id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09694v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09694v2
|
Whispers of Doubt Amidst Echoes of Triumph in NLP Robustness
| 2023-11-16T09:09:32 | 2024-04-03T15:07:45 |
Ashim Gupta, Rishanth Rajendhran, Nathan Stringham, Vivek Srikumar, Ana Marasović
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Do larger and more performant models resolve NLP's longstanding robustness
issues? We investigate this question using over 20 models of different sizes
spanning different architectural choices and pretraining objectives. We conduct
evaluations using (a) out-of-domain and challenge test sets, (b) behavioral
testing with CheckLists, (c) contrast sets, and (d) adversarial inputs. Our
analysis reveals that not all out-of-domain tests provide insight into
robustness. Evaluating with CheckLists and contrast sets shows significant gaps
in model performance; merely scaling models does not make them adequately
robust. Finally, we point out that current approaches for adversarial
evaluations of models are themselves problematic: they can be easily thwarted,
and in their current forms, do not represent a sufficiently deep probe of model
robustness. We conclude that not only is the question of robustness in NLP as
yet unresolved, but even some of the approaches to measure robustness need to
be reassessed.
|
[
-0.4107479453,
-0.7439869046,
0.2556221485,
0.2226895988,
0.191187188,
0.2891091406,
-0.0900851786,
-0.6669183373,
-0.1800376922,
0.3210355937,
-0.5287609696,
0.0017475256,
-1.061086297,
0.1435350925,
-0.8341174722,
1.173417449,
0.2234945744,
-0.1189160421,
-0.2266402841,
-0.3459458053,
-0.3967542052,
-0.5951206088,
-0.6703926921,
-0.369019419,
0.2176882029,
-0.3688340485,
1.2552708387,
0.1896941066,
0.8751088977,
0.287712723,
-0.5438730717,
0.1188994497,
-0.3898130357,
0.3718359768,
-0.0908754095,
-0.8029168844,
-0.5794920921,
-0.0584379956,
0.6954249144,
0.8934838772,
-0.0300653484,
0.1545181274,
0.3567724526,
0.4872761965,
-0.5665388107,
-0.2663436532,
-1.1821768284,
0.0776555538,
-0.06735266,
0.1457382292,
-0.4042755365,
-0.0057245907,
0.5024715662,
-0.3719874322,
0.3758402765,
0.2417140454,
1.1250253916,
0.6801356673,
-0.3807990551,
-0.4728563428,
-0.6777815819,
1.0862096548,
-0.9380621314,
0.2572283745,
0.4992363453,
0.2832234204,
-0.2194320261,
-1.0682772398,
-0.3147596717,
-0.5000938773,
0.0282141361,
0.1308483034,
-0.6317881346,
-0.110548526,
0.5321974158,
0.5386385322,
-0.6947521567,
0.0998258367,
0.022523582,
-0.2309966087,
0.4148783982,
0.0671802983,
0.2282570899,
-0.0291040521,
-0.3794555962,
-0.2856327891,
-0.5992999077,
-0.0122405933,
0.4354987442,
0.3672068417,
0.1537899971,
0.4609553218,
0.2658001184,
0.65823102,
-0.1362484992,
-0.1218652129,
-0.2977907956,
-0.3859130144,
-0.1848942637,
-0.4319094121,
0.7325139642,
0.2317300141,
0.0161564313,
-0.359233886,
-0.4296757579,
0.2443990856,
0.8552390933,
-0.5986341834,
-0.4452157617,
0.5250885487,
-0.5243115425,
-0.5847093463,
-0.2632140219,
-0.7164974809,
-0.4520719945,
0.0873003304,
0.7818844914,
-0.4234618545,
-0.2205163538,
0.1835972667,
-0.1489555985,
-0.0098831626,
0.1258939356,
-0.8595456481,
0.3839937449,
0.9590934515,
0.7762495279,
-0.2074675411,
-0.2902936041,
-0.1690336019,
-0.6056876779,
-0.4636407197,
0.4541777968,
-0.3115959466,
-0.3810052276,
0.1540650576,
-0.1012999266,
-0.3229320049,
-0.5781368017,
0.8853801489,
-0.3614744246,
0.290332377,
-0.3423047662,
-0.4705655277,
-0.0771325231,
0.5579537153,
-0.6154093146,
0.9914710522,
0.1119049713,
-1.1940484047,
0.4682497978,
-0.4890557826,
-0.4292586744,
-0.2935875654,
0.0458756648,
-0.5506335497,
0.2416671365,
0.1384226233,
0.2695414424,
-0.2095001042,
0.2031358331,
-0.4945335686,
-0.2917158306,
0.3352342844,
-0.8565144539,
1.2685679197,
0.1298802346,
-0.4847736657,
-0.0610959679,
-0.8354130983,
0.2296055853,
0.0844914243,
-0.0598128065,
-0.1996411681,
0.1891643256,
-0.3696143031,
0.0100109354,
0.038639266,
-0.0280660223,
-0.0612028576,
-0.6389664412,
0.4684993327,
0.5852815509,
-0.3293819129,
0.1544149816,
-0.7062826753,
0.8008319736,
-0.3343429863,
0.3359000683,
-0.1300558299,
-0.6667540669,
-1.0310239792,
0.1199604571,
0.5013361573,
0.4039205015,
-0.5767450333,
0.6133375764,
-0.2160637677,
-0.8473372459,
-0.2970888913,
-0.0333029591,
0.3984761536,
0.4850203991,
0.3755660951,
-0.4502291381,
-0.3173788786,
-0.6954532266,
-0.3830181956,
-0.6056304574,
-0.0379068628,
0.0790304989,
0.9016465545,
-0.1867342442,
0.5999233723,
-0.1973881721,
-0.0327032879,
0.0040218127,
0.2779123187,
0.1013085917,
0.4518460929,
0.6875473857,
-0.6976354122,
-0.0564931557,
-0.2030137628,
-0.6120617986,
0.2528573871,
-0.1463471502,
0.1813506335,
-0.2103567719,
0.4204104245,
-0.5286831856,
0.3087106049,
0.7893564701,
-0.0848686621,
0.8644456267,
0.0478230007,
-0.2706328034,
-0.9221060276,
0.0400991552,
-0.3323812783,
-0.0748747587,
-0.5018687248,
0.4789789021,
-0.188265115,
0.055659201,
-0.0917630121,
0.057854332,
-0.2537754178,
0.1237663478,
-0.2422459871,
0.1367457807,
0.3960976005,
0.0690318644,
-0.176092118,
0.7038416862,
0.8962666988,
-0.6014992595,
0.265229553,
0.2284847349,
-0.3538971841,
0.5204071999,
-0.9346853495,
0.2513604462,
0.2351332307,
0.1050692797,
-0.8705199957,
-0.1256914735,
-0.1894776821,
-0.5933981538,
0.4675166607,
-0.2698905468,
-0.2640531957,
-0.4754638374,
-0.4090940058,
0.2693622708,
0.4757181704,
-0.6471886039,
0.5636383891,
0.2039204985,
0.0498738773,
-0.9629107714,
-0.7608664036,
0.2825651467,
-0.4192473888,
-0.7254548669,
0.1096887514,
-0.0310627762,
-0.6213598251,
-0.2911869287,
-0.156621635,
-0.1149099171,
0.6345167756,
0.3117674291,
0.1071267128,
-0.506914258,
0.0677795187,
-0.3526340723,
0.1798620671,
0.3862383366,
-0.2904490232,
0.1840850413,
-0.5201074481,
-0.6577553153,
0.0042769844,
0.3994533718,
0.6186451912,
-0.2321150601,
0.6561378837,
0.7598030567,
-0.4074540436,
-0.5100990534,
-0.3746756911,
-0.1940465719,
-0.4706992209,
0.5939350128,
-0.1802760065,
-0.7909122109,
0.6885684729,
-0.2334854752,
0.2014162689,
0.6460257769,
0.4273359179,
-0.0189254601,
1.0776299238,
0.6544551253,
0.0576498881,
-0.0630412549,
-0.2350424677,
0.5061435103,
-0.6928590536,
0.1087223068,
-1.0621781349,
-0.0698998272,
-0.5346896648,
-0.1787747741,
0.2123655826,
0.1751421392,
-0.0160417017,
0.3963203132,
-0.5018928647,
0.2091641128,
0.4245428741,
-0.3070038259,
0.201544717,
-0.2563901842,
0.0327272974,
-0.2958565056,
-0.8968129754,
-0.7249641418,
1.0828723907,
0.5643123388,
0.6390303373,
0.3090834916,
0.2607613504,
-0.0094488608,
0.211453259,
-0.8586236835,
0.1795545369,
-0.2351682484,
-0.9566248655,
-0.2324875742,
-0.2707582712,
-1.1185058355,
0.2820406258,
-0.4517678618,
-0.7538627386,
0.2427550107,
0.019911306,
-0.7555981874,
0.5101496577,
-0.5730358958,
0.733581841,
-0.2749583125,
0.0337639786,
0.3834018409,
-0.7275341153,
0.5115568638,
-0.2239974886,
0.0323726609,
0.3370202482,
0.1676080972,
0.8323275447,
-0.4213758707,
0.7908833623,
0.4139896631,
-0.3475415111,
0.2955374718,
0.2824658155,
0.5392554402,
-0.0283281151,
-0.0833300427,
0.0421789773,
0.2763493061,
-0.3385046422,
-0.6893544793,
0.4236228168,
-0.565399766,
-0.5540101528,
-0.4018988907,
-0.2866319418,
-0.6967537403,
0.2202412486,
0.6492214799,
0.7708209157,
-0.2557571828,
0.4995032251,
0.8556225896,
-0.0695973411,
0.3671771884,
0.0986102745,
-0.2332381159,
-0.1406360567,
0.8384897709,
0.0881527066,
0.5728594065,
0.0240354445,
0.0594590493,
-0.3317045867,
-1.1177284718,
-0.1710923761,
-0.2589645982,
-0.7579566836,
-0.1579433531,
-0.5043950677,
-0.1967739314,
-0.5203418136,
0.0269475002,
-0.8440830112,
-0.239632234,
-0.1557511836,
0.076214686,
-0.0636888891,
0.937253058,
0.1911400855,
0.1935398281,
-0.5570964813,
0.2823717594,
0.5031188726,
0.1432677507,
0.1547554284,
-0.9031111002,
-0.1190928444,
-0.0543437898,
-0.4337025881,
-0.6508645415,
0.2734077275,
0.3004281819,
0.3585285842,
0.5838177204,
0.3755691946,
0.5054782629,
-0.3205607235,
1.1464875937,
0.0226727445,
-0.7535564303,
0.432813853,
-0.2979272306,
-0.0187514387,
0.6792370081,
0.4870012105,
0.0130531564,
-0.5914179087,
-1.0561224222,
-0.9120077491,
0.2185508609,
0.398247838,
0.3507161438,
0.0651101917,
0.3433879614,
0.1659654975,
0.045440264,
-0.73519665,
-0.3620524704,
-0.2512561977,
0.1343605369,
-0.0417661779,
-0.4318400323,
-0.620123148,
0.0739988238,
0.5119425654,
-0.1839247644,
0.018210521,
0.311781019,
0.1544628888,
0.1467054188,
0.0730974898,
0.3944505453,
0.8987499475,
-0.1368045658,
0.3225912452,
0.3371630609,
-0.5208831429,
-0.0285821967,
-0.0384740047,
-0.2951670587,
0.0452831313,
1.0464513302,
0.7936940789,
0.0604503602,
-0.4168497026,
0.7560982704,
-0.3544722199,
-0.3280184865,
-0.3275102377,
0.0666198209,
-0.1441476941,
0.1117686257,
0.1834664047,
0.7747659087,
0.2132435143,
-0.543295145,
0.0992603898,
0.6634693146,
-0.665649116,
-0.3770201206,
0.6901931167,
-0.1896733046,
-0.3381495476,
0.4414295256,
-0.2050222903,
-0.8703553677,
0.4159480333,
0.4620243907,
0.8363509178,
0.123851724,
0.1735803038,
0.1795643568,
0.8822753429,
-0.376024276,
-0.1375048906,
0.1030150205,
-0.7761728764,
-0.5134077668,
-0.5314280391,
-0.7110099792,
0.3217176199,
-0.9027435184,
-0.146800667,
-0.4535327554,
-0.6699637175,
-0.0448243171,
0.0798765346,
-0.3928845525,
0.4621843696,
-0.2384636253,
0.8868627548,
-0.7605066299,
0.3211902678,
0.4798706174,
-0.0579197742,
-0.8238221407,
0.2934331298,
-0.0193647947,
-0.4718119502,
0.2361930758,
-0.0311115924,
-0.2494311482,
-0.4897221923,
-0.5569906235,
-0.7397071123,
0.6937509775,
0.6350545287,
-0.1847656667,
0.0481419377,
-0.314308852,
0.7821554542,
0.0637740046,
0.2679177821,
0.5153109431,
0.4101959467,
-0.2264340073,
-1.2225255966,
-0.0791333914,
-0.3332807422,
-0.1222079173,
-0.4092151523,
-0.7157851458,
0.8452484012,
-0.187998116,
-0.1915334761,
0.2831524909,
0.6102075577,
-0.183466956,
0.1700734794,
0.5913824439,
0.5566846728,
1.0922343731,
-0.2920137644,
1.4052557945,
-0.0086611276,
0.2856713235,
1.2605063915,
-0.2050898969,
0.9560546279,
0.2624762952,
-0.6014786959,
0.0544232428,
0.4917683899,
-0.1711195111,
0.0474957339,
0.2772910893,
-0.0669489652,
-0.3815498948,
-0.1108238101,
-0.5165219307,
0.6585171223,
0.1251960993,
-0.179258436,
-0.0582599305,
-0.3707079291,
-0.0558861084,
0.2249335349,
0.1537241936,
0.5018582344,
0.1292913556,
-0.8077958822,
0.7520918846,
-0.2028998137,
0.8654757738,
-0.6659590006,
0.2782969475,
0.0107801594,
0.2683155835,
-0.0274593849,
-0.4094854593,
0.5916857123,
-0.1137000695,
-0.0055252565,
0.0291068032,
0.827340126,
0.0922265947,
-0.4591507316,
0.415928781,
0.5814467669,
0.1064343899,
-0.3096700609,
-0.8656713963,
0.2191697359,
-0.0089854198,
-0.2654698193,
0.4123654664,
0.4117895067,
0.2493988723,
0.9342303276,
0.4772925973,
0.3272629678,
0.1869654208,
0.1499556452,
0.618452251,
-0.145444572,
-0.1142758131,
-0.8006347418,
0.3114301562,
-0.0825877413,
-0.7036146522,
0.9582059979,
0.1674938947,
0.5686494708,
0.2676590681,
0.6252219081,
0.1765379906,
0.4187842011,
-0.5136922002,
0.9292793274,
-0.5611905456,
0.2506698966,
-0.3733859658,
-0.8117495775,
-0.465785861,
0.613735795,
0.1627103388,
0.3036197424,
0.7221871018,
0.776550293,
0.2114793062,
0.277533412,
0.467967093,
0.4055819511,
0.2953841984,
0.2907435596,
1.2103592157,
-0.8021506667,
0.7137150168,
-0.3464144468,
-0.031232493,
0.1417108029,
-1.062615037,
-0.9428873658,
-0.6855838299,
-0.501295805,
-0.701397717,
-0.0170747936,
0.2872900367,
0.8397218585,
-0.9686306715,
0.1994194388,
0.0102240611,
0.2123368829,
-0.2818965018,
-0.1488479376,
0.4855720699,
-0.4269615412,
-0.5370827913,
0.6215751767,
-0.0880030841,
0.2126239091,
-0.459818989,
0.2215092927,
0.2499565333,
0.2057376951,
0.4194990396,
0.1016691923,
-0.6662248373,
-0.418419987,
-0.0775930136,
0.0801999271,
-0.3584698737,
0.5601141453,
-0.3286150694,
0.3771567941,
0.2232882231,
0.7687664032,
-0.1518928558,
-0.0766445473,
0.5934309959,
-0.6748984456,
-0.0618267618,
0.4921169281,
0.5615307689,
0.4462347329,
-0.1381491721,
0.4321470559,
-0.0497433841,
-0.677921772,
-1.3437168598,
0.2239467949,
-0.887544632,
-0.1752808541,
0.7795465589,
-0.5196990967,
-0.0155807296,
-0.3322299123,
-0.0279698689,
-0.2211172134,
0.3712982237,
0.9069426656,
1.2373406887,
0.0592031851,
0.3893924356,
-0.6260322332,
0.8435751796,
0.8247981668,
-0.2307655066,
0.1468548626,
0.0450394191,
-0.0339175053,
0.7756078243,
0.2294357568,
-0.1931491643,
0.0240795594,
0.6737763286,
-0.5981296301,
0.1840999275,
-0.3722831011,
-0.3687156439,
0.4714449346,
0.475889504,
0.2545747757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09693v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09693v2
|
BLT: Can Large Language Models Handle Basic Legal Text?
| 2023-11-16T09:09:22 | 2024-02-28T14:46:25 |
Andrew Blair-Stanek, Nils Holzenberger, Benjamin Van Durme
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.1; I.2.7; J.7
|
We find that the best publicly available LLMs like GPT-4, Claude, and {PaLM
2} currently perform poorly at basic legal text handling. We introduce a
benchmark consisting of tasks that lawyers and paralegals would expect LLMs to
handle zero-shot, such as looking up the text at a line of a witness deposition
or at a subsection of a contract. LLMs' poor performance on this benchmark
casts into doubt their reliability as-is for legal practice. However,
fine-tuning for these tasks brings even a smaller model to near-perfect
performance on our test set and also raises performance on a related legal
task. These results suggest that many simple behaviors needed for a domain may
not be present in foundational LLMs, without additional engagement from subject
matter experts.
|
[
-0.0236607697,
-0.8188948631,
0.9075407982,
0.0853623599,
-0.5615497828,
-0.1459106207,
-0.2972810268,
-0.6825455427,
-0.3640817404,
0.8570238948,
-0.2398447543,
-0.5169126391,
-1.0012375116,
0.1090986729,
-0.7107541561,
1.0835348368,
0.132535547,
0.0319402069,
-0.2794888318,
-0.423435986,
-0.4637286365,
-0.6118295193,
-0.6728040576,
-0.4890398085,
0.420052439,
0.3639082611,
0.7726607919,
0.6291294098,
0.6350206137,
0.1684665829,
-0.3598214388,
-0.1416123211,
-0.5973687172,
0.214355424,
-0.3863596022,
-0.5370032787,
-0.6825460196,
0.1077976227,
0.7018321157,
0.5820051432,
-0.0525435135,
0.1455506235,
-0.2150309533,
0.6998341084,
-0.5778622627,
-0.0985417888,
-0.8227310181,
-0.1451054811,
-0.3316214085,
0.0248370972,
-0.5524528623,
-0.0899853781,
0.0421118401,
-0.3184467852,
0.2890916467,
0.1618173271,
1.0585882664,
0.3622843325,
-0.8539460301,
-0.3826462328,
-0.7550913692,
0.6644551158,
-0.7157874107,
0.3644455075,
0.5294749737,
0.2382086217,
0.0084822467,
-0.7844816446,
-0.5113633871,
-0.4805305004,
-0.026268797,
0.0095178355,
-0.4514074326,
0.3417675793,
0.7259739041,
0.1929914355,
-0.6517236829,
0.2724383175,
-0.3205996752,
-0.0289091878,
0.6742662191,
0.4214200079,
0.1908899546,
0.1001875624,
-0.0815442502,
0.2329858392,
-1.1230882406,
0.0122557217,
0.0801942796,
0.2210541368,
-0.1637271494,
0.770383358,
-0.0697252974,
0.7870693803,
0.0137251448,
-0.0039359797,
-0.1108037382,
-0.3929459155,
-0.7150056958,
-0.0065341229,
0.700511992,
0.3445481956,
0.5120739937,
-0.0254494734,
-0.3831883669,
-0.4503818452,
0.3296115398,
-0.8067686558,
-0.1303070933,
0.3476825058,
-0.3278045356,
-0.024819212,
-0.2602293789,
-0.4023765624,
-0.5550425053,
-0.5461961031,
0.4650166035,
-0.2830520868,
0.1506666243,
0.0689714476,
-0.016009558,
0.3604352772,
0.5597667694,
-0.6355108023,
0.5803938508,
0.7108181715,
0.8635855317,
-0.0096014887,
-0.0241739731,
-0.8854355812,
0.3053276539,
-0.467769891,
0.5721361041,
-0.4043848217,
-0.4309780896,
0.0886468366,
-0.0993776247,
0.0791836083,
-0.5832258463,
0.5786293149,
-0.5434894562,
-0.2668900788,
-0.5165715814,
-0.743725419,
0.114162825,
0.3246894777,
-0.5355452895,
0.5006961823,
0.0246844646,
-0.5956385732,
0.5072193146,
-0.4620282948,
-0.6098392606,
0.3282426,
-0.3446002007,
-0.5225829482,
0.2686054111,
-0.0241222773,
0.5469889045,
-0.4030967653,
0.1313550323,
-0.2059297264,
-0.7221800089,
0.1265761554,
-0.3637741506,
0.7554743886,
0.1906353086,
-0.3895945847,
-0.1437387317,
-0.7215154767,
-0.080014348,
-0.0136484103,
-0.5243242383,
-0.1477673352,
0.0330729857,
0.019056743,
0.1804618686,
0.2758415341,
-0.615114212,
0.1291279793,
-0.2795926332,
0.2960208058,
0.6826484799,
-0.0657594204,
0.3185850382,
-0.2860191166,
0.4820622504,
-0.052789256,
-0.1969694346,
-0.0737289041,
-0.4795201719,
-0.884814024,
-0.2710587382,
0.442371279,
0.4334722161,
-0.5384947062,
-0.0189016163,
-0.4846220911,
-0.5407547355,
-0.3711076975,
0.3794652224,
0.7275446057,
0.2462830991,
0.288264215,
-0.0941861123,
-0.2175749242,
-1.0685377121,
-0.4813753664,
-0.063294217,
0.0290644635,
0.3268755674,
0.376902163,
-0.0811599717,
0.7024327517,
-0.2656919658,
-0.249802202,
-0.3960337639,
0.3416360319,
0.3821400702,
-0.0247527696,
0.7050855756,
-0.7213608027,
-0.6127415895,
0.2538080215,
-0.7573524714,
-0.2657032311,
0.105010435,
0.3126482964,
0.3923993111,
0.5326758027,
-0.6421489716,
0.3545338511,
0.3770521283,
-0.5175762773,
0.5306607485,
-0.4172213674,
-0.0627211779,
-0.5772954226,
0.1601699591,
0.3600001633,
-0.6514853835,
-0.8559478521,
0.273207128,
0.3552922308,
-0.181664452,
-0.7706064582,
0.7180219889,
-0.4645999074,
-0.4109455049,
-0.6065174341,
0.0621919036,
-0.2658109367,
0.1756304353,
-0.0086139319,
0.9070358872,
0.5353525877,
-0.8321557045,
0.2089150101,
0.0923655704,
-0.1366375387,
0.9034621119,
-0.832901895,
0.1839541793,
-0.2677058876,
0.0002695932,
-0.6243431568,
-0.3300701976,
-0.0437572114,
-0.1422668546,
0.4946568906,
-0.5017534494,
-0.8523747325,
-0.2408492863,
-0.0739630386,
0.1651888192,
0.6746092439,
-0.0664819106,
0.3988941312,
0.1899565309,
-0.1345199943,
-0.5237026215,
-0.8860940933,
0.252121985,
0.0315619074,
-0.4026536644,
0.0046662106,
0.0634453595,
-0.3117007613,
0.0093314936,
-0.2022089213,
-0.3078044653,
0.0459079482,
0.3498235047,
-0.1156988218,
-0.3600195646,
0.1299461275,
0.0221131854,
0.143625319,
0.0724756941,
0.0967678428,
0.2670211494,
-0.1104427204,
-0.4614136219,
-0.1852178425,
0.0018565278,
0.6635605097,
0.0204281677,
0.3499288261,
-0.0161299035,
-0.4348476827,
0.0017551794,
-0.7576309443,
0.3178848624,
-0.497949183,
0.2311329246,
-0.4940105677,
-1.0558750629,
0.2423648983,
0.1780315936,
0.1445409805,
0.3932838142,
0.9212778211,
-0.2267562896,
0.4912774861,
0.6683718562,
-0.1550661772,
0.1901225001,
-0.0643292591,
0.1248538718,
-0.5168575048,
0.0559052974,
-0.6144071221,
-0.1700433344,
-0.6038416028,
-0.2541030645,
0.2924359143,
0.0533105657,
-0.4372719824,
0.5877035856,
-0.1937938631,
0.6715188026,
0.6943536401,
-0.066564627,
0.5130825043,
-0.1226184443,
-0.3553677797,
0.0899703056,
-0.4387540221,
-0.8294197321,
1.1966336966,
0.4147608578,
0.5592606664,
0.2726871371,
0.6941817999,
0.2220656723,
0.2697808444,
-0.5798594356,
0.7369423509,
-0.5081942081,
-0.9099657536,
-0.4472964108,
-0.3322201967,
-1.0743713379,
0.2264486253,
-0.0283287391,
-0.8014444113,
-0.0465323776,
0.1797216386,
-0.308060497,
0.2712732852,
-0.4160023928,
0.8241880536,
-0.220816493,
-0.5288093686,
-0.1659121066,
-0.4840767086,
0.4465381205,
-0.3277764618,
0.2595584095,
-0.3059078753,
-0.2000300139,
0.3830517828,
-0.3163865209,
0.7736174464,
-0.2543296814,
-0.1154767051,
0.3216347992,
0.50451684,
0.5265361071,
-0.0621796437,
-0.1377241015,
-0.055534292,
0.1869768202,
-0.6793909073,
-0.4941798747,
0.5904636383,
-0.590005815,
-0.6352075338,
-0.5567309856,
-0.3407072127,
-0.381524235,
0.2730546296,
0.2723527253,
0.2570112944,
-0.0874109119,
0.2627826929,
0.6580365896,
-0.00034473,
0.633769989,
1.016630888,
0.1596679837,
-0.0508194938,
0.8337476254,
0.3105141222,
0.0966494679,
0.2377061546,
0.0304249544,
-0.37934497,
-1.1445000172,
-0.4520982802,
0.3112139106,
-0.7895064354,
-0.1395040452,
-0.5540674329,
-0.2913846374,
-0.0829862952,
-0.1204651892,
-0.1125537828,
-0.1555884778,
-0.2130509764,
-0.1049286202,
0.1860573441,
0.9731811881,
0.1993716955,
0.2968631685,
-1.0319459438,
0.2271614522,
0.3012085259,
0.4717926085,
-0.3569500446,
-0.8708981872,
-0.2097989917,
-0.0840613469,
-0.4319331348,
-0.3135711849,
0.1408907175,
-0.0533808768,
0.5434911251,
0.1866851896,
-0.1256060898,
0.4183447063,
-0.7911633849,
0.9020436406,
0.1771194041,
-0.9398142695,
0.5861986876,
-0.6247000694,
0.2429129928,
0.6568533182,
0.4473426342,
-0.3741244674,
-0.6992982626,
-0.5486629009,
-0.5521757603,
0.7009227872,
0.4676303267,
0.5106735826,
0.0399715453,
0.588131845,
-0.1833928376,
0.4129572809,
-0.8243144155,
-0.0610462986,
0.1935999393,
-0.0307689477,
-0.3060003519,
-0.4942923486,
0.023258552,
-0.1975905299,
0.2874512672,
0.0080597363,
0.2932952344,
0.0482090972,
-0.306099534,
-0.2855313122,
0.3020242155,
1.1081199646,
0.8337839842,
-0.2652954161,
0.1076047719,
0.2281701118,
-0.4141671956,
0.3947460949,
-0.1681742668,
-0.3321124613,
0.0428028479,
0.5674114823,
0.7431261539,
0.4594865143,
-0.7231231928,
0.722001195,
0.1226195842,
-0.6769009233,
-0.1833207905,
0.1920437217,
0.0637581795,
0.2109413594,
0.2713637948,
-0.3034481704,
0.0476953238,
-0.7187908888,
0.4206694663,
0.3410874307,
-0.4817724228,
-0.2116741687,
0.8717439771,
0.1808915585,
-0.3945183456,
0.4079322517,
-0.323720336,
-0.2531479597,
0.5951576829,
0.3600119352,
0.6964467168,
0.3342056572,
-0.0611911789,
0.1291695982,
0.4186272323,
-0.2469572574,
0.1809710413,
0.2896491885,
-0.5307247043,
-0.6391738057,
-0.4144971967,
-0.771936059,
0.3408157825,
-0.3009607196,
0.2330352515,
-0.7568772435,
-0.0847207829,
0.05072565,
0.1274501383,
-0.8485586047,
0.4047338665,
0.1341046244,
0.9231939316,
-0.5860372782,
0.9151155353,
0.7584804893,
-0.5778636336,
-0.5069199204,
0.1250212491,
0.0793837905,
-0.5826685429,
0.9003126025,
-0.0957928598,
0.1477667093,
-0.1371580511,
-0.4875740409,
-0.4692938924,
1.0620871782,
0.6630655527,
-1.0116909742,
-0.2101807445,
0.4360046387,
0.8830545545,
0.0291450042,
0.2439830005,
0.4899414182,
0.5156566501,
0.1609362215,
-1.2142244577,
0.2058785707,
0.1245035753,
-0.1077320129,
0.113238588,
-0.8056294918,
0.8465747237,
0.2091804147,
-0.0308136083,
-0.0381234363,
0.3242396116,
0.3505835831,
0.6972626448,
0.1129175946,
0.6977146864,
0.6573492289,
-0.0993240476,
1.5795817375,
-0.2493085563,
0.3563736975,
1.1694903374,
-0.6599091887,
0.9474992156,
0.2090953887,
-0.280902952,
-0.0768840164,
0.3839336336,
-0.2225123644,
0.3016002178,
0.4081892669,
-0.2229893953,
-0.4229851961,
0.2108782381,
0.1663040519,
0.3568757474,
0.196177274,
-0.3028478622,
-0.3776976466,
-0.1737482399,
-0.1799119711,
0.1899971515,
-0.6364962459,
0.7471489906,
0.3837948442,
-0.5157226324,
0.3859642148,
0.340857029,
0.5226797462,
-0.2027982324,
0.1607136875,
-0.3319397867,
-0.0222195238,
0.005504413,
-1.0644494295,
0.3280067444,
0.3011190891,
0.0476082936,
-0.1927548945,
0.931417644,
-0.0524313375,
-0.4433125854,
0.3324372768,
0.7064855099,
0.4641921818,
-0.160910666,
-0.6027075052,
-0.089051351,
-0.3858191073,
-0.2321405709,
0.5743037462,
0.676402986,
-0.086142242,
0.8823573589,
0.4094694257,
0.276124984,
0.2839398384,
0.0944942832,
0.7183429003,
-0.8999745846,
0.0433404148,
-1.0346368551,
0.3461926281,
-0.1684573144,
-0.3523362577,
0.4548674524,
0.7463058233,
0.7283942103,
0.0270731747,
0.655246973,
0.2755917907,
0.5358378291,
-0.7723176479,
0.711288631,
-0.4849110246,
0.072998032,
-0.0356837288,
-1.0413408279,
-0.3829863071,
0.3278903365,
-0.2042862475,
0.055330798,
0.7553460002,
0.4022273719,
-0.3424888253,
-0.2836219668,
1.1420249939,
0.1411087066,
0.347545743,
0.5519970655,
0.598193109,
-0.3198090494,
0.6921607852,
0.0316830873,
0.2879382968,
-0.4817505777,
-0.9062284231,
-1.2218708992,
-0.0495126881,
-0.3313705921,
-0.1331395507,
0.3129528165,
0.7045778036,
0.6013419628,
-0.7386010885,
-0.1864159256,
-0.3133443296,
-0.1681685448,
0.3292905986,
-0.1342205107,
0.0454156436,
-0.5729045868,
-0.7462664843,
0.329446137,
0.3537739515,
0.3129661083,
0.0508599728,
-0.0666656271,
0.0178226605,
0.3067103326,
0.6730925441,
0.2548669279,
-0.7691580057,
-0.4968420863,
-0.2455446124,
-0.5505828261,
0.0666442364,
1.0727530718,
-0.3174649477,
0.1357713342,
0.1646906734,
0.8810130954,
0.8701743484,
-0.0629044473,
0.5723977685,
-0.966024816,
-0.0086253043,
0.3610631526,
0.5271741152,
-0.0546107143,
-0.166241914,
0.6325463653,
0.1701808572,
-0.6675781012,
-0.7758357525,
0.1641591638,
-1.0162597895,
-0.215560928,
1.2995046377,
-0.3679588437,
-0.1498711258,
-0.2942157686,
-0.061386954,
-0.0483621284,
-0.283711344,
0.3012490869,
1.107619524,
0.1175251454,
-0.5519778132,
-1.0362951756,
0.3610905111,
0.4148976207,
-0.5565546155,
0.0919334292,
0.4871590734,
0.7134791613,
-0.0967195481,
1.094524622,
0.0640490875,
0.5328062773,
-0.1569387019,
-0.2172694653,
-0.2225370705,
-0.1013066322,
-0.6064723134,
0.0675090402,
0.5859661698,
0.1615688205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09687v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09687v1
|
Inducing Political Bias Allows Language Models Anticipate Partisan Reactions to Controversies
| 2023-11-16T08:57:53 | 2023-11-16T08:57:53 |
Zihao He, Siyi Guo, Ashwin Rao, Kristina Lerman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social media platforms are rife with politically charged discussions.
Therefore, accurately deciphering and predicting partisan biases using Large
Language Models (LLMs) is increasingly critical. In this study, we address the
challenge of understanding political bias in digitized discourse using LLMs.
While traditional approaches often rely on finetuning separate models for each
political faction, our work innovates by employing a singular,
instruction-tuned LLM to reflect a spectrum of political ideologies. We present
a comprehensive analytical framework, consisting of Partisan Bias Divergence
Assessment and Partisan Class Tendency Prediction, to evaluate the model's
alignment with real-world political ideologies in terms of stances, emotions,
and moral foundations. Our findings reveal the model's effectiveness in
capturing emotional and moral nuances, albeit with some challenges in stance
detection, highlighting the intricacies and potential for refinement in NLP
tools for politically sensitive contexts. This research contributes
significantly to the field by demonstrating the feasibility and importance of
nuanced political understanding in LLMs, particularly for applications
requiring acute awareness of political bias.
|
[
-0.6741618514,
-0.6699001193,
0.7564517856,
0.0950503051,
-0.5270397663,
0.277207911,
-0.4391345382,
0.135609746,
0.1290038377,
0.7070680261,
-0.7363864183,
-0.495960623,
-0.8348309398,
-0.1181545183,
-0.2250455767,
1.0947716236,
0.436383307,
0.4084791243,
-0.0934410617,
-0.0265183821,
-0.0778517649,
-0.5592820048,
-0.080407463,
-0.6795448065,
0.3109840751,
0.3351510465,
0.6646000147,
0.717119813,
0.6133429408,
0.1952118576,
-0.4206776619,
-0.0600684062,
-0.6059713364,
-0.0542514175,
-0.4430589974,
-0.4172447026,
-0.1704270393,
0.2872811258,
0.3950710893,
0.4794417918,
0.0723482743,
0.1923270077,
-0.1166234761,
0.8469927907,
-0.6015582085,
0.1301914752,
-1.2897280455,
0.0931134671,
-0.2266187966,
-0.2336920947,
-0.5779988766,
-0.4091578126,
0.1940441877,
-0.3445361853,
0.120689325,
-0.2519386411,
0.8192790747,
0.2287447602,
-0.6700329185,
-0.4060197175,
-0.5462502837,
0.7794279456,
-0.6936030388,
0.2937959135,
0.3150108159,
0.0667880177,
-0.1207169071,
-0.2424575984,
-0.7164573073,
0.3257649541,
0.3803792894,
0.0891112089,
0.1895260364,
-0.0697440132,
0.1251065731,
0.2106987834,
0.0163209457,
-0.0678510815,
-0.200345695,
0.2162309736,
0.5401695371,
0.1961267292,
0.0547565594,
-0.7635108829,
-0.3967190385,
0.0882906616,
-0.474296093,
-0.2251490802,
0.8847951889,
0.5849183798,
-0.4540479183,
0.5502895713,
0.2336810827,
0.4776721597,
0.655375123,
0.1201511696,
-0.0273007154,
-0.3294922709,
-0.2337593585,
-0.0264588371,
0.8246062994,
0.5785899758,
0.6610058546,
0.4564786851,
0.0329473987,
0.1496320069,
0.3385364413,
-0.6416149139,
-0.0344151743,
0.3473032415,
-0.5505978465,
-0.594434917,
0.021368809,
-1.0816118717,
-1.2079275846,
-0.7208575606,
-0.4419713914,
-0.3675729632,
-0.498127073,
0.1795704067,
-0.0681770965,
0.3583729863,
0.34072721,
-0.7071579695,
-0.1072606519,
1.113106966,
0.7858154178,
-0.139046818,
0.2836564779,
-0.3096336126,
-0.2171857208,
-0.4833686352,
0.7161986232,
-0.8216747046,
-0.1642830968,
0.3831135929,
-0.1033123955,
0.3369960189,
-0.5166755915,
0.6351817846,
-0.7780664563,
0.2902155519,
-0.6131042838,
-0.5034953952,
-0.1585276574,
0.317320019,
-0.6324591041,
0.4760299921,
-0.1973342597,
-1.2228001356,
0.6216650605,
-0.3882420957,
-0.0025538413,
-0.1840375066,
-0.2552900314,
-0.4481956661,
0.3112048805,
0.1912759691,
0.6010807753,
-0.2782612145,
0.8356436491,
-0.6047781706,
-0.2789087892,
0.2267115563,
-0.3689614534,
1.1155267954,
-0.2474917173,
-0.3140924275,
0.1992706656,
-0.5732654333,
-0.3033185005,
0.0313855745,
-0.2833381891,
-0.4325467944,
0.3995042443,
0.0301587619,
0.3709792197,
0.0160030816,
-0.3638444543,
0.2010615617,
-0.5258008242,
0.3890809119,
1.1678886414,
-0.1554584205,
0.835257411,
-0.0077417074,
0.2481796294,
0.1375536919,
0.0357134491,
0.1228138357,
-0.1139642894,
-0.7110355496,
-0.2185123712,
0.2285733521,
0.6096027493,
-0.5920888186,
0.5513888597,
-0.3796687126,
-0.1686976105,
-0.6011909842,
0.0238336809,
0.0138842706,
0.1189268231,
0.0940397084,
0.157129392,
-0.4805283546,
-0.9613242149,
-0.556622386,
-0.3483184874,
0.0358551852,
0.4494458735,
0.6508054137,
-0.1358003914,
0.7395513654,
0.089298673,
0.0161314365,
0.0336096436,
0.1707045585,
0.1649850756,
-0.100900121,
0.0822136849,
-0.6403266191,
-0.437129885,
0.1241013706,
-0.6516050696,
-0.2844243944,
-0.2467890084,
-0.2092617601,
0.0910355449,
0.2818632722,
-0.4679122567,
0.2493273914,
0.6280307174,
-0.5431358814,
0.2945534885,
0.4836079776,
0.0758479014,
-1.0330415964,
-0.2265696675,
0.2352621257,
-0.2573963106,
-0.509006381,
-0.2344563305,
0.0717134178,
0.3339538276,
-0.7134917378,
0.2774528265,
-0.3323152065,
0.042165041,
-0.2293193638,
0.4730506539,
-0.0304970387,
-0.0322367549,
0.0432565659,
0.4544860721,
0.2461600453,
-0.0341082476,
0.0197792146,
0.0945478901,
-0.3469746113,
0.7612062097,
-0.3109821677,
0.3194413781,
-0.4943620861,
0.2139539719,
-0.7632860541,
-0.3101494908,
0.1969228983,
-0.1820550412,
0.2729200721,
-0.5705739856,
-0.3160389662,
-0.0444991998,
-0.3999179304,
0.1211199835,
0.2756072581,
-0.5948281884,
0.6556378007,
0.7954461575,
-0.0307914745,
-0.8011294007,
-0.2521648705,
0.0372946337,
-0.5259053111,
-0.3827911913,
0.1384237111,
0.4111556709,
-0.9000931382,
-0.2917071283,
0.2080153823,
0.142515108,
-0.2160469592,
0.3067853153,
0.261311233,
0.0589095801,
0.3532573283,
0.0436070226,
0.2022251934,
0.4059146345,
0.0103961201,
0.7895910144,
-0.283538878,
-0.2862206399,
-0.5001744628,
0.2155863643,
0.9635491371,
-0.1307630092,
0.6211165786,
0.3335519731,
-0.2270159274,
-0.3946083784,
-0.6723355651,
-0.2450831532,
-0.4604078829,
0.3209164739,
0.1553640664,
-0.6464104652,
0.5936185718,
-0.2430743873,
0.0823234543,
0.2122897208,
0.9175841212,
0.0202957112,
0.8153678775,
0.4485685527,
-0.0719177723,
0.3562483788,
-0.1448350102,
0.2508808672,
-0.7268903852,
-0.1961982995,
-0.3401628733,
-0.1139338538,
-0.69938308,
-0.6434157491,
-0.1209056154,
-0.3446955979,
-0.5530053973,
-0.3406118155,
-0.7242229581,
0.6544879675,
0.0692151785,
0.0241267886,
0.0291449465,
0.3239509761,
0.2750467956,
-0.5219165087,
-0.3008497059,
-0.8303613067,
0.9621886015,
0.6559883356,
0.6604858041,
-0.1741191447,
0.436550051,
0.3367030919,
0.4270866811,
-0.8570296168,
0.4603534341,
-0.3850591183,
-0.6972688437,
0.0299620274,
-0.2050068378,
-0.3590440452,
0.4908521175,
-0.4131603539,
-0.4891415536,
0.3627330661,
-0.03289406,
-0.067835018,
0.5977945924,
-0.2925048172,
0.5670474172,
-0.3505767882,
-0.6188291311,
-0.1939470023,
-0.5995287299,
0.6751077771,
-0.1564981639,
0.3660843968,
-0.5957583189,
-0.1661567539,
0.5440027714,
0.0792593434,
1.0304481983,
-0.2643224895,
-0.1318757236,
0.1034339592,
0.0661497042,
0.2646718919,
0.1165371686,
-0.4158480465,
0.4962043166,
-0.1624414325,
-0.110617958,
-0.1846822202,
0.7087988257,
-0.7168668509,
-0.6498375535,
-0.4679357111,
-0.6237751842,
-0.0545988865,
0.0326510556,
0.0384990871,
-0.2460512817,
-0.3354260921,
0.2355262786,
0.8319260478,
-0.330455631,
0.2080733329,
0.2306761891,
-0.3276351094,
-0.2176121175,
0.5263308883,
0.0535855368,
0.1575550139,
-0.146346882,
0.380464673,
-0.2419656664,
-0.1120176092,
-0.4542006552,
0.4049619734,
-0.8006767631,
-0.1670160443,
-0.5167690516,
0.0218880959,
0.1778302044,
-0.4177018404,
-0.6257750392,
-0.0348935686,
-0.597124815,
-0.0340312049,
0.3457086384,
0.7810226083,
0.2757596374,
0.434551686,
-0.1430527121,
0.3039976954,
-0.0520855412,
0.4095189273,
-0.3490281701,
-0.8084290624,
0.3267484605,
0.2249336988,
-0.2488738298,
-1.2874577045,
0.3115751147,
0.034314882,
0.0116420053,
0.56005615,
0.1408988833,
0.3605147004,
-0.70566082,
0.8037430048,
-0.040745154,
-0.9737394452,
0.5384348631,
-0.7247382998,
0.1781688929,
0.6382037997,
0.5074155927,
-0.0724818781,
-0.4854624569,
-0.5288307071,
-0.7167272568,
0.5392180681,
-0.1802420169,
0.6440645456,
-0.2350237072,
0.4684386253,
0.0709605813,
0.2471740991,
-0.8232307434,
0.1016602293,
-0.2411463261,
-0.2793402076,
0.252015084,
-0.3488467634,
-0.3815900087,
-0.1469603479,
0.5330215693,
-0.2256855369,
-0.0948460177,
-0.1263688952,
0.2538029253,
-0.1515663862,
0.2916157246,
0.472667098,
0.6182590127,
-0.1600402296,
0.2137680054,
0.0246476121,
-0.1874691844,
0.102870211,
-0.3275050521,
-0.2466470897,
0.2360670716,
0.1720967442,
0.469324857,
-0.2924605012,
-0.348863095,
0.7676985264,
0.0296955109,
-0.0787974,
-0.4404965639,
-0.3842449486,
0.5842743516,
0.3342719674,
0.0356007963,
-0.1583327502,
-0.0114512136,
-0.6597622633,
0.0730269924,
0.9979649186,
-0.6080757976,
-0.132459715,
0.4357953072,
0.3277010322,
-0.415156126,
0.5378505588,
-0.168135494,
-0.7365039587,
0.6207655668,
0.3794182241,
0.8047695756,
-0.2108419985,
0.3778228164,
0.2401818484,
0.4931602776,
0.1633023024,
0.211790055,
0.3961574137,
-0.8035843968,
-0.4355515242,
-0.4756073058,
-0.2824898958,
0.2447195351,
-0.5070376396,
0.493904978,
-0.9128273129,
-0.7693374753,
0.1941845119,
-0.0250006728,
-0.3288037181,
-0.1414514482,
0.3142625391,
0.5047397614,
-1.1620457172,
0.3548114002,
0.3562099934,
0.1974515021,
-0.2317405194,
0.296605438,
0.488878727,
-0.6892510653,
0.6715288162,
0.0214031264,
-0.2503177822,
-0.5558688641,
-0.7324367166,
-0.4261991978,
0.4460859597,
0.7151284814,
-0.6361874938,
0.14495112,
0.1730243117,
0.4179196656,
-0.5362201333,
0.0664715469,
0.578964293,
0.4483931959,
-0.3246054053,
-0.4184632003,
0.0308651272,
-0.0510477684,
-0.077097699,
0.2494672537,
-0.6272541881,
0.8148597479,
0.0319820084,
-0.2092146575,
-0.7806640863,
0.4206525385,
0.169531554,
0.3401354551,
0.4608793259,
0.0949730054,
0.7118062377,
-0.2931717932,
0.8493417501,
-0.5225927234,
0.1911317557,
1.085729599,
-0.4264709353,
0.6801835299,
0.8331848383,
0.0343012437,
0.6258884072,
0.5873422027,
-0.0259461589,
0.2953008115,
0.4536883533,
-0.4199769497,
-0.3179806769,
-0.4578877985,
-0.0910943225,
0.5809866786,
0.5712814927,
-0.6427995563,
-0.0300827473,
-0.1686871499,
0.3027884662,
0.5543497801,
-0.2244198769,
0.7204676867,
0.0971204415,
-0.5640739202,
0.2963404357,
-0.1340043545,
0.6671273708,
-0.0933458731,
-0.091959767,
-0.0325485095,
0.0562245511,
-0.3381356895,
-1.0790971518,
0.3596256077,
0.2020931989,
-0.3649002016,
-0.0002462752,
0.658716321,
-0.3399813175,
-0.5093004704,
0.3297415674,
0.4682929516,
-0.1723776162,
-0.031505473,
-0.7837554216,
0.6298902035,
0.2256530821,
-0.3127171695,
0.1893162131,
0.5300430059,
0.0315530673,
0.5994765162,
0.5382305384,
0.0687016398,
-0.2443037927,
0.1695498228,
0.7926029563,
-0.2455379963,
-0.0499749519,
-1.15980196,
0.6843364835,
-0.3840717673,
-0.1204047576,
0.4565320015,
0.2750166357,
0.5832815766,
0.0437519401,
0.8596723676,
0.2913188338,
0.3526291251,
-0.4338946939,
0.8284111023,
-0.2702167928,
0.334923476,
-0.1225081012,
-0.6537563801,
-0.2790753841,
0.9773606062,
-0.6782761216,
0.029050706,
0.1640319228,
0.6217127442,
-0.1532522291,
0.0479474552,
-0.0892885551,
0.1264920682,
0.132841289,
0.3145003915,
1.0608725548,
-0.0041955896,
0.2231370062,
-0.3911576569,
-0.0907564014,
-0.0591073856,
-1.1384404898,
-1.3180006742,
-0.382956624,
-0.2168873847,
-0.5571904182,
0.1461067051,
0.9433100224,
0.6417147517,
-0.5792052746,
-0.2877197564,
0.0765333995,
0.3828953505,
0.590921104,
-0.3156046867,
0.2848165631,
-0.0431213938,
-0.8851853609,
-0.2358334661,
0.2841381431,
-0.315351069,
-0.4526132643,
0.1780668646,
-0.4223006368,
0.5807317495,
0.6458251476,
-0.0915955752,
-1.0946148634,
-0.4697959721,
-0.0363671146,
-0.1645314246,
0.1309472322,
0.7057913542,
-0.4012747109,
0.6174141765,
0.5171524286,
0.5106331706,
0.1195390448,
0.4629153311,
0.4746111333,
-0.4803513587,
0.116291225,
0.5227652192,
0.1966102719,
0.7137526274,
-0.4157624245,
0.2437919527,
-0.0478861853,
-0.5908668041,
-0.8981819153,
0.4188745916,
-0.9434981942,
-0.2900830805,
1.3666341305,
0.2602185607,
-0.0439414904,
-0.1156944111,
-0.3384112418,
0.2944569588,
-0.3101034164,
0.9953560233,
0.8119666576,
0.2187729478,
-0.2723438144,
-0.7169959545,
0.4083552063,
0.2180772722,
-0.6430191398,
0.5928999186,
0.6859540343,
0.0568917282,
0.1445714384,
0.4298138022,
-0.2250003368,
0.0077067902,
-0.1657694727,
0.1171118245,
0.3543215096,
-0.1100361422,
-0.4693131447,
0.2216924727,
-0.1651647091,
0.2721528709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09684v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09684v2
|
Do Physicians Know How to Prompt? The Need for Automatic Prompt Optimization Help in Clinical Note Generation
| 2023-11-16T08:54:52 | 2024-03-19T16:27:37 |
Zonghai Yao, Ahmed Jaafar, Beining Wang, Zhichao Yang, Hong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study examines the effect of prompt engineering on the performance of
Large Language Models (LLMs) in clinical note generation. We introduce an
Automatic Prompt Optimization (APO) framework to refine initial prompts and
compare the outputs of medical experts, non-medical experts, and APO-enhanced
GPT3.5 and GPT4. Results highlight GPT4 APO's superior performance in
standardizing prompt quality across clinical note sections. A human-in-the-loop
approach shows that experts maintain content quality post-APO, with a
preference for their own modifications, suggesting the value of expert
customization. We recommend a two-phase optimization process, leveraging
APO-GPT4 for consistency and expert input for personalization.
|
[
-0.1985832453,
-0.6689062119,
1.1020503044,
0.3878912032,
-0.2351382673,
-0.0964908525,
-0.0983159244,
-0.3384367824,
-0.0471040532,
0.3214508593,
-0.6770069599,
-0.4596361816,
-0.4067568183,
0.7798522115,
0.2613928616,
0.9895874262,
-0.1570351422,
0.2562094331,
-0.0988094583,
0.2743871808,
-0.7373618484,
-0.190256983,
-1.1026540995,
-0.0835130066,
0.4881932139,
0.5148536563,
0.636523366,
1.0202393532,
0.4013874829,
0.3791284263,
0.0189097896,
0.2244199216,
-0.0626205206,
0.3742666841,
0.0643073395,
-0.1922593266,
-0.758230865,
0.0724861249,
0.2270518392,
0.4256645143,
-0.0054913415,
0.0570815988,
-0.1440401524,
0.6500223875,
-0.2148730159,
-0.0028271447,
-0.3825097084,
0.0518120341,
0.1532016546,
-0.569545269,
-0.4025306106,
-0.7880179286,
0.4060164094,
-1.0291684866,
0.6614363194,
0.2445280552,
0.6547018886,
0.5065509677,
-0.1554047912,
-0.6902014017,
-0.2634088099,
0.5081015825,
-0.6919671297,
-0.0840078816,
0.2932768762,
0.1753272712,
-0.2970850468,
-0.5363228917,
-0.219273299,
-0.4652050138,
0.0420605615,
0.1446179897,
0.0973002836,
0.5952115655,
0.4511915743,
0.2131069005,
-0.5723779202,
0.364883244,
-0.2320887446,
-0.30123806,
0.8777228594,
0.3299071789,
0.5352399349,
-0.0890585035,
-0.0458111838,
0.2892175615,
-0.6633620262,
0.1579895169,
0.2914865911,
0.1340292394,
0.2196285725,
0.2980746329,
-0.100992471,
0.6400482655,
0.2264923751,
-0.4530727863,
0.1070888489,
-0.4523876309,
0.0489526577,
0.2218952924,
0.8179726005,
0.54562217,
0.2620458305,
0.0652692541,
-0.4372586906,
-0.1785802543,
0.2886191607,
-0.5733407736,
-0.3750491738,
0.3107644618,
-0.4383885264,
-0.4420243502,
-0.3566786051,
-0.5305613875,
-0.4018548429,
-0.4785111845,
0.2166039199,
-0.2621319592,
0.3305825889,
0.081978552,
-0.1893581301,
-0.2310488522,
0.6737813354,
-0.9093027115,
0.0615495965,
0.4442031085,
0.6592014432,
-0.0107814511,
-0.0100200912,
-0.7668474913,
0.0109485509,
-0.4873843789,
1.0142921209,
-0.487570405,
-0.8704209328,
-0.0570218526,
-0.2505679131,
-0.0218519773,
-0.5801626444,
0.8056135178,
-0.3198102117,
0.4152479768,
-0.525452435,
-0.5106351972,
0.184135884,
-0.1820775419,
-0.4378983974,
0.6627786756,
0.2078170627,
-0.353510499,
0.5428873897,
-0.7722293139,
-0.3934627771,
0.330668062,
-0.372007519,
-0.4093435109,
0.4085547924,
0.5828258395,
0.2532944381,
-0.4029645622,
0.281686455,
0.0563568287,
-0.1318253875,
0.1586146653,
0.031795308,
0.3847557604,
0.2977748215,
-0.1861394346,
0.2392009646,
-0.8442592621,
-0.0441232733,
-0.0086929221,
-0.5078107119,
0.0056036348,
-0.1141426638,
-0.3114356697,
0.2780310512,
0.0873422399,
-0.4957360923,
0.3954538405,
-0.3619597852,
0.5191056728,
0.9000751972,
0.5137667656,
0.2999686003,
-0.5197615027,
0.9556576014,
-0.3086172938,
0.2783550322,
-0.5890793204,
-0.777484715,
-0.4537724257,
-0.250444591,
0.0963310972,
0.6638323665,
-0.5350058079,
0.2738956213,
0.2472091019,
-0.163436234,
-0.7138675451,
0.1483753175,
0.5370680094,
1.0915213823,
0.3556676805,
-0.1519584209,
-0.3990917206,
-0.9267839193,
-0.4566582441,
-0.0804774091,
-0.1178035513,
0.4315474927,
0.0537923425,
-0.1091894358,
1.0058575869,
-0.5973402262,
-0.1075047106,
-0.3036745191,
0.2761575878,
0.4156018198,
0.4434835613,
0.3888913989,
-0.3152523339,
-0.7567039132,
-0.2816468477,
-0.5320878625,
-0.9069045186,
-0.5167585015,
0.0199561939,
0.2443766445,
0.3854963779,
-0.6834011078,
0.1648821086,
-0.0334997401,
-0.1852761358,
0.7139419913,
-0.6624590158,
0.322183013,
-0.9404836893,
0.0678987876,
0.1782166958,
-0.0614608042,
-0.7280498147,
-0.232811287,
0.0334601477,
-0.4341955483,
-0.127056852,
0.6970553994,
-0.6497740746,
0.2245063782,
-0.4445106983,
0.1975096315,
0.1785803884,
0.0699887425,
-0.031985607,
0.9600857496,
0.396885246,
-0.5445683599,
0.2124307901,
0.453709811,
0.0102950782,
0.474259913,
-1.0190826654,
0.3611463308,
-0.1234475374,
0.1181863472,
-1.1507993937,
-0.410733521,
-0.0095937531,
-0.5645021796,
0.379912883,
-0.0973540321,
-0.4579658806,
-0.5491706133,
-0.2840940058,
0.1578584611,
0.7198557854,
-0.098370418,
0.1409770697,
-0.0148613509,
-0.7428064346,
-0.2292153239,
-0.1552105993,
0.2608590424,
-0.0226187687,
-0.6575489044,
0.3097650707,
-0.1950842589,
-0.1684543788,
-0.4481960535,
-0.0236488897,
0.1116785333,
0.0415525064,
-0.0066019711,
0.3570908308,
-0.0999935567,
0.2161976844,
0.4247324467,
-0.4251310825,
0.2594273388,
-0.1335971355,
0.2357326299,
0.4278235435,
-0.1582428217,
-1.0760009289,
0.502548337,
0.1983833462,
-0.0837516636,
0.1559141725,
0.1446899623,
-0.0404614136,
-0.1025570109,
-0.6872560978,
-0.2626473904,
-0.5948159695,
0.0914781913,
-0.4135331213,
-0.5832656026,
0.4541559517,
-0.0842424035,
0.2565285265,
0.4411202073,
0.4951975942,
-0.0795177743,
1.4197013378,
0.4329976737,
0.2115096152,
0.3039504886,
0.0957089663,
0.0978840068,
-0.6544978023,
-0.1428010911,
-0.5477685928,
-0.0233398993,
-0.3934568167,
-0.1100257263,
0.6731889844,
-0.004828996,
-0.1981250197,
-0.054517746,
-0.9391426444,
0.4106112719,
0.6072286963,
0.1812466979,
0.2305891514,
-0.2340985537,
-0.2102649957,
-0.0581493042,
-0.6850178242,
-0.8012698889,
1.0488003492,
0.4057740569,
0.5476421714,
-0.3557194173,
0.8053126931,
0.2554708123,
0.2662615776,
-0.5454162359,
0.555366993,
0.1014818624,
-0.2944480479,
-0.1439284384,
-0.2886425853,
-0.8537552953,
-0.1173844337,
-0.0025017152,
-0.4016745389,
0.0624641702,
0.5743388534,
-0.8893323541,
-0.3413841426,
-0.8736464381,
0.6711291671,
-0.0912845731,
-0.0906239003,
0.0701492727,
-0.7730981112,
-0.0073008598,
-0.1868590713,
0.2095764279,
-0.0869890079,
-0.4904019535,
0.4310651124,
-0.6759864688,
0.6303986907,
-0.3279043138,
-0.1600576341,
0.3571221232,
0.0407280251,
0.6464053392,
0.2734409869,
-0.049400676,
-0.570076406,
-0.3251099288,
-0.4152537584,
-0.5674538016,
0.6197243333,
-0.7261779308,
-0.9555937648,
-0.0864739269,
-0.3828186691,
-0.2930233479,
0.2240113765,
0.6241999865,
0.6820134521,
0.077449806,
-0.5642546415,
0.7677660584,
-0.4924404621,
0.503266871,
0.591620028,
0.508815527,
-0.6809650064,
0.4621479809,
-0.0519889891,
0.1935836673,
0.3277737796,
0.4421282709,
-0.345210284,
-0.8686598539,
-0.7078068256,
0.4665907621,
-0.7879201174,
-0.082751371,
-0.8319806457,
0.2277479172,
-0.6905944347,
-0.6097789407,
-0.0101054739,
-0.4127848744,
-0.6762553453,
-0.1211310253,
0.4696505666,
0.7490766048,
0.0664122999,
0.4654783607,
-1.0048060417,
0.1657393128,
0.1330410689,
0.0154770864,
-0.2433578223,
-0.5031195283,
-0.0587396659,
-0.4034055471,
-0.5127298832,
-0.9627330899,
0.296915561,
0.1389309317,
0.7431665063,
0.5543410182,
-0.0585118458,
0.4301432371,
-0.8350977302,
0.8934556246,
0.2478832603,
-0.8432149887,
0.9889796376,
-0.6223987937,
0.4138272703,
0.6705682874,
0.4598288238,
-0.4091006517,
-0.3579622209,
-0.5341235995,
-0.8139545918,
0.6233912706,
-0.0428826548,
0.0165824033,
-0.1829433739,
0.8539831042,
0.3842557371,
0.3238574862,
-0.2731171846,
-0.0679314435,
-0.0472666807,
-0.3399604261,
0.0095821368,
-0.3593308926,
-0.2632322013,
0.0800029188,
0.2893848717,
-0.1773124188,
0.2947899699,
0.6413360238,
0.0704220757,
-0.3690602779,
0.1455313563,
1.058650732,
0.9157034755,
0.0245247222,
-0.3424142301,
0.1451317221,
-0.5335031748,
0.2730418444,
0.2066398561,
-0.1979060769,
0.2331402898,
0.5834946036,
0.7969017029,
-0.1024131775,
-0.6241829991,
0.344443202,
0.0271063615,
-0.3071312308,
-0.0732768774,
0.3128557503,
-0.4229590893,
-0.0419380777,
0.310498327,
-0.0303107705,
0.4311252534,
-0.2193692625,
0.1587562561,
0.0742084533,
0.0158401337,
-0.4890863895,
0.9945013523,
0.4861525297,
-0.613756299,
0.4095103443,
0.0557131022,
-0.3503452241,
0.714966476,
0.4998163581,
0.9715590477,
-0.5104225278,
0.1857314557,
0.5004410744,
0.0212862417,
-0.1153544188,
0.3857515454,
-0.1170355082,
-0.13737984,
-0.6159749031,
-0.1404117942,
-0.50594908,
-0.2096711099,
-0.4211349785,
0.4153355956,
-0.7438124418,
-0.4081646204,
-0.0027830517,
-0.0128158713,
-0.5937601924,
0.4116496742,
-0.1077319682,
0.9373277426,
-0.5608249307,
0.3826988041,
0.9080917239,
-0.3498294055,
-0.9445598125,
-0.1875497401,
0.1007016376,
-0.8302248716,
0.6018915772,
0.1888027489,
0.2847515643,
0.0530848205,
-0.1956791729,
-0.5976532698,
0.9955287576,
0.0871410668,
-0.5890686512,
-0.3714824617,
0.0189898554,
0.7119909525,
-0.4771384597,
0.6579325795,
0.2864002585,
0.2602496743,
-0.0140485754,
-1.0943182707,
0.3541579843,
-0.2176389247,
0.1825374067,
0.1584952623,
-0.5107960105,
0.5453417301,
-0.6397539377,
-0.0672655851,
0.134471491,
0.2966564,
0.555442214,
0.5086740255,
0.323453635,
0.3611084521,
0.7687028646,
0.0462176725,
1.3014543056,
-0.5173584223,
-0.1497717947,
0.8630896807,
-0.1763805747,
0.0993117094,
0.3582930863,
-0.0924900472,
0.3237966299,
1.0757689476,
0.0983456373,
0.5464181304,
0.2551121414,
-0.3209296465,
-0.0891905129,
0.0735677406,
-0.4675059319,
-0.3403993845,
0.1659851223,
-0.8580791354,
0.0593845211,
-0.053802073,
0.2314960212,
0.0708365813,
-0.3464169502,
1.057913065,
0.1006904766,
-1.0754330158,
0.5628277659,
-0.175105229,
0.1226705238,
-0.4043888748,
0.1587313563,
-0.4831131995,
-0.162205115,
-0.2112990767,
-0.4224149287,
-0.1121473685,
-0.0147940163,
-0.27895087,
-0.4081943631,
0.3969417512,
-0.1095566079,
-0.1371293515,
-0.2378841639,
0.2053004205,
0.1091244891,
0.0901080444,
-0.805801928,
-0.2245305628,
-0.034097679,
-0.5053083897,
0.0618295111,
0.6760117412,
-0.019009918,
0.7503860593,
0.7252708077,
0.2532490194,
0.0374992266,
0.3241988122,
0.896094799,
-0.5923489332,
-0.580486238,
-0.9707840085,
0.5125237107,
-0.1731885672,
-0.7347088456,
0.6046536565,
0.5422848463,
0.2094189227,
-0.2191122025,
0.8145432472,
0.4300989509,
0.6892602444,
-0.5654698014,
0.3426136971,
-0.3121956587,
0.3125458956,
-0.5246673822,
-0.7886527181,
-0.3238446414,
0.2507855296,
-0.3731639087,
0.1458392888,
0.6543019414,
0.6959376931,
0.4591009021,
0.12604855,
-0.0127215525,
-0.0261928421,
0.5606726408,
0.4488781989,
0.7466239929,
-0.0297691952,
0.2552247643,
-0.074994728,
-0.5958467722,
-0.1818375587,
-0.7234153748,
-0.8707850575,
-0.2494937629,
-0.3999958336,
-0.178862676,
0.1037207842,
1.2035036087,
0.502568841,
-0.5546936393,
0.1073954999,
-0.310346365,
-0.2333650589,
0.0918273106,
-0.1837212294,
0.4524866939,
-0.9397547841,
-0.6206201315,
0.4741207361,
0.4109535813,
0.301106602,
0.0398053229,
-0.0017670523,
0.5038705468,
0.2269230187,
0.4279710948,
0.10283456,
-0.6615771055,
0.0291298199,
0.2961761355,
-0.2361008376,
0.212642625,
1.1918852329,
-0.457208395,
0.594113946,
0.6656885743,
0.4758096635,
-0.1219009534,
0.350846976,
0.9794947505,
-0.3821291625,
-0.1173201948,
0.4973604977,
0.3129784167,
0.2482155114,
-0.8869094253,
0.3200646639,
0.3404147923,
-1.0808165073,
-0.7640070319,
0.1766597778,
-0.7802225351,
-0.0968182534,
1.1653722525,
-0.1193557456,
-0.0360090174,
-0.4185416996,
-0.7104830146,
0.0283169169,
-0.8677873611,
0.9552083015,
0.5752372742,
-0.7112737298,
-0.4129605591,
-0.8115208745,
1.0417557955,
0.4825147986,
-0.8287124038,
-0.3391815722,
0.4195585847,
0.2553160489,
-0.1658581942,
1.0559185743,
-0.02058414,
0.5569810867,
-0.3101130128,
-0.0210697055,
-0.1612900347,
-0.0277309716,
-0.3724659681,
-0.0592487194,
0.2536221445,
-0.0724367797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09682v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09682v3
|
MacGyver: Are Large Language Models Creative Problem Solvers?
| 2023-11-16T08:52:27 | 2024-03-27T23:43:54 |
Yufei Tian, Abhilasha Ravichander, Lianhui Qin, Ronan Le Bras, Raja Marjieh, Nanyun Peng, Yejin Choi, Thomas L. Griffiths, Faeze Brahman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We explore the creative problem-solving capabilities of modern LLMs in a
novel constrained setting. To this end, we create MACGYVER, an automatically
generated dataset consisting of over 1,600 real-world problems deliberately
designed to trigger innovative usage of objects and necessitate out-of-the-box
thinking. We then present our collection to both LLMs and humans to compare and
contrast their problem-solving abilities. MACGYVER is challenging for both
groups, but in unique and complementary ways. For instance, humans excel in
tasks they are familiar with but struggle with domain-specific knowledge,
leading to a higher variance. In contrast, LLMs, exposed to a variety of
specialized knowledge, attempt broader problems but fail by proposing
physically-infeasible actions. Finally, we provide a detailed error analysis of
LLMs, and demonstrate the potential of enhancing their problem-solving ability
with novel prompting techniques such as iterative step-wise reflection and
divergent-convergent thinking.
This work (1) introduces a fresh arena for intelligent agents focusing on
intricate aspects of physical reasoning, planning, and unconventional thinking,
which supplements the existing spectrum of machine intelligence; and (2)
provides insight into the constrained problem-solving capabilities of both
humans and AI.
|
[
-0.6036549807,
-1.0001660585,
0.5777722597,
0.0611129887,
0.3036517203,
0.7211286426,
-0.286283344,
-0.590644598,
0.3372567594,
0.7438938618,
-1.0096601248,
-0.2325517237,
-0.4866455495,
0.2781009674,
0.0211298838,
0.7108952403,
-0.1208390445,
-0.2900318801,
-0.4165391922,
-0.0159606785,
-0.5266519785,
-0.1241043434,
-0.3806081116,
-0.417386055,
0.5254799724,
0.7801795006,
0.8357702494,
0.3594518006,
0.7174924612,
0.4155881703,
-0.0282368716,
0.4566465914,
-0.4804094136,
0.1153286621,
-0.446757108,
-0.4397134781,
-0.0397087783,
-0.0759025663,
0.4767068326,
1.0064307451,
-0.3176210821,
0.0980966613,
-0.2041084766,
0.5630403161,
-0.3105140328,
0.1445898414,
-0.8721577525,
0.2865962088,
-0.0254770759,
0.1473593116,
-0.0848180205,
-0.121581465,
-0.2466584891,
-0.8932217956,
0.210066244,
0.1993031204,
0.5578230023,
0.6025097966,
-0.2532793283,
-0.5154861808,
-0.838055253,
0.6979624629,
-0.5108785033,
-0.0922599211,
0.0580209345,
0.3334007561,
-0.7797455788,
-0.5670275092,
-0.7570103407,
-0.3570183516,
0.2632099092,
0.0435056984,
-0.5047103167,
-0.0353897288,
0.5587064624,
0.0921395123,
-0.5502129197,
0.2423839867,
-0.4672923982,
-0.0284261685,
0.8785389066,
0.4602930546,
0.4528312981,
0.1401401311,
-0.244614616,
0.0606468618,
-0.1975674927,
0.3361831903,
0.3282111585,
-0.087430872,
0.3800068796,
0.6488704681,
-0.2156970799,
0.4463070035,
-0.1384412497,
-0.2125137597,
0.1247511059,
0.3302305937,
-0.0395419896,
-0.2033838034,
0.8093236685,
0.1238513663,
0.5298711061,
-0.1778709143,
-0.3836907446,
0.1260599941,
0.2688504457,
-0.3864708841,
-0.2614754736,
0.0246017575,
-0.125602752,
-0.2769022584,
0.1418091208,
-0.2634280622,
-0.6764119864,
-0.1571206003,
0.4458959997,
-0.0932842121,
-0.3811405599,
0.5188710093,
-0.3462280929,
-0.1527184099,
0.1714763641,
-0.6798579097,
0.5401076078,
0.7224417329,
0.4716692567,
-0.0409733914,
-0.2330726832,
-0.2474091947,
0.117820628,
-0.4140976369,
0.5891342163,
-0.596817553,
-0.5719223619,
-0.4959710538,
0.1752494723,
0.1123851538,
-0.9017596841,
0.5151330829,
0.013932135,
-0.2710139453,
-0.4637440443,
-0.0091916444,
-0.2048081905,
0.5340695977,
-0.7543064356,
1.0371844769,
0.2388885021,
-0.8496146202,
0.0389515944,
-0.837700665,
-0.3178010881,
0.4537931383,
-0.3088766038,
-0.0468394943,
0.3876701295,
0.0798918605,
0.3987868726,
-0.4349651635,
0.469802469,
-0.28390342,
-0.1136955321,
0.6965725422,
-0.2211807668,
0.6469200253,
0.2309785783,
-0.2397110462,
0.0739343017,
-0.875685513,
0.0430364758,
0.5779439211,
-0.1606247425,
-0.220971927,
0.0639174953,
-0.1995790601,
0.5398703218,
0.1526654512,
-0.7520286441,
0.5022030473,
-0.1353514493,
0.6777942777,
0.6555808783,
-0.2188576907,
-0.0039072074,
-0.7115633488,
0.9087591767,
-0.1735054255,
0.0284873713,
0.0899756774,
-0.6041842699,
-0.5340157151,
-0.2227131277,
-0.3972194791,
0.7468556166,
-1.1363590956,
-0.2339262962,
-0.0453229658,
-0.6219528913,
-0.4815915823,
0.5056129694,
0.2596601546,
0.6438499689,
0.0149388779,
-0.3675075471,
-0.4075591862,
-0.7527905703,
-0.3537025452,
0.024344774,
0.1064176559,
0.6516280174,
0.7191616297,
-0.550178051,
0.8549842238,
-0.4369353652,
-0.0390647575,
-0.5109649301,
0.1210377216,
0.1819485873,
0.416849196,
0.1057725176,
-0.7800533772,
-0.1292771548,
0.0578871965,
-0.710418582,
-0.3245304823,
-0.1320861727,
-0.0560034998,
0.059517283,
0.5176525712,
-0.909981966,
0.0796476305,
0.3203838766,
-0.2618386447,
0.7749080658,
-0.4547636807,
-0.3113166988,
-0.8622656465,
0.0716958568,
-0.0651414394,
0.028095305,
-0.5740326047,
0.0547582768,
-0.1884084046,
-0.3190323412,
-0.3542377651,
0.6192090511,
-0.6594648361,
0.0540004261,
-0.1899379939,
0.3066144288,
-0.1276274472,
0.1894764453,
0.0220414568,
0.4197728038,
0.2824425697,
-0.4296036959,
0.8117334843,
0.1170104891,
-0.3657348454,
0.2099675089,
-0.6306786537,
0.3451525569,
-0.4489511251,
0.3883124888,
-1.0160490274,
-0.4340247512,
0.1629952341,
-0.2761263847,
0.2404364645,
0.3577677011,
-0.4615588486,
-0.9614819288,
-0.1109341756,
0.4370248318,
0.4178247452,
-0.2365893424,
0.5138344169,
0.3725095689,
-0.4381873012,
-0.7681827545,
-1.1517107487,
0.433270067,
-0.1404551268,
-0.7518513203,
0.4145460427,
-0.3340634406,
-0.8660744429,
0.18640019,
-0.1049380824,
0.2391974628,
0.3238581717,
0.2184990197,
0.1556503177,
-0.0589400306,
-0.0071221404,
-0.3408171833,
-0.2220482081,
0.2499283999,
-0.5145155787,
0.2735619843,
-0.280410707,
-0.3404072523,
-0.0656475648,
0.5362553596,
0.5731237531,
-0.3761536181,
0.4777523875,
0.5576837063,
-0.3302529752,
-0.3949350715,
-0.835128665,
0.1297052503,
-0.5223743916,
0.3672703505,
-0.5596606135,
-0.9498937726,
0.6108209491,
-0.0217114575,
0.0114689916,
0.2105387747,
0.6017001867,
-0.0906102732,
1.0070226192,
0.7885721326,
0.2001047432,
0.2189122885,
-0.5158241391,
0.2154450417,
-0.6749453545,
-0.5999000072,
-0.3063777685,
-0.7033768892,
-0.7421297431,
-0.398699224,
0.1246063337,
-0.0513983071,
-0.1877381355,
0.1264405698,
-0.7124538422,
0.7305412292,
0.3887873292,
-0.2797727883,
0.1590549648,
-0.3593944609,
-0.3404931128,
0.1530693322,
-0.891489625,
-0.5173285007,
0.7829843163,
0.2975167632,
1.0040490627,
0.1643972546,
0.6899485588,
-0.0891380161,
0.2573495805,
-1.0463168621,
0.6918237209,
0.0629512593,
-0.6725336313,
-0.0982555449,
-0.650118947,
-1.036088109,
0.064718008,
-0.214978829,
-0.8695152402,
-0.0914964676,
-0.0582046844,
-0.2285070568,
0.5874419808,
-0.4474260807,
0.7853428721,
-0.5644957423,
-0.2880576551,
-0.002169759,
-0.7596988678,
0.5887969732,
0.1495645791,
0.6943516731,
-0.2044024616,
-0.2277459204,
0.5307243466,
-0.1042750254,
0.6303439736,
-0.04235835,
-0.2836638391,
0.4854907691,
0.4442255497,
0.5960326195,
-0.0692517236,
0.1597137451,
-0.289365381,
-0.1042236537,
-0.4603117406,
-0.720261991,
0.6927760243,
-0.723946929,
-1.1160830259,
-0.3885523677,
-1.3059182167,
-0.2401123345,
0.1511521339,
-0.0233252794,
0.3332180083,
-0.2347234786,
-0.0414265506,
0.7889404297,
-0.2146875113,
0.6220395565,
0.4695711136,
-0.2056222856,
-0.3079765141,
0.9390383959,
0.2932422459,
0.4639621675,
0.1994552612,
0.2510516644,
-0.0266191028,
-0.4341852665,
-0.1026355624,
0.419680357,
-0.7714174986,
0.2798684835,
-0.7153567672,
-0.1632092446,
0.0326079689,
-0.4025289118,
-0.068117857,
-0.6786734462,
-0.257273823,
0.074031949,
0.0099034272,
1.0100924969,
-0.0542571992,
-0.1978894919,
-0.6126846075,
0.2593487501,
0.3525045514,
-0.1086301208,
-0.0694006458,
-0.0251375809,
-0.069297038,
-0.056177225,
-0.5030846596,
-0.5966803432,
0.5801500678,
-0.0981676877,
0.8129669428,
0.460180968,
0.1895399541,
0.3411104083,
-0.41828385,
0.7258585691,
0.2021224499,
-0.5592949986,
0.3786064982,
-0.239943549,
0.3093808591,
0.252201438,
0.4733263254,
-0.6014524698,
-0.3607765734,
-0.8642540574,
-0.6434183717,
0.4941947758,
-0.0024597924,
0.1524574906,
-0.1358135045,
0.3971615434,
0.2271603346,
0.2127987146,
-0.6071087718,
0.1358767152,
0.0213382225,
-0.1949647516,
-0.3995937705,
0.1188112497,
-0.1451881677,
-0.3513957858,
0.526545465,
-0.2385305017,
0.1168657914,
0.139789924,
-0.0845590532,
-0.3433543146,
0.3657175899,
0.8353632689,
0.5928244591,
0.070659183,
0.3025854528,
0.3361397386,
-0.5868402123,
0.32239151,
-0.0535899624,
0.2513452172,
-0.1519348919,
0.1786573678,
0.6291434169,
-0.0915810019,
-1.1673381329,
0.1035310403,
0.0188625045,
-0.5225339532,
-0.3347566426,
0.4556630552,
0.2186205536,
0.5705842972,
0.3700799942,
0.2526281178,
-0.1294598728,
-0.8422433734,
-0.3298451304,
0.8771631718,
-0.3623297811,
-0.180909887,
0.5963913202,
0.0953551158,
-0.9060152173,
0.4208416939,
-0.3547724485,
-0.7016271949,
0.9074341059,
0.7745354772,
0.7740806341,
0.1718417257,
0.2436378747,
-0.2841519713,
0.5590741038,
-0.113594614,
0.3931854069,
-0.149498105,
-0.9697359204,
-0.3650224209,
-0.1987583041,
-0.5763890147,
0.1822102666,
-0.3529186249,
-0.0270172618,
-0.5991226435,
-0.1329210997,
0.0288983285,
0.5137030482,
-0.554967761,
-0.008250773,
0.1297171861,
1.0809674263,
-0.4561597407,
0.5397017598,
1.0398306847,
-0.2345024347,
-0.7408825159,
-0.1662078053,
0.1718544513,
-0.763453722,
0.7773635387,
0.2525132596,
-0.3979578316,
0.2328957319,
-0.7490947247,
-0.7004272938,
1.2795389891,
0.4518436491,
-0.6782898307,
-0.2415189594,
0.0928666592,
0.2290952355,
-0.4424913824,
0.1161867008,
0.6191492677,
0.5528770685,
0.3482306898,
-1.1001985073,
0.0847691894,
-0.5624346137,
-0.0335128643,
0.4631575644,
-0.7358494997,
0.9085274935,
-0.6701162457,
-0.010492417,
0.1056653783,
0.2234233171,
0.3041502833,
0.4852472544,
0.2738166749,
0.6322013736,
1.0737781525,
-0.0113136787,
0.9377547503,
0.1924019903,
0.0747923627,
0.5210121274,
-0.2687658072,
0.5148586035,
0.5276364684,
0.0817951933,
0.5152026415,
0.3221899569,
0.0794584677,
0.1785432994,
0.7196742892,
-0.3417421877,
-0.3958544731,
-0.1151785031,
-0.0844037086,
0.3720275164,
0.6266144514,
0.0468000025,
0.0446491726,
0.3657309115,
0.0265206452,
0.1706998795,
-0.4214233756,
0.670892179,
0.3178996742,
-0.7405388355,
0.5802990198,
0.075905405,
0.6614501476,
-0.3189986944,
0.2557595372,
-0.0043644556,
0.3757801652,
-0.2311399728,
-0.8819459081,
0.1423136294,
-0.097190477,
-0.0790191218,
-0.1215130538,
0.8206880689,
-0.267718643,
-0.6793144345,
-0.1499076933,
0.4666164517,
0.2108422518,
0.1690373719,
-0.7571365833,
-0.0202793181,
-0.1860543936,
-0.1269294024,
-0.0194790717,
0.8086566925,
-0.3448281288,
1.3552577496,
0.6199361682,
0.1730725318,
-0.1343702078,
-0.1169876009,
0.9183802605,
-0.9839345217,
-0.4473252892,
-0.7329206467,
0.5870463848,
-0.0072485376,
-0.4207240939,
0.4334060252,
0.1973284483,
0.8924072981,
0.0326382592,
0.8579524159,
0.021848686,
0.1450854689,
-0.4314516783,
0.5016365051,
-0.4253216088,
0.3082295656,
-0.4388510883,
-0.80389148,
-0.3874551356,
0.5845527649,
-0.4816267192,
-0.0199293941,
0.466578722,
0.82740587,
-0.1042347848,
0.0517302565,
0.4131197035,
0.1313699484,
0.4408225119,
1.1553096771,
1.5119941235,
0.326818496,
0.4337344468,
-0.057935942,
-0.2925604582,
-0.2052749246,
-0.6892169714,
-1.1090102196,
-0.4125498235,
-0.2988235652,
-0.0468683504,
-0.2023634613,
1.3039872646,
0.2317555249,
-0.3002130389,
-0.2194999605,
-0.3118913472,
0.0521761365,
-0.1919613481,
-0.1862336695,
-0.2990486324,
-0.2653382719,
-0.2823911607,
0.4001794457,
0.193569541,
0.1206672192,
-0.5706834793,
-0.2325686216,
0.1027657166,
0.476536572,
0.4800839126,
0.45154652,
-0.9500026703,
-0.0413739383,
0.1768128872,
0.0955614075,
-0.1217962503,
1.0269172192,
-0.9477916956,
0.4886533916,
0.1847833097,
0.6558235884,
0.5641880035,
-0.1171917543,
0.1133654118,
-0.3071459234,
0.2951979041,
0.6191254854,
0.2442992181,
0.3281092346,
-0.3154075742,
0.2710521221,
0.33451581,
-0.5215733051,
-0.832785964,
0.4544194043,
-0.7916676402,
-0.4016581476,
1.0129271746,
0.1409212202,
-0.2287490517,
-0.1440487802,
-0.7022916079,
-0.1059821099,
-0.0550676398,
0.6960309148,
0.9125955105,
-0.3288580477,
-0.4676294327,
-0.8564019203,
0.3156837225,
0.2987595201,
-0.6567770839,
-0.1669501066,
0.2465202212,
0.3175492883,
0.2000300288,
0.3907665312,
0.2770133615,
0.1220963895,
0.076459378,
-0.0508143343,
-0.7222605944,
-0.4289670289,
-0.0459988005,
0.0939328745,
0.2475918978,
0.1017244458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09677v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09677v3
|
R-Tuning: Instructing Large Language Models to Say `I Don't Know'
| 2023-11-16T08:45:44 | 2024-06-07T02:46:36 |
Hanning Zhang, Shizhe Diao, Yong Lin, Yi R. Fung, Qing Lian, Xingyao Wang, Yangyi Chen, Heng Ji, Tong Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized numerous domains with their
impressive performance but still face their challenges. A predominant issue is
the propensity for these models to generate non-existent facts, a concern
termed hallucination. Our research is motivated by the observation that
previous instruction tuning methods force the model to complete a sentence no
matter whether the model knows the knowledge or not. When the question is out
of the parametric knowledge, it will try to make up something and fail to
indicate when it lacks knowledge. In this paper, we present a new approach
called Refusal-Aware Instruction Tuning (R-Tuning). This approach is formalized
by first identifying the disparity in knowledge encompassed by pre-trained
parameters compared to that of instruction tuning data. Then, we construct the
refusal-aware data based on the knowledge intersection, to tune LLMs to refrain
from responding to questions beyond its parametric knowledge. Experimental
results demonstrate R-Tuning effectively improves a model's ability to answer
known questions and refrain from answering unknown questions. Furthermore, when
tested on out-of-domain datasets, the refusal ability was found to be a
meta-skill that could be generalized to other tasks. Further analysis
surprisingly finds that learning the uncertainty results in better calibration
and an improved ability to estimate the uncertainty than uncertainty-based
testing. Our code is available at https://github.com/shizhediao/R-Tuning.
|
[
-0.5985013247,
-1.0029733181,
0.7114467621,
-0.0454796851,
0.0375285782,
0.0823816285,
-0.5083434582,
-0.2198269069,
-0.1274551898,
0.5397506356,
-0.9259207845,
-0.4995473325,
-0.5944890976,
0.056204576,
-0.2455168664,
0.7970499396,
0.0564068928,
0.0867972896,
-0.4745842814,
0.0651740879,
-0.6190813184,
-0.0164056346,
-0.4273731112,
-0.4549710751,
0.5458446741,
0.8417290449,
0.547734797,
0.8090769649,
0.2120333016,
0.2655673921,
0.0872710571,
0.3618308306,
-0.500413537,
0.2261678129,
-0.1178033352,
-0.7947347164,
-0.2469320893,
0.0011778629,
0.4152230322,
0.764947772,
-0.0203839019,
0.3767954409,
-0.0108638024,
0.9612535238,
-0.6600153446,
0.1748436093,
-1.0707712173,
-0.0192003287,
-0.0357882865,
-0.4740514457,
-0.5562483668,
-0.3480536342,
-0.0501210839,
-0.6622972488,
0.5037842989,
0.3727707267,
0.7649481893,
0.6825006604,
-0.1769191027,
-0.4150657952,
-0.7735764384,
0.7663389444,
-0.5315462947,
0.5954820514,
1.0444402695,
0.2893710732,
-0.1205542162,
-0.2626453638,
-0.5469338298,
-0.3012190461,
0.0473469198,
-0.1008132994,
0.1913955361,
0.0813283548,
0.4185932577,
0.2839446664,
-0.6260461211,
0.0777983665,
-0.480376184,
-0.1152053624,
0.3438546658,
-0.0461146608,
0.1645383686,
0.1006376818,
-0.0804808214,
-0.0778915137,
-0.8687040806,
-0.141119495,
0.5261277556,
0.3066096604,
0.090732187,
0.7911536098,
-0.2997408509,
1.0065336227,
0.283678025,
0.0055436189,
0.0364142768,
0.2556941807,
-0.1878172308,
-0.0430255309,
0.4117114842,
0.2266360372,
0.4262030721,
-0.2558349967,
-0.2313974053,
-0.0328135341,
0.3763717413,
-0.5500055552,
-0.2178021669,
0.2439427227,
-0.1995492429,
0.0404430926,
-0.024990743,
-0.9637699127,
-0.3882139027,
-0.4866689444,
0.6281909943,
-0.5655859709,
-0.2193873525,
0.2260308713,
0.1615807712,
0.4141441584,
0.0546482392,
-1.0456267595,
0.333289206,
0.6564660668,
0.5834461451,
0.0317198075,
-0.3770729899,
-0.7445717454,
-0.0538032092,
-0.490557909,
0.7693984509,
-0.6755571961,
-0.3921798468,
-0.4214650989,
-0.1043355092,
-0.4843891859,
-0.9517510533,
0.2993766069,
-0.6813614368,
-0.0414387956,
-0.3498925567,
-0.6071953773,
-0.437902689,
0.1571863592,
-0.4481303394,
0.7395800948,
0.0892452449,
-0.4995345771,
0.2852487266,
-0.2365891784,
-0.501255095,
0.0019349447,
-0.2584618032,
-0.6485999823,
0.2625041902,
0.2560629845,
0.3156283498,
-0.2162974477,
0.3178203702,
-0.5157154202,
-0.4828018546,
0.2218391597,
-0.3986037374,
0.1637628675,
0.0857604593,
-0.1434327662,
0.0065697851,
-0.8185639977,
0.4435780942,
-0.056744989,
-0.1480612904,
-0.2869694829,
0.092449978,
-0.4383250475,
0.0515492409,
0.1036914662,
-0.2421460897,
-0.0431372747,
-0.5839819312,
0.4270623028,
0.8389309645,
-0.0995112732,
0.3775790632,
-0.6421302557,
0.8178479671,
-0.2140044719,
0.0022491834,
0.1188787222,
-0.3231034875,
-1.1565662622,
0.2654608488,
0.3798749149,
0.6476352215,
-0.812553823,
0.3547632992,
-0.0293511767,
-0.2372791171,
-0.7624617815,
0.2254178971,
0.5287535787,
0.6197648048,
0.4422151148,
0.2924610376,
-0.6169504523,
-0.7843595743,
-0.4914037287,
-0.1421031803,
0.0820726082,
0.4338060617,
0.603253901,
0.1080300137,
0.6384427547,
-0.5353960395,
-0.2856721878,
-0.1549970508,
0.0257173143,
-0.0736786947,
0.3245215416,
0.114206709,
-0.7572274208,
-0.4204887152,
0.044620946,
-0.6724233031,
0.1538033336,
0.1471125036,
0.1547782719,
0.2880499065,
0.748947084,
-0.4174526036,
0.4092568159,
0.5604556203,
-0.0040109223,
0.5894936919,
-0.4235994518,
0.1050148383,
-0.7642602921,
-0.0244157109,
-0.1098743975,
-0.0723045468,
-0.3525829017,
-0.0307093393,
0.2043953836,
-0.0570169836,
-0.2732481062,
0.5809890032,
-0.4865649939,
0.002375711,
-0.2649925351,
0.1324282736,
-0.1839826107,
0.4620748758,
0.1155148596,
1.0239415169,
0.6532161832,
-1.0919588804,
-0.002644707,
0.2729562521,
-0.6801016331,
0.4274207652,
-0.5296119452,
0.2691343129,
-0.3081051409,
-0.2532000244,
-0.8187112212,
-0.3837665021,
0.391700536,
-0.5740884542,
0.343932569,
-0.3783640563,
0.0219602957,
-0.2802326083,
0.149931863,
0.2659530342,
0.3480854332,
-0.42730093,
0.4972153306,
0.2675034404,
-0.1520133615,
-0.6237542033,
-0.6667875648,
-0.2007200867,
-0.3604899645,
-0.1610840261,
0.2339507788,
-0.4552450478,
-0.2781229615,
-0.0338880345,
-0.3928408921,
-0.2186078727,
0.0430972688,
0.2864329517,
0.1211272478,
-0.1517229825,
0.2898093164,
0.2217180729,
-0.3169482052,
0.1053635031,
-0.1285306513,
0.413777858,
0.0372325778,
-0.6196632981,
-0.3782728016,
0.0617480911,
0.4678739011,
-0.2247351259,
0.6781124473,
0.2420107573,
-0.1510487944,
-0.752956152,
-0.5596724153,
-0.4915872216,
-0.5001211166,
0.2415068299,
-0.4670081735,
-0.9456866384,
0.2923464477,
-0.2095162719,
-0.1888153404,
0.0273757093,
0.413921535,
0.0104722325,
0.78093189,
0.6794497371,
0.0344112217,
0.2581403553,
-0.0888143182,
0.4103214741,
-0.7496023178,
-0.1863586009,
-0.6571258307,
-0.2215052545,
-0.4536006749,
-0.4535284042,
0.5195934772,
-0.1425131708,
-0.0479904786,
-0.0622428656,
-0.2417069227,
0.66180408,
0.3032667935,
0.3837147951,
0.2458746284,
-0.0498329215,
0.1253598481,
-0.1009770557,
-0.6387274265,
-0.3239745498,
1.1060177088,
0.0050467257,
0.7991297841,
-0.199430272,
0.4470166862,
0.1461175531,
-0.0752018318,
-1.0414485931,
0.5593007207,
0.1652269959,
-0.4917777777,
-0.3987986743,
-0.7424253225,
-0.685547173,
0.2570700645,
-0.2002459764,
-0.4048696756,
-0.1086511612,
0.335906297,
-0.5146378875,
0.3576188684,
-0.7852086425,
0.4877910316,
-0.0979570225,
-0.1174963787,
-0.2877296805,
-0.3287725449,
0.4347007573,
-0.1220755652,
0.409075737,
-0.1679384857,
0.100609675,
0.5248086452,
-0.242214039,
0.8954949975,
-0.0415295847,
-0.1258216351,
0.1728413701,
0.3950553238,
0.5930285454,
0.2360377759,
-0.3627252579,
-0.2548676133,
-0.0443428531,
-0.1845708489,
-0.7734791636,
0.7031760812,
-0.5671148896,
-0.7655643225,
-0.1716715544,
-0.6329903007,
-0.6214823127,
0.2528598905,
0.4538990855,
0.2895676196,
-0.1171608344,
0.0309802257,
1.1752704382,
-0.314135462,
0.1678206027,
0.6446311474,
-0.1759481877,
-0.2940588295,
1.1250247955,
0.2563686669,
0.3991176784,
0.4807246029,
0.1254761219,
-0.3418120444,
-0.593727529,
-0.4343264997,
0.2415058017,
-0.6235181093,
-0.2337962538,
-0.4353052974,
-0.4072770476,
-0.2084488422,
0.0534706488,
-0.3426048458,
-0.3106389046,
-0.3989171684,
-0.228721112,
0.5428722501,
0.8778160214,
0.0926561654,
0.0065883258,
-0.3861364424,
0.4331932962,
0.3830759823,
0.644127667,
0.1126195043,
-0.7947381735,
-0.1687291712,
0.2347738147,
-0.1796750128,
-0.4380164146,
0.2235840857,
0.3709946871,
0.5410246253,
0.198084414,
0.4509615004,
0.7641302943,
-0.4913156629,
0.1576537788,
-0.4070692658,
-1.0623751879,
0.5287591815,
-0.2500563264,
-0.0298364125,
0.6851997375,
0.3921039402,
-0.3160009086,
-0.4474849701,
-0.3025810719,
-0.6610178351,
0.6976882815,
-0.1590019614,
0.0893184021,
0.1302436888,
0.6732035279,
0.405893594,
0.2793694139,
-0.6295226216,
-0.4248661995,
0.120099701,
-0.0043633105,
-0.1942861229,
-0.1846975833,
-0.0185782723,
-0.4118527472,
0.9098142385,
-0.269254297,
0.1112558991,
0.0319799893,
-0.3010677695,
-0.3477701843,
0.3733070493,
0.8220482469,
1.0655299425,
-0.1341061592,
0.2075065076,
0.3054729104,
-0.36337924,
0.1686169058,
-0.3155504763,
-0.3645691276,
-0.3996047974,
0.2708736658,
0.8976148963,
0.151067853,
-0.6453329921,
0.1622191519,
0.048776906,
-0.5793454647,
-0.2455452532,
0.3870574832,
-0.0383214653,
0.0070109647,
-0.0590439513,
0.1190411747,
-0.2007562816,
-0.1781594902,
0.3528216779,
0.5138416886,
-0.5889496207,
-0.2385804504,
0.6132850051,
-0.1995218992,
-0.351334393,
0.6383746266,
-0.114470467,
-0.1710764617,
0.5758897066,
0.6878670454,
0.6718559265,
-0.1770682633,
0.5984457135,
0.2773711085,
0.4578122497,
-0.175515011,
0.3439631462,
-0.0514938459,
-0.7863355279,
-0.4946665466,
-0.5489218235,
-0.4831854403,
0.489502728,
-1.0125766993,
0.1071328819,
-0.7824562788,
0.0605213605,
-0.3503173292,
-0.1635189652,
-0.5396780968,
0.19768323,
-0.3362660408,
0.7433755398,
-0.922673583,
0.7633845806,
0.5199558139,
-0.131950438,
-0.7595433593,
0.4049181938,
-0.1434931606,
-1.0403398275,
0.21148476,
0.0049263937,
-0.2710625827,
0.3178385198,
-0.4366037548,
-0.7615157366,
0.757158339,
0.4374889135,
-0.7355742455,
0.1690062135,
0.1007419974,
0.2164748907,
-0.0422123671,
-0.0251053125,
0.62875247,
0.7958166599,
0.2521126866,
-0.5848964453,
-0.0030305483,
0.1707331389,
-0.2359744608,
0.1993902922,
-0.8153556585,
0.7436196804,
-0.5190217495,
-0.108430095,
0.1122150272,
0.5761431456,
0.1299431473,
0.2974378765,
0.4934138358,
0.5512353778,
0.9904537201,
-0.0344787166,
0.596337378,
-0.3094162643,
0.2528464198,
1.138882637,
-0.2872020602,
0.802588582,
0.4593732655,
-0.0248877238,
0.3230846822,
0.6365740895,
0.1269731969,
0.5496660471,
0.2253822982,
-0.2320695668,
-0.649981916,
0.1919526607,
-0.3921387196,
0.3881345093,
0.5813199878,
-0.0521490425,
-0.2388114333,
0.1362700462,
-0.1691068411,
0.4328008294,
-0.3042469323,
0.7392581105,
0.2334993184,
-0.8932668567,
1.0085167885,
-0.0520064272,
0.2179101855,
-0.6000079513,
0.0327927433,
-0.0126755498,
0.2262903303,
-0.1644395143,
-0.6812989116,
0.44194296,
-0.2976960242,
-0.4847148955,
-0.215284273,
0.3878851533,
-0.4105065763,
-0.526673615,
0.255615294,
0.6971490979,
0.0768228918,
-0.0822664425,
-0.7173703909,
0.1606008708,
0.1252547503,
-0.1591956466,
0.420003742,
0.5104326606,
0.1083269417,
1.1277680397,
0.3239903152,
0.1465699375,
-0.1167754158,
0.0367908701,
0.6618885398,
-0.620749414,
-0.1175323501,
-0.8304088712,
0.0864509791,
0.5478400588,
-0.2560174763,
0.8042812347,
0.3894970119,
0.957582891,
-0.1187335774,
1.1008579731,
-0.000956331,
0.7339053154,
-0.9479056001,
0.6701083779,
-0.6276342273,
0.4280724823,
-0.0199493952,
-0.6380401254,
-0.2295200229,
0.6441086531,
-0.7111412287,
0.3955546618,
0.7458247542,
1.1351281404,
-0.0945734605,
0.1591889411,
0.5940020084,
0.2571833432,
-0.0882221982,
0.5271059275,
0.8641867042,
-0.2433174253,
0.4484032989,
-0.1859155893,
-0.0401646309,
-0.0647174641,
-0.6655635834,
-1.2297025919,
-0.7244734764,
-0.0790680796,
-0.349381268,
0.1302241534,
0.7225092053,
0.7431649566,
-0.8200948834,
-0.1120063141,
-0.284009099,
0.6081484556,
-0.3114129305,
-0.1519139111,
0.2846132815,
-0.6078870296,
-0.5127127171,
0.6971132159,
0.1318182051,
0.086218968,
-0.2011838853,
0.0101888841,
-0.0083175534,
0.0915815085,
0.2515065968,
0.4328889847,
-0.6667083502,
-0.3363717794,
0.0883663818,
0.3831941485,
0.0512839667,
0.8469876647,
-0.702014327,
0.3512392342,
0.2056305408,
0.5031095743,
0.3007723987,
0.1039566994,
0.4899478853,
-0.6097593307,
0.1391923428,
0.1218148395,
-0.1183998436,
0.2221702933,
-0.5182822347,
0.0374310017,
0.1651716977,
-0.6932722926,
-0.6884773374,
0.5222169161,
-0.4072475433,
-0.4160113633,
0.9300970435,
0.1575649679,
-0.3998723924,
-0.3606689572,
-0.0501869731,
0.0284454376,
-0.2034958601,
1.0238575935,
0.7338619232,
-0.0000157689,
-0.3163847923,
-0.9221622348,
0.6950793266,
0.5346308351,
-0.6222791672,
0.4450341463,
0.2505423427,
0.6449829936,
-0.3925044835,
0.5324313045,
0.134843111,
0.133248955,
-0.2188479155,
-0.0629740432,
-0.2446626276,
-0.7435751557,
-0.3033144176,
0.0998758003,
0.3863255978,
-0.0921958312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09675v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09675v2
|
Where Do People Tell Stories Online? Story Detection Across Online Communities
| 2023-11-16T08:42:26 | 2024-02-27T03:37:03 |
Maria Antoniak, Joel Mire, Maarten Sap, Elliott Ash, Andrew Piper
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Story detection in online communities is a challenging task as stories are
scattered across communities and interwoven with non-storytelling spans within
a single text. We address this challenge by building and releasing the
StorySeeker toolkit, including a richly annotated dataset of 502 Reddit posts
and comments, a detailed codebook adapted to the social media context, and
models to predict storytelling at the document and span level. Our dataset is
sampled from hundreds of popular English-language Reddit communities ranging
across 33 topic categories, and it contains fine-grained expert annotations,
including binary story labels, story spans, and event spans. We evaluate a
range of detection methods using our data, and we identify the distinctive
textual features of online storytelling, focusing on storytelling span
detection, which we introduce as a new task. We illuminate distributional
characteristics of storytelling on a large community-centric social media
platform, and we also conduct a case study on r/ChangeMyView, where
storytelling is used as one of many persuasive strategies, illustrating that
our data and models can be used for both inter- and intra-community research.
Finally, we discuss implications of our tools and analyses for narratology and
the study of online communities.
|
[
-0.5903150439,
-0.5585972071,
0.6183840632,
0.472322315,
-0.3875848353,
0.4672905505,
-0.0342676118,
-1.2043694258,
0.9150820374,
0.2141385525,
-0.8337039351,
-0.3795925975,
-0.4942995906,
0.1966033131,
-0.3179623783,
0.8137668371,
-0.3302969933,
-0.2309044302,
-0.2747944295,
-0.198923409,
-0.4887105525,
-0.3202531934,
-0.2570296228,
0.175472796,
0.6304490566,
0.6383142471,
0.2398616672,
0.7446834445,
0.3039879203,
0.1589820087,
-0.0920524746,
0.2873572707,
-0.5205424428,
0.207335934,
0.0513806045,
-0.4680404663,
-0.0316043161,
-0.0098562436,
0.147309348,
0.5639643669,
-0.1417047083,
0.4348138273,
-0.2698780894,
0.3522183299,
-0.654252708,
-0.284838289,
-0.1625299901,
0.1522623599,
-0.5483712554,
-0.1809169203,
-0.0055553168,
-0.7431138158,
0.0865378529,
-0.6326999068,
0.6226738095,
0.1179550961,
0.3389159739,
-0.2425098717,
-0.3901993334,
-0.3677975833,
-0.8358886838,
0.4266023934,
-0.1876013428,
0.0584612116,
0.6945661902,
0.5813648701,
0.3879764974,
-0.758153975,
-0.4985114634,
0.3323800862,
-0.2901327312,
-0.1136506051,
-0.6785690784,
-0.5435693264,
-0.0263789166,
0.3566820025,
-0.642763555,
0.101270847,
-0.393409431,
-0.1266413927,
0.621784687,
0.384691596,
0.1297213584,
-0.1687118262,
-0.3215615451,
-0.0187982917,
-0.3424832821,
-0.0457995608,
0.6470839381,
-0.0237654131,
-0.0254559703,
0.3125591576,
-0.2256911248,
0.3888706267,
0.0331841782,
-0.1205419824,
0.3277527094,
-0.4305194914,
0.5984833837,
0.3520272374,
0.4503666759,
1.1048561335,
0.354901731,
0.088766396,
-0.207817927,
0.0951546356,
0.1104905605,
-0.6869747043,
-0.3697639406,
-0.1518312693,
-0.7499916553,
-0.5068823099,
0.1823856831,
-0.9231949449,
-1.3080409765,
0.3154308796,
-0.0249396078,
0.0013868569,
-0.6559422016,
0.0261547677,
-0.594836235,
-0.1038066521,
0.3595071435,
-0.9244378209,
0.3145884573,
0.6835728884,
1.0498008728,
-0.1539763063,
-0.2951363623,
-0.4990812242,
-0.0941464007,
-0.2309477776,
1.1433024406,
-0.5291819572,
0.0004644421,
0.1758285165,
-0.1594928056,
0.2137007564,
-0.4934613705,
0.5656984448,
-0.205427438,
-0.0533483624,
-0.195943892,
-0.5739557147,
-0.109177731,
0.2461850196,
-0.7010229826,
0.715800941,
-0.0330789499,
-0.9443805814,
0.5065774918,
-0.6238151789,
-0.4762207568,
0.0751074925,
0.2822747231,
-0.2673916519,
0.469084084,
0.5695640445,
0.3398532271,
0.0698188096,
-0.0789220259,
-0.0913000926,
-0.3533598185,
0.4573111236,
-0.4537543058,
0.5564395189,
0.123589702,
-0.1323981434,
0.1975190192,
-0.5945433974,
-0.3257825673,
0.3312623203,
-0.0684080347,
-0.3944574594,
0.227310732,
0.470274061,
0.1125263646,
0.041547101,
-0.7737796903,
0.2600223422,
-0.2030744404,
0.6987959743,
0.2874555588,
0.5507103205,
-0.1401172727,
-0.4848411977,
0.8724976778,
-0.1187972203,
0.3329920471,
-0.526242733,
-0.6585036516,
-0.4348352849,
0.1982514709,
0.0083492659,
0.2478035837,
-0.4077084064,
-0.0514669232,
0.0949789807,
-0.8418248296,
-0.5968933105,
-0.2254227549,
0.0799649581,
0.0676817,
0.3639492691,
-0.1423081607,
-0.6920000911,
-0.768759191,
-0.6511325836,
-0.1822808534,
-0.2141792327,
-0.0744441748,
0.2166072577,
0.0314811468,
1.0295702219,
-0.5965972543,
-0.2657938004,
-0.6734247804,
0.4620224237,
0.0202443805,
-0.1714503765,
0.3531021774,
-1.0916229486,
-0.7273920774,
0.0510848612,
-0.4112909436,
-0.5614925623,
-0.167748183,
0.4422318041,
0.0635753572,
0.5997778773,
-0.320035845,
0.6582910419,
0.5528512597,
-0.5585138798,
0.6323311925,
0.0430141576,
0.3598335683,
-1.056109786,
-0.198502779,
0.1850977689,
-0.4621713161,
-0.5935460925,
-0.2446859032,
-0.1590566188,
0.1321219206,
-0.3445951641,
0.5082812309,
-0.3264400363,
-0.300139755,
-0.2850316167,
0.3371447921,
0.0023529059,
0.1092430949,
0.0961163417,
0.4298939109,
0.1133391112,
-0.2260827422,
0.5034846067,
0.4226328731,
-0.7111006975,
0.5644745231,
-0.3543612957,
-0.016563857,
0.021783689,
0.6360527277,
-0.8042596579,
-0.347245872,
0.1611421406,
-0.7253819704,
-0.4409808218,
-0.1239537746,
-0.8224915266,
-0.3656279445,
-0.3858239353,
0.1708094627,
0.0556860007,
-0.5154332519,
0.2499500066,
0.6181430817,
-0.2956377566,
-0.0158592295,
-0.7158458233,
0.2667565346,
-0.5168864727,
-0.6192901134,
0.2606936097,
-0.0737188831,
-0.5845971107,
-0.0925245881,
0.0304206088,
-0.4064505994,
0.1776727438,
0.3273634017,
-0.3237025142,
-0.2713935673,
0.3848019242,
-0.0498132966,
-0.2487351149,
0.0308343116,
0.0395888612,
0.6127033234,
-0.0256062951,
-0.2909401059,
-0.3048320711,
0.5787113309,
0.3287661076,
-0.3283379376,
0.6379934549,
0.5610764623,
-0.4117981493,
-0.2504791915,
-0.5888017416,
-0.2364464253,
-0.4040948451,
0.2360980213,
0.0902333334,
-0.9384034276,
0.5262885094,
-0.0264158864,
0.2161859274,
0.3797397316,
0.3180044889,
-0.2883454859,
0.6290026903,
0.8620485663,
0.0773978978,
0.3259243965,
0.4073202908,
0.2255044281,
-0.2186837494,
0.0664260164,
-0.2579619586,
-0.7154685855,
-0.182284832,
-0.3362444043,
0.278416872,
0.2889307439,
0.310228169,
0.4106558859,
-0.338632375,
1.0615003109,
0.4313749671,
-0.1198268458,
0.7722184062,
-0.1745467186,
0.3184125423,
-0.383559674,
-0.5827258229,
-0.4086316824,
0.7406583428,
0.3791186213,
0.400780797,
0.2296304256,
0.5530325174,
0.6371728778,
0.1884495765,
-0.4993754029,
0.2808212638,
0.1522130519,
-0.6309057474,
0.0230091698,
-0.1670560986,
-0.8441106081,
-0.0800628141,
-0.3006737828,
-0.7416584492,
0.2552202642,
-0.0767636597,
-0.3751330674,
0.6009412408,
-0.6595276594,
0.8523337245,
-0.0773284957,
0.2419398278,
-0.2632172108,
-0.9567524791,
-0.0389800817,
-0.2595252395,
0.26318115,
0.0133346766,
0.0833656788,
0.6075820923,
-0.2841470242,
1.0536023378,
-0.0090514822,
0.3169005215,
0.4591505527,
0.3543008268,
0.3591580689,
-0.2097452432,
0.2590082288,
0.2698224187,
0.0321284905,
0.045390483,
-0.0722206756,
0.4397432208,
-0.5314159989,
-0.1568715274,
-0.3691621423,
-0.3278804123,
-0.3684289753,
-0.1368274689,
0.2738240361,
0.3897843063,
-0.2449746132,
0.4419023693,
0.4286858141,
-0.2016283274,
0.7712258101,
0.4960726798,
-0.4241046309,
-0.057157971,
0.9067664742,
-0.0178918187,
0.0819064304,
0.5178952217,
0.4134481251,
-0.1097283885,
-0.5027773976,
-0.1964299232,
0.0321665108,
-0.8789542913,
-0.0693643391,
-0.6119115949,
-0.1522238851,
0.0599466786,
-0.5093196034,
-0.3210882545,
-0.4934218824,
-0.1957474947,
-0.6240044236,
0.733097136,
1.1534739733,
-0.2723565698,
0.2368613482,
-0.811816752,
0.0778018981,
0.1006366834,
0.1548543721,
0.0198009312,
0.060463883,
-0.269162178,
-0.3283174932,
-0.2332856059,
-0.7334855199,
0.6541134715,
0.0459329672,
0.1689297706,
0.3305796683,
0.4726134837,
0.5813103914,
-0.2354204059,
0.5176439285,
0.1053867787,
-0.4845496714,
0.6211490631,
-0.5534670353,
0.2282722592,
0.582770288,
0.5316880345,
-1.2312786579,
-0.5095308423,
-0.3157401383,
-0.8930763602,
0.563999474,
0.3392094672,
0.1510374397,
-0.0505791232,
-0.0275689587,
0.5462487936,
0.219666779,
-0.7976536751,
-0.1660956591,
-0.2826286554,
0.054470785,
0.0358918756,
-0.1987907588,
-0.0483221225,
0.0841964111,
0.0557629205,
0.0228744354,
0.1029815525,
0.2651051283,
-0.2073497474,
-0.5656653643,
0.0066348515,
0.4598718584,
1.2752995491,
-0.0991716459,
0.0264219139,
-0.0389394388,
-0.5103417039,
-0.4832758009,
0.2374627441,
0.0558812767,
0.2509742081,
0.771259129,
0.7231736779,
0.3077136874,
-0.6693659425,
0.655636549,
-0.3862616122,
-0.2710633278,
-0.4787563384,
-0.1851709932,
0.3208829463,
0.6097103357,
0.8275353312,
-0.0105111664,
-0.0016704727,
-0.4958509207,
0.0813742951,
-0.401734978,
-0.5158802867,
-0.2689928114,
0.5858729482,
0.3496904075,
-0.5074391961,
0.3843045533,
-0.0999182016,
-0.4840485156,
0.6530448198,
0.2779463232,
0.8683907986,
0.2042941302,
0.5383849144,
0.1404356956,
0.4080169797,
0.1822482198,
-0.3254720271,
-0.0421134084,
-0.6274473071,
-0.1875793487,
-0.6929494739,
-0.3825508654,
-0.0516767018,
-0.5342389941,
0.266526401,
-0.2769774497,
0.2053322345,
0.3268759847,
-0.0567306615,
-0.1870810837,
-0.1937857121,
0.4121445715,
0.9759446383,
-0.9552338123,
0.3488074839,
0.3380013704,
-0.1185602695,
-0.3335016072,
0.4240962267,
0.4336720407,
-0.4461645484,
0.1744707525,
0.4888218641,
0.0635886565,
-0.0527813509,
-0.2777234614,
-0.4348161221,
1.2040373087,
-0.0803307667,
-0.6598585844,
0.1422405988,
0.0775592029,
0.7037026882,
-0.4278389215,
0.0566723645,
0.2256150246,
0.4314792454,
0.115812771,
-1.051825881,
-0.2875556648,
-0.1604723781,
-0.2414221168,
0.316192925,
-0.4345692694,
0.6956273317,
-0.1383216083,
-0.2807206213,
0.0836484358,
0.40076828,
0.2788755,
0.7146781683,
0.487044096,
0.265007019,
0.6555614471,
-0.0083379038,
1.2124843597,
0.0996902809,
0.2436465621,
1.0168195963,
-0.1881527901,
0.80929178,
0.2133312225,
-0.0263495725,
0.6025385261,
0.9599276781,
-0.0522007309,
0.3416155279,
0.1321396232,
-0.3340769708,
-0.3394647241,
-0.3117160201,
-0.2601423264,
0.3759331107,
0.1973759085,
-0.2227628678,
-0.3775774837,
0.2109977305,
-0.0047913142,
0.2692221105,
-0.583290875,
0.7356677055,
-0.0626974702,
-0.4902765155,
-0.1237944141,
0.0500271432,
0.5486201048,
-0.6555916071,
-0.0999195501,
-0.3707158864,
0.2105337977,
-0.2107669264,
-1.0628826618,
0.4940901697,
0.0871031731,
-0.2434135824,
-0.4467063844,
0.8960297108,
-0.1826350242,
-0.3608618677,
0.2887335122,
0.6237145066,
0.1767585278,
-0.3565917611,
-0.2744567692,
0.0427848808,
-0.1631707996,
-0.2229561061,
0.3212198317,
0.5569424033,
-0.4112777114,
0.5577037334,
0.4801363647,
-0.2809674144,
0.0566340201,
0.0729352757,
0.6531212926,
-0.6459395885,
-0.9927962422,
-0.5598812699,
0.3105473816,
-0.1988020986,
-0.9248799086,
0.9851040244,
0.5715622306,
0.8301971555,
0.0641191453,
0.646959424,
-0.2554717064,
0.8922044039,
-0.0853439271,
0.8387002349,
-0.4500726163,
0.0582879111,
-0.0097378008,
-1.0404320955,
-0.3058793843,
0.4626863301,
-0.1461022198,
-0.238222912,
0.7219755054,
0.3799182475,
0.0333200768,
0.4050220251,
0.1839208752,
0.3734624982,
0.0878331736,
0.2617397606,
1.1925644875,
0.1632504314,
0.8646963239,
-0.1923468858,
-0.0051713213,
-0.5579128265,
-0.8188673258,
-0.8902668953,
-0.7119950056,
-0.4585103095,
-0.0246078726,
-0.070557937,
0.7705232501,
0.6280367374,
-0.7386350632,
-0.2356169671,
-0.0873329937,
-0.0193273723,
-0.3824231625,
-0.2665323019,
-0.0597477742,
0.4567708075,
-0.2483062148,
0.5534858108,
0.265683651,
-0.3766779006,
-0.3531509042,
0.0742084458,
-0.4821045697,
-0.0848468989,
0.4453975856,
0.3607071042,
-0.4615325332,
-0.2584047616,
-0.1840550303,
0.0877550542,
0.1752428412,
1.0952749252,
-0.467531532,
0.676478982,
0.3371452391,
0.5010020137,
0.9314416647,
0.03846604,
0.4094458818,
-1.1445850134,
-0.322529465,
0.3847983181,
0.1785536259,
0.3910945058,
-0.2199890316,
0.5720300078,
0.4511431754,
-0.5076805353,
-0.558113873,
0.0630954504,
-0.7417674065,
-0.6015815139,
1.0309785604,
-0.0355246738,
0.1200196967,
-0.5487864614,
-0.2979459763,
-0.2499705106,
-0.3159731925,
0.6744517088,
0.8421455622,
-0.1753085703,
-0.5097878575,
-0.8018471003,
0.2310255617,
-0.4063444138,
-0.914486587,
0.3249017894,
0.5586364865,
0.2444215715,
0.2141629606,
0.5921240449,
0.3730939627,
0.3404810727,
0.0982545242,
-0.0445138812,
-0.259218812,
-0.330098182,
-0.2247047722,
0.3220199049,
-0.4293376207,
0.0166847315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09668v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09668v1
|
Improving the Generation Quality of Watermarked Large Language Models via Word Importance Scoring
| 2023-11-16T08:36:00 | 2023-11-16T08:36:00 |
Yuhang Li, Yihan Wang, Zhouxing Shi, Cho-Jui Hsieh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
The strong general capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) bring
potential ethical risks if they are unrestrictedly accessible to malicious
users. Token-level watermarking inserts watermarks in the generated texts by
altering the token probability distributions with a private random number
generator seeded by its prefix tokens. However, this watermarking algorithm
alters the logits during generation, which can lead to a downgraded text
quality if it chooses to promote tokens that are less relevant given the input.
In this work, we propose to improve the quality of texts generated by a
watermarked language model by Watermarking with Importance Scoring (WIS). At
each generation step, we estimate the importance of the token to generate, and
prevent it from being impacted by watermarking if it is important for the
semantic correctness of the output. We further propose three methods to predict
importance scoring, including a perturbation-based method and two model-based
methods. Empirical experiments show that our method can generate texts with
better quality with comparable level of detection rate.
|
[
-0.0195363499,
-0.4596948326,
0.4713555276,
0.0786881521,
-0.569453299,
-0.1654235423,
0.0750184059,
-0.5273806453,
-0.0575575493,
0.7136169672,
0.1033869535,
-0.5998286605,
-1.0556528568,
-0.1888580024,
-0.5575197339,
1.0721735954,
0.2196307629,
-0.0320675112,
-0.1422634125,
-0.0409588069,
-0.2003191262,
-0.6471648216,
-0.6679189205,
-0.1108199209,
0.451813817,
0.0611100756,
0.6794240475,
0.9319822788,
0.7599971294,
0.2441285551,
-0.4037647247,
0.0872346088,
-0.7179070115,
0.3467016518,
-0.3663834631,
-0.1796367466,
-0.4508770108,
0.0861276537,
0.5846914053,
0.5503640175,
0.3663164079,
0.3989281356,
0.2109573185,
0.4487476349,
-0.7938149571,
0.1953362823,
-0.9223046303,
-0.1983768642,
-0.2820685208,
-0.6010248661,
-0.4676249027,
-0.3983736038,
-0.0458516181,
-0.2357774973,
-0.0060436623,
0.1952947229,
1.1864358187,
0.1051408648,
-0.1083524004,
0.0263708252,
-0.6301217079,
1.0931687355,
-1.115896821,
0.0541134402,
0.4341364205,
-0.2259295583,
-0.5768286586,
-0.4918116927,
-0.3237644136,
0.2091308087,
0.3372555673,
-0.0204901453,
-0.1167399958,
0.1997447163,
0.3751294315,
0.4233404994,
0.0659981295,
0.1119948775,
-0.1657379419,
-0.3669412434,
0.8461754918,
0.2510024905,
0.4376701117,
-0.1009775028,
-0.1768038124,
-0.2292717844,
-1.053784132,
0.3406399786,
0.8501878977,
0.3124971092,
0.3329200745,
0.608458817,
0.0248600449,
0.6034382582,
-0.1136735752,
-0.4884476364,
0.0487436764,
-0.2179991007,
-0.0115143983,
0.086610496,
0.7506082654,
0.3866108656,
0.3100655675,
0.1139564365,
-0.4076794684,
-0.2267988175,
0.2510842085,
-0.9381152391,
0.1235786304,
0.3307294548,
-0.6379107237,
-0.7109435797,
0.2400145084,
-0.5346415043,
-0.5107015371,
-0.1381452829,
0.7342802286,
-0.5128849745,
-0.3074118793,
0.1302838475,
-0.3032625318,
-0.049419716,
0.4451598525,
-0.8711675406,
-0.0025209342,
0.6009604931,
0.3530403674,
-0.2030790597,
-0.0699849278,
-0.7421726584,
0.5167094469,
-0.6140202284,
0.7334102988,
-0.7198225856,
-0.3349745572,
0.0563865937,
-0.396604985,
0.2820199728,
-0.4288870096,
0.3907419443,
-0.6474525332,
0.19509615,
-0.231126681,
-0.896866858,
-0.106670402,
0.0574461631,
-0.6430472732,
1.0431895256,
0.0538411848,
-1.109806776,
0.557153523,
-0.6835848093,
-0.5363054872,
0.455930829,
0.0769865811,
-0.6754149199,
0.3517509997,
0.0419089459,
0.7629589438,
-0.2806200385,
0.4392745197,
-0.0910361856,
-0.3730251491,
0.3594903052,
-0.5783259273,
0.4703306258,
-0.0622602776,
-0.5492805243,
0.1898874938,
-0.9084585309,
0.5520275235,
0.0184454266,
-0.7307496667,
-0.6142346859,
0.0854469761,
0.0616878495,
0.052459158,
0.404602319,
-0.3113742173,
-0.3616320789,
-0.463101387,
0.445217818,
0.8075277209,
0.3954801857,
0.1384032071,
-0.1143747121,
0.4742456079,
0.1239585727,
0.3542057574,
-0.311098367,
-0.7783927917,
-0.7718046904,
-0.3557920158,
0.7311835289,
0.2337148339,
-0.3711045086,
0.854311347,
-0.5268210769,
-0.4539874792,
-0.5330709815,
0.0888583064,
0.4761441946,
0.0430586003,
0.2178188264,
-0.3452967405,
-0.1442305893,
-0.7631320357,
-0.399746716,
-0.5374000072,
0.1147627532,
0.2119918913,
0.3907027543,
-0.0202048551,
1.0704451799,
-0.3517064154,
-0.0335541442,
-0.3466471732,
0.1846731603,
-0.0267360788,
0.407428056,
0.4457839429,
-0.8170360327,
-0.2431579828,
-0.203660205,
-0.3186734915,
-0.4199640751,
0.2364759147,
-0.1384317577,
0.0372881368,
0.4191035628,
-0.4480138421,
0.6489593983,
0.8356624246,
-0.4516887665,
0.4616378844,
-0.1872803718,
0.4053015113,
-1.1633666754,
0.2138364464,
-0.3243791759,
-0.1713447571,
-0.6073533297,
0.0303751677,
0.063546747,
-0.2844014466,
-0.4359676242,
0.601137042,
-0.3065073788,
0.1588433832,
-0.4433775246,
-0.3030064702,
0.3890739083,
-0.0123525038,
-0.3993006051,
0.7000751495,
0.2153047025,
-0.5557836294,
-0.1389403194,
-0.3560838997,
-0.5665453076,
0.14084737,
-0.6400228143,
-0.0361253172,
-0.0499015935,
-0.2527263165,
-1.1665372849,
0.1260548979,
-0.1436420679,
-0.3854406178,
0.6565799713,
-0.1638916284,
-0.5731571913,
0.0418358184,
-0.4323296249,
0.3572425246,
0.4029193223,
-0.3586199284,
0.3292732835,
0.7835744619,
-0.1672012359,
-0.4987490773,
-0.4639809132,
0.265014261,
-0.3451351821,
-0.5786328912,
0.5260548592,
0.0820984989,
-0.3020000458,
0.1978684962,
0.0472476259,
0.226701051,
0.4043619931,
0.4300929904,
0.0060685128,
0.006109884,
0.2389166206,
0.2690825164,
-0.4119265676,
-0.0878517777,
-0.3752653003,
0.4345062971,
0.3812466264,
-0.3430553079,
-0.2373797148,
0.5378488898,
0.7011056542,
-0.3679959476,
0.9124515653,
0.4708887339,
-0.5517525077,
-0.2271323651,
-0.7401487231,
-0.1138578132,
-0.4267376065,
0.2895816863,
0.0059879092,
-1.1132490635,
0.3992720544,
-0.0665396973,
0.2373753488,
0.6928174496,
0.4410521388,
0.0576746948,
1.0524563789,
0.7579282522,
-0.2845680416,
0.7155935764,
-0.0947933719,
0.5640892982,
-0.6266486049,
0.0940726697,
-0.4999862313,
0.0567657948,
-0.450217545,
-0.5051540136,
0.2650494277,
0.3773477674,
-0.1087105051,
0.2362482399,
-0.5303282142,
0.5512449145,
0.4667897522,
-0.0907826945,
0.2777200341,
0.4261754751,
-0.2138112634,
-0.2787055373,
-0.5589959621,
-0.96537292,
1.1416386366,
0.4505211115,
0.5340175629,
0.0865241438,
0.903200388,
0.4484401345,
0.5037400126,
-0.3904343247,
0.4829528928,
-0.1361233741,
-0.6602121592,
-0.6268812418,
-0.5705062747,
-1.0791071653,
0.1661449373,
-0.2382296175,
-0.7538968921,
-0.1658059955,
0.0570207015,
-0.2728384435,
0.2474966049,
-0.5681240559,
0.6324729919,
-0.0604238249,
-0.5289651155,
-0.4246736169,
-0.1750536859,
0.0832861066,
-0.2657850087,
0.4407172799,
-0.3865007758,
-0.1520850807,
1.0625025034,
-0.5755620003,
0.8799058795,
-0.2061896622,
-0.3755705953,
0.4880803823,
0.161367774,
0.651327312,
-0.1183281764,
-0.3673321307,
0.4145071805,
-0.3709976673,
-0.2306978256,
-0.2246516049,
0.8141483665,
-0.519492507,
-0.9457083344,
-0.1859388351,
-0.3843036294,
0.0555775575,
0.3525255024,
0.5106149316,
0.4302165508,
0.1400738806,
0.0936257839,
0.5714987516,
-0.4032002091,
0.4949865639,
0.1649509519,
0.093699865,
-0.5574119687,
1.0207531452,
0.5291278958,
0.2628808916,
0.3006832004,
0.4981677532,
-0.2925948203,
-1.0583636761,
-0.2237590849,
0.0791871399,
-0.8884313107,
-0.560695529,
-0.7588862777,
-0.4163198173,
-0.2556118369,
-0.0160149857,
-0.2533708811,
-0.4048133194,
-0.4012954235,
-0.0540407598,
0.7485410571,
0.5583879948,
0.1605951041,
0.1041641384,
-0.8623293042,
0.0529109128,
0.3266144395,
0.5476307869,
0.081277132,
-0.8939722776,
-0.2061988264,
-0.135621503,
-0.3587296009,
-0.5379938483,
0.275529474,
0.1819834709,
0.6305318475,
0.481746316,
0.1153614745,
0.6957185864,
-0.6024383307,
0.9424558282,
0.3202172518,
-1.2358145714,
0.6497558355,
-0.3513870537,
0.0466653146,
0.4482854903,
0.0243417434,
-0.1401367337,
-0.7684187889,
-0.8496918082,
-1.3138346672,
0.4443630874,
0.4971560538,
0.5879718065,
-0.2117666751,
0.4391213059,
0.086709179,
0.2106062472,
-0.7340731025,
0.017394146,
-0.1064253747,
-0.3273300231,
0.1926449686,
-0.7944028378,
0.1353980601,
-0.1363936961,
0.9108622074,
0.0201897249,
-0.099395521,
-0.0526390634,
0.2516712248,
-0.303904146,
0.3742703497,
0.3315502107,
0.5237971544,
0.2113058269,
0.1116229743,
0.0302891284,
-0.6124730706,
0.293515116,
-0.3406479359,
-0.3050854504,
0.0325449705,
0.5480296016,
0.6880047321,
0.2983912528,
-0.6213869452,
0.6588046551,
0.0753009394,
0.1201906651,
0.0910334513,
0.3671793044,
0.2018097788,
-0.1062207371,
0.456587106,
-0.3485518098,
0.055494938,
-0.2379598022,
-0.0597166345,
0.4074378908,
-0.2405471802,
-0.1316968352,
0.5543417931,
0.3495726883,
-0.3486793637,
0.0814832672,
-0.0603697859,
-0.6569868326,
0.5204664469,
0.4528116584,
0.764719367,
-0.4383570552,
-0.1338152587,
0.6415130496,
0.3639656901,
-0.3226206303,
0.3379471302,
0.1934381723,
-0.7621925473,
-0.518732965,
-0.9415393472,
-0.3897505701,
0.4876179099,
-0.2067482322,
0.2871241868,
-0.5709546804,
-0.6567887664,
0.1351605952,
-0.1492506266,
-0.3376725316,
0.3602510691,
-0.0259397402,
0.4018657207,
-0.6796665788,
0.6217898726,
0.2893653214,
-0.066157043,
-0.8830240965,
0.1537524462,
-0.4410536885,
-0.4232066274,
0.7860271931,
0.3138028383,
-0.1686870009,
0.26798895,
-0.5383529663,
-1.3108003139,
0.7179028988,
0.4998893142,
-0.468665868,
0.6127283573,
0.3351327181,
0.5864189863,
-0.3087919056,
-0.0670778453,
0.1662128568,
0.4929562807,
-0.4190462828,
-0.4499431252,
0.217846036,
-0.4046244323,
0.4381682873,
0.4352271557,
-0.2621003985,
0.5378383994,
-0.2682580352,
-0.4467121065,
-0.0411738791,
0.3074455261,
0.3273543715,
-0.1175841615,
0.4811137617,
0.4651140869,
0.6159716249,
-0.0985028967,
1.0401915312,
-0.4096002877,
0.262906462,
0.6334744692,
-0.2745519876,
0.9173693061,
0.7140700221,
-0.1067242324,
0.1443551779,
0.4022562802,
-0.0516503714,
0.3154440522,
0.5325213671,
-0.1088615879,
-0.5124896765,
-0.3669694066,
-0.3175271153,
0.3290715516,
0.488466233,
-0.8550285697,
-0.0308816098,
-0.2549776137,
-0.024103649,
0.1467854083,
-0.1771025807,
0.7946292162,
0.0839360654,
-0.4903669357,
0.4673925042,
0.3090676963,
0.5504766107,
-0.5207489729,
-0.0772350281,
0.0236192904,
0.047389172,
-0.1992937326,
-0.7258814573,
-0.0507666916,
0.262601018,
-0.4360236824,
-0.254139334,
0.7874498963,
-0.3344094455,
-0.6256632209,
0.4903213978,
0.159134835,
0.295556426,
-0.0944747627,
-0.4940414727,
0.2081940472,
-0.1836687028,
-0.5653022528,
0.4913857579,
0.5873971581,
-0.3897695839,
0.5008432269,
1.0793774128,
0.3306082785,
-0.0495138727,
0.4307124019,
0.6584076881,
-0.6218484044,
-0.5076861978,
-1.0990414619,
0.4580873549,
-0.264475137,
-0.3776140511,
0.7344402671,
0.3394744098,
0.4293670654,
0.0486382209,
0.8368029594,
0.2188091725,
0.1164036095,
-0.5379889011,
1.1510784626,
-0.4833850265,
0.3448984623,
-0.6525248885,
-0.9671804905,
-0.6054475904,
0.3470111489,
-0.322514236,
-0.0544962063,
0.4401239753,
0.7011204362,
0.2579149604,
-0.2099495977,
0.7305166721,
-0.1455783695,
0.6181015968,
0.269600749,
0.7958564162,
-0.7958985567,
0.6275871396,
-0.1079984531,
-0.2517761886,
-0.2890882194,
-1.3206989765,
-0.7854400873,
-0.5874841809,
-0.7004649639,
-0.4723566771,
-0.0052674944,
0.7265768647,
0.695045948,
-0.9169330597,
0.198869884,
0.0323786065,
0.050143186,
-0.0662929565,
-0.2655015588,
0.6127431989,
-0.4139631987,
-0.5314745307,
-0.0993534252,
0.6666517854,
0.3735351264,
-0.1441220641,
0.1297760606,
0.3011676073,
0.4018955827,
0.6224364042,
-0.2964677215,
-0.6223553419,
-0.7045636177,
-0.3882099688,
-0.4221921563,
-0.2584737241,
0.7739449739,
-0.2515070438,
0.2461079508,
0.6289174557,
0.6357701421,
0.0875723809,
-0.1411869377,
0.4780320525,
-0.5948277116,
-0.0033348633,
0.2606499195,
0.5978247523,
0.7671119571,
-0.6285969019,
0.2213831097,
0.2985430062,
-0.3578980863,
-0.8212644458,
0.0241801366,
-0.5411142707,
-0.1469691992,
1.5128237009,
-0.5389611125,
-0.4869576097,
-0.3565959334,
-0.197288841,
0.1381620914,
-0.30521366,
1.1110100746,
0.9197474718,
0.5755226016,
0.2298627049,
-0.1402516514,
0.5208745003,
0.3929260969,
-0.8680517077,
0.4277516603,
0.1543994844,
0.5476331115,
0.2765529454,
0.3573453128,
-0.7623203397,
0.1871483773,
-0.1486371458,
0.4110563099,
-0.0091951573,
-0.0877943784,
-0.1330847889,
0.4327032268,
0.3581046164,
-0.0413980968
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09665v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09665v2
|
The Wisdom of Partisan Crowds: Comparing Collective Intelligence in Humans and LLM-based Agents
| 2023-11-16T08:30:15 | 2024-02-16T16:43:53 |
Yun-Shiuan Chuang, Siddharth Suresh, Nikunj Harlalka, Agam Goyal, Robert Hawkins, Sijia Yang, Dhavan Shah, Junjie Hu, Timothy T. Rogers
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Human groups are able to converge on more accurate beliefs through
deliberation, even in the presence of polarization and partisan bias -- a
phenomenon known as the "wisdom of partisan crowds." Generated agents powered
by Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly used to simulate human
collective behavior, yet few benchmarks exist for evaluating their dynamics
against the behavior of human groups. In this paper, we examine the extent to
which the wisdom of partisan crowds emerges in groups of LLM-based agents that
are prompted to role-play as partisan personas (e.g., Democrat or Republican).
We find that they not only display human-like partisan biases, but also
converge to more accurate beliefs through deliberation as humans do. We then
identify several factors that interfere with convergence, including the use of
chain-of-thought prompt and lack of details in personas. Conversely,
fine-tuning on human data appears to enhance convergence. These findings show
the potential and limitations of LLM-based agents as a model of human
collective intelligence.
|
[
-0.7145119905,
-0.1969067752,
0.8167743087,
-0.0673038512,
-0.1785032451,
0.6958592534,
-0.3078061938,
-0.1408127248,
0.366512835,
0.7193971872,
-0.6286056638,
-0.4429081976,
-0.4523873031,
0.0884086192,
0.0803706199,
0.7932989001,
0.862383306,
0.1210666522,
-0.431071043,
-0.1180685163,
-0.0822922289,
-0.6440728307,
-0.190172717,
-0.9359346628,
0.5766530633,
0.535620749,
0.8703907728,
0.494112134,
0.5611557364,
0.3608268201,
0.1816916615,
0.3964443803,
-0.695541501,
0.0074521787,
-0.6222305298,
-0.6858876944,
-0.1835472137,
0.6153770685,
0.4388027191,
0.869918704,
-0.2780258656,
-0.0698811933,
-0.1515210867,
0.9108307958,
-0.5234216452,
0.0876116902,
-1.0394015312,
-0.1992906928,
-0.1317185163,
-0.2446465641,
-0.4572799504,
-0.7069813013,
0.0619941987,
-0.4693885744,
0.3078120351,
0.1704760194,
0.6615685821,
0.4327130616,
-0.5398871303,
-0.1759119332,
-0.6143782139,
0.9666786194,
-0.6400703192,
0.188378796,
0.4826634526,
0.0210182089,
-0.4287734926,
-0.2296474725,
-0.6999241114,
-0.2646224201,
0.2000781447,
0.2616253793,
-0.0424021445,
-0.0465484001,
0.2223100364,
-0.1050163358,
-0.1888717413,
0.012468759,
-0.4194226563,
0.0723752305,
0.7650389671,
0.4273670316,
0.1242514476,
-0.2164556682,
-0.4497864842,
-0.2938738167,
-0.4181468189,
-0.0339601003,
0.5207574964,
0.2794547379,
0.1597110927,
0.4279100895,
-0.4540165663,
0.7056068182,
0.4793007374,
-0.0444142148,
0.0912355259,
-0.1668486744,
0.1275147349,
-0.13073726,
0.7875637412,
0.686380744,
0.7284697294,
-0.3631654084,
0.0158867054,
0.1014832184,
0.3836615682,
-0.6015122533,
-0.1932606846,
-0.1139494106,
-0.5449024439,
-0.2276505381,
0.477014035,
-0.8156861663,
-1.1054158211,
-0.5045801401,
-0.3105792105,
-0.1794281155,
-0.1501579285,
-0.1030700654,
-0.4079663455,
0.3353279233,
0.3947885334,
-0.6100424528,
0.488855809,
1.1734560728,
0.7042002082,
-0.3904920816,
-0.4403827786,
-0.5317884684,
-0.0726492628,
-0.5020586848,
1.2275998592,
-0.6240959167,
-0.4463003278,
-0.2852554917,
-0.3029545844,
0.0503608249,
-0.8808072805,
0.2018491477,
-0.7749606371,
0.1575353593,
-0.8385506868,
-0.6190751195,
-0.2185193002,
0.3635572195,
-0.4559492767,
0.2413823754,
-0.155970186,
-0.5568001866,
0.669197917,
-0.3973712325,
-0.0750722364,
0.2120558321,
-0.396338433,
0.0639404729,
0.2695909142,
-0.2347779274,
0.3279089332,
-0.5344656706,
0.1293803304,
-0.6363424063,
-0.3404667377,
0.7631474733,
-0.2001315504,
1.0694930553,
0.0450504795,
-0.0864656493,
0.1758730859,
-0.2753844857,
0.0231571402,
-0.1492306888,
-0.243314147,
-0.4745618999,
0.5346641541,
-0.6530360579,
0.2338812798,
0.0301238168,
-0.2844631672,
0.306207329,
-0.2922765017,
0.3456550539,
0.9831793308,
0.1063961834,
0.6737293601,
-0.8796956539,
0.2116995007,
0.0159782525,
-0.0701536462,
0.371053189,
-0.6852031946,
-0.5998019576,
-0.1621438116,
0.0759172663,
0.786244452,
-0.5839601159,
0.5098129511,
-0.5293516517,
-0.6883303523,
-0.2392858267,
0.2281869799,
-0.1241837814,
0.3420464694,
0.0240472797,
-0.5334852338,
-0.1687471569,
-0.8073022962,
-0.4820766449,
-0.6785214543,
-0.1775575578,
0.3695407808,
0.5994982123,
0.0282789879,
1.0474603176,
-0.1975606978,
0.0913085118,
0.1362959743,
0.1839906424,
0.1509463936,
0.1115312576,
-0.055736091,
-0.519374609,
-0.1827450246,
0.0401130468,
-0.8651724458,
-0.1438057274,
-0.0332242511,
-0.0991402715,
0.0534807406,
0.2683267295,
-0.7135346532,
0.1491639018,
0.2597813904,
-0.5404846072,
0.4540079236,
0.0080375578,
0.293312192,
-0.8632265925,
-0.1224978492,
-0.0187928472,
-0.1419349909,
-0.5965412855,
-0.2833916843,
-0.2562740147,
0.4724114239,
-0.4310300648,
0.3721259534,
-0.4898896813,
-0.0619482137,
-0.4660421014,
0.6477069855,
-0.0023434481,
0.0873408318,
-0.1543313414,
0.6789389253,
0.1624415815,
-0.5281590819,
0.6111479402,
0.0123966476,
-0.463277936,
0.8054587841,
-0.4584546983,
0.4967221618,
-0.2513716817,
0.2064077705,
-0.5182165504,
-0.4690443575,
0.2298554033,
-0.2229350507,
-0.0736488178,
0.0906562731,
-0.5947059989,
-0.3395593464,
-0.246497333,
0.1971079111,
0.7070207,
-0.2424377203,
0.6230598688,
0.7070359588,
-0.092448853,
-0.5270025134,
-0.5168066621,
0.2094669342,
-0.4312211871,
-0.6045623422,
0.0798978657,
0.1568065882,
-1.0930014849,
-0.0379282571,
0.2568913996,
0.2052370757,
-0.2868170142,
0.3505078554,
0.2133883387,
0.170453757,
0.442235589,
-0.4323329329,
0.0075619314,
0.2577953935,
-0.0716901049,
0.6248248816,
-0.5885449648,
-0.7288872004,
-0.252009958,
0.2295037657,
0.7929888964,
-0.1857881993,
0.7940716743,
0.0051808865,
-0.0464238375,
-0.0838886201,
-1.1348077059,
-0.5356817245,
-0.4746602178,
0.2388059944,
0.3184054494,
-0.6791960597,
0.9065394998,
-0.2812301517,
0.0523881242,
0.2183863223,
0.6997513771,
-0.0405800827,
0.6564630866,
0.0222665686,
-0.191061154,
0.2975977659,
-0.0082905209,
-0.221851632,
-0.5906066895,
-0.4919092953,
-0.4568940401,
-0.3636775911,
-0.6260528564,
-0.6829959154,
0.0719150603,
-0.187399298,
-0.5568740964,
-0.2052960843,
-0.70334059,
0.7097179294,
0.7410389185,
0.1081291735,
0.3851771653,
0.0756598189,
0.5906093121,
-0.0487980582,
-0.6331131458,
-0.6154522896,
0.8324269056,
-0.01144371,
0.7950273752,
-0.0201589204,
0.5004943013,
0.4901472926,
0.5229815841,
-0.7690122724,
0.8338359594,
-0.1325048357,
-0.5763309002,
-0.2357623726,
-0.5698805451,
-0.8134397268,
0.3432987928,
-0.3285798132,
-0.5516988039,
0.5276851654,
-0.3010817766,
-0.2513674796,
0.5238217115,
-0.4748308063,
0.4858784378,
-0.2845767736,
-0.380491972,
-0.4188662469,
-0.7704987526,
0.3232393265,
0.0730877444,
-0.015851263,
-0.6266852617,
-0.5501236916,
0.7787950635,
-0.2252154797,
1.0205171108,
-0.2647753954,
0.2168384492,
0.6457756162,
-0.2679448426,
0.4437920749,
-0.1325973123,
-0.3803644478,
0.3837148845,
-0.4822428524,
-0.3984338939,
-0.5666223764,
0.6449016333,
-0.8132842779,
-1.0670050383,
-0.4625603855,
-0.7726741433,
0.0175743271,
0.1129361987,
0.1626657844,
-0.0759188533,
-0.419844687,
0.3677193522,
0.5398706198,
0.21750471,
0.3426236212,
0.540223062,
-0.1627526134,
-0.5549843907,
0.8190865517,
0.3299349546,
0.3442733288,
-0.2016775161,
0.0022958568,
-0.1773720086,
-0.1703226417,
-0.1869121939,
0.3745650649,
-0.5282646418,
-0.2022940814,
-0.2937318683,
0.1017987132,
-0.026049722,
-0.0742582977,
-0.3742997944,
-0.0878580213,
-0.3333036602,
0.268193692,
0.2166555673,
0.8313325047,
-0.0576344989,
0.1217767298,
-0.5275523067,
-0.0442738384,
0.8054830432,
0.1333916634,
-0.2073615491,
-0.305844754,
-0.000229221,
0.3147923648,
-0.4172200859,
-1.2574750185,
0.0618015155,
0.124533236,
0.5312337279,
0.7040653229,
0.3517568707,
0.3667751849,
-0.3792458773,
0.6165280342,
0.0588429794,
-0.6591676474,
0.1849064827,
-0.5189970732,
0.3741149604,
0.7495778799,
0.066001907,
-0.3368004858,
-0.4801005125,
-0.5328530669,
-0.1560848653,
0.5892964602,
0.0299151279,
0.1195679829,
-0.261146456,
0.2652273774,
-0.0890987664,
0.2734036744,
-0.1890246123,
0.0084521985,
-0.2302025706,
0.2575205564,
0.0773683935,
0.0814195499,
-0.5693939328,
-0.0328518674,
0.1910666823,
-0.2459640354,
-0.0980795175,
0.2147417217,
0.4861431122,
-0.415430516,
0.2982492149,
0.8117986321,
0.8152242303,
0.0731461942,
0.225854218,
0.4116177261,
-0.1424706578,
0.2652344108,
-0.1898332089,
-0.2065067142,
-0.3047100008,
0.3669479489,
0.5165857077,
-0.2712861001,
-0.7010090351,
0.4436419606,
0.009011643,
-0.2548165917,
-0.3787788451,
0.2897029221,
0.4096510708,
0.6074033976,
0.4811176956,
0.5877665281,
-0.0021583745,
-0.870819211,
0.0703692958,
0.92729491,
-0.2254168093,
-0.2765126824,
0.3535857499,
0.3250620067,
-0.8179988265,
1.0335301161,
-0.4943514764,
-0.6686713099,
0.6785063744,
0.195733428,
0.7470245361,
-0.1587128788,
0.1842457652,
-0.0884039104,
0.554888308,
-0.1835589409,
-0.0887506232,
0.1062503085,
-0.9471939206,
-0.5492253304,
-0.1440091282,
-0.6711068153,
-0.3960103691,
-0.5928457975,
-0.0314943567,
-0.4795949459,
-0.7758312821,
-0.3039065599,
0.2920107245,
-0.480480969,
-0.2136047781,
0.1292605698,
0.7244859338,
-0.6606985331,
0.5858872533,
0.6903247833,
-0.0017022284,
-0.4656531811,
0.2988906801,
0.0863863006,
-0.6349748969,
0.5866596699,
0.0995185301,
-0.3627908528,
-0.210671559,
-0.7445107698,
-0.524882257,
1.0094916821,
0.5734855533,
-0.3833411336,
-0.0083467271,
-0.0209648553,
0.5912896395,
-0.6312612295,
-0.0279189162,
0.4729343057,
0.6682221889,
0.148270458,
-0.7094013691,
0.0538792275,
-0.131926313,
-0.2689114511,
-0.0311604887,
-1.205305934,
0.8521786332,
-0.3742099106,
-0.0987070277,
-0.3388938606,
0.8795070052,
0.6430437565,
0.6363461018,
0.877851069,
0.3075132072,
1.1008008718,
-0.072429195,
0.8475845456,
-0.4106372893,
-0.0118033588,
0.8919004202,
-0.58881706,
0.590551734,
0.4519529045,
-0.0999944508,
0.8182955384,
0.3511952162,
-0.1978260875,
0.3996466994,
0.1835422367,
-0.5450666547,
-0.791351676,
-0.3674265146,
-0.1906780899,
0.5384746194,
0.3814347386,
-0.1190560088,
0.0954544619,
-0.2842792869,
-0.1042898297,
0.2989477515,
-0.4182605147,
0.9171516299,
0.2046021968,
-1.1102995872,
0.0914544836,
-0.5318421125,
0.3990320563,
-0.0958996937,
0.047494363,
0.0564220324,
0.0368581377,
-0.1294956356,
-0.8379174471,
0.2701019347,
-0.0459191948,
-0.4180808365,
0.0571852103,
0.743388772,
-0.1775034219,
-0.249986738,
0.3316065669,
0.8940237761,
0.3186188936,
-0.198952198,
-0.5503181815,
-0.1030278131,
-0.0451182015,
-0.3878657222,
0.188332662,
0.4515368938,
-0.0249912683,
0.9891756177,
0.7045662999,
0.2169608474,
-0.0902524143,
0.1257688254,
1.0902651548,
-0.5337678194,
-0.0391753018,
-1.1936161518,
0.3738732934,
-0.6332094669,
-0.0444281064,
0.7279883027,
0.3175428212,
0.5239586234,
0.010631958,
0.5706722736,
0.0486521982,
0.478030473,
-0.1219671816,
1.0482411385,
-0.3024315238,
0.1889468879,
0.1221001372,
-0.80003649,
-0.129244864,
0.5482893586,
-0.6549665332,
0.4333170652,
0.4133883417,
0.9114819169,
0.2015903592,
0.0202367101,
0.3372554779,
0.2029393464,
0.0599752516,
0.3468341231,
1.1213566065,
0.4070598483,
0.5281931162,
-0.096054107,
-0.2267990112,
-0.1433105916,
-0.7360835671,
-1.3297588825,
-0.4116453528,
-0.2330290228,
-0.3067064583,
0.0181325395,
0.9685553312,
0.87492764,
-0.4810626507,
-0.2324776649,
-0.035472285,
0.435741812,
0.0728806108,
-0.2366288304,
-0.0768357664,
-0.0671763495,
-0.7724555731,
0.2645824254,
0.2864373326,
-0.3812453747,
-0.4559144676,
-0.2767148614,
-0.0674068332,
0.5281982422,
0.2572279871,
0.323712945,
-1.0745866299,
-0.3229999244,
0.1737992913,
-0.3207848072,
-0.0432156287,
0.6742820144,
-1.0020741224,
0.4517808855,
0.5279111266,
0.1618556976,
-0.3095521033,
0.6827651858,
0.479703486,
-0.2108965218,
-0.0080885105,
0.4056908786,
0.0089315185,
0.3615723848,
-0.0266323704,
0.4948379397,
0.451649636,
-1.1915023327,
-0.5833861232,
0.2823289037,
-1.0074743032,
0.0180947911,
0.9446291924,
-0.0247746538,
-0.2175089121,
-0.2417947948,
-0.1772349775,
0.1681327671,
-0.7673629522,
1.157779932,
0.8213425875,
-0.3064773083,
-0.0152798267,
-0.2735843062,
0.2783074975,
0.2094588429,
-0.8495733738,
0.1179930195,
0.4767879844,
-0.0821427703,
0.6058650613,
0.7140499353,
0.3302194774,
0.2529981434,
0.2223718315,
-0.04775621,
-0.0010793101,
-0.0913940892,
0.001901008,
0.4221843183,
0.0572146028,
0.2758879364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09661v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09661v1
|
Evolving Domain Adaptation of Pretrained Language Models for Text Classification
| 2023-11-16T08:28:00 | 2023-11-16T08:28:00 |
Yun-Shiuan Chuang, Yi Wu, Dhruv Gupta, Rheeya Uppaal, Ananya Kumar, Luhang Sun, Makesh Narsimhan Sreedhar, Sijia Yang, Timothy T. Rogers, Junjie Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Adapting pre-trained language models (PLMs) for time-series text
classification amidst evolving domain shifts (EDS) is critical for maintaining
accuracy in applications like stance detection. This study benchmarks the
effectiveness of evolving domain adaptation (EDA) strategies, notably
self-training, domain-adversarial training, and domain-adaptive pretraining,
with a focus on an incremental self-training method. Our analysis across
various datasets reveals that this incremental method excels at adapting PLMs
to EDS, outperforming traditional domain adaptation techniques. These findings
highlight the importance of continually updating PLMs to ensure their
effectiveness in real-world applications, paving the way for future research
into PLM robustness against the natural temporal evolution of language.
|
[
-0.2350130528,
-0.6301799417,
0.3996449411,
0.2611018419,
-0.3444477916,
0.3283421397,
-0.1583420783,
-0.1768538207,
-0.1758730263,
0.2919194698,
-0.6567578912,
-0.5419430733,
-0.6772065759,
0.2220296115,
-0.2069407254,
0.9543129802,
-0.1946706474,
-0.1261376441,
-0.410464108,
-0.495883733,
-0.5555052757,
-0.8563134074,
-0.611240387,
-0.2884595692,
-0.1210161597,
0.056062229,
0.4929262698,
0.4742885828,
0.4764006436,
0.2652114928,
0.336285919,
0.1248542368,
-0.1692148298,
0.2185554355,
-0.2637236714,
-0.3513147533,
-0.5894218683,
0.0702314228,
0.8489738703,
0.5902192593,
-0.2222453356,
-0.0079766857,
0.1429113597,
0.5730710626,
-0.4868122935,
-0.1191181615,
-0.6979140639,
0.0289483983,
-0.3919857144,
-0.6260241866,
-0.6224245429,
-0.2074802965,
0.4260410964,
-0.6780331135,
0.1901917458,
-0.1351633072,
0.6592839956,
0.30951038,
-0.2628713548,
-0.4661821425,
-0.7586563826,
0.7563719153,
-0.6798650026,
0.5627593994,
0.0648030713,
0.0238171183,
-0.3154170513,
-0.9411674738,
-0.5120831132,
-0.1179848388,
0.3453578949,
0.3232288361,
-0.0394716114,
-0.1103130803,
0.0121907396,
0.1835032403,
-0.6279731989,
0.4139266908,
0.1215062514,
0.2049096376,
0.5782929063,
-0.1249543354,
0.5233611465,
0.1880866587,
-0.7247130871,
-0.3564549387,
-0.7227199078,
0.1552736312,
0.2847757041,
0.2605366409,
-0.1264452636,
-0.0503561236,
0.224166736,
0.7071285844,
0.351015687,
-0.1166051477,
0.3761622608,
-0.2021829039,
-0.2655988634,
0.032133624,
0.5452989936,
0.0520739816,
0.1475131214,
0.0432635695,
-0.0933844894,
-0.1309196502,
0.458707124,
-0.6540189981,
-0.480591625,
0.1870357245,
-0.4883590639,
-0.0845784098,
-0.0714895576,
-0.8402234316,
-0.5058258176,
-0.4196544886,
0.4530521333,
-0.5132656097,
-0.3764415681,
0.2983658016,
0.0745638385,
0.4531106353,
0.3650341034,
-0.8946572542,
0.3738869429,
0.7123198509,
0.9094353318,
-0.5457696915,
-0.5098180175,
-0.5148417354,
-0.137513414,
-0.5124704242,
1.0574007034,
-0.4733924568,
-0.5637075901,
0.1728357673,
0.1274781078,
-0.5836801529,
-0.6179561615,
0.6679372191,
-0.7059002519,
0.411883533,
0.2110280246,
-0.6119426489,
0.0486155152,
0.246530503,
-0.5242282152,
1.036149025,
0.1032693237,
-0.4438977242,
0.6159118414,
-0.812482059,
-0.5360892415,
0.108196266,
0.1425573528,
-0.8553703427,
0.0089333178,
0.2208689451,
0.5414834619,
0.1858643889,
-0.0290617757,
-0.5009952188,
0.2395657152,
0.2818647921,
-0.2855909765,
0.8840644956,
0.2016966492,
-0.2328317165,
0.0106747737,
-0.6867666841,
-0.1237355694,
0.249762848,
-0.3104160428,
-0.6363031268,
0.4780754745,
-0.4334391952,
0.3250719905,
0.1280211806,
-0.1539473683,
0.3276330233,
-0.5650234818,
0.3177906573,
0.8916316628,
0.1453271359,
0.5108494163,
-0.2616110444,
0.629951179,
0.1183096096,
0.3000654578,
-0.3179930449,
-0.1726414859,
-0.8363081813,
-0.092143558,
0.4083625376,
0.533364296,
-0.9208961129,
0.5130687356,
-0.5414912105,
-0.36490646,
-0.2046538442,
0.2220639288,
0.0560488738,
0.1117084697,
0.4489941597,
-0.6054281592,
-0.3269795775,
-0.1785131246,
-0.5687647462,
-0.1900768429,
0.2251163572,
-0.0301907826,
0.3513792753,
-0.3030438423,
0.834092319,
-0.1178119481,
-0.1314352006,
-0.1270038784,
0.4793698192,
-0.2369340211,
0.3116070032,
1.1631171703,
-0.6898275614,
-0.7047286034,
-0.0866523013,
-0.5948359966,
-0.2947007418,
-0.574793756,
0.0248505827,
0.3909602165,
0.466294229,
-0.2390605211,
0.169409126,
0.8050245047,
-0.4033452868,
0.2672108114,
-0.1808755249,
0.0819172338,
-1.0357408524,
-0.343816489,
0.0911209062,
-0.5451327562,
-0.875746727,
-0.2337852865,
0.0676730573,
-0.0066158157,
-0.2902256846,
0.6041683555,
-0.7135961652,
-0.0403716192,
-0.410907954,
0.2436161637,
-0.1474069357,
0.2422408015,
0.2150869966,
0.7967159748,
0.6005102396,
-1.0235280991,
0.0478555001,
0.2062838376,
-0.2816511393,
0.6776067615,
-0.0783862919,
0.5150839686,
-0.0829537287,
0.015882574,
-0.8244463205,
0.2248546332,
0.2236179709,
-0.2428230196,
0.7859026194,
-0.071646966,
-0.1379727423,
-0.3429954946,
-0.6062253714,
0.1273546517,
0.3479532301,
-1.0769264698,
0.7772954106,
0.4585576653,
-0.6097937822,
-0.4316028655,
-0.2542878091,
0.0804396421,
-0.3033574522,
-0.1627147198,
0.4573939741,
-0.3277950883,
-0.1927534342,
-0.2788425088,
-0.1800308228,
0.019815281,
0.3668357134,
-0.0539216176,
0.1387642026,
-0.1670788378,
0.1340088397,
-0.0084080361,
0.060528487,
0.1052880511,
-0.6023408771,
0.5444275141,
0.0573526472,
-0.2914312184,
-0.4455403984,
-0.1024437398,
0.5525093675,
-0.0643147454,
0.6877811551,
0.3915452957,
-0.1231736317,
-0.859149754,
-0.1384859383,
-0.0180589948,
-0.518997252,
0.3437458873,
-0.5563347936,
-0.6930975914,
0.1630299389,
-0.5651319027,
0.1511720568,
0.515004456,
0.4100459516,
-0.2020990402,
0.8386452794,
0.8817930818,
-0.0646861941,
0.8328927159,
0.1181922257,
0.0510510243,
-0.6109005213,
0.0560091473,
-0.4486252666,
-0.1151627675,
-0.6436746716,
-0.3886162043,
0.0487568714,
0.0587250441,
-0.0545544885,
0.4000655413,
-0.3798179328,
0.1624905765,
0.1425902396,
-0.0682916194,
0.1647565067,
0.1430863738,
0.3728292286,
-0.1916044801,
-0.6544105411,
-0.3949724138,
1.1817128658,
0.5841783881,
0.6200850606,
0.1008303016,
0.4107601643,
0.7693331242,
0.7336261868,
-0.6563555002,
0.3422747254,
-0.5467145443,
-0.1771876514,
-0.1454741508,
-0.1128566042,
-0.8503507972,
0.1390984952,
-0.0641246289,
-0.1243281215,
0.4760245979,
0.2044446915,
-0.285733223,
0.249649331,
-0.4365478754,
0.8998980522,
-0.6338805556,
-0.0127210813,
-0.0725287944,
-0.4266109467,
-0.2677887976,
-0.4809660316,
0.1353257895,
-0.1037846357,
-0.2584377229,
0.9383227229,
-0.1381063312,
1.037212491,
-0.4034086466,
-0.3302420974,
0.4126941562,
0.0143015701,
0.5816936493,
-0.241233021,
0.0497110002,
0.2891388834,
-0.1003861427,
-0.4526624084,
-0.4866400063,
0.4750855267,
-0.9326717854,
-0.6054308414,
-0.7450484037,
-0.1468199939,
-0.5107839704,
0.0721009895,
0.1710708141,
0.478872478,
-0.5784066916,
0.1540393084,
0.8379064202,
-0.1696293652,
0.661580503,
0.7655230761,
-0.0792410001,
-0.4254333377,
0.7724717259,
0.1419853419,
0.3698035777,
0.5282496214,
0.0508642867,
-0.4778063595,
-1.1358807087,
-0.4415536523,
0.087367557,
-0.7388259768,
-0.1484614164,
-0.5260727406,
-0.0673924759,
-0.6125469804,
-0.2438240647,
-0.2790510058,
-0.259634465,
-0.4577800035,
-0.1683390588,
0.3700533509,
0.6571443677,
0.2994041443,
0.4251306653,
-0.6052982211,
0.101085417,
0.4552361965,
0.3622647226,
-0.5453789234,
-1.0979421139,
-0.0339422077,
-0.2190360874,
-0.3994980752,
-0.8004726768,
0.5227491856,
0.7821561694,
0.6782844663,
0.2689678073,
0.1347977668,
0.4697471261,
-0.5604068041,
0.789373219,
0.0767437965,
-0.9373934269,
0.4731627703,
-0.2681137621,
0.2531509101,
0.4896879494,
0.6510954499,
-0.2579271197,
0.1066735461,
-0.3395861685,
-0.3953191638,
0.7449751496,
-0.0859226659,
0.3622047901,
0.1545825154,
0.6197462678,
0.4105142057,
0.1185959503,
-0.8096886277,
-0.1695164889,
-0.6130574346,
-0.4839068055,
-0.0871575773,
-0.143587485,
0.0696278811,
-0.1740816683,
0.7122312188,
-0.518208921,
0.2203865647,
0.1561773121,
-0.4671167731,
0.063743338,
0.3066670299,
0.6371292472,
0.6867905259,
0.0629373193,
0.0923608243,
0.5108254552,
-0.7379209995,
0.2866676152,
0.2005091906,
-0.0512321778,
0.0222191792,
0.358081162,
0.9394457936,
0.0454892516,
-0.392472297,
0.5721172094,
0.037178725,
-0.2014898062,
-0.2482725829,
-0.0831287578,
-0.4501234889,
0.0203225203,
0.2434663773,
0.0361489467,
-0.1469804198,
-0.5521500111,
0.2893155813,
0.265624702,
-0.3701948524,
-0.7354483604,
0.4378541708,
0.2929322422,
-0.377849102,
-0.005900864,
-0.1837887168,
-0.6613738537,
0.3835304081,
0.7215080261,
1.2408165932,
-0.7357316613,
0.2995626032,
-0.0365321711,
0.2430109829,
-0.1305751204,
0.0628590956,
-0.0104692159,
-0.9119909406,
-0.2460175157,
-0.7379617095,
-0.4592006803,
0.1831169426,
-0.4089803398,
0.2608896792,
-0.8244639635,
-0.303158462,
-0.0495538041,
-0.0998893678,
-0.4884532988,
0.3037860692,
0.2417159528,
0.8968832493,
-0.8397793174,
1.0055047274,
1.0389970541,
0.0452479944,
-0.1762819737,
0.3988687694,
-0.0856847316,
-0.6255133748,
0.4932255447,
-0.1180152446,
-0.4067609012,
0.2635795474,
-0.5697333217,
-0.6861136556,
0.9635823369,
0.0957619846,
-0.443258822,
0.4524460733,
0.0595355779,
0.8135864735,
-0.5660307407,
-0.36764732,
0.5038871765,
0.1183906943,
-0.6053711176,
-0.743198216,
-0.2145677507,
-0.1656483114,
0.1264218092,
0.2755961716,
-0.7423066497,
0.7175557017,
0.1773403287,
-0.5649878383,
-0.0529595986,
0.8689739108,
-0.0276393145,
0.4793556631,
0.7467694283,
0.5365177393,
0.7260344625,
-0.1902516037,
0.8761919737,
-0.2855045497,
0.3150748909,
1.0872541666,
-0.7372798324,
0.9255084395,
0.0719087869,
-0.309757024,
1.0627262592,
0.6765506864,
0.0505172275,
0.7172794342,
-0.3337773681,
-0.4080124199,
-0.2525399625,
0.277164042,
-0.2926767468,
0.24374865,
0.5410034657,
-0.2060115486,
0.0744319111,
0.3231694698,
0.0745998919,
0.2827118337,
-0.3573083878,
1.0406069756,
0.0587197132,
-0.6980903745,
0.4373064637,
-0.0253453273,
0.7043114901,
-0.6666526794,
0.2927219272,
-0.0435653254,
0.5114504099,
0.0172312967,
-0.67101264,
0.0233641155,
-0.0604564585,
-0.1547602564,
-0.5274930596,
0.9984163046,
-0.2031787783,
0.0240521189,
0.5046176314,
0.5128480196,
-0.2511816323,
0.1788232476,
-0.9839511514,
-0.0005550385,
-0.2694770992,
-0.3518356979,
0.5084174275,
0.4456971288,
-0.1012201682,
0.6783829927,
0.6532985568,
-0.0793623477,
0.2953164279,
0.2201927751,
0.7376156449,
-0.5463008285,
-0.5663692951,
-0.8110708594,
0.1364046186,
-0.0553536117,
-0.308904022,
0.9706535339,
0.2458830774,
1.028839469,
-0.1774827987,
0.9618458152,
0.3112131059,
0.4850868881,
-0.704886198,
0.4880973399,
-0.357565701,
0.2065813541,
0.0480019636,
-0.765591383,
-0.2457776368,
0.4332017601,
-0.5219905376,
0.1795423031,
0.7951532602,
0.2760770023,
0.0712066889,
0.0203350522,
0.0195645001,
0.248748228,
0.3538752198,
0.2056521624,
0.9060082436,
-0.3977288902,
0.3012835085,
-0.0914919525,
-0.279738307,
-0.1326318234,
-1.0759421587,
-1.0092369318,
-0.5176950097,
-0.7671886086,
-0.2639113963,
0.2607054114,
0.9485957026,
0.8324793577,
-1.1949272156,
-0.0512203313,
-0.0595581867,
-0.244646892,
-0.5071322918,
-0.196208179,
0.4565801919,
-0.6828281283,
-0.7723650336,
0.6025397778,
0.5093400478,
0.2796085179,
-0.1266715229,
-0.1295616925,
-0.329860121,
0.3004005849,
0.8965272903,
0.6601566672,
-0.2456835061,
-0.3980590999,
0.1133464202,
-0.0590115152,
0.2542366683,
0.9672921896,
-0.6983526349,
0.6737941504,
0.5188276768,
0.9071567655,
0.1477643549,
0.3442828059,
0.5563444495,
-0.935420692,
-0.0177468359,
0.178861469,
0.2230236232,
0.5321683288,
-0.1304337978,
0.4083213508,
0.5849436522,
-0.6484180689,
-0.9109107852,
0.0494421683,
-0.8774883151,
-0.4385699034,
0.9879469872,
-0.1213573664,
-0.0938205048,
-0.6179243922,
0.1021878868,
0.0422326848,
-0.0376518033,
0.8268495202,
0.6648659706,
-0.2414349169,
-0.170670107,
-0.3029760718,
0.9356294274,
0.3837021589,
-1.2066825628,
0.1422970146,
0.0651878715,
0.3683022261,
0.197956413,
0.7189580202,
-0.0425283983,
0.1596309692,
-0.2454704195,
-0.0794846714,
0.2365630716,
-0.6000441909,
-0.819126606,
0.0974579379,
0.3419301212,
-0.2654841244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09656v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09656v2
|
Structured Chemistry Reasoning with Large Language Models
| 2023-11-16T08:20:36 | 2024-02-09T16:35:28 |
Siru Ouyang, Zhuosheng Zhang, Bing Yan, Xuan Liu, Yejin Choi, Jiawei Han, Lianhui Qin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) excel in diverse areas, yet struggle with
complex scientific reasoning, especially in the field of chemistry. Different
from the simple chemistry tasks (e.g., molecule classification) addressed in
previous studies, complex chemistry problems require not only vast knowledge
and precise calculation, but also compositional reasoning about rich dynamic
interactions of different concepts (e.g., temperature changes). Our study shows
that even advanced LLMs, like GPT-4, can fail easily in different ways.
Interestingly, the errors often stem not from a lack of domain knowledge within
the LLMs, but rather from the absence of an effective reasoning structure that
guides the LLMs to elicit the right knowledge, incorporate the knowledge in
step-by-step reasoning, and iteratively refine results for further improved
quality. On this basis, we introduce StructChem, a simple yet effective
prompting strategy that offers the desired guidance and substantially boosts
the LLMs' chemical reasoning capability. Testing across four chemistry areas --
quantum chemistry, mechanics, physical chemistry, and kinetics -- StructChem
substantially enhances GPT-4's performance, with up to 30\% peak improvement.
Our analysis also underscores the unique difficulties of precise grounded
reasoning in science with LLMs, highlighting a need for more research in this
area. Code is available at \url{https://github.com/ozyyshr/StructChem}.
|
[
0.0734771565,
-0.9331878424,
1.3249781132,
0.3332310021,
-0.0071736365,
0.4931911528,
-0.2929640412,
-0.2517876029,
-0.1138046235,
0.1512525529,
-0.41644907,
-0.8023335338,
-0.3272032142,
0.193897143,
0.0253148228,
0.7003985643,
-0.4536522329,
0.2361129522,
-0.4385267496,
0.3152937293,
-0.2091516852,
-0.253467083,
-0.6360789537,
-0.656311214,
0.6013068557,
0.4271274507,
0.4516968727,
0.3696649373,
0.455570817,
0.3286160529,
-0.2822058201,
0.1948202252,
-0.4245425761,
0.2897237241,
-0.3023277521,
-0.4559054077,
-0.4216125011,
-0.0541550778,
0.623269856,
0.8383108974,
-0.1951007694,
-0.2506909072,
-0.1161651835,
0.7484874129,
-0.3143013716,
0.4724314809,
-0.4912673235,
0.0598016754,
0.0284150317,
-0.0523496233,
-0.3084371388,
-0.2935704291,
0.0485108607,
-0.4384046197,
0.0006774978,
-0.0553226545,
0.6609179974,
0.2516005635,
-0.5563032031,
-0.1776392162,
-0.6702402234,
0.6308008432,
-0.5496393442,
0.6456375122,
0.0918974355,
0.1565942168,
-0.7055966258,
-0.9447926283,
-0.4717114568,
-0.5948619246,
0.2576967776,
0.172463581,
0.3251807988,
0.2973931432,
0.3412899077,
0.4001338482,
-0.6749068499,
-0.1886773258,
-0.3530756831,
-0.2706094384,
0.2608510852,
0.246330604,
0.2817282975,
0.1833960712,
-0.4040081799,
0.0040010577,
-0.863607049,
-0.059186101,
0.2314162999,
0.2118385434,
0.0298175532,
0.4988650382,
-0.145983547,
0.3762417734,
-0.0954832435,
0.0796882361,
0.0924618319,
-0.4994243383,
-0.2588809431,
0.1967370063,
0.5171705484,
0.0020893509,
0.0647921488,
0.04833626,
-0.015755577,
0.1983836889,
0.1148298085,
-1.1561985016,
-0.6633876562,
0.5672237277,
0.0184920263,
-0.0971971303,
-0.2008591741,
-0.47275576,
-0.1591945887,
-0.2963418663,
0.3033552766,
-0.4946879148,
-0.1225047484,
0.0503723398,
-0.3903574646,
0.1119534895,
0.6271389723,
-0.8636274934,
0.1004746482,
0.625302732,
0.9034259915,
-0.3423482776,
-0.1768141538,
-0.3806703985,
0.3184669614,
-0.4343018532,
1.0146369934,
-0.7925724983,
-0.3405380845,
-0.3429443836,
-0.0100137377,
0.1434546113,
-0.5573033094,
0.2519617677,
-0.39019835,
0.0836208388,
-0.5113199353,
-0.5712661147,
0.0647221431,
0.4714312851,
-0.5093255639,
0.9850835204,
0.0932101011,
-0.2856589556,
0.2185658216,
-0.5905428529,
-0.379216373,
0.1211521924,
-0.4049830437,
-0.2983272672,
0.1508779526,
-0.093697384,
0.2277870774,
-0.2027924806,
0.198984921,
-0.5350180864,
-0.2620735466,
0.2783484459,
0.0719965994,
0.3677228987,
0.3170461059,
-0.2152190655,
0.6026495695,
-0.60507375,
0.2992187142,
-0.0529315472,
-0.7507172823,
0.0391585864,
-0.0581864566,
-0.1707409769,
0.1662270129,
0.1984317601,
-0.2859937549,
0.4927774966,
-0.4611335993,
0.8263227344,
0.7677343488,
0.0680265874,
0.6883890033,
-0.0835248977,
0.2559503615,
-0.0068467949,
-0.1898209602,
-0.0225990228,
-0.4576768279,
-0.479208529,
-0.3887073398,
0.0863395259,
0.4489744008,
-0.6688819528,
0.1527032554,
-0.0275083389,
-0.6933315396,
0.0206577517,
0.4564302862,
0.2465582937,
0.5107731223,
0.4396159351,
0.0732469857,
-0.2291692793,
-0.8024669886,
-0.5101873875,
-0.2651497424,
-0.0745463669,
-0.0132282125,
0.6758722067,
-0.4048868716,
0.6515617371,
-0.5987182856,
0.1470242888,
-0.3658924699,
-0.0623946972,
0.2630096078,
0.397742182,
0.0229544677,
-0.7288120985,
-0.4747019112,
-0.0833417103,
-0.6739539504,
-0.2393430173,
0.1444651037,
-0.4566040039,
0.1400135607,
0.6400527954,
-0.8786451817,
-0.0418357849,
0.3317064047,
-0.494959861,
0.8501617908,
-0.1583430171,
0.1867560744,
-0.717136085,
0.0216283835,
-0.1024884209,
-0.1655798405,
-0.6969514489,
0.005053537,
0.0586265512,
-0.181566298,
-0.5593011975,
0.709805429,
-0.5033214092,
0.2255834192,
-0.2840438485,
-0.1408394426,
0.1368922889,
0.3772555292,
0.1860552579,
0.5765591264,
0.4755495191,
-0.6227645874,
0.5190942883,
0.1434669644,
-0.2069337815,
0.4485522211,
-0.7687413096,
0.1126918942,
0.1523631215,
0.4712635875,
-1.2076357603,
-0.5779675841,
0.0931099877,
-0.2062619627,
0.5126751065,
-0.0266936477,
-0.527905345,
-0.2131924629,
-0.2280806452,
0.36656183,
0.2354753762,
-0.3691572547,
0.8969689012,
-0.045929607,
-0.2997766435,
-0.2165038884,
-0.4175269604,
0.0646804646,
-0.2635774612,
-0.8457852006,
0.300996691,
-0.5390051603,
-0.3881463408,
-0.1051437408,
-0.6773938537,
-0.0776619911,
0.1381896436,
0.1171427667,
0.253780365,
0.0315674692,
0.3235932291,
0.0520598218,
-0.177826032,
0.2693695426,
-0.392428875,
0.5070349574,
-0.5205750465,
-0.2708342969,
-0.234639287,
0.3382111192,
0.6728845835,
0.0451782905,
0.4946264923,
0.2470396459,
-0.3039270043,
-0.3836678863,
-0.3455884755,
-0.5157979131,
-0.5159910917,
0.3363284171,
-0.5830307007,
-0.9469255805,
0.7052906156,
-0.279738903,
-0.2478255481,
0.1639955044,
0.8406939507,
-0.2423192114,
1.0142172575,
0.1685819179,
0.4060801268,
0.3587817848,
0.0242066756,
0.4902921617,
-0.4222353995,
-0.4933800101,
-0.3586191237,
-0.1809507459,
-0.3073739409,
-0.5287373066,
0.5368624926,
0.1562533975,
-0.6194530725,
-0.0211545378,
-0.4080120623,
0.6631604433,
0.3767255545,
0.1639702171,
0.3994468153,
0.2162489593,
-0.4690875411,
0.0648813993,
-0.6457919478,
-0.4809113145,
0.6522580981,
0.3835164011,
0.9710126519,
0.2552496493,
0.5350441337,
-0.1025776714,
0.2390641719,
-0.9214954972,
0.536149919,
0.3866304457,
-0.7180759311,
-0.2757766843,
-0.8311452866,
-0.5946868062,
0.3272029161,
-0.0489342287,
-0.3505554497,
-0.1978191286,
0.2396536618,
-0.2480491251,
0.1301529706,
-0.7701455951,
1.0296961069,
-0.4488099217,
-0.7091623545,
-0.0884755179,
-0.606223464,
0.3807249069,
-0.088312842,
0.1478669196,
-0.2811557055,
0.0713789687,
0.4435800314,
-0.6434901357,
0.5255771279,
-0.0381561294,
-0.2425872982,
0.2912531197,
0.3513413966,
0.5935572386,
0.0027561369,
0.0521209948,
0.1157193854,
0.1997567266,
-0.6528038383,
-0.7428103089,
0.8756682873,
-0.4688887894,
-0.7755131125,
-0.5278494954,
-0.6455101967,
-0.4031660557,
0.3573163152,
0.150682047,
-0.0283331126,
-0.0146396123,
0.02328391,
0.8882248402,
-0.2273385227,
0.1083658114,
0.4343908429,
-0.1126356348,
-0.3067153096,
0.5744252801,
-0.0322733745,
0.5475975871,
0.3057219088,
0.4291560948,
-0.4548499584,
-0.675508976,
-0.4149595797,
0.2627620995,
-0.9519949555,
-0.1377601773,
-0.4963342547,
-0.0726704597,
-0.3597160876,
-0.2615215182,
-0.4117509723,
-0.3208019137,
-0.0621135645,
-0.4748763442,
0.390627265,
0.5049398541,
0.0246150121,
0.0252096653,
-0.826813817,
0.2443985492,
0.4130367339,
0.3858835995,
-0.1941716969,
-0.258703053,
0.041058816,
-0.2246197909,
-0.2416396141,
-0.9932235479,
0.0767358691,
0.1027563885,
0.6503458619,
0.1567464769,
-0.2224903852,
0.6275317669,
-0.6371745467,
0.7288714647,
0.1942900866,
-1.0168608427,
0.6877022982,
-0.5940871239,
0.3137795031,
0.5505333543,
0.3965263367,
-0.2097756267,
-0.4071997702,
-0.4666018188,
-1.1432106495,
0.1604975611,
0.1308056563,
-0.1699665934,
0.0127334623,
0.4385259748,
-0.2717043459,
0.2304711193,
-0.646910727,
-0.0827426016,
-0.2583650053,
-0.436776787,
0.2337940782,
-0.1077112332,
-0.1971043497,
-0.3928175271,
0.6959509254,
-0.1390605122,
0.0913944691,
0.3134644628,
-0.1216892079,
-0.0819756463,
0.503049612,
0.6732633114,
0.688410759,
-0.2800457776,
0.5940017104,
0.2699164748,
-0.3495526016,
0.3722985685,
-0.0804384053,
0.2697044611,
-0.4723962247,
0.3078708351,
0.3697752357,
0.1972617954,
-0.8181203008,
0.1752792895,
0.1549510211,
-0.3418506086,
-0.1349380314,
0.3134049773,
0.5129207373,
0.3931749165,
0.3775174916,
-0.204493016,
-0.0029508111,
-0.9292774796,
0.0970119685,
0.3444444239,
-0.2463372052,
-0.1584103853,
0.6181891561,
0.1342296153,
0.0859415904,
0.59648031,
-0.2853381634,
-0.8054507971,
0.6103080511,
0.5761569738,
0.50730443,
-0.4203188121,
-0.0397173427,
0.3031519949,
0.2686868906,
-0.3423520923,
0.4526942074,
-0.0521678999,
-0.6762842536,
-0.4229026735,
-0.657307148,
-0.5948960781,
0.0956809372,
-0.025313044,
0.0830226988,
-0.8689427972,
0.2866431475,
-0.0485734195,
0.2171299309,
-0.4100617766,
-0.0328250043,
0.0231704973,
0.986553669,
-0.9189480543,
0.6064908504,
0.8153845668,
-0.432557255,
-0.9224089384,
-0.3646710217,
0.2511142194,
-0.5094280839,
0.8944603205,
0.1527863443,
-0.2602226138,
0.0234899316,
-0.8535799384,
-0.8354077339,
0.9818742871,
0.3698944449,
-0.5761300921,
0.1383115202,
-0.1019687951,
0.5710356832,
-0.2615978718,
0.2163852751,
0.7445668578,
0.922213912,
0.6142803431,
-0.73777771,
0.3947529495,
-0.3496344686,
-0.2377341092,
0.2259176075,
-0.4813483953,
0.8364319801,
-0.3616954088,
-0.1784432828,
-0.0476279967,
0.5674907565,
0.8356001377,
0.4443605542,
0.1703753918,
0.7209712267,
0.9699370861,
-0.3807743192,
0.870998621,
0.0098036584,
0.0864715576,
0.9000048637,
-0.6604059935,
0.6124014258,
0.5159568191,
-0.2901042998,
0.74394238,
0.8601308465,
-0.1817941517,
0.4616566598,
0.5317323804,
-0.4759227037,
-0.6624376774,
0.3006207347,
-0.2960262299,
0.0920051187,
0.7616413236,
-0.0300820433,
-0.2473788857,
-0.2341578156,
0.0503261872,
-0.102341935,
-0.4019834995,
0.5628666878,
0.3318820596,
-0.5108967423,
0.4165606201,
-0.0676580071,
0.1271988451,
-0.6394481659,
-0.2632630169,
-0.2155425549,
0.1691344678,
-0.4711515903,
-0.7338485122,
0.1602024436,
-0.198184669,
-0.2725045085,
-0.2498722076,
0.8805007339,
-0.689730525,
-0.287376076,
0.1773947626,
0.4440559447,
0.270067662,
-0.309407115,
-0.5843217373,
0.1999196857,
0.0067236992,
-0.1480185688,
0.2433065474,
0.2843866944,
-0.1226533949,
0.6598011851,
0.958325386,
0.1415458322,
-0.2604252398,
0.0069992882,
1.0356196165,
-0.9131162763,
-0.4430535734,
-1.0964932442,
0.3820064068,
-0.0048238696,
0.2435396165,
0.8598166704,
0.6596411467,
0.6087735891,
-0.141698122,
0.8197739124,
0.4519763291,
0.1122806147,
-0.7864596844,
0.4860033691,
-0.3984611928,
0.3691138923,
-0.1965741813,
-1.0857400894,
-0.5246831775,
0.8622905612,
-0.3510745466,
0.2625257075,
1.1383954287,
0.7793115973,
0.0982356369,
-0.1279545575,
0.061541874,
0.5634080768,
0.8177056313,
0.791523695,
1.1625503302,
0.0062271981,
0.3986819685,
0.3278351426,
-0.1295186579,
-0.2407023162,
-0.8997818232,
-0.9716310501,
-0.1018505245,
-0.3308998644,
-0.6679974794,
-0.1669903994,
1.0205870867,
0.5595992804,
-0.679970026,
-0.0388835967,
-0.4241216779,
0.4246558249,
0.1260053962,
-0.2723194063,
0.2853654027,
-0.4151746035,
-0.5860558152,
0.8370965719,
0.5773820877,
0.1437419951,
-0.1340527683,
-0.1406321377,
0.0247929338,
0.1378956586,
0.6664624214,
0.320057869,
-0.5896880627,
-0.2901672423,
-0.0534892119,
-0.1747335047,
0.1961717755,
0.8393571973,
-0.3977537751,
0.283449471,
0.9036496878,
0.4668448865,
0.7934731245,
-0.064863041,
0.5301600099,
-0.5794684291,
-0.2367780358,
0.3052756786,
0.4357642829,
0.390255928,
-0.2876457572,
0.4136831164,
0.5288226604,
-0.7336461544,
-0.7805044055,
0.4821695983,
-1.1933683157,
-0.7645391822,
1.2304917574,
0.0688936189,
-0.3088203669,
-0.2065897137,
-0.0456885621,
0.0998491421,
-0.6421127319,
0.6692258716,
0.9653907418,
-0.5272275209,
-0.0392573178,
-0.5049971938,
0.6910967827,
0.5119206309,
-1.0535411835,
0.0781737641,
0.7824510336,
0.7246182561,
0.2014860064,
0.5886749029,
-0.0753573328,
0.1845881641,
-0.1498789191,
-0.1495494097,
-0.2758967578,
-0.5425944328,
-0.1700267941,
0.2254912406,
0.1018598974,
0.5172927976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09649v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09649v2
|
ICXML: An In-Context Learning Framework for Zero-Shot Extreme Multi-Label Classification
| 2023-11-16T08:01:17 | 2024-04-15T13:16:46 |
Yaxin Zhu, Hamed Zamani
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
This paper focuses on the task of Extreme Multi-Label Classification (XMC)
whose goal is to predict multiple labels for each instance from an extremely
large label space. While existing research has primarily focused on fully
supervised XMC, real-world scenarios often lack supervision signals,
highlighting the importance of zero-shot settings. Given the large label space,
utilizing in-context learning approaches is not trivial. We address this issue
by introducing In-Context Extreme Multilabel Learning (ICXML), a two-stage
framework that cuts down the search space by generating a set of candidate
labels through incontext learning and then reranks them. Extensive experiments
suggest that ICXML advances the state of the art on two diverse public
benchmarks.
|
[
-0.4885210097,
-0.3429395556,
0.5542433262,
-0.2063069642,
-0.159665823,
0.3179859221,
0.0724700615,
-0.5860515237,
-0.3835815191,
0.2419757545,
-0.534211874,
-1.0464259386,
-0.5907101035,
-0.1420623213,
-0.3304311633,
1.2227334976,
-0.1603515744,
-0.2492478639,
-0.2524229884,
-0.4140978456,
-0.0502359085,
-0.7865088582,
-0.6444349885,
-0.4205780923,
0.7811793089,
0.8750371933,
0.5134800076,
0.8069601059,
0.0454223119,
0.0501243398,
-0.0537974611,
0.1478992105,
-0.5033851266,
0.1535949856,
-0.0177989304,
-0.1990604997,
-0.2271156162,
0.1836312711,
0.6557714939,
0.4847469628,
0.0217699762,
0.2194813341,
-0.1754208505,
-0.0633750483,
-0.9588928819,
0.1238368526,
-0.5486826301,
0.6443383098,
0.0112889856,
-0.2635045052,
-0.5818453431,
0.2537280023,
0.1730963141,
-0.7145313621,
0.0710061789,
0.4189645052,
0.5019636154,
-0.0239680279,
-0.7995657921,
-0.0171413589,
-0.5106626153,
0.9032410979,
-0.4168727994,
0.3549146056,
0.2431989908,
0.3942505121,
0.0378443114,
-0.8783510327,
-0.5215507746,
-0.0708747879,
0.1810245216,
0.3134088814,
0.0325982347,
0.1004515067,
0.271746695,
0.035649173,
-0.4836218655,
0.4283266068,
0.1715273559,
0.2559802532,
0.3393793702,
0.3786954284,
0.1939181983,
0.5204901695,
-1.0411589146,
-0.2980834246,
-0.8997085094,
0.0522262156,
-0.1714478433,
0.3238659799,
-0.0649012178,
0.0616934747,
-0.030385552,
0.7573536634,
-0.3574526012,
-0.4697853625,
0.2341249883,
0.0143652717,
-0.2781200707,
0.6877034307,
0.5026271939,
0.3328188956,
-0.6305088401,
-0.1403901875,
-0.3853696287,
-0.2259267122,
-0.0309906397,
-0.7805817127,
0.0689793378,
0.1923135519,
-0.3019250035,
-0.3193866313,
-0.0027683235,
-0.4350547493,
-0.2667153776,
-0.4985172153,
0.690066576,
-0.1693254411,
-0.0687539577,
-0.2237753421,
-0.2268973291,
0.1713210046,
0.4974699914,
-0.3772706985,
0.1503077447,
0.5011051297,
0.9037062526,
-0.2794809937,
-0.4890992343,
-0.4756439328,
0.7934281826,
-0.3390217721,
1.018501997,
-0.7093378305,
-0.5394967198,
-0.0544615276,
-0.1994066685,
0.3272080421,
-0.6408128142,
0.5366681814,
-0.255897671,
-0.3057954609,
0.1814609617,
-0.6738967299,
-0.2875768244,
0.4884511828,
-0.0259438623,
0.9884952307,
0.3704510033,
-0.3382873833,
0.7501410842,
-0.5650273561,
-0.3611521125,
0.3343494833,
-0.1452281028,
-0.7303843498,
-0.0108779687,
-0.240317896,
0.8531702161,
-0.2798298895,
0.2417398691,
-0.6931940317,
-0.5087171793,
0.387883544,
-0.3312623799,
0.4946835041,
0.1712686121,
-0.7190151811,
0.1731719822,
-1.0233982801,
0.2922819555,
-0.2208103389,
-0.3360637724,
-0.5054966211,
-0.1738659441,
0.365295887,
0.8250917196,
-0.5766955018,
-0.7867460847,
0.3337951005,
0.1401590258,
0.2820312679,
0.7454249859,
-0.198120445,
0.2288916558,
-0.0903568044,
0.2218119353,
0.2363854498,
0.3628672361,
-0.4842755198,
-0.404129833,
-0.6262503266,
-0.3437262774,
0.0879613459,
0.3265932798,
-0.7026894093,
0.2653199136,
0.0522937439,
-0.6650374532,
-0.0669806004,
0.1005625278,
0.8692763448,
0.7168273926,
0.6924749613,
-0.1157941669,
-0.40346843,
-0.858741641,
0.258707732,
0.1299919039,
0.1122323498,
0.6565701962,
0.5324159265,
-0.4706422091,
0.705124259,
-0.7278537154,
-0.7389966249,
-0.1807069778,
0.3396520317,
0.0532370619,
0.3902080953,
0.4801371098,
-0.8476058245,
-1.0038787127,
0.2113121897,
-0.7980881333,
0.0217949878,
-0.0654033571,
-0.2088495195,
0.1053544655,
0.6162369251,
-0.1927450597,
0.7325374484,
0.4079123139,
-0.2896862328,
0.4551045299,
-0.1566668153,
-0.0165688898,
-0.6775647402,
-0.1443722546,
0.3295210004,
-0.2421701401,
-0.7741287947,
0.1555585563,
0.5060060024,
-0.2038672119,
-0.9109563828,
0.6839068532,
-0.386520505,
0.187460646,
-0.4611646533,
-0.0277847964,
0.0036902337,
0.4929356277,
0.2924321592,
0.4369643331,
0.8200526834,
-0.5919556022,
0.0902307332,
0.0818416104,
-0.4014089108,
0.8022319674,
-0.1917894781,
0.0392635763,
-0.2323868126,
0.5854629278,
-1.1845066547,
0.0741244555,
0.1111635044,
-0.3236038387,
0.7208788395,
-0.0454481691,
-0.5831022859,
-0.2280665636,
-0.2872368991,
0.5484945774,
0.2089864761,
-0.9514962435,
0.178892076,
0.4846782088,
0.4068025351,
-0.6307861209,
-0.5398135781,
0.2367000282,
-0.1656675339,
0.0799007937,
0.4909977615,
-0.3046209216,
-0.1727111638,
-0.1042507663,
-0.1166986972,
-0.1246493384,
-0.038490925,
0.5448803902,
0.1855826974,
-0.0859203264,
0.1600509882,
0.2004766166,
-0.4804065526,
-0.2201198488,
-0.6008090973,
-0.0422060452,
0.2592279017,
-0.107415773,
-0.3440992534,
0.765206337,
0.4882601798,
0.3001401126,
0.800147891,
0.501902163,
-0.284283638,
-0.6121409535,
-0.2106956393,
0.2253120095,
-0.3813998103,
0.3848412931,
-0.2769856155,
-0.7669478059,
-0.0152367782,
-0.1557288766,
0.1529008448,
0.0208726451,
0.4381531477,
-0.0614268668,
1.5538491011,
0.8666993976,
0.1712757796,
0.1420602202,
-0.371309638,
0.2043850571,
-1.004963398,
-0.4979242682,
-0.4445734322,
-0.3923429847,
0.2080769688,
-0.2571925521,
0.6034126282,
-0.1649920642,
-0.4581178725,
0.2880576849,
-0.6539586186,
0.5663678646,
0.6837443113,
0.1495397091,
0.2549865246,
-0.0403727926,
-0.2877162397,
0.2198714763,
-0.6978898048,
-0.101568982,
1.1189215183,
-0.0781856477,
0.570931375,
0.1333002895,
0.4228251874,
0.2373443097,
0.9078031778,
-0.832316339,
0.3104884923,
-0.0016958135,
-0.8877899051,
-0.0091374982,
-0.2369592488,
-0.735203445,
0.4973075688,
-0.3452984393,
-0.6617428064,
0.1946480721,
0.1089217216,
-0.4140147269,
0.70586133,
-0.735930264,
0.6472676396,
-0.3213866055,
-0.3372295797,
0.2239322364,
-0.989123702,
0.371504724,
-0.3940505683,
0.3685193062,
-0.3504349291,
-0.4590604901,
0.4049240351,
-0.3903528452,
0.9466764927,
-0.2473213077,
-0.0904519632,
0.3020169437,
-0.221291706,
0.0742414445,
0.307136327,
0.216925621,
0.2787020504,
0.0520563275,
-0.2716292143,
-0.3912822008,
0.7332333326,
-1.0259102583,
-0.1650304049,
-0.585303247,
-0.5012394786,
-0.3813329637,
0.2622545063,
0.5114793181,
0.8199197054,
0.1042946577,
0.3137747347,
0.9897428751,
-0.3349987864,
0.5476719141,
0.6217480302,
-0.1055635512,
-0.4935083985,
0.9442515373,
0.3943012059,
0.2498948872,
0.9376315475,
0.0112946872,
-0.313155055,
-0.4306951165,
-0.4473260939,
-0.1556714624,
-0.8966813087,
-0.7352103591,
-0.8411740065,
0.0376602933,
-0.3590714335,
-0.4701089561,
-0.185256809,
-0.1934050024,
-0.4201654494,
-0.0629343763,
-0.1698862463,
0.661380887,
-0.1667886972,
0.4555062056,
-0.8457095623,
0.0832201093,
0.2266053706,
0.4197692871,
0.2754785419,
-0.4786408246,
-0.3887833357,
-0.2681352794,
-0.5247763991,
-0.6376055479,
0.2957457304,
0.5404862761,
0.7144089937,
0.7502689362,
0.303665638,
0.6969320774,
-0.5363340378,
0.4455762208,
0.6551729441,
-0.8179159164,
0.4511136115,
-0.0479337908,
0.5039866567,
0.2789920568,
0.9625633359,
-0.7591601014,
-0.1550067365,
-0.643089354,
-1.2466626167,
0.8922754526,
-0.1555366367,
0.0856870115,
-0.0443774983,
0.4764604568,
0.6592398286,
0.0644874051,
-0.6626101732,
-0.7604990005,
0.0130051924,
0.020928327,
-0.4211172462,
-0.3800841272,
-0.1641681194,
-0.5767678022,
0.849476397,
-0.4540343583,
0.1667715311,
0.1149416491,
-0.1188127175,
-0.0471139438,
0.0109061599,
0.6179215908,
0.6480737925,
-0.147394985,
0.5110393167,
0.2594239116,
-0.2404896766,
0.6610823274,
-0.1196800843,
-0.1073278263,
-0.1237999648,
0.1313913167,
0.797667563,
0.5833045244,
-0.9465807676,
0.664886117,
-0.2815870941,
-0.5267980099,
-0.3706525862,
0.0560041331,
-0.3252360523,
0.0598450936,
0.6157491207,
0.0968278572,
0.2786083221,
-0.6268718243,
0.4157898128,
0.2530585527,
-1.1603317261,
-0.1721965224,
0.727006495,
-0.2943625748,
0.0244561937,
0.5322883129,
-0.2307216972,
-0.3242046237,
0.6409217119,
1.0019341707,
0.6952238679,
-0.1421536356,
0.3436299264,
0.2275831401,
-0.1685192883,
0.097399503,
-0.3160077333,
-0.5501816273,
-0.5202077031,
-0.263581723,
-0.4609240294,
-0.7593480945,
0.088120155,
-0.5818546414,
0.4670399427,
-0.6537071466,
0.0601985343,
0.1237848327,
-0.2965388,
-0.2050494105,
0.4721512496,
0.5794866085,
0.9719726443,
-0.6954897046,
1.0811883211,
0.9096413851,
0.0395891778,
-0.5637467504,
-0.4262945652,
0.4213894308,
-0.6055388451,
0.6794710159,
0.6183737516,
-0.0373403132,
0.1880569011,
-1.0231488943,
-0.8664329648,
1.0660130978,
0.0195176639,
-0.2842157185,
0.4174823463,
-0.0715000331,
0.3002543747,
-0.5370342135,
0.4178696573,
0.3696348965,
0.2822119892,
0.4180965424,
-0.3144274056,
-0.1488792896,
-0.2573078573,
-0.0106751435,
0.4127761722,
-0.6762416959,
0.696975112,
-0.1114142314,
-0.0905250534,
-0.0792035088,
0.4809062481,
0.2980023324,
0.7163816094,
0.3389061391,
0.8084043264,
0.3706067204,
-0.1660653651,
0.8448951244,
-0.0166158751,
0.501229167,
1.1941413879,
-0.4979710281,
0.7401102781,
0.1791394055,
-0.0365697034,
0.2843714356,
0.8202248812,
0.0278221872,
0.5902054906,
0.0764217824,
-0.7734487653,
-0.3619345129,
-0.3612207472,
-0.4139335155,
0.3473177254,
0.6835232377,
-0.274797976,
-0.4707820117,
0.5895254016,
0.2492101192,
-0.4989731014,
-0.5279507637,
0.7390281558,
0.0899052992,
-0.4180814922,
0.4376941323,
-0.1756679416,
0.7270810604,
-0.5443853736,
-0.3831208944,
-0.0192322973,
0.563480556,
-0.2159435004,
-1.0998661518,
-0.0141520267,
-0.5461893082,
-0.0962435082,
-0.4412601292,
0.6498371363,
-0.3260563016,
-0.1904529333,
0.5510361195,
0.0500648357,
0.1723518819,
-0.1373785287,
-0.8307116032,
-0.0370560624,
-0.1319205463,
-0.0761431754,
0.8960059285,
0.4509786069,
0.0025954901,
0.6862465739,
0.5464439988,
-0.453848809,
-0.044351846,
-0.4025948942,
0.7680014372,
-0.698870182,
-0.3165371418,
-0.7144169211,
0.3505714238,
-0.0575742386,
-0.5653889775,
0.6529597044,
0.7385454178,
1.1811919212,
0.1056004241,
0.9676508307,
-0.0018386248,
0.3412415683,
-0.0992102623,
0.5911355019,
-0.85757339,
-0.1837094426,
-0.3071367443,
-0.9810948968,
-1.1008867025,
0.1186144426,
0.2821312249,
-0.1543713659,
0.5829183459,
0.5568753481,
-0.1984271854,
-0.0658882484,
0.9465562105,
0.0384454727,
0.2800480425,
0.8192268014,
1.0834536552,
-0.2505405247,
0.8126915097,
-0.6320388317,
-0.7132983208,
-0.2348753214,
-0.8537912369,
-0.7322956324,
-0.6265507936,
-0.5231031179,
-0.080874607,
-0.1659341902,
0.9116830826,
1.1157392263,
-0.7225987315,
-0.2331180274,
0.3420251906,
0.0624951497,
-0.3926077485,
-0.1789505929,
0.2681031525,
-0.3402616978,
-0.7396740913,
0.2864958644,
1.0352263451,
0.0712105408,
0.0411380753,
0.0032121523,
-0.3281984627,
-0.3616061807,
1.1108342409,
0.5268028378,
-0.2510707378,
-0.0755910054,
-0.4402853549,
-0.1177599505,
0.4227570295,
0.8589490056,
-0.910174787,
0.4934280217,
0.1543063521,
0.3055950999,
0.4907871187,
-0.319493711,
0.0877010524,
-0.8498668075,
0.0342885517,
0.0476657674,
0.2401568145,
0.0468778983,
-0.2734491825,
0.5063451529,
0.2753037512,
-0.6311512589,
-0.9702986479,
0.0525347069,
-0.773352921,
-0.6099709868,
1.1301909685,
-0.3675271869,
-0.3345677853,
-0.5753703713,
-0.3820679784,
0.0845327526,
-0.2801145911,
0.5109664798,
0.1539962888,
-0.5364959836,
-0.2633937895,
-0.5702084899,
0.0175785888,
-0.0036726585,
-0.7403709888,
-0.1556003392,
0.209694311,
0.0854052231,
0.2869695425,
0.3630136251,
-0.0616883337,
0.1848863363,
-0.0399385877,
0.1122766137,
0.0147806024,
-0.5926149487,
-0.0417779684,
0.5751363039,
-0.0033449987,
0.2434158921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09648v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09648v2
|
Event Causality Is Key to Computational Story Understanding
| 2023-11-16T07:59:12 | 2024-04-02T02:31:59 |
Yidan Sun, Qin Chao, Boyang Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Cognitive science and symbolic AI research suggest that event causality
provides vital information for story understanding. However, machine learning
systems for story understanding rarely employ event causality, partially due to
the lack of methods that reliably identify open-world causal event relations.
Leveraging recent progress in large language models, we present the first
method for event causality identification that leads to material improvements
in computational story understanding. Our technique sets a new state of the art
on the COPES dataset (Wang et al., 2023) for causal event relation
identification. Further, in the downstream story quality evaluation task, the
identified causal relations lead to 3.6-16.6% relative improvement on
correlation with human ratings. In the multimodal story video-text alignment
task, we attain 4.1-10.9% increase on Clip Accuracy and 4.2-13.5% increase on
Sentence IoU. The findings indicate substantial untapped potential for event
causality in computational story understanding. The codebase is at
https://github.com/insundaycathy/Event-Causality-Extraction.
|
[
-0.0608273484,
-0.9260593057,
0.8768215179,
0.424593389,
-0.1804674119,
-0.0984793752,
-0.2235851884,
-0.6952826381,
0.1262544245,
0.1560345739,
-0.7046285272,
-0.1490871757,
-0.7248412967,
-0.0963292792,
-0.2895755768,
0.9984092116,
-0.1303277761,
-0.1235613152,
-0.3074134886,
-0.1208432391,
-0.5596853495,
-0.5289736986,
-0.8314644098,
-0.2546416521,
1.0606042147,
0.188395828,
0.685988009,
0.9100651145,
0.6052804589,
0.2343746871,
0.1241434589,
0.205539003,
-0.6409323812,
-0.1070004553,
-0.2242917567,
-0.3370042145,
0.0196190011,
0.1634782851,
0.5904483795,
0.7839159369,
0.1808059216,
0.1276011765,
-0.0972293839,
0.6485514045,
-0.9685742855,
0.5346103311,
-0.4137483537,
0.1889159083,
-0.3008982241,
-0.5983904004,
-0.6386312246,
-0.042079784,
-0.0782245919,
-0.9768139124,
0.4213421643,
-0.0310623255,
0.9369354248,
0.3669499457,
-0.683965683,
-0.2114011794,
-0.9719203115,
0.4989930987,
-0.2259180099,
0.3290092349,
0.4085932076,
0.3414945006,
-0.3622486889,
-0.7663906217,
-0.8034572601,
-0.0513718762,
-0.2151144296,
0.103748329,
-0.221920222,
-0.1760642827,
0.3251441419,
0.0098803835,
-0.3131381869,
0.2380049378,
-0.3957076967,
-0.1676550508,
0.7895604968,
0.5686987638,
0.5906607509,
-0.1781484485,
-0.4371320009,
-0.027539162,
-0.6707743406,
0.179014653,
0.2167936265,
0.1059066951,
-0.407928586,
0.3750177026,
0.1235729083,
0.5503460169,
0.0006337027,
-0.0191220921,
-0.0230743252,
-0.6112526655,
-0.1663713902,
0.4827918708,
0.8884416223,
0.2648662627,
0.101017423,
-0.3816771805,
0.5220393538,
0.1419402957,
0.2484903038,
-0.7316534519,
-0.1580465883,
0.2086669952,
-0.4041219652,
-0.3150682151,
0.1841988415,
-0.3138615787,
-0.8720633984,
-0.5562671423,
0.2467215657,
-0.3301917911,
-0.0033514898,
-0.0380341783,
-0.3710725904,
0.2643168569,
0.4569373429,
-0.8249824047,
-0.1396869123,
0.8874543309,
0.635424912,
-0.1126040444,
-0.5926029086,
-0.825060606,
0.3445545733,
-0.583866775,
0.6634967923,
-0.22787489,
0.351592809,
-0.1194802299,
-0.0649304315,
-0.2378522307,
-0.0318446718,
0.8314622045,
-0.6587956548,
-0.0064523765,
-0.0787236542,
-0.5045650601,
-0.2124520093,
-0.1923861802,
-0.6722396612,
0.5972608924,
-0.3932256103,
-0.9475729465,
0.4637164772,
-0.1485368311,
-0.590480566,
-0.19218041,
-0.2528357804,
-0.3408028781,
0.3646475673,
0.2556159794,
0.3931379616,
-0.4589548111,
1.068005681,
-0.4215864241,
-0.2549673617,
0.4590651691,
-0.5816036463,
0.8410596251,
0.134132579,
0.0308321919,
0.243448481,
-0.906591475,
-0.715456903,
0.1168341413,
0.1942057908,
-0.37751019,
0.2744602859,
0.0263010897,
0.3489609361,
-0.0107546067,
-0.567843616,
0.0412517041,
-0.1143608093,
0.2947589755,
0.6436172724,
0.3737657368,
0.2607293129,
-0.1597808748,
0.2782488465,
0.0785245448,
0.1825204194,
-0.4103844762,
-0.5027956963,
-0.2945405841,
-0.3077898026,
-0.0355428904,
0.4628170133,
-0.6793778539,
0.2518399954,
-0.087098822,
-0.434646666,
0.0385213457,
-0.3382510543,
0.4070326686,
0.8392494917,
0.1297437698,
-0.0325365663,
-0.8706592321,
-0.5804424286,
-0.6662067771,
-0.5285994411,
-0.1498415619,
0.2227663696,
0.0559863821,
0.0458291695,
1.1131281853,
-0.6140754819,
-0.0604197793,
0.0910545066,
0.5066806078,
0.3457490206,
0.2329900265,
0.3275223374,
-0.9020757079,
-0.1347026974,
0.0008529154,
-1.0664125681,
-0.1854652315,
-0.5922499299,
-0.1154188141,
0.1084106639,
0.7686156034,
-0.4631190598,
0.6397209764,
0.2467450798,
-0.825430274,
0.7544047832,
-0.2435780466,
0.3028122485,
-0.7904806733,
0.1286065727,
0.0855246112,
0.0820108876,
-0.6464990973,
-0.2871246934,
0.1128892079,
-0.1314319819,
-0.5196557641,
0.5815710425,
-0.216037482,
-0.107520774,
-0.0830027834,
0.6091691256,
-0.2221442759,
0.7211809754,
0.0406757519,
0.2955904305,
0.2420318872,
-0.7323263288,
0.1345200837,
0.6285659671,
-0.3381468356,
0.412378937,
-0.3908802569,
-0.2576676607,
-0.2822443545,
0.3080889881,
-0.8366205096,
-0.2777923048,
0.0919388458,
-0.7461240888,
0.0101702465,
-0.1135827377,
-0.6441992521,
-0.1092612296,
-0.0106308647,
0.4739559293,
0.0801835954,
-0.7708879113,
0.6219339967,
0.3541148901,
-0.1222354397,
-0.4647518098,
-0.3630385399,
0.2196478844,
-0.2617951334,
-0.77384758,
0.2773208916,
0.0098520378,
-0.1736679673,
-0.2183496654,
-0.0723972619,
-0.287214458,
0.2093040943,
0.4347212613,
0.3959871829,
-0.0971334055,
0.482419014,
0.096707955,
-0.4628743529,
0.3166333437,
0.0540066361,
0.0738099292,
0.3944635391,
0.033256758,
-0.7781463265,
0.1536991745,
0.6555900574,
-0.01570764,
0.8888834715,
0.8395360112,
-0.503420651,
0.5249032378,
-0.3136396408,
-0.0345138796,
-0.3426966965,
0.3559895158,
-0.2154547721,
-0.8154867887,
0.6007912755,
-0.1181402132,
-0.2749360204,
0.7907115221,
0.2877519727,
-0.0542658381,
1.013859868,
0.6004232764,
-0.3352246583,
0.5762532949,
0.4077819884,
0.4168315828,
-0.7608011365,
-0.206959039,
-0.693510294,
-0.0914233848,
-0.4237516522,
-0.0980072245,
0.5084666014,
0.6664993763,
-0.5045336485,
0.3260172606,
0.1403585374,
0.4395208359,
0.1346645355,
-0.0014196665,
0.6542874575,
-0.2165057808,
0.0427735038,
-0.1021621525,
-0.787150085,
-0.1657392532,
0.7225692868,
0.1685569435,
0.3819986284,
0.096444346,
0.4001630843,
0.1816906035,
0.1445028335,
-0.222142294,
0.2303186953,
0.1017061025,
-0.4158979356,
-0.4230150878,
-0.4992190003,
-1.1936643124,
0.0728603974,
-0.5780274272,
-1.3048100471,
0.3893803358,
-0.0776982456,
-0.2380788773,
0.0395296812,
-0.712620914,
0.9433816075,
0.0453029461,
-0.6061925888,
-0.4856120646,
-0.7668770552,
0.4284472167,
-0.201104477,
0.4824517667,
-0.0414862595,
0.2531633973,
0.9170829654,
-0.4331460297,
1.0317595005,
0.1694591641,
0.0230948292,
0.2423365861,
0.085719876,
0.7982836366,
0.3531239927,
0.0445694514,
0.2780961692,
-0.0352243744,
-0.2947739959,
-0.905259788,
0.7693499923,
-0.7331804633,
-0.2882790864,
-0.3200546801,
-0.6956256032,
-0.2007693201,
0.0835622028,
0.0234282874,
0.6252551675,
-0.3691645861,
-0.0754230022,
0.3496724963,
-0.2664703727,
0.8739567399,
0.8743066192,
0.0113533335,
-0.5231336355,
0.9598959684,
-0.3595312536,
-0.0689555183,
0.5049163699,
0.4431391954,
0.0868066177,
-0.1849789768,
-0.4221735001,
0.2768831849,
-0.4570487142,
-0.2690086365,
-0.8955708742,
-0.0702208504,
-0.0825585872,
-0.4702046216,
-0.252209723,
-0.601965785,
-0.5023601651,
-0.3259304762,
0.4346088469,
0.6446092129,
-0.2694936693,
0.2127470672,
-0.95012784,
0.5473569036,
-0.1506577432,
0.0006589005,
0.2455664575,
-0.2382539064,
-0.5016433001,
-0.3774587512,
-0.3757594526,
-0.7962792516,
0.3169094026,
0.1431248635,
0.3883263171,
0.7930211425,
0.1335033327,
0.8394020796,
-0.5647636652,
0.801563859,
0.5394574404,
-0.9453309774,
0.5958721042,
-0.4990644157,
0.2783249617,
0.2830939889,
0.5375631452,
-0.7277768254,
-0.4385963082,
-0.9648286104,
-0.6596457362,
0.996935606,
0.5109779835,
-0.3640167117,
-0.0886161327,
0.5255351663,
0.143287912,
-0.0275058094,
-0.3968475759,
-0.3363208771,
0.4914728105,
-0.1476589888,
-0.5640131235,
-0.2427099645,
0.0011184494,
-0.3321977556,
0.6532703042,
0.0489558056,
0.214218393,
0.3358778059,
-0.1741564423,
-0.4187913239,
-0.1437051445,
0.4845000207,
0.8629897833,
-0.0729479641,
0.1057572365,
-0.1518437117,
-0.5085605979,
-0.1734783649,
0.4286344349,
-0.0609471686,
-0.2499847412,
1.0183593035,
0.8346642852,
0.5541976094,
-0.5872199535,
0.5350695252,
-0.2374349236,
0.1587444991,
-0.07626196,
-0.0777549446,
-0.1846430153,
0.4591734707,
0.4269793928,
-0.1425025314,
0.1456227899,
-0.6355320811,
0.2517022192,
0.1896542609,
-0.6862335205,
-0.3492434919,
0.6847220659,
0.0948043168,
-0.2953787744,
0.6257432699,
0.0490138344,
-0.3263503313,
0.996599853,
0.6148839593,
0.9157844186,
-0.1072770208,
0.2889255583,
0.7258046269,
0.4141124189,
0.2483202368,
-0.0002816617,
-0.1266713291,
-0.675904274,
-0.6176758409,
-0.4944734573,
-0.3509847522,
-0.1456981301,
-0.5306553245,
0.5154924393,
0.0798988342,
0.3588228822,
0.4112692475,
-0.1311970651,
-0.3824009001,
0.0843112916,
0.0929406211,
0.5492346883,
-1.1497856379,
0.6137603521,
0.1377590448,
-0.5439260602,
-0.8005105853,
-0.1574804038,
-0.0347661972,
-0.2255211323,
0.7154174447,
0.0720081627,
0.2831631601,
-0.2683762908,
-0.4353284538,
-0.8116105199,
1.0474245548,
0.5218219757,
-0.4964127243,
0.2231861651,
-0.0112714386,
0.6513513923,
-0.3478307724,
0.4003320634,
0.4105699956,
0.3856718838,
0.0965036377,
-0.6624724865,
0.2053561807,
0.0025584439,
-0.1822673231,
0.4852167666,
-0.2394452393,
0.3693751693,
-0.5086404085,
-0.3996254802,
-0.1033377349,
0.9095764756,
0.261180073,
1.0380690098,
0.1691865921,
0.2343544066,
1.0091832876,
0.0517801084,
1.2352091074,
-0.1963382363,
0.270802319,
1.3338679075,
-0.0234692581,
0.4563195407,
0.4941150844,
-0.1271484345,
0.5596770644,
0.6442269683,
0.5058278441,
0.5073458552,
0.0584829412,
-0.163950935,
-0.4790564775,
-0.0559774414,
-0.0335910432,
0.2319796681,
0.3410048485,
-0.303601712,
-0.2904307544,
0.1840122491,
0.0677792653,
-0.0750848949,
-0.3096301258,
0.8686650395,
0.0805995464,
-0.7020406723,
0.2817640901,
-0.0508568846,
-0.1159881651,
-0.6556628942,
-0.1547304988,
-0.0631226152,
0.2120228708,
-0.0979506746,
-0.4120445848,
0.4825900495,
-0.1485980302,
-0.4712424576,
0.2195226103,
0.6673414707,
-0.268489778,
-0.3916942775,
0.2147927284,
0.2062609643,
-0.0382175893,
-0.1165455505,
-0.0740958974,
0.296952039,
-0.3558163643,
0.2326126695,
0.3887774348,
0.6740043759,
-0.5217309594,
0.3588342667,
0.6825595498,
-0.4650522768,
-0.2104275972,
-0.0481244922,
0.6484937668,
-0.7862025499,
-0.7357386351,
-0.8994529843,
0.4230415225,
-0.1180007756,
-0.46525231,
0.6686794758,
0.5257658362,
0.4515339732,
-0.1137661934,
0.4179782271,
0.1310856491,
-0.0752755776,
-0.5608332157,
0.4814251065,
-0.1434075385,
0.1440482438,
-0.5548900366,
-0.4816977084,
-0.5918756127,
0.0133144893,
-0.3101941347,
-0.5522413254,
1.2305788994,
0.3784890473,
-0.029660197,
0.6169738173,
0.1124900654,
0.4371138513,
0.2974106371,
0.570348978,
0.8690154552,
-0.5703362823,
0.2864540815,
-0.0545880944,
-0.6894711256,
-0.1522652954,
-1.2049096823,
-0.7951714993,
-0.9383760691,
-0.7190862298,
-0.0313143991,
0.3921468854,
0.4069965482,
0.4479389191,
-0.5644825101,
-0.1050954163,
-0.5269290805,
0.535553813,
-0.6197611094,
-0.2524398267,
0.6238652468,
-0.5233954191,
-0.1515137106,
0.5698613524,
0.4409900308,
-0.5639154911,
0.3045918047,
0.007194255,
-0.3973850906,
0.3573981822,
0.8418432474,
0.481965065,
-0.4173223376,
-0.3623681962,
-0.5255841613,
0.1788172722,
-0.2085410058,
1.4187008142,
-0.803545773,
0.4269096255,
0.3895757794,
0.6340416074,
0.7881481051,
-0.3169870675,
0.686342597,
-0.6826277375,
0.1990711838,
-0.2234447151,
0.3292766511,
-0.0769257098,
-0.941944778,
0.6387760639,
0.3553504348,
-0.5517863035,
-0.5184448957,
0.2451180965,
-1.3122478724,
-0.2349806726,
0.862875998,
0.0636742413,
-0.3530783355,
-0.1327471733,
-0.2265679687,
0.497131139,
-0.0857976452,
0.8339132667,
0.6340178251,
-0.5588206649,
-0.0291697942,
-0.2525787652,
0.325144887,
0.0572805814,
-0.9362611771,
0.4013327956,
0.6874752641,
-0.4124994278,
0.1085180193,
0.4956192374,
-0.2455800027,
0.4547412992,
-0.155919984,
-0.0808343217,
-0.1732262969,
-0.6266584992,
-0.3390109837,
0.1956333369,
-0.5163142681,
-0.0867489502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09641v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09641v2
|
RLHFPoison: Reward Poisoning Attack for Reinforcement Learning with Human Feedback in Large Language Models
| 2023-11-16T07:48:45 | 2024-06-19T22:40:07 |
Jiongxiao Wang, Junlin Wu, Muhao Chen, Yevgeniy Vorobeychik, Chaowei Xiao
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.HC
|
Reinforcement Learning with Human Feedback (RLHF) is a methodology designed
to align Large Language Models (LLMs) with human preferences, playing an
important role in LLMs alignment. Despite its advantages, RLHF relies on human
annotators to rank the text, which can introduce potential security
vulnerabilities if any adversarial annotator (i.e., attackers) manipulates the
ranking score by up-ranking any malicious text to steer the LLM adversarially.
To assess the red-teaming of RLHF against human preference data poisoning, we
propose RankPoison, a poisoning attack method on candidates' selection of
preference rank flipping to reach certain malicious behaviors (e.g., generating
longer sequences, which can increase the computational cost). With poisoned
dataset generated by RankPoison, we can perform poisoning attacks on LLMs to
generate longer tokens without hurting the original safety alignment
performance. Moreover, applying RankPoison, we also successfully implement a
backdoor attack where LLMs can generate longer answers under questions with the
trigger word. Our findings highlight critical security challenges in RLHF,
underscoring the necessity for more robust alignment methods for LLMs.
|
[
-0.0936258063,
-0.6230711937,
0.1629842222,
-0.0434731282,
-0.0968242213,
0.1674982905,
-0.2069499493,
-0.5209152699,
0.198760733,
0.8600133061,
-0.671477139,
-0.370854795,
-0.5634769201,
-0.019930305,
-0.2732806504,
1.2756261826,
0.1248317584,
-0.1447238922,
-0.0220789742,
-0.0886144191,
-0.3266899288,
-0.9873362184,
-0.7626880407,
-0.471355319,
0.8222091794,
0.415186584,
0.889803648,
0.6018978357,
0.5943945646,
0.2377856225,
0.2030561119,
-0.012716162,
-0.7956576943,
0.3789601326,
-0.2164902985,
-0.3000150323,
-0.4702211916,
0.0264328085,
0.3423498273,
0.3020510972,
-0.2944310606,
-0.1433296204,
-0.0008311096,
0.8101760745,
-0.8545238376,
-0.1591670513,
-0.601262629,
0.2912393212,
-0.1609143317,
-0.3947328925,
-0.791434288,
-0.3199494481,
0.0591855347,
-0.5715495944,
-0.1739976555,
0.4034698606,
0.7071229219,
0.3956677616,
-0.2088609934,
-0.1413196921,
-0.2875585854,
0.7676386833,
-0.6896197796,
0.0526294373,
0.3103017807,
0.296926111,
-0.518312335,
-0.5023203492,
-0.3726921976,
-0.4588490427,
-0.2087302953,
0.2165920585,
0.161591813,
0.3688387573,
0.1867857575,
0.1159041971,
-0.6765695214,
0.2614144087,
-0.1480288357,
-0.3311930001,
1.0073933601,
0.1723559946,
0.4210941195,
-0.3777916133,
-0.7121670246,
-0.4692672789,
-0.874817729,
-0.0446245484,
0.8511788249,
0.3219680488,
0.1513449848,
0.339769721,
-0.1062817276,
0.6166678667,
-0.0360365249,
-0.0601168834,
-0.1585726589,
0.0412575752,
-0.0868870914,
0.5294461846,
1.0757231712,
0.5797011256,
0.359470129,
-0.1667672247,
-0.2274161577,
-0.2437206358,
0.5922116041,
-0.9065441489,
-0.5680764914,
0.6087653041,
-0.3499026597,
-1.0197697878,
0.1747666895,
-1.0453830957,
-0.5777181387,
0.5616471767,
0.4807301164,
-0.2814331353,
-0.3414947093,
-0.1490605772,
-0.1519143134,
0.1419211924,
0.090169549,
-1.2948470116,
0.2108942419,
1.0223988295,
0.5409352183,
-0.6069098115,
-0.8618909717,
-0.8983055353,
0.1315636337,
-0.2772153616,
0.5905212164,
-0.328088522,
-0.5620513558,
0.1406384856,
-0.0817065015,
-0.0620529838,
-0.5785644054,
0.5375430584,
-0.7870510221,
0.26136145,
-0.159079656,
-0.4183298349,
0.0196523406,
0.3964382112,
-0.5731703639,
0.9005961418,
-0.2536976933,
-1.0938900709,
0.156091556,
-0.4761239886,
-0.4404572845,
0.1544906199,
-0.0446085967,
-0.4914905429,
-0.3621871173,
0.1696355045,
0.4436592162,
0.1072366908,
0.1712202579,
-0.3809561431,
-0.4613774121,
0.5465686917,
-0.2827242911,
0.7130330801,
0.1145938262,
-0.2671845257,
0.6230301857,
-0.3755604029,
0.0841690302,
0.3163148761,
-0.4062602818,
-0.2520517707,
0.2036988586,
0.1000884399,
0.1349826604,
0.2217018157,
-0.4321420193,
0.2856672108,
-0.4568787813,
0.5814267397,
0.9501504898,
0.3885130286,
0.3498238623,
-0.5658909678,
0.5957227349,
-0.3142719269,
0.5259711742,
0.078620702,
-0.3681239188,
-0.3370594382,
-0.2409804761,
0.3213124871,
0.7610028386,
-0.6060904264,
0.4849983156,
-0.2395421267,
-0.4149708152,
-0.3284252882,
-0.0590892024,
0.5970240235,
0.5224878788,
0.3440411091,
-0.0422266647,
-0.2552406192,
-0.734808445,
-0.4348087311,
-0.3322940469,
0.1540575773,
0.2396837324,
0.5319603086,
-0.1816760302,
0.566811502,
-0.5857480764,
-0.2042009979,
-0.1379238069,
0.1194179431,
-0.0203208216,
0.5423841476,
0.2741838396,
-0.6146771312,
-0.1725561768,
-0.1245521754,
-0.5730103254,
-0.0260038171,
-0.077859737,
-0.2315433919,
0.3988539875,
0.4539056718,
-0.2514443994,
0.0537658557,
0.663983345,
-0.2313439995,
0.6317123175,
-0.0788393021,
0.3523529172,
-0.9170148969,
0.0352640264,
-0.3260943294,
-0.2528968155,
-0.7233365178,
0.4164185822,
0.1840712279,
-0.35948053,
-0.7929696441,
0.5224173069,
0.0258843806,
0.0922281668,
-0.1130711436,
0.1421862096,
-0.1812367588,
0.6318782568,
0.1136237532,
0.7655797601,
0.185075596,
-0.2963581681,
0.5808869004,
0.049377393,
-0.0373362154,
0.4623256028,
-0.4473361969,
0.1866039634,
0.2164865881,
0.2802590728,
-0.9649988413,
-0.5769380927,
0.4764658809,
-0.5721891522,
0.3908337951,
-0.3700080812,
-0.2941696942,
0.0488778464,
-0.7633294463,
0.5387433767,
0.2841278315,
-0.7919421792,
0.2652615607,
0.3699771464,
-0.0708692074,
-1.0302749872,
-0.549084723,
0.154794246,
-0.4957049191,
-0.6178148985,
0.3324048817,
0.0567389093,
-0.152222231,
-0.1398872882,
0.1161720082,
0.2569587827,
0.3619687557,
0.3787193298,
0.3751650751,
0.3222545981,
-0.1131995097,
-0.2159986794,
-0.2358905971,
0.3986487985,
-0.0713318661,
0.506876111,
0.1385744959,
-0.3575982153,
-0.5566878319,
0.4195364714,
0.6937306523,
-0.1359931976,
0.5845357776,
0.1922527254,
-0.2519233823,
-0.3506034613,
-0.3413576186,
-0.5448745489,
-0.4614285231,
0.4352188408,
0.0716783032,
-0.9473761916,
0.4300944209,
0.0832659453,
0.1332144141,
0.2980190814,
0.3649114072,
-0.0888866857,
1.1475013494,
0.2781647444,
-0.3932263553,
0.3847356439,
0.0686820373,
0.1021629944,
-0.6945900917,
-0.233028695,
-0.217164278,
-0.3231503665,
-0.6690344214,
-0.0321368612,
0.3358566761,
0.0448872894,
-0.328354001,
0.1516572684,
-0.6406154633,
0.5445644855,
0.377797693,
-0.0613223575,
0.1346077919,
-0.0501302592,
-0.1516498178,
-0.112238884,
-0.6550232768,
-0.0919424072,
1.1078169346,
0.4473433793,
0.948520422,
0.1730941832,
1.190967679,
0.5014892817,
0.3297687173,
-0.9087745547,
0.4474880993,
0.1561383456,
-0.3810813427,
-0.5391777158,
-0.4577700794,
-0.8472349048,
0.3774859011,
-0.3337455392,
-0.6749633551,
-0.1842006743,
0.2759925723,
-0.4512235522,
0.2803354263,
-0.6310971975,
1.06957376,
-0.5411820412,
-0.320902884,
-0.1930345893,
-0.5856271982,
0.6684037447,
0.1492044032,
0.1487969756,
0.095130451,
0.1066095978,
1.1605067253,
-0.702388525,
0.7744411826,
-0.082949549,
-0.1156556457,
-0.1614338458,
0.2232024372,
0.7087596059,
0.2516325414,
-0.0224703774,
0.1327942014,
0.1729795188,
-0.422673285,
-0.4631186724,
0.8886825442,
-0.710762918,
-0.7267464399,
-0.860832572,
-0.3128111362,
-0.1859291941,
0.1290441006,
0.439365536,
0.0610178858,
0.0183005352,
-0.1435778886,
0.8267428279,
-0.1770438999,
0.4056605995,
0.0721096322,
-0.4269587994,
-0.9422024488,
1.0992411375,
-0.1708310246,
0.462598592,
0.3594322503,
0.2873564065,
-0.1799439043,
-0.4555782378,
-0.5396927595,
0.3304576874,
-0.5560216308,
-0.3605849743,
-0.436449796,
-0.3322604597,
-0.3825256228,
-0.2886374295,
-0.3589630127,
-0.2185778916,
0.0105380556,
-0.0393414162,
0.4934624732,
0.6703928709,
0.072757408,
0.1651229709,
-0.7039078474,
-0.0200400688,
0.5823802352,
0.176876083,
0.1144376099,
-0.3929949105,
-0.0579473153,
-0.3274393678,
-0.1511422992,
-1.219242692,
0.3174826503,
-0.2856075466,
0.4751800895,
0.4165106714,
0.4079203606,
0.3038967252,
-0.2604121566,
0.8319839239,
0.2661240995,
-0.8043828607,
0.5078992844,
-0.3781500161,
-0.0125028519,
0.5580787659,
0.2977911532,
-0.9722129107,
-0.340577811,
-0.5007542968,
-0.9485934377,
0.8443208337,
0.0082765976,
-0.2246492058,
0.0071307141,
0.3880547583,
-0.1949773878,
0.1318835765,
-0.7577580214,
-0.3039872944,
-0.3092223406,
-0.0332825035,
0.1845612228,
-0.5319662094,
-0.3435299098,
0.1768015176,
0.8608986139,
-0.0386461504,
-0.0669475272,
0.1289024502,
-0.0789640248,
-0.2335115522,
0.394135505,
0.8078404665,
0.3428647518,
-0.4110749364,
0.2230624557,
0.1489363611,
-0.499759078,
0.0825550184,
-0.0071246424,
0.0446916595,
-0.6837043166,
0.752052784,
0.3983875513,
0.3906903267,
-0.8318448663,
0.662032783,
-0.2309258878,
-0.2599438429,
-0.2308967859,
0.3277773559,
-0.0005445265,
-0.0135644563,
0.3682371676,
-0.3513093591,
-0.1336773634,
-0.5138361454,
0.3010675013,
0.4831312001,
-0.637571454,
0.0343165062,
0.4723233283,
0.3427416384,
-0.4676856101,
0.5873798132,
0.0316999853,
-0.9382964373,
0.4279387295,
0.3430114985,
0.7305803299,
-0.5438666344,
0.0773481801,
0.336404264,
0.39272964,
-0.0621633083,
0.102676481,
-0.2070093155,
-0.62235111,
-0.3727737665,
-0.5103865266,
-0.6662071943,
0.1975917518,
-0.6914628744,
-0.1140540838,
-0.7578423619,
0.0539278463,
-0.255959481,
-0.1239514202,
0.3422306478,
-0.0997425541,
-0.0367688686,
0.6070168018,
-0.7137666345,
0.7484619021,
0.4750285149,
-0.2633675933,
-0.649657011,
0.4194143713,
0.1999654919,
-0.7180030346,
0.8147988319,
0.1462292373,
-0.2236311138,
-0.0869647488,
-0.3766684532,
-0.5213760138,
0.9890063405,
0.0448854193,
-0.2850095034,
0.101095587,
0.0170815103,
0.2042914033,
-0.0877278149,
-0.123969242,
0.5912173986,
0.5280175805,
-0.0450395718,
-0.6491749883,
0.1987294853,
-0.0343936048,
-0.1841223389,
0.5656382442,
-0.610786438,
0.6409381628,
-0.191444546,
-0.1753553301,
-0.1153026968,
0.5398587584,
0.4184803963,
-0.0253261123,
0.6163491011,
0.8075395823,
0.6229411364,
0.0445883982,
0.8673866987,
-0.057830479,
0.4496446252,
0.9219166636,
-0.519094348,
1.1410040855,
0.5209428072,
-0.0712921992,
0.3117735386,
0.5735659599,
0.1161807328,
0.6433740854,
0.4258104265,
-0.1492467821,
-0.3442716002,
0.1198711321,
-0.3644137084,
0.1706744581,
0.1731120348,
-0.0249907523,
-0.1565244198,
0.0352528542,
0.3686056137,
0.1730848998,
-0.18557024,
0.9166363478,
-0.1284395456,
-1.0558402538,
0.7235401273,
0.0200698934,
0.8249048591,
-0.5460436344,
-0.0513704419,
-0.1413436085,
0.1815688312,
-0.4494364262,
-0.8161146045,
0.1677632481,
-0.2107381821,
-0.012063276,
-0.1513582468,
0.5587545037,
-0.3412970304,
0.0235557929,
0.5245633721,
-0.1927933395,
-0.1410643458,
-0.0616307892,
-0.7635797858,
0.1967480183,
-0.0310955327,
-0.2149104476,
0.6848368645,
-0.2723786831,
-0.0242476594,
0.7179682255,
0.7807881832,
0.2891561389,
0.0024210992,
-0.1066599488,
0.540489614,
-0.6045853496,
-0.6411992311,
-0.9951184392,
0.0967821926,
-0.2702094615,
-0.0339390598,
0.6191759706,
0.3432004452,
0.7929109931,
0.0700043142,
0.6712121964,
0.3155838549,
0.3022097349,
-0.7271769047,
1.182289362,
-0.3529199064,
0.1718268842,
-0.0983106494,
-0.518748045,
-0.3694471121,
0.3814704716,
-0.3225658536,
-0.1182644442,
0.8473122716,
0.9726147056,
0.316183418,
-0.0348101854,
0.3240543902,
0.0414934345,
0.5390770435,
0.5904112458,
0.991964519,
-0.2569997013,
0.6939946413,
-0.4265524149,
-0.3042904437,
-0.5933331847,
-0.9932479858,
-1.0930973291,
-0.395745188,
-0.2314200848,
-0.6193324924,
0.3082441092,
0.9497768283,
0.69821769,
-0.9012576342,
-0.3130072653,
0.1289102137,
0.4516644478,
-0.2894852161,
-0.2909482419,
0.5171653628,
-0.2558842003,
-0.3861210048,
0.397782445,
0.459056437,
-0.3226473629,
-0.5361991525,
-0.3021256328,
-0.2248135507,
-0.1490391642,
0.2326220274,
0.5483685732,
-0.8311538696,
-0.5387496352,
-0.3059341013,
-0.2262541652,
-0.2214890122,
0.8943799734,
-0.5104017258,
0.2726362646,
0.590221405,
0.8880392909,
0.0419498049,
0.1036496907,
0.3801417351,
-0.7814400792,
0.0994722471,
0.3051049411,
0.3753527999,
0.3114901185,
-0.8375664949,
0.2367559373,
0.2274477631,
-0.7904012203,
-1.0112406015,
0.521115005,
-0.9490525126,
-0.3975121677,
1.1169091463,
-0.1053566337,
-0.4968009591,
0.0383346528,
-0.1705383658,
-0.0778800845,
-0.5875997543,
0.9531540275,
0.6101744771,
-0.2338058352,
-0.0386422016,
-0.4253070951,
0.9762406349,
0.5295132399,
-0.9448329806,
0.510640204,
0.3124966323,
0.2948690653,
0.2013114393,
0.3989365399,
-0.1779292524,
0.5521686673,
-0.391140908,
-0.0229533445,
-0.2808003426,
-0.2561325133,
-0.465236932,
0.4951248467,
0.3112328053,
-0.1043772623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09635v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09635v2
|
Evaluating In-Context Learning of Libraries for Code Generation
| 2023-11-16T07:37:25 | 2024-04-04T18:54:01 |
Arkil Patel, Siva Reddy, Dzmitry Bahdanau, Pradeep Dasigi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Contemporary Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit a high degree of code
generation and comprehension capability. A particularly promising area is their
ability to interpret code modules from unfamiliar libraries for solving
user-instructed tasks. Recent work has shown that large proprietary LLMs can
learn novel library usage in-context from demonstrations. These results raise
several open questions: whether demonstrations of library usage is required,
whether smaller (and more open) models also possess such capabilities, etc. In
this work, we take a broader approach by systematically evaluating a diverse
array of LLMs across three scenarios reflecting varying levels of domain
specialization to understand their abilities and limitations in generating code
based on libraries defined in-context. Our results show that even smaller
open-source LLMs like Llama-2 and StarCoder demonstrate an adept understanding
of novel code libraries based on specification presented in-context. Our
findings further reveal that LLMs exhibit a surprisingly high proficiency in
learning novel library modules even when provided with just natural language
descriptions or raw code implementations of the functions, which are often
cheaper to obtain than demonstrations. Overall, our results pave the way for
harnessing LLMs in more adaptable and dynamic coding environments.
|
[
-0.405068934,
-0.5500773191,
0.5132144094,
-0.0327713415,
-0.0396518558,
0.0469994582,
-0.3938343227,
-0.4067671001,
-0.3721423447,
0.3627434671,
-0.3561428785,
-0.5566743612,
-0.2737877667,
0.2296955585,
-0.4529857635,
0.9490725994,
-0.062219549,
-0.0442586802,
-0.5615563989,
-0.0546270236,
-0.5919417739,
-0.4057397246,
-0.1756919175,
-0.469450295,
0.3000834882,
0.4993878603,
0.404514879,
0.2897337675,
0.1507589817,
0.2081181109,
-0.0429737903,
0.1472999752,
-0.561252594,
-0.1114998534,
-0.2302437574,
-0.3992007077,
-0.0217106994,
-0.334138453,
0.6655432582,
0.6383875608,
0.3604399562,
0.4437384307,
0.3016813397,
0.5933278203,
-0.5881412029,
0.0834525749,
-0.8187224865,
0.0698702335,
-0.0210975185,
-0.3984809518,
-0.6372890472,
-0.1955551207,
0.1383362859,
-0.359493345,
-0.0968474075,
-0.1557547003,
0.5650436282,
0.1627685875,
-0.5053843856,
-0.90576756,
-0.7572331429,
0.7573382854,
-0.5894392729,
0.1642044336,
0.0728171542,
0.5057640076,
-0.1056643352,
-0.9437776208,
-0.4133888781,
-0.3406815827,
-0.1831352413,
-0.1760028154,
-0.1231738254,
-0.3589355946,
0.528124392,
0.4857357442,
-0.462352246,
0.2098584473,
-0.4768649042,
0.0183642767,
0.3130873442,
0.1604150236,
0.2388556451,
-0.2660571337,
-0.3452801108,
0.148214668,
-1.0598909855,
0.1582325697,
0.3508026302,
0.1444380134,
-0.2845120728,
0.4766750336,
0.0304707587,
0.7122945786,
-0.1313737631,
-0.1682254672,
0.2815591395,
-0.2130903155,
-0.395902127,
-0.3242104053,
0.3638580441,
0.0857292637,
0.1998801529,
-0.0794843584,
-0.5077435374,
-0.3324970305,
0.315014869,
-0.7923135757,
0.0533633307,
0.2612041533,
-0.6587690115,
-0.1356369704,
0.050901033,
-0.5774267912,
-0.392134577,
-0.4363959432,
0.5404240489,
-0.2813840508,
-0.1331663728,
0.0268663783,
-0.2200265527,
0.3743684888,
0.1317232996,
-0.7201212645,
0.0452141091,
0.6044008136,
0.8256055117,
-0.2684506774,
-0.1916100532,
-0.4475100636,
0.0873727649,
-0.2323581576,
0.5365213752,
-0.3307705522,
-0.3676357865,
0.4268397987,
-0.1141808033,
0.2276688069,
-0.8336477876,
0.2073188275,
-0.6648890972,
-0.2032596171,
-0.0886816904,
-0.5607016683,
0.018189894,
0.116668798,
-0.560541749,
0.7311000824,
0.4147670567,
-0.6670022011,
0.5564092994,
-0.5530999899,
-0.4545388222,
0.2379641533,
-0.4433457553,
-0.2026154995,
0.270749867,
-0.0201009214,
0.6129269004,
-0.0846306309,
0.3716165721,
-0.1090984717,
-0.4991979897,
0.6295837164,
-0.2075934261,
0.6627549529,
0.5757896304,
-0.4009123743,
0.2561766207,
-0.6441252828,
-0.0745819956,
-0.0739129633,
-0.5283634067,
-0.2541282475,
0.0392713062,
0.0455475934,
0.0952984095,
0.2052460313,
-0.234377265,
0.2052313983,
-0.3730081618,
0.5049074292,
0.5824888945,
0.0144688711,
0.5012233853,
-0.3226208389,
0.5997095704,
-0.3305805624,
-0.0302859899,
-0.5371007323,
-0.2710691094,
-0.5805896521,
-0.2811922431,
-0.0651807263,
0.0615614019,
-0.9734566212,
0.2502095401,
-0.1010374427,
-0.3236585259,
0.0620704442,
0.3680400252,
0.5848420858,
0.3096937537,
0.1699889302,
-0.1883111298,
-0.5849626064,
-0.8031559587,
-0.099215284,
-0.0554526076,
-0.1879066378,
0.6563157439,
0.7269781232,
-0.336293757,
1.0116904974,
-0.1275015622,
0.124559857,
-0.5608500838,
-0.1627913862,
0.3248969316,
0.3007379472,
0.5755821466,
-0.6013323665,
-0.4162971377,
0.2061771303,
-0.815040648,
-0.1324635148,
-0.269413203,
0.0919330195,
0.3081268668,
0.544436574,
-0.1526050866,
0.2181225717,
0.6748328805,
-0.0929093808,
0.6630018353,
-0.3151137233,
-0.2241457999,
-0.8844207525,
0.2137312144,
-0.2340049595,
0.0160203073,
-0.580981791,
0.4656248987,
0.2732100487,
-0.1683474034,
-0.6408664584,
0.7360494137,
-0.5333215594,
-0.5653282404,
-0.3837732971,
0.024751056,
-0.2863589823,
0.2204862088,
0.0742191076,
0.8211704493,
0.6559427381,
-0.7647945881,
-0.0511362664,
0.0398160741,
-0.9169522524,
0.0354420766,
-0.4280313253,
0.1009118184,
0.1833014935,
0.1930316538,
-0.7462559938,
-0.5322399139,
-0.192209959,
-0.1755068749,
0.1708542705,
-0.2426655442,
-0.5893421173,
-0.3841149807,
-0.0406002477,
0.376078248,
0.7582338452,
-0.9898591638,
0.2802494764,
0.2587729096,
0.2346317917,
-0.6020766497,
-0.6721292734,
-0.090960905,
-0.3500676453,
-0.4232910275,
0.1581817567,
-0.1926825792,
-0.409085393,
-0.2391341329,
-0.118997559,
0.0701207146,
0.3483082652,
0.3412813842,
-0.01684325,
-0.2938223183,
0.2162812203,
0.1078126132,
0.1928814054,
0.0725762844,
-0.4402818084,
0.511365056,
-0.3908235431,
-0.4979697168,
0.0667088479,
0.0466226824,
0.3709833026,
-0.1174241751,
0.4837685227,
0.4249010086,
-0.3399648964,
-0.77323699,
-0.2300224453,
0.1324521899,
-0.54304564,
0.3932732046,
-0.4458776712,
-1.1857357025,
0.4826681912,
-0.2726447582,
0.1272969395,
-0.0011669701,
1.0157140493,
0.2247780412,
0.3996807933,
0.6720772982,
0.3809164464,
0.3999595046,
-0.2761469483,
0.1812963784,
-0.5799059868,
-0.3746860623,
-0.3797997832,
-0.194725126,
-0.323700577,
-0.5780637264,
0.4033213258,
0.3102187216,
-0.1114440486,
0.4198934138,
-0.3671882451,
0.8347246051,
0.2102926224,
-0.162635833,
0.2965939343,
0.1749975234,
-0.2168144137,
0.3760086894,
-0.6987919211,
-0.8899821639,
1.2458052635,
0.5542324781,
0.7245003581,
0.262951076,
0.7119705081,
0.2724194229,
0.645563066,
-0.7954951525,
0.397337079,
-0.0653267652,
-0.4787892997,
-0.0823616013,
-0.2837136984,
-0.8207947016,
0.0673187673,
-0.0854121223,
-0.6316082478,
0.0935189128,
0.1040238664,
-0.3134679794,
0.1879429668,
-0.6754782796,
0.8605728745,
-0.3046889007,
-0.3530292511,
-0.1462695748,
-0.3135814071,
0.639510572,
-0.3743545413,
0.4354720414,
0.1634468734,
-0.1455883533,
0.2819209397,
0.0049606115,
0.9261200428,
-0.0998962745,
-0.4676654637,
0.5569564104,
0.2970548272,
0.0320089608,
0.3532756269,
-0.2222023755,
-0.0190994199,
-0.139081344,
-0.2205965817,
-0.5032532811,
0.8417506218,
-0.7085208297,
-0.420491159,
0.068883948,
-0.7097314,
-0.2284369171,
0.0244756881,
0.1568529755,
0.8162035942,
-0.3573729098,
0.3104144931,
0.6556125283,
-0.7236051559,
0.4760477543,
0.455608964,
-0.3864233494,
-0.1388028711,
0.7917274237,
-0.2239453942,
0.4606823623,
0.359916985,
0.154919669,
-0.0722792223,
-0.7413026094,
-0.5117223859,
-0.0395298563,
-1.151807785,
-0.1825736314,
-0.4240906537,
-0.037763264,
-0.1339054853,
-0.4869119525,
0.1095371172,
-0.2771174312,
-0.2935625017,
-0.0862190202,
0.0149556827,
1.1878913641,
0.1357108653,
0.212508738,
-0.7569524646,
-0.1000977829,
0.2637778223,
0.1795132309,
0.2652454674,
-0.5944367647,
-0.704014957,
-0.4371504784,
-0.3966086209,
-0.6529548168,
0.3463169932,
0.1531125605,
0.7877368331,
0.3953980505,
-0.0127054723,
0.4094269574,
-0.5469569564,
1.036793828,
-0.0754241645,
-1.0569307804,
0.5092791915,
-0.3055886626,
0.325774163,
0.2077925205,
0.519385457,
-0.075572595,
-0.4024342895,
-0.3795045018,
-0.6667671204,
0.5010282397,
-0.0079378886,
0.5047653913,
-0.1317991763,
0.5800181031,
0.4865526259,
0.1513136327,
-0.9853784442,
-0.0763444006,
-0.0570278391,
-0.0138462102,
-0.056780085,
-0.2248733491,
-0.1000332162,
-0.0663595349,
0.247646004,
-0.4352212548,
0.3326569796,
-0.0541119277,
-0.4055490792,
0.0463356525,
0.471203953,
0.7464830875,
1.0566346645,
-0.0306797549,
0.3085847199,
0.1916891485,
0.1213933304,
-0.0537490696,
-0.4701803327,
-0.0819097832,
-0.1790397167,
0.6317485571,
0.7170470953,
0.3655412197,
-1.2382116318,
0.5348951221,
0.1861677617,
-0.2806171477,
-0.3781681061,
0.226938352,
0.1700099111,
0.3236795962,
0.3316034675,
0.0341325477,
0.1272723079,
-0.7808559537,
0.3923220634,
0.4353327751,
-0.1963376999,
-0.2750537097,
0.3321519196,
0.1377864629,
-0.2563515306,
0.2723131478,
-0.3361624777,
-0.2822536826,
0.7124885321,
0.8911629319,
0.8692212701,
0.3078014255,
0.0323141553,
0.4692655206,
0.1676507145,
0.1395875067,
-0.0571877882,
-0.4029357731,
-0.6721255779,
-0.4847405851,
-0.7600203753,
-0.4104360938,
0.1533447057,
-0.5721852183,
0.3352177441,
-0.4267060459,
0.087229386,
-0.3889860809,
-0.2220754027,
-0.4934717715,
-0.2981642783,
0.3873418272,
1.1466065645,
-0.8189831972,
1.1160863638,
0.6905563474,
-0.3444479406,
-0.676009357,
0.157803759,
-0.1185803711,
-0.6561857462,
1.073084712,
0.3658456802,
-0.048523467,
-0.2084370255,
-0.5781197548,
-0.6315789819,
1.2020757198,
0.2721090913,
-0.3424177766,
0.0605841614,
-0.0236516893,
0.6839637756,
-0.8367257714,
0.3803524375,
0.4746286571,
0.1090084016,
-0.0084668947,
-0.8787231445,
-0.0516022518,
-0.1321928352,
0.122631155,
-0.2048933655,
-0.3173074126,
0.8306156397,
-0.2626061738,
-0.2844062746,
0.4231375158,
0.6029003263,
0.4237841368,
0.4100800753,
0.3566325903,
-0.0954819918,
0.5718817711,
0.2819154561,
1.1571128368,
-0.2534999549,
0.1706284583,
0.9094485641,
-0.4221869707,
0.9913485646,
0.4891642034,
0.0732370764,
0.7898054719,
0.4503338039,
0.1138001457,
0.390935421,
0.514621973,
-0.2686963379,
-0.1533975303,
0.1174762771,
-0.1892325282,
0.1790160239,
0.4804360569,
-0.3339078426,
-0.1556258947,
0.3613958359,
-0.4448536336,
0.3659354746,
-0.3793792725,
0.6497678161,
0.2064941227,
-0.6917170882,
0.7764018774,
-0.0208862275,
0.7335187793,
-0.4911208153,
-0.0342759527,
-0.1416482031,
0.2776862383,
-0.3440358341,
-0.8195975423,
0.4673415124,
0.4318155646,
-0.0654629245,
-0.4030289054,
0.6279706955,
-0.1152277216,
-0.0384082869,
0.3920788467,
0.5365117788,
0.3918960989,
0.4341987967,
-0.3356770575,
0.2259609997,
0.1127175614,
-0.2239891142,
0.77435112,
0.491266638,
-0.0248622466,
0.655790031,
0.4757680893,
-0.1786091328,
0.1128162071,
0.0840138122,
0.8904625177,
-0.2408926785,
-0.2238441259,
-0.6062805653,
0.4770383537,
0.2025719732,
-0.2451515496,
0.8662737608,
0.6417524815,
1.3334150314,
-0.5049359202,
0.7792099714,
-0.2112202346,
0.2078197598,
-0.7927848697,
0.4909888506,
-0.6980749965,
0.6659821272,
-0.0632719621,
-0.811283052,
-0.2091260254,
0.4797895849,
-0.2986066639,
-0.1197693869,
0.6513496041,
0.8848168254,
-0.1298826337,
-0.1208467931,
0.4977720678,
-0.0580117851,
0.2836968005,
0.6679712534,
1.2091419697,
-0.0716460347,
0.5768637061,
-0.0583622642,
-0.3005118668,
-0.0842538476,
-1.0185295343,
-1.2255131006,
-0.5173982382,
-0.0330150127,
-0.3026958406,
-0.2430330366,
1.0325587988,
0.5481328964,
-0.6855286956,
-0.7691754103,
-0.0271673054,
0.0669141784,
-0.1625733823,
-0.2074478269,
0.1464194357,
-0.7066403627,
-0.7118038535,
0.6848224401,
0.1240512058,
-0.1959996074,
-0.535286963,
-0.5199465752,
0.2902119756,
0.0633876696,
0.8822340369,
0.287620157,
-0.8208108544,
-0.1828511655,
0.0137293851,
-0.1578897983,
-0.1240119934,
1.1667739153,
-0.9234198332,
0.3459574878,
0.5261068344,
0.8255871534,
0.3890840113,
-0.291511327,
0.429395318,
-0.9344531894,
0.0564871244,
0.0033068948,
0.3773400486,
0.2133086622,
-0.1299936324,
0.2554990053,
-0.0305734184,
-0.6521789432,
-0.8913804293,
0.514347136,
-0.777105391,
-0.6207364202,
1.3499426842,
-0.2507932484,
-0.0401025787,
-0.1637361646,
-0.089295499,
-0.0689630359,
-0.0120853111,
0.4252451062,
0.3643747866,
-0.1501592696,
-0.0269988552,
-0.8184916377,
0.5083890557,
0.0535557121,
-0.6974705458,
0.1981512904,
0.5162930489,
0.3818819523,
0.0517383963,
0.5691950917,
-0.159077391,
0.2690995634,
-0.1439754218,
0.012249562,
-0.2609928846,
-0.4121680558,
-0.7320133448,
0.2483957261,
0.4622145295,
0.453294158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.00029v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.00029v2
|
Bergeron: Combating Adversarial Attacks through a Conscience-Based Alignment Framework
| 2023-11-16T07:31:18 | 2024-03-15T20:13:06 |
Matthew Pisano, Peter Ly, Abraham Sanders, Bingsheng Yao, Dakuo Wang, Tomek Strzalkowski, Mei Si
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Research into AI alignment has grown considerably since the recent
introduction of increasingly capable Large Language Models (LLMs).
Unfortunately, modern methods of alignment still fail to fully prevent harmful
responses when models are deliberately attacked. These attacks can trick
seemingly aligned models into giving manufacturing instructions for dangerous
materials, inciting violence, or recommending other immoral acts. To help
mitigate this issue, we introduce Bergeron: a framework designed to improve the
robustness of LLMs against attacks without any additional parameter
fine-tuning. Bergeron is organized into two tiers; with a secondary LLM
emulating the conscience of a protected, primary LLM. This framework better
safeguards the primary model against incoming attacks while monitoring its
output for any harmful content. Empirical analysis shows that, by using
Bergeron to complement models with existing alignment training, we can improve
the robustness and safety of multiple, commonly used commercial and open-source
LLMs.
|
[
-0.2656603158,
-0.5621832013,
0.3817847669,
-0.1188139319,
-0.2242209017,
-0.0297681019,
-0.1775172204,
-0.295747906,
-0.1169490442,
0.9821690917,
-0.6088457108,
-0.4509673417,
-0.9397039413,
0.0872193128,
-0.4788348079,
1.1642187834,
0.1617911309,
0.3997431397,
0.2205836177,
-0.3629728854,
-0.4977510273,
-0.59509027,
-1.0444600582,
-0.1578451991,
0.7583783269,
-0.2730882168,
0.9179906249,
0.8158462048,
0.6733180881,
0.3616138101,
-0.0863893628,
0.0588093773,
-0.665887773,
0.3087836802,
-0.2906740904,
-0.6321018338,
-0.5554991961,
0.1254748851,
0.4263027906,
0.2560555339,
-0.1006867141,
-0.1110592708,
0.176002726,
0.8086931705,
-0.8675382137,
-0.1453838795,
-0.7443206906,
0.0680586398,
-0.2468477041,
0.0906120017,
-0.7840002775,
-0.4503982663,
-0.0752608404,
-0.7111272812,
-0.1827491522,
-0.1361736804,
0.7161266804,
0.7063508034,
-0.5857155919,
-0.3463628888,
-0.4767170846,
0.8788943291,
-0.6778030992,
0.3424790502,
0.0821803287,
0.2561331689,
-0.4276727736,
-0.5785705447,
-0.6149140596,
-0.0508965738,
-0.0323615968,
0.254240483,
-0.2987481654,
0.2737725973,
0.1919180006,
-0.1301984042,
-0.6610367894,
0.2283419371,
-0.0979378298,
-0.2901457548,
0.5512043834,
0.2924808264,
0.5252760053,
0.0591939166,
-0.5319005251,
-0.25159356,
-0.8596116304,
0.0344514251,
0.8504286408,
0.3298075497,
0.0562973842,
0.6601164341,
0.2551574409,
1.0420563221,
0.4176339507,
-0.0060327058,
-0.5223927498,
-0.2438659966,
-0.3915718496,
0.4036052525,
0.8086657524,
0.4218295813,
0.2307335585,
-0.0558568425,
-0.106570743,
0.4834929705,
0.9718049765,
-0.8634159565,
-0.2903155684,
0.2250796854,
-0.31408149,
-0.6833325028,
0.1435081214,
-0.5831609368,
-0.9874645472,
-0.4241393209,
-0.0388692021,
-0.3777537346,
0.0628239363,
0.0378543139,
0.1539328098,
0.4353389144,
0.3480581045,
-0.9033666849,
0.2491516471,
1.3055535555,
0.6817908883,
-0.1006683558,
0.0035039354,
-0.8314133286,
0.4116381109,
-0.6162807345,
0.4492301345,
-0.5015117526,
-0.3653721511,
0.0078129703,
0.0563105531,
0.1113233641,
-0.2543824315,
0.7915403247,
-0.7528060079,
0.0989798009,
-0.274818182,
-0.6152762771,
-0.3817593455,
0.447368741,
-0.6706808805,
0.3583653271,
-0.1669003069,
-0.9139680266,
0.2479452193,
-0.1126011908,
-0.3994083703,
-0.177254051,
-0.427824676,
-0.4468122423,
0.1443534046,
0.2288677841,
0.4203196764,
-0.2537780702,
0.2187849879,
-0.5761120319,
-0.2417342365,
0.373201102,
-0.48729375,
1.3484846354,
0.1023575887,
-0.1897792965,
0.4171659052,
-0.524181664,
-0.0854626074,
0.0538228378,
-0.2095652074,
-0.205309689,
0.1383544952,
-0.4033242464,
0.1810022891,
0.2802762687,
-0.4317188859,
0.1551632732,
-0.5225177407,
0.2118479311,
1.2384146452,
-0.1210689992,
0.6369435191,
-0.5039778352,
0.5359112024,
-0.2462482899,
0.3287377357,
0.493912518,
-0.2702082992,
-0.7382125258,
-0.5031161308,
-0.0642318055,
0.781719923,
-0.5527464747,
0.6394918561,
-0.1696662009,
-0.4233915508,
-0.6041549444,
0.2228797972,
0.5795052648,
0.5997710228,
0.1204633042,
-0.4294033945,
-0.5672793984,
-0.9563245177,
-0.5530354381,
-0.3077609837,
0.1638709456,
0.0245260056,
0.025104234,
-0.2710586488,
0.5787632465,
-0.4090415835,
-0.1513453722,
0.0537267923,
-0.0644500554,
0.0558605641,
0.6284301877,
0.6816971898,
-0.9320556521,
-0.58434093,
0.0609410033,
-0.9612302184,
0.1714670658,
-0.0234957431,
-0.5189694166,
0.1492294073,
0.3870815337,
-0.4896302521,
0.3012042642,
0.477776587,
-0.0718676224,
0.3899552822,
0.2755863369,
0.1452394426,
-1.1824193001,
-0.107913442,
-0.0689420775,
-0.2269827724,
-0.9486054182,
0.1411527395,
0.0529962257,
-0.2909696102,
-0.5428059697,
0.4576713443,
0.0200248957,
0.2753253579,
-0.4887223542,
0.1626350433,
0.0908691958,
0.2833122909,
-0.2570104599,
0.7282279134,
0.6425409913,
-0.3702488542,
0.5184357166,
0.5110519528,
-0.0353612527,
1.2307860851,
-0.5665357113,
0.3262587488,
-0.1527361125,
0.3909991682,
-0.5500904918,
-0.3303373456,
0.5692139268,
-0.4606865942,
0.9197348952,
-0.5517858863,
-0.218939364,
-0.0308378544,
-0.3271462023,
0.4045101702,
0.3789854944,
-0.632197082,
0.8496726155,
0.4363951981,
-0.2477821857,
-1.1149413586,
-0.5605336428,
0.3530034125,
-0.4656922817,
-0.7832108736,
-0.1037796959,
-0.1975795627,
-0.4339004755,
-0.2227968425,
-0.1536329091,
0.0631537661,
0.4689792395,
0.3011663854,
0.3403805196,
0.1105156094,
-0.3889381886,
-0.3136270046,
-0.4163882732,
0.1268520802,
-0.7751134634,
0.3222202957,
-0.1153102219,
-0.3275951743,
-0.7735126615,
0.4351860881,
0.5775956511,
-0.3130393326,
0.9305114746,
0.5824719071,
-0.4897526503,
-0.0640504211,
-0.3948426545,
-0.1898966283,
-0.5440081358,
0.4688319862,
0.0189450681,
-0.8233190179,
0.3274580836,
0.2357560247,
0.2026987225,
0.0465226062,
0.5856734514,
-0.0413092114,
1.5624493361,
0.60983181,
-0.3392636478,
0.4917701483,
0.1580562741,
0.5355202556,
-0.9673854709,
0.0418770351,
-0.4109762013,
-0.0475833714,
-0.7196377516,
0.0371675715,
0.320661515,
0.252636373,
-0.573610127,
0.5254942179,
-0.7419119477,
0.3612835109,
0.3722710907,
-0.0232054554,
-0.159767434,
-0.2882247567,
0.2341018617,
0.0556087531,
-0.4389613867,
-0.8606961966,
1.1751731634,
0.2499074489,
0.8968448043,
0.5500184298,
0.7194932699,
0.270034194,
0.6652396321,
-0.7474126816,
0.625674665,
-0.4501549304,
-0.6958361268,
-0.00252825,
-0.4013883173,
-0.7306494713,
0.3165639043,
-0.0540084094,
-0.9953257442,
0.009148838,
0.2966090143,
-0.3419352472,
0.3715589345,
-0.2826732099,
0.8574742079,
-0.547718823,
-0.4566946924,
-0.0666563064,
-0.6759003401,
0.4758863449,
-0.2418590635,
-0.005274619,
-0.0218330007,
0.0978012457,
0.6600580215,
-0.401337713,
0.9733366966,
-0.0104806386,
-0.3468644321,
0.1642974317,
0.3567046523,
0.9062870741,
0.078859657,
-0.0771281347,
-0.0299232304,
-0.2280345708,
-0.5258775949,
-0.8045414686,
0.8259330988,
-0.7302542329,
-0.9699281454,
-0.4239318967,
-0.5624896288,
-0.114648059,
0.2938197851,
0.2930696011,
0.459274292,
-0.2401086539,
0.1324443966,
0.8277130723,
-0.002814458,
0.0148905525,
0.4100005329,
0.2785234153,
-0.7872779369,
0.9511743784,
-0.2114704102,
0.4251738489,
0.1735183299,
-0.0864789635,
-0.1648383588,
-0.5676389933,
-0.4601148665,
-0.1766180992,
-0.8798910975,
-0.3831443191,
-0.5625709295,
0.014761705,
-0.6764797568,
-0.768832624,
-0.5249397755,
-0.1502147615,
-0.2084433585,
-0.1807770878,
-0.1521950066,
0.8094066978,
0.073669605,
0.3680442274,
-0.6059328914,
-0.0144447563,
0.3651830256,
0.0071513467,
-0.1113176644,
-0.3048826158,
-0.1151375175,
0.2239120901,
-0.4776786566,
-0.8945742249,
0.1885924488,
-0.2186913043,
0.3586371839,
0.7362128496,
0.134671703,
0.3198339641,
-0.5261769891,
0.7432995439,
0.5913199782,
-0.980266571,
0.4359554052,
-0.4673237205,
-0.1781741679,
0.5683983564,
0.1596228927,
-0.3561973274,
-0.5902327895,
-0.4242870808,
-0.6123816967,
0.6289561391,
0.2333535403,
-0.087861523,
-0.0312640183,
0.4318240285,
-0.10221342,
0.326256901,
-0.8446347117,
-0.0800315887,
-0.3830420375,
-0.8180781603,
0.0425353497,
-0.0550134182,
-1.0566567183,
0.2749402821,
1.0422182083,
-0.3431040049,
0.0091919322,
-0.0110417251,
-0.1995807588,
-0.0806211159,
0.0950361118,
0.6879903078,
0.2271338552,
0.0884562582,
0.2818599045,
0.013118295,
-0.3629933298,
0.4333364666,
0.2099619955,
-0.2590941191,
-0.8027579784,
0.5219128728,
0.593372941,
-0.0288708266,
-0.3738490343,
0.6712595224,
-0.2869603634,
0.1506257206,
-0.3215067387,
0.3826974034,
-0.1775274277,
0.4995695651,
-0.2076981515,
0.3398486674,
-0.1219347119,
-0.2444979101,
0.2491464615,
0.8240018487,
-0.8757260442,
-0.2640079558,
0.7923938036,
0.11634247,
-0.3507437706,
0.3517576754,
-0.0349030904,
-0.8557171822,
0.6603892446,
0.4034597278,
1.0512607098,
-0.1434869766,
-0.042604614,
0.0664235726,
0.626101613,
0.0080950502,
-0.0319928266,
0.2302282155,
-0.9271877408,
-0.0864775851,
-0.5215919018,
-0.1891029328,
-0.1109888181,
-0.8615560532,
-0.024629835,
-0.9070720673,
-0.3168040514,
-0.0875003263,
0.0877064094,
-0.4077190459,
0.1287313253,
0.3022280335,
0.4890632927,
-0.5153440237,
0.5618968606,
0.6963360906,
-0.2883105278,
-0.6924561858,
0.0764356703,
0.7007608414,
-0.735349834,
0.3862531483,
0.299518466,
-0.3559893668,
-0.1695029587,
-0.7207295299,
-0.7049963474,
0.9733483791,
0.5401025414,
-0.5170980096,
0.3228716552,
-0.0586385168,
0.3945744634,
-0.3225718439,
-0.4036848843,
0.4377823174,
0.7052575946,
-0.2921279967,
-0.3149197698,
0.2330078632,
-0.0161445606,
-0.0924482569,
0.5846632719,
-0.8535467982,
0.6898984313,
0.0560964346,
-0.3679714203,
0.3419595957,
0.6337373853,
0.109592393,
-0.0620053746,
0.4359953403,
0.8926125169,
0.9376408458,
-0.1535092592,
1.1013588905,
-0.559512496,
0.1239760518,
1.1816228628,
-0.7165524364,
0.330041796,
0.3236387372,
0.2223906368,
0.2557871044,
0.424829334,
-0.2121887505,
0.5905496478,
0.145990625,
-0.4392552078,
-0.2606945634,
-0.1594472975,
-0.029708622,
0.3471489847,
0.2418766916,
-0.0849113464,
0.1262513995,
-0.1079197377,
0.3508606255,
0.3290114999,
-0.1995097846,
0.8777396679,
0.1633983403,
-0.7768567204,
0.3372630775,
-0.0348151699,
0.358366251,
-0.6519227028,
0.3087684214,
0.1664257944,
0.5303695202,
-0.0560301654,
-0.5625328422,
0.1467413604,
-0.0647055432,
-0.1580334157,
-0.0258787759,
0.7017732859,
-0.3743504286,
-0.4157184064,
0.5864776373,
-0.0861647651,
-0.4550504982,
0.2674097121,
-0.8718057871,
0.2153163254,
-0.0325823389,
-0.0199861396,
0.3193398118,
0.1733503342,
0.0752375796,
0.6113174558,
0.6982871294,
0.0592795759,
-0.0236040037,
-0.0135352388,
0.7923955321,
-0.1521321684,
-0.4274694026,
-0.9423417449,
0.3845307827,
-0.3286685944,
-0.0406808928,
0.7075490355,
0.2567817271,
0.8556275964,
0.3205775619,
0.836730361,
0.2063289136,
0.0058080046,
-0.6523407698,
0.8368268013,
-0.4095662534,
0.2143324018,
-0.1246740371,
-0.6753562093,
-0.4806959927,
0.6903077364,
-0.1821243167,
-0.0306071211,
0.3592295647,
1.0252703428,
0.0394692309,
0.2676033676,
0.25249663,
0.3825756609,
0.8230465651,
0.4889479876,
0.9146084189,
-0.2305017561,
0.3782371581,
-0.1300309896,
-0.3484757543,
0.0203664936,
-0.9064668417,
-1.1548056602,
-0.3120313585,
-0.168179214,
-0.6569401622,
0.4245911241,
0.7884377241,
0.779270947,
-0.9325661063,
-0.0140616857,
-0.2050557137,
-0.0077914055,
-0.105861485,
-0.1511722505,
0.2806856632,
-0.2500001192,
-0.58681494,
0.5651015639,
0.4593490958,
0.0964866802,
-0.3013364971,
-0.2881117761,
-0.1005589962,
0.4556134045,
0.1532160342,
0.1908012033,
-0.7998728752,
-0.6912924647,
-0.3441029489,
-0.4145227075,
-0.1787275672,
1.0112166405,
-0.1453074217,
0.5003887415,
0.2975839376,
0.938010335,
-0.2551653981,
0.1333827674,
1.0300086737,
-0.6447644234,
0.2544839382,
0.5154976249,
0.6115197539,
0.5219567418,
-0.7472967505,
0.4112658501,
-0.0268165357,
-0.5607426167,
-0.8196060658,
0.8255671859,
-0.8952649832,
-0.3042137027,
0.7745952606,
-0.3866758347,
-0.3028356433,
0.0071132514,
-0.2282716185,
0.4682681262,
-0.1916312575,
0.6867012382,
0.7811464071,
0.1370129436,
0.4181289971,
-0.3722186089,
0.7262341976,
0.5905532241,
-0.587982893,
0.1995384842,
0.409281075,
0.1204515472,
0.1718678474,
0.1421042234,
-0.133065477,
0.2012239248,
-0.2171513289,
-0.1578096747,
-0.0522270054,
-0.4206428826,
-0.5322372913,
0.1120223626,
-0.2042485327,
0.0290589817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09632v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09632v1
|
Online Continual Knowledge Learning for Language Models
| 2023-11-16T07:31:03 | 2023-11-16T07:31:03 |
Yuhao Wu, Tongjun Shi, Karthick Sharma, Chun Wei Seah, Shuhao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) serve as repositories of extensive world
knowledge, enabling them to perform tasks such as question-answering and
fact-checking. However, this knowledge can become obsolete as global contexts
change. In this paper, we introduce a novel problem in the realm of continual
learning: Online Continual Knowledge Learning (OCKL). This problem formulation
aims to manage the dynamic nature of world knowledge in LMs under real-time
constraints. We propose a new benchmark and evaluation metric designed to
measure both the rate of new knowledge acquisition and the retention of
previously learned knowledge. Our empirical evaluation, conducted using a
variety of state-of-the-art methods, establishes robust base-lines for OCKL.
Our results reveal that existing continual learning approaches are
unfortunately insufficient for tackling the unique challenges posed by OCKL. We
identify key factors that influence the trade-off between knowledge acquisition
and retention, thereby advancing our understanding of how to train LMs in a
continually evolving environment.
|
[
-0.2567599714,
-0.9278849363,
0.7622206807,
-0.1560288966,
-0.1662122905,
0.4745074213,
-0.3191149831,
-0.6526950598,
-0.3858299255,
0.3589298427,
-0.4944365025,
-0.2000109851,
-0.3441312909,
-0.1170033664,
-0.0977357253,
0.820127964,
-0.3492885232,
-0.0660178512,
-0.5486447811,
-0.3271613717,
-0.472689867,
-0.3945125043,
-0.7064979076,
-0.4719057679,
0.5810092688,
0.3466893733,
0.2499023527,
0.4038210511,
0.2620656788,
0.1743078083,
-0.1996298432,
0.4506673217,
-0.7727720141,
0.3860033453,
-0.0986706167,
-0.2588571608,
-0.1485642195,
-0.2080651969,
0.9579383731,
0.9940495491,
-0.4547687471,
0.2592475712,
0.1421738714,
0.4616933465,
-0.7886725664,
0.0916364491,
-0.7516342998,
0.1535561532,
0.1760808229,
0.004029274,
-0.283290267,
-0.6689664125,
0.3876727819,
-0.6025121212,
-0.3726092577,
0.0248610843,
0.8393769264,
0.1158816144,
-0.268461287,
-0.3734980524,
-0.7911168933,
0.8542179465,
-0.6010786295,
0.7880238891,
0.2878306806,
0.4443074465,
-0.1038416028,
-0.6422923803,
-0.4455467463,
-0.4976278245,
0.2690524459,
0.0331534185,
0.1982685626,
-0.4263592064,
0.0728689432,
0.1827750355,
-0.3193256557,
0.1154646724,
-0.2458887398,
-0.0822845921,
0.4306096137,
0.2382491976,
0.0749707669,
0.3562052846,
-0.442527473,
0.4451930225,
-0.9464630485,
-0.0616925433,
0.0527537167,
-0.0675777867,
-0.0982021913,
-0.0024320253,
-0.0803395063,
0.6549799442,
-0.1002849489,
-0.5156109929,
0.1666694432,
0.0525963083,
0.2060298622,
-0.1478796005,
0.3410574794,
0.0350163206,
0.1738169193,
-0.4769445062,
-0.2652591169,
-0.3080769777,
0.2742072642,
-0.3452543616,
0.2326138914,
0.0966458246,
-0.1783683747,
-0.0770469159,
0.0108220913,
-0.5270736217,
-0.2896625996,
-0.3775323927,
0.4733991921,
-0.3608384728,
-0.3450512886,
-0.1418268085,
0.0801322311,
0.1952393204,
0.3922604918,
-0.450830698,
0.2883031368,
0.6263527274,
1.0840756893,
-0.3864908516,
-0.2477544695,
-0.6176351905,
0.265963763,
-0.3490527272,
0.5079214573,
-0.2644198537,
-0.22299169,
0.2637076378,
-0.1547683924,
0.1021221504,
-0.6999344826,
0.011808726,
-0.8059056997,
0.0874081254,
-0.2681847811,
-0.8933272958,
0.0938268602,
0.5453503728,
-0.4482577741,
1.137992382,
0.2316275388,
-0.4261605144,
0.4354689121,
-0.342148453,
0.0078185899,
0.351480335,
-0.0251388904,
-0.4001758993,
0.0205187462,
-0.3868262172,
0.4121715724,
-0.2733952403,
0.5594679117,
-0.5637866259,
-0.2668356001,
0.3275080323,
-0.144333005,
0.5843025446,
0.4311258197,
-0.3284724951,
-0.2840509415,
-0.9180978537,
0.036258705,
0.2335580587,
-0.6572669148,
-0.4265298247,
0.4360147119,
-0.2296454906,
0.2638159692,
0.3909568787,
-0.7367303967,
0.3151869178,
-0.2330446392,
0.4702683091,
0.7415989041,
0.2653928697,
0.121985063,
-0.4775770009,
0.2842229605,
-0.2140177637,
0.4108939171,
0.0317880251,
-0.2805080414,
-1.0670506954,
0.0807063654,
-0.0561269484,
0.4093049467,
-0.7111734152,
0.417737633,
-0.5357288122,
-0.6687850952,
-0.1913260669,
0.5013894439,
0.3643089831,
0.2281485349,
0.4343764782,
-0.3175419271,
-0.3511289954,
-0.3028695583,
-0.2263964862,
-0.1125412136,
-0.0731786266,
0.2902580798,
0.5010300279,
-0.3394588232,
1.2050355673,
-0.33088696,
-0.2153710574,
-0.3697812855,
0.1882466525,
-0.129445672,
0.2750229239,
0.0553156659,
-0.4869922101,
-0.6381815672,
0.15919815,
-0.9513739347,
-0.1319007725,
-0.2805516422,
0.2268402129,
0.3479267955,
0.6611660719,
-0.3280585706,
-0.1395788491,
0.4672624171,
-0.1441680193,
0.5736457705,
-0.3453280032,
-0.1761241108,
-0.5142157674,
0.1324286312,
-0.2314661741,
-0.4491398036,
-0.5195509791,
0.3765739501,
0.3164168596,
0.0563093051,
-0.6880992651,
1.036149025,
-0.6705930233,
0.089414075,
0.0812604278,
0.532453239,
-0.1825213581,
0.4023784995,
-0.004311421,
0.1411385834,
0.2563475072,
-0.870488286,
0.5240784287,
-0.0759055763,
-0.7677431107,
0.5716511011,
-0.3435294032,
0.1724702418,
-0.0206481721,
0.2196949124,
-0.5775111914,
0.0800770819,
0.0860940292,
-0.1918366253,
0.4073191285,
0.1309276074,
-0.3757204115,
-0.2516670525,
0.0712172613,
0.1749301106,
0.6469361186,
-0.5741914511,
0.4952380955,
0.2836867869,
-0.1191358194,
-0.420820713,
-0.5026230812,
-0.0727848634,
-0.1027132794,
-0.1752654761,
0.1129194871,
-0.0809597448,
-0.5811983347,
0.2130531818,
-0.189645797,
-0.2080692053,
0.3114844859,
0.0280726273,
0.1454349309,
-0.1221894175,
0.4104363918,
-0.3167239428,
-0.0370036513,
0.0703142285,
-0.7054499388,
0.4826878309,
0.0711912587,
-0.4299212098,
-0.1207329929,
0.0575970151,
0.4676741958,
-0.0450484715,
1.1636594534,
0.436414361,
-0.3732739687,
-0.3913089037,
-1.0744012594,
0.0367123634,
-0.4528445899,
0.4453620315,
-0.2029231042,
-1.0199368,
0.5522264242,
-0.174700737,
0.3892253041,
0.3898410499,
0.5191936493,
-0.2442061007,
0.5255919695,
0.7206018567,
0.0161514189,
0.3969795406,
-0.1918002367,
0.1675214618,
-0.6666661501,
-0.5381711125,
-0.1098569855,
0.1115891635,
-0.0424488895,
-0.3058206737,
0.3333652914,
0.3712877333,
-0.353416115,
0.0913737863,
0.1603015661,
0.4339155555,
0.1124045327,
0.0573011376,
0.5246976614,
-0.1199462563,
-0.3315775096,
0.0765076205,
-0.7468893528,
-0.2399519235,
1.0049359798,
0.4736998677,
0.7227806449,
0.1817349195,
0.5561085939,
0.3542956114,
0.5066628456,
-0.5614262223,
0.4910895228,
0.4215946496,
-0.467754066,
-0.3869615495,
-0.895778358,
-0.8936530948,
0.0286209546,
-0.0996886343,
-0.742875576,
-0.3285876215,
0.33321473,
-0.2439048737,
0.6327511072,
-0.2453593314,
0.7822170854,
-0.6738846898,
-0.6515801549,
-0.4496683776,
-0.449167937,
0.1335934699,
-0.4501025975,
0.5634309053,
-0.1161480471,
-0.3069938123,
0.5385943055,
-0.3426426649,
0.8065304756,
-0.1424437165,
-0.3138824999,
0.3728453517,
0.0282023959,
0.6036128402,
-0.1834656745,
0.172110036,
0.2639895678,
0.0446249507,
-0.3998731971,
-0.3383383453,
0.7733878493,
-0.7499778271,
-0.3593021035,
-0.450258404,
-0.2252467871,
-0.6478955746,
-0.0719831958,
0.0704867542,
0.4297154844,
-0.3601869047,
0.2968129516,
0.7348726988,
-0.524749279,
0.2729466856,
0.8234155178,
-0.3284809887,
-0.2603837848,
1.1894314289,
0.515737772,
0.9978380203,
0.5065367222,
0.3495125175,
-0.4169445336,
-0.3884849548,
-0.1542764753,
0.364934504,
-1.0334938765,
0.0963941067,
-0.6524829268,
-0.3416315019,
-0.1729438752,
-0.2415224463,
-0.2525866926,
-0.1557271332,
-0.1505603939,
0.1459988505,
0.1731059998,
0.9561815262,
0.0685176775,
-0.0097383307,
-1.0464850664,
-0.0238305181,
0.508923173,
0.6268165112,
0.4373443127,
-0.8053489327,
-0.6235199571,
-0.1453008503,
-0.3626132011,
-0.638446331,
0.3343441188,
0.5033471584,
1.0110291243,
0.315386802,
0.0747266784,
0.5234616399,
-0.5114101171,
0.7831818461,
0.2378603667,
-0.7564368844,
0.2842808068,
-0.2923182249,
0.7047660947,
0.2754787803,
0.9037564397,
-1.0762584209,
-0.697067976,
-0.5792384744,
-0.8917040825,
0.3155606389,
-0.2336369604,
-0.0869327411,
0.0517827347,
0.3504657447,
0.2840432525,
0.3198969066,
-0.8032559156,
-0.1899661422,
0.154617995,
-0.0840241984,
0.0618130863,
-0.4372295439,
0.2766143084,
-0.1295419931,
0.8305347562,
-0.0018472304,
0.0365399309,
-0.212887913,
-0.6359932423,
-0.0645869523,
0.298271805,
0.3239583373,
1.1019740105,
-0.2677294314,
-0.1264248043,
0.6799178123,
-0.3497292101,
0.1560130864,
-0.4459637105,
-0.3169965446,
-0.1458781511,
0.4221659303,
0.6971147656,
0.544724524,
-1.0302464962,
0.1211914718,
0.1928507388,
-0.1283825636,
-0.7075737715,
0.0585103296,
0.1944301575,
0.0321334712,
0.5330529809,
-0.2313912362,
-0.4905156195,
-0.8367909789,
0.2598938644,
0.2637463212,
-0.6010600924,
-0.0481126793,
0.3757332265,
0.2112134844,
-0.1519184411,
0.5449488163,
-0.3821539283,
-0.6844977736,
0.2884550691,
0.3641725183,
0.566637218,
-0.2496455461,
0.0245439894,
0.5170409083,
0.1150915548,
-0.2217254639,
0.1146674082,
-0.1181347147,
-0.6296580434,
-0.3080969453,
-0.87261796,
-0.6175233126,
0.4146238863,
-0.5833224058,
0.2508881092,
-0.5146772265,
0.087020494,
-0.467964679,
0.0051251673,
-0.6384829879,
0.1070568189,
0.1640570611,
0.7729443312,
-0.5152059793,
0.9426150322,
0.2663686275,
-0.3104649782,
-0.4011629522,
-0.2212125659,
0.2879011631,
-0.6742110848,
0.6963780522,
0.1201593652,
-0.0602290928,
0.0915105268,
-0.2105909735,
-1.0352345705,
0.9966561794,
0.2679004073,
-0.8688732386,
0.0102680558,
-0.0127670541,
0.4366396368,
-0.2758411765,
0.0783380866,
0.4365513027,
0.3316852748,
0.0386230648,
-0.947050333,
-0.2600554228,
-0.0674999505,
-0.2302794904,
0.3327814639,
-0.5613737106,
0.7114470601,
-0.1608137488,
-0.3642219305,
0.0216428731,
0.3925514817,
0.0660991967,
0.0259611905,
0.6220170259,
0.5564727783,
0.6607030034,
-0.21211119,
0.779543519,
-0.2823478281,
0.6548888087,
1.1436918974,
-0.3903723061,
1.1875318289,
0.2783129215,
-0.317435652,
0.5284237862,
0.6446848512,
-0.1162446216,
0.3561731875,
0.2462309003,
-0.4851377606,
-0.5560612679,
-0.1147829369,
-0.443025291,
0.0970756784,
0.4660184681,
0.1460028738,
-0.1940633655,
0.1659248173,
-0.0171559155,
0.0175072085,
-0.3658091426,
0.8855471611,
0.2239811569,
-0.6821093559,
0.7682248354,
-0.2099018842,
0.6281471848,
-1.0114476681,
0.1664001942,
-0.1949431151,
0.4314633608,
0.0208108108,
-0.4270963073,
0.2350842804,
0.049264431,
0.1173208579,
-0.2297311872,
0.3452329934,
-0.6965586543,
-0.3145301342,
0.6117851138,
0.5767802596,
-0.0115545085,
0.2437404245,
-0.5269008279,
0.1974672675,
-0.2936271131,
-0.1803955436,
0.6386035681,
0.2826974988,
0.0960017666,
1.2527557611,
0.4670954645,
0.4035540223,
0.2066331506,
-0.1007803231,
0.6122373343,
-0.433100611,
-0.511333406,
-0.687815249,
0.4196997881,
-0.070847109,
-0.3161402941,
0.8467278481,
0.2796461582,
1.0632727146,
0.0473111346,
0.854634285,
-0.0730240643,
0.7080226541,
-0.7033458352,
0.8172379732,
-1.0244352818,
0.3548833132,
0.0101981098,
-0.948135078,
-0.1045843735,
0.5711930394,
-0.277894944,
-0.1498660892,
0.9946132302,
0.3427631557,
0.0670923293,
-0.2629564703,
0.5631349683,
0.2072009742,
0.2245746255,
0.6360521317,
1.0264385939,
0.0343515053,
0.6166384816,
-0.1529334784,
-0.0114125358,
-0.2395324409,
-1.0233018398,
-0.7452569008,
-0.6183428764,
-0.5032490492,
-0.2244019359,
0.3693481684,
1.0831229687,
0.4371336699,
-0.8700615764,
-0.4956737757,
-0.0512005575,
0.0282809287,
-0.3286264539,
-0.1363020092,
0.0387528874,
-0.6963013411,
-0.2326158285,
0.2762525678,
0.3066985905,
-0.1819841564,
-0.6385607719,
-0.408924669,
-0.4750337005,
-0.1553168744,
0.6273117661,
0.5854455829,
-0.8614637852,
-0.4614934325,
-0.1102609113,
-0.0902774036,
0.0164695829,
0.6973258257,
-0.7852109671,
0.6309850216,
0.2900721431,
0.9331588745,
0.5476628542,
-0.4178449214,
0.5211628079,
-0.6714859605,
-0.0951795503,
0.1279042959,
0.407376349,
0.3914273083,
0.0931471735,
0.3110641837,
0.5510638356,
-0.6034176946,
-0.8463051319,
0.2218865752,
-0.4600205421,
-0.3563277125,
1.2002429962,
-0.5704348087,
0.0751069188,
-0.7431057096,
0.284395963,
0.1252414733,
-0.1683021784,
0.8796576262,
0.8019076586,
0.2608667016,
-0.267365396,
-0.8744999766,
0.3660546839,
0.1516354084,
-0.8072302938,
0.0016451625,
0.5087714791,
0.5373885632,
0.1859614104,
0.4374294877,
0.2498639077,
0.1424136907,
0.0350066312,
-0.0497087091,
-0.0422306731,
-0.493697226,
-0.1960713863,
0.193945691,
0.2760441303,
0.3530164361
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09630v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09630v2
|
Decoding Susceptibility: Modeling Misbelief to Misinformation Through a Computational Approach
| 2023-11-16T07:22:56 | 2024-02-16T09:12:21 |
Yanchen Liu, Mingyu Derek Ma, Wenna Qin, Azure Zhou, Jiaao Chen, Weiyan Shi, Wei Wang, Diyi Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI
|
Susceptibility to misinformation describes the degree of belief in
unverifiable claims, a latent aspect of individuals' mental processes that is
not observable. Existing susceptibility studies heavily rely on self-reported
beliefs, which can be subject to bias, expensive to collect, and challenging to
scale for downstream applications. To address these limitations, in this work,
we propose a computational approach to model users' latent susceptibility
levels. As shown in previous research, susceptibility is influenced by various
factors (e.g., demographic factors, political ideology), and directly
influences people's reposting behavior on social media. To represent the
underlying mental process, our susceptibility modeling incorporates these
factors as inputs, guided by the supervision of people's sharing behavior.
Using COVID-19 as a testbed domain, our experiments demonstrate a significant
alignment between the susceptibility scores estimated by our computational
modeling and human judgments, confirming the effectiveness of this latent
modeling approach. Furthermore, we apply our model to annotate susceptibility
scores on a large-scale dataset and analyze the relationships between
susceptibility with various factors. Our analysis reveals that political
leanings and psychological factors exhibit varying degrees of association with
susceptibility to COVID-19 misinformation.
|
[
-0.2187797874,
-0.7246813774,
0.4222794175,
0.3160647154,
-0.0853215083,
0.0076807211,
0.0380321108,
-0.4089149237,
0.2847544849,
0.156157583,
-0.6130435467,
-0.055370383,
-0.7226448655,
0.0541280992,
-0.3741973937,
0.9336242676,
0.407237947,
-0.2472912669,
-0.4870845079,
0.2956784666,
-0.1468540728,
-0.8545496464,
-0.1973116994,
-0.5152232647,
0.2676503956,
0.4156283438,
0.8870347142,
0.0354287848,
0.4130952954,
0.0253347941,
0.2205194086,
-0.3804421127,
-0.7335547209,
-0.1123497486,
-0.496216625,
-0.549544096,
-0.0944954082,
0.069787614,
0.084549889,
0.3683875501,
-0.3514138162,
0.3252764046,
-0.0493668765,
0.1416532993,
-0.6381491423,
-0.2881501913,
-0.919023335,
0.0446672104,
-0.0784252509,
-0.472333163,
-0.4181067944,
-0.2118936032,
0.095164597,
-0.7603425384,
0.7276581526,
0.1087994277,
0.5082455873,
0.1973256767,
-0.2974430621,
-0.2546162903,
-0.8021880984,
0.4341362417,
-0.5677877069,
0.3280040622,
0.9411745071,
0.2337219715,
-0.1933066249,
-0.3600729108,
-0.6277084351,
-0.1233582422,
0.1683300585,
-0.0627325475,
-0.4105921686,
-0.4363432825,
0.2620944679,
0.2873995602,
-0.6778627038,
-0.3802683055,
-0.5278944969,
-0.4511766434,
0.8154414892,
0.1258024275,
0.5036218166,
-0.2685110867,
-0.4139612913,
0.2183782905,
-0.5702798963,
0.0730475336,
0.3895881474,
0.2805501819,
-0.539647162,
0.6348902583,
0.1776976138,
0.2618102133,
0.485155791,
0.1549595594,
0.127895534,
-0.3549905121,
-0.2181909233,
0.1822302192,
0.6413142085,
0.4846567214,
-0.0064623021,
-0.0489832424,
0.2392519414,
0.2745932937,
0.7230020165,
-0.6018496752,
-0.3968743384,
-0.2092080116,
-0.6966510415,
-0.4770538211,
-0.0726681501,
-0.7998199463,
-1.0269844532,
-0.0069275443,
0.5343875885,
-0.4737373292,
-0.5024286509,
-0.1220806763,
-0.2177360207,
-0.0938998535,
0.5498594046,
-0.7507160902,
0.5363928676,
0.5001535416,
0.8596577048,
-0.3221268356,
-0.1608271301,
-0.1757854968,
-0.0583282709,
-0.2970918417,
0.7056322098,
-0.739135325,
-0.3243546188,
-0.2608699799,
0.0516004302,
-0.1823081821,
-0.4528476,
0.5623013377,
-0.603516221,
-0.0854479894,
-0.4886619151,
-0.4587061703,
-0.0873854011,
0.175102964,
-0.6449835896,
0.8469321728,
0.2412890643,
-1.1862838268,
-0.0164365899,
-0.5197526813,
-0.2031638026,
0.0125871198,
-0.1976903081,
-0.3340554535,
0.4100385904,
0.0430049561,
0.1687939763,
-0.3068785667,
0.2769598663,
-0.6268856525,
-0.2678361535,
0.525921762,
-0.5471953154,
0.8965705633,
0.2816213667,
-0.0845803097,
-0.0444308519,
-0.3422438204,
-0.6042826772,
0.1103350073,
-0.0392182618,
-0.5874223113,
-0.0077432203,
0.0006796296,
0.3722105026,
0.1394654363,
-0.4162442982,
0.2334199548,
-0.3489423096,
0.3087184131,
0.7399743795,
0.4313863516,
0.3831522763,
-0.3856042027,
0.6209982038,
0.3293032646,
0.1759672463,
0.2377715856,
-0.3032123446,
-0.0839773938,
0.2130209208,
-0.1472377479,
0.6575645208,
-0.6565993428,
-0.1022770554,
-0.0751263052,
-0.5844278336,
-0.2091830224,
0.0271254983,
0.0973540843,
0.6652339697,
0.1964724511,
0.0015145056,
-0.6885492802,
-0.8525574207,
-0.6093139648,
-0.3695576787,
-0.0342986286,
0.1373600811,
0.7896491289,
-0.3516650498,
0.5723522902,
-0.570063293,
0.04820453,
0.0890709609,
0.3680922985,
0.1093880832,
0.2669070959,
0.4611473083,
-0.8680552244,
-0.0569094457,
-0.1076511666,
-0.8662548065,
0.1849445105,
-0.2096506059,
0.235034734,
0.3210208118,
0.6960663795,
-0.1621875763,
0.9608433247,
0.5746549964,
-0.4929570556,
0.7297829986,
-0.237405628,
0.1689771712,
-1.1738140583,
-0.0291599371,
0.2480910718,
-0.1115000919,
-0.7368551493,
-0.1130502671,
-0.256952852,
-0.1989126951,
-0.2951553762,
-0.0897999927,
-0.1918604225,
0.0003684799,
-0.3198193014,
-0.513348639,
-0.1122057587,
0.0805784091,
-0.1233387217,
0.8144522309,
0.4989583194,
-0.3084141016,
0.1773655266,
-0.0020238669,
-0.2256691456,
0.5701164007,
-0.6758819222,
-0.0482665449,
-0.2988336086,
0.2950294018,
-0.8277190924,
-0.4435210526,
0.6269820333,
-0.7204672694,
-0.2588650584,
-0.0774187595,
-0.2863864005,
-0.2080872208,
-0.1804741919,
0.506107986,
-0.0461486466,
-0.1078649759,
0.8422386646,
0.5173208117,
-0.2981556356,
-0.0852769837,
-0.7979288101,
0.097578153,
-0.3648709059,
-0.4912661612,
0.5643054843,
-0.2511889935,
-0.3103427291,
0.0044661071,
-0.2262320966,
-0.2437863201,
0.1659418941,
0.8226187825,
0.0509363376,
0.1692834795,
0.178381905,
-0.1911340505,
-0.0032329266,
0.3925377429,
0.0509374663,
0.4083179235,
-0.1533000022,
-0.4091356993,
-0.5504499674,
0.5780343413,
0.4628710449,
0.1097187549,
0.8881644607,
0.2681708932,
-0.992863059,
-0.0467707776,
-0.1080087274,
-0.339433372,
-0.3443520367,
0.0856612623,
-0.235735327,
-0.7059062719,
0.7505082488,
-0.070343487,
-0.542181015,
0.5139095783,
0.7197360396,
-0.169345811,
0.6131924987,
0.9111819267,
-0.0127908764,
0.2088333517,
0.1129210442,
0.3010815382,
-0.2865699828,
-0.4117341042,
-0.4674956203,
0.0788725019,
-0.479482621,
-0.6599442363,
0.4658755362,
0.0746020451,
-0.2018572539,
0.052683346,
-0.3177499771,
0.2460303456,
0.4156912863,
0.3108746707,
0.2323074341,
0.3383375704,
0.0662633032,
-0.1885745525,
-0.7513750196,
-0.2387211174,
0.9917416573,
0.2604737282,
1.0427693129,
0.2618251443,
0.3851727247,
1.1409698725,
0.2240315527,
-0.283539474,
0.1129773185,
0.0212801415,
-0.8580938578,
-0.2548060715,
-0.24392654,
-0.6070768833,
-0.1348465383,
-0.6817002296,
-0.9701100588,
0.4018833935,
0.2640326023,
-0.3982165456,
0.1040061042,
-0.5807009935,
0.5606153607,
-0.0057837614,
-0.3493283093,
-0.5689638257,
-0.8191756606,
0.3709035218,
-0.3598394394,
0.5184832811,
0.018476259,
0.5210476518,
0.6729115844,
-0.456148684,
1.1680395603,
-0.1631999612,
-0.0218032356,
0.3825782835,
0.1307663172,
0.392342627,
0.1856119931,
-0.3250402212,
0.2942959666,
0.2555380762,
-0.3562010229,
-0.5237013102,
0.6973600388,
-1.2034450769,
-0.3933631778,
-0.9320084453,
-0.5009521246,
0.0910908803,
0.0607804991,
0.5716056824,
-0.0876354054,
-0.3638389409,
0.0375894792,
0.6752647161,
-0.2052315474,
0.0117544299,
0.3177386522,
-0.1115125045,
-0.2339026332,
0.9274761677,
0.4668853879,
0.0284552164,
0.1518965214,
0.4760375321,
-0.1170202419,
-0.2118306011,
0.2040659338,
0.1473112553,
-0.4962840676,
-0.0788612962,
-0.3967260122,
-0.3462207019,
-0.6438431144,
-0.1353791505,
-0.1370817572,
-0.3392937779,
-0.5413372517,
-0.1990262419,
0.539237082,
0.7364323735,
-0.3837768137,
0.4647957385,
-0.2436541766,
0.7765315771,
0.0979131833,
0.3257750571,
0.0126753133,
-0.6004619002,
-0.256483525,
0.3721576333,
-0.3376422226,
-1.1201149225,
0.3847849667,
0.0712609887,
0.5169166327,
0.3733105361,
0.5637534857,
0.5677831769,
-0.0431706645,
0.6923235059,
0.1689054072,
-0.9688853025,
0.5062922835,
-0.454341948,
-0.2128515095,
0.5415267944,
0.7084963918,
-0.5826682448,
-0.0781240538,
-0.8027431369,
-0.6709519625,
0.6654703021,
0.1470466405,
-0.0508974157,
0.2347491235,
0.2886659205,
0.4282515943,
-0.1866401881,
-0.3679631948,
-0.2084195763,
-0.7855374813,
0.0357438661,
-0.1328613758,
-0.2530768216,
-0.3158015907,
-0.2774548829,
0.5791755915,
-0.0788404569,
0.2989640832,
0.3414755464,
-0.1873019636,
-0.2492810637,
0.0971533209,
0.7312027216,
0.7384675741,
-0.3439625502,
0.6169002056,
-0.0155829303,
-0.6327221394,
0.1911935359,
0.0926130265,
-0.3090610206,
-0.2905534804,
0.364149183,
0.3918251693,
-0.1581326872,
-0.2785158455,
0.8127356172,
-0.3532727957,
-0.1868001074,
-0.7213913798,
-0.140569672,
0.3180027306,
0.2016136348,
0.6401400566,
0.5201883912,
0.1056355163,
-0.6620949507,
0.4022366703,
0.2877908349,
-0.1622370183,
-0.8036587238,
0.73473984,
-0.0587645024,
-0.4044584632,
0.4320139587,
0.1920049936,
-0.2458786219,
0.555832088,
0.822213769,
0.4764381945,
-0.5143652558,
0.4728113413,
0.3053297997,
0.4758086503,
-0.0807987228,
0.2420008034,
0.2669958472,
-0.7326788306,
0.0010227347,
-0.4497484267,
-0.1737174988,
0.2395214289,
-0.8773954511,
0.0304196253,
-0.5525462031,
-0.4934315979,
0.3574565649,
-0.1236088797,
-0.6605806351,
0.2328311354,
0.1898485571,
1.0359399319,
-1.5178281069,
0.3493070602,
0.4918372035,
-0.3313913941,
-0.5760555267,
0.5670424104,
0.4456166029,
-0.5306069255,
0.1970320195,
0.0176854506,
-0.1146559492,
-0.3950577676,
-0.7547835112,
-0.8686317801,
0.848978281,
0.5962801576,
-0.3848766983,
0.1914599389,
0.1762758046,
0.4603557289,
-0.6630427837,
-0.1435301751,
0.2462696135,
0.1519186199,
0.134902969,
-0.4746468067,
0.3063233495,
-0.4676134884,
-0.1355879903,
-0.497682482,
-0.4779705405,
0.7141382098,
-0.3743726015,
-0.1347281337,
-0.5012146831,
0.622368753,
0.2541186213,
0.9304453731,
0.456882745,
0.3893949091,
0.8474847674,
0.3829823732,
0.9351992607,
-0.2718756199,
0.242258206,
1.2005800009,
-0.2046807557,
0.8005129099,
0.5345973969,
-0.057532914,
0.5895465016,
0.642052412,
0.0247422792,
0.5092651844,
0.24761042,
-0.2289180756,
-0.443112582,
-0.4568421543,
-0.4656619132,
0.438688755,
0.6711739898,
-0.5198013186,
-0.3360481262,
0.0083372323,
0.0116685452,
0.2918637693,
-0.3858343661,
0.5532767773,
0.0260103494,
-0.3776744008,
0.7017999291,
0.0531448126,
0.3067800403,
-0.2233985662,
-0.0388283171,
0.0230643842,
0.0063977959,
-0.5877735019,
-0.6171072125,
0.8965632915,
0.0313061923,
-0.7081595659,
0.0048793792,
1.1831650734,
-0.1166420206,
-0.7417361736,
0.1428876221,
0.3992156386,
0.1900071949,
-0.3062261045,
-0.5767237544,
0.3054100573,
0.0578588806,
-0.0867362246,
0.244339034,
0.2017864883,
-0.6866894364,
0.6965551972,
0.7803061008,
-0.2051208168,
-0.1306874007,
0.0585972965,
0.961720407,
-0.7032994628,
-0.5506560206,
-0.9031543136,
0.0964398831,
0.0618800931,
-0.0140694585,
0.8927691579,
0.5435638428,
0.5492087007,
-0.1759329885,
1.2947833538,
-0.0092955912,
0.4473596811,
0.135442391,
0.9861101508,
-0.313853085,
0.1561503559,
-0.1268853098,
-0.2515143752,
-0.2806953788,
0.5259860754,
-0.5206492543,
-0.2001861781,
0.1537983268,
0.9073588848,
0.0529431589,
0.2988492846,
-0.0320814215,
0.6055133939,
0.1635920107,
0.4774778783,
0.6999702454,
-0.1187530532,
0.2764099538,
-0.1162535325,
-0.3583875895,
-0.65404737,
-0.9169517756,
-0.7994479537,
-0.6407197118,
-0.3058003485,
-0.8490157127,
0.1932305098,
0.8125906587,
0.4600398839,
-0.6038369536,
0.12579602,
-0.2280799299,
0.1846043617,
-0.3296881914,
-0.2455625981,
0.2657683194,
0.6127542257,
0.0705941916,
0.0464076325,
0.0279704183,
0.1503154039,
-0.2278252095,
-0.107468538,
-0.3656719923,
0.5268924236,
0.3952386379,
0.4808790982,
-0.7403377295,
-0.2407834381,
0.014702471,
-0.1353919059,
-0.1452819854,
0.562885046,
-0.8028904796,
0.3784079552,
0.6728045344,
0.4383077621,
0.4404217005,
0.5233752728,
0.5202364922,
-0.5800498724,
-0.2727684081,
-0.0331752859,
-0.0927731693,
0.5050711036,
-0.7806526423,
0.1594269276,
0.6093865037,
-0.3416588008,
-0.8268638849,
0.318947643,
-0.9961026907,
-0.3706911206,
0.8160890341,
0.023824567,
-0.4501080215,
-0.2653182447,
-0.1246450841,
0.1885084808,
-0.555391252,
1.2728233337,
0.7417871356,
-0.2062213272,
-0.1880387664,
-0.2839942873,
0.483135432,
-0.1504153013,
-0.6345396042,
0.4243266582,
0.1943489909,
0.6736298203,
0.267351985,
0.8239188194,
0.1124599427,
0.4301318228,
0.3539743125,
-0.119784154,
-0.1539719701,
-0.2667759359,
-0.4858504236,
0.4282764792,
-0.1917651594,
0.1439754963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09627v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09627v2
|
Mitigating Biases for Instruction-following Language Models via Bias Neurons Elimination
| 2023-11-16T07:16:55 | 2024-06-05T05:49:19 |
Nakyeong Yang, Taegwan Kang, Jungkyu Choi, Honglak Lee, Kyomin Jung
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Instruction-following language models often show undesirable biases. These
undesirable biases may be accelerated in the real-world usage of language
models, where a wide range of instructions is used through zero-shot example
prompting. To solve this problem, we first define the bias neuron, which
significantly affects biased outputs, and prove its existence empirically.
Furthermore, we propose a novel and practical bias mitigation method, CRISPR,
to eliminate bias neurons of language models in instruction-following settings.
CRISPR automatically determines biased outputs and categorizes neurons that
affect the biased outputs as bias neurons using an explainability method.
Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of our method in mitigating
biases under zero-shot instruction-following settings without losing the
model's task performance and existing knowledge. The experimental results
reveal the generalizability of our method as it shows robustness under various
instructions and datasets. Surprisingly, our method can mitigate the bias in
language models by eliminating only a few neurons (at least three).
|
[
-0.3408419192,
-0.9694828987,
0.258623749,
-0.1744797677,
0.1129552498,
-0.159688279,
-0.3238915205,
-0.0373762064,
0.1445330828,
0.405180037,
-0.5942128897,
-0.1820770204,
-0.5806674957,
-0.3420151174,
-0.3625795841,
1.3105626106,
0.1099704206,
0.4355051219,
-0.3911981583,
0.0502985604,
-0.5003336072,
-0.3493026793,
-0.3740743101,
-0.7149060369,
0.7173225284,
0.5462958217,
0.6096097231,
0.9294372797,
0.0501942337,
0.175342828,
-0.2817159295,
-0.341285646,
-0.5170471072,
-0.0243788268,
0.0247977898,
-0.4232935905,
-0.1832482964,
-0.1148226857,
0.507506907,
0.9030532241,
-0.020745188,
-0.0892367363,
0.0972831771,
0.6660890579,
-0.7602263093,
-0.1792220026,
-0.5799865127,
0.3396558166,
-0.025475461,
-0.0537618101,
-0.6065832376,
-0.4847052693,
0.0028882294,
-0.4140247405,
0.5010432601,
-0.2933322787,
0.6012290716,
0.1466100216,
0.0258292016,
-0.0789015144,
-0.7513113022,
0.7968098521,
-0.7502121925,
0.0970626324,
0.4530050457,
0.0398925655,
-0.134823516,
-0.02811254,
-0.6204683185,
-0.2217197269,
0.0193565823,
-0.0374439955,
-0.2053701282,
0.1377116442,
0.600684762,
-0.1126970872,
-0.5190301538,
0.0678102523,
-0.6954553127,
-0.3359873593,
0.1141788736,
-0.2349470407,
0.7329058051,
-0.0055981781,
-0.076119028,
-0.1123781279,
-0.803570509,
-0.0036457081,
0.721511662,
0.1518187225,
0.1978517324,
0.6379095316,
-0.1058991179,
0.5438032746,
0.1631931812,
0.3371874988,
0.162023589,
-0.1521306187,
-0.1653009951,
0.2572751343,
0.4581575692,
0.2859128416,
0.5311665535,
-0.3335902095,
-0.0402501673,
0.2287138849,
0.382836014,
-0.8069807887,
-0.4071467221,
0.0563495122,
-0.4840087593,
-0.3236648142,
-0.4131138027,
-1.0080704689,
-0.3927111328,
0.1311517209,
0.4304897487,
-0.4735187292,
-0.0561679378,
-0.0252735224,
-0.4180904031,
0.3621011078,
-0.0257885475,
-1.0420429707,
0.4577464461,
0.4698332846,
0.5721248984,
0.0863935202,
-0.2846442163,
-0.481941849,
0.1415441334,
-0.4212654829,
0.7371917963,
-0.8607778549,
-0.4367310703,
-0.1680978239,
-0.2782633305,
0.088733539,
-0.4615159035,
0.631295979,
-0.2807833254,
0.2472197115,
-0.6626828909,
-0.6573626399,
-0.031346146,
-0.0141136702,
-0.6851690412,
0.7396318316,
-0.3111679256,
-0.8898177743,
0.2640120387,
-0.7211635113,
-0.7694218755,
-0.1383407712,
-0.2381601185,
-0.4270065725,
0.2454839647,
0.4974105656,
0.2908967137,
-0.0748483017,
0.2718958557,
-0.168610692,
-0.6632941365,
-0.020649381,
-0.6249501705,
0.81875664,
-0.0621505417,
-0.70875144,
0.0607072152,
-0.4560194016,
-0.0362477712,
0.2051267624,
-0.0136161027,
-0.5062568784,
0.2655785978,
-0.2329006493,
0.1125217527,
-0.0640598089,
-0.714618504,
0.2550297379,
-0.4569562078,
0.3635876775,
0.9992169142,
-0.0787383765,
0.9048365355,
-0.3580554724,
0.3868013322,
0.160985902,
0.1351649761,
-0.5149733424,
-0.5476920009,
-1.0458259583,
0.0104810782,
0.1257925779,
0.4856803417,
-0.7185964584,
0.1790424138,
0.0179317109,
-0.3689891398,
-0.5551202893,
-0.0220862422,
0.6864759922,
0.9396650195,
0.5422813296,
-0.2096825093,
-0.4619077444,
-1.1081895828,
-0.6228117347,
0.190676868,
-0.1334241182,
0.1858704984,
0.4531738162,
-0.1085514352,
0.639275074,
-0.4494263232,
0.2926973999,
-0.205983758,
0.162913993,
0.0006415194,
0.7552387714,
0.374812603,
-0.5523802638,
-0.2241047174,
-0.0227316692,
-0.3687627912,
-0.3146922588,
-0.3006752431,
-0.1210442558,
0.0756543279,
0.3942746818,
-0.5012711883,
0.7973667383,
0.0197538361,
-0.0959476754,
0.5553972125,
-0.1118823066,
-0.0817111433,
-0.6339545846,
0.0632172227,
0.194509685,
0.1494337767,
-1.0392930508,
-0.1950341761,
0.3312558234,
0.0258006305,
-0.2160501629,
0.6205047965,
-0.3083817065,
0.0621871464,
-0.39312765,
-0.2321060598,
0.214536339,
0.6101818085,
-0.0113240462,
0.8025273085,
0.6288254261,
-0.4971110225,
-0.1233217716,
0.1551851928,
0.0128693264,
0.1468800455,
-0.7780534029,
0.0549100488,
-0.5280038714,
0.1901983023,
-0.7191895247,
0.0142285665,
0.616204977,
-0.4957327843,
0.3027713895,
-0.19022879,
0.002046902,
-0.3745612204,
-0.4487627447,
0.2852364182,
0.7448313832,
-0.605979383,
0.4435296059,
0.0733068585,
-0.2487119585,
-0.8627306223,
-0.8201515675,
-0.1047403887,
0.0635652319,
-0.0253760517,
0.4797021449,
-0.336840421,
-0.0297866799,
-0.0376892984,
-0.3045892715,
-0.1965042204,
-0.1292743087,
0.119681567,
0.3276848793,
0.0763423368,
-0.0360482149,
0.3253026307,
0.0085008917,
0.2235072404,
-0.1560947597,
0.6406751871,
0.3924518824,
-0.411280632,
-0.5433010459,
0.5770967007,
0.5108942986,
-0.2450152487,
0.5897570848,
0.3387748897,
-0.5261673927,
-0.4675177932,
-0.557092309,
-0.5107905269,
-0.4554380178,
0.5188868046,
-0.0671123415,
-0.5247064829,
0.4137980938,
0.169189617,
0.0038349165,
0.0795548707,
0.5673357844,
0.0825501755,
1.1366664171,
0.6346087456,
-0.369189322,
0.6643401384,
0.04142588,
0.5905674696,
-0.9236078858,
-0.2936460078,
-0.7043055296,
-0.2652184963,
-0.3332487941,
-0.3791245222,
0.0840606093,
-0.1336156279,
-0.2082590759,
0.3150872588,
-0.6867753267,
1.057440877,
0.8196120262,
0.2079124004,
-0.3557321429,
-0.0849039406,
-0.5982798338,
0.1526948512,
-0.8519075513,
-0.431114614,
1.0638610125,
0.2584286332,
0.7542937398,
-0.467438668,
0.6080690622,
0.1714446843,
0.2630191445,
-0.6808608174,
0.4628207982,
-0.0672484189,
-0.6421993375,
-0.0581868999,
-0.5249589086,
-0.2496294677,
0.0860355347,
-0.0084913326,
-0.9247753024,
0.0861432701,
0.3741975725,
-0.4426705539,
0.5997906327,
-1.0506495237,
0.7135654092,
-0.1732685417,
-0.5795131922,
-0.0151328593,
-0.6100517511,
0.3028384745,
0.1120917052,
0.0446023419,
0.1098816618,
0.3866468966,
0.834092319,
-0.0863857716,
0.9941139221,
-0.4053355753,
0.1343398839,
-0.0133139789,
0.1846969724,
0.452712357,
-0.3051809072,
-0.1925220937,
0.2167355865,
-0.377091676,
-0.5904315114,
-0.5950940251,
0.8429746032,
-0.7179663181,
-0.4457740188,
-0.2929736972,
-0.7880644798,
-0.1497540474,
0.2683745921,
0.3821776509,
0.2684909999,
-0.3292124569,
-0.3193619847,
0.8850781918,
-0.6063482165,
0.7183579206,
0.2127463818,
0.0697576329,
-0.2025619149,
0.8570113778,
0.2008653432,
0.3149291277,
0.1258027256,
0.3089028597,
0.1756338477,
-0.4446400702,
-0.3779547215,
-0.037652079,
-0.6293839812,
-0.0837741345,
-0.7687451839,
-0.3041453063,
-0.4374194443,
-0.3770152926,
-0.2054229379,
-0.4521029294,
-0.3662062287,
-0.1873926818,
-0.0113579547,
0.7088847756,
0.0398578718,
0.4262684286,
-0.5159587264,
0.5051745772,
0.2789313793,
0.4691512287,
0.3504544199,
-0.4410556853,
-0.0314681679,
0.3904672563,
-0.3514270186,
-1.01889503,
0.4268490374,
0.1588761508,
0.7260997295,
0.6247027516,
-0.2642843425,
0.6562930942,
-1.0856776237,
0.6835103631,
0.3080093563,
-1.2372342348,
0.6335526109,
-0.1360080987,
0.543497324,
0.1251340359,
0.4684589505,
-0.4921024144,
-0.3138438165,
-0.4256234467,
-0.7418099046,
0.7330399752,
0.2392603159,
0.45264709,
-0.3620880842,
0.6112052798,
0.1640015244,
0.0607292913,
-0.6936194301,
-0.4423116148,
-0.3873137236,
-0.0001534198,
0.1026761606,
-0.4384019971,
-0.1896191835,
-0.4425745606,
0.8263288736,
-0.0290568341,
0.3981596529,
0.0515418313,
-0.014507344,
-0.2631945014,
0.4400268495,
0.7884706259,
0.3643387854,
-0.0795587301,
0.0750058219,
0.0477801524,
-0.548671186,
-0.0627207384,
-0.0351845436,
-0.7596693039,
-0.1686323136,
0.1282727122,
0.6620649099,
-0.0284766816,
-0.5769374371,
0.613902986,
-0.0388408713,
-0.0182485394,
0.1177432761,
0.3733447194,
0.0808451548,
-0.0307672732,
0.3931007683,
0.5318732858,
0.149624452,
-0.2593268156,
0.3668138981,
0.7251546383,
-0.637301147,
-0.3927683234,
0.6468755603,
0.0487292409,
-0.3021558821,
0.4228884876,
-0.0122058848,
-0.6847060323,
1.1049331427,
0.9756932855,
0.8416870832,
-0.4047621489,
0.3414361477,
0.3188206851,
0.5611173511,
-0.0858889893,
0.1093066111,
-0.0595864952,
-1.0075464249,
-0.4170058668,
-0.357175529,
-0.4151434898,
-0.0517141819,
-0.8808367252,
0.0033758243,
-0.643563211,
0.1161600575,
0.465998441,
-0.4837328196,
-0.4971036017,
0.1033439338,
0.2553128898,
0.8458332419,
-1.1052548885,
1.0531998873,
0.4069812298,
-0.3955123425,
-0.4361957312,
0.3941645026,
0.1110842749,
-0.8337935805,
0.4350216687,
0.3782956302,
-0.1184561625,
-0.2588321269,
-0.9798778296,
-0.3314044774,
0.5239482522,
0.4393661618,
-0.6622706652,
0.0326556861,
-0.1016281396,
0.2884759307,
-0.2633102238,
0.4254480004,
0.6279634237,
0.3596586883,
0.0653002858,
-0.4178119898,
-0.0951318443,
-0.5007914305,
0.0408045202,
0.2543776929,
-0.1148341447,
0.7362214923,
-0.4931665361,
0.0805433691,
-0.0466310084,
0.3967677653,
0.0105496654,
0.1767090112,
0.2071542442,
0.5564408898,
0.6806384325,
0.1039893553,
0.8239028454,
-0.2230948806,
0.0344988406,
1.2989684343,
-0.5755400062,
0.5375866294,
0.909806788,
0.2719098032,
0.3639157712,
0.1025246307,
0.0394012034,
0.6544969082,
0.5080221891,
-0.3206180632,
0.1140023693,
-0.315924108,
-0.0741113573,
0.2726485133,
0.2739490867,
-0.3890825808,
-0.2389944792,
0.3035636246,
0.4615020156,
0.1687825173,
-0.3719353974,
0.6513489485,
-0.4474849403,
-0.6548722386,
0.4726732075,
0.0034620303,
0.7623236775,
-0.4635754824,
-0.3367183805,
-0.3440355957,
0.0652472302,
-0.1049467996,
-0.369346261,
0.3195777535,
0.2737207115,
-0.5801542997,
-0.2655678689,
0.7216948271,
-0.4247335196,
-0.6000963449,
0.4248803258,
0.3407468498,
-0.193159163,
0.0954281539,
-0.4189340174,
0.0147149246,
0.1631205082,
-0.1425701976,
0.2866405845,
0.0555371009,
0.0146571863,
0.6538104415,
0.7100570202,
0.1516624838,
0.2328024805,
0.071801126,
1.2832863331,
-0.6631143689,
-0.1582204998,
-1.0215239525,
0.3216632605,
-0.1236336231,
0.0148801329,
0.5652152896,
0.5131850243,
0.9171645641,
-0.0349579789,
1.1194357872,
0.0356318019,
0.4207349718,
-0.2403963655,
1.10600245,
-0.0733091161,
0.3171712458,
-0.2987186611,
-0.7700054049,
-0.5679363608,
0.6828209162,
-0.4018352032,
0.240094766,
0.6531772614,
1.1317110062,
-0.1496680528,
0.1891211271,
0.2726576626,
0.4270682037,
0.0920150802,
0.4465349913,
0.5767951608,
-0.3030280471,
0.4142633677,
-0.5469657183,
-0.4000807703,
0.2320469767,
-0.9732357264,
-1.0802510977,
-0.1341272593,
-0.257427752,
-0.1602819413,
0.4538244605,
0.7814247608,
0.5895594358,
-1.0749279261,
0.0063852533,
-0.2993267775,
0.3852237761,
-0.3539173603,
-0.1827979833,
0.2395730615,
-0.3400380313,
-0.5957368016,
0.520154655,
0.2220859379,
-0.1104209721,
-0.1737907529,
-0.0434597135,
-0.32379058,
0.47111094,
0.1965829581,
0.4655777812,
-0.7129411101,
-0.2990322709,
0.2538678646,
0.0632910058,
0.2504023314,
0.8358650804,
-0.8731134534,
0.6247557402,
0.461363107,
0.6881583333,
0.1016688645,
-0.2422604561,
0.6336886287,
-0.7452710271,
0.0942712128,
0.2969699204,
0.2326660752,
0.3034739196,
-0.4159143567,
0.0040867478,
-0.1818145514,
-0.4443860054,
-0.6764139533,
0.1998192221,
-0.5529267192,
-0.368919611,
1.0737148523,
-0.0740515962,
-0.4900739491,
0.0284357704,
-0.2060804963,
0.4003406763,
-0.3993716538,
0.9043999314,
0.6435816288,
0.0473331176,
-0.3157129288,
-0.7352614403,
0.3765237331,
0.766309917,
-0.7249161601,
0.1250251234,
0.5480395555,
0.2949989736,
-0.1117652133,
0.4770663083,
-0.0879728869,
0.3812839985,
-0.223245278,
0.5488171577,
0.1540924311,
-0.688888967,
-0.6902146339,
-0.0540414676,
-0.2870468199,
-0.2544014752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09619v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09619v2
|
Take One Step at a Time to Know Incremental Utility of Demonstration: An Analysis on Reranking for Few-Shot In-Context Learning
| 2023-11-16T07:03:54 | 2024-04-02T21:05:40 |
Kazuma Hashimoto, Karthik Raman, Michael Bendersky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In-Context Learning (ICL) is an emergent capability of Large Language Models
(LLMs). Only a few demonstrations enable LLMs to be used as blackbox for new
tasks. Previous studies have shown that using LLMs' outputs as labels is
effective in training models to select demonstrations. Such a label is expected
to estimate utility of a demonstration in ICL; however, it has not been well
understood how different labeling strategies affect results on target tasks.
This paper presents an analysis on different utility functions by focusing on
LLMs' output probability given ground-truth output, and task-specific reward
given LLMs' prediction. Unlike the previous work, we introduce a novel labeling
method, incremental utility, which estimates how much incremental knowledge is
brought into the LLMs by a demonstration. We conduct experiments with
instruction-tuned LLMs on binary/multi-class classification, segmentation, and
translation across Arabic, English, Finnish, Japanese, and Spanish. Our results
show that (1) the probability is effective when the probability values are
distributed across the whole value range (on the classification tasks), and (2)
the downstream metric is more robust when nuanced reward values are provided
with long outputs (on the segmentation and translation tasks). We then show
that the proposed incremental utility further helps ICL by contrasting how the
LLMs perform with and without the demonstrations.
|
[
-0.3336082399,
-0.4961699545,
0.4603981674,
0.2311964035,
-0.2557366192,
-0.0465980247,
-0.2292140424,
-0.2176429927,
-0.1826049536,
0.2654947042,
-0.2865231335,
-0.678140521,
-0.848513484,
-0.1499784291,
-0.3603315055,
1.1676318645,
-0.058368288,
-0.1546274275,
-0.5451170802,
-0.2623007298,
-0.4152818024,
-0.7021266222,
-0.5148859024,
-0.7086446881,
0.6321055293,
0.917857945,
0.3318335712,
0.6430500746,
0.2546256781,
0.2669466138,
0.1320960075,
-0.1940559596,
-0.4242696464,
0.0267030448,
0.0429772884,
-0.39250651,
-0.0307232905,
0.3078418672,
0.8916779757,
0.7632046938,
0.1783781946,
0.2939813435,
0.4202855527,
0.3672071993,
-0.6466840506,
0.1314784735,
-0.5586272478,
0.1897419989,
-0.2274931818,
-0.4296886623,
-0.6093598604,
-0.448810786,
0.1415092796,
-0.2732000053,
-0.2296091765,
-0.2164334208,
0.6766382456,
0.341327101,
-0.450057745,
-0.2561466694,
-0.2993632555,
1.0851593018,
-0.5453227758,
0.227957055,
0.305074662,
0.2941070795,
-0.0599504635,
-0.8511734009,
-0.2158961445,
-0.5530745387,
-0.2636515796,
-0.0515020415,
0.1013175771,
-0.1731390059,
0.3321695626,
0.1925182641,
0.0623307899,
0.5387913585,
0.0259823054,
-0.2029275149,
0.3884922564,
0.0724450424,
0.120551385,
-0.023264043,
-0.6997491121,
-0.3311875165,
-1.0416443348,
0.6600363255,
0.1816738099,
0.224372834,
-0.1806228757,
0.5526380539,
-0.160419181,
0.7092340589,
0.0085038254,
-0.6440509558,
0.266559571,
-0.2262780517,
-0.2804475725,
0.2948080897,
0.4762681723,
0.0717297494,
-0.1806999147,
-0.1627694964,
-0.1327485591,
-0.2398404032,
0.1162184924,
-0.8704587221,
0.1150837019,
-0.0640655234,
-0.2974470258,
-0.3080117404,
-0.267578125,
-0.3776788414,
-0.2472031564,
-0.304533571,
0.816688776,
-0.4365699291,
0.2051823884,
-0.2071216404,
-0.0426616929,
0.2614314854,
0.2805705667,
-0.7286011577,
0.161701262,
0.5670870543,
0.74376297,
-0.2986142933,
-0.47901088,
-0.9109617472,
0.1100681722,
-0.3003662229,
0.6884906888,
-0.4216606021,
-0.3328064382,
0.0651299357,
-0.0601916909,
-0.0124160089,
-0.5122640729,
0.3889680803,
-0.350153029,
-0.1587201059,
-0.1674866676,
-0.6627511382,
-0.1646213531,
0.2594386935,
-0.2939885855,
0.7082037926,
0.0203997474,
-0.6837905049,
0.8987278342,
-0.559927702,
-0.6374036074,
0.285892874,
-0.3620434105,
-0.5283105969,
-0.1640655845,
-0.2024274468,
0.6689094901,
0.0970581025,
0.2392632812,
-0.1199846044,
-0.5586851835,
0.5927135944,
-0.6155841947,
0.475808382,
0.0446043015,
-0.7372047901,
0.1963012516,
-0.5075837374,
0.1347719282,
-0.2912302017,
-0.6760661602,
-0.4093105197,
0.0635769442,
-0.4300958514,
0.1777941287,
0.1049700528,
-0.5359133482,
0.1640261114,
-0.4019921422,
0.0060249879,
0.8716546893,
0.0302169099,
0.486954838,
-0.2181425542,
0.5565448999,
-0.0487548597,
0.038083151,
-0.3863252699,
-0.4133664072,
-0.6668285728,
-0.3893575668,
0.4085537791,
0.1979832351,
-0.6540638804,
0.1158904061,
-0.1909174323,
-0.3791596293,
-0.3081700504,
0.0948328748,
0.6466292739,
0.5622597337,
0.2289867997,
-0.1584094167,
-0.0559178181,
-1.0944821835,
-0.2382741719,
0.0789417848,
-0.0003999362,
0.2291760594,
0.3514917493,
0.1121224314,
0.6478765607,
-0.1856986582,
-0.3029850125,
-0.3247802258,
0.2622502446,
0.1193605438,
0.3929821551,
0.254520148,
-0.7169950008,
-0.6666573286,
0.1453166902,
-0.6628155708,
-0.0281720422,
-0.2008976787,
-0.0315116532,
0.3422487676,
0.4680715799,
0.1501072943,
0.5880512595,
0.302696228,
-0.0560105629,
0.2379858792,
-0.321637094,
0.1944380254,
-0.5707696676,
-0.3430493176,
0.2062218487,
-0.1981503367,
-0.4171349406,
0.0593075939,
0.2180501372,
0.2565119565,
-0.755458951,
0.5092715025,
-0.2355583608,
-0.1815370321,
-0.374992311,
0.1101932377,
-0.4428819418,
0.504014492,
0.134892121,
0.8635731339,
0.5431080461,
-0.9330568314,
-0.3024315238,
-0.0501033626,
-0.6403714418,
0.2736260295,
-0.3233489394,
-0.015612484,
-0.0123375366,
0.0856961012,
-1.3531755209,
-0.0337971523,
0.1851063222,
-0.2174791098,
0.4519419372,
-0.2237093449,
-0.4619157016,
0.0687271878,
-0.2929343879,
0.3094856739,
0.4398596287,
-0.8387954831,
0.1034984291,
0.4478445947,
-0.0158473961,
-0.6212271452,
-0.6385912299,
-0.12232811,
-0.5780940652,
-0.2268544286,
0.4140840173,
-0.0072827847,
-0.1921171546,
-0.3098906875,
-0.0993632749,
0.1320102066,
0.3070212007,
0.536878407,
-0.0201614462,
0.1829545051,
0.4692381918,
0.2799052298,
-0.3257425427,
-0.0502929799,
-0.2564262152,
0.2038349509,
-0.1570050865,
-0.4834489226,
-0.2244311571,
0.3571017683,
0.2270095348,
0.0650453269,
0.685575664,
0.4805420041,
-0.1135222167,
-0.099754706,
-0.2580060065,
-0.1174071804,
-0.4546353817,
0.2482309788,
-0.5074505806,
-0.8046017885,
-0.0526464544,
-0.4300251305,
0.3998533189,
0.2489478737,
0.4924644828,
-0.000846347,
0.9696049094,
0.7441455722,
0.059448678,
0.4767227471,
-0.4342079163,
0.1872937083,
-0.8210748434,
-0.4029249251,
-0.4730184972,
-0.5128974319,
-0.6622259021,
-0.2724245191,
0.7888978124,
-0.0237230156,
-0.3215072751,
0.1076861918,
-0.4481610358,
0.4469104707,
0.7095265985,
0.0546587259,
0.3342700601,
0.2507050633,
-0.2217479199,
-0.2639427185,
-0.8258535266,
-0.7242673635,
1.0646436214,
0.2806188464,
0.7239014506,
0.084942542,
0.9786632657,
0.2647346258,
0.9596034288,
-0.9585924149,
0.523314178,
-0.2570113242,
-0.1098937765,
-0.6051368117,
-0.032810688,
-1.0892595053,
0.5536004305,
0.0152506931,
-0.8623781204,
0.0484062918,
0.1382704228,
-0.1226822659,
0.1852013916,
-0.745311141,
0.8068168759,
-0.3740185499,
-0.5512986183,
-0.3104982972,
-0.5961111188,
0.3905429542,
0.0067964774,
0.2544544339,
0.0517223664,
-0.0729673803,
0.8766087294,
-0.117615737,
1.0028665066,
-0.1345715523,
-0.2112256438,
0.1094513312,
-0.1153584793,
0.4002636969,
0.0614079051,
-0.0100200465,
0.0893165842,
-0.1515902132,
-0.2350970805,
-0.3508864343,
0.8978008032,
-0.5153468847,
-0.7269144654,
-0.4075298905,
-0.4289693236,
-0.1827194095,
-0.0912048444,
0.5121001005,
0.627650857,
0.0794649124,
0.4499975443,
0.759763658,
-0.3826223612,
0.6202409863,
0.4023920596,
-0.0698844269,
-0.0589514337,
0.9308888316,
0.3591270149,
0.5243176818,
0.6110687852,
0.377584815,
-0.4695844352,
-0.4138409197,
-0.4042851031,
-0.0728638396,
-1.0493046045,
-0.2010944486,
-0.6006895304,
-0.0417227745,
0.0429086983,
-0.4271644354,
-0.0920382068,
-0.3208777606,
-0.0832552016,
-0.1594742537,
-0.0095704282,
0.6423816085,
0.0426070206,
0.1440662891,
-0.3714499176,
-0.0457990579,
0.5728344917,
0.2012804896,
0.1687385887,
-0.6735063195,
-0.4705302417,
-0.011898159,
-0.6429775953,
-0.7636398077,
0.2455198914,
0.0058139074,
0.8625259399,
0.2510490417,
0.0267128665,
0.634996891,
-0.4104069769,
0.7390272617,
0.2271984965,
-0.8969120383,
0.4361701012,
0.1700307578,
0.2718786299,
0.3363941014,
0.5600860119,
-0.3741913736,
-0.562949717,
-0.567132473,
-1.0092368126,
0.7986756563,
-0.0818962827,
0.1916920692,
-0.0734954774,
0.1581744701,
0.4900329113,
0.2568252683,
-0.869620502,
-0.6285005808,
-0.0815322474,
0.147817269,
-0.2247361392,
-0.2578659356,
-0.271810472,
-0.313421905,
0.655821383,
-0.2183772475,
0.191943258,
0.0795704722,
-0.2937384844,
0.1665246636,
0.6226776838,
0.5764297843,
0.6815445423,
-0.0141515704,
0.3043306172,
0.252815336,
0.017726725,
0.5888206959,
-0.1248538196,
-0.1953950822,
-0.074167043,
0.3323637247,
0.8943787813,
0.6326306462,
-0.5535060167,
0.4456191361,
0.2876702249,
-0.2572666705,
-0.2214991003,
0.0511494577,
-0.0463892594,
0.2045387924,
0.3935352564,
-0.1470847428,
0.325953573,
-0.590334475,
0.3310978115,
0.4926814139,
-0.3926746249,
0.0338997133,
0.4230528772,
-0.1580827683,
-0.3415699899,
0.2390140146,
-0.2987447679,
-0.3429694772,
0.6774560809,
0.6908479333,
0.6898010969,
0.0342958495,
0.4668125808,
0.3202091157,
0.0784660131,
0.156656906,
-0.2717639208,
-0.4367370009,
-0.5217195749,
-0.5412505269,
-0.4048458636,
-0.4974121153,
0.1300353557,
-0.6159276366,
0.0501284115,
-0.1245707944,
-0.0485083573,
0.2698601484,
-0.0898514688,
-0.6641306877,
0.0668451488,
0.098103188,
0.6789891124,
-0.7542182207,
0.9757947326,
0.7856462002,
-0.2748540044,
-0.8485905528,
0.2110800296,
-0.1900383532,
-0.5544585586,
1.2216938734,
0.2707749009,
-0.1871207058,
-0.0085739344,
-0.6617790461,
-0.8759490252,
1.0295981169,
0.327904731,
-0.17125009,
0.6997161508,
-0.0505825505,
0.3108087182,
-0.6545023322,
0.1073615402,
0.38952443,
0.5539601445,
0.2276041657,
-0.6263116598,
-0.1013262197,
0.1982793957,
0.009836914,
0.1954806149,
-0.5208426118,
0.5624551177,
-0.4450258315,
-0.2531970441,
-0.0282491054,
0.5135996938,
0.5346003771,
0.5456545949,
0.5474813581,
0.1538862884,
0.6207648516,
-0.1726033539,
1.4347279072,
0.2189453542,
0.1681153476,
0.9854550362,
-0.0305728484,
0.7427614331,
0.6556705832,
-0.3677730858,
0.6352726817,
0.6318415999,
0.4081491232,
0.7839035988,
0.3365586996,
-0.3271467388,
-0.3514005244,
-0.2440149933,
-0.3018014133,
0.1840619445,
0.2015735358,
-0.2211103439,
-0.2794479728,
0.3524700999,
-0.0169021916,
0.040536914,
-0.2716016769,
0.8088618517,
0.0363856331,
-0.9074813724,
0.7680404782,
-0.0117772231,
0.6578577161,
-0.6525499225,
-0.3010650575,
-0.2017960697,
0.2226185352,
-0.0878611878,
-0.9593697786,
-0.0595442019,
-0.2263394296,
-0.072696954,
-0.4151606858,
0.4241780043,
-0.4997836649,
-0.2955846488,
0.099480629,
0.1481968313,
0.3396977782,
0.2512169182,
-0.2283565998,
-0.1350040436,
0.1274619401,
0.0017914723,
0.9984408617,
0.2875878811,
-0.2404250801,
0.8890405893,
0.4029862285,
-0.1839610934,
0.2138777971,
0.0214442257,
0.6369953156,
-0.3960781395,
-0.4223606586,
-0.7947911024,
0.6366060376,
-0.0172987785,
-0.1745899618,
0.9679650664,
0.3870718479,
1.0247199535,
-0.1187797785,
0.8017658591,
0.0791881531,
0.2467345893,
-0.615573585,
0.0629910454,
-0.7338894606,
0.368163377,
-0.0945780426,
-0.3744881153,
-0.1408195794,
0.5457243323,
-0.3948989213,
-0.1522650123,
0.8128479719,
0.359793812,
0.1464884877,
-0.3208771646,
0.6116318703,
-0.2276901901,
0.234894231,
0.512237668,
0.8481377363,
-0.2285222113,
0.3994959891,
-0.4724354446,
-0.4007678926,
-0.0862692595,
-0.9460193515,
-0.6241497993,
-0.5793136358,
-0.4648577571,
-0.1283224225,
-0.0755135044,
0.9103723168,
0.719235301,
-0.6557682157,
-0.4920681417,
0.2831916213,
0.5455176234,
-0.6550722122,
-0.2004131079,
0.4310532212,
-0.7654514909,
-0.8833578229,
0.3552521765,
0.4892420173,
0.0075233271,
-0.1773290783,
-0.2476702929,
-0.117476739,
-0.2750328779,
0.8162330985,
0.2528308034,
-0.7716001868,
-0.2322935611,
-0.3347033262,
-0.0050447509,
0.1557466239,
0.9631301165,
-1.0253665447,
0.4014087319,
0.1420083195,
0.6879429221,
0.6159880161,
-0.0766600594,
0.3719445467,
-1.0220142603,
0.2574680746,
-0.0660080537,
0.3491458595,
0.3194839954,
-0.4584950209,
0.4164464474,
-0.1768527329,
-0.5895379186,
-0.6050015688,
0.2420589924,
-0.5673982501,
-0.2925315201,
1.3000273705,
-0.3244281709,
0.0825144798,
-0.0886039436,
-0.1218049526,
0.1052079722,
-0.3797856867,
0.7546745539,
0.6475117207,
-0.2507962584,
-0.0814313889,
-0.4962282181,
0.4373719096,
0.3676075637,
-0.6370659471,
-0.1367257237,
0.289423883,
0.3374270201,
0.0766705573,
0.6396814585,
-0.0799299553,
0.1535586417,
-0.3605787456,
-0.1550444812,
0.0181929823,
-0.4311432242,
-0.5173483491,
0.457624346,
0.4012656212,
-0.5493066907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09618v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09618v4
|
Simulating Opinion Dynamics with Networks of LLM-based Agents
| 2023-11-16T07:01:48 | 2024-04-01T01:12:35 |
Yun-Shiuan Chuang, Agam Goyal, Nikunj Harlalka, Siddharth Suresh, Robert Hawkins, Sijia Yang, Dhavan Shah, Junjie Hu, Timothy T. Rogers
|
physics.soc-ph
|
physics.soc-ph, cs.CL
|
Accurately simulating human opinion dynamics is crucial for understanding a
variety of societal phenomena, including polarization and the spread of
misinformation. However, the agent-based models (ABMs) commonly used for such
simulations often over-simplify human behavior. We propose a new approach to
simulating opinion dynamics based on populations of Large Language Models
(LLMs). Our findings reveal a strong inherent bias in LLM agents towards
producing accurate information, leading simulated agents to consensus in line
with scientific reality. This bias limits their utility for understanding
resistance to consensus views on issues like climate change. After inducing
confirmation bias through prompt engineering, however, we observed opinion
fragmentation in line with existing agent-based modeling and opinion dynamics
research. These insights highlight the promise and limitations of LLM agents in
this domain and suggest a path forward: refining LLMs with real-world discourse
to better simulate the evolution of human beliefs.
|
[
-0.6663265228,
-0.7433153987,
0.690630734,
-0.0337671861,
-0.0249619428,
0.3231716156,
-0.2876913846,
-0.2546222508,
0.5038554072,
0.5907331109,
-0.6213883758,
-0.2487090081,
-0.2399642318,
-0.0456019938,
-0.1243705153,
0.7726786733,
0.1477589458,
0.2194885463,
-0.3592981398,
0.0267865546,
0.0036133861,
-0.6088841558,
-0.3950482011,
-0.9994931817,
0.4936721027,
0.1156102642,
1.0036524534,
0.4011108875,
-0.0713496208,
0.2999829948,
-0.3044260442,
0.3640399277,
-0.6484103799,
0.1635063291,
-0.3585604429,
-0.4214785099,
-0.4025926292,
0.4872560799,
0.5893951058,
0.7634823918,
-0.1070658788,
-0.1127649695,
0.1671800315,
0.3678616881,
-0.2542749941,
0.27010566,
-0.5613740087,
-0.1481970996,
0.3376250565,
-0.2540731728,
-0.5188339949,
-0.3037316203,
0.1668851376,
-0.5020322204,
0.2564806044,
0.2642598152,
0.6462477446,
0.0594640337,
-0.6182330251,
-0.1589745134,
-0.9194394946,
0.8613612056,
-0.7074550986,
0.1593463123,
-0.0584113672,
0.075615406,
-0.4947378039,
-0.131457001,
-0.791846633,
-0.2911227345,
0.332295835,
0.1956878752,
0.0603755824,
0.2644386292,
0.0933553427,
-0.2895698249,
-0.141109705,
0.0590144396,
-0.1576682031,
-0.0129828481,
0.7139524817,
0.2295983583,
0.1869349182,
-0.1387759447,
-0.3519995809,
-0.3636198044,
-0.7570512891,
-0.117679134,
0.5725596547,
0.3867841363,
-0.0871025622,
0.351931572,
-0.147988975,
0.2939097583,
0.2065350711,
-0.11607939,
0.3100055158,
0.0861723572,
-0.2051319331,
-0.0240509305,
0.7052944303,
0.7522146106,
0.1790761352,
0.1039009094,
0.0369043984,
0.1230817214,
0.3414338827,
-0.7101347446,
0.0283873621,
0.2739571035,
-0.63299793,
-0.5928068757,
-0.0634763092,
-0.9307821989,
-0.9085941911,
-0.4664368629,
0.0280180946,
-0.083043918,
-0.5820535421,
0.1982164979,
-0.1301166862,
0.1528576314,
0.8819631934,
-0.2442778647,
0.2935768962,
0.8846027851,
0.7398585081,
-0.1920523793,
-0.427729696,
0.0973926187,
-0.0364803709,
-0.475433737,
0.890489161,
-0.6071041822,
-0.6435474157,
-0.0665868893,
-0.1022064313,
0.2063425481,
-0.7095090747,
0.0083481101,
-0.670912087,
-0.1389416605,
-0.6210438609,
-0.6821540594,
-0.1894353479,
0.5395278335,
-0.6082631946,
0.5364217758,
-0.2874727249,
-0.5305802226,
0.2955707908,
-0.6927772164,
-0.0417099781,
-0.3004944324,
-0.199285239,
-0.1051938757,
-0.0295750964,
0.0509586371,
0.2093615085,
-0.4421362281,
0.3622734845,
-0.8337816596,
-0.0660579279,
0.5244370699,
-0.5302565694,
0.6353244185,
0.3689344525,
-0.2429352552,
0.1649711728,
-0.1576323807,
-0.2663891613,
-0.1551138759,
-0.0925022736,
-0.1551692784,
0.3061716557,
-0.0915669873,
0.2159132063,
-0.0410650522,
-0.6114263535,
0.607137382,
-0.3525255322,
0.3047221601,
1.0053375959,
0.3931145072,
0.7416347861,
-0.6405453086,
0.6440908313,
0.2781859338,
0.129024297,
0.1508849263,
-0.5521286726,
-0.7282265425,
0.1068101972,
-0.0310484599,
0.3722777665,
-0.7945279479,
-0.117654115,
-0.3537958562,
-0.39933303,
-0.4954100847,
0.0149796121,
-0.0153517937,
0.2971482873,
0.2271443158,
-0.1551028043,
-0.3784960508,
-0.7095632553,
-0.4181737006,
-0.8011573553,
0.1805436164,
0.309871316,
0.4203126431,
-0.2351204306,
1.2583462,
-0.2241169512,
0.2514991462,
-0.4424537718,
0.3063657284,
0.1323293447,
0.1986207962,
0.475397706,
-0.5940278172,
0.0113870651,
-0.0458738059,
-0.5617088675,
-0.1121692732,
-0.2894184589,
-0.0232250895,
0.2366243005,
0.267683357,
-0.7030481696,
0.1490245312,
0.4222723544,
-0.233132109,
0.6126414537,
0.0312748961,
0.3337475061,
-1.0860711336,
-0.2805469334,
0.3951995373,
-0.3727501035,
-0.55626297,
-0.1006922647,
-0.5142230988,
0.1829215437,
-0.6516262293,
0.8351479769,
-0.6468569636,
0.0779779777,
-0.6666573286,
0.0701301694,
-0.0921153948,
0.2509855032,
0.149392873,
0.6451762915,
0.1881380081,
-0.4323028624,
0.5092514157,
-0.0555828363,
-0.3245816231,
0.2773316205,
-0.4222864211,
0.0705009624,
-0.5729076266,
0.5852215886,
-0.4692271948,
-0.3916873932,
0.1537813693,
-0.1417119056,
-0.0178401135,
-0.360309124,
-0.4273153841,
-0.3141029775,
-0.3452660441,
0.2863554657,
0.7954252362,
-0.4877192676,
0.8604692817,
0.556915462,
-0.0791552886,
-0.5344080925,
-0.524841547,
0.1374637932,
-0.2061397731,
-0.5135170221,
-0.0557339378,
-0.0765167996,
-0.9399328232,
-0.0675725341,
0.1135261431,
0.250410676,
-0.1705695242,
0.3836466968,
0.028141655,
0.0962809548,
0.1526165754,
0.0297277905,
0.3149797022,
0.3240669668,
-0.3706056178,
0.4404453039,
-0.1090982929,
-0.5576418638,
-0.2410864979,
0.1932477206,
0.8967553377,
0.4633278549,
0.6541111469,
-0.2500931919,
-0.2002487332,
-0.720474422,
-0.6184465289,
-0.512478292,
-0.4996746182,
0.4255809784,
0.0031686469,
-0.7155194879,
0.535666883,
-0.5090681911,
0.2023634166,
0.0406599566,
0.8752080202,
-0.1990250945,
1.0438468456,
0.2424057722,
-0.3523074389,
0.3369150758,
-0.2281091809,
-0.0160430651,
-0.5431931615,
-0.0852359086,
-0.3799719512,
-0.3185651302,
-0.3816066682,
-0.8361883163,
0.2830590308,
-0.1541075408,
-0.1487252414,
-0.2599887252,
-0.1659529656,
0.5927472711,
0.2180958986,
0.1943400055,
0.0097753415,
0.1212466657,
-0.1575489342,
0.1485588551,
-0.6192388535,
-0.9052917361,
0.7169446349,
0.435017705,
1.0525962114,
-0.1931964904,
0.4032595158,
0.7124875188,
0.9022663236,
-0.716604948,
0.6843286753,
0.4233262837,
-0.6202653646,
-0.2319931835,
-0.5019955039,
-0.7098044753,
0.3806530237,
-0.2479103655,
-0.4330402613,
0.4165123999,
0.389452368,
0.0051532374,
0.7033747435,
-0.389957577,
0.5246832371,
0.1857843101,
-0.3198355138,
-0.4180444181,
-0.5490939021,
0.1528947353,
0.2663024366,
0.6421854496,
-0.3757810295,
0.1096188426,
0.4233945608,
-0.8772076368,
1.3988543749,
-0.3536471426,
-0.1548976749,
0.7177683115,
0.1520783156,
0.6070700884,
0.0560299233,
-0.6182282567,
0.0599913187,
-0.4723852277,
-0.4868157208,
-0.6732110977,
0.6456469297,
-1.2274070978,
-0.8769227862,
-0.3431273401,
-0.4641082585,
-0.1785879731,
-0.1808713078,
0.0266740508,
0.1893579662,
-0.5373718739,
-0.2797500491,
0.6087331772,
0.0434397943,
0.2703581154,
0.3927927613,
-0.3597224951,
-0.4416180253,
0.6631494761,
0.2380938828,
0.3883230388,
0.0065923571,
0.2887634933,
-0.1170485765,
-0.5516218543,
-0.2095390707,
0.175133571,
-0.7621923685,
-0.0077936631,
-0.6528557539,
-0.032981053,
-0.290874809,
-0.2146838605,
-0.3564880788,
-0.2244470268,
-0.2625002861,
-0.446770221,
0.365636766,
1.0077476501,
0.0490354113,
0.4107334614,
-0.4253251255,
-0.0650373846,
0.2701541185,
0.0372391939,
0.1538047642,
-0.3236095905,
-0.1772453636,
0.4625167549,
-0.3265756071,
-1.1251021624,
0.6332417727,
-0.0948880762,
0.3767869473,
0.4654105008,
0.320545882,
0.4269717336,
-0.2631177902,
1.0515971184,
0.0129028792,
-0.8960912228,
0.1990791708,
-0.5691291094,
0.1932976991,
0.2890214622,
0.159518525,
-0.4848639071,
-0.6488138437,
-0.6028541327,
-0.5295127034,
0.5548093915,
-0.0606028177,
0.1535303742,
-0.2007484287,
0.4637955725,
0.1892187893,
0.2399325371,
-0.5361071825,
-0.2083421499,
-0.2771372199,
-0.1234792694,
-0.1288003922,
-0.1587763429,
-0.1387891769,
0.1326660067,
0.8678596616,
-0.357578516,
0.0191416703,
0.4157295823,
0.0559369139,
-0.2260593921,
0.3407162428,
0.6450048685,
0.4670757055,
-0.0502413139,
0.2805300951,
0.379052341,
-0.4187153578,
0.4876554906,
-0.485452652,
-0.6225479245,
0.0437362492,
0.129782185,
0.8117117882,
-0.3310256004,
-0.5075087547,
0.4944969714,
-0.0327376723,
-0.2359061241,
-0.1687390059,
-0.0733251348,
0.2795492709,
0.3811858594,
0.3541888297,
0.5386098623,
0.0274305679,
-0.8138851523,
-0.0303827077,
0.4961986244,
-0.5050951242,
-0.6390783787,
0.5937406421,
0.50187397,
-0.2188791633,
0.2019717395,
-0.257211864,
-0.5119718313,
1.0221760273,
0.2606423497,
0.8645855784,
-0.0865686983,
0.3167499304,
-0.0229224339,
0.4966314435,
-0.5706520081,
0.1528741717,
0.2799611688,
-1.1058071852,
-0.5060982704,
-0.4999250174,
-0.8350274563,
-0.1796612442,
-0.2982234955,
0.23253645,
-0.5208346248,
-0.6182718873,
-0.3387765884,
-0.1994664967,
-0.3152152896,
0.0559958331,
0.1517824829,
0.7821873426,
-0.8995606303,
0.8679540753,
0.9773272872,
-0.0682580024,
-0.7360884547,
0.1787510961,
0.3014245629,
-0.48951298,
0.4670577049,
0.0317125171,
-0.5056481361,
-0.4076589942,
-1.0183683634,
-0.5218496323,
0.8759380579,
0.5343809128,
-0.4473635256,
-0.0173497517,
0.0720645338,
0.6695245504,
-0.7394627333,
0.5246904492,
0.2075793594,
0.4118812978,
0.1091381758,
-0.7654848695,
0.0174336489,
-0.2626540363,
-0.0240543745,
-0.0553956404,
-1.0854190588,
0.767285645,
-0.2668452859,
-0.0333390534,
-0.2142023444,
0.9704014063,
0.4690473974,
0.4554208815,
0.7592705488,
0.1128496006,
0.6545599699,
0.2394141704,
1.0260145664,
-0.4988358915,
0.5190747976,
0.9550474286,
-0.7985010147,
0.5531999469,
0.4827264845,
0.0253574345,
0.6075384021,
0.5639021993,
0.1976488978,
0.1623094678,
0.5021491051,
-0.3931774795,
-0.6282106042,
-0.282102406,
-0.1650433093,
0.105860211,
0.2602386475,
-0.0724631101,
0.0960471705,
-0.0193939228,
0.0317205191,
0.1197000667,
-0.5060602427,
0.7367545962,
0.2288731933,
-0.6543874145,
0.2294650525,
-0.128431201,
0.6895350814,
-0.1830614358,
-0.1155525446,
-0.063725993,
-0.196332857,
-0.0302557368,
-0.6685789227,
-0.0431365333,
-0.0221610982,
-0.4205572307,
-0.5075833797,
0.6092322469,
-0.3100994527,
-0.3383051157,
0.3533435464,
0.6543453336,
0.2474788725,
0.1363582909,
-0.410032779,
0.0501881465,
-0.0004469453,
-0.7272846699,
0.2446524352,
0.323394388,
-0.1446184218,
0.9692835808,
0.542337656,
0.2342327088,
0.0564031787,
0.1387521178,
1.0385239124,
-0.5864644051,
-0.4720158577,
-0.8982549906,
0.0350394025,
-0.293739289,
0.1985898465,
0.482766062,
0.2995232046,
0.672772944,
-0.0873326808,
1.1782376766,
0.4059890807,
0.4708699584,
-0.3466353416,
0.951058805,
-0.4418462813,
0.4853976071,
-0.2433673441,
-0.8426202536,
0.1225700304,
0.2391255945,
-0.2411101609,
0.3157232702,
0.4287965894,
0.8726915121,
0.3316628039,
0.1358134449,
0.2047760934,
0.7133626938,
0.4014282227,
0.0853157043,
1.0605003834,
0.1999125779,
0.244650349,
-0.0030916706,
-0.1748297215,
-0.2275317609,
-0.8189989328,
-1.0182106495,
-0.1278908998,
-0.337990284,
-0.7496707439,
0.1309811771,
1.6807409525,
0.7775545716,
-0.649540484,
-0.4787310362,
-0.0380899757,
0.3279552162,
-0.0682737678,
-0.2460845709,
-0.1230774522,
0.0098068519,
-0.7475172281,
0.4160096645,
0.1844432652,
0.1983951181,
-0.6164000034,
-0.2724160552,
0.1740732938,
0.7564322948,
0.4097124934,
0.3767686188,
-0.891854167,
-0.3779471219,
-0.1331710666,
-0.1304300725,
0.0918411016,
0.8221024871,
-0.9738642573,
0.5085647702,
0.602537334,
0.2234421521,
0.1319743991,
0.3945416212,
0.9139624834,
-0.463111341,
0.1136011258,
0.2431059331,
0.3518769443,
0.2298850864,
-0.1606590748,
0.1027166843,
0.4103533626,
-0.6630662084,
-0.7549061775,
0.444411099,
-0.9017073512,
-0.3960503042,
1.4174674749,
0.0880122185,
-0.5360633135,
-0.1527296305,
-0.2589293718,
0.0018090827,
-1.0051141977,
0.8994184732,
0.7138871551,
-0.2172469944,
-0.1530694067,
-0.2580733299,
0.4072807133,
0.2818921208,
-0.7794812322,
0.3293608129,
0.6569288969,
0.2980343997,
0.1424839348,
0.6532456279,
0.3013135791,
-0.1061582789,
0.0155141037,
0.3628730476,
0.0402008928,
-0.2673029602,
-0.3193358183,
0.4240449965,
0.2874772251,
0.5142939091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09615v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09615v2
|
On Retrieval Augmentation and the Limitations of Language Model Training
| 2023-11-16T06:59:54 | 2024-04-02T06:23:23 |
Ting-Rui Chiang, Xinyan Velocity Yu, Joshua Robinson, Ollie Liu, Isabelle Lee, Dani Yogatama
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Augmenting a language model (LM) with $k$-nearest neighbors ($k$NN) retrieval
on its training data alone can decrease its perplexity, though the underlying
reasons for this remain elusive. In this work, we rule out one previously
posited possibility -- the "softmax bottleneck." We then create a new dataset
to evaluate LM generalization ability in the setting where training data
contains additional information that is not causally relevant. This task is
challenging even for GPT-3.5 Turbo. We show that, for both GPT-2 and Mistral
7B, $k$NN retrieval augmentation consistently improves performance in this
setting. Finally, to make $k$NN retrieval more accessible, we propose using a
multi-layer perceptron model that maps datastore keys to values as a drop-in
replacement for traditional retrieval. This reduces storage costs by over 25x.
|
[
-0.3247353137,
-0.580010891,
0.5477347374,
-0.1910283118,
-0.0618730113,
-0.0195097532,
-0.4136538208,
-0.4597651064,
-0.3932874501,
0.5041808486,
-0.4480436146,
-0.15474388,
-0.514870882,
0.1380575895,
-0.3607949615,
0.8968651295,
0.2211120874,
-0.1243895218,
0.061921183,
-0.1823178083,
-0.4614013135,
-0.7911245823,
-0.3691149652,
-0.408534646,
0.4223400354,
0.414747417,
0.9948159456,
0.634452045,
0.5579203963,
0.3353853524,
-0.3006530702,
0.0463624634,
-0.675490737,
0.1546035856,
0.2114190459,
-0.6594932079,
-0.2492875308,
-0.280390799,
0.7492896318,
0.831859231,
-0.0257116482,
-0.2433255017,
-0.1018443927,
0.7954239845,
-0.6621618271,
0.0267716255,
-0.8512480855,
0.1588227004,
-0.2579236329,
0.1599590331,
-0.1605502367,
-0.264528513,
0.4915381372,
-0.5441706777,
0.5989675522,
-0.2784154117,
0.8432605863,
0.1218155026,
-0.3321987092,
0.0744090378,
-0.777267158,
0.6455340385,
-0.5695203543,
0.6339858174,
0.3989168108,
0.2783761919,
-0.0296549015,
-0.495028466,
-0.5680086613,
-0.4833285809,
0.0152365463,
-0.2154098749,
-0.0310807135,
0.1090163663,
0.5712940097,
0.7032371163,
-0.471180886,
-0.146057114,
-0.5231605172,
-0.2183609307,
0.3388882875,
0.1703187674,
0.0562961139,
-0.1640701592,
-0.1126507372,
-0.2004112452,
-0.7778840661,
-0.1623249948,
0.4514914453,
0.520476222,
0.3745385706,
0.4448144734,
-0.3076631725,
0.4626246095,
-0.1299054325,
0.1557699442,
0.5749934316,
-0.5008051395,
0.0115525564,
-0.2229615003,
0.3777045608,
0.1416610181,
0.2161345929,
-0.4442875981,
-0.3418379724,
-0.2852577269,
0.1615097076,
-0.8145571947,
-0.2472562194,
-0.0773752257,
-0.1480981708,
-0.0925600454,
0.1138587594,
-0.2170031518,
-0.2672164738,
-0.1728821993,
0.4846815169,
-0.4290580451,
-0.4655380547,
-0.0673633739,
-0.2695703804,
0.2960019112,
0.056160301,
-0.8165863156,
0.4135540724,
0.7822059989,
0.9808465242,
0.0100618936,
-0.1898682117,
-0.1515209079,
-0.080648005,
-0.3526439965,
0.5279102921,
-0.8185334206,
-0.468203485,
0.0354216732,
0.0851884931,
0.0086923176,
-0.9468432665,
0.3663801849,
-0.6449092627,
0.1258739829,
-0.4010396004,
-0.5773339868,
-0.140982002,
-0.0209293235,
-0.9232364893,
1.0672039986,
0.3563651741,
-0.4617877901,
0.2283169329,
-0.406999737,
-0.4465177953,
0.1537864953,
-0.051884789,
-0.3003783822,
0.5008757114,
0.2546147704,
0.1713617444,
-0.1599170715,
0.0307832826,
-0.4032925963,
-0.6354315877,
-0.0093309386,
-0.4482721984,
0.4319442213,
0.1959718615,
-0.1618122309,
-0.4286144078,
-0.5781103969,
0.0077987909,
0.1230486408,
-0.490691036,
-0.3907164037,
-0.2587122917,
-0.1394507438,
0.0143706324,
0.2589559853,
-0.365426302,
0.6341122389,
-0.6470183134,
0.3671378493,
0.6426135898,
-0.3473458588,
0.5883890986,
-0.1010675728,
0.5160895586,
-0.0609397963,
0.1253136694,
-0.1712488085,
-0.3043906093,
-0.6204864979,
0.1463629752,
0.4546687901,
0.557292521,
-0.8895666599,
0.0013404196,
-0.4048537612,
-0.2318951935,
-0.6298886538,
0.3400557637,
0.4523132741,
0.5228512883,
0.3927142918,
-0.3425454199,
-0.393090874,
-1.1494482756,
-0.2973764539,
0.1071766242,
-0.0898133889,
0.5600315928,
0.278324604,
-0.0895845816,
0.7110349536,
-0.4676388204,
-0.1111516804,
-0.298299253,
-0.0237260628,
0.5829366446,
0.4986418486,
0.1614152789,
-0.8869767189,
-0.4926395714,
0.0772903934,
-0.4685961902,
-0.1952189505,
0.2991622984,
0.2767866552,
0.0988607928,
0.4611702561,
-0.7271220088,
0.4071063697,
0.2156966478,
0.1343524754,
0.4179798365,
-0.3335741758,
-0.0289686806,
-0.6952528954,
0.0054260134,
-0.2079654932,
-0.108918801,
-1.068261981,
0.1212864071,
0.295696795,
-0.1997176707,
-0.1799212694,
0.5085885525,
-0.491371572,
-0.0388189666,
-0.4759233594,
0.0886592567,
-0.1259169728,
0.3983433545,
0.0854448453,
0.9744378328,
0.3835442662,
-0.6114747524,
0.0978188068,
0.049432952,
-0.1901793629,
0.2811084986,
-0.6021031141,
0.4726500213,
-0.4009806514,
0.2996482551,
-0.7527567148,
-0.1155345514,
-0.1806049645,
-0.3487430215,
0.4641432166,
-0.4937331975,
-0.5127106905,
-0.3366157711,
-0.415671885,
0.6167645454,
0.4869520068,
-0.5967128873,
0.2693119347,
0.1161333099,
-0.0874369889,
-0.7592641711,
-0.6717188358,
0.0565589592,
-0.0046245726,
-0.5560082793,
0.2542900145,
-0.0130466474,
0.0576515347,
-0.0129379248,
-0.3653822243,
-0.1776353717,
0.005999682,
-0.0522887036,
0.1457559019,
-0.3170682192,
0.42589432,
-0.098320581,
-0.1942165792,
-0.2857320607,
-0.3524521291,
0.3794274926,
-0.2218335569,
-0.1881351769,
-0.0004526543,
0.2725750804,
0.1665286273,
0.1251578033,
0.64886415,
0.6960561275,
-0.4387648106,
0.119539097,
-0.8338438869,
-0.2679233849,
-0.5290967226,
0.7664072514,
-0.6965380907,
-1.2080509663,
0.5307680964,
0.0715965405,
-0.3344931304,
0.4101604819,
0.2805998027,
0.3436193764,
1.1577470303,
0.5797049403,
-0.266959101,
0.5851012468,
-0.397749126,
0.2555165291,
-1.1520917416,
-0.2073128968,
-0.4496227205,
-0.1181080267,
-0.8444675803,
-0.3501894176,
0.3956474066,
0.2883476913,
-0.1825875342,
0.4243543148,
-0.4993156493,
0.8775764108,
0.4888850451,
0.3264792562,
0.4420436621,
0.1116935685,
-0.1939684004,
-0.065172188,
-0.935877502,
-0.0756521523,
1.2792308331,
0.3555060923,
0.4714357555,
0.333268553,
0.3891183436,
-0.1048998758,
0.3677208722,
-0.4733030796,
0.4641213417,
-0.4340711236,
-0.8790842891,
-0.331961602,
-0.8740641475,
-1.0101747513,
0.4902624488,
0.0765814409,
-0.713378489,
0.2323767096,
0.1243447661,
-0.2201078236,
0.2403550446,
-0.8634861112,
0.5558111668,
-0.0158491321,
-0.4584233761,
-0.1029553339,
-0.5774403214,
0.3813602626,
-0.1313286722,
0.0307194218,
-0.0105021587,
-0.2288582623,
0.2880598009,
-0.7716908455,
0.292524308,
-0.3750114441,
-0.0072887167,
0.0705873668,
-0.0365003161,
0.5777239203,
-0.1597617418,
-0.1370566338,
-0.015985461,
-0.2523825765,
-0.4704248905,
-0.849563539,
0.8084013462,
-0.6727795005,
-0.666624248,
-0.1904433966,
-0.6246528029,
-0.412127167,
0.0723146051,
0.079028599,
0.4597225189,
0.2550835907,
0.4134294093,
0.6092195511,
-0.2190190107,
0.1941776872,
0.4775101542,
0.0069799623,
-0.3100120723,
1.110260725,
0.3675282598,
0.3946661949,
0.3214009404,
0.4181558788,
-0.6608502865,
-0.6943185329,
-0.0759201571,
0.0829766095,
-0.7367154956,
-0.172494173,
-0.4308022857,
-0.3226307631,
-0.4126879275,
0.3620420992,
-0.3616687953,
-0.6293753386,
-0.0567793213,
-0.0878858119,
0.4479246438,
0.789550364,
-0.2550822198,
0.4760243297,
-0.618678093,
0.0704811588,
0.334379077,
0.5914382339,
0.2832396626,
-0.7261009812,
-0.277232945,
-0.0896727368,
-0.1404918432,
-0.7484743595,
0.1378151625,
0.2828222811,
0.4168354869,
0.2426056415,
-0.349835366,
0.8465898633,
-0.4899903536,
0.5920445323,
-0.0884561911,
-0.6786388159,
0.3097245097,
-0.3466563225,
0.5921813846,
0.7729008794,
0.3924364448,
-0.2873163819,
-0.2729338109,
-0.6334196925,
-1.1114912033,
0.6296158433,
0.3392415345,
0.4899523854,
0.1087297574,
0.8477315307,
-0.0046977163,
0.3450829089,
-0.6465863585,
-0.3030396104,
-0.0677087307,
0.0709668621,
-0.0203939285,
-0.2525723875,
0.4130421877,
-0.560729146,
0.6962513328,
-0.0713131055,
0.1941702366,
0.2807569802,
-0.2306287587,
0.1511740237,
0.1614868343,
0.5030894876,
0.4540799558,
-0.3480603993,
0.0946342349,
0.5152698159,
-0.6847596765,
0.0428229757,
0.3360645771,
-0.2652756572,
-0.0206302144,
0.3118685484,
0.8332877159,
0.1554698646,
-0.4519320726,
0.4605182409,
0.0139649287,
-0.27580899,
-0.0059331227,
0.1133179218,
-0.1446599364,
0.3557868898,
0.6359300613,
-0.294023037,
0.3453926444,
-0.4953861237,
0.2829411626,
0.5016260743,
-0.3600332737,
-0.1241697297,
0.4462905824,
-0.20631437,
-0.2355492413,
0.8470111489,
-0.2337779403,
-0.7715940475,
0.3886522949,
0.4024161696,
0.7421805263,
-0.2313552052,
-0.2293769121,
0.4401315749,
0.3831769824,
-0.2264991999,
0.1659446955,
-0.0994655713,
-0.5969768167,
-0.625382185,
-0.185311839,
-0.2543753088,
0.5782331824,
-0.3551578224,
-0.018828297,
-0.2131049335,
-0.3124804199,
-0.3335787356,
0.2357677072,
-0.7303960323,
-0.0381680056,
-0.0488511994,
0.750293076,
-0.4520419836,
0.760956943,
0.2626449764,
-0.4182810485,
-0.8068957925,
-0.1183189601,
-0.2443024665,
-0.7925797701,
0.5063704848,
0.1899387538,
0.1196195781,
-0.1738103628,
-0.4770772755,
-0.8114508986,
0.9639869332,
0.4729853868,
-0.675332427,
-0.1114418358,
0.2928364277,
0.6667636037,
-0.1667758971,
0.6090857983,
0.6354901195,
0.4588429332,
-0.0226692744,
-0.9851626158,
0.0084101222,
-0.346534878,
0.2721861601,
0.2872912884,
-0.6150482893,
0.9838302732,
-0.0568931699,
-0.1259609312,
0.1829109788,
0.3994771838,
-0.0692966953,
-0.0016942227,
0.5795034766,
0.7039639354,
0.7508389354,
-0.0373011976,
1.3638631105,
-0.1943971813,
0.4520801306,
1.2361924648,
-0.0430126637,
0.6976495385,
0.3213267028,
-0.2657364309,
0.1558767706,
0.3591741025,
-0.0782223493,
0.4820524156,
0.2998928428,
-0.4450890124,
-0.1890072078,
-0.150033921,
-0.6015975475,
0.2283316553,
0.2209551483,
-0.2790618539,
-0.1737130135,
-0.1396595091,
0.0031252003,
-0.1537948102,
-0.1844537705,
0.7073552012,
0.0670983121,
-0.4547634423,
0.7833920717,
-0.1373341084,
0.4907841086,
-0.524768889,
-0.0162228495,
-0.4148233533,
0.2111797035,
-0.1539545953,
-0.5037129521,
0.0908025652,
-0.2214887887,
-0.0140864998,
0.1129638329,
0.9567080736,
-0.5695338845,
-0.4516242445,
0.2216768861,
0.6576505899,
0.2673856318,
-0.3390666246,
-0.6696480513,
0.1416799128,
-0.234602809,
-0.2976386249,
0.4376615584,
0.4495777488,
0.0116094397,
0.7676739693,
0.6806887984,
0.1290367842,
0.1655111462,
0.3883535564,
0.9955399036,
-0.548489809,
0.0293961465,
-0.8579632044,
0.0019437716,
-0.0336243249,
-0.1381732672,
0.650981307,
0.7161748409,
0.9023881555,
0.0015447162,
0.8324931264,
0.1466820538,
0.4602117836,
-0.3852525055,
0.3206272721,
-0.6003723741,
0.4156688452,
-0.2545796633,
-1.0947214365,
-0.2324916571,
0.6850519776,
-0.3935296535,
0.4076557457,
0.5734524727,
1.1586725712,
-0.1909008324,
0.0428175554,
0.3664728105,
0.2784341872,
0.1043234393,
0.8519384861,
0.8238385916,
-0.6238160729,
0.8105546236,
-0.3987799883,
-0.0032735539,
-0.1364695579,
-0.7337574959,
-0.7629227638,
-0.627872169,
-0.06893415,
-0.3754501343,
0.3045315146,
0.6389718652,
0.8253211379,
-0.5815705657,
-0.135586068,
-0.1085375845,
0.2696783245,
0.099444136,
-0.2278588563,
0.2358517945,
-0.5081980228,
-0.5478301048,
0.5003561974,
0.0605929531,
0.0427376218,
-0.3228255808,
-0.1462227106,
-0.1109792516,
-0.2081898451,
0.4305581152,
0.3083827794,
-0.4470211864,
-0.4218666553,
0.0839624926,
0.1044681817,
0.2664827704,
0.9873415232,
-0.7303197384,
0.4626295269,
0.4102573991,
0.8553458452,
0.7962680459,
-0.0779500306,
0.6696428061,
-0.8318662047,
0.0433680527,
0.1082902327,
-0.0296577662,
0.4000072181,
-0.3553284705,
0.5677344799,
0.3513546288,
-0.4454275072,
-0.8948777318,
0.2155266851,
-0.4565944076,
-0.0917686224,
0.976757884,
0.1305909455,
-0.1442282647,
-0.2727015913,
-0.00776482,
-0.0508040302,
-0.4258886278,
0.4870832562,
0.8673710823,
-0.0738008991,
-0.2519380748,
-1.0248737335,
0.6196139455,
0.7050509453,
-0.3324027061,
0.023370441,
0.3436132967,
0.2374162525,
0.0647415966,
0.6070206165,
-0.1545494795,
0.209418565,
-0.0688542575,
-0.2933335602,
-0.2056129426,
-0.2776694298,
-0.6458390355,
0.1832025647,
0.1168652549,
0.1631473154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09613v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09613v2
|
Digital Socrates: Evaluating LLMs through Explanation Critiques
| 2023-11-16T06:51:46 | 2024-02-16T08:49:07 |
Yuling Gu, Oyvind Tafjord, Peter Clark
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While LLMs can provide reasoned explanations along with their answers, the
nature and quality of those explanations are still poorly understood. In
response, our goal is to define a detailed way of characterizing the
explanation capabilities of modern models and to create a nuanced,
interpretable explanation evaluation tool that can generate such
characterizations automatically, without relying on expensive API calls or
human annotations. Our approach is to (a) define the new task of explanation
critiquing - identifying and categorizing any main flaw in an explanation and
providing suggestions to address the flaw, (b) create a sizeable,
human-verified dataset for this task, and (c) train an open-source, automatic
critique model (called Digital Socrates) using this data. Through quantitative
and qualitative analysis, we demonstrate how Digital Socrates is useful for
revealing insights about student models by examining their reasoning chains,
and how it can provide high-quality, nuanced, automatic evaluation of those
model explanations for the first time. Digital Socrates thus fills an important
gap in evaluation tools for understanding and improving the explanation
behavior of models.
|
[
-0.5897966623,
-0.6491014361,
0.9964206219,
-0.0544855632,
-0.6256753802,
-0.0168224201,
0.0116598783,
-0.3590448797,
-0.0520455353,
0.1656458974,
-1.026879549,
-0.2311763614,
-0.4262759686,
0.2824736536,
-0.3858638108,
1.0594619513,
-0.1467589438,
0.546339035,
-0.519526422,
0.3389211595,
-0.4536933899,
-0.0312244743,
-0.8013719916,
-0.6437918544,
0.4076616764,
0.4946677089,
0.6136506796,
0.4579407871,
0.3718015552,
0.3694162965,
-0.0062919748,
0.1135313362,
-0.4555235207,
-0.0582869649,
-0.4173260927,
-0.3837737143,
-0.5197916031,
0.1865481883,
0.490834862,
0.7122655511,
0.1141256765,
0.4849413633,
-0.0132521912,
0.6682314873,
-0.514601171,
0.0560334697,
-0.5290127993,
0.2079736739,
0.1218857467,
-0.1861508489,
-0.2113043666,
-0.7805924416,
0.3221601546,
-0.6288824677,
0.3143923581,
-0.3319666386,
0.675976932,
0.2191793174,
-0.2878745198,
-0.4625275135,
-1.069298625,
0.7256298065,
-0.5967451334,
0.030834021,
0.0692784339,
0.8175387383,
0.0558999591,
-0.8261110783,
-0.7893889546,
0.0138042932,
0.1804473549,
0.3456612527,
0.0684061497,
0.0668559,
0.0028580197,
0.7854828238,
-0.2389741093,
-0.1150119081,
-0.6882479787,
-0.4622650146,
0.95767349,
0.6578896046,
-0.0004371292,
-0.1949252635,
-0.3890700042,
0.362763226,
-0.2512314618,
0.2520696521,
0.6857587099,
-0.2525402606,
0.0970413163,
0.4884307086,
-0.0162271187,
0.7740288973,
0.0511362776,
-0.103680335,
-0.2779992223,
-0.6009255648,
-0.1824358106,
0.0426206514,
0.4785334468,
0.6506198049,
0.1572030634,
-0.1053265482,
-0.4906110168,
0.4068562388,
0.6829792261,
-0.6303271055,
-0.3694866598,
0.5292480588,
-0.5812460184,
-0.5535293818,
-0.0334921777,
-0.850638628,
-0.5968387127,
-0.7421315908,
0.6370236278,
-0.0914945677,
0.0145937372,
0.4618396163,
-0.2701429427,
-0.0134353098,
0.8728631139,
-0.6380267739,
0.6621409059,
0.5939104557,
0.7224824429,
-0.0737318769,
-0.0819819793,
-0.0761513188,
-0.0829290003,
-0.2426714003,
1.0060675144,
-0.4807723761,
-0.3719600439,
-0.359039247,
-0.0682290494,
0.0929072425,
-0.5387728214,
0.7127056122,
-0.3615797162,
0.3984566629,
-0.3624968529,
-0.6644487381,
-0.4259860814,
0.3679038286,
-0.4789398015,
0.8815407157,
0.1429839134,
-0.6479036808,
0.1809685081,
-0.63716048,
0.112353757,
0.0311281625,
0.0263175778,
-0.4176841974,
0.2230986059,
0.1836753935,
0.1940745562,
-0.5370121002,
0.141168192,
-0.4848149717,
-0.7649821043,
0.498103857,
-0.1388629973,
1.0550047159,
0.1519917101,
-0.3686261475,
0.0896341205,
-0.7028467059,
0.1503945291,
0.4727661908,
-0.1609287411,
-0.0699902847,
0.0213333499,
-0.4525853097,
0.1300735027,
0.2654850185,
-0.4875456691,
0.1841249168,
-0.2119514048,
0.7800400257,
0.9953724742,
0.2350227386,
0.2078324556,
-0.6143845916,
0.7500380278,
-0.1906941533,
0.633220613,
-0.2055291235,
-0.4128997028,
-0.5886211395,
-0.2158545703,
0.1711601317,
0.1979794055,
-0.3292770088,
-0.1123474315,
-0.1667591184,
-0.5755087137,
-0.8468942046,
0.176017344,
0.3724037111,
0.7363651991,
0.1417841464,
-0.6475841999,
-0.439560622,
-0.8475276232,
-0.34156394,
-0.1606374681,
-0.0121093346,
0.4971292019,
0.6687648296,
-0.1054072976,
0.9261617064,
-0.2436162233,
0.262529701,
-0.0822168887,
0.0161456354,
-0.0796488672,
-0.0181904733,
0.1753763407,
-0.5409319997,
0.017191859,
-0.6388559937,
-0.6368476748,
-0.2333423495,
-0.2938093841,
-0.0409706421,
-0.3389186561,
0.2047954351,
-0.240548566,
0.3341446519,
0.1691625863,
-0.2809903324,
1.2547677755,
-0.0102259275,
0.1562788635,
-0.5824181437,
-0.2522354126,
0.0120800063,
-0.0778638273,
-0.252402395,
-0.1173279136,
-0.2603141665,
-0.2659909427,
-0.3927178681,
0.5156624317,
-0.255907774,
-0.6345393658,
-0.136147812,
0.8116185665,
0.451189965,
0.1548963487,
-0.2438125461,
0.4708389938,
0.2772551775,
-0.7386783361,
0.7578517199,
0.1472332776,
-0.3154971898,
0.620136559,
-0.8633438349,
0.3964785337,
-0.1546281725,
0.316031903,
-1.3773037195,
-0.1616752893,
0.482311219,
-0.5219736099,
-0.3002002537,
-0.4104406536,
-0.3246846795,
-0.5823926926,
-0.5886318684,
0.3752823472,
-0.0655317381,
-0.5017830729,
0.2520055771,
0.0377400517,
0.0329183526,
-0.3644381166,
-0.3821865022,
0.0242486056,
-0.3179696202,
-0.7751743197,
0.4699315727,
-0.4916419685,
-0.7734689116,
0.0063070161,
-0.3612616658,
-0.1498934329,
0.5694988966,
0.2204534411,
0.4921115935,
-0.1038980111,
0.2467057407,
-0.0342713855,
-0.3659906387,
0.4611540139,
-0.2167951763,
0.3732944429,
-0.2665789425,
-0.5023269653,
-0.7604068518,
-0.2263928205,
0.6729861498,
-0.0581289493,
0.3090807498,
0.3743360639,
-0.3605878949,
-0.2415166199,
-0.2640598714,
-0.369340986,
-0.4540952742,
-0.1478447765,
-0.4637260735,
-0.3385593295,
0.5158435106,
-0.2366972417,
0.275942117,
0.4952642918,
0.6121593714,
-0.2176694125,
0.9847815633,
0.3037723005,
0.3434994519,
0.1814406216,
-0.2377030253,
0.2108365297,
-0.871360302,
-0.4905177653,
-0.5600425005,
-0.4800010622,
-0.1901902556,
-0.0985108241,
0.0643813387,
0.2285305113,
-0.3887176514,
-0.0742197409,
-0.7045364976,
0.4863223433,
0.2968701422,
0.2593589723,
0.5456840396,
-0.1685395539,
-0.259999603,
-0.173330307,
-0.2297020704,
-1.1220833063,
0.9773314595,
0.4304797351,
0.6432362795,
0.1598898321,
0.7592900395,
0.3927511275,
0.069236353,
-1.3095036745,
0.6712818146,
0.3673577607,
-0.7545395494,
-0.2554214895,
-0.2016730309,
-0.693690002,
0.3069778979,
-0.3015127182,
-0.6911014318,
0.0121757854,
0.0864746496,
-0.4609798789,
0.2140945196,
-0.6623978615,
0.8908302784,
-0.3447526693,
-0.3896588981,
-0.4466407895,
-0.2309748232,
0.80791682,
-0.0770263001,
0.3363712132,
0.0080222217,
-0.1109042242,
0.6886087656,
-0.582919836,
0.7744996548,
-0.2619028389,
-0.2224113345,
0.4218044579,
0.4209057391,
0.0420004986,
0.2875979841,
-0.4132608473,
-0.1086393744,
0.2786534131,
-0.5042082071,
-0.8108476996,
0.3986418843,
-0.8412567973,
-0.6633442044,
-0.0872132629,
-0.2794231176,
0.0009541942,
-0.0964884236,
0.1154646799,
0.4244917035,
0.0075900266,
-0.368196249,
0.4461363554,
-0.1885390282,
0.2209481299,
0.4237580001,
-0.1995554864,
-0.4003459513,
0.6033203602,
0.0130980276,
0.1128629521,
-0.4239005744,
0.4199425578,
-0.2565037012,
-0.7827146053,
-0.6697286367,
0.2425835133,
-0.9962458014,
0.1837209463,
-0.3054301143,
0.0448989198,
-0.093979843,
-0.2087880969,
-0.2453293055,
-0.8279517889,
-0.2624427974,
-0.1408946216,
0.0282243378,
1.1825287342,
0.1222296953,
0.4231864214,
-0.7230180502,
0.4489265382,
0.5375264287,
0.3491989076,
0.3491872549,
-0.7852149606,
-0.2018041164,
0.1125855818,
-0.6926421523,
-1.165595293,
-0.0350213982,
0.0739584342,
0.5196601748,
0.695083797,
0.1273960769,
0.8712582588,
-0.2337930202,
1.0125935078,
0.0033897161,
-1.1803412437,
0.7964609861,
0.0082251932,
-0.1319657862,
0.3792088628,
0.4442198277,
-0.3547283113,
-0.1567997336,
-0.7233225107,
-0.6153654456,
0.6504833102,
-0.0794696212,
0.0559121817,
0.1485129893,
1.0672389269,
0.3822261989,
0.161674276,
-0.9090136886,
-0.1481736153,
-0.2389442027,
-0.0523649976,
0.0059220488,
-0.4231082797,
-0.4391920865,
-0.2668519616,
0.7077507973,
0.0382816419,
0.3825964332,
0.4194853604,
-0.2366537303,
-0.3893173337,
0.2381512225,
0.7186493278,
1.1646233797,
-0.0129420869,
0.2718489766,
0.1399478912,
-0.3740386963,
0.2387903482,
-0.0867942646,
0.0252832007,
0.0676501468,
0.4336352348,
0.4356888831,
-0.1414590329,
-0.500724256,
0.405366838,
-0.3391939104,
-0.2900576591,
-0.4448634684,
0.1136192828,
0.1942180693,
0.5094685555,
0.2705366313,
-0.1825368404,
0.3498821855,
-0.8217105269,
0.087497212,
0.3087620437,
-0.437797904,
-0.526545763,
0.4735231102,
-0.000310575,
-0.3770951629,
0.4903320074,
-0.1731090844,
-0.6933925152,
0.7271838188,
0.4289992154,
0.7184409499,
-0.0807193294,
0.5667042732,
0.303806603,
0.4148044884,
0.1442646086,
0.250271678,
-0.2559764087,
-0.6639767885,
-0.3511143625,
-0.3834061623,
-0.9645408988,
0.0978334919,
-0.7343785763,
0.3909478188,
-0.8420838714,
-0.2248921841,
0.3336547613,
0.3627578616,
-0.3453524411,
0.4878199995,
0.0710713267,
0.6549111009,
-0.8790477514,
0.3572410643,
0.8289271593,
-0.4429452121,
-0.4951845706,
-0.0550029092,
0.3083913028,
-0.7842381597,
0.7232997417,
0.0346827693,
-0.3702601492,
-0.2525184155,
-0.5907126069,
-0.3433952034,
1.1479321718,
0.5414486527,
-0.4894012511,
0.0856606364,
-0.0877055153,
0.59982723,
-0.3498819768,
0.676685214,
0.2968012393,
0.5732814074,
0.0751575828,
-0.6136232615,
0.1301587969,
-0.1436892301,
-0.3455246985,
-0.1443771422,
-0.5168842077,
0.7538545728,
-0.5301132798,
-0.1498409361,
-0.0825132206,
0.1638890058,
0.0808052719,
0.7590346336,
0.6412152052,
0.5568571687,
0.9794812799,
-0.1480900049,
1.0543020964,
-0.0835664347,
0.3271526992,
1.1157025099,
0.1005738676,
0.3386886418,
0.3401921988,
-0.2668792307,
0.737148881,
1.3758716583,
-0.1542674452,
0.3695428967,
0.6269555688,
-0.3444038928,
-0.5335792303,
0.1339528114,
-0.0310226921,
0.343724668,
0.269543618,
-0.2852485478,
-0.2757474184,
-0.2162784338,
-0.3795160055,
0.0474517941,
-0.6352122426,
0.8078641295,
0.1203648522,
-0.4930795431,
0.6053561568,
0.1416821182,
0.030863395,
0.0307070892,
-0.0003002559,
-0.1788487583,
0.1857987642,
-0.5334952474,
-0.7320344448,
0.372500211,
0.0257021114,
-0.0310554337,
-0.1383022666,
0.6464259028,
0.2969373763,
-0.1657105833,
0.2257781327,
0.2762165666,
0.5362092853,
-0.0121807521,
-1.0454740524,
-0.014076842,
0.0306374487,
-0.0566476844,
-0.1064420864,
0.6068214774,
0.0320463851,
0.962352097,
0.292529583,
-0.0058766971,
-0.1226443499,
-0.0051937546,
0.8079345226,
-0.6910250783,
-0.1048034206,
-1.0124787092,
0.7699025869,
0.0479588062,
-0.2724745274,
0.5520464182,
0.5624374151,
0.8165124059,
0.0791649371,
0.805404067,
0.4881051183,
0.4773342907,
-0.4401316345,
0.1872251481,
-0.5918087363,
0.7913546562,
-0.0947970673,
-1.1729804277,
0.151013121,
0.76912117,
-0.5384064913,
0.0136232795,
0.7219772935,
0.2879786789,
-0.1677485704,
0.4061957002,
0.0067151147,
0.2125359923,
0.1274778545,
0.2499138117,
1.1993684769,
-0.3345942497,
0.6412327886,
-0.3615043163,
-0.1736053675,
-0.280836463,
-0.8451170325,
-0.8855825663,
-0.3086057305,
-0.6039931178,
-0.5903939605,
0.083403036,
0.6243914366,
0.4544067383,
-0.4971076548,
-0.1789609343,
-0.0391094871,
0.4861587286,
-0.0617493577,
-0.247765094,
0.0040025432,
-0.3502252698,
-0.7057646513,
0.3177793622,
0.0688641518,
0.0096647497,
-0.656039834,
-0.1519029737,
0.413633585,
0.4245397747,
0.4613818526,
-0.2428655177,
-0.7128955126,
-0.3339264095,
-0.1240816936,
0.0993848071,
0.16032435,
1.0188735723,
-0.6508626342,
0.8366697431,
0.3017834723,
0.5025855899,
0.8106740713,
-0.0611788034,
0.6631445289,
-0.0115976175,
-0.4169003963,
0.4286549389,
0.3692916632,
0.308501184,
-0.2929831147,
0.5623347163,
0.3117906451,
-0.5035578609,
-0.8601874113,
0.3201210797,
-0.8640741706,
-0.5027191639,
0.6341369152,
-0.5075341463,
-0.0599633269,
-0.3393122852,
-0.3640567362,
0.3964192867,
0.0308185928,
1.4473940134,
1.0040836334,
-0.1635340452,
-0.2962373495,
-0.7929765582,
0.3261259198,
0.2401919365,
-0.8653762341,
-0.0196399726,
0.6150276065,
0.3610898256,
-0.0651621446,
0.4027137458,
-0.5209368467,
0.4982456863,
-0.1580372602,
-0.010868744,
-0.1084686816,
-0.1088495553,
-0.657192111,
-0.129105553,
0.2575124204,
-0.0824682787
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09612v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09612v2
|
Efficient End-to-End Visual Document Understanding with Rationale Distillation
| 2023-11-16T06:50:26 | 2024-04-02T00:11:50 |
Wang Zhu, Alekh Agarwal, Mandar Joshi, Robin Jia, Jesse Thomason, Kristina Toutanova
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Understanding visually situated language requires interpreting complex
layouts of textual and visual elements. Pre-processing tools, such as optical
character recognition (OCR), can map document image inputs to textual tokens,
then large language models (LLMs) can reason over text. However, such methods
have high computational and engineering complexity. Can small pretrained
image-to-text models accurately understand visual documents through similar
recognition and reasoning steps instead? We propose Rationale Distillation
(RD), which incorporates the outputs of OCR tools, LLMs, and larger multimodal
models as intermediate "rationales", and trains a small student model to
predict both rationales and answers. On three visual document understanding
benchmarks representing infographics, scanned documents, and figures, our
Pix2Struct (282M parameters) student model finetuned with RD outperforms the
base model by 4-5% absolute accuracy with only 1% higher computational cost.
|
[
-0.3831849098,
-0.9018465877,
1.0789774656,
-0.0474307984,
-0.4855502844,
-0.0877634883,
-0.3344442248,
-0.404779315,
-0.3755151331,
0.4263177812,
-0.5080106258,
-0.3384084105,
-0.7471528649,
0.1216428131,
-0.27781111,
0.4076875746,
-0.3924537301,
0.2418378443,
-0.5353372693,
-0.213628009,
-0.3913494647,
-0.2862797081,
-0.4146524668,
-0.2712238729,
0.5711273551,
0.448707819,
0.3840617239,
0.7093818188,
0.5510132313,
0.4558632672,
0.0008275196,
0.119415164,
-0.5082736015,
0.0030008391,
-0.2370958626,
-0.7634619474,
-0.0131497774,
0.363250345,
0.1834888756,
0.637214601,
0.1187010184,
0.0703741759,
0.1109237671,
0.821033895,
-0.596632421,
0.2540334463,
-0.5857346654,
-0.0221681185,
0.0443090089,
-0.3268260062,
-0.8784602284,
-0.0931662321,
0.2938660383,
-1.0402656794,
0.1354768723,
0.0933457017,
0.9445360899,
0.5221030712,
-0.378369242,
-0.5691094398,
-0.5449172258,
0.6053686142,
-0.3700194061,
0.393740952,
0.4486891329,
0.6060439944,
-0.1628675014,
-1.1087133884,
-0.8489741087,
-0.0540938489,
-0.0459371023,
0.375112325,
-0.3296132684,
0.0512831211,
0.5357545018,
0.1088238209,
-0.5934997797,
-0.1590476781,
-0.4377173781,
0.1785755903,
0.1110522822,
-0.18546395,
0.3930980563,
-0.0380394235,
-0.6726234555,
-0.3317928016,
-0.1351715922,
0.0156340245,
-0.210624665,
-0.219252944,
0.1707072407,
0.7442831993,
0.0352516025,
0.8038146496,
0.2072965801,
-0.2964617312,
-0.1525860429,
-0.4386236072,
-0.5061573982,
0.0500320755,
0.4749782383,
0.4695961177,
0.4725959003,
0.1186047122,
-0.0630648509,
0.1238499507,
0.1514964253,
-0.9679591656,
-0.2759006917,
0.0565305986,
-0.5054946542,
-0.0357397571,
-0.1463257819,
-0.4819345474,
-0.4908587635,
-1.0149008036,
0.3648868203,
-0.7163776755,
0.0735856891,
0.128957063,
-0.6776007414,
0.2007382959,
1.0807932615,
-0.5883436203,
-0.0521102734,
0.3074071705,
0.9977201223,
0.1945531368,
-0.3570632637,
-0.4996837974,
0.116327405,
-0.2938434482,
1.1333736181,
-0.4886138737,
-0.2112594098,
-0.3816990256,
-0.1680778116,
-0.2472094744,
-0.3195567727,
0.4285775125,
-0.5027606487,
0.3754253089,
-0.2119119465,
-0.4579973519,
-0.3848536611,
0.2246355712,
-0.7722477913,
0.6726219058,
0.1729924381,
-0.7818982601,
0.6061589718,
-0.3721052408,
-0.1410788894,
0.0514092781,
-0.4208742678,
-0.1929655373,
0.31863603,
0.3720719814,
0.3418983817,
-0.3730882406,
0.2023988068,
-0.380905211,
-0.2623310685,
0.1937253475,
-0.7524005771,
0.6892526746,
0.3734061122,
-0.1540728062,
0.20340994,
-0.8490793109,
-0.1128274798,
0.2500491738,
-0.3273551762,
-0.6136896014,
-0.256560415,
0.2080636472,
0.3662027419,
0.3358757496,
-0.2905112505,
0.2644565105,
0.1803634167,
0.6374338269,
0.5454484224,
-0.308899492,
0.7230632901,
0.0880398825,
0.3526685834,
-0.047526069,
-0.0840195119,
-0.6762206554,
-0.3961152136,
-0.6520913243,
-0.7618260384,
0.0718092099,
0.4258770049,
-1.0954788923,
0.0927514806,
-0.2546676397,
-0.4073166847,
-0.2029385269,
-0.0013261748,
0.2987465262,
0.918014586,
0.3435750008,
-0.0143762743,
-0.2070272863,
-0.6356256604,
-0.1298251599,
-0.2904062271,
-0.1808944196,
0.0816098228,
0.4278076291,
-0.1926313192,
1.0065518618,
-0.512568593,
-0.439186275,
-0.3323578537,
0.7000110745,
0.1194490939,
0.162920028,
0.6990662813,
-1.0376578569,
-0.8142511249,
0.1748559028,
-0.9145781398,
-0.1223919094,
-0.5147462487,
-0.2605992556,
0.2355189025,
0.7185590267,
-0.4485324621,
0.8279930353,
0.0840189904,
-0.5339910388,
0.2538573742,
-0.5664295554,
0.3023000956,
-0.9094814062,
0.023380449,
0.4405615032,
-0.2422977388,
-0.4921737313,
-0.0621142574,
0.3473868966,
-0.2507436574,
-0.2194865346,
0.380189836,
-0.7916370034,
0.0022214197,
-0.2874416709,
0.3641931117,
0.533901751,
0.5061495304,
0.4695216417,
0.7910054326,
0.2859435678,
-0.0340536609,
0.2072063684,
0.1906858236,
-0.5355848074,
0.8415017128,
-0.6922018528,
-0.0975287333,
-0.4624999464,
0.2661274076,
-1.3030031919,
-0.3627069592,
-0.0832931697,
-0.3566961586,
0.4671853781,
-0.391007483,
-0.2810149491,
-0.087030448,
-0.2126242369,
0.3037552536,
0.4735904634,
-0.8615677953,
0.9520780444,
0.1260490716,
-0.2344496399,
-0.418566674,
-0.6570938826,
0.1314202547,
-0.1073418632,
-1.0149427652,
0.0245284326,
0.0978616998,
-0.3214104176,
-0.0252253357,
-0.0673214793,
-0.4580629766,
0.0383163355,
0.1479239613,
0.4548827708,
-0.25187397,
-0.056868583,
0.0040527117,
-0.2237221748,
-0.1188073531,
-0.3243000209,
0.3118154407,
-0.1400977373,
-0.4037275314,
-0.561748147,
0.351074785,
1.1499689817,
-0.2265418917,
0.500030756,
0.4626929164,
-0.4399734139,
-0.114736408,
-0.4938476384,
0.0228474755,
-0.4409566522,
0.3855547607,
-0.6666806936,
-0.4987278581,
0.3523680568,
-0.2673450112,
0.02585016,
0.3577439189,
0.3634112775,
-0.3960200846,
0.953453362,
0.5675297976,
0.4824320078,
0.6159252524,
-0.117158182,
0.2792035341,
-0.4443668127,
-0.4238660336,
-0.4728288949,
-0.1406780481,
-0.12947537,
-0.6394405365,
0.354316026,
0.597727716,
0.2073966414,
0.3376577199,
-0.5443825126,
0.8284314871,
0.6248200536,
0.150247857,
0.3542040288,
0.3631595671,
-0.1807563603,
-0.1894839704,
-0.5263779759,
-0.6911414266,
0.8205062151,
0.3598669469,
0.9315590858,
-0.1511295587,
0.4613452554,
-0.0258571133,
0.3503829837,
-0.9514011145,
0.364364028,
-0.0860781819,
-0.1675452441,
-0.4268318415,
-0.1750369668,
-0.5850293636,
0.5722378492,
-0.1599502861,
-0.5227481127,
0.5169906616,
0.1576721519,
-0.0982640013,
0.0344712213,
-1.2148643732,
1.1285419464,
-0.3456697464,
-0.5836129189,
-0.2073914558,
-0.4240055978,
0.3543749154,
-0.1905548573,
0.2744599581,
0.2050144076,
0.1376939267,
0.3823002875,
-0.8126901388,
0.582962811,
-0.0805258378,
-0.0321217664,
0.4338646233,
0.0308007207,
0.356756866,
0.0136120534,
-0.116082117,
0.1226403341,
0.1569936275,
-0.4236058295,
-0.978115201,
0.4879079759,
-0.569493711,
-0.5151460171,
-0.6397082806,
-0.2216808945,
0.2796212435,
0.4044127166,
0.4372674525,
0.5671511889,
0.0076710675,
0.2665144205,
0.8684319854,
-0.026792746,
0.3521864712,
0.3620002866,
-0.0494313352,
-0.3585290313,
0.7225021124,
0.1872962117,
0.227753371,
0.3306922615,
0.1639714539,
-0.6006094217,
-0.5473052263,
-0.775898397,
-0.0266947113,
-1.123281002,
0.1824726164,
-0.594155252,
0.183917895,
-0.1261890531,
-0.5162214637,
-0.1512375474,
-0.3029567599,
-0.5735864639,
0.1324008405,
0.2860592902,
0.5969949365,
0.0991611555,
0.2455366552,
-0.6437082291,
0.547755003,
0.3376293778,
0.2282199711,
-0.0849835128,
-0.7467820644,
-0.0308407601,
0.0432392396,
-0.156618312,
-0.8981361985,
0.3628805876,
0.1756084114,
0.4681052864,
0.5693414211,
0.1126831844,
0.9504504204,
-0.6511077285,
0.3868257403,
0.668813765,
-0.8793219328,
0.727812171,
-0.087487638,
0.321996063,
0.8279573917,
0.4780004919,
-0.2369571775,
0.1061271876,
-0.1708765924,
-0.6990229487,
0.6534830928,
0.1175887063,
-0.4349772632,
0.1250430942,
0.2973934114,
0.0080346568,
-0.1048910469,
-0.6776242256,
0.3540230393,
-0.4790500104,
-0.4593875408,
-0.0551619455,
-0.2001082301,
0.0502884276,
-0.2557499707,
0.2689684927,
-0.3230024874,
-0.0660114884,
0.4425643086,
-0.5055921078,
0.1282299906,
0.0776885822,
0.5338644981,
0.7522776723,
-0.2181704193,
0.3254080415,
-0.1467703283,
-0.5496463776,
0.0409854017,
0.0289769396,
0.1133685708,
0.1879336685,
0.5793216228,
0.7539970279,
-0.0069508776,
-0.7145910263,
0.7027742863,
-0.6236556768,
-0.3379170299,
-0.2890273333,
-0.1494063586,
0.0564453155,
0.2254223526,
0.2047751993,
0.2659864128,
0.0387876034,
-0.6830736399,
0.1217253432,
0.244544208,
-0.382512778,
0.012933746,
0.6871929765,
0.1358056366,
0.0278739296,
0.6893852353,
0.0642336905,
-0.3156706989,
0.7182382345,
0.3243204355,
0.7431026101,
0.3052276075,
0.0237679482,
0.3802032769,
0.2791415751,
-0.2373787612,
0.2446452081,
-0.3726783097,
-0.3123806417,
-0.4445721209,
-0.5781798959,
-0.3647766709,
-0.1339667588,
-0.6255286932,
0.4128850698,
-0.5136829019,
0.0253207888,
0.4296539724,
-0.3293159008,
-0.4763715267,
0.288521409,
0.2020443827,
0.9855851531,
-0.6206240654,
0.860160172,
0.6564221978,
-0.7631758451,
-0.6173296571,
-0.1414280683,
-0.0552946106,
-0.6274126172,
0.9945182204,
0.4180552065,
-0.3323281407,
-0.1144637316,
-0.6608385444,
-0.4707068801,
1.1667978764,
0.3771931231,
-0.8723587394,
0.0125612989,
0.1005415246,
0.6195896268,
-0.1812980175,
0.6492034197,
0.3177225292,
0.5130578279,
0.6005992293,
-0.4808801413,
-0.1479208618,
-0.4134050906,
0.094387643,
-0.1416852176,
-0.1799727678,
0.7075790167,
-0.2936292589,
-0.473097086,
-0.0991982669,
0.5098936558,
0.2402055413,
0.7532532215,
0.5232396126,
0.5284845233,
0.7439160347,
-0.2159343958,
0.9471030235,
-0.2110539228,
0.0385167152,
1.2931222916,
-0.3305904269,
0.8189726472,
0.7546164393,
0.0714753643,
0.2568932176,
0.7652958035,
0.1918158382,
0.5350297093,
0.077819325,
-0.1194609851,
-0.4808897674,
0.0149300564,
-0.1890266985,
0.2843388021,
0.3883318007,
-0.3396567106,
-0.2690352798,
0.0744924247,
-0.4230603278,
0.4431595504,
-0.1812824309,
0.9299253225,
0.1623431295,
-0.803184092,
0.7225266695,
-0.0139086014,
0.2935197353,
-0.5335193872,
-0.2237198204,
-0.0945596024,
0.340637356,
-0.0985069349,
-0.8425115347,
0.07116694,
0.1542517096,
-0.4694364369,
-0.4822390676,
0.7728144526,
-0.5142247677,
-0.5828886628,
0.2246231437,
0.1713089049,
0.0324387848,
-0.3029067218,
-0.3998982906,
0.0631266162,
0.0210031811,
-0.3231415153,
0.3073413968,
0.9918470979,
-0.1808715612,
0.51493752,
0.8185138106,
-0.3529650867,
0.1340878457,
0.0919359475,
0.8626430035,
-0.3016953766,
-0.5304914117,
-0.9298556447,
0.5435300469,
-0.300124824,
-0.2528874874,
0.5071546435,
0.3973748684,
0.9347448945,
-0.2512563169,
0.7896946073,
0.3793746531,
-0.0235886201,
-0.7341477871,
0.8607159853,
-0.7601818442,
0.038019754,
-0.3319118321,
-0.8454887271,
-0.2019683421,
1.0326216221,
-0.3295688033,
-0.4311890304,
0.7033221722,
0.4333153069,
-0.230551064,
0.175642699,
0.3620267212,
-0.0493243374,
0.3530013263,
0.3679606915,
0.927716732,
-0.2035183907,
0.4038571715,
-0.1642126143,
-0.6795707345,
-0.1790371984,
-0.8842025995,
-1.1915148497,
-0.5546668172,
-0.30226174,
-0.2017520666,
-0.2631007135,
0.6661310792,
0.5087348223,
-0.33457461,
0.041312255,
-0.3626221716,
0.0854340494,
0.1154222786,
-0.1418053061,
0.2648121417,
-0.3304943442,
-0.7716240883,
0.1444506943,
0.6551601291,
0.2886421382,
-0.0292227175,
-0.0540922433,
-0.1831999719,
0.1977975518,
0.8022244573,
0.1622651219,
-0.7370764613,
0.245770216,
0.0600217097,
-0.3523456454,
0.123146385,
0.8151046038,
-0.4591362476,
0.817617774,
0.9381023049,
0.5004742146,
0.7136405706,
0.1585033238,
0.4485699534,
-0.0957481936,
0.3575842679,
-0.1012435332,
0.7181318998,
0.1187703311,
-0.3119569123,
0.4749985039,
0.3417287469,
-0.1759444773,
-0.6677561402,
0.1307921559,
-1.1991103888,
-0.8136000633,
0.8213505149,
-0.4722577333,
-0.5771761537,
-0.0614706501,
-0.7547972202,
0.2867012918,
-0.1952990443,
0.5863938928,
0.6476902366,
0.0190778337,
-0.3908483982,
-0.2629011273,
0.0667987093,
0.2315318733,
-0.8529902101,
0.1023433954,
0.8338537216,
-0.0248763133,
0.2450504005,
0.5250592232,
-0.0672712103,
0.3258616626,
0.1294599324,
-0.0866357535,
-0.3271270394,
-0.584423244,
-0.1510100067,
0.1227400452,
0.0218294486,
-0.0624137744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09606v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09606v2
|
GistScore: Learning Better Representations for In-Context Example Selection with Gist Bottlenecks
| 2023-11-16T06:28:05 | 2024-02-22T05:15:55 |
Shivanshu Gupta, Clemens Rosenbaum, Ethan R. Elenberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In-context Learning (ICL) is the ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to
perform new tasks when conditioned on prompts comprising a few task examples.
However, ICL performance can be critically sensitive to the choice of examples.
To dynamically select the best examples for every test input, we propose
Example Gisting, a novel approach for training example encoders through
supervised fine-tuning with an attention bottleneck between the inputs and
outputs. These gist models form the basis for GistScore, a novel metric for
scoring and selecting informative examples. Further, we experiment with two
variations: (1) fine-tuning gist models for each dataset and (2) multi-task
training a single model on a large collection of datasets. The latter can be
used for new tasks out-of-the-box, enabling a training-free ICL pipeline.
Evaluations with 21 datasets spanning 9 tasks and 8 diverse LLMs show that our
fine-tuned models get state-of-the-art ICL performance with over 20% absolute
gain over off-the-shelf retrievers and 5% over the best prior methods. Further,
our multi-task model generalizes well to new tasks, datasets, and prompt
templates. Selection using this model matches or outperforms prior methods
while being three orders of magnitude faster than the strongest training-free
baseline.
|
[
-0.5170038939,
-0.7189057469,
0.4162395597,
-0.5312823653,
-0.5622336268,
-0.0755957961,
-0.5396912098,
-0.2043335885,
-0.3166611791,
0.2723009884,
-0.4490371346,
-0.6978548169,
-0.7733750343,
0.004735487,
-0.3824293613,
1.5351378918,
-0.0807285979,
0.1440764517,
-0.6964079738,
-0.2874680161,
-0.3602865636,
-0.3035516441,
-0.6231825352,
-0.276340872,
0.246261701,
0.9333513975,
0.2822555602,
0.5154162049,
0.3573515415,
0.1482269913,
-0.0888780504,
0.3434025943,
-0.6246420741,
0.4577015936,
-0.1546859443,
-0.3337579072,
0.0473854765,
0.0969783068,
0.3377672732,
0.5204359889,
0.0222288296,
0.5379317403,
0.4412491322,
0.5593329072,
-0.8240396976,
0.3945325911,
-0.6134355068,
0.017613316,
0.0890185982,
0.1150434911,
-0.2370749861,
-0.3049688339,
0.3809021115,
-0.5582475662,
0.3259299099,
-0.0752551854,
0.5197923779,
0.2975858152,
-0.08930251,
-0.6674973965,
-0.4269852638,
0.5168719888,
-0.5565665364,
0.2388578802,
0.279068321,
0.4467446506,
0.1592131704,
-0.7642131448,
-0.0247826204,
-0.4708732963,
0.0052995123,
0.1798134148,
-0.0022807214,
0.0593165532,
0.6164788008,
0.2983110547,
-0.5604039431,
-0.1457112134,
-0.2469730526,
0.1080721766,
0.2694428563,
-0.1203579679,
0.0863086283,
-0.02759647,
-0.3031994104,
-0.2807900608,
-0.688016057,
0.3368377984,
0.2479968518,
0.2493406832,
-0.0476382896,
0.3588272929,
-0.4322657883,
0.721590817,
0.4709233642,
0.020566009,
0.1721555591,
-0.0655988306,
-0.1918929219,
0.0720922351,
0.4146765172,
0.3735518157,
0.5113261938,
-0.2615590096,
-0.3225539029,
0.1097004935,
0.3223811388,
-0.8720297217,
-0.4811603427,
0.0175182465,
-0.1779781133,
-0.0139449025,
0.2560864389,
-0.5779218674,
-0.2378680706,
-0.4323909283,
0.1122480705,
-0.6693292856,
-0.0408463329,
-0.0059639835,
-0.2805459201,
-0.0993562788,
0.1881094575,
-0.7778314352,
0.3132410645,
0.6573745012,
0.8403007984,
-0.2241599113,
-0.2412830293,
-0.9834523797,
0.0558078066,
-0.3070993125,
0.8648120761,
-0.6924948096,
-0.2646222413,
-0.0868884176,
-0.1371050775,
-0.0124840429,
-0.7193453908,
0.5985935926,
-0.2516852915,
-0.1091046259,
-0.0411573052,
-0.6615917683,
-0.2167399824,
0.4688581526,
-0.4181555212,
1.1807185411,
0.3549437225,
-0.6429050565,
0.5893173218,
-0.684092164,
-0.4179531336,
0.1264674217,
-0.2992159724,
-0.4411092103,
0.44116804,
0.3747513592,
0.823263824,
-0.2853159904,
0.3374338448,
-0.3493042886,
-0.4550314546,
-0.1760187298,
-0.1345276535,
0.346783638,
0.2898939848,
-0.3525931239,
0.1796578169,
-0.3130552769,
0.190945819,
-0.005740792,
-0.1615346968,
-0.565215528,
0.0220943708,
-0.2279504091,
0.3912056386,
0.0039906795,
-0.3090862632,
0.2583287358,
-0.2269309312,
0.6108214855,
0.5509861112,
-0.0017971792,
0.5952761173,
-0.2908956409,
0.6765589118,
0.3160876036,
0.2348802984,
-0.3580490649,
-0.1592259556,
-0.723524034,
-0.142031163,
0.222301349,
0.3256894946,
-0.8345409036,
0.2881333828,
-0.4510321319,
-0.6094026566,
-0.4241185784,
0.2217756361,
0.5482902527,
0.7221380472,
0.3220364451,
-0.4290669858,
-0.3490513265,
-1.0820592642,
-0.2392695695,
-0.0513349585,
-0.0373649001,
0.4138512611,
0.5487190485,
0.1035923138,
1.0094661713,
-0.4287159145,
-0.2530629039,
-0.3348333836,
0.2471109778,
0.1540429443,
0.4786971509,
0.4681476951,
-0.7418534756,
-0.6750831008,
-0.0240394883,
-0.7075210214,
0.0505610034,
-0.0950208902,
0.0396813378,
-0.168157801,
0.6753750443,
-0.4171876311,
0.1746739298,
0.3960314691,
-0.0825281367,
0.5421341062,
-0.2846635282,
0.0342071801,
-0.8892040253,
-0.1831863374,
0.2493925691,
-0.393081367,
-0.4466020763,
0.3681847751,
0.4580568373,
-0.1976730824,
-0.5006648302,
0.3718602359,
-0.9051159024,
-0.075952515,
0.0018920605,
0.0624109767,
-0.1498851329,
0.6120154262,
-0.2888451815,
1.0969944,
0.8331880569,
-0.6140568852,
0.1224149689,
0.051728826,
-0.7971843481,
0.6674742699,
-0.5289368033,
0.3741729558,
-0.2680528462,
0.1940328032,
-0.9098524451,
-0.3113565445,
0.2109810114,
-0.124119781,
0.2313582748,
-0.5178619623,
-0.5676576495,
-0.4434426427,
-0.2582867742,
0.203928113,
0.6633014083,
-0.7193445563,
0.4802985191,
0.3260040283,
-0.0673453584,
-0.2695238888,
-0.5251976252,
-0.1467838734,
-0.5173857808,
-0.2682209015,
0.1835005432,
-0.2185507417,
0.0923798904,
-0.015144635,
-0.2441527247,
-0.039393317,
0.3999321759,
0.4194004536,
-0.2002606988,
-0.0920253396,
0.2620788217,
0.237888813,
-0.1275937408,
-0.1217363849,
-0.5825947523,
0.3137731552,
-0.2301255018,
-0.5106226802,
-0.060982801,
0.674420476,
0.559494853,
-0.3453324437,
0.1728402525,
0.4439709187,
-0.3735137284,
-0.5457116961,
-0.4312523901,
-0.1656783223,
-0.4024022818,
0.5897500515,
-0.457585156,
-1.0157233477,
0.3200168312,
-0.2968313992,
-0.0452543758,
0.1962359846,
0.3810140491,
-0.0578572974,
1.1358630657,
0.5254884958,
-0.2044718713,
0.8895545006,
-0.4865964651,
-0.0029220809,
-1.0459643602,
0.1365719885,
-0.323867321,
-0.2988885045,
-0.1497503519,
-0.3647312224,
0.6488002539,
0.4814100564,
-0.3219312131,
0.3252491653,
-0.8381975889,
0.9084656239,
0.5756223798,
0.2665805221,
0.1339062154,
0.0742539987,
-0.3635341823,
0.1110361814,
-0.8541583419,
-0.5533335805,
0.9929041266,
-0.0591174252,
0.7606468797,
-0.1682812721,
0.511120677,
0.2488674223,
0.3785407245,
-0.6995934844,
0.404771775,
-0.4113629758,
-0.3277642429,
-0.0914016291,
-0.1325112134,
-0.708119154,
0.1556019187,
0.05507797,
-0.8041479588,
-0.1956298053,
0.3311550319,
-0.4331548512,
0.2487012744,
-1.0245707035,
0.9308878779,
-0.2347475141,
-0.2514010072,
-0.089002803,
-0.5636001229,
0.0993195251,
0.2605838776,
0.0021453772,
-0.1043195501,
0.1275846809,
0.2506828308,
0.1230051145,
0.8688625097,
-0.370113045,
0.223552987,
0.3563740551,
0.0717014968,
0.8535670042,
0.3200870752,
-0.1659487933,
0.0326674655,
-0.299702853,
-0.0813717693,
-0.7948107719,
0.8739764094,
-0.5158452392,
-0.7503895164,
-0.1784732044,
-0.4290421903,
-0.2441468686,
-0.0060092043,
0.4807988107,
0.616283834,
-0.1047401577,
0.3591457605,
0.6693180203,
0.3475607336,
0.3840748668,
0.1128840894,
0.3686816692,
-0.2292020917,
0.6660180688,
0.3279361427,
0.2757284045,
0.1338629723,
0.0196861606,
-0.1230885163,
-0.8541297317,
-0.770491302,
-0.2451591641,
-0.8603572845,
-0.4062564075,
-0.7619498372,
-0.098141335,
-0.1900397986,
-0.2299921215,
-0.2175239176,
-0.090229772,
-0.5627456307,
-0.1533160359,
0.3490321934,
0.4644894898,
0.3290445209,
0.1722207963,
-0.6033807397,
0.168573156,
0.201695323,
0.5216351151,
0.1782349646,
-0.5065766573,
-0.6958388686,
0.0206369907,
-0.3787846267,
-0.6418860555,
0.1645611078,
0.4943681657,
0.7844035029,
0.3806918263,
0.1619857252,
0.8179777861,
-0.5835459828,
0.7326937914,
0.0592748635,
-0.8136440516,
0.6401454806,
-0.1651737243,
0.6260302663,
0.8552159071,
0.4598384798,
-0.6596007347,
-0.4864869416,
-0.5464196801,
-0.8482569456,
0.4970177114,
-0.1674671173,
0.0586875305,
-0.3200064003,
0.4792941809,
0.4650994539,
0.1679837853,
-0.372703135,
0.0981899202,
-0.1258268505,
-0.3576338291,
-0.2335743308,
-0.1290893853,
-0.1347572505,
-0.4115838706,
0.4435658455,
-0.7906301618,
0.1863860041,
0.4470683932,
-0.7519567609,
0.080912441,
0.2111289799,
0.4501498342,
0.5467029214,
0.0744159147,
0.2383740842,
0.4856130779,
-0.1943343282,
0.0043120645,
0.0186797045,
-0.1591328233,
-0.1428124458,
0.2738294899,
0.9319140911,
0.4648834467,
-0.8109571338,
0.5437551737,
-0.0590285249,
-0.0459854454,
-0.4480239153,
0.5033789873,
-0.1249171272,
0.4774489999,
0.4413926303,
0.2161781341,
0.3962262273,
-0.3726293445,
0.3852570653,
0.5093346238,
-0.6890223026,
-0.291022718,
0.5243880153,
-0.0256415941,
-0.1542818397,
0.5037670732,
-0.4449174106,
-0.5043388009,
0.7805581689,
0.3802511096,
1.0790024996,
0.2158390582,
0.1142098382,
0.5470947623,
-0.0837758854,
-0.2996536493,
-0.0880147293,
-0.332883358,
-0.512655735,
-0.1892368793,
-0.2418883443,
-0.4370539486,
-0.0458168015,
-0.8840059638,
0.2293639481,
-0.3323319554,
-0.0281921905,
-0.3284937441,
-0.0572129712,
-0.8723894954,
0.0941625014,
0.1873122007,
0.8593578935,
-0.7109902501,
0.998474896,
0.9810496569,
-0.2142089307,
-0.5385172367,
-0.0060349894,
-0.1623570472,
-0.3247371614,
0.4268533289,
0.4656935036,
0.0774751529,
-0.0299905445,
-0.6961734295,
-0.8750942945,
1.2232599258,
0.5676689148,
-0.6632015109,
-0.2295691222,
-0.3034800589,
0.4794078469,
-0.9299879074,
0.5824238062,
0.5553866625,
0.1030056626,
-0.233267203,
-0.4884468615,
-0.0920839906,
-0.3398611248,
0.1539858729,
0.0959796011,
-0.6983406544,
0.935447216,
-0.3096216321,
-0.2513009012,
0.0257437583,
0.498203516,
0.264066875,
0.1580153257,
0.8057183027,
0.4472680986,
0.7625995278,
-0.1215738952,
1.361112833,
-0.3543084264,
0.4595814049,
1.3475314379,
-0.1615356356,
0.5224236846,
0.4264823496,
0.3106972873,
0.4104678035,
0.8640633225,
-0.0596971735,
0.778621316,
0.2790111899,
-0.0468185581,
-0.441357255,
-0.1069401726,
-0.2135133743,
0.3938242793,
0.3768785,
-0.373169899,
-0.5344418883,
0.3168167472,
-0.1372157782,
-0.0149779795,
-0.2948272526,
0.8937767148,
-0.0728065372,
-0.8070713282,
0.5144587755,
-0.3854639232,
0.8652805686,
-0.7063547373,
-0.1534569263,
-0.2544869781,
0.1203911826,
0.1217972711,
-0.6325626373,
0.1062851846,
0.1054595262,
-0.3935887516,
-0.2562249303,
0.6606550217,
-0.5323321223,
-0.380943805,
0.4199210703,
0.4445166588,
0.0315162651,
-0.2234038115,
-0.6738108397,
-0.2461494952,
-0.1180673987,
-0.3500566185,
0.4853381217,
0.5475794673,
-0.3445506692,
0.7375222445,
0.5606670976,
-0.0259958897,
-0.2015123516,
-0.0817985237,
1.0712734461,
-0.4604343176,
-0.6442178488,
-0.7541105747,
0.551004231,
-0.246323958,
-0.6779168844,
0.5238395333,
0.7362481356,
1.3581280708,
-0.3022063971,
0.8829734921,
0.0822660848,
0.3454920352,
-0.5700429082,
0.5708085895,
-0.5916008949,
0.0097385533,
-0.1996656805,
-0.6892384291,
-0.1005245447,
0.6321723461,
-0.4101459384,
0.0181502216,
0.7268435359,
0.650623858,
-0.3882218301,
0.0107307592,
0.4471963346,
-0.0137374653,
0.2607431114,
0.8084152937,
0.7755545378,
-0.2000308782,
0.484593004,
-0.301907748,
-0.0816915408,
-0.2019874603,
-0.8823362589,
-0.9230263829,
-0.7213459611,
-0.3181807697,
0.1174893677,
0.3857555091,
1.1829786301,
1.1859223843,
-0.837513864,
-0.1843941212,
-0.0105164656,
0.1194965392,
-0.611058712,
-0.1686349511,
0.1668545753,
-0.5676132441,
-0.8221907616,
0.3294455409,
0.2049001008,
-0.1501137912,
0.0569539107,
0.0163359027,
-0.0149649773,
-0.4840483069,
0.6192495823,
-0.0089928331,
-0.6813666224,
-0.6487846375,
-0.298019588,
-0.1783384979,
0.3179385066,
0.9996418953,
-0.8964707255,
0.4154496789,
0.2520704269,
0.7738707662,
0.6975874305,
0.034604691,
0.2917049229,
-0.9195434451,
0.2110366821,
0.3295131922,
0.4920242429,
0.3406507075,
-0.4811652303,
0.6618775725,
-0.1240986362,
-0.4348557293,
-0.5043019652,
0.1876293868,
-0.7760480046,
-0.3660097122,
1.1292461157,
-0.4155934751,
-0.1305427402,
-0.0472849645,
-0.1920795888,
0.3087692559,
-0.6832278967,
0.6228649616,
0.8332083225,
0.0078396313,
-0.3322746456,
-0.795625627,
0.4994918704,
0.3845390081,
-0.6211805344,
0.154307574,
0.4982980192,
0.3778508604,
-0.1805358082,
0.16170232,
0.1518486738,
0.2608031631,
-0.3271148205,
0.0487391017,
-0.4244351685,
-0.5380717516,
-0.4409009218,
0.4364221096,
0.0691400617,
-0.0930960104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09605v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09605v1
|
Measuring and Improving Attentiveness to Partial Inputs with Counterfactuals
| 2023-11-16T06:27:35 | 2023-11-16T06:27:35 |
Yanai Elazar, Bhargavi Paranjape, Hao Peng, Sarah Wiegreffe, Khyathi Raghavi, Vivek Srikumar, Sameer Singh, Noah A. Smith
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The inevitable appearance of spurious correlations in training datasets hurts
the generalization of NLP models on unseen data. Previous work has found that
datasets with paired inputs are prone to correlations between a specific part
of the input (e.g., the hypothesis in NLI) and the label; consequently, models
trained only on those outperform chance. Are these correlations picked up by
models trained on the full input data? To address this question, we propose a
new evaluation method, Counterfactual Attentiveness Test (CAT). CAT uses
counterfactuals by replacing part of the input with its counterpart from a
different example (subject to some restrictions), expecting an attentive model
to change its prediction. Using CAT, we systematically investigate established
supervised and in-context learning models on ten datasets spanning four tasks:
natural language inference, reading comprehension, paraphrase detection, and
visual & language reasoning. CAT reveals that reliance on such correlations is
mainly data-dependent. Surprisingly, we find that GPT3 becomes less attentive
with an increased number of demonstrations, while its accuracy on the test data
improves. Our results demonstrate that augmenting training or demonstration
data with counterfactuals is effective in improving models' attentiveness. We
show that models' attentiveness measured by CAT reveals different conclusions
from solely measuring correlations in data.
|
[
-0.427378267,
-0.9570970535,
0.4908719361,
0.2295818031,
-0.409606725,
-0.2195228934,
-0.0860708877,
-0.3592011333,
0.2561005056,
0.2686081529,
-0.3955623209,
-0.0301047955,
-0.4926967919,
0.1506755203,
-0.5844956636,
1.1095626354,
-0.1995239258,
0.1635748148,
-0.5215139985,
-0.2289967984,
-0.5701369047,
-0.4885543287,
-0.6436324716,
-0.6597868204,
0.4494019449,
0.1152481511,
0.611717701,
0.2220104337,
0.5360396504,
0.2277535796,
0.0548354127,
-0.06161483,
-0.3447913826,
-0.174012363,
-0.2456812114,
-0.6872991323,
-0.3970110416,
0.2752338648,
0.5434420705,
0.7460494041,
-0.2276334465,
0.2222235054,
0.3965348601,
0.5056512952,
-0.8289136887,
0.1462486833,
-0.7972096801,
0.2401531339,
0.0172391217,
-0.5061955452,
-0.5593357682,
0.0341209807,
0.289116621,
-0.7934468985,
0.4833874404,
-0.0843714625,
0.6755751371,
0.5047396421,
-0.3455533981,
-0.0869353637,
-0.5555877686,
1.1127952337,
-0.5506561399,
0.5098006725,
0.8572537303,
-0.1126923114,
-0.2232445627,
-0.4503166974,
-0.6617397666,
-0.449711293,
-0.3736924827,
0.4930520952,
-0.2793577611,
-0.1675734818,
0.4242221713,
0.2446087748,
-0.6668251753,
-0.2922753096,
0.0312979147,
0.0791513175,
0.3038029373,
0.0810194165,
0.3123984039,
0.0841266364,
-0.2879002094,
-0.3256139755,
-0.6649003625,
0.0693499818,
0.0450342335,
0.2326452583,
-0.101209715,
0.5168895125,
-0.1577937454,
0.6212206483,
0.1700454056,
0.1446427405,
0.2938738763,
-0.6208186746,
-0.2142602056,
-0.0389853343,
0.5790045857,
0.3860763311,
0.1992664337,
-0.2972407639,
-0.1635773927,
0.348352313,
0.4396457374,
-0.533303678,
-0.4216395915,
0.0889684036,
-0.2465729713,
-0.4734710455,
-0.2011703104,
-0.4572376907,
-0.221283108,
-0.3178135455,
0.4867315888,
-0.2707151473,
-0.1030011773,
0.2661048174,
-0.0517556295,
0.2236548066,
0.1376075745,
-0.7133647203,
0.5283349752,
0.5012467504,
0.9789698124,
-0.1965423822,
-0.2684623301,
-0.7830722332,
-0.0143464077,
-0.5459757447,
0.8153709173,
-0.5706624985,
-0.4823392034,
-0.1331206262,
0.0591941364,
-0.3538861573,
-0.4994124472,
0.3857335746,
-0.323467046,
0.2716991901,
-0.5458632708,
-0.3213379979,
-0.1284277588,
0.330108732,
-0.7536976933,
0.9911751747,
-0.1493683308,
-1.0470496416,
0.72878474,
-0.7310041785,
-0.5541750789,
-0.2852008939,
-0.0256384723,
-0.761954844,
0.2844544053,
0.3393542171,
0.1646691561,
-0.165091604,
0.6234105229,
-0.7367174029,
-0.5045101643,
0.5303149819,
-0.5666066408,
0.7578898072,
-0.336525768,
-0.2220220715,
-0.0108800801,
-0.774344027,
-0.148233071,
-0.0212419908,
-0.0932092667,
-0.425065577,
0.2434070408,
-0.2191624045,
0.1901375204,
-0.3072814345,
-0.4966555536,
-0.0261032116,
-0.4580775797,
0.3277641535,
0.4971262813,
0.0845166892,
0.299241662,
-0.5792136788,
0.3531183898,
0.0232830569,
0.2445922196,
0.1705864221,
-0.382678777,
-1.1360752583,
-0.0667939931,
0.0893355906,
0.543649435,
-1.0184105635,
0.2533197403,
-0.171934709,
-0.2574824691,
-0.2324235588,
0.1785582751,
0.6393704414,
0.7932415009,
0.7246716619,
-0.6909201145,
-0.5788002014,
-0.7194306254,
-0.2315540612,
-0.3687897623,
-0.3224738538,
0.046774108,
0.7650447488,
0.1155302376,
0.875100255,
-0.3710629344,
-0.2560764253,
-0.0070831785,
0.3405415118,
0.0275909062,
0.6338465214,
0.4942842424,
-0.5472614169,
-0.5312752128,
-0.2303140312,
-0.6604180336,
-0.0631293058,
-0.0844593942,
0.021101011,
0.0463154651,
0.5288197994,
-0.5521218777,
0.6592869759,
0.1861927658,
-0.2070230991,
0.5209219456,
0.0983881056,
0.0189763084,
-0.5801474452,
0.3383106887,
-0.0257991664,
-0.1354557872,
-0.7005719543,
-0.1222227737,
-0.1163934022,
0.181347847,
-0.4272356927,
0.5676375628,
-0.2083473653,
-0.0064326124,
-0.1266840845,
-0.0598009713,
0.2021218836,
0.6271489859,
0.4232535958,
0.7561635375,
0.4731817842,
-0.4702781141,
0.3429096043,
0.3248875439,
-0.2421007305,
0.4128610194,
-0.9015731812,
0.1812416017,
0.1687596887,
0.5582697392,
-0.9682801366,
-0.0527788959,
0.3260418177,
-0.3351021707,
0.0700106397,
0.2522491813,
-0.4312679768,
-0.3304269612,
-0.5805193186,
0.2023026943,
0.1741361767,
-0.6123714447,
0.6412324905,
-0.044323951,
0.0274627581,
-0.6260407567,
-0.9814783335,
-0.1471423805,
-0.3537969589,
-0.0078284405,
0.197412461,
-0.1261641383,
-0.1250701398,
-0.1204954237,
-0.310382545,
-0.3108117878,
0.1751162112,
0.1327480525,
0.3199584782,
-0.1074517518,
0.2594292462,
-0.2911301851,
-0.04121463,
0.2172819823,
0.0291394684,
0.294601649,
-0.0607610568,
-0.3155290782,
-0.4181606174,
0.0674088001,
-0.046752777,
-0.0993835181,
0.5037522912,
0.6744294763,
-0.2317711711,
-0.0975567326,
-0.4652172327,
-0.4951823354,
-0.4123637676,
0.3899427652,
-0.4823000431,
-0.3738254309,
0.7019329667,
0.4373866916,
-0.2634291649,
0.1936829984,
0.2917427421,
-0.0326963328,
0.961987555,
0.6772543192,
0.0371583439,
0.7503845096,
-0.1056045666,
0.0746360719,
-0.8127039075,
0.1540050805,
-0.174362421,
0.1245694831,
-0.3237573802,
-0.2623853683,
0.1145821363,
-0.0952915475,
0.0034990341,
0.2490311116,
-0.2148676068,
0.718803823,
0.4162875116,
0.6784957051,
0.3290892839,
-0.1618715823,
0.1297931373,
-0.0887747929,
-0.7064065337,
-0.1773365885,
1.3719117641,
0.2656596899,
0.5617146492,
0.0660003796,
-0.0009239734,
0.126442194,
0.6088277698,
-0.747084856,
0.379109472,
-0.3969680071,
-0.4853341281,
-0.2862573564,
-0.2987729311,
-0.5876232982,
0.3129125834,
-0.4023235738,
-0.6672196984,
0.3455617726,
0.5589640141,
-0.5124281645,
0.0037064517,
-0.7476891875,
0.7875475883,
0.0586087964,
-0.7520061135,
-0.0274829902,
-0.5371159911,
0.5769136548,
-0.3197544515,
-0.1800022423,
0.4320688546,
0.1626490355,
0.8652549982,
-0.2937731445,
1.0207377672,
-0.005745024,
-0.1279218942,
0.2792059779,
0.1260049194,
0.5189983845,
0.1343871653,
0.1050397977,
0.0442202762,
-0.2498244941,
-0.4863307476,
-0.9637913108,
0.4557892382,
-0.5130261183,
-0.5734644532,
-0.3130097687,
-0.4953945279,
-0.6262884736,
-0.1260216236,
0.3061820865,
0.589615047,
-0.3287828863,
0.4112227857,
0.9085195065,
-0.1976750493,
0.3426908851,
0.738630414,
-0.0216917098,
-0.2129236758,
0.8577035666,
0.0379171111,
0.4440277815,
0.3940081298,
0.2420682013,
-0.466263175,
-0.1514270753,
-0.1273275912,
-0.0964592025,
-0.6299434304,
-0.0971049666,
-0.6339538097,
0.1100769266,
-0.2025852352,
-0.1528986096,
-0.4390709996,
-0.3292646706,
-0.2528705001,
-0.0835998729,
0.1439400762,
0.5549373031,
-0.1159732863,
0.5165463686,
-0.1354881078,
0.3750939667,
0.5445901752,
0.3673322499,
0.1919877529,
-0.7100108266,
-0.0847036913,
-0.0515633337,
-0.3457317948,
-0.6957868338,
0.3370562196,
0.4320742488,
0.3318785727,
0.3836776912,
-0.0199730732,
0.7542171478,
-0.3665571213,
0.5358310938,
0.3679609299,
-1.1323832273,
0.5206244588,
-0.2181400955,
0.3216374516,
0.5201871395,
0.3807369173,
-0.1414418221,
-0.5229378343,
-0.5873035192,
-0.5141599774,
0.6957162619,
0.1141898185,
-0.1521130055,
0.1312418282,
0.0103813251,
0.0164176021,
0.0019067015,
-0.978443265,
0.0975545943,
-0.5633965135,
0.0569178089,
-0.4392661154,
-0.2866185606,
-0.2643633187,
-0.4080962539,
0.7036342025,
-0.1428335309,
-0.0145737967,
0.3185215294,
-0.1457969695,
-0.1104935333,
0.1270170659,
0.6174298525,
0.5639175773,
-0.5813410878,
0.2802251875,
0.4820359945,
-0.5785999298,
0.0309832599,
-0.138656497,
-0.1735025197,
0.1638568044,
0.7230531573,
0.8343689442,
0.1598314345,
-0.3274315298,
0.8051616549,
-0.2075422853,
-0.1540098637,
-0.1873352081,
0.0751063824,
-0.2111427933,
-0.2597804964,
0.1246233359,
0.1173544824,
0.4033535421,
-0.5146951079,
0.5097512603,
0.41180408,
-0.6082357168,
-0.4638115168,
0.4772922993,
0.1422772408,
0.2385112643,
0.4045024216,
0.0000389551,
-0.5627683997,
0.6627987027,
0.8047606945,
0.8363714814,
-0.2290298641,
0.1532827914,
0.4438354671,
0.3712410331,
-0.0480140224,
0.0720402077,
-0.2285400927,
-0.8041480184,
-0.5876383781,
-0.3084276319,
-0.4805062115,
0.4182382524,
-0.9021880031,
0.2204274237,
-0.2550926507,
-0.2954998612,
0.2088851482,
-0.0984930545,
-0.6786436439,
0.3802244067,
-0.4006906152,
0.5345545411,
-1.3954837322,
0.8244054914,
0.6061253548,
-0.6239905357,
-0.3179981112,
0.208461985,
-0.1754690707,
-0.790456593,
0.8162335753,
0.0984793454,
-0.0992444754,
-0.2275593281,
-0.7248442769,
-0.6910771728,
0.5025093555,
0.2403355092,
-0.3980160356,
0.3017095923,
0.1948560327,
0.6769838333,
-0.2138296068,
0.667209506,
0.3885858953,
0.2075487822,
-0.092592828,
-0.990447402,
0.1575773507,
-0.3564420044,
0.0686705559,
-0.2300510705,
-0.3976818919,
0.733821094,
-0.0443816334,
-0.2553480566,
-0.1750318557,
0.3182756603,
0.1547289193,
0.305787921,
0.7337468266,
0.6537526846,
0.2790608108,
-0.0312387571,
1.0305690765,
0.015925467,
0.3908240199,
1.579890132,
-0.3017010391,
1.0810379982,
0.7821000218,
-0.3400989771,
0.2518019974,
0.5162085295,
-0.0186083652,
0.6989861727,
0.2755232751,
-0.081194602,
-0.3911951184,
-0.463789463,
-0.2996015549,
0.3596911132,
0.259750098,
-0.2121104002,
-0.1927811205,
0.2742527723,
-0.0049850056,
0.0581880473,
0.0145752029,
0.820569396,
0.1344051361,
-0.5844212174,
0.8855342865,
-0.5575780869,
0.5375905037,
-0.4310126305,
-0.1600965708,
-0.4516009092,
0.1996561289,
-0.1318997443,
-0.5349856615,
0.569677949,
-0.0232790392,
-0.4389714897,
0.0540433601,
0.4476618469,
-0.3697325885,
-0.4027913511,
0.441239655,
0.2639835775,
-0.0382317863,
-0.0889856219,
-0.6661956906,
0.0119562056,
-0.0596510842,
-0.3597562909,
0.1909501255,
0.1637584567,
-0.0936725438,
0.7899038196,
0.6991993785,
0.0350263678,
-0.1605742127,
0.2789440751,
0.853926003,
-0.3791745305,
-0.3795416057,
-0.8135813475,
0.216007039,
-0.0476774983,
-0.3680978715,
0.6090518236,
0.364639163,
0.8503856063,
-0.1985798627,
0.5695383549,
0.3216024637,
0.593557477,
-0.6260871291,
0.430993557,
-0.7226096392,
0.159945637,
-0.28810516,
-0.8353227973,
-0.5056626797,
0.4829462767,
-0.622636795,
-0.1897030175,
0.9810305238,
0.7494225502,
-0.2868713737,
0.0653922558,
0.3545936048,
0.164865911,
0.1340472996,
0.6947624683,
0.8402204514,
-0.6107832789,
0.3314554989,
-0.3812882602,
-0.2464535683,
-0.0324206911,
-0.8432306051,
-1.020052433,
-0.3761449158,
-0.5151958466,
-0.1562734693,
0.3887415826,
0.3572505713,
0.4540384114,
-1.0430153608,
0.0207605232,
-0.478097558,
-0.158758983,
-0.2281613052,
-0.2109963596,
0.5215251446,
-0.3595176339,
-0.406706363,
0.2549796999,
-0.0151291406,
0.1750985533,
-0.0622019954,
0.1935403049,
-0.3589649498,
0.1631640941,
0.591704309,
0.2209346294,
-0.7401551008,
-0.3520772755,
-0.1566784084,
0.0069582998,
-0.078842558,
0.5407987833,
-0.663985312,
0.6237459779,
0.4016826153,
0.375869453,
0.3539592326,
0.0760532022,
0.6480070353,
-0.7603017688,
0.336859256,
-0.1231859624,
0.3133347332,
0.3555320501,
-0.2112601399,
0.7840451598,
0.3276523352,
-0.3548502326,
-0.9805610776,
0.0655889139,
-0.8257626295,
-0.1778263301,
0.8116292953,
-0.38725245,
-0.2178245634,
-0.2087517232,
0.1292531192,
0.3574154973,
-0.23179847,
0.8965002298,
0.8875606656,
-0.1464492679,
0.1121119857,
-0.7519068718,
0.6995011568,
1.1217366457,
-0.5008246899,
0.1589859128,
0.1093190908,
0.0456431434,
0.2941405177,
0.5878958106,
0.0758983046,
0.3136739433,
0.2952677608,
0.0976949558,
0.2498708963,
-0.1869638115,
-0.3810909092,
-0.3766430914,
-0.2782122195,
-0.3307651579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09603v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09603v2
|
Self-Contradictory Reasoning Evaluation and Detection
| 2023-11-16T06:22:17 | 2024-02-19T18:01:56 |
Ziyi Liu, Isabelle Lee, Yongkang Du, Soumya Sanyal, Jieyu Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In a plethora of recent work, large language models (LLMs) demonstrated
impressive reasoning ability, but many proposed downstream reasoning tasks
focus on performance-wise evaluation. Two fundamental questions persist: 1) how
reliable is the quality of reasoning, and 2) can models detect unreliable
reasoning? In this paper, we investigate self-contradictory (Self-Contra)
reasoning, where the model reasoning does not support predictions. To address
1), we assess the Self-Contra rate across four datasets and delve into
finer-grained categories of Self-Contra reasoning. We find that LLMs often
contradict themselves when performing reasoning tasks that involve contextual
information understanding or commonsense. Importantly, a higher accuracy does
not necessarily correspond to a lower Self-Contra rate. The model may appear to
generate correct answers but it may take shortcuts in reasoning or skip over
contextual evidence, thereby displaying Self-Contra behaviors with compromised
reasoning. As for 2), we task GPT-4 with identifying Self-Contra reasoning and
finer-grained fallacies. We observe that GPT-4 struggles to effectively detect
Self-Contra reasoning, with significantly low performance compared with human
judgment. Our results indicate that the current LLMs lack robustness necessary
for reliable reasoning and we emphasize the urgent need for establishing best
practices in comprehensive reasoning evaluations beyond accuracy-based metrics.
|
[
-0.2681363523,
-0.6249110103,
1.1810257435,
0.1220379546,
-0.1073309854,
-0.0637300089,
0.1589349061,
-0.3880412579,
-0.2695329487,
0.3736895025,
-0.8737972379,
-0.200166598,
-0.4235702157,
0.3565872014,
-0.3721157312,
0.9533632994,
-0.0341273025,
0.0143640442,
-0.3732987344,
-0.060339842,
-0.7854714394,
-0.5557899475,
-0.1971258819,
-0.6156440377,
0.3296952248,
0.3443846405,
0.649420023,
0.4705638885,
0.2161503732,
0.3406006098,
0.3273534179,
-0.0396434031,
-0.433752805,
0.2252337635,
-0.7647545934,
-0.2785347402,
-0.3825562596,
0.149872303,
0.3546696305,
0.2185629755,
0.1167014837,
0.1086632237,
0.0817289054,
0.5315688252,
-0.5221407413,
-0.0871315971,
-0.8148094416,
-0.2069424242,
-0.372543484,
-0.0522382855,
-0.2798089385,
-0.0620981231,
-0.0173637886,
-0.2029041946,
0.425167501,
-0.0539796948,
0.6972571611,
0.5985023975,
-0.3728999496,
-0.4368454516,
-0.6764652133,
0.7869668603,
-0.966037333,
0.3653947115,
0.4628304541,
0.33192119,
-0.1203608587,
-0.5490585566,
-0.7223706245,
-0.4543756843,
0.0182869826,
0.3044354618,
-0.3965360522,
-0.221324414,
0.3545260429,
0.2920907438,
-0.6553188562,
0.1911198497,
-0.0303259436,
-0.2945422828,
0.6077254415,
0.3324390352,
-0.0344985537,
-0.5100317597,
-0.5204073787,
0.2721196413,
-0.7280956507,
-0.1399490982,
0.8418826461,
0.162476927,
0.2194824815,
0.4467948973,
-0.2253454775,
0.4654867053,
0.2558115721,
0.1383617073,
0.1031519845,
-0.6414346695,
-0.1617075503,
-0.2210049331,
0.930514276,
0.1824878305,
-0.0267752428,
-0.0095847826,
-0.5571867824,
0.1110216156,
0.259503454,
-0.4138600826,
-0.2988468111,
0.3505430222,
-0.3430382013,
-0.0391285568,
-0.266957581,
-0.6539698243,
-0.235499084,
-0.1385007799,
0.7958666682,
-0.3312262595,
-0.2274528146,
0.1245008186,
-0.0331943557,
0.0515500009,
0.3767551184,
-0.6571199894,
0.1433190405,
0.569501996,
0.5164065957,
-0.093034558,
-0.4860750139,
-0.240007624,
-0.0489098318,
-0.3310057521,
1.0252459049,
-0.3882772923,
-0.2934358418,
-0.5464276075,
0.1719277203,
0.0278845206,
-0.4738830924,
1.0529688597,
-0.1697879732,
0.4019098282,
-0.7559520006,
-0.6240933537,
-0.1820818186,
0.3387141526,
-0.4337891936,
0.6645286083,
0.0135229379,
-0.8330623507,
0.2818721533,
-0.3829953969,
-0.2330210209,
-0.0222016815,
-0.3090129793,
-0.4940563142,
-0.0418987982,
0.1818024367,
0.3968306184,
-0.4345874786,
0.4559138417,
-0.7336241007,
-0.5452615619,
0.1533670723,
-0.879163146,
0.6451498866,
0.3133374155,
-0.692927897,
-0.1821048409,
-0.454195261,
-0.0394488461,
0.2985439599,
0.0504529737,
-0.3146630526,
0.1275822073,
-0.5244411826,
0.3120877445,
0.3813579082,
-0.5285292268,
0.2217375785,
-0.1484796852,
0.4110528827,
0.9213322997,
-0.3216905892,
-0.0486151688,
-0.3791329563,
0.4009821117,
0.0247474685,
0.2703567743,
0.0360625051,
-0.60458529,
-0.5209686756,
0.1166566536,
0.0708785728,
0.5131433606,
-0.7251288295,
0.3613661528,
-0.1500671208,
-0.3851562738,
-0.2613961995,
0.1780846417,
0.619373858,
1.0216813087,
0.654519856,
-0.1016173661,
-0.4371521175,
-1.0723788738,
-0.8525803685,
-0.3669646084,
0.2791944146,
0.09784244,
0.753311336,
-0.2508497536,
0.8456949592,
-0.1486741155,
-0.036498148,
-0.0582903139,
0.3544824719,
0.3908481598,
0.3926049471,
0.3395149708,
-0.4731355011,
0.0155463722,
-0.3764488399,
-0.8161067367,
-0.5245859623,
-0.1183982268,
0.2312507033,
0.3378172517,
0.3938851953,
-0.445487529,
0.4087044895,
0.6991581321,
-0.3829726577,
1.0656512976,
-0.1346536279,
0.1059470922,
-0.4222644269,
0.0022105153,
0.0217175409,
-0.2368409187,
-0.4410685897,
-0.1676318496,
0.0059821778,
0.4936139286,
-0.0741696507,
0.7090174556,
-0.4336332381,
-0.1100011021,
-0.485152334,
0.0991679206,
0.2363106459,
0.2801088393,
-0.0448211506,
0.840441227,
0.2952648997,
-0.4159682393,
0.3661087453,
0.0342839099,
-0.2425202578,
0.6845734715,
-0.7600627542,
0.1390896887,
0.0251110457,
0.3468374014,
-1.1161944866,
-0.1560617387,
0.391340524,
-0.3110053241,
0.2282194197,
-0.3983539343,
-0.3499175012,
-0.6245346665,
-0.1083632931,
0.5292572975,
0.265937537,
-0.6513587832,
0.4010718763,
-0.0949659124,
0.1280862242,
-1.0293438435,
-0.8279380798,
-0.0956276208,
-0.1395764202,
-0.4444783926,
-0.0130305933,
-0.07090877,
-0.1754465848,
0.2299096137,
-0.4410108924,
-0.0347577333,
-0.00450134,
0.2432638854,
0.1225601807,
-0.2374578118,
0.2541691661,
-0.0741555467,
-0.1114565358,
0.2460442334,
-0.3898254633,
0.179081738,
-0.5717694759,
-1.0337036848,
-0.3856133521,
0.0251799058,
0.5010928512,
0.1944849044,
0.2999704182,
0.4514558017,
-0.2027970701,
0.0426789783,
-0.9501420856,
-0.0700806826,
-0.4304330349,
0.1830645949,
-0.7839112282,
-0.69280231,
0.5003277063,
0.0161066875,
-0.2649186552,
0.831507206,
0.5840982199,
-0.1141847223,
1.0083407164,
0.0023691854,
0.1553384364,
-0.0780056641,
-0.1007290408,
0.4198077321,
-0.7137224674,
-0.169250831,
-0.4188207686,
0.0925316289,
-0.7297053933,
-0.1592590958,
0.2705645859,
0.116837725,
-0.4154567122,
0.3468947709,
-0.38054353,
0.5072223544,
0.4427209198,
0.0861519799,
0.4557761848,
-0.5507539511,
-0.1608378291,
0.0832434073,
-0.7180863619,
-0.714962244,
0.988086164,
0.40988186,
0.9639538527,
0.1521945745,
0.4859094024,
0.3419083357,
0.2922159731,
-0.4073940217,
0.3852863014,
-0.2819571793,
-0.8428993225,
-0.329449892,
-0.6650784612,
-0.831033349,
0.2037129551,
0.0203383211,
-0.488365978,
0.2195405513,
0.2827554047,
-0.2318464667,
0.2610248327,
-0.8918451071,
1.2204488516,
-0.5653610229,
-0.5240565538,
-0.0403239094,
-0.6072081327,
0.8836535215,
-0.2976588905,
0.1213552803,
-0.4099579453,
0.274825573,
0.2670146823,
-0.3121959567,
0.6811192036,
-0.1508288682,
-0.1818022728,
0.3385855854,
0.4426425397,
0.3336474299,
0.0461330712,
-0.2333610356,
0.4769053459,
0.204280749,
-0.3630886078,
-0.7572600245,
0.8618628383,
-0.6432157159,
-1.0471278429,
-0.5914546847,
-0.3433206379,
-0.2313483506,
0.2508605719,
0.4466903806,
0.4179319143,
-0.1184794828,
-0.3261428475,
0.1710973829,
-0.0928791985,
0.1542390138,
0.485014379,
-0.0014870309,
-0.1574621052,
0.8380455375,
0.2297304124,
0.3589760065,
0.0725055337,
0.4620046616,
-0.9699878693,
-0.5000840425,
-0.5573566556,
0.2657496333,
-0.9522498846,
-0.2962420583,
-0.3900780678,
-0.0546349287,
-0.4698531032,
0.3968092501,
-0.4627424181,
-0.3798759878,
-0.1342799813,
0.1099055186,
-0.2380927056,
0.9457384944,
-0.302921474,
-0.113087967,
-0.5507113934,
0.2564503253,
0.6344242096,
0.3793492913,
0.0229117107,
-0.7205909491,
0.3046526611,
0.0435608216,
-0.4790756702,
-0.9218626022,
0.0100810761,
-0.1698247939,
0.8446487188,
0.5300639272,
0.0739455074,
0.6865794659,
-0.5210252404,
0.7511950135,
0.1230794191,
-1.3338335752,
0.591142118,
-0.3862926662,
0.1782330275,
0.3429360688,
0.4891596437,
-0.1035992578,
-0.4063153565,
-0.6553814411,
-0.3548755646,
0.5979523659,
0.2496950924,
-0.0129187526,
-0.0267623458,
0.4313108623,
0.456118077,
0.0047411453,
-1.0703750849,
-0.0004181153,
-0.6601853967,
0.003301027,
-0.0128011955,
-0.3321562707,
-0.1650279909,
-0.1838251054,
0.7024158835,
-0.3189019859,
0.1439982802,
0.4644241333,
0.2044084668,
-0.0911590904,
0.3238075674,
0.682364285,
0.8161205053,
-0.1393984854,
0.3869071305,
0.2163641006,
0.0602968931,
0.3840530813,
0.0630745664,
-0.1255003512,
-0.1403079331,
0.5844419003,
0.6003946066,
-0.0405335538,
-0.4882075191,
0.9504671693,
-0.1320251226,
-0.1698628664,
-0.2599336803,
0.0570894517,
0.0013080416,
0.3785898983,
0.087573275,
0.224464342,
0.2695400119,
-0.7094268203,
0.1165134981,
0.71640414,
-0.122244738,
-0.4351263344,
0.7369090319,
0.0310974848,
-0.0208237823,
0.5792518258,
-0.3349506259,
-0.7745112777,
0.3040905893,
0.4484649301,
0.8838472962,
-0.3984662294,
0.0806164742,
0.2055288702,
0.506655097,
-0.3283812106,
0.2129398733,
-0.0341097675,
-0.8876689076,
-0.6281425357,
-0.3393240571,
-0.3771053851,
0.4459342957,
-0.3036553562,
0.2930478156,
-0.2957967818,
-0.2498559952,
-0.1360171139,
-0.0901694894,
-0.4503812492,
0.2413963377,
0.0697860345,
0.6609193087,
-0.8501870632,
0.6021924615,
0.1410997808,
-0.432454735,
-0.7346435785,
0.41100806,
0.1150674224,
-0.7355262637,
0.6272497773,
0.2341400385,
-0.5994912386,
-0.5014922619,
-0.6219979525,
-0.7603350282,
0.7880889177,
0.5757815242,
-0.5596878529,
0.0993365124,
-0.0678783208,
0.6245036125,
-0.0919958428,
0.5724557042,
0.4367974102,
0.5982470512,
0.2136640698,
-1.1257579327,
0.32048437,
0.1836296618,
-0.3154193759,
-0.1441196352,
-0.7531703115,
1.0120557547,
-0.2632500827,
-0.1922123134,
0.2175199687,
0.3655637801,
0.2199871093,
0.6308240294,
0.6184003353,
0.7433053851,
0.6450639367,
-0.1324132979,
1.0951956511,
-0.0290744081,
0.478828162,
1.2596187592,
-0.606552422,
0.5579516292,
0.2208715081,
0.0006773418,
0.830989182,
0.5515512228,
-0.1602873951,
0.3076450527,
-0.0521602519,
-0.0591168366,
-0.8038457036,
0.2755287886,
-0.2948873043,
0.7016271949,
0.259927243,
-0.110030666,
-0.4116266966,
-0.3339931369,
-0.2000347525,
0.1170832738,
-0.0162994787,
0.1888290793,
0.0492986143,
-1.0128871202,
0.7809360623,
-0.0039846627,
0.3108193576,
-0.3805268705,
-0.0733370483,
-0.252859205,
0.2194707394,
-0.2664704323,
-1.2145513296,
0.4686529934,
-0.0502304956,
0.0179704502,
-0.2155274302,
0.8533022404,
0.0070625395,
-0.1517126709,
0.4278413057,
1.0158902407,
0.4355395138,
-0.104604587,
-1.0522425175,
-0.1293661892,
-0.074817352,
-0.0441461988,
0.0449470133,
0.6577861309,
-0.1740653366,
0.9172513485,
0.6351037621,
-0.1489784718,
-0.1496412009,
0.2267866284,
0.7909889221,
-0.5727979541,
-0.1927156299,
-1.1866027117,
-0.0961665288,
0.1156682372,
-0.2434485704,
0.9544257522,
0.3802218437,
0.7718518376,
-0.0005381107,
0.8048121333,
0.1535646468,
0.6896524429,
-0.6348146796,
0.1962727308,
-0.6506292224,
0.5232160091,
-0.417195797,
-0.6327795386,
0.0147137027,
0.5280359983,
-0.8206839561,
0.4470491707,
0.8039918542,
0.639306128,
-0.319514215,
0.2655114233,
0.4683822989,
0.597430706,
0.2536401749,
0.6979928613,
1.4675251245,
-0.3562958837,
0.6431131959,
-0.0245605223,
0.0144981137,
-0.0007450531,
-1.1008155346,
-0.8802868724,
-0.5015640259,
-0.1746598482,
-0.4950093031,
0.1365603209,
0.420231998,
0.6802678704,
-0.697503686,
0.0218061563,
-0.4924006462,
0.4091939926,
-0.1384047419,
-0.2081378251,
0.1115537509,
-0.3644991219,
-0.499789685,
0.5117262006,
0.342392087,
0.0563669987,
-0.5641926527,
-0.1075567231,
-0.0530019477,
0.0446096361,
0.1097630486,
0.3661694825,
-1.1934616566,
-0.6102653742,
-0.2931517959,
-0.0142804561,
0.0248859953,
0.6796082258,
-0.8291538954,
0.3211033344,
0.4722861946,
0.3615747094,
0.3665836751,
0.4486754239,
0.3803103268,
-0.4039835334,
-0.4299854338,
0.3742915392,
0.3969456553,
0.401594907,
-0.4969356656,
0.4375662506,
0.6804940701,
-1.0487533808,
-0.7045228481,
0.4984529912,
-0.6304892302,
-0.4791798592,
0.9934498072,
-0.3395080566,
-0.1182134151,
-0.4347543716,
0.0589476749,
-0.0997136757,
-0.0511538163,
0.7663738728,
0.8423301578,
-0.8188000321,
-0.0337606408,
-0.5579431057,
0.3565153778,
0.6423370242,
-0.5804243088,
0.065223664,
0.551201582,
0.7097684145,
0.2839824855,
0.7548680902,
0.0485502295,
0.28031528,
0.0469161533,
-0.3924650252,
0.0118945399,
-0.2445380241,
-0.4396434426,
-0.0443113856,
-0.0318621695,
0.0531382859
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09602v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09602v2
|
Language Models (Mostly) Do Not Consider Emotion Triggers When Predicting Emotion
| 2023-11-16T06:20:13 | 2024-03-25T20:42:57 |
Smriti Singh, Cornelia Caragea, Junyi Jessy Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Situations and events evoke emotions in humans, but to what extent do they
inform the prediction of emotion detection models? This work investigates how
well human-annotated emotion triggers correlate with features that models
deemed salient in their prediction of emotions. First, we introduce a novel
dataset EmoTrigger, consisting of 900 social media posts sourced from three
different datasets; these were annotated by experts for emotion triggers with
high agreement. Using EmoTrigger, we evaluate the ability of large language
models (LLMs) to identify emotion triggers, and conduct a comparative analysis
of the features considered important for these tasks between LLMs and
fine-tuned models. Our analysis reveals that emotion triggers are largely not
considered salient features for emotion prediction models, instead there is
intricate interplay between various features and the task of emotion detection.
|
[
-0.6000960469,
-0.4075345099,
0.468485713,
0.051136516,
-0.2292065918,
-0.1775716692,
-0.3778459728,
-0.9303449392,
0.3681072593,
0.0180359427,
-0.4687158465,
-0.3752456009,
-0.597614646,
0.2235540301,
-0.5701887608,
0.7519704103,
0.2807848454,
-0.4850955904,
-0.0488151237,
-0.0575035624,
0.0428434461,
-0.7251029015,
-0.3206544816,
-0.5266609192,
0.7511241436,
0.2931877673,
0.4527961612,
0.1945893466,
0.4182171822,
0.1743743867,
-0.1461078674,
-0.2174259722,
-0.3800565898,
0.2928079367,
0.3525299132,
-0.4757501483,
-0.1630364358,
-0.060247045,
-0.0507827178,
0.0513428114,
0.2686327696,
0.300026834,
-0.1657055318,
0.5666975379,
-0.7571796179,
0.0692342818,
-0.6023980975,
0.1377757639,
-0.2728824019,
-0.0779376402,
-0.2946868539,
-0.4658280611,
0.3541636765,
0.1108973697,
0.2406610847,
0.2147148699,
0.6761539578,
0.5312201381,
-0.5766531229,
-0.3416284025,
-0.2732473016,
0.4577417076,
-0.4922482073,
0.0874357373,
0.3786555529,
-0.1419084966,
0.2360282093,
-0.0020790405,
-0.6372020245,
-0.1375055015,
-0.2952218354,
-0.1174182966,
-0.4278500378,
0.0829846039,
0.643964529,
0.0295357294,
-0.4351063669,
0.2739828527,
-0.0502008796,
0.029695794,
0.8695166111,
0.1308270842,
0.220322594,
-0.3731952906,
-0.2636695504,
0.1831550002,
-0.6375346184,
0.2442651391,
0.3560353518,
0.2779850662,
-0.3583923876,
0.4749737382,
0.0246508904,
0.5662843585,
0.1898480803,
0.2530947924,
0.1028566957,
0.4580454826,
-0.1345261186,
0.3619210124,
0.9615806341,
0.4174251556,
0.9330921769,
0.058367718,
-0.0906524658,
0.382371515,
0.0863331705,
-0.5022337437,
-0.3368302286,
0.5057822466,
-0.0847778842,
-0.3396191597,
0.0202416833,
-0.8523059487,
-0.6583080292,
0.1060109437,
0.0870102048,
-0.1251057237,
-0.273173362,
-0.146619454,
0.047682371,
-0.0515901148,
0.3051350713,
-1.1280575991,
-0.0879521519,
0.7664723396,
0.6744346619,
0.0664684102,
-0.1142630428,
-0.1489079446,
-0.1874738038,
-0.3209695518,
1.0040370226,
-0.9100142717,
-0.0528856777,
0.4301024973,
0.18070364,
0.0860453546,
-0.2531685531,
0.5955345631,
-0.3985835612,
-0.1000256464,
-0.719045639,
-0.4716212153,
-0.5351912975,
0.0127525115,
-0.8232298493,
0.9378637075,
-0.1850633621,
-0.7542724609,
0.5700260997,
-0.6773613095,
-0.5517482162,
-0.0491766594,
0.0962392241,
-0.1494184136,
0.4833275974,
0.0625145435,
0.6359022856,
-0.2651757598,
0.2882632911,
-0.5062698126,
-0.4109554887,
0.5089638829,
0.0675956085,
0.1674961597,
-0.0721420422,
-0.3664818406,
0.0784075484,
-0.5338277221,
-0.4129605889,
0.0472749211,
-0.1722210497,
-0.3108571172,
-0.0902827457,
0.1409670711,
0.5649775267,
0.0536349081,
-0.5225669146,
0.0919970572,
-0.0754933432,
0.2080097049,
0.6615448594,
-0.0111813052,
0.3354594111,
-0.0243893825,
0.4947856069,
0.1454825103,
-0.1816492677,
-0.2300445586,
-0.647433877,
-0.7283466458,
-0.024318669,
0.1067527235,
0.3408073783,
-0.1112160608,
0.561111629,
0.2365776151,
-0.6280276179,
-0.5520807505,
-0.038934052,
0.3743753731,
0.1806668639,
-0.0065362277,
-0.0315389931,
-0.5520877838,
-0.6140639186,
-0.636446774,
-0.1670178771,
0.2009087801,
0.171285212,
0.4049954414,
0.1693569273,
0.6851927638,
-0.3710949421,
0.1308289766,
-0.015496538,
0.5506731868,
-0.1622391939,
0.036648538,
0.8104617596,
-0.760112226,
-0.4827829599,
-0.0553414971,
-0.8668271899,
-0.6312357783,
0.2628709078,
0.14434582,
0.4016230106,
0.202664122,
-0.5629578233,
0.6240416765,
0.7627589703,
-0.482357204,
0.1154745966,
0.2149040103,
0.3983569741,
-0.5533089638,
0.0066385716,
0.4230349064,
0.1443327814,
-0.8202183247,
-0.6144790053,
0.4112765193,
-0.1595928222,
-0.4055748582,
0.8668808341,
-0.3846173882,
-0.3666185737,
-0.3235215247,
0.1123895496,
0.027396746,
0.4230369031,
0.0951617956,
0.2270080298,
0.3799038529,
-0.5559407473,
0.348310262,
0.2960971892,
-0.3301506639,
0.505746305,
-0.3554147184,
0.086680837,
-0.0808522627,
-0.2190820426,
-1.1187876463,
-0.7474854589,
0.085969016,
-0.5523344874,
0.3206813931,
-0.1142240539,
-0.5526582599,
-0.411776036,
-0.2245938331,
0.0681030378,
0.6952722073,
-0.5841006637,
0.4147182107,
0.2085646391,
-0.1464906186,
-0.3534129858,
-0.7153428793,
-0.1109650657,
-0.4294609427,
-0.4785359502,
-0.2233126909,
0.384683609,
-0.4056077302,
0.0006688942,
0.1087262332,
0.1776038259,
0.3153195977,
1.0216230154,
-0.0927227587,
0.1635397673,
0.803822875,
0.0464945994,
-0.1843918115,
-0.0266804192,
0.4808689356,
0.2775364816,
0.1562209874,
-0.5854263902,
-0.4202332497,
0.1784614176,
0.6771258116,
-0.175978899,
0.6666039824,
0.7026577592,
-0.5754759312,
0.1223481596,
-0.7004237771,
-0.3519453108,
-0.3670327961,
0.3505494297,
-0.2767382562,
-1.1504380703,
0.7379255891,
-0.0125019057,
-0.2644142807,
0.4399084747,
0.6871028543,
-0.2545652688,
1.0769215822,
0.664611578,
-0.1273560077,
0.8167449832,
0.455863595,
0.378947407,
-0.8799334168,
0.0159255229,
-0.597708106,
-0.6518019438,
-0.6159870028,
0.1362785101,
0.1061228812,
-0.0642021224,
-0.1811181158,
0.1175400615,
-0.2266491354,
0.2247201502,
0.2816295624,
-0.3946963549,
-0.1229311004,
-0.0125868553,
0.6057587266,
-0.1131087095,
-0.536039114,
-0.548974514,
0.750304997,
0.273293972,
0.7854811549,
0.0394972675,
0.5298060179,
0.1618803144,
0.4022856653,
-0.5605005026,
0.3394731283,
-0.1451085508,
-0.7639349699,
-0.0982613489,
0.1592506915,
-0.7358263135,
-0.1366134733,
-0.5989786983,
-1.2145951986,
0.5874232054,
0.1717942208,
-0.5821638107,
0.1093047634,
-0.9737806916,
0.696986258,
-0.3844332695,
-0.3153341413,
0.0662300736,
-0.4298250675,
0.3410439491,
-0.3539528549,
0.1575636715,
-0.7530094981,
0.1340210289,
0.5574906468,
0.0163699687,
1.1206929684,
-0.0585086904,
-0.0426716581,
0.206248343,
0.2400734276,
0.4642476737,
-0.4612585902,
-0.4840925932,
0.0700274408,
-0.4294177294,
-0.1523149014,
-0.4739768207,
0.6229751706,
-0.5332560539,
-0.4425963163,
-0.3264232874,
-0.4939427376,
-0.0094688945,
-0.4025599062,
0.2196640968,
0.0185569767,
-0.0297968555,
-0.1153902039,
0.0656579658,
-0.1896735579,
0.5683419108,
0.3829324543,
0.0356287658,
0.1352518201,
0.5003756881,
0.0285483468,
0.3626030982,
0.1118831113,
0.0731417537,
-0.1203073338,
0.0818307325,
-0.0227486994,
0.1609835178,
-1.0400900841,
-0.1451493502,
-0.7375075221,
0.1459158212,
-0.4840595424,
-0.2946960032,
-0.1500127614,
-0.2221082002,
-0.3892748058,
-0.3480444551,
1.2422609329,
1.0398602486,
-0.2775112987,
0.2874315679,
-0.8434228897,
-0.0401863195,
0.3494647145,
0.2248366624,
0.0857620612,
-0.6053540707,
-0.2928024232,
-0.3054041862,
0.0155184958,
-0.9694030285,
0.6730394363,
0.4305766821,
0.1588638574,
0.8016492724,
0.1733638793,
0.3901751637,
-0.0722787753,
0.888972044,
-0.0094405403,
-1.030673027,
0.69578439,
-0.1654929519,
0.1170362756,
0.1556005031,
0.7086435556,
-0.6527236104,
-0.288028419,
-0.5426848531,
-0.5103840828,
0.6992272139,
-0.1964974701,
0.1046293452,
-0.2732591629,
0.3483432531,
0.1766203046,
0.2943187952,
-0.5632711649,
-0.053922113,
0.2035500407,
-0.3546521962,
-0.1221690029,
-0.6771109104,
0.1136946008,
0.0663600639,
0.2969260812,
-0.0430208892,
0.2165632248,
-0.2253713757,
-0.1482522488,
-0.7477500439,
0.3455815017,
0.5414179564,
0.1417173743,
-0.4039317966,
0.2343113571,
0.1836420596,
-0.2252851278,
0.0756482631,
-0.1164205819,
0.0691596791,
0.0145495813,
0.646438241,
1.0863236189,
0.6795405149,
-0.6118897796,
0.4553073347,
0.2765218914,
0.1336887032,
-0.0122808106,
0.0865706056,
0.2848235071,
0.7686055899,
0.1833010167,
-0.2102926672,
0.036174275,
-0.6827462316,
-0.1170581281,
0.140569821,
-0.7482248545,
-0.7819700241,
0.3434008062,
0.3217999339,
-0.2255159318,
0.2550573349,
-0.2267163992,
-1.155559063,
0.6528818011,
0.1847049296,
1.0360682011,
-0.5500324368,
-0.1913132071,
0.4571503103,
0.1459614784,
-0.0499959439,
0.5079005361,
0.2509756982,
-0.7256090045,
-0.1922586262,
-0.6716867685,
-0.3743584752,
-0.4770522118,
-0.5999610424,
0.4997891486,
-0.1197804511,
-0.2881109118,
0.2105567008,
-0.2146773338,
-0.824624598,
0.4308845699,
0.6853126884,
0.6147034764,
-1.4889403582,
0.7068347335,
0.6083036065,
-0.3726924956,
-0.6275553107,
0.0633399487,
0.3694300056,
-0.7008556128,
0.9994363785,
0.3371013701,
0.4399159551,
-0.1035641283,
-0.5205152631,
-0.6193073988,
0.7234831452,
0.3337441981,
-0.5605635643,
0.1493421197,
-0.092754066,
0.6880996823,
-0.6020569801,
0.4995849133,
0.4735587537,
0.5249878168,
0.2474585325,
-0.7470450997,
0.0405832976,
-0.2302597761,
-0.3001722395,
0.3077538311,
-0.5029695034,
1.1537109613,
-0.4050173461,
-0.3202404678,
-0.4050860107,
0.0723645836,
0.1573293805,
0.3224203885,
0.3602703214,
0.5215258598,
0.5237814188,
-0.5025011301,
1.1414163113,
-0.4563282728,
0.4334235489,
0.8907344341,
-0.7262073755,
1.2031286955,
0.2911627591,
-0.1604738832,
0.5852429271,
1.0690851212,
-0.043983791,
0.4006165564,
0.0226029586,
-0.2936193347,
-0.6198356152,
-0.3552815616,
-0.216576606,
0.6208401918,
0.4843807518,
-0.732798636,
0.0268647373,
0.0269760117,
-0.1833367646,
-0.3718782365,
-0.1720290631,
0.8733282089,
0.1810329705,
-0.4031741321,
0.1553818285,
-0.562982738,
0.710329771,
-0.19021447,
0.1144892573,
-0.1232559457,
-0.1329206526,
-0.4696927667,
-0.946616292,
0.1725178957,
0.3617167771,
-0.0993128717,
0.3052554727,
1.0276994705,
-0.3915049434,
-0.1073339507,
0.4838747382,
0.3807420731,
0.2596262991,
-0.4413660169,
-0.3528288901,
0.3076099753,
-0.1979976445,
-0.5954764485,
0.254627496,
0.961473763,
-0.0527890474,
0.4918128848,
0.4487689734,
-0.2143436819,
0.0015056146,
0.091564402,
0.5214146376,
-0.9670222402,
-0.1175291315,
-0.9949347377,
0.868616581,
0.1128689945,
-0.1504352391,
0.3859814703,
-0.1227080077,
0.3277821541,
-0.1831695437,
0.9249123931,
-0.0535441115,
0.3687421381,
-0.213426888,
0.5363531113,
-0.6514276266,
-0.08399795,
-0.481785953,
-0.720446229,
-0.2967103422,
0.4958131313,
-0.8873075843,
0.3057686985,
0.420997262,
0.6320801377,
0.3040344715,
0.3216404915,
0.689807415,
0.303542614,
-0.0170940366,
0.6991020441,
1.0138361454,
-0.1268393695,
-0.1093209609,
-0.1816451102,
0.0674244985,
-1.0172480345,
-1.1069308519,
-1.1266312599,
-0.6275384426,
-0.422216922,
-0.0580644459,
-0.1147922799,
1.0793548822,
0.4127194285,
-1.0608196259,
0.2144698352,
0.3582392335,
0.1713606864,
0.3391106427,
-0.1064597517,
0.3131795824,
-0.1696887761,
-0.5656852722,
-0.2299363017,
0.6030706763,
0.1762967855,
-0.0072850366,
0.0532810204,
-0.262467742,
-0.0432919934,
0.4444105923,
0.3767735362,
-1.0104095936,
-0.8209117651,
-0.1304106414,
-0.1815328747,
-0.0759667307,
0.2600901425,
-0.4839059711,
0.3980790377,
0.5348832011,
0.0892018899,
0.2674618363,
-0.1614101827,
0.4401300251,
-0.7509971261,
0.484698534,
-0.0120965857,
0.4998880029,
0.4834567904,
-0.6035863161,
0.6192412972,
0.011357828,
-0.5838007331,
-0.6643695235,
0.2982883453,
-0.7706538439,
0.2903658748,
1.0708733797,
-0.3588119745,
-0.2905796468,
0.1344183683,
-0.0652834624,
0.4483290911,
-0.5101536512,
0.8146945834,
0.8591500521,
-0.2633724809,
-0.5487527251,
-0.487064451,
0.7783132792,
0.2586589754,
-0.6849051714,
0.3704193532,
0.456484884,
-0.1260263026,
0.4003767669,
0.0331901163,
0.3461392224,
0.3806226552,
-0.0495080985,
0.6628621817,
0.194372192,
-0.0736644045,
-0.6921796203,
0.153610304,
0.1825921386,
0.2449877709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09593v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09593v2
|
Multi-Step Dialogue Workflow Action Prediction
| 2023-11-16T06:05:47 | 2024-02-13T01:47:52 |
Ramya Ramakrishnan, Ethan R. Elenberg, Hashan Narangodage, Ryan McDonald
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In task-oriented dialogue, a system often needs to follow a sequence of
actions, called a workflow, that complies with a set of guidelines in order to
complete a task. In this paper, we propose the novel problem of multi-step
workflow action prediction, in which the system predicts multiple future
workflow actions. Accurate prediction of multiple steps allows for multi-turn
automation, which can free up time to focus on more complex tasks. We propose
three modeling approaches that are simple to implement yet lead to more action
automation: 1) fine-tuning on a training dataset, 2) few-shot in-context
learning leveraging retrieval and large language model prompting, and 3)
zero-shot graph traversal, which aggregates historical action sequences into a
graph for prediction. We show that multi-step action prediction produces
features that improve accuracy on downstream dialogue tasks like predicting
task success, and can increase automation of steps by 20% without requiring as
much feedback from a human overseeing the system.
|
[
-0.1876977235,
-0.5961185098,
0.7192800641,
-0.0821129978,
0.1011725068,
0.0835730955,
0.4370053113,
-0.4359713793,
0.1245188564,
0.8413076401,
-1.0229399204,
-0.1550534368,
-0.7781678438,
-0.0565762967,
-0.3338261247,
0.7430036068,
-0.2063708901,
0.2946971357,
0.2654929161,
-0.0191434454,
-0.8026807308,
-0.1585247666,
-0.7362003922,
-0.7041327953,
0.8157864809,
0.5377307534,
0.4197873175,
0.2743403316,
0.3124613464,
0.3796824515,
0.072171919,
0.0693240538,
-0.286916256,
0.3750089109,
0.2536576092,
-0.3888607621,
-0.3682322502,
-0.1259974688,
0.14287965,
0.6054573655,
-0.190842703,
-0.0466491468,
-0.0107712215,
0.5999931097,
-0.3124952316,
0.5283702016,
-0.1236455142,
0.1998940557,
0.2446781695,
-0.1317265928,
-0.3120725751,
-0.1227941141,
0.173940748,
-0.2197282612,
-0.0927551463,
-0.0144895762,
0.0362755992,
0.3317456841,
-0.3805042207,
-0.1072027087,
-0.9969080091,
0.4565493762,
-0.8373758793,
0.1060681716,
0.2408011556,
0.6288030148,
-0.3824733198,
-0.595988512,
-0.5572083592,
0.1108101085,
-0.1315366924,
0.0530149341,
0.0019323124,
0.3053098023,
0.6108372808,
-0.0959586278,
-0.345587641,
-0.1759200692,
-0.353122741,
-0.0752333328,
0.3919783533,
0.6473799348,
-0.175517574,
-0.2265385538,
-0.3614296317,
-0.0671998635,
-0.3428083658,
0.3576655388,
-0.0074624852,
0.6281693578,
-0.0259094276,
0.5849537253,
-0.6452897787,
0.7283613682,
0.1031729653,
-0.4805394709,
0.1010396257,
-0.5649137497,
-0.3863692284,
-0.0180270523,
0.6896054149,
0.0298538674,
0.1387933344,
0.2249011099,
0.0056120148,
-0.1635668725,
0.3611572087,
-1.0195100307,
-0.0071054432,
0.537124157,
-0.1420904249,
-0.2645527422,
-0.0796307549,
-0.5841646791,
-0.5633506179,
-0.7784866095,
0.3691674471,
-0.5627086163,
0.1413656622,
-0.0471899994,
-0.0437963121,
0.0371944457,
1.0093166828,
-0.3731462061,
-0.0700294077,
0.7129616141,
0.9512950778,
0.0719092414,
-0.7298182845,
-1.1357502937,
0.2829076946,
-0.3854230642,
0.8575235605,
-0.9221826196,
-0.067862913,
0.114713341,
0.201781258,
-0.231710881,
0.0741709024,
0.2550828457,
-0.2659495473,
0.0122548798,
0.237598747,
-0.397836715,
-0.6987003684,
0.4251642525,
-0.9283517003,
0.4699817598,
-0.0700868368,
-0.4818443358,
0.51942873,
-1.1581139565,
-0.5230759382,
-0.0555811897,
0.062437702,
-0.2680245638,
-0.0207570028,
0.0075421296,
0.7641613483,
0.0086204372,
0.1669323295,
-0.5223116875,
-0.329210192,
-0.0989539176,
-0.3847663403,
0.5153252482,
-0.1678195447,
-0.3283948898,
0.3592462838,
-0.3482417166,
-0.0963698402,
-0.4331706166,
-0.1820109785,
0.3358230293,
-0.0683964416,
-0.5846195221,
0.7812386155,
-0.2459087223,
-0.4407514632,
0.2853288054,
-0.3160814345,
-0.0092108222,
0.6816002131,
0.176593855,
0.4048919678,
-0.4345324934,
0.8011521697,
0.2026745379,
0.2941116691,
-0.6845342517,
-0.8704131842,
-0.547097683,
-0.0684503689,
0.0475306697,
0.746968925,
-0.7015196681,
0.1600406021,
-0.1093568727,
-0.7693340182,
-0.153208971,
0.2965726554,
0.4690446556,
0.4168877304,
0.1602489203,
-0.5253103971,
-0.3453288674,
-0.2640437782,
-0.1800342798,
-0.3140461147,
0.131696552,
0.2437784076,
0.5746999979,
-0.2774060369,
0.6328140497,
-0.682580173,
-0.5860741138,
-0.4243116081,
0.979726851,
0.3073686361,
0.2494933605,
-0.1546187699,
-0.7224165201,
-0.6822418571,
-0.0565629676,
-0.3943997025,
0.5002502203,
-0.1355248243,
-0.1200081632,
-0.0451340489,
0.4915462434,
-0.6003240943,
0.9060000181,
0.4887441397,
-0.0683642104,
0.3130824268,
-0.0136259897,
0.0845242962,
-1.184905529,
-0.2546856701,
0.134118557,
-0.1228891686,
-1.1098679304,
-0.5185272098,
-0.1241788268,
-0.2207139879,
-0.608523488,
0.38606444,
-0.0529778935,
-0.183095023,
-0.2939674854,
-0.3589895368,
-0.2411555648,
1.0394176245,
0.3912289441,
0.4185427725,
0.7338852286,
-0.739546597,
0.497974515,
0.4554311335,
-0.2597981691,
0.4506619275,
-0.3330901563,
0.0866088048,
-0.1284421533,
0.7777510285,
-1.1339924335,
-0.5138724446,
0.0122864228,
-0.5996797085,
0.2517448366,
-0.526818037,
-0.3704480231,
-0.480158329,
-0.1261862963,
0.021174578,
0.1750178188,
-0.1786064059,
0.9971336722,
0.0813004524,
-0.3669824898,
-0.6603415608,
-0.3338545263,
-0.0281069502,
-0.0355292298,
-0.4016631246,
-0.1227087229,
-0.2144347578,
0.2956415713,
-0.5892398953,
0.0236828011,
-0.0673822984,
-0.0037574095,
0.7868109941,
0.1486246139,
0.2885962725,
-0.1526313424,
-0.2464656532,
-0.2280022949,
-0.0753048509,
-0.3632494807,
0.5467934012,
0.2030462623,
-0.6659337878,
-0.669767797,
0.4529932439,
1.0571089983,
-0.0332391299,
0.2669045329,
0.7669143081,
-0.5361739993,
0.1737769246,
-0.1594830453,
-0.4349151552,
-0.3768966794,
0.166706115,
-0.0529650748,
-0.3988992572,
0.2285713106,
-0.4289738238,
0.5935665965,
-0.057309892,
0.6683766246,
-0.3381734788,
1.5534194708,
0.6643779278,
0.0587065704,
0.871783793,
-0.3937676549,
0.5218889713,
-0.7343223691,
-0.3414310217,
-0.4951959848,
-0.4457486272,
-0.500620842,
-0.617320776,
0.4731452763,
-0.0712885484,
-0.2450485528,
0.7481267452,
0.0687081888,
0.0925004706,
0.6524719596,
-0.2475249916,
0.2896561027,
-0.0416293181,
-0.1987390667,
0.2598957121,
-0.5558843613,
-0.4439774156,
1.0058835745,
0.1631886363,
0.7376244068,
-0.0081463391,
0.9253950715,
0.2348447442,
0.2609208822,
-1.0655961037,
0.3188150227,
0.1981391609,
-0.4812198579,
-0.8854820132,
-0.0723108351,
-1.066182971,
0.0919848457,
-0.1043239459,
-0.771197021,
0.0025262721,
0.215381071,
-0.7377954721,
0.0656498522,
-0.5936643481,
0.6437024474,
-0.0490258895,
-0.2006920725,
-0.1729040444,
-0.7127621174,
0.0426973887,
-0.0497214161,
0.4079694748,
-0.2895409465,
0.4070443809,
0.5080992579,
-0.5197477937,
1.1743853092,
-0.3364302516,
0.0163429566,
0.2500443459,
0.1636308283,
0.8990010023,
-0.1791547984,
0.0258387178,
-0.1917741895,
-0.1104307249,
-0.3483461142,
-0.6814022064,
0.2641518414,
-0.0917058736,
-0.3423047662,
-0.4397098124,
-0.3380535841,
-0.5913332105,
0.2983539701,
-0.0113191251,
0.6074905396,
-0.1555761248,
-0.1957547963,
0.2372452021,
0.4663408995,
0.9072495103,
0.5650306344,
0.0213915072,
-0.3033871055,
0.6096169353,
-0.1038069353,
0.2944375277,
0.3866741359,
0.1093097404,
-0.3761189878,
-0.5222212672,
-0.6735795736,
-0.0924790129,
-0.4997669458,
-0.4553869665,
-0.718077302,
0.0399652198,
-0.5705752969,
-0.0647825152,
-0.1550404578,
-0.2180501521,
-0.1988449246,
-0.0591491275,
0.4432117045,
0.9643030763,
0.1364238262,
0.4364744425,
-0.9761202931,
0.3573198318,
0.655208528,
0.4883295,
-0.0236188192,
-0.4488001764,
-0.3419307172,
0.1134541109,
-0.7953462601,
-0.7383828759,
0.5035966039,
0.2313357443,
0.2834106088,
0.6180281639,
-0.1168800592,
0.8375395536,
-0.7729597688,
0.6954708099,
0.613858819,
-0.5814540386,
0.6648406386,
-0.1653837115,
0.3263898194,
0.4734842181,
0.5175548196,
-0.6451355219,
-0.3593626022,
-0.6303374171,
-0.4568010271,
1.1431225538,
0.0743948966,
0.1329461783,
0.3757972419,
-0.2299242169,
0.2085872293,
0.2632073462,
-0.3554322422,
0.0446358956,
-0.0885036141,
0.026009595,
-0.2436252832,
0.3375066817,
-0.2122699022,
-0.2212729454,
0.535754621,
-0.7305083275,
0.4825454354,
-0.2352633625,
0.1521819681,
-0.3641164303,
0.2874092162,
0.5879327059,
0.5849054456,
0.0045240102,
-0.4723101556,
0.2130262107,
-0.2264167517,
0.1040613949,
-0.0908626541,
0.2338106632,
0.1492176801,
0.3411521614,
1.225179553,
0.1770959646,
-0.5734141469,
0.5357117057,
0.0043741823,
-0.2769701481,
-0.4782332778,
0.3073517978,
-0.0012337799,
0.5890768766,
0.0712092891,
0.4217777848,
0.4087666571,
-0.8398096561,
0.1830733865,
0.1401665211,
-0.8673329353,
-0.1700351685,
0.1752346009,
0.1328415722,
-0.5950554609,
0.1000521928,
-0.1698970944,
-0.556125164,
0.5586650372,
0.1830524504,
1.0095608234,
-0.1980459392,
0.3953107297,
0.553098619,
-0.2179412544,
-0.4078528881,
0.4393934309,
0.1160792932,
-0.336782217,
-0.8028779626,
-0.5664826632,
-0.8306968808,
0.0533485115,
-0.4060333073,
0.5707981586,
-0.2511310279,
-0.1740202904,
0.2224813998,
-0.0383199677,
-0.7049352527,
0.3432428837,
0.1247163489,
0.7563061714,
-0.8254314065,
0.7810977101,
0.4316129684,
-0.3641659021,
-0.7328849435,
0.1152810976,
0.264257431,
-0.5324844718,
0.267544955,
0.4445830584,
-0.3779889345,
-0.3894457519,
-0.3307504654,
-0.9276007414,
1.2851128578,
0.0608432665,
-0.507737875,
-0.2147034556,
-0.119607076,
0.5297237039,
-0.7238994837,
0.414776057,
0.5907161832,
0.6078032255,
0.6892978549,
-0.8807501197,
-0.1335657835,
0.0794912055,
-0.0126727475,
0.3688163757,
-0.4116794765,
0.6974035501,
-0.5257021189,
0.1128235012,
-0.0169347357,
0.4594332278,
0.1128765345,
0.6058001518,
0.5778260827,
0.295478791,
0.617090106,
-0.0378330462,
0.9090519547,
-0.2448370457,
0.0786641762,
1.1919766665,
-0.3261005282,
0.9487722516,
0.167000562,
0.0267967153,
0.8088392019,
0.5512356162,
0.2469272017,
0.4737197757,
-0.3168377876,
-0.0918213949,
-0.3420835137,
0.0792813674,
0.3379228413,
0.7773020864,
0.4795856774,
-0.3023918271,
-0.076573506,
-0.0281126127,
-0.0789454728,
-0.4753559828,
-0.4947337508,
1.3348574638,
-0.2326393276,
-1.3048363924,
0.3167417943,
-0.2943001091,
0.3152158558,
-0.4356391728,
-0.4390865862,
0.0458664186,
-0.0119308764,
-0.1986161023,
-0.8026298285,
0.0992323086,
-0.0670260563,
-0.0081199985,
-0.4023648202,
0.4602427483,
-0.4400645494,
-0.470493257,
0.4003252983,
0.630959034,
0.2163612843,
-0.1230643988,
-0.8358536959,
-0.5548750758,
0.0820565,
-0.0196321309,
0.3044711351,
0.4644795954,
-0.1862480491,
0.7470855713,
0.6711981297,
-0.0441871844,
0.0611508414,
0.0740125403,
0.5859709978,
-0.752809763,
-0.4387858808,
-0.5545660257,
0.629076004,
-0.1651118994,
-0.0611576997,
-0.0294673312,
0.2059289515,
0.63500911,
0.0812683254,
1.0784446001,
0.0513201915,
0.6896514893,
-0.3514702618,
0.0225715954,
-0.354267329,
-0.2911442816,
-0.5352337956,
-0.6124685407,
-0.0857453719,
0.2202130556,
-0.0776895359,
0.2075068504,
0.7950611711,
0.6874134541,
-0.0237189159,
0.2878539264,
0.4378444552,
-0.1364745051,
0.3285727203,
0.4924121499,
0.4692014158,
-0.2076616436,
0.6928392053,
-0.4095500112,
-0.1307063997,
-0.706610322,
-0.9573518038,
-0.6689377427,
-0.615619719,
-0.1091309786,
-0.1825049222,
-0.4383338988,
0.8548985124,
0.9942813516,
-1.0060908794,
-0.2893484533,
-0.3519565761,
0.1822199672,
-0.6543259621,
-0.0562389232,
-0.2517492771,
-0.5165100694,
-1.0191968679,
0.3772241175,
0.6262276173,
0.2943579853,
-0.1025818586,
-0.3450691104,
-0.1523667872,
0.2378928959,
0.7448728085,
0.3883244395,
-0.885068655,
-0.0927518681,
-0.0842660889,
0.1094299927,
0.1921786219,
1.1374474764,
-0.5857156515,
0.5328532457,
0.4936467707,
0.2594003379,
0.7147347331,
0.0798659474,
0.9044376016,
-0.4714039564,
-0.2878495455,
0.3649435341,
0.5317388177,
0.0192181524,
-0.2083226889,
0.5787051916,
-0.1859240085,
-0.2166161239,
-0.3371584117,
0.6161127687,
-0.7627021074,
-0.0300885271,
1.0487920046,
-0.3100940585,
0.0485433787,
-0.544670701,
-0.470205009,
0.4044502378,
-0.6838001013,
0.6248736382,
0.6859564185,
-0.9323898554,
-0.195664078,
-0.5680692196,
0.661036551,
0.3488105834,
-0.8592267632,
0.4625001252,
0.627448976,
-0.087572962,
0.579089582,
0.486287266,
0.2315343916,
0.3963482678,
-0.3835287094,
-0.3623218238,
0.1293159574,
-0.9042924643,
-0.3041829169,
0.1968417168,
-0.0307643544,
-0.1269509643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10777v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10777v4
|
A Systematic Review of Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA): Domains, Methods, and Trends
| 2023-11-16T06:01:47 | 2024-04-16T10:59:11 |
Yan Cathy Hua, Paul Denny, Katerina Taskova, Jörg Wicker
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) is a fine-grained type of sentiment
analysis that identifies aspects and their associated opinions from a given
text. With the surge of digital opinionated text data, ABSA gained increasing
popularity for its ability to mine more detailed and targeted insights. Many
review papers on ABSA subtasks and solution methodologies exist, however, few
focus on trends over time or systemic issues relating to research application
domains, datasets, and solution approaches. To fill the gap, this paper
presents a Systematic Literature Review (SLR) of ABSA studies with a focus on
trends and high-level relationships among these fundamental components. This
review is one of the largest SLRs on ABSA, and also, to our knowledge, the
first that systematically examines the trends and inter-relations among ABSA
research and data distribution across domains and solution paradigms and
approaches. Our sample includes 519 primary studies screened from 4191 search
results without time constraints via an innovative automatic filtering process.
Our quantitative analysis not only identifies trends in nearly two decades of
ABSA research development but also unveils a systemic lack of dataset and
domain diversity as well as domain mismatch that may hinder the development of
future ABSA research. We discuss these findings and their implications and
propose suggestions for future research.
|
[
-0.8494838476,
-0.6240280867,
0.4867384136,
0.2101238221,
-0.5235002041,
0.1537040174,
0.3168836832,
-0.6488700509,
0.7264974713,
0.5013891459,
-0.5626119375,
-0.6085891724,
-0.3064415157,
0.0754988864,
-0.3898129463,
1.0616166592,
-0.0648872331,
0.0671335906,
-0.1533531994,
-0.5404572487,
-0.6673854589,
-0.6931455731,
-0.2272974551,
-0.2685734332,
0.4952909052,
0.2784963548,
0.4371268451,
0.0959197804,
0.910599947,
0.114915818,
-0.3505724072,
0.0161384884,
-0.0634001493,
0.2458946407,
-0.4793770909,
-0.2919898033,
-0.6829467416,
-0.082633622,
0.2513098419,
0.9398875237,
-0.0255185105,
0.1949905008,
0.1106597036,
1.1683959961,
-0.6224917769,
0.0384521894,
-0.3268607557,
-0.0809759647,
-0.426594466,
0.0620548539,
-0.0268097539,
-0.3537415564,
0.1602759659,
-0.2125720978,
0.3021950722,
0.064228639,
0.7431458235,
-0.1502919495,
-0.1658124328,
-0.5094693303,
-0.8153753877,
0.9849795699,
-0.7505475879,
0.1272194088,
0.0035187819,
-0.0952125564,
0.0815966651,
-0.1669142246,
-0.4276293814,
0.3604637682,
-0.0286452919,
0.0787899196,
-0.227313295,
-0.1292365938,
-0.1372299492,
0.5079036355,
-0.4500852227,
-0.0697972924,
-0.33740291,
0.1634207964,
0.6758822799,
0.1484589577,
0.1272222996,
-0.3890806735,
-0.366812706,
0.1360833794,
-1.0145652294,
0.163661018,
0.3244438171,
0.3062802255,
0.0874371231,
0.6112959981,
-0.4098782539,
0.3574725688,
-0.0549838729,
0.1703349054,
0.3471791148,
-0.5622505546,
0.0141599085,
-0.1041114703,
0.7916340828,
0.4313704073,
-0.3533890247,
0.3144628704,
-0.4364197254,
-0.047777012,
0.5423207283,
-0.5239209533,
0.1007719636,
0.4896622598,
-0.5760837793,
-0.0659400895,
0.2813625932,
-1.0229048729,
-0.3897963762,
-0.5140877366,
-0.0856977552,
-0.3269250393,
-0.5259178877,
-0.2168732285,
0.0441142991,
0.4743299782,
0.2300783545,
-0.2623144984,
0.1860508323,
1.166092515,
1.0239759684,
-0.3497127593,
0.2862561643,
0.4428171217,
-0.5703811646,
-0.6684623957,
1.1006497145,
-0.5293970704,
-0.53462255,
0.4182706773,
-0.1955710202,
0.2463128567,
-0.6184312105,
0.4953429103,
-0.7318703532,
-0.1080514416,
-0.5066710711,
-0.1352900565,
-0.654067874,
0.3580851853,
-0.5339483023,
0.8073756099,
-0.0262575708,
-0.8100629449,
0.4853211939,
-0.5324418545,
-0.4230830669,
-0.0885956064,
-0.2086102813,
-0.710854888,
0.4174779356,
0.2989741266,
0.1415992528,
-0.4351919293,
0.3306432366,
-0.3628886938,
-0.0183502939,
0.5049422383,
0.0951615423,
0.4655320942,
0.4525884688,
-0.3356013298,
0.1235225797,
-0.2871719301,
-0.1701592207,
-0.2967141271,
0.6427611113,
-1.0813918114,
0.1430689096,
0.1512463242,
0.3043732047,
0.2266183645,
-0.467907548,
0.1217322797,
-0.435906738,
0.2395475209,
0.347084254,
0.6679139733,
0.3790689111,
-0.3738903403,
0.5799806714,
0.3041710854,
0.4981405437,
-0.2743894458,
-0.494145155,
-0.6801609993,
-0.1523639262,
0.0556225777,
0.2135530561,
-0.543360889,
0.6510359049,
-0.0977393761,
-0.5264405608,
-0.5639898777,
0.0545475855,
0.4060378969,
0.1323815733,
0.3980543315,
-1.0771639347,
-0.2042641193,
-1.0496760607,
-0.0849836171,
-0.3602527976,
0.3391759992,
0.1805631667,
0.5242294073,
-0.1126889661,
1.4340792894,
-0.4810091555,
-0.8204903603,
-0.4892090857,
0.4892548621,
0.2109375149,
0.1114434227,
0.6957259178,
-0.8533831835,
-0.2796081603,
0.1098918989,
-0.7743090987,
-0.0413704552,
-0.0107793771,
0.0057639368,
0.2803829014,
0.0023768558,
-0.2435969561,
0.4983336627,
0.2381157279,
-0.1798718423,
0.2664287984,
0.4744318724,
0.2026604861,
-0.8216154575,
0.2164881676,
0.3293890953,
0.4576155245,
-0.5946786404,
0.1360997111,
-0.1395020038,
-0.1687395871,
-0.2613189518,
0.2985273898,
-0.4475415647,
-0.2540971041,
-0.570397675,
0.0924338326,
-0.0274784379,
0.3966420889,
0.0863188207,
0.5548745394,
0.4745891988,
-0.4342048764,
0.0159619469,
0.217179805,
-0.0922948942,
0.8484607935,
-0.5281247497,
0.2407261431,
-0.0521538407,
0.1638533622,
-0.8390877843,
0.1590091735,
0.2322059274,
-0.4145091772,
0.0801823661,
0.055484429,
-0.0580832548,
-0.1830550283,
-0.7264792919,
0.4529481232,
0.2772159874,
-0.0009224885,
0.6845268011,
0.5789293051,
-0.7173831463,
-0.788528204,
-0.1414532512,
0.0108755464,
-0.2248120159,
-0.2364859879,
0.0685421452,
0.2634162307,
-0.8908581734,
0.2465510964,
-0.359359175,
-0.2372785807,
-0.1636942625,
0.3345405459,
0.1445990801,
-0.1421275139,
-0.2759832144,
0.2503986657,
0.0162533019,
0.2673877478,
0.114464283,
0.3655818701,
-0.1967141926,
-0.3802745342,
-0.4592457414,
0.5225045085,
0.453495115,
-0.3089197278,
0.4057024717,
0.0014344953,
-0.0607230514,
-0.3155402541,
-0.3347821236,
-0.2228771597,
-0.3317379653,
0.2822676301,
-0.1636689901,
-0.3596861959,
0.6367315054,
0.0372107551,
0.3938085437,
0.4559787214,
0.1911151707,
-0.1223800257,
0.5268402696,
0.8188282251,
-0.3032650948,
0.5381572247,
-0.4574250877,
0.5068263412,
-1.0535750389,
-0.3000092804,
-0.6242887974,
-0.3154864907,
-0.2926861942,
-0.1813937128,
0.3134641051,
0.0784632564,
0.2228516042,
0.0343074128,
-0.4039897323,
-0.061787121,
0.1669535935,
-0.1777972281,
0.4433698356,
-0.2264696807,
0.3120410144,
-0.1650416404,
-0.1788621098,
-0.4404060245,
1.0834355354,
0.4283738732,
0.7454991937,
-0.093576327,
0.5992064476,
0.5480048656,
0.8469038606,
-1.0242571831,
0.5124773979,
-0.0433003381,
-0.6438928843,
-0.0698095113,
-0.0383209176,
-0.7447553277,
0.202733174,
0.1030072495,
-0.1480208039,
0.6894965768,
-0.0728532299,
-0.1639986634,
0.1581069827,
-0.0165903773,
0.2752201855,
-0.1047180742,
-0.3049416244,
-0.3044539392,
-0.3747334778,
0.504253149,
-0.2374444753,
0.6476860642,
-0.2633354664,
0.0800521076,
0.6723118424,
-0.4258066416,
0.8133248091,
-0.389179945,
-0.3190925717,
0.6846911907,
-0.031004319,
0.1165846884,
0.0830029547,
0.2127484083,
0.4910130501,
-0.2070225179,
-0.1508821994,
-0.5113133788,
0.7439181209,
-0.6779715419,
-0.4938919544,
-0.96282655,
-0.0579284355,
-0.5195167065,
0.0696947202,
-0.0869852975,
0.515578568,
-0.3847103417,
0.1696318984,
0.7462108731,
-0.0380883254,
0.3615476489,
0.6248351336,
-0.3045803607,
-0.4557222724,
0.7981052995,
0.1673941165,
-0.1324644536,
0.3497695029,
-0.2135912925,
-0.168386206,
-1.0802748203,
-0.3396940231,
0.4280730188,
-0.3571692407,
-0.3205126524,
-0.3545272052,
-0.045488745,
-0.4071217179,
-0.0313506722,
-0.6880703568,
-0.0243289731,
-0.1082663685,
0.0245527327,
0.2629502714,
1.075997591,
0.2659616768,
0.214506954,
-0.5656805634,
0.2058596611,
-0.1510632038,
0.298796773,
-0.0058826832,
-0.2170141786,
-0.2657063603,
-0.314086169,
-0.5380880237,
-0.8988978863,
0.5864521265,
-0.1183158085,
0.2875289619,
0.5476028323,
0.2095600665,
0.440669328,
-0.1402907073,
1.1384032965,
0.1898678094,
-0.7565582395,
0.6298236847,
-0.2503866255,
0.0633459985,
0.6762706041,
0.5367373824,
-0.5877017975,
-0.43015486,
-0.4585244358,
-1.3757556677,
0.5565993786,
0.182485953,
0.086077705,
0.2858937979,
0.3581324518,
0.2824381292,
0.3990065753,
-0.2867680788,
-0.5777751803,
-0.2027644962,
-0.2526839972,
0.3528597653,
-0.0884640887,
-0.2862168252,
0.2205869108,
0.8925980926,
-0.2876091003,
0.1802799553,
0.2639737129,
0.0253338087,
-0.1041770279,
0.6068502069,
0.0596643202,
0.9557696581,
-0.2136405706,
-0.1709106266,
-0.3675243556,
-0.7033257484,
0.1024234295,
0.0145253045,
-0.7625606656,
0.130636096,
0.308227241,
0.468719691,
-0.0366585292,
-0.4869750142,
0.5122056603,
0.0346839279,
-0.1329884827,
-0.5399922729,
-0.1937239915,
-0.4323767722,
-0.0359273106,
0.8256673813,
0.1879650801,
0.4103595912,
-0.7777730227,
0.243643865,
0.5939189792,
-0.8498377204,
-0.7322372794,
0.0618438907,
0.3698596358,
0.0886956826,
0.2735424936,
-0.1446111798,
-0.1629021466,
0.5891104937,
-0.1349504143,
1.0643543005,
-0.0280190632,
0.4117980599,
0.0623555966,
0.3815422654,
-0.0140611688,
0.4292266071,
0.3494189978,
-0.5545535088,
-0.4140950143,
-0.7543507218,
-0.6457020044,
0.2734707594,
-0.9704697728,
-0.0066265343,
-0.376704812,
-0.364757508,
-0.0336563028,
0.2428063005,
-0.3110497296,
0.0832372755,
-0.2024547607,
0.6519626379,
-0.9019643664,
0.572958529,
1.0146714449,
-0.6116954088,
-0.3400406241,
0.3123553991,
0.1165326014,
-0.1003967896,
0.3233403862,
0.0267743506,
-0.2798014879,
-0.78923136,
-0.3877454698,
-0.9155207872,
0.8725577593,
-0.4293217957,
-0.4834316075,
0.0577787049,
0.0535031781,
0.7707579732,
-0.540547967,
-0.0074075796,
0.6751517653,
0.1941720843,
-0.0905974135,
-0.5653503537,
-0.1410596222,
-0.2723276317,
0.1552612484,
0.3453744352,
-0.9255819917,
0.6047763228,
0.1683084071,
-0.2152326852,
0.1051710472,
1.1182764769,
0.2945224345,
1.0464934111,
0.2491615117,
0.3420135081,
0.0788530558,
-0.1902479231,
0.5852761269,
-0.3349496126,
0.4901860058,
0.6795817018,
-0.7000060081,
0.923301816,
0.4675823152,
-0.4005816877,
0.9201303124,
0.5945079327,
0.3588192463,
0.6720246673,
-0.1186870486,
-0.0536622144,
0.136490345,
-0.3748072982,
-0.4225533903,
0.1795917898,
0.7830361128,
-0.3136188686,
-0.0439525321,
0.1607539058,
0.0178390201,
0.2250167429,
-0.5943272114,
0.8595472574,
0.3034794629,
-0.6466362476,
-0.0991978645,
0.0301589631,
0.8087447286,
-0.7314209342,
0.011873805,
-0.8363037109,
0.1252517998,
-0.3284756541,
-0.9710412621,
0.6839603782,
0.0199644137,
-0.1464777291,
-0.1530995816,
0.6959252954,
0.0164886322,
-0.1865189224,
0.2133332193,
0.723496139,
-0.0773940161,
-0.1177365258,
-0.7049661875,
0.2162366062,
-0.105658114,
-0.3547798991,
0.4974883795,
0.5345313549,
-0.3611467183,
0.3198773861,
0.3155875206,
0.1089524031,
-0.4873941839,
-0.052369047,
1.0848299265,
-0.9542168975,
-0.4849944413,
-0.3554689884,
0.1399501562,
-0.0817887262,
-0.545891583,
0.8904602528,
0.5181965232,
0.6087582111,
0.1897161603,
0.93761307,
-0.3454168439,
0.7644905448,
-0.3216546178,
0.482858628,
-0.3890649676,
0.4694675803,
-0.2621436119,
-1.004237771,
-0.2841425836,
0.3001862466,
-0.3371687233,
0.0704412982,
0.7590289116,
0.5280680656,
0.0930158719,
0.4393440485,
-0.267908901,
0.0555300713,
0.3122843504,
-0.1840787977,
0.786501348,
-0.2363158166,
0.0121875713,
-0.4181393683,
-0.4190636873,
-0.347284615,
-0.5184388757,
-0.5036770105,
-0.5926266909,
-0.3849125206,
-0.0820286572,
0.1062083319,
0.6912016273,
0.4844748974,
-1.1352478266,
-0.2618741393,
0.0439592451,
0.3394967616,
-0.8804931045,
-0.3714223206,
0.4702879786,
-0.4310714304,
-0.5764324069,
0.0130569106,
0.3348446786,
-0.2936072946,
-0.8207796812,
0.354347378,
0.0212959312,
0.4323585331,
0.535808444,
0.3657797873,
-0.4947557151,
0.0743912011,
0.1137206405,
0.0701064691,
0.0505023934,
1.3743562698,
-0.4567140341,
0.1906714588,
0.6079664826,
0.2969028652,
0.1087053195,
0.3969486654,
0.4365552366,
-0.7190060616,
-0.2360180914,
0.4971760809,
0.3287644386,
0.4486905038,
-0.1782343984,
0.5030006766,
0.2897894979,
-0.4542979598,
-0.7385696769,
0.2222555131,
-1.0636109114,
-0.5685623288,
1.0789781809,
-0.1523552835,
-0.343652457,
-0.6272037029,
-0.1476189047,
-0.3369655311,
-0.8414902091,
0.9038994312,
0.5697678328,
-0.8077113032,
0.1316159964,
-0.3525627851,
0.432017684,
0.3019168079,
-1.0481973886,
0.3163627684,
0.7227704525,
0.057830099,
0.5924524665,
0.5896986127,
-0.4771798253,
-0.0207283851,
-0.3246856332,
0.2279341072,
0.3256239295,
-0.7662171125,
-0.485286504,
0.5701574087,
0.1884769797,
0.2110098004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09585v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09585v2
|
LifeTox: Unveiling Implicit Toxicity in Life Advice
| 2023-11-16T05:43:02 | 2024-03-19T02:20:50 |
Minbeom Kim, Jahyun Koo, Hwanhee Lee, Joonsuk Park, Hwaran Lee, Kyomin Jung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As large language models become increasingly integrated into daily life,
detecting implicit toxicity across diverse contexts is crucial. To this end, we
introduce LifeTox, a dataset designed for identifying implicit toxicity within
a broad range of advice-seeking scenarios. Unlike existing safety datasets,
LifeTox comprises diverse contexts derived from personal experiences through
open-ended questions. Experiments demonstrate that RoBERTa fine-tuned on
LifeTox matches or surpasses the zero-shot performance of large language models
in toxicity classification tasks. These results underscore the efficacy of
LifeTox in addressing the complex challenges inherent in implicit toxicity. We
open-sourced the
dataset\footnote{\url{https://huggingface.co/datasets/mbkim/LifeTox}} and the
LifeTox moderator family; 350M, 7B, and 13B.
|
[
0.1171339229,
-0.7701168656,
0.9931592941,
0.6596028805,
-0.1547152102,
-0.3799667656,
0.3343599439,
-0.6977177262,
-0.365154773,
0.4944498241,
-0.9232408404,
-0.9304248095,
-0.5252615809,
-0.1043605879,
-0.4331788421,
1.4253559113,
0.268345207,
0.1910355836,
-0.2408892661,
-0.283130914,
-0.5657083392,
-0.1637073308,
-1.1823813915,
-0.0171358418,
0.9847639203,
0.5753178,
0.7671041489,
0.3207696974,
-0.1080282331,
0.1301056892,
-0.3345563114,
-0.0155705884,
-0.5666298866,
0.4270105064,
-0.0189847965,
-0.3311965764,
-0.6183025241,
0.1014725119,
0.0845478997,
0.4253132939,
-0.0732783973,
0.1654588431,
0.0371766165,
0.4980663359,
-0.9657827616,
0.1534257829,
-0.3190514445,
0.3660199344,
0.0141439764,
0.0185184237,
-0.5611996651,
-0.6267867088,
0.2301734239,
-0.7339298725,
-0.3031839728,
0.2140185386,
0.3019678295,
0.5745112896,
-0.7421759367,
-0.3216522336,
-0.8345282078,
0.5815595984,
-0.5954725146,
0.116757758,
-0.0590415969,
0.4928338826,
-0.2499441206,
-0.5491148233,
-0.1687490791,
-0.1292948425,
-0.066121392,
0.1344433576,
-0.3162193,
0.1178830937,
0.2466216236,
0.1066569015,
-0.4105881751,
-0.1964407116,
-0.1456480622,
-0.2281796932,
0.5451241136,
0.3511407375,
0.6048880219,
0.0893643498,
-0.2445940524,
0.1736011654,
-0.8862649202,
-0.2587192357,
0.2337145358,
0.1889591962,
-0.1697416902,
0.5418948531,
-0.0386700258,
0.484988153,
-0.2801430821,
0.2126313895,
-0.1371291876,
-0.2149339467,
0.0863412768,
0.3414907455,
0.6631625891,
0.556659162,
0.78333956,
-0.1678874791,
0.1318323463,
-0.2096490562,
0.4005188346,
-0.8039702773,
-0.1167836636,
0.402109921,
-0.2018917203,
-0.5041422248,
-0.2760668993,
-1.0091298819,
-0.8691122532,
0.1079521999,
0.5801739693,
-0.1131453812,
-0.1781197786,
0.1980611384,
-0.3682507873,
-0.0512635112,
0.2221729606,
-0.4586364925,
0.247070685,
0.6323803663,
0.8061762452,
-0.041109167,
0.0270252135,
-0.8423032165,
0.2470716238,
-0.3022321463,
1.1659328938,
-0.8154122829,
-0.5741022825,
0.0442318209,
0.1033884883,
0.4353909194,
-0.5849993825,
0.7352997065,
-0.132564351,
0.1617300212,
-0.388944149,
-0.277174294,
0.1102383211,
0.0309919156,
-0.5614212751,
0.9743753672,
0.1229006052,
-0.7728116512,
0.7327646017,
-0.9730943441,
-0.4165974557,
-0.0208675899,
0.1937104464,
-0.4720171094,
-0.0160910897,
-0.1843758672,
0.5534000993,
-0.0904076844,
0.0120152356,
-0.8618947864,
-0.157777369,
-0.0132327508,
-0.4481591284,
0.7373566031,
0.3145813346,
-0.3459769785,
0.3789048493,
-0.9031121135,
-0.016114464,
0.0539784655,
-0.2811633945,
-1.0286098719,
0.1139765903,
0.1536702663,
0.3835989237,
-0.1415859908,
-0.8375490904,
-0.1063627303,
-0.1127939746,
0.3559978604,
0.755102694,
0.3598921299,
0.1961936802,
-0.2358140349,
0.4127108455,
0.0177602544,
0.8132346869,
0.2345787138,
-0.7153193355,
-0.4233556688,
0.0886902809,
0.0501824617,
0.4165129662,
-0.1067162678,
0.2573634684,
-0.2884611487,
-0.304866612,
-0.1456263512,
-0.1449228525,
0.6116027236,
0.4879994094,
0.5514774323,
0.0748936981,
-0.1797472835,
-0.8607022166,
-0.59969455,
0.2304235697,
0.0718333796,
0.7790519595,
0.4194633663,
-0.3911898136,
0.8710989952,
-0.914416492,
-0.3832992613,
0.1146156117,
0.3618195355,
-0.0868380293,
0.5480726361,
0.6396279931,
-0.6101640463,
-0.7385536432,
-0.1218070909,
-0.6777065992,
-0.3593245149,
0.1500270516,
-0.4642644227,
0.0561146848,
0.57819736,
-0.1939143986,
0.5522424579,
0.4581992924,
-0.7673249841,
0.3547281027,
-0.3169903159,
-0.0868929997,
-0.7828113437,
0.0068068998,
-0.0579487979,
-0.3020275831,
-0.5428635478,
-0.1886216849,
0.0205496512,
0.0307752956,
-0.8167919517,
0.990013063,
-0.2939191759,
0.0539430343,
0.040465951,
-0.1458084434,
-0.15112257,
0.112113297,
-0.0289301146,
1.01691401,
0.2403748184,
-0.623447299,
0.2209128588,
0.2011327147,
0.091292046,
0.9400390387,
-0.7717158794,
0.0536024645,
-0.1365631521,
0.5171948075,
-0.8070810437,
-0.2755808532,
0.3086048067,
-0.0786298364,
-0.1049632505,
-0.5462023616,
-0.402141273,
-0.1654984653,
-0.2612172961,
0.5471521616,
0.5313131213,
-0.4165244401,
0.8786230683,
0.4587757885,
-0.3008370996,
-0.6071591973,
-0.5442410111,
-0.1092038974,
-0.3608918786,
-0.4449121654,
0.0553845428,
-0.4654380083,
-0.3940126896,
0.073657915,
-0.407651186,
-0.2954247594,
0.0193188749,
0.7592971325,
0.0332258604,
0.2075510025,
0.2139891833,
0.3751595318,
-0.5138149858,
0.5637742281,
-0.1349833161,
0.266381532,
0.0866963863,
0.0185491219,
0.2295241207,
0.4908754528,
0.6859234571,
0.2835851312,
0.8549778461,
0.2748837769,
-0.3534993231,
-0.4320814908,
-0.3156110644,
0.1468328536,
-0.435305208,
-0.0787190944,
0.0430416875,
-0.5742713809,
0.6284468174,
-0.1426693201,
-0.0664046258,
0.3631893098,
0.2049801946,
0.0315039121,
1.5597220659,
0.5968860984,
-0.1301273257,
0.3169537187,
0.0426990017,
-0.1693059504,
-0.7753179073,
-0.2823965847,
-0.3442977071,
0.1304352134,
-0.2804173231,
-0.1677724272,
0.8749156594,
-0.6626675725,
-0.6366991997,
-0.0309245829,
-0.3697281182,
0.8405069709,
0.3621868193,
0.5234807134,
0.5788357854,
-0.3277917504,
-0.3105645776,
0.1040382311,
-0.5384506583,
-0.2956775129,
1.4420281649,
0.2472403347,
0.9164140821,
0.0112827187,
0.2866228223,
0.543500483,
0.7071493268,
-0.5713803172,
0.4445779622,
-0.3279279172,
-1.1638039351,
-0.0968463123,
-0.4166570604,
-0.8441817164,
-0.3897339106,
-0.2227004915,
-0.4610224962,
-0.0582683422,
0.1516761184,
-0.7423556447,
-0.0536528789,
-0.7687259912,
1.0880593061,
-0.3517041504,
-0.8252107501,
-0.1887255609,
-0.6652822495,
0.3823858798,
-0.1173855439,
0.419518441,
-0.2127780616,
-0.0045653163,
0.4707302153,
-0.3988164663,
0.6817110777,
-0.4049648941,
-0.5980593562,
0.0146827651,
0.1794322878,
0.4862380922,
0.3982779682,
0.0322671719,
0.0132473186,
0.1712141335,
-0.4096827507,
-0.4971191287,
0.9316893816,
-0.4987080395,
-0.0483895615,
-0.4386519194,
-0.4147410095,
-0.4669114351,
0.3061098754,
0.2591189742,
0.4146605134,
-0.3093551397,
0.080700092,
0.8241530657,
-0.7166912556,
0.1109103635,
0.8309774399,
-0.3085818887,
-0.119002454,
0.8344085217,
0.1008601561,
0.4937317669,
0.0772710592,
0.3769094348,
-0.489482075,
-0.2363981307,
-0.172364518,
0.1384664774,
-0.9289703965,
-0.1165456548,
-0.6707904935,
-0.2452260554,
-0.1122247577,
0.0918571725,
-0.3953845501,
-0.0518914871,
-0.0536964238,
-0.2709085047,
0.5709486604,
1.230168581,
-0.2248369753,
0.1685468405,
-0.993426919,
0.140266493,
0.8416300416,
0.7827679515,
-0.4590698481,
0.0710495189,
0.3480590582,
0.1064369231,
0.1634824723,
-1.0169615746,
0.2750630677,
0.1601708382,
0.4848496914,
0.489054054,
0.4637500048,
0.620467186,
-0.5340728164,
0.6595807076,
-0.412658304,
-0.872646451,
0.7200210094,
-0.7282287478,
-0.014593998,
0.6490076184,
0.7993125916,
-0.6907926798,
-0.4279001951,
-0.5537440777,
-1.0482352972,
0.4753997624,
0.1569172889,
0.2157453746,
0.0425695889,
0.6465087533,
0.3691056371,
0.1286028475,
-0.9370906353,
-0.3860533834,
0.0199210979,
-0.4347356856,
0.1649814397,
-0.5318270326,
-0.3803387284,
-0.3775103986,
0.5658290386,
-0.1967745274,
0.3584118485,
-0.0287683941,
-0.0837173164,
-0.4079877436,
0.4130580425,
0.5420008302,
0.3427634835,
-0.5619296432,
0.0662680641,
0.4223355949,
-0.4760345221,
0.1984808296,
-0.0676399767,
0.0110395513,
-0.4546197951,
0.3557090461,
0.2722303867,
0.7164999843,
-0.854093194,
0.6131017208,
-0.4873766005,
-0.0486765206,
-0.5763092637,
0.6432689428,
-0.136184454,
0.0298591182,
0.3109242022,
-0.1679834127,
0.4478637278,
-0.7072576284,
0.1828515828,
0.4302654266,
-0.9614772201,
-0.1337537915,
0.7834247351,
0.5170449615,
0.120292142,
0.5172489285,
0.0958617032,
-0.4152954221,
0.418356806,
0.2879724205,
0.8806772232,
-0.0600555278,
0.2238865346,
0.3226686716,
-0.0648370236,
0.2376101017,
0.3440199494,
-0.0432772376,
-0.519954443,
-0.146762684,
-0.5579039454,
-0.445843935,
0.406022042,
-0.608536303,
-0.0020980746,
-0.6304112077,
0.2393457294,
0.0544692427,
-0.2502293885,
-0.1737394631,
0.3853322268,
0.1334424019,
1.1520961523,
-1.2142320871,
0.3840571642,
0.5758558512,
-0.4614675343,
-0.6609523296,
0.3193848431,
0.2999327183,
-0.7005670071,
0.6963395476,
0.2613760531,
-0.3335852623,
0.2283353806,
-0.9962279797,
-0.5772588849,
1.0208816528,
0.3272561133,
-0.1758837402,
-0.1210970953,
0.154008612,
0.665722549,
-0.3600563705,
0.6616721153,
0.632261157,
0.8827579618,
0.0529617891,
-0.528503716,
0.327668488,
-0.4832106233,
-0.3139543831,
-0.0572363809,
-0.5723371506,
0.7026705146,
-0.1350818723,
-0.3621686399,
-0.0338084698,
0.0809036493,
0.1477137208,
0.452201575,
0.7993151546,
0.4135650992,
0.2613002956,
-0.1152626276,
1.1791499853,
-0.2233893126,
0.1618138999,
0.9800638556,
-0.2522367239,
0.5284901261,
0.0286755934,
-0.1644212157,
0.8266333938,
0.6137842536,
0.3857427537,
0.5481417179,
-0.1118107364,
-0.4153670967,
-0.6551061869,
-0.264177382,
-0.506673336,
-0.0645553246,
0.483458966,
-0.203189835,
-0.5161252022,
0.1032210663,
0.4370627403,
-0.209825322,
-0.0710450336,
0.9468203187,
-0.0801401064,
-0.7013035417,
0.138774097,
-0.648459971,
0.54445678,
-0.6363090277,
-0.4137653112,
-0.4623889923,
0.2367191762,
-0.1918723583,
-1.2137275934,
0.435616374,
-0.0449371748,
0.0404116511,
-0.1438491344,
0.7506032586,
-0.2762943506,
-0.1210724786,
0.8429864049,
0.3658209145,
-0.0308560822,
-0.5627288222,
-0.7734028101,
-0.2011819482,
-0.4179927111,
-0.0715291873,
0.2578837574,
0.4463449717,
0.0554691926,
1.0699396133,
0.6624262333,
0.0893020406,
0.1819232851,
-0.1276416928,
0.8928316236,
-0.7463891506,
-0.3076228499,
-0.5320876837,
0.8211040497,
-0.2130017877,
-0.4227523506,
0.74185884,
0.4568008482,
0.512616694,
-0.053473372,
0.8094977736,
0.1127971113,
0.5594949722,
-0.5424087048,
0.8267046809,
-0.8064737916,
0.4006231427,
-0.2211155891,
-0.7227566838,
-0.3759263158,
0.4168097079,
-0.4406552911,
0.2788865864,
0.8039879799,
0.7480262518,
-0.0787033439,
0.0855700672,
-0.0198080707,
0.7418856621,
0.3134969771,
0.6862885356,
1.0532323122,
-0.2424274534,
0.84135741,
-0.0967342779,
-0.1999661922,
-0.2964426875,
-1.2320076227,
-0.8384631872,
-0.3488641381,
-0.176233083,
-0.4119093418,
0.5019737482,
0.7667447329,
0.8009048104,
-0.8786811233,
0.3788985908,
-0.6391770244,
0.2217314541,
-0.0102220243,
-0.3183912933,
-0.2507698536,
-0.1259961873,
-0.635614872,
0.3602805436,
0.3373856544,
0.1729952842,
-0.1772861332,
-0.1369077712,
-0.134150967,
0.2375754565,
0.5599935055,
0.2693427801,
-0.2682252526,
-0.6587138772,
-0.2474875748,
-0.1374028772,
-0.2527998984,
0.6849139929,
-0.7474660873,
0.3097417653,
0.4001133442,
0.0525250807,
0.2918114066,
-0.1038494408,
0.8802469373,
-0.9245083928,
-0.1890118569,
0.082508646,
0.0377858542,
-0.1397018433,
-0.8345846534,
0.8033278584,
0.0965528265,
-0.550421536,
-0.6082559824,
0.131991744,
-1.0742946863,
-0.5306058526,
1.4754149914,
-0.2193938047,
-0.3516384661,
-0.6270379424,
-0.4889186025,
-0.0297562741,
-0.6312019229,
0.658029139,
0.5245147943,
-0.1435082853,
-0.0790068284,
-0.8740337491,
0.8653723598,
0.322853446,
-1.3006014824,
0.25233531,
0.673920095,
0.8257323503,
0.0363156125,
0.4274052978,
-0.1029846594,
0.4033112526,
-0.2264352441,
-0.335324198,
-0.0370003954,
-0.5257551074,
-0.1701467782,
0.1022689417,
-0.2891817093,
0.303486675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09581v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09581v2
|
DocLens: Multi-aspect Fine-grained Evaluation for Medical Text Generation
| 2023-11-16T05:32:09 | 2024-02-18T20:39:06 |
Yiqing Xie, Sheng Zhang, Hao Cheng, Pengfei Liu, Zelalem Gero, Cliff Wong, Tristan Naumann, Hoifung Poon, Carolyn Rose
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Medical text generation aims to assist with administrative work and highlight
salient information to support decision-making. To reflect the specific
requirements of medical text, in this paper, we propose a set of metrics to
evaluate the completeness, conciseness, and attribution of the generated text
at a fine-grained level. The metrics can be computed by various types of
evaluators including instruction-following (both proprietary and open-source)
and supervised entailment models. We demonstrate the effectiveness of the
resulting framework, DocLens, with three evaluators on three tasks: clinical
note generation, radiology report summarization, and patient question
summarization. A comprehensive human study shows that DocLens exhibits
substantially higher agreement with the judgments of medical experts than
existing metrics. The results also highlight the need to improve open-source
evaluators and suggest potential directions.
|
[
-0.2066344619,
-0.6672584414,
1.141707778,
0.078197889,
-0.3516002595,
-0.3661628067,
-0.4092948437,
-0.2355027348,
0.1789435893,
0.2256398797,
-0.1870234162,
-0.7009476423,
-0.6004313827,
0.3096057773,
-0.3420088887,
1.394105196,
-0.2982473075,
0.2063518167,
-0.5434989333,
0.1597468108,
-0.1368357688,
-0.0195760243,
-0.7024289966,
-0.2241717577,
0.4343547821,
0.6550802588,
0.4959034026,
0.5006765723,
0.9846482873,
0.3205720186,
-0.1057153121,
0.5961149335,
-0.0302589126,
0.3874073327,
-0.1527516842,
-0.1725667417,
-0.8013258576,
-0.0264135357,
0.4504236579,
0.6167434454,
-0.0383393019,
0.2205974758,
0.1135375798,
0.6828158498,
-0.6281179786,
-0.1619918644,
-0.2961019278,
0.2193876803,
-0.1635240167,
-0.4654862881,
-0.0308126882,
-0.6849563718,
0.1902662814,
-0.5705504417,
0.60755229,
-0.1461727023,
0.678301394,
0.1504198313,
-0.1607967615,
-0.724904716,
-0.5426493287,
0.6380484104,
-0.80492872,
0.0972904935,
0.4321782589,
0.2938781381,
0.1316252947,
-0.9669883847,
-0.3725236952,
-0.2574242949,
-0.3282311559,
0.4847469032,
0.1036354229,
0.2401417196,
-0.1325161308,
0.9309526086,
-0.3213199973,
0.0027444363,
-0.5588752031,
-0.0792666599,
0.6392675638,
0.3836191595,
0.1186822131,
-0.5127124786,
-0.1365347356,
0.1633045226,
-0.3891799152,
-0.1752702296,
0.1389861256,
0.0641497672,
-0.2102060318,
0.8083204627,
-0.4036333561,
0.616502583,
0.1994682252,
-0.2570383549,
0.2895135581,
-0.8456537127,
-0.3146468699,
0.0865778252,
1.0661798716,
0.569136858,
-0.0346206799,
-0.08138071,
-0.3168874085,
-0.2619635761,
0.6457349658,
-1.0199999809,
-0.1250066012,
0.7154858112,
-0.7809127569,
-0.5964364409,
0.2579317987,
-0.7747831941,
-0.4974104166,
-0.3828345835,
0.0175118819,
-0.8119792342,
0.1138299778,
0.0373883732,
-0.1871020198,
-0.3375200033,
0.515186131,
-0.6895275116,
0.2984912097,
0.7386494279,
0.8950657845,
-0.0791008174,
-0.2465389669,
-0.7722873092,
0.1032822356,
-0.4927153885,
0.9567697644,
-0.3918958008,
-0.5550749302,
-0.1636193991,
-0.1384144723,
0.0349546522,
-0.5191866159,
0.8852443099,
0.2872206867,
0.4624910057,
0.0337202884,
-0.6956348419,
0.1151382849,
0.4736321568,
-0.3043399453,
0.7259069681,
0.4519888163,
-0.7424114943,
0.5373972654,
-0.8110951185,
-0.6154184937,
0.2073924989,
-0.5901765227,
-0.613199532,
0.6191123724,
0.2654308379,
0.6650579572,
-0.4544733465,
0.3516968489,
0.2224791646,
-0.0680833161,
0.1493079811,
-0.4571801126,
0.0929159746,
0.4495343864,
-0.0570357665,
0.4713641107,
-0.9582002163,
0.2000414729,
-0.1489648223,
-0.5226057172,
-0.3694958389,
0.0519410186,
0.1140296161,
-0.051652316,
0.2693662941,
-0.6497492194,
-0.1418595016,
-0.4621873796,
0.2029162943,
0.2988049984,
0.3528160453,
0.3510031104,
-0.362468034,
0.4874785542,
-0.0401193872,
0.4615595639,
-0.3955203295,
-0.3374736905,
-0.4048699439,
-0.5449697971,
0.3179084659,
0.3641210198,
-0.4316061437,
0.4427781701,
-0.1497781873,
-0.8531796336,
-0.6198983192,
0.0055311853,
0.9458558559,
0.6281147003,
0.357005924,
-0.569218874,
-0.2108530849,
-0.9140380025,
-0.0615008548,
0.0305213165,
-0.3986060619,
0.4473526478,
0.2838070393,
-0.2035541981,
0.7391293049,
-0.7094666362,
-0.4440001547,
-0.0939781219,
0.2045639753,
-0.1150971726,
0.5088818669,
0.6216512918,
-0.6347109079,
-0.3973037004,
0.3697435856,
-0.6453242302,
-0.2418460846,
-0.0121443579,
0.1243299842,
-0.0057573784,
0.465154618,
-0.481710583,
0.2997994721,
0.3801900744,
-0.5745130777,
0.7789206505,
-0.7548925877,
0.5759123564,
-1.1813377142,
0.346244812,
0.1631498188,
-0.2198645473,
-0.5979052186,
0.2128224224,
0.1123850271,
0.0065710782,
-0.3693877757,
0.5773280859,
-0.2900324464,
0.0652666762,
0.0535703562,
0.432495296,
0.5428540111,
-0.1930609494,
-0.2568048537,
0.6765921116,
0.353744626,
-0.5408064127,
0.3129086792,
0.3520733714,
-0.46226421,
1.1624629498,
-0.7312635183,
-0.1442612559,
-0.1432028413,
-0.1658709347,
-0.6431736946,
-0.6016509533,
-0.0028821442,
-0.3355918527,
0.418533504,
0.1911565363,
-0.3765554726,
-0.421925962,
-0.4695895314,
0.0817200914,
0.2322836369,
0.0225705579,
0.3558157384,
0.1059946418,
-0.4751116037,
-0.0754044279,
-0.6401484013,
0.0450219586,
0.0747501701,
-0.3541021049,
0.4817127287,
0.0051685162,
-0.4360045493,
0.1788118333,
-0.0514538512,
-0.2329692841,
-0.0271735284,
0.1648743004,
0.1542384028,
-0.2990080714,
0.0558890924,
0.4521164596,
0.0005270392,
-0.1369563937,
-0.0163949076,
0.3470738232,
-0.0881035998,
-0.6243855357,
-0.3517659903,
0.5447439551,
0.4821036458,
-0.3915129602,
0.2373387218,
0.5987966657,
-0.2215780765,
0.1842098683,
-0.4049216807,
0.062486086,
-0.4093039036,
0.547768712,
-0.163142696,
-0.5268753171,
0.280637145,
-0.0302092414,
0.2595777214,
0.830655992,
0.6618093848,
-0.0368979536,
0.8576976061,
0.2626434267,
0.5646849275,
0.1209542006,
0.0310663134,
-0.1417316943,
-0.8743359447,
-0.5789397955,
-0.5698120594,
-0.0465768427,
-0.320016712,
-0.4634670019,
0.5787563324,
0.1755609065,
-0.0330499224,
-0.1009078026,
-0.9801192284,
0.4117456377,
0.4800521731,
0.2826725245,
0.2720585167,
-0.0529777259,
-0.1350670606,
0.1249083504,
-0.3584512472,
-0.7807785273,
1.1157431602,
0.2371397465,
0.6419568062,
-0.0113929007,
0.8466203213,
0.1983694881,
0.4139363766,
-0.7838996649,
0.3487676382,
-0.8354974389,
-0.2083027512,
-0.2679286301,
-0.3894492686,
-0.7891277075,
-0.0781932101,
-0.3273565173,
-0.3832399845,
-0.1910081506,
0.012839471,
-0.7889301181,
-0.0140708014,
-0.7223286629,
0.7569467425,
-0.216681093,
-0.0962600484,
-0.2177336365,
-0.3656661212,
0.2576124668,
-0.3125459552,
0.2654822469,
-0.0387063436,
-0.152718544,
0.5548219681,
-0.7140889168,
0.5950744152,
-0.1514708847,
-0.1772530526,
0.3099242151,
0.0206824299,
-0.0408556089,
0.1601089686,
-0.0626910999,
-0.0389097929,
0.1715392321,
-0.0458479598,
-0.4014734328,
0.6431386471,
-0.3660803139,
-0.3612938821,
0.064082168,
-0.4893752933,
-0.0590708889,
0.5163330436,
0.4908336997,
0.8002499342,
-0.5393188596,
-0.0561431684,
0.4235670567,
-0.3267491162,
0.1788442582,
0.3609524667,
-0.1448359489,
-0.6058549285,
0.8969702125,
-0.1413497478,
0.1671102494,
0.2177446038,
0.4578178525,
0.1702633351,
-0.8014996052,
-0.8124473691,
0.0269823,
-0.626755774,
-0.3169401288,
-0.542353034,
-0.4471694529,
-0.3972809613,
-0.4283810556,
-0.278775394,
-0.3872119784,
-0.4258586168,
0.1230841428,
0.2067621201,
1.0749675035,
0.1703235209,
0.2918581069,
-1.0147917271,
0.3887568712,
0.1392430514,
0.5807712674,
-0.2632027566,
-0.2294005603,
-0.3643567562,
-0.2595244348,
-0.6674304008,
-0.6462345719,
0.0106608989,
0.3179128766,
0.5117078424,
0.7881214023,
-0.1673614532,
0.4011961222,
-0.8789263368,
1.0041822195,
0.5571413636,
-0.8538041711,
0.8681337237,
-0.210463509,
0.2512691021,
0.7750294209,
-0.0209962875,
-0.3172721863,
-0.8840684295,
-0.6085992455,
-0.7379642725,
0.45170784,
0.3136195242,
-0.0731975287,
-0.1910539567,
0.3657491803,
0.4216366708,
0.1630349755,
0.2722859085,
-0.102275379,
-0.1782717556,
-0.7734747529,
-0.0855929106,
-0.3448141217,
-0.3578278422,
-0.0170657057,
0.299990356,
-0.1730654389,
0.0766652748,
0.6719836593,
0.3718708158,
0.0268882029,
0.6499971151,
0.910104692,
0.7442330122,
-0.1332604438,
0.1057578623,
-0.1311511099,
-0.8526009917,
-0.1315008551,
0.3996163607,
-0.1733586192,
0.4635578096,
0.4415856898,
0.6244752407,
0.0692631602,
-0.6327571273,
0.7431517243,
-0.136082381,
-0.479554981,
0.0227048118,
0.2016936243,
-0.2225104868,
0.0671899393,
0.1459557861,
0.4016432464,
0.4981105924,
-0.1610782295,
0.3173747063,
0.2338566035,
-0.660574317,
-0.2557056844,
0.7073987722,
0.3462181091,
-0.2835384011,
0.0972309038,
-0.2471541911,
-0.1148094535,
0.6376155615,
0.2802124918,
0.9466791749,
-0.2434156388,
0.315232724,
0.3780512214,
0.0965984538,
-0.1266039908,
0.4302725196,
0.0495269261,
-0.1301855892,
-0.3772878945,
-0.6215983033,
-0.5577446222,
-0.2280473113,
-0.5612127781,
0.3209643662,
-0.3264594972,
-0.3488011956,
0.3475767374,
-0.1002105549,
-0.5813426971,
0.5300778747,
-0.0329213776,
0.895557344,
-0.3750567734,
0.3426969051,
0.8901187181,
-0.5352448821,
-0.5810637474,
0.0788980126,
-0.0418375544,
-0.4030368328,
0.2437723577,
0.1412812471,
0.0846344456,
-0.3366217911,
-0.1902525723,
-0.2955785394,
1.0659103394,
0.1323568672,
-0.4459092021,
-0.2024939358,
-0.0304094627,
0.5865555406,
-0.3959316909,
0.4483529329,
0.5766814947,
0.3937406838,
-0.2364566177,
-1.2659703493,
0.0831368268,
-0.2777330875,
-0.2748213112,
0.1363989115,
-0.3215429783,
0.9004592299,
-0.3644246161,
-0.1146485358,
0.224357307,
0.1776925474,
0.2515795827,
0.57738626,
0.2468940169,
0.3075515032,
0.8932127357,
-0.0440333001,
1.4323507547,
-0.3564243615,
0.1994792968,
0.9990433455,
0.0780102313,
0.5118069649,
0.3551518917,
-0.2158076465,
0.4234687686,
0.3176282942,
0.0449779034,
0.460472703,
0.0229134746,
-0.1959774643,
0.1414427757,
-0.271027863,
-0.3586712182,
0.3381503224,
0.4293238521,
-0.8695852757,
-0.2517607212,
-0.0220699888,
0.1898559034,
0.2305829674,
-0.4731409848,
1.0285893679,
0.1077815071,
-0.8359113932,
0.1775834113,
0.1844828576,
0.484632045,
-0.6485958695,
0.159717679,
-0.1778300852,
0.2127025574,
-0.6179989576,
-1.1944233179,
0.4136646688,
0.3354730308,
-0.4081080556,
0.0944407731,
0.6575469971,
-0.401750952,
-0.6631254554,
-0.2506627738,
0.5482810736,
0.3265619278,
0.0489449836,
-0.440712899,
-0.3192564249,
-0.1381639838,
-0.3581974804,
0.0212223455,
0.80751127,
0.0758600459,
0.1612812281,
0.3351164758,
0.574998796,
-0.2896217406,
0.3756707907,
0.7833548188,
-0.3664508164,
-0.3817020357,
-0.8776223063,
0.4312704504,
-0.373813808,
-0.5709657073,
0.6956089735,
0.8852111101,
0.4486720264,
0.038115859,
0.8391260505,
-0.2104928195,
0.5625470281,
-0.5866737962,
0.976498723,
-0.6905872822,
-0.1109838411,
-0.3855553865,
-0.5867443085,
-0.3093664944,
0.2097568065,
-0.1215344965,
-0.1523770541,
0.8462423682,
0.2243787795,
-0.1177012697,
0.0169598497,
0.1154552847,
-0.1393807083,
0.3026536107,
0.4234264493,
0.373806566,
-0.1806755066,
0.3378543854,
-0.1922950149,
-0.4082679749,
-0.1034654304,
-0.6495020986,
-0.7607565522,
-0.4730001688,
-0.3196797669,
-0.214003861,
-0.3036985695,
0.7033833265,
0.491632849,
-0.8055446148,
0.3165806532,
0.0017722308,
-0.2276185006,
-0.2185731083,
-0.220719263,
0.7496460676,
-0.7781968117,
-0.7597817779,
0.2310629338,
0.4732038081,
0.0026911902,
-0.3009955883,
-0.0948651284,
0.3671531677,
0.1599786133,
0.6904176474,
-0.2108884305,
-0.6242958307,
-0.1160694584,
-0.1729934365,
-0.6402364969,
0.0130402008,
0.9488447309,
-0.3520112336,
0.6175191402,
0.3441545963,
0.4272379279,
0.0007158637,
0.0873921812,
0.4381147325,
-0.9372839332,
-0.0575221814,
0.1633386463,
0.3362313509,
0.4594532847,
-0.4128071964,
0.5085582137,
-0.0788048282,
-0.6578245759,
-0.5651334524,
-0.0481261909,
-0.6409813166,
-0.4650127888,
1.1544387341,
-0.2386745811,
-0.0462327227,
-0.1149639711,
-0.5293149352,
0.3480069041,
-0.2783953249,
0.6496804953,
0.3051655889,
-0.2786503732,
0.3251305521,
-0.6380552053,
0.659527719,
0.246209234,
-1.196865201,
-0.0807584077,
0.7083343267,
0.1116895601,
0.4902462661,
0.9741742015,
-0.3490644693,
0.2904927731,
0.0101583954,
0.0811948553,
-0.2854862213,
-0.1430457085,
-0.005372745,
0.2443443239,
-0.0566144846,
-0.1785437763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09580v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09580v1
|
MMOE: Mixture of Multimodal Interaction Experts
| 2023-11-16T05:31:21 | 2023-11-16T05:31:21 |
Haofei Yu, Paul Pu Liang, Ruslan Salakhutdinov, Louis-Philippe Morency
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multimodal machine learning, which studies the information and interactions
across various input modalities, has made significant advancements in
understanding the relationship between images and descriptive text. However,
this is just a portion of the potential multimodal interactions seen in the
real world and does not include new interactions between conflicting utterances
and gestures in predicting sarcasm, for example. Notably, the current methods
for capturing shared information often do not extend well to these more nuanced
interactions, sometimes performing as low as 50% in binary classification. In
this paper, we address this problem via a new approach called MMOE, which
stands for a mixture of multimodal interaction experts. Our method
automatically classifies data points from unlabeled multimodal datasets by
their interaction type and employs specialized models for each specific
interaction. Based on our experiments, this approach improves performance on
these challenging interactions by more than 10%, leading to an overall increase
of 2% for tasks like sarcasm prediction. As a result, interaction
quantification provides new insights for dataset analysis and yields simple
approaches that obtain state-of-the-art performance.
|
[
-0.5948807001,
-0.8263617158,
0.4805318117,
0.1002328247,
-0.0371270403,
0.2171893567,
0.0548695996,
-0.6840198636,
0.5870121121,
0.2325685471,
-0.6089368463,
-0.2798496187,
-0.6348133087,
0.0665565804,
0.1625313461,
0.7569849491,
0.2355354428,
-0.1549267173,
-0.6582181454,
-0.2693361342,
-0.4699281156,
-0.4729441404,
-0.4404679835,
0.0343705155,
0.6911011338,
0.6147024632,
0.7174913287,
0.1879694313,
0.6588855982,
0.4633256197,
0.2458405346,
0.6996267438,
-0.1874092668,
0.0500173457,
0.0310686883,
-0.2952856123,
-0.6804257631,
0.1260481924,
0.2102932781,
0.533788681,
-0.0331702903,
-0.0231096037,
-0.3152242005,
0.3032792509,
-0.8549079895,
0.2368208319,
-0.5918053985,
0.1960899085,
0.0301037952,
-0.4667518735,
-0.628734827,
0.242446959,
0.0282762814,
-0.6566330194,
-0.1010637954,
0.0784841031,
0.4914438426,
0.2294073701,
-0.9572331905,
-0.112833485,
-0.4952465296,
1.1815154552,
-0.5287817121,
0.3292495012,
0.3559545875,
0.3486696184,
-0.1273477674,
-0.3599484563,
-1.0722937584,
-0.3305260539,
-0.0352542512,
0.2099660933,
-0.2802315354,
0.3142300844,
0.0791849941,
-0.0351912864,
-0.0552183427,
0.0421066768,
-0.2339535803,
-0.2865457237,
0.6226108074,
0.1183230728,
0.356307447,
-0.4373400807,
-0.6947435737,
-0.115707159,
0.1109330282,
0.1938658804,
0.1475005448,
-0.1329397559,
-0.1129526645,
0.7077088952,
0.0008432955,
0.5071697831,
0.2021897882,
-0.6089765429,
0.7020434737,
-0.2343590409,
-0.3348843455,
-0.3270282149,
1.0257384777,
0.9337254763,
0.1683328301,
0.1033278331,
-0.0374616273,
0.1018069461,
0.1285345256,
-0.6478297114,
-0.2235644013,
0.3423018157,
-0.3951625824,
-0.6067923307,
0.2138694823,
-1.0974574089,
-0.4513751566,
-0.572784543,
0.3715180159,
-0.5433338284,
-0.5672756433,
-0.4330819249,
-0.4651121199,
-0.270075947,
0.5955174565,
-0.689004302,
0.1504650265,
0.3619605303,
0.5917392969,
0.0181185585,
-0.4203587174,
-0.5966018438,
0.471152097,
-0.1350601465,
0.7633407116,
-0.9016284943,
-0.4256080687,
-0.2326658517,
-0.2679103613,
-0.3607441187,
-0.4144201279,
0.262704432,
-0.3856225312,
0.3448839188,
0.1773304343,
-0.5325654149,
-0.3749325573,
0.5466817021,
-0.9331993461,
0.989090085,
-0.0201008189,
-0.9849340916,
0.4187109768,
-0.8071436286,
-0.2938362062,
-0.1115981489,
-0.276745528,
-0.1486638635,
0.1740872413,
0.2122466415,
0.8621752858,
0.0879249871,
0.368580997,
-0.6571235657,
0.0760655552,
0.7295926213,
-0.4158883095,
0.2541263998,
0.1530304253,
-0.1633315831,
0.2110557109,
-1.2013310194,
-0.0027728428,
-0.5429302454,
-0.1546167284,
-0.6652277708,
-0.1959385872,
0.0035564641,
0.6168575287,
0.2555527985,
-0.540322721,
0.0917981863,
0.1884982437,
0.1469721496,
0.9297420979,
-0.0058945487,
0.4931918383,
-0.0694686398,
0.4722161889,
0.5414295793,
0.2229112983,
-0.3667865694,
-0.666922152,
-0.6412605047,
-0.711610198,
0.2618776262,
0.5906264186,
-1.5032560825,
0.3505384326,
-0.2862291336,
-0.3685253263,
-0.7251637578,
0.2586486936,
0.6117403507,
0.6943742037,
0.4975386262,
-0.3707060516,
-0.4490105212,
-0.8734012842,
0.0199271012,
-0.2359053791,
-0.1042485237,
0.6379830837,
0.3504812419,
-0.6543768048,
1.0592495203,
-0.3493639529,
-0.1499031335,
-0.094314605,
0.623233676,
-0.3243379295,
0.5498183966,
0.5774967074,
-1.1987802982,
-0.5518624783,
0.3758026063,
-0.9529521465,
0.0687041134,
-0.0077328952,
-0.0728708804,
0.2432820648,
0.4064126313,
-0.4981037676,
0.2690422237,
0.7081598043,
-0.2141251564,
0.4957431257,
-0.119613789,
0.7175357938,
-1.0927727222,
-0.0678825006,
0.3883470595,
-0.2421070933,
-0.7716247439,
-0.1288066208,
0.1138810664,
0.0487919413,
-0.6728137732,
0.6369056702,
-0.3919960856,
0.1983429939,
-0.0895371586,
-0.0285935793,
-0.0279332995,
0.7514079809,
-0.0952239037,
0.5857942104,
0.5981024504,
-0.8377661109,
0.3706902862,
0.0054658265,
0.1022117957,
1.0196852684,
-0.2911446989,
0.1434138119,
-0.1961540878,
-0.0346406028,
-1.1278737783,
-0.5560690761,
0.1224824563,
-0.7685156465,
0.272110045,
0.0131935393,
-0.4491995871,
-0.2334762067,
-0.7092584372,
0.4877652526,
0.0945506319,
-0.3175476491,
1.1490882635,
0.5600526333,
-0.0585955158,
-0.8711594343,
-0.7002480626,
-0.0290145166,
-0.2225815207,
-0.9894946814,
0.1504855752,
-0.1955881715,
-0.23935543,
-0.1205712631,
0.2632927597,
-0.4075487256,
-0.0403104462,
0.401946038,
0.4020834565,
0.0483367331,
0.2844365239,
0.2650589347,
-0.2397071272,
-0.2201695144,
0.4068768322,
0.3250408471,
0.1296887398,
-0.14436768,
-0.9865251184,
0.2984772325,
0.8229983449,
-0.0373764746,
0.7988871336,
0.9931890368,
-0.1380596757,
0.3549309373,
-0.6590730548,
-0.0130191678,
-0.5260670781,
0.4145195782,
-0.7458053231,
-0.5408496857,
0.3536570668,
-0.246689409,
0.0208167471,
0.3581477404,
0.209205538,
-0.5495406985,
1.2341229916,
1.0457293987,
-0.1712227017,
0.6350548863,
-0.0034656951,
-0.0036534509,
-0.7235546112,
-0.6497445703,
-0.0343085527,
-0.6277285218,
-0.6937659979,
-0.6746528745,
0.4428127706,
-0.2983792126,
0.3809497952,
0.1642613113,
0.0386824645,
0.2962371707,
0.547534287,
0.3277150393,
0.3475026786,
0.1235086247,
0.1017909274,
-0.2251637727,
-0.4490240812,
-0.3800773025,
0.9471374154,
0.4261077344,
0.7647441626,
0.2638035119,
0.4937961698,
0.4922874272,
0.4023412466,
-0.6788076162,
0.7402834296,
-0.0546418875,
-0.3400182128,
-0.106649749,
-0.9056990743,
-0.8948553801,
0.417807579,
-0.5795664191,
-0.6451557279,
0.2430785149,
0.4124308228,
-0.0477317572,
0.1704340726,
-1.1176921129,
0.6562546492,
-0.0349728428,
-0.2778403461,
-0.3468318582,
-0.8585651517,
0.5707102418,
0.1519211382,
0.6752436161,
-0.1309440434,
-0.2529782355,
0.7687214017,
-0.0826188102,
0.9979003668,
-0.2698318064,
-0.0073854299,
0.2549194098,
0.1465480775,
0.0911465138,
-0.1446080804,
-0.0191499051,
0.0531561524,
-0.125959143,
-0.4396268427,
-0.8250337839,
0.6395205855,
-0.8492006063,
0.1452402771,
-0.120942913,
-0.7214838862,
-0.4045836627,
-0.1377464682,
0.0220993981,
0.4724065661,
-0.1696319878,
-0.0254322365,
0.6677004695,
0.0455045663,
0.5392171144,
0.3183857799,
0.0006404112,
-0.8434264064,
1.1913665533,
-0.0652939975,
0.2710211575,
0.6798203588,
-0.0815488771,
-0.0213906989,
0.102831237,
-0.3762425184,
0.0345680974,
-0.6223881841,
-0.1073579043,
-0.922720015,
0.2916488349,
-0.4192660153,
-0.0045517539,
-0.0308676902,
-0.6189308167,
-0.3825496137,
-0.2095312625,
0.0824944153,
0.4579491019,
0.0435279794,
0.6999892592,
-1.0574790239,
0.2991733849,
0.4237665236,
-0.0357258394,
0.0836796314,
-0.1310513169,
-0.0714915097,
0.0522699282,
-0.624052465,
-1.0958961248,
0.3726190031,
0.2655967474,
0.6243991852,
0.8463050723,
-0.2407851517,
0.8337624669,
-0.2429297715,
0.6608394384,
0.8390904665,
-0.9049517512,
0.3873004913,
-0.10754437,
-0.1385381669,
0.4201346338,
0.6684769988,
-0.4955858886,
-0.2262132615,
-0.9109637737,
-0.6749212742,
0.3380261362,
0.0756156445,
0.1552868485,
0.1183298752,
-0.1865563095,
0.2704895437,
0.7988753915,
-0.861364007,
-0.1076274067,
0.1175042018,
-0.7541012168,
-0.1060256958,
-0.3345270455,
-0.1526608765,
-0.2892357111,
0.4530311525,
-0.2446015626,
0.3459585011,
-0.1046275049,
-0.5058661699,
0.0035956095,
0.144882068,
0.5052520037,
0.41631338,
-0.1825560182,
0.4971578717,
-0.0670874119,
-0.4473172128,
0.0019763608,
-0.0837550163,
0.2329386771,
0.1714201719,
0.5474307537,
0.7039356232,
0.2965327501,
-0.8773885965,
0.6153485775,
-0.0114102596,
-0.2792512476,
0.0334555469,
0.0916493908,
-0.4880377054,
0.2391184419,
0.2165853828,
0.472661972,
0.4648199379,
-0.8270295858,
0.2959833741,
0.3611167073,
-0.481931597,
-0.5395749211,
0.1660657078,
0.7476759553,
0.0138239665,
0.4379235506,
-0.2217874378,
-0.4440967441,
0.7144985199,
0.0509072468,
0.5078265071,
-0.4578366876,
0.4534665346,
0.1521240622,
0.0946627706,
0.476665765,
0.3362192214,
-0.1011634171,
-0.762816608,
-0.4229160845,
-0.1718144119,
-0.5112935305,
-0.2038451582,
-0.4913434386,
0.3495891988,
-0.2564498484,
-0.4052782655,
0.2423936576,
-0.2342278808,
-0.6166437864,
0.3687718213,
0.0740213618,
0.5703632236,
-1.0793589354,
0.4111112058,
0.7857872844,
-0.4416688979,
-0.2825174928,
-0.2001944333,
0.0770735741,
-0.6530387998,
0.4546938241,
0.5048938394,
-0.0020704835,
-0.2938475907,
-0.6020871401,
-0.4654141963,
1.0477682352,
0.1957568526,
-0.3771933913,
0.2614959776,
-0.0695673376,
0.3420079648,
-0.3868586719,
0.8771810532,
0.2846750915,
0.6027258039,
0.3132668138,
-1.0450247526,
-0.2757742703,
-0.5269042253,
-0.18832241,
0.185205549,
-0.6908444762,
0.8736088276,
-0.3329129219,
0.1318210214,
-0.236363858,
0.9416233301,
0.1668135971,
1.0748066902,
0.658192575,
0.5222031474,
1.1052882671,
0.201060608,
0.8614496589,
-0.0338439718,
0.1508076638,
0.931427598,
-0.1673325896,
0.9928873181,
0.7178224921,
-0.0862857178,
0.7329338789,
0.5879229903,
0.0549993366,
0.597250998,
-0.4116953015,
-0.4787447751,
-0.1446402371,
-0.0837814957,
-0.1735895127,
0.2619504035,
0.4309159219,
-0.2784258127,
0.2459069639,
0.4688943326,
-0.0221838709,
-0.0457255356,
-0.4450334013,
1.0422999859,
-0.1848619431,
-0.3620068729,
-0.0626073331,
-0.0361951254,
1.1382176876,
-0.2937140763,
-0.1036814675,
0.0000959595,
0.0449438803,
-0.4792999327,
-0.8058462143,
-0.0176180396,
-0.2613272965,
-0.42376104,
0.2095277905,
0.7693274021,
-0.6415042281,
-0.6193378568,
0.1952571571,
0.5457054377,
0.2229871601,
-0.0441231392,
-0.4603885114,
-0.0926680565,
0.0421941839,
0.0427509733,
0.3923329711,
0.8281065226,
0.0310708489,
0.8761588931,
0.592038095,
-0.4381913245,
0.3485842943,
-0.0813042149,
0.8759006262,
-0.6104624271,
-0.4928191602,
-0.7985969782,
0.9693495631,
-0.4617730975,
-0.2810612917,
0.5619276166,
0.3304210305,
0.5950673223,
-0.2397145629,
0.8528658748,
-0.1996715069,
0.2665497363,
-0.5306195617,
0.0821852833,
-0.6599930525,
-0.1118356064,
-0.5124668479,
-0.614064157,
0.0271046758,
0.4776495993,
-0.1058312505,
0.2477324605,
0.6160396338,
0.5645064116,
-0.4311276674,
-0.0290485788,
0.5910502672,
0.0429915152,
0.3460153043,
0.4443081915,
0.8574899435,
-0.1699225754,
0.5038143992,
-0.5412495732,
-0.7588274479,
-0.3525461555,
-0.7931187153,
-1.0301859379,
-0.555975616,
-0.4116948247,
-0.0303536896,
-0.3150678575,
0.9359917045,
0.9346272945,
-0.4338392615,
-0.0813858211,
0.3111274838,
0.0646278411,
-0.2150192559,
-0.2939343154,
-0.0839200318,
-0.1957598031,
-0.889420867,
0.1324291825,
0.2262620926,
0.1352634132,
-0.0953600779,
-0.1721936613,
-0.1287779659,
0.1498824209,
1.0092372894,
-0.1118124947,
-0.4716038704,
0.1003568992,
-0.0510545149,
0.0572198965,
0.1720622033,
0.5901346803,
-0.6428244114,
0.612249136,
0.3163225055,
0.5827103257,
0.1959815621,
0.1319436729,
0.4063569605,
-1.1829001904,
0.3106400669,
0.1489863545,
0.336545527,
0.2709473968,
-0.4245071411,
0.2922060788,
0.4643062651,
-0.3163142204,
-0.7241423726,
0.1892283112,
-1.4774371386,
-0.0803400502,
0.9610901475,
0.0117018269,
-0.3395582736,
0.1324338615,
-0.4937447906,
-0.0383724235,
-0.7797752023,
0.8245252371,
0.6820964813,
-0.3771787584,
-0.4322538376,
-0.5470027924,
0.064289093,
0.3201034665,
-1.0732265711,
-0.5042291284,
0.7116968632,
0.0038796936,
0.5944749713,
0.6077964902,
0.3158593476,
0.2042148858,
-0.2023758292,
0.352750808,
-0.0633564517,
-0.6984391809,
0.1618189961,
0.3379430175,
-0.2671734691,
-0.5484608412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09579v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09579v2
|
Crafting In-context Examples according to LMs' Parametric Knowledge
| 2023-11-16T05:30:07 | 2024-04-04T01:00:16 |
Yoonsang Lee, Pranav Atreya, Xi Ye, Eunsol Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In-context learning can improve the performances of knowledge-rich tasks such
as question answering. In such scenarios, in-context examples trigger a
language model (LM) to surface information stored in its parametric knowledge.
We study how to better construct in-context example sets, based on whether the
model is aware of the in-context examples. We identify 'known' examples, where
models can correctly answer from their parametric knowledge, and 'unknown'
ones. Our experiments show that prompting with 'unknown' examples decreases the
performance, potentially as it encourages hallucination rather than searching
for its parametric knowledge. Constructing an in-context example set that
presents both known and unknown information performs the best across diverse
settings. We perform analysis on three multi-answer question answering
datasets, which allows us to further study answer set ordering strategies based
on the LM's knowledge of each answer. Together, our study sheds light on how to
best construct in-context example sets for knowledge-rich tasks.
|
[
-0.4302884638,
-0.8365311623,
0.798977077,
-0.0088598477,
-0.2326319218,
-0.2203257233,
-0.11718788,
-0.3204627633,
-0.2536429763,
0.4508110881,
-0.3879136443,
-0.4408470094,
-0.0940306261,
-0.1032356694,
-0.4668507576,
0.9309225678,
0.0529773049,
-0.0579224229,
-0.765116632,
-0.4790475965,
-0.6130078435,
-0.4959082305,
-0.5323272347,
-0.0703765303,
0.4538565278,
0.6554547548,
0.6311190724,
0.6200288534,
0.0702637956,
0.2247375846,
-0.0138913849,
0.4282175303,
-0.3697176278,
0.3165370226,
-0.0849367455,
-0.4810871482,
0.0759232268,
0.0506081209,
0.5318687558,
0.8847908974,
-0.0320596658,
0.3118467927,
0.2256002426,
0.1449708194,
-0.6253324747,
0.114464812,
-0.5522537231,
-0.1611242741,
0.150135532,
-0.4590041339,
-0.4809941053,
-0.3202746212,
0.2598623335,
-0.6031718254,
0.136729449,
-0.0076160626,
0.5052450895,
0.1468851715,
-0.3147549033,
-0.4934764206,
-0.6669253707,
0.7811176777,
-0.8480862975,
0.3219568431,
0.5002632141,
0.6702825427,
-0.1093951464,
-0.6825866699,
-0.3748426139,
0.1116697341,
-0.3161453009,
-0.0573105998,
0.3504088521,
-0.1131627336,
0.5277339816,
0.0047736126,
-0.4657739699,
-0.2337326705,
-0.3379321396,
0.0485677645,
0.2726411521,
0.1376744062,
0.193847999,
-0.1066357195,
-0.1469099522,
-0.0983432829,
-0.970061779,
0.3860473335,
0.2135177255,
0.4082742035,
0.0580757745,
0.5222315192,
-0.3604954183,
1.2999351025,
-0.0505943522,
-0.151660189,
0.0312544219,
-0.3164425194,
-0.1310323924,
-0.2764093876,
0.1815056205,
0.5028173327,
0.1430607289,
-0.3646814525,
-0.2252344638,
-0.4273649752,
0.0894698203,
-0.7694678307,
-0.0106991371,
0.1997732371,
-0.4923973978,
-0.0705582723,
0.0805683061,
-0.7046596408,
-0.4396881163,
-0.314135015,
0.721229136,
-0.3774579763,
-0.0168698337,
0.2056411207,
-0.4928104281,
0.4339448512,
0.2514769435,
-0.5192041993,
0.3418072164,
0.5619012713,
0.4112674296,
0.279024303,
-0.4215617776,
-0.8803034425,
0.4472385645,
-0.3570450544,
0.7221167684,
-0.7506429553,
-0.1578197181,
0.1604932547,
-0.2043088675,
0.1287634969,
-0.7989839315,
0.2400257736,
-0.5210754275,
0.6119114161,
-0.7647210956,
-0.7815319896,
-0.176843673,
-0.0151087958,
-0.4295707643,
0.9460600615,
0.2050740868,
-0.7005626559,
0.4638665915,
-0.5758624673,
-0.3826751113,
0.0377177335,
-0.4521144629,
0.0575100258,
0.203272596,
0.3202959597,
0.8252503276,
-0.1548829377,
0.0697549582,
-0.2491717041,
-0.5139897466,
0.4236060679,
-0.1510299742,
0.6332045197,
0.2371000499,
-0.1864005029,
-0.1332569867,
-0.5262541771,
0.0586886965,
-0.0400753543,
-0.2138086855,
-0.7381514311,
0.161986962,
-0.1874158382,
0.5075739622,
0.0020711997,
-0.3389535248,
-0.226060316,
-0.4673527181,
0.2542639375,
0.6019257307,
0.4762082994,
0.4603866637,
-0.7361747026,
0.3611807525,
-0.0283786543,
0.0227893032,
-0.2206401825,
-0.3682390451,
-0.6243458986,
0.1341283619,
0.0369985476,
0.2477576882,
-0.895470202,
-0.0531898588,
0.0670085698,
-0.3780271411,
-0.364649266,
0.2241012603,
0.6081613898,
0.9215167165,
0.3928765357,
0.4127082229,
-0.3825596273,
-0.9743213058,
-0.6506984234,
-0.0522882715,
-0.0928526074,
0.6159379482,
0.1264297515,
0.311008811,
1.0296469927,
-0.5066174269,
0.4329438508,
-0.2848317027,
-0.124195151,
0.0778489113,
0.2410084158,
0.669203341,
-0.855040133,
-0.4368849993,
-0.2639608979,
-0.8662257791,
0.1460852772,
-0.0952786729,
-0.2469860464,
-0.108028762,
0.6622533798,
-0.2844448686,
0.0777293816,
0.2590119541,
-0.2969961762,
0.1993350983,
-0.2672788203,
0.0980427712,
-1.4260196686,
-0.2591465414,
-0.0875532329,
-0.2641365826,
-0.9469076395,
0.2821779847,
0.276316613,
-0.1405733526,
-0.6038483977,
0.7719365358,
-0.3690291941,
-0.1821777821,
-0.1053056866,
0.1539077759,
-0.0234101973,
0.4623544216,
0.2603208125,
0.8514091969,
0.6343841553,
-0.9353151917,
-0.076895833,
0.158192277,
-0.891366303,
0.4266993105,
-0.4959795773,
0.1423794329,
-0.4302658439,
-0.1850874871,
-0.9141098261,
-0.3568665385,
0.0086483136,
-0.2011948377,
0.0111988308,
-0.0706336275,
-0.6020647883,
-0.1049522385,
-0.0653330982,
0.5531716943,
0.5492872,
-0.797621727,
0.3366737664,
0.3667402565,
-0.0050646784,
-0.617175281,
-0.4923107922,
-0.3207117915,
-0.8160378337,
-0.1543445587,
0.3435410261,
-0.4729477763,
-0.4665900171,
-0.2137816697,
-0.3148382008,
-0.2770290077,
0.1400227994,
0.1479113698,
-0.206911236,
-0.1171576679,
0.4946238995,
0.1642431617,
0.3683234155,
0.0618722551,
-0.1269854009,
0.5397814512,
-0.2016950101,
-0.3986472785,
-0.1429023892,
0.5459288359,
0.495444119,
-0.2029381692,
0.7952538133,
0.1119983047,
-0.6656048894,
-0.5099880099,
-0.5660638809,
-0.4421529174,
-0.5229754448,
0.2343307436,
-0.5995708704,
-0.6268669963,
0.617970407,
0.1734223813,
0.1955344975,
-0.0825016871,
0.3169542253,
-0.3371450901,
0.8876945972,
0.4370911419,
0.1535571218,
0.5011832714,
-0.1758158952,
0.1407133341,
-0.7402258515,
-0.1293554157,
-0.3441824913,
-0.1588453948,
-0.2650226653,
-0.4939868152,
0.3812611401,
0.2636633515,
-0.2228766978,
0.5226496458,
-0.2295292914,
0.8285078406,
0.5336673856,
0.5595577359,
0.0628884211,
-0.1157726347,
-0.0658345148,
0.3533800244,
-1.0970093012,
-0.5965053439,
1.0722450018,
0.0780550018,
0.5294677615,
0.0249739476,
0.6913087368,
-0.1262701452,
0.1618237048,
-0.3628446758,
0.51953578,
0.1532101184,
-0.5908352733,
-0.4260420501,
-0.1602184772,
-0.7054956555,
0.0511433035,
0.0995362028,
-0.4994704425,
0.1970948875,
0.1874233484,
-0.5952280164,
0.0898483098,
-0.6903856397,
0.8298462033,
-0.0535542071,
-0.1297443956,
0.03991035,
-0.5617338419,
0.0728490502,
0.0946227163,
0.3401443362,
0.2488391548,
-0.1636850387,
0.6107869744,
-0.1274522394,
0.7584563494,
-0.3605443835,
-0.0559187457,
0.5753655434,
0.1660434306,
0.4993805885,
0.3759471476,
-0.3807974756,
-0.4646866918,
0.1750736386,
-0.5335695148,
-1.0688663721,
0.6753951311,
-0.5207877159,
-0.7606849074,
0.221366778,
-1.0249747038,
-0.5597698689,
-0.2260956019,
0.3943216503,
0.9076541066,
0.1340980828,
0.3722518981,
0.8867602348,
-0.2365571409,
0.5867325068,
0.4699666202,
-0.0435823947,
-0.0170897823,
0.8077930808,
0.2047084868,
0.400090456,
0.5956987143,
0.2647778392,
-0.4342324138,
-0.4947412014,
-0.4021372795,
0.1445340365,
-1.1724461317,
-0.0767513439,
-0.6047603488,
-0.0976393968,
-0.2537178695,
-0.3004359901,
0.2747980654,
-0.448988378,
-0.1369201541,
-0.1589294225,
0.2508170605,
0.7055845857,
0.3804526925,
0.2113437653,
-0.4080261588,
0.2189374119,
0.6977069378,
0.2534647882,
0.1142068803,
-0.3968375325,
-0.2571391463,
0.1685042232,
0.1665919423,
-1.1423919201,
0.0789082795,
0.2113878429,
1.0767358541,
0.5661801696,
0.2125993222,
0.8347985148,
-0.372096628,
0.7034525275,
-0.4525067508,
-0.6146760583,
0.6343804002,
-0.4677744508,
0.3857853413,
0.6575509906,
0.4660492539,
-0.6624603868,
-0.8244761825,
-0.5747365952,
-0.5361996889,
0.6120004058,
0.0879876837,
0.2661880553,
-0.3150075078,
0.5579642653,
0.415027976,
0.4641084075,
-0.7970611453,
-0.1861721277,
0.0025080128,
-0.2408068925,
-0.295188427,
-0.1395723373,
-0.2472712845,
-0.2778249681,
0.3975693882,
-0.1960095167,
0.1882826686,
0.0231470019,
-0.4259042144,
0.2230425775,
0.1162586808,
0.7569848895,
1.0648647547,
-0.1670878381,
0.387593627,
0.4553310275,
0.2007476687,
-0.0820560977,
-0.1735892445,
-0.16629605,
-0.1280388683,
0.2325508147,
0.5235664248,
0.2222145796,
-0.9413107038,
0.3851317763,
0.0433152542,
0.0209340751,
-0.2180228084,
0.2132170647,
0.2525886297,
0.2924695909,
0.1710679829,
-0.1410173476,
0.2985456288,
-0.6288894415,
0.1777752638,
0.6155369282,
-0.3427707553,
-0.006626477,
0.292419523,
-0.1618781686,
-0.4667954445,
0.4179933071,
-0.005462213,
-0.2680551112,
0.7770626545,
0.7621557117,
0.4335863888,
-0.1352492124,
0.2979934812,
0.2021327615,
-0.0358742103,
-0.0865320638,
0.4255914986,
-0.6289480329,
-0.7449600101,
-0.0692257956,
-0.4181139767,
-0.2616146207,
0.3809799552,
-0.7344664335,
0.2496642768,
-0.3152788281,
0.3388054669,
-0.146102488,
-0.3909072876,
-0.7809877992,
0.1771587133,
-0.2316607535,
0.7149314284,
-1.1019508839,
0.6299589276,
0.8196767569,
-0.4628273845,
-0.7391958833,
0.3786376715,
-0.4836193919,
-0.5697487593,
0.4736223817,
0.1902587414,
0.0667362288,
-0.0791729838,
-0.4191947877,
-0.8437474966,
1.0725040436,
0.2521551251,
0.0300919525,
-0.0553619899,
0.2545736432,
0.5618905425,
-0.5796403885,
0.3771360815,
0.2257786542,
0.1789389551,
-0.1903131902,
-0.5723251104,
0.1403449476,
-0.157910645,
0.0029404282,
0.0649444088,
-0.5472581983,
0.77356112,
-0.1284763217,
-0.0936940089,
-0.0031104197,
0.5733655095,
0.3321151733,
0.425676614,
0.5221281052,
0.2661649287,
0.7091953158,
0.3342272937,
1.0463629961,
-0.283118844,
-0.2400377691,
1.3509935141,
0.0160556622,
0.8692002296,
0.6706347466,
0.2700914145,
0.5529662967,
0.9471299648,
0.3741934896,
0.8344640136,
0.1391905993,
-0.3275479972,
-0.4262620807,
0.0184330009,
-0.2693128288,
0.3101304471,
0.2789399624,
-0.3727557361,
-0.4931750596,
0.3127217591,
-0.2074088007,
0.2383583039,
-0.2719806731,
0.8347040415,
-0.2074971348,
-0.8289152384,
0.6169611216,
-0.127588287,
0.2059354335,
-0.2035572678,
-0.1975354403,
-0.4122678339,
-0.2278230488,
0.0271518584,
-0.8496290445,
0.3600453734,
-0.1343507469,
-0.4578324854,
-0.3682804108,
0.4598842859,
-0.5560932755,
-0.3218400776,
0.0580632798,
0.8096380234,
0.350241214,
-0.1198073849,
-0.3138547242,
-0.681538105,
-0.2132282704,
-0.1052118987,
0.5304329991,
0.548169136,
-0.2300659865,
0.7213631272,
0.3824422657,
-0.2921795249,
0.1486078948,
-0.0801359341,
0.8403636813,
-0.3022024632,
-0.360963732,
-0.6084745526,
0.5023109317,
-0.2587417364,
-0.2379122972,
0.9332419634,
0.8423360586,
1.098705411,
-0.292630136,
0.6706603765,
0.1276463717,
0.6312221885,
-0.4739944339,
0.6269850135,
-0.7338125706,
0.4529871941,
-0.3230029643,
-0.8117781878,
-0.0765345842,
0.493018508,
-0.3756623566,
0.0394265614,
0.6745670438,
1.0642826557,
-0.2021178901,
-0.0160594042,
0.5713370442,
-0.1713997573,
-0.0300285183,
0.4532496929,
1.0210671425,
-0.3563451171,
0.6019288301,
-0.5956441164,
-0.0518925637,
0.1900504082,
-0.7642038465,
-1.1962450743,
-1.0296128988,
-0.0702482983,
-0.2387738377,
0.1044848114,
0.7900474072,
0.7969110608,
-0.7339158654,
-0.5687491894,
-0.1139875948,
0.3299123943,
-0.453332752,
-0.1909441799,
0.3203066885,
-0.6032323837,
-0.6527886987,
0.648712039,
-0.0949650183,
0.0057713315,
0.1978146285,
-0.0234559923,
-0.1026995853,
0.2256560177,
0.6028956771,
0.2037545592,
-0.7050417066,
-0.5028674006,
0.2859074771,
0.2776671946,
-0.0597991422,
0.8766002059,
-0.9121388793,
0.3664466739,
0.6529663205,
0.7090134621,
0.2125809938,
0.2471324205,
0.6193652749,
-0.9474982023,
0.1443683207,
0.3189509213,
0.3298951983,
0.1324347705,
-0.3980396688,
0.0981976315,
-0.2210934162,
-0.5001100898,
-0.8690851927,
0.448343873,
-0.5886775851,
-0.6855957508,
1.3206607103,
-0.0599201173,
-0.0145017924,
-0.3204761744,
0.0230289586,
0.1702313125,
-0.1694105715,
0.8259752989,
0.7997794151,
-0.282851398,
-0.2222825587,
-0.6182578206,
0.8148502707,
0.4253431261,
-0.9294115901,
0.2458031774,
0.3945395947,
0.4649412036,
-0.1753382385,
0.376273334,
0.0675423592,
0.3416790068,
-0.280641973,
-0.4363291562,
-0.1104661599,
-0.6527960896,
-0.3017677665,
0.3835886419,
0.2471011728,
-0.1493573487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09578v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09578v2
|
Tied-Lora: Enhancing parameter efficiency of LoRA with weight tying
| 2023-11-16T05:29:39 | 2024-04-12T23:15:51 |
Adithya Renduchintala, Tugrul Konuk, Oleksii Kuchaiev
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We introduce Tied-LoRA, a novel paradigm leveraging weight tying and
selective training to enhance the parameter efficiency of Low-rank Adaptation
(LoRA). Our exploration encompasses different plausible combinations of
parameter training and freezing, coupled with weight tying, aimed at
identifying the optimal trade-off between performance and the count of
trainable parameters. Across $5$ diverse tasks and two foundational language
models with different parameter counts, our experiments provide comprehensive
insights into the inherent trade-offs between efficiency and performance.
Our findings reveal a specific Tied-LoRA configuration that distinguishes
itself by showcasing comparable performance to LoRA across multiple tasks while
utilizing only a fraction of the parameters employed by the standard LoRA
method, particularly at elevated ranks. This underscores the efficacy of
Tied-LoRA in achieving impressive results with significantly reduced model
complexity.
|
[
-0.3242357373,
-0.5365329385,
0.3419293463,
-0.1736644655,
-0.51543504,
0.1173184142,
-0.166327253,
-0.3858048022,
0.5783588886,
0.4963136613,
-0.1889317334,
-0.2211412042,
-0.6994512677,
-0.2695813775,
-0.4164335728,
1.1477724314,
-0.0011506919,
-0.0980039015,
-0.1307706088,
-0.5655090213,
-0.4842738509,
-0.5386470556,
-0.753723979,
-0.616853416,
1.2024917603,
0.6292375922,
0.6172148585,
0.7784621119,
0.632288754,
0.1853990853,
0.0619157739,
0.1240537986,
-0.8401044011,
0.0970617831,
-0.0586614609,
-0.7259385586,
-0.9901919365,
0.0046701692,
0.9131121039,
0.8902933598,
-0.2738958001,
0.5316660404,
0.1965678781,
0.9471874237,
-0.9572675228,
-0.3728869855,
-0.9901820421,
-0.3268470466,
-0.4679704607,
-0.3347789645,
-0.31326437,
-0.3146510422,
-0.1219957769,
-0.7341935635,
-0.2431259751,
-0.2300604135,
0.8985488415,
0.6771222949,
-0.3637519181,
-0.0167151988,
-0.6662377715,
0.624388814,
-0.7014632821,
0.4141331911,
0.5617138147,
0.2842264473,
0.3224950135,
-0.5288038254,
0.0556172282,
-0.1019883826,
0.3296940029,
0.1490839571,
-0.0993399918,
-0.203216657,
0.4311986566,
0.1531127393,
-0.2725747824,
0.6185118556,
-0.6473354697,
0.185093686,
0.7534615397,
-0.1707497835,
-0.0723095387,
0.2963580489,
-0.1276729703,
-0.0788990036,
-0.6646150351,
0.2660830319,
0.502124846,
0.5875739455,
-0.2280019373,
0.5821018219,
-0.2986935973,
0.9942749143,
0.2418327928,
-0.3687823713,
-0.0873778164,
0.175140202,
-0.1226048619,
0.0644334778,
0.2758947611,
0.1505825818,
0.1936867088,
-0.2544203103,
-0.1813135296,
0.2071429938,
0.2064742148,
-0.6972225904,
-0.1871103793,
-0.2074706107,
-0.3584590554,
-0.4159764647,
-0.1822420061,
-0.6426247954,
-0.3460603356,
-0.1721173972,
0.8071305752,
-0.3260386586,
0.1046922803,
0.1594139785,
-0.3326569796,
0.5391801,
0.4694054425,
-1.0251902342,
0.7236947417,
0.5952798128,
0.8730589747,
-0.2959574461,
-0.4917313159,
-1.2660512924,
0.3043545187,
-0.2936554253,
0.7535559535,
-0.4781230092,
0.0589679033,
-0.3973721862,
-0.4810782075,
-0.2739998698,
-0.1751949042,
0.4332934916,
-0.6895700097,
-0.0557766631,
-0.3464227021,
-0.3200921416,
0.0086588627,
-0.0058724927,
-0.8596599102,
1.1538118124,
0.1916833818,
-0.6122005582,
0.5746570826,
-0.6921831965,
-0.5206303,
-0.077946566,
0.1783113331,
-0.4731522799,
0.3594182134,
0.1097157896,
0.051468771,
-0.5067800879,
-0.265615195,
-0.4339381158,
-0.7272236347,
0.2472014576,
-0.0431379266,
0.4852203429,
0.1157741621,
0.0382599607,
0.0899299681,
-0.7186352015,
0.0881658196,
0.2626384795,
-0.823579371,
-0.7047222853,
-0.0302333124,
-0.2185731977,
-0.1810092926,
0.2837601602,
-0.0936865136,
0.6153696775,
-0.3187839687,
0.3241165876,
0.6397227049,
-0.245732069,
0.5258543491,
-0.4010552168,
0.5871436,
-0.4508044124,
0.2079715878,
0.400437355,
-0.5876139402,
-0.945351243,
-0.3565815389,
0.6438336372,
0.2877518833,
-0.6676831841,
0.203412801,
-0.2030910403,
-0.6657142639,
-0.4488094449,
0.2712543011,
0.2810345888,
0.5027823448,
0.223950088,
-0.3448769748,
-0.3832986057,
-0.5486439466,
-0.6190156341,
-0.2084818184,
0.157193929,
-0.194042623,
0.6562289596,
0.3022091687,
1.0331840515,
-0.7414956689,
-0.2460429072,
-0.2883111835,
0.1457495987,
0.3945454061,
0.59246099,
0.8569505215,
-0.6136481166,
-0.4775162041,
0.0977390856,
-0.566735208,
0.114083156,
0.0595080629,
-0.07844574,
0.035319116,
0.4011496305,
-0.1794688106,
0.4414760768,
0.855692327,
-0.227679655,
0.231689766,
-0.4364392757,
0.0175348036,
-1.0597852468,
0.3233192265,
-0.3858781755,
-0.1189796552,
-0.7897370458,
0.1451027244,
-0.0265678987,
-0.316532433,
-0.2913967073,
0.4293948114,
-0.4799455106,
-0.3022668064,
-0.2487236708,
0.1405603439,
-0.0842263922,
0.7535261512,
-0.1848630756,
0.6587725878,
0.5561558604,
-0.5624809861,
0.3039643764,
0.1891813129,
-0.2106406838,
0.5178183913,
-0.7984868884,
0.5036363602,
0.0349917524,
0.000455576,
-0.6473461986,
-0.326872468,
0.0897622555,
-0.3647985458,
0.1027329192,
-0.6060261726,
-0.0937227234,
-0.0841280147,
-0.5751672983,
0.7454405427,
0.7856717706,
-0.3886934221,
0.5407756567,
0.2036977559,
0.0895439908,
-0.5221804976,
-0.7292465568,
-0.1016403362,
-0.8320694566,
-0.1270685047,
0.3142672181,
-0.1195561141,
-0.0405567251,
-0.1734384149,
-0.2782023847,
-0.2299300432,
0.5653293133,
0.0517189018,
0.050932277,
-0.2997788787,
0.0000680908,
0.1627642065,
-0.1870351881,
-0.3173967898,
-0.3823928833,
0.5056319833,
-0.0632132664,
-0.6088570952,
-0.3231346607,
0.4650136828,
0.618560195,
-0.3941135705,
1.0845599174,
0.5235110521,
-0.496352911,
-0.1580129415,
-0.3660024405,
0.0563234389,
-0.4483976364,
0.223281309,
-0.5270709991,
-0.7406247258,
0.7199361324,
-0.0866401568,
-0.0937873274,
0.2885226607,
0.150800541,
-0.1559742242,
0.8976246119,
0.9010494947,
-0.2439936101,
0.6728355885,
-0.2814334035,
0.1506578475,
-0.801078856,
0.0631865263,
-0.8099863529,
-0.589512229,
-0.6328430176,
-0.4966785014,
0.6961160898,
0.7826133966,
-0.2254414409,
0.4317019582,
-0.2602809966,
0.4764688909,
0.6292461157,
0.2632188797,
0.4392906129,
-0.1474968791,
0.2639955282,
0.0940837264,
-1.1934885979,
-0.113089405,
1.082226038,
0.1997377574,
1.0852804184,
0.2030832022,
0.8469772935,
0.3872774541,
0.1075282916,
-1.1572390795,
0.4856066406,
-0.2429801673,
-0.1405501664,
-0.6011292338,
-0.2467676997,
-0.9890012741,
0.2211540937,
-0.152679801,
-1.0219311714,
0.0870351344,
0.5564240813,
-0.364848882,
0.3669486046,
-0.5806177855,
0.4569724798,
-0.4254577458,
-0.3277176321,
-0.3172679543,
-0.5296325684,
0.300029844,
-0.3470768631,
-0.1666026264,
-0.105541952,
-0.3478876054,
1.1720799208,
-0.3175388277,
0.8572567701,
-0.057341408,
-0.3991739154,
-0.2320256531,
-0.1918286681,
0.8119636178,
-0.1768590063,
-0.3697767854,
-0.0710355863,
0.0341113061,
-0.716843009,
-0.7284254432,
0.7480982542,
-0.790466547,
-0.3966608644,
-0.3740974665,
-0.659039557,
-0.4941115379,
0.3726049662,
0.3338698149,
0.6351644397,
-0.173332721,
0.218042627,
0.6753079891,
0.0775836185,
0.288833499,
0.2771788239,
-0.1879981309,
-0.5861705542,
0.9173875451,
0.4025919139,
0.4769918919,
0.6081165671,
0.309009552,
0.1381079108,
-0.8379474878,
-0.2562427223,
0.3890493214,
-0.769200325,
-0.3598149121,
-0.0829689503,
-0.1579593867,
-0.3011676669,
-0.5363282561,
-0.6647629738,
-0.5641901493,
-0.0668378174,
0.2021440715,
0.5398298502,
0.7675971389,
-0.0006492144,
0.5544245243,
-0.4248728156,
0.6298084259,
0.6271028519,
0.5997444987,
-0.1450711787,
-0.6140141487,
-0.6247810721,
-0.1713094711,
0.1526035964,
-0.9037389159,
0.2075140327,
0.5339953303,
0.5668685436,
0.3743540943,
0.3614452779,
0.8841474652,
-0.2588094473,
0.5192062259,
0.2854610085,
-1.0769592524,
0.732226789,
-0.5225875378,
0.5207213759,
0.5166513324,
0.1729145199,
-0.2374680489,
-0.1710085124,
-0.2807204723,
-0.7690215707,
0.8717387915,
0.1582627743,
-0.1728114039,
0.7008730769,
0.3296636641,
0.1576419622,
0.0414961465,
-0.545199573,
-0.1886095703,
0.0046286909,
0.108571589,
-0.0114791002,
-0.244446218,
-0.4972984493,
-0.4494852722,
0.5981382132,
-0.738249898,
0.1991188526,
-0.2034886926,
-0.3773077726,
-0.1366177797,
0.0803401098,
0.6118395329,
0.9532796144,
-0.2637925744,
0.0451989919,
0.7101593018,
-0.2487894893,
-0.1200708672,
-0.0571740679,
-0.1550791264,
-0.3714536726,
0.6417577267,
1.1076579094,
0.440423727,
-0.2361513972,
-0.0267849118,
0.076470755,
-0.2956613898,
0.06218509,
0.2467332929,
0.131791696,
0.1399047524,
0.3995251954,
0.0009478154,
-0.1023504063,
-0.3304079473,
0.0065489849,
0.4142065644,
-0.2154871523,
-0.4072518051,
0.5317697525,
0.3904303312,
-0.3950300813,
0.2926165462,
0.3570799828,
-0.209525615,
0.4380095899,
0.5114608407,
0.6820906997,
-0.2347026914,
0.1980001777,
0.1466969252,
0.1954593509,
0.173608914,
0.3337919116,
-0.3999613225,
-0.6130500436,
-0.4027305841,
-0.7104221582,
-0.4819617271,
-0.0260168277,
-1.322290659,
0.3668577075,
-0.2711988986,
-0.1495400667,
-0.0829298943,
-0.0036986831,
-0.5062777996,
-0.1091293842,
0.0412570946,
1.0601980686,
-0.9392588139,
1.0668050051,
0.8736981153,
-0.2992986739,
-0.6772360206,
0.2289687097,
-0.2138929218,
-0.9570987225,
0.4262126982,
-0.2836267948,
-0.7233837843,
0.1950744539,
-0.4156877697,
-1.2843463421,
1.2642753124,
0.8851370215,
-0.0829702914,
-0.1772643328,
0.0820462778,
0.43321383,
-0.1633057892,
-0.1972652823,
0.803516686,
0.4666193724,
0.0789285377,
-1.1205259562,
-0.0976783335,
-0.1981227547,
0.1140709668,
0.2791855633,
-0.9059010744,
0.5702915192,
-0.1855404377,
0.1531312168,
0.3894971609,
0.6690906286,
0.264185816,
0.2363990992,
0.6214268208,
0.4328466952,
0.8723057508,
0.0294867288,
0.7484486103,
-0.0103384154,
0.326823324,
1.0681005716,
-0.5088524222,
0.9995057583,
0.719989121,
-0.1007112041,
0.397754848,
0.4493446052,
0.367290169,
0.5418789387,
-0.0138883097,
0.0469372198,
-0.3078315258,
-0.3415806592,
-0.4961655438,
0.879694581,
0.1313854158,
0.123222895,
-0.0847385451,
0.0517687649,
0.1312439442,
0.0303378813,
-0.4090696573,
0.9231297374,
-0.0102435322,
-0.86571908,
1.106731534,
-0.3424370885,
0.6237080097,
-1.0597447157,
0.0872826502,
-0.3241302073,
0.2091772854,
-0.1352498829,
-0.25924775,
0.03437493,
0.1864973605,
-0.1890105158,
-0.3679260314,
0.8003769517,
-0.3394007981,
-0.3799956143,
0.4014968574,
0.5954164863,
0.0504979976,
0.1252363026,
-0.4981323183,
0.3540632725,
-0.3030837476,
-0.2325493544,
0.6676363349,
0.1544270217,
-0.0879743993,
0.7221438289,
0.5065065026,
0.2864947021,
-0.0476062782,
0.1617794931,
1.2085638046,
-0.6828939319,
-0.6934172511,
-0.4547456205,
0.5096278787,
-0.0221257079,
-0.3772965372,
0.5979590416,
0.3685750365,
0.5371829867,
-0.0892642215,
0.6070026755,
-0.1414220184,
0.2393953055,
-0.9488349557,
0.7992438674,
-0.7960463166,
0.1117892638,
-0.3241544962,
-0.7896091938,
-0.0952109843,
0.0858956128,
-0.200634554,
0.0552595332,
0.8003640771,
0.359161377,
-0.2501119971,
-0.608890295,
0.5687323809,
-0.1512047052,
0.0250731297,
0.705707252,
0.7425438166,
-0.6072936654,
0.5649372339,
-0.1138791293,
-0.3022374809,
-0.333029151,
-1.1141940355,
-0.8407989144,
-0.7376948595,
-0.4993514121,
0.0697683841,
0.3556376398,
0.5260703564,
1.1546325684,
-0.6927799582,
-0.4843252897,
0.2300956249,
0.2003700733,
-0.6897003055,
-0.0838247016,
0.2333165258,
-0.0817075074,
-0.5639426112,
0.659943521,
0.0956107751,
-0.2300877869,
-0.0624089129,
-0.2937276959,
-0.4590307474,
0.1709734797,
0.5496580005,
0.5774029493,
-0.6199253201,
-0.2255472839,
-0.2952591777,
0.2073908597,
-0.031335447,
0.9149327278,
-0.8627356291,
0.0049342401,
0.6760593653,
0.5929134488,
0.7290390134,
0.1537697911,
0.7100794315,
-0.8248784542,
0.2445946634,
0.0431794301,
0.2115640789,
0.2095357031,
-0.1863256544,
0.7472641468,
-0.0396305099,
-0.3580082357,
-1.064617157,
0.3344401121,
-1.3297621012,
0.0144961597,
0.9040988684,
-0.0979712531,
-0.0551592037,
0.2877318561,
-0.053588111,
0.4401709139,
-0.3430452943,
0.5767786503,
0.3053302169,
-0.4894551635,
-0.1243155003,
-0.2838650942,
0.5498759747,
0.5849093199,
-1.0824770927,
-0.1579610854,
0.1272464544,
0.1212073714,
-0.0327620059,
0.4504250288,
0.4262284935,
0.3411875367,
-0.1658679843,
-0.3110781312,
-0.0407762378,
-0.4701319635,
-0.6424721479,
0.2639490366,
0.7586914897,
-0.4148616493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09576v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09576v1
|
Work State-Centric AI Agents: Design, Implementation, and Management of Cognitive Work Threads
| 2023-11-16T05:21:25 | 2023-11-16T05:21:25 |
Chen Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
AI agents excel in executing predefined tasks, but the dynamic management of
work state information during task execution remains an underexplored area. We
propose a work state-centric AI agent model employing "work notes" to record
and reflect the state throughout task execution. This paper details the model's
architecture, featuring worker threads for task oversight, planner modules for
task decomposition and planning, and executor modules for performing subtasks
using a ReAct-inspired thought-action loop. We provide an exhaustive work state
record incorporating plans and outcomes, constituting a comprehensive work
journal. Our results show that this model not only improves task execution
efficiency but also lays a solid foundation for subsequent task analysis and
auditing.
|
[
0.1918132454,
-0.7576579452,
0.6536108851,
-0.176243484,
-0.2147408426,
0.0972936526,
-0.1598232538,
-0.6008363366,
0.6004283428,
0.5280083418,
-0.6276406646,
-0.2408169359,
-0.4543660879,
-0.2514877617,
-0.5260758996,
1.2262986898,
-0.3080945015,
-0.4032515585,
-0.3143391609,
0.0593927428,
-0.8245273829,
-0.2965738177,
-0.5834527016,
-0.7359410524,
0.3318114877,
0.0150028272,
0.5514153838,
0.6164005995,
0.5388461351,
0.4470217526,
0.214390412,
0.2428335398,
-0.2943364382,
0.4539625645,
-0.3531810641,
-0.7539083362,
-1.0701972246,
0.350461334,
0.1333838403,
0.077782996,
-0.3666284978,
0.2355939746,
-0.2467371374,
0.3708323836,
-0.6691954732,
0.8568097353,
-0.0696162358,
0.1795599312,
-0.1460201591,
-0.0119544491,
-0.5986526608,
-0.1424914151,
0.0663380027,
-0.745618999,
-0.2999152839,
-0.1533719748,
0.3016222715,
0.4973521531,
-0.3049629629,
-0.314285785,
-1.205671072,
0.4689209461,
-0.3606393337,
-0.0946521759,
0.1762395054,
0.1589488834,
0.0494611897,
-0.6789494753,
-0.6028799415,
0.0138199404,
-0.1341023892,
0.4490123391,
-0.1642872542,
0.2736024261,
0.1562005281,
0.4442386627,
-0.1833084375,
-0.2646030486,
0.0006648423,
0.0813455209,
0.6545151472,
1.0114377737,
0.299616009,
0.3446027339,
-0.1830865741,
0.002849058,
0.0463061407,
0.254085809,
-0.2447652519,
0.1234564111,
-0.1344826519,
0.699608326,
-0.3162107468,
0.5976468921,
-0.1220394745,
-0.2925907373,
0.0763727129,
-0.1765915453,
-0.281927079,
-0.3045802712,
0.6039633751,
-0.0460238308,
0.0809579119,
-0.1817144006,
-0.5700133443,
0.436719954,
0.9110966921,
-0.4247955978,
-0.144490689,
0.1476811171,
-0.4839985371,
-0.3615363836,
-0.162312746,
0.1174966469,
-0.5546933413,
-0.8095521331,
0.3762109876,
-0.4933765829,
-0.3841931522,
-0.375131458,
-0.2224984467,
-0.1283481717,
0.8941301703,
-0.4123167694,
0.2969458997,
0.9704549909,
0.4723935425,
-0.3427278399,
-0.6081454158,
-0.237474218,
0.3472149372,
-0.6237618923,
0.5740163326,
-0.8928640485,
-0.2798953652,
0.2333555669,
0.1028642431,
-0.3798456788,
-0.3309218884,
-0.0743573532,
-0.7091194987,
-0.3178372681,
-0.1816438437,
-0.6946336627,
-0.4757979214,
0.5100354552,
-0.8105430603,
0.9565668702,
0.3497718871,
-0.1945776194,
0.3775766492,
-1.2281748056,
-0.7932155132,
0.1364780217,
-0.2164953351,
0.0027277023,
0.2483714223,
-0.4541554153,
0.4409255981,
-0.3163494468,
0.0127006145,
0.2225770205,
-0.3410822451,
0.3304013908,
-0.0022605231,
0.4975594878,
0.1231020093,
-0.4149892032,
0.5439679027,
-0.2713062763,
-0.2376323044,
0.0138715822,
-0.3066164553,
-0.2091090381,
0.1022026986,
-0.2406024039,
-0.0012852295,
0.5370982289,
-0.6950428486,
0.0932706669,
0.3810605407,
0.5400921702,
0.6361141801,
-0.1293679476,
0.4721142054,
-0.7964608073,
0.6151247621,
0.221118018,
0.5550544858,
-0.3134810925,
-0.2093496323,
-0.5129355192,
-0.5117521882,
-0.3575362265,
0.7086216211,
-0.5579972267,
0.0922796354,
-0.0480468944,
-0.876070857,
-0.228561312,
-0.1331537962,
0.4698802531,
0.7020903826,
0.0908090621,
-0.3756759465,
0.063684009,
-0.7394067645,
-0.4028047919,
-0.2669334412,
0.6000124216,
0.1410433948,
0.670445323,
-0.2075660825,
0.8157917261,
-0.4935910404,
-0.3663918972,
-0.2599678338,
0.3635473251,
0.2754493356,
0.668253541,
0.0720617101,
-0.7431281805,
-0.4981176853,
-0.1504871845,
-1.0208566189,
0.5183911324,
-0.155192107,
-0.3039943278,
0.3839992881,
0.3791506886,
-1.2427995205,
0.8058257103,
-0.1609591246,
-0.2746412158,
0.5568596721,
-0.1405944526,
-0.0779971406,
-0.8645524383,
0.315793395,
-0.3385439515,
-0.50168401,
-0.6426577568,
0.0399376079,
0.1031376719,
-0.3772311509,
-0.2332221866,
0.2192180753,
-0.2800290287,
-0.0782687441,
-0.7252647281,
-0.1486721784,
0.0236055739,
0.7587545514,
0.1457049996,
0.5164220333,
0.2132016569,
-0.3900898099,
0.3339731097,
0.3194591105,
-0.2480118424,
0.6574961543,
-0.4811499417,
0.4922740459,
-0.1990498304,
0.4436915219,
-0.3568692207,
0.0039923689,
0.2306377292,
-0.1557713002,
0.4392298758,
0.0943034813,
-0.4704969525,
-0.3590379357,
-0.1429362893,
0.3154169619,
0.4506735206,
-0.0311553441,
0.9903243184,
0.8557503223,
-0.1655894965,
-0.4568978846,
-0.4992482364,
-0.0876527131,
0.2930230498,
-0.0560302436,
0.3639962673,
0.1063042358,
-0.4068183303,
0.4980104566,
-0.1044486016,
-0.1252363771,
0.1526588202,
0.6068893075,
0.4929878712,
0.0558810793,
-0.0470476039,
-0.2345674634,
-0.1971542984,
0.2091833949,
-0.2947316766,
0.1726322919,
-0.0291646216,
-0.3396880925,
-0.9936684966,
0.54964149,
1.0499335527,
-0.5645604134,
0.574682951,
0.3030354381,
-0.69294101,
-0.3249083459,
-0.3832362592,
-0.1270706952,
-0.3800704181,
0.2113549858,
-0.328086406,
-0.6764885783,
0.5239830017,
-0.000209059,
0.7089856863,
0.3572267592,
0.8338899016,
-0.6071586013,
0.8865084052,
0.6704318523,
-0.5350725055,
0.808169961,
-0.4325560033,
0.2406912148,
-0.9767891765,
-0.2277581096,
-0.1468869001,
-0.4055671692,
-0.2499923259,
-0.6307017803,
0.3448889554,
-0.4108244181,
-0.3990707994,
0.3786245883,
-0.585621357,
0.2900771201,
0.6233894825,
0.1681414545,
0.0544219241,
-0.6861263514,
0.3841658533,
0.2922360897,
-0.3700000346,
-0.4430647492,
0.758323133,
-0.0193273406,
0.8422079682,
-0.3325348496,
0.4624435902,
0.9559524059,
0.3997760117,
-0.4053854644,
0.43619591,
-0.0896285623,
-0.9264564514,
-0.6608641744,
0.1691122502,
-0.6286229491,
0.2067480534,
0.1304696798,
-0.7619869709,
-0.0243395455,
0.3186223507,
-0.3646764755,
0.2737947106,
-0.4422231913,
0.9903228283,
0.1095048115,
-0.0838176906,
-1.0016537905,
-0.1177810505,
0.2444255501,
0.1819351017,
-0.1270185709,
-0.3810953498,
-0.1359651387,
0.7325562835,
-0.9517998695,
1.0880059004,
-0.4224874377,
0.1526707709,
0.9914783239,
0.2466880679,
0.9836810827,
-0.3068028092,
-0.1291546524,
-0.2488457561,
-0.063843444,
-0.3298506439,
-0.5921405554,
0.2900190949,
-0.4908863306,
-0.5769249797,
-0.3893564343,
-1.0244631767,
0.2184844762,
0.3578862548,
-0.2632298172,
0.6585880518,
-0.1486599743,
-0.2833024859,
0.1006401628,
0.4147794843,
0.8274100423,
0.7262832522,
0.2630563378,
0.0946772918,
0.9262378216,
0.1970670819,
-0.3042138219,
0.3992491364,
-0.1527232826,
-0.1086244136,
-0.3203327954,
-0.2610586882,
0.0549466833,
-0.5942932963,
-0.1600781977,
-0.4542546868,
-0.026968088,
-0.1069633141,
-0.1950466931,
-0.6869345903,
-0.1427701116,
-0.1799720377,
0.0758393481,
0.3016318381,
1.1150325537,
0.0287213605,
0.0152742518,
-0.4268863201,
0.2834823132,
0.3925857544,
0.1081899256,
0.2371801436,
-0.0860589668,
-0.6857907176,
-0.2169014215,
-0.2467611879,
-0.6058026552,
0.2513276637,
-0.1296163946,
0.5162079334,
0.1734674424,
0.3001721799,
0.3819056153,
-0.2646512985,
0.6646731496,
-0.038057629,
-0.9716268182,
0.6641363502,
-0.4293369055,
0.2486546338,
0.5197498798,
-0.0214645825,
-0.4716574252,
-0.590241313,
-0.3647969067,
-0.3508431911,
1.1260806322,
0.1096998155,
0.0452621132,
0.0493477285,
0.4270040393,
-0.029352095,
0.5057623386,
-0.2288008183,
-0.0442292057,
-0.0733818635,
-0.2404289693,
-0.08530844,
0.0409165509,
-0.4539091885,
-0.0229085479,
0.5424846411,
-0.1607183069,
0.5191813707,
0.3256898224,
-0.4348075092,
-0.0097456342,
-0.1500759423,
0.6195448041,
0.7942895293,
0.1679648608,
0.1085189655,
-0.0701003596,
-0.5957838297,
0.2054457366,
-0.1411806196,
-0.4195864499,
-0.2907912731,
0.4391689301,
0.6854918599,
-0.1617728919,
-0.5718157887,
0.4283583164,
-0.066844739,
0.3515517712,
-0.8300501704,
0.5719096065,
0.2161983252,
0.8781613111,
0.0880894586,
0.2506023049,
-0.0674700364,
-0.9101344347,
-0.1295264661,
0.0999664366,
-0.703145504,
-0.6099736094,
0.8193157911,
0.2447224408,
-0.7306524515,
0.7021169066,
-0.2489164025,
-0.6166476011,
1.1234411001,
0.3989528418,
0.9667637944,
0.074564971,
0.1004650742,
-0.1572368443,
0.3828545511,
0.1126691625,
1.0346308947,
-0.3892922997,
-0.4763817489,
-0.476626724,
-0.0558443852,
-0.7715502977,
-0.2858416736,
-0.8256354332,
-0.4015737176,
-0.4881347418,
-0.370470643,
-0.0945046321,
0.0220941026,
-0.8224403858,
0.510904789,
0.0685066506,
0.8619490266,
-0.4871520102,
1.0175607204,
1.0092958212,
-0.4458908737,
-0.6736270189,
-0.364877522,
0.1507589966,
-0.7131325603,
0.3841890693,
-0.0720929503,
-0.039079316,
-0.4023119211,
-0.0858206525,
-0.7379400134,
1.3606331348,
0.1262373328,
-0.33617571,
0.2375684083,
0.1432717443,
0.6188106537,
-0.5868267417,
0.3974413276,
0.5330430269,
0.3491490185,
-0.7864598036,
-0.73509866,
0.2956683636,
-0.5210199952,
-0.2678323388,
0.3037212491,
-1.1665319204,
1.0702140331,
-0.0038474032,
0.2400027663,
-0.2369654775,
0.7295319438,
-0.0877603889,
0.4899761975,
0.6916464567,
0.634331584,
0.9555311799,
0.1846835613,
1.0119787455,
-0.6516308784,
-0.1048318297,
1.2138214111,
-0.51523453,
0.6577335596,
0.0895480737,
0.0373485386,
0.78774333,
0.2633462548,
0.2919341922,
0.1663872004,
-0.1692186445,
-0.2540138662,
-0.2133065164,
-0.6440124512,
0.2829886377,
0.7866101861,
0.3069959283,
-0.1503521204,
0.4609643817,
-0.0269145854,
0.1779652387,
-0.1237730756,
-0.3239685595,
0.7868163586,
0.0404112041,
-1.135579586,
-0.1223129556,
-0.2574854493,
-0.0728577301,
-0.3752378225,
-0.1091056764,
-0.1706379205,
0.350071013,
-0.0696384907,
-0.644164145,
0.4488247037,
0.2049698532,
-0.6768963337,
-0.3985284269,
0.6926587224,
-0.1418576241,
0.0476006605,
0.1638261825,
0.2452411205,
0.0228996538,
-0.2356553972,
-0.6011450887,
-0.0205581281,
-0.5121352077,
-0.4329240918,
0.1564213485,
0.2973125279,
-0.3725933731,
0.6044991612,
0.337253809,
-0.1055482104,
-0.172954008,
-0.1100786328,
0.8108591437,
-0.9316654205,
-0.8080373406,
-0.7228501439,
0.5630236864,
-0.2328258753,
-0.3492509425,
0.2065099925,
0.7231107354,
0.5042450428,
0.0071867988,
0.8949859142,
-0.3187179565,
0.4896150231,
0.0071338769,
0.8731685877,
-0.6385871172,
-0.3932679892,
-0.1749261618,
-0.5090770721,
0.5020655394,
0.139627248,
-0.0189203471,
-0.2667458653,
0.831020236,
0.4334793985,
0.2246400714,
0.3756634891,
0.0637160838,
0.1033882722,
0.3874145746,
0.5840017796,
0.9081202745,
-0.1782725006,
0.241754666,
-0.5738422871,
-0.168887645,
-0.2842465043,
-0.4630967081,
-0.7615843415,
-0.7331398129,
-0.5465772152,
0.0307313204,
-0.064086467,
0.5990481973,
1.0087404251,
-0.5520176888,
-0.4234126508,
0.0146539863,
0.0372921228,
-0.5636677742,
-0.1181756631,
0.2200069427,
-0.4327408075,
-0.629611671,
0.6486054659,
0.5523360968,
-0.3358349502,
-0.1024768949,
-0.0310437344,
0.1659168005,
0.2275989205,
0.6150417328,
0.4532711506,
-0.4999681115,
-0.0409478359,
-0.1385115534,
-0.4762463272,
-0.2353189737,
1.0797476768,
-0.3593097031,
0.5355360508,
0.6101857424,
0.6076424718,
0.8499668837,
-0.1395396739,
0.5962332487,
0.0526576787,
0.1399357766,
0.5045291185,
0.2908965647,
-0.2838664353,
-0.4474158585,
0.6854197383,
0.3335091174,
-0.5570759773,
-0.5799856782,
-0.1573726088,
-0.9322918653,
-0.1517400742,
0.1536936164,
-0.5115963221,
-0.6416881084,
-0.0459182076,
0.1193026453,
0.624933362,
-0.4181745648,
0.7855417132,
0.3284157217,
-0.7342748642,
0.1589730382,
-0.561416924,
0.3489925861,
0.6043425202,
-1.0084152222,
0.1959202141,
0.3983935714,
-0.1612609625,
0.2554641366,
1.1212248802,
0.0176056735,
0.607719481,
0.345425725,
0.2921502292,
-0.2834224701,
-0.5572735071,
0.1809588075,
0.0870416537,
-0.0255026221,
-0.5889123678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09569v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09569v2
|
Strings from the Library of Babel: Random Sampling as a Strong Baseline for Prompt Optimisation
| 2023-11-16T05:08:33 | 2024-04-17T06:00:51 |
Yao Lu, Jiayi Wang, Raphael Tang, Sebastian Riedel, Pontus Stenetorp
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent prompt optimisation approaches use the generative nature of language
models to produce prompts -- even rivaling the performance of human-curated
prompts. In this paper, we demonstrate that randomly sampling tokens from the
model vocabulary as ``separators'' can be as effective as language models for
prompt-style text classification. Our experiments show that random separators
are competitive baselines, having less than a 1% difference compared to
previous self-optimisation methods and showing a 12% average relative
improvement over strong human baselines across nine text classification tasks
and eight language models. We further analyse this phenomenon in detail using
three different random generation strategies, establishing that the language
space is rich with potentially good separators, with a greater than 40% average
chance that a randomly drawn separator performs better than human-curated
separators. These observations challenge the common assumption that an
effective prompt should be human readable or task relevant and establish a
strong baseline for prompt optimisation research.
|
[
-0.3135199249,
-0.6607402563,
0.3322518766,
-0.0081690317,
-0.2820626795,
0.096761018,
-0.2969453037,
-0.3470639586,
-0.0002637739,
0.1811763793,
-0.4242774248,
-0.2702377737,
-0.1890206337,
0.5377687216,
-0.538128376,
1.0271571875,
0.3976249099,
0.1088825688,
-0.2852312922,
-0.1146322638,
-0.6006107926,
-0.5312725306,
-0.8861960769,
-0.1539031714,
0.7728813291,
0.4168986976,
0.4068825543,
0.6532635689,
0.4414741397,
0.3480906188,
-0.5458936095,
0.2473337501,
-0.4155836105,
0.5921879411,
-0.3231357932,
-0.6890848279,
0.5538059473,
0.1111039892,
0.6219892502,
0.6637429595,
-0.3479398489,
-0.0956551284,
0.1279999018,
0.5592608452,
-0.5808761716,
-0.254338026,
-0.3976713121,
0.2070946842,
-0.4522404373,
-0.1756970882,
-0.5703263283,
-0.4500975013,
0.032566607,
-0.372184664,
0.4994824231,
0.5770051479,
0.9645543694,
0.1726057231,
-0.0847168639,
-0.3014152646,
-0.5702602863,
0.9834311008,
-0.2942932546,
-0.0030492053,
-0.0075594927,
0.6398304701,
-0.0968397036,
-0.7367521524,
-0.2400784045,
-0.1166326851,
-0.1022423059,
0.0161726661,
-0.2594563365,
-0.0207189582,
0.4162112474,
0.3623063564,
-0.472923547,
0.3765559196,
-0.4243314564,
-0.465774864,
0.3144517839,
0.1763136238,
0.7259041071,
-0.420463115,
-0.4620949626,
-0.1385359913,
-0.5414841175,
0.3549139202,
0.5360532403,
0.5245361328,
-0.0981473848,
0.4654427469,
0.004690975,
0.9707403183,
0.21585989,
-0.2092097253,
-0.1104150712,
-0.6081879139,
0.2755200565,
-0.1117046177,
0.7387185693,
0.2142139077,
0.3335897326,
-0.098308526,
-0.5031811595,
-0.070916988,
0.2625105381,
-0.7521910667,
-0.4788668752,
0.2685106695,
-0.5515547395,
-0.5371700525,
-0.057574261,
-0.5105885267,
-0.3168853223,
-0.2208545357,
-0.0561696291,
-0.4591881931,
0.1842997819,
-0.1008273736,
-0.5389307737,
0.0318524987,
0.439670682,
-1.1810803413,
0.1115955487,
0.5168398619,
0.7143434882,
-0.4344735146,
-0.1832885742,
-0.7958536744,
-0.5329313278,
-0.2995182872,
1.259529829,
-0.2630101442,
-0.4524548948,
0.1082150936,
-0.3516540527,
0.0133332033,
-0.5333269238,
0.7714822888,
-0.4281835258,
0.6228305697,
-0.4038686752,
-0.5612071753,
0.1708506048,
-0.1109721363,
-0.7935972214,
1.0924755335,
0.2245206237,
-0.7528244257,
0.8100426793,
-0.2282033861,
-0.2988397479,
0.5253112912,
-0.2194502354,
-0.0721956566,
0.2017019838,
0.1956662387,
0.1457729936,
-0.4980835021,
0.2531583905,
-0.0165144764,
-0.1354006678,
0.4121541381,
-0.6147623658,
1.0134791136,
0.7785311937,
0.0339803286,
0.2689659595,
-0.7780063152,
-0.0520246066,
-0.1257431954,
-0.4664327502,
-0.5103978515,
0.0305294674,
0.3562850952,
0.120505251,
0.1353698522,
-0.4367558956,
0.1583306342,
-0.4795403481,
0.3216673136,
0.7353705168,
0.0072703082,
0.6278154254,
-0.3721006513,
0.7485370636,
0.077847451,
-0.1240775287,
-0.466401279,
-0.5120438933,
-0.2456375957,
-0.602575779,
0.5729679465,
0.563647449,
-0.6405571699,
0.7295134068,
0.2361910939,
-0.3094833195,
-0.6007037163,
0.2668047249,
0.3711803854,
0.6985567808,
0.1024147943,
-0.329293251,
-0.4058127105,
-0.839302659,
-0.4079371691,
-0.2860177755,
-0.0589538515,
0.1018268988,
0.1725218445,
0.320127219,
1.4008150101,
-0.3956656158,
0.1741248965,
-0.641712606,
0.2385073155,
0.2903561592,
0.4566833079,
0.7480738759,
-0.856754899,
-0.3835194707,
-0.3302701712,
-0.64686203,
-0.5967911482,
-0.2711127996,
-0.342877537,
-0.1587832421,
0.3329211771,
-0.5554823875,
-0.0557012372,
0.0364513285,
-0.4312375784,
0.7434914112,
-0.1866246462,
-0.1594499648,
-1.1387243271,
0.1357858032,
0.0463611409,
-0.2879332006,
-0.6563706398,
0.0752534345,
0.1033389643,
-0.3765558004,
-0.7678985,
1.0704387426,
-0.527400434,
0.249487862,
-0.1843168736,
0.1796435714,
-0.0115870107,
-0.1139278859,
-0.2151112556,
1.124516964,
0.4301231205,
-0.3427850008,
0.1108799651,
0.2924581468,
-0.646997273,
0.6510464549,
-0.5831270814,
-0.2386541814,
-0.4803071618,
0.1811473519,
-1.3728554249,
-0.3059674799,
0.0707734078,
-0.1715313792,
0.3163124025,
0.0638246089,
-0.4532847703,
-0.5256057382,
-0.1926752031,
0.4406406283,
0.7601064444,
-0.7580217123,
0.3007751405,
0.3273693621,
-0.1012413129,
-0.6655297875,
-0.345531553,
-0.0153192924,
-0.4576455057,
-0.3781785369,
0.0072848196,
-0.1804453582,
-0.4544351399,
-0.1264229119,
-0.0473973528,
0.25028947,
0.4789505005,
-0.0270829257,
0.1110797822,
0.0274617579,
-0.0372099839,
-0.0676923096,
-0.2403226048,
-0.0778932497,
-0.5428689122,
0.6538031697,
0.2903857827,
-0.2370661199,
-0.3831373751,
0.1810526848,
-0.0219907425,
-0.0423536375,
0.5802710652,
0.4515033364,
-0.1349065453,
-0.6628023386,
-0.5383802652,
-0.3516996205,
-0.5303198099,
-0.0669886917,
-0.4137897193,
-1.0041644573,
0.6818205118,
0.2526409924,
0.1466537714,
0.3470672667,
0.3592987359,
-0.2326921672,
0.9450674653,
0.4862662852,
-0.164885506,
0.802570343,
0.2357326895,
-0.0358459204,
-0.3478657007,
0.1295502186,
-0.9783466458,
-0.3173147142,
-0.5781157613,
-0.3101398349,
-0.0323469117,
0.539575994,
0.0516632572,
0.1535920203,
-0.6919567585,
0.9184568524,
0.9132325053,
-0.254953742,
-0.1322803646,
0.2386086136,
-0.6429357529,
-0.054300081,
-0.9678445458,
-0.5655982494,
0.6614884138,
0.0577016436,
0.8403178453,
-0.4340349138,
0.9828750491,
0.3201536536,
0.2568477094,
-0.6823831201,
0.5009273291,
0.0302243922,
-0.7672299147,
-0.2463522404,
-0.5591965318,
-1.1006827354,
0.3365540802,
0.0890229493,
-0.8389961123,
0.2800306976,
0.0489469171,
-0.6012164354,
0.2082738727,
-0.706518352,
0.9524948597,
-0.0650056377,
-0.0924158022,
0.3817843199,
-0.6487980485,
0.0653390437,
-0.0439293906,
0.1639521718,
-0.1418770552,
0.0172512103,
0.8432058096,
-0.529827714,
0.8286957145,
-0.1421837509,
-0.1180180013,
0.721716404,
-0.1585582793,
0.405053407,
-0.1797911227,
0.0068138465,
-0.1865075231,
-0.2970519066,
-0.55632478,
-0.5439545512,
0.2039148211,
-0.835511744,
-0.4699508846,
-0.3734532893,
-0.3444445133,
0.1849133521,
0.2938448191,
0.6588659286,
0.6956985593,
-0.2791864872,
0.2418246567,
0.5441535115,
-0.3018355966,
0.6067869663,
0.3471606076,
-0.1025848836,
-0.6317558289,
0.8241534233,
0.1394138485,
0.1903226525,
0.6959066987,
0.4657076597,
-0.4690124094,
-0.670121789,
-0.5476493239,
0.0981528014,
-0.8088063598,
-0.1183094382,
-0.5515188575,
-0.055353038,
-0.2688354552,
-0.4701677859,
0.1223175675,
-0.6482198238,
-0.3051011562,
-0.3634405136,
0.1827866584,
0.4245155752,
-0.2536062598,
0.3569105268,
-0.847856164,
0.023222303,
0.2796040475,
-0.1731536835,
-0.1353032887,
-0.2876964808,
-0.2039038688,
-0.3672603667,
-0.0128179938,
-0.7774603963,
0.5249217153,
-0.213664785,
0.8007650971,
0.5356481075,
0.0523515195,
0.3312598169,
-0.646959722,
1.1432981491,
0.4075533748,
-0.5180574059,
0.5289994478,
-0.5426735878,
0.6677094102,
0.9767792225,
0.210912928,
-0.7105984688,
-0.6201757193,
-0.6383398175,
-0.9803528786,
0.8530269265,
0.3112955391,
-0.0857425556,
-0.4623565972,
0.1666488945,
0.2047189623,
0.2997807562,
-0.4549603164,
-0.3440651,
0.2339886874,
-0.4543845654,
-0.1964969188,
-0.3541611433,
-0.156691283,
0.1697527617,
0.1421971917,
0.0175861903,
0.0549014062,
-0.200174585,
-0.0886186138,
-0.1757121384,
0.2686738372,
0.4670745432,
0.5344386101,
-0.0122436732,
0.1308293343,
0.0556289144,
-0.5231990814,
0.4515929818,
0.0551529713,
-0.8346130252,
0.1062862575,
0.2535529733,
0.6090717316,
0.302176863,
-0.6112782955,
0.194957599,
-0.1674963683,
0.2036962658,
0.0925939083,
0.3692762256,
-0.0871369988,
-0.1074463353,
0.5538267493,
0.1957139671,
0.1801519245,
-0.2036691457,
0.355271399,
0.2494412214,
-0.1828627288,
-0.3034018874,
0.8007064462,
0.4292989075,
-0.7125195265,
0.3790621459,
-0.4128507376,
-0.3181233704,
0.7905581594,
0.6157520413,
1.08078897,
-0.3111054599,
0.2868722677,
0.4096955657,
0.0544024594,
-0.4106478989,
0.3118729889,
-0.3249800503,
-0.8515030742,
-0.1855339557,
-0.9655134678,
-0.5699517727,
-0.2895562947,
-0.5772590637,
0.4185656011,
-0.2283263057,
-0.1485494673,
0.0067734425,
0.0301434956,
-0.7437571883,
0.2263933867,
0.1217494905,
1.0278859138,
-0.7114514709,
0.455027163,
0.7039295435,
-0.5553165674,
-1.011878252,
-0.2772602439,
0.1469341069,
-0.4003587961,
0.8045121431,
0.3716181815,
0.2499039173,
-0.0218007043,
-0.5054565072,
-0.9245916009,
0.5788607001,
0.020496713,
-0.6719046831,
-0.2515089512,
-0.074709639,
0.5661052465,
-0.2445231974,
0.6147294044,
0.3608309627,
0.291729629,
-0.047758095,
-0.4716341794,
-0.0722848698,
-0.4117581546,
0.3432399333,
0.3481284082,
-0.538921535,
0.7398539186,
0.1488214582,
-0.6070039272,
0.3543396592,
0.8839617968,
0.5296442509,
0.0057705077,
0.5744717717,
0.5068418384,
1.1058814526,
-0.1299816221,
1.3675361872,
-0.5411332846,
0.0470285118,
0.6381782889,
-0.2847161293,
0.5761930943,
0.363238126,
-0.1520922482,
0.3834137022,
0.693991363,
-0.0124086449,
0.6042781472,
0.3611925542,
-0.2907377183,
-0.1649375558,
-0.2036995292,
-0.0420151502,
0.187604025,
-0.0419256352,
-0.2536505163,
-0.5075246096,
0.289298147,
-0.130431965,
0.0855099633,
-0.0369606912,
0.8748787642,
0.207403779,
-0.9114311337,
0.4761218727,
-0.1039777696,
0.7304088473,
-0.5601053238,
0.2831376791,
-0.4213131368,
-0.0214880295,
0.075103052,
-0.7053282857,
-0.1764137447,
0.2028841674,
-0.2211096287,
-0.6534128785,
0.9557825327,
-0.3776143193,
-0.3363576233,
-0.1940559,
0.6721481681,
0.2405795008,
0.5387309194,
-0.5252190232,
-0.3130515814,
0.0274262335,
-0.5110243559,
0.4867284298,
0.8507926464,
-0.0828978196,
0.5654642582,
0.8694842458,
0.3962907791,
-0.2251116037,
0.3454232812,
0.6517273784,
-0.7965624928,
-0.8848316073,
-0.8533563614,
0.7320178151,
-0.3152886629,
-0.6792628169,
1.1306887865,
0.6547061205,
0.7436693907,
-0.0306599159,
0.6913582683,
0.0592034534,
0.5609318018,
-0.4989853799,
0.7191296816,
-0.2207340598,
0.1826300323,
-0.09449514,
-0.9947532415,
-0.1335779428,
0.5789073706,
-0.2338909805,
0.0435040556,
0.7850169539,
0.6659286618,
0.1296498328,
0.1047365516,
0.3095048368,
-0.3475338519,
0.3642031252,
-0.0075916466,
1.3063168526,
0.2028967887,
0.4254293442,
-0.2694102526,
-0.087887615,
-0.1914464086,
-0.760989964,
-1.000536561,
-0.3796789348,
-0.1113113016,
-0.29289487,
0.1123481467,
1.1219530106,
0.5903826952,
-0.9017860889,
-0.3457304537,
-0.1750962883,
0.2128303498,
-0.2781009376,
-0.2599151433,
0.0859843716,
-1.1201940775,
-0.7757722735,
0.4627756476,
0.0135708898,
0.141820699,
-0.2224711627,
0.3524188697,
0.2234788686,
0.1265378743,
0.3704223037,
0.3307411075,
-0.489671737,
-0.1178091243,
-0.0408585854,
-0.6254976988,
-0.0111811645,
0.7996720672,
-0.7899720073,
0.4060936868,
0.9462413788,
0.6909496188,
0.0578793548,
0.6338905096,
0.6137006879,
-0.8946329951,
0.2133041173,
0.4299208224,
0.4205470085,
0.34271878,
-0.2729721069,
0.4631371796,
0.3358779848,
-0.537404716,
-0.922837019,
0.0896655023,
-0.7186177969,
-0.4645924866,
1.3218001127,
0.0498021282,
-0.6467681527,
-0.0456775762,
-0.4695158601,
-0.110640116,
-0.6876878738,
0.7664890289,
0.8842545152,
0.0675581545,
-0.0301534534,
-0.3224395812,
0.8186835051,
0.6678967476,
-0.8391332626,
-0.0754968747,
0.7434108853,
0.0691238791,
0.4163967967,
0.7002580166,
0.2253111452,
0.2775326371,
0.1599122435,
-0.116753377,
0.1955582947,
-0.4743589461,
-0.5053740144,
0.5880439281,
0.0872446969,
0.1274846047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09564v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09564v1
|
LongBoX: Evaluating Transformers on Long-Sequence Clinical Tasks
| 2023-11-16T04:57:49 | 2023-11-16T04:57:49 |
Mihir Parmar, Aakanksha Naik, Himanshu Gupta, Disha Agrawal, Chitta Baral
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Many large language models (LLMs) for medicine have largely been evaluated on
short texts, and their ability to handle longer sequences such as a complete
electronic health record (EHR) has not been systematically explored. Assessing
these models on long sequences is crucial since prior work in the general
domain has demonstrated performance degradation of LLMs on longer texts.
Motivated by this, we introduce LongBoX, a collection of seven medical datasets
in text-to-text format, designed to investigate model performance on long
sequences. Preliminary experiments reveal that both medical LLMs (e.g., BioGPT)
and strong general domain LLMs (e.g., FLAN-T5) struggle on this benchmark. We
further evaluate two techniques designed for long-sequence handling: (i)
local-global attention, and (ii) Fusion-in-Decoder (FiD). Our results
demonstrate mixed results with long-sequence handling - while scores on some
datasets increase, there is substantial room for improvement. We hope that
LongBoX facilitates the development of more effective long-sequence techniques
for the medical domain. Data and source code are available at
https://github.com/Mihir3009/LongBoX.
|
[
-0.268725872,
-0.7807799578,
0.8339047432,
0.1242995039,
-0.3650704324,
-0.0319941863,
-0.2759703994,
-0.7142295837,
0.0842563957,
0.7843298912,
-0.5065531731,
-0.542688787,
-0.7197960615,
0.6451717615,
-0.671980381,
1.0660464764,
-0.1281482726,
-0.0524286479,
-0.4502319694,
-0.1836355478,
-0.555695951,
-0.6234534979,
-0.4320430458,
-0.3849865794,
0.5447912216,
0.2382545024,
0.9340791702,
0.7426357269,
0.9441736341,
0.2438805401,
0.0286504328,
-0.086372517,
-0.5123144984,
0.1727169156,
-0.1422531605,
-0.3195313215,
-0.785795033,
-0.7137541771,
0.7303592563,
0.6438660622,
0.0528298356,
0.1640717983,
-0.1323728114,
0.8775743842,
-0.265540272,
0.0273140762,
0.0493895523,
0.26435256,
-0.3827143013,
-0.1575666964,
-0.5363097191,
-0.1252035201,
0.3063158393,
-0.2021288127,
0.3229050636,
0.0642370209,
0.3731883764,
0.4075420499,
-0.6294647455,
-0.3291422427,
-0.7902685404,
0.6476247311,
-0.4982013106,
0.5993560553,
0.4850850403,
0.4654968977,
-0.2543880939,
-0.8920762539,
-0.1711967885,
-0.2179010361,
-0.1404002756,
0.3245251775,
-0.4245238304,
0.3239837289,
0.5479763746,
0.5313718319,
-0.746004343,
0.3091453016,
-0.6612437367,
0.0755492821,
0.6652857065,
0.3106719851,
0.2800092697,
-0.2944186628,
-0.4578042924,
-0.0472294167,
-0.7796409726,
-0.1122347787,
-0.3113981485,
-0.1079916731,
-0.2472931445,
0.7326449156,
-0.1682981998,
0.7081199288,
0.0508121699,
-0.1484464407,
0.2750811279,
-0.2466563135,
-0.5455192327,
0.1002515629,
0.8505813479,
0.4448373616,
0.2303912789,
-0.3234404922,
-0.2279358357,
0.0427477695,
0.5669721961,
-0.9373191595,
0.1369461715,
0.688747406,
-0.7125430107,
-0.0565777533,
-0.1912675798,
-1.1052106619,
-0.2876040041,
-0.2748683393,
0.3285700083,
-0.3228411376,
0.1747264117,
0.5566219091,
0.1821500957,
0.0981477275,
0.0069323718,
-0.6050634384,
0.5536283255,
0.9322062135,
0.7246177793,
-0.6481411457,
-0.1084590107,
-0.766844213,
-0.0894601792,
-0.1434624642,
0.8407378793,
-0.2314639539,
-0.6657332778,
0.2671894729,
0.3444673419,
0.0977613851,
-0.8732959628,
0.8056330681,
-0.3309954405,
0.1637528986,
0.0809008852,
-0.7691920996,
0.2463590056,
0.0139357308,
-1.037411809,
0.6694170833,
0.2112348676,
-0.4461991787,
0.0895767659,
-0.8131812811,
-0.7968818545,
0.1351174265,
-0.2180741429,
-0.8541797996,
0.2992846668,
0.2318533957,
0.8342362046,
-0.6277781129,
0.4576971829,
-0.1912165433,
-0.420460403,
0.3168613315,
-0.3776602447,
0.2410631329,
0.0649425387,
-0.3571483493,
0.2603158653,
-0.8187043071,
-0.2045972943,
0.1422307193,
-0.08342354,
-0.0085501103,
0.1554905921,
0.0155773629,
0.1895254105,
-0.2169669718,
-0.3799065948,
0.2930670083,
-0.3828848898,
0.4486390352,
0.3700850606,
-0.1758704633,
0.0833588764,
-0.6038309932,
0.7756379247,
0.0498389378,
0.3381187022,
-0.3524524271,
-0.3736724555,
-0.5890057087,
-0.3831174374,
0.0962309167,
0.4833927155,
-0.6881281137,
0.5171094537,
-0.9380896091,
-0.1987238377,
-0.5870036483,
0.0999169722,
0.2947033644,
0.3088896871,
0.683390677,
-0.5280284286,
-0.0847702324,
-1.1389859915,
0.0676807165,
0.2744633257,
-0.3643303812,
0.1414631158,
0.6035615206,
-0.7446022034,
0.8202875853,
-0.3883703053,
-0.2698825896,
-0.2093239427,
-0.0426067598,
0.4266650975,
0.0554239415,
0.253521651,
-0.5518731475,
-0.2455270588,
-0.0855476409,
-0.6429783106,
-0.0116866529,
-0.2227546871,
-0.0269048158,
0.1718610227,
0.3266195357,
-1.0727000237,
0.6443167925,
0.5783647895,
-0.3354462385,
0.3964991271,
-0.0964134485,
0.2541465163,
-1.1623179913,
0.1854957789,
0.0464434102,
-0.6117919683,
-0.7946571112,
0.0199145228,
0.3484742939,
-0.2020269334,
-0.5410555601,
0.5893875957,
-0.3602391779,
-0.0507133231,
-0.2376081795,
-0.3262406588,
0.0274086148,
0.1211323589,
0.153092429,
0.7118604779,
0.2000040859,
-0.3065808415,
0.5853453875,
0.3106092215,
-0.6228683591,
0.6204098463,
-0.8380768299,
0.4656042457,
-0.3509252667,
0.4196717739,
-0.6872032881,
-0.4739804566,
0.1153659448,
0.0100663928,
0.6277307868,
-0.008710512,
-0.5963445902,
-0.8230878115,
-0.2992569208,
0.7424657345,
0.7536044121,
-0.4690638483,
0.3173991144,
-0.0743512586,
-0.2390572429,
-0.2364616394,
-0.536904633,
0.1242319718,
-0.3724045753,
-0.5224881768,
0.6462397575,
-0.1020003408,
-0.0247672293,
-0.3241901398,
-0.1496694684,
0.038598191,
-0.2402471602,
0.3274277449,
0.1466836035,
-0.305316031,
0.4182883799,
-0.1074373201,
-0.22686854,
0.2902097106,
0.0142509583,
0.3842589557,
0.1130890623,
-0.6293023825,
-0.2624056935,
0.754381299,
0.8828116059,
-0.2530902624,
0.4998420179,
0.4139278233,
-0.5695884228,
-0.0191537738,
-0.6604718566,
-0.152239278,
-0.4115329683,
0.8357180357,
-0.2394957244,
-0.8300333619,
0.3470126987,
-0.0479878001,
-0.0932420194,
0.451562047,
0.6108827591,
-0.1466846615,
0.8191245794,
0.3986944258,
-0.227651149,
-0.0186210684,
-0.1071696207,
0.3070410192,
-0.6912110448,
-0.0970248729,
-0.3379395306,
-0.3006345928,
-0.4132849574,
-0.6842252612,
0.6013322473,
-0.1267339438,
-0.1381883025,
0.1560108215,
-0.4806689322,
0.365349561,
0.0616255663,
0.4020830989,
0.3953510225,
0.0297629498,
0.4939997494,
0.1671204567,
-0.4745653272,
-0.3277309239,
1.2239662409,
0.815381825,
0.9362998605,
0.0259510279,
0.7384995818,
0.3356631994,
0.4682077467,
-1.0190302134,
0.3810453415,
-0.2894087732,
-0.3500233889,
-0.2102326602,
-0.2080062628,
-1.4651459455,
-0.2642877996,
-0.0155357309,
-0.4558379352,
-0.1949314326,
-0.1249807104,
-0.6467605233,
-0.026561901,
-0.3634415567,
0.9157416821,
-0.5943944454,
-0.4029875398,
-0.2477954477,
-0.7883872986,
0.2250453979,
-0.443352133,
0.140964359,
0.1566987932,
0.0449768864,
0.6099445224,
-0.2541446388,
0.7108152509,
0.4348756075,
-0.2631899714,
-0.13409473,
-0.1122542545,
0.3786627352,
0.0230985079,
0.1935003102,
0.2266674191,
0.3478951156,
-0.4295017123,
-0.6495668888,
0.5064274073,
-0.4976649582,
-0.5279374719,
-0.5107838511,
-0.2906468213,
-0.2893497646,
0.2231618017,
0.282084614,
0.6763204932,
-0.1999174803,
0.4261231422,
0.6256759763,
-0.486525923,
0.108239457,
0.2068785578,
-0.2887897789,
-0.3641105592,
0.4167217612,
-0.0928659067,
0.5564761758,
0.5806140304,
0.0750637203,
-0.3512780368,
-0.5621148944,
-0.4626316726,
0.3468664587,
-0.6231400371,
-0.4374789596,
-0.3551975191,
-0.310007751,
-0.1005961299,
0.0022040275,
-0.2200984508,
0.0992973,
-0.2285267264,
0.0198578518,
0.4419140518,
0.7907764316,
0.6928136945,
0.0862046406,
-1.2788949013,
0.7667514086,
0.1025789306,
0.7046616077,
-0.2751854956,
-0.2311438024,
-0.3743579984,
-0.0521897823,
-0.3955771625,
-1.0191514492,
0.3258382976,
0.0294033177,
0.2707149982,
0.309127301,
-0.1233826578,
0.7546623945,
-0.7693200707,
0.6934430599,
0.223839283,
-0.5888587832,
0.3853918016,
-0.2225320786,
0.627404809,
0.3614955842,
0.4890285432,
-0.5223930478,
-0.0492203198,
-0.430829823,
-0.757943213,
0.2343367934,
0.0792780221,
0.0455090404,
-0.3281244934,
0.2912582755,
0.2139265239,
0.127449289,
-0.4464308321,
-0.1008917168,
0.1271592975,
-0.57053864,
-0.3410116732,
-0.3619018793,
-0.1594611555,
-0.1833016276,
0.038110178,
-0.1722212136,
0.7395741343,
0.5561345816,
-0.2303216159,
-0.0933626965,
0.6170102954,
0.7013012171,
0.5873517394,
-0.2267129421,
-0.1216527596,
0.0884957463,
-0.4651589692,
-0.0368962735,
0.2988045514,
0.250127852,
0.0855684951,
0.5787921548,
0.7885872722,
0.4113096595,
-0.8753414154,
0.5490897894,
0.0619870313,
-0.0437111184,
-0.3146854937,
-0.3962384164,
0.010866221,
0.0603986382,
0.017036939,
-0.2691750526,
0.3392534852,
-0.5214416981,
0.410090059,
0.2065650523,
-0.2426943332,
-0.2871793509,
0.500287354,
0.1965508759,
-0.4746210873,
0.9446855187,
0.3827195168,
-0.3265859783,
0.6414491534,
0.7793251872,
0.9128421545,
-0.0709759742,
-0.1862011701,
0.0832664445,
-0.1473038644,
-0.2543295324,
0.0339146033,
-0.0134965666,
-0.1699956805,
-0.8027179837,
-0.4767481685,
-0.2463885397,
0.4162221253,
-0.8279733062,
0.4213068187,
-0.0103188409,
-0.4623460472,
-0.0204126351,
-0.189028725,
-1.1402947903,
0.08541096,
0.2822742164,
1.0348336697,
-0.3874769807,
0.8587235808,
0.3603319526,
0.0151873706,
-0.2774057686,
-0.0701930672,
-0.0984990224,
-0.6513338089,
0.4505548775,
0.4285958707,
0.1635411084,
-0.3184285462,
-0.0414464548,
-0.6481443644,
1.0078778267,
0.0481084734,
-1.1144026518,
-0.3085175157,
0.7704201341,
0.7551794052,
-0.0379475132,
0.3994760811,
0.8242091537,
0.2287113219,
-0.3940424621,
-1.3817191124,
0.0684542954,
-0.3055921793,
-0.3376362026,
0.6502530575,
-0.5406610966,
0.300357461,
-0.0484398231,
-0.1403752416,
0.3264108896,
0.3463605046,
0.0615054816,
0.5000939369,
0.1974222213,
0.4459363222,
0.5218691826,
-0.0454431325,
1.3887921572,
-0.2827271223,
0.3619350493,
0.8389126062,
-0.421081543,
0.9280524254,
0.4917443097,
-0.4927892387,
0.0139628928,
0.2549365163,
-0.129895255,
0.2682216167,
0.4410919249,
-0.2427203506,
0.0063303309,
0.2454320341,
-0.5340207815,
0.143079564,
0.4129982591,
-0.5696095824,
-0.0699266642,
0.3289862871,
-0.15204449,
-0.1584413797,
-0.1872682571,
0.7919031382,
0.4488088787,
-0.8335511684,
0.8015387058,
-0.2695690095,
0.6269770861,
-0.5199533105,
-0.0811906233,
-0.1014460772,
0.2613243461,
-0.2019520998,
-0.8715957999,
0.2309196144,
-0.0183380283,
-0.2596013248,
-0.2235743403,
0.6158667207,
-0.3287323713,
-0.5642591119,
0.3801316023,
0.3540016115,
0.0575060025,
0.0928146541,
-0.4191637635,
0.1620498747,
-0.3012914956,
-0.2275409997,
0.5095965862,
0.0779038072,
-0.259873569,
0.6829730868,
0.4126185179,
0.0756355673,
-0.1385405958,
0.2331200987,
0.5223969221,
-1.011027813,
-0.0630147085,
-1.0011452436,
0.4090678096,
0.0453263521,
-0.2081871629,
0.258931458,
0.6999386549,
0.6282552481,
-0.4309460819,
0.4443701208,
0.4631657898,
0.5735690594,
-0.6601558924,
0.5370297432,
-0.4720349312,
-0.0423635207,
0.0432580635,
-0.7916398048,
-0.534514904,
0.2749475241,
-0.1592537463,
-0.1625503153,
0.8130050302,
0.4913746417,
-0.2477147728,
0.0788355842,
0.4045963287,
0.2045608759,
0.5009219646,
1.0491675138,
0.7386618257,
-0.473493278,
0.069497034,
-0.3055405021,
0.0091729881,
-0.2993685603,
-0.9259347916,
-1.0158059597,
-0.348015815,
-0.1935220063,
-0.4690503776,
0.3303038478,
1.2637556791,
0.6164572835,
-0.6635993719,
-0.0986607373,
0.3289321065,
-0.2924735844,
-0.171136409,
-0.1075940505,
0.7671696544,
-0.0533048958,
-0.5901655555,
0.4336400628,
0.3361057341,
0.1627633274,
0.0474509336,
0.0377942249,
0.5997219682,
-0.2062788904,
1.0012874603,
0.3647155762,
-0.8152971864,
-0.3017462492,
0.3657785952,
-0.1367754638,
0.4141536653,
0.8540284634,
-0.8524208069,
0.5109927058,
0.2711610198,
0.8172895908,
0.4959384799,
0.1841260791,
0.622584343,
-0.3078453839,
-0.1442683488,
0.5312525034,
0.4108686447,
0.1625392735,
-0.3955559731,
0.360547334,
-0.1661541015,
-0.896574676,
-0.9518818259,
0.0336570442,
-1.2575073242,
0.0114577459,
1.2762935162,
0.3617210686,
-0.1699791849,
-0.0608254783,
-0.1661768705,
0.1389802396,
-0.0851283297,
0.81826967,
0.6545792818,
-0.2009013146,
0.0746890754,
-1.0436155796,
0.623277545,
0.6386656761,
-1.094466567,
-0.0524162352,
0.3802892864,
0.3223528564,
0.0679157302,
0.6200107336,
-0.2928410172,
0.5124816298,
-0.7387142777,
-0.2049564421,
0.1740330607,
-0.3270881176,
-0.7012822628,
-0.1492272317,
-0.1867655069,
-0.0465534963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09562v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09562v3
|
TextEE: Benchmark, Reevaluation, Reflections, and Future Challenges in Event Extraction
| 2023-11-16T04:43:03 | 2024-06-06T04:24:16 |
Kuan-Hao Huang, I-Hung Hsu, Tanmay Parekh, Zhiyu Xie, Zixuan Zhang, Premkumar Natarajan, Kai-Wei Chang, Nanyun Peng, Heng Ji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Event extraction has gained considerable interest due to its wide-ranging
applications. However, recent studies draw attention to evaluation issues,
suggesting that reported scores may not accurately reflect the true
performance. In this work, we identify and address evaluation challenges,
including inconsistency due to varying data assumptions or preprocessing steps,
the insufficiency of current evaluation frameworks that may introduce dataset
or data split bias, and the low reproducibility of some previous approaches. To
address these challenges, we present TextEE, a standardized, fair, and
reproducible benchmark for event extraction. TextEE comprises standardized data
preprocessing scripts and splits for 16 datasets spanning eight diverse domains
and includes 14 recent methodologies, conducting a comprehensive benchmark
reevaluation. We also evaluate five varied large language models on our TextEE
benchmark and demonstrate how they struggle to achieve satisfactory
performance. Inspired by our reevaluation results and findings, we discuss the
role of event extraction in the current NLP era, as well as future challenges
and insights derived from TextEE. We believe TextEE, the first standardized
comprehensive benchmarking tool, will significantly facilitate future event
extraction research.
|
[
-0.0565066971,
-0.5869176984,
0.5210391879,
0.2207709849,
-0.0952862501,
0.1353231221,
-0.2936671078,
-0.8134589195,
0.1363433152,
0.2785254121,
-0.4042719007,
-0.3855448067,
-0.8395528197,
0.2601262331,
-0.6609300971,
1.0070800781,
-0.3315006495,
-0.3210921288,
-0.271946758,
-0.0994898602,
-0.4900916219,
-0.6931447387,
-0.6380811334,
-0.2471856177,
0.4250518382,
0.3869014978,
0.1726678163,
0.4813584387,
0.7814199328,
0.2069514543,
0.0581654646,
0.037543878,
-0.2378598154,
0.3748221695,
-0.0759613514,
-0.3084747493,
-0.4807687402,
0.4208358526,
0.8866627812,
0.7571158409,
-0.2821061611,
0.3638390601,
-0.1179765835,
0.4201925397,
-0.9568561316,
-0.0200672951,
-0.6923011541,
0.1454430223,
-0.4747959077,
-0.0034001705,
-0.4867265821,
-0.5926054716,
0.3623635769,
-0.3828175664,
0.1887235343,
-0.1667394787,
1.0073857307,
0.1139340699,
-0.2393324375,
-0.1626714468,
-0.5151555538,
1.1036529541,
-0.5135231614,
0.3991464674,
0.213027209,
0.5186395645,
-0.0196380429,
-1.2270207405,
-0.3498626351,
0.0422714353,
0.3283709884,
0.0870572999,
-0.3376021981,
-0.5670709014,
0.3058606088,
0.2723115087,
-0.2523013353,
0.0296242349,
-0.0509302244,
0.0556144752,
0.7269591093,
0.2038143575,
0.3392041922,
-0.2027519792,
-0.1000348628,
-0.1477583349,
-0.4521724582,
-0.2262749225,
0.1934330463,
0.1326316744,
0.1137214378,
0.3225204945,
-0.1612969935,
0.1062317491,
-0.3603574038,
0.2781116962,
0.5258021355,
-0.3784791529,
-0.1635415405,
-0.1214600876,
0.7934190035,
0.4486156702,
0.3403618038,
-0.5745379925,
-0.1716463566,
-0.1341274381,
0.2768004537,
-0.916677773,
-0.0491758846,
0.3339051902,
-0.8762093186,
-0.1937621534,
-0.0523731932,
-1.388184309,
-0.3292755485,
-0.2098399699,
0.2629233003,
-0.1831437051,
-0.4294877946,
-0.0455084629,
-0.487891227,
0.4067671299,
0.6349284053,
-0.7912067771,
0.461991787,
1.0177724361,
0.6415076256,
-0.6306264997,
-0.2375393063,
-0.6307310462,
-0.2023880184,
-0.2555914521,
0.8363420367,
-0.7560071945,
-0.3312247992,
0.0461051874,
0.1250290573,
-0.1134091169,
-0.784535706,
0.8312082887,
-0.1622163951,
0.2378903478,
-0.1643507481,
-0.6716192365,
0.1209591031,
0.0159816761,
-0.6436242461,
0.8886558414,
-0.2636293471,
-0.6024453044,
0.7068555355,
-0.4088157415,
-0.3771626353,
0.0795455724,
-0.4060482979,
-0.3578365147,
0.4675218761,
0.3419930339,
0.0339175649,
-0.5981029272,
0.3069736362,
-0.1234601364,
-0.1407386661,
0.1553692073,
-0.798805356,
0.5002680421,
-0.0632474199,
-0.2946533263,
-0.276188612,
-1.1560469866,
0.3035667241,
0.132366702,
-0.1889635772,
-0.0777372867,
0.464889884,
0.5038118958,
-0.1049127951,
0.3396326303,
-0.6466035247,
0.1305608451,
-0.2673242092,
0.0482069179,
0.6180217862,
0.0488153882,
0.2505306602,
0.0561343394,
0.6404188871,
-0.2481051981,
0.0798476711,
-0.4151288569,
-0.2206630558,
-0.2853413522,
-0.0682079941,
0.6336950064,
0.631755054,
-0.2419677228,
0.3060619831,
-0.3760040104,
-0.5103882551,
-0.4019343555,
-0.1369019896,
0.3096482158,
0.5083857179,
0.3385834694,
-0.3756814301,
-0.7872530818,
-0.8460134268,
-0.6998103857,
-0.1564425528,
-0.1243818626,
-0.0487310961,
0.4320972264,
-0.0925799608,
1.0471462011,
-0.3792771399,
-0.0493357591,
-0.1346023977,
0.7275477648,
0.0758353546,
0.6133304238,
0.1811736226,
-0.7845250368,
-0.1266797036,
0.1401990503,
-0.9222729802,
-0.3442163467,
-0.0510887615,
0.1856452376,
0.2319315076,
0.5757656693,
-0.0166752264,
0.7360131145,
0.4901505709,
-0.1676244438,
0.7269760966,
0.3197365403,
0.2977868319,
-0.8496477604,
0.2324510217,
-0.0985352173,
-0.4107857347,
-0.327886939,
-0.1256830692,
-0.0615041554,
0.0164380148,
-0.1638404727,
0.522127986,
-0.2689022422,
-0.1708507091,
-0.4098472595,
0.3755952716,
0.1874538958,
-0.1196453869,
0.2529239655,
0.574197948,
0.136969015,
-0.2771582603,
0.2292286903,
0.3499666154,
-0.6206685901,
0.4322804213,
-0.7434449792,
0.329147011,
0.0730126426,
0.1897713989,
-0.3869044483,
0.1123930514,
-0.0704848245,
-0.3978685439,
0.2217147946,
-0.0651900247,
-0.5052655935,
0.2563996017,
-0.2210526019,
0.3766003549,
0.3629771173,
-0.5024775267,
0.7975608706,
0.6121021509,
-0.2340884954,
-0.7936371565,
-0.5687669516,
0.3586227,
-0.187661007,
-0.358820945,
0.2265976816,
0.1677434891,
-0.4743785858,
-0.1321092695,
-0.5035951734,
-0.2952184975,
0.112313576,
0.1889425665,
0.0270985235,
-0.1017712131,
0.0199380387,
-0.2226155251,
-0.2928781509,
0.1669247895,
0.0938552618,
0.119771786,
0.0271810349,
-0.2962884009,
-0.4770276248,
0.7184291482,
0.1426410377,
-0.2081154287,
0.5561797619,
0.527969718,
-0.6993493438,
0.0335224755,
-0.6783707142,
-0.002427279,
-0.3122066557,
0.6233377457,
-0.4796177745,
-0.497572571,
0.5479465127,
-0.4530255198,
0.5158007741,
0.4863142073,
0.0365117639,
-0.0002962121,
0.956792295,
0.705726862,
0.1632707715,
0.6952076554,
0.3280800283,
-0.1427219063,
-0.8725776672,
-0.305490762,
-0.9984468222,
-0.0864682943,
-0.40646258,
-0.1981524825,
-0.1382253766,
0.2061536908,
0.1439888626,
0.2948710024,
-0.0485648848,
0.4678257406,
0.1414723992,
-0.3017516434,
0.361892879,
-0.164541468,
0.3998010457,
-0.5231585503,
-0.367655009,
-0.9558563232,
1.0512105227,
0.3131399453,
0.544726193,
-0.0355113149,
0.8109225631,
0.3121411204,
0.3768223822,
-0.3608781397,
0.385253489,
-0.2737524509,
-0.6231306195,
-0.2688055336,
-0.5322319865,
-0.9991926551,
0.3414632976,
-0.1991799772,
-1.3300788403,
0.6141784191,
-0.2891198099,
0.0738183185,
0.0071192491,
-0.866592586,
1.1384011507,
0.0499107242,
-0.2214499116,
-0.0171305742,
-0.4633936286,
-0.0390644334,
-0.3246732652,
0.3228479922,
-0.4101271927,
-0.096057713,
1.0890870094,
-0.2201647013,
0.5186590552,
-0.0195112266,
-0.1766243875,
0.0241520442,
0.0238783732,
0.5075341463,
0.2292745411,
-0.2908852398,
0.2629366815,
0.431494236,
-0.2453376949,
-0.6264646053,
0.3947139978,
-0.4455886185,
-0.4200734496,
-0.3584524691,
0.0921188295,
-0.2627290487,
-0.0177582353,
0.2394457757,
0.7030405998,
-0.6292349696,
0.3127533197,
0.2252987027,
-0.2956234813,
0.7454828024,
0.4242390096,
-0.4013056755,
-0.5058521032,
0.8422163725,
-0.0533022881,
0.0908432305,
0.4405560493,
-0.1747128814,
-0.1228747517,
-0.4481540024,
-0.1447349936,
-0.2194592208,
-0.8837721944,
-0.150384441,
-0.7331613898,
-0.0272045713,
-0.3610521257,
0.0244538933,
-0.8112567663,
-0.6234641671,
-0.2269762605,
-0.0902175754,
-0.1865427345,
0.4226889908,
-0.109114401,
0.1372016668,
-0.9739319682,
0.3470568657,
-0.0097684953,
0.2406028509,
-0.1548746675,
-0.2237861454,
-0.277005285,
-0.5086224079,
-0.1368850619,
-0.7959221601,
0.1788252592,
0.3078832924,
0.6244840622,
-0.0286662541,
-0.175462082,
0.6703278422,
-0.7587698102,
0.7225560546,
0.0808504298,
-1.2637079954,
0.8928110003,
0.1804930419,
0.0929283202,
0.9041356444,
-0.0377885401,
-0.7279990315,
-0.2342400104,
-0.857524693,
-1.0838290453,
0.5990723372,
0.3236060143,
-0.1419679224,
-0.2010581493,
0.4958654344,
0.4504168034,
0.2961366773,
-0.7336267233,
-0.1180592179,
0.0626065359,
-0.1156622022,
-0.0559982657,
-0.2729211748,
0.0524740927,
0.1225883588,
0.3287827969,
0.0951858163,
0.0655027628,
0.2959851921,
-0.314201057,
-0.0108056553,
0.3099741936,
0.1513207555,
1.1113585234,
-0.4218407869,
-0.1159826219,
0.1987623125,
-0.5769212842,
-0.1742914021,
0.3106854856,
0.0812808201,
0.2042585015,
0.9200986624,
0.4886223674,
0.1658427417,
-0.7787485123,
0.5400176644,
-0.5744514465,
-0.0439553894,
-0.3678193688,
-0.1994809806,
-0.4806987345,
0.1811282188,
0.6607897282,
-0.2649403512,
0.2972842753,
-0.4765284657,
0.5472066402,
0.2732498348,
-0.4016126692,
-0.3108636737,
0.7116106153,
0.2882477045,
-0.2313722968,
0.524415791,
0.0849746391,
-0.2516725957,
0.7778348923,
0.3665190637,
1.1423456669,
-0.0579777621,
0.2126351148,
0.352507025,
0.5911185741,
0.0734424442,
0.2042521834,
0.1703423262,
-0.6695925593,
-0.8398880363,
-0.7655615807,
-0.6823632121,
0.0160913616,
-0.9685510397,
0.2992286682,
-0.0909767002,
-0.1032059863,
0.3364740312,
0.2238703668,
-0.5487935543,
0.3026914895,
0.1538925171,
1.2570128441,
-0.7175052166,
0.5577176213,
0.4804958701,
-0.4095354974,
-0.5052423477,
0.2649122477,
-0.1126371697,
-0.3572945893,
0.5823975801,
0.2352034897,
0.0919197276,
-0.2527443171,
-0.3388052285,
-0.5103655457,
0.6811177731,
0.3320196271,
-0.5988874435,
0.0914802998,
-0.0161880925,
0.4035315514,
-0.3836313188,
0.4900672734,
0.9032615423,
0.565509975,
-0.2310785204,
-0.8834062219,
0.0511434898,
-0.2469236851,
-0.1384527683,
0.1909460127,
-0.3915340602,
0.4135828614,
0.3941149414,
-0.4827278554,
0.0777697191,
0.7508837581,
0.048065044,
0.6224152446,
0.2672634423,
0.323972404,
0.854622364,
-0.4022492468,
1.1171320677,
0.2766094804,
0.2515977323,
1.2773575783,
-0.6494983435,
1.0448402166,
0.5110192299,
-0.2692603171,
0.4831264317,
0.4744843543,
0.1550147831,
0.3909072578,
-0.0162610039,
-0.1429148018,
-0.1553664356,
0.0014924047,
-0.5310621262,
0.7783716917,
0.2650952935,
-0.1402702481,
-0.4454497397,
-0.1226589158,
-0.1005494818,
0.0778777823,
-0.0275870096,
0.8757917285,
0.0312684961,
-0.6024904251,
0.0464736111,
-0.0849798918,
0.3275868297,
-0.4906119704,
-0.2696909904,
-0.2256453931,
0.2192413211,
-0.1001990065,
-0.4909682274,
0.5877481103,
0.1888768822,
-0.3348410726,
-0.1900349706,
0.6571716666,
-0.0064464193,
-0.2660844922,
0.2777956724,
0.5809324384,
0.3332891762,
-0.1727376729,
-0.5587316751,
0.4902685881,
0.0452766009,
-0.4075135887,
0.2914407551,
0.7471170425,
0.0241728164,
0.3196844757,
0.4631585479,
0.1253480017,
-0.0118748564,
0.3405172825,
0.3133624196,
-0.9118331671,
-0.0796718299,
-0.9462254643,
0.5198305845,
-0.4234408736,
-0.5978440046,
0.6102392077,
0.7026705146,
0.4046167433,
0.3082501292,
0.7211892605,
-0.094583407,
0.6508529782,
-0.3976491392,
0.3128172159,
-0.5490118265,
0.1674419343,
-0.4610486031,
-0.9405303597,
-0.1769375652,
0.4365662634,
-0.0755493119,
0.0310761277,
0.8730348349,
0.0483186878,
0.3965555131,
0.4368016124,
0.0788746923,
-0.2576434612,
0.6408662796,
0.3893877864,
0.9353507161,
-0.8562932014,
0.4888765216,
0.1401726454,
-0.4402096272,
-0.07957495,
-1.3644295931,
-0.4193103015,
-0.6681146622,
-0.7967428565,
-0.1293827444,
0.2199430764,
0.6744576693,
0.6994236112,
-0.9094100595,
-0.0938495845,
-0.0144327469,
0.2497971058,
-0.293220669,
-0.2540817261,
0.3135846555,
-0.4930678308,
-1.1167088747,
0.5661569238,
0.2335172445,
-0.0685870349,
0.3307864964,
0.4675787687,
-0.1082137153,
-0.0542871915,
0.3544552028,
0.5716543198,
-0.3102269471,
-0.4323661327,
-0.5050864816,
0.0395803489,
0.0066000051,
0.6739989519,
-0.7014166117,
0.173812747,
0.2859273255,
0.9207334518,
0.6585879326,
-0.1240245774,
1.0212116241,
-0.979044497,
-0.0470175892,
0.2016943097,
0.3287616968,
0.0646815896,
-0.1069420725,
0.8775448799,
-0.0025918826,
-0.776896596,
-1.2069401741,
0.0800641328,
-0.8243486285,
-0.0772018433,
0.8377687335,
-0.1711097807,
-0.2068001777,
-0.1540162861,
0.0973022208,
0.2065848112,
-0.0920280367,
0.5127126575,
1.004693985,
-0.1242879406,
-0.3902016878,
-0.7319666743,
0.4973590672,
0.4797529578,
-1.137267828,
0.4116278589,
0.4457374215,
0.0101593807,
0.3039368689,
0.5631514788,
-0.4266782105,
0.2624115944,
0.173530519,
0.3405523002,
0.644186914,
-0.4279073775,
-0.3327204287,
0.327988863,
-0.1833641976,
-0.2494421005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09559v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09559v3
|
Prompt-based Pseudo-labeling Strategy for Sample-Efficient Semi-Supervised Extractive Summarization
| 2023-11-16T04:29:41 | 2024-07-02T02:16:28 |
Gaurav Sahu, Olga Vechtomova, Issam H. Laradji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Semi-supervised learning (SSL) is a widely used technique in scenarios where
labeled data is scarce and unlabeled data is abundant. While SSL is popular for
image and text classification, it is relatively underexplored for the task of
extractive text summarization. Standard SSL methods follow a teacher-student
paradigm to first train a classification model and then use the classifier's
confidence values to select pseudo-labels for the subsequent training cycle;
however, such classifiers are not suitable to measure the accuracy of
pseudo-labels as they lack specific tuning for evaluation, which leads to
confidence values that fail to capture the semantics and correctness of the
generated summary. To address this problem, we propose a prompt-based
pseudo-labeling strategy with LLMs that picks unlabeled examples with more
accurate pseudo-labels than using just the classifier's probability outputs.
Our approach also includes a relabeling mechanism that improves the quality of
pseudo-labels. We evaluate our method on three text summarization datasets:
TweetSumm, WikiHow, and ArXiv/PubMed. We empirically show that a
prompting-based LLM that scores and generates pseudo-labels outperforms
existing SSL methods on ROUGE-1, ROUGE-2, and ROUGE-L scores on all the
datasets. Furthermore, our method achieves competitive L-Eval scores
(evaluation with LLaMa-3) as a fully supervised method in a data-scarce setting
and outperforms fully supervised method in a data-abundant setting.
|
[
-0.074284777,
-0.8207250834,
0.6063761711,
0.1142656654,
-0.7112333179,
0.4791455567,
-0.1289172322,
-0.1972920448,
0.4586939216,
0.0983368754,
-0.3710086942,
-0.7140780687,
-0.301251471,
0.5758259296,
-0.4084500372,
1.3475657701,
0.0455068238,
-0.0747772828,
-0.2856917679,
-0.0001971506,
-0.2172830701,
-0.4282130599,
-0.4002811909,
-0.1174756289,
0.502800107,
0.6102197766,
0.3112510145,
0.4130367339,
0.0958942622,
0.2860028148,
-0.3732627332,
0.4768273234,
-0.475471288,
0.1272324473,
0.1177713349,
-0.614341259,
-0.2994893789,
0.1304435432,
0.5995281339,
0.5826784372,
-0.0460935459,
0.4333713651,
0.2151694149,
0.6091442108,
-0.5810753107,
0.1065088362,
-0.1665434837,
0.1259959787,
-0.3557339013,
-0.4981476665,
-0.5735679269,
-0.5441817045,
0.300953269,
-0.6456785798,
0.2097000033,
0.2438858449,
0.8141616583,
0.2438954413,
-0.1947529763,
-0.1718588024,
-0.4294162989,
0.8752192259,
-0.6092065573,
0.0366625786,
0.3233270347,
0.3210583925,
0.1419268101,
-1.0223339796,
-0.2869600356,
-0.1176232845,
-0.1680030376,
0.6975069046,
-0.0994901657,
-0.0855984837,
0.2233022153,
0.2988230884,
-0.4368681312,
0.2196392864,
-0.4459805191,
-0.4690681696,
0.6061789989,
0.1420421153,
0.2044003159,
-0.0603993088,
-0.5002831817,
-0.0154056158,
-0.7243860364,
0.2557084858,
0.1857278943,
0.497585386,
-0.1241624355,
0.7814847827,
-0.170169279,
0.8097541332,
0.1782821566,
-0.2839810848,
0.457008481,
-0.4443874955,
0.0159815233,
0.508149147,
0.8629494905,
0.720521152,
0.2821329534,
-0.0312926099,
-0.4223370254,
-0.2266042233,
-0.0228713974,
-0.6416936517,
-0.5269547701,
0.1972924024,
-0.5598848462,
-0.529083252,
-0.0769338161,
-1.0243314505,
-0.1273943335,
-0.1894814819,
0.4282619059,
-0.0268224347,
0.2055772543,
-0.516119957,
-0.4276971519,
0.1726660281,
0.5004425645,
-0.5586450696,
-0.085800238,
0.0299580973,
1.2980350256,
-0.4911381602,
0.0006250901,
-0.8506191969,
0.0460223109,
-0.4758796394,
0.9472132921,
-0.25401631,
-0.7295117378,
0.0226583332,
-0.0861680508,
0.0916242599,
-0.3760344982,
0.3936537504,
-0.4856863618,
0.4805821776,
-0.302993834,
-0.7064474821,
0.1978450567,
0.1973052621,
-0.4939617813,
1.1718974113,
-0.020400621,
-0.8089798689,
0.1828775853,
-0.2788673043,
-0.6459077597,
0.2738933265,
-0.1109264567,
-0.7513019443,
0.0448591523,
0.2849888504,
0.5884872079,
-0.0904207379,
0.2829475403,
-0.2516873777,
-0.5548195243,
0.2714566588,
-0.3612363935,
0.7027509212,
0.2149445117,
-0.0930081978,
0.2694547474,
-0.6134695411,
-0.0098791597,
0.1931853443,
-0.265709132,
-0.382038027,
-0.2839223742,
-0.1007429436,
0.0245977025,
0.3193644881,
-0.3780145645,
-0.003889398,
-0.4515450597,
0.0932822153,
0.7839142084,
0.3569425046,
0.5181378126,
-0.4048504531,
0.5835012794,
-0.2066324502,
-0.028710857,
-0.4821004272,
-0.4111405611,
-0.5578970909,
-0.633885026,
0.5717642903,
0.7970207334,
-1.1647986174,
0.4989801943,
-0.0346137471,
-0.6420983076,
-0.4799818099,
0.1732770056,
0.5743981004,
1.0717285872,
0.6981967092,
0.1247099936,
-0.2862004638,
-0.8833714128,
-0.2294473946,
-0.2237288207,
-0.1498226821,
0.0074269418,
0.2594032884,
0.3396064043,
1.2216866016,
-0.7186467052,
-0.4055531621,
-0.7127445936,
0.5010982156,
0.2309843451,
0.1236075014,
0.3281832635,
-0.8041436076,
-0.5452027321,
-0.4584983587,
-0.8908646703,
-0.577144146,
-0.3575908244,
0.1325882673,
0.0776573569,
0.5040899515,
-0.1772424281,
0.4805739224,
-0.1877387613,
0.2460421473,
0.6360335946,
-0.5037485957,
0.0090095568,
-1.0028742552,
0.0600860864,
0.3389816582,
-0.3606189191,
-0.6314883828,
-0.5025082231,
0.3883131444,
0.0648965463,
-0.7181780934,
0.5531660318,
-0.614577651,
0.0624086186,
-0.391895622,
0.1393823028,
-0.0612682812,
0.3829710484,
0.5428340435,
0.9606139064,
0.5550763011,
-0.7677785158,
0.2220327109,
0.2433944941,
-0.0694650561,
0.4604388177,
-0.8393211365,
-0.1547545791,
-0.2175518572,
0.5808780193,
-1.1895769835,
-0.0228582658,
0.340302974,
-0.3966825306,
0.4938927591,
-0.000412354,
-0.4436855018,
-0.3460393846,
-0.7501708865,
0.2448137254,
0.7293358445,
-0.602717638,
0.5146218538,
0.2894211113,
-0.2628426254,
-0.480730921,
-0.700724721,
0.1489578336,
-0.4665184319,
-0.0474329293,
0.348916471,
-0.1046546325,
-0.0046279286,
-0.2218937129,
-0.2013649642,
0.2576766908,
0.1346975565,
-0.1434973478,
0.7369191051,
0.1605939567,
-0.0237344932,
0.3957880735,
-0.3777557909,
0.0290137809,
-0.1873147339,
-0.0078305993,
0.0081221927,
-0.0401860662,
-0.6222970486,
0.1525855213,
-0.0978442058,
-0.1527678668,
0.562687993,
0.2948700786,
-0.0134683894,
-0.4943620265,
-0.1575262696,
-0.3460728824,
-0.4356516302,
0.1232374534,
-0.0764030665,
-0.6705396175,
0.3774358034,
-0.4830345511,
0.306163162,
0.2410289943,
0.580817759,
-0.8138315678,
0.6146085262,
0.4210810065,
0.0763604864,
0.4077025354,
-0.1665314138,
0.172302708,
-0.5413725376,
-0.2383232415,
-0.4807399511,
-0.1554401219,
-0.2859238982,
-0.1547590643,
0.5297483206,
-0.037216302,
0.4610852897,
0.0484453812,
-0.4820902646,
0.5929280519,
0.6114364266,
0.2219880223,
0.2475236505,
-0.0948400721,
-0.05502088,
0.0462224036,
-0.6730690598,
-0.6283240318,
1.1328005791,
-0.0050763679,
0.6176599264,
-0.061512351,
1.0397634506,
0.8230865598,
0.2376714796,
-0.5393072367,
0.6689196229,
0.0881624445,
-0.2490248233,
-0.3253339231,
-0.5704226494,
-0.7536955476,
0.210260421,
-0.2429348677,
-0.584072113,
0.0454347953,
0.4571942389,
-0.5102869868,
0.0226688515,
-0.814791739,
0.5864241123,
-0.3185943365,
-0.3719310164,
0.3732809126,
-1.1697294712,
0.3604709506,
-0.355594635,
0.3190186024,
0.2882628739,
-0.310305506,
1.0510499477,
-0.4733504951,
1.0580316782,
-0.2941864729,
-0.0286928676,
0.5189452171,
-0.2634662986,
0.6746230125,
-0.0780798569,
0.3831395209,
-0.0654242933,
-0.1043588296,
-0.3710742295,
-0.4822080731,
0.2896098197,
-0.5349774957,
-0.4376034737,
-0.5895617008,
-0.0342378207,
-0.2523613274,
0.2528603971,
0.6833121777,
0.4508035183,
0.0684268177,
-0.1103016958,
0.9779672027,
-0.4022901952,
0.6001159549,
0.4378774166,
-0.0049540447,
-0.372705549,
1.2179985046,
0.2963940203,
0.252419591,
0.4336202145,
0.3479336798,
-0.7768492699,
-0.6293923855,
-0.5639309883,
0.1014092863,
-0.6675238013,
-0.3888677061,
-0.6412078738,
-0.0614324696,
-0.2156780958,
-0.33557266,
-0.2026164085,
-0.4565550685,
-0.5805514455,
-0.359526664,
0.1717073917,
0.1082357541,
-0.0834720805,
0.4548454285,
-0.8378273845,
0.5516896844,
0.0710437,
-0.2348436564,
-0.0572857074,
-0.850600183,
-0.0446019731,
-0.1745658219,
0.0480431765,
-1.2924913168,
0.2645277381,
0.0957434997,
0.700886786,
0.2957027853,
0.6906400919,
0.4975507557,
-0.2426303774,
0.8926292062,
0.2808970809,
-0.693328619,
0.7271828055,
-0.0642621517,
0.2415063232,
0.7313922048,
0.3919792175,
-0.1324483156,
-0.6264848113,
-0.5806438923,
-1.1030757427,
0.6780404449,
0.2546481192,
-0.1234916672,
-0.0762866065,
0.0435459353,
0.1323561966,
0.1668494642,
-0.5567315221,
-0.5751799345,
-0.2956091464,
-0.4460015893,
-0.1729990393,
-0.4083081484,
0.0557567887,
0.0728063285,
0.8222407103,
-0.1833948344,
-0.0974411666,
0.4441811144,
-0.4317858815,
0.3446613252,
0.2045995444,
0.4780404568,
0.3944958746,
-0.2722590566,
0.3450776637,
0.2384749055,
-0.242466867,
0.2824941874,
0.1847058088,
-0.5739688277,
0.0870425478,
0.6088470221,
0.3277774453,
0.1396397203,
-0.8128327727,
0.6215728521,
-0.2144918889,
-0.1984585971,
-0.130656153,
-0.1351497024,
-0.1160491183,
0.0282384194,
0.6208737493,
-0.1610506177,
0.3101370633,
-0.1492837369,
0.3512652516,
0.1732039005,
-0.1793573648,
-0.1378898472,
0.5179475546,
0.1624031812,
-0.1244876981,
0.4383509457,
-0.3094153702,
-0.4683075249,
0.4593592286,
0.5965633392,
0.6226526499,
-0.0547578335,
0.5733827353,
0.4556187093,
0.3272292316,
-0.2164738625,
0.1388603598,
-0.4569166601,
-0.344281435,
-0.2589042485,
-0.3812813759,
-0.4131724536,
-0.2690249979,
-0.7660688162,
0.2053434849,
-0.3928736448,
-0.0710701421,
-0.0612175949,
-0.0741674677,
-0.0759801418,
0.3007013202,
0.0201514866,
0.8697262406,
-1.293276906,
0.5571158528,
0.6952903867,
-0.3732042611,
-0.6717649698,
-0.1014384255,
0.193171978,
-0.5762016177,
0.1499771774,
0.2035551369,
-0.1221315712,
0.0643621534,
-0.5423414111,
-0.3948247135,
1.0857938528,
-0.0442212336,
-0.6406856179,
0.2165472358,
-0.1844760478,
0.6039372087,
-0.0032107448,
0.4303719699,
0.3695689142,
0.424931556,
0.4206337035,
-0.4164918065,
-0.082543999,
-0.335357368,
-0.14571549,
0.0139765674,
-0.512902081,
0.1614946127,
-0.4711188972,
-0.4954065382,
0.0255207382,
1.1204874516,
0.6716976166,
0.7664606571,
0.5125390887,
0.1956243068,
1.1274913549,
-0.0330112763,
0.8670522571,
0.0736452863,
0.095844537,
1.2701259851,
-0.2253077626,
0.4708792865,
0.5079497695,
-0.1162066013,
-0.1036354825,
1.1399632692,
-0.2784127295,
0.7821976542,
0.1800811738,
-0.1448524147,
-0.3752877414,
-0.3424791098,
-0.2666274905,
0.1282700747,
0.0737979114,
-0.3382846415,
-0.4522238076,
0.0619984716,
0.003632487,
0.1151542589,
-0.3596692979,
1.0154266357,
0.1380919516,
-0.5301002264,
0.3114691377,
-0.0868225843,
0.557914257,
-0.5203310847,
-0.0212565605,
-0.4503360987,
-0.2996270657,
-0.2032979578,
-0.9490740895,
-0.0390341841,
0.3940287232,
-0.025809424,
-0.4085601866,
0.7554211617,
-0.406532675,
-0.5800613165,
-0.0588548072,
0.6688991189,
0.3803988397,
0.3385112584,
-0.5231016874,
-0.3173422515,
0.2306181341,
-0.3099993467,
0.4775695503,
0.3645834029,
-0.2771330774,
0.5065917373,
0.8022801876,
0.1154500246,
-0.1472190022,
0.1349394321,
0.8187040687,
-0.5160101652,
-0.8356032968,
-1.0344473124,
0.4962213933,
-0.3703202009,
-0.3081332445,
0.8740281463,
0.8147996068,
0.4213728309,
0.0795935392,
0.7903834581,
0.2600265145,
0.5627629757,
-0.706866622,
0.3675733209,
-0.644149065,
0.4059961736,
-0.3436256051,
-0.8410218358,
-0.2953562737,
0.4616923928,
-0.1726537347,
-0.0057264548,
0.5793188214,
0.5566149354,
0.1571994722,
0.2291052938,
0.174375996,
-0.0092759449,
0.2487503141,
0.214876309,
1.0733469725,
0.2073475718,
0.5493105054,
-0.2902975082,
-0.6497853398,
-0.0817655772,
-0.9616142511,
-1.1861026287,
-0.4846456945,
-0.5148837566,
-0.1730172038,
0.035260655,
0.6777450442,
0.2342961729,
-0.5286303163,
0.2163697183,
0.31714046,
0.1003615707,
-0.2072926015,
-0.2141622901,
0.7760408521,
-0.3850545287,
-0.4787905514,
0.4442526698,
0.325738579,
0.2538505495,
0.2187012136,
0.148059696,
-0.0500458293,
-0.2384265363,
0.3132406175,
0.4010389745,
-0.431615442,
0.3384104967,
-0.0536732338,
0.02923855,
-0.1511154771,
0.4896715283,
-0.8141131401,
0.4224268496,
0.3881501257,
0.6691393852,
0.5185063481,
0.4004938304,
0.3321787119,
-0.8882464767,
-0.1701535583,
0.1372261941,
0.2238759547,
0.2770677507,
-0.4389199615,
0.2663681805,
0.2679370046,
-0.3040729165,
-0.8988528252,
-0.1562791169,
-1.0279314518,
-0.4288997352,
0.9191403389,
-0.2611371577,
-0.4123001695,
-0.1779452711,
-0.2038814276,
0.4519615173,
-0.6236940622,
0.7995128632,
0.3690203428,
-0.0815063566,
-0.2264940143,
-0.1779482812,
0.4747393131,
0.2877243161,
-0.8762842417,
0.0298593845,
0.5764647126,
0.0243929867,
0.053985808,
0.8106667399,
0.0711325705,
0.2981373966,
-0.4776875675,
-0.2764418423,
-0.3724464774,
-0.5185166001,
-0.2705326676,
0.1727903783,
-0.3180548847,
-0.3695796728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09558v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09558v2
|
What if you said that differently?: How Explanation Formats Affect Human Feedback Efficacy and User Perception
| 2023-11-16T04:26:32 | 2024-04-02T00:59:36 |
Chaitanya Malaviya, Subin Lee, Dan Roth, Mark Yatskar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Eliciting feedback from end users of NLP models can be beneficial for
improving models. However, how should we present model responses to users so
they are most amenable to be corrected from user feedback? Further, what
properties do users value to understand and trust responses? We answer these
questions by analyzing the effect of rationales (or explanations) generated by
QA models to support their answers. We specifically consider decomposed QA
models that first extract an intermediate rationale based on a context and a
question and then use solely this rationale to answer the question. A rationale
outlines the approach followed by the model to answer the question. Our work
considers various formats of these rationales that vary according to
well-defined properties of interest. We sample rationales from language models
using few-shot prompting for two datasets, and then perform two user studies.
First, we present users with incorrect answers and corresponding rationales in
various formats and ask them to provide natural language feedback to revise the
rationale. We then measure the effectiveness of this feedback in patching these
rationales through in-context learning. The second study evaluates how well
different rationale formats enable users to understand and trust model answers,
when they are correct. We find that rationale formats significantly affect how
easy it is (1) for users to give feedback for rationales, and (2) for models to
subsequently execute this feedback. In addition, formats with attributions to
the context and in-depth reasoning significantly enhance user-reported
understanding and trust of model outputs.
|
[
-0.3287769258,
-0.7321103215,
0.7582152486,
0.1778390855,
-0.151105538,
-0.2317488939,
-0.2462794185,
-0.5434928536,
0.0944116712,
0.3964031339,
-0.5924670696,
-0.1319333911,
-0.3925586939,
0.4567330778,
-0.1344006658,
0.9485114217,
0.0641751438,
0.2813536823,
-0.3258681297,
-0.1374914199,
-0.7726383209,
-0.5960942507,
-0.784828186,
-0.4701287448,
0.5975397825,
0.3795152903,
1.0138348341,
0.4134112895,
0.1990926415,
0.3918844759,
-0.1211190224,
-0.0634694919,
-0.0243386067,
-0.0766729489,
-0.2884395719,
-0.7793270946,
-0.455142796,
0.3003036082,
0.391040653,
0.8307008147,
-0.3745016754,
0.2003087103,
0.1163538769,
0.6848469973,
-0.5265607238,
-0.1008838713,
-0.4301937521,
-0.1437726021,
0.2682816982,
-0.4647340775,
-0.5866020918,
-0.4522874057,
0.5045760274,
-0.7912945747,
0.0100067742,
0.0025387087,
0.8746987581,
-0.0236469172,
-0.4466006756,
-0.3804452419,
-0.928468585,
0.7237850428,
-1.3035833836,
0.2503559589,
0.5122485161,
0.6266185045,
-0.0669040456,
-0.7959043384,
-0.7945544124,
-0.1389127672,
-0.475820899,
0.1591837108,
-0.167602092,
0.1283638179,
0.5752145052,
0.1407723874,
-0.3915864825,
-0.0814658925,
-0.3528006673,
-0.1877217591,
0.8853485584,
0.0568628646,
0.3897102773,
-0.2289479077,
-0.1920191497,
-0.3393620849,
-0.5683864355,
0.5219064355,
0.6796725988,
0.1865774393,
-0.0392082036,
0.645288825,
-0.2402514666,
0.8167968988,
0.3085445762,
-0.2029227465,
-0.0659036487,
-0.30508551,
-0.4409861863,
-0.2466835678,
0.4981129169,
0.7659317851,
0.0697825998,
-0.2258605957,
-0.427940011,
0.0557969064,
0.3061816692,
-0.7062878013,
-0.1615043283,
0.2181742936,
-0.665066123,
-0.0734752342,
0.1179498285,
-0.5768396258,
-0.4823799133,
-0.7548006177,
0.6213730574,
-0.3350397646,
-0.2487308383,
0.5137984157,
-0.448864609,
0.2735639215,
0.6504151225,
-1.0632380247,
0.4823896289,
0.5028250813,
0.3289788961,
0.1336851418,
-0.1436016411,
-0.3898004889,
-0.2980641723,
-0.2410936654,
0.8244504333,
-0.5461745262,
-0.3610245287,
0.0891587809,
0.0321318991,
-0.1457029581,
-0.632098496,
0.5071276426,
-0.5457903743,
0.9231817126,
-0.7300187349,
-0.6477692723,
-0.626685679,
0.1856485158,
-0.6478215456,
0.633060813,
0.0952786282,
-0.822743535,
0.358841151,
-0.7181296349,
-0.0452601649,
-0.0193962492,
-0.1184220761,
-0.0343091749,
0.1931258887,
0.1777017117,
0.1056647897,
-0.0867445022,
0.246406123,
-0.3032110631,
-0.182780534,
0.8017464876,
-0.5042418242,
0.8363930583,
0.1272349805,
-0.2718170881,
0.3781781495,
-0.7296780348,
0.2198825181,
0.1093655527,
-0.4261310101,
-0.3350589275,
0.088666454,
0.3017079234,
0.3780123293,
-0.043827448,
-0.5973529816,
0.157245636,
-0.6057602167,
0.5904669166,
0.5674755573,
0.0317418166,
0.7272916436,
-0.579549551,
0.8357765675,
-0.0434342287,
0.0826030448,
-0.4172901809,
-0.7123377919,
-0.2438012362,
0.1699314862,
0.317270726,
0.3657290041,
-0.4618095756,
-0.0791068375,
0.1155531257,
-0.1767632216,
-0.7337229252,
0.1431655735,
0.3972868323,
0.892370522,
0.1566311866,
-0.2984981537,
-0.8087216616,
-1.1438570023,
-0.6428536177,
-0.5672212243,
-0.3955604434,
0.228636086,
0.2875942886,
0.0500898287,
1.2151204348,
-0.3913360834,
0.2782346308,
-0.2353999317,
0.0666253269,
-0.1876905113,
0.2379814833,
0.4739299417,
-1.0022729635,
-0.3943116665,
-0.2114916742,
-0.4089109302,
-0.1368394941,
-0.3693220615,
0.0491653048,
0.3863866031,
0.2623371482,
-0.6475013494,
0.5397441983,
0.4135978818,
-0.5894123912,
0.71415627,
-0.2431257367,
0.2625009418,
-1.0620496273,
-0.0286288951,
0.0726097971,
-0.2564611733,
-0.4837611616,
-0.0120671289,
-0.0486623459,
0.1063694507,
-0.3519313931,
0.5558565855,
-0.1757839471,
-0.0657006502,
-0.1682626307,
0.1865558326,
0.5528167486,
0.3912096918,
0.0462313332,
0.707369864,
0.064268969,
-0.4515128434,
-0.059175618,
0.2405427098,
-0.2448730171,
0.4816579819,
-1.0447813272,
0.2998934984,
-0.3031976223,
0.3394627869,
-1.117607832,
-0.4472749829,
0.1953226328,
-0.8399365544,
0.0255457107,
-0.1054524556,
-0.4508812428,
-0.0438272879,
-0.3233710825,
0.0154010672,
0.4872367084,
-0.5198720098,
0.8265148401,
0.1616240442,
0.0407886095,
-0.4018747211,
-0.6673505902,
-0.1198727638,
-0.5550326109,
-1.0377492905,
0.3404882848,
-0.3677638471,
-0.683241725,
-0.0784810483,
-0.0183904376,
-0.1725713015,
0.4177978635,
0.2508007288,
0.2226901799,
-0.4873973429,
0.1767612249,
0.0221327264,
0.128236264,
0.3683055341,
-0.0385927632,
0.2419320494,
-0.2807747424,
-0.1789317578,
-0.8148425817,
0.6559390426,
0.3204734325,
-0.1128275767,
0.77618891,
0.4684206545,
-0.3189872801,
0.0105668381,
-0.3776697516,
-0.655490756,
-0.503151834,
0.1582481414,
-0.283914417,
-0.7097277641,
0.6204087734,
0.0437305979,
0.401036799,
0.2982382774,
0.6659380794,
-0.3452896774,
1.4403817654,
0.8425034881,
0.5467064977,
0.3079552352,
0.0414387099,
0.5305284858,
-0.6541768312,
-0.492742002,
-0.5965296626,
-0.3472435474,
-0.5024645329,
-0.0352132097,
-0.0640297085,
0.6259980798,
0.0194223579,
0.1765922755,
-0.3251962662,
0.4909251034,
0.3510151803,
-0.0800206214,
0.5189734697,
-0.1786691248,
0.3126782477,
-0.2392806113,
-0.515827775,
-1.0263280869,
0.9387534857,
0.5733647346,
0.6665965915,
0.4686743319,
0.5526873469,
0.1362009794,
0.4709939063,
-0.9163662791,
0.1958189905,
0.4728956819,
-0.649499774,
-0.273998946,
0.0222775135,
-0.6926430464,
0.478674829,
-0.2543775439,
-0.8783811927,
0.2441208214,
0.5660523772,
-0.6415854096,
0.0830285698,
-1.3303794861,
0.8144423962,
0.1984489709,
0.0458193161,
-0.01758595,
-0.7558560967,
0.3057307005,
0.1990135312,
0.1529652327,
0.1973351985,
0.0815181211,
0.8256839514,
-0.4770976901,
0.9384266734,
-0.11256513,
-0.0398789048,
0.2408174127,
0.083377108,
0.2757943571,
0.4177361131,
-0.1492716074,
-0.2657290101,
0.2783550024,
-0.2210617959,
-1.3719599247,
0.3676470816,
-0.7096809149,
-1.0465482473,
-0.041642718,
-0.5484305024,
-0.3224300444,
-0.1503391713,
0.3345861435,
0.5185366869,
0.1058877781,
0.0481443293,
0.4323101044,
-0.1351786405,
0.4621271491,
0.7105690837,
-0.3713404238,
0.0417173989,
0.2676970959,
-0.0831237882,
0.3640977442,
0.1094124913,
0.4044137299,
-0.5645293593,
-0.3151258826,
-0.6034326553,
0.1841823757,
-0.9643237591,
0.0096166553,
-0.6564459205,
0.153149128,
-0.5229512453,
-0.1695127785,
-0.1217532828,
-0.7190718651,
-0.3064883649,
-0.2941901386,
0.4147556424,
0.8631340861,
0.0153373675,
0.3758363128,
-0.6545882821,
0.0240303073,
0.3814410269,
0.1605845392,
0.294639647,
-0.7451875806,
-0.0281996038,
0.289277643,
-0.4341039062,
-1.2470501661,
0.5653974414,
-0.0238206387,
0.2899795771,
0.2712551653,
-0.0764407441,
0.6445599794,
-0.403210789,
0.8915281892,
0.110656321,
-0.9582237005,
0.5192754269,
-0.1445052922,
0.1094083786,
0.4360975921,
0.4403040707,
-0.7249849439,
-0.0902242288,
-0.6270754933,
-0.7144669294,
0.6211792231,
-0.006531409,
0.3406526744,
0.0130162407,
0.7725791931,
0.3490848541,
0.0098284977,
-0.7610775232,
-0.2751676142,
-0.3146670759,
0.1180381775,
0.0101371836,
-0.4895165861,
-0.4112312198,
-0.124051176,
0.4172456264,
-0.2513961792,
0.0237530041,
0.5461693406,
-0.0444410741,
-0.2060131282,
0.7508123517,
0.8240681887,
1.0154184103,
-0.3167254627,
-0.1402134001,
-0.1466904134,
0.0511023663,
-0.2326849103,
-0.2685735226,
-0.2446631044,
0.1635492891,
0.3076772094,
0.7104355693,
-0.0178209282,
-0.6466133595,
0.4197876453,
-0.428224504,
-0.0582665652,
-0.2124918997,
-0.1531130522,
0.2958760858,
0.1491894722,
0.2093465626,
0.2892288268,
0.4242883027,
-0.7606908083,
0.064493835,
0.2399245054,
-0.2733869851,
-0.726629734,
0.5415958166,
0.0529289581,
-0.7569004297,
0.3798332512,
0.0052620298,
-0.3764941394,
0.5975785851,
0.9250019789,
0.7403029203,
-0.1342536956,
0.4662089646,
0.3533105254,
0.1283521652,
-0.0111561408,
0.2776906192,
-0.0176265147,
-0.6810297966,
-0.6269921064,
-0.4379963279,
-0.582855463,
0.1430190802,
-1.0509377718,
0.1241746098,
-0.5280973315,
-0.3368443251,
0.4204623401,
-0.1906968504,
-0.5981888175,
0.2201920003,
-0.0425011702,
0.9817399383,
-1.0384948254,
0.5938321352,
0.9806882739,
-0.7153292894,
-1.3970601559,
0.0084313899,
0.3206266165,
-0.3447701037,
0.6321539283,
0.0145414881,
-0.0333932452,
-0.3998626471,
-0.7162531614,
-0.6319826245,
0.7262564898,
0.3752949536,
-0.3881779611,
-0.0698251352,
-0.1455784589,
0.8611428142,
-0.5140778422,
0.4869649112,
0.5765017271,
0.3685138822,
-0.1529899985,
-0.890974164,
0.1935798824,
-0.3367192447,
0.3608025908,
-0.325407356,
-0.0959996358,
0.6550149918,
-0.4622309506,
-0.2893272042,
-0.0048103356,
0.7170245051,
0.1584086567,
0.2885410786,
0.5705498457,
0.1964309365,
0.7330577374,
0.195209682,
1.5269259214,
0.1906693131,
-0.0106283501,
1.3075441122,
0.0303260721,
1.0296018124,
0.7715592384,
-0.1335170418,
1.0228340626,
0.8247614503,
0.4487910569,
0.3680147529,
0.1384724826,
0.1101226583,
-0.1286751926,
-0.1080552861,
-0.2566155195,
0.2695034146,
0.1393703669,
-0.2163851857,
-0.1267790794,
0.0054427586,
0.0010897006,
0.6041219831,
0.1270150989,
0.7470923662,
0.1384318322,
-0.9535208344,
0.5049744844,
0.4492667615,
0.5342200994,
-0.4863377213,
-0.2786125243,
-0.4538805783,
-0.0395614244,
-0.6403206587,
-0.7490664124,
0.6304747462,
-0.080051288,
-0.7150771022,
-0.1229461581,
0.2932617664,
-0.430767417,
-0.0456719734,
0.098562263,
0.312119633,
-0.0895614028,
-0.1412058622,
-0.695051074,
-0.0451202989,
0.0482983366,
-0.2994891703,
0.4083052278,
0.3109501302,
-0.3093287945,
0.8067151904,
0.7805384398,
-0.2127600163,
0.1417234242,
0.2442639172,
0.7110068202,
-0.5178835392,
-0.4126424193,
-0.6865959167,
0.8759573698,
-0.0492102429,
-0.4422754645,
0.9752020836,
0.2785952389,
0.8991626501,
-0.1193558946,
0.5153045654,
0.1504584253,
0.6127431393,
-0.4961943328,
0.5530241132,
-0.6330603957,
0.6869174838,
-0.1108487025,
-0.7117698193,
-0.1981921941,
0.4921312928,
-0.2969885767,
-0.0462500528,
0.6716619134,
0.6677942872,
0.244762972,
0.2653254569,
0.2280506343,
0.135599494,
0.4358560443,
0.1823566109,
0.8978678584,
-0.3662627041,
0.2240035683,
-0.4237427413,
-0.1074130386,
-0.0152113335,
-0.7714998126,
-0.7447589636,
-0.7033221722,
-0.4770238996,
-0.7382366657,
-0.2757774591,
1.0683412552,
0.598112762,
-0.8514865041,
-0.1756028384,
0.2766972184,
0.2902045548,
-0.1643244028,
-0.3225624561,
0.318118602,
-0.2461519986,
-0.6542204618,
0.2783797085,
0.2223926336,
0.0045510693,
-0.2667875886,
-0.1939655691,
0.1442016363,
0.3877714276,
0.6268160343,
0.4688935876,
-1.2148535252,
-0.3683454394,
0.3175009787,
-0.1062004417,
0.3041981161,
0.9266251922,
-0.8413216472,
0.6027712822,
0.556748867,
0.5550835729,
0.0042896746,
0.1599816531,
1.0983457565,
-0.4341040254,
0.1117528155,
0.3484943211,
0.3176063299,
0.5728455782,
-0.5751320124,
0.2183634043,
-0.1043841466,
-0.3972961307,
-0.7917086482,
0.2553616762,
-1.1602472067,
-0.3092616796,
1.0418711901,
-0.4158357978,
-0.1329450607,
-0.237471357,
-0.3848434091,
-0.2296628058,
-0.36265558,
1.068102479,
0.8306517601,
-0.1611485481,
-0.1814607382,
-0.4365714788,
0.8770699501,
0.6210568547,
-0.6842059493,
-0.0338555835,
0.3832777441,
0.5018604994,
0.0301121734,
0.6835547686,
-0.3178809285,
0.572599113,
-0.1514756382,
-0.1953893006,
0.1305381656,
0.0433529615,
-0.7317847013,
-0.0191357955,
0.3414258957,
0.2089463621
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09552v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09552v1
|
Large Language Models are Few-Shot Training Example Generators: A Case Study in Fallacy Recognition
| 2023-11-16T04:17:47 | 2023-11-16T04:17:47 |
Tariq Alhindi, Smaranda Muresan, Preslav Nakov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recognizing fallacies is crucial for ensuring the quality and validity of
arguments across various domains. However, computational fallacy recognition
faces challenges due to the diverse genres, domains, and types of fallacies
found in datasets. This leads to a highly multiclass, and even multi-label,
setup with substantial class imbalance. In this study, we aim to enhance
existing models for fallacy recognition by incorporating additional context and
by leveraging large language models to generate synthetic data, thus increasing
the representation of the infrequent classes. We experiment with GPT3.5 to
generate synthetic examples and we examine the impact of prompt settings for
this. Moreover, we explore zero-shot and few-shot scenarios to evaluate the
effectiveness of using the generated examples for training smaller models
within a unified fallacy recognition framework. Furthermore, we analyze the
overlap between the synthetic data and existing fallacy datasets. Finally, we
investigate the usefulness of providing supplementary context for detecting
fallacy types that need such context, e.g., diversion fallacies. Our evaluation
results demonstrate consistent improvements across fallacy types, datasets, and
generators.
|
[
-0.3445528448,
-0.5878006816,
0.7892761827,
-0.0813679472,
-0.1231331602,
-0.135323748,
-0.1559024006,
-0.1437609494,
-0.1609053165,
0.2899102867,
-0.289963007,
-0.240210712,
-0.4656362236,
0.2778917849,
-0.455640614,
1.0378417969,
0.0098061543,
0.0334312543,
-0.1078736484,
-0.0979225785,
-0.5343875289,
-0.6724925637,
-0.3934199214,
-0.6445407867,
0.190408662,
0.4191184342,
0.335215807,
0.2466614246,
0.1315783709,
0.2527085245,
0.2206115574,
0.1817358136,
-0.477984488,
-0.198052749,
0.0892057642,
-0.3279330432,
0.1636542976,
0.243107751,
0.6974859834,
0.5153052807,
-0.1755743623,
-0.0229353309,
-0.0641354248,
0.2614758909,
-0.7496947646,
0.2114367485,
-0.9456354976,
0.1105906069,
-0.0662782341,
-0.0357704572,
-0.6088258028,
-0.2276557684,
0.1389793605,
-0.3557115495,
0.5151723623,
-0.0944970176,
0.627604723,
0.2000199556,
-0.5184968114,
-0.2332389802,
-0.6832574606,
0.8415156007,
-1.0368945599,
0.1480132788,
-0.2022275329,
0.5753065348,
-0.3650846779,
-0.492503196,
-0.9212473035,
-0.2475081682,
-0.3107735813,
-0.0103617366,
-0.0552704632,
-0.2029654533,
0.7257812619,
0.1868448555,
-0.4716486633,
-0.0011093159,
-0.2249795496,
-0.3513143361,
0.3628201485,
0.1707388163,
0.2078594118,
-0.2205950022,
-0.0248787496,
-0.0457786694,
-1.0272195339,
-0.0872447342,
0.3568926454,
0.6582636237,
-0.2330555469,
0.3299698532,
0.0960829332,
1.0544301271,
-0.0178254507,
-0.2107712924,
0.3783137202,
-0.2754312158,
-0.1441951543,
0.1428205222,
0.5655441284,
0.1755007803,
0.1573837847,
0.1640413851,
-0.0336976983,
0.4330525398,
0.1439502537,
-0.7475328445,
-0.3164180517,
-0.0406909809,
-0.2610232532,
-0.3897531629,
-0.0963186026,
-0.5953868628,
-0.713018775,
-0.4528513551,
0.1848473251,
-0.3794489801,
-0.2616776824,
0.1956051886,
-0.492496103,
0.3227667212,
0.587389648,
-0.7268399,
0.1339055747,
0.5690948367,
0.691393733,
-0.2742083371,
-0.3494894505,
-0.5027508736,
0.2324433625,
-0.2560542226,
0.7829036117,
-0.5951914191,
-0.1645655483,
0.0471066982,
0.0535923652,
-0.1825900823,
-0.5718077421,
0.6222710013,
-0.0134117072,
0.3860987127,
-0.0213315934,
-0.5170577168,
-0.1356559694,
0.5677784681,
-0.5884944201,
0.6913563013,
0.1072316468,
-0.7703495026,
0.5637261868,
-0.5855873823,
-0.5657486916,
0.0984218419,
-0.4729420245,
-0.5763854384,
0.4151377082,
0.1379971802,
0.3410466313,
-0.27744928,
0.0541176796,
-0.343226552,
-0.3657774627,
0.2844647765,
-0.7760061622,
0.6742750406,
-0.1605462283,
-0.1891978234,
-0.3453546166,
-0.7766263485,
0.0672079474,
0.0187554117,
-0.5726072192,
-0.5265225768,
-0.0823664367,
0.1599598378,
0.4443399012,
-0.2277821302,
-0.5424617529,
0.3856162429,
-0.5204267502,
0.5653885007,
0.5195826888,
0.1396829933,
0.0187415555,
-0.0725332424,
0.3365769088,
0.4083307981,
-0.2773538232,
-0.0941079855,
-0.340914458,
-0.6324437261,
-0.4229572415,
0.2293381691,
0.435849905,
-0.9424902201,
0.2051830143,
-0.4892485142,
-0.1191209257,
-0.23598665,
0.0384368822,
0.3104847372,
0.8242313266,
0.2946741283,
0.1629665643,
-0.6463201046,
-1.0769957304,
-0.1339919865,
-0.1527993828,
-0.1326704174,
0.1426226199,
0.8440634608,
-0.1585364938,
1.2527397871,
-0.4363479614,
-0.1581890285,
-0.5052857399,
0.2699035704,
0.4650559425,
0.4308028817,
0.7952708006,
-0.8262593746,
-0.3587409556,
-0.1963371336,
-0.894313097,
0.095280841,
-0.0862338021,
0.2337866575,
0.2664106786,
0.161709711,
-0.7602059245,
0.25559026,
0.2266972065,
-0.0297264494,
0.6157745719,
0.2454628497,
0.1633758396,
-1.214253068,
-0.2615279555,
0.1733055413,
-0.2859104276,
-0.7189186811,
-0.0767450258,
-0.1378631741,
-0.0809738636,
-0.7448538542,
0.5816168189,
-0.1977175772,
0.1211818829,
-0.190570578,
-0.0190660935,
-0.062147256,
0.2465908378,
0.3076522648,
0.7107670903,
0.3085801303,
-0.6047353745,
0.3039883971,
0.2214936465,
-0.4004661441,
0.7495267391,
-0.5219368935,
0.1180518344,
-0.1872763634,
0.450509429,
-0.8212031722,
-0.6144733429,
0.1666302532,
-0.3526583016,
0.2602295876,
-0.5385757685,
-0.5691208243,
-0.5173737407,
-0.4070356488,
0.3643957376,
0.5300014615,
-0.9060860276,
0.5315955877,
0.3048259318,
0.2355971187,
-0.8015705347,
-0.7901455164,
-0.0485546961,
-0.5159207582,
-0.0396670923,
-0.0619555674,
0.022588104,
-0.0461964309,
-0.3765347302,
0.0262998994,
0.0425156429,
-0.0730183497,
0.0408222303,
0.1205401942,
-0.0627949759,
0.2099658251,
-0.0562700517,
0.2133198231,
-0.1003483757,
-0.202780962,
0.4219134152,
-0.1305303276,
-0.3774709105,
-0.1713168919,
0.3458257616,
0.4926906228,
0.4765794873,
0.5090010166,
0.310076654,
-0.6748722792,
-0.5609057546,
-0.4177425504,
-0.319257766,
-0.4271748364,
0.3115994334,
-0.4256390929,
-0.6651306152,
0.20856677,
0.0483620055,
0.2218377441,
0.2356943637,
0.7152842283,
0.1451110542,
1.0930906534,
0.1373199373,
-0.1453793645,
0.2846605182,
-0.1803187281,
0.3260198236,
-0.6553637981,
0.2801823616,
-0.4444918036,
-0.0276905689,
-0.4347333908,
-0.3401949406,
0.4889184535,
-0.0438275747,
-0.1903855354,
0.4875445664,
-0.4759449363,
0.8298758268,
0.259169817,
-0.0900259987,
0.2616140842,
0.393066287,
-0.007698942,
-0.3453858495,
-0.8786515594,
-0.7605055571,
0.8938053846,
0.1809099317,
0.5804030895,
0.2200365365,
0.7141907811,
0.457221061,
0.7383251786,
-0.943790853,
0.5891625881,
-0.2967964411,
-0.722917974,
-0.0493787415,
-0.6845372319,
-0.6844924688,
0.3831240237,
-0.1959455907,
-0.6346901655,
-0.0049424702,
0.4605598152,
-0.1503209174,
0.0738484934,
-0.9258814454,
1.0402826071,
0.1371028721,
-0.205738008,
0.0639835447,
-0.3350590765,
0.7656680942,
-0.0848812535,
0.1993163079,
-0.0174187049,
0.5592383146,
0.3867579401,
-0.4810546339,
1.056468606,
-0.2981413007,
-0.1833581775,
0.4172497392,
0.0508506633,
0.4159608483,
0.0518576726,
-0.1100241169,
0.0734176263,
0.0241319276,
-0.2159303874,
-0.6578909159,
0.5609573722,
-0.5074132681,
-0.4943996668,
-0.5957686305,
-0.4262653291,
-0.3303925395,
0.1502802968,
0.3824781179,
0.5746694207,
-0.2834877372,
0.1404057294,
0.2538704872,
-0.1399964839,
0.4171535075,
0.5098887086,
0.2047791779,
-0.3996257186,
0.9362770915,
0.0200878903,
0.2061257064,
0.0991009548,
0.1564803571,
-0.367139101,
-0.5153864622,
-0.6084789038,
0.204405576,
-1.1332187653,
-0.4662098885,
-0.3426702321,
-0.1956448853,
-0.554172039,
-0.1261054426,
-0.0266170148,
-0.618725121,
0.0340053923,
-0.0020513639,
0.1655134708,
0.4055761695,
0.0376011506,
0.5470733643,
-0.7754535079,
0.4090429246,
0.4606628418,
-0.0578713343,
-0.042920325,
-0.6467573047,
0.0310702175,
0.0370348468,
-0.3087138832,
-0.6818110347,
0.259694308,
0.3660397232,
0.5784554482,
0.3084903359,
-0.0875174031,
0.5316851139,
-0.8410455585,
0.8319584727,
0.419814378,
-1.0472280979,
0.5732834935,
-0.2999721169,
0.2067384273,
0.6463816166,
0.2988933027,
-0.3862294853,
-0.2115620375,
-0.5204454064,
-0.4418795705,
0.7420225739,
0.2447181195,
0.3049014509,
-0.2062516212,
0.3298299909,
0.1754851192,
0.4432375133,
-1.2401518822,
0.038636528,
-0.1207072586,
-0.5881364346,
0.1018181667,
-0.0040688943,
-0.3694673479,
-0.1098640561,
0.7629933953,
-0.5605242848,
0.089562498,
-0.2927900255,
-0.3266499043,
0.1785514355,
0.5652627349,
0.609797895,
0.5946030021,
-0.0222743228,
0.2002308518,
0.3098212779,
-0.2657749057,
0.4775056839,
0.1370836347,
-0.6156282425,
0.2482300401,
0.6510041356,
0.682553947,
-0.0967903584,
-0.6518423557,
0.5983736515,
0.1355676949,
-0.0012914409,
-0.4773134887,
0.0262865797,
-0.2733283639,
-0.0872554779,
0.1294008791,
-0.0704248846,
0.3416257799,
-0.7760778666,
0.1381134242,
0.5969701409,
0.0010292244,
-0.1769822091,
0.3402737081,
0.0829204172,
0.0457266867,
0.5635824203,
-0.2925543487,
-0.5880910754,
0.5207265615,
0.5605611801,
0.6324188113,
-0.1646984816,
0.4503296912,
0.4194332361,
0.2515694201,
-0.4656889141,
-0.0089676799,
0.0734503046,
-1.1309863329,
-0.2505629361,
-0.67896384,
-0.5252888203,
0.4306355417,
-0.147908181,
0.7476084232,
-0.373137325,
-0.0124879647,
0.2237373292,
-0.427442193,
-0.457537204,
0.04618714,
0.3621222675,
0.3775380254,
-1.2627980709,
0.5936185122,
0.7756766081,
-0.6592181325,
-0.5041469932,
0.1852065623,
0.1655237973,
-0.5267823935,
0.5609360933,
0.582484901,
-0.3822026849,
-0.245411694,
-0.7551441789,
-0.3362017274,
0.5610553026,
0.6100894213,
-0.4771232307,
-0.171607703,
0.2417232245,
0.6369876862,
-0.7974724174,
0.1148600429,
0.6930729151,
0.2664721906,
0.3079756498,
-0.6486533284,
0.2046054006,
0.0950474218,
-0.0061656353,
-0.0202214289,
-0.2719623744,
0.9126802683,
-0.0907846466,
-0.2053461671,
-0.2269725055,
0.2195971906,
0.8852873445,
0.5329037309,
0.7063882947,
0.6360266209,
0.3225821555,
-0.144685328,
0.8383091092,
0.0945141986,
0.4391238987,
1.3930717707,
-0.6294002533,
0.6010792255,
0.3452537954,
-0.1511030644,
0.6219493747,
0.5704494715,
-0.2316109687,
0.439380914,
0.3681348264,
-0.2679334581,
-0.5402451158,
-0.0829446241,
-0.3176594973,
0.2619318962,
0.5423907042,
-0.3992165923,
-0.5123491287,
0.1991524398,
0.089463912,
-0.0066164169,
-0.2886146903,
0.6276615262,
0.0509456731,
-0.6389598846,
0.9600444436,
-0.1496747136,
0.6448452473,
-0.2654134333,
-0.4892830253,
0.1261104643,
0.4163011909,
-0.2575701475,
-0.49119398,
0.0227303226,
0.0698153824,
-0.2572579384,
0.0926829651,
0.572612524,
-0.3934112489,
-0.7202299833,
-0.0826826617,
0.341622442,
0.3135570288,
0.1512864083,
-0.6541514993,
-0.0382499844,
-0.2034573704,
-0.0166778527,
0.0845842957,
0.4175400138,
-0.0701214671,
0.3024110198,
0.5876789689,
0.1537367105,
-0.1707454771,
0.4406751096,
0.8682284951,
-0.3739631176,
-0.5246979594,
-0.9179362655,
0.199088648,
-0.4886112511,
-0.0941899717,
0.65805161,
0.6471461058,
0.7229428887,
-0.5093774199,
1.2240530252,
-0.0839780569,
0.8041924238,
-0.6609326005,
0.2920213044,
-0.5380907655,
0.2513756454,
-0.4129422009,
-0.9288833141,
-0.3874236941,
0.6425697803,
-0.4528284967,
0.1257709414,
0.5557948947,
0.6917808652,
-0.4969866276,
-0.1694603562,
0.3305371702,
0.1893190444,
0.4396439195,
0.8259093165,
0.9371737242,
-0.5658946633,
0.5256572962,
0.2298965454,
0.06984061,
-0.2377804965,
-0.9271327853,
-1.1643881798,
-0.2683759332,
-0.5551493168,
-0.5597993135,
-0.1493500024,
1.1301553249,
0.7814442515,
-1.0717190504,
0.0090279626,
-0.2625108957,
0.1996740103,
0.0586351939,
-0.324226886,
-0.0507118143,
-0.1597109884,
-0.8565431237,
0.5191061497,
0.1133317947,
0.4514959455,
-0.192902863,
0.176232174,
-0.1333176643,
0.1681095511,
0.7999023795,
0.4792063236,
-0.7197075486,
-0.527769506,
-0.5533420444,
0.1916417927,
0.1137157455,
1.1285020113,
-0.8243308663,
0.1742341071,
0.5636966825,
0.5395234227,
0.2814647853,
0.1557864845,
0.5529949665,
-1.1318856478,
0.3793317378,
0.27309075,
0.5087467432,
0.6930708885,
-0.1828619987,
0.5683249235,
0.5370622277,
-0.1292409301,
-1.1445991993,
0.7323878407,
-0.5781801939,
-0.160364151,
1.1200950146,
-0.148424536,
-0.0232729577,
-0.1526835859,
-0.0831013694,
-0.1673489064,
-0.4144437909,
0.9126967192,
1.0379936695,
-0.2395991832,
-0.1947625428,
-0.6514359117,
0.7144808173,
0.2083792835,
-1.1050339937,
0.2978008389,
1.1331597567,
0.5429430008,
0.2666988075,
0.4389759004,
-0.0056101494,
0.2856170535,
-0.1760665029,
-0.2300333232,
0.1881918609,
-0.2551757097,
-0.5459346771,
0.1791066974,
-0.1729566455,
-0.0128043247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09550v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09550v1
|
A Speed Odyssey for Deployable Quantization of LLMs
| 2023-11-16T04:11:19 | 2023-11-16T04:11:19 |
Qingyuan Li, Ran Meng, Yiduo Li, Bo Zhang, Liang Li, Yifan Lu, Xiangxiang Chu, Yerui Sun, Yuchen Xie
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
The large language model era urges faster and less costly inference. Prior
model compression works on LLMs tend to undertake a software-centric approach
primarily focused on the simulated quantization performance. By neglecting the
feasibility of deployment, these approaches are typically disabled in real
practice. They used to drastically push down the quantization bit range for a
reduced computation which might not be supported by the mainstream hardware, or
involve sophisticated algorithms that introduce extra computation or memory
access overhead. We argue that pursuing a hardware-centric approach in the
construction of quantization algorithms is crucial. In this regard, we are
driven to build our compression method on top of hardware awareness,
eliminating impractical algorithm choices while maximizing the benefit of
hardware acceleration. Our method, OdysseyLLM, comes with a novel W4A8 kernel
implementation called FastGEMM and a combined recipe of quantization
strategies. Extensive experiments manifest the superiority of our W4A8 method
which brings the actual speed boosting up to \textbf{4$\times$} compared to
Hugging Face FP16 inference and \textbf{2.23$\times$} vs. the state-of-the-art
inference engine TensorRT-LLM in FP16, and \textbf{1.45$\times$} vs.
TensorRT-LLM in INT8, yet without substantially harming the performance.
|
[
-0.5643232465,
-0.5790919065,
1.0161715746,
0.2605379522,
-0.4301358163,
0.0852417722,
-0.1751683652,
-0.3183967471,
0.1640648544,
0.4720109105,
-0.5059533715,
-0.5433533788,
-0.5971423388,
0.159488827,
-0.1505791694,
0.5146926641,
-0.1877207458,
-0.295786798,
-0.31278795,
-0.4005393088,
-0.3059339225,
-0.5171878934,
-0.5249646902,
0.1437623948,
0.5307518244,
0.2243006825,
0.5756726861,
0.8278606534,
0.4747371376,
0.4236872494,
-0.2956463099,
0.0516539514,
-0.2137874365,
0.2780799866,
0.3527563512,
-0.8681178689,
-0.741725564,
-0.1509931535,
0.7965941429,
0.3985511959,
-0.3788941503,
0.3448895812,
-0.2078131288,
0.9667447805,
-1.0287208557,
-0.1474360824,
-0.403439343,
0.3418605626,
-0.4636271298,
-0.2481945604,
-0.4176890552,
-0.5203183293,
-0.357781589,
-0.9338197708,
0.0172060709,
0.3067625165,
0.283326298,
0.3418836594,
-0.4941002429,
0.019546289,
-0.8385460973,
0.8961808085,
-0.7715929151,
0.5438787937,
-0.138134405,
0.383302778,
-0.2194865346,
-0.9192990065,
-0.5639224052,
0.1427941769,
0.3877236843,
-0.1656312495,
-0.3714703918,
0.373290211,
0.6139235497,
0.6718412042,
-0.7158994079,
0.1062448099,
-0.2946420312,
-0.2829070389,
0.3657771945,
0.2494504303,
0.0342036895,
0.2972491384,
-0.2961494327,
-0.2138296962,
-1.0133658648,
-0.1813445091,
0.5099467039,
0.0045803408,
-0.0667502955,
0.4271708727,
-0.3053634763,
0.706399262,
-0.050111074,
-0.3531248868,
0.2880659401,
0.0370637961,
-0.1899331957,
0.182967633,
0.6935886741,
0.2718464434,
-0.055256635,
-0.0084131239,
-0.3844928741,
0.4860096276,
0.397464484,
-1.1220921278,
0.0313684493,
0.3417651057,
-0.4991936684,
0.0376038477,
-0.4159950614,
-0.7262528539,
-0.1054211259,
-0.1594503969,
0.588786602,
-0.3977623284,
-0.2008063197,
0.2474152148,
-0.0608999692,
0.0337032266,
0.2674951255,
-0.6615154743,
0.1377377063,
1.0399628878,
1.1498217583,
0.0373237915,
0.0959282145,
-0.7548341155,
0.0800082684,
-0.5187932253,
0.6397349834,
-0.3179920316,
-0.3028147221,
-0.0277609825,
-0.1598276049,
0.3550581932,
-0.5259519219,
0.5522642732,
-0.7146831155,
-0.1018076986,
-0.1285186559,
-0.8304641843,
-0.273733139,
0.1687075198,
-0.5893306136,
0.7064399123,
0.0167906582,
-0.6986032128,
0.2447266132,
-0.4127210081,
-0.2517204881,
0.2225003839,
-0.0438965037,
-0.4954495132,
0.7055375576,
0.1808393002,
0.3582395613,
-0.2053773254,
0.0564155467,
-0.5840392709,
-0.7437357306,
-0.1814004332,
-0.3773979843,
0.5685795546,
0.55744946,
-0.3786873519,
-0.0406929776,
-0.6929396987,
0.0152213033,
-0.1348049492,
-0.2350455672,
-0.5104327798,
-0.0944103971,
-0.4167765379,
-0.059674453,
0.2593100369,
-0.545715034,
0.4395048022,
-0.473772496,
0.4219969809,
0.8640991449,
-0.3167301416,
0.5022587776,
-0.1366010308,
0.9349995852,
-0.1298163086,
0.3489150107,
-0.2053732127,
-0.5368417501,
-0.7424808741,
-0.5096901655,
0.1652814597,
0.378603071,
-0.8494237065,
0.1592643708,
-0.3518248796,
-0.499247551,
-0.567235291,
-0.001389869,
0.5095539689,
0.3478556275,
0.1608990431,
-0.4170074463,
-0.4664317369,
-0.9342435598,
-0.2822741866,
-0.2546417117,
-0.0810586438,
0.1267202944,
0.0082290582,
-0.1928773522,
0.5933967829,
-0.6327735186,
0.112776719,
-0.1105345041,
0.207266286,
0.315492183,
0.6380060315,
0.2949514687,
-0.5110861063,
-0.0876245722,
-0.2921923399,
-0.7637031674,
-0.1206226349,
0.3514655232,
-0.25901106,
0.2561064959,
0.4483295679,
-0.7209227085,
0.3835771084,
0.82301718,
-0.2307229042,
0.5070585608,
-0.4176371396,
0.2695925236,
-1.0371521711,
-0.2021038979,
0.0063710068,
-0.5097588897,
-0.4039919674,
0.3956790864,
0.144733578,
-0.0397372358,
-0.5864362717,
0.4316533804,
-0.4782825112,
-0.3273266554,
-0.3098383546,
-0.0857746229,
0.1380859315,
0.2886716723,
-0.0551412217,
1.1050130129,
0.4884403944,
-0.8349168897,
0.2291059643,
-0.029649118,
-0.4220269322,
0.7214916945,
-0.5725128651,
0.1759831309,
-0.1150988266,
0.3876466751,
-0.5011526346,
0.364811331,
-0.0531220585,
-0.0675476715,
0.2493382841,
-0.2454670519,
-0.6475169063,
-0.2996590137,
-0.5007169843,
0.9487600923,
0.96369344,
-0.5846598148,
0.7498640418,
0.3479649723,
0.1636656225,
-0.3040835559,
-0.6057255268,
0.1254116595,
-0.751208365,
-0.7322689891,
0.3031423986,
-0.3754491508,
-0.2981619835,
-0.2874486744,
-0.1143010855,
0.2256301045,
0.2317617089,
0.2613120675,
0.0545717813,
-0.5795856714,
-0.0600397997,
0.0953732058,
-0.3473229408,
-0.053582605,
-0.7371120453,
0.2878522873,
-0.2947996259,
-0.0646783262,
-0.4241035879,
0.264578253,
0.4619060159,
-0.0339327604,
0.5807084441,
0.6420682669,
-0.2177776545,
-0.1609144807,
-0.7477762699,
-0.2401262969,
-0.5835472345,
0.0890937969,
-0.4066285789,
-1.2887903452,
0.2959714234,
-0.4589012563,
0.0758566782,
0.2858249843,
0.4868672788,
0.0691939294,
1.1572436094,
0.7205067873,
-0.0620321669,
0.3722562492,
-0.2196021527,
0.327660054,
-0.9789247513,
0.1146498397,
-0.4335246682,
-0.4656022191,
-0.7835559845,
-0.5605909824,
0.7903629541,
0.0332189575,
-0.275357455,
0.3684644699,
-0.4983133972,
0.1346208155,
0.6077343822,
0.0149082895,
0.3745911717,
-0.0791851431,
0.0258789957,
-0.0997636691,
-0.830552578,
-0.1696529984,
1.0702005625,
0.1995811015,
0.8369761705,
0.24862656,
0.7698571682,
0.2773005068,
0.2399191856,
-0.5846453905,
0.715166688,
-0.0779218674,
-0.2205091864,
-0.0412731059,
-0.7466778755,
-0.8994948268,
0.2210236639,
-0.0069158007,
-0.6507092714,
0.1209167466,
0.4727690518,
-0.5956997275,
0.4076367021,
-0.6239801049,
0.7722095847,
0.0919535458,
-0.3052859008,
-0.5179620385,
-0.5125697851,
0.7570344806,
0.0450244695,
0.4902154505,
-0.3219538331,
-0.2776152492,
0.7558044195,
-0.8623376489,
0.4310247898,
-0.1676342487,
-0.2283034772,
0.2551149428,
0.283582598,
0.569942534,
-0.0865326673,
0.0855142176,
0.2510087192,
0.0994932875,
-0.4691581726,
-0.7797858119,
0.831079185,
-0.3783676624,
-0.6287295222,
-0.3752509952,
-0.6379810572,
-0.2857367694,
-0.2220162749,
0.0836884454,
0.6994332075,
0.3322762847,
-0.1553506553,
0.8466476202,
-0.2530619204,
0.5138894916,
0.5632063746,
-0.21252352,
-0.4848271608,
1.0625331402,
-0.1067237481,
0.2607970834,
0.4183349013,
0.2909231484,
-0.2031860799,
-0.7005147338,
-0.4192403555,
0.2860605121,
-0.4429060817,
-0.4216073751,
-0.4690173864,
0.1868700236,
-0.3134227097,
-0.1963506043,
-0.7449558377,
-0.6855290532,
-0.0317666344,
0.080342114,
0.606004715,
0.5375304222,
-0.1169686243,
0.7053134441,
-0.9214943647,
0.1887143105,
0.1716818959,
0.3152468801,
-0.0211072695,
-0.5605701804,
-0.4663029909,
-0.3201001883,
-0.3958647251,
-0.4983665943,
0.3153024614,
0.239289403,
0.0306391753,
0.551522851,
0.0454610698,
0.9777176976,
-0.62825948,
0.775384903,
0.0358258709,
-0.9535477757,
0.4349424839,
0.1307203472,
0.3774627745,
0.5140779614,
0.4112967551,
-0.4910809398,
-0.4845592678,
-0.630458653,
-0.941460371,
0.3975118101,
-0.0739583299,
-0.0203392468,
0.1348627657,
0.6927947402,
-0.0071856831,
0.5693321228,
-0.3586001992,
-0.2430492342,
0.257597059,
-0.3266067207,
-0.1916435957,
-0.3802553415,
0.1300992519,
-0.141489476,
0.7323247194,
-0.270208627,
0.3515368998,
0.1109997556,
-0.1388939172,
0.1002335101,
-0.034178257,
0.5677149296,
0.4891805053,
-0.1012838185,
0.4643018544,
-0.1124308556,
-0.4161300659,
0.3628501296,
-0.0219134111,
-0.2820833325,
-0.1393954903,
0.2958619297,
1.0349622965,
0.2593508065,
-0.7461616397,
0.5799235702,
-0.3416920006,
-0.0775467083,
-0.1554724723,
0.0825411826,
-0.1496878862,
0.5679425001,
0.0929992199,
-0.1805776358,
0.4875892103,
-0.3152344525,
0.011656845,
0.6730319262,
-0.1665019244,
-0.5073278546,
0.9101065993,
0.0426367894,
-0.1842814833,
0.5283890963,
-0.3458414674,
-0.4162787497,
0.4337764382,
0.3221907914,
1.0817795992,
-0.275555104,
-0.1697306782,
0.3793286383,
0.3065313101,
-0.3279946446,
0.3011686206,
-0.3599245846,
-0.443128258,
-0.7885170579,
-0.892090261,
-0.2709900737,
-0.1753728539,
-0.4422164857,
0.2150194347,
-0.3776261806,
-0.1547486186,
-0.4057956934,
-0.1326966882,
-0.5541732907,
0.0645735189,
0.2725830674,
1.0790244341,
-0.5530967116,
0.6975297332,
0.1853938103,
0.1737431139,
-0.8126869202,
-0.2466282845,
0.050536558,
-0.8093152046,
0.2978550792,
0.1853267401,
0.1219625622,
0.2092354298,
-0.2569355667,
-0.7733286619,
1.181481719,
0.6407428384,
-0.8717675805,
-0.0002182527,
-0.1113641337,
0.1950025111,
-0.1825835407,
0.5126018524,
0.5663300157,
0.4019241929,
0.0405222364,
-0.6329241991,
0.2043135315,
0.1384054124,
0.3514633477,
0.5745910406,
-0.6598183513,
0.7064750195,
-0.1315281987,
-0.0922083333,
0.2876928747,
0.9107068777,
0.5147742629,
0.4253736436,
0.7292633653,
1.0477409363,
0.6705462337,
0.0932748392,
1.3007187843,
-0.7139784694,
0.2685289085,
0.5093904138,
-0.1195869595,
0.8126121759,
0.8084395528,
-0.4709112644,
0.4446873069,
0.7009681463,
0.5044309497,
0.4310322106,
0.3589555919,
-0.7816897035,
-0.3635110855,
0.1440630853,
-0.3202223778,
0.1808160096,
0.2273866981,
0.0242603589,
-0.033936277,
0.1193217859,
0.1646189839,
-0.3136524856,
-0.5080378056,
0.6991813779,
0.3264121711,
-0.5756276846,
0.7062071562,
0.1257257909,
0.8940762281,
-0.7365972996,
0.0916194692,
-0.364149034,
0.160793215,
0.007133503,
-0.2517425418,
0.2862876356,
-0.129946515,
0.0501216054,
-0.234930113,
0.3391307592,
-0.2380611748,
-0.6484438777,
0.0053751026,
0.2656410635,
0.3831331432,
-0.3073479831,
-0.2294610143,
0.5861625671,
-0.1656792015,
-0.357229501,
0.5608170033,
0.5587422848,
-0.1252277792,
0.734515667,
0.5036761761,
0.2389463335,
0.2305703461,
-0.228979364,
0.8156474829,
-0.5047969818,
-0.5933850408,
-1.0288492441,
0.1999125034,
0.4190484583,
-0.1362428367,
0.8408091068,
0.8133486509,
0.4197761118,
0.1545660198,
0.4770266712,
0.1744179279,
0.1429840922,
-0.8742947578,
0.228531599,
-0.876321435,
0.4186687768,
-0.2340185493,
-1.0886539221,
-0.2479966432,
0.4097502232,
0.0427784063,
0.0045779552,
0.640686214,
0.7633087039,
-0.0930771232,
-0.1064998358,
0.3925378025,
0.3021833301,
0.3116776943,
0.8909360766,
0.6369904876,
-0.3565806448,
0.4044564068,
-0.45903036,
-0.3418774903,
-0.1358918548,
-1.2693756819,
-0.2986029387,
-0.4391833544,
-0.5859897137,
-0.4015761018,
0.2422178686,
0.7212674022,
0.9315853715,
-0.3190335631,
-0.2185696959,
-0.3166308403,
0.1196513101,
-0.178128317,
-0.2058534175,
0.1580851078,
-0.3676436245,
-0.8232088089,
0.4939876199,
0.6085281968,
-0.0989687443,
-0.5725646019,
-0.2560558617,
0.4339354336,
0.1061343178,
0.644123137,
0.2697038949,
-0.4733118713,
-0.1045892686,
-0.3734756112,
0.2980369031,
0.2125786841,
1.1868524551,
-1.1802310944,
0.3361673355,
0.2766147256,
0.7277808785,
0.7614374757,
-0.1119157821,
0.7572313547,
-0.6906440258,
0.5948398709,
0.2171395421,
0.4128322303,
0.2880397141,
-0.3318143785,
0.229519397,
0.5247458816,
-0.7086193562,
-1.025184989,
0.1420787275,
-0.8360760212,
-0.0074863266,
1.0360825062,
-0.1454560161,
-0.6403570771,
0.3844496906,
0.068878673,
0.0342705213,
-0.4056446552,
0.6018661261,
0.3405324221,
-0.168824017,
-0.2721053958,
-0.6980051398,
0.5287765265,
0.4433071911,
-0.6486616135,
-0.1580693275,
0.4053361416,
0.0816185549,
-0.0564015061,
0.6872484088,
0.0961578637,
0.1695114672,
-0.0744481087,
0.329431653,
0.0372881778,
-0.1944921613,
-0.6559119225,
0.1418745369,
0.3294354975,
-0.269043535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09542v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09542v2
|
Pregnant Questions: The Importance of Pragmatic Awareness in Maternal Health Question Answering
| 2023-11-16T03:33:01 | 2024-04-02T19:42:21 |
Neha Srikanth, Rupak Sarkar, Heran Mane, Elizabeth M. Aparicio, Quynh C. Nguyen, Rachel Rudinger, Jordan Boyd-Graber
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Questions posed by information-seeking users often contain implicit false or
potentially harmful assumptions. In a high-risk domain such as maternal and
infant health, a question-answering system must recognize these pragmatic
constraints and go beyond simply answering user questions, examining them in
context to respond helpfully. To achieve this, we study assumptions and
implications, or pragmatic inferences, made when mothers ask questions about
pregnancy and infant care by collecting a dataset of 2,727 inferences from 500
questions across three diverse sources. We study how health experts naturally
address these inferences when writing answers, and illustrate that informing
existing QA pipelines with pragmatic inferences produces responses that are
more complete, mitigating the propagation of harmful beliefs.
|
[
-0.1764473468,
-0.6712886691,
0.6321166158,
0.1839722842,
-0.2509300709,
-0.5830617547,
0.2323207408,
-0.6372138262,
0.0283184052,
0.2971990108,
-0.6691282988,
-0.00578951,
-0.4779270291,
-0.2190019488,
0.0440823622,
1.1154550314,
0.1229070127,
-0.0474699438,
-0.1899217665,
0.2808924317,
-0.5762497187,
-0.3884712458,
-0.3854769766,
0.1971625835,
0.7470616698,
0.5343618393,
0.8390830159,
0.3397733569,
0.4202245176,
0.1055533439,
-0.163867265,
0.0326259024,
-0.2298610806,
0.2845856845,
-0.0559438691,
-0.6142745018,
-0.1288392544,
0.0589049608,
0.2212834805,
1.0082221031,
-0.250652492,
0.7810994387,
-0.1646155417,
0.4643858969,
-1.2404854298,
-0.2179686725,
-0.2808774412,
0.2627461553,
0.2476573735,
-0.1229462177,
-0.4285469055,
-0.5306581259,
0.5202819109,
-0.6661130786,
0.0746265724,
-0.142710343,
1.0337717533,
0.4615014493,
-0.9278638959,
-0.2333310843,
-1.0310949087,
0.5746296644,
-0.6254981756,
0.2768293917,
0.5256441236,
0.0575573221,
-0.2129141092,
-0.6490235329,
-0.4442330301,
0.2017508894,
-0.4440445602,
0.1632322967,
-0.3652538657,
0.2638165057,
0.2718441486,
0.1521939784,
-0.5205432773,
-0.2542631924,
-0.3543868363,
-0.1604720503,
0.4848025739,
-0.217866987,
0.3523885608,
0.0469764993,
-0.2804506123,
0.3456385434,
-0.8616091609,
0.135530442,
0.3185426891,
-0.4377919734,
0.1289386451,
0.5640599728,
-0.0994444788,
0.9723619819,
-0.0215922743,
-0.0219926145,
-0.1323044598,
-0.4163776934,
0.1127846912,
0.069827117,
0.0813179612,
0.8615700006,
0.4129099548,
0.152319029,
0.2567309141,
0.1629669815,
0.4995853007,
-0.5481613278,
-0.0155237727,
0.5384401679,
-0.3364173472,
0.1609604508,
0.1754123867,
-0.8504353762,
-0.4904864728,
-0.0069181393,
0.2560283244,
-0.0675030425,
-0.2293457687,
0.2564708292,
-0.4629274011,
0.239649266,
0.5535486937,
-0.330640167,
-0.2120919526,
0.5251846313,
-0.099316515,
0.4316329956,
0.2589737475,
-0.4266795218,
0.4459192157,
-0.403693527,
1.0789927244,
-0.1607589424,
-0.6153560877,
-0.0819122419,
-0.0124013619,
-0.2152462006,
-0.6087909937,
0.5342695117,
-0.436714679,
0.0867575631,
-0.7837833166,
-0.5169212818,
-0.200669691,
0.1896195114,
-0.2214853168,
0.3684008718,
-0.06216719,
-1.1368427277,
0.7028899193,
-0.1189915538,
-0.855025351,
0.2025086284,
-0.223372072,
-0.3613756597,
0.1818566173,
0.0953350067,
0.3085262179,
-0.3064834177,
0.2676119506,
-0.0103403255,
0.0088411672,
0.4305795133,
-0.1272614151,
0.5809972882,
0.1692922264,
-0.2809490263,
-0.0668895841,
-0.4617496729,
0.0597315915,
0.1058886647,
-0.3314990699,
-0.2757808268,
0.2422204316,
-0.5290874243,
0.1642904282,
0.2954108119,
-0.4570224881,
-0.2550323904,
-0.1717494726,
0.4613292217,
0.16348809,
0.8544276357,
0.0909308344,
-0.9562039375,
0.9155725837,
0.2472183108,
0.6968047023,
-0.2216285914,
-1.1334936619,
-0.4313465357,
-0.0747901127,
-0.1409858316,
0.4872184992,
-0.2244329453,
0.139592275,
0.1698084623,
-0.3689424396,
-0.7283294797,
0.0566566326,
0.7037581801,
1.1374952793,
0.2301070988,
-0.1032910198,
-0.5918706059,
-0.9291886687,
-0.4371472001,
-0.5821701288,
0.1251134276,
0.3419427276,
0.3377020657,
0.3566094637,
0.7070950866,
-0.9476750493,
0.2538443506,
-0.0334098227,
0.3448210359,
-0.0747276843,
0.5659485459,
0.5271836519,
-1.0605672598,
-0.0095101623,
-0.2857435048,
-0.4815469384,
-0.088887915,
-0.0954409242,
-0.4057367444,
-0.5027512312,
-0.0451768823,
-0.7316108942,
0.763731122,
0.3935986459,
-0.4876231253,
0.8485657573,
-0.1022625864,
-0.0736920461,
-0.9763882756,
0.0447136685,
0.1918260902,
-0.084533155,
-0.9765954614,
0.2583130002,
-0.1623382866,
0.181054756,
-0.7078795433,
0.4885931611,
-0.5257031322,
-0.0105656227,
0.2154570073,
-0.1643849313,
0.5242741704,
-0.0632443875,
0.0648389086,
0.874011457,
0.2108037174,
-0.7937195301,
-0.1986172497,
0.6119753122,
-0.1441315413,
0.5414150953,
-0.545388639,
-0.1396422088,
-0.2633667588,
0.3548535705,
-1.0148077011,
-0.3939273059,
0.2157581002,
-0.5978187919,
-0.0539311394,
-0.2225497514,
-0.4535811245,
-0.620570302,
0.1435572803,
0.2612603605,
0.5510151386,
-0.1322201937,
0.404447794,
0.720498383,
-0.1372647732,
-0.8035337329,
-0.6700145602,
-0.2247313112,
-0.091835171,
-0.4020216465,
-0.1547480822,
0.1419330388,
-0.5902846456,
0.0386155583,
-0.2234768569,
-0.4976744056,
0.465714395,
0.3975633085,
0.2791385651,
-0.2378181517,
0.3321532607,
0.1545175761,
0.0319703817,
0.271859318,
-0.170303762,
0.1977194995,
0.1544936001,
-0.3119138181,
-0.5115853548,
0.578646183,
0.1407397985,
-0.2175211161,
0.7270225883,
-0.0387039743,
-0.4867292047,
0.0871405005,
-0.7228213549,
-0.307451278,
-0.3135167956,
-0.2623669207,
0.1320233196,
-0.6612282991,
0.4544780254,
0.1492289603,
0.0712310374,
0.3220499754,
0.4119927585,
-0.6673091054,
1.246111989,
0.284321636,
0.5673264265,
0.095967114,
-0.0896805599,
0.4003105164,
-0.656365335,
-0.138155967,
-0.5178306699,
-0.0069726654,
-0.4118253589,
-0.7366882563,
0.4642947614,
-0.0833299309,
-0.4260954261,
-0.0161043797,
-0.7930161357,
0.0790821686,
0.5073486567,
0.5017430782,
0.4004713595,
-0.6057184339,
-0.0768803954,
0.0976194963,
-0.903773725,
-0.4414363205,
0.5859508514,
0.3254329264,
0.7012277246,
0.1210458651,
0.3981328607,
-0.2579179704,
0.6748586297,
-0.6271755695,
0.4350831509,
0.3342529535,
-1.3904851675,
0.1301753819,
-0.23708193,
-0.6853292584,
0.1628102511,
-0.2259074599,
-0.6210435033,
0.7917584777,
0.4007601142,
-0.8507127166,
0.0822014287,
-1.1266564131,
0.6509477496,
-0.138550207,
-0.2287866473,
0.1794520319,
-1.1283632517,
0.2827554345,
0.2349858582,
0.0028964735,
-0.361600101,
-0.1089642644,
0.7754117846,
-0.3398497105,
1.0542354584,
-0.2303738296,
0.0025293997,
0.9565820098,
-0.0863549337,
-0.0863683,
0.2015973032,
-0.1208987013,
-0.2023405582,
0.1621083468,
-0.6012898684,
-0.2736462355,
0.252546221,
-0.4777801931,
-1.1435219049,
-0.2652303576,
-0.5673385859,
-0.2721663117,
0.1369709074,
0.2367240787,
0.1893379092,
0.0736712739,
0.0526881404,
0.6728032231,
-0.3533942401,
-0.1968010068,
0.2565661967,
0.0507917218,
0.1804019809,
0.1155993119,
0.1031814516,
0.2588655949,
0.2748521566,
0.5859559178,
-0.3922017813,
-0.347014159,
-0.4073097706,
0.4132810235,
-0.9752497077,
-0.288302958,
-0.7818790674,
-0.1485801935,
-0.3215756714,
-0.2725119293,
0.1098328978,
-0.2745084465,
-0.4807356894,
-0.5413312316,
0.3823794723,
0.553753078,
0.3186252117,
0.2796143591,
-0.8914162517,
0.3817176819,
0.7741225958,
-0.1322082579,
0.0702802315,
-0.110866867,
0.3050392866,
-0.190168336,
-0.3321959972,
-1.327352643,
-0.0896220952,
-0.0536838211,
0.5626877546,
0.9570054412,
0.3029776514,
0.8527383208,
-0.2428664714,
0.7477833033,
0.2163329124,
-0.4572889209,
0.7858300209,
-0.5626881123,
0.1640233099,
0.7184159756,
0.709484756,
-0.1935872585,
-0.3850229383,
-0.7755694389,
-0.5495257378,
-0.2640446723,
0.1360727102,
-0.1441141367,
-0.3699149489,
0.6450478435,
-0.0725990683,
0.675588727,
-0.1718397886,
-0.2740532458,
0.0170074254,
-0.0129811596,
0.2305226624,
-0.5175316334,
-0.6292227507,
-0.3209297955,
0.217572853,
-0.0538015291,
0.1125469357,
0.6351774931,
-0.0653511211,
-0.1405696422,
0.4868606925,
0.6058524847,
1.1485821009,
-0.0036029213,
0.3335402906,
0.1469238102,
-0.4812375903,
0.3012510538,
0.0837763175,
-0.3888588548,
-0.1095532998,
0.6045604348,
0.3619946837,
0.5049805641,
-0.8403594494,
0.6157872081,
-0.1272430122,
-0.0397054404,
-0.3258885741,
0.0619876161,
0.5143011808,
-0.4277288914,
0.3651503325,
-0.1819479018,
0.1808378547,
-0.6852031946,
0.3729842603,
0.350086987,
-0.4268850982,
-0.320940882,
0.7631154656,
-0.0842635855,
0.0226600561,
0.3284769058,
0.4854651988,
-0.5092230439,
1.1451768875,
0.4026923478,
0.3864824176,
-0.5299454331,
0.2941963077,
0.5245330334,
0.2856452167,
0.0922028422,
0.8975659609,
0.0370879024,
-0.7332258821,
-0.5621904731,
-0.4009686112,
-0.6327677369,
-0.2810919881,
-1.0080822706,
-0.0792700574,
-0.4562658072,
-0.680392921,
0.1647487134,
-0.2484658957,
-0.7426304221,
0.7535421848,
-0.0509387553,
0.9998905659,
-0.9222502708,
0.2259065956,
1.0404398441,
-0.6086937785,
-0.9914135933,
0.2744530141,
-0.1998073012,
-0.8221688271,
0.2612352669,
0.0877307802,
-0.1842929572,
-0.1264034212,
-0.609133482,
-0.5320906639,
0.7537198067,
0.3165319264,
-0.3591946959,
-0.215384528,
-0.1022124961,
0.4298537672,
-0.2413980663,
0.2539788783,
0.5634141564,
0.7550392151,
-0.0122384941,
-0.5525812507,
0.0993924513,
-0.0137314042,
-0.0850303546,
0.054053396,
-0.1746798158,
0.5493170619,
-0.9950034022,
-0.2547617555,
-0.028533902,
0.3049266934,
0.3806363642,
0.5834506154,
0.6852503419,
0.4268042743,
0.6798890829,
-0.245396167,
1.4049649239,
-0.2930062115,
-0.0056914501,
1.0780308247,
-0.2377131134,
0.7244908214,
0.5893185735,
-0.1212634817,
0.4220847189,
0.8743414879,
0.3443563879,
0.1596145332,
0.1088603586,
-0.4525061548,
-0.2743332386,
-0.6575084925,
-0.4527989924,
0.2600082755,
0.7567490935,
-0.0579842776,
-0.1232953891,
-0.2672714591,
0.2821653783,
0.1229067743,
-0.0336968005,
0.9879639149,
0.2097390443,
-0.9592628479,
0.2589256763,
-0.438613981,
0.03942357,
-0.2541568279,
-0.2028921247,
0.0356702991,
-0.3774041235,
-0.1549500823,
-0.8995397687,
0.1655410528,
-0.0354161672,
-0.1924630851,
-0.1125299558,
0.9486287236,
-0.1072914973,
-0.41613397,
0.0418806821,
0.8299440742,
-0.0268418472,
0.0143399378,
-0.6823710203,
-0.4300062954,
-0.421615541,
-0.2915520072,
0.0359502025,
0.2097806931,
-0.2028641403,
0.7164738774,
0.8146386147,
0.5131562352,
0.4451164603,
-0.2823188901,
0.7659090161,
-0.3425267637,
-0.7432301044,
-0.2972299159,
0.6468784213,
0.010740703,
-0.4642104506,
0.664080739,
0.0228928905,
0.3676424026,
-0.0231433678,
0.7627151012,
0.1342405975,
0.6539646983,
-0.149867475,
0.6017546058,
-0.4053619802,
-0.2915188074,
0.1283383667,
-0.2269138545,
-0.3827219903,
0.4936479032,
-0.822245121,
0.2250301242,
0.6308432817,
0.3411542475,
0.3115241528,
0.3046470881,
0.0797861218,
0.3443864286,
0.1245020255,
0.4164312482,
1.0854375362,
-0.0462251008,
0.1496450603,
-0.4308962226,
-0.1474511474,
-0.4156385958,
-1.0216115713,
-0.2781945765,
-0.2834545374,
-0.4732502997,
-0.5979113579,
0.274556458,
0.461612016,
0.8039618134,
-0.7166801691,
0.2477271259,
-0.0279285517,
0.5279160142,
-0.4565545917,
-0.2680754364,
0.1633175761,
0.1564055681,
-0.3002480865,
-0.0588211007,
0.0883029401,
-0.0040516909,
0.0261643566,
0.5579943657,
-0.652687788,
0.2030051351,
0.0223724507,
0.5653271675,
-0.2488940954,
-0.3477941155,
-0.4087918699,
-0.1067268252,
0.2432249635,
0.8846248388,
-0.4660924375,
0.3180499077,
0.5561053753,
0.4726757407,
-0.0985941067,
0.5230748057,
0.7201228142,
-0.6524910331,
0.249243781,
0.7515274286,
0.2775517404,
0.368378669,
-1.0164813995,
0.175270915,
0.0250669122,
-0.4205393195,
-0.7027317882,
0.5462447405,
-0.6557178497,
-0.3242630363,
1.0798009634,
-0.4373334348,
-0.3593706787,
-0.4244666398,
-0.050001055,
0.3402672112,
-0.1260573715,
0.4936811924,
0.616995275,
-0.160243988,
-0.1599533856,
-1.2084585428,
0.4758930206,
0.7503581643,
-0.9359995723,
-0.069096826,
0.1948469281,
0.4652022421,
0.0120325228,
0.7450423241,
0.052607093,
0.7071852684,
-0.1472142935,
-0.0116849104,
0.5028554797,
-0.2885306776,
-0.0607913174,
0.1942861229,
0.2970138788,
-0.3008768559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09538v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09538v3
|
Reducing Privacy Risks in Online Self-Disclosures with Language Models
| 2023-11-16T03:28:43 | 2024-06-24T02:11:44 |
Yao Dou, Isadora Krsek, Tarek Naous, Anubha Kabra, Sauvik Das, Alan Ritter, Wei Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Self-disclosure, while being common and rewarding in social media
interaction, also poses privacy risks. In this paper, we take the initiative to
protect the user-side privacy associated with online self-disclosure through
detection and abstraction. We develop a taxonomy of 19 self-disclosure
categories and curate a large corpus consisting of 4.8K annotated disclosure
spans. We then fine-tune a language model for detection, achieving over 65%
partial span F$_1$. We further conduct an HCI user study, with 82% of
participants viewing the model positively, highlighting its real-world
applicability. Motivated by the user feedback, we introduce the task of
self-disclosure abstraction, which is rephrasing disclosures into less specific
terms while preserving their utility, e.g., "Im 16F" to "I'm a teenage girl".
We explore various fine-tuning strategies, and our best model can generate
diverse abstractions that moderately reduce privacy risks while maintaining
high utility according to human evaluation. To help users in deciding which
disclosures to abstract, we present a task of rating their importance for
context understanding. Our fine-tuned model achieves 80% accuracy, on-par with
GPT-3.5. Given safety and privacy considerations, we will only release our
corpus and models to researcher who agree to the ethical guidelines outlined in
Ethics Statement.
|
[
-0.3174028993,
-0.548289001,
0.499637723,
0.7108340859,
0.1625881642,
-0.0483685918,
-0.0528230071,
-0.9878226519,
-0.0242848992,
0.4481332898,
-0.6199864149,
-0.5880525708,
-0.5621245503,
-0.0142418854,
-0.6334557533,
0.9026674032,
0.0684285536,
-0.3930452168,
-0.2811771631,
0.2113275528,
-0.1660486758,
-0.4395883679,
-0.5192069411,
0.0805664286,
0.4595936835,
0.3076029718,
0.246577099,
0.8525756001,
0.3253564239,
0.3071246445,
-0.1998898536,
-0.3208057284,
-0.5658311248,
0.1259412766,
-0.4792342484,
-0.0517790578,
-0.541939795,
0.0421133935,
0.2414754033,
0.307611376,
-0.1585938334,
0.4836655259,
0.1805522144,
0.6926380396,
-1.09783113,
0.0527972989,
-0.0528150499,
-0.1638404578,
-0.0659274757,
-0.052241046,
-0.4577156007,
-0.1367907822,
0.0451263189,
-0.4200841486,
0.1313991696,
-0.1969342083,
0.4937769175,
0.0966742039,
-0.3259535432,
-0.1005685255,
-0.7269860506,
0.5348525047,
-0.5008382201,
0.2871784568,
0.9157372117,
0.4374982417,
0.4281485975,
-0.71508044,
-0.1800825745,
0.0375933982,
-0.3257619143,
-0.1769205928,
-0.4966399074,
0.2080087215,
0.060576044,
0.2481051534,
-0.5635638237,
0.2181973606,
-0.3899916708,
-0.5498773456,
0.8289188743,
0.0667600855,
0.2122726142,
-0.1893596798,
-0.3266707361,
0.0893161148,
-0.6155369282,
-0.0089405328,
0.640019238,
0.1202957034,
-0.3839937747,
0.3350374401,
-0.6252154112,
0.4040289521,
0.3387153745,
0.0210253131,
0.1277393699,
-0.6845462322,
0.0698534176,
0.0198788084,
0.7079489827,
0.5592516661,
0.1777821183,
-0.2523259819,
-0.1547110677,
-0.0842070132,
0.1953491271,
-0.9995287657,
-0.2496778816,
0.3863082826,
-0.7719634175,
-0.2990817726,
-0.098972477,
-0.3636688292,
-0.5337288976,
-0.2849991024,
0.5456357002,
-0.3250428736,
-0.2002474219,
0.1096036509,
0.269731164,
-0.1447505504,
0.3048092127,
-1.0897008181,
0.674451828,
0.584751308,
0.8187264204,
0.0431084037,
-0.1314497739,
-0.2934952676,
0.3489476144,
-0.0425950065,
0.6525422931,
-0.2728972137,
-0.3194800019,
-0.0865323395,
-0.080145061,
0.2028611153,
-0.3010624945,
0.1723631471,
-0.2177484185,
0.0829082131,
-0.0467776358,
-0.665342629,
0.020130327,
0.0285670348,
-0.4470106959,
0.4519920647,
-0.0431254432,
-0.9051824808,
0.0585672408,
-0.7380737662,
-0.3317182362,
0.1116891727,
-0.0683915913,
-0.2571608722,
-0.0349069871,
0.3453258574,
0.4857575297,
0.2749822438,
-0.0084420359,
-0.2601722777,
-0.3331619501,
0.1986131966,
-0.2328600734,
0.8225319982,
0.5680673122,
-0.2806935012,
0.2748036087,
-0.5959632993,
0.0109174997,
-0.2423970252,
0.0015803073,
-0.4524499774,
-0.4239923358,
0.2332154363,
0.2800324559,
0.6624042988,
-0.5298711658,
-0.3448393345,
-0.4117133617,
0.5857770443,
0.7814895511,
0.0657231361,
0.7392475605,
-0.1506347656,
0.5135563016,
0.0920843631,
0.4994473755,
-0.2020128965,
-0.2623251975,
-0.185275957,
-0.4293967187,
0.6720102429,
0.3066563606,
0.0512995459,
0.6781544089,
-0.0133446623,
-0.4761174619,
-0.7389563918,
0.24684003,
0.4618585706,
0.2636616528,
0.0621958226,
-0.0229785014,
-0.2629478574,
-1.2561362982,
-0.645062685,
-0.0405595489,
-0.1901767254,
0.3875147402,
0.169817239,
-0.3530513346,
0.9851522446,
-0.4766807854,
-0.4667645395,
-0.0296835154,
0.4272446036,
-0.2712965012,
0.699622333,
0.4294900596,
-0.9060996771,
-0.5271505713,
-0.3256745636,
-0.6270049214,
-0.1652303785,
-0.122628063,
0.0512824804,
0.1326501817,
0.5587708354,
-0.4782539904,
0.8030596972,
0.5400282741,
-0.4473322034,
-0.0267698728,
-0.4786189198,
-0.1122495681,
-0.8620342612,
-0.033531215,
0.2520791888,
-0.7255374789,
-0.6155224442,
0.2752176523,
0.371034801,
-0.1056409404,
-0.7544694543,
0.8208141923,
-0.6771028638,
0.1118669808,
-0.4286958575,
-0.1718381494,
-0.1507577449,
0.1827481538,
-0.1009811088,
0.6288779378,
0.7461428046,
-0.8123047948,
-0.4615443349,
0.2389807701,
-0.2480068356,
0.2593345344,
-0.5020368695,
0.4180660248,
-0.2201269716,
0.2453233302,
-0.7873470783,
-0.3477715254,
0.6266723871,
-0.5636878014,
0.0219865367,
-0.0571050197,
-0.3979460597,
0.103602156,
-0.6409775615,
0.5424137115,
0.0985002443,
-0.2999860346,
0.8047087193,
0.7930503488,
-0.2969198525,
-0.5350108743,
-0.9242458344,
0.1297871023,
-0.1519235224,
-0.7365577221,
0.6840165257,
-0.3805341423,
-0.2166891992,
0.0234689713,
-0.0848685578,
-0.3967557549,
0.3265914321,
0.6065559387,
-0.1086349338,
0.4301027954,
0.1233647764,
0.0966305882,
-0.3534581065,
0.078731209,
0.2243647128,
0.4181683064,
-0.4810648859,
0.0232157521,
-0.8751176,
0.5510850549,
-0.0598590039,
-0.0669789761,
0.7435404658,
0.6436182261,
-0.6608948708,
0.2629346251,
-0.53694731,
-0.4287539423,
-0.548144877,
-0.1663626134,
-0.3015629351,
-1.1656996012,
0.8501922488,
0.1228617728,
0.0293753222,
0.1532610208,
0.5724260211,
-0.1160209924,
0.9849401116,
1.0652347803,
0.0010841915,
0.3777074218,
-0.014148253,
0.4944123626,
-0.5218324065,
0.0190211479,
-0.3393779397,
-0.2809353471,
-0.9848495722,
0.0080182096,
0.1948821992,
-0.1642661095,
0.0652495548,
0.3927785754,
-0.5011405945,
0.6643689275,
0.490183562,
0.5488989949,
0.4770381153,
-0.2554732263,
0.5917548537,
0.0362446047,
-0.1771820486,
-0.4662346244,
1.0786948204,
0.6808108687,
1.1375944614,
0.3728888333,
1.3209245205,
0.6559790373,
0.2038100213,
-0.5236434937,
0.5128031373,
0.1037463099,
-0.992875278,
-0.3671294153,
-0.5073892474,
-0.89198488,
0.1142158732,
0.1193309203,
-1.2263095379,
0.4354786873,
0.3829769194,
-0.7424429059,
-0.3825672567,
-0.7676900625,
0.9049797654,
0.1420905143,
-0.5169669986,
-0.413474828,
-1.0215247869,
0.5372342467,
-0.1245132759,
0.4853115976,
-0.245167166,
-0.0520826802,
0.605093956,
-0.3274860978,
1.2013782263,
0.0560490415,
-0.0457221046,
0.3209605217,
0.3759506941,
0.3664983511,
0.1897867918,
0.3222123086,
0.1681153923,
0.1900969744,
-0.0802005827,
-0.3732137382,
0.9656907916,
-0.4744077921,
-0.5670660734,
-0.4148490131,
-0.5300708413,
-0.0586397201,
0.3268301189,
0.3831326663,
0.158483997,
-0.1194596291,
0.1521294713,
0.7265531421,
-0.103756845,
0.5355455279,
0.4512852132,
-0.3125362992,
-0.0292673502,
0.8679966331,
0.01033781,
0.1536270976,
0.0738768578,
0.5748333335,
-0.7502900362,
-0.2665601969,
-0.1115352884,
0.4168359637,
-1.0426361561,
-0.138535589,
-0.8726661205,
-0.2323339283,
-0.9054123163,
0.0406807214,
-0.3142221272,
-0.6940265298,
-0.352501899,
-0.350838393,
0.2403111309,
0.6659552455,
-0.6450968385,
0.4156886935,
-0.6694635153,
0.4919902682,
0.2502962649,
0.3227053881,
-0.1901261657,
-0.3982043862,
-0.0811028555,
-0.1416738331,
-0.1257528067,
-0.7276992202,
0.3961088359,
0.2028184086,
0.2788909972,
0.3461460471,
0.342625469,
0.4414669871,
-0.2158843577,
0.4114167392,
0.0586991273,
-1.2112575769,
0.5263636112,
-0.4825778902,
0.004876046,
0.8599478006,
0.4123668075,
-0.4606895149,
-0.3360918462,
-0.9129799604,
-1.1088708639,
0.5803160667,
0.3638902605,
0.4380877316,
0.0690666437,
0.2407611161,
0.0041009984,
0.3577560782,
-1.1837911606,
-0.3727711141,
-0.0738748536,
-0.1590684056,
0.3516978025,
-0.2893693149,
-0.2768343985,
-0.2502608001,
0.2616618872,
0.0375844873,
0.149961248,
0.0768304691,
-0.1991054714,
0.046790868,
0.2800503969,
0.3906350732,
0.9635592103,
-0.1545946002,
0.1497263461,
-0.3613864481,
-0.3014752865,
0.1110558435,
0.0543785952,
-0.3529030979,
-0.2544234395,
-0.0204163436,
0.1900396347,
0.3034850657,
-0.3898117542,
0.7559998631,
-0.2361658812,
0.0069034263,
-0.3741116524,
-0.0348277949,
0.3477748334,
-0.1447779238,
0.0199724361,
0.0270445403,
0.9319665432,
-0.5096353292,
0.3012625873,
0.0812291354,
-0.2954190671,
-0.1895159334,
0.6573160887,
0.2832686901,
-0.326272577,
0.1217686236,
-0.1856799424,
-0.0471878685,
0.237449795,
0.3939192891,
1.0028886795,
-0.6583076715,
0.4120079577,
0.1987974495,
0.197343275,
-0.1176877171,
0.1986966878,
-0.2972173989,
-0.4251947701,
-0.1260870099,
-0.3904570639,
-0.2477105558,
0.2457569391,
-0.8873758316,
0.0366608314,
-0.7565149069,
-0.2198108435,
0.3875081539,
-0.5300620794,
-0.4963000417,
0.0544849969,
0.0711395517,
0.7584450841,
-0.7780240774,
0.4728601277,
0.194846645,
-0.2921444178,
-0.5804509521,
0.0935555547,
0.2816906869,
-0.2485205233,
0.5563908815,
0.5476498008,
-0.3575552106,
-0.020459922,
-0.500033617,
-0.6718922257,
0.7660846114,
0.4419940114,
-0.7244226336,
0.0230813529,
0.1126857176,
0.5698114634,
-0.3359952271,
-0.0045345738,
0.3615437746,
0.4895706773,
-0.1233799309,
-0.9135414362,
0.2312428951,
0.1133758277,
0.0651063174,
-0.1133251339,
-0.4336192906,
0.8376922011,
-0.1409137696,
-0.6330874562,
0.0471713431,
0.7181337476,
-0.0107765524,
0.4321634769,
0.4392374754,
0.2016024888,
0.5330278277,
0.4259319305,
1.083532691,
-0.5130054951,
0.2911126614,
1.2611494064,
-0.02991038,
0.8309088349,
0.2611520886,
0.1846016943,
0.329980284,
0.8542507291,
0.4966851175,
0.7474345565,
0.2630817592,
-0.4250003397,
-0.4123136699,
-0.3024459183,
-0.2082407624,
0.3739179373,
0.3710324168,
-0.5223716497,
-0.3928900361,
-0.0048768357,
0.1790153235,
0.3402997255,
-0.3143087924,
0.7480523586,
0.1568593085,
-0.340247184,
0.1540602446,
0.1316468567,
0.6253020763,
-0.4450410604,
0.1068597212,
-0.1404736638,
0.2162414491,
-0.4282076359,
-0.7455819249,
0.4333663583,
-0.0500268228,
-0.1162820384,
-0.3705930114,
1.0046005249,
-0.4148680568,
-0.3897028267,
0.448805511,
0.5139403343,
0.1448282003,
-0.508508265,
-0.7647570372,
-0.0971332192,
-0.2640362084,
-0.1165994406,
0.5964457393,
0.0622281171,
-0.0861746222,
0.9372366667,
0.4842512608,
-0.2699432075,
-0.2010870427,
0.2427939326,
0.6885854006,
-0.7015115023,
-0.9924511313,
-0.9417617917,
0.3963176608,
-0.1109836698,
-0.1845815778,
0.7828293443,
0.4067294002,
0.7417660952,
0.0369308181,
0.6419695616,
0.0667648688,
0.590582788,
-0.4371879697,
0.9417493343,
-0.2161462754,
0.3946658671,
-0.1774277687,
-0.4202332795,
-0.1200475097,
0.5569061041,
-0.2402503043,
0.084265776,
0.3340455592,
0.7730993629,
0.0125285545,
-0.0557699725,
0.2560835183,
0.2056404948,
0.2313699275,
0.1535224319,
0.5969164371,
-0.2849719822,
0.2917943895,
-0.6481773853,
-0.3076532185,
-0.2373379022,
-1.0044062138,
-0.9070584178,
-0.5892730951,
-0.5505346656,
-0.2508567274,
-0.089715831,
0.6007164717,
0.9476549029,
-0.6482367516,
-0.2735666931,
0.0952239409,
-0.0890445486,
-0.1593961865,
-0.2168489099,
0.1638219357,
0.0786699727,
-0.4717562497,
0.4324341118,
0.3015452325,
0.2258153856,
-0.5264397264,
0.1179387346,
-0.1376408637,
0.0206361096,
0.3986761868,
0.4159514606,
-0.6634458899,
-0.3970954418,
-0.0330872796,
-0.2511464059,
0.0169780143,
0.6824335456,
-0.4015927613,
0.4383399189,
0.3977094293,
0.5631081462,
0.8209885359,
0.407171607,
0.4336899221,
-0.88796103,
-0.061464373,
0.2866744995,
0.0885128975,
0.4406168461,
-1.1139754057,
0.5521847606,
-0.3135079145,
-0.4434936047,
-0.6130055785,
0.1787794679,
-0.9071994424,
-0.573979795,
0.8933645487,
-0.210104987,
-0.3959470093,
-0.4145585299,
0.0517740101,
-0.1241509691,
-0.5892733335,
1.0932735205,
0.6547899246,
-0.3244117796,
-0.1898477972,
-0.3806583285,
0.7654995322,
0.0532493256,
-0.7965770364,
0.5474871397,
0.3910084963,
0.6502710581,
0.3416098356,
0.9763507247,
-0.2070792168,
0.4521147013,
-0.3301927745,
-0.02703139,
-0.1354717761,
-0.5412911773,
-0.5494155288,
-0.060185343,
-0.1274012327,
-0.2426182777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09533v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09533v3
|
Effective Large Language Model Adaptation for Improved Grounding and Citation Generation
| 2023-11-16T03:22:25 | 2024-04-02T20:04:01 |
Xi Ye, Ruoxi Sun, Sercan Ö. Arik, Tomas Pfister
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable advancements in natural
language understanding and generation. However, one major issue towards their
widespread deployment in the real world is that they can generate
"hallucinated" answers that are not factual. Towards this end, this paper
focuses on improving LLMs by grounding their responses in retrieved passages
and by providing citations. We propose a new framework, AGREE, Adaptation for
GRounding EnhancEment, that improves the grounding from a holistic perspective.
Our framework tunes LLMs to selfground the claims in their responses and
provide accurate citations to retrieved documents. This tuning on top of the
pre-trained LLMs requires well-grounded responses (with citations) for paired
queries, for which we introduce a method that can automatically construct such
data from unlabeled queries. The selfgrounding capability of tuned LLMs further
grants them a test-time adaptation (TTA) capability that can actively retrieve
passages to support the claims that have not been grounded, which iteratively
improves the responses of LLMs. Across five datasets and two LLMs, our results
show that the proposed tuningbased AGREE framework generates superior grounded
responses with more accurate citations compared to prompting-based approaches
and post-hoc citing-based approaches
|
[
-0.248565793,
-0.6513920426,
0.8531479239,
0.5705100298,
-0.3747865856,
0.0159360506,
-0.4516922534,
-0.3069129586,
0.1993256509,
0.4687872231,
-0.0575565845,
-0.436347425,
-0.5230906606,
0.1017447487,
-0.1888132095,
0.7964859605,
0.2671773434,
0.0280776154,
-0.2840306759,
-0.3751242757,
-0.8428274393,
-0.5812066197,
-0.3779388964,
-0.4381894171,
0.3788826466,
0.3629719317,
0.6080223918,
0.2767068446,
0.3984144628,
0.193743214,
-0.0698434487,
0.3063554764,
-0.4681029618,
0.4340030849,
-0.7561869025,
-0.2711398005,
-0.4707607627,
-0.1500488371,
0.5952347517,
0.7010248303,
0.0311743654,
0.0868275911,
0.1987512261,
0.7427774072,
-0.621090889,
-0.0434803031,
-1.2115265131,
-0.1307750344,
0.1559109092,
-0.6064978242,
-0.7851715684,
-0.2079489082,
-0.0598092116,
-0.7089434266,
0.1335369498,
0.1453656107,
0.7106962204,
0.3918456733,
-0.4331617653,
-0.2148543,
-0.4788847268,
0.5020824075,
-0.9163841605,
0.3457668126,
0.2837678492,
0.1530913413,
-0.5043994188,
-0.3742260337,
-0.3523879945,
-0.3697312474,
-0.1034443825,
0.2638896406,
0.0830820799,
-0.0661331788,
0.3035645783,
0.215822503,
-0.4107884169,
0.1413360387,
0.1573309451,
-0.0714548975,
0.5035102367,
-0.2319206148,
-0.0511455387,
-0.3357426226,
-0.162656799,
-0.0230249986,
-0.6439350843,
-0.226302579,
-0.0579793192,
0.628495872,
-0.0134906536,
0.6744180918,
-0.1755665839,
0.7197145224,
0.6874294281,
0.0685529783,
0.3057614863,
-0.019546859,
-0.3701269329,
0.2088884413,
0.4507862628,
0.5123097301,
0.3308807611,
-0.5991466045,
-0.0996665955,
-0.2099930793,
0.3457093239,
-0.823906064,
-0.0305865686,
0.2448764443,
-0.3757963479,
-0.2243037224,
0.0934927389,
-0.7686650753,
-0.8172445297,
-0.665564537,
0.3780335486,
-0.2993641794,
-0.3302711844,
0.164177388,
0.0410142578,
0.3739780784,
0.4290510118,
-0.6878327727,
0.1864350885,
0.5044139028,
0.9604024887,
-0.0648511723,
-0.1747443676,
-1.0170012712,
0.452501446,
-0.4442063272,
0.9702296853,
-0.4450955987,
-0.3202998936,
0.0291618966,
0.1565753371,
-0.0745595023,
-0.6141875982,
0.8145902157,
-0.8083436489,
0.1215302721,
-0.5507705808,
-0.4157109559,
0.1674931198,
0.4629437327,
-0.4494938254,
1.1236615181,
0.0005984076,
-0.7969136238,
0.3263840377,
-0.6851682067,
-0.5087692142,
-0.1205805987,
-0.0084540183,
-0.2767228484,
0.428132236,
0.4176301658,
0.3966583908,
-0.2841353714,
0.7055847645,
-0.5629505515,
-0.060350433,
0.1829246581,
-0.0491044298,
0.6681511402,
0.3709529936,
-0.5089087486,
0.3351083398,
-1.1026620865,
0.1116258502,
0.0851599798,
-0.317422688,
-0.5716448426,
0.2435440272,
0.0632345527,
0.2177035213,
0.0124747017,
-0.2113583982,
0.0798208937,
-0.4970905185,
0.2931287885,
0.8312529922,
0.1230584905,
0.469904542,
-0.2872786224,
0.0800346211,
-0.0062235654,
-0.598325491,
-0.1609908044,
0.0241344664,
-0.8065951467,
0.0189328305,
0.2308235019,
0.2710023224,
-0.4452168047,
0.967566371,
-0.8440203667,
-0.3682253957,
-0.2453600466,
0.2721587121,
0.0179398917,
0.7818239331,
0.6118691564,
0.1499191076,
-0.8236885667,
-0.5559226274,
-0.466106385,
-0.4179354012,
-0.1937160641,
0.3448658288,
0.3525922298,
0.062866658,
1.1439723969,
-0.1762696803,
-0.1677131802,
0.193423897,
0.2059491575,
0.2163195908,
0.4269548059,
0.7340287566,
-0.6598661542,
-0.6104568839,
0.0503317788,
-1.1378889084,
-0.3386132121,
-0.2758165598,
-0.4006569982,
0.038907893,
0.5700517893,
-0.4218511283,
-0.1041433364,
0.3188188374,
-0.4626049697,
0.167367503,
-0.1149191558,
0.120632425,
-1.2416678667,
0.1770766675,
-0.0888491049,
-0.5456895232,
-0.2621994913,
0.1241326332,
0.23614721,
-0.0197576061,
0.0169826671,
0.5136839151,
-0.6723029017,
-0.1663530767,
-0.5394276977,
0.2758393586,
0.0553171001,
0.0259224679,
0.1244429797,
0.9569241405,
0.4649941027,
-0.7173042297,
0.036195565,
0.4477085173,
-0.0275760721,
0.8279902339,
-0.6622151732,
0.4219070971,
-0.2798507214,
0.4637476802,
-0.7841275334,
-0.3575180173,
0.0291008018,
-0.3253941238,
0.2325877994,
-0.2889220715,
-0.2790472507,
-0.0527839586,
-0.236843735,
0.1273654848,
0.2962201834,
-0.988050282,
0.9415061474,
0.2924001813,
-0.0212680753,
-0.320417881,
-0.4386179745,
0.5806657076,
-0.4461266696,
-0.6410253048,
0.4883338809,
-0.3348156512,
-0.3661438227,
-0.158561185,
-0.2122622728,
0.1945489496,
0.3847460449,
0.2139103264,
-0.1276090294,
-0.5761566758,
0.3689430058,
-0.0957036912,
0.0472852662,
0.1521200389,
-0.4324647784,
0.4540780187,
-0.1011922359,
-0.2050727159,
-0.0088598682,
0.2569142878,
0.8201546073,
-0.169715941,
0.6521421075,
0.3787279427,
-0.40593943,
0.0017053372,
-0.7380447984,
-0.0531261191,
-0.4287140369,
0.0841013566,
-0.5883464217,
-0.7501845956,
0.3709347844,
-0.2241144329,
0.1752747893,
0.5109926462,
0.7837858796,
-0.0436668694,
0.6060545444,
0.4488839805,
-0.3099374175,
0.3802618384,
0.3074627817,
0.0649879798,
-0.7644976974,
-0.1362270117,
-0.8227227926,
-0.0450871326,
-0.4300064445,
-0.3268195987,
0.1043617949,
0.2515954375,
-0.2771392167,
-0.0404268727,
-0.3154392242,
0.3513916433,
0.1674785465,
0.1330485046,
0.3292839229,
0.3291963339,
-0.040129751,
-0.22218135,
-0.3598719239,
-0.5722601414,
1.0420951843,
0.2939479351,
0.6571801901,
0.307287544,
0.3872662485,
0.3820479214,
0.4946560264,
-0.7219112515,
0.2387084663,
0.2539403439,
-0.6158732772,
-0.1330133975,
-0.1991880536,
-0.5886588693,
0.4743501246,
-0.382478416,
-0.4546174109,
0.1604640931,
0.108299464,
-0.1554271579,
-0.0738417283,
-0.4707343876,
0.4889586568,
-0.3418963552,
-0.7092203498,
-0.0250529274,
-0.5839906335,
0.1333239973,
-0.2763117254,
0.32256338,
-0.1339707971,
0.2301891893,
0.7064603567,
-0.101476334,
0.7810105085,
-0.4183844924,
-0.4058332443,
0.113696754,
-0.0775365457,
0.9062229991,
0.3395570517,
-0.5976243615,
-0.1860518605,
-0.3442924023,
-0.5037181377,
-0.7121888399,
0.937924087,
-0.633980453,
-0.8212900758,
-0.535561502,
-0.6538130045,
-0.6240389347,
0.3542813063,
-0.0202117134,
0.0944552049,
-0.2809755802,
0.5169924498,
0.7547294497,
0.0345783383,
0.3493519127,
0.7104916573,
-0.2232474238,
-0.540101707,
0.5381768346,
-0.1097683087,
0.0368563943,
0.2930595279,
0.2043153793,
-0.5064995885,
-0.8912174106,
-0.417681396,
0.2834678888,
-0.8220375776,
-0.3620377779,
-0.9291834235,
-0.1135109887,
-0.8565448523,
-0.1716898978,
-0.084970355,
-0.2551928163,
-0.3806012869,
-0.3907701373,
0.4363169968,
0.252366513,
-0.068685554,
0.2822215855,
-0.6588541865,
0.4969847202,
0.1005864292,
0.1841997057,
-0.196282059,
-1.082039237,
-0.1258361489,
-0.0091410549,
-0.1419965923,
-0.8302739263,
0.1186968014,
0.4468762875,
0.5749752522,
0.0217147917,
0.3550666571,
1.1557255983,
-0.659332633,
0.59653157,
0.0613432974,
-0.9085576534,
0.6800572872,
-0.4075873196,
-0.0272668786,
0.8287786841,
0.1880130768,
-0.2523071468,
-0.1789513677,
-0.4078201056,
-0.8323905468,
0.3792381287,
0.1689496785,
0.3934008479,
0.0224037226,
0.6229895353,
0.0124537684,
0.0653148517,
-1.0582616329,
-0.0414919369,
-0.4200062156,
-0.2627601027,
-0.1591852754,
-0.4157011509,
-0.3272141516,
-0.2931389809,
0.8503348827,
-0.6194195747,
-0.0451269634,
0.2745209634,
-0.572011292,
-0.2779906392,
0.466506362,
0.4725589752,
0.8705980778,
-0.4190962613,
0.5118294954,
0.2022987604,
-0.0492221229,
0.3711841106,
0.0491220132,
-0.264406234,
0.0992845744,
0.3019743264,
0.6506078839,
0.2937575579,
-0.4411509931,
0.2679316401,
0.1022906378,
-0.0798050016,
-0.3540685177,
-0.0109014036,
0.1574818343,
0.2172163427,
0.4418375194,
-0.1032746285,
-0.0752897412,
-0.3684601188,
0.2419123352,
0.4674885273,
-0.2873602509,
-0.2413820475,
0.6680434346,
0.2682469487,
-0.163789615,
0.2341205329,
0.0113954898,
-0.3056360483,
0.1424688697,
1.0952887535,
0.889767468,
-0.0165194925,
0.1058970392,
0.617003262,
0.2152128518,
-0.1122579202,
0.0623890273,
0.0106475931,
-0.8006445169,
-0.4451145232,
-0.7297799587,
-0.1811595708,
0.3733638525,
-0.8404980898,
0.2438481897,
-0.5477951765,
0.0374241471,
-0.0959590748,
-0.0250131004,
-0.3122748733,
0.2753892243,
-0.0097064795,
0.9424080849,
-0.9532440305,
0.6969000101,
0.8399730921,
-0.3923199475,
-0.5620415807,
0.2937906682,
-0.3505734503,
-0.5959605575,
0.5689681768,
0.0582587793,
-0.1622193307,
0.3990294933,
-0.6115102172,
-0.9645094275,
1.020621419,
0.7480832934,
-0.553068459,
0.0361783579,
-0.1931226999,
0.5330547094,
-0.559869647,
0.1730439365,
0.4924499691,
0.5943236351,
0.1969131976,
-0.6358537078,
0.4532058239,
-0.1374851316,
0.0096082557,
-0.2997451425,
-0.5168308616,
0.3257580101,
0.0039584991,
-0.1256629974,
0.0677479431,
1.0096167326,
0.580792129,
0.3601279259,
0.6086478829,
0.4569887519,
1.140029192,
0.0613159128,
0.7517716289,
-0.346993953,
0.3180568516,
1.5414305925,
-0.693063736,
0.8249176145,
0.6958327889,
0.0383887328,
0.5023704767,
0.6666033864,
0.0155783016,
0.5288928747,
0.1478218585,
-0.067484349,
-0.5772177577,
-0.25911057,
-0.7452648878,
0.1853966713,
0.1926985979,
-0.4371411502,
-0.4012547135,
-0.079474628,
-0.0375755504,
0.4968187511,
-0.161051333,
0.7282221317,
0.0284796432,
-0.7851626873,
0.8554097414,
0.1042305902,
0.5243977904,
-0.2509133816,
0.0834970847,
-0.2627372444,
-0.0108107207,
-0.3668180704,
-0.3369177878,
0.1666903794,
0.1509931535,
-0.6272787452,
-0.1459614635,
0.8624403477,
-0.0758615658,
-0.4765340388,
0.4460192919,
0.4586980641,
0.0242337435,
-0.2892896533,
-0.6741859317,
0.0041929018,
-0.1619086862,
-0.1756344736,
0.422583878,
0.6263560653,
-0.0601450764,
0.303009063,
0.9061181545,
0.0340663381,
0.1034345105,
0.3715195358,
1.0188599825,
-0.776042521,
-0.4127429128,
-0.7867124677,
0.5023898482,
-0.3419786096,
0.0502981171,
0.8823811412,
0.5924782157,
0.3765918911,
0.0803619027,
0.9142203927,
-0.05682135,
0.490173012,
-0.8941437006,
0.5008192062,
-0.5179861188,
0.4801572263,
-0.2843976915,
-1.1295541525,
-0.3674821854,
0.7776754498,
-0.2915247381,
0.0831316113,
0.6888127327,
0.7130370736,
-0.1965364367,
-0.2929163873,
0.3689582944,
0.5106545687,
0.6765713096,
0.1816527396,
0.7600771785,
-0.5118305087,
0.1520978957,
0.1353235692,
-0.1217684522,
-0.2703864574,
-1.295328021,
-0.9566339254,
-0.1871663183,
-0.351896137,
-0.8437716961,
0.1842508465,
1.0912439823,
0.5953199863,
-1.0787245035,
-0.019269878,
-0.3630621433,
-0.0585462227,
0.1061225235,
-0.224902004,
0.4638687074,
-0.8316660523,
-0.5645925999,
0.7397244573,
0.1988815218,
-0.0464030914,
0.0422350764,
-0.2202344984,
-0.3092195988,
-0.0464148931,
0.6660721898,
0.1843634993,
-0.6872778535,
-0.6991195679,
0.076186128,
-0.0802971646,
0.4404990673,
0.9224388599,
-0.8567541838,
0.3467357457,
0.1372391582,
0.9940314889,
0.3315004706,
0.3361976147,
0.4720536172,
-0.6350225806,
0.2046562284,
0.1242696196,
0.3244046569,
0.5719801784,
-0.4521862864,
0.6712591648,
0.2803881764,
-0.4455619156,
-1.0176695585,
-0.0141801611,
-1.1447507143,
-0.1551686972,
1.4594801664,
-0.1182235703,
-0.0687040165,
-0.2688643932,
-0.2453470975,
0.1542689651,
-0.185041517,
0.9557429552,
0.7764564157,
0.2762550712,
0.0952413604,
-0.2777519822,
0.1111686304,
0.6375519037,
-1.0036325455,
0.4082252383,
0.7808751464,
0.5494709015,
0.2344628572,
0.721726656,
-0.04552944,
0.037309438,
-0.3736518025,
-0.1230526343,
0.0540199205,
-0.3421046734,
-0.541225493,
0.3170960844,
0.6133579016,
0.1978448331
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09528v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09528v1
|
HelpSteer: Multi-attribute Helpfulness Dataset for SteerLM
| 2023-11-16T03:13:29 | 2023-11-16T03:13:29 |
Zhilin Wang, Yi Dong, Jiaqi Zeng, Virginia Adams, Makesh Narsimhan Sreedhar, Daniel Egert, Olivier Delalleau, Jane Polak Scowcroft, Neel Kant, Aidan Swope, Oleksii Kuchaiev
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Existing open-source helpfulness preference datasets do not specify what
makes some responses more helpful and others less so. Models trained on these
datasets can incidentally learn to model dataset artifacts (e.g. preferring
longer but unhelpful responses only due to their length). To alleviate this
problem, we collect HelpSteer, a multi-attribute helpfulness dataset annotated
for the various aspects that make responses helpful. Specifically, our
37k-sample dataset has annotations for correctness, coherence, complexity, and
verbosity in addition to overall helpfulness of responses. Training Llama 2 70B
using the HelpSteer dataset with SteerLM technique produces a model that scores
7.54 on MT Bench, which is currently the highest score for open models that do
not require training data from more powerful models (e.g. GPT4). We release
this dataset with CC-BY-4.0 license at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/nvidia/HelpSteer
|
[
-0.46917665,
-0.2436232865,
0.2977217138,
0.3992252648,
-0.3681486547,
-0.4541680813,
-0.010022264,
-0.5931997895,
0.263572365,
0.2902005613,
-0.6836701632,
-0.1862490475,
-0.6641970873,
0.1508923918,
-0.0271516778,
1.7209949493,
0.5382978916,
0.4664841294,
-0.4789201021,
-0.4737802744,
-0.7199779153,
-0.4791952968,
-0.6678344011,
-0.4201697111,
1.018327117,
0.7773320079,
0.6568188667,
0.2764691412,
0.963760376,
0.175512895,
-0.0955750272,
0.2562045157,
-0.4879580438,
0.3241293728,
0.0979056731,
-0.2364839464,
-1.0171507597,
0.0168353338,
-0.1162360087,
0.289247185,
-0.0625052676,
0.4776459932,
0.084069103,
0.620598793,
-0.4445717931,
0.2565906942,
-0.4719617069,
-0.1944329888,
-0.3216813505,
0.1081214696,
-0.1358811855,
-0.5003896356,
0.1358758211,
-0.7852395177,
0.3608366251,
0.02746002,
0.3505997956,
0.6085427999,
-0.2806090117,
-0.1656555384,
-0.1621357054,
1.0323919058,
-0.6039031744,
0.2819519639,
0.9218521118,
0.3465900719,
0.1217178255,
-0.3438419402,
-0.4228714705,
-0.2201590389,
-0.3292052448,
-0.0033180218,
-0.055389069,
-0.1216788515,
0.2111110091,
0.4095429182,
-0.4273520112,
-0.0409851745,
-0.3816388249,
-0.3287807107,
0.9004867077,
0.2740374506,
-0.2920129299,
-0.5176182985,
-0.281124115,
-0.4886657,
-0.6370034814,
0.174744308,
-0.0237694196,
0.280248791,
-0.1826291829,
0.6853017211,
-0.2407132387,
0.5710324645,
0.0931435302,
-0.102602616,
0.6147757173,
-0.4025973976,
-0.318477422,
-0.0691854358,
0.568020761,
0.6728318334,
0.1412289888,
-0.2370052338,
-0.2687565982,
-0.1872054487,
0.2969821692,
-0.6786469817,
-0.4597828686,
0.4427091777,
-0.4551544487,
-0.2971940041,
0.1318596601,
-0.4493152499,
-0.7195039988,
-0.5562324524,
0.1655513346,
-0.3663198054,
-0.4360971153,
-0.1433386952,
-0.2274726629,
0.4441805482,
0.436093092,
-0.6728105545,
-0.0063868714,
0.5662355423,
0.7090022564,
-0.1776350886,
-0.2765173316,
-0.916642189,
-0.1251901388,
0.012844082,
0.9247945547,
-0.4309397638,
-0.4464678764,
-0.3432089686,
0.144188717,
0.3238766491,
-0.5503844023,
0.7124665976,
-0.5345919728,
0.0015314681,
-0.7108998895,
-0.2679662108,
-0.2316334844,
0.3514989018,
-0.9510466456,
1.3427211046,
0.1672320813,
-0.9095824361,
0.6070505977,
-0.9259700179,
-0.3188742995,
0.0670731291,
0.0286978856,
-0.7094171643,
0.3320031762,
0.3730555773,
0.7415708303,
-0.316604346,
0.357024163,
-0.5670449138,
0.1622416675,
0.3097720444,
-0.1728215516,
0.7087385654,
0.0393477753,
0.0635628626,
0.4251535833,
-0.9970579743,
0.0938847885,
0.1773893088,
-0.191602394,
-0.5863493085,
-0.4214515686,
0.4051390886,
0.2909748852,
0.2990969718,
-0.5989413857,
0.3436416388,
0.2465226054,
-0.1286981106,
0.9747464061,
-0.1710453779,
0.164567396,
-0.5479075909,
0.3173491955,
0.0527971797,
0.315992415,
0.1911306679,
-0.5681710839,
-0.919138968,
-0.3725967109,
0.0515678041,
0.1862998456,
-0.633998692,
0.3034990728,
-0.0527746379,
-0.5624213815,
-0.7125768065,
0.2788591683,
0.5056062341,
0.5527827144,
0.7242051363,
-0.3267232478,
-0.552732408,
-1.0698186159,
0.3063400984,
-0.1389635801,
-0.1438948214,
0.2368729264,
0.5066581368,
0.3453173637,
0.9804466367,
-0.4288116693,
-0.5195214152,
-0.2407532334,
0.0131724095,
0.1948098391,
0.2972652912,
0.7715356946,
-0.8525170684,
-0.1633382142,
-0.2497561127,
-0.7528902888,
-0.0750998557,
0.3386420608,
-0.0402502678,
-0.3813525736,
-0.0712075159,
-0.3359355927,
0.1656551063,
0.4755977392,
-0.3245740235,
0.5025098324,
-0.2658830583,
0.0313277766,
-1.1717590094,
0.1253093928,
0.1384862512,
-0.0918204263,
-0.5952586532,
-0.1577553302,
0.0566881672,
0.4469551444,
-0.3667656481,
0.4148771763,
-0.2316716462,
-0.0484587252,
-0.2559585869,
-0.2879993618,
-0.2049437016,
0.3851209879,
0.1758310497,
1.011669755,
0.3467022181,
-0.7455391884,
0.548227191,
0.7479695678,
0.1005878448,
1.2641026974,
-1.0403249264,
0.4461667836,
-0.2125561833,
-0.0367653407,
-0.8072025776,
-0.6193887591,
0.1017482728,
-0.2675589323,
0.0693789795,
0.271863848,
-0.0384333916,
-0.1410187483,
-0.7174963355,
0.2890430093,
-0.0070235832,
-0.6924974918,
0.3720718026,
0.2836360037,
-0.2671493888,
-0.6718087792,
-0.5881088972,
-0.2283417881,
-0.3775148988,
-0.4383698404,
0.2016460598,
-0.4855723083,
-0.1309468895,
-0.183362633,
0.2664617896,
-0.134058848,
-0.0120827174,
0.4531448483,
0.3542078733,
-0.0311652385,
0.4224203825,
-0.2545599937,
-0.4024219215,
-0.040521048,
0.3093824685,
0.221715346,
-0.338332206,
-0.4163715541,
-0.1652360111,
0.2880322635,
0.512283802,
-0.4350075424,
0.7196677327,
0.6550671458,
-0.0531244762,
0.2408183515,
-0.5383279324,
-0.4221801758,
-0.3731825948,
0.3797318935,
-0.4081523418,
-0.604647994,
0.330909729,
0.6258401275,
0.2351657152,
0.3962959945,
0.372695148,
-0.1035532877,
0.7447579503,
0.7639858723,
-0.4069105983,
0.4358358681,
-0.3680123985,
-0.1609598249,
-1.0565675497,
-0.6579899192,
-0.5506795049,
-0.3194523156,
-0.3039195836,
-0.1376369894,
0.4412506521,
-0.2175136805,
-0.3384625912,
0.2090434879,
-0.5185036063,
0.2403049767,
0.8301671147,
0.3719562888,
0.3943014741,
-0.0700431839,
0.1658338159,
-0.3039613366,
-0.5298790336,
-0.2361658514,
1.2992246151,
0.1247922927,
0.8651399612,
0.2519699931,
0.4568803608,
0.4928299189,
0.6655831933,
-0.863884449,
0.3981113732,
-0.0281990282,
-0.3850722611,
-0.148878932,
-0.1419762522,
-0.6340028048,
-0.2097008079,
-0.3012655973,
-0.3329425752,
0.1742712855,
0.361273706,
-0.1729033589,
0.0003727392,
-0.5268729925,
0.4042372108,
-0.542288661,
-0.6210024357,
0.0174605716,
-0.8343782425,
0.0775232315,
-0.1280495226,
0.0099695036,
-0.3088812232,
0.1517174244,
0.9227515459,
-0.4754973352,
0.861520052,
-0.4198699892,
0.1207825765,
-0.2094822973,
-0.2676436305,
0.4034962356,
-0.0798644722,
-0.4592958093,
0.1412796676,
-0.323964417,
-0.4278772771,
-0.2701318562,
0.5138450861,
-0.8791152835,
-0.4609265924,
-0.5327089429,
-0.6255735159,
-0.3960877061,
-0.0392574854,
0.0919220746,
0.2025556117,
0.0053004324,
0.4846439064,
0.4394603372,
0.1860839874,
0.3491778374,
0.3110229075,
0.1750789881,
-0.6616499424,
0.7271786928,
-0.0762774423,
-0.0896390826,
-0.0120142298,
0.1594474316,
-0.70023036,
-0.4485167861,
-0.4056769311,
0.1956783831,
-0.6904367805,
-0.7898658514,
-0.1703354418,
-0.1789530069,
-0.0525865108,
0.1970576644,
-0.1788428873,
-0.5745027065,
-0.2383552194,
-0.6058859825,
1.2169486284,
1.2932252884,
-0.2324548215,
0.3527084589,
-0.4777504802,
0.1448910534,
0.4048820734,
0.3987935483,
0.1370578855,
-0.3384250104,
-0.3196078837,
-0.1475811005,
-0.5272629857,
-0.6322499514,
0.0277104992,
0.3411376178,
0.7505972981,
0.2880454957,
0.2569303215,
0.6244064569,
0.0232069399,
0.8771494031,
0.3529620469,
-0.4048289359,
0.5564621687,
-0.1538835913,
0.0753795356,
0.6867400408,
0.5128003359,
-0.2493762672,
-0.1920786649,
-0.4038082361,
-0.7523123026,
0.7143678665,
0.0894462168,
0.0334545188,
0.1469265521,
0.3387724757,
0.4804100394,
0.3417817354,
-0.8030734062,
-0.4068310261,
-0.6572390199,
-0.4107376039,
-0.0682621822,
-0.3526197076,
-0.1341322809,
-0.2574829459,
0.8760828972,
-0.2554472387,
0.0631590635,
0.1165846512,
-0.1025401428,
0.1928741932,
0.3559574187,
0.365257889,
0.6293016076,
-0.2046256214,
0.1173959747,
0.3005774915,
-0.5852518678,
0.1786155403,
0.2449904084,
0.0345453136,
-0.4540506005,
0.4128517509,
0.720279634,
-0.1111898422,
-0.0104924766,
0.5154795647,
-0.1338322163,
0.037182726,
-0.0371582173,
0.2169606835,
-0.0454394184,
0.2565692365,
0.6329592466,
0.0277903099,
0.1211292818,
0.2118615955,
0.0435958058,
0.5312262177,
-0.5610188842,
-0.4549785256,
0.6162536144,
0.2297964841,
-0.2365203947,
0.7672480941,
0.1001925319,
-0.2547124028,
0.3750714362,
0.3582488298,
0.6071760058,
-0.3395891488,
0.2929295003,
0.3979586363,
-0.0624490455,
0.1209786236,
0.3504805863,
-0.2546057105,
-0.508095324,
-0.1587948352,
-0.6615165472,
-0.4800537229,
0.5628485084,
-0.9916053414,
0.1542726904,
-0.1467312574,
-0.5091876388,
0.13139081,
-0.0410353467,
-0.9701535702,
0.4327426851,
-0.2930017114,
0.8582350016,
-0.9118921161,
0.7400079966,
0.7655366063,
-0.9713980556,
-0.8327977061,
-0.151753962,
0.0213410612,
-0.8247929811,
0.7869792581,
0.2003865987,
-0.1971250325,
-0.2672693133,
-0.5734145641,
-0.5136112571,
1.2768422365,
0.5372801423,
-0.2448558509,
0.1050358862,
0.1281365156,
0.4673099816,
-0.2900971174,
0.690971911,
0.4584209323,
0.5476753116,
0.0621092208,
-1.0809268951,
-0.0617075115,
-0.4461825192,
0.0575458668,
-0.2271796465,
-0.9001379609,
0.7678766251,
-0.4681824446,
0.5885621905,
0.246382311,
0.6112044454,
0.4466871619,
0.444029659,
0.5335136652,
0.3327911496,
1.0639159679,
-0.216085583,
1.0402983427,
-0.0308621936,
0.2654367685,
1.1880283356,
-0.0216777157,
0.9160062671,
0.7782223225,
-0.1555365175,
0.3656815886,
0.7613121271,
0.0630174875,
0.7696356177,
-0.1436299086,
-0.2530675232,
-0.3458919823,
-0.5533663034,
-0.5921359062,
0.4593134224,
0.0320741124,
-0.2180959284,
-0.137434423,
0.1003887281,
-0.1312882304,
-0.3160314262,
-0.3381421864,
0.9598891735,
-0.0170517974,
-0.4752819836,
0.2740343511,
-0.403300643,
0.7824525833,
-0.867939949,
-0.2549298108,
-0.5430600047,
0.1591837257,
-0.5345743299,
-0.9285694957,
0.150373131,
0.124263227,
-0.5403994322,
0.0693998858,
0.7354527712,
-0.1284012347,
-0.5488247871,
0.3196448386,
0.6117876172,
0.1818325222,
0.1001133323,
-0.6343339682,
-0.216125235,
-0.2089060098,
-0.3546839058,
0.1815122813,
0.0830893368,
-0.2802217305,
0.7113553286,
0.7496079206,
0.1205162108,
-0.2018511146,
0.1819075942,
1.114403367,
-0.4738037586,
-0.2362818569,
-0.5378010869,
0.8023180366,
-0.4320529401,
-0.5673081875,
0.8433354497,
0.5192676187,
0.7463812232,
-0.2615691423,
0.8600311279,
-0.1809938997,
0.430768609,
-0.4462172985,
0.6130365729,
-0.7540947795,
0.1739725769,
-0.1161900386,
-0.6730604172,
-0.4031785727,
0.9619634151,
-0.5349931121,
0.3608080447,
0.2474927753,
0.8518688679,
-0.3718440831,
0.1733651757,
0.1969135702,
0.0054471511,
0.301287055,
0.4738720953,
0.8152234554,
-0.1672432423,
0.458204627,
-0.2717644572,
-0.121541366,
-0.3507010341,
-1.1560412645,
-0.8034759164,
-0.5845364332,
-0.0256475285,
-0.2463413775,
0.0956142396,
1.0907541513,
0.9687214494,
-1.0495462418,
-0.0495059043,
0.1921215653,
-0.0867852047,
-0.269761622,
-0.1768728346,
0.5524026752,
-0.1053364351,
-0.3130133748,
0.0833023116,
-0.0816547498,
0.1321759671,
-0.493914336,
-0.4390211403,
0.2136710286,
-0.4492734373,
0.4698925018,
-0.0862782821,
-0.452467829,
-0.5625427961,
0.2796787322,
0.1141441166,
0.4669342637,
0.6378266811,
-0.5938726664,
0.3469203711,
0.0460608304,
0.4562756717,
0.4546489418,
-0.1513670832,
0.4397031963,
-1.1074931622,
0.1945605874,
-0.039197281,
0.362937957,
0.9967913032,
-0.4152089655,
0.6082288027,
-0.1662160307,
-0.5899404287,
-0.3231958151,
0.0536276139,
-1.0054757595,
0.3492796421,
0.9927334785,
-0.156588763,
-0.0169205852,
-0.2688258886,
-0.6758509278,
0.0114750825,
-0.7816424966,
0.6448563337,
0.7351394892,
-0.5469422936,
-0.1801719964,
-0.2429752052,
0.7855207324,
0.2950054109,
-0.956164062,
0.1240259483,
0.72702384,
0.5460407734,
0.183492139,
0.6655065417,
0.3052431345,
0.4966536164,
-0.2195999771,
-0.1985851824,
-0.6508138776,
-0.4453024864,
-0.3369661868,
0.2091051489,
0.5878340602,
-0.2912558317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09521v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09521v2
|
AMRFact: Enhancing Summarization Factuality Evaluation with AMR-Driven Negative Samples Generation
| 2023-11-16T02:56:29 | 2024-04-02T20:46:37 |
Haoyi Qiu, Kung-Hsiang Huang, Jingnong Qu, Nanyun Peng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Ensuring factual consistency is crucial for natural language generation
tasks, particularly in abstractive summarization, where preserving the
integrity of information is paramount. Prior works on evaluating factual
consistency of summarization often take the entailment-based approaches that
first generate perturbed (factual inconsistent) summaries and then train a
classifier on the generated data to detect the factually inconsistencies during
testing time. However, previous approaches generating perturbed summaries are
either of low coherence or lack error-type coverage. To address these issues,
we propose AMRFact, a framework that generates perturbed summaries using
Abstract Meaning Representations (AMRs). Our approach parses factually
consistent summaries into AMR graphs and injects controlled factual
inconsistencies to create negative examples, allowing for coherent factually
inconsistent summaries to be generated with high error-type coverage.
Additionally, we present a data selection module NegFilter based on natural
language inference and BARTScore to ensure the quality of the generated
negative samples. Experimental results demonstrate our approach significantly
outperforms previous systems on the AggreFact-SOTA benchmark, showcasing its
efficacy in evaluating factuality of abstractive summarization.
|
[
-0.4624969661,
-1.0076665878,
0.3485071063,
0.3474472463,
-0.2660021484,
0.2209939957,
0.0261785612,
-0.4097391069,
0.7172718048,
0.4918686152,
-0.4571607709,
-0.5523249507,
-0.5068994164,
0.4305829108,
-0.4958052039,
1.3662178516,
-0.1873672903,
-0.3056519926,
-0.5344481468,
-0.4448453486,
-0.1397839636,
-0.4562155008,
-0.5189896822,
-0.5061764717,
0.1692656577,
0.6470851302,
0.6533299685,
0.2520706058,
0.3598549366,
0.2191712111,
0.0544001386,
0.3020184934,
-0.5359945297,
0.3708218038,
-0.0594076216,
0.0456684418,
-0.6064120531,
0.0393232815,
0.4959216416,
0.4445055723,
-0.2544750869,
0.2841079235,
-0.2874422073,
0.4963656366,
-0.8008043766,
0.0247884206,
-0.3495473862,
0.1821576357,
-0.0142668225,
-0.30600366,
-0.3432416618,
-0.7618723512,
-0.227216661,
-0.6091644764,
0.5227778554,
0.1439030617,
1.0172344446,
0.0597785674,
-0.530806303,
-0.4859247506,
-0.5679367781,
0.6091815829,
-1.1710016727,
0.0830699503,
0.1390440911,
0.3905386329,
-0.1651098132,
-0.4624006748,
-0.875221312,
-0.1982902884,
-0.3716815114,
0.2912168503,
-0.2082733214,
0.0877567902,
0.2560787499,
0.5655926466,
-0.4216910005,
-0.2368441075,
-0.2239141613,
-0.6153842807,
0.7447849512,
0.1900398433,
0.3125637174,
-0.4305837154,
-0.1420255154,
-0.1607626528,
-0.7491137981,
-0.2567360401,
0.6471808553,
0.1990414709,
-0.3741904795,
0.9524952173,
-0.5280406475,
0.5269085169,
0.1805228144,
-0.1927740127,
0.4931942523,
-0.6538051367,
-0.3655497134,
0.4361193776,
0.7791759968,
0.2670338154,
0.0462641492,
-0.1005726308,
-0.2134616375,
0.0878263488,
0.1244817376,
-1.0207008123,
-0.1520616561,
0.2382512838,
-0.2032650411,
-0.5965700746,
0.197914958,
-0.9575574398,
-0.2784666419,
-0.2908292711,
0.5237753391,
-0.3268736899,
-0.1686372012,
0.0333107784,
-0.4159221947,
-0.0027023347,
0.5082279444,
-0.9432758689,
0.6497387886,
0.3535759449,
0.6487901211,
0.0700745583,
-0.191701591,
-0.8768544793,
0.2713344991,
-0.2995074093,
0.9015156627,
-0.4245834947,
-0.3385944068,
-0.2502706945,
-0.2066490203,
0.1324007362,
-0.5752520561,
0.5007081032,
-0.3356336653,
0.4791351557,
-0.3342720866,
-0.3452185988,
-0.3681925237,
0.7220457792,
-0.4111482799,
0.6567879915,
0.0475213975,
-0.9392873645,
0.57456249,
-0.5872002244,
-0.9634601474,
-0.4223403931,
-0.5052341819,
-0.7665911913,
0.2151830643,
0.2486964166,
0.2950542867,
-0.1252788901,
0.1725321114,
-0.1564451903,
-0.363319844,
0.1726049185,
-0.5688098669,
0.4980356097,
-0.1719474196,
-0.2804908156,
0.0890229121,
-0.8248465657,
-0.1724589467,
-0.1115587577,
-0.4819100499,
-0.0704981685,
0.0976873487,
-0.1447168738,
0.1921891719,
-0.0424698703,
-0.8144950271,
-0.2029140145,
-0.488574028,
0.0279306062,
0.4293732345,
0.7163689137,
0.1612772644,
-0.5112653375,
0.6271787882,
-0.0182701964,
-0.3257681131,
-0.3114713132,
-0.2310380787,
-0.7173903584,
-0.1744415313,
0.2893476784,
0.368165791,
-0.5413058996,
0.2177667022,
-0.4108439684,
-0.2919179797,
-0.206398353,
-0.0759401992,
0.5345613956,
0.9507369995,
0.6736995578,
-0.2846838832,
-0.6775007248,
-0.7843798399,
-0.2002167702,
-0.2579065859,
0.117613256,
0.1123143286,
0.6304821372,
-0.2549697757,
0.906116128,
-0.5020701885,
-0.2006025165,
-0.2227704078,
0.6759412289,
0.3475599289,
0.4823816419,
0.3291527033,
-0.6536430717,
-0.4155808389,
-0.1641938239,
-0.7485857606,
-0.2257408351,
-0.2015244365,
-0.1844279319,
0.4125904441,
0.4601833522,
-0.6044000387,
0.4216838181,
0.4548279047,
-0.6313943267,
0.8800265193,
-0.2886273563,
0.513218224,
-0.8121024966,
0.3546414077,
-0.3160687983,
-0.3464698195,
-0.3055233061,
-0.167307198,
-0.0901089162,
-0.0251654126,
-0.0861643031,
0.3515677452,
-0.2459275126,
0.0449910052,
-0.1523537636,
0.0525413118,
0.3650040329,
0.1681281924,
-0.2103853524,
0.6732825041,
-0.0878275409,
-0.7699534297,
0.0304245874,
0.5343777537,
0.0232155435,
0.4881914258,
-0.6449538469,
-0.1487561911,
-0.3313544393,
0.303558588,
-1.0027458668,
-0.8120422363,
0.3529738784,
-0.5402060747,
0.4758630395,
-0.175967291,
-0.4790836275,
0.1165650934,
-0.4567402899,
0.1157308668,
0.3861187696,
-0.3449535966,
0.7161815763,
0.2917639017,
-0.1702862233,
-0.8593042493,
-0.9186384082,
0.2533449233,
0.0387344658,
-0.5343622565,
0.292052567,
0.2340698242,
-0.407553196,
0.2082552314,
-0.4110506177,
0.2490445226,
-0.0401639529,
0.0372141711,
-0.0814121738,
-0.3038652241,
0.0261668544,
0.5761023164,
-0.2496885508,
0.1908178478,
0.1488291472,
0.3736323118,
0.143595323,
-0.6300686002,
-0.0091761891,
0.1114801913,
0.5870137215,
-0.4348701835,
0.4368943274,
0.3114467859,
-0.2312815785,
-0.1006799936,
-0.5277867317,
-0.1699204445,
-0.3959302604,
0.1681563854,
0.0499667786,
-0.5814206004,
0.4989181757,
0.3207208812,
0.3192688823,
0.3829300106,
0.2595615089,
-0.0499971397,
0.6888098717,
0.2283194363,
0.2049232125,
0.0372512192,
-0.0909821317,
0.1886390448,
-0.5075392723,
-0.092813395,
-0.1111076772,
-0.2244977504,
-0.3476105332,
-0.3805712163,
0.470605284,
-0.2759622633,
-0.134287104,
-0.108232893,
-0.0507509112,
0.4652753174,
0.2671007216,
-0.1810788214,
0.6202877164,
0.0775921345,
-0.0658385381,
0.0256906003,
-0.2735700607,
-0.6220694184,
0.9052625895,
0.0511839576,
0.591866076,
0.5708399415,
0.8279583454,
0.3704503477,
0.5843393803,
-0.5946359038,
0.5382166505,
-0.175351724,
-0.7759639621,
-0.2228143066,
-0.4032784104,
-0.3795808852,
0.4101936817,
-0.6729431748,
-0.1531924605,
0.1623080224,
0.6101686358,
-0.2903862298,
0.0401807167,
-0.6413294673,
0.8077819347,
0.1596142799,
-0.4033509195,
-0.2741178274,
-0.5169753432,
0.7231791615,
0.0722682774,
0.210844323,
-0.2059448361,
0.2010377645,
0.4122551084,
-0.4914751351,
0.6987695098,
-0.3448170722,
0.1138134897,
0.3579005897,
0.2472047061,
0.5433830023,
0.4694985747,
-0.2018902004,
-0.1585019976,
-0.3054840267,
-0.3565637469,
-0.6441298723,
0.336411804,
-0.2186642736,
-0.4389282167,
-0.3928236067,
-0.298150748,
-0.270370245,
0.4024225771,
0.3933246732,
0.8601590991,
-0.5162113905,
0.058438994,
0.6130183339,
-0.2358557433,
0.243774578,
0.4887282848,
-0.303909421,
-0.6240884662,
1.0107229948,
0.181261152,
0.3269346058,
0.6063433886,
0.1774895489,
-0.2152955979,
-0.7445872426,
-0.5228497982,
0.2144901007,
-0.6149431467,
-0.4168733656,
-0.8050754666,
-0.0985648334,
-0.4556137621,
-0.1218491569,
-0.1456958354,
-0.6892287135,
0.0449967794,
-0.3820149601,
0.1478052288,
0.6660306454,
-0.1478324533,
0.0527500547,
-0.5368046165,
0.4834423959,
0.1355483085,
0.0459402762,
-0.1137003899,
-0.3858170509,
-0.2346885204,
-0.033510115,
-0.3900686204,
-0.7939937711,
0.3184621334,
0.1745621711,
0.3000611663,
0.3796685934,
0.244776845,
0.6290570498,
-0.4277945161,
0.5123628378,
0.1066275015,
-1.0053025484,
0.4005216658,
-0.3885161579,
0.3327264786,
1.0285481215,
-0.0254278425,
-0.4409219921,
-0.8549317122,
-0.864302814,
-0.949428618,
0.4594275951,
0.3290467262,
0.1839159727,
-0.1659461707,
0.1506877542,
0.2808133662,
0.5698235035,
-0.4989818037,
-0.17924124,
-0.6058071852,
-0.4176398516,
-0.1093620285,
-0.4801227748,
-0.1471764892,
0.1585201323,
0.9053737521,
-0.0810001045,
0.0899219289,
0.4735184908,
-0.2092009783,
-0.1241947636,
0.4791538417,
0.8512390852,
0.5996815562,
-0.5062696338,
0.500487864,
0.2770474553,
-0.8198232651,
0.2640230954,
0.2522109151,
-0.3910912573,
0.2903732061,
0.5967154503,
0.4165763259,
0.2088299841,
-0.8297702074,
0.6871640086,
-0.080885388,
-0.2817492485,
-0.4600452185,
0.2163271308,
-0.1620991677,
-0.2204134911,
0.2804231644,
0.4988792539,
0.4315062761,
-0.3945329189,
0.3281268775,
0.2579815388,
-0.3122753799,
-0.4913335741,
0.5715331435,
0.1782753617,
0.2572556734,
0.5390569568,
-0.7421313524,
-0.2733305097,
0.5422648191,
0.6361174583,
0.7077673674,
0.0731091052,
0.4173126221,
0.5912972689,
0.4500755668,
0.1320702881,
0.3312007487,
-0.012138146,
-0.8052383661,
-0.7907519341,
-0.4622094333,
-0.7162498236,
-0.0447520874,
-0.5141668916,
0.4188078046,
-0.608387351,
0.0520396642,
-0.1846162975,
0.0598286465,
0.0526842959,
0.4959758222,
-0.0570850521,
0.8475446701,
-1.0127615929,
0.2397660464,
0.8636803031,
-0.5345769525,
-0.5010802746,
0.2477723211,
0.1107320935,
-0.3163244724,
0.2693549693,
0.169373557,
-0.349560231,
-0.2193140239,
-0.3589119315,
-0.7951137424,
1.1725686789,
0.6459720731,
0.0034878359,
0.1521543413,
-0.1690015644,
0.4492541254,
-0.1875584722,
0.2172265053,
0.2748456299,
0.5352321863,
0.4780665338,
-0.3330716193,
0.4576163292,
-0.2631896734,
-0.6545664668,
0.4196706116,
-0.3682777882,
0.7020397186,
-0.4953556955,
-0.4481621683,
-0.2988171279,
0.745030582,
0.6209990382,
0.6280197501,
0.2730030119,
0.6662888527,
0.8600994349,
0.0869481564,
1.0255402327,
0.0224561766,
0.0275407042,
1.4802993536,
-0.0734628737,
0.6246486902,
0.5552598834,
0.0927402005,
0.6364070773,
0.1182475165,
-0.0632965341,
0.3782894909,
-0.0266976319,
-0.4589523673,
-0.0078228256,
0.0346915536,
-0.2368839681,
0.4232248366,
0.25975281,
-0.2298315167,
-0.5462782979,
-0.4267900586,
0.4305841625,
0.255494386,
0.0627636611,
0.6384111047,
-0.1341187507,
-0.646514535,
0.387252599,
0.1104836911,
0.4579497278,
-0.5716648102,
-0.3713261187,
-0.2715057135,
-0.0401059985,
-0.5878344774,
-0.4357235134,
0.6586699486,
0.0956143886,
-0.2236429602,
-0.0576664768,
0.6914715767,
-0.3202180266,
-0.3571993411,
-0.1760521978,
0.3361940086,
-0.0449093655,
0.2228571475,
-0.1800464541,
-0.1694591492,
0.0594921671,
-0.0959419087,
0.0235930588,
0.5121016502,
0.1167343557,
0.2077912092,
0.5352221727,
0.0987826511,
-0.2700935006,
0.0203737058,
0.7469004989,
-0.5378732085,
-0.4553233683,
-1.1346138716,
0.6710274816,
-0.4872795939,
-0.3903435469,
1.0470964909,
0.9058188796,
0.4745388925,
0.1405862123,
0.9842044115,
-0.4070949256,
0.6204938293,
-0.622364521,
0.8137982488,
-0.142027393,
0.2045336813,
-0.2454832643,
-0.7151430845,
-0.4942066371,
0.5453215241,
-0.5165865421,
-0.2521740496,
0.4847457409,
0.7330473065,
-0.4396135509,
0.134845376,
0.0516319647,
0.4539702535,
0.5761229992,
-0.0635904521,
0.7418323755,
-0.4776798189,
0.292873472,
-0.1276408434,
-0.1000818983,
-0.1676743031,
-1.1744810343,
-0.792118907,
-0.0499297492,
-0.455152601,
-0.5384120941,
-0.0393226929,
0.9648808837,
0.32269153,
-1.0821605921,
-0.1111031026,
-0.5523017049,
0.333655417,
0.0269198399,
-0.2622855902,
0.1684400588,
-0.5438011885,
-0.342174381,
0.2825554609,
0.3086725771,
0.4593639076,
-0.0722452626,
-0.0781022534,
-0.087138392,
0.3145719171,
0.52410537,
0.3957363367,
-0.0901788697,
-0.2125248164,
-0.2602216601,
0.249897331,
0.1342411488,
0.5685884953,
-0.7465627789,
0.4550266862,
0.5213001966,
0.508687377,
0.6178318858,
0.4812935591,
0.8091562986,
-0.9457675815,
-0.0348600596,
0.4221512675,
0.1556114554,
0.4922938049,
-0.244351849,
0.4807390273,
0.1012982801,
-0.26715675,
-0.9547176361,
0.1497950405,
-0.6207371354,
0.0384287909,
0.9549916387,
0.016142169,
-0.1615213007,
-0.2266881615,
-0.0491912402,
0.1450587213,
-0.533018589,
0.7644670606,
0.5323399901,
-0.4434318542,
0.3427863121,
-0.5094781518,
0.5773112178,
0.2810538411,
-0.8219884038,
0.1541121602,
0.7313318253,
0.1999867857,
0.3783043027,
0.9012485147,
-0.3367759287,
0.2799446583,
0.0751376897,
0.0290820487,
-0.2235488296,
-0.0085117007,
-0.2365388423,
0.226856336,
0.0252263881,
0.0908330828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09519v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09519v2
|
Leveraging Code to Improve In-context Learning for Semantic Parsing
| 2023-11-16T02:50:06 | 2024-03-27T21:52:11 |
Ben Bogin, Shivanshu Gupta, Peter Clark, Ashish Sabharwal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In-context learning (ICL) is an appealing approach for semantic parsing due
to its few-shot nature and improved generalization. However, learning to parse
to rare domain-specific languages (DSLs) from just a few demonstrations is
challenging, limiting the performance of even the most capable LLMs. In this
work, we improve the effectiveness of ICL for semantic parsing by (1) using
general-purpose programming languages such as Python instead of DSLs, and (2)
augmenting prompts with a structured domain description that includes, e.g.,
the available classes and functions. We show that both these changes
significantly improve accuracy across three popular datasets. Combined, they
lead to dramatic improvements (e.g. 7.9% to 66.5% on SMCalFlow compositional
split), nearly closing the performance gap between easier i.i.d.\ and harder
compositional splits when used with a strong model, and reducing the need for a
large number of demonstrations. We find that the resemblance of the target
parse language to general-purpose code is a more important factor than the
language's popularity in pre-training corpora. Our findings provide an improved
methodology for building semantic parsers in the modern context of ICL with
LLMs.
|
[
-0.2873001695,
-0.3824104965,
0.6889178753,
0.2723508179,
-0.364831537,
0.0535585992,
-0.4447050691,
-0.3665457964,
-0.3628466427,
0.3204709291,
-0.3137534559,
-0.7959008217,
-0.5415224433,
0.2859927714,
-0.2943036854,
0.9223698378,
0.0229879227,
0.2608268559,
-0.4392442405,
-0.1407578886,
-0.3284653723,
-0.3821915388,
-0.2190818042,
-0.3088161051,
0.4630529583,
0.5400469303,
0.390478909,
0.6660075784,
0.3432440162,
0.246616751,
-0.0075782365,
0.3281897902,
-0.2397539914,
-0.0715978518,
-0.4031695724,
-0.369582653,
-0.0843862817,
-0.3220007718,
0.5366165638,
1.0924839973,
0.2656059563,
-0.1257006824,
0.2671644092,
0.4838532507,
-0.7020171285,
0.423135519,
-0.8865819573,
0.0832487345,
-0.144659698,
-0.3869801164,
-0.5813498497,
-0.0109269572,
0.3431755602,
-0.5752224326,
-0.0062167374,
-0.2341898531,
0.66620785,
0.2523057163,
-0.3728016019,
-0.5322186351,
-0.2516303957,
1.029258132,
-0.7950072289,
0.3523401022,
0.2420646399,
0.2005754262,
-0.2668092549,
-1.1084799767,
-0.3590864539,
-0.3356823027,
-0.2006419748,
-0.2430454791,
0.1798431724,
0.0642834976,
0.3661216199,
0.1492556036,
-0.3434754908,
-0.0216966718,
-0.083283782,
0.0126004731,
0.3898916841,
0.2304846942,
0.4615497589,
0.084575817,
-0.4243027866,
-0.0968344733,
-0.823405385,
0.4074633718,
0.0436992235,
0.4591668248,
0.1158527136,
0.3986694217,
-0.3783831298,
1.0215183496,
-0.1306822896,
-0.4055610299,
0.218116805,
-0.0401476808,
-0.2076628208,
0.0850988552,
0.1901232451,
0.3528743386,
0.1859499812,
-0.335603267,
-0.0756576434,
0.3271368742,
0.0954817832,
-0.8353995681,
-0.2747671902,
0.1328721493,
-0.2908888161,
-0.0174523927,
0.1285940707,
-0.3711322844,
-0.0798426121,
-0.8589908481,
0.1349920779,
-0.6669039726,
0.2852137983,
0.4211166501,
-0.1739556938,
0.5777019858,
0.5792140961,
-0.7176471353,
0.440988332,
1.0386815071,
0.6565003395,
-0.2731980085,
-0.4923704565,
-0.8981525898,
0.3018084764,
-0.1643691063,
0.9223543406,
-0.8349865079,
-0.1845522225,
-0.0931216031,
-0.1336615682,
-0.2066470981,
-0.7981081605,
0.3422170281,
-0.4316110313,
-0.0602988787,
-0.1612972766,
-0.8875110149,
0.0632701591,
0.2472599596,
-0.246401757,
0.6654853821,
0.2629442811,
-0.7302975059,
0.6706507802,
-0.6462675929,
-0.5207141042,
0.2548159659,
-0.5191199183,
-0.0482523851,
0.0297951084,
0.2098188996,
0.5699281096,
-0.0060710888,
0.3594922125,
-0.2855668664,
-0.5970336795,
0.1213260889,
-0.1324480772,
0.7117154002,
0.2986111343,
-0.4835527837,
0.0486130603,
-0.8275272846,
0.32230106,
-0.1897470802,
-0.5008246303,
-0.355068922,
0.1529076099,
-0.1213494465,
0.2046572864,
-0.1367217153,
-0.5326660275,
0.1516619027,
-0.7569354177,
0.3185779452,
0.6743935943,
-0.2745623291,
0.5238224864,
-0.0810721517,
0.2623064816,
0.2822237015,
-0.123315759,
-0.3277115822,
-0.33573246,
-0.66359514,
-0.5969509482,
0.07083413,
0.4346832931,
-0.7821617126,
0.2971589863,
-0.2770891488,
0.028408464,
-0.3701011539,
0.3939232826,
0.2945117056,
0.8589670658,
0.5043244958,
-0.0385541767,
-0.3642261028,
-0.6495482326,
-0.4457465708,
0.0661168545,
-0.1057237014,
0.2767361701,
0.2441131324,
-0.4904060364,
1.3686094284,
-0.4910838008,
-0.046009928,
-0.5103570819,
-0.3146891594,
0.1410403699,
0.5089240074,
0.3955916166,
-0.844705224,
-0.8690761924,
0.0409504771,
-0.5818207264,
-0.3222124279,
0.1195728034,
-0.0789328292,
0.0892037824,
0.47402969,
-0.3502521217,
0.3764001727,
0.1614952832,
-0.4493438601,
0.3114583194,
-0.058731705,
-0.1524999142,
-0.6884241104,
-0.0562108085,
-0.1107397228,
-0.2937556803,
-0.6749441028,
0.2980383337,
0.4174278378,
-0.1757431924,
-0.9852923751,
0.5059671402,
-0.1835144162,
-0.067760244,
-0.3328282237,
0.1441923082,
0.1786416173,
0.397767812,
0.1759877205,
0.8724449277,
0.7244933844,
-0.7157351971,
0.1761362851,
0.1573472768,
-0.4797282517,
0.4592041969,
-0.4643803239,
0.0060290075,
-0.279027015,
0.2867716551,
-0.6532859206,
-0.2196740806,
0.1317415535,
-0.0701814145,
0.2591176629,
-0.1929181665,
-0.3746382594,
0.1677786261,
-0.2813944817,
0.3586109281,
0.2226391882,
-1.0370596647,
0.3197918832,
0.0721605867,
0.2618474066,
-0.5510808825,
-0.6974665523,
0.1859738231,
-0.4252992868,
-0.8349254727,
0.5448350906,
-0.1883165389,
-0.5582882762,
-0.0727933198,
-0.1101576909,
-0.01749257,
0.3966161609,
-0.064493455,
0.068358697,
-0.2754040956,
0.1235157549,
0.0417749807,
-0.3397911489,
-0.1631415337,
-0.5736439228,
0.6343914866,
-0.5860236287,
-0.4451779127,
-0.5135176778,
0.3998608589,
0.1613750905,
-0.27149266,
0.5943561792,
0.2088947594,
-0.0798917934,
-0.6289012432,
-0.1234215051,
0.0628001764,
-0.504250586,
0.1879353374,
-0.5044028759,
-1.0443091393,
0.1652855575,
-0.4206366837,
-0.1996190846,
0.1043913141,
0.339564234,
-0.0089812521,
0.9688434005,
0.5329104662,
-0.0240918659,
0.3129138052,
-0.295026511,
0.299485743,
-0.8076056838,
-0.1490394324,
-0.424244374,
-0.016213404,
-0.3810866773,
-0.3668146431,
0.2095839083,
0.1453040093,
-0.1428320706,
0.3244384825,
-0.2718918622,
0.8704876304,
0.3804676831,
0.1458685696,
0.2993572056,
0.0878799856,
-0.2476792783,
-0.0509840697,
-0.5273647904,
-0.622597456,
0.8581268191,
0.1879191548,
0.8650608659,
-0.0435738713,
0.9053058028,
0.1780509353,
-0.0433280244,
-0.8423653245,
0.5580384135,
-0.4530118704,
0.1910240501,
-0.0228880551,
-0.3703295887,
-0.7010070682,
0.6532642841,
0.4163708389,
-0.7046858668,
0.0227703266,
0.0006656153,
-0.1425228119,
0.1379464716,
-0.8507044315,
1.0082243681,
-0.1626698375,
-0.2923586667,
-0.0358508117,
-0.7465809584,
0.1248057261,
0.2114848346,
0.1459154338,
-0.150843516,
-0.1532567292,
0.0347965658,
-0.7594432235,
0.9679790139,
-0.2171213478,
-0.1549262553,
0.3322565854,
-0.1207030267,
0.4652272463,
0.2171902806,
0.0946887881,
-0.0634316504,
-0.0078705568,
-0.5176141858,
-0.6429488659,
0.84680897,
-0.5683016181,
-0.464543581,
-0.2550254166,
-0.5745525956,
-0.3727593422,
-0.1065835804,
0.074023582,
0.8000280857,
0.1659330726,
0.2575800717,
0.7314907908,
-0.2004046291,
0.431268096,
0.2565557063,
0.1136700138,
-0.2454584092,
0.7913687825,
-0.2876445055,
0.4241964519,
0.4703196287,
0.2643409669,
-0.1743752062,
-0.381642431,
-0.4599853456,
-0.0176871438,
-1.1312783957,
-0.3302828968,
-0.9129641652,
0.1089352444,
-0.5306546688,
-0.5890575051,
-0.0011515571,
-0.4520416856,
-0.5015007257,
0.0882749185,
0.0384568423,
0.2755356431,
0.2950735092,
0.3626105189,
-0.6145730019,
0.177728191,
0.256198287,
0.3878171444,
-0.1311566383,
-0.310977459,
-0.1539396644,
-0.1024984792,
-0.0448291823,
-0.4907665849,
0.2798199058,
0.5874321461,
0.6617210507,
0.2787882388,
0.0637144521,
1.1258146763,
-0.513476789,
0.7697411776,
-0.052710928,
-1.2145100832,
0.6898101568,
0.0160781518,
0.4497778416,
0.6416071057,
0.2248644978,
-0.5572531819,
-0.4755447507,
-0.4064277112,
-0.7938120961,
0.9543135762,
-0.1925747097,
0.2552520335,
-0.3080801964,
0.2644560039,
0.266232729,
0.050601583,
-0.7426019311,
-0.0773767307,
-0.1506403536,
-0.5022697449,
0.1239708737,
-0.1973861009,
0.0441737249,
-0.4004119933,
0.5121406317,
-0.6728515625,
-0.1232044771,
0.2256383151,
-0.6595293283,
0.2763548195,
0.2628233731,
0.4311345816,
0.8750368357,
0.0563273616,
0.5691338181,
0.2478601485,
-0.1439270675,
-0.0053707538,
-0.1248973012,
-0.1652602702,
-0.1852844357,
0.5621877909,
0.6510243416,
0.4984251857,
-1.2711254358,
0.7307719588,
-0.0216197651,
0.1004722267,
-0.0871346965,
0.3217914701,
-0.0970819592,
0.3327185512,
0.0566353872,
-0.1193414405,
0.2659714818,
-0.5043234825,
0.4776522517,
0.307777822,
-0.09554483,
-0.0585070476,
0.2786875069,
-0.0673266649,
-0.0046813339,
0.5264779925,
-0.2647716999,
-0.5663516521,
0.557698667,
1.04695189,
0.6897932887,
0.2691215873,
0.1534101218,
0.0536917523,
-0.2475845814,
0.1342113763,
0.0004942349,
-0.6592761278,
-0.6186628938,
-0.5629039407,
-0.7555875778,
-0.4117953181,
-0.279109925,
-0.3976333439,
0.5214809179,
-0.4765292704,
0.3251855075,
-0.306062907,
0.0358550139,
-0.6026531458,
0.0908665434,
0.3354781866,
1.0524675846,
-0.579413712,
1.0024504662,
0.8051010966,
-0.2291448563,
-0.6111172438,
0.1519594193,
-0.2651835978,
-0.5830834508,
1.0614757538,
0.3908462226,
-0.0992513224,
-0.1521247029,
-0.7329207659,
-0.8347454667,
0.9492518902,
0.3508596122,
-0.1511546671,
0.2043335438,
0.4471976161,
0.4781042337,
-0.8106634617,
0.058298368,
0.6392129064,
0.1035273001,
0.1394124329,
-0.5589702129,
-0.1483325213,
0.0326897912,
0.3660246134,
0.0574769415,
-0.3519072831,
0.79521209,
-0.0355961882,
-0.2567802072,
-0.0544097424,
0.8063001633,
0.4170988798,
0.6026411653,
0.4060646594,
0.5547426939,
0.7396932244,
0.1693897545,
1.0117009878,
-0.2482717782,
0.2481572628,
1.2790340185,
-0.534086287,
0.7238113284,
0.6007379889,
-0.0577617586,
0.5689526796,
0.2998572886,
0.2996215224,
0.7175734043,
0.1665779054,
-0.5726866126,
-0.3400574028,
-0.0255343765,
-0.0931485444,
0.4673911929,
0.5310408473,
-0.3175218999,
-0.8160949945,
0.386739701,
0.0934380293,
0.3577171862,
-0.2183492035,
0.8706049919,
0.1106267646,
-0.4478991926,
0.521568656,
0.0063013043,
0.6871961951,
-0.6219298244,
-0.2018378377,
-0.0995463505,
0.3599349558,
-0.2841070592,
-0.6589909196,
0.443490535,
0.2257145792,
0.0348123014,
-0.3636061549,
0.8666226268,
-0.4599404931,
-0.1887164563,
0.4759848416,
0.1340177506,
0.1763441861,
-0.0139493365,
-0.5034608841,
0.1680986732,
0.0608361922,
0.2081571817,
0.6110972762,
0.4974517822,
0.0017070953,
0.5732872486,
0.6361399889,
-0.1496316344,
0.3041139543,
0.0860341936,
1.3218985796,
-0.5748707652,
-0.4895099699,
-0.8674443364,
0.5254047513,
-0.0081076268,
-0.2353532314,
0.6576234102,
0.6201192141,
1.534455657,
-0.2052136362,
0.6376190782,
-0.185582906,
0.3291066885,
-0.6981223822,
0.2029443532,
-0.4969537556,
0.5381625891,
-0.1846154779,
-0.8729597926,
-0.7249687314,
0.6808030009,
-0.3255704641,
-0.4175096154,
0.6421954632,
0.7739724517,
-0.2953395844,
-0.0516566671,
0.5502007604,
-0.2784253657,
0.6030882001,
0.5317811966,
1.1180843115,
-0.1769762337,
0.256175518,
-0.6953279376,
-0.2236820608,
-0.0604212619,
-0.8961648941,
-0.8493075967,
-0.292388916,
-0.2920758724,
-0.2104777992,
-0.0308680832,
1.372461319,
0.4745748937,
-0.785266757,
-0.2989736795,
-0.0737206563,
0.0432051867,
-0.0775292963,
-0.2065121531,
0.3055393994,
-1.3032919168,
-0.7661387324,
0.7183351517,
0.3888235092,
-0.3170521259,
0.3035548925,
-0.2868921161,
-0.0270496868,
-0.2814618051,
1.046710372,
0.0846896693,
-0.8571989536,
-0.3673953116,
-0.2065673023,
-0.1713878959,
0.2347691059,
1.0676050186,
-0.8952011466,
0.2901575565,
0.5472226739,
0.9107294083,
0.2177454233,
0.0891271755,
0.2094464153,
-0.68953228,
0.2932969332,
0.2755456269,
0.5409494638,
0.3070422113,
-0.2459706962,
0.4515968263,
0.3408753276,
-0.3957214952,
-0.5578327179,
0.2515807152,
-0.9264454246,
-0.5056121945,
1.2326619625,
-0.3217022717,
-0.4184259176,
-0.155925855,
-0.328905344,
-0.1888937205,
-0.2017782778,
0.3922905922,
0.3481288552,
-0.4661599696,
0.2136601657,
-0.1642002761,
0.5537558198,
0.3496503532,
-0.7620708942,
-0.0233681295,
0.5908181071,
0.389962405,
-0.2040822655,
0.5303341746,
-0.264054656,
0.1874949932,
-0.3102960885,
-0.2997678518,
0.0913802162,
-0.5762354136,
-0.5679184794,
0.121819444,
0.1486427337,
0.0491277613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09517v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09517v1
|
GEE! Grammar Error Explanation with Large Language Models
| 2023-11-16T02:45:47 | 2023-11-16T02:45:47 |
Yixiao Song, Kalpesh Krishna, Rajesh Bhatt, Kevin Gimpel, Mohit Iyyer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Grammatical error correction tools are effective at correcting grammatical
errors in users' input sentences but do not provide users with \textit{natural
language} explanations about their errors. Such explanations are essential for
helping users learn the language by gaining a deeper understanding of its
grammatical rules (DeKeyser, 2003; Ellis et al., 2006). To address this gap, we
propose the task of grammar error explanation, where a system needs to provide
one-sentence explanations for each grammatical error in a pair of erroneous and
corrected sentences. We analyze the capability of GPT-4 in grammar error
explanation, and find that it only produces explanations for 60.2% of the
errors using one-shot prompting. To improve upon this performance, we develop a
two-step pipeline that leverages fine-tuned and prompted large language models
to perform structured atomic token edit extraction, followed by prompting GPT-4
to generate explanations. We evaluate our pipeline on German and Chinese
grammar error correction data sampled from language learners with a wide range
of proficiency levels. Human evaluation reveals that our pipeline produces
93.9% and 98.0% correct explanations for German and Chinese data, respectively.
To encourage further research in this area, we will open-source our data and
code.
|
[
0.0179097708,
-1.3822323084,
0.8244242072,
0.145329535,
-0.0851033181,
-0.350548625,
-0.192563042,
-0.111232549,
-0.2213846296,
-0.0648363531,
-0.8664559126,
-0.5946034789,
-0.498737365,
0.1475286931,
-0.2539353371,
1.0177618265,
0.0194401629,
0.3811976016,
-0.085462749,
0.4016804993,
-0.6594515443,
-0.2741836905,
-0.7154358029,
0.0580147989,
0.667227447,
0.833632946,
0.8560407758,
0.6138066053,
0.4508244693,
0.3351270258,
-0.1139443219,
-0.0186753478,
-0.4484692812,
-0.4046205878,
-0.2543765008,
-0.2630555034,
-0.8282207251,
-0.2069686055,
0.6608651876,
0.8460589647,
-0.0804226249,
0.134631142,
-0.1398693472,
0.656873107,
-0.2797408998,
0.3039605618,
-0.4503587484,
0.1462602615,
-0.4552700818,
0.0261540338,
-0.2659413815,
-0.4351450205,
-0.1604387909,
-0.7599861026,
0.5481437445,
-0.212513566,
0.8348400593,
0.1953711808,
-0.1227461621,
-0.1873498857,
-0.5578536391,
0.3144905269,
-0.8835511208,
0.1088633239,
0.2898492217,
0.1971762925,
-0.3112747073,
-0.7709280252,
-0.7714375854,
0.1584285498,
-0.1695230752,
0.2543528676,
-0.1362206191,
0.2058793604,
0.4444526434,
0.4526691735,
-0.9258583784,
0.1016293913,
-0.378059715,
-0.3638326824,
0.4142143726,
0.0459579378,
0.6021210551,
-0.3283856511,
-0.0464147031,
0.0535152964,
-0.4291798472,
0.0369383842,
0.4852268398,
0.316206485,
-0.1355245262,
0.4200983644,
0.027343953,
0.7495889664,
0.1286726147,
0.2449745089,
0.16614151,
-0.466704607,
-0.4115516543,
-0.2114362866,
0.7228230834,
0.3203419447,
0.2452363223,
-0.2705782056,
-0.0337089486,
0.1366631091,
0.1012121662,
-0.5540127158,
-0.2526825964,
0.3610856235,
-0.2773857713,
-0.1239462644,
0.3932050169,
-1.1542880535,
-0.1354281157,
-0.1597622782,
0.5702664852,
-0.1730970293,
-0.2351776361,
0.3967293203,
-0.4336342216,
-0.0652523264,
0.2382232398,
-1.2046689987,
0.0989808813,
0.5742294788,
0.6826773882,
0.2003403604,
-0.4865486026,
-0.7873194814,
-0.0638634562,
-0.3158976138,
0.6761196852,
-0.358825475,
-0.3752503991,
0.1223328784,
0.1606988609,
-0.1606819779,
-0.2606235743,
0.6765807867,
-0.2727523744,
0.7357646823,
-0.4844981134,
-0.5853688717,
-0.3430271447,
0.0382106192,
-0.5494189858,
0.8723302484,
0.4175647497,
-0.6036925316,
0.4515496492,
-0.9890742302,
-0.3307258487,
0.0914454758,
0.0400569178,
-0.4280974269,
0.1763485521,
0.5515806079,
0.3489570022,
0.0365729444,
0.3629915416,
-0.1531500071,
-0.5363269448,
0.0146282464,
-0.3707713485,
1.1201817989,
-0.0597835556,
-0.5312368274,
0.414115876,
-0.7486614585,
0.115101181,
0.3188581467,
-0.3783423305,
0.1956958622,
-0.0821278021,
-0.1480841339,
0.05941955,
0.1995007098,
-0.3965709507,
0.2331085801,
-0.2340517789,
0.634390533,
0.9075662494,
-0.1351867318,
0.4299412072,
0.1486696899,
0.8036387563,
-0.0531044416,
0.3859357536,
-0.4409966171,
-0.5258304477,
-0.577598691,
-0.0701455995,
0.2472199351,
0.5537155271,
-0.4443971813,
0.3349012434,
-0.3344959021,
-0.1529975235,
-0.3820559978,
0.2450800538,
0.4993555546,
0.7041704059,
0.3048398793,
0.0463396832,
-0.6247717738,
-0.6685426235,
-0.4791021943,
-0.4429867268,
-0.080304414,
-0.0453986563,
0.4602088034,
-0.3573259413,
0.9765970707,
-0.3914618194,
-0.0055743759,
-0.1048332229,
0.1252407879,
0.1590237021,
0.1596309245,
0.4464781582,
-0.6771354079,
-0.256599009,
0.0129334694,
-0.7393036485,
-0.2318781167,
-0.0486949347,
-0.2904235721,
0.1703218818,
0.5212215781,
-0.528041482,
0.2259618789,
0.5827478766,
-0.6624455452,
0.7595555186,
-0.2150659859,
-0.1001061648,
-0.7765849829,
-0.0627005175,
-0.127210483,
-0.3214166164,
-0.4887842238,
0.2791436613,
0.146521911,
-0.1043428481,
-0.2944259346,
0.3730340302,
-0.2740121484,
-0.0149993449,
0.0921557248,
0.2481084913,
0.0708454996,
0.5381620526,
-0.5673708916,
0.6929673553,
0.6694900393,
-0.3143333793,
0.4926280975,
0.3137430549,
0.1328169107,
0.1584413946,
-0.683516264,
0.2556622326,
-0.2190192491,
0.1456532925,
-1.3963019848,
-0.8402639627,
0.5509707928,
-0.6062117219,
0.1634750068,
-0.2770217657,
-0.4240433574,
-0.6251513958,
-0.1776463538,
-0.0189670641,
0.3821047246,
-0.7531147599,
0.4944658279,
0.0063281558,
-0.331468761,
-0.4715554118,
-0.7043844461,
0.161134541,
-0.1207848191,
-0.851377666,
-0.056766171,
-0.0831838772,
-0.2885504663,
0.2647405565,
-0.1440742314,
-0.0770701542,
0.2537717223,
0.2639306188,
0.4851506054,
-0.3691824973,
0.3772641718,
-0.1730616987,
-0.1639256477,
0.3060899377,
-0.310954541,
0.2010340244,
-0.3457682431,
-0.4095366299,
-0.4747550786,
0.3179127872,
0.544465363,
0.040726658,
0.557433188,
0.6483905315,
-0.3327902257,
0.0121078109,
-0.4051170945,
-0.1242433339,
-0.4288157821,
0.4582033455,
-0.324320972,
-0.7599641681,
0.5468075275,
0.3459852636,
0.0936903432,
0.7369299531,
0.4074386656,
0.0319564044,
1.1839063168,
0.4477034211,
-0.1287932396,
0.4806566536,
0.156050548,
0.3409895301,
-0.1859717816,
-0.0310844705,
-0.55775249,
-0.0821906328,
-0.4325637519,
-0.210887745,
0.1771337241,
0.2798343599,
-0.4094270766,
-0.0709291995,
-0.2613538802,
0.6543542743,
0.6570329666,
-0.0171083026,
0.2405518442,
0.1851766557,
0.0232828688,
0.0678930655,
-0.7405096292,
-0.5517885089,
0.7494063973,
0.3440270722,
0.4860209823,
0.2243794352,
0.5211378932,
0.1033522412,
0.0118412161,
-0.8578419685,
0.4430376589,
-0.313013941,
-0.7085468769,
-0.6027488708,
-0.4602334201,
-0.617393434,
0.155090183,
0.040549539,
-0.6331844926,
-0.1614774019,
0.5002393126,
-0.2892699242,
0.131902203,
-1.2994357347,
1.4033538103,
-0.1222529262,
-0.245406583,
0.1319642514,
-0.6455669999,
0.4694196582,
0.0509254597,
0.4106145799,
0.2397534996,
0.304754287,
0.4042100608,
-0.6282027364,
0.8077892661,
-0.4149479568,
-0.1469039321,
0.1984806061,
-0.0326232463,
0.6473440528,
-0.0675773174,
-0.1437536776,
0.3617576063,
-0.4944662452,
-0.3814333975,
-0.704554975,
0.4433675408,
-0.5298740864,
-0.5913585424,
-0.0430007577,
-0.2701874375,
0.0547834262,
0.1802891195,
0.443176955,
0.4702326357,
-0.1474286616,
-0.2063915282,
0.0834976062,
-0.085233748,
0.4571777582,
0.2927533388,
-0.2906984389,
-0.0757982209,
0.7705751657,
0.0061829458,
0.2029545605,
-0.0199385174,
0.3686147928,
-0.2108497471,
-0.5420240164,
-0.951993525,
0.2153661996,
-0.9534727931,
0.1486306787,
-0.5525507927,
0.1219469607,
-0.5191546082,
-0.0908951685,
0.0661511943,
-0.4955185354,
-0.3282305002,
-0.3505910337,
0.2864869833,
0.8476557732,
-0.1385199875,
0.5253819227,
-0.9338404536,
0.42955634,
0.4448179305,
0.4520946741,
-0.1447732151,
-0.6344753504,
-0.2531051934,
0.1606639326,
-0.2275400758,
-0.9405981302,
0.0932460353,
0.2984710336,
0.2680659592,
0.4585332274,
-0.7295122743,
1.2426886559,
-0.8307139874,
1.235401988,
0.0325438045,
-1.395236969,
0.7530544996,
-0.5200461745,
0.3782587349,
0.1812949479,
-0.0661409795,
-0.7524471283,
-0.4195164144,
-0.6635090113,
-0.8031545877,
0.8659823537,
-0.0274063274,
0.0868045911,
-0.2834110558,
0.6109517813,
0.15923585,
-0.228662625,
-0.7603295445,
-0.0591792837,
-0.2455366552,
-0.2308148891,
-0.1616086364,
-0.4446144402,
-0.0737740993,
-0.037404336,
0.9189620018,
-0.2826024592,
0.2586748898,
0.2439900786,
-0.1690703034,
-0.5818964243,
0.4548588693,
0.5750347376,
1.1537986994,
0.1598507017,
0.0914916247,
0.0689589009,
-0.3960424364,
-0.1856278181,
0.203473419,
0.0771864727,
0.2702070773,
0.5209107399,
0.6609787345,
0.0157499425,
-0.6027166247,
0.6292569041,
-0.1710251123,
-0.3073787093,
-0.2817287743,
0.0377358347,
0.2553177774,
0.0317982733,
0.2659769952,
-0.1863815933,
0.2433474213,
-0.571721375,
-0.0810224041,
0.3891828954,
0.034845084,
-0.5621789098,
0.8084651828,
0.1181157157,
-0.2899019122,
0.721555233,
-0.446028471,
-0.6833382845,
0.600906074,
0.4813482165,
0.7618457675,
-0.1051465645,
0.4401613772,
0.46494326,
0.1998962611,
-0.2265715897,
0.2888696492,
0.4137687683,
-0.5651201606,
-0.8811492324,
-0.2626363635,
-0.3404880166,
0.0626400933,
-0.5907920599,
0.2312674075,
-0.3548609912,
0.1288166791,
0.2829933167,
-0.4821336567,
-0.6366590858,
0.1812165976,
0.1708343774,
0.5720967054,
-1.0307511091,
0.1195013076,
0.7206293344,
-0.5413861871,
-1.1356556416,
0.092789188,
0.3891393244,
-0.8335325122,
0.695269227,
0.1533447653,
-0.0443262011,
0.0659178644,
-0.7081798911,
-0.4936778545,
0.6277272701,
0.5790786147,
-0.7648329139,
-0.2404753268,
-0.042746719,
0.54097718,
0.1550258696,
0.1650978774,
0.5486111641,
0.7613343596,
-0.1939430386,
-0.8688108921,
-0.0142233716,
-0.1324760616,
-0.1032325998,
0.3169146776,
-0.2483763546,
1.0254069567,
-0.3297750354,
-0.4288525879,
0.0306565706,
0.422342509,
-0.3108640611,
0.2484881133,
0.493055135,
0.6324517131,
1.0844845772,
-0.4377064109,
1.2945144176,
0.1555710435,
0.5299725533,
1.1365927458,
0.1159732938,
0.5374017954,
0.3377797902,
-0.3673465848,
0.7316494584,
0.821944356,
0.0669885427,
-0.0007161878,
-0.000191052,
-0.189787671,
-0.1430245191,
0.4016777277,
-0.181185618,
0.451857239,
0.2220018655,
-0.2677347064,
-0.2619033456,
-0.0450687483,
0.1629202813,
-0.0920737907,
-0.4981985986,
0.7728592753,
-0.4310848713,
-0.6603412032,
0.4272584915,
0.0107111279,
0.2807928026,
-0.3521756232,
-0.2500508428,
-0.307469964,
0.3060816824,
-0.491052866,
-0.5989094973,
0.1255425215,
0.3692368269,
-0.3708029687,
-0.1030781716,
0.5077677965,
-0.4616621435,
-0.5461158752,
-0.0181354154,
0.6124474406,
0.4182221591,
-0.1552480906,
-0.5907133222,
-0.0787039101,
0.0232493747,
-0.1009364277,
-0.214425981,
0.6791202426,
0.0217256118,
0.245946914,
0.5670796037,
-0.0146490959,
0.3060993254,
0.3772646189,
0.6263757944,
-0.669260025,
-0.6072175503,
-1.199806571,
0.9150452018,
-0.030817695,
-0.3174481392,
0.8584187031,
0.3649158478,
0.893368721,
-0.3672469258,
0.972194314,
-0.178889811,
0.522269249,
-0.7141688466,
0.0838877037,
-0.4426111281,
0.0943442881,
-0.2333884835,
-0.890488863,
-0.4813495874,
0.6570375562,
-0.1676325053,
0.1118218973,
0.9517127872,
0.8192565441,
-0.0275815241,
0.2683026195,
0.1110984758,
0.5666816831,
0.3393002152,
0.2946941555,
0.5603089333,
-0.3489519358,
0.4682863355,
0.0897745118,
-0.1938819438,
-0.3248344064,
-0.8815120459,
-0.6170633435,
-0.2061359882,
-0.2994860411,
-0.3627672791,
0.3375647366,
0.6265144348,
0.4688875079,
-0.6869997382,
0.2413637489,
-0.5976024866,
0.1624779105,
-0.2952571213,
-0.3052389324,
0.4736725688,
-0.7117097378,
-0.9787197113,
0.4254263937,
0.0992901325,
-0.0656827986,
-0.1400886476,
-0.0012332746,
0.0791218206,
-0.3797651231,
0.4970549941,
0.1945081055,
-0.9291081429,
-0.7176482677,
0.069999449,
0.0648387298,
0.1428195685,
0.8446070552,
-0.355360657,
0.7946650386,
0.4858208895,
0.6622812748,
-0.0024030001,
0.1344592273,
0.5780091286,
-0.8294472098,
-0.046954602,
-0.1748448461,
0.4523036182,
0.4592131376,
-0.5715299249,
0.6222502589,
0.2415928394,
-0.7394121885,
-0.4976329803,
-0.0142787984,
-0.8469623923,
-0.2789029181,
1.2348581553,
-0.3490378261,
-0.133085981,
-0.0708850324,
-0.4568565488,
0.4691928625,
-0.3167343438,
0.7056760192,
1.3360860348,
0.0597596876,
-0.0258294232,
-0.7903831601,
0.3717573881,
0.4914713204,
-0.9592434764,
0.2321082801,
1.0576577187,
0.4398989081,
0.0407174937,
0.4314047098,
-0.2389506847,
0.8687719703,
0.0602734834,
0.0293679722,
-0.0936447829,
-0.2005070597,
-0.8134171367,
-0.0994851366,
0.0000280565,
-0.3608562946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09513v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09513v1
|
Sequencing Matters: A Generate-Retrieve-Generate Model for Building Conversational Agents
| 2023-11-16T02:37:58 | 2023-11-16T02:37:58 |
Quinn Patwardhan, Grace Hui Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper contains what the Georgetown InfoSense group has done in regard to
solving the challenges presented by TREC iKAT 2023. Our submitted runs
outperform the median runs by a significant margin, exhibiting superior
performance in nDCG across various cut numbers and in overall success rate. Our
approach uses a Generate-Retrieve-Generate method, which we've found to greatly
outpace Retrieve-Then-Generate approaches for the purposes of iKAT. Our
solution involves the use of Large Language Models (LLMs) for initial answers,
answer grounding by BM25, passage quality filtering by logistic regression, and
answer generation by LLMs again. We leverage several purpose-built Language
Models, including BERT, Chat-based, and text-to-transfer-based models, for text
understanding, classification, generation, and summarization. The official
results of the TREC evaluation contradict our initial self-evaluation, which
may suggest that a decrease in the reliance on our retrieval and classification
methods is better. Nonetheless, our findings suggest that the sequence of
involving these different components matters, where we see an essentiality of
using LLMs before using search engines.
|
[
-0.5394384265,
-0.7308180332,
0.7041577101,
0.136965096,
-0.2687107921,
0.4074822366,
-0.0505878814,
-0.4747000635,
0.1474268585,
0.6092012525,
-0.5974169374,
-0.5389500856,
-0.6278623343,
0.4016866684,
-0.5654754043,
0.9663257003,
0.2688335776,
-0.2198186815,
-0.1813958585,
0.0059915688,
-0.6226203442,
-0.1463818699,
-0.8003510833,
-0.2185771465,
0.5686408281,
0.9324199557,
0.6926782131,
1.0439825058,
0.6062409878,
0.2830125391,
-0.1528709084,
-0.0639224574,
-0.5103051662,
0.5022575855,
0.0230581183,
-0.3389114439,
-0.3110127151,
0.0179730095,
0.4343421459,
0.8973809481,
-0.2617293596,
0.2405064702,
-0.2517334223,
0.7639280558,
-0.2479982525,
0.2402554005,
-0.6775426269,
-0.1511776,
0.0226347391,
-0.1091614589,
-0.6646257043,
-0.6112534404,
0.3911444545,
-0.41906932,
0.1199219152,
0.106750764,
0.5589943528,
0.0359357744,
-0.7457950711,
-0.5357120633,
-0.8272093534,
0.6863999367,
-0.8644362092,
0.2339408994,
0.4515220523,
0.2840683162,
-0.2977850437,
-0.9616699219,
-0.4887417853,
-0.5332685709,
0.068531245,
0.0622520261,
0.0676101372,
0.223222211,
0.288888365,
0.3290966749,
-0.7318276763,
0.0047630672,
-0.499589771,
0.0424751639,
0.578158319,
0.3831459284,
0.156976983,
-0.35344401,
-0.091640085,
-0.291221112,
-0.7951452732,
-0.051043734,
0.498134017,
0.296919167,
0.122056663,
1.0143905878,
-0.389647305,
0.5908155441,
0.2925217152,
0.0902856514,
-0.2383514792,
-0.42194888,
0.0436291508,
0.2199476361,
0.5632485747,
0.1042476371,
0.1827566624,
-0.0585986115,
0.1268943697,
-0.143154487,
0.5447187424,
-0.9453343749,
-0.2178140581,
0.4475352168,
-0.4729748666,
-0.3275798857,
0.2191746682,
-0.700222075,
-0.3534121513,
-0.5076748729,
0.1106268167,
-0.4014904499,
-0.2238718867,
-0.0907914937,
0.1742440611,
0.3718737066,
0.103272289,
-0.738879323,
0.2736606002,
0.8193539381,
0.759775281,
-0.2599630654,
0.0459532142,
-0.3617622554,
-0.0654296726,
-0.3796548247,
0.7896614075,
-0.6490296125,
-0.6357990503,
0.0448516421,
-0.1720523983,
0.0172583219,
-0.5516227484,
0.3131297827,
-0.7234190702,
0.2648591101,
-0.4122652113,
-0.7136435509,
-0.1508490592,
0.1546177268,
-0.7847983241,
0.9009702802,
0.1296375245,
-0.7216873765,
0.135023728,
-0.8344737291,
-0.6653705239,
0.2076656669,
0.0629963875,
-0.3510365784,
-0.0227235276,
0.0198393576,
0.5892318487,
-0.2612141967,
0.5163943768,
-0.0700406581,
-0.2876465321,
0.3177455366,
-0.0047614858,
0.4541823268,
0.4841654003,
-0.3868592381,
0.0199495181,
-0.8617358804,
0.1823218316,
0.141756922,
-0.4725964665,
0.0756667405,
0.1046653241,
-0.3544103503,
0.0660722405,
0.0412815697,
-0.5650589466,
0.3218693733,
-0.3300231993,
0.4575352073,
0.9161056876,
0.1823787242,
0.4596263468,
-0.3735987246,
0.7144703269,
-0.0111059258,
-0.0659296066,
-0.5910476446,
-0.5765256882,
-0.8931095004,
0.1541984975,
0.2217857093,
0.4159300625,
-0.9456785917,
0.2460763156,
-0.357621491,
-0.7511443496,
-0.3494484127,
-0.1833375096,
0.2043286413,
0.6545796394,
0.1678624898,
-0.3782794178,
-0.6433832049,
-0.7451094389,
-0.1936572045,
-0.5758974552,
0.1186175495,
0.3466093838,
0.3366672099,
-0.1943808347,
0.9934878349,
-0.4212769866,
0.3524159193,
-0.5796616673,
0.5790946484,
0.2596571743,
0.1987838894,
0.2481373698,
-0.7578598857,
-0.5737573504,
0.0302523617,
-0.5937018394,
-0.3597265482,
0.0784665868,
-0.1440262944,
0.2720988393,
0.3965384364,
-0.7454507947,
0.5733593106,
0.2471157461,
-0.2728146911,
0.6679060459,
0.1848994195,
0.3929844201,
-1.3894304037,
0.150353089,
-0.1893278211,
-0.3415780663,
-0.7905295491,
-0.0961828753,
-0.0772948116,
-0.2964369655,
-0.2859973907,
0.6220744252,
-0.3094621301,
-0.0720679313,
-0.4311159253,
0.0295198504,
0.0230898913,
0.5041794777,
-0.0611820966,
0.8859030604,
0.1893483996,
-1.0242048502,
0.3365059197,
0.4176046848,
-0.2994630039,
0.5032406449,
-0.6293733716,
0.5544115305,
-0.0781062171,
0.1799044907,
-1.1600335836,
-0.4301321805,
0.2320013195,
-0.7014356852,
0.423887074,
-0.1085896567,
-0.3200161159,
-0.6308666468,
-0.1583795398,
0.4244584441,
0.4038613141,
-0.4110171795,
0.6225214601,
0.3099155128,
-0.7357524037,
-0.5496265292,
-0.5956708193,
0.2889600396,
-0.1899641007,
-0.7172239423,
0.0570192225,
-0.3011502326,
-0.2594293654,
-0.2291039824,
-0.2230904102,
0.0787890851,
0.0488037616,
0.0849936455,
0.0049476167,
-0.4100932181,
0.2977651656,
-0.2177987248,
-0.0669162422,
0.1310174018,
-0.4573706686,
0.7758979797,
-0.0491557904,
-0.3607516885,
-0.2578176558,
0.5900706053,
0.590498507,
-0.0943739936,
0.7552621365,
0.2198430598,
-0.0489956774,
0.1369485259,
-0.783188045,
-0.2917746305,
-0.5046029687,
0.457937181,
-0.1658357978,
-0.942767024,
0.6770003438,
0.0107648065,
0.1486029625,
0.4381710291,
0.5237729549,
-0.2598297596,
1.034681797,
0.7489306927,
0.1423093081,
0.6559913754,
-0.2052744627,
0.5375047922,
-0.5693691373,
-0.39788571,
-0.7255240679,
-0.120657593,
-0.7360450029,
0.0260953307,
0.2682953477,
-0.4514408708,
-0.25333637,
0.6216406226,
-0.4373379946,
0.422955364,
0.6580095291,
-0.0386309102,
0.3481992483,
-0.0233013649,
-0.0073786178,
-0.0088942563,
-0.674574554,
-0.8371530175,
1.3561069965,
-0.0486710444,
0.78586936,
0.1480398327,
0.5194732547,
0.5213639736,
0.3388673067,
-0.7085118294,
0.8582243323,
0.1676032394,
-0.4003168643,
-0.2235135287,
-0.7161137462,
-1.4133826494,
-0.0010748768,
0.3425831795,
-0.7108385563,
0.0774909034,
-0.2081982344,
-0.1000657007,
0.2225361615,
-0.8067381978,
0.6597409844,
-0.1204833761,
0.0319539197,
-0.0962713286,
-1.0213552713,
0.4985949397,
-0.0305415057,
-0.1152066067,
-0.192213133,
0.2668967843,
0.8176982403,
-0.5936382413,
0.4318399429,
0.1325098276,
0.0562597886,
0.7983890772,
0.3668637872,
0.5518913865,
-0.0739976168,
-0.0628771037,
-0.1966755241,
-0.1386107355,
-0.463552624,
-0.5113876462,
0.448223263,
-0.6908407211,
-0.7818040252,
-0.413713932,
-0.3497605622,
-0.1467571706,
0.1379934251,
0.2726012766,
0.4473561645,
-0.2505195439,
0.3415833712,
0.7180194855,
-0.1902823448,
0.5730509758,
0.7037969828,
-0.0082253013,
-0.3750949204,
0.6705670953,
0.0767441988,
0.5275749564,
0.2985301018,
0.0686695129,
-0.3018317521,
-0.5407636166,
-0.0352712646,
0.2603124082,
-0.7952485085,
-0.417806685,
-0.9905911088,
-0.3639454842,
-0.8208041787,
0.1250983477,
-0.3663417995,
-0.4713522494,
-0.3313326538,
-0.3278846443,
0.3835568726,
1.1825220585,
-0.0994722843,
0.7066650391,
-0.7176243067,
0.5138776302,
0.3769161105,
0.1162103638,
-0.1019376665,
-0.6811358333,
-0.3304532766,
0.2065356523,
-0.6616233587,
-1.093162179,
0.2650499344,
0.0679410547,
0.3512818217,
0.1470742524,
0.1635753065,
0.646455884,
-0.1827779561,
0.7748228312,
-0.0723313689,
-0.8471938968,
0.8405191898,
-0.4539443552,
0.4749577343,
0.6585301161,
0.1792601049,
-0.8223625422,
-0.5637045503,
-0.7285948992,
-1.0695050955,
1.0246999264,
0.5410025716,
0.0916481316,
-0.4140335619,
0.4955979288,
0.1115331128,
0.434799552,
-0.7242658138,
-0.1649974585,
-0.0929480419,
-0.2743455172,
0.3184323907,
-0.5007024407,
0.3091549873,
0.083238095,
0.8927568793,
-0.1393810809,
0.4257559478,
0.1528070569,
-0.1363167465,
-0.1146653295,
0.2880722582,
0.564680934,
0.848175168,
-0.1094119847,
-0.1312119961,
-0.2479765862,
-0.7031992674,
0.3591861129,
0.1011693403,
-0.0496193953,
-0.1372767687,
0.2514620721,
0.6731997728,
-0.0793262944,
-0.6352672577,
0.4039538205,
-0.3700855374,
0.0875347555,
-0.0853362978,
-0.0748744085,
-0.1561022401,
0.2187736779,
0.5866032243,
-0.0691474155,
0.1213864982,
-0.5744608045,
0.3102296889,
0.0267189499,
-0.072340183,
-0.2753820121,
0.5746643543,
0.1525061876,
-0.5461824536,
0.9114991426,
-0.2101405263,
-0.4345406592,
1.1406294107,
0.2239010185,
1.004289031,
-0.5792444944,
0.5428684354,
0.4535876215,
0.3705082834,
-0.2557342947,
0.2070239335,
-0.0729899704,
-0.3652832806,
-0.581730783,
-0.2561552227,
-0.7187196016,
0.0299464371,
-0.6287131906,
0.2157862931,
-0.3236837387,
-0.1822180897,
-0.3687322438,
0.2496148199,
-0.8052250147,
0.1180288568,
0.0599966608,
0.7322262526,
-0.4551834166,
0.3566775024,
0.4654537439,
-0.3862561584,
-0.8770967722,
0.0204676893,
-0.2004317343,
-0.7044795752,
0.3396498859,
0.4355963767,
0.0496823303,
0.1365149319,
-0.8902260065,
-1.0648134947,
1.202278018,
0.4103318751,
-0.3255005479,
0.0770611539,
0.4140033722,
0.5573526621,
-0.4025138915,
0.4043423235,
0.639102757,
0.5716790557,
0.5467000604,
-0.793769598,
-0.0858635753,
-0.2616194189,
-0.009631345,
0.0208838973,
-0.5851511955,
0.7023784518,
-0.4032307565,
-0.6155152917,
0.559273243,
0.6594635248,
0.266810596,
0.2797056139,
0.1002985835,
0.5405573845,
0.7450766563,
-0.2400637865,
1.1776745319,
-0.1612024903,
0.0232074279,
1.288203001,
-0.4068676233,
0.4557792544,
0.2552924156,
-0.1930626184,
0.4873897135,
1.0387728214,
0.3013029397,
0.4780388176,
0.3181243241,
-0.0536860824,
0.013758569,
-0.2780089378,
-0.3823662102,
0.5289449692,
0.2698723972,
-0.2445999533,
-0.0783620477,
0.0095320679,
0.0898222476,
-0.0943630189,
-0.0930372253,
1.1374692917,
0.0685171187,
-1.1264157295,
0.0782618448,
0.0717044771,
0.059768077,
-0.6593340039,
-0.0456348918,
-0.6658825874,
-0.1563848853,
0.1869575828,
-0.8357813954,
0.2236925364,
0.007257517,
-0.000165356,
-0.2862672508,
0.6791603565,
-0.584371686,
-0.5026763082,
0.01699269,
0.559258163,
0.1765677929,
-0.1972388178,
-0.3604465425,
-0.2312498838,
-0.1532207429,
-0.3861423135,
-0.0258785151,
0.6391373873,
0.0648543835,
0.8549447656,
0.6271971464,
-0.2222421467,
0.4350824952,
0.0714637265,
0.7887403369,
-0.9296028018,
-0.5713595748,
-0.8736380935,
0.504848659,
-0.0727419183,
-0.0760808513,
0.4772964418,
0.5198810697,
0.6057193875,
0.1313498914,
0.6706463099,
-0.1613876522,
0.5392240286,
-0.4267924428,
0.4677453339,
-0.1294790804,
0.3660405278,
-0.1946381629,
-1.1638325453,
-0.0504068099,
0.3023495376,
-0.0278556682,
0.320775032,
0.749307394,
0.6045649052,
0.184494108,
0.2887055874,
0.1910349131,
0.3576171994,
0.5412316322,
0.5479294658,
1.0652656555,
-0.4825209677,
0.8734981418,
-0.0183593463,
0.1985141039,
-0.3551785946,
-0.8607148528,
-0.8217384219,
-0.6146925092,
-0.4222201109,
-0.3468374014,
-0.0648277625,
0.8028224111,
0.6806673408,
-0.7694473863,
-0.3207205534,
-0.2373728156,
0.4264229834,
0.148528263,
-0.2934005857,
0.0683912635,
-0.4292321503,
-0.4872862995,
0.2787592709,
0.2802188396,
0.3643865287,
-0.134242937,
-0.0302574709,
-0.3693112731,
0.2234978676,
0.4994404912,
0.3758119643,
-0.6864622831,
-0.3423165083,
0.3984429836,
-0.2148810476,
0.5068915486,
1.0497912169,
-0.8519407511,
0.6175345182,
0.4790939987,
0.7829964757,
0.5670935512,
0.1668202579,
0.8897689581,
-0.7549272776,
-0.0838686526,
0.4049689174,
0.2527756989,
0.4732498229,
-0.4532430768,
0.7167077065,
-0.0026571278,
-0.739312768,
-0.6764423847,
0.309366703,
-0.9289602637,
-0.0242034849,
1.1900866032,
0.0314278342,
-0.1950942576,
-0.2171850652,
-0.3091183305,
0.3865841329,
-0.4081392586,
0.9751834869,
1.0257198811,
-0.0013220805,
-0.2806215584,
-0.2918435931,
0.2367039919,
0.3570487797,
-1.0206456184,
-0.0351633877,
0.2422005981,
-0.03594945,
0.0435470007,
0.6788156629,
-0.0040471167,
0.1564766467,
-0.3778274655,
-0.0532075204,
0.1186651587,
-0.4018315375,
-0.0899010897,
-0.0630315468,
0.0627331212,
-0.0962537974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09510v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09510v3
|
Tailoring with Targeted Precision: Edit-Based Agents for Open-Domain Procedure Customization
| 2023-11-16T02:25:36 | 2024-05-31T01:32:23 |
Yash Kumar Lal, Li Zhang, Faeze Brahman, Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder, Peter Clark, Niket Tandon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
How-to procedures, such as how to plant a garden, are now used by millions of
users, but sometimes need customizing to meet a user's specific needs, e.g.,
planting a garden without pesticides. Our goal is to measure and improve an
LLM's ability to perform such customization. Our approach is to test several
simple multi-LLM-agent architectures for customization, as well as an
end-to-end LLM, using a new evaluation set, called CustomPlans, of over 200
WikiHow procedures each with a customization need. We find that a simple
architecture with two LLM agents used sequentially performs best, one that
edits a generic how-to procedure and one that verifies its executability,
significantly outperforming (10.5% absolute) an end-to-end prompted LLM. This
suggests that LLMs can be configured reasonably effectively for procedure
customization. This also suggests that multi-agent editing architectures may be
worth exploring further for other customization applications (e.g. coding,
creative writing) in the future.
|
[
-0.370986253,
-0.8908888698,
0.5657844543,
0.1414392292,
-0.061856132,
0.0784672052,
-0.3259824812,
-0.3000240922,
0.5279325247,
0.4884113967,
-0.5715078712,
-0.5758182406,
-0.4868710637,
0.4540092945,
-0.0572667271,
0.7934955359,
-0.1980789751,
0.0167051535,
-0.2837399542,
-0.3002509475,
-0.3194382191,
-0.1868868321,
-0.2062956244,
-0.2223093957,
0.3838864863,
0.6916983128,
1.1460365057,
0.9566745162,
0.6040104032,
0.4565883875,
-0.1001668945,
0.4835918844,
-0.3343301713,
0.2632523775,
-0.4180138707,
-0.3500963151,
-0.9381193519,
0.1201051548,
0.2336097062,
0.5485741496,
-0.0071454425,
0.2680085301,
-0.006458852,
0.6501085758,
-0.6669923663,
-0.1284348518,
-0.6073853374,
0.0710682496,
-0.1115665138,
-0.5840237141,
-0.2963370681,
-0.4243154228,
0.2849529088,
-1.0264501572,
0.2653201818,
-0.2264411449,
0.5781390667,
0.4767279625,
-0.3213203549,
-0.3891469538,
-0.7343147993,
0.5229927897,
-0.6840324998,
0.2849470377,
0.1744823158,
0.4135455787,
-0.3971911967,
-0.8826944232,
-0.2799690664,
-0.3736635745,
0.0033777375,
0.2930908501,
0.0315979347,
0.2236582339,
0.3120843768,
0.0607146733,
-0.6218556166,
-0.0504116565,
-0.1154656187,
-0.3249614239,
0.5448978543,
0.1078993753,
0.1203130856,
0.2095702291,
-0.1967730075,
0.016888909,
-0.4028276205,
-0.1420560479,
0.3548102081,
0.1841082424,
0.3415860236,
0.8230111003,
-0.4826613665,
0.8065251112,
0.3494155407,
-0.2364141345,
0.1773001701,
-0.385081023,
-0.5818545818,
-0.1994310915,
0.4539771974,
0.5135413408,
0.3449853063,
-0.2160516232,
-0.3113333881,
-0.3721512258,
0.537763834,
-0.6917872429,
-0.1832262874,
0.4253596961,
-0.5651403069,
-0.2495889515,
-0.0187760908,
-0.3948180377,
-0.4300039113,
-0.57951051,
0.4401199222,
-0.420665741,
0.3046565056,
0.0271561444,
-0.65375036,
0.157322377,
0.7501542568,
-0.6085965633,
0.3550753593,
0.8207141757,
0.932145834,
-0.2178440094,
-0.4681646228,
-0.5828499198,
0.2746267915,
-0.5881537795,
1.0539501905,
-0.6012765765,
-0.5323902965,
0.001993414,
-0.2021425366,
0.0789164901,
-0.6140013337,
0.096650064,
-0.6865701675,
0.0173199978,
-0.3283497095,
-0.7683336735,
0.1468870044,
0.607534349,
-0.507584691,
0.4888243973,
0.2508298159,
-0.3081193268,
0.5032592416,
-1.0279877186,
-0.3607728779,
0.0679181144,
-0.0930245891,
-0.441175133,
0.1402522624,
0.0532893799,
0.2386776358,
0.1185913533,
-0.1379023641,
-0.4172766507,
-0.2412583232,
0.2440091968,
-0.1722720265,
0.6368594766,
0.1516982168,
-0.2999559343,
0.6491855383,
-0.8545227051,
0.239037618,
-0.1465370208,
-0.6020991206,
-0.0554871187,
-0.3126313984,
-0.0642185956,
-0.098077774,
0.5765333772,
-0.4604653418,
0.4746107459,
-0.4916702807,
0.1007801369,
0.98148489,
0.1709094793,
0.7217873335,
-0.7121174335,
0.647744894,
-0.4095287323,
0.6174563169,
0.0441289358,
-0.5633020997,
-0.667078793,
-0.2693026662,
0.07648886,
0.6405543685,
-0.7289890051,
0.2925780714,
0.1046362445,
-0.7266464233,
-0.1930284649,
0.120250456,
0.4878762066,
0.5697038174,
0.2495626211,
-0.5453040004,
-0.1910081804,
-0.8340909481,
-0.3725390732,
0.0592100732,
0.0336033776,
0.3967121243,
0.5192886591,
-0.1924385726,
1.1436371803,
-0.6714161634,
-0.3119829595,
0.15673244,
-0.1283950359,
0.0772837326,
0.0581196807,
0.7176868916,
-0.7147357464,
-0.8509448767,
0.2239649892,
-0.4617336094,
-0.2006916255,
-0.0212277267,
-0.2220057547,
0.3493098021,
0.2577947676,
-0.7580634952,
0.6651678085,
0.0659984723,
-0.2450263798,
0.9401907325,
-0.7023533583,
0.4077591598,
-1.0999743938,
-0.1639057547,
-0.119180195,
-0.279746592,
-0.8296754956,
0.2398650944,
0.2156322151,
0.1238525435,
-0.7192231417,
0.4564464092,
-0.6318553686,
-0.2906019986,
-0.4873792827,
-0.0255594291,
0.0721985474,
0.4282453358,
-0.1158827767,
0.9732804298,
0.3647491932,
-0.5739160776,
0.5991714597,
0.4620102048,
0.0268167313,
0.8202773929,
-0.6811984777,
0.5102525949,
-0.0882780105,
0.0549902245,
-0.7321284413,
-0.5105766654,
0.3583121598,
-0.4673486948,
0.1328120083,
-0.0913828164,
-0.3070324361,
0.1835388839,
-0.7428790927,
-0.1521891356,
0.3916184604,
-0.4114817679,
0.7124827504,
0.0726486668,
0.0699608028,
-0.6922696829,
-0.5470653772,
0.2388870865,
-0.1436345875,
-0.6948465109,
0.4891648293,
-0.4648634195,
-0.4690494239,
-0.0458472744,
0.0705238804,
-0.2840153277,
0.1291760653,
0.2587995231,
0.0065899766,
-0.1882930845,
0.1669482589,
0.0729912072,
0.0359734073,
-0.1836690009,
-0.3394680917,
0.2309965342,
0.1195652187,
-0.5435210466,
-0.421661377,
0.3557646573,
0.4699983299,
-0.4349784255,
0.5187165141,
0.2855988443,
-0.3852094114,
-0.3791717887,
-0.38185817,
-0.0579163097,
-0.6067906022,
0.3975598514,
-0.659127593,
-0.6311671734,
0.4029372036,
-0.1610178202,
0.5250973105,
0.2004721463,
0.7924662232,
-0.0263330452,
0.5318213701,
0.6226094961,
0.2518955469,
0.5537333488,
-0.1885719001,
-0.2022829503,
-0.5653126836,
-0.1289922744,
-0.6776625514,
-0.2523058057,
-0.5085663795,
-0.6073191166,
0.4660710394,
-0.3053967059,
-0.1344768107,
0.3808182776,
-0.672424376,
0.7411637306,
0.8423614502,
0.1486623287,
0.4699269831,
-0.1691925675,
0.1440966427,
0.2381589413,
-0.3109891415,
-1.0674161911,
1.2509878874,
0.1813206077,
0.586222589,
0.24018538,
0.8641726971,
0.5060543418,
0.5540738702,
-0.8649358749,
0.563575983,
-0.1795425564,
-0.2118939608,
-0.8043772578,
0.0152564701,
-0.9003527164,
0.1272484362,
0.1463783681,
-0.5277032852,
0.2805393636,
0.6595139503,
-0.3098433912,
0.274482578,
-0.8294354081,
0.8659228683,
-0.1432258338,
-0.0461575128,
-0.1518574655,
-0.4816189706,
-0.2291272432,
-0.1258832067,
-0.0290913153,
0.0854564682,
-0.6876401901,
0.2864693999,
-0.8856748939,
0.7765401006,
-0.1536370069,
0.0177121479,
0.2068307549,
0.1481360793,
0.6301307082,
-0.0410993248,
-0.3830625713,
-0.2319052666,
-0.0437259078,
-0.263762325,
-0.8405785561,
0.5832446814,
-0.8151804805,
-0.9398731589,
-0.2223778963,
-0.6444161534,
-0.2335079461,
0.2479803413,
0.2095409632,
0.268217802,
-0.5667947531,
-0.0827089027,
0.5905038714,
-0.1146236286,
0.4505696893,
0.6517400742,
0.2095981985,
-0.5389530659,
0.7300726175,
0.4350395203,
0.4302583039,
0.5818576217,
0.3897319436,
-0.0153183704,
-0.997068882,
-0.6860415339,
-0.2455714941,
-0.7966578603,
-0.2338214368,
-0.4282971919,
0.0334926173,
-0.7503708005,
-0.4745557308,
-0.1556880772,
-0.4833200276,
-0.7017489076,
-0.0989691168,
0.3594506383,
0.9421897531,
-0.0213639289,
0.3680804074,
-0.7729468942,
0.2573230267,
0.3839922845,
0.2707238495,
-0.327329129,
-0.5593200326,
-0.0577195399,
0.0830439925,
-0.6631430387,
-1.1962919235,
0.4099954069,
0.4909069836,
0.4962114692,
0.5104541183,
-0.0107300207,
0.7149474621,
-0.7042765021,
0.5702167153,
-0.2718599737,
-0.9515171647,
0.6425952315,
-0.2704543173,
0.1900876015,
0.297552973,
0.2941600978,
-0.3916577995,
-0.4856778681,
-0.3857846558,
-0.3587910533,
0.5860334635,
0.0175410379,
0.0926715955,
0.1741850078,
0.6514809132,
0.246883139,
0.1827217191,
-0.2081816792,
-0.2416495681,
-0.133169204,
0.0186425485,
-0.0684619769,
-0.2177754939,
-0.3516591489,
0.2453045249,
0.4948619604,
-0.4006769657,
-0.0454671606,
0.4599502087,
-0.0157914888,
-0.398512423,
0.4302498996,
0.8001959324,
1.2119896412,
-0.2465112358,
-0.13268435,
0.3472470939,
-0.4053972661,
0.1541137695,
0.1179983839,
-0.2984276414,
-0.0004130224,
0.5498607755,
0.4984227717,
-0.2682986259,
-0.5525012612,
0.322127074,
0.0486186296,
-0.3808972538,
-0.184954375,
0.3193794787,
-0.0370122306,
0.4195931554,
-0.0320662558,
0.2827923596,
0.5849164724,
-0.4769245982,
0.295555532,
0.5171930194,
-0.302767396,
-0.221535027,
0.3682706952,
0.1454797089,
-1.1052699089,
0.2455115467,
-0.3309632838,
-0.1591186672,
0.9009972811,
0.2901882529,
0.959766686,
-0.3809527457,
0.4488424957,
-0.1913220584,
0.2942869961,
0.2930939794,
0.3823348284,
0.0753507316,
-0.5866343975,
-0.1744769663,
-0.2357440889,
-0.9358010888,
-0.1877652705,
-0.4363127351,
0.2104508877,
-0.5915470719,
-0.2926713824,
0.2779153883,
-0.0337711051,
-0.4628976285,
0.1860508323,
-0.615670085,
1.2519967556,
-0.5657804608,
0.5860574841,
1.2255574465,
-0.1295422763,
-0.6487616301,
0.0323096141,
0.1974096745,
-0.6351504326,
0.062223088,
0.004601541,
0.1116911098,
-0.5304477811,
-0.4700794518,
-0.7160045505,
1.2899944782,
0.3440024257,
-0.6221145391,
0.0602268651,
0.3134841323,
0.7844325304,
-0.2111402899,
0.1551808566,
0.4734380245,
0.5413960218,
0.1179340929,
-1.1386739016,
-0.1227889583,
-0.0328395851,
-0.0557486601,
0.1720449626,
-0.7214564681,
0.7076669335,
-0.317971617,
0.1604032516,
0.250661999,
0.5735810399,
0.2125200033,
0.6324974895,
0.4440639019,
0.331438154,
0.7347496152,
0.17313236,
0.9301708937,
-0.311190486,
-0.0293535795,
1.388956666,
-0.3399883509,
0.5593550205,
0.6015633345,
-0.0635620356,
-0.1036521643,
0.7305397391,
0.1048904955,
0.3896310925,
0.3390933573,
-0.2335524857,
-0.0585691594,
-0.2768034339,
0.0158640053,
0.1689914465,
0.098542802,
-0.3305639923,
0.0269266814,
-0.0231342725,
-0.117607601,
0.2802033722,
-0.1781998128,
0.9668197632,
-0.1075877622,
-0.813783288,
-0.0859981105,
0.2483416051,
0.375031054,
-0.5699815154,
-0.2369520962,
-0.2720912695,
0.1267114729,
-0.3380661607,
-0.8883678317,
0.5316128731,
-0.1193354353,
-0.1211517304,
-0.4440271854,
0.9675771594,
-0.2132886052,
-0.1723641902,
0.0762024149,
0.7418498397,
0.1702079922,
-0.1600976437,
-0.6815502048,
-0.1022871882,
-0.0096482476,
-0.5823256969,
0.1324592531,
0.601154685,
-0.1609703004,
0.6385685205,
0.6076617241,
0.3267697096,
0.0557443202,
0.3358041644,
0.8987271786,
-0.4013805091,
-0.2370108664,
-0.9710742831,
0.3445889652,
-0.2137819082,
-0.4806403518,
0.6515884995,
0.735604763,
0.9542214274,
-0.4256956875,
0.7276073098,
0.1417358667,
0.1710395217,
-0.2555719018,
0.4786758125,
-0.4672183394,
0.0299484748,
-0.2172235698,
-0.9320726395,
-0.2460400462,
0.3206662536,
-0.0951011628,
0.1587656885,
0.3638865054,
1.1821643114,
0.0990763456,
-0.2916101515,
0.5400523543,
-0.0170242507,
0.5882278681,
0.2996235788,
0.732658267,
0.0427905247,
0.5176553726,
-0.5025627017,
-0.5502046943,
-0.2441003174,
-0.9368636012,
-0.9200555682,
-0.3155021071,
-0.4989408553,
-0.1667453647,
0.2905650735,
1.2235081196,
0.6550486684,
-0.5767430067,
-0.1732890308,
0.0943456963,
0.1547495872,
-0.2930445373,
-0.1293766946,
0.374871701,
-0.3777011037,
-0.780639708,
0.3813822865,
0.6936239004,
0.300468117,
-0.1789264679,
-0.2310507149,
0.1254975498,
0.3810245097,
0.4910340607,
0.1788977683,
-0.6693902612,
-0.3798376322,
0.31097278,
-0.0574385375,
0.236795947,
0.7835677862,
-0.1990615577,
0.646166563,
0.5637947917,
0.5953351855,
0.0980420783,
0.0454075001,
0.6316501498,
-0.7685752511,
-0.2357426882,
0.196172893,
0.3499483466,
0.0794885606,
-0.6425853968,
0.4795531034,
-0.0079007288,
-0.8552109003,
-0.3823626935,
0.1761436164,
-1.0905863047,
-0.1509400606,
1.0478321314,
-0.3087911904,
-0.3012982607,
-0.2380241752,
-0.5162083507,
0.2955614328,
-0.3798678517,
0.8387225866,
0.5301901102,
-0.5421227217,
0.1421256363,
-0.1490591764,
0.5809407234,
0.1762354821,
-1.2598971128,
-0.2551386952,
0.6533135772,
0.55559057,
0.3024607003,
0.8918707967,
0.2746296525,
0.6520849466,
-0.3502325118,
-0.039067477,
-0.4460684359,
-0.350569278,
-0.1739739329,
0.2196184993,
0.3507881761,
-0.4417383969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09505v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09505v1
|
SegMix: A Simple Structure-Aware Data Augmentation Method
| 2023-11-16T02:05:15 | 2023-11-16T02:05:15 |
Yuxin Pei, Pushkar Bhuse, Zhengzhong Liu, Eric Xing
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Interpolation-based Data Augmentation (DA) methods (Mixup) linearly
interpolate the inputs and labels of two or more training examples. Mixup has
more recently been adapted to the field of Natural Language Processing (NLP),
mainly for sequence labeling tasks. However, such a simple adoption yields
mixed or unstable improvements over the baseline models. We argue that the
direct-adoption methods do not account for structures in NLP tasks. To this
end, we propose SegMix, a collection of interpolation-based DA algorithms that
can adapt to task-specific structures. SegMix poses fewer constraints on data
structures, is robust to various hyperparameter settings, applies to more task
settings, and adds little computational overhead. In the algorithm's core, we
apply interpolation methods on task-specific meaningful segments, in contrast
to applying them on sequences as in prior work. We find SegMix to be a flexible
framework that combines rule-based DA methods with interpolation-based methods,
creating interesting mixtures of DA techniques. We show that SegMix
consistently improves performance over strong baseline models in Named Entity
Recognition (NER) and Relation Extraction (RE) tasks, especially under
data-scarce settings. Furthermore, this method is easy to implement and adds
negligible training overhead.
|
[
-0.5670629144,
-0.7457040548,
0.3743053079,
0.7983115911,
-0.245456323,
0.2214353532,
0.0290193949,
-0.4820494652,
0.4837468266,
0.274473846,
-0.6590832472,
-0.4047279358,
-0.625187993,
0.253543973,
-0.4515530169,
0.6502774358,
0.0489772633,
-0.1225177944,
-0.3594441712,
-0.2157246023,
-0.3143446445,
-0.5918873549,
-0.3280708492,
-0.4303778708,
0.2258258313,
0.5186909437,
0.8031522632,
0.8790025711,
0.2675254047,
0.2319587171,
-0.3817245364,
0.4981060028,
-0.2220569849,
0.0268403608,
-0.1850448549,
-0.1746267825,
-0.7636787891,
-0.0050413706,
0.5372026563,
1.1660746336,
-0.1144316494,
0.1326315701,
0.2975833714,
0.571790874,
-0.5659431219,
0.0061540222,
-0.6347402334,
0.0568447374,
-0.1735521555,
-0.5165095925,
-0.1692595929,
-0.1413118392,
0.0369597003,
-0.602580905,
0.0824476033,
-0.0921456367,
0.5064579844,
0.5341203809,
-0.2496881038,
-0.1367554963,
-0.3923920393,
0.4473437071,
-1.1805419922,
0.1527634561,
0.3311102688,
0.1823614985,
-0.4387576878,
-0.6353538036,
-0.6707779169,
0.129876703,
-0.1309944093,
-0.1970837265,
-0.0040570749,
0.2005544603,
0.6401455998,
0.4531876445,
-0.4291390777,
0.0545607992,
-0.2675703466,
0.1253303736,
0.5150212049,
-0.0061403071,
0.6772360802,
-0.0914884284,
-0.6464428902,
0.0372081846,
-0.8377412558,
-0.0276973303,
0.4039528668,
0.5551570058,
-0.0744312629,
0.5766118765,
-0.3613316119,
0.8507611752,
0.1819600612,
0.1323973238,
0.6948828101,
-0.2132486552,
-0.430182606,
0.2733135223,
0.3511804044,
0.1565998644,
-0.0603051074,
-0.2539919317,
-0.0389976315,
0.0151457284,
0.2786795199,
-0.7437821627,
-0.3126395643,
0.4251683652,
-0.0294752251,
0.0133960294,
-0.3856667578,
-0.6590496898,
-0.4273103178,
-0.7489050627,
0.5839009285,
-0.3824805617,
0.0291812941,
-0.0670209751,
-0.1660991013,
0.0685124397,
0.4473965466,
-0.8477990031,
0.6535862684,
0.7057960629,
0.8436986208,
-0.4081475735,
-0.370242089,
-0.8806165457,
-0.0552964061,
-0.12802127,
0.9150848389,
-0.5815301538,
-0.2810370326,
-0.3705255389,
0.0508634634,
0.0002814548,
-0.8384004235,
0.5907819271,
-0.3200536668,
-0.0543782152,
-0.182664305,
-0.6463549733,
-0.3738152087,
0.3310495019,
-0.6711190939,
1.3704169989,
0.2121863961,
-0.7479587197,
0.4352657199,
-0.5068337321,
-0.6243970394,
0.2486815304,
-0.1603796631,
-0.1617864966,
-0.0285313185,
0.5971018076,
0.4582760036,
-0.188832745,
0.2707808912,
-0.5713557005,
-0.5738723874,
-0.1546022892,
-0.144243598,
0.7833941579,
0.1518720835,
-0.2615454495,
0.0965663567,
-1.0625531673,
0.3284715116,
-0.2667429149,
-0.4548487663,
-0.6963019371,
0.0919516608,
-0.0427947156,
0.3283897042,
0.0140194939,
-0.3092672825,
0.3565950096,
-0.6378144026,
0.3224518597,
0.6000134945,
0.0324633606,
0.6239851117,
-0.0865822658,
0.2435767651,
0.1937018484,
-0.18618536,
-0.2953907549,
-0.3171385527,
-0.7670692205,
-0.4038950801,
0.6375752687,
0.5313430429,
-0.893001616,
0.3842603266,
-0.4357741177,
-0.4034317732,
-0.323208034,
0.2274566293,
0.0376737751,
0.6836995482,
0.7793788314,
-0.2270138115,
-0.7351672649,
-0.9040269256,
-0.4059177339,
0.3467714489,
0.1563807726,
0.0808785185,
0.1902504861,
-0.4530329108,
0.8545634151,
-0.330786258,
0.0235306136,
-0.1205026284,
0.2644539177,
0.5124155283,
0.548910737,
0.5740468502,
-0.9077777863,
-0.6559975743,
-0.1710138172,
-0.4567753077,
-0.3698192239,
-0.0030867932,
0.1189363673,
-0.2776356041,
0.4399802983,
0.0838722289,
0.365326345,
0.5677408576,
-0.261571914,
0.0783517659,
-0.3473077714,
0.1917551458,
-1.0953630209,
-0.1050582826,
-0.0078048771,
-0.4175001085,
-1.0142071247,
-0.2473460883,
0.2939644754,
-0.0823007226,
-0.3948290646,
0.5175210238,
-0.4020760953,
-0.2356964797,
-0.4618121684,
0.0626390129,
0.0220470559,
0.7389864326,
0.0075204349,
0.8056453466,
0.4075484574,
-1.0715010166,
-0.0069501149,
0.3906541765,
-0.216070801,
0.615398407,
-0.539129734,
0.2994977534,
-0.2114651501,
-0.2683286369,
-0.8348560333,
-0.2043746263,
0.2294770032,
-0.3589185774,
0.2329486161,
-0.2673898637,
-0.3843906522,
0.0951216072,
-0.2836338282,
0.4521844983,
0.1304911375,
-1.0073788166,
0.5933623314,
0.7480601072,
-0.5054863095,
-0.6663452983,
-0.7256213427,
0.3648141325,
-0.2532635629,
-0.7216553688,
0.9520274401,
-0.2654010057,
-0.2079918534,
0.0135737984,
-0.3704654276,
-0.4935236573,
0.1429120451,
0.2781917453,
0.1292245239,
0.1173450351,
0.1239859164,
0.3627960682,
-0.0364798643,
-0.3093960583,
0.0004016319,
0.504686594,
0.1492242813,
-0.1304152012,
0.0809591711,
0.5325655341,
0.2936978638,
0.0278286748,
0.2994050384,
0.2737948895,
-0.7062487602,
-0.5388314724,
-0.2884125412,
0.0614145063,
-0.4751329124,
0.1939983964,
-0.5152917504,
-0.6306595802,
0.2619636655,
-0.2782467008,
0.2580949068,
0.2940695286,
0.3265954852,
-0.1863451898,
0.9858115911,
0.5425063372,
0.091076538,
0.4418921173,
-0.0882857963,
0.1772078723,
-1.0448920727,
0.0748555213,
-0.4855914414,
-0.6182807684,
-0.0347891189,
-0.6297101974,
0.2409284413,
0.174358353,
0.0653100163,
0.7240030169,
-0.481445998,
0.3358866572,
0.5522528291,
-0.0617891848,
0.3575752079,
0.3630965352,
0.0791431963,
-0.2148462236,
-0.7689617872,
-0.1634092331,
0.7660562992,
0.0425531119,
0.7363991737,
-0.0315143615,
0.6766737103,
0.7497649193,
0.1526041776,
-0.6824690104,
0.5338361859,
-0.0983400717,
-0.1964384019,
-0.01861904,
-0.47574386,
-0.6702675223,
0.4277552962,
-0.3865004778,
-0.6212160587,
0.7250679731,
0.2028207332,
-0.2308233827,
-0.0400889143,
-0.6541216373,
0.5013777614,
-0.1671960354,
-0.1811158508,
0.0682203248,
-0.3761841059,
0.0203183405,
0.0498995073,
0.2938624024,
-0.3356883824,
0.0283348616,
0.5564313531,
-0.7291375995,
0.4247108996,
-0.082351841,
-0.0031234354,
0.271845907,
-0.0354527235,
0.7827881575,
-0.0459409878,
-0.1744533032,
0.1806584895,
0.1042793542,
-0.2791115642,
-0.9454872012,
0.6382348537,
-0.4363335967,
-0.3756493628,
-0.3329521418,
-0.6136158705,
-0.5242708921,
0.0430217609,
0.0649445504,
0.581520319,
0.1682310402,
0.1656380594,
0.3572379351,
-0.0550400242,
0.2947118282,
0.1962623,
-0.0322903916,
-0.6945490837,
0.7856478095,
0.1925999522,
0.1258689463,
0.2837779522,
-0.1116444394,
-0.3094957173,
-0.4702957273,
-0.4527789652,
-0.1079721153,
-0.7774302959,
-0.1226649508,
-0.7544047236,
-0.210418269,
-0.4417885244,
-0.1790043265,
-0.2023895383,
-0.7357526422,
-0.0482023358,
-0.1333319694,
0.0389919728,
0.1813064218,
-0.1173552126,
0.3604568541,
-0.6390402317,
0.5231539607,
0.3352952003,
0.1492568403,
-0.5411105752,
-0.3622398078,
-0.1697906554,
0.1922483891,
0.1761253476,
-1.0935578346,
0.4605294466,
0.2129663974,
0.6608233452,
-0.0445074551,
-0.0354613848,
1.0067183971,
-0.4147007465,
0.3780789673,
-0.0171445273,
-1.0458165407,
0.3960548937,
-0.070505321,
0.1964932084,
0.6732560992,
0.0164129417,
-0.4714201689,
0.2042154521,
-0.5656674504,
-1.0937829018,
0.8893296123,
0.3582178652,
0.0474157669,
0.1924700439,
0.4504402578,
-0.0109359268,
0.4023344219,
-0.7050671577,
-0.4667953849,
0.0741470754,
-0.3106843531,
-0.0672265217,
-0.3246299922,
-0.1099151224,
-0.3159427643,
0.8682304621,
-0.4763088524,
0.0133228544,
0.3916421533,
-0.4699988067,
0.220919013,
0.5855558515,
0.1970130205,
0.5135287642,
-0.1931857467,
0.3818345368,
0.412620753,
-0.468267262,
0.1720972061,
0.5417220592,
-0.4921693206,
0.0513079502,
-0.1463453472,
0.7932788134,
0.4112083018,
-0.6940386891,
0.3347195685,
0.2095625103,
-0.2115777284,
0.2195328176,
0.1566424072,
-0.1798203439,
0.436186254,
0.1055921316,
0.3469637334,
0.6521756053,
-0.4437747896,
0.2979120016,
0.1947548091,
-0.5603817701,
-0.1792396307,
0.6132480502,
0.097698465,
-0.3125766814,
0.2402951121,
-0.1725741923,
-0.349981755,
0.6405256391,
0.805599153,
0.8329670429,
0.0272334479,
0.2313552052,
0.3588720858,
0.3218043149,
0.0200443417,
0.4769907594,
-0.4414226711,
-0.6616428494,
-0.4355901182,
-0.4972629249,
-0.5124799609,
-0.015639795,
-0.3782561123,
0.4543725848,
-0.3755354285,
-0.1396929622,
0.0281722657,
-0.0556866564,
-0.4275379777,
0.3985158503,
0.2685214579,
1.1261409521,
-0.3465712368,
0.6452428699,
0.9005798101,
0.0165697914,
-0.615570724,
-0.1137790531,
-0.1442730874,
-0.4013959169,
0.3264790177,
0.2829972506,
0.0203511342,
0.1125474945,
-0.232589379,
-0.8428592086,
0.8782675266,
0.4983123541,
-0.2616602182,
-0.3199483454,
0.1715770066,
0.2873354256,
-0.4246250391,
-0.1097762287,
0.5470150113,
0.4127325714,
0.1736027449,
-0.5448433161,
0.0404190011,
-0.6202775836,
-0.0667358041,
0.2591593862,
-0.1024150476,
0.8188922405,
-0.1490243226,
-0.4840137959,
-0.2674813867,
0.4409267902,
0.1653655916,
0.4603561759,
0.6941125393,
0.6701198816,
0.8453415632,
-0.1120654568,
0.7455421686,
-0.2606985867,
0.2305245548,
1.5739495754,
-0.1580990404,
0.6072492003,
0.4586682618,
-0.2693322003,
0.3444944024,
0.6175618768,
0.008745743,
0.3741342425,
-0.117389828,
-0.0802588537,
-0.2189814895,
0.1426933855,
-0.354257971,
0.1788037121,
0.4909549654,
-0.2421845645,
-0.50750494,
-0.2447804511,
0.0051921764,
0.068156831,
-0.4445255995,
0.6132329106,
0.0508012213,
-0.6595295668,
0.4647851586,
0.0096091731,
0.4818006456,
-0.4624124765,
-0.31901443,
0.0569336824,
0.0947564766,
-0.3941523433,
-0.5411756039,
0.321532011,
-0.2285027206,
-0.0799610093,
-0.1412734389,
0.8111152649,
-0.6403769255,
-0.1918839216,
0.1477918476,
0.4695669413,
-0.2085870802,
-0.3688521385,
-0.6221843362,
-0.2361987978,
0.0253780056,
-0.0084142331,
0.1210849211,
-0.0199294146,
0.0614091568,
0.3732268214,
0.7640104294,
0.0818596259,
0.2942745984,
-0.090200223,
0.9483757615,
-0.5768483877,
-0.6600899696,
-0.6941991448,
0.5663070083,
-0.4640335441,
-0.1127411872,
0.8468595147,
0.5556088686,
0.4876290262,
0.1536487639,
0.735435009,
-0.0634651408,
0.6406463385,
-0.5585119128,
0.2080202103,
-0.6796954274,
0.4422732294,
-0.4678071439,
-1.3246209621,
-0.394002378,
0.2553969026,
-0.3010692596,
-0.2962426841,
0.2821855247,
0.5576967597,
-0.2881175578,
0.1099930108,
0.2180576026,
0.1354685575,
0.205546394,
0.2381521314,
0.6552589536,
-0.4594183564,
0.1923807263,
-0.4361055493,
-0.2208932936,
-0.2226201594,
-0.6736215353,
-0.6749421358,
-0.5496177673,
-0.3768753111,
-0.2523781359,
-0.0645079613,
1.1035342216,
0.7588121891,
-0.699840188,
0.0888511762,
-0.1350721866,
0.1914732605,
-0.3710472584,
-0.2300111502,
0.3468069136,
-0.5880446434,
-1.0801057816,
0.8746231198,
0.8267372251,
0.1345787048,
0.2061789483,
0.0712904111,
-0.4049317539,
0.3456387222,
0.6298766136,
0.4104712903,
-0.1650094837,
0.0691981092,
-0.092320621,
0.050651677,
0.5355429649,
0.7714397907,
-0.998172164,
0.8315117359,
0.8533759713,
0.884259522,
0.459031105,
0.4145401716,
0.597931087,
-0.9473738074,
0.3228783906,
0.1435657591,
0.6271471977,
0.3353470564,
-0.3495429456,
0.8523525596,
0.1640726477,
-0.2079287171,
-0.9184995294,
0.0699645281,
-1.1096748114,
-0.1262828559,
0.9996963143,
0.0575564392,
-0.1244443506,
-0.1732677072,
-0.3972370625,
-0.0702351779,
-0.1211319938,
0.5301165581,
0.3525892794,
-0.136554271,
0.0799693614,
-0.4029683173,
0.6136703491,
0.2561254501,
-1.2423001528,
-0.1406114846,
0.4360172153,
0.3344854116,
0.2083054185,
0.7102187276,
-0.120371148,
0.1657133251,
-0.0220402312,
-0.012475132,
-0.1864407063,
-0.4112345576,
-0.2774933577,
0.2120820731,
-0.2732117176,
0.0556806661
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09502v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09502v2
|
SQATIN: Supervised Instruction Tuning Meets Question Answering for Improved Dialogue NLU
| 2023-11-16T01:57:00 | 2024-04-08T21:31:57 |
Evgeniia Razumovskaia, Goran Glavaš, Anna Korhonen, Ivan Vulić
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Task-oriented dialogue (ToD) systems help users execute well-defined tasks
across a variety of domains (e.g., $\textit{flight booking}$ or $\textit{food
ordering}$), with their Natural Language Understanding (NLU) components being
dedicated to the analysis of user utterances, predicting users' intents
($\textit{Intent Detection}$, ID) and extracting values for informational slots
($\textit{Value Extraction}$, VE). In most domains, labelled NLU data is
scarce, making sample-efficient learning -- enabled with effective transfer
paradigms -- paramount. In this work, we introduce SQATIN, a new framework for
dialog NLU based on (i) instruction tuning and (ii) question-answering-based
formulation of ID and VE tasks. According to the evaluation on established NLU
benchmarks, SQATIN sets the new state of the art in dialogue NLU, substantially
surpassing the performance of current models based on standard fine-tuning
objectives in both in-domain training and cross-domain transfer. SQATIN yields
particularly large performance gains in cross-domain transfer, owing to the
fact that our QA-based instruction tuning leverages similarities between
natural language descriptions of classes (i.e., slots and intents) across
domains.
|
[
-0.324442178,
-1.0491746664,
0.5160740614,
0.0482172854,
0.0662969723,
0.1447969079,
-0.1694662273,
-0.2304997444,
0.0697286949,
0.7324208617,
-0.856760323,
-0.4871637821,
-0.4648498297,
0.1258790493,
-0.0965487659,
0.8732525706,
0.1282289326,
0.1289015561,
-0.4208560288,
-0.0527791716,
-0.7006852627,
-0.3588839471,
-0.7840662003,
0.1370808482,
0.4901500642,
0.7023029327,
0.72825104,
0.5809780955,
0.2192939222,
0.3186993301,
0.1483745128,
0.4466414452,
-0.4832314849,
0.1877626628,
-0.0757561922,
-0.7152994275,
-0.5709996223,
-0.1297391057,
0.3920762539,
0.6921830773,
-0.0547963604,
0.0480338372,
-0.0978484601,
0.6131762862,
-0.4842672944,
0.1482201517,
-0.4022170603,
0.1009095684,
0.024120206,
-0.5205843449,
-0.4362780154,
-0.6526913047,
0.3618341684,
-1.4691418409,
0.1271986216,
0.3993441164,
0.8260904551,
0.399169147,
-0.368134886,
-0.5911306143,
-0.3639349043,
0.8497878909,
-0.7507543564,
0.3095271587,
0.6149431467,
0.3521787822,
-0.3641055524,
-0.8805256486,
-0.4988741577,
0.0989245176,
-0.172118187,
0.1342013627,
-0.3019002676,
0.2677433789,
0.2665536404,
0.4176778197,
-0.9102261066,
-0.0259566717,
-0.430981487,
-0.2012736201,
0.3991204798,
0.2183324546,
0.3881970048,
-0.0619535856,
-0.5595220923,
0.0686504096,
-0.4715492129,
0.1248401478,
0.1596872658,
0.0514827408,
0.2539631426,
0.4432198405,
-0.4246900082,
0.7486732006,
0.3210006356,
0.1553602517,
0.0320629925,
-0.3186037838,
-0.4067900479,
-0.0521124825,
0.6913962364,
0.5874479413,
0.0355722718,
-0.1191946343,
0.1418971717,
-0.3590417802,
0.5151230097,
-0.731475234,
-0.4358207285,
0.0441403016,
-0.2315625548,
-0.1760497391,
-0.1684775054,
-0.7585330009,
-0.1341204345,
-0.5611120462,
0.6753288507,
-0.6724092364,
-0.0181789845,
0.1609444171,
0.0448186994,
0.1142314076,
0.4438562989,
-0.9514997005,
0.4955773652,
0.998590529,
0.5039957166,
-0.2584754825,
-0.1086773574,
-0.9633642435,
-0.0218315329,
-0.3451838195,
0.7073981166,
-0.7197134495,
-0.2665840387,
0.0225684866,
0.0807818249,
-0.4746059179,
-0.6804990172,
0.7075337172,
-0.5329790115,
0.7625377774,
-0.2829141617,
-0.8087007999,
-0.2993118763,
0.2013875991,
-0.4876024127,
1.2314341068,
0.3206564188,
-0.3842168152,
0.2321357876,
-0.7504264116,
-0.3467966616,
0.18249771,
0.1928100139,
-0.2111630738,
0.17792961,
0.5080320239,
0.2411118597,
-0.2990854979,
0.2241892666,
0.1123602167,
-0.4757562578,
0.396348238,
-0.2891786098,
0.5517793894,
0.3798125982,
-0.3212481439,
0.4682933986,
-0.4776984751,
0.3186205626,
-0.2637048662,
-0.0082662292,
-0.3926922977,
-0.4094304442,
-0.3309438527,
-0.019072935,
0.1161995083,
-0.362206012,
0.3645510375,
-0.3754634559,
0.3221210837,
0.5515580177,
0.0192002859,
0.7854960561,
-0.2815495729,
0.6945767403,
-0.12551862,
0.5485684276,
-0.1249376684,
-0.5974600315,
-0.907746315,
-0.0519341752,
0.3591227233,
0.6855192184,
-1.035233736,
0.2826448381,
-0.1427310258,
0.0602760762,
-0.723067224,
0.1487552673,
0.3617098629,
0.4929589331,
0.3869333267,
-0.4522779584,
-0.5227959156,
-0.7597726583,
-0.2387386262,
-0.1395975798,
-0.0769239515,
0.6625973582,
-0.1302828491,
-0.021332372,
0.8184663653,
-0.4013561308,
-0.1464299411,
-0.4495724738,
0.3469223976,
-0.0084606819,
0.2971636057,
0.0388606973,
-0.8342109919,
-0.5713479519,
0.0148774795,
-0.7129771709,
-0.2035482973,
-0.3920030892,
-0.6271823049,
0.036572732,
0.4608742595,
-0.7404153943,
0.4139230251,
0.3999271989,
-0.2516772151,
0.4606537223,
-0.1120489985,
0.4855865836,
-1.1117979288,
-0.22494331,
-0.1688660979,
-0.1991645843,
-0.9213888049,
-0.1611912102,
0.031355571,
-0.0842615291,
-0.4308081865,
0.3795661032,
-0.2460322976,
-0.0998454913,
-0.3611690402,
0.3820576966,
0.3860756159,
0.7984751463,
-0.227861464,
1.0703393221,
0.4480679035,
-0.5522527099,
0.2031041086,
0.4407061934,
-0.1849251688,
0.7904917002,
-0.5664212704,
0.2445868552,
0.2574491501,
0.1636495143,
-0.6231057048,
-0.1465208232,
0.5492469668,
-0.3708443344,
0.3187638819,
-0.342515111,
-0.1330743879,
-0.0340543129,
-0.017597042,
0.4056980014,
0.2959370613,
-0.3579857051,
0.7254415154,
0.3411843777,
-0.4610292017,
-0.6493712664,
-0.1785725355,
0.1785266995,
-0.2020018697,
-0.5948777795,
0.1741280109,
-0.0983256176,
0.0513547324,
0.0069432701,
-0.2015023381,
-0.3494006395,
0.1070873514,
0.3357259333,
0.3226672709,
-0.4118966758,
0.2476309538,
0.519497931,
-0.2287023962,
0.0595026575,
-0.5527613163,
0.2968620956,
-0.0463447347,
-0.2266699672,
-0.7153674364,
0.5470511913,
0.3934582174,
-0.3085158765,
0.4035935402,
0.8092663884,
0.141278863,
-0.2978294492,
-0.320373863,
-0.356796056,
-0.4844772518,
0.2730902731,
-0.4501437247,
-1.2136282921,
-0.050038483,
-0.561122179,
0.1555782557,
0.1182155684,
0.3765773177,
-0.3136963844,
0.7097486854,
0.6421562433,
0.0657443255,
0.5351899862,
-0.2063878179,
0.4350680411,
-1.0369182825,
-0.0282464568,
-0.242251575,
-0.3490389287,
-0.1445296407,
-0.8821975589,
0.3407551944,
0.2682206333,
0.1230621487,
0.4437317848,
-0.5029064417,
0.4630527496,
0.8410576582,
-0.191486299,
0.2908113897,
-0.1857168525,
0.081079416,
-0.1425801665,
-1.0368573666,
-0.4688329995,
1.0863175392,
0.1615448892,
0.4600264728,
-0.0719978884,
0.5963170528,
0.4309524596,
0.0194497257,
-0.7541282177,
0.6109987497,
0.0002673033,
-0.4397143722,
-0.4346699119,
-0.5984328389,
-1.1165448427,
0.2341778427,
-0.175652653,
-0.7847912908,
0.1896591187,
0.1631219834,
-0.5331484079,
0.1200742945,
-0.8959089518,
1.0350526571,
-0.3386661112,
-0.3044772446,
-0.1771306098,
-0.7694286704,
0.196864143,
0.3734146357,
0.0221232045,
-0.263789922,
0.2214890271,
0.6127044559,
-0.1887236536,
0.6713952422,
-0.3443401456,
0.0895241946,
0.211965099,
0.0697834268,
0.3851392865,
0.2764230669,
0.0942985266,
-0.0993072167,
0.0854277983,
-0.3648659885,
-1.0740662813,
0.6944255233,
-0.6440129876,
-0.6109916568,
-0.17480582,
-0.9537142515,
-0.298804462,
0.0457030907,
0.0906327888,
0.5230983496,
-0.287112087,
-0.026136864,
1.0463011265,
-0.3637011051,
-0.1220423877,
0.3339629769,
-0.2759678364,
-0.214497447,
1.0769950151,
-0.3437052667,
0.3595808744,
0.5268879533,
-0.0341167375,
-0.2869099677,
-0.5214504004,
-0.8875072002,
0.0610459335,
-0.3684002161,
-0.3083061576,
-0.756932795,
-0.117217876,
-0.3063089252,
-0.0460740179,
-0.2347698212,
-0.6684526801,
-0.4091456234,
-0.0856096447,
0.4455050528,
0.5189239979,
0.2537112534,
0.2926484048,
-0.767170012,
0.5501363277,
0.5249444246,
0.12474107,
-0.4697817266,
-0.6259388328,
-0.4366506338,
0.1207503974,
-0.2634654939,
-0.5318002105,
0.365293473,
0.4766863585,
0.5756845474,
-0.017132163,
0.3573199809,
0.6797485948,
-0.3354490399,
0.6698753834,
-0.1050364673,
-0.9088791013,
0.4920870364,
-0.049712915,
0.2405278534,
0.7574846745,
0.3599607944,
-0.6298652887,
-0.4748194814,
-0.4332549572,
-0.9959313869,
0.8844300508,
0.3502288461,
-0.0241325311,
0.2224026769,
0.3221108317,
0.3757703006,
0.1531620026,
-0.1197840273,
-0.2059460133,
-0.3048483133,
-0.4503281713,
0.2251124978,
-0.0413898863,
-0.3718635142,
-0.1663088202,
0.7107158303,
-0.4272586107,
0.4271213114,
0.2595947981,
-0.447939992,
-0.1963750273,
0.5163738132,
0.5792838335,
0.5174657106,
-0.1173004434,
-0.233311817,
0.1525434703,
-0.404709518,
-0.1071470454,
0.1287568808,
-0.1914249212,
-0.1058565155,
-0.147263974,
1.25785923,
0.4463181198,
-0.7138601542,
0.4104636014,
-0.5100570917,
-0.3968298435,
-0.0631692633,
0.4006315768,
-0.1325027943,
0.4164269865,
0.4250515401,
0.1841183156,
0.4985823631,
-0.4162515998,
0.4050254226,
0.151686579,
-0.5326923728,
-0.1947508156,
0.4188806713,
0.2933024466,
-0.4383493364,
0.5369365215,
-0.1967328489,
-0.4424116611,
0.2895847857,
0.3703400195,
0.8118229508,
0.0693142414,
0.5973502398,
0.2197366357,
0.0971684158,
0.2997197807,
0.2235984653,
-0.4131148756,
-0.4567578435,
-0.6207863092,
-0.5669496059,
-0.6305860877,
-0.2751232684,
-0.977845788,
-0.446913898,
-0.3134367764,
-0.1003917158,
-0.1289395988,
0.0117812194,
-0.385538727,
0.0987835228,
-0.0109391445,
0.6778045893,
-0.5460453033,
1.0994756222,
0.5268966556,
0.2281095833,
-0.8825351,
-0.119060047,
0.12267524,
-0.4831650555,
0.419208318,
0.0884613693,
-0.1064608842,
0.0446336158,
-0.1365065724,
-0.6874207854,
0.9814448953,
0.0853855535,
-0.6796968579,
0.0318019837,
0.2246952057,
0.4062176049,
-0.4558880329,
0.2005199194,
0.8441747427,
0.5057577491,
0.0212413874,
-0.7319756746,
0.0308144223,
-0.4950454533,
-0.2531400621,
0.3189358711,
-0.3200693429,
0.4167287648,
-0.0827429891,
-0.2369743735,
0.3138212264,
0.7795516253,
0.0435443372,
0.767681241,
0.4771431684,
0.586116612,
0.8748412728,
-0.4574505687,
0.9182196259,
-0.2437846959,
-0.0737704635,
1.1183806658,
-0.1502198875,
0.6475909948,
0.4627436996,
0.0243932717,
0.4379171729,
0.3081498444,
0.2092817277,
0.4173352122,
-0.06851767,
-0.1583260596,
-0.1728726476,
-0.0860624388,
-0.0510400794,
0.2352037132,
0.63626194,
-0.0363164693,
0.201044023,
0.1654061526,
-0.1862026453,
0.0775256157,
-0.0255746469,
1.2457224131,
0.0060020401,
-0.8199807405,
0.7392072678,
-0.349930793,
0.4568016231,
-0.6032616496,
-0.1162597537,
-0.320155859,
-0.1309229732,
-0.1233987957,
-0.576217711,
0.2052304447,
-0.0488512553,
-0.0381464958,
-0.2229848057,
0.4904101491,
-0.6408575773,
-0.2268004566,
-0.110345535,
0.4978395402,
0.0653705001,
0.0666464865,
-0.9034922719,
0.0758681968,
0.2943137884,
-0.0659985244,
0.4251548946,
0.8088829517,
-0.0854718983,
0.6273758411,
0.7749704123,
-0.2080821693,
0.5358423591,
0.1682974696,
0.9720215797,
-0.5227835178,
-0.1477755457,
0.02177733,
0.5764397979,
-0.4165357649,
-0.641577661,
0.9336833954,
0.5459515452,
0.7621514201,
0.1060735881,
0.5854309201,
-0.0884136707,
0.6686102748,
-0.6207872033,
0.2467951775,
-0.4367691875,
0.3949691355,
0.0262173563,
-0.8187201023,
-0.2576065361,
0.5985962152,
-0.4727688432,
-0.3548581302,
0.6726591587,
0.9274529219,
-0.0525879934,
0.3284368515,
0.4507007897,
0.0076711876,
0.1865319163,
0.661028862,
0.93348068,
-0.7087913752,
0.5314364433,
-0.3236276209,
-0.1222813427,
-0.4588312209,
-0.1121392772,
-0.681923151,
-0.448492527,
-0.2515846193,
0.058432024,
0.4434784949,
0.7436783314,
0.8893671632,
-0.8678109646,
-0.2479742467,
-0.0745851174,
0.0771980286,
-0.4705626965,
-0.2759655416,
0.4214243293,
-0.6725730896,
-0.8390712738,
0.7601828575,
0.6079317331,
-0.4089412093,
0.2400481701,
-0.389244318,
-0.0897460356,
0.2668459713,
0.5075585246,
0.4750485122,
-0.6571707726,
-0.1181453541,
0.4352870584,
-0.1288188547,
0.2487443238,
1.0672924519,
-0.7072223425,
0.7400362492,
0.221766308,
0.8830924034,
0.6295779347,
0.2997123301,
0.9273331165,
-0.6680904627,
-0.0468981117,
0.5075159073,
-0.0217147507,
0.1873727143,
-0.4438556731,
0.2986006737,
-0.1758155227,
-0.8732064366,
-0.5791432261,
0.276284337,
-1.3454625607,
-0.3030895293,
0.6982306838,
-0.4096525013,
-0.2110402286,
-0.5422693491,
-0.5916873813,
0.2570985258,
-0.5353701711,
0.716715157,
0.1426243484,
-0.2060668766,
-0.4164740443,
-0.7034121752,
0.7454921603,
0.9656638503,
-1.0136672258,
0.1048203036,
0.5733474493,
-0.0462195948,
-0.1041718647,
0.3501155078,
0.0295901354,
0.5640912652,
-0.2763417065,
-0.2342036366,
-0.2532823682,
-0.4688246548,
0.0961765796,
0.0970246196,
0.0222551692,
-0.2587470114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09481v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09481v1
|
Personalized Jargon Identification for Enhanced Interdisciplinary Communication
| 2023-11-16T00:51:25 | 2023-11-16T00:51:25 |
Yue Guo, Joseph Chee Chang, Maria Antoniak, Erin Bransom, Trevor Cohen, Lucy Lu Wang, Tal August
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Scientific jargon can impede researchers when they read materials from other
domains. Current methods of jargon identification mainly use corpus-level
familiarity indicators (e.g., Simple Wikipedia represents plain language).
However, researchers' familiarity of a term can vary greatly based on their own
background. We collect a dataset of over 10K term familiarity annotations from
11 computer science researchers for terms drawn from 100 paper abstracts.
Analysis of this data reveals that jargon familiarity and information needs
vary widely across annotators, even within the same sub-domain (e.g., NLP). We
investigate features representing individual, sub-domain, and domain knowledge
to predict individual jargon familiarity. We compare supervised and
prompt-based approaches, finding that prompt-based methods including personal
publications yields the highest accuracy, though zero-shot prompting provides a
strong baseline. This research offers insight into features and methods to
integrate personal data into scientific jargon identification.
|
[
-0.8700808287,
-0.6027266979,
0.6021921039,
0.231294632,
-0.3375225365,
0.6299155951,
-0.331720382,
-0.798853159,
0.3903368115,
0.2176057845,
-0.4324274361,
-0.7027001977,
-0.7034768462,
0.787686348,
-0.3246534765,
0.9470337629,
0.0918200687,
-0.1945260763,
-0.7739933729,
-0.0412671342,
-0.489007175,
-0.4406977594,
-0.4374193251,
-0.4431346059,
0.6785107851,
0.3426744938,
0.4762453139,
0.5197712183,
0.6051712036,
0.2532994747,
-0.3470157683,
0.0375611335,
-0.3143521547,
0.0298329387,
-0.2560862601,
-0.1974676847,
0.1567452699,
-0.2444757521,
0.110399954,
0.9927746654,
0.271761179,
0.2101158202,
0.1364233047,
0.3492764831,
-0.5010440946,
0.245368585,
-0.5770036578,
0.3342260122,
-0.6680383682,
-0.3362700939,
-0.2464721203,
-0.2676193714,
0.4817729294,
-1.1402014494,
0.3711556792,
0.374610424,
0.9177365303,
0.0025572286,
-0.1617337167,
-0.4414948225,
-0.6291028857,
0.5525375605,
-0.453879416,
0.0930386707,
0.2986802459,
0.3385474384,
-0.0965392143,
-0.4116697907,
-0.5251392126,
-0.2677263916,
-0.3678445518,
0.035650257,
-0.233782202,
0.0321331881,
0.2843243778,
0.0376258269,
-0.4673463404,
0.0806801841,
-0.6584622264,
-0.2794592977,
0.4396206439,
0.1335960031,
0.1205048114,
-0.0208822787,
-0.4947106242,
0.1879717559,
-0.4781687856,
-0.0190503448,
0.2824535072,
0.2159354836,
-0.1408485919,
0.4785515964,
-0.602750361,
0.722442925,
0.4799349606,
-0.1167434305,
0.4628498554,
-0.2908042371,
0.0229204409,
0.1850783378,
0.7410510182,
0.1427425742,
0.4422900677,
-0.3190815449,
0.0360379145,
-0.2855459452,
0.2091599256,
-0.2014424354,
-0.5032764673,
0.0122737363,
-0.0971785933,
-0.1616850495,
0.1328579038,
-0.7087238431,
-0.9663687348,
-0.5285001397,
0.2372839004,
-0.3058099449,
-0.121937193,
-0.1694787592,
-0.4107017517,
-0.2505415678,
0.5352412462,
-0.8919584751,
0.3462024033,
0.6343114972,
1.0249825716,
-0.6002854109,
-0.1529089361,
0.0673533455,
0.0806641504,
-0.2015250027,
1.1966760159,
-0.7018948793,
-0.4581407309,
-0.1888071895,
-0.3058410883,
0.2721065879,
-0.6316351891,
0.146753177,
-0.500410676,
0.3927964568,
-0.4019416869,
-0.4118884206,
-0.366702497,
0.0325694121,
-0.4911090732,
0.6688344479,
0.3842759132,
-0.9618641138,
0.6731182933,
-0.7472100258,
-0.1617416888,
0.5969213843,
-0.423587054,
-0.015310416,
0.161394164,
-0.0172740836,
0.3252827525,
-0.4209080637,
0.2155505568,
-0.3392490447,
-0.1016612351,
0.2216318846,
0.0127843125,
0.4894727468,
0.5412291884,
0.1253885776,
0.1255470663,
-0.5981594324,
-0.5160588026,
-0.1483024359,
0.0724994093,
-0.8399136662,
-0.3585815132,
-0.0415298045,
-0.0028846387,
0.5268694758,
-0.6222886443,
0.1548987776,
-0.2624464035,
-0.1761419326,
0.6932002306,
0.2471021712,
0.3583975434,
-0.4219935834,
0.6057655215,
0.348262161,
-0.0779444277,
-0.1294122338,
-0.6981608868,
-0.1498436481,
-0.4263967574,
0.2846884131,
0.4835442603,
-0.4575819969,
0.432353586,
-0.1839899123,
-0.5091822147,
-0.1879019886,
0.3547031879,
0.3277066648,
0.8757318854,
0.427095145,
-0.5056837797,
-0.4357736707,
-0.9468588829,
-0.6795994043,
-0.1779428422,
-0.3131476641,
0.6018090844,
0.1582619548,
-0.0015867014,
1.4572927952,
-0.627513051,
-0.2076039463,
0.1720658541,
0.5254187584,
0.1834853739,
0.0662155896,
0.4816354513,
-0.8234115243,
-0.8126992583,
0.4051723778,
-0.9734860659,
-0.5745037794,
-0.4962441623,
0.1698991805,
-0.2129041404,
0.3984028399,
-0.21638605,
0.0613056906,
0.1609185487,
-0.4991295636,
0.5126327276,
0.2347408235,
0.1565555483,
-0.767116785,
0.2411887348,
0.5184412599,
0.0571297482,
-0.7238488197,
-0.2713316381,
-0.3210456371,
0.2032860816,
-0.3958289921,
0.9527474046,
-0.6376028657,
0.263289839,
-0.2087071687,
0.2092612386,
-0.1306720376,
0.0965885743,
0.2375636995,
0.798160255,
0.5836653113,
-0.6488794088,
0.123798728,
0.5725982785,
-0.2396957427,
0.756953001,
-0.5739415288,
-0.0070442231,
-0.3503983319,
0.0674820393,
-0.8650951982,
-0.5436225533,
0.6426956058,
-0.4302555621,
0.0771091655,
0.0472158827,
-0.136152342,
-0.270365566,
-0.2280965894,
0.3051150143,
0.3275591135,
-0.5745248795,
0.6210821867,
0.4054993689,
-0.6624153256,
-0.7126129866,
-0.3319877684,
0.3831629157,
-0.5885591507,
-0.4081120491,
0.2891063988,
-0.0858061016,
-0.4065488875,
-0.2160516828,
-0.2272544205,
-0.2743982673,
0.1374085546,
0.4766660333,
-0.0065187565,
0.069273904,
0.1998652518,
0.1456614435,
0.0725923106,
0.1002466157,
0.0914435759,
0.4607855976,
-0.0027795902,
-0.1118155569,
-0.3119395077,
0.4211991131,
0.3071187437,
0.2061596364,
0.3436378837,
0.5991024375,
-0.3236690164,
0.1531459391,
-0.6394563317,
-0.2656298876,
-0.5297486186,
-0.0199931841,
-0.5386875868,
-0.8241119385,
0.5699547529,
-0.3874209225,
0.14434883,
0.4389611483,
0.3863791227,
-0.1875784695,
0.4623781145,
0.6819068789,
-0.0223403145,
0.3967340589,
0.4152125418,
0.0266118106,
-0.5648307204,
-0.4612015486,
-0.5813317299,
-0.1315622926,
-0.044763349,
-0.0769896507,
0.4321523905,
0.1726828068,
-0.0695943758,
0.4594198167,
-0.6706924438,
0.5148673058,
0.4448530078,
-0.2546212673,
0.5815333128,
0.4270662665,
-0.0723850504,
-0.0162860304,
-0.3849024773,
-0.6279194951,
0.7410402298,
0.2499633431,
0.8153483272,
-0.1270336956,
0.8898951411,
0.6128553152,
0.3022791445,
-0.7289589047,
0.40517205,
0.2840380073,
-0.5375606418,
-0.04588883,
-0.4133681357,
-1.0717618465,
-0.0231654383,
-0.4394356608,
-0.9753798842,
0.2848023176,
0.2685654461,
-0.5647508502,
-0.2655596733,
-0.6157163978,
0.402402699,
0.0941979289,
0.1993967742,
0.1406964362,
-0.6729243994,
0.3512744606,
-0.7136732936,
0.3344603777,
-0.2229878157,
-0.301261127,
0.752358675,
0.0879001021,
1.1209958792,
0.149260506,
0.0899031088,
0.2937734425,
0.0187061373,
0.2410431355,
0.2065607011,
0.2038045377,
0.697044313,
0.2071368098,
-0.173615694,
-0.2645164132,
0.6994865537,
-0.6812645197,
-0.8029385805,
-0.6336897016,
-0.5200625658,
-0.3160696924,
0.2370340377,
0.4758721292,
-0.1947614849,
-0.1584932506,
0.116758354,
0.6391355991,
-0.1209637523,
0.3088783622,
0.4535073638,
0.0746789426,
-0.1376706362,
0.7678393126,
-0.0896697864,
0.0636181682,
0.2496425062,
0.5000752211,
-0.1775725484,
-0.4756201208,
-0.3084784746,
0.1663009077,
-0.7522262335,
-0.2968286276,
-0.9903221726,
0.0089442823,
-0.447763294,
-0.4403642416,
0.1946037114,
-0.4394011497,
-0.7051855922,
0.2711121142,
0.8528441787,
0.7356072068,
-0.001239185,
0.4505253732,
-0.6793606281,
0.3287172914,
-0.1392115802,
0.2121956944,
-0.2119132727,
-0.5107569695,
-0.0994722173,
-0.410842061,
-0.0451694056,
-0.9460046887,
0.3423017561,
0.2918419242,
0.5388011336,
0.6654986739,
0.0559060201,
0.3095591068,
-0.3184665143,
0.9114477634,
0.5008349419,
-0.810195148,
0.1427129805,
-0.4208231866,
0.4471185803,
0.7455595136,
0.9564153552,
-0.7490628362,
-0.3708410859,
-0.5446817875,
-0.7767198682,
0.2682340145,
-0.157516554,
0.0778944418,
-0.0723105818,
0.3660692275,
0.6148594618,
0.29989326,
-0.3927372992,
-0.1754368395,
0.0630463362,
-0.3978975415,
0.239785403,
0.124463141,
-0.6005170345,
-0.0976963118,
0.1769381762,
-0.413841486,
0.2313497216,
0.093567118,
0.0339072458,
-0.0598441027,
0.0614723265,
0.5656659007,
0.8160144091,
0.0008615717,
0.0639932603,
0.333014518,
-0.7148402333,
-0.1276708245,
-0.1323096752,
-0.3179133534,
0.3852568865,
0.1868605167,
0.2438970506,
-0.1642034501,
-0.6095945835,
0.3885824084,
0.141905278,
-0.1264050752,
-0.5699685216,
0.0353946276,
-0.0324265845,
0.0071457005,
0.5296644568,
0.2619760036,
0.3766029179,
-0.0886902586,
0.2476250827,
0.5053372979,
-0.3206677139,
-0.3874934316,
0.5686948299,
0.2347737104,
-0.1688982099,
-0.1888910979,
-0.0823889524,
-0.1065093055,
0.5636567473,
0.2556663156,
0.799321413,
0.1259761006,
0.1661881059,
0.2069074959,
-0.066746071,
-0.0647610277,
0.1310947388,
-0.1000020057,
-0.4366377592,
-0.0730581433,
-0.6681750417,
-0.5539600253,
-0.0487191528,
-0.4721978903,
0.4639011025,
-0.7610861063,
-0.2508833408,
0.5490514636,
-0.1970079392,
-0.8526220918,
0.1208323017,
0.4390090406,
0.8836359978,
-1.0094352961,
0.4559870064,
0.7958142161,
-0.3677092493,
-0.128774792,
-0.2046767771,
0.5535702109,
-0.3358968794,
0.7060040236,
-0.0759774968,
-0.1295042634,
-0.0838103071,
-0.4993118644,
-0.9973868728,
1.0702660084,
-0.1379145831,
-0.7280409336,
0.0153726293,
0.0418004245,
0.5846635699,
-0.6003343463,
0.3361856043,
0.4749836028,
0.660800159,
0.0750937983,
-0.9597112536,
0.0940036029,
0.0745374709,
-0.1525691152,
0.0106870532,
-0.4887003303,
0.5714738965,
-0.0276233107,
-0.3912416995,
-0.0589106306,
0.9864490032,
0.2504045069,
0.7588457465,
0.5085052252,
-0.0232397486,
1.0400143862,
0.1349673718,
0.6552960277,
-0.5066962838,
0.1470301747,
1.0403969288,
-0.1798918992,
0.3049124479,
0.6370911002,
0.1598680317,
0.5329861641,
0.7294065356,
-0.3663463295,
0.4246089756,
0.2406084388,
-0.6650021076,
0.1112917364,
-0.4388911426,
-0.4711039066,
0.3125975132,
0.6391841769,
-0.4110169411,
-0.1903257966,
0.1548531502,
0.1397251785,
0.1339360774,
-0.1882711351,
0.9671472311,
0.141145274,
-0.489551723,
0.6310195327,
-0.2318301797,
0.9891396165,
-0.5841827989,
0.137233451,
-0.0378027111,
-0.2664088905,
-0.4680151939,
-0.7709388137,
0.1726551056,
0.0893976837,
-0.0764494538,
0.108200632,
0.7926881313,
-0.3066108227,
-0.1182319447,
-0.0452360921,
0.6910594106,
0.3971298039,
-0.0165901817,
-0.5258728862,
-0.1975255311,
-0.2488498241,
-0.2553121746,
0.3936460018,
0.2881566286,
-0.3186863959,
0.6390166879,
0.5503850579,
0.031324137,
-0.0160241388,
-0.051359158,
0.9029842615,
-0.6178777814,
-0.2665295005,
-0.5766726732,
0.0652784556,
-0.3636569679,
-0.9759620428,
1.0869213343,
0.3649042249,
0.9671032429,
-0.5428514481,
1.1077082157,
-0.0658393577,
0.5619661808,
-0.1371305287,
0.6445747614,
-0.2334665358,
0.2523650527,
-0.2696634233,
-0.7616197467,
-0.4946879447,
0.2901991308,
-0.2107951641,
0.0192284379,
0.5744079351,
0.6554265022,
-0.186232686,
0.0186999012,
0.2917856574,
-0.0399007834,
0.1168807521,
0.0852171481,
0.7362829447,
0.3838531673,
0.2901130319,
-0.4131472409,
-0.3115357161,
-0.4392836988,
-1.0079590082,
-1.0813843012,
-0.5746584535,
-0.6897534132,
-0.2016527206,
-0.024523925,
1.1268032789,
0.4868769944,
-0.8948550224,
-0.0693919361,
0.1247936338,
-0.122510612,
-0.3673902452,
-0.2610629201,
-0.0524562001,
-0.3674896359,
-0.5309007168,
0.3795365095,
0.3448241353,
-0.0285716057,
-0.3123895526,
0.2500212193,
-0.0212424248,
0.4255442917,
0.4835694134,
0.8997187614,
-0.861564815,
-0.3435740769,
0.0911271274,
-0.1152779981,
0.1707728952,
0.8542671204,
-1.0194169283,
0.5430018902,
0.6948605776,
0.5555997491,
0.1081352234,
0.548306644,
0.3830469251,
-0.9697008133,
-0.120374158,
0.4075029492,
0.0521684065,
0.4548537433,
-0.9172711968,
0.5643621087,
0.4335877597,
-0.334951818,
-0.5874003768,
0.0922955051,
-1.2538893223,
-0.4497590959,
1.1459207535,
-0.142589584,
-0.1796288639,
-0.7731246948,
-0.2243560553,
-0.2000369579,
-0.6648238897,
1.0987205505,
0.8156374693,
-0.3239038885,
-0.0585078709,
-0.3829222023,
0.8225887418,
0.1762718856,
-0.7995121479,
-0.112488918,
0.4222914875,
0.4161189198,
0.6167561412,
0.400033921,
0.071521394,
0.2392499596,
-0.0765989795,
0.2850676775,
-0.3173412979,
-0.548086524,
-0.4177194536,
0.1242933497,
-0.0031688635,
0.3405713737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09480v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09480v2
|
Show Your Work with Confidence: Confidence Bands for Tuning Curves
| 2023-11-16T00:50:37 | 2024-04-08T18:21:53 |
Nicholas Lourie, Kyunghyun Cho, He He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
The choice of hyperparameters greatly impacts performance in natural language
processing. Often, it is hard to tell if a method is better than another or
just better tuned. Tuning curves fix this ambiguity by accounting for tuning
effort. Specifically, they plot validation performance as a function of the
number of hyperparameter choices tried so far. While several estimators exist
for these curves, it is common to use point estimates, which we show fail
silently and give contradictory results when given too little data.
Beyond point estimates, confidence bands are necessary to rigorously
establish the relationship between different approaches. We present the first
method to construct valid confidence bands for tuning curves. The bands are
exact, simultaneous, and distribution-free, thus they provide a robust basis
for comparing methods.
Empirical analysis shows that while bootstrap confidence bands, which serve
as a baseline, fail to approximate their target confidence, ours achieve it
exactly. We validate our design with ablations, analyze the effect of sample
size, and provide guidance on comparing models with our method. To promote
confident comparisons in future work, we release opda: an easy-to-use library
that you can install with pip. https://github.com/nicholaslourie/opda
|
[
-0.6783440709,
-0.5953700542,
0.6197295785,
0.3736865819,
-0.2110882998,
0.0090748277,
-0.2563488781,
-0.532265842,
0.2188789546,
0.3205879629,
-0.4232988358,
-0.6725425124,
-0.5799974799,
0.0342957973,
-0.4250687957,
0.8247568607,
0.0239429809,
-0.0823652893,
-0.1207737178,
-0.0009836361,
-0.1638875306,
-0.0247298256,
-0.6311418414,
-0.3915183246,
0.7677817941,
0.3844713867,
0.628207922,
0.7364564538,
0.5674681664,
0.2900465429,
-0.0764735639,
0.140359506,
-0.2379298657,
0.2709201872,
0.2176109701,
-0.6488704681,
-0.3458323777,
0.2113340497,
0.3901866972,
0.5443049073,
-0.2168829739,
0.4330596328,
0.0719702616,
0.5174659491,
-0.7990077734,
0.105072096,
-0.6307478547,
-0.3210359812,
-0.3617500365,
-0.2786961496,
-0.4160986245,
-0.9467907548,
-0.0876323283,
-0.7846157551,
0.1224864274,
0.2007613182,
1.1305083036,
0.691850841,
-0.1611260027,
-0.2463200539,
-0.765927434,
0.6889353395,
-0.5860469341,
0.3132783175,
0.8547888398,
0.512324512,
-0.2626750171,
-0.7816907167,
-0.4537407458,
-0.0573491156,
-0.0860308111,
-0.0702253804,
0.050216984,
0.1296824515,
0.4722796679,
0.6817666888,
-0.7127164006,
0.0713282749,
-0.3729688525,
-0.2573707998,
0.450558722,
-0.2215070724,
-0.2024655193,
-0.1447307318,
-0.1073670536,
-0.3932977617,
-0.5556797981,
0.22529158,
0.8889321685,
0.2301074415,
-0.0414550565,
0.6269478202,
-0.2898346782,
0.9962689281,
0.1712370217,
-0.1056356505,
0.2939921319,
0.0449922234,
-0.4065227807,
-0.0538311526,
0.6981218457,
0.3290810883,
0.5283377171,
0.0235591494,
-0.0334248804,
0.3425945342,
0.3398731053,
-0.4638495743,
-0.293970108,
0.3313160837,
-0.0760245994,
-0.195387736,
0.0620146021,
-0.8463529944,
-0.355284512,
-0.2801857293,
0.3614951074,
-0.5065162778,
-0.084957093,
0.2015382797,
-0.3551021516,
0.1737646759,
-0.1089780629,
-0.9824216366,
0.3185670972,
0.8668899536,
0.8932312131,
0.1931947768,
-0.175406009,
-0.5967465639,
-0.1207860783,
-0.500782609,
0.8554409742,
-0.4872445762,
-0.1956621557,
0.0137286428,
-0.1603442878,
-0.2247182876,
-0.4043184221,
1.2163097858,
-0.3556496799,
0.1480435729,
-0.2822395265,
-0.7289177179,
0.1032846197,
0.0404340699,
-0.7115287185,
1.30212152,
0.152305454,
-0.7003705502,
0.7658522725,
-0.6815700531,
-0.3847488463,
-0.0706664994,
0.0693118647,
-0.4613078833,
0.219919771,
-0.015869284,
0.2169360369,
-0.0501725674,
-0.0851889029,
-0.4652634263,
-0.4909349084,
0.2676576972,
-0.1686035991,
0.5827367306,
0.3993376195,
-0.142066285,
0.0460285097,
-0.9384838343,
0.5959484577,
-0.4340850711,
-0.3358051181,
-0.4900361896,
0.0088664573,
0.2152016908,
-0.1171599105,
-0.195776552,
-0.6608549953,
-0.043263156,
-0.4374957681,
0.4607023597,
0.7073014379,
0.0800793022,
0.0319113396,
-0.3855029941,
0.395766288,
-0.3823374212,
0.1169620454,
0.0670701042,
-0.6697379351,
-0.5890362859,
-0.1213897467,
0.742382288,
0.206864804,
-0.6628137827,
0.6683671474,
0.0305220168,
-0.80262357,
-0.8294937015,
0.0427850373,
0.341693908,
0.5977823138,
0.3170384765,
-0.1822899431,
-0.4427017272,
-0.9397392273,
-0.6317273378,
-0.3267274499,
-0.4012488127,
-0.285474807,
0.4154406786,
0.3496259451,
1.2454066277,
-0.8557983637,
-0.0178667456,
0.1861889511,
0.6551361084,
0.0811689198,
0.5945160389,
0.6678512096,
-0.9063079953,
-0.7087470889,
-0.0876752511,
-0.2790915966,
-0.1809422821,
0.2167569846,
-0.2638687193,
0.2133653909,
0.0839216039,
-0.3844023943,
0.416003108,
0.7459515929,
-0.3557857275,
0.4461725056,
-0.0619648956,
0.4338720739,
-0.6043423414,
0.1966221184,
0.5824583769,
-0.2718945742,
-0.4901151657,
-0.2382143289,
0.1343181431,
0.2110483497,
-0.0118396869,
0.2939426601,
-0.0239121001,
0.0149986884,
-0.1297023445,
-0.1004392877,
0.1410587877,
0.3451440036,
-0.0006234341,
0.7204636931,
0.6411166191,
-0.5897606015,
0.1236463711,
0.2680377662,
-0.8073433042,
0.726675272,
-0.6454719901,
0.0347198732,
0.0578125417,
-0.1242669448,
-1.0678681135,
-0.6666792035,
0.2966287732,
-0.7952720523,
0.2139336169,
-0.2547149956,
-0.3666541874,
-0.4175480008,
-0.2931289673,
-0.2753523588,
0.640917182,
-0.357108295,
0.1486528367,
0.4108654261,
-0.0557608865,
-0.5268517733,
-0.9441974163,
-0.3082343936,
-0.5149118304,
-0.5549041033,
0.3398468792,
-0.1746322066,
-0.2865394056,
-0.0974358469,
-0.293325007,
-0.5434414148,
0.1859688461,
0.3310963213,
-0.0281229094,
-0.1430531293,
0.345186621,
0.0667148978,
-0.3991613984,
0.0559779219,
-0.3183115721,
0.4664993584,
-0.064273186,
-0.358867377,
-0.4344588816,
0.1562087685,
0.7017610073,
-0.3812980652,
0.5395221114,
0.7562733889,
-0.3936456144,
-0.1267729402,
-0.649882257,
-0.0553342104,
-0.5030122399,
-0.1267923266,
-0.175614953,
-0.5766445994,
0.2128412873,
0.1177197546,
0.1710431278,
0.1758923829,
0.2436362803,
-0.1909660846,
1.1326640844,
0.8281587362,
0.2508381307,
0.4497326016,
0.2307725102,
0.1084511653,
-0.590177834,
0.0410204306,
-1.0717433691,
-0.32826823,
-0.574531734,
-0.1202964708,
0.4698522985,
-0.0454335958,
-0.2208219022,
0.3462011516,
-0.5349625945,
0.60804075,
0.8415538669,
-0.043576546,
0.3793564439,
0.082225889,
0.153208226,
-0.1120707914,
-0.3364478648,
-0.8002567291,
1.0052353144,
0.3468518257,
0.8075988293,
-0.2769003808,
0.5455836058,
0.1393709928,
0.3447594941,
-0.9359563589,
0.2562898993,
0.0025907164,
-0.7020107508,
-0.5240972042,
-0.6106624603,
-0.7249366045,
0.0444292538,
-0.3571870923,
-0.7063956857,
0.2465405315,
0.4626175165,
-0.6415151358,
0.0794987082,
-0.9740533829,
0.8624641299,
-0.1427137852,
-0.391938448,
0.1754039377,
-0.4042674005,
0.2048550993,
-0.0338557102,
0.0476884358,
-0.1920625567,
0.0839788988,
0.7394468188,
-0.3126702905,
0.5218055248,
-0.2393055111,
-0.0474093594,
0.3046744168,
-0.0406914912,
0.2498637885,
-0.0479073226,
-0.5410461426,
-0.0980296135,
0.2420146614,
-0.4797357023,
-0.5966765285,
0.6371736526,
-0.4100856781,
-0.1388082802,
-0.2829304039,
-0.500187099,
-0.5582160354,
0.2272574008,
0.5054448247,
0.3309397995,
-0.0622455701,
0.3192401528,
0.5290228128,
0.1161802337,
0.3187613189,
0.1905090213,
-0.1563643515,
-0.310526669,
0.5684894323,
0.3073284626,
0.4458429515,
0.065274395,
0.1957199425,
-0.4418592751,
-0.6094645262,
-0.5103522539,
0.060586594,
-0.5552772284,
-0.0610746816,
-0.1637905836,
0.2655512691,
-0.6514671445,
-0.0381253771,
-0.2884529531,
-0.4705004692,
0.2948790789,
-0.2637998164,
0.6323075891,
0.6897391677,
-0.0842480659,
0.6611685753,
-0.2319433242,
0.2304059118,
0.0921843499,
0.9166637063,
-0.4460092187,
0.0224909857,
-0.2715700269,
0.0460284464,
-0.3259141445,
-0.9206591845,
0.4228594899,
0.0925665498,
0.5744403005,
0.3290225863,
0.1727928221,
0.6758018136,
-0.0450254157,
0.4902169406,
-0.0086508393,
-1.029053688,
0.4155361056,
-0.3152022958,
-0.0289224647,
0.9978796244,
0.8051110506,
-0.5576603413,
-0.3778656721,
-0.5776091218,
-0.6341286898,
0.4421506524,
0.3934853971,
-0.4814455509,
0.0440982282,
0.4086330831,
0.077108711,
0.3474266231,
-0.6181129813,
-0.3971816897,
-0.2609146237,
-0.4874062836,
-0.2145166397,
0.0589776449,
-0.3472368419,
-0.1293983012,
0.6621037722,
-0.4341386557,
-0.1113733426,
0.3376909196,
0.2080904096,
-0.379588753,
0.3273127973,
0.2956149578,
0.6990687847,
-0.3502637148,
0.2342918962,
-0.1214137524,
-0.456659615,
-0.1316043586,
-0.0371821262,
-0.3816476464,
0.1143667623,
0.2158669531,
0.7351793647,
0.1852540672,
-0.3605129123,
0.2096787393,
-0.2376555502,
-0.1881045252,
-0.1582149565,
0.2623952627,
0.1194144562,
-0.2045596391,
0.1250458062,
0.3547841012,
0.0990146101,
-0.4486373663,
0.1992439628,
0.2131579816,
-0.782697618,
-0.0326319076,
0.3524385393,
0.0577801168,
-0.3791275918,
0.2370764911,
-0.1491387784,
-0.1705989391,
0.7134712338,
0.2691381276,
0.6688646078,
-0.2464368492,
0.4041154981,
0.5352024436,
0.4928554893,
-0.239430353,
0.2535437644,
0.046711985,
-0.2220931351,
-0.4978715777,
-0.8090562224,
-0.6378183961,
0.0533274263,
-0.966278851,
0.341001004,
-0.3028624058,
-0.3331211209,
0.2311031371,
0.0416647196,
-0.334543854,
0.2556495965,
-0.0237499606,
1.2244153023,
-1.0752928257,
0.7300397754,
0.5129631162,
-0.3649675846,
-0.8280879855,
0.1113196537,
0.0385675617,
-0.5063640475,
-0.139298588,
0.1844319254,
-0.1515915096,
0.1012693867,
-0.6095688939,
-0.7764722705,
0.9404568672,
0.4007720649,
-0.4225698709,
0.1665150374,
0.1304574907,
0.6466299891,
-0.1780954301,
0.4228032529,
0.8426911235,
1.0699797869,
0.4467942715,
-0.9955211282,
-0.2801369727,
-0.0249627288,
-0.4808314443,
0.3822974563,
-0.1969483793,
0.9857212305,
0.1698467284,
-0.4750138819,
0.2279172838,
0.4351475835,
0.0590073876,
0.5614760518,
0.6067590714,
0.4010953903,
1.2849104404,
-0.5269854665,
1.1563278437,
-0.2282340527,
0.3998403251,
0.9007358551,
-0.2840486765,
0.9257583022,
0.61574471,
-0.0937419161,
0.6016524434,
0.8099148273,
0.0324338488,
0.1997237653,
0.268628329,
-0.0024791136,
-0.3641512394,
0.0559732877,
-0.405110836,
0.2783635557,
0.2953004539,
-0.244569242,
-0.200430572,
-0.2132885903,
0.0017450716,
0.3925589323,
-0.3133122623,
0.3568890095,
0.0596240088,
-1.0418775082,
0.5773550272,
-0.0381930992,
0.690348506,
-0.9337135553,
0.0589414723,
0.1011754051,
0.1599701643,
-0.5228509903,
-0.8824391961,
0.5423303843,
0.1250656247,
-0.0801114962,
-0.1698729396,
0.5753384829,
-0.3413135409,
-0.3962145746,
0.0711683854,
0.3690840602,
0.0457113385,
-0.246449545,
-0.2918724716,
0.0678799972,
-0.1052632555,
-0.3030402362,
0.0717910975,
0.2124488503,
0.0677162185,
0.5435192585,
0.6830895543,
0.3689387739,
0.1116141826,
-0.144207567,
0.5051719546,
-0.6149670482,
-0.5197666287,
-0.5888594985,
0.4585498869,
-0.4441555738,
-0.7156802416,
0.7835184336,
0.6079751849,
0.7606054544,
-0.0537169315,
0.7752518058,
-0.1420401037,
0.8147785068,
-0.6752399802,
0.7739498615,
-0.3782972693,
0.027289845,
-0.2325114906,
-0.7353037596,
-0.4853162169,
0.6739886403,
-0.6308653355,
-0.0468067005,
0.8386753798,
0.8801261783,
-0.0584801622,
0.2882633507,
0.1361425817,
0.1541277617,
0.1707514375,
0.4459263384,
0.7488780618,
-0.289557606,
0.637921989,
-0.4612444639,
-0.4086740315,
0.1882419735,
-1.0873117447,
-0.484782517,
-0.5250290632,
-0.3657888472,
-0.2439663261,
-0.1347409934,
0.7979521751,
1.0268517733,
-0.6231028438,
-0.2411338985,
-0.0963452384,
0.3097196817,
-0.4959823489,
-0.2169206738,
0.0900293812,
-0.3269112408,
-0.8902680874,
0.4283024073,
0.0404929295,
-0.0136045944,
-0.1932416856,
-0.0655917525,
-0.0685425401,
0.1727865338,
0.0582923852,
0.5440837145,
-0.3307496309,
-0.3907929063,
-0.0899235979,
-0.1699687093,
0.22347036,
0.7880187035,
-0.8137583137,
0.041445639,
0.6121727824,
0.2314743698,
0.4721325934,
0.1939721406,
0.5331367254,
-0.6701844931,
-0.1391979009,
0.1482552141,
0.2657956183,
0.2806997001,
-0.1217537373,
0.7378028631,
-0.0089306952,
-0.6670134068,
-1.0113699436,
0.4464459419,
-1.0531482697,
-0.0397411063,
0.8297851682,
-0.1426654905,
-0.4132053852,
-0.4529830515,
-0.2627534866,
0.1183289438,
-0.2628269196,
0.7898791432,
0.8682246208,
-0.3175215125,
0.231129691,
-0.6151479483,
0.9855773449,
0.3034971952,
-0.7779538035,
0.1642689258,
0.3660734296,
0.2676401436,
0.5226184726,
0.3440701365,
-0.1264605373,
0.1761721075,
0.1544373482,
-0.0491263159,
-0.197399199,
-0.3291701376,
-0.3535858691,
0.5739890933,
0.3351583779,
-0.1684248596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09476v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09476v2
|
ARES: An Automated Evaluation Framework for Retrieval-Augmented Generation Systems
| 2023-11-16T00:39:39 | 2024-03-31T20:58:46 |
Jon Saad-Falcon, Omar Khattab, Christopher Potts, Matei Zaharia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Evaluating retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) systems traditionally relies
on hand annotations for input queries, passages to retrieve, and responses to
generate. We introduce ARES, an Automated RAG Evaluation System, for evaluating
RAG systems along the dimensions of context relevance, answer faithfulness, and
answer relevance. By creating its own synthetic training data, ARES finetunes
lightweight LM judges to assess the quality of individual RAG components. To
mitigate potential prediction errors, ARES utilizes a small set of
human-annotated datapoints for prediction-powered inference (PPI). Across eight
different knowledge-intensive tasks in KILT, SuperGLUE, and AIS, ARES
accurately evaluates RAG systems while using only a few hundred human
annotations during evaluation. Furthermore, ARES judges remain effective across
domain shifts, proving accurate even after changing the type of queries and/or
documents used in the evaluated RAG systems. We make our code and datasets
publicly available on Github.
|
[
-0.7329828143,
-0.3687333763,
0.6989905238,
0.2270751745,
-0.1750097871,
0.2522138953,
0.0485444888,
-0.3435924649,
0.2881729007,
0.5073239207,
-0.4107539356,
-0.0402044058,
-0.5390941501,
0.2365960181,
-0.5930805802,
1.0290158987,
0.056110058,
0.024184119,
-0.2863406241,
-0.3344629109,
-0.1841729283,
-0.2413319647,
-0.730979681,
-0.5264790654,
0.2327084541,
0.3581828177,
0.5593215823,
0.3186899126,
0.5240303874,
0.306104809,
0.1263664365,
0.5851543546,
-0.2869309783,
0.4833123386,
-0.412761122,
0.0097666616,
-0.4496575296,
0.0431573465,
0.2767979503,
0.3090394139,
-0.0170667488,
0.8782564998,
-0.0397824161,
0.767919004,
-1.0125886202,
-0.3217638135,
-0.6269843578,
0.0440443009,
-0.0996676162,
-0.513517797,
-0.5479960442,
-0.4082978964,
-0.0469167642,
-0.8608415127,
0.2736881375,
0.5269597769,
0.7432085276,
0.4794671237,
-0.3257391751,
-0.4824202657,
-0.9313804507,
0.7711426616,
-0.1955071241,
0.3948564827,
0.7443259954,
0.90357548,
-0.0935199708,
-1.1051101685,
-0.5335727334,
-0.3513142765,
-0.1205896735,
0.1280842274,
0.0203183759,
-0.0383351482,
0.1360827237,
0.465947479,
-0.2418068051,
-0.4960886538,
-0.3650712073,
-0.050519906,
0.7855294943,
0.1047750488,
0.0073361448,
-0.4238377512,
-0.3339550793,
-0.1287025809,
-0.6407165527,
-0.2066083401,
0.3471163809,
0.1592462361,
0.3378254771,
0.657302618,
-0.2658955455,
0.7370921969,
0.5408038497,
0.171214819,
0.1368971616,
-0.1322887689,
-0.3469411433,
-0.4115879536,
0.6635048985,
0.0736798421,
-0.1518213749,
-0.4961151481,
-0.648296833,
-0.2013758272,
0.7553959489,
-0.364574194,
0.1040197536,
0.1530843973,
-0.3706846535,
-0.4798676968,
0.1504315138,
-0.7329965234,
-0.7615039945,
-0.3392942846,
1.1162068844,
-0.239802435,
0.2194767147,
-0.1558843553,
-0.3939443827,
0.0425230823,
0.1552211493,
-0.6571324468,
0.5844183564,
0.6721507907,
0.2859186828,
0.2345720083,
-0.0667317286,
-1.0383477211,
-0.1593132615,
-0.353826344,
0.8537210226,
-0.520878911,
-0.3537907004,
-0.4009864926,
-0.1820155382,
0.126301676,
-0.5913262367,
0.976804018,
-1.0408655405,
0.1329331249,
-0.2640357018,
-0.557397306,
0.0495535359,
0.0261867307,
-0.5046353936,
1.2687926292,
0.3129041791,
-0.4965090454,
0.5704424381,
-0.6167855859,
-0.2050458491,
0.1154434159,
-0.068737708,
-0.2635492384,
0.2895149589,
0.3039352,
0.1825901419,
-0.426077038,
0.1853167415,
-0.1483090073,
-0.3610146344,
0.104907617,
-0.1611526906,
0.3214325607,
0.6178730726,
-0.5477612019,
0.2641438246,
-0.7156261802,
0.2107310295,
-0.1175153553,
-0.1338458657,
-0.3494610786,
0.1883327812,
0.1059164479,
0.0307441987,
0.2229774296,
-0.6014788151,
0.0939496681,
-0.225520134,
-0.1574519277,
0.6906752586,
0.1545230746,
0.6291479468,
-0.3827621639,
0.6717310548,
-0.7484536767,
0.4115701616,
0.0343984626,
-0.3425013125,
-0.9220225811,
-0.0401402675,
0.4976422191,
0.3353102505,
-1.0017453432,
0.5628371835,
-0.2095815241,
-0.6072254181,
-0.4988157749,
0.0379064158,
0.5293856859,
0.6335740089,
0.3660190105,
-0.1916355491,
-0.8326060772,
-1.0066136122,
-0.0900159329,
-0.0382229872,
-0.2832022905,
0.6286052465,
0.655502677,
-0.2094332129,
1.1802872419,
0.0308306478,
0.0085834647,
-0.0954033211,
0.3773160279,
-0.0863307118,
0.1397959143,
0.3847453594,
-0.8396164179,
-0.289919436,
0.0656709,
-0.7300713062,
-0.4831929803,
0.072764717,
-0.1542656124,
-0.1430139989,
0.2077634335,
-0.18120718,
0.3038915992,
0.4962061942,
-0.5345834494,
0.7099844217,
-0.1661545336,
0.5956078768,
-0.8777756691,
0.6647360921,
-0.3914615214,
-0.4084731936,
-0.178465724,
0.2779434621,
0.0181417204,
-0.2122682333,
-0.0874048695,
1.0826559067,
-0.2279453427,
-0.742754817,
-0.4096382856,
0.102885142,
0.2387581617,
-0.0199388601,
-0.3298377693,
1.2062236071,
0.0680848062,
-0.6626712084,
0.2844667137,
0.1367086917,
-0.2543950677,
0.4653266966,
-0.5822691321,
0.3632113039,
-0.0401802585,
0.4118506312,
-0.511405766,
-0.5453688502,
0.0241289698,
-0.6640661955,
0.0539924763,
-0.2420509756,
-0.3608174324,
-0.3617856801,
-0.255291909,
0.1528322697,
0.5581235886,
-0.6796426773,
0.8118439913,
0.4538389444,
0.1681499183,
-1.0108705759,
-0.021261178,
0.0454627872,
-0.1377333403,
-0.4771386087,
0.1312592328,
0.2335936278,
-0.3690358996,
0.2494368404,
-0.2035906613,
0.0025741735,
0.3187918067,
0.4080623686,
0.0265693925,
0.0588308983,
0.2450809777,
0.2034066319,
-0.2580634952,
-0.2589396536,
-0.3534807861,
0.4168727398,
-0.2761777341,
-0.5245190263,
-0.0295102727,
0.0353514813,
0.7221456766,
-0.4098228216,
0.3288036883,
0.4716645479,
-0.3711925447,
-0.3530656099,
-0.5141295791,
-0.1197636276,
-0.4699595869,
0.0216615219,
-0.4014683068,
-0.6139646173,
0.5025447607,
-0.1284211278,
0.3150919378,
0.8400050998,
0.2083744556,
-0.2662134767,
0.8582825065,
0.4336741865,
0.1914559454,
0.1561872959,
-0.4641677439,
-0.1262751669,
-1.1818379164,
-0.0066083898,
-0.5880744457,
-0.4808911383,
-0.1900275201,
-0.5086885095,
0.674970746,
0.4671167731,
-0.4190134704,
0.3032605648,
-0.6195645332,
0.3675411642,
0.4444029927,
-0.0714978576,
0.2015288323,
-0.0801644474,
-0.0022907525,
0.2328257263,
-0.4509147704,
-0.8820672035,
1.585422039,
0.2408012301,
0.5680317879,
-0.1088982522,
0.8962557912,
0.9342150688,
1.0155768394,
-0.5810590386,
0.5007935166,
-0.2426615506,
-0.9902091622,
-0.3154946864,
-0.3670501113,
-0.9280745387,
0.1148934811,
-0.5322833657,
-0.4990935624,
0.2031137943,
0.2192385346,
-0.6752145886,
0.1433137208,
-0.5615455508,
0.2676502168,
-0.2341393828,
-0.4394908845,
-0.3464747369,
-0.4547199309,
0.2125442177,
-0.2428051382,
0.2254650444,
0.0980116874,
-0.0619432293,
0.845304966,
-0.4484727979,
0.2354458421,
-0.3476645648,
0.3456518948,
0.495580256,
0.0580625162,
0.3405284584,
0.0413423963,
-0.4905668199,
-0.4566651881,
-0.2402346432,
-0.1631239802,
-0.8169070482,
0.6108337045,
-0.5893926024,
-0.2455327958,
-0.364854902,
-0.168081671,
-0.5009348392,
0.1272031069,
0.3893434703,
0.5534180999,
-0.1755487472,
0.076839231,
0.4238668382,
-0.2804236412,
0.0018739454,
0.3590677083,
-0.583945334,
-0.7739388943,
0.7864206433,
-0.1046233773,
-0.0936322063,
0.0038965747,
0.075673759,
-0.5074384212,
-0.3111305833,
-0.9793109298,
-0.042203974,
-0.6961399317,
-0.3991180658,
-0.4767744541,
-0.0468705595,
-0.1396801472,
-0.2176267207,
-0.503775835,
-0.6071731448,
0.2212744951,
0.0192279685,
0.273681432,
1.1599987745,
-0.1323983967,
0.2147847563,
-0.8395524621,
0.6535349488,
0.4524459541,
0.5775379539,
-0.2415552586,
-0.655361414,
-0.2428982109,
-0.2085655481,
-0.5443392992,
-0.8280131817,
0.1864828616,
0.3015148044,
0.5710244775,
0.048739396,
0.0236008018,
0.6188440919,
-0.5637639761,
0.6340922117,
-0.2828178108,
-0.9158169031,
0.5417738557,
-0.2399939001,
-0.2394388169,
0.901925981,
0.0609891862,
-0.207495153,
-0.3033011258,
-0.8152912855,
-0.9327619076,
0.702316165,
0.411547333,
-0.1613220721,
0.011390239,
0.670339644,
0.1576692462,
0.1639480591,
-0.2350622118,
-0.3840223849,
0.1844246686,
-0.2322736233,
0.0276024062,
-0.1169658974,
-0.2166805863,
0.0567538738,
0.977811873,
0.0552305207,
0.1972364634,
0.4501676857,
-0.1203344464,
-0.4263024926,
0.2673922777,
0.4123794138,
0.7413521409,
-0.3120986223,
0.009986449,
0.3303103745,
-0.4145746231,
0.4687274396,
0.3568333387,
-0.3665361404,
0.062725611,
0.1318497211,
0.7232899666,
0.1178470403,
-0.6215860248,
0.1202960312,
-0.3213540316,
0.1256178617,
-0.4269295335,
0.0490944572,
-0.3320826888,
0.298974216,
0.959874928,
0.460074544,
0.6659847498,
-0.289812237,
0.573900938,
0.3024933934,
-0.0476416722,
-0.1786141247,
0.8445420265,
0.5042047501,
-0.4610198438,
0.0571139604,
-0.523547411,
-0.4425656199,
0.5795792937,
0.0164659582,
1.1461025476,
-0.2303239852,
0.0680013299,
0.4291754961,
0.3002639413,
0.0603056699,
0.0286907107,
-0.4462511539,
-0.3339791894,
-0.5619310737,
-1.2600828409,
-0.6435053945,
0.1598948091,
-0.5881454945,
0.1726008505,
-0.3617833853,
-0.5194706917,
-0.0721464306,
0.103340432,
-0.5462067723,
0.5507153273,
0.1427604854,
1.001513958,
-0.8607058525,
0.4156130254,
1.0230345726,
-0.1395322233,
-0.6080041528,
-0.0550779998,
-0.2944825888,
-0.4208182395,
0.8940457106,
-0.0808577165,
-0.5300973058,
-0.1027806029,
-0.1881346554,
-0.9572356939,
1.0314172506,
0.3806707561,
-0.1128180027,
0.3691835999,
-0.2502625287,
0.6591745019,
-0.2382912934,
0.5272092223,
0.3829303384,
0.4913853109,
-0.1618763953,
-1.2540867329,
-0.4337567687,
-0.4328675866,
-0.3224059045,
0.2988592386,
-0.1345233321,
0.3574437201,
0.0609625056,
-0.2898443937,
0.2855888009,
0.6113383174,
0.5677652359,
0.8022328615,
0.7273906469,
0.7414032221,
0.5974622965,
-0.0736362711,
1.3484780788,
-0.384299159,
0.5084962845,
1.0968145132,
-0.1640694439,
0.8649725914,
0.3788893521,
-0.0781943724,
0.2746049464,
0.434127301,
0.4251800776,
0.3270153403,
0.0972988233,
-0.438805908,
-0.181538403,
0.1833378226,
-0.1975848824,
0.4007375538,
0.3557473123,
-0.5125390887,
-0.3738293946,
0.1362045854,
-0.4872761071,
0.1411523968,
-0.2198012769,
0.6795848608,
-0.2250135243,
-0.9059508443,
0.5538327694,
0.1508899629,
0.421123594,
-0.5256265402,
-0.1163701043,
-0.2394426316,
0.0738245249,
-0.2915939689,
-0.7516743541,
0.6361773014,
0.4639693499,
-0.091520451,
-0.2470028996,
0.9545504451,
0.2292872667,
-0.4705566168,
0.14742589,
0.3931330144,
0.0817036182,
0.1026263386,
-0.5504071116,
0.0447940901,
-0.1790635437,
-0.6632842422,
0.1772113144,
0.1820361018,
-0.214908421,
0.8630438447,
0.5302108526,
-0.0330117606,
0.1011920273,
-0.0987866372,
0.8004630804,
-0.272926867,
-0.1358431578,
-0.1390473396,
0.5449327826,
-0.22241956,
-0.4314844906,
0.6797155738,
0.6269429326,
0.3129004538,
-0.0343164802,
0.8242282271,
-0.5128540397,
0.7750465274,
-0.0982503667,
0.9512247443,
-0.7239102721,
0.2831503749,
0.0665032789,
-1.0455701351,
0.0525494143,
0.5330767632,
-0.460177809,
0.1903399229,
0.116588898,
0.4181119204,
-0.3545247912,
-0.111769326,
0.2226014435,
-0.2039221823,
0.197844848,
-0.0438366458,
0.8009047508,
-0.765737474,
0.3016655445,
-0.4089758694,
-0.3809154928,
-0.1989783347,
-0.5559673309,
-0.1653273255,
-0.7397432923,
0.2288762182,
-0.2902294397,
0.2525572777,
0.7942131162,
0.8238809109,
-0.7361081839,
-0.1105401218,
-0.1072104797,
-0.1658530831,
0.0256694704,
-0.2714975178,
0.3376343548,
-0.7784969807,
-0.6700655818,
0.7398830056,
0.2863489687,
-0.5241318941,
-0.2613633573,
-0.2673513293,
0.0911632031,
0.2572387457,
0.6265613437,
0.4245708883,
-0.6278829575,
-0.4395481944,
0.1307957768,
-0.123793751,
-0.5029718876,
0.5055753589,
-1.2482633591,
0.7578290701,
0.3868569434,
0.7992411852,
0.3774442077,
0.3851465881,
0.463820219,
-0.821942687,
-0.0600194521,
0.6624705791,
0.3583437204,
0.2811673582,
-0.1874951869,
0.7478888631,
-0.1257883161,
-0.9770160317,
-0.8834640384,
0.1224260256,
-0.6788051128,
0.1619395018,
0.9812054038,
-0.0804135352,
-0.0980906487,
-0.123247765,
-0.3302395344,
0.231479764,
-0.1192655191,
0.9684317708,
0.3325969577,
-0.3018842936,
0.2104640156,
-0.7068917155,
0.7308875918,
0.5315394402,
-0.7688038349,
-0.0436104797,
0.6282408834,
0.1864245236,
0.5339525938,
0.587937057,
-0.1650260985,
0.6606889367,
-0.1331499219,
0.2597890198,
-0.069679141,
-0.3256932199,
-0.2954497635,
0.2410741448,
0.2146416903,
-0.1378869414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09473v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09473v1
|
JAB: Joint Adversarial Prompting and Belief Augmentation
| 2023-11-16T00:35:54 | 2023-11-16T00:35:54 |
Ninareh Mehrabi, Palash Goyal, Anil Ramakrishna, Jwala Dhamala, Shalini Ghosh, Richard Zemel, Kai-Wei Chang, Aram Galstyan, Rahul Gupta
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With the recent surge of language models in different applications, attention
to safety and robustness of these models has gained significant importance.
Here we introduce a joint framework in which we simultaneously probe and
improve the robustness of a black-box target model via adversarial prompting
and belief augmentation using iterative feedback loops. This framework utilizes
an automated red teaming approach to probe the target model, along with a
belief augmenter to generate instructions for the target model to improve its
robustness to those adversarial probes. Importantly, the adversarial model and
the belief generator leverage the feedback from past interactions to improve
the effectiveness of the adversarial prompts and beliefs, respectively. In our
experiments, we demonstrate that such a framework can reduce toxic content
generation both in dynamic cases where an adversary directly interacts with a
target model and static cases where we use a static benchmark dataset to
evaluate our model.
|
[
-0.3827457428,
-0.9745407701,
0.3095341623,
-0.1103912145,
0.0433767959,
0.1856635809,
-0.2401150167,
-0.2947335541,
0.048085589,
0.5893568993,
-0.5218093991,
-0.4438054562,
-0.6006391048,
-0.0637561828,
-0.2350237817,
1.1864864826,
0.166472137,
-0.0293733869,
-0.1640903503,
0.0129425749,
-0.621929884,
-0.2590249181,
-0.7763067484,
-0.3934854567,
0.4779954553,
-0.0016663284,
1.1027295589,
0.3016048968,
0.3391725719,
0.3731601536,
-0.1636962146,
0.1844669282,
-0.496001482,
0.6610059142,
-0.4371332824,
-0.7649330497,
-0.1014788896,
-0.11643558,
0.3896677196,
0.5276502371,
0.064916268,
-0.1384236217,
0.0141600817,
0.2209794372,
-1.0123120546,
-0.0838737115,
-0.7470653057,
-0.1880830228,
0.2239754498,
-0.4214281142,
-0.755556643,
-0.240244031,
0.1164080277,
-0.5612582564,
0.2232309878,
-0.0609864257,
0.9311268926,
0.4638803601,
-0.3013133705,
-0.1913909912,
-0.5197503567,
0.5888973475,
-0.6984841228,
0.092720516,
0.3397909701,
0.1749251038,
-0.3953759074,
-0.4228650033,
-0.4625385702,
-0.5330350399,
-0.01087703,
0.1749230772,
-0.2650357485,
0.2262226343,
0.2893191278,
0.1996000111,
-0.4803023934,
-0.0828876421,
-0.2058649957,
-0.3091542125,
0.5877984166,
0.0596274026,
0.4870716631,
-0.0300732702,
-0.3202930093,
-0.6371933818,
-0.7348757982,
-0.0648845136,
0.5285279155,
0.378267318,
0.0876588896,
0.5554186106,
-0.054006841,
0.6679879427,
0.2917954326,
-0.006405998,
-0.0005095761,
-0.4297883511,
-0.0865699649,
-0.0703763813,
0.7923429012,
0.5872095227,
-0.1186014861,
-0.1592428088,
-0.1567571908,
0.7492969036,
0.8724409938,
-0.4386056066,
-0.6444301009,
0.2001947314,
-0.1052210554,
-0.7376661301,
-0.0247232653,
-0.6977379918,
-0.6197647452,
0.0817004144,
0.7770113945,
-0.6275084019,
-0.4889737666,
0.0184027441,
-0.3966474533,
-0.3442242444,
0.283292979,
-0.7344022393,
-0.0584410876,
0.5100210309,
0.6069703102,
-0.0675289184,
-0.1873614043,
-0.6636810899,
0.3113164902,
-0.5270468593,
0.5194148421,
-0.6657188535,
-0.3848620057,
-0.0705078393,
-0.1733425409,
0.0896868631,
-0.3603332043,
0.0921190381,
-0.6209389567,
0.542764008,
-0.3735821545,
-0.2039073259,
-0.4028186202,
0.7641711831,
-0.6068131328,
0.8543791771,
0.0502595007,
-0.9375374913,
0.5718016624,
-0.8801040053,
-0.3904789686,
0.1489598006,
-0.0587145463,
-0.5129239559,
-0.0562913753,
0.4868024886,
0.0773010179,
-0.1081255674,
0.2717771232,
-0.7162505388,
-0.3755072951,
0.1272921711,
-0.5391311049,
0.9854459167,
0.1008531526,
-0.6810861826,
0.3933857679,
-0.4584734142,
0.083095789,
0.1833457202,
-0.1990927309,
-0.5140250325,
-0.0202592947,
-0.4236289859,
-0.1007334739,
-0.0542079918,
-0.3269735575,
0.1973679364,
-0.6026129723,
-0.0639509186,
0.69577986,
0.2722649276,
0.4955909252,
-0.2898294628,
0.7088634968,
-0.0188360065,
0.0891082361,
-0.4825011194,
-0.3853603899,
-0.7133208513,
-0.069063291,
0.2886951864,
0.4207867384,
-1.3423023224,
0.2779548168,
0.0818857774,
-0.2686294913,
-0.6070349216,
0.0468998738,
0.661631763,
0.4166059494,
0.3548697829,
-0.1792252511,
-0.3217273951,
-0.6202001572,
-0.0591934957,
-0.6680911183,
-0.0764310062,
-0.0076216678,
0.3913598359,
-0.2165533453,
0.5331320763,
-0.1355653554,
0.2988155484,
-0.1353261024,
0.5028552413,
-0.0194092672,
0.3820370138,
0.5883157849,
-0.8943806887,
-0.4105496705,
0.0640038177,
-0.7276194692,
-0.1283485144,
-0.2372966558,
-0.0246434696,
0.1087348089,
0.20419541,
-0.2813441753,
0.52940166,
0.5918467045,
-0.3870678544,
0.3908287287,
-0.0562494323,
0.7000564933,
-1.1405754089,
-0.0287617426,
0.0072762542,
-0.2168822885,
-0.5954769254,
0.6835135818,
0.1963233352,
-0.0571454912,
-0.2853786945,
0.2051352113,
-0.4344180226,
0.116751492,
-0.5613672733,
-0.023774324,
0.1922409385,
0.2374114692,
-0.0733799189,
1.0667088032,
0.698219955,
-0.7334394455,
0.5113351941,
0.1991787255,
0.0660125986,
0.5702451468,
-0.7257913947,
0.024440458,
-0.1088467464,
0.1654495597,
-0.8658295274,
-0.3653546572,
0.4830289483,
-0.7939683199,
0.5889832377,
-0.0582344346,
-0.4413660467,
-0.4836560786,
-0.4326102734,
0.0872188285,
0.3633943796,
-0.7012822032,
0.4338733554,
0.3361766636,
-0.1332491636,
-0.7236297131,
-0.6575608253,
0.2333545238,
-0.1687445641,
-0.7809429169,
0.2842254937,
-0.1319198459,
-0.4416024089,
0.1408077627,
0.1137857735,
0.154966116,
0.3139979541,
0.2126075625,
0.4753368199,
-0.1313483417,
-0.1068814248,
0.1400910765,
-0.18695876,
0.3082257509,
-0.1519329846,
0.3656005859,
0.0655130893,
-0.625125289,
-0.1983999908,
0.4787431359,
0.4611009657,
-0.0737371147,
0.8185752034,
0.5570755601,
-0.2138730288,
-0.3308677971,
-0.3759660721,
-0.4290034473,
-0.5982042551,
0.1860030442,
-0.3219425082,
-0.9398467541,
0.3043039441,
0.0198675878,
-0.0360252745,
0.1859393418,
0.8608463407,
0.1581468135,
1.3920994997,
0.5597128272,
-0.0454627015,
0.2972723246,
-0.0938244164,
0.1521072239,
-0.4556761086,
0.044266995,
-0.2198821306,
0.0603944398,
-0.3846993744,
-0.2873292267,
0.8510354161,
0.0316606611,
-0.0993547216,
0.3928310573,
-0.7800344825,
0.4651693106,
0.6710968614,
0.4237273335,
-0.1401986629,
-0.2661359012,
-0.5131772161,
-0.0283580888,
-0.7288997769,
-0.2276652306,
0.9498001337,
0.415245086,
0.8471018672,
0.1694269478,
0.5536220074,
0.360483557,
0.2676120102,
-0.5794611573,
0.4221228361,
0.2603214681,
-0.8679834604,
-0.0018454313,
-0.3329938948,
-0.6413449049,
0.1435511261,
-0.3476599753,
-0.8127774596,
0.0020619752,
0.4458998442,
-0.4246275425,
0.3251188397,
-0.8060417175,
0.6456316113,
-0.1587934345,
-0.7739949822,
-0.3356198967,
-0.6236923337,
0.488666594,
0.0987872556,
-0.1435621381,
0.4616157115,
0.1548018008,
0.2783567011,
-0.2427427918,
1.0049550533,
-0.2704557776,
-0.1939359456,
0.2559766769,
0.3353741467,
0.801404655,
0.1821227223,
-0.2068873346,
-0.2551928759,
-0.2749316394,
-0.2948177159,
-0.6215641499,
0.6455059052,
-0.4928092659,
-0.9095052481,
-0.4605401754,
-0.9447336793,
-0.3176739812,
0.2690314651,
0.2549741566,
0.2557213902,
0.1195882857,
0.3337945938,
0.8270633817,
-0.5037748814,
0.2647408545,
0.482503444,
0.0878075734,
-0.4895164073,
0.7829090953,
-0.5345382094,
0.7848366499,
0.2875193954,
-0.0655226633,
-0.4491026998,
-0.8948466778,
-0.324485302,
-0.0285549574,
-0.7901182771,
-0.3524591923,
-0.4793436527,
-0.0774090737,
-0.6056982875,
-0.3486828208,
-0.3591572046,
0.1285689324,
-0.0906186551,
-0.0770510808,
0.2482832968,
0.8055446744,
-0.2193284035,
0.1982338578,
-0.7330501676,
0.311902523,
0.1554348469,
0.1611192971,
-0.3866207302,
-0.2486375272,
-0.107437253,
0.5051233768,
-0.3756835163,
-1.1167919636,
0.4679459631,
-0.3903201222,
0.5349619985,
0.3087722063,
0.5686116219,
0.6846824288,
-0.0110390931,
0.9724187255,
0.3802846372,
-0.9315496087,
0.94791466,
-0.6217173338,
0.3308909237,
0.571570456,
0.4069161117,
-0.0255728047,
-0.988954246,
-0.5630909801,
-0.6157884598,
0.6211085916,
0.2927575409,
-0.1493259966,
-0.0643943995,
0.031636741,
0.0815612674,
0.1167613789,
-0.7964782715,
-0.3151940405,
-0.1963085979,
-0.0877483562,
0.2181809545,
-0.0871483758,
-0.5918429494,
0.1344049871,
0.8582091331,
-0.4099668264,
0.1905097216,
-0.0361891203,
-0.0707314387,
-0.5405162573,
0.269906193,
0.3555125296,
0.306904465,
-0.1154671162,
0.0305874646,
0.2739447355,
-0.188139081,
0.1912751347,
0.1691841632,
-0.5307947993,
-0.1210967451,
0.3270661831,
0.9060737491,
0.1371129304,
-0.4892437756,
0.498781532,
-0.1617268622,
-0.2721148133,
0.1399694532,
0.4753864706,
-0.26066944,
0.4372037649,
0.1434959471,
0.4400677085,
0.1815880686,
-0.4691182077,
0.5623865128,
0.7225001454,
-0.2993567884,
-0.099833928,
0.8265346885,
0.149186179,
-0.0678038597,
-0.0588954724,
-0.4639952183,
-0.8702697754,
0.3379616439,
0.7360289693,
0.6399555206,
-0.2755695879,
0.4797698259,
0.485532403,
0.4276677668,
-0.0940651298,
-0.1164139286,
-0.1756710857,
-0.6388265491,
-0.5865347981,
-0.2109111995,
-0.7129647732,
0.1788821369,
-0.9640372396,
0.2779160738,
-0.48915416,
-0.0827708244,
0.0182332136,
0.0936647356,
-0.21145913,
0.4076315463,
0.0569906309,
0.3929257989,
-0.7964326143,
0.6501144767,
0.8148479462,
-0.4925508201,
-0.8008213043,
0.2386607826,
0.4769245386,
-0.8555505276,
0.3896526694,
0.1259548962,
-0.0483111627,
-0.2896107435,
-0.5757336617,
-0.7487443089,
0.7915287614,
0.3104760647,
-0.5021346211,
0.0490200035,
-0.2952753305,
0.440166533,
-0.0587798804,
0.4447268546,
0.2849305272,
0.4537061453,
0.4134385884,
-0.8137119412,
0.2767682374,
-0.5527448058,
-0.1787638664,
0.3948548734,
-0.4065145254,
0.6671809554,
-0.3956818879,
-0.3617631495,
-0.0206973664,
0.6323105693,
0.4864364862,
0.2758540809,
0.8023312688,
0.6261229515,
0.6219084263,
-0.1022899374,
1.2145723104,
-0.3355113566,
0.0640428513,
1.0092992783,
-0.2173353434,
0.4580977559,
0.2271278203,
-0.1174273044,
0.3225525022,
0.4294642806,
-0.1856748611,
0.6237740517,
-0.1347501278,
-0.42705217,
-0.2613079846,
-0.1434085071,
-0.4714100063,
0.1791541278,
0.6103792787,
-0.4071366191,
-0.2419719994,
0.1595465988,
0.1267071962,
0.3051198125,
0.0349936187,
0.8385006785,
-0.3721921742,
-1.1901204586,
0.7364403605,
-0.2609393597,
0.8430729508,
-0.6286689639,
0.0422006734,
0.1520845592,
0.3702241778,
0.1064330041,
-0.7726778388,
0.405015856,
-0.1202103943,
-0.0705752894,
-0.2212433964,
0.99184376,
-0.5621851683,
-0.2133319229,
0.4721984863,
0.0323376507,
-0.4732563198,
-0.0553743839,
-0.9019272923,
0.3222329617,
0.2810027301,
-0.1594110876,
0.2611675262,
0.1840464175,
0.2550512552,
0.7652752995,
0.7806890011,
0.33799088,
-0.046181377,
0.1482651085,
1.2530009747,
-0.4760017097,
-0.5448356867,
-0.6218187213,
0.7163708806,
-0.2753058076,
0.0120135807,
0.8215473294,
-0.1198313534,
0.8220695853,
0.2671708167,
1.0622234344,
-0.0861462206,
0.5157051086,
-0.3485152125,
0.7964089513,
-0.5152032375,
0.4320539236,
-0.2570048869,
-0.5101776719,
-0.329292804,
0.5391440392,
-0.2521440387,
0.0448800139,
0.6430063248,
1.1979010105,
0.2161153853,
0.1800386012,
0.3363260329,
0.2525710464,
0.6008654237,
0.5549098849,
0.8374663591,
-0.5393363237,
0.6297293901,
-0.4046519101,
-0.3639837503,
-0.0542353392,
-0.7948814631,
-1.1899443865,
-0.3841732144,
-0.4873515666,
-0.8546414971,
0.5057882667,
0.6821641922,
0.6635122299,
-0.986251533,
0.4224663079,
-0.3398910165,
0.0714085847,
-0.1672998071,
-0.3334181011,
-0.1945278645,
-0.5473842025,
-0.7624228001,
0.71009624,
0.3913696408,
0.060471952,
-0.4610314965,
-0.1419422328,
-0.1512881666,
-0.0904444233,
0.229767248,
0.2539859414,
-0.7933415174,
-0.4223222733,
-0.0631185174,
-0.0622998439,
-0.4004710913,
0.4935542345,
-0.7535845637,
0.9699955583,
0.4812198579,
0.8415465355,
0.2048340142,
0.0086246785,
1.2176123857,
-0.739582479,
0.1724515259,
0.3985355198,
0.1773292422,
0.4976122677,
-0.6056603193,
0.4324651957,
0.1258900017,
-0.4011225402,
-1.0337148905,
0.2639023066,
-0.7490837574,
-0.4483229518,
1.2636692524,
-0.3531779349,
-0.3109510243,
-0.1841218323,
-0.2214878052,
0.3560803235,
-0.4653761685,
0.9091494679,
0.5571812987,
0.3141519725,
-0.3013612032,
-0.0268539451,
0.3759324253,
0.6933096051,
-0.7737407684,
-0.1477113068,
0.5831843615,
-0.0267519187,
0.56283921,
0.2361291051,
-0.04216142,
0.6565513611,
0.6793034077,
-0.1781344116,
-0.2625407875,
-0.4275081754,
-0.0899522007,
0.4469988942,
-0.2182843983,
-0.288635999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09469v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09469v1
|
Clarify When Necessary: Resolving Ambiguity Through Interaction with LMs
| 2023-11-16T00:18:50 | 2023-11-16T00:18:50 |
Michael J. Q. Zhang, Eunsol Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Resolving ambiguities through interaction is a hallmark of natural language,
and modeling this behavior is a core challenge in crafting AI assistants. In
this work, we study such behavior in LMs by proposing a task-agnostic framework
for resolving ambiguity by asking users clarifying questions. Our framework
breaks down this objective into three subtasks: (1) determining when
clarification is needed, (2) determining what clarifying question to ask, and
(3) responding accurately with the new information gathered through
clarification. We evaluate systems across three NLP applications: question
answering, machine translation and natural language inference. For the first
subtask, we present a novel uncertainty estimation approach, intent-sim, that
determines the utility of querying for clarification by estimating the entropy
over user intents. Our method consistently outperforms existing uncertainty
estimation approaches at identifying predictions that will benefit from
clarification. When only allowed to ask for clarification on 10% of examples,
our system is able to double the performance gains over randomly selecting
examples to clarify. Furthermore, we find that intent-sim is robust,
demonstrating improvements across a wide range of NLP tasks and LMs. Together,
our work lays foundation for studying clarifying interactions with LMs.
|
[
-0.369220674,
-1.0627331734,
0.8587423563,
0.1792206019,
-0.1837030649,
-0.3322649598,
-0.4195446074,
-0.6589477062,
0.1067664251,
0.3581266999,
-0.9479839206,
-0.1121559143,
-0.6065117121,
0.2856097817,
-0.2148102373,
0.6086900234,
-0.2392799109,
-0.0896136761,
-0.5472460389,
-0.1704676449,
-0.6779095531,
-0.1988696754,
-0.9213827848,
-0.3999226391,
0.4750045836,
0.5041023493,
1.0099670887,
0.5605752468,
0.4761734009,
0.4569803178,
-0.1906949878,
0.5798908472,
-0.0510812104,
0.4294948876,
-0.2752913535,
-0.7663007975,
-0.2210238427,
-0.5921579003,
0.3014020026,
1.0271599293,
0.0045257299,
0.1563195437,
0.1481429338,
0.6250932217,
-0.8788710237,
-0.1437170953,
-0.5676862001,
0.0824694484,
0.0465956405,
-0.2158962488,
-0.2565944195,
0.1612393111,
0.2439823747,
-0.8204827309,
0.1148879528,
0.0850169212,
1.1010257006,
0.8332918882,
-0.4561226666,
-0.4387749434,
-0.9480505586,
0.7560331225,
-0.521545887,
0.401812613,
0.4770796597,
0.2684471011,
-0.2595847547,
-0.7044093013,
-0.4061990678,
0.0107137915,
-0.4029115736,
-0.2215536833,
-0.4084188342,
0.411836952,
0.3516639173,
0.2754204273,
-0.2058728933,
-0.2878732979,
-0.4318035841,
-0.1157247573,
0.6858028173,
0.1106975526,
0.1644871384,
-0.0850681514,
-0.3580334187,
0.4337631762,
-0.4816352129,
0.2063230574,
0.2053102106,
-0.020648811,
0.202222541,
0.7577999234,
-0.2094119042,
0.6825643182,
0.267529428,
0.2224371284,
-0.0212595854,
-0.2717207074,
-0.3619334698,
-0.2086680382,
0.5119552016,
0.4588973522,
0.0986718535,
-0.3393891454,
-0.2294948101,
-0.3607987761,
0.5041381717,
-0.229070887,
0.2393824011,
0.8415862918,
-0.2298191637,
0.3303843439,
-0.0757176727,
-0.3423621356,
-0.6974790096,
-0.7437159419,
0.6469284296,
-0.222090885,
-0.2088920474,
0.2778991461,
-0.049279999,
0.0114399958,
0.7849681973,
-0.6961907148,
0.2408397049,
0.6696183681,
0.5220223069,
-0.011253966,
-0.2758366764,
-0.3807232678,
0.3521443009,
-0.1909336746,
0.4420811236,
-0.1330200136,
-0.3814425766,
-0.1106118858,
-0.0076668016,
-0.2313262969,
-0.6123679876,
0.6887737513,
-0.4583256841,
0.1865082979,
-0.4097834826,
-0.7702240944,
-0.1863308847,
0.4651381075,
-0.6895672083,
0.9397902489,
-0.2253222764,
-0.7267589569,
0.3112266064,
-0.8591974974,
-0.122728765,
0.2314971685,
-0.3316421807,
-0.1890351325,
0.1100600362,
0.2242475301,
0.2726046741,
0.023190368,
0.4405655861,
-0.0285337158,
-0.2153375894,
0.2271313071,
-0.3902783692,
0.5146123171,
0.3695938885,
-0.237930581,
0.4363788366,
-0.4901566207,
0.2541355193,
-0.3504104912,
-0.2025877237,
-0.3105196655,
0.073657088,
-0.6322580576,
-0.0826369002,
0.7341964841,
-0.1657798737,
-0.0382518061,
-0.3029696941,
0.1797470897,
0.4512947202,
0.1718420386,
0.5944205523,
-0.2815081179,
0.5513069034,
0.0630173832,
0.4680727422,
-0.2029505074,
-0.5858947635,
-0.9814778566,
0.1198593453,
0.1121560633,
0.6839908361,
-0.7488745451,
0.3586273193,
0.0261651669,
-0.1398225725,
-0.9062021375,
0.3550980091,
0.3990600407,
0.3838525116,
0.6079923511,
0.1590173841,
-0.732375145,
-0.9883657098,
-0.6024379134,
-0.3925038278,
-0.2460366488,
0.406250298,
0.2631692886,
-0.2530076504,
1.3602718115,
-0.2720397711,
0.0714832395,
-0.329662323,
0.4652925432,
-0.0937814265,
0.4712072313,
0.1945420653,
-1.0701857805,
-0.3420110047,
0.0629714355,
-0.5935978889,
-0.1734105498,
-0.3131279647,
-0.1454812437,
0.2676808834,
0.8129156232,
-0.9228608012,
0.6917486191,
0.11601042,
-0.0888602957,
0.2465210855,
-0.5432987213,
0.1428516656,
-0.8741288185,
0.2299183607,
-0.1367023438,
-0.3858242035,
-0.9726388454,
-0.007591302,
0.0297383908,
0.2548024356,
-0.2665418088,
0.7373009324,
-0.5492008328,
0.1936144531,
-0.290032208,
0.2815032303,
0.1986206472,
0.3195886016,
0.0672726631,
0.56207937,
0.3283161819,
-0.9218714237,
0.0519830361,
-0.0696279854,
-0.0030118912,
0.5007928014,
-0.6994376183,
-0.043131154,
-0.3479511142,
0.0506765358,
-0.8573557734,
-0.3717994988,
0.5931326747,
-0.4214890301,
-0.0346983261,
-0.2732362151,
-0.2581442297,
-0.3693689704,
0.1242489815,
0.4328577518,
0.0170663297,
-0.308963716,
1.0479373932,
0.1587144881,
0.0140737994,
-1.0413557291,
-0.4858748615,
0.034986347,
-0.1786884218,
-0.7306312919,
0.1933749765,
-0.2720639408,
-0.670922339,
-0.0858369246,
-0.4877844453,
-0.3354899585,
0.4154162407,
0.487447232,
-0.0482111536,
-0.0315949321,
0.3285396695,
-0.0480490029,
0.0649620816,
0.2348365933,
0.2421982735,
0.3879447877,
-0.3202536106,
-0.8135052919,
-0.4596757889,
0.3794369996,
0.2724687457,
-0.0535694137,
0.5733334422,
0.7644574642,
-0.5370932221,
-0.0075105438,
-0.7430465221,
-0.1937472075,
-0.5638798475,
0.1285272837,
-0.5232748985,
-0.7635317445,
0.9196998477,
-0.0654496551,
0.2971681058,
0.3881357908,
0.2175827622,
-0.2452799827,
1.0898790359,
0.6544210315,
0.2683591247,
0.2661155164,
0.2542903721,
0.435597837,
-0.5784177184,
-0.4431440234,
-0.5867576599,
-0.4212204516,
-0.1305941343,
-0.4772944152,
0.2545174956,
0.3429731429,
0.2988365293,
0.0958264545,
-0.1802603006,
0.4197369218,
0.671243906,
0.1195774898,
0.2546365857,
-0.4343652129,
0.1813627481,
0.010872365,
-0.3724585176,
-0.5397268534,
0.6165513396,
0.4733383954,
0.6278879642,
0.4040980041,
0.6190522313,
0.2221290916,
0.0640760809,
-0.726464808,
0.5596956611,
0.4178946614,
-0.8566599488,
-0.474375993,
-0.3918897212,
-1.1216417551,
0.281978488,
-0.119893454,
-0.8978030086,
0.2184022665,
0.5857426524,
-0.5482182503,
0.0786126629,
-1.0391222239,
0.7799698114,
-0.2032980323,
-0.5603394508,
-0.0214890409,
-1.0998700857,
0.1465869844,
0.2540175617,
0.2317223549,
-0.1660015136,
-0.4283741713,
0.2429255247,
-0.5368846059,
0.940486908,
-0.1958876103,
-0.4554717243,
0.3322876394,
-0.0167668406,
0.4291861057,
0.2037540227,
-0.2897911072,
-0.1899040192,
0.0827539414,
-0.1313097477,
-0.9556258917,
0.3504633307,
-0.4711046815,
-0.9880897403,
-0.0620613582,
-0.8040168881,
-0.1514605582,
0.3075889647,
0.1620840877,
-0.0217660759,
0.0347429588,
-0.0180024989,
0.7813334465,
0.2107025087,
0.1473255157,
0.5890420079,
-0.1486294121,
0.1973429918,
0.3651827872,
-0.1844416857,
0.245157972,
0.3361331522,
0.0393701792,
-0.3807854652,
-0.3976636231,
-0.6293875575,
0.1942792684,
-0.9661562443,
-0.0054116142,
-0.6266741157,
-0.0168040544,
-0.292893976,
-0.0674340576,
-0.1198950112,
-0.3628126979,
-0.6159753203,
0.1805915385,
0.2955687642,
0.7757852077,
-0.1282378137,
0.4820635617,
-0.6559349298,
0.2897282839,
0.0581811592,
0.1650351286,
-0.3405937254,
-0.4807763994,
-0.1077479348,
0.4195282459,
-0.1723679602,
-1.0132579803,
0.045167882,
0.2113498449,
0.7583581209,
0.6438676119,
0.4042533636,
0.941016376,
-0.2417637855,
1.0447006226,
-0.1089429483,
-1.0677434206,
0.6327655315,
-0.0475871824,
0.3886045814,
0.9226252437,
0.3806423843,
-0.6645258665,
-0.5084850192,
-0.8010771275,
-1.2568584681,
0.5637254119,
0.2694438994,
0.0082631614,
0.0637475103,
0.8860775828,
-0.1729309261,
0.5447484851,
-0.7531237006,
-0.6473556757,
0.2739382088,
-0.2359256148,
0.2127606869,
-0.2563176453,
-0.5047074556,
-0.0631916672,
0.6046507359,
-0.0252669659,
0.1331387013,
0.3541541398,
-0.2791240215,
-0.2669198215,
0.4817601442,
0.8011193275,
0.9237601161,
-0.1726706177,
0.3042127192,
0.4442228973,
-0.1968234777,
-0.171670258,
0.0422018394,
0.0075050713,
0.326564461,
0.2028399408,
0.7334499359,
-0.0017148542,
-0.7550695539,
0.4631954134,
-0.2312486172,
-0.1597921848,
-0.2393714935,
0.2889351249,
0.0010220374,
0.1568156183,
0.1863149703,
0.1521025151,
0.3753266633,
-0.1760079116,
0.1212848499,
0.6265163422,
-0.4422400892,
0.0532019772,
0.4091025591,
0.2923991382,
-0.4538795352,
0.2673275173,
-0.2615640759,
-0.408829838,
0.641792953,
0.1154999584,
0.6554083824,
-0.4127196074,
0.0518664904,
0.1987588257,
0.4829475284,
-0.0423788056,
0.4817836881,
-0.5695061684,
-0.4586738646,
-0.3327804506,
-0.0859033838,
-0.8429374099,
0.1055757999,
-0.7521432638,
0.3471540809,
-0.1340852976,
-0.3100250065,
-0.0717955455,
-0.0434324853,
-0.4416406155,
0.2727478147,
-0.0542972758,
0.8523755074,
-0.7091212273,
0.2891522348,
0.9244203568,
-0.2375527024,
-0.901527524,
0.1747025102,
-0.0342351124,
-0.6499230862,
0.1950012147,
0.0497043841,
-0.4037334621,
-0.3034086525,
-0.5836231112,
-0.7985701561,
1.0271081924,
0.3257984817,
-0.283718437,
-0.0141927358,
0.3121992052,
0.575612545,
-0.1104310676,
0.5014532208,
0.4662550688,
0.7529371381,
0.1676861793,
-0.9165009856,
-0.1129025966,
-0.4354524612,
-0.3501192033,
0.3297137618,
-0.210117951,
0.6036993265,
-0.3947549462,
-0.4547581375,
0.3064304888,
0.8576562405,
-0.0379704162,
0.7370009422,
0.8285902739,
0.2335283011,
1.2042101622,
-0.0975884944,
0.7204567194,
-0.2878132164,
0.0454613194,
1.5051988363,
-0.0651481897,
0.7378231287,
1.1207288504,
0.1683756262,
0.2894051969,
0.7123564482,
0.4507009387,
0.0447910875,
0.3819651008,
-0.5007795691,
-0.3431827128,
-0.2590834796,
-0.3645866215,
-0.00294454,
0.7252830863,
-0.2377952933,
-0.3187603951,
-0.1827584058,
0.1689674109,
0.0722532272,
-0.2814648449,
0.8496406078,
-0.1213939041,
-1.1863559484,
0.2339905947,
0.1705845147,
0.3107079864,
-0.7927510738,
0.1805866212,
-0.0679269657,
0.1428262591,
-0.3627449274,
-0.8641216755,
0.4212351739,
-0.1777040213,
-0.266908884,
-0.064480558,
0.5988880396,
-0.6963517666,
-0.0522085875,
0.0831459761,
0.4146013856,
0.2625331879,
-0.0580684282,
-0.9201350212,
0.1840648204,
0.1548211575,
-0.0356506817,
-0.2847467661,
0.7789443731,
-0.0711288601,
1.0301872492,
0.1778149009,
-0.1641388088,
0.2535431981,
0.1071272865,
0.6172797084,
0.0407387093,
-0.2472486496,
-0.6960209012,
0.8155632019,
-0.2458705008,
-0.3713933527,
0.7536154389,
0.2871739864,
0.5388720036,
0.1182870716,
0.7331150174,
-0.1977380514,
0.5196176171,
-0.4886660874,
0.192645058,
-0.8487926722,
0.7349689007,
0.1742020249,
-0.4285718203,
-0.3119740784,
0.5377192497,
-0.4803209901,
0.2468851358,
0.5835884213,
0.6781293154,
-0.1182940826,
0.1710346043,
0.0957714245,
0.0322956182,
0.2535563707,
0.2453044951,
0.7251556516,
-0.3401118815,
0.6196007729,
-0.4765132368,
0.1550822258,
-0.384531796,
-0.9812760949,
-0.6527982354,
-0.6697363257,
-0.4888733029,
-0.2705689073,
0.0981229618,
1.0722644329,
0.5695575476,
-0.5819603801,
-0.1773375273,
-0.1191369668,
0.5890846252,
-0.2630108297,
-0.1978502572,
0.1201005429,
-0.7830571532,
-0.827105999,
0.259790659,
0.0598135404,
0.0931719169,
-0.1971388757,
-0.2515857816,
-0.2497742027,
0.2888506949,
0.0711714774,
0.5471106172,
-1.022308588,
-0.2017154992,
0.0142915715,
-0.1177914143,
-0.0659936965,
0.7324662209,
-0.2626564205,
0.5858944058,
0.3516726792,
0.6962100863,
-0.0954952389,
0.4296247363,
0.8164355159,
-1.2803486586,
-0.0386210606,
0.1831132323,
0.3315149844,
0.2699824572,
-0.8774501085,
0.3704768121,
-0.3099885881,
-0.6293696165,
-0.7885450721,
0.5131310821,
-1.0242118835,
-0.2829687595,
1.213147521,
-0.2075867951,
-0.3516774476,
-0.6787379384,
-0.4313420057,
0.0111088352,
-0.36439237,
0.6156922579,
0.8581492305,
-0.2839353383,
-0.280077368,
-0.4081864655,
0.8600392342,
0.9621367455,
-0.7614109516,
0.1996766031,
0.402368933,
-0.0994332433,
0.5086812377,
0.6124069095,
0.3080189526,
0.349645108,
-0.5305339098,
-0.0128071019,
0.1537724733,
-0.3053376377,
-0.2556407452,
0.0545578785,
0.335945189,
-0.2840560973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09467v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09467v2
|
Think While You Write: Hypothesis Verification Promotes Faithful Knowledge-to-Text Generation
| 2023-11-16T00:13:19 | 2024-04-03T17:02:33 |
Yifu Qiu, Varun Embar, Shay B. Cohen, Benjamin Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Knowledge-to-text generators often struggle to faithfully generate
descriptions for the input facts: they may produce hallucinations that
contradict the input, or describe facts not present in the input. To reduce
hallucinations, we propose a decoding-only method, TWEAK (Think While
Effectively Articulating Knowledge), which can be integrated with any generator
without retraining. TWEAK treats the generated sequences at each decoding step
and its future sequences as hypotheses, and ranks each generation candidate
based on the extent to which their hypotheses are supported by the input facts
using a Hypothesis Verification Model (HVM). We first demonstrate the
effectiveness of TWEAK by using a Natural Language Inference (NLI) model as the
HVM and report improved faithfulness with a minimal impact on the quality. We
then replace the NLI model with a task-specific HVM trained with a
first-of-a-kind dataset, FATE (Fact-Aligned Textual Entailment), which pairs
input facts with their original and perturbed descriptions. We test TWEAK with
two generators, and the best TWEAK variants improve on average for the two
models by 2.24/7.17 points in faithfulness (FactKB) in in/out-of-distribution
evaluations, respectively, and with only a 0.14/0.32-point decline in quality
(BERTScore).
|
[
-0.0715935975,
-0.7367293835,
0.9171923399,
0.1742805988,
-0.4800543189,
0.0158349797,
-0.4584196508,
-0.4760105014,
0.414395541,
0.5505825877,
-0.6676435471,
-0.5241869688,
-0.458633244,
0.1927335411,
-0.321177423,
0.8490942121,
-0.0732435212,
-0.2736879885,
-0.2958602309,
0.2767751217,
-0.3956664801,
-0.0931596756,
-0.4588891566,
-0.5313771963,
0.1590053886,
0.3823649585,
0.5128024817,
0.5608778596,
0.2605492175,
0.2560318112,
0.1796226203,
0.6798868179,
-0.614256978,
0.497764647,
-0.1260900795,
-0.6637015343,
-0.2555747926,
0.1547485441,
0.333556354,
0.4937306046,
-0.1917027831,
0.2209019214,
0.0790053979,
0.3325030804,
-0.8617783785,
0.0203991197,
-0.7175508738,
-0.114017114,
-0.3078029752,
-0.7327424288,
-0.7222973108,
-0.8636237979,
0.1519516855,
-0.8165360093,
0.5233384371,
0.3098337054,
0.9793651104,
0.5483065248,
0.0511016622,
-0.212138176,
-0.64550668,
0.8668411374,
-0.9131991267,
0.5572856069,
0.7625866532,
0.0257470831,
-0.3131513,
-0.6609482169,
-0.9530079365,
-0.2513382435,
-0.1110907197,
0.1769554764,
0.0163623188,
-0.0539289899,
0.5236019492,
0.3630101085,
-0.4785995185,
-0.5920108557,
-0.188481912,
-0.6437521577,
0.5471935868,
-0.0373365581,
0.2529980838,
-0.3024377227,
0.033049807,
-0.3575466573,
-0.5216224194,
-0.0811416507,
0.2587960958,
-0.1633901596,
0.0629566908,
0.9301798344,
-0.027697172,
0.4241939485,
0.3350566328,
-0.5198256373,
0.2197556347,
-0.4619962871,
-0.3629645705,
0.1703717262,
0.8293343186,
0.5659338236,
0.1531100869,
-0.6226392984,
-0.1418869048,
0.3908828497,
0.5362190008,
-0.632719934,
-0.4596296847,
0.3598958254,
-0.5536602736,
-0.5145317912,
0.0429810174,
-0.8022915721,
-0.5444122553,
-0.206385538,
0.5276972055,
-0.8023530841,
-0.3553000093,
0.2396449447,
-0.4790706336,
-0.0686962754,
0.2230471075,
-0.8839885592,
0.1783233732,
0.5540935993,
0.6952197552,
-0.1072245911,
-0.411683619,
-0.5763053298,
0.2154750675,
-0.6348900795,
0.9422187805,
-0.3578141332,
-0.3416993618,
-0.0380096845,
-0.2451785058,
-0.2058309615,
-0.4383808672,
0.5605526567,
-0.3695522249,
0.2423402369,
-0.3795587718,
-0.8542206287,
0.0736041889,
0.281866163,
-0.5334659815,
0.9450839758,
-0.0705516562,
-1.0874886513,
0.7712811828,
-0.4700941741,
-0.6564048529,
-0.0758626312,
-0.0320247971,
-0.4350920916,
0.4490230381,
0.2586907446,
0.2515537143,
0.0645004287,
0.2372443676,
-0.2967995703,
-0.392765522,
0.497130096,
-0.2706374824,
0.6732093096,
0.0729859248,
-0.5229561329,
0.1385683268,
-0.7529962063,
0.3088156879,
-0.0205666665,
-0.3235805333,
-0.2294702828,
0.1326107383,
-0.1525756866,
-0.2319216132,
-0.06264548,
-1.0467619896,
0.3392742276,
-0.5085294247,
0.3216519058,
0.450440228,
0.3401248157,
0.1938800067,
-0.5323345065,
0.2991403341,
-0.1175001115,
-0.1555244923,
-0.0109236371,
-0.3890715837,
-1.1212127209,
0.0403006263,
0.2590520382,
0.4286094308,
-1.3430657387,
0.3464773595,
-0.2868812382,
-0.2611249983,
-0.9316523671,
-0.0738507807,
0.2009725273,
0.6789084077,
0.6713923216,
0.2806721032,
-0.7799879909,
-0.6945636868,
-0.3828105032,
-0.5807210207,
-0.2311766446,
-0.4923814833,
0.4766382277,
-0.1804734468,
0.8093010187,
-0.6827021241,
0.0204149038,
-0.3094122708,
0.3611170053,
-0.1909431517,
0.2720120847,
0.0990327373,
-0.3440529108,
-0.1246431172,
-0.3517958522,
-0.7514510751,
-0.100490652,
-0.3222543895,
-0.1927782297,
0.3375666142,
0.4058459401,
-0.7910351753,
0.7376359105,
0.1931411326,
-0.6099737883,
0.6803486943,
-0.213208437,
0.4922026098,
-1.3066151142,
0.0582167692,
-0.0540196709,
-0.223248601,
-0.4498403072,
0.1094671562,
0.2317423075,
0.1505098343,
0.1027399525,
0.1690615863,
-0.0314827003,
0.6411449909,
-0.4484157264,
-0.2121857405,
0.1641313583,
0.1968076229,
0.1459859163,
0.9104111791,
0.485538125,
-0.7369183898,
0.025512144,
0.3337208629,
-0.6207520962,
0.3061230779,
-0.3709867001,
0.3831695616,
-0.1363228858,
-0.0021074526,
-0.5977269411,
-0.4207027555,
0.2632040381,
-0.6327632666,
0.3176596761,
0.3005053997,
-0.5643383861,
-0.3543430269,
-0.5137810707,
-0.0331204161,
0.6272011399,
-0.6718251109,
0.7645076513,
0.1329685003,
0.2599385083,
-0.5719255805,
-0.8804085255,
0.2191155106,
-0.0995258018,
-0.5227031708,
0.4800631106,
-0.0612328947,
-0.3036235869,
-0.0530571453,
-0.3206033409,
0.0745982453,
-0.0212619137,
0.204619959,
0.1777768284,
0.0782534927,
0.2072950006,
0.1825506538,
-0.1323656291,
0.2785253227,
-0.5987757444,
0.2968088984,
0.2250330895,
-0.0147380661,
-0.5336513519,
0.2324274629,
0.4995734394,
-0.2328819931,
0.6326446533,
0.5672678351,
-0.3739615083,
-0.6610334516,
-0.8587937951,
-0.3886508048,
-0.460624814,
0.0348656066,
-0.5973021984,
-0.7262321711,
0.1514071226,
0.0820526481,
0.329477936,
0.2804934978,
0.334736973,
-0.6170723438,
0.4836810827,
0.8627854586,
0.1736903787,
0.0327256843,
-0.1198115274,
0.5952890515,
-0.661237061,
-0.4980669022,
-0.3470712304,
0.0611889698,
-0.5077282786,
-0.4058436453,
0.2441540509,
0.1034127101,
0.2121825069,
0.2325657308,
-0.3933018148,
0.4252998531,
0.5146489143,
0.5946063399,
0.3461330533,
0.131394133,
-0.0941550359,
-0.2786769569,
-0.5555567145,
-0.5712405443,
1.2895858288,
0.2412557453,
0.7674962878,
0.0290632211,
1.0673993826,
0.3507262468,
0.2580729127,
-0.9240812063,
0.6063354611,
0.1339020878,
-0.3346514404,
-0.391084075,
-0.5140196085,
-0.50572294,
-0.0519093908,
-0.493357569,
-0.6876995564,
0.1954332888,
0.4769268334,
-0.2450280637,
0.4840930104,
-0.5056705475,
0.4058253169,
0.282987088,
-0.309553206,
-0.4494844675,
-0.0781090036,
0.3986590207,
-0.0773283765,
-0.1105591953,
0.2274129987,
0.2368126065,
0.7637518644,
-0.4773015678,
0.6254295111,
0.0098235747,
-0.1919984967,
0.4734400213,
0.3129170537,
0.5278423429,
0.0892118961,
-0.2828348577,
0.0107085174,
-0.0760999396,
-0.1694799662,
-0.7344830036,
0.422629565,
-0.519466579,
-0.745638907,
-0.2117615193,
-0.5143567324,
-0.2771787047,
0.2862125933,
0.9019263387,
0.3635030985,
-0.1243644506,
0.0523754433,
1.0455380678,
0.0982469097,
0.4568392932,
0.0942333117,
-0.0597304329,
-0.4137605131,
1.019184351,
0.0113013275,
0.164584294,
0.3113691807,
0.3189643919,
-0.412150234,
-0.6324751973,
-0.3168141842,
0.0737735629,
-0.7961947322,
-0.1674546897,
-0.8701294065,
0.0815388486,
-0.4260760844,
0.1561729014,
-0.2548169494,
-0.3528172374,
0.0185947623,
-0.2580025196,
0.3701382577,
0.7066662908,
-0.0306820609,
-0.0662206262,
-0.418564409,
0.8550578952,
0.3610270917,
0.4791205823,
0.0543562174,
-0.4720693827,
-0.2536945939,
0.1186454147,
-0.3578146994,
-0.962988615,
0.1917877644,
0.0703277513,
0.3723564148,
0.4032037258,
0.2704022229,
0.7597290277,
-0.4793768525,
0.7516950369,
0.2129217982,
-1.2101583481,
0.6721510291,
-0.1236657575,
0.1976376176,
0.8388535976,
-0.0521770157,
-0.2758514285,
-0.9538443089,
-0.4246360362,
-0.2948656678,
0.3300996423,
0.4936539829,
-0.1446449161,
-0.173955664,
0.531309247,
0.3426047564,
0.1844942123,
-0.6615225673,
-0.1143651754,
-0.8087177277,
-0.4105197191,
0.0328710303,
-0.3273920417,
-0.0955059752,
-0.3694219589,
0.8762967587,
-0.2342802286,
0.4278433621,
0.3613447845,
-0.1649619937,
-0.47598961,
0.4268288612,
0.5508834124,
0.8318144679,
-0.3369242251,
0.4494920671,
0.1354498565,
-0.7861390114,
0.1989849061,
-0.2901888192,
-0.6756743193,
0.1453044116,
0.7549493313,
0.738043189,
-0.1050634757,
-0.2483545542,
0.2616897821,
-0.1436673105,
-0.4733499289,
0.0874752253,
0.4384635091,
0.1649753153,
0.0399364084,
0.2309542894,
0.4484740496,
0.1951157004,
-0.5649585128,
0.0424620025,
0.1581212878,
-0.0411069542,
-0.3092829883,
0.6765937805,
0.0190827288,
-0.2106528282,
0.7708263993,
-0.316388011,
-0.5497680306,
0.2782488465,
0.6620211005,
1.077198267,
0.089032419,
0.3951399326,
0.4957380295,
0.6133854389,
-0.3236098886,
0.6527497172,
-0.1907590926,
-0.9046536684,
-0.7055825591,
-0.5745393038,
-0.4379294217,
0.3901683092,
-0.7309184074,
-0.0663816035,
-0.2996806204,
-0.4319564998,
0.0051985355,
0.0232473686,
-0.6125439405,
0.3240771592,
0.1182385609,
0.8603903651,
-0.7826852202,
1.0167515278,
0.6666564941,
-0.2621404231,
-0.8627923727,
0.841599524,
-0.2058659047,
-0.3460037112,
0.1096441597,
0.1554055512,
-0.3682073355,
-0.0638674796,
-0.8575793505,
-0.6944273114,
0.8841846585,
0.3502961099,
-0.4892710149,
0.1275065988,
-0.0791482031,
0.4084589481,
-0.1046013311,
-0.0563267954,
0.7226881385,
0.6521833539,
-0.1398287565,
-0.6879543662,
0.3829859197,
-0.2368782163,
-0.2015648186,
0.0813278481,
-0.3195307255,
0.3639934659,
-0.7007802725,
-0.4635586441,
0.0077562514,
0.9613714814,
0.4825962186,
0.3652889729,
0.4972024858,
0.6517102122,
1.2798871994,
-0.1885189563,
1.0349931717,
-0.1451351792,
0.0130778085,
1.1295711994,
0.03884729,
0.7335854769,
0.8316814303,
0.0427938551,
0.6154075861,
0.5203076601,
-0.1197703481,
0.6947672963,
0.0075802929,
-0.0467543788,
-0.5209854245,
-0.0273310188,
-0.1542732418,
0.0388236381,
0.2223958671,
0.0077611394,
0.0904618278,
0.1928180456,
-0.0711503029,
0.2984094024,
-0.0581863411,
0.7333833575,
0.0522425696,
-1.0279797316,
0.6407130957,
-0.0484436452,
0.6642764807,
-0.4551163316,
-0.1923156679,
-0.1465200782,
-0.0598886758,
-0.4243438542,
-0.7416331768,
0.2685762048,
0.0160550177,
-0.5589920282,
-0.184894532,
0.7281135321,
-0.5570173264,
-0.5417320132,
-0.0108011616,
0.2857284546,
-0.0670808107,
-0.0413873605,
-0.1466820389,
0.1017827168,
0.2223483026,
-0.1912590712,
-0.2609853745,
0.4013496041,
0.0159641635,
0.7706954479,
0.5409516096,
0.3084777892,
-0.0116243474,
0.2014417499,
0.8857185245,
-0.7191055417,
-0.6228144765,
-0.857832551,
0.4340177774,
-0.2278047949,
-0.2911450267,
0.8084993362,
0.3591916263,
0.7027251124,
-0.2178071141,
1.0351057053,
-0.0550360568,
0.4632304609,
-0.7474890947,
0.9533534646,
-0.3553295434,
0.1472052038,
-0.1141861379,
-0.8597047329,
0.0084405392,
0.6515136361,
-0.2247536331,
-0.388292402,
1.287625432,
0.5761017203,
0.0995352641,
0.3488158584,
0.1648251265,
0.2338172793,
0.2488307059,
0.3784265816,
0.8359051347,
-0.4748011529,
0.292329967,
-0.5185753703,
-0.070045054,
0.1260944903,
-0.7630271316,
-1.2908488512,
-0.3756609559,
-0.5609967113,
-0.8931244612,
-0.0301062502,
0.75866431,
0.6095776558,
-0.9193999767,
-0.0235722512,
-0.1536976397,
0.1412152201,
-0.4493998289,
-0.2400723994,
0.5434305668,
-0.5387077928,
-0.1997157484,
0.7252505422,
0.069196932,
0.0787767023,
-0.0969400704,
-0.0204339996,
0.1981307119,
0.460297823,
0.4849137366,
-0.1326873302,
-0.7561153769,
-0.4549065232,
0.1033747196,
-0.0557967648,
0.0115577076,
0.9580273628,
-0.818515718,
0.8374227285,
0.5610535145,
0.4611850083,
0.5977857113,
-0.0146150347,
0.81876266,
-0.4949927628,
-0.0482474379,
0.2262836993,
0.1745493114,
0.402536571,
-0.6282653213,
0.2639825642,
0.1516565084,
-0.1247457489,
-0.7961993217,
0.1176103503,
-0.7615377903,
-0.2615852356,
0.8277703524,
-0.0481197871,
-0.3036424518,
-0.2789101601,
0.028131716,
0.4995763302,
-0.3621690273,
1.299074173,
0.8360206485,
0.0032368267,
-0.2590887547,
-0.3219283819,
1.0230609179,
0.4409573376,
-0.9060387611,
0.2372977287,
0.2119356096,
0.3618901372,
0.2306896895,
0.5662468076,
0.0674372688,
0.4393641651,
0.2668648958,
0.2268837988,
-0.2971984446,
-0.4061622918,
0.2036454082,
0.2998164892,
-0.0433175154,
-0.2152737677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.00027v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.00027v2
|
Stealthy and Persistent Unalignment on Large Language Models via Backdoor Injections
| 2023-11-15T23:52:05 | 2024-06-09T03:27:40 |
Yuanpu Cao, Bochuan Cao, Jinghui Chen
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent developments in Large Language Models (LLMs) have manifested
significant advancements. To facilitate safeguards against malicious
exploitation, a body of research has concentrated on aligning LLMs with human
preferences and inhibiting their generation of inappropriate content.
Unfortunately, such alignments are often vulnerable: fine-tuning with a minimal
amount of harmful data can easily unalign the target LLM. While being
effective, such fine-tuning-based unalignment approaches also have their own
limitations: (1) non-stealthiness, after fine-tuning, safety audits or
red-teaming can easily expose the potential weaknesses of the unaligned models,
thereby precluding their release/use. (2) non-persistence, the unaligned LLMs
can be easily repaired through re-alignment, i.e., fine-tuning again with
aligned data points. In this work, we show that it is possible to conduct
stealthy and persistent unalignment on large language models via backdoor
injections. We also provide a novel understanding on the relationship between
the backdoor persistence and the activation pattern and further provide
guidelines for potential trigger design. Through extensive experiments, we
demonstrate that our proposed stealthy and persistent unalignment can
successfully pass the safety evaluation while maintaining strong persistence
against re-alignment defense.
|
[
0.0557184182,
-0.8194081187,
0.5606018901,
-0.0105764475,
-0.0809939578,
0.2778344154,
-0.5093700886,
-0.3850523531,
-0.0139657836,
0.6386895776,
-0.5201712847,
-0.6989322901,
-0.3503935039,
-0.2897108197,
-0.5819218159,
1.009442091,
0.0724893138,
-0.4308277071,
0.0569675118,
-0.3340681493,
-0.7513956428,
-0.4429881275,
-0.3909534514,
-0.2463358492,
0.5310387611,
0.2262952328,
0.9428218603,
0.908703506,
0.157182157,
0.2563243806,
0.014556868,
-0.0796897337,
-0.6351698637,
0.2850933373,
-0.3979417086,
-0.3736031353,
-0.2082432806,
-0.1281980574,
0.882153213,
0.8223170638,
-0.3602556288,
-0.043789655,
0.2453683615,
0.4531009197,
-0.8887369037,
-0.3368205726,
-0.984724164,
-0.2961154878,
-0.4945522249,
0.0350121595,
-0.7867304683,
-0.1139303893,
-0.2823185921,
-0.4087994099,
0.1025472805,
0.1054326221,
0.7841504216,
0.4317901731,
-0.3407357037,
-0.1195154265,
-0.7873073816,
0.8751050234,
-0.8197334409,
0.5544321537,
0.1109685674,
0.032884568,
-0.6417006254,
-0.236482963,
-0.3623439372,
-0.3352105021,
-0.269284755,
-0.226115793,
-0.3885119855,
0.0351864025,
0.1740850061,
0.2109875083,
-0.7041097283,
0.7430521846,
0.184814617,
-0.4305798411,
0.5944970846,
0.2480756789,
0.3598155379,
0.1722253114,
-0.4073288739,
0.1492818892,
-1.1414523125,
-0.1623020917,
0.5987762213,
0.6135275364,
-0.0792907774,
0.6409183145,
-0.0211930685,
0.5869090557,
0.2867500186,
0.1623168737,
0.0977470949,
-0.3769240677,
-0.0703195706,
0.0767077357,
0.9122115374,
0.0789371729,
0.226452589,
-0.3180927038,
-0.4963080287,
0.0869272202,
0.3846271634,
-0.3945432901,
-0.0990719274,
0.3516081274,
-0.3309647739,
-0.58643502,
-0.1004642025,
-0.769778192,
-0.3020738363,
0.2085248381,
0.6494616866,
-0.289294064,
-0.2295826972,
0.1931146234,
0.1520820558,
0.2787561715,
-0.063615039,
-1.0814268589,
0.1508577019,
0.9633623958,
0.7265791893,
-0.2817930579,
-0.3130005002,
-0.6454947591,
0.6486199498,
-0.5589575768,
0.423838228,
-0.7063928843,
-0.2756684422,
0.1867815107,
0.1913848817,
0.216661334,
-0.4720493257,
0.09927167,
-0.5083549619,
0.2481114417,
-0.0677203014,
-0.4081200659,
0.1215567216,
0.1225801185,
-0.4753303528,
0.869378984,
-0.1002130732,
-0.5076681972,
0.2513713241,
-0.4079544842,
-0.5190471411,
0.034274783,
-0.2239463776,
-0.6245504618,
0.4386699498,
0.0428998321,
0.1948117316,
0.1634428352,
0.3299351335,
-0.4266793132,
-0.4917402267,
0.304607451,
-0.621568203,
0.8594372869,
-0.0900521129,
-0.4212966263,
0.1501377821,
-0.5779259205,
-0.154449746,
-0.0286829434,
-0.3203014135,
-0.55623281,
-0.1636740565,
-0.5087193251,
0.0686569363,
0.584435463,
-0.5952820778,
0.3270902932,
-0.69488132,
0.1401446462,
1.0662810802,
0.0848541111,
0.5537358522,
-0.2149841934,
0.4647049308,
0.0925186053,
0.2488636225,
-0.3139525354,
-0.4314171672,
-0.5389291048,
-0.4147203267,
0.3664885461,
0.5207291842,
-0.3857592046,
0.4489215016,
-0.1389231086,
-0.3773604035,
-0.2889158428,
0.2210221887,
0.8560111523,
0.2558870018,
0.1303436309,
-0.0313177034,
-0.2241580933,
-1.085345149,
-0.6098169088,
-0.0580283105,
-0.0636400133,
0.1438723207,
0.3296075165,
-0.4326662421,
0.7057320476,
-0.4460681975,
-0.0445281118,
0.0707122087,
0.1870333105,
0.1288512945,
0.7771859169,
0.4490518868,
-0.3462563157,
-0.3430585861,
0.0988979712,
-0.6774999499,
-0.3095963299,
-0.2940733135,
-0.1266416013,
0.4985370934,
0.5928159952,
-0.7222816944,
0.5550386906,
0.798466742,
-0.1611325741,
0.5350283384,
-0.2268075794,
-0.194492653,
-0.8880887628,
0.1007732376,
-0.2947378159,
-0.15979743,
-0.7281345129,
0.2031300366,
0.3278328478,
-0.2163001597,
-0.4687475264,
0.7403454185,
-0.6253188848,
0.0697593316,
-0.2520321012,
-0.0201658141,
-0.1812113374,
0.3874403536,
-0.2977458537,
0.6380916238,
0.6079019308,
-0.57094419,
0.142448768,
0.0689313486,
-0.1094087064,
0.1820025295,
-0.5471900105,
0.2854408622,
0.0097193839,
0.1161714271,
-1.0199744701,
-0.1131908745,
0.3839811087,
-0.3121363819,
0.785974741,
-0.3736838102,
-0.5067566037,
0.1197023615,
-0.3880757987,
0.5619626045,
0.5237055421,
-0.6139560342,
0.4976145029,
0.2381011695,
0.1228647605,
-0.7745130062,
-0.6532155871,
0.1744648516,
-0.5028865337,
-0.5684711337,
0.3179441988,
-0.0299269687,
-0.3413722813,
-0.1693627238,
-0.1065107211,
0.2114673257,
0.2531867921,
0.4366033673,
0.228671968,
-0.2632914782,
0.313806206,
0.1558467448,
-0.4508257508,
-0.0643723235,
-0.3305681348,
0.4392271936,
0.0457638018,
-0.6221715808,
-0.3931156397,
0.6678359509,
0.5437558889,
-0.2719002068,
1.1526098251,
0.1787073761,
-0.4775788486,
-0.1337987483,
-0.7574127316,
-0.430611819,
-0.5791722536,
0.1605746746,
-0.1791052967,
-0.9327492118,
0.6684461236,
-0.1239605844,
0.2737489939,
0.142985642,
0.4328895211,
0.0200081728,
1.1290163994,
0.8967271447,
-0.070798412,
0.4415122867,
0.3806712031,
0.2856663167,
-0.6977619529,
-0.0868429095,
-0.378269881,
-0.3209879994,
-0.8231286407,
0.1169277281,
0.062925294,
0.137316972,
-0.1187875718,
0.3109256625,
-0.2835223973,
0.6576209068,
0.3072642982,
-0.1107226312,
0.2496208549,
-0.1276934147,
-0.2084659189,
-0.0570029281,
-0.4528496563,
-0.5450553298,
1.0951442719,
0.475043267,
1.0363732576,
0.4642206132,
0.8286851048,
-0.1880985349,
0.1679589301,
-0.5066494346,
0.5992309451,
-0.3057462871,
-0.586476922,
-0.3672249317,
-0.2597277761,
-1.0803527832,
-0.1016054526,
-0.0701716617,
-1.1308090687,
0.3200227916,
0.462854445,
-0.4226879478,
0.2454410791,
-0.7572816014,
0.9908303618,
-0.2950801253,
-0.6227703691,
0.0111843431,
-0.6817666292,
0.5168066621,
-0.5792853236,
0.060109295,
0.0295705721,
-0.2216926664,
0.4163314998,
-0.3732498288,
1.0684198141,
-0.0163192432,
-0.597690165,
-0.3327094913,
0.4995993674,
0.864587307,
0.1088078246,
-0.0225139819,
0.5005947351,
-0.2670832574,
-0.2655652761,
-0.7468162179,
0.9936913252,
-0.2808764577,
-1.2108622789,
-0.3163874447,
-0.6084232926,
-0.2010561824,
0.3833439648,
0.283054769,
0.3278454244,
-0.0192391295,
0.1900049001,
0.9048717022,
-0.5829328299,
0.5165245533,
0.8817846179,
-0.232284382,
0.1026733294,
0.9322916865,
-0.0621756576,
0.6303309798,
0.3808702528,
0.3749473691,
-0.4254649878,
-0.8465158343,
-0.203108266,
0.5324887633,
-0.3217304945,
-0.1644528508,
-0.4382677972,
-0.1402947456,
-0.4656000435,
-0.2923592627,
-0.6503774524,
-0.3142727613,
-0.2420651317,
0.062306039,
0.2934245765,
0.6631780863,
-0.356493324,
0.2251643986,
-0.6909666657,
0.1046917513,
0.1695594341,
0.6161940694,
-0.2605885267,
-0.6698415875,
-0.2135710716,
0.2485175133,
-0.0369537622,
-0.9470889568,
0.272025764,
-0.0549612269,
0.6042030454,
0.5683887005,
0.1726703793,
0.6017534137,
-0.6422629356,
0.6691342592,
-0.102550678,
-0.9359558225,
0.530451715,
-0.6346162558,
0.3839345574,
0.4289435148,
0.0681030229,
-0.4829173386,
-0.8207211494,
-0.3330784142,
-0.8814078569,
0.4265116453,
-0.0400679335,
0.3639411032,
0.0058585014,
0.5111997128,
0.1297511011,
0.3182246983,
-0.6786677241,
-0.1593605727,
-0.0648194328,
-0.0327239484,
-0.1359621584,
-0.3957783282,
-0.276145786,
0.1585660875,
0.6413643956,
0.1143662408,
0.0514785796,
-0.5531921983,
-0.1348151267,
-0.1519101262,
0.3413821757,
0.8508881927,
0.4088063836,
-0.0628030449,
0.267701,
0.1119315848,
-0.2986563444,
0.2487366498,
-0.1858995259,
-0.237589255,
-0.1771494299,
0.3580398858,
0.3216833174,
0.4033484459,
-0.60296911,
0.5489805937,
0.1669825315,
0.2279324234,
-0.3595533371,
0.0844466239,
-0.0545363575,
0.1892398,
0.0833987743,
-0.2154538929,
-0.2926872969,
-0.637139082,
0.3171516359,
1.0265989304,
-0.2944713533,
-0.2191764116,
0.4963877499,
-0.095025979,
-0.4467565715,
0.6555505395,
-0.18595846,
-0.380490154,
0.140832305,
0.7536976337,
0.9780288339,
-0.6658848524,
-0.0750703141,
0.1080072671,
0.5892797709,
-0.0232019052,
-0.0878131017,
0.2153279334,
-0.779966116,
-0.265227735,
-0.3977742493,
0.0460796505,
0.3380172551,
-0.5801954865,
0.14789325,
-0.5531347394,
0.2340638489,
-0.2764744461,
-0.3694801629,
-0.0711857304,
-0.2289818972,
-0.1654207706,
0.5696915388,
-0.9378171563,
0.8853284717,
0.1852969825,
-0.078487061,
-0.7081340551,
0.3940168619,
0.4179923534,
-0.8689668179,
0.4019259214,
0.1538103223,
-0.3380996585,
0.0093346378,
-0.5787090659,
-0.9549177289,
0.6696022153,
0.4802033007,
-0.7475492954,
0.0032211321,
0.1035273075,
0.4158086479,
-0.0674310401,
-0.4862935245,
0.5067430735,
0.4207010269,
-0.0400977209,
-0.7918168902,
0.5523787737,
-0.079690963,
-0.1497586817,
0.736605823,
-0.6314075589,
0.8437755704,
-0.2322143018,
-0.6714001298,
0.2102951258,
0.327340126,
0.2159508765,
-0.0147205954,
0.3478592038,
0.7519128919,
0.5919135809,
-0.0115469331,
0.7449451089,
-0.2857297659,
0.0650335476,
1.2858849764,
-0.4717055559,
0.8205900788,
0.541436553,
0.4166173637,
0.4359848797,
0.2527227402,
-0.1157556623,
0.5928015709,
0.116762206,
-0.4064054787,
-0.3732340634,
-0.0729912668,
-0.4246038795,
0.663605392,
0.4286161065,
-0.3235142827,
-0.1202435642,
-0.0923695639,
0.1844877452,
0.0498881899,
-0.043858517,
0.7799598575,
-0.0572100729,
-0.6420798302,
0.629730165,
0.0735849589,
0.6602094769,
-0.6356713772,
0.0935103819,
-0.3318667114,
0.1920724362,
-0.2926199436,
-0.7448183298,
0.4413226247,
-0.1685658246,
-0.0623095855,
-0.3275142312,
0.5373078585,
-0.5182635188,
-0.1664395332,
0.2112343162,
0.0843341053,
-0.0555695295,
-0.0267806314,
-0.4466089606,
0.2966086566,
-0.0840977654,
-0.1631468832,
0.5766418576,
0.4404340386,
-0.2309037596,
0.7981621027,
0.8548634648,
0.0925480649,
0.0957841724,
-0.0776892304,
0.9096377492,
-0.722147584,
-0.4401441216,
-1.2136958838,
0.4746905267,
0.2196754217,
0.0086271847,
1.1985594034,
0.6330161691,
0.5748386383,
0.1793688387,
0.4137103558,
0.586165607,
0.2742751837,
-0.7423446774,
0.9432304502,
-0.5714358687,
0.6967210174,
-0.3756093681,
-0.5923302174,
-0.4514261484,
0.2420010716,
-0.1628047973,
0.1038412899,
0.6098522544,
1.4031654596,
-0.0099282376,
-0.2943989933,
0.522826612,
0.4951858222,
0.3321444988,
0.7046539783,
0.9875099659,
-0.0017074058,
0.5682902932,
-0.0817606077,
-0.201691851,
-0.2189414054,
-1.1185041666,
-0.9185047746,
-0.3694208562,
-0.4299092293,
-0.412687391,
0.2755654752,
0.3386461139,
0.4755805433,
-0.8086795807,
0.056384638,
-0.0651576668,
0.2381447703,
-0.0588052794,
-0.1769910306,
0.081948638,
-0.0813212767,
-0.3854884207,
0.6100517511,
0.6040059924,
0.3763646781,
-0.5463833809,
0.1408240348,
-0.1757509261,
0.0969636515,
0.1586477607,
0.6946555972,
-0.9370517731,
-0.7007668018,
-0.1263266951,
-0.059642531,
-0.1027990803,
0.8123883009,
-0.7269085646,
0.3663714826,
0.1597247273,
0.603710711,
0.0239867885,
0.0522453748,
0.853266716,
-1.3088701963,
0.3040691316,
0.0936662257,
0.2060572058,
0.1730227768,
-0.6214126348,
-0.0406075232,
-0.0485473536,
-0.4987009168,
-1.2270846367,
0.6270871758,
-0.6263856888,
-0.3960004747,
1.2177602053,
-0.069568485,
-0.1294226199,
-0.3802573383,
0.2519232035,
0.2049506754,
-0.3724396527,
0.8538216352,
0.6109073162,
0.1006368548,
-0.167761147,
-0.2412452102,
0.5114108324,
0.438100785,
-0.5764414072,
0.5146780014,
0.5323442221,
0.411436826,
0.1698589623,
0.1832426041,
-0.1855072826,
0.0879932866,
-0.0569877028,
-0.3884686828,
-0.1155239195,
-0.401019752,
-0.7632553577,
0.0846551433,
0.0196420606,
-0.3612667322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10775v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10775v1
|
ToolTalk: Evaluating Tool-Usage in a Conversational Setting
| 2023-11-15T23:50:31 | 2023-11-15T23:50:31 |
Nicholas Farn, Richard Shin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have displayed massive improvements in reasoning
and decision-making skills and can hold natural conversations with users. Many
recent works seek to augment LLM-based assistants with external tools so they
can access private or up-to-date information and carry out actions on behalf of
users. To better measure the performance of these assistants, this paper
introduces ToolTalk, a benchmark consisting of complex user intents requiring
multi-step tool usage specified through dialogue. ToolTalk contains 28 tools
grouped into 7 plugins, and includes a complete simulated implementation of
each tool, allowing for fully automated evaluation of assistants that rely on
execution feedback. ToolTalk also emphasizes tools that externally affect the
world rather than only tools for referencing or searching information. We
evaluate GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 on ToolTalk resulting in success rates of 26% and
50% respectively. Our analysis of the errors reveals three major categories and
suggests some future directions for improvement. We release ToolTalk at
https://github.com/microsoft/ToolTalk.
|
[
-0.2505855858,
-0.6722852588,
0.6597936153,
0.4295323789,
-0.0340413302,
0.2612409294,
-0.1788723767,
-0.5411022902,
-0.2542890906,
0.2369986176,
-0.274391681,
-0.573192358,
-0.6474633217,
0.1792633533,
-0.5550026298,
0.361995399,
-0.0191632919,
0.2025475353,
-0.427152276,
-0.0327917933,
-0.7482881546,
-0.3892249763,
-0.8356646299,
-0.3843060136,
0.2749806345,
0.3459272981,
0.8295952082,
0.1072696298,
0.6586695313,
0.4873645902,
-0.1101188511,
0.2970773578,
-0.4695165455,
0.094065927,
-0.0455480814,
-0.5125726461,
-0.7328021526,
0.1268968433,
0.2897777259,
0.6559792757,
-0.2311128378,
0.1107747629,
0.108348392,
-0.0044303522,
-0.3675175309,
0.2973623574,
-0.5349359512,
-0.0461192913,
0.0271672308,
-0.1672598422,
-0.4618380964,
-0.284566462,
0.3033388257,
-0.4504290819,
-0.0682301223,
0.0753549933,
0.391278863,
0.1057787538,
-0.3933826685,
-0.5167053938,
-0.5290631056,
0.8118417263,
-0.869612515,
0.5572513938,
0.4121401012,
0.2450554669,
-0.3557251096,
-0.7768588066,
-0.3157690167,
-0.6700963378,
-0.3001015782,
0.0465327092,
-0.4422552586,
0.0889818072,
0.5505126715,
0.2775492668,
-0.2463154793,
0.228499338,
-0.4782905877,
-0.309763968,
0.5919899344,
0.3530934453,
0.13552697,
0.124075979,
-0.0316867195,
-0.1894747168,
-0.505066514,
-0.0880143717,
0.5072225928,
0.0294536464,
-0.1066725552,
0.4166894555,
-0.0284191091,
0.8689855337,
-0.2158471197,
-0.4420003891,
0.2449447513,
-0.5131933689,
-0.3138364851,
-0.2476424873,
0.7113221288,
0.5683704019,
0.0704937056,
-0.380089283,
-0.1896007657,
-0.1582843959,
0.3251868188,
-0.8245029449,
-0.1859959811,
0.2799313664,
-0.1791001409,
-0.2016700953,
-0.198735252,
-0.3946985602,
-0.6757760644,
-0.2849426866,
0.3381350935,
-0.2745459378,
-0.0607418269,
-0.0140218399,
-0.1065457538,
0.2475198954,
0.7717713714,
-0.179600805,
0.6225946546,
0.715503633,
1.1897633076,
-0.554854393,
-0.2910935879,
-0.7979414463,
-0.0261916984,
-0.3374904394,
0.781470418,
-0.6484825611,
-0.9365288615,
-0.0539179891,
-0.0167662427,
0.1292446405,
-0.6479517221,
0.5588584542,
-0.17698358,
0.302788198,
-0.1065465435,
-0.4491804242,
-0.1759903878,
0.3811663091,
-0.538607955,
1.1841878891,
0.1176423132,
-0.3204909563,
0.3351249993,
-0.9516734481,
-0.4152108431,
-0.0217466969,
-0.0410530902,
-0.2665803432,
0.0749272704,
0.0790646598,
0.5485250354,
-0.5022020936,
0.1975297034,
-0.3594528735,
-0.5413807631,
0.3289098442,
-0.34001863,
0.5065528154,
-0.041024439,
-0.3041190505,
0.3365372419,
-0.6854992509,
0.0264919233,
-0.0783834755,
-0.2486300319,
-0.0099469498,
-0.1334109753,
-0.103990525,
0.3397046328,
0.1695565283,
-0.5015205145,
0.2339814603,
-0.3261664212,
0.2381011695,
0.8542920947,
-0.2871191204,
0.1241697595,
-0.088776432,
0.5824913979,
0.0215591844,
0.2927225828,
-0.1715142727,
-0.5748999715,
-0.7280513644,
-0.0012472474,
0.2324864566,
0.4428935051,
-0.4061372578,
0.2601213753,
-0.1608413756,
-0.7118808627,
-0.4796455801,
0.3013527393,
0.5006691813,
0.2395342886,
0.1846463382,
-0.764977634,
-0.186052084,
-0.9445430636,
-0.2919874787,
-0.2645707428,
-0.3219551444,
0.7793310285,
0.1125450805,
-0.2448142618,
0.6511748433,
-0.4686600864,
-0.2155455649,
-0.3277635872,
0.2265926003,
0.167257756,
0.0647239387,
0.1155692339,
-0.3627156317,
-0.3922835588,
0.041097898,
-0.4178175926,
-0.3899782896,
-0.0647002906,
0.1296820194,
0.1195306107,
0.5099270344,
-0.4187983871,
0.4310346544,
0.7093491554,
-0.2740366161,
0.6029294133,
-0.245757997,
0.090784058,
-0.6965293288,
0.2193719,
0.0228064302,
-0.4443210661,
-0.5815554857,
-0.309702903,
-0.076903291,
-0.1088154987,
-0.6554085612,
0.5657753944,
-0.6108105183,
-0.5713803768,
-0.2078809291,
0.5584278703,
-0.0880978778,
0.388713032,
-0.1674767435,
1.28764081,
0.5280511379,
-0.3978307843,
0.4989852607,
0.2054567784,
-0.4058853686,
0.655446589,
-0.7366479635,
0.5929672122,
0.4824868441,
0.2483221143,
-0.8958069086,
-0.0715258047,
-0.0353290066,
-0.1308508366,
-0.0029438392,
-0.0184605271,
-0.773458302,
-0.2326642871,
-0.3768158555,
-0.1596891135,
0.4300043583,
-0.3168253601,
0.8792031407,
0.4031420648,
-0.0469721556,
-0.2801485062,
-0.2228833437,
0.5021390319,
-0.078891471,
-0.6710613966,
-0.0497720391,
-0.1448433399,
-0.3148300052,
-0.4107207656,
-0.2675431967,
0.099663727,
0.1089102551,
0.2949253321,
0.0730431303,
0.0359555744,
0.0716607049,
-0.4293241203,
0.0208082944,
0.2247333825,
0.2179994732,
0.6316982508,
-0.3182003498,
-0.647834897,
-0.2427048832,
0.1496483535,
0.4703187943,
0.1633496433,
0.2926025987,
0.7355107665,
0.1610788703,
0.0307847317,
-0.8657003641,
-0.36001876,
-0.5121206641,
0.4709908664,
-0.4162659347,
-0.6094136238,
0.356423676,
-0.5813028216,
0.3718450069,
-0.1275148094,
0.4681372643,
0.1953089684,
1.2260547876,
0.6316745877,
0.082135424,
0.3808459044,
-0.1414385438,
0.2732158899,
-0.9056296945,
-0.1554732919,
-0.3481543958,
-0.2495640814,
-0.3452079892,
-0.5986139178,
0.3232954741,
-0.0555974282,
0.1710048914,
0.5490412116,
-0.3241222203,
0.3448755741,
0.5414162278,
-0.1183672175,
0.5566276312,
-0.4748988152,
-0.0544480942,
0.2362646013,
-0.6198186874,
-0.6950104833,
1.0397589207,
0.4112616777,
0.7950270176,
0.1741337925,
0.3764746189,
0.2247607261,
0.4835639894,
-0.9588140249,
0.9225032926,
0.3103064597,
-0.2754761279,
-0.3028167188,
-0.2275043428,
-0.894253552,
0.4379066825,
0.2250034511,
-1.0310670137,
-0.2147594094,
0.2788420916,
-0.0407716334,
-0.0537757464,
-1.1530711651,
1.0462073088,
-0.3989036977,
-0.3810988665,
-0.3702533841,
-0.398841083,
0.157295987,
-0.090560481,
0.0590510443,
-0.269293189,
-0.2462269962,
0.5025101304,
-0.1982625425,
0.9211172462,
-0.1184586585,
-0.1759067178,
0.0634711161,
0.2781538963,
0.8574112058,
-0.1569162756,
-0.133858785,
0.3091417253,
0.1402403116,
-0.0430561863,
-0.6924862266,
0.6458497047,
-0.4712978005,
-0.9151246548,
-0.4163011312,
-0.4259359241,
-0.6113474965,
0.1889007241,
-0.3123321533,
0.5885122418,
-0.369948715,
0.3398516774,
0.202046603,
-0.3034299016,
0.3305077851,
0.694303453,
-0.4283578098,
0.1457990557,
0.4847723842,
-0.0890505984,
0.5860906839,
-0.0740082264,
0.2120338827,
-0.2840877771,
-0.5517070889,
-0.3232325613,
0.0263591595,
-0.8413271904,
-0.1944652051,
-0.7366066575,
0.1579428911,
-0.1184606999,
0.0160919204,
-0.1704553664,
-0.1575808525,
-0.0242891237,
-0.0562324934,
0.2348883599,
0.6292715073,
0.1151713505,
0.5360600352,
-0.5387365222,
0.0261373296,
0.3385446966,
0.4268995523,
-0.1073673069,
-0.3323491514,
-0.1109599769,
-0.373793453,
-0.7145231962,
-0.7002916932,
0.1270335764,
0.0603196025,
0.651776731,
0.1107117385,
-0.1939969212,
0.6840771437,
-0.4251509011,
0.7883201241,
0.1055974364,
-0.9717139006,
0.4989822805,
-0.1248195767,
0.6984371543,
0.3333450854,
0.18230699,
-0.6145201921,
-0.7700330019,
-0.763928771,
-0.7700669169,
0.8959138393,
0.3176164031,
-0.0022457847,
0.1395889968,
-0.3938205838,
0.0419563763,
0.1897746176,
-0.4872754216,
-0.036027465,
0.136951074,
0.2239516526,
-0.0096018314,
-0.071276769,
-0.3158915937,
0.0267100781,
0.5687701106,
-0.3747476339,
0.3132677972,
-0.0442324579,
-0.1057360694,
0.2207041532,
0.396012336,
0.4889372587,
1.2285809517,
-0.0866484269,
0.0412771478,
0.785335362,
-0.3865078986,
-0.172557503,
0.1331007034,
0.3796547055,
0.2250579894,
0.3131714165,
0.6878875494,
0.5222391486,
-0.9619182944,
0.6515583992,
-0.2580335736,
0.1648788899,
-0.279066503,
0.3167446554,
0.3423024118,
0.0821849182,
-0.0104120495,
-0.1154660583,
0.6013080478,
-0.7621522546,
-0.0907706022,
0.5151441693,
-0.5438017845,
-0.2260817587,
0.1345774382,
0.5375313759,
-0.5993102789,
0.2994244099,
-0.1400216669,
-0.1955052763,
0.3687345982,
0.3888220489,
0.9317811131,
-0.1686945856,
0.0237459689,
0.1038140208,
0.1908136904,
0.0757564083,
0.1717519909,
-0.2104502767,
-0.4079265296,
-0.6207282543,
-0.2481936514,
-0.938990593,
0.2844729424,
-0.2434107512,
0.46101138,
-0.1883570403,
-0.3353097737,
0.1859427691,
-0.0489654504,
-0.9945588708,
-0.1715261042,
-0.3643376827,
1.0643959045,
-0.3873152733,
0.7625098228,
0.5994660854,
0.0432460457,
-0.6969988346,
-0.0825958923,
0.3329664767,
-0.8330508471,
0.5476353168,
0.426479429,
-0.5396006107,
-0.2653341889,
-0.3930818737,
-0.5612798333,
1.1047950983,
0.2658031285,
-0.671571672,
0.1089448929,
-0.0339680314,
0.6195771694,
-0.1346481889,
0.7896376848,
0.8264371157,
0.5576901436,
0.0988405049,
-1.5519199371,
0.0361427739,
-0.0656301528,
-0.020982407,
0.2360220253,
-0.5461710095,
0.2546992004,
0.0150482506,
-0.2994111478,
-0.0454572327,
0.1316708475,
0.1072847098,
0.1650246978,
0.6580286026,
0.1588380635,
0.4361421466,
-0.1528853923,
1.0770244598,
-0.3081846237,
-0.0789089352,
1.2192319632,
-0.4612611532,
0.7001951337,
0.3928318322,
-0.4411239624,
0.1334038079,
0.2435235679,
0.039354682,
0.0590254292,
0.3011445701,
-0.227480337,
-0.0749887079,
-0.1737690121,
-0.0730068311,
0.7010967731,
0.3970113993,
-0.2769684792,
-0.1770340651,
-0.213935867,
0.2001464516,
-0.2153136879,
-0.0315545872,
1.229013443,
0.2421526015,
-0.8284304142,
0.3003509939,
-0.1169527397,
0.5365781188,
-0.6375071406,
-0.1532272995,
-0.0530836247,
0.2634352446,
-0.1280217618,
-0.9588808417,
0.1264772415,
0.0266576074,
0.4991136491,
-0.2698582709,
0.7510364056,
0.0025776408,
-0.3914822042,
0.4498387277,
0.5594885945,
0.534627974,
0.075794287,
-0.8558732271,
0.3268681467,
-0.0772310644,
-0.1822100282,
0.2537944913,
0.2467387766,
-0.0087463381,
0.8401376009,
0.6541396379,
0.1497683376,
-0.1993589848,
0.3737414181,
0.8566456437,
-0.3675603867,
-0.3416284919,
-0.6518447995,
0.3004059494,
-0.7405160666,
-0.5232248902,
0.9839199185,
0.6417405009,
0.7803310156,
0.2013960481,
0.5812954903,
0.0407311991,
0.6008836627,
-0.3504320085,
0.0781705379,
-0.2111468464,
0.4063915014,
-0.5121902227,
-0.9477463365,
-0.0206361618,
0.4979137182,
-0.6256126165,
0.1723846644,
0.6434981227,
0.9380753636,
-0.3391180933,
0.0831008106,
0.5876216292,
0.0708197355,
0.5498384237,
0.2504709661,
0.8917204738,
-0.1659181714,
0.851433754,
-0.2105906159,
-0.2747919858,
-0.3373207152,
-1.0541534424,
-0.9380701184,
-0.3620313704,
-0.3167446554,
-0.1387594342,
0.1376483738,
0.7981882095,
0.9413195848,
-0.6237171888,
-0.5919138193,
0.1163061857,
-0.0706388205,
-0.1534770727,
-0.1815187931,
0.1119071767,
-0.4518943727,
-0.7410203815,
0.5870259404,
0.5568614602,
-0.0858507454,
-0.6321617365,
-0.0623083413,
0.0216743462,
0.0212631524,
0.7923429012,
-0.0006590439,
-0.8818967342,
-0.3907943666,
-0.0377750248,
0.0717701092,
0.1938134581,
0.9494737983,
-0.629137814,
0.5995441675,
0.2671836913,
0.4011907876,
0.5678562522,
0.0285476595,
0.936321497,
-0.8171733618,
0.0213074107,
0.2124501467,
0.3692912459,
0.6043825746,
-0.1990548223,
0.8271067739,
-0.2516632378,
-0.6391131878,
-0.9050286412,
0.0889272988,
-0.8583005071,
-0.1333618015,
1.2389570475,
-0.2133993059,
0.1634662449,
-0.4436636269,
-0.6966804862,
-0.2401409,
-0.7186495066,
0.7219310403,
0.8604040146,
-0.4186058044,
-0.1985390037,
-0.8458921909,
0.5231007934,
0.2351998687,
-1.12464118,
0.1440629661,
0.6199345589,
0.0688812435,
0.4695900679,
0.6196078062,
-0.0068274005,
0.2127510011,
-0.120665133,
-0.3099308312,
-0.1136287749,
-0.0422877856,
0.0129444851,
-0.0702861771,
0.3707114756,
0.0385264717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09458v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09458v1
|
Lexical Repetitions Lead to Rote Learning: Unveiling the Impact of Lexical Overlap in Train and Test Reference Summaries
| 2023-11-15T23:47:53 | 2023-11-15T23:47:53 |
Prafulla Kumar Choubey, Alexander R. Fabbri, Caiming Xiong, Chien-Sheng Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Ideal summarization models should generalize to novel summary-worthy content
without remembering reference training summaries by rote. However, a single
average performance score on the entire test set is inadequate in determining
such model competencies. We propose a fine-grained evaluation protocol by
partitioning a test set based on the lexical similarity of reference test
summaries with training summaries. We observe up to a 5x (1.2x) difference in
ROUGE-2 (entity recall) scores between the subsets with the lowest and highest
similarity. Next, we show that such training repetitions also make a model
vulnerable to rote learning, reproducing data artifacts such as factual errors,
especially when reference test summaries are lexically close to training
summaries. Consequently, we propose to limit lexical repetitions in training
summaries during both supervised fine-tuning and likelihood calibration stages
to improve the performance on novel test cases while retaining average
performance. Our automatic and human evaluations on novel test subsets and
recent news articles show that limiting lexical repetitions in training
summaries can prevent rote learning and improve generalization.
|
[
-0.4073357582,
-0.3932850063,
0.1424310952,
-0.0287781488,
-0.3074190021,
-0.0591156669,
0.0145030729,
-0.3192617297,
0.1841632426,
0.4344468117,
-0.1458386183,
-0.3542699814,
-0.435027957,
0.0384257473,
-0.4784098268,
1.1557551622,
-0.0587987266,
0.2098505348,
-0.2338220328,
-0.5749695897,
-0.514680624,
-0.4217136502,
-0.3633299768,
-0.3888716996,
0.3212617338,
0.3771394789,
0.8673883677,
0.4640360773,
0.6781012416,
0.2253085524,
-0.0142983841,
0.3800320029,
-0.5255134702,
0.0518603437,
-0.3640340567,
-0.6342879534,
-0.389210999,
-0.0455323681,
0.6736549139,
0.8567771912,
-0.066072233,
0.0686014071,
0.1287470311,
0.7696968317,
-0.875343442,
0.0091954181,
-0.7309605479,
-0.0726419166,
0.1961948723,
-0.2812099755,
-0.4084125757,
-0.4407715499,
0.0722355917,
-0.5694003105,
0.5600295067,
-0.2551097572,
0.9126297235,
0.1156934798,
-0.0585648976,
-0.2380732298,
-0.6403943896,
0.5291194916,
-0.5748252273,
0.1168638319,
0.4010032713,
0.3873087168,
0.2785764039,
-0.5809637904,
-0.3006798029,
-0.2699776292,
-0.2223451883,
0.1688592881,
0.1632774025,
0.1841661781,
0.3641282916,
0.420994699,
-0.7291164994,
-0.1857738793,
-0.5751847625,
-0.2565894127,
0.5929203033,
0.420415163,
0.2799710035,
0.071326822,
-0.3172318637,
-0.3858576119,
-0.4640252888,
-0.1147617921,
0.0839388296,
0.4056587219,
0.0900065377,
0.3815433979,
-0.306933254,
0.5010387301,
-0.195962593,
0.0133993216,
0.5060226321,
-0.4815787673,
-0.1928829104,
0.0079362867,
0.6644883752,
0.4931931496,
0.8749339581,
-0.4634411931,
-0.2096794397,
0.0842164457,
0.5758660436,
-0.6305869818,
-0.0495557301,
-0.1270669103,
-0.1548249424,
-0.320070684,
0.4059635699,
-0.9937172532,
-0.0479359068,
-0.3979235291,
0.6586306691,
-0.7986380458,
0.1921188235,
0.184250772,
-0.607249558,
0.331795454,
0.2586209476,
-0.8335671425,
0.6896075606,
0.6502988338,
0.8968548179,
-0.1622729152,
-0.8603827357,
-0.5484858155,
0.07307823,
-0.4515545964,
0.575909853,
-0.4673660696,
-0.4771832526,
-0.0260809325,
-0.1091211066,
-0.4306456149,
-0.9685428739,
-0.186298877,
-0.6125633717,
-0.016949527,
-0.289267987,
-0.4986298978,
-0.1000412032,
0.247902289,
-0.625766933,
0.9784587026,
0.3908431232,
-0.5707810521,
0.3236472011,
-0.109553054,
-0.3772418201,
-0.317854017,
-0.1618744582,
-0.3125752807,
0.2553838789,
-0.0642836019,
0.0407833606,
-0.1693831235,
0.0064412882,
-0.2283328325,
-0.6456394196,
0.0639669821,
-0.274797529,
0.2333870232,
-0.0192217883,
-0.2964166999,
-0.1256296933,
-0.6922451258,
0.3051640689,
-0.1174302846,
0.0855759829,
-0.7174582481,
-0.4169222116,
-0.1559925675,
0.1421148777,
-0.0756589696,
0.0623047389,
0.1600145549,
-0.404689163,
-0.1832574457,
0.5449519157,
0.1159699932,
0.5552732348,
-0.9656521082,
0.4963782132,
0.0285638869,
-0.1022611856,
-0.5455916524,
-0.0560331717,
-0.7518461943,
0.166685611,
0.6226213574,
0.5461906195,
-0.4695254564,
0.1612706482,
-0.6349657178,
-0.5098145008,
-0.2784083784,
0.1191161722,
0.5994595289,
0.1503669769,
0.5122515559,
-0.7649831176,
-0.3910523653,
-0.8678353429,
-0.4059152603,
-0.1439059228,
-0.1209829822,
-0.0187133886,
0.8407156467,
0.0450939648,
0.9967250824,
-0.5214354396,
-0.2999691069,
-0.2297335416,
0.2338023335,
-0.4819784164,
0.5005549192,
0.5715565681,
-0.6361863017,
-0.3187875152,
-0.1083030105,
-0.6828311682,
0.1282392442,
-0.4071784317,
0.1507543325,
-0.0412709415,
0.6616140008,
-0.3903261125,
0.4857161939,
-0.0072148708,
-0.1855263561,
0.8349855542,
-0.1161189303,
0.2163681984,
-0.957436204,
-0.0730963573,
-0.430917263,
-0.2015087754,
-0.3426821828,
0.2110188901,
0.111259751,
0.1195197627,
-0.2059173882,
0.706050992,
-0.0636337996,
-0.1199479476,
-0.2152391672,
0.2235202789,
0.120804444,
0.3375584781,
-0.023105938,
0.9395976067,
0.2235883474,
-0.5897749066,
-0.1226381883,
0.1514891982,
-0.2986660898,
0.2309644371,
-0.588578999,
-0.0635585561,
-0.1153030097,
0.0912778899,
-0.8253108859,
-0.2015036941,
-0.2286865413,
-0.5222555995,
0.3524251282,
0.4857295156,
-0.3073988259,
0.0078550614,
-0.5962282419,
0.6006790996,
0.4742052853,
-0.3275194764,
0.3380391896,
0.037146192,
0.0276557431,
-0.6432050467,
-0.7552958727,
-0.3536813259,
-0.0584761687,
-0.4519934058,
0.4675177336,
0.1995599419,
-0.3466718197,
-0.1356749535,
-0.3939311504,
-0.3674192429,
-0.1584063917,
0.1853988916,
0.1039068475,
-0.233057484,
0.3575047851,
-0.2315227985,
0.0167779848,
0.0700452626,
0.0775883868,
0.612041533,
-0.2908169031,
-0.2687611282,
-0.1791810244,
0.2879889905,
0.8138801455,
-0.0426039323,
0.6750326753,
0.3959157467,
-0.3827309012,
-0.2287018746,
-0.4875076115,
-0.3377881348,
-0.4259701967,
0.7676709294,
-0.4200105667,
-0.4112100303,
0.5962642431,
-0.0149886943,
0.0201019142,
0.5261638165,
0.23652789,
0.0024013391,
0.3699475527,
0.5006299615,
-0.1580588818,
0.3398389816,
-0.5212236047,
-0.1452621371,
-0.7084946632,
-0.1233775318,
-0.2615282536,
-0.2206956297,
-0.3903022408,
-0.5320537686,
0.1374265999,
0.2338352799,
-0.2139198482,
0.3204380572,
-0.1212682277,
0.9594494104,
0.2406331599,
0.1865116209,
0.4470942616,
0.0841195062,
-0.4762098491,
0.0011152723,
-0.6487968564,
-0.5918960571,
1.2189776897,
0.1322292238,
0.7459558249,
-0.1734937727,
0.7891379595,
0.2980833054,
0.258613199,
-0.7539404035,
0.489642024,
-0.0603166111,
-0.365552336,
-0.3773318529,
-0.4879769981,
-0.9039523005,
0.4197876751,
0.2953155339,
-0.6524784565,
-0.0219443776,
-0.2133012414,
-0.5630244017,
0.2585987449,
-0.6232646108,
0.7361178398,
0.0979451835,
-0.2403041571,
-0.4351089299,
-0.5167285204,
0.5441665649,
-0.1345990747,
0.2465481758,
0.1522844136,
-0.092313394,
0.8658746481,
-0.5800135732,
0.7739892006,
0.1817530394,
0.4354892671,
0.3470879495,
0.2458883226,
0.1842080355,
0.0649321526,
0.0424121656,
-0.0489980206,
0.0521826372,
-0.465904206,
-0.7260220647,
0.4188237786,
-0.8512757421,
-0.3389888108,
-0.6997885108,
-0.6683190465,
-0.4301133752,
-0.0315757208,
0.4674669504,
0.5876905322,
-0.5265804529,
-0.0840015411,
0.619930923,
0.0332052149,
0.2802845538,
0.3367913663,
-0.0732479915,
-0.5153636932,
0.9801189303,
0.0380691998,
0.8999629617,
0.1738428771,
-0.0981976837,
0.0600149184,
-0.4378386736,
-0.109032318,
0.3525415659,
-0.7103499174,
-0.2324463725,
-0.5135016441,
-0.5839985013,
-0.4430623353,
-0.3276187778,
-0.4812903404,
-0.5221563578,
-0.0205611978,
0.0635793358,
0.0638300031,
0.6722419262,
-0.0737807676,
0.503769815,
-0.7970894575,
0.3663727939,
0.3988772035,
0.1889837384,
0.2488766909,
-0.8502699733,
-0.3422997892,
-0.0446208306,
-0.7287079692,
-0.7932339311,
0.1881127805,
0.3398497403,
0.3262087107,
0.3923110664,
-0.1021835431,
0.8638270497,
-0.5754945874,
0.5595635772,
0.273448348,
-0.745641768,
0.3455529809,
-0.147832796,
0.5558091998,
1.1376465559,
0.4969406128,
-0.6202461123,
-0.6031544209,
-0.8263019919,
-0.8729066253,
0.6309151649,
0.2362880111,
0.1132366657,
-0.100657545,
0.4612521231,
0.0953812227,
-0.0416896231,
-0.546495676,
-0.2441438735,
0.0796043649,
-0.1428765357,
-0.109363541,
-0.2675452828,
-0.1813784242,
-0.2605739832,
0.576372087,
-0.0010085421,
-0.028620027,
0.2312036455,
-0.3457475603,
0.192017436,
0.2438364178,
0.5608486533,
0.7154768109,
-0.2731035054,
0.0568606444,
0.6001014113,
-0.7495375276,
0.2513507009,
-0.1116473898,
-0.0808721632,
0.3726360798,
0.7552089691,
0.5086740255,
0.5606772304,
-0.7423530817,
0.5028975606,
0.0789334029,
-0.3048681915,
-0.3854334354,
0.3676870465,
-0.1344857514,
-0.0891222581,
0.122517474,
0.4317179918,
0.1092620417,
-0.7144131064,
0.7394188643,
0.1915991455,
-0.4821188152,
-0.218215093,
0.3519256115,
-0.1263792962,
-0.2431183457,
0.5827199221,
-0.3425439894,
-0.5446922183,
0.9678663611,
0.4295940697,
0.7384524941,
-0.5401121974,
0.1735919863,
0.7464177608,
0.3827229738,
-0.4408893883,
-0.0070805899,
0.0446143262,
-0.5773676634,
-0.0554712415,
-0.5444706678,
-0.3387131095,
0.1208641008,
-1.0113534927,
0.5226960778,
-0.3201419711,
0.1365337074,
0.0203613322,
-0.3710205853,
-0.4019782841,
0.2554272115,
-0.016832849,
0.9157899022,
-0.8850122094,
0.7313714623,
0.3774078488,
-0.5651348829,
-0.641518414,
0.2428026348,
-0.1119441986,
-0.8075916171,
0.5349265933,
0.5124365687,
0.2272761613,
-0.4251297414,
0.1886865944,
-0.7186819911,
1.0537089109,
0.1253605932,
-0.4985364079,
-0.4771950245,
0.547134161,
0.5645310283,
-0.4276545942,
0.8065704703,
0.8888212442,
0.1535271108,
0.2361728847,
-1.0945167542,
-0.0668768361,
-0.0812823176,
-0.0511206649,
0.2779156864,
-0.7673573494,
0.5726267695,
-0.5288093686,
-0.042074725,
0.2113699913,
0.3642028272,
0.2789121568,
0.4914652705,
0.4325951636,
0.6776350141,
0.6500745416,
-0.035927318,
1.0259767771,
0.0901782662,
0.3723217547,
1.8101274967,
-0.1188588962,
0.696675837,
0.3038356006,
-0.2814877629,
0.3349584341,
0.5408961773,
-0.0835878551,
0.6369736791,
0.4194926918,
-0.0916808844,
-0.190098688,
0.0474833697,
-0.6242808104,
0.5470191836,
0.3032482564,
-0.6096163988,
-0.7667971849,
-0.04008957,
-0.2638823688,
0.1495689154,
-0.238864556,
0.7358052135,
0.1664195657,
-0.6691858172,
0.8709233999,
-0.3809920847,
0.3004289865,
-0.7858192325,
0.0776477158,
-0.3609776199,
0.2996584773,
0.011885684,
-0.3061603606,
0.7293971777,
-0.2292861342,
-0.3399308026,
0.194466114,
0.1658387184,
-0.4426008761,
-0.2919074595,
0.3843340576,
0.4869580567,
0.1812318116,
-0.1934726834,
-0.4985973239,
-0.3281336725,
-0.0444895551,
-0.1258404553,
0.6123090982,
0.4372510314,
-0.1852172166,
0.4876395166,
0.1087636352,
0.0355734266,
0.0164084397,
0.3252101243,
0.8847728968,
-0.7812526226,
-0.3176148236,
-1.0308866501,
0.1941767782,
-0.1042710319,
-0.590909183,
0.421464771,
1.0635362864,
1.0283719301,
-0.0775307789,
0.69537431,
0.2831583321,
0.1805714816,
-0.4605754316,
0.5753176212,
-0.6249739528,
0.3234395087,
-0.2441815585,
-0.7085784078,
-0.1229369342,
0.3325777948,
-0.2805710435,
0.0638513342,
1.1979187727,
0.9624806643,
-0.1659126729,
0.1656900346,
0.4890114963,
-0.0308654346,
-0.0354601033,
0.7100341916,
0.6831110716,
-0.8633005023,
0.5802695155,
-0.3350283504,
-0.1467135698,
-0.1396086067,
-0.2575668693,
-0.9778769016,
-0.6358631253,
-0.2764301002,
-0.5296404362,
0.1937955618,
0.7045839429,
0.352704227,
-0.8982558846,
-0.3661417067,
-0.2297044992,
0.1309502423,
-0.3138804734,
-0.3605166078,
0.3916072547,
-0.9601972103,
-0.6783158183,
-0.1702017486,
0.0275237132,
0.2956242859,
0.1558323205,
0.0273667593,
0.0553695261,
0.0689531714,
0.2976375818,
0.2054488361,
-0.5199433565,
0.0019631786,
-0.0783622339,
-0.2683500648,
0.0735206008,
1.1093927622,
-0.9159332514,
0.4655611515,
0.32258448,
0.6327685714,
0.3920997381,
0.0406766199,
0.6381467581,
-0.5241249204,
0.2044588476,
0.4272934496,
0.2111011744,
-0.0974957049,
-0.0987628251,
0.8062620163,
0.2482740432,
-0.4366928041,
-0.7008810043,
-0.0147239789,
-0.9012295604,
-0.3124979734,
1.2832452059,
-0.1381814331,
-0.0173294116,
-0.140705958,
0.1190387532,
0.2088788748,
-0.1322673857,
1.0694109201,
0.8696327806,
0.1332068145,
0.482360512,
-0.6856604218,
0.6540700197,
0.7729623914,
-0.6777112484,
0.281704694,
0.2245014012,
0.4548203349,
0.2716517746,
0.4536371231,
-0.2902390063,
0.7030171156,
0.2629310787,
-0.0161526743,
0.0439472422,
-0.4525998235,
-0.3292930722,
0.1299994439,
-0.0758087635,
-0.2649580538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10774v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10774v2
|
MMC: Advancing Multimodal Chart Understanding with Large-scale Instruction Tuning
| 2023-11-15T23:36:42 | 2024-04-15T15:48:48 |
Fuxiao Liu, Xiaoyang Wang, Wenlin Yao, Jianshu Chen, Kaiqiang Song, Sangwoo Cho, Yaser Yacoob, Dong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the rapid development of large language models (LLMs) and their
integration into large multimodal models (LMMs), there has been impressive
progress in zero-shot completion of user-oriented vision-language tasks.
However, a gap remains in the domain of chart image understanding due to the
distinct abstract components in charts. To address this, we introduce a
large-scale MultiModal Chart Instruction (\textbf{MMC-Instruction}) dataset
comprising 600k instances supporting diverse tasks and chart types. Leveraging
this data, we develop MultiModal Chart Assistant (\textbf{MMCA}), an LMM that
achieves state-of-the-art performance on existing chart QA benchmarks.
Recognizing the need for a comprehensive evaluation of LMM chart understanding,
we also propose a MultiModal Chart Benchmark (\textbf{MMC-Benchmark}), a
comprehensive human-annotated benchmark with nine distinct tasks evaluating
reasoning capabilities over charts. Extensive experiments on MMC-Benchmark
reveal the limitations of existing LMMs on correctly interpreting charts, even
for the most recent GPT-4V model. Our work provides an instruction-tuning
methodology and benchmark to advance multimodal understanding of charts. Code
and data are available at https://github.com/FuxiaoLiu/MMC.
|
[
-0.2623333037,
-0.7682888508,
0.6956294775,
0.0260396581,
-0.2830829322,
0.2475744337,
-0.1182840466,
-0.278044045,
-0.1119818464,
0.5305176973,
-0.800703764,
-0.9432556033,
-0.5798326731,
-0.1481695175,
0.0305241048,
0.6183114648,
-0.1531505287,
0.0229973961,
-0.3092161119,
-0.3336871862,
-0.769025445,
-0.2598471344,
-0.6209411025,
0.101113908,
0.817642808,
0.9194773436,
0.6033346057,
0.6431574225,
0.502230525,
0.3753536344,
0.4238376915,
0.8251821995,
-0.5263690352,
0.0639952123,
0.1400341541,
-0.444506824,
-0.7909301519,
0.1866336763,
0.5087375641,
0.5408546925,
0.0146614881,
0.2226992548,
-0.3139990866,
0.8520361185,
-0.9782415628,
1.0018318892,
-0.222444579,
0.0350141339,
-0.1200285107,
-0.5156562328,
-0.9578126073,
0.0024076288,
-0.0514165387,
-0.8561151028,
-0.0051138527,
0.1271648854,
0.5529586077,
0.2590348125,
-1.0114004612,
-0.4094724953,
-0.4226819873,
0.8482150435,
-0.2696391642,
0.6407235265,
0.4757480919,
0.8158766627,
0.2131453902,
-0.8882881403,
-0.4235964417,
-0.2673672736,
0.2467436194,
0.5624879003,
-0.0234599113,
0.1335033178,
0.2991479337,
0.0809655413,
-0.4675041139,
0.2495990545,
-0.361810565,
-0.2437935323,
0.3323912323,
0.5344360471,
0.1675914079,
-0.0935253426,
-0.2740888298,
-0.4173494577,
-0.4455325305,
0.0460499525,
0.0727778152,
0.0794054568,
-0.3507561386,
0.5651982427,
-0.1471253932,
0.6742004156,
-0.0686386451,
-0.2512120605,
0.4422544837,
-0.4315307736,
-0.1467147321,
-0.137197271,
0.4891247451,
0.675568819,
0.3062150776,
0.056079898,
0.0471392088,
-0.0529882498,
0.4181616902,
-0.7238219976,
-0.311417371,
-0.1593780965,
-0.3150829077,
0.121484302,
-0.0566562414,
-0.6420459151,
-0.5401693583,
-0.7535721064,
0.2658472657,
-0.4410421848,
0.140338853,
-0.1475417614,
-0.051422324,
0.0896220654,
0.6001029611,
-0.9525939822,
-0.2539654374,
0.5858307481,
0.7625265121,
0.1797424108,
-0.3777333796,
-0.6446660161,
0.4210534096,
-0.5064486861,
0.8663770556,
-0.7322478294,
-0.1552655846,
-0.2034210414,
0.1247686669,
-0.3834725022,
-0.2695990503,
0.4081168175,
-0.5127649903,
-0.0155291306,
-0.0773540214,
-0.5691114068,
-0.527565062,
0.3465804458,
-0.765978992,
0.5499113202,
0.1077326089,
-0.461050421,
0.4506313205,
-0.6797990799,
-0.2797692418,
-0.1438957155,
-0.3745973706,
-0.3362457156,
-0.2291435301,
0.6578608155,
0.6263241768,
-0.2423658222,
-0.4686999619,
-0.4385939538,
-0.3561968505,
0.32397452,
-0.5603666902,
0.3118098974,
0.3493841887,
-0.3234786391,
0.4880675375,
-0.6768087745,
0.0192471091,
-0.0369453244,
-0.0514139235,
0.0451217256,
-0.0283869877,
0.0285019018,
0.2284503877,
0.2894103825,
-0.1064583734,
0.1606496722,
0.1328095347,
0.4435113966,
1.0321391821,
-0.1915727556,
0.3224271536,
0.0024547393,
0.6896265745,
0.1833677888,
0.4360260963,
-0.675280869,
-0.6050357819,
-0.7820954323,
-0.62204808,
0.0680605173,
0.4315221012,
-1.02924788,
0.1032039821,
-0.4232405424,
-0.4590532482,
-0.3473275304,
0.2780801058,
0.3531557918,
0.5146704316,
0.4585699439,
-0.419187218,
-0.2986496091,
-0.7995682359,
0.3767936826,
0.1747273803,
0.0187513009,
0.5098946095,
0.1972830147,
-0.3286689222,
0.5655963421,
-0.6115426421,
-0.4173607528,
-0.121473439,
0.4436546862,
0.0434169322,
0.197133705,
0.6140613556,
-0.6286433935,
-0.5274419188,
0.1486051232,
-0.7026886344,
0.0558349751,
-0.315633744,
-0.3258402646,
0.1740082353,
0.7416059375,
-0.3119867742,
0.3017571568,
0.7975369692,
-0.4495779872,
0.5995913744,
-0.5189297795,
0.6181486249,
-0.8803089261,
-0.1883693486,
0.0675179139,
-0.1703896523,
-0.2312613428,
0.1454520971,
0.5127401948,
-0.0779278055,
-0.209475562,
0.1289590001,
-0.5968104601,
0.0541144572,
-0.2555548549,
0.1803800464,
0.0677709952,
0.5854653716,
-0.2232850939,
0.7374573946,
0.4971744716,
-0.3156549633,
0.613309443,
-0.0051103639,
-0.3389385343,
0.7874237299,
-0.094526656,
0.3628088832,
-0.1131440997,
0.3708161116,
-0.9568719268,
-0.1981154382,
0.2063540071,
-0.224861294,
0.4168558121,
-0.2577919662,
-0.6527165771,
-0.2808133662,
-0.224067539,
0.287340939,
0.1525880247,
-0.4956270456,
0.7274872661,
0.1643329561,
0.1867968887,
-0.6740889549,
-0.5910224319,
0.1410255432,
0.0730786994,
-0.7120944262,
-0.1877341419,
-0.2475651503,
0.1621293426,
-0.3928827345,
-0.0161228906,
-0.1679735333,
-0.1981503516,
0.469370842,
0.4749961197,
-0.4294263721,
0.164003402,
0.112690784,
-0.4716046154,
-0.0408612713,
-0.0073566358,
0.3152762353,
-0.0882390887,
-0.8897178173,
-0.7121665478,
0.0228314064,
0.9527283907,
-0.3166215122,
0.6446335316,
0.8374385834,
0.1692157239,
0.166049242,
-0.4611754417,
-0.0280479975,
-0.5156042576,
0.4669475257,
-0.3633412719,
-0.720731914,
0.136937052,
-0.1483619213,
0.1626791656,
0.3026376963,
0.603356719,
-0.3618513048,
1.3289992809,
0.4511871338,
0.0185415652,
0.5445824265,
-0.355484277,
-0.0358192362,
-0.5219749212,
-0.2072443068,
-0.2124242932,
-0.6641671658,
-0.3589989245,
-0.9433210492,
0.6234602928,
-0.2947008908,
-0.2048906088,
-0.0017030303,
-0.1241859719,
0.5011211634,
0.39727211,
0.3033059239,
0.3265553713,
-0.1420922577,
-0.1543948501,
-0.1543273479,
-0.4633862376,
-0.3844350576,
1.3230175972,
0.2076606303,
0.8535023928,
0.062716864,
0.0684241131,
0.1143522933,
0.2078425735,
-0.705327332,
0.4491495788,
-0.3475503027,
-0.5634292364,
-0.1017528549,
-0.7043324709,
-0.901607275,
0.2116536647,
-0.271425426,
-0.4870486557,
-0.2029934078,
0.4113427103,
-0.0626735985,
0.2593229413,
-1.3648235798,
1.2951967716,
-0.4161290526,
-0.1716227829,
-0.6914637089,
-0.6122220159,
0.2701853812,
0.1461447626,
0.4990230203,
-0.3219559491,
-0.1673842967,
0.2878200412,
-0.0160199441,
0.9006732106,
-0.2816759646,
-0.1727712005,
0.1193713471,
-0.0422974452,
0.3357896805,
-0.2232182324,
0.1946957707,
-0.1944291443,
-0.0577420816,
-0.6117678285,
-0.8669177294,
0.6440911889,
-0.6348347664,
0.015477241,
0.0785359666,
-1.0160456896,
-0.3086237311,
-0.0486079864,
-0.2916101515,
0.7288804054,
0.1325010508,
0.3971837759,
0.3784835339,
-0.2111669332,
0.1010500491,
0.4610326588,
-0.0768431574,
-0.2946108878,
1.0455629826,
0.057807222,
0.3516885936,
0.67857337,
-0.0981427878,
-0.3205376267,
-0.4781449437,
-0.6850028634,
0.0772616714,
-1.0976982117,
0.0069003692,
-0.2555764318,
0.1660089344,
-0.2832057774,
-0.154322058,
-0.3156650364,
-0.2598229349,
-0.3286343515,
0.0127608292,
0.4125863612,
0.5122289062,
0.070128724,
0.3248866498,
-0.9003558159,
0.3520976901,
0.5600990653,
0.1872633547,
0.120383136,
-0.4465195239,
-0.5739752054,
0.1168112159,
-0.6024132371,
-0.5194485784,
-0.0143929655,
0.0664935559,
0.3751124442,
0.8894842267,
-0.1929659545,
0.948679328,
-0.4537339211,
0.4553741515,
0.4021897018,
-0.7897100449,
0.2817336321,
-0.2007726729,
0.7356067896,
0.2408157885,
0.2531341016,
-0.658293128,
-0.3950681686,
-0.2317021191,
-0.7423285842,
0.694887042,
-0.0283360928,
-0.0584869385,
0.1673306674,
-0.0313301533,
0.014995696,
-0.0061518564,
-0.402962476,
-0.2430743873,
-0.4675901234,
-0.539925158,
-0.5821208954,
-0.0579761006,
-0.1325349957,
-0.4425815344,
0.2242067158,
-0.6478043199,
-0.0508903898,
-0.2774709463,
-0.4122287929,
-0.0058793677,
0.1907685399,
0.7717407942,
1.0400215387,
-0.1122241244,
0.3609434962,
0.1838480532,
-0.5945644975,
-0.1073045582,
0.0519744121,
0.3470237851,
-0.4842562973,
0.7096937299,
0.9524546266,
0.671164453,
-1.0963953733,
0.320274055,
-0.0886713266,
-0.0840031654,
-0.0306316148,
0.060068626,
0.3770246804,
0.3875840902,
0.2375019342,
-0.0315985493,
-0.1231255978,
-0.4436931312,
0.1388357282,
0.2461754382,
-0.45967713,
-0.2466881871,
0.6670996547,
0.2059505582,
0.3063756526,
0.8741865754,
-0.0448434018,
-0.211391896,
0.7446700931,
0.0493029356,
0.350925535,
0.122139141,
0.2909872532,
0.3223697841,
0.5328257084,
0.6391143799,
0.1684034765,
-0.2140884697,
-0.4765444398,
-0.7760938406,
-0.0369169191,
-0.6527605057,
-0.2825571299,
-0.4370564222,
0.1093036383,
-0.475399673,
-0.0687844455,
0.1728114635,
-0.1381500214,
-0.6306245923,
0.0260284804,
0.4115300179,
0.6041615009,
-0.511222899,
0.7352029085,
0.5625965595,
-0.513350606,
-0.7567440867,
-0.4847548306,
0.4150794148,
-1.0431756973,
0.6090821624,
0.3348091841,
-0.2355640084,
-0.2008754164,
-0.5573469996,
-0.3224120438,
1.4264426231,
0.5149265528,
-0.6173626781,
0.1870020479,
0.2184675038,
0.3651374578,
-0.3545353115,
0.5578947067,
0.5995797515,
0.6882971525,
0.3156194389,
-0.8760815263,
-0.1935738623,
0.0444729924,
-0.3104997873,
0.0956514627,
-0.6209396124,
0.8671057224,
-0.3571617007,
-0.0133980829,
-0.1804280579,
0.5950805545,
0.2542753518,
0.6582238674,
0.6046615243,
0.5610505342,
0.6020936966,
0.0400610156,
0.9617318511,
-0.1372309178,
0.2216471285,
1.1134260893,
-0.0445025675,
0.7213435769,
0.2447848469,
0.0143620409,
0.507173419,
0.6672448516,
0.1308899224,
0.2583752871,
-0.2664405704,
-0.012005887,
-0.4291470349,
0.1475136578,
-0.2573516965,
0.6371039748,
0.5316743255,
-0.4646591842,
-0.2486766279,
-0.0612700395,
-0.1275002062,
-0.0161205065,
-0.440713495,
0.6118018627,
-0.100661777,
-0.1949788332,
0.5820834637,
-0.1800522357,
0.3325057328,
-0.7802906036,
-0.1920448244,
-0.0596663021,
0.260984689,
-0.0655784309,
-0.8511202931,
-0.0437293574,
-0.1305197179,
-0.2128587067,
-0.3219739199,
0.1388889104,
-0.2598439455,
-0.4262182415,
0.1822521538,
0.4892529249,
0.0766192302,
-0.1194671467,
-0.6810070872,
0.0929351971,
0.0048993588,
0.1617842168,
0.3290399909,
0.6885073781,
0.0709717721,
0.8882955909,
0.5999475121,
-0.4044418633,
0.2476622313,
0.5259590149,
0.6745676398,
-0.5372648835,
-0.3802137375,
-0.4301392734,
0.4375754297,
-0.0662115216,
-0.1630202979,
0.6911118627,
0.5814194679,
0.6733217239,
-0.2988381982,
0.2248924524,
0.2022757232,
0.2645627856,
-0.8583417535,
0.8952790499,
-0.7053283453,
-0.0951949209,
-0.3174837828,
-0.6357411742,
-0.1597719342,
0.3505997956,
-0.3868006468,
-0.052200105,
0.9387990236,
0.8122790456,
-0.3405224681,
0.0299649145,
0.3560221493,
0.0745314062,
0.440566808,
0.6340680718,
0.8618608713,
0.0285598729,
0.9838654399,
-0.3886521161,
-0.3785734475,
-0.1579798907,
-0.688207984,
-0.773031354,
-0.6996719241,
-0.2367304415,
0.1881277263,
-0.3677965105,
0.7141878009,
0.9045148492,
-0.6837208271,
-0.3773758709,
0.390134722,
0.1248989329,
-0.5607891083,
-0.2004160732,
0.4444969594,
-0.4233351052,
-0.8695375323,
0.4338443875,
0.5438603163,
-0.0425753929,
-0.2854353189,
-0.2835803628,
-0.1238050088,
-0.1449756175,
0.9092549682,
0.0256448593,
-0.5137283802,
-0.3329684138,
-0.092826739,
-0.0605389923,
0.260175705,
0.9841479659,
-0.4096524417,
1.0133405924,
0.0951221064,
0.4798056483,
0.6702032685,
-0.2604076564,
0.3323492408,
-0.7608261108,
0.3139543235,
0.0082080802,
0.378821224,
0.1707925647,
0.0092048468,
0.5189967752,
0.1624022573,
-0.3807064593,
-0.4137056768,
0.1848979145,
-1.2800395489,
-0.3254965842,
0.5290520191,
-0.0557254925,
-0.1189017966,
-0.0088745942,
-0.5433160663,
0.3253378272,
-0.4526930749,
0.7707313299,
0.6236232519,
-0.2674418688,
-0.5524958372,
-0.8418307304,
-0.1542599499,
0.1899507046,
-1.0154618025,
0.0208137166,
0.9539488554,
-0.1728479862,
0.1185946241,
0.3962591588,
0.0675435439,
0.5914342403,
0.1467000693,
0.088245213,
-0.2453985363,
-0.3031902611,
0.1807821393,
0.1872720271,
0.0878598839,
-0.4278450608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09447v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09447v2
|
How Trustworthy are Open-Source LLMs? An Assessment under Malicious Demonstrations Shows their Vulnerabilities
| 2023-11-15T23:33:07 | 2024-04-02T15:21:55 |
Lingbo Mo, Boshi Wang, Muhao Chen, Huan Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid progress in open-source Large Language Models (LLMs) is
significantly driving AI development forward. However, there is still a limited
understanding of their trustworthiness. Deploying these models at scale without
sufficient trustworthiness can pose significant risks, highlighting the need to
uncover these issues promptly. In this work, we conduct an adversarial
assessment of open-source LLMs on trustworthiness, scrutinizing them across
eight different aspects including toxicity, stereotypes, ethics, hallucination,
fairness, sycophancy, privacy, and robustness against adversarial
demonstrations. We propose advCoU, an extended Chain of Utterances-based (CoU)
prompting strategy by incorporating carefully crafted malicious demonstrations
for trustworthiness attack. Our extensive experiments encompass recent and
representative series of open-source LLMs, including Vicuna, MPT, Falcon,
Mistral, and Llama 2. The empirical outcomes underscore the efficacy of our
attack strategy across diverse aspects. More interestingly, our result analysis
reveals that models with superior performance in general NLP tasks do not
always have greater trustworthiness; in fact, larger models can be more
vulnerable to attacks. Additionally, models that have undergone instruction
tuning, focusing on instruction following, tend to be more susceptible,
although fine-tuning LLMs for safety alignment proves effective in mitigating
adversarial trustworthiness attacks.
|
[
-0.2040165961,
-0.9591014981,
0.4761262536,
-0.0239424594,
-0.0595654994,
-0.0910064057,
-0.1284010112,
-0.5456470847,
-0.1978341043,
0.4541803896,
-0.3599661291,
-0.350135237,
-0.7338485718,
-0.1680818349,
-0.6544877887,
1.0323172808,
0.0915551558,
-0.0541028939,
-0.3903394341,
-0.3792701662,
-0.1862301677,
-0.4946659505,
-0.7701034546,
-0.2441667914,
0.4777869582,
-0.0614322722,
1.0644402504,
0.5797407627,
0.480443716,
0.2825910449,
-0.0473795347,
0.0843529254,
-0.5436808467,
0.2840892673,
-0.1213412881,
-0.7973850369,
-0.4654129148,
0.2454733253,
0.2017951012,
0.1101585031,
-0.0916110501,
0.3600098491,
0.1306278259,
0.6038240194,
-0.5546081662,
-0.0729977116,
-1.027829051,
-0.0583293997,
-0.0568485074,
-0.1384523511,
-0.7101296186,
-0.5769536495,
0.056965299,
-0.6027736068,
-0.2265210748,
0.104161948,
0.7321573496,
0.4977408051,
0.0155395428,
-0.5493143201,
-0.4729459286,
0.7595860958,
-0.6702461839,
0.0280985851,
0.2569194436,
0.1563648283,
-0.3560351431,
-0.6431595683,
-0.4641746283,
-0.7743079066,
0.1876341999,
0.0636370629,
-0.6568713784,
-0.0832718834,
0.2764329016,
0.2290000618,
-0.5432152748,
0.4029471278,
-0.0517716408,
-0.341208756,
0.4295184314,
-0.1607509702,
0.4840086997,
0.1542963237,
-0.7261502743,
-0.180190593,
-1.0159983635,
0.0695911124,
0.7529450059,
0.0376442857,
-0.0807724595,
0.7637653351,
0.1837771982,
0.3618392646,
-0.0614881553,
0.2631157041,
-0.2624239028,
-0.0969041511,
-0.40838027,
-0.0398978107,
1.080943346,
0.1833703518,
0.5330649614,
-0.256229341,
0.0713928267,
0.2156143486,
0.5818573236,
-0.3992990851,
-0.3510303795,
0.5277618766,
-0.2922005653,
-0.8873379827,
0.0542013161,
-0.4597949088,
-0.6523486376,
-0.0338228047,
0.5505366325,
-0.6578723192,
-0.063281633,
-0.32902053,
-0.003540803,
0.1700650156,
0.4007653892,
-0.3578921556,
0.1386057436,
0.876791954,
0.9334383011,
-0.1038754135,
-0.3988963366,
-0.8660621047,
-0.0248748623,
-0.4002019763,
0.2542134523,
-0.3561939001,
-0.2924557328,
0.013496127,
-0.1054311618,
0.084269166,
-0.3234148622,
0.4983691275,
-0.7204567194,
0.0128171677,
-0.1668483764,
-0.4006083608,
-0.1319951117,
0.4430512488,
-0.8008087873,
0.8509482145,
-0.1755612642,
-0.8701792955,
0.0503762886,
-0.483139962,
-0.3058957458,
-0.1010637507,
-0.1238983944,
-0.2515544891,
0.1806378812,
0.3009821773,
0.5749405026,
0.0031247174,
0.0940957963,
-0.5470442772,
-0.3051464856,
0.7018587589,
-0.9037479758,
1.0426658392,
0.1892006099,
-0.4093143344,
0.2574685514,
-0.7742486596,
0.043706391,
0.1967328936,
-0.0664535016,
-0.5246411562,
-0.1509815902,
-0.477752775,
0.0019151671,
0.2999346554,
-0.3893894255,
-0.0438960418,
-0.5095171928,
0.4646737874,
1.028280735,
-0.063303642,
0.2406510711,
-0.3898103237,
0.5431116819,
-0.1335530728,
0.4239294529,
-0.1322946399,
-0.5905963182,
-0.5693559647,
-0.2218497992,
0.0183741581,
0.5627774596,
-0.7171545029,
0.3454766273,
-0.0153471073,
-0.6009123325,
-0.8048753738,
0.1688874215,
0.6985164285,
0.3028638363,
0.3532163203,
-0.1148684695,
-0.2628892958,
-0.6809400916,
-0.3904708922,
-0.5330005288,
-0.0468374565,
0.1756949276,
0.4737605751,
-0.1654248834,
0.509831965,
-0.1281261295,
0.2057501376,
0.3114036024,
0.0962770581,
-0.3110871911,
0.2454737723,
0.4676339924,
-0.4720959663,
-0.1333734095,
-0.1419508308,
-0.7389075756,
0.1976401508,
-0.0281992424,
-0.1178684756,
0.2507019639,
0.4930938482,
-0.7289637923,
0.1973518282,
0.8420935869,
-0.0992797762,
0.6610477567,
-0.3219437003,
-0.0267019495,
-1.0352677107,
-0.0259051397,
-0.0998937488,
-0.2670762539,
-0.4403792322,
0.6264201403,
-0.1058000475,
-0.0826406106,
-0.7933624983,
0.3111214638,
-0.1782111377,
0.0764065087,
-0.0917751938,
0.2788386047,
0.0413414128,
0.2210343182,
-0.4465032816,
0.6737954021,
0.6521651149,
-0.6706017256,
0.6012039781,
0.0244679432,
-0.3421123624,
0.6298184991,
-0.8922727704,
0.4588837326,
0.3249892592,
0.1006003246,
-0.7883238792,
-0.0520014092,
0.3045656383,
-0.7333692312,
0.3508776724,
0.0304548647,
-0.4603189528,
-0.0557561964,
-0.5228022337,
0.0203910135,
0.4641230702,
-0.8175484538,
0.2590837181,
0.2353824228,
0.1041457877,
-0.8995984793,
-0.7066568136,
0.1322387457,
-0.1490440071,
-0.8202542067,
-0.2401184738,
-0.0547110997,
-0.6585393548,
-0.1667525172,
-0.0180136804,
0.1197209507,
0.5420491695,
0.5345241427,
0.273455292,
-0.0938879326,
-0.2424937636,
-0.2745133638,
0.1103191227,
0.4032952785,
-0.2340281457,
0.2946394682,
-0.455018729,
-0.6472933292,
-0.4406214952,
0.0522660315,
0.873518765,
-0.1516189575,
0.7450616956,
0.8237646222,
-0.1804471761,
-0.3703426123,
-0.3834219575,
-0.0656859055,
-0.4877547622,
0.266174078,
-0.0927881151,
-0.9328386188,
0.3512910008,
-0.0335159749,
0.2206100374,
0.3255334795,
0.5496091843,
-0.0878202543,
0.8011162281,
0.2283000052,
-0.3057687879,
0.0498213619,
-0.0548685081,
0.0062058442,
-0.6464621425,
-0.2865669131,
-0.4625432193,
0.1179894358,
-0.6860704422,
-0.5887191296,
0.1417672932,
-0.0681951195,
-0.0490762331,
0.2940208316,
-0.2951484323,
0.2560195327,
0.6439504027,
0.1871749163,
0.3802939057,
-0.0632062033,
0.0730718598,
0.2607246637,
-0.4393629432,
-0.7782559991,
1.061476469,
0.9010154009,
1.0911759138,
0.1816071868,
0.5594167709,
0.3549541831,
0.0957252383,
-0.7664174438,
0.6691691279,
-0.1429687142,
-0.4187664092,
-0.4466064274,
-0.3041380942,
-0.6196848154,
-0.0805387124,
-0.2563422024,
-0.6195101738,
-0.1101509258,
0.3648478687,
-0.2952671349,
0.4206047654,
-0.5085813999,
0.4130848646,
-0.3689629138,
-0.4024962783,
-0.2043786645,
-0.685015142,
0.5879548788,
-0.0351292863,
0.3113498092,
-0.02073537,
-0.0950021595,
0.4914025366,
-0.3274191916,
0.907900691,
-0.0255158581,
-0.3286266923,
0.420242697,
0.4085445702,
0.843495667,
0.0892272666,
-0.0975440368,
0.3836500943,
-0.1982124001,
-0.2306077629,
-0.6922605038,
1.0883659124,
-0.8876419663,
-0.7326250076,
-0.2988291085,
-0.385957092,
-0.1686399579,
0.0360893607,
0.2886220217,
0.3622640073,
-0.5924434662,
0.3458974361,
1.0314307213,
-0.3570584357,
0.3185117245,
0.2215178162,
0.1308266819,
-0.321123302,
0.977682054,
-0.2972134948,
0.6238771677,
0.2761522233,
0.2948426008,
-0.11020495,
-0.6310120821,
-0.5073119998,
-0.0972928256,
-0.6525650024,
-0.0507258512,
-0.3977376819,
-0.1383224726,
-0.4683149457,
-0.1321726739,
-0.5488896966,
-0.5120378733,
-0.2788730264,
-0.1611561179,
0.4916240573,
0.8968239427,
0.3248884082,
-0.0720616952,
-0.6282618642,
0.1425429583,
0.4545526206,
0.2539863288,
0.0476046614,
-0.4886898398,
-0.1059811786,
0.1433220506,
-0.2730692625,
-0.6654031873,
0.0221768729,
-0.0601129755,
0.6161119938,
0.4061826468,
0.2819192708,
0.4021093249,
-0.4496174455,
1.1127090454,
0.2165097296,
-0.8953361511,
0.5044839382,
-0.2766469717,
0.0261196028,
0.4780157804,
0.5272395015,
0.0758992285,
-0.9193649292,
-0.7074253559,
-0.7326077223,
0.3831273615,
0.3770779073,
0.1497618556,
0.05194024,
0.3050201237,
0.1644870788,
0.1559541374,
-0.862128675,
-0.365526706,
-0.4994451404,
-0.0815519765,
0.0370319225,
-0.2047350854,
-0.521355629,
0.3502672911,
0.7949717641,
0.0234606452,
0.0108060818,
0.1814969331,
-0.1023685485,
-0.0409481674,
0.5734294653,
0.5774325728,
0.3753422797,
-0.0509102903,
0.2101104856,
0.0637238547,
-0.5606805682,
0.1580832452,
-0.0314430259,
-0.1647917628,
-0.1707899272,
0.4806887507,
0.753708303,
-0.0167205967,
-0.570738852,
0.7099307179,
-0.1672393829,
-0.2080783993,
-0.3657955825,
0.2304687947,
0.0218415577,
0.3344903886,
0.0009987933,
0.2154775113,
-0.0460405797,
-0.742362082,
0.0528672598,
0.750449419,
-0.6274670959,
-0.2392648757,
0.6762135625,
0.1824546456,
-0.2612836659,
0.4201154411,
0.0995768234,
-0.320771277,
0.4781075418,
0.287086904,
0.931255281,
-0.2317323685,
0.2826042473,
-0.0020365221,
0.8380247355,
-0.1870786101,
-0.1135262176,
0.1258321106,
-0.3764015734,
-0.1516265571,
-0.4751330018,
-0.8168898821,
0.2646717429,
-0.8804850578,
0.0783114657,
-0.5554340482,
-0.0704365969,
-0.303450048,
-0.1632677913,
-0.3589347899,
0.260420531,
0.1744960994,
1.0044094324,
-0.6673691273,
0.7911394835,
0.5595041513,
-0.1336991191,
-0.7144988179,
0.1706318259,
0.0779199302,
-1.135240078,
0.3464463651,
0.0357534923,
-0.2696741521,
-0.3239345551,
-0.7271615863,
-0.5832858086,
1.1811003685,
0.6251438856,
-0.6873884201,
-0.134862259,
-0.1003174409,
0.530946672,
-0.1571287811,
0.1872541606,
0.2360789925,
0.2718182504,
0.0359255522,
-0.7942686677,
0.4296651185,
-0.1522128284,
-0.1302721649,
-0.1242207661,
-0.7465105057,
0.5844778419,
-0.4079456627,
-0.0676638708,
0.2737752795,
0.6036243439,
0.397864759,
0.3489694297,
0.4822286963,
0.5692511201,
0.9165619612,
0.0731306374,
1.2678012848,
-0.3372523487,
-0.1300897896,
1.2174108028,
-0.060463842,
1.0039554834,
0.4423003495,
0.0023864396,
0.4654505849,
0.1990397274,
-0.1607084125,
0.3141506016,
0.236865297,
-0.0458329096,
0.0922646448,
0.0621308126,
-0.3935883045,
0.3592639863,
0.2148440778,
-0.5272095203,
0.1965445876,
0.0312025752,
0.3392285705,
0.161399141,
-0.4317852259,
0.7057440877,
0.3133948147,
-0.7148746252,
0.4169831872,
-0.3106273711,
0.5606945157,
-0.6750656366,
0.1289815605,
0.2937001884,
0.1919255108,
-0.2124125361,
-0.6677756906,
0.1743903607,
0.1819463968,
0.1353536993,
0.0788182169,
0.5905010104,
-0.1317193806,
-0.1162273809,
0.4262695312,
0.2798721492,
0.0404151753,
-0.1183527485,
-0.6484667063,
0.2600550354,
-0.1699336767,
-0.3275828958,
0.4993276894,
0.2490851879,
0.145231232,
0.8070492744,
0.6340235472,
0.2924604714,
0.0252987612,
0.0822015181,
0.770786345,
-0.2537342012,
-0.2133215219,
-1.1246081591,
0.3684252799,
-0.0523073524,
-0.0039043117,
1.2560367584,
0.1950625777,
0.8251165152,
0.2007386684,
1.0201708078,
0.3465591967,
0.192857489,
-0.7777365446,
0.8590512276,
-0.3606009483,
0.5776147842,
-0.2414603084,
-0.5261627436,
-0.0236541163,
0.1442418694,
0.0442023054,
-0.2036916614,
0.6290573478,
0.7145504951,
0.305541873,
0.2504466176,
0.4844662547,
0.5163316131,
0.5158627629,
0.4258413613,
1.0168442726,
-0.3451899886,
0.8893424869,
-0.2483077347,
-0.3729411066,
-0.0491501279,
-1.0572191477,
-1.1209118366,
-0.1702049077,
-0.3944462538,
-0.7747177482,
0.2932622731,
0.6602876782,
0.4323806167,
-0.7257460952,
0.1014875397,
-0.0558611229,
-0.017268924,
-0.1385522187,
-0.2096663117,
0.2395571917,
-0.0448171981,
-0.4255610108,
0.6408632994,
0.054571934,
0.0823350474,
-0.6916683316,
-0.0808875933,
0.0489486158,
0.4059070051,
0.4608736038,
0.278682977,
-1.0527822971,
-0.4420378208,
0.1334994435,
-0.1398982555,
-0.2719652355,
0.5957342982,
-0.4080539346,
0.6351633072,
0.2747047842,
0.5818630457,
-0.15177086,
0.0790881962,
0.7617093921,
-0.6459388137,
-0.0586308092,
0.1712707132,
0.3066710234,
0.4602918923,
-0.6416394114,
0.2607026398,
-0.0709690824,
-0.6828053594,
-0.8718210459,
0.2489564568,
-0.8590472937,
-0.2293591052,
1.2837257385,
-0.6039663553,
-0.3918751478,
-0.0289656594,
-0.0502401441,
0.1903109401,
-0.3937244713,
0.6622764468,
0.6856062412,
0.0308169369,
0.2788621485,
-0.533053875,
0.4119524658,
0.0885256454,
-0.629893899,
0.1799627692,
0.2533507049,
0.13508223,
0.3890474141,
0.270884335,
-0.3270190954,
0.3505245447,
0.182036981,
-0.3318964839,
-0.5925127268,
-0.3805710673,
-0.661463201,
0.3841007352,
0.3335255384,
-0.3088851869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09443v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09443v1
|
Subtle Misogyny Detection and Mitigation: An Expert-Annotated Dataset
| 2023-11-15T23:27:19 | 2023-11-15T23:27:19 |
Brooklyn Sheppard, Anna Richter, Allison Cohen, Elizabeth Allyn Smith, Tamara Kneese, Carolyne Pelletier, Ioana Baldini, Yue Dong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Using novel approaches to dataset development, the Biasly dataset captures
the nuance and subtlety of misogyny in ways that are unique within the
literature. Built in collaboration with multi-disciplinary experts and
annotators themselves, the dataset contains annotations of movie subtitles,
capturing colloquial expressions of misogyny in North American film. The
dataset can be used for a range of NLP tasks, including classification,
severity score regression, and text generation for rewrites. In this paper, we
discuss the methodology used, analyze the annotations obtained, and provide
baselines using common NLP algorithms in the context of misogyny detection and
mitigation. We hope this work will promote AI for social good in NLP for bias
detection, explanation, and removal.
|
[
-0.4208499491,
-0.8932016492,
0.091018945,
0.0357041992,
-0.044892367,
0.1344187707,
0.1387135535,
-0.2614825666,
0.2483851612,
0.5221876502,
-0.8630309105,
-0.4179852903,
-0.612124145,
0.1508745998,
-0.6575484276,
1.3612160683,
0.3361423314,
0.1747685969,
-0.1219543889,
-0.2061372548,
-0.5842075944,
-0.2337802351,
-0.284601897,
-0.2479203492,
0.3266536295,
0.3888932467,
0.9686105847,
0.6579392552,
0.5022409558,
0.1196411103,
0.018335456,
0.1978438646,
-0.5294669271,
0.2911190987,
-0.3691934049,
-0.3349964321,
-0.0820047408,
0.0426372476,
0.43538028,
0.89726758,
0.065428935,
0.5515540838,
-0.075973317,
0.6778257489,
-0.7570905685,
-0.0266178101,
-0.5739147067,
0.5246583819,
-0.6741130352,
-0.0228958242,
-0.0927687585,
-0.4207552671,
0.1244256422,
-0.4855914116,
0.6458749175,
0.139954403,
0.509994328,
0.5016304255,
-0.3491474986,
-0.2404791415,
-0.7416901588,
0.9849228263,
-0.6074228287,
0.0757154375,
0.3030471504,
0.2340587676,
0.0786808059,
-0.2417852879,
-0.2494206876,
-0.0256288331,
-0.2111383826,
-0.3751328886,
-0.3746915162,
-0.3054171205,
0.5397865772,
0.3917043209,
-0.4535109997,
-0.0241389927,
-0.3771662414,
-0.4801857471,
0.760530889,
-0.0114531629,
0.297044605,
-0.3104165196,
-0.0112428255,
0.3167151511,
-0.4840614498,
-0.4441609681,
0.711125195,
0.2022109181,
-0.0032894134,
0.6059798598,
-0.1961062104,
0.1603690386,
-0.0663486496,
0.0436663665,
0.4217829406,
-0.4505895674,
-0.1429565698,
0.1618563682,
0.5295547843,
0.6230666041,
0.6166496277,
-0.0165554937,
-0.2386793047,
0.4240404963,
0.2092508078,
-0.1555925608,
-0.3209460378,
-0.0523902178,
-0.4813500345,
-0.7297508717,
-0.3570590317,
-1.0160702467,
-0.8997665048,
-0.4240643978,
0.2101013809,
-0.162365064,
-0.2583644688,
-0.3852819502,
-0.6967829466,
0.183757633,
0.2353382409,
-0.6969204545,
0.2146836519,
0.3207258582,
0.4996297359,
0.1060700938,
-0.009717159,
-0.4120829701,
0.1828964204,
-0.5939864516,
0.3493531942,
-0.4971576631,
-0.0480494313,
0.2719261348,
-0.3278276324,
0.3014289141,
-0.4499646425,
0.7885761857,
0.0568807945,
0.0709439367,
-0.3832263052,
-0.232377395,
0.013057732,
0.1584208757,
-0.7962599397,
1.0370932817,
0.0108381324,
-1.1946070194,
0.5335679054,
-0.4504574239,
-0.3301021159,
-0.1359649003,
-0.2777305245,
-0.390647769,
0.1840878725,
0.615567565,
0.2526781559,
-0.1837626249,
0.5526789427,
-0.250115633,
-0.4125373363,
0.1716840118,
-0.4433583915,
0.6029927135,
0.1754027456,
-0.3936674893,
-0.0953154713,
-0.6004021168,
-0.3646219075,
0.0204966757,
0.2592164278,
-0.5778237581,
-0.1187462285,
0.178289026,
0.0816872194,
0.0542023331,
-0.1924937516,
0.0652569607,
-0.0302418638,
0.1626928449,
0.8640818596,
0.0738543421,
0.6412032247,
-0.1842830181,
0.3822471499,
-0.0974454284,
0.5098508,
0.1012236029,
-0.4159380198,
-0.8543357253,
0.0568683073,
0.2297152579,
0.6086130738,
-0.9703083634,
0.1684654057,
0.0882506073,
-0.3290167451,
-0.6528812051,
0.269353658,
0.6066248417,
0.4861782491,
0.4550217986,
-0.148630172,
-0.7396977544,
-1.4195895195,
-0.8065046072,
0.1097413749,
0.0271805581,
0.1183155999,
0.6417945623,
-0.2857505679,
0.9162116051,
-0.4374231994,
-0.5934794545,
-0.2466453165,
0.5793896914,
0.0268109702,
0.5300445557,
0.604452312,
-0.7708328366,
-0.101816535,
-0.4002305269,
-0.8916327953,
-0.6039164662,
-0.072745584,
-0.2403056622,
0.0371389017,
0.8319351077,
-0.1935320497,
0.6343096495,
0.0672517717,
-0.1564072073,
0.6674824953,
0.3054739535,
0.1986526251,
-0.646948576,
0.0175682511,
0.2938809395,
-0.1483741403,
-0.6431086659,
-0.1146983281,
-0.3561584353,
0.176655829,
-0.2423405796,
0.3894086778,
-0.2562210858,
-0.1574524492,
0.1375259757,
0.0836491063,
-0.0878135487,
0.4141303003,
-0.1659657061,
0.3855760694,
0.343167603,
-0.4961469471,
0.1674818248,
0.3314225972,
0.0859572068,
0.6235821843,
-0.4756521285,
0.2240329981,
-0.6066239476,
0.1151982918,
-0.8520692587,
-0.3805740774,
0.4464110434,
-0.3896387815,
0.0548177883,
-0.5401951075,
-0.5126266479,
-0.172001332,
-0.6379718184,
0.2830558419,
-0.05309375,
-0.2608478367,
0.466803968,
0.5143799186,
-0.1446118951,
-1.0317360163,
-0.8854988813,
0.0399598442,
-0.3357570767,
-0.3563192785,
0.187091887,
0.1060861349,
-0.5134339929,
-0.3384836018,
0.0395035446,
-0.2107861936,
-0.1077469885,
0.0574738309,
0.1922918558,
0.3294351101,
0.3618730605,
0.455177635,
-0.0125220623,
0.1275708526,
0.2481779307,
0.4700210094,
0.1616870016,
0.0096220914,
-0.1498433948,
0.7476483583,
0.087929517,
-0.0381410196,
0.4656486213,
1.2728021145,
-0.5217113495,
-0.2002033889,
-0.6170110106,
-0.2995087802,
-0.3682258427,
0.4003846049,
-0.1540421695,
-0.654266715,
0.6101542115,
0.0878854394,
0.0872651413,
0.4740180671,
0.0706310719,
-0.1081900522,
0.8578323126,
0.6686732769,
-0.3517001867,
0.4641901851,
-0.1835225224,
0.1278400272,
-0.6961749196,
-0.0337457694,
-0.7231438756,
-0.3977458179,
-0.7045637965,
-0.3422656357,
0.1707318127,
0.1077139974,
-0.280382216,
0.0287655964,
-0.6780421138,
0.4976693988,
0.6317776442,
0.0663427785,
0.2521242499,
-0.0587890521,
0.0696250573,
-0.5237936974,
-0.4299101233,
-0.6362127662,
1.12570858,
0.5071827769,
0.8134717941,
0.3943808079,
0.4383095801,
0.9680168629,
0.1694965214,
-0.3322529793,
0.4952720106,
-0.2591283321,
-0.9978073239,
-0.1625457257,
-0.3656845987,
-0.4354549646,
-0.1646949202,
-0.3976667225,
-0.7185450196,
0.2671734095,
0.217482537,
0.1337958276,
-0.0473276898,
-0.8314406872,
0.8662884831,
0.2430297583,
-0.3671497703,
0.0842960626,
-0.9404834509,
0.6689553857,
0.0314879194,
0.4411260784,
-0.1402614117,
0.1489214599,
1.0310516357,
-0.060592331,
1.0383154154,
-0.2899569273,
0.1487573832,
0.0658081025,
0.2835799456,
0.2630498409,
0.1935962141,
0.0578764081,
0.3938083947,
-0.3569553196,
-0.2532501519,
-0.176802963,
0.5448053479,
-0.5308297873,
-0.1848383546,
-0.3596269786,
-0.5126748681,
-0.0291305035,
0.0707379803,
0.1954865307,
0.3080418706,
-0.1160095185,
-0.1732514203,
0.7289890647,
-0.3987811208,
0.3844795525,
0.1257841438,
-0.3504687846,
-0.3730026782,
0.4740362763,
0.1749304235,
-0.0218100678,
0.3282438219,
0.1550591588,
-0.3648733199,
-0.2604392469,
-0.4044302106,
0.1037376001,
-0.9821343422,
-0.1881938428,
-0.5405588746,
-0.054151468,
-0.6912187338,
-0.1688548774,
-0.2611451745,
-0.3953162432,
-0.0971759781,
-0.4008080959,
0.5708693266,
0.7790923119,
-0.0630062073,
0.3534124792,
-0.3699502349,
0.457249999,
0.2514331639,
-0.0662187189,
-0.255382061,
-0.4949351549,
-0.0814912617,
-0.2527868748,
-0.3231530786,
-0.9547123313,
0.5500586033,
0.2041990161,
0.5517883897,
0.1467716098,
0.0293084066,
0.4456419647,
-0.1800112277,
0.8219873309,
-0.0176543202,
-1.2536394596,
1.0523535013,
-0.4321047068,
0.0771510378,
0.8020496964,
0.3887505531,
-0.5080358386,
-0.4267250001,
-0.6052420139,
-0.9264137149,
0.6180794239,
0.5792701244,
0.0947812125,
0.1744630486,
0.4815223813,
0.3278287649,
0.7810912132,
-0.8274353147,
-0.731847167,
-0.0494141765,
-0.316177398,
-0.0034148062,
-0.2409113348,
-0.3937631845,
-0.1533653438,
0.6294253469,
-0.2336669862,
0.213321507,
0.2964477241,
-0.3700646162,
-0.0466139764,
0.2014186829,
0.3602104485,
0.4975271225,
-0.3878587782,
0.1422160417,
0.086857833,
-0.6089766026,
-0.1279990077,
0.0240088496,
-0.4704245925,
0.4498994946,
0.6229978204,
0.5589782,
-0.1096738428,
-0.2720540166,
0.4827976227,
0.0393129699,
0.0803403258,
-0.3917863965,
-0.0230404828,
-0.3478703797,
0.0206390768,
0.6182110906,
0.4123341739,
0.6914815307,
-0.5474832058,
0.3154622614,
0.3702670038,
-0.5914016962,
0.0481523611,
0.4707933068,
0.1748233885,
-0.1197479069,
0.3760893643,
-0.1310777068,
-0.5929524302,
0.4995248318,
0.0377592742,
0.6984890699,
-0.3841920197,
0.4268797636,
0.3731554151,
0.6672676206,
0.1512899399,
0.0883872807,
0.1357566863,
-0.8088374734,
-0.2378568947,
-0.4382077456,
-0.260502696,
0.1592857838,
-0.6438368559,
0.4793706238,
-0.4791126847,
-0.0147197256,
0.3859528005,
-0.1592389047,
-0.6796777248,
0.2248944193,
0.2170146257,
0.6565182805,
-1.4646764994,
0.3898636997,
0.3959086239,
-0.611268878,
-0.5858279467,
0.0562264249,
0.2747269571,
-0.4631326199,
0.562735796,
0.2740004659,
0.1201603338,
-0.3263598979,
-0.6819537282,
-0.4301026165,
0.7079338431,
0.4804118276,
-0.5824776888,
0.0076466966,
0.1960600168,
0.47241956,
-0.3221399188,
0.5259745121,
0.8209189177,
0.5555059314,
-0.4196134806,
-0.8473141193,
-0.0489106216,
-0.2472355217,
-0.0336565413,
0.1250258088,
-0.165544793,
0.7473852038,
0.0304541029,
0.1539105922,
-0.314661622,
0.3853811622,
0.2856613696,
0.7577931285,
0.5411733389,
0.4343270659,
0.6870177984,
-0.2114579678,
0.8124838471,
0.5287590027,
0.2271760255,
1.0914320946,
-0.0227425452,
0.116997838,
0.6898008585,
-0.1289079338,
0.284943521,
0.5119318366,
0.1160000563,
0.4489552677,
0.3754998744,
-0.098610349,
-0.1058419496,
-0.6552984118,
-0.2998574376,
0.3043998778,
0.3931213915,
-0.6891202331,
-0.3165494204,
-0.0091906115,
0.1056990102,
0.2234633565,
-0.5064561963,
0.5624501109,
0.0497876666,
-0.2591140866,
0.0767469034,
-0.1711569428,
0.9077971578,
-0.3135561645,
-0.26385355,
-0.3837772608,
-0.0458246954,
-0.5712599754,
-0.6469805241,
0.4498856962,
0.0758935288,
-0.5843942761,
0.0605786853,
0.9982641935,
-0.4665378034,
-0.5874255896,
0.1469082236,
0.4643702209,
0.321303755,
-0.1048236713,
-0.9295579195,
0.1046007127,
0.2249609828,
0.2986727357,
-0.0212098565,
0.4442181289,
-0.3881099522,
0.731372714,
0.5441691875,
-0.1928797364,
0.1081333607,
0.692696631,
0.777443707,
-0.5828117728,
-0.2334335297,
-0.7284001708,
0.52967906,
-0.5064852238,
-0.5820843577,
0.7624441385,
0.4498564899,
0.6859027147,
-0.2406169921,
0.8454131484,
-0.0676194206,
0.7054166794,
-0.348374784,
0.4639989436,
-0.213000834,
0.4986388683,
-0.9194127917,
-0.9861357808,
-0.5223845243,
0.6317905784,
-0.3358677924,
0.281904608,
0.4450909197,
0.942037046,
0.0438144468,
0.1379662305,
0.1535168737,
0.162654072,
0.3310557902,
0.0954755768,
0.8859264255,
-0.7012071609,
0.445179224,
-0.3320302069,
-0.1682391763,
-0.343251735,
-1.0159255266,
-0.8656259179,
-0.2996201813,
-0.8536467552,
-0.2787743509,
0.2218236178,
0.6881297827,
0.5155978203,
-0.5244013071,
0.2115580142,
-0.241676867,
0.4262295663,
-0.3304628134,
-0.3730538785,
0.1482261717,
-0.0587193817,
-0.6997987628,
0.168302685,
0.0023652439,
-0.2385975122,
-0.5825716853,
0.1709018946,
-0.3637659848,
0.0703790933,
0.2287697047,
-0.2475877851,
-0.402348727,
-0.3772704303,
-0.3071115017,
-0.0176728405,
-0.3676164746,
0.6872807145,
-0.4420689046,
0.3140205145,
0.3787262738,
0.1846936196,
0.1975271702,
-0.1078852862,
0.6688088179,
-1.4876972437,
0.0264154505,
0.3849946856,
0.3188562691,
0.6732155681,
-0.6803660393,
0.7650797367,
0.3326002061,
-0.4177570641,
-0.9201382399,
0.3295595348,
-1.0612776279,
-0.141557917,
1.0026940107,
0.1079847068,
-0.164025262,
-0.5843873024,
-0.4021979272,
0.3397427797,
-0.6641998887,
0.7235338092,
0.7956604958,
-0.0698761642,
-0.2231535017,
-0.7034432292,
0.7615897655,
0.4576552808,
-0.5801596045,
0.2609312236,
0.5435454249,
0.2298709899,
0.4285617173,
0.5537180901,
-0.0847833231,
0.1046126932,
0.0033151028,
0.3539001346,
0.2477088869,
-0.3624415994,
-0.2881194353,
-0.0815884545,
-0.3794059455,
-0.1587079465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09438v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09438v2
|
Labeled Interactive Topic Models
| 2023-11-15T23:18:01 | 2024-02-07T14:41:40 |
Kyle Seelman, Mozhi Zhang, Jordan Boyd-Graber
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR
|
Topic models are valuable for understanding extensive document collections,
but they don't always identify the most relevant topics. Classical
probabilistic and anchor-based topic models offer interactive versions that
allow users to guide the models towards more pertinent topics. However, such
interactive features have been lacking in neural topic models. To correct this
lacuna, we introduce a user-friendly interaction for neural topic models. This
interaction permits users to assign a word label to a topic, leading to an
update in the topic model where the words in the topic become closely aligned
with the given label. Our approach encompasses two distinct kinds of neural
topic models. The first includes models where topic embeddings are trainable
and evolve during the training process. The second kind involves models where
topic embeddings are integrated post-training, offering a different approach to
topic refinement. To facilitate user interaction with these neural topic
models, we have developed an interactive interface. This interface enables
users to engage with and re-label topics as desired. We evaluate our method
through a human study, where users can relabel topics to find relevant
documents. Using our method, user labeling improves document rank scores,
helping to find more relevant documents to a given query when compared to no
user labeling.
|
[
-0.3458913565,
-0.827288568,
0.6554532647,
0.0835618302,
-0.1220695749,
0.0634518266,
-0.2472915649,
-0.224023819,
0.6138818264,
0.3367224634,
-0.4434341192,
-0.4761902392,
-0.522777319,
-0.3969060779,
-0.2892741859,
0.8892729282,
0.1754769236,
0.0674116239,
-0.627035141,
0.0287915729,
-0.2935094535,
-0.5504021049,
-0.9009609222,
-0.6723729372,
0.9684619308,
0.0792774782,
0.8007130623,
0.6111884713,
0.4889017344,
0.4086666405,
-0.5456777215,
0.0589208603,
-0.2456371486,
0.4560109973,
-0.4211717546,
-0.4018978179,
-0.5520136952,
0.2458218932,
0.132555455,
1.0140720606,
0.0688202083,
-0.1898265332,
0.0250740666,
0.0792928785,
-0.209939003,
0.0754728392,
-0.2414162606,
0.0782577842,
-0.2238628268,
-0.3775405288,
-0.3714025319,
-0.2135171741,
0.4904016256,
-0.852006197,
0.1018985584,
-0.1071938649,
0.7597747445,
0.2218996882,
-0.5052933097,
-0.3016120493,
-0.3400559723,
0.3921732306,
-0.6271033287,
0.2937434614,
0.6074584723,
0.0111359861,
-0.221787557,
-1.1690876484,
-0.3445761502,
-0.4339589775,
-0.133619681,
0.1932106018,
-0.1398000121,
0.1825891435,
0.1884287745,
-0.0057360018,
-0.0203404855,
0.3762529194,
0.0339370035,
-0.1752925068,
0.496619314,
0.2119513154,
0.5001656413,
-0.168163538,
-0.1227164343,
0.0813036785,
-0.3749421239,
-0.0905167982,
0.6585214734,
0.1852640659,
0.0827761143,
0.6073493958,
-0.1916728318,
1.0307644606,
0.2203273028,
0.1310511976,
0.1506755948,
-0.1463993192,
0.2418986857,
-0.1082293242,
0.4205906391,
0.3126814663,
-0.0895595104,
-0.2579098642,
-0.0469955616,
-0.58205688,
0.6099154353,
-0.6151483655,
-0.3908684552,
0.2728396654,
-0.5820424557,
-0.4973349571,
-0.036027059,
-0.4975067675,
-0.6837267876,
-0.6654163003,
0.6726475954,
-0.2918682098,
-0.0960989818,
-0.0955040455,
-0.2459688485,
-0.2782625258,
0.8926157355,
-1.0733159781,
0.0688139275,
0.7567536831,
0.6666669846,
-0.1347379684,
-0.3281235695,
-0.3589222729,
0.118463777,
-0.0231775437,
0.7986413836,
-0.609800756,
-0.2782967389,
0.0532474518,
-0.0349527486,
0.0222705808,
-0.2257916182,
0.2616946995,
-0.8357476592,
0.3291369975,
-0.3357357085,
-0.7521747947,
-0.1970538646,
0.3734649122,
-0.6266800165,
0.699816227,
0.0466568433,
-1.0344152451,
0.1563137025,
-0.862754643,
-0.0830971673,
-0.0415304117,
-0.1394003034,
-0.0648323074,
-0.0890991911,
-0.1786309481,
0.2354897112,
-0.0141166616,
0.6221522689,
-0.3694304824,
-0.2695239782,
0.5115150213,
-0.3442818522,
0.5877180099,
0.1473979354,
-0.0346218087,
0.5487034917,
-0.4832347631,
-0.2095843405,
-0.3092229366,
-0.4967877269,
-0.4950457811,
0.1016428769,
0.0561685488,
-0.0836200789,
0.6322774291,
-0.2490863949,
0.6744900346,
-0.1364388466,
0.4876916707,
0.5129871964,
0.3507457376,
0.4666213691,
-0.1940943599,
0.3106695414,
0.050733991,
-0.0614208467,
-0.3556766212,
-0.8152335286,
-0.8165434599,
-0.0872728601,
0.9682169557,
0.3832712471,
-0.6099728942,
0.4446295798,
0.0869752541,
-0.3679892123,
-0.5765803456,
0.0059239399,
0.1167004704,
0.6864674687,
0.3187224269,
-0.3493913114,
-0.030406829,
-0.9503293633,
-0.0336391889,
-0.0775060877,
-0.244430393,
0.3899304867,
0.2555194795,
-0.1233323961,
1.1157956123,
-0.7311339974,
-0.0529151149,
0.0854671448,
0.9757906199,
-0.0397597663,
0.4632180631,
0.1852297038,
-0.9945804477,
-0.3897555172,
0.0561177321,
-0.771861434,
-0.2440837175,
-0.2886265218,
-0.1153597981,
-0.1968186647,
0.7490140796,
-0.444140017,
0.595630765,
-0.2519122362,
-0.1901582927,
-0.0327865779,
-0.6841593385,
0.1215577796,
-1.0309582949,
0.0328141078,
0.0465672985,
0.0109616332,
-0.701870501,
0.0863426998,
0.1362591237,
-0.5117794871,
-0.5166983604,
0.7198317051,
-0.504884541,
-0.0024317498,
-0.5392338037,
0.2758727372,
0.0747684762,
0.5222194791,
0.4548861086,
0.4527062774,
0.4024377167,
-0.1733182073,
0.2356767654,
0.509763062,
-0.0617155768,
0.2480123341,
-0.6556637287,
0.2201114297,
-0.1424238235,
0.075737536,
-1.0507587194,
-0.234545514,
0.2961370945,
-0.3532841802,
0.7774089575,
-0.357110709,
-0.3777277768,
0.2294983864,
-0.3183634579,
-0.017100621,
-0.0091482317,
-0.4868611991,
0.5056260824,
0.4003278315,
-0.4540706873,
-0.3283425868,
-0.4691268802,
0.2915044725,
-0.2849027812,
-0.6921356916,
0.6656242013,
-0.0210341215,
-0.1065603197,
0.3310335577,
0.2421482056,
-0.2561757565,
0.2241611928,
0.335732609,
-0.1190033332,
0.0219761506,
0.619667232,
0.1362501234,
-0.3687473238,
-0.2558303177,
0.0385680124,
0.3519013226,
-0.0247376002,
-0.4542601407,
-0.3522160947,
0.5926665068,
0.3116851747,
-0.5299543738,
0.7016469836,
0.6715993881,
-0.5879811049,
0.3325071335,
-0.3729901016,
-0.3123089373,
-0.463613838,
0.293559432,
-0.3791001737,
-0.821549952,
0.456366539,
-0.3960263729,
0.00914538,
0.3135379255,
0.4401144981,
-0.619781673,
0.7780652046,
0.736132443,
0.3089033961,
0.4552555978,
-0.1704507768,
0.2163252831,
-1.0774004459,
-0.6204544902,
-0.5058720708,
-0.631847918,
-0.3814561963,
-0.2041838765,
0.0248665363,
0.3119657934,
0.0245312806,
0.2725410461,
-0.6543167233,
0.0426096879,
0.7990339398,
0.2575067878,
0.109358646,
-0.0805963725,
0.0113018779,
-0.3712315559,
-0.6532249451,
-0.529293716,
0.7273964882,
0.3944478631,
0.9694232345,
0.1021999046,
0.8190492392,
0.5620229244,
0.5931773782,
-0.6771850586,
0.4705488682,
-0.0632347912,
-0.5365017056,
-0.4726706743,
-0.0610453337,
-1.0963770151,
0.1027483195,
-0.5776972771,
-1.1404861212,
0.5547381639,
0.1592092216,
-0.498565495,
0.1412807405,
-0.8620967865,
0.9532956481,
-0.4520475268,
-0.7109346986,
-0.0400357544,
-0.4863720834,
-0.0855980664,
-0.1851073653,
-0.2559053898,
0.0359982513,
-0.5425741076,
0.8592804074,
-0.4104339182,
1.1310867071,
-0.0484313741,
0.0654476508,
0.2218800336,
-0.1788887978,
0.0508278869,
0.1062520593,
-0.3115516007,
-0.1032425091,
-0.4800924659,
-0.0563624054,
-0.7343825698,
1.0690202713,
-0.8163494468,
-1.072009325,
-0.4545645714,
-0.6829372644,
-0.0377025977,
0.3361581266,
0.062380448,
0.6173605919,
-0.0328493901,
0.3373541832,
0.8180081248,
-0.3903774321,
0.30986166,
0.4104056954,
-0.1804549843,
-0.3466005325,
0.9155275822,
0.4312068224,
-0.2243903428,
0.5736154318,
0.1797010452,
-0.5082992315,
-0.5618245006,
-0.0235324241,
0.0744163916,
-0.7625675201,
0.1371518523,
-0.955447495,
-0.3355741501,
-0.2208871096,
-0.3577674925,
0.0167077519,
-0.6260794401,
-0.8762825727,
-0.1768119186,
0.5263645053,
0.5311790109,
-0.2345347703,
0.65026474,
-0.6056435704,
0.3930538595,
0.4771217704,
0.3509986103,
0.1200760528,
-0.6310642362,
-0.0088730706,
-0.1245067716,
-0.6481078863,
-1.2945502996,
0.2098230571,
0.04423967,
0.9528377652,
0.5003959537,
0.0839408934,
0.200835675,
-0.2772887051,
0.5068099499,
0.0009285384,
-0.6720225811,
0.7152051926,
-0.5594175458,
0.2617402375,
0.6288505197,
0.8547421694,
-0.4592063427,
-0.1053249165,
-0.8594615459,
-1.1541540623,
0.8043106198,
0.0373367406,
0.2987557054,
-0.1362402737,
0.5133054256,
-0.0189143065,
0.422327131,
-0.398430407,
-0.2315083742,
-0.2602126002,
-0.0227891952,
0.2138000727,
-0.3941610754,
-0.0804642811,
-0.214575097,
0.6433433294,
0.0707107112,
0.0718442872,
0.0553527325,
0.0843789503,
0.2259103656,
0.0205587037,
0.4545831382,
0.689083755,
-0.7782407403,
0.1191126555,
-0.2777129114,
-0.119763568,
0.1044981107,
0.559501946,
-0.3507151008,
0.0223352741,
0.1536623836,
0.8390053511,
0.5588995814,
-0.2681216896,
0.2360898703,
-0.1568706036,
-0.1267195642,
-0.1007502452,
0.0992290154,
1.0288938284,
0.2070964426,
0.0864444524,
0.0171559267,
0.1326022595,
-0.5456818938,
0.3731014431,
0.0991967916,
-0.7074381113,
0.0600989312,
1.0129506588,
0.6731993556,
-1.0553830862,
1.0112657547,
0.0927240252,
-0.4783793092,
0.673366189,
0.2155569345,
0.6777248383,
0.0640163571,
0.4168908596,
0.340559721,
0.0832044706,
0.1929721236,
0.1158921048,
-0.2569147646,
-0.5294519067,
-0.1597783267,
-0.2823599875,
-0.7849836946,
0.3353852034,
-0.7838409543,
0.2592525184,
-0.1304936409,
-0.6024035811,
0.6113213897,
0.0788041875,
-0.2161822766,
0.2647278905,
-0.0909182802,
1.2201006413,
-0.7486038804,
0.9296765924,
1.0083554983,
-0.5494958758,
-0.1548291892,
0.0143192429,
-0.1282276362,
-0.0433810577,
0.5425286889,
0.0174310692,
0.4065741599,
0.1383736432,
-0.3943643272,
-0.7578793764,
1.005289793,
0.1509966105,
-0.1189568192,
0.1771346182,
-0.1622264981,
0.7626946568,
-0.2434439808,
0.6600523591,
-0.0594003201,
0.620634973,
0.05605397,
-0.2841930985,
-0.24309735,
-0.4275452793,
-0.0872667581,
0.1501212865,
-0.6262770891,
0.6149339676,
-0.1627346873,
0.4105205536,
0.1611044854,
1.0423541069,
0.1040152907,
0.4512340426,
0.4229258001,
0.4906180501,
0.8195910454,
-0.3289530575,
0.9343626499,
-0.2161326855,
0.0941329375,
1.376634717,
-0.2349410057,
0.8417143822,
0.5404990315,
0.1081064567,
0.0100070462,
1.202849865,
-0.1196379662,
0.619740963,
0.4906619787,
-0.3526535332,
-0.5028632879,
-0.3358614445,
-0.5022349954,
0.1134478152,
0.5585026741,
-0.166878745,
-0.3619049489,
-0.1405325383,
-0.1103320718,
0.1885279268,
0.0013097825,
0.580252707,
0.0796199739,
-0.6274610162,
-0.084281981,
0.3065904975,
0.5802106261,
-0.8259209991,
-0.2880985141,
-0.4235890806,
-0.2253948599,
-0.2304130197,
-0.9935563803,
0.0743263513,
-0.1176810786,
-0.4042791426,
-0.3210806847,
0.9827371836,
-0.6204890013,
-0.2635486126,
0.1261048317,
0.4048268199,
0.3486852646,
0.1873075217,
-0.6250026226,
-0.0933001116,
0.1731045097,
-0.6052210927,
0.724486351,
0.2482698709,
-0.4099884033,
0.8230309486,
0.5982378125,
-0.2001390159,
-0.0111060636,
0.1731497645,
0.819211781,
-0.4912754595,
-0.4982922375,
-0.185080111,
0.5427945256,
-0.3342631459,
-0.4726793468,
0.3823081553,
0.3113660514,
0.5085467696,
-0.1535884738,
0.4869457185,
0.019844722,
0.3177852631,
-0.3172011673,
1.0647588968,
-0.8496234417,
0.4225548506,
0.159824267,
-0.7599506378,
-0.1427148432,
0.4650120437,
-0.451366812,
0.0870258883,
0.3173704445,
0.6377652884,
-0.4023327827,
-0.0477741174,
0.2699274421,
0.0378534868,
0.1694375575,
0.0258531701,
1.0196381807,
0.0540334173,
0.172101289,
-0.5605458021,
-0.3116793931,
-0.3703469932,
-1.1758178473,
-0.7544906139,
-0.5990210176,
-0.9014062881,
0.0772744119,
0.2842001915,
0.488995254,
0.7208805084,
-0.4528572857,
0.0129453624,
0.4415402412,
0.3094074726,
0.0422219001,
-0.2072066069,
0.7247319818,
-0.1569108069,
-0.766242981,
0.4417966604,
0.148894757,
0.1010175794,
-0.1026333645,
0.1564688981,
-0.6368564367,
-0.0547368526,
0.1121757329,
0.4239757955,
-0.5184375048,
-0.1546435058,
-0.0942447633,
-0.1696517915,
-0.1386887282,
0.7274686098,
-0.651645124,
0.7272760272,
0.7700273991,
0.8307961226,
0.8127651215,
0.2135934383,
0.5961130857,
-0.7047610879,
0.1109995469,
-0.0276034698,
0.4206941724,
0.3151865602,
-0.5516802669,
0.4984002709,
-0.0596420728,
-0.3376275599,
-0.4223843515,
-0.0246666539,
-1.1656464338,
-0.4124404192,
0.8442912698,
-0.4734301865,
0.0247711521,
-0.2729427516,
-0.4031222165,
0.2651162446,
-0.3461227417,
0.7878895402,
0.7574290633,
-0.2171295136,
-0.1502173841,
-0.5562711954,
0.1696373969,
0.3197670579,
-0.7828222513,
-0.3606140912,
0.3039526939,
0.1792155504,
0.4176282287,
0.6176363826,
0.1610687375,
0.1763722152,
-0.0823070705,
0.2392372787,
-0.4969208837,
-0.4590584338,
-0.2752868235,
0.1847641021,
0.1670392007,
-0.2784694135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09433v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09433v2
|
Backdoor Activation Attack: Attack Large Language Models using Activation Steering for Safety-Alignment
| 2023-11-15T23:07:40 | 2023-11-24T16:22:41 |
Haoran Wang, Kai Shu
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
To ensure AI safety, instruction-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs) are
specifically trained to ensure alignment, which refers to making models behave
in accordance with human intentions. While these models have demonstrated
commendable results on various safety benchmarks, the vulnerability of their
safety alignment has not been extensively studied. This is particularly
troubling given the potential harm that LLMs can inflict. Existing attack
methods on LLMs often rely on poisoned training data or the injection of
malicious prompts. These approaches compromise the stealthiness and
generalizability of the attacks, making them susceptible to detection.
Additionally, these models often demand substantial computational resources for
implementation, making them less practical for real-world applications.
Inspired by recent success in modifying model behavior through steering vectors
without the need for optimization, and drawing on its effectiveness in
red-teaming LLMs, we conducted experiments employing activation steering to
target four key aspects of LLMs: truthfulness, toxicity, bias, and harmfulness
- across a varied set of attack settings. To establish a universal attack
strategy applicable to diverse target alignments without depending on manual
analysis, we automatically select the intervention layer based on contrastive
layer search. Our experiment results show that activation attacks are highly
effective and add little or no overhead to attack efficiency. Additionally, we
discuss potential countermeasures against such activation attacks. Our code and
data are available at https://github.com/wang2226/Backdoor-Activation-Attack
Warning: this paper contains content that can be offensive or upsetting.
|
[
0.0247410852,
-0.9157616496,
0.3454264104,
0.2574408948,
0.017326152,
0.1539105326,
-0.125370577,
-0.3792679012,
-0.203931734,
0.4764664769,
-0.5875192285,
-0.6115333438,
-0.6542832851,
-0.2854054272,
-0.6240693927,
0.9660636187,
0.2076200694,
0.0229289848,
0.1916356534,
-0.1897089481,
-0.4958646894,
-0.4461854994,
-0.6736270785,
-0.2939529419,
0.5831151605,
0.1635079384,
0.9326823354,
0.4942092001,
0.5156958699,
0.3623431027,
0.0486992002,
-0.5170488358,
-0.6552056074,
0.3182170391,
-0.2003017962,
-0.4032129347,
-0.6841471791,
0.060689386,
0.6034510136,
0.4723024964,
-0.1039344296,
-0.0947082192,
0.0085707093,
0.5990099311,
-0.8750656843,
-0.270203203,
-0.9979425669,
0.0885812938,
-0.1424141675,
-0.0553657264,
-0.658968389,
-0.2218243033,
-0.0465649031,
-0.2966268659,
-0.1655366719,
0.1210601404,
0.631988883,
0.4319066405,
-0.3267199099,
-0.1497455686,
-0.44217664,
0.8718416095,
-0.6987570524,
0.4688070416,
0.0945307389,
0.0985099077,
-0.4506406486,
-0.2280404121,
-0.4975637197,
-0.3411049843,
-0.0454457179,
0.1394520998,
-0.3956544399,
0.3374861479,
0.256224364,
-0.022100227,
-0.7200646996,
0.7167804837,
-0.0845521986,
-0.1953519285,
0.654409349,
0.1070057973,
0.6106236577,
0.1329055578,
-0.5822089314,
-0.1449816227,
-1.0356209278,
-0.1572801322,
0.5916417837,
0.2239508331,
-0.3256310821,
0.658279717,
-0.0487652086,
0.7042326331,
0.2617330551,
0.0761086345,
0.1191256568,
-0.1383871883,
-0.2379375994,
0.267742157,
0.8600999713,
0.3313025236,
0.0184135959,
-0.4378687143,
-0.3617329299,
0.0067914468,
0.5638719797,
-0.6221154332,
0.1185959727,
0.6166052222,
-0.0483603999,
-0.7120531201,
-0.0034991822,
-0.7787495852,
-0.389763236,
0.2301870883,
0.4376690686,
-0.4801004529,
-0.144064799,
-0.1262493879,
0.0379515365,
0.8040620685,
-0.0586229376,
-1.0825865269,
0.0715732723,
1.0722242594,
0.5269066691,
-0.3416951001,
-0.5134885907,
-0.7016242146,
0.5506719947,
-0.4721861184,
0.3102289438,
-0.4861918688,
-0.1999168694,
0.1646845937,
-0.1829158217,
-0.1263695359,
-0.3569507003,
0.2305342704,
-0.9801929593,
0.0717295781,
0.1585230678,
-0.3249538839,
-0.1495088786,
0.4944103956,
-0.6705035567,
0.7289961576,
-0.342930913,
-0.7096857429,
0.0198082291,
-0.7456154227,
-0.6691473126,
-0.1485995054,
-0.2054467052,
-0.4866079092,
0.0905304402,
0.1306354403,
0.4744361341,
0.0415897481,
-0.0383001752,
-0.1311227381,
-0.2539376915,
0.4611602426,
-0.403693974,
0.993191421,
-0.1151010245,
-0.740378499,
0.4941917062,
-0.4966956377,
-0.0209548529,
0.2151665837,
-0.2592438459,
-0.3088469803,
-0.0815120116,
-0.4164739847,
0.0577545352,
0.3414538205,
-0.4134901166,
0.082138367,
-0.7129392028,
0.1029283255,
0.8585067391,
0.0181690548,
0.6629673839,
-0.1241260767,
0.6607077718,
-0.1386719197,
0.2592848837,
-0.0088500585,
-0.4679814279,
-0.4876997471,
-0.254796803,
0.2937892377,
0.7320181727,
-0.5816465616,
0.658300817,
-0.1582403481,
-0.5133020282,
-0.5316156149,
0.2445221394,
0.8759037256,
0.3572100699,
0.2565844059,
-0.0155296298,
-0.1660375148,
-0.8130671978,
-0.3745159805,
-0.0553599671,
0.119987838,
-0.0513523035,
0.4526731074,
-0.3709378242,
0.6224921346,
-0.2603310049,
-0.1125945821,
-0.2570762634,
0.1075867414,
-0.1050569639,
0.750985384,
0.481205225,
-0.8277693987,
-0.3300849497,
0.0222703684,
-0.7511609793,
-0.0808359906,
-0.1835344434,
-0.1613690704,
0.4395965934,
0.6747339964,
-0.6522877216,
0.4674701095,
1.0909636021,
-0.0622972287,
0.3029314876,
0.0939835832,
-0.0478752404,
-0.8183611631,
0.0366998725,
-0.0405494571,
0.1658990681,
-0.9713802934,
0.5362041593,
0.2076343,
-0.1731590182,
-0.673062861,
0.451939553,
-0.3848142326,
-0.0320459083,
-0.1886640638,
0.0977440923,
-0.3259910345,
0.6124359965,
-0.2398726344,
0.6792943478,
0.3829539418,
-0.3646985292,
0.3494681716,
-0.0408433415,
-0.0429711044,
0.4084730446,
-0.5872270465,
0.4206796885,
0.1081853956,
0.1435204744,
-1.1608759165,
-0.2353015244,
0.6390755177,
-0.4927582145,
0.7784790397,
-0.1161967963,
-0.2050264478,
0.1701808423,
-0.5603999496,
0.4043917358,
0.5403704047,
-0.6031099558,
0.7379418612,
0.4092378318,
-0.0399311259,
-0.9889870882,
-0.5501692295,
0.1530221403,
-0.3714764416,
-0.6859471202,
0.395909369,
0.0649358481,
-0.3025773168,
-0.2327331901,
-0.1233099699,
0.0464407355,
0.4470962286,
0.4545460343,
0.253390193,
-0.034560699,
-0.2218277156,
0.0449864343,
-0.3103002608,
0.2525622249,
-0.0935005099,
0.6354030371,
0.0439348705,
-0.675870955,
-0.740884006,
0.3871515393,
0.7946495414,
-0.1288055032,
0.8448214531,
0.3779838085,
-0.2094232291,
-0.0885688588,
-0.4927126169,
-0.4270939827,
-0.5698590875,
0.6189131141,
-0.057636492,
-0.5814961195,
0.1946392357,
0.0271410979,
0.4176619053,
0.1994417459,
0.5925301313,
-0.3048404455,
1.2290033102,
0.5329099894,
-0.4175056815,
0.4975587428,
-0.0977405012,
0.1144940928,
-0.7551444173,
-0.1435117424,
-0.4950494468,
-0.4499939382,
-0.4676816165,
-0.05668585,
0.2509711683,
-0.1543299109,
-0.4119954407,
0.1106233597,
-0.2965589464,
0.4318997562,
0.3172821701,
0.1484979242,
0.0585173406,
-0.0356557481,
-0.0803341046,
-0.0733840391,
-0.6652940512,
-0.2819865048,
1.0038425922,
0.6153275371,
1.1267015934,
0.2940429151,
0.7206551433,
0.0778220892,
0.3258645236,
-0.754847765,
0.6598690152,
0.1015632525,
-0.7163729072,
-0.5060620308,
-0.133211568,
-1.0950366259,
0.1215111092,
-0.3571582437,
-0.665967226,
-0.1930579245,
0.3343692124,
-0.260445267,
0.2888438106,
-0.7729994655,
0.9393242598,
-0.8026989102,
-0.4078999162,
-0.3033328652,
-0.8039429188,
0.4800679386,
-0.2579986155,
0.2000154853,
0.1778229922,
-0.1987686902,
0.6631161571,
-0.0644917637,
1.3434666395,
-0.06588348,
-0.4062811136,
-0.2613541782,
0.1818668842,
0.8433842659,
-0.3532783985,
0.0045114988,
0.3835096657,
-0.5649784803,
-0.4426775575,
-0.7102315426,
0.6716756821,
-0.6684043407,
-1.177968502,
-0.4307955801,
-0.5453162789,
-0.1980221868,
0.1853182018,
0.1081170812,
0.070419021,
-0.1651872694,
0.2230784297,
0.7141515017,
-0.3109151423,
0.4916370213,
0.4050607383,
-0.0640185028,
-0.3719896376,
0.9049074054,
-0.3272917271,
0.8354693055,
0.4075556993,
0.1010453999,
-0.0756316632,
-0.9806504846,
-0.3398139179,
0.2088002712,
-0.5780070424,
-0.2005154043,
-0.469412744,
-0.3861888349,
-0.4392479658,
-0.2889284492,
-0.4450311363,
-0.2149665952,
-0.0840406567,
-0.1500468999,
0.1082711443,
0.5534490943,
0.1039894372,
0.503420651,
-0.7826902866,
0.1470215917,
0.4121783972,
0.0488412715,
0.0115304608,
-0.3355720341,
-0.1365992576,
-0.0668319985,
-0.4781627059,
-1.102873683,
0.2756367326,
-0.186251387,
0.7109453082,
0.4668031931,
0.0502030253,
0.2760295272,
-0.5395054817,
0.6269506812,
0.3524080813,
-0.8715364337,
0.405531019,
-0.2292559296,
0.0879439414,
0.4452590942,
0.5297685266,
-0.2296680808,
-0.6226758957,
-0.5613240004,
-0.809052527,
0.4940657318,
0.1005021632,
0.2423129827,
0.3488076031,
0.2178342193,
-0.1990235448,
0.2104617059,
-0.7988223433,
-0.3795093,
0.0031093969,
-0.3208977878,
0.3152511418,
-0.3599790335,
-0.4272554815,
0.1502559483,
0.7327752709,
0.0616062433,
-0.0329687707,
-0.2094264179,
-0.2398312092,
-0.210045889,
0.3924894929,
0.6506114006,
0.376981318,
0.032111045,
0.0289128516,
0.3827799559,
-0.5695085526,
0.257514149,
-0.0477443486,
-0.2691348791,
-0.5041640401,
0.5500506759,
0.390222609,
0.6073799133,
-0.4743837416,
0.5997415781,
0.146698609,
0.1671378911,
-0.1501807868,
0.3369955719,
0.037030492,
0.2900540531,
0.1784838587,
-0.1475874037,
-0.3683721125,
-0.6124495268,
-0.0049623987,
1.0544077158,
-0.6188989878,
-0.3430787623,
0.4353635311,
0.4389842749,
-0.5430349112,
0.5625766516,
0.0080636656,
-0.939012289,
0.481465131,
0.6054093838,
0.9672384262,
-0.5416967869,
-0.2487518936,
-0.0735561699,
0.6654382348,
0.3067683578,
-0.0593115427,
0.2293805778,
-0.9901109934,
-0.3689895868,
-0.246795401,
-0.5155732632,
0.1894163936,
-0.3987265229,
0.1354218423,
-0.7337223887,
0.0405817665,
-0.2015358061,
-0.371283263,
-0.1319943517,
0.0268394258,
0.1741354167,
0.7134096026,
-0.7370590568,
0.8636632562,
0.5264642239,
-0.1193908602,
-0.557643652,
0.3816995919,
0.2997324765,
-1.0004013777,
0.9167584777,
0.0839756653,
-0.2014162689,
-0.0042823795,
-0.7402980328,
-0.6295945644,
0.9557603002,
0.3175669312,
-0.5639127493,
-0.2158737928,
0.0627514347,
0.1694277823,
-0.2025112808,
-0.2212974727,
0.7111089826,
0.6383857727,
0.0588789582,
-0.7002254128,
0.2888731062,
0.114914909,
-0.3144364357,
0.1857918501,
-0.6197716594,
0.6457558274,
-0.2438340485,
-0.2096500099,
0.0424163751,
0.5950704813,
0.5539340377,
0.196656093,
0.5065462589,
0.727995038,
0.4621527195,
0.0460552014,
0.9784550667,
-0.4180283844,
-0.1414418817,
1.0499054193,
-0.4475980699,
0.7712971568,
0.591548562,
0.1124686375,
0.3209472001,
0.0942770243,
-0.0305511598,
0.5805011988,
0.1486264914,
-0.2527113259,
-0.0306432601,
0.2593941689,
-0.3473079503,
0.3886355758,
0.529099822,
-0.2377073765,
-0.0704064816,
-0.2047581375,
0.2624207139,
0.0010428083,
-0.1875733137,
0.8217827678,
0.0046000076,
-0.6476117373,
0.5283452272,
-0.0701981187,
0.8012481332,
-0.791952908,
-0.0013668337,
0.0862730518,
0.1067888439,
-0.3748117983,
-0.652015686,
0.0160461757,
0.0095893499,
0.1009920165,
-0.0108390432,
0.6687122583,
-0.1703453362,
-0.1196679696,
0.4258113503,
0.119379729,
-0.2405564189,
0.1092203334,
-0.8366974592,
0.4336558878,
0.1133426726,
-0.3346550167,
0.5435593128,
0.1188267395,
0.0218485277,
0.7165148258,
0.7581879497,
0.172712937,
0.2680020332,
-0.2647123933,
0.8905783892,
-0.798097074,
-0.2979646027,
-1.0866234303,
0.5388375521,
-0.1067711636,
0.0311047342,
0.8488447666,
0.3282192945,
0.6946086287,
0.2300044298,
0.7338721752,
0.3471970856,
0.0506140031,
-0.8465002179,
1.0167820454,
-0.3212557435,
0.5822066069,
-0.3311787546,
-0.6611099243,
-0.5020204782,
0.2849100828,
-0.5097233057,
0.0410556234,
0.5558185577,
1.0921468735,
0.1326610297,
-0.0690181553,
0.3794398904,
0.4815891683,
0.6089568734,
0.4546888471,
1.1702055931,
-0.2837489247,
0.6138238907,
-0.2133376449,
-0.3683699965,
-0.3688052893,
-1.0950092077,
-1.1767270565,
-0.1161549985,
-0.3677926958,
-0.5949536562,
0.3541966677,
0.7805893421,
0.6149045229,
-0.7677227855,
-0.1407492459,
0.132323578,
0.393889159,
-0.0517066382,
-0.167170614,
0.3373946249,
-0.4149656594,
-0.6481955051,
0.6495528817,
0.3291924,
0.1176702678,
-0.3978921771,
-0.1424924284,
-0.3081818819,
-0.140263319,
0.1969390512,
0.5879693627,
-0.7910054922,
-0.4315084219,
-0.2123987824,
-0.4476118386,
-0.0839522034,
0.6811811924,
-0.3839280307,
0.1374057382,
0.3741317987,
1.037671566,
-0.023869453,
0.0808245316,
0.803127408,
-0.8218053579,
0.3507460952,
0.3199305832,
0.1984921396,
0.2148156762,
-0.4877882302,
0.2373675108,
-0.0269366,
-0.4548015594,
-0.8758490682,
0.3017030656,
-0.8747141957,
-0.3413212597,
1.273727417,
-0.0371910147,
-0.5049012303,
-0.1027083993,
-0.0797732696,
0.100048624,
-0.4043628275,
0.8086015582,
0.3439136147,
0.0807563588,
0.2412180752,
-0.3788046539,
0.5343834758,
0.5843737721,
-0.6785049438,
0.1584353596,
0.3281902075,
0.2808212936,
0.237669602,
0.0188616738,
-0.1667652428,
0.4220359623,
-0.2345584035,
-0.0328687802,
0.0165832136,
-0.3422887921,
-0.7818719149,
0.4477928877,
0.0523251891,
-0.3399034739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09431v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09431v1
|
Striped Attention: Faster Ring Attention for Causal Transformers
| 2023-11-15T23:01:02 | 2023-11-15T23:01:02 |
William Brandon, Aniruddha Nrusimha, Kevin Qian, Zachary Ankner, Tian Jin, Zhiye Song, Jonathan Ragan-Kelley
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
To help address the growing demand for ever-longer sequence lengths in
transformer models, Liu et al. recently proposed Ring Attention, an exact
attention algorithm capable of overcoming per-device memory bottle- necks by
distributing self-attention across multiple devices. In this paper, we study
the performance characteristics of Ring Attention in the important special case
of causal transformer models, and identify a key workload imbal- ance due to
triangular structure of causal attention computations. We propose a simple
extension to Ring Attention, which we call Striped Attention to fix this
imbalance. Instead of devices having contiguous subsequences, each device has a
subset of tokens distributed uniformly throughout the sequence, which we
demonstrate leads to more even workloads. In experiments running Striped
Attention on A100 GPUs and TPUv4s, we are able to achieve up to 1.45x
end-to-end throughput improvements over the original Ring Attention algorithm
on causal transformer training at a sequence length of 256k. Furthermore, on 16
TPUv4 chips, we were able to achieve 1.65x speedups at sequence lengths of
786k. We release the code for our experiments as open source
|
[
-0.5257995725,
-0.7010960579,
0.4845894873,
0.7360494733,
-0.3156230748,
0.1173744351,
0.2986027598,
-0.6564104557,
0.239870429,
0.7070457935,
-0.4881922007,
0.0145434486,
-0.4247336686,
0.1768406183,
-0.3441976011,
0.9197909832,
-0.0045578508,
-0.4318840504,
0.2813771367,
-0.091456227,
-0.7550733685,
0.1700382829,
-0.5314341187,
-0.3893452287,
1.0556576252,
0.3622401953,
0.460106194,
1.1709206104,
0.8767693043,
0.2158017606,
-0.0252922736,
-0.2374749184,
-0.601579845,
-0.1970858723,
-0.3848751783,
-0.0715043321,
-0.6334955096,
-0.1054179743,
0.4641259015,
0.3891067505,
0.057490807,
0.796328783,
-0.0770354941,
0.7605758309,
-0.8416457772,
-0.1667855978,
-0.5573952794,
0.5506429672,
-0.3064544499,
-0.3737169504,
-0.7392904162,
-0.2578294873,
0.1403447092,
-0.7678030133,
0.6583169699,
0.4448963106,
0.6590977311,
0.6223207712,
-0.6041525602,
0.2822158337,
-1.1944926977,
0.5476822853,
-0.1909800768,
0.4721215665,
0.1940342635,
0.2690621912,
0.2361557186,
-0.6885390282,
-0.0605473816,
0.0628259555,
-0.0925522074,
0.5045477152,
-0.5236654282,
0.2072900087,
0.5993545055,
0.2686814964,
-0.3976428807,
-0.1454532295,
-0.5889340639,
0.19683595,
0.3818931282,
0.2550687194,
-0.0291564986,
0.2644015849,
-0.5646435618,
-0.1723906249,
-0.6679903865,
-0.1201514006,
0.4663331509,
-0.1404148191,
-0.0530033447,
0.4916370809,
-0.1660766006,
0.9605857134,
0.7275025845,
0.0332369246,
-0.3507856727,
-0.2174459845,
-0.3029817641,
0.6012178063,
0.4052426815,
0.0478941016,
-0.053386651,
-0.6440594792,
0.2435425669,
-0.1495114565,
0.9287053943,
-0.541105628,
-0.3845628798,
0.27782619,
-0.2630100548,
0.1648123115,
-0.0131360525,
-0.9117365479,
0.0018105697,
-0.3583426178,
0.5828030705,
-0.079939045,
-0.2219823599,
0.1655948162,
-0.1658707559,
0.1698614359,
-0.0280225687,
-0.9881625175,
0.236694783,
0.6853370667,
0.6386342049,
0.0468508229,
0.0339918397,
-0.726870358,
0.7186513543,
-0.489151448,
0.8981682062,
-0.3137740791,
0.0299089961,
-0.2091292143,
-0.1094643623,
-0.3479351699,
-0.4402062595,
0.6373220682,
-0.99129951,
-0.2836577296,
-0.1763267815,
-0.0132170729,
-0.08605095,
-0.1054251269,
-0.8606830835,
0.9733378291,
-0.1407596469,
-0.9799117446,
0.3378789425,
-0.7317115068,
-0.7253426313,
0.0770444199,
0.3445567489,
-0.7365261912,
0.3341528773,
-0.0883220136,
0.1908848733,
-0.3424705863,
0.0337034129,
-0.5307196975,
-0.5718436241,
0.1450251341,
0.0139798196,
0.3211272061,
0.0585581772,
-0.8403937817,
0.4226685166,
-0.7902838588,
-0.1140279397,
-0.197038129,
0.2348614633,
-0.2912371159,
-0.0299454574,
0.0389247425,
0.4134703875,
-0.0630912781,
-0.8150939345,
-0.0002043673,
-0.2741502225,
0.3318009675,
0.8276934624,
-0.251008749,
0.347822696,
0.0089845853,
0.4581938386,
-0.1626532525,
0.653429091,
0.1217362508,
-0.1932225823,
-1.0037964582,
-0.3353894353,
0.2570888102,
0.4716311097,
-0.4235886037,
0.3785213828,
-0.38147524,
-0.3789774477,
-0.5286508203,
0.044007156,
0.8818452954,
0.3606631458,
0.3255604804,
-0.3587494493,
-0.5896756053,
-1.1607342958,
-0.4896778166,
0.079501614,
-0.0102846986,
0.3696212471,
0.2568041086,
0.0049302708,
1.1682012081,
-0.5392926335,
-0.498400718,
0.017664846,
0.273489058,
0.3317169249,
0.2141124159,
-0.1051069647,
-0.6179820895,
-0.5911773443,
0.2690125406,
-0.2972302735,
-0.3138966858,
-0.1521773934,
-0.3152928054,
-0.0584759936,
0.4278003573,
-0.3584570885,
0.3474153876,
0.2037817687,
-0.5513808131,
0.6000878811,
-0.0992661342,
-0.178499952,
-0.6666691899,
0.3514074087,
0.1396155953,
-0.0626700297,
-0.8083361983,
-0.3848186135,
0.3906160891,
0.1305245161,
-0.3331096172,
0.376169771,
-0.534283936,
-0.48133865,
-0.3735195696,
-0.0808335617,
-0.2682747245,
0.7765165567,
-0.1232803315,
0.5423321724,
0.1561005116,
-0.7158756256,
0.1009093821,
0.2093221992,
0.1270444393,
0.5624277592,
-0.857937336,
0.2577467263,
0.1214134023,
0.0058450252,
-0.8389360309,
-0.136729151,
0.1598936319,
0.0683296099,
0.4198514521,
-0.1490711421,
-0.5875330567,
-0.762221396,
-0.1333165318,
0.6625907421,
0.323022306,
-0.9276555181,
0.5809002519,
0.0527607203,
0.3428036273,
-0.6724348664,
-0.4002543688,
0.0237190425,
-0.4634923637,
-0.6343101263,
0.4662061036,
0.2445973903,
0.0271793511,
0.2674105763,
-0.5467664599,
0.1161526814,
0.0156480577,
0.1417880207,
-0.0129311765,
-0.1925733089,
0.0451095328,
-0.1707715839,
-0.5056299567,
0.1629888266,
-0.6671204567,
0.5678783655,
0.1451329291,
-0.174749285,
-0.423196137,
0.271361649,
0.4210113585,
-0.2233004123,
0.3215260506,
0.9559480548,
0.1020359993,
-0.1241754219,
-0.873131156,
-0.1364901364,
-0.5267671347,
0.2006872594,
-0.3321596384,
-1.0278562307,
0.6212847829,
0.1092553511,
-0.1462288797,
0.4003300369,
0.243917048,
-0.1783693135,
1.1208325624,
0.6958930492,
-0.0676440671,
0.7159201503,
0.2506934702,
0.7161096334,
-1.1287010908,
0.0760270208,
-0.2837359309,
-0.5011231303,
-0.5735085607,
-0.0688971654,
0.5520572662,
0.1610800922,
-0.5356859565,
0.3594308794,
-0.8618280292,
0.3922939003,
0.6686194539,
0.2400449216,
0.2161725312,
0.0332628526,
0.4028559029,
-0.0046469579,
-0.8864870071,
-0.0689133108,
0.7340249419,
0.2682095766,
0.9103411436,
-0.0843714848,
0.2275477946,
0.2395760268,
0.1666512787,
-0.2694737911,
0.3886008561,
-0.0231628269,
-0.6992220879,
-0.0410976224,
-0.3971980214,
-1.0731035471,
0.2106491476,
0.2243848592,
-0.7107689977,
0.3211622834,
0.5459010601,
-0.3753651381,
0.3405252099,
-0.591148138,
0.9543209076,
0.1966892183,
-0.787787199,
-0.2887402177,
-0.7308904529,
0.6891590953,
-0.1392017603,
-0.3422807157,
-0.0345647335,
0.3123831451,
0.9225524664,
-0.1352424622,
1.1042950153,
0.1704378575,
-0.096902512,
0.1025786847,
-0.3477293551,
0.6026353836,
-0.1032523811,
0.8686876297,
-0.1059359238,
-0.3538724482,
-0.5112585425,
-0.4039981365,
0.3566167355,
-0.4103592336,
-0.7794387937,
-0.3484103084,
-0.5525888205,
-0.0301363543,
0.0211019795,
0.1221343204,
0.5040691495,
0.2113051414,
-0.0495855138,
1.2001651525,
0.1385311633,
0.7842960358,
0.446478337,
0.1664827168,
-0.5162546039,
0.9081581235,
0.0733233169,
0.3828843832,
0.365557313,
0.0760009885,
-0.3275909722,
-0.1283341348,
-0.5941480398,
0.5086406469,
-0.1714919806,
-0.4115515351,
-1.0656079054,
0.1909788251,
-0.2607477009,
-0.1588837206,
-0.603500545,
-0.3479597867,
0.0463317633,
0.1672755331,
0.7140946388,
0.6778513193,
-0.0834673792,
0.833673954,
-0.5537917018,
0.5823172927,
0.6752928495,
0.7776353359,
0.2724632621,
-0.5224163532,
-0.458142668,
-0.5961828828,
-0.6198206544,
-0.6474722028,
0.2789373696,
-0.0976728052,
0.3753964305,
0.6925047636,
0.0273878053,
1.1437699795,
-0.7000962496,
0.0927355736,
0.3805770576,
-0.9858157635,
0.3932121694,
-0.4641524255,
0.568056941,
0.2218301594,
0.065643996,
-0.5674147606,
-0.43378672,
-0.6607097387,
-0.8083918095,
1.288757205,
0.3727416992,
-0.3046800196,
0.3201520145,
0.3284063637,
-0.1747240275,
-0.1812780946,
-0.6595445871,
-0.4179799855,
-0.074714154,
-0.1036313847,
-0.0381115898,
-0.5272038579,
-0.3996896148,
-0.125636518,
0.6004341245,
0.1062001735,
0.7868875265,
0.6425786018,
-0.2323632091,
-0.3325771391,
0.3309579194,
0.8056340218,
0.6676722169,
-0.3568345904,
0.3837080598,
0.2463952899,
-0.8846763968,
0.2786201537,
0.0491050407,
-0.1230116934,
-0.1079455093,
0.1975457817,
0.9345575571,
0.4650048912,
-0.0556787811,
-0.0144176222,
-0.062672466,
0.078005299,
-0.1286562532,
-0.0621858276,
-0.0054571079,
0.3538109958,
0.5748386979,
-0.0020076153,
0.3397170603,
-0.1468752623,
0.1972510219,
0.2138220817,
-0.8229240775,
-0.4674246013,
0.7923491597,
0.0078324918,
-0.3930621445,
0.2228118926,
-0.1597784907,
-0.561301291,
0.7938014269,
1.0272830725,
1.0656510592,
-0.5959821939,
-0.0347046666,
0.4615897238,
0.533436954,
-0.0202788208,
-0.0659617335,
-0.3265337944,
-0.1187837347,
-0.761654973,
-0.4815169573,
-0.291439563,
-0.3178555369,
-0.8882610202,
-0.0213618893,
-0.337156266,
-0.2131911069,
-0.1341402382,
-0.1040744111,
-0.3698870838,
0.2275687754,
-0.1670073867,
0.5190016627,
-0.7293766737,
0.8865630031,
0.4242328107,
0.1981536597,
-0.5197217464,
-0.3649593592,
-0.5945003629,
-0.2643885612,
0.8929910064,
0.3337495029,
-0.2986100912,
0.3429812789,
-0.0322444253,
-1.0797251463,
1.0261019468,
-0.0089075277,
-0.6076304317,
0.3602238595,
0.466078788,
0.5431473255,
-0.0999459475,
0.4986814559,
0.661770761,
0.4589129686,
0.0348641798,
-0.8324027061,
0.1213410348,
-0.1754749268,
0.1052353233,
0.6889077425,
-0.8596134782,
0.4694822431,
0.06723129,
-0.2963732481,
-0.4736359119,
0.9081332088,
0.3088210523,
0.5037752986,
0.5864923,
0.6302322745,
0.1976566017,
-0.2300289273,
1.0462207794,
-0.1182920709,
0.287591368,
1.0214960575,
-0.2027193308,
0.2821677923,
0.5796540976,
-0.0908672363,
0.0250275675,
0.670202136,
-0.1058880389,
0.7528197765,
0.160907343,
-0.1631201059,
-0.157545507,
-0.1269698739,
-0.4080223143,
-0.0857864618,
-0.0859949291,
-0.1679761708,
-0.1397416592,
0.2465993017,
-0.0882934406,
-0.4718257785,
-0.6208868623,
0.8866090178,
-0.0688475519,
-0.7934272289,
0.3616630137,
-0.2691939771,
0.5545415282,
-0.4433369637,
-0.042593956,
-0.2889127135,
0.5325283408,
-0.1431921571,
-0.2649603188,
0.4054321051,
-0.163994357,
-0.6435806751,
-0.2859914601,
0.5710856318,
-0.2476588488,
-0.491201967,
0.4357354343,
-0.3540983498,
-0.1880503744,
-0.2716653347,
-0.2698051631,
0.0539563522,
-0.0260552168,
-0.0114398869,
0.2483307719,
0.3019028306,
-0.2222498953,
0.5108588934,
0.5708931088,
-0.518416822,
0.9925410151,
-0.1417618096,
0.6234552264,
-1.0229302645,
-0.5794386864,
-0.7493724227,
0.1543925852,
-0.2427863777,
-0.430521816,
0.9956642389,
0.634339869,
0.655446589,
-0.3905698657,
0.0246929713,
0.0391697809,
0.1975393593,
-0.2783080339,
0.4414851665,
-0.3234387338,
-0.0047884192,
-0.4215336144,
-1.1458392143,
-0.4037047625,
0.3082496226,
-0.3921208084,
-0.3018102944,
0.8760610223,
0.3742829561,
-0.4442697763,
0.1746445,
0.1834220737,
0.2454387546,
0.1754350662,
0.737959981,
0.7873364091,
-0.7121532559,
0.6370120049,
-0.486358285,
0.034339007,
-0.2864039242,
-0.6916193962,
-0.8558214903,
-0.3907786608,
-0.5226143599,
-0.1310251057,
0.1969055682,
0.0479331091,
0.7924700379,
-0.5032390356,
-0.2391758114,
-0.3662284613,
0.1452056915,
-0.5292826891,
-0.2208762318,
0.7539007664,
-0.5372181535,
-0.4822402894,
-0.0566907749,
0.6274963617,
-0.3118182719,
0.1422180384,
0.2727130949,
-0.1851303726,
-0.0946482643,
0.7195025086,
0.3637489974,
-0.7143031955,
-0.2570829093,
0.0812273696,
-0.1282739788,
0.3191838861,
1.0440582037,
-0.5604127645,
0.4388697743,
0.1977533996,
0.3071076572,
1.2547562122,
0.1529335827,
0.4482517838,
-0.6418587565,
0.107535176,
0.0820971057,
-0.1120556816,
-0.2072299868,
-0.6091507077,
0.6070170999,
0.0688395873,
-0.6537368298,
-0.7452444434,
0.0717066228,
-1.4652193785,
0.0888494626,
0.8807813525,
0.0845087245,
-0.7191974521,
-0.6071383953,
-0.1765718758,
0.4216927588,
-0.2120362669,
0.9598958492,
0.1600302905,
-0.2536432743,
-0.2534505725,
-0.5638559461,
0.4309677482,
0.7835742235,
-0.5536696315,
0.325617969,
-0.0087461155,
-0.0219403524,
0.5149841309,
0.0907892585,
-0.0134805217,
0.5897350907,
-0.0473708622,
0.4348540604,
-0.0500830933,
-0.4075958729,
-0.3893785477,
0.4348831475,
-0.6070091128,
-0.2059414089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09428v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09428v2
|
Beyond Detection: Unveiling Fairness Vulnerabilities in Abusive Language Models
| 2023-11-15T22:57:13 | 2023-12-05T20:36:23 |
Yueqing Liang, Lu Cheng, Ali Payani, Kai Shu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
This work investigates the potential of undermining both fairness and
detection performance in abusive language detection. In a dynamic and complex
digital world, it is crucial to investigate the vulnerabilities of these
detection models to adversarial fairness attacks to improve their fairness
robustness. We propose a simple yet effective framework FABLE that leverages
backdoor attacks as they allow targeted control over the fairness and detection
performance. FABLE explores three types of trigger designs (i.e., rare,
artificial, and natural triggers) and novel sampling strategies. Specifically,
the adversary can inject triggers into samples in the minority group with the
favored outcome (i.e., "non-abusive") and flip their labels to the unfavored
outcome, i.e., "abusive". Experiments on benchmark datasets demonstrate the
effectiveness of FABLE attacking fairness and utility in abusive language
detection.
|
[
-0.2077801675,
-0.7001630664,
0.3557081521,
0.2824457586,
0.1621073633,
0.1605977714,
-0.0149419522,
-0.6731812358,
-0.2961345315,
0.5209440589,
-0.19581981,
-0.3853308558,
-0.8792067766,
-0.2200946361,
-0.6546852589,
1.3251136541,
0.4424340129,
0.0052553252,
0.2165988386,
-0.3367488086,
-0.4936307967,
-0.6256110668,
-0.8769301176,
-0.3626255095,
0.2148652822,
-0.0253504179,
1.0183627605,
0.5733254552,
0.0589864403,
0.3402211666,
0.0396238267,
-0.4661813378,
-0.8308117986,
0.1980901212,
-0.2247839868,
-0.9364168048,
-0.4886498749,
0.2924840748,
0.4139528275,
0.2958751321,
-0.2814160287,
0.2037199736,
-0.1299832761,
0.3502683043,
-1.0925875902,
0.0202854928,
-1.0448920727,
0.386608541,
-0.6845558882,
0.0941583961,
-0.6411948204,
-0.5112098455,
-0.2521442771,
-0.3295400441,
0.0713047311,
0.047183767,
0.4353106022,
0.0520620979,
-0.3384304941,
-0.4899511933,
-0.3024717867,
0.9726324081,
-0.4616897404,
0.4026355743,
0.39860636,
0.2676200867,
-0.1829828173,
-0.7991615534,
-0.6199266315,
-0.1632276475,
-0.1179907098,
0.0172431897,
-1.0780656338,
-0.1123964265,
0.377753824,
0.1958082914,
-0.2995795012,
0.4198178649,
-0.2356529236,
-0.5199562311,
0.5090171099,
0.2407965362,
0.4316298664,
0.0501991883,
-0.2027415335,
0.0422765315,
-0.6436370015,
0.5434606075,
0.9111223817,
0.3535196781,
-0.1526315063,
0.2206574976,
0.4914358556,
0.5023284554,
0.1664356738,
-0.1431742609,
0.3100692034,
0.146463871,
-0.1172084063,
0.1837835014,
0.5819881558,
0.3531723022,
0.1308678687,
-0.3187744915,
-0.6775196791,
0.2921026647,
0.3534407616,
-0.4344828725,
-0.2041108608,
0.2821829021,
-0.5481627584,
-1.0062508583,
-0.203938961,
-1.1428236961,
-0.6973150373,
0.3869430721,
0.4825732708,
-0.3517942429,
-0.5358784199,
0.1472537369,
-0.2410379052,
0.2985629439,
-0.0626801252,
-0.8102627397,
0.5336763859,
0.8398270011,
0.6099060774,
0.0551423877,
-0.1205533296,
-1.1748278141,
0.0854669958,
-0.3044446707,
0.6291421056,
-0.7569846511,
-0.3198877275,
0.0743260831,
-0.2555990517,
0.2022172809,
-0.5116140842,
0.6745786071,
-0.9862924814,
0.2389241308,
-0.1225933135,
0.0173356924,
-0.1054075956,
0.2376957238,
-0.8131031394,
0.8959187865,
0.0742385238,
-0.9298692346,
0.4643606842,
-0.8674381971,
-0.7165994644,
-0.3144411147,
0.035179574,
-0.4270190597,
0.2887166142,
0.3248258829,
-0.1513897032,
0.1147688851,
0.2867676318,
-0.5235213637,
-0.5312183499,
0.4338150322,
-0.7869573236,
1.2642834187,
0.3754290938,
-0.7212860584,
-0.0502561964,
-0.4853246808,
-0.2131816,
0.3118716478,
-0.1303538084,
-0.4270370901,
-0.1554153264,
-0.0801522881,
0.2814592123,
-0.1154190674,
-0.5558575392,
-0.2205560356,
-0.7936989069,
0.029725045,
1.1745836735,
-0.5370878577,
0.4582930803,
-0.2557710409,
0.8034722209,
0.0077868695,
0.3997885585,
-0.0169840828,
-0.3803555667,
-0.4095324874,
-0.4122410417,
0.3578983843,
0.7343481779,
-0.6761065125,
0.034282662,
0.0299209505,
-0.1835703552,
-0.8491122127,
-0.247418344,
0.9329378605,
0.490491569,
0.2396198362,
-0.2005456388,
-0.3488337994,
-0.7315052748,
-0.8980096579,
-0.3348313272,
0.0476785153,
0.1710584611,
0.325080961,
-0.076010555,
0.9494249225,
-0.4716134667,
-0.2883476019,
-0.0987699255,
0.1370842606,
0.0674294531,
0.2209515572,
1.1859849691,
-0.854275465,
-0.1477234811,
-0.2653468251,
-0.6783103347,
-0.6642836928,
0.4366004169,
0.2440775335,
0.2009525001,
0.6470487118,
-0.0498833917,
0.6451724768,
0.5142837763,
-0.3884603083,
0.4452076554,
0.3055295348,
0.3388116062,
-0.6256405711,
-0.1253528893,
-0.2978801727,
-0.2044461817,
-0.6359364986,
0.4060971737,
-0.1708883345,
-0.1855882555,
-0.7162535191,
0.5711991787,
-0.0909605399,
-0.1879897863,
-0.1716939062,
0.0921892375,
-0.281164676,
0.325825274,
-0.4968037903,
0.7098005414,
0.6661370993,
-0.331476748,
0.3821546435,
-0.1729495823,
0.1858582646,
0.8028062582,
-0.4653564394,
0.296091795,
-0.3561239541,
0.302960068,
-0.9535605311,
0.1877280623,
0.4972122908,
-0.7057778835,
0.3492462635,
-0.5150191188,
-0.4320691228,
-0.1790614277,
-0.8646801114,
0.6092640758,
0.5065812469,
-0.6442148089,
0.7310755253,
0.7482997179,
0.0971102044,
-0.9828164577,
-0.7692552209,
0.1599206328,
-0.5013803244,
-0.6029698849,
0.1657798439,
0.1426186115,
-0.6946274638,
-0.1323642284,
0.089884527,
0.0075134914,
0.2290791124,
0.3208845258,
-0.2712804675,
-0.2389699817,
0.0792533159,
0.2721768022,
-0.3459868729,
0.2174337804,
-0.3770549893,
0.5419995785,
-0.3224112093,
-0.4548064768,
-0.2247463316,
0.5945662856,
0.5870622993,
-0.3946967423,
0.394846648,
0.6473460793,
-0.6835335493,
-0.1367457509,
-0.4759576023,
-0.0966736749,
-0.552082479,
0.3898046017,
-0.546470046,
-0.8798096776,
0.7267293334,
0.1571864188,
0.2436353564,
0.1730817854,
0.4313465655,
0.2161795199,
1.1874420643,
0.7504844069,
-0.3569399416,
0.3729183376,
0.0745688006,
0.3348082602,
-0.3193678558,
-0.2265308052,
-0.6730236411,
-0.2101222724,
-0.5738095641,
-0.143602863,
0.3573716581,
0.056329377,
-0.1287751198,
0.0934956372,
-0.136359781,
0.5852598548,
0.4267909229,
0.1105080619,
0.4689537883,
-0.0328971744,
-0.1973620802,
-0.4072253704,
-0.5061740875,
-0.5517491102,
1.2097629309,
0.5051947832,
0.7333196402,
0.5970612764,
0.5486441851,
0.5363566875,
0.6012599468,
-0.5161085129,
0.2393870801,
-0.2761032581,
-0.8023051023,
-0.119107686,
-0.0663387775,
-1.0292854309,
0.2529434264,
-0.2537704408,
-1.0019222498,
0.2460856587,
0.3992071152,
-0.3924638629,
0.6380285025,
-0.6795886755,
0.7183348536,
-0.2232485861,
-0.3178181648,
-0.3134768009,
-0.4739159942,
0.7273062468,
-0.426753372,
0.8493888378,
0.2717542052,
0.0240430515,
0.4592292011,
-0.16692321,
1.0941103697,
-0.2675976753,
-0.351010859,
0.0622630827,
0.5629826784,
0.4183308184,
0.1621538401,
-0.3896194696,
0.1933069229,
-0.339058876,
-0.4702035785,
-0.5686491132,
0.5587953925,
-0.3814195395,
-0.5575948954,
-0.5615070462,
-0.3430797756,
-0.260099709,
0.2135154605,
0.3837034106,
0.4409620464,
-0.1370777935,
-0.2743907571,
0.7233061194,
-0.6332640052,
0.4149948359,
0.6844488382,
-0.3685779572,
-0.1692911088,
0.8055269718,
-0.2647334337,
0.2297014743,
0.0420127511,
0.1962567866,
-0.4087148309,
-0.668558836,
-0.2280182987,
-0.3351455033,
-0.6328111291,
-0.4096069038,
-0.8450304866,
0.0110779786,
-0.6043164134,
-0.2266932875,
-0.4832071662,
0.0036770976,
0.0550831966,
-0.0688919425,
0.3800183237,
0.7963442206,
-0.6020643711,
0.4060593843,
-0.4894948602,
0.3866689801,
0.5860524178,
0.6027716398,
0.168993026,
-0.6677911282,
0.2840535343,
0.0300960205,
-0.3022497594,
-1.0595083237,
0.1373287737,
-0.1287119985,
0.6594025493,
0.4933308363,
0.2388961762,
0.5090373755,
-0.449734956,
0.6709643006,
0.3091930747,
-1.1485389471,
0.6483363509,
-0.2946548462,
-0.3325424194,
0.2429013252,
0.0191974342,
-0.4142478406,
-0.9216468334,
-0.5577359796,
-0.7094230652,
0.9844956994,
0.2676290572,
0.5038385391,
0.0944684967,
0.1575822383,
0.2814846933,
0.3523052931,
-1.1263790131,
-0.4084002972,
-0.4392877817,
0.0506348535,
0.292586714,
-0.1873721182,
-0.2936518788,
0.0328623615,
0.3430920243,
0.0825676695,
0.0819798484,
-0.4366373718,
-0.2935869694,
-0.2495408356,
0.1812737882,
0.288661778,
0.3437459469,
0.197885111,
0.0447234623,
0.264557153,
-0.6512082219,
-0.0518121868,
0.1796856076,
-0.1517147571,
-0.4262974262,
0.7690750957,
0.4345728159,
0.2066631019,
-0.6238366961,
0.9777516723,
-0.2569761574,
0.3321591318,
-0.0528476052,
0.2638494074,
-0.3817309141,
0.662953794,
0.4282835424,
0.0078419819,
0.5461845398,
-0.5617545247,
0.5360463262,
0.5643975735,
-0.6044480801,
-0.2571112812,
0.7070156336,
0.0566524863,
-0.4896091819,
0.4622777104,
-0.4649844766,
-0.8792655468,
0.3982215226,
0.8571543694,
0.706163764,
-0.2273434103,
0.2224543095,
-0.3203115165,
0.6314437389,
0.2939231694,
0.0858158618,
0.2199708521,
-0.8429015279,
-0.025455175,
-0.5137603283,
0.0711740851,
0.1658836007,
-0.6544415355,
0.1765780896,
-0.4616658688,
-0.2534622848,
0.0602319799,
-0.3071214855,
-0.4617452919,
0.0705737844,
0.0322277769,
0.7292587161,
-0.922896862,
0.3390700519,
0.3973175287,
-0.3417797983,
-0.518609345,
0.2896223068,
0.465318948,
-1.2387155294,
0.5798013806,
-0.1749539673,
-0.4602189064,
-0.0492377207,
-0.8878796697,
-0.3279719949,
0.652631104,
0.8902736902,
-0.1725533605,
0.3570085466,
-0.1392689198,
0.5308056474,
0.0126425019,
-0.0522850454,
0.8676118255,
0.4836289585,
-0.0474784374,
-0.9885829687,
0.0138820037,
-0.2057645768,
-0.2994275093,
0.2461212873,
-0.4296388328,
0.9090229869,
-0.4346587658,
-0.3081358075,
-0.2053148746,
0.4200385511,
0.5025751591,
0.7032244802,
0.684505403,
0.7948509455,
0.5823380351,
-0.100822933,
1.0170514584,
0.1982798725,
0.0995665714,
0.9414537549,
-0.1549740583,
0.2867447138,
0.2717365026,
-0.3982207775,
0.29919222,
0.3337332308,
0.0889433473,
0.6090017557,
0.3271511793,
-0.3346158266,
-0.0755892098,
-0.2315664142,
-0.5465777516,
0.6903222799,
0.3274711967,
-0.1873657852,
-0.4563731551,
0.2854378819,
0.5940390825,
0.5304152369,
-0.495198518,
0.5535438061,
0.0147098452,
-0.2831543386,
0.1539830565,
0.3831478059,
1.0253252983,
-0.4303525984,
-0.0252181739,
-0.2492720634,
0.238967374,
-0.1800453663,
-0.9814068675,
0.1633329093,
0.1891932487,
-0.0634146184,
-0.0221009795,
0.7726534009,
-0.08779791,
-0.2736902237,
0.6675265431,
0.2437770814,
-0.0452852026,
-0.0117096025,
-0.8393833041,
0.3457433879,
-0.0687838793,
0.0083021764,
0.3829286397,
0.6682291627,
-0.3568610549,
0.6542406678,
0.8144613504,
0.0409419313,
0.2545725703,
0.0541403443,
0.9459693432,
-0.4288931787,
-0.8316332698,
-0.9774982333,
0.3975411355,
-0.136345908,
-0.1532209963,
0.554040134,
0.3742081821,
0.815435946,
0.2119324207,
0.6354000568,
0.096375376,
0.2197852135,
-0.4095263779,
0.94196105,
-0.3827661872,
0.4867405891,
-0.806527257,
-0.3106191754,
-0.5211732984,
0.4068132937,
-0.2638994753,
0.3029078543,
0.2589826882,
0.8329182863,
-0.1227606833,
0.0935757905,
0.3300909698,
0.4219948351,
0.6273735762,
0.592315495,
0.889744401,
-0.3634634614,
0.8946553469,
0.2444570661,
-0.5027058125,
0.0647203848,
-1.0550529957,
-0.8818069696,
-0.1039404348,
0.0407546461,
-0.7475170493,
0.4337349534,
0.3970412016,
0.5235251188,
-1.015955925,
0.1202738211,
0.4676595032,
0.5778670907,
-0.0484603755,
-0.2979092896,
0.2578422129,
-0.2382667512,
-0.5294492841,
0.0451675467,
0.3870023191,
-0.0388899222,
-0.1448634416,
-0.0361589752,
0.1599778235,
0.0366457291,
0.7477551103,
0.173783496,
-0.635047853,
-0.2773139775,
-0.2092103958,
-0.0879045278,
-0.2595329285,
0.9545060396,
-0.9836168885,
0.4336645901,
0.0199169405,
0.5554756522,
0.0246213563,
-0.3390703499,
0.8330059648,
-0.9566218257,
0.4119807184,
0.3981289268,
0.1033522338,
0.0488299355,
-0.5505999923,
0.10335695,
0.4067779481,
0.159480989,
-1.2555687428,
0.5657191277,
-0.1837832779,
-0.5260260105,
0.6788699031,
-0.0916215181,
0.0368285216,
-0.5871300101,
-0.0873918161,
0.10638877,
-0.5703080297,
1.0498390198,
0.556542933,
0.0059863636,
0.2399570793,
-0.5530872345,
0.6874055862,
0.0021823747,
-0.4609223306,
0.1008914411,
0.5361129642,
0.4138165116,
0.1113201827,
0.8259552121,
-0.7830711603,
0.5500935912,
-0.0077007045,
-0.3566146195,
0.0444797762,
-0.0569059104,
-0.6145361662,
0.5121486783,
-0.2089640498,
-0.0548800081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09422v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09422v1
|
Predicting generalization performance with correctness discriminators
| 2023-11-15T22:43:42 | 2023-11-15T22:43:42 |
Yuekun Yao, Alexander Koller
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The ability to predict an NLP model's accuracy on unseen, potentially
out-of-distribution data is a prerequisite for trustworthiness. We present a
novel model that establishes upper and lower bounds on the accuracy, without
requiring gold labels for the unseen data. We achieve this by training a
discriminator which predicts whether the output of a given sequence-to-sequence
model is correct or not. We show across a variety of tagging, parsing, and
semantic parsing tasks that the gold accuracy is reliably between the predicted
upper and lower bounds, and that these bounds are remarkably close together.
|
[
-0.1819713265,
-0.2222873867,
0.5274689198,
-0.0564610735,
0.1753343195,
0.0028586148,
-0.0564847551,
-0.5830513835,
-0.2111383975,
0.437995255,
-0.2960420847,
-0.6134316325,
-1.086717844,
-0.0393515602,
-0.5559569597,
0.9507930279,
0.3134166598,
-0.25660941,
-0.3062173724,
-0.1554723531,
-0.3990295827,
-0.7592541575,
-0.1172048301,
-0.5960466862,
0.191240117,
0.08190348,
0.9967426658,
1.0073218346,
0.635931015,
0.2674641907,
-0.0390650891,
0.2991856337,
-0.1133485883,
-0.0467946418,
-0.3826321959,
-0.897574842,
-0.6441751122,
0.0262261033,
0.5851191282,
0.5958166718,
-0.2906792462,
0.1349054277,
0.0343325771,
0.6815285683,
-0.6412059069,
0.2022493035,
-0.9195008278,
0.2279330939,
-0.2226277143,
-0.2744574249,
-0.7560651302,
-0.4581707418,
0.2498648018,
-0.7776680589,
0.8188078403,
0.0462484136,
1.1147065163,
0.5036451221,
0.0178489331,
-0.0520538688,
-0.9335030913,
0.8147539496,
-0.5982472897,
0.4044259787,
0.7857663035,
0.5035995245,
0.0078715319,
-0.8408244252,
-0.3031867445,
-0.0652268156,
-0.2547263801,
-0.0589575209,
-0.3148194253,
0.2167488933,
0.5401400924,
0.4925141335,
-0.608044982,
-0.0432246737,
-0.2515545487,
-0.0235445146,
0.4697904885,
-0.0553311855,
0.0297069829,
0.2506976128,
0.0873378813,
-0.0614184663,
-0.2247539312,
-0.0849290639,
0.4024174213,
0.4266340733,
0.0983488262,
0.7648386359,
-0.155646354,
0.7006881833,
0.4680526257,
-0.0973800272,
0.3738801479,
-0.0495327599,
-0.2304729521,
0.0148146935,
0.4456883073,
0.2387932986,
0.5490630865,
-0.4341039956,
-0.1638636589,
0.6463945508,
0.4198047519,
-0.3371464908,
-0.6299963593,
0.1078206226,
-0.4015658796,
-0.2675652206,
0.2773274183,
-0.5416787863,
-0.2519916594,
-0.1731573343,
0.2841192484,
-0.3953385651,
-0.0473389812,
0.2862232327,
-0.2116257995,
-0.1645377725,
0.1080954373,
-1.09047544,
0.5198710561,
0.8310209513,
1.0251088142,
0.0325749591,
-0.3129734695,
-0.7848359346,
0.5332365036,
-0.3205387592,
0.5441203117,
-0.6728032231,
-0.0441344529,
-0.0453076288,
-0.2161976844,
-0.2871314585,
-0.5855250955,
0.7010329366,
-0.7494416237,
-0.3130931854,
-0.1067864597,
-0.9230125546,
-0.111473158,
0.1164644137,
-0.8413090706,
0.7853539586,
0.1492113918,
-1.0497933626,
0.7530671954,
-0.6293798089,
-0.1229107454,
0.0903892517,
0.0306634326,
-0.3900718689,
0.2816485763,
0.2552593648,
0.3810867667,
0.3764133453,
0.2489507645,
-0.5295166969,
-0.4691655934,
0.1796104163,
-0.3544670641,
0.3876895607,
0.0120220017,
-0.3006216884,
-0.2328853905,
-0.8789117932,
0.1137897223,
-0.0684208721,
-0.3802300096,
-0.300573498,
0.1257820427,
-0.6294376254,
0.0696032494,
0.1668628603,
-0.5373796225,
0.0338403918,
-0.7227621675,
0.0503319204,
0.8703639507,
-0.4705377817,
0.5343529582,
-0.5053798556,
0.544477284,
-0.0946936607,
0.2411449403,
0.2599411011,
-0.7105307579,
-0.6464810967,
0.0102087408,
0.7776862979,
0.8093754649,
-0.3472765088,
0.724511981,
-0.4833316207,
-0.5662728548,
-0.428275317,
0.2406055927,
0.4665520787,
0.3331094682,
0.4403186142,
-0.4888192415,
-0.6740504503,
-0.5831990242,
-0.4948679209,
-0.385030359,
-0.0092220558,
-0.0584586821,
0.4245020151,
-0.3361404836,
1.0448364019,
-0.4996308386,
-0.3479404449,
-0.1341868192,
0.2808604836,
0.2599278986,
0.6965777874,
0.2545851171,
-0.8279826045,
-0.2236336917,
0.1631312519,
-0.7258891463,
0.0770716369,
0.4828669429,
0.0660489276,
0.1897796839,
0.2779394388,
-0.5910054445,
0.7201125026,
0.9808802009,
-0.3956845701,
0.3822391033,
-0.4673170447,
-0.2217832506,
-0.6792116165,
0.0477846861,
0.3304486573,
-0.1782088429,
-0.7141550779,
-0.1815300435,
0.0265899934,
0.2597898245,
-0.0492956489,
0.2953807712,
-0.0299490932,
-0.3448074758,
0.1319906265,
-0.2683689594,
0.1477089673,
0.0014543772,
0.2284769416,
0.6890606284,
0.2062424719,
-0.7968845963,
0.106670633,
0.3194629252,
-0.4510812461,
0.5677155852,
-0.9248685837,
-0.0037844726,
-0.0703348219,
0.2468224615,
-0.8569417,
-0.3164689839,
-0.1134341806,
-0.7566598654,
0.2915818095,
-0.4725078642,
-0.6432828903,
-0.4135449231,
0.2007159144,
0.4436437786,
0.5272853374,
-0.6743465662,
0.5714663267,
0.1503985822,
0.2536517084,
-1.1543762684,
-0.86062181,
-0.3250280917,
-0.1879843473,
-0.6036578417,
0.2903419137,
-0.1033382416,
-0.1192957088,
-0.1903042346,
0.0630326867,
-0.2719442546,
0.1613508761,
0.4513478577,
0.1772351563,
0.004700453,
0.2385401279,
-0.0852126926,
-0.3107317388,
0.0400161222,
-0.2764538229,
0.4416874647,
-0.3134497702,
-0.4557317495,
-0.2687708139,
0.0384558365,
0.1050300375,
-0.3588325083,
0.758983314,
0.5688860416,
-0.4046956599,
-0.3234429359,
-0.4935888648,
0.0230734721,
-0.4982971251,
0.2189350575,
-0.4809792638,
-0.6713501215,
0.4045383036,
0.0355388932,
-0.0191307478,
0.465164721,
0.0404483601,
0.0286219865,
1.573251009,
0.7935199142,
0.2292153984,
0.0913440809,
-0.2543042004,
0.170790866,
-0.4851769507,
-0.1127798185,
-0.596614182,
0.0042576552,
-0.6792379022,
-0.3601045907,
-0.0621612556,
0.2530472875,
-0.2398492545,
0.2145616263,
-0.6000015736,
0.7491889596,
0.9089999199,
0.0630790293,
0.4846693277,
-0.0552213266,
-0.0768848583,
-0.163050428,
-0.5965788364,
-0.7447580695,
1.2426580191,
0.5784568787,
0.6879165173,
0.0886052847,
0.6401656866,
0.6399379969,
0.2325151712,
-0.5144023895,
0.1580298543,
-0.7473965883,
-0.7844686508,
-0.1521204263,
-0.3270354271,
-0.7832990885,
0.0295727383,
-0.1326361001,
-0.6516019106,
0.2397000194,
0.5295018554,
-0.4534000456,
0.4961515069,
-0.5868555307,
0.7626202703,
0.1401177943,
0.3086765707,
0.1852155626,
-0.8137428164,
0.3209067285,
-0.0258698091,
0.1252717525,
-0.2123000324,
0.0340123884,
0.7454281449,
-0.2633351982,
0.8135875463,
-0.2369805127,
0.1197778136,
-0.0697045103,
0.06518168,
0.5364495516,
-0.1827782989,
-0.114353478,
0.2912224233,
0.177575931,
-0.4625135064,
-0.5673370957,
0.2125715017,
-0.7906935811,
-0.212161094,
-0.5813310742,
-0.478192836,
-0.4046400487,
0.0677518174,
0.6494663358,
0.220212698,
-0.2018903941,
-0.1601832211,
1.1213921309,
0.0705117434,
0.0783271939,
0.1224217564,
0.0338432863,
-0.4642934501,
0.7770839334,
0.265660584,
0.3042198122,
0.4441438019,
0.1175219417,
-0.4861667156,
-0.7148917317,
-0.2579527795,
0.3083224595,
-0.9068557024,
-0.1773150563,
-0.6669620872,
-0.3092004955,
-0.4101109505,
-0.2959915698,
-0.3429678082,
-0.4566936195,
-0.3212471902,
-0.3805464506,
0.1265408546,
0.9022951722,
-0.3825888932,
0.5076099038,
-0.8570273519,
0.1432553381,
0.4615821242,
0.5185584426,
-0.2832493484,
-0.7505019903,
-0.2874759734,
0.0911299735,
-0.2255957276,
-0.3257091045,
0.5713421702,
0.4121106267,
0.4686864614,
0.3488501608,
0.077541858,
0.5713344216,
-0.4420423806,
0.7024876475,
0.0846891701,
-1.137242794,
0.8291525841,
-0.2834956646,
-0.0174018275,
0.5927092433,
0.2599372864,
-0.0877149701,
-0.5047464371,
-0.9486708641,
-0.4308653772,
0.6246156096,
0.136621207,
-0.1449335068,
-0.053225819,
0.3233710825,
0.2866171896,
0.2640318573,
-0.5674389601,
-0.2396800965,
-0.2501396835,
-0.1888887435,
-0.5640838742,
-0.2439288497,
-0.1597440094,
-0.2247323841,
0.7936812043,
-0.2376206815,
0.2627649605,
-0.0110386927,
-0.0416176803,
-0.3203169703,
0.1690750271,
0.3658205867,
1.1445783377,
-0.6421006918,
0.2701944709,
0.1555515677,
-0.5218617916,
0.2261729538,
0.2049251795,
-0.3182329535,
0.4070248306,
0.2923045158,
0.5772789717,
-0.3175879419,
-0.3681412339,
0.723702848,
-0.1769124717,
-0.2164355069,
-0.497203052,
0.1702466756,
-0.2666596472,
0.3510305882,
0.0516305789,
0.3558883667,
0.197705999,
-0.0803218409,
0.4396767616,
0.2294579297,
-0.4251609445,
-0.4922722876,
0.7821868658,
-0.127604112,
-0.0304658953,
0.5926223993,
-0.0796152949,
-0.4939910769,
0.4784851074,
0.5744871497,
0.5995457172,
-0.5022744536,
0.390479058,
0.3706216216,
0.2742244899,
-0.5144907236,
0.0753399506,
0.1820196658,
-1.0006914139,
-0.5267928243,
-0.6720950007,
-0.4936606288,
-0.1264028847,
-1.0702275038,
-0.0086615514,
-0.5510406494,
-0.610961616,
0.1220903769,
0.1257041693,
-0.7034599185,
0.6651728153,
0.0894683301,
0.8612834215,
-0.9517088532,
0.98131603,
0.4907172024,
-0.0421360843,
-0.704282701,
-0.2381487191,
-0.2561825812,
-0.8149982095,
0.7397524118,
0.3376808763,
0.0272932202,
-0.2314939797,
-0.3891774416,
-0.9805060029,
1.1193208694,
0.7498717308,
-0.4694533348,
-0.3666815758,
0.2096651047,
0.5244578719,
-0.2868638635,
0.0281881578,
0.8087479472,
0.3545420468,
0.0425825119,
-1.178275466,
-0.2970231473,
-0.1493669897,
0.306093663,
0.2385391742,
-0.2825926244,
0.8147107363,
-0.2103601098,
-0.1778841764,
0.111274682,
0.6794543862,
0.3930330575,
0.5641551614,
0.4144532382,
1.0631539822,
1.0792144537,
-0.2871033847,
1.133232832,
0.1072772369,
0.3595071435,
1.4246861935,
0.0001135434,
0.8082273006,
0.1370748878,
-0.3885641098,
0.5748217702,
0.3831416965,
-0.0891037807,
0.6855275035,
-0.0147738187,
-0.1218584329,
-0.3449412882,
-0.1744609773,
-0.4956769645,
0.3687019646,
0.3822001517,
-0.9049560428,
0.2161703855,
-0.4300726056,
-0.1848825067,
0.3877959549,
-0.4270378649,
0.6328229904,
-0.1516293734,
-0.5423844457,
0.5930549502,
-0.0570509173,
0.8726930618,
-0.5242187381,
-0.0982662737,
0.2035424709,
0.5477865338,
-0.4777015746,
-0.8677436709,
0.4459139705,
-0.3486002982,
-0.529235065,
0.2791596055,
0.8221331835,
-0.2322861552,
-0.4443612695,
0.3941986561,
0.2802266777,
-0.0482491702,
0.0514879264,
-0.5475723147,
-0.0667920485,
-0.2164738625,
-0.0330394171,
0.3684583306,
0.3546598852,
0.3010505736,
0.7181574106,
0.4748517573,
0.3070325553,
0.4761544466,
0.0054651867,
0.3715626895,
-0.2852864265,
-0.6103156805,
-0.8181062341,
0.3729955256,
-0.1886138767,
-0.1918094158,
0.7282572985,
0.3231872022,
1.1468677521,
-0.0574966222,
1.022239089,
0.3028613031,
0.7920759916,
-0.2825309336,
0.2330659926,
-0.1665831357,
0.0253255032,
-0.4243140221,
-0.8722422123,
-0.5862922668,
0.8883339763,
-0.3534756601,
0.0871882141,
0.2823512554,
0.7187921405,
-0.1284336597,
0.1441325992,
0.5224369764,
-0.1792122126,
0.2687391639,
0.6299502254,
0.6900699735,
-0.4750374258,
0.3922603428,
-0.8481578231,
-0.2811916769,
0.0067425063,
-0.8693006039,
-1.027422905,
-0.5304214358,
-0.2046775222,
-0.8081923127,
0.1758182049,
0.5328442454,
0.9429441094,
-0.8539569378,
-0.0676157251,
-0.3636746109,
-0.1191892475,
-0.5667518377,
-0.1904352158,
0.2117957324,
-0.1984602064,
-0.5618003011,
0.09216737,
0.0453029871,
0.3177400529,
0.085737966,
-0.3649017215,
0.0277655423,
0.2606726885,
0.4120393395,
0.3525066376,
-0.6412026286,
-0.5115409493,
-0.4666433036,
0.1724422425,
0.1606583148,
0.3344097137,
-0.5508816242,
0.40149647,
0.2005312294,
0.5072709322,
0.2417978495,
0.5325889587,
0.7508071661,
-0.9025972486,
-0.2447211891,
0.3552439213,
0.3060424328,
0.4054927528,
-0.4900727272,
0.8459138274,
0.1936639249,
-0.8423889279,
-0.8977273107,
0.4159820676,
-0.7482548356,
0.145257026,
0.9738147259,
-0.5995364785,
-0.0771248564,
-0.1942492872,
0.2041389793,
0.3750151396,
-0.4336203337,
0.7080162168,
0.6477458477,
-0.0995782465,
0.0133467559,
-0.2961097956,
0.7335514426,
0.3452017605,
-0.5005193949,
0.2118135393,
0.4371875226,
0.2138067037,
0.6075313091,
0.5190828443,
0.0155256847,
0.3385561407,
0.0539839268,
-0.2526133358,
0.0291531123,
-0.4838553369,
-0.3228747547,
0.4005960524,
0.5007656217,
-0.1095607728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09410v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09410v3
|
When Large Language Models contradict humans? Large Language Models' Sycophantic Behaviour
| 2023-11-15T22:18:33 | 2024-04-28T08:06:06 |
Leonardo Ranaldi, Giulia Pucci
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models have been demonstrating the ability to solve complex
tasks by delivering answers that are positively evaluated by humans due in part
to the intensive use of human feedback that refines responses. However, the
suggestibility transmitted through human feedback increases the inclination to
produce responses that correspond to the users' beliefs or misleading prompts
as opposed to true facts, a behaviour known as sycophancy. This phenomenon
decreases the bias, robustness, and, consequently, their reliability. In this
paper, we shed light on the suggestibility of Large Language Models (LLMs) to
sycophantic behaviour, demonstrating these tendencies via human-influenced
prompts over different tasks. Our investigation reveals that LLMs show
sycophantic tendencies when responding to queries involving subjective opinions
and statements that should elicit a contrary response based on facts. In
contrast, when confronted with mathematical tasks or queries that have an
objective answer, these models at various scales seem not to follow the users'
hints by demonstrating confidence in delivering the correct answers.
|
[
-0.1240535155,
-0.798029542,
0.8401861191,
0.2775745094,
-0.1229411736,
-0.0338140391,
-0.2682124972,
-0.5702385306,
0.2805319726,
0.6710663438,
-0.6708757281,
-0.1035893261,
-0.4821008444,
0.1197148189,
-0.4463522136,
1.0873632431,
0.3080931902,
0.114467971,
-0.4460727572,
0.0824363828,
-0.518520236,
-1.022903204,
-0.7386131287,
-0.5053462982,
0.5358601213,
0.1741265804,
0.9374340177,
0.0719843209,
0.22976695,
0.3006623983,
-0.2084997892,
0.2188777477,
-0.6228342056,
0.4842056334,
-0.27548334,
-0.9903942347,
-0.4642231464,
-0.154155314,
0.4453693628,
0.8437227607,
-0.3414588869,
-0.0456413403,
0.523750186,
0.6009637713,
-0.5868498087,
0.5091413856,
-0.5545625091,
-0.2498694211,
-0.0467305481,
0.022013329,
-0.7168681026,
-0.2772793174,
0.152522698,
-0.5369904637,
0.0586258024,
0.2005685419,
0.4428951442,
0.2009753734,
-0.3461917639,
-0.7164458036,
-0.7826161385,
0.8131583333,
-0.6913095117,
-0.0406598039,
0.8288657069,
-0.0216385461,
-0.3620657325,
-0.286339283,
-0.6187539101,
-0.8146784306,
-0.1688878089,
-0.0572341122,
-0.5315200686,
0.2379141599,
0.6510295868,
-0.1580104083,
-0.5046464801,
0.1219229177,
-0.0600457788,
-0.4797190428,
0.6955772042,
0.3952575922,
0.3283289671,
-0.3142952323,
0.0043203179,
0.1435513198,
-0.7275367379,
0.1782263815,
0.3145783544,
0.260137856,
-0.0407237336,
0.7146821618,
-0.1335822046,
0.8065015674,
0.3238260448,
-0.2279507965,
-0.1391682625,
-0.1478569955,
-0.0286355838,
0.1015854999,
0.7232667208,
0.470426172,
0.7080865502,
-0.0057151094,
-0.4967652857,
0.4135651588,
0.223887071,
-0.5772616267,
-0.2483388036,
0.1639805585,
-0.2338686436,
-0.2816220224,
-0.0940601826,
-0.5978260636,
-0.6780851483,
-0.0317391641,
0.5789411664,
-0.1705409437,
-0.1416943073,
0.2476543784,
0.1805857867,
-0.1034895256,
0.5493495464,
-0.8902503252,
0.4872433841,
0.7504178286,
0.6058951616,
-0.0444661304,
-0.1483374238,
-0.3935968876,
0.0873485059,
-0.474355191,
1.0176532269,
-0.5613188744,
-0.5761184096,
-0.2001621723,
0.2870721221,
-0.0471359305,
-0.7763262987,
0.568482101,
-0.2780268192,
0.3504417539,
-0.6919727921,
-0.2552319169,
-0.2673472166,
0.2874105871,
-0.4950835109,
0.7506250143,
-0.234794721,
-1.0154821873,
0.0554329716,
-0.3535406291,
-0.3347897828,
0.0765045807,
-0.2001891732,
-0.1140681729,
0.1283696741,
0.0167635363,
0.337451607,
-0.4776549935,
0.4113708436,
-0.5854346752,
-0.2367198765,
0.6454972029,
-0.5574610233,
0.8769494295,
0.1997008473,
-0.4286449254,
0.0334725641,
-0.2693375647,
-0.1531059891,
0.1019428894,
0.0044246037,
-0.8069141507,
0.2515839636,
-0.3176217675,
0.4242913127,
0.2802963555,
-0.398131758,
0.315782249,
-0.2004237175,
0.6776892543,
0.7285633683,
-0.1383809447,
0.0357508957,
-0.7070949078,
0.6571137905,
0.1943025589,
0.0884820744,
-0.1956366599,
-0.7534885406,
-0.4491210878,
-0.0024629899,
-0.1740740836,
0.5794505477,
-0.6352002621,
0.0771080703,
-0.2290922999,
-0.4619261622,
-0.2406500876,
-0.0440072939,
0.3694896996,
0.5359290242,
-0.0604586676,
-0.4527593255,
-0.495728761,
-1.0839105844,
-0.3545119464,
-0.633869648,
0.0275447275,
0.2123093158,
0.57932055,
-0.1566381902,
0.7951774001,
-0.5073117614,
0.1758292615,
-0.2683993876,
0.1775761545,
0.0218066275,
0.1418860406,
0.2619879544,
-0.7628293633,
0.0664741993,
-0.2321145087,
-0.7285456657,
-0.180645749,
0.0602639839,
0.389839083,
0.48964113,
0.4022453725,
-0.9269239902,
0.1576580703,
0.7047835588,
-0.4668565094,
0.8920098543,
-0.2459902018,
-0.0861616731,
-1.1595877409,
0.1822470725,
0.148443684,
-0.3652080297,
-0.4046095312,
-0.0917177945,
-0.2096846253,
0.0385195948,
-0.0261450149,
0.3230690658,
-0.3917089403,
-0.1821942925,
-0.262983948,
0.1572417915,
-0.0089686522,
0.2251205593,
0.0006717974,
0.7458491325,
0.4851277471,
-0.7244756222,
0.491420716,
-0.0342944004,
-0.2883108556,
0.6206818223,
-0.7067807913,
-0.0054709921,
-0.3913014233,
0.5081495643,
-1.2097605467,
-0.3031351268,
0.094348371,
-0.46192047,
-0.1494223773,
0.0312669948,
-0.527576685,
-0.475712806,
-0.08802104,
0.1976376325,
0.3901457787,
-0.11333552,
0.4039293826,
0.4804758728,
-0.5785845518,
-0.5171167254,
-0.9645192027,
0.1834308654,
-0.0032964677,
-0.454671979,
-0.0377711579,
-0.2974358201,
-0.6753284335,
-0.2583692074,
-0.1531600803,
-0.1739818901,
0.1172730848,
0.5124323368,
0.5977636576,
-0.0413850471,
0.1419559717,
-0.2804346085,
0.1352902055,
0.607627213,
-0.3916255236,
0.7287620306,
0.1023544818,
-0.4319605231,
-0.5477845073,
0.1737985462,
0.8465304375,
0.0674023628,
0.6636886001,
-0.0887475759,
-0.4494715333,
0.0728108883,
-0.5682668686,
-0.5517798662,
-0.4318373203,
0.5114143491,
-0.1648907363,
-1.0868353844,
0.5681700706,
0.1476761103,
-0.1795045584,
0.3742336929,
0.7484397888,
-0.1061922684,
1.5135594606,
0.4459760785,
-0.1012406051,
0.1198016629,
0.0006888685,
0.0881819353,
-0.4196086228,
-0.4602607489,
-0.8349098563,
0.0820100084,
-0.9348751903,
-0.154234603,
0.3337540627,
-0.1906735897,
0.0560661145,
0.1266913414,
-0.1872425526,
0.3200644553,
0.1045624837,
0.149945125,
0.3519493341,
-0.0518844798,
-0.2481223643,
-0.0392495468,
-0.9776902199,
-0.510591805,
0.7323530912,
0.2082398832,
1.1667351723,
0.0250656474,
0.2133681625,
0.4321168065,
0.2347792089,
-0.9427084327,
0.7065204978,
-0.0012092296,
-0.750661552,
-0.263743937,
-0.5505533814,
-1.0271410942,
0.0922417492,
-0.2660135925,
-0.8269212842,
0.0999389589,
0.3295425177,
-0.3477620482,
0.2274352014,
-0.6228160858,
0.5369315743,
-0.0385327898,
-0.3320935369,
-0.524920702,
-0.413310647,
0.4535605907,
-0.0452617854,
0.3990560174,
0.0426669717,
-0.0145577211,
0.6310266256,
-0.3355273008,
1.2243106365,
-0.0538993515,
-0.6699502468,
0.2680160403,
0.466986537,
0.6899661422,
-0.1200496852,
-0.0948416144,
-0.2162968665,
0.0263973642,
-0.5624902248,
-0.5697072744,
0.7707078457,
-0.6850783825,
-1.0350738764,
-0.4205540419,
-0.7409689426,
-0.2408396453,
0.1277109683,
0.5196592212,
0.7124789953,
-0.0331428908,
-0.0816636384,
0.7685242891,
-0.0761397555,
0.2874885798,
0.3743421435,
-0.4576438069,
0.0171635766,
0.5930227637,
0.2886769176,
0.5966889858,
0.3774836063,
0.0414216481,
-0.3963443935,
-0.2354196757,
-0.1964821517,
0.4584934413,
-0.4661570787,
0.0861931518,
-0.3912985027,
0.0228267573,
-0.49695158,
0.2233890295,
-0.0708994865,
-0.5800105929,
0.0150568662,
0.0848713517,
0.0720531195,
1.1751904488,
0.2870620191,
0.0835942328,
-0.6141706705,
0.0617656484,
0.7232465744,
0.0441018082,
0.1902194321,
-0.6373129487,
-0.0905864313,
0.3391922712,
-0.3143308759,
-0.9332529902,
0.2172327936,
-0.1730180681,
0.4143378437,
0.5051754713,
0.1946573853,
0.4959652126,
-0.1440737396,
0.7968989015,
0.0732703581,
-0.9044661522,
0.3091134429,
-0.467179656,
0.592692256,
0.0743288025,
0.6883994341,
-0.901676774,
-0.6604338884,
-0.4471663535,
-0.4032104909,
0.5904223919,
-0.0578057542,
0.1676058024,
0.1475960463,
0.5293631554,
0.0790987536,
0.2461456954,
-0.7804264426,
-0.1000988483,
0.0113165537,
0.073859401,
-0.2373057008,
-0.4840243757,
-0.1558488905,
-0.0050285612,
0.4610384107,
-0.2239993066,
0.0561659262,
0.3977443874,
-0.108378239,
-0.3121763468,
0.4517095089,
0.8692600131,
0.9199699759,
0.1174708456,
0.2307766676,
0.191546157,
-0.6410418749,
0.2411691099,
-0.0766439363,
-0.4216970801,
-0.1609844416,
0.5336091518,
0.7153184414,
0.199922204,
-0.7816109061,
0.4924920797,
-0.1097465456,
-0.0607042536,
-0.3092566431,
0.1795669198,
0.1377911121,
0.0894943774,
0.3927127719,
0.28814134,
0.1662714779,
-0.9401347041,
-0.1500341147,
0.7069256902,
-0.4618560076,
-0.6963044405,
0.5160455704,
-0.0543068796,
-0.3426955044,
0.5775399804,
-0.0533953086,
-0.7418999076,
0.4338904321,
0.7084282041,
0.7199564576,
-0.4902144074,
0.3173393607,
0.2088252306,
0.5398769379,
-0.2382956296,
0.3630201221,
0.0607389919,
-0.6322715282,
-0.7930257916,
-0.2374809533,
-0.394061476,
0.0599641167,
-0.8221951127,
0.1341962963,
-0.4380099475,
-0.4141619205,
0.0653344616,
-0.1225177273,
-0.1300641894,
0.1608493477,
0.335041374,
0.8603459001,
-0.7487196326,
1.0211336613,
0.7871467471,
-0.1886648089,
-0.8575162292,
0.3628165722,
0.1571842134,
-0.815520525,
0.5187419057,
0.099983409,
-0.5302140117,
-0.3105193675,
-0.8462828398,
-0.5603817701,
0.6215997338,
0.7410013676,
-0.7337723374,
-0.3586573601,
0.1797761768,
0.6183435321,
-0.322860539,
0.3176834285,
0.3044889569,
0.417039901,
0.0070021711,
-1.2870429754,
0.2448794395,
-0.1011122316,
-0.1133984253,
0.1384533346,
-0.7454397082,
0.8575060368,
-0.6513827443,
-0.1768936962,
0.216933459,
0.3679711521,
0.3422304392,
0.2857693434,
0.8101400733,
0.3203464448,
0.8065961003,
0.0335280783,
1.1746792793,
-0.2383565307,
0.2330372036,
0.7192304134,
-0.4139644802,
0.8926611543,
0.4154488444,
-0.0210343711,
0.8599749207,
0.4403997064,
0.3396933079,
0.1046372801,
0.1626300365,
-0.208605364,
-0.5807756186,
-0.2451466024,
-0.1098911762,
0.4596604705,
0.5752211213,
-0.0983360782,
0.0015442549,
-0.1598631442,
0.3722487092,
0.1717860401,
-0.5826917291,
0.6792370081,
0.2014240474,
-1.1559755802,
0.8281219602,
-0.1515794992,
0.7538782358,
-0.666868329,
0.1844353378,
-0.124922663,
0.08823172,
-0.3718405366,
-0.8188892007,
0.1840971112,
-0.0850761682,
-0.3534050286,
0.0442982651,
0.5343702435,
-0.2318288535,
-0.2122252584,
0.2485972345,
0.4384451807,
-0.0082504647,
-0.1519070566,
-0.6957932711,
-0.1762149483,
0.0644125268,
0.0558513254,
0.341870904,
0.4525990188,
-0.4363113642,
1.2633363008,
0.5216498971,
0.2152757645,
-0.3415389061,
-0.3368518949,
0.7570356727,
-0.6503891349,
-0.6193248034,
-1.0773793459,
0.0100774113,
0.2058878541,
-0.0858193785,
0.8592144847,
0.4491247833,
0.6741120815,
-0.0013590652,
0.8201657534,
0.1769800931,
0.4252753556,
-0.4367597699,
0.605918467,
-0.2510083616,
0.4300519526,
-0.3351629376,
-0.8734679222,
0.0159405731,
0.4146491289,
-0.5464818478,
0.2615216076,
0.7014849186,
0.9165330529,
0.2078178227,
0.397246629,
0.4242118895,
0.9485242367,
-0.0545753948,
0.5880826116,
1.193363905,
0.2628339827,
0.4633276761,
0.079676576,
-0.214188531,
-0.2109985054,
-0.5686725974,
-0.7312617898,
-0.7284598351,
-0.1689354628,
-0.5708591342,
0.2420884222,
1.0417969227,
0.7165168524,
-0.8561307192,
-0.6875214577,
0.0512000397,
0.0707445219,
-0.0925476179,
-0.2170373797,
0.0024161108,
-0.0577224456,
-0.5429323316,
-0.0458431691,
0.2692389786,
0.0541087091,
-0.7467147112,
0.1110514328,
0.062220268,
0.1245315149,
0.6742169857,
0.2835820317,
-0.9637517333,
-0.2130954266,
0.0920655206,
-0.3250191212,
-0.188557446,
0.9455060959,
-0.9169541597,
0.1758784205,
0.3266920149,
-0.009471938,
0.0476582833,
-0.2318703979,
0.6458933353,
-0.3006442785,
0.3268669248,
0.3133099675,
0.343980372,
0.4082748592,
-0.4543020725,
-0.1564390063,
0.4145826697,
-0.690530777,
-0.6771928668,
0.4173926115,
-0.8360016346,
-0.3603929281,
0.9915654659,
-0.1165926903,
-0.4841238558,
-0.153666392,
-0.5170624256,
-0.2542722821,
-0.5252002478,
1.2058367729,
1.0372934341,
-0.2253088206,
-0.0457460023,
-0.5979317427,
0.4703923762,
0.6943406463,
-0.6985704899,
0.422227025,
0.5813020468,
0.2688593268,
0.1962518543,
0.4324814081,
0.0306252949,
0.3830161095,
-0.2002675831,
-0.299821049,
0.3327997029,
-0.18076846,
-0.4799484313,
0.2281039357,
0.6470064521,
0.3893891275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09406v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09406v1
|
Alternatives to the Scaled Dot Product for Attention in the Transformer Neural Network Architecture
| 2023-11-15T22:10:42 | 2023-11-15T22:10:42 |
James Bernhard
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.NE, I.2.0; I.2.7
|
The transformer neural network architecture uses a form of attention in which
the dot product of query and key is divided by the square root of the key
dimension before applying softmax. This scaling of the dot product is designed
to avoid the absolute value of the dot products becoming so large that applying
softmax leads to vanishing gradients. In this paper, we propose some
alternative scalings, including dividing the dot product instead by the sum of
the key lengths before applying softmax. We use simulated keys and queries to
show that in many situations this appears to be more effective at avoiding
regions where applying softmax leads to vanishing gradients.
|
[
-0.573751092,
-0.5306297541,
0.1380629241,
0.3954287171,
-0.0017432392,
-0.160707742,
-0.2802060544,
-0.2576681376,
0.2342830449,
0.3935412467,
-0.6766840816,
-0.154542923,
-0.4759528935,
-0.1965704262,
-0.1204512939,
0.8756601214,
0.1813855916,
-0.0251763128,
-0.2126436234,
-0.4984990358,
-0.2340109646,
-0.4608235955,
-0.992503047,
-0.4315241277,
0.9611632228,
0.5181024075,
0.9587070942,
0.4854463935,
1.0119403601,
0.3656153083,
-0.4978457987,
-0.0559655428,
-0.6726633906,
0.1802352071,
0.0836843625,
-0.7894243598,
-0.7770268917,
0.2571786344,
0.603833437,
0.8073616028,
0.1244968176,
0.4576202035,
0.0477889031,
1.0954577923,
-0.8248226643,
0.0762792602,
-0.3002248406,
0.5100036263,
0.1588714868,
0.0861200914,
-0.375934124,
-0.2743126154,
0.2842354178,
-0.5666534305,
0.4586606622,
-0.1900084168,
0.6389849186,
0.4739345312,
-0.5099772811,
0.1865834594,
-1.0306963921,
0.8570501804,
-0.3972527981,
0.4121268988,
0.0581540391,
0.5548979044,
0.3185552955,
-0.874283731,
-0.4467971623,
-0.0072588017,
-0.1379434764,
0.2359642982,
-0.4393157363,
0.1036734059,
0.440361172,
0.5786934495,
-0.406473577,
-0.1596335769,
-0.3187520504,
0.0015528819,
0.429864347,
0.3569015861,
-0.132521227,
0.0078202365,
-0.6527095437,
-0.3929060698,
-0.997379601,
0.2601560354,
0.1843373775,
0.2805303335,
0.4648233056,
0.644446075,
-0.0412106328,
0.4646802545,
0.7415421605,
0.0021332828,
0.4219099283,
-0.2051368505,
-0.5546867847,
-0.1348915696,
0.4055144489,
0.7077382207,
0.2348797023,
-0.2139522433,
-0.3437002897,
-0.0811254457,
0.5811522007,
-0.9428917766,
0.0256212149,
0.2228182107,
-0.8475281596,
-0.3249031603,
-0.5886993408,
-0.6559457779,
-0.0916462243,
-0.4356327057,
0.7572844625,
-0.15850766,
-0.2557492256,
-0.0094737429,
-0.1788165122,
0.4367368519,
-0.090847224,
-0.7786325812,
0.6129553914,
0.5237019658,
0.8216884732,
-0.0924682915,
-0.0163604245,
-0.2830942571,
-0.2787781656,
-0.5107417107,
0.6901339889,
-0.3993590772,
-0.7269768715,
-0.1706643105,
-0.0050007571,
-0.0707889795,
-1.0200371742,
0.5776860714,
-0.8399425149,
0.1002361402,
-0.3068252504,
-0.2797854841,
-0.4921334684,
0.2848359644,
-0.8219839931,
0.8544635773,
0.2986603975,
-0.456184119,
0.3087644875,
-0.8572452068,
-0.7488705516,
-0.1263479441,
0.3740107119,
-0.9141353965,
0.3206861913,
0.2395486236,
0.2924626172,
0.0507276542,
-0.3519891202,
-0.2408265471,
-0.233140707,
0.3529583514,
-0.453301847,
0.7869689465,
0.0463661142,
-0.623296082,
0.1042859256,
-1.0492005348,
0.1912096143,
0.2569814324,
-0.1478082985,
-0.3045546114,
-0.0066406494,
0.190163061,
0.2361575812,
0.0010803068,
-0.5548416972,
-0.014674346,
-0.6408205628,
0.3911424279,
0.8651960492,
0.2280634791,
0.9877567291,
-0.0162730888,
0.8172175288,
0.1398138404,
0.8392413259,
0.1205415726,
-0.4305430949,
-1.3088867664,
-0.2409029007,
0.3067277372,
0.2491532117,
-0.5645494461,
0.2378796488,
-0.3826412857,
-0.4611460268,
-0.374770999,
-0.1266644746,
0.3967538476,
0.7783875465,
0.4018317163,
-0.1047475189,
-0.3109747469,
-1.3078504801,
-0.2403760701,
0.2498785704,
-0.414826721,
0.6090923548,
0.25095281,
0.0399427265,
0.8792030811,
-0.6942746639,
-0.6464486718,
-0.1001364514,
-0.0274978541,
0.4075056314,
0.2961842418,
0.5770116448,
-1.1442582607,
-0.7885888219,
-0.1556717008,
-0.1707428843,
0.2615290284,
-0.2191822082,
-0.109610185,
-0.2799041569,
0.4377561808,
-0.7201628685,
0.5514519811,
0.2650093138,
-0.2840697467,
0.106411159,
-0.0194545221,
-0.0473755673,
-1.0013856888,
0.3349877894,
0.272813648,
-0.3016963303,
-0.8223634362,
0.2737089396,
0.2775468826,
-0.2250800729,
-0.6258745193,
0.1502441615,
-0.7744832635,
-0.238657847,
-0.1571242362,
-0.131814748,
0.3155597448,
0.775796175,
-0.0792454183,
0.9507401586,
0.2458767891,
-0.5949819088,
0.5479986668,
0.3936065435,
0.1310879886,
0.800567627,
-1.1179332733,
0.0235278439,
-0.0757453218,
0.0548745953,
-1.0955728292,
0.5645113587,
0.0163530391,
-0.6484046578,
0.5325843096,
-0.1191219911,
-0.1184002161,
-0.6348788738,
-0.691650629,
0.537381053,
0.6853895187,
-0.5878836513,
0.6854618788,
0.2183742076,
0.2958192825,
-0.4589828849,
-0.9662311077,
0.103250891,
-0.4561235607,
-0.7746551037,
0.3008908629,
-0.0670746118,
-0.2617167234,
0.1367292553,
-0.186362505,
0.0921702087,
-0.0782285035,
0.3207134008,
0.2885273397,
-0.8299723268,
-0.0085224472,
-0.3584322333,
-0.5351625085,
0.1725388318,
-0.4833856225,
0.0964206159,
-0.0994153023,
-0.2189373374,
-0.1983950585,
0.5696731806,
0.7652778625,
-0.3163966238,
0.645409584,
0.3103639185,
-0.2419461161,
-0.3286913633,
-0.2981413305,
-0.2607410252,
-0.6102383137,
0.1823051572,
-0.475931108,
-0.4446473122,
0.5602320433,
-0.0600074455,
0.0290232673,
0.7820929885,
0.6324909329,
-0.0082248002,
1.0816400051,
0.9230149388,
0.0900367349,
0.5914950967,
-0.5525690913,
0.7665594816,
-1.2941418886,
-0.1697464138,
-0.428237319,
-1.0909352303,
-0.2757340074,
-0.6387770176,
0.7775793076,
-0.4400963783,
-0.1781978756,
0.3655323982,
-0.9250357151,
0.6230253577,
0.7735185623,
0.2396612763,
-0.0183564574,
0.1366853416,
0.1569129974,
-0.3121112287,
-0.8087493181,
0.1914678663,
1.2976150513,
0.3919035196,
0.613224566,
-0.2384528071,
0.1979176551,
0.0867112577,
0.3958097398,
-1.2903690338,
0.3973249793,
0.1846175641,
-0.682843864,
-0.582824707,
-0.375325799,
-0.9351187944,
0.4410961568,
0.0828314498,
-0.2895736098,
0.7801392078,
-0.0646151528,
-0.7105234265,
0.3013851345,
-1.0789973736,
0.7488590479,
0.2018309236,
-0.1372850537,
-0.2524413466,
-0.6515313387,
0.0459711701,
0.1329891682,
-0.1337317824,
0.36637339,
-0.4393998384,
0.7029551864,
-0.6660974026,
0.7928491235,
-0.0951141119,
0.0613018535,
0.4570189714,
0.0412670709,
0.5738337636,
-0.1391903758,
0.3473620415,
-0.2057084292,
-0.9147824049,
-0.4281556904,
-0.6221160293,
0.5973519683,
-0.7269672155,
-0.6741898656,
-0.1727131009,
-0.5393877029,
-0.4095385075,
0.1206151098,
0.2934762239,
0.5224360228,
-0.0886732712,
0.3837809861,
1.0028947592,
0.1161203533,
0.8952628374,
0.3242278695,
0.3046506345,
-0.3541801274,
0.767603159,
0.4858832955,
0.5052797794,
0.3997728527,
0.1606880724,
-0.3958341777,
-0.2631992102,
-0.2114269137,
-0.015225675,
-0.5993185639,
-0.5457894802,
-0.5666984916,
-0.437803179,
-0.4630171955,
-0.1999427676,
-0.730053544,
-0.7141339779,
-0.1109544933,
-0.2266497016,
0.4673211873,
0.5309147239,
-0.3367418647,
0.2301256955,
-0.5736408234,
0.4114374518,
0.7512170672,
0.5767666101,
0.3255822361,
-0.5645289421,
-0.2723661661,
-0.1263085604,
-0.3787005842,
-0.6619460583,
0.2025384754,
0.4042648077,
0.4819787443,
0.7676741481,
-0.0184210166,
0.3862633407,
-0.8594145179,
0.6772806644,
0.5131699443,
-0.6478036046,
0.23019889,
-0.1703165621,
0.4316885471,
0.1261001676,
0.3609776497,
-0.7413060665,
-0.1026880592,
-0.6815029979,
-0.9261974692,
0.5331974626,
0.4949060977,
0.3405836523,
0.2760449052,
0.2038777471,
-0.2503975034,
-0.0038933838,
-0.4972345531,
-0.860708952,
-0.2030238807,
0.2678879201,
-0.2008614391,
-0.4917012751,
-0.3271093667,
-0.2744356096,
0.5534374714,
0.0196156614,
0.4121167958,
0.2334638238,
0.0517556779,
-0.3178769052,
-0.186920315,
0.4751221836,
0.4324311018,
0.0099453665,
0.1760202944,
0.1031060144,
-0.6834452748,
0.1788662076,
-0.3324351311,
-0.2012529522,
0.0354080126,
0.0769007206,
0.5571534634,
0.1980275065,
-0.0696849972,
0.6450456977,
-0.1160837039,
-0.5301176906,
0.0719491765,
-0.1830620021,
0.4867390394,
0.4234253168,
0.4428387284,
0.3839441836,
0.393337518,
-0.1519474089,
0.2200224996,
0.3199030757,
-0.6273716092,
-0.2093512118,
0.7929415703,
0.2513613403,
-0.6076207757,
0.5746166706,
0.2935986519,
-0.6696689129,
1.2682617903,
0.4109846652,
1.1045366526,
-0.3535523415,
0.2526932359,
0.3528057337,
0.5322214365,
0.4776520133,
-0.1026636884,
-0.1768914014,
-0.3283621371,
-0.4337333441,
-0.3088743985,
-0.1529528052,
-0.1404277533,
-0.6996810436,
0.0145365782,
-0.5712473392,
-0.4747442603,
0.2954241037,
-0.1408700645,
-0.5442336798,
0.5161289573,
0.174036026,
0.805254519,
-0.6350903511,
0.4960635602,
0.3608114421,
-0.3553614616,
-0.7286390662,
-0.1216782704,
-0.2131969184,
-0.8794024587,
0.574858129,
-0.0534781069,
-0.0259002876,
-0.2847886682,
-0.3420794904,
-1.1002138853,
0.851909399,
-0.0718340874,
-0.2484012693,
-0.0683650672,
0.4267619848,
0.6874710321,
-0.0859853923,
0.1546124071,
0.368696481,
0.4123910367,
0.1692767441,
-0.4263358712,
-0.0066794902,
-0.2716403008,
0.2820859849,
0.1807411462,
-1.0927290916,
1.0169993639,
-0.1271208078,
-0.1890918463,
-0.4625521898,
0.526745677,
-0.6193710566,
-0.1190659702,
0.7770599723,
0.7237514853,
0.1720928848,
0.1280392259,
0.9185863137,
-0.1148914993,
0.6677558422,
0.8357889652,
-0.0132903904,
0.6403885484,
0.6125919819,
-0.5501325727,
0.0575295091,
0.7094166279,
-0.1552156657,
0.4922866821,
0.2409494668,
-0.1108531877,
-0.0971424729,
0.0495707802,
-0.5893500447,
0.1277524829,
0.1891533285,
-0.3488325477,
-0.2805148959,
0.1242689192,
-0.2341916263,
-0.091496706,
-0.4970361888,
0.827455163,
0.155726701,
-0.2817804813,
0.8828846812,
-0.2550419569,
0.4663490653,
-0.1905916333,
0.2401486486,
-0.7257759571,
0.5097497702,
-0.2211568505,
-0.5420983434,
0.5925563574,
-0.3935084939,
-0.4846971333,
-0.3799721301,
0.6461527348,
0.0455347225,
-0.7748168111,
0.2426454723,
0.1541647613,
-0.3842198253,
-0.2945003808,
-0.6449841261,
-0.5234410167,
-0.1665366888,
-1.0926568508,
0.3214379549,
0.6213901043,
0.4363001287,
0.7491639256,
0.4904452562,
-0.1355397999,
0.4086595774,
-0.0564737506,
1.1263016462,
-0.3939329684,
-0.4797598422,
-0.4764469862,
0.4249459505,
-0.3381706476,
-0.3513577878,
0.8715110421,
0.7740156651,
0.3607285917,
-0.1930405796,
0.2764522433,
0.3022767603,
0.3521589041,
0.0902201235,
0.7520734072,
-0.7470610142,
-0.2940990925,
0.0986985415,
-1.2818982601,
-0.6049038768,
0.3516224623,
-0.1579605788,
-0.1301246285,
0.8181724548,
0.7319378257,
-0.3067744374,
-0.2038578093,
0.6789805889,
0.3284572959,
0.1524931341,
0.6215881705,
0.4419930577,
-0.5532790422,
0.9127036333,
-0.1594525427,
-0.2193605155,
-0.2937482595,
-0.3067392707,
-0.9120947719,
-0.3338921964,
-0.1311662495,
-0.4180597663,
-0.3493893743,
0.0594441108,
0.8904747367,
-0.7728751898,
0.2724476457,
0.0557608344,
0.2500528991,
-0.3909773231,
-0.2069788277,
0.5287735462,
-0.6111806035,
-0.8426991701,
0.114160724,
0.4174517393,
0.0213600956,
-0.5059919357,
0.4027474821,
0.1484509557,
0.3804460764,
0.7519003153,
0.1841781735,
-0.2059423327,
-0.3085124791,
0.4777665734,
-0.2799648643,
0.670896709,
1.0315355062,
-0.7012372613,
0.2558442652,
0.6048559546,
0.6323331594,
0.6470409036,
-0.3325096071,
0.6375015974,
-0.6962465048,
0.4768090248,
0.5359864831,
0.1365615427,
0.1647739112,
-0.7770811915,
0.4229706526,
0.1118863001,
-0.5924249291,
-0.2802461088,
0.1226382554,
-0.8500542045,
-0.2908214331,
1.1209639311,
-0.2368070781,
-0.7350136638,
0.2320386022,
-0.2879982591,
-0.1242202222,
-0.2074787319,
0.5652794838,
0.340697974,
0.1529918611,
0.041022487,
-0.2765682936,
0.4789372981,
0.6029937267,
-0.1271587014,
0.1078437865,
0.215553984,
0.2015574276,
0.3790801764,
0.2917907238,
-0.2536469698,
0.3293526769,
0.4600344896,
-0.0624674633,
0.2882240713,
-0.2464497089,
-0.4971511662,
0.6564030647,
-0.1442830861,
-0.720725596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09404v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09404v1
|
To Translate or Not to Translate: A Systematic Investigation of Translation-Based Cross-Lingual Transfer to Low-Resource Languages
| 2023-11-15T22:03:28 | 2023-11-15T22:03:28 |
Benedikt Ebing, Goran Glavaš
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Perfect machine translation (MT) would render cross-lingual transfer (XLT) by
means of multilingual language models (LMs) superfluous. Given, on one hand,
the large body of work on improving XLT with multilingual LMs and, on the other
hand, recent advances in massively multilingual MT, in this work, we
systematically evaluate existing and propose new translation-based XLT
approaches for transfer to low-resource languages. We show that all
translation-based approaches dramatically outperform zero-shot XLT with
multilingual LMs, rendering the approach that combines the round-trip
translation of the source-language training data with the translation of the
target-language test instances the most effective. We next show that one can
obtain further empirical gains by adding reliable translations to other
high-resource languages to the training data. Moreover, we propose an effective
translation-based XLT strategy even for languages not supported by the MT
system. Finally, we show that model selection for XLT based on target-language
validation data obtained with MT outperforms model selection based on the
source-language data. We hope that our findings encourage adoption of more
robust translation-based baselines in XLT research.
|
[
-0.3260071576,
-0.4278822839,
0.587715745,
0.1168558151,
-0.0776512548,
0.2267795056,
-0.3277567625,
-0.6644388437,
0.0287103169,
0.4105249345,
-0.2943696976,
-0.0548163168,
-0.6932914257,
0.368366152,
-0.5767040253,
0.9856461883,
-0.469910264,
0.160987854,
0.1764169931,
-0.4611159265,
-0.4583041668,
-0.6041890383,
-0.5609833002,
-0.3529181182,
0.4894173145,
0.4680147767,
0.8069694042,
0.5514115691,
0.4183587134,
0.153526336,
0.1406310648,
0.1287929863,
-0.5955833793,
-0.3370632529,
-0.3736248016,
-0.486951828,
-0.477856189,
-0.1891462952,
0.6082104445,
0.9161958694,
0.134594366,
0.2652086914,
0.0672474578,
0.520611763,
-0.6069406271,
0.011300493,
-0.5595093369,
0.3536534607,
-0.1772097647,
-0.0501628891,
-0.7149157524,
-0.0904774293,
-0.1044790968,
-0.4596629441,
-0.1405721456,
0.2958555222,
0.5275353193,
0.0133902067,
-0.5770047307,
-0.0980392322,
-0.9096229076,
1.0495206118,
-0.6435284019,
0.62388134,
0.458306551,
0.3150811493,
0.3370969594,
-0.3904249966,
-0.3419879675,
-0.3713212609,
-0.1641083658,
0.1940837055,
-0.305411756,
-0.2549650371,
0.2048663944,
0.2595698833,
-0.6547809839,
0.1575974375,
-0.280620575,
-0.0562430136,
0.3153889477,
-0.057583075,
0.4496691525,
-0.0914963409,
-0.5231888294,
-0.1384299845,
-0.7645298839,
-0.1004246697,
-0.064124085,
0.729092896,
-0.3198278546,
0.6105213165,
-0.0235739984,
0.6121435165,
0.0040388778,
0.0351721384,
0.0381310731,
-0.8094881773,
-0.1891950816,
0.0723517016,
0.814530313,
0.2340092063,
0.2560217381,
-0.5712273121,
-0.3253503144,
-0.1801397502,
-0.1034738272,
-0.6862014532,
0.3517834246,
-0.0515748598,
-0.3776005208,
-0.0396838151,
-0.4217143953,
-0.3868520856,
0.0806999505,
-0.2328383625,
0.4546519518,
-0.6293577552,
-0.4044539332,
-0.0386780277,
0.3076822162,
0.1837254763,
0.3119619489,
-0.7853152156,
0.1887838393,
0.2460217327,
0.9837424755,
-0.382776469,
-0.3766627312,
-0.6227934957,
0.1698783189,
-0.8169662952,
0.7343545556,
-0.3153366446,
-0.309766084,
0.1676661819,
0.1644531488,
-0.223429665,
-0.4018593132,
0.5582942367,
-0.4304010272,
0.3544479609,
-0.5153468847,
-0.2893936932,
-0.2942605615,
0.3560402393,
-0.6740600467,
0.8758040071,
0.2898215353,
-0.4262107909,
0.195354566,
-0.7637958527,
-0.6072379947,
-0.0477621555,
0.2997792065,
-0.127055198,
0.0011751631,
0.1861203015,
0.262732923,
-0.3534730375,
0.0113905696,
-0.265650183,
-0.3005635738,
0.1326394379,
-0.5162734389,
0.8612604737,
0.509513557,
-0.3415460885,
-0.2233014405,
-0.5076881051,
0.2266890854,
0.1479454935,
-0.2190703303,
-0.3987038434,
-0.4008514881,
0.3039080501,
0.558478415,
0.1490891874,
-0.465228796,
0.0561714917,
-0.1815950423,
0.2886142731,
0.35020715,
-0.5888800025,
0.7972977161,
-0.4077084661,
0.6315248609,
-0.1537378281,
-0.0049190437,
-0.1216874272,
-0.1695345044,
-0.5844630599,
0.0264494941,
0.6174874902,
0.8463028669,
-1.3384970427,
-0.0826057717,
-0.3952503204,
-0.4285847545,
-0.593205452,
0.197486788,
0.593134284,
0.5132623911,
0.683161974,
-0.3165798485,
-0.3077075481,
-0.7903399467,
-0.3212392926,
-0.1636886001,
0.3121967316,
0.0806220621,
0.22289446,
-0.0447381288,
0.3716054261,
0.1125707701,
-0.2139343023,
-0.8196643591,
0.0595853329,
-0.0375121534,
0.4610546827,
0.9327873588,
-0.5937535763,
-1.1780984402,
0.6817023754,
-0.7249189019,
-0.0742767826,
-0.1586341411,
-0.1523560733,
0.5380811095,
0.3039710522,
-0.4945355952,
0.1619252861,
0.8923135996,
-0.0894672573,
0.4174060822,
-0.231994018,
0.449162215,
-1.0112159252,
0.3948511779,
-0.182810083,
-0.644264102,
-0.8130050302,
0.0507992879,
0.3835825324,
-0.0966220126,
-0.7808736563,
0.7288638353,
-0.5016396046,
-0.1013810635,
-0.2703903615,
0.1081804559,
-0.1319766194,
0.4638263583,
0.0689851344,
0.6991892457,
0.3941404521,
-0.2988283932,
0.2664307356,
0.155084908,
-0.1141766459,
0.8588782549,
-0.2551662028,
0.1308157742,
0.1339926124,
0.2044827044,
-0.6495344043,
0.1677993089,
0.4701933265,
-0.3480845988,
0.6286988854,
-0.3495407403,
-0.5161290765,
0.0099684559,
0.0000328295,
0.5239226818,
0.4630735219,
-0.389710784,
0.324395597,
0.0755239278,
-0.3248713017,
-0.5046605468,
-0.9803016782,
0.4824283421,
-0.1891474873,
-0.3689001501,
0.2327284813,
-0.1360116601,
-0.0725762323,
0.1171418056,
-0.0513098128,
-0.2929054797,
-0.1391247809,
-0.4084438086,
0.3034625947,
-0.3874855936,
-0.1576105058,
-0.1464425772,
-0.2217571884,
-0.2500846386,
-0.4841260314,
0.2478578389,
-0.0133663407,
-0.4636422098,
-0.2814561129,
0.5946625471,
0.6111371517,
-0.2202109098,
0.6473647356,
0.7220686078,
-0.2083338201,
-0.1417785585,
-0.4217389226,
0.0367096625,
-0.2951282859,
0.5325750709,
-0.4633856714,
-0.6398113966,
0.3061901629,
-0.0285554342,
0.2691113949,
0.39842242,
0.46385023,
0.1242301017,
1.1598156691,
1.0192573071,
-0.0436256528,
0.487226963,
-0.2164680958,
0.3472598195,
-0.6090656519,
0.1625978649,
-0.5696492195,
-0.2051499933,
-0.6547466516,
-0.4615028501,
0.1714504361,
-0.047362946,
0.0932834372,
0.8811837435,
-0.1112354249,
0.2545137405,
0.3048709929,
-0.3077743948,
0.4879182279,
0.2467763871,
-0.3009025455,
-0.1668790132,
-1.0636109114,
-0.392019242,
1.0657337904,
0.094128482,
0.5529091358,
0.2166147232,
0.3314911425,
0.1971788257,
0.5548957586,
-0.748446703,
0.3024805784,
-0.4360229075,
-0.5965015292,
-0.4118920863,
-0.63694489,
-0.8581819534,
0.5486298203,
-0.1346817613,
-0.30305475,
0.0965300873,
0.0313659273,
-0.2631714046,
0.6019022465,
-0.8605723977,
0.9255596399,
-0.7874883413,
-0.5851764679,
-0.0384650752,
-0.4280447662,
0.2718528509,
-0.592535615,
0.6432210207,
0.0780865252,
-0.0757890418,
0.3566664755,
-0.267141819,
0.5249550343,
0.0799194053,
-0.3233213425,
0.0645072609,
0.488737464,
0.5236112475,
-0.4252876043,
-0.2260233164,
0.4596868157,
0.212462157,
-0.5804813504,
-0.567043364,
0.4885653555,
-0.6869933605,
-0.2266422659,
-0.3378257453,
-0.8134519458,
-0.273812443,
0.5396579504,
0.177041173,
0.0783302337,
-0.1425095052,
0.092245467,
0.3294343352,
-0.2626281977,
0.3120805919,
0.8038505912,
-0.3536747992,
-0.3120837212,
1.0370641947,
0.3987189233,
0.7753771544,
0.5815229416,
0.0376122184,
-0.3590724468,
-0.5683578253,
-1.0181339979,
0.1778827906,
-0.5805362463,
-0.0350265503,
-0.4221060872,
-0.0731478781,
-0.5229356885,
-0.294418782,
-0.7043440938,
-0.54218328,
0.1890193969,
0.0063936692,
-0.0918354988,
0.4390039444,
-0.4228348732,
0.0687594637,
-0.9541950822,
0.1868539304,
-0.0432469398,
0.0452161431,
-0.1633600593,
-0.8048970699,
-0.6279771924,
0.2685626447,
-0.2615051568,
-0.6597883105,
0.6753972769,
0.0700080767,
0.698803246,
0.024626784,
0.1519891769,
0.7993388176,
-0.6514703631,
0.6210621595,
0.4398114383,
-0.8708892465,
0.1914035082,
-0.1055019423,
0.2217491716,
0.2956652641,
0.5481293201,
-0.8699184656,
-0.2815416157,
-0.3332802057,
-0.7891770005,
0.9288578033,
0.289650619,
0.0694802776,
0.3939710259,
-0.0785556138,
0.2511290312,
-0.0327122249,
-0.9626706243,
-0.1474384964,
-0.2965682745,
0.0466599427,
-0.2251028866,
0.1185412481,
0.0684495941,
0.1184609532,
0.59607023,
-0.2893442512,
-0.0644650459,
0.0906126723,
-0.5027275085,
-0.4768868983,
0.5672546625,
0.4420632422,
0.5584880114,
-0.1468977332,
0.1759383231,
0.589841783,
-0.0991499126,
0.3593157828,
0.1112096533,
-0.4128082097,
0.1420366019,
0.4510599971,
0.7816390395,
0.3875285089,
-0.4436024129,
0.3299267888,
0.2205590159,
-0.1801412851,
0.0813159496,
-0.336021632,
-0.0664391294,
-0.0190319717,
0.0343463309,
0.2484064996,
-0.0057703797,
-0.6167767048,
-0.0250730794,
0.4263385832,
-0.6958243847,
-0.601074636,
0.5409836769,
0.1600035578,
-0.1002895981,
0.3274706304,
-0.0818484351,
-0.4006174803,
0.3124992251,
0.6445870399,
0.765211165,
-0.3694799542,
0.1939589083,
0.3663276434,
0.6324291825,
-0.307266593,
-0.0604228973,
-0.1611769795,
-0.5506116748,
-0.8078014851,
-0.2597410381,
-0.6088171005,
0.1102368161,
-0.6173930168,
0.2730204761,
0.1730345041,
-0.0846234336,
-0.2984673381,
-0.0247667134,
-0.6732844114,
-0.1772210151,
0.3474095464,
0.8916020989,
-0.8103183508,
0.992632091,
0.7493540645,
-0.5023511648,
-0.6525635123,
-0.199822858,
-0.1302705854,
-0.8706647754,
0.6868801117,
-0.2332162708,
-0.0777138099,
0.0114312824,
-0.2508241236,
-0.8904893994,
0.7908619642,
0.7765665054,
-0.4822832942,
-0.0710042045,
0.6531179547,
0.3771421611,
-0.0862998813,
0.2777319849,
0.2813253105,
0.6855716109,
0.2035135478,
-1.4989449978,
-0.0058218963,
-0.030014487,
0.0233603287,
0.14408575,
-0.6613320708,
0.7225604057,
-0.2931555808,
-0.2964819372,
0.1835615933,
0.356556803,
-0.0628286675,
0.2895151079,
0.2865392268,
0.4617663026,
0.2273148149,
0.1092343479,
1.2323641777,
-0.49259004,
0.4611643553,
0.7988861799,
-0.5343636274,
0.8761701584,
0.5594848394,
-0.1223897487,
0.0070846691,
0.4211903214,
0.2139761299,
0.5547478199,
-0.1936243773,
0.0759042501,
-0.4165093899,
-0.2890839577,
-0.4864410758,
0.2487323135,
0.0841976926,
-0.1655830592,
-0.5293818116,
0.0387467258,
0.2639148533,
-0.0378032327,
-0.2458431572,
0.4335873425,
0.3606708348,
-0.848398149,
0.937959075,
0.1157636046,
0.5900015831,
-0.6582142711,
0.0055841631,
-0.4895856977,
0.1712392569,
-0.0931221247,
-0.5732967257,
0.3983727992,
0.2851059139,
-0.0058844853,
-0.8639845848,
0.5286262631,
-0.7052575946,
-0.6291328073,
0.5022130013,
1.1195840836,
0.2028991878,
0.1139342338,
-0.7505115271,
-0.1169791296,
0.1181426942,
0.0330030471,
0.6327390075,
0.7764289975,
-0.2784982622,
0.4532926381,
0.8524699211,
0.5053206682,
-0.0729092658,
-0.1885824651,
0.4121575654,
-0.6340404749,
-0.3405791819,
-0.6528066397,
0.3079910874,
0.1907849908,
-0.0557511151,
0.8501674533,
0.5218940377,
1.1622871161,
-0.0325512923,
1.0488468409,
-0.0088564437,
0.4554939568,
-0.5613324642,
0.7424501181,
-0.848710835,
0.0781030878,
-0.2371297628,
-0.9301695228,
-0.2960986793,
0.4765915871,
-0.2833699584,
0.0537896454,
0.834551394,
0.6016184688,
-0.2757591903,
-0.3943839371,
0.9151860476,
0.1973587722,
0.2422992587,
0.8699510694,
0.8260080814,
-0.5195366144,
1.1059479713,
-0.3176786304,
-0.250629127,
-0.3179934323,
-1.0091701746,
-0.5338643193,
-0.3001591563,
-0.3175399005,
-0.2025992274,
0.0629635379,
0.8492249846,
0.8094096184,
-0.9225668311,
-0.5935220718,
0.311814785,
0.1442907006,
-0.5396142602,
-0.0962791219,
0.2340023071,
-0.4986563623,
-0.8835870028,
0.5134156346,
0.4442339838,
0.1728769541,
-0.2580137551,
-0.2892642617,
-0.0468631648,
-0.0771737099,
0.9765464664,
0.5588182211,
-0.6082653403,
-0.0849823058,
0.4288991392,
-0.3650198281,
0.0727145001,
0.6658571362,
-0.5085098743,
0.3242647648,
0.4192376435,
0.7387836576,
0.2836090624,
-0.4028668404,
0.713226676,
-0.3190107346,
0.0520550422,
0.1153275743,
0.4427410662,
0.5121186972,
-0.0185112301,
0.6066931486,
0.3098450303,
-0.2029403895,
-1.0015298128,
0.1068594828,
-0.7120181918,
-0.2566150725,
1.2663958073,
-0.1991625726,
-0.1328873336,
-0.2012113631,
-0.0817723125,
0.2479322106,
-0.0886165574,
0.669103384,
0.6551644802,
-0.0589970648,
-0.2302158475,
-0.9483661056,
0.1783078164,
0.676846087,
-0.7109596729,
0.0403489061,
0.2908122241,
0.2304607332,
0.3194114566,
0.5489431024,
-0.3485806584,
0.2068149447,
-0.1927752793,
0.094106853,
0.0119244112,
-0.0598289445,
-0.1589304209,
-0.0020118137,
0.1642609239,
-0.0123979822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09390v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09390v2
|
LEEETs-Dial: Linguistic Entrainment in End-to-End Task-oriented Dialogue systems
| 2023-11-15T21:35:25 | 2024-04-04T11:26:17 |
Nalin Kumar, Ondřej Dušek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Linguistic entrainment, or alignment, represents a phenomenon where
linguistic patterns employed by conversational participants converge to one
another. While entrainment has been shown to produce a more natural user
experience, most dialogue systems do not have any provisions for it. In this
work, we introduce methods for achieving dialogue entrainment in a GPT-2-based
end-to-end task-oriented dialogue system through the utilization of shared
vocabulary. We experiment with training instance weighting,
entrainment-specific loss, and additional conditioning to generate responses
that align with the user. We demonstrate that all three approaches produce
significantly better entrainment than the base, non-entrainment-optimized
model, as confirmed by both automated and manual evaluation metrics.
|
[
-0.2998625934,
-0.5898881555,
0.2443427145,
-0.0999503881,
-0.2898302972,
0.0625858903,
-0.4280043542,
-0.1605703831,
0.2463794649,
0.411221236,
-0.5834020376,
0.0990242511,
-0.4261278808,
0.0821263343,
-0.2263969481,
1.0606007576,
-0.0642462224,
0.0881351233,
-0.3565073907,
-0.2186142057,
-0.7722697854,
-0.4568097889,
-0.7635288239,
-0.6730783582,
0.0032683997,
0.2820951343,
0.7945795655,
0.1071382836,
0.4105065167,
0.2018540949,
0.1076586694,
0.211414665,
-0.7138402462,
0.4367206693,
-0.1306839734,
-0.5285969973,
-0.1587303281,
-0.0380402207,
0.1938059777,
0.6749656796,
-0.3785834014,
-0.1977846771,
0.3846215308,
0.562718451,
-0.4902478158,
-0.1761691272,
-0.4881973565,
0.223228991,
0.0226224232,
-0.4732697308,
-0.3931548297,
-0.1563766599,
0.5755166411,
-0.9306172729,
-0.1002922952,
-0.0041891364,
0.8290318847,
0.5508956313,
-0.3760967553,
-0.4995678961,
-0.5271009803,
0.7258806229,
-0.8305366635,
0.5496559739,
0.5048266053,
-0.0182898361,
-0.038193319,
-0.375700593,
-0.6813802123,
-0.2098144442,
-0.0397567004,
0.6281796098,
0.3886470795,
0.456039995,
0.1620455086,
0.2020939291,
-0.6079985499,
0.0817295462,
-0.0848434642,
-0.0576911718,
0.3619550765,
-0.1208698824,
0.4505205154,
0.1082936823,
-0.3628750741,
0.210187003,
-0.7830247283,
-0.1689219326,
0.524977684,
0.2059390098,
-0.1815712452,
0.5961554646,
-0.1170002222,
0.9220231771,
0.4490796328,
-0.0986768007,
0.3569738567,
-0.2988039553,
-0.4416913092,
0.0625475347,
0.7388208508,
0.8793506026,
0.5237475038,
-0.5442677736,
-0.3042335808,
-0.0708224699,
0.1264390051,
-0.6634639502,
0.255859822,
0.1236632988,
-0.1613906473,
-0.2154491544,
-0.1928504854,
-0.4001561105,
-0.2531166375,
-0.730999589,
0.5191619396,
-0.4722148776,
-0.3675069809,
0.0798413679,
-0.3112498224,
0.406008333,
0.2885118723,
-1.3129382133,
0.585388422,
0.5087612867,
1.1388425827,
-0.2919102013,
-0.0017149124,
-0.4177544415,
0.2652567029,
-0.2879492939,
0.301512748,
-0.6608378887,
-0.4646618962,
0.3772681355,
-0.0869237259,
-0.291470319,
-0.6297965646,
0.1698790789,
-0.4028120041,
0.5535497069,
-0.1857596338,
-0.8549232483,
0.101064302,
0.252359271,
-0.1279904693,
1.2406173944,
0.2490319312,
-0.577519834,
0.4502492249,
-0.5531569123,
-0.2317891121,
0.1575390697,
-0.4594132304,
0.1716019511,
0.1793322414,
-0.1787115037,
0.0504974015,
-0.3286297619,
0.1821131706,
-0.0015384901,
-0.3161167204,
0.2648194134,
-0.1479685158,
0.5667392612,
0.1880161911,
-0.288325429,
-0.0831335112,
-0.3306897879,
0.2213151306,
-0.1513178498,
-0.1427853554,
-0.3749230206,
-0.1816055179,
-0.047899235,
0.1353740394,
0.3078017533,
-0.7932642102,
0.28199628,
-0.5677995682,
0.524602294,
0.4343123734,
0.0539899506,
0.5754780173,
-0.4200065732,
0.4429350793,
0.0592822284,
-0.0981861278,
0.032215599,
-0.5639901757,
-1.0074875355,
0.2520956099,
-0.0058702002,
0.9863701463,
-1.013957262,
0.58716923,
-0.1451788992,
0.0109055154,
-0.3357743323,
0.1864874512,
0.6522108316,
0.3824265599,
0.1067810059,
-0.8138864636,
-0.3546266556,
-0.8484201431,
-0.132864356,
0.0791469365,
-0.2442561537,
0.2459509969,
0.1781539619,
-0.1031058952,
1.1672492027,
-0.2076037079,
-0.2302673757,
-0.0560409576,
0.2145752907,
0.0479673967,
0.5876743793,
0.3469439447,
-0.3602076769,
-0.8964864612,
0.3955744803,
-0.8819134235,
-0.2471742481,
-0.2562831342,
-0.2323718667,
0.2021070421,
0.6692311168,
-0.388566196,
0.3617156148,
0.4798462689,
-0.2027404904,
0.3762570322,
-0.1024345234,
0.0016996264,
-1.1260139942,
-0.2734923065,
-0.1482558101,
-0.3796189129,
-0.9841659069,
-0.3428960145,
-0.318479389,
-0.1311747581,
-0.0189435761,
0.3631590605,
-0.4599396884,
-0.151593551,
-0.3649964333,
0.3678823709,
-0.0557812788,
0.8240215778,
0.1526190639,
1.0428036451,
0.6417148113,
-0.4168916047,
0.48054263,
0.4929915369,
-0.0729234293,
0.9601848125,
-0.7657900453,
0.6136238575,
-0.0675304607,
0.1437534541,
-0.9477114081,
-0.2199040353,
0.1510562003,
-0.3546688855,
0.3522056639,
-0.1470193267,
-0.09874098,
0.0615667254,
-0.0712348819,
0.4414040446,
0.6879091263,
-0.3508579433,
0.2370594889,
0.3579176962,
-0.2934238315,
-0.3370090127,
-0.6279489994,
0.0025490657,
-0.2502233386,
-0.5568968058,
0.1617940217,
0.1243888214,
-0.0707675144,
-0.1406047493,
-0.148679167,
-0.0811039507,
-0.2625233531,
0.1580945849,
-0.0571895093,
0.0537831225,
0.4297003448,
-0.0595869198,
-0.0732636452,
-0.3318680823,
-0.6513666511,
0.6929944158,
0.0185681898,
-0.624771595,
-0.7769952416,
0.6152134538,
0.376876384,
-0.0666546896,
0.7383029461,
0.4441897571,
-0.4638747275,
0.1878501773,
-0.618685782,
-0.2562011778,
-0.4621226192,
0.3675771952,
-0.2723245919,
-0.8937371969,
0.3546656668,
-0.2118588984,
0.2711301744,
0.0366751477,
0.5711143613,
-0.2940508127,
0.7223306894,
0.6331723928,
0.2068563402,
0.7763999701,
-0.0216782521,
0.4297434986,
-1.2264882326,
-0.2076405585,
-0.1881810278,
-0.4629041851,
-0.1480338424,
-0.3859450519,
0.1562207341,
0.3806982934,
-0.5189806223,
0.4260824323,
-0.5685334802,
0.298990339,
0.6495275497,
0.1659913957,
0.1597853452,
0.0954721645,
-0.1191444173,
-0.2607093751,
-0.3932808638,
-0.3959670365,
0.9950197339,
0.0442270525,
0.823775351,
0.3297439516,
0.8545768857,
0.1565788835,
0.1030042171,
-0.8329764009,
0.2862266898,
0.0354701281,
-0.1842336655,
-0.5876656175,
-0.1405394524,
-0.6701113582,
-0.0919659361,
0.158176288,
-1.1069984436,
0.2692040205,
0.1239900142,
-0.3990338445,
-0.3106588423,
-0.9028927088,
0.6849535108,
-0.3471009135,
-0.3605044186,
-0.0237129387,
-0.5923451781,
-0.0959467441,
-0.0567786247,
-0.0560883395,
-0.0707053617,
-0.172242865,
0.8436816931,
-0.8434906006,
0.9213460684,
-0.4009159207,
-0.2009995431,
0.3844968975,
-0.1304698884,
0.5907201171,
-0.0679386184,
0.189204216,
-0.3276538551,
-0.3214569092,
-0.1612455249,
-1.0035187006,
0.4713950455,
-0.8910175562,
-0.4348486066,
-0.0782247931,
-0.5644326806,
-0.6965610981,
-0.0243190527,
0.6057020426,
0.8003966808,
-0.1075978503,
-0.0035061084,
0.7718967199,
-0.03399029,
0.2483560145,
0.2712291479,
-0.2960739136,
-0.4189313054,
0.8658002615,
0.1864279658,
1.0693380833,
0.0659554899,
-0.2455032319,
-0.3041456342,
-0.4223067462,
-0.5124213696,
0.071622178,
-0.4603775144,
-0.1195141822,
-0.2905783951,
-0.456708312,
-0.2410737425,
-0.4775722325,
-0.2083083987,
-0.5617208481,
0.028260313,
-0.0934115574,
0.3582247794,
0.7107514739,
-0.0024262688,
0.8614907861,
-0.4276815653,
0.0780793205,
0.398342967,
0.4332611859,
-0.3339422941,
-0.8165058494,
-0.4359663725,
0.3900739849,
-0.4572550058,
-1.0227931738,
0.2376349121,
0.7850404382,
0.5665627122,
0.4674908519,
-0.1289236695,
0.7773094177,
-0.4878559411,
0.7757188678,
0.8831164837,
-0.8918786645,
0.4867475629,
-0.4688639343,
0.4648976028,
0.6825478077,
0.1256759912,
-1.2389130592,
-0.3439620733,
-0.2203064561,
-0.8349525928,
0.4855475426,
0.3396351635,
0.1840730608,
-0.1918196827,
0.1959042698,
0.063624382,
0.2339346409,
-0.4426500499,
0.0578752011,
-0.3555394113,
-0.464466095,
0.2567200661,
-0.1305066049,
-0.5951853395,
0.0142124388,
0.8861701488,
-0.3948659897,
0.4765920639,
0.3270213306,
-0.4439053237,
-0.0808708593,
0.176762253,
0.4921508133,
0.4662825763,
0.0503999442,
-0.3420505226,
0.1899155527,
-0.4028313458,
0.1518726945,
-0.3153328598,
-0.2138424069,
0.1211808696,
0.0010601486,
1.2297215462,
0.2831202745,
-0.4021276236,
0.5486954451,
-0.0345822312,
-0.2662785649,
-0.2550745308,
-0.074729614,
0.1113760471,
0.0247004908,
0.1300274432,
0.0412393883,
0.0517181382,
-0.5600005984,
0.2161558717,
0.6182407737,
-0.7917955518,
-0.1785978675,
0.4364106357,
0.8582789898,
-0.507779181,
0.7513363361,
-0.3816927671,
-0.5862557888,
0.2602460384,
0.7091408372,
1.2030382156,
-0.1607181132,
0.034784019,
0.4054075181,
0.1228924692,
0.0562943779,
0.3632254601,
-0.2477694899,
-1.0340138674,
-0.5276315212,
-0.6216865182,
-0.4781543016,
-0.1929804236,
-0.9852871299,
0.0432730094,
-0.1479793042,
-0.2651096582,
-0.5336337686,
-0.4339595139,
-0.7119119167,
-0.0574140437,
0.2452962399,
0.6285437942,
-0.683863461,
0.5722101331,
0.6021288037,
-0.1990406662,
-0.5953266621,
0.0348671712,
0.2744489908,
-0.9770516753,
0.453633666,
0.3517246544,
-0.0214128271,
0.142496869,
-0.2525444031,
-0.8372641206,
1.0070341825,
0.1637499332,
-0.8233184218,
-0.2350619733,
0.4132614136,
0.3470447361,
-0.3475979865,
0.49055022,
0.9023203254,
0.1328201145,
0.060543403,
-1.6862949133,
-0.14358069,
-0.3400297165,
0.1448211819,
0.3319761157,
-0.6189329028,
0.2860045135,
0.0663389936,
-0.2736379504,
0.2145854086,
0.5309864283,
-0.2673573196,
-0.2297230214,
0.5459600091,
0.9701345563,
0.8797956705,
-0.4050508738,
0.5791683197,
-0.6901227832,
0.4943647385,
1.2776217461,
-0.4668183625,
0.6273754239,
0.6340280771,
-0.1457051188,
0.2848852277,
0.6160548329,
0.4949578345,
0.7802890539,
0.1213090196,
-0.6193374395,
-0.1531374604,
-0.4854538143,
-0.5852517486,
0.2268235832,
0.6415832639,
0.0753352717,
-0.0148321325,
0.2458810806,
-0.1271990389,
-0.1444353908,
-0.0670779198,
1.1787557602,
0.3004050553,
-0.955395937,
0.7205749154,
-0.610601604,
0.8793451786,
-0.7447142005,
0.2185704559,
-0.2463775277,
-0.0483897105,
-0.4210644662,
-0.7015604377,
0.2248152792,
-0.1318153292,
0.1285615414,
-0.3881955445,
0.5160884857,
-0.9904979467,
0.0403623469,
0.145529598,
0.5289179087,
0.3301321864,
0.2560182512,
-0.4218916595,
-0.2160635889,
0.0659234002,
-0.1817114949,
0.2730723321,
0.4547505081,
0.1999203712,
0.4504930675,
0.4971839786,
-0.1039472818,
0.3255691528,
0.6353619099,
0.6398498416,
-0.1894448698,
-0.5973582864,
-0.5127261877,
0.4190168083,
-0.427715987,
-0.5220248699,
0.5366950631,
0.4578582644,
0.8092845678,
0.1061904207,
1.1725696325,
-0.320153743,
0.2982887328,
-0.5615982413,
0.2985640764,
-0.412017554,
-0.1642744392,
0.0843122974,
-0.8984251618,
0.2533045709,
0.7601103187,
-0.0845636427,
0.0481550358,
0.8246459961,
0.7235870957,
0.2201059014,
0.1782116741,
0.4220356643,
-0.1420374662,
0.2714465261,
0.7015376091,
0.8020540476,
-0.1713314503,
0.1418681294,
0.1055111587,
-0.4960663617,
-0.0878708661,
-0.4134492874,
-0.9309120774,
-0.6896157265,
-0.1632571667,
-0.2172247767,
0.5086793303,
0.9275856018,
0.7346017361,
-0.74386096,
-0.4895683527,
-0.4677565694,
-0.6583076119,
-0.0956671014,
-0.1818166226,
-0.1225596592,
-0.8920866251,
-0.7838432789,
0.3359185457,
0.4098487198,
0.120360896,
-0.1452092677,
-0.5583015084,
-0.0841673091,
-0.0089866882,
0.3489107788,
0.2965172827,
-0.6984570622,
-0.5097963214,
-0.0946309343,
-0.0703848526,
0.0863682553,
0.8767709136,
-0.6678940058,
0.725250721,
0.3369187415,
0.9036796093,
0.3610626459,
0.133700937,
1.1344348192,
-1.0192452669,
0.3879055977,
0.1392827481,
0.4574922621,
0.3984683752,
-0.1705983281,
0.6380419135,
0.2728812993,
-0.8032172918,
-0.5955662727,
0.5451690555,
-0.9802258015,
0.4491153061,
1.1996649504,
-0.1003454402,
0.3212509155,
-0.4312590659,
-0.3412739933,
0.3368332386,
-0.4598184526,
0.1213279516,
1.0698097944,
-0.2305175215,
0.1073252037,
-0.7893342376,
0.6852346659,
0.88895154,
-0.6756333113,
-0.0481762327,
0.1194423363,
0.1691165566,
0.22779046,
0.8795651793,
0.4509899318,
0.2500189543,
0.0129816206,
-0.0673929527,
0.1452045441,
-0.0376012176,
0.0156159131,
-0.4863839447,
0.0068778023,
-0.4048638344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09389v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09389v1
|
Neural machine translation for automated feedback on children's early-stage writing
| 2023-11-15T21:32:44 | 2023-11-15T21:32:44 |
Jonas Vestergaard Jensen, Mikkel Jordahn, Michael Riis Andersen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7
|
In this work, we address the problem of assessing and constructing feedback
for early-stage writing automatically using machine learning. Early-stage
writing is typically vastly different from conventional writing due to phonetic
spelling and lack of proper grammar, punctuation, spacing etc. Consequently,
early-stage writing is highly non-trivial to analyze using common linguistic
metrics. We propose to use sequence-to-sequence models for "translating"
early-stage writing by students into "conventional" writing, which allows the
translated text to be analyzed using linguistic metrics. Furthermore, we
propose a novel robust likelihood to mitigate the effect of noise in the
dataset. We investigate the proposed methods using a set of numerical
experiments and demonstrate that the conventional text can be predicted with
high accuracy.
|
[
0.0356178954,
-0.888710618,
0.3973349035,
0.3965382576,
-0.1815151274,
-0.0632500425,
-0.2221834958,
-0.4946013391,
-0.144510597,
0.2786930501,
-0.7367628813,
-0.6242072582,
-0.6655489206,
0.3486422598,
-0.6681315303,
1.0094076395,
-0.2557341456,
0.1865240037,
-0.0795188397,
0.329752326,
-0.286375314,
-0.4951188862,
-0.6958752871,
-0.1790651083,
0.7676663995,
0.5670359135,
0.3557329178,
0.7279773951,
0.3691357672,
0.3714568019,
-0.0251627583,
0.2857815623,
-0.1737767905,
0.1511596888,
0.1953433305,
-0.4423699677,
-0.5295118093,
-0.0552718565,
0.8242506981,
1.0804034472,
0.1404284984,
0.27335006,
0.4905865788,
0.5909781456,
-0.3240944147,
0.2730091512,
-0.3664902747,
0.3814007044,
-0.0595904663,
-0.0224737562,
-0.7395334244,
-0.6964970827,
0.0054717609,
-0.6548449397,
0.1540991962,
-0.0186911542,
0.5786043406,
0.3031871319,
-0.1323799491,
-0.4742337465,
-0.9027986526,
0.8649656177,
-0.8434017897,
-0.0170789137,
0.3734227717,
-0.0157705024,
-0.1605849713,
-0.6936330795,
-0.6785882711,
-0.2936974764,
-0.2549559772,
0.0102494163,
0.0355163887,
-0.0598913878,
0.0897880048,
0.1374275088,
-0.5580554008,
0.3255416751,
-0.2877131402,
-0.2771676183,
0.5331602693,
0.3042973876,
0.3177336156,
-0.2005306482,
-0.0100532342,
-0.1553237587,
-0.2016334385,
0.1537937969,
0.3978544176,
0.6525700688,
0.0493526123,
0.6131446362,
-0.1490983516,
0.8518971205,
0.0475845821,
-0.1095472947,
0.1407520473,
-0.3967555165,
-0.1535699517,
0.1066872999,
0.8189067245,
0.2946815193,
0.3479140401,
-0.1896936446,
-0.5068715215,
0.3088101447,
0.2697481215,
-0.724206388,
0.0555740334,
-0.2332089543,
-0.6945961714,
-0.7257357836,
-0.0776908696,
-0.9221745729,
-0.3090438247,
-0.3878979683,
0.2890432179,
-0.2789598405,
0.2403255254,
0.0121945683,
0.4138308167,
-0.0111744665,
0.4405052662,
-0.821593821,
0.4628067017,
0.416095674,
0.7722042203,
-0.1827887446,
-0.3802574575,
-0.2848656774,
-0.1629821062,
-0.4443742037,
0.7414189577,
-0.1874875277,
-0.3254264295,
0.1088251173,
0.0299185645,
-0.2116659582,
-0.3993807733,
0.6931761503,
-0.2617871761,
0.5167486072,
0.4883850217,
-0.4417755902,
-0.1145042628,
0.1032085121,
-0.5456725359,
0.9925280213,
0.2248270959,
-0.404735893,
0.440951705,
-0.4425314665,
-0.7841985822,
-0.1719209254,
0.2188842744,
-0.603489995,
0.2497218102,
0.4770783186,
0.4986206889,
-0.0776429251,
0.2177210748,
-0.0111415209,
-0.3706977963,
0.3874308765,
-0.5328836441,
0.4967853129,
0.3679900467,
-0.3963019252,
0.2484607399,
-1.030292511,
0.2223315537,
-0.1096249148,
-0.3805450201,
0.0775593221,
-0.1928922683,
0.2970273793,
0.2222244143,
0.2699781358,
-0.3232534826,
0.3555319309,
-0.5381976366,
0.4007859826,
0.4120856524,
-0.1205739453,
0.6008778811,
-0.6222890019,
0.6003978252,
0.0004416948,
0.1198164299,
-0.4338850379,
-0.5943868756,
-0.7259210944,
0.0669814274,
0.4380967319,
0.7812703252,
-0.6137375832,
0.5788900852,
-0.3137153089,
-0.246112287,
-0.7808067203,
0.473680377,
0.4655453563,
0.7025405169,
0.2170095444,
-0.5505493283,
-0.7996147275,
-0.4676332474,
-0.1625448316,
-0.4995243847,
-0.0574507788,
0.0535249338,
0.2127157301,
-0.0910157636,
0.4814532101,
-0.113735199,
-0.3227447271,
-0.1670861989,
0.5027571321,
0.2983599305,
0.7422614098,
0.0620358214,
-0.4605132937,
-0.6607372165,
-0.1452167332,
-0.549680531,
-0.2901284397,
-0.4159943759,
0.0004046898,
0.2618728578,
0.6401356459,
-0.5348623395,
0.7248892188,
0.3850527704,
-0.3578769863,
0.3988138735,
-0.0188184232,
0.1049618199,
-0.9567239285,
0.3020378351,
-0.0512110963,
-0.2362755686,
-0.5775142312,
-0.1593847871,
-0.0263702888,
-0.0613789968,
-0.3564324677,
0.3389450014,
-0.1913866401,
0.2948726118,
-0.3086765707,
-0.0573709831,
0.0036423374,
0.202767849,
0.0206852853,
0.6272975802,
-0.0239236709,
-0.5123871565,
0.1048386991,
0.2647636533,
-0.3091998696,
0.4558481574,
-0.5130028725,
0.3505247533,
0.0467665344,
0.2468462437,
-1.0018200874,
-0.118335478,
0.4376443923,
-1.0616995096,
0.4233246744,
-0.0522919931,
-0.6189700961,
-0.4554361701,
0.1152163967,
0.1086425558,
0.5628563762,
-0.0874402151,
0.2291103154,
0.0197230559,
-0.6737333536,
-0.3151736557,
-0.6923534274,
0.2427458912,
-0.0009416488,
-0.4205811322,
0.1932781786,
0.040075101,
0.1153935865,
0.1316167563,
0.3061252534,
-0.4686045647,
0.0991359204,
0.0958557576,
0.5398819447,
-0.5504763722,
0.0034072036,
0.1955233812,
-0.2355809063,
0.1648747325,
-0.7713036537,
0.3050798476,
-0.0958859771,
0.0527884103,
-0.5255776048,
0.3176389635,
0.718162477,
0.166846782,
0.61845541,
0.697409749,
-0.5935211182,
-0.4501083195,
-0.0235326253,
-0.1991321295,
-0.3991508782,
0.3024590909,
-0.0720309243,
-0.4846805632,
0.2876614332,
-0.0621020496,
-0.1905307919,
0.5005488992,
0.6268888116,
-0.3671169281,
1.1090677977,
0.7033199668,
-0.1081564352,
0.3392587304,
-0.090293467,
0.1442706436,
-0.4455170333,
-0.1545758843,
-0.7235913873,
-0.6650002599,
-0.3631893694,
-0.1720719635,
-0.125792861,
0.1803337187,
-0.0917425975,
0.3547743559,
-0.7346218824,
0.3856211007,
0.7570879459,
-0.0837905928,
0.3501293957,
0.0916573256,
-0.3059715033,
-0.4184056222,
-0.7786692977,
-0.8594232798,
1.1773048639,
0.1956174821,
0.631752491,
-0.2440481633,
0.687795341,
0.2039096504,
0.6868240833,
-0.9215037227,
0.4395385981,
-0.3444935381,
-0.4247360528,
-0.5829643607,
-0.40346843,
-0.9810231328,
-0.0164143778,
-0.3564412594,
-0.6358886361,
0.1460012496,
-0.0237293765,
-0.5664652586,
0.3240627646,
-0.6648396254,
0.6579989195,
-0.191264376,
-0.4361499846,
0.2152236551,
-0.8023790717,
0.0021860846,
-0.2075820863,
0.203584522,
0.3690912426,
0.0351731554,
0.8025069833,
-0.3968653977,
1.2969982624,
-0.0382049978,
-0.1777553558,
0.5460716486,
0.2063113153,
0.2641112506,
-0.0696833208,
-0.011424318,
-0.2395092696,
0.0634048209,
-0.340092063,
-0.5697196722,
0.4489202797,
-0.8500025272,
0.0310938787,
-0.4706577063,
-0.7352564335,
-0.0577639863,
0.5127218366,
0.3467209935,
-0.0087204343,
-0.1745005995,
-0.0033683875,
0.4127097428,
-0.0870510712,
0.5561497808,
0.5477833152,
-0.3270017505,
-0.6517497897,
0.8432034254,
0.1167198792,
-0.0783259422,
0.1958549023,
0.2387943417,
-0.3804623485,
-0.7568218112,
-0.8071067929,
-0.1504873484,
-0.6198563576,
-0.0732867345,
-0.443431437,
-0.2403980792,
-0.6690816879,
-0.2449704856,
-0.2534228861,
-0.7244362831,
-0.5588466525,
0.0612044968,
-0.2438849956,
0.9534025192,
-0.1216772646,
0.5343105793,
-0.9149081707,
0.2055078298,
-0.0608278587,
0.2864196002,
0.1940803081,
-0.6880242825,
-0.4106351137,
-0.1762465984,
-0.6280448437,
-0.73573035,
0.7383136153,
0.3857845664,
0.106438309,
0.2008884102,
-0.137898162,
0.4829550982,
-0.5956649184,
0.7443951368,
0.2079076916,
-0.9523617029,
0.8146877885,
-0.233401835,
0.2631461024,
0.6169798374,
0.1880774498,
-0.6774997115,
-0.2573394477,
-0.4790773988,
-0.8173139095,
0.5083890557,
0.126374349,
0.1013816893,
0.1748920083,
0.4972966015,
0.3455829024,
0.3273843229,
-0.7453215122,
-0.045215223,
-0.1208441183,
-0.7132660151,
-0.3906867504,
0.0858037472,
-0.0274507683,
-0.6921707988,
0.5280695558,
-0.1513210833,
0.2774419785,
0.1528652459,
-0.3370485008,
-0.4292485118,
0.2923345566,
0.6630582809,
0.2694739103,
0.0843231007,
-0.0602830537,
0.0616003014,
-0.7131209373,
0.4897383749,
0.3552453518,
-0.7686241865,
0.2463553399,
0.6698737144,
0.6407551169,
0.3572545946,
-0.1225116104,
0.4078052044,
-0.0834051967,
-0.3261331618,
-0.3298560381,
-0.1715761423,
-0.1664911062,
-0.0655068085,
0.1631997377,
0.2008060217,
0.1051819772,
-0.3455059826,
0.4388692379,
-0.2896152437,
-0.7156972289,
-0.4337692559,
0.4984547496,
0.3096477687,
-0.623241365,
0.8750650287,
-0.0471234694,
-0.442019403,
0.7278700471,
0.8088461161,
1.1896576881,
-0.138028726,
0.4577138722,
0.4566586912,
0.6333240867,
0.0583435297,
0.3242905438,
-0.0164544601,
-0.3943828046,
-0.7098415494,
-0.7277811766,
-0.4427297413,
0.0259550493,
-0.7681857944,
0.2990697622,
-0.53403759,
-0.2514437437,
-0.25265944,
-0.0346792787,
-0.6766635776,
0.4226069748,
0.3892726898,
0.4507872462,
-0.8329321146,
0.8098580241,
0.9784053564,
-0.4795992076,
-0.6716032624,
-0.0343162008,
0.002349271,
-0.6115666032,
0.6573804021,
0.3662348986,
-0.0771621913,
0.2829761207,
-0.641824007,
-0.5216849446,
0.7350108624,
-0.094626084,
-0.6188564301,
-0.3278555274,
0.4658701122,
0.7639485002,
-0.5409685373,
0.2403615564,
0.1898819059,
0.5180417895,
-0.1398900151,
-0.9147217274,
-0.1623024344,
-0.4204394221,
-0.0048445445,
-0.0451218262,
-0.1750888079,
0.6798526049,
-0.2920832634,
-0.2272210568,
0.441480577,
0.8609333634,
-0.3372894526,
0.702246666,
0.3627232015,
0.5256077647,
0.8567504287,
-0.0358071551,
0.7304922342,
-0.4728844762,
0.1543401629,
1.1681183577,
0.1212596968,
0.869451344,
0.6194316745,
-0.1918724924,
0.6024404764,
0.5489036441,
0.0782597288,
0.3788004518,
0.5987082124,
-0.250311017,
0.0705751255,
0.0716610774,
-0.1217621937,
0.1169188395,
0.3903567791,
-0.6864699125,
0.0725058317,
0.0268668961,
-0.1398205161,
0.5323195457,
-0.2035930753,
0.977861166,
0.374299705,
-0.8011871576,
0.5456423163,
0.1020682156,
0.7471522093,
-0.3216406405,
-0.0467002317,
-0.210828051,
0.3078295887,
-0.2418498397,
-0.536947608,
0.4052638113,
0.1155241579,
-0.2302321047,
-0.5100762844,
0.6861600876,
-0.485542506,
-0.8938185573,
0.0517795682,
0.5973199606,
-0.1441072375,
0.2653345764,
-0.6106519103,
-0.0795780122,
-0.4089869857,
-0.2727622688,
0.0016207302,
0.6005548835,
0.0731316358,
0.4249896705,
0.80257833,
0.4117996395,
0.4517412782,
0.0021704547,
0.5307751298,
-0.5308244228,
-0.5510612726,
-0.7848752737,
0.548486352,
0.2409187406,
-0.6302511096,
0.5902510881,
0.3402402699,
0.6974281669,
-0.2189406306,
0.8681667447,
0.1271492839,
0.6587958336,
-0.4099981189,
0.9307011962,
-0.229332149,
-0.0378426686,
-0.457152307,
-1.0018913746,
-0.6368360519,
0.8094305992,
-0.1215487272,
-0.1729268134,
0.9479019642,
0.5742054582,
0.1197516695,
0.154468447,
0.2752541304,
0.1140524745,
0.0474840589,
0.6527224183,
1.0279307365,
-0.5717749,
0.5877754092,
-0.4366252422,
-0.3201506436,
-0.1925514638,
-0.8847931027,
-0.6827090979,
-0.4439874887,
-0.3353261352,
-0.8099111915,
0.2198494971,
0.6359418035,
0.5365492702,
-1.0213721991,
-0.2459553033,
-0.209795922,
-0.0594994389,
-0.2730567157,
-0.1381017119,
0.1636483222,
-0.6461964846,
-0.8285214901,
0.3602265418,
-0.1112075746,
0.2228943259,
-0.2596809566,
-0.1174782738,
0.1007388905,
0.1260397732,
0.4804542363,
0.2221770734,
-0.5338059068,
-0.0323312059,
0.13972269,
-0.476737231,
0.1668898612,
0.8246472478,
-0.6126050353,
0.3776987493,
0.4582515955,
0.7778632641,
0.3100077808,
-0.2559811175,
0.6366802454,
-0.4953410625,
0.0602358207,
0.6152278781,
-0.0878303349,
0.424012661,
-0.35875386,
0.2379112095,
0.4263692796,
-0.4927328527,
-0.6945141554,
-0.0508763231,
-0.4651851654,
0.0707999021,
0.71180439,
-0.3032093048,
-0.3705098033,
0.0517033301,
-0.294598639,
0.5840504169,
-0.1006259397,
1.050778985,
1.0887954235,
0.1582827717,
-0.1214266866,
-0.4490622282,
0.263315171,
0.7127441764,
-0.6354718208,
-0.4544990063,
0.425046593,
-0.0649043843,
0.0731204972,
0.4508385956,
-0.3780609965,
0.1374242753,
0.1423971653,
0.0681785718,
0.0775289834,
-0.5367286205,
-0.5899699926,
0.1282412261,
0.1703296602,
-0.1668705195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09387v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09387v2
|
Banach-Tarski Embeddings and Transformers
| 2023-11-15T21:30:26 | 2023-11-21T18:31:57 |
Joshua Maher
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DS
|
We introduce a new construction of embeddings of arbitrary recursive data
structures into high dimensional vectors. These embeddings provide an
interpretable model for the latent state vectors of transformers. We
demonstrate that these embeddings can be decoded to the original data structure
when the embedding dimension is sufficiently large. This decoding algorithm has
a natural implementation as a transformer. We also show that these embedding
vectors can be manipulated directly to perform computations on the underlying
data without decoding. As an example we present an algorithm that constructs
the embedded parse tree of an embedded token sequence using only vector
operations in embedding space.
|
[
-0.2705344558,
-0.5919028521,
0.6028751731,
0.1650764197,
-0.5277711749,
0.5301140547,
-0.0279037282,
-0.2091718167,
0.4823329747,
0.4871815443,
-0.1230968237,
-0.5744564533,
-0.758633852,
-0.2378185987,
-0.8889023066,
0.9068959355,
-0.3442451656,
-0.1017646268,
0.0352955572,
0.0614645258,
-0.5185745955,
-0.4205584228,
-0.0890741721,
0.0445066392,
0.2162365764,
0.3740798533,
0.876146853,
0.7824370265,
0.1301901937,
0.2833592892,
-0.1238903403,
-0.1913500279,
-0.5404577851,
0.3626179099,
-0.2140874267,
-0.6394802928,
-0.1179179624,
-0.0587824322,
0.9092273116,
0.7667779326,
-0.0585492328,
0.1711005121,
0.0377414785,
0.2549373209,
-0.5170653462,
0.4399043918,
-0.6205105782,
0.3940384984,
-0.0338771939,
-0.4693090916,
-0.6301014423,
-0.4893662632,
0.0427659526,
-0.3004906774,
0.5906808376,
0.1359514296,
0.5294425488,
0.266558975,
-0.5135715008,
-0.3056179881,
-1.2121360302,
1.0614544153,
-0.0269113891,
0.7333654761,
0.0768158287,
0.5172720551,
-0.0604731739,
-0.6859511137,
-0.4354810119,
0.1051132306,
-0.3547445238,
-0.0455754176,
-0.504221797,
0.0185081027,
0.2637811899,
0.5638770461,
-0.1987922192,
-0.1962249577,
-0.6312058568,
0.0326329246,
0.2678636312,
0.2952881753,
0.0009773413,
-0.794931531,
-0.437828213,
-0.2217201442,
-0.6116378903,
-0.0236565825,
0.2587301433,
0.1133247912,
-0.3459289074,
0.7142869234,
0.4852562547,
0.3324574232,
0.026704248,
0.3143207431,
0.1442230344,
-0.1282471418,
-0.1807216704,
0.2478481084,
0.2399959862,
-0.1037179455,
0.1146320328,
-0.5487539768,
-0.2118652016,
0.2634906471,
0.4092136323,
-0.5174427032,
-0.0646432042,
0.1100013703,
-0.7799993157,
-0.6079201102,
0.5635513067,
-0.9150608182,
-0.0179573242,
-0.2155261189,
0.2958718836,
-0.2999483645,
-0.0759107247,
0.0201134849,
-0.1705886126,
0.8544905782,
0.004229459,
-0.8326188922,
0.8643369675,
0.8387162089,
0.8620638847,
0.0878304616,
0.0244069137,
-0.532779336,
0.3046472967,
-0.7508505583,
0.592866838,
-0.7749717236,
-0.4041306376,
0.0653633401,
0.3185833991,
0.1955270618,
-0.4075774252,
0.6230258942,
-0.7802812457,
-0.1714292914,
0.0521117821,
-0.4805749655,
-0.3614411056,
-0.1440122426,
-0.8987978101,
0.8206201196,
0.3903303444,
-0.6569377184,
0.1307161897,
-0.7261462212,
-0.5888875127,
-0.173674956,
-0.2341391295,
-0.5410476923,
0.5186004639,
0.2558533847,
0.5736121535,
-0.3976614773,
0.1479698718,
0.0800289437,
-0.4720975757,
0.133710295,
-0.4883616269,
0.7403619289,
0.2241801918,
-0.4769128561,
0.0490462072,
-0.6207121611,
-0.2100025415,
0.3479374051,
-0.1418990642,
-0.2850108743,
0.5060930848,
0.0728013963,
-0.0882177427,
-0.0580279268,
-0.8609024882,
0.3086997569,
-0.5282043219,
0.6729581952,
0.9569073319,
0.169443801,
0.3735432923,
-0.0948990658,
0.6374983788,
0.2478247136,
0.0461727977,
-0.2361695915,
-0.3446024656,
-0.5883966088,
-0.0788640827,
0.3994938433,
0.3876414001,
-0.8409942985,
0.5903177261,
-0.5005984306,
-0.330193162,
-0.3907631338,
-0.0617480204,
-0.1518503129,
0.1672550142,
0.3999169171,
0.0283666924,
-0.734831214,
-0.9993104935,
0.3165867031,
0.259414047,
-0.085450761,
0.1716982275,
0.489512831,
-0.1562839001,
0.8705956936,
-0.8416132927,
0.2623625398,
-0.1497900486,
-0.1369576156,
0.431481421,
0.8232629299,
0.5046264529,
-0.6802739501,
-0.3041814268,
-0.0667562634,
-0.5764200091,
0.4637079239,
-0.0315302722,
-0.090437375,
0.0047171321,
0.5786715746,
-0.5573874116,
0.7520281076,
0.5772864819,
-0.5550573468,
0.090681985,
-0.1258960813,
0.108352989,
-1.1704907417,
-0.0289939307,
-0.819945097,
-0.5440676808,
-0.4828799069,
-0.1332393438,
0.0628386661,
-0.3942408264,
-0.4262840748,
0.0589939058,
-0.4183047116,
-0.5036959648,
0.036150679,
-0.0281530134,
-0.0703252256,
0.2892678976,
-0.3018670082,
0.3812390566,
0.8227463961,
-0.5332148075,
0.5019863844,
0.7068997622,
-0.4251291454,
0.4876164198,
-0.9255247712,
0.1359309256,
-0.5034468174,
0.1923680156,
-0.9013840556,
0.1221178472,
0.2620916069,
-0.2667760253,
0.3160368204,
-0.4849979579,
-0.6118043065,
-0.3219618797,
-0.5523440242,
0.7042303681,
0.8182746172,
-1.0648415089,
0.7306196094,
0.1998508424,
0.143739745,
-0.5356744528,
-0.6952619553,
0.0377671421,
0.0581693277,
-0.4945873618,
0.6268967986,
0.2460314631,
0.076052621,
0.6954139471,
0.1122907624,
0.1527571678,
-0.075206615,
0.4184148312,
0.3654287755,
-0.358422488,
0.1713961214,
0.3388765156,
-0.3871624172,
-0.0192531869,
-0.3748354316,
0.7613552213,
-0.0949221775,
-0.4854990542,
-0.2146586627,
0.5204520226,
0.7252783179,
-0.3914823532,
0.8496929407,
0.4082390666,
-0.5744197369,
-0.5315809846,
-0.0841908827,
-0.0881596282,
-0.4937463403,
0.0935072452,
-0.4015082717,
-0.8218016624,
0.5746771097,
-0.0751122832,
0.0248741824,
0.68786484,
0.5297393799,
-0.0037866419,
1.059068799,
0.6879866123,
0.1421455443,
0.4068455398,
-0.7238816619,
0.4299294055,
-0.7096571922,
-0.3710620403,
-0.531826973,
-0.5853198171,
-0.9084468484,
-0.7443552613,
0.1700427681,
-0.120448865,
-0.3456703126,
0.5857198834,
-0.6671544313,
0.4448340237,
0.3899270594,
-0.1132361889,
0.0378106907,
0.1485904604,
-0.1402767152,
0.0360510573,
-0.7519019842,
-0.2497036308,
1.0070445538,
0.5774521828,
1.082908988,
0.1507671028,
0.7207242846,
0.2300013751,
0.0401288271,
-1.1646080017,
0.0346826464,
-0.4171521962,
-0.4514800906,
-0.141082108,
-0.3874597549,
-1.388915658,
-0.0319458917,
-0.3698560596,
-0.6617842317,
0.5591455698,
-0.1607407779,
-0.1046941727,
0.8392592072,
-0.6137571335,
0.6751488447,
0.0030016105,
0.184751153,
-0.4743608236,
-0.313187778,
0.266271323,
0.1250100434,
-0.0784801766,
0.2576816678,
0.0324995816,
0.9198952317,
-0.3250633776,
0.8034706116,
-0.3669273853,
0.1528020799,
0.5088891983,
0.3362617493,
0.608310461,
0.1776697487,
0.2055325806,
0.0895174295,
0.4751276672,
-0.6497359276,
-0.9766339064,
0.6339862347,
-0.8346357346,
-0.4246152639,
-0.3999614418,
-0.3166539371,
0.0542373098,
0.1593263,
-0.0411995314,
0.6385109425,
-0.2594867945,
0.6926399469,
0.444979459,
-0.5308927298,
0.2939777374,
0.0750340894,
-0.1714435071,
-0.2888090909,
0.6223805547,
0.1125166863,
-0.0832577497,
0.6512409449,
0.1972825527,
-0.290655762,
-0.1930121183,
-0.1336739659,
0.211340189,
-0.781855166,
-0.3005541265,
-0.4730899036,
-0.4647610486,
-0.1565659195,
-0.4657617211,
-0.681618154,
-0.5331577659,
0.0324715823,
-0.3922963738,
0.4610548913,
1.3637622595,
-0.1792483926,
0.2229455113,
-0.9123079181,
0.529971838,
0.3299203217,
0.8525671363,
0.2874628305,
-0.2063192129,
-0.2690062225,
-0.314517498,
-0.051042635,
-0.7492738962,
0.0492026396,
-0.2545176148,
0.6286668181,
0.377530396,
0.005909706,
0.4136268497,
-0.9206246734,
0.5291734338,
-0.058769118,
-1.3365089893,
0.3726425171,
0.088386856,
-0.1403152794,
0.054561425,
0.3329533339,
-0.465079844,
0.0918184444,
-0.7635849118,
-0.4980381131,
0.6463984251,
0.2142629176,
0.6134145856,
-0.0659261867,
0.2969142199,
0.2773752213,
-0.0749256536,
-0.2796665132,
-0.4582053125,
-0.5477600694,
-0.3053922951,
-0.2401587963,
-0.6057620645,
-0.052827023,
-0.357098192,
0.0098260269,
0.345173806,
0.832824707,
0.1477658153,
-0.0667589158,
-0.2350564003,
0.3110705018,
0.2756053805,
0.4982246459,
-0.2742218673,
0.6638193727,
0.0678598657,
-0.457262218,
0.3033003211,
0.0714895353,
-0.1017466262,
0.1110047176,
0.3234985769,
0.7866274714,
0.7307991385,
-0.2164951861,
0.5831077099,
0.0245797802,
-0.1560146362,
-0.5642414093,
-0.2515071034,
0.0038309186,
0.2232836187,
0.2609417737,
0.0138764316,
-0.0718350112,
-0.4970341623,
0.5508821607,
0.2737129033,
-0.4891142845,
-0.6930631995,
0.6092996597,
-0.1038732082,
-0.185983181,
0.6863738894,
0.0981012955,
-0.5385150909,
0.4540483057,
0.7108460069,
0.9217858911,
-0.1892900914,
0.4383015037,
0.2930541933,
0.558526814,
0.3443661332,
0.3208458126,
-0.2208031714,
-0.6880527735,
-0.5656029582,
-0.7322899103,
-0.2810615003,
-0.1510366499,
-0.6421040297,
0.3767944574,
-0.7891119123,
0.2745316625,
0.0798301846,
-0.4712301493,
-1.0104750395,
-0.2587185204,
-0.2689384818,
0.8884612918,
-0.654686451,
0.728025496,
0.3242985904,
-0.1888864487,
-0.6234378219,
-0.1436462104,
-0.3474352062,
-0.7681720853,
0.6606803536,
-0.1071261987,
-0.0546387918,
0.097694546,
-0.6805374026,
-1.1602040529,
1.2065517902,
0.3303438723,
-0.1110658497,
0.0533864535,
0.1372187883,
0.3119257092,
-0.1128758639,
-0.2470282018,
0.3830042481,
0.3851355612,
0.0932667106,
-0.3101875186,
0.2715595365,
0.1053977907,
0.0112390853,
0.5024951696,
-0.1858323961,
0.8989881277,
0.1909213513,
-0.6909767389,
-0.0696125701,
0.4853601456,
-0.4180935025,
-0.3855780065,
0.6081749797,
0.5349879861,
0.3775894046,
0.0038868666,
1.118409276,
-0.5352879763,
0.5698747635,
0.5246075988,
0.3376977444,
0.8827851415,
0.3486456275,
-0.3586139381,
0.7576305866,
-0.063736245,
-0.4700220823,
0.4027712941,
0.1737443805,
-0.0719010159,
0.0239961687,
0.0709715784,
-0.0912277848,
0.8055524826,
0.4406502247,
-0.5102246404,
-0.5242937207,
0.037032567,
-0.2760327458,
-0.0462325886,
-0.141691491,
0.2485556602,
0.1414489746,
-0.1120413616,
0.6073822975,
0.4015973806,
0.5896080732,
-0.4107446373,
-0.5328277349,
0.2516718805,
-0.0805099979,
-0.4876539111,
-0.9268082976,
0.8769116998,
0.1017142087,
-0.2134714723,
-0.3001515269,
0.4564711452,
-0.1215728745,
-0.6174643636,
0.324110657,
0.4390389621,
0.1377828419,
0.4285818338,
-0.1924140304,
-0.0497483276,
-0.2736396194,
-0.1694506109,
-0.3765438497,
0.1854849309,
-0.0425195992,
0.2662677765,
0.6571028233,
-0.0269019883,
0.2290145308,
-0.1054527611,
0.9080244899,
-1.0762757063,
-0.7008802891,
-0.5400580764,
0.4284246266,
0.4132661819,
0.1719926,
0.4770330787,
0.5937819481,
0.6121718884,
-0.1454856545,
0.5891883373,
-0.2530944943,
0.5102934837,
-0.5451081395,
0.616404295,
-0.146617651,
-0.0347057357,
-0.2521644533,
-1.1612648964,
-0.3559834361,
0.5845561624,
-0.4914063513,
-0.227301687,
0.7594228387,
0.4286215305,
-0.4376705885,
-0.0423073359,
0.503349483,
0.3255443871,
0.556501627,
0.4717859924,
0.8814505935,
-0.4959562123,
0.4957541525,
-0.2005873621,
-0.1551167369,
0.0977071077,
-0.6242780089,
-0.872689724,
-0.8079842925,
0.2808197141,
-0.1500135958,
-0.4081241488,
0.6603224277,
0.4922498465,
-1.0661863089,
0.0613395311,
-0.133102119,
0.5573132634,
-0.0222433805,
-0.3038988113,
0.9183878303,
-0.0723052993,
-0.8067060709,
0.3564123511,
0.206050083,
0.1625071019,
-0.4840482473,
0.0497736894,
0.0558233373,
0.1082507595,
0.8460780978,
0.0519445129,
-0.4624858499,
-0.8271357417,
0.1228476986,
0.2555865347,
0.4151787758,
1.046770215,
-0.88887012,
0.3756594658,
0.8017792702,
0.9647763968,
1.0402134657,
0.0476883762,
0.5624842048,
-0.7028639913,
0.3290343583,
0.3035012782,
0.4440956116,
0.1966390759,
-0.2129090279,
0.1017876044,
0.1719202101,
-0.0600338504,
-0.6207034588,
0.3457517028,
-1.01892066,
-0.2541647851,
0.48087129,
0.164217025,
-0.3678411245,
-0.1517614722,
-0.0180674586,
0.4357635081,
0.0307172332,
0.5060253143,
0.4816168249,
-0.0324802212,
-0.2373193353,
-0.5447954535,
0.2616080344,
0.1805562526,
-0.4066298306,
-0.1646386087,
-0.0056259334,
0.3599154651,
0.4218295217,
-0.0160400663,
-0.7335782647,
0.0281119663,
0.3971199095,
-0.1130980179,
-0.1631336361,
-0.4384067655,
-0.4565475583,
0.2224929333,
-0.0153271817,
-0.4723951221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10112v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10112v2
|
zrLLM: Zero-Shot Relational Learning on Temporal Knowledge Graphs with Large Language Models
| 2023-11-15T21:25:15 | 2024-03-15T15:38:07 |
Zifeng Ding, Heling Cai, Jingpei Wu, Yunpu Ma, Ruotong Liao, Bo Xiong, Volker Tresp
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Modeling evolving knowledge over temporal knowledge graphs (TKGs) has become
a heated topic. Various methods have been proposed to forecast links on TKGs.
Most of them are embedding-based, where hidden representations are learned to
represent knowledge graph (KG) entities and relations based on the observed
graph contexts. Although these methods show strong performance on traditional
TKG forecasting (TKGF) benchmarks, they face a strong challenge in modeling the
unseen zero-shot relations that have no prior graph context. In this paper, we
try to mitigate this problem as follows. We first input the text descriptions
of KG relations into large language models (LLMs) for generating relation
representations, and then introduce them into embedding-based TKGF methods.
LLM-empowered representations can capture the semantic information in the
relation descriptions. This makes the relations, whether seen or unseen, with
similar semantic meanings stay close in the embedding space, enabling TKGF
models to recognize zero-shot relations even without any observed graph
context. Experimental results show that our approach helps TKGF models to
achieve much better performance in forecasting the facts with previously unseen
relations, while still maintaining their ability in link forecasting regarding
seen relations.
|
[
0.0966421664,
-0.760992229,
0.8852086067,
-0.0783939809,
-0.6270145178,
0.2347114533,
-0.0729577616,
-0.5071852803,
-0.0040081553,
0.4164334536,
-0.7599567771,
-0.8950819373,
-0.3177993894,
-0.2492600679,
-0.0428444557,
0.9197153449,
0.0249846,
-0.063969776,
-0.2940507233,
-0.1534677297,
-0.0854600072,
-0.2311818749,
-0.2082171291,
-0.7666971684,
0.8123805523,
0.2181695402,
0.6891348958,
0.8487943411,
-0.1536498219,
0.0369382463,
0.0161433499,
-0.017159095,
-0.7470251918,
0.6071849465,
-0.0125036733,
-0.0937133357,
-0.3912108541,
-0.2319876999,
0.8110446334,
0.9938309193,
0.0439765789,
0.1354050189,
-0.2323852032,
0.3948998749,
-0.6881842017,
0.5814855695,
-0.7766361237,
0.5627423525,
-0.0925787017,
-0.178652361,
-0.5428887606,
-0.1953587532,
0.1691678464,
-0.5406128764,
0.0154047264,
0.1836442798,
0.8807048798,
-0.0116544897,
-0.641430378,
0.0683773458,
-0.9130126238,
0.8278529644,
-0.8078691959,
0.6696112156,
0.1699616313,
0.5479655862,
-0.2574937344,
-0.6572803855,
-0.4456889629,
-0.4088102579,
0.0066555198,
0.1610180736,
-0.1292705387,
0.0672281459,
0.2405451387,
-0.0088354396,
-0.4591592848,
-0.0061556119,
-0.079543896,
0.123460032,
0.4949109256,
0.3765508235,
-0.0261165202,
0.016568061,
-0.510492146,
0.0793026984,
-0.8139292598,
-0.4001291394,
-0.0327796936,
0.400764972,
-0.0795518383,
0.6501924992,
-0.2972263992,
0.9330047369,
-0.0334753208,
-0.0798326135,
0.2929498255,
-0.2254255861,
-0.384426415,
0.1140708849,
0.71816957,
0.2656957507,
0.2080080956,
-0.6775285006,
0.096710436,
-0.2344258726,
-0.0934192687,
-0.8454280496,
-0.1434957832,
0.0316507891,
-0.3081332147,
-0.4983393848,
-0.2394651622,
-0.4928899705,
-0.1884515733,
0.0664901584,
0.4992029369,
-0.4660357535,
-0.3743690252,
-0.1988121271,
-0.1610042751,
0.2781144381,
0.3714208901,
-0.4814985394,
-0.0511066243,
0.3919277191,
0.6962740421,
0.403375268,
-0.194450736,
-0.5127971768,
0.9500402212,
-0.4746145308,
0.481356144,
-0.6172486544,
-0.3296854198,
0.1734823734,
-0.1617737114,
-0.0105609102,
-0.0252151601,
0.0915176123,
-0.9236581326,
0.1152445227,
-0.1197696701,
-0.9523098469,
-0.1427944005,
0.455945611,
-0.357519418,
0.7188079953,
0.2991401255,
-0.6732887626,
0.4427839518,
-0.3718635142,
-0.2940482795,
0.2080828547,
-0.039844349,
-0.6398460269,
-0.0927538127,
0.2120341808,
0.6959607005,
0.1019112691,
0.2045986652,
-1.007784009,
0.0312472563,
-0.0002473113,
-0.1360352933,
0.6272246838,
0.0352386162,
0.0716636106,
0.0477427989,
-0.646833837,
0.3186152577,
0.1651349664,
-0.0089006387,
-0.3994598091,
0.1431814432,
-0.4231885076,
0.4819800556,
0.2254099697,
-0.870493412,
0.3573198617,
-0.3941488266,
0.2481794506,
0.4715123475,
0.4324303865,
0.5898143649,
-0.0023814326,
0.4512582123,
0.2670810819,
0.2675710917,
-0.2802380323,
-0.2666733265,
-0.5077024102,
0.4035235941,
0.2467795461,
0.134488672,
-1.1447019577,
0.0848779455,
-0.6810693145,
-0.6155179739,
-0.0165761448,
0.1090866402,
0.369422406,
0.7280834913,
0.2841419578,
0.2782832384,
-0.2833001316,
-0.5124675632,
-0.1831179559,
-0.3033786118,
-0.1949883401,
0.6675589085,
0.2291751653,
-0.1414104253,
0.9110398889,
-0.8128885627,
-0.3052470684,
-0.3660155237,
0.1215928942,
0.190766573,
0.0542295948,
0.6981599927,
-0.5651527643,
-0.7526230216,
0.2184832841,
-1.0545543432,
0.1860725135,
0.1498064399,
0.0018070389,
0.3286211789,
0.3727067113,
-0.4798321724,
0.3285831809,
0.5087568164,
-0.4838032424,
0.3579903543,
-0.0580674708,
-0.4368920326,
-0.8782466054,
-0.1367248744,
-0.2023126483,
-0.4460633993,
-0.7010077834,
-0.025257308,
0.2892843485,
-0.3415671885,
-0.4587468505,
0.8648743033,
-0.6292453408,
-0.2114792764,
0.0317306183,
0.3034934402,
-0.1085449085,
0.6603603959,
0.0118838055,
-0.0002434784,
0.4826014638,
-0.5698845387,
0.1776560396,
0.0929927975,
-0.1571139842,
0.0154174482,
-0.483923614,
0.2698693573,
-0.1728713214,
0.2133958638,
-0.6155064702,
0.0041877553,
0.4805224836,
-0.7515767217,
0.6523333192,
-0.5677644014,
-0.5231121778,
-0.3269096613,
-0.327298969,
0.2898840904,
0.4889886975,
-0.308239907,
0.7884799242,
0.0500489138,
0.129796803,
-0.785507679,
-0.3887920678,
-0.0202169567,
0.1586282849,
-0.5135387182,
0.2538833022,
0.1964633167,
0.0033086308,
0.7279286385,
-0.3696891069,
-0.1133531332,
-0.0481017791,
0.269074887,
0.3796696663,
-0.1875885278,
0.5796909928,
-0.0147889685,
-0.0265274756,
-0.1213975102,
-0.6037828326,
0.5692830086,
0.2858181596,
-0.1644663215,
0.2323401421,
-0.0489816479,
0.3917851448,
-0.036901325,
1.2592182159,
0.7469596863,
-0.1520440876,
-0.3956252635,
-0.2709066868,
0.0217563808,
-0.4122864306,
0.5171136856,
0.0048643318,
-1.0815188885,
0.5229276419,
0.0634647533,
-0.0414794087,
0.4319455624,
0.2763825059,
-0.1860935092,
0.7093572617,
0.6542682648,
-0.1882350743,
0.5574327707,
-0.2765849233,
0.308693856,
-0.8346505165,
-0.5478742719,
-0.1657051295,
-0.0260318257,
-0.4044985175,
-0.4449074566,
0.5033797622,
0.5472914577,
-0.5709992647,
0.1278310567,
0.228919223,
0.331459105,
0.0953445733,
0.2586718798,
0.2805453837,
0.1489362717,
-0.3554173708,
0.0837114751,
-1.0573874712,
0.0392188877,
1.2997643948,
0.1877601743,
0.6949032545,
-0.0183250681,
0.722556591,
0.1727912426,
0.4968057275,
-0.8416000605,
0.4407530129,
-0.1090739146,
-0.2653415203,
-0.4921356142,
-0.7812200189,
-0.8777284622,
0.1141495556,
-0.2787081003,
-0.6989492774,
0.0016820307,
0.2156920433,
-0.174849242,
0.6757714152,
-0.1963096559,
0.6830624342,
0.0367133431,
-0.5422736406,
-0.2147372812,
-0.583784461,
0.2596230507,
0.0959774256,
0.0019713226,
-0.3563574851,
-0.048316095,
0.5460453629,
-0.4037149549,
0.7663255334,
-0.4334304631,
0.1148192808,
0.1774936169,
0.2794692516,
0.6696848273,
-0.1578040719,
-0.1406962574,
0.1952969283,
-0.1359761655,
-0.4543637335,
-0.837245822,
0.6306908727,
-0.7646489143,
-0.4553627968,
-0.2166560292,
-0.5975682139,
-0.4979717135,
0.4139036536,
-0.1558059901,
0.6360064745,
-0.1817247421,
0.2883571982,
0.5114893913,
-0.3460189402,
0.5516743064,
0.8553319573,
-0.5377226472,
-0.3660853505,
0.7534182072,
0.3128495514,
0.3432665765,
0.6955940723,
0.2243809998,
-0.4602626562,
-0.3828154504,
-0.3561124802,
0.4743516743,
-0.6545018554,
-0.5382569432,
-0.8343942165,
-0.3771935403,
-0.395935446,
0.1727254242,
-0.1391406059,
-0.5843478441,
-0.3646228015,
-0.1465749741,
0.372068733,
0.7586112618,
0.0410054438,
0.1476709694,
-1.0635585785,
0.0530967042,
0.2191929072,
0.6176005006,
0.652705133,
-0.2493069619,
-0.5026860237,
0.1149706542,
-0.2895618975,
-0.7964971662,
0.592043519,
0.3469813168,
0.4714506865,
0.6911287904,
0.4604132771,
0.7017490864,
-0.664329946,
0.7075781226,
0.2069449574,
-0.6416836381,
0.3467357457,
-0.7534843087,
0.2441443503,
-0.0772382617,
0.5616480112,
-0.5876706839,
-0.3741453886,
-0.685097158,
-0.7212371826,
0.6072492599,
0.0924062654,
0.2058921009,
-0.083208777,
0.4695726633,
-0.1785435379,
0.3912023902,
-0.7955226302,
-0.3709154427,
-0.1443251371,
0.0019749412,
-0.0779719353,
-0.5508115292,
0.1647239476,
-0.0783807933,
0.4668818116,
0.0494051278,
0.4785726368,
-0.0321449563,
-0.1427252591,
-0.5102390051,
0.1847889572,
0.3831216395,
0.8014317155,
-0.5135842562,
-0.0263563823,
0.002884713,
-0.0968543738,
-0.0353049897,
-0.0328616351,
-0.2770013809,
0.2744069397,
0.7578780651,
0.8609113693,
0.6143763661,
-0.2954105437,
0.5279449224,
0.3043733835,
-0.2057687491,
-0.3914110959,
-0.0279834084,
0.2647435069,
0.3149958849,
0.463922292,
-0.29072842,
-0.4735604227,
-0.6206980348,
0.1025294438,
0.4895129204,
-0.7116872072,
-0.3706602156,
0.6669193506,
-0.2045836449,
-0.1318994164,
0.6989943981,
-0.2960236669,
-0.6830819249,
0.4044800401,
0.6181215048,
0.7692944407,
-0.2068004906,
0.3935506642,
0.4608763754,
-0.1206811145,
0.2587483227,
-0.0939155594,
-0.3705069423,
-0.9546220303,
-0.3667655587,
-0.710131824,
-0.3503211439,
0.0410175659,
-0.6816699505,
0.178185463,
-0.4281575978,
0.0591249801,
-0.1249756292,
0.1886827797,
-0.6540713906,
-0.1410096586,
-0.0267027318,
0.8277500868,
-0.8411720395,
1.2849729061,
0.3257482052,
-0.2904388011,
-0.8913473487,
-0.0233983044,
-0.347120285,
-0.8376992941,
0.9940854907,
-0.3009113371,
0.0489003994,
0.0841305181,
-0.5983506441,
-0.8913459778,
1.4143586159,
0.29921785,
-0.4391014576,
-0.1922186166,
0.0374658667,
0.5562062263,
-0.4231226146,
0.0694926083,
-0.2215542793,
0.2644204497,
0.5182593465,
-0.5232767463,
0.0081915595,
-0.0332072079,
-0.0686209947,
0.3993648291,
-0.4886227548,
0.8643224835,
-0.29280442,
-0.4807702005,
-0.1048239842,
0.4690269232,
0.142959848,
0.5433602929,
0.2467721999,
0.5577593446,
0.3277235329,
0.100075759,
1.1357287169,
-0.2601593435,
0.591776967,
1.4230810404,
-0.5552172661,
0.9260204434,
0.2247801274,
-0.1167716011,
0.7075075507,
0.3497403264,
-0.2351288646,
0.7649567127,
-0.2638207376,
-0.3483256102,
-0.5067796111,
-0.2895452678,
-0.4737390578,
0.0508292168,
0.3197614849,
-0.562438488,
-0.824868083,
-0.1306035519,
0.1708681881,
-0.2066661865,
-0.6080872416,
0.8731210232,
0.1901658922,
-0.1037339643,
0.3332765996,
-0.1468238533,
0.1885392368,
-0.8010404706,
-0.2117173672,
-0.1386472583,
0.0757594183,
0.0492185466,
-0.7838729024,
0.1752598733,
-0.299039036,
-0.2435293645,
-0.1916474253,
0.9682629704,
-0.7510328889,
-0.5655658841,
0.6935959458,
0.646371007,
-0.1748693138,
0.2677719295,
-0.3083939552,
-0.2113540769,
-0.0152653027,
-0.1274406761,
0.52569592,
0.6295213103,
-0.0115494141,
0.9662152529,
0.4881086648,
0.2247312963,
0.038753666,
0.0152561702,
1.0525141954,
-0.7667822838,
-0.3722393215,
-1.0620548725,
0.0432557911,
-0.0500298068,
0.4650692642,
0.9706380367,
0.2286055982,
0.6953377724,
-0.1615769416,
0.4948446155,
0.0981102586,
0.4611097574,
-0.40867576,
0.9343883395,
-0.4343098402,
0.005061341,
-0.3357485235,
-0.8714210391,
-0.4454166889,
0.1245819628,
-0.4264973998,
0.0437906347,
0.3628981113,
0.397301048,
0.0637195557,
-0.1688236892,
0.6605698466,
0.5805842876,
0.1284045577,
0.7553696036,
0.7748705745,
-0.2168585956,
0.6229311228,
-0.2914977372,
0.255078733,
-0.1897117645,
-1.2837178707,
-1.1026747227,
-0.320507139,
-0.2088981569,
-0.1606214792,
0.2040605545,
0.7814719081,
0.5068362355,
-0.4425634742,
-0.0614143498,
0.1546735764,
0.4490420222,
0.0005195673,
-0.2379131466,
0.5072173476,
-0.1247635856,
-0.1287664026,
0.2004524171,
0.2785852551,
0.1600582898,
-0.2353439033,
-0.121497035,
-0.1332440972,
-0.4177183807,
0.8309620023,
0.294899106,
-0.4866200686,
-0.5704058409,
-0.0996330157,
0.4197080731,
-0.1011948064,
0.5604588389,
-0.9946860075,
0.5458777547,
0.3288015723,
0.3437903225,
0.9863079786,
-0.1289965063,
0.8303966522,
-1.0533157587,
0.0728126988,
0.4048265815,
0.1458245069,
0.1769706011,
-0.321425885,
0.4655779302,
0.1465885937,
-0.2463766932,
-0.9361413121,
0.2455851734,
-0.7604136467,
-0.3205677867,
0.9830906391,
-0.5864797831,
-0.3378478587,
-0.1123507917,
0.6861744523,
0.6163563132,
-0.336920321,
0.6026247144,
0.4140427709,
-0.1617280692,
-0.4989677072,
-0.5088202357,
0.275763154,
-0.2267027497,
-0.1944054514,
0.106431447,
0.2975321412,
0.4999068081,
-0.0919590965,
0.4366364777,
-0.2034725845,
0.098187834,
0.0044530039,
-0.2883589268,
-0.8386247754,
-0.1813863367,
-0.1480309367,
0.2060252726,
0.1294380426,
0.0662427098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09383v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09383v1
|
Long-form Question Answering: An Iterative Planning-Retrieval-Generation Approach
| 2023-11-15T21:22:27 | 2023-11-15T21:22:27 |
Pritom Saha Akash, Kashob Kumar Roy, Lucian Popa, Kevin Chen-Chuan Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Long-form question answering (LFQA) poses a challenge as it involves
generating detailed answers in the form of paragraphs, which go beyond simple
yes/no responses or short factual answers. While existing QA models excel in
questions with concise answers, LFQA requires handling multiple topics and
their intricate relationships, demanding comprehensive explanations. Previous
attempts at LFQA focused on generating long-form answers by utilizing relevant
contexts from a corpus, relying solely on the question itself. However, they
overlooked the possibility that the question alone might not provide sufficient
information to identify the relevant contexts. Additionally, generating
detailed long-form answers often entails aggregating knowledge from diverse
sources. To address these limitations, we propose an LFQA model with iterative
Planning, Retrieval, and Generation. This iterative process continues until a
complete answer is generated for the given question. From an extensive
experiment on both an open domain and a technical domain QA dataset, we find
that our model outperforms the state-of-the-art models on various textual and
factual metrics for the LFQA task.
|
[
-0.3853135705,
-1.1725742817,
0.9703927636,
0.3562468886,
-0.1124543995,
0.0599441938,
0.0132939909,
-0.4719469249,
0.2091446072,
0.5213234425,
-0.9113002419,
-0.2858048379,
-0.173168093,
-0.0231534149,
-0.675270319,
0.7841427922,
-0.3475363553,
-0.341340065,
-0.3484985232,
-0.0130149797,
-0.6547804475,
-0.4594860673,
-0.6910167336,
-0.2534236014,
0.5334126353,
0.4860388935,
0.6739246249,
0.1896318793,
0.1861845106,
0.1686663479,
-0.1719516069,
0.1653410196,
-0.526694119,
0.2406915426,
-0.2461377829,
-0.0622386299,
-0.2016533762,
-0.3935832977,
0.6122740507,
1.0222892761,
-0.2195717096,
0.4934194684,
-0.2443623245,
0.6005926728,
-0.5299065709,
-0.1609464735,
-0.4294747114,
-0.0068334397,
-0.1144082174,
-0.1983138621,
-0.1822235435,
-0.283701241,
0.1788207144,
-0.5830123425,
0.1191846058,
-0.2434315383,
0.6612215638,
0.1116900295,
-0.6458846331,
-0.531111598,
-1.0866869688,
0.5285978317,
-0.4243971407,
0.3662887216,
0.2860026956,
0.4671866298,
-0.2281520069,
-0.9349149466,
-0.453397274,
-0.1910461187,
0.1866928041,
0.1807850003,
0.0190352015,
-0.0315296687,
0.1986143589,
0.1702704728,
-0.6704980135,
-0.1189817041,
-0.7324137688,
0.0034052753,
0.7128692269,
0.2585465014,
-0.0440611392,
-0.2125311196,
-0.5143275857,
0.26800704,
-0.7714779973,
0.5655342937,
-0.1434647441,
0.1167317331,
0.5231851339,
0.9067214131,
-0.6718668938,
0.7290614247,
0.1551948339,
-0.2231342793,
-0.3483341634,
-0.4139697254,
-0.2386824489,
-0.198440358,
0.4301169515,
0.1002408266,
0.0673720315,
-0.3181732595,
-0.301351577,
-0.3482306302,
0.3907334208,
-0.7958776951,
0.2249548435,
0.7094800472,
-0.15328601,
-0.0547165684,
-0.2133057117,
-0.7673675418,
0.0640806928,
-0.3000207841,
0.8058366179,
-0.4041459262,
-0.1359702051,
0.222494334,
0.0175010394,
0.3578469753,
0.2835443318,
-0.3114725351,
0.3292133212,
0.462192744,
0.3899670541,
-0.2590385675,
-0.2103126943,
-0.7740159631,
0.1941747963,
-0.3905399144,
0.7782408595,
-0.3288522065,
-0.5635297298,
0.2779437304,
-0.0754206032,
0.1376597583,
-0.4893501997,
0.4660745859,
-1.0093063116,
0.596711576,
-0.4220478535,
-0.567101419,
-0.0809030458,
0.4099253416,
-0.7522338033,
1.141712904,
0.3201234937,
-0.4636679888,
0.2190370262,
-0.6937083602,
-0.3413936198,
-0.0539826825,
-0.1945792288,
-0.2004795671,
-0.0110180248,
0.1868569106,
0.520544827,
-0.4215219021,
0.6049295664,
0.0468624122,
-0.2742544413,
0.3172454834,
-0.1508253515,
0.4983786643,
0.2844685316,
-0.3303471506,
0.1398856193,
-0.736415565,
0.2441735864,
0.2318561226,
-0.4575052559,
0.076753974,
0.0164490584,
-0.2237706184,
0.3872658312,
0.2665905952,
-0.594725132,
0.1202004403,
-0.0522326715,
0.3721830845,
0.4848974049,
0.3837077022,
0.5517880917,
-0.4836408794,
0.7826645374,
-0.073210381,
0.0580177084,
-0.0523758791,
-0.3197031021,
-0.5077013969,
-0.0217217617,
0.121597901,
0.263212949,
-0.9831990004,
-0.0158712734,
-0.2783747017,
-0.5034536719,
-0.1505858302,
0.0792791769,
0.1619898677,
0.6505890489,
0.4519838095,
-0.0806345716,
-0.1057802364,
-0.7259902358,
-0.0589937903,
-0.0482365005,
0.0439059213,
0.1469866186,
0.5364639759,
0.1962128878,
1.0211603642,
-0.745405674,
-0.041880399,
-0.1566704661,
0.0782421157,
0.2531041205,
0.0720012859,
0.3675267398,
-0.8615753651,
-0.0984115601,
-0.4685128927,
-0.5596234798,
0.2204049081,
-0.3286057413,
-0.3696196079,
-0.1585993469,
0.3764657378,
-0.9189616442,
0.4480605423,
0.0579069555,
-0.3893046677,
0.5778072476,
0.1808785647,
-0.0067006294,
-1.0848038197,
0.3433437347,
-0.3121425211,
-0.2145163715,
-0.7773780823,
0.4910977483,
0.0463541262,
-0.4573415518,
-0.3029678166,
0.8062903881,
-0.322997719,
-0.0333633423,
-0.1719370633,
0.1059443206,
0.2923566997,
0.5486282706,
0.1855874509,
0.8950879574,
0.1752339154,
-0.7698193789,
0.2015883625,
0.3507970273,
-0.1643640995,
0.2517578304,
-0.8339025974,
0.2444640994,
-0.6062905192,
0.3612177968,
-0.9713580608,
-0.4095598161,
-0.0118444143,
-0.3158071041,
0.2310279459,
0.1762478948,
-0.1876551807,
-0.5484628081,
-0.3098161519,
0.693267107,
0.3246242702,
-0.4508241415,
0.9091396928,
-0.034581393,
-0.4480427206,
-0.7359585166,
-0.129849121,
-0.1564568132,
-0.1731622666,
-0.8895163536,
0.55179286,
-0.1885707676,
-0.2532810569,
-0.065434821,
-0.2906469405,
-0.5337920785,
0.1950409263,
0.0354249105,
-0.103203401,
-0.3657201529,
0.4430094957,
0.1725372672,
0.3495565653,
0.2882291675,
-0.004231059,
0.5125650167,
0.4296541214,
-0.2648361623,
-0.0982265249,
1.185290575,
0.5491465926,
-0.5849109292,
0.4696697295,
0.3084602952,
-0.5683991313,
-0.2206983715,
-0.4234201908,
-0.0202341489,
-0.4236345589,
0.358166635,
-0.6178462505,
-0.776022315,
0.5499452353,
-0.1273395121,
0.4850798249,
0.4950428009,
0.341122508,
-0.2625705004,
0.6775119305,
0.7058874369,
0.2189922482,
0.1818345636,
-0.238515988,
0.108758688,
-0.3813806474,
-0.4930749536,
-0.6553953886,
0.0624435395,
-0.1115218773,
-0.5412341952,
0.4628504217,
0.3623797297,
-0.5196636915,
0.0042378469,
-0.3709309697,
0.0961997136,
0.6153035164,
0.2515503466,
0.3113577366,
-0.1792599112,
0.2707163095,
0.4741977155,
-0.5455492139,
-0.3734951913,
0.8831000924,
0.3748152256,
0.5153122544,
0.453273505,
0.9328562617,
-0.0706620365,
0.0819759592,
-0.7680237293,
0.412317872,
0.2087586224,
-0.6855171919,
-0.7681944966,
-0.176016584,
-0.8699073792,
-0.1050128713,
-0.0495490618,
-0.4648041129,
0.110740602,
-0.1652250439,
-0.7689663768,
-0.1922958493,
-0.2749882042,
0.5624786019,
-0.2523952425,
-0.4011536837,
0.0652362034,
-0.5795052052,
0.4875264168,
-0.4126343727,
0.0545801148,
-0.0015657522,
0.0411431193,
0.8269929886,
-0.2898629904,
0.5275105238,
-0.3142747581,
-0.3300959766,
0.6982896328,
0.0562630408,
0.4830461442,
0.2729406059,
-0.2398501784,
-0.5900759697,
0.4539037347,
-0.7914165258,
-0.7306300402,
0.4274742305,
-0.7440261245,
-0.7011386156,
-0.1839508116,
-0.4027503133,
-0.5278750658,
0.1424861252,
0.1925733238,
0.5231730342,
-0.4397085905,
-0.1394444257,
0.819636941,
-0.3346586227,
0.4304428697,
0.2361683697,
-0.4058125019,
-0.1788827181,
0.300891012,
0.1835356504,
0.2964230478,
0.4352199733,
-0.0754322782,
-0.5302065611,
-0.5210139155,
-0.6411497593,
0.2465671003,
-0.7285020351,
-0.3144239783,
-0.6001884341,
-0.3863343,
-0.2893919945,
-0.0864697695,
-0.0866289958,
-0.6177649498,
-0.2133121341,
0.0690457299,
0.2200907618,
0.7596108913,
0.4147469401,
0.1721262932,
-0.7799697518,
0.7507991791,
0.7151882052,
0.1666836292,
0.0227174256,
-0.323721081,
0.1053753272,
0.1327023953,
-0.4134698212,
-1.185270071,
0.0683475062,
0.3261713684,
0.4713795483,
-0.0693787858,
0.23279351,
0.8406683207,
-0.6000885367,
1.1161627769,
-0.0557047799,
-0.6656678915,
0.5357097387,
-0.2409817725,
0.5963363051,
0.5739101768,
0.7099648714,
-0.3071344793,
-0.1116417125,
-0.374979496,
-1.012830615,
0.1101618111,
0.1942207813,
0.2690828443,
-0.0204278659,
0.7279595733,
0.1691363603,
0.2127153724,
-0.6506880522,
0.0969700068,
-0.3445519507,
-0.0679463297,
0.1489333659,
-0.4303670228,
-0.3942084908,
0.0018017301,
0.5422782302,
-0.2722344995,
0.6542268991,
0.5034386516,
-0.1394111216,
-0.2051775008,
0.5221819282,
0.7630360126,
1.1271777153,
-0.0851476118,
-0.0714247599,
0.0644595101,
-0.0263621286,
0.1228657812,
0.2987391949,
-0.1824180186,
0.069502674,
0.2193611115,
0.2793651819,
-0.2040001601,
-0.7189257145,
0.5452235341,
0.0015316058,
-0.5076773167,
-0.7341218591,
-0.2136191279,
0.3521763384,
0.2880834043,
0.733666718,
-0.5755340457,
0.2146005481,
-0.7562676072,
0.3716608286,
0.3625724018,
-0.2282695472,
0.032429222,
0.6302012205,
0.1206603572,
-0.2180164903,
0.6097511649,
0.0612105168,
-0.3396812975,
0.7352706194,
0.5692450404,
0.5766794086,
0.0278326292,
0.5537587404,
0.4354406893,
-0.0898435488,
-0.0208123326,
0.8543621302,
-0.223263219,
-0.2443181574,
-0.7094829082,
-0.6491487026,
-0.2861683369,
0.2788023651,
-0.6746726036,
-0.0128354393,
-0.4812799394,
-0.0399010181,
0.0340503082,
0.0772758275,
-0.8326691389,
0.5606538653,
-0.1663985252,
1.2034225464,
-0.3816259503,
0.4931382239,
0.5709755421,
-0.6262592077,
-1.0613226891,
0.1991019845,
-0.4772384465,
-0.6306805015,
0.5979683995,
0.0941972136,
0.0028212219,
-0.1605418324,
-0.5439721346,
-1.02909863,
1.4281377792,
-0.1239595339,
-0.3778868616,
-0.5488997698,
0.3854388595,
0.4412621558,
-0.1312924474,
-0.0397020616,
0.2050065845,
0.2841961384,
0.2731024921,
-0.9133800268,
0.3059169948,
-0.0757945254,
-0.2341061383,
0.2377511114,
-0.5480847955,
0.6710300446,
-0.2407196909,
-0.2423566878,
0.5435326099,
0.910785377,
0.2742417157,
0.3854491115,
0.4252724051,
0.1159038916,
0.8136370182,
0.1136218682,
0.6630196571,
-0.1991317272,
0.1431839764,
1.2210104465,
-0.2057556957,
0.9139661789,
0.52333498,
0.0682906061,
0.3579876721,
0.772518158,
0.5513323545,
0.4497114122,
0.4358239472,
-0.53066957,
-0.3268403113,
-0.1165340915,
-0.294747591,
0.620328486,
0.0813342854,
-0.2357068062,
-0.560808897,
-0.010490681,
-0.0689404309,
0.1169917285,
-0.4064510763,
0.6887453794,
0.0249544084,
-1.1109730005,
0.6238923669,
0.0899244472,
0.1904849857,
-0.5861284137,
-0.1209697649,
-0.3858063221,
-0.3024344146,
0.0830314457,
-1.0905604362,
0.3001936078,
0.0649253651,
-0.3698362708,
-0.2246805429,
0.6749438643,
-0.4933534265,
-0.3620861769,
-0.0343605801,
0.9395626783,
-0.0730499551,
-0.2600391507,
-0.4958081245,
-0.407938838,
-0.1199432462,
-0.317908287,
0.1656577885,
0.5514791012,
-0.351267159,
0.6818379164,
0.3272958994,
-0.3863628209,
0.1338064671,
-0.2269260287,
0.9948622584,
-0.8912166953,
-0.3198094368,
-0.288649261,
0.7845581174,
-0.1476522088,
-0.4188029766,
0.0043936968,
0.374207437,
0.4765223563,
0.1213699281,
0.4519539475,
-0.0359867699,
0.6525655389,
-0.6948744059,
0.2690448761,
-0.6756156087,
0.1115646735,
0.0207200814,
-0.8968562484,
-0.0442967154,
0.1112773716,
0.1072678789,
-0.0585499518,
0.6744974852,
0.3839136064,
0.0844943598,
-0.0045342674,
0.2622885406,
-0.0712257624,
0.5584999323,
0.8151625395,
1.0456240177,
-0.3415049314,
0.6224719882,
-0.4468004107,
-0.043293532,
0.1714611501,
-0.6659625769,
-0.7060089707,
-0.7812485695,
0.0543223247,
-0.3599945009,
0.1027717218,
0.8229799867,
0.3754176497,
-0.418176651,
-0.1979790777,
0.3143897355,
-0.0329421684,
0.0126384422,
-0.2707019448,
0.4304559529,
-0.2767890394,
-0.3833024502,
0.4213452041,
-0.15511778,
0.0134687163,
-0.3727189898,
0.2908292413,
-0.2315388769,
0.2981334925,
0.8536989093,
0.4801502824,
-0.6633470654,
-0.5328418612,
0.6693098545,
-0.0249671359,
-0.0536141619,
0.7642307281,
-0.8673277497,
0.0802711695,
0.3258375227,
0.9813548326,
0.7277300358,
0.1573937237,
0.8270255923,
-0.7398781776,
-0.4430575669,
0.4756879508,
0.0714921281,
0.0679549649,
-0.6077585816,
0.5484495163,
-0.4434570968,
-0.6322392225,
-0.621997714,
0.5115658641,
-1.2873171568,
-0.6316444874,
1.3575378656,
0.0454069488,
-0.1046275571,
-0.2336068004,
-0.3613464832,
0.1306959391,
-0.2687016726,
0.7868958712,
0.544361949,
-0.4242314398,
-0.0273327772,
-0.5719032884,
0.5258088112,
0.4069142342,
-0.8799641132,
-0.0158325415,
0.6786991358,
0.5228001475,
0.2820130587,
1.1423094273,
0.0679941773,
0.6044592261,
-0.4290673435,
-0.2824280858,
0.1474091709,
-0.4503071606,
-0.0017775,
0.7964408994,
0.4184509814,
-0.0448791385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09367v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09367v1
|
A Survey on Online User Aggression: Content Detection and Behavioural Analysis on Social Media Platforms
| 2023-11-15T20:59:13 | 2023-11-15T20:59:13 |
Swapnil Mane, Suman Kundu, Rajesh Sharma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rise of social media platforms has led to an increase in cyber-aggressive
behavior, encompassing a broad spectrum of hostile behavior, including
cyberbullying, online harassment, and the dissemination of offensive and hate
speech. These behaviors have been associated with significant societal
consequences, ranging from online anonymity to real-world outcomes such as
depression, suicidal tendencies, and, in some instances, offline violence.
Recognizing the societal risks associated with unchecked aggressive content,
this paper delves into the field of Aggression Content Detection and Behavioral
Analysis of Aggressive Users, aiming to bridge the gap between disparate
studies. In this paper, we analyzed the diversity of definitions and proposed a
unified cyber-aggression definition. We examine the comprehensive process of
Aggression Content Detection, spanning from dataset creation, feature selection
and extraction, and detection algorithm development. Further, we review studies
on Behavioral Analysis of Aggression that explore the influencing factors,
consequences, and patterns associated with cyber-aggressive behavior. This
systematic literature review is a cross-examination of content detection and
behavioral analysis in the realm of cyber-aggression. The integrated
investigation reveals the effectiveness of incorporating sociological insights
into computational techniques for preventing cyber-aggressive behavior.
Finally, the paper concludes by identifying research gaps and encouraging
further progress in the unified domain of socio-computational aggressive
behavior analysis.
|
[
-0.4272438884,
-1.2916792631,
0.2438843846,
0.4087233245,
0.0239136387,
0.3587319553,
0.0203183163,
-0.6002351046,
0.6384699345,
0.381454885,
-0.7186895609,
-0.175099358,
-0.6682189703,
-0.0157453008,
-0.4498669207,
0.6489447355,
0.0921578556,
-0.0563765951,
-0.063226901,
-0.021472076,
-0.4654547572,
-0.4702430964,
-0.7904200554,
0.0042385682,
0.7876556516,
-0.105412446,
0.3681276143,
0.0672937632,
0.9037860036,
0.4979612231,
-0.1064452976,
-0.1060925722,
-0.6491883993,
0.2425823957,
-0.2835884392,
0.1790577024,
-0.4237388968,
-0.5197159052,
0.2885202765,
0.1659451574,
-0.1107007563,
0.2505652308,
0.1568226069,
0.4877761006,
-0.6862655282,
-0.3500805497,
-0.1973476857,
0.1403032392,
-0.3470186293,
-0.2910788655,
-0.0858481526,
-0.4357847869,
-0.2686665356,
-0.4707183838,
-0.2136155069,
-0.3541883826,
0.4466328621,
-0.0888923481,
-0.6041859388,
-0.5493194461,
-1.0222178698,
0.5954969525,
-0.183777079,
0.1491345912,
0.2830682099,
0.1929020435,
-0.2510198057,
-0.4303555489,
-0.3182272613,
0.2552135289,
0.0268970877,
-0.0121173989,
-0.8095865846,
-0.0034236072,
0.019998854,
0.0767881125,
-0.5188322663,
0.1916231662,
-0.6251193881,
-0.3021550179,
1.0497971773,
0.2424202263,
0.8070279956,
-0.1898016334,
-0.3860452473,
0.2322076559,
-0.098421894,
0.4888092577,
0.8711351156,
0.1466121674,
-0.0602585264,
0.3918074071,
0.0420754701,
0.1820667386,
0.3938869238,
-0.0702443942,
-0.0283074677,
-0.4520495534,
0.455040127,
0.1147396564,
1.120647788,
0.7370793223,
0.439181,
-0.0041468274,
-0.1430073529,
0.4190452993,
0.9406101704,
-0.6559804082,
-0.075631611,
0.4394411743,
-0.6344467402,
-0.6155378222,
0.0183573272,
-1.2746554613,
-0.816939652,
0.0007800658,
0.2702982426,
-0.1008590162,
-0.847162962,
-0.0871543214,
-0.0992181823,
0.2222934812,
-0.0883541927,
-0.4943748116,
0.8542976975,
0.5453124642,
0.81294626,
-0.4712848961,
0.0958138928,
-0.2837066054,
-0.3230911791,
-0.3917531371,
0.7173407078,
-0.4697861969,
-0.3708328903,
0.410292387,
-0.1847908646,
0.3470127583,
-0.2895855308,
0.6167064905,
-0.6783132553,
-0.4058190882,
-0.5688491464,
-0.1931189895,
-0.338591814,
0.4128903747,
-0.4136636853,
1.1725111008,
0.114381209,
-0.7317410707,
0.1608946174,
-0.9050964117,
-0.4767254889,
0.2122568786,
-0.0253646709,
-0.3487180769,
0.0200911108,
-0.0635422245,
0.3812277019,
0.157129094,
0.2043165714,
-0.6564641595,
-0.2694689035,
0.5196793675,
0.2812021673,
1.1662365198,
0.2337927371,
-0.3474210501,
0.448037982,
-0.1754470021,
-0.2121999711,
0.4445639849,
0.1352373511,
-0.5000672936,
0.257858485,
0.0940227285,
0.5304610133,
0.1919885129,
-0.9441464543,
-0.1106978357,
0.2567050457,
0.3571836352,
0.8682553172,
0.4502637982,
0.003470087,
-0.436165899,
0.7500992417,
-0.0084202159,
0.3690630794,
0.386613667,
-0.260020107,
0.1126357615,
-0.0968883857,
-0.2731725872,
0.4331296086,
-0.3188335299,
0.5278224349,
-0.0637261346,
-0.7901198864,
-0.1009929329,
0.1863941252,
0.4070213139,
0.1062244698,
0.3276828527,
-0.5328999162,
-0.8246750236,
-0.3073374033,
-0.5819657445,
-0.1871004552,
0.2756044567,
0.2672409117,
0.2438243628,
-0.3828949332,
0.6520668268,
-0.3858357966,
-0.3411584496,
-0.4064427316,
0.4677739739,
-0.6211352348,
0.1084198132,
0.6314893365,
-0.9739550948,
-1.0333007574,
-0.361274004,
-0.7923024297,
-0.3253836334,
0.0835621282,
-0.1847956479,
-0.3906876147,
0.808386445,
-0.2527794838,
0.3565870523,
0.1399765164,
-0.2558054328,
0.4394500554,
0.4131708741,
0.4012963772,
-0.4299803674,
-0.1581467092,
0.6944845319,
-0.0596812889,
-0.9294510484,
0.2730060816,
-0.4976459146,
-0.0623161159,
-0.4903922677,
0.046808593,
-0.0732026771,
-0.1029415429,
-0.2556414008,
0.1278469861,
-0.4104409814,
0.4334480464,
-0.1272334307,
0.4275615513,
0.6437692642,
-0.6329442859,
0.4120930433,
0.1995575279,
-0.1609738022,
0.8551861644,
-0.7002362609,
-0.035547711,
-0.3746894002,
0.1689755768,
-1.0931932926,
-0.1657620966,
0.5425741673,
-0.6110976338,
-0.0917826444,
-0.033821661,
-0.2258259505,
-0.2510448992,
-0.7981686592,
0.3958565295,
0.2918753624,
0.0089738993,
0.5711952448,
0.9164974093,
-0.599086225,
-0.4713972509,
-0.2881881595,
0.0969442949,
-0.4150315523,
-0.4995782673,
0.4159719348,
-0.152755931,
-0.7553600669,
-0.1642640233,
0.2034449279,
-0.4298994243,
0.1617703736,
0.2087703794,
0.1156428158,
0.1930144578,
-0.2996387482,
-0.2693573534,
0.3164541721,
0.6475486755,
0.3452625275,
0.8098675013,
-0.11355564,
0.0313767418,
-0.6474084258,
0.5282897949,
0.2697762549,
-0.0341997556,
0.1765237004,
0.8945277929,
-0.2113443762,
0.2501078844,
-0.1289876103,
-0.0883070081,
-0.5586833954,
0.2980375886,
0.1336600631,
-0.7222043276,
0.6448756456,
-0.0418545939,
0.1504440606,
0.4588324428,
0.5158195496,
-0.4231392741,
1.1288701296,
0.585565567,
0.1838141084,
0.6155397892,
0.2830477655,
0.1467493176,
-0.4049616456,
-0.3022649288,
-0.4807761014,
-0.6540772319,
-1.035389781,
0.2453542352,
0.2089960873,
-0.5716629624,
-0.3390222788,
0.5266862512,
-0.5041749477,
0.3291608095,
-0.2789504826,
0.2153585553,
0.0445453972,
-0.0292882249,
0.1605627686,
-0.3968752623,
-0.2889536619,
-0.0315327086,
0.9483731389,
0.2171915621,
0.5469669104,
0.6442222595,
0.3960843384,
1.1280486584,
0.1980144083,
-1.0395371914,
0.5908150673,
0.0852619335,
-0.892754972,
-0.091260612,
-0.4492146671,
-1.1624547243,
0.0487143397,
-0.2704302669,
-1.1723146439,
0.1113892421,
0.2058934867,
-0.5607068539,
0.3672756553,
-0.1105664968,
0.6287155151,
-0.4372159243,
-0.7374357581,
-0.271186471,
-0.5844990015,
0.6311540008,
-0.2107837349,
0.5545580983,
0.1013457403,
0.0646664128,
0.8596078753,
-0.0096716881,
0.9785716534,
-0.3501234651,
0.0043724487,
0.6695878506,
0.2630246878,
0.2352215946,
-0.3957999349,
0.3240936399,
0.132454142,
-0.0369200818,
-0.3763614595,
-0.1982865185,
0.6004043818,
-0.6676703095,
0.0855572894,
-0.399759531,
0.0830335245,
-0.1157888621,
0.201566413,
0.2059588879,
0.3522369564,
-0.709328413,
0.1272836477,
1.0112856627,
-0.0055218749,
0.4756634831,
0.4368315637,
-0.4306171536,
-0.2395120412,
1.2955243587,
-0.0398676395,
-0.179619506,
0.1660931706,
0.3129558563,
-0.3380005062,
-0.4339806736,
-0.0728368312,
-0.0512060188,
-0.2270685285,
0.0993050113,
-0.6921131611,
0.0019870105,
-0.5495477915,
-0.2811764777,
-0.4228194654,
0.345495522,
0.1212890446,
0.3182175457,
0.0974497944,
1.2026822567,
-0.1252991706,
0.9914343953,
-0.6777575612,
0.3671422601,
0.1926635653,
0.2696596086,
0.0197787154,
-0.182660073,
0.2074050307,
-0.3515055776,
-0.8236852288,
-1.1864032745,
0.2168472558,
-0.1572838575,
0.355980128,
0.7611512542,
0.178482756,
0.4542445242,
0.1058693752,
0.5036361217,
0.338752538,
-0.4227820933,
0.2199586332,
-0.7044222951,
-0.0725626051,
0.5242149234,
1.1016974449,
-0.8526878953,
0.2051326185,
-0.7601411939,
-0.690114677,
0.3239407539,
-0.0374912918,
0.2376382947,
0.1233967468,
-0.0233399551,
-0.1973317862,
0.2278395891,
-0.9395037889,
-0.3604388535,
-0.0269772913,
0.0564443432,
0.3874662817,
-0.1550670862,
-0.156099394,
-0.2181402445,
0.5069283843,
0.1859720945,
0.1780533344,
-0.1642806977,
-0.1782547683,
-0.6752009988,
0.0686098859,
0.1284308732,
0.5538164377,
-0.2304586321,
-0.2052849978,
-0.2908204198,
-0.7246125937,
0.1457313001,
-0.222838223,
-0.2978008687,
-0.2172184736,
-0.0860168636,
0.0165627468,
0.480759114,
-0.7563456297,
0.9164818525,
-0.2392843515,
-0.2945820093,
-0.4954963923,
-0.0996859148,
-0.1931606084,
-0.020109972,
0.1255001128,
0.098574765,
0.3490198255,
-0.6739045382,
0.2613224089,
0.4628673494,
-0.7578291893,
-0.4539027512,
0.3228164017,
0.3869338334,
-0.4453342259,
0.1569030434,
-0.5064911246,
-0.6167283058,
0.549077034,
0.2983326614,
0.8243170381,
-0.1984349489,
0.6287710071,
0.4208903909,
0.2999465764,
0.3010760248,
0.6933599114,
-0.0042643985,
-0.8043073416,
-0.1756499261,
-0.5109891295,
-0.2026225179,
0.4549506307,
-0.7403725386,
0.1998592466,
-1.0846948624,
-0.4894985855,
0.6250563264,
0.2267607301,
-0.4219327271,
-0.0509357043,
0.1108961701,
0.2811919451,
-0.8369554281,
-0.2125388682,
0.9509735107,
-0.3352795243,
-0.0742290318,
0.1014220417,
0.7562645674,
-0.4239095449,
0.1444384456,
0.0996965021,
-0.4030174017,
-0.2613385916,
-0.8145612478,
-0.5581252575,
0.3735992312,
-0.2589637339,
-0.0795505717,
0.3437731564,
0.1491453052,
0.7250675559,
-0.0493568219,
0.0938231796,
0.5445779562,
0.3186669648,
0.0484160185,
-0.2096921206,
-0.0200711992,
-0.3742657006,
-0.2574127018,
0.4930742979,
-0.8360227942,
0.7278544903,
0.2698609829,
-0.3555979729,
-0.3860837817,
0.3801443279,
-0.1279787719,
0.515778482,
0.5879592896,
0.227603972,
0.1365776956,
0.1883003116,
0.4538609385,
0.0187994242,
-0.0445498042,
0.5173225403,
-0.0804143474,
0.5452796221,
0.0975034088,
-0.4338361621,
0.8692114949,
0.8455414176,
-0.158023715,
0.1167958826,
0.2233074605,
-0.314347744,
-0.3166951537,
-0.6815828085,
-0.0192501731,
0.896761179,
0.7221304178,
0.0528110415,
-0.3753281236,
-0.2568292916,
0.3574169874,
0.5226208568,
-0.6832917333,
1.0372815132,
-0.3862783909,
-0.463096559,
-0.1229055971,
0.2567429841,
0.9848080873,
-0.8775078654,
0.3559360504,
0.1818193793,
-0.1791938841,
-0.4448592961,
-0.7777648568,
0.6283387542,
0.3268583715,
0.2570959926,
-0.2046932429,
1.3303729296,
0.0310541987,
-0.1363560408,
0.530726552,
0.6047328711,
0.2510059774,
-0.216956988,
-0.9540789723,
0.0645075217,
-0.2365543842,
0.01406518,
0.8459902406,
-0.0527982973,
-0.070795536,
0.3950656056,
0.6755361557,
0.0062202266,
-0.1322133541,
-0.4251866043,
0.9148116708,
-0.2724934518,
-0.6220481396,
-0.7676440477,
0.3305067122,
-0.4019978344,
-0.5453970432,
0.5376707315,
0.257314384,
0.836835742,
0.3924779594,
0.7602304816,
-0.7056879997,
0.3045652509,
0.1857755333,
0.44203192,
-0.4960404038,
-0.2632096708,
-0.5654239655,
-0.6278793216,
0.1564536393,
0.1772574782,
-0.2278900743,
0.0477916077,
0.0787251517,
0.5167845488,
-0.1086239368,
0.0550376624,
-0.0558000803,
-0.0574522428,
0.0455189124,
-0.1081962734,
0.6538836956,
-0.1586618572,
0.6937896609,
-0.3970091641,
-0.333966583,
-0.4215306044,
-0.5797541738,
-0.9969930649,
-0.2371606529,
-0.2349778265,
-0.2988006771,
-0.0590684824,
0.8993418813,
0.276422441,
-0.7609089613,
-0.4471994638,
0.1068102568,
0.0085806204,
-0.4128997624,
-0.2886385024,
-0.1892419606,
-0.0850241333,
-0.4284353554,
0.1067949906,
0.0930752233,
-0.227638185,
-0.5008264184,
0.0920123011,
-0.6411653757,
0.364576906,
0.5782818198,
0.7806674242,
-0.057113789,
0.1022729427,
0.2117935121,
-0.1890136302,
0.1438771039,
0.959841907,
0.0655817837,
0.5808041692,
0.6162460446,
0.7218167782,
0.1901887953,
0.4153529108,
0.1057384759,
-0.7863461375,
-0.4346815944,
0.3263157904,
0.0423924327,
0.2333080769,
-0.6636240482,
0.1594668925,
0.4087435007,
-0.4564752281,
-0.5781451464,
0.2865347266,
-0.8425683379,
-0.3442728519,
1.0126053095,
-0.0563588887,
-0.0498376824,
-0.2990757823,
-0.2065847516,
0.3590664566,
-0.8089445829,
1.2372362614,
0.7296370864,
-0.365614593,
0.150273174,
-0.6696156859,
0.6246477365,
0.1822111309,
-0.8985536695,
0.0792815834,
0.3892258406,
-0.0042292513,
0.2536089122,
0.3770914674,
-0.0262313224,
0.1938069165,
0.0685166791,
-0.0694479197,
0.2545799613,
-0.3474572897,
-0.3384893239,
0.3154216409,
-0.5184147954,
0.1496583372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09366v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09366v1
|
LOKE: Linked Open Knowledge Extraction for Automated Knowledge Graph Construction
| 2023-11-15T20:57:44 | 2023-11-15T20:57:44 |
Jamie McCusker
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While the potential of Open Information Extraction (Open IE) for Knowledge
Graph Construction (KGC) may seem promising, we find that the alignment of Open
IE extraction results with existing knowledge graphs to be inadequate. The
advent of Large Language Models (LLMs), especially the commercially available
OpenAI models, have reset expectations for what is possible with deep learning
models and have created a new field called prompt engineering. We investigate
the use of GPT models and prompt engineering for knowledge graph construction
with the Wikidata knowledge graph to address a similar problem to Open IE,
which we call Open Knowledge Extraction (OKE) using an approach we call the
Linked Open Knowledge Extractor (LOKE, pronounced like "Loki"). We consider the
entity linking task essential to construction of real world knowledge graphs.
We merge the CaRB benchmark scoring approach with data from the TekGen dataset
for the LOKE task. We then show that a well engineered prompt, paired with a
naive entity linking approach (which we call LOKE-GPT), outperforms AllenAI's
OpenIE 4 implementation on the OKE task, although it over-generates triples
compared to the reference set due to overall triple scarcity in the TekGen set.
Through an analysis of entity linkability in the CaRB dataset, as well as
outputs from OpenIE 4 and LOKE-GPT, we see that LOKE-GPT and the "silver"
TekGen triples show that the task is significantly different in content from
OIE, if not structure. Through this analysis and a qualitative analysis of
sentence extractions via all methods, we found that LOKE-GPT extractions are of
high utility for the KGC task and suitable for use in semi-automated extraction
settings.
|
[
-0.381618619,
-0.7366139889,
0.6972360015,
-0.1569404155,
0.1104322448,
-0.1390937269,
0.0170335416,
-0.7058644891,
0.0306161661,
0.1557704806,
-0.2712888718,
-0.5575845242,
-0.509657979,
0.1865563244,
-0.1017947122,
0.8586431146,
-0.445263207,
-0.2670858502,
-0.0385231115,
-0.0297205709,
-0.7378668785,
0.0459118634,
-0.7234615684,
0.047799021,
0.742380619,
0.2863907218,
0.5986127853,
0.5624163151,
0.1264837831,
0.2838587761,
-0.0045258622,
0.0203779247,
-0.4159979522,
0.3136005998,
-0.2916744649,
-0.3790796995,
-0.4150594473,
0.4374909103,
0.5017845035,
0.6703550816,
0.2463708669,
0.1838851571,
0.1393299401,
0.5611066818,
-0.6398265958,
0.7607584596,
-0.660538137,
-0.2127813101,
-0.2266589403,
0.1480703056,
-0.3421223462,
-0.5816116333,
0.1705254614,
-0.9124770164,
-0.0675176457,
0.5250191689,
1.1391173601,
0.1932214648,
-0.3743372262,
-0.4526937306,
-0.5226737261,
0.3900195658,
-0.6037434936,
0.5855411887,
0.0062927878,
0.3554237485,
-0.3650259972,
-0.6598243713,
-0.8197037578,
-0.2984338999,
-0.0755716264,
0.23937352,
0.1091582999,
0.0736913159,
0.4535748065,
0.3182206154,
-0.4730142057,
0.2355181426,
-0.5936403871,
-0.2201934904,
0.2941834033,
-0.0450950004,
0.5696746111,
-0.5686546564,
-0.4734376371,
0.0543860532,
-0.8971220851,
0.0872984082,
0.343745172,
0.3979494572,
0.331977427,
0.9349809885,
-0.1687620431,
0.5870827436,
-0.0214583538,
-0.0209681969,
0.0744625106,
-0.3456689715,
-0.1572275013,
0.2877363563,
0.9192571044,
0.201204896,
0.3717061281,
-0.5204743147,
-0.1678886861,
-0.2387039661,
0.1751089543,
-0.6186640859,
-0.2878482342,
0.052718129,
-0.4728043973,
-0.1333832592,
0.206681177,
-0.5399175286,
-0.2977864742,
-0.3572634161,
0.3351581693,
-0.4951995611,
-0.2684170008,
-0.1368910223,
-0.2790724337,
0.3287035525,
0.1376232058,
-0.5833221078,
-0.0826161504,
0.487426281,
0.8713454604,
-0.1470449716,
-0.2358083576,
-0.5204633474,
0.4527572989,
-0.1825093627,
0.735489428,
-0.4126835763,
-0.3437438309,
-0.2232497334,
0.052756045,
-0.3716533184,
-0.4228830338,
0.5272532105,
-0.8754683137,
0.5136138797,
-0.4516708553,
-0.6883351803,
-0.247269839,
0.0211823899,
-0.9879255891,
1.1360539198,
0.3858949244,
-0.8621282578,
0.5913918018,
-1.0069063902,
-0.3041064441,
0.1128980517,
-0.2952920198,
0.082934089,
-0.1061225533,
0.2310029864,
0.3729406595,
-0.4980043471,
0.2605326772,
-0.4997478426,
0.0520494208,
-0.1708886474,
-0.0638358518,
1.0953382254,
0.4199725986,
-0.2802388668,
-0.0776091889,
-0.5308908224,
-0.154952094,
0.1579909623,
-0.340370208,
-0.5262264609,
-0.0666853264,
-0.4487692416,
0.2316042185,
0.16365695,
-0.7589185238,
0.4670269191,
-0.6772665977,
0.3182137012,
0.8705239892,
0.1831133664,
0.4535811543,
0.0912686437,
0.4203880131,
-0.063237004,
-0.0033427021,
0.191321075,
-0.787768364,
-0.2837218642,
-0.2167268544,
0.5151205063,
0.7631275654,
-1.0636453629,
0.3569283485,
-0.3267438114,
-0.286842674,
-0.6203187108,
0.0344869979,
0.0512563661,
1.0702288151,
0.2519947886,
-0.1426779926,
-0.1526394039,
-0.7165979147,
-0.2359332889,
-0.5120904446,
-0.2069426328,
0.2810956836,
0.2442529052,
0.2825657129,
1.3477777243,
-0.7824259996,
0.0343978815,
-0.010235941,
0.2141254544,
0.4253463149,
0.2614998519,
0.5655904412,
-0.7661717534,
-0.6768183708,
0.1288711876,
-1.1225392818,
-0.147919029,
0.1698236763,
-0.2055899203,
-0.1242936477,
0.5895901918,
-1.0898790359,
0.1843350232,
-0.0968588442,
-0.3295885921,
0.7069661617,
0.3060880899,
0.3464160562,
-1.2513093948,
0.2665051222,
0.0345445052,
-0.0051263995,
-0.3286916614,
0.0545749515,
-0.0279393308,
-0.4421081543,
-0.3343457878,
0.8495476842,
-0.6074805856,
-0.0345296822,
-0.0202799756,
0.4524210095,
-0.0488322116,
0.35387218,
-0.3754667044,
0.9661334753,
0.5533875227,
-0.4303584099,
0.5429111719,
0.4546188712,
-0.3641190231,
0.3969666958,
-0.6296916008,
0.106767185,
-0.2193455696,
-0.1983765215,
-0.809661448,
-0.2264430821,
0.6120926142,
-0.4443309307,
0.6657343507,
-0.0129457489,
-0.5022976995,
-0.4502854943,
-0.2307128459,
0.1658931971,
0.4241131842,
-0.6007087827,
0.5667032003,
0.3758222163,
-0.6710799336,
-0.4427599609,
0.0902655795,
0.0381877534,
-0.1745668203,
-0.8162456155,
0.0996699259,
0.1002823412,
-0.2149359435,
0.4552230239,
-0.3826229274,
-0.0569634363,
0.2006990314,
0.0526343212,
0.5821146369,
-0.5034606457,
0.210943073,
0.1123224944,
-0.1868785173,
0.2433632314,
-0.6920606494,
0.0567498505,
0.1250077337,
-0.2080464214,
-0.1896866411,
0.349122107,
0.3613467515,
-0.2173217535,
0.89534235,
0.5520503521,
-0.479137063,
0.1358499229,
-0.3881035149,
-0.0225037467,
-0.4622781873,
0.1826091409,
-0.6713596582,
-0.9516548514,
0.3552425802,
-0.3627792001,
0.256198436,
0.8874780536,
0.1518621743,
-0.2244442105,
0.7487200499,
0.6072745323,
-0.3976921439,
0.3799373209,
0.0149229812,
0.5251166224,
-0.6513698697,
-0.1541760862,
-0.7930970788,
-0.1430152804,
-0.3813976645,
0.102733098,
0.5117328167,
0.7000113726,
-0.1700409651,
0.5685283542,
-0.3154808283,
0.4768529832,
0.6018941402,
-0.012311996,
0.1582478136,
0.0181264523,
-0.2838826776,
0.2920999229,
-0.7990947366,
-0.5599685907,
1.0383501053,
0.1280929297,
0.4139793217,
-0.0712327585,
0.6258044243,
0.2926984727,
0.3702844977,
-0.667378366,
0.6029667854,
0.0763804317,
-0.5717911124,
-0.5984490514,
-0.6341667771,
-0.8477941155,
-0.2809833586,
-0.1318274438,
-1.0091491938,
0.2162435055,
0.0368841626,
-0.2535584867,
0.4458003044,
-1.0474088192,
1.0359675884,
0.1281518042,
-0.0504784584,
0.1409506649,
-0.697755754,
0.3476983607,
-0.037090335,
0.0491176397,
-0.0382273011,
0.1158317253,
0.6760462523,
-0.4013284445,
0.5498632193,
-0.4327432811,
-0.3071669042,
0.6199208498,
-0.0997422561,
0.8180464506,
-0.069203198,
-0.2112195194,
0.085305877,
-0.2555863261,
-0.4128652811,
-0.7238385677,
0.7218460441,
-0.6580159664,
-0.6341750026,
0.0013802109,
-0.3551849127,
-0.2759694457,
0.4718104601,
0.1448906809,
0.4384337366,
-0.1461346895,
-0.2365683466,
0.6605902314,
-0.2234607786,
0.4232174456,
0.1636912525,
0.1515638679,
-0.2998756766,
1.0523694754,
0.1465973556,
0.1723090559,
0.468533814,
-0.0026027006,
-0.3551181555,
-0.5107356906,
-0.4718945324,
0.3599993885,
-0.8058056235,
-0.2293297797,
-0.7096504569,
-0.3339962959,
-0.7693767548,
-0.0635275915,
-0.0142369783,
-0.5600118637,
-0.2748754323,
-0.2465615124,
0.2406507879,
0.8877194524,
-0.0235842299,
0.0395937003,
-0.9336194396,
0.5094460249,
0.3654826283,
0.3650954664,
-0.0917467624,
0.1973837167,
-0.2393447608,
-0.2563929558,
-0.2023713589,
-1.2619540691,
-0.1026062071,
0.0340309478,
0.7778449059,
0.1876173168,
0.178973496,
0.1554583013,
-0.5346115828,
0.8113596439,
0.3091999292,
-0.5519004464,
0.4724198282,
-0.3166879117,
0.0150786778,
0.4328169525,
0.9087617993,
-0.3460061252,
-0.3779202402,
-0.4680896997,
-0.8396657705,
0.6333431602,
0.177686289,
-0.5272930264,
-0.3800368011,
0.7257866859,
0.2723806202,
0.2031518072,
-0.6676531434,
-0.1197676212,
-0.116962567,
-0.4667141736,
0.2382655442,
-0.2636279464,
0.0738302395,
0.1795252115,
0.8906489015,
-0.0926391259,
0.3510420918,
0.2472599149,
-0.2802376747,
0.1045529321,
0.3691775799,
-0.1686625034,
0.3394805193,
-0.1817483604,
-0.243182689,
-0.0818279684,
-0.3959339261,
-0.1087319329,
0.5391480327,
-0.4823882878,
-0.2057441175,
0.305608958,
0.8475213051,
-0.084775418,
-0.2006660998,
0.3004507124,
0.1963075995,
0.026452601,
0.1947396249,
0.0901166573,
-0.0113586811,
0.4351311028,
0.121613577,
-0.0858111829,
0.2436038703,
-0.3966411352,
-0.0056142514,
0.3679457307,
-0.386387676,
-0.3818886876,
0.9560584426,
0.3715457916,
-0.0842861161,
0.9155728221,
-0.4032221437,
-0.2216131091,
0.4372773468,
0.3113745451,
1.1239299774,
-0.0251626186,
0.1334753335,
0.5570169687,
0.442358017,
0.1871789992,
0.2564943135,
-0.0432969853,
-0.6391736269,
-0.7432337999,
-0.5603637695,
-0.0559957363,
-0.0385614075,
-0.4472429156,
0.2856653631,
-0.0112339081,
0.0434713401,
0.0331159346,
-0.1291361898,
-0.8041897416,
-0.0043932484,
-0.0315672606,
1.0283349752,
-0.7982029319,
0.699339211,
0.7947638631,
-0.7059165239,
-1.1754333973,
-0.0865240097,
-0.0172549058,
-0.6313168406,
0.7745464444,
0.1839337349,
0.1712155044,
0.2570920289,
-0.4815801084,
-0.7182043195,
1.32006073,
0.3332467079,
-0.3347878456,
-0.6870935559,
-0.0710361749,
0.0357591249,
-0.1983711421,
0.2639944553,
0.2728423178,
0.6005648971,
-0.1971794814,
-1.0424643755,
0.2381390631,
-0.1999014169,
-0.2869853079,
0.5388543606,
-0.301492542,
0.6227231622,
-0.1087782755,
-0.6637022495,
-0.0513354577,
0.7370049953,
-0.0723177716,
0.194704324,
0.7085751891,
0.5524169803,
0.8750892878,
-0.0478509739,
0.9014161229,
-0.2821055651,
0.2341676801,
0.9826699495,
-0.5062086582,
0.4757380486,
0.3459557891,
-0.183690533,
0.445553422,
0.5905207992,
0.1515848339,
0.4508520365,
-0.210719049,
-0.242535755,
-0.0301840082,
-0.167172119,
-0.3216742873,
0.094190374,
0.1813650578,
-0.1309963018,
-0.5015490055,
0.0882249326,
-0.1875273436,
-0.2842309773,
-0.286926955,
0.8405671716,
0.1086058393,
-0.5804115534,
0.1686686724,
-0.2403815687,
0.0488507226,
-0.5513119102,
-0.1995251477,
0.093072027,
-0.4513830543,
0.0180443358,
-0.8654541969,
0.2254725993,
-0.0958396271,
-0.4160569012,
-0.3109161854,
1.1285153627,
-0.2111168206,
-0.0300685856,
0.1751873791,
0.7207438946,
0.1817422062,
-0.1463267505,
-0.5240656734,
-0.5032388568,
0.0491175354,
-0.4359923899,
0.2277457267,
0.7207963467,
-0.0749201328,
0.3829905689,
0.5924285054,
0.1729400903,
0.1323171556,
-0.1199744642,
1.0937849283,
-0.8142670989,
-0.3804681301,
-0.4824596047,
0.544167161,
-0.2349992543,
-0.1466261595,
0.6540516019,
0.5896127224,
0.7900842428,
-0.0805059224,
0.8999766707,
-0.5923193693,
0.5891117454,
-0.8171573281,
0.5445445776,
-0.3631778061,
0.1247168481,
-0.2196922451,
-1.2283439636,
0.1992781013,
0.0181181114,
-0.3777132034,
-0.214384675,
0.9328026175,
0.6894657612,
-0.1359578669,
0.2597586513,
-0.0271268226,
0.452616334,
0.3804927468,
0.5028684139,
0.6748557091,
-0.3094627559,
0.6864818335,
0.1413002312,
-0.4070143402,
0.3953323662,
-0.924318254,
-0.7877268791,
-0.5619564056,
-0.2561863661,
-0.3113611937,
0.0442615598,
0.6285324693,
0.2437900752,
-0.7948761582,
0.204017967,
-0.0509051159,
0.3266561627,
-0.0706208944,
-0.3064625859,
0.4668799639,
-0.5767579675,
-0.602396071,
0.7441365719,
0.3245119154,
-0.0990094692,
-0.0058526765,
0.0856363475,
-0.3045645356,
-0.4019885659,
0.5068535209,
0.5406664014,
-0.4483452439,
-0.5650665164,
0.2609747648,
0.045816049,
0.0501596257,
0.8048046827,
-0.7735547423,
0.4515125155,
0.6173920035,
0.8503924608,
0.279576391,
-0.1714898199,
0.7827312946,
-0.5925818086,
-0.2261447906,
-0.0707741603,
0.4915324152,
-0.0183843877,
-0.3446181118,
0.6282609701,
0.5532354712,
-0.5577114224,
-0.495356828,
0.2924561501,
-0.8744353652,
-0.2788130939,
0.8919090033,
-0.2354863882,
-0.3123697042,
-0.3119108379,
-0.2630175054,
0.5426698327,
-0.3888794482,
0.7360475659,
0.957316637,
0.0720769316,
0.1633546948,
-0.7162547112,
0.200023964,
-0.0536318719,
-0.8816700578,
-0.1966434717,
0.6480593681,
0.2187536061,
0.2408165038,
0.5973925591,
-0.0651757866,
0.0332463011,
0.055327002,
0.1629163921,
-0.270732522,
-0.3786754012,
0.1664699018,
0.5830160975,
0.1415819824,
-0.1432075948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09363v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09363v2
|
Investigating the Emergent Audio Classification Ability of ASR Foundation Models
| 2023-11-15T20:52:56 | 2024-03-28T16:31:26 |
Rao Ma, Adian Liusie, Mark J. F. Gales, Kate M. Knill
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text and vision foundation models can perform many tasks in a zero-shot
setting, a desirable property that enables these systems to be applied in
general and low-resource settings. There has been far less work, however, on
the zero-shot abilities of ASR foundation models, with these systems typically
fine-tuned to specific tasks or constrained to applications that match their
training criterion and data annotation. In this work we investigate the ability
of Whisper and MMS, ASR foundation models trained primarily for speech
recognition, to perform zero-shot audio classification. We use simple
template-based text prompts at the decoder and use the resulting decoding
probabilities to generate zero-shot predictions. Without training the model on
extra data or adding any new parameters, we demonstrate that Whisper shows
promising zero-shot classification performance on a range of 8
audio-classification datasets, outperforming the accuracy of existing
state-of-the-art zero-shot baselines by an average of 9%. One important step to
unlock the emergent ability is debiasing, where a simple unsupervised
reweighting method of the class probabilities yields consistent significant
performance gains. We further show that performance increases with model size,
implying that as ASR foundation models scale up, they may exhibit improved
zero-shot performance.
|
[
-0.1645204723,
-0.4060920477,
0.4026429057,
0.0590963252,
-0.1594239771,
0.1533312649,
-0.1491676718,
-0.7234010696,
-0.0841308832,
0.3450274467,
-0.4375674129,
-0.5340531468,
-0.9766668081,
-0.0897588208,
-0.9803147912,
0.7910599709,
0.3647960424,
-0.1267955452,
0.2090634555,
-0.0376430675,
-0.4790883958,
-0.1645628214,
-0.6150974035,
-0.2829343379,
0.0217892919,
0.5204191804,
0.27752617,
0.7376140356,
0.3185885549,
0.2181587815,
-0.3483430743,
-0.452256918,
-0.1260265559,
0.1798890978,
0.3512254357,
-0.3045399785,
-0.1969661564,
0.1048006788,
0.5812702179,
0.5937387347,
-0.4556288421,
0.4233366251,
0.1612590104,
0.3207504451,
-0.8600802422,
0.0906681791,
-0.8852730989,
0.1470371038,
-0.1391680241,
-0.2911655307,
-0.5185722113,
0.2343861163,
0.517224133,
-0.308136642,
0.5809880495,
-0.3053206205,
0.5289696455,
0.4215077758,
-0.3146184683,
-0.4021892846,
-1.1337254047,
0.7659160495,
-0.5074581504,
0.619142592,
0.2339579016,
0.6684247255,
0.3568177223,
-0.4409512281,
-0.4683073461,
0.152944684,
0.3939366341,
0.0472298861,
-0.6585054994,
0.1385572404,
0.1756929308,
0.5110602975,
-0.2757025957,
0.2499032021,
-0.4831628501,
-0.1223294735,
0.3086689711,
-0.130552724,
-0.0097697387,
-0.2090393454,
-0.2239167541,
-0.1954326183,
-0.4938246906,
0.3108235002,
0.0047437856,
0.6323491931,
-0.2281688452,
0.548515141,
-0.3379175067,
0.8850995898,
0.2423335612,
-0.2737363577,
0.2904843986,
0.0563094951,
-0.5073307753,
0.6950921416,
0.6190589666,
0.2879016995,
0.026633909,
-0.1446456164,
-0.2327996492,
0.5837000012,
0.0811146349,
-0.8391520381,
-0.0438964181,
0.2644380331,
-0.2931680083,
-0.7358861566,
-0.1358013004,
-0.2834837735,
-0.2532915175,
-0.1780506968,
0.7859860063,
-0.3368674815,
-0.4109074771,
0.6213060617,
-0.5266412497,
0.2673305869,
0.4418434501,
-0.8243870139,
0.3303970993,
0.2909455001,
1.0042638779,
0.2173657566,
0.0331244133,
-0.6586111784,
0.3549475372,
-0.2244854867,
0.9467698336,
-0.4999972582,
-0.6274284124,
-0.1248122379,
-0.453720957,
-0.1982068866,
-0.5397292972,
0.5773538351,
-0.1949363947,
-0.101156652,
0.1557220966,
-0.4594255388,
-0.1114295423,
0.1289239675,
-0.2674688399,
0.5837524533,
-0.2140571326,
-0.7566187978,
0.5594918728,
-0.5248062015,
-0.4161864817,
-0.0316729285,
-0.3326056302,
-0.2983796895,
0.3716795146,
0.1588298231,
0.7819233537,
-0.2051918209,
0.0284638889,
-0.0909740776,
-0.6450212598,
0.1631907374,
-0.867595911,
0.64359653,
0.015658319,
-0.6666862369,
-0.1084380448,
-1.0356426239,
-0.0104292305,
-0.249929592,
-0.4128344655,
-0.1765721887,
-0.0921490416,
0.0072468701,
0.1292930394,
-0.3525901437,
-0.8965856433,
-0.1559707522,
-0.5157238245,
0.4508441091,
0.3756869733,
0.0997941718,
0.5007024407,
-0.3075691164,
0.4104426205,
0.0268058199,
-0.1338359118,
-0.5486239791,
-0.4468935728,
-0.9148865938,
-0.6270651221,
0.4429968596,
0.5733886957,
-0.3647246957,
0.3636955619,
-0.2445408404,
-0.7173295021,
-0.8740898371,
-0.1700527966,
0.5451387763,
0.6872245073,
0.5104909539,
-0.1360218823,
-0.6248836517,
-0.6000281572,
0.0708055049,
-0.1431869715,
-0.4097159803,
0.6242366433,
0.1089373305,
-0.2275439948,
0.9641394019,
-0.4768727124,
-0.4996588528,
0.0105043091,
0.4905813038,
0.3000978529,
0.3776077628,
0.542620182,
-0.5936069489,
-0.3531395793,
-0.1997529715,
-0.6245095134,
-0.2778149545,
0.1906542927,
0.5938636065,
-0.049416665,
0.4407713115,
-0.5610256195,
0.6692022681,
0.4545752704,
-0.3097979128,
0.5674837232,
0.1590108424,
0.0605732165,
-0.7291609645,
-0.0888963193,
0.0140039409,
0.0161593482,
-0.8945095539,
-0.3762782514,
-0.2826573551,
-0.2702331841,
-0.3615144491,
0.3341048062,
-0.4232727289,
-0.1837188601,
-0.4303683043,
-0.1854714602,
-0.0886370763,
0.030617509,
0.6229969859,
0.4085333645,
1.1235419512,
-0.7914473414,
-0.1975508779,
0.4032697976,
-0.4467953444,
0.5157490969,
-0.7813217044,
-0.0018741239,
-0.1709681153,
0.2537690997,
-0.8473471999,
-0.0429290086,
-0.2632564306,
-0.8173994422,
0.5570206642,
-0.5519425273,
-0.2932459712,
-0.2670976818,
-0.1216324642,
-0.0237794649,
0.6853592992,
-0.4931380451,
0.5777214766,
0.2462187707,
0.1066680476,
-0.6715853214,
-0.7571409941,
-0.1547126174,
-0.2264605314,
-0.2046305835,
0.2904307246,
-0.0261324197,
-0.0844501406,
-0.0834247395,
-0.4716231525,
-0.0182301663,
0.0227411445,
0.7796632051,
0.1013511196,
-0.3580915332,
-0.0844303817,
0.0644491613,
-0.4437225163,
-0.2153992504,
-0.3059450984,
0.1769988835,
-0.0057219239,
-0.3945367634,
-0.4730943143,
0.1232050061,
0.8191185594,
-0.2754192054,
0.4532873333,
0.5042214394,
-0.2809363306,
-0.3795824051,
-0.7449953556,
-0.1879756451,
-0.4745957255,
-0.1096260771,
-0.2874813676,
-1.0153172016,
0.3841449022,
0.1466698349,
0.142441988,
0.5773967505,
0.3010421097,
-0.1919300854,
0.8119220734,
0.6803450584,
0.0545834005,
0.3830350637,
-0.7133488655,
-0.3874409497,
-0.7766541243,
-0.2532211542,
-0.6702578664,
-0.2536186278,
-0.2278394401,
-0.4309426248,
0.3193327785,
0.2374085486,
-0.219951719,
0.4794087708,
-0.7669433355,
0.4733489454,
0.4732189476,
-0.09570124,
0.4192889333,
0.1478508711,
-0.0480231903,
0.1385571659,
-0.5594947934,
-0.2540361881,
1.1973955631,
0.5667927861,
0.6328511834,
0.1921606511,
0.687664628,
0.2861935794,
0.1277588755,
-0.9171525836,
0.2672674954,
-0.3893441558,
-0.6490826607,
-0.4459325373,
-0.2499028742,
-0.5478905439,
0.1462689489,
-0.5807430148,
-0.686973989,
0.7006954551,
0.0987035409,
-0.7771393061,
0.2605659664,
-0.5532624722,
0.4392720163,
0.1011101007,
0.3228440881,
-0.0129300971,
-0.4983422458,
0.0865870193,
-0.0939043462,
0.0159354564,
-0.3770803213,
0.1928082854,
0.7183918357,
-0.0538972206,
0.9385093451,
-0.5341561437,
0.1228240579,
0.6445798874,
0.2039537579,
-0.048042994,
-0.189826116,
-0.0924033523,
0.548813343,
0.0499537922,
0.046145957,
-0.5990982056,
0.3251049221,
-0.859392643,
-0.2601128221,
-0.3337076902,
-0.1313831955,
-0.4140951931,
0.1736018658,
0.5984126329,
0.901019156,
-0.1585910171,
0.724916935,
0.7837165594,
0.1846628636,
0.5458774567,
1.2965167761,
0.0378710404,
-0.3245260119,
0.7005165219,
0.3769143224,
0.1355337799,
0.5265032649,
0.2793680727,
-0.4397863448,
-0.9458889365,
-0.6230424643,
-0.3064191043,
-0.3518016636,
-0.5265631676,
-0.9220272899,
-0.6206709743,
-0.3979270458,
-0.4253351688,
-0.4290827215,
-0.6391947269,
-0.5619419813,
-0.4170545042,
0.3176990151,
0.6021348238,
-0.1943605095,
0.7060186267,
-0.8378113508,
0.1588489264,
0.4447663724,
0.3098168075,
0.1677891314,
-1.0259218216,
0.0714991093,
-0.0926626027,
-0.1947389096,
-0.9561084509,
0.0965988412,
0.5387368798,
0.4336188436,
0.8595741391,
0.1969666928,
0.6596644521,
-0.7607262135,
0.3572601378,
0.3571950197,
-0.8867421746,
0.7354358435,
-0.5575590134,
0.200951606,
0.6852637529,
0.1384736449,
-0.138336882,
-0.3208486736,
-0.7352956533,
-0.5039994121,
0.7498551011,
0.3435937762,
0.0833201259,
0.0524583086,
0.3060600162,
-0.0884253234,
0.3469220102,
-0.3301905692,
-0.1869780719,
-0.4533705413,
-0.070028685,
-0.3424179852,
-0.3605743051,
0.1422376186,
-0.2371176779,
0.3940333128,
-0.1336450726,
0.1674016565,
0.2478593737,
-0.0087104132,
-0.3084862828,
0.5536990762,
0.281853646,
-0.1055265591,
-0.5411958098,
0.1654752344,
0.0122905588,
-0.4963362217,
0.6018176675,
0.1492487639,
-0.4298554063,
0.0404913276,
0.5084446073,
0.9244928956,
0.7941716909,
-0.5999032855,
0.7714588642,
-0.0727731958,
-0.2439160049,
-0.3867326975,
0.3932638168,
-0.0620237514,
0.2949042916,
0.654919982,
0.3702231348,
0.5507697463,
-0.4488562942,
0.3166950941,
0.4165634811,
-0.8011463881,
-0.4022835195,
0.6360408664,
0.2418805063,
-0.2494900674,
0.5306244493,
-0.1024251133,
-0.2369897366,
0.3875570595,
0.8429889679,
1.1130478382,
-0.601305306,
0.2815855443,
0.270889163,
0.1348503083,
-0.068601869,
0.0376847275,
-0.5321937203,
-1.0407186747,
-0.3004398346,
-1.2214161158,
-0.3776856065,
0.157691285,
-0.8954373002,
0.3903272748,
-0.6034808755,
-0.2072303146,
0.4350264668,
-0.1211016625,
-0.4696621597,
0.4554318488,
0.2754579484,
1.2140624523,
-1.1339793205,
0.5069777369,
0.5274599791,
-0.1548806131,
-0.8008975983,
-0.0673878044,
0.2832633853,
-0.5536577106,
0.4884009063,
0.5490583181,
-0.5282943845,
0.323127836,
-0.2783875167,
-0.766738534,
1.2468954325,
0.4296420217,
-0.5614922643,
-0.1594513804,
-0.173541069,
0.5914661288,
-0.5582774282,
0.1915834993,
0.3971983194,
0.0323266089,
0.8501768708,
-1.2614994049,
-0.4634851813,
-0.0922972187,
-0.3355574906,
-0.007603012,
-0.2222367525,
0.5666889548,
-0.4761157632,
-0.4733854532,
-0.1430120915,
0.4032686055,
0.3803938925,
0.621021986,
0.7441455722,
0.6399611831,
0.4248882532,
-0.0417423286,
0.7693235278,
-0.1629775465,
-0.0309270918,
1.0921635628,
-0.4004073739,
1.4240825176,
-0.0331290066,
-0.1768470258,
0.5547920465,
0.2943221331,
-0.0233184136,
0.6926067472,
-0.1870651841,
-0.4509093761,
-0.2893131673,
-0.274705261,
-0.1566852182,
1.19409585,
0.4534661472,
-0.198856771,
-0.1416299343,
0.1563801765,
-0.3129581809,
-0.1593755335,
-0.5086339116,
1.0073510408,
0.1320461035,
0.0623225756,
0.2674733996,
-0.0449066907,
0.88817662,
-0.5392894149,
-0.005135871,
0.4624390602,
0.1862921417,
-0.3184489906,
-0.6332131028,
0.4576096833,
0.2234703153,
-0.6620461941,
-0.0495172366,
0.9123834968,
-0.2658266127,
-0.4835787714,
0.3225254118,
0.4441481233,
0.090905048,
-0.3620631993,
-0.4177176356,
0.0013538812,
-0.1454822719,
0.1898567379,
0.2228854299,
0.2432179749,
0.2598350942,
0.642475009,
0.8789206147,
0.2856250107,
0.0309932809,
-0.0814164951,
0.6384211183,
-0.4695603251,
-0.6965996027,
-0.7572424412,
0.436071068,
0.1225421205,
0.0303850416,
0.7392433286,
0.5917018056,
0.572727561,
-0.0182676483,
0.5992314816,
0.1452264339,
0.9528758526,
-0.3162281811,
0.8444856405,
-0.2162420154,
0.2819115818,
-0.3462797999,
-0.6245157719,
-0.3055880368,
0.5882565975,
-0.2091732174,
-0.0991109982,
0.0393088944,
0.4319324791,
-0.130704999,
0.1752266884,
0.4776776135,
0.1725605875,
0.0276734196,
0.2485856712,
0.7497118711,
-0.4498692453,
0.588463366,
-0.210869953,
-0.3942466378,
-0.1086889058,
-0.7856653333,
-0.8959751129,
-0.4360727966,
-0.422475487,
-0.1228703931,
-0.0208286159,
0.5042601824,
1.0346585512,
-0.8923057318,
-0.0831770748,
-0.0240340475,
-0.2960397899,
-0.0944615379,
-0.209708631,
0.247654587,
0.2772706151,
-0.2360388488,
0.8577877879,
0.4381330609,
0.5222273469,
-0.1285838783,
-0.0888163596,
0.2133674026,
0.2295901179,
0.5635786653,
0.436090529,
-0.622518003,
-0.2633286715,
0.0382527523,
0.3988337517,
-0.1546581537,
0.6882393956,
-1.1103299856,
0.5458613038,
0.0789821222,
0.3763652742,
0.6157827377,
0.0306912065,
0.2780168951,
-1.0483465195,
0.1892766953,
0.238945201,
0.1339645982,
0.5550438166,
-0.076742962,
0.2982186377,
0.2166737318,
-0.3096911609,
-1.2554496527,
0.0416692086,
-0.7850884795,
0.0604873933,
1.074849844,
0.049494084,
0.180943355,
-0.2032630444,
0.0567570068,
0.1866090149,
-0.3682294786,
0.6217460632,
0.2635605931,
-0.116933614,
-0.3313583434,
-0.5174103379,
0.5603052974,
-0.2107431591,
-0.1982150376,
0.1625834256,
0.4168554842,
0.5411695838,
0.6445941925,
1.0877521038,
-0.1135406196,
0.3481754661,
0.3068782985,
-0.1714998782,
-0.2269304842,
-0.6880877614,
-0.7346770167,
0.3030931354,
0.077758722,
-0.3592356443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09358v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09358v1
|
Empirical evaluation of Uncertainty Quantification in Retrieval-Augmented Language Models for Science
| 2023-11-15T20:42:11 | 2023-11-15T20:42:11 |
Sridevi Wagle, Sai Munikoti, Anurag Acharya, Sara Smith, Sameera Horawalavithana
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable achievements in natural
language processing tasks, producing high-quality outputs. However, LLMs still
exhibit limitations, including the generation of factually incorrect
information. In safety-critical applications, it is important to assess the
confidence of LLM-generated content to make informed decisions. Retrieval
Augmented Language Models (RALMs) is relatively a new area of research in NLP.
RALMs offer potential benefits for scientific NLP tasks, as retrieved
documents, can serve as evidence to support model-generated content. This
inclusion of evidence enhances trustworthiness, as users can verify and explore
the retrieved documents to validate model outputs. Quantifying uncertainty in
RALM generations further improves trustworthiness, with retrieved text and
confidence scores contributing to a comprehensive and reliable model for
scientific applications. However, there is limited to no research on UQ for
RALMs, particularly in scientific contexts. This study aims to address this gap
by conducting a comprehensive evaluation of UQ in RALMs, focusing on scientific
tasks. This research investigates how uncertainty scores vary when scientific
knowledge is incorporated as pretraining and retrieval data and explores the
relationship between uncertainty scores and the accuracy of model-generated
outputs. We observe that an existing RALM finetuned with scientific knowledge
as the retrieval data tends to be more confident in generating predictions
compared to the model pretrained only with scientific knowledge. We also found
that RALMs are overconfident in their predictions, making inaccurate
predictions more confidently than accurate ones. Scientific knowledge provided
either as pretraining or retrieval corpus does not help alleviate this issue.
We released our code, data and dashboards at https://github.com/pnnl/EXPERT2.
|
[
-0.078827709,
-0.6151855588,
0.8446283937,
0.1640661359,
0.0123183019,
0.2600937188,
-0.2068433315,
-0.6061623693,
-0.1276976913,
0.1417042613,
-0.0280139409,
-0.4848793149,
-0.7268058062,
0.1921337694,
-0.4689545035,
0.8044539094,
0.015868865,
0.0542795844,
-0.5348148346,
0.134568274,
-0.0745421574,
-0.4299579859,
-0.20206891,
-0.510977149,
0.5586196184,
0.1496601254,
0.8860679865,
0.3011560142,
0.7754135132,
0.1966196597,
-0.0472278595,
0.1374250948,
-0.2263594121,
0.4222326875,
-0.3901983798,
-0.4986767769,
-0.1888274699,
0.0233722664,
0.6699439883,
0.7746440768,
-0.3380043805,
0.3233982027,
0.0361418016,
0.5500426292,
-0.9474701881,
0.1557522565,
-0.7590808272,
0.0239145216,
-0.1184225827,
-0.2341339737,
-0.4664301872,
-0.3492202163,
0.2216807902,
-0.7739720941,
0.1641573906,
0.5581511855,
0.9348131418,
0.3332704902,
-0.3048013449,
-0.3314787745,
-0.8183624744,
1.0998210907,
-0.8580978513,
0.4645268023,
0.6869127154,
0.0709288269,
-0.2932503223,
-0.9174844027,
-0.429356724,
-0.2347432971,
-0.0641930848,
0.1026475951,
-0.1724474132,
0.0986599475,
0.1286733598,
0.1759750396,
-0.6448075175,
-0.0055068568,
-0.3092549741,
-0.3690268099,
0.6904575229,
0.0507177301,
-0.0154464981,
-0.2977613509,
-0.1822195351,
-0.3322336674,
-0.6373531222,
0.0631529987,
0.2650369108,
0.2312440425,
0.2653687596,
0.8899011612,
-0.3646279871,
0.6553298235,
-0.1717905104,
-0.0190422665,
0.1503265798,
-0.4642502666,
-0.1929140687,
-0.0972434729,
1.0362116098,
0.1949466169,
-0.0384504944,
0.0179583188,
-0.3117533326,
-0.2179441899,
0.2903315425,
-0.6599946618,
-0.0971830264,
0.2520842254,
-0.1053754091,
-0.3507625759,
0.2146815956,
-0.5945701003,
-0.2627681196,
-0.1635469794,
0.6161226034,
-0.4683521986,
-0.1997149438,
0.2174780816,
0.0679754317,
-0.2382818013,
0.4016211331,
-0.5133585334,
0.057972759,
0.553737998,
0.6572283506,
-0.1194823906,
-0.1945738941,
-0.1383495033,
-0.0715255439,
-0.4870814979,
0.5598107576,
-0.6933323741,
-0.5138002634,
-0.2223624885,
-0.4207614064,
-0.1423697323,
-0.2869582474,
0.6134751439,
-0.8804522753,
0.1756773442,
-0.177935034,
-0.4836860597,
-0.1207935438,
0.095025681,
-0.470787555,
1.4305266142,
0.1700906754,
-0.9710495472,
0.4426026642,
-0.410107404,
-0.1152336895,
0.0700938478,
-0.2206145823,
-0.3318805099,
0.1871437281,
-0.0596709363,
0.3235770166,
-0.3618157208,
0.5052170157,
-0.4457882643,
-0.2871984243,
0.6962257624,
-0.5037045479,
0.4454141259,
0.4861199856,
-0.0260312948,
-0.074528046,
-0.7019111514,
0.5250200629,
-0.2844920456,
-0.1610849649,
-0.6679863334,
-0.0050523952,
-0.194282189,
0.1079365388,
0.2529594302,
-0.5791143179,
-0.0778800324,
-0.3131600618,
0.2116857171,
0.4014132619,
0.2124762088,
0.3196268082,
-0.1331625134,
0.548361659,
-0.3364931941,
0.2534501255,
0.2171392739,
-0.5507869124,
-0.2763291597,
0.054548841,
0.571608305,
0.3944143653,
-0.5859450102,
0.3268574476,
-0.2685468197,
-0.5185462832,
-0.6061948538,
0.0847580284,
0.4822775424,
0.5196057558,
0.3543246984,
-0.0696628913,
-0.6796752214,
-0.5677760839,
-0.2803565264,
-0.4385816157,
-0.2441041619,
0.1458167881,
0.8621605039,
-0.1268758327,
1.1554925442,
-0.2454801649,
0.2271082103,
0.3193070292,
0.5240547061,
-0.0063431882,
0.524949491,
0.2377520651,
-0.766061902,
-0.3578669429,
-0.0436567552,
-0.8834822774,
0.1168108582,
0.1511063427,
0.0172985904,
0.1613765508,
0.1062243879,
-0.870285213,
0.6113626361,
0.5212070346,
-0.146115154,
0.8613935709,
-0.4335097373,
0.5044840574,
-0.5188655853,
0.2063992918,
-0.1205057353,
-0.0353063643,
-0.375382483,
0.2304670364,
0.0699414089,
0.2373789698,
-0.3574750423,
0.4827929139,
-0.4856446981,
-0.3190161884,
-0.1761061996,
0.1633167267,
0.341059655,
-0.2596972287,
0.1890378296,
0.8011823893,
0.4629432261,
-0.436660111,
0.045622807,
0.0370812044,
-0.6401024461,
0.204457894,
-0.8333923221,
0.1143245772,
0.0853966102,
-0.0134816589,
-0.7553267479,
-0.4178548157,
-0.0109238736,
-0.7370295525,
0.4789017141,
0.2061202675,
-0.4705065191,
-0.4462354779,
-0.0709763393,
0.3487555385,
0.4380847812,
-0.0659950227,
0.4885086119,
0.0217655115,
-0.2756758332,
-1.0327498913,
-0.7127960324,
-0.1191826761,
-0.0507912114,
-0.5039355159,
0.1614040732,
-0.0187437404,
-0.6483686566,
0.3072324991,
-0.4585969448,
-0.0440547317,
0.2176723927,
0.3999682963,
0.2269943655,
-0.1146897525,
0.2099602818,
0.084268637,
0.1351237595,
0.2569799125,
-0.0739101768,
0.1421113461,
-0.2627968788,
-0.6555507183,
-0.2185323238,
0.0254067425,
0.395624727,
-0.1824630797,
0.8882382512,
0.6161496043,
-0.3392670155,
0.0042814985,
-0.5340325832,
-0.407368958,
-0.4310622513,
0.4665988684,
-0.1727605462,
-0.9105340838,
0.6339513063,
0.1404828429,
-0.1015650183,
0.5818647742,
0.2308934331,
-0.4430176318,
0.9591426849,
0.355502367,
0.3672884703,
0.0300211757,
-0.0203912202,
0.1143959165,
-0.8353721499,
-0.4594911039,
-0.7877824903,
0.2616138756,
-0.2115117908,
-0.7445766926,
0.3477942646,
0.3834807277,
-0.3471636176,
-0.1674689353,
-0.441360265,
0.2209136784,
0.6231338382,
0.1326721609,
0.3852903247,
0.0228203684,
-0.028266374,
-0.2501706779,
-0.7005611062,
-0.7259410024,
1.3235347271,
0.2682465017,
0.9265489578,
-0.0455303006,
0.5622389913,
0.3717058897,
0.3672703803,
-0.4620138407,
0.229873538,
0.3043216765,
-0.7639472485,
-0.559923768,
-0.6069676876,
-0.9025040865,
0.2342850417,
-0.5956795216,
-0.6218589544,
0.1921458542,
0.1337069869,
-0.7222309709,
0.0498951189,
-0.4255405068,
0.4200261533,
-0.3502959907,
-0.4536032081,
-0.1994948536,
-0.9419968128,
0.3497020602,
-0.4755858183,
0.4400078356,
-0.0386425704,
0.0475885682,
0.7886254191,
-0.267126143,
0.6809022427,
0.0366225839,
0.0861110538,
0.4896315932,
0.2731316686,
0.6207671762,
0.1840452403,
-0.6076120734,
0.1605034769,
0.2999782562,
-0.3175883889,
-0.765973866,
0.5455570817,
-0.7799390554,
-0.7171221972,
-0.7860002518,
-0.7995319366,
-0.2828733325,
0.189256236,
0.3434185982,
0.0808756202,
0.1044368818,
0.4675993323,
0.8035430312,
-0.2716906369,
0.0677271634,
0.6874737144,
-0.323159337,
-0.1785680801,
0.4972225726,
0.1736838073,
0.4891190529,
0.3508605659,
0.1975163519,
-0.4965012074,
-0.9347246289,
0.0763728097,
0.0729891211,
-0.5592121482,
-0.4380425215,
-0.507915616,
-0.2699619234,
-0.4946281016,
0.098867476,
-0.4291811287,
-0.4433906376,
-0.5516361594,
-0.3304816186,
0.5181125402,
0.9348743558,
-0.1903700382,
0.1928925365,
-0.7886126637,
-0.1932964176,
0.0356519148,
0.1241794229,
-0.1500554234,
-0.8300924301,
-0.3291318417,
0.464002341,
-0.002480224,
-0.7348360419,
0.5616253018,
0.31180951,
0.7180197835,
0.2811272144,
0.4185458422,
0.5484620929,
-0.1778167635,
0.8540284634,
-0.075068444,
-0.7673580647,
0.492170155,
-0.1531064212,
-0.1470255852,
0.6537736654,
0.6359912157,
0.0496462099,
-0.3883075416,
-0.6324034333,
-0.8161017299,
0.4295476675,
0.1982564181,
-0.1533090621,
0.0973980576,
0.718763411,
0.0823861659,
0.3762682378,
-0.4293289781,
-0.1463704705,
-0.1876934171,
-0.1889665574,
-0.0090555791,
-0.4689505696,
-0.1494084001,
-0.1079646796,
0.7116039991,
0.125111416,
0.0561723784,
0.3870541453,
-0.0837144777,
-0.3325216472,
0.3215323687,
0.6166222095,
0.8449867368,
-0.6846401095,
0.3868620098,
0.0435392074,
-0.5988434553,
0.1119050309,
-0.0046789292,
-0.2849525809,
-0.007327449,
0.5079205036,
0.5746417046,
0.1879286021,
-0.6930114627,
0.3088313341,
0.158463493,
-0.1342113316,
-0.3445839584,
-0.0600627474,
-0.1623183191,
0.1483247727,
0.7771620154,
0.452034235,
0.2095284313,
-0.2304100096,
0.3253223002,
0.5359606147,
-0.0914494172,
-0.3831946552,
0.6379812956,
-0.2381180525,
-0.0797791034,
0.5938240886,
-0.2335244417,
-0.3404471278,
0.380122602,
0.4434661865,
0.2358323783,
-0.4133497477,
0.3293488622,
0.4225153923,
0.4154193997,
-0.3896553814,
0.2394157648,
0.2492420524,
-0.7557753325,
-0.7954831123,
-0.8747846484,
-0.5825279355,
-0.1637483984,
-1.1544423103,
-0.2703075111,
-0.1636743546,
-0.5863978863,
-0.4128833115,
0.2115284801,
-0.5756176114,
0.3013997376,
-0.3151795864,
0.7585242987,
-0.8941824436,
0.8167413473,
0.6540950537,
-0.3514825702,
-0.9929180145,
-0.3793494403,
-0.1327844113,
-0.6462356448,
1.0096799135,
-0.3870539963,
-0.1306335777,
-0.1039403751,
-0.6329059601,
-1.372079134,
1.1422082186,
0.3010586798,
-0.6123495102,
-0.0787043497,
0.1675119549,
0.7558758855,
-0.1149862856,
0.4992842972,
0.2255280167,
0.6519714594,
0.2438820302,
-0.8724104762,
0.0840327069,
0.0154435812,
-0.0664509907,
-0.0886368454,
-0.1533071399,
0.9029456973,
-0.3913802505,
-0.174179405,
0.1729021221,
0.8291552067,
0.597283721,
0.4931171536,
0.1343168318,
0.4033849537,
1.0886785984,
-0.1597494334,
1.1877139807,
-0.3694086671,
0.5516645312,
1.1610661745,
-0.4750262201,
1.1349241734,
0.7557061911,
-0.4885585308,
0.4266590476,
0.6951785088,
0.136383459,
0.3920674324,
0.0958811194,
-0.2327183038,
-0.3329985738,
-0.2097804844,
-0.5072473884,
0.1790064424,
0.7079997659,
-0.3855488598,
0.0443104804,
0.1115068942,
-0.0778720006,
0.1936720014,
-0.151740253,
0.1999109983,
0.1682372242,
-0.4853495657,
0.4193849862,
-0.216749832,
0.5723431706,
-0.6963168979,
0.0019688341,
0.0456670895,
-0.1178077087,
-0.4344362915,
-1.0079286098,
0.310518533,
-0.0591783747,
-0.1602825075,
-0.0514476262,
0.6534583569,
-0.3500421047,
-0.5474143624,
-0.014880727,
0.5940679312,
0.3478244245,
-0.1517590582,
-0.6425154805,
0.1902341843,
-0.0380886607,
-0.6256195903,
0.4287450612,
0.3984910846,
-0.0250584576,
0.9515820742,
0.7213165164,
0.3115952015,
0.2001370639,
-0.1225028336,
0.5082840323,
-0.2823373377,
0.2238318324,
-0.5477953553,
0.3550392091,
0.2014510334,
-0.1636592001,
1.2215023041,
0.4161127508,
0.6667361259,
-0.087822862,
0.7066075802,
-0.1265477389,
0.527107656,
-0.5408760905,
0.7310914397,
-0.4178302288,
0.43821311,
-0.2260614485,
-0.6350086331,
-0.496776849,
0.7501196861,
-0.4418721497,
0.2128200531,
0.645947814,
0.7659475207,
0.2598142922,
-0.123117812,
0.407305479,
0.1945694387,
0.0411863029,
0.1747607291,
0.8968510628,
-0.440115422,
0.3356950283,
-0.4703889489,
0.0363287218,
-0.0921753794,
-1.0927803516,
-0.45309636,
-0.4502652586,
-0.3213156164,
-0.4568089545,
0.164781332,
0.8127189279,
0.6693134308,
-0.8027746081,
0.0837043077,
-0.0194497481,
0.0203355551,
-0.120799832,
-0.2764784694,
0.547516346,
-0.1924790889,
-0.3946773708,
0.4225173295,
-0.0845479816,
0.0946747512,
-0.2130938172,
-0.1547274888,
-0.2185293138,
0.1383361369,
0.3755064011,
0.4145043194,
-0.7746294737,
-0.495319277,
0.2442073524,
-0.1706522256,
-0.2592690885,
0.2986442149,
-0.6098970771,
0.429320544,
0.388160795,
0.4784927964,
0.4425972402,
0.2745116651,
0.5362873673,
-0.8606372476,
-0.12546736,
0.4712812006,
0.3225286603,
0.3704109788,
-0.3878459632,
0.5513734221,
0.0341309384,
-0.8993861079,
-1.2439694405,
-0.0640231818,
-0.8314843774,
-0.1598545462,
1.0745413303,
-0.4783102572,
-0.1216674596,
-0.1101326942,
0.1295772642,
0.1088338718,
-0.3963634074,
0.7376152873,
0.7246354222,
-0.1448664218,
-0.04234045,
-0.7101432085,
0.4924262464,
0.5135844946,
-0.450212419,
-0.0506860577,
0.418445915,
0.3362267613,
0.4975860715,
0.1253984421,
-0.0870269611,
0.1649140716,
0.0308638085,
0.4327405989,
-0.2802724242,
-0.2766476274,
-0.1644457728,
0.2507990897,
0.4197191298,
0.3332243264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09356v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09356v1
|
LePaRD: A Large-Scale Dataset of Judges Citing Precedents
| 2023-11-15T20:33:27 | 2023-11-15T20:33:27 |
Robert Mahari, Dominik Stammbach, Elliott Ash, Alex `Sandy' Pentland
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present the Legal Passage Retrieval Dataset LePaRD. LePaRD is a massive
collection of U.S. federal judicial citations to precedent in context. The
dataset aims to facilitate work on legal passage prediction, a challenging
practice-oriented legal retrieval and reasoning task. Legal passage prediction
seeks to predict relevant passages from precedential court decisions given the
context of a legal argument. We extensively evaluate various retrieval
approaches on LePaRD, and find that classification appears to work best.
However, we note that legal precedent prediction is a difficult task, and there
remains significant room for improvement. We hope that by publishing LePaRD, we
will encourage others to engage with a legal NLP task that promises to help
expand access to justice by reducing the burden associated with legal research.
A subset of the LePaRD dataset is freely available and the whole dataset will
be released upon publication.
|
[
-0.0102531817,
-0.5287128091,
0.9772107005,
0.3112686574,
-0.6267460585,
-0.4294811487,
0.0012584499,
-0.067942135,
0.1755436063,
0.7250806093,
-0.1636260748,
-0.3579693139,
-0.6274078488,
-0.1978707761,
-0.5233677626,
0.8099713326,
0.4065866172,
0.3440087736,
-0.5359953046,
-0.0466671884,
-0.4145576656,
-0.6168043017,
-0.2528547645,
-0.2153325528,
0.7707413435,
0.2760184705,
0.4770690501,
0.6107922196,
0.6000037193,
0.1578669101,
-0.1972866803,
-0.3614587486,
0.0094978185,
0.3571806252,
-0.7444213629,
-0.3101135194,
-0.4689640403,
-0.1560280919,
0.3824768066,
0.8232700825,
-0.5888662338,
-0.122384049,
-0.4025070071,
0.6910571456,
-0.8673514724,
0.086703144,
-0.7418670654,
0.1830266267,
-0.6955547929,
-0.2136990279,
-0.6352934837,
-0.4101881683,
0.0893018618,
-0.6379498243,
0.2356031388,
0.3180832863,
0.3298040926,
0.4390672445,
-0.6287173629,
-0.0596025512,
-0.4685347676,
0.4395179749,
-0.6227383018,
0.4208636284,
0.48289451,
0.7181181908,
-0.2105914205,
-0.98914361,
-0.4617370367,
-0.2413734943,
0.1002612785,
0.1015908346,
0.0647064969,
-0.1950719208,
0.4126637876,
0.1164674684,
-0.6444218159,
-0.1056797728,
-0.4460504353,
-0.0767031237,
0.8590931892,
0.0170253254,
-0.0989141166,
-0.397508651,
0.0036947776,
-0.2104132175,
-0.8028617501,
-0.2772847712,
0.1372516453,
0.5493472219,
0.0932452157,
0.584877491,
-0.3985225856,
0.7154370546,
-0.178524375,
0.2143401653,
0.3623628318,
0.0786134824,
-0.2064110935,
0.3982182741,
0.8816587329,
0.5993257165,
0.2025763094,
0.0410843566,
-0.0370462164,
-0.7700202465,
0.4646914005,
-0.5586899519,
-0.0116839679,
0.0302198417,
-0.2994437814,
0.0173126236,
0.5796995163,
-1.0305143595,
-0.8995825052,
-0.3519279361,
-0.0379833952,
-0.1353267729,
0.197339043,
-0.0209377911,
-0.3133234978,
0.0958101824,
0.6773819923,
-0.7343057394,
0.3237119317,
0.85279423,
0.6999676228,
-0.0926494971,
-0.0411557518,
-0.803668499,
0.3208429813,
-0.3422227204,
0.7340674996,
-0.8598234057,
-0.787461102,
0.3066615462,
0.262419939,
0.0309978165,
-0.5788298845,
1.1625136137,
-0.6711914539,
-0.39849931,
-0.7654299736,
-0.6547314525,
0.0843744874,
0.1087529287,
-0.8301676512,
0.3502547741,
0.0940250456,
-0.8868364096,
0.6053798795,
-0.6515117884,
-0.5856356621,
0.3450213075,
-0.5131907463,
-0.3688112497,
0.2565018833,
0.2926149964,
0.3532985747,
-0.387300849,
0.4423007071,
-0.3732034266,
-0.1646410525,
-0.300022155,
-0.0885928571,
0.8645918965,
0.5783962607,
-0.106015496,
-0.2688456178,
-0.4772750437,
-0.4789295495,
0.1956943274,
-0.0135526853,
-0.4886759818,
0.2872773707,
0.0134279756,
0.2598889768,
0.0934314951,
-0.5878953934,
0.2556714416,
0.0188390501,
0.1782982051,
1.0349200964,
0.3569118083,
0.3077527285,
-0.1047984436,
0.6960027218,
0.0487761982,
0.1424120814,
0.0904550552,
-0.5572654605,
-0.2693704665,
0.6211252213,
0.7500677109,
0.5853562951,
-0.5266609192,
0.2911356688,
-0.5342904925,
-0.2708366811,
0.0184990615,
-0.114753522,
0.0073565589,
0.5680435896,
0.5019822121,
-0.0638971403,
-0.3280647397,
-0.9147590995,
-0.4469353855,
-0.2456209958,
0.2677870095,
0.5986090899,
0.8033585548,
0.0397525094,
0.7572417855,
-0.4285075665,
-0.488482058,
0.0016358665,
-0.0215568766,
0.5164136291,
0.4967514277,
0.4487841129,
-0.9801456928,
-0.5670664907,
0.223765552,
-0.6426675916,
-0.1752012968,
-0.0697494745,
-0.2709767222,
-0.2163781971,
1.1002628803,
-0.305034399,
0.5079751015,
-0.2152985036,
-0.6105025411,
0.4894945621,
0.0508296117,
0.0216477066,
-0.8487516046,
-0.1347309053,
-0.1415110379,
-0.3369457722,
0.110433951,
-0.0302978437,
0.0896004885,
0.4441160858,
-0.7132812738,
0.6008999348,
0.0761920512,
-0.5271146297,
0.205558762,
0.0451484211,
-0.0901581347,
-0.2030781358,
0.1725253016,
0.7295351028,
0.3673057854,
-0.3581958711,
0.3528314829,
0.3851341009,
-0.3078947663,
1.046500206,
-0.5738661885,
-0.107100524,
0.0327856019,
0.4708973765,
-0.1100518182,
-0.5079525709,
0.001117986,
0.063334845,
0.2627311647,
-0.381421268,
-0.8382552862,
-0.4028999209,
0.025959529,
0.4016893208,
0.2974600494,
-0.3273493052,
0.4293811321,
0.2988721132,
-0.3168011308,
-0.709381938,
-0.4712171853,
-0.0657972693,
-0.0199423097,
0.0911507905,
0.3045218587,
0.0444652103,
-0.4828710854,
0.1182305366,
-0.0975686461,
0.1351443529,
-0.1851350069,
0.519528389,
-0.2051413059,
0.0102072675,
0.4753837287,
0.3265154958,
0.1688088775,
0.3743800819,
-0.1161165982,
0.5714045167,
0.1637994796,
-0.636844039,
-0.1477598101,
0.4106363058,
0.2785438597,
0.1165970415,
0.4441669285,
0.1450753957,
-0.2397254258,
-0.2696202695,
-0.3114822209,
0.2282803655,
-0.4004849792,
0.0656305924,
-0.5629237294,
-0.4885434806,
0.2398999929,
-0.1237785742,
0.1445815265,
0.8518626094,
0.3819591701,
-0.2782947421,
0.5364769697,
0.4087285101,
-0.1734817475,
0.4880964756,
-0.1777615845,
-0.2220038176,
-0.9811586738,
-0.4693910778,
-0.5897470117,
-0.0613595173,
-0.5073426962,
-0.5316189528,
0.1972005367,
0.154846698,
-0.391328007,
0.2227009386,
-0.3670668006,
0.5735288858,
0.7179900408,
-0.0724540949,
0.5322493911,
-0.2009281218,
-0.6456569433,
0.031486135,
-0.2761553228,
-0.3539502919,
1.5394458771,
-0.1765284985,
0.5524838567,
0.2425225675,
0.8304904103,
0.78157866,
0.0717657879,
-0.4816540182,
0.5749545097,
-0.2479141355,
-0.7925578356,
-0.1482277513,
-0.2995513678,
-0.9973208308,
0.3171077669,
-0.1176659688,
-0.8183647394,
0.4502311349,
-0.1802796721,
-0.4552466273,
0.0806193277,
-0.1970131099,
0.6912977099,
-0.072662428,
-0.4814559817,
-0.2939220369,
-0.8150624633,
0.3090386391,
-0.1575469375,
0.3239031136,
-0.1812242419,
0.1194397062,
0.7974222302,
-0.8561378121,
0.2820959985,
-0.3647536933,
0.041179806,
0.1585318148,
0.1427249461,
0.4792020619,
0.5251541734,
-0.365093708,
-0.2246526778,
0.1362811625,
-0.4272551239,
-0.508372426,
0.8180987835,
-0.4383604527,
-0.5213155746,
-1.1785405874,
-0.3733287752,
-0.1866964847,
0.2233819216,
0.2644295096,
0.1318354458,
-0.285669446,
0.4409142435,
0.1481621265,
0.0342344493,
0.6542828679,
0.444432199,
-0.2491267622,
-0.3493243158,
0.6536958814,
0.2948809564,
-0.3529901206,
0.2694020867,
0.0764873847,
-0.6383300424,
-0.586925149,
-0.4462358654,
0.2160768509,
-0.9992751479,
-0.0224055126,
-0.3978880346,
-0.2670316398,
-0.6076815724,
-0.1305218488,
-0.1890559942,
-0.6617100239,
-0.1493477672,
-0.2897157669,
0.3629419804,
0.7900550961,
-0.1148835421,
0.2332127392,
-0.4778786004,
0.1848495454,
0.5877575278,
0.3502529562,
-0.458388865,
-0.5224924684,
0.0625901893,
-0.4350070059,
-0.4564925134,
-0.5686202049,
0.2285710573,
0.2346360683,
0.6544004083,
0.4744726717,
0.4619573355,
0.5352490544,
-1.1360116005,
0.9520711899,
0.1252679378,
-0.7471717,
1.1168732643,
-0.4342349172,
-0.1920250505,
0.8101177812,
0.477904886,
-0.2411371022,
0.0365349799,
-0.989649713,
-0.9422503114,
0.6248862743,
0.2002684325,
0.0301280469,
-0.052369684,
0.616527617,
0.1434327513,
0.33939448,
-0.4396027625,
0.1159575582,
-0.3130206764,
0.0689782724,
-0.2503454387,
0.1106208488,
-0.2624622881,
-0.7464373708,
0.5670397878,
-0.0959119573,
0.1907916814,
0.4356290102,
-0.2231145799,
0.0991422236,
0.2642714977,
0.6748568416,
0.9128726125,
-0.5205776691,
0.1144447103,
-0.0736211985,
-0.494140625,
0.0814972669,
0.2167973071,
-0.2687740028,
0.1637952775,
0.4456489086,
0.579434514,
-0.3932628632,
-0.6940646768,
0.836357832,
0.0772980228,
-0.3815327883,
-0.859808147,
-0.0386788696,
-0.0031570974,
0.5104511976,
0.5824870467,
0.0214885082,
0.5772935748,
-0.4660575986,
0.7226608992,
0.1051865891,
-0.6592165232,
-0.0863040015,
1.0491166115,
0.0078309709,
-0.1710349172,
0.35160321,
-0.2840375304,
-0.038373325,
0.5646296144,
0.2594913244,
0.7160300612,
0.0347331613,
0.1975102574,
0.314353317,
-0.1045864224,
-0.3679299653,
0.2701438963,
-0.1155157089,
-0.3588710427,
-0.3292016089,
-0.8277921081,
-0.5390831828,
0.0935176909,
-0.7770714164,
0.2552652955,
-0.7291340828,
-0.3799238503,
0.0435114093,
-0.0307401959,
-0.4563643038,
0.2317188829,
0.0594892688,
1.1256805658,
-0.8616636395,
0.9133582115,
0.5177255869,
-0.5951219797,
-0.1438163966,
0.3340343237,
0.2257413268,
-0.1862972081,
0.6140705943,
-0.1693393141,
0.1773876697,
-0.2158475667,
-0.5169157982,
-0.3549157679,
1.106667757,
0.3696748018,
-0.9046645761,
0.1451194435,
-0.0671261251,
0.2736726999,
-0.3742922544,
0.1221899465,
0.7547602654,
0.5682742596,
0.3343562782,
-0.7486298084,
0.1847851872,
-0.4082189202,
0.075367026,
-0.1614336818,
-0.6052886248,
0.9925775528,
-0.1386884153,
0.3111158013,
-0.0584807433,
0.6691538095,
0.3884969354,
0.4315802455,
0.5976709127,
0.8192489147,
0.7823972702,
-0.3629562259,
1.3394505978,
0.1406249553,
0.2575442195,
1.4127577543,
-0.5028343797,
1.240896225,
0.6323125958,
-0.2966556251,
0.9160457253,
0.6229144335,
-0.0755238831,
0.9553568363,
0.1704442799,
-0.0561493076,
-0.4747736752,
-0.3388109803,
-0.5711022615,
0.1758612096,
0.3009133935,
-0.6711945534,
-0.2861042321,
-0.217176944,
-0.2958398163,
0.3269899189,
-0.4396700263,
0.7572368979,
0.3716358244,
-0.4021073878,
-0.0428393856,
-0.3396267891,
-0.0124332141,
-0.0213664398,
-0.2944861054,
-0.1249127612,
0.1443249285,
-0.1535376608,
-0.8519235849,
0.1520363092,
-0.380507648,
-0.0777284354,
-0.2073941678,
0.1812150329,
0.1492002606,
-0.6275859475,
0.3807261586,
0.4802899957,
0.1775800288,
-0.1031570211,
-0.7957037091,
-0.1231634989,
-0.3935181797,
-0.2940791547,
0.3574963808,
0.56379807,
-0.5201202035,
0.4334639609,
0.5804201961,
0.3634943962,
0.2230074704,
0.7086818218,
0.9142344594,
-0.9791144729,
-0.6246505976,
-0.7400123477,
0.4134317935,
-0.6453506947,
-0.3049307764,
0.4933354259,
0.7027972341,
0.514141202,
0.0172987115,
0.7483238578,
-0.258174181,
0.7271615863,
-0.7426043153,
0.4270464778,
-0.5780073404,
0.3121754825,
-0.5190410018,
-1.0263053179,
-0.4574152827,
0.6958862543,
-0.380795002,
0.1025994644,
0.8442538381,
0.3463607728,
-0.2678923607,
0.1010794416,
0.2167653292,
0.0996380746,
0.2736290395,
0.3448468447,
0.7833691239,
-0.4613917172,
0.273622036,
-0.2943999767,
0.3903193176,
-0.7630010843,
-1.0039486885,
-0.5953755975,
-0.5426228046,
-0.1341976374,
-0.2810861468,
0.2078299671,
0.9631057382,
0.6614760756,
-1.0906134844,
-0.1113411263,
-0.5719510913,
0.2272498012,
-0.1479907036,
-0.2266265005,
0.6011993289,
-0.4107815623,
-0.7594389915,
0.5493508577,
-0.080551751,
-0.2467648387,
0.2887666225,
-0.0300106537,
-0.4325197935,
0.061565429,
0.4158947468,
0.1635071486,
-0.9602465034,
-0.3208106756,
-0.4085298777,
-0.0178495497,
-0.0248255003,
0.8569697142,
-0.5737787485,
0.4304465353,
0.648271203,
0.4252839386,
0.8541603088,
0.3940670192,
0.6099156737,
-0.9384041429,
0.2803627253,
0.4124059379,
0.8483085632,
0.03636932,
-0.0905682594,
0.9655237198,
0.3380713165,
-0.5746459365,
-0.8078051209,
-0.0353059657,
-1.2064279318,
-0.4904139042,
1.0651035309,
-0.2093527317,
-0.337338388,
-0.3625059426,
0.0097611714,
-0.1740948856,
-0.8484041095,
0.1638258696,
0.6444374919,
-0.2235989422,
-0.3026082516,
-1.1618356705,
0.5953451395,
0.1473399699,
-0.6892486811,
0.0116462344,
0.7009664774,
0.1181953177,
0.4378471375,
0.7870101929,
-0.3653691709,
0.3531974852,
-0.0455559902,
-0.1924262196,
0.238439098,
-0.4768535197,
-0.4206131399,
0.3279792368,
-0.0723158121,
0.0938341394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09344v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09344v1
|
Language and Task Arithmetic with Parameter-Efficient Layers for Zero-Shot Summarization
| 2023-11-15T20:04:58 | 2023-11-15T20:04:58 |
Alexandra Chronopoulou, Jonas Pfeiffer, Joshua Maynez, Xinyi Wang, Sebastian Ruder, Priyanka Agrawal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) using labeled task data can
significantly improve the performance of large language models (LLMs) on the
downstream task. However, there are 7000 languages in the world and many of
these languages lack labeled data for real-world language generation tasks. In
this paper, we propose to improve zero-shot cross-lingual transfer by composing
language or task specialized parameters. Our method composes language and task
PEFT modules via element-wise arithmetic operations to leverage unlabeled data
and English labeled data. We extend our approach to cases where labeled data
from more languages is available and propose to arithmetically compose PEFT
modules trained on languages related to the target. Empirical results on
summarization demonstrate that our method is an effective strategy that obtains
consistent gains using minimal training of PEFT modules.
|
[
-0.211804688,
-0.7773954868,
0.5032171011,
0.2448328137,
-0.3383779824,
0.1357964724,
-0.2011782527,
-0.3729649484,
0.0873710215,
0.6190249324,
-0.2533189654,
-0.4779529274,
-0.4199813604,
0.110461019,
-0.2155109346,
1.1250888109,
-0.1715476662,
-0.1928452104,
-0.083315894,
-0.217020303,
-0.1430314183,
-0.6080986261,
-0.6426930428,
-0.4371409714,
0.4752815664,
0.7268391252,
0.3312342167,
0.7485239506,
0.2458617687,
0.2969532907,
0.1273760498,
0.2486068606,
-0.5400329232,
-0.0205199085,
-0.2935281396,
-0.4789951444,
-0.923897624,
-0.2179258019,
0.8290121555,
1.1648321152,
0.2350961268,
0.259530127,
-0.2499992698,
0.7018972635,
-0.7270112634,
0.3068059087,
-0.3922345042,
0.1983929425,
-0.1261866987,
-0.2935031056,
-0.4321282506,
0.0364009105,
-0.2270139605,
-0.6075875759,
0.1325723827,
-0.1067642197,
0.4968127906,
-0.0331615657,
-0.4729196429,
0.2970769405,
-0.7448839545,
0.9767382741,
-0.8805698752,
0.3581320941,
0.3306445181,
-0.0654211789,
0.1317960918,
-0.355879873,
-0.2597738802,
-0.0821733102,
-0.0018262067,
0.097686924,
-0.1081445068,
0.1230559498,
0.1328868717,
0.1945185512,
-0.4972834587,
0.0895152688,
-0.4015258551,
-0.2333664894,
0.8585273623,
0.2151172012,
0.2101233155,
0.2684365213,
-0.1439787149,
0.0948115066,
-0.9257830977,
-0.0111518325,
0.481710583,
0.4286600351,
-0.1707216352,
0.66252774,
-0.7682211995,
0.9356973171,
0.3948307633,
-0.3185395896,
0.2419877499,
-0.4603109658,
-0.2793056965,
0.256523937,
0.5258239508,
0.3041875064,
0.3207232654,
-0.5023415089,
-0.2582213581,
-0.1720791012,
0.0819417387,
-1.0481412411,
-0.2383770049,
0.0172741078,
0.0210791267,
-0.2221649885,
-0.2643529475,
-0.2349097133,
0.2980291843,
-0.4219517708,
0.6432855725,
-0.4528560936,
-0.1178007722,
0.1964916736,
-0.0119225299,
0.1242622212,
0.3743281364,
-1.0064476728,
0.2676658034,
0.7097196579,
0.5908722878,
-0.0319855623,
-0.3099808693,
-0.8990578055,
0.4960288703,
-0.4920529723,
0.8625472188,
-0.6230214834,
-0.2314508557,
-0.2259353846,
0.0944303796,
-0.2648310065,
-0.40036273,
0.3336287439,
-0.2789165378,
0.217578575,
-0.1315386593,
-0.7083247304,
-0.192448765,
0.176559329,
-0.3130705059,
0.9631531835,
0.2390196621,
-0.3857804537,
0.1537925154,
-0.4690072834,
-0.9388231635,
0.2619732618,
-0.0169268548,
-0.2664944232,
0.3846010566,
0.4366951585,
0.7055141926,
0.0153925773,
-0.0220217891,
-0.067962423,
-0.4377340078,
0.0447296984,
-0.2628484964,
0.5139079094,
0.1739730388,
-0.4479499161,
-0.1551777869,
-0.8311026692,
0.0551042706,
-0.1749899089,
-0.57886976,
-0.4420289099,
-0.1605458558,
-0.1061601713,
-0.1092167199,
0.3334342539,
-0.5912206173,
0.0699056908,
-0.7133251429,
0.0623775572,
0.3825520873,
0.1019943953,
0.7998202443,
-0.2886387706,
0.5404656529,
-0.0318214558,
-0.2557482421,
-0.4337907135,
-0.1347720027,
-0.7615424991,
-0.2053922713,
0.3383104503,
0.612629652,
-1.0833266973,
0.4561926723,
-0.1655195951,
-0.5601254106,
-0.1975796074,
0.267144233,
0.712700367,
0.8174324036,
0.2041519433,
-0.2490544021,
-0.1519429833,
-0.9012292027,
-0.2938985527,
-0.1579948664,
-0.2160484195,
0.1099668667,
0.0210879911,
0.422041446,
0.457752496,
-0.5435120463,
-0.1238796413,
-0.5652267337,
0.4326134324,
0.1902449876,
0.503585279,
0.7542567849,
-0.3596873581,
-0.8389107585,
0.1445988864,
-0.3920795918,
-0.5282757878,
-0.1892989427,
-0.2627434134,
0.4025986493,
0.3497960269,
-0.4406211078,
-0.0846526697,
0.3360601664,
-0.4322102666,
0.118599765,
-0.2947309017,
0.3660167456,
-0.8472975492,
0.0954944789,
0.0452035293,
-0.5342791677,
-1.0168818235,
0.0283035822,
0.2046399415,
-0.0356399864,
-0.8642189503,
0.4307962954,
-0.5338186026,
0.2379218936,
-0.328016758,
-0.0427186415,
-0.0106897876,
0.8400729299,
0.1945971251,
0.5912827253,
0.6968189478,
-0.501141727,
0.159208551,
-0.1054856479,
-0.0882680938,
0.8921125531,
-0.6404120326,
0.1268733591,
-0.1841687709,
-0.0594314337,
-0.9475644231,
-0.0293952338,
0.2195960134,
-0.2878726721,
0.5923945904,
-0.1840265691,
-0.2626732886,
0.3588581085,
-0.4684638381,
0.60465765,
0.4680356085,
-0.054456085,
0.3610273004,
0.4973726869,
-0.491127789,
-0.3683710396,
-0.7099394798,
-0.0416469611,
-0.1918275058,
-0.4538596272,
0.5424932241,
0.0311410762,
0.001021027,
0.000227014,
-0.2707768679,
-0.1422682852,
-0.1815679371,
-0.1421744674,
0.0680242032,
-0.2688212991,
-0.0795315132,
0.3715777993,
-0.1756401807,
-0.0711675212,
-0.2163376808,
0.2509568632,
0.0246582907,
-0.1179990917,
-0.0002665609,
0.5339688659,
0.3403946459,
-0.1800447553,
0.4864930212,
0.6118462086,
-0.2391826659,
-0.3700250089,
-0.3035617769,
0.1153333336,
-0.42861709,
0.4331327081,
-0.3571479619,
-1.0007432699,
0.3320876062,
-0.0218319427,
0.2508312762,
0.5157545805,
0.6571608782,
-0.0518966392,
1.1132605076,
0.8747432828,
-0.1164308041,
0.4571759105,
-0.2150813639,
0.1983820796,
-0.5566471815,
-0.036845468,
-0.430596292,
-0.4261422455,
-0.2148321569,
-0.5804861784,
0.579929471,
0.102316685,
-0.1524061561,
0.4607026577,
-0.3438695073,
0.7679045796,
0.4697619081,
0.1346618384,
0.4231525064,
0.2928065062,
0.0938059464,
-0.0490225516,
-0.85289222,
-0.1346093267,
1.0516873598,
-0.0292028394,
0.6825253367,
-0.0495489538,
0.7777225375,
0.1531195641,
-0.028384624,
-0.736784935,
0.7371916175,
-0.4485034943,
-0.328481555,
-0.4317042232,
-0.5446109176,
-0.7828333974,
0.2378318459,
-0.0425414667,
-0.5787217021,
0.226020053,
0.0800194964,
-0.3947978318,
0.1510703415,
-0.6684733629,
0.590023458,
-0.3161145449,
-0.3187071085,
-0.3441419005,
-0.5487365127,
0.150782153,
-0.3088866472,
0.0418634601,
-0.4021504521,
-0.3897127807,
0.8072960377,
-0.5800845027,
0.8441038132,
-0.1788132042,
-0.2329230011,
0.1460059732,
0.0243466124,
0.5307512283,
-0.2230666727,
-0.0744043589,
0.1380583048,
-0.0540437289,
-0.6253662705,
-0.4885399044,
0.6546078324,
-0.5458130836,
-0.3323386014,
-0.0922200605,
-0.8489476442,
-0.5204272866,
0.2434155941,
0.098738566,
0.4888438582,
0.1211215034,
0.2954155803,
0.6742472649,
-0.1293541938,
0.7054133415,
0.9435181618,
0.1829025894,
-0.4163814187,
1.1268891096,
0.532266736,
0.2898936272,
0.9414733052,
-0.0634114146,
-0.0988294631,
-0.6149617434,
-0.7409287095,
0.2589462698,
-0.4171211123,
-0.3845145106,
-0.5346811414,
-0.0680536702,
-0.3438925445,
-0.4644188583,
-0.4287415445,
-0.9463136196,
-0.0577231236,
-0.1350275725,
0.4145969748,
0.2775757313,
-0.1195329279,
0.2920657992,
-1.0372680426,
0.5039188266,
0.1905969977,
0.329772383,
-0.1673271805,
-0.6418065429,
-0.6989055872,
0.067807138,
-0.1110232174,
-0.8403747678,
0.4318497479,
0.6112063527,
0.6745769382,
0.16656892,
0.2319500744,
0.8939600587,
-0.5304108262,
0.6312888861,
0.2094517946,
-1.0989569426,
0.3995687366,
-0.4177677631,
0.6294230819,
0.478716433,
0.3064213991,
-0.2528990805,
-0.6041494012,
-0.4357179999,
-1.1195569038,
1.078271389,
0.2081121802,
0.3491752744,
0.242740646,
0.2481582761,
0.0987776294,
0.1774621308,
-0.3833663762,
-0.2232552022,
0.1961583495,
-0.2655070126,
-0.0438327603,
-0.1706937253,
-0.0591494367,
-0.5049039721,
0.6755837798,
-0.2465898991,
0.0702872574,
0.0627909899,
-0.180851981,
-0.3823381662,
0.35582304,
0.5929718614,
0.6541431546,
-0.0434660725,
0.2921653688,
0.403219223,
-0.3610367775,
0.3574326336,
0.123978138,
-0.4170350134,
0.0231750403,
0.3987408876,
0.6931478977,
0.534139514,
-0.705780983,
0.2254003435,
0.386615783,
-0.4742248952,
0.1826508641,
0.3243187964,
0.1085512266,
0.1924303174,
0.32269153,
-0.2638280988,
0.2014297992,
-0.5337176919,
0.2460176945,
0.2087647915,
-0.071080327,
-0.4759927988,
0.5943076611,
0.2828832567,
-0.122863628,
0.3120336831,
-0.0645348653,
-0.1018476039,
0.5319267511,
0.6257744431,
0.831127286,
-0.3117913902,
0.4628223181,
0.1453987956,
0.3266989589,
0.1713372767,
0.4401078522,
-0.3814446628,
-0.5684258938,
-0.9271790385,
-0.654916048,
-0.6020762324,
-0.0890339315,
-0.3735225797,
0.0925429016,
-0.2668628097,
0.1480300874,
0.2243381888,
0.0583996028,
-0.3814922571,
0.2442179322,
0.2180514038,
0.5651134253,
-1.0209729671,
0.9634134769,
0.968277216,
-0.1637709886,
-0.883063674,
-0.4310034215,
-0.3760603666,
-0.7472697496,
0.4383105934,
-0.2448642701,
-0.0754412934,
0.0280813668,
-0.2495860606,
-0.7667298317,
0.8126536608,
0.7817767859,
-0.5138709545,
0.2087641805,
0.7095433474,
0.6633658409,
-0.4366452694,
-0.0519618578,
0.5208082795,
0.4940499663,
0.3527003527,
-0.9202272892,
0.1018900052,
-0.3629391789,
-0.0968900844,
0.5322546363,
-0.5581360459,
0.740410924,
-0.0357431099,
-0.0259522889,
-0.3243150711,
0.3902639747,
-0.0531982444,
0.4058650732,
0.267601639,
0.6905625463,
0.2475039661,
-0.009083312,
0.7445213795,
-0.4653251767,
0.1405827254,
0.988732338,
-0.1019152179,
0.8482635021,
0.3441913724,
-0.2180653512,
0.0649685264,
0.3477053344,
0.0574036762,
0.5481371284,
-0.238786906,
-0.4605128765,
-0.3873231709,
-0.1674005985,
-0.1062781885,
0.4561561942,
0.1314824224,
-0.2822593749,
-0.5918052197,
-0.147429049,
0.3518564999,
-0.1198648289,
-0.6039566398,
0.9087376595,
-0.0086214412,
-0.6606261134,
0.6813802123,
0.3542301655,
0.4568146169,
-0.5801730752,
-0.1083700806,
-0.5535410643,
0.0784947723,
-0.3619878292,
-0.7019188404,
0.5669846535,
0.1961688846,
-0.0176870618,
-0.503846705,
0.7924442291,
-0.9554202557,
-0.9381791353,
-0.2582708895,
0.6336732507,
0.3599601388,
-0.2415626496,
-0.4287135601,
-0.3366184235,
0.0950426012,
-0.3099402487,
0.604878962,
0.5033983588,
-0.1542175114,
0.1694672555,
0.5439081788,
0.3501556814,
0.0668790862,
-0.0249737017,
0.6684203148,
-0.6675347686,
-0.4218576252,
-0.8647489548,
0.5962625742,
0.1206004471,
-0.042908866,
0.8353447914,
0.661863029,
0.9595190287,
-0.232157737,
0.5903623104,
-0.0675752386,
0.2925125659,
-0.4391351938,
0.5826259851,
-0.6099377871,
0.1202609017,
-0.1856979877,
-1.1002198458,
-0.5527522564,
0.2957897186,
-0.1777344942,
-0.1172218919,
0.3694289029,
0.7626358867,
-0.1874174178,
-0.438144058,
0.6697887778,
-0.0030213422,
0.1396130621,
0.8866732121,
0.1596336812,
-0.3551665246,
0.5347584486,
-0.6618961096,
-0.233554855,
-0.048996225,
-0.9499463439,
-0.8258185387,
-0.2446957529,
-0.68095994,
0.4249300957,
0.0015124548,
0.5509036183,
0.7997022271,
-0.9239953756,
-0.3638149798,
-0.0675261915,
0.0876700133,
-0.3663474023,
-0.2355792969,
0.2872086465,
-0.4253247082,
-1.0095034838,
0.5164200664,
0.7739332914,
-0.1104428098,
-0.0947251022,
-0.0511080436,
0.0710829273,
0.3382021785,
0.9405626655,
0.3553445041,
-0.2491106242,
-0.1389087886,
0.0757375434,
0.2386391312,
-0.0417971723,
0.8782424331,
-0.6643294096,
0.348873198,
0.8066331148,
0.5881045461,
0.579247117,
0.1393515319,
0.8968414664,
-1.1263325214,
0.1527608335,
0.1320601702,
0.291479826,
0.2400010824,
-0.4186038971,
0.6240790486,
0.1690420657,
-0.3400255144,
-0.6421718597,
-0.0588749163,
-1.0647932291,
-0.2783342302,
0.9697936177,
-0.2629216313,
-0.0569083169,
-0.0776581466,
-0.1145336404,
0.1792011112,
-0.2697981596,
0.5872132182,
0.3652270436,
-0.5432313681,
-0.3285204172,
-0.1609967947,
0.1551995873,
0.5835817456,
-0.8180223703,
-0.0162267778,
0.6097354293,
0.3021406829,
-0.079506427,
0.8158718944,
-0.186239928,
0.2352544218,
-0.0042901384,
-0.12874268,
-0.3562987745,
-0.2911379337,
-0.1679850072,
0.3443483114,
-0.0270961411,
-0.1828664243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09336v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09336v3
|
LLMRefine: Pinpointing and Refining Large Language Models via Fine-Grained Actionable Feedback
| 2023-11-15T19:52:11 | 2024-04-02T16:39:13 |
Wenda Xu, Daniel Deutsch, Mara Finkelstein, Juraj Juraska, Biao Zhang, Zhongtao Liu, William Yang Wang, Lei Li, Markus Freitag
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent large language models (LLM) are leveraging human feedback to improve
their generation quality. However, human feedback is costly to obtain,
especially during inference. In this work, we propose LLMRefine, an inference
time optimization method to refine LLM's output. The core idea is to use a
learned fine-grained feedback model to pinpoint defects and guide LLM to refine
them iteratively. Using original LLM as a proposal of edits, LLMRefine searches
for defect-less text via simulated annealing, trading off the exploration and
exploitation. We conduct experiments on three text generation tasks, including
machine translation, long-form question answering (QA), and topical
summarization. LLMRefine consistently outperforms all baseline approaches,
achieving improvements up to 1.7 MetricX points on translation tasks, 8.1
ROUGE-L on ASQA, 2.2 ROUGE-L on topical summarization.
|
[
-0.1686116606,
-0.8080220819,
0.7844087481,
0.1800646186,
0.0530579761,
-0.1264976263,
-0.6087485552,
-0.1982768178,
-0.0304747485,
0.6336477995,
-0.9315363765,
-0.6611258388,
-0.2060690075,
0.0842760131,
-0.3567177951,
0.9646812081,
-0.3060279489,
-0.156660229,
-0.1959155947,
0.3456874788,
-0.1127656102,
-0.3324097097,
-0.6733938456,
-0.5402696133,
0.6980807781,
0.873859942,
0.2133850008,
0.8091897964,
0.1620578468,
0.2829897702,
-0.1375299394,
0.5714228749,
-0.7571899891,
0.1089208126,
-0.2979446054,
-0.5260850787,
-0.3677793145,
-0.1614400595,
0.4326728582,
0.6792712808,
-0.1585027426,
0.1960280985,
0.5041375756,
0.6876224875,
-0.6595228314,
-0.0576601401,
-0.6612145901,
-0.1111671478,
-0.224587217,
-0.1819436997,
-0.4753288627,
-0.5497425199,
-0.2334876955,
-0.3692724407,
0.6710727215,
-0.059170749,
0.9516684413,
0.276491791,
0.06047903,
-0.189732939,
-0.9079444408,
1.177934885,
-1.1229884624,
0.0884897485,
0.3499819338,
0.1358245909,
-0.4642243683,
-0.8835539818,
-0.3164626658,
-0.3722260892,
0.0598487519,
0.063020885,
-0.0589297973,
0.074669525,
0.0822847635,
0.3514426947,
-0.1851879209,
0.3239704072,
-0.2877129912,
-0.1849576533,
0.7432146668,
0.199772343,
-0.2219773382,
-0.215567261,
-0.0371492356,
0.0573515296,
-0.6943956614,
-0.0385605469,
0.4532848001,
0.3274334669,
0.2580009699,
0.5699958205,
-0.4622695148,
0.622775197,
0.1059700623,
-0.1807838529,
-0.1395989954,
-0.3518401384,
-0.1183893159,
-0.0473965071,
0.7362783551,
0.5061326623,
0.1919309795,
-0.0870620087,
-0.5209410787,
-0.1263607293,
0.1059893519,
-1.0610698462,
-0.2686402202,
0.3810717463,
-0.384739548,
-0.2666951418,
0.0217528362,
-0.7721589208,
-0.3345607519,
-0.2739584744,
0.0483377278,
-0.3800735176,
0.1971160769,
0.1141046956,
-0.033348497,
-0.1439210325,
0.6107263565,
-0.9657715559,
0.0739101544,
0.7247186303,
0.6880105138,
-0.0846582577,
-0.3826490045,
-0.6612741947,
0.2208729684,
-0.3241820633,
1.2435557842,
-0.3481989801,
-0.4558325708,
-0.0895537958,
-0.0980886891,
-0.0051365662,
-0.8300246596,
0.6323632002,
-0.206858933,
0.003043199,
-0.0527944677,
-0.481431365,
-0.121707432,
0.362287432,
-0.5476951599,
1.1644817591,
0.194227159,
-0.5740917921,
0.2035710961,
-0.3685709834,
-0.2320051342,
-0.2224980891,
-0.1806680262,
-0.3884063661,
0.343287617,
0.4772482812,
0.4986901581,
-0.6050328016,
0.2952151,
-0.2804994881,
-0.3185381889,
0.2542155385,
-0.5270656347,
-0.0993923172,
0.1230251864,
-0.4344505072,
0.3166954517,
-0.9731878042,
0.252399534,
-0.01327415,
-0.7125533223,
-0.120997861,
0.2613556385,
0.0325590931,
0.0454734825,
0.2364657968,
-0.5962551832,
0.1838897467,
-0.5191627145,
0.5241299868,
0.6922643185,
0.2372181267,
0.2761096954,
-0.3468464613,
0.3391595781,
-0.193008393,
0.0737633929,
-0.1695874035,
-0.0858313963,
-1.0812985897,
-0.0590308011,
0.5362315178,
0.3725619018,
-0.4839773476,
0.2868147492,
-0.0766056925,
-0.4920104742,
-0.6452701688,
0.5358645916,
0.47481215,
0.4518802762,
0.1811659783,
0.0236932468,
-0.4937556982,
-1.0560284853,
-0.3071126938,
-0.0628990158,
-0.2962809503,
0.209220469,
0.1179768145,
-0.4622445405,
0.9096491337,
-0.6521544456,
-0.1545711756,
-0.3870623708,
0.3545604646,
0.1169252768,
0.274988234,
0.1024420559,
-0.2939809263,
-0.1194578335,
0.1423290223,
-0.2998203635,
-0.5556967258,
-0.1186228096,
-0.1172767729,
0.3302104473,
0.9470438361,
-0.1164602041,
0.2708596587,
0.6866794825,
-0.1253921241,
0.5495357513,
-0.20550327,
0.0550078824,
-1.0424516201,
0.208245635,
-0.1344397664,
-0.2245790511,
-0.4025653005,
-0.1297843009,
0.045408871,
-0.0082863513,
-0.3562892973,
0.6363094449,
-0.4024910629,
0.141267404,
-0.5489625335,
0.4397278726,
0.1676697582,
0.4946679175,
-0.2319051772,
0.7084016204,
-0.2781110108,
-0.6998739839,
0.1276570857,
-0.1202154756,
-0.4175384939,
0.22989586,
-0.563790977,
0.2085367292,
-0.0964806825,
-0.0143480431,
-0.9694557786,
-0.3005578816,
-0.064881593,
-0.2516958416,
0.0656844229,
-0.1252786219,
-0.3388231397,
-0.2885739803,
-0.335321635,
0.1800406128,
0.1417839378,
-0.4981026351,
0.4217908978,
-0.1974885911,
-0.3955569863,
-0.3395017385,
-0.4893728495,
-0.0898361728,
0.1329744309,
-0.6004249454,
0.3808327317,
0.0333047621,
-0.3819433153,
-0.0825918615,
-0.0503773652,
0.2329431176,
0.171110779,
0.2063759714,
-0.0873229578,
-0.278706342,
0.0066012074,
0.1488258094,
-0.3715818226,
-0.1871482432,
-0.0191767197,
0.8404057026,
-0.0041445554,
-0.294454515,
-0.3564619422,
0.4509625435,
0.3425946832,
-0.252133131,
0.0926808044,
0.3658288419,
-0.1603263766,
-0.7357977033,
-0.5343991518,
-0.3359985948,
-0.4959722459,
0.5658195615,
-0.2005871534,
-0.8770597577,
0.467138201,
-0.4154425561,
0.4157092273,
0.573310554,
0.6193531156,
0.1918193251,
1.0077662468,
0.7137840986,
0.2356277853,
0.357601583,
-0.3061902225,
0.0513528772,
-0.8140229583,
-0.1776476204,
-0.6748713851,
-0.3832632303,
-0.2935331166,
-0.5778805017,
-0.1530326754,
0.5328202844,
-0.038327273,
0.1047748104,
-0.165917784,
0.446888566,
0.7860215306,
0.1007304937,
0.3809606731,
-0.0271203183,
-0.2564329505,
-0.1952677667,
-0.6628974676,
-0.7065444589,
0.7276608348,
0.3716830313,
1.2030907869,
-0.2230972052,
0.8529228568,
-0.1201732531,
0.5378080606,
-0.9860855937,
0.4447953105,
-0.3059652448,
-0.1269584298,
-0.1267495453,
-0.4712460339,
-0.6720637083,
-0.0696996525,
-0.0177469123,
-0.6902721524,
0.0024600783,
0.4158839285,
-0.4978833795,
0.2084705532,
-0.598834157,
0.7966628671,
-0.2025192678,
-0.2749135494,
-0.2265511453,
-0.1069191843,
0.3727937043,
-0.2168182135,
0.0967909098,
-0.2556248307,
0.0944761112,
0.6094474792,
-0.644007504,
0.9379077554,
-0.0026716334,
-0.5368450284,
0.145213753,
0.3006368876,
0.6401763558,
0.0869899243,
-0.1954340041,
-0.0730990097,
-0.1664636433,
-0.1885169297,
-0.7141367197,
0.8808196783,
-0.5511538386,
-0.6384032965,
0.061149545,
-0.5872953534,
-0.3182859123,
0.1855802536,
0.5328829885,
0.5009058714,
-0.2033108324,
0.0167014953,
0.435359478,
-0.2740474641,
0.6030579805,
0.4860442877,
-0.4530065954,
-0.5821998715,
0.8130598068,
-0.1421959847,
0.3858173192,
0.446334362,
0.3006644249,
-0.0056449836,
-0.6860739589,
-0.3717122078,
0.4673353434,
-0.5632576346,
-0.2802183926,
-0.5051609874,
-0.2986627221,
-0.2391349375,
-0.2988266051,
-0.6931034923,
-0.3476693928,
-0.5965580344,
0.0828154311,
0.3745001256,
0.8541377187,
-0.0625261962,
0.6687712073,
-1.0680299997,
0.2135953605,
0.2147801071,
0.3992449641,
0.1458813995,
-0.5191358328,
-0.3331179321,
0.0872836411,
-0.3875937462,
-0.3875974715,
0.3502927125,
0.3230244219,
0.2832883894,
0.560762465,
0.038172815,
0.8811656833,
-0.8122560382,
0.7296261191,
-0.0066627772,
-0.9192760587,
0.7043243051,
-0.0845729187,
0.4899828434,
0.6917263269,
-0.0018090134,
-0.7742976546,
-0.6152197123,
-0.3980411887,
-1.0891377926,
0.5398615003,
-0.1067031771,
-0.0607958622,
-0.0133873504,
0.5528944135,
0.1267477423,
0.0918132365,
-0.2895338237,
-0.008773745,
0.2253421992,
-0.1570317596,
-0.2091066837,
-0.5831183791,
-0.1771731079,
-0.0004018424,
0.6876577735,
-0.2709714174,
0.0834837258,
0.2780717909,
-0.0430761576,
-0.2270387262,
0.4577524066,
0.8777338862,
0.8777770996,
-0.3033981621,
0.1707285941,
0.0508543514,
-0.4810599685,
-0.0507268086,
0.2189683914,
-0.1749670058,
0.3056001365,
0.3888464868,
0.65679878,
0.3273720145,
-0.776948154,
0.215109393,
-0.0341084562,
-0.3742153943,
-0.1035379469,
0.1077752262,
-0.0061909603,
0.5094619393,
0.4020258784,
-0.2009647042,
0.0133778872,
-0.2561234832,
0.5245878696,
0.0909639075,
-0.5475347042,
-0.1356378496,
0.7044497132,
0.2028657049,
-0.286550045,
0.4810697436,
0.0581767038,
-0.4831495285,
0.3554800153,
0.5458039641,
0.8970115781,
-0.2652272582,
0.2723180056,
0.4158110023,
0.2651617229,
-0.1744813472,
0.2927803993,
0.2005283237,
-0.4335694909,
-0.7767068744,
-0.758538425,
-0.3795872927,
0.2487300187,
-0.6373568773,
0.3121413291,
-0.5445676446,
-0.1542868763,
-0.0548328981,
0.0840050802,
-0.2462964654,
0.1274283379,
-0.1192190945,
0.9967595339,
-0.544880569,
0.5794447064,
0.3420612514,
-0.082656309,
-0.8874017596,
0.1554828435,
-0.0998743847,
-0.8382704854,
0.6419886351,
0.2178687006,
-0.2098241597,
0.1560801864,
-0.6076190472,
-0.7823213339,
0.9674555063,
0.3761293292,
-1.0885765553,
-0.1285154819,
0.0515389778,
0.2883746922,
-0.051162295,
0.0306499936,
0.8067313433,
0.3986837864,
0.1961113065,
-0.704674542,
0.0016747201,
-0.155189395,
0.2652823627,
0.5528446436,
-0.5702098608,
0.7477835417,
-0.3922599554,
-0.1867502779,
0.3146802783,
0.7849003673,
0.4291076064,
0.0921209008,
0.311919421,
0.6444231868,
0.7510178685,
-0.1075577214,
1.0554511547,
-0.0919911861,
0.3155142069,
1.3066866398,
-0.1247394681,
1.0446156263,
0.6677729487,
0.1011239812,
0.4757539928,
0.7120865583,
-0.0482850932,
0.4942556322,
0.5072789192,
-0.2168351114,
-0.2668266892,
-0.1284250915,
-0.0938323513,
0.2405512929,
0.320322305,
-0.4941192567,
-0.6250908375,
-0.1731283814,
0.408339709,
0.2584357262,
-0.3596335351,
0.7041290402,
0.2085436583,
-0.7006752491,
0.7388188839,
0.4457354546,
0.6543331742,
-0.5302320123,
-0.2141177505,
-0.7354973555,
0.615293622,
-0.2936735451,
-0.4367054999,
0.1031094715,
0.1550164223,
-0.5091992617,
-0.0705682039,
0.4487097263,
-0.5939899683,
-0.6424502134,
0.2346928418,
0.1760763526,
-0.0268350355,
-0.2436008155,
-0.3891792893,
0.1587638408,
0.3350977004,
-0.3714087903,
0.0059578144,
0.4771946073,
-0.0846149847,
0.6288474798,
0.5775285959,
0.3474784493,
-0.054951597,
0.221265316,
0.7678719759,
-0.7972525358,
-0.2025277615,
-0.9887515903,
0.3976671398,
0.0013892351,
-0.4224933684,
0.7274266481,
0.5360621214,
0.7462376356,
0.0122557869,
0.7985819578,
0.1762616634,
0.8185541034,
-0.9403589368,
0.5719609857,
-0.5346665382,
0.411996901,
-0.1698235273,
-1.1301553249,
-0.2950064838,
0.3547868133,
-0.2748914957,
-0.1054849476,
0.7470214367,
1.0250051022,
0.0330122709,
-0.3100039065,
0.1258309782,
0.3161625266,
0.4393279552,
0.6390642524,
0.9649000764,
-0.3972346783,
0.6881709695,
-0.3363985121,
-0.1589949578,
-0.3424015343,
-1.0066174269,
-0.819904387,
-0.2476416528,
-0.2261103839,
-0.5016245842,
-0.1645780653,
0.8068189025,
0.3924430609,
-0.8482112885,
-0.4276537895,
-0.0773114711,
-0.055218894,
-0.0305271372,
-0.2449329942,
0.3976225555,
-0.5874006152,
-0.9324921966,
0.3602689207,
0.3031976819,
0.0040034396,
-0.3013223112,
0.0703556836,
0.0278053638,
0.048557844,
0.5817453265,
0.3965877891,
-0.7222713232,
-0.2308039069,
0.1287921667,
-0.1114645749,
-0.0276085082,
1.0569764376,
-0.3743622601,
0.2174843848,
0.3658976853,
0.6725463867,
0.5654650927,
0.1965416223,
1.0236816406,
-0.9493634105,
0.187901631,
0.2006533891,
0.1666585952,
0.381259203,
-0.1509412229,
0.2769077122,
0.0481110997,
-0.6633359194,
-0.7318554521,
0.1778010875,
-0.6272926927,
-0.4604592323,
1.4510376453,
0.0221493319,
-0.5285407305,
0.2206146121,
-0.5108203292,
0.0834874213,
-0.3577067554,
0.7214347124,
0.5161807537,
-0.0435432084,
-0.2668970525,
-0.5509138703,
0.7039405704,
0.3918928504,
-0.9743853211,
0.4896553755,
0.6251938939,
0.1572844088,
0.0830928832,
0.3970025778,
-0.1264845729,
0.0379455946,
-0.1853423715,
0.3462646902,
0.0117003322,
-0.3505744636,
-0.2318119407,
-0.1211885065,
0.4672749937,
0.0062242243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10111v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10111v1
|
VideoCon: Robust Video-Language Alignment via Contrast Captions
| 2023-11-15T19:51:57 | 2023-11-15T19:51:57 |
Hritik Bansal, Yonatan Bitton, Idan Szpektor, Kai-Wei Chang, Aditya Grover
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Despite being (pre)trained on a massive amount of data, state-of-the-art
video-language alignment models are not robust to semantically-plausible
contrastive changes in the video captions. Our work addresses this by
identifying a broad spectrum of contrast misalignments, such as replacing
entities, actions, and flipping event order, which alignment models should be
robust against. To this end, we introduce the VideoCon, a video-language
alignment dataset constructed by a large language model that generates
plausible contrast video captions and explanations for differences between
original and contrast video captions. Then, a generative video-language model
is finetuned with VideoCon to assess video-language entailment and generate
explanations. Our VideoCon-based alignment model significantly outperforms
current models. It exhibits a 12-point increase in AUC for the video-language
alignment task on human-generated contrast captions. Finally, our model sets
new state of the art zero-shot performance in temporally-extensive
video-language tasks such as text-to-video retrieval (SSv2-Temporal) and video
question answering (ATP-Hard). Moreover, our model shows superior performance
on novel videos and human-crafted captions and explanations. Our code and data
are available at https://github.com/Hritikbansal/videocon.
|
[
-0.4453489184,
-0.4550870359,
0.2545327842,
-0.0339763947,
-0.3522694111,
0.052039247,
-0.1511043161,
-0.116502434,
-0.0868216902,
0.2975720763,
-0.4980138838,
-0.5733681917,
-0.574698627,
0.0073441043,
-0.7280933857,
1.0065094233,
-0.2714791894,
0.1796947569,
-0.1990625113,
-0.530272305,
-0.2904091477,
0.0784308016,
-0.353826195,
-0.1479232907,
0.1685026586,
0.5083308816,
0.9960417151,
1.0842518806,
0.8223693967,
0.3081380129,
0.2215477824,
-0.0921937749,
-0.3174408674,
-0.1590085924,
-0.2584684491,
-0.0477842614,
-0.194690302,
-0.2596819401,
0.5768544078,
0.6538909674,
-0.3412469327,
0.0247759912,
0.0820658356,
0.4450168312,
-0.9564310312,
-0.1856887341,
-0.6917492747,
-0.025938496,
-0.0528184474,
-0.171041429,
-0.2078033686,
-0.0871835575,
0.1023639515,
-0.5214301944,
0.7382964492,
-0.059813194,
1.2183822393,
0.6165431142,
-0.2426796556,
0.0547504947,
-0.7835202217,
0.5859944224,
-0.5338602066,
0.6257809401,
0.1172121242,
0.5219162107,
0.2295448929,
-0.5284084082,
-0.8737854958,
0.0462087579,
0.0507687926,
0.3189648986,
-0.2202077508,
0.1973337978,
0.1582998484,
0.5129488707,
-0.9944480658,
0.3800150752,
-0.0209478475,
-0.1377688348,
0.3001573384,
0.3608362675,
0.3949051499,
-0.092407003,
-0.4625121057,
-0.1659338325,
-0.5740564466,
-0.097124666,
0.5433465242,
0.0140563799,
-0.5930649638,
0.6944229007,
-0.3528251946,
0.86087358,
0.0475677848,
-0.0026281963,
-0.0610641353,
-0.6560544968,
-0.4937041104,
0.0650853813,
0.8873953223,
0.7944967151,
0.2938511372,
0.0157772284,
0.0899809077,
0.4608874917,
0.1218133196,
-0.8396522999,
-0.6568251848,
0.1590481848,
-0.3349607587,
-0.2124442458,
0.3631618619,
-0.9259681702,
-0.5409610868,
-0.358450979,
0.445938468,
-0.1297271848,
-0.1186028197,
0.2262860835,
0.02189398,
0.5887376666,
0.31632635,
-1.043682456,
0.4810952544,
0.3637295067,
0.6847274899,
-0.3868187368,
-0.3768278062,
-0.7401539087,
0.1896856576,
-0.4152316451,
0.7061865926,
-0.4329014719,
0.1817779988,
0.4101863503,
0.1128752604,
0.1493283063,
-0.4703871012,
0.1333271265,
-0.3577594161,
0.2533480227,
0.0543000028,
-0.3607478738,
0.2778257728,
0.1795027256,
-0.7962550521,
0.627168119,
-0.3143913746,
-0.8486776352,
0.2709961832,
-0.2230225652,
-0.2690968513,
-0.1561513096,
-0.4584074914,
-0.528139174,
-0.1248041689,
0.269637078,
0.1376431584,
-0.2057596892,
0.2362164557,
-0.2519176304,
-0.4464790523,
0.4987418056,
-0.5430455208,
0.5315523744,
0.2680664361,
-0.3111983538,
0.1217757389,
-0.6184673905,
-0.5914446712,
-0.0322703533,
0.2502919734,
0.1120132208,
0.0341108963,
-0.2368922085,
0.137253657,
0.2466712594,
-0.3223745525,
-0.177053228,
-0.0410650074,
0.1997761875,
0.6452683806,
-0.2366543561,
0.8077632785,
0.0414945818,
0.5502348542,
0.0388689861,
0.3407865763,
-0.3797180653,
-0.1902625412,
-0.6360899806,
-0.1086915359,
0.218373552,
0.5729043484,
-0.7694422007,
0.1567180008,
-0.3259577453,
-0.1519372165,
-0.5131374598,
0.2690002918,
0.5461628437,
0.8443077207,
0.4079404175,
-0.4770823717,
-0.6275456548,
-0.9373069406,
0.0253800452,
-0.2311626375,
-0.0801364854,
0.1302984506,
0.2716781497,
0.0735300779,
0.6003967524,
-0.7377247214,
-0.061058376,
-0.0727815852,
0.1036938131,
0.0314743817,
0.3704815805,
0.321000427,
-0.9686242342,
-0.5415650606,
0.1757578254,
-0.6169122458,
-0.1656777561,
-0.2939424813,
-0.2294550538,
0.1106968746,
0.9223250151,
-0.4004453123,
0.313816905,
0.7560660839,
-0.1921276748,
0.6137427092,
-0.0824159682,
0.4184506834,
-1.0127948523,
0.149830237,
0.0905066431,
-0.1182000861,
-0.4902841449,
-0.0816120133,
-0.0688050315,
-0.1913967878,
-0.611784339,
0.4386105239,
-0.0753644407,
-0.1214430481,
-0.1513792127,
0.3808313906,
0.1074962318,
0.5832505822,
0.3224543929,
0.5882322788,
0.6706004739,
-0.4947398007,
0.4943309128,
0.4394366741,
-0.3942566514,
0.7757378817,
-0.438542366,
-0.178822428,
-0.2236263007,
-0.0253537931,
-1.3751211166,
-0.5558485985,
0.2381320298,
-0.5508346558,
0.3369152546,
-0.3857859373,
-0.0761085674,
0.1458133906,
-0.2085046917,
0.6678640246,
0.3243410885,
-0.5922328234,
0.4573983848,
0.0892905965,
-0.2783515155,
-0.9509534836,
-0.7793885469,
0.146572575,
-0.3126080036,
-0.3363596499,
0.6631767154,
-0.2288871855,
-0.3031592965,
0.1004002839,
-0.3811356425,
-0.279612124,
-0.1373307556,
0.1087341532,
0.5250054598,
-0.1722884029,
-0.0677369162,
-0.2733158469,
-0.0093149301,
-0.2604400516,
-0.0933297649,
0.4063036442,
-0.065192692,
-0.2891435623,
-0.5117159486,
0.4120492339,
0.4850946367,
-0.3078715801,
0.5378372073,
0.637516737,
-0.448343426,
0.3082800806,
-0.6740422845,
-0.049930308,
-0.3854507208,
0.6190932393,
-0.0897180364,
-0.6554031968,
0.5689935088,
0.3537487388,
0.042917423,
0.1625462621,
0.3269763887,
-0.4386984706,
1.2149825096,
0.6043272018,
0.1733222008,
0.9969613552,
0.0131413266,
0.1119647399,
-0.2514919937,
-0.1488269269,
-0.6271001101,
-0.1022482887,
-0.7834125161,
-0.0978208408,
-0.1031057313,
0.1703080237,
-0.5870150328,
0.6570945382,
-0.0929509923,
0.7405908704,
0.1117786244,
-0.1001801938,
0.2746153176,
0.0917100236,
0.2658480406,
-0.3289431632,
-0.5744364262,
-0.3696900606,
0.6968069077,
0.1598584652,
0.9988344312,
0.4597658813,
0.4308409095,
0.1558062732,
-0.0107312556,
-0.5643399358,
0.4347468615,
-0.6080380082,
-0.1206765547,
-0.1550276726,
-0.3524106741,
-0.7586337328,
-0.1321890056,
-0.3159485459,
-0.574433744,
0.0772927403,
0.3414282799,
-0.3658033311,
0.0973189622,
-0.6215872169,
1.3058018684,
-0.290545702,
-0.5822896957,
-0.0641231611,
-0.8335378766,
0.2921056449,
0.2926670611,
0.1871398687,
0.2613760233,
-0.0632042214,
0.3889698684,
-0.3349797428,
0.6662679315,
0.1854266077,
-0.0337438099,
0.2247347087,
0.384183228,
0.3041860163,
-0.0409058183,
0.3909204006,
-0.1661047935,
-0.2492384315,
-0.475405097,
-0.8289661407,
0.6190658212,
-0.5187174082,
-0.4396226406,
-0.0458612703,
-0.3253275156,
0.0344221108,
0.0797813237,
0.3703491986,
0.5363880396,
-0.2885769308,
0.206371963,
0.9050941467,
-0.3373031914,
0.5545949936,
0.5294353962,
-0.0427963585,
-0.8096958995,
1.0849215984,
-0.4482071102,
0.5754363537,
0.6998792887,
-0.1497404426,
-0.2212493569,
-0.6459386349,
-0.4365332723,
0.0817023814,
-0.8242465854,
-0.2176350802,
-0.2165688872,
-0.0529997163,
-0.4982058704,
-0.4665447772,
-0.4828558862,
-0.3232199848,
-0.1580863148,
-0.2647354603,
-0.0672351643,
0.2059829235,
0.0459878035,
0.4445762634,
-0.5804424882,
0.7345923185,
0.5715463161,
0.4760669768,
-0.5643549562,
-0.8790179491,
-0.2831473947,
-0.4174062908,
-0.3192491531,
-0.9043937325,
0.2118410468,
0.2451033741,
0.397973597,
0.6924260259,
-0.1842507571,
0.7760170102,
-0.4330406785,
0.9644962549,
0.5211836696,
-0.9057869315,
0.3208616674,
-0.2304199189,
0.4656857252,
0.6086462736,
0.2963773608,
-0.5431383252,
-0.290907979,
-0.5784096718,
-0.7001917958,
0.4302740991,
0.2794460058,
0.0385737754,
0.0534827709,
0.0280885268,
0.0750469938,
0.1391293406,
-0.8482547998,
-0.0763825029,
-0.6206607223,
-0.5229147673,
-0.0549266897,
0.1029406488,
-0.2166451067,
0.0571465045,
0.4884214103,
-0.4412543476,
0.0186464954,
0.0550532825,
-0.3092918396,
-0.20455046,
0.2045312226,
0.7765148878,
0.4346195459,
-0.1801005155,
0.5624160171,
0.146743685,
-0.3058523536,
0.013400686,
0.266413331,
0.0099580046,
0.0090420246,
0.5227999687,
0.6914393306,
0.2492245138,
-0.8493618965,
0.6437413096,
-0.0441086888,
-0.179783389,
-0.1000390723,
-0.1254518777,
-0.1351145059,
0.0809135213,
-0.1734507978,
0.0489563234,
0.1325210631,
-0.3868122697,
0.1914677769,
0.397608459,
-0.4913202226,
-0.251686126,
0.7900179625,
0.2105177045,
-0.2171637118,
0.622377336,
-0.0291581489,
-0.3026615977,
0.6921435595,
0.0935291722,
0.8200925589,
-0.262929976,
0.3845678568,
0.4962644279,
0.1638092548,
-0.2183215618,
0.1167301089,
-0.2715825438,
-0.8615864515,
-0.6243342757,
-0.2249893993,
-0.5050864816,
0.1174056754,
-0.8225889802,
0.5958118439,
-0.1581923962,
0.2454797029,
0.0383862518,
-0.3538182974,
-0.7435359955,
0.2748227417,
0.3901659846,
0.7676458955,
-1.2267580032,
0.6632329822,
0.5770110488,
-0.6690648794,
-0.451267451,
-0.0102286246,
-0.082406722,
-0.3889701068,
0.1545452178,
0.0763164312,
-0.113473177,
-0.2770158052,
-0.8945592642,
-0.566462338,
0.9879443049,
0.6346974373,
-0.6016491652,
0.0285666641,
0.3838820755,
0.5517181158,
-0.2896093726,
0.0547416806,
0.4612351358,
0.1597431004,
0.2313920408,
-0.675226748,
-0.2401728481,
-0.1573356986,
-0.207223624,
0.2503036261,
-0.4436139166,
0.4466104209,
-0.2264994532,
-0.1284104884,
0.2158446163,
0.8382883072,
0.0438074954,
0.2873618305,
0.5184646845,
0.6308800578,
0.3164780438,
-0.0151988566,
0.7703450918,
-0.1942361444,
0.1224834919,
1.4271068573,
-0.1582123637,
0.6839616299,
0.7235351801,
-0.019539142,
0.5893979669,
0.4672234058,
-0.1051004007,
0.6116241813,
-0.111792326,
-0.2961740792,
-0.7210348248,
-0.2855491638,
0.0883913338,
0.5207547545,
0.0595123172,
-0.3323203325,
-0.1511993706,
-0.2286000699,
-0.358119756,
0.4636537731,
-0.2034748346,
0.8045706153,
-0.2077057362,
-0.9462772608,
0.3845712543,
-0.3429171145,
0.3374750316,
-0.5460216999,
-0.1659670174,
-0.4110817015,
0.1688026786,
-0.3847360909,
-0.9519651532,
0.19569619,
0.4013006389,
-0.1742624193,
0.073235862,
0.1583454907,
-0.8834052682,
-0.0267140511,
0.0105207851,
0.1086496115,
0.0611138828,
0.3281852603,
-0.6062297225,
0.2245965451,
-0.0724709854,
0.2874029577,
0.274099499,
0.2567071021,
-0.1421192437,
0.3635742962,
0.0881391093,
-0.2379930913,
-0.2111133933,
0.4940515459,
0.4032609463,
-0.5179570913,
-0.2604885697,
-0.8770841956,
0.6653670669,
-0.1096079424,
-0.1456521302,
0.3554388583,
0.6386144757,
1.1666907072,
-0.0820848122,
0.5333812833,
0.0809988379,
-0.325722754,
-0.7627241015,
0.0969718173,
-0.5133864284,
0.1627432555,
-0.4539460242,
-0.8608978391,
-0.5285308361,
0.2939657867,
0.0769122839,
-0.2534374595,
0.7333614826,
1.2236930132,
-0.2206581533,
-0.2210868895,
0.2793027759,
0.1186187714,
0.3817492425,
0.4854822159,
0.829227984,
-0.5387288332,
1.3525009155,
-0.3621046543,
-0.1316354573,
-0.03756392,
-1.2426359653,
-0.6034060717,
-0.6804992557,
-0.9486793876,
-0.3961050808,
0.1041073129,
0.704826951,
0.4776737392,
-0.9316177368,
-0.3278118968,
-0.3765015304,
0.0640662313,
-0.4589907229,
-0.2132519931,
0.3402700722,
0.1034735441,
-0.8779454231,
0.2486965358,
0.2761258483,
0.3500044346,
-0.0805049464,
-0.3407714963,
-0.0570718162,
-0.0417564847,
0.0731240958,
0.6763800979,
-0.7038192749,
-0.2971852422,
0.2200446725,
-0.2739012241,
0.1176683828,
0.8852425218,
-0.3563814759,
0.6775456071,
0.678198576,
0.5846633315,
0.4297371507,
0.153140828,
0.6926345229,
-0.744571507,
0.0279305726,
-0.1366284192,
0.6292030215,
0.6772607565,
-0.015580439,
0.4379320145,
0.1516934484,
-0.3483787179,
-0.7387645841,
0.4845722914,
-1.2827919722,
-0.1719780862,
1.1162486076,
0.0851005465,
0.0161055252,
0.0914797485,
-0.2797381878,
0.5496326685,
-0.0965486467,
0.8532896638,
0.7084259391,
0.0449236296,
-0.4710635543,
-0.3485629857,
0.5473821163,
0.7197207808,
-0.6010172367,
0.2714052796,
0.5732245445,
0.279145211,
-0.037373744,
0.1570129097,
-0.2693751156,
0.7639382482,
-0.0780588016,
0.2922193706,
0.0569337942,
-0.4467409849,
-0.8052811623,
-0.0612001717,
0.0050249714,
-0.449747473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09335v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09335v2
|
Investigating Hallucinations in Pruned Large Language Models for Abstractive Summarization
| 2023-11-15T19:49:24 | 2024-01-29T17:59:30 |
George Chrysostomou, Zhixue Zhao, Miles Williams, Nikolaos Aletras
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the remarkable performance of generative large language models (LLMs)
on abstractive summarization, they face two significant challenges: their
considerable size and tendency to hallucinate. Hallucinations are concerning
because they erode reliability and raise safety issues. Pruning is a technique
that reduces model size by removing redundant weights, enabling more efficient
sparse inference. Pruned models yield downstream task performance comparable to
the original, making them ideal alternatives when operating on a limited
budget. However, the effect that pruning has upon hallucinations in abstractive
summarization with LLMs has yet to be explored. In this paper, we provide an
extensive empirical study across five summarization datasets, two
state-of-the-art pruning methods, and five instruction-tuned LLMs.
Surprisingly, we find that hallucinations from pruned LLMs are less prevalent
than the original models. Our analysis suggests that pruned models tend to
depend more on the source document for summary generation. This leads to a
higher lexical overlap between the generated summary and the source document,
which could be a reason for the reduction in hallucination risk.
|
[
-0.4168430567,
-0.7302798629,
0.6244305968,
0.17264615,
-0.6016759872,
-0.2782014608,
-0.3472643197,
-0.5546265841,
0.6546466947,
0.6628147364,
-0.5365721583,
-0.5747053623,
-0.5823639631,
0.3854943514,
-0.7531191111,
1.1526356936,
0.2085501552,
-0.1331613213,
-0.0436752327,
0.1157604456,
-0.523193717,
-0.9498666525,
-0.1941286474,
-0.1744332761,
0.5057615042,
0.0046028141,
0.9056286216,
0.519755125,
0.4441249967,
0.2347617596,
-0.3027683794,
0.2935226262,
-0.5681730509,
0.33725667,
0.2554145157,
-0.4075817764,
-0.3896322846,
-0.2480348796,
0.5311001539,
1.0346273184,
-0.2778368294,
-0.3293954432,
0.158238247,
0.5970132351,
-0.6371673942,
0.0051574442,
-0.6921185255,
0.1524917632,
0.1450339556,
-0.2723883688,
-0.3885413408,
-0.424957633,
0.1218873337,
-0.3832167685,
0.5319408774,
-0.1677078605,
0.7655377984,
0.3542266488,
-0.151386559,
-0.3768849373,
-0.8310936689,
0.6224998236,
-0.6916716695,
0.1013827249,
0.3319759965,
-0.0058859559,
-0.1527983844,
-0.7048861384,
-0.345059216,
-0.3532636166,
-0.3028773367,
-0.0489770323,
-0.0332974456,
0.2837159932,
0.2688756883,
0.4458809793,
-0.5259996057,
0.15260759,
-0.685403049,
-0.4036222398,
0.6552631259,
0.2813649774,
0.1680479348,
-0.2903651893,
0.050975062,
-0.0435090065,
-0.7763981819,
-0.6263408661,
0.5156274438,
0.1302105635,
0.2535429895,
0.7398989797,
0.1497056782,
0.6767358184,
-0.3373823166,
-0.2214742601,
0.1237040386,
-0.2362348139,
-0.2327708006,
0.3918763399,
0.5999848247,
0.6004719138,
0.625837326,
-0.4904381335,
-0.2514697909,
0.149460867,
0.6065289378,
-0.7444950938,
-0.5487507582,
0.3039957583,
-0.5678560734,
-0.3194184303,
0.1556492299,
-0.6336812973,
-0.4704568982,
-0.3805787861,
0.2640836835,
-0.4839927554,
-0.3735282719,
0.1354498714,
-0.2256121337,
0.1213232949,
0.4680330753,
-0.8492879868,
0.3109101951,
0.862555325,
1.1846777201,
-0.5040832162,
-0.3995855749,
-0.1675788462,
0.0342005007,
-0.6085122824,
0.733643055,
-0.3335152268,
-0.6474986672,
-0.0380313061,
0.1618626863,
-0.1349201351,
-0.874476254,
0.3916436136,
-0.1124427617,
-0.0631616861,
-0.2391785979,
-0.2871032059,
-0.4387258589,
0.0291184671,
-0.7687059641,
0.559949398,
-0.1367798448,
-0.7971305847,
0.1727823317,
0.0999121815,
-0.8670760989,
-0.1875589788,
-0.4209525883,
-0.5320070982,
0.8227077723,
0.1392885894,
0.5109394789,
0.0367901549,
0.4737092853,
-0.0075120209,
-0.7241313457,
0.2189417928,
-0.3834252656,
0.6337636113,
0.112634778,
-0.12867634,
0.3358798623,
-0.6369560361,
-0.4117114544,
0.1333516538,
0.114647992,
-0.4634099603,
0.0545820408,
-0.0305540394,
-0.0803354383,
-0.1209935918,
0.0156325866,
0.0727956891,
-0.686162293,
0.3288989961,
0.7610125542,
0.3657232523,
0.1377080828,
-0.670561552,
0.4640605152,
-0.0258985162,
-0.3272604048,
-0.3356380463,
-0.2273434848,
-0.7113229632,
-0.2861842513,
-0.0130467061,
0.2689764202,
-0.3169059753,
0.4669645727,
-0.224818185,
-0.2934533954,
-0.3535751104,
-0.2582128942,
0.1158677489,
0.1297538877,
0.1913509667,
-0.1634563804,
-0.5291482806,
-1.0992972851,
-0.1505217701,
-0.0629803911,
-0.3481459022,
0.0252386369,
0.7548585534,
-0.023512328,
0.6296241283,
-0.5497585535,
-0.5693872571,
-0.4717671871,
0.088696003,
0.0580369979,
0.3589209914,
0.3615852296,
-0.606121242,
-0.0094306096,
-0.183928445,
-0.8981394172,
0.0291943178,
-0.4747923315,
0.2865804136,
0.3782582283,
0.4514285922,
-0.9421403408,
0.5322483182,
0.3180014193,
0.0409289785,
1.0882700682,
-0.3629858494,
-0.0862030238,
-0.8931686878,
-0.0418979675,
-0.3200583756,
-0.0129826786,
-0.5345468521,
0.0166908577,
-0.2756214142,
-0.1231667921,
-0.0518557169,
-0.0567160696,
-0.7633533478,
-0.360150069,
-0.520688653,
0.2324805409,
-0.1080745608,
0.4113784432,
0.4547907114,
0.7258478403,
0.4458372593,
-0.8252425194,
-0.0258640982,
0.0521758348,
-0.5156655312,
-0.1982499212,
-0.6197712421,
0.0505617671,
-0.4253689945,
0.0938808993,
-0.7221503258,
-0.398550421,
0.0831206813,
-0.2662031353,
0.1728101671,
0.2525902689,
-0.4870775342,
0.0780785456,
-0.555350244,
0.0938982517,
0.50704813,
-0.3701863885,
0.5192326903,
0.46294415,
-0.3913272619,
-0.2612157464,
-0.8136542439,
0.2920336425,
-0.4105945528,
-0.4037962258,
0.5338135362,
0.2531706691,
-0.5836641788,
-0.0548463725,
-0.5204272866,
0.334104389,
0.1704034209,
0.4368084371,
0.1678735316,
-0.0385563448,
0.1731172949,
0.1156288385,
0.0373271592,
0.4657884836,
0.0767521113,
0.76771456,
0.0425047353,
-0.3184103072,
-0.3820475638,
0.360252738,
0.6259427071,
-0.0219292417,
1.0215650797,
0.035798952,
-0.532520771,
-0.3693937361,
-0.566020906,
-0.6557728648,
-0.3446957469,
0.618275106,
-0.4360370636,
-0.7171312571,
0.6268332005,
0.0494285487,
0.2793550491,
0.3333219886,
0.530857861,
0.0742775202,
0.9710860252,
0.4809706211,
0.0962781236,
0.1393013597,
-0.2487793565,
0.2625803947,
-0.7978863716,
-0.3081063032,
-0.5277376771,
-0.2348818183,
-0.429266274,
-0.3263469636,
0.2936833203,
0.0389091372,
0.4195106626,
-0.0306948572,
-0.7801643014,
0.5601724982,
0.1986130625,
0.0074369502,
0.5037794709,
0.3888646066,
0.3238427639,
-0.2327857763,
-0.5955632925,
-0.657394886,
0.9004472494,
0.3168466389,
0.7022858858,
0.0216110088,
0.7592274547,
0.0935186893,
0.1952592134,
-0.8470104933,
0.7041268945,
0.0975625962,
-0.3141103983,
-0.3666836023,
-0.4778886735,
-0.9011564255,
0.8239851594,
-0.1204586178,
-0.8979597688,
0.1697676331,
0.0205180999,
-0.3158512712,
0.2261995822,
-0.5521563292,
0.4563278258,
-0.1194269434,
-0.140772894,
-0.5007612705,
-0.372590065,
0.8480550647,
-0.1107415557,
0.1386956871,
0.1149053574,
0.0800718367,
0.9364684224,
-0.6424062848,
0.8243120909,
0.0976725444,
-0.180831641,
0.2034518123,
0.3175190091,
0.7395443916,
0.0138359657,
0.0910749659,
0.1794489175,
-0.0669821799,
-0.0413506404,
-0.4919746816,
0.8088063002,
-0.5599017143,
-0.9549023509,
-0.7071654201,
-0.6129359603,
-0.0450832546,
-0.1565120369,
0.4195487797,
0.2768036425,
-0.1221108139,
0.26332286,
0.7144945264,
-0.4244602323,
0.3505547941,
0.1064058617,
-0.4360074699,
-0.2596812844,
0.8688714504,
0.4023405015,
0.185400337,
-0.1384933144,
-0.0514010563,
0.1154346466,
-1.0393167734,
0.0689603686,
0.5787420869,
-0.6706812382,
0.0831739604,
-0.9283624291,
-0.5244342685,
-0.5125957131,
-0.1771601886,
-0.2130318433,
-0.5105045438,
-0.2635418177,
-0.4804601967,
0.274838537,
0.6461193562,
0.1856756359,
0.2223100811,
-0.5397768021,
0.4468991756,
-0.1241673157,
-0.0174909532,
0.3591632247,
-0.5608611703,
-0.0883411244,
-0.2027593255,
-0.0488519222,
-1.17674613,
0.7839656472,
-0.0192143228,
0.3556184471,
0.5822614431,
0.3095647991,
0.8224888444,
-0.2773604989,
0.676910758,
0.1458455175,
-0.4714211822,
0.1686957628,
-0.0799011812,
0.4343647957,
0.5546770096,
0.3092338443,
-0.3637375236,
-0.7879956365,
-0.464512378,
-1.0399081707,
0.5826196671,
0.3701363504,
0.0850387812,
-0.2187563777,
0.3762097061,
0.3591750562,
0.2719795108,
-0.7763211727,
-0.1033933088,
-0.0345856808,
0.0873453021,
-0.0596327521,
-0.4872787893,
-0.082370095,
-0.2741336823,
0.6490672231,
0.2360591888,
0.1196121126,
0.3326152265,
-0.3758051097,
0.0971977338,
0.0304637738,
0.7240406871,
0.902934432,
-0.2668786943,
0.3979846835,
0.2114420384,
-0.7155138254,
-0.1296249628,
-0.1221534833,
-0.3088116348,
0.3467300832,
0.7002723217,
0.8855597973,
0.2304759324,
-0.8664879203,
0.216058597,
-0.0464584306,
-0.4092998207,
-0.6645847559,
-0.0204797722,
0.0284137446,
-0.1413927823,
0.4359157383,
-0.0237050466,
0.2403495461,
-0.5413208008,
0.0159505717,
0.4475949407,
-0.1219072193,
-0.3133159578,
0.4736754596,
-0.004131394,
-0.3677246273,
0.8221682906,
0.0462074727,
-0.4353548288,
0.6395862699,
0.5730637312,
1.076659441,
0.0572181493,
0.138816759,
0.4467488229,
0.7774007916,
-0.2527323365,
-0.1782761812,
-0.1866365522,
-0.370289892,
-0.6011852026,
-0.7198033333,
-0.1590432227,
0.4965486825,
-0.5863517523,
0.1604443938,
-0.2780722678,
0.030041825,
-0.2450357676,
-0.3610562682,
0.0279263109,
-0.091773808,
-0.0726415068,
0.5006142259,
-0.8943279386,
0.6576504707,
0.3437154889,
-0.3094497919,
-0.5451211929,
0.375007689,
-0.101439476,
-0.2038795054,
0.209682554,
0.5563304424,
-0.177197367,
-0.0665985048,
-0.1266036779,
-0.5081868172,
0.7789616585,
0.3603981137,
-0.8178569078,
-0.45339185,
0.0328382552,
0.5073538423,
-0.1730511039,
-0.1184720024,
0.8035154939,
0.2824617028,
0.2175056636,
-0.69952178,
0.1682790965,
-0.1123919785,
-0.0863134563,
0.375215292,
-0.2662747502,
0.7608170509,
-0.4750231206,
-0.5270909667,
-0.0491487011,
0.6836857796,
0.5082662106,
0.2220119536,
0.4445865154,
0.3960424066,
0.7014856935,
0.0375690982,
1.0153124332,
-0.2564952075,
-0.1159991995,
1.1056836843,
-0.3692812622,
0.5410155654,
0.8116970062,
-0.0015358601,
0.0910560116,
0.5705925226,
-0.0492296256,
0.4544826448,
0.3918599486,
-0.0892054439,
-0.1695424169,
0.1477880478,
-0.5711815357,
0.070564732,
0.4895846248,
-0.4681824744,
-0.1940418333,
0.2631724477,
0.1375377327,
0.1362179965,
-0.2619280517,
0.9780881405,
0.3126991689,
-0.9082589746,
0.6944856644,
-0.0549520962,
0.5634331107,
-0.457236588,
-0.1068381295,
-0.3259788454,
0.0902433321,
-0.3179684877,
-0.2889766395,
0.8087496758,
0.0007331545,
-0.015554809,
-0.0421221256,
0.6802203655,
-0.2003313899,
-0.5181642175,
0.287532717,
0.2911616862,
0.6426334977,
-0.4229834378,
0.0594855584,
0.2540056705,
0.122031711,
-0.4554595053,
0.5464953184,
0.3631911874,
-0.3127526641,
0.5632444024,
0.4165681005,
0.5188829899,
0.0000117333,
0.155531615,
0.8174746633,
-0.7390248179,
-0.4677207172,
-1.0676426888,
0.2849548757,
-0.1194068566,
-0.0779611766,
0.8975042105,
0.7853549719,
0.5993651748,
-0.2864711583,
0.7342098951,
0.1444309205,
0.1688949168,
-0.5993170738,
0.8846092224,
-0.4073826671,
0.5508468151,
-0.149338752,
-1.2211723328,
-0.3548549414,
0.901258111,
-0.3462860882,
0.059636008,
0.8577384949,
0.9667664766,
0.2183892131,
0.0067985752,
0.3996600211,
0.4332555234,
-0.0129311681,
0.2926225662,
0.7910379767,
0.0000317596,
0.5738669634,
-0.4682644606,
-0.0732450262,
-0.3186843991,
-0.5753711462,
-1.1044664383,
-0.6490095258,
-0.3639144301,
-0.2213668227,
0.2180669904,
0.6631966233,
0.2797560096,
-0.7829850316,
-0.3194898963,
-0.3600995243,
0.2035247087,
-0.3307366073,
-0.2666410804,
0.6556386948,
-0.2211296856,
-0.5927301645,
0.1522755325,
0.2973861694,
0.1584145874,
-0.3927858472,
-0.0238790624,
0.0519480519,
-0.0036985015,
0.5475326777,
-0.0734966174,
-1.0398843288,
-0.0012540244,
-0.0449497625,
0.0910510868,
-0.1345409155,
0.9115946889,
-0.8379085064,
0.1653895378,
0.3835646808,
0.2976438701,
0.5707589984,
0.1722841412,
0.6382208467,
-0.6065408587,
0.3661626279,
0.4721448421,
0.2102947682,
0.1912102997,
-0.2320991606,
0.3203066587,
0.0865981057,
-0.3373624384,
-1.4165221453,
0.0734090582,
-0.6576652527,
-0.798954308,
1.0104266405,
0.2925080657,
-0.2674752474,
-0.0057872101,
-0.3988285065,
0.1414963305,
0.0264081974,
1.2616702318,
0.8540815115,
-0.0319623873,
-0.3286991119,
-0.5696146488,
0.6342011094,
0.5002746582,
-0.6731719971,
0.6157854795,
0.8419885039,
-0.1211884096,
0.227024287,
0.4377670288,
-0.0789777488,
0.2524899542,
0.1030811667,
0.0572492853,
-0.2769034207,
-0.6366709471,
-0.5017565489,
0.5850724578,
0.1255661696,
0.1405905634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09325v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09325v2
|
Temperature-scaling surprisal estimates improve fit to human reading times -- but does it do so for the "right reasons"?
| 2023-11-15T19:34:06 | 2024-07-03T16:12:32 |
Tong Liu, Iza Škrjanec, Vera Demberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
A wide body of evidence shows that human language processing difficulty is
predicted by the information-theoretic measure surprisal, a word's negative log
probability in context. However, it is still unclear how to best estimate these
probabilities needed for predicting human processing difficulty -- while a
long-standing belief held that models with lower perplexity would provide more
accurate estimates of word predictability, and therefore lead to better reading
time predictions, recent work has shown that for very large models,
psycholinguistic predictive power decreases. One reason could be that language
models might be more confident of their predictions than humans, because they
have had exposure to several magnitudes more data. In this paper, we test what
effect temperature-scaling of large language model (LLM) predictions has on
surprisal estimates and their predictive power of reading times of English
texts. Firstly, we show that calibration of large language models typically
improves with model size, i.e. poorer calibration cannot account for poorer fit
to reading times. Secondly, we find that temperature-scaling probabilities lead
to a systematically better fit to reading times (up to 89% improvement in delta
log likelihood), across several reading time corpora. Finally, we show that
this improvement in fit is chiefly driven by words that are composed of
multiple subword tokens.
|
[
-0.497572571,
-0.514254868,
0.5438341498,
0.1719017625,
-0.5115510821,
-0.0407454632,
-0.4209489822,
-0.6763707995,
0.0668740645,
0.1910055876,
-0.4224535823,
-0.1416547149,
-0.6136240959,
0.2725972831,
-0.1697672009,
0.6803841591,
0.3972918987,
0.0699031129,
-0.1490602344,
0.1896983832,
-0.2584146857,
-0.7226001024,
-0.3132457435,
-0.725628674,
0.6422153115,
0.2320457995,
1.2621811628,
0.8296869397,
0.7244105339,
0.193052277,
-0.2090532184,
-0.2352490723,
-0.2264588475,
0.2421152294,
-0.0286139846,
-0.7524648905,
-0.3693712354,
0.0020662306,
0.5075311065,
0.7513390183,
-0.2412494123,
0.0342469625,
0.0638002008,
0.8444834352,
-0.6758822203,
-0.0184003878,
-0.4024979174,
-0.2052614093,
-0.4149277806,
-0.2467141896,
-0.5745186806,
-0.1676582843,
0.2707538307,
-0.3828670382,
0.5171532631,
0.3398354053,
0.5137665868,
0.3057146668,
-0.4330945313,
-0.0667443573,
-0.740706861,
0.9524286389,
-1.0213278532,
0.6954598427,
0.6832538843,
0.0644983798,
-0.0188090988,
-0.2829414606,
-0.6498607993,
-0.4630177021,
-0.0237386394,
-0.148627758,
-0.2231083661,
0.1611626297,
0.4314697385,
0.1758670807,
-0.5513061881,
0.3168472946,
-0.4795012772,
-0.155685991,
0.7272693515,
0.3165172935,
0.2509475946,
-0.1260659099,
-0.0006586861,
-0.0181257259,
-0.575001955,
-0.051811479,
0.3324942887,
0.4593482912,
0.1494562328,
0.471408397,
0.00732328,
0.6947492957,
-0.3464004099,
-0.1973437518,
0.177780509,
-0.2717682719,
-0.1428245306,
0.1066135094,
0.4081089497,
0.5463341475,
0.3832541704,
-0.2485210449,
0.1752944142,
0.1494382918,
-0.0012916044,
-0.9280965924,
-0.4326148033,
0.1544376761,
-0.173581481,
0.0061953277,
-0.0502865352,
-0.6473906636,
-0.646564424,
-0.3502742648,
0.119772613,
-0.5318119526,
-0.3277465403,
0.4906632006,
-0.247777462,
0.0950663909,
0.1757728755,
-0.9961964488,
0.3676380515,
0.6085367203,
0.8686897159,
-0.2912664115,
-0.2024825513,
-0.1743693501,
0.0209272373,
-0.5357738733,
0.9053142071,
-0.8675640225,
-0.3218290806,
-0.3907785416,
-0.2613318563,
-0.1919225901,
-0.276840359,
0.3312290609,
-0.4949190319,
0.0781980231,
-0.6155574918,
-0.533057034,
0.0923254192,
-0.022446027,
-0.58644104,
0.7662799954,
-0.3663287759,
-1.0112600327,
0.5063433051,
-0.4790837169,
-0.5529155731,
0.0546598136,
0.3414809704,
-0.2037138343,
0.3350275457,
0.4251660705,
0.5003682971,
-0.5968772769,
-0.2059506029,
-0.4736144841,
-0.3145536184,
0.7189266682,
-0.6561692357,
0.446573019,
0.1588460505,
-0.2892519534,
-0.3244082034,
-0.4212583005,
0.1804597676,
-0.0423717313,
-0.3848838806,
-0.5858892202,
0.1489481479,
-0.0936086476,
-0.1328789741,
0.1641649157,
-0.7618601918,
0.2033486813,
-0.5203176737,
0.2985340655,
0.658659935,
-0.035475798,
0.2550906837,
-0.3500395417,
0.751234889,
-0.2087068111,
-0.136644423,
0.0696883425,
-0.3831671476,
-0.4316072166,
-0.2734180689,
0.4453140795,
0.6716489792,
-0.4637379646,
-0.0253851376,
-0.22315979,
-1.0148580074,
-0.327591747,
0.1109237894,
0.5995275378,
0.3923454285,
0.3738062382,
-0.0513889268,
-0.2793121934,
-0.7253319621,
-0.6692051888,
-0.2908135951,
-0.2909000218,
0.3243584037,
0.2711867094,
-0.130738467,
0.5581002235,
-0.777984798,
-0.0202122424,
-0.5316462517,
0.0963260755,
0.3270947933,
0.1768877357,
0.3897404969,
-0.8552607894,
-0.377124697,
-0.198198244,
-0.3690694869,
-0.2505702376,
0.2504458725,
0.2478801757,
0.5667554736,
0.4695296288,
-0.4519978762,
0.3895146251,
0.5773233175,
-0.4186657965,
0.766514957,
-0.5194365978,
0.0673451647,
-1.0130898952,
-0.1926780045,
0.3882364631,
0.1223554313,
-0.7640906572,
-0.051313296,
0.1395753622,
0.1929704845,
-0.367387712,
0.4585745335,
-0.4358665049,
-0.1034166887,
-0.0995473564,
0.0999700949,
-0.0747073814,
0.1478373259,
0.103966184,
0.8615003228,
0.3757751584,
-0.7542264462,
0.2953729331,
-0.2828656733,
-0.4025206864,
0.2459026128,
-0.6294301152,
0.1060051695,
-0.1246865094,
0.2316127568,
-1.190933466,
-0.2958833873,
-0.4845021367,
-0.3705420494,
0.3095255792,
0.4701789618,
-0.6599888802,
-0.2270373851,
-0.1360153556,
0.4636336863,
0.4231550395,
-0.303632617,
0.5172884464,
0.3886833191,
-0.3471648991,
-0.5338695645,
-0.9216920733,
0.0050879698,
-0.223920539,
-0.404304266,
0.3112390339,
-0.2882995009,
-0.5145947337,
-0.1942263842,
-0.0968188643,
0.0801275149,
0.0508670025,
0.1549918801,
0.3208542168,
-0.1012618914,
0.5300731063,
-0.2114291638,
-0.1508202255,
0.0234843194,
0.0806502029,
0.762077868,
-0.349919945,
-0.0409917086,
-0.3731634319,
-0.0255624168,
0.6442860961,
-0.0944747329,
0.8785259128,
0.2360378355,
-0.4309725165,
0.3428533673,
-0.6864455938,
-0.2983445525,
-0.4532910585,
0.3643986583,
-0.5007023811,
-0.5171070695,
0.5333597064,
0.2812624276,
0.0457407273,
0.5180330873,
0.4392335415,
-0.2208635658,
1.2438869476,
0.7183225155,
-0.0140384305,
0.4604544938,
0.0669704899,
0.1059125438,
-0.8548040986,
-0.2051196247,
-0.6725572944,
-0.3523527682,
-0.7568627,
-0.2282070667,
0.3303490579,
-0.201492101,
-0.0586449504,
0.3105657101,
-0.3467122316,
0.6976544261,
0.4058083296,
0.1040394083,
0.213896215,
-0.0112820193,
-0.1681644768,
-0.5543528199,
-0.6429908872,
-0.2419104874,
1.0872780085,
0.4931385219,
0.8864813447,
0.232883513,
0.2823182046,
0.2323465198,
0.4500119686,
-0.7234053016,
0.4896139801,
-0.5408219099,
-0.9203147292,
-0.6322953105,
-0.4464499056,
-0.9798223972,
0.2219362557,
-0.1230324581,
-0.7996146083,
0.1572980285,
0.1886837631,
-0.3339232504,
0.4349261224,
-0.8815659285,
0.4401757121,
-0.1532207131,
-0.0831807628,
-0.3949436843,
-0.4695928991,
0.1217043251,
-0.2242486328,
0.552319169,
-0.2137181312,
-0.3005023003,
0.9431834221,
-0.3783485293,
0.7705664039,
-0.0144639788,
-0.0849674866,
-0.0787670463,
0.2893134952,
0.2090451866,
-0.0832282975,
-0.5333178639,
0.1520167738,
0.4621037841,
-0.6287443638,
-0.5844083428,
0.3641987145,
-0.8117614985,
-0.7777286768,
-0.5207336545,
-0.7878978848,
-0.3606556952,
-0.00177416,
0.6203249693,
0.6267871261,
0.1052403748,
0.5341234207,
0.6966857314,
-0.042186141,
0.3484236002,
0.6170068979,
-0.2756925225,
-0.1257177293,
0.7186589837,
0.6931066513,
0.5336710215,
0.4542106092,
0.4953262806,
-0.3788905442,
-0.4623366296,
0.0397261158,
0.4139668345,
-0.3953980207,
0.0302449819,
-0.405770272,
-0.070597209,
-0.608630538,
-0.1849274337,
-0.1141560674,
-0.3725986481,
-0.3403222859,
-0.2115949988,
0.4751132727,
0.5321648121,
-0.1608379185,
0.3004670143,
-0.4924462438,
0.1809604913,
0.1170785278,
0.1826449484,
-0.2576794922,
-0.9700776935,
-0.1288247108,
-0.1402920336,
0.1633923203,
-0.8982118368,
0.5778313279,
0.4056385458,
0.1705328673,
0.2290189117,
0.35420084,
0.623781383,
-0.2346016914,
0.7862777114,
0.1515313536,
-0.8341690898,
0.2897922695,
-0.0961790681,
0.8211336136,
0.2788767517,
0.3856036663,
-0.6416369677,
-0.6176048517,
-0.6370218396,
-0.8344538808,
0.4515478313,
-0.0973449871,
0.3088879287,
0.0447703972,
0.5904468298,
0.2127975821,
-0.0463555492,
-0.3404229283,
-0.073664926,
0.1311564147,
0.2448329926,
-0.8052908778,
-0.5670730472,
0.3138544858,
-0.4179677665,
0.7534781098,
-0.121886611,
0.1670761257,
0.0685241744,
0.1372418255,
-0.2600598037,
0.4310293198,
0.7989743352,
0.8268520236,
-0.5654370189,
0.3044583201,
0.5927666426,
-0.8467405438,
-0.0276821963,
0.1011716649,
0.2666552961,
-0.0881845132,
0.8406062126,
0.5913345218,
-0.0146131814,
-0.5827094316,
0.1532173604,
-0.4098806083,
-0.086453937,
-0.3022507727,
0.2364770919,
0.1222747415,
0.2550322711,
0.5995748043,
0.0594285354,
-0.0386654809,
-0.5111462474,
-0.0148214195,
0.3670431674,
-0.1122590825,
-0.377933383,
0.4648008943,
-0.0957921892,
-0.411536932,
0.6344378591,
0.1052938476,
-0.6814337373,
0.7657532096,
0.7382631302,
0.5143163204,
-0.4596319497,
0.0297666546,
0.1953010708,
0.6134387851,
-0.0944145769,
0.3314077258,
0.1673601419,
-0.741183579,
-0.3566047549,
-0.7540917397,
-0.4769314826,
0.1007646397,
-0.6870415211,
-0.0755963176,
-0.429674089,
-0.4603120387,
0.1015072986,
0.4534167647,
-0.6903069615,
0.5768895149,
-0.014529272,
1.0235240459,
-0.9844849706,
0.8811979294,
0.3736690879,
-0.0890507475,
-0.8765842319,
0.3370764852,
-0.1223934591,
-0.5091688633,
0.5677657723,
0.2354910523,
-0.2229765803,
0.0158692673,
-0.2470176965,
-1.0069732666,
0.9322539568,
0.8070660233,
-0.8993623853,
-0.1423440129,
0.1139812022,
0.9214834571,
-0.2130522281,
0.1660287678,
0.848528266,
0.3668681681,
0.1300314665,
-1.0405026674,
0.008122378,
-0.1040007621,
0.051534567,
0.3760138452,
-0.3992935717,
0.7591547966,
-0.6014305949,
-0.2282654643,
-0.1695257127,
0.7602918744,
-0.009522099,
0.4056114554,
0.598013103,
0.5654204488,
0.9288630486,
0.0145904589,
1.4923125505,
-0.3540214896,
0.1657546908,
0.8425193429,
-0.0084439795,
1.2018575668,
0.5271036625,
-0.4186348617,
0.4726157784,
0.84979707,
0.3958488107,
0.4684020877,
0.091974698,
-0.1407297999,
-0.5963317752,
-0.2620343268,
-0.5218279958,
0.1681526452,
0.6113311648,
-0.337038219,
0.0285053309,
0.1512672305,
0.009963762,
0.0222035032,
-0.2661471367,
0.4452349544,
0.1740151644,
-0.5683223009,
0.6894800067,
-0.0301795807,
0.5611281991,
-0.2773733139,
0.6110093594,
-0.1762661487,
0.3405394852,
-0.202421546,
-0.969717145,
0.3479169905,
-0.0044919946,
-0.1596835256,
-0.0047431248,
0.6774059534,
-0.1305598617,
-0.6779617071,
0.2508555651,
0.320689708,
0.4613400996,
-0.03337235,
-0.456415236,
0.1113542691,
-0.2260177135,
-0.6152229905,
0.3840013444,
0.1610045582,
0.0957988799,
0.7918652892,
0.6126306653,
0.2313145399,
0.0243448727,
-0.1557617933,
0.4550147951,
-0.528473556,
-0.273663342,
-1.2366490364,
0.0777793676,
0.2064611018,
-0.3936673105,
0.526337862,
0.4284839332,
0.4360612929,
0.2065830976,
0.6771463752,
0.17901209,
0.5239434838,
-0.5714159012,
0.5139802098,
-0.5396025181,
0.3306792974,
-0.2724380791,
-1.0529731512,
-0.5158098936,
0.2895708382,
-0.9609259963,
0.0445230231,
0.7521461844,
0.8107591867,
0.1147038192,
-0.0228077769,
0.6191993952,
0.2623571157,
0.3027329445,
0.4254074395,
0.244104594,
-0.1054686233,
0.4491673708,
-0.4082407355,
-0.3111510873,
-0.3103949428,
-0.9231857657,
-0.9867236614,
-0.7316175103,
-0.3226976395,
-0.5904823542,
0.1097235158,
0.8589835167,
0.4154814184,
-0.481788069,
-0.0834047794,
-0.0347576328,
-0.0704253912,
-0.2494179606,
-0.196889922,
0.4889626801,
-0.2198990881,
-0.490765214,
0.0674286783,
0.2546517253,
-0.0520189628,
-0.1793946028,
-0.0208597872,
0.0415293835,
0.8184748888,
0.2916927636,
0.3315314651,
-0.7323529124,
-0.2764655054,
0.1564247459,
-0.3760880828,
-0.1648917496,
0.4201635718,
-0.6449002624,
0.5681207776,
0.6214568615,
0.4951480031,
0.4800843894,
-0.1382061094,
0.5673772097,
-0.5338336825,
-0.0513787456,
0.0377293304,
0.2663736641,
0.3819184005,
-0.5565532446,
0.3463739455,
0.121768117,
-0.556398809,
-1.0205081701,
0.3853798509,
-0.3705606759,
-0.4126837552,
1.1885453463,
-0.0083722295,
-0.4903613031,
0.0451411717,
-0.2192419022,
0.1697814614,
-0.3589301705,
1.1081979275,
1.0673937798,
-0.3971231878,
-0.3928483725,
-0.5885234475,
0.3897607028,
0.770998776,
-0.5779907703,
0.5070154071,
0.1478117704,
0.2645541131,
0.3853556216,
0.4033710659,
0.3505167961,
0.3104446828,
-0.2335909158,
-0.4228717387,
0.0844709054,
-0.2571921647,
-0.2813777924,
0.2057212591,
0.1839793175,
0.3160192668
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09319v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09319v2
|
Spoken Word2Vec: Learning Skipgram Embeddings from Speech
| 2023-11-15T19:25:29 | 2024-07-01T21:08:18 |
Mohammad Amaan Sayeed, Hanan Aldarmaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Text word embeddings that encode distributional semantics work by modeling
contextual similarities of frequently occurring words. Acoustic word
embeddings, on the other hand, typically encode low-level phonetic
similarities. Semantic embeddings for spoken words have been previously
explored using analogous algorithms to Word2Vec, but the resulting vectors
still mainly encoded phonetic rather than semantic features. In this paper, we
examine the assumptions and architectures used in previous works and show
experimentally how shallow skipgram-like algorithms fail to encode
distributional semantics when the input units are acoustically correlated. We
illustrate the potential of an alternative deep end-to-end variant of the model
and examine the effects on the resulting embeddings, showing positive results
of semantic relatedness in the embedding space.
|
[
-0.1676315665,
-0.6579230428,
0.562708497,
0.141838342,
-0.2375322431,
-0.120329082,
-0.1013468727,
-0.4922445714,
0.2442790568,
0.399949342,
-0.5595516562,
-0.6400059462,
-0.6452795863,
-0.2221383005,
-0.3913510144,
0.4470008314,
0.0751661584,
0.2603259087,
-0.3699361384,
-0.3489944339,
-0.8374196887,
-0.2841804326,
-0.45987764,
-0.4571284652,
0.2461882681,
0.4165802896,
0.8354088664,
0.5626916885,
0.0845152438,
0.1342014521,
-0.4021687508,
-0.1917627305,
-0.6768272519,
0.3926431239,
0.0273235906,
-0.5053036213,
0.0703995004,
0.1684583575,
0.4897398055,
1.0745716095,
-0.3248313367,
-0.2854345441,
0.1272086203,
0.3475409746,
-0.5239500403,
0.204039216,
-0.5648316145,
0.0927241966,
0.1520160288,
-0.3064877987,
-0.4788685143,
-0.1580987126,
0.3932732046,
-0.5373985767,
-0.1018456742,
-0.0991819203,
0.4737042487,
0.265706569,
-0.3519009352,
-1.0624065399,
-0.8451693058,
0.7966593504,
-0.4702703059,
0.8342157006,
0.8340125084,
-0.0760389119,
-0.0300247334,
-0.6261960268,
-0.4813346267,
-0.2260952145,
0.1379241794,
0.5105886459,
-0.2384349704,
0.0647246987,
-0.1876092702,
-0.0796109959,
-0.5747231245,
0.2140344381,
-0.2920128703,
-0.0184170268,
0.294954896,
0.0073552178,
0.2904212773,
-0.181998536,
-0.3872492611,
-0.3422467113,
-0.6910475492,
-0.1959807724,
0.5580316186,
0.2273673862,
-0.4357554018,
0.7416906357,
0.1681903899,
0.6123708487,
-0.3395459056,
0.0245407801,
0.5811145306,
-0.4122619927,
0.0758658424,
0.4672349393,
0.3905120492,
0.208032161,
0.4869656563,
-0.2504932284,
-0.0172280055,
0.1539708525,
-0.1262278259,
-0.2864216864,
-0.0821333751,
0.2229031324,
-0.5220195055,
-0.1152338907,
-0.106222339,
-0.3273826838,
-0.096800074,
-0.3294305503,
0.4468220174,
-0.7327347994,
-0.0262153763,
0.0727690682,
-0.6563046575,
0.537304759,
-0.0783460438,
-0.8731178641,
0.5811168551,
0.7389571667,
0.9785405993,
0.2003253251,
-0.3301467597,
-0.4405856431,
0.2167418003,
-0.739885807,
0.7172933221,
-1.0419822931,
-0.8458994627,
0.2777624428,
-0.2037656605,
0.1601909846,
-0.64575243,
0.4125177264,
-0.3869349957,
0.0957040861,
-0.3433517218,
-0.943523705,
-0.0709325522,
-0.1887670755,
-0.4924747646,
0.7498962283,
0.0831416249,
-0.8187354207,
0.4277092516,
-0.0681435615,
-0.4782786369,
-0.1957546473,
-0.2899708748,
-0.0430917069,
0.2091800421,
-0.0887414813,
0.4549821913,
0.0151988231,
-0.4036670625,
-0.5250223875,
-0.5631664395,
0.2419540584,
-0.3963053226,
0.6090846658,
0.171032548,
-0.0373510793,
-0.3470241427,
-0.6226960421,
-0.3018120527,
0.1765955985,
-0.1811051369,
-0.9445983171,
0.2695979178,
-0.0195092447,
0.0990668312,
0.0289844889,
-0.5754821301,
-0.1634925455,
-0.7064915299,
0.5115131736,
0.4309215248,
0.0974598676,
0.7213438153,
-0.0654431656,
0.1651584059,
0.0098774312,
-0.3127763867,
-0.2473670542,
-0.7339131832,
-0.3841281831,
-0.2926278412,
0.3169291019,
0.8425530791,
-0.5814854503,
0.3843999505,
-0.3613749146,
-0.0818069875,
-0.6291553378,
0.0927719846,
0.2968902886,
0.2955698967,
0.2928861976,
-0.3440312743,
-0.3881781101,
-0.7478573918,
-0.1732295752,
-0.2302943319,
-0.057405524,
0.6773263216,
0.1805225015,
-0.2799396813,
0.9075313807,
-0.3748542368,
-0.552831471,
-0.1953771859,
0.0397163667,
-0.0345549658,
0.3301844001,
0.4193176031,
-0.3904784322,
-0.1357752383,
-0.0340536982,
-0.7098124027,
0.0577119999,
0.0264709219,
0.1649062485,
-0.133077845,
0.769184351,
-0.3983843923,
0.616009295,
0.6946499944,
-0.2293535024,
-0.1340705752,
-0.4150007069,
-0.2782574892,
-1.0959880352,
-0.6361240149,
-0.3994160295,
-0.1391502023,
-0.5466898084,
-0.3586851656,
-0.3566214144,
-0.1421733052,
-0.5295540094,
0.6276812553,
-0.4893712401,
-0.5677534938,
-0.3223911822,
0.4767510891,
-0.1868442893,
0.1558977216,
0.3198858798,
0.5612787604,
0.7112050653,
-0.6593260169,
0.4078778923,
0.5380330086,
-0.0505432002,
0.5098785162,
-0.6985152364,
0.2892586887,
-0.2417717129,
0.4455294907,
-1.1637669802,
-0.0437291749,
0.0016195913,
-0.7731812,
0.3682954907,
-0.1565300226,
-0.381098628,
-0.0044812807,
-0.3465832174,
0.474673897,
1.0415619612,
-0.7451761961,
0.3852114975,
0.5402976871,
-0.0232170597,
-0.3338814974,
-1.1689295769,
-0.1781059355,
0.071976997,
-0.5924513936,
0.2459302694,
0.4140529633,
-0.3190530539,
0.2148027718,
0.243912369,
0.0232120492,
-0.1374009848,
0.4048670232,
-0.1903796941,
-0.074527137,
0.4110832512,
0.2013856173,
-0.0450277217,
-0.1339692771,
-0.6409763098,
0.5985996127,
0.3313936591,
-0.4051550627,
-0.3309731185,
0.6277909279,
-0.0197752342,
0.228718251,
0.7732046843,
0.6193483472,
-0.541883111,
-0.2974047959,
-0.1245228499,
-0.1749758571,
-0.414791733,
0.4601934552,
-0.4024420381,
-0.9381002188,
0.4765693843,
-0.1963315457,
-0.0583634079,
0.3149946034,
0.5631871223,
-0.4875397086,
0.5037629008,
0.3886499107,
0.105662711,
0.3173183501,
-0.28048262,
0.0696416721,
-0.8838174939,
-0.4104191065,
-0.5855625272,
-0.1160264388,
-0.8712717891,
-0.9399778843,
-0.0596738346,
0.086806789,
0.0682388842,
0.4238188565,
-0.1385568082,
0.2336255014,
0.5622589588,
-0.1754508168,
-0.1190948486,
0.1526221037,
-0.3571843803,
-0.0320526622,
-0.6870456934,
-0.1529219449,
0.8271590471,
0.5661560297,
0.9713937044,
0.118957594,
0.9846097231,
0.4272392094,
-0.4741672873,
-1.0567810535,
0.2385109067,
-0.4348059297,
-0.1235510483,
-0.4103535712,
-0.2148311883,
-1.0576497316,
0.0893053487,
0.0075409226,
-0.7495574355,
0.7168638706,
0.0504411533,
0.1295839101,
-0.0435448475,
-0.7626086473,
0.5022861362,
0.337025553,
-0.0876505226,
-0.5401938558,
-0.4772280753,
-0.0048553189,
0.1549343467,
0.4854881465,
0.0520386249,
-0.256662786,
0.8912732005,
-0.4643867016,
0.8357023001,
-0.1799835861,
-0.2496278882,
0.656109333,
0.1574097574,
0.5666710734,
-0.0961750075,
0.1394195557,
0.4717294276,
-0.2130430937,
-0.4527632594,
-0.4973373711,
0.8308605552,
-0.7232810855,
-0.0490201041,
-0.2262019217,
-0.0520341843,
-0.4526147246,
-0.2813296318,
0.3744458854,
0.683968842,
-0.5767301917,
0.0984313488,
0.7001568675,
-0.5155463219,
0.4876329601,
-0.0433328673,
0.1348417699,
-0.3423847258,
1.0434205532,
0.1681162864,
0.1731238216,
0.6336142421,
0.1624242663,
-0.4840124547,
-0.3504498303,
-0.2225737423,
0.2112962455,
-1.0992288589,
0.3708341122,
-0.7110514045,
-0.2161414474,
-0.6188766956,
-0.3031635284,
-0.5344612002,
-0.4563149214,
-0.6108355522,
-0.3858087063,
0.3243602514,
1.0175552368,
-0.4512614906,
0.2237070799,
-0.64877671,
0.2453730106,
0.6736362576,
0.3075305223,
0.0833130628,
-0.7705519795,
-0.0958676636,
0.0045982595,
0.1617465168,
-1.0705127716,
0.2698776424,
0.4468167126,
0.4458884597,
0.349249959,
-0.2326473445,
0.5475844145,
-0.8272995353,
0.8938509226,
0.211950615,
-1.0445655584,
0.5783765912,
-0.1292604208,
0.1878574789,
0.306191802,
0.366622746,
-0.6011798382,
-0.2849804461,
-0.5481705666,
-0.9292063117,
0.4532807767,
0.4043007493,
0.5676810145,
-0.4293330014,
0.1103241742,
0.2306355834,
-0.2183593661,
-0.0100028664,
-0.2824673951,
-0.4546425343,
-0.3182168603,
-0.2053530812,
-0.6725019813,
0.0543951169,
0.2447132915,
0.3646606207,
0.1768970788,
0.6085864305,
0.2761523128,
-0.1802041084,
0.3898287714,
0.2644880414,
0.6704419851,
0.0834332407,
-0.0870976746,
0.3171140552,
0.3377312124,
-0.6701413393,
-0.0379680283,
-0.0904203355,
0.0576261915,
0.3249278367,
0.9377987981,
1.0678184032,
0.4461139143,
-0.5403808951,
0.7994293571,
-0.0355129279,
-0.3523876369,
-0.6206193566,
-0.1885236055,
0.5518266559,
0.117590867,
-0.0603421032,
-0.1653697193,
0.3408723772,
-0.7080076337,
0.4349884987,
0.5185666084,
-0.9437550902,
-0.3182488084,
0.3874276578,
0.239823103,
-0.3820869029,
0.7115628719,
0.0633457154,
-0.1918311715,
0.3385770917,
0.4254225492,
0.9280961156,
-0.1680201739,
0.0077046538,
0.1606132537,
0.2992619276,
0.1020012647,
0.3758638799,
-0.4037315845,
-0.749756813,
-0.2476417571,
-0.5823246241,
-0.2873603106,
-0.317700237,
-0.649844408,
0.1105892137,
-0.3648537099,
0.0678493679,
-0.2058673501,
-0.5254292488,
-1.0391722918,
0.0160496514,
0.5788277388,
0.766613543,
-0.9750072956,
0.830966115,
0.4099538922,
-0.2007102966,
-1.0602953434,
0.1368920058,
-0.1656486094,
-1.0274523497,
0.8680536151,
-0.0845025629,
-0.262250036,
-0.0558666214,
-0.3152807355,
-1.0151028633,
0.9899435043,
-0.0882447585,
-0.6650335789,
0.0431155451,
0.2231096029,
0.4162572324,
-0.4489306808,
0.4280191958,
0.5584779382,
0.1544080675,
0.4569383562,
-0.8180466294,
-0.1655577719,
0.2610117495,
0.2175758928,
-0.388784498,
-0.2802814245,
0.6040961146,
-0.1610295027,
-0.2087804228,
-0.0409203805,
0.8393294215,
0.0177297518,
0.3346816301,
0.3304173946,
0.7790260911,
0.5248513222,
0.0536382794,
1.203627944,
-0.003402258,
0.3055510223,
1.1399888992,
-0.4871904552,
1.0521799326,
0.3595972955,
-0.2261534482,
0.5722174644,
0.600734055,
0.2845620811,
0.9580383897,
0.1713979542,
-0.1670963913,
-0.0072045405,
-0.2463409007,
-0.4021089673,
0.8352214098,
0.7237597704,
-0.5117893219,
-0.0315788537,
0.1622455716,
-0.3457895219,
-0.0738558695,
-0.1061856151,
1.1938322783,
0.5451689959,
-0.0945396423,
0.5826474428,
-0.1614535451,
0.7177838683,
-0.4486840963,
-0.3214628398,
-0.1711793542,
-0.0898260698,
0.0082990108,
-0.8175213933,
0.4091173112,
-0.4254861176,
0.017964432,
0.0093661267,
0.646825552,
-0.4788279533,
-0.0990435109,
0.8315790296,
0.5082373619,
0.4455730021,
0.504919827,
-0.4462003708,
0.1372703612,
-0.2750349939,
-0.2066572458,
0.1792674661,
0.4377861321,
0.1086465791,
0.5531356931,
0.5525156856,
0.3650388718,
0.2109593749,
0.4599911571,
0.5389972925,
-0.6492841244,
-0.8762357235,
-0.6674042344,
0.0090553071,
0.1705684215,
-0.1339832246,
0.3766949773,
0.3613266051,
1.0034550428,
-0.0252851937,
0.776098609,
0.2982834578,
0.5110616684,
-0.802041173,
0.3793179095,
-0.4572557807,
0.2698946595,
-0.3010308743,
-1.0195124149,
0.0401005261,
0.8231735826,
0.053459473,
0.0299911648,
0.8102885485,
0.5987293124,
-0.0182015151,
0.1427699924,
0.7137069106,
0.3082500696,
-0.0817999542,
0.3069018424,
0.9364899397,
-0.3603775799,
0.3364090323,
-0.0313652046,
-0.1706376076,
-0.0909922495,
-0.42470631,
-0.8717423677,
-0.7454283237,
-0.1716200709,
-0.4379116595,
0.3777886629,
0.8584621549,
0.5402590632,
-0.4586854279,
-0.0359498113,
-0.1841188222,
0.1548117101,
-0.1474599391,
-0.1743466407,
0.4689024985,
0.0521166101,
-0.5918893218,
0.6154899597,
0.3673695922,
0.3301714361,
-0.220776841,
-0.2812821567,
0.148180753,
0.5273855925,
0.601447463,
0.1578493863,
-0.7529984713,
-0.4642864168,
-0.2371658385,
-0.098416537,
-0.1873219907,
0.7155221105,
-1.0079586506,
0.2496126294,
0.8009932637,
0.5427166224,
0.4007264078,
-0.1815067083,
0.4433136284,
-0.8505957127,
0.6401354671,
0.421148479,
0.4264907539,
0.4274784625,
-0.014009132,
0.1782769859,
0.4150018096,
-0.1532526761,
-0.5366945863,
0.3963690102,
-1.147444129,
-0.4939237535,
1.5923886299,
-0.0935861394,
-0.2498232126,
-0.2916209698,
0.0865491554,
0.2903631926,
-0.36730358,
0.0392395034,
0.6909059882,
0.0428041369,
0.023389563,
-0.4506821632,
0.3435926735,
0.3165234029,
-0.0956711769,
0.0401339829,
0.2093155086,
0.4059502184,
0.0825250521,
0.8630976677,
-0.0377854817,
0.1426042169,
0.6421124935,
-0.1543322951,
0.2114153951,
-0.1099513993,
-0.5732154846,
-0.0280534048,
0.1233438328,
-0.5628482699
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10771v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10771v2
|
Automatic Restoration of Diacritics for Speech Data Sets
| 2023-11-15T19:24:54 | 2024-04-07T00:48:10 |
Sara Shatnawi, Sawsan Alqahtani, Hanan Aldarmaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD
|
Automatic text-based diacritic restoration models generally have high
diacritic error rates when applied to speech transcripts as a result of domain
and style shifts in spoken language. In this work, we explore the possibility
of improving the performance of automatic diacritic restoration when applied to
speech data by utilizing parallel spoken utterances. In particular, we use the
pre-trained Whisper ASR model fine-tuned on relatively small amounts of
diacritized Arabic speech data to produce rough diacritized transcripts for the
speech utterances, which we then use as an additional input for diacritic
restoration models. The proposed framework consistently improves diacritic
restoration performance compared to text-only baselines. Our results highlight
the inadequacy of current text-based diacritic restoration models for speech
data sets and provide a new baseline for speech-based diacritic restoration.
|
[
-0.1818380654,
-0.6782325506,
0.3169338107,
-0.0324171968,
-0.3419231772,
0.3618132174,
-0.354381144,
-0.4172286987,
0.2228453904,
0.725448668,
-0.1930053085,
-0.5930399299,
-0.7441433668,
0.5393998027,
-0.6459388137,
1.1809045076,
-0.1546437889,
0.1495708078,
0.2691183686,
0.016094178,
-0.4537640214,
-0.4468583465,
-0.632478714,
-0.1280092299,
0.1252460331,
0.4519948363,
0.9973330498,
0.9393492937,
0.6686108112,
0.3317580521,
0.2642469406,
0.0655817464,
-0.4338764846,
-0.0225512087,
0.0225511119,
-0.3123355806,
-0.5079368353,
-0.2047343999,
0.8178990483,
0.9776438475,
-0.3659878075,
-0.3823577762,
0.3019702137,
0.7619191408,
-0.6173868775,
0.021470692,
-0.6176911592,
-0.1868080348,
-0.4423784316,
0.0387994349,
-0.1662887931,
-0.6194220185,
0.1660848111,
-0.478897661,
0.4892776906,
-0.1153025404,
0.6267018914,
0.3429999352,
-0.26727584,
-0.18627882,
-1.1722326279,
0.7260892391,
-0.8489482999,
0.3595170081,
0.5597430468,
0.2225919366,
0.1544267088,
-0.9271163344,
-0.5728506446,
-0.0951180756,
-0.1354933381,
0.2966901064,
-0.270121187,
0.172122255,
-0.1279758364,
0.3803932965,
-0.4234319627,
0.1760625541,
-0.3484535515,
-0.5364643335,
0.6449533105,
0.3243057132,
0.3924420774,
0.1622801572,
0.0495810173,
-0.1620688885,
-0.6323747039,
-0.0827546269,
0.3495817482,
0.5285773277,
-0.2313725799,
0.1752679199,
-0.4396210611,
0.7987201214,
-0.211931318,
-0.3543803692,
0.3187642097,
-0.5557676554,
-0.1109308749,
0.4257965088,
0.4714245498,
0.4145402312,
0.6348662972,
-0.3327876329,
-0.1629741341,
0.1857641488,
0.1632925123,
-0.8759371042,
-0.5401784778,
-0.1546910852,
-0.3731547296,
-0.0140913166,
0.1343506873,
-0.5652688146,
-0.3735232949,
-0.5126662254,
0.3572035432,
-0.2819706202,
-0.0952865332,
0.4146793187,
-0.0905394405,
-0.1704286486,
0.5708640814,
-0.7900654078,
0.5871137977,
0.1697169244,
0.8218833804,
-0.2922285795,
-0.1559062898,
-0.2017840594,
0.2700177431,
-0.4739474654,
0.8399199843,
-0.8309565783,
-0.6273553371,
0.1045647189,
-0.1974758059,
-0.3166840374,
-0.9393862486,
0.9460991621,
-0.3282755613,
-0.0523375832,
0.0127311666,
-0.3883721232,
-0.1567729264,
-0.2953926325,
-0.6952441335,
0.5006603003,
-0.2379780263,
-0.6553041935,
0.190373823,
-0.3394016027,
-0.6111904383,
-0.0197317656,
0.0160467979,
-0.738602221,
-0.0409472249,
0.5610693097,
0.1037449241,
-0.2334294319,
-0.2508274615,
-0.2790777385,
-0.5532338619,
-0.0931579396,
-0.5663704872,
0.5066209435,
-0.0018202366,
-0.3955972195,
-0.1444213539,
-0.6605924368,
0.1184155121,
-0.236232385,
-0.321919173,
-0.3882116675,
0.1236255318,
0.2633011043,
-0.220085457,
0.1668137759,
-0.7148270607,
-0.0608014315,
-0.6734607816,
0.5570473671,
0.6201648116,
0.1695417166,
0.399390012,
-0.7120000124,
0.378736794,
0.1716992855,
-0.1320598125,
0.054838758,
-0.3850238323,
-0.9129992723,
-0.7528465986,
0.5781869292,
0.6542301774,
-0.4906362891,
0.1694024801,
-0.503182888,
-0.3371371031,
-0.9955821633,
-0.081644766,
0.6393094063,
0.6282092929,
0.5319507718,
-0.6222621799,
-0.7543231845,
-1.0132379532,
-0.2601717114,
-0.0839544833,
0.0215548873,
0.3658091426,
0.2055114061,
-0.0595462546,
1.1015326977,
-0.2434830517,
-0.3434480727,
0.1748444885,
0.2147169411,
0.0917269289,
0.5171105266,
0.1865689158,
-0.7333171368,
-0.8592198491,
-0.2014424354,
-0.381071806,
-0.4636812508,
0.1259398907,
0.1672585607,
0.132914111,
0.6591072083,
-0.3767459393,
0.8192414045,
0.2919026613,
-0.1668252349,
0.8448169827,
-0.2283736616,
0.5387256742,
-0.8084151745,
-0.1271689236,
-0.5185043812,
-0.3871044517,
-1.1577147245,
-0.4173064232,
-0.0485013761,
-0.1225796416,
-0.4852868021,
0.24530904,
-0.4507772326,
-0.0120204156,
-0.4735377431,
0.0056222873,
0.1277090311,
0.068162702,
0.0726834983,
1.2794657946,
0.7042427063,
-0.6408520937,
-0.0839368477,
0.695427537,
-0.3195045292,
0.4549179375,
-0.7803849578,
0.4317219257,
-0.2230574489,
0.3204934001,
-0.9244800806,
-0.0127443308,
-0.0385887288,
-0.2430249751,
0.2620842755,
-0.2053595334,
-0.349065125,
-0.1622755975,
-0.1605403125,
0.3158533275,
0.600620389,
-0.3136197031,
0.1444367766,
0.4065422416,
-0.7704104781,
-0.365888238,
-0.2999242544,
0.2892119288,
-0.1894315928,
-0.5814981461,
0.8352211118,
-0.1420849711,
-0.4131006002,
-0.3209921122,
-0.0195446238,
-0.0878174454,
-0.0361300744,
0.2509934306,
0.0780946687,
-0.2064798623,
-0.0455015078,
0.1774095446,
0.1462829709,
-0.1615793407,
-0.2153193355,
0.7017759085,
0.1925335675,
-0.3483060598,
-1.1128294468,
0.5276892185,
0.5449362397,
-0.2982192934,
0.564825356,
0.3623515069,
-0.3749838769,
0.0987850577,
-0.4813349843,
-0.2977858484,
-0.4591709971,
0.3171002567,
-0.5625275373,
-0.4885634184,
0.6034831405,
0.1196917892,
-0.1293052435,
0.5022285581,
0.710106492,
-0.342782557,
1.0557233095,
0.6229413152,
-0.4692018032,
0.2733382285,
-0.0724518597,
0.1187409237,
-0.4350263178,
-0.115411371,
-0.7851840258,
-0.0122115184,
-0.3996519446,
-0.0559371561,
0.3593411148,
0.2290342301,
-0.0830213651,
0.4144994915,
-0.2746316493,
0.2590387464,
0.5176730752,
0.5666306615,
0.4923334718,
0.2125875205,
0.1002696902,
-0.2175717801,
-0.4077335894,
-0.8166816235,
0.9279564619,
0.1478336155,
0.6572998762,
0.2037082762,
0.8506484032,
0.5877472758,
0.038090542,
-0.4886222184,
0.1795305908,
-0.4287696481,
-0.1512969285,
-0.44805637,
-0.2082652897,
-0.8776571751,
-0.0990481153,
-0.06228384,
-0.4765651226,
0.2000690699,
0.2099380493,
-0.6323193312,
0.0650836676,
-0.5408638716,
0.4166295826,
0.5851677656,
-0.0170238949,
-0.3791854084,
-0.3985066712,
-0.0711429939,
-0.4984328151,
0.1279335618,
-0.1248174757,
0.1091746315,
1.1029100418,
-0.8249596953,
0.8378145099,
-0.2303571403,
-0.0987346545,
0.2352674454,
-0.0796538219,
0.6854910851,
-0.1472569853,
-0.1780257672,
0.2921315134,
-0.2956445515,
-0.2036322206,
-0.610768795,
0.5045431256,
-0.8832805157,
-0.7195070386,
0.0960820988,
-0.734480679,
-0.3501984477,
0.0843468308,
0.1364036649,
0.7472029328,
-0.1496229321,
-0.0683389157,
0.4359002113,
0.1326012462,
0.7772402167,
0.6995581388,
0.4531368315,
-0.5947065949,
0.7689687014,
0.0442220047,
0.2663620412,
0.0793887973,
-0.1341061592,
-0.3267509043,
-1.1352579594,
-0.6645243168,
0.0952604786,
-0.4075716436,
-0.2657911479,
-0.7661877275,
-0.3526616096,
-0.7914367914,
-0.0682661533,
-0.2356015742,
-0.7974750996,
-0.5951704979,
0.2188718766,
0.4993799925,
0.547524035,
-0.0277022067,
0.6551750898,
-0.8516166806,
0.4686478078,
0.1704310328,
-0.1648918837,
-0.2601751387,
-1.2969529629,
-0.2916932702,
0.3164668977,
-0.1087077707,
-0.6819445491,
0.6756041646,
0.7279219031,
0.2239258885,
0.329313606,
0.2830161452,
0.9867035747,
-1.2809141874,
0.5013499856,
0.0751851574,
-0.9224305749,
0.3780598342,
-0.3720631599,
0.4042202532,
0.7304294705,
0.2558662295,
-0.3512285352,
-0.6531802416,
-0.3170576394,
-0.6023818254,
0.5420672894,
0.6763920784,
0.086615704,
0.2521505356,
0.2573651373,
0.2277147323,
0.1932736188,
0.0252090804,
-0.3769940138,
-0.4435606301,
-0.4242046773,
-0.3044608533,
-0.2020716667,
-0.1269590855,
-0.233422026,
0.7616435885,
0.2511315644,
0.4573425055,
0.2897305191,
-0.3337079883,
0.0947346538,
0.2388979495,
0.5768268108,
0.5442394614,
-0.0568133444,
0.0204627533,
0.104522787,
-0.9578797221,
0.291647166,
0.5272001028,
-0.4931511283,
0.0786664709,
0.3969808817,
0.8496769071,
0.0105186105,
-0.3984870315,
0.4464182556,
0.0953896195,
0.0597937256,
-0.3193073869,
-0.0750934705,
-0.3217491508,
-0.0534329489,
0.407147795,
0.279163152,
0.5314283967,
-0.5748886466,
0.6770886183,
0.4198148251,
-0.204428792,
-0.2028177232,
0.7279453874,
0.3573406339,
-0.696603179,
0.7180418372,
0.4849257171,
-0.6567537785,
0.5517736077,
0.6753966808,
0.6255173683,
-0.5895300508,
0.1523562372,
0.0763817951,
0.0687495321,
0.0899378955,
0.3126046658,
-0.1259443462,
-0.8007557392,
-0.196473673,
-0.7282806039,
-0.4476508498,
-0.0790412128,
-0.7124811411,
0.0239913501,
-0.2485385686,
-0.3736638427,
0.326423943,
-0.0923733413,
-0.4925942421,
0.4083560407,
0.1281450838,
0.7322945595,
-0.8523094654,
0.8861766458,
0.2770710588,
-0.2820082009,
-0.4603363276,
0.2024432272,
-0.1923587918,
-0.8075326681,
0.4497680664,
0.1675643176,
-0.5335386992,
0.4217022359,
-0.1817469299,
-1.0368890762,
0.6200509071,
0.4906474948,
-0.7529552579,
0.032914497,
0.6185824275,
0.5578039885,
-0.199988097,
0.3338181973,
0.7816737294,
0.3984137475,
-0.5486093163,
-1.6978702545,
-0.0645180121,
-0.1412826478,
-0.0215220284,
0.2248323113,
-0.3632081449,
0.5324066877,
-0.1358619928,
-0.3953161538,
0.4075303078,
0.6651198864,
-0.0344329663,
0.0082543148,
0.5317927599,
0.5280156136,
0.614028573,
-0.1008910313,
0.6604199409,
-0.2603510022,
-0.0094023608,
1.0537189245,
-0.3148565292,
0.7394672632,
0.250054419,
-0.1983729303,
0.7671351433,
0.3949863017,
0.258779496,
0.9233981371,
0.2000128478,
-0.596113503,
-0.0261063054,
-0.3659024835,
-0.2509723008,
0.8082318306,
0.1813029796,
-0.3489349186,
-0.1191713214,
0.4091676176,
0.134746924,
0.3623825908,
-0.3967922628,
0.8771782517,
-0.1085038483,
-0.4060426354,
1.0782622099,
0.0877221823,
0.3726293743,
-0.2196064889,
-0.0704512075,
-0.4021700323,
0.3887656629,
-0.1907288283,
-0.2797693312,
0.5201574564,
-0.0620299317,
-0.4337033033,
-0.2324786782,
0.4904940426,
-0.5644581318,
-0.2647862732,
-0.0883826986,
0.2116737962,
0.5127168894,
-0.2318338752,
-0.574585855,
0.2024290413,
0.1176520959,
0.171803534,
0.0756788775,
-0.086720638,
0.0541006811,
0.4992835522,
0.4681787491,
0.1749316752,
0.1021374017,
0.6292980909,
0.8233483434,
-0.3636021614,
-0.4323439598,
-0.8432599902,
0.3859102726,
-0.0434961021,
-0.0098245498,
0.8500378728,
0.7414575815,
0.613896966,
-0.1024891734,
1.0320012569,
0.3189408779,
0.9416499138,
-0.7641756535,
1.1305595636,
-0.0844200701,
0.0047974419,
-0.355435282,
-0.6776685715,
-0.3290768862,
0.4221398234,
-0.0901530981,
-0.0049390625,
0.7041611671,
1.2066663504,
-0.0720693395,
0.0799221396,
0.4844794273,
0.3195129037,
-0.0830699056,
0.295117557,
0.4349731803,
-0.6503991485,
0.6567838788,
-0.3502645493,
-0.3932667971,
0.0497833081,
-0.3245561719,
-0.7464475036,
-0.7095190883,
-0.4882555306,
-0.1734961122,
0.6614149809,
0.4003100097,
0.9133324623,
-1.1382516623,
-0.218708232,
-0.2687114179,
-0.4717454612,
-0.20513165,
-0.2042532712,
0.6386646032,
-0.1373045444,
-1.1238600016,
0.8485057354,
0.0002594309,
0.4363158345,
0.1461967975,
-0.0298980996,
0.1805060059,
0.2402107269,
0.2881523371,
0.1592697352,
-0.6319042444,
-0.323369354,
-0.2926532328,
-0.0559222884,
0.153420195,
0.8404732943,
-1.0338616371,
0.3026765883,
0.0859362707,
0.3655864596,
0.5330248475,
0.2319113016,
0.7558068633,
-0.5139329433,
0.1145707145,
0.2950031161,
0.3528489172,
0.5044611692,
-0.1752529442,
0.0678688288,
0.3636527658,
-0.4913601577,
-0.8331779242,
0.2834698856,
-0.5600471497,
0.0740354136,
0.9154137373,
-0.2030746639,
0.2208401412,
-0.5870856643,
-0.2551994622,
0.5334723592,
-0.4856188595,
0.9219307899,
0.5220349431,
-0.0100401007,
-0.0145060653,
-0.2180005461,
1.0064078569,
0.5827665329,
-0.7908107638,
0.3374985158,
0.3683333397,
0.2382469624,
0.009248076,
0.6957641244,
-0.057385765,
0.1682972163,
-0.0494230166,
-0.0222667493,
0.1371162832,
-0.7201907039,
-0.4580647647,
0.0201517418,
-0.1277465075,
-0.3917547166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09308v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09308v2
|
Divergences between Language Models and Human Brains
| 2023-11-15T19:02:40 | 2024-02-05T02:21:59 |
Yuchen Zhou, Emmy Liu, Graham Neubig, Michael J. Tarr, Leila Wehbe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, q-bio.NC
|
Do machines and humans process language in similar ways? Recent research has
hinted in the affirmative, finding that brain signals can be effectively
predicted using the internal representations of language models (LMs). Although
such results are thought to reflect shared computational principles between LMs
and human brains, there are also clear differences in how LMs and humans
represent and use language. In this work, we systematically explore the
divergences between human and machine language processing by examining the
differences between LM representations and human brain responses to language as
measured by Magnetoencephalography (MEG) across two datasets in which subjects
read and listened to narrative stories. Using a data-driven approach, we
identify two domains that are not captured well by LMs: social/emotional
intelligence and physical commonsense. We then validate these domains with
human behavioral experiments and show that fine-tuning LMs on these domains can
improve their alignment with human brain responses.
|
[
-0.5456059575,
-0.6780665517,
0.7118604779,
-0.1164485365,
0.0140341148,
0.467110604,
-0.4844665527,
-0.6372824907,
0.0413775407,
0.4074083567,
-0.7996079922,
-0.2966004312,
-0.4869872928,
0.1331904978,
0.0401919372,
0.5939475894,
0.0644340888,
0.1327301562,
-0.7416136861,
-0.264680326,
-0.6091141701,
-0.6749916077,
-0.3355548382,
-0.7992638946,
0.7153616548,
0.178489536,
0.833795011,
0.5319188833,
0.3261539936,
0.1508134604,
-0.1619463414,
0.4393486083,
-0.2066628337,
-0.0004664683,
-0.4091568887,
-0.4472724497,
-0.2061500102,
0.0418958515,
0.495420903,
1.0923327208,
-0.0973945782,
0.1042173877,
0.2589671016,
0.9038671255,
-0.4865050912,
-0.004259855,
-0.3689113855,
-0.0453340784,
-0.1412184238,
-0.2055337876,
-0.3903022707,
-0.2287262082,
0.1998990625,
-0.2418034375,
0.3335334063,
0.2799967229,
0.8409089446,
0.1561515182,
-0.4068712294,
-0.2639533281,
-0.6802582741,
0.9165470004,
-0.6529872417,
0.6676815748,
0.5959766507,
-0.0641740486,
-0.0605263337,
-0.3200568259,
-0.7307513952,
-0.3724754751,
-0.2868131995,
-0.2185650319,
-0.3335630894,
-0.1373601407,
0.2122041285,
-0.1540033221,
-0.7164505124,
0.4582456946,
-0.4258896708,
-0.2147208452,
0.7181058526,
0.4693335593,
0.5291337371,
-0.0189280529,
-0.1527904868,
-0.3022342026,
-0.7018206716,
0.1964886039,
0.5978860259,
0.4082116783,
0.0023312019,
0.4664537907,
0.042525474,
0.6279921532,
-0.1390816271,
-0.0597745217,
0.4557563066,
0.1356644183,
-0.0839892924,
0.0032587112,
0.7004101276,
0.6138578653,
0.673764348,
-0.3466095626,
-0.102430068,
0.272325635,
0.3069590628,
-0.4857531786,
-0.0491615981,
0.251144588,
-0.514716804,
0.1616183072,
-0.0895217732,
-0.6338146329,
-0.820563972,
-0.5986102223,
0.0562709607,
-0.4163800776,
-0.4746884406,
0.495164454,
-0.2091790438,
0.0099140406,
0.0623143576,
-1.0644133091,
0.6013672352,
0.8252446055,
0.6338546872,
-0.4805597067,
-0.4799050093,
-0.0151578654,
-0.1220917329,
-0.2906092107,
1.0350527763,
-0.4467255771,
-0.1443549395,
0.0300311465,
-0.1764700115,
-0.2099641562,
-0.9036002159,
0.5724111795,
-0.5878047347,
0.2865417898,
-0.4757868648,
-0.5602203608,
-0.2541760504,
-0.0686101317,
-0.6791803241,
0.4640212357,
-0.1228483692,
-0.9116093516,
0.2018169463,
-0.6567351818,
-0.4366896152,
-0.1907372326,
-0.1055876762,
-0.3515322804,
0.3498069048,
0.1773399413,
0.4368146658,
-0.364269793,
0.1608036757,
-0.4307404757,
-0.5728298426,
0.7871091962,
-0.3880247474,
0.767008841,
0.1350605637,
0.0129799172,
-0.113241978,
-0.5391268134,
0.0461322777,
0.2800283134,
-0.2086486369,
-0.409742713,
0.5170679688,
-0.0534925908,
0.2442265302,
0.1546444297,
-0.4731746316,
0.1539548337,
-0.4458737075,
0.4939125776,
0.4459067881,
-0.1266307533,
0.5555074811,
-0.5288021564,
0.1762080789,
0.3709264696,
-0.4252752364,
-0.1405645609,
-0.4975785911,
-0.4670509696,
-0.1237152517,
0.0355859548,
0.5192044377,
-0.0823025927,
0.4091532528,
-0.2750386298,
-0.1141317189,
-0.95286268,
-0.0560406484,
0.0680916384,
0.2706449032,
0.4814293683,
-0.31047225,
-0.4581778646,
-1.0703568459,
-0.8049867153,
-0.2895774543,
-0.439407438,
0.3374938965,
0.1371297687,
-0.3909444809,
1.1364986897,
-0.5128996372,
0.0302578826,
-0.1512055993,
0.3122425377,
0.0333145298,
0.246496737,
0.2626709044,
-0.5719876289,
-0.3082885742,
0.2122028768,
-0.7497971058,
-0.2127365917,
-0.0301193427,
0.1411591768,
0.3403207362,
0.3910936713,
-0.8191980124,
0.1863389909,
0.3988344967,
-0.5794949532,
0.3014785647,
-0.0949994624,
0.2334362417,
-0.709728837,
-0.0671252087,
-0.0014017058,
-0.1517413259,
-0.6547990441,
-0.2928261161,
0.1605723947,
0.2262758613,
-0.2197489142,
0.5413020849,
-0.7283326983,
-0.3176081777,
-0.3405219913,
0.4030791223,
0.1019395813,
0.6945188046,
0.1552686542,
0.5144342184,
0.4892747402,
-0.539740324,
0.0704450831,
-0.0505047813,
-0.3668515086,
0.5752156973,
-0.6263958216,
0.5323494673,
-0.5593377948,
-0.1298771054,
-0.8426707387,
-0.1696531326,
0.0613561198,
-0.6348139644,
0.3323981464,
0.2768911719,
-0.6373739839,
-0.3712796271,
-0.1535398811,
0.0431951806,
0.7393118143,
-0.2808301151,
0.4463030994,
0.5991000533,
-0.286996901,
-0.3890159726,
-0.9714826345,
-0.0351551846,
-0.280297935,
-0.7006260753,
0.3245553076,
-0.2276804298,
-0.667414546,
0.0045493636,
0.1055180579,
-0.1865379661,
-0.0129094841,
0.2911979556,
0.1459587663,
-0.2461545914,
0.3598874807,
0.0970751122,
0.1209293008,
0.3034053147,
-0.2161325514,
0.6609960794,
-0.0511124767,
-0.4097253382,
-0.5337982178,
0.3582440317,
0.5666778088,
-0.1210178733,
0.8449511528,
0.3878060877,
-0.4924879968,
-0.0346740969,
-0.4455010593,
-0.3986211419,
-0.4055252373,
0.3915199339,
-0.2767623961,
-0.9715875983,
0.4649854302,
-0.0733766854,
-0.0338570364,
0.280893594,
0.7776797414,
-0.5050672293,
1.2264764309,
0.6669668555,
0.0616690442,
0.2680887878,
0.0733409226,
0.1723760962,
-0.878202498,
-0.1822621226,
-0.4155827761,
-0.5277067423,
-0.4442574978,
-0.2135161906,
-0.1605084538,
0.0605274215,
-0.2116221488,
0.1856840104,
-0.3784390986,
0.7343322635,
0.3825261593,
-0.1385576576,
0.3871795535,
0.2055771649,
-0.3053367138,
-0.4502738714,
-0.6046594977,
-0.7968087792,
0.7155194879,
0.5174896717,
0.5086683035,
-0.1156393364,
0.4338986278,
0.3772832155,
0.3563033938,
-0.5720520616,
0.4420689344,
0.0397604369,
-0.5319200158,
-0.1426810175,
-0.3870165944,
-1.1446994543,
0.3874954283,
-0.1497562379,
-1.1151001453,
0.1586676985,
-0.1424326003,
-0.1984792501,
0.3650092185,
-0.8178194165,
0.7581211925,
0.0199933294,
-0.3105000556,
-0.3949724436,
-0.6116047502,
0.1823410839,
0.047614269,
0.164038375,
-0.3658221364,
-0.0784535408,
0.5722953081,
0.0212392956,
0.9046676755,
0.1130336076,
-0.1916834414,
0.4811413586,
0.2128858119,
0.0863656029,
-0.079354547,
-0.0480383672,
0.4206812978,
-0.2268802226,
-0.33620435,
-0.4902909994,
0.7291654944,
-1.0173670053,
-0.4891412258,
-0.3389327228,
-0.8210113645,
-0.3892755806,
-0.0430489331,
0.2442117929,
0.0254829936,
-0.4074927568,
-0.1307518929,
0.6578664184,
-0.0867322087,
0.4981333613,
0.565960288,
-0.1105517,
-0.167691797,
0.6618732214,
0.026993528,
0.148822099,
0.4463551641,
-0.0580682233,
-0.3759978414,
-0.291485101,
-0.2625052333,
0.5559291244,
-0.5552489758,
0.0969263241,
-0.6820347309,
0.0061427141,
-0.1819881797,
-0.041258499,
-0.289672941,
-0.1167301163,
-0.4542062283,
-0.1105237976,
0.197074905,
0.7994259596,
0.0768850446,
0.1579989791,
-0.8241792917,
0.0922808722,
0.2099833339,
0.2703113854,
0.1205359995,
-0.5060116649,
-0.410741657,
0.4798772931,
-0.2767991126,
-0.9157855511,
0.5396623015,
0.0016527545,
0.4110877216,
0.233272329,
-0.2832398117,
0.5071459413,
-0.7305022478,
0.7407006621,
0.1503485143,
-0.7618194818,
0.2229219079,
-0.2483944893,
0.4536312819,
0.333653003,
0.527921617,
-0.8923171759,
-0.2783097923,
-0.4664832354,
-0.3593461514,
0.6149074435,
0.138898313,
0.2207134217,
0.0458163992,
0.1360070109,
0.2268891335,
0.1614159346,
-0.3979409039,
-0.1532203257,
0.3081051707,
-0.1792563051,
-0.0893149599,
0.0194054749,
-0.0818404108,
-0.0534890778,
-0.010840768,
-0.1000289172,
0.4046860635,
0.0267031118,
-0.1788880527,
-0.3942331672,
0.1334180981,
0.5378825665,
0.5223869085,
-0.1242273301,
0.2837611735,
0.2158813477,
-0.4457209706,
0.0213713814,
-0.1318371594,
0.1381951421,
0.0077349865,
0.6017605066,
0.9103693366,
-0.0886151865,
-1.0139317513,
0.2445747405,
-0.2736150622,
-0.0493460856,
0.1151158512,
0.0991898179,
0.7301236987,
0.4608162642,
0.1043116823,
0.4370810688,
-0.0677811727,
-0.5713322163,
0.0202631019,
0.2275859118,
-0.1909523457,
-0.6180880666,
0.5126731992,
-0.0112058492,
-0.7029628158,
0.7723398805,
-0.1181463599,
-0.2296206057,
0.4683851004,
0.5714612007,
1.0670562983,
-0.0563039407,
0.0391556323,
0.1623400897,
0.2224263996,
0.0109679112,
0.2117305398,
0.0230034646,
-1.0822430849,
-0.4104953706,
-0.3867011666,
-0.3782761097,
-0.0014863434,
-0.6531369686,
0.1593247205,
-0.1716509014,
-0.3081646264,
0.1181853563,
0.0645256191,
-0.7064803839,
0.0055640424,
0.603233099,
0.4739172459,
-0.5959391594,
0.8090206981,
0.8359940052,
-0.2892081738,
-0.3087756932,
0.3485168517,
-0.128903091,
-0.5042937994,
0.7016322613,
0.2016155273,
-0.2552061677,
-0.1675128341,
-0.5033653378,
-0.7610217929,
0.908302784,
0.5144693851,
-0.6508443952,
0.1500398666,
0.3913970888,
0.8420913815,
-0.4673025608,
0.0213472601,
0.7020247579,
0.2750197351,
-0.4107242525,
-0.7983931899,
-0.2722634375,
-0.1229498759,
0.0830155462,
0.2235493809,
-0.5144275427,
0.85327667,
-0.4835939109,
-0.6847991347,
-0.1948057711,
0.8072359562,
0.4375748932,
0.5014910698,
0.2381554097,
0.4750059545,
1.0415890217,
0.0269280002,
0.91203475,
-0.218329981,
0.375251919,
0.8908694983,
-0.5323004723,
1.0156320333,
0.4990004599,
-0.3636533618,
0.7688145638,
0.6311724186,
0.3448622525,
0.3786579967,
0.2308233678,
-0.128191486,
-0.1904540509,
0.0392690152,
0.0180236846,
0.176218152,
0.3885780275,
-0.196310252,
0.0780369937,
-0.0039334581,
0.1671528965,
0.3103137612,
-0.2045753151,
0.5466783643,
0.3175698817,
-0.8757967353,
0.5619567633,
0.154718861,
0.7359580398,
-0.2637370825,
0.2059719414,
-0.2430132031,
0.193154335,
-0.0239467341,
-1.0764197111,
0.4115469456,
0.1166595072,
-0.4568508863,
-0.3315035105,
1.0808185339,
-0.6167144179,
0.0663112998,
0.4120446742,
0.8359485865,
0.1099060252,
-0.0704909787,
-0.5562095046,
0.2241815627,
-0.2278286815,
-0.3099679947,
0.4291704595,
0.3272893429,
-0.1276860386,
0.7484338284,
0.6054524779,
0.0507772081,
-0.0763307363,
0.2245118767,
0.6741880774,
-0.910553813,
-0.3516930044,
-1.1190565825,
0.4680558145,
-0.1149805933,
-0.3814736903,
0.4591362774,
0.2387318015,
0.8147062659,
-0.288662523,
0.5939391255,
0.3239285946,
0.6562921405,
-0.3922778964,
0.7349694967,
-0.3570305705,
0.2406983525,
0.0638916269,
-0.8876709938,
-0.4367606044,
0.6026118994,
-0.2187339365,
0.1025095731,
0.8318725824,
0.6663453579,
0.0649333298,
0.1113954633,
0.3887628913,
0.1619562656,
-0.0154237114,
0.6133862138,
1.1125426292,
-0.0746734887,
0.0131736351,
0.0531603247,
0.1221623793,
-0.1737540811,
-0.680147469,
-1.0620647669,
-0.6044213772,
-0.3513213396,
-0.0502622239,
0.1002575904,
0.9982199073,
0.5234270692,
-0.5558047295,
-0.5646745563,
-0.004063413,
0.2925533056,
-0.3885523081,
-0.2470292598,
0.1697963476,
-0.2666626871,
-0.8207014203,
0.2991915047,
0.5000272989,
-0.0697599426,
-0.5583201051,
-0.2903240323,
0.1046100259,
0.5250605941,
0.6143449545,
0.1877012253,
-0.7344363332,
-0.1655474454,
0.3889815211,
-0.5068812966,
0.2993624806,
0.934918344,
-1.0363345146,
0.1663962901,
0.6988599896,
0.4806747139,
0.1590348184,
-0.2381558269,
0.5541872382,
-0.6393036842,
0.0022813953,
0.4945411384,
0.3592356443,
0.6474444866,
-0.2082324922,
0.2748758197,
0.2283122987,
-0.6060308218,
-0.8284421563,
0.2873112559,
-0.8842744231,
-0.4760781825,
0.983348906,
0.202169165,
-0.328415364,
-0.1164921969,
-0.2404689938,
0.073998712,
-0.2464288175,
0.7759085298,
1.0236763954,
-0.4037071168,
-0.1679974496,
-0.5319126844,
0.3948990107,
0.3590082228,
-0.6818060279,
0.2734305859,
0.3171560168,
0.1815695614,
0.2728893757,
0.5088150501,
0.0134231402,
0.1460135281,
0.0164263565,
0.2514891922,
0.1751398146,
-0.1977862567,
-0.4121903181,
0.08511132,
-0.0555296615,
0.01998787
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09278v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09278v2
|
Symbol-LLM: Towards Foundational Symbol-centric Interface For Large Language Models
| 2023-11-15T18:59:56 | 2024-02-18T06:24:12 |
Fangzhi Xu, Zhiyong Wu, Qiushi Sun, Siyu Ren, Fei Yuan, Shuai Yuan, Qika Lin, Yu Qiao, Jun Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Although Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate remarkable ability in
processing and generating human-like text, they do have limitations when it
comes to comprehending and expressing world knowledge that extends beyond the
boundaries of natural language(e.g., chemical molecular formula). Injecting a
collection of symbolic data directly into the training of LLMs can be
problematic, as it disregards the synergies among different symbolic families
and overlooks the need for a balanced mixture of natural and symbolic data. In
this work, we tackle these challenges from both a data and framework
perspective and introduce Symbol-LLM series models. First, we curated a data
collection consisting of 34 tasks and incorporating approximately 20 distinct
symbolic families, intending to capture the interrelations and foster synergies
between symbols. Then, a two-stage tuning framework succeeds in injecting
symbolic knowledge without loss of the generality ability. Extensive
experiments on both symbol- and NL-centric tasks demonstrate the balanced and
superior performances of Symbol-LLM series models. The project page is
https://xufangzhi.github.io/symbol-llm-page/.
|
[
-0.3208967745,
-0.6873403192,
0.5003072619,
0.1367343217,
-0.30384624,
0.4364607632,
-0.2813110352,
-0.6103034019,
0.1532681882,
0.6240193248,
-0.6891540289,
-0.5995320082,
-0.7818474174,
0.2745880485,
-0.3552742302,
0.8390039802,
-0.2318898737,
0.1741259396,
-0.1003313363,
-0.3119865656,
-0.2842503786,
-0.6091185212,
-0.564117372,
-0.5578196049,
0.543353796,
0.2591317594,
0.7204206586,
0.7735969424,
0.5148275495,
0.198244378,
-0.0800734237,
0.2758863568,
-0.6730055809,
0.1553244144,
-0.0310515258,
-0.5055788755,
-0.4203457236,
0.0041145356,
0.7364131808,
0.8810805678,
0.2058183849,
0.1854875535,
0.1057689041,
0.650120616,
-0.2052395344,
0.5339323878,
-0.5033285618,
-0.1133074909,
-0.1385154575,
-0.0896158963,
-0.3553532064,
-0.1261628121,
0.0053407038,
-0.7495177388,
-0.1308477521,
0.2294359654,
0.7084059715,
0.2333592623,
-0.5367979407,
-0.3010130227,
-0.5784785748,
0.8791277409,
-0.6225452423,
0.4445755184,
0.1062462181,
0.2500208914,
-0.2940634489,
-0.4717924595,
-0.4697022736,
-0.2540493011,
-0.0913847983,
-0.1384456605,
-0.1013408601,
0.09206938,
0.3628110588,
0.3553806245,
-0.525464952,
0.1407843381,
-0.0336921215,
-0.0047896639,
0.5551950932,
0.2677125037,
0.5288485885,
-0.0124413678,
-0.3933130503,
0.1362644285,
-1.1585128307,
-0.3528012633,
0.3527715504,
0.6765296459,
-0.4194748998,
0.8561285734,
-0.1599220484,
0.7349306941,
-0.0046821609,
0.0473175012,
0.0080303308,
-0.2705168426,
-0.1223042682,
-0.0122768553,
0.6954917312,
0.0868004262,
0.4987042546,
-0.2838989198,
-0.221275866,
0.3207422793,
-0.1070643216,
-0.9811198115,
0.0563060157,
0.1237241924,
-0.1287713349,
-0.3399279118,
-0.0698578805,
-0.2905164659,
-0.5225487351,
-0.8181790113,
0.5775030851,
-0.3433137238,
-0.2593435943,
0.1418588161,
0.0012772743,
0.1211800575,
0.3298321366,
-0.9701747298,
0.2840358615,
0.8535340428,
0.8092666864,
-0.1352819204,
0.0110284276,
-0.5025098324,
0.4083326161,
-0.0652721301,
0.4150671661,
-0.6492241025,
-0.4806553423,
-0.1080828384,
-0.1759218127,
0.2409127653,
-0.5728963614,
0.1823805869,
-0.4297466874,
-0.1844702512,
-0.5033510327,
-0.6718790531,
-0.0294366721,
0.0702857673,
-0.7888637185,
1.1269948483,
0.1949097365,
-0.7807907462,
0.2199908942,
-0.4510554075,
-0.6495166421,
0.0902594253,
-0.6562298536,
-0.1586675346,
0.0885051787,
-0.0305654686,
0.6865924597,
-0.6408193111,
0.4447565377,
-0.5366459489,
-0.391335696,
0.1864146739,
-0.0478413552,
0.6860737801,
0.1295184046,
-0.2241365314,
0.1980007887,
-0.8317620158,
-0.3794854283,
-0.0054986076,
-0.0722521171,
-0.5185321569,
-0.0922756717,
0.3485819697,
0.3127671778,
0.2442907095,
-0.4676469564,
0.4160196483,
-0.5361503363,
0.5498267412,
0.7590199709,
-0.3601727784,
0.4704543352,
-0.2956206501,
0.3810485005,
0.1714259535,
-0.0395468138,
-0.2144928277,
-0.3696027696,
-0.8065122962,
-0.4380488396,
0.0432920642,
0.3069747388,
-0.9842603803,
0.6140068173,
-0.5367168784,
-0.3312457502,
-0.0690068901,
0.3896278143,
0.3121779561,
0.4538118243,
0.1046288908,
-0.1794736832,
-0.5942736864,
-0.9165558219,
-0.2506363988,
-0.265732944,
-0.1130779609,
0.1207177266,
0.4379298389,
-0.1964754611,
1.2428760529,
-0.3959896863,
-0.0403913632,
-0.4988406897,
0.2042619586,
0.3831399679,
0.3007965088,
0.2921576202,
-0.69573915,
-0.4141937494,
0.2236095369,
-0.9940577745,
-0.3659162223,
-0.0143469786,
-0.1738884896,
0.1478258669,
0.5539368391,
-0.5870738626,
0.0381774083,
0.5085095763,
-0.4355190694,
0.3483804762,
0.1979513019,
-0.1671200693,
-1.4535483122,
0.3415685892,
0.3793440163,
-0.1817805916,
-0.8583886623,
0.2592573166,
0.1296751052,
0.0268869512,
-0.435138762,
1.1640188694,
-0.5526530743,
0.0177191105,
-0.3186560571,
-0.0400393531,
-0.0413564853,
0.4271527529,
0.189928174,
0.6766645908,
0.4357867837,
-0.4759787321,
0.2441367656,
0.1612843126,
-0.1245604381,
0.5896459818,
-0.6215106845,
-0.2541143,
-0.0908088386,
0.1270042211,
-0.9079095125,
-0.1684853435,
0.3811877966,
-0.1761781722,
0.5552144647,
-0.0515307859,
-0.8659968376,
-0.0577508174,
-0.1611174047,
0.606115222,
0.3545364439,
-0.6276333928,
0.9553156495,
0.3603574038,
-0.2145885229,
-0.3810303509,
-0.5354827642,
0.1241064593,
-0.3913701177,
-0.7099802494,
0.0497690067,
-0.1283162087,
-0.3684535325,
-0.2217026055,
-0.2974210978,
0.1654345989,
0.1466198266,
0.4685709178,
0.4478952289,
-0.1599734575,
0.236970678,
0.2167877406,
-0.2821070552,
0.0871834159,
-0.1764136404,
0.5092812777,
-0.1501102746,
-0.4044640958,
-0.2516062856,
0.2245584279,
0.6282622218,
-0.0011557732,
0.7116937637,
0.305698812,
-0.4899752438,
-0.300085485,
-0.4680377841,
-0.3772301376,
-0.5002023578,
0.3534418643,
-0.4317767322,
-1.2072409391,
0.4747940898,
-0.2576640546,
0.1770047843,
0.3709132969,
0.6192490458,
0.0440376028,
0.768196702,
0.6836009622,
-0.3437009454,
0.2820207179,
-0.200904116,
0.1948629618,
-0.7995399833,
-0.0110416561,
-0.2519480586,
-0.2679193616,
-0.2931857407,
-0.3597719073,
0.379396975,
0.2860922217,
-0.3726374209,
0.3976451457,
-0.172300294,
0.2486382425,
0.1107664779,
0.0390976183,
0.6071128249,
0.1688843966,
-0.0444986857,
-0.0560202785,
-0.5627227426,
-0.552038312,
1.2087129354,
0.4568378031,
0.9982498884,
0.0996161774,
0.5347844958,
0.0440090522,
0.661989212,
-0.822911799,
0.6181277037,
-0.2549417317,
-0.3879422545,
-0.222363174,
-0.5477572083,
-0.6732121706,
0.1671474427,
-0.2415712625,
-0.4800130129,
-0.0303979348,
0.1968113929,
-0.0785495043,
0.1805260628,
-0.4012737572,
0.7346084714,
-0.3416140378,
-0.4422139823,
-0.1579235345,
-0.7568669915,
0.5834825635,
-0.3210374415,
0.2932300568,
-0.3513166308,
-0.0671472698,
0.3698062301,
-0.3426889479,
1.1150864363,
0.2181557864,
-0.467816025,
0.0255091786,
0.0548752099,
0.6283824444,
0.0500801839,
-0.0143029708,
0.236068964,
-0.214867264,
-0.3335985243,
-0.564342916,
0.6706913114,
-0.6821137071,
-0.3983355165,
-0.456721127,
-0.8360732794,
-0.4400324225,
0.1834910065,
-0.0643585101,
0.4354424179,
-0.2654298246,
0.0152876237,
0.8290930986,
-0.1840960234,
0.1916089207,
0.5113484263,
-0.4857185483,
-0.2139831036,
1.0159256458,
-0.1237670854,
0.539912641,
0.6855500937,
0.1001046002,
-0.4123294353,
-0.3009856343,
-0.5622383952,
0.5975368619,
-0.6957411766,
-0.0055211196,
-0.4649717808,
-0.1087785363,
-0.0986601412,
0.0037257737,
-0.1770426035,
-0.46889323,
-0.4300197363,
0.0174863953,
0.7407073975,
0.6829812527,
0.2786155939,
0.4282007813,
-0.7158405185,
0.5025829673,
0.0855897292,
0.4719317853,
0.0069280323,
-0.3658046722,
-0.407333076,
0.0044470546,
-0.009782074,
-0.5968557596,
0.1696904749,
-0.045669537,
0.3012635112,
0.4162937105,
-0.2099357545,
0.5310160518,
-0.3972391188,
0.4364995658,
0.3880251646,
-0.9529245496,
0.2019889206,
-0.716424942,
0.3479088843,
0.3609748185,
0.2726573646,
-0.8520340919,
-0.5496187806,
-0.1540599018,
-0.9250940681,
0.6122805476,
0.3581836224,
-0.0883427039,
0.0784259439,
0.5615282655,
0.099917382,
0.4564895034,
-0.6527047753,
-0.4568291605,
-0.0403614677,
-0.6832011342,
-0.1421753019,
-0.0108323041,
-0.0850236341,
-0.2346808016,
0.6846699119,
-0.2684461772,
-0.2092730552,
-0.2502004802,
-0.3564846516,
-0.1139674261,
0.0901930109,
0.4100347459,
0.5069378018,
-0.0259434395,
0.2240479141,
-0.102879867,
-0.3960074484,
0.1498374194,
0.0764230117,
-0.0580534786,
-0.1849355549,
0.3209268153,
0.8170868754,
0.4187826514,
-0.8429632187,
0.1454952806,
0.2033309042,
-0.0149701415,
-0.0776839852,
-0.0111461217,
0.4706209302,
0.2200423032,
0.2858118415,
-0.3672840595,
0.0245555472,
-0.5825439095,
0.1415619999,
0.6364104152,
-0.0939709693,
-0.2984116077,
0.6970484257,
0.2719353735,
0.1799674928,
0.4416826367,
0.168348074,
-0.353517741,
0.7104388475,
0.4680715203,
0.9453562498,
-0.0429534987,
0.0420649126,
0.3000859022,
0.2399632931,
-0.1996375322,
0.4261656106,
0.1388303936,
-0.6747274995,
-0.4005762637,
-0.7915315032,
-0.3056340814,
0.0336335748,
-0.4945386052,
0.4399550259,
-0.4302995801,
0.0427296162,
-0.0821485668,
-0.0899795666,
-0.4597072005,
0.0258818343,
0.1975220144,
0.9736449122,
-1.1364729404,
0.9438612461,
0.4381274581,
-0.4188895822,
-0.7292052507,
-0.3413096666,
0.0544261709,
-0.8925229907,
0.9475468993,
0.249288097,
-0.1727302521,
0.1497464925,
-0.2954481542,
-0.8723594546,
0.9902808666,
0.52493155,
-0.7729822397,
-0.0403661914,
0.6282473803,
0.5439509749,
-0.3644487262,
0.0107425684,
0.5308223963,
0.6142010093,
0.2915542722,
-0.6573903561,
0.3063538671,
-0.3653322458,
0.213705197,
0.5746861696,
-0.6748816371,
0.7274786234,
0.1450704038,
-0.3803722858,
0.2963976562,
0.6998791695,
0.5274664164,
0.0027098279,
0.2687717974,
0.7483510971,
0.2827259898,
-0.1914523542,
0.9414265156,
-0.625399828,
0.2571749389,
0.9849747419,
-0.470980078,
0.5882119536,
0.8158582449,
-0.2139973342,
-0.0724698678,
0.5547891855,
-0.0872736946,
0.0957712233,
0.4913157523,
-0.5163692236,
-0.3267594278,
-0.1574125588,
-0.3319429159,
-0.0663167536,
0.5547253489,
-0.1704404652,
-0.318025887,
-0.1477100253,
0.0329903662,
-0.0104976753,
-0.2740099132,
0.5047240257,
0.4895869792,
-0.1653116345,
0.4175505638,
0.0687716752,
0.6444315314,
-0.689238131,
-0.1114133298,
-0.261053592,
-0.0638801381,
-0.0751498044,
-0.6194472313,
0.1054467186,
-0.1667789221,
-0.2543543875,
-0.1812237203,
0.4345535338,
-0.6623256803,
-0.747466743,
0.2132620513,
0.564576745,
-0.0225039739,
-0.0406691395,
-0.4009194672,
0.3388325572,
-0.3708523512,
-0.1599168777,
0.3618808091,
0.3800618351,
-0.2848534286,
0.780280292,
0.5799670219,
-0.0153709799,
-0.0738099143,
0.2645531893,
0.8283683658,
-0.6579154134,
-0.3901682794,
-1.0785291195,
0.3028127253,
0.2485696524,
-0.0171322431,
0.7938530445,
0.7951563597,
0.5667024255,
-0.0829237252,
0.947922647,
0.1663852483,
0.2574342787,
-0.5705834627,
0.7281593084,
-0.6325975657,
0.36658445,
-0.2907513082,
-0.8238164783,
-0.5261429548,
0.2881539762,
-0.0116103161,
0.079623118,
0.4365547001,
0.7579250336,
-0.1613928974,
0.1486382186,
0.2442336828,
0.337356925,
0.3786879778,
0.6483989954,
0.7820371985,
-0.2015779465,
0.0602651387,
0.1190632954,
-0.1554638743,
-0.3166493177,
-0.892991066,
-1.0900714397,
-0.4206905961,
-0.1296010613,
-0.1048462316,
-0.0772054791,
1.0464371443,
0.4818770885,
-0.6910703182,
-0.7012623549,
-0.3372263014,
0.0597985201,
0.0570393652,
-0.1647338271,
0.2253192067,
-0.1164188161,
-0.7908115387,
0.2051983476,
0.5218645334,
0.2033950686,
-0.4513599873,
-0.3299675882,
0.1157235578,
0.0846107379,
0.895645082,
0.401900053,
-0.9504510164,
-0.1996700913,
0.0654236525,
-0.2025343776,
0.0363699794,
0.9208328724,
-0.7508651614,
0.2850031853,
0.4593085945,
0.8344984055,
0.3281380236,
-0.2544705272,
0.8373457789,
-0.6674140692,
-0.0148643469,
-0.066310294,
0.4478788674,
0.2081985176,
-0.3060854077,
0.4975476265,
0.3526704013,
-0.0559618063,
-0.9439324141,
0.5352172256,
-1.3720573187,
-0.3410618007,
1.1654913425,
0.2782002389,
0.0473591015,
0.0646217763,
-0.115704298,
0.532448709,
-0.3666132092,
0.6039429307,
0.879657805,
-0.0714365095,
-0.0335454047,
-0.3999688625,
0.2454782873,
0.3608607948,
-0.9991470575,
0.3020054996,
0.6085495949,
0.3707978427,
-0.134437412,
0.314846009,
-0.0857950449,
0.0412709229,
-0.3786617517,
0.2975867093,
-0.1750236452,
-0.4222240746,
-0.4950208068,
-0.0227765646,
0.2197747231,
0.2992189229
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09216v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09216v1
|
Assessing Translation capabilities of Large Language Models involving English and Indian Languages
| 2023-11-15T18:58:19 | 2023-11-15T18:58:19 |
Vandan Mujadia, Ashok Urlana, Yash Bhaskar, Penumalla Aditya Pavani, Kukkapalli Shravya, Parameswari Krishnamurthy, Dipti Misra Sharma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Generative Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable advancements
in various NLP tasks. In this work, our aim is to explore the multilingual
capabilities of large language models by using machine translation as a task
involving English and 22 Indian languages. We first investigate the translation
capabilities of raw large language models, followed by exploring the in-context
learning capabilities of the same raw models. We fine-tune these large language
models using parameter efficient fine-tuning methods such as LoRA and
additionally with full fine-tuning. Through our study, we have identified the
best performing large language model for the translation task involving LLMs,
which is based on LLaMA.
Our results demonstrate significant progress, with average BLEU scores of
13.42, 15.93, 12.13, 12.30, and 12.07, as well as CHRF scores of 43.98, 46.99,
42.55, 42.42, and 45.39, respectively, using 2-stage fine-tuned LLaMA-13b for
English to Indian languages on IN22 (conversational), IN22 (general),
flores200-dev, flores200-devtest, and newstest2019 testsets. Similarly, for
Indian languages to English, we achieved average BLEU scores of 14.03, 16.65,
16.17, 15.35 and 12.55 along with chrF scores of 36.71, 40.44, 40.26, 39.51,
and 36.20, respectively, using fine-tuned LLaMA-13b on IN22 (conversational),
IN22 (general), flores200-dev, flores200-devtest, and newstest2019 testsets.
Overall, our findings highlight the potential and strength of large language
models for machine translation capabilities, including for languages that are
currently underrepresented in LLMs.
|
[
-0.2001482397,
-0.8065007329,
0.358204037,
0.542460084,
-0.4520207345,
0.3316597044,
-0.6716064215,
-0.6758005023,
-0.1438545585,
0.3809879124,
-0.1879450232,
-0.3558715582,
-0.9577840567,
0.5714831948,
-0.5544586778,
0.8889247179,
-0.2212097496,
0.0831668153,
0.1124004051,
-0.1965514719,
-0.8094822764,
-0.3343854845,
-0.4483481348,
-0.2638612688,
0.2662998438,
0.3512102962,
0.5845374465,
0.432965517,
0.7721245885,
0.3753713965,
-0.3288876414,
0.571008265,
-0.344953686,
0.1120021269,
-0.2334132791,
-0.4635981619,
-0.5739181042,
-0.2861948311,
0.8944579363,
0.6935015321,
-0.1350689381,
0.3479388952,
0.1935833842,
0.4018509686,
-0.3973807991,
0.2328685671,
-0.8595218658,
-0.173484996,
-0.249903366,
-0.1371314973,
-0.5618005991,
-0.2906622291,
-0.3074402809,
-0.3195157349,
-0.2716702521,
0.2763400078,
0.8632181883,
0.305513382,
-0.7146008015,
-0.3772626519,
-0.8559519053,
1.1940842867,
-0.7656137347,
0.4562713504,
0.462872982,
0.3662729263,
0.0734313503,
-0.3361728787,
-0.5100886822,
-0.3491826355,
-0.0500235036,
-0.0262524616,
-0.3156211972,
-0.2357598394,
0.2110179067,
0.7726194859,
-0.5648877621,
0.5264527798,
-0.5921338797,
-0.0601067021,
0.935025692,
0.3188247383,
0.3118191361,
-0.1541774273,
-0.244347319,
-0.1291645914,
-0.5894861221,
0.0197929293,
0.1355831027,
0.5321500301,
-0.4026805162,
1.0131750107,
-0.1083805785,
0.8856519461,
-0.1884454787,
-0.4682769477,
0.2509278059,
-0.5641233325,
-0.2770439386,
-0.2409713119,
0.8224845529,
0.2910504639,
0.406281054,
0.0044079321,
-0.3324073553,
-0.0577777475,
-0.1467103511,
-0.7104401588,
0.6131387353,
0.0404026769,
-0.4067622423,
0.0252790116,
-0.5443686247,
-0.6746949553,
-0.3268783391,
-0.3953046799,
0.2062930018,
-0.431489408,
-0.2947925627,
0.1358528435,
0.4964281917,
0.811611712,
0.3626517057,
-0.9742244482,
0.0625540242,
0.6901775002,
0.8966400623,
-0.4311888814,
-0.500166297,
-0.282908231,
0.0280093513,
-0.612290442,
0.6434186697,
-0.5279570222,
-0.4675523639,
0.1426871568,
-0.0506744273,
-0.2417563945,
-0.5548473001,
0.6312480569,
-0.506640017,
-0.1775687337,
-0.0516884066,
-0.4681383967,
-0.2430725098,
0.5068214536,
-0.3260387778,
0.8350615501,
-0.0883977637,
-0.3162369132,
0.0757089406,
-0.4226380587,
-0.7633713484,
0.0593518615,
0.0879043415,
-0.1308422834,
0.2855075896,
0.3301785886,
0.74287045,
-0.6569093466,
0.3162825704,
-0.0469544716,
-0.3237131238,
0.1584564,
-0.5554371476,
0.5674521923,
0.4023386538,
-0.1158237606,
0.1865338683,
-0.7794642448,
0.0891398191,
0.0941384733,
-0.6004526019,
-0.1248365492,
-0.2817717493,
0.2054904103,
0.1967196614,
0.3338339925,
-0.4406666756,
0.239535436,
-0.5221899152,
0.6749575734,
0.6093502641,
-0.1955024153,
0.3749319017,
0.0107888654,
0.610861361,
-0.0445536599,
-0.0359540544,
-0.1223405823,
-0.6345022321,
-0.7755217552,
-0.3227386773,
0.401670754,
0.8183883429,
-0.373583436,
0.410504967,
-0.4085383713,
-0.6135289073,
-0.6844618917,
0.4599246979,
0.5298090577,
0.1935247034,
0.3906069398,
-0.0969514921,
-0.2739906609,
-1.0750344992,
-0.0486149117,
-0.0278789904,
0.0098875035,
0.0884541646,
0.7004158497,
-0.4830763638,
0.2311699539,
-0.3040507734,
-0.3829089999,
-0.369508028,
-0.1423738301,
0.322003603,
0.3266619146,
0.1821121126,
-0.8713317513,
-0.6828051805,
0.6670330763,
-0.7189372182,
0.0113906953,
0.0618211702,
0.1133572087,
0.4599986374,
0.5954055786,
-0.797429204,
0.2521023154,
0.9509057999,
-0.0862340555,
0.3653759956,
-0.402120769,
0.2532121241,
-1.4234865904,
0.1311065257,
-0.1004022956,
-0.2333752215,
-0.3545210361,
0.3931157887,
0.2265174985,
-0.2011596411,
-0.4676072896,
0.7397194505,
-0.422116369,
-0.0545353368,
-0.1211932972,
0.083240293,
-0.2990765274,
0.2901248634,
-0.2041516751,
0.9237403274,
0.4727784097,
-0.5935385823,
0.2307078093,
0.4129039645,
-0.5711473227,
0.5550385714,
-0.6894350052,
0.0461089835,
0.1113323644,
-0.0271511711,
-1.0460195541,
-0.3252926469,
-0.1311052144,
-0.4446551502,
0.5131586194,
0.1521800458,
-0.4980466366,
-0.1359371096,
0.0859606192,
0.319860816,
0.5344282389,
-0.2815733552,
0.7663587332,
0.1589210629,
-0.3062824309,
-0.4889661074,
-0.9220019579,
0.2783738375,
-0.2571223378,
-0.5796898603,
0.1446932107,
-0.2136580199,
-0.3871398568,
-0.3537116647,
0.1594571918,
0.0311831478,
-0.0721537545,
0.2607565224,
0.1763932407,
-0.2740074694,
-0.0703777373,
0.1682942212,
-0.0493641756,
-0.2325457335,
0.1530433297,
0.6618775725,
-0.3679076731,
-0.3901008666,
-0.2948159873,
0.4291042089,
0.8878858089,
-0.8630120158,
0.9193103313,
0.6508845091,
-0.4074190259,
-0.0255150031,
-0.6763902307,
0.2563776672,
-0.3693360686,
0.6747523546,
-0.6974152923,
-0.9239048362,
0.7314471602,
-0.0671571195,
0.1166572571,
0.5964515805,
1.1057639122,
0.1840790659,
1.1999872923,
0.6909264922,
-0.2329168767,
0.1826346368,
-0.2568969727,
0.4445741475,
-0.9552826881,
-0.265604198,
-0.5603941083,
-0.0890824124,
-0.8600763083,
-0.4774103463,
0.2373262495,
0.2912020087,
0.0111281583,
0.2785923183,
-0.1741788834,
0.4478264451,
0.2540712357,
-0.1258895248,
0.5885534286,
0.1429404616,
-0.016419135,
-0.0781737939,
-0.3165039718,
-0.6717219353,
1.2971224785,
0.4232404828,
0.6080334187,
0.3929787278,
0.3631193042,
0.2075429559,
0.3173086643,
-0.8765195012,
0.6789016724,
-0.3520770669,
-0.6776063442,
-0.3225801885,
-0.2842978239,
-0.9377488494,
0.44656232,
-0.2372677624,
-0.4959010482,
-0.1426477134,
-0.1709016114,
-0.1862340569,
0.2537181675,
-0.82627213,
0.5029327869,
-0.4593755901,
-0.3207479715,
-0.5365657806,
-0.4133347273,
0.521705687,
-0.4418976605,
0.3792716265,
-0.145835042,
-0.1237854734,
0.219245404,
0.0947559401,
0.6403003335,
0.3509985209,
-0.4027036428,
0.0114064738,
0.0805464312,
0.3944472671,
0.071874395,
-0.2880324125,
0.3148125708,
-0.0062180771,
-0.5380837917,
-0.2284185737,
0.841893971,
-0.8928035498,
-0.6250901818,
-0.3805875182,
-0.9019269943,
-0.2367085218,
0.324760139,
0.1335551143,
0.0228570569,
-0.0223488882,
0.4373140931,
0.5534550548,
-0.3688945174,
0.5257383585,
0.6163269281,
-0.4516476989,
-0.2614134848,
0.8252170682,
0.064027831,
0.4348978996,
0.4229623079,
0.1699589491,
-0.4346942008,
-0.9368901849,
-0.7785270214,
0.3573305607,
-0.6737531424,
-0.28571859,
-0.4898307621,
-0.2636494339,
-0.4918506145,
-0.1043340042,
-0.2989981771,
-0.0626452044,
-0.0929124728,
0.037760634,
0.1225438491,
0.8034299612,
0.2298363298,
0.1399893761,
-0.8661990762,
0.188075915,
0.4155712426,
0.1666402817,
-0.0173788052,
-0.9570573568,
-0.1372420639,
0.0351848118,
-0.2378409505,
-0.6612149477,
0.5334709883,
0.2570674419,
0.4505327642,
0.1125204787,
-0.4436024427,
0.7751087546,
-0.594627142,
0.7399235964,
-0.0091172392,
-0.8775010109,
0.4612550437,
-0.5162472725,
0.3223332465,
0.4255282581,
0.4849440753,
-0.4519540071,
-0.2808669209,
-0.0116086518,
-0.7412135005,
0.2822705805,
0.0737457722,
0.4489729404,
0.0861098096,
0.2461516708,
0.0030047074,
0.162240237,
-0.7221052051,
0.0426983424,
0.4264906943,
-0.012394622,
-0.5875176191,
-0.322067678,
0.1395172328,
-0.3690360487,
0.4934099615,
0.0265607145,
-0.1941438466,
-0.0974531397,
-0.2775759995,
-0.2047006637,
0.6273565292,
0.9098750949,
0.9248578548,
-0.0995006263,
-0.1800868511,
0.6257829666,
-0.4290271401,
0.1590974778,
0.3087779582,
-0.1046043187,
-0.3196584582,
0.6309369802,
0.7727161646,
0.0761662275,
-0.7775146961,
0.2774638236,
-0.019372059,
0.1146349832,
-0.2992275953,
-0.1657114327,
0.2177638859,
0.3023526073,
0.297916919,
0.0114968913,
-0.0665494278,
-0.5075321794,
-0.4254183173,
0.4976198971,
-0.1126588136,
-0.2238609344,
0.6632624269,
0.2470033914,
-0.4559071958,
0.6048067808,
-0.1724979877,
-0.3490204811,
0.3944523931,
0.8289504051,
0.438672632,
-0.5978614092,
-0.1607704014,
0.5516937971,
0.5926241279,
-0.2120991051,
0.1578763723,
0.2095353603,
-0.4739987254,
-0.9194213152,
-1.1203446388,
-0.3674227297,
0.3067589402,
-0.563031435,
0.3216925561,
-0.0346296355,
0.012922138,
-0.0501574762,
0.1726627499,
-0.7459210753,
0.1310424209,
0.0976724625,
0.8744542003,
-0.9849941134,
0.9356735349,
0.9395222068,
-0.4161273539,
-0.8393068314,
-0.2739680111,
-0.2820039392,
-0.9996753931,
0.647963047,
0.0276731048,
-0.1316258013,
0.2093385011,
-0.1855014861,
-0.8755866289,
0.9014768004,
0.4184225202,
-0.8996472359,
0.0887768343,
0.4318429828,
0.7601051927,
-0.2722389698,
0.1222970188,
0.5608531833,
0.5105617642,
-0.1155705228,
-1.4061763287,
-0.0930688977,
-0.2123996466,
0.2570562661,
0.2923455238,
-0.7977398634,
0.8069083691,
-0.2680312395,
0.0283212867,
0.2934177518,
0.6012551785,
0.3834327459,
0.1207079813,
0.3807343841,
0.5976421833,
0.5737509131,
0.089674674,
1.2827401161,
-0.2318802327,
0.1624821723,
0.7179158926,
-0.3764927089,
1.3458334208,
0.6041296124,
-0.3772898912,
0.1747400016,
0.5021151304,
0.1864793748,
0.1607073545,
0.2441135347,
-0.0797859803,
-0.4514279962,
-0.2937034667,
-0.5318656564,
0.8885534406,
0.4798027575,
-0.3759621084,
-0.0070535666,
0.2819335759,
0.056844078,
0.3025558591,
-0.4726617932,
0.4880039394,
0.2541516721,
-0.7793323398,
0.8353755474,
0.3001492918,
0.861048758,
-0.663905561,
-0.0732877925,
-0.5601273775,
0.3645578027,
-0.1022041216,
-0.7932197452,
0.3908738494,
0.2717277408,
-0.1352591962,
-0.2932210267,
0.6151453257,
-0.498467505,
-0.8722691536,
0.4368229806,
0.5981609821,
0.2083337605,
0.0145836901,
-0.4889036119,
0.4097436666,
0.0098545905,
-0.1442857385,
0.3895848095,
0.2613731325,
-0.4200540781,
0.8325397968,
0.6045647264,
0.3432817459,
0.1647710204,
-0.1772738397,
0.3753005862,
-0.5738806129,
-0.1324284375,
-0.864010334,
0.3331141174,
0.1342210323,
-0.5306009054,
0.9802880883,
0.6323279738,
0.8792026043,
-0.1635480821,
0.4364897311,
0.0154531505,
0.4718746543,
-0.5236253738,
0.678301394,
-0.7112135887,
0.2121004909,
0.0868707895,
-1.1865401268,
-0.3613105416,
0.3503895104,
-0.4566570818,
-0.0361605808,
0.5191839337,
0.7715985775,
-0.1477876306,
-0.2913588285,
0.545332253,
0.3232331574,
0.2600321174,
0.7561551332,
0.8471594453,
-0.4862937331,
0.7474125624,
-0.0556295775,
-0.1894255728,
-0.0637049526,
-0.7886352539,
-0.9797291756,
-0.6699427962,
-0.146471262,
-0.1806456298,
-0.1567544192,
0.7105445266,
0.6081447601,
-0.9227862358,
-0.4598373175,
0.335138768,
-0.0208311453,
-0.0520324297,
-0.0845862776,
0.4154316783,
-0.2207310349,
-1.066246748,
0.5191709995,
0.2661063075,
-0.1258793324,
-0.3996643722,
-0.1221796796,
-0.4139769971,
-0.0309896804,
1.0619566441,
0.1058418453,
-0.9494839907,
-0.0342253,
0.108831808,
-0.2741372287,
-0.2138781846,
0.3736350834,
-0.2237863094,
0.2783083916,
0.3571631908,
0.9126563072,
0.5160945058,
-0.194364056,
0.390186429,
-0.5780894756,
0.2914496362,
0.0277482644,
0.291962862,
0.6577064991,
-0.1031841561,
0.527128756,
-0.2484287024,
-0.7182311416,
-1.0355223417,
0.1193257868,
-0.9086235166,
-0.0915732086,
1.3509806395,
0.0262521598,
-0.1525876671,
0.1313489079,
-0.272488296,
0.2904549837,
0.0111807566,
0.6412616968,
0.7788398862,
0.1145473868,
-0.0894882828,
-0.9690279961,
0.1324945837,
0.6122819185,
-0.8930144906,
-0.0386670381,
0.2634023726,
0.1503330469,
0.3257961571,
0.4499275088,
-0.1555726081,
-0.0293512195,
-0.4488997161,
-0.1466413438,
0.0192942377,
-0.1226556376,
-0.6062501073,
-0.1331637949,
0.4380552471,
-0.0802737474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09214v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09214v3
|
Mind's Mirror: Distilling Self-Evaluation Capability and Comprehensive Thinking from Large Language Models
| 2023-11-15T18:56:23 | 2024-04-07T19:17:53 |
Weize Liu, Guocong Li, Kai Zhang, Bang Du, Qiyuan Chen, Xuming Hu, Hongxia Xu, Jintai Chen, Jian Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable advancements in natural
language processing. However, the massive scale and computational demands of
these models present formidable challenges when considering their practical
deployment in resource-constrained environments. While techniques such as
chain-of-thought (CoT) distillation have displayed promise in distilling LLMs
into small language models (SLMs), there is a risk that distilled SLMs may
still inherit flawed reasoning and hallucinations from LLMs. To address these
issues, we propose a twofold methodology: First, we introduce a novel method
for distilling the self-evaluation capability from LLMs into SLMs, aiming to
mitigate the adverse effects of flawed reasoning and hallucinations inherited
from LLMs. Second, we advocate for distilling more comprehensive thinking by
incorporating multiple distinct CoTs and self-evaluation outputs, to ensure a
more thorough and robust knowledge transfer into SLMs. Experiments on three NLP
benchmarks demonstrate that our method significantly improves the performance
of distilled SLMs, offering a new perspective for developing more effective and
efficient SLMs in resource-constrained environments.
|
[
-0.5188646317,
-0.6145266294,
1.0719206333,
0.2757525742,
-0.5163365602,
0.3783057034,
-0.4396109283,
-0.1796026528,
0.1419240981,
0.7187290192,
-0.5966215134,
-0.1137318239,
-0.7662302256,
0.2998197675,
-0.4296052158,
1.1716942787,
-0.1249886304,
0.141459167,
-0.1532068849,
-0.0940030515,
-0.5391850471,
-0.4376006424,
-0.4373306632,
-0.5188630223,
0.3008190393,
0.0337525159,
0.5592423081,
0.392644465,
0.5740565062,
0.2739693522,
-0.0486970209,
0.323073864,
-0.5818985701,
0.2650027275,
-0.6459367871,
-0.3236574829,
-0.3358826041,
0.0749921128,
0.5557416677,
0.5856003165,
-0.4369697869,
0.3571143746,
0.5388178825,
1.051637888,
-0.8217796087,
0.1128253713,
-1.0610755682,
0.0372839868,
0.1451375932,
0.0982746333,
-0.3148221672,
-0.2444658428,
0.2536564171,
-0.0163928401,
0.0637743548,
0.0110410191,
0.3949650526,
0.4620920122,
-0.0675156116,
-0.4260026813,
-0.8739457726,
0.8602309227,
-0.7137103081,
0.1770138294,
0.1119229496,
0.43721205,
-0.1741878092,
-0.7791216969,
-0.7256618738,
-0.01066963,
0.08584553,
-0.138757959,
-0.0071389023,
-0.1234741285,
0.0828384981,
0.5050371885,
-0.2813860476,
-0.2668129802,
-0.3512632549,
0.0907252505,
0.6831595302,
0.2745388746,
-0.0768818632,
-0.1250628084,
-0.419546634,
-0.187545687,
-0.4259110093,
-0.6649611592,
-0.0860294625,
0.5032560825,
0.2604165673,
0.3331492841,
-0.0014708786,
0.4207450449,
0.1109461412,
-0.322166115,
0.0833525509,
-0.536788702,
-0.4262296259,
0.0957272053,
0.7748565674,
0.2599141896,
0.1220407858,
-0.1945340633,
-0.4712288082,
-0.0238406826,
0.5733526349,
-0.6312357187,
-0.2365629822,
0.1892838627,
-0.4426039755,
-0.2761271596,
-0.3494726419,
-0.9903674722,
-0.72829175,
-0.3576993644,
0.6669718623,
-0.1536464989,
-0.307718873,
0.243982479,
-0.1230091825,
-0.0165672079,
0.1816191822,
-0.854197681,
0.5142679214,
0.7255057693,
0.9697824717,
-0.3896082044,
-0.1973843127,
-0.1434191912,
0.142484501,
-0.2399034798,
0.6193908453,
-0.3143055439,
-0.4174503982,
-0.1276440471,
-0.2449975014,
0.2386639714,
-0.7371572256,
0.4076837897,
-0.1967275888,
0.0770726353,
-0.5114135146,
-0.2639155388,
0.0508820564,
0.246660009,
-0.6169971824,
0.8182885051,
0.1304910928,
-0.6674823761,
0.2752532363,
-0.3473359346,
-0.3345607817,
-0.0451871864,
-0.2876330614,
-0.2542533278,
0.5114732981,
0.4007726908,
0.3878122866,
-0.544975996,
0.3323442936,
-0.3799918294,
-0.078025043,
0.0733515173,
-0.5845938325,
0.6107192636,
0.4779319465,
-0.5417316556,
-0.2458631843,
-0.5074166656,
0.1567703784,
0.1506424397,
0.1536817253,
-0.5291244984,
0.0460134037,
-0.211173892,
0.3394088745,
0.3128151596,
-0.3339623511,
0.2771126032,
-0.3363606334,
0.4765509367,
0.873501718,
-0.0836739019,
0.5402724743,
-0.189679876,
0.2699231207,
0.0129429074,
0.2882060409,
0.2157364488,
-0.222434178,
-0.9511342645,
-0.1081759185,
-0.1498385221,
0.2219354808,
-0.929251492,
0.4282459021,
-0.1721443534,
-0.5999597311,
-0.7938891649,
0.4310629964,
0.428781271,
0.4865387976,
0.4954784214,
-0.3914340138,
-0.4268519282,
-0.9539121389,
-0.3385277092,
-0.1991631091,
0.1377691776,
0.0575229935,
0.5787078738,
-0.2085244954,
0.8267560005,
-0.672819376,
-0.6475035548,
-0.6085686088,
0.1456621289,
0.2874001563,
0.3030316234,
0.2236716002,
-0.4097961783,
-0.3497665524,
-0.3639113605,
-0.7120318413,
-0.1680300236,
-0.3789505064,
-0.1884829998,
0.074274525,
0.2143469155,
-0.3147357404,
0.2163919657,
0.5262872577,
-0.0585239306,
0.6025570631,
-0.4172764421,
0.0000368052,
-1.0763468742,
-0.25461182,
-0.070644103,
-0.1658395976,
-0.2846741974,
0.2039459646,
-0.1011337116,
0.2182275653,
-0.2480303645,
0.3803229928,
-0.6596349478,
0.062595427,
-0.424584657,
0.3979708552,
0.2211066484,
0.2433347851,
-0.0416169167,
0.7663289905,
0.3146159649,
-0.3871825039,
0.329505682,
0.1461380124,
-0.504026711,
0.5555099845,
-0.3295613527,
0.4078123569,
-0.2050461173,
0.1149535701,
-0.703725636,
0.3436969817,
-0.0233225711,
0.1986501366,
0.302757293,
0.0881234184,
-0.4449051619,
-0.4424563348,
-0.3356997073,
0.2543608546,
0.4940937459,
-0.6484143734,
0.7449492216,
0.5153738856,
-0.1007344797,
-0.6216113567,
-0.91177845,
0.3325677216,
-0.2952732146,
-0.2395981103,
0.2476914525,
-0.0119106239,
-0.4726608694,
-0.0550549962,
-0.3309211135,
-0.1108193025,
0.0244756658,
0.0472426638,
0.3301549554,
0.093275331,
0.142485112,
0.0568876043,
0.0795739442,
0.3100815713,
-0.3422477543,
0.5684147477,
-0.4683879316,
-0.3813204467,
-0.1544453055,
0.2743047476,
0.6058353186,
-0.1667005867,
0.7605772018,
0.303283602,
-0.2572330534,
-0.7916159034,
-0.9642230272,
-0.3559248745,
-0.5241100192,
0.4669120312,
-0.3349506259,
-0.7490235567,
0.3486157954,
-0.2050569206,
0.0444578864,
0.2632815242,
0.6478150487,
-0.1464392096,
0.938444972,
0.6620258689,
-0.2697786689,
0.1366429776,
-0.3934710026,
0.6887677908,
-1.1245292425,
-0.2551176548,
-0.2854611278,
-0.3255256414,
-0.3718158603,
-0.6731823683,
0.3924412131,
-0.0512057543,
0.0319541842,
0.3034409881,
-0.7466017604,
0.5468919873,
0.1665643305,
0.1434375942,
0.5487263799,
-0.0405335464,
-0.2555515766,
-0.1476856768,
-0.5871478319,
-0.7886445522,
1.1719962358,
0.4070275128,
1.0558639765,
-0.1615802348,
0.9948759675,
0.1717122495,
0.4764311612,
-0.5640987754,
0.6345093846,
-0.200063616,
-0.7319896221,
-0.3096557856,
-0.4246170521,
-0.4546513557,
0.5150075555,
-0.1967873871,
-0.6564166546,
-0.0954092294,
-0.0082470225,
-0.4484520555,
0.5558321476,
-0.6196542382,
0.5663240552,
-0.4529901147,
-0.4664659202,
-0.5814736485,
-0.2625923455,
0.5021711588,
-0.4455370605,
0.5050679445,
-0.0549799949,
0.0569851696,
0.576928556,
-0.3234064281,
0.5530728698,
-0.0019577814,
-0.3165422678,
0.553475976,
0.3946737051,
0.3819708526,
0.0321434923,
-0.0156192994,
0.1422426105,
0.227594614,
-0.0232899953,
-0.9409375787,
0.8666276932,
-0.4667538404,
-1.0291801691,
-0.5790104866,
-0.454300046,
-0.3078591228,
0.0423505493,
-0.0948733762,
0.1205207035,
-0.0875274688,
-0.0653538629,
0.5160848498,
-0.0376261733,
0.5266384482,
0.3692163229,
-0.5507898331,
-0.4637570977,
0.7867546678,
0.2429210544,
0.5020124912,
-0.2430202067,
0.2672315836,
-0.4559029341,
-0.6725072265,
-0.1465767771,
0.3896734715,
-0.8406025767,
-0.1663041264,
-0.4181582034,
-0.2085719854,
-0.2362364829,
0.0020007696,
-0.8148007989,
-0.1754390597,
-0.1216769442,
-0.0258790385,
-0.0295402799,
0.9117944241,
-0.1075602546,
0.006783844,
-0.736754477,
0.3857066035,
0.5211230516,
0.5414115191,
0.3265181184,
-0.4683873951,
-0.1882893592,
0.291002363,
-0.4519497156,
-0.7490694523,
0.5021660924,
0.0716639087,
0.503988862,
0.3612208366,
0.2082784325,
0.984952569,
-0.6310527921,
0.7540650368,
0.287178129,
-1.0551912785,
0.6509885192,
0.2112566382,
0.2013504952,
1.0477448702,
0.305157423,
-0.3317423165,
-0.679276526,
-0.3678018749,
-0.768496573,
0.317820102,
0.1544581354,
0.2666420937,
-0.2449552566,
0.440810889,
0.2000271678,
0.2963386774,
-0.7656705379,
-0.0678172037,
0.0152592696,
-0.105012022,
-0.1496105641,
-0.2311840504,
-0.1725948155,
-0.4234080017,
0.6557535529,
-0.0608279891,
-0.0068911151,
0.4836986363,
-0.2487021536,
0.0701507851,
0.1857152432,
0.2114881575,
0.7458571792,
-0.1862727106,
0.5672256351,
0.6415966153,
-0.434877187,
0.2262534946,
-0.590441525,
0.0958500355,
-0.1388312131,
0.2357949615,
0.4778871536,
-0.010264582,
-0.5765094161,
0.4439279139,
-0.1064181402,
0.062778756,
-0.2956006825,
0.1350711435,
0.1812994629,
0.4311104715,
0.3698328733,
-0.1128068119,
0.2858664691,
-0.8550516367,
0.0967194065,
0.5293425322,
-0.3764837384,
-0.0585532822,
0.4768901467,
0.1724195033,
-0.1488293856,
0.6816470623,
-0.2589231133,
-0.5279919505,
0.1744543463,
0.6016622186,
1.3340847492,
-0.0911912248,
0.0633338988,
0.2239135206,
0.5471282005,
-0.5530955791,
0.141907081,
-0.1074609011,
-0.7086699009,
-0.5111832619,
-0.888959229,
-0.1841723323,
0.3298094571,
-0.7295438051,
0.1102070585,
-0.5929068327,
-0.5691993833,
-0.2702605128,
0.0244475435,
-0.5613703728,
0.0033157349,
0.5344840288,
0.8686569929,
-0.8604204059,
0.8876939416,
0.1783895791,
-0.3399724662,
-0.64477247,
0.0123979999,
-0.1345799714,
-0.6452865601,
0.6605384946,
0.0722169206,
-0.6184991598,
-0.2769787312,
-0.3799347579,
-0.710451901,
1.048597455,
0.3672758341,
-0.919664681,
-0.1268859804,
0.1622217149,
0.6932030916,
-0.4925079942,
0.1401989162,
0.9649934173,
0.3093637526,
0.0387788676,
-1.2521950006,
0.2447242141,
0.1469541937,
0.2889911532,
0.0325542651,
-0.6312109232,
0.5631648898,
-0.4110726714,
-0.3162362576,
-0.1844234616,
0.5724498034,
0.2940853536,
0.160818398,
0.5821477771,
0.6512724757,
0.5966972709,
0.0075172214,
0.7323631644,
-0.2591395974,
0.3718743622,
1.471783042,
-0.6526859403,
0.9853568673,
0.9038196802,
-0.3221657574,
0.6061429381,
0.0013955993,
-0.0504759215,
0.8290510178,
0.3215798438,
-0.2799460888,
-0.24207367,
0.1524390727,
-0.1902103275,
0.534344852,
0.2910287678,
-0.4329311252,
-0.3148806095,
0.0698117167,
-0.0386902466,
0.4504499435,
-0.2738846242,
0.8265613914,
0.3749409318,
-0.8533211946,
0.5910388827,
-0.3331183493,
0.7319742441,
-0.3658124506,
-0.0432296023,
-0.0648401827,
0.3754608929,
-0.0201773718,
-0.895793438,
0.6471808553,
0.0472910553,
0.0696860775,
-0.7180613279,
0.6492143273,
-0.3299235404,
-0.637280643,
0.5559128523,
0.7104231119,
0.1724381447,
-0.1971628368,
-0.5912613273,
0.122625418,
-0.0064329021,
-0.1423461586,
0.5086368918,
0.4348987341,
0.2139446288,
0.9364626408,
0.3022935092,
0.5059726834,
-0.1374365389,
0.1744809747,
1.0885146856,
-0.5263783932,
-0.2763499022,
-1.3295162916,
0.2244538963,
-0.2338805199,
-0.099693343,
0.6490767598,
0.5829843283,
0.6869904995,
-0.0662211776,
0.8154960871,
0.135408476,
0.2789565325,
-0.3199386895,
1.0753376484,
-0.4285235703,
0.5030119419,
-0.5026633143,
-1.1703029871,
0.0107286666,
0.93026793,
-0.404815644,
-0.0439710394,
0.8921408057,
0.650809288,
0.2904027104,
0.0406748801,
0.2539077103,
0.2837329209,
0.3348821402,
0.669885397,
0.9408423901,
-0.2402798831,
0.3681622148,
-0.5443150401,
-0.2539918423,
0.1656571925,
-1.1169450283,
-1.0686943531,
-0.7564697862,
-0.3360908628,
-0.3684213459,
-0.011944348,
0.9966663718,
0.4400846362,
-0.6305920482,
-0.469037354,
-0.09841346,
0.2177353203,
-0.1275684237,
-0.1957211196,
0.1404501647,
-0.6674396396,
-0.507545352,
0.1833295375,
0.5440089107,
-0.0865929052,
-0.9980050325,
0.1170715317,
0.031351991,
0.2547983229,
0.7027234435,
-0.3944926262,
-0.8704690933,
-0.4073961377,
-0.2737717032,
-0.0938227847,
-0.0636165813,
0.7166082859,
-1.0106259584,
0.7571954131,
0.2662405372,
0.3891739547,
0.5152519345,
-0.2514962554,
0.6677139401,
-0.3401939273,
-0.0549256429,
0.4099470973,
0.3591375947,
0.2882438898,
-0.2057113647,
0.4998814762,
-0.0987565815,
-0.468413204,
-1.0707945824,
0.1550748795,
-0.7197224498,
-0.49197644,
1.0921611786,
-0.0325098261,
-0.3231317103,
-0.0158767961,
-0.277918458,
0.1988366842,
-0.0429874621,
1.4052712917,
0.8933576345,
-0.0305929594,
-0.0393582992,
-0.4042209089,
0.6128684282,
0.3976109922,
-0.6835631728,
0.4308076203,
0.1893433183,
0.395016402,
0.2689616084,
0.4472592473,
-0.2919264734,
-0.2744745016,
-0.0144410627,
-0.0313476771,
-0.0066582458,
-0.4292135537,
-0.3913450539,
0.1082913801,
0.1791611016,
0.0987868607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09213v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09213v3
|
GENEVA: GENErating and Visualizing branching narratives using LLMs
| 2023-11-15T18:55:45 | 2024-06-05T20:59:27 |
Jorge Leandro, Sudha Rao, Michael Xu, Weijia Xu, Nebosja Jojic, Chris Brockett, Bill Dolan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dialogue-based Role Playing Games (RPGs) require powerful storytelling. The
narratives of these may take years to write and typically involve a large
creative team. In this work, we demonstrate the potential of large generative
text models to assist this process. \textbf{GENEVA}, a prototype tool,
generates a rich narrative graph with branching and reconverging storylines
that match a high-level narrative description and constraints provided by the
designer. A large language model (LLM), GPT-4, is used to generate the
branching narrative and to render it in a graph format in a two-step process.
We illustrate the use of GENEVA in generating new branching narratives for four
well-known stories under different contextual constraints. This tool has the
potential to assist in game development, simulations, and other applications
with game-like properties.
|
[
-0.2552196383,
-0.7570211887,
1.0408580303,
0.1020357534,
-0.3525145054,
0.2609025836,
0.1716078371,
-0.2981930971,
0.4619323611,
0.9889908433,
-1.0803596973,
-0.7884438634,
-0.5501738191,
0.0658429191,
-0.455373317,
1.0193164349,
-0.390996635,
-0.0386949144,
0.0337290876,
0.0524781123,
-0.4638924897,
-0.4642999172,
-0.7128075361,
-0.5503721833,
0.5376764536,
0.3566867113,
0.6760399938,
0.9116816521,
0.4414400756,
0.3597702086,
0.1243240535,
0.2478551418,
-0.9323959947,
0.5542515516,
-0.0526089035,
-0.3669348955,
-0.2783188224,
-0.0815059021,
0.4576684833,
0.4887988865,
0.0879148319,
-0.0237379652,
-0.1475796998,
0.4905789495,
0.1220486388,
0.5182641745,
-0.015238205,
0.3507716954,
-0.024909595,
-0.2289010733,
-0.165979296,
-0.4468067288,
0.3495327532,
-1.0652878284,
0.1497761905,
0.1756395251,
0.8557094336,
-0.2383220643,
-0.3870255947,
-0.6962094307,
-0.9779222012,
0.7188485861,
-0.7694773674,
-0.156852141,
0.1859254837,
0.2766782641,
-0.0798646808,
-0.9107274413,
-0.0613583587,
-0.2049776167,
0.0674304664,
0.343108505,
-0.0482392609,
0.199193567,
0.5412619114,
0.4546495378,
-0.3363192081,
0.2920210063,
-0.353277415,
-0.0717983469,
0.7769889832,
0.7305614352,
0.5785562992,
-0.2457959205,
-0.3691551089,
-0.0152668664,
-0.9372662902,
-0.2420298904,
0.4725865126,
-0.0951650739,
-0.3044164181,
0.9165657759,
0.161252737,
0.4247088134,
-0.0219267961,
-0.6548193097,
-0.0576547384,
-0.332911998,
-0.0509162247,
-0.0302516967,
0.7968463302,
0.9107687473,
0.2884869874,
-0.0921448022,
-0.3022413552,
-0.1539599746,
0.2071396858,
-1.0334225893,
-0.0956417397,
0.1334356368,
-0.6819329858,
-0.2815036476,
-0.0472694002,
-0.6212038994,
-0.6817312837,
-0.2002705634,
-0.0548616759,
-0.6752102375,
-0.0748512745,
-0.092092514,
-0.4908202589,
0.2454665601,
0.6470596194,
-1.1252453327,
0.1366321892,
0.7810232639,
1.1595081091,
-0.4062135816,
-0.1668029428,
-0.5612575412,
0.5202713609,
-0.7078183889,
0.4959155023,
-0.279473871,
-0.8552893996,
0.2766800225,
0.0045087268,
0.5349430442,
-0.4994309545,
0.5836681128,
-0.3675564826,
-0.1273461431,
-0.0496582016,
-0.8230355382,
-0.0453251041,
0.2732580304,
-0.8419862986,
0.4883212745,
0.2595054507,
-0.631110549,
0.1530731022,
-0.3683284223,
-0.4570780098,
0.3506807387,
-0.3954419196,
-0.2018894553,
0.4063795209,
0.1200838313,
0.3143617213,
-0.618282795,
0.4094359875,
0.1408008486,
-0.4529714584,
0.0593909696,
-0.158472538,
0.5672283769,
0.1521072239,
-0.1871583313,
0.3633828461,
-0.4681022465,
-0.072079137,
0.0582684018,
-0.1289461851,
-0.0567862689,
0.4517017007,
-0.2049067467,
-0.0098302998,
-0.0609326474,
-0.2915312648,
0.5423102379,
-0.3588498533,
0.3296559453,
0.465246588,
0.3922533691,
0.3419781029,
-0.5930386186,
0.8437198997,
-0.1574123353,
0.0113288201,
-0.7448009849,
-0.8392531276,
-0.7705590725,
-0.3074708879,
-0.0178316273,
0.5596936941,
-1.150393486,
0.3032141626,
0.071180962,
-0.4619885385,
-0.1889089048,
-0.2285465747,
0.0647311509,
0.3066598773,
0.0375927463,
-0.4732723534,
-0.4515877962,
-0.8103322387,
0.1397935599,
-0.4387542009,
-0.4200263917,
0.387493968,
0.4073766768,
-0.3625462651,
0.9500197768,
-0.8800975084,
-0.2466580719,
-0.5917093754,
0.6208965182,
0.1855700165,
0.1324131638,
0.3054840267,
-0.5657989383,
-0.3036184311,
0.0430816077,
-1.0673581362,
-0.2703310847,
-0.4864181876,
-0.0113371173,
-0.0010517894,
0.6026421189,
-0.603097558,
0.4993816912,
0.6013153195,
-0.2971671224,
0.9685429931,
-0.3565725386,
0.3139293492,
-1.0542978048,
-0.1840592325,
-0.1884022206,
-0.2637414038,
-0.8468712568,
0.1759805232,
-0.2911852896,
-0.2870358229,
-0.2701874673,
0.4099776149,
-0.6528654099,
-0.1511062086,
-0.0615148246,
0.3696857989,
0.0214200988,
0.1097596437,
0.3353019655,
0.4515989423,
0.5550751686,
-0.3609655201,
0.8369823694,
0.3871493936,
-0.4779829681,
0.4060193002,
-0.6544367671,
-0.1246513501,
-0.0526188351,
0.2486355752,
-0.6836310029,
-0.3972112536,
0.1363104284,
-0.086926803,
0.1069413871,
-0.4832291901,
-0.7500896454,
-0.2863226831,
-0.3689301908,
0.0875013694,
0.6847189069,
-0.3775602281,
0.6374301314,
0.268956244,
-0.447712183,
0.0667672232,
-0.8148059249,
0.166574806,
-0.5121640563,
-0.760812521,
0.4503576159,
-0.2893429697,
-0.3237303495,
-0.1471488178,
0.2864309847,
-0.1854266524,
-0.3357776701,
0.5070337057,
0.4804233015,
-0.2533844709,
-0.0502433665,
0.0878978595,
-0.1138732955,
0.1670182943,
-0.2141034305,
0.4277953804,
0.2271843851,
-0.5184925199,
-0.0954441428,
0.6690956354,
0.6327518225,
-0.0504105911,
0.5785335302,
0.2343892902,
-0.0492454991,
-0.2017066032,
-0.2733384371,
0.0249247346,
-0.4910914004,
0.2816289961,
-0.2214253396,
-1.1874657869,
0.7230314016,
-0.601664722,
0.1741884053,
0.3867503405,
0.6683875918,
0.1758614779,
0.9146966338,
0.496861428,
0.2490407228,
0.2550472021,
-0.3175797164,
0.3378062546,
-0.7644898891,
-0.2555426955,
-0.0126493471,
-0.0363185368,
-0.5705538988,
-0.9256978035,
0.4125457704,
0.3862618506,
-0.1309793144,
-0.0119834514,
-0.2447472811,
0.5394642353,
0.1921152622,
-0.5188986659,
0.6096938848,
0.063951008,
-0.2796728909,
-0.4118067622,
-0.6085651517,
-0.6130968332,
0.6873527765,
0.5111060739,
1.2171404362,
0.1152417585,
1.1653448343,
0.0485402457,
0.348757863,
-0.8451152444,
0.5004850626,
0.0496318452,
-0.4937395751,
-0.5443667769,
-0.5715415478,
-0.864759028,
-0.0101716127,
-0.3176089525,
-0.8127658963,
-0.1857905537,
-0.3723141551,
-0.4092139006,
0.3995409012,
-0.7509369254,
0.4815939069,
-0.2631938756,
-0.1956331432,
0.0777269378,
-0.4064118266,
0.5352797508,
-0.2437323332,
0.1221750006,
-0.0657661408,
0.0512466431,
0.3401162624,
-0.4458545148,
0.7499371171,
0.2194791287,
-0.2946467698,
0.6572028399,
0.5306451321,
0.4918399453,
0.3261184394,
0.129663527,
0.1000227109,
-0.2525965273,
0.1822783649,
-0.4034307003,
0.8978152275,
-0.7388001084,
-0.8281802535,
-0.7432592511,
-0.9228615165,
0.1002739593,
0.3230572045,
0.3162181675,
0.6093137264,
-0.7889906764,
-0.086000368,
0.5488547087,
-0.5525981784,
0.3234749138,
0.3402011991,
-0.9500461817,
-0.3368569016,
0.6861560345,
0.301199615,
0.5461797118,
0.0468124524,
0.0075048935,
-0.0295305606,
-0.6952796578,
-0.626023531,
0.4001752734,
-0.4677013755,
-0.2611351013,
-0.2204060405,
-0.6578217745,
0.1292749494,
-0.6225497127,
-0.1194692105,
-0.3649794161,
-0.375698179,
-0.2665689886,
0.5141298771,
1.5292550325,
-0.1331181675,
0.2310043424,
-0.7612394094,
0.5761150718,
0.3390122056,
0.3396472037,
-0.1437906772,
-0.0321380086,
-0.1743969321,
-0.1241951436,
-0.4243732989,
-0.9598197937,
0.6282621622,
-0.2515927255,
0.1910043806,
0.510040462,
-0.2508081794,
0.5476174951,
-1.0953975916,
0.9961645603,
0.6958765984,
-0.8711605668,
0.3171850741,
-0.7894942164,
0.6075178385,
0.0094632376,
0.4234318435,
-0.7599150538,
-0.599160254,
-0.5104863644,
-0.9036082625,
0.873991251,
0.4955316484,
0.0895458087,
-0.0750601888,
0.4237958789,
0.0409048572,
0.0704583675,
-0.4821389318,
-0.3800871372,
-0.1359448284,
0.0668740645,
-0.2056125551,
-0.4068599045,
-0.4332572222,
0.0127771096,
0.4079689682,
-0.0598127581,
0.233128652,
0.1301267296,
0.2445611805,
-0.252632767,
0.036863111,
0.3245544732,
1.0771076679,
-0.0459496863,
-0.0872282013,
0.1094645411,
-0.3322438598,
0.2307278216,
0.1072036698,
-0.4620025456,
0.2330636978,
0.7383999228,
0.9000920653,
0.2158612162,
-0.561914742,
0.3498351574,
-0.2774163187,
-0.430927366,
-0.1753192991,
0.0421965681,
0.8311693072,
0.4450720847,
0.3459351957,
-0.490634501,
0.1670703292,
-0.8325693011,
0.2381044626,
0.1985850185,
-0.3684087098,
0.0859606862,
0.4536712766,
0.2803892195,
-0.5536541343,
0.6442690492,
-0.325976193,
-0.2275506109,
0.6519336104,
0.8946086764,
0.8062869906,
-0.1809978485,
0.8811425567,
0.37415874,
0.1970439851,
-0.118618384,
-0.1177257895,
0.6138100624,
-0.3380377889,
-0.7390087843,
-0.5710744858,
-0.4984701276,
0.1946428567,
-0.4362142682,
0.2118169516,
-0.4686931074,
-0.0804248601,
-0.2112568915,
-0.0977308229,
-0.2133802325,
-0.089277409,
0.2453330755,
0.6693655849,
-0.5351667404,
0.572501719,
0.1164190769,
-0.4316609502,
-0.7520590425,
-0.0099022621,
0.158792153,
-0.4616751075,
0.6236871481,
0.0235629547,
-0.1886713654,
-0.1300071329,
-0.4011108875,
-0.7361702323,
1.3508996964,
0.2966762483,
-1.0213367939,
-0.336124599,
0.2791095078,
0.6985900998,
-1.0035521984,
-0.0002432537,
0.4812247753,
0.295004338,
0.5636403561,
-0.4770203531,
-0.167784974,
0.2148523778,
0.3226774931,
0.1872476935,
-0.4037066698,
0.8885415792,
-0.2464958727,
-0.4596571624,
0.5065045357,
0.6983193755,
0.6033089757,
0.092495285,
0.1754535437,
0.3758289814,
0.5900552273,
-0.3804947436,
1.2084485292,
-0.147920832,
0.2946611047,
0.8726397753,
-0.4730169773,
0.1217321381,
0.1256330758,
0.2459620982,
0.7634048462,
0.511326313,
-0.1072219759,
0.3459973037,
0.6657543778,
-0.3049198985,
0.0020081452,
-0.1753378063,
-0.2256706953,
0.0261442922,
0.4536774755,
-0.3628339469,
-0.2933498323,
-0.1624703407,
0.2369164973,
-0.0681043789,
-0.5000448227,
0.8214617372,
0.3485755622,
-0.6985113025,
0.2155715525,
0.0139847109,
0.2278703004,
-1.1415120363,
-0.5549785495,
-0.2269983888,
-0.0362007357,
0.068064712,
-0.9568797946,
0.1235591322,
0.2259710729,
-0.0507312454,
-0.527505219,
0.6974779963,
-0.6892767549,
-0.703961432,
0.4856731892,
0.6964309812,
0.1593946964,
0.3823457658,
-0.6072675586,
0.4486877918,
0.0770410225,
-0.0389493257,
0.1365561485,
0.9348731041,
-0.1188480407,
0.4318662584,
0.3642100394,
0.133762002,
-0.2396513075,
0.3336040378,
0.9449633956,
-0.6223728061,
-0.5488751531,
-0.7718957067,
0.4290044308,
-0.2053931206,
-0.1757505238,
1.0058088303,
0.7836850882,
0.2991943657,
-0.1552962065,
0.9307413697,
-0.0169739537,
0.2448117286,
-0.7093009949,
0.6419287324,
-0.061763484,
0.175676927,
-0.2694176733,
-1.0649374723,
-0.1715800166,
0.5266195536,
-0.0540532246,
-0.1642327756,
0.9696731567,
0.5078960061,
0.0051376489,
-0.1425159425,
0.5018453002,
0.3273381889,
0.562651515,
0.5075115561,
1.0842574835,
0.1173751131,
0.2425132394,
0.3792623878,
-0.4651865363,
-0.03796608,
-0.9137920141,
-1.2828109264,
-0.56563586,
-0.1939062029,
-0.4221452773,
0.1193548888,
0.3148746789,
0.5980077386,
-0.3985235393,
-0.7644326687,
-0.0531163849,
0.1935884804,
0.130136326,
-0.2133889794,
0.1827047616,
-0.0808178857,
-0.6070221066,
0.4464323521,
0.5894474983,
0.1342644542,
-0.6975135803,
-0.4065886736,
-0.1808895916,
0.3321846426,
0.7420912981,
0.1352306455,
-0.571280539,
-0.3376016319,
-0.1978717893,
0.0518481731,
0.034181267,
1.3506155014,
-0.3774056733,
0.7381547093,
0.2669974267,
0.3043186367,
1.2571017742,
0.010748907,
1.1681668758,
-0.5174806714,
-0.0409156531,
0.2872427702,
0.2167115062,
0.405082792,
-0.2017371953,
0.7132735848,
-0.0009145954,
-0.6239827275,
-0.3498785496,
0.6624982357,
-0.6883960366,
-0.2455536872,
1.2962173223,
-0.4529266357,
-0.0335328877,
-0.0990124792,
-0.6511158347,
0.1087644175,
-0.225867942,
0.3599545956,
1.293961525,
-0.4106986821,
-0.0127383443,
-0.8397758603,
0.8357744813,
-0.3528971374,
-1.0903558731,
0.0733523667,
0.9844742417,
-0.0104625747,
0.3787514567,
0.7590802908,
-0.27316764,
-0.1291488856,
0.1013301387,
-0.1577161252,
0.0506074466,
-0.3540301025,
-0.0970663577,
-0.0016706702,
0.0896716341,
0.5000537634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09212v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09212v3
|
Controllable Text Summarization: Unraveling Challenges, Approaches, and Prospects -- A Survey
| 2023-11-15T18:55:43 | 2024-05-28T02:04:50 |
Ashok Urlana, Pruthwik Mishra, Tathagato Roy, Rahul Mishra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Generic text summarization approaches often fail to address the specific
intent and needs of individual users. Recently, scholarly attention has turned
to the development of summarization methods that are more closely tailored and
controlled to align with specific objectives and user needs. Despite a growing
corpus of controllable summarization research, there is no comprehensive survey
available that thoroughly explores the diverse controllable attributes employed
in this context, delves into the associated challenges, and investigates the
existing solutions. In this survey, we formalize the Controllable Text
Summarization (CTS) task, categorize controllable attributes according to their
shared characteristics and objectives, and present a thorough examination of
existing datasets and methods within each category. Moreover, based on our
findings, we uncover limitations and research gaps, while also exploring
potential solutions and future directions for CTS. We release our detailed
analysis of CTS papers at
https://github.com/ashokurlana/controllable_text_summarization_survey.
|
[
-0.2853918672,
-0.361399591,
0.1887674332,
0.5601310134,
-0.0646726564,
0.6382422447,
-0.1799853146,
-0.3868800998,
0.3313481212,
0.4195434451,
-0.4310858548,
-0.5628429055,
-0.8677219748,
0.2984235287,
-0.5080011487,
1.3168907166,
-0.4394981861,
-0.4097291231,
-0.069292739,
-0.2902525961,
-0.4381060004,
-0.6029247642,
-0.5301034451,
-0.1372537017,
0.6814718246,
0.3239016533,
0.4876717031,
0.3174278736,
0.8370653391,
0.1919402331,
-0.3607462645,
0.3499115407,
-0.2658908367,
0.261223942,
-0.0987449065,
-0.0951040983,
-0.5166020393,
0.1235311478,
0.6583341956,
0.6763981581,
0.0030519706,
0.1176598519,
0.4406169951,
0.6166422367,
-0.9427286386,
-0.1041172892,
-0.1770585179,
0.2484214306,
-0.2779785395,
-0.4271219373,
-0.3014327884,
-0.5687485337,
0.2119652033,
-0.5046830773,
0.0526924469,
-0.0227812622,
0.5479958057,
0.1941128373,
-0.9534732699,
-0.5405519605,
-0.788850069,
1.0093226433,
-0.5068399906,
0.005972553,
0.1871411502,
0.3337594867,
0.0430080742,
-0.6577043533,
0.0858893245,
-0.146171689,
-0.4629943073,
0.4908417165,
-0.3938263357,
-0.0373094305,
-0.1054796502,
0.2663963437,
-0.6190168262,
0.232683897,
-0.2478083521,
-0.3051355183,
0.6484472156,
0.4449196756,
0.2281444073,
-0.1222707406,
-0.4373835027,
0.1249531955,
-0.3176503181,
0.4197058678,
0.1169175208,
0.0735572949,
-0.4001517892,
0.8507273793,
-0.3639555871,
0.6367878914,
0.0250227991,
-0.0339504406,
-0.143888697,
-0.5196016431,
-0.0675100386,
-0.0122545762,
0.8022228479,
0.5998470783,
0.0194667205,
-0.1767599881,
-0.2058333009,
-0.654946804,
0.1449227035,
-0.4939113557,
0.0448630974,
0.5705143213,
-0.5610249639,
-0.4743260145,
0.0629874915,
-0.5974790454,
-0.4398555458,
-0.4077058136,
-0.0252110884,
-0.3346467018,
-0.2946341336,
-0.2733996511,
-0.5024223924,
0.1786267161,
0.5704987645,
-0.8125316501,
0.223290801,
0.3843076229,
0.9408322573,
-0.93789047,
0.0598788485,
0.1755962819,
0.44523862,
-0.2917551994,
0.7489897013,
-0.3904990554,
-0.694065392,
0.1321666539,
-0.2021556348,
-0.1458261162,
-0.2959319055,
0.2568312883,
-0.2069308013,
0.1916709244,
-0.3544884622,
-0.2705104351,
0.1293837726,
0.577151835,
-0.4887367785,
0.6413593888,
-0.0412221178,
-1.0684833527,
0.140356034,
-0.4880954325,
-0.3408143818,
-0.1813234389,
-0.1547901481,
-0.4611981213,
0.2096470892,
0.0025951914,
0.517996788,
-0.0695036724,
0.4978667796,
0.0806620046,
-0.0964642689,
0.5183338523,
-0.2297653109,
0.7907024622,
0.4424916208,
-0.1133049726,
0.3841678798,
-0.4660534859,
-0.0755237937,
-0.1611545682,
-0.2333496809,
-0.3016473055,
0.1277276278,
0.4938604534,
-0.1535355896,
0.7060833573,
-0.2618669868,
0.261194706,
0.3224696219,
0.2026758194,
0.5576275587,
0.0932484716,
0.6246507764,
-0.4666854143,
0.8151252866,
-0.1072190404,
0.1092998832,
-0.1539666951,
0.0434393808,
-0.2775357664,
-0.3819145262,
0.2417410761,
0.6487926841,
-0.6882388592,
0.4042271972,
-0.0717675686,
-0.884564817,
0.0953519121,
-0.2472937852,
0.7781257629,
0.2916709781,
0.3821472824,
0.0386248566,
-0.2642135918,
-1.0844099522,
-0.5649451613,
0.1084159911,
-0.3847806156,
0.1583349556,
0.4046134651,
0.1551625729,
1.0847363472,
-0.7198173404,
-0.6566783786,
-0.7616711855,
0.432649672,
-0.1852793843,
0.5963194966,
0.5442311168,
-0.8401297927,
-0.3534811735,
-0.0039672959,
-0.7897164822,
-0.3398702741,
-0.2206351459,
0.2914277613,
0.1851518154,
0.6839212179,
-0.2062721401,
0.5289388895,
0.5423568487,
-0.3534191251,
0.5925164819,
-0.3198835552,
0.4311965406,
-1.0821059942,
0.5314647555,
0.0083089117,
-0.0786798671,
-0.4480006993,
-0.0580572486,
0.1558622718,
-0.0163841117,
-0.3280652165,
0.3808595836,
-0.5209485888,
0.1844648123,
-0.2683078945,
0.1144175902,
-0.3361589909,
0.3872900605,
0.0885666236,
0.5826289058,
0.0579031594,
-0.7485914826,
0.2257590294,
0.2929112315,
0.2376480699,
0.5674382448,
-0.8793416619,
-0.4470764399,
-0.3660649359,
0.4773570001,
-0.9811516404,
-0.3455604315,
0.1976281404,
-0.5275390744,
0.4184509218,
0.3901719153,
-0.1653111279,
-0.0761536956,
-0.4586682618,
0.4511786103,
0.2982077301,
-0.0135932453,
0.6072966456,
0.5184906125,
-0.3892481625,
-0.5592602491,
-0.7727380991,
0.242893219,
-0.2424958497,
0.1405373961,
0.5415642262,
-0.0120159751,
-0.2887939215,
0.0074573355,
-0.3653734624,
-0.1023750454,
-0.0265771281,
0.0208241511,
0.0025616116,
0.4341465235,
0.0867109671,
0.5045781136,
-0.3459062576,
-0.1081166565,
0.0833108574,
-0.0255621243,
0.0949348211,
0.0558150783,
-0.609786272,
0.6959526539,
0.3144709468,
-0.5030501485,
0.4191638529,
0.2257248759,
-0.1467505693,
-0.1042550877,
-0.2595023513,
0.1380355209,
-0.3931493759,
0.2809437215,
-0.1132677123,
-1.2711048126,
0.5037525296,
-0.1040315256,
0.5393061638,
0.2977965474,
0.2721762359,
-0.4892302752,
0.7201802731,
0.7044435143,
-0.0778539404,
0.2093350291,
-0.0794381574,
0.10606163,
-0.6240719557,
-0.5003801584,
-1.0217577219,
-0.5839672685,
-0.8532087207,
0.2821953595,
0.4901138544,
-0.2637744248,
0.0536257774,
0.4938732684,
-0.8888657093,
0.1823413372,
0.4006003737,
-0.0221622083,
0.5080258846,
-0.4694420099,
0.2717249393,
-0.1353645176,
-0.4832774401,
-0.3786256909,
0.7210562229,
0.0509537309,
0.823481977,
0.1943475008,
0.6148924232,
0.4781130552,
0.3240836561,
-0.4292864203,
0.4906102717,
-0.2810583115,
-0.5781552196,
-0.4006292522,
-0.4293074608,
-1.1301716566,
0.0197036974,
-0.0634479076,
-0.7573488355,
0.0040608658,
0.5013123155,
-0.0241743363,
0.1919958442,
-0.5461493731,
0.7112855315,
-0.1612469554,
0.1085738912,
0.1147081628,
-0.8865843415,
0.4720515013,
0.0160896517,
0.1269209385,
-0.0164753925,
-0.3479149938,
1.0381958485,
-0.3220725954,
0.704656899,
0.0570353605,
-0.2501747608,
0.3021609485,
-0.0665069818,
0.1495070606,
-0.1350153536,
0.5474478006,
-0.0851506814,
0.282574594,
-0.6213394403,
-0.33643502,
0.6474946737,
-0.3248961866,
-0.3367005587,
-0.7328723669,
-0.6125181317,
-0.2554026544,
0.367113471,
0.5884544849,
0.5070079565,
-0.2906925082,
0.221714288,
0.7551051974,
-0.2469472289,
0.8952437043,
0.1799317747,
-0.1891178042,
-0.5209751129,
0.7740392685,
0.43461743,
0.1406901181,
0.8452097178,
-0.1499021202,
-0.2039919645,
-0.8075421453,
0.1413945854,
-0.1180487052,
-0.0616152771,
-0.2076432705,
-0.6266236901,
-0.3270587921,
-0.3622758687,
-0.5665647388,
-0.2562127113,
-0.6809592843,
-0.3828785717,
-0.1110718548,
0.2525382936,
0.7612138391,
0.3120423555,
0.6247273088,
-0.8391860723,
0.5926974416,
0.107119821,
0.4233387113,
-0.2097549736,
-0.2453388721,
-0.2364087254,
-0.2161720544,
-0.4177414775,
-0.9653906822,
0.2574389875,
-0.2730354965,
0.3313221335,
0.3922053576,
0.540630579,
0.2764501274,
-0.055326961,
0.8319524527,
0.2996671498,
-0.8251131773,
0.7307631969,
-0.6196805239,
0.6459721327,
0.7128962278,
0.4587659836,
-0.5477077961,
-0.887075901,
-0.4389035404,
-0.9316480756,
0.4383341968,
0.5878595114,
-0.1299299002,
0.333384037,
0.1107860208,
-0.0517646372,
0.381693244,
-0.3925884068,
-0.3535369039,
0.0847424194,
-0.4672816396,
-0.2925225198,
-0.2546293736,
-0.0307486132,
0.2779576778,
0.4893049002,
0.2991456091,
-0.0512397029,
0.2447938174,
-0.0436454415,
0.3268737495,
0.5546240807,
0.7675876021,
0.6585993171,
-0.459433794,
0.1909928918,
-0.2411569208,
-0.759983778,
0.1888696551,
0.1431563199,
-0.586946547,
0.1464734077,
0.3706233501,
0.1405614763,
0.0917057991,
-0.5482722521,
0.514513433,
-0.2390073985,
-0.3291353583,
-0.4157604873,
-0.0598878451,
-0.1268058419,
-0.1418430805,
0.4444018304,
0.0221039224,
0.1292003691,
0.090827778,
-0.1432572454,
0.4640759528,
-0.6668195724,
-0.1158376187,
0.8210352063,
0.3660037518,
0.0052727344,
0.1365390569,
0.0573662594,
-0.0168444347,
0.6396917105,
0.2997393906,
1.0173746347,
-0.2046648264,
0.2122971565,
0.1836784482,
0.5788654089,
0.2488093376,
0.1430130005,
-0.2257498205,
-0.3675222099,
-0.2924388945,
-0.057398472,
-0.8314960599,
-0.1167907566,
-0.8967471123,
-0.0724192336,
-0.4413946569,
-0.1779725254,
-0.0243613329,
-0.11999771,
-0.1806847602,
0.3700958192,
-0.577244699,
1.2162034512,
-0.7354393601,
0.2067268342,
0.7050100565,
-0.3714115024,
-0.4451051652,
-0.3116398156,
0.2741669416,
-0.056472335,
0.1762965173,
-0.0433913618,
-0.0992685705,
0.066850096,
-0.7633703947,
-0.5319314003,
1.188954711,
-0.2657711208,
-0.2279568464,
-0.1535206139,
0.1475872248,
0.2896764576,
0.0288378559,
0.0627590865,
0.5875998139,
0.6528625488,
0.011984528,
-0.8331562281,
-0.0478804372,
-0.3882679045,
0.0399836749,
0.360195905,
-0.7410184145,
0.3348950446,
0.0815665945,
-0.0196795277,
0.0368598476,
0.867752254,
0.1899309754,
0.7582526207,
0.112416178,
0.4320488274,
0.2067450881,
-0.3911702037,
0.8740382195,
0.1329384297,
0.1505602747,
1.2237397432,
-0.0326619297,
0.3109790385,
0.5238767266,
-0.2742784619,
-0.1663099676,
0.5695259571,
0.1711394936,
0.3239959776,
0.1319960654,
-0.2308098525,
0.0651642159,
-0.3737635016,
-0.4034019411,
0.417581737,
0.302072376,
-0.2680950165,
-0.4772963822,
0.1559613645,
0.2315834016,
0.3329112232,
-0.4543217421,
0.8882015347,
-0.1781058609,
-0.6313489079,
0.0241342876,
0.1045187861,
0.8339122534,
-0.9803317189,
0.2027028948,
-0.3337972164,
-0.1950272769,
-0.2952587903,
-0.814864397,
0.4688591659,
0.3621056378,
0.0153044211,
-0.7622056603,
0.5538775325,
-0.3012776375,
-0.1690171808,
-0.2428019494,
0.322372973,
0.0890237018,
0.1350261867,
-0.0085036689,
-0.1360404491,
0.230629459,
-0.1595685929,
0.4556359649,
0.2936094105,
-0.2345892787,
0.7963377237,
0.1918613315,
0.1053090915,
-0.1224743426,
-0.4079739153,
0.7385227084,
-0.8623533845,
-0.5974092484,
-0.4302818179,
0.9024236202,
-0.2416040599,
-0.7378097177,
0.9287689328,
0.8503808379,
0.704844892,
-0.1832823455,
1.0340224504,
-0.2739737928,
0.6814806461,
-0.3239138126,
0.9921284318,
-0.4594611228,
-0.0354201756,
-0.2715895474,
-0.6803534031,
-0.68093431,
-0.1869365722,
0.0332116112,
-0.0044164024,
0.6849133968,
0.4385678768,
0.2918249965,
-0.2866206765,
0.0724718124,
-0.0983676016,
0.4006828368,
0.3451226652,
0.7354794145,
0.0785866752,
0.5957041979,
-0.2002763748,
-0.6125513315,
-0.1787041128,
-1.0678776503,
-0.7213608623,
-0.6328244209,
-0.5349928141,
-0.1184024736,
0.0309699923,
0.5492126346,
0.1032270491,
-0.9892918468,
-0.2603023052,
-0.2084973454,
0.4752472937,
-0.2490620911,
-0.2531782687,
0.6183189154,
-0.3134303689,
-0.7465609908,
-0.2214259356,
0.2467185259,
0.3920708001,
0.209612608,
0.3154813647,
0.1297357082,
-0.0479843058,
0.4220470786,
0.7413864732,
-0.3852140903,
0.0738020316,
0.1791152358,
-0.3929305375,
-0.479019165,
1.3621767759,
-0.2673112452,
0.2498089075,
0.5871455073,
0.6233796477,
0.1714489013,
0.0492175855,
0.3513846397,
-0.7657551765,
-0.0628984571,
0.3107945919,
-0.0156889688,
-0.1909374148,
-0.2376654297,
0.2356967479,
-0.1005719975,
-0.5567436814,
-0.4286349416,
0.2758961916,
-1.6767129898,
-0.379585743,
0.8523369431,
-0.0752202794,
0.1681728512,
-0.1526379138,
-0.4642427266,
0.3365803063,
-0.3379714191,
0.6789075136,
0.3375707865,
-0.2995052636,
-0.0824797302,
0.0248970538,
0.5940697193,
0.2152827382,
-1.0867861509,
0.3383974433,
0.7468196154,
-0.2099236101,
0.1179599017,
0.8247753978,
-0.2522447109,
0.0493055359,
-0.5314868093,
0.0812978521,
-0.2580889463,
-0.325930953,
-0.3712287545,
0.6067325473,
-0.3076267242,
-0.2424935102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09210v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09210v1
|
Chain-of-Note: Enhancing Robustness in Retrieval-Augmented Language Models
| 2023-11-15T18:54:53 | 2023-11-15T18:54:53 |
Wenhao Yu, Hongming Zhang, Xiaoman Pan, Kaixin Ma, Hongwei Wang, Dong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval-augmented language models (RALMs) represent a substantial
advancement in the capabilities of large language models, notably in reducing
factual hallucination by leveraging external knowledge sources. However, the
reliability of the retrieved information is not always guaranteed. The
retrieval of irrelevant data can lead to misguided responses, and potentially
causing the model to overlook its inherent knowledge, even when it possesses
adequate information to address the query. Moreover, standard RALMs often
struggle to assess whether they possess adequate knowledge, both intrinsic and
retrieved, to provide an accurate answer. In situations where knowledge is
lacking, these systems should ideally respond with "unknown" when the answer is
unattainable. In response to these challenges, we introduces Chain-of-Noting
(CoN), a novel approach aimed at improving the robustness of RALMs in facing
noisy, irrelevant documents and in handling unknown scenarios. The core idea of
CoN is to generate sequential reading notes for retrieved documents, enabling a
thorough evaluation of their relevance to the given question and integrating
this information to formulate the final answer. We employed ChatGPT to create
training data for CoN, which was subsequently trained on an LLaMa-2 7B model.
Our experiments across four open-domain QA benchmarks show that RALMs equipped
with CoN significantly outperform standard RALMs. Notably, CoN achieves an
average improvement of +7.9 in EM score given entirely noisy retrieved
documents and +10.5 in rejection rates for real-time questions that fall
outside the pre-training knowledge scope.
|
[
-0.394385308,
-1.0454033613,
0.5216057301,
0.1043869331,
-0.3483071625,
0.3167772591,
-0.2862406969,
-0.7534715533,
0.1732933372,
0.4237992764,
-0.3535266817,
-0.3078297377,
-0.4673760533,
0.1734922677,
-0.5366185308,
1.3645148277,
0.2478310615,
-0.3478734195,
-0.0999633372,
-0.2986059189,
-0.3944230974,
-0.618277669,
-0.5266602635,
-0.2278366834,
0.8010678291,
0.2196627855,
0.6987538338,
0.4587028921,
0.6669788361,
0.0972513035,
-0.1243223473,
0.5868154764,
-0.4565245211,
0.499294579,
-0.4001505971,
-0.3416878581,
-0.7044166923,
-0.1726187915,
0.426138252,
0.6432417631,
-0.2674231529,
0.1230318248,
0.228133142,
0.7788395882,
-0.849914372,
-0.1346663684,
-1.0101503134,
-0.3936679959,
-0.2625716627,
-0.4049055278,
-0.5490912199,
-0.2996866703,
0.249702841,
-0.7015920281,
0.1269479841,
0.2945201099,
1.0139695406,
-0.03768434,
-0.2338565439,
-0.5546897054,
-0.8351049423,
0.5218766928,
-0.6545356512,
0.2682007253,
0.8160396814,
0.1505796611,
-0.2945875227,
-0.7414624691,
-0.4825920761,
-0.3352086246,
0.0740174204,
0.1961990297,
-0.1444809586,
0.1147341058,
0.2951588333,
0.4679093361,
-0.4867386818,
-0.2132285535,
-0.1273298413,
-0.099688448,
0.4819303155,
-0.1553509086,
0.0291385595,
0.0518434756,
-0.344335556,
-0.0229902491,
-0.7204967141,
-0.0656750351,
0.387804836,
0.4307084084,
0.0616604201,
0.4785116613,
-0.3114115894,
0.8543073535,
0.1839054078,
0.0018070025,
0.069327049,
-0.4737678766,
0.0311924461,
-0.0776692703,
0.6588528752,
0.1268011183,
0.1106945649,
-0.138573423,
-0.5381130576,
-0.1744521856,
0.3805372715,
-0.5105722547,
-0.4381652176,
0.038477648,
-0.281521529,
-0.44229877,
0.1037950218,
-0.6153139472,
-0.2870352268,
-0.0538346097,
0.5555076003,
-0.3210247755,
-0.2694873214,
0.1135115176,
0.1022825092,
-0.2044228762,
0.4661419988,
-0.6710031033,
0.4359618723,
0.5325579643,
0.589841485,
0.2256344557,
0.0577447079,
-1.0102401972,
0.0861337259,
-0.3606671691,
0.8538351059,
-0.6959486604,
-0.3100158572,
0.0682807118,
-0.3756933212,
-0.0651816055,
-0.5175110698,
0.7729639411,
-0.7378346324,
0.0406185947,
-0.3484634459,
-0.3271398842,
-0.0639088899,
0.6859703064,
-0.6836462021,
1.2753466368,
0.1393310279,
-1.1418124437,
0.0941417515,
-0.0990359709,
-0.4198662341,
-0.2078133374,
-0.2074974775,
-0.4506715536,
0.0868589059,
0.2406257838,
0.1302484572,
-0.343414396,
0.2157181501,
-0.4726902843,
-0.4723788202,
0.4290883541,
-0.4882335961,
0.3790929914,
0.3466161191,
0.0584306978,
-0.2241578102,
-1.0070670843,
0.0695270821,
-0.1651056707,
-0.463118583,
-0.7778440118,
-0.1255083084,
-0.1341497898,
0.2645160556,
0.1767306775,
-0.3214499056,
0.3220949173,
-0.3275067508,
0.1114208102,
0.6584223509,
0.3188504577,
0.1856351495,
-0.5483512282,
0.6941836476,
-0.023025712,
0.1868916005,
-0.1886704862,
-0.4167459309,
-0.7394050956,
-0.0311518572,
0.1428431422,
0.5256028175,
-0.8715957403,
0.3095321357,
-0.2068623602,
-0.4322884679,
-0.4778375924,
0.1836896539,
0.6264817715,
0.8033312559,
0.3514840305,
-0.2957732379,
-0.8306602836,
-0.4377022684,
-0.3968362808,
-0.5386633277,
0.2407515645,
0.1409009695,
0.3915265203,
0.0888430476,
0.7920163274,
-0.2469960451,
-0.1352680773,
-0.2138022333,
0.1456754357,
0.172065556,
0.4432386756,
0.0961205661,
-0.6452991366,
-0.3141477704,
0.1658321917,
-0.6988981366,
-0.0550683513,
-0.2185599804,
-0.1582839787,
0.1216323003,
0.3677787781,
-0.5409088731,
0.5181950927,
0.2733893991,
-0.0654857457,
0.7342289686,
-0.4144764841,
-0.0226962231,
-0.8706621528,
0.4283028543,
-0.2760143578,
-0.176922068,
-0.4770756662,
-0.0580472164,
0.0156181213,
0.1482890099,
-0.0732662752,
0.4625988603,
-0.5206061006,
0.0280585904,
-0.1689024568,
0.5634480119,
0.3621700406,
0.3574133515,
-0.128484115,
0.6595858335,
0.3444190323,
-0.6712087393,
-0.0241313912,
0.3368260264,
-0.3585143685,
0.595639348,
-0.4076896608,
0.5199608207,
-0.0179025568,
0.2433373034,
-0.7396110296,
0.0894844159,
0.3015001714,
-0.6125669479,
0.3333933055,
-0.1455552876,
-0.4705214798,
-0.3695504367,
-0.3325788975,
0.3490513861,
0.2647909224,
-0.3455206156,
0.5945243835,
0.1013819426,
0.0054202722,
-0.9429494739,
-0.5400822759,
-0.0267574843,
-0.0363516845,
-0.3167319894,
-0.0445320904,
-0.0256076902,
-0.3353233635,
-0.0556328185,
-0.5381373763,
-0.1903946698,
0.3139511645,
0.0463628583,
0.4107834697,
-0.091368109,
0.3200423121,
-0.0786868632,
-0.0902667642,
-0.0892646909,
-0.3946509361,
0.3249861598,
-0.1455910206,
-0.3447010219,
-0.2002634406,
0.2576443851,
0.458266139,
-0.5796019435,
0.5831699967,
0.4176959693,
-0.3718179762,
-0.2386072129,
-0.6885436773,
-0.2286570072,
-0.4341518283,
0.2950918376,
-0.5651407242,
-0.836943388,
0.7354016304,
0.0942520797,
-0.0414872281,
0.2077722698,
0.1711403877,
-0.2219230235,
0.7984735966,
0.6467090845,
-0.0908310562,
0.4895681441,
-0.0685908645,
0.6058940887,
-1.0729421377,
-0.3308086097,
-0.8245018125,
0.1313252449,
-0.5740004182,
-0.2453363687,
0.379558295,
0.6457428932,
-0.121330075,
0.2247878313,
-0.486391753,
0.2184957564,
0.3974835575,
0.3031110168,
0.6598338485,
0.0815774649,
-0.2028811872,
0.2002572268,
-0.9091525078,
-0.5230532885,
1.0450655222,
0.1251134276,
1.0272978544,
-0.1481454521,
0.6363902092,
0.2686963379,
0.3416603208,
-0.435875833,
0.4408709407,
0.0610967502,
-0.5376834869,
0.0058518481,
-0.3387686908,
-0.8028780222,
0.1728493124,
-0.2695109248,
-0.7466754317,
0.2541596889,
0.4726414084,
-0.5782568455,
0.4418578446,
-0.2191665918,
0.4086890221,
-0.0271363016,
-0.5015099049,
-0.0736389011,
-0.8988370895,
0.3424784839,
-0.1778933555,
0.3511140049,
0.0676142424,
0.0426577069,
0.534806788,
-0.5069594979,
0.673322022,
0.1871059984,
-0.2797783911,
0.6293280721,
0.4103717506,
0.9849666357,
0.0007625382,
-0.2980185449,
-0.2882896364,
-0.0465627983,
-0.2025405765,
-0.8464889526,
0.6060783863,
-0.4161112309,
-0.5712134838,
-0.4886279106,
-0.6718654037,
-0.2823379934,
0.1172820181,
0.1742764115,
0.7775114775,
0.1145481244,
0.092256479,
0.7404149175,
-0.1251523346,
0.2525102198,
0.604696393,
-0.3412139416,
-0.5312057734,
0.9410501719,
0.1788463742,
0.5760011673,
0.6179856658,
0.0914992169,
-0.3938558996,
-0.5181834102,
-0.0382737853,
0.1919479966,
-0.8125872016,
-0.3605571985,
-0.8376957178,
-0.2611021698,
-0.2203105986,
0.0190370567,
-0.3033640385,
-0.6406846642,
-0.1625936627,
-0.3241067231,
0.5545883775,
0.7844654322,
-0.0975415558,
0.0472815633,
-0.8095193505,
0.0936136618,
0.0046926104,
0.401520133,
0.2259755135,
-0.684217751,
-0.4555669725,
-0.0080282977,
-0.2218737602,
-0.5407025218,
0.1729202569,
0.208229661,
0.3924090862,
0.3634973466,
0.4750156999,
0.8964183331,
-0.2182426304,
0.4968036413,
-0.1253917515,
-0.679633081,
0.8334220648,
-0.4579510987,
0.0686322674,
0.7503931522,
0.1520193517,
-0.3229436874,
-0.8799093366,
-0.7193204761,
-0.914763391,
0.3432445824,
0.2922527194,
-0.0586028546,
-0.4667908847,
0.5697372556,
0.1334078163,
0.3186504841,
-0.5890051126,
-0.1997144967,
0.0663398802,
-0.2013854533,
0.3568177819,
-0.4805954397,
0.0849268809,
0.0642212331,
0.7822780013,
0.1188584194,
-0.0422040932,
0.5326117277,
-0.1081810147,
-0.0704063028,
0.3058768511,
0.6021726727,
0.8209591508,
-0.5697132349,
0.5355024338,
0.0070805638,
-0.7728566527,
-0.0095043993,
-0.0667750388,
-0.327757597,
0.0980745032,
0.4797795713,
0.5221790671,
0.1013470814,
-0.6810471416,
0.2937558591,
0.0001432428,
0.175297156,
-0.237266928,
-0.1004003808,
-0.4222794175,
-0.0140562747,
0.4502667785,
0.3465684354,
0.1128442213,
-0.5168107748,
0.5061341524,
0.3227102757,
-0.5068566799,
-0.4375923872,
0.5515086651,
0.1606150717,
-0.3438408971,
0.7605864406,
-0.0877264291,
-0.4754639566,
0.3363192379,
0.6701026559,
0.6869406104,
-0.1385265291,
-0.0835781544,
0.4299842715,
0.4923137128,
-0.2872597575,
0.3759948015,
-0.2177405059,
-0.5531724095,
-0.2577891946,
-0.3956118226,
-0.3370931149,
0.0878479034,
-1.1370228529,
0.1135409623,
-0.5124627948,
-0.2917875051,
-0.5232463479,
0.129895702,
-0.4836753011,
0.2459084839,
-0.2604382634,
1.0441020727,
-0.6842469573,
1.1304041147,
0.4471938014,
-0.7698284984,
-0.8675070405,
0.0211437698,
-0.3437474072,
-0.5131090283,
0.3872687221,
0.0607291386,
-0.2458844781,
0.0226120036,
-0.31203264,
-0.7851392627,
0.9098232388,
0.3102865517,
-0.8529045582,
0.0812469721,
-0.2147638798,
0.5308817625,
-0.1627253145,
0.3803851008,
0.3874013424,
0.1615905464,
-0.0597854927,
-0.9485478401,
0.1572840661,
-0.3198743165,
-0.0560218841,
0.1057387516,
-0.5302340984,
0.7134498954,
-0.3914981186,
-0.1402849108,
0.3634290695,
0.6547880769,
0.564163506,
0.3857672811,
0.4502741098,
0.534116745,
1.1954599619,
0.0999669656,
1.2773066759,
-0.3659403324,
0.2335493714,
1.7360799313,
-0.4446007311,
1.0534226894,
0.6744535565,
0.0014855332,
0.5550548434,
0.4041831493,
0.2697947919,
0.5602637529,
0.1549109817,
-0.5700961351,
-0.3421358764,
-0.2986043692,
-0.3851277232,
0.0196657814,
0.2975385189,
-0.2160111219,
-0.1630869061,
-0.0068468978,
0.0289448202,
0.4266294241,
-0.1200814471,
0.6045771241,
0.3689650893,
-0.7345731854,
0.5884962082,
-0.3516071141,
0.4101959467,
-0.6951476336,
-0.3115788996,
-0.5315057039,
0.2589335442,
-0.0980025604,
-0.6562694311,
0.3195924759,
0.1303104758,
-0.3838218749,
-0.0242577586,
0.8580983281,
-0.5383518934,
-0.4331882596,
0.3213783205,
0.4875641763,
0.0668799654,
-0.1524411887,
-0.4733683765,
0.3773090541,
-0.1931935549,
-0.1758118421,
0.2855598629,
0.7023710012,
-0.285882622,
1.0408143997,
0.6608552933,
0.0895407647,
0.0035781832,
0.2313414216,
1.00317204,
-0.4443530738,
-0.3567668498,
-0.7703800797,
0.4865376949,
0.0069599901,
-0.1410498321,
0.847717464,
0.6010329127,
0.8575295806,
0.1879283935,
0.8141275644,
-0.0580374375,
0.6881001592,
-0.4647496045,
0.6690570116,
-0.3177044392,
0.7211623788,
-0.3273923397,
-0.6770764589,
-0.2797622383,
0.6727278233,
-0.0778731927,
0.0641434118,
0.7919788957,
0.8785136938,
0.135108158,
-0.0981490016,
0.2300116271,
0.1910193861,
0.3928411603,
0.5454942584,
0.9948285818,
-0.7754535079,
0.8216577768,
-0.3356429636,
0.0964965299,
-0.080919981,
-0.9270150661,
-0.840922296,
-0.518301785,
-0.464852035,
-0.5854227543,
0.3943657577,
0.7183122635,
0.4396979213,
-0.5955638885,
-0.1233625934,
-0.1414040029,
0.3658031821,
-0.3998255432,
-0.1636427939,
0.424493432,
-0.4785465002,
-0.1690686792,
0.3328009844,
0.3508850932,
0.0312930495,
0.0893839374,
0.0410334468,
-0.5497677922,
0.065297462,
0.422457844,
0.3374534547,
-0.6529387236,
-0.4886580706,
-0.0402682796,
-0.1463746876,
0.0678136051,
0.7337165475,
-0.8763995767,
0.7185898423,
0.3720939159,
0.5437235832,
0.2762734294,
0.2912748754,
0.6301077008,
-0.7792961597,
0.1853960305,
0.2791335881,
0.1342348456,
0.403911382,
-0.380826056,
0.6349202394,
0.1441718191,
-0.4617697597,
-1.1326454878,
-0.0100833559,
-1.2106802464,
0.1598593295,
0.7863489389,
-0.492240876,
-0.0898801833,
-0.2930031419,
-0.1936240345,
0.2686673999,
-0.3214719892,
0.9417678714,
0.5797156692,
0.2131329179,
-0.2361243665,
-0.6263564229,
0.4127969742,
0.3202678263,
-0.6165041327,
0.2500657141,
0.2761375606,
0.2050695717,
0.0085890759,
0.7827066183,
-0.2745710909,
0.2083090693,
-0.0808859542,
-0.0624536984,
-0.1752670854,
-0.3750151992,
-0.2681232393,
0.0675660819,
0.472058773,
-0.193570137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09277v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09277v1
|
Contrastive Chain-of-Thought Prompting
| 2023-11-15T18:54:01 | 2023-11-15T18:54:01 |
Yew Ken Chia, Guizhen Chen, Luu Anh Tuan, Soujanya Poria, Lidong Bing
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the success of chain of thought in enhancing language model
reasoning, the underlying process remains less well understood. Although
logically sound reasoning appears inherently crucial for chain of thought,
prior studies surprisingly reveal minimal impact when using invalid
demonstrations instead. Furthermore, the conventional chain of thought does not
inform language models on what mistakes to avoid, which potentially leads to
more errors. Hence, inspired by how humans can learn from both positive and
negative examples, we propose contrastive chain of thought to enhance language
model reasoning. Compared to the conventional chain of thought, our approach
provides both valid and invalid reasoning demonstrations, to guide the model to
reason step-by-step while reducing reasoning mistakes. To improve
generalization, we introduce an automatic method to construct contrastive
demonstrations. Our experiments on reasoning benchmarks demonstrate that
contrastive chain of thought can serve as a general enhancement of
chain-of-thought prompting.
|
[
-0.4596505761,
-0.8491649032,
0.6716012955,
-0.1197526306,
-0.3787521124,
0.0803762972,
0.0254210308,
-0.4620690048,
0.1952859014,
0.3597361445,
-0.6144903898,
-0.2232555598,
-0.2783294022,
0.0209945999,
-0.4186197519,
0.9519164562,
-0.124324128,
-0.0334979072,
0.1005950794,
-0.0761464015,
-0.6060355306,
-0.4045193791,
-0.8452370167,
-0.8406672478,
0.5113447309,
0.3517551422,
0.7029175758,
0.363185972,
0.2113600075,
0.2552449405,
-0.0180287939,
0.3242399693,
-0.4561878145,
0.0583728738,
-0.8244026899,
-0.4819610119,
-0.3593598902,
0.0073916111,
0.3093500733,
0.625148654,
-0.2069087923,
-0.1403426975,
-0.1220593452,
0.9016677737,
-0.7469943166,
-0.2865775526,
-0.8648173809,
-0.1616166979,
0.2081189305,
-0.1603743881,
-0.4118361175,
-0.4598106444,
0.2160158008,
-0.5359709859,
0.0022255993,
0.1606467515,
0.6948540211,
0.0328185596,
-0.2768529058,
-0.3708486259,
-0.7220726609,
0.6479833126,
-0.708068192,
0.3710355759,
0.3160626888,
0.1413098425,
-0.109882623,
-0.5411060452,
-0.8733943105,
-0.3016232848,
0.0683803931,
0.2245984823,
-0.278439641,
0.139228195,
0.4987046421,
0.4843432605,
-0.3379526734,
-0.1109677926,
-0.2296546698,
-0.049236875,
0.2711309195,
0.152218312,
0.3595859706,
0.1178241894,
-0.2515234649,
-0.3113785386,
-0.9361689687,
-0.0033320808,
0.4659046829,
0.2049209625,
0.0113227712,
0.0280722119,
-0.363953203,
0.685248971,
0.1953033954,
0.2409345657,
0.1956860572,
-0.1762273014,
-0.382799536,
0.0656731054,
0.6498166919,
0.5727387667,
0.2827388346,
0.0673706979,
-0.2387434989,
0.5167405009,
0.3992392719,
-0.794819057,
-0.5724183321,
0.0995755345,
-0.4729943573,
-0.3902606666,
0.1658024341,
-0.6883038878,
-0.2632589042,
-0.4003301561,
0.6174733639,
-0.3697646558,
-0.2045917213,
0.4454468191,
-0.5516682267,
-0.0873127878,
0.5118895173,
-0.8872771263,
0.6880449653,
0.4356219471,
0.3734665215,
0.0177725144,
-0.2363093197,
-0.3172890246,
0.0542339683,
-0.6330628991,
0.9306792617,
-0.688388586,
-0.1258356869,
-0.1203156412,
-0.1262045056,
0.1620745659,
-0.7522078753,
0.5824899673,
-0.3098325729,
0.325461328,
-0.5336715579,
-0.4825432599,
-0.5102950335,
0.362529248,
-0.5129225254,
0.6914797425,
-0.0779099613,
-0.7899568081,
0.299754411,
-0.5161257386,
-0.5192654133,
-0.150778681,
-0.3478142917,
-0.2047581822,
0.0062762569,
0.5167565346,
0.1489598453,
-0.4687789679,
0.2144068927,
-0.3281573057,
-0.5274764299,
0.2450475097,
-0.3519964814,
0.6993048191,
0.3080929518,
-0.6646392941,
0.0666176826,
-0.703322947,
-0.0412190445,
0.2124343365,
0.00591031,
-0.7091004252,
0.0967157707,
-0.520976007,
0.5336744189,
-0.2581656277,
-0.1210271344,
0.2741954923,
-0.5588805676,
0.3041999638,
0.8476824164,
0.259648025,
0.2192328572,
-0.5286778212,
0.4619575441,
0.2718544006,
-0.0228691883,
-0.1639027148,
-0.4920866191,
-1.1629194021,
0.324780196,
-0.0160381272,
0.6171002984,
-0.9835284948,
0.3146903813,
0.2567350566,
-0.18976219,
-0.6475683451,
0.2074995339,
0.6389679313,
0.8359639645,
0.611291647,
-0.281887114,
-0.8529421687,
-0.8047084808,
-0.2216096222,
-0.4129395485,
0.0666991025,
0.0248823445,
0.6916701198,
-0.1412136704,
0.3735739589,
-0.3496696055,
0.4142527878,
-0.2458507121,
0.1873767525,
0.4190768898,
0.526535213,
0.099496685,
-0.5640272498,
-0.2606624663,
0.0477442406,
-0.5855608582,
-0.0896731317,
-0.4075979888,
-0.3886229992,
-0.2523099482,
0.424370259,
-0.2096223086,
0.2936594486,
0.3369774818,
-0.2721687853,
0.671069324,
-0.3182532191,
0.2738782167,
-0.9841120839,
-0.0491411351,
-0.064121902,
-0.0200886894,
-0.6629992127,
0.0569344386,
-0.0868053213,
0.1352841705,
-0.3236623108,
0.4600556791,
-0.2579346001,
0.2059131563,
-0.3717563152,
0.2479294538,
0.1752516329,
0.3733789921,
0.2187025696,
0.7530453801,
0.6151589751,
-0.9579749107,
0.2124074847,
0.1131659523,
-0.3138308525,
0.552206099,
-0.5235428214,
0.3206064999,
-0.0304281879,
0.3038136363,
-0.859732151,
0.0621409789,
0.4964779913,
0.0318122171,
0.0290780142,
0.272854805,
-0.2961454988,
-0.6378729343,
-0.3380540013,
0.1840054989,
0.8039268255,
-0.8347734213,
0.124921374,
-0.0268795248,
0.1094310135,
-0.5762510896,
-0.7789821625,
-0.0622631945,
-0.2398569882,
-0.1822125465,
0.4165288806,
-0.2168108076,
-0.5483012199,
-0.2259275913,
-0.328769207,
0.0539216287,
0.0058318255,
0.0146717923,
0.313887924,
-0.0960646272,
0.374291718,
0.1920361072,
-0.055532828,
0.2337413579,
-0.4618830979,
0.4013625681,
-0.3234856427,
-0.3353622258,
-0.7366524935,
0.2175121754,
0.2138974965,
0.1362464577,
0.3009429872,
-0.003388582,
-0.2982355952,
-0.2661240101,
-0.7856807709,
-0.310367167,
-0.5042507648,
-0.0737994835,
-0.4007163346,
-0.6068333387,
0.4337951243,
-0.4310265183,
-0.3511286974,
0.2240757793,
0.3356232643,
-0.2695131302,
1.0091377497,
0.216849491,
-0.0464328378,
0.4856852293,
-0.2370283604,
0.2985883355,
-0.7258010507,
0.0972064808,
-0.3404258192,
-0.0946023092,
-0.4545285702,
-0.3122746646,
-0.1983503848,
0.5498831272,
-0.3429026902,
0.2021164298,
-0.6948983073,
0.8114721775,
0.296005249,
0.3546161354,
0.2707552314,
-0.0642734468,
-0.5058240294,
0.0765794888,
-0.701030314,
-0.6324118376,
0.6131619811,
0.0768334195,
0.8491396308,
-0.1070759073,
0.8682067394,
0.1433904022,
0.2857171893,
-0.4470144808,
0.5870882273,
-0.0581728183,
-0.3905284405,
-0.0854287967,
-0.3571253419,
-0.7779247165,
0.2977143526,
-0.1083677337,
-0.7184593678,
0.3557518125,
0.6121886373,
-0.2193034738,
0.33764112,
-0.6280384064,
0.5858951211,
-0.0557236709,
-0.3007983863,
-0.5460896492,
-0.6456227303,
0.4884671271,
0.1794590801,
0.2639632821,
0.4747000337,
0.2959122956,
0.6446099281,
-0.6691909432,
0.8690101504,
0.120095782,
-0.1881886274,
0.5773056746,
0.3167726099,
0.8578294516,
-0.4562425315,
-0.2218638957,
-0.3512552977,
-0.7658184767,
-0.1941453665,
-0.8250475526,
0.5030562282,
-0.3511480689,
-0.815085113,
0.0296117868,
-0.3588069081,
-0.1989810169,
0.0183671322,
0.1389101744,
0.3171292543,
-0.2108059824,
-0.2960423231,
0.5815739036,
-0.1326525211,
0.3043198287,
0.1668497175,
-0.3504261672,
-0.6770174503,
1.0409915447,
-0.2174877673,
0.728731513,
0.5664895773,
0.6025440693,
-0.3486589193,
-0.48345083,
0.0447788648,
0.1387432963,
-1.0924217701,
0.0498917773,
-0.5228057504,
0.1193264648,
-0.1919378787,
-0.4066665471,
-0.1074794307,
-0.5918249488,
0.0056450297,
-0.4446734786,
0.2295705676,
0.874748826,
-0.2198655605,
-0.0444052592,
-0.4232493937,
0.5403684378,
0.9238371253,
0.1923576742,
0.5563374758,
-0.2985585928,
-0.0347026363,
0.0468444526,
-0.6497037411,
-0.8239355087,
0.0745872334,
-0.1254975051,
0.6330018044,
0.7909328938,
0.039460972,
1.1127716303,
-0.4911858439,
0.7847676277,
0.7163453102,
-1.3513768911,
1.0949009657,
-0.2628511786,
0.4200013876,
0.467607379,
0.4522931874,
-0.5268645287,
-0.8337306976,
-0.8598188758,
-0.4434081018,
0.3847031891,
0.1997535676,
-0.1169555485,
-0.532625556,
0.1472465843,
0.2524236739,
0.085011296,
-0.9753712416,
-0.242524147,
-0.4467647672,
0.3246076107,
0.2295224369,
-0.0809653103,
-0.0222551506,
-0.4970183671,
0.85243541,
-0.0347979888,
0.067574732,
0.3816785216,
0.0501272529,
-0.188124612,
0.5992057323,
0.7654474378,
0.8627934456,
-0.1544727385,
0.5805665851,
0.5219627619,
-0.071377784,
0.316917181,
-0.4368264377,
-0.1460861564,
-0.1128022522,
0.2187018543,
0.9475890994,
0.1101632789,
-0.5028079748,
0.2929826677,
0.2445720881,
-0.3605109155,
0.1725567132,
0.3035708368,
0.2843563855,
0.2996127307,
-0.0411332846,
0.3015428483,
0.3468708694,
-0.7997653484,
0.0735346004,
0.0821519345,
-0.3886782825,
-0.2697106302,
0.5283307433,
0.4283516705,
-0.4436096251,
0.6996754408,
-0.2718107998,
-0.8240511417,
0.5049377084,
0.908048749,
0.8480350375,
-0.4062400758,
0.2165178061,
0.4805316925,
0.2089095116,
-0.4088639021,
0.5079734325,
-0.2535832524,
-0.9380214214,
-0.5263284445,
0.0230534095,
-0.6328184009,
0.2187425345,
-0.6883479357,
0.3456408679,
-0.55481112,
-0.0036419299,
-0.1805022061,
-0.3202330172,
-0.3550614417,
0.5259689093,
0.2636654973,
0.7947954535,
-0.9002189636,
0.9976677895,
0.4134510159,
-0.6755785346,
-0.7489033341,
0.1776117384,
-0.1636888683,
-0.5501693487,
0.878006041,
0.2902170718,
-0.6003052592,
-0.2836009264,
-0.4865225255,
-0.2539628744,
0.8420194983,
0.2864411175,
-0.7145441175,
0.0088809161,
-0.2590242624,
0.6013619304,
-0.5757572055,
0.355476737,
0.2592107952,
0.3553414643,
0.2912330925,
-0.6157341599,
0.5651715994,
-0.3070383966,
0.1271547973,
0.2385430634,
-0.3936011195,
0.9184992909,
-0.5226063728,
-0.2567645907,
-0.1697511673,
0.347900629,
0.4844787419,
0.2714833617,
0.7343381047,
0.6694949269,
1.0617843866,
0.3284611702,
1.1298297644,
0.041422531,
0.0225888323,
1.3558791876,
-0.4570594728,
0.9843032956,
0.6840189099,
-0.1730317324,
1.2195982933,
0.2739599943,
0.0140648829,
0.6644294262,
0.4323343337,
-0.2620377243,
-0.6981528997,
0.0153250247,
-0.4295239449,
-0.0490399785,
0.4206304848,
-0.5261415839,
-0.0509085283,
-0.2002271414,
-0.2228627354,
0.3042041659,
-0.3783823252,
0.5860821009,
0.2002552003,
-0.8953985572,
0.8742753267,
-0.5665501952,
0.4927071035,
-0.315182656,
-0.5884930491,
0.0262168478,
0.1232159659,
-0.1141300276,
-0.7072974443,
0.1731814891,
-0.1568073183,
-0.2073868066,
-0.4835166037,
0.8269104958,
-0.3325581253,
-0.1184500009,
0.473367542,
0.4056105316,
0.2666656375,
0.1278726757,
-0.726347506,
-0.2117320001,
0.0844977871,
0.1957107037,
0.0789887756,
0.4023099542,
-0.1237146109,
0.7779609561,
0.6864980459,
0.05183037,
-0.4300319254,
0.5935162902,
1.0205943584,
-0.911252439,
-0.6834819317,
-1.0353091955,
0.6048582792,
-0.4211852551,
-0.1340826303,
0.4204208553,
0.2045121044,
0.8130164146,
-0.1650636792,
0.7745332122,
0.258516252,
0.4954537749,
-0.7843265533,
0.4911589622,
-0.3974690139,
0.4047109783,
-0.565562129,
-0.6355637908,
-0.2052533776,
0.8639665246,
-0.4620389342,
-0.1477805972,
1.3787727356,
0.7557587028,
0.0491651036,
0.3948060572,
0.5031916499,
0.2701926827,
0.2113889754,
0.7413411736,
1.2701410055,
-0.4826433361,
0.4662095606,
-0.1723840535,
0.0131545598,
0.0499765873,
-1.0990326405,
-1.1612751484,
-0.2752624452,
-0.4783554077,
-0.4714007378,
0.4263069928,
1.064437747,
0.5112922192,
-0.920293808,
-0.3929977715,
-0.992895782,
0.4671123624,
-0.6021478176,
-0.199064672,
0.0454451554,
-0.430431962,
-0.3133977056,
0.40122208,
0.2155486345,
0.2346729934,
-0.0369698368,
-0.3020988405,
-0.4206517339,
0.2646670043,
0.4507398903,
0.1842456758,
-1.0686023235,
-0.4039834142,
-0.5066124797,
0.1585814357,
0.2972902954,
1.0382381678,
-0.9799561501,
0.6631197929,
0.6235771179,
0.2665545642,
0.4357285202,
-0.0994233415,
0.8791838288,
-0.3243132532,
0.1062067896,
0.2201699615,
0.4142103493,
0.1950917393,
-0.2042871118,
0.3942548931,
0.2253961414,
-0.3705739677,
-0.4403496683,
0.5544419885,
-0.7346059084,
-0.4597657025,
0.8668349981,
-0.1706525981,
-0.0475164466,
-0.1691138297,
-0.3875702918,
0.1317619085,
-0.5432406068,
0.9315882921,
0.8876165152,
-0.3480733633,
-0.2961894274,
-0.0117412554,
0.4953221679,
0.5413253307,
-1.1160318851,
0.1080677137,
0.2814201415,
-0.0062092352,
0.2200714499,
0.6354183555,
0.0938880444,
0.5440389514,
0.3811579049,
-0.0128810965,
0.2926047146,
-0.2600489855,
-0.4165215194,
-0.0938014239,
0.0604640022,
0.0348202847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09206v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09206v3
|
TableLlama: Towards Open Large Generalist Models for Tables
| 2023-11-15T18:47:52 | 2024-04-04T17:10:25 |
Tianshu Zhang, Xiang Yue, Yifei Li, Huan Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB
|
Semi-structured tables are ubiquitous. There has been a variety of tasks that
aim to automatically interpret, augment, and query tables. Current methods
often require pretraining on tables or special model architecture design, are
restricted to specific table types, or have simplifying assumptions about
tables and tasks. This paper makes the first step towards developing
open-source large language models (LLMs) as generalists for a diversity of
table-based tasks. Towards that end, we construct TableInstruct, a new dataset
with a variety of realistic tables and tasks, for instruction tuning and
evaluating LLMs. We further develop the first open-source generalist model for
tables, TableLlama, by fine-tuning Llama 2 (7B) with LongLoRA to address the
long context challenge. We experiment under both in-domain setting and
out-of-domain setting. On 7 out of 8 in-domain tasks, TableLlama achieves
comparable or better performance than the SOTA for each task, despite the
latter often has task-specific design. On 6 out-of-domain datasets, it achieves
5-44 absolute point gains compared with the base model, showing that training
on TableInstruct enhances the model's generalizability. We open-source our
dataset and trained model to boost future work on developing open generalist
models for tables.
|
[
-0.0880957469,
-0.9348618388,
0.6487666368,
0.0834649727,
-0.1952848732,
-0.3976259232,
-0.4548578262,
-0.460208118,
0.0130542181,
0.7784639597,
-0.2574880123,
-0.9780629277,
-0.4077906013,
-0.3516916633,
-0.6181231141,
1.0239207745,
-0.2243933231,
-0.1983897835,
-0.0190021619,
-0.0763384327,
-0.513584137,
-0.3751477897,
-0.2451004237,
-0.1455914974,
0.3888005018,
0.6311099529,
0.9109466076,
0.6576974392,
0.2850725055,
0.2470313162,
0.1020333394,
0.1528963,
-0.5446105599,
-0.0040327241,
-0.3507913053,
-0.5671693683,
-0.6663680673,
-0.0381896198,
0.57992661,
0.7725648284,
-0.5257614851,
0.4605692625,
0.2153121382,
0.6692399383,
-0.4510030448,
0.7176468372,
-0.7450259328,
0.1713710427,
-0.5018427372,
0.0238487478,
-0.5645074248,
-0.5114532113,
0.0814297795,
-0.7304648757,
0.0785361305,
0.1774347126,
0.5205249786,
0.094747059,
-0.2399136871,
-0.5082120299,
-0.9783834219,
0.5509805083,
-0.7052534223,
0.4855120182,
0.215797618,
0.5950052738,
-0.5292836428,
-0.7657429576,
-0.5475745201,
-0.6061661243,
0.042688746,
-0.3037320971,
-0.2410732955,
0.0396510735,
0.1738035828,
0.4952682853,
-0.8314353824,
0.3222007751,
-0.156632483,
0.1677121669,
0.3310197294,
0.251233995,
0.4506064653,
0.3331633508,
-0.0009570082,
0.0647320151,
-1.0355137587,
-0.1792974174,
0.1314007789,
0.4394627512,
-0.2105713934,
0.687815845,
-0.2517988682,
1.0823738575,
-0.3945370913,
0.0694368631,
-0.3023661375,
-0.0566434562,
-0.5075792074,
-0.0335782506,
0.3929332197,
0.1094136387,
0.5294910669,
-0.4425225258,
-0.0662818477,
0.3640913069,
0.19165501,
-0.5382789969,
-0.4165168405,
-0.069298774,
-0.1020682529,
-0.1068341136,
-0.0584354922,
-0.7834420204,
-0.2922050655,
-0.6192601919,
0.5890330076,
0.001909989,
0.099279575,
0.3011981547,
0.5319941044,
0.1941932589,
0.5557816029,
-1.0068181753,
0.4795638919,
0.6794487834,
0.9031041861,
-0.1217860058,
-0.0667072535,
-0.4494176805,
0.7175170183,
-0.6254056692,
0.7691087723,
-0.7488282323,
-0.323485285,
0.3289965987,
-0.0465485565,
0.1767453104,
-0.6843918562,
0.3419136107,
-0.4656817913,
0.2815594673,
-0.0776307583,
-0.3259672523,
-0.1768518984,
0.2020994574,
-0.808595717,
0.8564914465,
0.3194248378,
-0.2571043968,
0.3423709273,
-0.9923116565,
-0.368042469,
-0.063601546,
-0.3268423378,
-0.2364913225,
0.3229798079,
0.1332379282,
0.463919431,
-0.6829602122,
0.5487912297,
-0.2817881405,
-0.3069896698,
-0.1077918708,
0.0144341197,
0.4570004642,
0.0608783141,
-0.43269822,
0.303611517,
-0.7584006786,
0.0817900971,
0.0629787743,
-0.5279604197,
-0.3580170274,
0.2274947912,
-0.0597483739,
0.0854774117,
-0.0471643992,
-0.3403778076,
0.5112935901,
-0.3959648609,
0.5091548562,
0.702909112,
-0.3005762994,
0.4518338442,
-0.1133380458,
0.253618598,
0.1034182236,
0.1127326936,
0.2906710207,
-0.4677367508,
-0.9476011395,
-0.0317134149,
0.2335868776,
0.3381918073,
-0.5981904864,
0.3400316536,
-0.3421226144,
-0.6439133286,
-0.2868288159,
0.2625729442,
0.3335335553,
0.5623496771,
0.6710702181,
-0.2971951365,
-0.3504858911,
-1.0925836563,
-0.1814192683,
0.1307690144,
-0.2746627331,
0.0411212258,
0.5105615854,
-0.1665275246,
0.9075380564,
-0.5800397396,
-0.6819725037,
-0.2716273963,
-0.0049010664,
0.497723788,
0.483420223,
0.3148593307,
-0.245016709,
-0.6058397293,
0.2038558125,
-0.7613335252,
-0.0129115311,
0.2745976448,
-0.1471925676,
0.3064650595,
0.2098511904,
-0.6694865823,
0.431235671,
0.3811740279,
-0.1820273697,
0.2864064872,
-0.196254015,
-0.2425829321,
-0.9737254977,
0.234949559,
0.2833659947,
-0.0515104085,
-0.8931550384,
0.2662103772,
0.0924496055,
-0.3298012912,
-0.377088666,
0.5065045953,
-0.6181799173,
-0.2943193614,
-0.1498743147,
-0.0470070355,
-0.3264624774,
0.6123818159,
0.0403587036,
0.7742319107,
0.3689881861,
-0.7075029612,
-0.0010614379,
0.3127633333,
-0.8325973153,
0.3904881775,
-0.8748593926,
0.2070214152,
-0.0667608529,
0.2965866923,
-0.7884662151,
-0.3205604553,
0.5436290503,
0.1925081909,
0.445853442,
0.0254059322,
-0.4844759703,
-0.3524053395,
-0.0393811166,
0.0811753795,
0.2992216051,
-0.656750679,
0.4710845351,
0.683365047,
-0.0222883597,
-0.4722237885,
-0.563459456,
0.1421022266,
-0.0652571768,
-0.6025683284,
0.5473724604,
0.0640121326,
-0.3522607386,
-0.1754480153,
-0.3208627105,
-0.0085667744,
-0.0402304195,
0.3755001128,
0.1598381996,
-0.2812972069,
0.1056973338,
0.1298961341,
-0.0149282571,
-0.0363294892,
-0.5178740025,
0.7627615333,
-0.3330658674,
-0.2388331592,
-0.388928622,
0.119336091,
0.18958202,
-0.3402718902,
0.4802608788,
0.0749840662,
-0.4245886207,
-0.6075653434,
-0.5492863655,
0.0405660346,
-0.5097179413,
0.5248557329,
-0.2981260717,
-1.0434187651,
0.3834096789,
0.0754458532,
0.4965687394,
0.4150130749,
0.8220877051,
0.0228022132,
0.6884397268,
0.6797643304,
-0.1731260866,
0.1463229507,
-0.3424742818,
-0.1182659343,
-0.4226430357,
-0.2497803271,
-0.9216993451,
-0.4834618568,
-0.1836818308,
-0.63857162,
0.4137486219,
-0.3242048323,
-0.3636369705,
0.3827840388,
-0.5202023983,
0.7467606068,
0.5119655728,
0.1735762656,
0.3660811484,
0.0998446494,
0.2326582074,
0.1977712512,
-0.5388684273,
-0.7120810151,
1.1537935734,
0.3415540755,
1.0896887779,
0.1741367131,
0.4792944491,
0.4740563333,
0.5222085118,
-0.4652357697,
0.7481287718,
-0.2336263359,
-0.6611498594,
-0.5181711912,
-0.2696094215,
-0.9158753753,
0.1201211736,
0.0482910536,
-0.8074373007,
0.0359021686,
0.3857888877,
-0.1204091981,
0.2502320409,
-0.4187414646,
1.1530028582,
-0.1040885374,
-0.3701483905,
-0.2561953068,
-0.6062172055,
0.5890929103,
-0.1123171821,
0.1476848572,
-0.1530799419,
-0.0731880292,
0.7679496408,
-0.3018394113,
1.0165624619,
-0.4537729025,
-0.4637241066,
0.3218361139,
0.3469647467,
0.5649725199,
-0.0103452886,
-0.1110221967,
0.1901835352,
-0.0584885478,
-0.1569785923,
-0.5952324271,
0.8078480959,
-0.7691914439,
-0.7430222631,
-0.2377188951,
-0.8197818398,
-0.3885478973,
-0.0086426083,
-0.2148310393,
0.4975348413,
-0.3319494724,
0.3040486872,
0.6354050636,
-0.1461786777,
0.30312711,
0.6826853752,
-0.1411786377,
-0.1081605777,
0.7643870115,
0.2723452151,
-0.0299999043,
0.5224560499,
0.0753861889,
-0.2471593767,
-0.7225353122,
-0.5406111479,
-0.0064584217,
-0.5610613823,
-0.1377648264,
-0.2326718867,
0.0202758722,
-0.1005622968,
0.0706699789,
-0.1872305125,
-0.4967544675,
-0.3274501264,
0.0434803814,
-0.0822992101,
0.9359664917,
0.2096987665,
0.5944962502,
-0.5807814002,
0.1665240824,
0.3971680403,
0.4811767042,
0.1752771735,
-0.6307842731,
-0.3251331449,
-0.0801205635,
-0.3028209507,
-0.9715801477,
0.2838272452,
0.5360985994,
0.6898193955,
0.3445411623,
-0.1388290077,
0.5443749428,
-0.7787370086,
0.4460477233,
0.0040940978,
-1.0477517843,
0.5208095908,
-0.322789818,
0.2947359681,
0.6787623763,
0.5397209525,
-0.4585031271,
-0.2641213238,
-0.0855251625,
-0.571837008,
0.6194617748,
-0.2034099251,
0.1919325292,
0.1326110512,
0.4652667642,
0.4097165465,
0.2403099686,
-0.970995605,
0.2389997095,
-0.0583340712,
-0.3239587545,
-0.2900240719,
-0.3341601491,
-0.2505697608,
-0.2226826549,
0.6256602407,
-0.1303878725,
0.0959521979,
-0.3438117206,
-0.509627521,
-0.3455412388,
0.4625503719,
0.8697955608,
1.0857740641,
-0.1714251786,
0.2171698064,
0.1617315263,
-0.1958556026,
0.2068314701,
0.0047475346,
-0.2085857093,
-0.0708152279,
0.1448867768,
0.7243462801,
0.5653432012,
-0.4312788546,
0.0966885835,
0.2138304561,
-0.087008819,
-0.1874193102,
0.3236152828,
0.1747590154,
0.2504641116,
0.1464699805,
-0.6680155993,
0.0251908395,
-0.829700768,
0.0943057463,
0.5707048178,
-0.2882470787,
-0.4985274971,
0.8845991492,
0.0689361542,
-0.3847567141,
0.5460268259,
0.2267438918,
-0.0066468231,
0.2932923734,
0.7633595467,
0.5848798156,
-0.4070358872,
0.2734003067,
0.2017870396,
0.559635818,
-0.1214507297,
0.4158079624,
-0.0398857966,
-0.1881055683,
-0.2443535775,
-0.8755539656,
-0.6492931247,
0.3276282251,
-0.3844448924,
0.214951396,
-0.4971747398,
0.0537905283,
-0.0547612123,
-0.0472723469,
-0.5475004315,
0.0245162249,
-0.0452219434,
1.0550307035,
-0.7992068529,
1.1927558184,
0.4965212941,
-0.3550834656,
-0.6066114306,
-0.2650071383,
-0.2253961265,
-0.9014460444,
0.4425595105,
0.2272474617,
0.4060085416,
-0.0229705721,
-0.6555125713,
-0.8218715191,
0.9682819843,
0.5839640498,
-0.9377288222,
-0.61337322,
0.7675318718,
0.5762323141,
-0.3270059228,
-0.019348152,
0.7170602679,
0.6184583902,
-0.2196931541,
-0.8458434939,
0.0938535184,
-0.0290072225,
0.1248797253,
0.5129446983,
-0.1948600113,
0.8658169508,
0.1718893498,
-0.1456475854,
0.0553426258,
0.9333317876,
0.0317656063,
0.1533062756,
0.3920944035,
0.8010425568,
0.5269363523,
-0.1128334701,
0.7090039253,
-0.3492998481,
0.0361743681,
1.4570585489,
-0.5031231642,
0.8557866216,
0.2847254872,
-0.2771472037,
0.497379005,
0.4536265135,
-0.2014607638,
0.3675297499,
0.6435368061,
-0.0311855543,
-0.0335870273,
0.1354923099,
-0.5646620989,
0.5140337944,
0.449816227,
-0.3318457603,
-0.7938747406,
-0.167512998,
0.0068993196,
0.1469577402,
-0.4663495719,
0.6524165869,
0.0977373272,
-0.4920481145,
0.4963205159,
0.1910385191,
0.2627553642,
-0.7824423313,
-0.0676662624,
-0.31529212,
0.0608614124,
-0.1266553253,
-0.6945757866,
0.3611605167,
0.0035154189,
0.0776251853,
0.1204637289,
0.5987372398,
-0.6403610706,
-0.268152386,
-0.0392404385,
0.4227679372,
0.1153257489,
-0.2125540227,
-0.3787643313,
0.0959605277,
-0.2087731808,
-0.2589138746,
0.5475978851,
0.163732931,
-0.3448876739,
0.4552596807,
0.5308688879,
-0.0911989957,
-0.0125125768,
-0.1841945797,
0.9705787897,
-0.5129591227,
-0.5263471007,
-0.8787586093,
0.3114904761,
0.1324160099,
-0.2841197252,
0.4630432725,
0.7751287818,
0.7465043664,
-0.4405523837,
0.3146760464,
0.1299801916,
0.3874255717,
-0.6644356251,
0.9325226545,
-0.5357398391,
0.0899556801,
-0.1777169108,
-1.4523099661,
-0.4929380715,
0.3968799412,
-0.4551447332,
-0.1777221859,
0.293479532,
0.9907079935,
-0.2691137493,
0.2173565328,
0.2526732981,
0.2146335989,
0.5116819143,
0.7031226754,
0.7094692588,
0.1298846751,
0.4772803485,
-0.1772764623,
-0.3981286287,
-0.1965373605,
-0.6691313386,
-0.9380598664,
-0.629658699,
0.0327520669,
0.0486639179,
0.3569530547,
0.8702514768,
0.5775331855,
-0.9005157948,
-0.7401618361,
-0.0944221094,
-0.2179075032,
0.1749889404,
-0.1223707274,
0.5111992955,
-0.2726281583,
-0.6164545417,
0.7007698417,
0.3474689424,
-0.0961581096,
-0.3216085732,
0.1271093339,
-0.2328815758,
0.0424095578,
0.6975875497,
0.5611466169,
-0.6426370144,
-0.3978380859,
-0.3993422389,
-0.0991363749,
0.1469321549,
0.6090502739,
-0.4771175981,
0.1401436478,
0.117647849,
0.5336868763,
0.5648747683,
-0.1831463426,
0.5779910088,
-0.4958025515,
0.1704612523,
0.2647206485,
0.2867057621,
-0.0355285779,
0.1107863113,
0.9007949233,
-0.2132032067,
-0.5969730616,
-1.0543944836,
0.1368539333,
-1.0159484148,
-0.1477339417,
0.8523578048,
0.0582345538,
-0.5046310425,
0.1005856469,
-0.1153543368,
0.3087813258,
-0.1260246933,
1.137137413,
0.4307343662,
0.0706403181,
0.2029945999,
-0.6986240149,
0.5251390338,
0.2201435119,
-1.3622002602,
0.2383517474,
0.7171288729,
0.0383103006,
-0.0449335091,
0.4693256021,
-0.1048817635,
0.2751132548,
-0.3553637862,
0.2399725914,
-0.3809602857,
-0.8318787813,
-0.1247544736,
0.5232621431,
0.1504109949,
0.0154688815
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.