizing single
documents. Though recent work has demonstrated the effectiveness of
highlighting information salience for pre-training strategy design, it
struggles to generate abstractive and reflective summaries, which are critical
properties for MDS. To this end, we present PELMS, a pre-trained model that
uses objectives based on semantic coherence heuristics and faithfulness
constraints with un-labeled multi-document inputs, to promote the generation of
concise, fluent, and faithful summaries. To support the training of PELMS, we
compile MultiPT, a multi-document pre-training corpus containing over 93
million documents to form more than 3 million unlabeled topic-centric document
clusters, covering diverse genres such as product reviews, news, and general
knowledge. We perform extensive evaluation of PELMS in low-shot settings on a
wide range of MDS datasets. Our approach consistently outperforms competitive
comparisons with respect to overall informativeness, abstractiveness,
coherence, and faithfulness.
|
[
-0.4046012759,
-0.4164429307,
0.4940499067,
0.0237907451,
-0.6607130766,
0.2741516232,
-0.2109404653,
0.0943855643,
0.4112352729,
0.1669677198,
-0.5294370055,
-0.6800668836,
-0.8489854336,
0.1643370986,
-0.4462655485,
1.4700661898,
-0.0844229385,
-0.0329796858,
-0.2921225429,
-0.0185732804,
0.0560454614,
-0.826400578,
-0.185413301,
-0.1063813195,
0.716381371,
0.3089268506,
0.093530789,
0.1458601803,
0.5203995705,
0.1711671352,
0.1407036483,
0.4018466473,
-0.8067332506,
0.1940837055,
0.0035881335,
-0.2154325694,
-0.7469855547,
0.3077333868,
0.6985220313,
0.812341094,
0.0134433806,
0.4123711288,
0.4849418998,
0.6013892889,
-1.086532712,
-0.0425222479,
-0.6906556487,
0.0843113512,
-0.3940744698,
-0.3693754375,
-0.443241924,
0.1086415499,
0.2637222409,
-0.8361884356,
0.4226797223,
-0.1606726199,
0.8562374115,
0.0710497573,
-0.4389277399,
-0.1018213853,
-0.4981229305,
0.9082582593,
-0.6056703925,
0.2705792189,
0.4749285281,
0.0390502773,
0.2250618339,
-0.8810492754,
-0.2635814548,
0.1288479567,
-0.1673072577,
0.5307325125,
0.2165692002,
0.0813074484,
0.0275722798,
0.230305478,
-0.5338560343,
-0.2497812361,
-0.2980653048,
-0.308037281,
0.6714777946,
0.2202365398,
-0.3818194568,
0.3431535959,
-0.2271590084,
0.0438991487,
-0.6935244799,
-0.0130416257,
0.4559624791,
0.1985877752,
-0.3243405521,
0.6646849513,
-0.3512236178,
0.6818914413,
0.102119863,
-0.4327117801,
0.2856975794,
-0.9329550862,
-0.2065440863,
0.1459892988,
0.6678447127,
0.2558798194,
-0.1350423992,
-0.0631042123,
-0.2419286668,
0.1097433269,
0.3205111325,
-0.8516126275,
-0.356323719,
0.051321853,
-0.6488302946,
-0.4125625491,
0.1674836874,
-0.5468209982,
-0.1466955394,
-0.5168398619,
0.3379542828,
-0.4898231626,
-0.0506010465,
-0.0552105904,
-0.3925223649,
0.0927189589,
0.5545207262,
-0.8559103012,
0.3061024845,
0.5317765474,
0.7400273085,
-0.2417407632,
-0.7854717374,
-0.7323346734,
0.574732244,
-0.3306278884,
0.9377312064,
-0.4204361141,
-0.4704552889,
-0.2597338259,
-0.2782693803,
-0.2554650009,
-0.1297601461,
0.4085365832,
-0.1096036136,
0.3742058873,
-0.1376163065,
-0.513210237,
0.1524072737,
0.6694399118,
-0.1641166657,
0.6750177145,
0.0818554983,
-0.9332635999,
0.4929949343,
-0.6665756702,
-0.7120139599,
-0.4153185785,
-0.2211863548,
-0.6701640487,
0.3798241913,
0.1996991634,
0.4551407993,
0.1577205658,
0.0986353233,
-0.1834089756,
-0.3799019754,
-0.1787585318,
-0.4256323576,
0.2984095514,
0.13784796,
-0.0283807144,
0.4376354516,
-0.5657272339,
0.0149027305,
0.0970894918,
-0.5839099884,
-0.2523640096,
-0.1336532682,
-0.2598298192,
0.0486695692,
0.2120380402,
-0.2424712181,
0.0428237282,
-0.4691308439,
0.0699616671,
0.4746008515,
0.0693485141,
0.5467035174,
-0.5078533292,
0.3245337605,
-0.021949809,
0.4511508942,
-0.873309195,
-0.2647521496,
-0.4378328323,
-0.5246770382,
0.2792953551,
0.1330671161,
-0.6061566472,
0.4117906392,
-0.2232337296,
-0.5903868079,
-0.1925676465,
0.1242865026,
0.6638486385,
0.6276039481,
0.3815930784,
-0.4724420607,
-0.6031202674,
-0.7738243341,
-0.3546289504,
0.1297082454,
0.0530163608,
-0.1604579985,
0.6174557209,
0.220911175,
0.7734012604,
-0.4614149332,
-0.458335042,
-0.3028265238,
0.4785119891,
-0.0445247032,
0.2926869392,
0.5118824244,
-0.6982319951,
-0.6908398867,
-0.6199061871,
-0.635866642,
0.1562118828,
0.0166024193,
0.0479268469,
0.2234012187,
0.3933335245,
-0.4971027672,
0.5013650656,
0.4917483628,
-0.2056440264,
0.6280242801,
-0.6168521643,
0.1408695579,
-0.9710267186,
0.1793714464,
-0.429990977,
-0.187690258,
-0.4249098599,
-0.2964720428,
0.0227512978,
-0.3247080147,
-0.7476648092,
0.2690089941,
-0.7644725442,
-0.1925928742,
-0.1319239736,
0.0335451625,
0.6176652908,
0.4173745215,
0.1753167212,
0.5567342043,
0.3936131597,
-0.6523451805,
0.0778213069,
0.2161949873,
-0.0206173342,
0.7721523046,
-0.4506883621,
0.0840022564,
-0.3517763913,
0.4975818396,
-0.655403018,
-0.1035501957,
0.067854248,
-0.3993664682,
0.4773581326,
-0.1032482907,
-0.3108999133,
-0.2015684545,
-0.7662215233,
0.2569961548,
0.3154525757,
-0.1416042894,
0.743676126,
0.3822506368,
-0.333173573,
-0.5737328529,
-0.3662583828,
0.0648744702,
-0.0139170978,
-0.321356982,
0.5777378082,
-0.0295872185,
-0.1122257933,
0.0522944219,
-0.191948548,
-0.0554456525,
0.2480301559,
0.2073529661,
0.1625218242,
-0.0045603951,
0.037103124,
0.2569900453,
-0.2032005042,
-0.2398126721,
-0.4563113153,
0.7054895759,
-0.1673769951,
-0.677868247,
-0.2943488359,
0.63828969,
0.4708705842,
-0.6296014786,
0.7363899946,
0.4458265305,
-0.1452338994,
0.1350154877,
-0.3060745895,
-0.1968815625,
-0.2935895026,
0.3599404991,
-0.5518826842,
-0.2362849414,
0.2286975831,
-0.1050235182,
0.3020641208,
0.5796558857,
0.4819397032,
-0.5261791348,
0.8670456409,
0.6500347257,
0.2599845529,
0.452475816,
-0.5502431989,
-0.2040929347,
-0.6888504624,
-0.4929564893,
-0.3478181064,
-0.254414767,
0.3898100555,
-0.2233614326,
0.4206195772,
0.2278063595,
-0.1356350183,
-0.0978477448,
-0.4976668656,
0.6144298315,
0.5814658403,
-0.0279137399,
0.4372027814,
-0.0763296708,
-0.0680074543,
0.0325087197,
-0.8633833528,
-0.5505351424,
1.475585103,
0.0890740603,
0.8123395443,
-0.2155341506,
1.1588464975,
0.1347690076,
0.3462211192,
-0.49021703,
0.1761239171,
-0.2951048911,
-0.4279982448,
-0.3545559347,
-0.0798488557,
-0.9801931381,
0.2380362302,
-0.6178169847,
-0.0654875264,
0.0545647703,
0.3455034792,
-0.5663333535,
0.1523183435,
-0.7384163737,
0.9068132043,
-0.6028245091,
-0.2184150517,
-0.249710992,
-0.8538128138,
0.2410278618,
-0.336304605,
0.071668759,
-0.0909481198,
-0.3774491549,
0.7602146268,
-0.5315865278,
0.7225145698,
-0.181037277,
0.1494334042,
0.1589806378,
-0.2339834124,
0.4435121417,
-0.0906352177,
0.1855195016,
0.2702306509,
0.1752699018,
-0.6808567047,
-0.2934549153,
0.1875528544,
-0.6088941097,
-0.3826754689,
-0.454525888,
-0.4798355997,
-0.1233176142,
0.5396255255,
0.8066279888,
0.5088678002,
-0.455489248,
0.2435971797,
0.7081383467,
0.1117140576,
0.3956333995,
0.4965411127,
-0.1216505244,
-0.4803979099,
0.8393791914,
0.384262532,
0.2110065222,
0.345010221,
-0.0062101833,
-0.2678174973,
-1.1151782274,
-0.2406020761,
0.1679018438,
-0.5828824639,
-0.0863404348,
-0.7800962329,
-0.2071234435,
-0.6059529781,
-0.41365996,
-0.568987906,
-0.2276278734,
-0.2951372564,
0.1159476787,
-0.2178179473,
0.6957842708,
0.1812375039,
0.3193724453,
-1.071803689,
0.5244110227,
0.209572807,
0.2058444917,
-0.3843401968,
-0.544965446,
-0.4830077589,
0.0922636539,
-0.3895538449,
-0.7631415129,
0.343611598,
0.4137679338,
0.9003010392,
0.4105215967,
0.2886114717,
0.4181629717,
-0.4049052298,
0.6917166114,
0.5353672504,
-0.8583282828,
0.8213565946,
-0.4174950421,
0.2957724631,
1.0072249174,
0.3439632952,
0.0155793335,
-0.4159086049,
-0.7315144539,
-0.7603414059,
0.6025033593,
0.2185474485,
0.1356889606,
0.2147985846,
0.1597218961,
0.3491106033,
0.6311619878,
-0.2128120661,
-0.1190550029,
-0.6130657196,
-0.4696630836,
-0.3382274806,
-0.4527029693,
-0.5204585791,
-0.1319216043,
0.7590739727,
-0.2825978994,
-0.1618999243,
0.3649283051,
-0.3259992599,
0.3168329298,
0.2275469899,
0.8910035491,
0.8626766205,
-0.2851466238,
0.4107167125,
0.1359773129,
-0.6477577686,
0.1466171294,
0.2315030694,
-0.2142912,
0.1484727412,
0.5209565163,
0.6740127802,
0.1385678649,
-0.4328100085,
0.8387886882,
-0.2162011266,
-0.4693188667,
-0.2524843216,
-0.283893168,
-0.0442092009,
-0.0722495019,
0.276438266,
0.1809761673,
-0.0613421202,
-0.6051414609,
0.0516848713,
0.4588037431,
-0.1630771011,
-0.2953036129,
0.4446905255,
0.5329357386,
-0.0562506393,
0.2216778994,
-0.3018650115,
-0.3643615544,
0.2074090242,
0.2839488983,
0.6289781332,
0.0073152315,
0.1103861704,
0.0300877858,
0.3001629114,
-0.0589090027,
0.1101969704,
-0.2789455652,
-0.4003959596,
-0.4048118293,
-0.55486238,
-0.5018132329,
-0.0609911904,
-0.4578352571,
0.4834964871,
-0.4113923311,
-0.1742765903,
-0.0018714002,
0.0883373097,
-0.5029023886,
0.0508145206,
0.0722639114,
0.7951927781,
-0.7881095409,
0.8348371983,
0.6855124831,
-0.5929627419,
-0.5119429231,
0.0581591241,
0.0609030947,
-0.4412903488,
0.5758116245,
-0.0568849035,
-0.1170007661,
0.1628747433,
-0.2465346754,
-0.6761136651,
1.199742794,
0.5517248511,
-0.4510641992,
-0.2854259312,
-0.240224421,
0.2374958694,
-0.4897456169,
0.0049326504,
0.2680358291,
0.362706393,
0.0878491327,
-0.861715138,
-0.4912314117,
-0.2084450871,
-0.4970798194,
0.0834442899,
-0.4380944967,
1.1231459379,
-0.2656336725,
-0.0915186256,
-0.0821419582,
0.2768906951,
0.364525795,
0.7081012726,
0.348551929,
0.6632138491,
0.9440869093,
-0.052537784,
1.31825459,
-0.316726923,
0.2185970545,
1.6467168331,
-0.2633958161,
0.6156167984,
0.5499274135,
-0.0683921054,
0.2415972948,
0.670558393,
0.0663375556,
0.792306304,
-0.0469072759,
-0.3349993527,
-0.1936727166,
-0.136523217,
-0.6191794872,
0.4013405442,
0.196052283,
-0.4777344465,
-0.4382503927,
0.0812094137,
-0.0870483965,
0.1335743368,
-0.4134634733,
1.0756739378,
0.0495402291,
-0.6332889795,
0.4397498369,
-0.2230712324,
0.7589777112,
-1.0474553108,
0.1077935994,
-0.1093294621,
0.2134112418,
-0.2479159981,
-0.6496235728,
0.4284309745,
-0.0498577841,
-0.4710750878,
-0.3929450512,
1.0088295937,
-0.5001674294,
-0.3366111815,
0.0400457084,
0.7374202013,
0.187004149,
-0.4524877369,
-0.6131575108,
-0.132571429,
-0.4254239798,
-0.2013774216,
0.5160043836,
0.2877346277,
0.1489238888,
0.1573840231,
0.7784777284,
0.2610929012,
-0.0760216564,
0.1351059824,
0.8937948942,
-0.2182652056,
-0.662435472,
-0.9637879133,
0.5473601222,
-0.4095622599,
-0.1470439881,
0.9191445112,
1.0523587465,
0.8078632355,
-0.1097724289,
0.8414247632,
0.4172251225,
0.4413719773,
-0.5228594542,
0.9191524386,
-0.3729764223,
0.1003211662,
-0.0513661131,
-1.0369381905,
-0.2689695358,
0.3015208244,
-0.4030390084,
-0.2530163825,
0.7895582914,
0.2741639614,
-0.0359750018,
-0.3935354948,
0.3991266787,
-0.1507669985,
0.1928725094,
0.5037229061,
0.9502094388,
-0.1949454248,
0.8225539327,
-0.3164179921,
-0.1761265993,
-0.163063854,
-0.9944247007,
-1.0569919348,
-0.4379300177,
-0.1284798831,
-0.1770630479,
0.1085797921,
0.7049617171,
1.0109425783,
-0.6252340674,
0.1552066505,
0.0636772811,
0.1410225183,
0.0306724515,
-0.0590995587,
0.3957181871,
-0.5085766315,
-0.5336312652,
0.3373547196,
0.6705803275,
0.4912396073,
-0.1673759967,
-0.3822541535,
-0.1977569312,
0.0153534524,
0.7379902601,
0.0995227173,
-0.3916152418,
0.184256658,
-0.0720533431,
-0.1386530548,
0.0638906136,
1.0307152271,
-0.7150402069,
0.397680074,
0.5370445848,
0.4392002523,
0.7351222038,
0.0125456536,
0.4882288277,
-1.1117435694,
0.4101437628,
0.3666326106,
0.4692657888,
0.1435686797,
-0.0714471862,
0.4003590345,
0.4650884867,
-0.077132307,
-0.8867281079,
0.1002592817,
-0.6747492552,
-0.4726617038,
0.7062208056,
-0.5791720152,
-0.0732807294,
-0.4166119695,
-0.3923537135,
0.3451206684,
-0.1788851172,
0.5815067291,
0.5388233066,
-0.1867839247,
-0.0768050924,
0.1274530292,
0.5139052868,
0.2934519053,
-1.1434516907,
0.0227414276,
0.6061879992,
0.0794396326,
0.3998546898,
1.1460725069,
-0.1443867087,
0.1308428049,
0.2894152105,
-0.0926387906,
-0.5724599361,
-0.6457806826,
-0.2426072061,
0.4813274443,
0.0011329582,
-0.1970758438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09835v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09835v4
|
ML-Bench: Evaluating Large Language Models and Agents for Machine Learning Tasks on Repository-Level Code
| 2023-11-16T12:03:21 | 2024-06-18T12:49:41 |
Xiangru Tang, Yuliang Liu, Zefan Cai, Yanjun Shao, Junjie Lu, Yichi Zhang, Zexuan Deng, Helan Hu, Kaikai An, Ruijun Huang, Shuzheng Si, Sheng Chen, Haozhe Zhao, Liang Chen, Yan Wang, Tianyu Liu, Zhiwei Jiang, Baobao Chang, Yin Fang, Yujia Qin, Wangchunshu Zhou, Yilun Zhao, Arman Cohan, Mark Gerstein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-4 achieving impressive results
in function-level code generation, they struggle with repository-scale code
understanding (e.g., coming up with the right arguments for calling routines),
requiring a deeper comprehension of complex file interactions. Also, recently,
people have developed LLM agents that attempt to interact with repository code
(e.g., compiling and evaluating its execution), prompting the need to evaluate
their performance. These gaps have motivated our development of ML-Bench, a
benchmark rooted in real-world programming applications that leverage existing
code repositories to perform tasks. Addressing the need for LLMs to interpret
long code contexts and translate instructions into precise, executable scripts,
ML-Bench encompasses annotated 9,641 examples across 18 GitHub repositories,
challenging LLMs to accommodate user-specified arguments and documentation
intricacies effectively. To evaluate both LLMs and AI agents, two setups are
employed: ML-LLM-Bench for assessing LLMs' text-to-code conversion within a
predefined deployment environment, and ML-Agent-Bench for testing autonomous
agents in an end-to-end task execution within a Linux sandbox environment. Our
findings indicate that while GPT-4o leads with a Pass@5 rate surpassing 50%,
there remains significant scope for improvement, highlighted by issues such as
hallucinated outputs and difficulties with bash script generation. Notably, in
the more demanding ML-Agent-Bench, GPT-4o achieves a 76.47% success rate,
reflecting the efficacy of iterative action and feedback in complex task
resolution. Our code, dataset, and models are available at
https://github.com/gersteinlab/ML-bench.
|
[
-0.3609935939,
-0.5838823318,
0.5699619055,
0.1359358728,
0.0436721146,
0.0699497312,
-0.3935948908,
-0.345836252,
-0.3812212944,
0.3821054995,
-0.4125083089,
-0.7185569406,
-0.5820969343,
0.2015663087,
-0.5573441386,
0.9248646498,
-0.3058305979,
0.2491571009,
-0.4494473338,
-0.1199982986,
-0.2801074684,
-0.5373101234,
-0.248519659,
-0.4558143914,
0.3398364186,
0.2189869732,
0.3752217889,
0.633208096,
0.7641642094,
0.4265404642,
0.3957961798,
-0.0850032419,
-0.505880177,
0.3198238313,
-0.1709912419,
-0.4643666744,
-0.3574331105,
0.0594778694,
0.6291111708,
0.4571995735,
0.0124353366,
0.288780421,
-0.0860490799,
0.7471036315,
-0.6718088388,
0.4958726168,
-0.5076678395,
0.0219638199,
0.0111667067,
-0.0588183068,
-0.3756953776,
-0.1183332503,
0.0719102845,
-0.524780333,
0.2011145055,
-0.2919829488,
0.7444956303,
0.678119421,
-0.1060167849,
-0.2591557503,
-0.6031138897,
0.7650581598,
-0.5407218337,
0.1269053668,
0.3585672677,
0.524987936,
-0.1455917358,
-0.8985812664,
-0.2409475893,
-0.6308386922,
0.0645059049,
0.0384884216,
-0.091109857,
-0.0260075573,
0.5191619396,
0.2231607288,
-0.7553285956,
0.0933032706,
-0.0674749613,
-0.0347653329,
0.48195225,
0.1016584933,
0.0284553356,
0.1114802659,
-0.2269880176,
-0.3876260221,
-0.6099372506,
-0.0361987464,
0.1951834261,
0.165943414,
0.0910956934,
0.4849121571,
-0.2370105982,
0.6246256828,
-0.218843326,
0.1513876021,
0.5387188792,
-0.2471797913,
-0.3613601327,
-0.2892362177,
0.6170117259,
0.3275983334,
0.2996260524,
-0.2877824008,
-0.6690962911,
0.2469237596,
0.5624152422,
-1.0382653475,
-0.181278795,
0.29592821,
-0.3270181119,
-0.2435331792,
-0.1313805133,
-0.5482768416,
-0.7025017142,
-0.5648398995,
0.3786376715,
-0.3623409569,
-0.1248181984,
-0.3071281314,
-0.1432898343,
0.3980862498,
0.3075877726,
-0.4979943931,
0.4300385714,
0.7581226826,
0.6454984546,
-0.2753803134,
-0.5327305794,
-0.7440795898,
0.0434776768,
-0.4036646485,
0.7286304832,
-0.5344612598,
-0.3267077208,
0.0667051226,
-0.02541597,
-0.1607421339,
-0.75364995,
0.3990130424,
-0.2592848539,
-0.1331293583,
-0.1549156159,
-0.6545990705,
0.1286307275,
0.671108067,
-0.5948831439,
1.0137975216,
0.4880514443,
-0.2225664556,
0.3325801492,
-0.8273693919,
-0.3672278225,
0.0691938922,
-0.5389942527,
-0.4616811275,
-0.1310098618,
0.1196164116,
0.6410006881,
-0.4288499057,
0.1734107882,
-0.3150064647,
-0.6741104126,
0.3849253654,
-0.0928958207,
0.2325493991,
0.1371009648,
-0.8755618334,
0.4341151714,
-0.5848299265,
0.1067240313,
0.0821895376,
-0.3382820487,
0.0370832011,
0.0022018191,
0.1094103828,
0.141648829,
0.2283251435,
-0.2281291336,
0.1665758342,
-0.1248133928,
0.3983508646,
0.7566043139,
-0.347143203,
0.4193132222,
-0.2990377247,
0.517893672,
-0.3118080199,
0.2554632723,
-0.114586249,
-0.3413296938,
-0.5259916782,
-0.2759676874,
0.3838757873,
0.5488461852,
-0.7673056722,
0.2325047106,
-0.3228276968,
-0.6212935448,
-0.4247787595,
0.411120981,
0.7178874016,
0.3163638115,
0.3359000683,
-0.279553324,
-0.4435120523,
-0.9472831488,
-0.2120613158,
-0.2004169971,
-0.1634444743,
0.4976089001,
0.7361558676,
-0.5514631271,
0.6980606914,
-0.1106030568,
-0.2178708166,
-0.1192616075,
0.2611946166,
0.1738685668,
0.4143894017,
0.5893108845,
-0.7089421749,
-0.5061711669,
0.1771591604,
-0.926022172,
-0.2227247655,
0.0731798708,
0.0774611309,
0.430711478,
0.5877266526,
-0.7042840719,
0.117412895,
0.60834378,
-0.0537041835,
0.6115677357,
-0.1949107647,
0.2335197926,
-0.7355701923,
0.3758433163,
0.0837740824,
-0.2612525821,
-0.3981257081,
0.4111713469,
0.2299061269,
-0.1538556367,
-0.2506702244,
0.4188677073,
-0.4735928774,
-0.5630689263,
-0.2445732057,
0.000204051,
-0.1759437621,
0.5474521518,
-0.2020317614,
1.0000171661,
0.3609067202,
-0.3238535821,
0.3905653358,
-0.2103937715,
-0.3947204351,
0.3688004911,
-0.5622655153,
0.2317201644,
0.36223948,
0.4070140421,
-0.7743110061,
-0.3457509279,
0.221327588,
-0.2992646694,
0.4885107577,
-0.2792647183,
-0.660194397,
-0.3799479008,
-0.31935063,
0.16246894,
0.5181214809,
-0.2388489842,
0.5013493299,
0.4252001643,
0.0362086557,
-0.8455823064,
-0.5850974917,
0.1570049375,
-0.0267384201,
-0.3254037201,
0.2646379769,
-0.0809050649,
-0.429766506,
0.0412643291,
-0.1073712111,
-0.1191218793,
0.1698088348,
0.4689245522,
0.1250012517,
-0.2662625611,
0.1489312202,
-0.2927129865,
-0.2445961088,
0.2118768245,
-0.3374921381,
0.4740360081,
-0.5149226189,
-0.501180768,
-0.1490337253,
0.0438754894,
0.8111246824,
-0.0754126534,
0.4259525239,
0.8981962204,
-0.3062199652,
-0.2677018046,
-0.6037610173,
-0.1299729198,
-0.4029637575,
0.3832521141,
-0.6424252987,
-0.704398632,
0.3682419956,
-0.3136484027,
0.1547523439,
0.3582254648,
0.9130239487,
-0.0776877478,
0.7761324048,
0.3090507686,
-0.2611145675,
0.4902017415,
-0.4464803338,
-0.0644153357,
-0.4517141581,
0.0426147133,
-0.5569345951,
-0.4505394101,
-0.605383873,
-0.7475445867,
0.156738013,
-0.1069858894,
-0.3725418448,
0.4389557242,
-0.5666755438,
0.567043066,
0.5607284904,
-0.0208039675,
0.0397865884,
-0.2327326536,
-0.0975302458,
0.2471454591,
-0.4061254263,
-0.5274063349,
1.3260992765,
0.4795596898,
0.6032905579,
-0.0302868858,
0.7280961871,
0.6351312399,
0.6057593822,
-0.5623350143,
0.5019721389,
-0.0655607805,
-0.4506988525,
-0.3676191568,
-0.5117982626,
-0.9886510968,
0.2473688722,
0.1371855885,
-0.61302495,
-0.1199614257,
-0.0205788035,
0.0068541984,
-0.0503619052,
-0.9818910956,
1.2817271948,
-0.2359948605,
-0.4207412302,
-0.2416522205,
-0.607441783,
0.2934383154,
-0.1695758104,
0.0910468623,
-0.1959147155,
-0.2600914836,
0.3928292692,
-0.4426093698,
0.7359449267,
-0.4398643374,
-0.0440566055,
0.1572251469,
-0.0021291873,
0.7124890685,
-0.0664402246,
-0.2723070681,
0.0630789101,
0.0279194973,
-0.5309048891,
-0.5605330467,
0.9097296,
-1.013485074,
-0.3445864618,
-0.2272334546,
-0.8014236689,
-0.2582319081,
0.0683767274,
-0.0797843114,
0.3269112706,
-0.2047391683,
0.2813176215,
0.5351977944,
-0.1884026825,
0.286221385,
0.5652667284,
-0.2466038913,
-0.2134006321,
0.9749848247,
-0.038425561,
0.0685962811,
0.4020834863,
-0.1662844121,
-0.3701780736,
-0.7827369571,
-0.7186937928,
-0.0658399984,
-0.8140782714,
-0.1907741725,
-0.4649513364,
-0.2053344846,
-0.3231417537,
-0.0149550587,
-0.3919216096,
-0.2385740727,
0.0401301906,
0.1248036325,
0.2206035107,
0.7782910466,
0.12782754,
-0.0105290785,
-0.7266120315,
0.2149119079,
0.1161829904,
0.3745711148,
-0.3453376889,
-0.201660648,
-0.4353118539,
-0.2245656401,
-0.191245988,
-0.5622557998,
0.2283109576,
-0.0614373982,
0.7845993042,
0.0335573778,
0.0100881904,
0.4185452461,
-0.3666735291,
0.5228900909,
-0.1278776526,
-0.8358772397,
0.3951478601,
-0.499974221,
0.3287760615,
0.679864049,
0.2256678343,
-0.1147246733,
-0.4697602391,
-0.3195804954,
-0.7319781184,
0.6049351692,
0.4484428763,
-0.1511937082,
0.4022767842,
0.2451272309,
0.1062349305,
0.3269912302,
-0.677210331,
-0.1211848333,
-0.0138212126,
-0.1391499639,
-0.3561137319,
0.0905135423,
-0.3232697248,
-0.0625745654,
0.4765691161,
-0.311067611,
0.3441971242,
0.0137234079,
-0.4958451986,
-0.079972893,
0.2341914922,
0.6063529849,
0.843716085,
-0.3667623699,
-0.0097660534,
0.1255326569,
-0.338427186,
0.0576379038,
0.6137937307,
0.0879704803,
-0.0570495129,
0.4443199635,
0.5365547538,
0.2422013432,
-1.0049951077,
0.5663871169,
-0.2713704705,
-0.4107056558,
-0.2722966075,
0.230437994,
0.0739210173,
0.4819899499,
0.3651361763,
0.090365544,
0.1624207348,
-0.5220713019,
0.3524235785,
0.2567529976,
-0.4169735014,
0.0364280194,
0.3163312376,
0.3603688478,
-0.2339734584,
0.6404933333,
-0.3418726921,
-0.5195943117,
0.8602297902,
0.2636551857,
0.9355894327,
-0.0917872116,
0.0949533209,
0.1504769325,
0.3125681877,
0.0951499045,
0.1195515916,
-0.2797424495,
-0.4238519371,
-0.5919895172,
-0.5885633826,
-0.6928938031,
0.1642942429,
-0.4750115275,
-0.0135009214,
-0.344270438,
-0.1446807235,
-0.1117830947,
0.3921394348,
-0.6915067434,
-0.0497676358,
0.2466117442,
0.9745925665,
-0.6149864793,
1.0476461649,
0.738276124,
-0.3186670244,
-0.5120567679,
-0.0758679658,
-0.0422449,
-0.707490325,
0.4878546298,
0.479952842,
0.1494854093,
-0.1078274623,
-0.369643867,
-0.5606991649,
1.2614350319,
0.4787811637,
-0.6399298906,
0.2168974429,
0.2304494679,
0.7439082265,
-0.3454098105,
0.5198121071,
0.8011753559,
0.6629776955,
-0.1714835316,
-0.9125760198,
0.0071745599,
-0.6478251219,
-0.0799741223,
0.2607401609,
-0.2874513566,
0.820245862,
0.0213683136,
0.1796684414,
0.3049738109,
0.2140849382,
0.5590763092,
0.496455431,
0.5382940769,
0.5696271062,
0.6687128544,
-0.2474548966,
1.3868219852,
-0.5045921206,
0.2591793239,
1.0058584213,
-0.6223608255,
0.881988287,
0.3598390818,
-0.3017343283,
0.5361391306,
0.8110971451,
-0.2278911024,
0.2786154151,
0.6023914814,
-0.0844130144,
-0.0617777221,
-0.0461554714,
-0.4783994853,
0.2002114654,
0.3585207164,
-0.3879830241,
-0.092612423,
-0.1263017505,
-0.3307611942,
0.0023805348,
-0.1867359281,
0.5571731925,
0.0126517816,
-0.7735237479,
0.6071972251,
-0.1611423045,
0.2906216085,
-0.6179714799,
-0.157062009,
-0.0416386947,
0.6518575549,
-0.0212027002,
-0.7550089359,
0.0795933604,
0.2846462727,
-0.228562057,
-0.4015701413,
0.7358345985,
-0.0797794387,
-0.2320473939,
0.5729590058,
0.6715334058,
0.427513659,
-0.2815891206,
-1.1600451469,
0.2946901023,
-0.2418935746,
-0.4624647796,
0.7873930931,
0.4374488592,
0.0604439788,
0.7239207029,
0.6224659681,
-0.2902412117,
-0.1027933434,
0.4256824851,
0.9752700329,
-0.4685562253,
-0.0616790913,
-0.7986417413,
0.2718592584,
-0.2179786116,
-0.2323670834,
0.5490472913,
0.6656893492,
0.81895262,
-0.1565538645,
0.7337972522,
0.0409352444,
0.3340895474,
-0.3727961183,
0.7361155152,
-0.4669738412,
0.257802397,
-0.2592177391,
-1.0048816204,
-0.241688624,
0.5087842345,
-0.4407195151,
0.2137323469,
0.7255430222,
0.9160029292,
0.225987047,
-0.2304231524,
0.4597797096,
0.2325997651,
0.3240813911,
0.6416525841,
0.9998126626,
-0.3725422323,
0.8731244206,
-0.2275619656,
-0.2110349685,
-0.2855729461,
-0.6691671014,
-0.8783594966,
-0.4425355494,
-0.1721478105,
-0.436276257,
0.2400136292,
0.8297142386,
0.7620307803,
-0.8145162463,
-0.5175305009,
-0.3799593747,
-0.0181849897,
-0.2856875956,
-0.1836360842,
0.2176934034,
-0.733422637,
-0.8178430796,
0.4600567818,
0.2379204929,
-0.251731962,
-0.4999760985,
-0.5244327188,
0.0006826721,
-0.4594256282,
0.5204842091,
0.2108786851,
-0.749196589,
0.0984881818,
0.0152598554,
-0.6551411748,
-0.1030757502,
0.8225642443,
-0.9074681997,
0.329472363,
0.367457062,
1.0174075365,
0.6744615436,
-0.1083689332,
0.8161893487,
-0.7022311091,
-0.1623284519,
0.3395677805,
0.4118030965,
0.2587271333,
-0.0639631227,
1.0062074661,
0.1601260602,
-0.8788686991,
-0.976493001,
-0.2521663904,
-0.8136164546,
-0.5738327503,
1.1349035501,
-0.4533730447,
-0.305670023,
-0.038447272,
-0.0990890786,
0.2339081615,
-0.317001611,
0.7806731462,
0.6076849103,
-0.1009394377,
-0.1512209922,
-0.8377464414,
0.3845764399,
0.3860353827,
-1.0585230589,
0.0870958641,
0.5039061904,
0.0113894381,
0.1108090058,
0.5379356742,
0.1076671034,
0.5519728661,
0.1784080267,
0.2920168936,
-0.0786469802,
-0.1997465193,
-0.2618530095,
0.1697251797,
0.1481977999,
-0.2442141622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09834v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09834v1
|
Overview of the HASOC Subtrack at FIRE 2023: Identification of Tokens Contributing to Explicit Hate in English by Span Detection
| 2023-11-16T12:01:19 | 2023-11-16T12:01:19 |
Sarah Masud, Mohammad Aflah Khan, Md. Shad Akhtar, Tanmoy Chakraborty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As hate speech continues to proliferate on the web, it is becoming
increasingly important to develop computational methods to mitigate it.
Reactively, using black-box models to identify hateful content can perplex
users as to why their posts were automatically flagged as hateful. On the other
hand, proactive mitigation can be achieved by suggesting rephrasing before a
post is made public. However, both mitigation techniques require information
about which part of a post contains the hateful aspect, i.e., what spans within
a text are responsible for conveying hate. Better detection of such spans can
significantly reduce explicitly hateful content on the web. To further
contribute to this research area, we organized HateNorm at HASOC-FIRE 2023,
focusing on explicit span detection in English Tweets. A total of 12 teams
participated in the competition, with the highest macro-F1 observed at 0.58.
|
[
-0.6406357884,
-0.7574573755,
0.2153438032,
0.4282638431,
-0.1297916025,
0.3686829209,
0.1238815039,
-1.0053014755,
0.5742108822,
0.2482257783,
-0.7380324602,
-0.2156900316,
-0.7533815503,
0.348715961,
-0.8281077147,
1.0840585232,
-0.0989299193,
-0.3213210404,
0.0985283777,
0.0111836875,
0.0957077742,
-0.3799865544,
-0.7307699919,
-0.1337691844,
0.8979383111,
0.2529469132,
0.3320057392,
0.7298238277,
0.730708003,
0.2654940486,
-0.2328402251,
-0.1451781243,
-0.5897532701,
0.065836221,
-0.2290220708,
-0.2816231549,
-0.275110811,
-0.2013703585,
0.5138995647,
-0.0153189432,
0.1232867166,
-0.1936837286,
-0.3455030024,
0.1985980421,
-0.854189992,
-0.2775388062,
-1.2001959085,
0.2804265618,
-0.5508137345,
-0.1966992766,
-0.2866963148,
-0.3450915813,
-0.0052655502,
-0.52866292,
0.2097879797,
0.1680732816,
0.97351408,
0.1925230324,
-0.4880140424,
-0.441989094,
-0.4475781918,
1.0282454491,
-0.7200281024,
0.2436712831,
0.4296505451,
-0.0671231523,
-0.0202238355,
-0.4437275231,
-0.5700057745,
0.2379253954,
-0.199758932,
0.2211124003,
-0.6931692958,
0.0299535077,
-0.0621459521,
0.639772594,
-0.3894517422,
0.4091136754,
-0.8767938018,
-0.4878351092,
1.0124905109,
-0.0169134066,
0.430413425,
-0.0381078571,
-0.7513390183,
0.5860250592,
-0.6364489794,
-0.4451737702,
0.8087794185,
-0.0235875286,
-0.2342377752,
0.4860011935,
-0.042478431,
-0.0103027923,
0.0072006457,
-0.0628401935,
0.2734268904,
-0.1747898906,
-0.0324525312,
-0.1039526388,
0.785151124,
0.4419080317,
0.6934271455,
-0.2845071554,
-0.1837042123,
0.4844476581,
0.5413419604,
-0.6887642145,
-0.071339123,
-0.0339975096,
0.0246383641,
-0.6911503077,
-0.4081417024,
-0.7993622422,
-0.5329023004,
0.1751336902,
0.068138063,
-0.2003868818,
-0.2449875772,
-0.2001496255,
-0.3023383915,
0.060799215,
0.330242306,
-0.6797981858,
0.5873943567,
0.4422094822,
0.4442895651,
-0.876285255,
-0.4739115238,
-0.2787934542,
0.036297895,
-0.2616463602,
0.7479360104,
-0.5182253718,
-0.2710461617,
0.1643271446,
-0.0720054805,
0.0491385646,
-0.3527422547,
0.5451367497,
-0.6285502315,
0.0700329617,
0.0592021942,
-0.6667028069,
0.0031458521,
0.5370631218,
-0.6882194281,
1.3313663006,
0.0301359557,
-1.1202219725,
0.2706266046,
-0.5070531964,
-0.6283308864,
0.2539076507,
0.0148747014,
-0.6473570466,
0.1594840437,
-0.0493936688,
0.0999485105,
-0.041783832,
-0.278703481,
-0.2424921989,
-0.0957834348,
0.0080467826,
-0.0754869282,
0.602108717,
0.3260177374,
-0.6400217414,
0.1556777209,
-0.7811682224,
-0.401702106,
0.0361271165,
-0.0662273988,
-0.4005283415,
-0.0267712567,
0.0702880621,
0.2325882912,
-0.0703863055,
-0.8555188179,
-0.0845851228,
-0.3087767065,
0.1743208319,
0.8047091365,
0.1942989677,
0.2950027287,
-0.2043398917,
0.7208000422,
-0.1991811246,
0.3748602271,
0.1593103856,
-0.4424747825,
-0.8088440299,
-0.4823403955,
-0.3598288298,
0.4732776284,
-0.3900552094,
-0.0268701594,
0.3097275794,
-0.7025398612,
-0.1382148117,
0.0815878585,
0.5473768711,
0.5276404619,
0.5342168808,
0.0744369328,
-1.2644190788,
-1.0075063705,
-0.3635277748,
-0.3313355148,
0.3606881201,
-0.1951530576,
0.9035946727,
-0.2912660241,
0.6328864098,
-0.316609621,
-0.1401444077,
-0.2629621625,
0.3148932457,
-0.6186145544,
0.2223514915,
0.563555181,
-1.0459618568,
-0.4511728585,
-0.1327269822,
-0.4432001412,
-0.6053789258,
0.2840319276,
-0.1567612737,
-0.0313192904,
0.7471749783,
-0.0160545129,
0.9000399709,
0.7167146206,
-0.385745883,
0.7497267127,
0.6516377926,
0.542697072,
-0.7350600958,
-0.2282800972,
-0.0736440793,
-0.1721738726,
-0.6098466516,
0.1680132598,
-0.1616072059,
0.2606951594,
-0.8027291298,
0.5848702192,
-0.1150631532,
0.0550229847,
-0.2388171107,
0.0203514807,
-0.0573661365,
0.2823891044,
0.2367115915,
0.6937384009,
0.1821171492,
-0.3970422745,
0.3060215116,
-0.1646155417,
-0.2088833004,
0.6640049219,
-0.3904359341,
0.0118709449,
0.1038672626,
-0.0432581753,
-1.4652978182,
-0.1133558229,
-0.0044074119,
-0.427249372,
-0.3914877772,
-0.1295166314,
-0.2452153862,
-0.5781390667,
-0.4297606349,
0.6131395698,
0.0519284792,
-0.1413324475,
0.3482784629,
0.5463209152,
-0.0970714614,
-0.6222766638,
-1.0175739527,
-0.1378234029,
-0.3363424838,
-0.5323385596,
0.6980101466,
-0.2138463855,
-0.419906348,
-0.1353410184,
-0.0604458191,
-0.2518051267,
0.3924994767,
0.2961911857,
0.1406501085,
0.0651515126,
-0.1778537482,
0.080415681,
0.1551011801,
0.2074418962,
0.2495195568,
0.4581941962,
0.0014653942,
-0.0859860927,
-0.4809459746,
0.3485428691,
0.7200074792,
-0.1536272764,
0.6234715581,
0.5158166289,
-0.7459161282,
-0.4124336839,
-0.5889981985,
-0.0133349067,
-0.455290556,
0.1967387646,
-0.0296061542,
-1.2318661213,
0.8125818372,
0.3887722492,
0.1297676414,
0.6098079681,
0.6868638992,
-0.079997845,
0.6419620514,
0.6224167347,
-0.0009546006,
0.46340096,
0.1357276738,
0.0311616603,
-0.3125295639,
-0.3443643749,
-0.7343441844,
-0.2865948677,
-0.2783984244,
-0.1089496911,
0.1860194355,
-0.2281170636,
-0.1565871239,
0.6747879386,
-0.1758980304,
0.6471993923,
-0.000297343,
-0.3990403712,
0.2062781155,
0.0570410006,
0.0227288529,
-0.3276246488,
-0.0687197298,
0.0745056048,
0.606539011,
0.5059306026,
0.6814572811,
-0.04864344,
0.6119182706,
0.9257858992,
0.7604985833,
-0.8271722198,
0.5452606678,
0.1795358211,
-1.0724318027,
-0.285256505,
-0.2998805046,
-0.624458611,
0.1373576969,
0.0255206618,
-0.8545886278,
-0.1769852191,
0.3021816313,
0.0402609967,
0.5906580091,
-0.3349338174,
0.7236042023,
0.0458784588,
-0.1559773833,
-0.203435421,
-0.3577208817,
0.4587000012,
-0.0791032761,
0.5308284163,
-0.1272428632,
-0.1905638725,
1.0843046904,
-0.534183383,
0.7337366343,
0.1295880377,
-0.4271146059,
0.3166545331,
0.31622684,
0.6838819981,
-0.4890199006,
-0.2723054588,
-0.0923079029,
-0.3276626766,
-0.4666844904,
-0.0576816536,
0.478546828,
-0.5302890539,
-0.2471795678,
-0.3720234036,
-0.3949404061,
-0.2457847893,
0.2722934783,
0.7180982232,
0.0415384732,
-0.3808061182,
0.0841689855,
0.55722785,
0.0305172019,
0.4139346182,
0.3737185895,
-0.4007964432,
-0.5705025792,
0.4472336471,
0.1009404585,
0.2659888268,
0.4959565699,
0.1688344479,
-0.227846548,
-0.8474426866,
-0.0565891229,
0.3046868145,
-0.5301132798,
-0.3796525002,
-0.5774095654,
-0.2644338608,
-0.5769143701,
-0.6573696136,
-0.4386146665,
-0.0779869333,
-0.0515369773,
-0.7110883594,
0.448808521,
0.8854470849,
-0.2084908783,
0.7190875411,
-0.0486851819,
0.2032862306,
0.3769190311,
0.0151679162,
-0.25139153,
-0.7383511066,
-0.2513037026,
-0.4910304844,
-0.1194117516,
-0.8943039179,
0.4073376656,
-0.2297803313,
0.236785382,
0.3944739699,
0.0509622656,
0.6273410916,
-0.5111996531,
0.7502442598,
0.3781311214,
-1.1252942085,
0.6289822459,
-0.3142073154,
-0.0236682091,
0.5056943893,
0.9069503546,
-0.6697613001,
-1.0281144381,
-0.6639689207,
-0.7448650599,
0.621796906,
0.5047643185,
-0.0058078617,
-0.3855460584,
-0.0829263777,
-0.0762314573,
0.2689269781,
-0.9465221167,
-0.5609888434,
0.1249220297,
0.0110559668,
0.51474154,
-0.5493679643,
-0.1224093214,
-0.0210060403,
0.7316590548,
0.2942750454,
0.0416270159,
0.0454872735,
-0.2857758701,
-0.4092355072,
0.219728753,
0.8666316271,
0.7285948992,
-0.114882417,
0.515928328,
0.3621940911,
-0.5945500135,
0.0236324742,
-0.2138872296,
-0.1262705624,
0.1164220721,
0.695725739,
0.4958051145,
0.1900704652,
-0.5189607739,
0.7313293219,
0.1945975572,
-0.3406440914,
-0.4275773168,
-0.124973245,
-0.3019225895,
0.0232861713,
0.6576413512,
-0.0012285069,
0.2276640534,
-0.4995874465,
0.6321665645,
0.0982630327,
-0.5193037987,
-0.6068704128,
0.5452460647,
0.4215724766,
-0.2218583375,
0.0333070457,
-0.2641741931,
-1.1591011286,
0.8195474744,
0.7174454927,
0.5543721318,
-0.567285955,
0.3183021843,
0.1976318359,
0.6497032642,
0.5785015821,
0.233156532,
0.0761920363,
-0.890247941,
-0.3733483553,
-0.6127836704,
-0.2957355976,
0.6354150176,
-0.6617841125,
0.2520886064,
-0.6696308255,
0.1431790143,
0.3042185009,
-0.1623065174,
-0.4356151819,
0.5712715387,
0.7529754639,
1.1376236677,
-1.2370474339,
0.4567413032,
0.2382184416,
-0.0795837715,
-0.6118574142,
-0.0982714817,
0.5928994417,
-0.9476762414,
0.6370241642,
-0.0268398952,
-0.5123980045,
-0.085408926,
-0.8677696586,
-0.5810906887,
0.4481000304,
0.0649047568,
-0.3768387437,
-0.0311631057,
0.0901696235,
0.7622532248,
-0.2105422616,
0.3477813303,
0.4021938443,
0.5063521266,
0.1553900242,
-0.8997970223,
-0.1061005369,
-0.2578448951,
-0.2799689472,
0.4920124412,
-0.6709465981,
0.7934328318,
0.3288186491,
-0.2063681334,
-0.026921114,
0.7170880437,
0.0282522533,
0.3430592716,
0.6095332503,
0.6392772794,
0.458553344,
0.002507248,
0.7281900644,
0.3521861136,
0.3832239211,
0.8840895295,
-0.2710603476,
0.6343019009,
0.6808386445,
-0.284730047,
0.7203051448,
0.2227173597,
0.1994012296,
0.4232366979,
0.5316643119,
-0.4489803016,
-0.1829981208,
-0.2820313275,
-0.2949457467,
0.4080543816,
0.5696922541,
-0.4273709953,
-0.463454783,
0.4055385292,
0.7486663461,
0.2977106571,
-0.5279459357,
0.5820660591,
-0.3758252263,
-0.6286110878,
0.4791725278,
0.2400220484,
1.0098305941,
-0.8273079395,
0.2663745284,
-0.497693181,
0.0739093497,
-0.52615273,
-0.8112558722,
0.6710974574,
0.4764617682,
-0.1828462929,
-0.2220524997,
0.6644480228,
-0.3223384917,
-0.186879307,
0.7346335649,
0.0003136342,
0.3335584104,
-0.1207007542,
-0.7047129869,
0.5714355111,
0.127565518,
-0.2465959638,
0.06287615,
0.4733166099,
-0.1393083185,
0.4214667976,
0.2623528242,
0.02742997,
0.5345980525,
-0.0757948235,
0.8366455436,
-0.3735098243,
-0.4377987385,
-0.8712412715,
0.4921424687,
-0.1830012649,
-0.6801917553,
0.9972783923,
0.803709805,
1.1895589828,
0.0418943204,
0.7118040323,
-0.3290811181,
0.6781116724,
-0.1362844706,
0.3216197789,
-0.788001895,
-0.174631536,
-0.6301621199,
-0.3707244694,
-0.6249698997,
0.2389249951,
-0.5538458228,
-0.4852673113,
0.6908540726,
0.9713218212,
0.0468198694,
-0.0233753398,
0.4378277957,
0.2188922614,
0.2555001378,
0.2566555738,
1.0328878164,
-0.575279355,
0.8806907535,
-0.3168731332,
-0.1054797247,
-0.380638659,
-0.8729196191,
-0.8740089536,
-0.4963540733,
-0.5058759451,
-0.489854306,
0.2745853066,
0.6199632883,
0.6650921106,
-1.1311458349,
-0.1363366395,
-0.213462919,
0.4748643339,
0.0378196798,
-0.2647838891,
-0.0167466421,
-0.109771125,
-0.7589413524,
0.4094284177,
0.4288504124,
-0.0941819698,
-0.0414803326,
0.0972061157,
-0.6911906004,
0.3990134895,
0.6571497321,
0.5972972512,
-0.5277255177,
-0.4757430851,
-0.0120241446,
-0.282795608,
-0.1077700108,
0.8239822984,
-0.3977137506,
0.0790971369,
0.613925457,
0.7688092589,
0.5185349584,
-0.0462063178,
0.1820700467,
-1.0248833895,
0.2616838515,
0.4574640393,
0.2833304703,
0.0445974208,
-0.2802477181,
0.7041875124,
0.7986949682,
-0.3681764305,
-1.027813673,
0.4298192859,
-0.7676123977,
-0.2143958956,
1.2232638597,
-0.1033678353,
-0.1554516107,
-0.2322027683,
-0.1814599037,
-0.0447638109,
-0.3614357114,
0.5911958218,
1.0923831463,
-0.0216478817,
-0.2539457381,
0.2442055494,
0.7782225013,
0.4371466637,
-1.0927037001,
-0.2267605364,
0.3707208335,
0.2191013694,
0.2353200614,
0.6237828135,
-0.1130629405,
0.4259324968,
-0.0870787501,
0.0606004819,
0.2465015352,
-0.6511903405,
0.1791047752,
0.2224223316,
-0.4033138454,
-0.1278330684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09832v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09832v3
|
WatME: Towards Lossless Watermarking Through Lexical Redundancy
| 2023-11-16T11:58:31 | 2024-06-06T13:17:43 |
Liang Chen, Yatao Bian, Yang Deng, Deng Cai, Shuaiyi Li, Peilin Zhao, Kam-fai Wong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text watermarking has emerged as a pivotal technique for identifying
machine-generated text. However, existing methods often rely on arbitrary
vocabulary partitioning during decoding to embed watermarks, which compromises
the availability of suitable tokens and significantly degrades the quality of
responses. This study assesses the impact of watermarking on different
capabilities of large language models (LLMs) from a cognitive science lens. Our
finding highlights a significant disparity; knowledge recall and logical
reasoning are more adversely affected than language generation. These results
suggest a more profound effect of watermarking on LLMs than previously
understood. To address these challenges, we introduce Watermarking with Mutual
Exclusion (WatME), a novel approach leveraging linguistic prior knowledge of
inherent lexical redundancy in LLM vocabularies to seamlessly integrate
watermarks. Specifically, WatME dynamically optimizes token usage during the
decoding process by applying a mutually exclusive rule to the identified
lexical redundancies. This strategy effectively prevents the unavailability of
appropriate tokens and preserves the expressive power of LLMs. We provide both
theoretical analysis and empirical evidence showing that WatME effectively
preserves the diverse capabilities of LLMs while ensuring watermark
detectability.
|
[
-0.4784440994,
-0.6562001109,
0.5713343024,
0.1617500633,
-0.4637844861,
0.2259804308,
-0.0810229108,
-0.7107397318,
0.202119559,
0.523966074,
-0.3495495319,
-0.4531604946,
-1.0596120358,
0.0608423501,
-0.5327731371,
0.4283299744,
-0.0236795675,
-0.0994737297,
-0.4479208589,
-0.5661936402,
-0.8849585056,
-0.5334726572,
-0.2888879478,
-0.3867505193,
0.3903832436,
0.201303333,
0.6926917434,
0.6754934788,
0.4116275907,
0.3669259548,
-0.2872690558,
0.4014114738,
-0.4743764997,
0.253441751,
-0.3514716625,
-0.5409965515,
0.131117925,
0.0520530529,
0.6326173544,
0.5850365162,
0.0778579265,
-0.0576919466,
0.2460642606,
0.5913930535,
-1.143307209,
0.2206608504,
-1.0807807446,
0.104466781,
-0.1651704162,
-0.1044216901,
-0.2780451179,
-0.1549637616,
0.1130906418,
-0.5894070864,
-0.2009969205,
0.0397938229,
1.053042531,
0.2539971471,
-0.0433471575,
-0.037267819,
-0.7583357692,
1.0397123098,
-0.7095944881,
0.2663000226,
0.4296900928,
0.0185478125,
-0.0823845044,
-0.5276371241,
-0.7189152837,
0.3079268336,
0.111998409,
0.2011659741,
-0.3958178759,
-0.0921059102,
0.1651095152,
0.1685474515,
-0.0448800288,
-0.2313349247,
-0.0540985279,
-0.5671771169,
0.2837593555,
0.265544802,
0.6030458212,
0.0957514271,
-0.3276656568,
-0.0442086756,
-0.533652842,
-0.4965334237,
0.1223069653,
0.1440290213,
0.0730686262,
0.6363319159,
0.0593343452,
0.2782783806,
-0.5081384182,
-0.2993583679,
-0.1433466524,
-0.150529623,
-0.0434307083,
0.0147018945,
0.783637166,
0.1688212156,
0.4905172586,
-0.330845356,
-0.3178710938,
0.2990197837,
-0.1271788329,
-0.6638424397,
0.1837461293,
-0.1689089835,
-0.3951191604,
-0.1426819712,
0.0109547591,
-0.4521551728,
-0.5305256844,
-0.3967736363,
0.8117364049,
-0.5013790727,
-0.3852680326,
0.4158084393,
-0.5735824704,
-0.0862021446,
0.1416736841,
-0.6059684753,
0.297410816,
0.7546301484,
0.8746055961,
-0.265839994,
-0.2548165023,
-0.3320239186,
0.5493661761,
-0.1116832569,
0.6364846826,
-0.8309176564,
-0.440444231,
-0.0056928266,
-0.009314931,
-0.0223433636,
-0.6661251783,
0.0752766654,
-0.848690331,
0.2527282238,
-0.5088753104,
-0.8029159307,
-0.351868093,
0.229530111,
-0.7732978463,
0.6306781173,
-0.0134464642,
-1.0683550835,
0.1856021881,
-0.4079230726,
-0.4640186429,
0.1178964227,
-0.131563127,
-0.4344182312,
0.2040388882,
-0.0984020829,
0.1997695118,
-0.4535493553,
0.2345968187,
-0.5205263495,
-0.2920488119,
0.2253728509,
-0.7476728559,
0.4213781953,
-0.0202606544,
-0.5180469751,
-0.1117858961,
-0.8005264401,
0.0689523295,
0.3993641734,
-0.2893657386,
-0.7712562084,
0.0922688395,
-0.0156204198,
-0.0664460436,
0.3845284283,
-0.7095095515,
-0.2995425463,
-0.0904112607,
0.7027056813,
0.6893762946,
0.0384826735,
0.2800964117,
-0.346588999,
0.3719826341,
0.1203167439,
-0.0079822354,
0.1280153245,
-0.5471615791,
-0.5636504292,
-0.4199678898,
0.4465404153,
0.523073256,
-0.7532581091,
0.2128689885,
-0.284768194,
-0.4018625915,
-0.2525652945,
0.1290752739,
0.3452715874,
0.4190552533,
0.3892897964,
-0.3178014159,
-0.4524497688,
-1.0581818819,
-0.378429383,
-0.1521522701,
0.1352499872,
0.213024497,
0.4355964065,
-0.4484564364,
1.0861599445,
-0.4795348942,
-0.269046396,
-0.3441693783,
-0.0683329478,
-0.3385215104,
0.3627895415,
0.161163494,
-0.6812525392,
-0.0844259709,
-0.1889405102,
-0.7424570322,
-0.4207563102,
0.0583718009,
-0.3407515585,
0.1808529943,
0.584254384,
-0.6942144632,
0.670891881,
0.628977716,
-0.3138876259,
0.4792025685,
-0.2152429074,
0.1156328097,
-0.8109304309,
0.0312009305,
-0.2216474265,
-0.0052666399,
-0.0872492492,
-0.1484247595,
0.1382499039,
-0.1205301136,
-0.3082937896,
0.7141240835,
-0.5543633699,
-0.0184247252,
-0.5663369298,
0.1780278832,
0.3966521323,
0.2777834237,
0.0116420519,
0.6583018899,
0.2555216849,
-0.5524523258,
-0.1587202847,
0.1701955348,
-0.1854234934,
0.3692311049,
-0.6850347519,
-0.1836485565,
-0.1552504897,
-0.2176727951,
-0.9571422935,
0.2429834455,
0.0025296253,
-0.2207401991,
0.381018728,
-0.0757966861,
-0.6867716908,
0.0420913622,
-0.2721117437,
0.5694945455,
0.4226398766,
-0.3675698042,
0.6728352308,
0.5750803351,
0.0665661022,
-0.4138614833,
-1.0073882341,
0.155029133,
-0.2843769193,
-0.6431401372,
0.5678783655,
0.0847041905,
-0.2277475744,
0.256973505,
-0.3455097377,
-0.1004046649,
0.2079511583,
0.4222132564,
0.2805765569,
-0.1482823342,
0.1548916698,
0.0284169987,
-0.3056595922,
0.0213050712,
-0.3805128634,
0.5841412544,
0.0543547161,
-0.5488721132,
-0.6160209179,
0.5430645347,
0.8936653137,
-0.4202161729,
1.0132973194,
0.5493440032,
-0.6216502786,
0.0225083623,
-0.7648803592,
-0.1760481745,
-0.505854845,
0.288118422,
-0.0578357615,
-1.0168542862,
0.5680631995,
-0.0271394849,
0.1578581929,
0.3720362186,
0.08970429,
-0.0443295911,
0.5292408466,
0.7208819389,
-0.4266042709,
0.7534497976,
-0.0597036146,
0.2021345645,
-0.7144762874,
-0.1624223441,
-0.4355076253,
-0.3383436799,
-0.2726847827,
-0.3937091529,
-0.001123641,
0.2676469386,
-0.2905752659,
0.3403728902,
-0.5224052072,
0.7451816797,
0.4754149616,
0.1348511577,
0.396566838,
0.4465513527,
-0.3453303277,
-0.287522167,
-0.6983953714,
-0.5897264481,
0.8667321205,
0.0718252063,
0.5864802003,
-0.035513632,
0.6764622927,
0.4758303463,
0.1883581281,
-0.5198783875,
0.8425706029,
0.080828853,
-0.4828859866,
-0.4361360371,
-0.5412732363,
-1.1482340097,
0.4349298775,
-0.2934951484,
-0.5259392858,
-0.137078777,
-0.2330194861,
0.0944801793,
0.7373310328,
-0.730415225,
0.6539211273,
0.0635480955,
-0.6524150372,
-0.5180364847,
-0.1083159596,
0.1083728373,
-0.2175028473,
0.3860594332,
-0.4015564322,
-0.4309975505,
0.886080265,
-0.5446513295,
0.8101735115,
-0.3396664858,
-0.2732750773,
0.5842767358,
0.3639594316,
0.4711480439,
-0.0818888322,
0.0022504972,
0.5203133225,
0.0116354367,
-0.5369528532,
-0.2769802511,
0.6545956135,
-0.5598477721,
-0.7781557441,
-0.2533164024,
-0.5780445933,
-0.4361656308,
0.4739411175,
0.0290804766,
0.4537142515,
0.150041461,
-0.0683044866,
0.6803816557,
-0.5160267353,
0.7933238745,
0.5104206204,
0.2833786905,
-0.6759309173,
1.0316990614,
0.1528382152,
0.4038334489,
0.3836174011,
0.3264755607,
-0.2521428168,
-0.7328152061,
0.026891401,
0.5291036963,
-0.8415940404,
-0.3199583292,
-0.7052123547,
-0.1385716945,
0.1774453372,
-0.0021247207,
-0.3923655152,
-0.2985011935,
-0.283726871,
0.2207996547,
0.3004258871,
0.6118166447,
-0.1041471437,
0.0394357219,
-0.9759101868,
0.312949717,
0.2973704934,
0.5178639293,
0.265945673,
-0.5472599864,
-0.0993702859,
0.0345232449,
-0.3386849463,
-0.6039293408,
0.1377303153,
0.0938805193,
0.4838220477,
0.4760028124,
0.1450367421,
0.8098629117,
-0.5507159233,
0.5835969448,
0.4782852232,
-1.1670013666,
0.319845289,
-0.0929270461,
0.4876044095,
0.4293139279,
0.1293951869,
-0.5810986757,
-0.5791930556,
-0.4969561696,
-0.9428013563,
0.3365730047,
0.3118513525,
0.4144799709,
-0.3496520221,
0.2270353138,
0.0620407313,
0.1048476622,
-0.7108719349,
-0.0331913717,
0.0958966389,
-0.1734521538,
0.5071008205,
-0.5431738496,
-0.025110485,
-0.046932023,
0.7340944409,
0.2343117446,
0.1435513496,
0.3039969206,
-0.2089472562,
0.0503691062,
0.1967723519,
0.5361261368,
0.3033887744,
0.2900941968,
0.310605824,
0.1896765232,
-0.5328762531,
0.0845316797,
-0.3990026712,
-0.1601468623,
0.1442822665,
0.7672213316,
0.2450487167,
0.2960649133,
-0.8408231735,
0.3845778704,
-0.1384983063,
-0.2287401259,
0.1374474615,
0.0607968383,
0.4156994522,
0.2371566445,
0.2730279565,
0.1757366508,
-0.3007386029,
-0.3383158445,
0.1359909177,
0.7422361374,
-0.2463299781,
-0.1193618476,
0.7337241173,
0.1296491325,
-0.0625019297,
0.2566580772,
0.0823950917,
-0.618588686,
0.6079335809,
0.4497024119,
0.8333770633,
0.1101727635,
-0.2266679704,
0.2551270723,
0.4738121033,
-0.2663019598,
0.0856053531,
-0.0968714803,
-0.9346668124,
-0.185410589,
-0.5663835406,
-0.2918133736,
0.2905284464,
-0.4032609463,
0.0711140558,
-0.5410014987,
-0.3461937606,
-0.0031065834,
-0.3192931712,
-0.4321675897,
-0.0090005724,
0.3292210698,
0.7107727528,
-0.5754771233,
0.6076106429,
0.2635866702,
-0.1825863719,
-0.5956147313,
0.06701269,
-0.0122480076,
-0.9424879551,
0.4344439209,
0.2954615951,
-0.3694076836,
-0.1413904279,
-0.4496040642,
-0.8673115969,
0.9727218151,
0.6260775328,
-0.5419498682,
0.4700237215,
0.5404539704,
0.3266329169,
-0.1051524058,
-0.0339523777,
0.4897616506,
0.5566359162,
-0.1422806084,
-0.6769807935,
0.3816111684,
-0.0613310002,
0.1539196074,
0.2862135172,
-0.5853645802,
0.2917229235,
-0.1360441297,
-0.6737955213,
0.0026932817,
0.424654305,
0.1349295825,
0.1582440585,
0.5850901604,
0.6037626266,
0.6899274588,
-0.0597714148,
0.726952672,
-0.3727969527,
0.0886602029,
0.8318318129,
-0.2617261112,
0.7715066075,
0.6133292317,
-0.2037246972,
0.2792754471,
0.1823651344,
0.0779888928,
0.594304204,
0.3476784825,
-0.5337726474,
-0.4115643203,
-0.3552601039,
-0.4043568671,
0.1764760017,
0.1956780553,
-0.1939793378,
-0.1889206022,
0.0100839343,
-0.054120075,
0.3124424815,
-0.1352799088,
0.719678998,
0.1808645278,
-0.2503316104,
0.7131245136,
0.1256940514,
0.9807377458,
-0.6519012451,
0.1084972769,
-0.4966536164,
-0.0002072593,
-0.135568127,
-0.5830011368,
0.4120475948,
-0.1322752386,
-0.4631539285,
-0.0392408632,
0.9523882866,
-0.4239037931,
-0.2668406069,
0.7448270321,
0.5483604074,
-0.0296369679,
-0.2287244946,
-0.5054093003,
0.3607746661,
0.0515359789,
-0.0898444057,
0.3413940966,
0.922008574,
-0.1451191902,
1.0129377842,
0.6468465328,
0.1347881854,
-0.0795747712,
0.185098663,
0.6372346878,
-0.8105460405,
-0.2879858315,
-1.2219946384,
0.090229854,
-0.10545329,
0.0961523354,
0.6164156199,
0.4357748628,
0.6354141831,
-0.1016918048,
0.8833663464,
0.2863067389,
-0.1390792727,
-0.2592630088,
0.9146795869,
-0.6393150687,
0.6031523347,
-0.6071773767,
-0.9265469909,
-0.3210222721,
0.1424971223,
-0.0744010508,
-0.2117984593,
0.6730395555,
0.8118951917,
-0.0310366079,
0.1687819809,
0.6350416541,
-0.3509665132,
0.3091662228,
0.5355267525,
0.9249358773,
-0.4106759429,
0.911486268,
-0.0088092294,
-0.0313838534,
0.0601563491,
-0.8523566723,
-0.8542694449,
-0.4209558368,
-0.699891746,
-0.3140772283,
-0.1175248325,
0.494074136,
0.629588306,
-0.665148437,
0.2118050605,
-0.2683164477,
0.4543254375,
0.0874708518,
-0.2354056388,
0.2385565341,
-0.2133417279,
-0.5734057426,
-0.0250667501,
0.6681191921,
0.4677852392,
-0.1040007249,
-0.0517303683,
0.1061629504,
0.4940305948,
0.6781694293,
0.1281037629,
-0.5906292796,
-0.3028991818,
-0.3930307031,
-0.2463644147,
-0.1382781416,
0.6813605428,
-0.6116057634,
0.1645892709,
0.4387161732,
1.0605568886,
0.147610262,
-0.3925461471,
0.3267558217,
-0.3959799111,
0.2874312997,
0.0836487338,
0.6900845766,
0.3982361555,
-0.0016277466,
0.4729709625,
0.8245104551,
-0.0182037,
-0.751632452,
0.057334844,
-0.6954182386,
-0.6025550365,
1.1656736135,
-0.1077912226,
-0.2049522251,
-0.2261939347,
-0.1326194406,
0.1027053297,
-0.2264014035,
0.8813996315,
1.1581777334,
0.5125561357,
-0.0128936572,
-0.3049787879,
0.068723999,
0.8021069765,
-0.687320292,
0.2980456054,
0.373893857,
0.659124732,
0.0480510294,
0.2524769604,
-0.4519363344,
0.0519442186,
0.2116590291,
0.283134371,
-0.2789991498,
0.0896875039,
0.0833863765,
0.3568562865,
-0.0896409601,
-0.4295943677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09830v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09830v2
|
AutoPlanBench: Automatically generating benchmarks for LLM planners from PDDL
| 2023-11-16T11:55:27 | 2024-02-09T09:48:41 |
Katharina Stein, Daniel Fišer, Jörg Hoffmann, Alexander Koller
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
LLMs are being increasingly used for planning-style tasks, but their
capabilities for planning and reasoning are poorly understood. We present
AutoPlanBench, a novel method for automatically converting planning benchmarks
written in PDDL into textual descriptions and offer a benchmark dataset created
with our method. We show that while the best LLM planners do well on some
planning tasks, others remain out of reach of current methods.
|
[
-0.6721687913,
-0.364600867,
0.7113116384,
0.3651193082,
-0.072808072,
-0.1144750416,
0.0541853234,
-0.2296396941,
-0.0058081825,
0.4589279592,
-1.0008188486,
-0.5938934088,
-0.1620922834,
0.100995943,
-0.580427587,
0.550793767,
-0.6579507589,
-0.1217181683,
-0.3585418463,
0.0003014287,
-0.21034953,
-0.4023654759,
-0.2248320282,
-0.5022469759,
0.3392073214,
0.4906300306,
0.4776777625,
0.8414949179,
0.5034606457,
0.2402729243,
0.4725404382,
0.3618116379,
-0.3488583267,
0.1427929103,
-0.2864123881,
-0.3313247263,
-0.6381575465,
0.2570514381,
0.4924612045,
0.8484070897,
-0.2147656977,
0.3761550486,
-0.1473798454,
0.5981295109,
-0.8115419745,
0.3190806806,
-0.641443789,
0.4198586345,
-0.283310473,
-0.3690699935,
-0.1847680658,
-0.629496038,
0.0502799489,
-0.3299813569,
0.3069335222,
0.0657112449,
0.3731932044,
0.7469316125,
-0.36607939,
-0.2111863345,
-0.7673895359,
0.4739391208,
-0.56373173,
-0.175567776,
0.4742307365,
0.819111824,
-0.3950860798,
-0.6646670699,
-0.4893706441,
-0.0110382866,
-0.2058213651,
0.1070039123,
0.1372692734,
0.1432737559,
0.5332183242,
0.4525243938,
-0.63002038,
0.153934449,
-0.0508353636,
-0.0731238276,
1.2141721249,
0.7085253,
-0.2291479707,
-0.2309124321,
-0.5158455372,
-0.3493426442,
-0.8935353756,
-0.1692562401,
0.3992845118,
-0.2971559167,
0.2668830454,
0.6996217966,
-0.410533756,
0.5083631277,
-0.2223234028,
0.0038335845,
-0.0546436645,
-0.4043636918,
-0.5272575617,
0.0629319325,
0.4784719646,
0.6557793021,
0.0310172942,
-0.2667161226,
-0.5224999785,
-0.1016543806,
0.1049042419,
-0.5242496133,
-0.8631534576,
0.0820471197,
-0.4111210108,
-0.0761723444,
-0.0688568056,
-0.7540572286,
-0.2468134761,
-0.3622940481,
0.1517185569,
-0.1387010217,
0.0241288804,
-0.2657685876,
-0.1108469814,
0.3006363511,
0.5431986451,
-0.697450757,
0.5221809745,
0.3298989832,
0.3721031845,
-0.5093588233,
-0.552460134,
-0.3492738903,
0.527600348,
-0.5217677355,
1.2155988216,
0.1308732182,
-0.9001111984,
-0.1944922656,
-0.0665787533,
0.0760123581,
-0.8301612139,
0.3680476844,
0.0302044339,
0.132107392,
-0.487849921,
-0.597406745,
0.1052019969,
0.1559547633,
-0.6879473329,
1.364538312,
0.1907705963,
-0.2474755943,
0.6147736907,
-0.4730255306,
-0.3751196563,
0.1576151997,
-0.4389238358,
-0.1336425692,
-0.0034942443,
0.1869371533,
0.4795649648,
-0.4091686904,
0.4663015604,
-0.2588548362,
0.0527215861,
0.188990593,
-0.3648716807,
0.6582504511,
0.33228302,
-0.5273403525,
0.2332949936,
-0.8592356443,
0.2931019962,
0.0104888817,
-0.4146638215,
0.2544585466,
0.2889129817,
0.0321551524,
0.3714452088,
0.5057781935,
-0.145647943,
0.3737953603,
-0.3180374801,
0.02272892,
0.8057887554,
-0.2576264739,
0.311078012,
-0.6191701293,
0.5179795623,
-0.5464851856,
0.0020114544,
0.0820739791,
-0.1623518318,
-0.7611583471,
0.0118539762,
-0.0267466679,
0.4534196854,
-0.5339471102,
0.7132826447,
-0.0470544174,
-0.6449028254,
-0.1936337799,
0.3069753945,
0.3021338284,
0.4764058292,
0.4776028395,
-0.3727392554,
-0.4880658984,
-0.9970051646,
-0.343837142,
-0.186591953,
0.0860365555,
0.2866044641,
0.3569575846,
0.0337299965,
1.0462731123,
-0.6602644324,
-0.2843002677,
-0.5369399786,
0.4660120606,
0.0334213451,
0.2699673474,
0.5879717469,
-0.4772822559,
-0.7396677732,
-0.3944819272,
-0.4770654142,
-0.6047660112,
-0.4818188846,
-0.1904735863,
0.1530777216,
0.7297639847,
-0.7182980776,
0.739228487,
0.1786905378,
-0.1615087092,
0.7918227315,
-0.3949690163,
-0.3485566676,
-0.8073452711,
0.2634392381,
-0.1988610625,
-0.2720333338,
-0.1057578698,
-0.1734677255,
0.1432591379,
0.1025717705,
-0.1555586606,
0.8683350086,
-0.6764937043,
-0.5962679386,
-0.367754668,
-0.024317354,
0.0434913859,
0.2184101492,
-0.0677517354,
0.9065964222,
0.2157091945,
-0.5417403579,
0.8449577689,
0.4077937007,
-0.3448779881,
0.4973953664,
-0.2492174208,
-0.1584159434,
0.0859720334,
0.5593724847,
-1.0167745352,
-0.5709017515,
-0.0596672297,
0.1844975799,
0.2099716812,
-0.1035602093,
-0.8238940835,
-0.6281553507,
-0.3297222257,
-0.0340524092,
0.3227775395,
-0.703744173,
0.7321103811,
0.353544116,
-0.2812471688,
-0.1847987473,
-0.9298428893,
0.1899590194,
-0.302657485,
-0.2429012656,
0.7596656084,
-0.2665620148,
-0.2822404504,
-0.064016521,
-0.3633707166,
-0.0825844705,
0.0582955256,
0.3007084131,
0.1707546562,
0.1120561212,
-0.0025827049,
0.0481624193,
-0.3120161295,
0.5844647288,
0.1352124065,
0.5342808962,
0.3109108806,
-0.5222577453,
-0.3471595645,
0.2658152282,
0.352699399,
-0.040267691,
0.1692324728,
0.2416291237,
-0.1589488983,
-0.7683439851,
-0.7499281764,
0.2278908342,
-0.5166733265,
-0.0251647625,
-0.6084695458,
0.0974796116,
0.3244530559,
-0.7076925039,
0.2458074093,
0.5681735873,
0.5569372177,
-0.0454767011,
0.8564695716,
0.5770062208,
0.1157061681,
0.1466756165,
-0.2957850993,
-0.1596480906,
-0.5585027933,
-0.2444270402,
-0.3721469641,
-0.4544006586,
-0.2228508294,
-0.4526305795,
0.0990149975,
0.0269786119,
-0.0958557129,
0.6962484121,
-0.514302969,
0.6299540401,
0.4619436264,
-0.426151216,
0.2148531824,
-0.3316787183,
-0.3646426499,
-0.0386166126,
-0.4444610476,
-0.622889936,
1.3387920856,
-0.0398112535,
0.9293223023,
0.0016018003,
0.9147301912,
0.1445988715,
0.4549109042,
-0.3045740426,
1.0086855888,
-0.2009603083,
-0.5440965891,
-0.1248562038,
-0.2632547617,
-0.5060390234,
-0.0079516377,
0.0513768941,
-0.5891705751,
0.5296090841,
0.096834749,
-0.3559975624,
0.1930978894,
-0.6498165727,
0.7902020812,
-0.6991358995,
-0.2521647811,
-0.2836842835,
-0.4257656634,
0.0149759036,
-0.3768199384,
-0.0859756544,
-0.7854772806,
-0.2142827511,
0.4210563898,
-0.5959926844,
0.5366202593,
-0.3738640547,
-0.1013242528,
-0.0640981346,
0.3055873215,
0.6627416015,
0.0037673598,
-0.6209548116,
-0.4887178242,
0.0527925938,
-0.1956068426,
-0.2594572902,
0.7100041509,
-0.5994403362,
-0.5491796136,
-0.22015737,
-0.8257698417,
-0.3590919375,
0.2299560905,
0.0632976666,
0.1970635355,
-0.6538366675,
-0.4600920975,
0.1483230293,
-0.1324587166,
0.759914279,
0.5054619312,
-0.1833569705,
-0.2831177711,
0.5762282014,
0.2388933748,
0.1702116877,
0.189146921,
-0.2466821969,
-0.6598834991,
-0.7878016233,
-0.4154638052,
-0.0906582773,
-1.1759486198,
-0.1493480057,
-0.3118739426,
-0.2541667223,
-0.2138940692,
-0.4248122573,
-0.3499877155,
-0.8263810277,
-0.0474066883,
-0.1900179982,
-0.0715262219,
0.9363310933,
-0.3994830251,
0.143263787,
-0.2194572389,
0.399887383,
0.3773356974,
0.1695141494,
-0.382050097,
0.2425023913,
0.0442517251,
-0.4022970498,
-0.398856014,
-0.6606439352,
0.8242554069,
0.1347445101,
0.9871844053,
0.2049884796,
0.3407132328,
0.9040076733,
-0.3206626177,
0.4934765399,
-0.1782949865,
-0.6819272637,
0.9494845867,
-0.0657195598,
0.356000632,
1.0207891464,
0.4772626162,
0.2409479916,
-0.1080102101,
-0.6835289001,
-0.9606287479,
0.6792402267,
0.089492172,
-0.3001881838,
0.0707448199,
0.2866227329,
0.3407461941,
0.3969393969,
-0.617274642,
-0.3443298936,
-0.1090241373,
-0.1174719185,
-0.2099791318,
-0.1978406161,
-0.5700461864,
-0.3871688247,
0.3615288138,
-0.3019216061,
0.2803988755,
0.3205372095,
-0.2697066665,
-0.3191333115,
0.0186960734,
0.2391210496,
1.0113976002,
-0.3482519984,
0.337264508,
0.5340821743,
-0.032118734,
0.0289098583,
0.8662327528,
0.1613564789,
0.0167204756,
0.1019004285,
0.2867154181,
0.0931361988,
-0.7952582836,
0.1636333466,
-0.0957228243,
-0.4224820733,
-0.6632949114,
0.2393474579,
0.0717931911,
0.1486320049,
0.4732380509,
-0.1170545369,
0.1516575366,
-0.4110394716,
0.2038740814,
0.2816151381,
-0.0217600949,
0.0282241181,
0.8240875006,
0.2988652587,
-0.0143015003,
0.2381486297,
-0.2839051485,
-0.1778379828,
0.7354897261,
0.2576961517,
0.9899567962,
-0.1108627468,
-0.0223838091,
0.2227173597,
0.2816767097,
-0.0032291454,
0.3892201781,
-0.4305340946,
-0.3760986328,
-0.3154737055,
-0.6430095434,
-0.6372280121,
-0.2122807503,
-0.4979685545,
0.2583844364,
-0.7195072174,
-0.1468215883,
0.0669719502,
0.2645043135,
-0.7585887909,
0.1581017375,
0.2151699811,
1.1742466688,
-0.4739006758,
0.9820145965,
0.7885943651,
-0.1254935265,
-0.6579384208,
0.1714972407,
0.2681803405,
-0.8495166302,
0.8070825338,
0.1271904558,
-0.1655859202,
0.0732998326,
-0.2202098966,
-0.8753252625,
1.5269767046,
0.1455423683,
-0.5625801086,
-0.2961825728,
0.6049498916,
0.262691021,
-0.4872863591,
0.1733062863,
0.750623107,
0.7336939573,
-0.0826839358,
-1.0810052156,
0.1884330213,
-0.2879918218,
-0.020804286,
0.1768770218,
-0.4542966187,
0.9499551058,
0.0757013559,
-0.2782147825,
0.3052032888,
0.2031412423,
-0.1015080139,
0.3331001997,
0.3323732913,
0.7551342249,
0.7883957624,
-0.241709128,
0.9650377631,
-0.4243145585,
0.1396302581,
1.3387031555,
-0.7137844563,
0.7908334136,
0.164626807,
-0.3101359904,
0.5223931074,
0.6745364666,
-0.3821002543,
0.6864705682,
0.1460361332,
-0.3162100017,
-0.3329999149,
0.2823973894,
-0.2710744143,
0.260374248,
0.5135403872,
-0.249924764,
-0.7997332811,
-0.3511254191,
-0.4098623097,
0.0553005673,
-0.1406493783,
0.8461579084,
0.0355594791,
-0.7345317006,
0.4487782717,
-0.0650675297,
0.3446356058,
-0.4622053802,
0.1470389217,
-0.2179554105,
0.4043143988,
-0.2234726697,
-1.0251767635,
0.692155242,
-0.3020097017,
0.1239287183,
-0.846298337,
0.7969247103,
-0.1851435751,
-0.229101643,
0.4165294468,
0.8583265543,
0.2366677821,
0.1942568123,
-0.9058551788,
-0.2951055169,
-0.0808407813,
-0.1361240298,
0.2629080415,
0.4871832728,
0.0138641428,
0.8180866241,
0.5477634072,
0.1806111336,
0.1618657857,
-0.1364798695,
1.0473692417,
-1.013002634,
-0.3661083877,
-0.5954632163,
0.2048428804,
-0.3595385551,
-0.4171827734,
0.8319558501,
0.7575202584,
0.9214609861,
0.0963851064,
0.7928599119,
-0.0808602646,
0.565072298,
-0.5620915294,
0.6099107265,
-0.4057667851,
0.5055189133,
0.2341561019,
-1.230002284,
-0.078972064,
0.5614449978,
-0.6361550689,
-0.2035571039,
0.8426472545,
0.6686348319,
0.1381098479,
-0.0687569007,
0.1774948537,
-0.0479934663,
0.4757026136,
0.6826120019,
0.8791140318,
0.0887653977,
0.6647031307,
-0.7205781937,
-0.0023173047,
-0.187151894,
-0.9591993093,
-1.0259463787,
-0.3173397481,
-0.2236134112,
0.201812163,
0.1511271447,
0.7516648173,
0.6635665894,
-0.6282472014,
-0.5956210494,
-0.4448455274,
-0.080344528,
0.1685879827,
-0.2170554101,
0.3218444586,
-0.4257016182,
-0.4388146102,
0.6920748949,
0.3815001845,
0.2860393822,
-0.6999172568,
-0.0104037225,
0.111048393,
0.0053423643,
0.1797964424,
0.4160673916,
-0.5900452137,
0.2262913287,
-0.4735636115,
-0.2727153897,
-0.0239203945,
0.7821740508,
-1.0942522287,
0.2907841802,
0.3972176015,
0.4361724854,
0.812187314,
0.1300593615,
0.8961905241,
-0.5330178738,
0.0658515617,
0.3393864632,
0.4548943341,
0.1478671134,
-0.0390831232,
0.8913674951,
-0.0968088657,
-0.6246106029,
-0.7502816916,
0.2562346458,
-0.8637271523,
-0.3242069483,
0.8574688435,
-0.0261869431,
-0.2180083096,
-0.3809632957,
-0.2866290808,
-0.2299732864,
-0.0058247289,
0.8279249668,
0.5198715329,
-0.6077814698,
-0.018456297,
-0.665091455,
0.9827721715,
0.3786871135,
-1.2644830942,
0.3642955124,
0.5648804903,
0.0536064133,
-0.0806362703,
0.8540289402,
-0.0125986207,
0.419023186,
0.0956973583,
0.0005559555,
0.0789603144,
-0.1673525274,
0.298664391,
0.0441016778,
0.3109768331,
0.399802953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09829v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09829v1
|
FollowEval: A Multi-Dimensional Benchmark for Assessing the Instruction-Following Capability of Large Language Models
| 2023-11-16T11:53:31 | 2023-11-16T11:53:31 |
Yimin Jing, Renren Jin, Jiahao Hu, Huishi Qiu, Xiaohua Wang, Peng Wang, Deyi Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The effective assessment of the instruction-following ability of large
language models (LLMs) is of paramount importance. A model that cannot adhere
to human instructions might be not able to provide reliable and helpful
responses. In pursuit of this goal, various benchmarks have been constructed to
evaluate the instruction-following capacity of these models. However, these
benchmarks are limited to a single language and are constructed using automated
approaches, which restricts their applicability and the quality of the test
examples they contain. To bridge this gap, we introduce the FollowEval
benchmark in this paper. This benchmark is composed of instances in both
English and Chinese, and all test examples are crafted by human experts.
Furthermore, the FollowEval benchmark is designed to assess LLMs across five
critical dimensions of instruction following: string manipulation, commonsense
reasoning, logical reasoning, spatial reasoning, and response constraints. To
enhance the complexity and present a sufficient challenge, each test example is
designed to evaluate more than one dimension. We have evaluated various LLMs
using the FollowEval benchmark and found that their performance significantly
lags behind that of humans. This highlights the considerable room for
improvement in the instruction-following ability of these models.
|
[
-0.1837021261,
-0.6636388302,
0.2332533002,
0.5356410742,
0.2369650751,
0.2563362718,
-0.2585452795,
-0.2156530619,
-0.2073287517,
0.4944039583,
-0.644515276,
-0.6127087474,
-0.4902648926,
0.0102322036,
-0.1736812443,
0.6164882183,
-0.434297204,
0.0317661874,
-0.1085417643,
-0.2655805945,
-0.6349092126,
-0.3260158598,
-0.3883126974,
-0.0409845673,
0.4959075451,
0.3071318269,
0.605576396,
0.8196453452,
0.6416039467,
0.2352969497,
0.0791012272,
0.4031537473,
-0.5824198723,
-0.0052348915,
0.1691482067,
0.0299006868,
-0.3813527524,
-0.0051928707,
1.0402832031,
0.8806291223,
-0.1115406677,
0.3758770227,
0.2974959612,
0.595687151,
-0.5395536423,
0.212176457,
-0.2987230718,
-0.1256535053,
0.057016436,
0.1183268428,
-0.5279374123,
-1.1152762175,
0.1774019599,
-0.4193416238,
-0.1410384625,
0.0124913687,
0.4371712208,
0.2375835776,
-0.2748356462,
-0.1270338744,
-0.5425508618,
0.7390070558,
-0.7454903722,
0.791321516,
0.5517496467,
0.4384301007,
-0.0342976078,
-0.6885171533,
-0.3206322491,
-0.5179945827,
0.0932753161,
0.0847203135,
0.1705681235,
-0.3686441779,
0.42005983,
-0.1540413648,
-0.7407458425,
0.0073793828,
-0.3361082375,
-0.0017570978,
0.6118026972,
0.2734521329,
0.3578542769,
0.2808577418,
-0.5656988621,
-0.4850125611,
-0.8721783161,
0.2118304372,
0.1007352695,
0.3486677408,
-0.1293644011,
0.2616516054,
-0.0162303708,
0.5982365608,
-0.1155020669,
0.0672723204,
0.3442097008,
-0.5152355433,
-0.0136138117,
-0.0638831407,
0.6287004948,
0.3825098872,
0.309827894,
0.1476572156,
-0.2229755521,
-0.3234656453,
0.2339646071,
-1.0087497234,
-0.2479802072,
-0.0674514398,
-0.5040910244,
0.0662070289,
0.0734954178,
-0.7656478286,
-0.481084764,
-0.1705596,
0.2618711293,
-0.695962429,
-0.1043342054,
-0.2511057258,
0.4951353669,
0.7475484014,
0.3408074677,
-0.9934068322,
0.303799063,
0.99314785,
0.9173900485,
-0.3225682676,
-0.6704364419,
-0.6884928942,
0.0915894508,
-0.8776886463,
0.7566017509,
-0.9389635921,
-0.3882692456,
0.270124495,
0.0823669881,
-0.3198762238,
-0.513479352,
0.5879619718,
-0.5326464176,
-0.0750849545,
-0.5707151294,
-0.8643260598,
-0.6266239285,
0.2652150691,
-0.5150181055,
1.0246096849,
0.0676883161,
-0.3425274789,
0.2455445528,
-0.1747389436,
-0.540468812,
0.2179231495,
-0.2156033516,
-0.1870389879,
-0.0290934183,
0.1998272538,
0.3177242875,
-0.185925737,
-0.1658412367,
-0.5037008524,
-0.6751688123,
-0.2170657665,
-0.6718476415,
0.8414334655,
-0.2941506505,
-0.30502671,
0.1931292713,
-0.7464393973,
0.3922710419,
-0.0745459273,
-0.4338444471,
-0.4766685963,
0.384365201,
-0.1099893972,
0.0021768657,
0.4402354658,
-0.2807882726,
0.3308932781,
0.0521298088,
-0.1009223461,
0.9551472664,
-0.0191318039,
0.0440960526,
-0.2584361434,
0.5776831508,
-0.5007784963,
-0.0428250916,
-0.5204530358,
-0.1717863083,
-0.515705049,
-0.1325855553,
0.1335727721,
0.7555504441,
-0.4142591357,
0.3052657247,
-0.2882305682,
-0.7289102674,
-0.7090026736,
0.3664670289,
0.486666441,
0.3834123611,
0.5532273054,
0.0749404877,
-0.3797051907,
-0.5455610156,
-0.1743278354,
-0.3413529694,
-0.1786599457,
0.2428918034,
0.4878569841,
-0.0271826573,
0.0223544668,
-0.3609237373,
-0.0048066708,
-0.0965514034,
-0.1155172065,
0.2536661923,
0.4174707532,
0.3995427191,
-0.4058436453,
-0.99129951,
0.1978707314,
-0.8890480995,
-0.158228904,
-0.1540224999,
-0.0127632935,
0.1771218181,
0.6773073077,
-0.0873711258,
0.3758467138,
0.6489105821,
-0.3483939171,
0.6975895166,
-0.3701714873,
0.3490929306,
-0.7525892854,
-0.0449160114,
-0.0663900599,
-0.0387525409,
-0.6347716451,
0.3372273147,
0.3925288022,
0.1850350052,
-0.22227332,
0.4270219505,
-0.5495154262,
-0.1752165854,
-0.0831630751,
0.0927708521,
-0.1773388386,
0.3400661945,
0.1606997699,
1.1790173054,
0.6641641855,
-0.4413328767,
0.3592519164,
0.1542152911,
-0.4257667959,
0.5712935328,
-0.9521771073,
0.1557038575,
0.1425177455,
0.1052058935,
-1.128549695,
0.0067390162,
-0.1410728246,
-0.1307828873,
0.2625672519,
0.0333065055,
-0.6457765102,
-0.341917783,
-0.4874642491,
-0.011863675,
0.7710860372,
-0.7646187544,
0.7497856617,
-0.1932262778,
-0.1375622451,
-0.4715120792,
-0.5128139257,
-0.1366329789,
0.0179162417,
-0.561337471,
0.0654411167,
-0.3946360648,
-0.0624751188,
-0.3249834478,
-0.1399300247,
0.0541947782,
-0.1508510113,
0.0827965587,
0.4350179136,
-0.5113528371,
-0.0584874861,
-0.1704119891,
0.091603227,
0.2820931077,
-0.1484437287,
0.4432696998,
-0.4046862423,
-0.6630374193,
-0.6735089421,
0.2321173847,
0.4809864163,
-0.3490884304,
0.6570624709,
0.36407727,
-0.2651306689,
-0.2803867757,
-0.485866189,
-0.0573791601,
-0.5022341609,
0.6708542109,
-0.3181674182,
-0.1814559102,
0.4953982532,
0.0850508809,
0.6186035872,
0.1309219003,
0.485532999,
-0.1897400916,
1.1124905348,
0.5491158366,
-0.2000174969,
0.321918726,
-0.1061429754,
-0.2626795173,
-1.0386036634,
-0.2293644547,
-0.4813271165,
-0.1121854335,
-0.7196834087,
-0.6577362418,
0.1876819283,
-0.0910583958,
-0.5393580198,
0.5923608541,
-0.2160549313,
0.5134223104,
0.4932413399,
-0.1047747359,
0.0918492153,
-0.1409889013,
-0.4900502861,
-0.0162704065,
-0.5860054493,
-0.7169924378,
0.8616179824,
0.4592303336,
1.1053640842,
0.3859581053,
0.4814965725,
0.1060646027,
0.5303236246,
-0.5726831555,
0.7568157315,
-0.4671355784,
-0.238701269,
-0.1600243002,
-0.3935158253,
-0.6882458329,
0.4352780581,
0.0562449582,
-0.7882407904,
-0.2837215662,
-0.0571271963,
-0.3091934025,
0.3230648637,
-0.7430685759,
0.7078030109,
-0.408595711,
-0.6234692931,
-0.1575357914,
-0.5319480896,
0.1196535826,
-0.0164214708,
0.0760458186,
0.140925169,
-0.2800701857,
0.6526425481,
-0.2373266667,
0.8446831703,
0.0167049561,
-0.1415711045,
0.1815818846,
0.3256166279,
0.4185247421,
-0.372970432,
-0.1384496242,
-0.0846381783,
0.1046903282,
-0.4583983421,
-0.5261186957,
1.0108240843,
-0.8120372295,
-0.6940335631,
-0.1989470124,
-0.4835936725,
-0.4562551677,
0.4402056038,
-0.2083591074,
0.4787986279,
-0.2743157446,
0.2913963497,
0.8384971023,
-0.2256277204,
0.4379833043,
0.5194619894,
-0.3245367706,
-0.2952528894,
0.994663775,
0.2461806685,
0.3781841099,
0.4106995165,
0.3231950998,
-0.5071091652,
-0.5040590763,
-0.6127223372,
0.2321445644,
-0.7563798428,
0.0813082308,
-0.1668745428,
-0.4196007252,
-0.285528779,
-0.2251695246,
-0.3432814777,
0.18096371,
-0.3077246547,
0.1103422567,
-0.0699807182,
0.8845495582,
0.2935803235,
-0.0962368995,
-1.040527463,
0.1237030923,
0.3777166605,
0.6075709462,
0.4490996599,
-0.8754208088,
-0.0248738769,
-0.1191365644,
-0.3712353706,
-0.8017882109,
-0.0242508594,
0.1567082405,
0.9390165806,
0.575299859,
-0.0498286039,
0.8012623787,
-0.9030344486,
0.5966398716,
-0.0896337628,
-0.7893487215,
0.4943557978,
-0.2998969257,
0.5894865394,
0.5408556461,
0.6555047035,
-0.5277987123,
-0.1760710627,
-0.2207930684,
-0.4980998039,
0.4035821259,
-0.038906917,
0.1202157959,
0.0161291268,
0.1738395095,
-0.0291778464,
-0.2255985588,
-0.2924102843,
-0.1400253326,
-0.1288270652,
-0.2818429172,
0.0374724604,
-0.0334386751,
0.198494792,
0.0731051639,
0.5524260998,
-0.154817611,
-0.1219592988,
-0.1263303757,
0.0316641144,
0.0126099102,
-0.1736545116,
0.7168655396,
0.7985543609,
-0.1978528053,
-0.0072757332,
0.5155781507,
-0.5938825607,
-0.0862909406,
0.30780527,
-0.3750154674,
-0.3103339076,
0.9914619327,
0.5680022836,
0.0034805434,
-0.7479199767,
0.3754508197,
0.0178827755,
-0.0987744853,
-0.3643671274,
0.0993725955,
0.251696378,
0.4136799872,
0.422333777,
-0.1674494892,
-0.0829804465,
-0.4789875746,
0.3213998079,
0.4768953025,
-0.771071732,
-0.4896742105,
0.5896710753,
0.101086095,
-0.5287048221,
0.712262094,
0.1381991506,
-0.5396678448,
0.635504365,
0.5243788362,
0.6750351191,
-0.6359034777,
0.0639458522,
0.6278703213,
0.6048649549,
-0.1017661765,
0.3466669023,
0.1201824546,
-0.4255810082,
-0.3957755566,
-0.0930667669,
-0.4882724583,
-0.125156045,
-0.8256381154,
0.2096042633,
-0.7907301188,
0.3441381454,
-0.0842589512,
0.2047041953,
-0.5150145292,
-0.0534328558,
0.1683176607,
1.286044836,
-0.533972919,
0.7140235305,
0.669292748,
-0.4617788494,
-0.7832434773,
0.3439769447,
0.2766054273,
-1.0154426098,
0.7497352958,
0.4475682378,
-0.3091605902,
-0.2904417813,
-0.5082748532,
-0.7442970872,
1.0510758162,
-0.1699674278,
-0.6860103607,
0.1991539001,
-0.2923636436,
0.7335526347,
-0.6276869178,
0.4645187855,
0.5246446133,
0.368969053,
0.4125830829,
-0.6024103761,
0.2242103964,
0.0303768776,
0.1395272315,
0.1533439755,
-0.9432310462,
0.5006254315,
-0.5261663198,
-0.1148948073,
0.3116404712,
0.7253295183,
0.5214067698,
0.1049408838,
0.4050423205,
0.2014102936,
0.675776422,
0.1224363819,
1.0441553593,
-0.3332853913,
0.234181121,
1.3591140509,
-0.6678174734,
1.549297452,
0.1605992764,
-0.3073789179,
0.6406633854,
0.519525528,
-0.2673076987,
0.4438706934,
0.2808973789,
-0.0202533994,
-0.1936790645,
0.0016806036,
-0.339487046,
0.2520162463,
0.3351297081,
-0.2069276571,
-0.1759793609,
-0.2735406458,
0.0684726909,
0.4273246229,
-0.3172324598,
0.7004097104,
-0.2053923011,
-0.6925448775,
0.87175107,
-0.3661369085,
0.1980744898,
-0.7127524614,
-0.5307012796,
-0.4751787186,
0.272521764,
0.1369416863,
-0.9977638721,
0.1002229527,
0.0529439859,
0.173826322,
-0.2699318528,
0.3272260427,
-0.3520445526,
-0.7134261727,
0.5271649957,
0.3205402493,
0.004275904,
0.5524722934,
-0.750127852,
0.2456932515,
0.0856888294,
-0.3960643411,
0.1702171117,
0.2989896536,
-0.1866966337,
1.0793904066,
0.536057055,
0.2252148837,
0.0523369499,
0.2258611321,
0.7397022247,
-0.6097847223,
-0.1288551837,
-0.8267660737,
0.1330814213,
-0.0050186082,
-0.3549212515,
0.9543812275,
0.4343078136,
0.7593188286,
0.1862157583,
0.6979919076,
0.2202855051,
0.7738878131,
-0.4101721644,
0.6822395325,
-0.4413254559,
0.552069962,
-0.1965679675,
-1.1114238501,
-0.2137471586,
0.7754090428,
-0.2673612535,
0.384658128,
0.7110154629,
0.6047636867,
0.0198164508,
-0.0471352004,
0.4317936897,
0.41912058,
0.2762251198,
0.6402395964,
0.8484838605,
-0.31786111,
0.6062479019,
0.0196610168,
-0.4441257417,
0.0502189994,
-0.8065345287,
-1.2930874825,
-0.3845285773,
-0.2588479221,
-0.2533943355,
0.0267084073,
1.0514029264,
0.7542977333,
-0.9223041534,
-0.3772092164,
0.0657815412,
0.1128074676,
-0.7014962435,
-0.1553735286,
0.7773128748,
-0.2439966947,
-0.7185891867,
0.4032416344,
0.187187165,
0.021554919,
-0.6475993991,
-0.0699712783,
-0.4237723947,
0.2694699764,
0.6012064815,
0.2653375864,
-0.7788501978,
-0.6080662608,
0.4858484268,
-0.1913247406,
-0.2615452409,
0.4712151289,
-0.4747430384,
0.5169332027,
0.5751370192,
1.0204455853,
0.2344459742,
0.1170115918,
0.4720279574,
-0.429700762,
-0.4875294566,
0.1195523888,
0.2337660193,
0.4544909894,
0.1060776263,
0.5057516098,
-0.1208904535,
-0.6064183116,
-0.5506005287,
0.1147930473,
-0.6075599194,
-0.091158174,
1.1503227949,
-0.7382640839,
-0.0210872572,
0.1495160758,
0.0569950901,
-0.2474128008,
-0.3464170098,
0.6365637183,
0.8457482457,
-0.0976112634,
-0.5856617093,
-0.8787718415,
0.0359252281,
0.3205046058,
-0.8361569643,
0.4869866967,
0.4086383581,
0.2620353699,
0.159227699,
0.3628669679,
0.0664890185,
0.2426153123,
0.3031940162,
-0.310641259,
0.1377621442,
-0.3537257016,
-0.2453352362,
-0.0114485752,
-0.0374844037,
-0.3370254338
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09828v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09828v3
|
AfriMTE and AfriCOMET: Enhancing COMET to Embrace Under-resourced African Languages
| 2023-11-16T11:52:52 | 2024-04-23T18:22:05 |
Jiayi Wang, David Ifeoluwa Adelani, Sweta Agrawal, Marek Masiak, Ricardo Rei, Eleftheria Briakou, Marine Carpuat, Xuanli He, Sofia Bourhim, Andiswa Bukula, Muhidin Mohamed, Temitayo Olatoye, Tosin Adewumi, Hamam Mokayed, Christine Mwase, Wangui Kimotho, Foutse Yuehgoh, Anuoluwapo Aremu, Jessica Ojo, Shamsuddeen Hassan Muhammad, Salomey Osei, Abdul-Hakeem Omotayo, Chiamaka Chukwuneke, Perez Ogayo, Oumaima Hourrane, Salma El Anigri, Lolwethu Ndolela, Thabiso Mangwana, Shafie Abdi Mohamed, Ayinde Hassan, Oluwabusayo Olufunke Awoyomi, Lama Alkhaled, Sana Al-Azzawi, Naome A. Etori, Millicent Ochieng, Clemencia Siro, Samuel Njoroge, Eric Muchiri, Wangari Kimotho, Lyse Naomi Wamba Momo, Daud Abolade, Simbiat Ajao, Iyanuoluwa Shode, Ricky Macharm, Ruqayya Nasir Iro, Saheed S. Abdullahi, Stephen E. Moore, Bernard Opoku, Zainab Akinjobi, Abeeb Afolabi, Nnaemeka Obiefuna, Onyekachi Raphael Ogbu, Sam Brian, Verrah Akinyi Otiende, Chinedu Emmanuel Mbonu, Sakayo Toadoum Sari, Yao Lu, Pontus Stenetorp
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the recent progress on scaling multilingual machine translation (MT)
to several under-resourced African languages, accurately measuring this
progress remains challenging, since evaluation is often performed on n-gram
matching metrics such as BLEU, which typically show a weaker correlation with
human judgments. Learned metrics such as COMET have higher correlation;
however, the lack of evaluation data with human ratings for under-resourced
languages, complexity of annotation guidelines like Multidimensional Quality
Metrics (MQM), and limited language coverage of multilingual encoders have
hampered their applicability to African languages. In this paper, we address
these challenges by creating high-quality human evaluation data with simplified
MQM guidelines for error detection and direct assessment (DA) scoring for 13
typologically diverse African languages. Furthermore, we develop AfriCOMET:
COMET evaluation metrics for African languages by leveraging DA data from
well-resourced languages and an African-centric multilingual encoder
(AfroXLM-R) to create the state-of-the-art MT evaluation metrics for African
languages with respect to Spearman-rank correlation with human judgments
(0.441).
|
[
-0.5523962975,
-0.2183061689,
0.0607836209,
0.4681801498,
-0.2119922936,
0.4137589037,
-0.5726941228,
-0.3953592479,
0.3962630033,
0.2673791945,
-0.5492277741,
-0.2901143432,
-0.7512666583,
0.4579183459,
-0.3956383467,
0.9232487082,
-0.254712522,
0.0738732964,
-0.0941414535,
-0.552524507,
-0.2706001997,
-0.6418545246,
-0.250261724,
-0.280659765,
0.4238016009,
0.6831986308,
0.8882385492,
0.4755840302,
0.5204773545,
0.2984524369,
0.2317084372,
0.6253355145,
0.0515243448,
-0.0557510369,
-0.1761004031,
-0.0071524,
-0.4035478234,
-0.0217106864,
0.4947913289,
0.8782639503,
-0.3059522212,
0.434502244,
0.1721556634,
0.8901723027,
-0.6773576736,
0.0448478013,
-0.4564062655,
-0.2555443048,
-0.458581835,
-0.0129965693,
-0.0665747002,
-0.2440157235,
-0.3476498127,
-0.4594386816,
-0.1084311604,
-0.0451111905,
0.5453131199,
0.366874218,
-0.4253680706,
-0.4788461626,
-0.4772265255,
0.8504356146,
-0.382959038,
0.5136951804,
0.5955030322,
0.4147746265,
-0.0878492072,
-0.4705807567,
-0.3445185125,
-0.0670738369,
0.0524187945,
0.2260199934,
-0.2259602249,
-0.1824958175,
-0.1623740941,
0.4315965474,
-0.2846820056,
0.034240447,
0.0618113987,
-0.5425931215,
0.7552872896,
0.032974612,
0.2459009737,
-0.3424242437,
-0.2331114858,
-0.1590405852,
-0.2656401992,
-0.1391294301,
0.560863018,
0.5556941628,
-0.1528495699,
0.463316232,
-0.2671110332,
0.496922344,
0.005528132,
0.2108595073,
0.6393361688,
-0.4787774086,
0.0571844392,
-0.0298266765,
1.0326932669,
0.2250341326,
0.2727868855,
-0.2486324459,
-0.2952061892,
0.2884242237,
0.4087042511,
-0.8318520188,
-0.0888719931,
0.13804923,
-0.3768143058,
0.0602035671,
-0.0361004062,
-0.967402041,
-0.417167604,
-0.1175032109,
0.3756433129,
-0.5332683921,
-0.1078626364,
-0.0883500576,
0.1510090381,
-0.2631121576,
0.4875881672,
-0.8907227516,
0.4685210884,
0.3544590175,
0.720103085,
-0.0365217216,
-0.3007957041,
-0.4572013021,
-0.3790052533,
-0.1350703984,
0.4171049297,
-0.3061178327,
-0.273850739,
0.1070402041,
-0.0629026517,
-0.1320011467,
-0.3631723523,
1.0334382057,
-0.2498403192,
-0.1766248345,
-0.3482527733,
-0.3701869249,
-0.5843392611,
0.0773741156,
-0.4381543696,
0.8460927606,
0.5738820434,
-0.4782747626,
0.5153241158,
-0.7017477751,
-0.7428385615,
0.3616445959,
-0.075916253,
-0.2608186603,
0.194475472,
0.3901736736,
0.0717215538,
-0.4735021889,
-0.0679767579,
0.1783695966,
-0.2097822428,
0.2076701224,
-0.5615747571,
0.7470694184,
0.3346354067,
-0.5908992887,
-0.1012285724,
-0.9375501275,
0.2884737849,
-0.1708911955,
-0.4809071422,
-0.1407641321,
-0.014363762,
0.2475702316,
0.2502217293,
0.2995290756,
-0.7094760537,
0.0115876729,
-0.0456816368,
0.2285897583,
0.179664731,
-0.268925637,
0.3407440484,
-0.1823157966,
0.5507512093,
-0.0574361309,
0.0692274049,
0.224032566,
-0.5008372068,
-0.8906998038,
0.0390846804,
0.6206303239,
0.7190374732,
-0.8379113078,
0.5287544727,
-0.3716347516,
-0.6004776359,
-1.2774437666,
0.6425654888,
0.4437962174,
0.1731544435,
0.706700325,
-0.7251088023,
-0.4193002284,
-0.8554739356,
-0.0495709553,
-0.1088119671,
-0.0586205535,
0.3889736533,
0.4678421319,
-0.7385192513,
0.4301311672,
0.1128144786,
-0.5344188809,
-0.1155551672,
0.1660544574,
0.2381437868,
0.6067761183,
0.69690907,
-0.7233352661,
-0.2780245841,
0.2713543475,
-0.4870727658,
-0.3736305833,
0.091091767,
-0.0430233739,
0.333883673,
-0.0413000956,
-0.1992305368,
0.274697125,
0.8068092465,
-0.3409389257,
0.5690737963,
-0.2334474474,
0.7736735344,
-0.5026810765,
0.1757467538,
-0.1372332573,
-0.1681171358,
-0.3092111051,
0.16009067,
0.3324895203,
0.0498474054,
-0.4685887098,
0.4883958101,
-0.4728092849,
-0.0652755797,
-0.3411012888,
0.3875326216,
-0.0627184808,
0.2639870644,
-0.0650333837,
0.8441489339,
0.0572878718,
-0.6311879754,
0.3472048938,
0.7853122354,
-0.5373595357,
0.7156822085,
-0.1995645761,
0.1011449471,
0.2564159334,
-0.0913252831,
-0.5851896405,
-0.0575859621,
0.1045395881,
-0.7720351815,
0.3749348819,
-0.3216562271,
-0.5341794491,
-0.5148922205,
0.1254758835,
0.4507741034,
0.3810239434,
-0.4794273674,
0.4267401099,
0.2120702118,
-0.0614691973,
-0.7118166685,
-1.078627944,
0.3201635778,
0.0658282042,
-0.7894551754,
0.0701229721,
-0.1162547544,
-0.255505085,
-0.2423075289,
-0.1290581822,
-0.0207320526,
0.5148568749,
0.2479373813,
-0.2796320617,
-0.150150463,
-0.0822074115,
0.0102345906,
-0.0647475049,
-0.0329367444,
-0.3110426664,
0.6583886743,
-0.1693312824,
-0.2827012837,
-0.2503435612,
0.2803094685,
0.2918872833,
-0.5180928707,
0.8055921793,
0.9315720201,
-0.21269463,
-0.0384084508,
-0.4908197522,
0.0177722462,
-0.3872639835,
0.0747925788,
-0.5096308589,
-0.593567431,
0.7339448333,
0.0515333973,
-0.0280322526,
0.458245188,
0.7443885207,
-0.0705336332,
0.6856831908,
0.3939628899,
-0.0430460349,
0.2103370726,
-0.3036515415,
-0.35716784,
-1.1111576557,
-0.0085471729,
-0.6462667584,
-0.4521203339,
-0.7507395148,
-0.2595512271,
-0.0159200747,
0.1245833784,
-0.0589389242,
0.5708732605,
-0.0612161085,
0.0559617206,
0.5215114951,
-0.0172581319,
0.1185994446,
-0.0479849316,
-0.4551018476,
-0.071267359,
-0.6839471459,
-0.5592237711,
0.9994629025,
-0.0489822552,
0.4804149568,
0.2622768581,
0.8626605868,
0.4599887133,
0.441675663,
-0.8209670186,
0.0629016086,
-0.5248462558,
-0.6025835872,
-0.0224568807,
-0.8335821033,
-0.9550729394,
0.432474345,
-0.1224639043,
-0.4139605463,
0.3782967031,
-0.022026794,
-0.1822809279,
0.1046986058,
-0.416750133,
0.8919945359,
-0.4372429252,
-0.2976911366,
-0.1905406564,
-0.640981555,
0.0904092863,
-0.4744821489,
0.8010052443,
-0.1619445533,
-0.0223017875,
0.7290213704,
-0.7082901597,
0.3631421924,
-0.2716898918,
0.0657353327,
0.4737706482,
0.5065355301,
-0.0855437666,
0.0122518791,
-0.4172948301,
0.4878951013,
-0.2513839602,
-0.5422428846,
-0.4104519188,
0.5632296205,
-0.7635656595,
-0.2304434329,
-0.3585575819,
-0.5351352096,
-0.1515866518,
0.0896703899,
0.1417234093,
0.4417897463,
-0.1636114568,
0.1438804418,
-0.2240405083,
-0.2125567049,
0.3687697947,
0.7416206002,
0.0508466586,
-0.8109191656,
0.7516084313,
0.0057777339,
0.4243369699,
0.110192284,
0.0234484747,
-0.2630633116,
-0.8216153383,
-0.9841451049,
0.059305191,
-0.5159714222,
-0.6631376147,
-0.431178838,
0.0817192495,
-0.1852873117,
-0.1057285815,
-0.4151308835,
-0.7042149305,
-0.0764725432,
0.1290016174,
0.3982789814,
0.3098709583,
-0.5531341434,
0.6700614691,
-1.2080097198,
0.1538134962,
-0.2870306969,
0.0989953503,
0.0164236352,
-0.6137136817,
-0.6315975189,
0.6490595937,
-0.4138567448,
-0.3785512745,
0.4998179078,
0.4941886067,
0.6054798961,
0.0946752205,
0.0454156995,
0.6385551095,
-0.5895130038,
0.6230734587,
0.1211174428,
-1.0573778152,
0.4632065892,
-0.1090585664,
0.2393013835,
1.0613718033,
0.4132336676,
-0.7899131775,
-0.2750956714,
-0.4723813236,
-0.7729450464,
0.5194664598,
0.6425175071,
-0.0541579649,
-0.2509616911,
0.3300391734,
0.1836666018,
0.4624192119,
-0.2496454865,
-0.4732201099,
-0.4478631914,
-0.3334451318,
-0.3977513611,
0.0754099563,
0.0882770419,
0.026624348,
0.633241117,
-0.1531964093,
-0.0447177738,
0.2968611419,
-0.6706037521,
-0.3686754704,
0.3813616037,
0.1619959772,
0.4841937125,
-0.4438780546,
-0.1931286007,
-0.1193588004,
-0.7679297924,
0.4686512053,
0.4466412067,
-0.114011474,
-0.1204135194,
0.4048329592,
0.3708366454,
0.0874856189,
-0.3405997157,
0.4695292115,
-0.0700192377,
0.0336422361,
-0.1029227972,
-0.1354500055,
-0.210853368,
-0.0827936754,
0.5750080347,
0.3077976406,
0.1795801222,
-0.5842564702,
0.4817274809,
0.2174021006,
-0.6517205238,
-0.3297017217,
0.6302448511,
0.7653638124,
-0.1425533146,
0.7207311392,
-0.3710784316,
-0.7061491609,
0.426723659,
0.2360602319,
0.676402688,
-0.5778842568,
0.1845819354,
0.2969260812,
0.6818363667,
0.1220351756,
0.5302454829,
-0.0373319685,
-0.9402513504,
-0.5033749342,
-0.9818602204,
-0.3385685086,
-0.4191246331,
-0.7919415832,
0.0605527088,
-0.3294530213,
-0.4148726165,
0.0043296004,
0.5858005285,
-0.8548231721,
0.3666616082,
0.0367486514,
0.8818179965,
-0.6232241988,
0.666523695,
0.6410819292,
-0.7584237456,
-0.2989910543,
-0.5045174956,
0.2568416893,
-0.797630012,
0.5816701651,
0.0032067506,
-0.0777700618,
0.0450612195,
0.1492383331,
-0.5552483201,
0.840723455,
0.2963833511,
-0.5861420631,
0.5495265722,
0.0878800303,
0.4717437327,
-0.3031454086,
0.4722516239,
0.7266920805,
0.8644467592,
-0.1185459867,
-1.1365358829,
-0.0631905273,
-0.0240998361,
-0.5074370503,
0.7988373041,
-0.6742565036,
0.4307695925,
-0.3094820976,
-0.5506808758,
0.4387901127,
0.5130374432,
-0.1999224722,
0.0988459438,
0.3675730526,
0.5822533369,
0.6504489183,
-0.3751133084,
1.2642365694,
-0.3279916346,
0.0960847959,
0.8954126835,
-0.1541803777,
0.7407766581,
0.1512324661,
-0.2848462164,
0.5462468863,
0.5680610538,
-0.117501922,
0.1747228056,
0.2239647359,
0.0162256882,
-0.3396817148,
-0.2772665024,
-0.1982661933,
0.5973441005,
0.6108347774,
-0.1115781292,
-0.2018820792,
-0.0959874317,
0.0634214804,
0.4424087703,
-0.4611029923,
0.6028851867,
0.3172736168,
-0.1553999484,
0.7807817459,
0.0468286574,
0.8510065079,
-0.5907777548,
0.3298897743,
-0.4122039676,
0.1212247759,
-0.4993596971,
-0.6741000414,
0.2754459977,
-0.0252603497,
-0.0424321219,
0.0452236123,
0.3157728612,
-0.626085639,
-0.6260131598,
0.6685987711,
0.812817812,
0.1982501596,
-0.1571924239,
-0.6832105517,
0.0322908051,
0.067567192,
0.2598643899,
0.1368763447,
0.5126094222,
-0.0228059255,
0.7198264599,
0.6547874212,
0.4061717987,
-0.1896552145,
0.3941999078,
0.360389024,
-0.6728702784,
-0.2009674013,
-0.7877553105,
0.2842464447,
0.2153831273,
-0.3287224174,
1.0044645071,
0.6085318327,
0.6748303175,
0.0500420853,
0.5808508396,
-0.078389436,
0.4885771573,
-0.3666586876,
0.9623507857,
-0.6057382226,
-0.1779344231,
-0.4786790609,
-1.242451787,
-0.2440599799,
0.4856783152,
0.1992324144,
-0.0628643855,
0.6708927155,
0.1810894161,
-0.0518458448,
-0.1783821136,
0.1773135364,
0.0673704222,
0.2515301406,
0.5609768629,
0.7754410505,
-0.8073477149,
0.6552467346,
-0.2555215359,
-0.2706011236,
-0.2297373563,
-0.7869849205,
-0.4969703853,
-0.4665630162,
-0.5193007588,
-0.2542313337,
-0.1140644997,
0.9435955286,
0.5290126204,
-1.0447427034,
-0.50617522,
0.3797817528,
-0.0438401252,
-0.463522464,
-0.1535130888,
0.2572004497,
-0.3311335444,
-0.5981351733,
0.583517909,
0.0596284457,
0.213571623,
-0.0486407541,
-0.21791251,
-0.3324138224,
-0.1944158524,
0.54581815,
0.1376548558,
-0.4118772745,
-0.2521989346,
-0.3567434549,
0.1074747145,
0.1557136476,
0.5618007183,
-0.700470686,
0.3533651233,
0.0338705704,
0.7675004601,
0.3571251035,
0.1641624719,
0.7756896019,
-0.8117818236,
0.1912347227,
0.3236268163,
0.702614665,
0.8549737334,
-0.0452139191,
0.9125063419,
0.0355961844,
-0.6288793683,
-0.5113383532,
0.2076364756,
-0.9114775658,
0.203738898,
1.0637338161,
-0.199544549,
-0.2271404564,
-0.0759307146,
0.0303090271,
0.1190537885,
-0.6502272487,
0.5105239749,
0.8033697605,
0.1516793072,
0.2020206004,
-0.5456668139,
0.5574498773,
0.2007799149,
-0.6972894073,
0.071097374,
0.5616713762,
0.094732821,
0.6533274055,
0.0487363897,
-0.2648718953,
0.4740319848,
0.0212234147,
0.2053946704,
-0.0358726121,
-0.0316683501,
-0.3216613829,
-0.4015932679,
0.0951129496,
-0.2040088475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09827v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09827v2
|
Cognitive Overload: Jailbreaking Large Language Models with Overloaded Logical Thinking
| 2023-11-16T11:52:22 | 2024-02-29T08:20:07 |
Nan Xu, Fei Wang, Ben Zhou, Bang Zheng Li, Chaowei Xiao, Muhao Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated increasing power, they
have also given rise to a wide range of harmful behaviors. As representatives,
jailbreak attacks can provoke harmful or unethical responses from LLMs, even
after safety alignment. In this paper, we investigate a novel category of
jailbreak attacks specifically designed to target the cognitive structure and
processes of LLMs. Specifically, we analyze the safety vulnerability of LLMs in
the face of (1) multilingual cognitive overload, (2) veiled expression, and (3)
effect-to-cause reasoning. Different from previous jailbreak attacks, our
proposed cognitive overload is a black-box attack with no need for knowledge of
model architecture or access to model weights. Experiments conducted on
AdvBench and MasterKey reveal that various LLMs, including both popular
open-source model Llama 2 and the proprietary model ChatGPT, can be compromised
through cognitive overload. Motivated by cognitive psychology work on managing
cognitive load, we further investigate defending cognitive overload attack from
two perspectives. Empirical studies show that our cognitive overload from three
perspectives can jailbreak all studied LLMs successfully, while existing
defense strategies can hardly mitigate the caused malicious uses effectively.
|
[
-0.3128937781,
-1.1818178892,
0.6560685039,
0.0844070166,
-0.1055009738,
0.2416234761,
-0.249840036,
-0.7909206152,
0.0525506809,
1.1819130182,
-0.3355926275,
0.0816851258,
-0.7422222495,
-0.3625757098,
-0.4480715096,
1.1813839674,
0.0123298299,
0.0125698857,
-0.188927412,
-0.0822727978,
-1.1336259842,
-0.7834527493,
-0.3463465869,
-0.080009684,
0.2654305398,
0.1514562368,
0.6672419906,
0.1284040958,
0.4547325969,
0.2702815831,
0.1100624576,
-0.3480728865,
-0.5550127029,
0.3213394582,
-0.3738994598,
-0.7123196125,
-0.4892547131,
-0.0208957419,
0.156322211,
0.1824606061,
-0.4114869237,
0.2041945308,
-0.2195383906,
0.7978922725,
-0.9379245043,
-0.2450294048,
-1.1163361073,
-0.2214799076,
-0.389529705,
0.1911081821,
-0.6315934658,
-0.0504485779,
-0.1203236133,
-0.2677582502,
-0.4458573163,
0.067764096,
0.3392688036,
0.4827193916,
-0.4749698341,
-0.3637407124,
-0.4963425398,
0.8313593268,
-0.4888134003,
-0.0048220339,
0.5989608169,
0.3606349826,
-0.1088918969,
-0.1447735429,
-0.438265413,
-0.3766462803,
0.1830134541,
0.0923445225,
-0.3702777326,
0.0453550816,
0.3592566252,
0.0927260295,
-0.3277992606,
0.0703374594,
-0.7447912693,
0.0168121271,
0.6004146338,
0.1301668286,
0.6426038146,
-0.135386318,
-0.6109132171,
0.2571590245,
-0.6945836544,
-0.1477766186,
0.3534249961,
-0.0576519817,
-0.1450272501,
0.8058732152,
0.3617557883,
0.7050552368,
-0.2883323729,
0.0889707878,
-0.1155978441,
0.0734326243,
-0.2820233703,
0.5268427134,
0.731771946,
0.5240402222,
0.6867597699,
-0.1532575488,
0.1091755107,
0.2079437822,
0.8636161089,
-0.6757487059,
0.1412386894,
0.5106393099,
-0.032532759,
-0.6303214431,
-0.0300738774,
-0.7251502872,
-0.769243896,
0.399322331,
0.1747868955,
-0.487847954,
-0.273445636,
0.4899080098,
-0.0099422401,
0.2083835304,
0.0595852472,
-0.8188731074,
0.3764654696,
0.660479784,
0.6912902594,
-0.0281044301,
0.0014795943,
-0.1667276323,
0.4412498474,
-0.2508140206,
0.4689311087,
-0.2449205816,
-0.4703147411,
-0.1975936592,
-0.3210260868,
-0.1152357385,
-0.4018498957,
0.5080251098,
-0.7585369945,
-0.0680408552,
-0.0741827637,
-0.5033575892,
-0.1667417735,
0.4487490058,
-0.9374812245,
0.7531413436,
-0.1361190379,
-0.8770468831,
0.0404139198,
-0.5218707323,
-0.6012452245,
-0.0218103714,
-0.173906669,
-0.1646215916,
0.1338563114,
0.0136008235,
0.2676400244,
-0.6486488581,
0.4058682323,
-0.6112672687,
-0.017787477,
0.7459964156,
-0.3588794172,
1.0867732763,
0.3283276856,
-0.3063008487,
-0.1495529115,
-0.7051377296,
0.074603416,
0.5486838222,
-0.2662076056,
-0.6415197849,
0.1237682998,
-0.1828539073,
0.4592425823,
0.457731843,
-0.859092176,
0.1566614509,
-0.2732193172,
1.0050673485,
0.7108469605,
0.0119687021,
0.1422322392,
-0.2721800208,
0.3370083272,
-0.18955037,
0.3456399441,
-0.0398924127,
-0.3375163078,
-0.2380536348,
-0.3657396734,
-0.2241420746,
1.0462063551,
-0.3285020292,
0.3540147841,
0.0613954738,
-0.4869779646,
-0.535675168,
0.3170304298,
0.5688799024,
0.2624395788,
0.4485694468,
-0.2201431245,
-0.3519225419,
-0.8019025326,
-0.4410301447,
-0.1782278121,
0.2082525939,
0.1040005684,
0.4887194335,
-0.2193612307,
0.5980724096,
-0.7082005143,
-0.4308864474,
-0.4190634787,
-0.4417524338,
0.0358425193,
0.5792322755,
0.7758659124,
-0.4986839294,
0.1019642279,
-0.2955526114,
-0.7855898738,
0.0130699081,
-0.3783331513,
-0.0112606538,
0.1706205755,
0.9046801925,
-1.0713354349,
0.1779634356,
0.3571459353,
-0.4704702199,
0.5205998421,
-0.1212698147,
-0.305659622,
-0.9384698868,
-0.2508066297,
-0.1624053121,
0.1199243367,
-0.5990849137,
0.5530354977,
0.1592068076,
-0.111398086,
-0.4743495286,
0.3140974045,
-0.291385293,
0.1182297617,
-0.4054231048,
0.0821374729,
0.0706539825,
0.2680950463,
-0.2548770308,
0.2830904424,
0.5920413733,
0.0638256744,
0.54690063,
0.0348953977,
-0.5587356091,
0.4354062974,
-0.7225714326,
0.2429280728,
-0.0782260075,
0.4212598801,
-0.9197718501,
-0.1410018355,
0.0750445575,
-0.2473463863,
0.3871130049,
0.094003357,
-0.5876184106,
-0.2928166091,
-0.5551973581,
0.6117289662,
0.2461396456,
-0.2603410482,
0.5079616308,
0.5533706546,
0.0376161523,
-0.6012772322,
-1.1103807688,
0.3656463027,
-0.4612114429,
-0.6829684973,
0.1112860739,
0.0819591805,
-0.6030550599,
-0.208118394,
-0.1880594641,
0.1094951704,
0.6092716455,
0.430439949,
0.5339499712,
0.024190126,
-0.1920651942,
-0.3151297569,
0.0770134479,
0.5276536942,
-0.3422507644,
0.5821014047,
-0.1934460402,
-0.4229362011,
0.0317926668,
0.4739001095,
0.9045868516,
-0.441783458,
0.9338473082,
0.0909114331,
-0.287497133,
-0.0423312411,
-0.847673893,
0.0072514229,
-0.4607438743,
0.5575288534,
-0.2629449368,
-1.011950016,
0.4071071446,
0.2010208368,
0.0874404758,
0.0447935797,
0.5983546376,
-0.0896973461,
0.8325132132,
0.5105683208,
-0.5054681897,
0.4686512351,
0.0183623414,
0.1202777699,
-0.890098989,
-0.255651325,
-0.3248791397,
-0.123100169,
-0.5096062422,
-0.3239593208,
-0.0538066477,
0.2400029302,
-0.5278574228,
0.4235247374,
-0.3305712044,
0.6138702035,
0.3216035068,
0.1717981547,
0.1693682075,
-0.2699240148,
-0.0664677918,
0.193697691,
-0.4800244272,
-0.40361619,
1.3844966888,
0.4499911368,
1.0027014017,
0.3708689511,
0.4128528833,
0.3013285995,
-0.046864666,
-0.6279541254,
0.5923730135,
0.0636223853,
-1.213178277,
-0.0739535242,
-0.1619269103,
-0.7979950309,
0.3082080483,
-0.2937985659,
-1.2344574928,
-0.1647866964,
0.0218921583,
-0.3536384702,
0.4059299827,
-0.7472127676,
0.8575342298,
-0.8726750016,
-0.3263634443,
-0.6595087051,
-0.8516913652,
0.8782935739,
-0.4977050722,
0.6284226179,
-0.1100154743,
0.1138669178,
0.4712121189,
-0.3495242894,
1.0832151175,
-0.0108308084,
-0.1889328212,
0.3563733697,
0.3347454965,
0.4995681047,
0.0638490766,
0.0745511651,
0.2126550376,
-0.1021082401,
-0.6710558534,
-0.5536602736,
0.7559507489,
-0.8323942423,
-1.079174161,
-0.349249959,
-0.6010517478,
-0.1595353037,
0.1472553909,
0.1167793497,
0.2035687417,
-0.1526713818,
-0.0545971394,
0.6471464634,
-0.4276771843,
0.2257412076,
0.5112812519,
-0.2012148052,
-0.4540224671,
0.8190367222,
0.0665520132,
0.7895912528,
0.0625231937,
-0.0458974987,
0.145312041,
-0.6083287597,
-0.3377729952,
0.0865743235,
-0.5512290001,
-0.1387662739,
-0.5823908448,
-0.1845764667,
-0.3075697422,
-0.2941885293,
-0.3591073751,
-0.5846541524,
0.1865477115,
-0.3659905195,
0.4260551631,
0.5729019046,
0.3479074538,
0.3287503719,
-0.6617902517,
0.4100869894,
0.261654824,
0.2058987319,
0.0025888488,
-0.1538673192,
-0.1714658439,
-0.3799177408,
-0.5978121758,
-1.1403825283,
-0.0117140803,
-0.1752340645,
0.5391617417,
0.4913696349,
0.2335259765,
0.4272673726,
-0.5737651587,
0.6174201369,
0.3924872577,
-0.8594338894,
0.4945052862,
-0.1808309257,
0.2645023167,
0.4785908759,
0.1018136665,
-0.348721385,
-0.8632196188,
-0.6995953321,
-1.0679051876,
0.5738176703,
0.1293848604,
0.3445487022,
-0.2084801197,
0.2993067205,
-0.238904357,
0.2756409347,
-0.854141891,
-0.1152711883,
-0.4222892225,
0.0530649424,
0.1048953682,
-0.3808746934,
-0.2468958795,
0.01102228,
0.6044172049,
0.3159717619,
-0.1430873722,
-0.0430108421,
-0.4917072356,
-0.0504261144,
0.5062148571,
0.5422766209,
0.156296581,
-0.1664721817,
0.2088327855,
0.3044953644,
-0.7080360055,
0.2222940028,
-0.1240206733,
-0.0294658989,
-0.8078061938,
0.5821405649,
0.7419192195,
0.3019607663,
-1.055814743,
0.4250247478,
0.1209152639,
0.1259126514,
-0.5202963948,
0.3632274568,
0.1652591676,
0.3896265626,
0.1417623609,
0.2204700857,
-0.2077532262,
-0.8241452575,
0.0585744977,
0.7974103689,
-0.3074191809,
-0.0606256388,
0.746607542,
-0.0332481787,
0.008398273,
0.5731713176,
0.3000514805,
-0.6551543474,
0.6834261417,
0.7596004605,
0.7815382481,
-0.1830584705,
-0.2753798068,
0.0463215597,
0.8606622815,
-0.0680599734,
0.0980904549,
-0.0170107428,
-0.9454339147,
-0.5213709474,
-0.2323711663,
-0.1152276471,
0.2858463526,
-0.7726024389,
0.1247109324,
-0.9153699279,
-0.4339680076,
-0.041531045,
-0.2051610053,
-0.0054921941,
0.0575496368,
0.496408999,
0.9093312025,
-0.5270698071,
1.09230721,
0.4511322677,
-0.1778484732,
-0.4523580968,
-0.073139593,
0.2917026877,
-0.9709994197,
0.5673635602,
0.2384667993,
-0.0803717598,
-0.2487449795,
-0.4481010437,
-0.8785745502,
0.7520329356,
0.5499863029,
-0.5691317916,
-0.0673593506,
0.1780285835,
0.2435307652,
-0.1769890487,
0.0461847819,
0.842762053,
0.5170173049,
-0.2101079971,
-0.6289356947,
0.4620831311,
-0.1317561716,
-0.2404965162,
0.5876836181,
-0.6928064823,
0.7686268687,
-0.5925714374,
0.0729092732,
-0.0419949144,
0.305223465,
0.4720614552,
-0.1356146187,
0.4282219708,
0.865819037,
0.4686013162,
0.3041771948,
1.1917116642,
-0.3190178275,
0.0130350944,
1.254856348,
-0.4941081405,
0.7361516356,
0.5329336524,
0.1572010964,
0.3254967332,
0.0466999784,
-0.2363492846,
0.5602379441,
0.5621196032,
-0.0458911806,
-0.2177989632,
0.2574094236,
-0.1777021885,
0.3914493322,
0.800919652,
-0.1366537511,
-0.2618997395,
0.3418742716,
0.4300194681,
0.0611553267,
-0.3286682069,
0.6520246267,
0.3642780185,
-0.5960930586,
0.7673173547,
0.1737281382,
0.543348968,
-0.5313910246,
0.4916708767,
0.3080676496,
0.1973249018,
-0.3096454442,
-0.8299349546,
0.3272594213,
0.3289334774,
-0.1184391603,
-0.0339941122,
0.7396474481,
-0.0610788316,
-0.4382849932,
0.8902577758,
0.2119481266,
-0.142008394,
-0.2383716702,
-0.8408210278,
0.1246626973,
-0.0297604688,
-0.4607288241,
0.600259304,
0.1416373849,
-0.5262367725,
0.8047962189,
0.6405774355,
0.1824882478,
0.3015350401,
-0.2188552916,
0.8162351251,
-0.7988607883,
-0.2800376117,
-1.3535128832,
0.2254139185,
-0.1223892048,
-0.0994540304,
0.6312975883,
0.3104798496,
0.7208451033,
0.2776474655,
0.943688035,
-0.1967066675,
-0.0701511428,
-0.6361100674,
0.8096016049,
-0.2490574419,
0.5731834769,
-0.4892616272,
-0.5957420468,
-0.2274964005,
0.240634799,
-0.6246419549,
-0.2238705903,
0.6280091405,
0.4343349338,
0.1951798052,
0.1719225049,
0.2136334181,
0.5543612242,
0.3659798205,
0.930141449,
0.9662801623,
0.0352260992,
0.7642752528,
0.043099191,
-0.2703813612,
-0.131058827,
-0.7123383284,
-1.2051949501,
-0.2034866065,
-0.2178703547,
-0.4320275784,
0.0268409774,
0.5968542099,
0.3007064462,
-0.6068550348,
-0.2183985561,
-0.1139747947,
0.0791284218,
-0.0139820129,
-0.1992968619,
0.080382742,
-0.2944006026,
0.0362100936,
0.4015907049,
0.2468815893,
-0.113271594,
-0.3432956636,
0.2769280672,
-0.2428410947,
0.3581420183,
0.5139023066,
0.2310231328,
-0.739546895,
-0.1447726041,
-0.2331925631,
-0.2877580523,
-0.0860990956,
0.8719834685,
-0.5141740441,
0.2153707147,
0.1204990223,
0.7640994191,
0.4273241758,
-0.1915946603,
0.7065404058,
-0.4956164658,
0.4166514874,
0.0597674884,
0.5624215007,
0.0769867375,
-0.5119720697,
0.1978939027,
0.0192907639,
-0.3053399324,
-0.8427920938,
0.6300029755,
-1.0451353788,
-0.9769377112,
0.8913160563,
0.0062350715,
-0.3305805027,
-0.1740377247,
-0.4167004824,
-0.0832848921,
-0.3566720188,
1.0456848145,
0.9133341312,
0.223195225,
0.0723764077,
-1.2380115986,
0.2280668765,
0.4294510186,
-0.7051659822,
0.3766017258,
0.3788780272,
0.2533261776,
0.317905426,
0.2095260918,
-0.4311686456,
0.3147913516,
-0.2681755722,
0.0567067005,
-0.2216736674,
-0.1280933321,
-0.128907308,
0.4097904563,
0.0181546658,
0.0224946551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09825v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09825v1
|
Human Still Wins over LLM: An Empirical Study of Active Learning on Domain-Specific Annotation Tasks
| 2023-11-16T11:51:13 | 2023-11-16T11:51:13 |
Yuxuan Lu, Bingsheng Yao, Shao Zhang, Yun Wang, Peng Zhang, Tun Lu, Toby Jia-Jun Li, Dakuo Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated considerable advances, and
several claims have been made about their exceeding human performance. However,
in real-world tasks, domain knowledge is often required. Low-resource learning
methods like Active Learning (AL) have been proposed to tackle the cost of
domain expert annotation, raising this question: Can LLMs surpass compact
models trained with expert annotations in domain-specific tasks? In this work,
we conduct an empirical experiment on four datasets from three different
domains comparing SOTA LLMs with small models trained on expert annotations
with AL. We found that small models can outperform GPT-3.5 with a few hundreds
of labeled data, and they achieve higher or similar performance with GPT-4
despite that they are hundreds time smaller. Based on these findings, we posit
that LLM predictions can be used as a warmup method in real-world applications
and human experts remain indispensable in tasks involving data annotation
driven by domain-specific knowledge.
|
[
-0.2413721979,
-0.7899364829,
0.5801218152,
-0.0525737852,
-0.1937559098,
0.1933027059,
-0.7628978491,
-0.8027124405,
-0.1715685576,
0.3544019461,
-0.3560087681,
-0.3099206686,
-0.5849232674,
0.2822043598,
-0.0605627187,
0.7864118814,
-0.1586580127,
0.0010134219,
-0.379000634,
-0.1945252717,
-0.3036444485,
-0.6687924266,
-0.7688196301,
-0.6141821146,
0.6490637064,
0.4589338005,
0.7884990573,
0.7127629519,
0.6050305963,
0.2571993768,
-0.0451144688,
0.4265860617,
-0.3042468131,
0.0246609654,
0.0266947001,
-0.6994789839,
-0.5252887011,
0.3439273834,
0.5639634132,
0.8914296031,
-0.130594641,
0.0143896267,
-0.0484306514,
0.5359181166,
-0.4391942024,
0.0576078631,
-0.815998733,
0.0066154255,
-0.2984196544,
0.0678721145,
-0.3647535741,
-0.1058962047,
0.2186415792,
-0.6079745889,
0.478479594,
0.3055689931,
0.9517326951,
0.5611065626,
-0.3722269535,
-0.1528592259,
-0.7877964973,
0.9100063443,
-0.6633666754,
0.2104842216,
0.6281234026,
0.2718343735,
0.0955030546,
-0.5435621738,
-0.6023661494,
-0.349732399,
0.0410229675,
-0.0435096063,
-0.0993148014,
-0.0347242244,
0.4743989408,
0.1082520112,
-0.3082166314,
0.4510451853,
-0.3964859247,
-0.1280736327,
0.7494292855,
-0.0035525854,
0.2323310822,
0.0043978784,
-0.5783014297,
0.2182749361,
-0.9429604411,
-0.1473541111,
0.02596974,
0.4273014665,
0.0145461243,
0.4600509405,
-0.1400205642,
0.5964316726,
0.0866617411,
-0.1765726954,
0.0096578728,
0.0479984991,
-0.354301095,
-0.123934187,
0.6768113375,
0.123603344,
0.6010217071,
-0.4889336526,
-0.3261400461,
0.0632283837,
0.1329070628,
-0.5213523507,
-0.5192696452,
-0.2066821754,
-0.210488826,
0.0928374827,
-0.1279096603,
-0.3207179606,
-0.427631706,
-0.3007942438,
0.4340631664,
-0.0932368636,
-0.2017193139,
-0.0674492791,
0.4157694578,
0.0053367959,
0.6624902487,
-0.7895523906,
0.5421962142,
0.574850142,
0.8872693777,
-0.5156185031,
-0.1647196859,
-0.3159234226,
-0.0428559966,
-0.3694991767,
0.8779628277,
-0.441573441,
-0.1194457039,
-0.0541658513,
-0.1006893888,
-0.17595011,
-0.9090518951,
0.3106819391,
-0.7840622663,
-0.0332524441,
-0.4036780298,
-0.4767528474,
-0.035047695,
0.2041984051,
-0.7851810455,
0.9766054153,
-0.1087057069,
-0.5784617066,
0.5288760066,
-0.4814339578,
-0.4784189761,
0.1989416927,
-0.3555995226,
-0.624700129,
0.088921681,
-0.1227568164,
0.7787926197,
-0.4117312431,
-0.1991897225,
-0.283291012,
-0.3004052043,
0.4571756124,
-0.1253579259,
0.4543919265,
0.1851518601,
-0.5969778895,
-0.097303547,
-0.4623107314,
-0.1618977189,
0.5014337897,
-0.706589222,
-0.2934411168,
-0.1108295694,
-0.3039609194,
0.3373476267,
-0.00717904,
-0.5121751428,
0.3681317866,
-0.0193327442,
0.2926645577,
0.7922542095,
0.0187174343,
0.586184144,
-0.2519885898,
0.6178443432,
-0.2209523618,
-0.3294882774,
0.1980399042,
-0.6129022837,
-0.7784222364,
-0.4371873438,
0.6443377733,
0.4127094746,
-0.7652273178,
-0.1086505949,
-0.1942521185,
-0.4626261592,
-0.5074308515,
0.4765823781,
0.4497171044,
0.3966068029,
0.2252581865,
-0.2051451951,
-0.3237245679,
-0.8150519133,
-0.3901405036,
-0.2014205009,
-0.0765495002,
0.59356457,
0.4219960272,
-0.0788366273,
0.8024801016,
-0.5198298097,
-0.3324410319,
-0.5264738202,
0.2483038753,
-0.1376181096,
0.2671330273,
0.5366507173,
-0.7965125442,
-0.6711750627,
-0.0064614974,
-0.8120754957,
-0.0156324785,
-0.021276271,
0.2220551223,
0.2811455131,
0.1639158279,
-0.8191612959,
0.2575737238,
0.2700789571,
-0.2561823726,
0.4688521326,
-0.1294199973,
0.0427206643,
-0.4675578773,
-0.0570272692,
0.239968434,
-0.4040142596,
-0.6119740009,
-0.1329630762,
0.171726048,
-0.0384590887,
-0.4292095304,
0.7844651341,
-0.4882155359,
-0.0349369608,
-0.4891985059,
0.2983189225,
-0.37266469,
0.5353522301,
0.4328655601,
0.7144272923,
0.565348506,
-0.5362611413,
0.2622265816,
0.1414140463,
-0.3879655898,
-0.0182704832,
-0.6337415576,
0.3604510427,
0.1668106765,
0.2333265245,
-0.8118613362,
-0.3827581406,
-0.0896876976,
-0.3046225607,
0.3225952089,
-0.0622716099,
-0.6801190972,
-0.1422482878,
-0.0326403603,
0.1995020509,
0.8204650879,
-0.4752589464,
0.3495334089,
0.4129320383,
-0.3614412248,
-0.5120305419,
-0.5261714458,
0.1199776381,
-0.2648824751,
-0.3615475893,
0.0707928836,
0.043767944,
-0.4626960158,
-0.0766544566,
-0.2364878803,
-0.0724624321,
0.5147823095,
0.3135204613,
0.2568824589,
-0.0712538213,
0.1536313593,
-0.5065305829,
-0.1991316378,
0.0941124111,
-0.0465445295,
0.1194566637,
-0.1470624357,
-0.4222925603,
-0.3488816321,
0.0272118207,
0.2145386189,
-0.0269595981,
0.7431194186,
0.5608845353,
-0.6091902256,
-0.4422248602,
-0.548619628,
-0.4347378314,
-0.3931109607,
0.203383863,
-0.3479068279,
-0.8530879021,
0.3849624693,
-0.3116439581,
0.2467103004,
0.5263776779,
0.5948680043,
-0.3525945544,
1.0536805391,
0.6958509088,
0.0557840466,
0.4021485746,
-0.4688699841,
-0.0065798527,
-0.5114668012,
-0.1647742391,
-0.3182841241,
-0.5133185387,
-0.2277240902,
-0.3988488317,
0.124827221,
0.1117775291,
-0.0230465773,
0.1264130473,
-0.2206808478,
0.3291146755,
0.4662881196,
0.1895541549,
0.2550513148,
0.0199801046,
0.1935441196,
-0.0577351786,
-0.9926926494,
-0.7180951238,
1.1208424568,
0.5416128039,
0.7533783317,
0.0727904439,
0.4609128237,
0.6061471105,
0.7227271795,
-0.7199231982,
0.7446079254,
-0.0183607507,
-0.6788348556,
-0.282515794,
-0.4883002937,
-0.7764496207,
0.1179499999,
-0.3259885013,
-0.2559726536,
0.002011426,
0.330052793,
-0.4378660023,
0.4935200214,
-0.7098889947,
0.7452361584,
-0.332947284,
-0.6058565974,
-0.0495153293,
-0.6657978296,
0.1242583469,
-0.3638501763,
0.3934565187,
-0.4508252442,
-0.3965863287,
1.295188427,
-0.2461155951,
1.1563251019,
-0.4595271647,
0.0317073911,
0.473826468,
-0.0329795703,
0.5734454393,
-0.0697278604,
-0.0680473,
0.0054079681,
-0.5664381981,
-0.7697689533,
-0.4958534539,
0.6284129024,
-1.0328601599,
-0.5870651007,
-0.3531790674,
-0.1289524883,
-0.3313927948,
0.0845244676,
0.135400787,
0.3066982925,
0.0668813586,
0.0997530818,
0.9037048817,
0.31484586,
0.3048117161,
0.5249906778,
0.2206809819,
-0.1365003288,
0.7900682688,
0.2958572209,
0.4923613071,
0.0875653774,
0.2090933919,
-0.0798029304,
-0.8784267902,
-0.4141354859,
0.315874517,
-0.8022215366,
-0.3755745888,
-0.6852465272,
0.1151880622,
-0.0614158884,
-0.254951328,
-0.4159335196,
-0.4858851731,
-0.1456603706,
-0.2862324715,
0.3487451375,
0.9366171956,
0.0385110676,
0.2238314003,
-0.5129522085,
0.2127471268,
0.6542584896,
0.0048175743,
-0.0168118216,
-0.5762127042,
-0.6783012152,
-0.1387835294,
-0.0688326359,
-0.5635858774,
0.0731336549,
0.3672778308,
0.6716195345,
0.3774469495,
0.2072347552,
0.432250917,
-0.4408564866,
0.9502288103,
0.0917354971,
-0.4295034707,
0.2845681012,
-0.1949504465,
0.1393661201,
0.4419341683,
0.5283538103,
-0.1383075416,
-0.2991519272,
-0.84668082,
-0.7926617265,
0.5931558013,
0.0481355786,
-0.0199993253,
0.0073854672,
0.650052309,
0.3906213939,
0.1085519493,
-0.73421067,
-0.261215657,
0.1713953614,
-0.0007966478,
-0.0694868863,
-0.1341460198,
-0.0427060425,
0.0839778036,
0.6355663538,
-0.233131811,
0.338709712,
-0.0092536313,
-0.281686604,
-0.4084293544,
0.1246178895,
0.4293173552,
0.6885790229,
-0.2393077314,
0.5069980025,
0.6656986475,
-0.4333092868,
0.1145513728,
-0.0876516774,
0.0001511493,
-0.0977549776,
0.831592083,
0.6619355679,
0.419175297,
-0.8393948674,
0.489256829,
-0.0777232349,
-0.2023780346,
-0.1789338738,
0.2197187394,
0.0213390794,
0.1378882527,
0.6862918139,
0.2915783823,
-0.3544995189,
-0.5703056455,
0.1504147947,
0.3372865021,
-0.4046221972,
-0.6575854421,
0.8288305402,
0.4331475496,
-0.2452257574,
0.3438077867,
-0.1502081007,
-0.6744870543,
0.4816581607,
0.423500061,
0.7220146656,
-0.0104940766,
-0.243079409,
0.0971885994,
0.1019932479,
-0.3172210753,
0.1306089908,
-0.1615178585,
-0.6254364252,
-0.5618500113,
-0.4484508038,
-0.7274468541,
-0.0641840994,
-0.4700858295,
-0.077863358,
-0.5504259467,
-0.3321022093,
0.1200297996,
0.5495935082,
-1.0528095961,
0.5193835497,
0.1604487002,
0.9198842645,
-1.1547058821,
1.0153135061,
1.1438897848,
-0.3009176254,
-0.580416441,
-0.0560001768,
-0.0418889709,
-0.7936370373,
1.0228571892,
-0.0699974373,
-0.1287605017,
-0.1272401214,
-0.6585848927,
-0.4999221563,
1.057559371,
0.2107705921,
-0.466045171,
-0.0386397429,
-0.2373957485,
0.4083470702,
-0.4681216478,
-0.1390932798,
0.5509390831,
0.3807293177,
-0.012649334,
-1.0339092016,
0.064850308,
0.0341524519,
-0.4829330742,
0.0343055166,
-0.7221397758,
0.7931479812,
-0.5747280717,
-0.3389917016,
-0.1109888852,
0.9656128287,
0.2470084727,
0.4112856686,
0.6392589808,
0.2958812714,
0.8194051981,
-0.0883709043,
1.0978360176,
0.0000232362,
0.3017705381,
0.8425455093,
-0.3736639917,
1.0405907631,
0.1518186182,
-0.3520196676,
0.1236116663,
0.9501114488,
0.2032862008,
0.5035383701,
-0.1103914231,
-0.3088288903,
-0.7240459323,
-0.0365254916,
-0.0520037301,
0.2431724966,
0.2355136573,
-0.0181188751,
0.1526731402,
0.0486281104,
0.3696739078,
0.2530419528,
-0.4085923731,
1.0354806185,
0.1943398565,
-0.4567053616,
0.7013074756,
-0.047117386,
0.7657676935,
-0.5305621624,
0.2113713473,
-0.0582300387,
0.2950477898,
-0.2019286156,
-0.5757632852,
-0.035275422,
0.1694751233,
-0.1809251308,
-0.3265767992,
0.920555234,
-0.3266431391,
-0.2567824125,
0.0768533275,
0.7067972422,
0.2338298708,
-0.0590102375,
-0.605787456,
-0.0362230614,
-0.0841196701,
-0.4715849161,
0.568381846,
0.4688518345,
-0.196702674,
0.8136153817,
0.4969716072,
0.3399969935,
0.0127414474,
-0.1912275851,
0.9212223887,
-0.6958028674,
-0.0980403349,
-0.780662775,
0.2091857493,
-0.1208168715,
-0.1243565083,
0.9144355655,
0.4960778952,
0.8264671564,
-0.0919977129,
1.1050742865,
0.1064573228,
0.7362588048,
-0.5169209838,
0.5186074376,
-0.5329450965,
0.2781633437,
0.1821942329,
-0.9266965985,
-0.3419667482,
0.5380184054,
-0.6613119841,
0.3102715611,
0.4894466102,
0.2639582753,
0.038746547,
-0.2237124443,
0.4069415331,
0.0833361372,
0.2270814478,
0.3937191963,
0.9030684233,
-0.0293295234,
0.4152313769,
-0.2251683921,
-0.4219533801,
-0.4545460939,
-0.7734056115,
-1.2078382969,
-0.4536429644,
-0.5148032904,
-0.0979718491,
0.0723585114,
1.056458354,
0.8783943057,
-0.709653914,
0.0284567885,
0.4743692875,
0.0444438905,
-0.4105090201,
-0.1010184214,
0.6131942868,
-0.2409428507,
-0.663343668,
0.4032524526,
0.0282348637,
0.0695034266,
-0.2208385319,
-0.1991491765,
-0.1327988207,
0.1321990043,
0.5210430026,
0.5277225375,
-0.8214076161,
-0.3499073684,
-0.0537405126,
-0.3301316202,
-0.1347428709,
0.8327549696,
-0.9523137808,
0.0720063001,
0.25083372,
0.7421414256,
0.4975989461,
0.1441274434,
0.3088376224,
-0.8337925673,
0.0055058319,
0.2838726938,
0.3670128882,
0.5142689943,
-0.1452634633,
0.800227046,
0.3318737149,
-0.7435113192,
-0.8551098108,
0.030427238,
-0.8930629492,
-0.2434053719,
1.3479744196,
-0.4162289202,
-0.2191712409,
-0.280100584,
-0.147535339,
-0.0223544203,
-0.4024740756,
0.9904020429,
0.3517187536,
-0.4323196709,
-0.0659554973,
-0.9585589767,
0.8488076329,
0.2990062237,
-0.6798568368,
0.4022030234,
0.2097436488,
0.3738931715,
0.0988373905,
0.6218545437,
0.3858423531,
0.284522146,
-0.1376433969,
0.064967975,
-0.3613502979,
-0.4071791172,
-0.0726505592,
0.290500015,
0.6205580235,
-0.1448400021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09821v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09821v1
|
Towards Robust Temporal Reasoning of Large Language Models via a Multi-Hop QA Dataset and Pseudo-Instruction Tuning
| 2023-11-16T11:49:29 | 2023-11-16T11:49:29 |
Qingyu Tan, Hwee Tou Ng, Lidong Bing
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Knowledge in the real world is being updated constantly. However, it is
costly to frequently update large language models (LLMs). Therefore, it is
crucial for LLMs to understand the concept of temporal knowledge. However,
prior works on temporal question answering did not emphasize multi-answer and
multi-hop types of temporal reasoning. In this paper, we propose a complex
temporal question-answering (QA) dataset Complex-TR that focuses on
multi-answer and multi-hop temporal reasoning. Besides, we also propose a novel
data augmentation strategy to improve the complex temporal reasoning capability
and robustness of LLMs. We conducted experiments on multiple temporal QA
datasets. Experimental results show that our method is able to improve LLMs'
performance on temporal QA benchmarks by significant margins.
|
[
-0.2060783207,
-1.0192768574,
0.8462536931,
-0.041641999,
-0.1931081861,
0.5403594375,
-0.154601112,
-0.569725275,
-0.232734412,
0.1398505419,
-0.7401112914,
-0.3289311826,
-0.1522372663,
-0.1113805249,
0.0847717598,
0.5556238294,
0.0885052606,
0.078071408,
0.1086452231,
-0.2728208601,
-0.5509476066,
-0.5610663891,
-0.6524064541,
0.0002019519,
0.4831926823,
0.4536292851,
0.819178164,
0.7785794735,
0.1757022887,
0.2621060908,
-0.0703554228,
0.7990595698,
-0.1413867474,
0.2662002444,
-0.2796042264,
-0.7258104086,
-0.8038652539,
-0.403716296,
0.8044289947,
0.6335558295,
0.0311437789,
0.2441857457,
-0.269623965,
0.3502108753,
-0.649533689,
0.2005516738,
-0.7061211467,
-0.2110885531,
-0.2915164828,
-0.3808306158,
-0.4100109637,
-0.4403893352,
0.0142709231,
-0.6548377275,
-0.1424745917,
0.237041682,
0.7334592938,
0.2578480244,
-0.3945633173,
0.1124798432,
-0.9050422311,
0.8682613373,
-0.9138698578,
0.5449157953,
0.2123007774,
0.5260326862,
-0.2041319758,
-0.5820686817,
-0.7483631372,
-0.0329166502,
0.0824838057,
-0.0359842815,
0.0714550763,
-0.1008333564,
0.473008424,
0.0700268671,
-0.7516576052,
0.1506131142,
0.2040775269,
-0.1099407524,
0.1800064445,
0.3093096912,
0.367700398,
0.2744657099,
-0.0742487311,
-0.2241882831,
-0.6336320639,
0.2360078543,
0.3185296953,
0.2795904875,
-0.0457111746,
0.6129251122,
-0.1997787505,
1.0764611959,
-0.0314174779,
-0.3260630667,
0.2293400913,
-0.4461618364,
-0.0551534481,
-0.1374863833,
0.2965926528,
0.136173889,
0.4712108076,
-0.2430272698,
-0.0524165146,
-0.0370774716,
-0.0587731339,
-0.6040343046,
-0.0538378172,
0.4896315634,
-0.06418778,
0.0337410979,
-0.1027065888,
-0.8080427647,
0.3351200819,
-0.5511237979,
0.4688984156,
-0.4256626368,
-0.11156106,
0.3427323699,
0.1113329753,
0.3323113918,
0.3563147187,
-0.415283978,
-0.0810801461,
0.5564874411,
0.6031639576,
0.2295219898,
-0.2884814441,
-0.8781325817,
0.5815627575,
-0.455560267,
0.9050694704,
-0.8002539277,
0.0908719823,
-0.1118789986,
0.1199416518,
-0.2010079324,
-0.3573460877,
0.4475109875,
-1.0582040548,
0.3052207232,
-0.2412422746,
-0.3749211729,
-0.0070774108,
0.5624415278,
-0.5169055462,
0.8451790214,
0.0613737553,
-0.7787002921,
0.1886307448,
-0.4729424417,
-0.4864372313,
-0.2153119743,
0.0723629668,
-0.6204017997,
-0.3971172571,
0.8043129444,
0.1611656696,
-0.1959552318,
0.5806603432,
-0.6661738753,
-0.4154567122,
0.4830639064,
-0.4612455368,
0.6499707699,
0.3338131607,
-0.10844405,
0.0628369674,
-0.7150803208,
0.3846936524,
0.0143104549,
-0.4011872113,
-0.2134294808,
0.0070448369,
-0.307056129,
0.3972581923,
0.2463672012,
-0.3895131648,
0.5791352391,
-0.3274656236,
0.4937033653,
0.7375720739,
0.0654692426,
0.3084125221,
-0.6726231575,
0.4414803386,
0.2505969107,
0.4764603972,
-0.2936525047,
-0.2133945823,
-0.6078740358,
-0.2973586917,
0.1550678611,
0.723723948,
-1.0738723278,
0.4129568934,
-0.5290106535,
-0.3347874284,
-0.3441360593,
-0.1596486717,
0.2625658512,
0.6511452198,
0.7180010676,
0.355633229,
-0.488362968,
-0.5527002215,
-0.3240367174,
-0.2572476864,
-0.1295900643,
0.3263961077,
0.0705042109,
-0.2688280344,
0.7994990349,
-0.5389491916,
0.2146306187,
-0.1382953823,
0.0005485601,
0.2772624791,
0.4260333478,
0.5421634316,
-0.6111994982,
-0.0307812076,
-0.3100143671,
-0.4599393606,
-0.1383728534,
-0.4607704282,
-0.2772423029,
-0.2653152347,
0.4632350206,
-0.5701911449,
-0.0669207126,
0.3087670505,
-0.2801027298,
0.7129363418,
-0.0527788438,
0.360574007,
-1.1144933701,
-0.1387811452,
-0.2341526151,
-0.349789232,
-0.4441080093,
0.0105908299,
0.0828135535,
-0.0341585353,
-0.3255672753,
0.6237715483,
-0.3947076201,
0.0314435847,
-0.0594926402,
0.026071446,
0.1956125349,
0.6077700853,
0.0876376107,
0.850423038,
0.7121185064,
-0.6312747002,
0.3366191089,
0.1492267698,
-0.2422553003,
0.2736873031,
-0.6575391889,
0.2942562401,
-0.2398360819,
0.2851969898,
-0.798107028,
-0.0865192488,
0.0382111035,
-0.3104149997,
0.4532268047,
-0.4421117902,
-0.7700254321,
-0.1954662353,
-0.2324924618,
0.5171278715,
0.1034913287,
-0.6508340836,
0.8687406778,
0.0955455154,
-0.0824738815,
-0.4768142998,
-0.6297842264,
0.0801187158,
-0.2412689179,
-0.7264264822,
0.2439954132,
-0.198740676,
-0.3393858075,
0.0345256366,
-0.1850759089,
-0.0985500142,
-0.0035408684,
-0.3697777987,
0.4137631357,
-0.3953199089,
0.3195862174,
0.304749012,
-0.0882497057,
-0.2106811553,
-0.4635902345,
0.6209897995,
-0.1540037841,
-0.5202976465,
-0.3803026676,
0.2217350602,
0.8109247088,
-0.4467077851,
0.7762470841,
0.6663069129,
-0.3032552302,
-0.343723774,
-0.5530415773,
-0.4434191287,
-0.4389875531,
0.2507370114,
-0.535597384,
-1.017341733,
0.400587976,
-0.3743065596,
0.1851920933,
0.1980242431,
0.5576573014,
-0.3521602154,
1.0416247845,
0.043917343,
-0.0132159991,
0.4979973137,
-0.1617770195,
0.3012932837,
-0.7282615304,
-0.2560244799,
-0.6112777591,
-0.2450944781,
-0.3892301619,
-0.4500539601,
0.5815641284,
0.1540605426,
-0.5559958816,
-0.0401413701,
-0.1210190579,
0.187082544,
0.5403390527,
0.2273757309,
0.3224643469,
-0.2370764017,
-0.1021601334,
0.1654714197,
-0.8924132586,
-0.4840251505,
0.8694630265,
0.2269825488,
0.8551048636,
0.3497503996,
-0.1499588192,
0.1217588186,
-0.3212405443,
-0.3740390241,
0.3120130897,
0.0264439192,
-0.5269960761,
-0.3087527454,
-0.6139884591,
-0.6372050047,
0.0671531633,
-0.3291209638,
-0.5175721645,
0.2587260604,
0.2551492155,
-0.4767006636,
0.4856533706,
-0.8627929091,
0.6976115108,
-0.4633253217,
-0.3037347198,
0.0009965781,
-0.8553094268,
0.295627296,
-0.0126965446,
0.3272885084,
0.0268327501,
0.0351691954,
0.4420403242,
-0.5209758878,
0.6911527514,
-0.0931340903,
0.1135484651,
0.3509482145,
0.1669834852,
0.8333699107,
0.3851225674,
0.0432725661,
-0.1186966673,
0.3728826344,
-0.6552004218,
-0.8252030015,
0.6151581407,
-0.7670755982,
-0.4493864179,
-0.3987153172,
-0.8016054034,
-0.9371160865,
-0.0599746741,
-0.1648212522,
0.8181805611,
0.4786854088,
0.0982471779,
0.9112179875,
-0.3147103786,
0.4138952792,
0.5989393592,
0.0593239143,
-0.2510206699,
0.5081348419,
-0.0218520425,
0.4680161774,
0.7888076305,
0.3833250999,
-0.6857074499,
-0.5468603373,
-0.6559962034,
0.2446444333,
-0.4246444702,
-0.1774479598,
-0.7784589529,
-0.1364626437,
-0.4827335179,
0.123860307,
-0.190250352,
-0.480175972,
-0.0985230654,
-0.0844818652,
0.5705057383,
-0.0642778575,
0.0286007058,
0.3541606069,
-1.1218236685,
0.6222187281,
0.6986860037,
0.3260782361,
0.1792619377,
-0.6508234739,
-0.0915142596,
0.1992912292,
0.1127865165,
-0.6315382123,
-0.0239903908,
0.2796272337,
0.5801072121,
0.2586680949,
0.1647626758,
0.9220904112,
-0.3995699286,
0.6949520111,
-0.2673262656,
-0.7730158567,
0.6225107908,
-0.4601926208,
0.6638510227,
0.2598114312,
0.1704464853,
-0.2928343415,
-0.4914342463,
-0.4554949403,
-0.7591620088,
0.5557965636,
0.04076441,
-0.136596635,
0.1785574853,
0.4833126366,
-0.1683087498,
0.0704186782,
-0.5117481351,
-0.1861931235,
-0.2369603962,
-0.2183163613,
0.2441369742,
-0.2407952249,
0.0212908629,
-0.1607498676,
0.6366413236,
-0.2665314078,
-0.063524887,
0.0420934968,
-0.1333871484,
-0.0803865194,
0.6342743635,
0.5091599226,
1.0129810572,
-0.2381278425,
0.3326840699,
0.2792694271,
-0.4178854823,
0.2594097555,
-0.0420420505,
-0.1185847893,
-0.2639820874,
0.751478076,
0.5531473756,
-0.1276788563,
-0.8306722045,
0.2697627842,
-0.1313603073,
0.2878035903,
0.0028251242,
0.0777420849,
0.1504469365,
0.4809761345,
0.4260912538,
0.0426511206,
-0.2272030264,
-0.6568998694,
0.2828515172,
0.1238305792,
-0.0884821117,
-0.3233292997,
0.6569342613,
-0.2399969995,
0.0398724675,
0.6063212156,
-0.1251755208,
-0.565580368,
0.4608374238,
0.5501323342,
0.3523383141,
-0.2488096505,
-0.0567362383,
0.4570881724,
0.4302794039,
-0.0099103292,
0.621219933,
0.1203078404,
-0.7361502647,
-0.9893122911,
-0.3863769472,
-0.2523722649,
0.2695264816,
-0.3452676833,
0.0976513252,
-0.3638265729,
-0.0703402832,
-0.3198342919,
-0.0120371692,
-0.5495648384,
0.4468068779,
-0.2594921589,
0.6976956725,
-0.7847934961,
0.9831908941,
0.5290525556,
-0.2894980013,
-1.05582726,
0.1620221138,
-0.2553738952,
-0.660310626,
0.4209286571,
-0.3632141054,
-0.3304791152,
-0.0460416377,
-0.4949735403,
-0.8448691368,
0.8683933616,
0.4748579562,
-1.0042977333,
-0.1765916497,
0.0238841586,
0.477522701,
-0.0144741777,
0.2141937166,
0.4599911571,
0.6799248457,
0.2388965786,
-0.6234616637,
-0.1230145916,
-0.0843521655,
-0.2993363738,
0.1456111819,
-0.5846200585,
0.6681329012,
-0.4487858713,
-0.1265326738,
-0.259542942,
0.5830746889,
0.5494222045,
0.3013229668,
0.7013300657,
0.7283535004,
0.6926404238,
-0.2377856821,
0.8742185235,
-0.1923459321,
0.0034546212,
1.4543230534,
-0.1275857091,
0.4689756036,
0.2547769547,
-0.2385439724,
0.3970538676,
0.8105623126,
0.1741130352,
0.4715535045,
0.0287335925,
-0.1746109426,
-0.8683648109,
-0.1178342253,
-0.4111765921,
0.4084375799,
0.3524751067,
0.2927702069,
-0.2171485275,
-0.1119677871,
0.1113677099,
-0.0099206278,
-0.2768466175,
0.7080559731,
-0.0508286357,
-0.5170261264,
0.3083468676,
0.0056882771,
0.2714702189,
-0.5892779827,
-0.1455626488,
-0.1808700114,
0.002217344,
-0.0194966905,
-0.8123351932,
0.3152115047,
0.0101600746,
-0.1723769009,
0.1451376379,
0.4056375027,
-0.5654631853,
-0.429907918,
0.0736769065,
0.8950075507,
-0.2659418583,
0.0358980149,
-0.6475769281,
-0.0400939919,
-0.2668294907,
-0.0654016361,
0.1240239888,
0.8162001967,
-0.3481900096,
0.9520300031,
0.9604692459,
0.2561804056,
0.2674177885,
0.570505619,
0.9474902153,
-0.5613526106,
-0.5863179564,
-0.7212697268,
0.2734677196,
0.0925631747,
-0.0915890858,
0.5290463567,
0.528821528,
0.6910217404,
0.0886647999,
0.5861799717,
0.1094741374,
0.9408379197,
-0.8774207234,
0.2689436972,
-0.5146516562,
0.4681749642,
-0.1377222985,
-0.8859804869,
-0.3889503181,
0.178437382,
-0.3154531419,
0.1355405897,
0.5218445659,
0.8223505616,
-0.1869063377,
-0.1497868001,
0.1595342755,
0.355581224,
0.658855021,
0.8011025786,
1.1108397245,
-0.1742201298,
0.6406762004,
-0.0899612904,
-0.1370768845,
0.0989202484,
-0.9335878491,
-0.8610569239,
-0.4913896918,
-0.2503201365,
-0.2042831779,
0.1394068152,
0.8140243888,
0.6759238243,
-0.84371382,
0.2954927385,
0.3605213761,
0.19231686,
-0.5452435613,
-0.2382960916,
0.7931182981,
-0.4249051511,
-0.6593405008,
0.6042696834,
0.3097715676,
0.0081673404,
-0.0593549907,
0.2209667861,
-0.4917045236,
0.0552974828,
0.6400563121,
0.1704113185,
-0.3400324881,
-0.4998710752,
0.3221928775,
0.1526938677,
0.1326932609,
0.8683301806,
-0.6277627349,
0.5498261452,
0.5042634606,
0.7739214897,
0.4970479906,
0.1292004734,
0.3915521801,
-0.6995012164,
0.0498233549,
0.4597524703,
0.4256895185,
0.2131719738,
-0.3425492048,
0.1428636312,
0.2121205479,
-0.5650740862,
-0.6084416509,
0.2700349092,
-1.1867713928,
-0.5745300651,
1.0134085417,
-0.09703587,
-0.1945030689,
-0.609616816,
0.0348293073,
0.4094116092,
-0.3150293529,
0.8191409111,
0.4508680105,
-0.0740164518,
-0.2220249772,
-0.3495484591,
0.2144623995,
0.0727936924,
-1.1464768648,
0.0086051645,
0.6228917837,
0.3209550381,
-0.0920256972,
0.3133016825,
-0.3307455778,
0.341111958,
-0.2918644845,
-0.4444117248,
-0.426238358,
-0.6440194845,
0.0705713779,
0.1640204489,
0.2026613653,
-0.3299011588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09818v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09818v2
|
SUQL: Conversational Search over Structured and Unstructured Data with Large Language Models
| 2023-11-16T11:48:17 | 2024-03-13T17:07:02 |
Shicheng Liu, Jialiang Xu, Wesley Tjangnaka, Sina J. Semnani, Chen Jie Yu, Monica S. Lam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.PL
|
While most conversational agents are grounded on either free-text or
structured knowledge, many knowledge corpora consist of hybrid sources. This
paper presents the first conversational agent that supports the full generality
of hybrid data access for large knowledge corpora, through a language we
developed called SUQL (Structured and Unstructured Query Language).
Specifically, SUQL extends SQL with free-text primitives (summary and answer),
so information retrieval can be composed with structured data accesses
arbitrarily in a formal, succinct, precise, and interpretable notation. With
SUQL, we propose the first semantic parser, an LLM with in-context learning,
that can handle hybrid data sources.
Our in-context learning-based approach, when applied to the HybridQA dataset,
comes within 8.9% exact match and 7.1% F1 of the SOTA, which was trained on 62K
data samples. More significantly, unlike previous approaches, our technique is
applicable to large databases and free-text corpora. We introduce a dataset
consisting of crowdsourced questions and conversations on Yelp, a large, real
restaurant knowledge base with structured and unstructured data. We show that
our few-shot conversational agent based on SUQL finds an entity satisfying all
user requirements 90.3% of the time, compared to 63.4% for a baseline based on
linearization.
|
[
0.0306599233,
-0.95353055,
0.8172600269,
-0.1634077877,
-0.208532691,
0.4317029417,
-0.1201493517,
-0.1974143088,
0.3141483665,
0.6233729124,
-0.4630095065,
-0.6986686587,
0.1291790009,
-0.0040206555,
-0.4313970804,
0.9120599031,
0.4998246431,
0.1265583038,
-0.4291425645,
-0.1561395824,
-0.0751642808,
-0.7934513688,
-0.1766070873,
-0.2905505598,
0.1959064007,
0.4710243046,
1.1155908108,
0.2874771655,
0.0678675249,
0.3036028743,
-0.1128603667,
0.4426399171,
-0.6491395831,
0.1774030775,
-0.4504477978,
-0.5233676434,
0.0800176933,
-0.3031965196,
0.5728111863,
0.9335998297,
-0.3471158743,
-0.267618686,
-0.1050183475,
0.7491109371,
-0.2716227472,
0.235911116,
-0.8406829238,
-0.1553025544,
-0.2030778676,
-0.4254600406,
-0.1795132309,
-0.2847731709,
0.0812868327,
-0.8518381119,
-0.0171175767,
0.1734816879,
0.5065743327,
0.1369497031,
-0.6707772613,
-0.4114866853,
-0.5778923631,
0.7878690958,
-0.5993717909,
0.5579065681,
0.3568018377,
0.3385805786,
-0.6596021652,
-0.9596137404,
-0.8353922963,
-0.3731185198,
-0.2704217136,
0.0634301454,
-0.1001238823,
0.0728027597,
0.0085306102,
0.4543495178,
-0.6264247298,
-0.0916606411,
-0.3975047767,
-0.0244614985,
0.7071410418,
0.298545897,
0.3760285974,
-0.2463615388,
-0.5511744618,
0.2646144331,
-0.6238917708,
0.1139035448,
0.023503568,
0.4049346149,
0.1791419834,
0.6413854957,
-0.5429189801,
0.7830559611,
-0.3668414056,
0.1053824723,
-0.0365802795,
-0.6336721778,
-0.1761864424,
-0.0249274205,
1.0185638666,
0.3690673709,
0.1716908813,
-0.2991833985,
-0.2285289764,
0.1079698652,
0.092515789,
-0.1832053959,
-0.1803944558,
0.2499305755,
-0.1296668202,
-0.0487425812,
0.002067053,
-0.4962349534,
-0.4863261282,
-0.2299615741,
0.1037635207,
-0.456677258,
0.0291352402,
-0.0049675619,
0.1437299252,
0.3295317888,
0.2852467299,
-0.7494254112,
0.5869464278,
0.5820209384,
0.6594296098,
-0.1425389498,
0.0067314142,
-0.5942611694,
0.1340203583,
-0.4251330793,
0.7847972512,
-0.7138333321,
-0.5332392454,
0.1078987494,
-0.1769580841,
-0.0559508204,
-0.6319245696,
0.5505231023,
-1.0240932703,
0.3285226524,
-0.1406608522,
-0.8899223804,
-0.0567498729,
0.2218211442,
-0.3703959584,
1.3054918051,
0.3222074211,
-0.6084416509,
0.137856245,
-0.710267663,
-0.4706206024,
0.6029464602,
-0.5367487669,
0.2423295826,
-0.1908818781,
0.1064188927,
0.4071191251,
-0.4901943505,
0.4568125308,
-0.0508189015,
-0.359169215,
0.3687123358,
0.2861454189,
0.6529743671,
0.210019514,
0.0139432671,
0.1594973207,
-0.6762337089,
0.2444769144,
0.1875914484,
-0.5258560181,
-0.7045152783,
0.0911572203,
0.1625767499,
0.1305078417,
0.3920709491,
-0.6415678859,
0.1187820584,
-0.5882644057,
0.6278399825,
0.5080041885,
-0.1248303875,
0.5334227681,
-0.029158745,
0.3065574169,
-0.0972540155,
-0.0637594759,
-0.2121871561,
-0.2652753294,
-0.6270117164,
-0.0234065503,
0.2066749483,
0.6063821316,
-0.9698044658,
0.6150864363,
-0.237914592,
-0.3246697783,
-0.5134846568,
0.3434360623,
0.3241533339,
0.6493293047,
0.4561211169,
-0.103628628,
-0.5598956347,
-1.0179470778,
-0.2526882887,
-0.2182586789,
-0.2466706187,
0.5834783316,
0.171461612,
-0.2457629144,
1.1698657274,
-0.4429853261,
-0.4937460423,
-0.6222571731,
-0.0940368623,
0.2787681222,
0.2174660563,
0.0559096448,
-1.002182126,
-0.5717747808,
0.21397385,
-0.8318587542,
-0.0450314693,
0.0923961774,
-0.084802784,
0.1960839033,
0.7074266076,
-0.6386628747,
0.2061357945,
0.3346978724,
-0.2306503356,
0.0547733866,
-0.1902240962,
-0.1484295726,
-1.2087517977,
-0.0843317062,
-0.1219737828,
-0.5479364395,
-0.7106100321,
0.0301811527,
0.0665089116,
-0.1649320722,
-0.4609151185,
0.3364513218,
-0.1570010632,
-0.4033192694,
-0.0682598278,
0.3288691938,
-0.0405825414,
0.4983274639,
0.3322609961,
0.9806503654,
0.3461151421,
-0.7479601502,
0.5602495074,
0.3587348759,
-0.3701583445,
0.549824357,
-0.7792848945,
0.4581357241,
-0.15614371,
0.4226904511,
-0.9503699541,
-0.1155165657,
-0.1397873312,
-0.2559909523,
-0.3298563063,
-0.0569136143,
-0.6519342661,
-0.0233660601,
-0.0277792029,
0.1688962579,
0.1424287558,
-0.4970022738,
0.6490504146,
0.6301956177,
0.0085874954,
-0.1745843291,
-0.4329490662,
0.0522865579,
0.0675628856,
-0.7967081666,
0.327023983,
-0.1807668209,
-0.3207840621,
-0.0028244935,
-0.0532894917,
-0.2665753663,
-0.0407711528,
-0.0186226014,
0.4552932084,
-0.1490512788,
0.1269419938,
-0.2706994116,
-0.1508524418,
-0.2938020825,
-0.4131254256,
0.7611508369,
-0.5133723021,
-0.0874461457,
-0.3830162287,
0.3957400918,
0.4202508032,
-0.0603923239,
0.7197639942,
-0.0410719514,
-0.1917440444,
-0.1519100666,
-0.4345375896,
-0.0347628258,
-0.4764700532,
0.2128596902,
-0.1958902031,
-1.0597833395,
0.4374247491,
-0.0122714089,
-0.0905633196,
0.2963368595,
0.4287999272,
-0.3361044526,
0.7152023911,
0.4928185642,
-0.1096565053,
0.3717640936,
-0.1155694202,
0.1296869218,
-0.3408535719,
-0.5279886127,
-0.2930707335,
-0.0657200366,
-0.5272437334,
-0.3968227208,
0.7375031114,
-0.173434183,
-0.0109778438,
0.2765870392,
-0.1195517257,
0.8182875514,
0.8579627275,
-0.0668905601,
0.6925343275,
-0.3638708293,
-0.1204947904,
-0.0566757359,
-0.481808275,
-0.4054742455,
0.7206200361,
-0.0517687537,
0.900603354,
0.1502560675,
0.4760815799,
0.595408082,
-0.2854135036,
-0.8247421384,
0.6624685526,
0.0081018545,
-0.6089497209,
-0.4754165709,
-0.6389576197,
-0.9712473154,
0.3717330992,
-0.2178674191,
-0.585916698,
-0.012643897,
-0.042383451,
-0.3627215922,
0.021785384,
-0.7481788397,
0.8417370319,
-0.3712388873,
-0.2377136797,
-0.0655033365,
-0.8908648491,
0.2926754951,
-0.0344227962,
0.2722336054,
0.0299134571,
-0.0164696593,
0.5043686628,
-0.5987950563,
0.6090486646,
-0.1205770001,
0.2151977718,
0.2845260799,
0.2831483185,
0.5809797049,
0.1034594327,
0.1170401648,
0.1293643564,
0.4095069766,
-0.4431445599,
-0.9353141189,
0.5404629707,
-0.6843146682,
-0.3065697849,
-0.3094895482,
-0.5539749265,
-0.5098767877,
0.2725563943,
0.1715866923,
0.1066723168,
-0.2956953645,
0.6014998555,
0.6447712779,
-0.0860128254,
-0.0000770399,
1.0135282278,
-0.1719914824,
0.0470765866,
0.6976780295,
0.0683755055,
0.127501294,
0.6377466917,
0.3229211569,
-0.7201001048,
-0.180171445,
-0.4311906099,
0.0465688482,
-0.3521873355,
-0.3511252999,
-0.7539569736,
-0.2730349302,
-0.4091912806,
-0.1932250708,
-0.574926734,
-0.3546536267,
-0.2645357847,
-0.1509196609,
0.1654037833,
0.6188999414,
0.3010706902,
0.2099340558,
-0.693808794,
0.3008480966,
0.3679822683,
0.085248515,
-0.4049668312,
-0.302577734,
-0.0462369882,
-0.020362122,
0.0801509097,
-0.8742738366,
0.484170258,
0.3448250294,
0.5842680931,
0.2756647468,
0.5048882365,
0.3696141839,
-0.1608269811,
0.7852146626,
0.0605769493,
-0.7853870392,
0.6605936289,
-0.4196247458,
0.0001047712,
0.740413785,
0.4564048946,
-0.9739224911,
-0.2380805612,
-0.6167728901,
-0.8647769094,
0.6836180091,
0.1544879526,
0.2542732954,
-0.0741393194,
0.0842363164,
0.1219704524,
0.2639400959,
-0.6229671836,
-0.1251833439,
-0.1353374869,
-0.1805310994,
0.0032211631,
-0.3776368201,
-0.151995033,
-0.1846978217,
0.471421212,
-0.3510263264,
-0.122178182,
0.2374009937,
-0.2420939654,
0.0009643794,
0.6331005096,
0.1316090971,
0.6269203424,
-0.1805928648,
0.225775525,
0.0928138942,
-0.0063050385,
-0.1861825883,
0.1467248052,
-0.3952772021,
-0.1329502165,
-0.045300439,
0.4038519263,
0.4847243428,
-1.23029387,
0.6338178515,
-0.0241450444,
-0.0328209139,
-0.4801464975,
0.0839958861,
0.0569779128,
0.4190028012,
0.5421221852,
-0.6571879387,
0.3557697535,
-0.7944769859,
0.3563089073,
0.5542519093,
-0.2714784741,
-0.2215658575,
0.5085219741,
0.1240010038,
-0.1260084361,
0.7452399731,
-0.1812871397,
-0.4749354124,
0.0853214636,
0.7116186023,
0.2812975347,
-0.0920397639,
0.491446346,
-0.0773172677,
0.0397612154,
0.1417824328,
0.430236578,
-0.224255532,
-0.9629651308,
-0.0262936782,
-0.6376870275,
-0.6114146709,
0.2400266379,
-0.4451823235,
-0.0683626011,
-0.7028085589,
0.2881163061,
0.0379462913,
0.2185641974,
-0.4335682392,
0.0362511463,
-0.075698331,
0.8872762918,
-0.6546325088,
0.8269862533,
0.9401105642,
-0.4733218849,
-0.7698107362,
-0.4194799662,
-0.0018383154,
-1.0657941103,
0.4111361206,
-0.3009969592,
-0.1150390059,
0.0265882928,
-0.7994258404,
-0.7395139337,
0.9300995469,
0.380299449,
-0.2300311029,
-0.0011432248,
0.2925431728,
0.7143287659,
-0.4513992369,
0.0885536149,
0.7666304708,
0.0198421814,
0.4642215371,
-0.8622829318,
-0.0720563829,
-0.2573735416,
0.0791874751,
0.0051751304,
-0.7815278172,
0.7181984186,
0.0414611548,
-0.3199581504,
-0.1104863882,
0.9386724234,
0.0502779782,
0.5449302197,
0.4989393055,
0.3217651546,
1.0681350231,
0.1544915289,
0.9803703427,
-0.174011454,
0.167593047,
1.1676683426,
-0.5021011829,
0.8764544129,
0.3170771003,
-0.2918683589,
0.6389787793,
0.5214573145,
0.3309125602,
0.5733548999,
-0.0518895984,
-0.3776770234,
-0.4313346744,
-0.7159238458,
-0.2198174745,
0.5466576219,
0.4848845601,
-0.2501200736,
-0.3766341805,
-0.4329052866,
-0.1927529126,
0.6190045476,
-0.1420128793,
0.9632800817,
-0.0064992951,
-0.3452709317,
0.3413003981,
0.1136991978,
0.413120389,
-0.7083486319,
0.1251923442,
-0.6394600272,
-0.2193186432,
-0.3628058136,
-0.8564732075,
0.1739170402,
-0.1765081584,
0.1279951036,
-0.0094085196,
0.8579158187,
-0.5724688768,
-0.1610221714,
0.2335810512,
0.6564731598,
0.3422520757,
-0.2305901796,
-0.5148530602,
-0.3110111058,
-0.174090609,
-0.0794415101,
0.3952488601,
0.4191549122,
-0.2241700143,
0.5984811783,
0.9713385701,
-0.2804956436,
0.130160287,
0.1068775877,
1.3241035938,
-0.8483763337,
-0.9367094636,
-0.4384872019,
0.2052576542,
-0.0562673137,
-0.0269376691,
0.5836345553,
0.9212896824,
0.9059796333,
0.2943719327,
0.7802752256,
0.0598134845,
0.7939296365,
-0.6875836253,
0.3540389836,
-0.6325885653,
0.2404294014,
-0.0442278869,
-0.8775949478,
-0.114666976,
0.7115454674,
-0.362226069,
-0.1245248467,
0.427189678,
1.0295711756,
-0.0710588098,
0.322155565,
0.6750821471,
0.1303340197,
0.0947334096,
0.5962657332,
1.2458029985,
-0.0281808991,
0.6430482268,
0.0363002419,
-0.2182221711,
-0.2816484571,
-0.2949208915,
-0.7258675694,
-0.6735451221,
0.1709667891,
-0.4410780072,
0.0614211261,
1.1658039093,
0.5394780636,
-0.7127864957,
-0.256634593,
-0.1102818176,
0.1909472495,
0.1736721992,
-0.2626374662,
0.2101169527,
-0.3566871583,
-0.5911584496,
1.0660406351,
0.3516395986,
-0.2590830028,
-0.1468852013,
-0.1613762677,
-0.3269381821,
0.0427483208,
0.4733057618,
0.6821218133,
-0.4969897568,
-0.0181340463,
0.1433052421,
-0.3575919271,
0.1349653453,
1.0706118345,
-0.9160962701,
0.4868286848,
0.2388163358,
0.7227218747,
0.5068321824,
0.2475512624,
0.4114256501,
-0.9271935821,
0.0620506145,
0.3846623898,
0.1398450732,
0.3934479654,
-0.6413514614,
0.6106730103,
0.3485898674,
-0.4757681489,
-0.4086747766,
0.3160355091,
-1.1401203871,
-0.1475882828,
1.25063169,
0.1527225524,
-0.3186764419,
-0.6066828966,
-0.1809928864,
-0.00753495,
-0.7175515294,
0.5621811152,
0.2041832358,
-0.3355076313,
-0.0603729822,
-0.4910626709,
0.4158650041,
0.3891689181,
-0.649594903,
0.0939797089,
0.8477928638,
0.1173291728,
0.0228427052,
1.247433424,
-0.0097958772,
0.1037220135,
-0.2161580473,
-0.2571021616,
-0.0411178656,
-0.1506450623,
0.0266069863,
0.2029631138,
-0.1136852801,
-0.0862919018
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10537v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10537v4
|
MedAgents: Large Language Models as Collaborators for Zero-shot Medical Reasoning
| 2023-11-16T11:47:58 | 2024-06-04T23:47:43 |
Xiangru Tang, Anni Zou, Zhuosheng Zhang, Ziming Li, Yilun Zhao, Xingyao Zhang, Arman Cohan, Mark Gerstein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs), despite their remarkable progress across
various general domains, encounter significant barriers in medicine and
healthcare. This field faces unique challenges such as domain-specific
terminologies and reasoning over specialized knowledge. To address these
issues, we propose MedAgents, a novel multi-disciplinary collaboration
framework for the medical domain. MedAgents leverages LLM-based agents in a
role-playing setting that participate in a collaborative multi-round
discussion, thereby enhancing LLM proficiency and reasoning capabilities. This
training-free framework encompasses five critical steps: gathering domain
experts, proposing individual analyses, summarising these analyses into a
report, iterating over discussions until a consensus is reached, and ultimately
making a decision. Our work focuses on the zero-shot setting, which is
applicable in real-world scenarios. Experimental results on nine datasets
(MedQA, MedMCQA, PubMedQA, and six subtasks from MMLU) establish that our
proposed MedAgents framework excels at mining and harnessing the medical
expertise within LLMs, as well as extending its reasoning abilities. Our code
can be found at https://github.com/gersteinlab/MedAgents.
|
[
-0.2262262106,
-0.5697057247,
1.2115335464,
-0.0948959813,
0.1167805642,
0.2608784437,
-0.1714491397,
-0.5443206429,
0.2970276177,
0.7394759059,
-0.5836744905,
-0.6426075101,
-0.4568324387,
0.1633253396,
0.1217507794,
1.0263519287,
-0.1417129189,
0.3152513802,
-0.4301481247,
-0.3845298588,
-0.4496161342,
-0.6025304794,
-0.5867572427,
-0.8046243787,
0.9285923243,
0.4898014963,
0.5529580712,
0.4998198152,
0.3999508321,
0.3488750458,
0.4200832248,
0.2268729508,
-0.1948667467,
0.5667450428,
-0.4963296354,
-0.5413295627,
-0.6982411742,
0.0993706882,
0.0711226836,
0.8632457852,
-0.177055046,
-0.1126132607,
-0.6580806375,
0.311110884,
-0.4926864505,
0.21822083,
-0.628046453,
0.1945797056,
-0.0426652096,
-0.3699331582,
-0.5120746493,
0.1045260951,
0.2036568522,
-0.6194358468,
0.2282126546,
-0.1928938627,
0.5106961727,
0.384275198,
-0.4007410705,
0.0483800173,
-0.5600842237,
0.7367255092,
-0.6573460102,
-0.0259142686,
0.4008573294,
0.4549591541,
-0.3178085685,
-0.5750010014,
-0.3309161961,
-0.2803974152,
0.1223322377,
0.1639095992,
-0.0844789296,
0.2341235131,
-0.0099448385,
0.1622872353,
-0.5801585317,
0.2403008342,
-0.2409254313,
-0.1366047114,
0.5814669132,
0.2564678192,
0.3032663167,
0.330268681,
-0.1609674096,
0.5806806684,
-0.5464334488,
-0.4513666332,
-0.433683455,
0.1960921437,
-0.2994244099,
0.6401591897,
-0.1489867717,
0.6277186275,
-0.129115209,
-0.2395947427,
0.3013421893,
-0.0531361289,
-0.4352829456,
-0.1059935391,
0.7220036387,
0.2529457808,
0.2767013609,
-0.4262533188,
0.0172687862,
0.3501051962,
0.1979471892,
-0.7453916669,
-0.3554457128,
0.5370470881,
-0.1913191378,
-0.4778286219,
-0.4789763987,
-0.3861980736,
-0.6740276217,
-0.3993739784,
0.3932132721,
-0.4101530313,
-0.2463605255,
0.3347841501,
-0.0108381314,
0.0625329912,
0.6090273857,
-0.4166978598,
0.2629784346,
0.7019565105,
0.7974888086,
0.0472443625,
-0.4370137751,
-0.7086907625,
0.3476939499,
-0.3222387135,
1.0977925062,
-0.4976389706,
-0.3809922934,
-0.1760084927,
-0.0046056169,
-0.1385053694,
-0.4519466758,
0.2551519573,
-0.223195821,
0.1327280849,
-0.0566512085,
-0.6563246846,
0.1613392085,
0.5826720595,
-0.4493308663,
0.4127298892,
0.0729009286,
-0.4411168694,
0.2708376944,
-0.8520820737,
-0.4113144279,
0.5610391498,
-0.7634608746,
-0.1890946329,
-0.0369246937,
0.1049035415,
0.611125052,
-0.602799356,
0.3509382606,
-0.3528739214,
-0.1899407953,
0.5015138388,
-0.1452278495,
0.5629675388,
-0.0269082468,
-0.1250688583,
0.3771661222,
-0.6706712842,
0.0585563183,
0.1158557311,
-0.0784472451,
-0.2872035801,
0.007621679,
-0.1259061396,
0.5400241017,
-0.1661310792,
-0.6056281328,
0.3992837071,
-0.4221043289,
0.5534722209,
0.5747975707,
0.1278111488,
0.4563991427,
-0.6184562445,
0.5752928257,
-0.0556545518,
0.2494351119,
-0.2838949859,
-0.5862315893,
-0.4468061924,
-0.6264714003,
0.0921743438,
0.4391973913,
-1.1671928167,
0.1558256,
-0.0874168202,
-0.5860854983,
-0.531413734,
-0.2314305305,
0.3268667161,
0.5365145206,
0.4460597932,
-0.113634713,
-0.2629319429,
-0.7846012115,
0.0310904682,
-0.1056151018,
-0.1087067276,
0.3437209129,
0.6187438965,
-0.4582012296,
0.8472784758,
-0.5140392184,
-0.4680075049,
-0.2746608555,
0.0250257924,
0.088326849,
0.3947212398,
0.61367172,
-0.5031456947,
-0.4515216947,
0.1701711714,
-0.9829310179,
-0.2848647833,
-0.0097208796,
-0.2081252635,
0.0680129752,
0.5356327891,
-0.7806177735,
0.1808592677,
0.5917472839,
-0.4590339363,
0.6662682295,
-0.2822499573,
0.1424015164,
-1.2372044325,
0.2373774648,
0.0031771732,
-0.2713316679,
-0.93164289,
0.1556853503,
-0.4050932825,
-0.1926820725,
-0.3555118442,
0.7417706251,
-0.2785386741,
0.3530391753,
-0.2134254277,
0.1098326668,
0.1034181193,
0.3046405911,
-0.0048164809,
0.681845665,
0.6900910139,
-0.2106612325,
0.3901431561,
0.2465585172,
0.1586997062,
1.1290739775,
-0.6572435498,
0.1058734581,
0.0030850933,
0.272618413,
-0.4549247026,
-0.4772679508,
0.2083690315,
-0.5286114812,
0.1097570434,
-0.328845948,
-0.5292533636,
-0.3193114996,
-0.1639418155,
0.3723632693,
0.0109205097,
0.0386945456,
0.6446035504,
0.6029610634,
-0.2275469601,
-0.4929356277,
-0.7089252472,
0.3334819674,
0.2239927799,
-0.4627563059,
0.186059162,
-0.3325541317,
-0.3853849769,
0.1447329521,
0.0540051945,
-0.428465426,
-0.1109892055,
0.3939229846,
0.3676773906,
-0.0962673277,
0.3771369755,
-0.0688605905,
-0.3305106759,
0.0630267039,
-0.3191703856,
0.328379631,
-0.0125530669,
-0.6264284253,
-0.0369097628,
0.6364718676,
0.9396190047,
-0.4880714118,
0.7908770442,
0.2727992833,
-0.3806314766,
-0.3125474751,
-0.7573616505,
-0.126340121,
-0.3938840628,
0.3855563402,
-0.263491869,
-1.2143261433,
0.5584381223,
-0.2185607553,
0.1556082517,
0.1516138464,
0.9524476528,
0.2139938623,
0.9320685863,
0.6184293032,
0.0808109045,
-0.2455459535,
-0.0286574252,
0.0939847007,
-0.5054638386,
-0.456351459,
-0.3572421074,
-0.0203487668,
-0.2337724268,
-1.0448141098,
0.7155631185,
-0.5714632869,
-0.3249366581,
-0.1986232847,
-0.4355014861,
0.5616231561,
0.1193690896,
0.058320269,
0.335059315,
-0.1385751665,
-0.4313912094,
0.1426787972,
-0.6992149353,
-0.2145196646,
0.888260603,
0.3183992803,
0.6520428061,
0.0423942357,
0.6918247342,
0.0617689267,
0.5271447301,
-1.2486436367,
0.6316364408,
-0.1291131973,
-0.7903595567,
-0.0499720983,
-0.5477571487,
-0.9128187895,
0.3454806805,
-0.2490957379,
-0.5512385368,
-0.1495617181,
-0.2403284013,
-0.4949118197,
0.4057237506,
-0.4100190699,
0.7119566202,
-0.0132416766,
-0.5109241605,
-0.0792939588,
-0.8791232109,
0.1766529381,
-0.204851225,
0.411493808,
-0.4011940956,
-0.1144063696,
0.2344441414,
-0.5706515312,
0.8342103958,
-0.1442609876,
-0.1016287729,
0.2021180987,
0.3282625675,
-0.0904564634,
-0.0208939221,
-0.1240998283,
0.1742270142,
0.0719315857,
-0.5450505018,
-0.3992539048,
0.8560536504,
-0.7089630365,
-0.397582233,
-0.5542385578,
-0.9836603403,
-0.6130137444,
0.3132244945,
-0.1874831319,
0.4043312967,
-0.2114902586,
0.1056564227,
0.6278944612,
-0.1540969759,
0.1666562557,
1.0190179348,
-0.1611410677,
-0.4021773338,
0.6901789308,
0.1598184556,
0.2973967791,
0.2910961509,
0.2029642761,
0.1420722306,
-0.3600605726,
-0.5335240364,
0.3778117299,
-0.5565465689,
-0.4317836761,
-0.626652956,
-0.3967544436,
-0.0771380514,
-0.3876527846,
-0.3287933171,
-0.1806252301,
0.0899023935,
-0.0069674193,
0.450322181,
0.8787582517,
-0.0664968714,
0.004745652,
-1.0791261196,
0.0887693092,
0.1663118452,
0.5274349451,
-0.088542521,
-0.042500291,
-0.4644780457,
-0.2872795761,
-0.0119769573,
-0.8767562509,
0.2944332659,
-0.2193207443,
0.7401614189,
0.1588790268,
-0.0995331332,
0.4079099298,
-0.9116303325,
0.7139890194,
0.2902366221,
-0.699665606,
0.4026709795,
-0.7336376309,
0.2876407504,
0.5921846628,
0.2343174964,
-0.5655998588,
-0.4827253222,
-0.4903934896,
-0.6603941917,
0.5598009229,
0.2558915913,
-0.1819521934,
0.0775830671,
0.3839036822,
0.0369810537,
0.2813138962,
-0.3728125095,
-0.1822252721,
0.3627614081,
-0.2440468371,
0.0496001393,
0.165362075,
-0.6438012719,
-0.2091597021,
0.3882573247,
-0.4046205878,
0.2016939968,
0.3771679401,
0.0015444469,
-0.3501681983,
0.3975864649,
0.6048699617,
0.7581062913,
0.1070294306,
0.2658066154,
0.1209961027,
-0.3397794068,
0.3638405502,
0.2848433852,
0.2115451396,
-0.085113205,
0.5411140323,
0.2209660858,
0.2135848105,
-0.7561902404,
0.6315245032,
-0.0915285945,
-0.4859601855,
-0.0972756371,
-0.151581198,
0.2298261821,
0.4530868828,
0.1330665648,
0.2238051742,
-0.0486771166,
-0.4084212184,
0.5446745157,
0.2417390049,
-0.4909943342,
-0.3049616516,
0.5197457671,
0.2602208555,
-0.1579348296,
0.0248505846,
-0.1195107251,
-0.2475507706,
0.6488434076,
0.3611267209,
0.6818268299,
-0.4819607735,
0.434420079,
-0.2527233362,
0.1299715191,
0.0061006788,
0.1988958418,
0.3220867217,
-0.771382153,
-0.9702970982,
-0.2373463362,
-0.7954267859,
0.3199057877,
-0.2651884556,
0.1819957495,
-0.3501245975,
-0.1794154495,
0.396058321,
-0.0100016473,
-0.5232967138,
0.0265269745,
0.0870544314,
0.8171668053,
-0.7883188725,
0.8592937589,
1.0798149109,
-0.6172061563,
-0.7932954431,
-0.1211978793,
0.2894302607,
-0.8399332762,
0.3123665452,
0.0914435685,
-0.1185766757,
-0.2500652671,
-0.6360188127,
-0.3195443749,
1.1427607536,
0.4674493968,
-0.408988595,
-0.0875388235,
0.1589763761,
0.7705947757,
-0.5681253672,
0.1427075416,
0.3535057008,
0.1010628194,
0.3974488974,
-1.1691894531,
0.0974782631,
-0.3079399168,
-0.4946857095,
0.1381027699,
-0.56172508,
1.0007634163,
-0.4017004669,
0.4779244363,
0.2076946348,
-0.046343036,
0.5372495651,
0.5453086495,
0.1839380264,
0.5423927903,
0.6920185089,
0.1905301064,
0.8539410233,
-0.2930738926,
0.3434125781,
1.1531734467,
-0.9091663957,
0.5858999491,
0.4614448845,
-0.0008223021,
0.5649697185,
0.0708256513,
-0.0731326118,
0.0707940832,
0.2273540348,
-0.8383290172,
-0.52927953,
-0.4965466261,
-0.3201775849,
0.3704063594,
0.4392125309,
-0.3296207488,
-0.4234475791,
-0.0205619428,
0.447979629,
0.0544882454,
-0.2475493252,
0.7730296254,
0.3312657773,
-0.3923483789,
0.2307982296,
-0.0493346415,
0.2783937454,
-0.5366204381,
-0.356462121,
0.0849199966,
0.3426065147,
-0.2400699109,
-0.8581319451,
0.0601791367,
-0.0600388311,
-0.3476692736,
0.0421812981,
0.9612356424,
-0.546413362,
-0.4429830015,
0.4542233348,
1.1727501154,
0.141969502,
-0.0980553478,
-0.7287405133,
-0.0723086521,
-0.4511958063,
0.1168536171,
0.4504276216,
0.7675668001,
-0.0536989681,
0.6936199069,
0.6538158059,
0.2830772996,
-0.5300713778,
0.5660440326,
1.1295285225,
-0.3926603198,
-0.2523433566,
-1.0187375546,
0.526463151,
-0.150861457,
0.103627108,
0.4301894307,
0.4774356782,
0.4072497487,
-0.0854503363,
1.0125794411,
0.1775714606,
0.546733737,
-0.0755213425,
1.08905375,
-0.3804502189,
0.0533159226,
-0.0475414023,
-0.3106420934,
-0.7625201344,
0.6671509743,
-0.262973845,
-0.02367438,
0.6973811388,
0.5953547955,
0.0966889113,
-0.2350800037,
0.7236096859,
0.3294705749,
0.6601766944,
0.827659905,
0.6742824912,
-0.065507628,
0.236110881,
0.0081695197,
-0.4532644451,
-0.0048367996,
-0.771263957,
-1.2722200155,
-0.183698073,
-0.3078255057,
-0.2664307356,
0.0602159128,
1.4421923161,
0.9006887078,
-0.5817620754,
-0.2290406227,
0.0488172844,
-0.0114237973,
0.1922235489,
-0.2258950174,
-0.0008375627,
-0.1876374483,
-0.2822140455,
0.6216342449,
0.6838444471,
-0.2521265447,
-0.4395083785,
-0.015894277,
-0.3582942784,
0.3957559168,
0.9115298986,
0.1862563789,
-0.5772817731,
-0.1700332016,
0.1171294227,
-0.143527627,
-0.0131148184,
0.9497106075,
-0.8961083889,
0.5084696412,
0.052165173,
0.6261926889,
0.0981110707,
-0.4736138284,
0.5795072317,
-0.7414972782,
0.1928562075,
0.469686836,
0.274944216,
0.2845700085,
-0.1879322976,
0.5907670856,
0.4745855033,
-0.8618846536,
-0.77751261,
0.2296082079,
-0.786593914,
-0.4088058174,
1.0677367449,
-0.2867503464,
0.0590715036,
-0.4271249771,
-0.3217077255,
0.1534731835,
-0.3433755338,
0.5478140712,
0.4690700769,
-0.4434588552,
-0.1014553457,
-0.8873093724,
0.363804996,
0.2128367722,
-1.1620078087,
-0.1577789783,
0.5929168463,
0.5131250024,
0.2966898978,
1.1126959324,
-0.1662976146,
0.1414070129,
-0.1131884903,
0.1678210944,
-0.2339478135,
-0.4857979715,
-0.1775878072,
0.0847053677,
0.1233110651,
0.0876977369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09816v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09816v1
|
Performance Trade-offs of Watermarking Large Language Models
| 2023-11-16T11:44:58 | 2023-11-16T11:44:58 |
Anirudh Ajith, Sameer Singh, Danish Pruthi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Amidst growing concerns of large language models (LLMs) being misused for
generating misinformation or completing homework assignments, watermarking has
emerged as an effective solution for distinguishing human-written and
LLM-generated text. A prominent watermarking strategy is to embed a signal into
generated text by upsampling a (pseudorandomly-chosen) subset of tokens at
every generation step. Although this signal is imperceptible to a human reader,
it is detectable through statistical testing. However, implanting such signals
alters the model's output distribution and can have unintended effects when
watermarked LLMs are used for downstream applications. In this work, we
evaluate the performance of watermarked LLMs on a diverse suite of tasks,
including text classification, textual entailment, reasoning, question
answering, translation, summarization, and language modeling. We find that
watermarking has negligible impact on the performance of tasks posed as k-class
classification problems in the average case. However, the accuracy can plummet
to that of a random classifier for some scenarios (that occur with
non-negligible probability). Tasks that are cast as multiple-choice questions
and short-form generation are surprisingly unaffected by watermarking. For
long-form generation tasks, including summarization and translation, we see a
drop of 15-20% in the performance due to watermarking. Our findings highlight
the trade-offs that users should be cognizant of when using watermarked models,
and point to cases where future research could improve existing trade-offs.
|
[
-0.3545264006,
-0.5228062868,
0.5319662094,
0.1598236561,
-0.6066785455,
0.2051254958,
-0.055039376,
-0.5868323445,
0.0032496729,
0.7818433046,
-0.2491003126,
-0.1969416589,
-0.8450220823,
-0.0777694955,
-0.6563689113,
0.8314160109,
-0.0780618563,
-0.1659540087,
-0.5258510709,
-0.0172641315,
-0.51537925,
-0.8981825709,
-0.6867126226,
-0.5179219842,
0.2841112614,
0.0452183522,
0.6251006722,
0.7238859534,
0.4400796592,
0.1951564997,
-0.3499417007,
-0.009538006,
-0.3984275162,
0.3159546852,
-0.0732399672,
-0.469982475,
-0.1433029771,
-0.1112856194,
0.7089783549,
0.5331377983,
0.3627097011,
0.3111892939,
0.3023882806,
0.6120463014,
-0.9289121032,
0.2434670329,
-0.5917745233,
-0.0680750012,
-0.4642671943,
-0.2633615434,
-0.4255965948,
-0.1190697178,
0.0618665516,
-0.3221094906,
0.0458826832,
0.1430056393,
0.8385477066,
0.2689265013,
-0.1373823732,
-0.2851424813,
-0.7936213017,
0.9334272742,
-0.9077946544,
0.3215619028,
0.5345864892,
-0.0208261292,
-0.1234132946,
-0.6500973105,
-0.4737369716,
-0.1313711703,
0.062772654,
0.2414512485,
-0.3310879767,
0.0365392715,
0.4796418548,
0.370855689,
-0.2903858125,
0.1907533556,
-0.0533040464,
-0.2982048988,
0.5915607214,
0.1499297172,
0.3497686982,
0.0023048415,
-0.2242325991,
-0.2959685028,
-0.9077300429,
0.279697448,
0.5289070606,
0.360086292,
0.2914346159,
0.6655758619,
-0.0530833192,
0.7595647573,
-0.2580735385,
-0.078487061,
-0.1794051677,
-0.2594730556,
-0.0712285489,
0.0038840466,
0.5176731944,
0.1875279546,
0.5140477419,
-0.0753254816,
-0.4124734104,
-0.0174454115,
0.1382266879,
-0.9251790643,
-0.1795081049,
0.0983472839,
-0.4215963483,
-0.2018400729,
-0.1786534339,
-0.669182539,
-0.496671319,
-0.3548007607,
0.7387151122,
-0.1238033995,
-0.0860337764,
0.1674378067,
-0.3125723302,
-0.0692551881,
0.154425174,
-0.7214797735,
0.4311542809,
0.5276070833,
0.8789007664,
-0.4296397269,
-0.0764817297,
-0.5936531425,
0.3922249973,
-0.1480820626,
0.926810503,
-0.6273070574,
-0.4355189204,
-0.0271411594,
-0.2400159091,
-0.2011279166,
-0.6752906442,
0.3127256036,
-0.790156424,
0.1682793647,
-0.2803784907,
-0.9513353705,
-0.0434864201,
0.0045897029,
-0.8570562005,
0.9310233593,
-0.1524310112,
-0.9670022726,
0.3549133837,
-0.5078854561,
-0.5912212729,
0.1154638454,
0.0483154394,
-0.7138496637,
-0.0986097679,
-0.0115984976,
0.6014426351,
-0.3035208583,
0.1566482335,
-0.2917019427,
-0.7062019706,
0.398142308,
-0.5259740949,
0.5002192855,
-0.0364825986,
-0.5399418473,
-0.0867343619,
-0.6076141,
0.104746677,
0.1264845878,
-0.7088692188,
-0.7658724189,
0.0818751529,
0.1532027274,
0.0478444099,
0.1428847313,
-0.4346299469,
-0.0753217787,
-0.1197436005,
0.3665937781,
0.7458490729,
0.0585060827,
0.2619489729,
-0.4791297019,
0.6882538795,
0.0122198993,
0.0952854231,
-0.1719646007,
-0.7411828041,
-0.7064215541,
-0.5589672327,
0.6529367566,
0.5497609973,
-0.756334126,
0.1693590581,
-0.3540303409,
-0.3917520642,
-0.3014598787,
0.2525390983,
0.4984759688,
0.1630011201,
0.3415299952,
-0.2336737663,
-0.1821100414,
-0.9607112408,
-0.7263125777,
-0.1595237851,
-0.0060150605,
0.0745455399,
0.6551475525,
0.0538229235,
0.9900717735,
-0.6031130552,
-0.2443165481,
-0.4103441834,
0.1263632476,
-0.0531479418,
0.3281113505,
0.3786790967,
-0.7545823455,
-0.3446137905,
-0.3450849652,
-0.2129362673,
-0.4535570741,
-0.1649129242,
0.1034866124,
0.3016521931,
0.5350209475,
-0.5891971588,
0.5269104242,
0.6943749785,
-0.3176711202,
0.5712879896,
-0.2329408079,
0.0157616939,
-0.9785445333,
0.3274689019,
-0.2214073688,
-0.1792738885,
-0.542011261,
-0.0958712175,
0.0956843942,
-0.0385085717,
-0.2300615162,
0.7287261486,
-0.4822821617,
-0.1452144384,
-0.5756874681,
-0.2616713643,
0.1350563318,
0.2291248292,
0.0270147193,
0.9453750253,
0.2778245509,
-0.5349844098,
-0.1097521111,
-0.0479545817,
-0.4835677445,
0.2294550836,
-0.7083927989,
0.1252979487,
-0.0217521861,
0.0528894626,
-1.0630755424,
0.1477997005,
0.0993512794,
-0.218013823,
0.4032438993,
-0.2560960054,
-0.7565258741,
-0.0572185889,
-0.4194214344,
0.2692937553,
0.5180910826,
-0.5029330254,
0.4723387659,
0.3501316607,
-0.3283502162,
-0.4932411611,
-0.8745760918,
0.1880968213,
-0.3146316111,
-0.2677811384,
0.5488250256,
-0.0104852542,
-0.1088185608,
0.1303255111,
-0.0365925096,
-0.179407835,
0.3161988854,
0.3947164714,
0.1416626871,
0.08000613,
0.098982282,
0.2204351872,
-0.0981228724,
-0.0465024523,
-0.0618793815,
0.5970739126,
0.1945451349,
-0.5795016289,
-0.1718249172,
0.3668971956,
0.6302275658,
-0.3451736569,
0.7292538881,
0.2755866647,
-0.4457294345,
-0.2457864583,
-0.5062855482,
-0.1730701327,
-0.4343287051,
0.2043685764,
-0.1119837984,
-0.9845113754,
0.5497104526,
-0.1108002141,
0.1171209142,
0.2782700062,
0.3759506345,
-0.1109674871,
0.9223027825,
0.4027322531,
-0.3495493531,
0.7809541821,
-0.154587388,
0.3376832008,
-0.7177700996,
0.0659430996,
-0.479512006,
-0.1683526039,
-0.3613672554,
-0.3279667795,
0.0390446968,
0.2612282336,
-0.0564239956,
0.4204416871,
-0.2367650568,
0.45184201,
0.8533596992,
-0.1899721473,
0.6363424063,
0.21581541,
0.0397098437,
-0.1308730543,
-0.7000018358,
-0.6709672809,
1.1582750082,
0.0688980669,
0.627014339,
-0.0536573455,
0.6709813476,
0.5864202976,
0.4829044044,
-0.5617272258,
0.5500825047,
-0.2498581856,
-0.6222477555,
-0.3193292022,
-0.5913867354,
-1.0766779184,
0.3029467165,
-0.2658494115,
-0.6135113239,
-0.0842630714,
0.1577503532,
-0.2411843389,
0.458812952,
-0.6342131495,
0.7497372627,
-0.2095834911,
-0.4175983071,
-0.2234409899,
-0.157386139,
0.1276450008,
-0.4197070897,
0.3072495162,
0.0534472987,
0.0093986103,
0.9357025623,
-0.0784012154,
0.892018199,
-0.2198037803,
-0.0848812833,
0.2564024925,
0.140255183,
0.4742470086,
-0.1939683408,
0.069689922,
0.1716110408,
0.144882068,
-0.3112162352,
-0.3879172802,
0.5118311644,
-0.4762586057,
-0.6170735955,
-0.4503635466,
-0.5005734563,
-0.2898830473,
0.3200107813,
0.3552800417,
0.5854922533,
0.2082032114,
0.0370451473,
0.5315532088,
-0.3584680855,
0.621011138,
0.4933208227,
-0.1053706482,
-0.3832260668,
1.0555263758,
0.4440597296,
0.4457127154,
0.3001913726,
0.2325239927,
-0.4453602731,
-0.8704409599,
-0.5660675764,
0.2081337571,
-0.7571327686,
-0.2222800255,
-0.4976347983,
-0.1279473156,
-0.0110787945,
0.1040713415,
-0.4053370357,
-0.4243506491,
-0.376947999,
0.1943391711,
0.2383330464,
0.6273761988,
0.2331856936,
0.2772318423,
-0.7657701373,
0.1308601201,
0.3089148998,
0.472533077,
0.1064550206,
-0.7947466373,
-0.2224703133,
0.0480177402,
-0.3879750073,
-0.5115004778,
0.1545115858,
0.2493504137,
0.5886970758,
0.2664192021,
0.1942641139,
0.5578947663,
-0.3707973659,
0.6434419155,
0.0440829135,
-1.1414699554,
0.2324463725,
-0.1020112336,
0.4730242193,
0.4289509058,
0.179823786,
-0.4903327525,
-0.614515841,
-0.3904716969,
-0.9938008785,
0.4128897488,
0.4537249506,
0.2958546281,
0.1242884845,
0.2803952992,
0.0863494501,
0.3205379248,
-0.7021148801,
-0.0957499072,
0.1045417264,
-0.0584604219,
-0.0552112758,
-0.3967663348,
0.1684228033,
-0.228307724,
0.6534611583,
-0.0748770088,
0.2044051439,
0.0189335886,
-0.2249907106,
0.1001039594,
0.3400202096,
0.7283430696,
0.4999417961,
-0.0678322315,
0.3075224161,
-0.0228666216,
-0.4858637154,
0.1323970854,
0.0918657854,
-0.4471060634,
0.0396799557,
0.7207272649,
0.6421048045,
0.2224990577,
-0.9046765566,
0.5003522635,
0.0043443274,
-0.0079135867,
-0.0739678815,
0.0284765735,
0.3363173902,
0.2293604761,
0.2916117609,
-0.0154438531,
0.1434433907,
-0.3510073125,
-0.0559979528,
0.5356955528,
-0.0463338234,
-0.2701190114,
0.6484608054,
-0.0358009338,
-0.2241185308,
0.3790435791,
0.1532622129,
-0.7859942913,
0.5757088661,
0.4973706603,
0.7907374501,
-0.0282253046,
-0.0571799055,
0.0489408299,
0.3363183141,
-0.3709861934,
0.2956257761,
-0.0399918891,
-0.7514883876,
-0.6071277857,
-0.6131129861,
-0.6539134383,
0.3425933421,
-0.679122448,
-0.0255764015,
-0.2349449545,
-0.4545277953,
0.0122185033,
-0.1089089438,
-0.5269463062,
0.2001284361,
0.2475460619,
0.6517300606,
-0.8434681892,
0.7078127861,
0.7868562341,
-0.1569076329,
-0.4202554524,
0.2023912519,
-0.4134593904,
-0.581306994,
0.6299988031,
0.2300872356,
-0.2821629047,
0.013526883,
-0.2704072893,
-0.8755376339,
0.8370156884,
0.6236470342,
-0.4961570799,
0.4248060882,
0.6021406651,
0.6430568099,
-0.0862653181,
0.0232148152,
0.4667999744,
0.4087314308,
-0.2684793174,
-0.8118830919,
0.2801187634,
-0.2276629955,
0.1995622665,
0.2122529894,
-0.4436389804,
0.6718124747,
-0.0022599883,
-0.3824017644,
-0.0111018121,
0.1549928039,
0.276224196,
0.3096447587,
0.6507505774,
0.4912620187,
0.4897706807,
-0.051300142,
1.2904393673,
-0.3615253568,
0.247983411,
0.8417904377,
-0.3074256182,
1.0670251846,
0.7288858891,
-0.2697434723,
0.1476329565,
0.5772657394,
-0.0050589261,
0.6702446938,
0.4816317856,
-0.356949687,
-0.4802135229,
-0.2114498913,
-0.3862287402,
0.3080545068,
0.0813895166,
-0.4128157496,
-0.001824748,
-0.0564753003,
0.0762169436,
-0.0271719676,
-0.1984563917,
0.7133138776,
0.2430030257,
-0.6241112947,
0.4011412561,
0.0595339127,
0.811101675,
-0.4871067703,
-0.0492729843,
-0.2439007312,
0.3140908182,
-0.0356219746,
-0.9460224509,
0.2839495242,
0.0256521963,
-0.3051533699,
-0.479529947,
1.0295884609,
-0.4234871268,
-0.2998245358,
0.6129679084,
0.4909819365,
0.0892186612,
-0.4812174141,
-0.4455753863,
0.1621052027,
-0.2179039717,
-0.5127488375,
0.6069217324,
-0.0511859953,
-0.2257841229,
0.8735132217,
0.8763601184,
0.29124403,
0.0830865204,
0.2292465419,
0.7899884582,
-0.4559406638,
-0.4441030324,
-1.0543595552,
0.1612695009,
-0.1928346455,
-0.2344102114,
0.7469436526,
0.5886688828,
0.8692247272,
-0.2507554591,
0.9934376478,
0.392352283,
0.3133976161,
-0.5051198006,
0.9364960194,
-0.5632496476,
0.3041511774,
-0.4381608069,
-0.971519053,
-0.3627551794,
0.1730448902,
-0.4189828634,
0.0432121903,
0.441937089,
0.5221540928,
0.0309450459,
0.1361660212,
0.4105553329,
-0.3855869472,
0.4055607319,
0.30777812,
1.0450205803,
-0.2708294988,
0.7539857626,
-0.3698818088,
-0.0710316896,
-0.1172073931,
-0.9991793036,
-1.0306227207,
-0.443059057,
-0.4462862313,
-0.1234434247,
0.1139180064,
0.5063505769,
0.5746764541,
-0.9858642817,
-0.1797780395,
0.0370581448,
0.053184364,
-0.1991470605,
-0.2078517377,
0.452442944,
0.0740588903,
-0.4790866673,
0.0568949431,
0.3000309467,
0.2988027036,
-0.0199652798,
0.099590525,
0.0402860828,
0.2073496431,
0.6457729936,
0.15404962,
-0.5286267996,
-0.3560382724,
-0.0145111606,
-0.0461468622,
-0.2688487172,
0.9238204956,
-0.4962027371,
0.3535925448,
0.4351274967,
1.0054626465,
0.549187243,
-0.1074874029,
0.3951998651,
-0.6201295257,
-0.1126840562,
0.1742424816,
0.3928568661,
0.5115269423,
-0.1996944249,
0.2409320325,
0.4559167922,
-0.4265241921,
-0.9350748658,
0.0123037342,
-0.6492937803,
-0.4102925062,
1.1887387037,
-0.3348091543,
0.0587566607,
-0.3327754736,
-0.0963233486,
0.1298168004,
-0.225534305,
0.9126502872,
1.0193734169,
0.0088409912,
-0.0564154685,
-0.7064279914,
0.4195743203,
0.6731522679,
-0.9108453393,
0.2936511636,
0.1916440278,
0.5027914047,
0.0232930481,
0.424120903,
-0.0038760186,
0.1051869243,
-0.2608160079,
0.1417512447,
-0.2321721911,
-0.0045753298,
-0.2824242115,
0.0754293874,
0.1896345466,
-0.3314204216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09812v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09812v2
|
Large Language Models for Propaganda Span Annotation
| 2023-11-16T11:37:54 | 2024-01-14T06:32:09 |
Maram Hasanain, Fatema Ahmed, Firoj Alam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T50, F.2.2; I.2.7
|
The use of propagandistic techniques in online contents has increased in
recent years aiming to manipulate online audiences. Efforts to automatically
detect and debunk such content have been made addressing various modeling
scenarios. These include determining whether the content (text, image, or
multimodal) (i) is propagandistic, (ii) employs one or more propagandistic
techniques, and (iii) includes techniques with identifiable spans. Significant
research efforts have been devoted to the first two scenarios compared to the
latter. Therefore, in this study, we focus on the task of detecting
propagandistic textual spans. Specifically, we investigate whether large
language models (LLMs), such as GPT-4, can effectively perform the task.
Moreover, we study the potential of employing the model to collect more
cost-effective annotations. Our experiments use a large-scale in-house dataset
consisting of annotations from human annotators with varying expertise levels.
The results suggest that providing more information to the model as prompts
improves its performance compared to human annotations. Moreover, our work is
the first to show the potential of utilizing LLMs to develop annotated datasets
for this specific task, prompting it with annotations from human annotators
with limited expertise. We plan to make the collected span-level labels from
multiple annotators, including GPT-4, available for the community.
|
[
-0.5499557853,
-1.0927444696,
0.5274266601,
0.5071955919,
-0.3179335296,
-0.0362803116,
-0.4385357797,
-0.7223251462,
0.1802383363,
0.4923174977,
-0.398353219,
-0.3108874261,
-0.906330049,
0.3435557783,
-0.4975044727,
1.0510056019,
-0.1470525861,
-0.2773944139,
0.1644582152,
0.3023796976,
-0.2092692256,
-0.5481778383,
-0.6075696945,
-0.0097820908,
0.7127223611,
0.176505506,
0.7665843964,
0.8358527422,
0.3786957562,
0.2886387706,
0.0410123393,
0.3736347556,
-0.3540436029,
0.0636006668,
-0.0236656498,
-0.2047418654,
-0.3019820154,
0.209763512,
0.7583284974,
0.2415053993,
0.1517325789,
0.2166988999,
-0.2465106398,
0.0836160183,
-0.5108882189,
0.2017068863,
-0.6843531132,
-0.1083679721,
-0.5827537775,
-0.0484080799,
-0.5279356241,
-0.5176948309,
0.1226903051,
-0.804566741,
0.007367739,
0.1556600928,
0.9526698589,
0.031421084,
-0.5355388522,
-0.4997254908,
-0.6514565945,
0.7358689904,
-0.708263278,
0.2376702428,
0.6069151759,
0.2064697593,
0.0273639858,
-0.6593274474,
-0.6374010444,
-0.3216232359,
-0.2036199868,
0.0105438959,
-0.4276833832,
-0.1190458387,
0.3897915781,
0.2126860023,
-0.4994235933,
0.2837451696,
-0.5372319221,
-0.5654559731,
0.5651866794,
-0.1136639863,
0.4041932523,
-0.3905890882,
-0.623072505,
0.1512007266,
-0.7439907193,
-0.5732389688,
0.785233736,
0.054950051,
-0.0827950314,
0.7456889153,
-0.1152494028,
0.6378371716,
-0.0051360037,
-0.22632581,
0.2163318396,
-0.263130486,
-0.0905844197,
-0.0072683687,
0.7742923498,
0.309322387,
0.7074135542,
0.1366034746,
-0.2514670789,
0.3128385842,
0.1675381511,
-0.7708991766,
-0.320386529,
-0.1187382862,
-0.2542298734,
-0.2218054533,
-0.1360055059,
-0.8457118869,
-0.5272779465,
-0.203411147,
0.5604644418,
-0.5709729195,
-0.4893595576,
0.0292387586,
-0.1381516606,
-0.068625994,
0.2664781809,
-0.8064832687,
-0.0903772265,
0.6166785955,
1.0414983034,
0.0091458065,
-0.2309505939,
-0.5247936845,
0.1576002687,
-0.4950836301,
0.900447011,
-0.7286659479,
-0.1606120169,
0.3258344531,
-0.1027704999,
-0.0015962665,
-0.2688993216,
0.7487415671,
-0.6699326634,
0.2390764803,
-0.2116679102,
-0.7921184301,
0.0972109064,
0.5388195515,
-1.1128919125,
0.8743437529,
0.1728622168,
-1.0901937485,
0.2703616321,
-0.6496583819,
-0.4178626239,
0.0061628795,
0.0663932934,
-0.6305796504,
-0.0994292125,
0.5623493195,
0.5793675184,
0.0024869086,
0.261230588,
-0.1333978772,
-0.2292742729,
0.3130202293,
-0.7167782784,
0.3451319039,
0.2756717801,
-0.3795476556,
0.0984066725,
-0.4566731751,
-0.4096337855,
-0.0309186969,
-0.4158818722,
-0.556306541,
-0.1339319199,
0.1204313412,
0.2718934417,
0.2146170139,
-0.4231636524,
0.3334337473,
-0.192604214,
0.1568873525,
0.7604294419,
0.2443041056,
0.1793654412,
-0.2085341662,
0.6252836585,
-0.0229191873,
0.20531708,
-0.4838362336,
-0.5378341079,
-0.5158053041,
-0.5593534708,
0.1160271019,
0.2096131742,
-1.0395150185,
-0.083762303,
-0.2120773941,
-0.5638845563,
-0.2762886286,
-0.0459057316,
0.4256797433,
0.4400108755,
0.4507679641,
0.2985678017,
-0.7054068446,
-1.1460108757,
-0.4677826464,
-0.1692267805,
-0.0776165202,
-0.3228906691,
0.6902178526,
0.0021822769,
0.8221405149,
-0.6437541842,
-0.3061834872,
-0.2874571979,
0.6356517673,
-0.1552039832,
0.0341253355,
0.4172449708,
-1.0634763241,
-0.5510292053,
-0.1139002815,
-0.4546241462,
-0.352923274,
-0.2021906078,
0.0590281449,
0.3026528358,
0.4059837759,
-0.7333539128,
0.2288768291,
0.8285620809,
-0.3096918166,
0.8603762388,
-0.0727747455,
0.2924496531,
-0.981464386,
-0.0857218653,
0.6527357101,
-0.2355994433,
-0.7564881444,
-0.3724760115,
0.18236579,
0.4443532228,
-0.1875959933,
0.4334656298,
-0.552785635,
0.0550641455,
-0.2664451301,
0.3090074956,
0.0143289473,
0.0734120831,
0.2729154527,
0.7111096978,
0.1412205249,
-0.2512622476,
0.2715784013,
0.1118214354,
-0.4613550305,
0.694984138,
-0.4231824577,
-0.2113135606,
-0.1310223937,
0.6781995893,
-0.9196215272,
-0.6072919965,
0.3849410117,
-0.3042709529,
0.1491246819,
-0.2844811976,
-0.7935942411,
-0.4041632414,
-0.2616668642,
0.1321322024,
0.2793222964,
-0.4593554735,
0.2807213068,
0.4688839316,
-0.1170006394,
-0.5111275911,
-0.5668424964,
0.1117141694,
-0.6204823852,
-0.5417364836,
0.2039432526,
0.2001330703,
-0.3296720684,
-0.2279806882,
0.1352199018,
-0.1090494394,
-0.1639917642,
0.1763922274,
0.3631067276,
-0.1874429286,
0.3982857168,
-0.2043608129,
0.1075128689,
0.1870633066,
-0.3129975796,
0.4784176052,
0.0258309599,
-0.3557484746,
-0.3417918086,
0.3235449493,
0.4771495461,
-0.5169901848,
0.8099508882,
1.0110516548,
-0.4708307385,
-0.232395649,
-0.9604067802,
-0.1673387736,
-0.4000067115,
0.5309712291,
-0.2142946869,
-0.9765844345,
0.3180679381,
-0.0783541724,
0.0333539955,
0.6057866812,
0.6436229944,
0.2300987691,
1.0689287186,
0.5100104809,
-0.1599218547,
0.4752549529,
-0.0554806143,
-0.03739715,
-0.5985615849,
-0.173223123,
-0.425453186,
-0.1338589042,
-0.4581331611,
-0.668063283,
0.4248674512,
-0.1570936292,
-0.2899175882,
0.2373724133,
-0.3711537719,
0.358776927,
0.2725538909,
-0.1358634979,
0.4476627111,
0.0698908865,
0.2604782879,
-0.1048809066,
-0.3829386234,
-0.6106619835,
0.9872695208,
0.7374793291,
0.6417226195,
0.0784436166,
0.2298453599,
0.3676648736,
0.93251127,
-0.4885865748,
0.3380098045,
-0.024520088,
-0.9003314376,
-0.3149130642,
-0.4717689157,
-0.7466401458,
0.2742600143,
-0.1690209955,
-0.6469157934,
-0.1625757962,
0.2699414194,
-0.1109579951,
0.4447861314,
-0.7095659375,
0.6877596974,
-0.0744280815,
-0.1284336299,
-0.1382384449,
-0.5299338698,
0.5787941217,
-0.4696893692,
0.4643681049,
-0.2134231925,
-0.0968169346,
0.7205898166,
-0.0688978955,
1.1292561293,
-0.1748627424,
-0.4318657815,
0.2767560482,
-0.1304561645,
0.741237402,
-0.1176015809,
-0.0641104728,
-0.051398579,
-0.3411011994,
-0.1750255376,
-0.179951176,
0.6393486261,
-0.7491478324,
-0.5434858203,
-0.2801217139,
-0.6527518034,
-0.1433790177,
0.1379375607,
0.2356766015,
0.4271700978,
-0.0247567166,
0.1209258288,
0.6092113256,
-0.1276195794,
0.3602414727,
0.2542911172,
-0.2492548227,
-0.2807025909,
0.6940425038,
0.3460789919,
0.4179141819,
0.3043792546,
0.3074477911,
-0.464664489,
-0.4425502121,
-0.4870247245,
0.4223937988,
-0.762910068,
-0.2527032197,
-0.5484352708,
-0.0934384838,
-0.1916612238,
-0.0147483367,
-0.3056013286,
-0.1650151461,
-0.1699882895,
-0.3091014326,
0.6022828221,
0.9714996219,
0.0391749181,
0.586736083,
-0.482562691,
0.2393894643,
0.0494412556,
0.1180049926,
-0.2783860862,
-0.5221552849,
-0.4452905655,
0.1447610855,
-0.2062680721,
-1.2250491381,
0.4494067132,
-0.155721128,
0.4330197871,
0.5164402127,
0.0421881974,
0.6607661843,
-0.4402346015,
0.8085090518,
0.0903967395,
-0.9296454787,
0.2357655764,
-0.7262883186,
0.1151919812,
-0.050066296,
0.8207108974,
-0.5107224584,
-0.6032934189,
-0.4358361959,
-0.8052415848,
0.4176235497,
0.2869811356,
0.1828411371,
-0.3902190328,
0.2011449635,
0.0478716083,
0.1624676883,
-0.9393981695,
0.099231109,
-0.2657929957,
-0.1526101381,
-0.0073487009,
-0.3451616168,
-0.0574067049,
0.2259467393,
0.7186710835,
-0.2293254733,
-0.1006024182,
0.2111540139,
-0.2738920152,
-0.1336143762,
0.2316297293,
0.7386877537,
0.9267175198,
0.1219141111,
0.4463893175,
0.205910638,
-0.4634730816,
-0.0916344002,
0.2188028246,
0.0234817713,
0.2213713974,
0.6388298273,
0.7730084062,
0.2194057703,
-0.4961056709,
0.6794079542,
0.3169231117,
-0.2184551358,
-0.6114854217,
-0.5164018869,
0.3138255477,
0.4265376627,
0.5126063824,
-0.3451159298,
-0.0741213262,
-0.3539595008,
0.2475811988,
0.3989719748,
-0.0441030525,
-0.4236480594,
0.6209805012,
0.0143109113,
-0.0195439737,
0.4348318279,
-0.0946036577,
-0.7452021241,
0.5220494866,
0.7116501331,
0.3210399449,
-0.5311828852,
0.5649474263,
0.2164359391,
0.5704687834,
-0.4187949896,
-0.2029875964,
0.4473525286,
-0.5515254736,
-0.8821110725,
-0.5410234332,
-0.2261047363,
0.372954011,
-0.3006455004,
0.3306922615,
-0.0850670412,
-0.1481583416,
0.2584507465,
-0.071077913,
-0.4249850512,
0.368272841,
0.6225867867,
0.8946706057,
-1.2857681513,
0.837294817,
0.5038597584,
-0.5714965463,
-0.9195851684,
0.1980559975,
0.1173070967,
-0.6654065847,
0.8121407628,
0.3563379347,
-0.0604138151,
-0.032649301,
-0.5109490156,
-0.8576179147,
0.9662560225,
0.3303614855,
-0.5314980745,
-0.2449833006,
0.2273443341,
0.5956865549,
-0.4004016519,
0.3551653028,
0.5398498178,
0.9409076571,
0.0145379109,
-1.0283341408,
0.1285482049,
0.121910587,
-0.0822517648,
0.357496798,
-0.4857943654,
1.1592712402,
0.1796271354,
-0.1063279435,
-0.0597675964,
0.6984552741,
0.1983228773,
0.207467407,
0.7491483092,
0.1467185915,
0.5217727423,
-0.0894025937,
1.0022075176,
0.0557448082,
0.3815573454,
0.716792047,
-0.0025595545,
0.7851698995,
0.4488340318,
0.0357755125,
0.4516517818,
0.4893373549,
-0.2237265408,
0.0706124753,
0.3637263179,
-0.2514466941,
-0.2609675229,
-0.1047659963,
-0.1266669035,
0.351349473,
0.6599603295,
-0.5643149018,
-0.2953475118,
0.1636520922,
0.7856456637,
0.2274928242,
-0.3559589982,
0.4455281496,
-0.038002234,
-0.8370791078,
0.2948307395,
0.2223872244,
0.7534694672,
-0.8734959364,
-0.01575871,
-0.050453186,
0.2402216941,
-0.2083711475,
-0.8043448329,
0.399479866,
0.20144476,
0.0218931194,
-0.2257002741,
0.842015028,
-0.7619518042,
-0.5165947676,
0.1641235799,
0.3920009136,
0.0666314587,
-0.4684298635,
-0.2422245294,
0.4408858716,
-0.01449834,
-0.6405169368,
0.2047796994,
0.3343584239,
-0.5749597549,
0.5201649666,
0.6891283989,
0.2477903068,
0.1441565007,
-0.0040065898,
0.9325154424,
-0.2785355151,
-0.4240869284,
-1.0515848398,
0.4407122731,
-0.5018947124,
-0.1592189521,
1.0982302427,
0.4706650674,
0.6747637987,
-0.1295725107,
1.0380380154,
0.1018926576,
0.5110910535,
-0.4909654856,
0.7022708058,
-0.279322654,
0.1202849597,
-0.4177835286,
-0.7913948894,
-0.4811005294,
0.5395120978,
-0.7804885507,
0.0078728152,
0.5219802856,
0.7746927142,
-0.0886358544,
0.1461818069,
0.2830822766,
0.361561209,
0.5612068772,
0.3763790727,
1.1373252869,
0.1601436883,
0.80722332,
-0.1019272208,
-0.1939584315,
-0.2428859919,
-1.1462703943,
-1.1552989483,
-0.6623414159,
-0.3145780265,
-0.2265857905,
0.1816349626,
0.7945286036,
0.6412842274,
-0.2724113464,
0.07526014,
0.2358268648,
-0.1670134813,
-0.0281218626,
-0.2126133144,
0.6470829248,
-0.0985778198,
-0.8445538878,
0.2393055558,
0.0810673758,
-0.1300433725,
-0.6655836105,
0.1976108998,
-0.407007575,
0.2786731124,
0.5865616202,
0.0190164875,
-0.8583594561,
-0.7022377849,
-0.0942585245,
0.0121543249,
-0.1642726809,
0.6914104819,
-0.496252954,
0.3143459558,
0.2163408548,
0.4531334341,
0.5216088891,
0.3469506502,
0.4499215782,
-1.1197897196,
-0.077382803,
0.1148362607,
0.24971205,
0.628405869,
-0.3569071591,
0.2707974613,
0.1768529713,
-0.55089885,
-0.6397509575,
0.2887589037,
-0.598816216,
-0.2066859603,
1.5878537893,
-0.4494176209,
0.073063843,
-0.1688862294,
-0.3759962618,
0.3193061352,
-0.2102612108,
0.658447504,
0.8852318525,
0.1336199045,
-0.1826581657,
-0.7919200659,
0.6067057848,
-0.0708048269,
-1.0476169586,
0.0787913054,
0.8882758617,
0.4918947518,
0.3354386687,
0.4971052706,
-0.0161168352,
-0.0535030439,
0.0230068397,
-0.2108557522,
-0.2336317152,
-0.24261944,
0.1173340008,
0.4363382459,
-0.1435467303,
-0.0391173996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09808v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09808v3
|
PixT3: Pixel-based Table-To-Text Generation
| 2023-11-16T11:32:47 | 2024-06-03T17:43:23 |
Iñigo Alonso, Eneko Agirre, Mirella Lapata
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Table-to-text generation involves generating appropriate textual descriptions
given structured tabular data. It has attracted increasing attention in recent
years thanks to the popularity of neural network models and the availability of
large-scale datasets. A common feature across existing methods is their
treatment of the input as a string, i.e., by employing linearization techniques
that do not always preserve information in the table, are verbose, and lack
space efficiency. We propose to rethink data-to-text generation as a visual
recognition task, removing the need for rendering the input in a string format.
We present PixT3, a multimodal table-to-text model that overcomes the
challenges of linearization and input size limitations encountered by existing
models. PixT3 is trained with a new self-supervised learning objective to
reinforce table structure awareness and is applicable to open-ended and
controlled generation settings. Experiments on the ToTTo and Logic2Text
benchmarks show that PixT3 is competitive and, in some settings, superior to
generators that operate solely on text.
|
[
-0.2183602452,
-0.8200005889,
0.7721194029,
0.2377714962,
-0.1530886441,
-0.2487505078,
-0.0425533727,
-0.2106305361,
-0.0441587195,
0.4113454223,
-0.3283070624,
-0.4989507198,
-0.3355534971,
0.0393650085,
-0.7640717626,
1.2878391743,
-0.0765586793,
-0.2448641658,
-0.4309642315,
0.4261145294,
-0.5262768865,
-0.3239827156,
-0.2290983349,
-0.0437907316,
0.9211134911,
0.7738659382,
0.8720366359,
0.9627991319,
0.4515790939,
0.2143832743,
0.4361222684,
-0.0161381196,
-0.4632214308,
0.2818929255,
-0.0591231659,
-0.3757653832,
-0.5105996132,
-0.0595147349,
0.6500218511,
0.4633157253,
0.0548748039,
-0.0144252377,
-0.035611257,
0.7642646432,
-0.7613546252,
0.3001857996,
-0.930067718,
0.4936655462,
-0.4894853532,
-0.1815645397,
-0.54706496,
-0.302914083,
-0.1596578062,
-0.6514763236,
0.5947574973,
0.1806559116,
0.4282241166,
-0.1001214013,
-0.4363668263,
-0.3176753819,
-0.7809209228,
0.2693062127,
-0.3140150607,
0.3956449628,
0.2889133394,
0.3960445225,
-0.1330844462,
-1.1242204905,
-1.0805844069,
-0.0460382514,
-0.0995672494,
0.3065489829,
-0.16283077,
-0.4217060208,
0.1598914713,
0.3218565583,
-0.6663196087,
-0.2765825391,
-0.3894512057,
-0.0325467885,
0.4688767195,
0.0310196485,
0.3981938362,
-0.1341824234,
-0.5389124155,
-0.24727346,
-0.8047321439,
-0.2131240964,
0.1708140969,
0.4151032567,
-0.0026709503,
0.7585731149,
0.10228315,
0.8646051884,
-0.160715431,
0.1518205255,
-0.1106990725,
-0.4759982526,
-0.0857069194,
0.3300236166,
1.091339469,
0.4788985848,
0.0871913731,
-0.1293491125,
-0.1920042783,
0.2360236496,
0.5202317834,
-0.7278476954,
-0.5159236193,
-0.1252615452,
-0.3113767207,
-0.3211204708,
0.0847434178,
-1.2417185307,
-0.4224111438,
-0.1544192135,
0.6235278845,
-0.3603421152,
-0.1199171916,
-0.2233370543,
-0.1464357227,
0.0251769256,
0.5910764933,
-1.0749638081,
0.4065700769,
0.4025606513,
0.9074397683,
-0.4624857306,
-0.1658803672,
-0.5859208107,
0.4221812785,
-0.5774187446,
0.8447959423,
-0.4238001406,
-0.550609231,
-0.122378476,
-0.4643960893,
0.088769637,
-0.1924330145,
0.0003145051,
-0.1475117803,
0.4468087852,
0.065023005,
-0.3208492994,
0.227141872,
0.0716395006,
-0.6520842314,
0.7612614632,
0.0181226321,
-0.7345324755,
0.6078788638,
-0.6367443204,
-0.3994652331,
0.2254670262,
-0.6430571675,
-1.0385063887,
0.2862534821,
0.3163053691,
0.7682487965,
-0.2518731356,
0.2064790577,
-0.3300036788,
-0.2186071873,
0.2926581204,
-0.4836570323,
-0.1947895139,
0.3317213953,
-0.2912472486,
0.2686238587,
-0.8062974811,
0.0888746679,
0.2631589174,
-0.2311923504,
0.2939058244,
0.3066192567,
0.5415114164,
0.2490355819,
-0.1385071427,
-0.6005451083,
0.0545858741,
-0.1936993301,
0.5783037543,
0.3336723149,
-0.1854143441,
0.2939184904,
-0.3073281348,
0.1658573598,
0.1045391038,
-0.1885922253,
-0.4897256196,
-0.5181910992,
-0.697104454,
-0.1292017549,
0.2821493447,
0.220235914,
-1.0054672956,
0.0905903652,
-0.5357558727,
-0.3970711529,
0.3351768851,
-0.0335894078,
0.1334203482,
0.7454032302,
0.3416774273,
-0.1150473803,
-0.1624009907,
-1.0337949991,
0.0520478226,
0.0435446054,
0.0344195291,
0.2303084284,
0.6507582664,
0.0059006186,
1.2710975409,
-0.3648872674,
-0.4680745602,
-0.5010792613,
0.2285409868,
0.0157857109,
0.8788844347,
0.3731722534,
-0.8515856266,
-0.6401360631,
0.4072934091,
-0.4047400951,
0.3281242847,
-0.393432945,
0.0731685683,
0.2707858086,
0.481705308,
-0.2075784057,
0.8045965433,
0.4088876545,
-0.504928112,
0.1863008291,
-0.3403030336,
-0.0689759552,
-1.3157426119,
0.2166373581,
0.1769047678,
-0.4295384586,
-0.7277843952,
-0.4165984392,
0.5296955705,
-0.847001791,
-0.7078116536,
0.4019819796,
-0.3787184954,
-0.4861002564,
-0.2514682412,
0.2293563485,
0.1652588248,
0.6452215314,
0.404355675,
1.0661629438,
0.292675674,
-0.6024716496,
0.3896457851,
0.3807292581,
-0.4369476736,
0.6539771557,
-0.5480439067,
-0.0349940173,
-0.1047748998,
0.2209288031,
-1.0216619968,
-0.3625807762,
0.2863607407,
-0.6593125463,
0.3365088105,
0.0851599649,
-0.720300138,
-0.1716078073,
-0.1639529169,
0.6716476083,
0.1374967396,
-0.6165406704,
0.5855787992,
0.1941049844,
-0.1944083869,
-0.2129212767,
-0.6442549229,
0.3171218932,
-0.1073171943,
-0.5078778863,
0.6146104336,
0.2420602143,
0.1935862303,
-0.3552419841,
-0.279750675,
-0.1994867325,
-0.2040452808,
0.1830508709,
0.290374279,
0.0442506447,
0.4929452538,
-0.04359781,
-0.0158499293,
0.0099553447,
-0.1556523591,
0.6026893854,
-0.2747844458,
-0.0852449909,
-0.734778285,
0.4641965628,
0.3601262867,
-0.3152302802,
0.1595775783,
0.5796968341,
-0.3557246029,
-0.1787821352,
-0.2713334858,
-0.0139895454,
-0.4303859472,
0.5509850979,
-0.4992972314,
-0.5179512501,
0.1679726094,
-0.0067156125,
-0.0824319273,
0.5996874571,
0.557477951,
-0.5548744202,
0.9531154633,
0.5251708627,
0.6856713891,
0.4442047477,
0.0067685475,
0.0185577199,
-0.5626850724,
-0.5369458795,
-0.621224165,
-0.5309352875,
-0.4920791686,
-0.3154653013,
0.5638266802,
-0.3241720498,
-0.2685003579,
0.3641840816,
-0.5338541865,
0.4001314342,
0.5688813329,
0.4372312725,
0.043084342,
0.2803730369,
0.0311149266,
-0.1119263396,
-0.9343041182,
-0.2433238178,
1.0184139013,
0.3307690024,
1.041041255,
0.0128136007,
0.5125354528,
0.3993663788,
0.2051889002,
-0.7295160294,
0.4495354891,
-0.1961434782,
-0.3375589252,
-0.1454639286,
-0.7154406309,
-0.9987309575,
0.0699289665,
-0.8229817152,
-0.7065173388,
0.2419323176,
0.4534032643,
-0.2564169466,
0.4053096175,
-0.8309417367,
1.060346365,
-0.4698257744,
-0.9460020661,
0.2120324224,
-0.436583817,
0.2453488111,
-0.0056538684,
0.0719084665,
0.0603036433,
-0.1047939286,
0.5934404135,
-0.6669998765,
0.8349289894,
0.0962432846,
-0.1826318055,
0.0875742882,
0.4688528478,
0.4526056349,
0.3954395652,
0.2288130224,
-0.1519185454,
-0.0701995417,
-0.2003408968,
-0.6523514986,
0.7142081857,
-0.7216522098,
-0.3629717827,
-0.5106580257,
-0.792796433,
-0.2820500731,
0.2911485732,
0.3038573265,
0.6350437403,
0.0695150122,
0.5317755938,
0.6443683505,
-0.3735198677,
0.7817226052,
-0.1581769884,
-0.5272710323,
-0.8578149676,
1.1830679178,
-0.2189853936,
0.0976485386,
0.6035802364,
0.2555376589,
-0.5421196818,
-0.2770981491,
-0.5874657631,
-0.0442421511,
-0.3361557722,
-0.3608499169,
-0.5579782724,
-0.0456163362,
-0.2225307673,
-0.2929748297,
-0.5705134273,
-0.625095129,
-0.492313832,
0.2136681527,
0.2034665942,
0.8990741968,
0.2633696795,
0.7610637546,
-0.5263420939,
0.4679147899,
0.6112291813,
0.8288959861,
-0.4226119816,
-0.0880829543,
0.0661616325,
-0.1532173008,
-0.4176502228,
-0.9828356504,
0.6074944139,
0.2973459363,
0.1542025954,
0.1396858543,
-0.2453182638,
0.5606065989,
-0.6153670549,
0.5401173234,
0.9530074596,
-1.2399051189,
1.0256136656,
-0.4466509819,
0.3804916739,
0.2209216058,
0.179540962,
-0.5765239596,
0.1452072561,
-0.3528778553,
-0.6804147959,
0.9052091241,
0.5329840779,
-0.0127340732,
0.0508537926,
0.2822631001,
0.4653947055,
0.2599178851,
-1.4716757536,
0.1973644048,
-0.9623680711,
-0.3413909078,
-0.0446686186,
-0.2216066271,
0.0732767284,
0.1084671691,
0.2232084572,
-0.3510348499,
0.5554180741,
0.2212774158,
-0.1806567311,
0.2264655083,
0.3344793916,
0.8849072456,
0.7711952925,
-0.036228288,
0.4380335212,
-0.218450278,
-0.3851577044,
-0.0692899525,
-0.1979191899,
-0.0890846178,
-0.0249135569,
0.0411362574,
0.9685971737,
-0.0157551058,
-0.2896975875,
0.772601366,
-0.2752300203,
-0.5616887808,
-0.1320356429,
0.0946652815,
-0.3899621964,
-0.2420619279,
0.2345661819,
0.0871256068,
-0.0269551836,
-0.6856307387,
0.5043755174,
0.4131369889,
-0.7153165936,
-0.0271686986,
0.9712888002,
0.3319182992,
-0.3787206709,
0.6335895658,
0.310649842,
-0.0724167749,
0.4321808815,
0.8775056005,
0.4121733606,
0.1593389362,
0.3740064502,
0.3281771839,
0.0492594428,
0.1387475431,
0.3502128422,
-0.4532523453,
-0.548104465,
0.0358335264,
-0.2503823042,
-0.3689547479,
0.0111876028,
-0.3813572228,
0.4038442969,
-0.7336792946,
-0.3293665051,
0.0205540638,
-0.3288331032,
-0.3082280755,
0.3281521499,
0.3023352027,
0.585131228,
-0.4607833028,
0.8604741693,
0.4164493382,
-0.3296482563,
-0.3418163061,
-0.1777488142,
-0.155461058,
-0.6480772495,
0.6844511628,
0.4110763371,
0.3110072911,
0.0194648318,
-0.545127511,
-0.7804954052,
1.1377774477,
0.0685550645,
-0.6048983335,
-0.0297214743,
0.6280354857,
0.2522158325,
-0.4718909264,
0.2214205265,
0.2006154954,
0.3455725312,
0.3450366855,
-0.6069835424,
-0.1987340897,
-0.491335243,
0.5309206843,
0.1259596199,
-0.234447822,
0.8776684403,
0.0556901321,
-0.2686235309,
-0.1752203405,
0.8064903617,
0.1718045175,
0.2288665324,
0.356724143,
0.3626887202,
0.1896252781,
-0.5801547766,
0.8428405523,
-0.0859580114,
0.0177492984,
1.2969577312,
-0.3316212296,
0.8798028231,
0.5439985394,
0.072172001,
0.1647858769,
0.4235482514,
-0.3096786737,
0.3661670089,
0.158862114,
-0.0219499618,
-0.1444197446,
0.1201393902,
-0.4166002274,
0.5990634561,
0.7113505602,
-0.4197060466,
-0.6047919393,
0.0214478187,
-0.1020487919,
0.5141717792,
-0.6207580566,
0.7840781212,
-0.4802439213,
-0.5094664097,
0.1982749254,
-0.0943538621,
0.4470836222,
-0.4857905805,
-0.2526624501,
-0.2511203587,
0.0299868844,
-0.3015736639,
-1.0448908806,
0.3359784186,
-0.0351931527,
-0.1863739192,
-0.6699311137,
0.5569637418,
-0.5483118892,
-0.8085534573,
-0.3912235498,
0.3716239333,
-0.1726790518,
-0.1014136299,
-0.3254080117,
0.1404115707,
-0.0144693619,
0.1793887615,
0.1816909909,
0.3781524599,
-0.0427864343,
0.6219549179,
0.4140601754,
-0.0692784265,
0.0522126779,
-0.312343955,
0.7315836549,
-0.6889516115,
-0.6004211903,
-0.7798727751,
0.3834044933,
0.080797039,
-0.2636938095,
0.5094390512,
0.9509437084,
0.6843616962,
-0.3288701773,
0.6493213177,
-0.1066698357,
0.3176073432,
-0.6124092937,
1.0884498358,
-0.6767041683,
0.0558175519,
-0.3798489869,
-1.0734639168,
-0.5975986123,
0.4828226566,
-0.1243522093,
0.0452513918,
0.7534332275,
0.6043620706,
-0.0835447237,
0.1220472082,
0.4904016852,
-0.1554572433,
0.4333188832,
0.7191179395,
0.9487402439,
-0.4665918946,
0.9298526645,
-0.3157966435,
-0.0848311111,
0.118398957,
-0.8771519661,
-0.76126647,
-0.8603939414,
-0.200207606,
-0.0754181743,
-0.0827603191,
0.611664176,
0.6999335885,
-0.5095923543,
-0.4823084176,
-0.5873451829,
0.0464582108,
0.0795332864,
-0.1845505983,
0.3831978142,
-0.5088031292,
-0.6558567882,
0.1484120637,
0.4142214954,
0.422704488,
0.0854930133,
0.3753522635,
-0.209932074,
-0.3155335486,
0.7586001158,
0.279933691,
-0.4453591108,
-0.0151427789,
-0.3081024885,
-0.0200187657,
0.6109527946,
0.9351152778,
-0.922424078,
0.5915040374,
0.3828679919,
0.5617946386,
0.7510958314,
-0.1102283597,
0.9371643066,
-0.8810907006,
-0.1339260638,
0.1959462464,
0.3052188754,
0.1743169129,
-0.2377848476,
0.3455532193,
0.2535226941,
-0.249594897,
-0.4693779945,
0.2837176919,
-1.0773751736,
-0.2681748569,
0.8368363976,
0.2078318745,
-0.3960523009,
0.2490013093,
-0.3215243816,
0.1172044426,
-0.5236016512,
0.8099396229,
0.1071622595,
-0.2299008369,
-0.5401819944,
-0.1562253088,
0.6228116155,
0.2930856049,
-1.2517774105,
0.1617302299,
0.739787817,
-0.2175294608,
0.2529778779,
0.1950963438,
-0.2584900558,
0.6224589348,
0.0357736237,
0.3699717224,
-0.2313545346,
-0.6952481866,
0.0117267594,
0.6223652959,
-0.4566672742,
-0.1056176946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09807v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09807v2
|
The Curious Decline of Linguistic Diversity: Training Language Models on Synthetic Text
| 2023-11-16T11:31:50 | 2024-04-16T15:57:11 |
Yanzhu Guo, Guokan Shang, Michalis Vazirgiannis, Chloé Clavel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study investigates the consequences of training language models on
synthetic data generated by their predecessors, an increasingly prevalent
practice given the prominence of powerful generative models. Diverging from the
usual emphasis on performance metrics, we focus on the impact of this training
methodology on linguistic diversity, especially when conducted recursively over
time. To assess this, we adapt and develop a set of novel metrics targeting
lexical, syntactic, and semantic diversity, applying them in recursive
finetuning experiments across various natural language generation tasks in
English. Our findings reveal a consistent decrease in the diversity of the
model outputs through successive iterations, especially remarkable for tasks
demanding high levels of creativity. This trend underscores the potential risks
of training language models on synthetic text, particularly concerning the
preservation of linguistic richness. Our study highlights the need for careful
consideration of the long-term effects of such training approaches on the
linguistic capabilities of language models.
|
[
-0.5510001779,
-0.642106235,
0.144310534,
0.0566588044,
-0.1446275264,
0.3648070991,
-0.3901484013,
-0.5734109282,
-0.0650215074,
0.3447808325,
-0.6805045009,
-0.2035304457,
-0.7506115437,
0.3761376441,
-0.6017435193,
1.2043714523,
0.2135457397,
0.1329281181,
-0.0459699631,
-0.3006073236,
-0.4849685133,
-0.4874624908,
-0.5782414079,
-0.2970829904,
0.5806927681,
0.1372838467,
0.5768734813,
0.6371734142,
0.1795476675,
0.3300790787,
-0.4677816927,
0.0727448091,
-1.0375566483,
0.4226976931,
-0.4310830534,
-0.7729059458,
0.2750480175,
0.1116428822,
1.0518267155,
1.2722053528,
-0.080523245,
-0.1235112697,
0.1141318679,
0.7950487733,
-0.4906402826,
-0.3289367557,
-0.9895552993,
0.0836562663,
-0.2062869519,
-0.1865756959,
-0.2710234225,
-0.1438089758,
0.3244950473,
-0.3282220364,
0.9025560021,
-0.1783566475,
0.5386638641,
0.0222282112,
-0.3209058642,
-0.3026946187,
-1.1543684006,
1.1295582056,
-0.5195676088,
0.5596969724,
0.047282882,
0.2427130193,
-0.0234221853,
-0.6084379554,
-0.5685704947,
-0.4103464186,
0.1768521518,
0.0687442198,
-0.0929045007,
-0.2200132906,
0.1150205433,
0.7792439461,
-0.4009663165,
0.3531963527,
-0.5177410245,
0.0683135763,
0.6512479782,
0.5507082343,
0.414116621,
0.0695534125,
0.1293108761,
-0.1337135732,
-0.5619888902,
-0.0252161082,
0.8440143466,
0.523321867,
-0.1056550518,
0.5563082099,
-0.3414087892,
0.384003222,
-0.2954050899,
-0.0851596221,
0.303421706,
-0.669413507,
0.1398336887,
-0.4197954834,
0.7021123767,
0.2166375369,
0.2452850789,
-0.3758655488,
-0.2715724409,
0.1260961592,
0.2727718651,
-0.5569860935,
-0.3595353663,
-0.0979477093,
-0.1980079263,
-0.3204060793,
-0.0530206077,
-0.5590475202,
-0.2162271887,
-0.172861129,
-0.1193681508,
-0.6257036924,
-0.246197477,
0.2170368582,
-0.5202558041,
-0.0162140261,
0.2487766147,
-1.341160655,
0.2597541511,
0.680182755,
0.7014035583,
-0.4391188622,
-0.460065335,
0.0436884686,
-0.2961081564,
-0.3908497393,
0.408069104,
-0.6026111841,
-0.7402722836,
-0.0539851263,
0.216917336,
-0.0757583752,
-0.788644731,
0.2620079815,
-0.1661148667,
0.4669190943,
0.1141767278,
-0.4301656485,
-0.0879514813,
0.3104147315,
-0.7917321324,
0.8092796206,
0.1590099484,
-0.7767558098,
0.5176089406,
-0.2402393222,
-0.604024291,
0.0537322052,
-0.2073200345,
-0.4903815389,
0.3173634708,
-0.2149140239,
0.0768531263,
-0.3121941388,
0.0250335522,
-0.270975858,
-0.30197981,
0.2986084521,
-0.6756640077,
0.7563529015,
0.2294247001,
-0.4006674886,
-0.3181358278,
-0.8859707713,
-0.060343653,
0.2314684689,
-0.4745571315,
-0.4316829443,
0.0113859372,
0.0620798022,
0.0623647198,
-0.1954658777,
-0.6435912251,
-0.0527791083,
-1.0209521055,
0.4683631957,
0.4112227559,
-0.0455816537,
0.5203270316,
-0.5115070343,
0.7991763949,
-0.1349790096,
-0.1514277011,
-0.0510361865,
-0.6518007517,
-0.7650678158,
-0.0022182113,
0.1521772295,
0.2818353176,
-0.473742038,
0.1599157602,
-0.317014277,
-0.7254906893,
-0.6953040957,
0.1887962669,
0.2039344311,
-0.0763214082,
0.0864113197,
-0.484583348,
-0.5675730705,
-1.0034316778,
-0.638489902,
0.0416790359,
-0.0533584543,
0.0592105202,
0.6175816655,
-0.4767825007,
0.74608922,
-0.1112833247,
0.1719757617,
-0.6143081784,
0.3544237018,
0.0308089089,
0.6707904935,
0.7235758305,
-0.6777380109,
-0.162876904,
0.1275487393,
-0.1326577514,
0.285520941,
-0.1642655581,
0.0606700927,
0.3423114121,
0.0784520954,
-0.6252371669,
0.1635120213,
0.7037311196,
0.0025358004,
0.6269328594,
0.1664665788,
0.1516367942,
-1.0083783865,
0.0068873982,
-0.3509511948,
0.1298792064,
-0.7189037204,
0.0997586995,
-0.3918248117,
-0.13689816,
-0.3439745307,
0.5157717466,
-0.2878316343,
0.1264466792,
-0.1328896731,
-0.0348922201,
-0.1084646583,
0.0820382014,
-0.0892802477,
0.5902679563,
0.3583836257,
-0.5687546134,
0.1422723234,
0.0205473993,
-0.2950181365,
0.1013908386,
-0.397094965,
-0.0003490454,
-0.4508730471,
-0.1048917323,
-1.0170533657,
-0.2558333576,
-0.0278342739,
-0.5021877885,
0.371966958,
0.0140926111,
-0.2683002055,
-0.4683102667,
-0.3496559262,
0.5942665339,
0.4916111231,
-0.297085911,
0.2289178818,
0.1777008176,
-0.2460305393,
-0.4348184764,
-1.1580697298,
-0.0091622593,
-0.1736523658,
-0.5771406293,
0.3019978106,
-0.1564230025,
-0.2798898518,
-0.1342399269,
-0.1024832129,
-0.071381405,
0.521617949,
0.0179332122,
-0.2192303091,
-0.1645814478,
0.2884126902,
0.0667985603,
0.2178550363,
0.0037702236,
-0.4165018797,
0.7467964888,
-0.1030412391,
-0.1635844111,
-0.1737437099,
0.5418850183,
0.4283603132,
-0.2475290149,
1.1486635208,
0.4618605077,
-0.189199701,
-0.7794425488,
-0.2881124616,
-0.1871756017,
-0.4559466839,
0.752597928,
-0.0720875338,
-1.2254830599,
0.5024620295,
0.1970255822,
0.1997859627,
0.6816362739,
0.7903296351,
-0.1895015687,
0.9593546987,
0.8890112638,
0.407272011,
0.6511210799,
-0.6150726676,
0.2713243663,
-0.2867254615,
-0.3688174784,
-0.4520955682,
-0.2153888345,
-1.1587598324,
-0.1695066988,
-0.0735812336,
-0.1248910874,
-0.1104292497,
0.0496829934,
-0.477897495,
0.5016058087,
0.4424767792,
-0.1986699551,
0.2712439299,
0.0865912884,
0.1978950948,
-0.2119694054,
-0.892046392,
-0.2700025737,
1.0595718622,
0.339733094,
0.8314363956,
-0.0287427008,
0.9121412635,
0.0483238101,
0.2572015822,
-0.7675380111,
0.3552781641,
-0.5092524886,
-0.5653074384,
-0.3324055076,
-0.7203041315,
-1.2833334208,
0.1032122225,
-0.127117604,
-0.2246386111,
0.0445397347,
0.1533947438,
-0.132401064,
0.3696203232,
-0.5198034048,
0.8349871039,
-0.1654213518,
-0.1617429256,
-0.2321089059,
-0.3851553202,
0.5140960813,
-0.229706049,
0.2380127907,
0.0386073701,
0.1377896518,
0.7269650698,
-0.2148562074,
0.8153046966,
0.253247261,
-0.1960170418,
0.1383564919,
0.1660163701,
0.1669045389,
-0.0425535627,
0.0658436269,
0.0351692401,
-0.1607420295,
-0.5173112154,
-0.4445619285,
0.7056065202,
-0.8413078189,
-0.5371366143,
-0.2417714,
-0.8238602877,
-0.2130732834,
0.1152167544,
0.535646975,
0.28305915,
-0.3139458299,
0.4005977809,
0.3656343222,
-0.3902267814,
0.2693186402,
0.1494925618,
0.0014734996,
-0.4705120921,
0.9243125916,
0.3513410091,
0.8671422005,
0.0811604261,
0.1040547565,
-0.1427079737,
-0.9718498588,
0.0392234698,
0.1977543533,
-0.7037826777,
0.223902747,
-0.7292019129,
-0.2494734079,
-0.3749452829,
-0.1136361584,
-0.4778733253,
-0.7319143414,
-0.358058095,
-0.1950570494,
0.1734532714,
0.9790709615,
0.2129628956,
0.1829876453,
-0.6677634716,
0.0555934906,
0.2210188061,
0.442569226,
-0.1288648099,
-0.6543953419,
-0.3705203533,
0.2636608183,
-0.3421859741,
-0.5811237097,
0.4032967091,
0.4049760699,
0.6271438003,
-0.0400195606,
-0.2878590226,
0.1035653278,
-0.4339667261,
1.0674743652,
0.1945126504,
-0.5165577531,
0.4291954339,
-0.5538644791,
0.6833657026,
0.6475858688,
0.4375061691,
-0.6202032566,
-1.0907058716,
-0.6413292289,
-0.9330250621,
0.5097550154,
0.297865659,
0.7009335756,
-0.3438375592,
0.1426865011,
0.6241585612,
0.3072426617,
-0.8902208805,
-0.2893759012,
-0.2474864274,
-0.0778201222,
-0.1345411092,
-0.2376538664,
-0.0679181516,
-0.3673118353,
0.4906435907,
0.050832551,
-0.0111609763,
-0.1023570672,
-0.058995083,
0.0500744991,
0.4144523144,
0.5420808792,
0.5258942246,
0.2445178926,
0.1672486514,
0.220666036,
-0.4806336761,
0.1624746472,
-0.0028949035,
-0.4034096897,
0.2204810083,
0.4479030371,
0.8779222965,
0.3666123152,
-0.7402521968,
0.0292651542,
0.1727666557,
-0.3733114898,
-0.2390368432,
0.2550113201,
0.1767530441,
0.017843334,
0.0264033675,
0.4342937768,
0.136110723,
-0.8324179053,
0.2755713761,
0.3992073536,
0.009264267,
-0.2963521183,
0.606872499,
0.1540841907,
-0.4336131513,
0.5091419816,
-0.4316921234,
-0.4585001171,
0.628872335,
0.6369229555,
1.0541394949,
-0.2573317289,
0.1956112534,
0.3615001142,
0.5127696991,
-0.1410824507,
0.1069950834,
0.2405117452,
-0.7665566206,
-0.2182164639,
-0.7850934267,
-0.1309099942,
0.3027768433,
-0.3385426104,
0.0356755108,
-0.5365267396,
-0.3895144165,
-0.0728551149,
-0.2684437335,
-0.7791126966,
0.2165277004,
0.2831587195,
0.5278184414,
-0.7399230599,
0.5171753764,
0.5549713373,
-0.4399254024,
-0.4480946064,
0.0077674012,
-0.0828999132,
-0.3658728004,
0.8338384032,
0.3590864837,
-0.2317842245,
0.0502966978,
-0.395931989,
-0.8036693931,
0.6658396125,
0.3911373317,
-0.5764626265,
-0.0652445778,
0.6503555775,
0.9749214053,
-0.3091986775,
-0.0841820836,
0.8084488511,
0.0022137447,
-0.0643072277,
-0.9537620544,
-0.2868608832,
-0.4636670649,
0.3346913159,
0.2770642042,
-0.2803358734,
1.1051992178,
-0.1487794369,
-0.7302240729,
0.4547942877,
0.3918757439,
0.0361353457,
0.0367045626,
0.3863321543,
0.6562178135,
0.5904857516,
-0.1154364794,
1.2893779278,
-0.0576081686,
0.4257920086,
0.9001406431,
0.2245827913,
0.6468391418,
0.3821606934,
-0.290726155,
0.5142123699,
0.4752567708,
-0.1739106327,
0.4916859269,
0.4940932691,
-0.3646380901,
-0.0878365785,
-0.0957402587,
-0.2350771725,
0.3577460349,
0.2504866421,
-0.5086303353,
-0.248024255,
0.2563227117,
-0.2900858521,
0.4329708517,
0.0025800478,
0.5063471198,
0.0178379416,
-0.6423617005,
0.9579997063,
-0.1509221196,
0.8820100427,
-0.4846534431,
0.1180841029,
-0.4589294791,
0.0373138413,
-0.1058045402,
-0.7923304439,
0.4225567281,
-0.1449804455,
-0.3446540236,
-0.1511883885,
0.2169523239,
-0.9160425067,
-0.4834030271,
0.3180405498,
0.4948362112,
0.0010311131,
0.2704390585,
-0.4890919924,
0.0821011662,
0.0310036577,
-0.0824155733,
0.2073600292,
0.5366345644,
0.1362856627,
0.8030826449,
0.6362646222,
0.1006826609,
0.328358084,
0.352712661,
0.7806964517,
-0.6187227964,
-0.5383251905,
-0.8178502917,
0.5801349282,
-0.0273663942,
-0.6256393194,
0.6458590031,
0.5237568021,
1.4208461046,
-0.2525051534,
0.8669973016,
0.1487375647,
0.4638154209,
-0.4336338043,
0.7816538215,
-0.6577549577,
0.457844913,
0.0456273407,
-0.9205566049,
-0.2801047564,
0.075880006,
-0.2617918551,
0.3758060932,
0.6154799461,
0.7806853652,
0.0227406882,
0.0109831169,
0.2279752493,
0.279189676,
0.3150079548,
0.1939071864,
1.1675397158,
-0.1370526403,
0.4304419458,
-0.3942238688,
0.0637672395,
0.0077788038,
-0.3665094972,
-0.8412017226,
-0.6367846727,
-0.1152849793,
-0.034047313,
0.2546520829,
0.6730930209,
0.3464479148,
-0.9115732908,
-0.2201297432,
-0.4950846434,
-0.1599476486,
0.0262821317,
-0.2603309751,
-0.2133088857,
-0.6184878945,
-0.8214287162,
0.3422066867,
0.1119815856,
0.3356691599,
-0.3900781572,
-0.0456766747,
-0.0467893071,
-0.0085137207,
0.6558153629,
0.3699119687,
-0.8861578703,
-0.3033855557,
0.0358585194,
-0.2061329037,
-0.1196411327,
0.6932905912,
-0.645092845,
0.6969514489,
0.6270859838,
0.9322721958,
0.235977456,
-0.3340134621,
0.9754318595,
-0.8825110793,
0.3045313656,
0.597098887,
0.1546386629,
0.6232535839,
0.0755029842,
0.3816968799,
0.7521216273,
-0.2680295706,
-0.946993649,
0.4663250446,
-0.5270690918,
-0.3207522631,
1.0689272881,
0.2305513769,
-0.0043308893,
-0.2000680119,
-0.129772231,
0.1406556517,
-0.0208011214,
0.9719871283,
0.7174187303,
0.001176365,
-0.2002624571,
-0.6060064435,
0.7547947764,
0.8604307175,
-0.6760423183,
0.2100328356,
0.4318363667,
0.3605357707,
0.2349455357,
0.2360174954,
-0.0185435507,
0.3589415848,
0.2012088746,
-0.0219890792,
0.2796967328,
-0.3406293392,
-0.4573662579,
0.0571543425,
0.2454576492,
0.1288650632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09805v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09805v1
|
DocMath-Eval: Evaluating Numerical Reasoning Capabilities of LLMs in Understanding Long Documents with Tabular Data
| 2023-11-16T11:30:53 | 2023-11-16T11:30:53 |
Yilun Zhao, Yitao Long, Hongjun Liu, Linyong Nan, Lyuhao Chen, Ryo Kamoi, Yixin Liu, Xiangru Tang, Rui Zhang, Arman Cohan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent LLMs have demonstrated remarkable performance in solving exam-like
math word problems. However, the degree to which these numerical reasoning
skills are effective in real-world scenarios, particularly in expert domains,
is still largely unexplored. This paper introduces DocMath-Eval, a
comprehensive benchmark specifically designed to evaluate the numerical
reasoning and problem-solving capabilities of LLMs in the context of
understanding and analyzing financial documents containing both text and
tables. We evaluate a wide spectrum of 19 LLMs, including those specialized in
coding and finance. We also incorporate different prompting strategies (i.e.,
Chain-of-Thoughts and Program-of-Thoughts) to comprehensively assess the
capabilities and limitations of existing LLMs in DocMath-Eval. We found that,
although the current best-performing system (i.e., GPT-4), can perform well on
simple problems such as calculating the rate of increase in a financial metric
within a short document context, it significantly lags behind human experts in
more complex problems grounded in longer contexts. We believe DocMath-Eval can
be used as a valuable benchmark to evaluate LLMs' capabilities to solve
challenging numerical reasoning problems in expert domains. We will release the
benchmark and code at https://github.com/yale-nlp/DocMath-Eval.
|
[
-0.3319834471,
-1.0413990021,
0.8771077991,
0.3873366416,
-0.1686146408,
0.5588154793,
-0.2617615461,
-0.146300137,
-0.2367925644,
0.3675123155,
-0.3162884712,
-0.8445626497,
-0.4688498676,
0.3396648169,
-0.2884803712,
0.9045626521,
-0.3339518905,
0.2211804092,
-0.8434371948,
0.2410562783,
-0.2989698946,
-0.3087212443,
-0.7356984615,
-0.3543705344,
0.1600148529,
0.280883491,
0.4557300806,
0.3811070025,
1.1095561981,
0.3291105628,
0.0418253765,
0.2838447094,
-0.4053935707,
0.0961228907,
-0.1325782537,
-0.4624187052,
-0.7354496121,
0.0658454672,
0.7091449499,
0.5010393858,
-0.3948801756,
0.1016526297,
-0.1235642135,
0.8244722486,
-0.2978436947,
0.5547586083,
-0.5520521402,
-0.0115609439,
-0.1929737329,
-0.2996293306,
-0.3738130331,
-0.6032307744,
-0.0294109825,
-0.8237038255,
0.1124016047,
0.0682311282,
0.4684820771,
0.4416976869,
-0.2626325488,
-0.3958893716,
-0.3323830664,
0.4700316489,
-0.5226185322,
0.249087289,
0.3214533925,
0.3843798339,
-0.2421377152,
-0.8141838312,
-0.4112229347,
-0.3968358934,
0.1439400613,
0.3283549249,
-0.3088458478,
0.045708213,
0.6468276381,
0.1410420239,
-0.6159369946,
-0.0677906573,
-0.4798305035,
-0.0311866105,
0.6590675116,
0.2909667194,
-0.0748098567,
0.0627309605,
-0.4225204885,
-0.2459328026,
-0.3902387917,
-0.0379093364,
0.4368784726,
-0.1608378589,
-0.1266942024,
0.3719174862,
0.0625610352,
0.5633726716,
-0.2554633915,
-0.2403042763,
0.3317649961,
-0.1468572021,
-0.1191012561,
-0.0998030454,
0.4905748963,
0.3382426202,
0.53316921,
0.1181297675,
-0.4574643373,
0.0938962922,
0.4998994768,
-0.5167250633,
0.0357996859,
-0.0413160212,
-0.1467455626,
-0.3092291653,
-0.0121985832,
-0.8084350228,
-0.364089191,
-0.423702538,
0.2105793059,
-0.4381280839,
0.01161604,
0.1549963802,
-0.3232925534,
0.2495093793,
0.4969183207,
-0.5595524311,
0.8079419136,
1.2654309273,
0.6657488942,
-0.2788364887,
-0.2942894697,
-0.7234458923,
-0.1645989567,
-0.4874730408,
1.1433143616,
-0.7123115063,
-0.7648513317,
-0.153332293,
-0.5138955712,
-0.2312128544,
-0.7292664647,
0.9676342607,
-0.3944989741,
-0.2744414508,
-0.2050281465,
-0.7408419251,
-0.0365107618,
0.520773828,
-0.4083252847,
1.1599527597,
0.4918888807,
-0.5482347608,
0.1712046415,
-0.9296529293,
-0.1636758894,
0.3086959422,
-0.5095407367,
-0.2981821299,
0.0574399345,
0.0242278595,
0.177702114,
-0.7534856796,
0.4201901257,
-0.2912515402,
-0.4361951947,
0.4552602172,
-0.7084763646,
0.0697784647,
0.1306741983,
-0.1742314994,
-0.0546139628,
-0.8441260457,
0.2219389826,
0.0961688831,
-0.2957316041,
-0.2458916903,
-0.1447167546,
-0.1560083777,
-0.0193522107,
0.3494061828,
-0.2605995834,
0.3025057018,
-0.1468104124,
0.3684068918,
0.8136706352,
-0.105652079,
0.1143220738,
-0.3672716618,
0.8263489604,
-0.3033746183,
-0.1855848432,
-0.0606694669,
-0.3017546535,
-0.2642835975,
-0.234568879,
0.3692995012,
0.6536863446,
-0.5726442337,
0.0101062395,
-0.2207395881,
-0.5071681142,
-0.3219414055,
0.1680565476,
0.6013284922,
0.8784074187,
0.3560638726,
-0.1447380334,
-0.0971115455,
-1.0176124573,
-0.4538742304,
-0.2253976762,
-0.1032941192,
0.5655337572,
0.6937980056,
-0.0346254259,
0.7497300506,
-0.7600243092,
-0.0282287728,
-0.0129930265,
0.4375633597,
0.4095635116,
0.2227575779,
0.3701818883,
-0.6557759643,
-0.5854908228,
0.04746655,
-0.7622159123,
-0.5272590518,
-0.2616824508,
0.0397425666,
0.1526853293,
0.4969447553,
-0.5708550811,
0.3719859421,
0.1466471106,
-0.5211769342,
0.8083420396,
-0.7340838313,
0.0190800801,
-0.4001896977,
0.2143934965,
0.303876847,
-0.0728995949,
-0.4274111688,
0.1372065097,
0.4287976623,
-0.0700037777,
-0.1514319032,
0.7222160101,
-0.4628204107,
-0.4182072282,
-0.0085015818,
0.2927822769,
0.0974630266,
0.279474318,
-0.0047372086,
1.1814266443,
0.339922905,
-0.0540818572,
0.3257961571,
0.161344409,
-0.343067646,
1.0183566809,
-0.4509713054,
0.1643670946,
0.0222269502,
0.2747522295,
-0.7820007801,
0.1543678343,
-0.0974764302,
-0.1852036715,
0.4376125038,
0.1039177254,
-0.4449770153,
-0.5046310425,
-0.3337396383,
0.2865941823,
0.3743515909,
-0.1595434994,
0.7737944722,
0.0446178764,
-0.4981411099,
-0.5263264179,
-0.3040001988,
0.3424046636,
-0.2556072772,
-0.6289525628,
0.3600511849,
-0.2732000947,
-0.8105210066,
-0.1723619252,
-0.4424592555,
-0.0827966928,
0.2237491906,
0.015848441,
0.5148541331,
-0.1606519371,
-0.0118953036,
0.0007179661,
-0.6139135361,
0.5069288015,
-0.1630144566,
0.2897557616,
-0.6089430451,
-0.4570487738,
0.0481437556,
0.1225681528,
0.5381245017,
-0.3125522733,
0.1800070852,
0.3271384239,
-0.1817929894,
-0.2166215032,
-0.7952179909,
0.1940688938,
-0.5055878162,
0.3072506487,
-0.6495454907,
-0.416336149,
0.4858219028,
-0.3912065029,
-0.1221799701,
0.7532723546,
0.5084891319,
-0.0405559838,
0.4779118598,
0.1771203578,
0.1014450267,
-0.1328260005,
-0.4200175703,
0.0035879714,
-0.8566710949,
-0.4745976925,
-0.5990300179,
-0.0550952367,
-0.2529787421,
-0.8163718581,
0.5596483946,
-0.0250527654,
-0.058145348,
0.0130863255,
-0.4467090666,
0.7213079929,
0.2304764092,
-0.1614571959,
0.3061621785,
-0.2328675538,
-0.5843515992,
-0.1243314072,
-0.2947511673,
-0.5455461144,
1.1952054501,
0.4211377203,
0.8661162853,
-0.2205854356,
0.6235616803,
0.6278838515,
0.559918642,
-0.671865046,
0.6908761263,
-0.1539473385,
-0.0653219968,
-0.3025612533,
-0.7461360693,
-0.6543479562,
0.1875487566,
0.1067299917,
-0.5169653296,
-0.2520537972,
-0.3564026952,
-0.2485411018,
0.1370645761,
-0.5760520697,
0.7765631676,
-0.6763259172,
-0.4279847741,
-0.3459093869,
-0.2364925444,
0.1665201485,
-0.70996207,
0.5264138579,
-0.2484208345,
-0.5622950792,
0.759236753,
-0.5114793777,
0.3749864995,
-0.1175805777,
-0.3151164949,
0.1862249821,
0.1863014102,
0.513014853,
0.2474416643,
-0.3841965795,
0.2302431464,
0.1551839709,
-0.2494809926,
-0.6948003769,
0.6081823707,
-0.5132984519,
-0.7506890297,
-0.6107792854,
-0.5467924476,
-0.3950707316,
0.1786241978,
-0.2395368069,
0.5297654867,
-0.2291044742,
0.0727006495,
0.4689409733,
0.0172089394,
0.2436744273,
0.7773561478,
-0.0631469935,
-0.5390558839,
0.9049845934,
0.1523066163,
-0.0816164985,
0.3358900249,
0.3434363902,
-0.5976614952,
-0.7105558515,
-0.3465222716,
0.2425197214,
-0.9170595407,
-0.204555437,
-0.4772249162,
-0.1894244403,
0.0298613049,
-0.4161678553,
-0.0330210663,
-0.2693220079,
-0.1686672866,
-0.2474551499,
0.2928139269,
0.6748617887,
-0.1436810941,
-0.3049276173,
-0.7576246858,
0.3941529393,
0.3077024519,
0.6234405041,
-0.0769306868,
-0.347787261,
-0.0592383407,
-0.3269503117,
-0.269855082,
-0.6702145338,
0.3341133296,
-0.016428519,
0.8119824529,
0.4506581128,
-0.0225673858,
0.5295910835,
-0.4305758476,
0.3938142359,
0.225574553,
-0.8213530183,
0.2192611694,
-0.5605764985,
0.3147411346,
0.7493075728,
0.3111108541,
-0.4089556932,
-0.3698558211,
-0.6990773082,
-0.6796606183,
0.4281994402,
0.2594666481,
-0.1766049415,
-0.1046060249,
0.4512487352,
0.2702314556,
0.3120549619,
-0.0201173685,
-0.090695262,
0.2250864208,
-0.1393687874,
-0.0529230125,
-0.2546395659,
-0.0963710546,
-0.3832480013,
0.3249443769,
-0.2371656448,
0.1348538399,
0.145032227,
0.1298434585,
-0.0101847826,
0.2602622211,
0.8812717199,
1.1498126984,
-0.3613363206,
0.0275892746,
0.480607599,
-0.7145571113,
-0.0460926518,
0.6172956824,
0.1410560161,
-0.1086350083,
0.3916510046,
0.3522237539,
0.5509037375,
-0.9083516002,
0.378017962,
-0.3401622176,
-0.7052125931,
-0.4522661269,
0.0667554438,
0.1910406947,
0.1975147724,
0.6845828295,
0.0448979735,
0.1202358231,
-0.4225860834,
0.3011905253,
0.3491829336,
-0.1088128164,
0.0203981847,
0.5808080435,
0.2693947256,
-0.6625874043,
0.6211768985,
-0.1710566431,
-0.6089423299,
1.1493167877,
0.5323018432,
0.8164091706,
0.2202179134,
0.1992653608,
0.1468276531,
0.1039495468,
0.0349150896,
0.4923068583,
-0.2605053782,
-0.3815351427,
-0.2474946082,
-0.6136919856,
-0.9077492952,
-0.0577103458,
-0.6329450011,
0.090433754,
-0.5259193778,
-0.2065437436,
0.241210416,
0.409031868,
-0.8289747238,
0.0751235634,
0.109772861,
1.3909047842,
-0.3217020035,
0.4711802304,
0.5108572841,
-0.0418813415,
-0.5650361776,
-0.3544245958,
0.2199673057,
-0.9438015223,
0.62870574,
0.1212921664,
-0.1002565473,
0.009215299,
-0.2369000018,
-0.4915167689,
0.9705463052,
0.2342652977,
-0.7711117268,
0.0087665962,
0.3008926511,
0.6979449391,
-0.2843684852,
0.6686552167,
0.8756791353,
0.9531285167,
-0.0226481073,
-0.8922433257,
-0.1054785475,
-0.5444758534,
-0.2676767409,
0.2312950343,
-0.6688115597,
0.6911379099,
-0.1912527233,
0.105464831,
-0.1426597536,
0.2381356061,
0.4185205698,
0.8673462272,
0.3571840823,
0.6027639508,
1.0472797155,
-0.2675564587,
1.1140159369,
-0.5507280827,
0.2052962035,
0.8082011342,
-0.4831508696,
0.8592543602,
0.3051066995,
-0.5728892684,
0.3446266353,
0.4956824183,
-0.3808650672,
0.0687091202,
0.6580746174,
-0.2598568201,
-0.3133070469,
0.081145145,
-0.573368609,
0.2450986356,
0.5711032152,
-0.0385955349,
-0.3476012945,
-0.390930593,
-0.0937297419,
0.250890106,
-0.2523488998,
0.6824339032,
0.4983487129,
-0.6472167969,
0.3215983808,
0.0868984014,
0.3465395272,
-0.8067750931,
-0.2045207024,
-0.3252173066,
0.0724915564,
-0.0593824275,
-1.0174764395,
0.2069789469,
0.3429403603,
0.1108199805,
-0.3694233298,
0.8086807728,
-0.0234773718,
-0.6632300615,
0.2296355367,
0.680583179,
0.2942775786,
-0.0319409259,
-0.7333752513,
-0.1493814737,
-0.335842967,
-0.2265274972,
0.4066780806,
0.4412612021,
-0.0388836786,
0.7746875882,
0.9313930869,
0.0208921582,
-0.4567433,
0.2961256504,
0.8651628494,
-0.803227365,
-0.5264166594,
-0.9041971564,
0.139224574,
-0.0953246281,
-0.3887082934,
0.6163148284,
0.8523148894,
0.5484833717,
0.0674327388,
0.6072663665,
0.541596055,
0.183017686,
-0.5033941269,
0.5882229805,
-0.4328790903,
0.5145008564,
-0.3384994566,
-0.9575508833,
-0.1142225862,
0.4764578938,
-0.696788311,
-0.0374426506,
0.9300119877,
0.3682462871,
0.2490883023,
0.1774488091,
0.4250150323,
-0.0051756799,
0.2384790033,
0.3922098577,
0.8403841257,
0.1471789032,
0.6221931577,
-0.0656554028,
-0.154873088,
-0.0996949673,
-0.9946748614,
-0.6211449504,
-0.161813572,
-0.2923162878,
-0.1385553032,
0.005476329,
0.7118499279,
-0.0065013743,
-0.2618130744,
-0.2611422539,
-0.0064194696,
0.2757695913,
-0.2331553996,
-0.2272490263,
0.4755055606,
-0.292126894,
-0.4526010156,
0.504278481,
0.688108325,
-0.0842454582,
-0.2833408415,
-0.1449919641,
0.3089393973,
0.3108261526,
0.3316721916,
0.0777677745,
-0.427803427,
0.0964485481,
0.086215198,
-0.2315868288,
0.1959091276,
0.9459247589,
-0.591493845,
0.4657624066,
0.5134697556,
0.7656241655,
0.6824974418,
0.34110111,
0.4319683611,
-0.1280160099,
-0.4029088318,
0.3715920746,
0.4070560634,
-0.0224116147,
-0.206526041,
0.9617149234,
0.2644456923,
-0.5558577776,
-0.7012493014,
-0.3993399739,
-0.9997199774,
-0.1620305181,
1.0499596596,
-0.1583047956,
-0.2743696272,
-0.065093942,
-0.2572428882,
-0.236475274,
-0.6639766097,
0.8063982725,
0.7678799033,
-0.0550173521,
-0.0155906156,
-0.8154829741,
0.3077724278,
0.2902782261,
-1.1413705349,
-0.0298176575,
0.3458103538,
0.2002421916,
0.0477765426,
0.9221636653,
-0.0590251125,
0.449963659,
0.380328089,
-0.3568890393,
-0.4904816449,
-0.1528257132,
-0.2703979313,
0.1918126792,
-0.0857519805,
0.4211737812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09802v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09802v1
|
Neuro-Symbolic Integration Brings Causal and Reliable Reasoning Proofs
| 2023-11-16T11:26:21 | 2023-11-16T11:26:21 |
Sen Yang, Xin Li, Leyang Cui, Lidong Bing, Wai Lam
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Though prompting LLMs with various reasoning structures produces reasoning
proofs along with answers, these proofs are not ensured to be causal and
reliable due to the inherent defects of LLMs. Tracking such deficiencies, we
present a neuro-symbolic integration method, in which a neural LLM is used to
represent the knowledge of the problem while an LLM-free symbolic solver is
adopted to do deliberative reasoning using the knowledge. Specifically, our
customized meta-interpreters allow the production of reasoning proofs and
support flexible search strategies. These reasoning proofs are ensured to be
causal and reliable because of the deterministic executing nature of the
symbolic solvers. Empirically, on ProofWriter, our method surpasses the CoT
baseline by nearly double in accuracy and more than triple in proof similarity.
On GSM8K, our method also shows accuracy improvements and nearly doubled proof
similarity. Our code is released at https://github.com/DAMO-NLP-SG/CaRing
|
[
0.0163723212,
-0.6416484714,
1.0568897724,
0.6635330915,
-0.2925536036,
-0.191436708,
-0.1777685434,
-0.5274912715,
0.3915865421,
0.2095675617,
-0.5105230808,
-0.5928952098,
-0.6238006949,
0.2145272493,
-0.1825574338,
0.4501901269,
0.0063623972,
0.462079525,
-0.3259861767,
0.1175248176,
-0.5815967917,
-0.5026358366,
-0.7880762815,
-0.5335336328,
0.6194521189,
-0.1987440437,
0.2865666151,
0.5394812822,
0.4985038936,
0.2661403716,
-0.371324122,
0.581807375,
-0.0379283763,
0.1477883905,
-0.260742873,
-0.7862538099,
-0.4685935676,
-0.0311082955,
0.3650868535,
0.3306857944,
-0.2980781794,
-0.0913309902,
0.0382893234,
0.3013147712,
-0.7529967427,
0.4753682315,
-0.6075814366,
0.1994008124,
0.1700833142,
-0.4230563641,
-0.6980813146,
-0.6894581914,
-0.2768730521,
-0.6193195581,
-0.2928542793,
-0.4316620529,
0.5360380411,
0.7981395125,
-0.5728013515,
-0.1256910712,
-0.8243990541,
0.7929603457,
-0.9247408509,
0.1328066885,
0.2610048652,
0.5663439035,
-0.4950198233,
-0.5641779304,
-0.5086324215,
-0.3601059616,
-0.2959813774,
0.1193876565,
-0.2203694433,
0.1740479767,
0.3992297649,
-0.1536106467,
-0.2894328833,
0.0147800343,
-0.0599225722,
-0.334790498,
0.6941357255,
0.3441304862,
0.5847186446,
-0.0580089949,
-0.0872552171,
0.282263875,
-0.7163503766,
-0.4305909872,
0.1628145725,
0.1260607243,
-0.0237590186,
0.5885534883,
-0.0588298142,
0.620905757,
0.0011961908,
-0.120154798,
0.1377206296,
-0.2429543287,
-0.0666103736,
0.2529399991,
0.8904425502,
0.3017291725,
0.4641500413,
-0.2285142243,
-0.1268997192,
0.2870233059,
0.2245648354,
-0.5652336478,
0.0339060202,
0.3707612455,
-0.3792042732,
-0.2582337558,
-0.435009867,
-0.2922517657,
-0.3111014366,
-0.5856714249,
0.4593406022,
-0.7015190721,
-0.1917467415,
0.3395944238,
-0.2010262311,
0.1573154181,
0.5892266631,
-0.7793673873,
0.144087553,
0.8033115268,
0.809687078,
0.0585594438,
-0.1605007648,
-0.6660906076,
0.2919609547,
-0.4764817357,
0.872390449,
-0.1933109015,
-0.015643198,
-0.0558581054,
-0.2171879709,
-0.1069856286,
-0.3414471149,
0.5185510516,
-0.6309679151,
0.0046211756,
-0.401065588,
-0.2922519445,
-0.3957707584,
0.4842208028,
-0.5847720504,
0.7589164972,
-0.0198658127,
-0.5465657115,
0.1953432113,
-0.7231271863,
-0.3243494928,
-0.1059344336,
-0.326228708,
0.0215039905,
0.1657589972,
0.2940011322,
0.2147508711,
-0.2832736373,
0.5782369971,
-0.5033604503,
-0.4615279138,
0.3215432763,
-0.3427217007,
1.1030615568,
-0.0701474473,
-0.4895446002,
0.2338160276,
-0.5379363298,
0.089524135,
0.1701934636,
0.0303268265,
-0.388387233,
0.0910828412,
-0.291949898,
0.5389283299,
0.5138006806,
-0.6306300759,
0.1989369541,
-0.4174846113,
0.5436354876,
0.7936886549,
0.0125725539,
0.2840706706,
-0.0682356283,
0.3125365674,
0.2753207684,
0.3378380239,
0.1626809537,
-0.4354924858,
-0.5449767709,
-0.1845948696,
0.19883129,
0.6035051346,
-0.6534149647,
0.5627177358,
-0.1442420632,
-0.3980229199,
-0.2038301528,
-0.2083554268,
0.3249153793,
0.6217744946,
0.6560854912,
0.1905770153,
-0.5270466805,
-0.8394759893,
-0.2738871872,
-0.2397392988,
-0.0709863827,
0.2485629469,
0.4251954556,
-0.4742749333,
0.7483971119,
-0.3463368118,
-0.2408747226,
0.0004036038,
0.0338085778,
0.5173587203,
0.6055101752,
0.4485878944,
-0.1773583889,
-0.2057641596,
0.1159479842,
-1.3457331657,
-0.3915410042,
-0.1695866585,
-0.4341997206,
0.3626905084,
0.4716845155,
-0.8542746305,
0.4432197213,
0.3171884418,
-0.2992827296,
0.7371803522,
-0.3390369713,
0.0166856013,
-1.0720801353,
0.0420950502,
-0.0161191281,
-0.0639438704,
-0.3272467554,
-0.1367260963,
0.1194189936,
0.2884643972,
-0.4337116778,
0.4540616572,
-0.3991210759,
0.2268920094,
-0.298506707,
0.2759663165,
-0.3250112236,
0.3305712342,
-0.119804129,
0.5811111331,
0.4920186698,
-0.5418239236,
0.3215423226,
0.2763539255,
0.1454429477,
0.60906142,
-0.9476793408,
0.1181270406,
-0.165217936,
0.333121717,
-0.5105160475,
0.1227153316,
0.4701007605,
-0.2339606732,
0.1576997787,
-0.1042683646,
-0.7418354154,
-0.1257106066,
-0.1189315617,
0.4270499647,
0.2274650037,
-0.7006016374,
1.0871677399,
0.1489460766,
0.2575477362,
-0.8822386861,
-0.8778476715,
0.2283417135,
0.0045727612,
-0.7553914785,
0.4184455872,
0.1460256875,
-0.1343615055,
0.1902091801,
-0.3121364415,
0.1223306581,
0.0369099341,
0.1140230596,
0.3445163667,
-0.2468622476,
0.0425067879,
0.7027776241,
-0.6812329888,
0.5984371305,
-0.4022493362,
0.4615399539,
-0.1689277589,
-0.8117100596,
-0.6733602881,
0.4567739367,
0.6410778761,
-0.0668401867,
0.5726960301,
0.4429779351,
-0.6303433776,
-0.4170675576,
-0.5324305296,
-0.3792726099,
-0.4227386713,
0.0087433495,
-0.1934952289,
-0.7904964685,
0.5794315338,
-0.1242329478,
0.0241103135,
0.4900890887,
0.3002792001,
-0.0875103101,
1.2509582043,
0.3553646803,
0.2419592291,
0.1144102439,
-0.1454633027,
0.4224610031,
-0.9769081473,
-0.6467111111,
-0.3906104863,
-0.6068531275,
-0.5175914168,
-0.3599689007,
0.3416816294,
0.0800539404,
-0.4284210205,
0.4398225546,
-0.7859918475,
0.3946012557,
0.6001399159,
0.5353829861,
0.4090858102,
-0.2269752622,
-0.220482856,
-0.1903553605,
-0.5471684337,
-0.5371550918,
0.8166444898,
-0.0232491158,
0.8207938075,
0.1641219109,
0.8647984266,
-0.0102081494,
0.6460655332,
-0.8505400419,
0.8688918352,
-0.1378853768,
-0.3098033369,
-0.0164094642,
-0.5504529476,
-0.6772071123,
0.1945588738,
0.0416765139,
-0.9947040677,
0.3430637717,
0.1728897244,
-0.1984688789,
0.1454832852,
-0.4976625443,
0.7205659151,
-0.4642985761,
-0.1948482692,
-0.4946484268,
-0.501401484,
0.5203403234,
0.115688771,
-0.4377168417,
-0.1917849481,
-0.0344185606,
0.5949814916,
-0.4579484463,
0.9095001817,
-0.1383125782,
-0.0110017424,
0.0916504264,
0.3232594132,
0.4193880856,
0.2640290856,
-0.1278971136,
0.5896248221,
0.0208694562,
-0.0462879539,
-1.0584354401,
0.8364003301,
-0.5395286083,
-0.8941361904,
-0.6290577054,
-0.7541466355,
-0.1040232778,
0.3027139008,
-0.1384579688,
0.0780884549,
0.0711858198,
-0.0721102133,
0.5841284394,
-0.0931027755,
0.4900125861,
0.3683393896,
-0.2047338635,
-0.630249083,
0.4875934124,
-0.0053151068,
-0.0783998147,
0.3719237149,
0.3136781454,
-0.4154953361,
-0.3106382191,
-0.2240496576,
0.593480885,
-0.7589533925,
-0.3933738172,
-0.8560574651,
-0.406996876,
0.0035114901,
-0.1082877964,
-0.2574805915,
-0.3892655373,
-0.2065930516,
-0.0227999948,
0.3677097857,
0.5015391707,
-0.3281961381,
0.1321333051,
-0.865739882,
0.3247526288,
0.2843906283,
0.1864497215,
0.020197114,
-0.1378722787,
-0.1057534143,
0.187192142,
-0.3324445188,
-1.1219500303,
0.3184902966,
-0.3136406541,
0.7353984714,
0.3883845508,
-0.226528734,
0.6793426275,
-0.4090434909,
0.4736464024,
0.2510641515,
-1.1759608984,
0.7483488321,
-0.2109682858,
0.1759364307,
0.4011992216,
0.3767528832,
-0.3980478346,
-0.3403993547,
-0.5167272091,
-0.5460003018,
0.536190331,
0.0882317051,
-0.1745800078,
-0.2475009859,
0.491061002,
-0.371869415,
-0.1193588153,
-0.3917461038,
-0.2405722141,
0.0913774967,
-0.2545762062,
0.329428345,
-0.2636734545,
-0.3389910161,
-0.3234259188,
0.7097505331,
-0.2167831212,
0.4948363602,
0.2855974734,
-0.0638830662,
0.1494730711,
-0.0784231946,
0.7186636329,
0.4869033694,
0.034543395,
0.3700673878,
0.2640555799,
-0.3972979188,
0.1790671945,
0.0295282323,
-0.3128480017,
0.3775878251,
0.2774637341,
0.2895466089,
0.2841062248,
-0.3849839866,
0.2660508156,
-0.1759358048,
-0.1628492177,
-0.2342845649,
0.1034558862,
0.5434544683,
0.449398011,
0.0384473726,
0.1650197804,
0.1797285229,
0.0471754335,
0.0972229317,
0.6233536601,
-0.296987772,
-0.2659056485,
0.8713985085,
0.0329166986,
-0.4272869825,
0.8875953555,
-0.0020967524,
-0.5756831765,
0.8654778004,
0.910464406,
1.3287466764,
-0.211735785,
0.2375222296,
0.5112476349,
0.6112191677,
-0.1742653102,
0.6122666001,
-0.0501019284,
-0.7146241665,
-1.1369541883,
-0.369556427,
-0.4998579025,
-0.1863040775,
-0.3122542799,
0.3736950457,
-0.4514729977,
-0.292991966,
-0.2762972414,
-0.4033295214,
-0.3966515362,
-0.0707902834,
-0.0087000057,
1.2297317982,
-0.8129514456,
0.5888054371,
0.4559558928,
-0.4017479718,
-0.938460052,
-0.181071192,
0.0087324334,
-0.69466573,
0.9599353671,
0.270008415,
-0.4254660308,
-0.3264748156,
-0.6336867809,
-0.8277435303,
1.1212992668,
0.9718714952,
-0.3494093418,
0.1167752221,
0.0877155885,
0.6945633292,
-0.1693151146,
0.472649157,
0.2704865932,
0.6701847315,
-0.1674246192,
-0.8109288812,
0.5259526372,
-0.2918919921,
0.0600479729,
0.3433912098,
-0.4503345191,
0.2976040244,
-0.3562784493,
-0.1642960757,
-0.3057616353,
0.7210199833,
0.6725270748,
0.4291309714,
0.3834750652,
0.690440774,
0.7615537047,
-0.3062484562,
0.8623581529,
-0.5711100698,
0.1911394596,
1.1572639942,
-0.0943284631,
0.4835317731,
0.7579394579,
0.0099465866,
0.6651521325,
0.2743211985,
0.2713814378,
0.3878434896,
0.2652651966,
-0.5999807715,
-0.5101069212,
-0.2175768912,
-0.3259369731,
0.2540316284,
0.3443589509,
-0.3959365189,
-0.3685561121,
-0.5850430131,
0.0466110073,
-0.0397726707,
0.0857447535,
0.5527805686,
0.5266848803,
-0.631238997,
0.3714154661,
-0.1496262699,
0.6287979484,
-0.6488921642,
-0.3530493081,
-0.1200049669,
0.0791110024,
-0.4399001896,
-0.664422214,
0.7933059931,
-0.3547577262,
-0.084218666,
-0.2069969028,
0.7297170162,
-0.2207581699,
-0.2470031828,
0.4898331463,
0.6193116903,
-0.0227926765,
-0.0937266722,
-0.3822401762,
-0.1307252198,
-0.3026485741,
-0.0225365963,
0.074844107,
0.5537525415,
-0.1149425432,
0.8427625299,
0.9454174638,
0.0649610385,
-0.117330417,
0.2379978001,
0.7553412914,
-0.7265235186,
-0.352856636,
-1.2787940502,
0.3673384786,
-0.3122261763,
-0.298602879,
0.5843862295,
0.3457356989,
0.4173481166,
-0.1456425935,
0.4507440627,
0.099729307,
-0.3866398036,
-0.3680761158,
0.8008952737,
-0.3162888587,
0.2601106465,
-0.0388444364,
-0.8750892282,
-0.8020810485,
0.7580322623,
-0.4509841502,
0.0204817653,
1.1705913544,
0.8989689946,
-0.0853919685,
0.144270435,
0.1129489318,
0.1167553365,
0.3776674271,
0.9469460249,
0.9822049141,
-0.4020070434,
0.2375835776,
-0.3049246371,
-0.2821582556,
-0.0451845862,
-1.3018553257,
-0.7097581029,
-0.2070496231,
-0.4710465968,
-0.6182245612,
0.0242518373,
0.6612606049,
0.6779729128,
-0.5472588539,
-0.0062501724,
-0.3487759531,
0.6185660958,
-0.7495671511,
-0.2368419468,
0.3780842125,
-0.5107040405,
-0.6376593113,
0.4257941842,
0.6417461038,
-0.4837608039,
-0.2321110964,
-0.1084275544,
-0.0863369927,
0.1763770878,
0.6776204705,
0.1210221276,
-0.5966948271,
-0.2594535947,
0.2113043368,
-0.3735123277,
-0.0213126615,
0.7838694453,
-0.7208501101,
0.1943014264,
0.7393024564,
0.7635451555,
0.4045547247,
-0.4637664258,
0.6570199132,
-0.1269450039,
-0.131918177,
0.4222654998,
0.655272305,
0.0436901525,
-0.6421812773,
0.5992001891,
0.2805644572,
-0.5402572751,
-0.772013247,
0.2565713525,
-1.4347758293,
0.0973113403,
1.0997501612,
-0.0102159027,
-0.4740945697,
0.0122235874,
-0.007934846,
0.457696408,
-0.1960306317,
1.0612959862,
0.3748478889,
-0.3669170439,
-0.1094605774,
-0.2408872098,
0.0430995487,
0.5868242383,
-1.0792402029,
-0.3095577061,
0.3374685645,
0.2089120895,
0.3769934475,
0.5083478093,
-0.4866155982,
0.5281493068,
0.0211632587,
0.272328347,
-0.3745566607,
-0.0974850953,
-0.4084354341,
0.0267904699,
-0.2823590338,
-0.2341037393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09800v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09800v2
|
$\textit{Dial BeInfo for Faithfulness}$: Improving Factuality of Information-Seeking Dialogue via Behavioural Fine-Tuning
| 2023-11-16T11:25:44 | 2024-03-04T14:35:59 |
Evgeniia Razumovskaia, Ivan Vulić, Pavle Marković, Tomasz Cichy, Qian Zheng, Tsung-Hsien Wen, Paweł Budzianowski
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Factuality is a crucial requirement in information seeking dialogue: the
system should respond to the user's queries so that the responses are
meaningful and aligned with the knowledge provided to the system. However, most
modern large language models suffer from hallucinations, that is, they generate
responses not supported by or contradicting the knowledge source. To mitigate
the issue and increase faithfulness of information-seeking dialogue systems, we
introduce BeInfo, a simple yet effective method that applies behavioural tuning
to aid information-seeking dialogue. Relying on three standard datasets, we
show that models tuned with BeInfo} become considerably more faithful to the
knowledge source both for datasets and domains seen during BeInfo-tuning, as
well as on unseen domains, when applied in a zero-shot manner. In addition, we
show that the models with 3B parameters (e.g., Flan-T5) tuned with BeInfo
demonstrate strong performance on data from real `production' conversations and
outperform GPT4 when tuned on a limited amount of such realistic in-domain
dialogues.
|
[
-0.3924084902,
-0.7463071346,
0.4088845551,
0.285230577,
-0.5562025309,
-0.2614093125,
-0.2170237452,
-0.5135956407,
-0.0448034108,
0.7224841118,
-0.8159988523,
-0.1873246878,
-0.3131321967,
0.0992128253,
-0.3995189667,
1.2148500681,
0.4419475198,
0.3013598025,
0.0906215459,
-0.0936344564,
-0.5298546553,
-0.3177292645,
-0.7398920059,
-0.3669222295,
0.6291671395,
0.4433732629,
1.209554553,
0.5330280066,
0.6434239745,
0.1444464326,
0.1028153971,
0.6478725672,
-1.0450456142,
0.3215743005,
-0.5031110048,
-0.7698694468,
-0.0606042817,
0.0381747261,
0.4202633798,
0.5110626817,
-0.2259864956,
0.0089728003,
0.1266388148,
0.6056295633,
-0.3891260624,
0.346973151,
-0.9145829678,
-0.0886323303,
-0.1809588224,
-0.6263355017,
-0.4642543495,
-0.4506517649,
0.2764868438,
-0.8058641553,
0.5675479174,
0.4768092036,
1.2365586758,
0.2568946481,
-0.1451859325,
-0.336280942,
-1.0506527424,
0.5629496574,
-0.7522747517,
0.7216060758,
0.7136210203,
0.0714554265,
-0.4498538971,
-0.4544338584,
-0.6071986556,
-0.138289392,
0.0095174825,
0.1865498424,
0.1348084211,
0.1691458672,
0.3486815095,
0.4549074471,
-0.3663518429,
-0.4444959462,
-0.2543379366,
-0.4346809387,
0.3528334796,
0.2138415724,
-0.13718009,
0.0449609794,
-0.0550082996,
-0.0865403339,
-0.8078045845,
-0.2012892216,
0.6154110432,
0.4585741758,
0.1328657568,
0.4726066589,
-0.274995476,
0.9379259348,
0.5485136509,
-0.1401139796,
-0.1934467107,
-0.6897104383,
-0.1771260053,
-0.001930094,
0.4181730449,
0.6508111954,
0.3529074788,
-0.3579971194,
-0.2391587049,
-0.1573474705,
0.5830468535,
-1.0890697241,
-0.4400915205,
0.135130614,
-0.1779928207,
-0.1209071428,
0.1998360902,
-0.6807665229,
-0.1327954978,
-0.5002028346,
0.3676124215,
-0.7749785781,
-0.2750745416,
0.1337883025,
-0.1576448679,
0.3224282265,
0.4425295889,
-0.9379707575,
0.0564623661,
0.7169079185,
0.8690683246,
0.1698045582,
-0.0225792266,
-1.0371156931,
0.2958177626,
-0.6307768226,
0.6929967999,
-0.7083913684,
-0.4844229221,
0.0686689541,
0.0504183918,
0.0431681499,
-0.8195426464,
0.7737639546,
-0.7145985365,
0.0810615867,
-0.5789855719,
-0.2732827067,
-0.222662434,
0.3042082787,
-0.4958391786,
0.8422911167,
0.1240941286,
-0.4573841393,
0.5678982139,
-0.674471736,
-0.4575049877,
-0.1041765362,
0.091622971,
-0.1387685984,
0.3441975117,
-0.0756026208,
0.2839969099,
-0.3037549555,
0.312130779,
-0.5135974288,
-0.4839101732,
0.3592566848,
-0.6814428568,
0.3126403093,
0.2875237167,
-0.3739431202,
-0.4280014634,
-0.5338511467,
-0.0090018455,
-0.0922894627,
-0.3019875288,
-0.2632162571,
0.1486474574,
-0.1718619019,
0.0524662472,
0.006096967,
-0.5012876987,
0.0150048789,
-0.8565465808,
0.0095218932,
0.5489747524,
0.0524806455,
0.1174586639,
-0.6696164012,
-0.0257292893,
0.4865276814,
0.2660059929,
-0.0983577445,
-0.395160079,
-1.0257874727,
0.0825032368,
0.3706253469,
0.4629383385,
-0.8723910451,
0.1386843622,
-0.232777968,
-0.2070629597,
-0.6656830311,
0.2611679435,
0.3926003873,
0.6796849966,
0.1825312078,
-0.4092529416,
-0.2945179641,
-0.8972853422,
-0.37044397,
-0.3091789186,
-0.0014408572,
0.6255308986,
0.1076458171,
-0.1124113426,
0.7775948048,
-0.3145991564,
-0.2130278647,
0.0569687299,
0.3979750574,
0.3344401717,
0.2811567485,
0.4486015737,
-1.1205042601,
-0.4686704278,
0.1374317855,
-0.6988036036,
-0.0070517468,
0.0020357631,
-0.4241628945,
0.3153349757,
0.0690791756,
-0.6024737358,
0.4860337079,
0.2981715798,
-0.0941476822,
0.3851983249,
0.0129888281,
0.3652788997,
-0.8524919748,
0.0649258569,
0.0067947414,
-0.5368821025,
-0.6911048889,
-0.0201797821,
-0.051576294,
0.0285311807,
-0.283638835,
0.3657245636,
-0.3111337125,
0.2541798949,
-0.3970344365,
0.4263554811,
0.1019303575,
0.58622998,
-0.0470649637,
1.0369672775,
0.4445220828,
-1.1061439514,
0.3507609069,
0.5984903574,
-0.3301830888,
0.9937009215,
-0.3845550716,
0.1861513257,
-0.2231221646,
-0.0093642948,
-0.7348051667,
-0.5188432336,
0.3044102192,
-0.409291476,
0.3697330356,
-0.3145872951,
-0.5117601156,
-0.0842801183,
-0.0266067199,
0.2083590925,
0.1254525632,
-0.5951011181,
0.5302287936,
0.159040615,
-0.1471265852,
-0.4106912315,
-0.3770748377,
0.1775521189,
-0.004146405,
-0.7908760309,
0.3096381128,
-0.3950052261,
-0.1851449758,
-0.3275328875,
-0.3886077404,
-0.0637189373,
-0.1153825969,
0.0004232292,
0.3322881758,
-0.3303079605,
-0.0201828256,
-0.1475737542,
-0.0324073061,
0.0085410438,
-0.5060364008,
0.5688792467,
-0.1092634797,
-0.3470084369,
-0.4384581447,
0.2450627834,
0.5589991212,
-0.0059432359,
0.6839379668,
0.5046822429,
-0.2120587826,
-0.1120154485,
-0.8379318118,
-0.6318969727,
-0.5210729241,
0.1306255013,
-0.3570367396,
-0.7196187377,
0.1918878555,
-0.2252472639,
0.1482402086,
0.0827348381,
0.3497452736,
-0.1944747418,
1.2359825373,
0.7247770429,
0.0170247871,
0.4929590523,
0.0579016432,
0.5273572803,
-0.6993921399,
-0.2506580055,
-0.5318002701,
0.0308772642,
-0.3400307,
-0.1526806802,
0.6001176238,
0.0107815834,
-0.1075725183,
0.1395172477,
-0.2050383091,
0.3804704845,
0.6100597978,
0.3592464328,
0.3850539327,
0.1273999065,
-0.2517187297,
-0.2470825315,
-0.7012975216,
-0.4212454855,
0.7526674867,
-0.0421107411,
0.8772404194,
0.2109159827,
0.0912537649,
0.2328062952,
0.1315985769,
-0.7727505565,
0.3407607377,
0.0241992492,
-1.0419721603,
-0.2339654863,
-0.5419197679,
-0.6771503091,
0.0026080329,
-0.1218580678,
-0.8715531826,
0.2379657179,
0.4491420388,
-0.5038092136,
0.1481530219,
-0.4345563352,
0.4741829634,
-0.2102826089,
-0.8341524005,
-0.2517012656,
-0.5852496624,
0.2138611525,
-0.1108138785,
-0.0746958554,
-0.1306801885,
0.5726306438,
0.3433966041,
-0.3156453967,
0.7690934539,
-0.1774470955,
-0.2608907521,
0.1703549773,
0.4688105583,
0.8161916733,
0.4223135114,
-0.3378579021,
0.1544418633,
0.2834164798,
-0.2705340981,
-0.8685615659,
0.5178787708,
-0.4854208529,
-0.9519416094,
-0.2636178732,
-0.4510664046,
-0.6222596169,
0.2687536478,
0.3639576137,
0.7490251064,
-0.3026480675,
0.5259468555,
1.2003061771,
0.177395016,
0.0356430113,
0.7711672783,
-0.2462205887,
-0.134372741,
0.9311232567,
-0.0015974678,
0.3864432573,
0.4612376392,
-0.0315043442,
-0.4643886685,
-0.3116674721,
-0.557564497,
0.2192424983,
-0.4212173223,
-0.4451822937,
-0.5822907686,
-0.4047747254,
-0.2913846672,
0.2791613936,
-0.3903431594,
-0.1294061542,
-0.3884933889,
-0.0658566579,
0.2991327941,
0.439394176,
-0.1979023665,
0.4744063318,
-0.8402189612,
0.6064547896,
0.1034953818,
0.6876710653,
-0.355228126,
-0.8745394945,
-0.4714716971,
0.8037381172,
-0.4702097476,
-0.7345015407,
0.2667586803,
0.4528360963,
0.5049902797,
0.7507280111,
0.1656810641,
0.8623725176,
-0.25629583,
0.6029165387,
-0.0545096397,
-0.8227703571,
0.6709327698,
-0.625697732,
0.0180453062,
0.7981944084,
0.4178540111,
-0.5821855068,
-0.410629034,
-0.3521977663,
-0.4373915792,
1.1115562916,
0.5547657609,
0.2734164894,
0.0800012946,
0.5877293944,
0.2098799944,
0.5390389562,
-0.5281367302,
-0.2428486794,
-0.5452904105,
-0.0960990265,
0.1953264177,
-0.1299309433,
-0.4882263839,
-0.1445739865,
1.1707628965,
-0.4269851446,
0.4820901453,
0.3894250691,
0.1715836525,
-0.4380432069,
-0.1203746125,
0.4844608307,
0.5247091651,
-0.3690465093,
-0.140331015,
-0.0766527951,
-0.5110455751,
-0.0793849304,
-0.1116274223,
-0.4497625828,
0.1370059252,
-0.3463094532,
1.0834542513,
0.1658168286,
-0.4094121158,
0.3868287206,
-0.165083617,
-0.2021754831,
-0.1000958085,
0.6785728931,
-0.1768452972,
0.2359755933,
0.2231269628,
0.2943739891,
0.290520519,
-0.8151932359,
0.1282035261,
0.6376803517,
-0.7805715203,
-0.3451590538,
0.5757061839,
0.1618039012,
-0.5365491509,
0.8072810173,
-0.1340510994,
-0.3236675262,
0.1240156665,
0.775587976,
0.7872644067,
-0.0827029869,
0.5112876296,
0.2608237863,
0.311763227,
-0.3027823567,
0.2860398889,
-0.0965499282,
-0.99008286,
-0.1336997747,
-0.6325006485,
-0.6638547778,
0.4016548991,
-0.6188192964,
0.1614726484,
-0.3881819546,
-0.4054671824,
-0.0760823265,
-0.1197316647,
-0.6944835782,
0.3851719201,
-0.1333102584,
0.858039856,
-0.0792221501,
0.6742907763,
0.2783444822,
-0.2823784351,
-0.6989652514,
0.4601358175,
-0.0696901157,
-0.5657171011,
0.2789833248,
0.1105401739,
-0.4647438824,
-0.0207314026,
-1.0220075846,
-0.9765104055,
0.7115296721,
0.7032376528,
-0.5699219704,
0.0583954677,
0.362827152,
0.3956510127,
-0.1830445528,
0.2086939514,
0.6503263712,
0.7390105724,
0.2328532487,
-0.9161132574,
-0.2320477962,
-0.3551517725,
-0.284920007,
0.1211615652,
-1.1120285988,
0.1712078303,
0.036507912,
-0.3639715314,
0.2363855392,
0.6113998294,
0.0499269851,
0.3323755562,
0.398195982,
0.0210720766,
1.0001013279,
-0.5273747444,
0.7695974112,
-0.6788406372,
0.0503058657,
1.0278815031,
-0.499297142,
0.4465795755,
0.3905856609,
0.1996329278,
0.4210763872,
0.5539220572,
-0.0117656365,
0.6433967948,
-0.2130093724,
-0.3166597784,
-0.583899796,
-0.3306025565,
-0.0632776022,
0.3966278732,
0.649443388,
-0.020254517,
-0.07877969,
-0.1834476441,
-0.0854796618,
-0.0726362541,
-0.0732961074,
0.8461575508,
0.0425712615,
-1.1326555014,
0.7437878251,
0.0343780033,
0.305488795,
-0.8347989917,
-0.0336604528,
-0.5643322468,
0.0232678428,
-0.1110302806,
-0.4348675311,
0.3335747421,
-0.1779658943,
-0.2924878299,
0.1735338718,
0.7442432046,
-0.3488323092,
-0.3055320382,
0.244245708,
0.3107754886,
0.0575416796,
-0.2686183453,
-0.5064607859,
-0.3012147248,
0.2398106456,
-0.0331281759,
-0.0183816496,
0.8222458959,
0.1895630509,
0.8266465068,
0.8393955827,
0.0690445751,
-0.0658636838,
-0.0037236344,
0.8453814387,
-0.7021702528,
-0.3177884519,
-0.5378110409,
0.1315101385,
-0.2333320826,
-0.3281884193,
0.631076932,
0.6757467985,
0.9436392188,
0.0150289349,
0.8418644667,
0.1893073022,
0.5436474085,
-0.6931999922,
0.4011049867,
-0.5479280353,
0.1496278048,
-0.1939668506,
-1.058047533,
-0.0229555536,
0.7380969524,
-0.0710679591,
0.0947711915,
0.5775252581,
1.3942697048,
-0.5008350611,
0.6133652925,
0.6287202835,
0.4173181355,
0.1014441028,
0.1077231243,
1.0010194778,
-0.4462408423,
0.6157746911,
-0.0671840534,
-0.0977751091,
-0.4713914692,
-0.6723462939,
-0.8913025856,
-0.5377194881,
-0.018374864,
-0.5274325609,
0.5095204711,
0.8818347454,
0.974976182,
-0.8329470158,
-0.0304056332,
-0.0431993455,
-0.0997085497,
-0.1736077964,
-0.248210907,
-0.334592253,
-0.5041739345,
-0.864736855,
0.4205620587,
0.6109216809,
0.1196505427,
-0.1289312989,
0.0071445457,
-0.0188387781,
0.7858678699,
0.3797943592,
0.2142782658,
-0.5247452259,
-0.4901532233,
0.1672124863,
0.002674517,
0.3922832906,
0.8409478664,
-0.444145292,
0.4843375683,
0.0491055548,
0.4270432293,
0.7995129824,
0.2259045392,
0.9355416298,
-0.6982393265,
-0.0086460933,
0.095703803,
0.1089035124,
0.536573112,
-0.7364823222,
0.5503074527,
0.2226322591,
-0.5212293267,
-0.6244652271,
0.3420487046,
-0.8687348962,
0.0774943903,
1.127603054,
-0.0176865719,
-0.1554059833,
-0.6018704176,
-0.5510621667,
0.398801595,
-0.6357654929,
1.1901874542,
0.8552165031,
-0.0209117346,
0.2532733381,
-0.577863276,
0.7721779943,
0.5980611444,
-0.4338803589,
0.324955672,
0.5872541666,
0.1286598891,
0.2463730723,
0.4942206144,
-0.0267621707,
0.2985547483,
-0.1471062154,
-0.5825581551,
0.176192075,
-0.6539711356,
0.3308634162,
-0.0162863601,
0.0092270123,
0.2697644234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09799v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09799v2
|
How Far Can We Extract Diverse Perspectives from Large Language Models?
| 2023-11-16T11:23:38 | 2024-02-18T09:50:59 |
Shirley Anugrah Hayati, Minhwa Lee, Dheeraj Rajagopal, Dongyeop Kang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Collecting diverse human opinions is costly and challenging. This leads to a
recent trend in collaborative efforts between humans and Large Language Models
(LLMs) for generating diverse data, offering potential scalable and efficient
solutions. However, the extent of LLMs' capability to generate diverse
perspectives on subjective topics remains an unexplored question. In this
study, we investigate LLMs' capacity for generating diverse perspectives and
rationales on subjective topics, such as social norms and argumentative texts.
We formulate a new problem of maximum diversity extraction from LLMs. Motivated
by how humans develop their opinions through their values, we propose a
criteria-based prompting technique to ground diverse opinions. To see how far
we can extract diverse perspectives from LLMs, or called diversity coverage, we
employ a step-by-step recall prompting for generating more outputs from the
model in an iterative manner. As we apply our methods to various tasks, indeed
we find that LLMs can generate diverse opinions according to the degree of task
subjectivity
|
[
-0.827287972,
-0.4993190169,
0.678144753,
0.1782027334,
-0.2276061624,
0.1162190437,
-0.4056997001,
-0.2644004822,
-0.0577034764,
0.5635482073,
-0.5598899126,
-0.5664556026,
-0.7724339962,
0.2397893965,
-0.177012071,
1.1251249313,
0.2552312613,
-0.2144228816,
0.0085753137,
-0.2487217784,
-0.46067366,
-0.6014631987,
-0.2921721041,
-0.1948991418,
0.8766838312,
0.7775349021,
0.4514400363,
0.0461044237,
0.0053217686,
0.3098308444,
-0.3777738512,
0.3515460491,
-0.4502197206,
0.2808186412,
-0.355710566,
-0.458771646,
0.0465797372,
0.2772184908,
0.6388036013,
0.9021509886,
-0.0087138163,
0.0398962796,
0.1507904381,
0.7103930712,
-0.4054912329,
-0.3494791389,
-1.0050677061,
0.0854808018,
-0.0714334548,
0.0452881344,
-0.4112469852,
-0.4370931089,
0.2292032093,
-0.1044934914,
0.1628744304,
-0.3018030822,
0.6407088041,
-0.2048952729,
-0.7125604153,
-0.2086830437,
-0.7222220898,
1.074401021,
-0.7095133662,
0.1439692229,
0.1322922558,
0.1581286341,
0.1276087165,
-0.0216197278,
-0.6494324803,
-0.2396600842,
0.3330957294,
-0.0196638722,
-0.1656399816,
-0.298427403,
0.2808522582,
0.3349123299,
-0.0374145657,
0.0635645986,
-0.4224565029,
-0.039271567,
0.7651444077,
0.159572199,
0.2132651657,
-0.4692368805,
-0.0574417375,
0.1148784757,
-0.651914537,
0.3063677251,
0.6125331521,
0.297301054,
-0.0536813401,
0.6705774665,
-0.3924518228,
0.5855308771,
0.1255409569,
-0.2564827204,
0.2828094959,
-0.1918201745,
-0.2709132731,
-0.4512192905,
0.6601790786,
0.4208038449,
0.2139840871,
-0.0655216128,
-0.1624653041,
-0.1981411725,
0.2781565487,
-0.6618686318,
0.2117058784,
0.2299153209,
-0.5063579082,
-0.4813629687,
-0.0546883196,
-0.9193876982,
-0.7779608369,
-0.3883707821,
-0.0531254523,
-0.1766082793,
-0.507437408,
0.1192431599,
-0.1676055193,
0.3825982809,
0.6252676845,
-0.7212389708,
0.0206200574,
0.5285786986,
0.555303812,
-0.4518754184,
-0.1456944197,
-0.4229593575,
-0.1400319189,
-0.2326216847,
0.8018651605,
-0.6678250432,
-0.5347365737,
-0.0568584688,
-0.1982881725,
0.4390141666,
-0.611454308,
0.3840665519,
-0.375811547,
0.2041655332,
-0.8307511806,
-0.3859915435,
-0.2326250374,
0.5532244444,
-0.5700672269,
0.6716846228,
0.0422695316,
-0.8285167813,
0.4757579565,
-0.2691208422,
-0.4053965807,
0.1097394302,
-0.4928894043,
-0.1849519908,
0.2390746325,
0.2671809494,
0.4922671914,
-0.5200579762,
0.4949194491,
-0.5653855205,
0.1808823198,
0.5304833651,
-0.3809024096,
0.8848294616,
0.2691678703,
-0.4255547822,
0.1998474896,
-0.5246851444,
-0.280284822,
0.0452294871,
-0.6437395811,
-0.3012046218,
-0.0380865969,
-0.106460087,
0.3033217192,
-0.0362285376,
-0.6522194743,
0.0228585042,
-0.3397965133,
0.4113344252,
1.0204834938,
0.0271904636,
0.5532870293,
-0.4681477249,
0.4764876962,
0.2261860073,
-0.2273394763,
-0.0528681278,
-0.5705419183,
-0.6143880486,
-0.23256661,
-0.0796476826,
0.265129596,
-0.4108968675,
0.5169076324,
-0.0174925067,
-0.4659603834,
-0.3892919421,
0.4924005568,
0.0486260988,
0.4672518075,
0.0230422635,
-0.2390683144,
-0.4734613001,
-0.9646165371,
-0.4165370464,
-0.0559610762,
-0.033811979,
0.6563752294,
0.3653994799,
-0.166865319,
1.031390667,
-0.3115445673,
0.1041046232,
-0.5940161347,
0.094605431,
0.3538951278,
0.2418318093,
0.3179680109,
-0.8342502713,
-0.3759773374,
-0.0797397494,
-0.5777582526,
-0.1601536572,
-0.2098606229,
-0.3354644179,
0.1215698719,
0.1530939043,
-0.5735274553,
0.0049313153,
0.4629552662,
-0.206791684,
0.4890919328,
0.2145029455,
0.1464051306,
-1.1343345642,
0.0091022355,
0.2261675447,
-0.1893496811,
-0.4585660398,
0.0133995228,
-0.2953053117,
0.0059642368,
-0.3796580732,
0.567369163,
-0.5087358356,
0.0119761294,
-0.2899802625,
0.1632743478,
0.0922747925,
0.3754270971,
0.0975085646,
0.4133282006,
0.4485923648,
-0.5942286849,
0.2550944388,
0.136448279,
-0.3619526029,
0.5147646666,
-0.495164752,
0.1945208162,
-0.3719871044,
0.2919733226,
-1.0059952736,
-0.3776752353,
0.1015246436,
-0.2555462122,
-0.0613055937,
-0.0803765878,
-0.102641575,
-0.3010534048,
-0.3834167719,
0.340046376,
0.6165023446,
-0.5213623643,
0.6657447815,
0.8710625172,
-0.5961180925,
-0.6100227833,
-0.5883613229,
0.1436156332,
-0.381927073,
-0.5889467597,
0.0153999636,
-0.2245074362,
-0.6544451118,
-0.2502396107,
-0.0391109698,
0.1002734676,
0.1646942049,
0.2441276461,
0.2146972418,
-0.0035189958,
0.055895593,
0.1912326664,
0.3117412329,
0.1296521574,
-0.2292046398,
0.5213520527,
-0.177384302,
-0.4416132271,
0.129204765,
0.777639091,
0.453802824,
-0.2004656196,
0.413125664,
0.0851602182,
-0.3597556949,
-0.4864138961,
-0.8990699053,
-0.008394043,
-0.4618752301,
0.4702593386,
-0.2661764622,
-1.199690938,
0.5099526644,
0.2352502644,
0.4675423801,
0.3670168221,
1.1416940689,
0.0268152393,
0.8983181119,
0.3459763825,
-0.1451136023,
0.4517436624,
0.0241397526,
-0.0615833141,
-0.6571552157,
-0.3379455209,
-0.6223000884,
-0.3176921308,
-0.3462073505,
-0.4888526797,
0.1764814556,
-0.1031553671,
-0.1520135254,
-0.3592082262,
-0.5616409779,
0.5497684479,
0.529424727,
0.2745185494,
0.3080694377,
0.3071070015,
-0.1298241913,
-0.0718128234,
-0.2925229967,
-0.6371425986,
1.0197367668,
0.3386003077,
0.5134615302,
0.0691094026,
0.8817980886,
0.1964007169,
0.7678996921,
-1.0051138401,
0.5925880075,
-0.1467385143,
-0.7093315125,
-0.3498689234,
-0.5420995951,
-0.7394306064,
0.5349287987,
-0.1066612303,
-0.634599328,
0.2232869714,
-0.0801847875,
-0.2633954883,
0.475749433,
-0.3154653013,
0.4240916073,
0.0020352933,
-0.2432623208,
-0.2728008628,
-0.6037401557,
0.688672781,
-0.0566940047,
0.2858022749,
-0.3533600569,
0.1409765035,
0.7052285671,
-0.0538584143,
1.0429011583,
-0.254044801,
-0.4670247734,
0.4871328473,
0.1024719551,
0.0491356328,
0.2313074917,
-0.3396342993,
0.0907598957,
-0.607010603,
-0.4020565748,
-0.2037451416,
0.5980813503,
-0.8542224169,
-1.0429934263,
-0.2506144345,
-0.8294162154,
-0.4749521613,
0.1594632417,
0.1884949058,
0.1220991313,
-0.236988768,
0.2174803764,
0.663215518,
-0.4922685325,
0.3522443473,
0.2974660993,
-0.0837821886,
-0.4560208917,
0.7340336442,
-0.0010582386,
0.2860985994,
0.0587042235,
0.3481439948,
-0.1844264865,
-0.6564930081,
-0.3728883266,
0.1360207796,
-0.971046865,
-0.0697600767,
-0.8864665627,
-0.0130419796,
-0.1878590733,
-0.2602386177,
-0.0427150913,
-0.2817011476,
-0.1961336434,
-0.2398568392,
0.215885058,
0.7467529178,
-0.0049258987,
-0.0162454322,
-1.0554947853,
0.2989944816,
0.6517189145,
0.0142269889,
0.1425819993,
-0.4356547594,
0.1496194899,
0.0764841065,
-0.4256822765,
-1.072807312,
0.3579750061,
-0.2039531767,
0.6925496459,
0.2414728254,
-0.0518268906,
0.274086535,
-0.246286884,
0.944699347,
0.315641135,
-0.9789757729,
0.3558728397,
-0.339787364,
0.4109275937,
0.6469970942,
0.3170476854,
-0.6241534948,
-0.7907316685,
-0.4729191065,
-0.7211619616,
0.5664873719,
-0.040544387,
0.5185367465,
-0.0681016073,
0.1548860669,
0.5615060329,
0.2515586913,
-0.8355342746,
0.1576842219,
-0.204306066,
-0.0868304148,
-0.0311213471,
-0.3047713041,
-0.3443143666,
-0.1813402325,
0.2786436379,
-0.2418269962,
-0.123971574,
0.2734356523,
-0.0729997382,
-0.0527811572,
0.7293539643,
0.4450023174,
0.6119120121,
0.1789239198,
0.3391990066,
0.2197667211,
-0.1273840368,
0.2088980824,
-0.1694509387,
-0.3542813063,
-0.0599551275,
0.1382243186,
0.8112727404,
-0.2711011767,
-0.7220722437,
0.441760242,
-0.0407033749,
-0.2736849487,
0.0702513307,
0.000118292,
0.4128748477,
0.3184298873,
0.3503965437,
0.185909912,
0.127078563,
-0.6266007423,
0.1601061225,
0.6416838169,
-0.1841024756,
-0.266672194,
0.4260063767,
0.3828251362,
-0.1201086417,
0.3331934214,
-0.1484831721,
-0.5905319452,
0.7892497182,
0.2949571013,
0.9744339585,
-0.0181094892,
0.4713581204,
0.3403261006,
0.1341012269,
0.0184128508,
0.4231151938,
-0.1360442042,
-0.9685919881,
-0.4600557983,
-0.6896175742,
-0.511649847,
0.0954701602,
-0.4120016694,
0.1236434951,
-0.5279205441,
-0.0841591507,
0.1210932285,
-0.1495880187,
-0.5208112001,
0.2264152467,
0.5667234659,
0.7508960962,
-0.7655411363,
0.5906327963,
0.5632023811,
-0.347892046,
-0.9596976042,
0.1828043908,
0.0794612393,
-0.6343650818,
0.7244070768,
0.2879139185,
-0.2017186433,
-0.3649410605,
-0.816744566,
-0.3656210005,
0.5355696678,
0.429046452,
-0.6976981163,
0.0422768258,
0.0708347112,
0.2531603277,
-0.610390842,
0.1215155199,
0.4479458332,
0.4460426569,
0.2522314191,
-0.478574127,
0.2274167091,
-0.3762427866,
-0.0453216694,
-0.2557772994,
-0.4989249706,
1.0670126677,
-0.4866032004,
0.0405560248,
-0.111112766,
0.6797907352,
0.7251247764,
0.0962295905,
0.9095070362,
0.0898005143,
0.8581011295,
0.340074867,
1.1000300646,
-0.0356012583,
0.1803562343,
0.8812891841,
-0.4379026592,
0.5076872706,
0.4752741158,
-0.0387162007,
0.4486249685,
0.6162602305,
-0.0158446208,
0.2694498599,
0.2898400426,
-0.4201021492,
-0.6266723275,
-0.1769808829,
-0.1510940641,
0.2015602887,
0.1326760948,
-0.317374289,
-0.1840820611,
-0.0326735638,
0.0374146923,
0.0378052704,
-0.2675543725,
0.7436349392,
0.2842657268,
-1.0262937546,
0.4850435555,
0.1033778861,
0.8046976924,
-0.4316876829,
0.037403781,
-0.335047394,
-0.1343687177,
-0.2586333752,
-1.0685687065,
0.058658503,
0.2909569144,
-0.3501734138,
-0.2368505597,
0.7085000277,
-0.4307846725,
-0.4328063726,
0.1432536244,
0.6803299189,
-0.0888865441,
-0.0429037251,
-0.3955896199,
-0.0027526687,
0.4570104778,
-0.5249282122,
0.35610044,
0.6165552735,
-0.0818119571,
0.4676392972,
0.7213007808,
0.2287586033,
0.1428869516,
0.1616663337,
1.0667322874,
-0.7181503773,
-0.4256864488,
-1.0446746349,
0.7227191329,
-0.3695460856,
-0.4181304872,
0.6101876497,
0.2964476943,
0.6683325768,
-0.0486505292,
1.2596436739,
-0.0226700082,
0.4680613875,
-0.217753306,
0.4805243015,
-0.7225713134,
0.3528954685,
-0.2817285359,
-0.8048468828,
-0.1052422896,
0.5473812819,
-0.2707759142,
0.0652043521,
0.4287537336,
0.6747054458,
0.0811511651,
0.3013725877,
0.2198799253,
0.2612003684,
0.5672338009,
0.5834732652,
1.1144349575,
0.4165162444,
0.5149827003,
0.0217994526,
-0.428894788,
0.0215918217,
-0.8264423609,
-1.0463935137,
-0.3828482926,
-0.0599774607,
-0.5321837068,
-0.4161563516,
1.0782585144,
0.5959233642,
-0.8759323359,
-0.3455351591,
-0.1215423644,
0.3699014187,
0.2529967725,
-0.1967403144,
-0.1028766036,
-0.3418682218,
-0.960062027,
0.212499693,
0.1971943229,
-0.2490248084,
-0.5753524899,
-0.0218656491,
0.0382588431,
0.2989260256,
0.6247153282,
0.1740140319,
-0.7818453908,
-0.3037422895,
0.0478311144,
-0.3353899419,
0.273242414,
1.023722887,
-0.4848798811,
0.301992774,
0.6294717193,
0.8674923778,
0.4478738606,
-0.0881062448,
0.7759085894,
-0.6249569058,
0.095674105,
0.4631664157,
0.3988907635,
0.5422695279,
-0.1752106696,
0.0208107457,
0.2323605716,
-0.3475878537,
-0.7735042572,
0.6368052959,
-1.0943309069,
-0.5361308455,
1.6075150967,
-0.0738013387,
-0.0076232366,
-0.1141547784,
-0.5639238358,
-0.0147415278,
-0.545766294,
0.8604964018,
0.9025130272,
0.0546705984,
-0.1748179495,
-0.2351229936,
0.210452199,
0.6026363969,
-1.0975363255,
0.2137605101,
0.6749457121,
0.565032959,
0.084085986,
0.8300415874,
-0.2327938676,
0.032535851,
-0.2376401722,
-0.0382196046,
0.3290883601,
-0.2144866586,
-0.3022044897,
0.52070117,
0.2478849292,
0.3643857241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09797v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09797v1
|
KnowledgeMath: Knowledge-Intensive Math Word Problem Solving in Finance Domains
| 2023-11-16T11:22:08 | 2023-11-16T11:22:08 |
Yilun Zhao, Hongjun Liu, Yitao Long, Rui Zhang, Chen Zhao, Arman Cohan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce KnowledgeMath, a novel benchmark designed to evaluate LLMs'
capabilities in applying financial knowledge to solve complex math word
problems. Compared to prior works, this study features three core advancements.
First, KnowledgeMath includes 1,259 problems with a hybrid of textual and
tabular content and require college-level knowledge in the finance domain for
effective resolution. Second, we provide expert-annotated, detailed solution
references in Python program format, ensuring a high-quality benchmark for LLM
assessment. Finally, we evaluate a wide spectrum of 14 LLMs with different
prompting strategies like Chain-of-Thoughts and Program-of-Thoughts. The
current best-performing system (i.e., GPT-4 with Program-of-Thoughts) achieves
only 45.4% accuracy, leaving substantial room for improvement. While
knowledge-augmented LLMs can improve the performance (e.g., from 23.9% to 32.0%
for GPT-3.5), it is still significantly lower the estimated human expert
performance of 94%. We believe that KnowledgeMath can facilitate future
research on domain-specific knowledge retrieval and augmentation into the math
word problem-solving process. We will release the benchmark and code at
https://github.com/yale-nlp/KnowledgeMath.
|
[
-0.0630381778,
-0.8018363714,
0.4482469857,
0.4051820934,
0.1406155229,
0.5895957351,
-0.1960121393,
-0.3631355762,
-0.0221795328,
0.245618701,
-0.4255093038,
-0.5612415671,
-0.7177798748,
-0.0898050144,
-0.1220919639,
0.6212912202,
-0.2630352378,
0.2526677251,
-0.9390442371,
-0.0328536443,
-0.5335456729,
-0.3823471367,
-0.5590494275,
-0.4772892892,
0.1194121167,
0.2791604996,
0.5554706454,
0.4244413972,
1.129475832,
0.3123512268,
0.1022780836,
0.1170699075,
-0.4243733883,
0.1057398915,
-0.08481244,
-0.425768435,
-0.6838291287,
0.2614574134,
0.3061817288,
0.9415521622,
-0.4603065252,
0.1740955859,
-0.1307256371,
0.9865714312,
-0.7348351479,
0.5943260193,
-0.6612251997,
-0.1007401794,
-0.3056665063,
-0.2025551796,
0.1004392728,
-0.517036736,
0.4139369726,
-1.0832816362,
-0.114650324,
0.2208087444,
0.3327245414,
0.4922450483,
-0.1472951025,
-0.3627682328,
-0.329166919,
0.7630941868,
-0.5282530189,
0.1290574074,
0.2645786405,
0.5682354569,
-0.1586543918,
-0.562710762,
-0.3751651049,
-0.0335700177,
0.4223807454,
0.3612252772,
-0.413056314,
-0.0233903732,
0.5278161168,
0.5460981131,
-0.3751426339,
-0.1748612076,
-0.3630184531,
-0.37168172,
0.6204835773,
0.3425325751,
-0.0205884557,
0.2904346883,
-0.386370182,
-0.1873285174,
-0.6229786873,
-0.0821430013,
0.4435292482,
-0.1164586991,
0.1451299042,
0.7077093124,
-0.2632635832,
0.6411249638,
-0.5065293908,
-0.3487444222,
0.2828045189,
-0.0481955372,
-0.0721161366,
-0.1631383598,
0.3680754304,
0.4496778548,
0.5173603296,
0.0011314451,
-0.374061197,
0.1366910189,
0.1626232862,
-0.4918010831,
-0.3311914504,
-0.0794399008,
0.0658279657,
-0.2181127816,
-0.2204529494,
-0.5346229076,
-0.5809320807,
-0.4631863832,
0.7962303758,
-0.6038483977,
0.0069075935,
0.4171925485,
-0.3962145746,
0.2036150247,
0.5144960284,
-0.4684501886,
0.5584221482,
1.0594847202,
0.5435723066,
-0.473611474,
-0.1783517748,
-0.3685022593,
0.0039355634,
-0.267935127,
0.9168971181,
-0.5470817685,
-0.3200237751,
-0.0000090052,
-0.9477169514,
-0.1546004564,
-1.0885486603,
0.4020087421,
-0.5519433022,
0.047904525,
-0.3966259062,
-1.12496984,
-0.2139168233,
0.5289832354,
-0.4380697906,
1.0716286898,
0.4701356888,
-0.7299970984,
0.164572075,
-1.0001028776,
-0.1347054541,
0.3682303429,
-0.1834707111,
-0.0762795582,
-0.0456414111,
0.0055558411,
0.1640307605,
-0.5294061303,
0.2673533857,
-0.3587400615,
-0.3140848577,
0.3953351676,
-0.3053410649,
0.2008136511,
0.0721901134,
-0.1642231047,
-0.1144133434,
-0.8470984697,
-0.0321861617,
0.3144281209,
0.0327603407,
-0.5090103745,
-0.0579462536,
-0.1606080383,
-0.1008741558,
0.7503695488,
-0.4404345751,
0.0466864258,
-0.0788295567,
0.2478196323,
0.8785249591,
-0.1591805667,
0.1714908034,
-0.707175374,
0.6567285657,
0.0095047923,
-0.159932211,
-0.050178986,
-0.5180801749,
-0.5651801229,
-0.0253431052,
0.1760956496,
0.7405293584,
-0.5496269464,
0.0327996016,
0.0222414639,
-0.4920513034,
-0.2780978382,
0.2476887405,
0.394513309,
0.8144058585,
0.5840753317,
-0.1301643401,
-0.2411351651,
-0.9354054332,
-0.8552657366,
-0.0246511307,
0.1115727499,
0.3950384855,
0.4850227535,
0.0834879428,
1.1242654324,
-1.0770149231,
-0.4141228795,
-0.0112010138,
0.2495497614,
0.3390281498,
0.3181712031,
0.3315705061,
-0.5455874205,
-0.3417904079,
-0.076414071,
-0.5926864743,
-0.257709235,
0.1870207638,
-0.0005803421,
-0.1265868843,
0.3565474153,
-0.4327282608,
0.3218809366,
0.342225045,
-0.3894194365,
0.7973086238,
-0.2579761147,
-0.208929494,
-1.007923007,
0.1787678301,
0.1588651091,
0.0540896617,
-0.2546687722,
0.0766254887,
0.135227561,
-0.107084699,
-0.1061173007,
0.6455873847,
-0.2033126205,
-0.3320442438,
-0.1567137986,
0.3855780661,
-0.1676211506,
0.4922638535,
-0.3035632968,
1.1998755932,
0.4367052317,
-0.3529056311,
0.6474087834,
0.1833803505,
-0.6072250009,
0.8395346999,
-0.5949139595,
-0.0314964689,
0.117276296,
-0.0702092946,
-0.7439181209,
0.058263272,
-0.1123584062,
-0.3041203618,
0.0416315049,
0.4765741527,
-0.487490654,
-0.3621698618,
-0.3126358092,
0.6479918361,
0.4112594426,
-0.0483077131,
0.4925279915,
0.3840284646,
-0.324939549,
-0.6458036304,
-0.2157555073,
0.0603064336,
-0.1231415495,
-0.5926141143,
0.5076147914,
-0.4625928402,
-0.7164869308,
-0.0000356546,
-0.5739626884,
0.0055129016,
0.325938195,
-0.1259045452,
0.470464617,
-0.0524465181,
0.0780106485,
-0.1495901048,
-0.5093119144,
0.5085625052,
-0.4798388183,
0.369472146,
-0.2525728047,
-0.455021143,
0.0072239023,
0.0292936098,
0.3670791984,
-0.2413890362,
0.1621575654,
0.3858563006,
-0.5322448015,
-0.0598700456,
-0.884398818,
0.1727919579,
-0.4906074703,
0.3970132172,
-0.4673675001,
-1.1124230623,
0.6150829792,
-0.4780879617,
0.1059386134,
0.6997661591,
0.4893944561,
-0.1124006808,
0.4105680883,
0.5609592199,
-0.1911989897,
0.1777127087,
-0.2657069564,
0.0600621626,
-0.7317826748,
-0.4003250599,
-0.3714953661,
-0.3705531657,
-0.161314711,
-0.6704919934,
0.5877664685,
0.1652075648,
-0.107221894,
0.4265134633,
-0.1872430593,
0.5484026074,
0.3307863772,
-0.1135198474,
0.5191966295,
-0.2189773172,
-0.5990613103,
-0.3976230621,
-0.5147637129,
0.0488218367,
1.4146672487,
0.2763342857,
0.7016576529,
-0.0150491009,
0.5101269484,
0.4741015732,
0.5149954557,
-0.9614610076,
0.5887883306,
0.1115026921,
-0.3819835484,
-0.2443032712,
-0.8484196067,
-0.5372225642,
-0.0001301339,
-0.0439547338,
-0.5289844871,
-0.4729123712,
-0.214113757,
-0.3898594677,
0.2008328885,
-0.4145747423,
0.7025191188,
-0.2274375409,
-0.3085893095,
-0.500151813,
-0.1612613201,
0.3163386583,
-0.6135908961,
0.4495457411,
-0.5347106457,
-0.4213006198,
1.069062233,
-0.5304277539,
0.3828437924,
-0.1160277054,
-0.4158969522,
0.1125635281,
0.1824057251,
0.403385818,
0.0496921986,
-0.0343092605,
0.0511377379,
0.014173273,
-0.4108190536,
-0.7057011724,
0.484292835,
-0.6850526929,
-0.8233151436,
-0.4881163836,
-1.1180199385,
-0.7349418402,
0.1565680951,
-0.2132304609,
0.4391028583,
-0.2037234008,
0.0807626694,
0.725607276,
-0.1163717508,
0.2597484589,
0.5748473406,
-0.3063774109,
-0.7935761809,
1.0872914791,
0.1278373003,
0.0724973157,
0.513132751,
0.4222995937,
-0.5008035898,
-0.5027862787,
0.0350438543,
0.3404650986,
-0.8083711863,
-0.5073978305,
-0.4452797472,
-0.1468715668,
-0.3169797957,
-0.0750358403,
-0.3863505423,
-0.4949750602,
-0.0666601285,
-0.017159611,
0.599309504,
0.7296808958,
-0.0013209268,
-0.0032046493,
-0.6966629028,
0.3216113448,
0.6025747657,
0.6159374118,
-0.2039148659,
-0.4886285961,
-0.2294783145,
-0.2592815757,
-0.4074321091,
-0.4264677763,
0.1429904997,
0.0427436754,
0.6354388595,
0.4510529339,
0.1918077767,
0.8507876992,
-0.1471114159,
0.3019622564,
0.3734288514,
-0.9626627564,
0.3162218332,
-0.4736609757,
0.3668079078,
0.6834208369,
0.3335784674,
-0.5969547629,
-0.4181258678,
-0.657715261,
-0.6739856005,
0.365226984,
0.3059725761,
-0.131644547,
0.1442635506,
0.4160352349,
0.1964594871,
0.4526170194,
-0.0264272243,
-0.3363458812,
0.202033326,
-0.1984946728,
0.005316562,
-0.1751602441,
-0.2151949108,
-0.4379858375,
0.4460173845,
-0.2694066763,
0.1403221637,
0.0187944472,
-0.1606089324,
-0.1091764793,
0.0401351079,
0.6753066182,
1.1273601055,
-0.3425577879,
-0.0945353881,
0.3673921525,
-0.7146584988,
-0.1997513473,
0.4882372916,
0.1143554822,
-0.194993183,
0.3207832575,
0.1610305905,
0.5887494683,
-0.9729158878,
0.67136693,
-0.0001001374,
-0.7538755536,
-0.5674491525,
0.1380205601,
0.2259324938,
0.268582195,
0.9009809494,
0.3230728209,
0.0605844148,
-0.2274383456,
0.216037035,
0.5252113342,
-0.2500093579,
-0.0980341434,
0.6875638366,
0.2327307016,
-0.1721838117,
0.498816371,
-0.0458078496,
-0.7202854156,
0.7734388113,
0.5990812778,
0.6826062202,
0.2089628428,
-0.0450491868,
0.2150767148,
-0.0561070889,
-0.0562573969,
0.5704135895,
-0.2365520895,
-0.8121846914,
-0.4782138765,
-0.6540498137,
-0.9414018989,
-0.0475622527,
-0.7166907191,
-0.0028178669,
-0.5894626379,
-0.1305392534,
-0.2196291238,
0.530148685,
-0.6271288395,
0.0230210796,
-0.0182738416,
1.461656332,
-0.3088351786,
0.5409671664,
0.8513211608,
0.1792457998,
-0.6168048978,
-0.3103288114,
0.1095953956,
-1.1271243095,
0.2738087177,
0.2048051059,
-0.0721560419,
0.3262942731,
-0.3547715843,
-0.7989643812,
1.3675076962,
0.3131590486,
-0.5534607768,
0.1245342568,
0.2594769299,
0.2554440498,
-0.2113057971,
0.2957414985,
0.7082089186,
0.6906345487,
0.2847205698,
-0.839412868,
-0.1870169491,
-0.4898019135,
-0.0391167253,
0.1630173028,
-0.6173155308,
0.6044055223,
-0.246080786,
-0.0053371838,
-0.0021198918,
0.7979941368,
0.6208840609,
0.6587339044,
0.3540936112,
1.0408588648,
1.0110923052,
-0.2497673631,
0.6475016475,
-0.5578893423,
0.4353261292,
0.7697029114,
-0.2900847495,
0.6984521747,
0.5273342729,
-0.7263097167,
0.2362201661,
0.4755687416,
-0.1197086349,
0.0693863034,
0.6822462678,
-0.2832650542,
-0.4870404303,
-0.2330361903,
-0.7971521616,
0.2882149816,
0.4204511046,
0.3348214328,
-0.2728026807,
-0.2933134437,
-0.0737164095,
0.3125637472,
-0.3317213655,
0.6252849698,
0.4075214863,
-0.3734674156,
0.0011343834,
-0.024805028,
0.7080554366,
-0.763215363,
-0.01176643,
-0.3955031037,
0.2191726118,
0.0202609859,
-0.6828355193,
0.2350599021,
-0.1618822515,
0.1010724381,
-0.1814035922,
0.6918342113,
-0.2505738437,
-0.5758495331,
0.181584537,
0.8344824314,
0.0384238623,
-0.3646095097,
-0.6091698408,
-0.2862254679,
-0.4690479934,
-0.1045701057,
0.3945105374,
0.5201403499,
0.1503575146,
0.9364851117,
0.9012212753,
-0.0664911345,
-0.152250275,
0.091175817,
0.9647305608,
-0.8562675118,
-0.3188226819,
-0.6532062292,
-0.0337303393,
-0.0080337599,
-0.5647566915,
0.7199491858,
0.8447239399,
0.8498139977,
0.0362707265,
0.6255039573,
0.2873576283,
0.3524790704,
-0.4293572903,
0.5640465021,
-0.6529861689,
0.4206036627,
-0.5014481544,
-1.1329836845,
-0.520001471,
0.267404139,
-0.4989866316,
-0.1015869454,
0.8927224874,
0.4283940494,
0.3466462195,
0.180616647,
0.4562416971,
-0.2046300769,
-0.0180983469,
0.7125634551,
0.9918378592,
-0.3321579993,
0.6460654736,
-0.3109352291,
-0.1628431231,
-0.1589294374,
-0.8268569112,
-0.6136578918,
-0.2291507721,
-0.4961211383,
-0.1273040175,
-0.253346324,
0.9897760749,
0.0313661583,
-0.5885394216,
-0.4137617648,
-0.0182459969,
0.3435373008,
-0.4637897611,
-0.2130200267,
0.2514086664,
-0.5815610886,
-0.3961893618,
0.4216189384,
0.6274368167,
-0.0188099183,
-0.2278491408,
-0.1097888499,
0.3697833419,
0.032152079,
0.4098151922,
-0.0839610845,
-0.3476870656,
0.0629855022,
0.3045010269,
-0.1818925291,
0.0251034535,
1.2070264816,
-0.5054239035,
0.3872140944,
0.454017818,
0.9955453873,
0.3022233248,
0.0962111503,
0.5859921575,
-0.2321501374,
-0.3032930791,
0.3116041422,
0.4076495171,
-0.0560222939,
-0.0809718445,
0.5893270373,
0.8859042525,
-0.3026979864,
-0.320938468,
-0.0264248475,
-1.0324057341,
-0.1705239713,
0.9263295531,
-0.1472306699,
-0.2466402501,
-0.1535727829,
0.0852452293,
-0.0898559839,
-0.5433800817,
0.7308032513,
0.8594530821,
0.0319628753,
0.0104459263,
-0.5984140635,
0.3998241425,
0.6040226817,
-0.8328351378,
0.0690094009,
0.2309283316,
0.2425406426,
0.1289205104,
0.6862433553,
-0.1565386206,
0.3929187059,
0.0904165953,
-0.0142583102,
-0.4023316205,
-0.1293403655,
-0.0430095047,
0.3016985655,
0.0100542614,
0.2237893045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09796v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09796v2
|
Interpreting User Requests in the Context of Natural Language Standing Instructions
| 2023-11-16T11:19:26 | 2024-03-07T16:49:07 |
Nikita Moghe, Patrick Xia, Jacob Andreas, Jason Eisner, Benjamin Van Durme, Harsh Jhamtani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Users of natural language interfaces, generally powered by Large Language
Models (LLMs),often must repeat their preferences each time they make a similar
request. We describe an approach to LLM-based dialogue modeling in which
persistent user constraints and preferences -- collectively termed standing
instructions -- as additional context for such interfaces. For example, when a
user states "I'm hungry", a previously expressed preference for Persian food
can be automatically added to the LLM prompt, influencing the search for
relevant restaurants. We develop NLSI, a language-to-program dataset consisting
of over 2.4K dialogues spanning 17 domains, where each dialogue is paired with
a user profile (a set of users specific standing instructions) and
corresponding structured representations (API calls). A key challenge in NLSI
is to identify which subset of the standing instructions is applicable to a
given dialogue. NLSI contains diverse phenomena, from simple preferences to
interdependent instructions such as triggering a hotel search whenever the user
is booking tickets to an event. We conduct experiments on NLSI using prompting
with large language models and various retrieval approaches, achieving a
maximum of 44.7% exact match on API prediction. Our results demonstrate the
challenges in identifying the relevant standing instructions and their
interpretation into API calls.
|
[
-0.4312192202,
-0.51432091,
0.8173456192,
0.4647496641,
-0.061765641,
-0.0402995683,
-0.1923009604,
-0.3672477305,
0.3787661195,
0.9526521564,
-0.9800025821,
-0.4583285153,
-0.1297937781,
0.5026444793,
-0.387481302,
0.6647931337,
-0.1834207624,
0.0085539995,
-0.4773055911,
-0.2949440777,
-0.8564245105,
-0.354331702,
-0.6908735633,
-0.436639607,
0.4732353687,
0.453102082,
0.7782127857,
0.149386853,
0.0933886394,
0.1885712296,
-0.1364338398,
0.1396074742,
-0.1301521659,
0.2339055538,
-0.0370172337,
-0.5659788251,
0.0383124799,
-0.1255543381,
0.5836657286,
0.952955842,
-0.1153367162,
-0.0831302926,
0.0217405073,
0.5596681237,
-0.2126132697,
-0.0681867003,
-0.3483223021,
0.1002796441,
-0.017311506,
-0.5046274662,
-0.6312080026,
-0.4241199195,
0.6891073585,
-0.339985162,
-0.23427926,
0.0329537429,
1.0050700903,
0.2006864697,
-0.383918345,
-0.7594447732,
-0.5463107228,
0.9472393394,
-0.885954082,
0.3969490826,
0.4339602888,
0.2398007214,
-0.5455433726,
-0.439065218,
-0.6482561231,
-0.78580755,
-0.3921385705,
-0.2353493869,
-0.1662375182,
0.0330829062,
0.4007389545,
-0.0854137316,
-0.5361412168,
0.1465334892,
-0.0881991014,
0.0931684673,
0.2987404168,
0.282033354,
0.7572930455,
-0.3869500756,
-0.477157712,
0.4253002703,
-0.8076025248,
0.2000440955,
0.2197527885,
0.5303678513,
-0.3043155074,
0.7435309291,
-0.2819339335,
1.0355912447,
0.0511559024,
0.0514378734,
-0.0008337365,
-0.3506812155,
0.092399314,
-0.0407790616,
0.4698599279,
0.5474099517,
0.2918149233,
-0.2394926846,
-0.2784988284,
-0.3537143171,
0.2479234934,
-0.5114411712,
-0.0007929199,
0.291239202,
-0.3947387934,
0.0799465105,
0.0590142831,
-0.4475865662,
-0.5477401614,
-0.8165239096,
0.1348037571,
-0.2493387908,
-0.0985476449,
-0.0408766456,
-0.0197017025,
0.5275894403,
0.1709537655,
-0.8993269801,
0.5186139941,
0.6981167793,
0.9908190966,
-0.2310099602,
-0.1719542891,
-0.5963538885,
0.1043503657,
-0.0730502158,
0.6420603395,
-0.8000333309,
-0.5842307806,
0.0144228898,
0.0355192609,
-0.0972772241,
-0.5024195313,
0.5230052471,
-0.5792557597,
0.2157022506,
-0.4795500338,
-0.5628957152,
0.2228156775,
0.2743261456,
-0.6982925534,
0.8921235204,
-0.1207258403,
-0.4248813987,
0.1825178415,
-1.0502039194,
-0.4151760638,
0.3225919306,
-0.2768862844,
-0.0572781973,
0.2682409585,
0.1604143828,
0.1661400944,
-0.0705976635,
0.1372942179,
-0.2988155186,
-0.2941102684,
0.5651682019,
-0.3776879311,
0.7641378045,
0.0522621349,
-0.2234317213,
0.0795312449,
-0.620893538,
0.0027739382,
0.1684556156,
-0.3953135312,
-0.5153684616,
0.3663833439,
-0.3801486492,
-0.1157317162,
0.4831425548,
-0.2951725423,
0.2045793682,
-0.7348689437,
0.5376286507,
0.7282580733,
0.0530534536,
0.3790902197,
0.1026365608,
0.4497999251,
-0.3547158539,
0.1109251082,
-0.2929422259,
-0.6615499258,
-0.772634387,
0.3188115656,
0.0050705336,
0.4819825888,
-0.5733511448,
0.1714963615,
-0.2568012774,
0.2370047569,
-0.3414839804,
0.0325786546,
0.2655642927,
0.5294672847,
0.2432020903,
0.0103115514,
-0.7732246518,
-0.9488409758,
-0.0557302311,
-0.3607009649,
-0.3717789054,
0.5060845017,
0.1614389122,
-0.2210851014,
1.3565798998,
-0.2441416532,
0.2115497291,
-0.343667537,
0.0884713233,
0.5379027128,
0.1141895577,
0.5612376928,
-0.9594059587,
-0.5812522769,
0.0413312316,
-0.6096220016,
-0.5329000354,
-0.2708828747,
-0.1676977575,
0.2617447972,
0.4180373847,
-0.4992389381,
0.446732372,
0.679136157,
-0.128325507,
0.5909629464,
0.1784922481,
0.0076299058,
-1.1739249229,
0.0207870528,
0.250525564,
-0.1420526206,
-0.7772982121,
0.0483227856,
-0.2093512118,
-0.2676807344,
-0.2661545277,
0.9662798047,
-0.4723733366,
-0.3193484843,
-0.4885210693,
0.166259855,
0.2020247579,
0.4125753045,
0.2382009625,
0.9218639731,
0.3472473025,
-0.6960555911,
0.2629968524,
0.3059770763,
-0.2891300023,
0.5925329328,
-0.8613035679,
0.1820177287,
0.1973758638,
0.3189366162,
-1.0006172657,
-0.2452104986,
0.3052019477,
-0.4472251236,
-0.1294609755,
-0.4462353587,
-0.3194777966,
-0.4531350434,
-0.0993959755,
0.0739221051,
0.0871480927,
-0.8650224805,
0.854786694,
0.2429742664,
-0.3872572184,
-0.5266050696,
-0.2727369666,
0.3987365067,
-0.1078021154,
-0.4197825789,
-0.0697481111,
-0.1760827601,
-0.4568178654,
-0.0895557702,
-0.265676558,
0.0329538472,
0.2840549648,
0.5832746625,
0.386012882,
-0.1591560692,
-0.2534744143,
-0.0890710279,
-0.1681379229,
0.2590783238,
-0.5693429708,
0.6841177344,
-0.3041866422,
-0.4734306335,
-0.9100072384,
0.5955206156,
0.418271929,
0.1812345982,
0.5839438438,
0.0472907461,
-0.2922818959,
0.0443987809,
-0.3353361785,
-0.2074810416,
-0.5203076601,
-0.01198484,
-0.6250886917,
-0.6822232604,
0.6062583923,
-0.0193688348,
0.4999061823,
0.0761583745,
0.4469200075,
-0.4707508385,
1.4823586941,
0.4838219285,
-0.1289247721,
0.5194379687,
0.1804011166,
0.2952592671,
-0.7178621292,
-0.1392196268,
-0.743850112,
-0.3602495193,
-0.2670483887,
-0.1146222055,
0.2297065556,
-0.1082572192,
0.1274795532,
0.5021272898,
-0.2239419967,
0.8101283908,
0.4942629337,
-0.1194284409,
0.1032712534,
0.0178662799,
-0.2419174314,
-0.0012676512,
-0.279481858,
-0.7647634745,
0.5834838152,
0.402086854,
0.7010094523,
0.3251755834,
0.4978760183,
0.5143227577,
0.137922585,
-0.8545187116,
0.7337315083,
0.0140001494,
-0.321466893,
-0.2258656621,
-0.7063990235,
-0.946180284,
-0.1179897413,
0.0620516613,
-0.9101700783,
0.044208087,
0.2241064459,
-0.5250411034,
0.0551132634,
-0.8831298351,
0.6578891277,
-0.4588128328,
-0.053135898,
0.0692839697,
-0.5353490114,
-0.0038021985,
0.4573941231,
0.0584033914,
-0.263238579,
0.1606200337,
0.4329433739,
-0.5334718227,
1.0344315767,
-0.3926405609,
-0.168999061,
0.0664744154,
0.03994653,
0.6453903317,
0.3455014825,
-0.2785041928,
0.1802767664,
-0.0147885699,
-0.4077405632,
-0.6887105107,
0.914042592,
-0.6583168507,
-0.7269743681,
-0.2257176638,
-0.1486844271,
-0.2937841713,
0.2442285419,
0.0679163411,
0.6239001155,
-0.1942686588,
-0.0764134377,
0.6219300628,
-0.3058793843,
0.2362887263,
0.5319182277,
-0.4095444679,
0.0195820108,
0.8796133399,
-0.2698028088,
0.2627162039,
0.2981099188,
0.2491799444,
-0.5390823483,
-0.7062740922,
-0.6717175841,
0.1575332433,
-0.6172456145,
0.1232396066,
-0.5664396882,
-0.1074053794,
-0.1388892531,
-0.310605824,
-0.1080739051,
-0.1094049513,
-0.4699094296,
-0.0395563468,
0.1603956074,
0.5394268036,
0.3924533427,
0.3159048557,
-0.5907144547,
0.2753167152,
0.1957297027,
0.5705324411,
-0.1359447539,
-0.4476473927,
-0.1406401098,
0.1649501771,
0.3189984262,
-0.8864130378,
0.3832297623,
0.0905990899,
0.7334603667,
0.458869338,
0.139286682,
0.621157825,
-0.5922791362,
0.8777446747,
0.2089293301,
-0.8277584314,
0.7451056242,
-0.1510955691,
0.5771173239,
0.7517079711,
0.3980868757,
-0.8762623072,
-0.3502480686,
0.0015047598,
-0.95535779,
0.7220460176,
0.0919679403,
0.6467256546,
-0.1695867926,
0.6389886141,
0.0372408479,
0.0538012832,
-0.8832351565,
-0.0220533386,
0.0677135959,
-0.0460506231,
0.5449243188,
-0.328202486,
-0.3351221085,
0.0958266407,
0.5434905887,
-0.3237571716,
0.1857587248,
-0.2136569768,
-0.0549484082,
-0.0705898106,
0.3751268387,
0.659027338,
0.931368351,
-0.2496345788,
-0.0772696137,
0.2459272146,
0.0139936842,
-0.3139496446,
-0.1439214945,
-0.2715983093,
0.2521444559,
0.0806453973,
1.2655233145,
0.4542281628,
-0.9882448316,
0.2591389418,
-0.4824520648,
0.0817504153,
-0.7122189403,
0.0534140766,
-0.0509117469,
-0.1154041067,
0.4538011253,
-0.0263515282,
0.0950756818,
-0.6025884748,
0.3323587775,
0.5032501817,
-0.4737916291,
-0.3854971528,
0.2698623538,
0.4543796778,
-0.5902996063,
0.7578365803,
-0.0018028575,
-0.3312089145,
0.3338387311,
0.4376625717,
0.7393126488,
-0.0031316532,
0.3274599016,
0.2716123462,
-0.1149883643,
0.0752381831,
0.2388256639,
-0.0907051191,
-0.6109740734,
-0.4735128284,
-0.7676039934,
-0.8315005898,
0.0064525693,
-0.8901901245,
0.4071620405,
-0.5532492995,
-0.1293411553,
0.150866136,
-0.1641518474,
-0.3563870192,
-0.4559356272,
0.498267144,
0.9123344421,
-0.6283758879,
0.4304172695,
0.6511204839,
-0.1591154188,
-0.6296520829,
0.2353030443,
0.453931421,
-0.7533278465,
0.3438501358,
0.3666742742,
-0.246961236,
-0.2085557133,
-0.7521131039,
-0.7755930424,
0.5045769811,
0.1717807651,
-0.46288836,
-0.1841876209,
0.1349520236,
0.4278443158,
-0.4696957469,
0.202134639,
0.7518247366,
0.3056129813,
0.3599320352,
-0.7996567488,
-0.1700372249,
-0.2609393597,
0.0665207431,
0.3591277897,
-0.2668995857,
0.4385519028,
-0.0930785015,
-0.5677748919,
0.4357616305,
0.6331576109,
0.4623202682,
0.3732687831,
0.6735823154,
0.3077916801,
0.6627162099,
-0.0652527213,
1.127895236,
-0.0760115981,
-0.0365136042,
1.3196389675,
-0.6927387118,
0.9984548092,
0.6991679072,
0.0576794632,
0.8921489716,
0.8139126301,
0.0428905152,
0.4326167703,
0.0617588647,
-0.3833693564,
-0.0424732342,
-0.3469946086,
-0.0684743822,
0.0902996138,
0.5773314834,
-0.0817825943,
-0.3245149553,
0.1244882643,
-0.3000056148,
0.0653077066,
-0.1101215556,
0.9778921008,
0.1342608631,
-0.8724586368,
0.4645060599,
0.0869882256,
0.4157655835,
-0.5708293915,
-0.1954270601,
-0.3036348224,
-0.3418062627,
-0.205428347,
-0.8844243884,
0.25439924,
0.3339784741,
-0.3984476626,
-0.28725034,
0.3746381104,
-0.1427742839,
-0.2903494537,
0.3384220302,
0.0242307931,
0.2994045615,
0.1862981021,
-0.9081527591,
0.3339673579,
0.27183038,
-0.3263304234,
0.1991219372,
0.2099428922,
-0.2489975095,
0.7071230412,
0.7226603031,
-0.1508864164,
0.1295754462,
0.6424354911,
0.7150962353,
-0.6023237109,
-0.4804494679,
-0.7933056355,
0.3741578758,
-0.2441783994,
-0.2004078031,
0.6143025756,
0.3366647959,
0.6930205226,
0.2186449915,
0.8452181816,
0.0624364987,
0.5229646564,
-0.8103976846,
0.1537620872,
-0.4567111433,
0.8552335501,
0.0444262549,
-0.7969359159,
-0.1177236885,
0.5484777689,
-0.5799330473,
-0.1111666262,
0.1783212423,
0.7936081886,
0.0287945084,
0.2413801998,
0.0060559488,
0.0012135081,
0.3598092198,
0.2429198325,
1.2488549948,
0.2132921964,
0.4126289189,
0.2639224231,
-0.0699228197,
-0.5844020247,
-0.540237844,
-0.7013312578,
-0.4690476954,
-0.1881183237,
-0.3549801707,
-0.0144177238,
1.1994878054,
0.6645342708,
-1.024750948,
-0.4239286482,
-0.1000569984,
0.236450389,
-0.2416662276,
-0.3021401763,
-0.0073028463,
-0.3935960531,
-0.8329464197,
0.8668259382,
0.4935124516,
0.0866783038,
-0.3643633425,
-0.4205994904,
-0.219367668,
0.3768365681,
0.4928289354,
0.7492203116,
-1.1051530838,
-0.3248444498,
0.246432811,
-0.0458955914,
0.1326699853,
0.8506935835,
-0.5226528645,
0.5502325296,
0.1651929021,
0.6144872904,
0.1811268181,
0.1825104952,
0.8489276767,
-1.2102557421,
-0.1347179413,
0.2052674145,
0.2984307706,
0.3078177571,
-0.3496320546,
0.2436071932,
-0.2048536688,
-0.2844629288,
-0.9417306185,
0.5072954893,
-1.0868946314,
-0.3172177374,
1.095793128,
-0.1527344733,
-0.3151959777,
-0.3245681524,
-0.2722710073,
-0.3399982154,
-0.5233659148,
0.6889674664,
0.7881638408,
-0.3805328012,
-0.3546267748,
-0.814514935,
0.3232751489,
0.5927101374,
-0.5220517516,
0.2138647586,
0.7707437277,
0.1761510074,
0.4491548538,
0.4957839251,
0.1484742463,
0.1103555486,
-0.514305234,
-0.2129251957,
0.3355882168,
-0.4002336264,
-0.3276716769,
0.0925412253,
0.200159654,
-0.0012555512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10781v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10781v2
|
Can Language Model Moderators Improve the Health of Online Discourse?
| 2023-11-16T11:14:22 | 2024-05-06T17:44:12 |
Hyundong Cho, Shuai Liu, Taiwei Shi, Darpan Jain, Basem Rizk, Yuyang Huang, Zixun Lu, Nuan Wen, Jonathan Gratch, Emilio Ferrara, Jonathan May
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Conversational moderation of online communities is crucial to maintaining
civility for a constructive environment, but it is challenging to scale and
harmful to moderators. The inclusion of sophisticated natural language
generation modules as a force multiplier to aid human moderators is a
tantalizing prospect, but adequate evaluation approaches have so far been
elusive. In this paper, we establish a systematic definition of conversational
moderation effectiveness grounded on moderation literature and establish design
criteria for conducting realistic yet safe evaluation. We then propose a
comprehensive evaluation framework to assess models' moderation capabilities
independently of human intervention. With our framework, we conduct the first
known study of language models as conversational moderators, finding that
appropriately prompted models that incorporate insights from social science can
provide specific and fair feedback on toxic behavior but struggle to influence
users to increase their levels of respect and cooperation.
|
[
-0.2216151506,
-0.9251217842,
0.5812069178,
0.1789371669,
-0.2100067288,
0.0715223774,
-0.2445706874,
-0.5504055619,
0.158212468,
0.4558443725,
-0.1944625825,
0.0385596491,
-0.6454503536,
0.1330721825,
-0.3764757812,
1.0194693804,
0.6118975878,
0.4069473147,
-0.2954432368,
0.0904459134,
-0.4766681194,
-0.491574049,
-0.8037412763,
-0.2737888694,
0.5083015561,
-0.1430423707,
0.8632676601,
0.542255342,
0.5660783648,
0.412969619,
-0.5447617173,
0.213002041,
-0.7320250869,
0.1191198826,
-0.064351052,
-0.1991167963,
-0.5288801789,
-0.0453523956,
0.3376263082,
0.8424316645,
-0.5829014778,
-0.1252181232,
0.2507525682,
0.2415937483,
-0.3449017704,
0.0711786449,
-0.5644652247,
-0.271274358,
0.2761228681,
-0.2587780952,
-0.4358232319,
-0.7826135159,
0.1798801869,
-0.505281806,
-0.2413346618,
-0.0276465658,
0.6563226581,
-0.0844426602,
-0.7956715226,
-0.4326211214,
-0.9088535905,
0.6595479846,
-0.9705054164,
0.2681352496,
0.550625205,
0.3199600279,
-0.2171063423,
-0.6143343449,
-0.3696201146,
-0.4137008488,
-0.1915037483,
0.039038498,
-0.2441506833,
0.4322199523,
0.1190883294,
0.3069034517,
-0.1352186352,
-0.0807401538,
-0.5412839651,
-0.2287515104,
0.5419053435,
0.3834339678,
0.6560831666,
-0.4443830848,
-0.2453245074,
0.3616850376,
-0.4134382308,
0.0081468672,
0.4599169791,
0.3391397297,
-0.1275024414,
0.1157901287,
0.0211849809,
0.5880252719,
0.0069693564,
-0.3373778462,
-0.2261662334,
-0.7634090185,
-0.021376336,
-0.5080647469,
0.6201373339,
0.8771713376,
-0.1162024811,
-0.2830052078,
-0.21654208,
0.3215074241,
0.512660265,
-1.1732037067,
-0.301903069,
0.0203711726,
-0.6280277371,
-0.8315609097,
0.3403903246,
-0.7429234982,
-0.6419700384,
-0.1763203293,
0.3226174414,
-0.0015562371,
-0.5768760443,
0.1257643998,
-0.2162167579,
-0.0942596048,
0.2344775349,
-0.7424067855,
0.5450672507,
0.7604840994,
0.6237430573,
0.0585113354,
0.4370797276,
-0.4310964644,
-0.0598709993,
-0.2595996261,
0.6742987633,
-0.6157112718,
-0.5096885562,
0.2882402539,
-0.1155650616,
0.0623606555,
-0.5142852068,
0.7634456754,
-0.4474936426,
0.5005381107,
-0.4797249734,
-0.5285409093,
-0.1467578113,
0.2937810719,
-0.5823161006,
0.6179702878,
-0.0543571711,
-0.6328390837,
0.3002533019,
-0.6382465959,
-0.508888185,
0.4021280408,
-0.0192472748,
-0.2264735252,
0.1115054265,
-0.029590819,
0.2681378722,
-0.4568262398,
0.8684647679,
-0.3724322021,
-0.0798153058,
0.5171772838,
-0.5404137373,
0.9892542362,
0.1936583966,
-0.174412787,
0.5553098917,
-0.3319646418,
0.2968773246,
-0.2313562632,
-0.6815089583,
-0.2330040783,
0.3769575655,
0.3180284202,
0.3136776686,
-0.3418977857,
-0.5109295845,
-0.3437659144,
-0.6528549194,
0.8637103438,
0.7443968654,
0.3378069401,
0.2296488434,
-0.9050636292,
0.6011705995,
-0.4092564881,
0.4741050005,
-0.2256101519,
-0.7144820094,
-0.836324513,
-0.3446033597,
0.127036795,
0.227650851,
-0.7655882835,
0.662522316,
-0.2081223726,
-0.8110423088,
-0.4394143224,
0.1057597473,
0.531308949,
0.3440495133,
0.0410285331,
-0.6142622828,
-0.2558882833,
-0.6507939696,
-0.2698754668,
-0.3612807691,
-0.205456987,
0.3861779869,
-0.0094469422,
-0.2475105375,
0.7393538356,
-0.0401844867,
0.0158393234,
-0.2833332121,
0.3430069685,
-0.3684320748,
0.200951457,
0.5033302307,
-0.5034742951,
-0.3339925706,
-0.2150025517,
-0.4955858886,
-0.4597386122,
0.1188646778,
0.0300266221,
-0.2813327909,
0.3260940015,
-0.2153662741,
0.1417720169,
0.6060695648,
-0.4371712804,
0.3174080551,
-0.0581328347,
0.3420075476,
-0.8747560382,
0.2259135842,
-0.1000592187,
-0.4715784192,
-1.1269624233,
0.4412748516,
-0.1139274761,
-0.2451516092,
-0.5528141856,
0.3000761569,
-0.0659845397,
0.5756021738,
-0.3396143913,
0.3170659542,
0.1439847499,
0.0710599646,
-0.4191364646,
0.2454947233,
0.2542910278,
-0.6925937533,
0.2558659613,
0.0366805568,
-0.5481228828,
0.5519401431,
-0.8094112277,
0.1846234649,
-0.174055323,
0.4866811037,
-0.9055233598,
-0.3698865175,
0.1267629117,
-0.2381742299,
-0.0589666925,
0.1336246133,
-0.2199320197,
-0.1709823757,
-0.497572124,
0.228953138,
0.3066972196,
0.0109309135,
0.4750696123,
0.8170485497,
-0.2297711521,
0.0138230035,
-0.3752878308,
0.1613245904,
-0.1779507399,
-0.8120828867,
0.0283438377,
-0.4982987642,
-0.6604908109,
-0.2128121704,
0.2094748467,
-0.2781156301,
0.4322701395,
0.2620622218,
0.1983791441,
0.0046313922,
0.1980392039,
-0.0259374864,
-0.008153352,
0.3839467466,
0.4929060638,
0.5194544196,
-0.1107169464,
-0.1611383408,
-0.5995520949,
0.3733190596,
0.4481263459,
-0.0939887613,
0.5706989169,
0.2421634048,
-0.4604755342,
0.146991238,
-0.5993797183,
-0.6184421778,
-0.5123825669,
0.2664768398,
0.2907048762,
-1.0005642176,
0.2974231243,
-0.0947126076,
0.0912164301,
0.3095888197,
0.5640056729,
0.2154183537,
1.2751413584,
0.6964402199,
0.1433002055,
0.334246546,
0.3574709296,
0.4840572476,
-0.3176243901,
-0.1489502043,
-0.6162802577,
0.0873995945,
-0.3866364956,
-0.3462249637,
0.2926824093,
-0.0717483386,
0.0787187591,
0.0231619477,
-0.4126689434,
0.4584439397,
-0.1801017821,
0.3768306077,
0.3873685896,
-0.2197006941,
-0.1197690144,
-0.3475825787,
-0.6469821334,
-0.7333039045,
0.6420682669,
0.5175192356,
0.6863375306,
0.3791514635,
0.0324520953,
0.3027021587,
0.8974196315,
-0.7924416661,
0.5304681659,
0.2796678543,
-0.9731100202,
-0.0776973218,
-0.6261443496,
-0.7427377105,
0.15384233,
-0.4415911734,
-0.4481448829,
-0.1819074303,
0.152789101,
-0.7204662561,
0.2459014654,
-0.6235471964,
0.674862206,
-0.320640862,
-0.2948843837,
-0.5096669197,
-0.6081622839,
0.3871996403,
-0.0874377042,
0.7517992258,
-0.1968417764,
0.1090303063,
0.5131685138,
-0.4193141758,
0.9854930639,
-0.0690676793,
-0.0199390892,
0.2649757862,
0.3700616956,
0.062021371,
0.0319179036,
-0.2719940245,
0.0874468759,
0.0902237296,
-0.0807652473,
-0.5828360319,
0.6455988884,
-0.6393229365,
-0.6263007522,
0.024389755,
-0.0470530316,
-0.0935498327,
0.1031691208,
-0.0490300171,
0.5033603311,
-0.5474694967,
0.3504360914,
0.4000500441,
-0.3328635693,
0.2965550721,
0.3002013564,
-0.5311018229,
-0.5002835393,
0.9360004663,
-0.2346340716,
0.6987580061,
-0.075613901,
0.5923649073,
-0.061956726,
-0.0924530476,
-0.1942143291,
-0.0157285612,
-0.7883788943,
-0.2767629623,
-0.5473909974,
-0.2098291218,
-0.3857972622,
-0.2095994353,
-0.0920465067,
-0.3543258309,
-0.2070651948,
-0.2006385624,
-0.060459353,
1.1869125366,
-0.0179010797,
0.3575566411,
-0.6971529126,
0.0183935557,
0.642075181,
0.2943946123,
0.0812619179,
-0.4575510323,
0.1902180165,
0.2251029015,
-0.5267501473,
-0.9857364893,
0.3346550167,
0.3027010858,
0.4749263227,
0.7158603668,
0.0699835941,
0.5824289918,
-0.2173541337,
0.8217046857,
0.268019706,
-1.006562829,
0.4200251997,
-0.5213894844,
0.0400027744,
0.4863427579,
0.3208882511,
-0.8876947165,
-0.5680512786,
-0.3915116191,
-0.6922163367,
0.4559433162,
0.2471058816,
0.7719072104,
-0.2415868938,
0.2175286561,
0.0052675949,
0.2126111984,
-1.0042396784,
-0.0368059725,
-0.1301190257,
0.1421083063,
0.3585032523,
-0.6147471666,
-0.4086930752,
-0.3637569547,
0.6361474991,
-0.0346453562,
0.1496131569,
-0.1147043481,
0.1365041137,
-0.5858007669,
0.437738955,
0.491656065,
0.8121410608,
0.1300785989,
0.1873684973,
0.0550942533,
-0.0489275046,
-0.074841395,
-0.3504743278,
-0.4086043239,
-0.2155600488,
0.1785470694,
0.5022156835,
0.6576691866,
-0.6159186363,
0.7958007455,
-0.3857305646,
0.0959582105,
0.1623124629,
0.1337856352,
0.1759848744,
-0.2052414566,
0.0833727866,
0.1041996777,
0.0542873405,
-0.5967850089,
0.2501195073,
0.5873509049,
-0.6688377261,
-0.3944444358,
0.7170929313,
0.8156576753,
-0.6629619002,
0.2872419655,
-0.1953539997,
-0.7162488103,
0.4067746997,
0.4795392156,
0.5626439452,
-0.4608828425,
0.28110677,
0.5122629404,
0.4748966694,
0.1500020176,
0.2501166761,
0.2494762838,
-0.7051945329,
-0.2563231289,
-0.6210680008,
-0.2780501246,
0.1694298983,
-0.3093599379,
0.4671781063,
-0.7346104383,
-0.477914989,
0.0849038661,
-0.2193939835,
-0.367484808,
-0.0588846914,
0.0572046824,
0.4431450069,
-0.897749722,
0.4338571727,
0.4063425064,
-0.2974145412,
-0.6820243597,
-0.0697237477,
0.2077001482,
-0.263757199,
0.2046740502,
0.4151829481,
-0.1623214483,
-0.203926146,
-0.5855109096,
-0.5280371308,
0.6470741034,
0.4365516305,
-0.1648998857,
0.0984438509,
0.0792688802,
0.8885957599,
-0.2072310597,
0.5082984567,
0.1494592726,
0.5966845155,
-0.1579952389,
-1.3009585142,
0.2776302993,
-0.4300236106,
0.1410108805,
-0.0682906434,
-0.5125524402,
0.5609592795,
0.0796052814,
-0.4880413115,
0.3620766401,
0.3578629196,
-0.2436881661,
-0.2247204334,
0.5909169316,
0.2307855785,
0.5716679096,
-0.0766872317,
1.0305655003,
-0.5483978987,
0.291275233,
0.7718291879,
-0.1643566936,
0.5526822209,
0.234755829,
0.0332807191,
0.50323385,
0.2815724313,
0.2909549177,
0.2897249758,
0.3158688247,
-0.5852900147,
-0.6605923176,
-0.661459744,
-0.1495243609,
0.4464302361,
0.3335087895,
-0.4683286548,
-0.1806251705,
-0.0416354388,
0.2856780589,
0.5318866968,
0.0286861714,
0.8108198643,
0.0341721028,
-0.7895330191,
0.0864110813,
0.4507449269,
0.5781910419,
-0.4578659534,
-0.0620982796,
-0.0327188484,
-0.0481010005,
-0.1194175705,
-0.2610962689,
0.402112633,
-0.1653689891,
0.2796208262,
-0.3624096811,
1.0241554976,
-0.2638785839,
-0.4211876094,
0.3358938992,
0.6485636234,
-0.0925164446,
0.1837494224,
-0.5425319672,
0.1610722095,
-0.1979212612,
-0.0962305591,
0.2097086459,
-0.0746378154,
0.0059218197,
0.7488642335,
0.7593644857,
0.0777698681,
0.0548106916,
0.1266202778,
1.0529421568,
-0.3119647205,
-0.2184550911,
-0.7106004953,
0.6830254793,
-0.1623973697,
-0.3014024198,
0.5931286812,
0.3822451532,
0.5166803598,
0.2784804404,
0.7190614939,
-0.2164672315,
0.3649451137,
-0.0480232351,
1.1724137068,
-0.2410577238,
0.1667345613,
-0.265291512,
-0.5043773651,
-0.5816624761,
0.6665353179,
-0.0405795798,
0.1180983409,
0.5083302259,
1.0271594524,
0.0913201794,
0.3733223975,
0.5017704964,
0.3356674314,
0.7238326669,
0.0163886696,
0.9716007113,
-0.2430913597,
0.5032302141,
-0.3260984123,
-0.3607898355,
-0.0558998957,
-1.0214942694,
-1.0892133713,
-0.3540164828,
-0.2204795331,
-0.2496191114,
-0.0808266476,
1.1033027172,
0.7820882201,
-0.556473732,
-0.2798020542,
0.0623546876,
0.0001232742,
0.0173956733,
-0.2801174223,
-0.4581798017,
-0.0804111734,
-0.519736886,
0.5719841123,
0.2340859175,
-0.3181869984,
-0.6408079863,
-0.1813965738,
-0.0503353179,
0.4655703604,
0.8573798537,
0.0324391834,
-0.8706413507,
-0.5421939492,
-0.0455777422,
-0.4162001312,
-0.1055534184,
0.906586051,
-0.3715358675,
0.8467910886,
0.5762076974,
0.4127002656,
-0.1552512497,
0.026345646,
0.6593068242,
-0.5847436786,
-0.1122756004,
0.4612153172,
0.2240232825,
0.4780237079,
-0.1256652474,
0.2648534179,
0.2595312297,
-0.7007117867,
-0.7369348407,
0.1822317988,
-0.8204040527,
-0.1555137038,
1.3049638271,
-0.1750409901,
0.1613909751,
-0.396905154,
-0.4985776246,
0.287284106,
-0.3452549875,
1.2216062546,
0.8276546597,
0.0391099937,
0.1214931831,
-0.7229419351,
0.6218662262,
0.3513688147,
-1.1244164705,
0.123627089,
0.7679153085,
0.2800291777,
0.1510407478,
0.6446124911,
-0.2041153759,
0.1039689854,
-0.4114198387,
-0.3108940125,
0.1440701336,
-0.1286312193,
-0.3636452258,
0.1720845252,
0.2610759735,
0.8457620144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09783v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09783v2
|
Investigating Data Contamination in Modern Benchmarks for Large Language Models
| 2023-11-16T11:03:04 | 2024-04-03T23:29:03 |
Chunyuan Deng, Yilun Zhao, Xiangru Tang, Mark Gerstein, Arman Cohan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent observations have underscored a disparity between the inflated
benchmark scores and the actual performance of LLMs, raising concerns about
potential contamination of evaluation benchmarks. This issue is especially
critical for closed-source models and certain open-source models where training
data transparency is lacking. In this paper we study data contamination by
proposing two methods tailored for both open-source and proprietary LLMs. We
first introduce a retrieval-based system to explore potential overlaps between
evaluation benchmarks and pretraining corpora. We further present a novel
investigation protocol named \textbf{T}estset \textbf{S}lot Guessing
(\textit{TS-Guessing}), applicable to both open and proprietary models. This
approach entails masking a wrong answer in a multiple-choice question and
prompting the model to fill in the gap. Additionally, it involves obscuring an
unlikely word in an evaluation example and asking the model to produce it. We
find that certain commercial LLMs could surprisingly guess the missing option
in various test sets. Specifically, in the TruthfulQA benchmark, we find that
LLMs exhibit notable performance improvement when provided with additional
metadata in the benchmark. Further, in the MMLU benchmark, ChatGPT and GPT-4
demonstrated an exact match rate of 52\% and 57\%, respectively, in guessing
the missing options in benchmark test data. We hope these results underscore
the need for more robust evaluation methodologies and benchmarks in the field.
|
[
-0.4442004263,
-0.6907476187,
0.7257953882,
-0.1083434373,
-0.0349541381,
0.1320182085,
-0.2388074696,
-0.8664920926,
-0.2883836329,
0.6556528211,
-0.3167793155,
-0.4891551137,
-0.6001683474,
-0.0981599167,
-0.4474338591,
0.706951797,
-0.3586219251,
0.1410443336,
-0.4311240315,
-0.2958221734,
-0.3431760669,
-0.6516920328,
-0.2813838124,
-0.2525997162,
0.3588315845,
0.2551456094,
0.6152135134,
0.9126261473,
0.6465355158,
0.2682920396,
-0.1591857225,
0.1738660634,
-0.6080482602,
0.1320465803,
-0.3469456434,
-0.6446805596,
-0.1746497899,
0.2462995946,
0.6514198184,
0.6870423555,
-0.0781943649,
0.4068205357,
-0.0328089371,
0.4684074521,
-1.2221915722,
-0.0920111835,
-0.8104785681,
0.0214679707,
-0.5216392279,
-0.3283042312,
-0.4419542253,
-0.4516623616,
0.0054598823,
-0.4787986875,
0.2730728388,
0.0518563278,
0.8422433138,
0.3061704636,
-0.1440482885,
-0.2452614307,
-0.7958487272,
0.9758065939,
-0.6288559437,
0.3613317013,
0.4998500943,
0.4752578735,
-0.1964010745,
-0.7249732018,
-0.2486110479,
-0.3239637911,
0.1389148682,
-0.0730721802,
-0.2385312319,
-0.0878631473,
0.434420675,
0.4755542874,
-0.2026090622,
0.2795947492,
-0.4474349022,
-0.305254668,
0.5422519445,
0.0027426048,
0.146617189,
0.0274761021,
-0.5498117208,
-0.1211354509,
-1.289303422,
-0.1912177801,
0.506397903,
0.2452622354,
0.2014227659,
0.7043750882,
-0.2418927252,
0.7654308081,
-0.4146051407,
0.1821725368,
0.3616030514,
-0.4991272986,
-0.4090574682,
0.0247260183,
0.702978313,
0.1665741354,
0.2863253653,
-0.298093468,
-0.3201543391,
-0.032015752,
0.1520987004,
-0.5339487195,
0.0022420497,
0.2761664689,
-0.0916006863,
-0.3270125985,
-0.0188986175,
-0.6963723898,
-0.493018806,
-0.3139336109,
0.7691423893,
-0.1862704903,
-0.2408885062,
0.1531305313,
-0.0744311661,
-0.0078485413,
0.2316544503,
-0.6289276481,
0.3975914121,
0.9325121045,
0.5833669901,
-0.1967186183,
-0.1040823013,
-0.8533790708,
0.1103336215,
-0.3521310985,
0.6615145802,
-0.6288027167,
-0.3238320351,
0.0377521329,
-0.2504943013,
0.0448163077,
-1.0378313065,
0.5847391486,
-0.5720820427,
0.2398517132,
-0.3236687481,
-0.7561770678,
0.0981676504,
0.1647417396,
-0.7103048563,
1.3887021542,
-0.0308914781,
-1.0138862133,
0.3897049725,
-0.3841512799,
-0.0492996387,
0.0621571727,
-0.411649704,
-0.2649000585,
-0.0574773662,
0.124059774,
0.1822525561,
-0.2737960219,
0.2781695426,
-0.5884398818,
-0.7642261982,
0.4166349769,
-0.6120501757,
0.6689062715,
0.2202793658,
-0.4723124504,
-0.0804357529,
-0.8651574254,
0.2880111337,
-0.0111418637,
-0.1504967511,
-0.521545887,
-0.2368114293,
-0.1595998704,
0.1096653789,
0.1997392178,
-0.4978424907,
-0.1694300026,
-0.0521727502,
0.3657587469,
0.9578095675,
0.0164411403,
0.1705142558,
-0.6010419726,
0.4834555089,
-0.0532139838,
0.257209003,
-0.0359776691,
-0.2113283873,
-0.7944420576,
-0.2974244654,
0.6025819778,
0.3612892032,
-0.4822863042,
0.1584208012,
-0.2950441837,
-0.6741108894,
-0.8940054178,
-0.0135043738,
0.4891713262,
0.4185420573,
0.3992556334,
-0.2797394693,
-0.4212600589,
-1.015869379,
-0.5846269131,
0.0093130479,
-0.3489269912,
0.4757145941,
0.5648218989,
0.0537491217,
0.9720781446,
-0.4272755682,
0.0025682659,
0.2748842239,
0.0451121107,
0.0919873193,
0.5260146856,
0.2155948132,
-0.519554317,
-0.2925581336,
-0.3492760658,
-0.6403926611,
-0.2329251468,
0.2499662191,
-0.1099591702,
-0.0725208148,
0.6580397487,
-0.4518689513,
0.1557907611,
0.4561014175,
0.246331811,
0.8316332102,
-0.176500231,
0.127425164,
-0.6391410828,
0.2843438983,
-0.0512998402,
-0.2394507378,
-0.4841148853,
0.3479203582,
0.2702245116,
0.2300432473,
-0.765540719,
0.4972453117,
-0.4967629313,
-0.3506552577,
0.0612710118,
0.40887779,
0.0099375034,
-0.0220972858,
-0.2010149062,
1.0745749474,
0.4767799973,
-0.4096778035,
-0.0074189724,
0.1759483218,
-0.6830337048,
0.3379008174,
-0.4658104479,
0.3108690679,
0.0211714953,
0.0936254635,
-0.8565084338,
-0.0136129931,
0.2777744532,
-0.2187471837,
0.275280565,
-0.1834506989,
-0.8154152036,
0.0272993147,
-0.3699149489,
0.4193278849,
0.3334017098,
-0.7129802704,
0.0684673935,
0.2172818482,
-0.0913452879,
-0.9530784488,
-0.7088105083,
0.0581811443,
-0.3049421906,
-0.5647711754,
0.198259145,
-0.1899227798,
-0.5126787424,
0.0072745653,
-0.4127940536,
-0.1249901801,
0.3617109358,
0.1493926346,
0.3548385203,
-0.2313598394,
0.1368881464,
-0.2130725384,
0.1567703187,
0.1460463256,
0.1692654192,
0.4755534232,
-0.0215135328,
-0.7085424066,
-0.1335446239,
0.0459187105,
0.4372441769,
-0.3591925204,
0.495395571,
0.2292155772,
-0.3704812527,
-0.1877182424,
-0.8344176412,
0.0133341905,
-0.5536624789,
0.2638646662,
-0.4111485481,
-0.6646712422,
0.3416273594,
-0.1693321317,
-0.1307530403,
0.2729697227,
0.2804370821,
-0.0083655538,
0.603278935,
0.4615033269,
0.0193095896,
0.3813436627,
-0.0251110848,
-0.0346103758,
-0.8151663542,
-0.1043400541,
-0.7377635241,
-0.0412449948,
-0.6605204344,
-0.6733921766,
0.1943269074,
0.1792778969,
-0.2418834269,
0.143113777,
-0.1383226365,
0.8266882896,
0.6742352247,
0.1682679951,
0.7398383021,
-0.163458094,
-0.3790306747,
-0.0961951017,
-0.505672574,
-0.5187379122,
1.465805769,
0.4023011327,
0.7422044873,
-0.1007342711,
0.8870691061,
0.2220850736,
0.561406672,
-0.2995321155,
0.4500181079,
0.0401712507,
-0.7947243452,
-0.1760083288,
-0.6514264345,
-0.8823934793,
0.3624862134,
-0.1259693205,
-0.8598744273,
0.1074267626,
-0.2482213974,
-0.0774156004,
0.3011708856,
-0.6009255052,
0.7135591507,
-0.2846693099,
-0.6817494631,
0.0297365934,
-0.5717731118,
0.6420249939,
-0.4277692735,
0.2910842001,
-0.1822920889,
0.0126882736,
0.6434445381,
-0.3126516342,
0.5065295696,
0.064633891,
-0.2561542988,
-0.0318615064,
0.1384779215,
0.5138610005,
-0.1589728892,
-0.2221415788,
0.3241607249,
0.0691313967,
-0.4251159728,
-0.3202004731,
0.6391267776,
-0.6247283816,
-0.5450567007,
-0.5199357271,
-0.4576101899,
-0.5482649803,
0.3505872786,
0.425168097,
0.2464893609,
-0.1992694139,
0.244797945,
0.7645753622,
-0.3123632669,
0.160908252,
0.8105796576,
-0.026501447,
-0.127183035,
0.5841929317,
0.0807540417,
0.685898304,
0.2845706344,
0.0027100253,
-0.3795584142,
-0.7338345647,
-0.2022856921,
0.377455622,
-0.7485599518,
-0.1778887212,
-0.4232651591,
-0.3623082042,
-0.1030405611,
0.3034742773,
-0.5217480659,
-0.1634724438,
-0.1898177117,
-0.2018942386,
-0.0615725294,
0.7900250554,
-0.0616121404,
0.0245077498,
-0.7411572933,
0.1221804395,
-0.132059291,
0.7303267717,
-0.0634157434,
-0.3130100369,
-0.1153250933,
0.1024855152,
-0.2193184644,
-0.6588851213,
0.0037271318,
-0.1251510829,
0.8583215475,
0.3438410163,
0.1969684213,
0.5884245038,
-0.4745694101,
0.5826115608,
0.0319730267,
-0.985130012,
0.2985269129,
-0.3375285268,
0.1137992889,
0.7839762568,
0.4371385574,
-0.6202925444,
-0.9207669497,
-0.6340045929,
-0.7586590052,
0.6240810156,
0.2442048788,
-0.3037443757,
0.1172153205,
0.1498611122,
0.2822826505,
0.3380368054,
-0.5014497042,
-0.3337114453,
0.4104018211,
0.0085581848,
-0.2157995403,
-0.1948461384,
-0.3468435407,
0.132364586,
0.5271639824,
0.2445984334,
-0.051543165,
0.0228226427,
-0.3788549006,
-0.144584924,
0.3425209522,
0.4485088885,
0.9794968367,
-0.4005814493,
0.2507582605,
0.0527174659,
-0.3399308324,
0.1567535102,
0.1682192534,
-0.1811281741,
0.0590892062,
0.248114109,
0.4356873035,
0.4001404643,
-0.9175769687,
0.5575818419,
-0.0461925007,
-0.0953066126,
-0.3036762178,
0.0629281998,
0.1684573442,
0.1309196502,
0.4279498458,
0.0847659484,
0.1348462552,
-0.6540444493,
0.4892471433,
0.3453659713,
-0.3039999604,
0.0011370182,
0.6985238194,
-0.1510948241,
-0.0546860322,
0.5087012053,
0.0409706458,
-0.4176807404,
0.5687381029,
0.296900481,
0.5863554478,
-0.2058447301,
0.1377255768,
0.0712652579,
0.4077028632,
-0.2664403021,
0.1496473402,
0.0768325776,
-0.5430775881,
-0.4656988978,
-0.3775449097,
-0.7517895699,
0.6189130545,
-0.8373621106,
0.332498461,
-0.2415405065,
0.054413747,
0.0570927784,
0.1208680496,
-0.7361272573,
0.0733479559,
0.3527784348,
1.2317599058,
-0.8317232132,
0.6456362605,
0.1598171443,
-0.4248630106,
-0.6264306307,
0.0793441758,
-0.1022166759,
-0.8781902194,
0.5505841374,
0.2319109887,
0.1338212043,
-0.4227976799,
-0.4212020934,
-1.0314390659,
0.8586473465,
0.604511559,
-0.5694307685,
0.1483963728,
0.4238417149,
0.5225170255,
-0.0064218282,
0.4246554375,
0.899740696,
0.5895188451,
-0.2079451382,
-1.0429917574,
0.2921293676,
-0.0852824599,
-0.2771500647,
0.3528544009,
-0.576838553,
0.766469121,
0.1217525974,
-0.3282040954,
0.3134650886,
0.0672633052,
0.4279173911,
0.4843236506,
0.3488119245,
0.5034233332,
1.0429676771,
-0.0966217741,
0.8859568834,
-0.1928261966,
0.4307277799,
1.5323245525,
-0.5763117671,
1.0934715271,
0.4620095193,
-0.3640978932,
0.1327280104,
0.8067828417,
-0.2131661922,
0.4938892424,
0.762245059,
-0.3472068012,
0.0753433034,
-0.1262276918,
-0.5544852018,
0.357658565,
0.2060783356,
-0.3376871943,
-0.4857365489,
-0.2693943381,
0.0280964673,
-0.0038333617,
-0.0947084054,
0.5174196959,
-0.1040864587,
-0.7569876909,
0.6233959198,
-0.0681545585,
0.5587661862,
-0.5284841657,
0.1336186379,
-0.3628082573,
0.1346328706,
-0.1488726586,
-0.6572377086,
0.0205174126,
-0.0951949507,
0.262627691,
-0.2144189328,
0.5533192754,
-0.5178920627,
-0.1165113002,
0.5039619207,
0.7806767821,
0.4156889021,
-0.2806696892,
-0.4674650729,
0.2912529111,
-0.2145811319,
-0.1000491604,
0.6109997034,
0.2375805378,
-0.0483186357,
0.7067242861,
0.6040445566,
0.257607162,
0.2342925966,
0.0648348182,
0.8036785126,
-0.4806225896,
-0.2288162708,
-0.7627362013,
0.0335189961,
-0.0751419514,
-0.0705628544,
0.7384807467,
0.957672298,
0.9702703357,
0.1990672052,
0.839849472,
0.4350113869,
0.6080622077,
-0.5870993733,
0.6517716646,
-0.4511229396,
0.5357201099,
-0.1984197795,
-0.9976011515,
0.0378197767,
-0.0557706952,
-0.4164748192,
0.0631508827,
0.8674675226,
0.6747738719,
-0.3392817378,
0.0625522062,
0.2928158343,
0.2633643746,
0.3340958953,
0.5168288946,
0.971329093,
-0.349224478,
0.7576218843,
-0.2421287596,
-0.3250390589,
-0.2719457746,
-0.8705260158,
-0.4908495843,
-0.2288174182,
-0.2834548652,
-0.4013614655,
0.2740961313,
0.4380075037,
0.5228021741,
-0.6577345133,
-0.1489641517,
0.0093464293,
0.0247991644,
-0.2346969545,
-0.2369209826,
0.3348494768,
-0.3633395731,
-0.7785754204,
0.5508657694,
-0.2070412189,
0.0852238163,
-0.3458606899,
0.304836154,
-0.1205188259,
0.11821419,
0.1259842366,
0.1737829,
-0.4736697078,
-0.4019312263,
-0.0870205536,
-0.1912966818,
0.2787846327,
0.6993454099,
-0.6077318788,
0.4828142524,
0.2720553875,
0.8193362951,
0.7555336952,
0.122981213,
0.701038003,
-0.9331278801,
-0.1098845229,
0.3114641309,
0.2699365616,
0.4807335436,
-0.3487316668,
0.7116703987,
0.048926048,
-0.4155083597,
-1.2011421919,
0.1374182999,
-0.7640763521,
-0.2967066765,
1.1431519985,
-0.2344383448,
-0.1464487016,
-0.0676808506,
0.2612525821,
0.1061820239,
-0.135350883,
0.9050505757,
1.1477748156,
0.1129829288,
0.2210195065,
-1.1182365417,
0.2989911437,
0.4335948825,
-0.8224600554,
0.2699888349,
0.4682875276,
0.7145926952,
0.1351001561,
0.5434029698,
-0.4315408766,
0.2288555801,
0.0856765583,
-0.0858201236,
-0.2026256025,
-0.0137140555,
-0.3900421262,
0.0911492258,
0.0071137222,
-0.3781476915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09782v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09782v2
|
More Samples or More Prompts? Exploring Effective In-Context Sampling for LLM Few-Shot Prompt Engineering
| 2023-11-16T11:02:49 | 2024-04-02T17:16:40 |
Bingsheng Yao, Guiming Chen, Ruishi Zou, Yuxuan Lu, Jiachen Li, Shao Zhang, Yisi Sang, Sijia Liu, James Hendler, Dakuo Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While most existing works on LLM prompting techniques focus only on how to
select a better set of data samples inside one single prompt input (In-Context
Learning or ICL), why can not we design and leverage multiple prompts together
to further improve the LLM's performance? In this work, we propose In-Context
Sampling (ICS), a low-resource LLM prompting technique to produce confident
predictions by optimizing the construction of multiple ICL prompt inputs.
Extensive experiments with three open-source LLMs (FlanT5-XL, Mistral-7B, and
Mixtral-8x7B) on four NLI datasets (e-SNLI, Multi-NLI, ANLI, and Contract-NLI)
and one QA dataset (CommonsenseQA) illustrate that ICS can consistently enhance
LLMs' performance. An in-depth evaluation with three data similarity-based ICS
strategies suggests that these strategies can further elevate LLM's
performance, which sheds light on a new yet promising future research
direction.
|
[
-0.7335970998,
-0.4718032479,
0.7953280807,
0.3652592003,
-0.1967070699,
0.0714304745,
-0.0150985373,
-0.378441602,
-0.1327830106,
0.0223036855,
-0.9219333529,
-0.4522843957,
0.006569284,
0.4318466187,
-0.0868421867,
0.6578682065,
-0.0067588054,
0.2645053566,
-0.3826978505,
-0.0000268983,
-0.6081487536,
-0.1299377084,
-0.7394114733,
-0.4066590965,
0.5944796205,
0.9430530667,
-0.0273104068,
0.0300772078,
0.1539244354,
0.1464877725,
-0.2462173849,
0.3901241124,
-0.3136799932,
0.1603678912,
0.3300079107,
-0.5136103034,
-0.1256680191,
0.1359696537,
0.5814629197,
0.491556555,
0.2170211673,
0.4514618516,
0.5791752338,
0.377954036,
-0.8512977958,
-0.0257760603,
-0.5108247399,
0.0654413477,
-0.1471312791,
-0.3501459062,
-0.6201398373,
-0.3371761143,
0.1002042443,
-0.5959481001,
-0.0455183685,
0.3644147217,
0.3082145452,
0.2645736635,
-0.2358496934,
-0.1751965731,
-0.3613376319,
0.9847629666,
-0.7943813205,
0.1818231642,
0.2393712848,
0.4039164484,
-0.2743874788,
-0.4880122244,
-0.4172625244,
-0.311583966,
0.0497854054,
0.3623273969,
0.05006852,
0.0923174545,
0.471955359,
-0.2862408161,
-0.3687129319,
0.4844440818,
-0.1188661754,
-0.0730699301,
0.4291471541,
0.2914816439,
-0.1098513752,
-0.0934175923,
-0.7976194024,
-0.1378233433,
-1.2008681297,
0.5628845692,
0.1261817366,
0.6378253698,
-0.1621568799,
0.4032792449,
-0.2704944313,
0.7837867737,
0.2469234467,
-0.3614496589,
-0.0463784859,
-0.4588079751,
-0.1480240077,
0.2040741742,
0.6836836934,
0.3465934694,
-0.1250201613,
0.1423188299,
-0.3293809295,
-0.3139125705,
-0.0018710592,
-0.7833278179,
0.111757718,
0.3803920448,
-0.4431533813,
-0.1814671159,
0.11235746,
-0.848598659,
-0.5160012841,
-0.4206869304,
0.2981616855,
-0.48917377,
0.2450437695,
-0.1605061442,
-0.2455979288,
0.3646110892,
0.48034361,
-0.529615581,
0.0882341266,
0.5821110606,
0.8428250551,
-0.4857837558,
-0.4314936101,
-0.7537513971,
-0.0007015733,
-0.3525614142,
1.0141400099,
-0.4459010363,
-0.7276588678,
0.0478618592,
-0.5467359424,
0.1892063022,
-0.6630864739,
0.2186545134,
-0.4843939841,
0.0605368428,
-0.6278702021,
-0.6099600792,
0.1977959573,
0.4973106384,
-0.6448228359,
1.0541470051,
-0.0097430982,
-0.5768174529,
0.6778744459,
-0.7247248888,
-0.0310786702,
0.1180129051,
-0.4911399484,
-0.1981266886,
0.1485071182,
0.3417801261,
0.5114126801,
-0.2425880134,
-0.1111801043,
-0.4694169462,
-0.6966657639,
0.4486129284,
-0.4982558191,
0.7154095173,
0.3813835382,
-0.1209258363,
0.1212241501,
-0.5561143756,
0.1520912349,
-0.414232403,
-0.4953989089,
-0.0134798866,
-0.3338114619,
0.0038558275,
0.2830335498,
-0.0851285085,
-0.5626916289,
0.2527301013,
-0.3807789683,
0.0877935141,
0.7358117104,
0.1672341824,
0.6603762507,
-0.7580945492,
0.8537722826,
-0.0430761389,
0.033372052,
-0.436686337,
-0.4811860919,
-0.2881525457,
-0.3763281703,
0.0456438623,
0.5174950361,
-0.9688213468,
0.0246961508,
-0.0223153215,
-0.2770701647,
-0.3553115129,
0.2011419535,
0.2192175239,
0.7197354436,
0.3290701509,
0.1459885687,
-0.5323562622,
-0.5465763807,
-0.2253236324,
-0.1188535616,
-0.3411224186,
0.4197811782,
0.2719770372,
0.368173331,
1.402670145,
-0.3279358745,
-0.1857603192,
-0.4487629533,
0.064389579,
0.4168590605,
0.2627821863,
0.6649664044,
-0.3607490361,
-0.5821054578,
-0.4110156298,
-0.5449935794,
-0.0821782351,
-0.2927990556,
-0.0103293536,
-0.3128757179,
0.6886790395,
-0.4434414804,
0.3046215773,
0.2488476485,
0.0045124195,
0.5413197875,
0.14780581,
0.1084362715,
-1.0584719181,
-0.1825079024,
0.0854855329,
0.057530582,
-0.5107331276,
0.0634680241,
0.1617606133,
-0.1722568274,
-1.0611542463,
0.9333888292,
-0.5440353751,
-0.0364969894,
-0.3537946939,
0.1255328655,
-0.0276555605,
0.3249326646,
-0.3560002148,
1.2113907337,
0.6505624652,
-0.9072079062,
0.2099697888,
0.2743293941,
-0.490809381,
0.7056363821,
-0.6158471704,
0.1851779073,
-0.2441357672,
0.5591813326,
-1.1177128553,
-0.2722683251,
0.1139069349,
-0.2885074914,
0.1639260948,
-0.0641220436,
-0.5244688988,
-0.2548733652,
-0.6276180744,
0.5548009276,
0.4785377085,
-0.9155184031,
0.416754216,
-0.02812282,
-0.0842156634,
-0.5828309059,
-0.7456483841,
-0.1637831777,
-0.3871391118,
-0.408588618,
0.4103844464,
-0.3436343074,
-0.3160065711,
-0.2098264247,
-0.1084120572,
0.0480802953,
0.3191200495,
0.2556020319,
0.3841053247,
-0.1005655229,
0.2171176523,
0.0488426052,
-0.1437396556,
0.0877475441,
-0.5073486567,
0.3631150424,
0.1709493995,
-0.6665494442,
-0.7254254818,
0.3347129822,
0.144352898,
0.2782337666,
0.1483377814,
0.3573081195,
-0.4032404423,
-0.5690003037,
-0.3242033124,
-0.5663409233,
-0.4924397767,
-0.1983447969,
-0.4862165749,
-0.881066978,
0.3142135441,
-0.4860477746,
0.2743997872,
-0.0338459015,
0.2509921193,
-0.4485724568,
0.8500835299,
0.5449419022,
-0.3096700311,
0.6757203341,
-0.3960694969,
-0.2185787112,
-0.7213273644,
0.0143770073,
-0.5397466421,
-0.6000340581,
-0.2078890055,
-0.2238050848,
0.7712150812,
-0.0149733862,
-0.0498962365,
0.0095752645,
-0.2668879628,
0.720993042,
0.8311619163,
0.2251764685,
0.1377259195,
0.0923261791,
-0.462282598,
0.1192612946,
-0.8871515989,
-0.5967946053,
0.9109594822,
0.0021005028,
0.7975298762,
-0.1167306751,
0.9617502689,
-0.1977236122,
0.2394419163,
-0.8386521935,
0.5497578979,
0.3047747016,
-0.5481085777,
-0.3272089064,
-0.1564054638,
-0.8454585075,
-0.0428306423,
-0.2302971482,
-0.684697628,
0.3467221558,
0.3173175752,
-1.0336623192,
0.189704299,
-0.4929802418,
0.2053993791,
0.0063933572,
-0.2451027483,
-0.0766649991,
-0.5145670176,
0.2365476191,
0.0182201546,
0.1479062587,
-0.1031703427,
-0.1126856729,
0.3176192939,
-0.2968282998,
1.0565334558,
-0.232750088,
-0.0560016073,
0.6579169631,
-0.1113810763,
0.6203953028,
0.3371923566,
-0.4464849532,
-0.2779625654,
-0.1629970372,
-0.3189833462,
-0.6202803254,
0.6835544109,
-0.3564323783,
-0.2148112059,
-0.1778753996,
-0.3419533372,
-0.5366965532,
0.0051305844,
0.7924072742,
0.571852386,
-0.0561958775,
0.1350636333,
0.6353048086,
-0.1243269667,
0.9159279466,
0.0676017404,
0.1840761602,
-0.3032270968,
0.6362637877,
-0.059046533,
0.2191189826,
0.4152001739,
0.1028968766,
-0.3167566657,
-0.617692709,
-0.4829215109,
-0.0907701775,
-0.6054407358,
-0.549736917,
-0.3121233284,
0.0464365222,
-0.3081592321,
-0.4421185255,
-0.0975612253,
-0.0649516881,
-0.6873216033,
-0.1658540964,
0.3372852802,
0.6422293782,
0.0845736042,
0.5870934725,
-0.8524411321,
0.1870809495,
0.3754819036,
0.3969422579,
0.0471108481,
-0.3454327881,
-0.0648639277,
-0.005889175,
-0.3569064736,
-0.8431771994,
0.2018102705,
0.039902214,
0.741890192,
0.2787801325,
0.1881737113,
0.7315443158,
-0.4449153543,
0.9903219342,
0.1482198685,
-0.6850600839,
0.6605249643,
-0.0568349101,
0.614593327,
0.9514552355,
0.436203897,
-0.3130000234,
-0.2262501568,
-0.426282227,
-0.6909433603,
0.7191114426,
-0.0905936062,
0.005900518,
0.0198946428,
0.4167403579,
0.2316157222,
0.1476450711,
-0.273023963,
-0.25910905,
0.167404145,
-0.3521461487,
0.1987952739,
-0.2618611455,
-0.2458358705,
0.0846038014,
0.5687792897,
-0.6646731496,
0.197223261,
0.2494999319,
-0.0008765796,
0.0189407058,
0.287920028,
0.5298030376,
0.6602758765,
-0.0284208097,
0.171866864,
0.7331444621,
-0.1764960438,
0.2337973267,
-0.1490802467,
-0.4106765985,
-0.0513987467,
0.2707037926,
0.7370638251,
0.2629404664,
-0.6073248386,
0.4559397101,
-0.0997330099,
0.0031055026,
-0.2398967594,
0.0938832462,
-0.2006807029,
0.3925248981,
0.6504968405,
0.0273046345,
0.3426960111,
-0.241667822,
0.2386843264,
0.5059642196,
-0.3980958462,
-0.1826312393,
0.5098602772,
0.0940957591,
-0.1459450573,
0.4617739916,
-0.3655963838,
0.0845127404,
0.6858932972,
0.4374388754,
0.7580621243,
0.1926632226,
0.1198744699,
0.4369602501,
-0.0364606902,
-0.2134685069,
0.5158593655,
-0.1027786061,
-0.6005309224,
-0.5956660509,
-0.1960214972,
-0.741014719,
0.1360048652,
-0.3858952522,
0.7470732927,
-0.578176558,
-0.191843465,
-0.4977399707,
-0.0513005964,
-0.7679384947,
0.0375640467,
0.236220032,
1.1408491135,
-0.5517400503,
0.5163448453,
0.6711655855,
-0.1779001057,
-0.9527739882,
0.0769969299,
0.5376183987,
-0.4739420414,
0.5657160878,
0.3030655086,
-0.2010021508,
0.1016714871,
-1.0762624741,
-0.8480249643,
1.4782354832,
0.2961994112,
-0.4469072223,
-0.0715337396,
-0.2889065742,
0.0576474853,
-0.5134262443,
0.4605304599,
0.3976820707,
0.3698955178,
0.1068545729,
-0.5668793917,
-0.041748669,
-0.0167813879,
-0.0202163607,
-0.2401739657,
-0.5576871037,
0.6520006657,
-0.3825862408,
-0.3623320162,
0.2207567841,
0.8089959621,
1.16365695,
0.6245679855,
0.6589033008,
0.0249300897,
0.8738135695,
0.1004110873,
1.079441309,
-0.3802884817,
0.0035826527,
1.2094562054,
-0.4227124155,
0.6231840849,
0.6647087932,
-0.0287531242,
0.1346892416,
0.8774437904,
0.1434552521,
0.4218051732,
0.1098776609,
-0.473968029,
-0.043498911,
-0.377879411,
-0.1848539412,
0.2675527632,
0.2425968945,
0.1661514044,
-0.2766151726,
0.2475048006,
-0.2389299273,
-0.2232448757,
-0.0380231999,
0.7409626842,
0.2142702639,
-0.5965440869,
0.2440298051,
-0.4000629783,
1.0022227764,
-0.4116612375,
-0.1355318725,
-0.4214168489,
-0.323628515,
-0.0502616242,
-0.7163851857,
-0.2451987565,
-0.0704008341,
-0.0163872056,
-0.6222038865,
0.6368959546,
-0.2266756892,
-0.1610860378,
0.0713334084,
0.6836493611,
0.1263054162,
-0.0354437344,
-0.4202535152,
-0.1433009654,
-0.2195187807,
-0.1445524693,
0.372667402,
0.5295419097,
0.0370422304,
0.7393401265,
0.6878069043,
0.2502335012,
0.0084927874,
0.2202065736,
0.8550797701,
-0.6333010197,
-0.348475337,
-0.8510770202,
0.5913299918,
-0.0213244632,
-0.6426354051,
0.680829227,
0.4359241128,
0.9763994217,
-0.0188713148,
0.874951601,
0.3318105638,
0.4741599262,
-0.7951296568,
0.3323357403,
-0.3814712763,
0.4320563078,
-0.2762274742,
-0.720777452,
-0.2467330247,
0.2295280099,
0.1490924954,
-0.0044468562,
0.6070324183,
0.8291516304,
0.0782086253,
0.0280968621,
0.2800567448,
-0.2416374683,
0.4576531053,
0.491050303,
1.2921088934,
-0.1028052121,
0.4507316351,
-0.3574835062,
-0.1997237056,
-0.3773979545,
-1.0098208189,
-0.5912213922,
-0.3948246837,
-0.0688417628,
-0.114814803,
-0.3599921167,
1.4447722435,
0.8553086519,
-0.7601263523,
-0.3042007685,
-0.0362804756,
0.2376807332,
-0.3552685678,
-0.1465536952,
-0.0546944812,
-0.7594237328,
-0.8310863972,
1.137947917,
0.2332876623,
0.2996125221,
-0.1028451249,
-0.0288722552,
0.0430864431,
-0.0663749278,
0.6658558846,
0.0829223245,
-0.6316845417,
-0.1590506285,
0.4662396908,
-0.2445765585,
0.0118794134,
0.9858253598,
-1.0938192606,
0.1991922557,
0.7727887034,
0.7723363638,
0.1888193339,
0.1760907918,
0.4726898968,
-1.1571452618,
0.0682449788,
0.3284426928,
0.3531128168,
0.1145294383,
-0.5049751997,
0.3592096269,
-0.0486206226,
-0.4497692287,
-0.6800067425,
0.3618579805,
-0.8370993137,
-0.4054840505,
1.2721607685,
0.1032696292,
-0.0377463587,
-0.1498842537,
-0.3820514083,
0.0091562066,
-0.6870361567,
0.457375437,
0.6093638539,
-0.6622534394,
-0.0821480155,
-0.5657458901,
0.6965517402,
0.4305719733,
-0.8515259624,
-0.3350075185,
0.609657526,
0.0441207178,
0.0280823391,
0.7510082126,
0.2793333232,
0.3146618009,
-0.2429660112,
-0.1793008447,
-0.0932431743,
-0.5663659573,
-0.7346026301,
0.4217050374,
0.2393854558,
-0.2963691056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09774v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09774v1
|
HuatuoGPT-II, One-stage Training for Medical Adaption of LLMs
| 2023-11-16T10:56:24 | 2023-11-16T10:56:24 |
Junying Chen, Xidong Wang, Anningzhe Gao, Feng Jiang, Shunian Chen, Hongbo Zhang, Dingjie Song, Wenya Xie, Chuyi Kong, Jianquan Li, Xiang Wan, Haizhou Li, Benyou Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Adapting a language model into a specific domain, a.k.a `domain adaption', is
a common practice when specialized knowledge, e.g. medicine, is not
encapsulated in a general language model like Llama2. The challenge lies in the
heterogeneity of data across the two training stages, as it varies in
languages, genres, or formats. To tackle this and simplify the learning
protocol, we propose to transform heterogeneous data, from the both
pre-training and supervised stages, into a unified, simple input-output pair
format. We validate the new protocol in the domains where proprietary LLMs like
ChatGPT perform relatively poorly, such as Traditional Chinese Medicine. The
developed model, HuatuoGPT-II, has shown state-of-the-art performance in
Chinese medicine domain on a number of benchmarks, e.g. medical licensing
exams. It even outperforms proprietary models like ChatGPT and GPT-4 in some
aspects, especially in Traditional Chinese Medicine. Expert manual evaluations
further validate HuatuoGPT-II's advantages over existing LLMs. Notably,
HuatuoGPT-II was benchmarked in a fresh Chinese National Medical Licensing
Examination where it achieved the best performance, showcasing not only its
effectiveness but also its generalization capabilities.
|
[
0.0488006435,
-0.5815658569,
0.2713476121,
0.192452386,
-0.5766311884,
-0.1248855069,
-0.3334704936,
-0.4309084415,
-0.131721735,
0.3101378381,
-0.2953332961,
-0.4456038773,
-0.5963717699,
-0.145321995,
0.0971479565,
1.1718015671,
-0.1075285748,
0.6562787294,
-0.1127147675,
-0.3000710309,
-0.3364908695,
-0.5346918702,
-0.6989270449,
-0.9317695498,
0.3273663819,
0.39331159,
0.4262060523,
0.5724205971,
0.6597294211,
0.0863286257,
0.1989778727,
0.0142766405,
-0.4209577739,
-0.0456726179,
-0.1966107488,
-0.5058883429,
-0.646355629,
0.0471284613,
0.7319687605,
0.7349742055,
-0.3698593974,
0.0564713702,
0.5045465231,
0.4379261136,
0.0209886432,
0.1040072441,
-0.6749480367,
0.1856549531,
-0.0735896602,
-0.5279114246,
-0.3080484569,
-0.3818559647,
0.2973853052,
-0.7402466536,
0.0994492173,
-0.0804762319,
0.8917027712,
0.2815388143,
-0.5532939434,
-0.0888782665,
-0.6275392771,
0.4094242454,
-0.8305031061,
0.3484448195,
0.1352871209,
0.6816657186,
-0.3273063004,
-0.9785353541,
-0.1356873214,
-0.214767307,
0.0995596722,
0.1892940253,
0.3310421109,
0.1812183112,
0.0047202571,
0.4216456115,
-0.7238627076,
0.4057634175,
-0.4008360505,
-0.3726530671,
0.3889711797,
0.0996774063,
0.381706506,
0.0906456038,
-0.6736568809,
0.1226145923,
-0.9653603435,
-0.0949527472,
-0.1072774827,
0.3076612353,
-0.3537911177,
0.4254146814,
-0.2368964702,
0.3695021272,
0.127894327,
-0.2766452134,
0.1185480729,
-0.3044878244,
-0.3107494414,
0.0574196279,
0.6348943114,
0.1808806658,
0.0951503068,
-0.1598122567,
-0.0018037955,
-0.3263072968,
0.2337569892,
-0.9391545057,
-0.4236959815,
0.394718647,
-0.4255273938,
-0.3854242563,
-0.2290841937,
-0.6587717533,
-0.4712751806,
-0.2522670627,
0.5054332614,
-0.5386433005,
-0.149424836,
0.0992839187,
0.1643707901,
0.6975337863,
0.5487934947,
-0.9524078369,
0.6050840616,
0.8796537519,
0.7790114284,
-0.6503579617,
-0.4479160905,
-0.5383812785,
0.0091492468,
-0.2030251622,
1.0128787756,
-0.1130854562,
-0.3102074862,
0.0679962039,
0.0896239579,
-0.0574327633,
-0.7747296095,
0.4763357043,
-0.292550981,
0.3889095187,
-0.1418123543,
-0.5094000101,
-0.1517987996,
0.3640471399,
-0.2799381018,
0.9161855578,
0.4049392641,
-0.5937087536,
0.4421320856,
-0.6330724955,
-0.5132066607,
0.2458076179,
-0.2304111123,
-0.4543188214,
-0.2097711414,
0.149444893,
0.3412222862,
-0.6551276445,
0.4739550054,
-0.2410894632,
-0.2909691632,
-0.1364343762,
-0.2727912068,
0.9571120143,
-0.0095625818,
-0.2313157469,
-0.0109119574,
-0.7993778586,
0.2025419027,
0.2840957046,
-0.8470293283,
-0.1158119887,
-0.1741342545,
0.0789110363,
0.2882733345,
0.0387424976,
-0.3845767975,
0.5934842229,
-0.4224217832,
0.4270768464,
0.6381998062,
0.0518073142,
0.369432807,
-0.4497956634,
0.4821972549,
0.0998263732,
0.2108648866,
0.1626631171,
-0.6293811798,
-0.7308140993,
-0.0359644517,
0.5557711124,
0.6820371747,
-0.8531527519,
0.1615661234,
-0.2776513398,
-0.5787999034,
-0.5430188179,
0.0491870902,
0.2319903225,
0.7515255809,
0.3116803467,
-0.5643417239,
-0.4776532352,
-0.6363620758,
-0.133983314,
-0.4113866091,
-0.1763893962,
0.1577343643,
0.3092338443,
-0.4326477945,
0.2928779721,
-0.1633224487,
-0.2493114322,
-0.0891057774,
0.0197559427,
0.0478757918,
0.681781292,
0.5011720061,
-0.5444967151,
-0.4467793107,
0.4421165586,
-0.7011728883,
-0.2028361708,
-0.1746300757,
-0.2903736234,
0.0731408074,
0.1880251765,
0.0646623373,
0.1997261047,
0.8738982677,
-0.1467605531,
0.6499792337,
-0.3724121749,
0.1797519922,
-0.9846422076,
-0.01703199,
-0.2728146911,
-0.4265311658,
-0.9218224883,
0.1038436294,
0.1237086579,
0.0490288883,
-0.4469713867,
0.5896995664,
-0.1715846509,
-0.1098199189,
-0.2006331682,
-0.1792418361,
-0.166430071,
0.502985239,
0.2696460485,
0.5874065161,
0.7061555982,
-0.5829681754,
0.4629873037,
0.2168394476,
-0.045243904,
0.6286828518,
-0.7451912761,
0.3290219307,
0.2413781285,
0.184585616,
-0.9002459049,
-0.4038374424,
0.4081705511,
-0.5126833916,
0.3990984559,
-0.1635068506,
-0.1316334158,
-0.134278819,
-0.3080644011,
0.4399005473,
0.7453109622,
-0.6128610373,
0.614813745,
0.1794946045,
-0.0863305852,
-0.3307627439,
-0.783411324,
-0.1407269686,
-0.1911365986,
-0.4125647545,
0.2827506959,
-0.0427038483,
0.2054673433,
-0.1944219321,
-0.1319248676,
-0.4577990174,
0.1608122885,
0.2169523984,
0.346157968,
-0.5813994408,
0.0498239733,
0.2913363278,
-0.1859108806,
-0.0084329089,
-0.4349144101,
0.6553097963,
0.1747485846,
-0.5461394787,
-0.5407015085,
0.1039149091,
0.3252240419,
0.0834524408,
0.2203793973,
0.5584376454,
-0.4956085682,
-0.2832604647,
-0.2679926157,
-0.1676027924,
-0.4267643094,
0.4463473856,
-0.2928315401,
-0.6191629767,
0.2480818629,
-0.4952723682,
0.1355823278,
0.4946421981,
1.0417877436,
-0.0520873629,
0.5367927551,
0.5506391525,
0.1423735321,
0.1413639039,
0.1126303375,
-0.0352897272,
-0.9532952309,
-0.3283721507,
-0.3583038151,
0.0374338068,
-0.6819309592,
-0.5645871162,
0.5066064596,
-0.1444364041,
-0.2901601791,
0.2500568926,
-0.4507656097,
0.0148678282,
0.6349905729,
0.5114513636,
0.3859724104,
0.1835792959,
-0.1613206714,
0.0499980114,
-0.8643561602,
-0.3988167346,
1.574686408,
0.5807854533,
0.6871750951,
-0.1273906231,
0.8533633351,
0.0766930804,
0.5171611309,
-1.0228341818,
0.2491746694,
-0.2887980044,
-0.4291252494,
-0.2690644562,
-0.1206744462,
-0.9076656699,
0.2376631647,
-0.1880986243,
-0.5172486305,
0.0435490794,
0.246194616,
-0.3324477971,
0.2490690053,
-0.4476651549,
0.5800203681,
-0.2967616916,
-0.1843591779,
0.0366255976,
-0.6792836189,
0.4640655518,
-0.4493193924,
-0.0017410375,
-0.1832730174,
-0.0821832195,
0.7273269892,
-0.3859112263,
0.5390172601,
-0.1285387725,
-0.0906527638,
0.1231932119,
0.0497806557,
0.3136041462,
0.1589077562,
-0.0835320204,
0.3909819424,
0.2401136756,
-0.5397207141,
-0.471239686,
0.3491260707,
-0.9226973057,
-0.5540775061,
-0.3529165089,
-0.5258995891,
-0.5290980935,
-0.0217613857,
0.4850318134,
0.2965255082,
-0.4598898292,
-0.0023110581,
0.4657698274,
-0.3902050853,
-0.2423943281,
0.4425923228,
-0.2211987823,
-0.2933053672,
0.5479103923,
-0.127548337,
0.6319501996,
0.1878884435,
0.4644498229,
-0.1238148883,
-0.7298104763,
-0.418958962,
0.2544180453,
-0.7753189802,
-0.0114684673,
-0.4087197781,
-0.5417357087,
-0.6745406389,
0.0292195175,
-0.2646600306,
-0.4069311917,
-0.0798520744,
0.2117451429,
0.0740616098,
0.4216687083,
-0.2410815507,
0.3732360899,
-0.6549325585,
0.58981812,
0.54290694,
0.3349905014,
-0.3736213744,
-1.0447493792,
-0.1946919262,
0.021158604,
-0.2286978811,
-0.7082659006,
0.0278539211,
0.4113765359,
0.65619874,
0.5299383402,
-0.4016571045,
0.5940822959,
-0.6298006177,
0.7236308455,
0.1915566623,
-0.6552411318,
0.6470965743,
-0.2592468858,
0.1161583588,
0.4821742177,
0.256434083,
-0.7519777417,
-0.1125092804,
-0.3469659686,
-0.3991439342,
0.6796246767,
0.0528846458,
0.0324993245,
0.6104797721,
0.6331802011,
0.4564697742,
-0.0020835996,
-0.7290354371,
-0.3436592817,
-0.2086667269,
-0.0837602839,
0.1651350558,
-0.2128288001,
-0.3268081844,
-0.60607934,
0.7545566559,
-0.2572828531,
0.5400149226,
0.2559002936,
0.0620704778,
0.0514110811,
0.2280755788,
0.2370340973,
0.4968150258,
-0.1226825714,
0.2089058161,
0.1770361364,
-0.995934546,
0.4334701598,
0.2186982036,
-0.046889782,
-0.0278943516,
0.5619540811,
0.5615183711,
-0.0110706184,
-0.5038698316,
0.3625432849,
0.1553874761,
-0.4473001957,
0.2614226639,
0.1941432506,
-0.1170973107,
0.2003177404,
0.0856673345,
-0.3611658514,
0.3363650143,
-0.7346608043,
0.4381225109,
-0.0086725922,
-0.4332871139,
-0.4644038379,
0.8588644862,
0.0983935744,
-0.2798045278,
0.3679648638,
-0.0809401944,
-0.4747572839,
0.6968445778,
0.8370880485,
0.7525163293,
-0.656001389,
0.3814863861,
0.5806044936,
0.2351848781,
-0.2301065922,
0.3625831306,
0.1198657826,
-0.7764027715,
-0.0123608597,
-0.3419529498,
-0.4938057065,
0.0457512885,
-0.7331906557,
0.5662630796,
-0.6186525226,
0.0536268763,
0.0598235875,
-0.085775286,
-0.7403876781,
0.2878298461,
0.1973851472,
0.712387085,
-0.8658168316,
1.3093470335,
0.9067515731,
-0.2280703187,
-0.8663347363,
0.0371286869,
0.14411439,
-1.4897258282,
0.2683315277,
-0.1859772801,
0.4082350433,
-0.105082646,
-0.6373369098,
-0.544880867,
1.2634574175,
0.1582920253,
-0.6790470481,
-0.2257822752,
0.6716808677,
0.572579205,
-0.33743608,
-0.0688060969,
0.8334413767,
0.202579543,
0.138082549,
-1.0938259363,
0.2045185119,
-0.0404064395,
0.0769707263,
-0.2916962802,
-0.5013621449,
0.8839673996,
-0.2104168683,
-0.1480133086,
0.0981358737,
0.2254456282,
0.4755321741,
0.3916315138,
0.3751261234,
0.0962985978,
0.8009418845,
-0.2578147352,
0.8500993252,
-0.2243033201,
0.4728336036,
1.3346350193,
-0.3317127228,
0.6337721348,
0.6578591466,
-0.4523759782,
0.3500626087,
0.7697162032,
-0.1142157242,
0.5531833172,
0.1487377137,
-0.0580144562,
-0.1993275881,
-0.0221496467,
-0.5125095844,
0.459849149,
0.3233178556,
-0.1288415194,
-0.2803915441,
0.0636079609,
-0.0481787771,
-0.1284062415,
-0.1073795334,
0.9761490822,
0.2768941224,
-0.4809967875,
0.7896072865,
-0.0372458398,
0.4739359021,
-0.7876455188,
-0.0986843705,
-0.2271931767,
-0.0882170126,
-0.2888195813,
-0.6119191647,
0.0447752886,
-0.239846319,
0.4535806775,
0.3469136357,
0.7932388186,
-0.501588583,
-0.2471843362,
0.1786582917,
0.5817162991,
0.2555316985,
0.0062365192,
-0.6691606641,
-0.3324468732,
0.0513979495,
-0.2572696805,
0.2700828612,
0.5466388464,
-0.0036450101,
0.5236823559,
0.438514024,
0.3655581772,
0.0446991771,
0.132893905,
0.7876733541,
-0.4287390411,
-0.3087667823,
-0.5691518784,
0.3263061345,
0.2750423849,
-0.2892892063,
0.4144119322,
0.4799830616,
0.5622883439,
0.1165846512,
0.9361362457,
0.1777625382,
0.21523799,
-0.6244078279,
0.5645905733,
-0.6901631951,
0.2382155657,
0.1238612458,
-0.7036930919,
-0.409065932,
0.2572887838,
0.0220697206,
-0.1348201782,
0.877589643,
0.4655814171,
0.0083958786,
-0.2479832917,
0.4370763898,
0.2006471902,
0.3070702553,
0.9282326102,
0.631537497,
-0.65117383,
0.2856978774,
-0.3555444777,
-0.3487769365,
-0.3665999472,
-0.6323814988,
-0.8449863791,
-0.4862811565,
-0.4033274353,
-0.5445659161,
0.0918631479,
1.0347310305,
0.7836962938,
-0.8867856264,
-0.1293840408,
0.096327506,
-0.1063835397,
-0.3488095403,
-0.1252212822,
0.5338996053,
-0.3082810044,
-0.5659633875,
0.0845192522,
0.4515813589,
0.3355475664,
-0.1303766072,
-0.2155265361,
0.1660339981,
0.0750978515,
0.4840295017,
0.2568179667,
-0.6497659683,
-0.2637096643,
-0.1824783385,
-0.3120479286,
0.747083962,
0.8230053782,
-0.5690194368,
0.5072650313,
0.3198507428,
0.692404449,
0.2940871119,
0.0066374592,
0.4934794605,
-0.2243061662,
0.4575704932,
0.225194186,
0.3370799422,
0.0881521553,
-0.3937168717,
0.6322901845,
0.2944832742,
-0.5869178772,
-0.713388443,
0.0381969847,
-1.2627075911,
-0.1730752736,
1.539504528,
-0.2173351943,
0.002029724,
-0.2187813967,
-0.3965055645,
0.5029411912,
-0.0114870593,
0.808903873,
0.5044403076,
-0.0215177145,
0.1009733155,
-0.7539140582,
0.5970107317,
0.3486188352,
-1.2904295921,
-0.2097869664,
0.1703515798,
0.6836658716,
-0.3337808251,
1.081029892,
-0.5155519843,
0.5027493834,
0.0734437481,
0.1189378127,
0.1485796273,
-0.0654856488,
-0.7778151035,
-0.1145128533,
0.4277612567,
-0.4107845426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09773v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09773v1
|
To be or not to be? an exploration of continuously controllable prompt engineering
| 2023-11-16T10:55:29 | 2023-11-16T10:55:29 |
Yuhan Sun, Mukai Li, Yixin Cao, Kun Wang, Wenxiao Wang, Xingyu Zeng, Rui Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As the use of large language models becomes more widespread, techniques like
parameter-efficient fine-tuning and other methods for controlled generation are
gaining traction for customizing models and managing their outputs. However,
the challenge of precisely controlling how prompts influence these models is an
area ripe for further investigation. In response, we introduce ControlPE
(Continuously Controllable Prompt Engineering). ControlPE enables finer
adjustments to prompt effects, complementing existing prompt engineering, and
effectively controls continuous targets. This approach harnesses the power of
LoRA (Low-Rank Adaptation) to create an effect akin to prompt weighting,
enabling fine-tuned adjustments to the impact of prompts. Our methodology
involves generating specialized datasets for prompt distillation, incorporating
these prompts into the LoRA model, and carefully adjusting LoRA merging weight
to regulate the influence of prompts. This provides a dynamic and adaptable
tool for prompt control. Through our experiments, we have validated the
practicality and efficacy of ControlPE. It proves to be a promising solution
for control a variety of prompts, ranging from generating short responses
prompts, refusal prompts to chain-of-thought prompts.
|
[
-0.3615105152,
-1.0622874498,
0.5336450934,
0.8624157906,
0.0760146603,
0.2183707654,
-0.1953639835,
-0.2887374461,
0.1565618813,
0.3247753084,
-0.9333274961,
0.130047828,
-0.5309818387,
0.2848522961,
-0.1926817149,
0.7828813791,
-0.1787859648,
-0.2292372882,
0.2647829354,
0.1764863282,
-1.0744765997,
-0.2064506859,
-0.9807716012,
-0.3451092839,
1.0719085932,
0.5166019201,
0.5735971332,
0.1750431508,
0.1387099326,
0.1872803867,
-0.1700791121,
0.0759425685,
-0.6614159346,
0.3405052423,
-0.3439130783,
-0.42764768,
-0.2183671743,
0.2402589172,
0.5611380935,
0.7007707953,
0.0218713023,
0.041384317,
0.4686922133,
0.6237685084,
-0.709466517,
-0.2392753959,
-0.4686178267,
0.1966410875,
0.0376496203,
-0.3695126176,
-0.8634264469,
-0.3721865714,
-0.3336287439,
-0.4668919742,
-0.360009253,
0.6173267365,
0.7733322382,
0.5767711997,
-0.1533828974,
-0.1804571897,
-0.8079098463,
0.7724843621,
-0.3922343254,
-0.087749809,
0.1545101702,
0.5994144678,
-0.5263082981,
-0.5043584108,
-0.3443440795,
-0.40074265,
0.0971205905,
0.1913597584,
-0.4364188015,
0.1005525514,
0.5407529473,
0.0358351171,
-0.1639440507,
0.6949337721,
-0.1184588224,
-0.1578930467,
0.3991548419,
0.0489779115,
0.6116582155,
-0.0675488859,
-0.5412032604,
0.1416238546,
-0.7077781558,
0.5770826936,
0.2771834433,
0.4475124776,
-0.1353968233,
0.8698577285,
-0.2437070459,
0.6448972225,
0.5555433035,
0.1313125044,
-0.3954198658,
-0.2298924327,
-0.332410723,
0.2681573629,
0.8110774755,
0.4533639848,
0.3244770169,
0.0520377643,
-0.2167790681,
-0.0439067446,
0.2998478115,
-0.6848142147,
0.0570324734,
0.2904430628,
-0.409468472,
-0.6032509208,
-0.276065439,
-0.7174854279,
-0.6073299646,
-0.3069101274,
0.4480661452,
-0.2561556399,
0.157139197,
0.0281931628,
-0.3525300026,
0.0069499803,
0.4224057496,
-0.8501942754,
0.2028948069,
0.5111532211,
0.9106218219,
-0.4352340102,
-0.390722692,
-0.955165267,
-0.1517695338,
-0.5539070368,
0.6686753631,
-0.6676452756,
-0.6760018468,
-0.2135909796,
0.1692810953,
0.04621353,
-0.3162356913,
0.4709112942,
-0.4151838124,
0.4271300137,
-0.3475211561,
-0.3171713352,
0.1589872092,
0.0022247226,
-0.612267673,
0.7617655396,
0.1442494094,
-0.4872018397,
0.5140885711,
-0.6708605886,
-0.2157970369,
0.0735292286,
-0.1155343726,
-0.1988352686,
0.2715081871,
-0.1193025038,
0.0637303218,
-0.2079697698,
0.2332839221,
-0.0126709295,
-0.07992962,
0.2399904728,
-0.3297047913,
0.7819347382,
0.2322064191,
-0.3340810835,
0.3749392033,
-0.5867578387,
0.1268303096,
-0.2011063695,
-0.299797982,
-0.2775848806,
0.1604239643,
-0.0211454146,
0.1956317723,
0.3440032601,
-0.596894145,
0.4741116762,
-0.0011666272,
0.4830077589,
0.9152077436,
0.261135608,
0.6421663761,
-0.6315342188,
0.7981870174,
-0.4605228007,
0.4938677251,
-0.0370852537,
-0.5607435703,
-0.4185220897,
-0.3545877337,
0.1361427903,
0.7080239058,
-0.7421616316,
0.508746922,
0.4576325715,
-0.4762140214,
-0.1017168164,
-0.0254853368,
0.057974387,
0.9005057216,
0.4026893079,
0.2130603343,
-0.3266081214,
-0.7721264362,
-0.2736297846,
-0.0149565274,
-0.297029525,
-0.0361331366,
0.1394001842,
0.1689516455,
1.140443325,
-0.3892149329,
-0.0535868518,
-0.3431838453,
0.0625403225,
0.593170166,
0.7736142278,
0.718991518,
-0.5370293856,
-0.6761568189,
-0.24226138,
-0.5848170519,
-0.7078804374,
-0.4995641708,
-0.3330252767,
-0.1883724183,
0.7434496284,
-0.5427266359,
0.2376600802,
0.4073259532,
-0.769705236,
0.7116640806,
-0.2741938233,
0.209192574,
-0.7722597122,
0.1407099664,
-0.1620165259,
-0.2624613345,
-0.4271534383,
-0.1076515764,
0.3017707169,
-0.506675303,
-0.5642281175,
0.7619485855,
-0.3458904326,
0.5446169972,
-0.5076732039,
-0.1496772617,
0.231262058,
0.4196806848,
-0.292530328,
0.9339552522,
0.6239086986,
-0.9743641019,
0.5630776882,
0.2412412167,
-0.3131231666,
0.8618526459,
-0.9747661352,
-0.1657557487,
-0.1118680239,
0.2115699649,
-0.82618016,
-0.076155968,
0.5049179196,
-0.2145294994,
0.2728412449,
-0.1734852046,
-0.3210259974,
-0.2432362139,
-0.2964923978,
-0.1351609975,
0.9221081138,
-0.5442599654,
0.5413827896,
-0.0685446709,
-0.7145978212,
-0.3069513142,
-0.5098583102,
0.0698958337,
-0.5243732929,
-0.1525203735,
0.2864363194,
-0.5745151639,
-0.3276816607,
-0.3844019473,
-0.0889000297,
0.2278502733,
0.415186137,
0.5199161172,
0.1995353103,
0.1460997313,
0.163102895,
0.4816993475,
-0.1934975535,
0.1682996005,
-0.2455927283,
0.5506695509,
0.630841136,
-0.1667763293,
-0.6864506006,
0.4909848869,
0.4632751048,
-0.1386417598,
0.3979904354,
-0.1168401688,
-0.2506316602,
-0.6792039275,
-0.1849578917,
-0.1424279064,
-0.6063259244,
-0.0192459431,
-0.3655298948,
-0.7451506257,
0.4024678767,
-0.3009073734,
0.3729081452,
0.162497431,
0.3934426308,
-0.349963069,
0.9759486318,
1.0060743093,
-0.0963420123,
0.8754427433,
0.3422978818,
0.0025695141,
-0.4548226893,
-0.1487153023,
-0.7926434875,
-0.7810222507,
-0.503449738,
-0.1067891642,
0.3927419484,
0.2558944523,
-0.3333443403,
0.0133610768,
-0.5742315054,
0.5597561598,
0.2933076322,
0.0363526084,
0.2095066607,
-0.317022562,
0.1720065027,
0.0861260891,
-0.754942894,
-0.4759937823,
0.41621387,
0.3951590359,
1.1562585831,
-0.1012479365,
0.2933079302,
0.7426523566,
-0.0377718024,
-0.8719346523,
0.4616284072,
0.095565401,
-0.2803908587,
-0.5293951631,
-0.1552482843,
-0.9714636803,
-0.0760994852,
-0.1967649609,
-0.6217244267,
0.4743461311,
0.2437888682,
-0.7462516427,
0.0420040004,
-0.8494044542,
0.5245366096,
-0.3013795912,
-0.3645112514,
0.0601031482,
-0.344175458,
-0.0112224193,
-0.3365514874,
0.0335515104,
-0.2750749588,
-0.2991533279,
0.481133163,
-0.7576134205,
0.940971911,
-0.3153625727,
-0.4322010279,
0.2765139341,
0.3490395844,
0.8511410356,
0.1805468351,
-0.2369672507,
-0.3076221943,
-0.0527509078,
-0.6668425202,
-0.577149868,
0.7560888529,
-0.4412221313,
-0.6258856058,
-0.1538477391,
-0.4153857231,
-0.1706806421,
0.4757614732,
0.6531761289,
0.1966381371,
-0.1992282122,
-0.1797455102,
0.7308498621,
-0.3919349015,
0.8050683141,
0.4100248218,
-0.4516510367,
0.0020894667,
0.6242058873,
0.188903302,
0.4201943576,
0.426330477,
0.4413297176,
-0.0689536259,
-0.2434660196,
-0.4789313376,
-0.0322207995,
-0.4405739307,
-0.0241050776,
-0.4373606145,
-0.1062366515,
-0.060369011,
-0.521622777,
-0.1420057714,
-0.4093085527,
-0.3568215072,
0.0234785378,
0.5516324043,
0.640329659,
0.0323482901,
0.549618125,
-0.3668085635,
0.410354495,
0.4944512546,
0.2556206882,
-0.4287547171,
-0.456217736,
0.2839476168,
-0.2289471924,
-0.0287090447,
-0.8392563462,
0.1865574121,
0.2854117453,
0.3872646391,
0.0832761303,
0.470760107,
0.0531649031,
-0.7922180295,
0.9249190688,
0.2107704282,
-0.9021799564,
0.894588232,
-0.2421921194,
0.6007707715,
0.5566446185,
0.3350109756,
-0.5141845942,
-0.4182010591,
-0.3979903758,
-0.6109575629,
0.4518360198,
-0.1875716746,
0.3718669116,
0.1475868225,
0.3191693425,
0.5059752464,
0.2764374018,
-0.441024065,
-0.0304624308,
-0.1374420971,
0.0038207751,
-0.0181850418,
-0.4125335217,
-0.1981164515,
0.357316643,
0.4543755054,
-0.0674808696,
-0.1392319202,
0.0836637765,
0.2143472433,
-0.2415379137,
0.5443121195,
0.4688796401,
0.7002567649,
-0.1053183153,
0.0669210777,
0.0711617097,
-0.3335216939,
0.1795395613,
-0.1316039711,
-0.5992213488,
0.0614568815,
-0.0004645906,
0.7287837863,
-0.0617432036,
-0.524650991,
0.1584793031,
-0.1206893772,
-0.0676577389,
-0.0889003351,
0.412410289,
-0.4520295262,
0.1139073968,
0.217431888,
0.1145687997,
-0.1907713413,
-0.3824778795,
-0.1496488601,
0.2469836473,
-0.5607609749,
-0.2501058578,
0.9592353702,
0.5331597328,
-0.4388230741,
0.4421718419,
-0.0080277734,
0.013785094,
0.6609936357,
0.4448187053,
0.6383042336,
-0.2413998097,
0.2660509348,
0.2663350999,
0.4307618141,
-0.0584621802,
0.5630944371,
0.0142737506,
-0.4407728612,
-0.7263820171,
-0.2836020887,
-0.7721478939,
0.1207263246,
-0.4347663522,
0.5511392951,
-0.9677420855,
-0.2740824521,
-0.004893729,
-0.4828306735,
-0.2388214022,
0.0947536677,
-0.0859183222,
1.3305071592,
-0.9003655314,
0.5313860178,
0.5074011683,
-0.2029171437,
-0.7041113377,
-0.092548728,
-0.1053008884,
-0.4435764253,
0.5661239624,
-0.0141555658,
-0.0607418157,
0.2879724205,
-1.0363676548,
-0.5597689152,
0.7993927598,
0.2388337106,
-0.8226314187,
-0.2526220083,
-0.3333696127,
0.2132222056,
-0.1303580254,
-0.1276237816,
0.3313938677,
0.6159150004,
-0.1487398297,
-1.0856883526,
0.0433944575,
-0.2460348904,
-0.2029352337,
0.2141589373,
-0.7593258023,
0.746298492,
-0.0119248172,
-0.242674917,
0.1115236208,
0.4884346426,
0.5672624111,
0.2358052433,
0.5036107302,
-0.0339456536,
0.8957776427,
-0.1820411235,
0.9516072273,
-0.253557533,
-0.1163996533,
1.1253294945,
-0.4351921976,
0.3850828707,
0.8030527234,
0.0448508598,
0.2949934602,
0.7395969629,
0.1132199019,
0.4990092814,
0.3655118048,
-0.2070761472,
-0.2313962579,
-0.4929310083,
-0.3564074337,
0.1225092337,
0.2482635677,
-0.0932566971,
-0.1388670504,
0.5315397978,
0.2019717842,
0.2378837466,
-0.6155897379,
0.3007794023,
0.142007634,
-0.7344479561,
0.7345902324,
-0.248544082,
0.8475958109,
-0.9618166089,
-0.0066695474,
-0.2944103777,
-0.2733840346,
-0.0395410247,
-0.5261403918,
-0.0998279676,
0.3391229212,
-0.3342533708,
-0.7421335578,
0.522138238,
0.0493533574,
-0.2584454417,
0.0338010341,
0.5304816365,
-0.1254799217,
-0.0231473614,
-0.6297369003,
0.0861536339,
0.0073589957,
-0.3625870943,
0.1137718111,
0.5970311165,
-0.2996173203,
0.8582528234,
0.4991554916,
0.4262028933,
0.0740088224,
-0.0324517861,
0.8609386086,
-0.6533266902,
-0.9154677391,
-0.7334290147,
0.5633855462,
0.0755903572,
-0.3443041146,
0.6788893342,
0.3129122853,
0.297903657,
-0.2254822701,
1.045466423,
-0.4221793413,
0.5534050465,
-0.7751678824,
0.7477815747,
-0.3671892881,
0.1567734927,
-0.0824023634,
-1.0375397205,
0.0339801796,
-0.0162866954,
-0.0424014814,
-0.15641056,
0.7564034462,
0.6058243513,
0.2219308913,
-0.26305902,
0.3283382654,
0.2533636391,
0.5065335631,
0.4407951832,
1.199246645,
0.1909194142,
0.0892868116,
-0.1507828385,
-0.5777334571,
-0.0981400236,
-1.3418848515,
-0.6573560834,
-0.2153839022,
-0.3980172873,
-0.3747499585,
0.043518424,
0.9899134636,
0.4494898021,
-0.6881893277,
-0.0807623193,
-0.2381496131,
0.324960649,
-0.3152574599,
-0.1504038125,
-0.0084115425,
-0.6361618042,
-1.0076930523,
0.9670776725,
0.427947104,
0.2879248559,
-0.1885008067,
0.2631549239,
0.0037912168,
0.2099853903,
0.562676847,
0.731397748,
-0.2853027582,
-0.3413555026,
0.1611056924,
-0.2062384635,
-0.1619323343,
0.8332934976,
-0.7135865092,
0.3962185383,
0.7173155546,
0.4091043472,
-0.2590402961,
0.2013132572,
0.779355526,
-0.7570557594,
0.209856078,
0.1096792296,
0.1881290823,
-0.0779037178,
-0.6362774372,
0.4153574109,
-0.0695054233,
-0.7752194405,
-0.673137486,
0.4929407537,
-1.2000066042,
-0.5230062604,
1.2305688858,
0.1407112777,
-0.2323609442,
-0.0312121119,
-0.8520823717,
0.0354554951,
-0.5778570771,
0.7828632593,
0.617764771,
-0.4005679786,
-0.3174355924,
-0.6523436308,
0.6255145669,
0.5285308361,
-0.8468393683,
0.0455359034,
0.7076973319,
0.1301219761,
0.1108936146,
0.5315331817,
0.2136643827,
0.1661156714,
-0.3682693839,
0.0708527714,
-0.1689606905,
-0.3937357962,
-0.4365492165,
0.3413170576,
0.4399314225,
-0.2085014433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09766v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09766v4
|
LLMs as Narcissistic Evaluators: When Ego Inflates Evaluation Scores
| 2023-11-16T10:43:26 | 2024-06-07T09:41:36 |
Yiqi Liu, Nafise Sadat Moosavi, Chenghua Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic evaluation of generated textual content presents an ongoing
challenge within the field of NLP. Given the impressive capabilities of modern
language models (LMs) across diverse NLP tasks, there is a growing trend to
employ these models in creating innovative evaluation metrics for automated
assessment of generation tasks. This paper investigates a pivotal question: Do
language model-driven evaluation metrics inherently exhibit bias favoring texts
generated by the same underlying language model? Specifically, we assess
whether prominent LM-based evaluation metrics (e.g. BARTScore, T5Score, and
GPTScore) demonstrate a favorable bias toward their respective underlying LMs
in the context of summarization tasks. Our findings unveil a latent bias,
particularly pronounced when such evaluation metrics are used in a
reference-free manner without leveraging gold summaries. These results
underscore that assessments provided by generative evaluation models can be
influenced by factors beyond the inherent text quality, highlighting the
necessity of developing more reliable evaluation protocols in the future.
|
[
-0.3982669711,
-0.4251894057,
0.6892896295,
0.4375077486,
-0.0863384232,
0.1008436605,
-0.195728153,
-0.3456846774,
0.2177228332,
0.4445855916,
-0.5620518923,
-0.3150967956,
-0.5709060431,
0.2367225438,
-0.4646262527,
1.6224639416,
0.0136266425,
0.2074828297,
-0.6836505532,
0.0327508599,
-0.2085901201,
-0.5916466117,
-0.1672043204,
-0.7197395563,
0.4451752305,
0.0186499823,
0.898946166,
0.2302268445,
0.5578309894,
0.1823728234,
-0.0504540391,
0.2707146704,
-0.2937155068,
0.4930443764,
-0.2279770374,
-0.3263952136,
-0.7898696065,
0.3737200797,
0.5662764311,
0.7802301645,
-0.0001556947,
0.5742676854,
0.2304281443,
0.9097707868,
-0.6663987637,
-0.091084227,
-0.7053011656,
0.1365905851,
0.0241574738,
-0.5040099025,
-0.3703536391,
-0.5264420509,
0.2101918906,
-0.3153939843,
0.3487141132,
-0.017128082,
0.9834342003,
0.3080745637,
-0.1447406113,
-0.7757363319,
-0.6241332889,
0.9614402652,
-0.6436599493,
-0.0586026199,
0.237040624,
0.0533882417,
0.2942987382,
-0.46452865,
-0.1993941367,
-0.349773407,
-0.086605601,
0.2888879478,
-0.415381372,
-0.0305283722,
0.0501334108,
0.735147357,
-0.3854917288,
0.2504172325,
-0.1833090484,
-0.0107171955,
0.7428936958,
0.428383261,
0.2258942574,
-0.4853978157,
-0.2645187974,
0.2910336852,
-0.5354250073,
-0.3546582162,
0.6817899942,
0.2925691307,
-0.0448203012,
0.6639478207,
0.0004418043,
0.5205514431,
0.2302277833,
0.0934964046,
0.3265615702,
-0.4844379127,
-0.3048019409,
-0.0753456056,
0.9571787715,
0.6815422177,
0.5730717778,
-0.3408266604,
-0.473439604,
0.2630988657,
0.5559130311,
-0.6100090146,
0.0086622182,
0.4150792062,
-0.4490912259,
-0.6731256843,
0.1380970329,
-0.8294416666,
-0.3367650211,
-0.2006917745,
0.0948235765,
0.0224180911,
-0.0848413929,
-0.0826585367,
-0.1581738442,
-0.0286029764,
0.1666837335,
-0.8820115328,
0.3164994717,
0.6676099896,
0.82833606,
-0.4420321584,
-0.0944658071,
-0.4417341948,
-0.2452951074,
-0.5251498222,
0.9155673385,
-0.3891824484,
-0.5672008991,
0.042312596,
-0.2197480351,
0.0531589687,
-0.8008269072,
0.5079193711,
-0.4235169291,
0.5792717934,
-0.2338992804,
-0.3656786978,
0.0641952008,
0.1243385598,
-0.5351768136,
1.0882674456,
0.1802020818,
-0.7677803636,
0.7259367704,
-0.7196288109,
-0.1324187666,
0.0847413093,
-0.0926769078,
-0.5489284396,
0.3225857913,
0.2878405154,
0.4942911267,
-0.4156526327,
0.6059265733,
-0.1579472572,
-0.137305513,
0.4323741496,
-0.7117915154,
0.537322998,
0.2821065784,
-0.4365411401,
0.1018458232,
-0.6370605826,
0.2375323623,
-0.025626678,
-0.4075835645,
-0.4502966702,
-0.0675759092,
0.0135123665,
0.1468411982,
0.2326085567,
-0.0955167264,
-0.0484123938,
-0.4820069671,
-0.0126182688,
0.8348523974,
0.3364969492,
0.6379503012,
-0.5983736515,
0.915584743,
-0.315664798,
-0.1981642246,
-0.2092267126,
-0.2876699269,
-0.7346903086,
0.0178742278,
0.2203096151,
0.252936542,
-0.4742211401,
0.4848810434,
-0.4691093564,
-0.7369117141,
-0.6270429492,
0.3086544573,
0.5495332479,
0.1633713096,
0.0264178291,
-0.4612875879,
-0.4610958993,
-1.0134015083,
-0.6796156168,
-0.1999110878,
-0.3295755982,
0.4353224635,
0.4762981236,
0.0040968531,
0.8984314799,
-0.2351060808,
-0.3299087286,
-0.4352731407,
0.2609210014,
0.1273539215,
0.2958322763,
0.7932617664,
-0.3132179976,
-0.3107685149,
-0.4085278511,
-0.9552249312,
-0.8349923491,
-0.560259819,
0.0068872203,
0.05539326,
0.1938204914,
-0.3875390291,
0.0560523011,
0.5665633678,
-0.4838738739,
0.919066906,
-0.0303191282,
-0.0014278156,
-0.6736484766,
-0.0037762329,
0.1314125508,
-0.352163136,
-0.3025512695,
0.1585476547,
-0.1448144466,
0.4199166,
-0.2675383687,
0.5484674573,
-0.6851174831,
-0.4037691653,
-0.2608635426,
0.5560690165,
0.3605159819,
0.1180215105,
-0.0887671262,
0.7560284734,
0.2106111795,
-0.7696149945,
0.0572797209,
-0.0452941768,
-0.5082711577,
0.6921967864,
-0.53417027,
0.0759570152,
-0.1539185494,
0.2111166567,
-0.680175662,
0.0350398049,
0.0194360316,
-0.5311236978,
0.1738681793,
0.3150079548,
-0.524522543,
-0.2252301276,
-0.4498873353,
0.1888498962,
0.4154778123,
-0.4156993032,
0.4206153452,
0.3431895673,
-0.2432027161,
-0.6568008065,
-0.8755205274,
0.0895336717,
-0.2754922211,
-0.2712967396,
0.2185124308,
-0.057174772,
-0.7652530074,
-0.0177763533,
-0.0606196932,
0.3831178844,
0.1316905767,
0.3984999955,
0.2074159384,
-0.1854096055,
0.1356137693,
0.0753977075,
0.0752772465,
0.3514194191,
-0.0832782984,
0.5157560706,
-0.1931903213,
-0.3872321248,
-0.1823400706,
0.2456389964,
0.4243789017,
-0.0641939938,
0.4655213654,
0.3992303014,
-0.018431697,
-0.3260166645,
-0.5512157083,
-0.0416843668,
-0.3917069137,
0.5556122661,
-0.0801342577,
-0.5870158076,
0.368070364,
0.2686980069,
0.3375958204,
0.710763514,
1.0620831251,
-0.0573689155,
0.9122643471,
0.3360527158,
-0.0204902999,
0.3394876122,
-0.1946186572,
0.1051192135,
-1.1170316935,
0.0358840637,
-0.4119136333,
-0.1999360472,
-0.5355544686,
-0.2798979878,
0.2894115746,
-0.1490260661,
0.0127936313,
-0.2370469272,
-0.5808385015,
0.4439555109,
0.1172525436,
-0.235988453,
0.4054271579,
-0.0929395184,
-0.1079868972,
-0.310238719,
-0.719743669,
-1.0434215069,
1.4367262125,
0.4586403966,
0.6149750352,
-0.0921796635,
0.5095080733,
0.6317858696,
0.9417726994,
-0.7887490392,
0.4342428446,
0.1107306331,
-0.6567059159,
0.0696392208,
-0.2969235182,
-0.801158905,
0.5579622388,
-0.1429216266,
-0.6238995194,
-0.0160384234,
-0.0208002012,
-0.4151284993,
0.1878361404,
-0.522484839,
0.462441206,
-0.4728889763,
-0.4349371493,
-0.0150725665,
-0.2293349206,
0.6927595139,
-0.1795719713,
0.3054696321,
-0.2001294941,
-0.172728315,
0.8629446626,
-0.3463371098,
0.6624429226,
-0.1204790324,
-0.3023721874,
0.3429614902,
0.3519372642,
0.1299424618,
0.0613789968,
-0.247158289,
0.1847914606,
-0.2552870512,
-0.1706030667,
-0.6452162266,
0.7438491583,
-0.6197835207,
-0.5986427069,
-0.6352653503,
-0.5148848295,
-0.1451449543,
-0.1526934654,
0.2444259673,
0.1741321683,
-0.3733903766,
-0.0538823009,
0.2056650519,
-0.3487808406,
0.3670714498,
0.4021764994,
-0.4806032777,
-0.1856958419,
0.6793479323,
0.0156803783,
0.6797600389,
-0.0152791543,
0.0882787406,
-0.0170060378,
-0.2790984511,
-0.5515992045,
0.2288342714,
-0.7293265462,
-0.2188802361,
-0.7242399454,
-0.1737363487,
-0.1567670107,
-0.2509143949,
-0.4676241875,
-0.4143153429,
-0.4120406508,
-0.4370187819,
-0.1788282841,
0.8784074783,
0.0484139025,
0.2841155827,
-0.4661812782,
0.1824585199,
-0.0185513627,
0.1174555495,
0.3742302954,
-0.6735182405,
-0.2973379195,
-0.1813534051,
-0.6392121315,
-0.7427825928,
0.6288030744,
0.1623105556,
0.4710532725,
0.5309658051,
-0.281580627,
0.3082693219,
-0.3829989433,
1.2842559814,
0.0522041619,
-0.8077379465,
0.2482166886,
-0.3658992946,
0.5449610353,
0.4733125865,
0.2434729487,
-0.3804160953,
-0.8786114454,
-0.7615791559,
-0.9364063144,
0.5534361005,
0.1922137886,
0.4042146802,
-0.1430581361,
0.1683322191,
0.4119818211,
0.5383415222,
-1.1650105715,
-0.3410406709,
-0.0909736678,
-0.0583550595,
-0.0665910393,
-0.4926276505,
0.0704026967,
0.1991134733,
0.6789348722,
-0.0092938542,
0.252573967,
0.2345940769,
-0.2414009422,
-0.2046649903,
0.3663683534,
0.5535664558,
0.7413410544,
-0.1971240193,
-0.0690446049,
0.0141051766,
-0.3113343716,
0.0314052776,
-0.320856601,
-0.4048878849,
0.4879059792,
0.4252368212,
0.5974892974,
0.1432611495,
-0.5895322561,
0.6192774773,
0.1019217372,
-0.338457346,
-0.5218994617,
-0.0381200649,
-0.0489711203,
-0.0582658499,
0.5102151632,
0.1954310387,
0.139354825,
-0.4157320559,
0.0987561345,
0.7130698562,
-0.4441865981,
-0.4365552068,
0.7198861241,
0.0543815047,
-0.1914544851,
0.1814893186,
-0.3500904143,
-0.5187225938,
0.503240943,
0.2846322954,
1.2186299562,
-0.2200652063,
0.3142182231,
0.2637055516,
0.5327744484,
0.1190174893,
0.0317125805,
-0.1903990656,
-0.7037175298,
-0.2728790343,
-0.9529420137,
-0.2127418816,
0.2467712462,
-0.6963305473,
0.1899134517,
-0.2359247059,
-0.2689249814,
-0.0916645601,
-0.2238864601,
-0.7215197086,
0.3771620989,
0.2070759535,
0.3346620202,
-0.8359669447,
0.1935036331,
0.3366848826,
-0.4698149562,
-0.3821949065,
0.1242410839,
-0.023997562,
-0.6521606445,
0.7246859074,
0.0492699929,
-0.0575142726,
-0.4923924804,
-0.1869797558,
-0.8321248293,
0.8061054945,
0.1094588637,
-0.2950505912,
-0.5216991901,
0.0781838149,
0.79771173,
-0.7489954233,
0.722193718,
0.5057685971,
0.4720052481,
-0.6757023335,
-1.071538806,
-0.0472761951,
-0.2143380642,
0.024211308,
-0.1310703605,
-0.5778594613,
0.6520157456,
-0.2502180934,
-0.322883606,
0.0651942864,
0.4980842769,
0.2149376422,
0.3707585335,
0.3842007816,
0.2167779654,
0.5100382566,
-0.0311016068,
1.339823246,
-0.2667360604,
0.2631872892,
1.276979804,
-0.1048955321,
0.4540240765,
0.6173246503,
-0.2859896421,
0.6961410046,
0.5373361111,
-0.2313875854,
0.3827151358,
0.4968317151,
0.0498697199,
-0.0001936586,
-0.1685556471,
-0.1128606498,
0.51476717,
0.4305031896,
-1.0669361353,
-0.3761861026,
-0.2963986397,
0.1032959297,
0.3691055477,
-0.3517504334,
0.8284098506,
0.3066422343,
-0.9230800271,
0.3742839992,
0.134103328,
0.8867683411,
-0.4682718217,
0.3353184462,
-0.0320352092,
-0.1313099712,
-0.5144194961,
-0.4659560621,
0.4665801525,
0.4801372588,
-0.3443113863,
-0.5285738707,
0.4891656935,
-0.1248498559,
-0.5694279075,
0.289593488,
1.0140486956,
0.3676156104,
0.0061681648,
-0.6493961811,
-0.271565944,
0.0810774416,
-0.7576152086,
0.4132932723,
0.2485626936,
-0.0713303536,
0.6401071548,
0.5517309904,
0.4885228872,
-0.0144501207,
0.50078547,
0.5651419163,
-0.3877204657,
-0.4683817923,
-1.1557047367,
0.435246706,
0.0094826622,
-0.3964366019,
0.9454250932,
0.7533963323,
0.7479449511,
-0.0353764109,
1.0301661491,
0.2216065228,
0.6575983763,
-0.5293809772,
0.8778486848,
-0.6348938942,
0.6353205442,
-0.6624247432,
-1.190507412,
-0.0358865485,
0.3368359506,
-0.5720297694,
0.5387170911,
0.6670059562,
0.4257670641,
0.2553638518,
-0.1778111905,
0.3168573081,
-0.0195866991,
0.2587070167,
0.3356744647,
0.9025648236,
-0.3530614078,
0.2813413143,
0.1104906797,
-0.1028753296,
-0.1554662138,
-0.9670471549,
-0.801181078,
-0.4358899295,
-0.2166810185,
-0.3180531859,
-0.1141094416,
0.7864259481,
0.2462931126,
-0.5421264172,
-0.2969033718,
0.0340307802,
0.1519560218,
-0.1448080838,
-0.4281647801,
0.2664513588,
-0.567481041,
-0.9061462879,
0.0234123711,
0.3621891737,
-0.1338792592,
-0.8448459506,
0.0566410385,
0.1720322967,
0.2587919533,
0.3700603545,
-0.3609699011,
-0.8729442954,
0.0078564081,
-0.1112775877,
-0.2320455015,
0.0596471503,
0.7608551979,
-0.9667162895,
0.3739934266,
0.1639295667,
0.4044777751,
0.0868700966,
0.2978970706,
0.9209973812,
-0.6528627872,
-0.2409875542,
0.4852689803,
0.1849816591,
0.6650874615,
-0.4440696239,
0.4006271958,
0.0327350013,
-0.639313519,
-1.1056944132,
0.1404225826,
-0.5628002286,
-0.039229311,
1.3053405285,
0.0347320586,
-0.1105196252,
0.2140123397,
0.0994592458,
-0.0802581757,
-0.3545084894,
0.9253062606,
0.9507297873,
-0.1721051186,
0.2048022002,
-0.7589666843,
0.6506331563,
0.821175158,
-0.6124004722,
0.1086907461,
0.4820539951,
0.1766086668,
0.3619796634,
0.6416802406,
-0.359675616,
0.2044919282,
-0.0052822558,
0.1584112644,
0.1019061729,
-0.0089475354,
-0.3854033351,
0.1346035153,
0.1563746482,
0.2948031127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09763v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09763v1
|
Test-time Backdoor Mitigation for Black-Box Large Language Models with Defensive Demonstrations
| 2023-11-16T10:38:43 | 2023-11-16T10:38:43 |
Wenjie Mo, Jiashu Xu, Qin Liu, Jiongxiao Wang, Jun Yan, Chaowei Xiao, Muhao Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Existing studies in backdoor defense have predominantly focused on the
training phase, overlooking the critical aspect of testing time defense. This
gap becomes particularly pronounced in the context of Large Language Models
(LLMs) deployed as Web Services, which typically offer only black-box access,
rendering training-time defenses impractical. To bridge this gap, our work
introduces defensive demonstrations, an innovative backdoor defense strategy
for blackbox large language models. Our method involves identifying the task
and retrieving task-relevant demonstrations from an uncontaminated pool. These
demonstrations are then combined with user queries and presented to the model
during testing, without requiring any modifications/tuning to the black-box
model or insights into its internal mechanisms. Defensive demonstrations are
designed to counteract the adverse effects of triggers, aiming to recalibrate
and correct the behavior of poisoned models during test-time evaluations.
Extensive experiments show that defensive demonstrations are effective in
defending both instance-level and instruction-level backdoor attacks, not only
rectifying the behavior of poisoned models but also surpassing existing
baselines in most scenarios.
|
[
-0.1824220121,
-1.060537219,
0.2560902238,
0.2429944575,
-0.0520144589,
0.2467137426,
-0.1372060776,
-0.3674747348,
-0.3058332205,
0.498685956,
-0.542586565,
-0.5052360892,
-0.2089383602,
-0.2157942206,
-0.6972823739,
1.0015904903,
0.0723409951,
-0.3142910302,
0.0107457703,
0.3239614666,
-0.4240139723,
-0.4351527989,
-0.6098510623,
-0.4314296246,
0.3855014443,
0.1982788593,
0.398775965,
0.188365519,
-0.0768246204,
0.2764323652,
0.0498251505,
-0.3215102553,
-0.5808017254,
0.321975857,
-0.4526863396,
-0.4558894038,
-0.2221421748,
-0.0628662929,
0.4074042141,
0.2671464682,
-0.2937239707,
0.1089492738,
0.0521718115,
0.2732651234,
-0.9208344817,
-0.2085739225,
-0.8331122398,
0.4017843604,
-0.1672221571,
-0.3145315945,
-0.808273375,
-0.0391769484,
-0.069020547,
-0.229765296,
0.2400618047,
-0.0355020948,
0.6674321294,
-0.0463419408,
-0.4130160213,
0.3181638122,
-0.7478862405,
0.7221221924,
-0.8255187273,
0.3204804063,
0.2689469755,
0.5448778272,
-0.3278173208,
-0.4277566671,
-0.4850352407,
-0.6307471395,
0.0579277091,
0.160152033,
-0.6448884606,
-0.0828048959,
0.5132607222,
-0.0136542162,
-0.8722881675,
0.6248854399,
-0.1376609653,
-0.5050475597,
0.7177129984,
0.293574363,
0.1936734021,
0.1208118796,
-0.3973124921,
-0.080689624,
-1.055624485,
0.0605121888,
0.385561645,
0.2556123435,
-0.0862149,
0.5487369299,
-0.2670801878,
0.4273737073,
0.0736589134,
0.1217904091,
-0.0750618652,
-0.1458804011,
-0.1946563125,
0.110240303,
0.7008811235,
0.3307302594,
0.1477324963,
-0.3962300718,
-0.4924778044,
0.2309285402,
0.5877326131,
-1.0542185307,
-0.0538116731,
0.4205758572,
-0.3204437196,
-0.5735940337,
-0.3133029938,
-1.1767821312,
-0.5380131006,
0.4788664877,
0.6775434613,
-0.1620710492,
-0.4093475044,
-0.0320664607,
-0.2894918621,
0.087353766,
0.1026745215,
-0.4694969058,
0.4408739209,
0.7927815318,
0.7887747884,
-0.0442613401,
-0.2873153389,
-0.9360201359,
0.4854647517,
-0.4251735508,
0.5336894393,
-0.4314766228,
-0.4782926738,
0.3780215085,
0.0327638015,
0.2431874126,
-0.5879929066,
-0.0740169883,
-0.7793931365,
0.0014559474,
0.3885212243,
-0.3751903772,
0.0151728885,
0.5502205491,
-0.3261571229,
0.7167659998,
-0.2156938016,
-0.6096903682,
-0.0021457372,
-0.6665666699,
-0.7467612624,
0.1100665554,
0.0250271726,
-0.6106209755,
0.0962463021,
0.112932533,
0.5766863227,
-0.0296518262,
-0.28990224,
-0.5907425284,
-0.43199265,
0.4409582317,
-0.4651587903,
0.7116951942,
0.1264478117,
-0.8078534007,
0.1946948767,
-0.7920580506,
-0.0465106182,
0.4523300231,
-0.0456997938,
-0.6071540713,
-0.0159299485,
-0.4806808829,
0.2388634831,
-0.0151248621,
-0.715287745,
0.1118681505,
-0.5769044757,
0.2512420714,
0.935076654,
0.3401468396,
0.179320693,
-0.3236655295,
0.8706838489,
0.0739528239,
0.5585337281,
-0.2925500274,
-0.3589978814,
-0.407109499,
-0.1055139974,
-0.1329414099,
0.6847078204,
-0.646288991,
0.1825835705,
-0.1768994629,
-0.6808396578,
-0.2098406851,
0.1062146872,
0.845273912,
0.273444593,
0.2376218587,
-0.1972080171,
-0.1499650925,
-0.8873342276,
-0.0260877591,
0.0456017926,
-0.0800055191,
-0.0089720702,
0.6973659992,
-0.3021055758,
0.5384148359,
-0.5314480066,
-0.0192803778,
-0.0183908716,
0.0839967057,
-0.0388175659,
0.3855295777,
0.5291800499,
-0.5366067886,
-0.1875331104,
-0.0975845978,
-0.4361546636,
-0.2819419503,
-0.0743488148,
-0.0480442196,
0.4011542797,
0.5430597067,
-0.5135198832,
0.6961552501,
0.7588306665,
-0.3631865084,
0.9340173006,
0.0804298148,
-0.0500643104,
-0.801645875,
-0.2326155752,
-0.0281498358,
-0.2601958513,
-0.6548882723,
0.4075709283,
0.192574352,
-0.4782550633,
-0.6138755679,
0.8210492134,
-0.2841873467,
-0.0588224865,
-0.2377086431,
0.0540233254,
-0.0428511985,
0.4938654006,
-0.1973308474,
0.9358695149,
0.5193004608,
-0.7553579807,
0.4870509207,
0.0091031166,
-0.1926009357,
0.5819081664,
-0.6050550938,
0.2694759071,
0.470089376,
0.3341522515,
-1.0152988434,
0.1814920306,
0.334777832,
-0.3678588867,
0.3470475674,
-0.4183117151,
-0.4017634094,
-0.4956330955,
-0.5421883464,
0.0863445178,
0.576824367,
-0.5827534199,
0.5908986926,
0.1127336323,
-0.1140540242,
-0.8154257536,
-0.8755478263,
0.1868128181,
-0.2420218587,
-0.5235162377,
0.3093678653,
-0.1400561929,
-0.2839476168,
-0.329662472,
-0.1343703419,
-0.0874426961,
0.619133234,
0.5163955092,
0.0693759248,
-0.2322354615,
0.0996801779,
-0.0412877463,
0.1623775065,
0.3878734112,
-0.3048981726,
0.8008065224,
0.2479562312,
-0.7520573139,
-0.5339306593,
0.6223967671,
0.4610924423,
-0.3833743036,
0.7075484991,
0.4047866166,
-0.4329305887,
-0.5623825192,
-0.662494123,
-0.566789031,
-0.5385425687,
0.4286393225,
-0.4019203484,
-0.65148139,
0.4404766858,
0.1653229147,
0.2722052932,
-0.1249923259,
0.4592930377,
0.1395540535,
1.0650700331,
0.3440919518,
-0.0618388951,
0.4721227288,
-0.3521231115,
0.1618045121,
-0.6366020441,
-0.0787650794,
-0.4689303041,
-0.0003742917,
-0.2161615193,
0.1026647687,
0.1306592822,
-0.1378033012,
-0.4452479184,
0.1068864912,
-0.1574980319,
0.2770938575,
0.4711169004,
0.3781586587,
0.2122375965,
0.0991513729,
-0.3820072412,
0.1109896377,
-0.5388967991,
-0.4116224945,
1.0181562901,
0.5161575079,
0.9830076098,
0.4827326238,
0.7627705336,
0.4533006251,
0.474380821,
-0.5652148128,
0.9364979863,
0.1746278256,
-0.6944718361,
-0.3156107962,
-0.5340915918,
-1.064078927,
0.1385906786,
-0.123936072,
-0.8788669705,
-0.1504874378,
0.4427435696,
-0.455940783,
0.3632690012,
-0.8922086358,
1.1100845337,
-0.4112255275,
-0.7483739257,
-0.6244692206,
-0.2255273908,
0.5124590397,
-0.1815281361,
0.1936650276,
0.2753508389,
0.0441523343,
0.5076406598,
-0.2737933099,
1.226142168,
-0.4324299991,
-0.5193439126,
-0.2006639391,
0.6787111759,
0.7186940908,
-0.0510904863,
0.2398201823,
-0.0953128636,
-0.284520328,
-0.5615945458,
-0.6788161397,
0.5919617414,
-0.306435287,
-1.1863291264,
-0.2672892809,
-0.3363904655,
-0.370837003,
0.0559036471,
-0.0547742657,
0.5016382337,
-0.1915165484,
0.0532019138,
0.6616034508,
-0.6390952468,
0.5565376878,
0.9490576982,
-0.3591173291,
-0.0092907045,
0.721906662,
-0.1801126599,
0.7002549171,
0.4916815162,
0.3971486688,
-0.3342111707,
-0.9824041128,
-0.1812531352,
0.1392960846,
-0.4645445049,
-0.2737666667,
-0.7327972651,
-0.2788966,
-0.6769148707,
-0.0065834173,
-0.2953420281,
-0.3480929434,
0.1884309649,
-0.2099572718,
0.3258527517,
0.5608868003,
-0.0606342144,
0.2897380888,
-0.8215859532,
0.1154698953,
0.706443131,
0.2613571882,
0.4663487375,
-0.6406705976,
-0.2276698351,
-0.0656991154,
-0.658968091,
-1.0419306755,
0.3075997531,
-0.1270162165,
0.6237263083,
0.5721909404,
0.2790054977,
0.4585604072,
-0.6183841825,
0.9094435573,
0.1084975004,
-0.8405792117,
0.691844523,
-0.2557350099,
0.0868231952,
-0.2195259333,
0.2590480149,
-0.4981954992,
-0.8219147325,
-0.5374834538,
-0.7389523983,
0.2280955911,
-0.0634532943,
0.2963331342,
0.2269288003,
-0.0395606197,
-0.09590891,
0.1946063489,
-0.8097715378,
0.0697230995,
-0.3651196659,
0.061637409,
-0.1600009054,
-0.2966815531,
-0.5950607061,
0.231893599,
0.8535664678,
0.1279535443,
0.0374658629,
-0.1509904116,
-0.3768107295,
0.0099628922,
0.6745603681,
0.7428296208,
0.5608027577,
-0.0295527223,
0.2158289701,
0.3622941077,
-0.3444941342,
0.5194057822,
0.453564316,
-0.2625612319,
-0.2554243207,
0.4303796291,
0.4805079997,
0.2863940001,
-0.8326829076,
0.7402814031,
0.0409757718,
0.2060371637,
-0.4414795339,
0.2364103496,
-0.1130191535,
0.4598273039,
0.4456309676,
-0.6169012189,
-0.035065081,
-0.7130424976,
0.2950492203,
0.7150176764,
-0.2269064337,
-0.1675192714,
0.4137637317,
0.1754296422,
-0.6211479902,
0.4699513018,
-0.1061334461,
-0.8579720259,
0.5745096207,
0.8403779864,
0.7858715653,
-0.6253182292,
0.2444265187,
0.0061053121,
0.4288428426,
0.2185746282,
-0.0376817919,
0.0119925225,
-0.6297850609,
-0.275221616,
-0.2259662002,
-0.3699068427,
0.5103462338,
-0.4814101458,
-0.0402104035,
-0.6446226239,
0.0229357816,
-0.0172196515,
-0.0559489876,
-0.2777015567,
-0.0805445462,
0.0472687408,
1.3392170668,
-0.8906930089,
0.4882929623,
0.2960322201,
-0.3131507635,
-0.4958537519,
0.0974666029,
0.1976835877,
-0.6500496864,
0.7149822712,
0.1436898708,
-0.266672492,
-0.1756689847,
-0.4629389048,
-0.0714035183,
0.6766338348,
0.2823914587,
-0.7053671479,
0.1456879675,
-0.1876696199,
0.5093127489,
-0.0866955817,
0.0674112365,
0.170589149,
0.3207664788,
-0.4082288742,
-0.6899003983,
0.3728524148,
-0.1906033754,
-0.149228245,
0.1279402375,
-0.5295205116,
0.3586155176,
-0.2172609121,
-0.3071648479,
0.1221088171,
0.4875725806,
0.5419105291,
0.4620645046,
0.80474931,
0.6386864185,
0.2914296687,
0.0396360308,
1.2906792164,
0.0450988747,
-0.1343036741,
1.1267647743,
-0.5428615808,
0.9511327147,
0.3954120576,
0.0183974896,
0.4327078462,
0.3746556938,
-0.2131708711,
0.4388363957,
0.6144196987,
-0.3951664865,
-0.2817291617,
-0.1001734585,
-0.436054498,
0.3968551755,
0.235790208,
-0.0514461324,
-0.2060723752,
0.3134847283,
0.176755473,
0.3925061524,
-0.4161122739,
0.6878315806,
-0.0844759941,
-0.6571217179,
0.6746370196,
-0.2346561998,
0.635602653,
-0.828572154,
-0.1034331992,
-0.2189784944,
0.5340194702,
0.0041339886,
-0.7980392575,
0.0439449288,
0.17551817,
0.0844136029,
-0.1505908668,
0.4109905064,
-0.3675145805,
0.025532579,
0.7234312296,
0.0593954027,
-0.069431372,
-0.3015266359,
-0.6141623259,
-0.0406033248,
-0.262735337,
-0.1945766658,
0.4513589144,
0.3001207709,
-0.107885696,
0.9608627558,
0.6352620721,
0.3071371317,
0.2774522901,
0.4038255811,
0.8593732119,
-0.5752233267,
-0.583745718,
-1.0194590092,
0.2827446461,
-0.3705142736,
0.2371263951,
0.9456786513,
0.7203809619,
0.896777153,
-0.1103646532,
0.77870363,
0.6144877076,
0.6095743179,
-0.7309183478,
0.8827980757,
-0.586458087,
0.2553324103,
-0.2922588289,
-0.4357114136,
-0.0558924489,
0.2093916386,
-0.1250449866,
-0.1330468059,
0.5515277386,
1.2398133278,
-0.1647568345,
-0.2327035666,
0.4208238721,
0.6454026103,
0.7509785891,
0.799382627,
1.4419785738,
-0.0509467348,
0.9788038731,
-0.4090383053,
-0.4012840688,
-0.2280872315,
-1.0156472921,
-1.247633934,
-0.2518343329,
-0.3420936465,
-0.7526111603,
0.559432745,
0.6796594262,
0.8193241954,
-0.8722486496,
-0.2219549268,
0.396394223,
0.0681060478,
-0.4742433429,
-0.2396356314,
-0.064163141,
-0.073634699,
-0.2437493205,
0.4701493382,
0.1561843753,
0.4489766657,
-0.55311656,
0.170699656,
-0.1680689007,
0.0138564985,
0.5018588305,
0.5183581114,
-0.6219958663,
-0.4072864354,
-0.3516916931,
-0.1196839958,
-0.385245949,
0.7264908552,
-0.612590313,
0.0797726437,
0.1481323242,
0.9102829695,
0.4683952034,
-0.4131393731,
0.7565323114,
-0.9732124209,
0.385725081,
0.2888537347,
0.312071234,
0.2930604517,
-0.4066255987,
0.3482044041,
0.2085190713,
-0.2068001926,
-1.1370497942,
0.5607509017,
-0.6273111105,
-0.5455133319,
1.230869174,
-0.333327204,
-0.2554532886,
-0.1912427098,
0.0931840017,
0.1350631118,
-0.4326411486,
1.3451837301,
0.6338358521,
0.5299079418,
-0.3746557534,
-0.5519257188,
0.2535378337,
0.2386127561,
-0.9677309394,
0.4409745336,
0.4594818056,
0.3932848871,
0.2133565396,
0.150050208,
-0.1146826744,
0.4400240183,
-0.2577281594,
-0.1396084279,
-0.3104682863,
-0.3833294511,
-0.5865813494,
0.2333695143,
-0.1979093552,
-0.3710156381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09762v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09762v2
|
Graph Elicitation for Guiding Multi-Step Reasoning in Large Language Models
| 2023-11-16T10:36:08 | 2024-06-22T18:04:33 |
Jinyoung Park, Ameen Patel, Omar Zia Khan, Hyunwoo J. Kim, Joo-Kyung Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting along with sub-question generation and
answering has enhanced multi-step reasoning capabilities of Large Language
Models (LLMs). However, prompting the LLMs to directly generate sub-questions
is suboptimal since they sometimes generate redundant or irrelevant questions.
To deal with them, we propose a GE-Reasoning method, which directs LLMs to
generate proper sub-questions and corresponding answers. Concretely, given an
input question, we first prompt the LLM to generate knowledge triplets, forming
a graph representation of the question. Unlike conventional knowledge triplets,
our approach allows variables as head or tail entities, effectively
representing a question as knowledge triplets. Second, for each triplet, the
LLM generates a corresponding sub-question and answer along with using
knowledge retrieval. If the prediction confidence exceeds a threshold, the
sub-question and prediction are incorporated into the prompt for subsequent
processing. This approach encourages that sub-questions are grounded in the
extracted knowledge triplets, reducing redundancy and irrelevance. Our
experiments demonstrate that our approach outperforms previous CoT prompting
methods and their variants on multi-hop question answering benchmark datasets.
|
[
-0.673212409,
-1.3450554609,
1.0222011805,
-0.1305877566,
-0.2708012462,
0.3000484407,
-0.1000721231,
-0.2533590198,
-0.0359453559,
0.2749329507,
-0.4953406155,
-0.6347475648,
-0.4357501268,
0.0838837847,
-0.3507834971,
0.8948024511,
-0.2114717364,
-0.170404315,
-0.2055533379,
0.146380499,
-0.3619605899,
-0.3407733142,
-1.1170729399,
-0.6483305097,
0.9657174945,
0.5793528557,
0.5516285896,
0.1793594658,
-0.1924506426,
0.2416711897,
-0.1423188448,
0.6793255806,
-0.3778542876,
0.2767313123,
0.0191894528,
-0.221968919,
-0.3480708003,
-0.0784279034,
0.5445350409,
0.9189130664,
0.0897188038,
0.0778312385,
0.2963698506,
0.3874758184,
-0.5091784,
0.3562552631,
-0.7352038622,
-0.1760852635,
0.2128360122,
-0.3742262423,
-0.7192369103,
-0.3990927637,
-0.1486056,
-0.4969365597,
0.1017524302,
0.276484549,
0.5736475587,
-0.0789233074,
-0.4474865794,
-0.2270662487,
-0.4698600769,
0.3033031225,
-0.3705723286,
0.318525672,
0.1596249491,
0.1331229657,
-0.2255634367,
-0.7044866681,
-0.6142218113,
-0.224133864,
-0.1287938207,
0.0769663453,
-0.1139310598,
0.084147796,
0.4582675397,
0.0157046858,
-0.6076434851,
-0.1762188226,
-0.2539003491,
-0.1482158601,
0.3526115417,
-0.040857546,
0.3026762307,
-0.0642295033,
-0.2542524636,
-0.1573496461,
-1.0256829262,
-0.1370670944,
0.4061096907,
0.5513703227,
0.1673196554,
0.4640009403,
-0.1809157729,
0.9449188709,
0.304248631,
0.0844417214,
0.3513935208,
-0.3383105993,
-0.0443068855,
-0.085183084,
0.827922523,
0.188102901,
0.6912961006,
0.0313674174,
-0.0129886381,
-0.215156287,
0.0304459184,
-0.6228768229,
-0.215904206,
0.4982577562,
0.0767174214,
-0.033021193,
-0.0176306684,
-1.0384215117,
-0.2487362772,
-0.1476432383,
0.2717596889,
-0.4769159257,
-0.2159626484,
0.0529817902,
-0.2095946372,
0.1135244295,
0.4196203351,
-0.7381398678,
0.1300806701,
0.4912319481,
0.6307030916,
0.2866393626,
-0.51231426,
-0.878226459,
0.3478142619,
-0.5114384294,
0.8528680801,
-0.6534224153,
-0.4369226694,
0.0696338043,
-0.1522040069,
-0.2183165699,
-0.1546112001,
0.0356595926,
-0.6847882271,
0.0454850383,
-0.5844525695,
-0.4570985138,
-0.1064941734,
0.6989338994,
-0.4518287778,
1.1831011772,
-0.0326201543,
-0.7733293176,
0.1759563088,
-0.5134161115,
-0.5180590153,
0.0882530734,
-0.5351176858,
0.0036681115,
-0.3618494272,
0.9465306997,
0.4934386015,
-0.2880091965,
0.1301196069,
-0.2561879456,
-0.1224556863,
-0.164197728,
-0.3360510767,
0.5360074043,
0.0086244699,
-0.1070608348,
0.022225501,
-0.4816299975,
0.4808264971,
0.2474857569,
-0.2036515176,
-0.1069870293,
-0.1274348199,
-0.7091216445,
0.2917965651,
0.0934554636,
-0.5178621411,
0.3859359324,
-0.0190278031,
0.2597858012,
0.679861784,
0.4576356113,
0.2010558248,
-0.1759037077,
0.7406512499,
0.0573362224,
0.0792554393,
-0.3078835905,
-0.9264345169,
-0.6535693407,
0.0859732106,
0.1710076481,
0.4957132936,
-1.1671224833,
0.2370996177,
-0.1979249865,
-0.4445433319,
-0.1809392422,
0.0173104573,
0.4116416276,
0.7314369082,
0.6048895121,
0.2320668697,
-0.2769958973,
-0.4704856873,
-0.0210501049,
-0.4306847155,
0.066537492,
0.2926734984,
0.6320694685,
0.1669237912,
0.6990377903,
-0.8471093774,
0.2630626857,
-0.4328094423,
0.6881433725,
0.0507503897,
0.3278867006,
0.315112114,
-0.6680322886,
-0.4490875006,
0.0753678232,
-0.6128176451,
-0.1638159901,
0.0071281791,
-0.3644072413,
-0.1837715358,
0.8025884032,
-0.7478734851,
0.1827168763,
0.4308470786,
-0.0599049591,
0.5322861075,
-0.1485244185,
0.3975700736,
-1.1337460279,
0.074037075,
-0.2864721417,
-0.2493185848,
-0.3925562203,
0.1036684811,
-0.0602345094,
-0.1139065921,
-0.2621430159,
0.5322548151,
-0.5598120689,
-0.1255761087,
-0.0821116194,
0.5075555444,
0.2041340619,
0.509070456,
-0.1472799331,
0.7960595489,
0.6224873662,
-0.8050565124,
0.440558821,
0.2161565721,
-0.1962150484,
0.5085065961,
-0.6694212556,
0.7026135325,
-0.4205496311,
0.5842791796,
-1.2102113962,
-0.0948400721,
0.191267997,
-0.5358341932,
0.2045214772,
-0.4698058963,
-0.7033534646,
-0.8748477697,
-0.073072806,
0.4886772037,
0.4248920977,
-0.4982443452,
0.8021201491,
0.2122435868,
-0.342055589,
-0.5874750018,
-0.4976765811,
-0.1219840571,
0.0101221772,
-0.573984921,
0.0544455461,
-0.192825079,
-0.051461447,
0.0480803661,
0.0363337807,
0.2942265868,
-0.2162626088,
-0.2451546043,
0.2788592875,
-0.0851170421,
0.3613536656,
0.2199033052,
-0.362274915,
0.1031775177,
-0.7710782886,
0.8868108392,
-0.1063906476,
-0.6667991877,
0.1080441773,
0.5879776478,
0.6153588891,
-0.2865519822,
0.4751567841,
0.4165774584,
-0.3337256312,
-0.4050832391,
-0.303248018,
-0.1802023351,
-0.4037900567,
0.0962046906,
-0.5845876932,
-0.8327175975,
0.629050374,
-0.325130254,
0.0873057023,
0.1807408333,
0.6300654411,
0.046123594,
1.4665659666,
0.0751408413,
-0.0421092324,
0.2594708502,
-0.3814386427,
0.5239405036,
-0.856970191,
-0.3516077995,
-0.6116999984,
-0.0841980651,
-0.2296999097,
-0.6433824897,
0.7229706645,
0.1210981384,
-0.3952621818,
0.202737242,
-0.4079238772,
0.6553603411,
0.5194057226,
0.1057552099,
0.2693194151,
-0.181745559,
-0.8157649636,
0.6903706789,
-0.8374025822,
-0.4031912684,
0.7716414332,
-0.0891134441,
0.9964609146,
-0.2566899061,
0.7743442655,
-0.0073128794,
0.1369651705,
-0.6243036985,
0.7463482618,
0.3158667684,
-0.521638155,
-0.5786142945,
-0.4589547217,
-0.9880506396,
0.4285694659,
0.121266894,
-1.0145679712,
-0.0192834511,
0.3754894733,
-0.5574582815,
0.4257885814,
-0.5739787221,
0.5644631386,
-0.0551928878,
-0.0063825832,
0.0051161903,
-0.5651006699,
0.1366620809,
0.043745935,
0.2783935666,
-0.0309429429,
0.2678188384,
0.4542060792,
-0.4195638299,
0.6711169481,
-0.2485714555,
-0.237348035,
0.7600616217,
0.2151466906,
1.0586385727,
-0.1178248525,
-0.1204735637,
-0.2905863225,
-0.3085182309,
-0.2788939774,
-0.8037078977,
0.6330458522,
-0.3527634144,
-0.8077828288,
-0.0590068735,
-0.7177268863,
-0.7277706861,
0.27823174,
0.3342712522,
0.4463916719,
0.1740792692,
-0.0904928073,
0.5008506179,
0.016789563,
0.1902882606,
0.0653151348,
-0.5872849226,
-0.531324327,
0.5018358231,
0.1650369018,
0.7376425266,
0.2872991264,
0.322491467,
-0.5983102918,
-0.3872677088,
-0.7469357252,
0.2035392374,
-1.0728173256,
-0.1162418723,
-0.7369925976,
-0.1983772963,
-0.5418621898,
-0.2273482978,
-0.0407982953,
0.0262899585,
0.1136953533,
-0.5906100273,
0.4184398055,
0.719148159,
0.027215695,
-0.0735142231,
-0.7615740299,
0.4314320385,
0.6661558747,
0.0933987573,
0.3587275445,
-0.1507663727,
-0.0622763298,
0.1236558557,
-0.1960160285,
-0.9317663312,
-0.0476733483,
-0.2913702726,
0.6041728258,
0.2187570482,
0.0865188017,
0.9993148446,
-0.78160882,
0.8180280328,
0.3327871859,
-1.016851902,
0.8473293781,
-0.4606791735,
0.2987654805,
0.5529901385,
0.3824174404,
-0.4088965654,
-0.7104774714,
-0.6608418822,
-1.0146175623,
0.3866500258,
0.1023295894,
0.1113089621,
-0.4629663825,
0.1151207611,
-0.0324712805,
0.1591360718,
-0.5588096976,
-0.2259343863,
0.0217321832,
-0.0782824531,
0.1476207823,
0.0398465842,
-0.1947601587,
-0.3350874782,
0.7136968374,
-0.7088996172,
0.3373106122,
0.242621392,
0.1730650663,
-0.3129695356,
0.3809969127,
0.1785262525,
0.8283442259,
0.1571795344,
0.3366461396,
0.4174660444,
-0.0583424643,
0.2307952046,
-0.0452248231,
-0.2938529253,
-0.1139172018,
0.290402621,
0.6309673786,
0.0588945076,
-0.2134957165,
0.3413844705,
0.2934717536,
-0.3083925843,
0.0786886215,
-0.0328622796,
0.2750647962,
0.2202041,
0.3292305768,
-0.3924096823,
-0.1869868189,
-0.6318878531,
0.1613611281,
0.3247708082,
-0.1530963331,
0.1421763897,
0.5805880427,
0.0679002702,
-0.0714936182,
0.762019217,
-0.2121173292,
-0.6452628374,
0.6470418572,
0.6668490171,
0.6630488038,
0.0183796678,
0.3924594522,
0.595033884,
0.2843432128,
-0.038662307,
0.6193102002,
-0.00946684,
-0.8559828401,
-0.5730891228,
-0.2501668632,
-0.4081307352,
0.2374456376,
-0.6101993322,
0.1805724055,
-0.4301512539,
-0.0989104286,
0.0141084595,
-0.3800462186,
-0.5343922377,
0.3653775752,
0.4609268606,
0.8669114113,
-0.8472730517,
0.6102930307,
0.4933825433,
-0.7688477039,
-1.2860915661,
0.3777187467,
-0.0965988114,
-0.9674460292,
0.2955173254,
0.0793351978,
-0.5488989949,
0.2937222421,
-0.808766067,
-0.8308748603,
1.1353501081,
0.3616176844,
-0.4503704607,
-0.1279102415,
-0.0417131148,
0.3930734098,
-0.4596296251,
0.2694133818,
0.437815398,
0.718061626,
0.6247873902,
-0.6281280518,
0.330404371,
-0.1343568712,
-0.1321170628,
0.3969261646,
-0.4500058591,
1.1207747459,
-0.6105820537,
-0.2205759436,
-0.0929640383,
0.4698505402,
0.7134677768,
0.0797174051,
0.8963064551,
0.44642663,
1.3319637775,
-0.0483780205,
1.212020874,
-0.4398543835,
0.4405068457,
1.167318821,
-0.4726130962,
0.6627462506,
0.4734602869,
-0.1039850116,
0.9403406978,
0.7551763654,
0.2545512021,
0.2813560963,
0.3657244146,
-0.1794697195,
-0.6304550171,
-0.0122554405,
-0.4041611552,
0.0766645968,
0.3544392288,
-0.2186092585,
-0.4749939442,
-0.2135573775,
0.2378169894,
-0.2603174746,
-0.301987797,
0.6331344843,
0.1607750952,
-1.1798579693,
0.4972284734,
-0.4151006341,
-0.1756937057,
-0.727163434,
-0.2471349686,
-0.0376265422,
-0.2595665455,
0.0397039764,
-1.2253358364,
-0.2115320712,
0.0661360025,
-0.0569722876,
-0.3219679594,
0.6117697358,
-0.6523331404,
-0.5153215528,
0.6338639855,
0.9849476814,
0.2092640251,
-0.0414782129,
-0.7068135142,
-0.3075708747,
-0.2180775106,
-0.2831028998,
-0.0110651599,
0.7525473237,
-0.170900777,
0.7294372916,
0.7891486883,
0.0557419211,
-0.0205550548,
0.7553521991,
1.0749528408,
-0.4151580632,
-0.7937928438,
-0.8201152682,
0.4933927655,
-0.1720682532,
-0.0774067119,
0.6180129051,
0.3183443248,
0.7436864376,
0.135810405,
1.0160280466,
-0.2212039381,
0.2576559484,
-0.7564846873,
0.2437473089,
-0.430775255,
0.0516855791,
-0.4939939678,
-0.6988998652,
-0.1031127796,
0.46238482,
-0.4301608801,
0.4741837382,
1.1992297173,
0.7980329394,
0.0723990947,
0.1121797562,
0.2785567939,
0.1908691525,
0.3817920983,
0.7519062161,
1.0110298395,
-0.1178472042,
0.7069047689,
0.1732677668,
-0.0420146734,
0.1690312177,
-0.8941138983,
-0.84391433,
-0.5083066225,
-0.2242887318,
-0.5300475955,
-0.092275925,
0.8471559286,
0.7439726591,
-0.7313428521,
0.162408039,
-0.3908522725,
0.4430497289,
-0.4177843332,
-0.2147582471,
0.4138555527,
-0.5878478289,
-0.7627810836,
0.4514600635,
0.2340996563,
0.0472794473,
-0.3809587359,
0.0061362511,
-0.5440818071,
0.1523288786,
0.6684039831,
0.0329709873,
-0.6984058022,
-0.7699209452,
-0.1957194656,
0.088630259,
0.1062278152,
1.034937501,
-0.7767516971,
0.3838257194,
0.670575738,
0.4580373168,
0.5557089448,
0.2044496387,
0.6174640059,
-0.9888786674,
-0.2149817646,
0.2350563854,
0.6025776267,
0.2230726331,
-0.5465779305,
0.5071099997,
0.1465392709,
-0.3868788481,
-0.3349027932,
0.4566475153,
-0.735647738,
-0.3402643502,
1.5157456398,
-0.336669147,
-0.1727611423,
-0.397577852,
-0.3228753209,
0.303313911,
-0.2910871208,
0.3629924059,
0.9671577811,
-0.3667802513,
-0.1136423424,
-0.3185122311,
0.1269737035,
0.0829289183,
-1.0839596987,
0.3625666201,
0.5597043633,
0.1736090034,
0.3232160211,
0.9522628188,
-0.1365795135,
0.1165420562,
0.2621559203,
-0.1805958301,
-0.1263270527,
-0.7977021933,
0.1307265759,
0.4405670762,
-0.0621692277,
-0.310371846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09761v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09761v2
|
MAFALDA: A Benchmark and Comprehensive Study of Fallacy Detection and Classification
| 2023-11-16T10:35:11 | 2024-04-09T20:49:26 |
Chadi Helwe, Tom Calamai, Pierre-Henri Paris, Chloé Clavel, Fabian Suchanek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We introduce MAFALDA, a benchmark for fallacy classification that merges and
unites previous fallacy datasets. It comes with a taxonomy that aligns,
refines, and unifies existing classifications of fallacies. We further provide
a manual annotation of a part of the dataset together with manual explanations
for each annotation. We propose a new annotation scheme tailored for subjective
NLP tasks, and a new evaluation method designed to handle subjectivity. We then
evaluate several language models under a zero-shot learning setting and human
performances on MAFALDA to assess their capability to detect and classify
fallacies.
|
[
-0.4254970551,
-0.7906932831,
0.3473835588,
0.0554663688,
0.0018352319,
0.1229763776,
0.1970158666,
-0.3217793405,
-0.0315413848,
0.5462575555,
-0.3945708871,
-0.5905662775,
-0.7684773803,
0.2204505801,
-0.5496409535,
1.1165802479,
-0.0393467918,
0.075014241,
-0.2427275926,
-0.5912308693,
-0.2648375332,
-0.7287185192,
-0.3302015662,
-0.5911667943,
0.2940069139,
0.3631001413,
0.6889770031,
0.1425575614,
0.5250149965,
0.2432305068,
0.0730853304,
0.3786535561,
-0.0322245285,
-0.0597900301,
-0.0178909991,
-0.5269972682,
-0.3699964285,
0.2171562016,
0.368578732,
0.8443251848,
-0.585308969,
0.4786841869,
-0.3408691883,
0.6989418268,
-0.8873378634,
0.0160227101,
-0.3983621597,
0.4106926322,
-0.3815465868,
0.21881859,
-0.5742032528,
-0.6181412935,
0.020757569,
-0.1025957689,
0.3546618521,
0.028160695,
0.8875404596,
0.6965758204,
-0.6398387551,
-0.1482488215,
-0.3066908121,
1.0642521381,
-0.9775273204,
0.5444915891,
0.0074646184,
0.5492511988,
-0.1511345953,
-0.245906204,
-0.7615039349,
-0.3283444941,
0.1295960844,
-0.2645233274,
-0.0866475627,
-0.1554928869,
0.2993484735,
0.5075064301,
-0.4011289179,
-0.1356272846,
0.038184531,
-0.2755719721,
0.6456211805,
-0.117104426,
0.3014248908,
-0.2033949345,
-0.3843887448,
0.0437928066,
-0.5893579721,
-0.2422316968,
0.3284189999,
0.2228612453,
-0.0576900095,
0.455342114,
-0.2900992334,
0.8628394008,
-0.042526558,
-0.3663961887,
0.7683165073,
-0.0502710789,
-0.3647407293,
0.0362548009,
0.584579885,
0.5107307434,
0.2105029225,
-0.1087202802,
-0.1070233807,
0.4675868154,
0.2464650124,
-0.3359396756,
-0.1600917131,
0.1033234373,
-0.5515732765,
-0.7979871631,
-0.1226689592,
-0.7462972403,
-0.7183240056,
-0.2289743721,
0.3562339544,
-0.1434901655,
-0.5105965137,
0.3980393708,
-0.1473225504,
0.0093781371,
0.4582867026,
-0.7768912911,
0.5441963077,
0.7980219126,
0.8303156495,
-0.5085959435,
-0.4010394812,
-0.4042239785,
-0.1268919557,
-0.4446280599,
0.9906401634,
-0.3426141143,
-0.2722018957,
0.0655982569,
-0.0479577892,
0.0108708786,
-0.5885000229,
1.1378699541,
-0.2231848389,
0.3369897902,
-0.2339741439,
-0.4527520835,
-0.7727491856,
0.398699075,
-0.7298021317,
0.871896565,
0.2280934304,
-0.8788990378,
0.6064395308,
-0.9174672961,
-0.6648962498,
-0.2322254628,
-0.1013847813,
-0.4438440502,
0.2276785523,
-0.1536627263,
0.3499084711,
-0.5364652872,
0.5433031917,
-0.3406406641,
-0.1145713255,
0.5210185647,
-0.5136685967,
1.0091582537,
0.0911798477,
-0.5068398714,
-0.3398459554,
-0.7819396257,
-0.0735949576,
-0.1597957015,
-0.4625054002,
-0.3874844313,
0.1364301145,
0.0439800955,
0.2425856739,
0.1745386273,
-0.6669114232,
-0.0628554747,
-0.365613848,
0.0940598026,
0.6822704673,
-0.1005030349,
0.0359608829,
-0.4027489126,
0.3949421346,
0.194471404,
0.3178320825,
0.2665235996,
-0.5671101213,
-1.0287958384,
-0.0758382007,
0.5574734807,
0.5116372705,
-0.5931155682,
0.594268918,
-0.1808906198,
-0.45687747,
-0.5203104615,
0.0989560708,
0.5926527381,
1.1404652596,
0.5154656172,
-0.5000463724,
-0.2508904636,
-1.2184333801,
0.0957402289,
-0.3836621046,
0.0058726557,
0.0800875723,
0.7607240081,
-0.0862929001,
0.8575285077,
-0.5793216228,
-0.4568907619,
0.3107089102,
0.6555843949,
0.3646655083,
0.3969040811,
0.8739665151,
-0.9426827431,
-0.0221615322,
-0.0925333127,
-0.9550173879,
-0.3994823396,
0.3468259275,
0.0998798087,
0.5951909423,
-0.1179823726,
-0.5929104686,
0.2947990894,
0.3996022344,
-0.3032909632,
0.7447730899,
0.5521191955,
0.446282059,
-0.972181499,
-0.0229202248,
0.0139136007,
-0.1083507314,
-0.6156750321,
0.0448562987,
-0.3027740121,
0.3786596954,
-0.4942391813,
0.4764603376,
-0.1152763516,
-0.0962942094,
-0.2029352635,
-0.1212247908,
0.091496326,
0.3363359272,
0.1433163434,
0.6561082602,
0.4012598991,
-0.5051130056,
0.488437742,
0.4135080576,
-0.3060234785,
0.9434766769,
-0.4696792364,
0.0362509899,
-0.0132186264,
0.0950175896,
-0.841648221,
-0.2090243697,
0.3293209076,
-0.6548305154,
-0.0389328413,
-0.2320396304,
-0.50714463,
-0.2300712466,
-0.3285452724,
0.0277937744,
0.26888901,
-0.6882007718,
0.5334990621,
0.7055915594,
0.3173592687,
-1.2350565195,
-1.0001415014,
-0.0743098259,
-0.3092177808,
-0.0655676574,
-0.0968304053,
-0.0718214065,
-0.4544344842,
-0.2197616696,
-0.1597587019,
-0.3602833152,
0.4363691509,
0.2405145466,
0.1566099972,
-0.2688755393,
0.3224982023,
0.0480999909,
0.091348961,
0.0504053645,
0.1426355839,
0.3654944897,
-0.1759977043,
-0.5713064075,
-0.0527902283,
0.32899791,
0.4391143322,
0.1316979676,
0.4988197684,
0.3288540244,
-0.4629290402,
-0.5087617636,
-0.7324416637,
0.1799622178,
-0.3770737648,
0.0201983154,
-0.4839133322,
-0.5272187591,
0.1696546823,
-0.1106752977,
0.5502848625,
0.3581439853,
0.4602336884,
0.0709562227,
0.9544817209,
0.5324653387,
0.0052076206,
-0.0843192264,
-0.1733520627,
0.1543517709,
-0.5429639816,
-0.1194965765,
-0.671807766,
-0.1153596044,
-0.2561964393,
-0.6252096295,
-0.1547852606,
-0.0795388371,
-0.2763696313,
0.2705328166,
-0.6082674861,
0.5590249896,
0.1488857567,
-0.2127646059,
0.4595225453,
-0.1300730556,
-0.0539275967,
-0.2408851981,
-0.3438887,
-0.833983779,
1.1809307337,
0.2738539577,
0.4615304172,
0.6265456676,
0.6786291599,
0.9867628217,
0.7810345292,
-0.9374228716,
0.6351967454,
-0.2668567896,
-0.9136565924,
-0.0569202825,
-0.3768095076,
-0.4843353629,
0.3779061735,
-0.2996018529,
-0.5812553167,
0.2424219549,
0.0060653058,
-0.0611897409,
0.2133367807,
-0.7670514584,
0.9729814529,
-0.2213165164,
0.029082315,
-0.0316966288,
-0.4047097862,
0.9259660244,
-0.2947283685,
0.4304097295,
-0.6747412682,
-0.2610676885,
0.8687556386,
-0.4830344915,
0.8309574723,
-0.2998965383,
-0.1416556835,
-0.0895449445,
0.2343575805,
-0.2808926105,
-0.3103936911,
-0.4378320277,
0.5755380392,
0.1927987933,
-0.3757861555,
-0.4663718045,
0.4230420589,
-0.4790908694,
-0.3759942055,
-0.8842493892,
-0.1443944722,
-0.4655760825,
0.2371130735,
-0.2006011754,
0.3411381543,
-0.5035302639,
0.0915355757,
0.5447618365,
0.2922334373,
0.212449044,
0.7973091602,
-0.410446465,
-0.3399275243,
0.6609282494,
0.0221150964,
-0.0122990562,
0.252319783,
-0.0863162503,
-0.4402559102,
-0.713594079,
-0.435985148,
0.2237377912,
-1.2255811691,
-0.4162035882,
-0.3445488214,
-0.0631072447,
-0.2553417683,
-0.0134140877,
-0.1195342988,
-0.6383549571,
-0.0242625326,
-0.1318994164,
0.2924394608,
0.5275675654,
-0.0491739027,
0.3533504605,
-0.6866180897,
0.4219610989,
0.2577112019,
0.1484414488,
0.0396721326,
-0.492459476,
0.1726250798,
-0.0439629629,
-0.3415716588,
-1.0150233507,
0.0012045905,
0.2858319581,
0.7869384885,
0.6522315741,
0.3143230677,
0.2917258143,
-0.647954762,
0.7516030073,
0.4932134449,
-1.2910915613,
0.6685279608,
0.0648298264,
-0.2580966353,
0.8349465132,
0.6871374846,
-0.4643673301,
-0.1113703847,
-0.5909842253,
-0.2769758403,
0.4340905249,
0.0341297612,
-0.0488541126,
-0.2485078275,
0.1844994575,
0.426335603,
0.5949041247,
-0.7514440417,
-0.314260453,
0.0214894842,
-0.4473260343,
-0.0980051905,
-0.0538841374,
-0.5943938494,
-0.1122483164,
0.5626024008,
-0.5999781489,
-0.0896255746,
-0.0651280731,
-0.3182225525,
0.0268968754,
0.1421835124,
0.3820255101,
1.106292963,
-0.2146610618,
0.1119463667,
0.4081338048,
-0.2726801932,
0.5286123157,
0.1790656447,
-0.5808899403,
0.6625731587,
0.5913271904,
0.4686470926,
0.2714882493,
-0.7806479931,
0.7447275519,
0.0492196009,
-0.2743231356,
-0.3417869806,
0.0689379722,
-0.2232801616,
0.000184308,
0.3698253036,
0.2593846321,
0.6524256468,
-0.6626572609,
0.3490129411,
0.3320645988,
-0.111262992,
-0.1405622959,
0.6490221024,
0.4156156182,
-0.3133019507,
-0.0241423529,
0.074347198,
-0.4772112072,
0.3387432694,
-0.0014860173,
0.7981013656,
-0.4478339553,
0.8671728373,
0.1341365427,
0.2178055048,
-0.1960345507,
0.2605676949,
-0.4139016569,
-1.095115304,
-0.1904112399,
-0.9907872081,
-0.9741176963,
-0.0916222185,
-0.4941143394,
0.4778105319,
-0.6449152827,
-0.3581849635,
0.6906752586,
0.108714208,
-0.0545628145,
0.3265045285,
0.2140458673,
0.8666575551,
-1.2609701157,
0.6070510149,
0.7126145363,
-0.8234442472,
-0.0374609381,
0.229209438,
0.3392938375,
-0.589969039,
0.7075504661,
0.3959138393,
-0.6703796387,
-0.4545437694,
-0.4753870964,
-0.5340667963,
0.751716733,
0.3569155037,
-0.1625295579,
0.0850158408,
-0.0247067288,
0.5084130168,
-0.7045548558,
0.0250020605,
0.7108978629,
0.3533316553,
0.0961045474,
-0.9529513717,
0.1036609337,
-0.0236098468,
-0.2107716948,
0.1468536854,
-0.7259430885,
0.8938980103,
0.0494948104,
-0.1890592277,
-0.1703439504,
0.368506819,
0.2662805617,
0.5505444407,
0.8357261419,
0.7213807702,
0.9052761197,
-0.271797657,
0.6054416299,
0.2105026543,
0.4486996531,
1.0544981956,
-0.8033524156,
1.0451381207,
0.2255532593,
-0.4962228835,
0.7250671387,
0.7955470085,
-0.1574743986,
0.4120954871,
0.1506551206,
-0.2897881567,
-0.3470352292,
-0.3722559512,
-0.3209442198,
0.3546913862,
0.3119309843,
-0.1420104355,
-0.4085840583,
0.0735145286,
0.3402138352,
0.3165449202,
-0.0868974924,
0.5529970527,
0.0961812884,
-0.6171389818,
0.8462470174,
-0.0616983213,
0.80095613,
-0.1411687434,
-0.1843066365,
-0.1138783768,
0.3042036891,
-0.3929348886,
-0.8337977529,
0.3490091264,
0.0601988994,
-0.1407267302,
0.1620527506,
0.490984261,
0.0151361497,
-0.5281928778,
0.3386367261,
0.4996128678,
0.4263247848,
0.4764779508,
-1.1542538404,
0.0166351888,
-0.1107557267,
-0.0889787599,
-0.0837465972,
0.2075462788,
0.0082442928,
0.7984546423,
0.805755794,
0.0135440407,
-0.1329311877,
0.3195509017,
0.6747038364,
-0.475804925,
-0.1929873675,
-0.7022380233,
0.0802655816,
-0.5510939956,
-0.4331738353,
0.6326215863,
0.5686703324,
0.5512331128,
-0.1473141164,
0.7859494686,
-0.1270561665,
1.0751308203,
-0.6210551858,
0.6352149248,
-0.7473305464,
0.0156493597,
-0.1962577701,
-0.8796203136,
-0.4448518455,
0.6253522635,
-0.3117438257,
-0.0788918212,
0.7083700299,
0.5844175816,
-0.1111803427,
0.1394475847,
0.4001893699,
0.1492949277,
0.0114321355,
0.5267758369,
0.8425050974,
-0.5767759085,
0.3480772674,
-0.0704190657,
-0.2379832119,
-0.4713127017,
-0.8657506704,
-1.102148056,
-0.5447745919,
-0.7054883838,
-0.3508421183,
0.048418086,
0.7619810104,
0.7694644332,
-1.1594501734,
-0.1488963068,
0.2383244485,
0.4785045385,
-0.1778165251,
-0.2728535831,
0.0422780886,
-0.1883370429,
-0.7874773741,
0.2326558381,
0.1505289972,
0.0937946811,
-0.4900250435,
0.0709591731,
-0.6258485317,
0.3719896376,
0.500400722,
0.3531056941,
-0.9209986329,
-0.2103436142,
-0.5073424578,
0.1432195902,
0.1955683678,
0.4008387625,
-0.4433628917,
0.2009861916,
0.4402570426,
0.5642755032,
0.1019164547,
0.1020834446,
0.4736735225,
-0.6377423406,
0.1604568362,
0.3025873601,
0.3142103851,
0.6961016655,
-0.1347611845,
0.924012363,
0.3253943324,
-0.3314782977,
-1.316593647,
0.3145987391,
-0.820525527,
-0.2852681577,
0.617192328,
-0.3832784295,
-0.6110127568,
-0.4170039296,
0.0233691856,
-0.2422214746,
-0.2991507351,
1.0640038252,
1.201562047,
-0.1724701524,
-0.2053325027,
-0.817363739,
0.6645154953,
0.4337132573,
-1.0777270794,
0.0667196214,
0.9732122421,
0.4477621019,
0.6682727933,
0.6200295091,
-0.0579985678,
0.6482836604,
-0.0599123538,
0.1152616069,
0.2038590014,
-0.1242823377,
-0.3382430077,
0.3115655482,
0.0862622783,
-0.4854249656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09758v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09758v2
|
OrchestraLLM: Efficient Orchestration of Language Models for Dialogue State Tracking
| 2023-11-16T10:30:55 | 2024-02-28T20:41:25 |
Chia-Hsuan Lee, Hao Cheng, Mari Ostendorf
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized the landscape of Natural
Language Processing systems, but are computationally expensive. To reduce the
cost without sacrificing performance, previous studies have explored various
approaches to harness the potential of Small Language Models (SLMs) as
cost-effective alternatives to their larger counterparts. Driven by findings
that SLMs and LLMs exhibit complementary strengths in a structured knowledge
extraction task, this work presents a novel SLM/LLM routing framework designed
to improve computational efficiency and enhance task performance. First,
exemplar pools are created to represent the types of contexts where each LM
provides a more reliable answer, leveraging a sentence embedding fine-tuned so
that context similarity is close to dialogue state similarity. Then, during
inference, the k-nearest exemplars to the testing instance are retrieved, and
the instance is routed according to majority vote. In dialogue state tracking
tasks, the proposed routing framework enhances performance substantially
compared to relying solely on LLMs, while reducing the computational costs by
over 50%.
|
[
-0.2263425142,
-0.7535967827,
0.7620034218,
-0.1744334549,
-0.3265485168,
0.2567377687,
-0.1826180369,
-0.2858507037,
0.0584940799,
0.7940739393,
-0.4670623541,
-0.4938922822,
-0.2379245907,
-0.2035588324,
-0.5015667677,
0.7213939428,
0.221251592,
0.00741647,
-0.2587606907,
-0.2868859172,
-0.0770621076,
-0.2590448856,
-0.8884966373,
-0.5165541768,
0.6219403744,
0.2119708508,
0.4509629309,
0.9692266583,
0.3989001513,
0.4607628286,
-0.2403489649,
0.2500757873,
-0.3668783903,
0.5415127873,
-0.0415916406,
-0.6405275464,
-0.4211279154,
-0.3221046627,
0.5977572799,
0.7328104377,
-0.4048689604,
0.314137578,
-0.0718831271,
0.7706865072,
-0.3882432282,
0.3974675536,
-0.7394405007,
-0.1892642379,
-0.5193506479,
-0.1414517164,
-0.3417043984,
-0.4182027876,
0.3161604702,
-0.5650400519,
-0.1070363745,
0.5600037575,
0.3346405029,
0.1937642395,
-0.2134447098,
-0.4550648332,
-0.5212844014,
0.6681208014,
-0.6747137904,
0.2961703539,
0.2600512505,
0.4082193971,
-0.054729145,
-0.9103534222,
-0.2875636816,
0.0135844378,
-0.1212399378,
-0.0310879592,
-0.3159205914,
0.2748696804,
0.2054049224,
0.35672158,
-0.6198917031,
0.1460230947,
-0.2883485556,
-0.1290720254,
0.5706589222,
0.401475668,
0.2155202627,
-0.0865684375,
-0.1085744128,
0.1685387194,
-0.6959379911,
0.212983802,
0.2968221307,
0.2911231816,
-0.1993326247,
0.4603881538,
-0.2652739584,
0.9664767981,
0.0351376161,
-0.3815433979,
0.054839626,
-0.3037289381,
-0.2996047139,
0.2533176243,
0.6543901563,
0.0020088491,
-0.1011393368,
-0.2372377813,
-0.2437953502,
0.0081875809,
0.2281049043,
-0.5630816817,
-0.3676714897,
0.0764711201,
-0.4527416229,
-0.2222895026,
-0.275026679,
-0.8941725492,
-0.3293975592,
-0.4136565626,
0.1710999459,
-0.563844502,
-0.0971257389,
-0.2632068396,
0.1629126966,
0.2464023083,
0.4490747154,
-0.8352274895,
0.4842118621,
1.1408007145,
1.1140421629,
-0.359171778,
0.1818424314,
-1.1014435291,
0.0887089074,
-0.4428705573,
0.6557042599,
-0.7463853955,
-0.1274584085,
-0.0039575635,
-0.1375777423,
-0.2876865268,
-0.5248386264,
0.4566841125,
-0.9891670346,
0.0318973921,
0.1902516633,
-0.9048831463,
-0.2309865952,
0.0310600102,
-0.6406152248,
0.8701832294,
0.1013325974,
-0.3586566448,
-0.1344295591,
-0.6315516233,
-0.5869758725,
0.115468055,
-0.0674296692,
-0.2108001709,
0.2477101237,
0.1366351545,
0.1561760753,
-0.4841759801,
0.220257774,
-0.2711488008,
-0.4351184666,
-0.0455941483,
-0.1865757853,
0.6509455442,
0.4764865339,
-0.178718999,
0.3304885924,
-0.9049748778,
0.0606114306,
-0.2894316018,
-0.4379504919,
-0.6984980106,
0.2345384955,
-0.3348080218,
0.1496504843,
-0.0745982304,
-0.4360688925,
0.0776579008,
-0.7949225307,
0.409140408,
0.9217202067,
-0.1238161549,
1.0935686827,
-0.2913674414,
0.6779415607,
-0.1817167997,
-0.1290969402,
-0.4631009996,
-0.3337822855,
-0.91731745,
-0.4769918323,
0.1700569838,
0.3768526614,
-0.8405427337,
0.135832727,
-0.2106949389,
-0.5878879428,
-0.8113998771,
0.2593608201,
0.3985014856,
0.6734902859,
0.0996898785,
0.065623641,
-0.61583215,
-0.7780582905,
-0.2428514063,
-0.2534831464,
0.1033150703,
0.3190474212,
0.2981802821,
0.2337108105,
0.9616749287,
-0.4652480483,
-0.3184784949,
-0.37632972,
0.1128724217,
0.2146338075,
0.3842903674,
0.1559493095,
-0.6171712875,
-0.5230567455,
0.1124715209,
-0.6442197561,
-0.4668990672,
0.1709911078,
-0.2666376829,
0.2981289029,
0.4385562837,
-0.5839810371,
0.1628199071,
0.6826961637,
-0.1231439859,
0.3388494551,
0.0993035883,
-0.087216191,
-0.720081389,
-0.0274277627,
-0.2262576967,
-0.3606305122,
-0.7988989353,
0.0644297674,
-0.145927608,
-0.1072600484,
-0.3494523764,
0.6848368645,
-0.5909411907,
-0.2528813779,
-0.1907762438,
0.4619311392,
-0.0620828159,
0.7485993505,
-0.0704031736,
0.6847116947,
0.8609696627,
-0.658575654,
0.467610538,
0.0104568861,
-0.6233279705,
0.6930403709,
-0.4083505571,
0.2550168633,
-0.0394226387,
0.2072063982,
-0.9333642721,
-0.0264904741,
0.0673156902,
-0.0679779351,
0.0832221285,
-0.3093931675,
-0.3988330364,
-0.0006016681,
-0.0258109234,
0.2233113647,
0.7955856919,
-0.4892682433,
0.9735316038,
0.527420938,
-0.3909606338,
0.1311724782,
-0.491691798,
-0.0459157825,
-0.6353542209,
-0.7283195257,
0.1765341163,
0.0888605639,
-0.634676218,
-0.2403691411,
-0.2607128322,
-0.1789774597,
0.2099870443,
0.2300112247,
0.0880561769,
-0.3692378104,
0.3924660683,
0.0631295815,
-0.1064113975,
0.0887791142,
-0.5753324032,
0.6030961871,
-0.0567124113,
-0.5353684425,
-0.3434423506,
0.5014948845,
0.7037987113,
-0.3920419812,
0.4545718729,
0.3713578284,
-0.0696621537,
-0.4042236805,
-0.6089231968,
-0.1854558885,
-0.4959473312,
0.2469430864,
-0.2007247061,
-1.2214024067,
0.4452781379,
-0.3107863963,
0.233145833,
0.0627266094,
0.3100648522,
-0.2737724781,
1.1730593443,
0.2500743866,
-0.3464816213,
0.4399271905,
0.0675691068,
0.2424286902,
-0.9370085001,
-0.0705537647,
-0.7241020799,
-0.1866772324,
-0.4070821404,
-0.6468576193,
0.673237443,
0.0842363238,
-0.1839636266,
-0.0257553887,
0.002910821,
0.1117372587,
0.6234492064,
-0.2343514711,
0.586827755,
0.1525322497,
-0.3077920079,
0.0526547991,
-1.1849241257,
-0.5238804817,
0.6751319766,
0.0576332994,
0.9023082256,
0.3849396408,
0.6660116911,
0.3656098843,
0.3353196383,
-0.5763946176,
0.7852191329,
-0.0318545513,
-0.1919891983,
-0.4739166498,
-0.4653042257,
-0.8352134824,
0.5986498594,
0.1792013645,
-1.063888669,
-0.2053214014,
0.2414187044,
-0.3197187483,
0.3581335247,
-0.404807657,
0.5163826346,
-0.2790972292,
-0.521337688,
-0.2261698842,
-0.570535779,
0.423761338,
-0.2180107683,
0.464654088,
-0.0704776347,
-0.0689699799,
0.7294422388,
-0.6837489009,
0.6740812063,
-0.1054530442,
-0.0612428337,
0.4299014211,
0.2468366474,
1.0255610943,
-0.1373293549,
-0.3583455086,
-0.1309840679,
-0.3425925374,
0.0788866878,
-0.7815779448,
0.8129785657,
-0.1860098541,
-0.6356035471,
-0.2148485631,
-0.6158989072,
-0.2289922088,
0.0582474992,
-0.1074451134,
0.7611065507,
0.1516422331,
0.3795611858,
0.6845268011,
-0.0965083539,
0.664160192,
0.8748553991,
-0.3249942064,
-0.2900633216,
0.7013700604,
-0.1139137596,
0.3627230525,
0.3605041504,
0.1783423871,
-0.4925908446,
-0.4999571443,
-0.5972642303,
-0.0447850972,
-0.4621109664,
-0.1664867699,
-0.7016370893,
-0.0297524203,
-0.2444938719,
-0.0695027187,
-0.4553786814,
-0.2034839839,
-0.2718986273,
-0.1489433497,
0.403029263,
0.3583679199,
0.0549907051,
0.4551166594,
-0.6981779337,
0.0872491822,
0.2847471535,
0.3991774917,
0.3283545375,
-0.5846802592,
-0.3120261431,
-0.1479808092,
-0.0850987509,
-0.7185908556,
0.3222026229,
0.3776918948,
0.6838304996,
0.2928302884,
0.2083277851,
1.0165666342,
-0.7167887092,
0.8410611153,
0.1760341078,
-0.9823323488,
0.5316976309,
-0.3286520243,
0.5065150857,
0.3304023445,
-0.1019758284,
-0.4651238918,
-0.7369171977,
-0.4653851986,
-0.811824739,
1.0390808582,
0.363565743,
-0.2596760988,
-0.0166625902,
-0.0002396828,
-0.200600192,
0.2828851044,
-0.2698962986,
-0.3976206183,
0.3598270118,
-0.204581216,
-0.0803192034,
-0.1460130215,
-0.1901423037,
-0.2078416348,
0.8127710819,
-0.2583943307,
0.063556321,
0.1176236495,
-0.3139599264,
-0.0994247422,
0.3248513937,
0.6017774343,
0.544683218,
0.2366369963,
0.3818159401,
0.2661570013,
0.1261557639,
0.2363143414,
0.045287665,
-0.534054935,
0.095610939,
0.5247883201,
1.0473967791,
0.5641518235,
-0.7550038695,
0.2339755148,
0.1903768778,
-0.0036365474,
-0.236579299,
0.3833771944,
0.4087245464,
0.591740191,
0.2526471317,
-0.0447429307,
0.1309324354,
-0.3134637177,
0.2776019573,
0.3615218699,
-0.5480219126,
-0.1919214725,
0.4222533107,
0.2964502871,
-0.778265059,
0.3971644044,
-0.0433997959,
-0.4918968379,
0.4627148509,
0.4371629655,
0.7552654147,
-0.2090639472,
0.1671849489,
0.1696303487,
0.0451188684,
-0.2201378793,
-0.0675451159,
-0.3614230454,
-0.3486197591,
-0.4160625637,
-0.9010870457,
-0.1379172504,
-0.0441219099,
-0.7141601443,
-0.1376646906,
-0.016062459,
0.060973078,
-0.3757669926,
-0.2795947492,
-0.3887242377,
-0.1472412348,
0.2443146855,
1.0068253279,
-0.4270622134,
0.955021441,
0.6498296857,
0.1463933587,
-0.8725901246,
-0.457338959,
0.3323385715,
-0.4740281403,
0.5216289163,
-0.0773033947,
-0.4142415226,
0.0852366164,
-0.292072773,
-1.0464291573,
1.1576390266,
0.2339880764,
-0.8867246509,
0.1139395684,
0.0201777201,
0.7026384473,
-0.6859636903,
0.0828361735,
0.7506234646,
0.3827242851,
0.1549763381,
-0.7941328883,
-0.1218573079,
0.0226352904,
0.0792866349,
0.2591183186,
-0.5594390035,
0.6689899564,
0.1228667945,
-0.2465907931,
0.3417183757,
0.6935774088,
0.5253141522,
0.5261223912,
0.6683576107,
0.4243099391,
0.9673634768,
-0.1614723504,
0.8828585148,
-0.2994145453,
0.1014151871,
1.4461774826,
-0.5787317157,
0.579442203,
0.6016997695,
-0.0561742298,
0.5652715564,
0.4088801742,
0.3277904093,
0.7501090765,
0.5566685796,
-0.4427586496,
-0.3546679914,
-0.0610077679,
0.0236776117,
0.6079143286,
0.1568378508,
-0.5372555256,
-0.3759467006,
0.1088882461,
0.1546795666,
0.1107045412,
-0.5417901278,
1.0587871075,
0.2249442041,
-1.2124352455,
0.0791559741,
-0.15249677,
0.3268331587,
-0.9326606989,
-0.060392689,
-0.4657563865,
0.0568546243,
0.1167690009,
-0.3278585374,
0.3036754131,
0.1991918087,
-0.0272643231,
-0.3206478655,
0.8059696555,
-0.6605638266,
-0.4422677159,
0.3767757118,
0.5885804296,
0.1144984066,
0.0639845356,
-0.6162857413,
0.2560905516,
-0.0301397797,
-0.3186939061,
0.4535206258,
0.2956240773,
-0.112933889,
0.9453882575,
0.6980583668,
0.2792812884,
0.2794930935,
0.1486715376,
0.76803267,
-0.3808616102,
-0.8207668662,
-0.9547176957,
0.4697535336,
-0.3192459643,
-0.0426128358,
0.7711577415,
0.5965917706,
0.4255155623,
0.1461732388,
0.6233582497,
0.031360995,
0.5505208969,
-0.7610856295,
0.515679121,
-0.4951007366,
0.7590930462,
-0.2519007325,
-0.7334593534,
0.0239372607,
0.5487603545,
-0.1321878731,
-0.2966636717,
0.594119072,
0.9455792904,
0.0601183325,
0.3558378816,
0.3041019142,
0.2581112981,
0.4388498664,
0.5108704567,
0.7860062718,
-0.0789910927,
0.525229454,
-0.2626084685,
0.0253088009,
-0.0293425713,
-0.7851800323,
-0.7141191959,
-0.4962075949,
-0.305431664,
-0.0044177296,
0.1817188561,
0.7827506065,
1.0318127871,
-0.5840060115,
-0.5213364959,
-0.1593819261,
0.4903147221,
-0.3464435637,
-0.2783764899,
0.3928620219,
-0.4071091712,
-0.5684896708,
0.6343575716,
0.5164373517,
-0.3747929931,
-0.2855271399,
-0.3228654563,
-0.2005712837,
0.0496310182,
0.6521299481,
0.0089878878,
-1.0119533539,
-0.3420028389,
-0.0695072338,
-0.1502731442,
-0.0344092138,
0.8911226392,
-0.7254192829,
0.4401944578,
0.4108712971,
0.6323038936,
0.5711554289,
0.1822581589,
0.6328704357,
-0.5775205493,
-0.2200118303,
0.2700698376,
0.3299867809,
0.1419567913,
-0.0337219574,
0.6679808497,
0.1646192521,
-0.4889033735,
-0.8133830428,
0.2302024513,
-0.9864724278,
-0.012755204,
1.1711679697,
-0.3227945268,
-0.3245840967,
-0.3101492822,
-0.0884060115,
0.0183480959,
-0.4964361489,
0.3647733331,
0.5957394838,
-0.3199972808,
-0.4703658819,
-0.5053195953,
0.5320740342,
0.2886618376,
-0.8073502183,
0.0004339406,
0.6216919422,
0.1708234102,
0.1400023848,
0.7078378797,
0.10072653,
0.0161890611,
-0.2145436257,
-0.4348564744,
-0.1961963773,
-0.1908318251,
-0.3122906983,
0.4733672142,
-0.2644973993,
-0.0210147873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09756v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09756v1
|
FairytaleCQA: Integrating a Commonsense Knowledge Graph into Children's Storybook Narratives
| 2023-11-16T10:30:26 | 2023-11-16T10:30:26 |
Jiaju Chen, Yuxuan Lu, Shao Zhang, Bingsheng Yao, Yuanzhe Dong, Ying Xu, Yunyao Li, Qianwen Wang, Dakuo Wang, Yuling Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
AI models (including LLM) often rely on narrative question-answering (QA)
datasets to provide customized QA functionalities to support downstream
children education applications; however, existing datasets only include QA
pairs that are grounded within the given storybook content, but children can
learn more when teachers refer the storybook content to real-world knowledge
(e.g., commonsense knowledge). We introduce the FairytaleCQA dataset, which is
annotated by children education experts, to supplement 278 storybook narratives
with educationally appropriate commonsense knowledge. The dataset has 5,868 QA
pairs that not only originate from the storybook narrative but also contain the
commonsense knowledge grounded by an external knowledge graph (i.e.,
ConceptNet). A follow-up experiment shows that a smaller model (T5-large)
fine-tuned with FairytaleCQA reliably outperforms much larger prompt-engineered
LLM (e.g., GPT-4) in this new QA-pair generation task (QAG). This result
suggests that: 1) our dataset brings novel challenges to existing LLMs, and 2)
human experts' data annotation are still critical as they have much nuanced
knowledge that LLMs do not know in the children educational domain.
|
[
-0.3442922235,
-0.4300302565,
0.3775428534,
-0.1495817602,
-0.0598447397,
0.315992713,
0.414444685,
-0.6545042992,
-0.1886467636,
0.3845292032,
-0.7396054268,
-0.5124121904,
-0.3851737976,
0.0178910382,
-0.26061064,
0.8608535528,
-0.0214265753,
-0.2265096307,
-0.8757270575,
0.0467274934,
-0.576812923,
-0.4712914526,
-0.4812987149,
-0.1407532394,
0.6258575916,
0.6598116755,
0.7872109413,
0.6681516767,
0.0517785102,
0.2127562165,
-0.2399195582,
0.5768123865,
-0.4807404578,
0.035895668,
-0.2479260713,
-0.5637311339,
-0.3723599613,
0.0891314447,
0.3981050253,
0.8313099742,
0.0838463604,
0.2480502874,
0.2564851046,
0.6252930164,
-0.480286479,
0.2991481423,
-0.3466180265,
0.3066829145,
0.20340617,
0.0790311098,
-0.1275036633,
-0.5131465793,
0.3947052062,
-1.1009581089,
0.2241052687,
0.2986072004,
0.81817168,
0.1361991465,
-0.6657488346,
-0.4729468822,
-0.2996921837,
0.852815032,
-0.5033943057,
0.1850511432,
0.6865220666,
0.0870871842,
-0.1692740172,
-0.8164310455,
-0.775704205,
-0.0586923957,
-0.2175642848,
0.1894013137,
-0.3372853994,
-0.2883964181,
0.2093857378,
-0.0524088591,
-0.4447238743,
0.2128240317,
-0.4308692515,
-0.0926846415,
0.8347639441,
0.5417349339,
0.4113032818,
-0.3885498047,
-0.4536093473,
-0.0342452116,
-0.659730196,
0.3726014197,
0.3255337775,
0.1068285182,
-0.00594137,
0.3307600021,
-0.2070804387,
0.6179303527,
0.0848798454,
-0.2273684293,
0.1356858015,
-0.3660418391,
0.1900858283,
0.3027071059,
0.5387724638,
0.5953837633,
0.3571048677,
-0.0708490908,
-0.1979152858,
-0.0445315428,
0.0940997079,
-0.6416825652,
-0.341853261,
0.149298951,
-0.1810209304,
-0.4844235778,
-0.2405211329,
-0.7696527243,
-0.6376511455,
-0.3797258139,
0.4128004313,
-0.4260792434,
-0.1587227583,
-0.0996475965,
-0.2211266756,
0.2979132831,
0.4164181054,
-0.9164921045,
0.1895345449,
0.791156888,
0.5887622237,
-0.0911612734,
-0.3626254201,
-0.3771955967,
0.0083662597,
-0.775002718,
0.8628262281,
-0.500275135,
-0.3435078859,
-0.0793782473,
-0.2021958083,
-0.3297997415,
-0.4155863225,
0.6178975105,
-0.6229406595,
0.4364785552,
-0.3825355768,
-0.7197322249,
-0.2431835681,
0.3715893626,
-0.645162046,
0.7669910789,
0.0825785175,
-0.8635844588,
0.4160508811,
-0.3084007204,
-0.2954177558,
0.0503989831,
-0.0262102187,
-0.1447154731,
-0.1126248911,
0.7910523415,
0.3170520365,
-0.1867346615,
0.4828745723,
-0.0377842188,
-0.2955374122,
0.3368506432,
-0.7730093002,
0.7753790617,
0.1161659881,
0.0798999891,
-0.3454033434,
-0.57429111,
0.074270919,
0.1895702779,
0.0040658419,
-0.3131210208,
-0.0867255628,
0.0081931893,
0.3069202602,
0.2512641251,
-0.3867552876,
0.1204203442,
-0.2836017013,
0.4920851886,
0.5082275867,
0.2388882339,
0.0886780918,
-0.8631125093,
0.763623476,
0.0179738365,
0.1592872292,
-0.2548404932,
-0.7901417613,
-0.5181750655,
0.0503080189,
0.5155658126,
0.4398530126,
-0.9694917202,
0.2914537489,
-0.2922899127,
-0.5370505452,
-0.4474585652,
-0.0425826497,
0.3484340012,
0.9080063701,
0.3553381264,
-0.2324843109,
-0.1880632192,
-0.7813984752,
-0.0700424835,
-0.4624132514,
-0.0046180151,
0.6038683653,
0.3577257991,
0.2558611333,
1.19041574,
-0.3442918658,
0.0318452492,
-0.1629285961,
0.0426316671,
0.307033509,
0.5796691775,
0.3567086756,
-0.9692967534,
-0.3579872549,
-0.1884783953,
-0.7722290158,
-0.1288073808,
-0.2483622134,
-0.1155153811,
0.0093466612,
-0.0208938904,
-0.7207181454,
0.4109452367,
0.4970566034,
-0.7732373476,
0.7411211133,
0.0785316229,
0.4075211883,
-0.9342123866,
-0.1587481797,
-0.2402486056,
-0.1384827495,
-0.631872952,
-0.1513989717,
0.1548167765,
-0.0409781337,
-0.5277788639,
0.7823124528,
-0.015340412,
-0.116175428,
0.0407703333,
0.6458989382,
0.3641004264,
0.4257638752,
0.1213439927,
0.8287512064,
0.485942781,
-0.3269779384,
0.4727346599,
0.7583717704,
-0.0708264261,
0.7794269919,
-0.483187288,
0.2049223334,
0.1758377403,
0.2506164908,
-0.6610324383,
-0.1865728199,
0.2658681273,
-0.7261862755,
0.1502596587,
-0.1731303334,
-0.767369628,
-0.3088978529,
-0.2412273884,
0.3601797819,
0.509305656,
-1.0509431362,
0.4934199452,
0.1847617179,
-0.380674094,
-0.6727617979,
-0.4906461537,
0.4787735343,
-0.2431079596,
-0.7464761734,
0.1818313897,
-0.0453850552,
-0.0543890037,
0.3241021037,
-0.3267445266,
-0.2668026686,
0.0987399146,
0.1292856783,
0.3748239875,
-0.439884305,
0.4221871197,
0.505720675,
-0.2332651168,
0.2344204336,
-0.2429895997,
0.0931364745,
-0.053994868,
-0.2897588313,
-0.3990512192,
0.2189944983,
0.2451515645,
-0.2028368413,
0.6016404033,
0.3124541342,
-0.4623525739,
-0.3433371186,
-0.11410065,
-0.0810146555,
-0.447006017,
0.2518182993,
-0.2236695141,
-0.8757477403,
0.2414148301,
0.1337642223,
0.1291812658,
0.4635413587,
-0.0359526537,
-0.4854770601,
0.768029511,
0.2404436022,
-0.000533167,
-0.1541299373,
-0.2157446444,
0.0454196297,
-0.7064574361,
-0.3751855791,
-0.2605741918,
-0.351243645,
-0.5295891166,
-0.2652632892,
0.1926845461,
0.3025994897,
-0.2642059922,
-0.0262006987,
-0.3245870173,
0.6553760767,
0.8020992875,
0.1175437644,
0.6930887699,
-0.1522438377,
0.0199168641,
0.0872462764,
-1.1617139578,
-0.8839839697,
1.1541730165,
0.2916494906,
0.2560569942,
0.1058276966,
0.8318399191,
0.30985412,
0.2262868583,
-0.5269498229,
0.485136956,
-0.1491090655,
-0.6463474631,
-0.3309842944,
-0.3195118606,
-0.9080978036,
0.0154357906,
-0.3857232034,
-0.7596107721,
0.4285624623,
0.1377383918,
-0.612190783,
0.2899971604,
-0.7983854413,
0.7383714318,
-0.2619903982,
-0.5233242512,
-0.0755540803,
-0.4880379438,
0.3053340316,
-0.3424689472,
0.0262363199,
0.1461741775,
-0.2190251946,
0.9732552171,
-0.3795764446,
1.0336204767,
-0.0811629519,
-0.1462619454,
0.7386868,
0.0575722456,
0.4902900159,
0.1813703179,
0.1548980623,
-0.0477708913,
0.284948945,
-0.6070070267,
-0.631575942,
0.7253448367,
-0.8805018663,
-0.6137048602,
-0.5649216771,
-0.6770806909,
-0.665653348,
-0.096740976,
-0.199105531,
0.5326465964,
0.0921683908,
0.032665316,
0.719012022,
-0.4043858349,
0.3290161788,
0.2697123587,
-0.0958295166,
-0.302844286,
0.901665926,
0.2106877267,
0.1060972512,
0.1269468218,
0.2565095425,
-0.3842646778,
-0.7357356548,
-0.4565250576,
0.0076981867,
-0.7958256006,
-0.3274038136,
-0.5642538667,
-0.3979862928,
-0.1020120233,
-0.3041451275,
-0.0649130642,
-0.6445761323,
-0.5562769771,
-0.4860227406,
0.6774343848,
0.8887020946,
-0.1603218764,
0.0992860273,
-1.0102204084,
0.3061614037,
0.8603990674,
0.0362594537,
0.2290995121,
-0.5325552821,
-0.1844086796,
0.0593653396,
-0.2146166563,
-0.7966997623,
0.255823344,
0.1762095541,
0.4447015822,
0.2846909463,
0.2992369235,
0.5348292589,
-0.1698379964,
1.0267491341,
0.2107321471,
-0.7523596883,
0.2157505155,
-0.416837275,
0.0532489307,
0.1776655763,
0.3777162433,
-0.680162549,
-0.084378764,
-0.8134457469,
-0.7042900324,
0.8600900173,
0.3506517708,
0.3998920918,
0.2652440965,
0.3271937072,
0.3980812132,
0.3810177445,
-0.1947216243,
-0.1457504332,
-0.4917805195,
-0.5072318912,
0.0520235412,
-0.2147517502,
0.0196097996,
-0.1800146699,
0.4569925666,
-0.2084632516,
-0.1024373621,
0.0035815481,
0.0552483127,
-0.1213930324,
0.111118637,
0.0059532626,
0.8099409938,
0.1132691205,
0.0032023042,
0.2939753532,
-0.5956181884,
-0.1125133932,
0.4653995931,
-0.3519912958,
-0.4390900731,
1.0452586412,
0.6930330992,
0.1713441014,
-0.8244382739,
0.3612532914,
-0.0732521564,
-0.3102136254,
-0.1260141432,
0.4602666795,
0.4301838875,
0.6368976235,
0.6115407348,
-0.2438680828,
-0.051394958,
-0.1419876665,
0.5029748678,
-0.0306482799,
-0.2089217007,
-0.1946590394,
0.399045378,
0.2968299985,
-0.2130763382,
0.7482894659,
-0.1176706329,
-0.5141529441,
1.0736559629,
0.4393389225,
0.6963812113,
0.1324252039,
0.7203710675,
0.3927785456,
0.3244549334,
0.3975779414,
0.066097185,
-0.1146381199,
-0.7999787331,
-0.2008037865,
-0.3778592348,
-0.6453008056,
0.038875591,
-0.470775336,
-0.0291965976,
-0.3371101618,
0.2092253417,
-0.3495726883,
0.3386137187,
-0.8764427304,
0.6136929989,
0.2576341033,
0.7503665686,
-0.8267382383,
0.4713387787,
0.4470010102,
-0.4040924013,
-1.0225101709,
0.173049286,
-0.1446473598,
-0.7289959192,
0.5665873885,
0.0311243832,
0.2142656296,
0.1975184828,
-0.694018364,
-0.9003528953,
1.5186036825,
-0.0506720096,
-0.8584670424,
-0.1898413897,
0.2509225607,
0.6628651619,
-0.6351461411,
0.1600646675,
0.6407088041,
0.4630458057,
0.3234414756,
-0.5334900022,
-0.0898670554,
-0.235122934,
-0.284599632,
-0.3029550612,
-0.5371966958,
0.3851260543,
-0.4180627465,
-0.177302897,
0.018544035,
0.7785493731,
0.7562764287,
0.9183781743,
0.4268764257,
0.4251125455,
0.9944878221,
-0.0096369283,
0.6610448956,
-0.205629766,
0.0760153532,
1.1763166189,
0.0612023696,
0.7201724052,
0.3432318866,
-0.2338338494,
0.2568004429,
1.0655466318,
-0.0897383466,
0.3479114771,
0.0473570861,
-0.0923828855,
-0.4339160323,
-0.4263802469,
-0.2841406763,
0.1718564779,
0.3349132538,
-0.1445467621,
-0.0689218044,
-0.2053220719,
0.0449314006,
0.2047552168,
-0.4736416042,
0.6350659132,
0.2691935301,
-0.4760127664,
0.429574728,
-0.3310315609,
0.3483151197,
-0.2782729864,
-0.1843993515,
-0.6245663762,
-0.5541011691,
-0.2535182536,
-0.9424401522,
-0.3200224638,
0.2261788547,
0.0764445662,
0.1056962684,
0.6522042751,
-0.5004546642,
-0.672319293,
-0.0918858573,
0.8198931217,
-0.1511571109,
0.2673571706,
-0.7121133804,
-0.4263776839,
-0.0572249591,
-0.3929826021,
0.201378867,
0.8032432199,
-0.0745917112,
0.7798968554,
0.7073802948,
-0.0721722841,
-0.0094648656,
-0.2012307346,
1.0391677618,
-0.6136866808,
-0.6204770803,
-0.2079125494,
0.6820296049,
-0.0083728721,
-0.5196246505,
0.5904805064,
0.2339991629,
0.5444557071,
0.1552311331,
0.878020227,
0.2138441652,
0.3998472095,
-0.6571176052,
0.7926774621,
-0.4952623844,
0.2837097943,
-0.0969212577,
-0.8196550012,
-0.0637159199,
0.1849686205,
-0.3330124915,
0.183788836,
0.7376879454,
0.5355471969,
0.1265064329,
0.4885404408,
0.3192287982,
0.0355096646,
0.2221107632,
0.8876486421,
1.2698765993,
-0.3490574062,
0.4159257114,
-0.3015290201,
-0.1797372401,
0.1661171019,
-0.8132781386,
-0.9911859035,
-0.5181567073,
-0.4774310589,
-0.11272569,
0.5208913088,
0.8575572371,
0.3263460398,
-0.7500852942,
0.2740637958,
0.045896925,
0.2915706635,
-0.1517713368,
-0.2107880712,
0.8601868749,
-0.2030399591,
-0.7335591912,
0.353438586,
-0.3289422989,
-0.0274479166,
-0.2823550999,
-0.196967572,
0.0468004458,
0.3503765166,
0.2660979629,
0.0681468397,
-0.398986727,
-0.3385327756,
-0.1030347049,
0.1023364291,
0.0192011818,
0.3938691318,
-1.1450121403,
0.4573395252,
0.1739531755,
0.6890215278,
0.3125286698,
0.1406564265,
0.3355642259,
-0.5731475949,
-0.4223520756,
0.5121974349,
-0.0181215126,
0.4238765538,
-0.3541820943,
0.3324726224,
0.4558391571,
-0.3465112746,
-0.61824435,
0.0470722951,
-0.5000454187,
-0.1859821379,
1.0282342434,
-0.2279186398,
-0.3035582602,
-0.3519749045,
-0.1844412833,
0.0184805151,
-0.546400249,
0.7520759106,
0.6906598806,
-0.0159791466,
-0.3592203557,
-0.4586129785,
0.4436575174,
0.1964541376,
-0.8656164408,
0.1135973036,
0.6202858686,
0.0180795472,
0.061720185,
0.2018126994,
0.08801312,
0.4436056316,
0.3680011928,
-0.1059631184,
-0.6118227243,
-0.3413450718,
-0.168767184,
0.3386721909,
-0.0187031571,
-0.151709795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09755v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09755v1
|
How Does Calibration Data Affect the Post-training Pruning and Quantization of Large Language Models?
| 2023-11-16T10:30:00 | 2023-11-16T10:30:00 |
Miles Williams, Nikolaos Aletras
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pruning and quantization form the foundation of model compression for neural
networks, enabling efficient inference for large language models (LLMs).
Recently, various quantization and pruning techniques have demonstrated
state-of-the-art performance in a post-training setting. They rely upon
calibration data, a small set of unlabeled examples, to generate layer
activations. However, no prior work has systematically investigated how the
calibration data impacts the effectiveness of model compression methods. In
this paper, we present the first extensive empirical study on the effect of
calibration data upon LLM performance. We trial a variety of pruning and
quantization methods, tasks, models, and datasets. Surprisingly, we find
substantial variations in downstream task performance, contrasting existing
work that suggests a greater level of robustness to the calibration data.
Finally, we make a series of recommendations for the effective use of
calibration data in LLM quantization and pruning.
|
[
-0.1684442908,
-0.3930165172,
0.4453565776,
-0.0330428332,
-0.2032287717,
-0.2291668206,
-0.4974277616,
-0.131129235,
-0.1896470189,
0.4463355541,
-0.2999360561,
-0.4457934499,
-0.4400415421,
-0.0270060077,
-0.1546853483,
0.8604968786,
0.2513971627,
0.3239139318,
-0.4027232826,
-0.0960224941,
-0.5304659605,
-0.9467343092,
-0.4676986039,
-0.4959281981,
0.5042445064,
0.0413967445,
0.7293592095,
0.7210400701,
0.1315451562,
0.2508153021,
-0.1963501126,
0.0192967318,
-0.6614495516,
0.1866083592,
0.097896643,
-1.0109138489,
-0.1328949481,
-0.0606366433,
0.9796971679,
0.8814697266,
-0.1479572356,
0.2947049141,
0.3274044991,
0.8015913367,
-0.9059572816,
0.1594745368,
-0.5081982017,
-0.006744571,
-0.2558012307,
-0.4669287801,
-0.4643948376,
-0.5184504986,
-0.0685311407,
-0.4098614752,
0.2617287934,
-0.2166189104,
0.5922521353,
0.5102624893,
-0.6083606482,
0.1150985509,
-0.8470161557,
1.0083823204,
-0.8939774036,
0.3412484825,
0.570168972,
0.0605753995,
-0.0217471793,
-0.5390740633,
-0.1222239509,
-0.0516771227,
0.114009954,
-0.1531419903,
0.1348453313,
0.1265937388,
0.6249613166,
0.60613662,
-0.3950290382,
0.2075212449,
-0.3874031901,
-0.422773093,
0.5848665237,
-0.0332994945,
0.0267315526,
0.2162692696,
-0.0308175255,
-0.6705963016,
-1.3212168217,
0.0983445197,
0.8258277774,
0.135858506,
0.3640166223,
0.5086923242,
-0.1423112899,
0.9906701446,
-0.3693317175,
-0.0385551862,
0.1521968544,
-0.3980211318,
-0.3297432065,
0.0129879676,
0.6945695877,
0.2568226457,
0.4975402057,
-0.2184980512,
-0.3352930248,
0.0304492507,
0.1026828438,
-1.005562067,
-0.5073451996,
-0.0404111184,
-0.1903660297,
-0.367274493,
-0.0314929634,
-0.1843380928,
-0.3913146555,
-0.6636588573,
0.4295490682,
-0.3240637481,
-0.238487348,
0.1679216474,
0.0524824336,
0.2335668802,
0.1505437195,
-0.7842763066,
0.2506144643,
0.8126292825,
0.5940613151,
0.3805917799,
-0.1176290363,
-0.6823188066,
-0.1769117713,
-0.4739260674,
0.4331014156,
-0.1358838677,
-0.1387032419,
0.012977276,
-0.0826867893,
-0.2078293264,
-0.8476223946,
0.4812662005,
-0.6202307343,
-0.2097136229,
-0.3817725182,
-0.4889680445,
-0.2995902598,
0.0876635164,
-0.897870183,
0.876724422,
-0.0170871187,
-0.6028773785,
0.3455471992,
0.1258538961,
-0.4026865959,
-0.0069733309,
-0.1670269072,
-0.2666165829,
0.6039707661,
0.1154397354,
0.3167804182,
-0.6071250439,
0.3252596259,
-0.2440125942,
-0.5269568563,
0.389039278,
-0.5659250021,
0.8583641648,
0.0716154203,
0.0334797837,
-0.2054976225,
-0.63244313,
0.4282447398,
-0.1436455548,
-0.3545157313,
-0.371093899,
0.1826185584,
-0.1150374711,
0.2244773507,
-0.0560829714,
-0.5162507296,
0.0740602687,
-0.5245912671,
0.7186788917,
0.5295650363,
-0.0994051695,
0.3768324256,
-0.5109347105,
0.5904836655,
-0.1484232098,
-0.271402359,
-0.3994934559,
-0.1034822762,
-0.6851163507,
0.2294099927,
0.8829050064,
0.4470680654,
-0.4768595695,
0.3468659222,
-0.5976970196,
-0.5157999396,
-0.425796181,
0.197350651,
0.4032957852,
0.2419888377,
-0.103568919,
-0.3784763217,
-0.379817456,
-0.9005733132,
-0.3619599938,
-0.1600714773,
-0.3710102439,
0.2784430087,
0.1647166014,
0.3227801323,
0.9979953766,
-0.3664429188,
-0.0788885951,
0.2466028929,
0.4638780057,
0.0453002825,
0.6046130657,
0.3583451807,
-0.6701934934,
-0.125178352,
-0.2836532891,
-0.3119866252,
-0.2860223055,
-0.0973838866,
0.0066723311,
-0.0858817622,
0.4515801072,
-0.2863300741,
0.4521739781,
0.9144201279,
0.1901436597,
0.7301416993,
-0.2361384928,
0.1905095577,
-0.7384626269,
0.1559939384,
0.1877015531,
-0.5444514155,
-0.7083958983,
0.147484526,
0.2633032799,
0.0172648039,
-0.504114151,
0.1698462665,
-0.4502162039,
-0.2148626298,
-0.2736610174,
-0.168972522,
0.10378512,
0.3156063557,
0.0501590706,
0.9270429015,
0.4080496728,
-0.6067406535,
0.2883709967,
0.0153115811,
-0.747622788,
0.0362712219,
-0.7301646471,
0.3890938759,
-0.0612772666,
0.2499282956,
-0.9392866492,
0.0670811757,
-0.2578134537,
-0.2245629132,
0.3373527825,
-0.2826211154,
-0.9353798032,
-0.0474621318,
-0.2986225486,
0.9183061719,
0.4434937537,
-0.1551608741,
0.3002126217,
0.2784751356,
0.022198217,
-0.2317987233,
-0.9682617188,
-0.004632419,
-0.1815175116,
-0.5613543391,
0.4888982475,
-0.1585955918,
-0.0394182727,
-0.4272246361,
-0.2924379408,
-0.1546776593,
0.1435523033,
0.5510628223,
-0.0242003333,
-0.2312531322,
0.1336568296,
-0.1991571635,
0.0221044682,
0.3295351863,
0.0124524496,
0.8308123946,
0.0185024068,
-0.2580599785,
-0.4169267118,
-0.2526755333,
0.3256215453,
-0.3859420717,
0.9884386659,
0.3698218465,
-0.3344123065,
-0.2028720528,
-0.5522931814,
-0.4394469261,
-0.4498826563,
0.2245379984,
-0.237484023,
-0.8366087675,
0.5089247823,
-0.3934549093,
-0.0378728248,
0.1748469621,
0.3974755406,
0.1393932551,
1.2238104343,
0.5355719924,
-0.0408526175,
0.6030292511,
-0.3307052553,
0.2198453248,
-1.0829645395,
0.1684732735,
-0.5578808188,
-0.5545687675,
-0.4887512922,
-0.4281193018,
0.2011076659,
0.3734478951,
-0.0770174116,
0.3099812567,
-0.1865009069,
0.540486753,
0.5173943043,
0.320659101,
0.0346875042,
0.0856310949,
0.2849180698,
-0.1704493016,
-0.7573957443,
-0.4872151017,
1.2083836794,
0.341812253,
0.6069523096,
-0.1513610482,
0.3377242386,
-0.0925646797,
0.2970375419,
-0.8864210248,
0.4776422977,
-0.1193258762,
-0.4152440429,
-0.1120891273,
-0.7560275197,
-0.8675673604,
0.156997785,
-0.0069273124,
-0.6871761084,
0.2704859376,
0.3134542406,
-0.6252344251,
0.0543327332,
-0.8265442848,
0.7326197028,
-0.1239144504,
-0.2944515944,
-0.2741367221,
-0.4397303462,
0.4093955159,
-0.3731247485,
0.1602348387,
-0.0419988595,
0.0783294439,
1.0340465307,
-0.4997633696,
0.8575306535,
-0.0512907766,
-0.1657016426,
0.2501661181,
0.186868906,
0.4233960211,
-0.1544855684,
-0.4026653171,
0.2642134726,
0.4442123473,
-0.1644624025,
-0.567923367,
0.7194536328,
-0.5770698786,
-0.5921643376,
-0.1457156837,
-0.797462225,
-0.3862031996,
-0.041948393,
0.1467835605,
0.8036386967,
0.0945411026,
0.739462018,
0.4584592879,
-0.3046084046,
0.2439886928,
0.3031303883,
0.0499582328,
-0.4103372693,
0.8555269241,
0.3291402757,
0.5193431377,
0.3597996831,
0.1118316725,
-0.005294851,
-0.5396806002,
-0.1168935895,
0.2877748013,
-0.7088888884,
-0.4841731787,
-0.0913975015,
-0.3546090722,
-0.5428180099,
0.3792087734,
-0.293384254,
-0.5170522332,
-0.3273822367,
0.0050553088,
0.1061787903,
0.4210921228,
0.1652099192,
0.7054477334,
-0.973906517,
-0.1550635546,
0.0829394907,
0.0546016693,
-0.0736949965,
-0.488656044,
-0.5118145347,
0.5743684769,
-0.0885874927,
-0.8900454044,
0.372475028,
0.560983181,
0.1915041506,
0.4248355031,
-0.0764976293,
0.7931061387,
-0.3658483028,
0.7370529771,
-0.1682953686,
-0.6979412436,
0.277374357,
-0.0619267672,
0.6407412887,
0.6465803981,
0.128847748,
-0.456607759,
-0.0558764823,
-0.3009214997,
-0.7046326995,
0.7261259556,
0.0311421715,
0.3622756004,
0.3901351988,
0.6489243507,
-0.1718259007,
0.4727314115,
-0.6735390425,
-0.2728716731,
0.2958922684,
-0.0731878579,
-0.3370996714,
-0.3496426344,
-0.1396874636,
-0.2896358371,
0.4305922985,
-0.0905007944,
-0.009660271,
-0.2857495546,
-0.5048520565,
-0.1458514482,
-0.0342806838,
0.2848525941,
0.8497418165,
-0.087951079,
0.1371363252,
-0.0916930586,
-0.4524308741,
-0.0012940419,
-0.0009716417,
-0.234304145,
-0.2391351759,
0.3428017497,
0.9880511761,
0.4104288816,
-0.703460753,
0.6417418122,
-0.0714763775,
-0.361743778,
-0.1290183067,
0.3195407987,
-0.3484185338,
0.0355296731,
0.2784893513,
0.0732376873,
-0.0961795598,
-0.4269648194,
0.0582079329,
0.5096595883,
-0.0292751398,
-0.46256271,
0.5196200609,
-0.2861818671,
-0.1940624863,
0.7907752395,
0.220282197,
-0.6296082735,
0.6095143557,
0.483122468,
0.4889082313,
-0.3371059,
0.1241184548,
0.4330278635,
0.3961633444,
-0.2234327495,
0.0548072048,
-0.430148989,
-0.6791362166,
-1.0528959036,
-0.716629982,
-0.0789148137,
0.2768237591,
-0.8158236742,
0.1655500084,
-0.2294374406,
-0.4256498218,
-0.2151942253,
0.0481037535,
-0.9140128493,
0.4620146453,
0.3219910562,
0.8719599247,
-1.0998033285,
0.902054131,
0.6363306046,
-0.0101118442,
-1.1473587751,
-0.1040574759,
-0.1766697615,
-0.6541392803,
0.6890155077,
0.3217775822,
0.0846443698,
0.4835398793,
-0.3132778108,
-0.9971696138,
1.0593297482,
0.7936555743,
-0.6703795195,
-0.1410583854,
0.5927196145,
0.547700882,
0.0203529224,
0.4303639531,
0.709931314,
0.2224140763,
0.1685089469,
-0.9375921488,
-0.0769242942,
-0.2130059898,
0.2332723886,
0.3820843399,
-0.3815827668,
0.7421700358,
0.2447926104,
-0.3585672081,
0.0840135515,
0.3405026793,
0.1920639873,
-0.208304584,
0.6981064677,
0.7635782361,
0.5635566115,
-0.4178580642,
1.1117210388,
-0.6229746342,
0.2441436052,
1.0026614666,
-0.1794534028,
0.8775236607,
0.6050428748,
-0.2487084568,
0.2403925359,
0.7924546003,
0.1053568795,
0.5046441555,
0.4334214628,
-0.2973458469,
-0.2693143487,
-0.1147081777,
-0.2185150236,
0.2602096796,
0.273209542,
-0.297950089,
-0.0919367224,
0.1355900466,
-0.0953996181,
-0.3824281394,
-0.2391539514,
0.5939707756,
0.1391771883,
-0.8502013683,
0.7118951082,
0.0251639877,
0.3702916503,
-0.4637265503,
0.1099015921,
-0.0045197071,
0.1596583873,
-0.2795292139,
-0.540923655,
0.1059041992,
-0.2384571731,
0.0504999124,
-0.6030058265,
0.5812225938,
-0.4359558821,
-0.330216378,
-0.1727896035,
0.3823732436,
0.3228776157,
-0.5984805226,
-0.2466889471,
0.2887038589,
0.1121205166,
-0.6260170937,
0.5036345124,
0.2009736747,
0.1974501759,
0.3769840598,
0.7635046244,
0.4861860275,
0.1971903741,
0.1665101945,
0.8869873881,
-0.3171800077,
-0.2133901417,
-0.8210006356,
0.5073034167,
0.2096965909,
-0.284609139,
0.6876055002,
0.7112134695,
0.9924429059,
0.2734297812,
0.3242031634,
0.1777541786,
0.0614969842,
-0.6119511724,
0.4956891537,
-0.5126509666,
0.3793102503,
0.2150868326,
-1.2118263245,
-0.4425886869,
0.5886844993,
-0.756413579,
0.18905586,
0.5574486256,
0.9840000272,
0.1038169861,
-0.0838535428,
0.2719516158,
0.0795976967,
0.2577506602,
0.552254796,
0.5613058805,
-0.5873186588,
0.4388454854,
-0.6950595975,
-0.1008674949,
-0.0791790262,
-1.0211896896,
-0.5039044619,
-0.6696019173,
-0.45073089,
-0.1993291676,
-0.2669093907,
0.4108836055,
0.9551979899,
-0.6762158871,
-0.3141416311,
-0.3651521504,
-0.3710106015,
-0.0988428444,
-0.1759581119,
0.2312947512,
-0.0328529738,
-0.7178148031,
0.3630280197,
-0.0752108842,
-0.0741487816,
-0.269941777,
0.0554253459,
0.1556642354,
-0.1461192518,
0.3636693656,
0.2921254337,
-0.444731921,
0.0440764651,
-0.1602386534,
-0.0593707785,
0.0724091083,
1.1163897514,
-1.1799632311,
0.4377470613,
0.4981898367,
0.6424296498,
0.5447057486,
0.199535355,
0.95028162,
-1.0315474272,
0.3283868134,
0.3677332699,
0.2850656807,
0.3433805108,
-0.124082379,
0.3216324747,
-0.0929759592,
-0.941002965,
-1.2187120914,
0.0169510171,
-0.2965785563,
-0.013028468,
1.1829490662,
-0.0880301967,
-0.3674975336,
0.6296460629,
-0.1666526645,
0.499961704,
0.076002799,
0.4121222496,
1.0450748205,
0.2556529939,
-0.3956647217,
-0.8282951117,
0.3989243507,
0.8511960506,
-0.5325954556,
0.2439172566,
0.6752543449,
0.2163618356,
-0.1221966222,
0.1600318998,
0.1564352065,
0.1696747988,
-0.270370245,
-0.2139350027,
-0.0559413247,
-0.0905794576,
-0.6925865412,
0.0132216429,
0.2157162726,
-0.0059834612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09748v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09748v1
|
Translation Aligned Sentence Embeddings for Turkish Language
| 2023-11-16T10:25:22 | 2023-11-16T10:25:22 |
Eren Unlu, Unver Ciftci
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Due to the limited availability of high quality datasets for training
sentence embeddings in Turkish, we propose a training methodology and a regimen
to develop a sentence embedding model. The central idea is simple but effective
: is to fine-tune a pretrained encoder-decoder model in two consecutive stages,
where the first stage involves aligning the embedding space with translation
pairs. Thanks to this alignment, the prowess of the main model can be better
projected onto the target language in a sentence embedding setting where it can
be fine-tuned with high accuracy in short duration with limited target language
dataset.
|
[
-0.0230066385,
-0.8095532656,
0.3670636714,
0.2040943652,
-0.7200921178,
-0.3663844168,
-0.2190966308,
-0.1294511408,
0.2026454508,
0.6153215766,
-0.661469698,
-0.5499029756,
-0.6568179727,
0.1447912902,
-0.3211001754,
1.0272488594,
-0.4593008757,
0.3354319334,
0.0233947542,
-0.3632634282,
-0.6526659727,
-0.0826375186,
-0.3991273344,
-0.1188913658,
0.1731435061,
0.508246243,
0.8204625845,
0.9848405719,
0.6576428413,
0.1628356278,
0.0304025039,
0.0533875562,
-0.2784015536,
0.2177717984,
0.0563472062,
-0.2467112839,
-0.0824032277,
0.0449498966,
0.8153278828,
0.6393123269,
-0.2714829743,
0.3814711571,
0.2465459108,
0.5504686832,
-0.6884096861,
0.0037167622,
-0.1039282009,
0.2668170035,
-0.3473362625,
0.0003115197,
-0.3040445447,
-0.4748831689,
0.057285361,
-0.6403438449,
0.0387452133,
0.1500088274,
0.7254289985,
0.303714931,
-0.6952101588,
-0.3192248046,
-0.6493964195,
0.592982769,
-0.7271025181,
0.4878981709,
0.1148039848,
0.2468393296,
-0.2350423038,
-0.8070975542,
-0.4677625597,
-0.1629230529,
-0.1947924644,
-0.0374149792,
0.2635367811,
0.1225943267,
0.0210936815,
0.5569363236,
-0.7039473057,
-0.0920564905,
-0.2101197988,
0.0636886358,
0.4959806502,
0.319945097,
0.238276422,
0.1556161493,
-0.2930207551,
-0.0565199479,
-0.7599773407,
0.0707055926,
0.5256985426,
0.4960424304,
0.0063236975,
1.076256156,
-0.2214344889,
0.961399734,
0.2128407061,
0.0611845218,
0.1454328001,
-0.4296858907,
-0.3110006452,
0.345025748,
0.7248899937,
0.0991062969,
0.1354747117,
-0.0872868076,
-0.2785035372,
0.3168492913,
0.5240572691,
-0.6444687843,
0.1180936247,
0.1959784478,
-0.3973821402,
-0.3716115355,
0.2927552462,
-0.3701420426,
-0.1322969645,
-0.1118766442,
0.5322540998,
-0.3268873394,
0.0165400114,
0.4874501228,
0.1655669212,
0.4632909894,
-0.0127983531,
-0.933716774,
0.3066214621,
0.8787661195,
0.8470613956,
0.2278342545,
-0.3203073144,
-0.6812927127,
0.2370204329,
-0.5936114192,
0.516613543,
-0.6478278041,
0.1515730321,
0.6036140323,
0.1483491957,
-0.1067954078,
-0.1833014041,
0.87006253,
-0.3215064704,
0.4106813371,
-0.1508832574,
-0.9836530089,
-0.0878670737,
0.2396146059,
-0.6118311286,
0.7771761417,
0.2355351448,
-0.976729393,
0.4940261841,
-0.4906402826,
-0.5079293251,
-0.0282935835,
-0.0277882814,
-0.6137842536,
0.203488335,
0.4241755009,
0.4624424577,
-0.0639052764,
0.1661948264,
-0.1610288918,
-0.415908128,
-0.005173333,
0.1241231784,
0.6802334785,
0.5384273529,
-0.1201498359,
0.0119330287,
-0.3334314227,
-0.1960092485,
-0.0372900479,
-0.5794473886,
-0.1884246171,
-0.0230570305,
0.2635638118,
0.2357515991,
0.3855283558,
-0.7238771915,
0.4454344213,
-0.5938503146,
0.3347410858,
0.2645587623,
0.0503425673,
0.5785924792,
-0.297062993,
0.6442437172,
0.1863476187,
0.0305860452,
-0.0754040703,
-0.2643505335,
-0.855186224,
0.0306745879,
0.279854089,
0.7846320271,
-0.3918602765,
0.7454867363,
-0.2558959424,
-0.1626133621,
-0.9688922167,
0.356996268,
0.4515035748,
0.3311638534,
0.262989223,
-0.2394156307,
-0.6542692184,
-0.8213092089,
-0.4704998434,
0.1840608567,
0.3484867811,
-0.4005279541,
0.5194084644,
0.0895541385,
0.5801122785,
-0.1039348543,
-0.604624629,
-0.5003970861,
-0.0402254499,
0.3324423432,
0.8704653978,
0.3492480218,
-0.5944319367,
-0.8158817887,
0.0979845822,
-0.7820686102,
0.1601192206,
-0.0312229507,
-0.3505033553,
0.1276895702,
0.8204315901,
-0.5648661256,
0.4648874402,
0.6123644114,
-0.6787905693,
0.1598307192,
-0.1870020926,
0.2445595413,
-1.4839338064,
-0.0436979309,
-0.0929517522,
-0.5314464569,
-0.7845698595,
0.2516672909,
0.0008531884,
-0.0823783129,
-0.4260499477,
0.2732566893,
-0.60417068,
0.0966376811,
-0.2359992564,
0.0986715406,
-0.0872031003,
0.1740152091,
0.1907821894,
0.6279240251,
0.3134572506,
-0.2937203646,
0.3024737537,
0.8791615963,
-0.9260001183,
0.5853112936,
-0.6225044131,
0.1086805016,
-0.0730175301,
0.2500444949,
-0.8195084333,
-0.06946145,
0.586258173,
-0.1291450411,
0.4339672625,
-0.1753327549,
-0.355116576,
-0.34713462,
-0.0701425746,
0.4319842756,
0.4468435645,
-0.3945174217,
0.2521159053,
0.2445614189,
-0.2006369382,
-0.8207710385,
-0.7538773417,
-0.117527701,
-0.4089565277,
-0.6628000736,
0.2341602296,
0.4137305617,
0.0640693083,
0.1999344528,
-0.0063519976,
0.064731285,
-0.1409281194,
0.0218176879,
-0.1559197009,
-0.5124560595,
0.1625486016,
0.2878439724,
0.0020049103,
-0.3394829333,
-0.7108208537,
0.4499138892,
-0.1595549136,
-0.271684736,
-0.6819745898,
0.639110446,
0.3346864581,
-0.4890230596,
1.2340582609,
0.7531870604,
-0.497163564,
0.3904023468,
-0.5672984123,
0.0766579583,
-0.4391291142,
0.4572386742,
-0.5345129371,
-0.8468210697,
0.3193503618,
-0.0825470462,
0.1683254689,
0.4725495577,
0.4872188866,
-0.2599340677,
1.1833757162,
0.908709228,
-0.1082596108,
0.6484102011,
-0.008423687,
0.3046159148,
-0.8423262239,
-0.2702720463,
-0.4805791974,
-0.3575524092,
-0.4644696414,
0.0233835932,
0.0011919629,
0.5228431821,
-0.4929228127,
0.3848999441,
-0.2916889191,
0.476582557,
0.4369662106,
0.2008096725,
-0.1162552834,
0.0454756804,
-0.2471460998,
-0.1404048204,
-0.736715436,
-0.8664999008,
0.803883791,
0.2640699446,
0.6882432103,
0.1461151987,
0.7907737494,
0.1449009329,
-0.3369683623,
-0.5562816858,
0.0772438869,
-0.3665575087,
-0.4776976407,
-0.4563013911,
0.0288588181,
-1.1416497231,
-0.1065403894,
-0.4806310534,
-0.6701176763,
0.1080532074,
0.1102487072,
-0.3114709258,
0.0591412336,
-0.4607833028,
1.4143147469,
0.1069220528,
-0.0815819055,
-0.3179674149,
-0.7196059823,
0.0530290045,
0.2522005141,
-0.178886041,
-0.0455739312,
0.087808609,
0.8376941085,
-0.706615746,
0.4508200586,
-0.2591876686,
0.1636353433,
0.3026950359,
0.0952620506,
0.65520823,
-0.06929636,
0.1890700161,
-0.3372061551,
0.2062653154,
-0.7435147762,
-0.6955553889,
0.2545025647,
-0.7307836413,
-0.6069992185,
-0.5040955544,
-0.4111859798,
-0.1089062244,
0.0618889965,
0.3333030343,
0.3360518813,
-0.6362453103,
0.210109815,
0.2873226106,
0.0055170059,
0.2633158565,
0.1886873543,
-0.1291940659,
-0.4953970611,
0.4011250734,
-0.2064815313,
0.0296866782,
0.5534417033,
0.0449740291,
-0.3174672723,
-0.4904280305,
-0.4126892984,
0.2513917685,
-0.5983840823,
-0.1067602187,
-0.5216344595,
-0.304091543,
-0.6870325804,
-0.2905597985,
-0.6005700231,
-0.4432373643,
-0.2255373895,
-0.1995389462,
0.3320842385,
0.9453893304,
-0.0257736761,
0.65065974,
-0.8482103348,
0.068697989,
-0.0339462981,
0.1391738206,
-0.5762150884,
-0.8280912042,
-0.8673067093,
0.2341392338,
-0.1777324677,
-0.8270691633,
0.5205004215,
0.3404740095,
0.5252678394,
0.6477257609,
-0.0675593317,
0.6811097264,
-0.6529050469,
0.6232238412,
0.0752732307,
-0.9343966246,
0.8445802331,
-0.1383201778,
0.368301928,
0.6739012599,
0.3622452915,
-0.6958228946,
-0.4484140277,
-0.164241761,
-0.5561287403,
0.7040849328,
0.2183584571,
0.1827338487,
0.0337277241,
0.5348838568,
0.2584065199,
0.1476380676,
-0.4460915625,
-0.0200831592,
-0.2483195066,
-0.694088757,
-0.3978858292,
-0.5614879131,
-0.228997767,
-0.3746251762,
0.855614841,
0.1370220631,
0.4415798187,
-0.0192093067,
-0.4827683866,
-0.2500248551,
0.1694508195,
0.600270927,
0.2876909077,
-0.3621940315,
-0.2022831887,
-0.052806139,
-0.6314091086,
0.5537909865,
0.0717082396,
0.0036182271,
-0.0973522365,
0.3627137244,
1.1491057873,
-0.1873127669,
-0.0940790474,
0.740665555,
-0.1275939196,
-0.0543297939,
-0.4877880514,
-0.27365309,
-0.0224307161,
0.5682649016,
0.0039386498,
-0.2378990799,
-0.0189063493,
-0.3093393445,
0.2800591886,
0.2109821886,
-0.5718801022,
-0.1918728352,
0.601723969,
0.1115852073,
-0.3982726634,
1.1091576815,
0.1475922912,
-0.3357236981,
0.315536499,
0.8366047144,
0.9848732948,
-0.438380003,
0.3195993006,
0.4459799528,
0.4782374501,
-0.4712167084,
0.4095178246,
0.1948736012,
-0.8980813026,
-0.4021402597,
-0.733917892,
-0.0197719391,
-0.1189428493,
-1.1018346548,
0.567692697,
-0.0491441861,
-0.0643583909,
-0.4011576474,
0.178192839,
-0.7274900079,
0.2336203307,
0.2445640862,
1.0146368742,
-1.2931923866,
1.0826597214,
0.8785312772,
-0.4261378646,
-0.634165287,
-0.1211649477,
-0.3336763382,
-0.5445655584,
0.3255888522,
0.3974048793,
0.2060363144,
0.2032805979,
-0.4307576418,
-0.8085502386,
1.0079164505,
0.6688840389,
-0.5555201173,
0.0150826629,
0.2615651488,
0.4438254535,
-0.8485137224,
-0.2826274037,
0.6995229721,
0.3484607041,
-0.2437543869,
-0.7291529775,
0.0881723538,
-0.3338309228,
0.0409618542,
0.3034763038,
-0.4208456576,
0.62280792,
0.0894608721,
-0.3138252497,
0.4063193202,
0.8971747756,
-0.1695943177,
-0.1363050491,
0.2962546647,
0.9795852304,
0.4667784274,
-0.1612038165,
1.0310310125,
-0.4819444716,
0.2254946232,
1.0943357944,
0.1601751298,
0.983071506,
0.5996178985,
0.0156852864,
0.5286766291,
0.8778119087,
0.0961168036,
1.045170188,
-0.1050926521,
-0.2227896601,
-0.4645798802,
-0.0832215175,
-0.4512140155,
0.6014204621,
0.4259139001,
-0.4310921729,
0.0683260635,
0.1943314224,
-0.1157793701,
0.1221784577,
-0.1236274019,
0.7204366922,
0.0667367056,
-0.5999501944,
0.3406601548,
0.0852463022,
0.2548899949,
-0.4932791889,
0.0806774199,
-0.2748420537,
0.3009973466,
-0.0060856561,
-0.6242943406,
0.4523777068,
-0.2417936027,
0.1110483631,
-0.190956682,
0.2903611958,
-0.8389142752,
-0.7499393225,
-0.1324586421,
0.4986747801,
0.2492457777,
0.1286377758,
-0.5452665091,
-0.1487772763,
-0.1586431265,
-0.3895901442,
0.0869735479,
0.4797227681,
0.0661546364,
0.3346533477,
0.2041273266,
0.1046763286,
0.2595412731,
-0.0588601604,
0.5528551936,
-0.6511873603,
-0.709657371,
-0.8763831258,
0.5709719062,
0.2598024607,
-0.3959695101,
0.4839824438,
0.6134756804,
0.8244104385,
-0.1874612123,
0.5935342908,
0.0384449102,
0.2325741947,
-0.7595562935,
0.6223855019,
-0.5217124224,
-0.2226839066,
-0.0696682334,
-1.1789392233,
-0.4976940155,
1.077970624,
0.0065860855,
-0.1971903145,
0.8911802769,
0.6457798481,
-0.1325825453,
-0.1165619716,
0.2629375756,
0.0389273502,
0.0147061879,
0.5544256568,
0.8299624324,
-0.6979866624,
0.3178414702,
-0.2801936269,
0.1294931024,
-0.2581053376,
-0.8256130815,
-0.9241481423,
-0.7671918273,
-0.3935243487,
-0.3751121759,
0.3841092288,
1.1213325262,
0.4566686749,
-1.0798639059,
-0.2810282111,
-0.3401430249,
-0.2774562836,
-0.5278885961,
-0.0831129029,
0.4273771346,
-0.493154794,
-0.6995658875,
0.1687965691,
0.0679951608,
0.2268757373,
-0.0480536632,
-0.326841563,
-0.5872285962,
0.0446650162,
0.1608100086,
0.1451323777,
-0.6690151691,
-0.4674232304,
-0.0883628726,
-0.4818229377,
0.147107318,
0.9412519336,
-0.4573387802,
0.5687406659,
0.3922491074,
0.6459589601,
0.6807548404,
0.0217657816,
1.039129138,
-0.8286732435,
0.4828835726,
0.0525665209,
0.4896027744,
0.3275827765,
-0.3761113584,
0.500587523,
-0.262685895,
-0.4871886075,
-0.6476704478,
0.1806124151,
-0.7816325426,
0.1363368779,
1.0080493689,
-0.4730840325,
-0.1023348793,
-0.0524761043,
-0.1539355516,
0.8630917668,
-0.0155108608,
0.6575101018,
0.8723784089,
0.1301434189,
-0.1637323052,
-0.2533178329,
0.4794822633,
0.4192188084,
-0.3795724213,
-0.1819783449,
0.357105881,
0.1073864177,
-0.1394281089,
0.3161936998,
-0.0470002964,
0.2660426199,
0.3366270661,
0.0377293304,
-0.1314297169,
-0.3736438751,
-0.5481306911,
-0.1552662402,
0.2263092697,
-0.6589422226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09743v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09743v2
|
Capturing Perspectives of Crowdsourced Annotators in Subjective Learning Tasks
| 2023-11-16T10:18:32 | 2024-05-16T06:01:26 |
Negar Mokhberian, Myrl G. Marmarelis, Frederic R. Hopp, Valerio Basile, Fred Morstatter, Kristina Lerman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Supervised classification heavily depends on datasets annotated by humans.
However, in subjective tasks such as toxicity classification, these annotations
often exhibit low agreement among raters. Annotations have commonly been
aggregated by employing methods like majority voting to determine a single
ground truth label. In subjective tasks, aggregating labels will result in
biased labeling and, consequently, biased models that can overlook minority
opinions. Previous studies have shed light on the pitfalls of label aggregation
and have introduced a handful of practical approaches to tackle this issue.
Recently proposed multi-annotator models, which predict labels individually per
annotator, are vulnerable to under-determination for annotators with few
samples. This problem is exacerbated in crowdsourced datasets. In this work, we
propose \textbf{Annotator Aware Representations for Texts (AART)} for
subjective classification tasks. Our approach involves learning representations
of annotators, allowing for exploration of annotation behaviors. We show the
improvement of our method on metrics that assess the performance on capturing
individual annotators' perspectives. Additionally, we demonstrate fairness
metrics to evaluate our model's equability of performance for marginalized
annotators compared to others.
|
[
-0.6262782216,
-0.2375127077,
0.640181601,
-0.0724050477,
-0.1876669973,
-0.0197428018,
-0.1796966195,
-0.5505802631,
0.1719195545,
0.4705788195,
-0.1655277759,
-0.6641588211,
-0.9863094687,
0.2786565125,
0.0647929609,
1.3167585135,
0.0174791533,
-0.1713796705,
-0.574067533,
-0.543025434,
-0.2659836113,
-0.9651344419,
-0.4220102727,
-0.3802058697,
0.8374645114,
0.5607475638,
0.5201079249,
0.2023762017,
0.3949860334,
0.4267618656,
-0.0021725458,
0.2283646613,
0.020601593,
0.2831376195,
-0.2044349164,
-0.3566226363,
-0.2261207551,
0.5592867136,
0.3115362525,
0.6113416553,
0.0501477309,
0.3783464134,
0.2262596935,
0.611115694,
-0.8499584794,
0.3699651062,
-0.4296586812,
0.4034172297,
-0.2056121379,
0.0649238378,
-0.6860494018,
-0.4292992651,
0.0550679229,
-0.8811117411,
0.2144307792,
-0.2325809598,
0.4219914377,
0.5791199207,
-0.3686126173,
-0.3199939132,
-0.4161275029,
0.7909329534,
-0.533711791,
0.187108323,
0.5553894639,
0.2448504418,
0.3573712707,
-0.366566658,
-0.5103602409,
-0.1966404766,
-0.3534781039,
0.2559601963,
-0.0225171056,
0.0400080495,
0.1763725281,
0.1447465271,
-0.0968656689,
-0.0158976167,
-0.2143490314,
-0.4004865885,
0.5932311416,
-0.0701297894,
-0.2441212088,
-0.5578784943,
-0.5672513843,
-0.0818943605,
0.2184930444,
0.1561149657,
0.1843595952,
0.4153981507,
-0.0420464091,
0.6116986275,
-0.2110480666,
0.7692599893,
0.3361236453,
0.0653728396,
0.6433949471,
-0.1095617637,
0.076334171,
0.0783033371,
0.8607932925,
0.4581795931,
0.1308828741,
-0.0674350336,
-0.2007940114,
-0.0161598325,
0.4214291871,
-0.6861132979,
-0.4641895592,
0.1631445289,
-0.581002593,
-0.4575153887,
0.1005961299,
-0.7465756536,
-0.7962636352,
-0.3757493198,
0.4701272845,
-0.1622192115,
-0.3453506827,
-0.1687108576,
-0.0622498244,
-0.199916929,
0.4899465144,
-0.4433892369,
0.1249081939,
0.4759462476,
1.0858514309,
-0.0346606895,
-0.1184414402,
-0.6949504018,
-0.0449778475,
0.0430116355,
0.9341824651,
-0.6307684183,
-0.5102532506,
-0.0918298885,
-0.3085089922,
0.1783038676,
-0.3631671667,
0.5569812059,
-0.508390367,
0.3036088049,
-0.7484655976,
-0.5582808256,
-0.3935074806,
0.5955526233,
-0.7613762617,
0.8742272854,
0.0102011682,
-1.2358083725,
0.704937458,
-0.8781003356,
-0.1259547919,
0.1062378213,
-0.1065161377,
-0.5165179968,
0.1165105328,
0.4432471991,
0.7833846211,
0.4499768019,
0.1136671975,
-0.4278575778,
-0.1117984131,
0.5947287679,
-0.3385113478,
0.8027974367,
0.1986582726,
-0.0827493221,
0.2279670537,
-0.4267449379,
-0.1921844482,
-0.4765021503,
-0.3107217252,
-0.7989561558,
0.0672302395,
0.3243418336,
0.4287004173,
-0.007741841,
-0.6832735538,
0.1346224546,
0.0771138221,
-0.0296168011,
1.058159709,
0.2632721364,
0.464677155,
-0.236866951,
0.2954241633,
0.3557144701,
0.2870906293,
0.0883860439,
-0.3997069001,
-0.7223548293,
-0.3020601273,
0.4767558575,
0.2030621171,
-0.7760620117,
0.3173902631,
-0.0882174075,
-0.6158269644,
-0.6672599912,
0.1016812399,
0.3057394922,
0.6192122698,
0.5490436554,
-0.683300972,
-0.2031232417,
-0.7562092543,
-0.3672838211,
-0.557387948,
-0.05439597,
0.2445687801,
0.4678778052,
0.0397883952,
1.1496492624,
-0.309738487,
-0.6684520841,
0.1414692998,
0.6195773482,
-0.1861001849,
0.5287130475,
0.4221100807,
-0.9948663116,
-0.3385913372,
-0.1102407947,
-0.877825141,
-0.0318885297,
-0.0478594266,
-0.1115433276,
0.0282950085,
0.2616608441,
-0.2038671523,
0.2637923956,
0.3114013076,
-0.3366699517,
0.1947854459,
0.0755589157,
0.312304318,
-0.7745331526,
-0.0257544909,
0.4958958328,
-0.4115157127,
-0.3454228342,
-0.0895255432,
-0.09031827,
0.0838415101,
-0.4534034729,
0.3754351735,
-0.4520097077,
0.1653755456,
-0.369661063,
0.1671872586,
-0.001357977,
0.432161361,
0.4137082696,
0.5336461067,
0.3895955384,
-0.4911895394,
0.0177092664,
0.2745425999,
0.0268361419,
0.7663998008,
-0.357426554,
0.3634051979,
-0.4784970582,
0.3560257852,
-0.696364522,
-0.2846229672,
0.5366678834,
-0.7877051234,
-0.0103545627,
-0.310660243,
-0.4422105253,
-0.1828812361,
-0.3681967258,
0.3708033264,
0.140440613,
-0.571285665,
0.7579779029,
0.7437704206,
-0.0375576504,
-0.6584341526,
-0.7123582959,
-0.0460796207,
-0.4029919207,
-0.0081653586,
-0.1699340641,
0.1969379038,
-0.2732534409,
0.1806154996,
0.0627567768,
0.0689766333,
-0.0076641091,
0.5099138618,
-0.0481451191,
0.198944062,
0.3138011396,
0.0119509799,
-0.3185041547,
0.3831821978,
-0.1190214604,
0.0113347825,
-0.1332231909,
-0.5519962311,
-0.3462937772,
0.5650657415,
0.296358943,
-0.6306915283,
0.6178066134,
0.7856314182,
-0.4037194252,
0.0856095105,
-0.7574589252,
0.0300647635,
-0.4766165912,
0.3241214156,
-0.0956036747,
-0.8064738512,
0.6144246459,
0.0167167131,
0.2037090957,
0.3172291219,
0.4481085241,
-0.1010912731,
0.8737823963,
0.6132898927,
-0.2244551033,
0.4718356133,
-0.1135253757,
-0.1966938227,
-0.7775008678,
-0.5492826104,
-0.4357001781,
-0.4444302917,
-0.5662314892,
-0.6355807185,
0.6917861104,
-0.312769264,
-0.2528168261,
-0.238565594,
-0.8965377212,
0.5592709184,
0.8418456912,
0.5230078101,
0.5140883923,
-0.0368966572,
0.3306672275,
-0.1391181499,
-0.4301743805,
-0.7561344504,
1.0441288948,
0.3693307936,
0.3346953988,
-0.0911160633,
1.1457334757,
0.3562588394,
1.0748517513,
-0.8115859628,
0.3910764158,
-0.100054346,
-0.8498505354,
-0.1160187274,
-0.3524954617,
-0.3052298427,
0.4067517817,
-0.1866987497,
-0.4695083499,
0.7070733905,
0.2445854098,
-0.3565095663,
0.3843961954,
-0.6828143001,
0.7890748978,
0.0599367507,
-0.4615560472,
-0.0085729463,
-0.7695634365,
0.1834629327,
-0.0262419265,
0.4420089722,
-0.1686817557,
-0.1762575507,
0.9792842865,
-0.2880894244,
1.1778131723,
-0.8626650572,
0.1817541867,
0.5834495425,
-0.1542518288,
0.1970017105,
0.2437441796,
-0.3315571249,
0.3171490431,
-0.5441731811,
-0.5294134617,
-0.3124373853,
0.4715325534,
-0.7128480077,
-0.33102566,
-0.8142524958,
-0.2513939142,
-0.4889262319,
-0.0018868544,
0.2310673594,
0.0548232011,
0.0288124364,
-0.2006356567,
0.3811677992,
0.1224206686,
0.3983397186,
0.2283037007,
0.0569122881,
-0.3794009686,
0.7159203291,
0.069117032,
0.056561511,
0.0576907322,
-0.0338069201,
-0.1718503535,
-0.4028084874,
-0.3393550217,
-0.246787861,
-0.8379768729,
-0.6932048798,
-0.7815639973,
0.0699855015,
0.0416855589,
-0.0765671134,
-0.2433108687,
-0.2600566745,
-0.2669189274,
-0.5608404875,
0.7076677084,
0.7135486603,
-0.6235473156,
0.2789315879,
-0.6160559654,
0.1661640257,
0.4719744921,
0.3808708787,
0.2543150783,
-0.0843598098,
-0.4400837123,
0.1601665318,
-0.3556438088,
-1.0158592463,
0.1367681921,
-0.1360403895,
0.3824952245,
0.3806938529,
0.3008513749,
0.4461289644,
-0.2363327146,
0.673529923,
0.125632748,
-0.9646725059,
0.4929147959,
-0.1438002288,
-0.0700368434,
1.2084186077,
0.5666021109,
-0.5361013412,
-0.7943657041,
-0.2605241835,
-0.8062565923,
0.6616721153,
0.2170273513,
0.21380575,
-0.0140957292,
0.3036240637,
0.4967282414,
0.0829054713,
-0.9701464176,
-0.2569478154,
-0.8235068917,
-0.2789937556,
-0.188192755,
0.0169252716,
0.0231367219,
-0.3799101412,
0.3668189645,
-0.0846770257,
-0.0208212733,
0.5114191771,
-0.1234079078,
0.0392075591,
0.3364143968,
-0.1468511522,
0.2445435077,
-0.2620766461,
0.4877067804,
0.0094337407,
-0.5417369008,
0.2419076264,
0.4537970126,
-0.2086863071,
0.2242904454,
0.4012003541,
0.3659451008,
-0.0427212305,
-0.411042273,
0.5801432729,
0.0209313035,
0.0787539259,
-0.2200306952,
-0.1498421282,
-0.087440677,
0.3133189082,
0.4651153088,
0.5073122382,
0.6461116672,
-0.2440651208,
0.240396753,
0.2442094535,
-0.7984799147,
-0.2197092026,
0.716277957,
0.4773412049,
0.0288440082,
0.405677855,
-0.4487434328,
-0.7682676315,
0.3601928651,
-0.1483448297,
0.8173137903,
-0.2924048901,
0.4609992206,
0.4292183816,
0.2801321447,
-0.0256796945,
-0.1622844189,
-0.3558440208,
-0.6515592337,
-0.3997325301,
-0.3774305284,
-0.703325808,
-0.3643111587,
-0.9893965125,
-0.0546290688,
-0.2290017754,
-0.5544674993,
0.1194897667,
-0.0042954069,
-0.85048002,
0.2892920673,
0.3311825693,
0.548119247,
-1.3053456545,
0.2891766131,
0.9807236195,
-0.7267218828,
-0.644421041,
0.1803491563,
-0.0638694018,
-0.3543770611,
0.5103127956,
0.372921288,
0.0483840555,
-0.3887324333,
-0.6192141771,
-0.3553691804,
0.6173804998,
0.1351618022,
-0.4547352493,
0.0202049818,
0.1281802654,
0.572740972,
-0.1511614323,
0.3646442294,
0.0414510705,
0.6450938582,
-0.3232540488,
-0.6932548881,
0.1227556616,
-0.3996872306,
-0.241240263,
-0.1726725847,
-0.7574151754,
0.6723960638,
-0.2484597117,
0.0611343533,
-0.4250914156,
0.949260056,
0.4230368435,
0.7645655274,
0.8380743265,
0.2279397994,
0.8260330558,
0.1888858676,
0.9334435463,
0.2194398791,
0.479221642,
1.0193604231,
-0.0616967715,
0.8081795573,
0.4680149257,
-0.0393909402,
0.4899419546,
0.7447749376,
0.0918732136,
0.6507174373,
0.0614967719,
-0.5023615956,
-0.6455121636,
-0.2871676087,
-0.2454371154,
0.4570008516,
0.1247028485,
-0.226763621,
-0.0500790849,
0.3673734963,
-0.052065894,
0.3806647658,
-0.4937893748,
0.9807784557,
0.075081639,
-0.3957751393,
-0.0125035793,
-0.1470306516,
0.992770195,
0.069100894,
-0.1917625517,
-0.1177456528,
0.0762344971,
-0.3694744408,
-0.8401889801,
0.1907432079,
0.1582396477,
-0.2827659249,
-0.3616702855,
0.6561718583,
-0.3064498305,
-0.8667452335,
0.0937322602,
0.4786805809,
0.0332279615,
-0.3623098135,
-0.3425389826,
-0.0315728113,
-0.1826552153,
-0.363492012,
0.1004769132,
0.7239106297,
0.0038120185,
0.3842453659,
0.2265378833,
-0.0892639011,
-0.0764223784,
-0.1033446863,
1.0836391449,
-0.5508967042,
-0.41554299,
-0.7497224808,
0.737179637,
-0.3032871783,
-0.3259803057,
0.7346560955,
0.7150323391,
0.9685789943,
-0.0794554204,
1.0406280756,
0.0735526755,
0.7231057286,
-0.2709460557,
0.9329992533,
-0.4113840461,
-0.0234488826,
-0.3183095455,
-0.593754828,
-0.2185525,
0.9145947695,
-0.3064172566,
0.2477466017,
0.1820474565,
0.1128481179,
-0.1816976964,
0.1739581078,
-0.2743631899,
0.1165482104,
0.2044464797,
0.514080584,
0.9641139507,
-0.1449348181,
0.2839665115,
-0.6343756318,
-0.3548186719,
-0.0432284102,
-0.8006828427,
-1.0205739737,
-0.7315972447,
-0.5997955203,
-0.1733851433,
-0.0090380805,
0.8969538808,
0.8362216949,
-0.7461723089,
0.1526153386,
0.33804214,
0.0816026255,
-0.1387995631,
-0.2527436316,
0.3206573725,
-0.2028685659,
-0.7188636661,
-0.3559935987,
-0.2146428674,
-0.271674037,
-0.2924341857,
0.0901608393,
0.1393577009,
-0.1656273007,
0.6500657201,
-0.0567532666,
-0.4722695351,
-0.4945535362,
-0.229804039,
0.0820598751,
0.1707537919,
0.7248659134,
-1.2132689953,
0.4785549641,
0.0427247062,
0.4086820185,
0.5078728199,
0.368843317,
0.0191074014,
-1.0485354662,
0.1654981226,
0.7172887921,
0.0710264519,
0.6868254542,
-0.3653924465,
0.2887935936,
-0.0636801496,
-0.4174459279,
-0.7680231929,
-0.1466534138,
-1.0983763933,
-0.1178589016,
0.9585748911,
-0.2860007882,
0.023292318,
-0.2823192775,
-0.1770873517,
0.3952357769,
-0.7223285437,
0.9115960002,
0.747309804,
-0.2865107656,
0.0910167098,
-0.462451607,
0.2810245156,
0.0622653253,
-0.8963873982,
0.3503738642,
0.756626308,
0.2319152355,
0.5358181596,
0.9304043055,
-0.1792056859,
0.015157952,
-0.1410769522,
0.2648668289,
-0.2818187177,
-0.1051264927,
-0.1186859608,
0.3504327834,
0.2083382756,
-0.4775843918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09741v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09741v2
|
P^3SUM: Preserving Author's Perspective in News Summarization with Diffusion Language Models
| 2023-11-16T10:14:28 | 2024-04-04T09:10:34 |
Yuhan Liu, Shangbin Feng, Xiaochuang Han, Vidhisha Balachandran, Chan Young Park, Sachin Kumar, Yulia Tsvetkov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this work, we take a first step towards designing summarization systems
that are faithful to the author's intent, not only the semantic content of the
article. Focusing on a case study of preserving political perspectives in news
summarization, we find that existing approaches alter the political opinions
and stances of news articles in more than 50% of summaries, misrepresenting the
intent and perspectives of the news authors. We thus propose P^3SUM, a
diffusion model-based summarization approach controlled by political
perspective classifiers. In P^3SUM, the political leaning of a generated
summary is iteratively evaluated at each decoding step, and any drift from the
article's original stance incurs a loss back-propagated to the embedding
layers, steering the political stance of the summary at inference time.
Extensive experiments on three news summarization datasets demonstrate that
P^3SUM outperforms state-of-the-art summarization systems and large language
models by up to 13.7% in terms of the success rate of stance preservation, with
competitive performance on standard metrics of summarization quality. Our
findings present a first analysis of preservation of pragmatic features in
summarization, highlight the lacunae in existing summarization models -- that
even state-of-the-art models often struggle to preserve author's intents -- and
develop new summarization systems that are more faithful to author's
perspectives.
|
[
-0.081988737,
-0.6181058884,
0.7194751501,
0.267695874,
-0.4372359514,
-0.3895702362,
0.0555458888,
0.1410123259,
0.4422342181,
0.6826968193,
0.0552563258,
-0.3535164297,
-0.8709257841,
-0.1344157308,
-0.3370233774,
1.5095069408,
-0.0156733692,
-0.0927591622,
-0.0024171311,
-0.1916995049,
0.1053024828,
-0.3810319304,
-0.4485896826,
-0.1830847412,
0.3810819685,
0.3637642562,
0.8423804045,
0.5174031854,
0.2094700485,
0.0971672162,
-0.4287839234,
-0.0721840039,
-0.7404618859,
-0.1561004817,
-0.0555914082,
-0.5554609299,
-0.7610247731,
0.349278301,
0.8875140548,
0.7942382097,
-0.3209736943,
-0.2115220279,
0.1253258586,
1.2688865662,
-0.7264235616,
-0.0212089065,
-0.3946470916,
-0.1493331194,
-0.0609941371,
0.0020077331,
-0.6231167316,
-0.6446444988,
0.2094959468,
-0.3184458017,
0.1297718585,
-0.2834136784,
0.7318975925,
-0.0123042203,
-0.4987598956,
-0.0076761479,
-0.5793136358,
0.6437357664,
-0.9768044353,
0.0513932817,
0.3732601404,
-0.1115753725,
-0.0555470847,
-0.2636082768,
-0.6288813353,
0.269558847,
-0.0710967928,
0.460410744,
-0.1699324697,
-0.3216304481,
-0.3601844311,
0.4265451729,
-0.263810873,
-0.2462869436,
-0.4444622993,
-0.1182468906,
0.733027339,
-0.0695962682,
-0.073932834,
-0.3696447313,
-0.3723779917,
0.0771771595,
-1.1134538651,
-0.2545862198,
0.4048160315,
0.1904016584,
-0.1360160559,
0.7080572248,
-0.2089344859,
0.6608061194,
0.0899797156,
-0.3743719757,
0.2031107694,
-0.3482907414,
-0.1280750036,
-0.1234327182,
0.7595160604,
0.9010996819,
0.3059007525,
0.1936506778,
0.0629146397,
-0.3389445841,
0.1016728207,
-0.6067516804,
-0.384526968,
0.2305136472,
-0.8579579592,
-0.3019291162,
0.3262107074,
-0.6526236534,
-0.820214808,
-0.1460652947,
0.0567464903,
-0.4489252865,
-0.6656058431,
0.3280047476,
-0.3335588574,
0.0314090326,
0.8261259198,
-0.5853944421,
0.2233927697,
0.8697242737,
1.0825765133,
-0.3801770508,
-0.3531510532,
-0.3034606576,
0.3922457695,
-0.287758708,
0.7583696246,
-0.2330454886,
-0.3159277439,
-0.0564275123,
-0.1306099296,
0.1013412103,
-0.3473094404,
0.1855843216,
-0.5340291262,
0.6141307354,
-0.2803359032,
-0.6889708638,
-0.3563886583,
0.1641561836,
-0.6624204516,
0.4323970377,
-0.0540828109,
-1.1006144285,
0.3677904606,
-0.4979272187,
-0.5108704567,
-0.5351960659,
0.1645933539,
-0.5644524097,
0.515014708,
0.0689528137,
0.4407249987,
0.3338947892,
0.1358002573,
-0.0916360393,
-0.0243394766,
0.057445243,
-0.0878511071,
0.8732923865,
0.0278659556,
0.0672567859,
0.0600258559,
-0.3777781725,
-0.8678221107,
-0.0298892986,
-0.3595637679,
-0.4781576097,
0.4345794916,
-0.1971766353,
0.2134753615,
0.3457699418,
-0.5370747447,
0.145550102,
-0.5662118793,
0.1984476298,
0.6995370388,
0.3877221346,
0.9523254037,
-0.5450590849,
0.378688693,
0.3525276482,
-0.0721065477,
-0.386182785,
-0.6379457116,
-0.5279021263,
-0.2176078707,
0.2535220683,
0.6578216553,
-0.3472834826,
0.3203024566,
-0.2975467443,
-0.3382761478,
-0.1132630035,
-0.1353639811,
0.0208048001,
0.4655580223,
0.0577722453,
-0.0865047127,
-0.2430803925,
-1.183541894,
-0.6953613758,
-0.4831870794,
-0.103514947,
-0.1777009964,
0.5177965164,
0.4429567456,
1.1018925905,
-0.5501029491,
-0.1978078932,
-0.5243302584,
0.2755716741,
0.2959427834,
0.5168918371,
0.6013762355,
-0.927646637,
-0.1703102738,
-0.270883292,
-0.5107036829,
-0.1098090261,
-0.1251312345,
-0.1202766597,
0.2216174603,
0.2159039527,
-0.6358264685,
0.5743715167,
0.4746172428,
-0.448748976,
0.102411896,
-0.1123910621,
0.1100735217,
-1.3041210175,
-0.1000464335,
0.0443576537,
-0.490708977,
-0.6337339878,
-0.2318364978,
0.1135956123,
0.0334094763,
-0.6612817645,
0.4718407989,
-0.4152983725,
0.0824013799,
-0.6399050355,
0.3680652082,
0.2487799078,
0.1565742791,
0.4149907231,
0.3646639884,
0.176364243,
-0.5992755294,
-0.3089698255,
0.3482912481,
-0.1922118813,
0.780102253,
-0.530374229,
-0.0273817889,
-0.6187527776,
0.6130232811,
-0.9313374758,
-0.1725444347,
0.2063156664,
-0.5004531145,
0.120938465,
-0.3014416695,
-0.5424856544,
0.2956942618,
-0.6360787153,
0.0281633697,
0.4179552495,
0.0046258788,
0.7235364318,
0.8098671436,
-0.4754592478,
-0.4147409499,
-0.6469705701,
0.2156978399,
-0.3219843507,
-0.3284184635,
0.3986842334,
0.1212768555,
-0.4717866778,
0.2023902088,
-0.300593257,
0.1428033561,
0.0001937965,
-0.0359042846,
0.1845254153,
0.1037781313,
-0.1177720353,
0.034867961,
-0.0467249416,
-0.0562839732,
-0.3696646988,
0.218932569,
0.0893931016,
0.0399573557,
-0.639592886,
0.6174638867,
0.6794726849,
-0.2824055851,
0.9843572974,
0.0641976148,
-0.3817676008,
0.0309647061,
-0.3413801491,
0.1932706237,
-0.3210431635,
0.3250682056,
-0.0446031317,
-0.7439351678,
0.5486788154,
0.0959431604,
0.2825736105,
0.6528570056,
0.6032169461,
-0.0095559144,
0.8529926538,
0.8808018565,
-0.1410311311,
0.6181147695,
-0.147275269,
0.192375198,
-0.7582723498,
-0.1911619008,
-0.3465719819,
-0.1654916555,
-0.2449952066,
-0.0982693136,
0.6106358171,
-0.0356758907,
0.0055618505,
0.033467114,
-0.2619681358,
0.7239798307,
0.194196701,
0.1307428628,
0.2658094764,
-0.1097740903,
0.7219213843,
0.032174401,
-0.6246699691,
-0.8528553843,
0.9195219874,
0.4529301822,
0.6058291793,
0.4092825949,
0.9155842662,
0.3647823036,
0.4317917228,
-0.5601260662,
0.512915194,
-0.085265018,
-0.336596638,
-0.1330026239,
-0.4572235346,
-0.5267688632,
0.3737539649,
0.0905466899,
-0.6030676961,
0.5571075678,
0.0898012966,
-0.2989369035,
0.4494556189,
-0.6419668198,
0.7432063818,
0.216855377,
-0.2397419512,
-0.2622011602,
-0.6040830612,
0.6580221653,
0.2227735817,
0.3293841779,
-0.3628818095,
-0.4510332346,
0.8997513652,
-0.3780175447,
0.8107107878,
-0.5475233197,
-0.4808418453,
-0.0595692322,
0.3127226532,
0.3196759522,
0.2661005259,
-0.290047437,
-0.0802880675,
-0.2802898586,
-0.6250137687,
-0.5253974199,
0.5840177536,
-0.5637506843,
-0.8116605878,
-0.420940876,
-0.5665697455,
0.0206611957,
0.3001352847,
0.1669659466,
0.2724087536,
-0.3653233349,
0.2980903089,
0.7624036074,
0.1802187264,
0.4094439149,
0.5584192276,
-0.2655202746,
-0.5164363384,
0.7186992168,
0.2230293006,
0.2537297308,
0.5595806241,
0.4130281508,
0.0088265147,
-0.8106123805,
-0.2198002487,
0.239838019,
-0.7053313255,
-0.3037437201,
-0.8814755082,
0.1471309364,
-0.2474790961,
-0.323410362,
-0.4365812242,
-0.9082363248,
-0.3990468383,
0.0736092478,
0.2150134146,
0.9681074619,
0.0773602352,
0.4966539443,
-0.4940748513,
0.4756557643,
-0.1520018876,
0.2766579092,
-0.2732134163,
-0.6081068516,
-0.2814433277,
0.0143813575,
-0.2579874694,
-1.4641729593,
0.3463311195,
0.0638629943,
0.3032840192,
0.4466747046,
0.1706459671,
-0.0108950417,
-0.4148194492,
1.0724072456,
0.0681126267,
-0.962477684,
0.8540639877,
-0.6250962019,
0.4014042318,
0.7515077591,
0.315228194,
-0.2462631017,
-0.7983351946,
-0.7333022952,
-0.8156797886,
0.766272068,
0.2409799844,
0.143468082,
-0.1457367539,
0.3922811449,
0.3596711159,
0.3348846138,
-0.6011676192,
-0.0672985986,
-0.7502076626,
-0.2419499159,
-0.0212171357,
-0.3823171854,
-0.3487994373,
-0.1041380391,
0.8114378452,
0.1275595129,
-0.1678071767,
0.2514337897,
-0.0904728472,
0.4647146165,
0.2083994746,
0.9479575753,
0.9406995177,
-0.2052937448,
0.3022467494,
-0.2204961032,
-0.5412161946,
0.1042847261,
-0.0389968753,
-0.5438122749,
0.098668471,
0.1342803389,
0.4267151952,
0.0831527039,
-0.0759785846,
0.9888603687,
-0.0782426074,
-0.1586086899,
-0.2477558851,
-0.1802517921,
0.2019291371,
-0.1445199698,
0.3578960001,
0.3813759685,
0.2437816262,
-0.6573807597,
0.0220051967,
0.1845188141,
0.1430647671,
-0.505946815,
0.7554194927,
0.2909238935,
-0.0823791027,
0.0481227562,
-0.1762790531,
-0.4916109145,
0.2932063341,
0.518961072,
1.1046772003,
-0.2528610528,
0.4016921818,
0.2018588632,
0.391812861,
-0.2951650023,
0.1404596418,
0.0299717393,
-0.6278287172,
-0.1788614392,
-0.2577803135,
-0.5482644439,
-0.303732723,
-0.4099169374,
0.2354544252,
-0.5214096904,
0.049142547,
0.1917646974,
-0.1322622597,
0.2535983622,
-0.0379155912,
0.0102795819,
1.0174109936,
-0.9965386987,
0.5217263103,
0.6573904157,
-0.2361566424,
-0.051499851,
0.3942573369,
0.3063780069,
-0.3124284148,
-0.0182260759,
-0.1640112996,
-0.2439890802,
-0.2679800689,
-0.5732191801,
-0.6385095119,
0.8489338756,
0.5324769616,
-0.0866086408,
0.1129050255,
-0.3970243931,
0.0767563805,
-0.5422353148,
-0.2220682949,
0.6039002538,
0.4400196671,
-0.2131590694,
-0.4513686597,
-0.1062103808,
-0.4391221702,
-0.0501554087,
0.3797911108,
-0.6996684074,
0.9700128436,
-0.2562392056,
-0.1835849881,
-0.2151174247,
0.8694794774,
0.2223053426,
0.1554617286,
0.4719060063,
0.3320448399,
0.5030580759,
-0.0874464586,
1.2556328773,
-0.194600746,
0.175575912,
0.9922797084,
-0.3053491414,
0.8483844995,
0.512442112,
-0.0028486992,
0.5968224406,
0.2065674365,
0.2527126372,
0.7052154541,
-0.0974759832,
-0.3489434421,
0.1511817276,
0.1679607183,
-0.1164569855,
0.4883790016,
0.2560236752,
-0.2429900467,
-0.2690418363,
-0.1436481327,
0.773285985,
0.4480604231,
-0.2620884478,
0.993432045,
-0.1190792993,
-0.8079969883,
0.1726891547,
0.1661787182,
0.3548660874,
-0.4637210071,
-0.0618163794,
-0.448333919,
0.0104378173,
-0.4086138904,
-1.0050975084,
0.6145540476,
-0.0143236769,
-0.6228060126,
-0.4401560426,
0.4238286018,
-0.4816065431,
-0.4265919328,
-0.4380613267,
0.5188339353,
0.1108425409,
-0.0931343883,
-0.005741958,
0.10567642,
-0.1363215148,
-0.4446638227,
0.24139449,
0.4934921265,
0.1663975716,
0.0982467383,
0.2740508616,
0.4668153524,
-0.4186080396,
0.0972696617,
0.7216252685,
-0.6030055881,
-0.8555839062,
-1.0596777201,
0.5728103518,
-0.2768297791,
-0.3199605644,
0.9321883321,
0.8892119527,
0.311976403,
0.0364916511,
0.8162870407,
-0.1360975057,
0.5340955853,
-0.6883850098,
1.0644729137,
-0.3701745868,
0.0727715865,
-0.2960126996,
-0.7365477681,
-0.4757496417,
0.5194060802,
-0.3928273022,
0.0499053001,
0.586188674,
0.4102289081,
0.0065096212,
0.0896988586,
0.0415695533,
0.2138367444,
0.1589385867,
0.4494738579,
0.8197979927,
-0.137534678,
0.1341776997,
-0.187664777,
-0.5961014032,
-0.1748427004,
-1.157961607,
-0.7197743058,
-0.649676621,
-0.5272356272,
-0.23200652,
-0.0249568075,
0.1816027761,
0.574706614,
-0.6169903278,
-0.1689578444,
-0.1560324878,
0.418725729,
-0.1663545221,
-0.236363858,
0.5374266505,
0.0448263362,
-0.6771582961,
0.1352017522,
0.479768157,
-0.0308202878,
-0.2934081852,
0.0643178672,
-0.2509566247,
0.1671805233,
0.6518763304,
0.1283073872,
-0.6932547092,
-0.2437129766,
-0.1974887401,
0.2049524188,
0.1459743381,
1.0058035851,
-0.7121763229,
0.185364306,
0.6826677322,
0.3020188808,
0.3814261854,
0.4158350229,
0.744301796,
-0.639465332,
0.177420482,
0.3111063242,
0.5428180099,
0.6118609905,
-0.1417659372,
0.2000336498,
0.1017572358,
-0.4708916247,
-0.7551568151,
0.2627637386,
-0.9758345485,
-0.213944599,
1.0299010277,
-0.1720907092,
-0.2754420638,
0.0926348642,
-0.3194963336,
0.1573816091,
-0.4114863276,
0.6520274878,
0.7171456218,
-0.1190762892,
-0.4291333556,
-0.5817932487,
0.5179814696,
0.2163224071,
-0.7349724174,
0.6480967999,
0.7579147816,
0.2482421249,
0.1861340851,
0.9996635914,
-0.5042910576,
0.4231424928,
-0.1609096229,
-0.1793424785,
0.0512269065,
-0.4566785693,
-0.5667503476,
0.5674844384,
-0.1770306677,
-0.0909551978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09736v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09736v2
|
CARE: Extracting Experimental Findings From Clinical Literature
| 2023-11-16T10:06:19 | 2024-04-24T18:15:36 |
Aakanksha Naik, Bailey Kuehl, Erin Bransom, Doug Downey, Tom Hope
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Extracting fine-grained experimental findings from literature can provide
dramatic utility for scientific applications. Prior work has developed
annotation schemas and datasets for limited aspects of this problem, failing to
capture the real-world complexity and nuance required. Focusing on biomedicine,
this work presents CARE -- a new IE dataset for the task of extracting clinical
findings. We develop a new annotation schema capturing fine-grained findings as
n-ary relations between entities and attributes, which unifies phenomena
challenging for current IE systems such as discontinuous entity spans, nested
relations, variable arity n-ary relations and numeric results in a single
schema. We collect extensive annotations for 700 abstracts from two sources:
clinical trials and case reports. We also demonstrate the generalizability of
our schema to the computer science and materials science domains. We benchmark
state-of-the-art IE systems on CARE, showing that even models such as GPT4
struggle. We release our resources to advance research on extracting and
aggregating literature findings.
|
[
0.1201249585,
-0.5236045718,
0.6918284297,
0.1753127873,
-0.1341586411,
-0.2104685903,
0.0789444521,
-0.7207068801,
0.5366535783,
0.5062150359,
-0.161720112,
-0.5744322538,
-0.7453477979,
0.2127607018,
-0.4719528258,
1.3258093596,
-0.0219217166,
0.2779426873,
-0.2309782803,
-0.2065692991,
0.0908818617,
-0.0085951779,
-0.6664081216,
-0.3883183599,
0.993765831,
0.345906496,
0.4466797113,
0.3789022267,
1.2187334299,
0.2423502207,
0.0406426489,
0.3833152056,
-0.1141250879,
0.10906367,
0.0242787283,
-0.5012748241,
-0.8477608562,
0.1144991294,
0.225314185,
0.8075643182,
-0.1692879051,
0.1272511929,
-0.2321707904,
0.412588954,
-0.5512814522,
0.4126964211,
-0.3106560707,
0.4972365201,
-0.3112933934,
-0.4299555123,
-0.4693973958,
-0.4128347337,
0.2932136655,
-1.0088564157,
0.2831655145,
0.2391027957,
0.9202415347,
-0.12755391,
-0.2391590178,
-0.3797893822,
-0.5105762482,
0.6659415364,
-0.6337167621,
0.0321501084,
0.4236814082,
0.367754966,
-0.1212437674,
-1.2105447054,
-0.0358921923,
-0.2797059119,
-0.5190461874,
0.2968458235,
-0.121218279,
0.1470612735,
0.0699232072,
0.7616971135,
-0.1820934564,
0.0736181512,
-0.7997424006,
-0.462944001,
0.8543074727,
0.3228724003,
0.6013374925,
-0.1771284491,
-0.1706965268,
0.1547403336,
-0.7430899739,
-0.0112779792,
-0.3022553623,
0.3305303156,
-0.0498114713,
0.8187281489,
-0.1775666922,
0.0449195541,
-0.3116768599,
-0.1247577295,
0.5098983049,
-0.242993474,
-0.2353228182,
0.2816664577,
0.8370247483,
0.7224705815,
-0.014491396,
-0.4793496132,
0.0885986537,
0.1782122701,
0.3474536836,
-0.9308367968,
-0.505798161,
0.4789989591,
-0.6206719279,
-0.5521302819,
-0.1128220633,
-0.6826034784,
-0.429025054,
-0.1717169881,
0.1888879538,
-0.6588593125,
-0.2390509397,
0.2167591304,
-0.3825199008,
-0.0066598016,
0.6907390952,
-0.6180639267,
0.4521353543,
0.4683759511,
0.9314536452,
-0.3845742941,
-0.0562637635,
-0.5301041007,
0.2517929673,
-0.1542854458,
1.0619199276,
-0.577064693,
-0.4876739085,
0.2031512111,
0.3942975998,
0.2209316045,
-0.2893455029,
0.6609850526,
-0.1468860507,
0.0547912493,
-0.2539334595,
-0.4991943538,
0.3983730078,
0.1387674063,
-0.8950644732,
0.7810001373,
0.3672486544,
-0.8849819303,
0.6349962354,
-1.0125448704,
-0.5570194125,
0.2158171684,
-0.2569105923,
-0.2544156611,
0.6345748305,
-0.1574886739,
0.4985547066,
-0.1860383898,
0.1091522798,
-0.5603276491,
-0.249436602,
0.1852310747,
0.0368335359,
0.5385821462,
0.4808979034,
0.1646840274,
-0.1590684503,
-0.9505247474,
-0.0995294079,
0.0749852955,
-0.0815717131,
-0.7444759607,
-0.0651611909,
0.2016713321,
0.0784671083,
0.0770553872,
-0.8808024526,
0.4190817773,
-0.3640184104,
0.7168931961,
0.2584032118,
0.1342249066,
0.3960889876,
-0.2549131811,
0.2163977772,
0.2677693963,
0.3123096824,
-0.0794900656,
-0.1077742875,
-0.2979212999,
-0.349614799,
0.4545955658,
0.1937921047,
-0.3836842179,
-0.2220105082,
-0.2325667888,
-0.248461768,
-0.894094944,
-0.4230219126,
0.3613545895,
0.2475060523,
0.7493079305,
-0.4886772037,
-0.1895042658,
-1.2991491556,
-0.1131975353,
0.0745028108,
-0.3290719092,
0.3490006924,
0.4380844831,
-0.2701720595,
0.6497665048,
-0.6959792972,
-0.6147261262,
0.163088873,
0.5557813644,
-0.2252679169,
0.4251687229,
0.1650951803,
-0.4620091617,
0.0237996075,
0.4677861929,
-0.9503389597,
-0.2391061634,
0.1543247551,
-0.3807924092,
-0.2751744986,
0.6846784353,
-0.5982765555,
0.6617594957,
-0.0785171315,
-0.1798521727,
0.3721183538,
-0.2721791863,
0.1196574122,
-0.8676066995,
0.2966969907,
0.1235020459,
-0.040706452,
-0.4727129936,
-0.1348818839,
0.0048864596,
0.3599945903,
-0.3325597644,
0.419293046,
-0.3664510846,
0.098027043,
-0.0421814024,
0.0437036864,
0.5570729971,
-0.006371126,
0.0621403158,
0.4165023863,
0.1538991779,
-0.2179912776,
-0.0575674437,
0.5240362287,
0.1009198502,
0.4670763016,
-0.6264958978,
-0.361661315,
-0.1518290341,
0.2516678572,
-0.4477822781,
-0.5662423968,
-0.1136080176,
-0.204486385,
0.4000708163,
0.0744345188,
-0.4713204801,
-0.1754325479,
-0.4274780452,
0.1532470286,
0.1165873557,
0.2964309454,
0.387306869,
0.6105054021,
-0.499961406,
-0.1275900304,
-0.8324477077,
-0.120661661,
-0.1888088435,
-0.1360557526,
0.6498904824,
0.345078975,
-0.4129693508,
0.263981849,
-0.1659282148,
-0.3845794499,
-0.0324316733,
0.3363717198,
0.1865963489,
-0.2559622526,
0.4374394715,
0.3731781244,
0.0332655273,
0.4197948277,
0.2925345302,
0.0046423408,
-0.0126875415,
-0.4352567792,
-0.2931498885,
0.9355797768,
0.5984348059,
-0.2544641495,
0.2553632557,
0.5215219259,
-0.6578326821,
-0.0211691037,
-0.2636255622,
-0.2468537241,
-0.2955214083,
0.303409338,
-0.1466159075,
-0.7569313049,
0.5824420452,
-0.3939203322,
0.403552711,
0.762401104,
0.0858987123,
-0.342879355,
0.9520974159,
0.5912992358,
0.235753417,
0.142300725,
-0.2938852906,
0.1930851638,
-1.1083276272,
-0.4852305055,
-0.3946489096,
-0.229879275,
-0.4891345203,
-0.1960254461,
0.4812252522,
0.0568157285,
-0.2039218694,
-0.0478776656,
-0.6539854407,
-0.054722257,
0.3482162952,
0.6424614191,
0.4469406605,
0.1433283538,
-0.1467020065,
0.0464391336,
-0.430154264,
-0.5647311211,
1.1660927534,
0.4134117663,
0.629314363,
-0.0921798125,
0.7691032887,
0.3752556443,
0.9261217713,
-0.6270045042,
0.0885135382,
-0.2917102873,
-0.60245049,
-0.2650232017,
-0.0360680297,
-1.1781569719,
-0.0363094807,
-0.1945012212,
-0.865398705,
0.3360016346,
0.1151585281,
-0.8144827485,
-0.1890828907,
-0.7571633458,
0.4725865424,
-0.0938423648,
-0.629257977,
0.2014570236,
-0.7494119406,
0.2611974776,
0.1851339936,
0.2562175989,
-0.1071346253,
0.2383721918,
0.5296372771,
-0.4826173782,
0.6544306874,
0.0210589599,
0.1133829355,
0.1259170026,
0.0627766997,
0.2599477172,
0.1966200322,
0.1061826199,
0.016773168,
0.5286038518,
-0.4960501492,
-0.5033518672,
0.52565521,
-0.4265452921,
-0.1973594725,
-0.5981105566,
-0.6202528477,
-0.1568502635,
0.172558099,
0.3630661666,
0.6910156012,
-0.1647527814,
0.1412337124,
0.46944502,
-0.2100337893,
0.1556913257,
0.5390272737,
-0.1184210703,
-0.1873209476,
0.7335910201,
0.1007794663,
0.1517096758,
0.1692837328,
0.1619181633,
-0.1378336996,
-0.7488455772,
-0.0593148991,
0.0062552015,
-0.2729434073,
-0.4168280065,
-0.7523553371,
-0.3915393353,
-0.3079466224,
-0.0438334271,
-0.2901747227,
-0.3094429374,
-0.2674829662,
-0.2450266182,
0.641307354,
0.8906744123,
-0.0898573995,
0.1113985628,
-0.9407219291,
0.2124840617,
-0.0628332719,
0.3192482293,
-0.2909649611,
0.0479856618,
-0.4176725149,
-0.077394776,
-0.4608931243,
-0.7991361618,
0.4248125255,
0.3607062101,
0.318164289,
0.5704402924,
0.0708463192,
0.7748137116,
-0.7342258692,
0.7164416909,
0.3208797574,
-0.279240191,
0.7298002839,
-0.2826781273,
-0.0988154039,
0.9488264918,
0.3508071601,
-0.2409260869,
-0.3082119226,
-1.0593223572,
-1.2054409981,
0.4183673561,
0.1847965866,
-0.4168048799,
-0.2587273121,
0.5855775476,
0.2245840281,
0.1754861623,
-0.4245136678,
-0.0701666251,
-0.0045351572,
-0.4173953533,
0.241746977,
-0.1162797287,
-0.7181753516,
-0.1736361682,
0.2626526654,
-0.324534446,
0.5047979951,
0.8869949579,
-0.1545821279,
-0.1140196919,
0.162535727,
0.2579625547,
0.3222530186,
-0.3391984105,
0.3167672753,
-0.0398466289,
-0.6666113138,
-0.273827374,
0.4316484034,
0.0458790436,
-0.1044843495,
0.8397832513,
0.236676693,
0.4004178941,
-0.5018738508,
0.5254507065,
-0.1403685957,
-0.2782853842,
-0.4289667308,
0.0386789218,
-0.0813683718,
0.1706759781,
0.1130693033,
-0.0468485616,
0.9567137957,
-0.3521710932,
0.4517714679,
0.2751787901,
-0.7790310979,
-0.5334708095,
0.380646646,
0.1422821432,
-0.0412221141,
0.2927085757,
-0.1330030411,
0.1917760819,
0.5646875501,
0.5076124668,
0.6426433921,
0.1347158253,
0.3182140887,
0.0331707895,
0.0217993893,
-0.2554954886,
0.3123284578,
0.2736322582,
-0.3531863987,
-0.4689042568,
-0.8120955825,
-0.4185693264,
0.3532755673,
-1.0786221027,
0.14932926,
-0.2302320749,
0.0054076966,
0.4769431651,
0.2253558785,
-0.7661677003,
0.309286207,
-0.1834262609,
1.0646500587,
-1.0316538811,
0.6003630161,
0.7342045307,
-0.6729598045,
-0.8880001903,
-0.4908314347,
-0.061680343,
-0.655077219,
0.5289643407,
0.0932777375,
0.3095461428,
-0.3856648207,
-0.5873796344,
-0.5645526648,
1.3376017809,
0.0451967418,
-0.5608198047,
-0.1898277104,
0.1616577357,
0.8190063834,
-0.7291358113,
0.6786901355,
0.8649243116,
0.3770836592,
-0.1024455205,
-0.7184260488,
-0.0053852275,
-0.7634133697,
-0.4005185068,
0.0183665734,
-0.5376839638,
0.933919549,
-0.1312266737,
-0.0113879684,
-0.0379413478,
0.2749726474,
0.3527150154,
0.9201577306,
0.0980756134,
0.5943212509,
0.8739414811,
-0.3000864983,
1.0860638618,
-0.1712286025,
0.2114756852,
1.00368011,
-0.4840299785,
0.5277322531,
0.5465432405,
-0.3883951604,
0.3753062487,
0.7274871469,
0.1837039739,
0.4978709221,
0.4263344109,
-0.3442145288,
-0.0818012208,
-0.521597743,
-0.4677395821,
0.141284138,
0.8110208511,
-0.6552878618,
-0.3033776879,
-0.1368185729,
0.2545102239,
-0.3762729168,
-0.2041924447,
0.8443995118,
0.2980065644,
-0.4279757738,
-0.1880037338,
-0.3859007955,
0.1085316464,
-0.582314074,
-0.5772972107,
-0.2685223222,
-0.1153223291,
-0.44568941,
-0.4661637843,
0.2572022378,
-0.2788312733,
-0.141853869,
0.2035694867,
0.763779819,
-0.3012535274,
-0.6628719568,
0.1470167935,
0.5040389895,
0.3194583356,
0.2851012349,
-0.2546541989,
-0.0570074655,
-0.2444233298,
-0.310190618,
0.4447830915,
1.1018531322,
-0.3993064761,
0.3182443976,
0.5588442087,
0.6655002832,
-0.171803683,
0.005870054,
1.0697695017,
-0.694280386,
0.0379927792,
-0.460939914,
0.5241917372,
-0.5772899985,
-0.7306744456,
0.2508662045,
0.4562729299,
0.2041379213,
0.1992713511,
1.0492758751,
-0.0017354449,
0.4119473994,
-0.4255745411,
0.4412109256,
-0.6632480621,
0.1466166079,
-0.1630503386,
-0.2998234034,
-0.6584282517,
0.578791976,
-0.0061361641,
-0.4391415119,
1.0109987259,
0.4155206978,
-0.2654732764,
0.3843204975,
-0.0227325931,
0.5550453067,
0.4468962848,
0.4223838151,
0.487872839,
-0.3812966347,
-0.0184922535,
-0.212033093,
-0.3491107523,
-0.3977260292,
-1.0229045153,
-0.4995740354,
-0.2867672145,
-0.3444316685,
-0.3865059614,
0.1969988495,
0.8642051816,
0.5999554396,
-0.9707283974,
0.4858456254,
-0.1613106132,
-0.4129697084,
-0.2405550927,
-0.2157067657,
0.8531824946,
-0.5319334269,
-0.4109023213,
-0.0105947973,
0.5514716506,
-0.07357651,
-0.2569938302,
0.2586776018,
-0.1081361473,
-0.0415624343,
0.7890507579,
0.2984349132,
-0.4962279499,
-0.3465665877,
-0.0762969777,
-0.2241221964,
0.0665326789,
0.7373731136,
-0.4730090499,
0.2301322967,
0.132473141,
0.4694083333,
0.4918839931,
-0.2975324392,
0.4951308966,
-0.5409633517,
-0.1092750132,
0.5139695406,
0.5250518918,
0.0255265366,
-0.4766549468,
0.619143188,
0.0338070691,
-0.5574688315,
-0.9524884224,
-0.0169966072,
-1.1520416737,
-0.1288293004,
0.9919877052,
-0.4838954508,
-0.3873800933,
-0.205773741,
-0.3276376724,
0.1574366689,
-0.5722905993,
1.0044997931,
0.5652031302,
-0.5594477057,
0.0245286431,
-0.864369154,
0.7332693338,
0.1891624033,
-1.0696873665,
0.0204856247,
0.4611610174,
0.0188904647,
0.5600489974,
0.8543428183,
-0.6592575908,
0.1241664514,
-0.0987356156,
0.311566025,
-0.0975840241,
-0.3368166387,
-0.0870904401,
0.3933349848,
-0.0996488184,
0.0351102985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09734v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09734v1
|
Tracking the Newsworthiness of Public Documents
| 2023-11-16T10:05:26 | 2023-11-16T10:05:26 |
Alexander Spangher, Emilio Ferrara, Ben Welsh, Nanyun Peng, Serdar Tumgoren, Jonathan May
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Journalists must find stories in huge amounts of textual data (e.g. leaks,
bills, press releases) as part of their jobs: determining when and why text
becomes news can help us understand coverage patterns and help us build
assistive tools. Yet, this is challenging because very few labelled links
exist, language use between corpora is very different, and text may be covered
for a variety of reasons. In this work we focus on news coverage of local
public policy in the San Francisco Bay Area by the San Francisco Chronicle.
First, we gather news articles, public policy documents and meeting recordings
and link them using probabilistic relational modeling, which we show is a
low-annotation linking methodology that outperforms other retrieval-based
baselines. Second, we define a new task: newsworthiness prediction, to predict
if a policy item will get covered. We show that different aspects of public
policy discussion yield different newsworthiness signals. Finally we perform
human evaluation with expert journalists and show our systems identify policies
they consider newsworthy with 68% F1 and our coverage recommendations are
helpful with an 84% win-rate.
|
[
-0.3802374303,
-0.5543911457,
1.1056742668,
0.3156504631,
-0.0017839881,
-0.1496311277,
-0.0787750557,
-0.5864173174,
0.510720253,
0.4425227046,
-0.2624602318,
-0.6808097363,
-0.4979720414,
0.0367893018,
-0.3306711018,
1.2294532061,
-0.1313851625,
-0.2572769225,
-0.2060581148,
-0.0121676605,
0.0378618725,
-0.4796553254,
-0.2342456877,
-0.1563162953,
0.4920023382,
0.2581846714,
1.414157629,
0.681851387,
0.6325188875,
0.1753052324,
-0.5518926978,
0.0362400971,
-0.4732014835,
-0.3451406956,
-0.1874272376,
-0.6317706704,
-0.1784145385,
0.2871999145,
0.8784778714,
0.5544352531,
-0.0202272274,
0.0483202189,
-0.1426292956,
0.7422898412,
-0.4561007321,
0.237070933,
-0.6641453505,
-0.1980327219,
-0.4226430655,
-0.0748603269,
-0.0701607913,
-0.6052401066,
0.0873201489,
-0.7809441686,
0.3650356233,
0.0243376009,
1.0005186796,
0.0186654534,
-0.4628194571,
-0.0959334001,
-0.3483462334,
0.4262486994,
-0.4875949323,
0.4176261723,
1.0333440304,
0.084303014,
-0.423950851,
-0.2302426249,
-0.6768996119,
-0.5004730821,
-0.5229232311,
0.0134626832,
-0.3787685931,
-0.0995982587,
0.1804875284,
0.2278099954,
-0.4469280839,
-0.3003133237,
-0.6751833558,
-0.3466147184,
0.7229428291,
-0.2039481103,
-0.0083850175,
-0.6692228913,
-0.4888759255,
0.1476972848,
-0.5687795281,
0.0986116976,
0.6603978276,
0.0454934798,
-0.0116268042,
0.3371753395,
-0.6168377399,
0.5686050653,
-0.2138234079,
-0.2445633858,
0.4644271433,
-0.6537543535,
0.0550049208,
0.1076272279,
0.6237103939,
0.4265985489,
0.0456631742,
-0.1430206597,
-0.0913863629,
-0.2083766311,
0.2878773808,
-0.3434135914,
-0.1370469332,
-0.0019866053,
-0.5808952451,
-0.5894899368,
0.3442974687,
-0.3523918688,
-0.5780451298,
-0.4499790668,
0.1699278802,
-0.1833135933,
-0.1801474541,
0.0527070463,
-0.330196619,
-0.2277968824,
0.4215595722,
-0.5500469208,
-0.0243178979,
0.7414355874,
0.9205802679,
0.0286037624,
-0.3755531311,
-0.4373724759,
0.3518054783,
-0.4158614278,
0.8554198146,
-0.1514611244,
-0.2016313672,
0.0391691551,
0.2123244256,
0.1230343282,
-0.3429935575,
0.7103008032,
-0.2463534325,
0.081011802,
-0.4063920975,
-0.1099874228,
-0.1420631707,
0.3325165212,
-1.0975983143,
0.8694469333,
0.3618269861,
-0.9905372262,
0.6024236679,
-0.2137751579,
-0.6389950514,
-0.2752008438,
0.1394888312,
-0.5700402856,
0.2728204131,
0.1746231914,
0.3635156453,
-0.0115444623,
0.6315276623,
-0.3663637042,
-0.4672234654,
0.2389507443,
-0.5718605518,
0.5426014662,
-0.0942081288,
0.0984453857,
0.1930456012,
-0.8354438543,
-0.5126150846,
-0.4213107228,
-0.810244143,
-0.5039606094,
0.2380190343,
0.1052173674,
0.1273902357,
0.0883379728,
-0.6949029565,
0.0140209943,
-0.2195326537,
0.4022574425,
0.3293098211,
0.3491035998,
0.4719913006,
-0.8659763932,
0.084173277,
-0.1054934487,
0.4227619767,
-0.1177475229,
-0.5393318534,
-0.0555843711,
-0.147536397,
0.1099281684,
0.2144665569,
-0.4610073268,
0.031892091,
-0.2429241091,
-0.7083503604,
-0.6000426412,
0.0471723527,
0.1738740355,
0.4122113585,
0.3333118856,
-0.0711837411,
-0.2336364537,
-0.9776741862,
-0.6176680923,
-0.4296251535,
-0.1179399565,
-0.0447456911,
0.3562380373,
0.0011227211,
1.0248529911,
-0.4068052769,
-0.4064605534,
0.0305539314,
0.6377483606,
0.2933159769,
0.2207789123,
0.5159822106,
-1.0954889059,
-0.0530946963,
-0.1392157376,
-0.2824614942,
-0.0190909095,
-0.3273602128,
-0.052471146,
0.3545186222,
0.3508119285,
-0.8045620322,
0.5528370738,
0.3952408433,
-0.4645176828,
0.5022485852,
-0.1292270124,
0.348754555,
-0.6065013409,
0.0040031821,
0.3071398735,
-0.4115020335,
-0.2906241417,
-0.4314271808,
-0.2314881384,
-0.3507874608,
-0.5054665208,
0.4087553322,
-0.3719967902,
-0.3772753179,
-0.0666799247,
0.2270406485,
0.1427368373,
0.2953793705,
0.2133176178,
0.554959774,
0.0729896724,
-0.307051003,
0.2253871858,
0.1098645329,
-0.6763834953,
0.3098603785,
-0.3513552248,
-0.3696145415,
-0.530544579,
0.4984185398,
-0.6609418988,
-0.213777706,
-0.0945180506,
-0.5050827861,
-0.1873037219,
0.2578602135,
-0.6498112679,
-0.1574852765,
-0.4768463075,
-0.2980920374,
0.0007276731,
-0.4131989777,
0.2320069671,
0.623162806,
-0.2758870125,
-0.1873104125,
-0.5955376029,
-0.157874465,
0.0420022234,
-0.5479274988,
0.3737072349,
0.2571724057,
-0.3530910611,
0.384911418,
-0.4681057334,
-0.4633446336,
0.3075618446,
0.3628155887,
0.0253856555,
-0.0761796981,
0.2100173831,
0.0062716268,
-0.1108789369,
0.2645840347,
0.2137839049,
-0.2110166997,
-0.237417236,
-0.1927175373,
-0.7403703332,
0.5252459049,
0.556333065,
-0.4029254317,
0.6736215353,
0.6289796233,
-0.3685218096,
0.1847212017,
-0.4917503595,
-0.027720565,
-0.2958044708,
0.445304364,
-0.1142994836,
-0.4404996336,
0.1363224387,
0.0717546716,
-0.1669695079,
0.4347875714,
0.1026196256,
-0.0497818738,
0.8376492858,
0.5900065899,
-0.5655785203,
0.5445961356,
0.2005327046,
-0.1316394955,
-0.0231994782,
-0.2315868735,
-0.5831656456,
-0.1531608701,
-0.7515830398,
-0.3207360208,
0.3313414752,
0.493516624,
0.0883069858,
0.6738606691,
-0.3832953572,
0.507438004,
0.8445558548,
0.0549158193,
0.8551920652,
-0.0057352791,
0.6232843399,
0.2020674795,
-0.3766250312,
-0.5388431549,
0.7647135258,
0.614408493,
0.6108068824,
0.1039337441,
0.7531458735,
0.4011397064,
0.742618084,
-0.4695164561,
0.2956988811,
0.0884651616,
-0.6719246507,
-0.488250643,
-0.4772563577,
-0.6018609405,
-0.0094185593,
-0.6201105118,
-0.7100627422,
0.4113990366,
0.0872106329,
-0.2052197456,
0.1125622913,
-0.4588862062,
0.6396757364,
-0.1025007665,
-0.1616489291,
-0.4101305902,
-0.488609314,
0.2461218387,
-0.1799280792,
0.4068814516,
-0.3999172747,
0.0971790627,
0.6017707586,
-0.0805570111,
0.4787478447,
0.0985413715,
-0.0025902661,
0.3809172511,
-0.1695142686,
0.5156276822,
0.385912329,
-0.2930580676,
0.362447679,
0.4131175578,
-0.3056128919,
-0.4895272255,
0.49698627,
-0.4865257144,
-0.5100855827,
-0.5737209916,
-0.6050599217,
-0.2047833204,
0.3289297819,
0.2334303707,
0.2316444814,
-0.1538458019,
0.3613924384,
0.4143961072,
0.2250614613,
0.3387388289,
0.9419509768,
-0.0788755342,
-0.2046824098,
0.9710419178,
0.4295529425,
-0.1400432289,
0.8338469267,
0.1781115234,
-0.2153090835,
-0.3518324494,
-0.0111956615,
0.1539197266,
-0.3138764501,
-0.2977769971,
-0.0724578798,
-0.0187686142,
-0.1431106776,
-0.1084664091,
-0.1433976442,
-0.4858479798,
-0.3058860302,
-0.3616007864,
0.2599139214,
0.7983705997,
-0.1131261587,
0.2305456847,
-0.7310994864,
0.296151489,
0.0256316569,
0.4144932628,
-0.6031640768,
0.1589158028,
-0.3830295205,
-0.1752660573,
-0.3420448005,
-1.268535614,
0.163421765,
-0.2517098188,
0.4793371558,
0.2028640956,
0.3486602604,
0.1318785101,
-0.2230348289,
0.3453306556,
0.0900027081,
-0.6735296249,
0.7565862536,
-0.6967822313,
0.0098878834,
0.9406532645,
0.7994629741,
-0.1858957112,
-0.7511602044,
-0.8009302616,
-0.5932676196,
0.3126796484,
0.1303160936,
-0.1249206141,
-0.3163176477,
0.1261793673,
-0.3177045882,
0.4520941079,
-0.5515771508,
0.2427528501,
-0.0757524297,
-0.0590539463,
0.0074136178,
-0.2678236961,
-0.1811052561,
-0.0076486804,
0.5788998008,
-0.0246967003,
0.0057893014,
0.5554044843,
0.1966662258,
-0.1833085865,
0.5491933227,
0.4971434772,
1.1862623692,
-0.517547965,
0.175731957,
-0.0980433151,
-0.5924628973,
-0.1875886321,
0.5751513243,
-0.4722147882,
0.7201412916,
0.4635358453,
0.6054736376,
0.542098403,
-0.5200151205,
0.9253063798,
0.2021665871,
-0.4144671857,
-0.3615099192,
-0.1289752573,
-0.0221515335,
0.3828917444,
0.5030329227,
-0.0543771237,
0.2047758996,
-0.8041204214,
0.3019618094,
0.2343521416,
-0.5828108788,
-0.2426948845,
0.5694698095,
0.2955115139,
-0.245098725,
0.2689749599,
-0.3647910058,
-0.4825668037,
0.4402721822,
0.3104752004,
0.0897028819,
0.1677451283,
0.4963088036,
0.1728130132,
0.5402998328,
-0.4981753528,
0.2620835304,
0.0267170276,
-0.3174989223,
-0.4477741122,
-0.5480328202,
-0.4441194236,
0.2636045516,
-0.640059948,
0.2825212181,
-0.2261469215,
-0.3564708233,
0.1163312644,
0.4504084289,
-0.2799427509,
0.1515455991,
0.0844624192,
1.3526968956,
-1.0902644396,
0.7957748175,
0.4199846387,
-0.6972090602,
-0.8281331658,
0.4427684546,
0.1750033796,
-0.4145109057,
0.3274077177,
0.1861240715,
0.3051278293,
-0.3584110737,
-0.2702078223,
-0.8222793341,
1.2302052975,
0.4685118496,
-0.7723904252,
-0.2875392437,
-0.3234572709,
0.2131118029,
0.1738696098,
-0.005348267,
0.6651186943,
0.7266801596,
-0.3265067041,
-1.1166764498,
-0.0082697254,
0.1071925461,
-0.0838684738,
0.6892830729,
-0.7040277123,
0.7772887349,
-0.2875816226,
-0.1362850964,
-0.0589565299,
0.8318911195,
0.1274376661,
0.9038065672,
0.3410153389,
0.4519204795,
0.97709167,
-0.0935314,
1.2108305693,
-0.1882995516,
0.2010048628,
1.0206525326,
0.1355798244,
1.0671613216,
0.2960205376,
0.0079898573,
0.4040558636,
0.2928031385,
-0.1963826567,
0.5749351978,
0.2590821087,
-0.3200462162,
0.0365906917,
-0.5335121751,
-0.1790364832,
0.3748084307,
-0.1278684735,
-0.4715088904,
-0.2518317401,
-0.0409985073,
0.3476985097,
0.4649661481,
-0.6396766305,
0.4780221581,
-0.1828873008,
-0.8700067997,
-0.0409988537,
0.0536039583,
0.2417545319,
-0.4583238661,
-0.1502115279,
-0.0953264683,
-0.0341436192,
-0.4975548983,
-1.1466875076,
0.6601498127,
-0.1887006462,
-0.6601302624,
-0.168130666,
0.8560321927,
-0.4044804871,
-0.2752257884,
0.0960956812,
0.3682166934,
0.1601418406,
-0.4437866807,
-0.1989253461,
0.1039239243,
-0.2773846984,
-0.466119945,
0.437150389,
0.3825755417,
-0.283136189,
0.2938978672,
0.7159950733,
0.4164903164,
-0.4065491557,
-0.0087228715,
0.788814187,
-0.5335037112,
-0.6059238911,
-0.3905709386,
0.256143719,
-0.2966260016,
-0.5897545218,
0.6568473577,
0.6377068162,
0.925979495,
0.3418693841,
0.6687681079,
0.1998822838,
0.7486891747,
-0.5345265865,
0.7901554108,
-0.0767322853,
0.1307365894,
-0.0076377592,
-0.6063258052,
-0.0431564786,
0.5763964057,
-0.6199316382,
-0.6629772782,
0.5838810205,
0.7347663641,
0.1227639765,
0.3793386221,
-0.0755639449,
-0.1059748158,
-0.1144424677,
0.4778217077,
0.5724709034,
0.042556826,
0.985959053,
-0.2389303297,
-0.2772180438,
-0.0387343541,
-1.0286813974,
-0.6536120176,
-0.5270973444,
-0.2557430863,
-0.4077940583,
0.3970435262,
0.2414631397,
0.7823953032,
-0.3840735257,
0.1738695353,
-0.3076123297,
0.5429838896,
-0.2222783566,
-0.2852605283,
0.32198596,
-0.1146154478,
-0.2223415822,
0.2855397165,
-0.0084010744,
-0.1013146341,
-0.1091137603,
0.16059798,
-0.2912616134,
-0.2553430498,
0.2512189746,
0.4155811369,
-0.3575749099,
-0.2066888362,
-0.4088494778,
-0.3509790003,
-0.1333947629,
0.7646252513,
-0.9273614883,
0.0309370663,
0.6027701497,
0.5906341672,
0.607550621,
0.4512081742,
0.402790904,
-0.7989135981,
0.0356697105,
0.1649321914,
0.1416096985,
0.2615101337,
-0.5199811459,
0.5647409558,
0.2405115962,
-0.5725234747,
-0.6954064369,
0.0266543739,
-0.5564801097,
-0.2683242261,
1.049390316,
0.029121099,
-0.4302885532,
-0.0572933741,
-0.1256604046,
-0.0459791087,
-0.6106296778,
0.5337584615,
0.7271668911,
-0.0903173387,
-0.0301321372,
-0.9193906188,
0.6698292494,
-0.2059444636,
-0.7894425392,
-0.0159015451,
0.5521865487,
0.1628182977,
0.5915895104,
1.1616832018,
0.1146518737,
0.5178343058,
-0.1002937183,
-0.5780367851,
-0.2926055193,
-0.6100689769,
-0.1400008649,
0.1591528058,
-0.081125021,
-0.1003100127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09733v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09733v2
|
MOKA: Moral Knowledge Augmentation for Moral Event Extraction
| 2023-11-16T10:04:49 | 2024-05-23T01:53:15 |
Xinliang Frederick Zhang, Winston Wu, Nick Beauchamp, Lu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
News media often strive to minimize explicit moral language in news articles,
yet most articles are dense with moral values as expressed through the reported
events themselves. However, values that are reflected in the intricate dynamics
among participating entities and moral events are far more challenging for most
NLP systems to detect, including LLMs. To study this phenomenon, we annotate a
new dataset, MORAL EVENTS, consisting of 5,494 structured event annotations on
474 news articles by diverse US media across the political spectrum. We further
propose MOKA, a moral event extraction framework with MOral Knowledge
Augmentation, which leverages knowledge derived from moral words and moral
scenarios to produce structural representations of morality-bearing events.
Experiments show that MOKA outperforms competitive baselines across three moral
event understanding tasks. Further analysis shows even ostensibly nonpartisan
media engage in the selective reporting of moral events. Our data and codebase
are available at https://github.com/launchnlp/MOKA.
|
[
-0.1299211085,
-0.6576408744,
0.7534676194,
0.1024378613,
-0.645290792,
0.0409938172,
-0.0627737343,
-0.4815963507,
0.3255652189,
0.546390295,
-0.547326684,
-0.5491753221,
-0.7180797458,
-0.0666117221,
-0.2046309114,
1.0236899853,
0.4683480561,
0.1388940215,
-0.3092335165,
-0.5032590032,
0.0300479438,
-0.5979743004,
-0.5553582311,
-0.3483570516,
0.4100229144,
0.2622067034,
0.5540921092,
0.641155839,
0.6821810603,
0.1447715163,
-0.3639436364,
0.2930721939,
-0.6938631535,
0.00298604,
-0.2796702981,
-0.6131271124,
-0.4084299803,
0.481972456,
0.393558085,
0.4392594993,
-0.0898862481,
0.3828888237,
-0.2064625919,
0.9754594564,
-0.7804549336,
0.0886941701,
-0.7925579548,
0.3497053683,
-0.2285085917,
-0.4937407672,
-0.194764629,
-0.3305304348,
-0.0291016046,
-0.7504169941,
-0.0862494111,
-0.1255608201,
0.8081837893,
0.0370394811,
-0.7931701541,
-0.4788224995,
-0.2667839527,
1.0407847166,
-0.3987612128,
0.2952793539,
0.6921393871,
-0.2999803424,
-0.1619091481,
-0.4053045213,
-0.5574368238,
-0.1021680236,
-0.080768548,
0.2891556025,
-0.0597757511,
-0.1965679973,
0.2586638331,
0.4000407159,
-0.1055398732,
-0.1048368141,
-0.3379640281,
-0.0491878763,
0.6122695208,
0.1933478415,
0.3184283078,
-0.6785881519,
-0.3127200902,
0.0155619374,
-0.7608395219,
0.409968704,
0.8721004128,
0.017553417,
-0.2218141407,
0.8343920708,
-0.135044083,
0.2817102373,
0.1232893392,
-0.2467724532,
0.2864543498,
-0.4747703969,
-0.1427767426,
0.018297933,
0.9464755654,
0.5487869382,
0.282337755,
0.3829371631,
-0.0901397318,
-0.0774089992,
0.1646448523,
-0.7339871526,
-0.0335106552,
-0.0460803732,
-0.8045158982,
-0.9016144276,
-0.0436600633,
-0.9000322819,
-0.8621430993,
-0.1225887239,
0.0074242586,
-0.3488418758,
-0.2167700827,
0.2312844247,
-0.2394650728,
0.4130767286,
0.3776368201,
-0.6352449656,
-0.3298472762,
0.7210633755,
0.7874892354,
0.0084505761,
0.4251038134,
-0.9696916938,
0.2185988873,
-0.3196174204,
0.5592811108,
-1.0628073215,
-0.4328590631,
-0.0559730195,
-0.0616940185,
0.5958632827,
-0.1836260855,
0.7410674691,
-0.6764413714,
0.188610062,
-0.3343230784,
-0.5749820471,
-0.0981344953,
0.1975396872,
-0.6618482471,
0.680220902,
-0.3049265146,
-0.603810668,
0.4893645048,
-0.624417007,
-0.7533952594,
-0.1653664559,
-0.2246630341,
-0.4270807803,
0.5296407938,
0.4096697569,
0.5501190424,
0.0074734567,
0.4016543031,
-0.3931166232,
-0.132264033,
0.2344697565,
-0.357612431,
1.038434267,
-0.0496733747,
0.0014064795,
0.0163383558,
-0.8845630288,
-0.4473693371,
0.3184243143,
-0.5678714514,
-0.5881812572,
0.2487016916,
-0.2176814526,
-0.0319701992,
0.188483417,
-0.5819637179,
0.1955685616,
-0.2104833722,
0.1803593189,
0.9623100162,
0.1361544281,
0.7577238083,
-0.3408923149,
0.3446492553,
0.0397350863,
0.1125177667,
-0.149459973,
-0.4934138954,
-0.6093013287,
-0.1543691903,
-0.1153568327,
0.460162878,
-0.6400081515,
0.4670907855,
-0.0332294926,
-0.1248651072,
-0.1486319304,
0.0891411602,
0.0460846759,
0.4449204206,
0.2786149979,
-0.0296055079,
-0.7717553973,
-0.7775451541,
-0.5728129148,
-0.4879645407,
-0.0512333363,
0.1579627097,
0.3838219643,
0.2318480164,
0.7305767536,
-0.2148046046,
-0.5990960598,
-0.1055580378,
0.3893735111,
0.2823128402,
0.34596017,
0.4443149865,
-0.9967237711,
-0.0528204218,
0.3088759184,
-0.8576210737,
-0.1433193833,
-0.3358283341,
-0.0414056256,
0.0054999627,
0.4244050682,
-0.1232058108,
0.435775876,
0.668022871,
-0.4630619884,
0.4853898883,
0.3929617703,
0.3474561274,
-1.0347980261,
-0.1705771536,
-0.2298213542,
-0.507132411,
-0.2515818477,
-0.4470578432,
-0.020880824,
0.2382510304,
-0.5602394938,
0.3310312331,
-0.2980976105,
-0.1084229574,
-0.205067724,
0.4449134469,
0.138448894,
0.3902527392,
0.089834176,
0.5679689646,
0.2313842028,
-0.4685189426,
0.4738393128,
0.4469044805,
-0.5631859899,
0.6968337893,
-0.155203402,
0.0161294229,
-0.1913981587,
0.0617458075,
-0.4281156361,
-0.1474963576,
0.187246114,
-0.468747139,
-0.3090498149,
-0.7406593561,
-0.5382902026,
0.2801779509,
-0.3579456806,
0.1821635067,
0.565506041,
-0.3580654562,
0.7050854564,
0.8500999808,
-0.035461247,
-0.7480006218,
-0.5977739692,
-0.0307932384,
-0.3304797411,
-0.5076236725,
-0.0705509111,
0.2802107036,
-0.2662638724,
0.2879562974,
-0.2768574953,
-0.028089026,
0.1283216327,
0.119708173,
0.1167534217,
-0.3312479258,
0.5288282037,
0.0888814628,
-0.176233843,
0.155116424,
-0.2496568859,
0.3315410614,
-0.688601017,
-0.4513299763,
-0.5146284699,
0.4107042551,
0.463523984,
-0.4058761895,
0.7423929572,
0.7560198903,
-0.3500162065,
0.2443766147,
-0.5591545701,
-0.0917190835,
-0.4404739738,
0.2793115079,
-0.0367628112,
-1.0727432966,
0.5443338156,
0.0189052448,
0.1723634899,
0.4098258913,
0.4318517745,
-0.6267458797,
0.9030635357,
0.4695446491,
0.2016936988,
0.8965598941,
-0.0921807587,
-0.1005088538,
-0.7547236085,
-0.2066779733,
-0.048581779,
-0.4932312071,
-0.337143302,
-0.4057888985,
0.243224293,
0.2798512876,
0.1050305516,
0.0723880306,
-0.1325255036,
0.9031934142,
0.3795332611,
0.0244125929,
0.8759974241,
0.1943092048,
0.2339965701,
-0.118806988,
-0.4603218734,
-0.6207658052,
0.9430299997,
0.0299231093,
0.5921350121,
0.213948831,
0.5283836126,
0.4076118171,
0.3647562265,
-0.8399873376,
0.5634414554,
-0.3938215375,
-0.5090174079,
-0.1199987531,
-0.5231071711,
-0.8086789846,
0.166582942,
-0.572535336,
-0.598451972,
0.5696857572,
-0.1528925598,
-0.2541714609,
0.5896515846,
-0.3341654837,
0.3218575716,
-0.1908505708,
-0.1633722633,
-0.5928514004,
-0.408883661,
0.4187027812,
-0.0254155416,
0.1465019584,
-0.7627590895,
-0.4531390369,
0.7961233258,
0.118744269,
0.9470453262,
0.0665718764,
0.0557284653,
0.4014414847,
0.069735907,
0.84419173,
0.6257219911,
-0.0441911146,
0.2430690825,
-0.0433879197,
-0.3289431036,
-0.4577565789,
0.434643358,
-0.3813218474,
-0.5111443996,
-0.3461443782,
-0.5495651364,
-0.1875105798,
-0.0436156243,
0.1916592866,
0.3052747846,
-0.145348087,
0.8588395119,
0.6295931339,
-0.1871685088,
0.444554925,
0.4490157366,
-0.1363559961,
-0.5427808762,
0.7326865196,
-0.1057128385,
0.0147609971,
0.2789077461,
0.3886102438,
-0.0346550234,
-0.4970269203,
-0.2834785581,
0.0899080187,
-0.7751138806,
-0.3366337419,
-0.8513730764,
0.0545150824,
0.1360540539,
-0.5196213722,
-0.6455587745,
-0.5169470906,
-0.5775620937,
-0.4511567652,
0.5021579862,
0.6267249584,
-0.3216398656,
0.3234865367,
-1.012894392,
0.3689169586,
0.1236588433,
0.3869035542,
-0.538300693,
-0.1990151852,
-0.071143806,
0.1070893779,
-0.1469659656,
-1.0070630312,
0.1387166828,
0.1963799596,
0.3987068236,
0.561701417,
0.2778046131,
0.6764557958,
-0.1635585576,
0.7447001338,
0.4334386289,
-0.9524000883,
0.8675109148,
-0.649427712,
-0.099189721,
0.5877090693,
0.1749175489,
-0.4332007468,
-0.4756759405,
-0.8246144652,
-0.5942847729,
0.7034255266,
0.7089136243,
0.43622908,
-0.1232007816,
0.3818894923,
0.1722229272,
0.2738515735,
-1.0382666588,
-0.0598587617,
-0.1055992916,
-0.328097254,
0.3971881568,
-0.490550518,
-0.3952262998,
-0.0013023312,
0.6579037905,
-0.1996665597,
0.0614755191,
0.3664123118,
-0.3771277964,
-0.1510612071,
0.1097928882,
0.5335390568,
0.6149742007,
0.0082983654,
0.027876351,
0.1821070313,
-0.6214419007,
0.1054901704,
-0.2344387472,
0.0285690576,
-0.1212664247,
0.6248915195,
0.464304626,
-0.0209206548,
-0.7959379554,
0.7129036784,
-0.219088316,
-0.1165475473,
-0.3987500966,
0.138188079,
0.0670326203,
0.5731173754,
0.4491153359,
0.0651277602,
0.0832360461,
-0.6511585116,
0.4265205562,
0.417206943,
-0.5589767098,
-0.3562798202,
0.3405512571,
0.5618906021,
-0.0873444825,
0.527956605,
-0.312348038,
-0.200162977,
0.7321425676,
0.1488991082,
0.5935755372,
0.1306172162,
0.2932443023,
0.3348555267,
0.5161509514,
0.2979282141,
0.3759773076,
0.0860735029,
-0.9237468243,
-0.7067027092,
-0.7652340531,
-0.149891749,
0.3147954345,
-0.688400507,
0.3141809702,
-0.5162143707,
-0.1336236894,
-0.308118403,
0.0317571573,
-0.2561897337,
-0.1655470729,
0.2089149654,
0.4693944156,
-0.7641856074,
0.6738515496,
0.6383705735,
-0.2234455198,
-0.0829803944,
-0.0027728339,
0.2076138854,
-0.809527576,
0.3023186624,
0.11691048,
-0.1586630642,
-0.1563152522,
-0.5349660516,
-0.5812910795,
0.935592711,
0.6104827523,
-0.355730325,
0.2166018337,
0.045016773,
0.3493585885,
-0.7493921518,
-0.3952063024,
0.3118238747,
0.5676717162,
0.0346859023,
-0.1841175705,
-0.1556286365,
-0.2224108726,
-0.4440539777,
0.2309007645,
-0.5613532662,
0.3640997708,
-0.3395344317,
-0.3134404123,
-0.2150771171,
0.9332197309,
0.2324987799,
0.5082588196,
0.7774117589,
0.1512777507,
1.0036994219,
-0.1528482735,
0.8351547122,
0.134077549,
0.3277752995,
1.0698059797,
0.1508029699,
0.4873349369,
0.5401997566,
0.0097787213,
0.3342615068,
0.5304560661,
-0.0806642175,
0.4393198788,
-0.2883532047,
-0.3480692804,
-0.7625272274,
-0.4258267581,
-0.171248123,
0.6518383026,
0.6530206203,
-0.3389620483,
-0.049061235,
0.1047851443,
-0.021050686,
-0.0164450631,
-0.3138550818,
0.8410440683,
0.308784306,
-0.0838258788,
-0.1458734572,
-0.2684091926,
0.3672481477,
-0.6467861533,
-0.1449711621,
-0.2286040187,
-0.1419709027,
-0.16751948,
-1.0575903654,
0.7070713043,
0.1065554097,
-0.2011206448,
-0.2830922902,
0.8994493484,
-0.3022315502,
-0.4222083092,
0.3478190899,
0.482616961,
-0.122075282,
-0.2545593083,
-0.495909512,
-0.0847725794,
0.1328718513,
-0.5775557756,
0.2616902292,
0.5409237742,
-0.0524225086,
0.7056359649,
1.2473932505,
-0.1544296294,
-0.0300300214,
0.0017812923,
0.7386085987,
-0.7973417044,
-0.3986214399,
-1.0682219267,
0.6217373013,
-0.5232141614,
-0.3445436656,
0.2898708582,
0.3495457172,
0.6260561347,
0.0055263434,
0.5837822556,
-0.1028539762,
-0.1970246136,
-0.8992916942,
0.6975453496,
-0.7995900512,
0.2598850727,
0.1710995585,
-0.5693538785,
-0.2449986637,
0.6816973686,
-0.2360662222,
-0.3180682361,
0.5384618044,
0.4213286042,
-0.0674788132,
0.3660692275,
0.4652490318,
0.1507012546,
0.3540655971,
0.3868454397,
1.3094091415,
-0.0737265944,
0.9820013046,
-0.2605091929,
-0.0160955675,
-0.3261466324,
-1.2086261511,
-0.9650688171,
-0.6724185944,
-0.2166270912,
-0.0755791366,
0.1044974774,
0.7364912033,
0.6725470424,
-0.7120862603,
0.1224514693,
-0.1222374588,
0.614813149,
-0.183780387,
-0.2386876494,
0.2209049314,
-0.3889685571,
-0.697050035,
0.5584267378,
0.444416672,
-0.1075436994,
0.2203684896,
0.2026955038,
-0.3584510982,
0.2428196669,
0.7001419663,
-0.197096765,
-0.6038483381,
-0.5669814348,
-0.2371447682,
-0.096158728,
0.2295894325,
0.9403612018,
-0.7178046703,
0.2549338043,
0.6695170403,
0.6388378143,
0.3653231859,
-0.061254248,
0.6522905231,
-0.940707624,
0.2348993868,
0.4843063951,
0.5269201994,
0.1616668552,
-0.6952424645,
0.8366291523,
0.5928063393,
-0.2344992459,
-0.7010151148,
0.5769227743,
-1.1843470335,
-0.0822500885,
1.1708935499,
-0.0257405397,
-0.0862639323,
-0.2210252881,
-0.0631263405,
0.0596695133,
-0.42059654,
0.5080977082,
0.8585948944,
-0.1639840901,
-0.213473469,
-0.677314043,
0.4256805182,
0.3246905506,
-0.7989236712,
0.0936018825,
0.5130203962,
0.0446172208,
0.221007809,
0.5307394862,
-0.3236748576,
0.4252343178,
-0.1780661643,
-0.0314329527,
-0.4428384006,
-0.1103279516,
-0.1496018469,
0.358092308,
-0.8851879239,
-0.0291344766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09732v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09732v1
|
Source Prompt: Coordinated Pre-training of Language Models on Diverse Corpora from Multiple Sources
| 2023-11-16T10:03:26 | 2023-11-16T10:03:26 |
Yipei Xu, Dakuan Lu, Jiaqing Liang, Xintao Wang, Yipeng Geng, Yingsi Xin, Hengkui Wu, Ken Chen, ruiji zhang, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Pre-trained language models (PLMs) have established the new paradigm in the
field of NLP. For more powerful PLMs, one of the most popular and successful
way is to continuously scale up sizes of the models and the pre-training
corpora. These large corpora are generally obtained by converging smaller ones
from multiple sources, they are thus growing increasingly diverse. However, the
side-effects of these colossal converged corpora remain understudied. In this
paper, we identify the disadvantage of heterogeneous corpora from multiple
sources for pre-training PLMs. Towards coordinated pre-training on diverse
corpora, we further propose source prompts (SP), which explicitly prompt the
model of the data source at the pre-training and fine-tuning stages. Results of
extensive experiments demonstrate that PLMs pre-trained with SP on diverse
corpora gain significant improvement in various downstream tasks.
|
[
-0.6678588986,
-0.3442359269,
0.5140820742,
0.4783478379,
-0.3107968569,
0.2394793928,
-0.5423452854,
-0.233701691,
-0.1066089571,
0.4609841704,
-0.7467444539,
-0.4682703018,
-0.7138847709,
0.586776197,
-0.1806209534,
1.0296396017,
-0.0395301916,
0.3477326632,
-0.0438285172,
-0.2147102207,
-0.7019854188,
-0.7281572223,
-0.3313481808,
0.1580419987,
0.6959755421,
0.4927983582,
0.6581794024,
0.2905451953,
0.3734344542,
0.3743462563,
0.2167274505,
0.3387277126,
-0.3125312626,
0.2461297512,
-0.3167812526,
-0.5351201296,
-0.0731177106,
0.3278850913,
0.8243428469,
1.1997971535,
0.0403765887,
0.2396601737,
0.2628254592,
0.3703482151,
-0.7623599172,
-0.3091392815,
-0.620171845,
0.070277907,
-0.3123308122,
-0.2812176049,
-0.5060349107,
-0.2729375958,
0.3420147002,
-0.6923388839,
0.2938687503,
0.0618984327,
0.6604366899,
0.3944270313,
-0.0994489267,
-0.3198956847,
-0.7231529355,
0.8228607178,
-0.4375692904,
0.3243626952,
0.1695065945,
0.2715772986,
0.1978043318,
-0.6828397512,
-0.4879662097,
-0.167167291,
-0.2420288622,
-0.0999329761,
0.0195690691,
-0.176591143,
0.2671621144,
0.1807596684,
-0.3466879129,
0.3819799721,
-0.2581661344,
-0.121066004,
0.1434503049,
0.0996404886,
0.327724129,
0.0930468291,
-0.3118031323,
-0.0952686369,
-0.8010933399,
-0.3075855076,
0.5134109259,
0.7616203427,
-0.2486926615,
0.4022656083,
-0.031842228,
0.9514282346,
0.137319386,
0.0256982017,
0.4424324334,
-0.8071634173,
-0.0050797537,
-0.0557364039,
0.7490234375,
-0.2459235191,
0.1891925037,
-0.0885398313,
0.0545261912,
0.1805439293,
0.216069296,
-0.5996261239,
-0.0504446179,
0.2127643079,
-0.3784477413,
0.0335795619,
-0.0221521053,
-0.6878132224,
-0.0866841599,
-0.660227716,
0.1639108956,
-0.3834078908,
-0.160865128,
0.068899028,
-0.0043118522,
-0.0155559396,
0.5057116747,
-0.90442276,
-0.0214213114,
0.4773170054,
0.6766453981,
-0.1371991038,
-0.6140463352,
-0.9684225917,
-0.0641367435,
-0.2439418584,
0.9796549678,
-0.7353973985,
-0.3225841224,
-0.0260653999,
-0.2076046467,
-0.1212353557,
-0.5464505553,
0.4502725601,
-0.2262135595,
0.6479091644,
-0.5037306547,
-0.3719625473,
0.3544270694,
0.1449653804,
-0.6169328094,
0.5767743587,
0.1224303991,
-1.0156490803,
0.3308311403,
-0.4860733449,
-0.3599787354,
0.183355093,
-0.3649327457,
-0.0982673988,
-0.0258760192,
0.4013881683,
0.4904527366,
-0.2003521174,
0.342762351,
-0.4688021839,
0.0459119268,
-0.0593875051,
-0.2867373526,
0.9496989846,
0.5492223501,
-0.06026081,
0.2595013082,
-0.8148424029,
-0.1701358706,
-0.2817620039,
-0.4383369982,
-0.5099183321,
-0.2015479803,
-0.2368721515,
0.4807489812,
0.3178082108,
-0.2583712637,
0.0120366095,
-0.1978963315,
0.0918907821,
0.7306589484,
-0.3655576706,
0.6026910543,
-0.3196543753,
0.747859478,
0.1053899974,
0.1204466447,
-0.3456112146,
-0.3199081719,
-0.3824550807,
-0.4018688202,
0.2900932431,
0.5066307187,
-0.8214510083,
0.5802747607,
-0.0669620112,
-0.3926670253,
-0.599657774,
0.3970327377,
0.258146435,
0.3540787101,
0.4291770756,
-0.1053442582,
-0.8224881291,
-0.6053429842,
-0.2855263948,
0.2201829851,
-0.229814738,
0.0378006324,
0.1921587437,
-0.2624376118,
1.012596488,
-0.2036984265,
-0.0667292327,
-0.299500674,
0.3010637462,
-0.068658106,
0.5818314552,
0.5345022678,
-0.7752915025,
-0.6956236362,
-0.4201676548,
-0.523142457,
-0.5154340267,
-0.1738842875,
-0.2477203012,
-0.0753866732,
0.666151762,
-0.6026665568,
-0.3263177872,
0.9760559797,
-0.1907568574,
0.8886879683,
-0.2029807419,
-0.1724667996,
-1.1011509895,
0.0570454113,
-0.2810298502,
0.0166613664,
-0.5468531847,
-0.1122994795,
-0.1256558895,
-0.2010298371,
-0.461476326,
0.3661033213,
-0.6400567889,
-0.1173924133,
0.0026661535,
0.1679976881,
-0.0040933853,
0.1526886225,
0.267617017,
0.716925025,
0.6966838837,
-0.7722599506,
0.2377809882,
0.3317944705,
-0.2390726209,
0.5177463293,
-0.4505904019,
-0.1007108018,
-0.1804691553,
0.2032833695,
-0.7426710725,
0.0150017748,
0.1726794541,
-0.1807147861,
0.3844236732,
0.2558287978,
-0.4276420474,
-0.3632340729,
-0.1535045356,
0.317350924,
0.1370434612,
-0.8083934784,
0.626899302,
0.1336653233,
-0.3260598183,
-0.7002817392,
-0.6171791553,
-0.1722749472,
-0.2617794275,
-0.5536459684,
0.2803914845,
-0.3554970026,
-0.1477270275,
-0.0712158233,
-0.0010283564,
0.1166410148,
0.0913599357,
0.0849027485,
0.3311970532,
-0.3407163322,
0.2935633361,
-0.1327345073,
-0.1173337549,
-0.0861424133,
-0.3913403749,
0.7871290445,
-0.2322046757,
-0.3435159028,
-0.1596438587,
0.5981222391,
0.2169033885,
-0.551505506,
0.8604297042,
0.5878118277,
0.0186733287,
-0.3307719231,
-0.5372593403,
-0.1141195744,
-0.4905879796,
0.1460929066,
-0.2732698619,
-1.1313768625,
0.4576890171,
-0.3876848221,
-0.0568711013,
0.4347129166,
0.6248252988,
0.0905801132,
0.9114720821,
0.7649852633,
0.0807263255,
0.7529845238,
0.116359137,
0.017469544,
-0.5077207088,
-0.1504625082,
-0.9878525734,
0.1582517326,
-0.7147192955,
-0.4343113899,
0.1076078564,
0.1683537513,
-0.3050933182,
0.2703121603,
-0.4359099567,
0.2807697654,
0.6876628399,
-0.2331539392,
0.2301157117,
0.0311059393,
-0.3409841359,
0.0336407572,
-1.0189951658,
-0.5540857911,
1.1134091616,
0.1796270162,
0.6177349687,
-0.1331744343,
0.7690493464,
-0.1978361607,
0.3280492127,
-0.2628253698,
0.3415693939,
-0.4408618808,
-0.6427079439,
-0.2737190127,
-0.6512169838,
-0.9371879697,
0.265081495,
-0.4163331687,
-0.3098624349,
0.3853927851,
0.2400939018,
-0.8645731211,
0.1351522654,
-0.9571875334,
0.9196842909,
-0.316736877,
-0.213263765,
-0.0473388024,
-0.8961150646,
0.2378998846,
-0.3957009017,
0.3920798004,
-0.0590885989,
0.019861225,
0.5804623961,
-0.5998919606,
0.7797762156,
-0.1040783599,
-0.0885221064,
0.1950549185,
-0.360067904,
0.3125176132,
0.0542712174,
0.1227789149,
0.1340942234,
-0.2990543246,
-0.43706128,
-0.2612162232,
0.4939971864,
-0.912288487,
-0.4344823062,
-0.2651028931,
-0.4963448942,
-0.5153510571,
0.2380957305,
0.7235703468,
0.3582918346,
-0.0640853122,
0.1230732724,
0.6259872317,
-0.6934205294,
0.3551489115,
0.5679078698,
-0.0425514914,
-0.22075212,
0.5807383657,
0.0136335921,
0.568872869,
0.428396672,
0.0499908291,
-0.1796336919,
-0.5838320851,
-0.1866647899,
0.2463468462,
-0.6522425413,
-0.1224242896,
-0.7774835229,
0.1472061872,
-0.568911612,
-0.2393168509,
-0.5399905443,
-0.0735672563,
-0.5750475526,
0.0561739206,
0.04087127,
0.4209557176,
-0.3367762268,
0.5999053121,
-1.0468751192,
0.3761607707,
0.441757977,
0.5750154853,
-0.349268049,
-0.3553788662,
-0.2867436707,
0.0136267524,
0.0829877555,
-0.7725453377,
0.3841560781,
0.0737881437,
0.7884546518,
0.345213145,
0.0325463824,
0.4454335272,
-0.6204679012,
0.6698493958,
0.4580740929,
-0.8953341842,
0.5396623015,
-0.2930458188,
0.6832460761,
0.8150318265,
0.8384010196,
-0.2180326879,
-0.4915225208,
-0.5352945328,
-0.6994090676,
0.8249382377,
-0.1490413994,
0.1063013747,
-0.0989656225,
-0.1416791975,
0.4861989021,
0.4606725872,
-0.5903571844,
-0.2217086256,
-0.5038850307,
-0.05537403,
-0.2882741094,
-0.2369046509,
-0.0762591138,
-0.1521240175,
0.4522379041,
0.0202452,
-0.0327201486,
-0.0328019671,
-0.2019857317,
-0.0687192678,
0.4462440312,
0.5056086183,
0.6477646232,
-0.158896476,
0.3808562756,
0.0347180963,
-0.3547742963,
0.0498221107,
0.3459759355,
0.0586209819,
0.2566783726,
0.4284186065,
1.0048503876,
0.1246194541,
-0.5515986085,
0.2757218778,
-0.0760771185,
0.0078564147,
-0.2221341729,
-0.1453141868,
0.0955063254,
0.0522044934,
0.3909376562,
0.3957645297,
-0.2481079102,
-0.5516347885,
0.1826147735,
0.2686864734,
0.1468638033,
-0.2063252926,
0.4480299354,
0.2964227498,
-0.0618841015,
0.5317679048,
-0.2984948158,
-0.4645924568,
0.3302992582,
0.4701141119,
0.4827128947,
-0.5658507943,
0.2978494465,
0.3970204294,
0.2103371173,
-0.3638758957,
0.0544052385,
0.0263664238,
-0.9768006206,
-0.788446784,
-0.7594290376,
-0.3193987906,
0.279407084,
-0.4093729258,
0.510966599,
-0.5829980969,
-0.0446420498,
0.1439186335,
-0.1472747475,
-0.8258729577,
0.1808467209,
0.4666873515,
0.7578231692,
-0.9125238061,
0.8951442838,
0.5402141809,
-0.4426113963,
-1.0768876076,
-0.2038175613,
-0.2750803232,
-0.4728070199,
0.8173753023,
0.2600566447,
0.0452670604,
0.0530865453,
-0.7172340751,
-0.9420770407,
0.4816224873,
0.7222313881,
-0.8299943805,
-0.1854112595,
0.2578025162,
0.5050932169,
-0.6820591688,
0.1046849564,
0.3445391059,
0.4428633451,
-0.1661537737,
-0.9173271656,
0.133865416,
-0.2107601613,
0.0274501778,
-0.0856985301,
-0.1923500448,
1.4212647676,
-0.1499808431,
-0.243435204,
-0.2403174043,
0.6217468977,
0.4728896022,
-0.1000552699,
0.7351887822,
0.283788383,
0.8400613666,
0.1367973536,
1.0844599009,
-0.1949056834,
-0.0269591771,
1.5980980396,
-0.2710556686,
0.5061591268,
0.3783091605,
-0.159027189,
0.6858768463,
0.6228318214,
-0.1053550541,
0.6242253184,
0.1367033869,
-0.2490347177,
-0.3657262325,
-0.0281354375,
-0.7572918534,
0.353915453,
0.432719022,
-0.2575708926,
-0.495105803,
0.4386286438,
-0.2145450115,
0.3309293389,
-0.2856548727,
0.3920928836,
0.1565915197,
-0.8616330028,
0.5680353642,
-0.2279428691,
1.0658284426,
-0.9114108682,
0.3392620683,
-0.1529637277,
-0.0301621165,
-0.229137361,
-0.2095046937,
0.4182032943,
0.0125124939,
-0.2788203061,
-0.5090222359,
0.5393335819,
-0.7082668543,
-0.2018126696,
0.4259773791,
0.6869865656,
-0.0066799112,
-0.2738427222,
-0.6188091636,
0.0445243306,
-0.1220922694,
-0.1803286225,
0.407269001,
0.5927093029,
-0.0374483839,
0.4600092769,
0.7648538947,
0.1495714188,
0.2815690637,
0.3249282241,
0.8215405941,
-0.2545543611,
-0.7446911335,
-0.6904033422,
0.2811433673,
-0.01610226,
-0.2672268152,
0.9402735233,
0.3390203416,
1.1068594456,
-0.2644873559,
0.9068338275,
0.0645035654,
0.8109816909,
-0.3709507883,
0.2907712758,
-0.3217627406,
0.4887533188,
-0.2916903496,
-0.7659583092,
-0.2891971767,
0.49364537,
-0.4259621203,
0.0940135494,
0.8836446404,
0.4419934452,
-0.043022804,
0.093507044,
0.005760598,
0.1106984988,
-0.0074168639,
0.3169719279,
0.995193541,
0.3719233871,
0.6305988431,
-0.2284522057,
-0.1225008443,
-0.1219244972,
-0.8863704205,
-0.8194780946,
-0.5534601212,
-0.2713403404,
-0.0599525236,
-0.191577509,
1.0522007942,
0.6769179702,
-0.9784997702,
-0.0708748996,
-0.2519912422,
0.0414102599,
0.0491115712,
-0.1138235629,
0.156579867,
-0.9633834958,
-0.6501547694,
0.3698796332,
-0.0485944189,
0.1843051761,
-0.3120969534,
-0.1312853396,
-0.4690230489,
-0.2854419351,
0.558452487,
0.2336902916,
-0.2316248417,
-0.0881754234,
-0.138718605,
-0.3307605982,
-0.0928091854,
1.0242042542,
-0.7844397426,
0.1725924015,
0.5808644295,
0.6614266634,
0.1842887253,
-0.0707202628,
0.8885682821,
-1.0261641741,
0.518517077,
0.2874686718,
0.2935433686,
0.6349166036,
-0.235517174,
0.2541661561,
0.252473563,
-0.3020678759,
-0.821844697,
0.2373081446,
-0.8388849497,
-0.7712638974,
1.1107745171,
-0.3119832873,
0.1221784055,
-0.2832351625,
-0.0600806102,
0.5443987846,
-0.0447933599,
0.3764242828,
0.6829038858,
0.2378477454,
0.0973907486,
-0.454847306,
0.7277395129,
0.7888528705,
-0.9062964916,
0.0180653986,
0.6060163379,
0.2253309488,
0.4799397588,
0.6874200702,
0.0879800767,
0.0067467415,
0.1416545361,
0.085499756,
-0.1097719893,
-0.5433157086,
-0.4227242172,
0.280207932,
-0.0462451205,
-0.0607804507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09731v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09731v2
|
Examining LLMs' Uncertainty Expression Towards Questions Outside Parametric Knowledge
| 2023-11-16T10:02:40 | 2024-02-16T17:30:41 |
Genglin Liu, Xingyao Wang, Lifan Yuan, Yangyi Chen, Hao Peng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Can large language models (LLMs) express their uncertainty in situations
where they lack sufficient parametric knowledge to generate reasonable
responses? This work aims to systematically investigate LLMs' behaviors in such
situations, emphasizing the trade-off between honesty and helpfulness. To
tackle the challenge of precisely determining LLMs' knowledge gaps, we
diagnostically create unanswerable questions containing non-existent concepts
or false premises, ensuring that they are outside the LLMs' vast training data.
By compiling a benchmark, UnknownBench, which consists of both unanswerable and
answerable questions, we quantitatively evaluate the LLMs' performance in
maintaining honesty while being helpful. Using a model-agnostic unified
confidence elicitation approach, we observe that most LLMs fail to consistently
refuse or express uncertainty towards questions outside their parametric
knowledge, although instruction fine-tuning and alignment techniques can
provide marginal enhancements. Moreover, LLMs' uncertainty expression does not
always stay consistent with the perceived confidence of their textual outputs.
|
[
-0.3771348894,
-0.78105551,
1.0798870325,
-0.0838371292,
-0.00299922,
-0.0552442111,
-0.2311560214,
-0.2734811902,
-0.2810534239,
0.1997348368,
-0.7208551764,
-0.4384415448,
-0.7703431249,
0.0764669403,
-0.3331746757,
0.6744334102,
-0.0846185833,
0.1428780854,
-0.4647805989,
-0.038151294,
-0.2343107611,
-0.4313678443,
-0.5442273021,
-0.2654464245,
0.4753981829,
0.4255285263,
0.8296493292,
0.4357024431,
0.433591783,
0.3060397804,
-0.0576420091,
0.1455559134,
-0.3321326077,
0.2507264912,
-0.2807723582,
-0.7553136945,
-0.1883608252,
0.0473418608,
0.5331130028,
0.7382460833,
-0.228703022,
0.4456251264,
0.2973632514,
0.4469599426,
-0.6395357847,
0.3700455427,
-0.9080396891,
-0.1414100677,
-0.0751495957,
0.0421694405,
-0.1359885931,
-0.4910564423,
-0.053287942,
-0.55960536,
0.0136690298,
-0.1078218967,
0.776186049,
0.4152179956,
-0.2520577312,
-0.4748069048,
-0.5219915509,
0.6266850829,
-0.866314292,
0.2151163667,
0.6922804117,
0.1113295853,
-0.2743906975,
-0.531308949,
-0.4958990812,
-0.1381986737,
-0.0539183207,
-0.1187021956,
-0.1247680485,
0.0553722382,
0.2068746239,
0.2611703575,
-0.2559947073,
0.0802432299,
-0.0025368945,
-0.2069768608,
0.5089612007,
0.2951782644,
-0.1802086532,
-0.1672754288,
-0.2636935711,
-0.1496067345,
-0.6136623621,
0.4242354333,
0.6157767773,
0.0564461648,
-0.0081073772,
0.7480434775,
-0.2528904974,
0.7862101793,
-0.0217383504,
-0.0739672109,
-0.2555561364,
-0.0800240338,
-0.2328837216,
-0.4410056472,
0.7495525479,
0.3731000423,
0.2352953404,
-0.124470979,
-0.4760356545,
-0.1054927781,
0.085042581,
-0.4548522234,
0.1030234918,
0.3514355123,
-0.1579821557,
-0.123693645,
0.1075425893,
-0.7829139233,
-0.553439796,
-0.1441188008,
0.5819278955,
-0.3217446506,
-0.1040951684,
0.0458430164,
-0.0375089943,
0.2746710479,
0.3964943588,
-0.465998143,
0.2736492455,
0.3875453174,
0.4126314819,
0.0718156323,
-0.1017745435,
-0.511854887,
0.2629235685,
-0.5560879111,
0.5304436088,
-0.6254850626,
-0.5196397901,
0.0101659233,
-0.130880177,
-0.0647100508,
-0.432195574,
0.6465139985,
-0.5345122218,
0.2341710478,
-0.5848295689,
-0.8038519025,
-0.0755287036,
0.491518259,
-0.3210426569,
0.9710459709,
0.2673075199,
-0.8521314263,
-0.1608337909,
-0.2783197165,
0.2753524482,
-0.1463584602,
-0.5754004717,
-0.1476338655,
0.2961427867,
0.2429551333,
0.5918763876,
-0.5033418536,
0.2902122736,
-0.4967035949,
-0.3753685057,
0.9439743757,
-0.7567104697,
0.4284804761,
-0.0750084966,
-0.3027144074,
-0.2405781895,
-0.6867961287,
0.389099896,
0.1124295741,
-0.2156000733,
-0.3381792009,
-0.1875968426,
-0.4747291505,
0.4566152692,
0.5634685755,
-0.4960327744,
0.1245942414,
-0.2892792225,
0.0939256176,
0.9935125709,
0.197458446,
0.1609153599,
-0.4966034293,
0.6685737371,
-0.1813478321,
0.2334515154,
0.3176187277,
-0.4918949902,
-0.9400647283,
0.3165709674,
0.2159693837,
0.4064268172,
-0.7987820506,
0.1332569569,
-0.2287681997,
-0.4641319215,
-0.6646038294,
0.4231469035,
0.5755928159,
0.7049747705,
0.2268729508,
0.1321852952,
-0.1916411072,
-0.9434275627,
-0.2872309089,
-0.4437265098,
-0.1560501605,
0.1896945387,
0.3908797503,
0.1888450533,
0.7870328426,
-0.3563178182,
0.0314471461,
-0.0163941048,
0.1748456806,
-0.0703080446,
0.2156199217,
0.1112888381,
-0.75272578,
-0.3237654269,
-0.1936695129,
-0.7780438066,
-0.030212488,
0.0039993403,
0.2340358198,
0.0693458468,
0.6072375774,
-0.8523014188,
0.4723718166,
0.6438826323,
-0.0759099647,
0.5304676294,
-0.2733170986,
0.1406394094,
-0.8611302972,
-0.0688804314,
-0.1984290034,
0.0039386512,
-0.3616193831,
0.1064340621,
0.0364368334,
0.2318555117,
-0.4583253264,
0.6100851893,
-0.6173408031,
-0.04617339,
-0.0961207747,
0.3443939388,
0.0311910436,
0.3200879097,
-0.0668390542,
0.8824244738,
0.5833328962,
-0.5887305737,
0.1933313161,
0.2585166693,
-0.3443010747,
0.7307718396,
-0.6509289742,
0.1804425269,
-0.0830969065,
0.0054853233,
-0.9907101393,
-0.4062565863,
0.3270902932,
-0.6717478633,
0.3054856658,
-0.2083021998,
-0.5587540269,
-0.3467344642,
-0.3478777409,
0.0746722072,
0.5826024413,
0.0143307606,
0.4255598783,
0.0310062245,
-0.3567649722,
-0.7724465728,
-0.8490642905,
-0.0444654264,
-0.3372010887,
-0.4675103128,
0.0476558879,
-0.2319963574,
-0.6287694573,
-0.0396281667,
-0.3319919109,
-0.2261143178,
0.1183965728,
0.29588902,
0.1708794236,
-0.1522545516,
0.3487103581,
0.032146804,
0.141332522,
0.3794337809,
-0.0170804337,
0.3808752,
-0.2774647772,
-0.7967281342,
-0.3121541739,
0.2176001817,
0.333340168,
0.0218960028,
0.9087418914,
0.5237699151,
-0.3049275875,
-0.0792165846,
-0.7462151647,
-0.21992746,
-0.537229836,
0.1850836277,
-0.3167040348,
-0.9216990471,
0.6892009974,
0.0582585968,
-0.1297386587,
0.2873463333,
0.4672854245,
-0.3068735003,
0.7967256308,
0.4757237732,
0.2977955341,
-0.1585160643,
0.0429648049,
0.0576459393,
-0.8345321417,
-0.3007512391,
-0.6701325178,
-0.064042978,
-0.5273951888,
-0.7022779584,
0.5406947732,
0.2497211695,
-0.1212838367,
-0.0269260313,
-0.128722921,
0.3876951039,
0.4101454914,
0.0813454315,
0.2416987568,
-0.4712395668,
-0.0892795101,
-0.0895153731,
-0.5575637221,
-0.7154291868,
1.0142225027,
0.4066531658,
0.941375196,
0.2030330151,
0.520328939,
-0.0281092785,
0.2072309256,
-0.5588812828,
0.5958912969,
0.4571609795,
-0.5575310588,
-0.5635117292,
-0.533839345,
-0.7450600863,
-0.0080772797,
-0.011668996,
-0.8091786504,
0.1140774563,
0.0876410156,
-0.4466804564,
0.4031600356,
-0.4827316999,
0.526907742,
-0.3079951406,
-0.2462072819,
0.2306002975,
-0.9707427025,
0.2705052197,
-0.3472526968,
0.4459240437,
-0.2394632399,
-0.4634014666,
0.4608766139,
-0.1403548419,
1.0304197073,
-0.1490688175,
-0.3970182836,
0.3792716265,
0.3824440837,
0.7573109865,
0.2510623932,
-0.3579671979,
-0.0274329036,
0.0676223561,
-0.4334920347,
-0.8639706969,
0.5064522624,
-0.6344923973,
-0.9751632214,
-0.22400859,
-0.8941964507,
-0.8832042813,
0.0393489748,
0.4267664552,
0.1087308228,
-0.0941298679,
0.1461272389,
0.9769955277,
-0.2650849521,
0.4131509066,
0.6691901088,
-0.0766250119,
0.0489558354,
0.5375461578,
0.149864316,
0.5337971449,
0.4743435681,
0.23737818,
-0.6315034628,
-0.6742830276,
-0.315985322,
0.192321524,
-0.8806403279,
-0.3716135919,
-0.32042858,
-0.2563994527,
-0.4487211108,
0.0675558969,
-0.2793751061,
-0.4518143833,
-0.3403778672,
-0.2310654372,
0.3056646585,
0.9046345949,
0.0197765119,
0.3138699234,
-0.8126048446,
0.0744700804,
0.509629786,
0.2078293413,
-0.224171266,
-0.81119138,
-0.0725567564,
0.3026044965,
-0.2508296669,
-0.9884896874,
0.1134390682,
-0.026496768,
0.7306690216,
0.3944666982,
0.4762293398,
0.5365422964,
-0.1465311795,
0.8678500056,
-0.1184871048,
-0.9771543741,
0.404569,
-0.5600210428,
0.1180214882,
0.5152575374,
0.6826433539,
-0.224773705,
-0.7585684657,
-0.6838695407,
-0.5782334208,
0.5373311639,
0.3276534975,
0.3093445301,
0.1524466574,
0.491694212,
0.0905034989,
0.5993355513,
-0.8524397612,
-0.3061355948,
0.1353972703,
-0.2702221572,
-0.0431660078,
-0.2090681344,
-0.3731235266,
-0.0583571158,
0.5184448957,
-0.2142572999,
0.3679758906,
0.1205793694,
0.0805801004,
-0.208989501,
0.6516002417,
0.5118499994,
0.9014168382,
-0.092120789,
0.1772309393,
0.2722674012,
0.0997025445,
0.167151168,
0.258751899,
0.0387104079,
-0.2055725455,
0.2341507226,
0.5462022424,
0.1471440345,
-0.8399412036,
0.772141993,
-0.1569972634,
-0.0792623833,
-0.310483247,
0.0949261785,
0.3857504427,
0.2397272438,
0.1952814013,
-0.1119749025,
-0.0400601104,
-0.3205345273,
0.0716976002,
0.6879689693,
-0.3803994358,
-0.1679998785,
0.4095472097,
-0.3089967668,
-0.1944136769,
0.4979699552,
-0.1747423112,
-0.2065108269,
0.4581519663,
0.2479638606,
0.4247944355,
-0.2872694433,
0.4753877819,
-0.2024588585,
0.5149019957,
0.1132194474,
0.2745967805,
0.0240670033,
-0.7035650611,
-0.1728863716,
-0.5541481376,
-0.6577206254,
0.4189083278,
-1.0286152363,
0.0494296439,
-0.4034400284,
-0.146370694,
-0.4119560719,
-0.2150882483,
-0.6783503294,
0.2593388855,
-0.1144283637,
0.8963794112,
-0.6757742167,
0.699288249,
0.748934567,
-0.5313079357,
-1.123857379,
0.3669494092,
-0.045629371,
-1.0628457069,
0.2955562174,
-0.0575566888,
-0.1393505633,
-0.1526474506,
-0.7142030001,
-0.8780403733,
0.9874998331,
0.6960667372,
-0.3537748754,
-0.3824496567,
0.5772433877,
0.5966905355,
0.0579403378,
0.1398447305,
0.3660919964,
0.62567693,
0.0320639536,
-0.7479208708,
0.0311833303,
0.0440720841,
-0.015842827,
0.0092169577,
-0.8954099417,
0.9524255991,
-0.0474704802,
0.1010801867,
0.3881420791,
0.622843504,
0.1436673701,
0.2811778784,
0.2240329534,
0.3555079401,
0.8833092451,
-0.1108871698,
0.9807289243,
-0.3709056973,
0.2506091595,
1.1488679647,
-0.1467875838,
0.8775060773,
0.6976079345,
-0.0899621472,
0.4717442393,
0.7171673775,
0.2324739397,
0.163286671,
0.3181285262,
-0.293401897,
-0.4662678242,
-0.1544760764,
-0.3374671042,
0.3760388494,
0.6945215464,
-0.2013464719,
-0.2821741104,
-0.1867562532,
0.0308088139,
0.254762888,
-0.3229452968,
0.5223072767,
0.2053193152,
-0.7662536502,
0.5294620395,
0.1733591706,
0.4716822803,
-0.8264696002,
0.0552382916,
-0.2878564894,
-0.0551595129,
0.0181862339,
-1.2224075794,
0.211514011,
-0.0921991915,
-0.0117677236,
-0.1027873009,
0.5474630594,
-0.3709164858,
-0.3354246914,
0.1285330802,
0.9101379514,
0.200003624,
-0.1141160652,
-0.8460496664,
0.063063845,
-0.0261113122,
-0.3180237412,
0.4813039899,
0.8341787457,
0.0768379122,
0.9060046673,
0.3099294305,
0.1499918252,
0.1141686887,
-0.3117131293,
0.7803732753,
-0.1288591921,
-0.0824620724,
-0.6361809373,
0.4600380063,
0.1283844858,
-0.4355480075,
0.9943516254,
0.0239545889,
0.8293190002,
-0.0736631081,
0.7453739643,
0.1245860532,
0.616120398,
-0.7203039527,
0.3829175532,
-0.524720788,
0.4218431413,
-0.3070293963,
-0.6502379179,
0.1772805452,
0.4752778113,
-0.4269798696,
0.2391528338,
0.5939735174,
0.7591237426,
0.0924133211,
0.0229219142,
0.6848106384,
0.2711323798,
-0.0011625488,
0.6217736602,
1.1510243416,
-0.25876683,
0.7450340986,
-0.3757176697,
0.1021515653,
0.3264616132,
-0.8257807493,
-0.7704578638,
-0.5585303903,
-0.0542062074,
-0.2567280233,
-0.0234505236,
0.6588025689,
0.3268775642,
-0.6223512292,
-0.1652583182,
-0.15056476,
0.1418736577,
0.1764103621,
-0.2457032949,
0.2612000108,
-0.4099347591,
-0.6883326173,
0.3170163333,
-0.0390462577,
0.3979807198,
-0.428848207,
0.0120959505,
0.0451417565,
0.4586639404,
0.0018333993,
0.1285157204,
-0.6232355833,
-0.3505571783,
0.2034888566,
-0.0335863717,
-0.132130295,
0.5047024488,
-0.3302677572,
0.0513995662,
0.0363974161,
0.8972828984,
-0.0087900758,
0.2431888431,
0.4925656617,
-1.1659531593,
-0.0928454772,
0.4232545197,
0.2238715738,
0.5247324705,
-0.5064342618,
0.1908643544,
0.0407726429,
-0.6711453795,
-0.764421761,
0.2790141404,
-0.5854068995,
-0.3095638752,
1.36282897,
-0.4909362197,
0.0378672332,
-0.2492298484,
0.0196550805,
0.0535759069,
-0.327916652,
0.7232475877,
1.2207341194,
-0.389939934,
-0.1215115115,
-0.6237183213,
0.4983401,
0.5041915178,
-0.884837091,
0.1011578962,
0.5473607183,
0.4294221699,
0.0276957527,
0.4649810791,
-0.0321254916,
0.0786193088,
-0.0744208395,
-0.3243937194,
0.0566214733,
-0.1593402922,
-0.3133421242,
0.2544645667,
0.5162807703,
-0.0174282752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09730v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09730v1
|
Aligning with Whom? Large Language Models Have Gender and Racial Biases in Subjective NLP Tasks
| 2023-11-16T10:02:24 | 2023-11-16T10:02:24 |
Huaman Sun, Jiaxin Pei, Minje Choi, David Jurgens
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Human perception of language depends on personal backgrounds like gender and
ethnicity. While existing studies have shown that large language models (LLMs)
hold values that are closer to certain societal groups, it is unclear whether
their prediction behaviors on subjective NLP tasks also exhibit a similar bias.
In this study, leveraging the POPQUORN dataset which contains annotations of
diverse demographic backgrounds, we conduct a series of experiments on four
popular LLMs to investigate their capability to understand group differences
and potential biases in their predictions for politeness and offensiveness. We
find that for both tasks, model predictions are closer to the labels from White
and female participants. We further explore prompting with the target
demographic labels and show that including the target demographic in the prompt
actually worsens the model's performance. More specifically, when being
prompted to respond from the perspective of "Black" and "Asian" individuals,
models show lower performance in predicting both overall scores as well as the
scores from corresponding groups. Our results suggest that LLMs hold gender and
racial biases for subjective NLP tasks and that demographic-infused prompts
alone may be insufficient to mitigate such effects. Code and data are available
at https://github.com/Jiaxin-Pei/LLM-Group-Bias.
|
[
-0.4017266929,
-0.3263355792,
0.3237105012,
0.3071827888,
0.1777871847,
-0.0262216218,
-0.3930060863,
-0.6338983774,
0.042759493,
0.4174022675,
-0.7367214561,
-0.2738315463,
-0.6450617909,
0.3050144911,
0.0039828359,
0.9551393986,
0.5491981506,
0.2226478308,
-0.2310756743,
-0.1286021024,
-0.664796114,
-0.8558887243,
-0.502248168,
-0.5025423169,
0.7214295268,
0.3335833549,
0.8163231015,
0.2541712821,
0.2647725046,
0.3033187985,
-0.2668633163,
-0.0929534063,
-0.4825922251,
0.2453052551,
-0.4032053351,
-0.4182733297,
-0.2523396015,
0.1367106885,
0.3252551556,
0.7875757217,
0.1005795747,
0.2160609365,
0.1145528778,
0.5370867848,
-0.5221982598,
-0.0683824271,
-0.8771314621,
0.1984192431,
-0.2605059743,
-0.0829430595,
-0.4269948006,
-0.3414451182,
0.3620971143,
-0.3769158721,
0.2111703008,
0.3033883274,
0.4820576906,
0.2749799788,
-0.5258859396,
-0.1412552446,
-0.4415515661,
0.9705559015,
-0.8239932656,
0.1508893222,
0.546595037,
-0.0870223865,
-0.0460721366,
0.0450373925,
-0.517124176,
-0.2909818888,
-0.1817558259,
0.0591414981,
-0.1478602588,
-0.1054602787,
0.6058555841,
0.093036294,
-0.582624495,
0.5673469305,
-0.5777034163,
-0.1965275109,
0.7021191716,
0.06502565,
0.378015846,
-0.4973274171,
-0.2543255985,
0.1947590262,
-0.5348404646,
0.1316329986,
0.5704381466,
0.6716573238,
-0.1708094478,
0.7387278676,
0.024350334,
0.6326836944,
0.4459394217,
-0.0030031886,
0.4748498201,
-0.0851000696,
0.0760060847,
0.2419295758,
0.9119650722,
0.7610744238,
0.8671664596,
0.0263873525,
0.0054840846,
0.1192281693,
0.1105826274,
-0.4866086543,
-0.0506416336,
0.119445473,
-0.4242093563,
-0.1424385011,
-0.1631856114,
-0.6947558522,
-0.6549193859,
-0.5066461563,
-0.0579641461,
-0.1131240949,
-0.4455519319,
-0.2263802588,
-0.1900645643,
0.0739215612,
0.230548203,
-1.281519413,
0.142997548,
0.8192924857,
0.6100347042,
-0.3782986104,
-0.2294907719,
-0.621252656,
-0.1425808221,
-0.1983964145,
0.5669845343,
-0.7939798832,
-0.4968132079,
-0.0270000696,
-0.1833653897,
0.1334345341,
-0.6761636138,
0.5967587829,
-0.2820902467,
0.5496466756,
-0.7910624743,
-0.239622578,
0.0378080271,
0.0449164212,
-0.5187966228,
0.9047515988,
0.0493821837,
-1.0648947954,
0.4296202064,
-0.6393286586,
-0.1268147081,
0.1869954765,
-0.3424993157,
-0.0392992981,
0.1650277525,
0.2577608526,
0.4773531854,
-0.1356655657,
0.2811038494,
-0.5907898545,
-0.2925169766,
0.4846014977,
-0.0352530852,
1.0788537264,
0.144070223,
-0.2825449407,
0.2408357114,
-0.1599246413,
-0.2859157622,
0.178961888,
-0.0434473716,
-0.6777191162,
-0.0097919023,
-0.0401079804,
0.540803194,
0.169794485,
-0.533533752,
0.1427648813,
-0.4492553771,
0.3236424029,
1.2685676813,
-0.4008190036,
0.512455523,
-0.4334643483,
0.6395127177,
-0.1928587556,
-0.0593451038,
0.1990800649,
-0.6141276956,
-0.1912772804,
-0.0118614621,
0.0437806211,
0.5474615097,
-0.468888104,
0.3719452024,
-0.2311941385,
-0.2235700637,
-0.2683419883,
0.1268723607,
0.2458251715,
0.6230931878,
0.06411504,
-0.1234359741,
-0.5339230299,
-1.1091766357,
-0.4631721079,
-0.5175153613,
-0.3066052496,
0.3577002883,
0.2415006608,
0.0844185725,
0.9705063105,
-0.3736793399,
-0.0383800119,
-0.0902729258,
-0.0233420581,
0.1831306964,
0.2745996118,
0.6119291186,
-0.703430593,
-0.4211514592,
-0.18814376,
-0.4199815392,
-0.7558979392,
0.2998047173,
-0.1937843859,
0.1027904078,
0.4756664932,
-0.3130661547,
0.033113163,
0.893882513,
-0.4629288912,
0.7684176564,
0.3966220915,
0.0556802824,
-1.1077262163,
-0.0694722831,
0.5798404217,
-0.1391885281,
-0.4983346164,
-0.2549796402,
-0.2544287145,
0.0018643856,
-0.4740701914,
0.7234654427,
-0.3053481281,
-0.1845048368,
-0.1157390326,
0.1595834196,
-0.1558321267,
0.355240345,
0.3174326122,
0.9059663415,
0.2733975351,
-0.6418677568,
0.0246971734,
0.4196297228,
-0.3048863411,
0.8019784689,
-0.7726386786,
0.2636799812,
-0.4434886873,
0.2246160507,
-0.9845633507,
-0.206040144,
0.2868218422,
-0.665691793,
-0.0436761566,
-0.0787666142,
-0.2936114669,
-0.4608857334,
-0.1349945813,
0.5487318039,
0.5975131392,
-0.3834397495,
0.6549864411,
0.4314695001,
-0.524384737,
-0.7499483824,
-0.8143276572,
-0.1441184729,
-0.6015455127,
-0.5737377405,
0.130683437,
-0.1074806228,
-0.6951780915,
-0.4975015819,
0.2241752297,
0.1548743993,
0.0291132387,
0.4609166682,
0.4376333058,
-0.0108645409,
0.3099632263,
-0.298624903,
0.2031162232,
0.3271838129,
-0.1081724465,
0.687881887,
0.0106658302,
-0.2577183247,
-0.3038984537,
0.2262381613,
0.3751249611,
-0.2751635313,
0.8119562268,
0.3519591689,
-0.166989401,
0.0007544147,
-0.6426867247,
-0.3479059041,
-0.5111755729,
0.4543153942,
-0.0211396702,
-1.1131170988,
0.5278384686,
0.2994887233,
0.3214621544,
0.3866035342,
0.7422379851,
-0.1582480669,
0.9988409877,
0.3632369041,
-0.2139860243,
0.6208828688,
0.2912796438,
0.0302366707,
-0.9621015191,
-0.2076492608,
-0.8893818259,
-0.4559086859,
-0.7780672312,
-0.1563166231,
0.1886122823,
-0.469730854,
-0.4260805547,
-0.0941985846,
-0.6645974517,
0.4307519794,
0.357786119,
-0.1460377425,
0.1345693469,
0.150085941,
0.0449325368,
-0.4559979141,
-0.5871350169,
-0.5089219213,
1.0482587814,
0.4497532845,
0.6747983098,
0.1861443073,
0.2331798524,
0.5005946755,
0.5281190872,
-0.7440607548,
0.5254119039,
-0.3062419295,
-1.0137281418,
-0.0206657723,
-0.5709583759,
-1.0141375065,
0.3166318536,
-0.2256231904,
-1.044498086,
0.2119642198,
0.2259515673,
-0.3056493104,
0.1705966741,
-0.6200481653,
0.6290880442,
-0.179128468,
-0.1169191375,
0.1937042326,
-0.563833952,
0.7076144814,
-0.2033301145,
0.3514176905,
-0.5346642733,
-0.0243569743,
0.8193046451,
-0.1224058717,
1.0610449314,
-0.2072313875,
-0.4289506078,
-0.1388460994,
-0.0141869783,
0.1350523084,
-0.2045649141,
-0.5692831874,
0.4679264724,
-0.310996592,
-0.2795558274,
-0.3312303126,
0.6811231971,
-0.8191270232,
-0.7421548963,
-0.5242350101,
-0.6243976951,
-0.2646454871,
-0.0868341923,
0.3964284062,
0.4149736762,
0.0239026342,
0.0515089966,
0.4404582977,
-0.2964878976,
0.1509725153,
0.3917022049,
-0.4316228628,
-0.0652613193,
0.4369702339,
-0.0389111675,
0.5948759913,
0.0428620391,
0.403837502,
-0.4899748266,
-0.2509796321,
-0.1505463421,
0.3469154835,
-0.7283822894,
0.1297986209,
-0.6482567787,
0.1385138929,
-0.5273608565,
-0.1173613966,
0.0142637528,
-0.3071551621,
-0.2555514276,
-0.0167145729,
0.2485183477,
0.6242318749,
0.0559173971,
0.3751114309,
-0.5335611701,
0.1471921355,
0.304254055,
0.007158123,
0.1857234091,
-0.8361077309,
0.2307109535,
0.1402626783,
-0.1152520999,
-0.8562979102,
0.1465794444,
-0.0824058726,
0.4296114743,
0.4215508997,
0.2349599302,
0.3323213756,
-0.502692461,
1.0451767445,
0.303319931,
-0.8377702832,
0.3255302012,
-0.5322636366,
0.5707828999,
0.5481018424,
0.4149544239,
-0.8844856024,
-0.6186664701,
-0.3050167859,
-0.45367378,
0.7493600845,
-0.0358937941,
0.4086366892,
-0.3123552203,
0.2946799695,
0.2630039155,
0.1163542047,
-1.0230312347,
-0.3815706074,
-0.1080887765,
-0.2367946059,
-0.0341035724,
-0.2266701758,
-0.0826616734,
0.0215049088,
0.438889116,
-0.1521870196,
0.0809072778,
0.0070007853,
0.2158478051,
-0.1875894368,
0.2989904583,
0.4918926656,
0.8702117801,
0.0015680721,
-0.139048174,
0.2623743415,
-0.2401397377,
0.2384061217,
-0.0569198057,
-0.1999733746,
-0.0086748824,
0.5075608492,
0.693472743,
-0.0369654447,
-0.5535445213,
0.3749896884,
-0.2247155756,
-0.1138770729,
-0.3357525468,
0.1727355123,
0.0965066105,
0.0234021861,
0.4454036057,
0.0528313369,
0.0330179706,
-0.6195083857,
-0.2553196549,
0.7025696039,
-0.2516839206,
-0.3365460932,
0.7010291219,
0.3994194269,
-0.4555141926,
0.6181204915,
0.0544570349,
-0.806411624,
0.5537372231,
0.3619205058,
0.6490716338,
-0.4716748297,
0.1671904027,
0.4246089458,
0.2226594836,
0.2657850683,
0.1042425185,
0.1482396871,
-1.0022608042,
-0.7361975908,
-0.4608960748,
-0.2779026031,
0.1132532805,
-0.6100493073,
0.2303229123,
-0.5035845041,
-0.50505656,
0.248562783,
-0.2243091762,
-0.6081672907,
0.1304427534,
0.5688723326,
0.6624317765,
-0.9315802455,
0.2126251906,
0.6965474486,
0.0071730223,
-0.8148342967,
0.2985208333,
0.4352288842,
-0.7187646627,
0.9990731478,
0.2815395892,
0.0308579616,
-0.4206981659,
-0.554335773,
-0.8339147568,
0.2927963436,
0.4292616248,
-0.6323571801,
-0.1790154576,
0.0540150777,
0.3762465417,
-0.3163003027,
0.4294573367,
0.2900763452,
0.5204950571,
0.1024736539,
-1.2432906628,
-0.0003882317,
-0.095887363,
0.104736954,
0.0074814269,
-0.7441915274,
0.8662550449,
-0.0798458159,
-0.0710859001,
-0.2237061411,
0.7393749356,
0.4975822866,
0.163598612,
0.8097162247,
0.0679706335,
0.8877879381,
-0.1424659938,
1.0721144676,
0.1100263968,
-0.2158750594,
1.1974232197,
-0.5469110608,
0.4172689021,
0.2924958766,
-0.2351382971,
0.5925447941,
0.7133069038,
0.1752097756,
0.1091697142,
0.2318851948,
-0.2186718881,
-0.0658197552,
-0.5229336619,
-0.4714782238,
0.6591364145,
0.3300872445,
-0.373329699,
0.2202102393,
-0.0913741961,
0.1503781825,
0.2361372262,
-0.5112782121,
0.7388902307,
0.1659035534,
-0.9985699058,
0.4342520535,
-0.0451903157,
1.0493732691,
-0.5855202079,
0.3487171531,
-0.0264174845,
-0.1974351257,
-0.4191716909,
-0.8694877028,
0.1836448908,
0.0691454783,
-0.4080518484,
-0.0612769872,
0.4641630352,
-0.517315805,
-0.4211326838,
0.217130661,
0.2895874679,
0.1285897046,
0.0195174944,
-0.7819558978,
0.0568703823,
0.3184721768,
0.0111375758,
0.3333641887,
0.3805153668,
-0.2459917814,
0.641520679,
0.7070379257,
0.1738051325,
-0.0061445753,
0.3195154667,
0.6101210713,
-0.4382843971,
-0.4281161129,
-1.1119215488,
0.4769340456,
-0.198903352,
-0.4580962062,
0.7866978049,
0.2919684947,
0.7418847084,
-0.0397399552,
0.8402338028,
0.1154803932,
0.5792952776,
-0.4255792201,
0.4319853783,
-0.4514072239,
0.0311023481,
-0.4702193141,
-1.2726558447,
0.0407171324,
0.6548765302,
-0.681661427,
0.5410618186,
0.3722866774,
0.6690755486,
0.2112689465,
0.1372913867,
0.1064889133,
0.1531929523,
0.3516125381,
0.486438036,
1.0113303661,
0.477404505,
0.1368476301,
-0.0563145354,
-0.1771122664,
-0.1148954108,
-1.0363725424,
-1.0866959095,
-0.3536793292,
-0.3358008862,
-0.3322477639,
-0.3480859995,
1.3152674437,
0.7130041122,
-0.6759241223,
-0.154317528,
0.4949122965,
0.0614750236,
0.0951633975,
-0.3057802916,
0.0640857816,
0.0094584078,
-1.0039967299,
-0.1185741052,
-0.0560574122,
-0.065448001,
-0.4561870694,
-0.0376626849,
0.00319509,
-0.0226513185,
0.5192862749,
0.1905044019,
-0.9557549357,
-0.2527427971,
-0.0328392908,
-0.0358596183,
0.0576219559,
0.6801703572,
-0.6060324907,
0.2293235809,
0.2689635158,
0.3178505599,
-0.1865416169,
0.5265479088,
0.7885909081,
-0.8317497969,
0.1729962826,
0.5541236997,
0.3331021369,
0.7848204374,
-0.7104696035,
0.2540676594,
-0.0028335785,
-0.742559731,
-0.6559813619,
0.2356202751,
-0.7799329758,
-0.1902708411,
1.3415739536,
0.2384487987,
-0.1774161458,
-0.1003788039,
-0.4303846657,
-0.098630257,
-0.776181519,
0.735389173,
1.023733139,
0.073457852,
-0.2113061547,
-0.6539596915,
0.4937587082,
0.7275152206,
-0.6119178534,
0.2210426331,
0.7798640728,
0.1874930859,
0.238680318,
0.6951400042,
0.1770948619,
0.2159212977,
-0.5843476057,
0.1121116355,
0.1337072849,
0.0817857981,
-0.3188586235,
-0.0110274041,
0.1484450698,
0.216810137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09724v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09724v2
|
OVM, Outcome-supervised Value Models for Planning in Mathematical Reasoning
| 2023-11-16T09:56:28 | 2024-04-01T13:50:51 |
Fei Yu, Anningzhe Gao, Benyou Wang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) often struggle with maintaining accuracy
throughout multiple multiple reasoning steps, especially in mathematical
reasoning where an error in earlier steps can propagate to subsequent ones and
it ultimately leading to an incorrect answer. To reduce error propagation,
guided decoding is employed to direct the LM decoding on a step-by-step basis.
We argue that in guided decoding, assessing the potential of an incomplete
reasoning path can be more advantageous than simply ensuring per-step
correctness, as the former approach leads towards a correct final answer. This
transforms the task into a $\textit{value estimation}$ problem in planning.
Inspired by the findings that $\textit{outcome supervision for guided
decoding essentially acts as a value model}$, we propose Outcome-supervised
Value Model (OVM) that employs outcome supervision for training a value model,
which prioritizes steps that lead to accurate conclusions. Furthermore, the OVM
eliminates the need for labor-intensive annotations of step-level correctness,
thereby significantly enhancing its scalability. Our experiments on two
multi-step mathematical reasoning datasets, GSM8K and Game of 24, demonstrate
the superior performance of the OVM model. Notably, in GSM8K, our
$\textbf{OVM-7B model achieves state-of-the-art results among LLMs up to 13B
parameters}$; especially it does not utilize GPT-4 or code execution. These
findings offer a novel perspective on the role of outcome supervision in
training value models for multi-step reasoning tasks and provide theoretical
justification for its advantage in value estimation for guided decoding.
|
[
-0.0062086205,
-0.614628911,
0.9572972059,
0.1662810594,
-0.1851971447,
-0.3841849566,
0.0245045424,
-0.1144883037,
-0.012555833,
0.855314374,
-0.5895220041,
-0.6933405399,
-0.718919754,
-0.1377545744,
-0.1903208196,
0.7091519237,
-0.4107133448,
0.44226107,
-0.3198227882,
0.015673222,
-0.5551143885,
-0.5019859076,
-0.7998036146,
-0.4932078421,
0.4563735723,
0.2124318033,
0.5489410162,
0.8532919288,
0.5586650372,
0.2454838604,
-0.2203939706,
0.3680102825,
-0.4042346179,
0.0496162362,
0.0724986345,
-0.7242333293,
-0.9051873684,
0.0427280702,
0.3940616548,
0.9382588863,
-0.3310969174,
-0.0123944534,
-0.1703698933,
0.688126266,
-0.7129197717,
0.7933478951,
-0.1926706135,
0.0566696376,
0.3072325885,
-0.3622500896,
-0.7521131635,
-0.572543025,
-0.1934246421,
-0.5282996297,
-0.331815064,
-0.2659632564,
0.2694602013,
0.469214201,
-0.3424327075,
-0.635083437,
-0.6958935857,
0.8755005598,
-0.6155320406,
0.2881513238,
0.5598027706,
0.3391270041,
-0.4785479903,
-0.37240237,
-0.0793986991,
0.1771755517,
0.0766637251,
0.4455263913,
0.2379661053,
0.4017980993,
0.6148027182,
-0.0432149768,
-0.1254617423,
-0.139496237,
-0.2495440543,
0.0362811014,
0.7134172916,
0.4401048124,
-0.2310450375,
-0.3225034177,
-0.0547580719,
-0.1147520542,
-0.6137503386,
0.5155088902,
0.3736653924,
0.3616741598,
0.3805644214,
0.742772162,
-0.4679371715,
0.9283597469,
-0.1804571599,
-0.5482286215,
-0.1192486435,
-0.4752852321,
-0.1832055151,
0.3830778599,
0.3580324054,
0.2742193341,
0.4176370203,
0.0716330707,
-0.2948729694,
0.2297999859,
0.277284652,
-0.9847297072,
-0.3083792627,
0.2372572571,
-0.4246346951,
-0.1710742563,
-0.0512365401,
-0.4992084503,
-0.0891503021,
-0.4272619486,
0.3687312901,
-0.645999074,
-0.0731378347,
0.8201717734,
0.1105351746,
0.1467185915,
0.6285960674,
-0.8396983743,
0.176723972,
0.8269006014,
0.6692302823,
0.0745731667,
-0.1055041999,
-1.0359643698,
-0.0010730897,
-0.8270787001,
0.6344216466,
-0.6181347966,
-0.5682793856,
0.0074549918,
-0.3615993261,
-0.0028528229,
-0.1728032678,
0.9136849642,
-0.6721164584,
-0.1208799258,
-0.3689336777,
-0.5415711403,
-0.4108092189,
0.2655878365,
-0.4683543742,
0.7614020705,
0.0108451201,
-0.3691644073,
0.8311932683,
-0.655366838,
-0.2723423839,
-0.0813346505,
-0.2599535882,
-0.5049095154,
0.2430021763,
0.4760171175,
0.4996465445,
0.0558321103,
0.3118193448,
-0.4413200617,
-0.5200396776,
0.0838521048,
-0.5434885025,
0.6379547715,
-0.1363188773,
-0.0648994371,
0.1620963514,
-0.9365880489,
0.3011416793,
0.0219209511,
-0.5666904449,
-0.5445283651,
0.5014498234,
-0.7525967956,
0.3264085054,
-0.025556339,
-0.2636734545,
0.4423970282,
-0.3672219813,
0.094842419,
0.7364035249,
-0.0573553368,
0.5591562986,
-0.1500039697,
0.4997596145,
-0.1479002088,
0.2613570094,
-0.5643251538,
-0.6876854897,
-0.6892388463,
-0.20252572,
0.0867871642,
0.4428180158,
-0.7117909193,
0.1714027524,
-0.2058878988,
-0.0663743243,
-0.4910343289,
-0.2523667216,
0.4712203145,
0.6527447104,
0.483640939,
0.1209895611,
-0.313953191,
-0.4608138204,
-0.288896203,
-0.1795289069,
0.1113296673,
0.1502029598,
0.4060183764,
0.0315163061,
0.8371210694,
-0.6922947764,
-0.310608536,
-0.1692866981,
0.2094122618,
0.5444140434,
0.0575723313,
0.1835234165,
-0.8928412199,
-0.2147778571,
-0.2614369094,
-0.9024805427,
-0.0909427553,
-0.1204998195,
-0.2360169888,
0.1123147905,
0.1837867051,
-0.378331095,
0.7764835954,
0.3670569062,
-0.4419516921,
0.4590004683,
-0.4444107115,
0.5060889125,
-0.8168191314,
-0.4642131925,
-0.0640004501,
-0.1641087383,
-0.533639729,
-0.1394118965,
0.2217438072,
0.4654120505,
-0.1840635538,
0.019581303,
-0.4632506669,
-0.2583259344,
-0.3271609545,
-0.0748305693,
-0.0671723038,
0.4660535157,
0.4864498973,
0.6475738883,
0.3942537606,
-0.6458306313,
0.5269556642,
0.2788958848,
-0.3059379756,
0.7912716269,
-0.4440864325,
-0.2288849652,
-0.0972196236,
0.133673653,
-0.7482149601,
-0.1098931655,
0.3211877048,
-0.5049892664,
0.0669985488,
-0.5910009742,
-0.3751796484,
-0.2523283362,
-0.0760836899,
0.3971104622,
0.6449708939,
-0.6869370937,
0.780546844,
0.1224743351,
-0.0462124571,
-0.5395357609,
-0.6302118897,
-0.2464125007,
-0.2328671664,
-0.6757529378,
-0.0627234653,
-0.0141589604,
-0.3311146796,
0.1488070786,
-0.1965811849,
-0.0368981995,
-0.1136560515,
0.504697144,
0.2872372866,
-0.1436895877,
-0.021691734,
0.1379102021,
-0.5810704827,
0.6046476364,
-0.5186262727,
0.2493215352,
0.0960094184,
-0.8822721243,
-0.0103489161,
0.381817162,
0.1374564916,
-0.2980698645,
0.7761067152,
0.0751236975,
-0.4736489952,
-0.2967202961,
-0.1761418581,
0.1050522849,
-0.3885451555,
0.2030345052,
-0.7201242447,
-0.53287673,
0.4370054603,
-0.2114087045,
0.066006422,
0.2353288084,
0.313359946,
0.0237295888,
1.3987652063,
0.3944459558,
0.4753937721,
0.2215632647,
-0.4045972228,
0.2565178275,
-0.7871102095,
-0.5760188699,
-0.2528396547,
0.065158695,
-0.2021240443,
-0.6578201056,
0.5048367977,
0.436455518,
0.0262302104,
0.0316651538,
-0.4438276291,
0.3138070703,
0.5665456653,
0.1845666319,
0.5060930252,
-0.168993324,
0.0309401937,
-0.0585913919,
-0.8413283825,
-0.5519139767,
1.2347714901,
0.1152896732,
0.9857639074,
-0.1118115038,
0.8235071898,
-0.1553127021,
0.1578850001,
-1.0413047075,
0.4052154422,
0.2113835961,
-0.0606363788,
-0.6067165732,
-0.7488238215,
-0.7119369507,
0.4091485739,
0.0464067012,
-0.6474391222,
0.0747336969,
0.2482068986,
-0.5510367751,
0.2771009207,
-0.4943397641,
0.7848373652,
-0.3877304494,
-0.2544153333,
-0.0432107598,
-0.1700532883,
0.5366947055,
-0.2113957256,
0.4483110905,
0.1241075099,
0.1343889385,
0.6925165653,
-0.5205734372,
0.4351621866,
-0.1819232255,
-0.1071282625,
0.3954842985,
0.1545951664,
0.7065343261,
0.3168295324,
-0.2244683206,
0.0069935555,
0.0168052819,
-0.4049764574,
-0.633861959,
0.6483523846,
-0.3957516849,
-0.5754029155,
-0.5870549083,
-0.6567476392,
-0.0598777495,
0.2288091183,
0.013968938,
0.6178458929,
0.1883505434,
-0.056031879,
0.908002615,
-0.0359901935,
0.4992484748,
0.3227508366,
-0.3349268138,
-0.3756544888,
0.5586115718,
0.2556317747,
0.5202246308,
0.4084649682,
0.0499660634,
-0.484154433,
-0.8503094316,
-0.3719668388,
-0.0213505421,
-1.0279327631,
-0.1340198815,
-0.5686029196,
-0.2544696331,
-0.1644632369,
-0.195188418,
-0.5634883046,
-0.1107985973,
-0.0702150017,
-0.2692769766,
0.4368578494,
0.9057688117,
-0.1154439524,
0.1723416001,
-0.5912887454,
0.3995865285,
0.154623419,
0.4764561951,
-0.2519080341,
-0.3780256808,
-0.3687670529,
0.3797461987,
0.0129639767,
-0.8204392791,
0.5124487877,
-0.3642537892,
0.5863882303,
0.3241637945,
0.2212815285,
0.9087023735,
-0.5762710571,
0.4560494125,
0.110410206,
-0.8228507638,
0.6938055754,
-0.1971744299,
0.3003180623,
0.1658623219,
0.1712842733,
-0.2712794244,
0.0677443817,
-0.4167749286,
-0.669347167,
1.0612409115,
0.1367342025,
-0.3340902627,
0.0280825961,
0.4336070716,
-0.0043019331,
0.2206984311,
-0.4559516907,
-0.0443925373,
-0.1746667624,
0.0253775083,
-0.094552733,
-0.5104081631,
-0.1526077837,
0.0222402178,
0.5159004331,
-0.3495355248,
0.1786168963,
0.1210469902,
0.1110868976,
-0.171206221,
0.0622443818,
0.553673327,
0.9150079489,
-0.3670198619,
0.1413918138,
0.2946161926,
-0.1179790348,
0.1463422477,
0.1031971574,
-0.0905089751,
-0.1186738238,
0.6562981606,
0.8056767583,
0.194394514,
-0.4081586599,
0.5573296547,
-0.0574535988,
-0.3230985701,
-0.397395432,
0.1461186111,
0.0709612444,
0.4244611263,
0.1897236556,
0.0236076917,
0.2599151134,
-0.2993772626,
0.1075929329,
0.2364176959,
-0.3267138898,
-0.0515692644,
0.6908901334,
-0.2232642323,
-0.3733930588,
0.6342864633,
-0.3227634728,
-0.4367180467,
0.79402107,
0.2012881935,
0.5646188259,
-0.1513236314,
0.179968819,
0.3758473992,
0.2116439342,
-0.5588226914,
0.5851585269,
0.0996382236,
-0.5619090199,
-1.0293233395,
-0.7329206467,
-0.3352137506,
-0.2109865993,
-0.9117411971,
0.3562842011,
-0.1268191785,
0.0720359385,
-0.3321708441,
-0.2652158737,
-0.4891732633,
0.4734349847,
-0.115667209,
0.8005609512,
-0.6047878265,
0.7902212143,
0.3863168955,
-0.4379142225,
-1.038004756,
-0.3330879211,
-0.1703294516,
-0.8455632925,
0.7578682899,
0.0231449306,
-0.3210254908,
-0.2357531488,
-0.060782019,
-0.9264014959,
1.1479878426,
0.2551403344,
-0.437998414,
-0.1414759606,
0.264899224,
0.3790335953,
-0.4286601841,
0.5289445519,
0.5721482635,
0.4466293156,
0.6234371662,
-0.6519340873,
-0.1133677438,
0.2889297009,
0.0129628275,
0.5687349439,
-0.2272441536,
0.8182635903,
-0.5028496385,
0.1572892368,
-0.0402289145,
0.4657981694,
0.352342248,
0.3983549178,
0.2818686664,
0.5031211376,
0.4715748727,
-0.3795948029,
1.1944510937,
-0.1051297188,
0.3155344427,
1.0101575851,
0.1007623971,
0.8062919974,
0.272808224,
-0.1995429248,
0.0048081768,
0.8141353726,
0.4092539549,
0.7730238438,
0.1594742239,
0.1101301014,
-0.7509840131,
0.2025607377,
-0.283520788,
0.4584721625,
0.50132972,
-0.3406652808,
-0.270070076,
-0.1972490102,
-0.1059010923,
0.2099688798,
-0.5935752988,
0.6208491325,
0.25704059,
-0.7012848258,
0.4995309114,
-0.0483205542,
0.1966025382,
-0.6711611152,
-0.4194971621,
-0.1444477141,
0.4247764647,
-0.2906675339,
-1.0486239195,
0.3906163871,
-0.2003338188,
-0.166115582,
-0.5617811084,
0.372154206,
-0.4586432576,
-0.6838874817,
0.5171567202,
0.3285133243,
0.0870181695,
-0.3104603589,
-0.3732078671,
0.104263477,
-0.1870842874,
-0.3363600075,
0.1355423033,
0.7298910022,
-0.1895669103,
0.7948979735,
0.5454719663,
0.2670933008,
0.1670375466,
0.0034561143,
0.8012419939,
-0.6788533926,
-0.5738764405,
-1.0662215948,
0.59553653,
-0.0346721448,
-0.1177943423,
0.7078938484,
0.5576481223,
0.957847774,
0.1130939424,
0.6673700809,
0.4752794206,
0.207424283,
-1.0261096954,
0.106925182,
-0.3434038162,
0.4303555191,
-0.3485524356,
-0.8412501812,
-0.4144226611,
0.8335359693,
-0.7724381685,
0.1760265529,
0.5643594861,
0.3405784667,
-0.0236504115,
-0.0120271146,
0.6079780459,
-0.1643926948,
0.5709771514,
1.0514490604,
0.9226886034,
-0.2988969684,
0.7784149647,
-0.1057118326,
-0.5435059071,
-0.203733176,
-0.9347566962,
-1.0388770103,
-0.160532549,
-0.1915335655,
-0.3881188035,
0.1415383965,
0.7026389837,
0.6750464439,
-0.6496295333,
-0.2498440892,
-0.2756795287,
0.2333269566,
-0.3899065256,
-0.0858029798,
0.3325220346,
-0.3052307069,
-0.7283533812,
0.3124725819,
0.6195679307,
-0.2696435153,
-0.1533790231,
-0.4351375103,
0.1077306718,
0.1751936525,
0.7214359045,
-0.2061734796,
-0.8290511966,
-0.2785883546,
0.072471112,
0.020355599,
0.1509488225,
0.5942408442,
-0.6743773818,
0.6922549605,
0.2700099051,
0.6750568748,
0.6792642474,
0.0144507084,
0.6343550086,
-0.0348800421,
-0.165865764,
0.1861682236,
0.6332185864,
0.0538454764,
-0.459688127,
0.6561408043,
0.1317629069,
-0.5153729916,
-0.6152691245,
0.3816261292,
-0.7212073803,
-0.1684772521,
1.29188025,
-0.4341115355,
-0.1722660959,
0.2305167615,
-0.460636735,
0.1928420365,
-0.462457329,
0.6269107461,
0.8646181226,
-0.5521646738,
-0.2895850539,
-0.696613133,
0.5592848063,
0.1704379469,
-0.8565385342,
-0.0570425838,
0.7244409919,
-0.0660944209,
0.0560935959,
0.6122655869,
0.0212576538,
0.2827301621,
0.214477852,
-0.1941759884,
-0.4030085504,
-0.5045747161,
-0.311925441,
0.3037549853,
0.1042062566,
-0.4995238185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09721v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09721v1
|
On Evaluating the Integration of Reasoning and Action in LLM Agents with Database Question Answering
| 2023-11-16T09:55:07 | 2023-11-16T09:55:07 |
Linyong Nan, Ellen Zhang, Weijin Zou, Yilun Zhao, Wenfei Zhou, Arman Cohan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study introduces a new long-form database question answering dataset
designed to evaluate how Large Language Models (LLMs) interact with a SQL
interpreter. The task necessitates LLMs to strategically generate multiple SQL
queries to retrieve sufficient data from a database, to reason with the
acquired context, and to synthesize them into a comprehensive analytical
narrative. Our findings highlight that this task poses great challenges even
for the state-of-the-art GPT-4 model. We propose and evaluate two interaction
strategies, and provide a fine-grained analysis of the individual stages within
the interaction. A key discovery is the identification of two primary
bottlenecks hindering effective interaction: the capacity for planning and the
ability to generate multiple SQL queries. To address the challenge of
accurately assessing answer quality, we introduce a multi-agent evaluation
framework that simulates the academic peer-review process, enhancing the
precision and reliability of our evaluations. This framework allows for a more
nuanced understanding of the strengths and limitations of current LLMs in
complex retrieval and reasoning tasks.
|
[
-0.4151301384,
-1.1272448301,
1.206889987,
-0.0631011575,
-0.1324830502,
0.014005661,
-0.2437119186,
-0.4641551673,
-0.0427664034,
0.5916205049,
-0.6498893499,
-0.28861323,
-0.2723519802,
0.2488995194,
-0.3610099256,
0.5965145826,
-0.2043786496,
0.1050331146,
-0.4797422886,
-0.1595125943,
-0.6370809078,
-0.693066597,
-0.6037695408,
-0.2727552652,
0.2898094952,
0.1780079603,
0.7910470366,
0.1910322458,
0.6042151451,
0.3975126147,
0.0601717271,
0.3117946982,
-0.5856148005,
0.3884135783,
-0.5303744674,
-0.3329904675,
-0.5248112679,
-0.0579664856,
0.5630614161,
0.7811207771,
-0.3154795468,
0.1023312137,
-0.1225394085,
0.4185207486,
-0.2644935846,
0.2890912294,
-0.5528997183,
-0.2246175706,
0.0594601557,
-0.00691811,
-0.4009539783,
-0.4234336913,
0.236094594,
-0.4144130349,
-0.1676609069,
-0.0265973452,
0.6968493462,
0.1746228486,
-0.4721558988,
-0.4458377957,
-0.7586802244,
0.5848109722,
-0.5487565994,
-0.0141256154,
0.1631080955,
0.4808756113,
-0.2708087265,
-0.599173665,
-0.7714229226,
-0.1081527472,
-0.1185646057,
-0.0650675595,
-0.1550248265,
0.1919474751,
0.1900069565,
0.0605396517,
-0.6097999215,
-0.1147022918,
-0.2245318741,
-0.0316649228,
0.7599622607,
0.5098420382,
0.2010174692,
-0.2473306805,
-0.170264259,
0.2272804379,
-0.4068726301,
-0.0503605604,
0.243958205,
0.2469633073,
0.3927896619,
0.7879816294,
-0.1044668108,
0.6942524314,
-0.1005486026,
0.2960265577,
-0.0571081452,
-0.8308379054,
-0.2012643963,
-0.3100699186,
0.9463917613,
0.4466747344,
0.3651764095,
-0.2630678117,
-0.2803361714,
-0.2555865943,
0.3156168759,
-0.6658492088,
0.3043984175,
0.7379738688,
-0.1274806559,
-0.0016218267,
-0.0899026841,
-0.8232295513,
-0.4065470397,
-0.504647851,
0.6891208291,
-0.4283625185,
-0.4444063902,
0.2493821383,
-0.0218630768,
0.6897609234,
0.5235478878,
-0.6006619334,
0.5510641932,
0.7668528557,
0.5592406392,
-0.3890524805,
-0.4035387933,
-0.5529916286,
0.3075864613,
-0.3937586248,
0.8875399232,
-0.5332211852,
-0.4020828605,
0.001622949,
0.1174301133,
-0.3344331682,
-0.529686749,
0.5291357636,
-0.633656621,
0.1466099769,
-0.4525944591,
-0.6155020595,
-0.1405448169,
0.5024229288,
-0.7193973064,
0.8670325875,
0.3160831332,
-0.3150523007,
0.1276097745,
-0.8062153459,
-0.2881661654,
0.160133034,
-0.3319855034,
-0.0262302812,
-0.0527719297,
0.1952495128,
0.4092592597,
-0.5958681703,
0.3232687712,
-0.2691806555,
-0.5666896105,
0.5267142653,
-0.1793651879,
0.5111150146,
-0.0052799312,
-0.203305155,
0.1989571601,
-0.460414052,
0.2835220397,
0.252519846,
-0.1800346524,
0.0222921837,
-0.0255285483,
-0.4517613053,
0.1948462278,
0.1800294966,
-0.2493208796,
0.393237561,
-0.2071427703,
0.4703819156,
0.6241403222,
0.3426354229,
0.3764913976,
-0.0857706144,
0.720102787,
-0.2121843845,
0.2452694178,
0.0014213328,
-0.1431609988,
-0.5403206944,
0.0888889655,
-0.0932924673,
0.4916759729,
-1.1035293341,
0.0809179768,
-0.3177792728,
-0.3915224969,
-0.4557275474,
0.109067589,
0.291189611,
0.2106120288,
0.5485001802,
-0.2059516162,
-0.1602715552,
-0.6576435566,
-0.2484314591,
-0.2094520777,
0.0849413946,
0.5072183013,
0.6690862179,
0.0107126618,
0.9698882699,
-0.209939748,
0.1473858505,
-0.6194939613,
-0.0597767197,
0.397326678,
0.2938054204,
0.4200872481,
-0.4324147999,
-0.3112847805,
-0.0401100069,
-1.0680023432,
0.1060412824,
-0.181432873,
-0.2948268056,
0.1276720315,
0.2898337543,
-1.1456682682,
0.2463990301,
0.1490938514,
-0.4122614563,
0.7981979251,
-0.0437709577,
0.4532626569,
-0.6093878746,
-0.0331849158,
-0.1353614181,
0.0678650737,
-0.8413302898,
0.1562391818,
-0.2069855779,
-0.2476318628,
-0.3630795181,
0.5469560623,
-0.6564873457,
-0.3156693876,
0.0205362439,
0.4567041099,
0.2337759286,
0.4196628928,
0.0710180327,
0.9080411792,
0.5347667336,
-0.4198074043,
0.686342299,
0.3619799614,
-0.2991988361,
0.8409445882,
-0.8192356229,
0.4295886159,
-0.1681749672,
0.1479244083,
-1.0196743011,
-0.3377243578,
0.2164204717,
-0.2881397605,
0.2056003958,
-0.3441040218,
-0.6344174147,
-0.3884808421,
-0.213983506,
0.229431048,
0.1362629086,
-0.2836948931,
0.9535601735,
0.2306617051,
-0.4292755425,
-0.6111120582,
-0.4863540232,
0.3276049495,
-0.2333214581,
-0.7378298044,
-0.083584778,
0.1136478558,
-0.4855701625,
-0.0839556381,
-0.2090957314,
-0.1634604931,
-0.0429757386,
-0.1444226801,
0.3422311246,
-0.2755098045,
0.1688145399,
0.197864905,
0.1275247335,
0.5193622112,
0.0744150504,
0.4852098227,
-0.2601772249,
-0.66389817,
-0.4517357945,
0.4125400484,
0.6425598264,
-0.4996160865,
0.8262593746,
0.2468922883,
-0.0885137171,
-0.0171812009,
-0.5854167342,
-0.1869854182,
-0.4233058095,
0.4562571347,
-0.6612255573,
-0.5850388408,
0.3906968832,
-0.0694241077,
0.0879644603,
0.2874458134,
0.471891433,
-0.0856542662,
0.871019423,
0.0448758975,
0.2898133695,
0.0733074695,
-0.3089969158,
0.1046711728,
-0.7650896907,
-0.2910173833,
-0.5146847963,
0.026364591,
-0.0491382964,
-0.7546597123,
0.2461461723,
0.1232062653,
-0.3147646785,
0.1700270176,
-0.3179051876,
0.649074614,
0.0538120009,
0.0662473664,
0.4437618256,
-0.2898426354,
0.0711898953,
0.2345063239,
-0.3981781006,
-0.7982856631,
1.0794421434,
0.258896172,
0.7633394003,
0.5380455256,
0.5237051845,
0.0557325743,
0.3032855093,
-0.6938159466,
0.8468157649,
0.3979769945,
-0.6554664373,
-0.6948755383,
-0.4531176388,
-0.9243873954,
0.6294164658,
-0.2094724923,
-0.7017879486,
0.0588975772,
-0.1981524229,
-0.2378543317,
-0.0906493142,
-0.8427893519,
1.1026319265,
-0.4890272319,
-0.7669485807,
-0.2075299472,
-0.6555326581,
0.3701076508,
-0.1134551689,
0.1755358428,
-0.1528705508,
-0.0956405625,
0.37696141,
-0.1996996254,
0.5143224001,
-0.3488990664,
-0.0494024977,
0.6333361864,
0.2236873507,
0.5339665413,
0.0366715379,
-0.5248025656,
-0.1097315699,
0.3397995234,
-0.4080498815,
-0.7683209777,
0.5136618018,
-0.6320191622,
-0.8160000443,
-0.4068968296,
-0.4083952308,
-0.4874739647,
0.1559679359,
-0.4733439982,
0.3306755424,
-0.3747745454,
0.0218700971,
0.4760543704,
-0.2001581341,
0.2256788909,
0.7503816485,
-0.255189687,
-0.1516925842,
0.7016434073,
0.0387949906,
0.4446957409,
0.0620562099,
-0.0943895057,
-0.60381037,
-0.7165609598,
-0.53113693,
0.4641667008,
-0.8550937176,
0.0806412771,
-0.5074632764,
-0.0841596946,
-0.1417271048,
0.2413311452,
-0.0451750979,
-0.2563497722,
-0.1277520061,
-0.1604290456,
0.1091424823,
0.8354403377,
0.4094257057,
0.1646723598,
-0.6879971027,
-0.0043605077,
0.4061288536,
0.2554372847,
0.098605983,
-0.2737959325,
-0.0915681571,
-0.2098491639,
-0.3535223007,
-1.2232544422,
0.0352508388,
0.0576512851,
0.8792783022,
-0.0498068072,
-0.0588573776,
0.4978718162,
-0.4917680919,
0.8931724429,
-0.1992257237,
-0.8890294433,
0.4348497093,
-0.3812022507,
0.1224414557,
0.659569025,
0.492534101,
-0.2212568521,
-0.359615922,
-0.3309022188,
-0.7292894125,
0.729545176,
0.323518008,
0.0379079469,
-0.0782496259,
0.6924829483,
-0.1034199521,
0.3898920715,
-0.587138474,
-0.0289607942,
-0.0504560359,
0.0245937631,
0.000738163,
-0.2308007777,
-0.2716663182,
-0.1816433221,
0.3702646494,
-0.262363255,
0.0780562237,
0.0465966798,
-0.3643413484,
0.0156617351,
0.5300806761,
0.271384567,
1.0292341709,
-0.1722016633,
-0.0842773914,
0.2382728904,
-0.0960084125,
0.0829425082,
0.3365232348,
0.2725662589,
-0.0754125193,
0.368460536,
0.5804674029,
-0.1671622843,
-0.8379354477,
0.5340897441,
-0.3480181098,
-0.2169571966,
-0.1553100199,
0.0413773954,
0.2901908457,
0.3719877005,
0.3995646238,
-0.460818857,
0.169391647,
-0.7295318246,
0.1428320408,
0.6794311404,
-0.2466238439,
-0.1695990115,
0.3504853547,
0.2905966341,
-0.1426208466,
0.7210862041,
-0.1663696319,
-0.451362282,
0.7478303909,
0.171366483,
0.5392425656,
-0.3357256651,
0.2105677277,
0.293046087,
0.4244625568,
0.0700673461,
0.5584003925,
0.1300652176,
-0.6925774813,
-0.8812999129,
-0.5004329085,
-0.7817886472,
0.0268705785,
-0.6208080649,
0.1554405987,
-0.0512224175,
-0.1629799306,
-0.0254233163,
0.1181266829,
-0.5748822093,
-0.1484522521,
-0.3387486339,
0.6443762183,
-0.6653357744,
0.7649842501,
0.6583943963,
-0.7736451626,
-0.8148534894,
-0.1547213644,
-0.0773330331,
-0.7478533983,
0.3707776368,
0.1839308441,
-0.0403931327,
-0.0444789603,
-0.4032320082,
-0.6560115814,
1.1389706135,
0.4295061529,
-0.2926104665,
-0.0898567215,
0.3314733803,
0.8318764567,
-0.2772268057,
0.6005703807,
1.0904225111,
0.6883128285,
0.1580186486,
-0.8956888318,
0.1785205603,
-0.0477729551,
-0.3216690123,
0.2772115469,
-0.481639117,
0.6569903493,
-0.2797513902,
-0.1677889079,
0.1713691056,
0.4665631056,
0.2614467144,
0.207535997,
0.4601666331,
0.1857096106,
0.696059227,
-0.2280640453,
1.1204360723,
-0.2222523838,
0.4315381646,
1.1305310726,
-0.7317626476,
0.6630553603,
0.5790319443,
-0.4402436018,
0.4112676084,
0.4973551631,
0.0124991899,
0.077613458,
0.3880920708,
-0.388130933,
-0.3152623177,
0.00475943,
-0.1438068151,
0.3191459477,
0.5759689212,
0.0812643468,
-0.2550464571,
-0.222919181,
-0.1240924448,
0.1254099607,
-0.1540490985,
0.9119986296,
-0.1202315912,
-0.877928853,
0.4355407059,
-0.2795180082,
-0.0655874312,
-0.5063579679,
-0.2355329096,
-0.3481771648,
0.0344786867,
-0.0775304437,
-1.2661496401,
0.2877222598,
0.0127981473,
0.1555518955,
-0.0091201961,
0.4303396642,
-0.5606567264,
-0.0563652217,
0.258942306,
0.9501016736,
0.4548287988,
-0.1521492451,
-0.882881701,
0.1756100506,
-0.2772351503,
-0.4980751276,
0.3768134117,
0.7953845263,
-0.0433111116,
0.7188172936,
0.5104942322,
-0.0617910214,
-0.2154005021,
0.2525954843,
0.9281814694,
-0.6010391712,
-0.0460451506,
-0.8115307093,
0.3428303897,
-0.1553757191,
0.133245185,
0.560618341,
0.4233329594,
0.2239060551,
0.0877728239,
0.6207721829,
-0.0399035364,
0.5882425308,
-0.5425137281,
0.3663814664,
-0.4331228137,
0.5733444095,
-0.2267917395,
-0.9364708066,
0.1157784164,
0.39672786,
-0.4631528556,
0.2192920893,
0.9791007042,
0.641227901,
0.1819663495,
-0.0818910003,
0.2559712827,
0.2775195241,
0.5936698318,
0.6229733825,
1.0894334316,
-0.156274572,
0.8531028032,
0.0806172639,
-0.1765723675,
0.0023298892,
-0.6830121875,
-0.9241192341,
-0.2598820329,
0.022853883,
-0.5295437574,
0.1859076321,
0.7602097392,
0.2386006415,
-0.628929019,
-0.5116141438,
0.0723153427,
0.3146351874,
-0.2044113278,
-0.2823261023,
0.4885039628,
-0.3464100659,
-0.7787007689,
0.4158407748,
0.2873537242,
-0.1322159916,
-0.4487402141,
-0.1138869748,
-0.3338122666,
0.2437686026,
0.6454375982,
0.0979369432,
-0.631850481,
-0.2931257486,
0.1234094352,
-0.1565521955,
-0.0390757062,
0.6869244576,
-0.5043616295,
0.4777247012,
0.2126847953,
0.8430038691,
0.5669084191,
0.3152322769,
0.676738739,
-0.3858597875,
-0.2998899817,
0.3500975966,
0.2875620723,
0.1515258849,
-0.2561360002,
0.7309272289,
-0.0304598622,
-0.7472670078,
-0.8446303606,
0.1798815131,
-0.9319680929,
-0.3984471858,
1.1954663992,
-0.1547476649,
-0.0579920523,
-0.3730297983,
-0.4092663825,
-0.1643041372,
-0.293171078,
0.3650760651,
1.0233246088,
-0.5803732872,
-0.3128675222,
-0.7110680938,
0.3389369845,
0.2558431327,
-1.1364045143,
0.1622789353,
0.8137461543,
0.2384165674,
0.018560702,
0.7157844305,
-0.1322961599,
0.3282422721,
-0.2246158123,
0.036288064,
0.0467528217,
-0.171325326,
-0.3859728575,
0.2065497935,
0.2498247474,
0.2753167748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09718v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09718v2
|
You don't need a personality test to know these models are unreliable: Assessing the Reliability of Large Language Models on Psychometric Instruments
| 2023-11-16T09:50:53 | 2024-04-01T20:51:03 |
Bangzhao Shu, Lechen Zhang, Minje Choi, Lavinia Dunagan, Lajanugen Logeswaran, Moontae Lee, Dallas Card, David Jurgens
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The versatility of Large Language Models (LLMs) on natural language
understanding tasks has made them popular for research in social sciences. To
properly understand the properties and innate personas of LLMs, researchers
have performed studies that involve using prompts in the form of questions that
ask LLMs about particular opinions. In this study, we take a cautionary step
back and examine whether the current format of prompting LLMs elicits responses
in a consistent and robust manner. We first construct a dataset that contains
693 questions encompassing 39 different instruments of persona measurement on
115 persona axes. Additionally, we design a set of prompts containing minor
variations and examine LLMs' capabilities to generate answers, as well as
prompt variations to examine their consistency with respect to content-level
variations such as switching the order of response options or negating the
statement. Our experiments on 17 different LLMs reveal that even simple
perturbations significantly downgrade a model's question-answering ability, and
that most LLMs have low negation consistency. Our results suggest that the
currently widespread practice of prompting is insufficient to accurately and
reliably capture model perceptions, and we therefore discuss potential
alternatives to improve these issues.
|
[
-0.414388448,
-0.9073868394,
1.1492910385,
0.4444527924,
-0.0416517965,
0.087966904,
-0.3144255877,
-0.2029285431,
0.0086314408,
0.4594069123,
-0.6775339246,
-0.1001224592,
-0.6242536902,
0.4270471931,
-0.3431414068,
0.7632445097,
0.0442477614,
0.2590382993,
-0.3535708487,
-0.1309925467,
-0.5927621722,
-0.3259527385,
-0.7841902375,
-0.4671987891,
0.9393514991,
0.4510999322,
0.6031394005,
0.1347624362,
0.3264698386,
0.2481675744,
-0.1432491243,
0.0357807577,
-0.3433059454,
0.4007056952,
-0.1935114115,
-0.4278544486,
-0.3812093735,
0.0990346968,
0.5367948413,
1.0082204342,
0.0206747502,
0.264421612,
0.2233595401,
0.4374988675,
-0.5185657144,
-0.0048668231,
-0.5288486481,
-0.2577491701,
-0.1790291816,
0.0678222179,
-0.8001083732,
-0.5301952362,
0.2685860991,
0.0127406782,
-0.1200813204,
-0.0203926358,
0.6138566136,
0.0684142932,
-0.5466378331,
-0.1975981891,
-0.7884058952,
0.7360475659,
-0.7566868663,
0.2432978004,
0.5933671594,
0.3947587013,
-0.1786937714,
-0.2646319866,
-0.6132805943,
-0.6593328714,
-0.0645859689,
0.0072065089,
0.01051737,
-0.1731721312,
0.2545430362,
0.0974089578,
-0.6917845607,
0.3260768354,
0.0072854101,
-0.1458545029,
0.4764326811,
0.3347158432,
0.3030741811,
-0.223473385,
-0.100918211,
-0.0658963844,
-0.8780761361,
0.1279515773,
0.5814216137,
0.2509031296,
-0.1849206239,
0.6151459813,
0.1606736779,
0.6952213049,
0.5659797788,
-0.2829173505,
0.0278969835,
-0.1826559007,
-0.0893585831,
-0.3397631347,
0.8195883632,
0.0919145346,
0.6239705086,
-0.1933327317,
-0.20659253,
-0.0295858588,
0.3353877366,
-0.5526310802,
-0.1825781018,
0.6367476583,
-0.2000204623,
-0.1470155269,
0.0002070932,
-0.7734815478,
-0.655374527,
-0.3258309364,
0.3874544203,
-0.5211978555,
-0.269290477,
-0.0310922526,
0.154294759,
0.4602232873,
0.4352518916,
-1.0911345482,
0.0561099276,
0.6387484074,
0.6653091908,
-0.1594432443,
-0.335393995,
-0.667068541,
-0.3940500617,
-0.4690571427,
0.9450362921,
-0.5337559581,
-0.4636616409,
-0.0235893074,
0.1716027111,
-0.0723508373,
-0.5269221067,
0.3785214126,
-0.2886465788,
0.2729336321,
-0.7890861034,
-0.529568553,
0.1799642295,
0.5014557242,
-0.383169651,
0.6842340827,
0.0252386536,
-0.6200543046,
0.2840279341,
-0.125779599,
-0.2390918732,
0.0233157668,
-0.2997558713,
-0.1272310317,
0.1243565008,
0.2095486522,
0.4719163477,
-0.0899991989,
0.4694949389,
-0.7188346386,
-0.2153000683,
0.749696672,
-0.5260572433,
0.8455126286,
-0.0823718384,
-0.2590849698,
-0.0102325585,
-0.5307595134,
-0.0257061962,
0.1776114255,
-0.156810239,
-0.0549437813,
-0.0359582976,
-0.1347230077,
0.0234557725,
0.1942661107,
-0.6625395417,
0.088183254,
-0.2936802208,
0.2672502995,
1.0076793432,
-0.0958604217,
0.3722968102,
-0.6816174984,
0.7062724829,
-0.1636568457,
-0.1346812546,
-0.3083844781,
-0.4202261865,
-0.5839881301,
-0.161104992,
0.0304518249,
0.3858125508,
-0.3416525126,
0.5803611279,
-0.0864218399,
-0.8309066296,
-0.233926937,
0.1102346852,
0.2562428415,
0.7194026709,
-0.0067010126,
-0.0676302537,
-0.4264017344,
-0.8229885101,
-0.4535572827,
-0.4513322711,
-0.1560943872,
0.35107252,
0.6047980189,
0.0474791639,
0.9081308246,
-0.1336350888,
0.4422072172,
-0.4970886409,
0.0969447792,
0.1818649024,
0.044471059,
0.5643220544,
-0.419977814,
-0.5515522957,
-0.5146481991,
-0.7521056533,
-0.3088695109,
-0.0676121414,
0.2552365065,
0.0993231907,
0.1663974971,
-0.6342380047,
-0.0732352808,
0.6358876228,
-0.3761809766,
0.8576505184,
0.0310948566,
0.0161372256,
-0.6396667957,
0.2533915937,
0.0365977772,
-0.275801748,
-0.579407692,
-0.0398132317,
0.1660354733,
0.1477709264,
-0.4098446369,
0.8611770272,
-0.174215138,
0.1411945075,
-0.2393712848,
0.1543253064,
0.1637744009,
0.0686738938,
-0.1636955738,
0.8069520593,
0.5024988651,
-0.7707314491,
0.2506790161,
0.4271974564,
-0.3616560102,
1.2577959299,
-0.9456066489,
0.5570339561,
-0.4994724393,
0.220231995,
-1.1913660765,
-0.5663437247,
0.2735927701,
-0.4634176791,
0.2196769416,
0.0070860335,
-0.3730904162,
-0.3405079842,
-0.2516742051,
-0.1133377254,
0.5358416438,
-0.613556385,
0.664888978,
0.0996727422,
-0.4408610463,
-0.4628078341,
-0.5959208608,
0.0941016674,
-0.3351976573,
-0.6355319619,
-0.245444119,
-0.5898728967,
-0.6797705889,
-0.3615095913,
-0.1421736032,
-0.0752112195,
0.1873396635,
0.1925640702,
0.355381012,
-0.1618299335,
0.1225622818,
-0.2428828925,
0.1333776265,
0.250236392,
0.064315699,
0.6472839713,
-0.0853427276,
-0.4402657151,
-0.4503277242,
0.2016519904,
0.7890222073,
-0.1473993361,
0.6393631697,
0.272955358,
-0.2452926636,
-0.0342913866,
-0.7721743584,
-0.4735046029,
-0.4767343402,
0.0778082982,
-0.2237599343,
-0.8349428177,
0.5514996648,
0.2973194122,
0.2073313892,
0.0189651102,
0.58150208,
-0.3916036785,
1.0719916821,
0.2114312798,
0.0854421705,
0.2387672514,
0.4382705688,
0.3276299834,
-0.7221736908,
-0.2626219392,
-0.6884258389,
-0.297154963,
-0.2447997928,
0.2312165946,
0.2686550617,
-0.3467011452,
-0.3946242929,
-0.0317089111,
-0.0363017954,
0.4488458633,
0.0779340789,
0.072981365,
0.2551136315,
-0.3387160897,
0.1401737332,
-0.3314065933,
-0.1619475037,
-0.9474215508,
1.1089944839,
0.3591068983,
0.9764838219,
0.2595365644,
0.4511063695,
-0.0022679723,
0.4417701066,
-0.8474400043,
0.6683139801,
0.158111617,
-0.6676170826,
-0.2236706764,
-0.3286171556,
-0.8147811294,
0.0910208002,
-0.0716934577,
-0.9564291239,
0.1739138365,
0.2206657976,
-0.6023399234,
0.1535758525,
-0.5964144468,
0.5836875439,
-0.3966712952,
-0.2334140539,
0.5525736213,
-0.4615387917,
0.5820385218,
-0.3748233318,
-0.1148408651,
-0.288105756,
0.1883652806,
0.6006194949,
-0.2635699213,
1.0260640383,
-0.0273860451,
-0.3027139902,
0.1375349313,
0.334946245,
0.6063403487,
0.2566999197,
-0.2183753997,
-0.3027312756,
0.1792731136,
-0.290130794,
-0.9277036786,
0.6163501143,
-0.5770247579,
-0.8176320791,
-0.3756928444,
-0.4400917292,
-0.5543197989,
0.1624550372,
0.2413796932,
0.465551585,
-0.2397565097,
0.254427731,
0.8859895468,
-0.1668227613,
0.1696122587,
0.6168091893,
-0.2482032478,
-0.089400664,
0.4053426981,
0.03817904,
0.5484909415,
-0.0984458178,
0.4333948493,
-0.426307857,
-0.442915678,
-0.3821861148,
0.4130762219,
-0.6251015067,
0.101725623,
-0.6156879663,
0.057534501,
-0.6136617064,
-0.1258020848,
-0.4253854752,
0.197174266,
-0.2282315046,
-0.2175733298,
0.2540013492,
1.0070743561,
0.1517640352,
0.1637263298,
-0.6305586696,
0.1558661014,
0.4020879269,
0.0696006715,
0.0981252193,
-0.7490800023,
0.3750571609,
0.0366374664,
-0.2045146376,
-1.2692285776,
0.2923199534,
-0.082100682,
0.4582222998,
0.4708169103,
0.1162440851,
0.4176816344,
-0.3587473333,
0.9706338644,
-0.092539221,
-0.9025897384,
0.4008039236,
-0.5410240889,
0.4399214387,
0.7932540178,
0.5129747987,
-0.6416267157,
-0.6686445475,
-0.5803966522,
-0.4750736356,
0.3802472353,
-0.1931835711,
0.4219643772,
-0.1755899787,
0.5938106775,
0.2761632204,
0.2157298923,
-0.6967839003,
-0.2057465762,
-0.0834469721,
-0.2695532143,
-0.1138033047,
-0.3504900038,
-0.0015641148,
-0.0611525588,
0.3359505534,
-0.1795278192,
0.0402186289,
0.3254265487,
0.2038781047,
-0.1102028415,
0.4903695285,
0.4355353713,
0.870382309,
-0.3258136809,
0.3435424566,
0.1324433386,
-0.3878312111,
0.4128320813,
-0.3704140484,
-0.3759926856,
-0.0186060239,
0.2743400335,
0.4816087186,
0.214593187,
-0.7383571863,
0.4296279252,
-0.1006696895,
-0.2903384864,
-0.5094496608,
0.059967909,
0.2884690762,
0.0417161211,
0.0743127689,
-0.1636082977,
-0.3017528057,
-0.7525009513,
0.0725867748,
0.6334648728,
-0.3010869324,
-0.5033165216,
0.5476285219,
0.0218983982,
-0.5576332211,
0.6335010529,
-0.2418869138,
-0.1972117424,
0.4886308312,
0.5806689858,
0.6587322354,
-0.3357572556,
0.5671577454,
0.2431670278,
0.390775919,
-0.3175668716,
0.4873017371,
0.3767812252,
-0.6702945232,
-0.4059895873,
-0.3867642581,
-0.8994023204,
0.6285857558,
-0.56882447,
0.1990210414,
-0.7858845592,
-0.2141022533,
-0.0781249404,
-0.1722760051,
-0.6358470917,
0.0498959832,
0.0578788929,
0.904026866,
-0.9191921949,
0.4768244624,
0.5692003369,
-0.38083148,
-1.0254729986,
0.1375578195,
0.2948205769,
-0.6037706733,
0.3839871883,
0.1569538862,
0.0931039825,
-0.1772021055,
-0.9320769906,
-0.776230514,
0.7397432923,
0.7314465642,
-0.533531785,
-0.0506672636,
-0.039940834,
0.4430235028,
-0.3160896301,
0.514950335,
0.609210372,
0.9332832098,
0.1727262437,
-0.9002343416,
0.0830037296,
0.021920573,
-0.286804378,
-0.2508477569,
-0.5170692205,
0.9134719372,
-0.2368227988,
-0.1319259703,
0.4279578626,
0.435331285,
0.6829525828,
0.1661626548,
0.487949878,
0.0494744368,
1.1567783356,
-0.1357251406,
1.1387357712,
-0.0112813888,
0.1031051651,
1.2749722004,
-0.7289688587,
0.875659883,
0.5741923451,
-0.0221257005,
0.6090296507,
0.6740897894,
-0.1970866323,
0.0857174918,
0.0211341493,
-0.1346856058,
-0.547269702,
-0.0742264912,
-0.0174016561,
0.4345907569,
0.1132677794,
-0.2249062955,
-0.0807506815,
0.0425726436,
0.2726434767,
0.2024604529,
0.1070560664,
0.3009343445,
0.28687796,
-1.0006431341,
0.3336681128,
-0.2921493649,
0.6299347878,
-0.7327308655,
0.3870706558,
-0.5116278529,
-0.0604269914,
-0.1034896076,
-0.8475758433,
0.2111767083,
0.0759375989,
-0.051925268,
-0.3459201753,
0.604072094,
-0.1865551174,
-0.370862186,
0.03404909,
0.8667376637,
0.1429137588,
-0.0607913211,
-0.4374920428,
0.0931405425,
-0.228980124,
-0.4000385702,
0.3404442966,
0.1054942682,
0.2583562434,
0.7804976702,
0.4850760996,
0.1305205077,
-0.2237518579,
-0.0002868211,
0.3795415461,
-0.4573960304,
-0.2016307265,
-1.0412395,
0.5656777024,
-0.0001350256,
-0.2757840753,
1.0797442198,
-0.074588649,
0.4763234258,
-0.0003735895,
0.8112290502,
0.1954671443,
0.4661650062,
-0.4804443717,
0.6874303222,
-0.3332359791,
0.222054556,
-0.1871156245,
-0.8429508209,
-0.1595324576,
0.6043367386,
-0.5659638643,
0.4368924499,
0.8206030726,
0.8206310272,
0.2258782238,
0.0959852785,
0.2773888707,
0.3949025571,
0.4648275375,
0.3848030269,
1.0330951214,
0.0965153873,
0.2388580441,
0.1134395823,
-0.1210437641,
-0.0157870818,
-0.8340421915,
-1.1076917648,
-0.3236021996,
-0.3659677505,
-0.6659678221,
-0.0573131926,
0.8226679564,
0.4401569664,
-0.5632677078,
-0.1312133819,
0.088314794,
0.2107999474,
0.0582363494,
-0.1874651611,
0.069461748,
-0.3481835425,
-0.7412121296,
0.4765646756,
0.2667244971,
0.1918587536,
-0.8466615677,
-0.0285456385,
0.0631072372,
0.4692667127,
0.2312260866,
0.3876063824,
-0.7672001123,
-0.7284439802,
0.5069161057,
-0.1705491096,
0.0354950912,
0.6589069366,
-0.5421771407,
0.2732408345,
0.5520799756,
0.4473531544,
-0.2722480595,
-0.1161137521,
0.6317792535,
-0.4761674106,
-0.2682870328,
0.3404302895,
0.4951272607,
0.6471416354,
-0.3332554102,
0.0965077132,
0.1591597646,
-0.6658272743,
-0.8026878238,
0.5378830433,
-0.9923995137,
0.0003757806,
1.4359949827,
-0.1516951621,
-0.4049251974,
-0.4415952265,
-0.1564857215,
-0.4637236893,
-0.2744178176,
0.7106505632,
1.0585643053,
-0.1701006889,
-0.3445906639,
-0.537063539,
0.1690961123,
0.6329063773,
-0.7326596379,
0.2013760209,
0.4043184519,
0.6074618101,
0.1164925024,
0.8360748291,
-0.0593503751,
0.0901536122,
-0.2475416809,
-0.4430443943,
0.2443835735,
-0.2924897373,
-0.5424316525,
0.0791653991,
0.4921681881,
0.3803019226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09712v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09712v1
|
Regularized Conventions: Equilibrium Computation as a Model of Pragmatic Reasoning
| 2023-11-16T09:42:36 | 2023-11-16T09:42:36 |
Athul Paul Jacob, Gabriele Farina, Jacob Andreas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present a model of pragmatic language understanding, where utterances are
produced and understood by searching for regularized equilibria of signaling
games. In this model (which we call ReCo, for Regularized Conventions),
speakers and listeners search for contextually appropriate utterance--meaning
mappings that are both close to game-theoretically optimal conventions and
close to a shared, ''default'' semantics. By characterizing pragmatic
communication as equilibrium search, we obtain principled sampling algorithms
and formal guarantees about the trade-off between communicative success and
naturalness. Across several datasets capturing real and idealized human
judgments about pragmatic implicatures, ReCo matches or improves upon
predictions made by best response and rational speech act models of language
understanding.
|
[
-0.5037047267,
-0.6206908822,
0.3335925937,
0.2530163527,
-0.3110123575,
-0.4230489433,
-0.6456788778,
-0.3857401907,
0.2558611631,
0.6404058933,
-0.4798253775,
-0.5240871906,
-0.3112177551,
0.2648865879,
-0.053554263,
0.6528707743,
0.0009665659,
-0.1131972373,
-0.1609909683,
0.0051999893,
-0.4820433855,
-0.3964666128,
-0.5843226314,
-0.6382234693,
0.2551977038,
0.7542360425,
0.8905618191,
0.8322580457,
0.5686733127,
0.3755699992,
-0.1858980209,
-0.1308197677,
-0.8942741156,
0.1834202856,
-0.1579188406,
-0.6215590835,
0.0841737911,
0.5043454766,
0.7698816061,
0.9572118521,
-1.0412012339,
-0.1479113549,
-0.0955590531,
0.4667697847,
-0.3907493353,
0.3463000059,
-0.841996789,
0.0309482142,
0.1907843202,
-0.3302155435,
-0.4795991778,
-0.3589830101,
0.476147145,
-1.1051502228,
0.3296031058,
0.0092815496,
1.2435417175,
0.0493826047,
-0.1528368145,
-0.3760437965,
-0.6227862835,
0.8716337085,
-0.446667552,
0.4232200384,
0.4976173639,
0.3308874369,
-0.4489124417,
-0.9377545714,
-0.549464345,
-0.3482839763,
-0.2758027017,
0.1227003336,
-0.1525988579,
0.7341079712,
0.0867321268,
0.2062271982,
-0.3015958369,
-0.1628601998,
-0.4320648015,
-0.0518128537,
0.6682617664,
-0.0439257659,
0.1893445849,
0.339522332,
-0.1651921719,
0.2285245359,
-0.3858289719,
0.1271505952,
0.152756989,
0.1303013712,
-0.0723481178,
0.0123252245,
-0.4340031445,
1.2979274988,
0.1422927529,
-0.1048686579,
-0.2338273078,
-0.4453778267,
-0.3243030012,
-0.0639436767,
0.4442261755,
0.674754262,
0.7602866888,
-0.3086929321,
-0.1959187984,
0.1286834627,
0.2348126918,
-0.4505153894,
-0.3934930563,
0.0118938033,
-0.4840719998,
-0.0607463121,
-0.0752932951,
-0.678491354,
-0.0231751073,
-0.9352257252,
-0.055898048,
-0.0165935624,
-0.1998526454,
0.4973585904,
-0.2968482375,
0.2524259984,
0.3587727249,
-0.7689241767,
0.6794013381,
0.7022271752,
0.7915715575,
0.1157969758,
-0.219052732,
-0.3539617658,
0.1279492825,
-0.6337205768,
0.8407667279,
-0.777251482,
-0.4001552463,
0.0407980345,
-0.157986477,
-0.1068864763,
-0.6154223084,
0.836797297,
-0.4718464017,
0.0459397398,
-0.1132794842,
-0.6080598235,
-0.2774819136,
0.0413410999,
-0.6608425379,
0.1809430569,
-0.4755482376,
-0.4654909372,
0.5024669766,
-0.5563881397,
-0.3912890255,
0.1672316939,
-0.131707564,
0.0875766799,
0.1208180934,
-0.4586458206,
0.0259640869,
-0.4825652838,
0.5516456962,
-0.1303504258,
-0.5793976188,
0.3215201795,
0.0218580067,
0.6576408148,
0.6786618829,
0.0017015501,
0.2457428426,
-0.5573662519,
-0.0562169068,
0.1631979346,
-0.4156402647,
-0.2072370201,
0.3421579599,
-0.41040048,
0.1174201071,
0.1195005924,
-0.3065852225,
-0.0510370098,
-0.5841468573,
0.7928800583,
0.5581403375,
0.0198623333,
0.7418584228,
-0.6934298873,
0.4255027771,
-0.207398802,
0.1374538541,
-0.0190110821,
-0.6140403152,
-0.5991151333,
-0.3308597803,
0.2952384651,
0.6764499545,
-0.2514502704,
0.1962141544,
-0.0927134976,
-0.3727046847,
-0.6455430388,
-0.2241321504,
0.2951339185,
0.6330789328,
-0.1291470677,
-0.2887006998,
-0.6060093641,
-1.0488808155,
-0.3841279745,
-0.0054630283,
0.1157492846,
0.40736866,
0.0335857309,
0.1116600931,
0.8902677894,
-0.3463739455,
-0.0343217403,
-0.1009435728,
0.639391005,
0.4233367741,
0.6135337949,
0.2767957151,
-0.8849815726,
-0.2956097126,
-0.076489538,
-0.3112063408,
-0.2782002389,
-0.3885778487,
-0.3143480122,
-0.2133719027,
0.3521074951,
-0.3783217371,
0.2808995247,
0.4185926318,
-0.0615983382,
0.1663077921,
-0.1889307499,
0.3746695518,
-0.5518965125,
0.1613769531,
0.1470555216,
-0.2179031819,
-0.9890162945,
0.28848809,
-0.396784991,
-0.2007318139,
-0.2490438074,
0.3427006006,
-0.5105500817,
0.00451328,
-0.1030348614,
0.6726637483,
0.0818640813,
0.2681929469,
0.5243271589,
0.8009300232,
0.5464308262,
-0.8430326581,
0.4345380962,
0.1492655277,
-0.2821215391,
0.5103735328,
-0.8547893167,
0.2003695816,
-0.4488650262,
0.2377717048,
-1.3335375786,
-0.2296636254,
0.1134861931,
-0.7283234,
0.2384183556,
-0.4987680316,
-0.1509651691,
0.0975314155,
-0.0461068749,
0.4351965189,
0.6123380661,
-0.1315157264,
0.2247711122,
0.867939949,
-0.219690755,
-0.6081596613,
-0.5697573423,
-0.0751616433,
0.0041297269,
-0.8294606805,
0.2193255872,
0.0216481499,
-0.6807177067,
-0.3450419605,
0.1558167785,
-0.4007062912,
0.1528823525,
-0.0734368339,
0.1063782275,
-0.0862288401,
-0.1680038571,
-0.2359253764,
-0.1299425215,
-0.0161544625,
-0.3309774101,
0.4816252887,
-0.056061063,
0.0055685905,
-0.7770879865,
0.4218358994,
0.2996143401,
-0.0200287923,
0.571256578,
-0.0209733099,
-0.5443530679,
0.2017723173,
-0.5637910962,
-0.386020571,
-0.4603252411,
-0.0794831142,
-0.4901553094,
-0.8649758697,
0.7417777777,
-0.0737709999,
0.4018834829,
0.1479478925,
0.5275254846,
0.1393725276,
1.0770316124,
0.4295241237,
0.4243023694,
0.5875991583,
0.0876489505,
0.188740775,
-0.1501846611,
-0.2552388012,
-0.8033904433,
-0.3179052472,
-0.7754119635,
-0.2744255066,
-0.1901661903,
0.1407485902,
-0.2233631462,
0.182905376,
-0.7340307832,
0.9072377682,
0.7120524049,
-0.2808825672,
0.2417820543,
-0.0278300215,
-0.2175622433,
-0.3339909315,
-0.9441117644,
-0.5421081185,
0.5004425645,
0.3024739921,
0.8628505468,
-0.041030623,
0.9317271709,
-0.0169103313,
0.4245859385,
-0.8850786686,
0.4149089158,
0.2952456176,
-0.6626112461,
-0.209777832,
-0.7434969544,
-1.2123949528,
0.3004708886,
-0.1464575827,
-0.8595225811,
0.7306722999,
0.2001803815,
-0.2396156639,
-0.1449373811,
-0.9055089355,
0.9503614902,
0.3603199124,
-0.3550192714,
-0.4867176116,
-0.7931295037,
0.5560616851,
0.4604689777,
0.4372056723,
-0.1652326584,
-0.151635468,
0.9915162921,
-0.0263719503,
0.7059797049,
0.0684038699,
0.1048757359,
0.708353281,
0.5408774614,
0.4464535415,
0.0982684568,
-0.0061182226,
0.1626660973,
0.358933717,
-0.5655357838,
-0.3013990223,
0.6198724508,
-0.6181243658,
-0.6258949041,
-0.564599812,
-0.5170633793,
0.0618221052,
0.2064060271,
0.291536361,
0.1168000624,
-0.2792213559,
0.0087558543,
0.6773406267,
0.0397263318,
-0.0841843262,
0.7269538641,
0.2763927281,
-0.295671463,
0.9139595628,
0.1258672327,
0.3692629933,
0.2042167783,
0.1009486988,
-0.3827363253,
-0.4094407856,
0.0777224973,
0.4240956008,
-0.9118318558,
-0.1902590841,
-0.121358566,
-0.0062445444,
-0.255235374,
-0.5161136985,
0.0051043401,
-0.274259001,
-0.3361775577,
-0.0734519809,
-0.0523624383,
0.7051957846,
-0.5684271455,
0.3247529268,
-0.6946586967,
0.3946341574,
0.2655205727,
0.4411131144,
-0.3070571423,
-0.6523429751,
0.0388161652,
0.3560956717,
-0.1724546105,
-1.119782567,
0.3344675004,
0.3169552982,
0.8070401549,
0.4092177153,
-0.0152686825,
0.667999506,
-0.4434340596,
0.5354840159,
0.3288514316,
-1.0259063244,
0.4406121075,
-0.4146858454,
-0.2285857648,
0.6318520904,
0.4024406374,
-0.9234804511,
-0.3619751632,
-0.8504737616,
-0.6102975011,
0.7743772864,
0.2314202935,
-0.0694827065,
-0.2253707498,
0.6308349967,
-0.3182705045,
0.3477816284,
-0.3615216613,
-0.0847362578,
0.0926133692,
-0.2084770054,
0.1568554789,
-0.3121936023,
-0.8954809308,
-0.1862711459,
0.0984169319,
0.099264048,
0.3688302338,
0.3773575127,
0.0775602907,
-0.4301943481,
0.2242445797,
0.9596912861,
1.0374704599,
-0.1385819614,
0.0836600363,
-0.173468098,
-0.3202845156,
0.1369746774,
0.1852827519,
-0.2557157874,
0.0523985289,
0.1999711096,
0.5018708706,
0.391435802,
-0.9169919491,
0.2555699646,
-0.3362244368,
-0.3218087256,
0.0168357715,
0.0071437401,
-0.02781092,
-0.1514082551,
0.0114192525,
-0.1231072843,
0.4963873923,
-0.6320621967,
0.719909668,
0.4202590883,
-0.0668453798,
-0.1517770588,
0.5336740613,
0.5050649047,
-0.4271064699,
0.547467351,
-0.3121885061,
-0.3910231888,
0.7095532417,
0.6175724864,
0.5708028674,
-0.1824008524,
0.1361647844,
0.5811318159,
0.3801138699,
-0.28159675,
0.4598129392,
-0.2141399533,
-0.9275874496,
-0.5716230869,
-0.3354992568,
-0.692404449,
-0.2435838133,
-0.7456288934,
0.2329033911,
-0.6530525684,
-0.1264800131,
0.0316738151,
0.0460375398,
-0.3751971424,
0.0528933369,
0.211803928,
0.9585151076,
-0.7306611538,
0.4119038284,
0.648625195,
-0.3556670845,
-0.7136662006,
-0.1284848601,
-0.0554315709,
-0.8958466053,
0.4255951941,
-0.1219358519,
-0.2795849144,
0.1783946604,
-0.9230379462,
-0.771301806,
0.709014833,
0.588129282,
-0.8304927349,
0.2587734461,
-0.5405729413,
0.3434220552,
-0.427827239,
0.1727790385,
1.0515687466,
0.5952280164,
0.3985330462,
-1.0615797043,
-0.1350724101,
-0.0628771484,
-0.241471231,
0.2918098569,
-0.4984933138,
0.6786275506,
-0.2708833516,
-0.6673476696,
0.0205805488,
0.6917814016,
0.3249254525,
0.4021344185,
0.3197768629,
0.5249733329,
0.7979483008,
-0.3581534624,
0.9548911452,
-0.6094253063,
0.4603639841,
0.8184574246,
-0.2057314366,
0.5280826092,
0.3283325136,
-0.1307347119,
0.2036507279,
0.8869758844,
0.5674638152,
0.3701761365,
0.6711053848,
-0.1204482839,
-0.3605712354,
-0.3900947571,
-0.0063202754,
0.1502922326,
0.6170151234,
0.0342787765,
-0.1687274873,
-0.6300349832,
0.016526727,
0.5235692263,
-0.229972139,
1.0013557673,
-0.0552429073,
-1.050478816,
1.1902351379,
0.1094708443,
0.4991359413,
-0.4527314305,
-0.2860284746,
-0.2383673042,
-0.2222374976,
-0.1745058149,
-0.9729279876,
0.2625932992,
-0.3218339384,
0.1247440279,
0.0375632904,
0.6036911607,
-0.7882291675,
0.1518181264,
-0.0027751408,
0.1281719208,
0.3563197851,
0.3421517313,
-0.8826920986,
0.0744517297,
-0.0601667166,
-0.0222916789,
0.1070354506,
0.5135953426,
0.2548125088,
0.6784557104,
0.6010049582,
0.2899665236,
0.1284051985,
0.0931415856,
0.5932864547,
-0.3667942882,
-0.7286713123,
-0.5199790597,
0.1259225905,
-0.2292113304,
-0.1867673993,
0.1883335263,
0.2014086097,
0.7721221447,
0.2441794425,
0.4272447526,
0.2039132565,
0.2553204298,
-0.4833111763,
0.3629668057,
-0.3311537802,
-0.2374531627,
0.1980545074,
-0.5081834197,
-0.4157405198,
1.3552883863,
-0.519076407,
-0.0365945958,
0.3788387179,
0.8046227098,
-0.0972101986,
0.2180046141,
0.302593708,
0.0401141904,
-0.0817900375,
0.6841323972,
0.7673882842,
0.1756914407,
0.4388583004,
-0.2177618146,
-0.6451585293,
-0.4603768289,
-0.7475950122,
-0.4539604187,
-0.7393921018,
-0.1916735023,
-0.3410946429,
0.0921271071,
1.0563738346,
0.7920274734,
-0.560306251,
-0.8062357306,
-0.5616917014,
0.4712028503,
-0.3203665614,
-0.2855676711,
-0.3740747571,
-0.7401325107,
-0.7956472039,
0.1155005619,
0.1456557214,
0.0460566543,
0.117124863,
-0.2592965961,
-0.4385233819,
0.6854991913,
0.1118565798,
0.7063016295,
-0.6486620903,
-0.0321220011,
-0.2223747373,
-0.1182836369,
0.1739611626,
1.3085303307,
-0.3652565777,
0.8040573597,
0.8835805655,
0.3397542834,
0.0209585372,
0.2185445279,
0.9820478559,
-0.4675011933,
0.7259597182,
0.5537224412,
0.329036206,
0.1076920107,
-0.3070669472,
0.4135073721,
0.3539474308,
-0.8229265809,
-0.937630415,
0.6694190502,
-0.7537823319,
-0.1386090219,
0.9245138764,
-0.3584267795,
-0.2689280212,
-0.2826604545,
-0.2565881014,
0.3003706634,
-0.6792779565,
0.7558882236,
0.885641098,
-0.2109529823,
-0.2161018699,
-0.561493814,
0.8389700055,
0.3363099694,
-0.3331961632,
0.2889735699,
0.6582393646,
0.1072636098,
0.2339340746,
0.8895267248,
0.1985386461,
0.4878050089,
-0.0648869723,
-0.0315119103,
0.3850144446,
-0.4143108428,
-0.3434033692,
-0.1150592789,
0.397138238,
-0.2561354339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09709v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09709v2
|
The Ups and Downs of Large Language Model Inference with Vocabulary Trimming by Language Heuristics
| 2023-11-16T09:35:50 | 2024-04-28T23:43:53 |
Nikolay Bogoychev, Pinzhen Chen, Barry Haddow, Alexandra Birch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Deploying large language models (LLMs) encounters challenges due to intensive
computational and memory requirements. Our research examines vocabulary
trimming (VT) inspired by restricting embedding entries to the language of
interest to bolster time and memory efficiency. While such modifications have
been proven effective in tasks like machine translation, tailoring them to LLMs
demands specific modifications given the diverse nature of LLM applications. We
apply two language heuristics to trim the full vocabulary - Unicode-based
script filtering and corpus-based selection - to different LLM families and
sizes. The methods are straightforward, interpretable, and easy to implement.
It is found that VT reduces the memory usage of small models by nearly 50% and
has an upper bound of 25% improvement in generation speed. Yet, we reveal the
limitations of these methods in that they do not perform consistently well for
each language with diminishing returns in larger models.
|
[
-0.3770884573,
-0.7359684706,
0.5183813572,
0.0641830936,
-0.1364607662,
0.3333560526,
-0.6448436975,
-0.1235045195,
0.0839682594,
0.703237772,
-0.4098068476,
-0.5282889605,
-0.3984348476,
-0.0452058129,
-0.3978461921,
0.352455616,
-0.0138528785,
-0.326584816,
-0.0628440678,
-0.0202674214,
-0.4581519961,
-0.5188658237,
-0.5602634549,
-0.1797608137,
0.5142697096,
0.4949550033,
0.7694147825,
1.1760030985,
0.3266092837,
0.2116951495,
-0.4071362615,
0.3425116241,
-0.5584033132,
0.1160401851,
-0.1014792174,
-0.4511485398,
-0.0256181359,
-0.3035029471,
0.8856047988,
0.825404048,
-0.2776451409,
-0.0430464298,
-0.0358340554,
0.3864251971,
-1.0965594053,
-0.1783136129,
-0.9074748755,
-0.150770694,
-0.2660028338,
-0.0124630304,
-0.4826154113,
0.2390934676,
0.0765485093,
-0.4575442374,
0.0598573349,
0.2337452024,
1.1486749649,
0.2427883595,
-0.2065725029,
-0.1031608731,
-0.7014728785,
1.2922375202,
-0.8206484914,
0.4538421035,
0.6200932264,
0.0845772699,
-0.0429189727,
-0.4406169951,
-0.1549583822,
-0.4503227174,
0.1894533783,
-0.2098299414,
-0.2626921237,
0.1352245063,
0.3187453747,
0.1971448511,
-0.2267383337,
0.6742358208,
-0.4330728054,
-0.3631623685,
0.4203229249,
0.0967678502,
0.2638531923,
-0.1221315637,
-0.1422939152,
0.1271189451,
-0.9411022067,
-0.5464342833,
0.4257470965,
0.378788203,
0.1418040842,
0.6160346866,
0.1727060825,
0.5819929838,
-0.5522654653,
-0.1144564152,
-0.3466605246,
-0.175103873,
-0.3580708504,
-0.3346737027,
0.530900538,
0.3206963539,
0.4756868184,
-0.1912622601,
-0.1955627799,
0.0695292279,
0.2287849188,
-0.7107016444,
0.036970403,
0.1148412973,
-0.2147207856,
0.0811750293,
-0.322435379,
-0.5852382779,
-0.1183939204,
-0.1068328544,
0.0609588809,
-0.8328617215,
-0.1383655965,
0.1674363464,
-0.211075753,
0.1659315228,
0.3255434036,
-0.8517751098,
0.3825987577,
0.8287059665,
0.9762061834,
-0.2669145763,
-0.1345824599,
-0.6719267964,
0.3861562312,
-0.4381782413,
0.5219825506,
-0.6807971597,
-0.6199336648,
0.1150070354,
-0.297070533,
-0.1925022751,
-0.7215822339,
0.2193244249,
-0.5444191098,
-0.2592743337,
-0.1154091358,
-0.8540543914,
-0.0578499623,
0.2098219097,
-0.6132478118,
0.7815207839,
0.1358688772,
-0.2342852354,
0.2703752816,
-0.0826306194,
-0.4635311365,
0.0795525312,
0.0710512474,
-0.2183165401,
0.4025062323,
0.2286909521,
0.4146254361,
-0.5044303536,
-0.090187557,
-0.437767148,
-0.3478613496,
0.0831546634,
-0.4252631664,
0.5776566863,
0.658192277,
0.1971528232,
0.1014381051,
-0.3925824165,
0.0140147004,
0.0717027709,
-0.4153212309,
-0.595210731,
0.0895176977,
0.1465298384,
-0.1455707997,
-0.007223119,
-0.4373189509,
0.3634978533,
-0.5312504172,
0.7962041497,
0.4992871284,
-0.1866610944,
0.5547686815,
-0.2874576151,
0.6770730615,
-0.1488817036,
-0.0636042655,
-0.1667108089,
-0.1070719436,
-0.7176992893,
-0.8236995935,
0.6391220689,
0.4193308055,
-0.7667430043,
0.3247421682,
-0.4071387351,
-0.1797455251,
-0.541061759,
0.487647295,
0.4054706991,
0.0788608491,
0.1834047288,
-0.1965868324,
-0.40114218,
-0.8953101635,
-0.2965733707,
-0.0535373241,
-0.1429842561,
0.1519230306,
0.4613730907,
0.0611959174,
0.766487956,
-0.6144867539,
-0.1876132935,
-0.5225144029,
-0.3971985281,
-0.05591131,
0.3227808475,
0.4526362121,
-0.4319317043,
-0.3643654287,
-0.1237084493,
-0.1607883722,
0.0338701233,
-0.1088370532,
0.0367356241,
0.3577174544,
0.7702301145,
-0.6342657208,
0.5796574354,
0.2842784524,
0.0472135507,
0.3921586275,
-0.481113255,
-0.3878183067,
-1.0612026453,
-0.252741158,
0.1766267717,
-0.3632121682,
-0.4367357194,
0.3202079833,
0.143019855,
0.2762821615,
-0.5864094496,
0.8197626472,
-0.8789231181,
-0.0375060067,
-0.2983738184,
0.0448629707,
0.0513690114,
0.0775853395,
0.0544919819,
0.6884183288,
0.3548462689,
-0.7082098126,
-0.0606494173,
0.0890441164,
-0.6092275381,
0.1145700291,
-0.3025815189,
-0.2125829905,
0.1023189276,
-0.0384732261,
-0.9350610375,
-0.2007844895,
-0.2072001249,
-0.0793810189,
0.5369131565,
-0.2212450355,
-0.6879478097,
-0.3587921858,
-0.3856441677,
0.1034326702,
0.9468417764,
-0.4650642276,
0.5068683624,
0.4294351339,
0.0964039341,
-0.4736680686,
-0.8015624881,
0.382612586,
-0.4709713459,
-0.4338766634,
0.5392149091,
0.1345143169,
-0.5262959003,
-0.0692016706,
-0.0472988039,
-0.1123284101,
0.3398830593,
-0.1599685848,
0.1728242487,
-0.2077283859,
0.2861418426,
0.1884777099,
0.0932100788,
-0.2840909362,
-0.184582293,
0.6831490993,
0.1091475487,
-0.4508651793,
-0.2253732979,
0.4186093509,
0.5104845166,
-0.2804160118,
0.8072605729,
0.5456480384,
-0.3723011911,
-0.5414659381,
-0.7024146318,
-0.2352573723,
-0.4204225242,
0.5505359173,
-0.4638374746,
-1.0492284298,
0.4730640054,
-0.2305006385,
0.3263292313,
0.3974127471,
0.6546404362,
0.0566807427,
0.87727952,
0.5272884369,
-0.1657744944,
0.6194299459,
-0.3727777004,
-0.0078314701,
-1.0077291727,
0.4055746794,
-0.6182543635,
-0.1320145428,
-0.4852653444,
-0.6037197113,
0.0921808183,
0.1479557902,
-0.1212238744,
0.3266787529,
-0.3415125012,
0.5666980147,
0.5998257995,
-0.0874991268,
0.2807813287,
0.395890981,
-0.1031241342,
0.0229529385,
-0.8815353513,
-0.4468704462,
0.9526196122,
0.4235218465,
0.884855628,
0.265953809,
0.5039916039,
0.041134458,
0.296701014,
-1.0772168636,
0.5700397491,
-0.499212414,
-0.6427514553,
-0.4059724808,
-0.4076458514,
-0.9891918898,
0.3932460248,
0.1099196076,
-1.0167118311,
-0.2800355256,
0.1013534442,
-0.4841074049,
0.576156497,
-0.7404145002,
0.2833145261,
0.0386134721,
-0.4930975139,
-0.5172328949,
-0.4665204287,
0.322019875,
-0.071435824,
0.1602454036,
-0.4286465943,
-0.4004878402,
0.4372080863,
-0.9032583833,
0.8868572116,
0.0579033419,
-0.1755752861,
0.4270839691,
0.2314211279,
0.2940742075,
-0.1694231331,
-0.4317296445,
0.2911423743,
0.2183451951,
-0.481843859,
-0.2788667381,
0.8251988888,
-0.5583344102,
-0.8906983733,
-0.0726853311,
-0.8189700842,
-0.2279365361,
0.0449207164,
0.2295242995,
0.1415219158,
-0.1039152965,
0.257482022,
0.5275352001,
-0.4932246506,
0.5929592848,
0.3162511587,
-0.3242438436,
-0.259431392,
0.931309104,
0.4817141593,
0.5476151109,
0.384049654,
0.2978663445,
-0.3223342597,
-0.8155853152,
-0.5827094316,
0.495575726,
-0.5190936327,
0.0738275275,
-0.4756591022,
-0.1205178201,
-0.4671458304,
-0.2266762555,
-0.374224335,
-0.4169312716,
-0.3961039484,
0.1428979486,
0.5236410499,
0.3895612061,
0.0730764866,
0.769638598,
-0.8138796687,
0.0641881302,
-0.1308245659,
0.1530036181,
0.0622211546,
-0.7256595492,
-0.2686777711,
-0.1587504745,
-0.1523490548,
-0.5647897124,
0.5999209881,
0.430793941,
0.2933487594,
0.2608525455,
-0.08572983,
0.7986088395,
-0.5066689849,
0.6513880491,
-0.0349199064,
-0.8650465608,
0.1367980987,
-0.3862498701,
0.5478891134,
0.3814151585,
0.0784027278,
-0.4586194158,
-0.2508983314,
-0.2499886155,
-1.0627403259,
0.5536361933,
0.1564957798,
0.3885631561,
-0.1198540777,
0.5515753627,
-0.0545360558,
0.0693566054,
0.0685932785,
-0.0708840415,
0.4807543159,
-0.2254727483,
-0.207698524,
-0.320928514,
0.1555276811,
-0.3099531829,
0.6760513783,
-0.1690855026,
-0.0431028232,
-0.1975311339,
-0.2921600342,
0.1507185698,
0.2547124028,
0.4954458177,
0.452062875,
0.0780742466,
-0.0141253611,
0.4219190776,
-0.3199846148,
-0.0463417806,
-0.234713167,
-0.2987571657,
0.03625945,
0.4208972454,
0.6971422434,
0.2251317054,
-0.858020246,
0.1261691004,
0.0674839914,
-0.2201511264,
-0.2748607695,
0.1842460036,
0.4320983291,
-0.0692335516,
-0.0250199363,
-0.4148485959,
-0.2291308194,
-0.3891355991,
0.0324760936,
0.6297357082,
-0.2141794711,
-0.0907426327,
0.4605605602,
-0.0662060827,
-0.323466748,
0.8718808889,
0.0866796374,
-0.2046856433,
0.7756980062,
0.4676024318,
0.7441779971,
-0.2661162913,
-0.1231916472,
0.1313548535,
0.4169504046,
-0.2503871024,
0.2241314054,
0.0098328916,
-0.7683614492,
-0.8041718006,
-0.7620528936,
-0.502355516,
0.2709851265,
-0.601780653,
0.3146275878,
-0.4649833739,
-0.2826852798,
0.0964909643,
-0.171741277,
-0.6333543658,
-0.1068807617,
0.2026633322,
1.2243235111,
-0.3556922078,
0.9464308619,
0.4496145546,
-0.1719994098,
-0.8234189153,
0.0977453813,
0.0714504868,
-0.9332728982,
0.4402735233,
0.1306013018,
-0.031895712,
0.2196341157,
-0.4396010637,
-0.9942070246,
0.5349801183,
0.5600231886,
-0.6868225336,
-0.2794598043,
0.0789065138,
0.358469218,
-0.2057596296,
0.1743417829,
0.7587000132,
0.5326863527,
0.2186946273,
-0.8686782718,
-0.0656505898,
0.1322957128,
0.4202311933,
0.3706313372,
-0.7407699823,
0.7325751185,
-0.2833139896,
-0.2090532035,
0.4093931019,
0.600431025,
0.2032986283,
-0.1282935143,
0.619556427,
0.5217241049,
0.6039830446,
-0.0214119144,
1.206191659,
-0.3658160567,
0.1257026792,
0.9140449166,
-0.6606760025,
0.8817996383,
0.7139747143,
-0.1035645455,
0.1057652012,
0.7429630756,
0.0280973185,
0.2498906702,
0.6704754233,
-0.3246774375,
-0.5544223189,
-0.3680818081,
0.0510151498,
0.6187486053,
0.9392230511,
-0.3283715844,
-0.3093580902,
0.1032499522,
0.3079205751,
-0.0786658004,
-0.2139014304,
0.5851882696,
0.3745212853,
-0.7759768367,
0.7296115756,
0.2790076733,
0.6516156197,
-0.5362116098,
0.1507595628,
0.0124932267,
0.3782480359,
0.1154061034,
-0.4623158574,
0.3874209225,
0.0703956261,
0.0712825134,
-0.2709405422,
0.6810542345,
-0.4722276926,
-0.426954031,
0.3743270636,
0.8209056854,
0.3515294492,
-0.1652299017,
-0.444319427,
0.2875742614,
-0.0382070504,
-0.500005126,
0.396507442,
0.185955435,
-0.4674399495,
0.8703769445,
0.6417254806,
0.3499018848,
-0.0202817451,
0.2131706029,
0.7107055783,
-0.6336455345,
-0.4190064073,
-1.1244117022,
0.0617727451,
0.0030701063,
-0.1194713116,
0.8279451728,
0.6084558368,
0.6418703198,
0.0145432185,
0.8602483869,
0.2375045717,
0.4023260474,
-0.5653274059,
0.7450475097,
-0.8223656416,
0.5927531719,
0.0771554783,
-0.7027611732,
-0.469886899,
0.1928191781,
-0.3707621396,
0.1172668189,
0.5506459475,
0.9129047394,
-0.0420161672,
-0.3412257135,
0.7556831837,
0.1997742504,
0.3737136424,
0.4558652639,
0.7900144458,
0.0428610556,
0.5803238153,
-0.2405016124,
-0.0200334042,
-0.4172676504,
-0.8544092178,
-0.9404281974,
-0.2893492281,
-0.3336665928,
-0.3133908808,
0.0088848695,
0.9421530366,
0.9168092012,
-0.559907198,
-0.3690147698,
0.0176507644,
0.3195437193,
-0.1859896183,
-0.1494525671,
0.3788363636,
-0.2110221982,
-0.8835191727,
0.5622279048,
0.3089646995,
-0.179436326,
-0.4610368013,
0.1286630183,
-0.236337468,
0.3107670546,
0.6187438965,
0.2989863455,
-1.0081564188,
-0.3019833863,
0.0760078207,
-0.123942025,
-0.0342578962,
0.6838026047,
-0.5716659427,
0.1792337745,
0.4253477752,
0.8028521538,
0.4946412742,
-0.2651072443,
0.5672172308,
-0.9525702596,
0.0858369023,
0.1267327964,
0.6021386385,
0.2811456919,
-0.184297353,
0.4187407792,
0.1065349579,
-0.1465547979,
-1.0069226027,
0.4265392721,
-0.7008089423,
-0.6268161535,
1.493241787,
-0.0634073019,
-0.694075346,
-0.2075252235,
-0.1415835172,
0.2710502446,
-0.3498257399,
0.502550602,
0.8636602759,
0.1608897299,
-0.0783369094,
-0.5561139584,
0.1896687597,
0.6588910818,
-0.5409937501,
0.3104357123,
0.4651857615,
0.4020514488,
-0.0268793553,
0.2833643556,
0.1857200116,
-0.0163411945,
-0.071813859,
0.1279720217,
-0.1704501957,
-0.1959755123,
-0.3080545664,
0.3365722597,
0.189242512,
-0.002535057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09708v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09708v1
|
A Self-enhancement Multitask Framework for Unsupervised Aspect Category Detection
| 2023-11-16T09:35:24 | 2023-11-16T09:35:24 |
Thi-Nhung Nguyen, Hoang Ngo, Kiem-Hieu Nguyen, Tuan-Dung Cao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Our work addresses the problem of unsupervised Aspect Category Detection
using a small set of seed words. Recent works have focused on learning
embedding spaces for seed words and sentences to establish similarities between
sentences and aspects. However, aspect representations are limited by the
quality of initial seed words, and model performances are compromised by noise.
To mitigate this limitation, we propose a simple framework that automatically
enhances the quality of initial seed words and selects high-quality sentences
for training instead of using the entire dataset. Our main concepts are to add
a number of seed words to the initial set and to treat the task of noise
resolution as a task of augmenting data for a low-resource task. In addition,
we jointly train Aspect Category Detection with Aspect Term Extraction and
Aspect Term Polarity to further enhance performance. This approach facilitates
shared representation learning, allowing Aspect Category Detection to benefit
from the additional guidance offered by other tasks. Extensive experiments
demonstrate that our framework surpasses strong baselines on standard datasets.
|
[
-0.4775063992,
-0.2698262334,
0.590821445,
0.4796926677,
-0.4829947352,
0.1954937428,
-0.0198291056,
-0.3245515823,
0.7400519252,
0.8098836541,
-0.707038641,
-0.3564591408,
-0.4133216739,
0.1312455088,
-0.3681796491,
0.9602180123,
0.1071527004,
-0.1761755198,
-0.5015407205,
-0.218801707,
-0.3337751627,
-0.515951395,
-0.3094965816,
-0.3056446314,
0.1910134256,
0.5721442103,
0.2755357325,
0.6887925267,
0.484821856,
0.311822772,
0.0288382042,
0.3705728352,
0.0749452636,
0.5340616107,
-0.2509026527,
-0.0708897933,
-0.5032305717,
-0.0914265439,
0.4472818971,
0.6322435141,
-0.0389226042,
0.1622317731,
0.4858089089,
0.9386107922,
-0.6316467524,
0.3560120165,
-0.2719552219,
0.1479644328,
-0.2875704765,
-0.2662695348,
0.0992072821,
0.397929877,
-0.1816038638,
-0.6805884242,
0.4882999957,
0.0881979167,
0.4482426047,
0.3561125398,
-0.1716887057,
-0.1535591334,
-0.4375780523,
0.6648948789,
-0.3230981827,
0.3973356783,
0.4619076848,
-0.3255201578,
-0.2470062971,
-0.3701943159,
-0.5205466151,
0.1060496569,
-0.3024286628,
0.1964610219,
-0.1895130575,
0.4213340282,
0.0049066097,
1.0596536398,
-0.4702836871,
-0.1131202504,
-0.1579259783,
-0.3891506493,
0.3541071117,
0.0402058512,
-0.0662313923,
-0.8007040024,
-0.0456018671,
-0.0950580761,
-0.346827209,
0.3143542707,
0.4988412857,
0.1696561277,
0.1181906462,
0.6268625855,
-0.6901968122,
0.4430938065,
0.3172125816,
0.0844886601,
0.4805355966,
-0.7630243301,
-0.0920648426,
-0.2111134529,
0.804947257,
0.1901168972,
-0.769970119,
-0.2305767685,
-0.2459840178,
-0.1005499363,
0.4944403768,
-0.6490921974,
-0.4501258135,
0.3977977633,
-0.5309661627,
-0.4694529176,
0.0318121761,
-0.755442977,
-0.5318368673,
-0.3229068816,
0.5751383305,
-0.4362391829,
-0.4258205593,
0.1131175384,
-0.0998480767,
-0.3194509447,
0.0455736443,
-0.757951498,
-0.158759743,
0.7775425911,
0.7864823937,
-0.1322088987,
-0.3711490333,
-0.521304369,
0.0281421226,
-0.4151639938,
1.0120643377,
-0.482110709,
-0.3543027639,
-0.3123701215,
0.3134628832,
0.3832834959,
-0.4462625086,
0.435901165,
-0.1041716486,
0.2263686657,
-0.2043423504,
-0.4387404919,
-0.4559153616,
0.1668488681,
-0.5437831283,
1.2167479992,
0.1707103997,
-0.6906968951,
0.7062707543,
-0.9582206607,
-0.6421533227,
0.0719879642,
-0.2393547446,
-0.5801155567,
0.4419013858,
0.665474534,
0.8309158683,
0.1630834341,
0.1932685971,
-0.3849755526,
0.1403448135,
-0.0244739149,
-0.152234897,
0.0700077564,
0.0780760497,
-0.1085222065,
0.6169083714,
-0.7340411544,
0.0442270674,
-0.269638747,
-0.2767319083,
-0.5301052332,
-0.2014194131,
-0.2887478173,
0.2192108482,
0.3551575243,
-0.7854811549,
0.2032439858,
-0.4606542885,
0.2519815266,
0.5772145987,
0.2041663378,
0.5234969854,
-0.3040601015,
0.4365228415,
0.5856761932,
0.2706084251,
-0.4748109281,
-0.1747339219,
-1.0248667002,
-0.3443187177,
0.0176633392,
-0.0276353024,
-1.0619021654,
0.9705646634,
-0.1474927366,
-0.1360607296,
-0.7751618624,
0.6932225227,
0.3831044436,
0.0642528608,
0.468028754,
-0.8741362691,
-0.6818276048,
-1.1082509756,
-0.1550424248,
0.0703763813,
-0.0028379802,
0.039532274,
0.3673551977,
0.2056013644,
0.9721415043,
-0.352941364,
-0.8564020991,
-0.3459617198,
0.5315668583,
0.3107292056,
0.6318846345,
0.2876242399,
-0.7093381286,
-0.1579020321,
-0.2785485089,
-0.7261250019,
0.1909823269,
-0.0555306077,
-0.0506922305,
-0.3119180501,
0.3623027205,
-0.0159528293,
0.3353054523,
0.7308971882,
-0.4748945534,
0.4558523297,
-0.3494601846,
0.3941545188,
-1.4606171846,
-0.3967873752,
0.1962738037,
-0.461602211,
-0.4869063795,
0.1142442301,
0.1543911397,
-0.0953597203,
-0.2723529637,
0.0643560812,
-0.6455662847,
-0.1331604868,
-0.8503605127,
-0.369146347,
0.3122858107,
0.6369583011,
0.1500335634,
1.0700114965,
0.856059134,
-0.6747587323,
0.1232328638,
0.067955561,
-0.2558267713,
0.7336466312,
-0.2374195755,
0.087159127,
-0.4011710584,
0.1499352008,
-0.5511340499,
-0.3911691606,
0.1302425116,
-0.3284052312,
0.2093487531,
-0.207701385,
-0.5950077176,
-0.5460878611,
-0.5790242553,
0.2182774842,
-0.0164372511,
-0.9134263992,
0.6023362279,
0.5352215767,
0.0962608084,
-0.3748054206,
-0.3924882412,
0.1131312549,
-0.1173254699,
-0.4123870134,
0.3868405223,
0.1743082702,
0.4986263812,
0.2198937088,
-0.1001075059,
-0.1970617771,
-0.0367788374,
0.6399555206,
-0.1803665459,
-0.1923965812,
0.3077188432,
0.3623487949,
-0.0163898598,
-0.0754467174,
-0.4768159688,
0.453522265,
-0.2176594585,
-0.3475011587,
-0.3627225161,
0.5275390148,
0.3199690878,
-0.3477338552,
0.5086884499,
0.7750841379,
-0.244408682,
0.1121200398,
-0.5823963881,
-0.2317516804,
-0.5283210278,
0.7221180797,
-0.5088242888,
-1.1433823109,
0.1558765024,
0.0374815725,
0.0318570621,
0.3644589186,
0.1677277684,
-0.2732986212,
0.8148709536,
0.9793021679,
-0.1138745025,
0.657351017,
-0.3233896792,
0.2197100818,
-1.5932245255,
-0.0949754342,
-0.0823409855,
-0.0656916499,
-0.376775682,
-0.7569290996,
0.3488434553,
0.4679357111,
0.0165325534,
0.5167832971,
-0.9804262519,
0.4836375713,
0.5661809444,
0.4768945277,
0.5510077477,
0.1659041047,
0.2294044048,
-0.2148471773,
-0.546670258,
-0.2573868036,
1.160908103,
0.3424506187,
0.5960181952,
0.154119432,
0.9301948547,
0.4024231732,
0.176213935,
-0.7472839355,
0.3295813203,
-0.5506093502,
-0.3914883733,
-0.2567557693,
-0.309917599,
-0.8103859425,
0.3548994064,
-0.2349415123,
-0.7600783706,
0.542842865,
0.344004482,
-0.6718617678,
0.3459790647,
-0.3567329347,
0.6829209924,
-0.1261005998,
-0.3936567605,
-0.4606231451,
-0.0755891502,
0.4178943336,
-0.1275597811,
0.3318739533,
-0.2077727467,
0.1920414567,
1.2010823488,
-0.1514935344,
0.8945115805,
-0.0338559262,
0.1809328198,
0.2023838013,
0.1523337513,
0.1633336395,
0.2233329415,
0.1729741096,
0.1980064958,
-0.04911533,
-0.3598196805,
-0.6115176082,
0.758801043,
-0.559922576,
-0.7136207223,
-0.3901758492,
-0.4668397605,
-0.2694788575,
0.1201606914,
0.0936289206,
0.3925348222,
0.1454645842,
0.2899903655,
0.2071928233,
0.0401858166,
0.561673224,
0.4608654082,
-0.506309092,
-0.6131113172,
1.267551899,
-0.1998451054,
-0.0702616051,
0.0652719513,
0.1974550933,
-0.4183662534,
-0.4855358303,
-0.3853831589,
0.0045292336,
-0.5440965295,
-0.3571699262,
-0.9803046584,
-0.1675191075,
-0.5639912486,
0.2824155092,
-0.6918269992,
-0.2959377468,
-0.2790214121,
0.0153278308,
0.5587292314,
1.0049923658,
-0.5646183491,
0.5254360437,
-0.6649286747,
0.3172690868,
0.3506779373,
0.4621355534,
-0.0028146268,
-0.5915418863,
-0.3723377883,
-0.1530645937,
-0.7541582584,
-0.566529274,
0.3694205284,
0.2714039683,
0.3469310701,
0.4998957217,
0.0010351478,
0.8201078176,
-0.0490115881,
0.8917858005,
0.5299013853,
-0.9519068003,
0.8583676219,
-0.0492430776,
0.1256754696,
0.6277154088,
0.0878874734,
-0.4171940088,
-0.5480613112,
-0.6802811027,
-0.7903001308,
0.69308424,
0.4343524277,
0.0970690995,
0.2742650807,
0.4748726189,
0.3332629204,
0.4762281179,
-0.8648209572,
-0.2236712277,
-0.5854004025,
-0.2011301666,
-0.053088896,
-0.3546290696,
0.019775141,
-0.4850360155,
0.6516049504,
-0.3869191408,
0.3224090934,
0.2826033533,
0.0182550941,
-0.0438763388,
0.549353838,
0.1015727147,
0.3170054555,
-0.0168208908,
0.2755685449,
-0.2591866255,
-0.4935703576,
0.3303619325,
0.0702354833,
0.109083876,
-0.1543185264,
0.4117931724,
0.7448250055,
0.2846809924,
0.0522659421,
0.6336119175,
0.0419818871,
0.0603037775,
-0.0459334292,
0.1885306835,
-0.310299933,
0.2762767375,
0.4013724029,
0.1627556831,
0.5171227455,
-0.5320912004,
0.4673796594,
0.4164478779,
-0.6710577011,
-0.3595059216,
0.2760665119,
0.3908777833,
-0.098600924,
0.0860353634,
-0.8723607063,
-0.768891573,
0.3828344047,
0.2404560298,
0.8470523953,
-0.0644002333,
0.4581126571,
0.3301472068,
0.2309324145,
-0.177028507,
0.3702898622,
-0.3228905499,
-0.7881705165,
-0.7077382803,
-0.9368681908,
-0.1521465927,
0.628844738,
-0.7263845205,
-0.0750438124,
-0.2332415134,
-0.0136503391,
-0.0304471944,
-0.1261676401,
-0.6055841446,
0.0802911073,
-0.2465988845,
0.1801097393,
-0.7462971807,
0.7555158138,
1.0516349077,
-0.4550847113,
-0.6414085627,
0.1951292902,
-0.0278326012,
-0.6284328699,
0.339243412,
0.4772577286,
0.1739804447,
-0.1373614222,
-0.1654971838,
-0.8982737064,
0.7252827883,
-0.1515350342,
-0.5726540685,
0.1642910242,
-0.0714026392,
0.3893680573,
-0.4911153018,
-0.0132537177,
0.3334828615,
0.1656952649,
0.0758241639,
-0.7849911451,
0.0260344371,
0.0929223821,
-0.1081752628,
0.2788960338,
-0.4229121208,
0.5942516327,
0.0109151946,
-0.1192308888,
-0.0543248393,
1.2648361921,
0.0365435444,
0.1351296008,
0.8973212838,
0.4598024487,
0.4021448195,
0.0055302344,
0.6435437202,
-0.5002915859,
0.601645112,
1.2635728121,
0.2168520838,
0.4710410535,
0.5246472955,
-0.2651367188,
0.3206276,
0.8534106612,
0.212974593,
0.6848011017,
-0.2358697802,
-0.203241691,
-0.8121279478,
-0.4164948165,
-0.1341532171,
0.5252637863,
0.3730323613,
-0.324939847,
-0.3313815594,
0.6486367583,
-0.4367766082,
0.0162200723,
-0.4588116407,
0.8963820934,
0.0916585252,
-0.5955761671,
-0.2007206827,
-0.2108938247,
1.1511214972,
-0.1458781213,
-0.1138407886,
-0.1993877143,
0.0262732524,
-0.4723989666,
-1.1762359142,
0.4551309645,
-0.2952730954,
-0.3371763229,
-0.180573985,
0.6618663073,
-0.4875741005,
-0.7446374893,
0.2419681251,
0.466434598,
0.1390281022,
-0.6022878885,
-0.6756883264,
-0.3607810438,
0.0274796598,
0.0276983697,
0.278314203,
0.4970621169,
0.2772610784,
0.4601368904,
0.7144654393,
0.2680296898,
-0.1705773622,
-0.0130855972,
1.0234848261,
-0.6289869547,
-0.96385324,
-0.4819863439,
0.2593649328,
-0.3626885414,
-0.3657312095,
0.6146615744,
0.5838139057,
0.6064335108,
0.089693144,
0.5899788141,
-0.1939136833,
0.501193583,
-0.6041668653,
0.5084972382,
-0.9115878344,
0.2793698907,
-0.2564109266,
-0.72585392,
-0.0670266151,
0.5814678073,
-0.0578164235,
-0.1762876064,
0.8760513067,
0.8625968695,
-0.3614534736,
0.1445616931,
0.5125598311,
-0.0137249548,
0.4339684248,
0.1473349184,
0.7044866085,
-0.2483109236,
0.2619590759,
-0.9695036411,
-0.434733808,
-0.0084834956,
-0.6785154939,
-0.8517856598,
-1.0593720675,
-0.5883698463,
-0.4021612406,
-0.0587465018,
0.9772687554,
1.0607374907,
-0.7694747448,
0.118665196,
-0.117496483,
0.0267084427,
-0.3993643522,
-0.2927815318,
0.4397516251,
-0.453307569,
-0.2312636375,
0.7178827524,
0.5924444199,
-0.0737621188,
-0.6506550908,
0.1396072358,
0.1374229938,
-0.3589929342,
0.6149787307,
0.1077221036,
-0.6543503404,
-0.5188558102,
-0.2644607425,
0.2551993728,
0.4013066292,
1.2024050951,
-0.5551347733,
0.632175684,
0.1365622282,
0.3868052065,
0.3797114491,
0.0907165855,
0.3130117655,
-1.239861846,
0.2688494623,
0.1512194276,
0.4169793725,
0.412201196,
-0.8675630689,
0.3286110163,
0.2464502603,
-0.3806512356,
-0.4411979616,
0.2437676638,
-0.7861614227,
-0.2652102113,
0.9047884345,
-0.1270470917,
-0.3494600058,
-0.4812117517,
0.0514877662,
0.0088921059,
-0.7566236854,
0.8661763668,
0.6454724073,
-0.7499321699,
-0.2831836939,
-0.070968315,
0.5922881365,
0.4949916601,
-0.859685719,
0.1328759491,
0.2644423842,
0.2745098174,
0.5585074425,
0.6206154227,
0.1059476733,
0.2084851861,
-0.3916460872,
0.4710992575,
-0.3407330513,
-0.4179207981,
-0.4974494278,
0.1867010295,
0.0161295421,
-0.6856408715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09707v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09707v1
|
GenCodeSearchNet: A Benchmark Test Suite for Evaluating Generalization in Programming Language Understanding
| 2023-11-16T09:35:00 | 2023-11-16T09:35:00 |
Andor Diera, Abdelhalim Dahou, Lukas Galke, Fabian Karl, Florian Sihler, Ansgar Scherp
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.PL
|
Language models can serve as a valuable tool for software developers to
increase productivity. Large generative models can be used for code generation
and code completion, while smaller encoder-only models are capable of
performing code search tasks using natural language queries.These capabilities
are heavily influenced by the quality and diversity of the available training
data. Source code datasets used for training usually focus on the most popular
languages and testing is mostly conducted on the same distributions, often
overlooking low-resource programming languages. Motivated by the NLP
generalization taxonomy proposed by Hupkes et.\,al., we propose a new benchmark
dataset called GenCodeSearchNet (GeCS) which builds upon existing natural
language code search datasets to systemically evaluate the programming language
understanding generalization capabilities of language models. As part of the
full dataset, we introduce a new, manually curated subset StatCodeSearch that
focuses on R, a popular but so far underrepresented programming language that
is often used by researchers outside the field of computer science. For
evaluation and comparison, we collect several baseline results using fine-tuned
BERT-style models and GPT-style large language models in a zero-shot setting.
|
[
-0.470816046,
-0.3088306785,
0.1927583516,
0.0432727784,
0.037826553,
0.2318612188,
-0.2500386238,
-0.2238296419,
-0.1663619429,
0.4089370668,
-0.4287706614,
-0.7733229995,
-0.4595530629,
0.162688002,
-0.7076311707,
1.0370019674,
-0.1113823429,
0.0810936913,
-0.3281233609,
-0.1973945498,
-0.129968971,
-0.4983735383,
-0.4854611158,
-0.2195211351,
0.0957880318,
0.3050375283,
0.7862403989,
0.54522264,
0.6801524758,
0.1971630901,
0.032663215,
-0.2385744601,
-0.5011332631,
0.1903845966,
-0.0838396773,
-0.5098331571,
-0.1352926195,
-0.0352112278,
0.3297680318,
0.7650440335,
-0.3269471526,
0.5015212297,
-0.0023993473,
0.616741538,
-0.7050420046,
0.165419817,
-0.5173495412,
0.3391442895,
0.0266325809,
-0.2443607301,
-0.2252697945,
-0.6138831377,
0.138716206,
-0.4207237959,
0.8903374076,
-0.0767604783,
0.6787429452,
0.0884339064,
-0.2287700027,
-0.4857542813,
-0.7212850451,
0.7926283479,
-0.7240455747,
0.3504903615,
0.32956025,
0.3783647418,
0.014672678,
-0.6712450981,
-0.1841644496,
-0.50010252,
0.0258828569,
0.0207955986,
-0.3524102569,
0.1764462292,
0.4672140479,
0.7166499496,
-1.3010313511,
0.0255137458,
-0.4219358265,
-0.0933992341,
0.4300364256,
0.0296330918,
0.7014181614,
0.0043864804,
-0.0113165602,
-0.2556420863,
-0.5713472366,
-0.0598067865,
0.4192154706,
0.2086848915,
-0.0523428172,
0.4596489668,
-0.4609116912,
0.9956408739,
-0.5394746661,
0.3427154124,
0.3417011499,
-0.4794528782,
-0.4365315735,
-0.3114266694,
0.507596314,
0.1556272805,
0.8486885428,
-0.5387818813,
-0.0588922836,
0.4371559918,
0.2877469957,
-0.8021358252,
-0.4094693065,
0.0962323099,
-0.6688951254,
-0.3952311873,
0.2819801569,
-0.9639974833,
-0.1808524877,
-0.2555014491,
-0.1088716015,
-0.3936695755,
-0.1060153246,
0.2502192259,
-0.3835381866,
0.4701289237,
-0.2809720337,
-1.0552155972,
0.3403432965,
0.7685251832,
0.6653926969,
0.1468332708,
-0.2674731612,
-0.5569301248,
-0.3278963864,
-0.5156083703,
0.4857390225,
-0.8740320802,
-0.4907323718,
0.1390003711,
-0.1293704957,
-0.1034546569,
-0.6930634379,
0.302172929,
-0.6192557812,
0.0830382332,
0.1246935353,
-0.6059368253,
0.0202452317,
0.1810439229,
-0.3670979142,
1.0456001759,
0.2602294385,
-0.4811505377,
0.5433860421,
-0.5302758217,
-0.3721282482,
0.2418260276,
-0.467782706,
-0.2883270979,
0.1685229838,
0.3735359609,
0.4051510096,
-0.3563866913,
0.3491320014,
-0.4024056792,
-0.6213761568,
0.0509122722,
-0.1729247123,
0.6655913591,
0.3655241728,
-0.4703321159,
-0.1209063306,
-0.6888611913,
0.4279589653,
0.2477333546,
-0.2899950147,
-0.3247032166,
0.2167273462,
-0.1890461296,
-0.0075860936,
-0.0508961678,
-0.4033875167,
0.2964049578,
-0.2806268036,
0.2256290913,
0.3560399115,
-0.1502934694,
0.4942227602,
0.0432748049,
1.0669690371,
-0.5290442705,
0.4545308948,
-0.1187321916,
-0.5805200934,
-0.5657049417,
0.1185359284,
0.3091790974,
0.5455706716,
-0.6171198487,
0.398147285,
-0.3543766737,
-0.3884120882,
-0.4666914046,
0.3990925252,
0.6287255883,
0.0640508085,
0.2960938513,
-0.4272926748,
-0.8096771836,
-0.870970428,
-0.2479161173,
-0.0332685299,
-0.558034718,
0.3133711219,
0.4306450188,
-0.5538833737,
0.9080582857,
-0.5878865123,
0.0661009103,
-0.4446700215,
0.3003267646,
0.2760573924,
0.3478224277,
0.6035930514,
-0.7410475016,
-0.3902189434,
0.098295033,
-0.8700518608,
-0.0565449558,
0.2867896557,
0.1550956815,
-0.082797043,
0.7163573503,
0.0855185464,
0.3822520375,
1.0919867754,
-0.2008364052,
0.5120203495,
-0.2183233351,
0.2310994416,
-0.7720766068,
0.4585803449,
0.0327490233,
0.0910453796,
-0.5396558642,
0.5917459726,
0.2211125642,
-0.5845370889,
0.0509035476,
0.1334551573,
-0.6179409027,
-0.4806945324,
0.0776028037,
0.0831114799,
-0.091569379,
0.1843566597,
-0.3271638751,
1.2472977638,
0.5949560404,
-0.5370982885,
0.4192592204,
0.2170214206,
-0.5996749997,
0.0510205962,
-0.859256506,
0.3718824685,
-0.1320653707,
0.1089920551,
-0.783863306,
-0.1195066348,
-0.1661486626,
-0.5230567455,
0.0939840823,
-0.5139360428,
-0.3202885687,
-0.718313992,
-0.1381730586,
0.3023481071,
0.7630029917,
-0.5517576337,
0.2739343643,
0.1768372804,
-0.1199342832,
-0.6832889318,
-0.8443135023,
0.1302198619,
0.0904629603,
-0.5722310543,
0.0687983111,
-0.1390800327,
-0.1444214135,
-0.0924318656,
-0.1319103241,
-0.1496369988,
0.1013628468,
0.0436874926,
0.4188457727,
-0.4245327711,
0.1518362314,
-0.3139475286,
-0.1887682527,
-0.0350879841,
-0.4941217005,
0.6880313158,
-0.2296122462,
-0.5808885098,
0.2240101546,
0.1781077385,
0.2712592185,
-0.5161228776,
0.4438782036,
0.4051552117,
0.0000454009,
-0.5713873506,
-0.4296757877,
0.0334410965,
-0.427739799,
0.5612943769,
-0.2869744897,
-1.1425256729,
0.6066768765,
0.1212024763,
-0.1931987554,
0.2054351568,
0.2785906196,
0.2568736076,
1.0319652557,
0.6324548125,
-0.484105438,
0.2763346732,
-0.3528434336,
0.4745686352,
-0.4921942353,
0.0848682597,
-1.0045078993,
0.0103343241,
-0.6577290297,
-0.4152323008,
0.0126460288,
0.0297230594,
-0.1329627931,
0.5274704695,
-0.7736177444,
0.8288117051,
0.5310487151,
-0.0622607656,
0.1958377808,
0.0676065907,
-0.1654947698,
0.0798724294,
-0.6391196251,
-0.3562950194,
1.3519175053,
0.226959452,
0.8756151795,
-0.0369408503,
0.6899684668,
0.4586728513,
0.1981285214,
-0.4733235538,
0.4729999304,
-0.6854497194,
-0.5297688246,
-0.1714112163,
-0.8092307448,
-0.9246376753,
0.0207658131,
0.2648059428,
-0.6404208541,
0.2295293063,
0.0835514292,
-0.2479530424,
0.3668601513,
-0.8041037917,
1.0377258062,
-0.0766624585,
0.2550273836,
-0.175892666,
-0.3168473244,
0.3291941881,
0.1305976659,
0.1390992552,
-0.1554826945,
0.2999141514,
0.679897368,
-0.0586761087,
0.473814249,
-0.1035058051,
0.1361876577,
0.00056899,
0.2450398356,
0.3720135689,
-0.1730486453,
-0.0931024849,
0.1362127066,
-0.1177638322,
-0.4879013896,
-0.5306041241,
0.5151751637,
-0.5744144917,
-0.0526979379,
-0.1255887747,
-0.2613160014,
-0.2907372713,
-0.0421946384,
0.323698014,
0.6651206017,
-0.5508547425,
0.2817285657,
0.854399085,
-0.4772504568,
0.0554171726,
0.3811019659,
-0.4509728253,
-0.0408964567,
0.8333728909,
-0.4161869884,
0.3843884468,
0.3109277785,
-0.0675754473,
0.0871061832,
-0.6573305726,
-0.2405626178,
-0.2215736806,
-0.7092593908,
-0.235334605,
-0.4965684414,
-0.3787612319,
-0.5387898684,
-0.2390329838,
-0.0859347656,
0.1045165807,
0.0735844374,
-0.117463775,
0.1984359026,
0.8687124252,
0.0001989418,
-0.1037644818,
-0.7154280543,
0.4397214353,
0.5598682165,
0.7118476629,
-0.0270376801,
-0.2495519519,
-0.1929484457,
-0.0435923599,
0.106973283,
-0.6236823201,
0.2666202188,
0.2349257767,
0.7841839194,
0.2482450604,
-0.3194919229,
0.3575052917,
-0.2646166086,
0.6436551809,
0.1045246497,
-0.9701078534,
0.7064054608,
-0.42632249,
0.306122005,
0.8142573237,
0.1226652637,
-0.9457312822,
-0.3788941205,
-0.415841192,
-0.6712945104,
0.4833104908,
0.1326530576,
0.1200936437,
-0.0342231058,
0.2425539345,
-0.0457645878,
0.0890824124,
-0.3335851431,
-0.2117823064,
0.0261537433,
-0.206576407,
-0.3742282689,
-0.3645594418,
-0.0037790712,
-0.2702049017,
0.4427663684,
-0.3550053835,
0.3922352791,
-0.0329446644,
-0.1064863205,
0.0120021934,
0.4911633432,
0.2986807525,
0.8021995425,
-0.4141067266,
-0.0065526953,
0.0403539836,
-0.6544826627,
0.1387182325,
0.1790625602,
-0.1320063919,
-0.0371699594,
0.3278411925,
0.5688178539,
0.3562340438,
-0.7438553572,
0.4875128269,
-0.1936165541,
-0.3081795275,
-0.0549823903,
0.2992046475,
0.0452102125,
-0.1339851618,
0.4261421263,
0.0975348502,
0.3659034073,
-0.4413590431,
0.4858648777,
0.3643995821,
-0.2664211988,
0.0245747529,
0.4547963738,
0.1121565253,
-0.0912431404,
0.9461443424,
-0.4479145408,
-0.6038640738,
1.1308662891,
0.2528837323,
1.0793608427,
-0.1863677949,
0.5914111137,
0.4654555321,
0.4666605592,
-0.1020547301,
0.1716066301,
-0.0471158102,
-0.7659396529,
-0.585434556,
-0.6106728911,
-0.5388941169,
-0.0118136117,
-0.8309144378,
-0.0453440472,
-0.2878540456,
0.0769459531,
-0.1155768409,
-0.1723757684,
-0.9302416444,
0.0891494751,
0.1472167969,
1.0451866388,
-0.8752337098,
0.7852124572,
0.5189390779,
-0.5087658763,
-0.6420485377,
0.1384966969,
-0.1661789715,
-0.9563128352,
0.6471863985,
0.1038986966,
0.103465721,
-0.0658024997,
-0.7766966224,
-0.8065149188,
0.8769096136,
0.2894922793,
-0.5896632671,
-0.0596382134,
0.1527296007,
0.6589568257,
-0.3341185749,
0.2944735289,
0.7951971889,
0.2939794064,
-0.298912406,
-0.776378572,
-0.2298910469,
-0.4172936976,
0.4856431484,
0.1855538785,
-0.051981613,
0.775652349,
-0.0751754567,
-0.2991606891,
0.1091821715,
0.1538526118,
0.1653795242,
0.1853437126,
0.2459553331,
0.5361747742,
0.5971935987,
-0.1496698558,
1.3797351122,
-0.2929553688,
0.7576999068,
0.9954401851,
-0.3031705916,
0.6499888301,
0.0888264924,
-0.626830101,
0.5374514461,
0.3160790801,
-0.4226364195,
0.3474529088,
0.6678147912,
-0.0246963389,
-0.106394805,
0.1593832523,
-0.4732126892,
0.1542958617,
0.0753482282,
-0.5011860132,
-0.4670120478,
-0.0483815223,
-0.1478047818,
0.1794681102,
-0.0320474692,
0.6221916676,
-0.0879831761,
-0.4600013793,
0.5484474897,
-0.1713890284,
0.8719453812,
-0.9458736181,
0.0925249681,
-0.455232352,
0.3507447541,
-0.0718790367,
-0.6925164461,
0.3030689955,
0.1567595154,
-0.176863417,
-0.0239309855,
0.7406340241,
-0.2148712277,
-0.4755845666,
0.7447218299,
0.4385606349,
0.0995919406,
-0.0678897649,
-0.7983397841,
0.0599538535,
0.2431856692,
0.0059909308,
0.3969726264,
0.0275714584,
0.370549202,
0.7399967909,
0.5873878002,
0.1659124792,
0.1563687027,
0.4887895286,
0.6802014709,
-0.413852483,
-0.3935741186,
-0.594923079,
-0.0098106172,
-0.1562179327,
-0.3294762969,
0.7927961349,
0.6999824643,
0.9552789927,
-0.2335347831,
1.0737375021,
-0.203714177,
0.4421884418,
-0.4241021872,
0.5774471164,
-0.3130164444,
-0.0323306099,
-0.2336802185,
-0.9403347969,
-0.3183198869,
0.521155417,
-0.4237107933,
0.3558475673,
0.5807765722,
1.0360426903,
-0.2658624351,
0.156962797,
0.4085640907,
-0.1598257422,
0.2919386327,
0.5644869208,
0.6359632611,
-0.4100717902,
0.5817343593,
-0.1886203438,
-0.3556286991,
-0.1552459449,
-0.6166431904,
-0.8087924123,
-0.443738699,
-0.1750514507,
-0.2213001549,
0.4840221703,
0.5927710533,
0.7367477417,
-1.2050323486,
-0.3415094018,
-0.5109513402,
-0.2035113275,
-0.2834966481,
-0.2654424608,
0.1472909153,
-0.6992124915,
-0.3837834001,
0.5097427964,
0.1801078916,
-0.0817884654,
-0.4156316817,
-0.1381850839,
-0.0028155041,
-0.2973284423,
0.2463922948,
0.5024474859,
-0.2369292378,
-0.0395482928,
0.1130816489,
-0.254229188,
-0.1254700273,
1.1911469698,
-0.6572535038,
0.5823671818,
0.6613174081,
0.7756276727,
0.3371751904,
-0.0200350825,
0.8298504353,
-0.8446855545,
0.0090631219,
0.2116895765,
0.3306995332,
0.2815358341,
-0.2850614786,
0.9354436398,
0.034553349,
-0.7434980869,
-0.5155872107,
0.1808375716,
-0.4599808156,
-0.4049323201,
1.1655703783,
-0.054070048,
0.0964844674,
-0.2344174534,
0.1246770769,
-0.0550505593,
-0.2236334682,
0.5466794372,
0.4846220016,
0.2210251242,
0.0162946265,
-1.0056488514,
0.4513320923,
0.4429776371,
-0.7805752754,
0.1486532986,
0.3117462695,
0.3747111559,
0.0161034148,
0.5558314919,
-0.1180916652,
0.2424332649,
0.1511983275,
0.6288846135,
0.1888003945,
-0.0425889567,
-0.5444358587,
0.1143708825,
-0.0657674968,
-0.228398785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09702v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09702v3
|
Deceptive Semantic Shortcuts on Reasoning Chains: How Far Can Models Go without Hallucination?
| 2023-11-16T09:27:36 | 2024-04-05T18:08:51 |
Bangzheng Li, Ben Zhou, Fei Wang, Xingyu Fu, Dan Roth, Muhao Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the recent advancement in large language models (LLMs) and their high
performances across numerous benchmarks, recent research has unveiled that LLMs
suffer from hallucinations and unfaithful reasoning. This work studies a
specific type of hallucination induced by semantic associations. Specifically,
we investigate to what extent LLMs take shortcuts from certain keyword/entity
biases in the prompt instead of following the correct reasoning path. To
quantify this phenomenon, we propose a novel probing method and benchmark
called EureQA. We start from questions that LLMs will answer correctly with
utmost certainty, and mask the important entity with evidence sentence
recursively, asking models to find masked entities according to a chain of
evidence before answering the question.
During the construction of the evidence, we purposefully replace semantic
clues (entities) that may lead to the correct answer with distractor clues
(evidence) that will not directly lead to the correct answer but require a
chain-like reasoning process. We evaluate if models can follow the correct
reasoning chain instead of short-cutting through distractor clues. We find that
existing LLMs lack the necessary capabilities to follow correct reasoning paths
and resist the attempt of greedy shortcuts. We show that the distractor
semantic associations often lead to model hallucination, which is strong
evidence that questions the validity of current LLM reasoning.
|
[
-0.3610199988,
-0.9663690329,
1.1385028362,
-0.3014545441,
-0.3678598702,
-0.0189414695,
0.0444478989,
-0.6337485313,
0.2004555315,
1.0172137022,
-0.7489261031,
-0.3987393975,
-0.6389753222,
0.2295687348,
-0.4828885198,
0.6934858561,
-0.011746916,
-0.112672545,
-0.2137268484,
-0.1087321341,
-0.497225374,
-0.6760305166,
-0.2171336263,
-0.3459733129,
0.6906622052,
0.1759145111,
0.8835237622,
0.6924236417,
0.2978550792,
0.2806176841,
-0.2553843558,
0.1268188953,
-0.3394097388,
0.2475607842,
-0.327442944,
-0.4326069951,
-0.0762993991,
-0.1040562838,
0.24125579,
1.0565999746,
-0.120887652,
0.1272146702,
0.0247960798,
0.7254132032,
-0.7045886517,
-0.2112807184,
-1.0602532625,
-0.2291909307,
-0.2849417925,
-0.2011376172,
-0.4500432909,
-0.2466268092,
0.2263956517,
-0.3693802059,
0.1576379836,
0.2028281838,
0.880207777,
0.4504579008,
-0.6315490007,
-0.7154372931,
-0.707192719,
0.7837626338,
-0.4837476313,
0.4187857509,
0.3575315773,
0.2605218589,
-0.3572603166,
-0.63575387,
-0.2856394947,
-0.4984375238,
-0.0775448903,
-0.3420114517,
-0.2917430997,
0.214086771,
0.6088036895,
0.1285454333,
-0.347643733,
0.0193682015,
-0.3966750205,
-0.3922820389,
0.3401392102,
0.3570636511,
0.2659843564,
-0.1439910978,
-0.4096707404,
0.0542023256,
-0.9466466904,
-0.2129206061,
0.2661990225,
0.1537895352,
0.4764371812,
0.7667989135,
-0.1552548409,
0.8660929799,
-0.1893489212,
0.1246603727,
-0.1920229495,
-0.1480485499,
-0.175775528,
0.3920579255,
0.5581471324,
0.2745759785,
0.47665447,
-0.2614253163,
-0.2993223369,
0.4200033844,
0.2033171058,
-0.7367395163,
-0.2568403184,
0.2617563605,
-0.3527431488,
-0.2101644874,
-0.2265299261,
-0.5819576979,
-0.3434515297,
-0.0771875903,
0.5221316814,
-0.2561516166,
-0.0321450159,
0.4342732728,
-0.1807166785,
0.1972884089,
0.3168354034,
-0.6936044693,
0.5630603433,
0.7010298967,
0.6749603152,
-0.1929289997,
-0.2234787345,
-0.5131244063,
0.1724791229,
-0.2953000069,
0.8315441012,
-0.7528185248,
-0.2309396118,
0.0134645281,
0.061815083,
-0.0225090459,
-0.7488337755,
0.6420333385,
-0.5692747235,
0.0506084599,
-0.5176210403,
-0.6578538418,
-0.5360582471,
0.2268278599,
-0.7890483737,
0.8526072502,
-0.2947472334,
-0.7918745875,
0.2426093817,
-0.2886749208,
-0.2270061374,
-0.2812895775,
-0.3497217894,
-0.0245246142,
0.2651546001,
0.1163809747,
0.3977996111,
-0.5211941004,
0.3079000711,
-0.3929209709,
-0.4615482688,
0.603734076,
-0.5167596936,
0.8058132529,
0.0135959191,
-0.4851747453,
-0.1446233243,
-0.8557514548,
-0.2086472958,
0.2247467041,
0.0893382803,
-0.8832144737,
0.0492955372,
-0.2700721025,
0.4630446434,
0.0311203059,
-0.4432719052,
0.1188773885,
-0.2973022461,
0.3048483133,
0.9342781305,
0.2929495871,
0.2250628024,
-0.3386942744,
0.4002091587,
0.034864787,
0.0118212029,
0.0281837024,
-0.5286701918,
-0.8670959473,
-0.0048742639,
0.2467945665,
0.1814252436,
-0.4310229123,
0.1623346061,
-0.1090159565,
-0.1896725148,
-0.4825548828,
-0.0301006287,
0.3581900597,
0.389560461,
0.322435379,
-0.2029024363,
-0.2373904884,
-0.9551168084,
-0.6353949308,
-0.1427076906,
-0.1652225852,
0.1858001202,
0.9073446989,
-0.0376729146,
0.5093112588,
-0.4933138788,
-0.2710749507,
-0.1091777533,
-0.055240348,
0.1637699157,
0.1174464226,
0.1576250494,
-0.7657114267,
0.0495803356,
-0.498052597,
-0.5321265459,
0.0141153913,
-0.3928030133,
-0.125539422,
0.0413458981,
0.5672273636,
-0.7684496045,
0.4364151359,
0.2311744392,
-0.6535158753,
0.5189102292,
0.0422272272,
-0.2284812629,
-0.7032844424,
-0.1207082048,
-0.3566912711,
-0.1116847321,
-0.5624301434,
0.0278738327,
-0.2586849928,
0.3611534238,
-0.3880967796,
0.5124740005,
-0.7719656229,
-0.1452987492,
-0.214732945,
0.3173372447,
0.1483746022,
0.5978821516,
0.1741732508,
0.3049647212,
0.4404101372,
-0.8860004544,
0.0313941352,
0.2269763649,
-0.3613885343,
0.0992341787,
-0.6602007151,
0.1584522724,
-0.031849131,
0.2019875944,
-0.6452868581,
-0.1548484862,
0.308150351,
-0.1679564565,
-0.1544624865,
0.0745110214,
-0.7197233438,
-0.1464164704,
-0.2150339782,
0.4515379965,
0.5478597283,
-0.6541935205,
0.6893587112,
0.1679276377,
0.2949287891,
-0.518720448,
-0.7702406645,
-0.1225745082,
-0.4304398894,
-0.4968946278,
0.4075284004,
0.027753111,
-0.4934200644,
-0.1405512542,
-0.4466777444,
0.0865377411,
0.2557428181,
0.3791903853,
0.1590324342,
0.0576553345,
0.0474552326,
-0.0214833673,
0.1717258096,
0.6677051187,
0.0081882533,
0.4902155697,
0.0045162472,
-0.6062113047,
-0.2782345712,
0.2915508151,
0.6933144927,
-0.0371006578,
0.6939480901,
-0.0076145916,
-0.5774320364,
-0.2702308595,
-0.7261419892,
-0.588291347,
-0.4574521184,
0.2108271122,
-0.660433054,
-0.9092483521,
0.8454944491,
-0.3582266569,
-0.2061598152,
0.3077215254,
0.4791959822,
0.3082665205,
1.1386401653,
0.4535818994,
0.2352025062,
0.0150851011,
-0.2281510085,
0.1640412658,
-0.787819922,
-0.4230569005,
-0.5727262497,
0.0819322616,
-0.8849303722,
-0.4306811392,
0.1832680851,
0.2397288978,
-0.2287368327,
0.1412544101,
-0.4729390144,
0.7105892301,
0.3371348977,
0.0748734996,
0.4459374845,
-0.1756581813,
-0.5189607739,
-0.059174668,
-0.6988374591,
-0.5605986118,
0.9121913314,
0.391605854,
0.8823907375,
0.0425690822,
0.7522771955,
0.0955550596,
-0.163233012,
-0.6878002286,
0.7509023547,
0.3809762001,
-0.7327235341,
-0.2670576274,
-0.2411925793,
-0.6976675391,
0.3438293338,
0.083332628,
-1.0653289557,
0.2720209658,
-0.0937826633,
-0.2201788127,
0.3872933686,
-0.2115667164,
0.8843235373,
-0.3269332051,
-0.4336326122,
-0.1077278107,
-0.7917884588,
0.62151438,
-0.0922767147,
0.1005506143,
-0.2484496385,
0.0327053666,
0.8658146262,
-0.5539278984,
0.8266876936,
0.0248694904,
-0.1927534193,
0.3361542523,
0.5944619179,
0.8805288076,
-0.208907783,
0.1702782661,
0.0252768937,
0.0020983405,
-0.3560832441,
-0.6914712787,
0.5804407001,
-0.3575757742,
-0.8231801391,
-0.7066245079,
-0.4069657028,
-0.2939200401,
0.0396763757,
0.227976203,
0.309017092,
-0.2207436413,
-0.1084736884,
0.8210855722,
-0.0429439917,
0.2972057164,
0.407528162,
-0.2971586585,
0.0203693919,
0.6270723343,
0.0115858307,
0.5651931763,
0.3189910054,
0.1522238255,
-0.4440715313,
-0.5130010247,
-0.1840371788,
0.4288569689,
-0.9086286426,
-0.0440283939,
-0.6729781628,
-0.1484502107,
-0.0077894796,
0.0498145483,
-0.4062540829,
-0.5283846259,
-0.1735295504,
-0.1255375445,
0.352420181,
0.8493368626,
0.0686733276,
-0.2397014052,
-0.6577202082,
0.2193043232,
0.4346462488,
-0.1060384065,
0.2275165915,
-0.5683825016,
0.0359434746,
-0.0031621894,
-0.2648936808,
-1.1975414753,
0.1339997798,
-0.1682427526,
0.5008442998,
0.6409324408,
0.3038470745,
0.7590414286,
-0.5655732155,
0.7669720054,
0.1039190665,
-0.864084363,
0.4831165075,
-0.1693681031,
0.1510625333,
0.5115502477,
0.6419045925,
-0.435344547,
-0.7393449545,
-0.6429085732,
-0.6353003979,
0.2261548489,
0.2725898325,
-0.0047338074,
-0.2824299932,
0.2367348522,
0.1881746203,
0.0297422148,
-0.7644298077,
-0.24578017,
0.142145291,
0.2186495364,
0.3535040319,
-0.485470444,
-0.2512530684,
-0.1179701313,
0.5014326572,
-0.0762409493,
0.2294185162,
0.2327366322,
-0.2312671542,
-0.0126728276,
0.4244711995,
0.566948235,
0.8295407891,
-0.405649662,
0.3253499568,
0.0616669133,
-0.2018373311,
0.0924145952,
-0.0607457235,
-0.2501239181,
0.2800800204,
0.3613036275,
0.6565172076,
0.1902195066,
-0.8542470336,
0.5112738609,
-0.0032370663,
-0.2160503715,
-0.3830391169,
-0.0053643389,
0.0451029576,
0.2986481488,
0.3084831238,
-0.0635581911,
0.390818119,
-0.6993436813,
0.0605937466,
0.553258419,
-0.4432790577,
-0.3472712338,
0.7713910937,
-0.1244521141,
-0.1535725445,
0.6535199285,
0.0284481701,
-0.7641385794,
0.4605216384,
0.4026827812,
0.9999812245,
-0.0084618637,
0.2838692069,
0.1532929838,
0.5014197826,
-0.180737868,
0.2432464659,
-0.1156365797,
-0.7011688352,
-0.3799273074,
-0.6087678671,
-0.3053313196,
0.2987145782,
-0.7784507275,
0.1588282734,
-0.0326596014,
0.1234568506,
0.0182485562,
-0.1243931279,
-0.6511277556,
0.0056242873,
0.0866301656,
1.0265338421,
-0.8293982744,
0.8445923328,
0.2158338428,
-0.5378651619,
-0.8097205162,
0.2249704301,
-0.0278551579,
-0.5894434452,
0.72477144,
0.353099674,
-0.334572047,
-0.3373209536,
-0.5422558188,
-0.7324191332,
0.9483925104,
0.2219647318,
-0.6683493853,
-0.4538634121,
0.4272517264,
0.3135584891,
-0.4412594736,
0.1292032003,
0.7963685989,
0.3149107397,
0.2188319415,
-0.72872293,
0.7492620349,
0.2455921173,
0.0334279351,
0.2272661775,
-0.4452241361,
0.7171188593,
-0.4941613972,
-0.2845689356,
0.2681297958,
0.4095729887,
0.5021895766,
0.2295169383,
0.6144824028,
0.5161862969,
0.7232132554,
0.1122081578,
0.8430982828,
-0.3166287839,
0.1447304338,
1.2083034515,
-0.4378354847,
0.8467227817,
1.0482535362,
0.204279229,
0.7891311646,
0.7242879868,
0.0255673937,
0.851351738,
0.5221028924,
-0.1550578624,
-0.64673841,
-0.3462876976,
-0.2416297346,
0.4650049508,
0.4948134422,
-0.5372570157,
-0.2917354703,
0.0113604134,
0.0886372402,
0.0968686342,
-0.1914911717,
0.6723355651,
0.2824175954,
-0.7459502816,
0.7503952384,
-0.1393323541,
0.3232820332,
-0.4625193477,
-0.3576994836,
-0.1764440089,
-0.0145409619,
0.0911106914,
-0.488396883,
0.1904311627,
-0.0177292954,
0.1600506306,
-0.0657158643,
0.7997860312,
-0.2458247095,
-0.2651815414,
0.6204654574,
0.741992414,
0.4420887828,
-0.2672569752,
-0.7373683453,
0.0678094625,
0.0118275508,
-0.2734530568,
0.3782086372,
0.7800157666,
-0.1858803332,
0.7438320518,
0.5927436948,
0.1195828989,
0.1229985729,
0.0851249248,
1.102622509,
-0.9496467113,
-0.2746704817,
-1.0994185209,
0.2562120259,
0.0603691824,
-0.1406443864,
0.7518984675,
0.5124189854,
1.0108038187,
0.00279448,
0.4001801908,
0.3467737138,
0.4038603902,
-0.9021654129,
0.5185438395,
-0.5962469578,
0.6069175005,
-0.2109810412,
-1.033315897,
-0.1602066755,
0.3594775498,
-0.2619532645,
-0.0216202196,
1.0950269699,
1.0034741163,
-0.0226710998,
-0.0227068625,
0.5180186629,
0.390434891,
0.0363172032,
0.8113712072,
1.2349241972,
-0.3744800091,
0.6613954306,
-0.2405474335,
0.2384981215,
-0.1330414414,
-0.6972039938,
-1.2670707703,
-0.5307392478,
-0.3069071174,
-0.6018468738,
0.2556984723,
0.7329197526,
0.2065969557,
-0.5878513455,
-0.1531908959,
-0.4543398321,
0.448409766,
-0.1534623802,
-0.1961917877,
0.4373776317,
0.017928265,
-0.4111103415,
0.1729111522,
0.1323102564,
0.1181724891,
-0.5981805325,
-0.0218143146,
-0.2585755289,
0.3199067712,
0.2332141995,
0.1052163914,
-1.3866118193,
-0.4113758504,
0.1117462441,
-0.0402570851,
-0.1060088128,
0.9188275933,
-0.8303534985,
0.31928882,
0.3710035384,
0.3957566321,
0.3886369169,
-0.2345703244,
0.3245182037,
-0.3325186968,
-0.0212625712,
0.3671105802,
0.3654638231,
0.2583465576,
-0.2397740781,
0.4709840715,
0.098507911,
-0.5948433876,
-1.0958764553,
0.4267351627,
-0.8455475569,
-0.5364894271,
1.1975206137,
0.0668895841,
-0.6321578026,
-0.1426885873,
0.0624807402,
-0.0219664406,
-0.1250352561,
0.9133281112,
0.7777364254,
-0.2608342171,
0.0754145682,
-0.7026791573,
0.8225286603,
0.4329505563,
-0.4559418857,
0.2686663568,
0.5849499106,
0.2874128222,
0.2697358131,
0.5373706222,
-0.0742774084,
0.2295738459,
0.1332265735,
-0.2559098005,
0.1538795233,
-0.587182343,
-0.2819621861,
0.0374727584,
0.1557626426,
-0.2794430256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09696v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09696v2
|
Fumbling in Babel: An Investigation into ChatGPT's Language Identification Ability
| 2023-11-16T09:12:20 | 2024-04-08T20:57:40 |
Wei-Rui Chen, Ife Adebara, Khai Duy Doan, Qisheng Liao, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
ChatGPT has recently emerged as a powerful NLP tool that can carry out a
variety of tasks. However, the range of languages ChatGPT can handle remains
largely a mystery. To uncover which languages ChatGPT `knows', we investigate
its language identification (LID) abilities. For this purpose, we compile
Babel-670, a benchmark comprising 670 languages representing 24 language
families spoken in five continents. Languages in Babel-670 run the gamut from
the very high-resource to the very low-resource. We then study ChatGPT's (both
GPT-3.5 and GPT-4) ability to (i) identify language names and language codes
(ii) under zero- and few-shot conditions (iii) with and without provision of a
label set. When compared to smaller finetuned LID tools, we find that ChatGPT
lags behind. For example, it has poor performance on African languages. We
conclude that current large language models would benefit from further
development before they can sufficiently serve diverse communities.
|
[
-0.5262612104,
-0.7259064317,
0.0644522458,
0.202677846,
-0.017662026,
0.4348342717,
-0.2861761451,
-0.8182684779,
-0.1045479625,
0.2639057934,
-0.431404531,
-0.0739217252,
-0.7749398947,
0.0449592173,
-0.5951536894,
1.1045928001,
0.3711647987,
-0.283703804,
0.21694839,
-0.0032500997,
-0.3770937324,
-0.5880147815,
-0.7352033854,
-0.2744891942,
0.4664408267,
0.3813836575,
0.945546329,
0.4183713794,
0.6700863838,
0.3057282865,
-0.3674316406,
-0.0007786421,
-0.7008065581,
-0.2139166594,
0.0216270816,
-0.3569487333,
-0.0357840694,
-0.22211878,
0.5021434426,
0.6236478686,
0.0318622924,
0.0797729418,
0.0503632128,
0.5876876116,
-0.3896301985,
0.34317258,
-0.8264618516,
0.1514613032,
-0.7450483441,
0.0866108462,
-0.4215599298,
0.0324841738,
0.3151614368,
-0.2319712043,
0.5104346275,
0.2124566883,
1.1398463249,
0.2589671314,
-0.232095927,
-0.1799781919,
-0.7609155774,
0.4869847,
-0.4977835715,
0.2513867319,
0.5101011395,
0.4870837331,
-0.2263717651,
-0.3915613294,
-0.3700747788,
-0.1514472812,
-0.1302315891,
0.1258649975,
-0.1290087849,
-0.1566890329,
0.5920346379,
0.5622811913,
-0.8296569586,
0.0557404794,
-0.5507105589,
-0.3167048693,
0.5156639218,
-0.2549644411,
0.4622168243,
-0.0930661559,
-0.4225769341,
0.1825964302,
-0.7520030737,
-0.1776595414,
0.2515564263,
0.3290487528,
-0.3130356073,
0.5543087125,
-0.2561846673,
0.7424891591,
-0.311480701,
0.0669297725,
0.0818172246,
0.0946189538,
-0.0640481189,
-0.0432529189,
0.8574621677,
0.0830958411,
0.504296124,
-0.4492258132,
-0.3756641746,
0.0209398009,
0.017648017,
-0.5309855938,
-0.4545736313,
0.0026367877,
0.018439455,
-0.0400289483,
-0.1969424635,
-0.5288664103,
-0.4674449861,
0.2750064135,
0.3584048748,
-0.7286919951,
-0.3309805989,
0.0445020199,
-0.2652177811,
0.69643116,
-0.0093856854,
-1.1127607822,
0.3260495961,
0.7401469946,
0.9361034632,
-0.2796608806,
-0.3163390756,
-0.3655523062,
-0.0660534427,
-0.0577080995,
0.9292454123,
-0.6216728091,
-0.2941340804,
0.0565821715,
-0.1439791918,
0.0014599719,
-0.5934684873,
0.2401706725,
-0.6595463753,
-0.0147435395,
-0.3546371758,
-0.4285975695,
-0.0235243551,
0.0818673447,
-0.7025995851,
1.1293708086,
0.3242810965,
-0.74616611,
0.335233897,
-0.4425872862,
-0.4897982776,
0.5869088769,
-0.170067355,
-0.2132730335,
0.176565662,
0.1059029698,
0.220722273,
-0.3673084676,
-0.0011694685,
-0.2105837166,
-0.5697804093,
0.3901298642,
-0.7774612308,
1.0086535215,
0.3389473855,
-0.2128087133,
-0.4945420325,
-0.5121968985,
-0.0193511453,
0.0304576401,
-0.2645712197,
0.2182812244,
-0.059075579,
0.1378456205,
0.2800674438,
0.2023421526,
-0.5424330831,
0.2574504018,
-0.434535712,
0.3941260278,
0.4004406035,
-0.234423086,
0.0309328176,
-0.2575599551,
0.7123421431,
-0.1346565187,
0.0301292446,
0.0420707166,
-0.9559485316,
-0.8660748601,
-0.1363411546,
0.6801834702,
0.5889232159,
-0.8453296423,
0.0841149092,
-0.2297833115,
-0.5766108036,
-0.523704946,
-0.1304614246,
0.5501292944,
0.0143019715,
0.0591233112,
-0.5260008574,
-0.1517895311,
-1.0601263046,
-0.242094174,
-0.1391775906,
-0.1899753064,
0.3404417634,
0.5097435117,
0.0992623046,
0.9044172764,
-0.3887787461,
-0.1029772311,
-0.1608581394,
0.1075318158,
0.0766616985,
0.1714293361,
0.5406899452,
-0.7875984311,
-0.5984254479,
0.3970097899,
-0.4619934857,
-0.2669044733,
0.1253756434,
-0.0434491336,
0.2547204196,
0.4117972255,
-0.5115996599,
0.2282991409,
0.7340156436,
-0.274543345,
0.5793982744,
-0.1573921293,
-0.1660117358,
-0.5174136162,
-0.058895532,
-0.2422924936,
-0.0674174875,
-0.5794935226,
0.026804937,
0.0909216553,
-0.4132810533,
-0.5799078941,
0.6742305756,
-0.4748069048,
-0.2397830784,
-0.1484369189,
0.3933463693,
-0.492493391,
0.5584441423,
0.2208916247,
0.8002186418,
0.626879096,
-0.2612172663,
0.2524758577,
-0.0051873983,
-0.4891179502,
0.3322665691,
-0.4620853364,
0.1012298837,
0.1346320808,
-0.008004385,
-0.8950889707,
-0.3910464048,
0.1588774025,
-0.4059023857,
0.263294071,
-0.6494811177,
-0.4210689366,
-0.2653231323,
0.431722492,
0.4256128073,
0.6313478947,
-0.4138377309,
0.34547171,
0.560547173,
-0.2029015422,
-0.6302360892,
-0.4960873127,
0.0891766474,
-0.2747193575,
-0.4707441032,
0.1950376034,
0.0042515094,
-0.0935272202,
-0.1809258908,
-0.2242355049,
-0.4478949904,
0.0702548251,
0.1358689964,
-0.0544251651,
-0.2103121281,
0.3797667623,
-0.3438436091,
-0.2427970469,
-0.2369614244,
-0.1066913679,
0.6866996884,
-0.6245108843,
-0.3436266184,
0.1017656997,
0.3620654941,
0.3938760459,
-0.5543355942,
0.5851315856,
0.7098720074,
-0.2015720457,
-0.1194586828,
-0.5968464017,
0.0598079525,
-0.4944697917,
0.2935002744,
-0.5551555157,
-0.7273682356,
0.7324754596,
0.0912936255,
-0.0159719754,
0.3418629169,
0.5406852961,
0.0401067361,
0.372510016,
0.7119625211,
-0.2398094237,
0.4741692841,
-0.1017572582,
0.4130267203,
-0.4830593765,
0.0252582971,
-0.6396986246,
-0.1797783077,
-1.0011726618,
-0.4027598798,
0.1419129521,
0.0394596308,
0.0327166915,
0.507371366,
-0.3566139638,
0.9098266363,
0.5772545338,
-0.0742218271,
0.3167979717,
-0.2260174602,
-0.0177764464,
0.28351596,
-0.9593988657,
-0.4459466934,
0.7033834457,
0.030498663,
0.4483231604,
0.280518353,
0.6155648232,
0.1317349225,
0.2504389584,
-0.8307884932,
0.5384432673,
-0.1501590759,
-0.924482286,
-0.177053079,
-0.3663276434,
-1.1277025938,
0.4453420639,
-0.0627731234,
-0.8921801448,
-0.1575098187,
0.1674843132,
-0.2046185732,
0.1096914932,
-1.0873154402,
0.9851671457,
-0.3868506849,
-0.1371065378,
0.1838245094,
-0.6264688969,
0.238136515,
-0.2694917321,
0.1927215308,
-0.4561746418,
0.1455810815,
0.5532847047,
-0.253801167,
0.8186914921,
0.1103976071,
-0.1173741594,
0.243878305,
0.1407551169,
0.2012996525,
-0.1299467236,
-0.0127979191,
0.3980804384,
0.1020491421,
-0.768643558,
-0.4794414043,
0.5398214459,
-0.4920009673,
-0.5332301855,
-0.3401245177,
-0.5370825529,
-0.3300325871,
0.3183544278,
0.4754692614,
0.5885031819,
-0.1343097389,
0.2492467314,
0.4993833303,
-0.3076238632,
0.6336888075,
0.4037150145,
-0.2781147361,
0.3125299513,
1.0847139359,
0.2583323419,
0.5857499242,
0.3517398536,
0.2325178385,
-0.047026094,
-0.5055113435,
-0.4757227898,
0.2488568872,
-0.3209385872,
0.0301795863,
-0.1977650076,
-0.3973905742,
0.0732679963,
-0.0820290893,
-0.4290703237,
-0.5191577077,
0.465618819,
0.2956394553,
0.3361165822,
0.641535759,
0.277027905,
0.5377106071,
-0.6392790675,
0.2268053293,
0.2782484293,
0.4940183163,
-0.2776454389,
-0.3300061524,
-0.2376812398,
0.0907524452,
-0.1532436311,
-0.8494864702,
0.1291089207,
0.22934632,
0.2855067551,
0.4063027799,
0.1871310472,
0.4777644277,
-0.6098285913,
0.7933539748,
-0.2572004199,
-0.6467888951,
0.1086112186,
-0.5752055049,
0.6011111736,
0.0738327727,
0.367091924,
-0.847774744,
-0.7309620976,
-0.8652828336,
-0.7620444298,
0.694611907,
0.4959753752,
0.1284064651,
-0.1301339567,
-0.0192331746,
0.0351345725,
0.134125948,
-0.8622228503,
-0.1193921119,
0.1065047011,
0.1207821444,
0.0647056252,
-0.0807814002,
-0.0189421512,
0.1297669709,
0.5714427829,
-0.0907652527,
0.4504921734,
-0.2830242813,
-0.2389648408,
0.3350726962,
0.3244395852,
0.3133248985,
0.4907850623,
-0.0471799634,
0.0683319569,
0.1248820275,
-0.3890223801,
-0.2493755519,
0.1070251986,
-0.1976169795,
-0.1049076021,
0.4397349358,
0.7141874433,
0.1270851642,
-0.6984390616,
0.3725197315,
-0.033263091,
0.1108712032,
-0.1458236575,
0.3512502015,
0.1490585953,
0.2084198296,
0.1173733622,
0.0318802185,
0.0057280031,
-0.494266212,
0.1187370718,
0.6539216638,
-0.4709375799,
-0.1942082494,
0.3031101823,
0.3135282993,
-0.6654294729,
0.9349019527,
-0.3000435233,
-0.6117325425,
0.589279294,
0.4981239736,
0.8197872043,
-0.1247327998,
0.2247022986,
0.0140503123,
0.5190195441,
0.2004264742,
0.0171538815,
-0.1917155832,
-1.0024876595,
-0.3684584796,
-0.6332569122,
-0.4067332149,
0.1309214681,
-0.4770503342,
0.0949032009,
0.0867010057,
-0.1183068007,
0.2372410297,
-0.0498101674,
-0.8344449401,
-0.0239940006,
0.2508998513,
0.6433263421,
-1.0187717676,
0.8913125992,
0.2672833502,
-0.2268843055,
-0.5671590567,
0.1103952155,
0.2987952828,
-0.7214502096,
0.3951182365,
0.2672318518,
-0.310785681,
0.0855474845,
-0.3532485962,
-0.8227127194,
0.424526602,
0.4614809453,
-0.3603824675,
0.1148073077,
0.3466976285,
0.6602937579,
0.1195669472,
0.3876316249,
0.8477746844,
0.4794294536,
0.11595162,
-1.3422071934,
-0.3185507953,
-0.3248308003,
-0.1178809255,
0.4387631714,
-0.8248144388,
0.390273124,
-0.1431267858,
-0.4507589042,
0.0174969696,
0.2379345,
-0.1279054284,
-0.3311412632,
0.2556414902,
0.2493843436,
0.7906117439,
-0.604847312,
1.117743969,
-0.1837029606,
0.463822782,
0.961175561,
-0.113242276,
0.9271165133,
0.3896051943,
-0.3332621753,
-0.1347533017,
0.6652936935,
-0.061541222,
0.299400568,
0.1149234995,
-0.3270631433,
-0.1528035551,
0.0411099494,
-0.2725737691,
0.6445880532,
0.5340597034,
0.2199273109,
-0.3097239435,
-0.1350354552,
0.0045223045,
-0.5490943193,
0.0860329792,
0.697342813,
0.0251376107,
-0.7496246696,
0.7822659016,
-0.3277557194,
0.3679203689,
-0.6284618378,
0.1257943809,
-0.2814293504,
0.0994457304,
-0.0399718545,
-0.8850198984,
0.269156456,
-0.0770896375,
0.1465902776,
-0.0898540989,
0.5927112103,
-0.5748856664,
-0.2620155513,
0.091070056,
0.6305518746,
0.5484161973,
-0.0397981368,
-0.6478176713,
0.0032189516,
0.0489850454,
-0.101195313,
0.3015977442,
0.7239590287,
-0.1472703964,
0.9208438396,
0.2820473909,
0.0800769255,
0.3380342424,
-0.0190493558,
0.4223468602,
-0.5067000389,
-0.1678980142,
-0.7111711502,
0.2743449211,
-0.1394337714,
-0.5071812272,
0.7173897028,
0.6309357285,
1.0912872553,
-0.3596905768,
0.7059083581,
-0.4978889823,
0.1589388698,
-0.4997529387,
0.6948875785,
-0.2314437181,
0.2604705989,
-0.3216752112,
-0.8582767844,
-0.3629078567,
0.6001959443,
-0.425933063,
0.105888173,
0.8309124708,
0.963772893,
-0.1710559279,
0.1384946853,
0.5079398751,
0.1346302778,
0.3412576914,
0.5004011989,
0.7986449003,
-0.2468106002,
0.769413054,
-0.3850911558,
-0.2727086544,
-0.2616516948,
-0.7788109183,
-0.7318243384,
-0.5408879519,
-0.2701360285,
0.0190102812,
0.0742752403,
0.3898333609,
0.7781021595,
-0.6185301542,
-0.2748224139,
0.2275856286,
0.1667694747,
-0.5278005004,
-0.1634710431,
0.3007510602,
-0.3667724431,
-0.8328915834,
0.3243829012,
0.2949472368,
-0.0913628787,
0.0161070284,
0.1258189976,
0.0265914071,
-0.1333161592,
0.6120246649,
0.5794098377,
-0.814361155,
-0.4544633627,
-0.3531396687,
0.1159836501,
0.1794263273,
0.6977438927,
-0.6858923435,
0.548547864,
0.2563715875,
0.6687418222,
0.6582545638,
-0.1487060189,
0.6138504148,
-0.8057619333,
0.2883639932,
0.1879244149,
0.4245794713,
0.3089126945,
-0.0068834899,
0.6981158257,
0.0118642692,
-0.7457609177,
-0.4705298841,
0.4910038114,
-1.0214731693,
-0.0159151964,
1.1005376577,
-0.0909144655,
-0.0669490099,
-0.5174064636,
-0.3847723901,
-0.0700348094,
-0.3334000707,
0.8182448149,
1.0127824545,
-0.2876328528,
-0.144001469,
-0.8882594109,
0.636061132,
0.1911938637,
-0.6310058832,
0.2755336165,
0.3812752962,
0.1568396688,
0.2865935564,
0.5992831588,
-0.2042294294,
0.3049601018,
0.1476497352,
-0.1365036964,
0.3785841167,
-0.2923653424,
-0.0088598356,
0.1260491759,
0.2369801551,
-0.0297745094
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.