id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09205v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09205v1
|
When Is Multilinguality a Curse? Language Modeling for 250 High- and Low-Resource Languages
| 2023-11-15T18:47:42 | 2023-11-15T18:47:42 |
Tyler A. Chang, Catherine Arnett, Zhuowen Tu, Benjamin K. Bergen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multilingual language models are widely used to extend NLP systems to
low-resource languages. However, concrete evidence for the effects of
multilinguality on language modeling performance in individual languages
remains scarce. Here, we pre-train over 10,000 monolingual and multilingual
language models for over 250 languages, including multiple language families
that are under-studied in NLP. We assess how language modeling performance in
each language varies as a function of (1) monolingual dataset size, (2) added
multilingual dataset size, (3) linguistic similarity of the added languages,
and (4) model size (up to 45M parameters). We find that in moderation, adding
multilingual data improves low-resource language modeling performance, similar
to increasing low-resource dataset sizes by up to 33%. Improvements depend on
the syntactic similarity of the added multilingual data, with marginal
additional effects of vocabulary overlap. However, high-resource languages
consistently perform worse in multilingual pre-training scenarios. As dataset
sizes increase, adding multilingual data begins to hurt performance for both
low-resource and high-resource languages, likely due to limited model capacity
(the "curse of multilinguality"). These results suggest that massively
multilingual pre-training may not be optimal for any languages involved, but
that more targeted models can significantly improve performance.
|
[
-0.4988118708,
-0.2350788563,
0.1387948394,
0.4734381139,
-0.2884316444,
0.1786427349,
-0.5273486376,
-0.8322175741,
0.3772543371,
0.5598379374,
-0.2147626579,
-0.0048331479,
-0.7032216191,
0.1877191067,
-0.0429468155,
1.1840776205,
0.2571283579,
0.4312838912,
-0.2950697243,
-0.3487231433,
-0.4565673172,
-1.0711370707,
-0.5391572118,
-0.1446819007,
0.6462066174,
0.1796764731,
0.9077910185,
0.3811504245,
0.633366406,
0.3108406961,
0.0476251766,
0.0632662624,
-0.5652629137,
-0.0172777809,
0.0147805214,
-0.4419040084,
-0.6667147875,
0.0304073617,
0.7213893533,
1.1262682676,
-0.0509674102,
0.5676808357,
0.3034050465,
0.408752203,
-0.6853491068,
0.0123727703,
-0.4729762375,
0.078116253,
-0.6460391283,
-0.1255638301,
-0.3714726865,
0.0979329124,
0.183222875,
-0.5976064801,
0.2108480185,
0.1522564292,
0.589702487,
0.2090293914,
-0.4111425877,
-0.3730531931,
-0.8248727322,
1.0440683365,
-0.7062696815,
0.5579167008,
0.4442003667,
-0.1523741186,
0.2623310685,
-0.2436321676,
-0.4228572845,
-0.4537281692,
-0.1726914495,
0.0683870241,
-0.0423221998,
0.0030506712,
0.4615026712,
0.0138657279,
-0.5044646263,
0.399733603,
-0.5922404528,
-0.1653989106,
0.3044766784,
0.0231281854,
0.3414958119,
-0.2336480767,
-0.290825367,
0.0051453952,
-0.6756410003,
-0.1047534347,
0.8020039797,
0.8154492378,
-0.1422668844,
0.3700762987,
0.3390532136,
0.5755419731,
-0.6490055919,
-0.3881693482,
0.1523296386,
-0.5800073147,
0.0226740222,
0.0830130279,
0.7001881003,
0.1181520298,
0.669129312,
-0.2965447903,
0.0299154725,
0.1385234147,
0.1378663331,
-0.660774231,
-0.2040261775,
-0.1676522344,
-0.4337694347,
0.0458751321,
-0.2316602618,
-0.904171288,
-0.4846166074,
-0.1323486418,
0.0609169751,
-0.3266233802,
-0.5956149101,
0.2632763982,
-0.008217385,
-0.275390178,
0.066081278,
-0.8829574585,
0.3674552143,
0.3833911121,
0.6796090603,
-0.0857251734,
-0.7761682272,
-0.3721291125,
-0.1431528926,
-0.3729950488,
0.6016435623,
-0.6374310851,
-0.4900844395,
-0.1140081957,
-0.0821118876,
-0.2637447715,
-0.6560084224,
0.2232381552,
-0.2638729215,
-0.0348812267,
-0.3279669285,
0.0122628342,
0.0059005725,
-0.0454483815,
-0.9341645837,
0.749997735,
-0.1020398512,
-0.4579769969,
0.6072049141,
-0.4468639195,
-0.6069252491,
0.0395231061,
0.0865108445,
-0.1294373572,
0.3437154293,
-0.1603636146,
0.1675505042,
-0.4437271655,
0.3273522258,
-0.4901548624,
-0.313436985,
0.2028698325,
-0.7278743386,
0.72528404,
0.2019807845,
0.0088658342,
-0.3409468234,
-0.6328256726,
0.0064300345,
-0.069655098,
-0.4937409163,
-0.5552357435,
-0.1467910856,
0.274538666,
0.6956002712,
0.2689071596,
-0.3274092376,
0.0821336508,
-0.3648709655,
-0.1264506131,
0.623966217,
-0.5741629004,
0.4254924655,
-0.3643298149,
0.8206460476,
0.1683895141,
0.1645630151,
-0.0917593762,
-0.5871039033,
-0.6947553754,
0.0935944766,
0.4453670681,
0.3855599761,
-0.7225461006,
-0.2861484289,
-0.4785494208,
-0.3136542737,
-0.7357589602,
0.4792182148,
0.7587072849,
-0.0090205865,
0.3597311378,
-0.5851324201,
-0.5377505422,
-1.0320491791,
-0.4811756313,
-0.2002007514,
0.2744577825,
0.1982525736,
0.4429013133,
0.2093883902,
0.4644633532,
-0.2003603131,
-0.332882762,
-0.2932877541,
0.0870061889,
0.0248776283,
0.5448182225,
0.9623454213,
-0.6442834735,
-0.4878681004,
0.0510749444,
-0.5835515261,
0.0722550154,
0.0440312438,
0.2752865255,
0.4331253171,
0.1668551564,
-0.2756828368,
0.1273127794,
1.006375432,
-0.2471410334,
0.885786593,
-0.4064778686,
0.1232025474,
-0.9562706351,
0.1341025084,
0.0277191456,
0.120966278,
-0.8029711843,
0.0784077644,
-0.0645294562,
-0.2049394697,
-0.4669044614,
0.6019409299,
-0.5515369773,
-0.0967091992,
-0.1345676035,
-0.0801746994,
-0.0962447524,
0.4421916902,
-0.0277852826,
0.8347389102,
0.6107081771,
-0.5870885849,
0.2641943991,
-0.1523254365,
-0.5647735596,
0.2639772892,
-0.2780647874,
-0.033115074,
-0.230815053,
-0.0344739184,
-0.4769180417,
-0.1145401523,
-0.2599994838,
-0.1567658633,
0.4174878597,
-0.2971003652,
-0.7000970244,
-0.4526811242,
-0.0571392998,
0.7249324322,
0.1053670719,
-0.4315086305,
0.5088900328,
0.2692429125,
-0.2675695121,
-0.8210399151,
-0.853226006,
0.3513503075,
-0.2564106584,
-0.6280025244,
0.1116641834,
-0.2873049974,
-0.3720702231,
-0.1654980183,
0.1283549219,
-0.1754734516,
0.1978673041,
0.1308572888,
0.133646667,
-0.2356239259,
0.3832234144,
-0.2936960757,
-0.0074549089,
-0.0589481667,
-0.1861011386,
0.8509585261,
-0.2585662305,
-0.3107603192,
-0.0221413001,
0.5023902655,
0.5421559215,
-0.5301249027,
0.9324487448,
0.4067072868,
-0.2622776926,
-0.1326502115,
-0.6110884547,
-0.0991710499,
-0.4160101116,
0.5379084349,
-0.6374784708,
-0.5992349982,
0.7399725914,
0.1231185123,
-0.1795485318,
0.2503764331,
0.3455210328,
0.1532794088,
1.0191044807,
0.6783064008,
-0.1226872206,
0.4415463209,
-0.0849056393,
0.2227627635,
-0.3694638908,
-0.0368358679,
-0.5412890911,
-0.1733301133,
-0.9766253233,
-0.4182551503,
0.2645954192,
0.1206076592,
0.0115536051,
0.3245071769,
-0.0778211206,
0.3506359458,
0.5285857916,
-0.2214453816,
0.4837870002,
0.0589829944,
-0.0456436835,
-0.3012052774,
-0.9255917668,
-0.3127475083,
1.1881998777,
0.0724513978,
0.7508154511,
0.3114099205,
0.5069055557,
-0.1197089925,
0.2031101137,
-0.5061908364,
0.1683198214,
-0.640661478,
-0.8106971383,
-0.1831878275,
-0.5521453023,
-0.9728298783,
0.395981729,
-0.3049327135,
-0.4296292961,
0.2881858051,
0.323097527,
-0.5661747456,
0.3566693366,
-1.0392837524,
0.9472134709,
-0.5494154692,
-0.3495188057,
-0.3144289255,
-0.4808676243,
0.4134636819,
-0.529060781,
0.6470624208,
-0.0931084603,
0.1920699775,
0.7675426006,
-0.2638595998,
0.8006631732,
0.0259790178,
-0.2310001105,
0.0279686358,
0.067938596,
0.3482677639,
-0.0081859129,
-0.2145543694,
0.3315642774,
0.1191785485,
-0.6624035835,
-0.4309825003,
0.8698556423,
-0.6895805001,
-0.5081158876,
-0.3514010012,
-0.4881966412,
-0.3604116738,
0.2963466048,
0.3625020683,
0.6561548114,
-0.0696585402,
-0.0941071063,
0.3138845563,
-0.505150795,
0.5680913925,
0.5603392124,
-0.2710876465,
0.0173983146,
1.2920571566,
0.5899769068,
0.5667224526,
-0.0425131433,
0.1080406159,
0.0412440859,
-0.3957014084,
-0.3639261723,
0.3785808682,
-0.5293101668,
0.0569337681,
-0.6658918858,
0.0213001389,
-0.5806360245,
0.1618933827,
-0.6742383242,
-0.4037473202,
-0.0414141007,
0.2015376687,
0.0623693652,
0.6412585378,
-0.0700190887,
0.3767999411,
-0.7583351135,
0.0881933197,
0.0561067499,
0.7008081675,
0.168170765,
-0.3992842734,
-0.5782511234,
0.0542682856,
0.0286191758,
-0.4235413373,
0.3737935424,
0.3505595028,
0.3757498264,
0.3067026734,
-0.1910270751,
0.8369506598,
-0.6267194748,
0.6255797148,
0.3241202235,
-0.732191503,
0.0637972876,
-0.2041203231,
0.4355698228,
0.4536572397,
0.3666573465,
-0.7370944619,
-0.5461549163,
-0.4682700336,
-0.6002730131,
0.8151105046,
-0.206989795,
0.5346791148,
0.0202922411,
-0.0223528724,
0.2561326027,
0.32785514,
-1.0437874794,
-0.4213752747,
-0.2257724702,
0.3432687521,
-0.3876542747,
-0.3281672895,
0.0699392855,
-0.1946976185,
0.4489312172,
-0.1613379717,
0.0122086788,
-0.4734571278,
-0.3251971304,
-0.2018400431,
0.2861172259,
0.6390524507,
0.8395524621,
-0.0986210033,
0.3151233792,
0.2667977214,
-0.5105748177,
-0.0398790874,
0.2348209769,
0.324262321,
-0.0616121963,
0.7032977343,
0.9324894547,
0.4745233953,
-0.6149352789,
0.3457118273,
0.0823002681,
0.1649143398,
-0.198268503,
-0.1718349308,
0.1498771459,
-0.1469100118,
0.2061406225,
0.3612148166,
-0.1091404185,
-0.6780628562,
-0.1641774476,
0.3728266358,
-0.2071787566,
-0.4450708032,
0.522898674,
0.0211677775,
-0.0522566587,
0.6273828149,
-0.1562870592,
-0.3928321302,
0.5821305513,
0.4779005647,
0.2322782874,
-0.5971326828,
0.1960703582,
0.3646641374,
0.5605511069,
-0.1332898438,
0.1755316705,
0.3044009209,
-0.9159467816,
-0.6503828764,
-0.9387398958,
-0.0730874389,
0.1408131272,
-0.5565418601,
0.2397138327,
-0.1177764684,
-0.3730665743,
0.0931174308,
-0.0181380231,
-1.0245422125,
0.0919005647,
0.147646293,
0.5896745324,
-0.8194575906,
0.9862003922,
0.43143785,
-0.5654153824,
-0.5678233504,
-0.1890209019,
-0.0901948586,
-0.7323896289,
0.7511531115,
0.0339365192,
-0.0739283189,
0.0046520797,
-0.07756304,
-1.0624539852,
0.3941171765,
0.6758873463,
-0.5184720755,
-0.3153587878,
0.6285037398,
0.7559108138,
-0.2123058289,
0.0832769051,
0.4311617315,
0.5641973615,
-0.4189405143,
-1.439838171,
-0.2175454795,
-0.2126630396,
0.0531468876,
0.2570141554,
-0.6192647815,
0.9666186571,
-0.3588649929,
-0.2349780202,
-0.0181160774,
0.200428322,
-0.0423665643,
-0.0091350693,
0.4531414211,
0.4013529122,
0.5760056973,
-0.0065417457,
1.3242986202,
-0.550907135,
0.2304539829,
1.2098503113,
-0.285474807,
0.5891752243,
0.4731865823,
-0.2210633755,
0.1534866244,
0.3772041798,
0.0615197197,
0.2256882787,
0.2589263916,
-0.2025442123,
-0.3404426575,
-0.4405018687,
-0.3976297975,
0.7398058772,
0.2256978601,
-0.2120587826,
-0.3376286328,
0.5446010232,
0.179201141,
0.0232108962,
-0.1983292401,
0.4995791614,
0.1795460284,
-0.7253793478,
0.7462029457,
-0.0703310594,
0.8660507202,
-0.6118543744,
0.3066101968,
-0.2490707785,
0.069911249,
-0.091218017,
-0.3605525792,
0.3368836045,
0.025784621,
-0.3411974907,
-0.3872237504,
0.3898748755,
-0.706682086,
-0.59619838,
0.856303215,
0.9154188633,
0.2320471108,
-0.0741604567,
-0.5220962167,
-0.0002155484,
-0.3675674498,
-0.0972952321,
0.6591212153,
0.30436939,
-0.1003977433,
0.6326771379,
0.6308961511,
0.4834984541,
0.3517577946,
0.396892339,
0.7119971514,
-0.3641697466,
-0.2253265381,
-0.7601388693,
0.2040292323,
0.1419533044,
-0.5786144733,
0.9228253365,
0.7429630756,
1.1118324995,
-0.2055662125,
0.7513148785,
0.1720262021,
0.2691875994,
-0.4230713546,
0.8700555563,
-0.8551991582,
0.0883511156,
-0.3293873072,
-0.8928128481,
-0.3189736307,
0.1595266759,
-0.2914752662,
0.4582298398,
0.7364890575,
0.7502227426,
-0.0817463249,
-0.2034665644,
0.5410294533,
0.2328956276,
0.1708848476,
0.3367333114,
0.7357760668,
-0.0501590669,
0.6912671924,
-0.3963049054,
-0.1144628301,
-0.0526632406,
-0.6445280313,
-0.6297057867,
-0.6446429491,
0.0401966833,
-0.2213362008,
-0.0820859075,
0.7730218768,
0.6995009184,
-0.7882278562,
-0.5934224129,
0.4177642167,
0.1440442204,
-0.2685350776,
-0.171606034,
0.1112471372,
-0.5189002156,
-0.8680939078,
0.4409046173,
0.1460916549,
0.06379278,
-0.4096523821,
-0.070032917,
-0.3623307943,
-0.155672729,
0.7032758594,
0.2483255416,
-0.7774572372,
-0.0687670484,
0.0115760965,
-0.1239739433,
-0.0413888767,
1.0047245026,
-0.4570405483,
0.7743942142,
0.1215062514,
0.109563902,
0.3000257313,
-0.4638187289,
0.7050427198,
-0.8879039288,
0.3838552535,
0.1101650596,
0.4900452197,
0.3901362121,
-0.1993534863,
0.2100798786,
0.3011804223,
-0.2455489337,
-1.0162210464,
0.1922656894,
-0.4904876053,
-0.4718271792,
0.9365639091,
0.0499747917,
0.1082623675,
-0.2380940318,
0.2418579757,
0.1804505289,
-0.1369071752,
0.6229974627,
1.1122330427,
0.0483329557,
0.0486259349,
-0.9726099968,
0.7377358675,
0.5694264174,
-0.5493473411,
0.3140780032,
0.3749261498,
0.1417635232,
0.5314719081,
0.6399210095,
-0.0175453462,
0.1678474098,
0.1090817302,
0.1266040504,
0.0659376606,
-0.7471026182,
-0.2509128451,
0.1081497371,
0.1990243196,
0.4139365256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09204v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09204v3
|
Fusion-Eval: Integrating Assistant Evaluators with LLMs
| 2023-11-15T18:46:56 | 2024-06-06T22:47:44 |
Lei Shu, Nevan Wichers, Liangchen Luo, Yun Zhu, Yinxiao Liu, Jindong Chen, Lei Meng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Evaluating natural language systems poses significant challenges,
particularly in the realms of natural language understanding and high-level
reasoning. In this paper, we introduce 'Fusion-Eval', an innovative approach
that leverages Large Language Models (LLMs) to integrate insights from various
assistant evaluators. The LLM is given the example to evaluate along with
scores from the assistant evaluators. Each of these evaluators specializes in
assessing distinct aspects of responses. Fusion-Eval achieves a 0.962
system-level Kendall-Tau correlation with humans on SummEval and a 0.744
turn-level Spearman correlation on TopicalChat, which is significantly higher
than baseline methods. These results highlight Fusion-Eval's significant
potential in the realm of natural language system evaluation.
|
[
-0.5609331727,
-0.8653650284,
0.6705047488,
0.0891345367,
0.0350765251,
0.4979029,
-0.2324537337,
-0.5048764944,
0.2172421962,
0.5806117654,
-0.2791557014,
-0.3356028497,
-0.5450250506,
0.1535696536,
-0.6307790875,
0.8781327605,
0.0101782931,
0.112683937,
-0.4502416849,
0.0154277021,
-0.3882854283,
-0.4867380857,
-0.4844870865,
-0.5311095715,
0.0808614567,
0.3479273021,
0.6734155416,
0.0166110452,
0.8060937524,
0.3798555434,
0.0208155904,
0.1647088677,
-0.3812133968,
0.0954574868,
-0.2897275984,
-0.2208858877,
-0.3984072506,
0.0342133865,
0.6889168024,
0.8134307861,
-0.2125310898,
0.0728006586,
0.1758169532,
0.4878866076,
-0.9347804785,
0.0569653176,
-0.2040942609,
-0.1854322106,
0.2765214741,
0.1083455309,
-0.6204387546,
-0.4241489172,
0.454677552,
-0.3688428998,
-0.2059900165,
0.0168989077,
0.6522046924,
0.3064396977,
-0.3546759784,
-0.2085460275,
-0.9865804911,
0.8497725129,
-0.6728187799,
0.3606662452,
0.2844534814,
0.5985103846,
-0.1759626269,
-0.4058690071,
-0.6555095315,
-0.4649859369,
-0.2993310094,
0.1737279892,
-0.4914697409,
0.1304410398,
-0.3014279604,
0.4811351597,
-0.5624427795,
0.1611182094,
-0.1178693324,
-0.0196988434,
1.0048084259,
0.3769080341,
0.2974520922,
-0.3737351298,
-0.4591341019,
-0.1513753533,
-0.0959913507,
-0.2175433785,
0.0843483508,
0.2306918204,
-0.1399872899,
0.6213883758,
-0.271209985,
0.8940683603,
-0.0061195423,
-0.1062537357,
-0.0868740007,
-0.5905894637,
-0.4171565771,
0.0687205791,
1.0528739691,
0.1437959075,
-0.107608512,
-0.1904506236,
-0.3900785446,
0.3434155583,
0.2277877927,
-0.1711006612,
-0.2495813817,
0.2935808301,
-0.3408632874,
-0.3126938045,
0.1452548355,
-0.8037697077,
-0.6558286548,
-0.4812137485,
0.8640381098,
-0.5534091592,
-0.2486971021,
0.0648912489,
-0.2051344812,
0.5373380184,
0.3583751023,
-0.5630038977,
0.8820005655,
1.0528514385,
0.5311025977,
-0.4273672402,
-0.4067427814,
-0.712863028,
-0.1506645828,
-0.1976109892,
1.1428078413,
-0.8325634003,
-0.5489889979,
-0.1392491013,
-0.4887784123,
-0.1141321436,
-0.5170238018,
0.4666051865,
-0.5280183554,
0.266635865,
0.0907519981,
-0.6598850489,
-0.0486944206,
0.328388989,
-0.5145683885,
1.1969132423,
0.2806043625,
-0.3040819764,
0.0361911394,
-0.9853435755,
-0.4243709743,
0.2749586105,
-0.0221909359,
0.048440244,
-0.0020115266,
0.2877228558,
0.3534149826,
-0.7211120725,
0.3742382228,
-0.0818723515,
-0.3009444475,
0.3176549673,
-0.362878859,
0.6234285831,
0.2131838202,
-0.0316903517,
0.3830135465,
-0.8043032289,
-0.2001323253,
-0.0754656494,
-0.3123287857,
-0.517498076,
-0.3038740754,
0.04483293,
-0.0252803154,
0.4938483536,
-0.3615550101,
0.0750639364,
-0.4328822792,
-0.0753227547,
0.5521764159,
0.0729418844,
0.5035051107,
-0.2184632868,
0.7186246514,
-0.5143138766,
0.0590956435,
-0.1369039118,
-0.331900388,
-0.9071157575,
-0.160363093,
0.2857343853,
0.5364191532,
-0.8181684613,
0.9698917866,
-0.2969898283,
-0.8544893861,
-0.6755118966,
0.288320452,
0.5902788639,
0.4182234704,
0.2939932942,
-0.0955392346,
-0.4077044725,
-0.9371112585,
-0.2464730144,
-0.3748340607,
-0.1424311996,
0.2242474705,
0.5011077523,
-0.163052693,
1.207696557,
-0.5007531643,
-0.0283223707,
-0.645917654,
0.28954041,
0.091621466,
0.2651149035,
0.1140435636,
-0.5480456948,
-0.4575743377,
0.2114189565,
-0.6448009014,
-0.3745711148,
0.0285047106,
-0.2037092149,
0.0508390293,
0.1772506386,
-0.5333738923,
0.1855195612,
0.6727132797,
-0.6409096122,
0.4591560066,
-0.254519552,
0.1968656629,
-1.0490016937,
0.2082152963,
0.3595676124,
-0.0936442837,
-0.8491405249,
0.2158927917,
0.0101619605,
-0.1615307182,
-0.3580659628,
0.7531158924,
-0.2979082763,
-0.3705506027,
-0.2856612504,
0.389020741,
0.1099813506,
0.1611814052,
-0.0620145053,
0.5497809052,
0.3441803157,
-0.6367027164,
0.7672847509,
0.1693044603,
-0.368116498,
0.7519279718,
-0.3763892353,
0.2348264307,
0.1143895164,
0.4443242252,
-1.1586940289,
-0.3919872046,
-0.0373198427,
-0.1838404089,
0.0778209195,
0.3476264775,
-0.508564055,
-0.3551917076,
-0.4468135834,
0.1622586101,
0.4730719626,
-0.5639851093,
0.9991516471,
0.6383783817,
-0.0960989296,
-0.2023186088,
-0.3853714764,
0.3629177809,
-0.2212681919,
-0.7171311975,
0.0828659311,
0.1982536763,
-0.7810613513,
0.0956085026,
0.1592119634,
-0.03369743,
0.331638068,
0.0205589831,
0.659706831,
-0.2640073597,
0.1038833559,
-0.0416692272,
-0.3325335085,
-0.008036809,
0.2029609233,
0.7790240645,
-0.4128106833,
-0.6967940927,
-0.6070037484,
0.3551213443,
0.6045173407,
-0.2852572799,
0.6229923368,
0.3297370374,
-0.3970952928,
0.2624441385,
-0.9725033045,
-0.1138177589,
-0.4275799692,
0.2485085577,
-0.1696777344,
-0.7194901705,
0.2724815011,
-0.041641593,
0.1090960279,
0.6447328329,
0.5548003912,
0.1323738992,
1.0719031096,
0.470185101,
-0.1819758564,
0.1651940346,
-0.1453140378,
0.2515121698,
-1.1030430794,
-0.282214433,
-0.6035578251,
-0.4284782112,
-0.1172154397,
-0.3901078999,
0.4217077494,
-0.0018693683,
-0.0401016213,
0.3683633804,
-0.3975732625,
0.5251464248,
0.2984037697,
-0.089450717,
0.4597152472,
-0.5746767521,
0.1678573638,
0.3737594485,
-0.4902989566,
-0.677054584,
0.8737962842,
0.4229758978,
0.9515787363,
0.2894393802,
0.8957185149,
0.3918653727,
0.5340144634,
-1.0135045052,
0.8043189645,
-0.1870612204,
-0.1293483973,
-0.5135258436,
-0.2141142339,
-0.9065101743,
0.4138613641,
-0.3017140329,
-0.9646673799,
-0.0860023871,
-0.1723890901,
-0.6905439496,
-0.2029864192,
-1.0178904533,
0.6517822742,
-0.3203342557,
0.0120556895,
-0.3476253748,
-0.4079744518,
0.6506214738,
-0.1142963246,
0.3537526727,
-0.0363184772,
-0.1449947506,
0.8903820515,
-0.3417852819,
0.5951201916,
0.0698642805,
-0.2390856743,
0.105642207,
0.2090712488,
0.414673537,
-0.2313114554,
-0.2332538515,
-0.1181466356,
-0.0191316474,
-0.1473508328,
-0.8777227998,
0.9347913861,
-0.8197832704,
-0.8029943705,
-0.3466757536,
-0.5407729745,
-0.5192526579,
-0.1255342811,
-0.2753649056,
0.2195395976,
-0.3568480611,
0.2085069269,
0.2280887663,
-0.1857587695,
0.3096314669,
0.67898947,
-0.4547845721,
-0.2765571177,
0.8820767999,
-0.3452987671,
0.5042771697,
0.3595601618,
0.5858321786,
-0.2419512868,
-0.1491923779,
-0.3520256877,
0.1130707264,
-0.6625805497,
-0.2068780065,
-0.7578989267,
-0.2895488143,
-0.559894979,
-0.2390650362,
-0.257379353,
-0.2717151642,
-0.1618254036,
0.0820203796,
0.3337427974,
0.9518125653,
0.1241483688,
0.2195536941,
-1.0198403597,
0.3725058734,
0.4723979831,
0.1032411084,
0.0409164689,
-0.488442421,
-0.0653019547,
-0.1266649067,
-0.1628759503,
-1.0353537798,
0.4743282497,
0.0992796868,
0.6936839819,
0.3427154422,
0.0689385012,
0.7214413285,
-0.194693312,
1.1569012403,
0.1967392117,
-1.2238454819,
0.7065643072,
-0.0681956485,
0.5465242863,
0.5727446079,
0.1723835021,
-0.5578466058,
-0.6264104843,
-0.5855355859,
-0.5717580318,
0.7572999597,
0.1143407747,
0.0123951342,
0.0918806493,
-0.050055407,
0.0396220423,
-0.2417175174,
-0.2005852312,
0.0105890278,
0.3081863225,
-0.2962705791,
-0.0835056975,
-0.1442727745,
-0.1193351969,
-0.363925159,
0.5542547107,
-0.0507404841,
-0.0147363758,
-0.013787156,
-0.2175766975,
-0.00573172,
0.4555340707,
0.4227672517,
0.5849182606,
-0.0580941774,
0.2382400632,
0.543048501,
-0.0583368056,
-0.0098470384,
0.1385018975,
0.3673040271,
-0.1194321811,
0.5983474255,
0.6347717047,
0.6890187263,
-0.9025400281,
0.4251525104,
-0.1694541425,
0.0196632594,
-0.0123961652,
0.2279031426,
0.146854654,
0.2107218355,
0.4810644388,
-0.2772703171,
0.44516927,
-0.720022738,
0.2444331199,
0.5915081501,
-0.4434063733,
-0.2302960902,
-0.011708484,
0.4866949916,
-0.6762503982,
0.3049264848,
0.0593202449,
-0.5810156465,
0.5931281447,
0.5622252822,
1.0189071894,
-0.677952826,
0.1463307887,
0.0856166556,
-0.0048198984,
0.0871383846,
0.0199116245,
-0.1080695391,
-0.6772570014,
-0.5090315342,
-0.861634016,
-0.7786491513,
0.1133599281,
-0.716467917,
0.4482876956,
-0.1508307159,
0.1380141079,
0.2560993135,
-0.0696737841,
-0.6565949917,
-0.1857943088,
0.1446017176,
0.9431890845,
-0.9576984644,
0.5943542123,
0.8002604842,
-0.1346679777,
-0.6487073898,
-0.038850829,
0.1270827204,
-0.8042708039,
0.6690313816,
-0.0546230823,
-0.2494160086,
-0.1289459318,
-0.0772311613,
-0.7878145576,
0.9884784818,
0.2880724669,
-0.3272977769,
0.1179697961,
0.0697313622,
0.7705360651,
-0.4475445449,
0.4432627857,
1.3270089626,
0.5873013139,
0.1428263783,
-1.4126857519,
-0.1658875793,
-0.2689510286,
-0.0375952683,
0.4522146285,
-0.4716784656,
0.5763087273,
0.1277344674,
-0.2394708544,
0.0336673521,
0.4433994293,
0.1809522808,
0.2531060278,
0.5374654531,
0.4386119843,
0.6105594635,
0.1268522888,
1.4211238623,
-0.3911742866,
0.3873168826,
1.0666089058,
-0.3913917243,
1.142747879,
0.5494526029,
-0.3791922331,
0.457894206,
0.2160697579,
0.2288894206,
0.193096593,
0.2140355259,
-0.6036333442,
-0.4319797754,
-0.4185711145,
0.023090601,
0.8885156512,
0.5132680535,
-0.1401165873,
-0.5159577727,
0.165613547,
-0.3392543495,
0.2389551699,
-0.0855901316,
1.2689633369,
0.0697122812,
-0.7895498872,
0.2501577437,
-0.0537301749,
0.6309294701,
-0.3869638443,
-0.1655359864,
0.0110577736,
0.083932586,
-0.1561190933,
-1.0591602325,
0.4178218842,
0.2213432342,
0.4021850526,
0.004654177,
0.9558168054,
-0.1963246316,
-0.6262252331,
0.2974156439,
0.6127007008,
0.1440271884,
0.1077111289,
-0.4603404999,
0.1738255918,
-0.3306944966,
-0.1840843707,
0.3602595627,
-0.0116161462,
0.156598568,
0.7177872062,
0.7313886285,
-0.1500473022,
-0.2855164707,
0.0116071729,
0.8012205362,
-0.5442016125,
-0.4015437365,
-1.1847282648,
0.507139802,
-0.1952846199,
-0.2880136669,
0.760455668,
0.5195882916,
0.250369817,
0.2013586611,
0.7644186616,
0.1856300235,
0.5357739329,
-0.4987484217,
0.6508788466,
-0.2505396605,
0.4727838635,
-0.3542833626,
-0.9917640686,
-0.1635762751,
0.557101965,
-0.5549789667,
-0.2508085668,
0.5013965368,
0.4379994571,
0.0084038535,
0.3195731938,
0.4368808866,
-0.1278858632,
0.6204506159,
0.5745456219,
1.1900477409,
-0.2394634783,
0.3874586225,
-0.2323118597,
-0.445279628,
-0.3576665223,
-0.6277562976,
-0.7075623274,
-0.5408389568,
-0.1967410594,
-0.1924615353,
-0.2580189407,
1.1201740503,
0.2459714264,
-0.715307653,
-0.5327797532,
0.1189825013,
0.1534381509,
0.0574880838,
-0.371852994,
0.347094804,
-0.3386769593,
-0.7459918857,
0.6658401489,
0.5956500769,
-0.2935141623,
-0.8883261085,
-0.276172936,
-0.289606452,
0.3039394617,
0.708982408,
0.0307021961,
-1.0385780334,
-0.502201438,
-0.0553566962,
-0.163494125,
-0.1452007145,
0.6923186779,
-1.1729412079,
0.5666273236,
0.5598422885,
0.9610315561,
0.0960732773,
0.0364867598,
0.8310407996,
-0.5531264544,
-0.3732327521,
0.4478646219,
0.3408014476,
0.3369984031,
-0.2811542749,
0.4451028705,
-0.2832859755,
-0.4401259124,
-1.0337468386,
0.0133277858,
-1.0216472149,
-0.0554337353,
1.3952749968,
0.0816030651,
-0.0933021978,
-0.2234614938,
-0.3011504412,
0.0073202564,
-0.4211758673,
0.8353814483,
0.9669469595,
-0.6414740086,
-0.1779707968,
-0.1425896585,
0.1120197549,
0.4552372098,
-1.3477572203,
-0.0811125711,
0.3617606163,
-0.1412512064,
0.764677465,
0.4024621844,
0.2016342729,
0.346696943,
-0.1005938277,
-0.2104741484,
0.2521116138,
0.0297516305,
-0.7119437456,
0.0773170814,
0.023416752,
-0.0109946672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10770v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10770v2
|
Exponentially Faster Language Modelling
| 2023-11-15T18:42:50 | 2023-11-21T06:59:59 |
Peter Belcak, Roger Wattenhofer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE
|
Language models only really need to use an exponential fraction of their
neurons for individual inferences. As proof, we present UltraFastBERT, a BERT
variant that uses 0.3% of its neurons during inference while performing on par
with similar BERT models. UltraFastBERT selectively engages just 12 out of 4095
neurons for each layer inference. This is achieved by replacing feedforward
networks with fast feedforward networks (FFFs). While no truly efficient
implementation currently exists to unlock the full acceleration potential of
conditional neural execution, we provide high-level CPU code achieving 78x
speedup over the optimized baseline feedforward implementation, and a PyTorch
implementation delivering 40x speedup over the equivalent batched feedforward
inference. We publish our training code, benchmarking setup, and model weights.
|
[
-0.0276743434,
-0.9575072527,
0.5023466945,
0.826441586,
0.1529576033,
-0.04322109,
-0.3088147044,
-0.5938685536,
-0.1158262864,
0.4414854646,
-0.4041047096,
-0.0322030522,
-0.3955099881,
-0.1660298109,
-0.699014008,
0.7658977509,
0.35507828,
0.1573243141,
0.320040077,
-0.1310963333,
0.3673079014,
-0.3907464743,
-0.8038241863,
-0.5782658458,
0.6800480485,
0.2955467999,
0.9947119355,
0.7100734115,
0.233134836,
0.4012910724,
-0.4741550684,
-0.5359535813,
-0.3432693183,
0.1954976171,
0.2330232412,
-0.3660647273,
-0.3005415499,
-0.2689309418,
0.6928268075,
0.8586401343,
-0.2175885886,
0.0588171892,
-0.4305916131,
0.7200995088,
-0.4327636361,
-0.0692257881,
-0.6254894733,
0.3293029368,
0.0829991475,
0.0012787131,
-0.6947908998,
-0.2536342442,
0.3039048612,
-0.5508720279,
0.3750963509,
0.071250625,
0.6502190828,
-0.0943023711,
-0.1903804392,
0.1863991022,
-0.6306331754,
0.4748846292,
-0.7508042455,
0.6740458608,
-0.0263866503,
0.1613081843,
-0.2039625794,
-1.4437334538,
-0.6188113093,
-0.236060217,
0.1541827023,
-0.2653188109,
-0.3564420938,
0.5676118135,
0.6823300123,
0.0412344784,
-0.6814054847,
0.1809102148,
-0.0721196532,
-0.2865510285,
0.5039418936,
0.2316010445,
-0.0079279151,
-0.0839601755,
-0.3623603582,
-0.3229546547,
-0.5487540364,
0.2250994891,
0.4388739467,
0.1459240764,
0.2390005291,
0.2549255788,
-0.3108412623,
0.8522794843,
-0.1367064267,
0.1169765368,
0.3002512157,
-0.0428069942,
-0.3826556802,
0.1124203056,
0.7718802094,
-0.0142618287,
0.2974234521,
-0.2896910906,
-0.4238738716,
-0.0591263101,
-0.1284555942,
-1.0598655939,
-0.6419731975,
0.473207891,
-0.5143612027,
-0.1022493392,
-0.587043941,
-0.5640618801,
-0.0381729715,
-0.1126774997,
0.5189687014,
-0.5193586349,
-0.1526484936,
0.0492270552,
-0.3113725185,
0.1408880353,
0.3107043803,
-0.9457455277,
0.1073103547,
0.5912547112,
0.6523883939,
0.1233823746,
-0.4658612907,
-0.5099399686,
-0.2260086089,
-0.5546310544,
0.6817809343,
-0.6675596237,
-0.0014749353,
0.1046520472,
0.1506712288,
0.0019507912,
-0.0764648318,
0.8663574457,
-0.8071194887,
-0.1997157484,
-0.09890683,
-0.58433038,
-0.2571071386,
-0.6296933293,
-0.5905125737,
1.2132053375,
0.1747604311,
-0.5886385441,
0.3196418881,
-0.4194698632,
-0.7484467626,
0.2347644269,
0.1758904159,
-0.1586652547,
0.2677164674,
0.2593021393,
0.6827812195,
-0.143751204,
0.4997669458,
-0.2691887617,
-0.5817053914,
0.0217754506,
-0.5530537367,
0.9951002598,
0.4020346999,
-0.6099944115,
0.2923615277,
-0.8091343641,
0.3697349429,
0.0895440057,
-0.3481194079,
-0.156238094,
0.0995345861,
0.4122903943,
0.2850451767,
-0.0154514657,
-0.5584466457,
0.0512077399,
-0.2722258568,
0.7085647583,
0.8927934766,
-0.3773744106,
0.4554382861,
0.0325891003,
0.3814995885,
-0.3428692222,
0.3772906363,
-0.4325307012,
-0.6646394134,
-0.8316170573,
-0.4707013071,
0.7640173435,
0.3402846754,
-0.927377522,
0.4025908113,
-0.1574664563,
-0.3316197693,
-0.6164014339,
-0.0152835697,
0.5721493363,
0.4647929966,
0.1429785639,
0.1010158285,
-0.3934904635,
-0.9730827808,
-0.1828834116,
-0.1571086496,
-0.2137354761,
0.1501976997,
0.4204113185,
0.1334848851,
0.4396663606,
-0.179635033,
0.3214398921,
-0.3786413074,
0.4965262711,
0.3629735112,
0.4499739408,
0.6691487432,
-0.6923293471,
-0.4885352552,
-0.2383419871,
-0.5347900987,
-0.1775913984,
-0.1262412965,
-0.1769698113,
0.2519858778,
0.5624598861,
-0.5612406731,
0.2802557051,
0.641946733,
-0.2829009891,
0.2359525561,
-0.4772452712,
-0.0530220903,
-0.3672432601,
-0.0133724539,
0.035130281,
-0.2452523857,
-0.6535214186,
0.2195242047,
0.5938034654,
-0.2362221479,
-0.6793480515,
0.4781026244,
-0.4891956151,
-0.0840907916,
-0.1041363403,
0.0219735764,
-0.1417048573,
0.8803576827,
0.0282005034,
0.976480186,
0.9144595861,
-0.5244132876,
0.0688243583,
-0.0116861574,
-0.3728070557,
-0.2473824173,
-1.0934239626,
0.0323051624,
-0.1121520922,
0.4935537577,
-0.9920411706,
-0.0163081624,
-0.3579706252,
-0.3439120948,
0.1934244186,
-0.10609027,
-0.8222684264,
-0.6007087231,
-0.3999196887,
-0.0434105694,
0.8679300547,
-0.9541552663,
0.6267079115,
0.2270555794,
0.0244351383,
-0.8133949637,
-0.8099414706,
-0.1287754327,
0.451408416,
-0.7612065673,
0.4092950523,
-0.0438499413,
0.0712709352,
-0.0165870208,
0.0140665201,
0.0145463832,
0.1465437263,
0.123559922,
-0.0247233715,
-0.3188851178,
0.1388554573,
0.1690416038,
0.0945396423,
-0.1154756621,
-0.5506730676,
0.5144855976,
-0.2211578637,
0.1223992482,
-0.4659132659,
0.3131489456,
0.442494154,
0.0187378563,
0.9105067849,
0.6104852557,
-0.2002673298,
-0.4439398944,
-0.5153561234,
-0.2032049745,
-0.5516536832,
0.3921176493,
-0.3315097392,
-0.9460609555,
0.6108297706,
0.1544486135,
0.1129989848,
0.5428472161,
0.5228176713,
0.1482487917,
1.4510502815,
0.8222658038,
-0.0944735259,
0.6173371077,
-0.3771353662,
0.2926393449,
-0.8028069139,
-0.0232228171,
-0.6761666536,
-0.1961472034,
-0.6763299704,
-0.312661171,
0.0705299675,
0.2738434374,
-0.2173853815,
0.5902203918,
-0.5748356581,
0.5443282723,
0.4665216208,
0.0239031631,
0.0613584965,
0.1503010392,
-0.6334251761,
0.2635318041,
-1.1865773201,
-0.184507221,
1.2205351591,
0.2552753687,
0.79888767,
-0.102704607,
-0.0238357931,
0.4395342171,
0.5649340153,
-0.5341145396,
0.8079096079,
-0.1414240748,
-1.0286338329,
-0.2521120012,
-0.6033412218,
-0.7136805654,
0.4062747657,
-0.2102434039,
-0.87042588,
0.1770078987,
0.2465939373,
-0.4434891939,
0.3365410864,
-1.0323388577,
0.712665379,
-0.2072120011,
-0.67575109,
-0.2191109359,
-0.8229930997,
0.256742239,
0.0500151664,
-0.2175222933,
-0.3337770402,
0.0807215646,
0.7857939601,
-0.2767917812,
0.4661326408,
-0.2970962822,
0.2472563386,
0.1808046252,
0.0110980859,
0.5315061212,
0.1283646524,
-0.4363059402,
0.2911432683,
-0.4165295064,
-0.4691553116,
-0.5101629496,
0.8936286569,
-0.5806171894,
-0.3871874213,
-0.3438442051,
-0.5016883016,
-0.1664697826,
-0.0087859184,
0.0768008456,
0.4887992144,
-0.0386770777,
0.070790492,
0.4943413436,
-0.0778098702,
1.0705822706,
0.7676846981,
-0.1835107654,
-0.0936444998,
0.729341805,
-0.0171754546,
0.1138483956,
0.4682627618,
0.0433129817,
-0.4671644866,
-0.4689233005,
-0.5759690404,
0.1061811075,
-0.7735977769,
0.0102248434,
-1.2011425495,
-0.2213593125,
-0.4087233543,
-0.3045027256,
-0.4151520133,
-0.8831282854,
0.0979264751,
0.0772824734,
0.6361297369,
0.4644370079,
-0.2401362658,
0.6638525724,
-0.6251965761,
0.0953365415,
0.4088692665,
0.3734489977,
0.5125553012,
-0.6475251913,
-0.1255566031,
-0.1898065358,
-0.2038851231,
-0.4977813661,
0.4503223896,
0.5381937027,
0.6833249331,
0.4450095594,
-0.1749606282,
0.6292538047,
-0.8807044625,
0.7199617028,
0.3400576711,
-1.09763062,
0.1804165691,
-0.1357865185,
0.2652351856,
0.3737843633,
0.7514324188,
-0.2561731637,
-0.3185076416,
-0.7603160143,
-1.082529664,
0.7818309069,
0.2984137535,
0.218356818,
-0.003449094,
0.4165045023,
-0.0464583263,
0.2102432102,
-0.4675397575,
-0.3831294179,
0.0569004975,
-0.0954054818,
-0.3148430586,
-0.3059663177,
0.1560567915,
-0.7985519171,
0.5892134905,
-0.200730592,
0.7676108479,
0.213437289,
-0.2324823439,
-0.2011782378,
-0.0655613691,
0.6011314392,
0.744582057,
-0.3920536041,
0.0452969708,
0.0116994698,
-0.3625922203,
0.21251221,
0.381848067,
-0.0770123303,
0.1300685555,
0.5240173936,
0.9285095334,
0.2735387385,
-0.7195770144,
0.498961091,
-0.4676859081,
-0.2887225449,
-0.0615323633,
0.1687157601,
0.3729400933,
0.4803596735,
0.5687832832,
0.0438709743,
0.0867288113,
-0.3347962201,
0.3643243015,
0.1629469246,
-0.3451908529,
-0.3744329512,
1.0055407286,
0.2093454003,
-0.4998240471,
0.9555960298,
-0.2410776913,
-0.735791266,
0.6876909733,
0.3876618445,
0.9445774555,
-0.2200499177,
0.2250797451,
0.081563659,
0.2471850514,
-0.2306538671,
0.4159754217,
-0.3425167203,
-0.5612209439,
-0.7264963388,
-0.9224618077,
-0.3378384709,
-0.0661570951,
-0.1630809903,
-0.2629895508,
-0.6831565499,
-0.1998046488,
0.6924780011,
-0.3173856139,
-0.4843434691,
0.1616547704,
-0.0342262723,
1.1996577978,
-0.7690736651,
1.255348444,
0.4148467481,
-0.0850534365,
-0.8671257496,
-0.044414077,
-0.333778739,
-0.7133078575,
1.102181077,
0.1021089703,
0.0152279306,
0.0498927794,
-0.6866481304,
-0.4623596072,
0.6843352914,
0.400411278,
-0.7465590239,
0.0511491559,
-0.273480624,
0.7860461473,
-0.3560270369,
0.7970331907,
0.4677552879,
0.2295428216,
-0.0333919637,
-0.4886104465,
-0.1807886362,
-0.2559933364,
0.3733607829,
0.2652161419,
-0.6561356783,
1.2095607519,
-0.2846671343,
0.1718432456,
0.0508797765,
0.7487030625,
-0.2413535565,
-0.1277760118,
0.5266949534,
0.6217064857,
0.3871861398,
-0.1203265414,
1.2171751261,
-0.8333140612,
0.4968794584,
0.7367076874,
-0.2967909873,
0.8604715466,
0.2489783615,
-0.1240996644,
0.1719360501,
0.5783681273,
0.2440542877,
0.5307912827,
0.2462047487,
-0.4126146138,
-0.445969671,
-0.0635235384,
-0.2174918205,
0.2486087233,
0.2934297621,
-0.6319332719,
0.0242200624,
0.0702351332,
0.2849310338,
-0.3072813153,
-0.2662980855,
0.1598220468,
-0.1626775861,
-0.7762707472,
0.8247360587,
0.2558487356,
0.7288951874,
-0.7240479589,
-0.1372768581,
-0.3244723976,
0.3487158418,
0.0595667548,
-0.8455981612,
-0.1735253185,
-0.037911661,
0.0858121738,
-0.3652738035,
0.5418291688,
-0.2159936577,
-0.5376344323,
0.7719238997,
0.0799409151,
-0.019408999,
0.0279418789,
-0.8654120564,
0.173933208,
0.011159108,
-0.722546041,
0.1667326093,
0.3927223384,
0.1063964069,
0.7662078142,
0.7934423685,
0.0302368496,
0.42111215,
0.2033588588,
1.0155605078,
-0.50290066,
-0.2781287432,
-0.6151841283,
0.2333818674,
-0.0619839914,
-0.440186888,
0.7165370584,
0.2917248011,
0.7872547507,
0.0596086234,
0.2998024225,
-0.2435989231,
0.1314809322,
-0.4579981863,
0.8717803955,
-0.7945569754,
0.0358768962,
-0.316765964,
-0.8253646493,
-0.2835045159,
0.6156199574,
0.0076439688,
0.0813861042,
0.897018671,
0.8733116984,
0.0213890634,
0.473649472,
0.5685455203,
0.3333716094,
0.1744974405,
0.5848312974,
0.4697852433,
-0.5073664188,
0.4193892181,
-0.7547706962,
-0.321947813,
-0.2081858814,
-0.9611708522,
-0.8886159062,
-0.4991253614,
-0.2110125721,
-0.3361962438,
0.5499901175,
0.7659472823,
1.1054382324,
-0.6563661695,
-0.1771196425,
-0.3022808731,
0.0203338824,
-0.256534189,
-0.2283213735,
0.3231045604,
-0.2521033883,
-0.5841449499,
0.4650385082,
0.247993663,
-0.3655772507,
-0.1350925118,
0.070604153,
-0.4621763825,
0.2554793358,
0.6264227033,
0.3270264864,
-0.370924145,
-0.2228567004,
0.0600126758,
-0.137099281,
-0.0039636404,
1.0905362368,
-0.8886682391,
0.3924527466,
0.7599641681,
0.6683220267,
0.8503099084,
-0.3825026155,
0.3953812122,
-0.4605160952,
0.7278012037,
0.3220642507,
0.3984620869,
0.1589268446,
-0.2665829957,
0.2992401719,
0.2508493066,
-0.7139517069,
-0.7580282092,
-0.0509460792,
-0.6811711192,
-0.3522977531,
0.7418591976,
-0.4373193681,
-0.6205372214,
0.1728516519,
0.2717413902,
0.2100717872,
-0.6887879968,
0.2693509459,
0.2727587819,
-0.4289296567,
-0.2153613716,
-0.8622881174,
0.410864532,
0.8842900991,
-0.3481395543,
0.0980259925,
0.1711716205,
0.0804668963,
-0.0603402928,
0.5165848136,
0.0979690552,
0.3513069749,
0.3078232706,
0.4405719042,
0.1468303204,
-0.6871592402,
-0.3615444005,
0.3072701097,
-0.1138321161,
0.3197193444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09198v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09198v1
|
Never Lost in the Middle: Improving Large Language Models via Attention Strengthening Question Answering
| 2023-11-15T18:42:44 | 2023-11-15T18:42:44 |
Junqing He, Kunhao Pan, Xiaoqun Dong, Zhuoyang Song, Yibo Liu, Yuxin Liang, Hao Wang, Qianguo Sun, Songxin Zhang, Zejian Xie, Jiaxing Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While large language models (LLMs) are equipped with longer text input
capabilities than before, they are struggling to seek correct information in
long contexts. The "lost in the middle" problem challenges most LLMs, referring
to the dramatic decline in accuracy when correct information is located in the
middle. To overcome this crucial issue, this paper proposes to enhance the
information searching and reflection ability of LLMs in long contexts via
specially designed tasks called Attention Strengthening Multi-doc QA (ASM QA).
Following these tasks, our model excels in focusing more precisely on the
desired information. Experimental results show substantial improvement in
Multi-doc QA and other benchmarks, superior to state-of-the-art models by 13.7%
absolute gain in shuffled settings, by 21.5% in passage retrieval task. We
release our model, Ziya-Reader to promote related research in the community.
|
[
-0.3538980186,
-0.6439897418,
1.0659569502,
0.1576156467,
-0.3582045138,
0.0719469935,
-0.2825652063,
-0.2641566992,
-0.0076244334,
0.5616893172,
-0.4906466603,
-0.5213702917,
-0.8486247063,
0.0155609688,
-0.4721934199,
0.6384682059,
-0.0134422556,
0.177262038,
-0.107257098,
-0.1978982836,
-0.4339206219,
-0.3869572878,
-0.8156383038,
-0.1907806247,
0.7755696177,
0.6991772056,
0.7055593729,
0.4128863513,
0.5500741601,
0.2066235989,
-0.3317433894,
0.3057317734,
-0.6522468328,
-0.0401795842,
-0.2256683707,
-0.7775659561,
-0.3253690004,
-0.010080575,
1.029309392,
0.7156086564,
-0.4216373265,
0.0026788327,
-0.1491605043,
1.0952738523,
-0.8008503318,
-0.0723663121,
-0.5110175014,
-0.1468731314,
-0.3506362736,
-0.4179466963,
-0.3880196512,
-0.3858217895,
0.2329813838,
-0.4591839612,
0.3886155188,
-0.0039659217,
0.8079918623,
0.2725103796,
-0.7198187113,
-0.1525922567,
-0.6143272519,
0.8232936859,
-0.8693703413,
0.7078528404,
0.1956242919,
0.2441788912,
-0.2675814629,
-0.366482228,
-0.7753263712,
-0.0923666283,
0.2493716329,
0.2111559212,
-0.0568749495,
0.1412542611,
0.2346033454,
0.2057849765,
-0.2607390583,
-0.272151202,
-0.2790792584,
0.2426235676,
0.4317761064,
0.0636760965,
0.34506616,
0.2443488091,
-0.1888827235,
-0.0784813613,
-0.9481217861,
0.2180954218,
0.2325041443,
0.0269293506,
0.2390858382,
0.4510436654,
-0.2308909297,
0.7583499551,
0.2130420208,
-0.1612491459,
-0.1239657104,
-0.491730541,
-0.1776445061,
-0.0473183692,
0.2018135339,
0.5269168019,
0.1158173755,
-0.2570412457,
-0.2440784723,
-0.4631345272,
0.4158531725,
-0.6666740775,
0.1366639584,
0.1746477485,
-0.5738297105,
0.1772818863,
-0.1323836595,
-0.4478676915,
-0.3400394022,
-0.3525483906,
0.084232308,
-0.277812928,
-0.294880867,
0.3239376843,
-0.0089387558,
0.4968451858,
0.6234784126,
-0.8268872499,
0.3707117736,
0.6265550852,
0.8469737172,
-0.1385446042,
-0.1194006503,
-0.6633144617,
0.3775649667,
-0.5752894878,
0.8162343502,
-0.63592875,
-0.1554721147,
-0.0468682908,
0.0296935774,
-0.1870928854,
-0.5595486164,
0.6584880352,
-0.8915138245,
0.1363077164,
-0.4586933851,
-0.4594690502,
-0.3213725388,
0.6372511983,
-0.6432869434,
0.8867533207,
0.0506335199,
-0.771350801,
-0.1711585671,
-0.5515808463,
-0.2117985487,
-0.2794034779,
-0.1172556505,
-0.4257737994,
0.2350466549,
0.3217429221,
0.3776715994,
-0.4298672378,
0.1749843061,
-0.234907046,
-0.6105448604,
0.3310474753,
-0.1670894176,
0.4485038221,
-0.313700527,
-0.3386002779,
0.1406201273,
-0.6974473,
-0.038476795,
0.0958193094,
-0.6878373623,
-0.6098656058,
-0.1144879237,
0.1447266191,
0.3412007093,
0.2342867106,
-0.7642305493,
0.202893123,
-0.4818555415,
0.1799656153,
0.5639180541,
-0.0911939591,
0.4858796,
-0.2027783543,
0.6626347899,
0.1461420953,
0.3151025474,
0.140344277,
-0.3623972833,
-0.8079528809,
0.1241025105,
0.1667521447,
0.3669665158,
-0.8464369178,
0.0334264748,
-0.2754291296,
-0.4238860309,
-0.9844594002,
0.1472520232,
0.4381239116,
0.5106116533,
0.33836326,
-0.3489702642,
-0.2288684547,
-0.9168921709,
-0.2205669433,
0.021112578,
0.1097195297,
0.3532667756,
-0.0033690105,
-0.3477680385,
0.543097198,
-0.6003718972,
-0.4976689816,
-0.4825467169,
-0.2645811141,
0.4425980449,
0.0486552529,
0.3129448891,
-0.9893038273,
-0.6829022765,
-0.1074825078,
-0.3531596959,
0.0253528953,
0.1991609037,
-0.2806538641,
0.0526172444,
0.5991281271,
-0.9035589099,
0.174349308,
0.3756287992,
-0.4259062409,
0.6021302938,
-0.1918377578,
0.1296989918,
-1.0531058311,
0.4133691788,
-0.0936876237,
-0.1584286839,
-0.8278009892,
0.2857444584,
0.4075165093,
-0.1330682784,
-0.1430437416,
0.6110344529,
-0.6519922614,
-0.0323864259,
-0.5897011161,
0.5991855264,
0.1980384886,
0.4879700243,
-0.1465897262,
0.849467814,
0.4747667909,
-0.4247314632,
0.192598775,
0.1025591344,
-0.1736614853,
0.6907190681,
-0.633035183,
0.2429650277,
-0.5754206181,
0.3019287884,
-1.0909825563,
-0.0582844913,
0.0710276589,
-0.4221844375,
0.5844509602,
0.0275442246,
-0.578353405,
-0.3112246394,
-0.3885453939,
0.2550411224,
0.1489902139,
-0.345520556,
0.6366038918,
0.4145217836,
-0.4376426637,
-1.0274909735,
-0.3267826438,
0.2202037275,
0.0024340404,
-0.7012462616,
0.187442705,
-0.2591765225,
-0.0326416902,
-0.0782122388,
-0.2902792394,
-0.2164190114,
0.1452046037,
-0.1129978225,
0.0694771558,
-0.2405233532,
0.6849380732,
-0.0719893649,
-0.1305943727,
0.0461281687,
-0.1776896864,
0.5000767708,
-0.1828279346,
-0.1523482352,
-0.4246028364,
0.8137797713,
0.7146723866,
-0.5953304172,
0.6810390353,
0.5641871095,
-0.2720538974,
-0.0954029933,
-1.0336045027,
-0.1829811037,
-0.4003632069,
0.5759013891,
-0.2882781923,
-0.9575443268,
0.5748829246,
0.1330937743,
0.0012331847,
0.2837555408,
0.3736435473,
-0.1126591563,
1.1278059483,
1.2689294815,
-0.2287960947,
0.7004917264,
-0.1207462028,
0.4321232438,
-1.2460503578,
-0.3328348994,
-0.4519153833,
-0.2255841196,
-0.0243023895,
-0.4321074486,
0.6442788243,
0.1333085597,
0.2408242226,
-0.1904289573,
-0.4766055048,
0.5979653597,
0.792344451,
0.2673136294,
0.4422077537,
-0.2333211601,
0.022778023,
0.0436744913,
-0.842132628,
-0.5391507745,
1.1593004465,
0.4126088619,
0.7070336938,
0.3392798603,
0.6190527678,
-0.2269214243,
0.375222683,
-0.719606936,
0.4817150235,
-0.1114648208,
-0.6105463505,
-0.7146859765,
-0.3289944828,
-0.9603654742,
0.3503680825,
0.2440857291,
-0.3704178333,
0.2094070166,
-0.120632574,
-0.815402329,
0.2588578761,
-0.5385083556,
0.7048778534,
0.0408650339,
-0.299695015,
-0.4639160931,
-0.9236114621,
0.2623527944,
-0.0490677655,
0.011915111,
-0.2296534181,
-0.1956581175,
0.6455372572,
-0.1572910696,
0.5357787609,
-0.2015217543,
-0.194644928,
0.1584635377,
-0.380019635,
0.5328319073,
-0.0104156928,
0.0449610129,
-0.4302759469,
-0.1130147278,
-0.7023624182,
-0.88964504,
0.6968179941,
-0.7569812536,
-0.941727221,
-0.2130325735,
-0.7063655257,
-0.2652614713,
0.4955705106,
-0.1478035152,
0.3174355626,
-0.0307757147,
0.2799415588,
1.2801722288,
-0.0076847617,
0.2995347977,
0.8795494437,
0.1538168937,
-0.1298304945,
0.3814765215,
0.3301972449,
0.1997116655,
0.3586214483,
-0.0424170531,
-0.4482230246,
-0.6933034062,
-0.5458706617,
0.6378320456,
-0.8824238777,
-0.2351067066,
-1.0733735561,
-0.153497979,
-0.3647824526,
0.1287064999,
-0.3923107386,
-0.0844921917,
-0.2841463983,
0.0780130103,
-0.011389778,
0.4830525517,
0.3302992284,
0.5024313331,
-0.9671243429,
0.304261297,
0.3180517256,
0.4894786477,
0.4601127505,
-0.4799599051,
-0.5768529177,
-0.212366581,
-0.3526607454,
-0.8762064576,
0.1447229087,
-0.0652133226,
0.5747832656,
0.3769327402,
-0.0947310776,
0.5073230863,
-0.3942779005,
0.3882058263,
0.1594679356,
-0.7578859329,
0.3364464939,
-0.3507172763,
0.7927779555,
0.6245754957,
0.2692119777,
-0.8083752394,
-0.5000743866,
-0.5982913971,
-0.842579186,
0.6033499241,
0.0844421089,
0.0557663776,
0.1874346286,
0.4840242863,
-0.1340369731,
0.3278464973,
-0.6860697269,
0.006380206,
0.3091681004,
-0.2566384077,
-0.0581446365,
-0.4851419926,
-0.1693691909,
0.0374197252,
0.8884971142,
-0.1441533417,
0.1114624068,
0.5857519507,
0.1012830287,
-0.2432459891,
0.5708962083,
0.4923694134,
0.8330803514,
-0.2183006257,
0.2961051166,
0.0102317827,
-0.4735102057,
0.1488699615,
0.3694365919,
-0.1597398072,
0.1494160593,
0.211932525,
0.540145278,
0.2357092053,
-0.7212538123,
0.7475637197,
-0.2388599366,
0.3808068633,
-0.3661408126,
-0.0056130444,
0.38420403,
0.6257212758,
0.7293179631,
-0.2191664726,
0.4663546383,
-0.7293851376,
0.1304018199,
0.3894328475,
-0.5666753054,
0.0201115422,
0.4987722337,
0.0486124717,
0.0491127223,
0.8509515524,
0.0329141431,
-0.6431111097,
0.7115815282,
0.495580703,
0.6734455228,
-0.5086242557,
0.0363899358,
0.083612144,
0.4195809662,
-0.3240805864,
0.5725569725,
-0.0288854726,
-0.4276831448,
-0.334880054,
-0.2427993864,
-0.4148575664,
-0.1213762462,
-0.5629577041,
0.0071875332,
-0.2734828591,
-0.2888697684,
-0.2494734526,
0.4405362308,
-0.5455374718,
0.3007082641,
0.0281526744,
0.916059792,
-0.5742800832,
0.9042640328,
0.7463702559,
-0.3173742294,
-0.7936093211,
0.1850645691,
-0.5216009617,
-0.4386946261,
0.3272609711,
0.3078592718,
-0.2480553538,
0.2062422782,
-0.7680540085,
-1.2196633816,
1.2149857283,
0.2502726316,
-0.8082532883,
-0.3543303311,
-0.1748900712,
0.7034939528,
-0.3071230054,
0.2635496557,
0.5858929753,
0.3907652795,
0.049596522,
-0.8368460536,
0.1018418744,
-0.3323642612,
-0.1007040516,
0.3733462095,
-1.147116065,
0.9227313995,
-0.561047256,
-0.3342285156,
0.0432264917,
0.5767711997,
0.426004827,
0.5572054386,
0.4132324755,
0.4723263085,
0.8532856703,
-0.034628883,
1.2534127235,
-0.2373797148,
0.2027931362,
1.11432302,
-0.132902354,
0.956976831,
0.6549816728,
0.2135219127,
0.3442911208,
0.6078763604,
0.2053964138,
0.6770108342,
0.1309308708,
-0.26249668,
-0.4129078984,
-0.3155148029,
-0.2668688297,
0.0380284637,
0.3412607908,
-0.2301487178,
-0.1377097219,
-0.0578532293,
0.0538305268,
0.1808258891,
-0.4832139015,
0.5151859522,
0.3435069323,
-0.7060493827,
0.5353034139,
0.2472488433,
0.4324829578,
-0.4885153174,
0.0266537778,
-0.5220674872,
0.3714534938,
-0.0301913116,
-0.7381286621,
0.0972546712,
-0.3450405598,
-0.5338305235,
0.191492632,
0.707072258,
-0.9079835415,
-0.3720858693,
0.4903795123,
0.4857018888,
0.0459796861,
-0.4435791373,
-0.5629053712,
-0.0230606552,
-0.144693628,
-0.2294335812,
0.0840287358,
0.5724791884,
-0.2245812714,
1.0075381994,
0.4385316968,
0.0385448039,
0.1870162934,
0.2006992996,
1.0522668362,
-0.8746979833,
-0.548022747,
-0.590034008,
0.3109405041,
-0.390892446,
-0.1346503049,
0.8301994205,
0.4872173071,
0.6834477782,
-0.1371100992,
0.5888270736,
0.4942620695,
0.8831552267,
-0.4430753291,
0.8842058778,
-0.7778161764,
-0.0866277888,
-0.122866258,
-1.045291543,
-0.44625476,
0.2653028071,
-0.2351190597,
-0.0484847799,
0.6693409681,
0.6944280863,
-0.2426023185,
-0.3992606997,
0.497413516,
0.3301486671,
0.3273214996,
1.1010459661,
0.8493568897,
-0.5591444969,
0.4856591523,
0.1287848502,
-0.241528675,
-0.4984105527,
-0.1724541038,
-1.0483753681,
-0.4787366092,
-0.0232200306,
-0.2227670103,
0.367102921,
0.6652625203,
0.5527727008,
-0.5309774876,
-0.2184224725,
0.3434453905,
0.2844693065,
-0.0246992894,
-0.1352055818,
0.6751176715,
-0.3035318851,
-0.750218153,
0.4485041201,
0.6143334508,
0.1203765273,
-0.4236307442,
0.0653670132,
-0.663834691,
0.2824148834,
0.5647108555,
0.0336288102,
-0.7334720492,
-0.0889681354,
0.2326583415,
-0.5328845978,
0.1394356936,
0.6793070436,
-0.3672871888,
0.5527846217,
0.4991202056,
0.8042327762,
0.428385675,
0.1369164884,
0.6493423581,
-0.6517543793,
-0.1143837944,
0.3163517416,
0.1977717727,
0.6422745585,
-0.4753446281,
0.5963959694,
-0.0709106699,
-0.5579306483,
-0.7316942215,
0.0859211683,
-0.9661179185,
-0.1526834667,
0.9950046539,
-0.2500781715,
-0.3660562932,
-0.2601142824,
-0.446167767,
0.6111107469,
-0.5053598881,
1.3697856665,
0.9692063928,
0.1414490938,
-0.4175888598,
-0.6081812382,
0.4830057025,
0.8321761489,
-0.7976360917,
0.1752101332,
0.340978533,
0.3206525743,
0.2283335179,
0.985417068,
-0.2333904654,
0.5048120618,
-0.5798335075,
0.1104700565,
0.1959097385,
-0.6087760925,
-0.3816263676,
0.25631845,
0.3019261062,
0.0502629988
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09194v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09194v1
|
Structural Priming Demonstrates Abstract Grammatical Representations in Multilingual Language Models
| 2023-11-15T18:39:56 | 2023-11-15T18:39:56 |
James A. Michaelov, Catherine Arnett, Tyler A. Chang, Benjamin K. Bergen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Abstract grammatical knowledge - of parts of speech and grammatical patterns
- is key to the capacity for linguistic generalization in humans. But how
abstract is grammatical knowledge in large language models? In the human
literature, compelling evidence for grammatical abstraction comes from
structural priming. A sentence that shares the same grammatical structure as a
preceding sentence is processed and produced more readily. Because confounds
exist when using stimuli in a single language, evidence of abstraction is even
more compelling from crosslingual structural priming, where use of a syntactic
structure in one language primes an analogous structure in another language. We
measure crosslingual structural priming in large language models, comparing
model behavior to human experimental results from eight crosslingual
experiments covering six languages, and four monolingual structural priming
experiments in three non-English languages. We find evidence for abstract
monolingual and crosslingual grammatical representations in the models that
function similarly to those found in humans. These results demonstrate that
grammatical representations in multilingual language models are not only
similar across languages, but they can causally influence text produced in
different languages.
|
[
0.075213179,
-0.6151436567,
0.7727395892,
0.5973175168,
0.0234952588,
-0.159633711,
-0.3582449853,
-0.6470826268,
-0.0205122568,
0.0185673274,
-0.0737156942,
-0.5222072005,
-0.4571901262,
0.2683048248,
-0.3471022546,
0.6381163597,
0.0892743915,
0.4071764052,
-0.4759445786,
0.0725852847,
-0.2431005836,
-0.965252161,
-0.3468989134,
-0.4506912529,
0.3941136301,
0.1733434647,
0.688511312,
0.6943336725,
-0.0214650109,
0.4362451136,
-0.1571438462,
-0.3107347488,
-0.1191474721,
0.0866058022,
-0.4632493556,
-0.8007799387,
-0.2998592257,
-0.071942538,
0.8891528249,
1.3165236712,
0.2959904969,
-0.0587889664,
0.239841342,
0.6494500041,
-0.785094142,
0.5813217759,
-0.3911009729,
-0.062134482,
-0.1715036333,
-0.0647451282,
-0.6426508427,
0.0505756103,
0.0360265635,
-0.4626573324,
0.0492276549,
-0.0769581869,
0.6499027014,
-0.1625988483,
-0.6778409481,
-0.1477390081,
-0.7954915166,
0.6004722118,
-0.530784905,
0.5912907124,
0.5552988648,
-0.1128882244,
0.1392848492,
-0.5389973521,
-0.2191821933,
-0.5334949493,
-0.5639774203,
-0.131163612,
-0.058901418,
0.3977017105,
0.1641750038,
0.3866662681,
-0.6468654871,
-0.0567578413,
-0.5569874048,
-0.1797939688,
0.4121294618,
-0.3047566116,
0.5825093389,
-0.3173052669,
-0.2640110254,
0.0133317374,
-0.6661546826,
0.2718129754,
0.4567399919,
0.4166784585,
-0.254599452,
0.6779911518,
-0.1860387176,
0.8588263392,
-0.1083910018,
0.0111701209,
0.1444430947,
-0.5875731111,
-0.2211999893,
0.2380895764,
0.5878875256,
0.2136904895,
0.7786184549,
-0.5119886994,
0.240412876,
0.4246276319,
-0.0620919354,
-0.4196857214,
-0.0828491375,
-0.0660622939,
-0.3738441765,
0.0452249423,
0.3325848877,
-0.3175745308,
0.0670465529,
-0.1707885414,
-0.1518356353,
-0.3142784536,
-0.3026742339,
0.4814017117,
-0.2048130333,
0.0658766776,
-0.2743769884,
-1.2040041685,
0.6221023798,
0.7178121805,
0.616304934,
0.073782593,
-0.6064552665,
-0.2111008167,
0.3303916752,
-0.5486987233,
0.7107539177,
-0.7359785438,
-0.0576047562,
-0.0198158436,
0.163162753,
-0.1998319626,
-0.4421882331,
0.2027953565,
-0.3190897703,
0.1126600206,
-0.1276335716,
-0.3445914686,
-0.4137600958,
0.3278452754,
-0.6461316943,
0.5075153708,
-0.2863971293,
-0.297278434,
0.3891464472,
-0.2118782699,
-0.5496715307,
-0.2220410109,
-0.4393634796,
-0.1481503248,
0.418830961,
0.0798973888,
0.3991553187,
0.0872862786,
0.2250383049,
-0.1848934293,
0.0238246806,
0.2480844855,
-0.0673506036,
0.4582754672,
-0.2663562298,
-0.1496092975,
0.2405261844,
-0.598125875,
0.053006433,
-0.0115727577,
-0.4454800487,
-0.8028755188,
-0.1170775518,
0.0850811228,
0.2019097656,
0.1443184614,
-0.591743052,
0.0884672031,
-0.6403930783,
0.3879957795,
0.3439772129,
0.1871031076,
0.8819925189,
-0.3389402628,
0.4139298797,
-0.0308837965,
-0.4841758609,
-0.5641373992,
-0.4904995561,
-0.5160675049,
-0.0204073265,
0.4431871474,
0.4553805888,
0.1582774818,
0.0873172134,
-0.2638214827,
0.023724312,
-0.0361230895,
0.2085369825,
0.7279230356,
-0.1216136515,
0.0195119232,
-0.1217854246,
-0.765159905,
-1.3288023472,
-0.6610597968,
-0.3642220795,
0.0896347165,
-0.0678674877,
0.3840719759,
0.2323630899,
0.7524442673,
-0.2415813357,
-0.2666124105,
-0.5096234083,
0.4062095582,
-0.0897968486,
0.4810843468,
0.8628168106,
-0.8030979037,
-0.4927361608,
0.1026349589,
-0.7947050333,
0.080788441,
-0.1606867313,
0.0886611864,
0.2149670273,
0.729121387,
-0.5492873192,
0.3072612882,
0.5333020091,
-0.4774586856,
0.4551091492,
-0.3983528912,
0.0114007536,
-0.8935129642,
0.1179170385,
-0.0859109685,
-0.5867408514,
-0.4975673556,
0.2001132816,
0.0128648784,
-0.2101290077,
-0.4031604528,
0.3558321297,
-0.9781951308,
-0.2632564902,
-0.2289547622,
-0.2220539451,
-0.0032223293,
0.634195745,
0.3385222852,
0.5524356365,
0.6515304446,
-0.6288602948,
-0.0456787609,
-0.0958006158,
-0.5028259158,
0.027210718,
-0.815128088,
-0.087896809,
-0.5928022861,
0.091331467,
-1.0581427813,
-0.2670246065,
0.1128155738,
-0.3042997718,
0.1907639652,
-0.4432038367,
-0.3531277776,
0.3419238329,
-0.0259185676,
0.7786012888,
0.2717597485,
0.1840623617,
0.6456496119,
0.3894326985,
-0.6917892098,
-0.362657994,
-0.8834910989,
0.0523973703,
0.1971251369,
-0.6522147655,
0.436735183,
0.3153019547,
-0.6263859272,
0.1813318431,
-0.1275694519,
-0.0572144724,
-0.0474514142,
0.4033237994,
-0.0098893195,
-0.3120730817,
0.401584655,
-0.0318693817,
-0.2569282055,
0.3729535937,
-0.5069169998,
0.7767544985,
-0.2416352183,
-0.4765813649,
-0.2047486454,
0.6146987081,
0.7889566422,
-0.1999345869,
0.6203246117,
-0.2811250985,
-0.5572545528,
0.0163016319,
-0.1935564131,
-0.1366828829,
-0.3245666623,
0.4749228954,
-0.6034349799,
-0.4133024514,
0.5008014441,
0.0309447348,
0.0375965461,
0.2410441488,
0.4695396721,
0.0497608259,
0.8180270195,
0.8488093615,
-0.0378216058,
0.4508256912,
-0.2897990346,
-0.2038765401,
-0.246205911,
-0.3349208534,
-0.5627079606,
-0.4289964736,
-0.2463172525,
-0.4140834212,
0.2007783353,
0.1275991052,
-0.0050907317,
0.188216418,
0.078264229,
0.7447041273,
0.3120788634,
-0.0663523898,
0.7417244315,
0.2536401749,
-0.4117638171,
-0.1826656312,
-0.6709560752,
-0.5835460424,
0.8548724055,
0.2086312324,
0.805510819,
-0.0106741264,
0.3599191904,
-0.0386134051,
0.0052527501,
-0.7601716518,
0.3983660936,
-0.2715009451,
-0.7332673073,
-0.0980709791,
-0.2603567839,
-0.999575913,
0.490091145,
-0.2109584957,
-0.6417329907,
0.4036315382,
0.0911378264,
-0.2161172777,
0.1669603884,
-0.6245122552,
0.9658397436,
-0.1596864909,
-0.1618527472,
-0.4299126267,
-0.5032421947,
0.2999532819,
0.341803968,
0.4400381744,
0.1391899884,
-0.0791931525,
0.6185495257,
-0.164629519,
1.1206585169,
0.2165414095,
-0.2206250876,
0.057936158,
0.0432838686,
0.2461902499,
0.0951151177,
0.1367338747,
0.0637865439,
-0.2583506107,
-0.4764675498,
-0.6444965601,
0.5673659444,
-0.5623511076,
-0.5375024676,
-0.5837987661,
-0.6856377721,
-0.1652082801,
0.2397188693,
0.3905851841,
0.48440817,
-0.403016299,
0.1500772983,
0.3305734992,
0.1449235976,
0.4637137651,
0.3582172096,
-0.4978793561,
-0.0017922653,
0.5687026381,
0.0261750761,
0.5766963363,
0.7817736268,
0.0948370248,
-0.183347851,
-0.3285982013,
-0.3684265316,
0.5180068016,
-0.7109166384,
0.3067628145,
-0.7897430658,
-0.070176512,
-0.6033501625,
-0.029842658,
-0.3150862753,
-0.8459382653,
0.2295773029,
-0.4609053433,
-0.0978983566,
0.9521950483,
-0.1756725013,
-0.0604264215,
-0.7833861113,
0.3962811828,
0.4483561516,
0.0676709265,
-0.0129634924,
-0.1234663501,
-0.091005221,
0.2775278091,
0.0066923765,
-1.0828692913,
0.0197464563,
0.5599227548,
0.614025414,
0.3659470081,
-0.2710522413,
0.6642006636,
-0.6354958415,
0.5371537209,
0.0050114035,
-1.0892966986,
0.241845265,
-0.3465728462,
0.4846796393,
0.4352662265,
0.5444017649,
-0.7274122238,
-0.7019936442,
-0.3259035945,
-0.7606827021,
0.3673502207,
0.0800378099,
0.2327892333,
0.0704375952,
0.2370867133,
-0.0025340705,
0.0824311301,
-1.3812381029,
-0.1855853349,
0.0524930544,
0.1145837083,
-0.2462659627,
-0.2523943186,
0.0035997061,
-0.0930318236,
0.3325915039,
0.0673663691,
0.0724853948,
0.1956657469,
-0.4729715288,
-0.1543765813,
0.6242391467,
0.6622620225,
0.821140945,
0.1178576499,
0.4726517498,
-0.1429674178,
-0.2365470231,
0.3669678867,
0.0094945626,
-0.1896699071,
0.2782845795,
0.7965039015,
0.4356533587,
0.7952786684,
-0.56468606,
0.3330665529,
0.1996789426,
-0.2138564885,
-0.2505316436,
-0.3146554232,
0.2732328475,
0.0307396296,
0.299313724,
0.2133930773,
0.0756487772,
-1.0972665548,
0.0200538374,
0.3956111372,
0.0529324971,
-0.6453653574,
0.4901444316,
-0.0917938575,
0.0831055194,
0.4106360376,
-0.1316572279,
-0.6064391136,
0.4407132268,
0.7737532258,
0.6269381642,
-0.2308395654,
0.0968157798,
0.4562399685,
0.4184252918,
-0.0541215502,
0.3816871047,
-0.1715584248,
-0.5899137855,
-0.8965569735,
-0.4303263426,
-0.0163735691,
0.0151457116,
-0.6759311557,
0.0028982153,
-0.3345350325,
0.0587718263,
0.1438609213,
-0.5130455494,
-0.2119170576,
-0.0984761342,
0.4740348756,
0.7141578794,
-1.320502162,
0.570908308,
1.1765372753,
-0.3647819161,
-0.6116091013,
-0.1063842773,
-0.1131246388,
-0.5128342509,
1.1579271555,
0.2153018415,
-0.2621591389,
-0.2377943695,
-0.3267992735,
-0.8174960017,
0.4452449381,
0.6435769796,
-0.3354898095,
-0.6205861568,
0.5554091334,
0.4636521339,
-0.3915212154,
-0.342592001,
0.102643542,
0.5770270228,
-0.1056479961,
-0.9625195861,
0.1035343558,
-0.4657963514,
0.0494793355,
0.1379789412,
-0.1162552536,
1.0189282894,
-0.3243193924,
-0.6903892756,
0.1845945567,
0.794913888,
0.1301792264,
-0.0083559155,
0.5033639073,
0.5571264625,
0.417242378,
0.0407931097,
1.0573780537,
-0.4339515269,
-0.0214146636,
1.0895118713,
-0.0227841754,
0.5910041332,
0.3826759458,
0.0982825905,
0.9454166889,
0.2004563957,
0.4935340285,
0.5042210817,
0.1730594188,
-0.2246866971,
-0.4946027696,
0.0168476775,
-0.4780578315,
0.5917162299,
0.3797303736,
-0.6293913126,
-0.5064488649,
0.2294305116,
0.1345706731,
0.4102866054,
-0.3893757761,
0.9235149026,
0.2370448411,
-0.8519366384,
0.6888195872,
0.3922913074,
0.285355866,
-0.6891625524,
-0.1073610559,
0.0199899338,
0.3042632937,
-0.2343586534,
-0.4471375644,
0.5043517351,
-0.1561080068,
-0.5888672471,
-0.6758342981,
0.628385365,
-0.7897093296,
-0.5290256739,
0.3230388761,
0.638011694,
0.2703079283,
-0.1907583326,
-0.0957548544,
-0.0797504187,
-0.33880651,
0.0642741024,
0.2987082303,
0.2234705985,
-0.3256185055,
0.4586408138,
0.6857532859,
0.3671366572,
0.3279516697,
0.0475788005,
0.6228768826,
-0.6649780273,
-0.841081202,
-1.0804327726,
0.4973340333,
0.0967885479,
-0.1427945644,
0.8619398475,
0.8378088474,
1.0224013329,
-0.4008995593,
0.7545492649,
0.0408935398,
-0.0679759383,
-0.651874423,
0.5110659599,
-0.2800269723,
-0.2192081064,
-0.1886993796,
-0.8457349539,
-0.3497805595,
0.7658956647,
-0.5079004765,
-0.0021850113,
0.8511345387,
0.4571356773,
-0.2483906746,
-0.087784119,
0.3457505107,
0.4449765682,
-0.1479237527,
0.5546588898,
0.8717967868,
-0.2133064419,
0.4705260694,
-0.0916685984,
-0.2533096373,
0.2127909511,
-0.7594199777,
-0.9667485356,
-0.758400023,
-0.0658711344,
-0.0367021933,
0.1499291956,
0.7389724851,
0.9547303319,
-0.6792994142,
-0.6430763006,
-0.3292661905,
0.1288968921,
-0.5522074103,
-0.1701319516,
0.038557712,
-0.6173342466,
-0.8877719641,
0.5707480311,
0.3365622461,
0.1469963044,
-0.3398225904,
0.2592200935,
-0.4567887783,
-0.2167249322,
0.6381002665,
0.4037931561,
-0.7207158804,
0.0512911491,
0.2050139457,
-0.2587210238,
0.0284100659,
1.3149539232,
-0.8430187106,
0.0796124861,
0.8119423985,
0.2774168551,
0.4413779676,
0.0125512332,
0.9978887439,
-1.1562489271,
0.6689583063,
0.0736724287,
0.6656549573,
0.235001564,
-0.2349812537,
0.1501985341,
0.2515990138,
-0.1363719553,
-0.4610031843,
0.4902680218,
-0.6803847551,
-0.5494794846,
1.0553206205,
-0.1465552747,
-0.2467730045,
-0.3129721284,
-0.0448756479,
-0.0580147542,
-0.1919313073,
0.5419943929,
1.0237753391,
0.1162835807,
-0.1777001917,
-0.0876443982,
0.3082924783,
0.5537977815,
-0.7079908252,
0.2472222894,
0.4878671467,
0.3179337978,
0.5802697539,
0.5169730186,
-0.2994894385,
0.4218950868,
-0.0064761066,
-0.1403796673,
-0.1693965793,
-0.6315587163,
-0.2810665667,
0.5023943782,
0.0100763682,
-0.0962035432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09193v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09193v1
|
The Role of Chain-of-Thought in Complex Vision-Language Reasoning Task
| 2023-11-15T18:39:21 | 2023-11-15T18:39:21 |
Yifan Wu, Pengchuan Zhang, Wenhan Xiong, Barlas Oguz, James C. Gee, Yixin Nie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
The study explores the effectiveness of the Chain-of-Thought approach, known
for its proficiency in language tasks by breaking them down into sub-tasks and
intermediate steps, in improving vision-language tasks that demand
sophisticated perception and reasoning. We present the "Description then
Decision" strategy, which is inspired by how humans process signals. This
strategy significantly improves probing task performance by 50%, establishing
the groundwork for future research on reasoning paradigms in complex
vision-language tasks.
|
[
-0.736479342,
-0.7075180411,
0.8079580665,
0.0091801705,
-0.2931542397,
0.2511201799,
-0.1447299421,
-0.6897452474,
0.3171818852,
0.4468783438,
-0.5200713277,
-0.0521739386,
-0.3794434965,
-0.0425345302,
-0.3016633093,
0.6041737199,
-0.1279314756,
0.1571439207,
0.137552917,
0.1437984705,
-0.4794360697,
-0.3969947696,
-1.0024273396,
-0.5094338655,
0.7073997855,
0.2673200965,
0.6474693418,
0.5363553762,
0.9659487605,
0.2066179216,
0.0221263487,
0.3598392308,
-0.3569426835,
0.122039564,
-0.5838555098,
-0.7900854349,
-0.6532076001,
0.0140403034,
0.4894142151,
1.025983572,
-0.2975893319,
0.1407145709,
-0.0686108992,
1.0484786034,
-0.7825015187,
0.031060094,
-0.3763441145,
0.0960695371,
-0.0793004036,
-0.4449606538,
-0.4424523711,
0.1354251355,
0.6764618754,
-0.4502151906,
-0.1941692829,
0.4634515643,
0.3785398304,
-0.0542160943,
-0.4024273455,
-0.1148863286,
-1.0524740219,
0.7036400437,
-0.3013032973,
0.3889670968,
0.264310807,
0.3435050547,
-0.3496501744,
-0.5638074875,
-0.6623494029,
-0.0357899889,
0.0619896837,
0.3736099601,
0.0082767056,
0.4484811723,
0.5586854815,
0.2760415375,
-0.3090245426,
-0.2335119992,
-0.562285006,
0.0252237506,
0.6033073068,
0.133876726,
0.2267183959,
0.0593159795,
-0.434137851,
-0.1646283418,
-0.5937098265,
0.2954602242,
0.0848779306,
-0.0186957754,
0.381673336,
0.5347492099,
-0.9133318663,
1.1364701986,
0.0047220248,
-0.0087895226,
-0.0367837809,
-0.3062269688,
-0.5155345201,
0.1619745642,
0.2840071023,
0.5963155627,
0.4229743183,
0.0301549677,
-0.1220891625,
0.433983475,
0.6658546329,
-0.1388950199,
-0.4078121185,
0.0372802727,
-0.4442979991,
-0.2722688615,
0.1218066365,
-0.5796226859,
0.0037025001,
-0.5551151633,
0.562245965,
-0.249416694,
-0.347237438,
0.6364104152,
-0.3805072606,
0.2263227254,
0.4124585688,
-0.7596410513,
0.6630370021,
0.5251151919,
0.4264872968,
-0.1962500662,
-0.3489136696,
-0.3440664709,
0.2825238705,
-0.5514637232,
0.8852257133,
-0.4570554793,
0.1539423466,
-0.3203050196,
-0.3741895258,
-0.0906727761,
-0.4063664973,
0.4140310884,
-0.4753769934,
-0.0458640121,
-0.5387793779,
-0.3549179435,
-0.4594197869,
0.6228495836,
-0.6650584936,
0.778021872,
-0.1603992283,
-0.7760295868,
0.5213723779,
-0.7352522612,
-0.6088498235,
0.2534969151,
-0.4142823219,
0.0934298709,
0.092369847,
0.165665552,
0.3655775487,
-0.3372206092,
-0.0099035269,
-0.0719495639,
-0.4368404746,
0.4037639201,
-0.1426692754,
0.5942608118,
0.1555215418,
-0.9372582436,
-0.0291931052,
-0.5367199183,
0.3476415575,
0.0482172593,
-0.237058714,
-0.7101715803,
0.3523578048,
-0.4077265859,
0.2481877506,
-0.1040009186,
-0.2921896875,
0.3990177512,
-0.568808496,
0.3015425503,
0.4538785517,
0.0097746002,
0.5338087082,
-0.2923837304,
0.4580173194,
-0.0684219971,
0.5477933884,
0.0762298256,
-0.5341435075,
-1.2546756268,
0.1612637341,
-0.0496658124,
0.7744523287,
-1.1324943304,
0.0517909564,
0.0353143103,
-0.4544431865,
-0.2165136337,
-0.1297053099,
0.8582391143,
0.3667876124,
0.3714670539,
-0.484392941,
-0.6631465554,
-1.0280063152,
-0.3711682856,
-0.3990682662,
0.3168151975,
-0.1578639299,
0.7096292377,
-0.1524797529,
0.5101179481,
-0.8615937829,
-0.2191214859,
-0.4749310315,
0.188209489,
0.0720726624,
0.4299454093,
0.1058445722,
-1.0105860233,
-0.1473733932,
0.0175800305,
-0.5682640076,
0.268193841,
-0.3113145828,
-0.5728004575,
-0.1449846923,
0.4443912804,
-0.6888568997,
0.5575484037,
0.1733780652,
-0.2770456672,
0.7373974919,
-0.2351056486,
0.3151574731,
-0.7309190035,
-0.1958927214,
-0.0299579985,
-0.0020865947,
-0.7100128531,
0.2024753243,
-0.2909666598,
0.3780473173,
-0.2891496718,
-0.0223353896,
-0.5965685248,
-0.2387891859,
-0.1901712418,
0.256041497,
-0.1360129863,
0.5905365944,
0.2210594416,
0.4438999593,
0.9914385676,
-0.7626873851,
0.5228729248,
0.0705255568,
-0.6090377569,
0.7294171453,
-0.2825393081,
0.1046932116,
-0.1993947923,
0.1166681051,
-1.1615101099,
0.1056975275,
0.2637773752,
-0.2906037271,
0.0410125889,
0.490665704,
-0.4372329116,
-0.7534121275,
-0.1077498198,
0.5344878435,
0.3091039956,
-0.2317233831,
0.6918595433,
0.4115984142,
0.257532537,
-0.5837876201,
-0.763448596,
0.1118720993,
-0.1295157969,
-0.1942006052,
0.3870089054,
0.1118830591,
-0.7682036161,
-0.3775781095,
-0.4859231412,
0.0342037454,
-0.0393231213,
-0.1190898046,
0.2641240358,
0.1074118614,
0.1161808819,
-0.0430171229,
-0.0735484362,
0.3174180388,
-0.7099124193,
0.5436662436,
-0.3060398698,
-0.2770202458,
-0.4166899323,
0.3868536651,
0.6861634851,
-0.4166722298,
0.2833617926,
0.188201949,
-0.2497625798,
-0.4580314159,
-0.5746785998,
-0.2327376604,
-0.4514746666,
0.2629424632,
-0.682644546,
-0.5795778036,
0.1660612971,
-0.498778671,
-0.3338194788,
0.2647333443,
0.2851694226,
-0.8313956857,
1.1463806629,
0.4016695619,
0.2009309232,
0.3196372092,
-0.5122676492,
0.6281404495,
-0.942732513,
-0.5101471543,
0.0627027303,
-0.5507964492,
-0.2647711039,
-0.441268295,
0.4549843967,
0.3181238174,
-0.0230340827,
0.3762920201,
-0.602532804,
0.3134374022,
0.653675735,
0.5088689923,
0.3349917233,
0.0447512567,
-0.2405581623,
0.2277288437,
-0.900532186,
-0.2652479112,
0.7907056808,
0.078821905,
0.7516291738,
-0.2407345474,
0.5100480914,
0.3456442654,
-0.2962623537,
-0.8491570354,
0.9314873815,
0.0627560839,
-0.4569071233,
-0.3142844737,
0.0037825448,
-0.7816663384,
0.327960968,
-0.2075888067,
-0.73222965,
0.0611543581,
0.2217048407,
-0.3817996085,
0.4292176664,
-0.5335482955,
0.4803251624,
-0.5185613036,
0.0037683696,
-0.6856684685,
-0.7519607544,
0.2316193879,
0.1927230358,
0.2489377409,
0.473518908,
-0.0174216423,
1.1518037319,
-0.1236071214,
0.7585789561,
0.1618153304,
-0.0790322646,
0.7186803818,
0.1040608138,
0.4907803535,
-0.4087636769,
0.4379336238,
-0.1291070282,
-0.1893856823,
-0.2008049488,
-0.7776057124,
0.224541977,
-0.22757864,
-0.7909489274,
-0.3386643529,
-0.5683270693,
-0.3245915771,
0.1987530291,
0.3705348969,
0.5124104619,
0.0776668638,
-0.0697728172,
0.8737853169,
0.3161854446,
0.1844111532,
0.0905975252,
-0.3826975822,
-0.325489521,
0.469930917,
0.0879353806,
0.7948003411,
0.7589359283,
0.0988395214,
-0.139105916,
-0.5422918797,
-0.1341551542,
-0.0698743612,
-0.888790071,
0.1721907407,
-0.6273174286,
0.0313598178,
0.0913448483,
-0.1608563215,
-0.3957836628,
-0.3503573239,
0.3380041718,
-0.346390903,
0.1033629701,
0.6338034868,
0.1937719136,
0.2235486209,
-0.3175956309,
0.3883851469,
0.7205528021,
0.1580402851,
0.2104046792,
0.2018706053,
-0.2805330455,
0.1761505902,
-0.1155244857,
-0.7160027623,
-0.0006093298,
-0.1624967605,
0.7143001556,
0.4368990362,
-0.0792808607,
0.8342341781,
-0.3111293018,
0.528927207,
0.6426334381,
-1.0404806137,
0.9985713363,
-0.2683760822,
0.4676249027,
0.3402401507,
0.3533012569,
-0.1761713028,
-0.628598094,
-0.4995613098,
-0.5355450511,
0.4326591492,
0.5233021975,
-0.4069136083,
-0.0255658887,
0.3619580567,
-0.2681677639,
0.2039755732,
-0.432061255,
-0.248880595,
0.4202282429,
0.2499879748,
0.1932446808,
-0.2712449133,
-0.0722995475,
-0.6577729583,
0.2382835597,
-0.200171575,
0.4480087459,
0.5876318812,
0.1483533382,
-0.2187716961,
0.3687573969,
0.4722345769,
1.0535576344,
-0.022724824,
0.5234798193,
0.2931997478,
-0.5513643622,
-0.0168500021,
-0.6582301855,
-0.0670674592,
-0.3257873356,
0.535282135,
0.7007585168,
0.0711071566,
-0.9345924258,
0.2485288829,
0.2421946526,
-0.3898222148,
-0.1566008776,
0.365054667,
-0.1859631389,
0.6668615341,
0.4638940394,
0.6174711585,
0.6345174909,
-0.9825729132,
0.2949023843,
0.1532201618,
-0.4675906003,
-0.227167815,
0.3406147957,
-0.0486988761,
-0.2449219972,
0.6562632322,
-0.0992002934,
-1.0299266577,
0.7254041433,
0.5189070106,
0.6467915177,
-0.1768980026,
0.3311858773,
0.201366663,
0.4348494112,
-0.7138824463,
0.9796289206,
-0.3328664005,
-0.8853407502,
-0.7499807477,
-0.2996113598,
-0.2284350544,
-0.455347985,
-0.9667930603,
0.0332930163,
-0.3265461922,
-0.4818722904,
-0.1051718816,
-0.2228188515,
-0.5417054296,
0.7480892539,
0.3447716236,
0.7691861391,
-0.5941082835,
0.9441977143,
0.7728786469,
-0.360940218,
-0.9059497118,
0.0400876068,
-0.3551872373,
-0.6108130217,
1.2577972412,
0.0728808492,
-0.8867745399,
-0.0155198621,
-0.4649629295,
-0.9443092942,
0.99470222,
0.1036514044,
-0.8964580297,
-0.1405848861,
-0.1480957717,
0.6285344362,
-0.5296707153,
-0.0789163783,
0.694897294,
0.4512176514,
0.2904117405,
-1.251838088,
0.1414140463,
-0.1909108162,
0.1146064252,
0.4493400156,
-0.4745135605,
0.8754062653,
-0.6224829555,
-0.2466811091,
-0.2555429637,
0.4515981972,
0.1504031569,
0.2416963577,
0.8699335456,
0.6034771204,
0.6883851886,
0.028325187,
1.0256310701,
0.1945337355,
0.2540515065,
0.9170588851,
-0.0480035283,
1.0515364408,
0.8226655126,
-0.3582348824,
0.8444132805,
0.3863575161,
0.1278413981,
0.8794872165,
0.4630229175,
-0.0078186598,
-0.5576738119,
-0.0003533182,
0.0643706173,
0.7414117455,
0.5090633631,
-0.3533276916,
0.2299901694,
0.2233278006,
-0.3584752083,
0.0274353288,
-0.8295103908,
0.6348280907,
0.1631048024,
-1.0592213869,
0.5491130948,
-0.5336942673,
0.3470616937,
-0.2892413735,
-0.2908602655,
0.4557447433,
0.5523300171,
-0.1716667265,
-1.1242531538,
0.4119543433,
-0.4792299569,
-0.2536559999,
-0.420535028,
0.8829164505,
-0.3424115777,
-0.3926461041,
0.6265229583,
0.465652138,
0.0972838178,
-0.3631365299,
-0.6217440367,
-0.0208987538,
0.0635114983,
-0.0698704123,
-0.0207659304,
0.216212675,
-0.2234839052,
0.9716425538,
0.4407551289,
0.2002545744,
0.085507378,
0.0675449893,
0.8142444491,
-0.9216130376,
-0.5794602036,
-0.9399058223,
0.4281032979,
-0.2388649732,
-0.1773609072,
0.5935869217,
0.4088817239,
1.1567612886,
-0.1875186712,
0.7026032805,
-0.1793811321,
0.1080588624,
-0.7758369446,
0.3438796401,
-0.4897837043,
0.0679551736,
-0.4731632769,
-0.8138489127,
-0.4250356257,
0.7598959804,
-0.4937666953,
-0.2121106833,
1.4375964403,
0.2848687768,
0.3257154822,
0.1215808764,
0.1388498098,
-0.0266948678,
0.1364856213,
0.9305161238,
0.9852262139,
-0.337446779,
0.5179610848,
-0.3100996315,
-0.4361870587,
0.0688600764,
-0.5363733768,
-1.0508089066,
-0.6522455812,
-0.2913352549,
-0.0352396853,
0.0186408889,
0.6646069884,
0.7524399161,
-0.4627151489,
-0.5678108931,
-0.5243407488,
-0.119150959,
-1.0725623369,
-0.1648964584,
0.2748939395,
-0.3658311367,
-0.3101958632,
0.2241454273,
0.7707683444,
-0.3203539848,
-0.4351921082,
0.0393280685,
-0.4590778649,
-0.0964766741,
1.0691261292,
-0.1707114875,
-1.1318719387,
-0.1378521919,
0.1526842117,
-0.0033938256,
0.0013462491,
1.0397125483,
-0.7285695672,
0.9674426317,
0.6504411697,
0.2844370306,
0.6122747064,
-0.2016724795,
0.8312154412,
0.0414061248,
0.0954570845,
0.1452064067,
0.3961082101,
-0.0874661729,
-0.5657008886,
0.6726210713,
0.2004182041,
-0.2051952928,
-0.3004570007,
0.5557305217,
-1.4782102108,
-0.3543184102,
0.9338485003,
0.0056556049,
-0.4416999817,
-0.1392486244,
-0.6659834981,
0.2082833946,
-0.1496638954,
0.8655015826,
0.7409959435,
-0.5815740228,
-0.3105745316,
-0.403938055,
0.4196549356,
0.3785993755,
-0.7288008928,
-0.2013055533,
0.2200926989,
-0.2262775451,
0.4518788755,
0.7363252044,
0.1828322411,
0.2519290745,
0.083331041,
-0.2516057193,
0.4081961811,
-0.7051112056,
0.4022932053,
0.1053251997,
-0.0198362041,
-0.4188695252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09189v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09189v2
|
PsyEval: A Suite of Mental Health Related Tasks for Evaluating Large Language Models
| 2023-11-15T18:32:27 | 2024-06-03T08:37:10 |
Haoan Jin, Siyuan Chen, Dilawaier Dilixiati, Yewei Jiang, Mengyue Wu, Kenny Q. Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Evaluating Large Language Models (LLMs) in the mental health domain poses
distinct challenged from other domains, given the subtle and highly subjective
nature of symptoms that exhibit significant variability among individuals. This
paper presents PsyEval, the first comprehensive suite of mental health-related
tasks for evaluating LLMs. PsyEval encompasses five sub-tasks that evaluate
three critical dimensions of mental health. This comprehensive framework is
designed to thoroughly assess the unique challenges and intricacies of mental
health-related tasks, making PsyEval a highly specialized and valuable tool for
evaluating LLM performance in this domain. We evaluate twelve advanced LLMs
using PsyEval. Experiment results not only demonstrate significant room for
improvement in current LLMs concerning mental health but also unveil potential
directions for future model optimization.
|
[
0.0158323534,
-0.5187972784,
0.7650148869,
0.3808577061,
-0.2234552354,
0.2053619474,
-0.3304699361,
-0.2216624618,
0.1201617271,
0.4707095623,
-0.9748721123,
-0.8811662793,
-0.8843942285,
0.1137259901,
-0.474905163,
1.1862339973,
-0.0538958833,
0.3027035892,
-0.2049346119,
0.3805652559,
-0.0742804557,
-0.378153652,
-0.1619724482,
-0.4688671529,
0.2520649135,
0.2486151159,
0.4289126694,
-0.1679367423,
0.973059833,
0.2368438393,
0.040403422,
0.034859553,
-0.7083073854,
0.6116909385,
-0.5364038348,
-0.1726623625,
-0.5866654515,
-0.2940590382,
0.3976176977,
0.591117084,
-0.4146543443,
0.600109756,
-0.2238374949,
0.6973292828,
-0.551094234,
0.1875650734,
-0.3024472594,
0.2534467578,
-0.4303362668,
-0.0973296314,
-0.1381917,
-0.2699656487,
0.2865901291,
-0.5579191446,
-0.2515158355,
0.1028299108,
0.3418800831,
0.1266325712,
-0.4498771727,
-0.2413106859,
-0.7001134753,
0.9737792611,
-0.8060554266,
0.2110110372,
0.4655251205,
0.419139564,
-0.3382772207,
-0.8059852719,
-0.2104292065,
-0.0930821747,
0.0964617208,
0.0223102998,
-0.4449570775,
0.2671773732,
0.2959890664,
0.4380482733,
-0.9058785439,
-0.3711376786,
-0.5709202886,
-0.2006269395,
0.8603593707,
0.8113602996,
0.554489851,
-0.2024862319,
0.3196419477,
0.4463397563,
-0.448282361,
-0.0378820673,
0.3530076146,
0.2221957892,
-0.0159044079,
0.9122394919,
-0.5550869107,
0.7419043183,
0.1618197262,
-0.6221911907,
-0.035219457,
-0.2017165422,
-0.3570456505,
-0.1044034511,
0.6995315552,
0.3377535045,
-0.0697536245,
-0.2872727215,
-0.1527964473,
0.1010976955,
0.5636428595,
-0.9679582119,
-0.3947175145,
0.4702021778,
-0.5455934405,
-0.2572225928,
-0.2730523944,
-0.7087699175,
-0.8822541237,
-0.1522906721,
0.2877810597,
-0.6553823352,
-0.2363891006,
0.5213388205,
0.3092069626,
0.163143158,
0.252790004,
-0.8949772716,
0.5235549808,
1.0110989809,
0.7933987975,
-0.2214653194,
-0.2440443337,
-0.4998235703,
-0.1493124068,
-0.237146318,
0.8874554038,
-0.8791713715,
-0.2590816915,
0.0252311472,
0.1416482329,
0.0775156096,
-0.3102205098,
0.7256433964,
-0.1010976806,
-0.0618147999,
-0.601545155,
-0.3370752335,
-0.0645508543,
0.059482459,
-0.2663674653,
0.8364429474,
0.4974761605,
-1.0304419994,
0.1261844039,
-0.243965283,
-0.5354557037,
0.4291206896,
-0.1171491891,
-0.3020374179,
0.2265645564,
-0.1331335902,
0.605055213,
-0.7963852882,
0.1643900871,
-0.392559886,
-0.5265479088,
0.2980689704,
0.2918562591,
0.7158574462,
0.0353708379,
-0.1749947369,
0.5351781845,
-0.7288064361,
0.1666104496,
-0.0221443865,
-0.0517553352,
-0.1538916379,
0.3391226828,
0.2214162946,
0.3277080953,
0.4273667634,
-0.447021395,
0.0396432467,
-0.5460184216,
0.2834905088,
0.5574372411,
0.2309851348,
0.1055139229,
-0.4973882139,
1.0251214504,
-0.2738916278,
0.3028257787,
0.1486515999,
-0.5882466435,
-0.3433936536,
-0.5993869901,
-0.39947927,
0.4076061547,
-0.4610253572,
0.5324703455,
-0.0976521373,
-0.9637395144,
-0.4199888706,
0.0808794871,
0.1932625622,
-0.0444392711,
0.0233828276,
-0.096816197,
-0.4654174745,
-1.0388288498,
-0.3117397428,
0.3068153858,
0.0842538923,
0.1001148298,
0.7060655355,
-0.3478323817,
0.580288887,
-0.4715612233,
-0.246707648,
-0.3751575351,
0.0692290142,
0.2793772519,
0.0453779884,
0.5654143691,
-0.0290595051,
-0.6063781977,
0.2791135907,
-0.6291922331,
-0.3579929769,
0.3623296022,
0.0205234159,
-0.2054434121,
-0.0842897817,
-0.7498235703,
0.0152348457,
0.7731202245,
-0.332023263,
1.0949456692,
-0.0907692537,
0.1399724931,
-0.8518589139,
0.2513729036,
-0.0714236274,
-0.1262310892,
-0.8214509487,
0.0355694443,
-0.123431921,
-0.4560169876,
-0.2413633913,
-0.0481857769,
-0.2274411023,
-0.2448560596,
-0.2614088058,
0.1934721023,
-0.0877748355,
0.2550166249,
-0.5109368563,
0.8219485879,
1.1479500532,
-0.0356051251,
1.2304917574,
-0.1552459598,
-0.7300575376,
0.8654769659,
-0.7620128989,
0.2242689431,
-0.2932343185,
0.1261121333,
-1.0247195959,
-0.3959048092,
0.2704947293,
-0.114917174,
0.0838686302,
0.4108294249,
-0.3502025306,
-0.4370765388,
-0.350707531,
0.3606499135,
0.3937414885,
0.075383313,
0.3622987568,
0.5666458011,
-0.3939063847,
-0.5141130686,
-0.1884994507,
0.0485599339,
-0.4194634855,
-0.477820158,
0.3581618071,
0.0362957269,
-0.6200660467,
-0.0786125809,
-0.4039388299,
0.0064704623,
-0.0636317134,
0.3864948153,
0.0813598931,
-0.1591094732,
0.0994438305,
0.074265264,
-0.0701333284,
0.1470924318,
-0.3778177798,
0.6063793302,
-0.4705532491,
-0.3308969736,
-0.6257446408,
0.5989408493,
0.846865356,
-0.5059209466,
0.8302292824,
0.3480919003,
-0.7585731745,
-0.2859548926,
-0.2875556052,
0.0260158237,
-0.4001653492,
0.824945271,
-0.33937639,
-0.813161552,
0.3413210809,
-0.1483052075,
-0.1965898573,
0.0709539205,
0.5982952118,
0.1524595022,
1.1344050169,
0.5094404221,
-0.0959747583,
-0.0322202593,
-0.0253911465,
0.7678592801,
-0.8537418842,
-0.3934707344,
-0.4894457459,
-0.0953026116,
-0.3509838581,
-0.4619121253,
0.3297508955,
-0.0327401794,
-0.3360093236,
0.3758547008,
-0.4748563766,
0.2248350531,
-0.2121068984,
0.2035440654,
0.1911062449,
-0.2720576823,
0.1372029036,
-0.4479646683,
-0.3386196196,
-0.6760622859,
1.1299929619,
0.2343164831,
1.0174576044,
0.2423452586,
0.3498843014,
0.3595845997,
0.3836147189,
-1.2194575071,
0.6971486211,
-0.2829670012,
-0.3839058578,
-0.3711007237,
-0.1918345243,
-0.7302259207,
0.3235795796,
-0.3158545494,
-1.257874012,
-0.3161302805,
-0.3980433047,
-0.6559927464,
0.0150704794,
-0.0824849755,
0.7215833664,
-0.2676161528,
-0.2310663909,
-0.6923081875,
-0.362713486,
0.6931213737,
-0.3324168622,
0.0119831096,
-0.6445649266,
0.0307918042,
0.7058127522,
-0.0758780316,
0.4166305363,
0.1770743728,
-0.2024074048,
-0.4070576727,
0.151408866,
0.2877455354,
0.0350902453,
-0.2634237409,
-0.0212615095,
0.6857387424,
-0.418977797,
-0.9110100269,
0.9754734039,
-0.8657057285,
-0.7003442049,
-0.7436061502,
-0.7092664242,
-0.4365523756,
0.3550581336,
-0.0686623007,
0.5108522177,
-0.4199703634,
0.1700356901,
0.490611285,
-0.6147239804,
-0.1930719167,
0.5617262721,
-0.6659732461,
-0.4034264088,
0.7641612291,
-0.012450221,
0.0101397131,
0.1695868373,
0.148965463,
-0.0417247042,
-0.6560854912,
0.0902329609,
0.5280219316,
-0.6866892576,
-0.2506732941,
-0.4900977612,
-0.2444709688,
-0.6262992024,
-0.0582023934,
-0.4486811757,
-0.1858002245,
0.0348755233,
0.0233289488,
0.1146963388,
1.1906998158,
0.3680635691,
0.1288893223,
-0.5419816375,
0.23585549,
0.3773445189,
0.3637968898,
-0.1590840667,
-0.2650921047,
-0.2204241008,
-0.1956799328,
-0.3040858209,
-1.2349971533,
0.4846517742,
0.0949486122,
0.694308877,
0.6322619915,
0.2474240065,
0.5271583796,
-0.4764874279,
0.7899537086,
0.2923428416,
-1.1209310293,
0.6532592177,
-0.5298095345,
0.1959846467,
0.3680119216,
0.6029869914,
-0.869404912,
-0.25539428,
-0.1644951403,
-0.6640229821,
1.0311130285,
0.2301493436,
-0.0799461752,
-0.044040937,
0.3858074844,
-0.0826645568,
0.2505916357,
-0.3616617024,
-0.225658983,
0.0070979362,
-0.274081111,
-0.0242439471,
-0.4278132915,
-0.4598428011,
-0.3990993202,
0.8530333042,
0.122747466,
0.2325277925,
0.0823134407,
-0.1531366408,
-0.4062114954,
0.313704133,
0.8356509209,
0.9643713236,
-0.2700276971,
0.1752849519,
0.330922544,
-0.4878105223,
0.3374972939,
-0.0192144569,
0.3457108736,
-0.2903310359,
0.3461198807,
0.7379910946,
0.3189937174,
-0.9571915269,
0.7425478101,
-0.0262087137,
0.0402544849,
-0.1579464823,
0.1316983104,
0.1068002135,
0.5213159919,
0.1981117576,
-0.1582092792,
0.3488438427,
-0.6726416945,
0.1691951752,
0.5177063346,
-0.4402324557,
-0.6138825417,
0.1333071589,
0.0730862096,
-0.7916477919,
0.2513060868,
-0.1495507956,
-0.5300159454,
0.347066462,
0.7491449714,
0.746688664,
-0.5703088045,
0.4907996655,
0.3620932996,
0.4319151938,
-0.02193138,
0.3870422244,
0.0257989299,
-0.3663322031,
-0.3021091223,
-0.8590070605,
-0.4007759392,
0.4976704419,
-0.8471742868,
0.2167886943,
-0.6973791122,
-0.3278858066,
-0.2855750918,
0.4533187747,
-0.329320699,
0.055714488,
0.1324840784,
0.5791240335,
-0.7294660807,
0.7751178741,
0.8764448762,
0.1119223312,
-0.2756595016,
0.3333235979,
0.1971599609,
-0.5149253607,
0.5215163231,
0.1900595278,
-0.6773629189,
-0.2035082877,
-0.1133713871,
-0.9586609602,
1.0640795231,
0.5872433186,
-0.4898872375,
0.1341637075,
0.2857902646,
0.6517317295,
-0.3493484259,
0.1846800148,
0.8669185638,
0.5427978039,
-0.1388515234,
-0.9085016251,
0.2090315521,
-0.3883423507,
0.1043249145,
-0.0168129094,
-0.5799492002,
0.6695171595,
-0.1068743318,
-0.3652901351,
0.3307538927,
0.4523607492,
0.401370734,
-0.1277070791,
0.092489399,
0.2728131413,
1.0306036472,
0.0941082984,
0.8802512884,
-0.6901566386,
0.6182299852,
0.8246114254,
-0.8517772555,
0.5153384805,
0.2506582737,
-0.6369973421,
0.1502332538,
0.5540027022,
0.3273183107,
0.7065445781,
0.7799887657,
-0.8113247156,
-0.3547084332,
-0.1468522996,
-0.3460817337,
0.4610208869,
0.6057897806,
0.0098114796,
-0.3417172134,
0.1457883269,
-0.0559025146,
0.1058766246,
-0.0717745125,
0.2563999593,
0.1498892158,
-0.3727796674,
0.2598648965,
0.3797396123,
0.4551911056,
-0.8881073594,
0.1851639301,
0.0070150858,
0.3195209205,
-0.3489003181,
-0.5975877643,
0.7808781862,
-0.038325116,
-0.0725171193,
-0.0333059691,
0.8093950748,
-0.2215198427,
-0.7813876867,
0.5174851418,
0.1012745351,
0.2105084509,
-0.1909751892,
-0.620570302,
0.2440052181,
-0.3780120909,
-0.3634667993,
0.4015486836,
0.4662033617,
0.2377173305,
0.7849866748,
0.4146648645,
0.4895312786,
-0.3370416462,
0.0054355557,
0.6658049822,
-0.5156889558,
-0.1185113937,
-0.6838651896,
0.0659396872,
-0.0215427205,
-0.3849537671,
0.866671145,
0.3185659945,
0.1781211942,
-0.0411552899,
0.9078806043,
0.0203592926,
0.2743468583,
-0.1548308134,
1.0278298855,
-0.478397578,
0.0516729914,
-0.4779469669,
-0.8450054526,
-0.3131133914,
1.0288438797,
-0.7978172898,
-0.209457919,
1.1294589043,
0.848208189,
0.099845171,
0.2239402682,
0.753813982,
0.3503599465,
0.2886073291,
0.8447954059,
1.0879442692,
-0.2171408385,
-0.0525871031,
-0.334449023,
-0.3424802721,
0.1777831018,
-0.6004488468,
-1.1712963581,
-0.8160070777,
-0.0585855283,
-0.1640857905,
0.227443561,
1.2533992529,
0.762235105,
-0.8624695539,
-0.3877349794,
0.0825976133,
-0.0468206853,
-0.2610144615,
-0.1798287779,
0.1025417373,
-0.2271333933,
-0.4090352654,
0.5572187304,
0.921354115,
-0.4909614623,
-0.629588306,
0.0920662284,
-0.030190574,
0.2638532817,
0.8082701564,
-0.2046735436,
-0.8571609259,
-0.2159067839,
0.083235696,
-0.2350766659,
-0.3383991122,
0.9868355393,
-0.2469093502,
0.2267972529,
0.6245892644,
0.4242606461,
0.4272689819,
-0.3088668287,
0.6216059923,
-0.0966414437,
0.0407891385,
0.3198268414,
0.4362290502,
0.3677279353,
-0.5188128352,
-0.0448881909,
0.1614133716,
-0.5107054114,
-0.8508609533,
0.3565478623,
-0.9544569254,
-0.1837060899,
1.1366204023,
-0.4079757035,
-0.1907389015,
-0.3437232971,
-0.4335324168,
-0.0304616243,
-0.1017461941,
1.0496789217,
1.1586909294,
-0.2442783862,
-0.2150157988,
-0.6211843491,
0.606423676,
0.3811790347,
-1.0349411964,
0.0937845632,
0.3373891413,
0.4657693505,
-0.2092877477,
0.8594689965,
-0.1969892085,
0.3424199522,
-0.1944964677,
-0.2180736959,
0.2045390308,
-0.459526062,
-0.3682841063,
0.1169637144,
-0.0818065256,
0.4577052593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09188v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09188v2
|
Towards Verifiable Text Generation with Symbolic References
| 2023-11-15T18:28:29 | 2024-04-15T16:09:33 |
Lucas Torroba Hennigen, Shannon Shen, Aniruddha Nrusimha, Bernhard Gapp, David Sontag, Yoon Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
LLMs are vulnerable to hallucinations, and thus their outputs generally
require laborious human verification for high-stakes applications. To this end,
we propose symbolically grounded generation (SymGen) as a simple approach for
enabling easier manual validation of an LLM's output. SymGen prompts an LLM to
interleave its regular output text with explicit symbolic references to fields
present in some conditioning data (e.g., a table in JSON format). The
references can be used to display the provenance of different spans of text in
the generation, reducing the effort required for manual verification. Across a
range of data-to-text and question-answering experiments, we find that LLMs are
able to directly output text that makes use of accurate symbolic references
while maintaining fluency and factuality. In a human study we further find that
such annotations can streamline human verification of machine-generated text.
Our code will be available at http://symgen.github.io.
|
[
-0.0408575051,
-0.5449534655,
0.9387329817,
0.0217213091,
-0.4526176751,
-0.1021092758,
-0.0351943709,
-0.3547632694,
0.0684831515,
0.7013500333,
-0.7690064907,
-0.7379728556,
-0.5138445497,
0.6828514338,
-0.5041045547,
1.170915246,
-0.1763813943,
-0.0570873395,
-0.4326673746,
-0.0285754576,
-0.3942737877,
-0.96642977,
-0.5515979528,
-0.7078022361,
0.5079264045,
-0.0355239138,
0.5444088578,
0.9632917047,
0.4439594746,
0.3111387491,
0.0965093523,
0.6025534868,
-0.5871089697,
0.6554691792,
-0.0667016879,
-0.4147392809,
-0.3474286795,
-0.0535943881,
0.5274451971,
0.2678489387,
0.0487476587,
0.1838465035,
-0.0191052575,
0.445902884,
-0.5438339114,
0.2026677877,
-0.9303796291,
-0.0031626299,
-0.2124213129,
-0.3401676118,
-0.716332376,
-0.4871415794,
-0.3716068566,
-0.719396174,
0.4017562866,
0.2246109545,
1.2582947016,
0.5339789987,
-0.5174013376,
-0.1809580028,
-0.7820578218,
0.5269847512,
-0.5887725353,
0.1616526693,
0.5056154728,
0.4291081429,
-0.263487637,
-1.0007412434,
-0.6241858006,
-0.6482501626,
-0.4156571329,
0.1793807149,
-0.0318379849,
0.0320110992,
0.6707122922,
0.1356548071,
-0.2803236544,
-0.3617101014,
-0.2591315508,
-0.2970324755,
0.7458316088,
0.2634493709,
0.4977392852,
-0.3476363719,
-0.1845751852,
-0.1918589175,
-1.1458889246,
-0.5104933977,
0.367372185,
0.0658969209,
0.0805154145,
0.7961953878,
-0.1521497667,
0.4910532236,
0.1606033891,
-0.0773084834,
-0.0373028927,
-0.3437214792,
-0.2148584723,
0.4655649662,
0.8295325041,
0.3972100019,
0.4458719194,
-0.3566988111,
-0.4912420809,
0.4853070676,
0.4798559844,
-0.9438615441,
-0.2717207074,
0.0033345094,
-0.0718499571,
-0.5124762654,
0.2866659164,
-0.3450967669,
-0.8028835058,
-0.3783892691,
0.4442348778,
-0.3377367258,
0.2105979621,
-0.2297984958,
-0.3041841686,
-0.2530388832,
0.3609552383,
-0.6193624735,
0.1693502069,
0.5741634965,
0.6238745451,
-0.0556365624,
-0.2691158354,
-0.5677585006,
0.6964411736,
-0.2989503443,
0.6445912719,
-0.0490571484,
-0.3081023097,
0.0858489349,
-0.0173309445,
0.3332752585,
-0.5852512121,
0.5166646838,
-0.2085000426,
0.2032340467,
-0.2230610847,
-0.2206285596,
0.130978778,
0.3165902793,
-0.7615460753,
1.3502676487,
0.1102210879,
-0.8718711734,
0.498777777,
-0.1732077152,
-0.5504463911,
-0.0946510583,
-0.6907670498,
-0.5770388246,
0.3096831739,
0.1027101725,
0.652405262,
-0.5468995571,
0.6774598956,
-0.1259738356,
-0.3096288741,
0.485945344,
-0.4622071683,
0.4032393992,
0.1956018806,
-0.5741394758,
0.2440182567,
-1.2224190235,
-0.2338941395,
0.3317245245,
-0.2603958845,
-0.3385857344,
0.1909715831,
-0.0950940996,
0.2095062435,
0.0469059199,
-0.4338978529,
0.0806355104,
-0.4158866107,
0.2020286024,
0.8070680499,
0.1719665527,
0.1002971977,
-0.4953137934,
0.141911149,
0.1329418272,
-0.2054356486,
-0.4758836925,
-0.2624482214,
-0.9370449781,
-0.1179982126,
0.0171694979,
0.4280066192,
-1.0050011873,
0.4181474447,
-0.4489380419,
-0.4294202626,
-0.2816687822,
0.3470519483,
0.4775191247,
0.6439111829,
0.1459634006,
0.1450611502,
-0.8280073404,
-0.9895069003,
-0.2376158834,
-0.6537721753,
-0.3159427941,
0.1055456996,
0.3749542236,
-0.3228162527,
1.0322703123,
-0.4069072306,
0.0645169988,
-0.1721165925,
0.2017486542,
0.1960190684,
0.3994359076,
0.2854683101,
-0.4995346665,
-0.0948171988,
0.1181317121,
-1.2615077496,
-0.5602836609,
-0.4028232396,
-0.3481555581,
0.115874216,
0.5814456344,
-0.7850754857,
0.2234189212,
0.3197544515,
-0.5566301346,
0.3727617562,
-0.1264050752,
0.1806049049,
-1.4023131132,
0.0963032767,
0.0496163331,
-0.5566779971,
-0.5835009217,
-0.0866814852,
0.0081699518,
-0.2230751067,
-0.2832988501,
0.5496963859,
-0.528090775,
0.4013593495,
-0.2134277076,
0.2481142879,
0.0381851234,
0.1157620847,
-0.0410952494,
0.7683376074,
0.2290783077,
-0.6043551564,
0.3029593825,
-0.0963885412,
0.1944599301,
0.5500116348,
-0.8029342294,
0.1503222138,
-0.3732827306,
0.265740782,
-0.899977386,
-0.4467489421,
0.5791333318,
-0.2627319396,
0.1730341166,
0.0424949899,
-0.8829330802,
-0.133610338,
-0.2281837165,
0.1235410348,
0.6314795017,
-0.5074449182,
0.8390527964,
0.1228182688,
0.1496718973,
-0.096614629,
-0.6300874949,
0.2606152594,
-0.331510365,
-0.5749623775,
0.091921322,
0.063739486,
-0.512072742,
-0.3173270226,
-0.2328302264,
0.1490987539,
0.2385033667,
0.8834061027,
0.4545513391,
-0.2118108571,
0.1057813317,
0.4877771139,
-0.4015394747,
0.4769640863,
-0.2213466913,
0.1888408959,
0.1733295321,
-0.4303475022,
-0.3029001951,
0.3639048636,
0.5884853005,
0.3416086435,
0.3929157555,
0.3761583865,
-0.8162310719,
-0.3218182623,
-0.535487771,
-0.5885273814,
-0.4645889997,
0.170540452,
-0.331485033,
-0.6074944735,
0.1899046451,
-0.3455848098,
0.2367699891,
0.6719942093,
0.6797969937,
-0.0866993666,
1.0997848511,
0.4369872808,
0.2040075362,
-0.1849955618,
0.331306994,
-0.0593366958,
-0.0642782003,
-0.2983185947,
-0.5876379609,
-0.0686046556,
-0.3496836126,
-0.1413631886,
0.2245445549,
0.1414812952,
-0.3585813344,
0.2635895014,
-0.6694945693,
0.4425576031,
0.4836232662,
0.2673648894,
0.443939954,
0.1851648092,
-0.1577000618,
-0.1490839422,
-0.4145763814,
-1.1378000975,
0.7647022009,
0.3524097204,
0.750616014,
-0.1685559601,
1.0866364241,
0.4035801888,
0.8481965661,
-0.3500982523,
0.861539185,
0.17069529,
-0.6228626966,
-0.1192547381,
-0.4493298829,
-0.678604424,
0.0972460136,
-0.4359691441,
-0.7418797016,
-0.410725832,
0.5943186879,
-0.056920398,
0.0500488915,
-0.6104875207,
0.5274138451,
-0.2384452671,
-0.4044519365,
0.1694700569,
-0.6371461749,
0.4724973142,
-0.2139568031,
-0.221645698,
-0.1729011834,
0.1214764565,
0.7304553986,
-0.5993871689,
1.0947784185,
0.0240107998,
-0.4511826634,
0.3131258786,
0.3229186237,
0.8359670043,
0.3645149767,
-0.0834971592,
0.1977941543,
-0.1229481548,
0.0754070058,
-0.7244567871,
0.6146268845,
-0.7592981458,
-0.9195864797,
-0.6477323174,
-0.5676642656,
-0.2184172273,
0.3191982508,
0.4455073476,
-0.0619401336,
-0.0358876288,
-0.1036133096,
0.713262856,
0.1302246302,
0.1438219845,
-0.001446652,
-0.3955518305,
-0.7184380889,
0.7329490781,
-0.111911729,
-0.0570942536,
0.2037202716,
0.1994071752,
-0.1187720448,
-0.2069758624,
-0.7960878611,
0.4362523854,
-0.8970201015,
-0.2228895128,
-0.4857044816,
-0.297498852,
-0.1625484079,
-0.1794408858,
-0.1316823065,
-0.4836499691,
-0.4108397961,
-0.3369758427,
0.5189232826,
0.9030051231,
0.3281564116,
0.4494519532,
-0.8076508641,
0.5182642937,
0.0914776847,
-0.1812755316,
-0.388885349,
-0.1725920588,
-0.076368466,
0.0935025439,
-0.3058004081,
-1.1026293039,
0.0262154154,
-0.0774209797,
0.3901072443,
0.4296941757,
0.1314986497,
0.6148069501,
-0.6140896082,
0.8689417243,
0.5324111581,
-1.0145485401,
0.8719159365,
-0.2352791876,
0.038442716,
0.6050120592,
0.2691311538,
-0.331179291,
-0.7654961944,
-0.5454195142,
-0.765869081,
0.3518517315,
0.5638013482,
0.1626487523,
-0.0021559158,
0.692194581,
0.262383014,
0.1229407042,
-0.9163173437,
-0.4112430513,
-0.2999446988,
-0.3431258202,
-0.1165921316,
-0.3706622422,
-0.4895702302,
-0.0062184017,
0.6714118123,
-0.1178609207,
0.0012622932,
0.3106510639,
-0.1189699024,
-0.0412036367,
0.0550384969,
0.5462177992,
0.5124104023,
-0.0092549883,
0.757578969,
0.3367011845,
-0.4492548406,
0.5641548634,
-0.0271964166,
-0.6788715124,
0.5226150751,
0.3500798643,
0.6658557653,
-0.1310302168,
-0.4441847801,
0.0977203771,
-0.0657333583,
-0.3690132499,
-0.2336642295,
0.2330844402,
-0.0245154072,
0.0191275366,
0.2826085687,
-0.1675465554,
-0.2335054278,
-0.0895460993,
0.3644712865,
0.0302657913,
-0.3107499778,
-0.3377699256,
0.9356289506,
0.0567400306,
-0.1566577256,
0.473292172,
0.0120267468,
-0.1164614186,
0.2545908988,
1.1219629049,
1.1190595627,
0.1990958601,
-0.0060687494,
0.3462550044,
0.536291182,
-0.0816768929,
0.2643067241,
-0.1962585002,
-0.3283906579,
-0.2225515693,
-0.5108780265,
-0.3009501398,
-0.031333968,
-0.2002558708,
0.4008981586,
-0.6415603161,
-0.5147383213,
-0.3309852779,
-0.4968727827,
-0.2817804217,
0.3144585192,
0.3416567147,
0.6687809229,
-1.105931282,
0.6751208901,
0.9446578622,
-0.4350498021,
-0.7606437802,
-0.0371558219,
0.0217280611,
-0.5551245213,
0.9988359809,
0.2995019257,
-0.3334257007,
-0.0284943171,
-0.609608829,
-0.4378752708,
1.3138266802,
0.9019886851,
-0.4081157744,
-0.1173535064,
0.4539738595,
0.4589062929,
0.0460563488,
0.094125025,
0.1449039578,
0.6409839392,
0.0165577084,
-0.3410997391,
0.724816978,
-0.472135663,
0.3271035552,
0.1551776677,
-0.1704888195,
0.3956817985,
0.0883783549,
-0.5588005781,
0.0362414159,
1.1902732849,
0.8908162117,
0.5289501548,
0.3989016414,
0.4796797633,
0.8304672837,
-0.3496282697,
0.9862231016,
-0.4483982325,
-0.0024822564,
0.8905297518,
-0.5458158255,
0.4596381187,
0.9771323204,
0.1512692273,
0.3978787661,
0.4230205119,
-0.1096288487,
0.055308789,
0.694801271,
-0.4065794349,
-0.3692767918,
-0.2002317905,
-0.2767857611,
0.0030164805,
-0.0856753141,
-0.6325494647,
-0.3536323309,
-0.2719374299,
0.3808400035,
0.3418022394,
0.0036871701,
0.6163910031,
0.1921866536,
-0.7835918665,
0.5546273589,
0.1271487623,
0.4220089018,
-0.7137184739,
-0.4369516373,
-0.2359819263,
0.1127791032,
-0.2651965618,
-0.2959750295,
0.3103380501,
0.2791901827,
-0.2638192475,
-0.4536374807,
1.2113465071,
-0.150180012,
-0.6707319021,
-0.1725686938,
0.5758178234,
0.2097094953,
-0.0504294559,
-0.1317166537,
0.0253678113,
-0.1822091192,
-0.2324801981,
0.2069725692,
0.7826147676,
-0.2111724317,
0.6421613097,
0.8343549371,
0.1460742205,
0.1166752428,
0.108367458,
0.7656437159,
-0.6741099358,
-0.2865465879,
-1.3344473839,
0.5219084024,
-0.1900206208,
-0.3840712905,
1.0185015202,
0.6443803906,
0.5718669295,
-0.3368925452,
0.8280681968,
0.2740961313,
-0.0634613186,
-0.6881528497,
1.0922598839,
-0.2443129122,
0.2241295129,
-0.3345815837,
-0.746917665,
-0.599609375,
0.5272285342,
0.2860330045,
-0.0370428823,
0.690800488,
0.9732362628,
0.0335050188,
-0.1600351781,
0.3714518547,
-0.0468783677,
0.2729541063,
0.4636266232,
1.2253988981,
-0.4722024798,
0.3991753459,
-0.321916461,
-0.1074834615,
0.1733088046,
-1.2356642485,
-1.1500600576,
-0.4917943478,
-0.4742707908,
-0.9021366835,
0.301546663,
0.8676416278,
0.520260632,
-0.5957868695,
-0.3294712901,
-0.324257642,
0.004249312,
-0.0224570129,
-0.1617026925,
0.1545511037,
-0.124002777,
-0.5841293931,
0.1258664876,
0.3750193417,
0.3055099547,
-0.3474921882,
-0.2510164678,
0.2323475331,
0.0868392959,
0.6457625628,
-0.0109497355,
-0.8176521063,
-0.2302596569,
-0.1637580097,
-0.497326076,
-0.0356406495,
1.0654569864,
-0.9968017936,
-0.0597841479,
0.4601789117,
0.8588247299,
0.1780719906,
0.0160399582,
0.6636170149,
-0.922395587,
-0.1936420798,
0.0719944537,
0.4309396148,
0.0803432912,
-0.7084138989,
0.601544857,
0.5618340373,
-0.2475153655,
-1.0752897263,
0.182734549,
-1.0486627817,
0.1030806974,
1.3611588478,
-0.0778021738,
-0.297160238,
0.1515370458,
-0.5167981982,
0.5931125879,
-0.192876786,
0.9678717256,
0.7116947174,
0.1792796552,
-0.0523510836,
-0.2159326375,
0.3814118505,
0.5019620657,
-1.2465014458,
0.307605654,
0.7853760719,
-0.0884339362,
0.3066459894,
0.4108271599,
-0.0547776669,
0.3025784791,
0.1663448066,
0.2244227678,
-0.3856122792,
-0.3602356315,
-0.0782519728,
0.3095337749,
0.2023773044,
-0.0294229239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09184v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09184v1
|
Benchmarking Generation and Evaluation Capabilities of Large Language Models for Instruction Controllable Summarization
| 2023-11-15T18:25:26 | 2023-11-15T18:25:26 |
Yixin Liu, Alexander R. Fabbri, Jiawen Chen, Yilun Zhao, Simeng Han, Shafiq Joty, Pengfei Liu, Dragomir Radev, Chien-Sheng Wu, Arman Cohan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
While large language models (LLMs) already achieve strong performance on
standard generic summarization benchmarks, their performance on more complex
summarization task settings is less studied. Therefore, we benchmark LLMs on
instruction controllable text summarization, where the model input consists of
both a source article and a natural language requirement for the desired
summary characteristics. To this end, we curate an evaluation-only dataset for
this task setting and conduct human evaluation on 5 LLM-based summarization
systems. We then benchmark LLM-based automatic evaluation for this task with 4
different evaluation protocols and 11 LLMs, resulting in 40 evaluation methods
in total. Our study reveals that instruction controllable text summarization
remains a challenging task for LLMs, since (1) all LLMs evaluated still make
factual and other types of errors in their summaries; (2) all LLM-based
evaluation methods cannot achieve a strong alignment with human annotators when
judging the quality of candidate summaries; (3) different LLMs show large
performance gaps in summary generation and evaluation. We make our collected
benchmark, InstruSum, publicly available to facilitate future research in this
direction.
|
[
-0.1837877929,
-0.5048767328,
0.3887922466,
0.3593305945,
-0.1814212799,
0.3014388382,
-0.5543613434,
-0.4244098365,
-0.1887839437,
0.548786521,
-0.2819125056,
-0.6287071705,
-0.6659584641,
0.3651663363,
-0.4096637368,
1.0595582724,
-0.3069889545,
0.1627184898,
-0.5424484611,
-0.2751416862,
-0.3145152628,
-0.3993053138,
-0.3940762579,
-0.4387987554,
0.0954963863,
0.4417603314,
0.4095909297,
0.5995094776,
0.7594011426,
0.2903873026,
-0.0941674039,
0.3184467256,
-0.4735953808,
-0.0164227206,
-0.087874651,
-0.3545547724,
-0.685084939,
-0.047656212,
1.0655322075,
0.722460568,
-0.1358724236,
0.3676407933,
0.313624531,
0.6876290441,
-0.869720459,
0.1756137908,
-0.4076126814,
0.0081517585,
-0.0219610613,
-0.0574350469,
-0.5742832422,
-0.8191462755,
0.0128346803,
-0.1108288392,
0.1285259575,
-0.0514207371,
0.6174268723,
0.2425689697,
-0.4447283149,
-0.5445313454,
-0.5781791806,
0.9131826162,
-1.0408866405,
0.2429076284,
0.1277647913,
0.3233866096,
-0.1269242018,
-0.6411435008,
-0.1680075526,
-0.5192503929,
-0.1499454379,
0.303232491,
-0.2807775438,
0.0466569848,
0.1528606117,
0.3710761368,
-0.5473054051,
0.3717854321,
-0.3133739233,
-0.0581505932,
0.7986187339,
0.4627065957,
0.0658217669,
-0.0533343777,
-0.3945087194,
-0.1068114713,
-0.7714059949,
-0.0723901838,
0.2915912271,
0.036350973,
-0.3481522501,
0.7062247396,
-0.2815787494,
0.6663311124,
-0.2632175088,
-0.2087647468,
0.2309699804,
-0.2725236118,
-0.3911339045,
0.085718222,
0.9557276964,
0.7544807196,
0.0576907247,
-0.3063516915,
-0.4788868725,
-0.1104296744,
0.1247759163,
-1.0100777149,
0.0622530505,
-0.0100418776,
-0.3978001475,
-0.2129227221,
0.0829369053,
-0.7142330408,
-0.3460590243,
-0.324709028,
0.4135044217,
-0.2459241301,
0.1259452403,
-0.0680361539,
-0.0185265988,
0.1151180565,
0.2763752937,
-0.8431333899,
0.7773707509,
0.7487053275,
0.7448404431,
-0.747795105,
-0.2373494655,
-0.5307146311,
0.1369427741,
-0.4526475668,
0.7616069913,
-0.4951015413,
-0.4731090367,
0.0155484313,
-0.0314359069,
-0.1753538102,
-0.8725319505,
0.3096730113,
-0.3716591597,
0.1428657621,
-0.0973151401,
-0.8980791569,
-0.0187460911,
0.2475999743,
-0.5296508074,
0.8391988873,
0.0852353498,
-0.5698384047,
0.1716222018,
-0.4769605994,
-0.4690074027,
-0.0081885336,
-0.2611591518,
-0.4811728299,
0.1480186135,
0.0801530629,
0.5166348219,
-0.611675024,
0.3190527558,
0.0285275821,
-0.6029793024,
0.2391927242,
-0.4919427931,
0.4637590051,
0.0358144864,
-0.4107577503,
0.2811679542,
-0.6621712446,
0.0225427952,
-0.088666521,
-0.5409576893,
-0.0581516288,
0.0417986549,
-0.2163364738,
-0.1695421785,
0.4779146016,
-0.3422690332,
0.0979438275,
-0.1338555813,
0.0435124524,
0.6125350595,
0.0141501008,
0.1653882861,
-0.4041998386,
0.754432559,
-0.3159873486,
-0.0563279428,
-0.307690084,
-0.0380290113,
-0.6878674626,
-0.214685753,
0.3266804516,
0.5912201405,
-0.4834452868,
0.4820851386,
-0.2944901884,
-0.6061160564,
-0.2389738858,
0.3193424642,
0.9960439205,
0.4953576624,
0.2244797945,
-0.2099937797,
-0.239991948,
-1.0456490517,
-0.2789684832,
0.0117655769,
-0.2432074994,
0.1274834573,
0.4110497534,
0.0355878882,
0.5661138892,
-0.4320561886,
-0.0297927968,
-0.5806178451,
0.4065132141,
0.2290312648,
0.2394491583,
0.4196965098,
-0.2869137526,
-0.3011360765,
-0.0540166423,
-0.8991745114,
-0.3913064897,
-0.0836883485,
0.0616841763,
0.3923362195,
0.628898263,
-0.2902696431,
0.1980512738,
0.6431392431,
-0.053314615,
0.7033147216,
-0.4506017864,
0.3428132534,
-0.8862333298,
0.1429137588,
-0.0136622712,
-0.1541311741,
-0.1685039252,
0.0426803343,
0.364479959,
0.078097716,
-0.3352991045,
0.4611358345,
-0.5449130535,
-0.3740712106,
-0.3350292146,
0.3114540875,
-0.0098947166,
0.3567107618,
-0.1348315328,
0.8531445265,
0.0656095594,
-0.6068406701,
0.3193741739,
0.0483582802,
-0.7195943594,
0.3096847534,
-0.8496608138,
-0.1277755946,
-0.1494874507,
0.2907960117,
-0.9136270285,
-0.2285672873,
0.0710126609,
-0.0269663669,
0.4829847813,
0.1668926328,
-0.5644477606,
-0.0806233734,
-0.4974669218,
0.1732212007,
0.500107348,
-0.4962604642,
0.3629406393,
0.2541934848,
-0.4398764372,
-0.5626549721,
-0.5839169621,
0.1953871548,
-0.0829798132,
-0.2068090886,
0.3434022367,
-0.1902335286,
-0.4158536792,
-0.0513809212,
-0.2535279095,
0.2306144834,
0.0637009516,
0.1617612541,
0.3524480164,
-0.1002435163,
0.2117273211,
0.2116852701,
-0.0621742494,
0.2480154186,
0.250723213,
0.2921199203,
-0.1808618903,
-0.411985904,
-0.3051178455,
0.244855389,
0.3905259669,
-0.3821434081,
0.370742172,
0.1970389783,
-0.2397746742,
-0.3877484202,
-0.5662000179,
0.0524955988,
-0.4130432308,
0.5688354969,
-0.0287784226,
-0.7173871398,
0.282766521,
-0.0638821572,
0.4871833026,
0.4455111921,
0.6357084513,
0.0530191362,
0.8168100119,
0.4714337289,
-0.0707762688,
0.2219243795,
-0.2680487633,
-0.2546038032,
-0.7788994312,
-0.1490444988,
-0.5481951833,
-0.3451437652,
-0.5692713857,
-0.2312641144,
0.5457414985,
0.0916423723,
-0.1179630756,
0.1972895414,
-0.4226192236,
0.7270639539,
0.3180136383,
0.0291835554,
0.50267905,
-0.2263643146,
-0.0496331565,
0.0081893001,
-0.5830404162,
-0.8773577213,
1.1099083424,
0.2120101303,
0.9005913734,
0.0475226603,
0.7824325562,
0.4080113173,
0.857204318,
-0.4410896003,
0.6885617375,
-0.3265028,
-0.1538510323,
-0.2454256713,
-0.6316481233,
-0.6519235969,
0.2383015603,
-0.0523389615,
-0.683603704,
-0.2805804312,
0.0991938412,
-0.1637770683,
0.2298399061,
-0.8763830066,
0.8525531292,
-0.3728625178,
-0.264798075,
-0.1757259518,
-0.5105693936,
0.6141815782,
-0.0073033771,
0.1148739532,
-0.1427229792,
-0.2371780723,
0.8711929321,
-0.3684552908,
0.7495343685,
0.0849205554,
-0.1533339471,
0.1475847811,
0.0189611036,
0.3303549886,
-0.1887716949,
-0.2258738428,
0.0415301509,
-0.1699541956,
-0.1726953983,
-0.4417106509,
0.823805213,
-0.6360042691,
-0.430511415,
-0.2939177155,
-0.5360915661,
-0.2963106632,
0.1954993308,
0.329303354,
0.6389538646,
-0.4018043876,
0.2372175455,
0.5894472003,
-0.2948084176,
0.6306405663,
0.5467772484,
-0.2110466063,
-0.5332380533,
0.8419474363,
0.1643981338,
0.3863040805,
0.6177427769,
0.1715720594,
-0.2563522458,
-0.676661253,
-0.5083292723,
0.2585557401,
-0.7374410033,
-0.2493205816,
-0.4904078841,
-0.1888586134,
-0.1723960787,
-0.1752595454,
-0.3125280142,
-0.3361237943,
-0.0743302628,
-0.1214128733,
0.0307545401,
1.082903266,
0.279073894,
0.2701907456,
-0.9050827026,
0.4151328504,
0.2242898196,
0.5295329094,
0.0726775974,
-0.4578125775,
-0.4710932076,
-0.2428360879,
-0.503783524,
-0.725274384,
0.1120791063,
0.0630547181,
0.5832452178,
0.2981847525,
0.118509002,
0.3652798533,
-0.4329103231,
0.6821930408,
0.0302097239,
-0.8861007094,
0.3007563949,
-0.0776637495,
0.6745249033,
0.5575485229,
0.251722753,
-0.2101324201,
-0.6526660323,
-0.3540910482,
-0.8932929635,
0.6872060299,
0.0946929902,
-0.0849103779,
-0.0124102281,
0.0847567767,
0.2406756282,
0.3105862737,
-0.2958145738,
-0.1629995704,
0.157997787,
-0.2961269617,
-0.3593010604,
-0.495567292,
-0.2183672339,
0.1671589464,
0.6774813533,
0.0315753706,
-0.0784822255,
-0.024236368,
-0.2458231449,
-0.0467050821,
0.3547921777,
0.8062303066,
1.047317028,
-0.401548475,
0.0256209671,
0.3643853366,
-0.3269164562,
0.0463405289,
0.3315088451,
-0.2295864224,
0.1362526417,
0.7109736204,
0.5974868536,
0.5563883781,
-1.0075905323,
0.4382427037,
-0.2841922045,
-0.1229448467,
-0.3103697598,
0.1754360944,
0.2544508874,
0.1684553921,
0.3400765359,
-0.3445628285,
0.1415982693,
-0.1762785316,
0.0534610264,
0.310804069,
-0.1059486046,
-0.1577049345,
0.6952397227,
0.1652410626,
-0.188540712,
0.3043659925,
-0.1262301952,
-0.1325824261,
0.67229563,
0.4710590839,
1.0515085459,
-0.1497086883,
0.0411310792,
0.4357818067,
0.4044630527,
0.0580405407,
0.1424425542,
-0.1658097208,
-0.3849751949,
-0.5201348662,
-0.4956127703,
-0.9985703826,
0.0557654388,
-0.76757586,
0.1331614405,
-0.3847828805,
0.1053156182,
0.0422512628,
0.0158144571,
-0.3739716113,
0.1932509989,
-0.0341344513,
0.9786664844,
-0.6833578348,
0.3277629018,
0.6733360887,
-0.1936904639,
-0.5260359645,
-0.0937367156,
-0.1126612946,
-0.3782159388,
0.4996805489,
0.2672226727,
-0.3282807171,
-0.329800576,
-0.4398704171,
-0.4436215162,
1.2284401655,
0.4568817616,
-0.7110766768,
0.0417005047,
0.1036541462,
0.5224869251,
-0.4109444618,
0.5085576773,
0.7378206253,
0.3476385772,
-0.0588192567,
-0.8826588988,
-0.0476500131,
-0.2889527082,
0.0047693136,
0.2770023048,
-0.7716950178,
0.6534162164,
-0.1342376769,
-0.2211242169,
0.1161420122,
0.6767020226,
0.4002802074,
0.4200019538,
0.2181382477,
0.4576695859,
0.4639608562,
-0.0473782197,
1.2222599983,
-0.3442951441,
0.0867538154,
1.5737073421,
-0.3867858946,
0.8078632355,
0.1461140215,
-0.2150669098,
0.1065428108,
0.2943227887,
-0.0280913934,
0.1619433463,
0.306117326,
-0.315980345,
0.0079036048,
-0.1179117635,
-0.2967962027,
0.3649746478,
0.1867877543,
-0.4516620934,
-0.5783607364,
-0.3322948217,
0.1413765252,
0.2838129401,
-0.29451406,
0.9421247244,
-0.1217304319,
-0.7549147606,
0.6655446291,
0.1377121061,
0.5268884897,
-0.7719243765,
-0.151998654,
-0.3161368072,
0.2568606734,
-0.1468070149,
-0.6361554861,
0.0931984708,
0.3950578868,
-0.0330610164,
-0.1901789606,
0.3985197544,
-0.4070225358,
-0.5677013397,
0.1786536574,
0.2985910773,
0.2563109398,
0.3731900454,
-0.1774832606,
0.2596195936,
-0.0508944206,
-0.4409522712,
0.4271070659,
0.2397453189,
-0.2357891798,
0.7046257257,
0.3165880442,
0.2190705538,
0.0484580323,
0.2023308128,
0.800151825,
-0.5734009743,
-0.2150061131,
-0.9046990871,
0.3539500237,
-0.0992357507,
-0.4247015715,
0.8570008874,
0.9080140591,
0.8886992931,
-0.1069370508,
0.8931310773,
0.1725947559,
0.5447850823,
-0.6541267037,
0.7429375648,
-0.3342700601,
0.2464889884,
-0.2002924383,
-0.9926954508,
-0.1767658144,
0.0586590543,
-0.1915059537,
0.0300746057,
0.5237498879,
0.7050554156,
0.1347395927,
-0.1313850284,
0.2695012689,
0.1468356252,
0.3271205425,
0.4966121912,
0.764831841,
-0.2809895873,
0.5049571991,
-0.2934879661,
-0.4194573462,
-0.2657949924,
-1.1816648245,
-0.8987791538,
-0.1350355446,
-0.3506046832,
-0.0138121312,
0.1124641225,
0.9860081077,
0.3203930855,
-0.8817068934,
-0.6904675961,
0.1410592496,
0.2780905664,
-0.2398522794,
-0.2051121294,
0.5246879458,
-0.3803602457,
-0.9396129847,
0.4828032851,
0.3934458494,
-0.0042205034,
-0.265220046,
-0.1697748601,
0.1683808267,
-0.1384555995,
0.5557460785,
0.2034250647,
-0.5003696084,
0.0855044425,
-0.2089730948,
-0.2316202968,
-0.1913804114,
0.819892168,
-0.3859111071,
0.465591073,
0.4508198798,
0.7932525277,
0.382171303,
0.1643646955,
0.6341521144,
-0.6718856692,
-0.141634956,
0.2203786373,
0.3294702172,
0.3263401985,
-0.0156187229,
0.4612273574,
-0.3134405613,
-0.6658748388,
-0.7925873399,
-0.1388784349,
-0.8155041933,
-0.0165951997,
0.9831781983,
-0.3307559788,
-0.1416518241,
0.4332226217,
-0.0619295686,
0.2769429982,
-0.2575557232,
0.7486684322,
0.5988852978,
-0.1947990954,
-0.1938467175,
-0.5474401116,
0.2773596644,
0.1889928877,
-1.0795361996,
0.3381324708,
0.6854299903,
0.2268192172,
-0.1227357686,
0.4189499617,
-0.2717947066,
0.3907830715,
-0.2856972814,
0.3659139872,
-0.3091136515,
-0.277480334,
-0.4012844265,
0.1340982616,
0.0817583054,
-0.1818602532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09182v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09182v2
|
ContraDoc: Understanding Self-Contradictions in Documents with Large Language Models
| 2023-11-15T18:23:17 | 2024-04-12T21:06:43 |
Jierui Li, Vipul Raheja, Dhruv Kumar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent times, large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive
performance on various document-level tasks such as document classification,
summarization, and question-answering. However, research on understanding their
capabilities on the task of self-contradictions in long documents has been very
limited. In this work, we introduce ContraDoc, the first human-annotated
dataset to study self-contradictions in long documents across multiple domains,
varying document lengths, self-contradictions types, and scope. We then analyze
the current capabilities of four state-of-the-art open-source and commercially
available LLMs: GPT3.5, GPT4, PaLM2, and LLaMAv2 on this dataset. While GPT4
performs the best and can outperform humans on this task, we find that it is
still unreliable and struggles with self-contradictions that require more
nuance and context. We release the dataset and all the code associated with the
experiments (https://github.com/ddhruvkr/CONTRADOC).
|
[
-0.5105731487,
-0.6322460175,
0.9722498059,
0.2198038846,
-0.2594726384,
-0.0431760699,
-0.0514222607,
-0.4204775989,
-0.0099019352,
0.6120002866,
-0.9376829863,
-0.4820465147,
-0.6995355487,
0.5483189821,
-0.5174198151,
1.146415472,
-0.3114984035,
-0.0266769733,
-0.5543270707,
-0.3049037158,
-0.3591943085,
-0.5129924417,
0.0881487206,
-0.3010414839,
0.4289068878,
0.4460781515,
0.5792152882,
0.4785886109,
0.3762520552,
0.3534782231,
0.4593831897,
0.0072578499,
-0.4421322942,
0.1679035574,
-0.5783187151,
-0.346411705,
-0.4075744152,
0.2430205792,
0.5349264741,
0.3852387667,
0.1074914709,
0.0448547266,
0.1767704934,
0.6093529463,
-0.4661183059,
0.142334491,
-0.5707209706,
-0.2821733057,
-0.5653963685,
0.1010569483,
-0.039345704,
-0.0953643247,
0.0207193624,
-0.8170989752,
0.741032958,
-0.1529247463,
0.6562088728,
0.5273387432,
-0.4547653496,
-0.6745417714,
-0.5804880857,
0.6158442497,
-0.9181795716,
0.3078775108,
0.45853585,
0.2401171029,
-0.2629321218,
-0.7161307931,
-1.0316343307,
-0.0798073038,
-0.0747996122,
0.2900701463,
-0.2188501507,
-0.1567252725,
0.332092911,
0.3256028593,
-0.9050168395,
0.4303306937,
-0.2235509604,
-0.1032814756,
0.5894703865,
0.125528872,
0.1088415682,
-0.3896690905,
-0.3803207278,
0.0794719979,
-0.7807334661,
-0.4178730547,
0.6738939285,
-0.025119191,
-0.0071092271,
0.4801830053,
-0.1268872619,
0.4629457593,
-0.1971014887,
0.1247037426,
0.2312492281,
-0.4283050001,
-0.3055397272,
-0.2361228019,
0.9533647299,
-0.0113173006,
-0.0192480311,
-0.0489501022,
-0.1932768822,
-0.129412815,
0.3069456816,
-0.5079865456,
-0.1281144619,
0.3463926911,
-0.1101394817,
-0.0121760694,
0.0098412596,
-0.7817296386,
-0.5063852072,
-0.2664690316,
0.4823690951,
-0.2339251637,
0.0513364375,
0.0049913432,
0.0072576045,
0.0764579773,
0.4327185452,
-0.772759676,
0.4223588705,
0.8261166811,
0.8975860476,
-0.1235430092,
-0.6882365942,
-0.3263348043,
-0.0782428682,
-0.3025487959,
0.6889172792,
-0.0632428676,
-0.5891776681,
-0.1708098799,
0.1067440957,
0.1192217618,
-0.527171731,
1.0353285074,
-0.2921011746,
0.3891933858,
-0.4835112989,
-0.656696856,
-0.0256904885,
0.1912306249,
-0.6105445027,
0.607364893,
0.0880868956,
-0.9386572242,
-0.0956642032,
-0.4645841718,
-0.3612796366,
0.2384856045,
-0.522188127,
-0.6265534759,
-0.0475438163,
0.1341744512,
0.5331660509,
-0.6565342546,
0.3257479072,
-0.4474973977,
-0.1386250854,
0.2624854147,
-0.3918063343,
0.8106803298,
0.2482981384,
-0.585324049,
-0.0369209014,
-0.5420507193,
-0.2911808193,
0.4148957431,
0.1129011661,
-0.4069247544,
-0.0246069096,
-0.2762638628,
0.3581638634,
0.3409624994,
-0.5549180508,
0.2746998072,
-0.0827398747,
0.4072428346,
0.794154644,
-0.3715956211,
-0.074881278,
-0.2630198002,
0.4795170724,
-0.1069003195,
0.1312546432,
-0.1545806229,
-0.4625000954,
-0.456905514,
-0.1139634773,
0.1365646869,
0.4715504944,
-0.7085052729,
0.4910637438,
-0.3156665266,
-0.3452889025,
-0.4706324339,
0.5267888904,
0.5435094237,
0.8589873314,
0.4840534329,
-0.1774851829,
-0.3624148369,
-1.266684413,
-0.4395810068,
-0.1395538896,
-0.0028608763,
0.4166193306,
0.8691795468,
-0.4259198904,
0.9592253566,
-0.4221410751,
-0.5471810699,
0.0214705151,
0.6279751062,
0.2294992507,
0.321547389,
0.4016492963,
-0.7474800944,
-0.2978224754,
-0.3045887649,
-0.8716762662,
-0.6679212451,
-0.2863018513,
0.2922949791,
0.3656774461,
0.5825631618,
-0.5345729589,
0.3779188693,
0.9145249128,
-0.1741547436,
0.9237477779,
-0.5288174748,
-0.0016284452,
-0.8781604171,
0.0970690548,
0.0568794385,
-0.3333216906,
-0.5007693172,
-0.195364967,
0.3746258616,
0.2184911966,
-0.162390694,
0.4643898308,
-0.5322324634,
-0.1183595881,
-0.3684675992,
0.5167924762,
-0.0222641975,
0.2585922778,
-0.1335271597,
0.7972401977,
0.3320561051,
-0.2261552662,
0.4897919893,
0.2776806355,
-0.1651432961,
0.533724308,
-0.6775887012,
0.4827797711,
-0.1343144774,
0.4772379994,
-0.9519546032,
-0.4290874302,
0.2130986154,
-0.2171330005,
0.1350407004,
-0.2750351429,
-0.6959241629,
-0.5216134191,
-0.3276468217,
0.4933120906,
0.1955764741,
-0.7133114338,
0.5381515026,
0.0720890611,
-0.1237662062,
-0.8067849874,
-0.7500703931,
0.1840232015,
0.0641914085,
-0.4812682271,
0.3014546633,
-0.2512554824,
-0.1353323907,
-0.0919233412,
-0.2038298398,
0.1894685328,
-0.0854405314,
0.6219013333,
0.1422713101,
-0.0526062138,
0.1957242936,
0.0278237835,
-0.057737533,
0.0970565528,
-0.5308287144,
0.2506077588,
-0.4755388796,
-0.7777263522,
-0.3232339919,
0.290060252,
0.6145434976,
-0.0788111016,
0.5021255612,
0.2994151115,
-0.1987903118,
-0.1563597322,
-0.7406492829,
0.4107734561,
-0.4693493247,
0.2988692224,
-0.5063418746,
-0.7895438671,
0.588442266,
-0.1067648679,
-0.0477133617,
0.6755874157,
0.5702859163,
-0.0777785704,
0.5462438464,
0.3840364814,
-0.049723126,
0.0275019184,
-0.1740485579,
0.0215940941,
-0.7277829647,
-0.1878239065,
-0.542537868,
0.011359063,
-0.8131851554,
-0.4651394486,
0.3244248629,
0.1364364028,
-0.1216573417,
0.3092371821,
0.0121885315,
0.6181279421,
0.2988092899,
-0.2961974442,
0.3584056795,
-0.5561867952,
-0.1768223196,
0.0451499783,
-0.4775847197,
-0.6766582131,
1.1105241776,
0.4418020844,
0.7784866095,
0.2588256001,
0.7189044952,
0.2319408804,
0.3678677082,
-0.4917345941,
0.3837453127,
-0.4389611185,
-0.7441684604,
-0.3103892505,
-0.5851051211,
-1.0386931896,
0.250248611,
0.0315438583,
-0.4896242023,
0.1297575831,
0.1612854749,
-0.0622536205,
0.2375942171,
-0.8745570779,
1.1417675018,
-0.7391242385,
-0.5190928578,
0.0111488951,
-0.805973649,
0.4369227588,
-0.5671541095,
0.2650463581,
-0.1387030929,
-0.1325345635,
0.5612592101,
-0.3801115155,
0.7801895142,
0.049517002,
-0.3974918425,
0.0746490732,
0.2894613743,
0.5628197789,
0.1656561047,
-0.0224110112,
0.5522348285,
0.0457139313,
-0.5335851908,
-0.734346509,
1.0248463154,
-0.8586536646,
-0.936478138,
-0.5906201601,
-0.4559509158,
-0.3473447561,
0.6804366708,
0.3655982018,
0.276689291,
-0.512829423,
-0.0737683252,
0.4113843441,
-0.1955806762,
0.2139321566,
0.6547100544,
-0.1076046452,
-0.2305215746,
0.67684412,
0.2324302197,
0.2098985612,
0.1749212444,
0.3292993903,
-0.5461248159,
-0.6973776817,
-0.4289216101,
0.5000810027,
-0.8041686416,
-0.1476770192,
-0.4742498994,
0.0525868833,
-0.7477529049,
0.1539816856,
-0.4161628187,
-0.2393734902,
-0.463383615,
0.0739884824,
-0.1431649923,
1.340165019,
-0.2135306597,
0.0655491501,
-0.6284505129,
0.5960879922,
0.4623984993,
0.4698889852,
-0.2981851399,
-0.4260663986,
-0.0260619447,
-0.0073522818,
-0.4097524583,
-1.0593396425,
0.3047979474,
-0.1381851435,
0.5539119244,
0.3276214004,
0.1296980232,
0.4780732095,
-0.4708471596,
0.6304700971,
0.0852160826,
-1.2664744854,
0.3577818573,
-0.5085022449,
0.2284341305,
0.4738335907,
0.7028250694,
-0.6258999705,
-0.2220590115,
-0.750751555,
-0.7521767616,
0.6873732805,
0.5044232011,
-0.1475560069,
0.2913466692,
0.5923249722,
0.5309075117,
0.2041786462,
-0.6483367682,
-0.0668202266,
-0.6188874245,
-0.3646605313,
-0.5257976055,
0.017833259,
-0.3094622493,
0.0274749212,
0.681194067,
-0.40452227,
-0.0919405594,
0.5163403153,
-0.2483562976,
-0.0303057302,
0.3618274033,
0.8872606158,
0.8314529061,
-0.0896596462,
0.5849675536,
0.3677795529,
-0.2921006382,
-0.0584210791,
0.440816164,
0.0876100585,
-0.2332982272,
0.6295187473,
0.5147610903,
-0.3037594259,
-0.5784707069,
0.7195140719,
-0.1819165796,
-0.4307609797,
-0.3545686901,
-0.067733027,
0.1145506129,
0.3151910603,
0.1990227252,
-0.2178690732,
-0.0273573771,
-0.6128118038,
0.0987282395,
0.4461269975,
-0.067318663,
-0.3474771678,
0.5416917801,
0.2032623887,
-0.2748197615,
0.5894862413,
-0.2704832852,
-0.7134127617,
0.3072996438,
0.5060586929,
0.974620223,
-0.0558905154,
0.0215277113,
-0.0782864019,
0.443993181,
-0.180012688,
-0.1199556962,
-0.181127876,
-0.5651151538,
-0.2561022937,
-0.240236938,
-0.4814661741,
0.4975241721,
-0.2580854297,
0.1468197554,
-0.4335133135,
0.0816510022,
0.1046352386,
0.1604965925,
-0.6211590767,
0.0181886666,
0.0049867355,
0.66270715,
-0.7901174426,
1.0921766758,
0.346080929,
-0.377263397,
-0.4352198243,
0.4060700536,
0.3426004946,
-0.5872648954,
0.6900709271,
0.0249801073,
-0.5893005729,
-0.3069670498,
-0.6896553636,
-0.4768429995,
1.0272817612,
0.5546209216,
-0.7957620621,
0.0674415454,
0.3778519332,
0.8143548965,
-0.2132371962,
0.1818124801,
0.4136297107,
0.4831913114,
-0.1908944845,
-0.9988984466,
0.154579863,
-0.0715301856,
-0.2915412188,
0.0158191547,
-0.7667530179,
0.8459547162,
-0.137748152,
-0.1555282474,
0.1852766573,
0.4947149158,
-0.0635886863,
0.4192599356,
0.470302701,
0.5983350873,
0.8715022206,
-0.0211953241,
1.0237667561,
0.1163349524,
0.5800033808,
1.5276068449,
-0.5942319632,
0.5212694407,
0.3336988091,
0.107575722,
0.59335953,
0.3092167675,
-0.0730014816,
0.0598054118,
0.2394788712,
-0.0735628083,
-0.3584392071,
0.361879915,
-0.1980824172,
0.335282445,
0.2712276876,
-0.2065941393,
-0.362483114,
-0.3001451492,
-0.1386890113,
0.1659258008,
0.2175512016,
0.5792737603,
0.1779278517,
-0.7716497779,
0.6738194227,
0.2112265378,
0.4977874756,
-0.5863409042,
0.0212399028,
-0.2722250521,
0.3048080504,
-0.2371589094,
-1.2392839193,
0.2238868177,
0.1427438557,
0.0673165247,
-0.3694951832,
0.6742261052,
-0.1727026254,
-0.1613628417,
0.4705509245,
0.5038455129,
0.1895306259,
-0.1474022269,
-0.9366167188,
-0.1143875122,
-0.2511232495,
-0.034326151,
0.2826010287,
0.61109972,
-0.0677236989,
0.6910583377,
0.6284291744,
-0.0709340721,
-0.1722814441,
0.0887757167,
0.8022165895,
-0.65746665,
-0.4252098799,
-0.8717340231,
-0.0571479686,
-0.051997859,
-0.4912976325,
0.9433757663,
0.6112033725,
0.9590092301,
0.0985407382,
0.8606377244,
0.1622678936,
0.6577360034,
-0.4291360974,
0.5221120715,
-0.7357123494,
0.4390439093,
-0.2625982463,
-0.418240577,
-0.2136208862,
0.335778892,
-0.6120888591,
0.0772823021,
0.7576566339,
0.7407468557,
-0.2212342471,
0.1742537916,
0.2949501276,
0.4956097603,
0.565438509,
0.5169658065,
0.9607911706,
-0.2468240559,
0.5644564033,
-0.1548756361,
-0.1595660448,
-0.0829340219,
-0.9846866131,
-0.9215521812,
-0.8910517693,
-0.0881383121,
-0.3808819056,
0.1445915103,
0.7303557396,
0.5504084229,
-0.6404248476,
-0.2147759497,
-0.4417110085,
0.3413582742,
0.1379391998,
-0.1031050831,
0.3397549987,
-0.1086788327,
-0.5504020452,
0.3313529193,
0.27859357,
0.1927777827,
-0.5283074379,
-0.268104881,
-0.1737970412,
0.1091309413,
0.1503632218,
0.539444387,
-0.8442023396,
-0.158698529,
-0.2878234982,
-0.2122799158,
0.0486025847,
1.2989262342,
-0.5797618032,
0.5322703719,
0.5322570801,
0.5323228836,
0.6099517345,
0.1891971678,
0.44004336,
-0.7220185399,
-0.313026309,
0.2674754262,
0.3858937323,
0.4657952785,
-0.3635037541,
0.3188617229,
0.5165022016,
-0.7696223855,
-0.4835894108,
0.3662241101,
-0.9741067886,
-0.655146718,
1.0395718813,
-0.3878808022,
-0.1987596601,
-0.3928728104,
-0.0720947236,
0.3370274305,
-0.04292164,
0.8729150295,
0.7552828193,
-0.4103520811,
0.1434313208,
-0.6839582324,
0.4215491414,
0.5648832917,
-1.053635478,
0.4967627525,
0.5484358072,
0.572378993,
0.30736202,
0.5575504899,
-0.1331356168,
0.0700735375,
-0.1761055887,
-0.2119477689,
-0.260953635,
-0.2093885094,
-0.5987964272,
-0.0919975489,
-0.0370467417,
0.1509563327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09180v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09180v1
|
PEARL: Personalizing Large Language Model Writing Assistants with Generation-Calibrated Retrievers
| 2023-11-15T18:19:58 | 2023-11-15T18:19:58 |
Sheshera Mysore, Zhuoran Lu, Mengting Wan, Longqi Yang, Steve Menezes, Tina Baghaee, Emmanuel Barajas Gonzalez, Jennifer Neville, Tara Safavi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR
|
Powerful large language models have facilitated the development of writing
assistants that promise to significantly improve the quality and efficiency of
composition and communication. However, a barrier to effective assistance is
the lack of personalization in LLM outputs to the author's communication style
and specialized knowledge. In this paper, we address this challenge by
proposing PEARL, a retrieval-augmented LLM writing assistant personalized with
a generation-calibrated retriever. Our retriever is trained to select historic
user-authored documents for prompt augmentation, such that they are likely to
best personalize LLM generations for a user request. We propose two key
novelties for training our retriever: 1) A training data selection method that
identifies user requests likely to benefit from personalization and documents
that provide that benefit; and 2) A scale-calibrating KL-divergence objective
that ensures that our retriever closely tracks the benefit of a document for
personalized generation. We demonstrate the effectiveness of PEARL in
generating personalized workplace social media posts and Reddit comments.
Finally, we showcase the potential of a generation-calibrated retriever to
double as a performance predictor and further improve low-quality generations
via LLM chaining.
|
[
0.0363543332,
-0.6987510324,
0.6498298049,
0.2359637171,
0.0371648036,
0.4983959794,
-0.3594919741,
-0.4069629312,
0.5196262002,
0.5071196556,
-0.5546031594,
-0.3585297763,
-0.4106437266,
0.3681927919,
-0.1765551418,
0.8170835376,
0.1443505287,
0.052941978,
-0.2775021791,
0.1273584217,
-0.8886681795,
-0.4078016877,
-0.7718917131,
-0.3262418807,
0.7017124891,
0.5437813401,
0.5235852599,
0.6590754986,
0.391327709,
0.287460506,
-0.0938011855,
0.3572777212,
-0.8122246265,
0.2822283804,
-0.2744481862,
-0.7624555826,
-0.7554728389,
-0.2300712466,
0.3619172275,
0.7642111182,
0.142753616,
0.0931149051,
0.2385300845,
0.8023124337,
-0.7303081751,
-0.01558029,
-0.7592383027,
0.1765046269,
-0.3982754648,
-0.4243814945,
-0.6451115608,
-0.5601109862,
0.0427026339,
-0.7091963291,
0.3822464943,
0.0407705978,
0.5741475821,
-0.2784969807,
-0.300234884,
-0.447819382,
-0.7148143649,
0.8989263773,
-0.5313147306,
0.3459560871,
0.5842228532,
0.2187021971,
0.1307056546,
-0.6060256958,
-0.3580254316,
-0.2065193802,
0.0949247256,
0.1673281491,
0.2678911388,
-0.0684522241,
0.0235364959,
0.7258514166,
-0.3618298471,
0.1820384264,
-0.200863421,
-0.1842190772,
0.8148884773,
0.2339218855,
0.3287365139,
0.1599708796,
0.1521976888,
-0.0447133519,
-0.8214161396,
-0.1253748536,
0.620351851,
0.4615031779,
-0.1011570096,
0.4703189433,
-0.4625659585,
0.5956648588,
0.1276376992,
-0.1555420905,
0.3791351616,
-0.1360019892,
0.1146033257,
0.1299555451,
0.5204843879,
0.2214083672,
0.2954757214,
-0.4245090783,
-0.3371879756,
-0.3995867968,
0.2530817688,
-0.7190474868,
-0.3690070808,
-0.1933700144,
-0.4271499515,
-0.7301461101,
0.0730321482,
-0.7215033174,
-0.8282600641,
-0.3813816011,
0.2948958874,
-0.178475216,
-0.0849508196,
-0.141919449,
-0.0214532819,
-0.104713209,
0.5012635589,
-1.3021019697,
0.0793275833,
0.5737921,
0.6799955368,
-0.0989374816,
-0.2690609097,
-0.857760489,
0.3358253539,
-0.4572168589,
0.6418180466,
-0.7192181349,
-0.7709390521,
0.3909744024,
-0.1748427451,
0.1964106411,
-0.596799612,
0.4385592937,
-0.6875857711,
0.145126164,
-0.5440633297,
-0.398910284,
0.2956531346,
0.2315085977,
-0.5724258423,
0.7036978602,
0.1791699231,
-0.5515852571,
0.361273706,
-0.4552228749,
-0.5121317506,
0.2983492017,
-0.0620140992,
-0.4887143075,
0.2133063227,
0.2868853211,
0.5357092619,
-0.1866159588,
0.0026782248,
-0.5345623493,
-0.4146479666,
0.3372371197,
-0.5033614039,
0.3887461126,
0.2290505171,
0.1794543862,
-0.00980761,
-1.0934185982,
-0.1248063669,
0.2594864964,
-1.089987874,
-0.2491970807,
-0.2163151801,
0.0257036686,
-0.4187485278,
0.7562642097,
-0.7687057257,
0.2251112312,
-0.3916424811,
0.043166969,
0.8534502983,
0.0816180184,
0.4950762391,
-0.4838065207,
0.4595814049,
-0.3168960512,
-0.1816436499,
-0.4719450772,
-0.0285265315,
-0.85928756,
-0.0645947531,
0.1842241883,
0.4313335419,
-0.6558334231,
0.4918714166,
-0.3888294995,
-0.3242211342,
-0.6447340846,
0.6464988589,
0.5594261289,
0.7326824665,
0.3336403966,
-0.2642219365,
-0.6161517501,
-0.7243247628,
-0.5834317803,
0.1438843459,
-0.0359980464,
0.3105961382,
-0.2080242187,
-0.159067288,
0.9871849418,
-0.6953859925,
-0.3548955321,
-0.5119329691,
0.1819718033,
0.1947590113,
0.3778431714,
0.0880951136,
-0.7301380038,
-0.7529185414,
0.174926579,
-0.7747936249,
-0.4059120715,
-0.3289297223,
-0.240075767,
-0.0548211597,
0.5314768553,
-0.2950408757,
0.2436657399,
0.1666682214,
-0.0527862348,
0.4799964726,
-0.4101409912,
-0.000976868,
-1.361338377,
0.2151326388,
0.1143985614,
-0.4249179959,
-0.700173974,
0.0062297364,
0.27078107,
-0.2151410133,
-0.0438611507,
0.5348566771,
-0.6065651774,
-0.0421896018,
-0.3412255049,
0.1750364751,
0.0143525768,
0.2353883833,
0.0484022871,
0.8802441955,
0.0661674067,
-0.401794374,
0.2152762115,
0.5670866966,
0.0604448728,
0.9250528216,
-0.6086556315,
0.5161556005,
-0.1465933621,
-0.0651542246,
-0.7178433537,
-0.2868733704,
-0.3388397396,
-0.3387048244,
0.5331359506,
0.0800297782,
-0.4826385975,
-0.315279305,
-0.6421873569,
-0.0759278759,
0.4029916823,
-0.6931681037,
0.5479813218,
0.0088003092,
-0.3757609129,
-0.3571290374,
-0.9714999795,
0.2768619061,
0.01392591,
-0.4554155171,
0.3742871284,
-0.37513569,
0.0451284498,
-0.3200554848,
0.1527467072,
0.1572665721,
0.1047462597,
0.2780285478,
0.3387419581,
-0.1670686901,
0.1081025526,
0.2454794496,
-0.1367379427,
-0.1191619337,
0.3198413551,
0.6520447135,
0.099977687,
-0.3803274333,
-0.3687298596,
0.0253628343,
0.1483608633,
-0.3878029585,
0.6445760727,
0.552128911,
-0.0693882182,
-0.3146080375,
-0.8770444393,
-0.1829373389,
-0.5341505408,
0.3186040819,
-0.4379248321,
-0.7271760702,
0.244644627,
-0.1341263652,
0.1263265312,
0.1429745406,
0.5614048243,
0.0747540295,
1.0011553764,
0.7863559723,
-0.4342715442,
0.6691273451,
-0.2388635427,
0.2340447307,
-1.247351408,
-0.106975235,
-0.1914343238,
-0.2544069588,
-0.1090722606,
0.2020159215,
0.1623585075,
0.1411907971,
-0.1448169053,
0.2468049973,
-0.4727661312,
0.6149144173,
0.7973992229,
0.1712664813,
0.6175058484,
-0.1444418132,
0.0837066397,
-0.1253213137,
-0.3564186692,
-0.7580906153,
1.314682126,
0.2837583125,
0.9829687476,
0.0429218411,
0.9955895543,
0.5211685896,
0.416323185,
-0.3387589455,
0.6162033677,
-0.1519021988,
-0.3174276948,
-0.0126312589,
-0.4272834957,
-1.0010203123,
0.1055827811,
-0.2896242738,
-0.8923960924,
0.0521178357,
0.4342712164,
-0.3713220358,
0.1667669863,
-0.6461301446,
0.7450351119,
-0.0973649025,
-0.5595734715,
-0.2220502347,
-0.4614635408,
0.3933540583,
-0.4269769192,
-0.0010804251,
0.0002756645,
0.078701593,
0.3837771118,
-0.4943585396,
0.9161143303,
0.0035726076,
-0.0165894069,
-0.0492831469,
0.4541370571,
0.692498982,
0.0301298834,
-0.3952028155,
-0.5004370809,
-0.3184562325,
-0.0588810891,
-0.2034096718,
1.0370323658,
-0.6877211928,
-0.5655015111,
-0.0369309597,
-0.7040879726,
-0.4435821176,
0.4438022077,
0.2411057651,
0.5325185061,
-0.2211077511,
0.3724427521,
0.6125875711,
-0.2878044844,
0.4661099911,
0.5154622793,
-0.1100124717,
-0.5553365946,
1.3013211489,
-0.0286661629,
0.2177840769,
0.6231617928,
0.1810575724,
-0.2082884163,
-0.4392111003,
-0.3477624357,
0.3210735917,
-0.8266569376,
-0.2769017816,
-0.4819773138,
-0.0841987059,
-0.3452913165,
-0.713927865,
-0.1092449874,
-0.0855673179,
-1.0465809107,
-0.0129942968,
0.1837610751,
0.6267284155,
0.1030951366,
0.4626961648,
-0.8429204822,
0.2420656383,
0.3494583368,
0.1551447958,
0.1400088221,
-0.4580996037,
-0.2679619789,
0.1014187112,
-0.6717141867,
-0.7137323022,
0.359020561,
0.2754636109,
0.3184539974,
0.3088105619,
-0.0822646543,
0.5579081178,
-0.3854845166,
0.7223368883,
0.111822933,
-0.8288767934,
0.7235630155,
-0.4011657536,
0.2583373785,
0.7858766317,
0.0993327275,
-0.5740600228,
-0.3283573985,
-0.3212399781,
-0.5772114396,
0.6228731275,
-0.2118967772,
0.5033246875,
0.069370687,
0.4265457988,
0.1019494385,
0.3822430372,
-0.6770188808,
0.2137864977,
0.2614388168,
-0.5234247446,
-0.0250431858,
-0.4405626655,
0.0890365541,
0.2270444036,
0.8029965162,
-0.1771328002,
-0.2139407843,
0.1687540859,
-0.3192477226,
-0.3314503729,
0.1336145401,
0.244067058,
0.8350587487,
-0.1970988661,
0.0845908672,
0.3861961365,
-0.4854102135,
-0.0284155104,
0.1633205116,
-0.3168882728,
-0.1976310164,
0.4441820681,
0.5276530981,
0.1622177511,
-0.6089496613,
0.6253774166,
0.083055824,
0.1083925962,
-0.3232709169,
0.2569917142,
0.1689996123,
0.1624524593,
0.3179731369,
-0.180406034,
0.0672316477,
-0.5029961467,
-0.2366350591,
0.4856134653,
-0.206531778,
-0.389580071,
0.8978473544,
0.4425398111,
-0.6007747054,
0.5498790741,
-0.3099575937,
-0.1582835317,
0.1096761003,
0.65760988,
0.8235260248,
-0.2374947667,
0.0710706785,
0.0672977418,
-0.0506018698,
0.0016675132,
0.3471836448,
-0.0569708347,
-0.4816968143,
-0.0540305041,
-0.7392383218,
-0.4253577888,
0.0565996841,
-0.5365597606,
0.4255689085,
-0.4955133498,
-0.13555336,
-0.1491962373,
0.116649434,
-0.6626606584,
0.0149742281,
-0.0186119135,
0.7885824442,
-0.6551094055,
0.5529859066,
0.5053389668,
-0.6589933038,
-0.5022362471,
-0.1139822751,
0.0268518906,
-0.7515650988,
0.5998185873,
0.0841250792,
-0.0525819026,
0.1558267474,
-0.1801838726,
-0.6837680936,
1.4328807592,
0.3250054717,
-0.7396037579,
-0.0498748496,
0.3102064729,
0.527921319,
-0.2912476957,
0.1744147241,
0.4634255171,
-0.0156757701,
-0.0602161847,
-0.8484244943,
-0.0010207588,
-0.239367336,
0.7037822008,
-0.0111393249,
-0.7703416944,
0.7188750505,
-0.1100180149,
0.0176113918,
0.5410859585,
0.691262722,
0.4905522466,
0.3046745956,
0.2202574909,
0.5619053245,
0.8488152027,
0.1268453598,
1.2041525841,
-0.4715016484,
0.1095771044,
1.1607662439,
-0.3635071516,
0.9210875034,
0.2895883918,
-0.0969275385,
0.4585505724,
0.3851850331,
-0.0354675055,
0.4618808627,
0.064957574,
-0.6431232691,
0.0901516452,
-0.2381910831,
-0.2713240087,
-0.2375138402,
0.0496033877,
-0.7490538955,
0.0499765724,
0.0904754251,
0.1783416569,
0.439689666,
-0.3955637217,
0.8789827228,
0.0046859877,
-0.4806978106,
0.2233897299,
0.0520203486,
0.7367097735,
-0.5810831189,
0.0468421392,
-0.4182962775,
0.464317292,
-0.3839557171,
-0.7824323177,
-0.1181401908,
0.0768171102,
-0.1114137173,
-0.3135306835,
1.0365134478,
-0.6521607041,
-0.5400791168,
-0.1798779815,
0.3546705544,
-0.1018894464,
-0.0347680263,
-0.3077597022,
0.4035270214,
-0.0121276882,
-0.3909040689,
0.2538116276,
0.2137408257,
0.3567372859,
0.6378647089,
0.8782374263,
0.4443475306,
0.0929211527,
0.3904254138,
0.8070802093,
-0.2527273595,
-0.5101779103,
-0.8485579491,
0.4759936333,
-0.370844543,
-0.4526157677,
0.8721026778,
0.9395901561,
0.7348419428,
-0.3097736835,
0.9033126235,
0.3208832741,
0.9088341594,
-0.4322837591,
0.6904588342,
-0.4746069908,
0.4097582996,
-0.2678551674,
-1.1532759666,
-0.1982363611,
0.46419397,
-0.5679152012,
0.212728098,
0.2750827372,
1.0307856798,
-0.2844001651,
-0.0623043478,
0.2340511978,
-0.0334191471,
0.6932402849,
0.4357430935,
0.6739848852,
-0.1208393946,
0.476878345,
-0.4392347038,
-0.0819830373,
-0.5109030008,
-0.7008492351,
-0.9412674904,
-0.4360248744,
-0.1873413771,
-0.222491771,
0.1165138483,
0.9885817766,
0.6371157169,
-0.3930283487,
-0.3377538621,
-0.3104341924,
-0.1816231608,
0.4059531093,
-0.2599325776,
0.133585006,
-0.6945772767,
-0.6896201968,
0.5892823339,
0.2735889852,
0.1877683401,
-0.432341367,
-0.222623691,
0.1372169554,
-0.0487536937,
0.5842036605,
0.3432900012,
-0.4694880545,
-0.1195907444,
-0.1892759502,
-0.154216677,
0.1235555485,
0.6280577183,
-0.53864187,
0.7750766277,
0.4702011049,
1.000831604,
0.675778389,
0.1533416361,
0.6110541224,
-1.0766862631,
-0.2443612665,
0.1581084132,
0.369089216,
0.7402601838,
-0.6823773384,
0.4237940311,
0.1730639338,
-0.6897553802,
-0.8177598119,
0.0445260666,
-0.6983166933,
0.0176437553,
1.039573431,
-0.044599358,
-0.1294020414,
0.2878789902,
-0.6443181038,
0.0752190873,
-0.4207834601,
0.9156680107,
0.4950324297,
0.0555903316,
-0.1523880512,
-0.5383339524,
0.3202247322,
0.3679767549,
-1.0454066992,
0.1674366295,
0.4181111157,
0.2968557477,
0.1941646636,
0.8936148882,
0.1247397587,
0.2445977181,
-0.1529704183,
0.051238317,
-0.2395121455,
-0.099759914,
-0.3712742031,
0.0129889138,
0.5157629251,
-0.0571741126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10768v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10768v1
|
Memory Augmented Language Models through Mixture of Word Experts
| 2023-11-15T18:19:56 | 2023-11-15T18:19:56 |
Cicero Nogueira dos Santos, James Lee-Thorp, Isaac Noble, Chung-Ching Chang, David Uthus
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Scaling up the number of parameters of language models has proven to be an
effective approach to improve performance. For dense models, increasing model
size proportionally increases the model's computation footprint. In this work,
we seek to aggressively decouple learning capacity and FLOPs through
Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) style models with large knowledge-rich vocabulary
based routing functions and experts. Our proposed approach, dubbed Mixture of
Word Experts (MoWE), can be seen as a memory augmented model, where a large set
of word-specific experts play the role of a sparse memory. We demonstrate that
MoWE performs significantly better than the T5 family of models with similar
number of FLOPs in a variety of NLP tasks. Additionally, MoWE outperforms
regular MoE models on knowledge intensive tasks and has similar performance to
more complex memory augmented approaches that often require to invoke custom
mechanisms to search the sparse memory.
|
[
-0.5984914899,
-0.7962654233,
0.2342057079,
0.1133518964,
0.0346658006,
0.3725601435,
-0.3774637878,
-0.458232373,
0.5654301047,
0.6861469746,
-0.1357407719,
0.022275731,
-0.7079185843,
-0.3415669799,
-0.4646607935,
0.4558020532,
0.2266922593,
-0.0716883317,
-0.2261825055,
-0.438300997,
-0.7112360597,
-0.2018652558,
-0.4978763163,
-0.4879106879,
0.3083728552,
0.2206012756,
0.8113230467,
0.5995250344,
0.1267278641,
0.33005476,
-0.0346184671,
0.5408855081,
-0.6418229938,
-0.118056871,
-0.4462400079,
-0.2150094956,
-0.7270787954,
-0.1096479967,
0.2147251815,
0.9759885669,
-0.6045371294,
-0.3368582726,
0.0183484685,
0.4556337893,
-0.8311174512,
-0.1834077984,
-1.1520334482,
-0.2759149075,
-0.0200729482,
-0.3261205554,
-0.3606741428,
0.2469110936,
0.3247653246,
-0.6204266548,
0.2491333634,
0.2555597723,
0.5785153508,
0.1167742684,
-0.1870723963,
-0.2219340205,
-0.6682705283,
1.1098883152,
-0.8753144145,
0.4836189747,
0.5370859504,
-0.0792805403,
-0.3568878174,
-0.0873149484,
-0.6932729483,
0.0031802095,
0.3984303474,
0.1293744445,
0.0246502068,
0.1977039129,
-0.1238328516,
0.5762547851,
-0.1342636794,
0.2687539458,
-0.3762729466,
-0.2020549774,
0.8096081614,
0.1081025228,
0.4461539984,
0.2408198118,
-0.3227760494,
0.1549299955,
-0.3578628898,
-0.418676585,
0.3793686926,
-0.0023202798,
0.0470391326,
0.5604705811,
-0.2379940152,
1.0362417698,
0.0594775714,
-0.6640657187,
0.081803672,
0.0267583746,
-0.1245903671,
-0.1318186074,
0.7244451642,
0.4093963802,
0.2388249636,
-0.5513123274,
-0.5529747009,
-0.2475555241,
0.2822026312,
-0.5562011003,
-0.6385299563,
0.1547112167,
-0.2905348241,
-0.2463104725,
-0.2472026199,
-0.7926520705,
-0.4827777743,
-0.2195554227,
0.9158539176,
-0.9924733043,
-0.7286333442,
0.4046554267,
-0.4205206931,
-0.2568674684,
0.3036278188,
-1.1188651323,
0.4981189668,
0.6035984159,
0.624728322,
-0.3220023811,
-0.2378405035,
-0.5548111796,
0.4325323999,
-0.3364564478,
0.607657969,
-0.9171634316,
-0.8130053282,
-0.048799023,
-0.8889597654,
-0.2677514553,
-0.9384778738,
-0.047528822,
-0.7767769694,
0.1479710042,
-0.2491860837,
-0.7504875064,
-0.487309128,
0.3433617055,
-0.5547266006,
1.2497155666,
0.2855674326,
-0.6263388395,
0.2884809673,
-0.4956548214,
-0.3950513005,
0.1342755854,
-0.2190039158,
0.3396077156,
0.3378200233,
0.269310236,
0.6117938757,
-0.2229997665,
0.214387387,
-0.2834915519,
-0.2972940505,
0.2735773325,
-0.3167248368,
0.5593388081,
0.0557092056,
0.0163511727,
-0.0372596569,
-1.2450134754,
-0.0133633493,
-0.0737872049,
-0.6531139016,
-0.7885466814,
0.1268021762,
-0.2011714876,
-0.0057431357,
0.3653276861,
-0.3040176332,
0.1968239695,
-0.1717345566,
0.4544760585,
0.6014244556,
0.0161098577,
0.5564234853,
-0.3183616698,
0.3608104885,
0.3777017295,
-0.3939662874,
-0.0605390817,
-0.6101410985,
-1.0135660172,
-0.438954711,
0.5464211106,
0.5485896468,
-1.1323933601,
0.4756107032,
-0.4451766908,
-0.5579837561,
-0.7292385697,
0.4908528328,
0.2220478058,
0.6999030113,
0.5562343001,
-0.3556711674,
-0.1468528658,
-0.8821154833,
-0.2034515142,
-0.2035931051,
-0.0922591537,
0.4619243443,
0.2457580715,
-0.2907450199,
1.0265458822,
-0.5254950523,
0.0756130144,
-0.3570379615,
0.2159125656,
-0.232765913,
0.4363628626,
0.4789440334,
-0.633680284,
-0.1003041863,
0.016646225,
-0.3257251382,
-0.1007994935,
0.0331137367,
-0.13820903,
-0.0216136165,
0.1967779249,
-0.3538885713,
0.0194664542,
0.7842117548,
-0.0595219322,
0.5754233599,
-0.4066587687,
-0.0068684402,
-1.1358155012,
-0.2666086257,
0.132634595,
-0.1037428603,
-0.4845168889,
0.3459762335,
-0.0457265526,
-0.0960068703,
-0.12068367,
0.6037618518,
-0.5624958873,
0.0577208363,
-0.5053008199,
0.165460825,
0.0107111577,
0.4926325679,
0.0076707895,
0.9471949935,
0.7032181025,
-0.9759988785,
0.1509112716,
-0.1547736377,
-0.4183323085,
0.2721305788,
-0.4871917367,
0.0757707506,
0.1699466556,
-0.2294775844,
-1.0423004627,
-0.2811728418,
-0.2707722783,
-0.2295806706,
0.4078130126,
0.1148401573,
-0.5757862926,
-0.1411840618,
-0.0593926571,
0.358790338,
0.6141793132,
-0.2854499221,
1.0840374231,
0.6585359573,
0.0412912071,
-0.3977209628,
-0.7364258766,
0.0466925949,
-0.0616642125,
-0.794850111,
0.5677733421,
0.0939079374,
-0.378108561,
0.0479127392,
0.074255608,
-0.4289424717,
0.0713782087,
-0.1394018829,
0.1165336519,
-0.3119198978,
0.1209259406,
0.1240983084,
0.033435639,
-0.2191712558,
-0.2293261886,
0.8702311516,
0.1617943048,
-0.0492647365,
0.0941376463,
0.5947848558,
0.6719846129,
-0.4558817744,
1.0227913857,
0.6878072619,
-0.3705976903,
-0.2369598895,
-1.1744918823,
-0.0207761377,
-0.4810918272,
0.4134297669,
-0.4280465543,
-0.7880609632,
0.700412333,
-0.1499692053,
0.1541103572,
0.47366786,
0.4111297131,
0.0349620208,
0.684736371,
0.8445982933,
-0.3822192848,
0.3079869449,
-0.3157886565,
0.1974660009,
-0.9171161056,
-0.1626545042,
-0.0719707459,
-0.5409112573,
-0.1707196534,
-0.8045161366,
0.3067624569,
0.4200685322,
0.1382890195,
0.207343787,
-0.1949000508,
0.2711271048,
0.6311020255,
0.2844712734,
0.2335187495,
0.1980656087,
-0.3908832371,
0.1023942009,
-1.2629131079,
-0.1184685603,
0.8991978168,
0.1848233342,
0.75990659,
-0.0600382537,
0.606269002,
0.1154092476,
-0.0237141624,
-0.7301002145,
0.9903646111,
-0.1829507351,
-0.4297183752,
-0.1284768432,
-0.4454344213,
-0.5247365236,
0.4016374946,
-0.4270579815,
-0.6611700058,
0.2878780365,
0.2117518187,
-0.465767771,
0.752157867,
-0.8006047606,
0.2290869504,
-0.0041952012,
-0.271432519,
-0.7550340891,
-0.1724609882,
0.5438489914,
-0.0120807663,
0.2586079836,
-0.0016374977,
-0.5908578634,
0.8884028196,
-0.6575922966,
0.6755802631,
0.0393521488,
-0.084329702,
0.4094879627,
0.3171189725,
0.402869463,
-0.4406041801,
-0.3722997904,
0.2705118656,
-0.5977379084,
-0.5527206063,
-0.5793164372,
0.8596383929,
-0.8619240522,
-0.5797995329,
0.2216017991,
-0.9381792545,
-0.6307093501,
0.0591209754,
0.2394132018,
0.7370297909,
0.2832051516,
0.1909435391,
1.0250309706,
-0.1790078282,
0.4850043356,
0.6578269005,
-0.2087628096,
-0.5774018168,
1.2253986597,
0.5350517035,
0.3249863684,
0.4242707789,
0.2713835835,
0.0836769119,
-0.8738365173,
-0.4046376348,
-0.0551524311,
-0.2674427927,
0.0553799458,
-1.0544188023,
-0.1534293145,
-0.1588506997,
-0.2170471102,
-0.5991014242,
-0.3694773316,
-0.2082499862,
0.1191452593,
0.5999821424,
0.5178362131,
0.1141787916,
0.5234017372,
-0.8992248774,
0.2533451915,
0.3951024711,
0.396382302,
0.5561001301,
-0.6204138994,
-0.3470976651,
-0.1409848779,
-0.2549006045,
-0.8477755189,
0.3481806517,
0.2322622389,
0.6231946945,
0.8398192525,
-0.1746568829,
1.181201458,
-0.5583519936,
0.8956634998,
0.3444890678,
-0.7606981993,
0.1646715254,
-0.6506881118,
0.0160495695,
0.4048196375,
0.2932806611,
-0.174190253,
-0.3864535093,
-0.7945070863,
-1.0554209948,
0.1252132654,
-0.0770587102,
0.3005670309,
-0.1371527314,
0.1968385577,
0.4141097665,
0.4060604572,
-0.0616201982,
-0.0844925568,
0.1880495548,
-0.077043958,
0.173488304,
-0.6098273993,
0.0108653056,
-0.4025608003,
0.685400486,
0.1570033878,
0.1374903917,
-0.1999799013,
-0.0806697011,
-0.0129820956,
0.1800236255,
0.5306534171,
0.8821604252,
-0.0296720397,
-0.050146658,
0.3136618435,
-0.5965973735,
-0.1518775523,
-0.2248533964,
-0.2628003359,
-0.00407709,
0.4440541267,
0.7000259161,
0.6784199476,
-0.7515800595,
0.1510701925,
0.4612563252,
-0.2893771231,
0.079694517,
0.6757029295,
0.3058671653,
-0.0574640557,
0.6070421338,
0.4729109406,
0.1117810011,
-0.5868405104,
0.1053386331,
0.3303417265,
-0.1228711531,
-0.1982975006,
0.5290029645,
0.6037777662,
-0.4256019294,
0.4952921271,
-0.1484700292,
-0.589132905,
0.1912679523,
0.5097260475,
0.5392976999,
-0.3596604764,
-0.1897787303,
0.0705685839,
0.1585940123,
-0.3153764307,
0.3236320019,
0.0419776775,
-1.1170915365,
-0.6208150387,
-0.3973166347,
-0.2801695466,
0.3733819425,
-0.6788461804,
-0.073155202,
-0.4524003565,
-0.0145620471,
-0.3824955821,
-0.0036864269,
-0.4491867125,
0.3805441558,
-0.1255876422,
1.1290181875,
-0.5788899064,
0.9376701713,
0.7788003683,
-0.0774913356,
-0.870459199,
0.1060884073,
-0.3786944151,
-0.8870666623,
0.2274313569,
-0.0483497679,
0.010408869,
0.0560206845,
-0.3227087259,
-0.6940091848,
0.8718381524,
0.0987224281,
-0.6841034889,
-0.0077289185,
-0.2491708994,
0.2921904027,
-0.3627761602,
0.1706658453,
0.4076248407,
0.0943782553,
0.1864380687,
-0.7892267704,
-0.3821922243,
-0.1304889619,
0.0585216545,
0.2163167149,
-0.8397163749,
0.935893178,
-0.1149230674,
0.2778325379,
-0.1860881746,
1.2873616219,
0.4671165347,
0.1086925566,
0.7774516344,
0.9206464291,
1.0321902037,
0.317861706,
1.0501887798,
-0.4817319512,
-0.1267866194,
1.0262374878,
-0.1589799374,
1.2378560305,
0.3473273218,
-0.1848252416,
0.5724111199,
0.3120589554,
0.3316655159,
0.503922224,
-0.1845206022,
-0.3586543202,
-0.6154831052,
0.0302262008,
-0.2643977702,
0.294110924,
0.6514905691,
-0.143860504,
-0.1267948449,
0.1273001581,
-0.1178050414,
0.2062641382,
-0.7262965441,
0.6040910482,
-0.0401556492,
-0.5496457219,
0.296010375,
0.3297601342,
1.1042699814,
-0.5525563955,
0.055815313,
-0.0458589494,
0.0652794093,
-0.0326060504,
-0.7089039683,
0.0146732647,
-0.2343968004,
-0.3746844828,
0.1448670477,
1.0276756287,
-0.8481236696,
-0.5827715397,
0.2789798975,
0.5061015487,
0.0574689843,
-0.1585384756,
-0.534350574,
-0.070361957,
-0.0806731582,
-0.1187847778,
0.4333307445,
0.568358779,
0.1736070216,
1.0492585897,
0.429169625,
0.2701948285,
0.5799281597,
-0.2523517013,
0.9220690131,
-0.3537012935,
-0.677087605,
-0.759347856,
0.4814366698,
-0.1415627599,
-0.3210838139,
0.7897201777,
0.6449522972,
0.6461184025,
-0.154418394,
0.6897717118,
-0.0284576118,
0.5230610371,
-0.5977927446,
0.7044158578,
-0.7398996949,
0.2045231611,
-0.0196014829,
-0.6452522278,
0.3943222165,
0.2764127553,
-0.3256932795,
0.2917311192,
0.1919946223,
0.7146405578,
-0.419683814,
-0.0723040104,
0.6067094803,
0.3321660161,
0.1371764392,
0.3887475133,
0.3908730745,
-0.2783196867,
0.3452194035,
-0.4394640923,
-0.2195001692,
-0.4529118538,
-0.74222368,
-0.9540708661,
-0.4650710225,
-0.502176106,
-0.1905482113,
-0.229868874,
0.8285406232,
0.8435394764,
-0.6378265023,
-0.0101883262,
0.0778361857,
0.0143886171,
-0.285300225,
-0.269318819,
0.2071279734,
-0.223554492,
-0.5987926126,
0.6503505111,
0.5519285798,
-0.1274644732,
-0.615858674,
-0.0448245369,
-0.1433411837,
0.538849175,
0.5904892683,
-0.0264851861,
-0.584153533,
0.027692318,
-0.2908158898,
0.0406466201,
-0.1634512991,
0.7195093036,
-0.8504532576,
0.5736793876,
0.6468033195,
0.8947443366,
-0.0785427094,
0.0061988467,
0.8502815962,
-0.7048385143,
0.3281993568,
0.201233685,
0.5871499777,
0.1958948225,
-0.2407654226,
0.3701248169,
0.4728401303,
-0.2319276333,
-0.5754096508,
-0.0511236005,
-1.2488247156,
-0.2438187152,
1.3154585361,
0.1025797799,
-0.2825573683,
-0.1119519472,
-0.1065904498,
-0.1884684265,
-0.4940318763,
0.8292778134,
1.0775663853,
0.1603837162,
-0.1905377507,
-0.7179887891,
-0.0823474005,
0.5243709087,
-0.2491074353,
-0.326518476,
0.2029948384,
0.4698132873,
0.2803468406,
0.6419649124,
0.0383604169,
-0.008333724,
0.2587675452,
0.0443168655,
-0.391084969,
-0.2873898447,
0.2693591416,
0.3806031644,
-0.1208269969,
-0.255087167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09179v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09179v1
|
SiRA: Sparse Mixture of Low Rank Adaptation
| 2023-11-15T18:15:37 | 2023-11-15T18:15:37 |
Yun Zhu, Nevan Wichers, Chu-Cheng Lin, Xinyi Wang, Tianlong Chen, Lei Shu, Han Lu, Canoee Liu, Liangchen Luo, Jindong Chen, Lei Meng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Parameter Efficient Tuning has been an prominent approach to adapt the Large
Language Model to downstream tasks. Most previous works considers adding the
dense trainable parameters, where all parameters are used to adapt certain
task. We found this less effective empirically using the example of LoRA that
introducing more trainable parameters does not help. Motivated by this we
investigate the importance of leveraging "sparse" computation and propose SiRA:
sparse mixture of low rank adaption. SiRA leverages the Sparse Mixture of
Expert(SMoE) to boost the performance of LoRA. Specifically it enforces the top
$k$ experts routing with a capacity limit restricting the maximum number of
tokens each expert can process. We propose a novel and simple expert dropout on
top of gating network to reduce the over-fitting issue. Through extensive
experiments, we verify SiRA performs better than LoRA and other mixture of
expert approaches across different single tasks and multitask settings.
|
[
-0.5827994347,
-0.7026154399,
0.4817792475,
0.1186872274,
-0.1798610538,
0.0575144552,
-0.1814721525,
-0.4185898006,
0.7025193572,
0.4535229504,
-0.6130415797,
0.1284197867,
-0.6012650728,
-0.2018054724,
-0.1908134222,
1.0146455765,
0.2984195054,
-0.2558039427,
0.0437033735,
-0.270845145,
-1.0261393785,
-0.2491202801,
-0.8393466473,
0.0486583151,
0.8336489797,
0.8549300432,
0.5215177536,
0.1996507943,
0.1650436223,
0.3470383883,
-0.0188036673,
0.4899200499,
-0.9064291716,
0.1042658091,
-0.1146760434,
-0.5183371902,
-0.4891101718,
-0.1534067988,
0.6668443084,
0.6134542823,
-0.2051832974,
-0.0523379445,
0.0552685708,
0.6374955177,
-0.819863379,
-0.3248325288,
-1.1229859591,
-0.3022043109,
-0.1452091336,
-0.2872017622,
-0.0244633164,
0.086599797,
-0.1146156415,
-0.8284310699,
0.0612669513,
0.0902908295,
0.5749850273,
0.7095001936,
-0.0185128488,
-0.0016849124,
-0.7525904179,
0.8827063441,
-0.7560971379,
0.228911683,
0.4201181829,
0.4559427202,
-0.1505610198,
-0.1742318571,
-0.367595166,
-0.074968949,
0.3803619742,
-0.0181785747,
0.1532355547,
-0.0943622813,
0.2342939824,
0.0456849933,
-0.1874147505,
0.3294048905,
-0.471876651,
0.3246571422,
0.4993157983,
-0.1109850332,
0.1418322921,
0.0013460804,
-0.0859719589,
0.2253270447,
-0.6853701472,
-0.0855984837,
0.1827150434,
0.428797096,
-0.0578141622,
0.2618353665,
-0.3498419821,
0.6465553641,
0.4043940306,
-0.4244986773,
-0.0747672692,
-0.0292036477,
-0.266531527,
-0.0350425169,
0.4551932216,
-0.0834144205,
0.0034859928,
-0.2972248495,
0.013935118,
-0.4364902675,
0.5956400037,
-0.6927690506,
-0.373701185,
-0.0668695867,
-0.1106822044,
-0.1115864441,
-0.2556481361,
-0.8677946925,
-0.6122531295,
-0.1095841229,
0.7646204829,
-0.1766858399,
0.0119633032,
-0.1112300828,
0.0270719677,
0.0944121853,
0.5786908865,
-1.1961512566,
0.5298976302,
0.5779468417,
0.9162170887,
-0.2008402497,
-0.5736035109,
-0.9417088628,
0.2878323197,
-0.165361464,
0.9432761073,
-0.3694866002,
-0.2761271894,
-0.6344280243,
-0.0239977203,
-0.6969216466,
-0.5579690337,
0.4496577382,
-0.4344602227,
0.0486611947,
-0.488642633,
-0.0094446279,
-0.4150196612,
-0.080481194,
-0.5519397855,
1.2081760168,
0.3518492281,
-0.4590204656,
0.5669934154,
-0.8018736839,
-0.5105473995,
0.2088184804,
-0.1415778995,
-0.1618179977,
0.3637339175,
0.4125187397,
0.3960300386,
-0.2409850955,
-0.2250514477,
-0.467700094,
-0.6563087702,
0.128594771,
-0.0616324134,
0.4560988843,
0.204907313,
-0.2536515296,
0.1336496621,
-0.7653467655,
0.0159278587,
-0.0627936274,
-0.3052437603,
-0.6331130266,
0.2474367321,
0.0325472094,
0.1771612167,
0.0488172024,
-0.1715675443,
0.2065031081,
-0.4851697087,
0.8333207369,
0.9988138676,
0.026117079,
0.4758744836,
-0.3936868608,
0.4127641618,
-0.1209861413,
-0.1167687029,
0.5664066076,
-0.7635654211,
-0.9057648778,
-0.6405231357,
0.4592788517,
0.5483642817,
-0.7205173373,
0.53949368,
-0.3216580451,
-0.382522881,
-0.7131718993,
0.5378972888,
-0.1645926535,
0.3615912497,
0.1159359217,
-0.3423632085,
-0.4435225129,
-0.707591176,
-0.0217991024,
0.0537263863,
0.1518850178,
0.5367206335,
0.3589269519,
-0.2496168017,
0.7998136282,
-0.5995014906,
-0.2752701938,
-0.2918384671,
0.0314560533,
0.2528794706,
0.7046545744,
0.8714225292,
-0.3763442039,
-0.5845404863,
0.2141980529,
-0.3745760918,
0.0527060255,
-0.3235736787,
-0.4854392111,
-0.2387353629,
0.1836876124,
-0.4505050778,
0.0655145571,
0.5927868485,
-0.0375961885,
0.1193537563,
-0.3705117106,
0.1874642074,
-1.3202780485,
0.0419572182,
-0.0223009549,
-0.4439309239,
-0.6445115805,
0.2687154412,
-0.3437465727,
-0.3415333629,
-0.0999713168,
0.4421133995,
-0.1968175471,
-0.3062529862,
-0.4574902952,
0.1017874926,
-0.1314735115,
0.6613610387,
-0.258518517,
1.1864416599,
0.51799196,
-0.5852465034,
0.0009662789,
0.2628048956,
-0.1748120189,
0.6470705867,
-0.7493111491,
0.3404719532,
-0.0134883318,
-0.2097518295,
-0.9617133737,
-0.2556106448,
0.1388249695,
-0.2853866816,
0.0890606046,
-0.2345647812,
-0.2183288038,
0.1005580947,
-0.3690850437,
0.3872076273,
0.5674478412,
-0.4034586251,
0.7224601507,
0.5756078362,
-0.5124095082,
-0.2509913743,
-0.5123556852,
0.2087226212,
-0.3974188864,
-0.4938113987,
0.176693514,
-0.4060001373,
-0.021895105,
-0.1821581274,
-0.0401232913,
-0.5461658835,
0.485480845,
0.3664685786,
-0.0829713941,
-0.3679916263,
-0.3944389522,
0.4518561363,
0.0070052836,
-0.4031414688,
0.0890624523,
0.302675128,
0.2268481255,
-0.2423045039,
-0.5258278251,
0.6692394018,
0.8167927861,
0.2098939419,
0.9863461852,
0.5603185296,
-0.3094707429,
-0.4038458765,
-0.6535758972,
-0.1375925243,
-0.5042625666,
0.4650100172,
-0.5215662718,
-0.7875366211,
0.6023409367,
0.0092362026,
-0.0663149804,
0.529733777,
0.492016077,
-0.1997607648,
0.8053472638,
0.7614991069,
-0.5348635912,
0.4982394576,
-0.1908784956,
0.3946811557,
-0.7368819714,
0.2203992903,
-0.9298953414,
-0.4724903703,
-0.5465399623,
-0.5852068663,
0.6587100625,
0.2039012015,
0.0941163749,
0.2300072312,
-0.3450623751,
0.4789355099,
0.7210714817,
0.1388460994,
0.024304552,
0.0984670371,
0.3208425343,
0.0227966998,
-1.1126312017,
0.1388214678,
0.6264690757,
0.2291676551,
0.8044002652,
-0.0277501103,
0.5644907355,
0.5109030604,
-0.1022443548,
-0.8372257948,
0.5458586812,
-0.4266084135,
-0.2401890755,
-0.4402745068,
-0.3809984028,
-0.6483351588,
0.3323844075,
-0.3539384007,
-0.6195702553,
0.5680328012,
-0.0293257684,
-0.7436611652,
0.1357951611,
-0.9521223307,
0.5281282663,
-0.0331553929,
-0.1264121085,
-0.401161164,
-0.3329617381,
0.2017154992,
-0.2612999678,
0.2364790738,
-0.0009777925,
-0.0555569716,
0.9442108274,
-0.5706116557,
0.9131708741,
-0.2814358771,
0.0476181209,
0.0422298238,
-0.0957358852,
0.8316474557,
-0.0279544909,
-0.1297482848,
-0.0348333269,
0.0612187535,
-0.7060483098,
-0.6818859577,
1.1941828728,
-1.2305984497,
-0.1451850086,
-0.1753084213,
-0.7345725298,
-0.6700656414,
0.0356822535,
0.0170100387,
0.2199529558,
0.1526789814,
0.1448114067,
0.6135383248,
0.0267729498,
0.1284768134,
0.2313056737,
0.4954338968,
-0.6767115593,
1.264824152,
0.2598461211,
0.1211635545,
0.1213911474,
0.1362869889,
-0.0063791312,
-0.9893686771,
-0.8081924915,
0.2661328316,
-0.5385292172,
0.0129618589,
-0.5070903897,
-0.2723104656,
-0.4554361701,
-0.4883103967,
-0.2738645077,
-0.6470251679,
-0.6552470326,
0.2930263579,
0.360694319,
0.7336603999,
0.2701141238,
0.7370449305,
-0.5726647973,
0.4944933355,
0.813100338,
0.2628139555,
0.1062701792,
-0.8455429673,
-0.5157364607,
-0.1246858165,
0.0231373012,
-0.7414401174,
0.258155793,
0.6069050431,
0.8584685922,
0.4898679256,
-0.1764292866,
1.1907929182,
-0.4584869146,
0.6561689973,
0.0219113361,
-0.8296979666,
0.2705944777,
-0.480769366,
0.0690428615,
0.8838508725,
0.1341784,
-0.2127820849,
-0.1512999982,
-0.2589832842,
-0.7269133925,
0.7131859064,
0.0044439351,
0.0484296493,
0.406637758,
0.4439543486,
0.3696093261,
0.2337776124,
-0.5305425525,
0.1327868104,
-0.1163185239,
-0.1527986825,
-0.1590059549,
-0.3862569928,
-0.1667330712,
-0.4289531112,
0.858879745,
-0.513862431,
0.2700870335,
-0.3167749047,
-0.1767609864,
-0.2987115681,
0.2361903638,
0.8374823332,
0.8116428256,
-0.1024930403,
-0.1316946149,
0.5773898363,
-0.4124345779,
-0.1985981315,
0.0645646453,
-0.4743708372,
-0.2729180455,
0.099433668,
0.9874975085,
0.5677825809,
-0.5373443365,
0.136726439,
0.2586877048,
-0.4337149858,
0.2314730585,
0.5191372633,
-0.1081444547,
0.060174752,
0.5032545924,
0.3591337502,
0.249382928,
-0.2902873158,
-0.2392223477,
0.4954358637,
-0.2124129385,
-0.2771162093,
0.5081577301,
0.372284025,
-0.1309591085,
-0.0392911099,
-0.0440023094,
-0.1846997589,
0.434192121,
0.3924997747,
0.8999421,
-0.0469567031,
0.2008608133,
-0.0207158234,
0.3395714462,
-0.0087271398,
0.2776181996,
-0.0830718428,
-0.3178758323,
-0.8317902088,
-0.5279326439,
-0.3989791572,
0.1468002051,
-0.3281773031,
-0.0276527498,
-0.6820375323,
0.1688926518,
-0.0067508537,
0.0288267247,
-0.2832199037,
0.0601695888,
-0.2151861638,
0.5928976536,
-0.9428001642,
0.7560412884,
0.7948134542,
-0.0753223523,
-0.6311815977,
-0.0541597754,
-0.3196426034,
-0.8556850553,
0.3654320538,
-0.2631118298,
-0.230977118,
-0.0420247726,
-0.416841805,
-0.87914294,
0.8378850222,
0.4060590863,
-0.306013912,
-0.1286611408,
-0.072611928,
0.3154898882,
-0.2163794637,
0.1074954271,
0.3150391579,
0.3500010967,
0.3631132841,
-0.9875671864,
-0.0361296646,
-0.0114132585,
0.0630772635,
0.1074792743,
-0.7547471523,
0.9183573723,
-0.0501606688,
0.2756439447,
0.3127295673,
0.639102757,
0.126924783,
0.3029780984,
0.7206094265,
0.6407715082,
0.8673830032,
0.3452258408,
0.6121388674,
-0.1256583035,
0.0252434406,
1.0068016052,
-0.3114394844,
0.9424099922,
0.4955739677,
-0.3250768185,
0.5330939889,
0.5674622655,
0.4454265237,
0.7711359859,
-0.1256764531,
-0.0977128223,
-0.3994044065,
0.0478948243,
-0.4609387219,
0.4212216139,
0.2932349741,
0.0721917972,
-0.150529623,
0.0116591239,
-0.2755762041,
-0.1979531646,
-0.6817166805,
0.9362947941,
-0.0640822053,
-0.5932074785,
0.8663555384,
0.0970738158,
0.7025297284,
-0.6332144141,
0.0238627791,
-0.1476315111,
-0.0856420025,
-0.1901983619,
-0.0314991809,
-0.0406611152,
-0.2539567053,
-0.3946483731,
0.150097236,
0.9283701777,
-0.1920161992,
-0.5322546363,
-0.1237235591,
0.7413832545,
0.1659769416,
-0.2003986537,
-0.7269386053,
-0.157829836,
-0.1500509828,
0.190655306,
0.8788921237,
0.4154424667,
0.0413068719,
0.6874160171,
0.721937418,
0.4670637846,
0.3419125676,
0.0043938565,
1.1636189222,
-0.5938091278,
-0.9582882524,
-0.1789370477,
0.1060245186,
-0.0120025128,
-0.2777093649,
0.7679441571,
0.1906225532,
0.3010453582,
-0.1393508762,
0.7930549383,
-0.0836667195,
0.6198132038,
-0.6559368372,
0.6317805052,
-0.7848035693,
0.1832612008,
-0.3654107153,
-0.8512058258,
0.1649354547,
0.6112492681,
-0.22438775,
0.3162238598,
0.5846379995,
0.689235568,
-0.3712222278,
-0.1348858774,
0.4946026504,
0.2080803066,
-0.0375936218,
0.6232907176,
0.4890627861,
-0.2663786709,
0.1680688858,
-0.2181695551,
-0.1497593522,
-0.6066247821,
-0.7227270603,
-0.9441877007,
-0.4498844743,
-0.2076518536,
-0.0515048951,
0.3330560923,
0.8244717121,
1.4208847284,
-1.014167428,
-0.1195189506,
0.090619497,
0.241900146,
-0.62548244,
-0.2193679363,
0.1757092327,
-0.3146558106,
-0.6235060096,
0.9753991961,
0.2749712467,
-0.2834080756,
-0.4191071093,
-0.2286335975,
-0.1768740565,
0.2052553296,
0.6308889985,
0.4641379714,
-0.4164141119,
-0.3604778349,
-0.2317588031,
0.1835158169,
0.1009644866,
0.9335916042,
-0.7075156569,
0.1062531769,
0.5824380517,
1.088642478,
0.3088367283,
0.1865121871,
0.1670818031,
-0.7340884805,
0.2151684016,
0.0801260918,
0.209227562,
0.0142728984,
-0.5966615081,
0.317650497,
0.4697473347,
-0.7987127304,
-0.8350633979,
-0.1837027818,
-1.5713021755,
-0.2632719576,
1.017616272,
0.2354996353,
-0.2892994583,
-0.3785454929,
-0.4265783429,
-0.4614467323,
-0.6934658289,
0.8958368301,
0.4229426086,
-0.0702566803,
-0.3380208313,
-0.8649372458,
0.3118497133,
0.6627530456,
-1.1007553339,
-0.363502264,
0.4557753503,
0.4466028214,
-0.033257328,
0.911555171,
0.5992772579,
0.3019710183,
-0.1184209585,
-0.4261321723,
-0.1189869195,
-0.5865741372,
-0.1883988678,
0.4139055908,
0.6566346288,
-0.2709751427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09174v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09174v3
|
AbsPyramid: Benchmarking the Abstraction Ability of Language Models with a Unified Entailment Graph
| 2023-11-15T18:11:23 | 2024-04-01T16:24:24 |
Zhaowei Wang, Haochen Shi, Weiqi Wang, Tianqing Fang, Hongming Zhang, Sehyun Choi, Xin Liu, Yangqiu Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Cognitive research indicates that abstraction ability is essential in human
intelligence, which remains under-explored in language models. In this paper,
we present AbsPyramid, a unified entailment graph of 221K textual descriptions
of abstraction knowledge. While existing resources only touch nouns or verbs
within simplified events or specific domains, AbsPyramid collects abstract
knowledge for three components of diverse events to comprehensively evaluate
the abstraction ability of language models in the open domain. Experimental
results demonstrate that current LLMs face challenges comprehending abstraction
knowledge in zero-shot and few-shot settings. By training on our rich
abstraction knowledge, we find LLMs can acquire basic abstraction abilities and
generalize to unseen events. In the meantime, we empirically show that our
benchmark is comprehensive to enhance LLMs across two previous abstraction
tasks.
|
[
-0.2773637474,
-0.7663707733,
0.5642762184,
0.0920243114,
-0.1907621175,
0.1872296482,
-0.4036889076,
-0.6983014345,
-0.0497841612,
0.297317028,
-0.330815345,
-0.7907229662,
-0.6080321074,
0.0067979284,
-0.4082376957,
0.7743141055,
-0.3304336369,
-0.1689350158,
-0.5633435845,
-0.2606114447,
-0.219310075,
-0.1652770191,
-0.2532131076,
-0.877864182,
0.177814588,
0.1439957917,
0.336345315,
0.7452976704,
0.4462287724,
0.2502243817,
0.1112786159,
0.0242628157,
-0.3998817205,
0.2655591369,
-0.309110254,
-0.2175749093,
-0.7164575458,
-0.0069820224,
0.5409657955,
1.2307231426,
0.1268219352,
0.0475988649,
0.2026150823,
0.4786701798,
-1.069308877,
0.3744473457,
-0.5676230788,
-0.2214557976,
-0.2949177027,
0.1415457278,
-0.2635198534,
-0.1970804185,
0.0121837743,
-0.7369856834,
-0.1737885326,
-0.2339812964,
0.7306091189,
0.1887245029,
-0.3535507321,
-0.3004843295,
-0.5164790154,
0.6534218788,
-0.3139642775,
0.2817656994,
0.4079458416,
0.0970134437,
0.0378009677,
-0.9486148357,
-0.2421982288,
-0.1979309022,
-0.0540122278,
0.2617934644,
-0.5204133987,
0.377268523,
0.0655921623,
0.1510252655,
-0.4475454092,
0.1642417014,
-0.28219679,
-0.209282577,
0.6769548655,
0.3933460414,
0.4692362249,
0.1461661905,
-0.3964039683,
0.2746407986,
-0.7966054678,
0.0003594038,
0.3085035086,
-0.0648206323,
-0.1900463551,
0.7193652391,
-0.7303150296,
0.893553853,
-0.4362985194,
0.1322306097,
0.279276222,
-0.405623883,
-0.0990477875,
-0.0195188578,
0.5989228487,
0.1401227415,
0.5401856303,
-0.4505136013,
-0.1112502217,
0.2561282516,
0.1466505527,
-0.9956048131,
-0.4257164896,
0.5058137774,
-0.2789432108,
0.2774840593,
0.0280488245,
-0.3698990643,
-0.2945462167,
-0.2994302213,
0.3189644814,
-0.9318200946,
-0.4271594882,
0.2968732119,
-0.3217431009,
0.1170038059,
0.3554261923,
-0.7743154168,
0.6495319605,
1.1295604706,
0.7621278763,
-0.5020109415,
-0.6466881037,
-0.0551868789,
0.2223784924,
-0.4838791192,
1.2376769781,
-0.7594019771,
-0.1686968207,
-0.1409649253,
-0.4665205777,
-0.1749522239,
-0.5570813417,
0.4405961633,
-0.1741534323,
-0.3782819211,
0.2282627225,
-0.9329402447,
-0.344089061,
0.133591488,
-0.2835431099,
0.7216150761,
0.1170268729,
-0.6218122244,
-0.0330114588,
-0.6762682199,
-0.3960788548,
0.396769017,
-0.5349569321,
0.1452367157,
0.3442717493,
0.0825287923,
0.328306675,
-0.2269831449,
-0.0233141202,
-0.2925238907,
-0.4153749347,
0.3204372823,
-0.1566783339,
0.962284565,
0.1118705422,
0.057170745,
0.1513595283,
-0.631706059,
0.3314757645,
-0.1065986454,
-0.2511260808,
-0.5256745815,
-0.2992323935,
-0.1279595494,
-0.1972325742,
0.3996519744,
-0.5416446924,
0.058883369,
-0.4780922532,
0.1212197244,
0.5371096134,
0.1560130417,
0.5017712712,
-0.3388151824,
0.5465017557,
-0.0239571035,
-0.3871015906,
-0.5340821743,
-0.6510591507,
-0.4367836714,
-0.754950583,
0.2969397902,
0.3513159156,
-0.3167563081,
0.5029743314,
-0.4674821198,
-0.5248610973,
-0.5006819963,
0.1640986949,
0.6005544066,
0.3117460907,
0.170543626,
-0.5671008825,
-0.4679459035,
-0.8917341828,
-0.5650033355,
-0.2555983663,
-0.3196418285,
0.0466115177,
0.5902030468,
-0.1784376949,
1.0265923738,
-0.4505464733,
-0.3969197869,
-0.3152860999,
0.437623024,
0.0950422361,
0.2102198005,
0.3151821792,
-0.0774046183,
-0.2569391429,
0.2522894144,
-0.9610767365,
-0.279710561,
0.1902414709,
-0.2769396603,
0.2571320534,
0.3789269626,
-0.7900195718,
0.6595156789,
0.2910363972,
-0.4086327553,
0.4754608572,
-0.3459444642,
-0.1120177507,
-0.6328060031,
0.1517644376,
-0.2547021508,
0.057197459,
-0.6505918503,
0.3105012774,
0.2023323327,
0.1501334906,
-0.2862798572,
0.6661472321,
-0.6424766183,
-0.2420655936,
-0.3324852884,
0.4193434119,
-0.2349989265,
0.423319608,
0.1012571007,
0.2330567688,
0.900780201,
-0.6462120414,
0.3539145887,
0.0433952175,
-0.5273025632,
0.6171370149,
-0.6366171837,
0.1583424062,
-0.1916977614,
-0.0175890867,
-1.1974518299,
-0.2939606011,
0.0641354173,
-0.4951897562,
0.1141114235,
-0.1775167733,
-0.2341079265,
0.0873080567,
-0.2986909747,
0.5816041827,
0.5583797693,
-0.1845935732,
0.953147769,
0.4804828465,
-0.160549596,
-0.5307767391,
-0.4738366306,
0.0191853102,
0.0485070571,
-0.4111597836,
0.5000341535,
-0.0948282778,
-0.6111819148,
0.2813118696,
-0.1339794099,
-0.1801543832,
0.2321682274,
0.633864224,
-0.0160766058,
-0.1872802675,
0.176402092,
-0.1958547384,
-0.3498099744,
0.2500731647,
-0.0967648476,
0.6974848509,
-0.313398242,
-0.5662333965,
-0.4913265705,
-0.0248955619,
0.2064352334,
-0.1805381626,
0.3064148426,
0.1563270539,
-0.6856864095,
-0.2481380552,
-0.066069372,
-0.1408846527,
-0.3668519855,
0.6014912128,
-0.5346004367,
-0.3026257455,
0.5194120407,
-0.3308765888,
0.2597923577,
0.1987908483,
0.5516229868,
0.0324864872,
0.5208158493,
0.3451737761,
0.0532357432,
0.2029940635,
-0.400994122,
-0.2325704992,
-0.9365096688,
-0.3633825481,
-0.5234321952,
-0.356518507,
-0.1748981923,
-0.3084084094,
0.0307253301,
0.4202763736,
-0.3844469786,
0.1464257389,
-0.1121091917,
0.8122649193,
0.2331311554,
0.0066060838,
0.7616581321,
0.093352139,
-0.1568811834,
-0.095435068,
-0.337190181,
-0.4645181298,
1.3617707491,
0.1212161705,
0.8737459779,
0.1016802266,
0.7808074355,
0.0172115024,
0.6289158463,
-0.8710881472,
0.6862499118,
0.0959670618,
-0.5158894658,
-0.240402177,
-0.260289073,
-1.1228804588,
0.3823749721,
-0.0358624607,
-0.9884861112,
-0.1883253753,
-0.1539327949,
-0.1067410409,
0.097271204,
-0.4782529771,
0.63449049,
-0.195973143,
-0.1700545847,
-0.4851694405,
-0.1308978051,
0.365750134,
-0.0011629069,
0.1840560138,
-0.5780371428,
-0.5861569643,
0.6745910645,
0.0057386938,
0.7502192259,
0.1824789494,
0.0792039111,
0.2223870754,
0.5330606699,
0.052873034,
0.03510423,
-0.1232927889,
0.4844213128,
-0.213999033,
-0.3352487683,
-0.5522789955,
0.639834404,
-0.8735312223,
-0.4485744238,
-0.4231259823,
-0.7768969536,
-0.2308350503,
0.358736515,
0.1540058702,
0.5850948691,
-0.4907028079,
0.1299129725,
0.4029299617,
0.2190646231,
0.6379122138,
0.598772645,
-0.3796019256,
-0.2099491358,
0.6794660091,
0.188049227,
0.1016920432,
0.2080476433,
-0.0380904898,
-0.3243615925,
-0.9123859406,
-0.2445209771,
0.279629916,
-1.0038459301,
-0.2418412119,
-0.7235366702,
-0.3507191539,
-0.2129659653,
0.0380539857,
-0.463136822,
-0.734572947,
0.0056190826,
-0.2701764107,
0.35076195,
0.9729287624,
-0.0867977068,
-0.133498773,
-0.2177629173,
0.5192924738,
0.0887408778,
0.6140295267,
0.0280363411,
-0.5808969736,
-0.0270589422,
-0.0520279147,
-0.4134165049,
-0.7709059715,
0.0702083036,
0.534448266,
1.0024523735,
0.6136820912,
0.3275311887,
0.620029211,
-0.4049957395,
0.4120692611,
0.0663945079,
-0.9595281482,
0.3590374887,
-0.2007032484,
0.485196501,
0.3532035351,
0.5944405198,
-0.2953033745,
-0.6241392493,
-0.6206660271,
-0.8863682747,
0.5543205738,
0.3600418568,
0.0833436176,
0.0602803975,
0.2754454911,
0.1728466451,
-0.0127171455,
-0.3792364895,
-0.2747733891,
-0.0682755858,
-0.4156376123,
0.1302354187,
0.1356404424,
-0.2868454158,
-0.3433398008,
0.3468959928,
-0.0871668831,
0.1349479705,
-0.115273118,
-0.354868263,
0.1757158637,
0.1472757757,
0.2506127357,
1.3346517086,
-0.2317584008,
0.4259848893,
0.1927602887,
-0.595082283,
-0.0832404867,
0.0915197507,
-0.0649430677,
-0.1419774145,
0.8481167555,
0.3585796058,
0.1718374938,
-0.9908258319,
0.2909378409,
-0.0532500073,
-0.1746520549,
-0.2907775342,
0.297295928,
0.4017549157,
0.0332210287,
0.5338831544,
-0.131575048,
0.0622646697,
-0.7011580467,
0.2949275374,
0.4983282089,
-0.3777178824,
-0.3503218293,
0.4432599843,
0.0502942577,
-0.2951453626,
0.6273365021,
-0.067058444,
0.0338255651,
0.6386785507,
0.5695371032,
0.908192873,
-0.0191606674,
0.0982406959,
0.2648668885,
0.3179571927,
0.1459223926,
0.3703573346,
-0.0276511237,
-0.9524963498,
-0.1786943376,
-0.5244881511,
-0.5460122824,
-0.0156885888,
-0.7117675543,
-0.0280157253,
-0.5476304293,
0.0488391481,
0.2457887381,
-0.037576247,
-0.7445042729,
-0.2299036235,
-0.0257334895,
0.8676835895,
-0.6254504323,
0.908834815,
0.9816587567,
-0.4082133472,
-0.134650737,
-0.0864114091,
-0.0784245431,
-0.7801408172,
0.6510017514,
0.2293958068,
-0.3612531126,
0.07414148,
-0.4038553536,
-0.4823547304,
1.0825316906,
0.5225563049,
0.0234583337,
0.4180005193,
0.1570615768,
0.7421269417,
-0.8146375418,
0.6873188615,
0.8294916749,
0.311489135,
0.0053859078,
-0.5499129891,
0.0935213044,
-0.1634680927,
0.1273456365,
-0.0772124901,
-0.15987885,
0.9237449765,
-0.3841760159,
-0.6948085427,
0.2571828961,
0.798879087,
0.4581386149,
0.4012610316,
0.0244194344,
0.6765379906,
0.7817070484,
-0.1906769425,
1.029227972,
-0.4238539338,
0.0668703839,
1.2407819033,
-0.33845824,
1.0239654779,
0.2021662593,
-0.1082636937,
0.5852407217,
0.3023907244,
0.5143283606,
0.3765474856,
0.1403921247,
-0.4120959342,
-0.347899437,
-0.1658702195,
-0.2430992723,
0.5762767792,
0.6788462996,
0.0883457363,
-0.6391992569,
-0.306914866,
0.0369748585,
0.3947091997,
-0.4432043135,
0.929407835,
0.0420547985,
-0.5933210254,
0.7995119095,
0.0734886602,
0.5023838878,
-0.716770947,
-0.075107798,
-0.5658918023,
0.4139092863,
-0.1907927692,
-1.1146520376,
0.3451871276,
-0.0960119292,
0.3106001019,
0.0156301055,
0.6887809038,
-0.322747618,
-0.2716602981,
0.4535625279,
0.6719301939,
0.4457927048,
-0.1532804072,
-0.4303848743,
0.1622181982,
-0.3258145452,
-0.1355748326,
0.265509814,
0.6588366032,
-0.116289869,
0.8981353045,
0.2911094725,
0.1421866417,
-0.0125469491,
-0.0908171162,
0.7748625875,
-0.7327631712,
-0.2488469779,
-1.0346039534,
0.3184329867,
-0.1530858278,
-0.3990765512,
0.811427772,
0.701094985,
0.9411767721,
0.0277062934,
0.8554641604,
-0.0007374113,
0.1403940767,
-0.433339715,
0.8028899431,
-0.2127650082,
0.2030542791,
0.0737799779,
-0.7696318626,
-0.3783805668,
0.5450604558,
-0.1176021919,
-0.0595313981,
0.8393627405,
0.6769547462,
-0.1091667041,
0.0361222997,
0.4186270237,
0.33876279,
-0.0425606966,
0.7080096006,
1.0262261629,
-0.2516620755,
0.5921726823,
-0.1596645862,
-0.3029420674,
0.0022719176,
-0.7875286937,
-1.1196811199,
-0.5944078565,
-0.4312422872,
-0.1844098121,
0.1400100142,
0.7860367894,
0.4836519063,
-0.7307628989,
-0.6340518594,
-0.0373821668,
0.411221385,
-0.5540543199,
-0.1186972558,
0.4094000757,
-0.4785510004,
-0.7503063083,
0.2628384829,
0.5618544221,
0.0298988856,
-0.1627832502,
-0.2129058987,
-0.0206203405,
0.1582749188,
0.4148449898,
0.4061511159,
-0.7239592671,
-0.0707616508,
-0.3990931213,
-0.0333973803,
0.001692672,
0.9642409682,
-0.862208426,
0.4177823961,
0.692489028,
0.620020926,
0.3881677687,
0.1038107499,
0.397667259,
-0.729437232,
0.4503977597,
0.2076240182,
0.4324930906,
0.204482615,
0.2213863879,
0.6875430942,
0.1799365282,
-0.1515491903,
-0.6273034811,
0.4385644495,
-0.7912518382,
-0.6720821261,
1.1087722778,
-0.3502874374,
-0.369412154,
-0.7381590009,
0.062381357,
-0.0349675603,
-0.2459937185,
0.7254536152,
0.5526920557,
-0.6744312048,
-0.2676196098,
-0.4711416662,
0.4079852104,
0.0491577983,
-0.9919214845,
0.328555584,
0.4642208517,
0.3427377939,
0.1483784616,
0.9379938841,
-0.2580881715,
0.2909247279,
0.1849056333,
0.2617884576,
-0.3735699952,
-0.4337466955,
-0.417091161,
0.241460681,
0.1304055452,
-0.0986569598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09154v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09154v3
|
CLEAN-EVAL: Clean Evaluation on Contaminated Large Language Models
| 2023-11-15T17:50:30 | 2024-06-03T03:06:55 |
Wenhong Zhu, Hongkun Hao, Zhiwei He, Yunze Song, Yumeng Zhang, Hanxu Hu, Yiran Wei, Rui Wang, Hongyuan Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We are currently in an era of fierce competition among various large language
models (LLMs) continuously pushing the boundaries of benchmark performance.
However, genuinely assessing the capabilities of these LLMs has become a
challenging and critical issue due to potential data contamination, and it
wastes dozens of time and effort for researchers and engineers to download and
try those contaminated models. To save our precious time, we propose a novel
and useful method, Clean-Eval, which mitigates the issue of data contamination
and evaluates the LLMs in a cleaner manner. Clean-Eval employs an LLM to
paraphrase and back-translate the contaminated data into a candidate set,
generating expressions with the same meaning but in different surface forms. A
semantic detector is then used to filter the generated low-quality samples to
narrow down this candidate set. The best candidate is finally selected from
this set based on the BLEURT score. According to human assessment, this best
candidate is semantically similar to the original contamination data but
expressed differently. All candidates can form a new benchmark to evaluate the
model. Our experiments illustrate that Clean-Eval substantially restores the
actual evaluation results on contaminated LLMs under both few-shot learning and
fine-tuning scenarios.
|
[
-0.2486757189,
-0.8840149045,
0.6623571515,
-0.1938249767,
-0.1512166411,
0.2315812856,
-0.4369255304,
-0.3761799335,
-0.3724517226,
0.9099075794,
-0.1736823022,
-0.6603423357,
-0.5087448955,
0.0217183474,
-0.6159982681,
1.0704189539,
0.0994829908,
-0.1359345913,
-0.1593597233,
0.0294619147,
-0.204826355,
-0.1597697735,
-0.6669920683,
-0.1740479916,
0.3013774753,
0.4144679308,
0.5942125916,
0.6694613099,
0.46108675,
0.4133190513,
-0.2231105566,
0.2162947357,
-0.7310698628,
0.3023134768,
-0.6195801497,
-0.3481352329,
-0.1692918986,
-0.0781321004,
0.5270596147,
0.7167230248,
-0.2070871145,
0.3303265572,
0.2171020657,
0.5534644127,
-0.9808110595,
-0.0481923707,
-1.0345615149,
-0.3282235563,
-0.1397791952,
-0.2173808664,
-0.5724619031,
-0.2593770325,
-0.3367946148,
-0.5003401637,
-0.0556935444,
-0.1034146622,
1.1251235008,
0.3678884208,
-0.3389618695,
0.2479201853,
-0.8314678669,
1.0272312164,
-0.9107719064,
0.4426959157,
0.440269649,
0.3803452551,
-0.3008816242,
-0.6987571716,
-0.5399383903,
-0.3241215944,
0.2123663574,
0.0245414246,
-0.2715155184,
-0.0423305556,
0.1740393788,
0.0836941004,
-0.3863958418,
0.2717782259,
-0.551374197,
-0.5310507417,
0.7447004318,
0.2266482413,
0.4870832562,
-0.1754949987,
-0.7755112052,
-0.2061489224,
-0.9837578535,
-0.1916288286,
0.3826971948,
0.4523189366,
0.1812847853,
0.3391203284,
-0.4892824888,
0.5845636725,
-0.4199692607,
-0.1303346008,
0.2997887433,
-0.4646274149,
-0.3245325685,
0.0025124208,
0.9633715153,
0.241175428,
0.3084187806,
-0.01964573,
-0.6064295769,
-0.0132217966,
0.3105137944,
-0.8557098508,
-0.3175697029,
0.1789656281,
-0.382301271,
-0.379848361,
-0.1329165399,
-0.8985277414,
-0.5547029376,
-0.4984671175,
0.6785368323,
-0.4358466864,
-0.2105932534,
0.2421579659,
0.0654364675,
0.025088748,
0.713083148,
-0.5221697688,
0.4051555097,
0.9872705936,
0.3889631629,
0.0945803225,
-0.0710475072,
-0.8982641697,
-0.1084009111,
-0.3631789982,
0.7604965568,
-0.6650129557,
-0.2566336989,
-0.1392185688,
-0.4890874326,
0.1944276839,
-0.9259585738,
0.6446583271,
-0.5208708048,
0.1002267748,
0.0369665623,
-0.640362978,
-0.241906777,
0.2834523022,
-0.6340282559,
1.0707762241,
0.0689181983,
-0.6126052737,
0.4299578369,
-0.2592502832,
-0.1128408089,
0.4176596403,
-0.0004379289,
-0.4289400578,
0.0262045059,
-0.022556521,
0.3744077981,
-0.0842089877,
0.2258696556,
-0.5526056886,
-0.3721783757,
0.0912999138,
-0.5996925235,
0.8519434333,
0.4564032555,
-0.1940775365,
0.2001206875,
-0.7612605095,
0.4325607121,
-0.2641538084,
-0.3663318157,
-0.6000386477,
-0.0469005965,
0.2276734114,
0.5121523738,
0.2953730524,
-0.7218552828,
-0.2409889698,
-0.4154706299,
0.09901236,
0.8597391844,
0.1142137721,
-0.0531447344,
-0.352820456,
0.3530656099,
-0.1497559249,
0.0260545984,
-0.2215874642,
-0.1614923775,
-0.6157938242,
-0.5471084118,
0.2694152892,
0.5550378561,
-0.6739430428,
0.5643501282,
-0.4552919269,
-0.7174013853,
-0.8339316249,
0.4869275093,
0.6797115207,
0.4259100556,
0.4209300578,
-0.0078062271,
-0.319663465,
-1.0420640707,
-0.4919314384,
-0.0752783865,
-0.1992737502,
0.3163050413,
0.7974425554,
-0.1336541325,
0.8141003251,
-0.477486819,
-0.1578015685,
-0.1550649256,
-0.0883564353,
-0.1346753389,
0.2747972012,
0.0338483341,
-0.4997695088,
-0.3599512577,
0.1736160964,
-0.5353180766,
-0.2874313593,
0.116922535,
-0.0687935278,
0.0420894399,
0.6717045903,
-0.2832816541,
0.1874641925,
0.3840125799,
-0.3797025979,
0.6155946851,
-0.2033532262,
0.3071477413,
-0.8521496058,
0.3846728802,
-0.0929712057,
-0.4666485488,
-0.5828288198,
0.3947100639,
0.1415088028,
-0.0366372466,
-0.8973799944,
0.9211218953,
-0.025268482,
0.254344672,
-0.2962241769,
0.4719593823,
0.3357851505,
0.1171243563,
-0.3033457994,
0.6817015409,
0.2568740249,
-0.3490490913,
0.0797162503,
0.3381736577,
-0.4467530847,
0.2523031533,
-0.4088468254,
0.2334058881,
0.0905488133,
0.1369286925,
-0.9199259281,
0.0556540787,
-0.1251578778,
-0.0620940737,
0.2567269802,
-0.0450400002,
-0.678030014,
0.1500592977,
-0.4926993549,
0.4149336815,
0.5603504777,
-0.800737679,
0.1382053792,
0.3385748863,
-0.1574411988,
-0.3979236186,
-0.3102190197,
0.1856191456,
-0.4787786603,
-0.6422067285,
0.0285684839,
0.1396508962,
-0.5778328776,
-0.0134307062,
-0.2562204897,
-0.0809029564,
0.5964220166,
-0.0128704133,
0.2384892702,
-0.1439255029,
0.0266148765,
-0.0048363148,
-0.0115848882,
-0.0792445689,
0.1829356849,
0.6000949144,
-0.2750612199,
-0.2953597307,
-0.4262601733,
0.0039192513,
0.46061939,
-0.5193281174,
0.4488188922,
0.2756839395,
-0.6061232686,
-0.4986262321,
-0.5977963209,
-0.1235719994,
-0.5506961942,
0.5598230362,
-0.1637741923,
-0.6530641317,
0.4109529853,
-0.236273393,
-0.0451827757,
0.3519568443,
0.4797098637,
-0.0110452641,
0.6087280512,
0.3173848689,
0.0451679155,
0.2333689481,
-0.1371239424,
0.2933175564,
-0.8518323898,
-0.2285118252,
-0.6915698647,
-0.0904355794,
-0.4698391557,
-0.2849034965,
0.1802857965,
0.3173330426,
-0.3748284578,
0.3327172697,
-0.0783551261,
0.622518599,
0.259576112,
0.1801646501,
0.5079338551,
-0.2772038877,
-0.1133291051,
0.1652789861,
-0.1262268722,
-1.0721946955,
1.0799795389,
0.3275053501,
0.7323989868,
-0.1334250718,
1.3000953197,
0.1840760559,
0.3623131812,
-0.4238028228,
0.7527868152,
-0.4340798259,
-0.5142349601,
-0.3185431063,
-0.547141552,
-1.0301725864,
0.3716504574,
-0.1831727773,
-1.0130575895,
-0.1899112761,
-0.0948462337,
-0.3608911037,
0.3904661238,
-0.6636832952,
0.9321143627,
-0.2736102045,
-0.6218594909,
-0.3561685681,
-0.3731180131,
0.6331329346,
-0.4197238684,
0.4423029721,
-0.330775857,
-0.1728520244,
0.7299604416,
-0.4478398561,
0.5783230066,
-0.0967143476,
-0.3159240484,
0.1625347584,
0.427318275,
0.2694448531,
-0.1443213224,
-0.1489782184,
0.2839536965,
0.1497690082,
-0.2320473641,
-0.5922071338,
0.7865893245,
-0.5436064005,
-0.5961404443,
-0.0335402973,
-0.3674624264,
-0.2245438099,
0.4943363369,
-0.031958349,
0.3010589182,
-0.1764804423,
0.3003934324,
0.4577755332,
-0.5985738635,
0.3512913883,
0.5031429529,
-0.3566981852,
-0.0750875473,
1.0276088715,
-0.3320967853,
0.5313047767,
0.3354824185,
0.3611965775,
-0.1998171061,
-0.6539821029,
-0.1959139854,
0.0419316404,
-0.7084416747,
-0.4531677365,
-0.523160398,
-0.0260847695,
0.058679726,
0.1364396513,
-0.6475896835,
-0.2183669955,
-0.0346218683,
-0.068518497,
0.0690030158,
0.5731169581,
0.1211322695,
-0.02470701,
-1.0112917423,
0.3782555163,
-0.236254096,
0.4709814191,
-0.2393501103,
-0.3751781881,
-0.0704044402,
0.2944476306,
-0.3967348635,
-0.540354073,
0.5035036206,
0.2194077224,
0.5167378783,
0.463850379,
0.1210688576,
0.5195690989,
-0.5530237556,
0.6519483924,
-0.1038986519,
-1.0378313065,
0.5183214545,
-0.3768391013,
0.0433139056,
0.993920505,
-0.0452005863,
-0.5039973259,
-0.8390718699,
-0.6575073004,
-1.1084629297,
0.3446770906,
0.0285788793,
0.0804411843,
-0.053944461,
0.0584921651,
0.2982671261,
0.1504271179,
-0.2840333879,
0.1909316033,
0.0932745337,
-0.1876963973,
0.0701428503,
-0.0624870397,
-0.1689989716,
0.0958529115,
0.7843623161,
0.2382746041,
-0.2546644509,
-0.2327839434,
-0.3446060419,
0.059268821,
0.569133997,
0.3039084673,
0.4451747537,
-0.0310200062,
0.1691786647,
0.2703386843,
-0.2605341077,
0.112441726,
-0.0549379103,
-0.14671354,
-0.3468340635,
0.5677360296,
0.5076491833,
0.4670320749,
-1.2080277205,
0.6085901856,
0.1244524717,
0.0802810267,
0.0400671586,
0.4040086567,
0.0141988555,
-0.0157730784,
0.1093211696,
0.1386691332,
0.4178653955,
-0.5981178284,
0.6814669371,
0.3967928886,
-0.0900918767,
-0.090759322,
0.5638536215,
0.1948049217,
-0.2343412191,
0.8453005552,
-0.3091008663,
-0.653336525,
0.5189708471,
0.343637526,
0.9002448916,
-0.2835826278,
0.0028891212,
0.2503022254,
0.1520510465,
0.0129712103,
0.2065707743,
0.1777162552,
-0.7964034081,
-0.5558263659,
-0.8423067927,
-0.1687513441,
0.495853126,
-0.6656895876,
0.4843540192,
-0.2968860269,
0.3118714392,
-0.0050500408,
0.2094458044,
-0.7516719103,
0.2328923792,
0.295034945,
0.9827272892,
-1.1214469671,
0.5987161994,
0.353315562,
-0.2981379032,
-0.9500208497,
-0.0093312096,
-0.0424370728,
-0.6008725166,
0.7900272608,
0.2367657721,
-0.0961559936,
-0.2178214639,
-0.3238271177,
-0.8014743924,
0.6795244813,
0.5925722122,
-0.5889647007,
0.3241605461,
0.0199170616,
0.6854697466,
0.2276952267,
0.2872123718,
0.7108433247,
0.6428055167,
-0.3374952972,
-1.1289093494,
0.2966875434,
-0.432328105,
-0.1845370084,
0.4661582708,
-0.3745003343,
0.4631927013,
-0.1697738767,
-0.3842144608,
0.3131930828,
0.2631253302,
0.3490921259,
0.2841575444,
0.4870401919,
0.6436650753,
0.8147760034,
-0.1380008906,
1.1421447992,
-0.3237180412,
0.606028378,
1.2394405603,
-0.6456690431,
1.2074649334,
0.3331965804,
-0.1561895162,
0.2263837606,
0.1907620281,
-0.224920854,
0.5172044039,
0.583191514,
-0.4379690289,
-0.2963695526,
-0.0798274875,
0.0662080795,
0.9552868009,
0.2318419069,
0.0033271872,
-0.8826609254,
0.1167780682,
0.1329924166,
0.5251502395,
-0.2741728723,
0.7876380086,
0.0031957806,
-0.6028924584,
0.5632503033,
0.0040301615,
0.4471792281,
-0.3213450313,
-0.3106510341,
-0.1185173094,
0.4023254216,
-0.3006382883,
-0.7880346775,
0.3407051265,
-0.0257393382,
0.3555928171,
-0.3517804146,
0.7490468025,
-0.6063625813,
-0.2515420616,
0.4211340249,
0.593108654,
0.3392149508,
-0.1209818125,
-0.4521137476,
0.1506028026,
-0.0560156591,
-0.3169148266,
0.4362517893,
0.2920720875,
-0.2204027772,
0.8965693116,
0.7565728426,
0.2182046771,
-0.0175420083,
0.0222022887,
0.6943507195,
-0.4137346447,
-0.207781896,
-0.9638141394,
0.5912377238,
0.1466129124,
-0.2450432926,
0.6629133224,
1.0281175375,
0.7991991043,
0.1392426789,
0.7922288179,
0.3827509582,
0.4625088573,
-0.5566038489,
1.0369129181,
-0.3794850707,
0.5056706667,
-0.3448842466,
-0.7653335929,
-0.2051838934,
0.419865936,
-0.2217176408,
0.1556031704,
0.7232723832,
0.7426604033,
-0.1781294346,
-0.1152848452,
0.481834501,
0.3903045654,
0.6628755927,
0.5108006597,
0.8385694027,
-0.225561142,
0.5140039325,
-0.3673079908,
-0.1986216158,
-0.0916996449,
-0.9659153223,
-0.525772512,
-0.4043260515,
-0.5138785243,
-0.4376252592,
0.0580016226,
0.6462365389,
0.2924087048,
-0.7581240535,
0.0027328983,
0.1346502602,
0.0845310539,
-0.2513556182,
-0.2429773808,
0.5002787709,
-0.4780305326,
-0.8291410804,
0.7145999074,
0.1660307348,
-0.5258204937,
-0.131153971,
0.2654238045,
-0.0307225026,
0.0368665978,
0.4695598483,
0.0604626536,
-0.5990934968,
-0.7268330455,
-0.2574729323,
-0.2948571146,
-0.1510280818,
0.3288020492,
-0.9871844649,
0.4830341041,
0.4846043885,
0.7620369792,
0.2862713039,
0.0191493742,
0.4250748158,
-0.7001177073,
-0.2512059212,
0.3972164989,
0.6269136071,
0.4564953446,
-0.3229216933,
0.3397526145,
-0.3101884425,
-0.4137768149,
-1.0878977776,
0.1857503206,
-0.9727863073,
-0.3450259268,
1.6271640062,
-0.3280155361,
-0.0463724136,
-0.0779821277,
-0.1576356888,
0.1497698426,
-0.2267233878,
0.9382404089,
0.6158747673,
0.166190356,
0.2979130149,
-0.6586812139,
0.2433061302,
0.2169516087,
-1.152590394,
0.2673147023,
0.4684181809,
0.8746230602,
0.0142581537,
0.196039781,
-0.3134922385,
0.2183125019,
-0.1304122061,
0.0293924958,
-0.2825036049,
-0.2472257614,
-0.455105871,
0.0580883436,
-0.0122619448,
-0.2231722176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09149v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09149v2
|
Temporal Knowledge Question Answering via Abstract Reasoning Induction
| 2023-11-15T17:46:39 | 2024-05-17T03:17:02 |
Ziyang Chen, Dongfang Li, Xiang Zhao, Baotian Hu, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
In this study, we address the challenge of enhancing temporal knowledge
reasoning in Large Language Models (LLMs). LLMs often struggle with this task,
leading to the generation of inaccurate or misleading responses. This issue
mainly arises from their limited ability to handle evolving factual knowledge
and complex temporal logic. To overcome these limitations, we propose Abstract
Reasoning Induction (ARI) framework, which divides temporal reasoning into two
distinct phases: Knowledge-agnostic and Knowledge-based. This framework offers
factual knowledge support to LLMs while minimizing the incorporation of
extraneous noisy data. Concurrently, informed by the principles of
constructivism, ARI provides LLMs the capability to engage in proactive,
self-directed learning from both correct and incorrect historical reasoning
samples. By teaching LLMs to actively construct knowledge and methods, it can
significantly boosting their temporal reasoning abilities. Our approach
achieves remarkable improvements, with relative gains of 29.7% and 9.27% on two
temporal QA datasets, underscoring its efficacy in advancing temporal reasoning
in LLMs. The code can be found at https://github.com/czy1999/ARI-QA
|
[
-0.0140130101,
-0.8541380763,
1.2577041388,
0.3339348137,
0.064937368,
0.2360657454,
0.0900849625,
-0.7773049474,
-0.2838962078,
0.0535427891,
-0.6574058533,
-0.4507681429,
-0.4152914882,
0.1784855872,
-0.2962065637,
0.3826723099,
-0.2885943353,
-0.0315905064,
-0.3913128078,
-0.1376110017,
-0.0935076252,
-0.3158283234,
-1.0108575821,
-0.723737061,
0.4177885354,
0.2430474311,
0.559243381,
0.8586873412,
-0.1033972129,
0.2482481301,
-0.1026597843,
0.4817022681,
0.1752753258,
0.2977328002,
-0.4612308145,
-0.5953220129,
-0.3832504451,
-0.4635305703,
0.5179442167,
0.7340584993,
-0.2177461386,
0.3593400419,
-0.4062166512,
0.4591689706,
-0.6571030617,
0.6096141338,
-0.8869062662,
0.1122610494,
-0.0469143614,
-0.4575747848,
-0.3788121045,
-0.4522827566,
-0.0317664221,
-0.8729529977,
-0.1051250473,
0.3197204769,
0.6057389975,
0.4077818394,
-0.4360274076,
-0.1944081634,
-0.8945723176,
0.755623877,
-0.7855607867,
0.1929190606,
0.3211171031,
0.4343648255,
-0.117184408,
-0.812418282,
-1.0621402264,
0.1018906534,
0.0721922368,
-0.166612938,
-0.0094099473,
-0.1616471857,
0.2888796329,
0.1835623085,
-0.7114715576,
0.1207266748,
-0.0815287307,
-0.0296096541,
0.4510761499,
0.3558056056,
0.3891527355,
0.0980916023,
-0.0862604827,
0.2934046388,
-0.7717607021,
-0.0562608689,
0.2005576342,
-0.0446060151,
0.0238584243,
0.6787402034,
-0.4485897124,
0.6035402417,
0.1421293765,
-0.1437294185,
0.212812081,
-0.2293519676,
0.0510673225,
0.3934215009,
0.4816643298,
0.1060040891,
0.3672917187,
-0.2480710447,
-0.0643814281,
0.2476241142,
-0.2890817225,
-0.7110153437,
0.1004655361,
0.616996944,
-0.0771877542,
-0.1841063499,
-0.4341700971,
-0.5831837654,
-0.2637538314,
-0.5409136415,
0.4373418093,
-0.4967776835,
-0.3175334334,
0.3265680075,
0.0237696432,
0.5376922488,
0.5194687843,
-0.8844197392,
0.1156501919,
0.7986958623,
0.4735335708,
0.2670816779,
-0.1367668062,
-0.5483440757,
0.5241722465,
-0.3708537221,
0.9455031157,
-0.77379632,
-0.0044196071,
0.0643345937,
-0.1231550127,
-0.2545070648,
-0.4610736072,
0.2542870045,
-1.0627868176,
0.4029716849,
-0.111027889,
-0.5225585103,
-0.1227338612,
0.3692476749,
-0.2216158211,
0.9729568362,
0.0416817293,
-0.5055830479,
0.3294438422,
-0.7981521487,
-0.4125106335,
-0.0435796008,
-0.427177459,
-0.1827686429,
-0.4640879333,
0.7728566527,
0.3329290152,
-0.0466751531,
0.4522530735,
-0.2817115784,
-0.1467594206,
0.2823356986,
-0.2092293352,
0.4858503342,
0.3798723221,
-0.5399867296,
-0.1682782918,
-0.8124575615,
0.1674755067,
0.2876229584,
-0.1975083649,
-0.2344723493,
0.203642115,
-0.7274329662,
0.3215927482,
0.236567989,
-0.6283756495,
0.4068201184,
-0.5216977596,
0.3468521535,
0.7459487319,
0.477158457,
0.4865556061,
-0.6306148767,
0.3838237226,
0.2776412964,
0.0070447451,
-0.2742951512,
-0.4439247251,
-0.6181982756,
0.1737481505,
0.1100959927,
0.7464056611,
-1.0896801949,
0.2981354594,
-0.4368601441,
-0.1377511173,
-0.3800249994,
0.1534903497,
0.3325474858,
0.6457947493,
0.5178437829,
0.3114620447,
-0.6643186808,
-0.4463675022,
-0.1160785258,
-0.5468405485,
-0.156084761,
0.1221681163,
0.5493255258,
-0.1436405182,
0.7915916443,
-0.3833996356,
0.1593677104,
-0.1132462099,
0.3290020823,
0.1385661066,
0.3146890998,
0.3563863039,
-0.5107659101,
-0.1425257772,
-0.0282169934,
-1.1257650852,
-0.1888809055,
-0.1898323447,
-0.0782623217,
0.3590858877,
0.4885524511,
-0.618201375,
0.3706999123,
0.3178997636,
-0.6625953317,
0.6498394608,
0.2960859239,
0.2106571794,
-1.0113549232,
-0.0999890342,
-0.2360042036,
-0.333596915,
-0.2282765061,
-0.2298403531,
-0.2575312555,
-0.0918375924,
-0.5122792721,
0.8492048383,
-0.255649507,
-0.0030759391,
-0.151632756,
0.0815871283,
0.1640563607,
0.6086957455,
0.1644037366,
0.8693690896,
0.4342384338,
-0.8336074352,
0.275844872,
0.4487853944,
-0.4475357234,
0.2336185277,
-0.6855767965,
0.1038186923,
-0.3445278406,
0.2315607369,
-0.5693265796,
-0.0611506663,
0.4308245182,
-0.5488096476,
0.3425340354,
-0.3282186389,
-0.6335265636,
0.0228583086,
0.0948613212,
0.6010997295,
0.5336526632,
-0.698343575,
0.972112596,
-0.0632923543,
-0.4964777529,
-0.7601863146,
-0.3656932712,
-0.1581199467,
0.0925668925,
-0.7767643332,
0.3544023633,
-0.0081940554,
-0.855178237,
0.4252021015,
-0.3883839846,
0.0992172435,
-0.2028091103,
-0.0553870127,
0.0878011361,
-0.4039566815,
0.3424084783,
0.3661548197,
-0.162226066,
0.375303179,
-0.6333431005,
0.582442224,
-0.1463766247,
-0.6789397597,
-0.5880659819,
0.162383005,
0.7226772904,
-0.3156437278,
0.9581851363,
0.4561007619,
-0.30850631,
-0.2834543288,
-0.6239509583,
-0.274105072,
-0.3890478611,
0.0853213668,
-0.2944961786,
-0.7499545813,
0.5614486337,
-0.1687299311,
0.3654545546,
0.4495038688,
0.547996223,
-0.11149358,
1.1483517885,
0.0459704399,
0.1700135618,
0.2891251445,
-0.2502695918,
0.0333795324,
-0.8003906608,
-0.5947688818,
-0.399084717,
-0.0700273067,
0.0405081697,
-0.4062654972,
0.4471202493,
-0.241024062,
-0.6221036315,
-0.4380655587,
-0.1347333789,
0.3350166082,
0.3080121279,
0.1836513132,
0.7207448483,
-0.2175427973,
-0.0557271615,
0.289681524,
-0.6976038218,
-0.5200511813,
1.1273596287,
0.3726187944,
0.6217461824,
0.2076983005,
0.3617147505,
0.2447470129,
0.0586736724,
-0.5305805802,
0.6186464429,
0.3579828143,
-0.7626592517,
-0.4719456732,
-0.4737370908,
-0.6596472263,
0.1442146003,
-0.3201560378,
-0.5390962958,
0.1502547115,
0.1036976203,
-0.5025605559,
0.4667057395,
-0.5707172751,
0.619882226,
-0.3984982967,
-0.4592972696,
-0.2067977637,
-0.5842259526,
0.4412689805,
0.1736963987,
0.3692128658,
-0.437010169,
-0.0523949564,
0.6659764647,
-0.5510161519,
0.7924733758,
-0.3352095187,
0.1407375336,
0.4593591392,
0.1783245802,
0.6661489606,
0.4857422709,
-0.0784166828,
-0.1782808304,
0.2684878111,
-0.5665053725,
-1.0487532616,
0.4764203727,
-0.9401938915,
-0.7941489816,
-0.6952932477,
-0.7489690185,
-0.5069671273,
-0.043649286,
-0.0954823345,
0.7566956878,
0.3346936703,
-0.0209183935,
1.1428084373,
-0.0838116482,
0.3882443309,
0.7815193534,
-0.4593051672,
-0.0567813143,
0.3453660309,
-0.2606092393,
0.2254290879,
0.8035162687,
0.2003549933,
-0.7106244564,
-0.7871772051,
-0.4650541842,
0.377910763,
-0.7726147771,
-0.0608482882,
-0.9563315511,
-0.2401059419,
-0.5819023848,
0.0754355937,
-0.1758068353,
-0.8202472925,
-0.0108727682,
-0.2653105557,
0.4642476737,
0.2804884613,
0.1618429869,
0.046952948,
-0.7296045423,
0.4953473508,
0.6254618168,
-0.003001662,
0.0406726561,
-0.6600382328,
0.1426859498,
-0.0899047256,
-0.2568956316,
-0.4902919531,
-0.0179194305,
0.2447635233,
0.7109842896,
0.3998965919,
0.2748651206,
0.6044688225,
-0.5652426481,
0.7521491647,
-0.16013439,
-0.7253137231,
0.6543012261,
-0.3988227844,
0.4788711369,
0.3574209213,
0.3476632833,
-0.30481565,
-0.5034742951,
-0.6695637107,
-0.8936479688,
0.3220253885,
0.1512529105,
-0.1596872509,
0.0289066304,
0.5651233196,
0.0942389965,
0.1586049646,
-0.7009908557,
-0.3144601882,
-0.1247521862,
-0.3941656053,
0.3766018748,
-0.3907450438,
-0.2398314625,
-0.2981537879,
0.9054970145,
-0.1332024038,
0.2482189834,
0.3225045502,
-0.1829495132,
-0.2515095472,
0.6516374946,
0.4142097831,
1.3122339249,
-0.0334185027,
0.2407777607,
0.3999606073,
-0.1622269303,
0.2529757023,
0.1896662265,
-0.307269752,
-0.0839114711,
0.5676168203,
0.4313136339,
0.1173999235,
-0.5623351932,
0.2540649474,
-0.0772307888,
-0.2017426044,
-0.9096205831,
0.0159196332,
0.0756294355,
0.4599821568,
0.6455988288,
-0.0824119151,
-0.3532196879,
-0.5402426124,
0.2265526503,
0.1690511554,
0.141170904,
-0.2400111556,
0.910154283,
0.109383747,
0.0322060771,
0.6064034104,
-0.3618157804,
-0.388905555,
0.517678678,
0.6259328723,
0.5753257275,
-0.148751542,
0.0794730484,
0.312589854,
0.2033350617,
0.0736264586,
0.486381948,
-0.0754827708,
-1.1089912653,
-1.0329961777,
-0.7455605268,
-0.5407090187,
0.23079364,
-0.2872164249,
-0.0523351915,
-0.598280251,
0.1682326496,
-0.0141113149,
0.0624544397,
-0.467897296,
0.1052004024,
0.1597293764,
1.0903229713,
-0.8238473535,
0.6221891046,
0.7864736319,
-0.3562926054,
-0.8469826579,
-0.0799606368,
0.0897124484,
-1.0775550604,
0.7154223323,
-0.2196002454,
-0.20491831,
0.0446661636,
-0.5984145403,
-0.6250320077,
1.4057774544,
0.0271264706,
-0.3653222919,
-0.2367184311,
0.1032994092,
0.4126439989,
-0.3710630536,
0.1358270645,
0.506436646,
0.5870379806,
0.6378343105,
-0.4395486414,
0.1262672544,
-0.2886728346,
-0.3628402948,
0.1269521862,
-0.1771113127,
0.4323530793,
-0.3957327008,
-0.2689506114,
0.0781507641,
1.0618625879,
0.6855496764,
0.8809112906,
0.5358536243,
0.7473689914,
0.6823789477,
-0.2549615502,
0.9630795717,
-0.4930801988,
-0.3513636887,
1.1685558558,
-0.3567267954,
0.4622967839,
0.4927232265,
-0.2547787726,
1.0428147316,
0.5254312754,
0.4341984391,
0.2171130627,
-0.2239509076,
-0.7603852153,
-0.5976848006,
-0.1451493949,
-0.5706216097,
0.1860991418,
0.519967854,
-0.0400300324,
-0.3117580414,
-0.2674580812,
0.398542583,
0.3373922706,
-0.5197122097,
0.649676621,
0.1116027161,
-0.6816309094,
0.1753284335,
-0.0756907538,
0.2245900929,
-0.8216096163,
-0.2384984195,
-0.1542767286,
0.1050320715,
-0.3076420724,
-0.8306940198,
0.4675925374,
-0.0609628931,
-0.3013209105,
-0.0851783752,
0.539337635,
-0.3753455579,
-0.460408181,
-0.1641133875,
0.6768702865,
-0.2464995533,
-0.017630592,
-0.4895097017,
-0.1159018055,
-0.3198239803,
-0.1261951029,
0.1847198606,
0.7185475826,
-0.1747896373,
1.072275281,
0.8660042882,
0.2647801638,
0.055981189,
0.0195245817,
0.7279006243,
-0.5167688131,
-0.4132960439,
-0.7220486403,
0.4235843718,
-0.0263018385,
0.0418036357,
0.5313184857,
0.4576974213,
0.6658759713,
0.0300049745,
0.9396464229,
-0.1178517193,
0.7944207191,
-0.9634231925,
0.3621691465,
-0.2494222969,
0.6697380543,
0.2144445628,
-0.7813186646,
-0.2893413007,
0.2104323506,
-0.7588686943,
-0.038641233,
0.9033762813,
0.666303277,
0.2801406085,
0.1644926369,
0.0249560382,
0.241520673,
0.4907653332,
0.8899128437,
1.3353706598,
-0.1912866682,
0.744768858,
-0.284540683,
-0.2667948902,
0.214704901,
-0.9173516631,
-0.904153049,
-0.4737344682,
-0.4162612557,
-0.3736257255,
0.3894589245,
1.1372437477,
0.4130083621,
-0.8485445976,
0.2788334489,
0.0745970681,
0.3456665874,
-0.4019558132,
-0.2892254293,
0.3698007464,
-0.5556111932,
-0.6061450243,
0.4993957877,
0.1351074576,
-0.0262137149,
-0.0125816036,
0.0135023249,
-0.2951432467,
-0.0455280431,
0.7215214372,
0.7270010114,
-0.4926047027,
-0.5844752192,
0.0155631425,
0.267098099,
-0.1133668348,
0.7637742758,
-0.8620597124,
0.2069964409,
0.4511830211,
0.7413917184,
0.6037749052,
0.1551231444,
0.5951511264,
-0.636785686,
0.1179369465,
0.4905823767,
0.4125705957,
0.1691000164,
-0.4316440225,
0.4950946271,
0.4455341697,
-0.671227634,
-0.5876913667,
0.5054392815,
-0.8483282924,
-0.2944182754,
1.4338178635,
0.0807899833,
-0.2783783078,
-0.7075613141,
0.2167314738,
0.2689569592,
-0.2866189182,
0.9597886801,
0.3377212286,
-0.4787301719,
-0.2412294149,
-0.3973113,
0.408198297,
0.1998131424,
-0.8231753707,
-0.2529321611,
0.4177890122,
0.4915267527,
0.0865062922,
0.6336692572,
-0.6114163995,
0.4031417668,
-0.0570230037,
0.0141091989,
-0.6609172225,
-0.3460339606,
0.0244321935,
0.1122595593,
0.3064984679,
-0.1768112779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09144v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09144v2
|
Grounding Gaps in Language Model Generations
| 2023-11-15T17:40:27 | 2024-04-02T19:34:15 |
Omar Shaikh, Kristina Gligorić, Ashna Khetan, Matthias Gerstgrasser, Diyi Yang, Dan Jurafsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Effective conversation requires common ground: a shared understanding between
the participants. Common ground, however, does not emerge spontaneously in
conversation. Speakers and listeners work together to both identify and
construct a shared basis while avoiding misunderstanding. To accomplish
grounding, humans rely on a range of dialogue acts, like clarification (What do
you mean?) and acknowledgment (I understand.). However, it is unclear whether
large language models (LLMs) generate text that reflects human grounding. To
this end, we curate a set of grounding acts and propose corresponding metrics
that quantify attempted grounding. We study whether LLM generations contain
grounding acts, simulating turn-taking from several dialogue datasets and
comparing results to humans. We find that -- compared to humans -- LLMs
generate language with less conversational grounding, instead generating text
that appears to simply presume common ground. To understand the roots of the
identified grounding gap, we examine the role of instruction tuning and
preference optimization, finding that training on contemporary preference data
leads to a reduction in generated grounding acts. Altogether, we highlight the
need for more research investigating conversational grounding in human-AI
interaction.
|
[
-0.4743219614,
-0.968559444,
0.6885043383,
0.0641231462,
-0.0837573782,
-0.0296560582,
-0.1053152233,
-0.2975636125,
-0.2318852246,
0.4453155994,
-0.6180179119,
-0.4343151152,
-0.6440623403,
-0.2841536999,
-0.152168408,
0.560729444,
0.330390662,
-0.1000224426,
-0.6616031528,
-0.1338132918,
-0.8801224828,
-0.7437447309,
-0.6633166671,
-0.8583187461,
0.0444676429,
0.7657391429,
0.8317008018,
0.7049617171,
0.1787889749,
0.2507775426,
-0.4583079517,
-0.026265569,
-0.6938733459,
0.0527667627,
0.1050898209,
-0.5688732862,
-0.2590183616,
0.3332463205,
0.4919612408,
1.1423069239,
0.0341032334,
-0.3347076476,
-0.0776642114,
0.8437072635,
-0.3269347847,
0.0761414617,
-0.6619167924,
0.2095960677,
-0.0749483779,
-0.2874282002,
-0.3463163078,
-0.1909813136,
0.0947899371,
-0.2801205516,
0.45676741,
-0.0449461825,
1.0058704615,
0.3914378583,
-0.3885352612,
-0.2600870132,
-0.4986115694,
0.6466203332,
-0.7920569181,
0.4113198817,
0.6777796149,
-0.1465385109,
-0.369138211,
-0.1453092694,
-0.4581341147,
-0.5761784315,
0.0022746115,
-0.0370283984,
0.0139934504,
0.3851855993,
0.4870842397,
0.4842927158,
-0.2633645535,
0.1336898059,
-0.2844468951,
0.040818885,
0.3137989342,
0.2497587651,
0.5400828719,
-0.0429912545,
-0.088339448,
-0.1110814437,
-0.964479804,
0.3332027793,
0.3749702573,
0.0668681487,
-0.2751158476,
0.4465113878,
-0.3047272861,
0.8101024032,
0.2033270597,
0.1099126935,
-0.0648704916,
0.0400472246,
-0.1516020149,
-0.0083639789,
0.4780923426,
0.8876778483,
0.4173676074,
-0.3098920584,
0.0390497856,
0.2313551903,
0.1989590228,
-0.6358013153,
-0.1125122979,
0.018568242,
-0.3329282999,
-0.4760773778,
0.0831454992,
-0.6356503367,
-0.5076826811,
-0.5862177014,
-0.1273023188,
-0.4253204167,
-0.1552690715,
0.124890849,
-0.2639735341,
0.3959902823,
0.1799887419,
-1.0697473288,
0.5155145526,
0.6714198589,
0.8142184019,
-0.0060059521,
-0.4187957644,
-0.3840976357,
-0.0162810124,
-0.4713650048,
0.702398181,
-0.6229555607,
-0.6365769506,
-0.1087014526,
-0.2178694159,
-0.104420349,
-0.6152796149,
0.6516900659,
-0.3065739572,
0.3651488721,
-0.4241042137,
-0.6708916426,
-0.1586759388,
0.2314985991,
-0.3628834188,
0.9345981479,
-0.0713757202,
-0.7334051132,
0.4210816026,
-0.4715895653,
-0.3773821294,
0.0165478475,
-0.4917674959,
-0.2586663961,
0.3453522921,
0.1533474773,
0.3868324161,
-0.3690851927,
0.4510974288,
-0.1304565668,
-0.4821121097,
0.2073747218,
-0.5338969231,
0.5401155353,
-0.0016560251,
-0.5947134495,
-0.0239595082,
-0.736301899,
-0.0206231214,
0.1555425078,
-0.3560127318,
-0.3871887028,
0.4235079885,
-0.214422524,
0.2728924453,
-0.0151919238,
-0.1387870014,
0.1434092224,
-0.6278048754,
0.6023125052,
0.6135239005,
0.0150224734,
0.4650396407,
-0.5519766808,
0.2359663844,
0.1116932705,
-0.3195489347,
-0.3788579702,
-0.5546961427,
-1.1945126057,
0.2901230752,
0.0398778804,
0.4916383624,
-0.1780968159,
0.6908771396,
-0.2639780343,
-0.2836083472,
-0.4054285884,
-0.0455923565,
0.3786708415,
0.6206896305,
0.1758605391,
-0.2022579163,
-0.413825959,
-0.8336815834,
-0.1861481965,
-0.266338408,
-0.0252951309,
0.449085176,
0.0426350795,
-0.1605193168,
1.2146072388,
-0.3614856601,
0.2473862767,
-0.3279264867,
0.4228006899,
-0.0460185483,
0.5723133683,
0.4810246527,
-0.7778450847,
-0.3047670126,
-0.1630564779,
-0.8139944673,
-0.2706680596,
-0.27829656,
0.0080278898,
-0.0285026934,
0.7952628732,
-0.8228781223,
0.4246884286,
0.5289189219,
-0.3559051156,
0.1824835241,
-0.1009248197,
0.2983545661,
-0.9115110636,
-0.1623417735,
-0.0646999255,
-0.1624811441,
-0.8211869001,
-0.0836459324,
-0.180396691,
-0.2464640886,
-0.224082619,
0.3378183544,
-0.4862673283,
-0.0953975916,
-0.3328772485,
0.2536537945,
0.05331368,
0.4276361167,
0.1285601407,
1.1414574385,
0.5456462502,
-0.8422544599,
-0.217534259,
0.2445714623,
-0.1669403911,
0.385887742,
-0.8625596166,
0.5460262895,
-0.24329786,
0.2675566375,
-0.9069126248,
-0.2773700356,
0.1790727973,
-0.5739204884,
-0.0042613628,
-0.3870223165,
-0.1554344296,
-0.1333561689,
0.0143994223,
0.2814858258,
0.7059589624,
-0.3267350495,
0.2716585696,
0.5103515983,
-0.2352894247,
-0.3017807305,
-0.4533806443,
0.3460060358,
-0.4618941247,
-1.0326753855,
0.2635625899,
-0.1173272207,
-0.5138862133,
-0.3923043609,
-0.0744167566,
0.0271456279,
0.4145927131,
0.5456082225,
-0.1163874418,
-0.3415595591,
0.0467926227,
-0.0433671996,
-0.316349417,
0.2702696919,
-0.0712993219,
0.9252514243,
-0.1301815361,
-0.4560875893,
-0.5345499516,
0.4373648465,
0.9054033756,
0.0581133328,
0.8459864855,
0.0735987127,
-0.3535373807,
0.2233601213,
-0.6662088037,
-0.1530096084,
-0.4585851729,
0.1043599099,
-0.4261169434,
-0.9286302924,
0.416028589,
-0.2253796011,
-0.0171643179,
0.3818914294,
0.4350102842,
-0.0910011977,
1.1769016981,
0.7136797905,
-0.1767355502,
0.3515621424,
-0.0160937477,
0.2122588158,
-0.612752974,
-0.1446326822,
-0.6741563678,
0.0359638594,
-0.3800017834,
-0.3858737946,
-0.0370382071,
0.4964009523,
-0.0537879355,
-0.0905811638,
-0.2679548264,
0.7695227265,
0.6181970239,
-0.1499973834,
0.0544160716,
0.1281549335,
-0.0115262689,
-0.267477423,
-0.6104694605,
-0.7430158854,
0.6656020284,
0.3851591945,
0.5236190557,
-0.2314947844,
0.598085165,
0.2682880461,
0.0742370114,
-0.6245671511,
0.481671989,
0.0650698319,
-0.2679812014,
-0.2379378676,
-0.4892030358,
-0.905343473,
0.1445018053,
-0.1416314542,
-0.719126761,
-0.1825804263,
0.1069090217,
-0.128856495,
0.0927513242,
-0.7017583847,
0.7854993343,
-0.109579578,
-0.1796077639,
-0.2886410952,
-0.8914211988,
0.2702713907,
0.4507513344,
0.3153493106,
-0.2239279002,
0.6328449845,
0.7483648658,
-0.2273887247,
0.9203457236,
-0.2539696395,
-0.2079657465,
0.3490431309,
-0.1131541133,
0.3514741063,
0.0113866739,
0.1280394644,
0.2036001235,
-0.5835946798,
-0.4712094665,
-0.3491301239,
0.551604867,
-1.0712053776,
-0.8252035975,
-0.3242252767,
-0.4182989299,
-0.3404701054,
0.0923885554,
0.4501206279,
0.1943544745,
-0.6522963047,
0.2232649922,
0.9158468843,
-0.2127801925,
0.2532647848,
0.3654597998,
0.0014057542,
-0.2572156489,
0.7766577601,
-0.2175665796,
0.4780991077,
0.227808699,
0.2645698786,
0.0178162027,
-0.5809217095,
-0.4334990382,
0.0934899226,
-0.6848862767,
0.1474041492,
-0.8317750096,
-0.3980758786,
-0.5029870868,
-0.3872082233,
-0.1672401279,
-0.2866957486,
-0.3940823376,
-0.3853720129,
0.1180631295,
0.8446112275,
0.0133652557,
0.6762498021,
-1.0008171797,
0.3279310763,
0.4071950018,
0.046370279,
-0.0193559416,
-0.4685595334,
-0.0945591182,
0.4885212183,
-0.4279822409,
-0.7621317506,
0.1718321294,
0.078914322,
0.5121535063,
0.3573601246,
-0.179507345,
0.8338441253,
-0.7581339478,
1.096295476,
0.2929268181,
-1.1856799126,
0.6462645531,
-0.5245661736,
0.2115325332,
0.5740883946,
-0.0541594215,
-1.0345965624,
-0.4336695671,
-0.7907226682,
-0.9452315569,
0.8202776909,
0.4213806689,
0.4398611784,
-0.0651773363,
0.2555256188,
-0.0453710072,
0.087898396,
-0.7762309313,
-0.3014636934,
-0.092355676,
0.068500489,
-0.2404400557,
-0.368573457,
-0.4170313776,
-0.1016904414,
0.2915137708,
0.0309843142,
0.1625552773,
-0.1214234456,
-0.2000953853,
-0.4990282953,
0.384753406,
0.9692792296,
0.5000960231,
-0.1403422952,
0.1527596712,
0.088310644,
-0.2234874815,
0.2336665988,
-0.2471016943,
-0.1668082923,
-0.0438691862,
0.2621401846,
1.2201507092,
0.1613957137,
-0.6114755869,
0.4114364982,
-0.1580619365,
-0.1020978466,
-0.2191815823,
0.2805637717,
0.2639506757,
-0.0489849448,
0.251122117,
0.2599414289,
-0.1098707467,
-0.47474733,
0.2449742407,
0.2839949131,
-0.3265247941,
-0.2467603087,
0.5133268833,
0.5033553243,
-0.6418015957,
0.7920276523,
0.0244278293,
-0.6268254519,
0.7712693214,
0.5490478873,
0.8351952434,
0.0116771255,
0.1895649582,
0.0474845432,
0.2736821175,
-0.161049962,
-0.192447111,
-0.0922445953,
-0.8686800003,
-0.2516104281,
-0.2594302893,
-0.5442947745,
0.3239441514,
-0.6008674502,
0.3479067385,
-0.3857378364,
0.0396887138,
-0.2982301414,
-0.1485743672,
-0.4972659051,
0.3417121172,
0.5321461558,
0.6403078437,
-1.2154664993,
0.4625473917,
0.5678851008,
-0.3462507725,
-0.6371002197,
0.4851567447,
-0.0655271187,
-0.6504772902,
0.6302626729,
0.6754817963,
-0.2254491448,
0.1236552596,
-0.7656931877,
-0.7092151046,
0.8969874978,
0.2548234463,
-0.3594208956,
-0.2058932483,
0.4309186637,
0.451852113,
-0.4274291694,
0.157764405,
0.6557420492,
0.3079847395,
0.103509523,
-0.5882248878,
-0.1898892671,
-0.1784307212,
-0.0158627369,
0.1329585612,
-0.7666803002,
0.896027863,
0.1464924514,
-0.3204859197,
0.0125830118,
0.5132959485,
0.5251740217,
0.6071279049,
0.4997451901,
0.8961971402,
0.6795444489,
-0.2078594416,
0.7946489453,
-0.4108894169,
0.1536370665,
0.9394932389,
-0.2956081629,
0.4035911262,
0.3338361979,
-0.1299130321,
0.361713469,
0.6802324653,
0.4630303383,
0.3211568296,
0.2491057962,
-0.1424846947,
-0.3794210851,
-0.03075701,
-0.5760153532,
0.3427874446,
0.614772737,
-0.1026772335,
-0.1522274911,
-0.2347306162,
0.0662004948,
0.1328110397,
-0.0316066369,
0.9271247983,
0.0849731341,
-0.8740817308,
0.7667712569,
0.0844772011,
0.5427529812,
-0.2985250652,
-0.1309499443,
-0.5659527779,
-0.2519576252,
-0.010120023,
-0.5435715914,
0.0484011918,
0.0230306406,
-0.389898777,
-0.3759402037,
0.657245338,
-0.4209827483,
0.0127230864,
0.1992326677,
0.6327831745,
0.3101540506,
0.1811059564,
-0.5863562226,
0.1346175224,
0.107102789,
-0.155024752,
0.4079315066,
0.6571900845,
-0.0358600989,
0.5823662281,
0.757014811,
-0.0153136961,
0.268116653,
0.3648324311,
0.9753454328,
-0.8206047416,
-0.5983478427,
-0.7771624327,
0.7604860663,
-0.3070839643,
-0.3907311261,
0.5094610453,
0.3569698632,
0.6279128194,
0.0367930681,
0.9117494822,
-0.0971741006,
0.3345973492,
-0.9240682125,
0.5564392209,
-0.3422074914,
0.3535972536,
-0.1476814598,
-1.0093910694,
-0.0788362846,
0.8593124151,
-0.3236947954,
0.1020780355,
0.6189225912,
0.6201034784,
-0.0855789483,
-0.0015378615,
0.6346423626,
0.006071256,
0.4004491866,
0.4511899948,
1.2642012835,
-0.2043450326,
0.0579323098,
0.0703862533,
-0.1647396386,
-0.2623492777,
-0.6787477732,
-1.101573348,
-0.3867734671,
-0.1548071057,
-0.2982425392,
0.2799461782,
0.9965735078,
0.7566031814,
-0.7333490252,
-0.3545217812,
-0.8627462387,
0.0505305901,
0.1256418228,
-0.2669442296,
0.0167573746,
-0.6502646208,
-0.7233629227,
0.6677453518,
0.0686965436,
0.3201890886,
-0.0099494802,
-0.2722128332,
0.0349187814,
0.1584807783,
0.2703461945,
0.3595151305,
-0.7686716914,
-0.4285164177,
-0.0529202186,
-0.1988477111,
0.5159181952,
1.2718673944,
-0.6983848214,
0.1266004741,
0.3369675279,
0.7774272561,
0.1768623441,
0.3398746848,
0.8793455958,
-1.0423529148,
0.5277554989,
0.2278164178,
0.1086354554,
0.6016358137,
-0.3744529486,
0.305999577,
0.4079406559,
-0.7791710496,
-0.7557584643,
0.3362025023,
-0.6633005738,
-0.1717081368,
1.1663770676,
-0.0830681026,
0.2535520196,
-0.1839634776,
-0.3448622227,
0.2291724086,
-0.4770410359,
0.8828678131,
1.1288912296,
-0.0638440996,
-0.2873769701,
-0.3629026711,
0.6353522539,
0.7232509255,
-0.8724150658,
0.35869205,
0.8127040267,
0.2145934254,
0.2296604961,
0.7276741862,
0.3770522773,
0.1088487804,
0.1332823783,
-0.0593482293,
0.3315747976,
-0.4417469501,
-0.4551458657,
0.0312653594,
0.3704634607,
0.0265113227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09136v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09136v2
|
Rescue: Ranking LLM Responses with Partial Ordering to Improve Response Generation
| 2023-11-15T17:27:14 | 2024-02-17T01:37:09 |
Yikun Wang, Rui Zheng, Haoming Li, Qi Zhang, Tao Gui, Fei Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Customizing LLMs for a specific task involves distinguishing effective
responses from erroneous ones. This skill can be developed using supervised
fine-tuning with extensive human preference data. However, obtaining
expert-annotated preference data is expensive for most tasks. In this paper, we
present a novel method to optimize LLMs using ranking metrics. This method
trains the model to prioritize the best responses from a pool of candidates
created for a particular task. Rather than a traditional full ordering, we
advocate for a partial ordering, as achieving consensus on the perfect order of
candidate responses can be challenging. Our partial ordering is more robust,
less sensitive to noise, and can be achieved with limited human annotations or
through heuristic methods. We test our system's improved response generation
ability using benchmark datasets, including the latest multi-document question
answering task. We conduct ablation studies to understand crucial factors, such
as how to gather candidate responses for specific tasks, determine their most
suitable order, and balance supervised fine-tuning with ranking metrics. Our
approach, named \textsc{Rescue}, suggests a promising avenue for enhancing
LLMs' contextual understanding via response ranking.
|
[
-0.5837730169,
-0.58434093,
0.3292779922,
0.0137181981,
-0.2077259719,
0.3281633258,
-0.0943451822,
-0.3056158721,
0.3655058444,
0.6669023037,
-0.4928558469,
-0.3594910502,
-0.528832376,
0.3309834003,
-0.2581648827,
1.195021987,
0.3510617316,
0.0617324561,
-0.564614594,
-0.0183447581,
-0.4497447014,
-0.6277258992,
-1.0776304007,
-0.2876936495,
0.9141020775,
0.7022852302,
0.476192981,
0.7658780217,
0.8649953008,
0.3607971966,
-0.1532143503,
0.5007610917,
-0.6803974509,
0.1988412738,
0.0138309626,
-0.4285053611,
-0.7123766541,
0.1373178661,
0.1751826406,
0.620336771,
-0.4109584689,
0.3983071744,
0.0245230459,
0.742960155,
-0.6950699091,
-0.2137122601,
-0.8954328299,
0.0958466753,
0.2103993595,
-0.7156869769,
-0.5056763887,
-0.4575463235,
0.298719883,
-0.3743161559,
0.6631162167,
0.3692748845,
0.448454082,
0.3876999319,
-0.1407847106,
-0.1162842289,
-0.5229591727,
0.6507384777,
-0.4748641551,
0.0726022273,
0.650069952,
0.3372308016,
-0.1000225991,
-0.56527704,
-0.1487738043,
-0.0315534621,
-0.171363458,
0.5846470594,
0.1829290539,
0.182715252,
0.2106419951,
0.4133684635,
-0.5912843347,
0.2048796117,
-0.1379621029,
-0.2430614531,
0.6529754996,
0.3838586211,
0.0424448401,
-0.2233960032,
-0.3291386664,
-0.2104436755,
-0.6325517893,
0.1237550303,
0.4010452032,
0.5848852396,
0.1104134843,
0.516684413,
-0.4656548798,
0.6281397939,
0.294018656,
-0.0879018456,
0.2313370556,
-0.4542334378,
-0.3170820475,
0.1905085593,
0.4886452854,
0.6061025262,
-0.1389236897,
-0.2220113128,
-0.2417135835,
-0.0864565521,
0.7378316522,
-0.7465654016,
-0.1470221877,
0.2005348504,
-0.4044314325,
-0.5222454667,
-0.1808419377,
-0.6685901284,
-0.632635653,
-0.2281575948,
0.2028579712,
0.0377063528,
-0.1349315196,
0.1979159564,
0.0631707981,
0.1880845428,
0.5339574218,
-0.9211871028,
0.1490711719,
0.4809935093,
0.678968668,
-0.1957235038,
0.0934370756,
-1.0275789499,
0.0860800296,
-0.2300824225,
1.1462205648,
-0.4434732199,
-0.5193163157,
0.1859951466,
-0.093459256,
0.2161856294,
-0.8118557334,
0.7962532043,
-0.7157664895,
0.2831990123,
-0.4851226807,
-0.2915973067,
0.1461798549,
0.504283905,
-0.3802845776,
1.0654090643,
-0.161230132,
-0.9445433021,
0.1229971647,
-0.5468674302,
-0.2671743333,
-0.1592608392,
0.1101808399,
-0.5594879389,
0.2285102159,
0.3813894987,
0.6131308079,
-0.3827473819,
-0.1344633698,
-0.3013603389,
-0.2298242748,
0.0427393429,
-0.0795849338,
0.2303220481,
0.2692584395,
0.0263767373,
0.2944270372,
-0.5354834199,
0.0138876345,
0.2731834352,
-0.6893333197,
-0.3638752103,
0.1599595547,
-0.2595296502,
-0.0346115828,
0.4540891647,
-0.5494349003,
-0.0283659231,
-0.6508517265,
0.0950818285,
0.9077576399,
0.2551806569,
0.7569875717,
-0.5789287686,
0.4719471931,
-0.115033716,
0.1953091323,
0.0566993579,
-0.1874054223,
-0.9415791631,
-0.1415315568,
0.0289226416,
0.620012939,
-0.613112092,
0.4173672199,
-0.1557143331,
-0.2932498753,
-0.6457085013,
0.168287456,
0.5730367899,
0.9004404545,
0.5442199111,
-0.3291534185,
-0.6043087244,
-1.090088129,
-0.0721545964,
-0.2919137478,
-0.282205224,
0.5189663172,
-0.0761523545,
0.0629765019,
0.7943469882,
-0.8208630085,
-0.1227954105,
-0.2078862786,
-0.0118724918,
0.227892518,
0.1896981597,
0.3325750828,
-0.8499569893,
-0.2565919161,
-0.2125428617,
-0.5009840131,
-0.1942309886,
0.023733614,
-0.5126059055,
0.092099309,
0.2520801723,
-0.3089535832,
0.1738131195,
0.0122436127,
0.0462722071,
0.2117573321,
-0.3119634688,
0.1856399626,
-1.4427739382,
0.1298007667,
-0.0966237113,
-0.319501996,
-0.6051168442,
0.0390836336,
0.004352367,
0.0299920589,
-0.274821192,
0.3504201174,
-0.4067256153,
-0.1714459956,
-0.3072244227,
0.1878230125,
-0.35675776,
0.4374486804,
0.0874671713,
0.5298500061,
0.0407575667,
-0.4248026013,
0.2838909328,
0.7208411694,
0.0035996307,
0.619918108,
-0.5114928484,
0.595441699,
-0.4600019157,
-0.0070655537,
-1.383684516,
-0.4148368835,
0.0393317714,
-0.5668310523,
0.3064474165,
-0.3263257742,
-0.6144676805,
-0.3931013346,
-0.5221154094,
0.0701618195,
0.5042939186,
-0.4554668665,
0.2983039916,
0.3311220407,
-0.4451743066,
-0.6584531665,
-0.2510498464,
-0.1094126999,
-0.3958041668,
-0.1939176172,
0.2148451805,
-0.7308508158,
-0.0014578003,
-0.3844765425,
-0.4033289552,
0.0695868805,
0.378369689,
0.1704441756,
0.3704473972,
-0.0092494525,
-0.1712100059,
0.2134006768,
-0.2336304188,
-0.0142228324,
0.1948180199,
0.4113690853,
0.2167676091,
-0.1652515978,
-0.0456397645,
0.3511130214,
0.4980892837,
-0.4165204167,
0.5253002644,
0.3191761672,
-0.2968430221,
-0.005331167,
-0.7972870469,
-0.3806618452,
-0.5342717171,
0.2817897499,
-0.1105528995,
-0.7323440313,
0.4109998345,
-0.0477287248,
0.5374760628,
-0.1266174316,
0.7548235655,
-0.2614217997,
1.2146128416,
0.5890336633,
-0.4728093147,
0.7525209785,
-0.1812755764,
0.0008729763,
-0.7642610669,
-0.2697830796,
-0.6477998495,
-0.3777313828,
-0.2593584359,
-0.1608032137,
0.6702280045,
0.0474771746,
-0.2929695249,
0.1493278295,
-0.8227879405,
0.6156781912,
0.4318884015,
0.3767376542,
0.3972302973,
0.3474850953,
-0.0360009298,
0.0994078442,
-0.5464084744,
-0.4607196748,
1.0992712975,
0.071889922,
0.5908131003,
0.083442539,
1.0045119524,
0.1224587783,
0.5048679709,
-0.775521934,
0.6197140217,
-0.0247953683,
-0.4136126041,
-0.3267417252,
-0.5034745336,
-1.0818030834,
0.4081737995,
-0.43622908,
-0.4791197777,
-0.3046517074,
0.0948400199,
-0.6756930351,
-0.1213565767,
-0.5861778855,
0.3025009334,
-0.0941576734,
-0.3093827963,
-0.1940667182,
-0.9423608184,
0.101363726,
-0.0497246757,
0.0082578529,
-0.1820195764,
-0.1965446174,
0.6374515295,
-0.2409516871,
0.6586928368,
-0.2500887215,
0.1315201223,
-0.186048314,
0.0408594869,
0.5307676196,
0.1458251923,
-0.4334444106,
-0.5157295465,
-0.2645379603,
-0.4797502458,
-0.6187144518,
0.818374753,
-0.7011360526,
-0.8053238988,
-0.1299879104,
-0.5269342065,
-0.5334672332,
0.2016859055,
0.3579948246,
0.2791460752,
0.1902768314,
0.1028608754,
0.8489687443,
-0.1585719436,
0.4979831874,
0.7690900564,
0.3256901503,
-0.8979313374,
0.6138238907,
0.0218336545,
-0.0023594142,
0.5624294281,
0.1051364839,
-0.415800184,
-0.99631387,
-0.286634177,
0.1893111169,
-0.4398967922,
-0.6586357951,
-0.6926399469,
-0.1195227727,
-0.3337871432,
-0.2764839232,
-0.1865901649,
-0.1086829603,
-0.3588320017,
-0.404728353,
0.2194985449,
0.5385400057,
0.2094725519,
0.0941295177,
-0.7255827188,
0.5381823182,
0.2897088826,
0.1594800502,
0.0952072591,
-0.496855557,
-0.2230605781,
-0.0433562212,
-0.5440639257,
-0.6593489647,
0.301802516,
0.004355696,
0.8306229711,
0.1002024561,
0.6378658414,
0.8928638101,
-0.6239166856,
0.5192744732,
0.2174074054,
-0.2808254659,
0.8443588614,
-0.3845247328,
0.0902862549,
0.6893907785,
0.3016005754,
-0.3420515656,
-0.5744675398,
-0.4829280376,
-1.2127207518,
0.7744759917,
0.2660136223,
0.2654081583,
-0.1591808498,
0.7152321935,
-0.0088219531,
0.3777400255,
-0.2728837729,
-0.32277897,
0.0580598675,
-0.2474909276,
-0.2184273154,
-0.2157146484,
-0.4248734713,
-0.0960263461,
0.4298333824,
-0.3441771865,
0.3146729767,
0.3356305957,
0.0848760828,
-0.1536668837,
-0.0040605594,
0.5499076247,
0.2573672235,
-0.3013177812,
0.07774847,
0.2424021065,
-0.2258728743,
0.1237168685,
0.0999547392,
0.1718775183,
-0.4068930149,
0.3295434117,
0.3434295356,
0.1532759368,
-0.4756752849,
0.4033394754,
-0.2543732822,
0.0089565609,
-0.1966247857,
0.1785994768,
0.1085684001,
0.3318575025,
0.496556133,
0.0870014876,
0.2956648767,
-0.2724987268,
0.0451119095,
0.571242094,
0.1487461627,
-0.1446411014,
0.682849884,
0.4650675356,
-0.3941907585,
0.6494097114,
0.2066862583,
-0.2188137621,
0.6561578512,
0.4231517315,
0.7943819761,
-0.2358544171,
0.180657059,
0.4026910365,
0.1004024446,
-0.2689423561,
0.2268534154,
-0.2039783895,
-0.6323897243,
-0.0680376664,
-0.8096476197,
-0.5728904009,
0.1502652913,
-0.9854219556,
0.0226671603,
-0.8291914463,
-0.3055903018,
-0.1039045304,
0.1446843296,
-0.5984000564,
0.1181925386,
-0.0060129445,
0.7719772458,
-0.5727593899,
0.329732269,
1.0215089321,
-0.3639449775,
-0.5644642711,
0.1739137024,
-0.1248272136,
-0.8268003464,
0.3505347669,
0.1040076613,
-0.1653189212,
0.1840103269,
-0.5405429006,
-0.8558334708,
1.1483384371,
0.7722588181,
-0.148084417,
-0.0046064355,
-0.1580449343,
0.6595816016,
-0.3106790483,
0.4730996788,
0.2731961906,
0.1230108365,
0.2630648613,
-0.9574949145,
0.1219260246,
-0.2504183054,
0.1589498818,
0.1663657725,
-0.790974617,
0.0612392128,
-0.3281960487,
-0.162681669,
0.5581330061,
0.369581461,
0.4101272225,
0.4547592402,
0.5500537753,
0.3892860711,
0.8451808691,
0.0650004297,
0.9663870335,
-0.1127910763,
0.3783052266,
1.050508976,
-0.2531378865,
1.0776535273,
0.4838043153,
-0.0137022492,
0.1083476245,
1.1772162914,
0.3381126821,
0.9191212654,
0.3940116763,
-0.2357215732,
-0.5353984833,
-0.2574064732,
-0.1451560557,
0.0721658692,
0.0271542538,
-0.344307065,
-0.229422465,
-0.0487782247,
-0.11946854,
0.0944451019,
-0.2592550218,
1.191221714,
-0.1153881997,
-0.6520766616,
0.9118936062,
-0.2069059461,
0.5871136785,
-0.4416877031,
0.0185539071,
-0.8573870063,
0.0310950652,
-0.3890076876,
-0.5707802176,
-0.0016122271,
0.0900623575,
-0.692234695,
-0.4844096601,
0.3725948036,
-0.3837625682,
-0.3578765094,
0.2770413458,
0.5239194036,
0.1347680986,
0.1813186854,
-0.7231215239,
-0.1813492626,
-0.1664023846,
-0.5406527519,
0.6692529917,
-0.0670735911,
0.1373061091,
0.7133526206,
0.8027873635,
-0.0095924996,
-0.1185456663,
0.0019941819,
0.8954462409,
-0.3840922415,
-0.374777317,
-0.5948708057,
0.5357787013,
-0.3142514825,
0.0318873711,
0.5499521494,
0.678401947,
0.7207621336,
-0.1603338569,
0.6377677917,
0.2109429985,
0.6891365051,
-0.5478162169,
0.6028923392,
-0.8191862106,
0.4845153987,
-0.3600910604,
-0.9156411886,
-0.4204030931,
0.4327961802,
-0.1765276939,
-0.0337304659,
0.4944921732,
1.0429910421,
-0.0197866149,
-0.3304594159,
0.3829152882,
0.0934512317,
0.2723542154,
0.6457436681,
0.759788692,
-0.0838613063,
0.7305880785,
-0.1200486422,
-0.2427907139,
-0.2140085399,
-0.5525672436,
-0.9724189639,
-0.3349635601,
-0.168082118,
-0.3156509697,
0.0309853666,
1.1152406931,
0.79904145,
-0.5838625431,
-0.1305624098,
0.1322274655,
0.0866658762,
0.0699422657,
-0.1822581887,
0.2449129224,
-0.4267640114,
-0.8768603802,
0.6519752741,
0.122630544,
0.0172039326,
0.0567400195,
-0.1159620956,
0.1869460493,
0.0685957596,
0.5809383988,
0.0170283727,
-0.7244285941,
-0.4094775617,
0.2174230814,
-0.1360501498,
0.1566980332,
0.780587852,
-0.7415748835,
0.4095384181,
0.6515668035,
0.916359365,
0.38907969,
0.2783046365,
0.3802334666,
-0.9374044538,
-0.2253156006,
0.1980321109,
0.2801327407,
0.4873901904,
-0.73535496,
0.7739701271,
0.1741964966,
-0.5673048496,
-1.0835953951,
0.3155709803,
-1.0576734543,
0.0031454586,
1.1186375618,
-0.161154151,
0.160077855,
-0.0503451489,
-0.545157969,
0.1976042092,
-0.6753041744,
1.0695621967,
0.4156882167,
-0.6073835492,
-0.1310922503,
-0.4847036004,
0.3960413039,
0.6532201171,
-0.8835498691,
0.1655867249,
0.5089741945,
0.489382267,
0.286452055,
0.7835285068,
0.0305469166,
0.1692126989,
-0.6016461849,
-0.3048650324,
-0.0760249794,
-0.2254326344,
-0.2121870071,
0.4954795241,
0.2539497614,
-0.3067359626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09132v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09132v1
|
Aligning Neural Machine Translation Models: Human Feedback in Training and Inference
| 2023-11-15T17:21:58 | 2023-11-15T17:21:58 |
Miguel Moura Ramos, Patrick Fernandes, António Farinhas, André F. T. Martins
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) is a recent technique to
improve the quality of the text generated by a language model, making it closer
to what humans would generate. A core ingredient in RLHF's success in aligning
and improving large language models (LLMs) is its reward model, trained using
human feedback on model outputs. In machine translation (MT), where metrics
trained from human annotations can readily be used as reward models, recent
methods using minimum Bayes risk decoding and reranking have succeeded in
improving the final quality of translation. In this study, we comprehensively
explore and compare techniques for integrating quality metrics as reward models
into the MT pipeline. This includes using the reward model for data filtering,
during the training phase through RL, and at inference time by employing
reranking techniques, and we assess the effects of combining these in a unified
approach. Our experimental results, conducted across multiple translation
tasks, underscore the crucial role of effective data filtering, based on
estimated quality, in harnessing the full potential of RL in enhancing MT
quality. Furthermore, our findings demonstrate the effectiveness of combining
RL training with reranking techniques, showcasing substantial improvements in
translation quality.
|
[
-0.0642028823,
-0.1659258455,
0.4420617521,
0.0096703861,
-0.2985958159,
0.1964540631,
-0.3144617677,
-0.3633857369,
0.204758659,
0.5140433311,
-0.6125060916,
-0.5466227531,
-0.7330284119,
0.0692069754,
-0.2946563661,
1.1558505297,
-0.2069433331,
0.307286799,
-0.2305124104,
-0.2516008914,
-0.5380109549,
-0.8784642816,
-0.689216733,
-0.7587179542,
1.0569199324,
0.1361738741,
0.8311774731,
0.9152719975,
0.6297944784,
0.2508524954,
0.1155146286,
0.3604045212,
-0.4454390705,
0.3436388969,
-0.2514847815,
-0.704208672,
-0.2166327685,
0.2958682477,
0.6203814149,
0.6912875175,
-0.3942877948,
0.0880293399,
0.1879623383,
0.8177207112,
-0.5926680565,
-0.0524409376,
-0.1451976895,
0.359975636,
0.1667143852,
-0.3874034584,
-0.5802217722,
-0.5412435532,
-0.09419889,
-0.5253022909,
-0.0442380868,
0.2147379369,
0.9531319737,
0.6433081031,
-0.319768399,
-0.0729002282,
-0.4807082117,
1.040584445,
-0.9290973544,
0.4609764218,
0.2845251262,
0.1777586341,
-0.2978212237,
-0.5848660469,
-0.2483830303,
-0.1841648966,
-0.3177196383,
0.2471401542,
0.111083746,
-0.0442058407,
-0.0211794134,
0.36846596,
-0.3642854095,
0.4129236937,
-0.1888662428,
-0.199228406,
0.7664126158,
0.2458527833,
0.2131962329,
-0.1774330288,
-0.3092035949,
-0.723484695,
-0.7786344886,
0.3923722506,
0.4181713462,
0.4661093354,
0.1650516987,
0.479385972,
-0.2233189046,
0.7459240556,
-0.1850771755,
-0.2198067158,
0.160782516,
-0.3037278354,
-0.1894853711,
-0.105435878,
0.9925377369,
0.4342679381,
0.1045698673,
-0.3698454499,
-0.6669219136,
-0.034556251,
0.5651425719,
-0.523345232,
-0.031565506,
0.2037293464,
-0.7906112671,
-0.6313512921,
0.1998034716,
-0.5030791163,
-0.3470070362,
-0.3938021064,
0.4307551682,
-0.1195723861,
-0.2004587352,
-0.0290145893,
-0.2148029506,
0.140628919,
0.2378370762,
-1.0094704628,
0.2008370757,
0.8327717781,
0.696115911,
-0.4958422482,
-0.4411205351,
-0.8888654113,
-0.2227724344,
-0.5553744435,
0.7238385081,
-0.0864317194,
-0.2708489895,
0.1680099219,
-0.0739996284,
-0.0387710109,
-0.7508157492,
0.8330748081,
-0.7242055535,
0.2790666819,
-0.2134865075,
-0.6017768383,
-0.2369050533,
0.213194713,
-0.5948052406,
1.0005463362,
0.190956369,
-0.4225306213,
0.5241619945,
-0.4264971614,
-0.440461278,
-0.1139680222,
-0.0511351377,
-0.4359998703,
0.3269468844,
0.4126661122,
0.3220430613,
-0.3263294101,
0.5490534902,
-0.1694357395,
-0.3513511717,
0.696598053,
-0.4791533053,
0.2502634525,
0.3698543608,
-0.1843797714,
0.5576539636,
-0.2237652689,
0.2717405856,
-0.0575142987,
-0.7566771507,
-0.0801725462,
0.1582935899,
0.0485178083,
0.3097942472,
-0.2084121853,
-0.3371488154,
0.1835942119,
-0.5799824595,
0.5528495908,
0.6755668521,
-0.0191008747,
0.4411942661,
-0.4774212539,
0.5230497718,
0.0515811741,
0.0807949379,
0.0702542514,
-0.3731281459,
-0.5649572611,
-0.0519920997,
0.8665364385,
0.4954115152,
-0.7060050964,
0.4117455482,
-0.5110319257,
-0.1952084303,
-1.1940678358,
0.1856963187,
0.5384408236,
0.274844408,
0.3701634407,
-0.5668577552,
-0.2844083607,
-0.8079091907,
-0.457153827,
-0.1456284225,
-0.2318619639,
-0.0636541918,
0.2437488139,
0.1417427212,
0.7187247872,
-0.2150046974,
-0.1847524494,
-0.2951668501,
0.3670644164,
0.3485943377,
0.663544476,
0.0690572411,
-0.6253290772,
-0.3022099137,
-0.0267667379,
-0.7356345654,
-0.0018236807,
-0.1156483516,
-0.1926652342,
0.2077510953,
0.4008589089,
-0.2485474497,
0.391171813,
0.6637942195,
-0.2306312472,
0.3652351201,
-0.3750786781,
0.562323451,
-0.7053070664,
-0.0243838821,
-0.0933880061,
-0.5743895769,
-0.461637646,
0.1752843857,
0.2082241327,
0.1592270285,
-0.4234803319,
0.4332653284,
-0.2273613811,
-0.3170102537,
-0.5681166053,
0.2589994371,
-0.007916539,
0.6793419719,
0.1472974271,
0.7810943723,
-0.0733674616,
-0.548614502,
0.3915908635,
0.0762179121,
-0.4872814417,
0.5950007439,
-0.6165567636,
-0.0581293851,
0.0299108941,
0.208711803,
-0.9757347703,
-0.0334008373,
0.4308463037,
-0.7712379694,
0.283054024,
-0.0942303017,
-0.6103206873,
-0.1682442725,
-0.1677344143,
0.1951294243,
0.6131904721,
-0.7225615978,
0.2991815805,
0.2691337168,
-0.0499652401,
-0.7183555365,
-0.8158875704,
0.1402383596,
-0.2425795197,
-0.3233980834,
0.5265517831,
0.2157663405,
0.1099045426,
0.2222314924,
-0.0410083719,
0.084562555,
0.2171344906,
0.271481365,
0.363355577,
-0.1051268578,
0.1611266434,
0.0183917377,
-0.3837649524,
0.104316622,
-0.5203267932,
0.2087500393,
0.2257380933,
-0.5355356336,
-0.7303366065,
0.2695434093,
0.4090286791,
-0.2951054871,
0.8744310141,
0.618915379,
-0.0899385065,
-0.0932602435,
-0.4914497137,
-0.5709443092,
-0.378034085,
0.2813338339,
-0.1257051975,
-1.0093904734,
0.2485742122,
0.0215982199,
0.2471636981,
0.399852097,
0.46009624,
-0.3463997245,
1.4092744589,
0.475191772,
-0.3401173055,
0.5658928156,
-0.0712229982,
0.1910217553,
-1.005002737,
-0.3028163016,
-0.4927140772,
-0.7012557983,
-0.5672014952,
-0.3703424633,
0.1315018237,
0.1918038428,
-0.2008377761,
0.1231970936,
-0.5099467039,
0.2261136025,
0.9154960513,
0.2588643134,
0.3429285884,
0.2023474574,
-0.1966914535,
-0.2166618854,
-1.013892293,
-0.3845480978,
1.1628447771,
0.5389511585,
0.7869265079,
0.1002160013,
0.8034752011,
0.3481854498,
0.6646794081,
-0.8394882679,
0.0907989144,
-0.1320085526,
-0.2714321315,
-0.3630651832,
-0.6685578227,
-0.9453056455,
0.5886595249,
-0.3539256752,
-0.4015177786,
0.1008721218,
0.2285321057,
-0.507845521,
0.2318596989,
-0.5449841619,
1.0339826345,
-0.4460712969,
-0.3501114249,
-0.4421470165,
-0.6283411384,
0.2976162732,
0.3234557509,
0.1533430219,
0.0561301336,
0.0041252645,
0.9461060762,
-0.4284548461,
0.7219547629,
-0.0951476917,
-0.0684199929,
0.056868095,
-0.0275726002,
0.5894301534,
0.0072072749,
0.027960645,
-0.0613348745,
0.0055645532,
-0.4559843838,
-0.8332365751,
0.6141688228,
-0.9643922448,
-0.4075841606,
-0.3834766448,
-0.6990427375,
-0.1624910682,
-0.042100057,
0.0742517784,
0.1599757224,
0.1362730414,
0.1192536056,
0.5814824104,
-0.3381765783,
0.1628675163,
0.3015244603,
-0.3014748991,
-0.8482636213,
0.8977310658,
-0.2739449441,
0.4471938312,
0.5289140344,
0.1191013828,
-0.6280591488,
-0.4393598437,
-0.4706397951,
0.318974942,
-0.7606784105,
-0.3837547004,
-0.3237195611,
-0.1852751523,
-0.3939611018,
0.0430580825,
-0.4050825238,
-0.3226442635,
-0.0160775781,
-0.1019525528,
0.1246381775,
0.7331729531,
-0.1693236679,
0.4453848302,
-0.9292318821,
0.0365153328,
0.1313144416,
0.2936576307,
0.0901914537,
-0.7708854675,
-0.5645138621,
0.1884803325,
-0.1649979651,
-0.8065266013,
0.6212986112,
-0.3137102127,
0.7945037484,
-0.0404708199,
-0.0492474996,
0.5644052625,
-0.2646897435,
0.6813647151,
0.3584184349,
-0.6971978545,
0.2866717279,
0.0876657665,
0.1423740983,
0.5264979005,
0.1655796915,
-0.9551298022,
-0.3054987788,
-0.397598654,
-0.7401699424,
0.7194421887,
-0.0034653703,
-0.2679825425,
0.2335826308,
0.494176805,
-0.2186740935,
0.3113943636,
-0.826908946,
-0.1648268402,
-0.1983249187,
-0.3733097315,
-0.3115966022,
-0.0848989189,
-0.2597913444,
-0.1391257793,
0.7182611227,
0.0376302525,
0.1259367615,
0.1572399139,
-0.2918975353,
-0.2274818271,
0.2546745241,
0.4952911437,
0.3454967737,
-0.2117491961,
0.1172595769,
-0.0366710834,
0.1100946888,
0.3684945107,
-0.2882182896,
-0.0568900593,
-0.066777274,
0.4409859776,
0.9617086649,
0.3058170974,
-0.5236726403,
0.3224593699,
0.0014195174,
-0.3650724292,
0.2676630616,
0.1273863614,
0.2196188867,
0.2164887488,
0.0489448644,
-0.0784901679,
-0.1584091634,
-0.3965490758,
0.3147799075,
0.3124241233,
-0.6973976493,
-0.027706556,
0.5454095602,
0.1281022727,
-0.4779371023,
1.0153750181,
-0.0677746534,
-0.6393716931,
0.4105729163,
0.3469313085,
0.6819385886,
-0.2081856877,
0.2881636024,
0.6017488837,
0.357768327,
-0.3812925518,
-0.0473220833,
-0.0167181473,
-0.5557686687,
-0.9915192127,
-0.5765224099,
-0.4664573669,
-0.2024177015,
-0.7934092879,
-0.1016034037,
-0.0415214486,
-0.2007275075,
-0.1924780011,
-0.0839943662,
-0.5452398658,
0.1666369587,
-0.0527698994,
0.6958584785,
-0.8846229911,
0.8957820535,
0.6073720455,
-0.6803786755,
-1.0356445312,
-0.1296222061,
-0.0077487072,
-0.7822422981,
1.063313961,
-0.0632654205,
-0.015207639,
0.1079015732,
-0.35287112,
-0.813945055,
1.0817470551,
0.0716121718,
-0.2702005506,
0.1110316515,
0.1864909083,
0.5368723273,
-0.5186844468,
0.1765089333,
0.6583967209,
0.5043743253,
-0.0444142632,
-0.594188571,
-0.0023171501,
-0.0278957095,
0.2095429748,
0.3608304858,
-0.1178902164,
0.4350731075,
-0.1084975079,
-0.2534863651,
0.089041695,
0.7722626328,
0.3375609815,
-0.0396028869,
0.5561586022,
0.6881650686,
0.6178708673,
-0.1940037161,
1.2264876366,
-0.159215644,
0.3889887631,
1.0264406204,
-0.007909473,
1.1316388845,
0.7468670607,
-0.3302128315,
0.5788139105,
0.9878557324,
0.1446217149,
0.764544189,
0.4562034905,
0.0410623886,
-0.3227484226,
-0.1612187922,
-0.206109181,
-0.1534101218,
0.1659767628,
-0.389657259,
-0.1109073013,
-0.0481607057,
-0.239199847,
0.2511251569,
-0.0879655778,
0.9129580259,
0.1776927412,
-1.3346511126,
0.5437080264,
0.3090124726,
0.7229260206,
-0.3464809656,
-0.0119200721,
-0.4818130732,
0.179117918,
-0.1623783112,
-0.8763149977,
0.343290925,
-0.150056988,
-0.2781746686,
-0.5565532446,
0.2883409262,
-0.5906895995,
-0.1912385523,
0.2866040468,
0.4233998954,
0.1607696563,
-0.1535891891,
-0.8050567508,
0.0414110757,
-0.0153409643,
-0.1488073468,
0.579562068,
0.1758263558,
0.1172529981,
0.7268314958,
0.9352092743,
0.3038642108,
-0.076201275,
0.2574380934,
0.5102365613,
-0.752872169,
-0.5720199943,
-0.791370213,
0.5669795275,
-0.0204274114,
-0.0992813408,
0.395282656,
0.2031123489,
0.8766550422,
-0.0660350546,
0.51733464,
0.3047060668,
0.5449739695,
-0.5523414016,
0.5885222554,
-0.709729135,
0.2149121165,
0.0999268368,
-0.7167567611,
-0.3648222089,
0.6826576591,
-0.1854237467,
-0.1424406469,
0.8081822991,
0.811019361,
0.1968259662,
-0.3314467371,
0.3408583999,
-0.2711753249,
0.3990983367,
0.6191499829,
0.9926486015,
-0.5686303973,
0.6010456085,
-0.1435251385,
-0.0288123935,
-0.3189992905,
-0.8396205306,
-0.4372766316,
-0.4266673923,
-0.2618841827,
-0.4589843452,
0.1711499244,
1.0102553368,
0.8601748347,
-0.902546525,
-0.5486132503,
-0.0078500723,
0.5107298493,
-0.8142529726,
-0.1550158262,
0.351593703,
-0.7328938246,
-0.6668404937,
0.3942554593,
0.2792259455,
-0.1685230881,
-0.2914646566,
-0.5429633856,
-0.136566788,
-0.288534224,
0.4055792391,
0.1825127602,
-0.9234742522,
-0.2649970353,
0.0079529248,
-0.4376087487,
0.0888810307,
0.9424256086,
-0.742813766,
0.2554116547,
0.5284093022,
1.1055737734,
0.2701103985,
0.16722776,
0.8178034425,
-0.6384065151,
-0.1274338365,
0.0269857254,
0.2543906271,
0.4402426779,
-0.1610586047,
0.6390163302,
0.1624100506,
-0.745636344,
-0.8991948366,
0.2648356557,
-0.5681515932,
-0.2966699898,
0.7516088486,
-0.2685366273,
-0.2220712751,
0.2199865133,
0.0513388626,
0.4167411923,
-0.3416295946,
0.7988958955,
0.8874769807,
-0.0166365728,
-0.2273060232,
-0.72851789,
0.5059766173,
0.956705749,
-0.7678182721,
0.01979471,
0.3235110044,
0.1190517619,
-0.0032877431,
0.3992271423,
-0.1481710672,
0.2669715583,
-0.3741541505,
0.2016936839,
0.0389618874,
-0.1962530613,
-0.6408343315,
-0.0336801,
0.4207060635,
-0.264721185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09130v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09130v1
|
Social Meme-ing: Measuring Linguistic Variation in Memes
| 2023-11-15T17:20:20 | 2023-11-15T17:20:20 |
Naitian Zhou, David Jurgens, David Bamman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Much work in the space of NLP has used computational methods to explore
sociolinguistic variation in text. In this paper, we argue that memes, as
multimodal forms of language comprised of visual templates and text, also
exhibit meaningful social variation. We construct a computational pipeline to
cluster individual instances of memes into templates and semantic variables,
taking advantage of their multimodal structure in doing so. We apply this
method to a large collection of meme images from Reddit and make available the
resulting \textsc{SemanticMemes} dataset of 3.8M images clustered by their
semantic function. We use these clusters to analyze linguistic variation in
memes, discovering not only that socially meaningful variation in meme usage
exists between subreddits, but that patterns of meme innovation and
acculturation within these communities align with previous findings on written
language.
|
[
-0.389015913,
-1.0123325586,
0.2933216691,
0.6274331808,
-0.3840664625,
0.654269278,
-0.2405311763,
-0.525280416,
0.9955706596,
-0.0179865044,
-0.7086131573,
-0.5440071225,
-1.0027515888,
0.4458238184,
-0.3047536612,
0.4275852144,
0.1390488148,
-0.1981741488,
-0.2571521699,
-0.5082999468,
-0.2771387696,
-0.3775973618,
-0.3812443316,
-0.0766934603,
1.0543223619,
0.6305414438,
0.6080744863,
0.3779099882,
0.4569705427,
0.3735000491,
-0.0137879271,
0.0075210743,
-0.3152059317,
0.1539005935,
-0.4474350512,
-0.504111588,
0.1399656981,
0.1111656949,
0.815336287,
0.7199978828,
-0.0334490798,
0.1393309683,
-0.048439838,
0.7476382256,
-0.7171007991,
-0.0370818228,
-0.6597310901,
0.0244473908,
-0.618365109,
-0.3178158998,
0.0853298753,
-0.2543624043,
0.0838874057,
-0.0453633629,
0.1612156928,
-0.2208627462,
0.6640363932,
0.0203820504,
-0.4554389119,
-0.4060674608,
-0.6510256529,
1.0660898685,
-0.7789102793,
0.387457937,
0.1549272537,
0.3679549992,
-0.0315569006,
-0.8013394475,
-0.6362566948,
0.0908872485,
-0.0004592794,
-0.1224671677,
-0.1065767631,
-0.4606940746,
-0.084411554,
0.3377358317,
-0.6377394199,
-0.0187419467,
-0.5388385057,
-0.0906972066,
0.5288085938,
0.1937035322,
0.718685329,
-0.3900906146,
0.0300975367,
-0.4503001571,
-0.6417713165,
-0.039362181,
0.4131895006,
0.0616090819,
-0.3639300168,
0.7015957236,
-0.1472164392,
0.4750801027,
-0.4467188418,
-0.2195501924,
0.3691753745,
-0.4902704358,
-0.0039098598,
-0.3538835347,
0.7214845419,
0.5874715447,
0.1778931618,
0.0829629824,
0.2034199983,
0.5644993186,
-0.0168904234,
-0.4010790884,
-0.1550324708,
-0.2032809108,
-0.44775334,
-0.4043107927,
0.1340431124,
-0.9084659219,
-0.5001630783,
-0.0955165029,
-0.329056412,
-0.2208076268,
-0.6142470837,
-0.0178979188,
-0.6113215685,
0.2274553031,
0.0209026858,
-1.1763044596,
0.0994871035,
0.6877272129,
0.981641233,
0.0756105706,
-0.5031490922,
-0.0024075755,
-0.0766475201,
-0.5065870285,
0.9302118421,
-0.9808431268,
-0.1855260432,
0.1227561906,
0.1920018941,
-0.0233028065,
-0.4521603286,
0.1669143885,
-0.1622161418,
-0.1691138744,
-0.136903882,
-0.6186830997,
-0.2384227365,
0.153381452,
-0.6129584908,
0.7374696136,
0.1195458546,
-0.6420092583,
0.6608516574,
-0.5455584526,
-0.3372601569,
0.253809005,
-0.7006632686,
-0.1802636534,
0.4740249515,
-0.2969478667,
0.6088349819,
-0.2713781595,
-0.1050210297,
-0.5142846107,
-0.0367087536,
0.4917206466,
-0.2270541936,
0.5462281108,
0.308503896,
-0.2370660454,
-0.1582231373,
-0.6306912303,
-0.0970560983,
0.2124326825,
-0.2176006436,
-0.7337943912,
0.4314053357,
-0.0898550823,
0.172665894,
0.1216992959,
-0.8307082653,
-0.1060978621,
-0.3305150867,
0.7643372416,
0.5614176989,
0.0211010575,
0.6237570047,
-0.3388072848,
0.2946589291,
-0.1180834472,
0.2469425499,
0.1180554107,
-0.8658432364,
-0.3016640842,
-0.2692311704,
0.0709808096,
0.1722127497,
-0.7369571328,
0.2684033513,
-0.0205496997,
-0.6339621544,
-0.3806946576,
0.2081772238,
-0.1778963953,
-0.2500342429,
0.0548684895,
-0.4796991646,
-0.2953525484,
-0.8680536151,
-0.3873661458,
-0.049606055,
0.0026978632,
0.3512876928,
0.2455774844,
-0.7813120484,
0.4898541272,
-0.261680156,
0.0633089244,
-0.2626085281,
0.5364347696,
0.1806773096,
0.4129275084,
0.8186942935,
-0.5510612726,
-0.8034565449,
-0.0346219465,
-0.7242642045,
-0.2412740737,
-0.111438565,
0.0628505051,
0.0461299978,
0.7983422279,
-0.0166688804,
0.4204726815,
0.9652237892,
-0.4387705922,
0.3741656542,
-0.0749597475,
0.4835124016,
-0.9350852966,
-0.6110747457,
-0.0537633002,
-0.0498486981,
-0.378467381,
-0.0922521353,
0.0071265893,
0.131875664,
-0.4422259629,
0.3995761871,
-0.6323382258,
0.104000248,
-0.1638678461,
0.1685230136,
-0.1617152691,
0.1354369223,
-0.4573287666,
0.3788045049,
0.6302974224,
-0.3880994618,
0.4412313402,
-0.1684804112,
-0.5033744574,
0.577798605,
-0.5821301937,
0.224076286,
-0.2982052565,
-0.2456640601,
-1.1760183573,
-0.5001276731,
0.2451906204,
-0.4616821408,
0.0561336391,
0.1188471913,
-0.6719276309,
-0.1721208543,
-0.596773386,
0.6484733224,
0.2104517519,
-0.2604675591,
0.350151211,
0.6343033314,
-0.2546996772,
-0.4203608632,
-0.5305303335,
0.3354518712,
-0.2731872797,
-1.0775368214,
0.0962023586,
-0.1591547579,
-0.3854403794,
-0.0039130319,
0.234367609,
-0.106318891,
0.1544144005,
0.1167741194,
-0.423677206,
-0.3126173019,
0.2087174207,
0.4398164451,
0.1556465477,
-0.150574103,
0.028609369,
0.8092133403,
-0.3435828686,
-0.4437861741,
-0.037193276,
0.7759597301,
0.543448329,
0.0583422557,
0.601582408,
0.3215218484,
-0.3163035214,
-0.2090206295,
-0.5289584398,
-0.1434411258,
-0.4870558381,
0.2479154319,
-0.1096693054,
-1.3605701923,
0.3953438103,
-0.236541003,
0.1494874656,
0.378059268,
0.5765283108,
-0.4692479372,
0.6912219524,
0.8263488412,
0.2536094189,
0.8345149755,
0.0099513708,
0.3512423038,
-0.2607938647,
0.0478123762,
-0.5767131448,
-0.7147942781,
-0.9118233323,
-0.8082550764,
0.2194286436,
-0.2154474258,
0.2811988592,
0.1296005994,
-0.3760008216,
0.7014560103,
0.5637619495,
-0.0692248344,
-0.0646008998,
0.2882332802,
-0.1704817414,
-0.5946636796,
-0.6453083754,
-0.4985050261,
0.7160463333,
0.2278400064,
0.977386415,
0.2428745031,
0.7082386017,
0.5289516449,
0.1487597823,
-0.4443407655,
0.3778277338,
-0.5647168756,
-0.2309736311,
-0.3782261014,
-0.213709861,
-1.1440275908,
-0.0193588082,
-0.5400725007,
-0.532621026,
0.2709163129,
0.1550260633,
0.4679576457,
0.2141790986,
-0.5571194887,
0.8570495248,
-0.030742947,
-0.119142361,
-0.6782315373,
-0.8183608055,
-0.1122319922,
0.1191631109,
0.2823177576,
-0.3524244726,
0.2551926672,
0.515252471,
-0.1688161194,
1.0966597795,
0.2282879651,
0.1754907817,
0.6878649592,
0.0145163983,
0.045174703,
-0.1220262721,
0.2988817096,
0.4473151863,
0.0126829417,
-0.7193791866,
-0.7507866621,
0.7592720985,
-0.6196883321,
-0.1155593172,
-0.1425528228,
-0.350484252,
0.1718016267,
-0.0789713115,
0.1756358147,
0.4059786201,
-0.3350844681,
0.7209362984,
0.2013478875,
-0.3942498863,
0.4676339626,
0.0603601336,
0.1571319252,
-0.3900185525,
0.9674271345,
0.4336420894,
0.1114836186,
0.3278416991,
0.5796034336,
-0.3683074117,
-0.0803827792,
-0.2537615299,
0.4894902408,
-0.8325563073,
0.1019484252,
-0.5328763127,
0.0932970196,
-0.5140974522,
-0.6522652507,
-0.2188535333,
-0.666210413,
-0.1404751241,
-0.1834312975,
0.2097461224,
1.1585195065,
-0.3244285583,
0.4479451478,
-0.7440360188,
-0.1246510074,
0.4958604872,
0.4742390513,
-0.0066318475,
-0.0590295382,
-0.0347324349,
0.0560395867,
-0.262033999,
-1.2689841986,
0.1493048668,
0.4151391685,
0.6157895327,
0.4986690879,
-0.3717961013,
0.2665717304,
-0.3687381148,
0.9436812997,
0.4942654669,
-0.6979483366,
0.4100976586,
-0.4241561592,
0.3117847443,
0.4622054398,
0.1004330739,
-1.0125869513,
-0.956435442,
-0.8378840089,
-0.8882364035,
-0.0518364981,
0.2477282137,
0.6982126236,
-0.5460250378,
0.5571497679,
-0.0565149412,
0.1938119978,
-0.8342885375,
-0.2583818138,
-0.2517056167,
-0.2609557509,
-0.2323770672,
-0.6700143814,
-0.0927636847,
-0.3310413957,
0.2027704567,
-0.0390841216,
0.1448251754,
0.0472608283,
-0.182498157,
-0.005962675,
0.1913560927,
0.7410032153,
0.8618463874,
0.278763473,
0.8102397919,
-0.1059649363,
-0.3994521797,
0.0976865292,
-0.6413022876,
0.0972087085,
0.3516138196,
0.2511609197,
0.3660486937,
0.1329585612,
-0.5562252998,
0.4134549201,
-0.1667225361,
-0.3747928143,
0.0327545404,
0.0863256007,
0.4206507802,
0.4330393672,
-0.0911602452,
0.046968475,
0.1517253965,
-0.6250810623,
0.4137659669,
0.3492217064,
-0.5056448579,
-0.6265645027,
0.3112604022,
0.191263631,
-0.4950599074,
0.2131078243,
-0.1236728206,
-0.1188336909,
0.8340950608,
0.6038241386,
0.8757273555,
-0.319265008,
0.5532686114,
0.1729569137,
0.6874234676,
0.171054095,
0.2331912518,
0.0298769884,
-0.8613426685,
-0.2332130373,
-0.5188812017,
-0.2689297497,
-0.1514058709,
-0.0360075198,
0.3215400279,
-0.5125248432,
-0.1173001528,
0.457873553,
-0.6017515063,
-0.315666467,
0.1597196311,
0.0660558194,
0.5870580673,
-1.1693269014,
0.2444288433,
1.0224026442,
-0.0996310189,
-0.4081961215,
-0.2204683125,
-0.0151817845,
-0.5359249115,
0.0571350642,
0.1631498933,
-0.1964334548,
-0.215214625,
-1.304558754,
-0.6150074005,
0.5690305829,
0.1310856789,
-0.1343628019,
0.7002469897,
0.4383031726,
0.7707144022,
-0.5374125242,
-0.1278513968,
0.2807223499,
0.1832131445,
0.0571233816,
-0.1400879025,
-0.1328621656,
-0.5440579057,
0.1585790217,
0.4297754467,
-0.5214015841,
0.9026677608,
-0.0025404438,
-0.3138909936,
-0.4516084194,
0.5980300307,
-0.0251404904,
0.4216339886,
0.7518184781,
0.0175644699,
0.6662272215,
0.1165721193,
0.8909506798,
-0.1165505424,
0.3687299788,
0.9362831712,
0.1444333345,
0.5252146125,
0.628230989,
-0.0466826595,
0.78568542,
0.6499462724,
-0.0150258383,
0.4097853005,
0.4827747345,
-0.4429126382,
0.0417294689,
-0.0894714147,
-0.0775054768,
0.3480430245,
0.6920834184,
-0.3461719453,
-0.3205634356,
-0.2272379994,
0.047847677,
0.2760043442,
0.1253533959,
0.9155248404,
0.2291674316,
-0.2763094008,
0.5480830073,
0.0764185712,
0.6777713895,
-0.4773101509,
-0.1960393339,
-0.1472181231,
-0.077223964,
-0.260972023,
-0.7569289207,
0.8060740232,
-0.2252296507,
-0.1872118562,
-0.0059001506,
0.9428113103,
-0.3670546114,
-0.6253859997,
0.6297131181,
0.6839672327,
0.3492202759,
0.125990659,
-0.6954559088,
-0.1428814381,
-0.065195851,
0.2552017868,
0.2166381329,
0.8689646125,
-0.2318714857,
0.3252287209,
0.5650085807,
-0.0064503169,
0.7604294419,
0.4750033319,
0.7044888139,
-0.5333098173,
-0.4051608145,
-1.1199965477,
0.4212735295,
-0.3588578701,
-0.4510180354,
0.6674451828,
0.1647827327,
0.6536919475,
-0.1245770752,
0.645793736,
-0.4641588926,
0.3559460342,
0.0420221947,
0.5893576145,
-0.9530380964,
-0.1418550611,
-0.6671162844,
-0.7919342518,
-0.4952017367,
0.8352918029,
0.1090380624,
-0.4919700325,
0.6190657616,
0.8317722678,
-0.0826329738,
0.1128800511,
0.4945458174,
0.1726944298,
0.3081475198,
-0.2266860157,
1.2352133989,
-0.0371647254,
0.0898325145,
-0.3650604784,
-0.6780250669,
-0.1270372421,
-0.8418816924,
-0.7882165313,
-0.680609405,
-0.2973729968,
-0.1867724359,
-0.1566144675,
0.8285840154,
0.476056546,
-0.5885154605,
-0.5980164409,
-0.1560135484,
0.5361815691,
-0.2762298286,
-0.2353435755,
-0.1779301316,
-0.5641016364,
-0.6444534063,
0.2177384347,
0.7666259408,
0.0944217891,
-0.3595071137,
0.2993555963,
-0.5156089067,
0.4603399932,
0.904710114,
0.0487693883,
-0.392059803,
-0.5289274454,
0.2977038622,
-0.0747521818,
0.166787833,
1.0003012419,
0.365739584,
0.6836819649,
0.8616494536,
0.5270170569,
0.3267077506,
-0.2882213295,
0.4996106923,
-1.0270684958,
0.3545592725,
0.0856072828,
0.3621059954,
0.5051214099,
-0.2590375543,
0.604080677,
0.6420394778,
-0.4751578867,
-0.3626975715,
0.2617194653,
-0.8257998824,
-0.3682783842,
1.0671774149,
0.2020156085,
-0.4002200067,
-0.4102847278,
0.1251404732,
-0.0918704346,
-0.2479858398,
1.1316803694,
0.9674963951,
0.0270145983,
-0.1973391175,
-0.4605296254,
0.29007411,
0.5028924942,
-0.6998778582,
-0.3248620927,
0.4248652458,
0.3632333875,
0.5337385535,
0.9135301113,
-0.2309280187,
0.156149134,
0.0205222219,
0.0693649799,
1.0131967068,
-0.3399202824,
0.1221461743,
0.1574944258,
-0.1367329806,
-0.1584109068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09122v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09122v3
|
Universal NER: A Gold-Standard Multilingual Named Entity Recognition Benchmark
| 2023-11-15T17:09:54 | 2024-06-29T22:50:48 |
Stephen Mayhew, Terra Blevins, Shuheng Liu, Marek Šuppa, Hila Gonen, Joseph Marvin Imperial, Börje F. Karlsson, Peiqin Lin, Nikola Ljubešić, LJ Miranda, Barbara Plank, Arij Riabi, Yuval Pinter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce Universal NER (UNER), an open, community-driven project to
develop gold-standard NER benchmarks in many languages. The overarching goal of
UNER is to provide high-quality, cross-lingually consistent annotations to
facilitate and standardize multilingual NER research. UNER v1 contains 18
datasets annotated with named entities in a cross-lingual consistent schema
across 12 diverse languages. In this paper, we detail the dataset creation and
composition of UNER; we also provide initial modeling baselines on both
in-language and cross-lingual learning settings. We release the data, code, and
fitted models to the public.
|
[
-0.409979403,
-0.2075909376,
0.0203015581,
0.1287989765,
0.1073800772,
-0.1922307014,
-0.1725137234,
-0.7748536468,
0.0577905439,
0.6593248844,
-0.1316969544,
-0.4459297359,
-0.2910747528,
0.6254786849,
-0.3874087036,
1.0723303556,
-0.1039769724,
0.2095289677,
0.0839828998,
-0.5790962577,
-0.1558156461,
-0.7260828614,
-0.5861186385,
-0.4743648171,
0.718028307,
0.5241513252,
0.3426238596,
0.3799988031,
0.6104890108,
0.2544443905,
0.0634376705,
0.0974661559,
-0.2968426943,
-0.0560102984,
-0.3029877245,
-0.033871524,
-0.3754505813,
-0.310279578,
0.8907321692,
0.8875281215,
-0.1684360802,
0.1990626752,
0.1565454006,
0.5566896796,
-0.6447890401,
-0.0586883351,
-0.5577700734,
0.1203172728,
-0.378259033,
0.0953870118,
-0.2252427489,
-0.3041093051,
0.2318157405,
-0.9150210023,
0.2130021155,
-0.231809929,
0.9979609251,
-0.1136918589,
-0.6066899896,
0.0454891324,
-0.8167170286,
0.7849805355,
-0.3285740912,
0.8518568277,
-0.0195813142,
0.4278282821,
-0.0505586974,
-0.988632381,
-0.4894784093,
0.1690316945,
-0.0112210456,
-0.0477559492,
-0.4500075877,
-0.2132003456,
0.071253866,
0.2482841313,
-0.5762114525,
0.0763956755,
-0.3178445697,
-0.2158512324,
0.6032527089,
0.1268317103,
0.1938863695,
0.0733530149,
-0.4753161967,
0.1525772959,
-0.8388822675,
-0.2341016531,
0.2515015006,
0.616877079,
-0.1372457147,
0.5740248561,
-0.4798490405,
0.6577291489,
-0.1260323822,
-0.0321709178,
0.5816226602,
-0.1556298733,
-0.256921351,
0.3154590428,
0.8312166333,
0.3865101337,
0.6943495274,
-0.58883214,
-0.3178637326,
0.0807147175,
-0.1720314771,
-0.6332730055,
-0.3524961472,
-0.4069370329,
-0.1944847107,
0.1183772162,
0.282512784,
-0.7831802964,
-0.2274241298,
-0.4552025497,
0.3583029509,
-0.0890159458,
-0.41208902,
0.1111956388,
0.0949394554,
0.3308030963,
0.2889552116,
-0.5950525999,
0.7854890227,
0.5839197636,
0.4197994173,
-0.1606336087,
-0.4701245129,
-0.5517622828,
0.1776731014,
-0.1750663072,
0.9479705095,
-0.4468584061,
-0.2548353374,
-0.0490922444,
0.3811040819,
0.0159589183,
-0.5268334746,
0.405877322,
-0.4604154825,
0.1843254566,
-0.5150405765,
-0.528613627,
-0.3076585233,
0.2720755041,
-0.8254269958,
1.052547574,
0.0479679778,
-0.9032016397,
0.6790548563,
-0.7422491908,
-0.2212564498,
0.4458922744,
-0.3372165561,
0.0701911673,
0.1081498712,
0.0810863599,
0.1478453577,
-0.5515207052,
0.2464480549,
0.1463091373,
-0.1705790609,
0.1347307861,
-0.5647546053,
0.6629452109,
0.185952127,
-0.1982556134,
-0.2535137832,
-1.0681970119,
0.2214092463,
0.0983859226,
-0.326734215,
-0.5993523598,
-0.2333838791,
0.7185350657,
0.138452366,
0.2255816311,
-0.8571030498,
0.0299694873,
-0.0367147513,
0.0855294764,
0.3147446215,
-0.0398802198,
0.2482432276,
0.0611028038,
0.1984084845,
-0.1990939677,
-0.0931121483,
-0.0583493747,
-0.3046078086,
-0.7559990883,
-0.1238518357,
0.8615662456,
0.6760755777,
-0.0928996652,
0.2762132883,
-0.4704076946,
-0.2229896933,
-0.6425200701,
0.1973890066,
0.6421040893,
0.5476051569,
0.3875343204,
-0.4396035671,
-0.8821167946,
-0.9424596429,
-0.2111912817,
-0.031749092,
-0.1056680754,
0.1125563979,
0.5541475415,
-0.3780649006,
0.8768057823,
0.1317956597,
-0.4628933072,
-0.2632660568,
0.1876793653,
-0.0078252945,
0.5431929827,
0.299425602,
-0.9363008142,
-0.730268538,
0.4355006814,
-0.9165574312,
-0.0394947901,
0.1282242686,
-0.001610124,
0.2686896622,
0.5441431403,
-0.2230574787,
0.4011651576,
0.5359330773,
-0.2403128147,
0.1622117758,
-0.2818933129,
0.0891211703,
-1.1198316813,
0.3433262408,
0.1250753403,
-0.0753293782,
-0.49355039,
-0.036455255,
0.1888767779,
0.0975170359,
-0.6311380267,
1.0477794409,
-0.804528892,
-0.1280578226,
-0.0123030832,
0.0944605917,
0.0839523599,
-0.0493848771,
0.2236690372,
0.6592824459,
0.644523859,
-0.7435199022,
0.22313568,
0.2808855474,
-0.2484465092,
1.0231499672,
-1.0261942148,
0.1090032086,
-0.0287587512,
-0.0465203896,
-0.5306746364,
-0.3594186604,
0.0122745084,
-0.3716028929,
0.3447030783,
-0.3421147764,
-0.6981450319,
-0.0464673936,
0.4164737761,
0.4691212773,
0.1879268885,
-0.8366897702,
0.7168806791,
0.6484131813,
0.0105788112,
-0.6625763774,
-0.9109060764,
0.1967050284,
-0.1230224743,
-0.2133851051,
0.4529803693,
-0.0365624838,
-0.3797435164,
0.1237760186,
-0.1281241179,
-0.3004444838,
-0.2347811908,
0.2538836896,
0.1175519526,
-0.3636484742,
0.0224923473,
-0.3298456967,
-0.4859394431,
-0.1587439924,
-0.120850876,
0.2761496902,
-0.3800071478,
-0.4634594619,
-0.3159647882,
0.4579595029,
0.3238494396,
-0.4809873998,
0.3705441356,
0.390658468,
-0.6769201159,
0.1860891134,
-0.6848234534,
0.3549694419,
-0.4010598958,
0.1876557171,
-0.6885359287,
-0.9025957584,
0.805529058,
-0.0453652851,
0.2094068229,
0.5804776549,
0.0317406282,
0.4752839506,
0.9565229416,
0.8702170849,
-0.2501888871,
0.0518618263,
-0.0932925344,
0.0510500446,
-0.9562178254,
-0.619756043,
-0.7283086777,
-0.2942120433,
-0.8298026323,
-0.1058944166,
0.0112172971,
0.3069179654,
-0.6045390368,
0.5911594033,
-0.6515797973,
0.9168543816,
0.4831027091,
-0.4713974595,
0.4375905693,
0.0449201129,
-0.3673136234,
-0.3319452107,
-0.2994323075,
-0.6005319357,
1.0591161251,
0.0399793051,
0.9373168945,
0.1003520042,
0.8431928158,
0.0768703371,
0.3354514837,
-0.2604300976,
0.4930513203,
-0.2798542082,
-0.7682523727,
-0.0926440582,
-0.4180883765,
-1.2702996731,
0.2028439343,
-0.0183125939,
-1.1225510836,
0.4344878793,
-0.1853723526,
-0.0210437942,
0.471401751,
-0.1692570597,
1.0907263756,
-0.4456380904,
0.0085409433,
0.3075794578,
-0.5903161764,
-0.0495772101,
-0.0569837131,
0.0674988702,
-0.216935277,
-0.1907118559,
0.6159209013,
-0.0036474897,
0.4696035087,
-0.0087034805,
0.113170445,
0.1923023015,
0.04411228,
0.2909903824,
0.2709796727,
-0.2926444113,
0.6860282421,
-0.3461782038,
-0.1651019752,
-0.0594253652,
0.9557176828,
-0.6709617376,
0.2495942414,
-0.6157233119,
-0.3676586151,
0.1102527082,
0.5262752771,
0.4841087162,
0.5218958259,
-0.7709988952,
0.1667491645,
0.6896994114,
-0.0526482053,
0.369437784,
1.0438203812,
-0.3662437797,
-0.7699835896,
0.9076510668,
0.164771378,
-0.1328680813,
0.6457328796,
-0.3709242642,
-0.3016417623,
-0.1877672523,
-0.512027204,
0.2026503384,
-0.8170207143,
-0.3198103607,
-0.887952745,
-0.3287812769,
-0.2702369988,
-0.2347842306,
-0.6896074414,
-0.3603540361,
-0.1373497844,
-0.0901794285,
0.458471179,
0.8221321106,
-0.4473408759,
0.0083504794,
-0.7436525226,
0.3910173178,
0.203036353,
0.5558779836,
-0.5525532365,
-0.4394021928,
-0.0350192413,
-0.1240131855,
0.0560018457,
-0.5658762455,
0.3333158493,
0.4954555929,
0.997590065,
0.4556953907,
-0.0197022259,
0.6303500533,
-0.6914726496,
0.4594075382,
0.3327399492,
-0.8200266957,
0.4088923931,
0.0080097588,
0.2005351782,
0.9041705132,
0.4857076705,
-0.8534030318,
0.0469337404,
-0.666541338,
-1.0439642668,
0.2274643183,
-0.0834287256,
0.1789647192,
-0.2871317863,
0.0955246091,
0.3799616098,
0.0251140427,
-0.8415254951,
-0.4349738359,
-0.0202008151,
-0.0606010929,
-0.1532599032,
0.0016722884,
-0.0498825498,
-0.2769782543,
0.5752939582,
-0.1297640651,
0.0924839973,
0.2029646486,
-0.3235068917,
-0.2922278643,
0.4694451988,
0.0068834312,
0.5988009572,
-0.0529430248,
0.0284522567,
0.3629167378,
-0.2838589251,
0.0529747009,
0.5415636301,
-0.4505813122,
0.4613264203,
-0.0807622671,
0.6895257831,
0.5721362233,
-0.6292841434,
0.2280405164,
-0.2398901582,
-0.1967163831,
-0.6103196144,
-0.2539710999,
-0.1001655385,
0.1023831517,
0.4605551064,
-0.1294272542,
0.2574433386,
-0.2640622258,
0.3891303241,
0.4101349115,
-0.6344455481,
-0.4446726739,
0.8381057382,
0.0414097048,
-0.1775315702,
0.8133162856,
-0.3271767795,
-0.3630231917,
0.2843934298,
0.6763274074,
0.889133215,
-0.354881078,
0.274284631,
0.6769186258,
0.4941451252,
-0.2664515078,
0.6118733287,
0.2090179324,
-0.7539844513,
-0.1531194746,
-0.6587649584,
-0.5310271382,
0.1462836415,
-1.0043965578,
0.295561254,
-0.1450012475,
-0.0647421777,
0.2419672757,
-0.0019289223,
-0.9671651721,
0.3324196041,
0.3205500841,
1.0015618801,
-0.7308188677,
0.6142178774,
1.0839183331,
-0.6345472932,
-0.7437272072,
-0.320790261,
0.1615575999,
-0.4835463464,
0.7337679863,
0.338814497,
0.1401082426,
-0.0298757032,
-0.372449398,
-1.2287365198,
0.910992384,
0.4752636254,
-0.5398386121,
0.0040491321,
0.4177948534,
0.4473972917,
-0.6234036088,
0.3348326087,
0.3517798185,
0.6379631162,
-0.2158405781,
-1.1199258566,
-0.2592321336,
-0.5929079652,
0.0176525693,
0.5663073659,
-0.4238051474,
1.0903842449,
-0.3052999675,
-0.2750678062,
0.1147894859,
0.7654209137,
0.203089878,
0.3873163462,
0.2248508036,
0.8412675858,
0.8330138922,
-0.2370974123,
0.8519521356,
-0.3113052845,
0.1185376197,
1.3172411919,
-0.679641068,
0.7986358404,
0.3466503322,
0.0286919642,
0.5598698854,
0.4256546795,
-0.2596618533,
0.528945446,
0.2669998407,
-0.2752852142,
-0.0581759363,
-0.5265818238,
-0.6494498849,
0.4295679033,
0.1974786669,
-0.0805863962,
-0.505533874,
-0.0186790954,
-0.0385620035,
0.0139514552,
-0.4692197442,
0.8240258098,
0.0059927446,
-0.3013613522,
0.2862108946,
-0.0524912402,
0.7498694062,
-0.6149475574,
-0.1870549172,
-0.1828186959,
0.4632638693,
-0.1425400525,
-0.6275467277,
0.0011313108,
0.3247236311,
-0.0837011859,
0.1480457038,
0.6624706984,
-0.4273706079,
-0.8164461255,
0.7322667837,
0.5480520725,
0.506670177,
-0.060458716,
-0.6541768909,
-0.1572576761,
-0.3295501471,
-0.2223765403,
0.524353981,
0.9803066254,
-0.1259108335,
0.4364051223,
0.4804369807,
-0.0146047631,
0.2389964461,
0.5278173089,
0.5126250982,
-0.7655203938,
-0.1811825782,
-0.3322097361,
0.6989590526,
-0.0962208658,
-0.8600665331,
0.894577682,
1.0168398619,
1.5185966492,
0.2598062158,
0.8458680511,
-0.2096256018,
0.6208304167,
-0.0668110028,
0.6345946193,
-0.6985089183,
-0.0798468292,
-0.4631067216,
-1.2144781351,
-0.5318077803,
0.6024523973,
0.2522481382,
0.0503673851,
0.4156088233,
0.5670203567,
-0.2713980079,
-0.094388783,
0.3435120881,
-0.2735734582,
-0.1480555385,
0.4346959293,
0.5730742216,
-0.860984087,
0.5858895183,
-0.3869641423,
0.187358126,
-0.0208171625,
-0.9324972034,
-0.5774448514,
-0.38448596,
-0.4598291814,
-0.2170087695,
0.1991139054,
1.0082266331,
0.5079569817,
-1.2086811066,
-0.2893104851,
-0.3379048109,
-0.2643931508,
-0.1805541217,
-0.1770880222,
0.1261113882,
-0.0280941594,
-0.5767335296,
0.496655941,
0.1069162488,
0.1318615377,
-0.0233160146,
-0.5585016608,
-0.095898129,
-0.0349864475,
0.1672748774,
0.9876770973,
-0.7209314108,
-0.1103520766,
0.1236729324,
-0.2851183414,
0.0084118005,
0.6479590535,
-0.6394671798,
0.3958097994,
0.1697169691,
0.5540058017,
0.2100719213,
-0.3260875344,
0.4223233163,
-0.6688007712,
-0.0355785713,
0.169775486,
0.6219483614,
0.6526380777,
-0.1440978795,
0.9511396885,
-0.0432766639,
-0.6522625685,
-1.0276778936,
-0.0739102066,
-0.7996578217,
0.2344056815,
0.8674933314,
-0.0871280804,
0.0857183337,
-0.2421648055,
0.2110014111,
0.2974667549,
-0.427716434,
0.2485164404,
0.2288970649,
0.0384815894,
-0.052185405,
-0.6247528791,
0.0017819924,
-0.0412674583,
-0.8070836067,
0.0774481222,
0.5902118683,
0.5719124079,
0.2471339703,
0.8197367787,
-0.4564203918,
0.3413109481,
0.134383738,
0.7140518427,
0.1849334389,
-0.836019814,
-0.3391233981,
-0.0457598157,
-0.1961647868,
0.1088170931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09117v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09117v2
|
R-Spin: Efficient Speaker and Noise-invariant Representation Learning with Acoustic Pieces
| 2023-11-15T17:07:44 | 2024-04-01T15:04:42 |
Heng-Jui Chang, James Glass
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
This paper introduces Robust Spin (R-Spin), a data-efficient domain-specific
self-supervision method for speaker and noise-invariant speech representations
by learning discrete acoustic units with speaker-invariant clustering (Spin).
R-Spin resolves Spin's issues and enhances content representations by learning
to predict acoustic pieces. R-Spin offers a 12X reduction in computational
resources compared to previous state-of-the-art methods while outperforming
them in severely distorted speech scenarios. This paper provides detailed
analyses to show how discrete units contribute to speech encoder training and
improving robustness in diverse acoustic environments.
|
[
-0.4115531743,
-0.7635509372,
0.2768205404,
-0.0845496953,
-0.0918651149,
0.256754756,
-0.3606112301,
-0.2043449134,
0.5640146732,
0.0312889181,
-0.6704596281,
-0.2092579007,
-0.4503301978,
-0.0184192285,
-0.4300701916,
0.6587197185,
0.7552624345,
0.2809586227,
-0.1585267484,
-0.141440779,
-0.3014099896,
-0.3783842325,
-0.6026781797,
-0.5107564926,
0.5764426589,
0.449228555,
0.6299837828,
0.7367525697,
0.4086566567,
0.3943017125,
0.0012778126,
0.2023824006,
-0.4425662756,
0.4897701442,
-0.4830060601,
-0.1928815991,
-0.6954957247,
-0.0689417645,
0.7844863534,
0.7431914806,
-0.5721265078,
-0.0143635105,
-0.0060023647,
0.5997954607,
-0.4184733629,
0.2317352593,
-0.69526124,
0.2367807031,
-0.2131471783,
-0.2016673088,
-0.7366669774,
-0.2275294513,
-0.1250460446,
-0.6756231785,
0.2011359483,
0.0094727911,
0.5868871212,
0.6041078568,
0.1356528103,
-0.2709461749,
-0.9697287083,
1.0314348936,
-0.4561604261,
0.9017952681,
0.6074385643,
0.2541579604,
-0.1164920032,
-0.6334483624,
-0.4339566529,
0.3321161866,
0.0598770529,
0.1337563694,
0.0041706273,
0.0815738142,
0.0102214627,
0.4271843433,
-0.3140327036,
0.0618447401,
-0.3540273607,
-0.1075992212,
0.6861453652,
-0.2562383115,
0.2997975349,
-0.1094625071,
-0.1385754794,
-0.4449452162,
-0.5703914762,
-0.2955792844,
0.238625586,
0.7371988893,
-0.3984368742,
0.1667211056,
0.2459445298,
0.6887342334,
0.6591873765,
-0.6999439001,
0.4188585877,
0.2212128937,
0.1052482575,
0.6264378428,
0.7438578606,
-0.3135277927,
0.2811985016,
-0.2163825333,
0.0385005139,
-0.175837189,
0.6072192192,
-0.5321862698,
-0.3960383832,
0.0312367845,
-0.5078126192,
-0.2500153184,
0.2277658731,
-0.8799999952,
-0.4315234423,
-0.4334453046,
0.5205941796,
-0.4844023287,
-0.6420594454,
0.0044286251,
0.159127906,
0.0562113933,
0.1952420622,
-1.1372196674,
0.4967692792,
0.8120371699,
0.6908921599,
-0.4417548776,
-0.237220183,
-0.5663720965,
0.19382599,
-0.6896446347,
0.6929359436,
-0.4194034934,
-0.439716965,
-0.3526489437,
-0.2874501944,
-0.3759683073,
-0.7597329617,
0.3551248908,
-0.3090909719,
0.1963496655,
-0.1473470479,
-0.5751134157,
-0.2956553102,
-0.2457914054,
-0.6299946308,
0.7740466595,
0.4098454118,
-0.6651036739,
0.2683392167,
-0.2756893933,
-0.463318944,
-0.0576134585,
-0.6428827047,
-0.8464953303,
0.2584182322,
0.3078959286,
0.4683989286,
0.1648093313,
-0.0439980403,
-0.4098539352,
-0.3527694345,
0.5481525064,
-0.1613004804,
0.4407172203,
0.4241960049,
-0.337490648,
0.1568196565,
-0.9488725662,
-0.1243375018,
0.0745705217,
-0.127269581,
-0.1832271367,
0.3070625961,
-0.2065947652,
-0.2478714585,
0.0161477327,
-0.5524260402,
-0.3226200938,
-0.3703702688,
0.3751886189,
0.9141250253,
-0.0010631598,
0.5743156075,
-0.3508209586,
0.5450564027,
0.0746071935,
-0.2518447042,
-0.167617023,
-0.3077253997,
-0.5484964848,
-0.7035896778,
0.3931244314,
0.5448173285,
-0.4826795161,
0.5791039467,
-0.1395877004,
-0.4213433564,
-0.5527009964,
-0.0507809967,
0.2608016729,
0.4108830392,
0.2780858278,
-0.2402759194,
-0.5980910659,
-0.5555053353,
-0.1918460876,
-0.2185316086,
0.1722989678,
0.1025335416,
0.0684964359,
-0.2333679199,
1.0007480383,
-0.1929455549,
-0.5573552251,
-0.3542164564,
0.187698096,
0.2455043048,
0.6277859211,
0.4607689083,
-0.7804560065,
-0.653978765,
0.1532506049,
-0.7768422365,
0.1717330068,
-0.2061490417,
0.3849442303,
0.295629859,
0.6975159049,
-0.3564775288,
0.3312272429,
0.6198889613,
-0.1560179889,
0.3091830313,
-0.056481488,
-0.0318533033,
-0.8623524904,
-0.4588855207,
-0.1888122559,
-0.5429319739,
-0.7658316493,
-0.3385352492,
-0.1555719376,
-0.3562379479,
-0.0410600491,
-0.0447738096,
-0.4458362162,
-0.3715447783,
-0.4350675941,
0.2800096273,
-0.2491854578,
0.4405330122,
0.0190145299,
1.0573117733,
0.7260736227,
-0.5680622458,
0.155191049,
0.1690152586,
-0.35934937,
0.8758220673,
-0.5622527003,
0.5873047709,
-0.1154407635,
-0.0907117203,
-0.5776031017,
-0.2043095231,
0.2495989799,
-0.6451046467,
0.935121119,
-0.0555479936,
-0.087970525,
0.2863302231,
0.0341036506,
0.6307635903,
0.3628800213,
-0.8250952363,
0.9925442934,
0.8487278223,
-0.3449482024,
-0.4334070981,
-0.6894062161,
-0.346170783,
-0.4412732124,
-0.3833056986,
0.5151484013,
0.0688539818,
-0.3485675454,
0.1733461469,
-0.4212959707,
-0.2306535244,
-0.2267109752,
0.2544424832,
-0.2565303743,
-0.2255725265,
0.1429249495,
-0.1720694453,
-0.3579034209,
0.0429053307,
0.0813538134,
0.6077104211,
-0.3397955298,
-0.6095502377,
-0.6208226681,
0.5480483174,
0.4925915301,
-0.1477511674,
0.4106476903,
0.9142229557,
-0.283770442,
-0.7603672147,
-0.401335597,
-0.4161436856,
-0.6389987469,
0.5982020497,
-0.4406131506,
-1.186270237,
0.4453290403,
-0.0169726871,
-0.3012954295,
0.2141076922,
0.4020260572,
-0.26875633,
0.8697853684,
0.5231776834,
-0.2760825753,
0.5037713647,
-0.0363328271,
0.6348475218,
-0.6231565475,
-0.2093164325,
-0.5857034326,
-0.1070363522,
-0.5466126204,
-0.6199740171,
0.4636286497,
-0.0044337711,
-0.3974906504,
0.1919345111,
-0.7887486815,
0.2717131376,
0.5048158169,
0.1098841354,
-0.0649803728,
0.3396387994,
0.1464739591,
-0.415045619,
-0.8995878696,
0.0868556127,
0.6895172596,
0.6320827007,
1.1791094542,
-0.0917622223,
1.0279816389,
0.5339784026,
-0.7545781136,
-0.8891637325,
0.365753144,
-0.15436171,
-0.3682258427,
-0.4250532389,
-0.6301285625,
-0.6961063743,
0.1957674474,
-0.2090761662,
-0.6237284541,
0.7632474899,
0.0255719125,
-0.4156125784,
0.5600888729,
-0.4410644472,
0.2187186033,
-0.1219657287,
0.0965315104,
-0.7341272831,
-0.2381297499,
-0.1904153824,
-0.1060627177,
0.6530726552,
-0.0960760787,
0.3127586544,
0.9191229939,
0.03692846,
0.9724776745,
-0.3398033679,
0.09205769,
0.4897659123,
0.3176585436,
0.270465076,
-0.0399061181,
0.0636095256,
0.1313182414,
-0.2280424386,
-0.0794224888,
-0.5443455577,
0.4795137644,
-1.0228303671,
-0.2098730952,
-0.6997784376,
-0.7283969522,
-0.3100409508,
0.0790383667,
0.0470227785,
0.6800515652,
-0.1346061826,
0.522384882,
1.4100705385,
-0.1849697679,
0.4836822152,
0.2597542703,
-0.159747541,
-0.9377167821,
1.3253817558,
0.1180442944,
0.1020061299,
0.38734442,
0.2388972193,
-0.0564240403,
-0.5050722957,
0.0800880268,
0.3490721285,
-0.5445091128,
-0.3281408548,
-0.421574384,
-0.4043000937,
-0.449955821,
-0.2220695317,
-1.0969069004,
-0.724162817,
-0.494833827,
-0.3853587806,
0.3834962547,
1.1404546499,
-0.8826055527,
0.5236268044,
-0.2774182856,
0.6015658975,
0.7796495557,
0.4104188383,
-0.1543986201,
-0.5750086308,
-0.538507998,
-0.2657510042,
-0.0820040032,
-0.7154702544,
0.2737204731,
0.843075335,
0.8593102694,
0.7751764655,
0.1896747798,
0.6131436825,
-0.4916728437,
0.5799437165,
0.2572090328,
-1.051296711,
0.3403671086,
-0.5267029405,
0.0016869572,
0.5585187078,
-0.0134013714,
-0.3092683554,
-0.0601938516,
-0.4993109107,
-0.8129241467,
0.8302147985,
-0.2363144606,
-0.0730005801,
0.1004729122,
0.2170668244,
0.0114935301,
-0.0259256791,
-0.6667333841,
-0.4366996586,
-0.5523589849,
-0.1689346135,
0.0412917919,
-0.6605392694,
-0.2647846639,
-0.4040159881,
0.9105510712,
-0.0674952641,
0.8439362645,
0.3609625995,
-0.0454307646,
-0.2058704793,
0.202604264,
0.6839726567,
0.7208327055,
-0.3510714173,
0.3393132985,
0.2898622453,
-0.624214828,
0.0497116111,
-0.2783014178,
-0.0217844173,
0.1637796909,
0.3075546026,
0.6693233252,
0.4239841104,
-0.0625977814,
0.2951924801,
-0.0047381851,
-0.2938837707,
-0.5795425773,
0.0386489481,
0.1268493086,
0.2284252942,
0.3826516569,
-0.0753732771,
-0.0368690342,
-0.4368213415,
0.6403569579,
0.0781876296,
-0.8466190696,
-0.308654815,
0.4968901873,
-0.0677958727,
-0.5469380617,
0.6094183326,
-0.3571954966,
-0.4097950161,
0.0999661013,
0.7500393391,
1.0790544748,
-0.7867176533,
0.2146654427,
0.4006626904,
0.2117078602,
0.1347369254,
0.3497748673,
-0.176582247,
-0.9388051629,
-0.4665895104,
-0.4466637075,
-0.8216953874,
-0.3335092962,
-1.1366620064,
-0.0839806423,
-0.7138268352,
-0.3153086007,
-0.3489181697,
-0.282440871,
-0.0080732303,
0.0171432402,
0.2347008139,
0.4764796495,
-0.8478934169,
1.0528261662,
0.5478389859,
0.0818775892,
-0.8279260993,
-0.3366780281,
0.1728182882,
-0.5905374289,
0.171019733,
-0.2233847976,
-0.6314232349,
-0.1891959459,
-0.4679993987,
-1.0979158878,
0.8940503001,
0.3985948563,
-0.4929406941,
0.5343152285,
0.2449790388,
0.1202790439,
-0.5984547734,
-0.2089327127,
0.472333163,
0.2900440395,
-0.0218552444,
-0.7796465755,
-0.3787475228,
-0.0427752808,
-0.0803674385,
0.0068921554,
-0.556978941,
0.9257489443,
0.0760540664,
-0.0890579075,
-0.3847680688,
1.256811142,
0.4795607328,
0.3114278018,
0.8031160235,
0.822496295,
1.0981465578,
-0.3699647188,
0.3513195515,
-0.2696480453,
0.2821881771,
1.3256027699,
0.0954512879,
0.8034084439,
0.3393442333,
-0.4208831191,
0.7294330001,
0.1070127785,
0.0183851887,
0.8931200504,
-0.1402345449,
-0.4762246907,
-0.5297648907,
0.2368013561,
-0.6023323536,
0.8086726665,
0.7803298235,
0.1487237066,
0.0002511785,
0.0480215922,
0.2300658226,
0.4588400126,
-0.3873113394,
0.8411502242,
0.5660846829,
-0.0097790323,
0.3053845167,
-0.2835645974,
0.8251115084,
-0.7013537884,
0.0528907627,
0.1484036446,
0.4995082319,
-0.518270731,
-0.202844575,
0.6006811857,
-0.3675274849,
-0.4383054972,
-0.4269666374,
0.8044909239,
-0.2913665771,
-0.5279797316,
0.3664875925,
0.0990134329,
0.164408505,
0.1242417619,
-0.6451098323,
0.36355564,
0.0555912517,
0.0125321634,
0.52933532,
0.4165575504,
0.4999205768,
0.5793684721,
0.3284711242,
0.2963915169,
0.3417845964,
0.0212768391,
0.578234911,
-0.6794042587,
-0.6082735062,
-0.4404945374,
0.2223457694,
-0.0429860801,
0.1046260893,
0.8465850353,
0.41947335,
0.9214035869,
0.075582169,
0.6307093501,
-0.1508103162,
1.2569115162,
-0.1631219834,
1.1456718445,
-0.0796535909,
0.1345569789,
-0.4196798801,
-0.620588541,
-0.234950617,
1.4428155422,
0.0526448041,
0.0856188685,
0.5868366361,
0.8494158983,
-0.1079044938,
0.2686165273,
0.363789618,
0.2002164274,
0.2505380511,
-0.2079835683,
0.6975719929,
-0.3745470941,
0.1268687397,
-0.8086968064,
-0.1356482804,
0.161849156,
-0.8225601912,
-0.868639946,
-0.6872193217,
-0.8117832541,
-0.1934059858,
0.0686496496,
1.0219618082,
1.1389502287,
-1.2969040871,
-0.728736639,
0.2138992399,
0.3895102143,
-0.6318320036,
-0.1880135983,
0.518825233,
-0.7440770268,
-0.5008141398,
1.1438660622,
0.2746549845,
-0.2168234289,
-0.2366439551,
-0.3354108036,
0.0993657932,
-0.0016208672,
0.5728873014,
0.4537931979,
-0.2499828339,
-0.4030760527,
-0.2924703956,
0.3266782165,
0.2826653719,
0.5477588177,
-0.55363518,
0.5499737859,
0.4320296347,
0.4069142938,
0.6635413766,
0.0798566043,
0.615799427,
-0.7264521122,
0.3895485401,
0.3825487792,
0.3015424311,
0.4498569667,
-0.1037670523,
0.423163116,
0.1723808199,
-0.9625895619,
-0.9429629445,
0.1701204479,
-1.3977347612,
-0.1915721893,
0.9485667348,
-0.141683951,
-0.136370495,
-0.1236510277,
0.2201685011,
0.1451743394,
-0.4181455076,
0.7583895922,
0.143055737,
-0.3170822561,
-0.4077911377,
-0.2550599277,
0.6151896119,
0.2954831421,
-0.2701634765,
-0.2148039639,
0.2022394538,
0.2672024965,
0.4323672354,
0.5384071469,
-0.4374711812,
0.1919273734,
0.2978073359,
0.178141281,
-0.0890396833,
-0.834295392,
-0.5234048367,
0.3009313345,
0.283023566,
-0.4648507833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09114v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09114v2
|
Ever: Mitigating Hallucination in Large Language Models through Real-Time Verification and Rectification
| 2023-11-15T17:04:56 | 2024-02-25T04:39:07 |
Haoqiang Kang, Juntong Ni, Huaxiu Yao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable proficiency in
generating fluent text. However, they often encounter the challenge of
generating inaccurate or hallucinated content. This issue is common in both
non-retrieval-based generation and retrieval-augmented generation approaches,
and existing post-hoc rectification methods may not address the accumulated
hallucination errors that may be caused by the "snowballing" issue, especially
in reasoning tasks. To tackle these challenges, we introduce a novel approach
called Real-time Verification and Rectification (Ever). Instead of waiting
until the end of the generation process to rectify hallucinations, Ever employs
a real-time, step-wise generation and hallucination rectification strategy. The
primary objective is to detect and rectify hallucinations as they occur during
the text generation process. When compared to both retrieval-based and
non-retrieval-based baselines, Ever demonstrates a significant improvement in
generating trustworthy and factually accurate text across a diverse range of
tasks, including short-form QA, biography generation, and multi-hop reasoning.
|
[
-0.0244362112,
-1.1713949442,
0.665120244,
0.3830679059,
-0.1042492613,
0.1983307153,
-0.2067934573,
-0.7090829611,
0.0210609846,
0.8583461642,
-0.7923596501,
-0.4121847451,
-0.0783851221,
0.2173734456,
-0.6625412107,
0.6629616022,
-0.0353204049,
-0.3053457141,
-0.1518730521,
0.1126465276,
-0.4161887169,
-0.7353795767,
-0.7182410359,
-0.4618691504,
0.2752359211,
0.4211889803,
0.5076756477,
0.7073597908,
0.2251674682,
0.1766430438,
0.2428817749,
0.5124296546,
-0.5945367217,
0.6827792525,
-0.1712842882,
-0.2167483419,
-0.3969231546,
-0.218528688,
0.7718462944,
0.5715881586,
-0.1945663393,
0.1446120888,
-0.0723365843,
0.5157638192,
-0.7209177017,
-0.2638257146,
-0.8937186003,
0.311558187,
0.0131774535,
-0.6576161981,
-0.6190637946,
-0.6662971377,
-0.1827254146,
-0.5081025362,
0.6372469068,
0.1890784651,
1.1132860184,
0.3615688086,
-0.200061664,
-0.168344304,
-1.0639796257,
0.8382999301,
-0.7188266516,
0.6284995079,
0.1795505136,
0.1431244612,
-0.4281955063,
-0.6666057706,
-0.8982309699,
-0.5947007537,
-0.0240064822,
-0.2387732416,
0.2193113714,
-0.0098419571,
0.4656696618,
0.0621529184,
-0.5767154694,
-0.0702086613,
0.1462480128,
-0.4168213308,
0.5774939656,
0.2426360399,
0.3167914748,
-0.2823969126,
0.0635230914,
-0.1685879976,
-0.9223138094,
-0.3920345604,
0.1607185006,
0.1924723387,
0.368391484,
0.5938182473,
-0.161149472,
0.5888379216,
0.1816382408,
-0.3193816245,
0.1715422124,
-0.4914723933,
-0.200659737,
0.3533032238,
0.7181050181,
0.0530997925,
0.1768580228,
-0.2422200441,
-0.3510404527,
-0.0789948329,
0.6251867414,
-0.8644445539,
-0.202491954,
0.5128204226,
-0.2545501888,
-0.5309413075,
-0.0090809977,
-0.7757129073,
-0.3837294579,
-0.2754261494,
0.4318808913,
-0.378459692,
-0.3928478062,
0.1613557786,
0.5245164633,
0.1886345744,
0.1134988442,
-0.5548423529,
0.0565194599,
0.7319421768,
0.7045779824,
-0.1141967624,
-0.5161863565,
-0.8221114874,
0.2527750134,
-0.503034234,
0.8340876102,
-0.1544054896,
-0.1017676666,
0.2291429341,
-0.0580138788,
0.0996852666,
-0.6828860044,
0.4963814914,
-0.4239459038,
0.0606853031,
0.1643217802,
-0.4154823124,
0.1252955496,
0.5832638144,
-0.5577569604,
0.9494749308,
-0.1048085019,
-0.5623582602,
0.2376894951,
-0.3844454885,
-0.7395390868,
0.0567083769,
-0.3394095898,
-0.8207007647,
0.0333545133,
0.0607324466,
0.4984812438,
-0.1788728386,
0.4674142599,
0.0190027282,
-0.3270679414,
0.0952963531,
-0.554148972,
0.5942092538,
0.25287956,
-0.8077204227,
0.2236709595,
-1.0875767469,
0.2050826102,
0.3508080244,
-0.0806357637,
0.0473903492,
0.0494654886,
0.0484548993,
-0.0108740889,
0.1852133572,
-0.6550298929,
0.1529405266,
-0.4939077497,
0.4448482394,
0.5628914833,
0.0658310875,
0.1351644695,
-0.2144872546,
0.5568944812,
-0.1905637532,
0.2227022499,
-0.3643187284,
-0.1532218754,
-0.8720548749,
-0.11029277,
0.1060708985,
0.76894629,
-0.6463333368,
0.7206907868,
-0.3494665623,
-0.4407280684,
-0.4491230249,
-0.1373357028,
0.5447357893,
0.4659136236,
0.2256055623,
0.0782124326,
-0.8530802131,
-0.5459671617,
-0.1499088258,
-0.3586551249,
-0.1107783169,
0.1597421169,
0.3820982873,
-0.4219011664,
0.8589440584,
-0.3760713041,
-0.2627969682,
-0.1690972447,
0.372879684,
-0.1218560711,
0.6126161814,
0.2272812575,
-0.5881028771,
-0.2713005245,
-0.0405713469,
-0.9661326408,
-0.2889903486,
-0.7776808143,
0.0679054931,
0.6561079621,
0.8972321153,
-0.6315920353,
0.353823036,
0.2938539386,
-0.3716734648,
0.9253923893,
-0.3595853746,
0.3286260366,
-0.7089978456,
0.0926111788,
-0.4276342988,
-0.5681375265,
-0.4459200203,
0.3278059363,
0.093516849,
-0.0845018849,
-0.1364654899,
0.5427293181,
-0.5178595185,
0.1100517064,
-0.1179105937,
0.4143556356,
0.1764653325,
0.0348451175,
0.0183324739,
0.5521844625,
0.3899596035,
-0.7251793742,
0.5923742652,
-0.0335637815,
-0.4045928717,
0.6057599783,
-0.4426829517,
0.0729923248,
-0.1961904168,
0.3814405203,
-0.9865769744,
-0.3377144933,
0.2989997566,
-0.6655632854,
0.2544677854,
0.2844703496,
-0.8545143604,
-0.2701401711,
-0.2139274776,
0.4824990928,
0.3544785082,
-0.8868982196,
0.8420367837,
-0.0102260886,
0.162989825,
-0.560891211,
-0.6192542911,
0.3591965139,
0.1142156199,
-0.4925359488,
0.4255948961,
-0.2419947386,
-0.2863435149,
-0.2430573255,
-0.1641740203,
0.078664504,
0.0150378579,
0.2799512446,
0.2423087955,
-0.0057174866,
0.1541342884,
0.0766503811,
-0.082054697,
0.0931432471,
-0.3151242733,
0.7142891884,
0.3951892555,
-0.5951882005,
-0.7114283442,
0.3556510806,
0.7826664448,
-0.0670408756,
0.7110490799,
0.6147924066,
-0.4684197009,
-0.4099826217,
-1.1790421009,
-0.6771192551,
-0.371748507,
0.3266850114,
-0.6316051483,
-0.8569439054,
0.5031747222,
0.1898481846,
0.4875668883,
0.3354691267,
0.437076807,
0.0223787818,
1.1808930635,
0.5138481259,
0.2019932568,
0.2419172972,
0.0018829424,
0.7293453217,
-0.5702523589,
-0.5365149379,
-0.6788082719,
0.1093373299,
-0.2732358277,
-0.0859328583,
0.0020610108,
0.0354192443,
-0.2389387786,
0.2886394858,
-0.8560006022,
0.4553675354,
0.1838905811,
-0.0147959841,
0.4946383536,
0.1715652347,
-0.0432070829,
-0.1673694104,
-0.6000501513,
-0.5308905244,
0.9420539737,
0.2423701733,
0.683047533,
-0.0667089075,
0.7781884074,
0.4680968821,
0.4319127202,
-0.6601923108,
0.7357037067,
0.2355307192,
-0.6064987779,
-0.3780297637,
-0.6878705025,
-0.810939312,
0.2543480992,
-0.4257796407,
-0.5045318007,
-0.0544755645,
0.2835319042,
-0.6566064954,
0.4968278706,
-0.3962061107,
0.6949520707,
-0.110770829,
-0.3819309771,
-0.2552561462,
-0.5326726437,
0.4081986547,
-0.1834026128,
0.2860252559,
0.1762731522,
0.0565020703,
0.3392036855,
-0.281149596,
0.6722587943,
0.1582934558,
-0.5453290939,
0.2309879363,
0.5977661014,
0.8078483939,
0.1721887589,
-0.0067901863,
-0.0435000062,
-0.0351824388,
-0.2035620362,
-0.471940428,
1.0623242855,
-0.5458726287,
-0.5495689511,
-0.3863885403,
-0.4366480708,
0.0242658462,
0.1537256092,
0.4468028247,
0.401817292,
-0.1313830912,
0.0218925029,
1.1346094608,
-0.17739667,
0.1789223552,
0.4611260891,
-0.5791960955,
-0.3042065203,
1.0529651642,
-0.0477480516,
0.2612612545,
0.3797274232,
-0.1443911642,
-0.1885323375,
-0.5759780407,
-0.4176905453,
0.6139199734,
-0.6098541617,
-0.1706109792,
-1.0598766804,
-0.3115988076,
-0.7635732293,
-0.2595295012,
-0.711304605,
-0.2420981526,
-0.4173239768,
-0.0792677924,
0.1372655779,
0.6063597202,
-0.1723238528,
-0.0234062485,
-0.9649320841,
0.6484442353,
0.2876141071,
0.2201005667,
0.1361909956,
-0.7851544023,
0.0002625456,
-0.1257850826,
-0.0661397204,
-0.7214332819,
0.2747548521,
0.0548346825,
0.4038296938,
0.335871011,
0.10550531,
0.7409191132,
-0.5369976163,
0.9477891326,
0.088712655,
-1.0098092556,
0.4650602639,
0.1022109613,
0.0881023929,
0.3939142823,
-0.0338304304,
-0.4808479548,
-0.6565252542,
-0.7229146361,
-0.9743354917,
0.3517664075,
0.4517017603,
0.2089133412,
-0.1579166502,
0.8074965477,
0.0058647427,
0.2013523132,
-0.7408394814,
-0.085743919,
-0.4188391268,
0.0668410957,
0.1611855924,
-0.6252371669,
0.0697611272,
-0.1758324206,
0.9141049981,
0.0876615569,
-0.0243580807,
0.429607898,
-0.2097744793,
-0.3229251802,
0.1889975816,
0.7876209617,
0.8240744472,
-0.385967344,
0.1802316755,
-0.0049933069,
-0.4246877134,
0.2240836322,
-0.2149211466,
-0.3092883229,
0.3747503757,
0.4907988012,
0.4847770333,
-0.0753041133,
-1.0200651884,
0.2527846992,
-0.0232054219,
-0.3044984043,
-0.6261560321,
-0.0863723606,
-0.2640995085,
0.1196749657,
0.4511070549,
-0.3225046098,
-0.0893840194,
-0.6889112592,
0.3757120967,
0.3801835179,
-0.2844053209,
-0.1307069063,
0.7887700796,
0.0991672128,
-0.4960690141,
0.9499367476,
-0.3395777941,
-0.4985076487,
0.4799536169,
0.8267580271,
1.1460044384,
-0.4331746697,
0.2184234858,
0.8203076124,
0.4450578392,
-0.3329588175,
0.2227285206,
0.0096106976,
-0.7777260542,
-0.6875696182,
-0.5993198156,
-0.3116060197,
0.3975031674,
-0.4370214343,
0.0224552508,
-0.5330477357,
-0.1187513545,
-0.2197901011,
-0.3666835427,
0.0286611281,
0.4395291209,
0.0701679885,
0.500998199,
-0.7176293135,
0.6915309429,
0.515396297,
-0.3382247984,
-0.5286030769,
0.2416513562,
-0.1332223117,
-0.4749905467,
0.550072968,
0.1827080846,
-0.5631080866,
0.2268359661,
-0.8054082394,
-0.3907001913,
0.8188336492,
0.2428958416,
-0.7927407026,
-0.105709292,
0.0284264479,
0.500036478,
-0.3783959746,
-0.0804091021,
0.7521801591,
0.4948045909,
0.3637321591,
-0.7832131386,
0.225021556,
-0.0878573284,
-0.0880334973,
0.2515318692,
-0.1837309301,
0.7378466129,
-0.3912573159,
-0.393343389,
0.2103827,
0.8214809895,
0.796554625,
0.1015681699,
0.6867973208,
0.5490114689,
0.7682766914,
-0.042178493,
0.8749550581,
-0.3826860487,
0.2623871863,
1.204680562,
-0.3732283711,
0.5932236314,
0.5986715555,
0.1494826078,
0.3573281467,
0.4137763381,
0.0477789082,
0.2069343776,
0.3778881431,
-0.405488044,
-0.6289966106,
-0.255430311,
-0.3542325497,
-0.0826331303,
0.2395876497,
-0.0467140265,
-0.1413415372,
0.328992635,
0.3427167237,
0.4149388671,
0.0180174503,
0.6051335335,
-0.1612777114,
-0.8138481379,
1.035774231,
-0.1108486876,
0.72888273,
-0.5052520633,
-0.3043022454,
-0.2780941725,
0.2908642888,
-0.3596081734,
-0.5703021884,
0.4871273637,
0.1090235785,
-0.2448471189,
-0.3867062628,
0.5555918217,
-0.535623908,
-0.4416869581,
0.25991413,
0.1363206208,
0.2904027104,
-0.5571498871,
-0.4682032168,
0.3283996582,
0.393456459,
-0.3045752645,
-0.0457199849,
0.4827234447,
0.0073872567,
1.0157926083,
0.685115397,
0.2966452539,
0.1273671538,
0.33590886,
0.5523338914,
-0.7496056557,
-0.1780113429,
-0.9409611821,
0.2315999269,
-0.0807069764,
0.091194205,
0.7091782093,
0.5523792505,
0.742133975,
-0.0341179632,
0.7332394719,
-0.0074664634,
0.6521303654,
-0.4627486169,
0.9322206378,
-0.8986493945,
0.3089902401,
-0.0968739912,
-1.0735652447,
-0.8683621883,
0.810459137,
0.2260576487,
-0.1949167401,
0.952644825,
0.99288553,
0.2181185782,
-0.204377532,
0.4495326877,
0.4665753543,
0.6566489339,
0.2526677847,
0.6007127166,
-0.2762917578,
0.850066781,
-0.252381891,
-0.2074935883,
-0.3744386137,
-1.0439367294,
-0.8678020835,
-0.476891458,
-0.5076724887,
-0.8538485169,
0.1547854394,
0.8859125376,
0.439365983,
-0.913400948,
-0.2555379272,
-0.1930923462,
0.1763702333,
-0.3464939594,
-0.2617480755,
0.38459903,
-0.6031705737,
-0.5650014877,
0.3420014381,
0.4510112703,
0.0010972198,
-0.770281136,
0.165236026,
-0.140838325,
0.2644831538,
0.8169884086,
0.3891479373,
-0.8097656965,
-0.3427264094,
-0.0138838496,
-0.4269968271,
0.0455810465,
0.792073667,
-0.7994709611,
0.5250148773,
0.5211034417,
0.4672198594,
0.3234064877,
-0.1061927304,
0.4885585904,
-0.3870910108,
0.026987398,
0.2914978564,
-0.0152606973,
0.4287036359,
-0.4974349439,
0.4439369142,
0.351509124,
-0.658849895,
-1.2729376554,
0.3968935609,
-0.8050609827,
-0.2147874534,
0.979118526,
-0.0385214537,
-0.2099922895,
-0.3318283558,
-0.2638352513,
0.4500234127,
-0.1231778562,
1.3752998114,
0.5436477065,
0.0317508057,
-0.2288956791,
-0.481054455,
0.6309896111,
0.5982922316,
-1.0242228508,
0.5939375758,
0.661250174,
0.062330585,
0.4072908461,
0.5497640967,
-0.2967528403,
0.0772167146,
-0.2075443864,
0.4774757028,
-0.006042676,
-0.6830361485,
-0.0093562454,
0.2925463915,
-0.093832165,
0.0283529274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09109v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09109v2
|
Does Pre-trained Language Model Actually Infer Unseen Links in Knowledge Graph Completion?
| 2023-11-15T16:56:49 | 2024-06-06T16:01:08 |
Yusuke Sakai, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Katsuhiko Hayashi, Taro Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Knowledge graphs (KGs) consist of links that describe relationships between
entities. Due to the difficulty of manually enumerating all relationships
between entities, automatically completing them is essential for KGs. Knowledge
Graph Completion (KGC) is a task that infers unseen relationships between
entities in a KG. Traditional embedding-based KGC methods, such as RESCAL,
TransE, DistMult, ComplEx, RotatE, HAKE, HousE, etc., infer missing links using
only the knowledge from training data. In contrast, the recent Pre-trained
Language Model (PLM)-based KGC utilizes knowledge obtained during pre-training.
Therefore, PLM-based KGC can estimate missing links between entities by reusing
memorized knowledge from pre-training without inference. This approach is
problematic because building KGC models aims to infer unseen links between
entities. However, conventional evaluations in KGC do not consider inference
and memorization abilities separately. Thus, a PLM-based KGC method, which
achieves high performance in current KGC evaluations, may be ineffective in
practical applications. To address this issue, we analyze whether PLM-based KGC
methods make inferences or merely access memorized knowledge. For this purpose,
we propose a method for constructing synthetic datasets specified in this
analysis and conclude that PLMs acquire the inference abilities required for
KGC through pre-training, even though the performance improvements mostly come
from textual information of entities and relations.
|
[
-0.4737816751,
-0.5942462087,
0.7168229818,
-0.1917019188,
-0.2385819405,
0.0807005614,
-0.0149457231,
-0.2700441778,
0.2222510278,
0.5458343625,
-0.7929890752,
-0.6425392628,
-0.4608622491,
0.1456642896,
-0.1218969822,
0.9095223546,
-0.179134354,
-0.0892385468,
-0.7202680707,
-0.1176690832,
-0.1910265982,
-0.3238162398,
-0.3053058386,
-0.514980793,
0.4446391165,
0.1169296876,
0.8042267561,
0.7768480182,
0.0863050297,
0.3419520855,
0.0079021091,
0.3861159086,
-0.5607416034,
-0.1266633719,
0.0909232944,
-0.5595701337,
-0.4777627885,
0.3633099198,
0.8252454996,
1.1558459997,
0.0737734213,
-0.0495918468,
0.2428908795,
0.8551262021,
-0.7681814432,
0.3184834123,
-0.5970087051,
0.2854550779,
-0.0919918939,
-0.1548229903,
-0.671733439,
-0.5148369074,
0.4306136072,
-0.7916737199,
0.1656164825,
0.029278433,
0.81346035,
0.1100219488,
-0.7129971981,
-0.622720778,
-0.5454415083,
0.3535143435,
-0.5473549962,
0.7799390554,
0.7921319604,
0.3142620027,
-0.4399461746,
-0.896797359,
-0.7186796069,
-0.5159134865,
-0.4323483109,
0.4661951959,
0.2626110315,
0.3755329549,
0.5945049524,
0.1530297995,
-0.2058357745,
-0.2245013714,
-0.3637090325,
-0.1778916121,
0.0909772664,
0.0386944041,
0.2546799779,
-0.2586092353,
-0.2337555587,
-0.0855445564,
-0.9624415636,
0.0093710357,
0.6141068935,
-0.0107414816,
-0.2299089432,
0.6855069399,
-0.2506140769,
0.9196740389,
-0.2742776275,
-0.2704672813,
0.3656166494,
-0.2535206079,
-0.1283753365,
0.0215520766,
0.8175341487,
-0.0841819793,
0.6867288351,
-0.5623267293,
0.1013342887,
-0.1114396304,
0.2143095434,
-0.4353450835,
-0.6874884963,
-0.1453720629,
-0.3962971568,
0.0238971114,
0.0983652472,
-0.2174329013,
-0.1374136657,
-0.1998257339,
0.5073345304,
-0.613027215,
-0.2072958946,
-0.3222552836,
-0.1098409742,
-0.1559710205,
0.1157910377,
-0.421608597,
0.1007538661,
0.3269797266,
0.5488361716,
0.2523580194,
-0.5206767917,
-0.2828882337,
0.4211607575,
-0.368059516,
0.6587943435,
-0.656786859,
-0.5275272727,
-0.0962131768,
-0.0677300841,
-0.3801169991,
-0.5538313985,
0.2744773328,
-0.8619337082,
0.0788136274,
-0.3796901405,
-0.8738744855,
-0.2223664075,
0.0643669963,
-0.7893061638,
0.7254000306,
0.000781288,
-0.9768743515,
0.4919642508,
-0.3667635322,
-0.6022514105,
-0.1127038002,
-0.0138455806,
-0.3435603082,
-0.2562857866,
0.2207119763,
0.432847023,
-0.0042351843,
0.175240308,
-0.7249443531,
-0.1194690466,
0.3627026081,
-0.2293760777,
0.5717096329,
0.1104890108,
-0.0211091377,
-0.2619051337,
-0.957408905,
0.3064413667,
-0.1230700463,
-0.4336029887,
-0.3270405233,
0.1279389113,
-0.9000371695,
0.2773224115,
0.105572626,
-0.4057833552,
0.0150911482,
-0.5130395889,
0.0945741683,
0.6997879744,
0.0683754459,
0.6100074649,
-0.0553502552,
0.4140411317,
-0.0586172417,
-0.0607785471,
-0.2324292362,
-0.5350398421,
-0.7828569412,
-0.114165023,
0.409389317,
0.3072912991,
-1.0236014128,
0.2776842713,
-0.292565912,
-0.4130398631,
-0.2956284881,
0.126883626,
0.7086336613,
0.8426994085,
0.2550138831,
-0.2238060981,
-0.5475512743,
-0.5997017622,
-0.4741335511,
-0.2573758364,
-0.1357272565,
0.6690652966,
0.3283551335,
0.0824958682,
1.2381817102,
-0.560223639,
-0.1196138114,
-0.2964467406,
0.1647158414,
0.0791932866,
0.3118805587,
0.4015308917,
-0.6451428533,
-0.6414121985,
-0.1628979146,
-0.9808098078,
-0.1757349819,
0.1059168354,
-0.138254568,
0.0803679377,
0.441968739,
-0.6772130728,
0.6092460155,
0.4901455045,
-0.0941972509,
0.5040566325,
-0.4701717496,
-0.041107811,
-0.7773535848,
0.0554595478,
-0.4290281236,
-0.1482127607,
-0.5647159815,
-0.4366630614,
0.2394223213,
-0.0580496565,
-0.2273876965,
0.6148165464,
-0.6420134306,
-0.3094305396,
-0.075799942,
0.1993382871,
-0.0111895176,
0.7129350305,
0.0852078944,
0.4845930934,
0.4699043632,
-0.7356100082,
0.0005116276,
0.1109006405,
-0.3075865209,
0.1786002964,
-0.2264722884,
0.2753778696,
-0.2651910782,
0.259149313,
-0.8603283167,
-0.219453454,
0.3540217578,
-0.4306339324,
0.3484171331,
-0.4345532358,
-0.6056028008,
-0.5140980482,
0.1509126425,
0.3437381089,
0.6627631783,
-0.5050237775,
0.7892790437,
0.2740201652,
0.2104769647,
-0.4698291421,
-0.3769422174,
-0.3153158128,
0.1546499282,
-0.5007150173,
-0.0145990793,
-0.0147295194,
0.1787003726,
0.2724815905,
-0.2598648369,
-0.297877878,
0.0708924755,
0.6823319197,
0.1571457684,
-0.0439233407,
0.1801160872,
-0.0949944854,
-0.0782127604,
0.1324892044,
-0.234062165,
0.5036323071,
0.0291032139,
-0.6675407887,
-0.42496714,
-0.2511705756,
0.3700555265,
-0.1756729335,
1.0818479061,
0.2235724479,
-0.1798166037,
-0.1177879795,
-0.7312716842,
-0.1466104686,
-0.4734380245,
0.2239925414,
-0.512588203,
-0.7155362368,
0.6182790995,
-0.4243213534,
-0.5599840283,
0.3094006181,
-0.1090649813,
-0.3258269131,
0.8551063538,
0.3557854295,
0.1579191983,
0.2905504107,
-0.3255284727,
0.1907170713,
-0.7242417336,
-0.5429450274,
-0.323225081,
-0.0247655716,
-0.6258163452,
-0.0640661493,
0.4244605899,
0.6205680966,
-0.2657553554,
0.3134726882,
0.1495005339,
0.5866433978,
0.6055977345,
0.2644928098,
0.3049608767,
0.1278523505,
-0.8510506749,
0.0440091304,
-1.0423018932,
-0.1133388281,
1.2656239271,
0.0796451345,
0.5542307496,
-0.2502632141,
0.6598348618,
-0.0153589947,
0.62368536,
-0.4845462441,
0.6840645075,
-0.0142142083,
-0.3525244594,
-0.2147124708,
-0.7336781025,
-0.8845651746,
-0.041321665,
-0.3002687097,
-0.6857762337,
-0.155615136,
0.340102762,
-0.0747206807,
0.4535618424,
-0.9008140564,
0.9118159413,
-0.0639031753,
-0.1570940763,
-0.1505378187,
-0.6947214603,
0.2486980408,
-0.1977353543,
0.0537452586,
0.0407584049,
0.4321082532,
0.9362245798,
-0.7208307981,
0.8073282242,
-0.3346175551,
0.1773289144,
0.6624781489,
0.1409091204,
0.8619174957,
-0.2135961503,
0.024591025,
0.0830249637,
-0.4074994028,
-0.3596900105,
-0.8191882968,
0.4813612401,
-0.7684937716,
-0.5512364507,
0.0558861308,
-0.5029157996,
-0.5443914533,
0.419644922,
0.0736707821,
0.4556977153,
0.0017424107,
0.0439722836,
0.4344268739,
-0.3157339692,
0.3024781644,
0.6836547852,
0.0793215632,
-0.5346370935,
0.762549758,
0.4121158719,
0.3620625436,
0.3657668531,
-0.0609372742,
-0.5290105343,
-0.5704929233,
-0.1543731093,
0.5695115328,
-0.8500902057,
-0.0162275583,
-0.8650689125,
-0.381249994,
-0.3940572143,
-0.0598904677,
-0.3962039948,
-0.0648819655,
-0.0477545038,
-0.3201136291,
0.2008494437,
0.8309486508,
-0.0688588843,
0.3538147807,
-1.041831255,
0.4371975958,
0.382444948,
0.5902781487,
0.3254901171,
-0.0888446793,
-0.2343528271,
0.2829013169,
-0.0207893066,
-0.9354465604,
0.2237513065,
0.1832481921,
0.7234802246,
0.54465276,
0.1113363504,
0.8463788033,
-0.5649998784,
0.3883401752,
0.1896382272,
-0.6935874224,
0.4330016077,
-0.2654192746,
0.2453691065,
0.3762509525,
0.6383999586,
-0.2016085833,
-0.3781109452,
-0.7561812401,
-0.5473354459,
0.8964267969,
0.3783399463,
-0.2407358587,
-0.3128366172,
0.4024470448,
-0.1446673572,
0.4520667195,
-0.745226562,
-0.4508274198,
-0.1464472264,
-0.1038851961,
0.1128989905,
-0.4964417815,
0.1453619897,
-0.1189479381,
0.6237242818,
0.0679769441,
0.1127548814,
0.0265141316,
-0.3309452534,
0.0432748348,
-0.0805974752,
0.1600437462,
0.8425844312,
-0.2232809067,
0.2106069624,
0.3452382982,
-0.4854554236,
-0.0427733175,
0.0055180197,
-0.06439206,
-0.1404629648,
0.5604857206,
0.9259204865,
0.2142593116,
-0.5512661934,
0.3705039918,
0.2896432877,
0.0054557971,
-0.2974379659,
0.0320688672,
0.2843238115,
0.2104811221,
0.1992636621,
0.1172898263,
-0.3157946467,
-0.3609355092,
0.2312773913,
0.5067349672,
-0.4497744441,
-0.3225908875,
0.4897706509,
-0.1075744405,
-0.0019513022,
1.0845402479,
-0.2076230496,
-0.6632238626,
0.7191594839,
0.4715630412,
0.5483241081,
-0.2093321085,
0.3838868141,
0.4023566246,
0.1948054582,
0.0170274843,
-0.0639302582,
-0.4317167699,
-0.8998428583,
-0.560148716,
-0.6782984138,
0.0671551004,
0.0449434817,
-0.394284308,
-0.035202045,
-0.287238121,
-0.0289697684,
-0.3536764085,
-0.0922210813,
-0.9081231952,
0.3774003088,
-0.0483960435,
0.7920622826,
-0.7984009385,
1.1458055973,
0.4714824557,
-0.4022939205,
-1.3041965961,
-0.0019321829,
-0.3178943098,
-0.8679545522,
1.0102380514,
0.0549098924,
-0.1179696694,
0.1587013006,
-0.1352540702,
-0.8784835935,
1.153457284,
0.4644637108,
-0.0952713042,
-0.0723623782,
0.6874383092,
0.5326920748,
-0.2447194308,
0.3826223314,
0.178190574,
0.4148079753,
0.3404080272,
-0.9912692308,
-0.0358796604,
-0.0873097554,
-0.220434472,
0.2534351647,
-0.2960531116,
0.7978564501,
-0.3013504446,
-0.416765213,
-0.0422557406,
0.4183225632,
0.205214262,
0.397152096,
0.4429460466,
0.9219096899,
0.7546723485,
0.1529214382,
1.2550332546,
-0.3399249613,
0.331068486,
1.3454051018,
-0.3072136045,
0.519471705,
0.1695483327,
-0.3884676993,
0.4470787048,
0.3950663507,
0.1751405299,
0.7411751747,
-0.0447814651,
-0.1674898267,
-0.3942278028,
-0.0715868473,
-0.4657337666,
0.1871058941,
0.3758477271,
-0.5909045935,
-0.3443517089,
-0.1513278484,
-0.0018749156,
-0.1110935956,
-0.3946644962,
0.8442975879,
0.132967636,
-0.7865587473,
0.6095664501,
-0.3434399068,
0.1153704897,
-0.9661805034,
-0.041910708,
-0.261639297,
-0.0475694463,
-0.1479237229,
-0.6928969622,
0.0666108876,
-0.2957063615,
-0.1144858003,
-0.0171629358,
1.0064504147,
-0.5355624557,
-0.2833788991,
0.426818192,
0.6947507262,
0.2044096291,
-0.051494848,
-0.3124049306,
-0.5909227133,
0.075503163,
-0.2894064784,
0.4421093464,
0.5264823437,
-0.0415495969,
0.9549511075,
0.7615642548,
0.0950139612,
0.2856288254,
0.0803830326,
0.8291012049,
-0.3961237967,
-0.4486086369,
-0.858797431,
0.272705406,
-0.0566373467,
0.2981761396,
0.8681804538,
0.5239017606,
1.1108013391,
-0.3505808413,
0.7263643742,
0.1568026394,
0.4091218114,
-0.8028737307,
0.978864491,
-0.3194840848,
0.1963799447,
-0.273653388,
-0.8554370999,
-0.023171952,
0.5130640268,
-0.6821045876,
0.3642695844,
0.8886612058,
0.8530161977,
-0.1724142581,
-0.0134182591,
0.2929444611,
0.342810601,
-0.1826073974,
0.5542882681,
0.8550310135,
-0.1224627271,
0.828022182,
-0.3652656078,
0.1470770091,
0.3364385962,
-0.8170388937,
-1.1567087173,
-0.57177037,
-0.1747201979,
-0.4597429335,
0.1768919677,
0.5442937016,
0.4019269347,
-0.5667495131,
0.0830212012,
-0.3984870911,
0.3891877532,
0.1190891266,
-0.1876678765,
0.6869702339,
-0.2367686331,
-0.4351920187,
0.3224608004,
0.191227749,
0.2626056075,
0.1779682785,
-0.3149309754,
-0.2507918477,
-0.4639206827,
0.4083770216,
0.3196043372,
-0.5702301264,
-0.3151092529,
-0.2059949934,
0.1821853817,
-0.0136524979,
0.9003356695,
-1.3442122936,
0.6260392666,
0.5520094633,
0.5231668353,
0.5617018938,
-0.1788661033,
0.5705321431,
-1.0032176971,
0.1650242358,
-0.1398190707,
0.4411812425,
0.1253810376,
-0.1199878007,
0.464643389,
0.5427005887,
-0.0595418438,
-0.6472895741,
0.4100926518,
-0.5712263584,
-0.2340097874,
0.9568565488,
-0.6457102299,
-0.3386315405,
-0.1656222641,
0.1345133781,
0.7040035725,
0.0616494641,
0.5634108782,
0.6454684734,
-0.0261670705,
-0.0523318425,
-0.4669642448,
0.6263562441,
0.3002678156,
-0.5331828594,
-0.1451384574,
0.3522955775,
0.3658001125,
0.1090512052,
0.7915315628,
-0.0088302912,
-0.0553202406,
0.065380834,
-0.2600189447,
-0.4298426211,
-0.368660301,
0.5269006491,
0.4145284295,
-0.0840858743,
0.0431041643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09106v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09106v2
|
"We Demand Justice!": Towards Social Context Grounding of Political Texts
| 2023-11-15T16:53:35 | 2024-02-26T09:34:42 |
Rajkumar Pujari, Chengfei Wu, Dan Goldwasser
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social media discourse frequently consists of 'seemingly similar language
used by opposing sides of the political spectrum', often translating to starkly
contrasting perspectives. E.g., 'thoughts and prayers', could express sympathy
for mass-shooting victims, or criticize the lack of legislative action on the
issue. This paper defines the context required to fully understand such
ambiguous statements in a computational setting and ground them in real-world
entities, actions, and attitudes. We propose two challenging datasets that
require an understanding of the real-world context of the text. We benchmark
these datasets against models built upon large pre-trained models, such as
RoBERTa and GPT-3. Additionally, we develop and benchmark more structured
models building upon existing Discourse Contextualization Framework and
Political Actor Representation models. We analyze the datasets and the
predictions to obtain further insights into the pragmatic language
understanding challenges posed by the proposed social grounding tasks.
|
[
-0.2040357888,
-0.8057793379,
0.6367623806,
-0.0501949713,
-0.6217491627,
0.2067838907,
-0.2868694365,
0.0749421939,
0.0028641145,
0.642516017,
-0.6061303616,
-0.4615437686,
-0.9748389125,
-0.0005116645,
-0.3037573099,
0.8479724526,
-0.0245969221,
0.1375141591,
0.0388333276,
-0.3229806125,
-0.5014204979,
-0.5146484375,
-0.2099912614,
-0.2764807343,
0.646512866,
0.3401125073,
0.7244762778,
0.4960845411,
0.5211727619,
0.2446620315,
-0.1360366791,
-0.073997654,
-0.7669625282,
0.06684912,
-0.5908576846,
-0.3544613123,
0.2137038112,
0.4824923277,
0.3682503104,
0.7219836712,
0.2571029067,
0.1503195018,
-0.1499802768,
0.7616904378,
-0.841864109,
0.0286080167,
-0.7558050752,
0.2996506691,
0.0802683309,
-0.0838858336,
-0.1956575066,
-0.3148085773,
0.0032416291,
-0.8056579828,
0.0775828585,
-0.1745499372,
1.0648912191,
0.2162400037,
-0.7177066803,
-0.327398628,
-0.5597376227,
0.5130637884,
-0.2957748473,
0.1263923347,
0.5217894316,
0.4291805029,
-0.129115358,
-0.8149963021,
-0.6526551843,
0.3293691278,
-0.0729072541,
0.2160209268,
-0.0214495081,
0.0234001577,
0.2719437182,
0.0988039747,
-0.2003392428,
-0.4972167313,
-0.4667397738,
0.1222373173,
0.4709778428,
-0.0271857809,
0.2536378801,
-0.4851542711,
-0.1946293265,
-0.1326270252,
-0.5765029788,
0.0783813,
0.3443318903,
0.6627137661,
-0.4368721545,
0.3288917243,
-0.1490758806,
0.5180065036,
-0.0320012346,
0.2952018678,
-0.0800315216,
-0.101409398,
-0.4213249981,
-0.1247029155,
0.8113788962,
0.5334252119,
0.3097197711,
0.1544712335,
0.0779769868,
0.4298144579,
0.5865161419,
-0.6466673613,
0.0343771055,
0.2141201794,
-0.5551971793,
-0.3660933971,
0.1962547898,
-0.6950451136,
-0.9827953577,
-0.6189979911,
0.071665898,
-0.2310018837,
-0.4069734514,
0.0428527854,
-0.2449796945,
0.3164378703,
0.3350091279,
-0.4182731211,
0.1683146954,
0.9228006601,
0.8633522987,
0.2516702712,
0.0297190621,
-0.4060436785,
0.079942055,
-0.4773505628,
0.8021100163,
-0.8063376546,
-0.2430914342,
0.25238958,
0.0153671242,
0.1133121848,
-0.4067675173,
0.9836147428,
-0.462687701,
0.0169772059,
-0.9331071973,
-0.4484928548,
-0.2257139981,
0.4036774933,
-0.527320087,
0.8092617989,
-0.0312597603,
-0.9695497155,
0.5140220523,
-0.4187384844,
-0.5749673247,
0.1286499202,
-0.7283130884,
-0.1072128713,
0.5512367487,
0.1396506578,
0.7384783626,
-0.4345676005,
0.8093599081,
-0.2276073694,
-0.5627908707,
0.0782581493,
-0.2134538889,
0.7527931333,
0.33193174,
-0.4570542574,
0.1122329757,
-0.8667861223,
-0.321369797,
0.3281558752,
0.1279674917,
-0.4718395174,
0.453461647,
0.2672230601,
0.3812333941,
-0.067416735,
-0.2913060486,
-0.2311192751,
-0.3501027226,
0.7747250199,
1.0052344799,
-0.1375181079,
0.6559289694,
-0.1728910357,
0.5236865878,
0.0207147151,
-0.093240872,
-0.0385269821,
-0.1226605102,
-0.1984754205,
0.0651539862,
-0.0515936352,
0.6469510198,
-0.4717004001,
0.2159959376,
-0.332480669,
-0.2027657926,
-0.3582445383,
-0.2751969397,
0.205199033,
0.4180155396,
0.2523424923,
0.2014401853,
-0.8564075232,
-1.0274357796,
-0.6795575619,
-0.4234339595,
0.1939634085,
0.3024086058,
0.5503773093,
0.0143218795,
1.2407369614,
-0.2645282745,
0.0334503837,
-0.1433545947,
0.2543594241,
0.20921278,
0.0409277491,
0.2538473308,
-1.5192468166,
-0.4345258176,
0.1070714518,
-0.888620615,
-0.2688115239,
-0.1124296412,
-0.1871419698,
-0.437705934,
0.5591009855,
-0.2677862644,
0.5395165086,
0.5224767923,
-0.3363597095,
0.0132313548,
0.4194696844,
0.5557432175,
-1.3261446953,
-0.0069344053,
-0.0293446537,
-0.4222385883,
-0.7667269111,
0.282422483,
-0.019459879,
-0.3029112518,
-0.7527846098,
0.3556460738,
-0.2247202396,
0.0365413725,
-0.214968726,
0.3423343599,
0.1356297135,
0.0903647915,
0.0833783671,
0.6837629676,
0.3772745728,
-0.1045464054,
0.2752007246,
-0.0228103474,
-0.2713582218,
0.7967005968,
-0.7004725933,
0.1444437355,
-0.4735693038,
0.54236269,
-0.8599378467,
-0.4707156122,
0.5093594193,
-0.3326349556,
-0.2001536936,
-0.5207664371,
-0.4193943441,
-0.1483502835,
-0.0676383451,
0.4173226953,
0.3066322803,
-0.0615220405,
0.6673992872,
1.1049553156,
0.1592217088,
-0.5699959993,
-0.5573092699,
0.3556632102,
-0.3146794438,
-0.3532370925,
0.3136822879,
0.4011322558,
-0.698223412,
-0.0783128291,
0.0542410053,
-0.008843624,
-0.0210152883,
0.6148109436,
-0.3602186441,
-0.0545650274,
0.1695197076,
0.1320586354,
0.0308750365,
0.1048264205,
-0.0917614624,
0.3119790256,
-0.1214466393,
-0.0743379593,
-0.4239355326,
0.8829439282,
0.4268043935,
0.0637248307,
0.6964191794,
0.1428138912,
-0.7486662269,
0.2456352562,
-0.4360963404,
-0.1115975752,
-0.4405689836,
0.0161207225,
-0.0767182857,
-1.1015874147,
0.6316421032,
-0.2439522594,
0.0806131959,
0.3293168545,
0.610024035,
-0.097995162,
0.7515571117,
0.2904196084,
-0.1710914522,
0.2279139459,
-0.051079955,
0.2435532361,
-0.2041344494,
0.1083981246,
-0.5993202329,
-0.1212892085,
-0.3909265995,
-0.4965738058,
0.0970357284,
0.0053891358,
-0.095061928,
0.2635197341,
-0.7228376269,
0.668320477,
-0.0056201066,
-0.0622911789,
-0.2498463541,
0.0750482678,
-0.0591459498,
-0.2799916565,
-0.2440939397,
-0.7874587178,
0.3598611951,
0.2183291465,
0.2745067775,
-0.0896378905,
0.3804171979,
0.451089263,
0.3692236245,
-0.4780690968,
0.6320549846,
-0.1084439307,
-0.6917669177,
-0.0343020558,
-0.2991339862,
-0.8063161969,
0.5421190858,
-0.0137985628,
-0.4196999967,
0.247752592,
-0.1511553824,
-0.2687962353,
0.1366959363,
-0.3926452994,
0.9378555417,
0.2394159883,
-0.3575835824,
-0.2259673178,
-0.9298809767,
0.0566814654,
0.4558116496,
0.9866734743,
-0.3872174323,
0.1073753983,
0.4726999104,
-0.3750504851,
1.0166267157,
-0.2969112396,
-0.156505093,
0.3807025552,
-0.3277076483,
0.3585543931,
0.1162810475,
0.0228845291,
0.00817711,
-0.1623376161,
-0.5165967941,
-0.3866973519,
0.4533912539,
-0.7707961202,
-0.5665333867,
-0.421705842,
-0.3153450787,
0.0104611041,
0.0103764096,
0.273560226,
0.287216872,
-0.5359190702,
0.1118237227,
0.5730914474,
0.0607898943,
0.0879573524,
0.1361687779,
0.0044534444,
-0.3950208426,
0.7265997529,
0.2101548165,
-0.2812740207,
0.3388158679,
0.0832172632,
-0.0263430271,
-0.2728306055,
-0.3354242146,
0.1222267151,
-0.8899485469,
-0.219715476,
-0.9218893051,
0.1362520456,
-0.5078504086,
-0.5519961715,
-0.3456158042,
-0.1943410337,
-0.5434446335,
-0.2316519618,
0.2700968087,
0.7432207465,
-0.0334496647,
0.5665973425,
-0.5234732032,
0.5587739944,
0.0342085026,
0.1929231435,
-0.6782097816,
-0.4228530228,
-0.022816591,
0.1542180032,
-0.278147161,
-1.4698079824,
0.0181614272,
-0.0383457169,
0.0725088269,
0.0985291526,
0.3279387653,
0.8058211803,
-0.9915572405,
0.9064231515,
-0.1759483963,
-0.83465904,
1.0482212305,
-0.7151654363,
-0.0024923121,
0.92438519,
0.4176713824,
-0.6197633743,
-0.5316383243,
-0.5958727598,
-0.9734515548,
0.6024740338,
0.3007711768,
0.6791254878,
-0.2414124012,
0.7865035534,
-0.2035612762,
0.1720311046,
-0.7365982533,
0.0411000922,
-0.3495117724,
-0.1587051302,
0.086249575,
-0.1614779979,
-0.4399913549,
-0.1144433245,
0.2537290156,
-0.1850647628,
-0.045751363,
0.1185345873,
-0.1020421535,
-0.1047732159,
0.2280059904,
0.7089599967,
0.7621560097,
0.1025407016,
0.1051876843,
-0.1265946329,
-0.3365052938,
0.2998591959,
-0.0859856233,
-0.1390661448,
0.0709152892,
0.1876887083,
0.7373415828,
0.3567848802,
-0.5118718743,
0.6989028454,
-0.3069755137,
-0.1123618186,
-0.5461632609,
-0.2443254143,
0.2357171923,
0.1457228065,
0.7079571486,
-0.1014635563,
0.2779587805,
-0.7656679749,
0.2205135524,
0.3073531091,
-0.6225777268,
-0.3104733825,
0.44478333,
0.0904232934,
-0.457775861,
-0.0221703444,
-0.2587153912,
-0.7524833083,
0.4455551803,
0.2879832983,
0.6239833832,
0.0534646064,
0.5659818053,
0.2029007524,
0.2401483506,
-0.2700036764,
0.2563225329,
-0.0145081347,
-0.6906200647,
-0.5151322484,
-0.391835928,
-0.4360212982,
0.1160623282,
-0.7229759097,
0.2456937432,
-0.8849149942,
-0.4597159326,
-0.0994424969,
0.2033591419,
-0.2630848587,
0.3309546709,
-0.0168734808,
0.5807109475,
-1.241617322,
0.3373467028,
0.7657153606,
-0.0231664907,
-0.454051286,
0.0813079178,
0.3181864619,
-0.386572808,
0.4854380488,
0.3186745644,
-0.1255532354,
-0.2981351614,
-0.8444529772,
-0.2246847451,
0.5233650208,
0.7038975954,
-0.4346999824,
-0.0031441308,
0.0566569157,
0.4224518538,
-0.584707737,
-0.1926700473,
0.4261243939,
0.3761401772,
-0.0436376184,
-0.2102114856,
0.2376320958,
-0.4214075208,
0.1476236135,
0.2658654749,
-0.5740557909,
0.7748667002,
0.4067194462,
-0.6213328242,
-0.6820275187,
0.8062304854,
0.2023024112,
0.4952220321,
0.4301835895,
0.2789590359,
0.537211895,
-0.1702774316,
1.0151453018,
-0.1270197332,
0.2250644863,
0.8972912431,
-0.4326603115,
0.5618386269,
0.4355225563,
-0.2003807127,
0.3517396152,
0.6775669456,
0.4504057467,
0.5445382595,
0.4330707192,
-0.3000546098,
-0.2630314529,
-0.3821879923,
-0.3032483459,
0.2300985903,
0.7371158004,
-0.1215554103,
-0.1249906942,
-0.0008444992,
-0.0620198324,
0.9450579882,
-0.232957378,
0.683353126,
0.2903256714,
-0.4162693322,
0.2111158818,
0.2075744718,
0.3328073919,
-0.0393043533,
-0.1928108782,
0.0463414453,
-0.3623350263,
-0.0061044237,
-0.4997040927,
0.631077826,
0.1302066445,
-0.2917592227,
-0.2767142951,
0.7748601437,
0.0492453054,
-0.4397315085,
0.2990184426,
0.1566999406,
0.1276147068,
-0.1543907076,
-0.983201623,
0.561111331,
-0.3257528543,
-0.2270417958,
0.224936232,
0.7519109845,
-0.0883067399,
0.2064337134,
0.6370052099,
0.0629778802,
-0.2168974429,
0.3407697976,
0.9875507951,
-0.3407127857,
-0.4271792769,
-1.0685546398,
0.5347698331,
-0.4989941716,
-0.3054044247,
0.2524937391,
0.3740045428,
0.545813024,
0.5007660985,
0.8019297719,
-0.1919190288,
0.6583414078,
-0.4910920858,
0.7307030559,
-0.5500610471,
-0.0508689433,
-0.4470747411,
-0.4061042666,
-0.3676800132,
1.1590592861,
-0.315225929,
-0.126811564,
0.2542071342,
0.4177993238,
-0.2027856559,
0.3057969809,
0.4032023549,
0.0770129338,
0.182825923,
0.4399360418,
0.9383866787,
-0.6091194153,
0.2714227438,
0.1245707348,
-0.0658755451,
-0.0288345795,
-1.0005666018,
-1.0460393429,
-0.8555480242,
-0.1312918067,
-0.4107888639,
0.2265277803,
1.0405623913,
0.6196700931,
-0.6699323654,
-0.0724146664,
-0.257391721,
0.2590341568,
0.2035307139,
-0.2202495337,
0.2446722686,
-0.2061536163,
-0.6211070418,
0.2230857015,
0.2636850476,
-0.2961951792,
-0.0246685073,
0.1954461038,
-0.4678074718,
0.2939824462,
0.5198175907,
0.1005499437,
-0.8789396882,
-0.7040390968,
-0.1689626873,
-0.2865419984,
0.0594934076,
1.2815816402,
-0.6693585515,
-0.0323943608,
0.3970250487,
0.8262717724,
0.0025827999,
0.1183328927,
0.6989766359,
-0.8302232623,
0.3880891502,
0.2583807111,
0.2753487527,
0.474422425,
-0.3669920564,
0.4843837023,
0.3374876678,
-0.3703606129,
-1.1058239937,
0.5648962855,
-0.6208528876,
-0.3410495222,
1.0118466616,
-0.2360097021,
-0.2909409404,
-0.3845080435,
-0.2791388035,
0.5376691818,
-0.3066926003,
0.4945982695,
0.9947680831,
0.5906527042,
-0.4804841578,
-0.677397728,
0.3170184195,
0.3548179567,
-0.5963274837,
0.3778735697,
0.6033214927,
-0.0552339889,
0.199239701,
1.1195766926,
-0.0294380095,
0.2937210202,
-0.2116307169,
-0.2814210951,
0.50599581,
-0.0890076905,
-0.3208532035,
0.6039037108,
-0.6557256579,
0.3475042582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09105v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09105v2
|
MAVEN-Arg: Completing the Puzzle of All-in-One Event Understanding Dataset with Event Argument Annotation
| 2023-11-15T16:52:14 | 2024-06-18T22:15:39 |
Xiaozhi Wang, Hao Peng, Yong Guan, Kaisheng Zeng, Jianhui Chen, Lei Hou, Xu Han, Yankai Lin, Zhiyuan Liu, Ruobing Xie, Jie Zhou, Juanzi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Understanding events in texts is a core objective of natural language
understanding, which requires detecting event occurrences, extracting event
arguments, and analyzing inter-event relationships. However, due to the
annotation challenges brought by task complexity, a large-scale dataset
covering the full process of event understanding has long been absent. In this
paper, we introduce MAVEN-Arg, which augments MAVEN datasets with event
argument annotations, making the first all-in-one dataset supporting event
detection, event argument extraction (EAE), and event relation extraction. As
an EAE benchmark, MAVEN-Arg offers three main advantages: (1) a comprehensive
schema covering 162 event types and 612 argument roles, all with expert-written
definitions and examples; (2) a large data scale, containing 98,591 events and
290,613 arguments obtained with laborious human annotation; (3) the exhaustive
annotation supporting all task variants of EAE, which annotates both entity and
non-entity event arguments in document level. Experiments indicate that
MAVEN-Arg is quite challenging for both fine-tuned EAE models and proprietary
large language models (LLMs). Furthermore, to demonstrate the benefits of an
all-in-one dataset, we preliminarily explore a potential application, future
event prediction, with LLMs. MAVEN-Arg and codes can be obtained from
https://github.com/THU-KEG/MAVEN-Argument.
|
[
-0.6657482386,
-0.5727027059,
0.5766879916,
-0.2467238307,
-0.57064116,
-0.443754822,
-0.1008954942,
-0.3401233256,
-0.1193845347,
0.6809809804,
-0.8254644871,
-0.7975632548,
-0.7342329621,
0.058121711,
-0.1921069324,
1.1508055925,
-0.1112979949,
-0.1396394819,
-0.3843644857,
-0.3621538579,
-0.22903274,
-0.4105553329,
-0.8951876163,
-0.241830796,
0.573341012,
0.46999529,
0.2003675401,
1.0166902542,
0.2700379193,
0.1272705644,
0.0167973228,
0.3711146712,
-0.1016749144,
0.2595187128,
-0.0295934174,
-0.093190603,
-0.4288518429,
0.1268630028,
0.6282781959,
0.5793753862,
0.1554256231,
0.4818525612,
-0.1608454287,
0.480546236,
-0.7482252121,
0.2866697907,
-0.4742673934,
-0.0032078014,
-0.6483405232,
-0.1404687911,
-0.361007601,
0.2011666149,
0.2171859592,
-0.8573736548,
-0.015504472,
0.2292306721,
0.7998132706,
0.2688507736,
-0.4673786461,
-0.1091301665,
-0.5022563934,
0.7098752856,
-0.6895765066,
0.2761212587,
0.2104470283,
0.148050651,
-0.4745784998,
-0.4798668921,
-0.4633839428,
-0.06422171,
0.07330852,
0.2872523963,
0.1961903423,
0.3099132478,
0.2774997354,
0.3984179497,
-0.7732050419,
0.1720162481,
0.0173266418,
0.0701760352,
0.5342105031,
0.0698092356,
0.1778633446,
-0.1953995228,
-0.5939697623,
0.2339788526,
-0.6458716393,
-0.2496548444,
0.2488187104,
0.1558829993,
0.0641522035,
0.3846598268,
-0.1776489615,
0.8954474926,
-0.1681921184,
0.1158331186,
-0.0311910044,
-0.2635084093,
-0.2559781671,
0.0850240216,
0.7513523102,
0.1917972565,
0.2178075761,
-0.2255552709,
0.2809467018,
-0.329197973,
0.0804706886,
-0.6931983829,
-0.029575292,
0.279128015,
-0.4321811795,
-0.2419546098,
0.031236127,
-1.1839348078,
-0.8966278434,
-0.2232014537,
0.4035102427,
-0.2417485267,
-0.2410773933,
0.2490845621,
-0.1563551426,
0.3246955872,
0.4709073305,
-0.523311615,
0.1990015209,
0.9022567868,
0.7127367258,
-0.3949311674,
-0.4121930599,
-0.9107211232,
0.2915629447,
-0.2888730466,
0.9875132442,
-0.789522469,
-0.2465046793,
-0.0609925762,
-0.057757657,
0.1348299086,
-0.2244689018,
1.0195598602,
-0.2275212854,
0.4760539532,
-0.141602397,
-1.0456427336,
-0.368997246,
0.286177814,
-0.6671683788,
0.9906612039,
-0.2899128199,
-0.5642085671,
0.7955582142,
-1.0169143677,
-0.2553914785,
0.2419869304,
-0.156394735,
-0.5245268345,
-0.0314118303,
0.4257793128,
0.4955569506,
-0.5526562929,
-0.1734659672,
-0.3956998587,
-0.1720019877,
-0.300319761,
-0.1150300428,
0.5646904707,
-0.0403260887,
-0.2917656004,
-0.0686248913,
-0.9595441222,
-0.4737205207,
0.1804691255,
-0.2069042921,
-0.257676363,
0.2274236977,
-0.3144754469,
0.0886863172,
0.2978085577,
-0.5811530352,
0.4873624146,
-0.4030506015,
-0.1600990146,
0.7914226055,
0.3091199398,
0.6592977047,
0.0063981935,
0.6023333669,
0.1298812628,
0.1906285435,
-0.599512279,
-0.7449018955,
-0.509820044,
-0.3385807276,
0.1482201666,
0.4502730668,
-0.3632702827,
0.3426391482,
-0.1503919512,
-0.4921015203,
-0.308544755,
0.0463862941,
0.182160601,
0.5307840109,
0.2003962845,
0.3464098573,
-0.8558680415,
-0.7990714908,
-0.4416233301,
-0.6167183518,
-0.1630055159,
0.2729370296,
0.3541168869,
-0.0726726577,
0.7212799191,
-0.2507071197,
-0.1604896933,
-0.0076111918,
0.5420706272,
0.2003199458,
0.1713100374,
0.4583416581,
-0.5487552881,
-0.0359663852,
0.3424482644,
-0.5253321528,
-0.3725238442,
-0.284737438,
-0.4208917916,
0.2885889411,
0.3669700325,
-0.5353771448,
0.2064035982,
0.4451864362,
-0.3965496123,
0.5675240159,
0.2012441456,
0.2670890093,
-1.1553994417,
-0.2275604755,
0.0046438389,
-0.1462999731,
-0.5882428885,
-0.0358358733,
-0.185885489,
0.023908291,
-0.3546806574,
0.9747445583,
-0.2139033377,
0.0970089659,
-0.2793957293,
0.3252983093,
0.2673154473,
0.1898752004,
-0.0218885057,
0.6492974162,
0.6810430884,
-0.6310867071,
0.5095310807,
0.2232838571,
-0.1388320625,
0.3376433849,
-0.085928686,
0.1245920509,
-0.0627575219,
0.1571769118,
-0.865881145,
-0.2264597863,
0.3019452989,
-0.4332966208,
0.0399676077,
-0.7206001878,
-0.5231558084,
-0.1248781309,
-0.2373450696,
0.1348003149,
0.2477553636,
-0.8978036046,
1.0922784805,
0.3171413243,
0.0319742337,
-0.6297308207,
-0.40718472,
0.2479278147,
-0.442953974,
-0.550426662,
-0.0462409668,
0.1758455187,
-0.2985517979,
-0.1034938991,
-0.2611041069,
-0.1191995144,
0.0373713784,
0.3577628136,
0.415553391,
-0.4300356805,
0.6352606416,
-0.2376879305,
-0.4066932201,
0.0494849533,
-0.5941268206,
0.1126630828,
-0.0464875586,
-0.5825544,
-0.0376485065,
0.5408343077,
0.7269137502,
-0.2539232671,
0.659660995,
0.5577405691,
-0.5962578654,
-0.1015434191,
-0.729398489,
-0.0680521727,
-0.3510343134,
0.3514437377,
-0.3359767199,
-0.733623445,
0.5252044201,
-0.4121897519,
0.6048085093,
0.6674301028,
0.4088691175,
-0.0308442023,
0.9979408383,
-0.0390366502,
-0.0538964048,
0.3740852773,
0.2970709205,
0.1088838577,
-0.6263302565,
0.0432548635,
-0.3363072574,
-0.0489651561,
-0.3407325149,
-0.264932543,
0.0264363438,
0.2406418324,
-0.332768172,
0.1478270441,
-0.4670529664,
0.5768443942,
0.2170438021,
-0.3991988599,
0.298579663,
-0.4613699615,
0.1403110623,
0.0842389539,
-0.5159875751,
-0.8230667114,
0.9045270681,
0.045040071,
0.2090503573,
-0.1767466664,
0.8417900801,
0.2486857474,
0.1411425322,
-0.7738890052,
0.6223021746,
-0.1474514455,
-0.7365059853,
-0.278714478,
-0.2098430246,
-0.8639340401,
0.2313565463,
-0.3155329227,
-0.8860793114,
0.0755349845,
0.0688438639,
-0.1608594656,
0.6433471441,
-0.717654109,
1.0278638601,
-0.0287540611,
-0.0993388668,
0.1225672215,
-0.1891655773,
0.2723326385,
-0.0371530391,
0.3602350056,
-0.3748823106,
-0.1307757497,
1.0124057531,
-0.1839057207,
0.307982564,
-0.1552895755,
0.0830341503,
0.3989380002,
0.07306315,
0.8626928329,
0.3040623963,
-0.4113094509,
0.1491097361,
-0.0763828903,
-0.41939798,
-0.5724129677,
0.5463222265,
-0.3761270344,
-0.6964671016,
-0.32904616,
-0.3619861901,
-0.1940070093,
-0.1053419262,
0.2303550094,
0.4755184948,
-0.0774150267,
0.0429359153,
0.6380375624,
-0.0683074519,
0.4135281444,
0.5151703954,
-0.2150366306,
-0.1713344008,
0.6900151372,
0.0059306049,
-0.0667854548,
0.1124496385,
0.334027499,
-0.017307505,
-0.5137836337,
-0.8208764791,
-0.1208277419,
-0.8669136167,
-0.219342947,
-0.8954256177,
0.1359876394,
0.0400911234,
-0.3269200921,
-0.4400992692,
-0.5018465519,
-0.3501998782,
-0.3591645062,
0.9048007131,
0.6582481265,
0.0213637091,
0.0764022097,
-0.9380764961,
0.2167772353,
0.2155388892,
0.4423686266,
-0.2201137394,
-0.2472686917,
-0.3231197894,
-0.271379143,
-0.057856828,
-0.9906823039,
-0.1316985041,
0.3129849732,
0.5673356056,
0.5563473105,
0.1554053426,
0.5510503054,
-0.5243753195,
1.1467498541,
-0.1701188833,
-0.8920121789,
0.7483610511,
-0.539444387,
0.1793663353,
0.3379890025,
0.0341871157,
-0.5091512203,
-0.3086621761,
-0.5641044974,
-0.8497310877,
0.7442640066,
0.135138914,
-0.4447208047,
-0.307911098,
0.7808200717,
0.481654346,
-0.3360505402,
-0.5149660707,
-0.3052313626,
0.1086245552,
-0.0274980552,
0.22993128,
-0.1675244719,
-0.1836513281,
0.0245375428,
0.7226376534,
-0.1087055802,
0.0060867793,
-0.0790980607,
0.0924218521,
-0.1001360789,
0.3565790057,
0.2925484776,
0.618449688,
-0.1310191751,
0.1445461512,
0.8515866399,
-0.2563430667,
-0.0434478223,
0.2459803969,
0.2873033285,
0.1266019046,
0.5500593781,
0.6430826783,
-0.0261208136,
-0.5607838631,
0.532378912,
-0.034763813,
-0.2228198946,
-0.2550866902,
0.012620572,
0.067455776,
0.3168201447,
0.4186249077,
-0.2581871152,
0.3260012865,
-0.1524777859,
0.3625685871,
0.2066039592,
-0.272370249,
0.0082970569,
0.58420825,
0.1386137307,
-0.0625022873,
-0.0252467692,
-0.4300668836,
-0.3596649468,
0.7118353248,
0.2119714916,
0.8909721971,
0.1138012186,
-0.0349448062,
0.4257002175,
0.2266074121,
0.0183217637,
0.1653032005,
0.0316027589,
-0.4344189763,
-0.784711659,
-0.6072464585,
-0.6865144968,
0.2848787606,
-0.4536559284,
0.5216507912,
-0.18853046,
0.1238057911,
0.1343979686,
0.0963556394,
-0.5281353593,
0.1125948057,
0.3937860131,
0.6820859313,
-0.7636021972,
0.5431597233,
1.0838137865,
-0.2842121422,
-0.1179224402,
-0.0174466819,
0.1718419343,
-0.2305241525,
0.4320230186,
0.0320339799,
-0.1194501594,
-0.1482189894,
-0.2282936275,
-0.6835506558,
0.8089473248,
0.2954180241,
-0.3116687536,
0.2673915625,
0.0262849499,
0.138865754,
-0.5168987513,
0.0193085093,
0.6554465294,
0.9486294389,
0.0762699842,
-0.3861584663,
0.0715022534,
-0.0732143,
-0.3281776905,
0.595805645,
-0.2096416056,
0.5635816455,
0.1076820046,
-0.2365248948,
-0.175462231,
0.6315217614,
0.3574514389,
0.4040788412,
0.6315893531,
0.6021808386,
0.7023878694,
-0.346744597,
1.0329883099,
-0.1415448487,
0.1472074389,
1.0562672615,
-0.1970367879,
0.4843364358,
0.2526814342,
0.0820382461,
0.187518239,
0.8456000686,
0.1455754936,
0.1325747073,
-0.0423153974,
-0.5466011167,
-0.7312772274,
-0.1207268462,
-0.1998185515,
0.3976355195,
0.3704945147,
0.0553833358,
-0.4720596075,
0.055869516,
0.1089545861,
-0.2337096781,
-0.3637744784,
0.846968472,
-0.147842139,
-0.3603885472,
0.0554900691,
-0.3555971384,
0.3367688954,
-0.5408594012,
-0.2326914966,
0.189108789,
0.0040023937,
-0.1283576638,
-0.9368923306,
0.3139978349,
0.0064721582,
-0.220847711,
0.1415264606,
0.836268127,
-0.1363022476,
-0.3051816523,
0.5461400747,
0.3926410973,
0.0764279589,
-0.2441196591,
-0.2912385464,
-0.1690975428,
-0.3351045847,
-0.7550531626,
0.1480518281,
0.897028625,
0.0806998163,
0.3296553791,
0.5527480245,
0.0641108751,
0.2051901817,
0.0048375404,
0.5890051126,
-0.4404278398,
0.0195401665,
-1.1695711613,
0.6151373982,
-0.2704607844,
-0.5476499796,
0.5007827282,
0.427485913,
0.5697398186,
0.2890666723,
0.7658724785,
0.3655307889,
0.4027516246,
-0.3091694117,
0.3812748492,
-0.6403374076,
-0.0407792106,
-0.0215023477,
-0.7463801503,
-0.59775424,
0.4096356928,
-0.2950239182,
-0.1581659317,
0.4101939201,
0.4423111975,
0.1671971381,
0.3939022422,
0.3572071791,
-0.0338154696,
0.5124902725,
0.3289011419,
0.6948333979,
-0.3508538902,
0.6807360053,
0.2393445224,
-0.2925343812,
-0.3094508648,
-1.1639530659,
-1.0418254137,
-0.7733275294,
-0.4749751091,
-0.0464375243,
0.2298135906,
1.2953078747,
0.6850166321,
-0.9385317564,
0.189563185,
-0.1745940447,
0.0807566345,
-0.1466302127,
-0.1394535601,
0.337341845,
-0.3875618875,
-0.6483387351,
0.5608812571,
0.6574843526,
-0.1883172095,
0.0860072523,
-0.0670519099,
-0.5062195063,
0.4462306499,
0.6081859469,
0.3408203721,
-0.6563200355,
-0.4299664795,
-0.4594279528,
0.1965129972,
-0.0093031414,
0.4938445091,
-0.572349906,
0.6168435216,
0.5137104392,
0.964892745,
0.5850875378,
-0.2540638447,
0.6899738312,
-0.8477661014,
0.0838009566,
0.0828609541,
0.7384653687,
0.0247422922,
-0.4767881036,
0.6529543996,
-0.1118607223,
-0.649815619,
-0.6489697695,
0.4276100099,
-0.8598554134,
-0.217422545,
1.2725430727,
-0.1524145156,
-0.085257329,
-0.3717371821,
-0.349188,
0.5099887848,
-0.2952257097,
0.6791379452,
1.1590363979,
-0.1757845432,
-0.4251460731,
-0.7022897005,
0.4472093284,
0.2485349625,
-0.9244980216,
0.4695665538,
0.377910614,
-0.3785234392,
0.121208258,
0.1252304465,
-0.1039548367,
0.3443454504,
-0.1284470558,
0.304857105,
-0.3579729795,
-0.1325220764,
-0.2222271413,
0.1059847623,
-0.0042670672,
-0.6329119205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09101v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09101v2
|
Towards A Unified View of Answer Calibration for Multi-Step Reasoning
| 2023-11-15T16:47:57 | 2024-02-25T15:53:37 |
Shumin Deng, Ningyu Zhang, Nay Oo, Bryan Hooi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) employing Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting have
broadened the scope for improving multi-step reasoning capabilities. We
generally divide multi-step reasoning into two phases: path generation to
generate the reasoning path(s); and answer calibration post-processing the
reasoning path(s) to obtain a final answer. However, the existing literature
lacks systematic analysis on different answer calibration approaches. In this
paper, we summarize the taxonomy of recent answer calibration techniques and
break them down into step-level and path-level strategies. We then conduct a
thorough evaluation on these strategies from a unified view, systematically
scrutinizing step-level and path-level answer calibration across multiple
paths. Experimental results reveal that integrating the dominance of both
strategies tends to derive optimal outcomes. Our study holds the potential to
illuminate key insights for optimizing multi-step reasoning with answer
calibration.
|
[
-0.5753944516,
-0.6824355125,
1.0026239157,
-0.0819442868,
-0.1906272024,
0.3284908533,
-0.0731181577,
-0.2255599797,
-0.2574714422,
0.6694051027,
-0.8200967312,
-0.3081298769,
-0.2747772932,
0.0833281204,
0.1302947849,
1.0664782524,
-0.2424235195,
0.4264568686,
-0.3813668489,
-0.2071387172,
-0.6199595332,
-0.4931583405,
-0.4453689158,
-0.671651423,
0.8355506063,
0.4861456454,
0.5038338304,
0.3592197299,
0.2404715866,
0.1648149043,
-0.2146475911,
0.4677850902,
-0.1095796078,
0.3430802822,
-0.2226920575,
-0.6409365535,
-0.296038866,
-0.0579184629,
0.3460423648,
0.7968320251,
-0.0889807343,
0.4957324564,
0.0903782323,
0.7704147696,
-1.0515304804,
-0.2603048384,
-0.5210158229,
-0.0999578759,
0.1665729433,
-0.5174244642,
-0.6974589229,
-0.4784602225,
-0.0084523754,
-0.3451094031,
-0.0295256302,
-0.0922251269,
0.0694055706,
0.3562153876,
-0.8603986502,
-0.5369967222,
-1.0046445131,
0.9380185008,
-0.569694221,
0.1016436368,
-0.0846475363,
0.4448998272,
-0.1548650116,
-0.32111305,
-0.127328068,
0.0541889779,
0.0945579782,
0.0133575862,
0.4043906331,
0.2473944128,
0.2330104262,
0.232095778,
-0.4496771395,
-0.1323881149,
-0.2261032164,
-0.3446345031,
0.6096816063,
0.1409200728,
-0.0734378472,
-0.1048322022,
-0.5188530684,
-0.3200874627,
-0.8406904936,
0.2552665472,
0.3806340396,
0.5497898459,
0.483889401,
0.3564595878,
-0.0432713106,
1.0082341433,
0.0364691988,
-0.3762934208,
-0.0980389118,
-0.7608798146,
-0.0405633263,
0.01359253,
0.4695480764,
0.0373298451,
0.2976760268,
-0.0704572126,
-0.0820319429,
-0.320181042,
0.3516030014,
-0.6828848124,
0.0907595307,
0.5453984141,
0.1933961064,
-0.2211773098,
-0.05550633,
-0.8295149207,
-0.503929913,
-0.4976831675,
0.5582728386,
-0.123103939,
-0.1347759366,
0.2018998563,
0.1005515158,
0.7327854633,
0.8312946558,
-0.4787553251,
0.2562778592,
0.8257367015,
0.5356677175,
0.186645478,
-0.138320595,
-0.8351751566,
0.1434746236,
-0.6840596199,
0.9993157983,
-0.2196384072,
-0.317658931,
-0.1024381816,
-0.5446200371,
-0.1062512845,
-0.2255828232,
0.5812764764,
-0.7174373269,
0.0963407382,
-0.7341916561,
-0.3176332712,
-0.4551360607,
0.4715743661,
-0.4714268744,
0.9560680389,
-0.4313832521,
-0.7546333075,
0.2116056383,
-0.6297546625,
-0.3401387632,
-0.161152333,
-0.3464442194,
0.2971817255,
0.0586002767,
0.5785729289,
0.2344792038,
-0.5677839518,
0.2192218155,
-0.1645590663,
-0.3347879648,
-0.0070164069,
-0.758790791,
0.8456363082,
0.2812303603,
-0.2945200801,
0.0455168821,
-0.7040371895,
0.5322456956,
-0.2287941575,
-0.3754300773,
-0.1391216069,
0.0807728991,
-0.4153108001,
0.6015377045,
0.2133700699,
-0.6743790507,
0.0774770826,
-0.091980353,
0.1414336413,
1.0361562967,
0.1717011482,
0.2811279297,
-0.309600085,
0.6475036144,
0.1685244292,
0.1671665907,
-0.5536876321,
-0.486623913,
-0.7109813094,
0.1966441721,
0.0746786892,
0.6673713923,
-0.4129231572,
0.3142000437,
-0.0315299816,
-0.546620965,
-0.7389796972,
0.2299523354,
0.6385659575,
0.6003332734,
0.4854536057,
-0.0297050625,
-0.1764210314,
-0.5775358081,
-0.4389975667,
-0.3272485137,
0.0756183639,
0.2289204597,
0.4253285229,
0.213240996,
0.6848785281,
-0.5394716859,
0.2838363349,
0.0231947601,
0.2661215365,
0.2480637282,
0.0821515247,
-0.0155454362,
-0.7549036145,
-0.2421072423,
-0.0962226093,
-0.5979158282,
0.0683500767,
-0.2180822492,
-0.265953809,
0.0064059505,
0.4744334519,
-0.0510385558,
0.4723548293,
0.4633962512,
-0.0353928171,
0.6916729808,
-0.2832756639,
0.520658493,
-0.968613565,
-0.0195056479,
-0.0053875796,
-0.3595419526,
-0.6534641981,
0.4998277426,
0.0017994614,
0.5328517556,
-0.4905919135,
0.2532450259,
-0.5668796301,
-0.1441322714,
-0.195558846,
0.5228452682,
0.2005954087,
0.511919558,
-0.251013279,
0.8089318871,
0.3399439156,
-0.6043573618,
0.7055391669,
0.1000004262,
-0.1011146829,
0.7088727355,
-0.5282313228,
0.646530807,
-0.3777333796,
0.7443003654,
-1.571855545,
0.1663314849,
-0.0428015478,
-0.2391111851,
-0.0178751014,
-0.1958457232,
-0.7311170101,
-0.6829436421,
-0.5527898669,
0.7135615945,
0.1392800212,
-0.6478507519,
0.650811851,
-0.0828601792,
0.0694159716,
-0.7723615766,
-0.6064065695,
-0.2160959095,
0.0004199048,
-0.5996910334,
-0.0643938333,
-0.5630866289,
-0.123391211,
-0.7154806256,
-0.5464637876,
0.1065322906,
-0.2622764707,
0.1033913121,
0.305464834,
-0.1330096126,
0.027967196,
0.0953099281,
-0.1580110937,
0.2092262208,
-0.070573993,
0.7872229815,
-0.1985298842,
-0.7329688072,
-0.1642956138,
0.4151428342,
0.6996640563,
-0.4393928051,
0.5345997214,
0.3480246365,
-0.0985882208,
0.1123052835,
-0.6715071797,
-0.1110845655,
-0.4291889369,
-0.0163614042,
-0.7088277936,
-0.5604134798,
0.4704031646,
-0.3607494533,
0.5611824393,
0.2774347961,
0.5532386899,
0.1832736582,
1.2950421572,
0.2115920037,
0.3211842775,
-0.176926598,
-0.2429878265,
0.4573192894,
-1.3845169544,
-0.5083864331,
-0.7046939135,
-0.1494597495,
-0.4356288314,
-0.698261261,
0.455252856,
0.3145002127,
-0.5780121684,
0.1332339346,
-0.5133422017,
0.4957856834,
0.402094245,
0.2622311711,
0.4951558411,
-0.2771817744,
-0.7814924121,
0.2851132452,
-0.5488989353,
-0.6233284473,
1.3297048807,
0.1184171364,
0.8137714863,
-0.1578505337,
0.801892817,
-0.1531620473,
0.1558583677,
-0.7541005015,
0.6891075373,
0.2233130038,
-0.6658753157,
-0.4537081718,
-0.3366475701,
-0.4659897089,
0.5872266889,
0.1428447813,
-0.9712067246,
-0.0887325779,
0.1088410541,
-0.4880298376,
0.4848124087,
-0.4588487446,
0.6200973988,
-0.3318023086,
-0.2247257978,
-0.1590414941,
-0.9323646426,
0.3357823789,
-0.2094213367,
0.4898416102,
0.0099864108,
-0.0068726637,
0.4455410242,
-0.2746151686,
0.426674366,
-0.1581571251,
-0.539681673,
0.4569976926,
0.0084602321,
0.3715489209,
-0.1293103397,
-0.2927415371,
-0.3535889685,
0.4174534082,
-0.4209540784,
-0.5892779231,
0.7271530628,
-0.4530563951,
-0.777629137,
-0.4210008383,
-0.6047440171,
-0.7201564312,
0.0478522778,
0.1364428252,
0.6373331547,
-0.1181029677,
-0.1750446707,
0.6427538991,
-0.0696938485,
0.4160159826,
0.2806971669,
-0.5027446151,
-0.5593128204,
0.2388964444,
-0.2485486865,
0.761494875,
0.519392252,
0.2552651763,
-0.5563558936,
-0.0768520758,
-0.6970184445,
0.3324515522,
-1.1269574165,
-0.2613621354,
-0.2659218907,
-0.3453090787,
-0.3815994561,
-0.0443714298,
-0.2494520992,
-0.1926903725,
0.0089395847,
-0.1212140992,
0.2247365862,
0.7984088063,
-0.0846730471,
-0.0707261488,
-0.626953423,
0.442751497,
0.4721127152,
0.0218277834,
0.2977205515,
-0.2752407789,
0.0368520655,
0.6664351821,
-0.6631814241,
-0.9532790184,
-0.4333124459,
-0.0587360859,
0.4098487496,
0.2113159746,
0.0844835863,
1.1941193342,
-0.7101572156,
0.7317817211,
0.3690033257,
-0.8223320246,
0.9008525014,
0.0781918168,
0.5929803252,
0.8790504336,
0.3854133785,
-0.5982384682,
-0.3756635487,
-0.1531419456,
-0.8420656323,
0.4761089385,
-0.1999411136,
0.2246322632,
0.259965986,
0.3630443513,
-0.038070824,
0.2798282504,
-0.468547672,
-0.4640387893,
0.3284370005,
0.0858240053,
-0.0359933041,
0.2208040953,
-0.340886265,
-0.4308981001,
0.5025315285,
-0.4158701301,
0.0036345664,
0.1566203684,
-0.0904003009,
-0.4631565213,
0.5300676227,
0.3263431787,
1.04594028,
-0.1963105202,
0.1654636562,
0.0514038876,
-0.3341895342,
0.467885375,
-0.1738716662,
-0.1866296679,
-0.2606550157,
0.234444499,
0.6514391303,
0.0769792199,
-0.4221403003,
0.6442509294,
0.1563914865,
-0.2117641121,
-0.027508622,
0.1839698702,
0.0254305806,
0.0866480619,
0.4825930595,
0.197275281,
0.1072332188,
-0.6740210652,
0.0455145165,
0.4720078707,
-0.4204456508,
-0.0556711704,
0.53658849,
-0.0637785643,
-0.2629385591,
0.543048501,
0.3212639689,
-0.4766375721,
0.4413203299,
0.4669624865,
0.8304247856,
-0.4384084344,
0.6250723004,
0.4201975763,
0.1558606476,
-0.0887666568,
0.338157624,
-0.3315474987,
-0.6646543145,
-0.8011294603,
-0.7406044006,
-0.6198586822,
0.0277628992,
-0.9690463543,
0.1554306895,
-0.2381870151,
0.1284957677,
0.073597081,
0.0787071362,
-0.7389089465,
0.3802793324,
0.1967732608,
0.9979435205,
-0.7384335995,
0.4763710201,
0.8498980403,
-0.3723944426,
-1.0571939945,
0.3249171078,
0.2128521353,
-0.8524549603,
0.2219872624,
0.4381661415,
-0.7845717669,
0.0026346578,
-0.5190728903,
-0.7210723758,
1.1792991161,
0.2901000381,
-0.3098429441,
-0.2677805424,
0.3781218231,
0.5303610563,
-0.3643202484,
0.5032019019,
0.7189655304,
0.4854519665,
0.7178341746,
-0.861281693,
0.0754878148,
0.1231708601,
0.1294350624,
0.3368246853,
-0.415827632,
0.5033391714,
-0.5228918195,
0.1414710283,
0.2825369835,
0.1639222205,
0.7280079126,
0.1513283253,
0.6680477262,
0.4623643756,
0.6081333756,
0.0299330112,
0.8557708859,
-0.2280427516,
0.2734563351,
1.002301693,
-0.23186782,
1.0287911892,
0.7064382434,
-0.3294707239,
0.8065456748,
0.8137816191,
0.5470526814,
0.4928310812,
0.5365481377,
-0.4183876216,
-0.4945843816,
0.1443696171,
-0.0283013694,
0.3173195124,
0.2064024508,
0.0712338686,
-0.4819402695,
-0.0743835419,
0.1414707899,
-0.0271942839,
-0.5769676566,
0.7900983095,
0.0188584253,
-1.219163537,
0.6032995582,
-0.1862887591,
0.1906234771,
-0.3840655982,
-0.0145587064,
-0.1782860309,
0.1116327494,
-0.1015941352,
-1.1108721495,
-0.0783244297,
0.1956266314,
0.0506083779,
-0.2463745028,
0.2329971194,
-0.2531383634,
-0.4900574982,
0.5154781342,
0.747058332,
0.0540797301,
-0.1571284533,
-0.7547215223,
-0.3050615788,
0.030792689,
-0.2478495836,
0.047932025,
0.4115880728,
0.1454885155,
0.6145825386,
0.5076450109,
0.0166434459,
0.3056964576,
0.2064892054,
0.8143075705,
-0.4544603229,
-0.2752084136,
-0.7323706746,
0.7158802152,
0.1417234242,
-0.3072461188,
0.4253131449,
0.5751053691,
0.7416102886,
0.3544019759,
0.5474775434,
0.2964360714,
0.4206649959,
-0.519199729,
-0.0813643113,
-0.7844257355,
0.5206444263,
-0.5892486572,
-1.0245367289,
-0.368724525,
0.463252306,
-0.3284227848,
0.2959108353,
0.9807833433,
0.7668556571,
0.1218840629,
0.0964581966,
0.1510938257,
-0.0977369398,
0.3169009686,
0.8004286289,
0.6749660969,
-0.5277438164,
0.7399627566,
-0.1426460594,
-0.4133397043,
0.1132124588,
-0.8914955258,
-0.5068797469,
-0.5200183988,
-0.1204383969,
-0.3423865139,
-0.1018152907,
0.6256216168,
0.6544141769,
-0.9259921312,
-0.5174818039,
-0.3616341949,
0.1022736058,
-0.205065906,
-0.1525052339,
0.174890846,
-0.556859076,
-0.3520068228,
0.0988150164,
0.4841514826,
-0.4080406725,
-0.5905054212,
-0.0465555415,
-0.4647293389,
0.6328809261,
0.605817616,
0.0421994105,
-1.0534945726,
-0.281822741,
0.1589294523,
-0.1654645056,
0.5027063489,
0.9014031291,
-0.6686293483,
0.7350450158,
0.3682138026,
0.4350065291,
0.5191226006,
0.2841439545,
0.6227586269,
-0.570577383,
-0.3208007216,
0.205932796,
0.2270121574,
0.2963197529,
-0.1285762489,
0.4886311591,
-0.2809313834,
-0.7923510075,
-0.6092395782,
0.6319115758,
-0.7560192943,
-0.3423471451,
1.2885396481,
-0.1759833395,
-0.0237179343,
0.1567597985,
-0.433568716,
0.2965025604,
-0.0638314933,
0.3754533529,
0.9465335011,
-0.5201500654,
-0.1964082271,
-0.5746057034,
0.1335101426,
0.1855788678,
-1.0333653688,
0.1999436468,
0.621694684,
0.1538821757,
0.5429636836,
0.7612475157,
-0.2560859919,
0.2759999931,
-0.3145052791,
-0.4562030733,
0.5201513171,
-0.6981768012,
-0.4475772679,
-0.0386761092,
0.2433701307,
-0.2083144635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09096v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09096v2
|
Defending Large Language Models Against Jailbreaking Attacks Through Goal Prioritization
| 2023-11-15T16:42:29 | 2024-06-12T08:28:15 |
Zhexin Zhang, Junxiao Yang, Pei Ke, Fei Mi, Hongning Wang, Minlie Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While significant attention has been dedicated to exploiting weaknesses in
LLMs through jailbreaking attacks, there remains a paucity of effort in
defending against these attacks. We point out a pivotal factor contributing to
the success of jailbreaks: the intrinsic conflict between the goals of being
helpful and ensuring safety. Accordingly, we propose to integrate goal
prioritization at both training and inference stages to counteract.
Implementing goal prioritization during inference substantially diminishes the
Attack Success Rate (ASR) of jailbreaking from 66.4% to 3.6% for ChatGPT. And
integrating goal prioritization into model training reduces the ASR from 71.0%
to 6.6% for Llama2-13B. Remarkably, even in scenarios where no jailbreaking
samples are included during training, our approach slashes the ASR by half.
Additionally, our findings reveal that while stronger LLMs face greater safety
risks, they also possess a greater capacity to be steered towards defending
against such attacks, both because of their stronger ability in instruction
following. Our work thus contributes to the comprehension of jailbreaking
attacks and defenses, and sheds light on the relationship between LLMs'
capability and safety. Our code is available at
\url{https://github.com/thu-coai/JailbreakDefense_GoalPriority}.
|
[
-0.1985723227,
-0.7526807785,
0.5659709573,
0.3070820272,
-0.2002640218,
0.3099429905,
-0.2649827898,
-0.3326975107,
0.018930221,
0.6532466412,
-0.141187638,
-0.4064953327,
-0.9737590551,
-0.2478456497,
-0.1675899178,
1.1935677528,
-0.1068288907,
-0.0758808553,
-0.0481734537,
0.2535479367,
-0.7899026275,
-0.7706851959,
-0.731490016,
-0.1484934241,
0.5113535523,
0.5236791968,
0.481466651,
0.562517941,
0.6497715712,
0.2829416394,
-0.2513797581,
-0.1191119924,
-0.545689702,
0.3472450674,
0.0510540195,
-0.5329375267,
-0.4625086486,
-0.0571166761,
0.23579292,
0.2647460699,
-0.1414757371,
-0.2218601108,
-0.0197539814,
0.7296591401,
-0.7733032107,
-0.2671377361,
-0.9294041395,
0.0099328915,
-0.2857095003,
0.1731654406,
-0.4182305932,
-0.3298498392,
-0.0773089081,
-0.1105762199,
-0.1049095392,
-0.0244709477,
0.8749041557,
0.3515303433,
-0.3118668497,
-0.1109930053,
-0.3352468908,
0.6730780602,
-0.6868443489,
0.1042073071,
0.6217404604,
0.1397164315,
-0.4178551435,
-0.403470397,
-0.1340049505,
-0.4509411156,
0.1803978235,
-0.157941401,
-0.2183307707,
0.3600114584,
0.5424561501,
0.0560899936,
-0.4032590687,
0.3288426101,
-0.6238187551,
-0.301492393,
0.6207447052,
-0.0153568545,
0.2742581964,
0.0924571529,
-0.5018495321,
-0.0143031441,
-1.0258313417,
0.2142043561,
0.6247550249,
0.261461556,
-0.0660117045,
0.6057420969,
-0.1633554399,
0.5709103942,
-0.0857319385,
-0.2018954754,
0.2193649262,
-0.1855335534,
-0.1450562179,
0.3312186003,
0.81595999,
0.5044906735,
0.5148106217,
-0.3227342665,
-0.1831053346,
-0.0157229193,
0.6250303984,
-0.9781453609,
-0.1205143258,
0.39312765,
-0.236273244,
-0.4103269577,
0.064340882,
-0.5071395636,
-0.5301449895,
0.220958218,
0.1787034422,
-0.474496901,
-0.1470482945,
0.0881368816,
-0.0112470286,
0.2163312733,
0.0349289216,
-1.1180764437,
0.2542029023,
0.9711206555,
1.0244204998,
-0.090656355,
-0.2381915152,
-0.5868933797,
0.3738053143,
-0.2368730307,
0.6192778349,
-0.1849023253,
-0.5817388892,
-0.3060514033,
-0.2732228935,
-0.3087417483,
-0.5182068944,
0.7306214571,
-0.4295041859,
-0.6079967618,
0.0012259695,
-0.6367716193,
-0.035368897,
0.3830148578,
-0.4775914848,
0.4468139708,
-0.3849285841,
-0.8108864427,
0.2222094089,
-0.4272889197,
-0.8202168941,
-0.2947355509,
0.1096062139,
-0.6527584195,
0.0871907845,
0.1775368452,
0.5191687942,
-0.1011260822,
0.5211293697,
-0.419202745,
-0.228162989,
0.1378174275,
-0.2282990962,
0.4885638654,
0.3871574402,
-0.3242077231,
0.2421590984,
-0.3338578045,
0.0508609451,
0.2536382377,
-0.5548874736,
-0.3561462462,
0.425840348,
-0.2448389828,
-0.0179177374,
0.4305467904,
-0.5386770964,
0.230024308,
-0.4748003781,
0.7000285387,
0.847655952,
0.0067334492,
0.3873186409,
-0.1567841619,
0.4455132484,
-0.2539316714,
0.4254733622,
0.0321149491,
-0.3135482371,
-0.5084988475,
-0.2576934099,
0.1508560181,
0.931651473,
-0.0854868144,
0.4328770041,
0.0391943343,
-0.6500008702,
-0.2056575119,
0.3395092189,
0.765209198,
0.4260320663,
0.403387934,
-0.444324702,
-0.6957335472,
-0.8449453115,
-0.3307843208,
-0.4166483581,
0.1213626266,
-0.0864523053,
0.3754658699,
-0.0732920468,
0.8198494911,
-0.5282512307,
-0.1916408241,
-0.616076827,
-0.457190305,
0.4055605829,
0.8961227536,
0.6477951407,
-0.9342998266,
-0.3736578524,
-0.3120369315,
-0.7743282318,
-0.2316463292,
-0.0129414238,
-0.1905255467,
-0.1647020429,
0.7673102021,
-0.7186038494,
0.4643783867,
0.2626380026,
-0.3425593674,
0.7127513885,
0.068746075,
-0.0081515526,
-0.8567624092,
-0.3105290532,
-0.0054414845,
-0.1114956886,
-0.9009700418,
0.1911202818,
-0.0324792415,
0.1650780141,
-0.530521512,
0.3269720972,
-0.1165033579,
0.1495593041,
-0.3026744425,
-0.0705062449,
-0.287296474,
0.1837351918,
0.0193633642,
0.7450999618,
0.5290774107,
-0.4432588518,
0.0588390343,
0.2355478853,
-0.3811141253,
0.2953321934,
-1.0372782946,
0.113234669,
0.2629175484,
-0.0593021549,
-0.8563133478,
-0.0166747887,
0.3471564054,
-0.455334723,
0.4323539734,
-0.5290852189,
-0.320427984,
-0.3418469727,
-0.4507107437,
0.0344739184,
0.3576475978,
-0.2106924504,
0.2177997679,
0.5992950201,
-0.1197227165,
-0.8453429341,
-0.5254811049,
0.1769454628,
-0.6795535684,
-0.6393607855,
0.2472406626,
-0.161299333,
-0.5246528387,
-0.3674944043,
-0.3630162477,
0.0499449112,
0.6829425097,
0.563940227,
0.3194585741,
0.0850559771,
-0.3117993176,
-0.0300322641,
-0.2145216763,
0.1819197685,
-0.3989436328,
0.6062167287,
-0.0635282099,
-0.3329518735,
-0.1788013577,
0.1441719234,
0.482730329,
-0.3449379504,
1.0090504885,
0.1564339995,
0.0470994078,
0.2050409168,
-0.720744133,
-0.1146023571,
-0.4972907603,
0.4885399938,
-0.4353001714,
-1.1043647528,
0.3903536499,
-0.0375516042,
0.2439676225,
-0.0616229959,
0.4981069863,
-0.1219562069,
0.8535771966,
0.6411905289,
-0.6653128266,
0.8930847645,
-0.0639742836,
0.3597868979,
-0.8989583254,
-0.0575647317,
-0.449059844,
-0.1250256151,
-0.5068801045,
-0.1639291495,
0.0774396062,
0.5769079924,
-0.4682893753,
0.6463152766,
-0.4355096817,
0.6682989597,
0.3529534042,
0.1752459705,
0.057735201,
-0.0560849942,
-0.1831841916,
0.1058292612,
-0.489108175,
-0.7093679905,
1.3420138359,
0.5150210261,
0.8428432345,
0.2335567474,
1.1025202274,
0.2053948343,
0.2334611863,
-0.6663379669,
0.6847394705,
-0.0168735329,
-0.6596798301,
-0.0881684497,
-0.3295899034,
-0.9877138734,
0.4283688664,
0.0601890348,
-1.3191863298,
-0.2871898413,
0.1760257781,
-0.353525579,
0.3996451795,
-0.9554941654,
1.1723042727,
-0.5232776403,
-0.4244245887,
-0.330516398,
-0.8886024952,
0.5087081194,
-0.0618050881,
0.3037250638,
-0.4761874974,
0.1065320298,
0.7692720294,
-0.7161125541,
0.9426518679,
-0.4088926017,
0.0738655031,
0.257653892,
0.0405478477,
0.5388941169,
0.1983809769,
-0.0389437415,
0.0815919414,
-0.2532918453,
-0.4626381695,
-0.1673247665,
0.5613448024,
-0.6675157547,
-1.1936970949,
-0.2586761415,
-0.4831646085,
-0.1020818502,
0.1210329831,
0.2486099005,
-0.0316762812,
-0.1286618263,
-0.0144502837,
0.7613379359,
-0.0870534703,
0.5254397392,
0.406791389,
0.0448936969,
-0.4611463845,
0.762072742,
-0.0708638802,
0.6519786119,
0.1965468526,
0.1092635691,
-0.1008063257,
-1.2749027014,
-0.2036875337,
0.0364524312,
-0.6120365858,
-0.3503397107,
-0.5925209522,
-0.2335690409,
-0.3994106948,
-0.441432178,
-0.374666661,
-0.2162364572,
-0.0093463613,
-0.3902308643,
0.4622392356,
0.4385341704,
-0.1743893027,
0.5359384418,
-0.7415670156,
0.1271813363,
0.0257999785,
-0.1019114777,
0.0444659404,
-0.5077618957,
-0.2653825879,
-0.3330017924,
-0.460087806,
-0.8696846366,
0.3367294669,
-0.0115312226,
0.7375953794,
0.4316144884,
0.1006914824,
0.6313527822,
-0.754290998,
0.3922980428,
0.3769191504,
-0.8489371538,
0.9615047574,
-0.3084071875,
0.0031118442,
0.9387404919,
0.1918498278,
-0.3420560062,
-0.7128207088,
-0.4228620231,
-1.2844799757,
0.5311600566,
0.130386129,
0.1821597517,
-0.1138064042,
0.2900218666,
-0.2812052369,
0.3374643326,
-0.8458029032,
-0.0666990653,
0.0496727079,
0.0029991462,
0.0357080065,
-0.3221692741,
-0.1180575043,
-0.2220896333,
0.6140397191,
0.1758040637,
-0.0631169677,
-0.0205637701,
-0.3606871963,
0.3861270845,
0.3058673739,
0.4622430205,
0.3852595091,
-0.1245426461,
0.0378584638,
0.2360844165,
-0.9025215507,
0.4614952803,
0.206518352,
-0.2761895955,
-0.6251097918,
0.4516849518,
0.8516904116,
0.1985975951,
-0.8370328546,
0.3345325589,
-0.0419770367,
0.1036453024,
-0.2135777473,
0.5446916819,
-0.0377072319,
0.4478377998,
0.3581876755,
0.1019509658,
-0.167554155,
-0.3365014791,
0.2895894647,
0.5227025151,
-0.2695711553,
-0.0501476564,
0.7217912674,
0.0115336264,
-0.2795189023,
0.456063658,
-0.1182089075,
-0.8480552435,
0.9700796008,
0.6450263858,
0.8113135099,
-0.3692984581,
-0.1253826171,
0.3561362922,
0.6818958521,
-0.2732540667,
0.0675095692,
-0.0388238728,
-0.8580703139,
-0.3422400057,
-0.6521475315,
-0.3058222532,
-0.0809245557,
-0.4767563641,
0.1228555813,
-0.7443204522,
-0.2544804513,
-0.2216275632,
-0.1190655157,
-0.0494511835,
0.0626158416,
0.1936597228,
0.8992697597,
-0.4762628376,
0.9725738764,
0.4515182972,
-0.358040601,
-0.8216160536,
0.09651535,
0.1772024632,
-0.5992805958,
0.7697173953,
0.5046146512,
-0.0182402749,
-0.0771949291,
-0.5589607954,
-0.8536286354,
0.8390126228,
0.5494549274,
-0.8944790959,
0.0731606185,
-0.1021267176,
0.2013581693,
-0.2246116698,
0.0291730948,
0.8493075371,
0.4934031963,
0.0087900162,
-0.8831936121,
0.023648791,
-0.0738148689,
-0.2081585824,
0.5518459082,
-0.4444666803,
0.6221199036,
-0.7764081359,
-0.0214604605,
0.2518514097,
0.4221460521,
0.5043893456,
0.2090859264,
0.5070983768,
0.7936229706,
0.4770151973,
-0.2420966178,
1.1839891672,
-0.1078013778,
0.0696910992,
1.1253764629,
-0.2761353254,
0.9485112429,
0.6581114531,
-0.2326571643,
0.1860871017,
0.7951135635,
-0.1218610406,
0.8327394128,
0.5101285577,
-0.3189175129,
-0.2757483125,
0.1121830642,
-0.2831498086,
0.4274231195,
0.466635406,
-0.2127833217,
-0.1046569869,
0.1392065436,
0.6430651546,
0.0321131982,
-0.4764451385,
0.7629466057,
0.2070845217,
-0.6727949977,
0.6052144766,
0.0098231202,
0.8015858531,
-0.8512367606,
0.4187110066,
-0.1060509905,
0.2652873695,
-0.2638991773,
-0.7734373212,
0.3110726774,
0.4377547503,
-0.1875896305,
-0.0952429995,
0.7508312464,
-0.1060803309,
-0.121780552,
0.6488212943,
0.1880191118,
0.1292949468,
-0.0731891543,
-0.7252090573,
0.2687935829,
0.1011493802,
-0.4301416874,
0.6987726092,
-0.1578553766,
-0.1943616569,
0.717107296,
0.6960764527,
0.1987258643,
0.0671433508,
0.0078952899,
0.9970651269,
-0.3949949741,
-0.5063974857,
-1.4470547438,
0.3912187517,
-0.2258260995,
-0.012059873,
0.8455216289,
0.5139771104,
0.82041049,
0.1862508953,
0.7381625772,
-0.3607286811,
0.0964835957,
-0.6668716669,
0.9432808757,
-0.2349077612,
0.531511724,
-0.4151327908,
-0.7507053018,
-0.3095997572,
0.7503095865,
-0.8920832872,
-0.1889978945,
0.3327000439,
0.7426562905,
0.3200256824,
-0.3470031023,
0.2214852273,
0.1018957347,
0.4219144285,
0.9357026219,
1.0186425447,
-0.1368654668,
0.6451966763,
-0.0745552406,
-0.1043097153,
-0.0006177417,
-0.7949262261,
-1.137696743,
-0.1261569858,
-0.1974655688,
-0.2683019638,
0.4511440098,
0.7797628641,
0.7874709964,
-0.9491088986,
-0.3614813685,
-0.2331048995,
0.4308365583,
0.002954585,
-0.117204532,
0.0214408766,
-0.5376480222,
-0.3621071875,
0.7136766911,
0.1798547655,
-0.0060104989,
0.1821439415,
-0.1893435121,
-0.3533498049,
-0.1392861307,
0.4191820621,
0.5317490101,
-0.630751133,
-0.2915369272,
-0.4269990623,
-0.1411847025,
0.1254851669,
0.8510580659,
-0.6179775596,
0.0517858751,
0.0908845142,
0.8063242435,
0.4352840483,
-0.0703603029,
0.5807467103,
-0.7723113298,
0.436611414,
0.0484957881,
0.5186468959,
0.2822424471,
-0.4092694223,
0.7011598349,
0.1097809747,
-0.5236569643,
-0.9666355252,
0.3816172481,
-0.6081768274,
-0.3358056843,
0.9802628756,
-0.4728688598,
-0.1522983164,
-0.130512923,
-0.3338398635,
0.2153750509,
-0.5752826333,
0.6577420831,
0.6023877859,
0.1415732652,
-0.1139880046,
-0.9526825547,
0.5264213085,
0.4260807633,
-0.888633728,
0.1415432096,
0.3163031042,
0.3875543475,
0.026849797,
0.4633357823,
0.0244620517,
0.2000847161,
-0.2619754076,
-0.1078368574,
-0.1323699653,
-0.3838913739,
-0.2570483983,
0.2717227638,
0.3371298015,
-0.2989037931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09090v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09090v3
|
Social Bias Probing: Fairness Benchmarking for Language Models
| 2023-11-15T16:35:59 | 2024-06-22T11:57:21 |
Marta Marchiori Manerba, Karolina Stańczak, Riccardo Guidotti, Isabelle Augenstein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While the impact of social biases in language models has been recognized,
prior methods for bias evaluation have been limited to binary association tests
on small datasets, limiting our understanding of bias complexities. This paper
proposes a novel framework for probing language models for social biases by
assessing disparate treatment, which involves treating individuals differently
according to their affiliation with a sensitive demographic group. We curate
SOFA, a large-scale benchmark designed to address the limitations of existing
fairness collections. SOFA expands the analysis beyond the binary comparison of
stereotypical versus anti-stereotypical identities to include a diverse range
of identities and stereotypes. Comparing our methodology with existing
benchmarks, we reveal that biases within language models are more nuanced than
acknowledged, indicating a broader scope of encoded biases than previously
recognized. Benchmarking LMs on SOFA, we expose how identities expressing
different religions lead to the most pronounced disparate treatments across all
models. Finally, our findings indicate that real-life adversities faced by
various groups such as women and people with disabilities are mirrored in the
behavior of these models.
|
[
-0.4041546881,
-0.8034037948,
0.3437783122,
0.420843035,
0.2848745584,
0.0906251594,
-0.1664476395,
-0.2229082137,
0.0630878508,
0.2595006227,
-0.5486185551,
-0.2806672156,
-0.8859596252,
-0.0846795663,
-0.3984722197,
0.7539268136,
0.3689067662,
0.7803090811,
-0.0773137137,
-0.5935565233,
-0.3446260989,
-0.5289461613,
-0.3850767612,
-0.1868486851,
0.3472034931,
0.0680502057,
0.8832988143,
0.3836497962,
0.3590400815,
0.2905530035,
-0.3185522854,
-0.333599031,
-0.6622021198,
-0.160798803,
-0.3512298763,
-0.5091630816,
-0.345069319,
0.2821729183,
0.4880068004,
1.0958479643,
0.0666655898,
0.7713604569,
-0.0500649586,
0.9002102613,
-0.8762669563,
-0.1691884398,
-0.6697480679,
0.0753201544,
-0.3914802074,
0.3629182577,
-0.3411222398,
-0.8461347818,
-0.2622386515,
-0.0070352396,
0.6798618436,
0.0727528781,
0.6659015417,
0.3202382326,
-0.83481282,
-0.1217837483,
-0.4407356381,
0.7862879038,
-0.7152996659,
0.5661218762,
0.3672330678,
0.5339193344,
-0.0842447877,
-0.3542663753,
-0.587451458,
-0.2020272911,
-0.2571767271,
-0.2251787037,
0.0882269219,
-0.2281234115,
0.6215842962,
0.4071090221,
-0.494764179,
-0.1081511378,
-0.344338119,
-0.0187721048,
0.8046634197,
0.235025391,
0.4110402763,
-0.3510283828,
-0.1193580478,
-0.0738246888,
-0.6186822653,
0.2064716369,
0.6636300087,
0.1072068438,
-0.0243345816,
0.3204567134,
-0.045399446,
0.4759071469,
0.0019572366,
0.3264922798,
0.3627294898,
-0.1153696105,
0.0052569392,
0.0000863367,
0.4109663963,
0.8287931681,
0.4539657533,
-0.0829372033,
-0.004208019,
0.4653929472,
0.1144652367,
-0.5576097369,
0.1528546959,
-0.0537528247,
-0.7206525803,
-0.3561385572,
-0.2576115131,
-1.257652998,
-0.8871119618,
-0.047098577,
0.0134615693,
0.2016075104,
-0.5645896196,
0.3572533727,
-0.2882671058,
0.3240568638,
0.0328597352,
-1.0225559473,
0.6735160351,
0.7802879214,
0.5989440084,
-0.119859539,
0.0423282012,
-0.7979078889,
-0.0730916634,
-0.2606924474,
0.5928484797,
-0.6885287166,
-0.2970858812,
0.2642578185,
0.0860641673,
0.3923099041,
-0.6003974676,
0.3584881425,
-0.2449518293,
-0.0304654501,
-0.9107646346,
-0.4408263862,
0.2218265831,
0.1444209367,
-0.9015666842,
1.1119279861,
0.4809180796,
-0.8540097475,
0.7246119976,
-0.5629941821,
-0.2480127215,
-0.0987678021,
-0.5092759132,
-0.4974669814,
0.3840097487,
0.0570527017,
0.1624055803,
-0.3469074368,
0.5979686975,
-0.9886645079,
-0.5413684249,
0.2275582552,
-0.4186930656,
1.2672501802,
0.0630163178,
-0.7767891884,
-0.2723834515,
-0.6727711558,
-0.3152688444,
0.2640500069,
0.0597351044,
-0.65860039,
0.1028984562,
0.3065664172,
0.1290959269,
-0.0424797162,
-0.6668543816,
-0.0134616205,
-0.2010988593,
0.1472019255,
1.1884608269,
-0.4053089321,
0.6208107471,
-0.463930279,
0.4064275622,
-0.261374712,
0.5336614251,
0.4871533513,
-0.2441278547,
-0.7167237997,
-0.1203763708,
0.5095838904,
0.2445035428,
-0.2582857311,
0.0628007725,
-0.1092569605,
-0.2328812629,
-0.8354525566,
-0.0381322354,
0.6328569055,
-0.0224748161,
0.2042318583,
-0.5480591059,
-0.1961728632,
-1.1861023903,
-0.8882772326,
-0.1578341424,
-0.0550081581,
0.559672296,
0.5661305189,
0.0211656801,
0.5928881168,
-0.378169924,
-0.1232786253,
0.1315094382,
0.1211138144,
0.0996950567,
0.3547827601,
0.7580233216,
-0.8927236199,
-0.5889660716,
-0.319083035,
-0.4878145754,
-0.5104435682,
0.2391163558,
-0.118410103,
-0.0795068517,
0.4966151416,
-0.1187528521,
0.6585153937,
0.6326419115,
-0.7412348986,
0.5898482203,
0.4673784375,
0.3905238509,
-0.7564085126,
-0.114162311,
0.1033681855,
-0.1688869745,
-0.2995312214,
0.0185548365,
0.1073745862,
0.3344029486,
-0.5322957635,
0.8194988966,
-0.6258821487,
-0.4380726814,
0.1062741801,
-0.0233853143,
0.0501799695,
0.2799887061,
-0.1273209006,
0.3837639093,
0.2477453798,
-0.2653607726,
0.1274238974,
0.1048006341,
-0.3974198103,
0.8446318507,
-0.684607625,
0.2185778022,
-0.3745424449,
0.282071799,
-1.1229099035,
0.0298606455,
0.0994033143,
-0.4770714939,
-0.0945487618,
-0.1681636125,
-0.4526740611,
-0.1748553663,
-0.3822384179,
0.8684616685,
0.4471899867,
-0.3173308074,
0.4938872457,
0.7791700363,
-0.2118915021,
-0.6733294725,
-0.5083678365,
-0.2241817415,
-0.5025871396,
-0.5224667192,
0.3348932266,
-0.2284298539,
-0.9570670724,
-0.0340307988,
-0.1384521425,
-0.0479712225,
0.1514005959,
0.1593162417,
0.0295541249,
-0.1472503543,
0.0677946061,
0.1444516182,
0.1102809384,
0.1443757862,
0.38794595,
0.5820550323,
-0.2178476155,
-0.5279501677,
0.2438873649,
0.7402203083,
0.2639498413,
-0.2751719058,
0.6109471917,
0.5739877224,
-0.5138899684,
-0.1062505245,
-1.1277673244,
-0.3722322583,
-0.4924366772,
0.3816509843,
-0.3020345569,
-1.0103378296,
0.7933261395,
0.0604548119,
0.1153210327,
0.0085886475,
0.5647351146,
0.2113981396,
1.0592957735,
0.7056291699,
-0.2746525407,
0.3739547431,
0.2633989453,
0.1924140155,
-0.6433203816,
0.0623099171,
-0.9348156452,
-0.4548112452,
-0.807235539,
-0.5788892508,
0.1589399725,
-0.1183857098,
-0.2860585451,
0.0080262423,
-0.4982001781,
0.7185992002,
0.4380955398,
0.1355716288,
0.3297736645,
-0.3376110792,
0.0764622986,
-0.2715125084,
-0.3059424162,
-0.6711380482,
1.1811460257,
0.4452753663,
0.583296597,
0.2701115012,
0.4271681309,
0.6800881028,
0.8554650545,
-0.1622070223,
0.4013881981,
-0.165399164,
-1.2883335352,
-0.4019872248,
-0.4464709759,
-0.7672917843,
0.4312552512,
0.0184712,
-0.8939772248,
0.6867644191,
0.1306244731,
-0.0672110543,
0.2095063776,
-0.6504324079,
0.9561095834,
-0.253747195,
-0.6562922597,
-0.0225482564,
-0.6312441826,
0.5039018393,
0.0154493758,
0.6373364329,
-0.4062598944,
0.272762835,
0.5628747344,
-0.1558451802,
0.7245653868,
-0.4633673728,
-0.0014441673,
-0.3585390449,
0.2515277267,
0.1670139879,
0.1924219728,
-0.4761503935,
0.2794495225,
0.1839737892,
-0.8177232146,
-0.646856606,
0.5805819631,
-0.5641793609,
-0.5772954822,
-0.4684778452,
-0.5045785904,
-0.5223629475,
-0.0027983475,
-0.1741227359,
0.1508253962,
-0.6327618361,
0.0259199888,
0.7787383795,
-0.5069488883,
0.0699752495,
0.9374527335,
-0.301132977,
0.0271592736,
0.3126950264,
0.0621728189,
0.2761214674,
0.02004149,
0.0878144503,
-0.2737269998,
-0.2394613773,
-0.3229752183,
0.2267465293,
-0.5391510129,
0.1004699543,
-0.5553767681,
0.1704171896,
-0.7789698839,
-0.147787869,
-0.4606834054,
-0.2109766006,
0.5116803646,
-0.248177588,
0.1413693726,
0.8028741479,
-0.1136794388,
0.2079006135,
-0.2455123812,
0.486291647,
0.3102456033,
0.5224633217,
0.0183226001,
-0.304720968,
0.091124624,
0.0087526403,
-0.0653527081,
-1.1251349449,
0.0503971949,
-0.2063541561,
0.7347738147,
0.0927011892,
0.2207740396,
0.5213850141,
-0.8035778403,
0.7271388173,
0.1488317698,
-1.0057102442,
0.2353062183,
-0.381968528,
0.0211500004,
0.8591825962,
0.407240212,
-0.6059166789,
-0.5764733553,
-0.5180165768,
-0.876811862,
0.5981924534,
0.0324696787,
0.2258112133,
-0.2145598978,
0.2483429164,
0.2135671973,
0.2563659251,
-1.1952211857,
-0.3193028271,
-0.1190512329,
-0.1680942625,
-0.0606879368,
-0.3038697541,
-0.2285317034,
-0.2618730366,
0.4165354669,
0.0329983011,
0.0519147851,
-0.0435873345,
-0.2011600882,
-0.0918352455,
0.2567912936,
0.225338757,
0.5057942271,
-0.2184442729,
-0.0378145911,
0.297492981,
-0.1426214874,
0.3478427827,
0.1327753067,
-0.0111672599,
0.2617589235,
0.0957864076,
0.4380488694,
0.0899399966,
-0.5071734786,
0.9210785031,
-0.4172433317,
-0.1220609173,
-0.3117996156,
-0.140821144,
0.2256232351,
0.2808785439,
0.0994859487,
-0.3648487926,
0.6435226798,
-0.6545009613,
0.2248407155,
0.6265992522,
-0.6849796176,
-0.0571711473,
0.6268440485,
0.2550163567,
-0.5441195369,
0.3621734381,
-0.1620331109,
-0.2968696952,
0.7228555679,
0.2196590155,
0.6999175549,
-0.3686570823,
0.3511644006,
0.2193975598,
0.5852932334,
0.1135931611,
0.0557815544,
-0.1012269706,
-0.7513368726,
-0.0596261807,
-0.8310914636,
-0.1930107176,
0.0714289695,
-0.9934214354,
0.1076247469,
-0.2165452987,
-0.2928590178,
0.146328643,
-0.1090931222,
-0.9572733045,
0.1441290379,
0.0744269043,
0.9231999516,
-1.3679543734,
0.398193419,
0.4448468685,
-0.4558364153,
-0.4608997405,
0.1297406256,
0.3213657439,
-0.8286170959,
0.5703803301,
0.1640154421,
-0.035194274,
-0.4710304737,
-0.279635191,
-0.3849250376,
0.5617362261,
0.6662112474,
-0.7190482616,
-0.0941947624,
0.5737671256,
0.5184892416,
-0.2331231683,
0.5890545249,
0.8852253556,
0.618455708,
-0.6174501181,
-1.0191529989,
0.2565618753,
-0.5533080101,
0.1924820989,
0.0244212057,
-0.8369944692,
0.7062227726,
0.2332994193,
0.1004425734,
-0.1440803558,
0.3484739959,
0.3241377473,
0.6530038714,
0.8469740152,
0.2240648121,
0.5880741477,
-0.2095099539,
0.9238473773,
-0.0339749753,
0.2403810471,
1.1078813076,
-0.662872076,
0.2819633782,
0.562823534,
-0.3741690218,
0.3976026177,
0.5675580502,
0.3356713653,
0.4940448105,
0.9588185549,
-0.2767694294,
-0.0638226196,
-0.3162567317,
-0.5626116991,
0.1851081103,
0.2094357312,
-0.3643243611,
-0.1900520176,
-0.0889609978,
0.0926917046,
0.6861507893,
-0.2504391372,
0.7968655229,
0.075769268,
-0.6146816611,
0.2079413384,
-0.0736702606,
0.6734857559,
-0.4739534557,
-0.163534075,
-0.5864601135,
0.2185267508,
-0.0967105627,
-0.3535361886,
0.173788175,
-0.0429220125,
-0.3880124092,
-0.1467199326,
0.4873292148,
-0.2780449688,
-0.6045753956,
0.7037009597,
0.4988755584,
0.1388398409,
0.1212821081,
-0.8012512326,
0.5073361993,
-0.0191056952,
-0.0919118747,
0.5014004111,
0.473429203,
-0.1730939746,
0.4527310729,
0.2889314592,
0.1294899434,
0.3183354437,
0.5938156247,
0.6528325081,
-0.6149286032,
-0.3607567251,
-0.9068903923,
0.7961954474,
-0.4999147952,
-0.2903226018,
0.7760184407,
0.5418759584,
0.8699606657,
0.1109593585,
0.7800247669,
0.0337748416,
0.4895021617,
-0.1954721212,
0.7762432098,
-0.6714671254,
0.2082429826,
-0.8341467977,
-0.8395606875,
-0.0210556425,
0.7643037438,
-0.4735220671,
0.343185544,
0.4695291817,
1.1707060337,
-0.0730167329,
0.205805108,
0.2290631384,
0.2683970332,
0.3236375749,
0.2609197199,
0.8496557474,
-0.3706144094,
-0.0129370773,
0.1554945856,
-0.6863501668,
-0.1273315698,
-0.8888425231,
-1.017635107,
-0.4699368775,
-0.0954462662,
-0.5376115441,
0.5994633436,
0.7220808268,
0.7251614332,
-0.7182018757,
-0.349634558,
0.2173041552,
0.2563773096,
-0.3020763397,
-0.3047106564,
0.1677913964,
-0.1411201954,
-0.8989091516,
-0.1962474436,
-0.0110069076,
-0.5974905491,
-0.7448940873,
-0.0853901803,
-0.0478165932,
0.375495553,
0.3817158341,
-0.1946214139,
-0.4724525213,
-0.3014800251,
-0.0950405523,
-0.0716711357,
-0.145356074,
0.917555511,
-0.3599444628,
0.3412229121,
0.2640797794,
0.6304089427,
0.4280968606,
-0.2062214762,
0.6792032719,
-0.5598452091,
0.083286345,
0.3708631694,
0.4602670372,
0.4073400497,
-0.4059352875,
0.5536386967,
0.0245218184,
-0.5648363233,
-1.338106513,
0.4717874229,
-0.658731997,
-0.3486724198,
1.155711174,
-0.0089787636,
-0.2386955917,
-0.336202234,
-0.1617338359,
0.1664978117,
-0.3094724119,
1.3506869078,
0.8958253264,
0.335429579,
0.0037747805,
-0.802423954,
0.6272298098,
0.6690939069,
-0.5119726062,
0.2596036792,
0.5833966732,
0.5137133002,
-0.1440972984,
1.150698185,
-0.5477539897,
0.442232132,
-0.0253603738,
0.008875329,
0.4315116704,
0.1006935984,
-0.1506145298,
0.0573723279,
-0.1324393749,
0.1747589558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09086v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09086v3
|
The Uli Dataset: An Exercise in Experience Led Annotation of oGBV
| 2023-11-15T16:30:44 | 2024-06-24T07:31:19 |
Arnav Arora, Maha Jinadoss, Cheshta Arora, Denny George, Brindaalakshmi, Haseena Dawood Khan, Kirti Rawat, Div, Ritash, Seema Mathur, Shivani Yadav, Shehla Rashid Shora, Rie Raut, Sumit Pawar, Apurva Paithane, Sonia, Vivek, Dharini Priscilla, Khairunnisha, Grace Banu, Ambika Tandon, Rishav Thakker, Rahul Dev Korra, Aatman Vaidya, Tarunima Prabhakar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI
|
Online gender based violence has grown concomitantly with adoption of the
internet and social media. Its effects are worse in the Global majority where
many users use social media in languages other than English. The scale and
volume of conversations on the internet has necessitated the need for automated
detection of hate speech, and more specifically gendered abuse. There is,
however, a lack of language specific and contextual data to build such
automated tools. In this paper we present a dataset on gendered abuse in three
languages- Hindi, Tamil and Indian English. The dataset comprises of tweets
annotated along three questions pertaining to the experience of gender abuse,
by experts who identify as women or a member of the LGBTQIA community in South
Asia. Through this dataset we demonstrate a participatory approach to creating
datasets that drive AI systems.
|
[
-0.0106569128,
-0.8245177865,
0.1772944629,
0.1994783133,
0.1365210563,
0.1089094281,
0.1644525379,
-0.4180639088,
-0.1867667884,
0.4243757129,
-0.4726988375,
-0.3541019559,
-0.4426441491,
0.1407066584,
-0.442156136,
0.6720539927,
-0.159984991,
0.3568546772,
0.177557081,
-0.3411702812,
-0.7431993484,
-0.490675509,
-0.7287886739,
-0.1544092894,
0.3410889208,
0.3683784008,
0.3428738415,
0.4323686063,
0.5805344582,
0.2215741575,
0.1621991098,
0.1183387861,
-0.525295496,
0.0566431396,
-0.2069116086,
-0.4647756815,
-0.1278042346,
0.1779239476,
0.4974875152,
0.5021941662,
-0.5044721365,
0.2569247484,
0.0180257447,
0.4456134439,
-0.6139298677,
0.058999896,
-0.4188074172,
0.1156084687,
-0.3925015032,
0.1626377851,
-0.0321299434,
-0.3718773127,
-0.3050040901,
-0.4280712605,
-0.139344126,
-0.0447857156,
0.5418800116,
0.3236712217,
-0.3182825148,
-0.4765552282,
-0.9705469012,
0.7414887547,
-0.3923737407,
0.4619476497,
0.5897250175,
0.2967137396,
-0.1410325617,
-0.2576582432,
-0.693680346,
0.133261621,
-0.220459342,
0.0459493287,
-0.3833417892,
-0.2794410288,
0.1872407943,
0.1800394803,
-0.4197486043,
0.3275154531,
-0.5432392955,
0.1142496318,
0.7834455371,
0.2787957191,
0.6553153396,
-0.3354884982,
-0.088921681,
0.1434697956,
-0.6907693148,
0.0745897368,
0.984077096,
0.5637204647,
-0.1952616274,
0.724141717,
0.0364364609,
0.4918913245,
-0.0254811496,
-0.1597153693,
0.2290420085,
-0.1294324398,
-0.2494383156,
0.1580043733,
0.855261445,
0.5360196233,
0.3914278746,
0.0747216642,
0.2457250059,
0.1038507968,
0.3128043115,
-0.6360865235,
0.0458158776,
0.1757855564,
-0.4037646055,
-0.3467215896,
-0.0251336042,
-1.0321593285,
-0.9320091009,
-0.2880368531,
-0.039585337,
-0.4169351459,
-0.6030801535,
-0.2972748578,
-0.2142657787,
0.6130496264,
0.2448223233,
-0.7694201469,
0.1023420841,
0.410479933,
0.5566318035,
-0.0460828282,
-0.0949085578,
-0.1827974617,
0.1582687944,
-0.397518605,
0.4737524688,
-0.9751518369,
-0.3126911819,
0.2082642317,
-0.197514981,
0.079292506,
-0.3961080015,
0.4309370518,
-0.1130696461,
0.0730528682,
-0.0081739379,
-0.2453234941,
-0.1082390919,
0.0903009027,
-0.4096799791,
1.1241115332,
0.1369263381,
-0.8891342282,
0.6398759484,
-1.1071215868,
-0.4829811454,
0.15262945,
-0.5611917973,
-0.2630912066,
-0.1295797527,
0.4314986169,
0.5935973525,
-0.314860791,
0.3963105083,
-0.1953792125,
-0.1721304655,
-0.1671175808,
-0.2085493654,
1.0286428928,
0.303434819,
-0.425935179,
0.0998279974,
-0.7478996515,
-0.3759071529,
0.3681648672,
-0.0046032742,
-0.6438494921,
0.1493093222,
0.1164433509,
0.0090024993,
-0.3259623647,
-0.9305112362,
0.2210141271,
-0.0681645796,
0.2016137242,
0.8798676133,
-0.1529201269,
0.1444867998,
0.1137272045,
0.4628503025,
-0.0160896704,
0.3232066035,
0.1197903678,
-0.3818942904,
-0.3427727222,
-0.2835389674,
0.1708721071,
0.7244662046,
-0.9097763896,
0.0005434955,
-0.1304956079,
-0.4514408112,
-0.7989708185,
0.21386154,
0.3052541018,
0.4287572801,
0.2331080884,
0.1474260986,
-0.9026101828,
-1.2087574005,
-0.1325408816,
-0.5516046882,
-0.1430291682,
0.4147583842,
0.471346885,
-0.2204221785,
1.0769218206,
-0.1607684195,
-0.575933516,
-0.460395366,
0.8458111286,
-0.2738481462,
0.3251637816,
0.5613465905,
-1.0647755861,
-0.2653454542,
-0.0336923786,
-1.2323640585,
-0.5301491618,
-0.053461574,
-0.1541791707,
0.1348261982,
0.610517621,
0.227137506,
0.7634803057,
0.5460358262,
-0.4087858498,
0.2688517272,
0.2746158838,
0.6457843184,
-1.2301796675,
0.1475982815,
0.0711664706,
-0.2052529901,
-0.6863353252,
0.0847876742,
-0.2729975581,
0.064355284,
-0.6645335555,
0.4687284231,
-0.2719746828,
0.1650768965,
-0.1679332107,
-0.1732483357,
-0.88023597,
0.1986175328,
0.0929258391,
0.7225933075,
0.2992601395,
-0.176480785,
0.3356131017,
0.36781618,
-0.0162733383,
0.9918757081,
-0.4337530136,
0.1108345836,
-0.3676059246,
-0.2414071709,
-0.578284204,
-0.4818581641,
0.3999998569,
-0.412987709,
-0.0429609939,
-0.2139892578,
-0.6139631271,
-0.2929520607,
-0.2081075013,
0.4789518714,
0.2648791075,
-0.4069764912,
0.8594423532,
0.8803524375,
0.0548698083,
-0.6533882022,
-0.6061949134,
0.2159595042,
-0.3686647415,
-0.1673773676,
-0.5579417944,
-0.0629262105,
-0.702503562,
-0.1212294549,
0.481590867,
-0.1267870814,
0.3301624954,
0.8904113173,
-0.0295285657,
0.2850130796,
-0.0213680658,
-0.02306371,
0.3825413287,
0.0146088451,
0.3778148592,
0.7000973821,
-0.1574543715,
-0.3882335126,
-0.344405055,
0.844358623,
0.0657623038,
0.0288487561,
0.6376154423,
0.7960458994,
-0.648395896,
0.1548749655,
-0.3605412245,
0.3282195628,
-0.3687206805,
0.1434357464,
-0.4115873277,
-0.9906172156,
0.5312191844,
0.0389126055,
0.1433983445,
0.4712246954,
0.5986285806,
-0.2645196021,
1.0024052858,
1.0173066854,
-0.4366394579,
0.2898875475,
-0.0618604608,
0.2277860492,
-0.6500586271,
-0.2859749198,
-0.4653376937,
-0.1423726678,
-0.7324196696,
-0.0611104667,
0.185217768,
0.1248937845,
-0.2475702912,
0.2616390586,
-0.3726537824,
0.277830869,
0.3269679248,
-0.0235195085,
0.1298857927,
0.0476928167,
0.2159725875,
-0.2589149773,
-0.4545345306,
-0.5382615924,
1.1274881363,
0.1915544122,
0.6670801044,
0.3026192486,
0.3281530142,
0.9542706609,
0.6614047289,
-0.29517138,
0.4257666767,
0.0649459511,
-0.8204470873,
-0.4737370014,
-0.3368545771,
-1.1999887228,
-0.2114346176,
-0.0501815602,
-1.0220899582,
0.3099229932,
-0.0412043333,
-0.2435757667,
0.5624156594,
-0.3463985324,
0.4270397723,
0.0253357366,
-0.203840822,
-0.0063873287,
-0.4922192097,
0.4044726193,
-0.1485759914,
0.6317990422,
-0.0024453816,
0.2297409326,
0.9623519778,
-0.4406784177,
0.9437559247,
-0.2613858283,
0.0018039468,
0.3048970401,
-0.0830101818,
0.067689687,
-0.0676720217,
-0.1215823665,
0.4767017365,
-0.5935012102,
-0.4047762156,
-0.0924802572,
0.3995047808,
-0.8252830505,
-0.2038898915,
-0.4992049634,
-0.4448113441,
-0.1245548278,
0.0755818784,
-0.0641718805,
0.3473158479,
-0.2160820514,
0.0866823718,
0.4213816524,
-0.2288576066,
0.5629829764,
0.357213825,
-0.5940288305,
-0.1945602149,
0.6565925479,
0.0754922181,
-0.2246254236,
-0.0308407824,
0.0767528564,
0.0673597753,
-0.3291703165,
-0.7879740596,
-0.0305823889,
-0.5700752139,
-0.1096696183,
-0.653559804,
-0.1201971769,
-0.5719969869,
-0.1592958868,
-0.2221068144,
0.1349621266,
-0.046424292,
-0.327927649,
0.5078984499,
1.134016633,
-0.3930757344,
0.5080782771,
-0.3413838148,
0.4424283803,
0.528999269,
0.2891750038,
-0.4873146415,
-0.3820197284,
0.0104628894,
0.0895303935,
0.1510147303,
-1.1455156803,
0.3706829846,
0.0244008247,
0.5096632242,
0.1883096993,
-0.0344288498,
0.7742943764,
-0.4246599674,
0.9343929887,
-0.0112863993,
-0.6601777673,
0.861830771,
-0.6340286136,
-0.1730253398,
0.5102853179,
0.9063194394,
-0.6309329867,
-0.3901331723,
-0.5936243534,
-0.9599086642,
0.7221226096,
0.4796188474,
0.171746105,
0.0471975952,
0.3916200995,
0.2701526284,
0.4449644089,
-0.6191219687,
-0.6375627518,
-0.0709772259,
-0.345492512,
0.1934791654,
-0.3314878643,
-0.0800061375,
-0.4419382215,
0.6988816261,
-0.0411489457,
0.3336939514,
0.1006755531,
-0.3407403529,
-0.2584830225,
0.0321553089,
0.1407193244,
0.7596529722,
-0.3156911135,
-0.2443077415,
0.0176816452,
-0.5780864358,
0.1877481341,
0.1945463568,
-0.2813383937,
-0.2206967026,
0.3060802519,
0.8937616944,
-0.2189943641,
-0.6984875798,
0.5141815543,
-0.3270663023,
0.0132667338,
-0.6294291019,
-0.2088921517,
-0.278434515,
0.2563613355,
0.6099300981,
-0.4916220903,
0.3288167715,
-0.8001483083,
0.23454988,
0.1175253168,
-0.5465214849,
-0.0577069819,
0.709884882,
0.1261624247,
-0.3806705773,
0.5999531746,
-0.3545920551,
-0.5632391572,
0.2286950797,
0.1747055501,
0.7062646151,
-0.4997613132,
0.4343972504,
0.4344256222,
0.6214100122,
0.3403479159,
0.6580132246,
0.2478476465,
-0.6932464838,
-0.1893861145,
-0.7485268712,
-0.2959825695,
0.4937030077,
-0.7745196819,
0.2470535934,
-0.5189648271,
0.1975187659,
0.1330183595,
-0.2530139387,
-0.8545290232,
0.2997798622,
0.4308541715,
0.3445130289,
-1.3795393705,
0.487403363,
0.7360469103,
-0.5259609818,
-0.8388325572,
-0.2059179544,
0.1611202657,
-0.9158119559,
0.7047650218,
0.1105744094,
0.249143526,
-0.1507772356,
-0.8231403828,
-0.5749248266,
0.7449415922,
0.009782034,
-0.3600586355,
0.4589390755,
0.6652387977,
0.7345055938,
-0.4751644135,
0.6511682868,
0.7657960057,
0.5815908909,
-0.413382262,
-0.9729055166,
-0.1028592959,
-0.5109464526,
-0.0813657939,
0.2504523396,
-0.5740898848,
0.6893405914,
0.1889085919,
-0.1263542771,
-0.2943394184,
0.7173757553,
-0.070186846,
0.1481273323,
0.7390632629,
0.4678146243,
0.5246271491,
-0.200840652,
1.0675604343,
0.4662027359,
-0.0584049039,
1.2547069788,
-0.3334223032,
0.7143715024,
0.2372707725,
-0.2097618282,
0.3852054775,
0.5019000173,
-0.0104150027,
0.1634564996,
0.2828805447,
0.0884440914,
-0.2254803181,
-0.7052289844,
-0.129306078,
0.8205752373,
0.3840434551,
-0.1870858967,
-0.2271652669,
0.6412881613,
0.2460800707,
0.1846511662,
-0.5493163466,
0.9538666606,
-0.3980558217,
0.0505991876,
0.1147047281,
-0.0746437907,
0.6451659799,
-0.3472187221,
-0.3679299653,
-0.1269867569,
-0.1656832248,
-0.1520015001,
-0.9506385326,
0.3480098248,
0.5104836822,
-0.1709570587,
-0.1564320624,
0.6870203614,
-0.3886608183,
-0.7833259702,
0.378110975,
0.5247061253,
0.594825685,
-0.148908928,
-0.5523395538,
0.1657714695,
0.0970198065,
-0.1898775697,
0.2819634974,
0.1096167266,
-0.6505182981,
0.6534916162,
0.5445894599,
0.1152501479,
0.1590067148,
0.2143338323,
0.6928377151,
-0.5008779764,
-0.182510078,
-0.6693646312,
0.511537075,
-0.5427008867,
-0.3990997076,
0.7014188766,
0.4635558426,
0.9870324731,
0.5161066055,
1.1064012051,
-0.6371130347,
0.833358705,
-0.1553354859,
0.6000676751,
-0.6152377725,
-0.0040152711,
-0.4329458773,
-0.5415615439,
-0.2726797462,
0.4768812656,
-0.1685578078,
-0.020940097,
0.1427997798,
0.5627186894,
0.1038209572,
0.2376598716,
0.3262571096,
0.3550721407,
0.4501724541,
-0.1509779692,
0.778814435,
-0.6241431832,
0.338549763,
-0.2662702203,
-0.249719888,
0.0319765732,
-0.9850866795,
-0.9948188066,
-0.6146584749,
-0.2453805804,
-0.0201292932,
0.3929902017,
1.0250816345,
0.4228697419,
-0.7969129682,
-0.3264432549,
0.1888030022,
-0.1093228161,
0.0699191615,
-0.2436483502,
0.3913789392,
0.2477124929,
-0.7959335446,
0.2825804651,
0.0176486615,
-0.2587758899,
-0.294665277,
0.1564894617,
-0.8603719473,
0.0084706554,
0.6287666559,
0.2533045411,
-0.4834752977,
-0.4618183076,
-0.3901138604,
0.1101252735,
0.1113743559,
0.7316877842,
-0.5696163177,
0.4615241587,
0.1871372908,
0.5022224188,
-0.0219550598,
0.1194876805,
0.6251562834,
-0.8616122603,
0.1302777827,
0.0250030253,
0.3245985508,
0.5895574093,
-0.4479898214,
0.8860403299,
0.2789613903,
-0.4106813073,
-1.0550564528,
-0.0867771655,
-0.4802650809,
-0.3153544664,
1.3639289141,
-0.1502981484,
-0.3017304838,
-0.5594338775,
-0.457190007,
0.4840252995,
-0.6027686,
0.6290431023,
0.6480820179,
-0.0797012225,
-0.0958826467,
-0.7766887546,
0.5108702183,
0.0756475478,
-0.9856619835,
0.3099247813,
0.563010633,
0.0197124779,
0.0922840983,
0.5759805441,
0.0495446026,
0.0576160811,
-0.1725419164,
0.5581996441,
-0.1127094477,
-0.4551746845,
-0.382571131,
0.1348122954,
-0.510284543,
0.0012295506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09071v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09071v2
|
How Vocabulary Sharing Facilitates Multilingualism in LLaMA?
| 2023-11-15T16:13:14 | 2024-06-03T06:11:06 |
Fei Yuan, Shuai Yuan, Zhiyong Wu, Lei Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs), often show strong performance on English tasks,
while exhibiting limitations on other languages. What is an LLM's multilingual
capability when it is trained only on certain languages? The underlying
mechanism remains unclear. This study endeavors to examine the multilingual
capability of LLMs from the vocabulary sharing perspective by conducting an
exhaustive analysis across 101 languages. Through the investigation of the
performance gap before and after embedding fine-tuning, we discovered four
distinct quadrants. By delving into each quadrant we provide actionable and
efficient guidelines for tuning these languages. Extensive experiments reveal
that existing LLMs possess multilingual capabilities that surpass our
expectations, and we can significantly improve the multilingual performance of
LLMs based on these attributes of each
quadrant~\footnote{\url{https://github.com/CONE-MT/Vocabulary-Sharing-Facilitates-Multilingualism}.}.
|
[
-0.6664832234,
-0.4677883387,
0.3604049981,
0.5553485155,
-0.2741895914,
0.4979392588,
-0.3756102324,
-0.8733276129,
0.5331930518,
0.3478601873,
-0.3864249587,
-0.2588546872,
-0.849265635,
0.3148979247,
-0.0513050221,
0.8331111073,
-0.1646631211,
0.2420734465,
-0.1454827636,
-0.5927297473,
-0.6528651118,
-0.6977065802,
-0.5281248093,
-0.4217203557,
0.9894385934,
0.467284143,
0.7371593118,
0.7488227487,
0.4936820567,
0.3891361952,
-0.2418246269,
0.4820040464,
-0.4860919416,
0.1003426164,
-0.1108113825,
-0.5401139855,
-0.5516197085,
-0.1392454058,
0.8956343532,
0.833530128,
-0.180759117,
0.1270958185,
0.3601602316,
0.5230174065,
-0.4558171034,
-0.0900248662,
-0.7981875539,
0.1285580397,
-0.5534474254,
-0.245165512,
0.0268210862,
-0.027676072,
-0.0888923928,
-0.7854189873,
-0.0661377311,
0.0720292106,
0.6270821095,
0.2397619486,
-0.6279584765,
-0.2985436618,
-0.2991708815,
0.8601379395,
-0.3088645339,
0.4700475037,
0.5779880881,
-0.0595960245,
0.1117118597,
-0.3540540636,
-0.5866128206,
-0.1213949099,
0.0405627787,
-0.214929387,
-0.0569490492,
0.0315021127,
0.0276988707,
0.3745687306,
-0.433226943,
0.5355626941,
-0.3969101608,
-0.2215205282,
0.46345523,
-0.0101176761,
0.3514583111,
0.0583689883,
-0.3253010213,
-0.0973082334,
-0.8454535604,
0.0298153516,
0.4363462329,
0.3408489823,
-0.21410124,
0.762011826,
0.15103966,
0.4158426225,
-0.5688058138,
-0.2259667665,
0.4216709435,
-0.407845974,
0.0415511876,
-0.1004493237,
0.5545009375,
0.1661208272,
0.5146971941,
-0.1618993282,
-0.2433074117,
-0.0758922771,
0.1552655846,
-0.4296457767,
0.2284337878,
-0.0775320604,
-0.2096107453,
0.0109316679,
-0.2505665421,
-0.3703550398,
-0.4681107104,
-0.2202396691,
0.3812114298,
-0.2481648624,
-0.4599789977,
0.227339834,
-0.0822124481,
-0.0664465949,
-0.0085672121,
-0.8420477509,
0.2962600291,
0.8702721,
0.9364776015,
-0.2329936475,
-1.0779309273,
-0.3422407806,
0.190829888,
-0.4505301714,
0.7078679204,
-0.6992866397,
-0.3757482171,
0.1960033029,
-0.032169763,
-0.1481263489,
-0.5728965402,
0.2314420044,
-0.7240580916,
-0.3391501307,
-0.6485435963,
-0.5085300207,
-0.2893553376,
0.3396173418,
-0.7770988941,
0.8904915452,
-0.3282238245,
-0.5534933805,
0.4679442346,
-0.4648895264,
-0.353790164,
0.1656650752,
-0.0337368511,
-0.0263741966,
0.1580361873,
-0.0256405156,
0.4198819101,
-0.0664486289,
0.0496038683,
-0.2589410543,
-0.4445143044,
0.4220624268,
-0.3965377808,
0.4105092585,
0.0596267544,
-0.0126755172,
0.0689729601,
-0.406806618,
-0.0823225826,
0.0009533195,
-0.6079264879,
-0.397433877,
-0.1701814234,
-0.1500766277,
0.1953728348,
0.4654202163,
-0.4186894596,
0.2692284286,
-0.2465629876,
0.1416457742,
0.7612407804,
-0.2637257278,
0.4524230957,
-0.4653410017,
0.7570315003,
0.0278891325,
-0.1099042967,
-0.1269454807,
-0.632787466,
-1.0333371162,
-0.2515676618,
0.3524718285,
0.4960273504,
-0.5901963711,
-0.0919338763,
-0.1538442075,
-0.3490843475,
-0.7752904296,
0.8191204071,
0.4478419423,
-0.2167592347,
0.3687484264,
-0.3833047152,
-0.3928839862,
-0.9943967462,
-0.1011085138,
0.0614151694,
0.2349590361,
0.2928151786,
0.3955288827,
-0.1536170989,
0.1937632561,
-0.0743127391,
-0.4059971571,
-0.4597028494,
-0.1651472449,
0.0928669646,
0.1810946167,
0.5889356136,
-0.592451334,
-0.5350774527,
0.3537937105,
-0.7218153477,
-0.0644420609,
0.1009927168,
-0.1713293046,
0.3359367847,
0.6104589105,
-0.3352750838,
0.1580704749,
1.062030077,
-0.1268678755,
0.4137206376,
-0.5052415729,
-0.1888736337,
-0.9332535267,
-0.2514567375,
-0.110169515,
-0.0106629115,
-0.5556027889,
0.2474379539,
0.0563442521,
0.244740203,
-0.3659178317,
0.4745467305,
-0.6296352148,
-0.329110831,
-0.3900496066,
0.3572549522,
-0.1537946016,
0.3954682648,
-0.0399299972,
0.8071132302,
0.7943770289,
-0.7548266053,
0.0803886205,
0.1074491441,
-0.2776195705,
0.5466820598,
-0.614217639,
-0.0302839689,
-0.0344599672,
-0.0259020086,
-0.8726421595,
-0.0327015817,
0.0167758297,
-0.2072178274,
0.3047243953,
-0.0420328975,
-0.4367251694,
0.0266910214,
-0.3434470892,
0.583562851,
-0.2012620717,
-0.5431103706,
0.4983037412,
0.6617174745,
-0.3673105836,
-0.8462854624,
-0.6280614138,
0.3839086592,
-0.34329772,
-0.6237191558,
0.2280273139,
-0.1749375612,
-0.383004427,
-0.2253159881,
0.2850721478,
-0.0625512898,
0.301404506,
0.1858637631,
0.1232319549,
-0.2034761459,
0.5893685818,
0.1400509477,
-0.0216383543,
-0.2478811443,
-0.0853402242,
0.8079198599,
-0.2953550816,
-0.4531377852,
-0.3864904046,
0.5747392774,
0.399910748,
-0.4996912479,
0.9844056368,
0.4372156262,
-0.1558355987,
-0.1116794497,
-0.6741359234,
0.0463844389,
-0.5100611448,
0.4461370111,
-0.5135552287,
-1.1332581043,
0.6982277036,
-0.0374953076,
0.0904228687,
0.2562134564,
0.4902515411,
0.0766387284,
0.6402290463,
0.9426594973,
-0.3211891949,
0.3903386891,
-0.1386502534,
-0.0329511762,
-0.8573224545,
-0.3655400574,
-0.4368703663,
-0.511767447,
-1.0001059771,
-0.6653750539,
0.3854672611,
0.1713932604,
-0.1675692946,
0.1350168884,
-0.0224354956,
0.6696459651,
0.4011673033,
-0.4305635393,
0.4902881682,
0.2260374278,
-0.4722040296,
-0.1086658463,
-0.7173057199,
-0.5140942931,
0.8815590739,
0.3925127387,
0.5780205131,
0.4760996997,
0.587690115,
0.0086356634,
0.1443084925,
-0.7757367492,
0.4888571799,
-0.1462265402,
-0.3816289604,
-0.2463304847,
-0.2148047239,
-1.1621115208,
0.712138772,
-0.3236439526,
-0.6397918463,
-0.1067722663,
-0.2341419905,
0.0977822691,
0.3236935735,
-0.4347249866,
0.5069272518,
-0.3452375531,
-0.2512301803,
-0.6058374643,
-0.3151785135,
0.1647014022,
-0.4287025332,
0.3293440342,
-0.1073343754,
-0.4456053972,
0.6233378649,
0.0047923354,
0.9011067152,
0.1442147046,
-0.3856781125,
-0.1105668396,
0.0667924806,
0.1058702618,
0.1849829257,
-0.092074573,
0.7546858191,
-0.1535194665,
-0.5017028451,
-0.0711626783,
0.934432447,
-0.9749327302,
-0.6345946193,
-0.4219712019,
-0.7111423612,
-0.3545379043,
0.1513582617,
-0.0688947737,
0.143197149,
-0.0283103976,
0.1053949594,
0.4066032767,
-0.2858563364,
0.6446043253,
0.5802085996,
-0.4219699204,
-0.1811335385,
0.901812017,
0.3321306109,
0.1521697342,
0.2584570646,
0.1024251804,
-0.2942942977,
-0.5202915072,
-0.4011508524,
0.7362167239,
-0.7398464084,
-0.0983910933,
-0.5697906613,
-0.043927338,
-0.0793367997,
-0.1119512469,
-0.3823488355,
-0.4214547873,
-0.173214823,
-0.1741561741,
0.2813008726,
1.1845700741,
-0.1597606391,
0.5520616174,
-0.7863318324,
0.0761287957,
0.2884633243,
0.4335296452,
0.2972601354,
-0.403427273,
-0.4026845396,
0.1120903194,
-0.3211897612,
-0.5234948993,
0.2159360498,
0.4790570438,
0.7446375489,
0.3389857411,
-0.474442184,
0.8576578498,
-0.4865535796,
0.6707604527,
-0.0031235565,
-0.9541602731,
0.0096937092,
-0.1715898067,
0.1373430043,
0.2016328722,
0.5283650756,
-0.9497342706,
-0.5447704792,
-0.1982728541,
-0.9301695228,
0.5328923464,
-0.1024410278,
0.4492140412,
-0.0099497112,
0.2298239768,
0.1257994026,
0.3220757544,
-0.7167599201,
-0.2979233563,
-0.0243477542,
0.3479787707,
-0.3756619692,
-0.2713322341,
-0.2988985181,
-0.147440508,
0.3727454245,
-0.2291478068,
-0.0570582785,
-0.1943500638,
-0.2966715395,
-0.0712368414,
0.2101853639,
0.7454464436,
0.8936063647,
0.3977975845,
0.2829761505,
0.5467433929,
-0.4777472019,
-0.0745734349,
-0.1756173819,
0.3968240619,
-0.1430562288,
0.6112052798,
0.7580062747,
0.0855996013,
-0.542099297,
0.2715404034,
-0.2224974632,
-0.0443488173,
-0.2921797633,
-0.0013168462,
0.4846828282,
0.4446995854,
0.3646923006,
-0.1385934651,
-0.3393966556,
-0.4039953947,
-0.0903700665,
0.6523752213,
0.0675984398,
-0.3231016099,
0.2716692984,
0.0547559038,
-0.268384546,
0.4000838399,
-0.1170528382,
-0.5357726812,
0.4683920145,
0.5347498655,
0.3316899836,
-0.38870579,
0.2113631815,
0.0478689037,
0.4223448932,
0.1506910622,
0.3577176034,
-0.0363523737,
-1.0765205622,
-0.6928014159,
-0.7614008188,
-0.43705073,
-0.0189574342,
-0.6282043457,
0.0171980467,
-0.2203880697,
-0.0180808399,
-0.0095770275,
0.2039462179,
-0.7056783438,
-0.1633858085,
0.2536908686,
0.8628046513,
-0.6613084078,
0.905498445,
0.7236007452,
-0.0499981232,
-0.8173695207,
-0.0787812471,
0.0160826594,
-1.2123094797,
0.7846142054,
0.2056923807,
-0.3592067659,
-0.1667075306,
-0.0048720231,
-0.7535776496,
0.8922852874,
0.3398300707,
-0.5302856565,
0.263995856,
0.5745049715,
0.6523057818,
-0.497998178,
-0.0620398261,
0.4988062382,
0.4436147213,
-0.1191507578,
-1.2463790178,
-0.1792683899,
-0.1898228526,
0.0690735132,
0.1267075837,
-0.6456046104,
0.8417800665,
-0.268227458,
0.0335063301,
0.1536213607,
0.4678271413,
0.3458857238,
0.1407435089,
0.4608545005,
0.5075592995,
1.2244645357,
0.1121368483,
1.1090406179,
-0.6256340146,
0.0584755689,
0.7910383344,
-0.2606976032,
1.163410306,
0.6962868571,
-0.0197034087,
0.3300592303,
0.5442309976,
0.2344825566,
0.2613643408,
0.1474139392,
-0.5078642368,
-0.2681399882,
-0.5502789617,
-0.5122183561,
0.903155148,
0.4657473862,
-0.1114177555,
0.0767935067,
0.1720492393,
0.2307531983,
-0.1093441471,
-0.491029948,
0.6607763171,
0.1594692767,
-0.6253749728,
0.6842397451,
-0.0164035447,
1.0269004107,
-0.7544474006,
0.135267511,
-0.3859750926,
0.1056388766,
-0.1833827347,
-0.9283404946,
0.2512391508,
-0.0184674524,
0.1221419126,
-0.2821610868,
0.385103941,
-0.5881829262,
-0.4100465775,
0.7050817013,
0.8866243362,
0.2929806113,
0.0630500913,
-0.3738886714,
0.3110719621,
-0.2921773791,
0.0146016628,
0.5737424493,
0.5433707237,
-0.1822594851,
0.845600307,
0.6617850661,
0.5256360173,
0.1493953019,
0.2323940992,
0.9022330642,
-0.4630671144,
-0.2979267538,
-0.8660321236,
0.0910468847,
0.150612548,
-0.6245194674,
0.9501498938,
0.4187773466,
1.1676011086,
0.1313369721,
0.466678232,
0.3638525903,
0.2044976205,
-0.4484418929,
0.8080892563,
-0.9164751172,
0.3797082603,
-0.0538502708,
-0.897277236,
-0.2821061313,
0.5416993499,
0.0226681214,
0.0277004652,
0.6556148529,
0.8942744136,
0.0563292429,
-0.0627842695,
0.586389482,
0.060098853,
0.1106091738,
0.2722878754,
1.0341029167,
0.0878729746,
0.555631876,
-0.2275387347,
-0.0505476072,
0.0265065022,
-0.7836501002,
-0.7351760268,
-0.5072154999,
0.1190975308,
0.0122680273,
-0.1407994181,
0.7122543454,
0.517865479,
-0.3467338681,
-0.6392891407,
0.2600461245,
0.3146741986,
-0.1326821595,
-0.045816604,
0.0960195437,
-0.299887687,
-0.8381071091,
0.5013267398,
0.2071426958,
-0.0499184728,
-0.5058810115,
-0.2460805476,
-0.2606781721,
-0.0001928453,
0.6665756702,
0.0924524367,
-0.6496392488,
-0.1031037942,
0.0818649381,
-0.0151219591,
0.0660973266,
0.8623104692,
-0.3764260113,
0.3222882152,
0.1296879202,
0.5713429451,
0.1848785579,
-0.4440749288,
0.3461864293,
-1.0557191372,
0.2995437682,
-0.0928417221,
0.6445214748,
0.5848021507,
-0.1382574439,
0.2741776705,
0.0197758488,
-0.6302626133,
-0.6322222352,
0.1216592714,
-0.8567849398,
-0.1571852416,
1.3329231739,
-0.1130934209,
0.142990455,
-0.2353796512,
-0.1617629826,
0.2467904836,
-0.2221084982,
0.6594558954,
1.0185718536,
-0.0562318414,
-0.0930168107,
-0.7198165059,
0.2790437639,
0.3507195413,
-0.5382761359,
-0.1195762977,
0.1745079011,
0.405256927,
0.3188077807,
0.528932631,
0.2218176723,
0.1318671852,
-0.2679733932,
-0.1986884028,
-0.0436135419,
-0.4917533398,
-0.5424236059,
0.0780545622,
0.5300300121,
-0.1187174842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09069v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09069v2
|
How Well Do Large Language Models Truly Ground?
| 2023-11-15T16:11:27 | 2024-06-29T18:07:34 |
Hyunji Lee, Sejune Joo, Chaeeun Kim, Joel Jang, Doyoung Kim, Kyoung-Woon On, Minjoon Seo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
To reduce issues like hallucinations and lack of control in Large Language
Models (LLMs), a common method is to generate responses by grounding on
external contexts given as input, known as knowledge-augmented models. However,
previous research often narrowly defines "grounding" as just having the correct
answer, which does not ensure the reliability of the entire response. To
overcome this, we propose a stricter definition of grounding: a model is truly
grounded if it (1) fully utilizes the necessary knowledge from the provided
context, and (2) stays within the limits of that knowledge. We introduce a new
dataset and a grounding metric to evaluate model capability under the
definition. We perform experiments across 25 LLMs of different sizes and
training methods and provide insights into factors that influence grounding
performance. Our findings contribute to a better understanding of how to
improve grounding capabilities and suggest an area of improvement toward more
reliable and controllable LLM applications.
|
[
-0.3239376247,
-0.8782675266,
0.8043535352,
0.3432978094,
-0.2107724696,
-0.0137540549,
-0.5178384781,
-0.3114722371,
-0.1897243261,
0.4867703617,
-0.1097336709,
-0.2980751097,
-0.7988004088,
-0.120371066,
-0.641238451,
0.8467842937,
0.0032181181,
0.1522941887,
-0.6144514084,
-0.1861153245,
-0.847835362,
-0.7831261754,
-0.4246118665,
-0.5938594937,
0.1825095266,
0.3240184486,
0.6947954893,
0.8484442234,
0.5138199925,
0.1784718037,
-0.348667562,
0.0185407624,
-0.6978122592,
0.109291859,
-0.2217325717,
-0.5708671212,
-0.1656765789,
0.170929119,
0.7087174058,
1.0126649141,
-0.0092609497,
-0.1073870957,
0.0106656728,
0.6025298238,
-0.5711066127,
0.0209189486,
-0.6569064856,
0.1266940385,
0.2812551856,
-0.2080427408,
-0.4470399916,
-0.2308019847,
0.0545927063,
-0.2832885087,
0.0259130131,
0.0282188412,
0.9587106705,
0.2643977702,
-0.4514104724,
-0.1592049599,
-0.8928903937,
0.5053620934,
-0.741904676,
0.5024119616,
0.5659026504,
0.2299783826,
-0.1133892313,
-0.3855530918,
-0.3437573314,
-0.6059353352,
0.0047286591,
-0.0163999088,
0.2056036294,
0.2348909676,
0.6698831916,
0.4314718246,
0.012985209,
0.0986161828,
-0.1688578874,
0.0189913474,
0.2305900455,
-0.0471002497,
0.3442435563,
0.1299342811,
-0.0903919935,
0.0168609936,
-0.8110297322,
0.0970331505,
0.1052082181,
0.2750943303,
-0.1389248073,
0.9758291841,
-0.2589049041,
0.7082546353,
0.2826717496,
-0.205661267,
-0.1119717136,
0.0904982015,
-0.4677345753,
-0.0006406784,
0.3401317,
0.6177762151,
0.3700852692,
-0.6904950142,
-0.3968341053,
0.0403038412,
0.4001174569,
-0.6228176355,
0.0137774674,
0.1901238859,
-0.2372582257,
-0.3621319234,
0.1186870113,
-0.1996567845,
-0.6772277951,
-0.7244935632,
0.3796361387,
-0.413739711,
-0.4390460551,
0.047554031,
-0.1106240824,
0.3122854829,
0.2038764358,
-0.6648700833,
0.4259434044,
0.7222809792,
0.9034081697,
-0.160476312,
-0.239413783,
-0.4980129302,
0.2044832557,
-0.8407714367,
0.5019074678,
-0.3772861362,
-0.1998885721,
0.0099933976,
0.0784221366,
0.1165874451,
-0.5980105996,
0.5584389567,
-0.7785531282,
0.0365926586,
-0.5998649597,
-0.6327191591,
-0.2126675546,
0.5874193311,
-0.4023683071,
0.7967247367,
-0.1268769205,
-0.7709506154,
0.5770493746,
-0.0694138333,
-0.4345108271,
-0.1992917508,
-0.2770855725,
-0.0847284049,
0.5191405416,
-0.0222551711,
0.5990173817,
-0.3829746544,
0.8210656047,
-0.2654764354,
-0.4340758622,
0.1319825351,
-0.1470913589,
0.4738799036,
-0.1319986731,
-0.6158893108,
0.0809809268,
-0.9774239659,
0.1081325561,
0.2044575363,
-0.2900972068,
-0.3204888403,
0.1748470515,
-0.1475832909,
0.3775357902,
0.0122535052,
-0.230379954,
-0.0357772075,
-0.5932428241,
0.3622436523,
0.5812408924,
-0.1655271649,
0.5486437082,
-0.4038741291,
0.1871819049,
0.0059752683,
-0.4636305273,
-0.2153525054,
-0.0746493265,
-1.087243557,
-0.0345053226,
0.2138397396,
0.5278949142,
-0.1289081126,
0.8251847625,
-0.4685018063,
-0.5746642947,
-0.0067868917,
0.0909048319,
0.3296412528,
0.6550965905,
0.350979954,
0.1850237995,
-0.6957119703,
-0.9154242277,
-0.1022271961,
-0.050702095,
-0.0877268836,
0.344448477,
0.4357752502,
-0.3262444437,
1.128908515,
-0.1127600819,
-0.1043710113,
-0.3023109138,
-0.0643611848,
0.2276105583,
0.4437831938,
0.3749037683,
-0.7297201157,
-0.1531748176,
0.0896142721,
-1.2641071081,
-0.1622768193,
-0.0485053845,
0.07180655,
0.0480420478,
0.7427933216,
-0.9164937735,
0.1773811132,
0.5944087505,
-0.1332283914,
0.5519432425,
-0.2586400509,
0.1285471469,
-0.6662403345,
0.177398935,
-0.173023805,
-0.2680324912,
-0.6130466461,
0.3890202343,
0.1136620343,
-0.1163926646,
-0.1467240155,
0.3862135708,
-0.5107877254,
-0.0545128807,
-0.528349638,
0.1165848449,
0.1033087373,
0.0755395666,
0.1941645294,
0.8420315385,
0.7277380824,
-0.8687121272,
0.3848981261,
-0.0395903923,
-0.4118777812,
0.373219043,
-0.9385699034,
0.2276298702,
-0.282492727,
0.2709216177,
-1.1172927618,
-0.4806494713,
-0.2733042538,
-0.2079179734,
0.0335654467,
-0.3340759873,
-0.5882988572,
-0.317173034,
0.1032103747,
0.305360049,
0.6165793538,
-0.5697644353,
0.8001960516,
0.4164935648,
0.2488604635,
-0.2797555625,
-0.6457595229,
0.3017285466,
-0.4668660462,
-0.7175942659,
0.2200032473,
0.1047955379,
-0.6497741938,
-0.2541350424,
-0.2624230981,
0.0438848026,
0.3376470804,
0.5257294178,
-0.2945864797,
-0.3230032623,
0.3157176971,
-0.1926445514,
-0.0600834712,
0.4478555024,
-0.2741864026,
0.7929852605,
0.0264142826,
-0.4393551946,
-0.2676364481,
0.076670073,
0.8431108594,
-0.1264628023,
1.0061460733,
0.0001156464,
-0.7297751904,
-0.0774625167,
-0.9024938345,
-0.1557803005,
-0.4181739986,
0.0484579802,
-0.6103961468,
-0.7492442131,
0.7339907289,
-0.0708713979,
-0.090700902,
0.3418655396,
0.4365411401,
-0.0438521393,
1.1885783672,
0.9191511869,
-0.1250263304,
0.0065972679,
-0.076615721,
0.2064529061,
-0.6592984796,
-0.3471522629,
-0.4859271646,
0.0374733172,
-0.3010993004,
-0.3633320928,
0.0156625919,
0.563374579,
-0.3883427382,
-0.0158677306,
-0.2150991559,
0.5210886598,
0.2281602025,
-0.0003291479,
0.1281463057,
0.0726625025,
-0.2394843847,
-0.0928249061,
-0.6109187603,
-0.7073945403,
0.910422802,
0.5383080244,
0.782730639,
-0.1610298306,
0.1543854475,
0.1008720919,
0.2779156268,
-0.6925396323,
0.426263392,
0.207856521,
-0.4858368933,
-0.2953192592,
-0.4168304503,
-0.3355691433,
0.306025207,
-0.2729545832,
-0.5173833966,
-0.2124157846,
0.095353514,
-0.2684256434,
0.4006250799,
-0.5380859971,
0.52010566,
-0.3977158368,
-0.3557529747,
-0.0199913625,
-0.553984046,
0.3798351884,
-0.0986816585,
0.3582346439,
-0.1107479408,
0.2738184035,
0.7867495418,
-0.1924743801,
0.7733669281,
-0.2595261335,
-0.5533618331,
0.2429021746,
0.0793298483,
0.5418912768,
0.1065746248,
-0.1067693606,
0.0599876344,
-0.2848927379,
-0.4013837576,
-0.6103956103,
0.8350274563,
-0.8670286536,
-0.7776929736,
-0.2013670057,
-0.4512734711,
-0.6101886034,
0.4337799847,
0.2702402771,
0.3195495307,
-0.2932546735,
0.4993010759,
1.0825840235,
-0.1768622845,
0.082960315,
0.3370440304,
-0.4760074615,
-0.3151723742,
0.5521062613,
0.3190915287,
0.2431225777,
0.2817735672,
0.2522189319,
-0.2398841232,
-0.6524325609,
-0.2732527554,
0.2096491903,
-0.8560641408,
-0.0210920293,
-0.9706761837,
-0.3536499441,
-0.5470870137,
-0.309409678,
-0.3933595121,
-0.1674357355,
-0.1500310451,
-0.5874275565,
0.0645168275,
0.7170783877,
0.1778208464,
0.4955114126,
-0.6392511129,
0.3688880801,
0.3468168974,
0.4982540309,
-0.0579256006,
-0.8698989749,
-0.2009347081,
0.2806027532,
0.1375753582,
-0.6432609558,
-0.0078534335,
0.0515532196,
0.5202503204,
0.4202897847,
-0.0304704998,
0.900570631,
-0.8322020173,
0.8204139471,
0.0781090707,
-1.0570909977,
0.6353214979,
-0.5835574865,
0.2089645714,
0.4667637944,
0.1841202527,
-0.5616970062,
-0.5697402358,
-0.5247516632,
-0.8321893215,
0.3681911528,
0.0318728872,
0.570048213,
-0.060468886,
0.5598767996,
-0.1581887603,
0.2856629491,
-0.8915435672,
0.0136553533,
-0.1483914405,
0.1932898313,
-0.3683952987,
-0.6628932953,
-0.5659087896,
-0.1917894334,
0.4631961286,
-0.1168057248,
0.074463293,
-0.1010910049,
-0.4102698267,
-0.3986171782,
-0.0195079036,
0.6936792135,
1.1397899389,
-0.2051326483,
0.5436772108,
0.3287642002,
-0.059409447,
0.3811122179,
-0.296090126,
-0.193438381,
-0.1808361113,
0.5600680709,
0.8142006397,
0.1222996414,
-0.7464451194,
0.4918772578,
0.1876747012,
-0.1294744313,
-0.4685280919,
0.2292508185,
-0.0156934056,
0.0009736562,
0.4425263107,
-0.0948508456,
-0.2298371047,
-0.3317094147,
0.2712896168,
0.3962382674,
-0.4147926867,
-0.1639576554,
0.6421844959,
0.0142512228,
-0.118840903,
0.4930973649,
0.1766802967,
-0.5191932321,
0.8485317826,
0.8242511749,
0.5079199672,
0.1502152383,
-0.1682466716,
0.3277288377,
0.6433721781,
-0.5393961072,
-0.1424508691,
0.297457844,
-0.9068606496,
-0.6010417938,
-0.4001464844,
-0.2633035779,
0.446359694,
-0.6398428082,
0.3806084991,
-0.8437090516,
-0.1183532402,
-0.541502893,
-0.1203973368,
-0.4385407269,
0.8519215584,
0.2444667667,
1.2127147913,
-1.1094110012,
0.48780182,
0.8820930123,
-0.2224547714,
-0.7812197804,
0.1377319098,
-0.301954776,
-0.5110576749,
0.8365685344,
0.6272172332,
-0.2174474597,
0.1087117195,
-0.7735199928,
-0.99351722,
0.9096210599,
0.3365305066,
-0.3175705075,
0.0035898441,
0.0645171255,
0.5552949309,
-0.3826586902,
0.1731236875,
0.5058392882,
0.4187826812,
-0.156377241,
-0.7614597678,
0.0953063443,
-0.0946282521,
0.029922517,
-0.2428929061,
-0.5947819948,
0.584209621,
0.0384311639,
-0.1904123873,
0.0172004458,
0.8489786983,
0.3971475661,
0.1580921113,
0.5083133578,
0.9938360453,
0.8810036182,
-0.3250212967,
0.9551917911,
-0.4984353483,
0.1569281071,
0.9283359647,
-0.4866265357,
0.4353980124,
0.3239895701,
0.115977928,
0.2011309862,
0.3598106503,
0.1551841795,
0.5196911097,
0.3589548171,
-0.0257661473,
-0.5984431505,
-0.160461396,
-0.5385888815,
0.366186589,
0.1604714245,
-0.3351990879,
-0.1137897596,
0.3152910173,
0.0044945925,
0.3082628548,
-0.3296739459,
0.7469605803,
0.043747142,
-0.6584616899,
0.8113783002,
0.2942061126,
0.381510973,
-0.4277058542,
0.0271800235,
-0.3584935963,
-0.1011220142,
-0.1389559805,
-0.4835120738,
0.1781264693,
0.1195227206,
-0.6157183647,
-0.325268209,
0.786511302,
-0.1366598308,
-0.271314472,
0.4941729903,
0.4939184487,
0.0106903212,
-0.0491214395,
-0.1801598221,
0.267726481,
-0.3868767619,
-0.2798348069,
0.3003900647,
0.770162344,
-0.012746525,
0.972158432,
0.6466318965,
0.2029806376,
0.2080142349,
0.0433199853,
1.0059224367,
-0.6501604319,
-0.4679130614,
-0.9532937407,
0.5674515963,
-0.1970793158,
-0.1048804298,
0.9126278758,
0.4418766201,
0.5903706551,
0.029039029,
0.8476501703,
-0.1106445342,
0.3811114132,
-0.7652977109,
0.5782343149,
-0.3303380907,
0.3009120524,
-0.0604799427,
-1.1133836508,
-0.4346774817,
0.7932347655,
-0.5140366554,
0.1433112323,
0.4832270145,
0.3501638174,
-0.1741479337,
-0.3380319774,
0.7219215035,
0.4301251769,
0.4012232423,
0.09617915,
1.0870728493,
-0.1571933478,
0.0168302041,
-0.2530838847,
-0.1941981316,
-0.0553701483,
-1.0095386505,
-1.3149204254,
-0.1595196426,
-0.0263118949,
-0.6299976707,
0.1570655853,
0.9005545378,
0.9205203652,
-0.9059100151,
-0.2041561157,
-0.5884011388,
0.0429258384,
0.0242609307,
-0.1616967171,
0.1578392982,
-0.6955959201,
-0.2150036097,
0.5268414021,
0.012030418,
0.0391185097,
-0.2608908415,
-0.0145858051,
-0.0027433066,
0.1599768996,
0.6355981827,
0.0518088862,
-0.6128550172,
-0.5359589458,
0.0783160254,
-0.3120861053,
0.044219926,
0.7836115956,
-0.7015078664,
0.1103360429,
0.1918493062,
0.9548378587,
-0.0847322866,
0.295137316,
0.7407768369,
-0.7967833281,
0.3288635314,
0.1684195101,
0.2677910328,
0.4942429066,
-0.3523221612,
0.4635922611,
0.4264661372,
-0.539506793,
-0.9871063828,
0.1036417261,
-0.5898730755,
-0.121880807,
1.52224648,
-0.1179833487,
0.0614811964,
0.0770381689,
-0.2781546116,
0.2166930735,
0.1217920408,
0.8551007509,
1.1598305702,
0.4202354252,
-0.2565249503,
-0.6068831682,
0.3068188131,
0.5600121617,
-0.67557621,
0.3106479347,
0.7389750481,
0.460670948,
0.2884103656,
0.5854153633,
0.2346830368,
-0.0101581328,
-0.2395874411,
-0.0236592311,
0.0486397706,
-0.7626076341,
-0.4626397192,
0.4319478869,
0.4214158654,
0.396578908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09066v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09066v3
|
Identifying Self-Disclosures of Use, Misuse and Addiction in Community-based Social Media Posts
| 2023-11-15T16:05:55 | 2024-06-13T21:15:26 |
Chenghao Yang, Tuhin Chakrabarty, Karli R Hochstatter, Melissa N Slavin, Nabila El-Bassel, Smaranda Muresan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the last decade, the United States has lost more than 500,000 people from
an overdose involving prescription and illicit opioids making it a national
public health emergency (USDHHS, 2017). Medical practitioners require robust
and timely tools that can effectively identify at-risk patients.
Community-based social media platforms such as Reddit allow self-disclosure for
users to discuss otherwise sensitive drug-related behaviors. We present a
moderate size corpus of 2500 opioid-related posts from various subreddits
labeled with six different phases of opioid use: Medical Use, Misuse,
Addiction, Recovery, Relapse, Not Using. For every post, we annotate span-level
extractive explanations and crucially study their role both in annotation
quality and model development. We evaluate several state-of-the-art models in a
supervised, few-shot, or zero-shot setting. Experimental results and error
analysis show that identifying the phases of opioid use disorder is highly
contextual and challenging. However, we find that using explanations during
modeling leads to a significant boost in classification accuracy demonstrating
their beneficial role in a high-stakes domain such as studying the opioid use
disorder continuum.
|
[
-0.1746991277,
-0.538682282,
0.8399315476,
0.24458085,
-0.0721010044,
-0.1452937573,
0.2705946863,
-0.7020887733,
0.6227295995,
0.5124070048,
-0.3716637194,
-0.6712643504,
-0.7971189022,
0.3190374672,
-0.6725519896,
0.8234249949,
-0.204910934,
-0.0419251844,
-0.0715868175,
-0.0938581526,
-0.7023778558,
-0.4391391575,
-0.4703721106,
-0.0793780014,
1.0410648584,
0.422537446,
0.0986856595,
0.4422026873,
0.7827376127,
0.2630160451,
0.298920542,
-0.3635610938,
-0.4227581918,
-0.0689473599,
-0.3050532937,
-0.1062473431,
-0.4348087907,
0.0369011126,
0.003402771,
0.795230031,
-0.3171199262,
0.356338352,
-0.0157684535,
0.3576484919,
-0.8380782008,
-0.387193799,
-0.3756358027,
-0.1037230417,
-0.0238867439,
-0.3804686666,
-0.0846984833,
-0.3700652122,
-0.004599411,
-0.8950240016,
0.2193189859,
-0.1095379367,
0.46663028,
0.2418893576,
-0.2664657235,
-0.5649627447,
-0.8322306275,
0.3184069693,
-0.3956028521,
-0.0258820299,
0.5751425028,
0.3746143878,
0.2086822987,
-0.565607667,
-0.2601691186,
0.5066204667,
-0.5948726535,
-0.2976313829,
-0.0412129052,
0.1225550622,
0.1472076625,
0.2995166779,
-0.5261579156,
0.0676282495,
-0.8265081644,
-0.2452439517,
0.7683631778,
0.3126587868,
0.4173904061,
-0.2713637352,
-0.5454062223,
0.575170815,
-0.6031859517,
-0.2309544683,
0.1526648551,
0.1950970441,
-0.3238279521,
0.688598156,
0.1844782978,
0.5465297699,
0.0200593658,
-0.0226479918,
0.2984934449,
-0.4627285302,
-0.0535990559,
-0.0250588059,
0.9173844457,
0.7878159285,
0.0670372471,
0.1216734126,
-0.0460838526,
-0.2695125639,
0.5359331369,
-0.6598080397,
-0.2637189031,
0.5022260547,
-0.9630130529,
-0.3541577458,
0.0182090774,
-0.8004305363,
-0.9216086268,
-0.0354737192,
0.8047163486,
-0.2184545845,
-0.4897528589,
0.1812185645,
-0.2010206729,
-0.407628864,
0.3173790574,
-0.8944776654,
0.3729480207,
0.5497885346,
1.1189712286,
-0.2083664536,
-0.164564535,
-0.016803436,
0.0402473994,
-0.3868384659,
0.8053064346,
-0.2690023482,
-0.3542482555,
0.4242416024,
0.2738212347,
0.0426482297,
-0.6801149845,
0.345508188,
-0.2939609587,
-0.2458676249,
-0.4950396419,
-0.5035486221,
-0.1551448852,
-0.079449527,
-0.5425906777,
0.5588817596,
0.0798162371,
-0.8241539001,
0.5190237761,
-0.8294353485,
-0.2702035904,
0.1021555215,
0.1067518592,
0.0197815746,
0.3816395402,
0.0637215599,
0.4166416824,
0.3613021076,
-0.0068185427,
-0.2291678041,
-0.4015868604,
0.1155373454,
0.0092278775,
0.5930672288,
0.5419458151,
0.4507986605,
0.0802829936,
-0.4899724126,
-0.4608491361,
-0.0558430739,
-0.199922055,
-0.7489860654,
-0.0780798495,
-0.0547264814,
0.1709505469,
0.1780056804,
-0.6979849339,
-0.181521669,
-0.1308520287,
0.6120980382,
0.4122222662,
0.5535145998,
0.0721705109,
-0.4399825037,
0.5873837471,
0.1120686904,
0.4015189111,
-0.499268949,
-0.1091343686,
-0.0519809313,
-0.2254514843,
0.4249951243,
0.309612602,
-0.4215448797,
0.3562594354,
-0.0601216778,
-0.4211169481,
-0.4724260569,
0.0354173295,
0.0184162781,
0.7050303221,
0.5738847852,
-0.1936921626,
-0.4756290317,
-0.9415289164,
-0.3301481307,
0.2203542739,
-0.0099030025,
0.2699023485,
0.6557323933,
0.0578922518,
0.7051045299,
-0.338429004,
-0.6324934363,
-0.281781435,
0.6554152369,
0.0749896169,
0.2201614976,
0.4221740365,
-0.3838122487,
-0.5539588332,
-0.3173924685,
-0.7499306202,
-0.3826526105,
-0.3440846801,
0.0774115101,
-0.3267733455,
0.5030274987,
0.216743499,
0.5259760618,
0.4865823984,
-0.2405995578,
0.1035086364,
-0.2560785711,
0.250998497,
-0.7278220057,
0.244618088,
0.1117488444,
0.0395331755,
-0.525411129,
-0.4511350989,
-0.1919886619,
-0.1913104653,
-0.2283698767,
0.141536355,
-0.5471951962,
-0.0283094663,
-0.3283411264,
0.0497635864,
-0.0584571101,
-0.1151274666,
-0.0223243423,
0.3663705289,
0.5736848712,
-0.1834748685,
0.0040603722,
-0.0318130031,
-0.2262781858,
0.5748253465,
-0.725420177,
-0.3045399785,
-0.3352572918,
-0.0441204868,
-1.0700776577,
-0.5138478279,
0.5178725719,
-0.475672245,
0.0122091519,
-0.5144708753,
-0.2021648288,
-0.530919075,
-0.2380678207,
0.5270959735,
0.0268750936,
0.0307409093,
0.2622439563,
0.4693651795,
-0.2221369445,
-0.6308846474,
-0.6162275672,
-0.0334592275,
-0.315590173,
-0.247753486,
0.3247000873,
0.0330320634,
-0.3278666139,
0.207186833,
0.0623354539,
-0.1882986128,
0.1032021716,
0.4862549007,
0.0952260345,
0.1829795092,
0.5674362183,
-0.0389183909,
-0.1164615825,
0.3353607655,
0.5038202405,
0.5097683668,
0.2971141338,
-0.2800484896,
-0.6540715098,
0.9830572605,
0.3717572391,
-0.0713371187,
0.7610965967,
0.1680002511,
-0.5273462534,
0.0575654395,
-0.5365433097,
-0.4075876772,
-0.3948755264,
-0.1356238723,
0.1181239784,
-0.5599020123,
0.5953193307,
0.1352192163,
0.0402772501,
0.2007676214,
0.2075209171,
-0.2888761461,
0.5736524463,
0.37830019,
0.1254001558,
0.3054070771,
-0.0903038159,
0.2923056185,
-0.3831279278,
-0.0149339633,
-0.0924027711,
-0.3565214276,
-0.3836745918,
-0.3870612979,
0.6463776827,
0.1753943712,
0.0112990243,
0.1069432944,
-0.6500793695,
0.491756767,
0.3652690947,
0.2643337548,
0.3880083561,
-0.1440159827,
0.5867967606,
-0.1525032669,
-0.4134052098,
-0.3980757594,
1.2448936701,
0.5404730439,
0.7380049825,
-0.1702418774,
1.0107221603,
0.6284246445,
0.6758437157,
-0.6863383055,
0.1422829032,
-0.0328558758,
-1.0515533686,
-0.1273306906,
-0.1740252674,
-0.8666658401,
0.1303512454,
-0.5129137039,
-0.5822758675,
0.3950091004,
0.4273427725,
-1.1353257895,
0.0525763072,
-0.8955051303,
0.846232295,
-0.159927845,
-0.0773757994,
-0.3138712347,
-0.7495502234,
0.3092985153,
-0.1888765991,
0.8104815483,
-0.213358894,
-0.0578812845,
0.7048398256,
-0.695584178,
1.0384225845,
-0.3095597029,
0.1886480004,
0.6789703965,
-0.0324909128,
-0.0572007149,
-0.1279370785,
0.3483943641,
0.3738988638,
0.2322215885,
-0.1225376576,
-0.4427734613,
0.5329890251,
-0.5470095873,
-0.1661708057,
-0.3015547097,
-0.0701488256,
0.1440046877,
0.1311329603,
0.3752234876,
0.5907114744,
-0.0260376427,
-0.0377909467,
0.4416930974,
-0.2639398575,
0.3573492765,
0.4165492952,
-0.3678590953,
-0.4108136594,
0.6319310069,
0.6972815394,
0.1337813437,
0.0339460447,
0.3909425735,
-0.0420168079,
-0.7514871955,
0.033462137,
0.6496354938,
-0.5267643929,
-0.1762176901,
-0.5328727961,
-0.0084071858,
-0.643112421,
-0.1446321905,
-0.3280511498,
-0.2042137533,
-0.1906926483,
-0.3251319826,
0.3991259038,
1.1888914108,
-0.7548610568,
0.4083732367,
-0.7615454197,
0.3842902482,
0.3417376578,
0.4464309514,
0.0632660314,
-0.1087306589,
-0.2462927699,
-0.2776305079,
-0.0861752331,
-1.4170745611,
0.2230768949,
-0.113165617,
0.5299750566,
0.5998257399,
0.425172627,
0.514216423,
-0.1137407497,
0.7202479243,
0.1833643764,
-0.5999859571,
0.6183203459,
-0.7224317193,
-0.2943591774,
0.890494287,
1.072252512,
-0.9280318618,
0.164345488,
-0.3622233272,
-0.9699514508,
0.5477765203,
-0.0573397391,
0.0821121708,
-0.2953335941,
0.4138136208,
0.3023192883,
0.127344653,
-0.8325244784,
-0.4273026586,
-0.388530612,
-0.1978073716,
0.307020992,
-0.6992909312,
-0.3972660601,
-0.1317113191,
0.2474479079,
0.213478595,
0.3194593191,
0.4588364363,
-0.0297072474,
-0.1971725821,
0.1806264073,
0.5014381409,
0.9134685993,
-0.2184960991,
0.4405481815,
-0.2118614763,
-0.487935245,
-0.1579403281,
-0.1388516277,
-0.0740822703,
-0.1237289906,
0.5934044123,
0.1175528988,
0.0864859223,
-0.5806411505,
0.6797088981,
0.2384628356,
-0.3948229849,
-0.5252824426,
-0.0712390319,
0.0349053331,
-0.0764158666,
0.4170100987,
-0.1755398959,
0.3736111224,
-0.7414292097,
0.1081963331,
0.1085557863,
-0.5380114913,
-0.4453094006,
0.5281638503,
0.4694544673,
-0.2759885192,
0.0565379634,
0.0780211762,
-0.0850488469,
0.2187402397,
0.1018609852,
0.5423855186,
-0.0970467106,
0.237618953,
0.9394575953,
0.0676401481,
0.0485603698,
0.2877178788,
0.0175994523,
-0.5652300715,
-0.0793417394,
-0.3273651898,
0.3355365098,
0.2549609542,
-0.7530975938,
0.1196004674,
-0.5623472333,
-0.3268388212,
0.2659261823,
-0.4959673584,
-0.0280318968,
-0.0427238047,
0.1438800246,
0.7413704991,
-1.1953798532,
0.0752856731,
0.4587982893,
-0.5462441444,
-0.5092897415,
-0.1091395393,
0.2361839414,
-0.5711454153,
0.2514276206,
0.223124668,
0.0016948145,
-0.2841417789,
-0.7551660538,
-0.7683773041,
1.020247817,
-0.394616425,
-0.4426482916,
0.0341902487,
0.1271272749,
0.7076269984,
-0.6495957971,
0.1080046892,
0.1972378343,
0.3608617783,
0.264468044,
-0.8013765812,
-0.0182234813,
0.0121143172,
-0.0769061893,
0.2455401868,
-0.231322661,
0.8288472891,
-0.5180627704,
-0.4546191096,
-0.067108281,
0.2388073355,
-0.140565604,
0.490665555,
0.6823936701,
0.312758714,
0.3805516958,
0.1601782739,
0.6119861603,
-0.0140702557,
0.3110577166,
1.0940796137,
-0.0650796071,
0.9440484047,
0.3747327626,
0.1278888434,
0.4527305365,
0.6166144013,
0.032101348,
0.556183815,
0.1435727477,
-0.0573866628,
-0.5303096771,
-0.2267200202,
-0.2933953106,
0.2144607902,
0.6715635061,
-0.9709647894,
-0.439113766,
0.0727123395,
0.2498793602,
0.1985326707,
-0.4441335797,
0.9008023739,
-0.0609371327,
-0.6296419501,
0.3276007473,
-0.3929665387,
0.4554625154,
-0.259411037,
-0.1932465881,
-0.0383222103,
-0.0678910464,
-0.474335283,
-0.8309650421,
0.7669332623,
-0.1834738404,
-0.1335983723,
-0.3499055207,
0.8243355751,
-0.3861553371,
-0.458465606,
0.2855499089,
0.48600927,
0.376005888,
-0.1951538622,
-0.5103614926,
0.0272729266,
-0.3164305389,
0.1070028394,
0.0431462675,
0.3593857586,
0.0535849184,
0.395263344,
0.2687733173,
0.3452821672,
-0.08041168,
-0.0555736981,
0.3885486126,
-0.547385931,
-0.0481413081,
-0.4638794363,
0.5566284657,
-0.3233935535,
-0.5954990387,
0.5044828057,
0.2230975628,
0.519079864,
0.0567383207,
0.5681152344,
-0.3573163152,
1.3004328012,
-0.1711615473,
0.882974565,
-0.7112346292,
0.231745556,
0.0360536799,
-0.0618923381,
-0.2846638262,
0.6396855712,
-0.4804022014,
0.0614480041,
0.5650051832,
0.6405493021,
0.2806624174,
-0.0944811851,
0.1388078928,
0.4288543463,
-0.0975088105,
0.1460222155,
0.7025037408,
-0.318031311,
0.4667605758,
-0.4385953248,
-0.1831126064,
-0.5485379696,
-0.6502231359,
-0.8916849494,
-0.6470919251,
-0.4219605625,
-0.1837479621,
-0.0813551992,
0.9039435387,
0.6686658859,
-0.4719263911,
-0.0207356047,
0.1363751292,
0.39011392,
-0.1354161501,
-0.2878759503,
-0.1738269627,
-0.0265954025,
-0.1651921421,
0.0832159519,
0.1712688357,
-0.0266838111,
-0.3642978072,
0.4821136296,
-0.2711105347,
-0.1614170372,
0.4068026841,
0.2951408923,
-0.4569558203,
-0.2676190436,
0.0452701449,
-0.1512833089,
0.053602431,
1.1150895357,
-0.3468937576,
0.4738439023,
0.664383769,
-0.2188891619,
0.1452204883,
0.4717556536,
0.46758762,
-0.3419286311,
-0.7245493531,
0.2554500401,
0.3090108633,
0.210214898,
-0.3266694844,
0.3798555434,
0.3545641601,
-0.4907997549,
-0.5667544007,
-0.0917060673,
-0.7421914935,
-0.6156920195,
0.869697392,
-0.1667417884,
-0.1173516735,
-0.8110638261,
-0.1036512926,
-0.2918485999,
-0.6185781956,
0.9814405441,
0.6017764807,
-0.3763214648,
-0.2318667173,
-0.8928588033,
0.5699249506,
-0.409439981,
-0.7618581653,
0.5097277164,
0.614136219,
0.6172429323,
0.5728632212,
0.9075782895,
-0.1689954102,
0.0567001067,
0.0368483476,
0.0459503643,
-0.0815159976,
-0.3495470583,
-0.1641578525,
0.4501776099,
-0.3045393527,
-0.2339588702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09060v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09060v2
|
Do Localization Methods Actually Localize Memorized Data in LLMs? A Tale of Two Benchmarks
| 2023-11-15T15:52:40 | 2024-04-02T06:32:40 |
Ting-Yun Chang, Jesse Thomason, Robin Jia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The concept of localization in LLMs is often mentioned in prior work;
however, methods for localization have never been systematically and directly
evaluated. We propose two complementary benchmarks that evaluate the ability of
localization methods to pinpoint LLM components responsible for memorized data.
In our INJ benchmark, we actively inject a piece of new information into a
small subset of LLM weights, enabling us to directly evaluate whether
localization methods can identify these "ground truth" weights. In our DEL
benchmark, we evaluate localization by measuring how much dropping out
identified neurons deletes a memorized pretrained sequence. Despite their
different perspectives, our two benchmarks yield consistent rankings of five
localization methods. Methods adapted from network pruning perform well on both
benchmarks, and all evaluated methods show promising localization ability. On
the other hand, even successful methods identify neurons that are not specific
to a single memorized sequence.
|
[
0.0318847001,
-0.4495832324,
0.6053496003,
0.0390680172,
-0.239707157,
0.1369903386,
-0.4836525619,
-0.3018402755,
0.1005777642,
0.0852753222,
-0.2615384459,
-0.7080361843,
-0.1586061269,
0.066750899,
-0.3011934459,
0.6908434629,
-0.2731889784,
0.4100476801,
-0.5508426428,
-0.2713138163,
-0.5048783422,
-0.7772130966,
-0.5559778214,
-0.5916321278,
0.4341830015,
0.4722618759,
0.2405076325,
1.0277328491,
0.8813372254,
0.2034755945,
-0.5750408769,
0.1235819235,
-0.411939472,
-0.1385635436,
0.1282373071,
-1.1631852388,
-0.2435150445,
-0.005197078,
1.0468603373,
0.9698943496,
-0.1772828251,
0.2784357071,
-0.2798887491,
0.801805675,
-0.7586776614,
-0.338872999,
-0.6770760417,
0.4404617846,
-0.4874111414,
-0.3744825721,
-0.2742696702,
-0.636323452,
-0.0287311003,
-0.3888970613,
0.7279740572,
-0.3218169808,
0.6703167558,
0.2231741399,
-0.4402541518,
0.0066420967,
-0.835570693,
0.7251377702,
-0.726298213,
0.2330915183,
0.3691005707,
0.3769230247,
-0.2424567193,
-0.5458545685,
-0.1164589897,
-0.2351709157,
0.0791960731,
0.2233600765,
0.1565927863,
-0.1570889503,
0.6388518214,
0.5161331296,
-0.3066227436,
0.0931623578,
-0.358966589,
-0.3243765235,
0.3814299703,
-0.0203403905,
0.0201245286,
0.0400473736,
-0.7466217279,
-0.0701963827,
-1.058427453,
0.0657086596,
0.2801659703,
0.1825420707,
-0.0225872025,
0.4729016721,
-0.2828443348,
0.4194499254,
0.0026221187,
-0.5182888508,
0.6050385237,
-0.2174367011,
-0.1015335023,
0.4115456343,
0.6046285629,
0.3354016542,
0.2641174197,
-0.6191356182,
-0.3770171106,
-0.2001948059,
0.0538651422,
-0.3737954795,
-0.2308308482,
-0.0668186173,
-0.6620469093,
0.1106675789,
-0.1432122886,
-0.0438490137,
-0.4361966848,
-0.3280462623,
0.3767944574,
-0.3671738803,
-0.1921396255,
-0.0849093497,
-0.2897951603,
0.3398093283,
0.1786962003,
-0.8347110748,
0.4199485183,
0.7616843581,
1.0430905819,
-0.3779486716,
-0.3761501312,
-0.140986532,
0.2343506962,
-0.6055429578,
0.8857628107,
-0.0928181559,
-0.1671126634,
-0.0301081389,
-0.1065122038,
-0.2120375335,
-1.2521193027,
0.4362738431,
-0.3723572791,
-0.4107043743,
-0.9209061265,
-0.5769585967,
-0.3156099916,
0.266948849,
-0.3720633686,
1.0795243979,
-0.2494885325,
-0.8110172749,
0.5985124111,
0.0456322916,
-0.5975474715,
-0.2687110305,
-0.0460998043,
-0.2375234663,
0.5458400249,
0.1523419768,
0.2706837952,
-0.105242677,
0.3168474734,
-0.1615601331,
-0.8095184565,
0.2889284492,
-0.4876655638,
0.5706134439,
-0.0602395684,
-0.3276890814,
-0.2198141068,
-0.5590023398,
-0.0503280982,
0.2527028918,
-0.366468519,
-0.1163824499,
0.0924354196,
-0.4854244888,
-0.1869085133,
0.3170247674,
-0.5305030346,
0.1372683048,
-0.3769459724,
0.2329004109,
0.4590637982,
0.0176006667,
0.6241393685,
-0.4519038796,
0.2856164873,
0.271845907,
-0.0457613282,
-0.1756029874,
-0.2020117193,
-0.8627887964,
-0.1808624268,
0.2159149796,
0.5553557873,
-0.2439554036,
-0.0125420606,
-0.3928104341,
-0.5560895801,
0.0493003875,
-0.1203088164,
0.5056768656,
0.8029983044,
0.4793432653,
-0.5924935937,
-0.23048985,
-1.0413048267,
-0.4470247924,
0.1431244761,
-0.0821862593,
0.1912597567,
0.271720171,
0.2896000445,
0.977586031,
-0.1090670675,
-0.371630162,
0.3194501996,
0.2973250747,
0.2916334867,
0.328641355,
0.3802614212,
-0.2621257305,
-0.0509894639,
0.1081689298,
-1.048175931,
0.0163727701,
-0.2050218582,
0.2912144959,
-0.1348084658,
0.4823952317,
-0.3980732858,
0.5477337837,
-0.0552536733,
0.4644137025,
0.3958751559,
-0.578851819,
0.1868880242,
-0.6405175924,
0.0204665381,
-0.1807259023,
-0.242830202,
-0.5334666371,
-0.3022961318,
0.4261597097,
0.2093498409,
-0.4821798801,
0.3911785185,
-0.9064131379,
-0.8338512182,
0.0244204123,
0.2735877335,
-0.2897727191,
0.3854041994,
0.0443955287,
0.8518228531,
0.4671281278,
-0.4574643373,
0.316151768,
0.1154923216,
-0.5905449986,
0.3763389289,
-0.4389895201,
0.1827159077,
-0.2410849333,
0.4182631671,
-0.889885962,
0.1813973486,
0.0996447653,
-0.2912234068,
0.2919022143,
-0.5321117043,
-0.6005060673,
-0.2670437098,
-0.1959119141,
0.6499002576,
0.4281552434,
-0.7031306624,
-0.0111822952,
0.2528858483,
0.2596877515,
-0.5991800427,
-0.8670009375,
-0.1044815481,
-0.4126388431,
-0.2032426298,
0.4596512616,
0.1303035617,
-0.1065376699,
-0.3377639949,
-0.8520774841,
-0.2140762657,
0.2372183949,
0.3892509937,
-0.1693598032,
-0.3286121488,
0.2910485864,
-0.2626605034,
-0.2738198042,
0.3071827292,
-0.1522737592,
0.1715894938,
-0.1129544899,
-0.6125987768,
-0.4789123535,
-0.2518849373,
0.255959779,
-0.5001360178,
0.3069884181,
0.5613108873,
-0.5301257968,
-0.0852027535,
-0.8762565255,
-0.158274889,
-0.4480981231,
0.2213912606,
-0.2884941697,
-0.4004788697,
0.7523704767,
-0.5365365744,
-0.2451054007,
-0.0041276873,
0.1881247461,
-0.3526115716,
0.5829865932,
0.1221959442,
-0.0351697579,
0.4521509707,
-0.3340804875,
0.232243672,
-1.1893584728,
-0.2549164891,
-0.4927512109,
-0.8051818013,
-0.1624450535,
-0.4468033612,
0.3381232917,
0.7132709622,
-0.1126581803,
0.28679052,
-0.4884698093,
0.9138928652,
0.6635920405,
0.1218136474,
0.2013182491,
0.2677357197,
-0.3765567243,
-0.3028724194,
-0.9263778925,
-0.3873673677,
1.3366497755,
0.3367145658,
0.3347634375,
-0.1245871261,
1.0354232788,
0.1024790034,
0.6330781579,
-0.7560233474,
0.6630557179,
0.038107615,
-0.2766906619,
-0.0428909622,
-0.6048125625,
-0.8685795665,
0.042337101,
-0.006915811,
-0.921043992,
0.3096977472,
-0.023406934,
-0.3300063312,
0.6951882839,
-0.6616224051,
0.7583521008,
-0.4538680315,
-0.1675591916,
-0.0932622105,
-0.6480026841,
0.2477535903,
0.0143997325,
0.0613319427,
-0.5724617839,
-0.1097036749,
0.9860255122,
-0.316226095,
0.6159313321,
-0.3414056301,
-0.168634668,
0.2538153529,
0.0946983024,
0.4783908427,
0.0845063627,
-0.1860024035,
0.4962497652,
-0.0557101481,
-0.3379646838,
-0.4981057644,
0.9303297997,
-0.4803996086,
-0.2676344812,
-0.3409035802,
-0.4133327901,
-0.2088354379,
0.2116494626,
0.3412970603,
0.5835738182,
-0.0872168168,
-0.0113888029,
0.8782503605,
-0.0348820873,
0.7031632066,
0.5807076693,
0.3061921299,
-0.5427948236,
0.9841017723,
0.4646142125,
-0.0545383766,
0.7496369481,
-0.0652591437,
-0.0876558796,
-1.1278198957,
-0.0868025795,
0.4105383158,
-0.965644896,
-0.266349256,
-0.0056677689,
0.0688800067,
0.0929727703,
-0.2116653919,
-0.7347053289,
-0.3117845058,
-0.0802425295,
-0.1429317594,
0.0586571656,
0.6726461053,
-0.2312718481,
0.3076924384,
-0.69453758,
0.3886228502,
-0.0758734271,
0.4060211182,
-0.0568087623,
-0.319255203,
-0.5063855648,
0.1817128658,
0.000841334,
-0.8710232377,
0.1343664825,
-0.1735963374,
0.6341001987,
0.3133762479,
-0.249113366,
0.8041840792,
-0.5168525577,
0.6260191202,
0.2214365155,
-0.7037340403,
0.5628407001,
-0.2834709883,
0.4052308202,
0.6801147461,
0.0517284572,
-0.3712461889,
-0.0630092323,
-0.2370942831,
-0.7502377033,
0.6307852864,
-0.0559841432,
-0.118559964,
-0.5281255245,
0.8513199091,
-0.1802770793,
0.0930579007,
-0.4031903744,
-0.6904145479,
0.3375331461,
0.166555956,
-0.0707179382,
-0.2233778536,
-0.1616001427,
-0.2719736695,
0.2471173108,
-0.0317239612,
0.3998224735,
0.6059150696,
-0.3075100482,
-0.0731305778,
-0.095176436,
0.6366505027,
0.9045296907,
-0.4424830675,
-0.0042792778,
0.6046540737,
-0.4633854032,
0.2622199357,
-0.2630441189,
-0.5836496353,
0.3130558431,
0.5719826818,
0.5274493694,
0.5191983581,
-0.2742216885,
0.7244553566,
-0.0911482945,
-0.2306123823,
-0.4809701443,
-0.0998035371,
0.0932063609,
0.2365543544,
0.3435277045,
0.4340799749,
-0.074073799,
-0.1297430098,
0.0800852701,
0.5359430909,
-0.5259524584,
-0.3246477842,
0.7177139521,
0.0655261725,
-0.3879269958,
0.7533698082,
-0.0546328239,
-0.3301991224,
1.0565114021,
0.5869274139,
0.9470307827,
0.0406667888,
0.0483941585,
0.7020543218,
0.4561273158,
-0.3313566148,
0.0594882928,
-0.4764387608,
-0.6523848176,
-0.3066859841,
-0.1678916514,
-0.2258409262,
-0.1122938246,
-0.9314285517,
-0.1224194765,
-0.5784069896,
-0.4892104864,
-0.2421551943,
0.1130750254,
-0.7100505829,
0.2600657046,
0.4448899031,
1.0103127956,
-0.6248601675,
0.7896619439,
0.7730165124,
0.0039773053,
-0.5879815221,
0.2033545673,
-0.0650120825,
-0.5270047188,
0.6900299788,
0.3187613189,
0.0060634781,
-0.2664813101,
-0.2789657414,
-1.1611914635,
1.5254131556,
0.534919858,
-0.5874602795,
0.3084203601,
0.0220755897,
0.381067425,
0.0105295824,
0.5501803756,
0.5504747629,
0.2932953537,
-0.1851814091,
-0.9788119197,
-0.1898692697,
-0.0623905547,
0.0023219709,
0.2940258682,
-0.8004325628,
0.7248467803,
-0.4948654473,
-0.5076634884,
-0.0935124159,
0.4450190067,
-0.0527286269,
0.413176626,
0.1053533331,
0.8870179057,
1.1188203096,
-0.23349078,
0.928026855,
-0.1451916844,
0.280757308,
1.5268477201,
-0.4601117373,
0.8925423026,
0.5544650555,
-0.2880145013,
-0.0094251735,
0.6589123607,
0.0184448846,
0.5351858139,
0.5914512277,
-0.2667871714,
-0.0997468755,
-0.059421476,
-0.5082743764,
0.0746597648,
-0.0734811202,
-0.1292400956,
-0.2726771832,
-0.2647078037,
-0.0545728989,
-0.0044403481,
-0.3327480853,
0.7722821236,
-0.0443313047,
-0.6358252764,
0.7912062407,
0.0956519842,
0.5062888265,
-0.7067462206,
0.1831085086,
-0.8433220387,
0.3099150658,
-0.2061592638,
-0.4254480004,
0.3199552298,
-0.2646601796,
-0.2875324786,
-0.3493177295,
0.5536128879,
-0.1382833868,
-0.0385500155,
0.3340337276,
0.3157040477,
0.3312482834,
0.0646659657,
-0.2830610573,
-0.1661366075,
0.0161687173,
-0.3224180639,
0.3532006443,
0.3196697831,
-0.194891125,
0.940033257,
0.6888266802,
0.2628208995,
0.257059902,
0.1904646754,
0.4930550158,
-0.73513937,
0.1902512014,
-0.637009263,
0.0168353934,
-0.0603067279,
-0.4573203921,
0.9514845014,
0.8495454192,
1.1514900923,
-0.0268494319,
0.3446748257,
0.3714351654,
0.36940521,
-0.4529883862,
0.4913142323,
-0.4015354216,
0.5805055499,
0.1940178722,
-1.2308647633,
-0.5572251081,
0.6532774568,
-0.6626994014,
-0.1107295901,
0.8829197884,
0.994907856,
-0.0609313883,
-0.3621668518,
0.1959186792,
0.1353642046,
-0.1520342082,
0.6642435193,
0.8611688018,
-0.6615648866,
0.3556014895,
-0.5688954592,
-0.1298669428,
0.0192972682,
-0.8352137208,
-1.0065329075,
-0.1201294586,
-0.51916188,
0.1614592671,
0.1238788366,
0.4885447919,
0.8386090994,
-0.6611270905,
-0.2410633415,
-0.1154372916,
0.334043473,
-0.548071146,
-0.1103072017,
0.3198428452,
-0.2919535041,
-0.2295806259,
1.0380786657,
0.4789766073,
0.037766695,
0.0989297405,
-0.0257629696,
-0.0444733612,
-0.1654286683,
0.0136373304,
0.3735618889,
-0.7175892591,
-0.0541070215,
-0.1884778142,
-0.3208622932,
0.405298233,
0.9848492146,
-1.0597976446,
0.6109723449,
0.5449194908,
0.3572924137,
0.6748651266,
0.1254348159,
0.37296018,
-0.9763273597,
0.2132666558,
0.1452400088,
0.3426437378,
0.3913353682,
-0.0964647382,
0.7276646495,
0.1581564248,
-0.5248029828,
-0.7750812769,
0.0116106402,
-0.6556147337,
0.1766862422,
0.8655914068,
-0.3919661939,
-0.3575507998,
0.2364848703,
0.0403785892,
0.2985511422,
0.182454288,
0.5655049682,
0.5161826611,
0.2322412729,
0.1159547791,
-0.6250740886,
0.5041123033,
0.6605612636,
-0.5632125735,
0.0442650765,
0.397310853,
0.4745795131,
0.0501875691,
0.7436471581,
-0.0328041837,
0.1785057336,
-0.0644196793,
0.0701263025,
-0.1248946115,
-0.3443994522,
-0.5616326928,
-0.0565905198,
-0.0223554429,
-0.4018928409
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09053v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09053v1
|
Assessing Knowledge Editing in Language Models via Relation Perspective
| 2023-11-15T15:44:42 | 2023-11-15T15:44:42 |
Yifan Wei, Xiaoyan Yu, Huanhuan Ma, Fangyu Lei, Yixuan Weng, Ran Song, Kang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Knowledge Editing (KE) for modifying factual knowledge in Large Language
Models (LLMs) has been receiving increasing attention. However, existing
knowledge editing methods are entity-centric, and it is unclear whether this
approach is suitable for a relation-centric perspective. To address this gap,
this paper constructs a new benchmark named RaKE, which focuses on Relation
based Knowledge Editing. In this paper, we establish a suite of innovative
metrics for evaluation and conduct comprehensive experiments involving various
knowledge editing baselines. We notice that existing knowledge editing methods
exhibit the potential difficulty in their ability to edit relations. Therefore,
we further explore the role of relations in factual triplets within the
transformer. Our research results confirm that knowledge related to relations
is not only stored in the FFN network but also in the attention layers. This
provides experimental support for future relation-based knowledge editing
methods.
|
[
-0.265309304,
-0.6396054626,
0.5052700043,
0.2741987407,
0.261947155,
-0.0391168669,
-0.2787671685,
-0.5123121738,
-0.0120002404,
0.5314916372,
-0.2338408977,
-0.3747613728,
-0.4665144682,
0.1801320612,
-0.4356511831,
0.9028398395,
-0.1973835081,
0.0050796447,
-0.5201559067,
-0.4580889344,
-0.5465889573,
-0.5310810804,
-0.6446141005,
-0.3746680617,
0.6121374369,
0.2919635773,
1.1018601656,
0.7204268575,
0.7853492498,
0.301176995,
-0.4817619622,
0.0437244028,
-0.3994093239,
0.0988705084,
-0.5542401075,
-0.6089957952,
-0.8270816803,
-0.0425480679,
0.8650855422,
0.9358420968,
0.0922796056,
0.2510486245,
-0.1106719673,
0.8481917977,
-0.822157681,
0.3965502977,
-0.7655799389,
-0.0088229077,
-0.1676866859,
0.0239772722,
-0.4402444661,
-0.319601506,
0.0586983189,
-0.5756906867,
0.3734589815,
0.1205511466,
0.8731774092,
0.2284957916,
-0.3863254786,
-0.0064975717,
-1.0619450808,
0.4180170298,
-0.5481662154,
0.867721796,
0.1966052502,
0.1089206934,
-0.0761256889,
-0.6147859097,
-0.6525068283,
-0.0064753122,
-0.3760263026,
0.0197677873,
-0.2142239362,
-0.0068063862,
0.5520110726,
0.5349100828,
-0.0025490031,
-0.1585739404,
-0.1346537322,
0.0596792847,
0.4983707368,
0.267077148,
0.1611842662,
-0.5408932567,
-0.1825419813,
-0.007076181,
-0.7295675874,
0.0142958816,
0.1936696321,
-0.0298376139,
0.2246644497,
0.6820111275,
-0.2066715211,
0.6814550757,
0.210450694,
-0.0132909203,
0.3101499379,
-0.2926475108,
-0.3508276343,
-0.2461924851,
0.9473795295,
0.6521282196,
0.3388296366,
-0.3635298014,
-0.135027349,
-0.0601447001,
0.2882888615,
-0.4542933702,
-0.2322350144,
0.1045719981,
-0.2368486822,
-0.4346497059,
-0.2015371919,
-0.5752103329,
-0.5200491548,
-0.1604408324,
0.3082855642,
-0.8202480674,
-0.3865559995,
0.0754107982,
-0.0618535317,
0.3072140217,
0.3453240097,
-0.8454388976,
0.4165793061,
0.9150342345,
0.6117213368,
-0.0283193663,
-0.5531136394,
-0.3172279298,
0.3937334716,
-0.4648112357,
0.8121808171,
-0.4241448045,
-0.2123526037,
-0.1076151803,
-0.2704380155,
-0.1481491923,
-0.3856907785,
0.6310642958,
-1.0342782736,
0.0986501127,
-0.4313370883,
-0.9239016175,
-0.14732337,
0.3422043622,
-0.7735923529,
1.3346227407,
0.2919402421,
-1.1714764833,
0.4137042463,
-0.5967291594,
-0.4778850377,
-0.0409739353,
0.1358531564,
-0.3336836994,
-0.0821330771,
0.3538268507,
0.4625076056,
-0.1643432975,
0.3966168165,
-0.2739629149,
0.0844606236,
0.4409854412,
0.0392677151,
0.624648869,
-0.2842385471,
0.0636370927,
0.1623901874,
-0.9864519238,
-0.3481318951,
-0.0859240592,
0.000819836,
-0.7001753449,
-0.1235873774,
-0.3251729608,
0.2588991523,
0.0904261023,
-0.5518741012,
0.3283207417,
-0.3843066692,
0.2035743147,
0.6205973625,
0.4540450871,
0.5645632148,
-0.1524889916,
0.3704283535,
0.0578652099,
0.2739548981,
0.1046307683,
-0.3144935668,
-1.1346184015,
0.2432632446,
0.7067023516,
0.4546342194,
-0.9300623536,
0.3047410548,
-0.8061875701,
-0.5183308721,
-0.4718011916,
0.2028230131,
0.3744500279,
0.766004324,
0.2950947881,
-0.1371512264,
-0.3506973684,
-1.0902192593,
-0.7346202731,
-0.3734923303,
-0.0435935594,
0.0961831883,
0.422354728,
0.0656491518,
1.1433702707,
-0.4023571312,
-0.2726847231,
-0.0208580848,
-0.021274196,
0.1333255023,
0.1342270523,
0.5614623427,
-0.5407887697,
-0.5476770401,
0.0950514674,
-0.9402245283,
-0.0132615613,
0.0364381336,
-0.2727164328,
0.0204196591,
0.4618030787,
-0.7043809295,
0.2422051281,
0.2806465924,
-0.2653160989,
0.4609281123,
0.0513077378,
0.2780513167,
-0.8469868302,
0.0732280761,
-0.0066075204,
-0.4148214757,
-0.8340008855,
0.1198237017,
0.5555899143,
0.2097762376,
-0.5009840131,
0.3523473144,
-0.4579976797,
-0.265819937,
0.2132366747,
0.2551986873,
0.1137294546,
0.649302125,
-0.0528425425,
0.6568172574,
0.3105101585,
-0.5261706114,
0.4825145006,
0.5276637673,
-0.4805670083,
0.8082806468,
-0.5275013447,
0.3217096627,
-0.1318741888,
-0.0179068819,
-0.6345650554,
0.0531989634,
0.2278009504,
-0.2735008895,
0.3092013001,
-0.1829794347,
-0.7624329925,
-0.0656912476,
-0.3959176838,
0.1453238875,
0.1170582473,
-0.4753537476,
0.7890737653,
0.2936609089,
-0.0775988698,
-0.662637651,
-0.5340912938,
0.2010763586,
-0.1752813607,
-0.9988940954,
0.3719335198,
0.1845262051,
-0.5450828671,
0.4133540988,
-0.0902317911,
0.0812764987,
-0.0511063859,
0.0246555079,
0.3190791905,
-0.2001254708,
0.2465117723,
0.017616,
-0.1654365808,
0.2872830033,
0.2236692607,
0.0019934834,
-0.1237261742,
0.0409222022,
-0.2480945736,
-0.0558384582,
0.5783478618,
-0.5127959251,
1.0332461596,
0.1559331566,
-0.3319130242,
0.0249811318,
-0.8150949478,
0.2001484185,
-0.4074054658,
0.4039018452,
-0.7744954824,
-0.8231596351,
0.6846727729,
-0.0369271971,
0.0710753053,
0.5938122869,
0.2370711714,
-0.0098222038,
0.4971700311,
0.6244955063,
-0.015693929,
0.2583970129,
-0.1811939776,
0.3036632538,
-1.3832405806,
0.0319770873,
-0.4260299504,
-0.1142670736,
-0.5036679506,
-0.4189291894,
0.6126765609,
0.3548280001,
-0.0959886536,
0.5177938938,
-0.0247177575,
0.4740870595,
0.1389113665,
0.0035941689,
0.7984374166,
-0.5916883349,
0.0260293577,
-0.2198418528,
-0.7254421711,
-0.3990114629,
1.1268174648,
0.4744732678,
0.4030872583,
0.1932540983,
0.3095098138,
0.0488169044,
0.7226148844,
-0.8868689537,
0.506182611,
0.0935098156,
-0.7041794658,
-0.6137156487,
-0.4014120996,
-0.4360710979,
0.4547795653,
-0.2069255859,
-0.61222893,
0.255458653,
0.2000137419,
-0.2002256215,
0.5560074449,
-0.6270220876,
0.8182111979,
0.0452862307,
-0.6263315678,
-0.170150131,
-0.6045143604,
0.5655930042,
-0.0757244751,
0.5892475843,
0.0350530744,
0.0820247754,
0.8042284846,
-0.4765065908,
0.3120279312,
-0.0267052259,
-0.2201973647,
-0.1019579619,
0.4023361504,
0.5772535205,
0.1452957839,
-0.4245319963,
0.0951004624,
-0.068634674,
-0.0239001084,
-1.0441691875,
0.5986596346,
-0.6827511191,
-0.5714118481,
-0.3076556623,
-0.5840087533,
-0.8790203333,
0.207056731,
-0.229780674,
0.3080429733,
-0.5570771098,
0.2141671628,
0.6829141974,
-0.204727903,
0.221968621,
0.5984274149,
-0.6574854851,
-0.2377965599,
0.4935575128,
0.1765604615,
0.4139234126,
0.6699307561,
0.167150721,
-0.0732047111,
-0.3198075593,
-0.4946156144,
0.3108789921,
-0.8959590197,
-0.2099663615,
-0.9720609784,
-0.3121494055,
-0.4011260569,
0.1731740534,
-0.6694420576,
-0.4510067999,
0.3336056471,
-0.1420603544,
0.6258252263,
0.7551153898,
0.002382295,
0.2325448394,
-0.7291613817,
0.5021257997,
0.3772063553,
0.7502041459,
0.1041641161,
-0.3992871344,
-0.4614537358,
-0.2725151479,
-0.1175656617,
-0.8487137556,
-0.0244763214,
-0.0371626653,
0.2313571423,
-0.0093548568,
-0.0774892569,
0.575145781,
-0.6488333344,
0.6369011402,
-0.1027395278,
-1.2575560808,
0.3177217841,
-0.4514164925,
0.1698445976,
0.4686222076,
0.0599287115,
-0.8470509052,
-0.4567580223,
-0.7281268835,
-0.4498253167,
0.7649434805,
0.380243063,
-0.0512578897,
0.3761335611,
0.4659986794,
-0.1228632629,
0.2620747089,
-0.5988898277,
-0.5780181289,
0.0710139275,
0.3254372776,
0.0761028826,
-0.5171377063,
0.0949075595,
-0.4473100007,
0.9125269651,
0.4121285975,
-0.1192255467,
0.0872012451,
-0.1506723166,
-0.2522137165,
0.4576113224,
0.1510730237,
0.9393985271,
-0.3258514106,
0.0259214547,
0.3613341749,
-0.2782204151,
-0.0449271575,
-0.049683962,
-0.2506965101,
0.111148335,
0.5393269062,
1.0293051004,
0.5473381281,
0.1313949227,
0.5625377893,
-0.2178670168,
-0.1600984037,
-0.1531785727,
0.0139967259,
0.3998121917,
-0.1185097694,
-0.1383918971,
0.2985522151,
0.0404876322,
-0.3172737658,
-0.08970467,
0.1410182267,
-0.2586677074,
-0.1843408644,
0.4872120023,
0.1844024807,
-0.4288084507,
0.4764374197,
0.0137823205,
-0.485866785,
0.1312011033,
-0.0124445492,
0.7212001085,
-0.4238405824,
0.0360934436,
0.392223984,
0.5218624473,
0.2358402908,
-0.1860720515,
0.125895381,
-1.2696379423,
-0.5792490244,
-0.42618981,
-0.6668348908,
0.3623971343,
-0.9006376266,
0.5546258092,
-0.1962269694,
0.0476353392,
0.4663713276,
-0.2285648733,
-0.9937755466,
0.2184411138,
-0.462762475,
0.788369596,
-0.695140183,
1.0672506094,
0.726380527,
-0.2614373267,
-0.8718878627,
-0.0367623903,
-0.2378068864,
-0.469311893,
0.4890851974,
-0.2018157989,
-0.1854923069,
-0.1248690635,
-0.3144425452,
-0.7934806943,
0.736972928,
0.3020474911,
-0.5425599217,
-0.1098332331,
0.3696836531,
0.7662758827,
0.0741703957,
0.1920890957,
0.8955378532,
0.5252736807,
-0.1675779372,
-0.9533467889,
-0.2283288836,
-0.3907643557,
0.2595153749,
0.3896527886,
-0.6619924307,
0.6606106162,
0.3548057973,
-0.1110986546,
-0.3997159004,
0.7820980549,
-0.2385533005,
-0.1867413819,
0.6984178424,
0.724381566,
0.4110827446,
0.1623041928,
1.0701543093,
-0.5628418326,
0.4070110619,
1.392111063,
-0.4817323685,
0.7403754592,
0.6136642694,
-0.46087569,
0.6309702396,
0.0790851787,
0.115668647,
0.1617423594,
0.0158717725,
-0.2073378116,
-0.1147612333,
0.0383286141,
-0.2914745212,
0.4171533287,
0.3600398302,
-0.2470733076,
0.016169643,
-0.1027764678,
0.336746335,
0.2589535117,
-0.1225451082,
0.8451012373,
0.0052688266,
-0.5677258372,
0.2131149769,
0.247329101,
0.3983824253,
-0.369734019,
0.0679858029,
-0.1325053722,
0.1379819065,
-0.3020983338,
-1.048281312,
0.4947036505,
0.2686183453,
-0.4190662503,
-0.2214898318,
0.7719250917,
-0.2578097582,
-0.5637038946,
0.4181676805,
0.6964222193,
-0.2693023086,
-0.0499455594,
-0.3822392225,
0.1893135458,
-0.2204356939,
-0.5223585963,
0.0979916975,
0.8191733956,
0.01319631,
0.4775676131,
0.3278587461,
0.2258010358,
-0.1969590634,
0.1162476391,
0.7559913397,
-0.6638720632,
-0.3461342454,
-0.7306373119,
0.5410693288,
-0.1942253709,
-0.2514281571,
0.9750536084,
0.5516960621,
0.8975487947,
-0.0942255557,
0.8605875373,
-0.0859215483,
0.8403784037,
-0.4319260418,
0.6503832936,
-0.10289184,
0.3047459722,
-0.6380776167,
-1.1445999146,
-0.4183816016,
0.2993034124,
-0.6947614551,
-0.1801363677,
0.9716717005,
0.7978089452,
-0.1780682355,
0.3263712525,
0.286898762,
0.4380078316,
0.2221488804,
0.3161677122,
0.8788036108,
-0.7573071122,
0.2865109444,
-0.8652390838,
-0.1405596882,
0.213401258,
-0.9813988805,
-1.0274053812,
-0.5797938108,
-0.420556426,
-0.2511432469,
0.0890906304,
0.6424852014,
0.2548282146,
-0.5478503108,
-0.2627118826,
-0.0499199554,
0.2026372105,
-0.2657376528,
-0.2614118159,
0.6149325371,
-0.0530979596,
-0.6047261953,
0.1823825985,
0.3169884086,
-0.5540019274,
-0.3512642682,
0.3111224473,
-0.2739255428,
-0.3042704761,
0.7093046308,
-0.1805403829,
-0.4514188766,
-0.6567590237,
-0.0086691976,
0.0064958693,
0.2645822167,
0.8301362395,
-0.6145522594,
0.5496768355,
0.4828071892,
0.5474302769,
0.4951794744,
0.0022293997,
0.7709801793,
-0.7113167644,
-0.1250120699,
0.0150793288,
0.3584620953,
0.7864521146,
-0.3337945342,
0.5885571241,
0.2046786249,
-0.5705523491,
-0.5794878602,
0.0236934777,
-0.808514595,
0.2951625884,
1.2568998337,
-0.1574474126,
-0.2057464868,
-0.0532618016,
-0.0904733613,
0.4997793138,
-0.0960155427,
0.545784533,
1.0221248865,
-0.3321433365,
-0.2955625653,
-0.6569260955,
0.6311337352,
0.4646297097,
-0.7420563102,
0.3373149037,
0.4572426379,
0.3556090891,
0.1604795456,
0.4387617409,
-0.2590405345,
0.0978770256,
-0.1819723397,
0.3376502395,
-0.0640564561,
-0.1621558368,
-0.352586627,
0.0130237089,
0.2506940663,
0.2202922851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09048v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09048v3
|
GRASP: A novel benchmark for evaluating language GRounding And Situated Physics understanding in multimodal language models
| 2023-11-15T15:38:28 | 2024-06-06T09:35:53 |
Serwan Jassim, Mario Holubar, Annika Richter, Cornelius Wolff, Xenia Ohmer, Elia Bruni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents GRASP, a novel benchmark to evaluate the language
grounding and physical understanding capabilities of video-based multimodal
large language models (LLMs). This evaluation is accomplished via a two-tier
approach leveraging Unity simulations. The first level tests for language
grounding by assessing a model's ability to relate simple textual descriptions
with visual information. The second level evaluates the model's understanding
of "Intuitive Physics" principles, such as object permanence and continuity. In
addition to releasing the benchmark, we use it to evaluate several
state-of-the-art multimodal LLMs. Our evaluation reveals significant
shortcomings in the language grounding and intuitive physics capabilities of
these models. Although they exhibit at least some grounding capabilities,
particularly for colors and shapes, these capabilities depend heavily on the
prompting strategy. At the same time, all models perform below or at the chance
level of 50% in the Intuitive Physics tests, while human subjects are on
average 80% correct. These identified limitations underline the importance of
using benchmarks like GRASP to monitor the progress of future models in
developing these competencies.
|
[
-0.3374588192,
-0.6595584154,
0.7389526367,
0.300039202,
-0.0620872453,
0.0587257519,
-0.1532258391,
-0.0684324652,
-0.3324379325,
0.0096128928,
-0.3481387496,
-0.4431500137,
-0.8209597468,
-0.1540485919,
-0.3458393514,
0.3170051873,
-0.1951280683,
0.0709415525,
-0.5557915568,
-0.3699610531,
-0.4085205495,
-0.2320419699,
-0.1854617447,
-0.6024242043,
0.188704744,
0.2794664502,
0.9235523343,
0.4057582319,
0.5529298186,
0.3266081214,
-0.2942115068,
-0.1232827976,
-0.3672237992,
-0.3017606437,
-0.2450345606,
-0.4466029704,
-0.3304775655,
0.121221669,
1.036198616,
1.0843164921,
-0.1343399286,
-0.0365876704,
-0.0619022958,
0.4366192818,
-0.8958693147,
0.0692661703,
-0.5335741043,
0.2693071663,
0.3097150922,
-0.0812989175,
-0.3949705958,
0.0489929095,
-0.0254534464,
-0.6639708281,
-0.0939670801,
-0.0557980575,
0.8858279586,
0.1013786569,
-0.7791852355,
0.1510904282,
-0.2438385785,
0.8681986928,
-0.6167129278,
0.9478526115,
0.384339869,
0.4312849343,
-0.025082536,
-0.5388481021,
-0.6238049269,
-0.4845941365,
0.3701538742,
0.3641512692,
-0.093833372,
0.2068246603,
0.5702467561,
0.2125783265,
-0.3449386954,
0.1754185557,
-0.1691336185,
-0.1063680276,
0.1726504117,
0.0496922247,
0.550981462,
-0.2193182856,
-0.5859588981,
-0.3758773804,
-0.6302605867,
0.2829279304,
0.1246312335,
0.1360717863,
-0.3877442181,
0.8538924456,
-0.3605026901,
0.572840333,
-0.1303506941,
-0.4619619846,
0.368629545,
-0.1633677781,
-0.3637688458,
-0.27238518,
0.7616189718,
0.7696006298,
0.2944723964,
-0.0604633242,
0.0455732718,
-0.0086822994,
0.1041246578,
-0.6471499801,
-0.1320504546,
0.0627922937,
-0.5030435324,
0.0201955549,
-0.0896520987,
-0.5642931461,
-0.6410011053,
-0.4320053458,
0.3381874561,
-0.6889395714,
-0.6639653444,
0.2964724302,
-0.1036179066,
0.4483327866,
0.4348935783,
-0.947476685,
0.3759047687,
0.8375983834,
1.0291707516,
0.0021663031,
-0.7449986935,
-0.4877282679,
0.202940762,
-0.2037061602,
0.7597523928,
-0.3237734139,
-0.2816735804,
-0.1580389738,
-0.2798664272,
-0.0776829123,
-0.4652497768,
0.2662990391,
-0.3321124911,
-0.2208077461,
-0.3638893068,
-0.3842104971,
-0.317569375,
0.5421174169,
-0.5743408203,
0.858283937,
-0.0336936265,
-0.550267756,
0.862554729,
-0.2174112797,
-0.2416087687,
-0.0152562829,
-0.3564053178,
-0.0056851483,
0.2315785736,
0.3059357107,
0.316560626,
-0.2380531281,
0.6128326058,
-0.6190727353,
-0.1153381392,
0.0053383484,
-0.5417516828,
0.5118421316,
0.2275046259,
-0.1801732779,
-0.0187324397,
-0.6173402071,
0.0761411339,
-0.015395198,
-0.1941963881,
-0.2177362144,
0.2462557703,
0.0260966513,
0.3497925997,
0.2295244336,
-0.2138105333,
0.0965495482,
-0.2043232322,
0.0854809657,
0.4998201132,
-0.4286668301,
0.6447451115,
-0.1161785722,
0.6448253393,
-0.0191592872,
-0.0027605474,
-0.5899800062,
-0.2835403979,
-0.3864448071,
-0.445976615,
-0.1907069981,
0.4988003075,
-0.5184113383,
0.2040241063,
-0.3806768656,
-0.5015084743,
-0.265781492,
0.2378941923,
0.5559719801,
0.5499333739,
0.2875174284,
-0.2134739757,
-0.1952640861,
-0.7658247948,
-0.4957666397,
-0.3945958316,
-0.14478302,
0.373920083,
0.4712822437,
-0.0046581286,
1.0247480869,
-0.0864445195,
0.01493234,
-0.2115641385,
0.2636482418,
0.1450777203,
0.3327363431,
0.4954133928,
-0.9104583859,
-0.0850438401,
0.2239804268,
-1.3385154009,
-0.0079703089,
-0.0603357181,
0.2863169312,
-0.3563630879,
0.5635032058,
-0.7425784469,
0.2377235591,
0.6672100425,
-0.5139455795,
0.633711338,
-0.1593540609,
0.4607870281,
-0.7682139277,
0.167787239,
0.0998947024,
-0.2174840868,
-0.3989087939,
0.3586807251,
0.3576813042,
-0.3327293098,
-0.9292497039,
0.680936873,
-0.8393671513,
-0.3240128756,
-0.0584556833,
0.3837981224,
0.0221234988,
0.160928607,
0.1637961119,
0.7628474236,
0.7614257336,
-0.5797120333,
0.3469826281,
0.0971927196,
-0.6200963855,
0.8182522058,
-0.7263870239,
-0.2818053663,
-0.1395013779,
-0.0581003092,
-1.0269492865,
-0.3692492843,
-0.2653721571,
-0.4117875993,
0.153530553,
-0.3272953928,
-0.6459268928,
-0.1775233001,
-0.1738624573,
0.5884359479,
0.4747909606,
-0.5303611159,
0.8835631609,
0.3798404038,
0.0977778584,
-0.6806411147,
-0.5765372515,
0.2542757094,
-0.334667474,
-0.6612058878,
-0.1120144054,
-0.1495136917,
-0.4553273022,
-0.3455860317,
-0.3092221916,
-0.0312850848,
0.3099838495,
0.257178098,
-0.2311552465,
-0.0409074016,
-0.0917437375,
0.1962348372,
-0.1022202745,
0.3675682843,
0.0821552873,
0.4315985143,
-0.4174573123,
-0.8408540487,
-0.5341043472,
-0.1472792178,
0.8201808333,
0.028784411,
0.487647295,
0.3483253419,
-0.4731361866,
0.215961203,
-0.5538775921,
-0.1335300654,
-0.5523141623,
0.5929988623,
-0.8649255633,
-0.6346200109,
0.5152363181,
-0.5707043409,
-0.0975225717,
0.1162226945,
0.4592114687,
-0.0158506855,
1.2438054085,
0.5497454405,
-0.1145623252,
0.4041160047,
-0.2418791652,
-0.0938123837,
-0.7729569077,
-0.3802391589,
-0.2802114785,
-0.0603335723,
0.0068906499,
-0.421050638,
0.3595637977,
0.5566087961,
-0.0832816139,
0.3343816102,
0.1282400042,
0.5956988931,
0.1382736713,
-0.0753968656,
0.3289430737,
0.1870733351,
-0.6690363884,
-0.2933222353,
-0.5635546446,
-0.6757162213,
0.8296178579,
0.6431442499,
0.8428643346,
0.2402840555,
0.2551752031,
0.0358949564,
0.2076548189,
-0.9529420137,
0.6889637113,
0.2670869827,
-0.4240951836,
-0.0663491189,
-0.4768387973,
-0.7149560452,
0.6899018884,
-0.1922394335,
-0.8137323856,
-0.1783666313,
0.0841208771,
-0.0336473659,
0.5301508904,
-0.812643826,
0.9542904496,
-0.3212824166,
-0.5081950426,
-0.3342228234,
-0.4665915072,
0.4765769541,
0.3217422664,
0.5804610252,
-0.3506407738,
-0.1605848223,
0.534055233,
-0.0633498803,
0.7138661146,
-0.3391337097,
-0.4393604696,
0.1391720176,
0.3754813373,
0.0264193676,
0.2265608758,
-0.1501660049,
0.1453470886,
-0.0587202534,
-0.3964476585,
-0.6833075285,
0.6423983574,
-0.7155524492,
-0.375818342,
-0.379976213,
-0.6538068056,
-0.447540164,
0.4856186211,
0.0661984831,
0.5296800733,
-0.42239663,
0.2104232609,
0.7327321172,
-0.2508199811,
0.2595169246,
0.6291866899,
-0.4118842781,
-0.4541698992,
0.7040452957,
-0.3582234681,
0.5466617346,
0.5069832802,
0.245985806,
-0.480808109,
-0.5541955233,
-0.3580083847,
0.2448706627,
-0.9017737508,
-0.0512719266,
-0.753254354,
0.1547083259,
-0.3971506059,
-0.3559642732,
-0.4846054614,
-0.1366705745,
-0.1403928697,
-0.3779302537,
0.1210039556,
0.622787118,
-0.0714794099,
0.4291903973,
-0.5885867476,
0.5921481848,
0.2945703566,
0.4954194427,
-0.0464895219,
-0.6352673769,
-0.0592130423,
0.0770567879,
-0.3327986002,
-0.6357313395,
0.1771385372,
0.2216817737,
0.653214097,
0.6580824852,
-0.3714816272,
0.8012333512,
-0.5886397362,
0.7833850384,
0.73883003,
-1.1221985817,
0.5216962099,
-0.6870157123,
0.7883841395,
0.6622086763,
0.3173083663,
-0.4634071887,
-0.4186044633,
-0.4010169506,
-0.703633368,
0.6086214185,
0.046505101,
0.2123828232,
-0.0204323288,
0.0885433182,
-0.1237695664,
0.2137175798,
-0.7776522636,
-0.0240395311,
-0.0129187098,
-0.0867995843,
-0.1592506319,
-0.2185773998,
-0.079401046,
-0.1942449957,
0.049350027,
-0.304466486,
0.0928457379,
-0.0622025952,
-0.5067715049,
-0.0315724425,
0.0914203748,
0.4747528434,
0.8689473867,
-0.2315317392,
0.375616461,
0.4735677242,
-0.6188585758,
0.1257268935,
-0.1425810456,
0.1415493041,
-0.2168657184,
0.614351809,
0.6654005647,
0.6628994942,
-1.0513124466,
0.5897800922,
0.0564409308,
-0.3703826368,
-0.0914872736,
-0.1564915627,
0.0228684042,
0.1170416996,
0.3955260217,
-0.0427956544,
0.2217087895,
-0.5064375997,
0.3098843098,
0.5091567039,
-0.335182488,
-0.5199220777,
0.7928797007,
-0.0411761776,
0.0493453816,
0.4521468282,
-0.0042825816,
-0.4024102092,
0.6846591234,
0.4994244874,
0.5744513869,
-0.0448969156,
0.11131078,
0.5234214067,
0.4352861643,
-0.3322341144,
0.3325725794,
-0.2380003631,
-0.8451374769,
-0.4823029935,
-0.2778813243,
-0.6149077415,
-0.1523384601,
-0.7258108258,
0.4972451329,
-0.578099072,
-0.1578152925,
-0.2685777545,
-0.1201878935,
-0.5707967877,
0.311820209,
0.2790905833,
1.0863933563,
-0.9546875358,
0.535615325,
0.8943583369,
-0.2104041874,
-0.534199059,
-0.2791298628,
0.2976507843,
-0.7358682156,
0.8386499882,
0.429708004,
-0.4339519143,
-0.0897053778,
-0.4996415079,
-0.8875274658,
1.1201062202,
0.6408920288,
-0.32153669,
0.1358032823,
-0.049413085,
0.3126817644,
0.024300918,
0.8525054455,
0.4186711311,
0.4885621071,
0.0506951399,
-1.2451583147,
-0.1377101541,
-0.3536415994,
-0.1470578462,
0.0546386987,
-0.6217079759,
0.7260986567,
-0.3612489998,
-0.3476758003,
0.0110123362,
0.7839379311,
0.7645125389,
0.5389341712,
0.6510463953,
0.8720408678,
0.484898597,
-0.0470096581,
0.9785068631,
-0.0929108858,
0.5380966663,
0.8255723119,
-0.5711436272,
0.8646488786,
0.5664548278,
-0.3458675742,
0.3023765087,
0.1272865534,
0.2985861003,
0.4555220902,
0.2085887641,
-0.2889012396,
-0.3814015388,
-0.136833936,
-0.4331332147,
0.4908266664,
0.467531532,
0.1676662415,
-0.451983422,
0.3351328671,
0.1042947099,
0.4009071887,
-0.3199633658,
0.6526325941,
0.1922777444,
-0.5300617814,
0.631603539,
-0.1303655356,
0.6327894926,
-0.629553616,
0.0662067011,
-0.1322362721,
0.1967037767,
-0.0391156599,
-1.0201132298,
-0.0675366521,
0.0111102937,
-0.0603174902,
-0.6033808589,
0.5527711511,
-0.2515318096,
-0.2328681499,
0.5621913671,
0.4189711511,
0.2555707693,
0.0758062974,
-0.7393178344,
0.3807589412,
-0.4612609446,
-0.3079997301,
0.4420128167,
0.5812171102,
0.045483686,
1.1471246481,
0.4048892558,
-0.0626721531,
0.0746138841,
0.3587275743,
0.7661932707,
-0.6573811769,
-0.3664673269,
-0.7279827595,
0.5129042268,
0.1085848734,
-0.2639379799,
0.998272419,
0.5902910233,
0.7587617636,
-0.0576119535,
0.5565419793,
-0.1464484036,
0.0603456683,
-0.8382376432,
0.7159509063,
-0.7426481247,
-0.0579210296,
-0.4683184624,
-0.7968077064,
-0.3724469841,
0.6708487272,
-0.3545439243,
0.3492914736,
0.7960497141,
0.414652437,
-0.5280017257,
-0.3636096418,
0.6644379497,
0.1138598993,
0.3662866354,
0.5495970845,
1.0479887724,
-0.5029776692,
0.3588705659,
-0.0837717727,
-0.4503751993,
0.0491709411,
-1.1724354029,
-1.1511303186,
-0.3165714145,
-0.2966497242,
-0.0773920566,
-0.2170244455,
0.6739284396,
0.9941875339,
-0.6484288573,
-0.5239478946,
-0.1524583995,
-0.0029639935,
-0.352391094,
-0.2140486985,
0.0173753183,
-0.3615715206,
-0.7917920351,
0.7586876154,
0.2063205987,
-0.0126383528,
-0.184597984,
-0.1653755009,
-0.2747775614,
-0.4140797257,
0.8878484964,
0.3820729256,
-0.8704121113,
-0.0961222872,
0.1253351569,
0.0684193,
-0.1482850015,
0.8464130759,
-0.9595005512,
0.7055988312,
0.4099513888,
0.5061257482,
0.2350508124,
0.1620611697,
0.6995577812,
-0.6409242153,
0.6152729392,
-0.0426443294,
0.5209898949,
0.3954165578,
0.0044208062,
0.2346122712,
0.2371973693,
-0.2626737952,
-0.8772024512,
0.2596526742,
-1.1349663734,
-0.1294285655,
1.1539654732,
-0.1289483607,
-0.0767595097,
0.1275452971,
-0.1218685284,
0.0549547076,
-0.2675919831,
0.483525753,
0.773219049,
0.4393467605,
-0.6200363636,
-0.6909202933,
0.0177598428,
0.7429297566,
-0.6290532351,
0.1247592196,
0.6189222932,
0.336492151,
0.0187948626,
0.505510807,
-0.1607183367,
0.3269430101,
0.034725491,
0.2701716423,
-0.0254958142,
-0.5937700272,
-0.6137314439,
0.1230677068,
0.2231238931,
0.1589823365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09033v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09033v3
|
MELA: Multilingual Evaluation of Linguistic Acceptability
| 2023-11-15T15:25:28 | 2024-06-06T12:31:51 |
Ziyin Zhang, Yikang Liu, Weifang Huang, Junyu Mao, Rui Wang, Hai Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this work, we present the largest benchmark to date on linguistic
acceptability: Multilingual Evaluation of Linguistic Acceptability -- MELA,
with 46K samples covering 10 languages from a diverse set of language families.
We establish LLM baselines on this benchmark, and investigate cross-lingual
transfer in acceptability judgements with XLM-R. In pursuit of multilingual
interpretability, we conduct probing experiments with fine-tuned XLM-R to
explore the process of syntax capability acquisition. Our results show that
GPT-4o exhibits a strong multilingual ability, outperforming fine-tuned XLM-R,
while open-source multilingual models lag behind by a noticeable gap.
Cross-lingual transfer experiments show that transfer in acceptability judgment
is non-trivial: 500 Icelandic fine-tuning examples lead to 23 MCC performance
in a completely unrelated language -- Chinese. Results of our probing
experiments indicate that training on MELA improves the performance of XLM-R on
syntax-related tasks. Our data is available at
https://github.com/sjtu-compling/MELA.
|
[
-0.4664368927,
-0.6400623322,
0.480642736,
0.6401571631,
-0.1027938277,
0.1308942437,
-0.6981517673,
-0.8220154047,
0.1719030142,
0.1541571766,
-0.1565159857,
-0.5407159925,
-0.8635763526,
0.5720542073,
-0.0392873995,
0.8170568943,
-0.3228114843,
0.027180532,
0.0116908671,
-0.7094533443,
-0.5407978892,
-0.4628446996,
-0.6132112145,
-0.2692004442,
0.6731287241,
0.4009633064,
0.5915017724,
0.3179042041,
0.3744455874,
0.3093462288,
-0.1559506357,
-0.1118581966,
-0.2385539263,
-0.1394007206,
-0.3599259257,
-0.8740590811,
-0.6236884594,
0.0146144191,
0.9059539437,
0.410357058,
-0.2616595924,
0.2286033779,
-0.0892377272,
0.8966423273,
-0.5360744596,
0.3652619123,
-0.9550493956,
0.1040524468,
-0.299439013,
0.0572026148,
-0.4455410242,
-0.4041006267,
-0.0225854591,
-0.8158851266,
-0.1325020194,
-0.1232411489,
0.5957779288,
0.0279411674,
-0.4816491902,
-0.2124499083,
-0.5210370421,
0.6675739884,
-0.6138472557,
0.6020777822,
0.5281060338,
0.4982337356,
0.2786652446,
-0.5392787457,
-0.7563784122,
-0.1635631025,
-0.0585647896,
0.1120128557,
-0.2288528979,
-0.0510587133,
0.221291855,
0.4154157043,
-0.7922710776,
-0.0646182224,
-0.2956662774,
-0.010817687,
0.4926406741,
-0.1585769057,
0.6959847808,
-0.0490332954,
-0.0827418938,
0.1823415309,
-0.6379270554,
0.177869767,
0.2790803909,
0.4205060601,
-0.1690300107,
0.743681252,
-0.1283548921,
0.7453580499,
-0.5106746554,
0.2012500316,
0.4837332368,
-0.7194809914,
-0.2933396995,
-0.2153976858,
0.6719263196,
0.153440401,
0.5134620667,
-0.2346172184,
-0.0132671176,
0.1864601225,
0.2746742666,
-0.4689802229,
-0.025429884,
0.0456960686,
-0.4439088702,
0.239917621,
-0.118001245,
-0.9569918513,
-0.0380742885,
-0.4008775353,
0.4417528212,
-0.5521338582,
-0.4391189218,
-0.0253793318,
0.0333533883,
0.2828849554,
0.1961754709,
-0.9973053932,
0.3555804789,
0.5280185342,
0.859675467,
-0.2923695743,
-0.7788395882,
-0.3479663432,
-0.0703966022,
-0.3084562421,
0.613673985,
-0.6886640191,
-0.306383431,
-0.257718116,
0.0977503434,
-0.7414546013,
-0.8227009177,
0.4021266699,
-0.5451803803,
-0.0955078751,
-0.1719059944,
-0.1453197151,
-0.3963323236,
0.4987865984,
-0.6169523001,
0.8282231092,
0.476973325,
-0.4083811641,
0.6529218554,
-0.6638355255,
-0.4177263677,
-0.1441387981,
-0.1349847168,
-0.2228216082,
-0.0226104558,
0.1307733804,
0.1257953048,
0.0937090367,
0.1345624626,
-0.4010152519,
-0.2836380303,
0.3615069091,
-0.3989616632,
0.7375444174,
0.3474879563,
-0.3507656455,
0.1542315036,
-1.0915542841,
0.0886270851,
-0.0860042721,
-0.5959354043,
-0.254291594,
-0.3738659322,
0.0320301093,
0.4928169549,
0.1073876396,
-0.532087326,
0.0980045274,
-0.4013294578,
0.3592975736,
0.5858393312,
-0.5811769366,
0.3767384589,
0.0196386836,
0.8023399711,
-0.0238710567,
0.0152254896,
-0.0522453859,
-0.7333541512,
-0.5656550527,
-0.1347325593,
0.3172396123,
0.8666931987,
-0.7585279942,
0.0347200446,
-0.0820566043,
-0.3047995567,
-0.5644644499,
0.5636641383,
0.6647258997,
0.132524088,
0.4071444869,
-0.2244622558,
-0.5559886694,
-0.9046316743,
-0.5788023472,
0.0207908228,
0.1904499382,
0.3933077455,
0.2396655828,
-0.372754395,
0.5451378226,
-0.1141218022,
-0.1566825956,
-0.3628308475,
0.1131199673,
0.2644162476,
0.3769235313,
0.9378706217,
-0.6721440554,
-0.886290431,
0.6525052786,
-0.7689692974,
0.0518191196,
0.4412748218,
-0.0692436844,
0.434530437,
0.3604977429,
-0.464861393,
0.166588068,
1.0804079771,
-0.5999388695,
0.474776417,
-0.3231146932,
0.397880882,
-1.1030967236,
0.2773204744,
-0.0251901709,
-0.4208629429,
-0.4876829386,
0.3016830087,
0.2883982062,
-0.0081823329,
-0.4242359102,
0.6113477945,
-0.3706407249,
-0.3244532943,
-0.0895194337,
0.289095819,
-0.0740510374,
0.4605278373,
-0.2837133408,
1.0237915516,
0.492803812,
-0.5535855293,
0.2042644769,
0.2492881864,
-0.4134443104,
0.8008752465,
-0.365971595,
0.1351691633,
0.003234603,
0.1193834543,
-1.0726695061,
0.1586185992,
0.3843966424,
-0.446034044,
0.5052623153,
-0.1441583335,
-0.1567574888,
-0.0996507555,
0.0141790258,
0.7820013762,
0.1444789022,
-0.4446926713,
0.7353219986,
0.1599169374,
-0.6730374694,
-0.8362631202,
-0.7445188761,
0.276096642,
-0.1717659682,
-0.4446763098,
0.1813197732,
-0.4670396745,
-0.3499564826,
-0.1276856363,
0.1464809775,
-0.1372749805,
-0.0306588411,
-0.0603984334,
0.1655884981,
-0.4310795069,
-0.3964183033,
0.0464939848,
-0.2122244984,
-0.0161278732,
-0.0373353623,
0.2954596877,
-0.3773571551,
-0.1461209655,
-0.2404420376,
0.102240406,
0.6160771251,
-0.0836524516,
0.6666855812,
0.7036939859,
-0.2654184401,
-0.0743390843,
-0.3595567048,
0.3295437098,
-0.3540137708,
0.1541880816,
-0.7887892723,
-0.859013021,
0.7446035147,
0.2222778648,
-0.001190935,
0.6934279799,
0.4530715644,
0.464417994,
0.8385865688,
0.5261490941,
-0.0725352764,
0.3505795598,
-0.0439110249,
-0.1401088834,
-0.8128983974,
-0.1348922998,
-0.8545966148,
-0.2089679986,
-0.6614750624,
-0.4712482393,
0.0341446027,
0.0717707723,
0.2670924962,
0.5990704894,
0.0758555084,
0.576264739,
0.2198179662,
-0.1145754606,
0.6287254691,
-0.1625274122,
-0.4392419755,
-0.1420685351,
-0.6076006293,
-0.3315107524,
1.1723831892,
0.364874661,
0.249482289,
0.4323621094,
0.0690854192,
-0.0042556548,
0.7469519973,
-0.6759247184,
0.3348335028,
-0.5083476901,
-0.5520198345,
-0.2081851065,
-0.7924345136,
-0.908423543,
0.5777837038,
-0.1520355642,
-0.8720210791,
0.0265625808,
0.1283449382,
0.0061472626,
0.1941641718,
-0.9321965575,
1.0330764055,
0.0079521351,
-0.021943111,
-0.3992681205,
-0.5559278131,
0.5354366302,
-0.3208853304,
0.7033375502,
-0.2660958469,
0.1122780442,
0.5171138048,
0.2152951956,
0.450597316,
-0.1203302294,
-0.3079477251,
-0.0212370306,
0.1094966158,
0.2431556433,
0.2637038827,
-0.2917548418,
0.5891611576,
0.3049824834,
-0.4662779868,
-0.6440986991,
0.7221741676,
-0.7996558547,
-0.1937541515,
-0.2749455273,
-0.6686406136,
-0.4413165152,
0.2767735124,
0.1414125562,
0.2874438465,
-0.384277463,
-0.1295356303,
0.2053191066,
-0.4705794156,
0.2876273096,
0.6553515792,
-0.7064458132,
-0.6438459158,
1.1033537388,
0.1890811473,
0.4124136567,
0.5329399109,
0.1099602878,
-0.3554005921,
-0.8216896653,
-0.8556243777,
0.328805089,
-0.6746703386,
0.2696209252,
-0.5791777968,
-0.1214839593,
-0.4383043051,
0.0011558485,
-0.3372783065,
-0.5277180076,
-0.0135028623,
-0.1016803831,
0.0237766374,
0.8775274754,
-0.0242285896,
0.0597384386,
-0.9170154929,
0.5099394917,
0.2350251377,
0.84107095,
-0.3708134592,
-0.6502639055,
-0.2548362017,
-0.0617042892,
-0.0279640146,
-0.4480386078,
0.2222554982,
0.1973229945,
0.8332249522,
0.2577130497,
-0.4735989571,
0.449178189,
-0.518321991,
0.6985554099,
0.0311018489,
-1.0535302162,
0.428011477,
-0.2669855952,
0.320261687,
0.6823953986,
0.2924011648,
-0.486210078,
-0.5860755444,
-0.3459922373,
-0.7271587253,
0.863655448,
0.2308863252,
0.0939998999,
0.1168243736,
0.3381160498,
0.5441092253,
0.2075461894,
-0.832400918,
-0.3804705739,
-0.0907991901,
0.0038159245,
-0.7039374709,
-0.2954556644,
-0.1594066173,
-0.2047964782,
0.547796607,
-0.2259413004,
0.0928898677,
-0.0435282476,
-0.3105905056,
-0.0524432994,
0.6372053027,
0.8935747147,
1.1632032394,
-0.2997797132,
0.2923246026,
0.3863290548,
-0.6035037041,
0.1377909631,
0.469186902,
0.1093959138,
-0.1023773476,
0.1702978462,
0.678952992,
0.2397848219,
-0.6724919081,
0.2529510856,
-0.4620638192,
-0.2557063699,
-0.0048282333,
-0.0453027599,
-0.0310108867,
0.1331320107,
0.0023775951,
0.1943851709,
0.0716715232,
-0.5633417368,
0.16334562,
0.3968770206,
-0.3256327808,
-0.6199342012,
0.5380679369,
-0.0274040177,
-0.0889171809,
0.3268200457,
-0.2039851844,
-0.2840189338,
0.576395154,
0.7032820582,
0.6367086768,
-0.5307417512,
0.1868147999,
0.3768332601,
0.4842684269,
0.2063184828,
0.4047957063,
0.0024646439,
-0.975885272,
-0.5908337831,
-0.6929249763,
-0.4968698025,
-0.0906727836,
-0.7108903527,
0.0658717602,
-0.26389274,
0.0178618282,
0.1211933717,
-0.1939259619,
-0.606449306,
0.1307540983,
-0.1133677587,
1.043477416,
-0.8070418239,
0.8626838923,
0.8533860445,
-0.239556998,
-0.7563604116,
-0.2998515069,
-0.0396387801,
-1.1089769602,
0.3108593225,
0.2522718906,
0.0706005916,
-0.0693968609,
0.105065152,
-0.673220396,
1.0562264919,
0.7033513188,
-0.4979056716,
0.3380229771,
0.1851915121,
0.5090131164,
-0.0808374807,
0.3027381599,
0.9029366374,
0.7047359943,
-0.1418604404,
-1.2764770985,
-0.0340276584,
-0.4687203169,
-0.1136703789,
0.2086257041,
-0.6636210084,
0.6914137006,
-0.1103853807,
-0.0059391269,
0.0245871898,
0.4384061992,
0.4265579283,
0.8201141357,
0.5344966054,
0.7071466446,
0.5631241202,
-0.007772001,
1.0413169861,
-0.3201276958,
0.2246287167,
0.8498207331,
-0.105385147,
1.0430374146,
0.3900365531,
-0.6208769679,
0.4948827028,
0.4255020618,
0.423278451,
0.1601387411,
0.0154108871,
-0.2991796732,
0.2126251459,
0.0994572714,
-0.466870904,
0.5573304296,
0.4523311853,
-0.3796827495,
-0.0749495029,
0.2124020159,
0.1651661247,
0.177631408,
-0.470525533,
0.6340993047,
0.356743753,
-0.9747763872,
0.4986171722,
0.0773187429,
0.782730937,
-0.654922545,
-0.017594181,
-0.2690657079,
0.2087253928,
-0.2670140266,
-0.9316701889,
0.6822713614,
-0.048022829,
-0.2113871723,
-0.0991878286,
0.5477438569,
-0.5850718021,
-0.4484332502,
0.7786349654,
0.7369485497,
0.3408104479,
-0.0910854563,
-0.6603784561,
-0.0054822043,
-0.0838416889,
-0.294809103,
0.5892850757,
0.4659640193,
0.2058236152,
0.504632175,
0.5917022824,
0.3792212009,
0.1003688946,
0.3745085597,
0.5497124791,
-0.7295428514,
-0.3953998685,
-0.8022735715,
0.1447179168,
0.4688684642,
-0.4658175707,
0.8687285781,
0.485509932,
1.0513406992,
-0.016303556,
0.8863271475,
-0.0500241853,
0.3475414217,
-0.8234472275,
0.6426670551,
-0.6085111499,
0.0997816324,
-0.4331301451,
-1.1062986851,
-0.537583828,
0.3347266316,
-0.2316478491,
0.3349278569,
0.9140014052,
0.5300758481,
-0.1866416484,
0.1374210119,
0.6542604566,
0.2754209936,
0.1882234216,
0.5214536786,
0.6041141748,
-0.1570131481,
0.7958145738,
-0.1459452957,
-0.312066853,
0.0343540385,
-0.869574666,
-0.7017597556,
-0.4140118062,
0.0029744694,
-0.4953175485,
-0.0104982639,
0.7456005812,
0.5377976894,
-0.9058304429,
-0.289680481,
-0.088523455,
0.1749763042,
-0.5965073109,
-0.2353381813,
0.0792360604,
-0.4746410251,
-0.8386335969,
0.7274232507,
0.3925914764,
-0.0325252898,
-0.1215822399,
-0.2152849138,
-0.2500601411,
-0.1505540013,
0.9383186102,
0.5305503607,
-0.6058309674,
-0.1907953322,
-0.0102240695,
0.0172049943,
0.2488424331,
0.9342674017,
-0.4267264009,
0.7201240063,
0.2992258966,
0.7620190978,
0.3752471507,
-0.1832264513,
0.836466372,
-0.6162163019,
-0.0331653059,
-0.3584309518,
0.5340733528,
0.2920003235,
-0.2523116469,
0.6743353605,
0.1746336222,
-0.6310978532,
-0.4824959934,
0.0160967186,
-1.2167919874,
-0.1319100708,
1.2517693043,
-0.5340082049,
0.0767573416,
-0.3030900359,
-0.3023465276,
0.1762420684,
-0.2674646974,
0.6166990399,
0.9943244457,
-0.1597051173,
-0.3745845556,
-0.9013584256,
0.31085217,
0.6525330544,
-1.1398943663,
-0.0259450302,
0.2320388407,
0.576417923,
0.1147778481,
0.944134891,
-0.2679169178,
0.422938019,
-0.0279850177,
-0.1455260813,
0.0790136904,
-0.4555721283,
-0.7916846871,
0.0302045979,
0.5822814107,
-0.0352680683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09022v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09022v3
|
Exploring the Potential of Large Language Models in Computational Argumentation
| 2023-11-15T15:12:15 | 2024-07-01T09:40:58 |
Guizhen Chen, Liying Cheng, Luu Anh Tuan, Lidong Bing
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Computational argumentation has become an essential tool in various domains,
including law, public policy, and artificial intelligence. It is an emerging
research field in natural language processing that attracts increasing
attention. Research on computational argumentation mainly involves two types of
tasks: argument mining and argument generation. As large language models (LLMs)
have demonstrated impressive capabilities in understanding context and
generating natural language, it is worthwhile to evaluate the performance of
LLMs on diverse computational argumentation tasks. This work aims to embark on
an assessment of LLMs, such as ChatGPT, Flan models, and LLaMA2 models, in both
zero-shot and few-shot settings. We organize existing tasks into six main
categories and standardize the format of fourteen openly available datasets. In
addition, we present a new benchmark dataset on counter speech generation that
aims to holistically evaluate the end-to-end performance of LLMs on argument
mining and argument generation. Extensive experiments show that LLMs exhibit
commendable performance across most of the datasets, demonstrating their
capabilities in the field of argumentation. Our analysis offers valuable
suggestions for evaluating computational argumentation and its integration with
LLMs in future research endeavors.
|
[
-0.5111200809,
-1.0978568792,
0.5131001472,
-0.0088292016,
-0.3795280755,
-0.0925933272,
-0.4792853594,
-0.3195707202,
-0.1037793756,
0.4850743711,
-0.2862749696,
-0.3579773903,
-0.4946540892,
0.15671058,
-0.4733911157,
0.8173570633,
-0.0632488504,
0.1241787001,
-0.4842038751,
-0.1351672411,
-0.6517167687,
-0.6650295258,
-0.6444768906,
-0.386261642,
0.5655797124,
0.493329823,
0.4675474167,
0.5110966563,
0.1317989528,
0.3443846107,
0.0994138718,
-0.0776175931,
-0.522723794,
0.3079025745,
-0.344404459,
-0.2720289826,
-0.169514358,
-0.1480058879,
0.6414840221,
0.4291940928,
0.0614944547,
0.3108831644,
-0.2679536343,
0.298427999,
-0.6550931931,
0.0707192495,
-1.0123142004,
-0.0990281403,
-0.6000808477,
0.0335583277,
-0.3314109445,
-0.1668020189,
0.0850557387,
-0.1719290018,
-0.1392917931,
-0.0952894315,
0.6350802183,
0.0690921992,
-0.2480323762,
-0.4290883541,
-0.7774869204,
0.7837800384,
-1.055300951,
0.0331645496,
-0.1842824966,
0.3601948023,
-0.258136332,
-0.7694752216,
-0.7592378855,
-0.2308259904,
0.3276302814,
0.0765403435,
-0.7305551767,
-0.0400872007,
0.3747559786,
0.1741400063,
-0.7266878486,
0.5279638171,
-0.0769782364,
-0.0592514575,
0.7496609688,
0.2751373351,
0.0944888368,
-0.1483986974,
0.0033439761,
-0.1109358072,
-0.7388381958,
-0.2367044091,
0.4352909923,
0.4135613441,
-0.1995515078,
0.6765543818,
-0.1546270549,
0.9537235498,
-0.1616265178,
0.211769253,
-0.2756716609,
-0.1236888915,
-0.3579672277,
0.1240101904,
1.1396491528,
0.122284919,
0.6370648146,
0.1177765056,
0.1826175749,
0.208304584,
0.1677062362,
-0.9847073555,
0.0839091241,
0.2899698615,
-0.2877697051,
-0.3408432603,
-0.285014838,
-0.950325489,
-0.6731541753,
-0.165856421,
0.1042261124,
-0.1495978385,
-0.3019180596,
0.1862439215,
-0.0316188261,
0.2611317039,
0.0908173025,
-0.7404867411,
0.3418945372,
1.0525993109,
0.8329226971,
-0.2024706304,
-0.1613740623,
-0.539873004,
-0.0634762943,
-0.8201943636,
1.1846280098,
-0.8073985577,
-0.3280193508,
0.1480350643,
-0.2670469284,
-0.0864068046,
-0.6890273094,
0.8820967674,
-0.5184428692,
-0.1369785368,
-0.2472139001,
-0.6752129793,
-0.231442526,
0.4572005868,
-0.5365033746,
0.8316350579,
-0.1055331752,
-0.4946846068,
0.3174829483,
-0.802365303,
-0.557322681,
0.4006208777,
-0.4187813699,
-0.2528389394,
0.2956550419,
0.0044777561,
0.615354836,
-0.9219138622,
0.4671800137,
-0.3952325583,
-0.1420011818,
0.3525308967,
-0.4797422886,
0.5528093576,
0.2491116673,
-0.2883082032,
0.157468766,
-0.5768185258,
0.0084194262,
0.3643383384,
-0.0170306452,
-0.1067937464,
0.2945700288,
-0.1394267082,
0.2968231738,
0.0250202417,
-0.6470218897,
0.1264212728,
-0.6091595888,
0.6871927977,
0.5119754076,
0.1924133152,
-0.24288176,
-0.0805172622,
0.5816313624,
-0.0775930658,
-0.3694859743,
-0.1708657742,
-0.5292468667,
-0.5096920729,
-0.0874446779,
0.3233654499,
0.516033113,
-0.3756963015,
-0.0144945439,
-0.3346666098,
-0.6404205561,
-0.1714614332,
-0.0962044001,
0.1266978979,
0.3467585444,
0.090121977,
0.1051113158,
-0.7978240848,
-0.8746842146,
-0.3926763237,
-0.2256108522,
0.0382678807,
0.476249069,
0.5695034266,
-0.0504237711,
1.0569429398,
-0.2578389347,
0.2041781992,
-0.4040185213,
0.4050879478,
0.3692626953,
0.0736194104,
0.5535950661,
-0.2822762132,
-0.4751079977,
0.1325085759,
-0.7185456753,
-0.3354315162,
-0.2437424213,
0.0971107185,
0.1747982651,
0.3840873241,
-0.7326079607,
0.188614428,
0.4511845112,
0.0523506925,
0.6544445753,
0.3036956787,
-0.0194053557,
-0.9526008368,
0.1246871874,
0.0054905098,
-0.2015614212,
-0.8951937556,
-0.0110140704,
-0.4184758365,
-0.2766001225,
-0.5117866993,
0.6654640436,
-0.1551591754,
-0.0175447017,
-0.5026581287,
0.1562243402,
-0.3033177555,
0.1986998469,
0.2191375345,
0.5456479788,
0.6372708678,
-0.2519559264,
0.6113717556,
-0.1543393433,
-0.4968600273,
0.5192160606,
-0.9527577162,
0.3498190939,
0.1547742486,
0.2812051177,
-1.0530970097,
-0.278007865,
-0.08642295,
-0.2615091801,
0.0482707918,
-0.2826275527,
-0.5575705767,
-0.44079566,
-0.3706515431,
0.4305896461,
0.1801346838,
-0.3900654912,
0.4185136259,
0.4247623682,
-0.284147501,
-0.3288392127,
-0.4219980836,
0.5453554392,
-0.545981288,
-0.6250696182,
0.2035249174,
0.0688534528,
-0.5828478336,
-0.3119328618,
0.3355542123,
0.0863811821,
-0.0354218781,
0.3842480779,
0.0751863867,
-0.5023056269,
0.0658302829,
-0.1144803464,
-0.0067271153,
0.2034623176,
-0.134740293,
0.8395117521,
-0.2514381409,
-0.3101515174,
0.0094962493,
0.4231476188,
0.6063420177,
-0.0767605603,
0.5441093445,
0.3275532126,
-0.548781395,
-0.165562883,
-0.6442247629,
0.0996863991,
-0.408816874,
0.4171302915,
-0.3410793543,
-0.8943010569,
0.4796090126,
-0.358571738,
0.4661667347,
0.617764473,
1.0861896276,
0.2971716523,
0.9545608759,
-0.1313503683,
-0.2303233147,
0.1769651175,
-0.1138132662,
0.3778728843,
-0.5053565502,
0.2499563396,
-0.7157480717,
-0.0368333682,
-0.4874679446,
-0.5761495829,
0.0609369054,
0.0306540877,
-0.5284972787,
0.309443593,
-0.227862224,
0.4471640587,
-0.0266155191,
-0.6930682659,
-0.0736652613,
0.0930255204,
-0.1010253951,
0.06970191,
-0.7185764909,
-0.7946872711,
0.9356857538,
0.4364564121,
0.3782648444,
-0.0219038073,
0.4774842262,
0.4414637387,
0.4267319739,
-1.0882822275,
0.6880916357,
-0.4592562914,
-0.558868885,
-0.3129344881,
-0.3305363357,
-1.0024913549,
0.3960340619,
-0.2862772942,
-0.9401987195,
-0.0316713452,
-0.0000949148,
-0.3671135306,
0.3978759646,
-0.3602687418,
1.0961925983,
-0.1726552844,
-0.5809293985,
-0.2678390145,
-0.1424231082,
0.5612543821,
-0.1639488786,
0.1865300387,
-0.1837556064,
0.3242332339,
0.8803167939,
-0.3443540931,
0.6583633423,
-0.0922804773,
-0.2908467054,
0.7357361317,
0.1333477646,
0.3706675172,
-0.133531794,
-0.4639202058,
0.5056455731,
0.2014518678,
-0.0100521389,
-0.3225152493,
0.7937060595,
-0.4628058076,
-0.566364646,
-0.3732891679,
-0.4173276126,
-0.3566937447,
0.1686024368,
0.1111299396,
0.3851744235,
-0.4963112175,
0.2758160233,
0.2773318887,
-0.4192854762,
0.5190426707,
0.5351652503,
-0.0315226316,
-0.3965013623,
1.0796723366,
0.094417423,
0.0672571883,
0.0767000094,
0.661270082,
-0.3784280419,
-0.7088098526,
-0.7574618459,
0.1884157956,
-0.5556669831,
-0.3203427494,
-0.5270684361,
-0.2677618861,
-0.4366019964,
-0.0092654265,
-0.4760953188,
-0.3975544274,
-0.155951798,
0.1231273115,
0.1974249929,
0.7978872061,
0.133030802,
0.2049666047,
-0.621560514,
0.2748188078,
0.2731051743,
0.2471745014,
0.270619303,
-0.3762646914,
0.0167383626,
0.0698679984,
-0.3656342328,
-0.872808814,
0.2608600259,
0.1762693822,
0.5207518339,
0.4688472152,
-0.0126221599,
0.8410918117,
-0.6277048588,
1.0706601143,
0.1598645151,
-0.9190565348,
0.2859142423,
-0.4009639025,
0.3438076377,
0.3806606531,
0.1591060907,
-0.6783176661,
-0.045640409,
-0.3561723828,
-0.677816391,
0.4492343664,
-0.0220323429,
0.2589541078,
-0.3233501613,
0.2281131446,
0.0241469499,
-0.0025243564,
-0.6671868563,
0.2555003762,
-0.0839701742,
-0.1019140333,
0.1059772223,
-0.2640954256,
-0.23402071,
0.0478656664,
0.4011538923,
-0.249873966,
0.0008870135,
-0.2193132043,
-0.0127147352,
-0.1746097803,
0.6140669584,
0.8910762072,
0.5002006292,
0.1247914582,
0.0827918947,
0.5621730089,
-0.172080636,
-0.0170615725,
0.0073965453,
0.0477681831,
-0.1221645772,
0.7114682198,
0.8431865573,
-0.0411954001,
-0.8867760301,
0.4001244605,
0.0215251297,
-0.4095438421,
-0.2777603269,
0.0021435218,
0.3646457791,
0.0894303173,
0.0543180108,
-0.3937618136,
-0.0053269407,
-0.6369625926,
-0.0805553645,
0.7490775585,
-0.1696924418,
-0.1508210897,
0.263379097,
-0.039936699,
-0.3048471212,
0.3585748971,
0.0365982577,
-0.4182318449,
0.6137669086,
0.6179178953,
0.9001489878,
-0.0282833911,
-0.0035083075,
0.4484559596,
0.0770169348,
0.0914951935,
0.1027386487,
-0.0689289644,
-0.7235184908,
-0.4579344988,
-0.5811846256,
-0.402302146,
0.5184645653,
-0.2340953648,
0.2386144698,
-0.4983363748,
-0.1633099169,
0.263632983,
0.0621943027,
-0.4228361845,
-0.1081680059,
0.4477610588,
0.7427498102,
-0.7829489112,
0.5811560154,
0.640676558,
0.1029898673,
-0.4257077873,
-0.0712630451,
0.1101609021,
-0.4313471317,
0.4935527444,
0.1217139438,
-0.5047858953,
-0.4224522114,
-0.5729306936,
-0.4927085042,
0.6453410387,
0.5681022406,
-0.7563813925,
0.4390946329,
0.617844224,
0.8204737902,
-0.5929447412,
0.4185519814,
0.675368309,
0.4537373483,
0.197779119,
-0.7106795311,
-0.0365330726,
-0.1150854602,
0.0077622207,
-0.0595768988,
-0.5644142628,
0.8073419929,
0.0038887607,
-0.3327555656,
0.0364350043,
0.5770508051,
0.5694622993,
0.2733990848,
0.5485672951,
0.4194884002,
0.3905674219,
0.0928490311,
0.9438192248,
-0.2663554847,
0.0221222509,
1.2009422779,
-0.9120311141,
1.0885335207,
0.1322488487,
-0.2226249278,
0.5295945406,
0.6461318135,
-0.0510959923,
-0.1148417667,
0.8653728962,
-0.2987084985,
-0.4243493974,
-0.3248677254,
-0.1648094356,
0.8061808348,
0.5162035823,
0.0268350653,
-0.3698425889,
-0.2809585929,
0.1885268241,
0.1262217909,
-0.1202943996,
0.8209440708,
0.0159651861,
-0.8932807446,
0.7470681071,
0.2548859119,
0.4477397203,
-0.5032581687,
-0.3068417311,
0.0628066435,
-0.0505262092,
-0.2029904276,
-0.8260524869,
0.281586349,
0.7288421392,
0.0421710201,
0.1129136682,
0.8077200651,
-0.0754680783,
-0.5732614994,
0.3141661286,
0.2294708788,
0.4217840135,
0.0045822477,
-0.696657598,
0.2928144634,
-0.2928613424,
-0.3134841621,
0.288374871,
0.2963605523,
-0.4630481005,
0.4543475509,
0.6803237796,
0.247960031,
-0.0039422736,
0.3893381953,
0.8510926962,
-0.4803950787,
-0.0886847898,
-1.2665598392,
0.2088359147,
-0.1300313473,
-0.2106010765,
0.5997569561,
0.7769215107,
0.3195833862,
0.0816098899,
0.8433912396,
-0.0077367174,
0.550976634,
-0.2808011174,
0.4195567369,
-0.1507296562,
0.1477387995,
-0.488578558,
-0.7373174429,
-0.2683324814,
0.5556851625,
-0.4621506929,
-0.0348631367,
0.282250315,
0.7139076591,
-0.0175749436,
0.2742889822,
0.4166534841,
0.2394121289,
0.6245629787,
0.6682502031,
1.0936278105,
-0.1901748478,
0.361864686,
0.1620409489,
-0.060613066,
-0.0586563759,
-1.3388388157,
-0.972078681,
-0.3599664271,
-0.2940018773,
-0.0357602835,
-0.109168604,
0.8435531855,
0.7523440123,
-1.0193026066,
-0.6978310943,
-0.0789954364,
-0.0213998295,
0.0040082908,
-0.2292542756,
0.1290286183,
-0.0905956775,
-0.4270511866,
0.7588009238,
0.2642868161,
-0.348793447,
-0.3854319155,
-0.0672942102,
-0.3970736861,
0.7034963965,
0.9259213805,
0.5292779803,
-0.8374895453,
-0.1494755298,
-0.3279049695,
0.2419878691,
0.0084871501,
1.1017340422,
-0.6291594505,
0.3940336108,
0.5594556928,
0.6794975996,
0.5300809145,
0.0980050862,
0.557749033,
-0.4875878692,
-0.0030561457,
0.19484815,
0.3816343546,
0.3222967386,
0.0134642748,
0.3743875623,
-0.1159272864,
-0.5302482843,
-1.0370910168,
0.1546845287,
-0.8465173244,
-0.3307769001,
1.1908552647,
-0.3105216026,
0.0151002184,
0.0278459042,
-0.1721847355,
0.2267256677,
-0.2139434963,
0.4853345454,
1.066793561,
-0.2871741056,
-0.1524796188,
-0.7757718563,
0.2294199765,
0.3778914809,
-1.0548889637,
0.6632671356,
0.6862117648,
0.0903268605,
0.1789346188,
0.3787235022,
-0.2224095166,
0.2055180669,
-0.0866837353,
-0.2373702675,
0.0148902368,
-0.1841000021,
-0.595066607,
0.4261367917,
0.1924754083,
0.0795808882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09008v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09008v1
|
End-to-end Task-oriented Dialogue: A Survey of Tasks, Methods, and Future Directions
| 2023-11-15T14:50:16 | 2023-11-15T14:50:16 |
Libo Qin, Wenbo Pan, Qiguang Chen, Lizi Liao, Zhou Yu, Yue Zhang, Wanxiang Che, Min Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
End-to-end task-oriented dialogue (EToD) can directly generate responses in
an end-to-end fashion without modular training, which attracts escalating
popularity. The advancement of deep neural networks, especially the successful
use of large pre-trained models, has further led to significant progress in
EToD research in recent years. In this paper, we present a thorough review and
provide a unified perspective to summarize existing approaches as well as
recent trends to advance the development of EToD research. The contributions of
this paper can be summarized: (1) \textbf{\textit{First survey}}: to our
knowledge, we take the first step to present a thorough survey of this research
field; (2) \textbf{\textit{New taxonomy}}: we first introduce a unified
perspective for EToD, including (i) \textit{Modularly EToD} and (ii)
\textit{Fully EToD}; (3) \textbf{\textit{New Frontiers}}: we discuss some
potential frontier areas as well as the corresponding challenges, hoping to
spur breakthrough research in EToD field; (4) \textbf{\textit{Abundant
resources}}: we build a public website\footnote{We collect the related papers,
baseline projects, and leaderboards for the community at
\url{https://etods.net/}.}, where EToD researchers could directly access the
recent progress. We hope this work can serve as a thorough reference for the
EToD research community.
|
[
-0.6148654819,
-0.9516481757,
0.6552459002,
-0.2560248375,
-0.3611532748,
0.3081094921,
-0.2785256207,
-0.6023005843,
0.3818108737,
0.4529054761,
-0.5964082479,
-0.2596022189,
-0.5728019476,
0.1841115355,
-0.3824327588,
0.9077100754,
-0.0016749545,
0.0393956378,
-0.2110079974,
-0.1651899517,
-0.4359838665,
-0.6499958038,
-0.7489303946,
-0.029356312,
0.3054956496,
0.4732682407,
0.0550887696,
0.2826581299,
0.2110027224,
0.4287795722,
-0.3251141012,
0.3054918349,
-0.5035243034,
0.5119979978,
-0.126944989,
-0.3133687675,
-0.6361893415,
-0.2977837324,
0.3037344515,
0.8595727682,
-0.2582083941,
0.1805507094,
0.0652279109,
0.6231810451,
-0.3227671385,
-0.1444817334,
-0.3560729623,
0.2910400331,
0.0363557562,
-0.5281696916,
-0.3285109103,
-0.0374255143,
0.3027279675,
-0.4414152503,
-0.0358923934,
0.1941541284,
0.2345978171,
0.0965369791,
-0.5513708591,
-0.2624682486,
-1.0501426458,
0.8094792962,
-0.720089972,
0.0812224224,
0.1900830567,
0.3216381371,
-0.2450333089,
-0.8639422059,
-0.4908197522,
-0.1577504724,
0.6239523888,
0.4239805043,
-0.0642424896,
0.3843162954,
0.1210417077,
0.4867955148,
-0.2244365513,
0.0201896001,
-0.4526397288,
0.3198908269,
0.4580067992,
0.3486104012,
0.2012771368,
0.0898372456,
-0.3604144454,
0.3151562512,
-0.46161443,
0.343968302,
0.0716905072,
0.0578427799,
0.0661928058,
0.6398655772,
-0.5930728912,
0.8566845059,
0.2034566998,
0.178074792,
-0.0017273495,
-0.6511041522,
-0.5133382082,
-0.0413509905,
0.6908744574,
0.873375535,
-0.2312152833,
0.018832501,
-0.159854576,
-0.1854481548,
0.3594897389,
-0.6575901508,
0.3315739334,
0.4607310295,
-0.8675807118,
-0.1581415385,
-0.3952749074,
-0.5607203245,
-0.1820409447,
-0.7830238938,
0.0686378479,
-0.0441761166,
-0.7409675717,
-0.0874905288,
-0.1013674736,
0.2146480829,
0.7264646888,
-0.4360459149,
0.5010116696,
0.9211054444,
0.9839237928,
-0.075977467,
0.1713321209,
-0.3834055066,
-0.1243755892,
-0.2620652318,
0.8231102228,
-0.8437214494,
-0.4927061796,
0.1612261087,
-0.2797698379,
0.0655354112,
-0.4502235949,
0.4129090607,
-0.2168310136,
0.4080570638,
-0.2450982034,
-0.4754284918,
-0.2346253097,
0.6406232715,
-0.3307898939,
0.835635066,
-0.1001446024,
-0.3618614078,
-0.0258538462,
-0.7943902016,
-0.1985475421,
-0.155284375,
-0.4946496189,
0.0714225769,
0.4921861887,
-0.0878024772,
0.3936990201,
-0.9251677394,
0.5677122474,
-0.1806533039,
-0.0574730448,
0.1432207972,
-0.2114000916,
0.8482175469,
0.456779182,
-0.5001872778,
0.2802622616,
-0.8179654479,
0.1003627777,
-0.2601499259,
0.0691882148,
-0.2061771601,
0.1298052073,
0.1335029006,
0.3731409907,
0.002094134,
-0.9566969872,
0.0079831304,
-0.2858732343,
0.7487716079,
0.788154304,
-0.0823067129,
0.2004040331,
-0.3821901679,
0.5284157395,
0.0463173762,
0.5321202278,
-0.3850106895,
-0.6560727358,
-0.7358332872,
0.0548602976,
-0.399615854,
0.3241018951,
-0.6820729971,
0.3577363789,
-0.1006914601,
-0.3403954506,
-0.1069564149,
-0.2036917955,
0.5509153008,
0.5952609777,
0.2616177201,
-0.6938349009,
-0.6940811872,
-0.5706093907,
0.1208753213,
-0.2898620963,
0.1898107827,
0.5497962236,
0.2651566863,
-0.002025394,
1.0010653734,
-0.1755745262,
-0.3151166141,
-0.5352499485,
0.1751264334,
0.2008515447,
0.4559317231,
0.2608067393,
-0.7895610929,
-0.7507674098,
0.397672832,
-0.7264408469,
0.3646318018,
0.0374368429,
-0.0907005519,
0.1465218514,
0.6328302026,
-0.7523565292,
0.3087859154,
0.035914287,
-0.2678011954,
0.4411770105,
0.1244199127,
0.1941968501,
-1.5767606497,
0.1033327952,
-0.1858351231,
-0.2459577024,
-1.0435595512,
0.0414081514,
-0.6376265883,
-0.115035899,
-0.1781459898,
0.2099504918,
-0.4978609383,
-0.1360611469,
-0.3449618518,
-0.0309089478,
-0.2815461755,
0.603310883,
0.1711521894,
0.3518331349,
0.6401795745,
-0.5247702003,
0.7297045588,
0.3977086544,
-0.1675824523,
0.8064060211,
-0.8537778258,
0.4507595301,
-0.2236192673,
0.474791348,
-1.2185361385,
-0.0530203879,
0.4735265374,
-0.697917819,
0.4298711717,
0.0432154089,
-0.0777458251,
-0.0929966271,
-0.4948522449,
0.622074008,
0.5591576099,
-0.088900581,
0.817506671,
0.425847739,
-0.6518982649,
-0.7133175731,
-0.419313103,
0.3974976838,
-0.0035111231,
-0.3948495686,
0.2184087485,
-0.2865780592,
-0.3995526135,
-0.2012489587,
-0.2572722137,
-0.3355615735,
-0.1031070575,
0.1546682864,
0.1752635688,
-0.2177075893,
-0.198288098,
-0.0445668623,
-0.0450327545,
0.3376432061,
-0.5855882168,
0.4599160552,
-0.0929607451,
-0.4029786289,
-0.2843642831,
0.9256467223,
0.4089156985,
-0.1637222022,
0.1401753426,
0.2949580252,
-0.3606140614,
-0.0614996739,
-0.6219575405,
0.0138312988,
-0.4183493853,
0.6028918028,
-0.0724411234,
-1.0545566082,
0.3659142256,
-0.5117981434,
0.5311931372,
0.1733130813,
0.6886200309,
-0.2825091481,
0.639418304,
1.0007864237,
0.268723011,
0.538382411,
-0.2184125036,
0.3148881197,
-1.2506071329,
-0.5957384109,
-0.5580466986,
-0.3901312649,
-0.1125411764,
-0.5452495217,
0.2764980197,
-0.1158303022,
-0.1721483618,
0.2672642171,
-0.7435995936,
-0.0436894894,
0.5046384931,
0.0585619546,
0.291210711,
-0.0847569704,
0.0595877208,
0.2812373936,
-0.4895531535,
-0.2635329366,
1.4084191322,
0.325588882,
0.281088084,
0.137233451,
0.6577711105,
0.3738338351,
0.009230148,
-0.6904662251,
0.8162127137,
0.3882558346,
-0.5938333869,
-0.5394274592,
-0.1197197959,
-0.6824658513,
0.0842284933,
0.4900253713,
-0.8594105244,
0.5497140288,
0.1233091876,
-0.6335322857,
0.282602489,
-0.3776729703,
0.601520896,
-0.2900036573,
-0.4026427567,
-0.3894708753,
-1.0280352831,
0.100837335,
0.3837274909,
0.1636980921,
-0.1063324511,
-0.0510819703,
0.6889349222,
-0.6864115596,
0.9296486974,
-0.3302154541,
-0.0827271566,
0.583614409,
-0.3913688958,
0.4032098055,
-0.0729342997,
0.265435338,
-0.2121053338,
-0.1036069468,
-0.1019550487,
-0.3093653023,
0.2981619835,
-0.7453563809,
-0.520770669,
-0.375377506,
-0.5162688494,
-0.3212362826,
0.0649823323,
0.258487314,
0.9331076741,
-0.2979506552,
0.1963031292,
1.0301519632,
-0.162326768,
0.7539926767,
0.2218444198,
-0.1853100061,
-0.3830207288,
0.9259268641,
-0.049652718,
0.3566313982,
0.53379035,
-0.1564008296,
-0.2746939361,
-0.8630222082,
-0.595610261,
-0.4406918287,
-0.6814207435,
-0.2252881974,
-0.8481044173,
-0.047999166,
-0.2445911169,
0.0829960629,
-0.4130394459,
-0.5553763509,
-0.1955918372,
-0.2126048505,
0.4708866179,
0.758967042,
0.083895281,
0.0256355293,
-0.5057355165,
0.3650086522,
0.2325269282,
0.241511479,
0.2883272767,
-0.4930026531,
-0.2654981315,
0.0005606131,
-0.3490923047,
-0.6030425429,
0.0826108158,
0.59739995,
0.5511568189,
0.5252873302,
0.3278264105,
0.6260913014,
-0.5336033702,
0.9459306002,
0.6671335101,
-0.6335053444,
0.4359538257,
-0.3192569017,
-0.0010146666,
0.6603291631,
0.3282864392,
-0.7249011397,
-0.3096008599,
-0.2923237681,
-1.1130077839,
0.8758923411,
0.0749778375,
0.3742522299,
0.0982394665,
0.0451364629,
0.3753882647,
0.6247861385,
-0.350330621,
-0.4456015229,
-0.3191584051,
-0.0594122559,
0.3138702214,
-0.4067779779,
-0.5273547173,
-0.3385359049,
0.4371993244,
-0.1472909153,
0.9103713036,
0.4545294642,
-0.099938035,
-0.2974335551,
0.6300724745,
0.5961260796,
0.9149801731,
-0.1413297206,
-0.196258679,
-0.1376856565,
-0.3424531221,
0.1283621639,
0.1287375838,
-0.0799830407,
0.122565344,
-0.0175585672,
0.9806931615,
0.0038751448,
-0.7966359854,
0.4876346588,
0.0370650031,
-0.3115012646,
-0.5966088772,
-0.2938400805,
-0.1046046317,
0.5473640561,
0.6192020774,
0.2324328125,
0.6941794753,
-0.9813300371,
-0.0078811841,
0.3833605349,
-0.6026366353,
-0.3664479852,
0.5318927765,
0.7010121346,
-0.2891959548,
0.3398434818,
-0.0764082223,
-0.4116705656,
0.7051996589,
0.4141428471,
1.2587345839,
-0.0397885107,
0.2386142164,
0.1938141882,
0.1484176517,
0.1235084757,
0.6438122392,
-0.6943014264,
-0.2741485536,
-0.7331447005,
-0.3394103646,
-0.630243361,
-0.0320521705,
-0.8295769691,
-0.2144165486,
-0.6123197675,
-0.1626496464,
-0.2650097907,
-0.2207106203,
-0.349352181,
0.1091409177,
0.2857868075,
0.8471093774,
-0.1717531532,
0.4276559055,
1.0899266005,
-0.1645785868,
-0.3338047862,
-0.216796428,
0.0736517385,
-0.4792543054,
0.4145877361,
0.268024981,
-0.0714131221,
0.1206476092,
-0.5048218369,
-0.7098630071,
1.1093217134,
-0.1442558914,
-0.7187595963,
-0.249704212,
0.2925504446,
0.3949905932,
-0.4613932669,
0.9081790447,
0.2175380141,
0.2663507164,
0.0325892642,
-1.0902988911,
0.127342239,
-0.8890099525,
0.2648232877,
0.0636694878,
-0.8069844246,
0.8563414216,
-0.0898238048,
-0.0099289864,
0.2840073109,
0.7258691192,
-0.114185065,
0.7581432462,
0.3709816039,
0.4481141269,
0.2644787133,
-0.0300069731,
0.7448799014,
-0.3457347751,
0.2753632665,
1.0852150917,
-0.3521260321,
0.831515789,
0.5882579088,
-0.2698557079,
0.1402690113,
0.660734117,
0.1471149325,
0.6221250892,
-0.0047951215,
-0.4443969727,
-0.2561175525,
-0.5765957832,
-0.6161142588,
-0.0224529821,
0.3810918629,
-0.1828491837,
-0.2084909379,
0.3583656251,
-0.3330114186,
0.0358846113,
-0.5826873779,
1.041934371,
0.392473489,
-0.6906517744,
0.3868059814,
-0.1656671166,
0.6944531798,
-0.6214200258,
-0.1800121516,
-0.1193049625,
0.0003003027,
-0.1791588217,
-0.6100654602,
0.1892418861,
0.0954833031,
-0.1163998619,
-0.4285376966,
0.7303672433,
-0.3076474369,
-0.0193327609,
0.1660849452,
0.6558052301,
0.1321391612,
-0.1211381182,
-0.5403150916,
0.0711484402,
0.04412622,
-0.384673357,
0.3163900673,
0.4801460803,
0.211825639,
0.537748456,
0.5479384661,
-0.331784308,
0.13680242,
-0.0667873099,
1.1000503302,
-0.6230697036,
-0.513558507,
-0.5605825782,
0.6878768206,
-0.3557354808,
-0.6301641464,
0.4422158599,
0.4918405116,
1.0260323286,
0.2063638121,
1.0094931126,
-0.7180044651,
0.516505599,
-0.1643877029,
0.264024049,
-0.5271502137,
-0.0843286812,
-0.2009583861,
-0.874861896,
0.2866093516,
0.2295971662,
0.2001041621,
0.0876226947,
0.7391906381,
0.1830951124,
0.0506527238,
0.2899354398,
0.2770293057,
0.2857429087,
0.2858127952,
0.7010205984,
1.1272096634,
-0.2111991495,
0.5132974386,
-0.2032260299,
-0.2338881791,
-0.4778217375,
-0.5551671982,
-0.9712637067,
-0.6974260807,
-0.0994579569,
0.0148247471,
0.2790490985,
1.3570518494,
0.5856687427,
-0.680372715,
-0.4521233439,
-0.5870107412,
-0.3155241013,
-0.4094368815,
-0.0728592426,
-0.0357184894,
-0.2451293617,
-0.7059884667,
0.3410601318,
0.4534007311,
-0.5299257636,
-0.1177743673,
-0.2335475236,
-0.1612108052,
-0.1990091652,
1.0123728514,
0.6217442155,
-0.9192929268,
0.1138180196,
0.281231463,
0.2800161242,
0.1895770431,
0.9348038435,
-0.551373601,
0.7250673175,
0.4146501422,
0.9679796696,
0.2489367425,
-0.2284823507,
1.0406602621,
-0.3678313792,
-0.1175273582,
0.5180521011,
0.1542500854,
0.0348582938,
-0.2994175255,
0.5621821284,
0.1752638668,
-0.5188611746,
-0.99314785,
0.409963876,
-1.3238637447,
-0.0847308561,
0.8735883236,
-0.2929727435,
0.1296594441,
-0.569897294,
-0.4011505544,
0.3701460361,
-0.6724048853,
0.5395410657,
0.4878988862,
-0.374779284,
-0.3856723309,
-0.8697031736,
0.3196180165,
0.6799809337,
-1.1121214628,
0.0227608923,
0.51815027,
-0.1725229472,
0.1170965433,
0.886365056,
-0.0710898042,
0.4914486408,
-0.2072950155,
-0.0905782729,
-0.4891387522,
-0.5073109269,
-0.0197736602,
-0.0474217087,
0.0841632113,
-0.2965088487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09006v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09006v1
|
Data Similarity is Not Enough to Explain Language Model Performance
| 2023-11-15T14:48:08 | 2023-11-15T14:48:08 |
Gregory Yauney, Emily Reif, David Mimno
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models achieve high performance on many but not all downstream
tasks. The interaction between pretraining data and task data is commonly
assumed to determine this variance: a task with data that is more similar to a
model's pretraining data is assumed to be easier for that model. We test
whether distributional and example-specific similarity measures (embedding-,
token- and model-based) correlate with language model performance through a
large-scale comparison of the Pile and C4 pretraining datasets with downstream
benchmarks. Similarity correlates with performance for multilingual datasets,
but in other benchmarks, we surprisingly find that similarity metrics are not
correlated with accuracy or even each other. This suggests that the
relationship between pretraining data and downstream tasks is more complex than
often assumed.
|
[
-0.2789960504,
-0.550051868,
0.4819985628,
0.147222504,
-0.2265437245,
0.0599411093,
-0.1701003909,
-0.516356647,
0.1115051955,
0.2727961838,
-0.4585857093,
-0.360509932,
-0.7028205991,
-0.078526862,
-0.8241621852,
0.8051912785,
-0.0850637332,
-0.0327698886,
-0.5500103235,
-0.235460639,
-0.2435983121,
-0.6869146228,
-0.4887133241,
-0.4463748336,
0.603128016,
0.1260852814,
0.6419468522,
0.8519012332,
0.647135973,
0.2807419002,
0.2297066897,
-0.3729076684,
-0.6657937169,
-0.0951349586,
-0.1026039124,
-0.6275033355,
-0.2363801301,
0.1153523549,
0.6444170475,
0.9934023619,
0.0634499118,
0.2150932699,
0.2208104879,
0.6080531478,
-0.5954071879,
0.2850705981,
-0.3561866581,
-0.136085242,
-0.447635442,
-0.0800453573,
0.0134252179,
-0.4118899703,
0.1606075764,
-0.5927087069,
0.5139453411,
0.4589128196,
0.988402307,
0.1288932115,
-0.3445413709,
-0.5324615836,
-0.6533511877,
0.7526166439,
-0.7141212821,
0.3928435147,
0.4093441665,
0.0695630088,
0.1419296414,
-0.403690964,
-0.698412478,
-0.2902205586,
-0.1225721166,
-0.191546306,
-0.0215854067,
-0.0442330241,
0.4979287386,
0.3880464435,
-0.7043467164,
0.3063530922,
-0.2954348326,
0.0939927772,
0.3943250775,
0.2795203924,
0.1748574078,
0.1334160566,
-0.3897756636,
-0.5375096202,
-0.9084788561,
0.2924718261,
0.6199118495,
0.5141935945,
-0.2493383735,
0.5096444488,
-0.1425992101,
0.5749426484,
-0.1996785253,
0.01413975,
0.5965937376,
-0.2453827113,
-0.168229267,
-0.0577993616,
0.8426424861,
0.2582059503,
0.5932815671,
-0.4253995419,
-0.1793213487,
0.0198273584,
0.1808007658,
-0.689456284,
-0.3028182685,
0.001915096,
-0.3522465527,
-0.0262218677,
0.2006977648,
-0.4399600327,
-0.04274638,
-0.48566553,
0.491235137,
-0.2142989337,
-0.3818219006,
-0.1361855716,
-0.1771892458,
0.3458756804,
-0.1660203636,
-1.0022386312,
0.5944500566,
1.133808136,
0.8988159299,
-0.5094239712,
-0.8243057728,
-0.3784396052,
-0.0321208462,
-0.5921164751,
0.7553040385,
-0.8012167215,
0.0041441997,
-0.0039763092,
-0.0041249376,
-0.4040032327,
-0.9010034204,
0.2528020144,
-0.4597991705,
-0.1191618145,
-0.5606352091,
-0.7954138517,
-0.0515992604,
0.0032041741,
-0.8786796927,
1.1438597441,
0.1878940016,
-0.9621016979,
0.7589748502,
-0.2136513889,
-0.4851412177,
-0.1890495569,
-0.4081611633,
-0.3177871406,
0.2638891041,
-0.2254700661,
0.6720190644,
-0.3915167153,
0.2591414452,
-0.76103127,
-0.6668981314,
0.0094796028,
-0.1238971725,
0.3827778697,
-0.0264124144,
-0.2988225818,
-0.2314936668,
-0.5923877954,
-0.0175778996,
-0.0395421945,
-0.1835350394,
-0.6083958149,
0.0101139843,
0.0014544326,
0.3561481833,
0.2116382718,
-0.3862064779,
0.1484756321,
-0.2489414364,
0.0351830237,
0.5522512794,
-0.556786418,
0.5455175638,
-0.6967304945,
0.4965054095,
0.1486266404,
-0.3994719684,
0.1152137369,
-0.2188914418,
-0.5832288265,
-0.0936009139,
0.4142594934,
0.3312963545,
-0.212703079,
0.160018146,
-0.7879010439,
-0.656928122,
-0.4858706892,
0.2794979811,
0.5272820592,
0.1815053225,
0.2053675205,
-0.6493769288,
-0.3907463849,
-1.0599542856,
-0.5223277807,
-0.005858745,
-0.0298279747,
0.1783566326,
0.3985836804,
0.1581691951,
0.724470377,
-0.377601862,
-0.096734181,
-0.1596629769,
0.2046245486,
0.190142557,
0.5272713304,
0.7903878093,
-0.4810867608,
-0.4447313249,
-0.0515524112,
-0.6595947146,
-0.143184334,
0.2282785326,
0.1896503568,
0.0952308327,
0.7807000279,
-0.419003576,
0.1314523965,
0.830181241,
-0.2297797799,
0.3662121892,
-0.3249982595,
0.2289369851,
-0.9105838537,
0.2930566072,
-0.2636685967,
-0.1394988,
-0.5760433674,
-0.0046589002,
-0.0283755865,
-0.0895851254,
-0.3010874689,
0.4712883234,
-0.2125868946,
-0.5858921409,
-0.1954142153,
0.1106097475,
-0.1638813019,
0.431797117,
-0.0162875596,
0.6448748112,
0.7960206866,
-0.7156073451,
0.2819130123,
0.0023882042,
-0.6874811649,
0.429046005,
-0.7207880616,
-0.0216015503,
-0.0391907841,
-0.1284270585,
-0.9458866119,
-0.0489802994,
-0.3312779069,
-0.2228488028,
0.2790055871,
0.1561583877,
-0.5349323153,
-0.1625759155,
-0.1679428667,
0.5731059313,
0.5354921818,
-0.38065207,
0.3180827796,
0.1166037917,
-0.3419411182,
-0.6271070242,
-0.8570836782,
-0.3333786726,
-0.5012907386,
-0.3401411176,
0.2657217085,
0.1784050912,
-0.1533876359,
0.0329669714,
-0.1834210455,
-0.3930375576,
0.2257753313,
0.3878764808,
-0.1483392268,
-0.4283560812,
0.3801786005,
-0.2202264518,
0.0294048525,
0.1946285367,
0.1602135003,
0.4971396029,
0.215004757,
-0.702246964,
-0.2679036856,
0.3487499654,
0.6250705123,
0.0224417746,
0.9306878448,
0.4736502469,
-0.147263974,
-0.0024105865,
-0.4500817657,
-0.074993372,
-0.4212372601,
0.5537330508,
-0.7623252273,
-0.8666754365,
0.5469753742,
-0.0511522144,
-0.0337577723,
0.2455778867,
0.2980909646,
-0.2868572176,
0.8591871858,
0.5482692122,
-0.2619688213,
0.5691818595,
-0.1421616375,
0.4107348621,
-0.4923266172,
-0.1814867407,
-0.9023281336,
-0.4128734767,
-0.8018035889,
-0.309111923,
-0.3854885697,
0.238277182,
-0.49617818,
0.5115205646,
0.19078812,
0.3179298341,
0.5215262175,
-0.4526131153,
0.2489716709,
0.0953117609,
-0.0120825553,
-0.0720894188,
-0.8088348508,
-0.4810742736,
0.9753721356,
-0.0228469037,
0.8554316759,
-0.047786817,
0.675057292,
0.0177763533,
0.1054695696,
-0.3907797635,
0.2104256153,
-0.4833322167,
-0.3887421191,
-0.3642022312,
-0.546020031,
-1.360896945,
0.1365656853,
-0.2852628231,
-0.5811499953,
0.0313546583,
0.1151280776,
0.0626599044,
0.1426311582,
-0.7251797915,
0.8675178289,
-0.0481628962,
-0.038284041,
-0.3099598587,
-0.2753700614,
0.0584521517,
-0.378307879,
0.5730127096,
-0.3227903843,
0.0655784309,
0.9354090691,
-0.4519446194,
0.5679443479,
-0.0231572278,
0.0109667396,
0.0261684731,
0.1507154852,
0.319565177,
-0.6488625407,
-0.2189889401,
0.1202743426,
0.2086870968,
-0.7274072766,
-0.7917991877,
1.0072929859,
-0.8515670896,
-0.4241710603,
-0.1018231586,
-0.3711216748,
-0.1495473087,
0.0299876574,
0.1943758428,
0.560516417,
-0.2224367559,
0.4080056548,
0.1783081442,
0.0968366116,
0.5170684457,
0.3251346052,
-0.0161462352,
0.4309360683,
0.838845551,
0.2653744519,
0.51994133,
0.5091394782,
0.0370126106,
-0.3654127121,
-0.3390577435,
-0.1331974119,
0.0339709595,
-0.4310071468,
0.1840673387,
-0.6096683741,
0.1032674983,
-0.3355271816,
0.0262078736,
-0.5891777277,
-0.3018687665,
-0.0341337807,
-0.1088269204,
0.3496923149,
1.2269406319,
0.0897792578,
0.3431127071,
-0.6962451935,
0.2526807785,
0.3373078704,
0.5638108253,
0.5038087964,
-0.5847145915,
-0.5412492752,
0.0809474811,
-0.1991237998,
-0.5506520271,
0.2740426958,
0.4313502014,
0.7036786675,
0.3528593183,
-0.208620593,
0.7355026603,
-0.5900598764,
0.6999840736,
0.0326518267,
-1.1350904703,
0.1192427427,
-0.0911222696,
0.0866396129,
0.5853892565,
0.721729815,
-0.1909787953,
-0.5131750703,
-0.7367865443,
-0.6474768519,
0.6373670101,
0.1625952721,
0.3480007946,
0.0615524761,
0.182545051,
0.2126523107,
0.3114126921,
-0.6904457211,
-0.3197247982,
0.0123570058,
-0.2233967036,
-0.6663165092,
0.2275500894,
0.3092068136,
-0.099267371,
0.2529675364,
0.0337932482,
0.2059887201,
-0.1993284822,
-0.1562932432,
0.0236072484,
0.2147147655,
0.4129376113,
0.6847221851,
0.0067491112,
0.2411638051,
0.3154971898,
-0.4532973766,
0.0856047496,
-0.1474699229,
0.485455364,
-0.0073716016,
0.9477757812,
0.9148204923,
0.4881206155,
-0.653647542,
0.7755471468,
0.1123449504,
-0.2305107564,
-0.0148733919,
0.3026235104,
0.4495744705,
0.1806485057,
0.2644328475,
-0.1967698187,
-0.092522338,
-0.7721700072,
-0.0044695055,
0.3605127335,
-0.4452623725,
-0.4603076875,
0.2492667437,
-0.0625671297,
-0.3802379966,
0.7720192671,
-0.0308485609,
-0.3911993802,
0.8379277587,
0.3032026291,
0.330729425,
-0.262891829,
-0.1330478191,
0.3882463872,
0.1277268082,
-0.3737387955,
0.2372519076,
0.0195204616,
-0.5508618355,
-0.6025955081,
-0.5095075965,
-0.1059753224,
0.201468125,
-0.8658100367,
0.2354216576,
-0.0427956916,
0.0757776126,
-0.0512812063,
-0.0349120051,
-1.2155579329,
0.4066560864,
-0.1769156754,
0.6656563878,
-1.366758585,
0.8475144506,
0.4349997342,
-0.1483843029,
-1.1526402235,
-0.0459694006,
-0.4431065917,
-0.6713094115,
0.8791341186,
0.3469997942,
0.2370684296,
-0.2378783524,
-0.1350821853,
-0.9466593266,
1.0349823236,
0.6163855195,
-0.8006418347,
-0.188277781,
0.4977926016,
0.646602869,
-0.6385210752,
0.3783561885,
0.5347830057,
0.1357756257,
-0.08574339,
-1.2962801456,
0.0158930533,
0.0172637664,
-0.0684504434,
0.2969017923,
-0.553214848,
1.1489095688,
-0.1299477965,
-0.2115824819,
-0.1982066035,
0.154987365,
0.1135729253,
0.2516551018,
0.452239275,
0.9241768122,
0.7057216763,
-0.0577989146,
1.3180456161,
-0.255169034,
0.5269216299,
1.2990247011,
-0.4328373373,
1.2184671164,
0.4184096158,
-0.4265375733,
0.5633521676,
0.5247126818,
0.0220315438,
0.5691255927,
0.4086059034,
0.2527283728,
-0.3434584439,
0.0931989104,
-0.4932811558,
0.6345112324,
0.1121841818,
-0.5179044008,
-0.261967808,
-0.1274053156,
-0.4119991362,
0.0756717548,
-0.1157101244,
0.8944053054,
0.1852960438,
-0.6209034324,
0.6842387319,
-0.3932515979,
0.5869176388,
-0.3597916067,
0.1380523741,
-0.0297115538,
-0.053227853,
-0.1252265275,
-0.7533996701,
0.5985375047,
-0.1494883597,
-0.2658235431,
-0.0933849439,
0.1166079417,
-0.3232363164,
-0.143851459,
0.621776104,
0.8205669522,
0.5837043524,
-0.0200635828,
-0.5124716759,
0.0716463476,
-0.2122243494,
-0.2376869172,
0.5303198099,
0.4656859934,
-0.1093055308,
0.7946855426,
0.4807540476,
0.2462635636,
0.2485550195,
0.3085730374,
0.6132006049,
-0.6101391315,
-0.3532571495,
-0.9430756569,
-0.0358927399,
0.040838331,
-0.2849390805,
0.5091501474,
0.7950808406,
1.1510499716,
-0.1842864156,
0.5241156816,
0.1957067102,
0.6275943518,
-0.4572085142,
0.5017458797,
-0.6490989327,
0.0189332217,
-0.2920294404,
-1.34676373,
0.2606284916,
0.5355033875,
-0.3885582685,
0.3541835845,
0.9841954708,
0.8929137588,
-0.5486233234,
-0.1693407744,
0.5851597786,
0.2001771182,
-0.000667775,
0.7450124621,
0.7832327485,
-0.3361893892,
0.3880821466,
0.0741601586,
0.0548338518,
-0.0650324523,
-0.9336836338,
-1.0440315008,
-0.8786571622,
-0.1537625939,
0.1322865486,
0.0610679686,
0.6957193613,
0.9087967277,
-0.8903536201,
-0.372651577,
-0.2338619232,
-0.1113316342,
-0.0606593527,
-0.1930231601,
0.4769875705,
-0.2332747579,
-0.7469769716,
-0.0372872092,
-0.163100943,
0.1800723672,
-0.0602550097,
-0.030356735,
-0.0205650609,
-0.0077129249,
0.2054219097,
0.0229868684,
-0.6780841351,
-0.2956044376,
-0.1953575015,
-0.2784824371,
0.0965992659,
0.954387784,
-0.6946235299,
0.1110708117,
0.672328651,
0.6698893309,
0.6128243804,
-0.0457823463,
0.6698486209,
-0.7827239037,
0.1439403594,
-0.1729908884,
0.3164791763,
0.5351240635,
-0.0089575797,
0.1362784952,
-0.0130868694,
-0.5757037401,
-0.5678117871,
0.2105183005,
-0.7606947422,
-0.1576204747,
0.9649894834,
-0.5976302028,
-0.1058455631,
-0.2460087538,
0.23669824,
0.3174173236,
-0.2420262396,
0.6112189293,
1.0999372005,
-0.0151660414,
0.1454090327,
-0.5958920717,
0.6375653744,
0.5146049261,
-0.628108263,
0.2372920066,
-0.0475463457,
0.6424910426,
0.1129811257,
0.4448184371,
0.2218768299,
0.0353557244,
0.202621296,
-0.1992692202,
0.1401970387,
-0.0611451343,
-0.354297936,
0.2413119674,
0.3193861246,
0.0259707402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09000v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09000v3
|
Factcheck-Bench: Fine-Grained Evaluation Benchmark for Automatic Fact-checkers
| 2023-11-15T14:41:57 | 2024-04-16T07:41:43 |
Yuxia Wang, Revanth Gangi Reddy, Zain Muhammad Mujahid, Arnav Arora, Aleksandr Rubashevskii, Jiahui Geng, Osama Mohammed Afzal, Liangming Pan, Nadav Borenstein, Aditya Pillai, Isabelle Augenstein, Iryna Gurevych, Preslav Nakov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The increased use of large language models (LLMs) across a variety of
real-world applications calls for mechanisms to verify the factual accuracy of
their outputs. In this work, we present a holistic end-to-end solution for
annotating the factuality of LLM-generated responses, which encompasses a
multi-stage annotation scheme designed to yield detailed labels concerning the
verifiability and factual inconsistencies found in LLM outputs. We further
construct an open-domain document-level factuality benchmark in three-level
granularity: claim, sentence and document, aiming to facilitate the evaluation
of automatic fact-checking systems. Preliminary experiments show that FacTool,
FactScore and Perplexity.ai are struggling to identify false claims, with the
best F1=0.63 by this annotation solution based on GPT-4. Annotation tool,
benchmark and code are available at https://github.com/yuxiaw/Factcheck-GPT.
|
[
-0.4996907413,
-1.0010868311,
0.7629865408,
0.0042483169,
-0.0138176214,
-0.0358847417,
-0.1111874506,
-0.5298527479,
-0.2170601338,
0.3037645221,
-0.3465238512,
-0.6932731271,
-0.6161696911,
0.1937263161,
-0.544184804,
1.2637302876,
-0.1947049499,
-0.2617770731,
-0.5378924608,
-0.1829968393,
0.0040608896,
-0.4726032019,
-0.2680111825,
-0.5355947614,
0.3517766595,
0.3363429606,
0.5512696505,
0.4172514677,
0.5254631639,
0.361854583,
0.1473395824,
0.3209946454,
-0.3738871515,
-0.0115585625,
-0.2230026722,
-0.3960055709,
-0.6141203642,
0.3409633934,
0.3541245162,
0.1953419745,
0.0412728004,
0.5929765105,
-0.3270980418,
0.2241076529,
-0.7148590684,
0.4473724365,
-0.6122272611,
0.0559545681,
-0.2287092507,
0.0910747349,
-0.3479236662,
-0.8460529447,
-0.1183267906,
-0.4208777547,
0.3439766765,
0.1938310117,
1.2118785381,
0.4071970582,
-0.2964834571,
-0.2920621336,
-0.5714784861,
0.3387659788,
-0.8616273999,
0.2155656815,
0.4853208363,
0.479191035,
0.1151024178,
-0.6806287766,
-0.8030260801,
-0.3663481474,
-0.3265468776,
0.2506665289,
0.0595142394,
-0.127522558,
0.4892939925,
0.5843721628,
-0.4459780753,
-0.0796667784,
0.0660406053,
-0.5322773457,
0.5654675961,
-0.018400969,
0.1528973281,
-0.1275901794,
-0.3180736005,
0.0542486794,
-0.5096209049,
-0.1354539394,
0.2422278821,
0.1827518344,
-0.1763156652,
0.7450737357,
-0.658247292,
0.4479105771,
0.0854040533,
-0.3003900647,
0.3637016714,
-0.5911824703,
-0.3349446356,
0.0608263537,
0.6610081196,
0.2498379499,
0.0761216432,
-0.3583215177,
-0.5253432393,
0.1753837913,
0.1262492239,
-0.8356584311,
-0.0216241702,
0.3726216853,
0.1049032658,
-0.4009346664,
-0.0031193676,
-0.5920920372,
-0.5708043575,
-0.3606299758,
0.5936985016,
-0.2393142283,
0.0687105134,
-0.018857073,
0.1826582253,
0.2124390602,
0.4934081435,
-0.4881264865,
0.3850116134,
0.7483460903,
0.7654586434,
0.0793710947,
-0.2051813751,
-0.8576943278,
0.2214021087,
-0.4142039716,
1.1496891975,
-0.398586452,
0.0762766078,
0.1707033813,
-0.0642370805,
0.2020451576,
-0.4910202622,
1.1080472469,
-0.4646216035,
0.0562617406,
-0.4694581926,
-0.6426098943,
-0.0383925848,
0.8505119085,
-0.5914772153,
1.1780158281,
0.0910528451,
-0.7967374921,
0.4875751734,
-0.5684661269,
-0.4263736308,
0.1236928031,
-0.3057642579,
-0.5566948056,
-0.0157110523,
0.1931428164,
0.3518523276,
-0.4553032517,
0.3954741359,
-0.2815606594,
-0.2263564765,
0.3431510627,
-0.4411450624,
0.3814513981,
-0.000331471,
-0.6719270349,
0.1568705887,
-1.1044740677,
-0.0861032084,
0.0318016373,
-0.6126042008,
-0.0034701978,
-0.2232133597,
-0.1624548137,
0.3008238673,
0.3239987791,
-0.8529485464,
-0.0204450116,
-0.0755609274,
0.0839361101,
0.55904001,
-0.1606989503,
-0.2543558776,
-0.3673526347,
-0.0308692493,
0.076787442,
0.1197233498,
-0.0239453204,
-0.1629637182,
-0.9789472222,
-0.3946169019,
0.5542747974,
0.5191234946,
-0.5599011183,
0.550768435,
-0.3390475214,
-0.4648509622,
-0.3255130947,
-0.0719555914,
0.4919373095,
0.694262743,
0.3695445657,
-0.1131668761,
-0.3193199635,
-1.1092005968,
-0.4009214044,
-0.3898702562,
0.0256769825,
0.1346534938,
0.7317067981,
-0.3341863751,
1.0424925089,
-0.3265589476,
-0.0875446275,
0.2548999786,
0.7044530511,
-0.011264151,
0.0613097996,
0.2576642036,
-0.4494131505,
-0.2493708581,
0.1413387954,
-0.7312208414,
-0.5098717809,
-0.1605499536,
0.1202189773,
0.3788962364,
0.2272554189,
-0.7818739414,
0.428783983,
0.3194491565,
-0.1457175314,
0.7655001283,
-0.1590372026,
0.479609251,
-0.4679890275,
0.2886359096,
0.0603267364,
-0.5276723504,
-0.2118244618,
0.0375055969,
0.211753279,
0.1632905304,
-0.1170737222,
0.422385633,
-0.1971406192,
-0.2642304003,
-0.1515431553,
0.4422584176,
0.0984160304,
0.3945603669,
-0.1938437968,
0.8260291219,
0.1472413391,
-0.3594861627,
0.4930495322,
0.238018021,
-0.3420716226,
0.7172157764,
-0.523648262,
0.0507474951,
0.0905007198,
0.5636021495,
-1.0733485222,
-0.4598940909,
0.1860718876,
-0.269048363,
0.0141282883,
-0.1951090097,
-0.8829636574,
-0.3423668742,
-0.4750248492,
-0.0565075427,
0.148697108,
-0.5002750158,
0.4499908686,
0.3426937461,
-0.1347324848,
-0.4141741395,
-0.5851460099,
0.3507397771,
0.2081484646,
-0.4128189385,
0.0691957325,
-0.0381152555,
-0.4012893736,
-0.128246963,
-0.3245511055,
-0.1372705102,
0.002033188,
0.1770706475,
0.1028737724,
-0.2348590344,
-0.0947911665,
-0.1037435085,
-0.1102321744,
0.2124721259,
0.0234334674,
0.2480980009,
-0.6551993489,
-0.7096431851,
-0.0834428668,
-0.0350151733,
0.6558359861,
-0.2971755564,
0.366899699,
0.7686250806,
-0.4602113962,
0.0407074839,
-0.9119011164,
0.0749080032,
-0.335514307,
0.0288771577,
-0.4062846005,
-0.7765532732,
0.5124787688,
-0.2809865177,
0.2377841175,
0.7024009228,
0.6717610955,
0.2212628424,
0.4994650781,
0.1604376435,
0.1778734475,
-0.207274273,
0.048071865,
0.3031908274,
-0.4910663962,
-0.2567826509,
-0.5849910975,
0.0389825292,
-0.2969597578,
-0.5603645444,
0.2991399765,
-0.0533076748,
-0.2114097774,
0.0306728855,
-0.0776489079,
0.5517685413,
0.3284253478,
-0.1566554457,
0.5320999622,
-0.2431340516,
-0.2079479396,
0.2722233832,
-0.2342002839,
-0.6493055224,
0.7947737575,
0.3415815234,
0.5015605092,
0.1841257662,
0.6065828204,
0.4105539918,
0.6823926568,
-0.5868184566,
0.5482214689,
0.0907749012,
-0.7134953141,
-0.2773538232,
-0.2720612288,
-0.2132736295,
0.2687655091,
-0.343732357,
-0.6476753354,
-0.0346758552,
0.0914408341,
-0.4905232787,
0.1937061697,
-0.5683000088,
0.6841113567,
-0.2487725914,
-0.7158863544,
-0.0615605228,
-0.5703533888,
0.6592082381,
-0.2934506834,
0.3455502391,
-0.2956389487,
0.1391839087,
0.3705104291,
-0.5549612045,
0.9787377715,
-0.0652787536,
-0.457880497,
0.3809840679,
0.0872616321,
0.7630745769,
0.2975825965,
0.0096588237,
0.2261089683,
0.0480470695,
-0.168207705,
-0.2793921232,
0.5964862704,
-0.6123203635,
-0.5271985531,
-0.6652710438,
-0.4878075123,
-0.4872472882,
0.2580702007,
-0.0728959739,
0.7035228014,
-0.3887305856,
0.0269739274,
0.7018361688,
-0.0924234465,
0.3362870514,
0.8387804031,
-0.2036941946,
-0.3752641678,
0.7348675132,
0.0684504285,
0.0067097708,
0.3520016074,
0.2284120172,
-0.4127258062,
-0.5255827904,
-0.5629621148,
0.0970315412,
-0.828374207,
-0.3062734604,
-0.6254113913,
-0.3091283441,
-0.3824704587,
0.2350081503,
-0.421816349,
-0.3958446085,
0.4386309981,
-0.179178074,
0.2196321636,
0.8596701622,
-0.2564954162,
0.057105463,
-0.6324257851,
0.5757055283,
0.4032272398,
0.6029042006,
-0.4074326754,
-0.4550343156,
-0.3999603093,
-0.0575955808,
-0.3025589585,
-0.3559525013,
-0.3102765083,
0.0443664193,
0.517064333,
0.1239031106,
0.0702233911,
0.3946599364,
-0.5922981501,
0.8911142945,
-0.0289554913,
-0.9892216325,
0.4220927954,
-0.2733215094,
0.2343785763,
0.7379438877,
0.0883800834,
-0.4282641411,
-0.4467833936,
-0.6142755151,
-0.7548481822,
0.5869756937,
0.2076633275,
-0.3576456606,
-0.1279770136,
0.2470269203,
0.3565264344,
0.2470834255,
-0.5953074694,
-0.1898686141,
-0.2560060024,
-0.1436579525,
0.212211892,
-0.3709375262,
-0.5977178216,
0.0691098347,
0.8381991982,
-0.4139943421,
-0.0825402737,
0.3636730015,
-0.3070561886,
-0.146494329,
0.5097129345,
0.6547691822,
0.8796491623,
-0.4226169288,
0.5420228243,
0.23941423,
-0.329138577,
0.1885567904,
0.3058061898,
-0.2902328074,
0.1331498772,
0.5010310411,
0.5531932712,
0.2733938098,
-0.4485735595,
0.597894907,
-0.1966403574,
-0.1066520512,
-0.0328567773,
-0.039945133,
0.0955963284,
0.137915656,
0.1098540649,
0.0852414444,
0.2972598374,
-0.4974450469,
0.3283370435,
0.2802391648,
-0.0141623197,
-0.3042210937,
0.5029535294,
0.3187356889,
0.0355070941,
0.1009551063,
-0.2953700721,
-0.526709795,
0.3600202501,
0.4280913174,
0.862659514,
0.1413490772,
0.3730203509,
0.317599535,
0.488843888,
-0.075228624,
-0.0292204507,
-0.0798816681,
-0.525988102,
-0.5705236197,
-0.6844856143,
-0.662584424,
0.3667683601,
-0.3544411361,
0.087436609,
-0.4981824458,
-0.1555576026,
0.1609686613,
0.2453457415,
-0.6661765575,
0.539857924,
0.4577887654,
0.8573718071,
-0.8152006269,
0.6376422048,
0.6734947562,
-0.6089839339,
-0.4688698351,
0.3342564702,
0.1652760655,
-0.7717641592,
0.667883873,
0.0880774483,
-0.4580664039,
-0.3992468715,
-0.6854323149,
-0.7027775645,
0.8879181743,
0.5127321482,
-0.6492137909,
0.4791514874,
0.4718291759,
0.4715364575,
-0.1191056296,
0.5606697202,
0.8548685908,
0.7594950199,
0.0178277101,
-0.9189843535,
0.2360331118,
-0.0778787136,
-0.1901362538,
-0.1683307886,
-0.7645287514,
0.7225607634,
0.0331889838,
-0.1346469373,
-0.1924824864,
0.627694726,
0.287750572,
0.3373422325,
0.5004497766,
0.8027153611,
0.9240722656,
-0.2000755817,
1.0753346682,
-0.4441520274,
0.5981470346,
1.3044370413,
-0.4512343407,
0.600197494,
0.2569268942,
-0.3774352372,
0.29902637,
0.5941953659,
0.0036573173,
0.1027201712,
0.3670864403,
-0.2208487093,
-0.2565565705,
-0.2053569555,
-0.1625279337,
0.1188574135,
0.2309903204,
0.301220119,
-0.6659673452,
-0.6155162454,
0.2510355413,
-0.0157274846,
-0.0622917786,
0.7043424845,
-0.2509900331,
-0.5620194674,
0.6689059138,
0.0022256963,
0.4431296289,
-0.5550590158,
-0.0661934912,
-0.3958674073,
0.1022948027,
-0.3633679152,
-0.9134815931,
0.1219678074,
0.3903732002,
-0.1981239915,
0.223715201,
0.7637562752,
-0.3968326747,
-0.3289662004,
-0.0050892127,
0.5135548115,
0.1191915572,
-0.0827602968,
-0.6505985856,
0.327855289,
-0.2574918866,
-0.3617373705,
0.1314204931,
0.7349581122,
-0.1758676767,
0.3906023502,
0.4213130474,
-0.0924694166,
-0.013832028,
0.4336867034,
0.7580472827,
-0.301935643,
-0.1570662111,
-0.8909319043,
0.3581789434,
-0.3729379773,
-0.3668633401,
0.7598140836,
0.8563824296,
0.7461402416,
0.0665306374,
1.2351571321,
-0.2735711336,
0.4393546283,
-0.3758690357,
0.5186557174,
-0.306607753,
0.1077037677,
-0.1872992218,
-0.7641143203,
-0.3643029928,
0.3319511116,
-0.5075289011,
-0.1039063781,
0.8838874698,
0.6855492592,
-0.2118533999,
0.1276926845,
0.3182885647,
0.5574845076,
0.4550138414,
0.1640859842,
0.8100953102,
-0.5008562803,
0.3835811615,
-0.1263350844,
-0.282649219,
-0.3800076544,
-1.0762608051,
-0.8174738288,
-0.292751044,
-0.6175733805,
-0.4002657831,
0.0085570067,
0.6324000359,
0.5122638941,
-1.0426982641,
0.0867249519,
0.1623447239,
-0.0417833626,
0.0962376148,
-0.1497245133,
0.4251181781,
-0.7113385797,
-0.3853397071,
0.1420546472,
0.4285681844,
-0.1082822755,
-0.2357249558,
0.1167157665,
-0.3197846413,
0.4172375202,
0.6471037269,
0.1577495486,
-0.871036768,
-0.7844911814,
-0.5680958033,
-0.3672397733,
0.1185230687,
0.6393768191,
-0.5980105996,
0.2476346493,
0.2432540506,
0.961684227,
0.5416073799,
0.2400705963,
0.2380930483,
-0.8837000728,
-0.2512659729,
-0.1124287546,
0.3897997141,
0.593337059,
-0.2254820615,
0.7264313102,
0.3071349859,
-0.5223519206,
-0.7871599197,
0.0013965807,
-0.8516992331,
-0.0239467453,
1.0655263662,
-0.4132989645,
-0.3914417028,
-0.0615065508,
-0.1720174104,
0.30717206,
-0.1913516521,
0.8646851778,
1.0359225273,
-0.1015074775,
0.2358069718,
-0.6976695061,
0.534937799,
0.1748208404,
-1.2518599033,
0.564150393,
0.6674131155,
0.3562368155,
0.3888812363,
0.4535254836,
-0.1836041361,
0.1151561514,
0.0789956152,
0.1976511627,
-0.0939638615,
-0.1809349358,
0.0091470443,
0.1793373376,
0.1151856929,
-0.0743460506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08993v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08993v1
|
When does In-context Learning Fall Short and Why? A Study on Specification-Heavy Tasks
| 2023-11-15T14:26:30 | 2023-11-15T14:26:30 |
Hao Peng, Xiaozhi Wang, Jianhui Chen, Weikai Li, Yunjia Qi, Zimu Wang, Zhili Wu, Kaisheng Zeng, Bin Xu, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In-context learning (ICL) has become the default method for using large
language models (LLMs), making the exploration of its limitations and
understanding the underlying causes crucial. In this paper, we find that ICL
falls short of handling specification-heavy tasks, which are tasks with
complicated and extensive task specifications, requiring several hours for
ordinary humans to master, such as traditional information extraction tasks.
The performance of ICL on these tasks mostly cannot reach half of the
state-of-the-art results. To explore the reasons behind this failure, we
conduct comprehensive experiments on 18 specification-heavy tasks with various
LLMs and identify three primary reasons: inability to specifically understand
context, misalignment in task schema comprehension with humans, and inadequate
long-text understanding ability. Furthermore, we demonstrate that through
fine-tuning, LLMs can achieve decent performance on these tasks, indicating
that the failure of ICL is not an inherent flaw of LLMs, but rather a drawback
of existing alignment methods that renders LLMs incapable of handling
complicated specification-heavy tasks via ICL. To substantiate this, we perform
dedicated instruction tuning on LLMs for these tasks and observe a notable
improvement. We hope the analyses in this paper could facilitate advancements
in alignment methods enabling LLMs to meet more sophisticated human demands.
|
[
-0.4966605902,
-0.6847853065,
0.7306091785,
-0.0131208254,
-0.32733953,
0.1284382045,
-0.4508824944,
-0.7776808739,
-0.6609964967,
0.1678023338,
-0.4948703349,
-0.2985775173,
-0.6769394279,
0.1214802116,
-0.5368818045,
1.2897616625,
-0.252789408,
-0.07297194,
-0.6560205817,
-0.1986088157,
-0.6560003757,
-0.3932633698,
-0.5235697627,
-0.5190207958,
0.3765208423,
0.9365873337,
0.3348133266,
0.7972915173,
0.5511692166,
0.100803718,
-0.2959017754,
0.2890171111,
-0.630173564,
-0.1208248138,
-0.0114777023,
-0.391467452,
-0.0649008676,
0.1716521233,
0.8187696934,
1.0386544466,
0.1461544335,
0.2075562775,
0.5333575606,
0.7473220825,
-0.8297681808,
0.0144460453,
-0.6496121883,
-0.1107915267,
-0.5623073578,
-0.1472320706,
-0.3951057792,
0.2710956633,
0.3543199897,
-0.2905547023,
0.0512241833,
0.2386795878,
0.8133622408,
0.300424695,
-0.6359567642,
-0.5983749032,
-0.7915675044,
1.060819149,
-0.5502393246,
0.3469246626,
0.3715060949,
0.0957838669,
-0.1307528317,
-0.4152652621,
-0.3897282779,
-0.3765781522,
-0.1133809388,
-0.2183888257,
0.2414914817,
0.0679552257,
0.665876627,
0.1576395184,
-0.3004955947,
0.4180034399,
-0.2699620426,
0.1911172569,
0.344955802,
0.40895468,
0.2430967689,
-0.0852606222,
-0.484896332,
0.1801472753,
-1.1435251236,
0.426863879,
0.1071217954,
0.1572726071,
-0.1518273652,
0.4191826284,
0.0265021101,
0.8705021739,
0.1935308427,
-0.3301609457,
-0.1478343159,
-0.1516548246,
-0.2177265435,
0.14041619,
0.4781535566,
0.3434405923,
0.0318493135,
-0.3015963733,
-0.3947262168,
-0.4427652359,
0.0423896313,
-0.6463729739,
0.2546049356,
0.1475064903,
-0.360804677,
0.1962823272,
-0.017089555,
-0.2775429487,
-0.1810407341,
-0.7073330283,
0.3741396666,
-0.4990980327,
0.3025459051,
-0.0845116004,
0.060448356,
0.432223469,
0.3689632714,
-0.9750029445,
0.4594901502,
0.650975585,
0.7207858562,
-0.5633144379,
-0.4191324115,
-0.4735281169,
0.2355545163,
-0.3839504123,
0.5245431662,
-0.2875281274,
-0.1762539744,
-0.2326783389,
-0.052215606,
-0.1332600713,
-0.7148983479,
0.4421503246,
-0.3484923244,
0.0875394493,
-0.4495893717,
-0.7191245556,
-0.0467495061,
0.094340466,
-0.2469002455,
0.8782752156,
0.0850802362,
-0.859490335,
0.5345694423,
-0.4331219494,
-0.7999608517,
0.1250720173,
-0.2665981948,
-0.1471632868,
0.2187751383,
-0.2549637854,
0.7650094628,
-0.6903083324,
0.2161862701,
-0.0907767341,
-1.0222132206,
0.3283484876,
-0.3130645752,
0.8305416107,
0.2173349112,
-0.5958449841,
-0.219547078,
-0.5050920844,
-0.237628907,
0.0794782415,
-0.5596955419,
-0.3941651881,
0.5155414343,
0.062555939,
0.4004123211,
0.3593451679,
-0.5004786849,
0.0179731958,
-0.4752699137,
0.5536401868,
0.8236889243,
-0.4131960869,
0.6593034863,
-0.3460191488,
0.2437883765,
-0.0033933024,
0.1548000127,
0.2463919371,
-0.0329284854,
-0.6659751534,
0.1315451264,
0.0585213825,
0.5442869067,
-0.5140375495,
0.269411087,
-0.3293925524,
-0.406750381,
-0.3354481161,
0.5467013121,
0.7001419663,
0.7974897027,
0.3460218012,
-0.143843472,
-0.462058872,
-0.9630192518,
-0.2509219646,
0.057512477,
0.0039954986,
0.3896602094,
0.5580204129,
-0.2043464482,
1.0714975595,
-0.226137802,
-0.2600387037,
-0.5601766109,
-0.1811765581,
-0.013977455,
0.4480868578,
0.3992434144,
-0.8207070827,
-0.568841517,
0.0471243449,
-0.690930903,
0.1257238835,
0.0284559168,
0.2778427303,
0.3630179167,
0.8048473001,
-0.5091633201,
0.2410552204,
0.3260809183,
-0.0487317443,
0.5528686047,
-0.1330698431,
-0.2592485845,
-0.8559384942,
0.0781317726,
0.2146156877,
-0.155131951,
-0.5444800258,
-0.0268378276,
0.414264828,
0.0174103603,
-0.5696448684,
0.579985559,
-0.4237375259,
-0.0303797722,
-0.2889051437,
0.2418755889,
-0.1266192347,
0.3262417018,
-0.3177890182,
0.7562147975,
0.4283878803,
-0.7803719044,
-0.0105743632,
-0.1241003126,
-0.5709241629,
0.3341453373,
-0.4354012311,
0.1566631198,
-0.264312923,
0.1950429231,
-0.8665630817,
-0.4250210226,
0.0958367661,
0.0813954696,
0.7099921107,
0.0023114691,
-0.5952507854,
-0.0866478011,
0.0120042823,
0.539201498,
0.5557794571,
-0.6761796474,
0.2121368796,
0.21934475,
0.1545764953,
-0.701803565,
-0.843236804,
0.0483322479,
-0.5444834232,
-0.3713890314,
0.5375159979,
-0.2848319709,
-0.4544089139,
-0.2669575512,
-0.2286213189,
0.0168139841,
0.5017912984,
0.1562079042,
0.0328913406,
-0.0661059916,
0.3171232641,
-0.0310327336,
0.1283008009,
0.1231578216,
-0.0145422434,
0.2659255266,
-0.1926753372,
-0.362986505,
-0.6391729712,
0.2916118801,
0.6798474789,
0.0097683575,
0.7064641714,
0.1511630118,
-0.2412739843,
-0.3845001459,
-0.592530787,
-0.1306678355,
-0.4066866338,
0.4800416231,
-0.1833609343,
-0.9149642587,
0.364150852,
-0.0992054939,
0.0556586236,
0.3757092357,
0.0795983672,
-0.5773680806,
1.1933321953,
0.701867938,
-0.11129269,
0.6670820117,
-0.020802008,
0.0805582702,
-1.1022474766,
-0.0951952785,
-0.4046058059,
-0.4356161952,
-0.4233664274,
0.0938808918,
0.3399479091,
0.1416091174,
-0.1632476598,
0.0767582953,
-0.3138539493,
0.6515518427,
0.3042345047,
0.0601998568,
0.1034429744,
-0.2355776876,
0.2318262756,
-0.0809004307,
-0.6012137532,
-0.4581626356,
0.8623545766,
0.196829468,
0.8768293262,
-0.1204839423,
0.4519466758,
-0.044847101,
0.1643723398,
-0.8011732101,
0.4584956169,
-0.3338751197,
-0.4715352654,
-0.3096233904,
-0.2983200252,
-0.7909188271,
-0.0704808459,
0.1361905783,
-0.6171267629,
-0.0771536157,
0.2140321136,
-0.2343998253,
0.073291868,
-0.7108921409,
0.8744143844,
-0.4775102437,
-0.3017370105,
-0.057902772,
-1.0167036057,
0.4028822184,
-0.1221200228,
0.2745298147,
-0.126496166,
-0.0292900279,
0.7263067961,
-0.1247354075,
0.9304169416,
-0.130903855,
-0.051046811,
0.039583452,
-0.1723677963,
0.5646754503,
0.0364878736,
0.0260185692,
-0.1298785508,
-0.1266333312,
-0.5048760772,
-0.5900930762,
0.7073824406,
-0.6505159736,
-0.5326769352,
-0.2563408315,
-0.6128461361,
-0.3538003862,
-0.0829418898,
0.6401001811,
0.5628142953,
0.0432552099,
0.4400447607,
1.002712965,
0.0527610853,
0.6456410289,
0.3677415252,
0.2483592033,
0.1569793373,
0.8216244578,
0.4848038852,
0.5837590694,
0.341160953,
0.0695643499,
0.0191125646,
-0.8800809979,
-0.3192097247,
0.048136618,
-0.8420862556,
-0.0508808084,
-0.3486605883,
-0.2433304787,
-0.2098175883,
-0.2715756595,
-0.2445224375,
0.044084765,
-0.6833572388,
0.202349484,
-0.1176573411,
0.9044992924,
0.5384953022,
0.2857395411,
-0.5930005312,
-0.1343584657,
0.2051003575,
0.287628293,
0.1942831129,
-0.8106218576,
-0.7804418802,
-0.1082035154,
-0.4532856345,
-0.3929826021,
-0.06719134,
0.3529030383,
0.5162885785,
0.4599379897,
-0.1003194526,
0.9239382148,
-0.4771270752,
0.5839089155,
-0.2126993537,
-1.0187125206,
0.3737065196,
-0.1766876429,
0.5995026231,
0.5002146959,
0.4636635184,
-0.6432515979,
-0.2807866633,
-0.3901415467,
-0.9197440743,
0.9136682153,
-0.1438894868,
-0.0137075866,
-0.1083799228,
0.8527356982,
0.2615180314,
-0.0458791442,
-0.6908882856,
-0.2113226503,
0.415831387,
-0.2483692765,
-0.3573993444,
-0.4262570143,
-0.0186768398,
-0.3257456124,
0.6228342652,
-0.3431583643,
-0.0641470104,
0.1676626801,
-0.5902619958,
-0.2651211023,
0.2821983099,
0.8220690489,
1.0827505589,
-0.1246316433,
0.0871574059,
0.5622745156,
-0.0948367491,
-0.0291349161,
0.0902690664,
-0.0652789176,
-0.43308568,
0.5785338879,
0.786873579,
0.654094696,
-1.0327955484,
0.6583968401,
-0.059412811,
0.0210651066,
-0.3604644537,
0.0611651354,
0.0652202219,
0.0217507277,
0.6146755219,
0.0943799466,
-0.054179389,
-0.5190640688,
-0.0875374675,
0.7584120035,
-0.5164864063,
-0.1477818787,
0.4376909137,
-0.1960796565,
-0.113157481,
0.7881066203,
-0.1662975252,
-0.1686544418,
0.5646541119,
0.6555364132,
0.5867124796,
0.1027852744,
-0.252551496,
-0.1843108386,
0.294593215,
-0.2511136532,
0.0117186494,
-0.191779241,
-0.4783444405,
-0.7153178453,
-0.5277560353,
-0.3631341457,
0.1192084253,
-0.5627703667,
0.3718043566,
-0.5210437179,
0.2867931724,
-0.3511147499,
0.0326221511,
-0.6869961619,
0.1827764213,
0.1128461063,
0.9243236184,
-0.7901984453,
0.7362985611,
0.6365017295,
-0.1735879928,
-0.7157371044,
0.2415989786,
-0.0081262654,
-0.3558974862,
0.9846090674,
0.418634057,
-0.0196223352,
-0.0963815227,
-0.7929646969,
-0.9733005166,
1.1084704399,
0.5694662929,
-0.6315404177,
-0.4885324836,
0.1302073598,
0.4674464464,
-0.4747265279,
-0.0459581129,
0.4853181839,
0.2487603873,
-0.1554950327,
-1.0111080408,
0.1113989726,
0.2214942873,
-0.0510632396,
0.2892922759,
-0.7764917016,
0.9463515878,
-0.1147286072,
-0.2471941262,
0.0332526304,
0.4987743795,
0.0096007045,
0.4231220484,
0.5466874242,
0.4689937234,
0.5156367421,
-0.037294779,
1.1681952477,
-0.1136357933,
0.1366809458,
1.1100500822,
-0.3725146055,
0.882579565,
0.6109880209,
0.1203317642,
0.3333362639,
0.883623004,
0.2756553292,
0.3207096756,
-0.0243641995,
-0.2190883011,
-0.3841360807,
-0.0606517941,
0.0518483967,
0.6579073668,
0.5174809098,
-0.2575474679,
-0.1561144292,
0.4210042357,
-0.2549813986,
-0.2040881664,
-0.297236383,
0.8408657312,
0.305609107,
-0.7398989797,
0.6073189974,
-0.1868873239,
0.6454494596,
-0.4756352007,
0.0793528557,
0.0022312345,
0.2470503449,
-0.1252959073,
-0.6551902294,
0.1408615112,
-0.2651308775,
-0.3043750226,
-0.3315619528,
0.6048774719,
-0.2245844156,
-0.0267325267,
0.4486001432,
0.3022883832,
0.1254230142,
-0.0625837669,
-0.4810348153,
-0.0374675915,
-0.1938854009,
-0.1515934765,
0.8907051086,
0.4941393435,
-0.1709627062,
0.7425714135,
0.2311205566,
-0.0892507136,
-0.1455962211,
-0.4109145403,
0.8071611524,
-0.6573489308,
-0.0962132066,
-1.1350830793,
0.3996737003,
0.1118977964,
-0.4482925236,
0.7108446956,
0.6037012935,
1.1728796959,
0.1113816202,
0.6880266666,
-0.1118550301,
0.3911525607,
-0.7239183784,
0.5164488554,
-0.9552800655,
0.3285955191,
-0.0433470979,
-0.9095070958,
-0.2750895321,
0.0222372077,
-0.3047130704,
-0.073086217,
0.8704866767,
0.3672597706,
-0.1511546224,
-0.2545782924,
0.2838441133,
0.09493348,
0.3100372553,
0.6724465489,
0.9122849703,
-0.1654915512,
0.7506129146,
-0.3553396761,
-0.1089599952,
-0.5081067085,
-0.7898316383,
-0.8872838616,
-0.7368612289,
0.0060324222,
-0.0807067901,
0.163968876,
1.2091143131,
0.7544400692,
-0.5998754501,
-0.4240823388,
-0.1207149848,
0.3099287748,
-0.1872549951,
-0.2072321326,
0.2834213078,
-0.7498688698,
-0.7783047557,
0.5413906574,
0.3840807378,
0.1640995145,
-0.0078684185,
-0.0620914698,
-0.1798547655,
-0.4694718122,
0.4997271299,
0.4730826616,
-0.9484055042,
-0.3443126976,
-0.1774855852,
-0.3765830398,
0.1373480409,
0.8262546062,
-0.5551416278,
0.1133415848,
0.3438465893,
0.7724137902,
0.1157233715,
-0.1505669951,
0.4773584604,
-0.9292045236,
-0.1141362712,
0.1993196607,
0.3864171803,
0.3866008818,
-0.5090630054,
0.0564540625,
0.0506490692,
-0.9959053397,
-0.7807685137,
0.2253406346,
-0.7972136736,
-0.4442503154,
1.0686560869,
0.0967663825,
-0.2793571651,
-0.2721694708,
-0.2357383817,
0.1699002236,
-0.1879971623,
0.9085528851,
0.9692885876,
-0.4745828807,
0.0073174154,
-0.7436429262,
0.8882008791,
0.5638595223,
-0.5562174916,
0.18941468,
0.2391269952,
0.3321477473,
-0.0167161189,
0.273489058,
0.2453108877,
0.3891595304,
-0.7028529644,
-0.2635422349,
0.2827856541,
-0.343483597,
-0.389170289,
0.1507383734,
0.5820362568,
0.2147761583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08982v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08982v1
|
SentAlign: Accurate and Scalable Sentence Alignment
| 2023-11-15T14:15:41 | 2023-11-15T14:15:41 |
Steinþór Steingrímsson, Hrafn Loftsson, Andy Way
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present SentAlign, an accurate sentence alignment tool designed to handle
very large parallel document pairs. Given user-defined parameters, the
alignment algorithm evaluates all possible alignment paths in fairly large
documents of thousands of sentences and uses a divide-and-conquer approach to
align documents containing tens of thousands of sentences. The scoring function
is based on LaBSE bilingual sentence representations. SentAlign outperforms
five other sentence alignment tools when evaluated on two different evaluation
sets, German-French and English-Icelandic, and on a downstream machine
translation task.
|
[
0.1377441883,
-0.6576775908,
0.6530445814,
0.6825011373,
-0.1510710269,
0.2530694306,
-0.2685194314,
-0.2193686366,
0.3387571871,
0.2218047529,
-0.7757629156,
-0.4102954566,
-0.7234377265,
0.1664580703,
-0.3265878558,
0.8726443648,
-0.3209634125,
0.3615570664,
-0.356423676,
-0.6392455101,
-0.7905182242,
0.0930294096,
-0.3927308321,
-0.2999241054,
0.5234809518,
0.759092629,
1.1787278652,
0.7212175727,
1.159158349,
0.3635659218,
0.1523853838,
-0.0702455491,
-0.3774504364,
0.4939745665,
-0.2057503313,
-0.5544549823,
-0.4664466679,
0.0766859353,
0.8973263502,
0.7878931761,
-0.1927006245,
0.1498189867,
-0.2693826556,
0.7727423906,
-0.3534601629,
-0.2841031551,
-0.2110919207,
0.0082123717,
-0.726139605,
0.0371708088,
-0.182953015,
-0.8675055504,
0.0281263739,
-0.9902137518,
-0.1241655052,
0.3277060986,
0.9796717763,
0.6861419082,
-0.5253285766,
-0.3518028259,
-0.3557306826,
0.8715904355,
-0.5311371684,
0.4137935042,
0.1328914464,
0.6215639114,
-0.1471925378,
-0.8875863552,
-0.4226108491,
0.3277780116,
-0.3476729393,
0.4541516006,
-0.1138625145,
-0.1588146985,
0.4288850129,
0.4682075679,
-1.3322728872,
0.3099989295,
-0.2482000291,
-0.156561926,
0.5171377659,
0.3239314258,
0.6266936064,
-0.0678169504,
-0.3862151504,
-0.3227676749,
-0.6188738942,
-0.2674626112,
0.4563073814,
-0.0236769468,
-0.0374941751,
0.8184779286,
0.0341875553,
1.0843262672,
0.4739503562,
0.0830829218,
0.3147240281,
-0.2679400742,
-0.4046637416,
0.5592577457,
1.1236279011,
0.7694564462,
0.1721003801,
-0.1685374826,
-0.1539415121,
-0.0001131785,
0.3543013036,
-0.5166128874,
0.1824824512,
0.4076514542,
-0.2536919415,
-0.2232256681,
-0.0719319955,
-0.6070995927,
-0.2874122262,
-0.358840704,
0.1948068291,
-0.4982837737,
0.257119149,
0.2379697412,
-0.3228371143,
0.2898629904,
0.2538017035,
-0.8947142959,
0.1128576919,
0.9738785028,
1.1974622011,
-0.1179062128,
-0.6574855447,
-0.9988182187,
0.0304072611,
-0.2958565354,
0.847943604,
-0.6611050963,
-0.0537284911,
0.0701020956,
0.0289420262,
-0.5279582739,
-0.3883116543,
0.78213346,
-0.5094394684,
0.7913658023,
-0.0417509452,
-0.8442571759,
-0.1087036133,
0.5099253654,
-0.9671686292,
0.8686241508,
0.4633634686,
-0.9697229266,
0.2573804259,
-0.7428418994,
-0.5102540255,
0.2806366384,
0.1000177637,
-0.3485033214,
-0.1634467989,
0.5410211682,
0.3208917677,
-0.1993742287,
0.4400136471,
-0.2202902138,
-0.6185379028,
0.2529612184,
-0.2369150817,
1.083722949,
0.2174887061,
-0.2357861996,
0.4902138114,
-0.4776551127,
0.0870197043,
-0.3604639471,
-0.4710282385,
-0.1822931468,
-0.3381029367,
0.3786283731,
0.0112280576,
0.5614497662,
-0.6193175912,
0.4067193568,
-0.7394710779,
0.3776027262,
0.4042520225,
-0.276450932,
0.7741787434,
-0.4958786368,
0.939443171,
-0.2598980963,
0.0634123832,
0.1403484792,
-0.3893198073,
-0.530908525,
-0.1540962607,
0.4594258666,
0.9178048968,
-0.5205423832,
0.7646403313,
-0.8095827699,
-0.6127238274,
-0.7827311754,
0.0952406451,
0.5176478624,
0.294403106,
0.094080016,
-0.0000647746,
-0.3284963965,
-0.8643335104,
-0.6535692215,
0.0110622374,
0.1566122919,
-0.1408663243,
0.1412512362,
-0.0263490509,
0.5617869496,
-0.6399282217,
-0.2566319406,
0.0492356531,
0.4808484614,
0.1961020529,
0.6529340744,
0.5992481112,
-0.6442950964,
-0.8364998698,
0.2208625227,
-0.8655824661,
-0.1914768219,
-0.4501193762,
-0.4273482263,
0.0357632749,
0.7666154504,
-0.7769232392,
-0.0222010612,
0.8252758384,
-0.5942819715,
0.3395577669,
-0.2599123716,
0.4331744313,
-1.4014815092,
0.2179593146,
0.0647466779,
-0.8145326972,
-0.1627663821,
0.1222798526,
0.3634482622,
-0.3672114313,
-0.3355278671,
0.2017443776,
-0.5411421061,
-0.1318380982,
0.0737073496,
0.3744860291,
0.0118861794,
0.094865419,
-0.1345223933,
0.8941790462,
0.4077346623,
0.2244344354,
0.8569713831,
0.4916468561,
-0.5647842884,
1.3716095686,
-0.6661714315,
0.2407912165,
0.058178667,
0.1819617748,
-0.9327216744,
-0.4377504289,
0.1554885954,
-0.3668602705,
0.3383933902,
0.3189769089,
-0.609172225,
-0.4984394014,
-0.2175851464,
0.6290439367,
-0.0113708153,
-0.5246737599,
0.3892956078,
0.0632190704,
-0.4967183173,
-0.6412377357,
-0.5503189564,
0.2942582965,
-0.4271852672,
-1.0707377195,
0.353474319,
-0.1684310436,
-0.2635910213,
0.0260756481,
0.1440418214,
-0.0635328889,
-0.27886343,
0.4589945078,
0.1207573339,
-0.4610234201,
0.3794632852,
0.3086192012,
-0.181845054,
-0.3840070963,
-0.2403875589,
0.514348805,
-0.2568687201,
-0.2709098458,
-0.3619120121,
0.6266392469,
1.279453516,
-0.1922806203,
0.6801995635,
0.6517576575,
-0.4298551083,
0.2535433769,
-0.5503079891,
0.2845481634,
-0.4215247035,
0.1744756848,
-0.3897461593,
-0.897525847,
0.3893630207,
-0.0041605723,
0.2858364582,
0.482475698,
0.4133790433,
-0.1129053086,
1.0641577244,
0.5807537436,
-0.2278257161,
0.0727508217,
0.4492313266,
0.3753151596,
-0.6822209358,
-0.136159271,
-0.5165196061,
-0.774150908,
-0.3493920565,
-0.1236940399,
-0.0181553438,
0.0227284785,
-0.3372539282,
0.8828281164,
-0.7013274431,
0.6010341048,
0.7367542982,
-0.1026252359,
0.0803719684,
-0.2843291163,
-0.1191339046,
-0.3131628931,
-0.4004630446,
-0.4719178677,
0.951408267,
0.0975825638,
0.5361107588,
0.2361283153,
0.4914807677,
0.19059214,
0.1602088511,
-0.9530727267,
0.336928308,
-0.2829041481,
-0.6803730726,
-0.4155128598,
-0.2498760521,
-0.9779013991,
-0.0779151991,
-0.2018964738,
-0.6574047804,
-0.0778106302,
-0.1380252689,
-0.5642908812,
-0.0494746305,
-0.8473803997,
1.2305604219,
-0.4885790348,
0.0860472992,
-0.135456264,
-0.7973821759,
0.1590582877,
-0.4064985812,
-0.2207414061,
0.0454529934,
0.1352621913,
1.0840444565,
-0.5647398233,
0.2686786056,
0.214853406,
0.2337234616,
-0.3146634102,
0.0783419833,
0.3425403535,
-0.1949829608,
-0.1633956134,
-0.1648738533,
0.0971313193,
-0.3527764976,
-0.9131446481,
1.2415047884,
-0.491489619,
-0.4770227373,
-0.4793227315,
-1.1306247711,
-0.0380927138,
0.4489691556,
0.4372448027,
0.3056973219,
-0.3924348652,
0.203941673,
0.1833817214,
-0.0031298927,
0.5994406343,
0.4309539199,
0.0302808192,
-0.8209698796,
0.6283307076,
0.0868332833,
-0.0947162881,
0.5349909663,
0.0329514556,
-0.4904994071,
0.0057790894,
-0.8339009881,
0.4866595268,
-0.6500622034,
-0.3588554263,
-0.4698318839,
0.1053243056,
-0.4892304242,
-0.8505421877,
-0.3197205961,
-0.7137682438,
-0.1774498075,
-0.2413468659,
0.3157284856,
0.6983651519,
0.1414791495,
0.7927654982,
-1.035104394,
-0.1828218997,
-0.019217588,
0.3171967566,
-0.7830071449,
-0.221040979,
-0.0019221462,
-0.1671839803,
-0.2905599773,
-0.8905801177,
0.2719805837,
-0.0324044712,
0.3226787448,
0.6438791156,
-0.1749931127,
0.7193225622,
-0.4346312881,
0.792716682,
0.5909525156,
-0.9800969362,
0.6515123248,
-0.4979503155,
0.8889716268,
0.8213762641,
0.526771605,
-0.759326756,
-0.3723552227,
-0.5745380521,
-0.4316014647,
0.7783225179,
0.2768969238,
-0.2904147804,
0.2941989303,
0.1585983187,
0.0476047844,
-0.0409553498,
-0.4792417884,
0.1363508552,
-0.0675321743,
-1.1492840052,
-0.31962201,
0.0815568641,
-0.3153320551,
-0.0436243489,
0.504221797,
0.0605395585,
-0.0411211997,
-0.0781807676,
-0.4748484492,
-0.4346940219,
0.1328455657,
0.7927619219,
0.6958132982,
-0.2518180609,
-0.0781843439,
-0.2421565205,
-0.6239620447,
0.3162434399,
0.5712867975,
-0.0394078866,
0.1510890126,
0.4420079589,
0.6721283793,
0.0865678117,
-0.6225805879,
0.8764887452,
-0.1302094907,
-0.2647637725,
-0.0665936619,
-0.2847633362,
0.3287701011,
0.3665708899,
-0.3773795366,
0.224328801,
-0.0443064831,
-0.2227006704,
0.236163348,
0.2761704624,
-0.8750729561,
-0.12034747,
0.7908304334,
0.3410142958,
-0.6249108911,
1.1617904902,
-0.0075480202,
-0.6822458506,
0.5064390898,
0.5708013773,
0.8916221261,
-0.3319307566,
0.3437823653,
0.3670412898,
0.2945955098,
-0.5133185983,
0.0137321735,
0.0935117006,
-0.4867369235,
-0.5487841368,
-0.499017626,
-0.1388963163,
-0.1369377077,
-0.7502283454,
0.2938228846,
-0.2506524026,
-0.0968832448,
0.3549962044,
-0.1324852556,
-0.5406938195,
0.1553407907,
-0.1288813949,
0.7230276465,
-1.195856452,
0.4374120831,
1.1655592918,
-0.4055113196,
-0.8601913452,
0.0153374709,
0.2905440927,
-0.8250542283,
0.6401510835,
0.4091913402,
-0.0525765345,
-0.0083061848,
-0.3460612595,
-0.9417500496,
0.9400486946,
0.499565959,
-0.9085937142,
-0.0278932787,
0.2190927267,
0.3462132812,
-0.1497962773,
0.2219282091,
0.6594039202,
0.6297195554,
0.0432560258,
-1.1744164228,
0.2497669607,
-0.4225003719,
-0.374876678,
0.5910503268,
-0.5506471992,
0.4283011258,
0.2866929173,
-0.1579332352,
0.0554549135,
0.5239108205,
-0.1678606868,
0.240745008,
0.4450833201,
1.2103340626,
1.0288900137,
-0.2913095653,
0.7722583413,
-0.1565995961,
0.1422125697,
1.2671922445,
-0.3479394615,
0.7268849611,
0.4240017235,
0.0915721208,
0.58015728,
0.7331555486,
0.0358955227,
0.2986766696,
-0.0276663303,
-0.0839101598,
-0.2148391902,
0.1466301829,
0.0975275487,
0.4379577339,
0.264515996,
-0.2870919406,
-0.3321513534,
0.2386327684,
0.2383369356,
0.3298364878,
-0.1175933108,
0.6621123552,
-0.0600715838,
-1.3433949947,
0.3936774135,
-0.2590650618,
0.3453339338,
-0.1967883855,
0.1009760872,
-0.2337340117,
0.3716696501,
-0.2839842141,
-1.1304758787,
0.4911489785,
-0.0499275848,
-0.151780799,
-0.4326148033,
0.581543982,
-0.5735936165,
-0.6738186479,
-0.1040057391,
0.375769645,
0.1690481752,
-0.1480016857,
-0.8728811145,
-0.0158285387,
0.0014561962,
-0.0780209899,
-0.0415803939,
0.5010660887,
-0.0354284383,
0.5025801659,
0.2856458426,
-0.0773473978,
-0.0159840342,
0.3255862892,
0.3998150229,
-0.6392120123,
-0.5647757053,
-0.7417573929,
0.472360462,
-0.5134830475,
-0.6626989841,
0.8179724216,
0.9659613967,
0.5827003717,
0.0865470394,
0.3450830281,
0.138394177,
0.4848513901,
-0.4740128517,
0.7280952334,
-0.671513617,
-0.2831968069,
-0.113851361,
-1.2516999245,
-0.8571383953,
0.5445477962,
-0.4002399147,
-0.5547560453,
1.2248086929,
0.8895614743,
-0.2691334486,
-0.0253132824,
0.1558120698,
-0.263083756,
0.1007840335,
0.5906411409,
0.6600245237,
-0.4875989556,
0.4753762186,
0.1355077028,
-0.2292761654,
-0.1124431342,
-0.6216797233,
-0.7147408128,
-0.5631062388,
-0.6132942438,
-0.2168689668,
0.1019519866,
0.6699858308,
0.590672493,
-0.4547337592,
-0.2069675326,
-0.281855464,
-0.0918868557,
-0.346132338,
-0.2548884749,
0.5458000302,
-0.3509348929,
-0.9622189403,
0.4031717777,
0.5120284557,
0.0214712303,
0.1160168573,
-0.0190679412,
-0.2465451658,
-0.0806594416,
0.2141337991,
0.0907872319,
-0.5535618663,
-0.2269099355,
0.2534455657,
-0.5075088739,
0.0505399406,
0.7887952328,
-0.2544279695,
0.692189157,
0.8460911512,
0.4855974317,
0.4231825471,
0.3135563731,
1.1926387548,
-0.5946385264,
0.0807490125,
0.112388812,
0.4738054574,
0.6688557863,
-0.5794155002,
0.5461471081,
-0.0120997783,
-0.8851041794,
-0.5711637139,
-0.1144959629,
-1.3812091351,
-0.0978356004,
0.8842092752,
-0.2670296133,
-0.2455730438,
0.1820039153,
-0.2090847492,
0.4487255216,
-0.1511318535,
0.3664455712,
1.0146855116,
0.1748585254,
-0.1261294484,
-0.2817382514,
0.3435479701,
0.6834881902,
-0.7732072473,
-0.1468127817,
0.6679245234,
0.0293198358,
0.326406002,
0.352180928,
-0.0685186014,
0.5333734751,
0.0417076796,
-0.2187864929,
0.3940149248,
-0.0932286754,
-0.4293836951,
-0.0853435472,
-0.0859669074,
-0.3740599453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08981v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08981v2
|
Speculative Contrastive Decoding
| 2023-11-15T14:15:30 | 2024-03-13T17:32:50 |
Hongyi Yuan, Keming Lu, Fei Huang, Zheng Yuan, Chang Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models~(LLMs) exhibit exceptional performance in language
tasks, yet their auto-regressive inference is limited due to high computational
requirements and is sub-optimal due to the exposure bias. Inspired by
speculative decoding and contrastive decoding, we introduce Speculative
Contrastive Decoding~(SCD), a straightforward yet powerful decoding approach
that leverages predictions from smaller language models~(LMs) to achieve both
decoding acceleration and quality improvement. Extensive evaluations and
analyses on four diverse language tasks demonstrate the effectiveness of SCD,
showing that decoding efficiency and quality can compatibly benefit from one
smaller LM.
|
[
-0.1396464407,
-0.4519079328,
0.4554547369,
0.2651458383,
-0.2859336734,
0.4245588183,
-0.1515895426,
-0.6387701631,
0.4049766958,
0.6233821511,
-0.5522381663,
-0.3893404305,
-0.6383110881,
0.0426258333,
-0.5000010133,
0.5610331893,
0.0238793865,
0.1642537117,
-0.1748205572,
0.3001701534,
0.0603497252,
-0.4688726664,
-0.7987090349,
-0.1428240091,
0.2762090564,
0.5187492967,
0.7298561931,
1.0040260553,
0.6325550079,
0.3166969717,
0.0925266743,
0.2255532593,
-0.7612370849,
0.2366334051,
-0.2881517112,
-0.6458086967,
-0.0342385545,
-0.2561706305,
0.5254591703,
0.8083773851,
-0.1827069521,
-0.1957080364,
0.0974564031,
0.6211375594,
-0.8669852614,
0.3017021418,
-0.5347986817,
-0.1347381771,
-0.1000687033,
-0.3150361776,
-0.726812005,
-0.223663494,
-0.3193482161,
-0.6461677551,
0.3992449045,
0.3133648038,
0.6504256129,
0.3499872983,
-0.2296257019,
-0.2047294527,
-0.9725832939,
0.8408641815,
-0.8203995824,
0.4849640131,
0.3608950377,
0.016886767,
0.0133291539,
-0.7938427925,
-0.6298474669,
-0.0532749668,
0.0117757665,
0.1711505502,
-0.2587361634,
0.1781546474,
0.2250495106,
0.6346151829,
-0.4306642711,
0.3824747205,
-0.1943861693,
-0.2255240083,
0.4500176013,
0.6571225524,
-0.0765221193,
0.0458094217,
-0.0623487309,
-0.2519937158,
-0.5848650932,
-0.2289420366,
0.2557697594,
0.3012117445,
-0.2810904384,
0.3948493004,
-0.3419962823,
0.4123571515,
0.2341843694,
-0.1861782372,
0.0024286448,
-0.299282372,
-0.1938990653,
-0.2212486565,
0.579890132,
0.4715293646,
-0.3344714642,
-0.3020649254,
-0.1895798147,
0.7816080451,
-0.1016010419,
-0.896982789,
-0.4574627876,
0.1055000946,
-0.7778583765,
-0.3404764831,
-0.2034318,
-0.7948914766,
-0.4559412003,
-0.0934465528,
0.0395880267,
-0.6013972759,
-0.2461622208,
0.5416417718,
-0.0156312101,
0.1345830113,
0.203028366,
-1.1915557384,
0.463504225,
0.5006580353,
0.5465257168,
-0.3882032633,
-0.0770079121,
-0.4413079619,
0.1397099495,
-0.8071967959,
0.9580994844,
-0.7136247158,
-0.5528917313,
-0.2250170857,
-0.1900499016,
0.068206057,
-0.2855833769,
0.9249544144,
-0.815967083,
-0.1301766485,
-0.305048883,
-0.7007879615,
0.0258710701,
-0.0984178632,
-0.9027279615,
0.7345933318,
0.1297558099,
-1.0871905088,
0.2923398316,
-0.2384239137,
-0.3994042873,
-0.0003553352,
-0.1762473583,
0.1672004312,
0.3970475197,
0.2135955244,
0.3238061965,
-0.5701912045,
-0.1480931789,
-0.3945498168,
-0.6445237994,
0.0623218827,
-0.4202831686,
0.2718306184,
0.8237687349,
0.0424775183,
0.0234338995,
-0.7278699875,
-0.1366967261,
0.2001037598,
-0.3028595448,
-0.3882342875,
0.1648821384,
0.0441983193,
0.1428730935,
0.0121406037,
-0.3676771522,
-0.0650108978,
-0.7194991112,
0.2750274241,
0.616689086,
-0.1581621021,
0.5551103354,
-0.2235691994,
0.7848106623,
0.2204389423,
-0.4031234384,
-0.3839688003,
0.1733407825,
-0.9456204176,
-0.33193627,
0.4729474485,
0.376265049,
-1.3443796635,
0.2393452972,
-0.2121979743,
-0.3323264718,
-0.7802075148,
-0.0386112109,
0.459433645,
0.4712326527,
0.2416576445,
0.0211647321,
-0.5802899599,
-0.927254796,
-0.3515482843,
-0.0028575694,
0.0524506792,
0.0563113429,
0.0532573499,
-0.3340055943,
0.3950026035,
-0.6193219423,
0.2221910357,
-0.5390005708,
0.0587694421,
0.3895036876,
0.5108651519,
0.3823950291,
-0.4666384161,
-0.6340452433,
-0.0243209992,
-0.5448821783,
0.0274570864,
-0.1382396519,
-0.053833887,
0.4455263019,
1.1185307503,
-0.5146068931,
0.1578689516,
0.6955720782,
-0.3741867244,
0.6347533464,
-0.3511252403,
0.3836539388,
-1.0819158554,
-0.13529329,
-0.0579156168,
-0.1982190013,
-0.4664364159,
0.4605258405,
0.0681192428,
0.2032153308,
-0.1790397316,
0.340962857,
-0.6568844914,
-0.1029349715,
-0.563254416,
0.0091170305,
-0.1463511437,
-0.0079023298,
0.282582283,
0.7478659749,
0.7299564481,
-0.3725246489,
0.1406730115,
-0.2479328811,
-0.5401967168,
0.0592118427,
-0.4316409528,
-0.0035756568,
-0.2748948932,
0.3587883711,
-1.2451882362,
-0.3300773501,
-0.0060755652,
-0.1171981692,
0.3689676225,
0.1478709877,
-0.6492208242,
-0.6837317348,
-0.2716594636,
0.7462800741,
0.6691854596,
-0.7317760587,
0.4805808663,
0.1184234321,
-0.181307435,
-0.6968047619,
-0.8390353918,
0.0548796207,
-0.026582418,
-0.4303459823,
0.4449766278,
-0.1343949288,
-0.3293733001,
0.0697720721,
-0.1144516021,
0.2094640285,
-0.1384727508,
0.0374737084,
0.3355999291,
-0.5548838377,
-0.0989497676,
0.1820839643,
-0.4067740738,
0.0037559741,
-0.2883491218,
0.7322428823,
-0.0337923169,
-0.2836138904,
-0.3831128776,
0.576317668,
0.417902261,
0.1692183465,
0.4818567932,
0.4965711832,
-0.3157997131,
-0.3477599025,
-0.7094112039,
-0.4106336534,
-0.5692303777,
0.4063578248,
-0.5810673237,
-0.9844630957,
0.6048241258,
-0.0758150592,
-0.2650878727,
0.6045718193,
0.3851411641,
-0.0679079443,
1.1780046225,
1.040733695,
-0.1402700692,
0.3142953813,
-0.1924062967,
0.1165396944,
-0.4044626355,
-0.1019417942,
-0.6032501459,
-0.2094950676,
-0.7129842639,
-0.763430059,
-0.2548044622,
0.3340749741,
0.0913101286,
0.1020424217,
-0.3096555769,
0.8435497284,
0.4054840803,
0.2119985968,
0.4379964173,
0.1604837924,
-0.308398366,
-0.4665913284,
-0.9917285442,
-0.2797169685,
0.9347743392,
0.3261713386,
1.2617108822,
-0.1249579266,
0.6855280399,
0.3727028966,
0.1640852839,
-0.6748427153,
0.4897733033,
-0.511157155,
-0.1846402735,
0.0543090962,
-0.419252038,
-0.7463029623,
0.3452804685,
-0.4308354557,
-0.5259208083,
0.5272660255,
0.2871192992,
-0.3991473019,
0.3347465992,
-0.7218746543,
0.589186728,
0.1453759223,
-0.4834058583,
-0.6690479517,
-0.5930614471,
0.6976124644,
0.0331592038,
0.2646348178,
0.2457327396,
-0.1635527164,
0.5869719386,
-0.214363873,
0.7643439174,
0.1784220487,
-0.1769123375,
-0.0056165061,
0.4283417463,
0.7176671028,
-0.0496080369,
-0.4307980537,
-0.2911362052,
0.1648882926,
-0.743716836,
-0.5018923283,
0.9947147369,
-0.6011191607,
-0.484872967,
-0.3705051243,
-0.7584727407,
-0.4452520013,
0.2308620811,
0.4811305702,
0.2245472968,
-0.3206157982,
-0.09884765,
0.7107441425,
-0.2268992215,
0.5035207868,
0.528558135,
-0.1967612058,
-0.0783762857,
1.0303452015,
-0.4869403541,
0.4746041894,
0.5862531662,
-0.0579416268,
-0.4723728597,
-0.8513964415,
0.010331451,
0.3074718714,
-0.938572526,
-0.1345206499,
-0.7133594751,
-0.1129112914,
-0.4294547737,
-0.4851127863,
-0.4995599389,
-0.4242736101,
-0.3153356016,
-0.2984535098,
0.0594788156,
0.8068674207,
-0.3331590295,
0.2354797423,
-0.6548774838,
0.5544834137,
-0.0845983997,
0.2624544501,
0.0084406072,
-0.5795650482,
-0.3085185587,
-0.1545152366,
0.1053083017,
-0.4703242481,
0.7049583793,
-0.1520925313,
0.5367850661,
0.7244524956,
0.3973342776,
0.5185495615,
-0.3394413292,
0.6901960373,
0.4783597291,
-0.8496382236,
0.1343317926,
-0.1494064927,
0.2348840386,
0.450037092,
0.4147238135,
-0.3333861232,
-0.4063867629,
-0.6502813101,
-0.837955296,
0.8653025031,
-0.2169717997,
0.0832756907,
-0.3205479681,
0.3252699971,
0.3832262456,
-0.0851629451,
-0.4382312894,
-0.180614993,
-0.1432424188,
-0.1474616081,
-0.3866954446,
-0.6883597374,
0.048073601,
-0.0245782714,
0.3674422503,
-0.1450685412,
0.3965145946,
-0.0836652145,
-0.0208992716,
-0.1716405004,
0.2227132767,
0.5144180059,
0.2754836679,
-0.0747776181,
0.3772078753,
0.1697297841,
-0.209213227,
-0.0110087534,
-0.0431137234,
0.1029734239,
-0.1458653063,
0.4873713553,
0.7649547458,
0.1725483835,
-0.6358446479,
0.2043295205,
-0.0895768851,
-0.112674728,
0.2628654838,
0.1166824549,
0.3381671309,
0.4235998094,
0.2914815843,
0.2268005311,
0.4289439619,
-0.5035592914,
0.236654371,
0.3278815448,
-0.1460438222,
-0.1454490423,
0.6683980823,
0.2558266222,
0.033233691,
0.4561979771,
-0.2953166068,
-0.1837877482,
0.6612645388,
0.9624390602,
0.7365809083,
-0.2085904032,
0.0687739924,
0.2453187555,
0.1805967838,
-0.3204032183,
0.5358096361,
0.0861334354,
-0.8481499553,
-0.8084475398,
-0.5793377161,
-0.3752841651,
0.0899297819,
-0.8892329931,
-0.0276549421,
-0.4783455729,
0.1820084602,
-0.0891641378,
-0.0088401306,
-0.6057239771,
0.2843423784,
0.0016611244,
1.1742795706,
-0.6370519996,
1.0614202023,
0.1547329426,
-0.0674793944,
-0.6686112285,
0.2657557726,
-0.2037254125,
-0.773203671,
0.7813504338,
-0.1225300357,
-0.5817201734,
0.2114235163,
-0.4794462025,
-0.827652812,
0.8537575603,
0.5861566663,
-0.8202373981,
-0.0944101885,
-0.1600694209,
0.7129334211,
-0.6580158472,
0.3400391936,
0.7971653342,
0.1826103628,
0.2154060453,
-0.3991675377,
0.3210218251,
-0.2113634497,
0.1514771283,
-0.0908859223,
-0.5289145708,
0.8175253272,
-0.6409843564,
-0.5888797641,
0.5260014534,
0.9727138281,
0.1259256899,
0.0882141963,
0.2393656969,
0.3159247339,
0.5458439589,
-0.1004473493,
1.4309873581,
-0.7567020059,
0.2065190375,
1.021576643,
-0.1433562636,
1.0422823429,
0.3836500049,
-0.1634688377,
0.5173637271,
0.7992840409,
0.2619301081,
0.7768297195,
0.1508444846,
-0.2733212411,
-0.6797150373,
-0.0911330581,
-0.4835315645,
0.2073744088,
0.7293813825,
-0.4609642923,
-0.2245592624,
-0.1632802039,
-0.4299287796,
0.4953110218,
-0.3215622306,
0.4530059397,
0.0820635408,
-0.3968221843,
0.6918057799,
0.3234946132,
1.1339223385,
-0.4015157521,
0.0769887418,
-0.4547037482,
0.3643656969,
-0.1192326769,
-0.6143752337,
0.2721213102,
-0.4369681478,
-0.4530860782,
-0.0667462423,
0.7899173498,
-0.555236876,
-0.5091261864,
0.521602571,
0.3715126216,
0.0124930684,
0.2860969305,
-0.6108812094,
0.422304213,
-0.0941032842,
0.0759781897,
0.2728751302,
0.4548121393,
0.1457627267,
0.7870566249,
0.7096374035,
0.2281461656,
-0.2642255127,
0.0253351554,
1.0057256222,
-0.9241396189,
-0.9888463616,
-0.6623146534,
0.0763253644,
0.0968507007,
0.1314530969,
0.8136460185,
0.494163245,
0.743249774,
-0.3665447235,
0.86482656,
0.3324049115,
0.7171046734,
-0.8354114294,
0.4356260598,
-0.304549396,
0.5660236478,
-0.3558464646,
-0.5707836151,
-0.2308794707,
0.5547460914,
-0.1624137759,
0.0061402977,
0.8963386416,
0.8767781854,
-0.1089596301,
0.1378540993,
0.5389549136,
0.4762170911,
0.0370203592,
0.6164881587,
1.0092185736,
-0.3571771383,
0.476508528,
-0.212767005,
-0.1475800723,
-0.3862759769,
-0.9602993131,
-0.7755947709,
-0.3168467879,
-0.1865821481,
-0.6745146513,
0.2141296118,
0.7781134844,
0.6937263012,
-0.9568558931,
-0.2907755673,
-0.3222528994,
0.0457730368,
-0.246544525,
-0.2598812282,
0.3347260356,
-0.3743465245,
-0.8770335913,
0.6266569495,
0.2508220375,
0.077076301,
-0.1353131533,
-0.3194502592,
0.2590231001,
0.4301255941,
0.7467511296,
0.3863334656,
-0.737336874,
0.0116087906,
-0.0199734811,
-0.4594921768,
-0.1926630288,
1.0678503513,
-0.8298083544,
0.1854831725,
0.6907064319,
0.8546069264,
0.8438717127,
-0.0039414046,
0.6247344017,
-0.2813419998,
0.3519038856,
0.2656812668,
0.3432257473,
0.2223282158,
-0.3873387277,
0.2706885338,
0.3702313602,
-0.1780374199,
-0.7416441441,
0.2643564641,
-1.0219351053,
-0.690190196,
1.32183218,
-0.0153863467,
-0.05184488,
-0.1400005221,
-0.1363098025,
-0.1484428495,
-0.4803417027,
0.7792937756,
0.6709396839,
-0.1785299778,
-0.3357461691,
-0.1193693429,
0.7150179148,
0.5206606388,
-0.7086829543,
0.2980101407,
0.660172224,
0.1771831214,
0.0511126257,
0.7538387179,
-0.0605051331,
0.2744388282,
0.7250179648,
-0.1403865367,
0.1569862664,
-0.2793935835,
-0.425750792,
0.2223567814,
0.2437254936,
0.0406794883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08968v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08968v2
|
Identifying Linear Relational Concepts in Large Language Models
| 2023-11-15T14:01:41 | 2024-03-29T22:14:30 |
David Chanin, Anthony Hunter, Oana-Maria Camburu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Transformer language models (LMs) have been shown to represent concepts as
directions in the latent space of hidden activations. However, for any
human-interpretable concept, how can we find its direction in the latent space?
We present a technique called linear relational concepts (LRC) for finding
concept directions corresponding to human-interpretable concepts by first
modeling the relation between subject and object as a linear relational
embedding (LRE). We find that inverting the LRE and using earlier object layers
results in a powerful technique for finding concept directions that outperforms
standard black-box probing classifiers. We evaluate LRCs on their performance
as concept classifiers as well as their ability to causally change model
output.
|
[
-0.287581712,
-0.9297761321,
0.8229959607,
-0.1589785814,
-0.1780920327,
0.3774996698,
-0.1359651089,
-0.3967877626,
0.1453073472,
0.511300385,
-0.5644603968,
-0.3654384017,
-0.4219477177,
-0.3944321275,
-0.5265308619,
0.7016380429,
0.0267082322,
-0.0907595456,
-0.5565752983,
-0.2185526043,
-0.5136203766,
-0.4842553735,
-0.3629333973,
-0.6399487853,
0.8717612028,
0.3764592707,
1.0783429146,
0.5434840918,
0.6960716248,
0.2417125702,
-0.393491745,
0.0097959861,
-0.5295882225,
0.2243055105,
-0.4418246448,
-0.3854702115,
-0.1771527678,
-0.0257781502,
0.7182586193,
1.1954934597,
-0.1650673598,
0.0594248846,
-0.3852565289,
0.5784233809,
-0.5242142677,
0.3849574924,
-0.4987363517,
0.1440367103,
-0.2361104935,
-0.260076344,
-0.6088439822,
-0.261272341,
0.3395587206,
-0.3608010709,
0.2412147969,
0.2158968151,
0.946700573,
-0.0599292107,
-0.4363198876,
-0.4851735532,
-1.2472721338,
0.7518782616,
-0.3709803522,
0.9033563137,
0.1728002131,
0.4559910297,
-0.1557219177,
-0.7719045281,
-0.6644404531,
-0.1740644127,
-0.3432148993,
-0.2800893784,
-0.1463131905,
-0.1616595536,
0.3099290133,
0.1215590462,
-0.4244434237,
-0.0144239208,
-0.4051136971,
0.0163221117,
0.6781583428,
0.1147217304,
0.1928601116,
-0.0644616559,
-0.2914580107,
-0.2257902324,
-0.8378440142,
0.0297725759,
0.0058173351,
0.4321512282,
0.2043614537,
0.670614481,
0.1474635452,
0.6488817334,
0.1558006257,
-0.1751217544,
0.21325396,
-0.2314832658,
-0.0242821872,
0.0232992582,
0.6396086812,
-0.0264293533,
-0.1009759307,
-0.3886243701,
-0.2819043994,
0.0564547628,
0.2794264257,
-0.713095367,
-0.244092077,
-0.0995066166,
-0.4639773071,
-0.211342752,
0.2422944009,
-0.3170808256,
-0.6022734642,
-0.3540897071,
0.2383130342,
-0.2734884024,
-0.4757444561,
-0.0477881432,
0.0300341658,
0.7081138492,
0.1660909653,
-0.7058125138,
0.3383184671,
0.8691784739,
0.567516923,
-0.0387648195,
0.1139665768,
-0.2287514508,
0.1225908324,
-0.4950307608,
0.7281503677,
-0.8755589128,
-0.3692382872,
-0.0185146183,
-0.0471811108,
0.1895312071,
-0.4829632938,
0.5858559608,
-0.8190635443,
0.2852214575,
-0.2030358762,
-0.7819702625,
-0.0766896382,
0.0786163434,
-0.5619649291,
0.7825345397,
0.0881241485,
-0.9007732272,
0.0703930259,
-0.6152008176,
-0.1883859038,
0.0459133424,
-0.5488670468,
-0.6350919008,
0.1925676316,
-0.1710785329,
0.7066349983,
-0.4668816328,
0.4174599349,
-0.2158857733,
-0.1308870167,
0.6504557133,
0.120961085,
0.4892683625,
0.0806527063,
0.1349826157,
0.2875818908,
-0.6748819947,
-0.1808224022,
0.4784844816,
0.3536829948,
-0.8936835527,
0.4824783802,
-0.1565170288,
0.188934803,
-0.0640790761,
-0.3273988068,
0.150499478,
-0.2202538401,
0.3711814582,
0.3556737304,
-0.0010612489,
0.7705111504,
0.2144967318,
0.3422540128,
0.2308587134,
-0.1806358397,
-0.1527925134,
-0.5646204948,
-0.881200552,
0.2343758047,
0.2215076089,
0.1495128274,
-0.6981942058,
0.4521106184,
-0.3673672378,
-0.3979370594,
-0.3500718474,
0.05632836,
0.4205035865,
0.4666931629,
0.3083335459,
0.025368955,
-0.3372908831,
-1.0326241255,
-0.2103611529,
-0.2758440673,
-0.0620216727,
0.3082773983,
0.5452125669,
-0.4470937252,
0.9664568305,
-0.8120143414,
-0.2421825081,
-0.2153325081,
0.0556764789,
0.2894790471,
0.2340563536,
0.1448705643,
-0.9005734324,
-0.1575800329,
0.1444519162,
-0.8701919913,
0.2995458245,
-0.2075005025,
-0.0733856708,
-0.2754449248,
0.9571563601,
-0.4934494495,
0.2398364693,
0.0583280176,
-0.5277791619,
0.0074702529,
-0.0333077051,
-0.750926435,
-0.7836244106,
-0.0638208985,
0.0435554646,
-0.334391892,
-0.7766379118,
0.3571250439,
0.3203364611,
-0.1258327067,
-0.2373621613,
0.4234258533,
-0.6188432574,
-0.1519497335,
-0.0416765064,
0.4769096971,
0.0360382237,
0.2664290965,
0.2566282451,
0.3647167683,
0.2544770539,
-0.5756493211,
0.3594519198,
0.3980453014,
-0.1842700392,
0.670331955,
-0.7075289488,
0.5354354978,
-0.6037573814,
0.239132911,
-0.8250133395,
0.108675085,
0.2244117856,
-0.227844432,
0.459085077,
-0.1042624563,
-0.1151137203,
-0.6818233728,
0.0267557744,
0.362401247,
0.1849669069,
-0.4580655396,
0.7831680775,
0.4450628161,
0.1012666225,
-0.7475497127,
-0.463876009,
-0.1650476754,
-0.1817573309,
-0.4485009313,
0.5345807076,
0.1783748865,
-0.5949110985,
0.1384499371,
-0.1043497697,
-0.0620272942,
0.0230160262,
0.3037167192,
0.2229650021,
-0.3664752245,
0.4476443529,
-0.2030315101,
-0.1754195541,
0.4441443086,
-0.3346610367,
0.524040401,
-0.1898200661,
-0.4104214013,
-0.1659121066,
0.0923850387,
0.369205296,
-0.300106287,
0.8988916874,
0.4703346491,
-0.3940270245,
-0.3070810437,
-0.4013245106,
-0.1976397783,
-0.4355408549,
0.5980346203,
-0.4688740373,
-0.5708893538,
0.4766410887,
0.0395352617,
-0.3283153176,
0.1906428039,
0.3734851778,
-0.1510557085,
0.6052167416,
0.925245285,
-0.0616717413,
0.4559619427,
-0.6422234178,
0.6288868785,
-0.8206454515,
-0.5980778337,
-0.5296988487,
-0.2831593156,
-0.6308506131,
-0.8152704835,
0.3061461151,
0.3248381317,
-0.2699924409,
0.3816508055,
-0.2689802945,
0.5718894005,
0.2327662408,
0.3676923513,
0.4293130934,
-0.3146937788,
-0.2158759981,
0.0130073493,
-0.3739051819,
-0.3797931969,
0.8679141998,
0.7887385488,
0.923268795,
0.1839990467,
0.5681449771,
-0.1416963637,
0.4672899246,
-1.2180049419,
0.4181035459,
0.0646459684,
-0.5918120742,
-0.3935301006,
-0.3252317309,
-0.7395519018,
0.2780092955,
-0.1797064096,
-0.3541737199,
0.3752845824,
-0.0869688541,
-0.1400517374,
0.368424654,
-0.3318286836,
0.7694426775,
-0.2153033018,
-0.4527621269,
-0.1421108544,
-0.6289249659,
0.3246116042,
-0.1260417849,
0.2242863476,
-0.0545771904,
0.0437092446,
0.4514892101,
-0.3103727698,
0.6954743266,
-0.2807363868,
-0.4552297592,
0.1767875254,
0.2818288207,
0.5564564466,
-0.0197714251,
0.1829830259,
-0.0736514702,
-0.3499738872,
-0.2130708098,
-0.9497699738,
0.4493878782,
-0.7540066838,
-0.6287791133,
-0.3117853999,
-0.656382978,
-0.2135190815,
0.1353142112,
-0.167655766,
0.2818106413,
-0.5688356757,
0.3048237562,
0.7827197313,
-0.3757766783,
0.3138050735,
0.6334921718,
-0.6653215885,
0.2224849612,
0.8102580905,
-0.1673153937,
0.4132974744,
0.8698624969,
0.4784878492,
-0.6319762468,
-0.2457443476,
-0.1617598236,
0.4753373563,
-0.6891291142,
-0.1796786189,
-0.496491313,
-0.4180551171,
0.108181186,
0.0793785527,
-0.5800398588,
-0.4489534497,
-0.1528545022,
-0.1840196252,
0.1207642704,
0.8779857159,
0.4288700819,
0.2933582962,
-0.3071908653,
0.2680134773,
0.5694966316,
0.1922605932,
0.043977391,
-0.4573261738,
-0.1638918966,
0.2370798737,
-0.5076054931,
-0.7406086326,
0.3160173893,
0.0947723761,
0.4571155608,
0.8034331799,
-0.0128820091,
0.6751851439,
-0.4567015469,
0.2883037627,
0.3493116498,
-1.0321005583,
0.4759373665,
-0.2291868925,
-0.0081777396,
-0.0763359517,
0.6095411777,
-0.6950669885,
-0.084157154,
-0.5469948053,
-0.4940098822,
0.3908323646,
0.2376387268,
0.1111030206,
0.1703686118,
0.4139193296,
-0.2428190857,
0.1116728857,
-0.7698932886,
-0.5558193326,
-0.2096465528,
-0.0111953551,
-0.2722534835,
-0.3222551048,
-0.0447205156,
-0.1901841462,
0.166869998,
-0.0645578951,
0.594750464,
0.0905719399,
-0.0991543457,
-0.4767713249,
0.3708266318,
0.6280381083,
0.9445902705,
-0.3756790459,
0.4876509905,
-0.1331109703,
-0.067844443,
0.233531177,
-0.080948323,
-0.1933072656,
0.1643395126,
0.5687601566,
0.8544747829,
0.2788769901,
-0.2191273272,
0.6638307571,
0.0368794017,
0.1366922855,
-0.5948781967,
-0.1617049575,
0.4522064626,
0.2323935032,
0.3260543346,
-0.1586967111,
-0.196311757,
-0.9385726452,
0.3009836078,
0.6516189575,
-0.5686861277,
-0.5856704712,
0.6058789492,
0.0338932499,
-0.4943040311,
0.6501780152,
-0.1557154655,
-0.5053018928,
0.4158759415,
0.6805711985,
0.7615822554,
-0.4692489803,
0.4392195344,
0.2107930183,
0.1313048303,
-0.0271568056,
0.0950535983,
0.1041912585,
-1.3624825478,
-0.3082946539,
-0.3147055209,
-0.398884207,
0.0021935657,
-0.9074857831,
0.2864404619,
-0.3408964872,
0.0376633555,
0.5647364259,
-0.158183679,
-0.7533783913,
-0.1738283336,
0.3620331883,
0.657311976,
-0.8570256829,
1.3287185431,
0.6715405583,
-0.5881513953,
-0.9393328428,
-0.1163702384,
-0.1210642681,
-0.9000263214,
1.3259320259,
-0.1683578789,
-0.2861143649,
-0.1472466737,
-0.6371834874,
-0.7705230117,
1.1512447596,
0.0221329033,
-0.8788819313,
-0.4025681913,
0.3665387332,
0.770919621,
-0.5397865176,
0.484985292,
0.5304238796,
0.3709952831,
0.3419994414,
-0.6666284204,
0.0534194596,
0.1324660033,
0.173517555,
0.3947916031,
-0.2496978343,
0.9189211726,
-0.4375792742,
-0.3003053665,
-0.1835400313,
0.7522808909,
0.0285789706,
0.2967198789,
0.5734741092,
0.4135823548,
0.7643330097,
-0.0044509745,
0.9142509699,
-0.1235162392,
0.5360470414,
0.9470307231,
-0.3179048896,
1.0513491631,
0.5542251468,
-0.1167851463,
0.8635978103,
0.0696557984,
0.1982277036,
0.5051916838,
0.335021168,
0.0335124247,
-0.1985719502,
-0.285589844,
-0.3456351161,
0.4022763073,
0.8463943005,
-0.5788116455,
0.0342870653,
-0.1616671979,
0.0737763271,
0.2179809809,
-0.2255902737,
0.702286303,
0.3459458649,
-0.2490177602,
0.7932617664,
-0.0408301502,
0.1943774819,
-0.3333442509,
-0.1501853317,
-0.22069484,
0.5816937685,
-0.1599124372,
-0.8488313556,
0.3078056276,
-0.4966739118,
-0.1481592655,
-0.3162946701,
0.7443219423,
-0.65032655,
-0.7265529633,
0.6381551027,
0.8053832054,
-0.2341776788,
0.0748541057,
-0.666380465,
0.0487171039,
-0.2304643393,
0.092548348,
-0.0572916418,
0.7008300424,
-0.2667511702,
0.9554514885,
0.4076758623,
0.0775455087,
-0.3926225305,
0.2205637246,
1.1248412132,
-1.1251788139,
-0.1649509221,
-0.5793600082,
0.2189662158,
0.0568152666,
0.1461427212,
0.6668608785,
0.2995407283,
1.0451955795,
-0.1354593337,
0.2122232914,
0.0604257472,
0.8544745445,
-0.3376932144,
0.4506813288,
-0.2889083624,
0.5443795323,
-0.5059449673,
-0.9924777746,
-0.4469596148,
0.9645335674,
-0.3497805297,
-0.2716370523,
0.8702524304,
0.9065615535,
-0.273253262,
-0.033320602,
0.3410111368,
0.5190139413,
0.4712506533,
0.3342548013,
1.3611406088,
-0.3787818253,
0.3043583632,
-0.4512083232,
0.1028226241,
-0.0546711683,
-0.8133774996,
-1.1654477119,
-0.6466110945,
-0.3195212185,
-0.2587813735,
-0.0486635529,
0.8980542421,
0.6593117714,
-0.9450635314,
-0.4797538519,
-0.1156722158,
0.5258367658,
-0.1226797923,
-0.249085933,
0.4821453393,
-0.0429595299,
-0.3061650693,
0.3104645014,
0.0212981869,
-0.1248488948,
-0.77103585,
-0.119623445,
-0.2716729045,
-0.1869236529,
0.833614409,
0.0594357327,
-0.8728700876,
-0.5503322482,
0.2292626053,
0.0357842743,
-0.0267129242,
1.3145196438,
-0.8520348668,
0.3896965981,
0.2080707103,
0.410733819,
0.4536525607,
0.111221537,
0.6858534813,
-0.9499873519,
0.4009133875,
0.4602543414,
0.2632102966,
0.308567822,
-0.1794613302,
0.5822968483,
0.2362346947,
-0.3086573184,
-0.7834761739,
0.3289856017,
-0.9106192589,
-0.3252115846,
1.0297467709,
-0.0499666482,
-0.1507428288,
-0.1696436256,
0.1139531285,
0.0005974895,
-0.2214505672,
0.3884696364,
0.1625483781,
-0.0164200477,
-0.4617726803,
-0.3108630478,
0.4102137983,
0.0326183066,
-0.4888654053,
-0.0093674222,
0.3071627319,
0.1176174805,
0.6055396199,
0.0727549791,
-0.1556942761,
-0.3462542295,
-0.3644008934,
0.1121819317,
0.0677817762,
-0.3633610904,
-0.0789543986,
-0.1397570223,
0.2241290808,
-0.0462860428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08966v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08966v1
|
Improving Large-scale Deep Biasing with Phoneme Features and Text-only Data in Streaming Transducer
| 2023-11-15T13:53:28 | 2023-11-15T13:53:28 |
Jin Qiu, Lu Huang, Boyu Li, Jun Zhang, Lu Lu, Zejun Ma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Deep biasing for the Transducer can improve the recognition performance of
rare words or contextual entities, which is essential in practical
applications, especially for streaming Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR).
However, deep biasing with large-scale rare words remains challenging, as the
performance drops significantly when more distractors exist and there are words
with similar grapheme sequences in the bias list. In this paper, we combine the
phoneme and textual information of rare words in Transducers to distinguish
words with similar pronunciation or spelling. Moreover, the introduction of
training with text-only data containing more rare words benefits large-scale
deep biasing. The experiments on the LibriSpeech corpus demonstrate that the
proposed method achieves state-of-the-art performance on rare word error rate
for different scales and levels of bias lists.
|
[
-0.3957476616,
-0.3337047994,
0.2536862195,
-0.2606647611,
-0.641669035,
0.1074207649,
-0.388836056,
-0.4757987559,
0.5268241763,
0.7201881409,
-0.4458478689,
-0.4381154478,
-0.7727033496,
-0.1073696017,
-0.4527257681,
0.770491302,
0.1566542387,
0.3832232952,
0.384760052,
-0.5485721231,
-0.4232876301,
-0.5105685592,
-0.6037877798,
-0.3055942655,
0.4308755696,
0.1831584424,
0.6417095661,
0.6048129201,
0.1582646519,
0.1762340814,
-0.3539499044,
0.3115243018,
-0.4194088876,
0.3041673303,
-0.2611920536,
-0.0771014765,
-0.3286006749,
-0.0809963569,
0.9551339149,
0.7660319805,
0.2324703485,
0.0928889588,
0.3233880997,
0.6289953589,
-0.9053214192,
-0.0964772105,
-0.7306440473,
0.1818776131,
-0.6034498811,
-0.2489906996,
-0.188261196,
-0.3177652359,
0.3388121426,
-0.3710460365,
0.4682966173,
-0.3311388791,
0.6065977812,
0.4451965392,
-0.3611484468,
-0.2212471962,
-0.8749637008,
0.7275047302,
-0.7946996689,
0.8420825601,
0.326292932,
-0.0194939673,
0.2512143552,
-0.5491728187,
-0.4412637651,
0.0284751002,
-0.0272130873,
0.0845816135,
0.1253091246,
0.0166314244,
0.4243310988,
0.3026714325,
-0.4663550854,
0.1470483541,
-0.2363791019,
-0.495271951,
0.605158627,
-0.1976175904,
-0.1115319133,
0.0803441852,
-0.002336622,
-0.2833180428,
-0.6314709783,
-0.0885271356,
0.2328787893,
0.4894068241,
-0.0300056841,
0.2907408774,
-0.0311638322,
0.5096896291,
-0.0330004841,
0.027002519,
0.8568305969,
0.0413634144,
-0.0997206569,
0.4282843769,
0.697247088,
0.1420490891,
0.3409705162,
-0.0679935738,
-0.1380913705,
0.088663511,
-0.051016558,
-0.7899915576,
0.0293543544,
0.0832718909,
-0.4172109663,
-0.0140956789,
0.0593604147,
-1.0010246038,
-0.9144711494,
-0.094299607,
0.3012181818,
-0.3054988384,
-0.4676322937,
-0.0786333904,
-0.2254740447,
0.0632336736,
0.1685417145,
-0.7178867459,
0.1329730749,
0.4528554976,
0.7894163132,
-0.2361204028,
-0.2222294956,
-1.1736373901,
0.2330788374,
-0.074967064,
0.8139867783,
-0.7052221298,
-0.6155678034,
0.3011700213,
-0.0642124489,
0.0128558017,
-0.855922699,
0.9418573976,
-0.4725870192,
-0.0601610243,
-0.183782056,
-0.8139283061,
-0.055957377,
-0.215754047,
-1.1179510355,
0.8717108369,
-0.2725599706,
-0.8045239449,
0.6883007884,
-0.4551278055,
-0.7786197662,
0.1462569088,
-0.1904482394,
-0.4993922412,
0.1912565231,
0.3086610734,
0.4074919224,
-0.0529437661,
-0.1868681163,
-0.3577230871,
-0.5576910377,
0.4118002951,
-0.7723118663,
0.4309654236,
0.123344861,
-0.5708295703,
-0.3764829636,
-0.8585126996,
0.2627768517,
-0.3005045354,
-0.5110288262,
-0.5576893091,
0.1836568862,
0.4313896894,
-0.1500873566,
-0.0889783874,
-0.6173424125,
0.1290710419,
-0.5250957012,
0.4322496355,
0.4291639328,
-0.2419288605,
0.7032339573,
-0.0775174573,
0.1638544351,
0.1296589524,
-0.2365183234,
0.0230566263,
-0.154555276,
-0.7419875264,
-0.411642164,
0.532494545,
0.500171721,
-0.4018820524,
0.4025224745,
-0.469523102,
-0.2088688612,
-0.7588067651,
0.3838291168,
0.1890223622,
0.3023685217,
0.3860558569,
-0.4036855698,
-0.6996712685,
-0.6428436637,
-0.7940642834,
0.3284305036,
-0.2891325355,
0.5280809402,
-0.1562691331,
-0.5938035846,
0.6522045732,
-0.3934696615,
-0.6080918908,
-0.0447897278,
0.1049232185,
0.3012381792,
0.1939569712,
0.159176603,
-0.709757328,
-0.3268308938,
-0.0639853999,
-0.3192176819,
-0.2268624306,
0.0531694777,
0.2249159068,
0.1531657875,
0.4741622508,
-0.4508396685,
0.3052775562,
0.4618287981,
-0.1979546994,
-0.1198342666,
0.1448382586,
-0.1211389005,
-0.742919445,
-0.0999954715,
0.0101722619,
-0.4073987007,
-0.5809316039,
-0.3651492596,
0.0686990544,
0.0115595488,
-0.3796406984,
0.6772848964,
-0.5938726068,
-0.0795465931,
-0.4912017882,
0.3270313442,
-0.1000038385,
0.0409803838,
0.4111618996,
0.6811422706,
0.5118174553,
-0.6726057529,
0.4354431629,
0.07182879,
-0.3314033449,
0.4059937894,
-0.3669098318,
0.5238468647,
-0.0532354377,
0.412927717,
-0.5271940827,
0.1137713194,
-0.2792545259,
-0.442548126,
0.5161387324,
-0.141586706,
-0.2366464287,
-0.3396080732,
-0.2496390343,
0.4444164336,
0.4824096859,
-0.5459209085,
0.8300466537,
0.5081655383,
-0.1095538363,
-0.7269099355,
-0.8721718192,
0.0264195222,
-0.1323665828,
-0.337261349,
0.2794353068,
0.1357078999,
-0.0290689748,
-0.3829517365,
-0.3235389888,
-0.2025836855,
-0.2890070379,
0.4435919821,
-0.0271223877,
-0.0218281206,
0.2803315222,
0.0464343689,
-0.1528921127,
-0.1783745289,
-0.7736076713,
0.7371931076,
0.2360547334,
-0.0477353334,
-0.2508380115,
0.4482848644,
0.4438069761,
-0.125386402,
0.2256632596,
0.9487769008,
-0.2895694673,
-0.4574097693,
-0.9410074353,
-0.2734205425,
-0.4520379603,
0.2889007628,
-0.3197517097,
-0.9857837558,
0.2407535315,
-0.2463784218,
-0.025280362,
0.2657067478,
0.4186584055,
-0.0178531948,
0.6335856915,
0.4278444946,
-0.5975506902,
0.4723217487,
-0.3402734101,
0.1256328374,
-0.7031088471,
0.2255790234,
-0.3909591138,
-0.4798033237,
-0.8212704062,
-0.4766553342,
0.3332896233,
-0.4251194298,
-0.1362223029,
0.0113256611,
-0.6042063236,
0.3396503925,
0.7587122917,
0.3350667655,
0.3612519205,
0.4326201975,
-0.1268944591,
-0.2456815243,
-0.2295177728,
-0.3063317835,
1.126696229,
0.2422819734,
0.6837768555,
-0.1475185752,
0.7034109235,
0.5821245313,
-0.0277984515,
-0.8346869349,
0.4489813745,
-0.5547432303,
-0.7651962638,
-0.3988149166,
-0.3509597778,
-0.8238369823,
0.1064632162,
-0.198981598,
-0.4986655712,
0.4037936628,
0.1472195089,
-0.3528160155,
0.2629503906,
-0.5690622926,
0.2672820091,
-0.0654941872,
-0.3244559765,
-0.3599689007,
-0.4270696342,
-0.1804967523,
-0.2612383068,
0.2342850715,
0.0079184249,
-0.145267114,
0.8474329114,
-0.5092608333,
0.608766973,
-0.3916662633,
-0.0656034574,
0.2486504763,
-0.0560599305,
0.5792644024,
0.0145230377,
-0.2274750918,
0.4199243486,
-0.2404313833,
-0.3059213161,
-0.285459727,
0.8009284139,
-0.8818049431,
-0.3163251877,
-0.3762630522,
-0.3215836585,
-0.5465882421,
0.1574983001,
0.5899293423,
0.3581931293,
-0.326926738,
0.1180465594,
0.9236041903,
-0.1470736861,
0.591226995,
0.5167728066,
0.2622647583,
-0.525411129,
0.8149741292,
0.4088907242,
-0.0272782296,
0.3851826191,
0.152641356,
-0.344222784,
-0.3607388735,
-0.5059844851,
0.2339863032,
-0.3772493899,
-0.1226486191,
-0.9111816287,
-0.5122920871,
-0.3720459044,
0.0227232333,
-0.4187975824,
-0.2720576525,
-0.3061889708,
-0.1497181505,
0.5572770238,
0.4589527547,
-0.2879983783,
0.413202852,
-0.9336977601,
0.3883392811,
0.5955739021,
0.2407965809,
0.000432626,
-0.7216641307,
-0.1763819456,
0.1629699618,
-0.0461966395,
-0.7597885132,
0.464070648,
0.5097518563,
0.217264235,
0.499733597,
-0.0638195574,
0.447887212,
-0.6161195636,
0.5312784314,
0.0538019128,
-1.2150347233,
0.460098654,
-0.330273062,
0.3860504627,
0.6363078952,
0.1798296422,
-0.569350481,
-0.112194337,
-0.5694682598,
-0.9810643792,
0.471729368,
0.124965094,
0.4270713329,
0.4927541912,
0.1359450519,
0.2876798809,
0.3069554865,
-0.620742023,
-0.2438681126,
-0.260170579,
-0.1139896289,
-0.0713291094,
-0.4136133194,
-0.0513239689,
-0.303116411,
0.6615915895,
-0.0821166262,
0.0720634088,
0.2243324071,
-0.4209908545,
-0.0537320077,
0.5366389155,
0.2645131648,
0.2310826778,
-0.0874305069,
0.2979792058,
0.4900384247,
-1.2284208536,
0.1657873541,
0.4463227987,
-0.4115665853,
0.4996180534,
0.462690711,
0.8635467887,
-0.11154145,
-0.5681032538,
0.6026723981,
0.227151081,
0.1508110166,
-0.4919562042,
0.1408760548,
0.0298364628,
0.2609924674,
0.7776510715,
-0.126336351,
0.3516373932,
-0.4328034818,
0.096611619,
0.4248470068,
-0.4382922649,
0.0780529901,
0.4548457563,
0.4123211205,
-0.1489498466,
0.4734810293,
-0.0236128476,
-0.4052414894,
0.269234091,
0.1875534058,
0.9006671906,
-0.5168535113,
-0.0225116685,
0.2220409662,
0.1577800959,
-0.0782705471,
0.3021001518,
-0.2554069757,
-0.8062264919,
-0.5241045952,
-0.5281352997,
-0.2911405563,
0.4944839776,
-0.4636706114,
0.490562588,
-0.6038983464,
-0.4145642519,
0.3044960797,
0.0531327426,
-0.8451158404,
0.4004596472,
0.4636078775,
0.5403985977,
-0.7250828743,
0.8016628623,
0.6972053647,
-0.0152604273,
-0.8368714452,
0.1230667308,
0.1281211972,
-0.7794547081,
0.699957788,
0.186929822,
-0.2265871763,
-0.1336587816,
-0.4333951473,
-0.9314825535,
0.7405574322,
0.1634919792,
-1.22752738,
0.0163611304,
0.388708353,
0.3622904122,
-0.2079215646,
0.6034556031,
0.7365558743,
0.5250663161,
0.118401885,
-1.132399559,
-0.1222459301,
-0.0901673734,
-0.0778134465,
0.2980569303,
-0.6731178164,
0.4573726654,
0.1094546691,
-0.1806478947,
-0.3425755203,
0.6657591462,
-0.0287735518,
0.4629056454,
0.7576446533,
0.60542804,
0.927252233,
0.0004700168,
0.4018616676,
0.0552907921,
0.1450246722,
1.2267092466,
-0.5756775737,
0.7495276332,
0.1039785147,
-0.0260412935,
0.4010997117,
0.3764221966,
-0.0888657793,
0.5033529401,
0.1285650581,
-0.5724151731,
-0.2033102065,
-0.3259939551,
-0.4297631085,
0.6317666173,
0.4611960351,
-0.5782663822,
-0.0245237481,
0.3267180026,
0.2583926916,
-0.022176154,
-0.5485432744,
0.877585113,
0.4058901966,
-0.1399476975,
0.7663210034,
-0.5280397534,
1.1041046381,
-0.279453516,
0.1839546412,
-0.1912358999,
0.4061788023,
-0.4451998472,
-0.5059633255,
0.0976203904,
0.063151747,
-0.4353338778,
-0.0083557637,
0.8642370701,
-0.3242492676,
-0.426867485,
0.5094171166,
0.6044976115,
0.1803611666,
-0.327486366,
-0.3114382923,
0.2378517836,
0.0249283612,
-0.0606822856,
0.000713056,
0.4616644681,
0.2119297832,
0.4394931793,
0.4178462923,
0.6456131339,
0.1698534042,
0.6376896501,
0.82116431,
-0.840651989,
-0.4979763329,
-0.8087022305,
0.258925885,
-0.4450348616,
-0.2227874547,
0.5837274194,
0.6114153266,
0.7543091774,
0.0760465339,
1.0137175322,
0.2912130654,
1.077086091,
-0.2861219347,
0.6928288937,
-0.2697603405,
0.0986851826,
-0.5496090055,
-1.1040848494,
-0.0978866443,
0.6200745702,
-0.2116954774,
0.057079237,
0.7477484345,
0.5587627888,
-0.1858843714,
0.1114703789,
0.3468855321,
0.46861431,
-0.0803687349,
0.5837435126,
0.6003517509,
-0.4726002514,
0.5944221616,
0.165991351,
-0.1191077456,
-0.1831858158,
-0.5560439229,
-0.9792211652,
-0.5558254123,
-0.2900400758,
-0.5735359192,
0.1754921526,
0.8837416768,
0.795574367,
-0.9208191037,
-0.0624655932,
0.2011970729,
-0.0773842707,
-0.1524881721,
-0.1847490221,
0.3245998323,
0.1267704815,
-0.8047425151,
0.3861272335,
0.1438014805,
-0.0689921379,
-0.2141678333,
0.2031387836,
0.1401274651,
0.0849097595,
0.491042465,
0.318223089,
-0.2957790792,
-0.1797378808,
-0.1079733744,
-0.0711047202,
0.0123669021,
1.0883842707,
-1.047834754,
0.2241120785,
0.426949352,
0.6621143222,
0.8886901736,
-0.3838794231,
0.4081322253,
-0.7008273005,
0.4692420065,
0.5583983064,
0.2957543433,
0.5804655552,
-0.3012380898,
0.5568102598,
0.2652918696,
-0.5499891639,
-0.6576666832,
0.1960464269,
-0.9583115578,
-0.0546615012,
1.4656391144,
0.2982498109,
0.07517647,
-0.147414282,
-0.2456911057,
0.3920625448,
-0.6950337291,
0.5521493554,
0.6044827104,
0.4167850018,
-0.2692900598,
-0.4730335772,
0.5946201682,
0.5830687881,
-0.3256932497,
0.0605950765,
0.5986046791,
0.4244071245,
0.1583753079,
0.5555386543,
0.1977497339,
0.024021998,
-0.2604447305,
-0.0635694787,
0.2375273854,
0.1648638994,
-0.418633014,
0.0571670532,
-0.1367039829,
-0.1437630206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08941v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08941v3
|
Transformers in the Service of Description Logic-based Contexts
| 2023-11-15T13:23:24 | 2024-04-26T16:32:02 |
Angelos Poulis, Eleni Tsalapati, Manolis Koubarakis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advancements in transformer-based models have initiated research
interests in investigating their ability to learn to perform reasoning tasks.
However, most of the contexts used for this purpose are in practice very
simple: generated from short (fragments of) first-order logic sentences with
only a few logical operators and quantifiers. In this work, we construct the
natural language dataset, DELTA$_D$, using the description logic language
$\mathcal{ALCQ}$. DELTA$_D$ contains 384K examples, and increases in two
dimensions: i) reasoning depth, and ii) linguistic complexity. In this way, we
systematically investigate the reasoning ability of a supervised fine-tuned
DeBERTa-based model and of two large language models (GPT-3.5, GPT-4) with
few-shot prompting. Our results demonstrate that the DeBERTa-based model can
master the reasoning task and that the performance of GPTs can improve
significantly even when a small number of samples is provided (9 shots). We
open-source our code and datasets.
|
[
-0.6008043289,
-0.7402296066,
0.792111516,
0.0126640452,
-0.1588378996,
-0.3313282132,
-0.0234060884,
-0.377492547,
-0.1385434717,
0.7294533253,
-0.6759889126,
-0.3110292852,
-0.6702561975,
0.2814021409,
-0.6526837945,
1.0434112549,
0.0279725138,
-0.2141979188,
0.2229815871,
-0.0283809528,
-0.6445816159,
-0.1210007742,
-0.7201001048,
-0.3146445453,
0.4812266231,
0.3386158347,
1.0069960356,
0.5009989142,
0.4526322186,
0.2246341258,
-0.0243396722,
0.270898968,
-0.1542786211,
0.1697864085,
-0.5055386424,
-0.6003031135,
-0.2657863498,
-0.0791435689,
0.3109179139,
0.6509401798,
0.0606665649,
0.0757073835,
-0.2211932987,
0.7765657306,
-0.645489037,
0.5083375573,
-0.7761414647,
0.0000207525,
0.2609336972,
0.0690798387,
-0.5243614316,
-0.2006701231,
0.3205630779,
-0.6430037022,
0.1954152584,
-0.1847616881,
0.778565824,
0.4809623361,
-0.5551111698,
-0.3216638565,
-1.1320056915,
0.7849402428,
-0.3359341621,
0.2879786193,
0.4060628414,
0.7824639082,
0.0377344936,
-0.8671201468,
-0.8178605437,
0.1091375723,
-0.5330299139,
0.1510819495,
-0.6077321768,
-0.040401265,
0.5987552404,
0.2405493706,
-0.3578141332,
-0.0571205392,
-0.5694756508,
0.1015746668,
0.6046888232,
0.392917484,
-0.1107949764,
-0.3628543913,
-0.1535335481,
-0.106678389,
-0.4889580309,
0.2233119756,
0.0290763788,
0.2509206533,
0.0971802548,
0.5427005887,
-0.6382320523,
0.8540888429,
0.1267969906,
0.095863007,
-0.2117422521,
-0.1311913282,
-0.5051074624,
-0.2685578763,
0.598672986,
0.1350927949,
0.4565343857,
-0.1507235914,
-0.3119953573,
0.1764315665,
0.2866259813,
-0.63428545,
-0.4252522886,
0.1734751463,
-0.3456822038,
-0.0917400271,
0.0636263862,
-0.3236108124,
-0.2677031159,
-0.6634327173,
0.3884728253,
-0.6131241322,
-0.0019979337,
0.2956578434,
0.0574220195,
0.4433244169,
0.3137723505,
-0.9007953405,
0.3914952278,
0.6593584418,
0.4357894063,
0.0834434107,
-0.0971904844,
-0.5232906938,
0.0408733934,
-0.1717966199,
0.8393206,
-0.4625903964,
-0.106925495,
-0.1917425692,
0.0289711207,
-0.0476867817,
-0.5186970234,
0.7900791168,
-0.688172102,
0.1274123639,
-0.2098889053,
-0.3784193993,
-0.3928536773,
0.2677211165,
-0.8960195184,
0.7169055343,
0.4687731266,
-0.6372622848,
0.345718652,
-0.7474882007,
-0.5606498718,
0.1480332315,
-0.3699982166,
-0.0709010884,
0.1600593925,
0.4985085726,
0.5065281391,
-0.4218329191,
0.2444202155,
0.3626871109,
-0.4142687917,
0.3354198635,
-0.5323119164,
0.8283933401,
0.1942671537,
-0.4152537882,
-0.0933542401,
-0.7160827518,
0.1130915135,
0.0648176596,
-0.0508021824,
-0.0825764313,
-0.0527350977,
-0.2598972917,
0.4653969705,
-0.1232217848,
-0.2429244518,
0.378228724,
-0.6084928513,
0.4754532576,
0.4032414854,
-0.1048926264,
0.6111788154,
-0.1702622324,
0.7259407043,
0.1788960099,
0.3829003274,
-0.2800916135,
-0.4808382094,
-0.8928790689,
-0.5104727149,
0.2109850943,
0.7554004788,
-1.0877921581,
0.4447800815,
-0.4178388715,
-0.461630106,
-0.4002469182,
-0.0257173367,
0.019056011,
0.6249296665,
0.7595961094,
0.2256418169,
-0.3708665967,
-1.5262415409,
-0.1881354302,
0.0035630907,
-0.3819253743,
0.1525763124,
0.5163974762,
-0.3371876478,
1.3559776545,
-0.6661629081,
-0.347102046,
-0.4853974283,
0.0115095554,
0.5292335749,
0.0543289073,
0.5329306126,
-0.7099657655,
-0.4175330698,
-0.1469812989,
-0.7444307208,
-0.0545548275,
-0.1852016896,
-0.1252366155,
0.2133807838,
0.1850809157,
-1.0273520947,
0.6146165729,
0.3402886093,
-0.2232634127,
0.3319512308,
-0.0301610809,
-0.0703581944,
-0.9122161269,
-0.105212979,
-0.1117971689,
-0.1203083619,
-0.7288507819,
-0.1119837165,
-0.0286718011,
0.1463080496,
-0.4757933021,
0.5015382767,
-0.0363705643,
0.2167556882,
-0.5469001532,
0.1988871396,
0.1049150899,
0.5133649707,
0.2327258289,
0.352483511,
0.741415143,
-0.7910041809,
0.4520494938,
0.3777197599,
-0.2828225493,
0.5756156445,
-0.7703124881,
-0.07062608,
-0.2881793678,
0.5356193781,
-0.6693139672,
-0.1843110323,
0.2614265978,
-0.1037845984,
-0.1815131158,
-0.2043841779,
-0.8279871941,
-0.4435135722,
0.2024245113,
0.2774244845,
0.6869814396,
-0.5974865556,
0.963462472,
-0.0559515022,
-0.0270337667,
-0.498621881,
-0.6656423807,
-0.1039659157,
-0.0309574064,
-0.6712716818,
0.1658758819,
0.3217507005,
-0.4408963323,
-0.0439108126,
-0.1376557648,
-0.1848817617,
0.0563033335,
0.2701321244,
0.2847712338,
-0.0031828082,
0.4407715201,
0.2811127901,
-0.2864744961,
0.2136724144,
-0.4217775166,
0.3441798091,
-0.3941496015,
-0.3075420558,
-0.4254644215,
0.3251100183,
0.3184083104,
-0.274833411,
0.8665770888,
0.4217311144,
-0.4382154047,
-0.5122130513,
-0.2298879474,
-0.5184127688,
-0.462695539,
0.1422255933,
-0.5835827589,
-0.7481638789,
0.4200856686,
0.2550593913,
0.0297384579,
0.8197988272,
0.4309599102,
-0.0828461498,
1.0154521465,
0.3120012283,
0.0506549291,
-0.0125139775,
-0.4624812901,
0.496776551,
-0.4386582375,
-0.1314898729,
-0.3275670111,
-0.3435785174,
-0.5747148395,
-0.3552351296,
0.3599483669,
0.2423797548,
-0.252892524,
0.5394822955,
-0.6300967336,
0.6997095346,
0.5902500153,
0.0836994648,
0.5444431305,
-0.0539902933,
0.1287353337,
0.0887214914,
-0.569756031,
-0.8039659858,
0.7296516895,
0.3240733147,
0.7329664826,
0.2180214077,
0.321348995,
0.0789810941,
0.1518745869,
-1.0823493004,
0.5289517641,
-0.2352045923,
-0.7138677239,
-0.3572135866,
-0.3608296514,
-0.9197403789,
0.0433807224,
-0.1069719791,
-0.6064321995,
-0.0468565486,
0.1475133598,
-0.4998828173,
0.0467528664,
-0.5741582513,
0.6401321888,
-0.1475696266,
-0.0088688601,
-0.161247462,
-0.7249475121,
0.3912190497,
-0.0107912151,
0.0589533038,
0.0015469003,
0.2908220887,
0.270519793,
-0.2436119318,
0.6031472087,
-0.1505449116,
-0.3872365952,
0.6271172762,
0.3816379011,
0.5088341236,
0.2436463386,
0.126012966,
-0.1373072416,
0.1575564891,
-0.29114452,
-1.1535915136,
0.4056973755,
-0.4452832043,
-0.5609348416,
-0.1317115873,
-0.7073926926,
-0.2968381643,
0.088049598,
0.2514592111,
0.4348852634,
0.128909111,
0.2059394717,
0.696721375,
-0.1141514182,
0.2941846848,
0.4429850578,
-0.1673375815,
0.091164656,
0.4327234626,
0.0097677195,
0.2103547305,
0.6318511367,
0.0684376955,
-0.3257524967,
-0.2132173926,
-0.3819713295,
-0.0177871846,
-1.1312935352,
-0.3754405081,
-0.8661762476,
-0.3487190008,
-0.0773047805,
-0.0012281927,
-0.3288585842,
-0.9031396508,
0.0543662682,
-0.1743637472,
0.4586149752,
0.767421782,
0.2955366373,
0.3800677061,
-0.8825119734,
0.5285146236,
0.6391193867,
0.2928867638,
-0.0899867117,
-0.4750258625,
-0.3073723316,
0.1678534299,
-0.4214490056,
-0.7146636844,
0.2411369979,
-0.0855097175,
0.5577334762,
0.1878210753,
0.1533759683,
0.2152513713,
-0.4416778088,
0.6927527785,
-0.181915015,
-1.0171633959,
0.743355751,
-0.3603287041,
0.5137417316,
0.4469448626,
0.3212910593,
-0.3685357571,
-0.365041852,
-0.709775269,
-0.6760540605,
0.7606441379,
0.6456025243,
0.1984110624,
-0.1984285712,
0.4311227202,
0.1514999121,
-0.0240592659,
-0.55615592,
-0.3858621418,
-0.3853516281,
-0.466255188,
0.2424211502,
0.1362854242,
-0.2271961421,
-0.3032006025,
0.6533230543,
-0.4389904141,
0.3082832098,
0.0302583352,
-0.2326501906,
0.3519181609,
0.6322167516,
0.5773726702,
0.5454349518,
0.1293298006,
0.3069505394,
0.1968801767,
-0.1255407333,
0.0486097448,
0.2665457726,
-0.2018934786,
-0.0545295775,
0.3586305082,
0.7775967717,
-0.2311074436,
-0.789185226,
0.4287631512,
-0.1506597102,
-0.2457417399,
-0.3906189799,
0.2518640161,
0.0259197634,
0.528057754,
0.4995455146,
0.0126479948,
0.3753533959,
-0.340199858,
0.2137802392,
0.2610504925,
-0.3394418359,
-0.2761691511,
0.5488736629,
-0.0477736183,
0.0179064926,
0.9009687901,
-0.3008122742,
-0.4645170569,
0.6619841456,
0.2047448903,
0.7949056625,
0.2811415195,
0.2609367073,
0.3077176213,
0.4009969234,
-0.1988903284,
0.1918441206,
0.0639224201,
-0.9043238759,
-0.5448716283,
-0.4337454438,
-0.221400246,
0.1302844286,
-0.6066124439,
0.3539506495,
-0.308901608,
-0.1179643273,
0.1575089693,
-0.2581700981,
-0.9908393621,
0.4022743702,
0.0296698622,
0.9903091788,
-0.8536423445,
0.8435314894,
0.4845525324,
-0.5927363634,
-1.0054335594,
-0.1169204041,
-0.2729461193,
-0.4093197882,
1.1912039518,
0.1966052055,
-0.3620729148,
-0.10817644,
-0.4309507012,
-0.4424670637,
1.2219570875,
0.445939064,
-0.4732053876,
-0.0545979515,
0.2759647369,
0.826938808,
-0.5052176118,
0.3104101121,
0.9857695103,
0.5643417239,
0.0456072465,
-0.937646389,
0.0661455169,
0.0672911853,
-0.1201880947,
0.1029772833,
-0.3040228784,
0.9004006982,
-0.0683543906,
-0.230706498,
0.0303630512,
0.5829762816,
0.2157101184,
-0.0238812007,
0.5793220997,
0.4565450251,
0.4487927854,
-0.2997089624,
1.2138947248,
-0.1357084513,
0.3621942997,
1.2584527731,
-0.1251321137,
0.6222909093,
0.3303633332,
-0.0688841268,
0.7073135972,
0.1193823144,
-0.1001682654,
0.4742111564,
0.1646478176,
-0.3022066951,
-0.3175039291,
0.000599798,
-0.0185424164,
0.7845314145,
0.2690439522,
-0.6468861103,
-0.2268399596,
0.0467021465,
-0.2461894602,
0.1984426379,
-0.2344363481,
0.7023296356,
0.0423820354,
-0.7630195618,
0.604753077,
0.0891800672,
0.2832662165,
-0.1894582361,
-0.1037739441,
-0.1771742254,
0.3785358667,
-0.1916541606,
-0.9728424549,
0.5972706079,
-0.0530126318,
-0.4886532426,
-0.1857968122,
0.5493552685,
-0.2417163402,
-0.5332191586,
0.0948126167,
0.6388415694,
-0.0726929158,
-0.2867514193,
-0.3945843875,
-0.3704849184,
-0.284886837,
-0.1940053254,
-0.1625746489,
0.6166844368,
-0.302010417,
0.789644897,
-0.0584996417,
-0.2796034217,
-0.0839804709,
0.2469302267,
0.879894495,
-0.6035283804,
-0.2514398098,
-0.7870390415,
0.5422096848,
0.073895894,
0.0278926864,
0.5023534298,
0.4787602723,
0.7676708102,
-0.4254021943,
1.03459692,
-0.2037838548,
0.5316592455,
-0.6286293268,
0.2821534872,
-0.1420533955,
0.2708404362,
0.0675842762,
-0.9169775248,
-0.3365191221,
0.7866578102,
-0.3533474505,
0.020649964,
0.8635034561,
0.6993165016,
-0.3040631115,
0.2611471713,
0.1953783929,
0.0220837779,
0.4192609191,
0.7549046874,
1.0263717175,
-0.5948470831,
0.7324842215,
-0.2523087561,
-0.0438734852,
0.1411745399,
-0.7315770984,
-1.0427470207,
-0.4902082086,
-0.2089400738,
-0.3411401808,
-0.4754851162,
0.8766236305,
0.4839051366,
-0.8243584633,
0.2044579238,
-0.2541924417,
-0.0279075392,
-0.4109809697,
-0.2809669673,
0.3373641074,
-0.2398744375,
-0.7895460725,
0.293821305,
0.1827140898,
-0.006509983,
-0.2912258506,
-0.0456430539,
0.0437005349,
0.2046514601,
0.9325920939,
-0.0386090837,
-0.9374554753,
-0.4109823108,
0.3576842248,
-0.1077869907,
-0.1779269725,
0.8316238523,
-1.1511359215,
0.1636603326,
0.4357745945,
0.6039557457,
0.3454571962,
-0.0886914283,
0.5186484456,
-0.7625709772,
0.0597476251,
0.212955907,
0.2768581808,
0.2175977081,
-0.2323621809,
0.7221313715,
-0.0251266435,
-0.3465054035,
-0.2750612795,
0.6699637175,
-0.9805497527,
-0.2656498551,
1.1325514317,
0.0268356632,
0.2271062434,
-0.1612911671,
-0.3246610165,
0.1857981682,
-0.228006795,
0.7506760359,
0.693479836,
-0.3556459844,
-0.3287911713,
-0.6029849648,
0.5804610848,
0.2362155169,
-0.8591971993,
0.0371700078,
0.5189015269,
0.1549189836,
0.3041700423,
0.4089074731,
0.011153575,
0.2878686488,
-0.2894658744,
-0.3386187255,
0.000347737,
-0.4118032455,
-0.257504791,
0.094119817,
-0.0530168042,
0.125243172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08921v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08921v3
|
Self-Improving for Zero-Shot Named Entity Recognition with Large Language Models
| 2023-11-15T12:47:52 | 2024-03-21T00:27:37 |
Tingyu Xie, Qi Li, Yan Zhang, Zuozhu Liu, Hongwei Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Exploring the application of powerful large language models (LLMs) on the
named entity recognition (NER) task has drawn much attention recently. This
work pushes the performance boundary of zero-shot NER with LLMs by proposing a
training-free self-improving framework, which utilizes an unlabeled corpus to
stimulate the self-learning ability of LLMs. First, we use the LLM to make
predictions on the unlabeled corpus using self-consistency and obtain a
self-annotated dataset. Second, we explore various strategies to select
reliable annotations to form a reliable self-annotated dataset. Finally, for
each test input, we retrieve demonstrations from the reliable self-annotated
dataset and perform inference via in-context learning. Experiments on four
benchmarks show substantial performance improvements achieved by our framework.
Through comprehensive experimental analysis, we find that increasing the size
of unlabeled corpus or iterations of self-improving does not guarantee further
improvement, but the performance might be boosted via more advanced strategies
for reliable annotation selection. Code and data are publicly available at
https://github.com/Emma1066/Self-Improve-Zero-Shot-NER
|
[
-0.2220759839,
-0.3802753687,
0.6282442808,
0.0389795378,
-0.29694888,
0.1379570961,
-0.4837082922,
-0.6007945538,
0.4378697276,
0.6494665146,
-0.1069691107,
-0.458301723,
-0.7234476209,
0.5255342126,
-0.5867275,
1.0829542875,
-0.0306462497,
0.0586990677,
-0.1131900921,
-0.1671837568,
-0.5495031476,
-0.4228181839,
-0.6428030729,
-0.3771848977,
0.6147989035,
0.5265637636,
0.1265400797,
0.8560364842,
0.3433676064,
0.2063135505,
0.1171733439,
-0.0095402086,
-0.4748937488,
0.4923685491,
-0.2090441585,
-0.0706639215,
-0.3346404433,
-0.3117817044,
0.9430650473,
0.4309161901,
0.0149643747,
0.3184266984,
0.0892213657,
0.324497968,
-0.7892610431,
0.1780675799,
-0.8468087912,
-0.1456349343,
-0.4394590557,
-0.2243921161,
-0.3217639923,
0.3060278594,
-0.0693399534,
-0.4109326601,
0.2571330667,
-0.0698766187,
0.684058845,
0.4163708687,
-0.2114834487,
0.0211315732,
-0.7808892131,
0.6855418086,
-0.67905581,
0.4740741253,
0.2668644488,
0.0554614849,
-0.398868829,
-0.3443839848,
-0.5379570127,
-0.2236273885,
0.0922917128,
0.018500464,
-0.2459805161,
-0.0413392447,
0.378218621,
0.1768720448,
-0.3040861785,
0.5120232105,
-0.175475955,
-0.2369284332,
0.6571596265,
-0.1579950452,
0.1306220293,
-0.0760628954,
-0.3983451426,
0.1440786868,
-0.8299707174,
-0.2211259305,
0.0282781832,
0.5349590182,
0.2168564349,
0.5268335938,
-0.5253010392,
0.518768847,
0.2938756049,
-0.0618359298,
0.4888899326,
0.1965116411,
-0.3524884284,
0.4384822845,
0.7593749166,
0.071924299,
0.2390418798,
-0.5756026506,
-0.5366271734,
-0.2025752217,
0.0723255426,
-1.0037965775,
-0.2721871436,
0.1773957163,
-0.0830866247,
-0.1260331422,
-0.3186475635,
-0.637137711,
-0.4011085331,
-0.3192082047,
0.6791994572,
-0.4196466208,
-0.2750143707,
-0.0765192658,
0.2072791606,
0.1093508378,
0.5003048182,
-1.0278549194,
0.093776688,
0.417763412,
0.7019099593,
-0.1418236494,
-0.3203526139,
-0.8045259118,
0.3675366044,
-0.5020236969,
1.1036387682,
-0.3854246736,
-0.280788511,
-0.3011898994,
-0.0869404897,
-0.0450762771,
-0.649361968,
0.398797214,
-0.4092483521,
-0.1734714508,
-0.0906324089,
-0.9451156855,
0.051304806,
0.3212633133,
-0.4986810088,
1.1026549339,
-0.1312511414,
-0.7055556774,
0.4178080559,
-0.6350319982,
-0.2452689111,
0.5270961523,
-0.3452201486,
-0.4477964938,
0.3155460954,
0.2764719129,
0.7438260317,
0.0291212201,
0.2207800001,
-0.4754311442,
-0.4216673076,
0.1451421231,
-0.3158868253,
0.3970082402,
-0.0801417306,
-0.5264413953,
-0.0225666594,
-1.0393021107,
0.0191050321,
0.3316404223,
-0.3579761982,
-0.3623160422,
-0.2251690775,
-0.2623563409,
-0.0615999177,
0.161090672,
-0.9681045413,
0.2871519029,
-0.4119433463,
0.1352262944,
0.6356053948,
0.0660156608,
0.5759415627,
0.1090963557,
0.2234347165,
0.0007878725,
-0.2749648094,
-0.3150398731,
0.0260754135,
-0.891895771,
-0.4855149388,
0.9034097791,
0.3017798066,
-0.6764484048,
0.2061869949,
-0.2924382091,
-0.4230289757,
-0.4848351181,
0.3004029393,
0.4228883088,
0.758208096,
0.6832405925,
-0.3608228564,
-0.5704101324,
-0.7829508781,
-0.0208551213,
-0.0335154608,
-0.0483959615,
0.2406713068,
0.6123448014,
-0.327822715,
0.9616772532,
-0.2223945111,
-0.5414460897,
-0.2244078368,
0.172168687,
-0.0365882516,
0.4161120355,
0.3780947328,
-0.1999638677,
-0.4500148594,
-0.2404269129,
-0.7789283395,
-0.2131671607,
-0.0811125487,
-0.0362610631,
0.3520236611,
0.5360148549,
-0.3665075004,
0.4000865221,
0.3362433612,
-0.0422572307,
0.5665279031,
-0.3519769013,
-0.1637090594,
-0.8745399117,
-0.1059687361,
0.0432719029,
-0.2947072089,
-0.7306547761,
-0.2604650855,
0.3337020278,
0.1356226802,
-0.3757684827,
0.9176666141,
-0.8908199668,
-0.1233150065,
-0.6363013387,
0.2081914544,
-0.3566563427,
0.3305272162,
0.2535713017,
0.7953793406,
0.8262376785,
-0.6488584876,
0.0435413048,
0.1108463034,
-0.2326174676,
0.5363089442,
-0.5062684417,
0.1363013387,
-0.3994047344,
0.1440696865,
-0.6206746101,
-0.2688440382,
0.385848105,
-0.4719158709,
0.7793638706,
-0.2418903559,
-0.4869998991,
-0.0923637524,
-0.0217962619,
0.3069798052,
0.1584085971,
-0.8048308492,
0.603685379,
0.3983843327,
0.15065974,
-0.733592391,
-0.5600437522,
0.3950368464,
-0.0788815394,
0.0008664363,
0.4173390269,
-0.0485946648,
0.2020935863,
-0.0690444261,
-0.2214915305,
-0.0424979404,
0.0960798338,
0.3758054674,
0.1532184482,
-0.0552191399,
0.6191092134,
-0.1085445806,
-0.3204863369,
-0.0208884291,
-0.341260761,
0.3149096966,
-0.1110355854,
-0.0461030379,
-0.4368817508,
-0.0803339705,
-0.0008360027,
-0.451708734,
0.6463332772,
0.5243737102,
-0.4622243345,
-0.3707993627,
-0.771981895,
-0.0990398899,
-0.3793889284,
0.1390511543,
-0.5054252744,
-1.2423950434,
0.2413333505,
-0.2137925774,
-0.0582180396,
0.5631123781,
0.3233852983,
-0.1999710202,
0.4679240584,
0.7425082922,
-0.1417740732,
0.4111245275,
-0.2734667659,
0.1314870417,
-1.0785058737,
-0.1471670866,
-0.3794467449,
-0.1398178786,
-0.5053193569,
-0.308832556,
-0.1421567947,
0.2529884875,
-0.2150429189,
0.6020290852,
-0.5441857576,
0.6227998137,
0.4721640944,
-0.1719803661,
0.2052304298,
0.0030242468,
-0.216589421,
-0.0847977176,
-0.4352210164,
-0.4394035339,
1.1778352261,
0.3088614047,
0.7011547685,
0.0097200889,
1.3525727987,
0.0606055669,
0.5228185654,
-0.6788988113,
0.6190400124,
0.1254233122,
-0.533202529,
-0.4770928919,
-0.5893288255,
-1.1649762392,
0.1691658199,
-0.4444399476,
-0.9449242353,
0.1969826221,
0.2817185521,
-0.5388416648,
0.4334645867,
-0.3644758761,
0.8014034033,
-0.5874429941,
-0.2141688019,
0.2168744653,
-0.39570871,
0.0147884618,
-0.4212017059,
-0.1145536155,
-0.4619806409,
-0.0898256227,
0.5716517568,
0.056435518,
0.7216686606,
-0.2386826873,
-0.1085482314,
0.1661768407,
0.1855999082,
0.2781454623,
0.1489030123,
-0.1690502018,
0.6550084949,
-0.1224361658,
-0.222125873,
-0.6859281063,
0.7231976986,
-0.5980887413,
-0.5649894476,
-0.5659038424,
-0.270794183,
-0.1322270036,
0.5097901821,
0.1283089966,
0.4688225687,
-0.1868578792,
0.3717567623,
0.7040184736,
-0.021622939,
0.7436928153,
0.6313813925,
-0.3483938873,
-0.6070804,
0.8125559092,
0.6063806415,
-0.0228768792,
0.551007688,
-0.1103234142,
-0.4858893454,
-0.8087415099,
-0.7444554567,
0.4106497467,
-0.4075313807,
-0.6560428143,
-0.7707588077,
-0.2898129523,
-0.614151299,
0.206881851,
-0.5622004271,
-0.3834967315,
-0.5735601783,
-0.1050551757,
0.313098222,
0.5909075141,
-0.1604126692,
0.2291106582,
-0.5287512541,
0.0472322851,
0.0271744169,
0.5913798213,
0.0361577272,
-0.7424453497,
-0.3156044483,
-0.1448289007,
-0.1642889231,
-0.804987371,
0.445763737,
0.3218732774,
0.5969519019,
0.3309661448,
0.2369865626,
0.667350173,
-0.665043354,
0.2718506455,
0.2126226723,
-0.823086679,
0.6304042339,
-0.2536070943,
0.2863157094,
0.6267717481,
0.2621321082,
-0.438347131,
-0.1841637045,
-0.642973423,
-0.7616791129,
0.4471713305,
0.2368628234,
0.1628564596,
-0.2820145786,
0.7554789782,
-0.1123131588,
0.1639786512,
-0.9034966826,
-0.2928936183,
-0.0831418782,
-0.0491415635,
-0.1533483565,
-0.4300783277,
0.3154070079,
-0.1417128593,
1.0138278008,
-0.394007355,
0.2248915881,
0.4506327212,
-0.2878111601,
-0.1196978837,
0.4364708066,
0.2546630204,
0.3164170384,
-0.1179105267,
0.1591641605,
0.580735147,
-0.0689864308,
0.2313159406,
0.2532534301,
-0.5029966235,
0.0216461811,
0.0209345017,
0.7758726478,
0.5211468935,
-0.5359880328,
0.4972514808,
-0.0882546082,
-0.0968345106,
-0.6534999013,
0.1766215712,
-0.0200188644,
0.3652892411,
0.348644644,
-0.3295981288,
0.1614612192,
-0.1634747535,
0.1841675043,
0.629316926,
-0.3985413313,
-0.0998924449,
0.5870826244,
-0.0434964709,
-0.3132112622,
0.5959336758,
-0.4955648482,
-0.1618959457,
0.2741985321,
0.7466025352,
0.9453894496,
-0.3353147805,
0.3015475571,
0.5586528182,
0.1107176766,
-0.2149033844,
-0.0295388587,
-0.2814871073,
-0.8368085027,
-0.4927629828,
-0.939627111,
-0.4358530939,
0.324383527,
-0.3288219273,
0.4280439317,
-0.5474231243,
-0.1878702343,
0.2070263326,
0.120016247,
-0.4983893037,
0.4036395252,
0.3760502338,
0.6569922566,
-0.3114439547,
0.9570860267,
0.6180215478,
-0.5566620231,
-0.871348083,
0.0378737636,
-0.2523843348,
-0.5036671162,
0.7148811817,
0.5081090331,
-0.0901948288,
0.123747319,
-0.4203746617,
-1.4088429213,
1.1547852755,
0.5875005126,
-0.9694753289,
0.1174537614,
0.0791409835,
0.6776657104,
-0.6235746741,
0.4816218913,
0.1748748273,
0.0738006234,
0.1891795248,
-0.8781071901,
-0.1518703252,
0.0517817587,
0.2268489003,
0.5233849883,
-0.5597532988,
0.3514272273,
-0.4118667245,
-0.3791154027,
0.1175769493,
1.0325088501,
0.0341444276,
0.3839415312,
0.4346461594,
0.86833179,
0.7438829541,
0.0897614434,
0.6745032668,
-0.437513262,
0.5203877091,
1.7734979391,
-0.4992879331,
1.2011152506,
0.2344311923,
0.2799564898,
0.4901270568,
0.5318201184,
-0.4227078855,
0.2524831295,
0.2514427304,
-0.3631106913,
-0.4236876369,
-0.1153538823,
-0.1259570867,
0.8516702652,
-0.0211325623,
-0.4542790055,
-0.4603630006,
-0.0327154361,
0.0986759663,
-0.1778106093,
-0.4028488398,
0.9295402765,
-0.0265976377,
-0.2868584394,
0.4444032013,
0.0593321174,
0.6653859615,
-0.2144104242,
0.0521975569,
-0.0266186558,
0.1719834656,
-0.2487925589,
-0.5723519921,
0.1357524246,
0.1034562439,
-0.1716411114,
-0.1010505036,
1.0944463015,
-0.5414280295,
-0.5209771395,
0.7029331326,
0.4552270472,
0.5379334688,
-0.2273959816,
-0.5703064203,
-0.2336872369,
-0.202265054,
-0.1396141648,
0.5563758016,
0.3918623328,
0.0670438036,
0.6201914549,
0.6957671642,
0.2101792246,
-0.0843925849,
0.2382293195,
0.5887387395,
-0.7856858969,
0.0353562087,
-0.904663682,
0.2673142254,
-0.0957455859,
-0.2508318424,
0.7802518606,
0.6971561313,
1.2495926619,
0.1333067715,
0.4819104373,
0.2278654724,
0.8030467629,
-0.1858237833,
0.6524713039,
-0.5121311545,
0.1571266055,
-0.2007381916,
-1.0037690401,
-0.5272651911,
0.5212017298,
-0.3509495854,
-0.0070196986,
0.2515432239,
0.8518494368,
0.1512372047,
-0.2811148465,
0.6919819713,
0.3190335929,
0.1640120894,
0.1151507795,
0.6197385192,
-0.4881623089,
0.4120819271,
-0.4546821415,
-0.1025569737,
0.0675525591,
-1.0592924356,
-0.8890964389,
-0.2860461175,
-0.6435793638,
-0.2051588744,
0.1391114295,
1.1507499218,
0.6483173966,
-0.8091107011,
-0.0514437072,
0.033819858,
-0.2068323195,
0.214538902,
-0.151662752,
0.0948844627,
-0.5593920946,
-0.5970458984,
0.5705166459,
0.6488518119,
0.1605124921,
-0.1735939533,
0.004845012,
-0.1257421523,
-0.0172992609,
0.5965325832,
0.5802298188,
-0.7375164032,
-0.3917033374,
-0.1215462536,
0.0743355229,
0.2317079604,
0.4155848324,
-0.9978014827,
0.5549628735,
-0.097212486,
0.9528250694,
0.5051746964,
-0.1469990015,
0.0097973999,
-0.6429700255,
-0.4874569178,
0.1486445516,
0.5540944934,
0.6727495193,
-0.46599406,
0.6726704836,
0.1499893069,
-0.8297891021,
-0.7362416983,
-0.0693465769,
-0.7658005357,
0.0607036054,
1.183524847,
-0.1282784492,
-0.3482581079,
0.0851556733,
0.0759087726,
0.3430844843,
-0.6194757223,
0.8772388101,
0.3268865645,
-0.399167031,
-0.3868982494,
-0.3917490542,
0.239648506,
0.3279416859,
-0.7070987821,
0.1135215163,
0.5852676034,
0.7906253934,
0.1522371471,
0.8362799287,
-0.0162847601,
-0.0467920862,
-0.422725141,
0.4619666338,
-0.0441417471,
-0.5807430744,
-0.7620372772,
0.093830213,
0.1381843686,
-0.0241418183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08896v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08896v2
|
HeLM: Highlighted Evidence augmented Language Model for Enhanced Table-to-Text Generation
| 2023-11-15T12:02:52 | 2024-04-27T12:51:11 |
Junyi Bian, Xiaolei Qin, Wuhe Zou, Mengzuo Huang, Congyi Luo, Ke Zhang, Weidong Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large models have demonstrated significant progress across various domains,
particularly in tasks related to text generation. In the domain of Table to
Text, many Large Language Model (LLM)-based methods currently resort to
modifying prompts to invoke public APIs, incurring potential costs and
information leaks. With the advent of open-source large models, fine-tuning
LLMs has become feasible. In this study, we conducted parameter-efficient
fine-tuning on the LLaMA2 model. Distinguishing itself from previous
fine-tuning-based table-to-text methods, our approach involves injecting
reasoning information into the input by emphasizing table-specific row data.
Our model consists of two modules: 1) a table reasoner that identifies relevant
row evidence, and 2) a table summarizer that generates sentences based on the
highlighted table. To facilitate this, we propose a search strategy to
construct reasoning labels for training the table reasoner. On both the FetaQA
and QTSumm datasets, our approach achieved state-of-the-art results.
Additionally, we observed that highlighting input tables significantly enhances
the model's performance and provides valuable interpretability.
|
[
-0.2994565964,
-0.7503354549,
0.7940837741,
0.0851756856,
-0.4606965184,
-0.3436146975,
-0.2292467058,
-0.4288317561,
0.0124314921,
0.8806601167,
-0.3231001496,
-0.6906575561,
-0.4772887528,
0.2246001959,
-0.5809049606,
1.2725044489,
-0.0717413351,
-0.1385865211,
-0.2234702408,
0.0239504036,
-0.638115108,
-0.2802040279,
-0.3053849339,
-0.3084338009,
0.6842983365,
0.9467650056,
0.6747357249,
1.0184389353,
0.3490290642,
0.1517982781,
-0.2779890895,
0.5558097959,
-0.4926733673,
0.2886467874,
-0.4382787943,
-0.3786263466,
-0.6923197508,
-0.3194913864,
0.297841996,
0.5236964822,
0.1015485302,
0.1421810538,
0.045796182,
0.4411714673,
-0.6447518468,
0.2984404564,
-1.0088968277,
-0.2073597908,
-0.4715184867,
-0.2208872437,
-0.661648035,
-0.2969184816,
-0.0438117757,
-0.6247308254,
0.0978907421,
0.2091087848,
0.7358563542,
0.2431243807,
-0.6467688084,
-0.2026889324,
-0.42016837,
0.6882283688,
-0.8120802641,
0.3845433295,
0.3789924085,
0.2214108407,
-0.2847091258,
-1.0178951025,
-0.8138601184,
-0.182371676,
-0.3017756045,
0.0209766794,
-0.1435263455,
0.0910574198,
0.316006422,
0.4266686141,
-0.3172337413,
0.2954288721,
-0.1005668417,
-0.1287374347,
0.4961743057,
0.1870923936,
0.2634122074,
-0.0566983595,
-0.1464190036,
-0.1702100635,
-0.8922426701,
-0.216224879,
-0.0419224016,
0.5866281986,
-0.1256373227,
0.8239732981,
-0.6478877068,
0.8854750395,
-0.0182641502,
-0.1565745324,
-0.1582635045,
-0.1484445781,
-0.107616432,
0.2157886028,
0.4451580346,
0.6278988123,
0.0860022008,
-0.2043507248,
-0.3657738268,
0.1817288399,
0.0783113092,
-0.9503198862,
-0.2691383064,
0.1942029148,
-0.202726081,
-0.5067101717,
-0.1273895353,
-0.7533046603,
-0.7124586105,
-0.2655219138,
0.5001382232,
-0.0194736943,
0.0189279392,
-0.0095877331,
-0.3264515102,
0.1963132024,
0.4667735994,
-0.8817551732,
0.2748508751,
0.6932729483,
0.5453783274,
-0.6354296803,
0.1561580896,
-0.8385640979,
0.4724182189,
-0.4349108934,
1.0399026871,
-0.5020621419,
-0.1839505583,
0.300193131,
-0.2092616707,
0.3612428606,
-0.6801675558,
0.7497425079,
-0.7170296311,
0.1145282239,
-0.5776998997,
-0.4921452999,
-0.166026786,
0.2018723488,
-0.6216369271,
0.9910084009,
0.0195466951,
-0.7817938924,
0.7670930624,
-0.7450390458,
-0.678160727,
0.033592362,
-0.3075690269,
-0.7561661005,
-0.0404482149,
0.857290566,
0.5161888003,
-0.5743649602,
0.7042780519,
-0.2082865834,
-0.0997373983,
0.2118748724,
-0.0918207318,
0.349170655,
0.1157727316,
-0.4309326708,
0.6026895046,
-0.9318831563,
-0.2237811536,
0.1188074872,
-0.4981958568,
-0.0567083731,
0.1082143635,
0.2281325459,
0.0031606338,
0.144094184,
-0.3904132247,
0.0451814681,
-0.3250445724,
0.3373742998,
0.3966220319,
0.2980442345,
0.2506827414,
-0.357026875,
0.104925774,
0.1841134578,
-0.0951761007,
-0.2857531309,
-0.4953028858,
-1.0161383152,
-0.3202183545,
0.3842681348,
0.480427891,
-0.9052013755,
0.3179583848,
-0.1794117689,
-0.3202261329,
-0.0498979613,
-0.0068974057,
0.244814381,
0.9447233677,
0.7845631838,
0.0718883052,
-0.5862122178,
-1.155367732,
-0.3239167333,
0.0434929915,
-0.1174437776,
0.3727826476,
0.4402533472,
-0.3159977794,
1.1543275118,
-0.5712893009,
-0.2454575747,
-0.6549683809,
-0.0115807317,
0.3944280744,
0.5092562437,
0.4244213104,
-0.6055335999,
-0.3550246358,
0.3145866692,
-0.6159026623,
-0.5111154318,
-0.0434307456,
-0.1636782289,
-0.0903048515,
0.6497625709,
-0.4365862608,
0.475348562,
0.0652559623,
-0.4029623568,
0.4644672573,
0.1118641123,
0.0740069672,
-0.9774214625,
0.1553403139,
-0.041165594,
-0.2245920151,
-0.7068510056,
0.1752083004,
0.2164106667,
-0.1466059089,
-0.234060809,
0.6544046998,
-0.3321607113,
0.061056409,
-0.5681565404,
0.0624137037,
0.0933461338,
0.487436831,
0.0776488855,
1.0479351282,
0.3373369873,
-0.7746432424,
-0.0062015117,
0.5600609183,
-0.3894455731,
0.3672689497,
-0.8233079314,
-0.0688723549,
0.1749442965,
0.1025613919,
-0.9684636593,
-0.5347003937,
0.035127148,
-0.0540816896,
0.4576352537,
0.0395911485,
-0.598441422,
0.0042564236,
-0.2720977664,
0.3216394186,
0.3424470723,
-0.8904657364,
0.5010188222,
0.5608359575,
-0.4853867888,
-0.36694929,
-0.6222492456,
0.3673218191,
-0.3140456378,
-0.5402111411,
0.577037394,
0.3570332825,
-0.4424473643,
-0.5578306913,
-0.1530028135,
0.0264965743,
0.1365510821,
0.146144405,
0.1036855578,
-0.1998810917,
0.2811315656,
0.647172451,
-0.1604249775,
0.0611802265,
-0.0987653434,
0.4099720716,
0.098771207,
-0.1134197339,
-0.348737359,
0.2808909118,
0.3834395409,
-0.4070101082,
0.607462883,
0.3084015548,
-0.2196579278,
-0.3636848629,
-0.7736756206,
-0.5293191075,
-0.4637126923,
0.4739196599,
-0.0283747278,
-0.9822183847,
0.5763229132,
-0.3903099,
0.22782664,
0.6989836097,
0.7451760769,
0.0695576817,
0.9379635453,
0.4956605136,
0.2138389349,
0.3516639471,
0.1497939527,
-0.2069772184,
-0.7192848325,
-0.2273373157,
-0.6598893404,
-0.1813757569,
-0.2939571738,
-0.3271070421,
0.6499506831,
0.0349174514,
-0.2565009594,
0.0848170593,
-0.4285230935,
0.3931259215,
0.6428750753,
0.3830109239,
0.5079338551,
0.034391135,
-0.2220193744,
0.0001326673,
-0.7891213894,
-0.503511548,
0.9813753366,
0.3155840337,
0.566175282,
0.0628251582,
0.4069695473,
0.4386730194,
0.5105903149,
-0.4492679834,
0.5985994339,
-0.0021724612,
-0.5040832758,
-0.2659493387,
-0.2842264175,
-0.8104559183,
0.1772817224,
-0.6632905602,
-0.5923109055,
0.2180783749,
0.3168615103,
-0.0890850946,
0.0619577803,
-0.5232000351,
0.8012697697,
-0.0661162436,
-0.5924077034,
-0.2229436189,
-0.408577323,
0.4749818146,
-0.0136281289,
0.0140340617,
0.1688999981,
0.0877694488,
0.9168586135,
-0.8718549013,
0.8387011886,
-0.1301698387,
-0.3559824526,
0.2200705558,
-0.072200872,
0.857778132,
0.2545256317,
-0.1874350458,
-0.037089102,
-0.5488446355,
-0.0726910383,
-0.3741203249,
0.5041674972,
-0.4082474709,
-0.8066781759,
-0.0234397221,
-0.821189642,
-0.4968788326,
0.2899567187,
0.283026278,
0.4016852379,
0.1515781581,
0.2546327114,
0.8761254549,
-0.4693600535,
0.1730189025,
0.3626906574,
-0.4853307307,
-0.5573012829,
0.6696131229,
-0.1116880402,
-0.0541188866,
0.6241911054,
0.231415242,
-0.2636454999,
-0.9250352979,
-0.6688591838,
0.081983991,
-0.6229797602,
-0.6151567101,
-0.7806952596,
0.1165691465,
-0.198156938,
-0.0118874796,
0.0054653431,
-0.7120685577,
-0.3867115676,
-0.359306097,
0.8598099947,
0.620434165,
0.206689015,
0.6485344172,
-0.4894188643,
0.5487918854,
0.646034956,
0.4197763503,
-0.0425908491,
-0.6428705454,
-0.2434357405,
-0.1410584897,
-0.2608622909,
-1.1899112463,
0.1190359369,
0.2196926028,
0.509231329,
0.402476728,
0.2119692266,
0.5404367447,
-0.443128109,
0.5904852748,
0.0025769309,
-0.9845244288,
0.7945479155,
-0.6247212887,
0.2518537641,
0.5629234314,
-0.1781543642,
-0.0737798139,
-0.4386637807,
-0.124274455,
-1.0759886503,
0.606875658,
0.1642211676,
-0.3342972994,
-0.0729150474,
0.4444279671,
0.2647583187,
0.1787426323,
-0.7795869708,
0.0360516123,
0.0062584053,
-0.1765215248,
0.2591162324,
-0.5762161613,
-0.1172065288,
-0.3171208501,
0.7357652187,
-0.1906971186,
-0.1582138985,
0.0710623786,
-0.3860477805,
-0.0429158732,
0.4868904352,
0.7109525204,
0.6181923151,
-0.0259244163,
0.1725103408,
0.5521570444,
-0.3961658478,
-0.2618612647,
0.2175913155,
-0.4700671732,
0.0599145256,
0.3730900288,
0.9157865644,
0.2611317933,
-0.6475909352,
0.4103796184,
0.15549694,
-0.1703211516,
0.1769472957,
0.2322111875,
-0.0148738539,
0.3601209521,
0.5052576065,
-0.3596894145,
0.394988358,
-0.3368162215,
0.2639405727,
0.4057460129,
-0.3606373072,
0.0673487782,
0.9167326093,
0.2248310447,
0.1031623185,
0.4495856464,
0.0760128573,
-0.4956185222,
0.4338370562,
0.5484770536,
0.4725753069,
0.098043181,
-0.1031217128,
0.2771303654,
0.3185078502,
-0.0770155638,
0.4284825623,
-0.2601230741,
-0.4952538013,
-0.4986326396,
-0.523549974,
-0.5413154364,
0.1363992393,
-0.7261055708,
0.2656454146,
-0.1567080915,
-0.1753254086,
0.0729389861,
-0.2399630249,
-0.4151437879,
0.2111863643,
-0.1099531949,
1.0994861126,
-0.7970954776,
0.6242421865,
0.4047619104,
-0.2095385939,
-0.7486923933,
-0.1955824047,
-0.3061607182,
-0.6612145305,
0.553219378,
0.1616632789,
0.1919680387,
-0.09380389,
-0.705776453,
-0.6037687659,
1.0262788534,
0.4819401205,
-0.6267611384,
0.2971681356,
0.3534373641,
0.3772684038,
-0.228410393,
0.1989257485,
0.8085383177,
0.7333126664,
-0.1181801334,
-0.8923831582,
0.2782586217,
-0.1285532564,
-0.0570829771,
0.2107355446,
-0.0962160453,
0.7074737549,
-0.3605204821,
-0.18093732,
-0.0528350025,
1.0496895313,
0.5744092464,
0.4889897704,
0.3022347093,
0.5734544992,
0.6494703293,
-0.2231226861,
0.882547915,
-0.1738943905,
-0.0865121856,
1.0709639788,
-0.4648531079,
0.8608759642,
0.476092875,
0.0280235801,
0.4415776134,
0.2639901638,
-0.13519153,
0.5532386303,
0.1571229249,
0.0620001554,
-0.3388050795,
-0.3580699861,
-0.4840035737,
0.3996780515,
0.5748026967,
-0.5915766954,
-0.4019600153,
-0.0828589052,
0.0529357828,
0.3447664082,
-0.5996002555,
1.1009652615,
-0.170726791,
-0.6397455931,
0.3743456006,
0.1622838825,
0.5808427334,
-0.3225164711,
-0.3379434943,
-0.2889613509,
-0.0343889557,
-0.4011304677,
-0.6784209609,
0.0576775111,
0.3005499542,
-0.2799243331,
-0.0892304033,
0.8189411759,
-0.3965750039,
-0.348813802,
-0.1999039948,
0.5665165186,
-0.1752991974,
-0.2071766704,
-0.0358393341,
0.1069944352,
-0.0528484806,
-0.1442621648,
0.2822284102,
0.417360723,
-0.334903121,
0.3840153515,
0.7465996742,
-0.0568639264,
-0.3056719899,
0.111339651,
1.1612268686,
-0.6634131074,
-0.7482697368,
-0.8149167299,
0.4647417963,
-0.2893433273,
-0.3946725428,
0.6174321771,
0.7837045789,
0.3216686845,
-0.1792321354,
0.5530236363,
0.3158402145,
0.8379419446,
-0.7225952744,
0.9550594091,
-0.4680476785,
0.3684375286,
-0.3053659499,
-0.807990849,
-0.4543245733,
0.4610131979,
-0.2273262888,
-0.0391857587,
0.3193398416,
0.8033494949,
0.0323352702,
0.1704729795,
0.0337690301,
0.4150547683,
0.3673443794,
0.2282004803,
0.6862665415,
-0.2219608724,
0.4931821227,
0.0121800648,
-0.3236703873,
-0.380777061,
-0.9864956737,
-0.95748353,
-0.3895536065,
-0.3463393748,
-0.2049353272,
0.1381009817,
0.671538353,
0.5102655292,
-0.9803171754,
-0.1061302051,
-0.2250082642,
0.1849344075,
-0.2027376592,
-0.1701562107,
0.5540519953,
-0.1843703538,
-0.210848242,
0.4584870934,
0.3818236887,
-0.1883257329,
0.1306910515,
0.1359160841,
0.015607479,
0.0672178417,
0.8181371689,
0.1244987622,
-0.5955453515,
-0.1043914035,
-0.1505982131,
-0.0141559998,
0.1047260687,
0.7285259366,
-0.9397325516,
0.1398775876,
0.4119258523,
0.7128306627,
0.7105333209,
0.0239408482,
0.6299142241,
-0.7402969599,
-0.0273253508,
0.2198711336,
0.4263838232,
0.3020846248,
-0.2820700407,
0.3865273893,
-0.2753920555,
-0.5288726687,
-1.0309085846,
0.2855719924,
-1.1882411242,
-0.1915387064,
1.1818605661,
0.3367608786,
0.0232950281,
-0.1889716238,
-0.3784062564,
0.4844367504,
-0.4951789975,
1.0666126013,
0.1865947694,
0.0063449475,
-0.2561706603,
-0.2568859756,
0.6768437624,
0.4448880851,
-1.207921505,
0.301576376,
0.5366483927,
-0.1145231798,
0.0742974356,
-0.0486577861,
-0.0944973305,
0.5809207559,
-0.0517724641,
0.0493308417,
-0.3490404785,
-0.2730106115,
-0.0722255334,
0.2759019136,
0.2059082985,
0.2702874839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08894v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08894v3
|
Few-shot Transfer Learning for Knowledge Base Question Answering: Fusing Supervised Models with In-Context Learning
| 2023-11-15T11:56:56 | 2024-06-13T12:06:27 |
Mayur Patidar, Riya Sawhney, Avinash Singh, Biswajit Chatterjee, Mausam, Indrajit Bhattacharya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Existing Knowledge Base Question Answering (KBQA) architectures are hungry
for annotated data, which make them costly and time-consuming to deploy. We
introduce the problem of few-shot transfer learning for KBQA, where the target
domain offers only a few labeled examples, but a large labeled training dataset
is available in a source domain. We propose a novel KBQA architecture called
FuSIC-KBQA that performs KB-retrieval using multiple source-trained retrievers,
re-ranks using an LLM and uses this as input for LLM few-shot in-context
learning to generate logical forms. These are further refined using
execution-guided feedback. Experiments over multiple source-target KBQA pairs
of varying complexity show that FuSIC-KBQA significantly outperforms
adaptations of SoTA KBQA models for this setting. Additional experiments show
that FuSIC-KBQA also outperforms SoTA KBQA models in the in-domain setting when
training data is limited.
|
[
-0.3218434155,
-0.9569450617,
0.7912684083,
-0.0392337479,
-0.0182535648,
-0.0776590481,
0.1262793541,
-0.4418708682,
-0.2438695133,
0.6694399118,
-0.8049716353,
-0.3096274436,
-0.5453554392,
0.0489575304,
-0.2952059507,
0.8747987747,
-0.1201148555,
0.0583427548,
-0.5954802632,
-0.2022573501,
-0.5423292518,
-0.4779361784,
-0.3829530478,
-0.3103601336,
0.3578556478,
0.7516738176,
0.2625392377,
0.091165483,
0.4174032807,
0.1493962109,
0.1519856602,
0.2199625224,
-0.7320962548,
-0.0150778824,
-0.0416237935,
-0.5532560349,
-0.1400315464,
-0.1836774647,
0.6744750142,
0.8852154016,
0.2774346173,
0.2501112819,
-0.0639737844,
0.5952963829,
-0.8279076219,
0.161366865,
-0.7424530983,
-0.218488887,
0.0574446321,
-0.0909114331,
-0.786303103,
-0.4423807859,
0.4680325985,
-0.7845278382,
-0.2938936949,
0.0498596504,
0.5769135356,
0.3367068172,
-0.7023823857,
-0.0869859308,
-0.5018416643,
0.6061635017,
-0.5423657894,
0.408967644,
0.4397304952,
0.6761379242,
-0.2351207286,
-0.6310046911,
-0.4262151122,
-0.0208628494,
-0.1418655366,
0.0912507549,
-0.1775549799,
-0.1727924645,
0.1516596973,
-0.4262058139,
-0.5452423096,
-0.3183590472,
-0.6082607508,
-0.0981488749,
0.49737221,
0.1683122516,
-0.120527938,
-0.1853292137,
-0.6452351213,
0.2301363945,
-0.8261890411,
0.1537530571,
-0.1830916405,
0.4806720912,
0.2281744331,
0.4434423447,
-0.4957663715,
1.1064468622,
0.1497478634,
-0.3251003921,
-0.1705401689,
-0.1093579456,
-0.3639974296,
0.0499086343,
0.3609122634,
-0.0279779863,
-0.0187875181,
-0.4336449504,
0.0742145255,
-0.4431465566,
0.2442073375,
-0.887579143,
-0.3840250969,
0.0986435339,
-0.2383401245,
-0.20506607,
0.023575753,
-0.391787678,
-0.2409733534,
-0.110547252,
1.1071945429,
-0.546543777,
0.0967046693,
-0.0751793906,
-0.1468499601,
0.5467177033,
0.5967175961,
-0.6776011586,
0.5056718588,
0.4736769795,
0.4469318688,
-0.1170020327,
-0.3106138408,
-0.7521124482,
0.3952265978,
-0.2979956567,
1.1303852797,
-0.5664257407,
-0.1332749277,
-0.3336293399,
-0.0973844454,
-0.1086701006,
-0.5379419923,
-0.0765271112,
-0.9850959778,
0.2882151604,
-0.5900896788,
-0.80978477,
-0.4522387385,
0.3368457854,
-0.4809805751,
0.8117622137,
0.6205908656,
-0.5606661439,
0.3344774842,
-0.5293921828,
-0.4445545077,
0.0943589061,
-0.1447665989,
-0.113865152,
-0.2286111861,
0.0739051178,
0.5761178136,
-0.123929508,
-0.0044807023,
-0.4025381505,
-0.4615156054,
0.2940099835,
-0.1181988642,
0.7648386359,
0.1402774155,
-0.1215572655,
-0.3523943722,
-0.6276896,
0.1122226566,
-0.015828032,
-0.5973569155,
-0.2540027201,
-0.4235687256,
-0.272780329,
0.397117883,
-0.0021338267,
-0.5688415766,
0.4275363386,
-0.3060965836,
0.1280577779,
0.4278958738,
0.4956714213,
0.7978023887,
-0.40616256,
0.508847177,
0.2355876416,
0.0315453894,
0.1589640826,
-0.4525993764,
-0.4680815339,
-0.1546173841,
0.2501288056,
0.5845362544,
-1.0392161608,
-0.0972134173,
-0.2451713085,
-0.4878832102,
-0.5015232563,
0.3964374065,
0.2331812233,
1.0428156853,
0.5585387945,
0.0298662577,
-0.2519899011,
-0.9141412377,
-0.0856396034,
-0.2825517952,
0.1767315567,
0.5794417858,
0.5486602187,
0.1783804744,
1.1716091633,
-0.5229673386,
-0.2192037851,
-0.3582225442,
0.0570109412,
0.0735905617,
0.1559354514,
0.6217493415,
-0.7451940179,
-0.4711503088,
-0.0107810749,
-0.7525821328,
0.0319150873,
-0.2071456611,
-0.4884707332,
0.1566630006,
0.2805945277,
-0.6230735779,
0.2081420124,
0.2013445348,
-0.0434276238,
0.2760819793,
0.4845682383,
0.3387170434,
-1.0223652124,
0.1835088283,
-0.4681051672,
-0.4558874965,
-0.6781606674,
0.0174411461,
0.169474721,
-0.0344384685,
-1.092792511,
0.6797881126,
-0.1316860616,
-0.075229615,
-0.3088100553,
0.1568787098,
0.2144089788,
0.7681011558,
0.0583508052,
0.608918488,
0.3229924142,
-0.7044612169,
0.4050891399,
0.6857562661,
-0.2477700412,
0.4958534539,
-0.2468398213,
0.2972891033,
-0.3257054687,
0.4748103917,
-1.0770944357,
-0.306745559,
0.3105923235,
-0.388101995,
0.3286023438,
-0.6378149986,
-0.2208754122,
-0.0555580594,
-0.1681661457,
0.5357604623,
0.3852464855,
-0.4948934317,
0.5567680597,
0.0820654109,
-0.1032858789,
-0.659353137,
-0.958859086,
-0.418323189,
-0.0996840373,
-0.7002692819,
0.2433063686,
0.0063055749,
0.0408072881,
0.2701680958,
-0.3079927266,
-0.519528389,
0.2847276032,
0.0321503431,
0.3302830756,
-0.5363682508,
0.1921182871,
0.2183592618,
0.1593987346,
0.0204168949,
-0.4299473464,
0.033007849,
-0.1496535242,
-0.207945466,
-0.0527331159,
0.537879765,
0.2138212919,
0.2221393138,
0.9024055004,
0.3824652433,
-0.6236733198,
-0.1845722646,
-0.4248273373,
-0.2031011432,
-0.3711108863,
0.2671342194,
-0.6096646786,
-1.0992305279,
0.2667007148,
-0.2296525985,
0.1046350822,
0.3288275301,
0.5890461206,
-0.5142917037,
0.4782243073,
0.6741243005,
-0.1143975705,
0.1927815974,
-0.3169236183,
-0.0533727966,
-0.483394891,
-0.2072909623,
-0.2241711318,
-0.3872973919,
-0.1508124918,
-0.153295815,
0.6018859744,
0.3454155624,
-0.4049565196,
0.5447137356,
-0.0696237013,
0.734552443,
0.5674522519,
0.4852306843,
0.4620380104,
-0.1386715025,
0.1355704367,
0.2906786203,
-1.050016284,
-0.2978836,
1.1160533428,
0.062246263,
0.7977001667,
0.4150260985,
0.8990511894,
0.0146523872,
0.4753176868,
-0.8607682586,
0.4098944962,
-0.0164162163,
-0.8112770915,
-0.289373666,
-0.5052869916,
-0.5909296274,
0.0882479846,
-0.4034506083,
-0.6822072268,
0.1823823899,
0.2225400954,
-0.7588551641,
0.1931178123,
-0.8183104396,
1.0157952309,
-0.1374317408,
-0.3776772916,
0.1388824433,
-1.0643324852,
0.7177574039,
-0.1280040443,
-0.1437942833,
0.069170326,
0.0607871749,
0.7461412549,
-0.2514722049,
0.6866905093,
-0.3587623835,
0.1909228861,
0.5915340781,
0.3200124204,
0.3404133618,
-0.0930346325,
0.0457017682,
-0.2807421982,
0.3439466953,
-0.6890671253,
-0.9968142509,
0.536259532,
-0.7290655971,
-0.489533484,
0.0233082753,
-0.4445497096,
-0.7723243833,
0.1694021225,
0.2962198853,
0.3726688921,
-0.033026468,
0.2722416222,
0.8235964179,
0.1102113798,
0.0397502594,
0.393029511,
-0.0304354243,
-0.2164207697,
0.7378258705,
0.1294630617,
0.5420662761,
0.8531095386,
0.1060343161,
-0.2403334528,
-0.2444008589,
-0.6037653685,
0.0351763107,
-1.1341693401,
-0.696064055,
-0.6860380769,
-0.3667055666,
-0.4587321579,
-0.2313393652,
-0.2170955539,
-0.6518211365,
-0.2705248594,
0.0349178314,
0.5456062555,
0.6824956536,
0.3602811992,
0.4585987926,
-0.9709985256,
0.442055285,
0.6813035607,
0.158452943,
-0.145435065,
-0.7881065011,
-0.1786150932,
-0.0167294443,
-0.3669044673,
-1.1845290661,
-0.0689305142,
0.2165904939,
0.5362414122,
-0.0345209278,
0.2155526578,
0.7737163305,
-0.3008470833,
0.5690476894,
-0.0913502574,
-0.6185101867,
0.5168841481,
-0.0281011425,
0.2659012675,
1.0850189924,
0.7704392672,
-0.3389697969,
-0.1017932296,
-0.5067105889,
-0.4541066885,
0.9903345704,
-0.0524220839,
-0.102085121,
0.1839602739,
0.418323189,
0.3804397285,
0.1306419969,
-0.6531787515,
-0.1770413071,
-0.0820353776,
-0.2907463014,
0.5585252047,
-0.0180885922,
-0.1431457698,
-0.1806968898,
0.726493597,
-0.4206524193,
0.4239865541,
0.331926465,
-0.6062881351,
-0.1497012228,
0.4182658494,
0.2999638617,
0.5030364394,
-0.2375551015,
0.1142283976,
0.4812278152,
-0.078738153,
0.2819201946,
-0.0692306533,
-0.2032727599,
-0.2368303686,
0.384490639,
0.5806674957,
0.465099901,
-0.4647526443,
0.762070179,
0.2975674272,
-0.5339220166,
0.1335873902,
0.0824111328,
0.1463231593,
0.4623610973,
0.3933010995,
0.0723697469,
0.3532663882,
-0.4968960881,
0.4054010808,
0.3534883559,
-0.0892603621,
0.024898516,
0.5711479187,
0.1648717672,
0.1638073176,
0.711394906,
0.0119780665,
-0.5247145891,
0.3778288066,
0.5207878351,
0.6358563304,
0.2703539431,
0.2289353609,
0.1739483178,
0.2394983321,
0.0704167411,
0.2872562408,
-0.4553205967,
-0.6223783493,
-0.4346008599,
-0.3834952116,
-0.6393877268,
0.0585119352,
-0.5465260744,
0.3848367035,
-0.4052921236,
0.1266534775,
-0.1068736911,
0.0813455954,
-0.8035346866,
0.0365595706,
0.2671706975,
1.1681848764,
-0.976478219,
0.8114596605,
0.7044482827,
-0.5299473405,
-0.8590479493,
-0.1562523991,
-0.0255715698,
-0.6626662016,
0.7290507555,
0.0008664284,
-0.1725699604,
0.2545298338,
-0.8141276836,
-0.8574277163,
1.3836051226,
0.5784388781,
-0.0729243681,
-0.1893175095,
0.1008098722,
0.2285683751,
-0.2673176825,
0.022114832,
0.6447333097,
0.405394733,
0.2863281071,
-0.6484933496,
-0.003709866,
0.0873698071,
-0.4536828399,
-0.0221653376,
-0.7447066903,
0.2726150751,
-0.2374970317,
-0.0830882192,
0.1323476881,
0.7501847744,
0.3106755614,
0.3526141047,
0.316613704,
0.2908988297,
0.4784873426,
0.1353254765,
0.8699367046,
0.1924908608,
0.2572936416,
1.1911486387,
-0.2618737817,
1.0463949442,
0.5578705072,
-0.2640319169,
0.4747017026,
0.4896640182,
0.2681649029,
0.6813672185,
-0.0857870579,
-0.2401113659,
-0.4849356115,
0.0741663203,
-0.0105378004,
0.5354571939,
0.1708915383,
-0.0124243675,
-0.5028574467,
0.0431029424,
-0.2407780141,
-0.2584919631,
-0.1533612013,
1.0630843639,
0.1592636853,
-0.6340782046,
0.5813901424,
-0.2473263443,
0.3387807906,
-0.7421153188,
-0.2266227752,
-0.3026535511,
-0.2890074551,
-0.3675726652,
-0.7424143553,
0.313990891,
-0.0718675032,
-0.2713012993,
-0.1538928151,
0.9681776762,
-0.5269811749,
-0.3889409602,
-0.0515116341,
0.9007356763,
0.1313068718,
-0.0437534936,
-0.4849328995,
-0.4749751985,
-0.1684863269,
-0.4177956879,
0.4854990542,
0.3879236579,
-0.2129454017,
0.7638929486,
0.329483062,
-0.2533616722,
0.3700934947,
-0.1930394918,
0.9502853751,
-0.5487527847,
-0.2426759154,
-0.596901536,
0.2786487341,
0.4351093173,
-0.1987982243,
0.3549584448,
0.3327018619,
0.8832493424,
-0.1730674952,
0.7385972738,
-0.1649244428,
0.3397806287,
-0.6322546601,
0.5985975862,
-0.5050119758,
0.0662165806,
-0.2699886858,
-0.6092709303,
-0.2875404358,
0.4418279529,
-0.2626971602,
-0.0376057066,
0.5784541368,
0.6998509765,
-0.2038617879,
-0.0379675254,
0.4669364989,
0.0836515278,
-0.0016209884,
1.1800749302,
0.9669035673,
-0.657010138,
0.8975604773,
-0.5334392786,
-0.0842333063,
-0.2571390867,
-0.709610343,
-0.5987854004,
-0.5027891994,
-0.3413712084,
-0.2193312496,
-0.0350663252,
0.9397577643,
0.9267753959,
-0.8557622433,
0.1450281143,
0.3004387021,
0.203997612,
-0.0900378153,
-0.3087438941,
0.2321659923,
-0.2949082851,
-0.2480434924,
0.4917671978,
0.2319809198,
-0.0413893312,
0.0064826012,
0.0958975852,
-0.4496771991,
-0.1255156845,
0.7701659799,
0.306203872,
-0.6100560427,
-0.4312212467,
0.3738662601,
-0.2441073358,
-0.0280930717,
0.6945813894,
-1.2447383404,
0.1482289881,
0.6262942553,
1.4676059484,
0.5453389287,
0.2446723282,
0.3315580785,
-1.1481200457,
-0.2857463658,
0.3371275365,
0.0872576535,
0.1723147184,
-0.5271012187,
0.3421294987,
0.3225346804,
-0.3776930571,
-0.4386584461,
0.1267622113,
-1.2391138077,
-0.4738306999,
1.1198618412,
-0.027611319,
-0.2893550098,
-0.1737218499,
-0.0751415044,
0.0161129795,
-0.1611613035,
0.3424452543,
0.7809207439,
-0.6339863539,
-0.242093578,
-0.4640393853,
0.400806874,
0.3354566991,
-0.9683436751,
-0.0138380826,
0.6168700457,
0.6060658097,
-0.1369864196,
0.8181049228,
0.0451066531,
0.6896169782,
-0.1090320945,
-0.3955393732,
-0.1866969615,
-0.5467712283,
-0.2584574521,
0.2394322157,
0.242048353,
-0.2112298608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08890v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08890v1
|
Large Language Models are legal but they are not: Making the case for a powerful LegalLLM
| 2023-11-15T11:50:10 | 2023-11-15T11:50:10 |
Thanmay Jayakumar, Fauzan Farooqui, Luqman Farooqui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Realizing the recent advances in Natural Language Processing (NLP) to the
legal sector poses challenging problems such as extremely long sequence
lengths, specialized vocabulary that is usually only understood by legal
professionals, and high amounts of data imbalance. The recent surge of Large
Language Models (LLMs) has begun to provide new opportunities to apply NLP in
the legal domain due to their ability to handle lengthy, complex sequences.
Moreover, the emergence of domain-specific LLMs has displayed extremely
promising results on various tasks. In this study, we aim to quantify how
general LLMs perform in comparison to legal-domain models (be it an LLM or
otherwise). Specifically, we compare the zero-shot performance of three
general-purpose LLMs (ChatGPT-20b, LLaMA-2-70b, and Falcon-180b) on the LEDGAR
subset of the LexGLUE benchmark for contract provision classification. Although
the LLMs were not explicitly trained on legal data, we observe that they are
still able to classify the theme correctly in most cases. However, we find that
their mic-F1/mac-F1 performance is up to 19.2/26.8\% lesser than smaller models
fine-tuned on the legal domain, thus underscoring the need for more powerful
legal-domain LLMs.
|
[
-0.1859601587,
-0.6331868172,
0.670409441,
0.0847569183,
-0.5074346066,
0.1949495822,
-0.4860341847,
-0.6674530506,
-0.029604869,
0.8662019968,
0.0807574019,
-0.7270197868,
-0.7524430156,
-0.0156434309,
-0.6788480878,
0.8559814692,
0.3263006806,
0.051309485,
-0.0310782138,
-0.3930144906,
-0.5545328856,
-0.7968738675,
-0.4336754382,
-0.3355832696,
0.2757065296,
-0.1313568056,
0.9298514724,
0.6243286133,
0.5498265624,
0.1995048672,
-0.386982739,
-0.1717377007,
-0.2669150829,
-0.0770619288,
-0.3527287543,
-0.5067272186,
-0.5889721513,
0.0530473813,
0.5364340544,
0.5304903984,
-0.4830828011,
-0.0231196247,
-0.3544022739,
0.6719947457,
-0.6037362218,
0.1207529902,
-0.9581183791,
0.1268385202,
-0.3117659986,
-0.0858934298,
-0.5238930583,
0.0201081876,
0.1130531505,
-0.4848923683,
0.2400422096,
0.4217523932,
1.0230507851,
0.2152430862,
-0.4617128074,
-0.5590359569,
-0.6932149529,
0.6509336233,
-1.1454416513,
0.3072840571,
0.1678155214,
0.4611820579,
-0.1995811611,
-0.6693280339,
-0.4328389466,
-0.7244106531,
0.1737411767,
0.0677260682,
-0.5266730189,
0.2821330726,
0.4149454534,
0.1941180974,
-0.7319694161,
0.7562932372,
-0.1902750731,
-0.066181168,
0.8266032338,
0.1883488894,
0.2962812483,
-0.0517430007,
-0.1608337611,
0.2255750597,
-0.9496293068,
0.0319884568,
0.3086977303,
0.4916569889,
-0.0726906508,
0.8670015335,
0.1319037527,
0.6831268668,
-0.1383881569,
-0.2853640616,
0.0560565144,
0.0363813601,
-0.6198259592,
0.0491743572,
0.964068532,
0.1773848534,
0.6132007241,
-0.2824802697,
-0.3500991464,
-0.2282045931,
0.3022995293,
-0.6877760291,
0.2671945989,
0.2618257403,
-0.4065066874,
0.0822309107,
0.1704863906,
-0.3236146271,
-0.4885603487,
-0.5840627551,
0.1391831785,
-0.2218824923,
-0.2093526721,
0.6146919131,
0.0671180412,
0.5897192359,
0.2573024035,
-0.7156829834,
0.3321929872,
1.1663463116,
0.7059845924,
-0.0749267936,
0.1394579411,
-0.5051169991,
0.0302427448,
-0.6011926532,
0.4981481433,
-0.5491595864,
-0.3465227783,
0.363734901,
-0.0339575559,
-0.1230384037,
-1.0072035789,
0.734118104,
-0.8018269539,
-0.2349882275,
-0.1145828962,
-0.7779012918,
-0.0695373639,
0.2089630961,
-0.4996090829,
0.201289773,
-0.0885961428,
-0.5113832951,
0.7511755228,
-0.5253822207,
-0.5036683679,
0.4690567553,
-0.5209646225,
-0.5091499686,
0.2904675603,
-0.1550489068,
0.6625152826,
-0.6356142163,
0.62030375,
-0.373087436,
-0.5106468201,
0.285607934,
-0.2304887921,
0.738617599,
0.3385114968,
-0.3469050229,
0.0642668456,
-0.5516701341,
-0.1359986812,
0.1515115499,
-0.5069454312,
-0.1789340079,
0.0395791866,
-0.1234914884,
0.3540003002,
-0.1753733009,
-0.4694496393,
0.1228853092,
-0.4858085811,
0.6002757549,
0.4019082785,
-0.4110909402,
0.2634764314,
-0.2306817174,
0.8520204425,
-0.1814988106,
-0.2268041521,
0.2547052503,
-0.5637762547,
-0.6255717874,
-0.53095752,
0.5943762064,
0.521828115,
-0.323038131,
0.2578031123,
-0.5909426212,
-0.3400686085,
-0.4778249264,
0.1616159827,
0.1964865327,
0.0320527032,
0.2083854526,
-0.0630339235,
-0.3037341237,
-0.9927220345,
-0.4341832995,
-0.2140821368,
-0.0306261294,
0.5245710611,
0.5082349181,
-0.2089401931,
0.8798103929,
-0.0769217759,
-0.3547445238,
-0.5350950956,
0.0385778584,
0.5693297982,
-0.0739151612,
0.835662961,
-0.6545724869,
-0.4993724227,
0.2822784185,
-0.8417641521,
-0.2721779346,
-0.1243008152,
0.3280335665,
0.2720199823,
0.5771327615,
-0.9359281063,
0.2468233407,
0.2026880234,
-0.5324779749,
0.6694118977,
-0.2840532362,
-0.2109064013,
-0.5129500031,
0.0519581847,
0.0090725161,
-0.4351543486,
-0.6967215538,
0.3244367838,
0.1504085958,
-0.0558868051,
-0.7725473046,
0.4081152976,
-0.46866256,
-0.3654824793,
-0.5559732318,
-0.0189533625,
-0.1669236571,
0.235428229,
-0.0099950973,
0.8256662488,
0.5512545109,
-0.584736526,
0.4140706956,
0.1374426186,
-0.4420862496,
0.4315879941,
-0.7614592314,
-0.0547998436,
-0.1975053102,
0.0942817777,
-0.335451901,
-0.2472948581,
-0.0767775699,
-0.0372085311,
0.6636375785,
-0.2847296894,
-0.6379490495,
-0.5499597788,
-0.0966267064,
0.3229851723,
0.6618332267,
-0.3007448018,
0.5611810684,
0.318769455,
-0.083157219,
-0.7170793414,
-0.8562214375,
0.529707551,
-0.5357103944,
-0.5217777491,
0.3810896277,
0.3452931643,
-0.5434092283,
0.058476273,
0.0879256353,
0.0039968034,
0.1704239547,
0.3929001987,
-0.063084662,
-0.4400912523,
0.15409787,
-0.3278264701,
0.0516269319,
0.2453519851,
-0.024192933,
0.6106880903,
-0.1359080523,
-0.4798122644,
-0.1560783982,
0.0731767341,
0.8627366424,
-0.2691323757,
0.742809236,
0.1173573136,
-0.2024929225,
-0.3685988188,
-0.6977104545,
0.4671747983,
-0.4218136072,
0.2689681649,
-0.2922356427,
-1.1376404762,
0.4495557547,
0.12459068,
0.1951670647,
0.6915088296,
0.6298084855,
0.1985009462,
0.5982190967,
0.4917055666,
-0.2748649716,
0.1200954616,
-0.1688088179,
0.4472755492,
-0.5402994752,
-0.2078065425,
-0.5401790738,
0.1237984076,
-0.6238387227,
-0.3071960807,
-0.007339376,
0.1107181907,
-0.1963724047,
0.6080946326,
-0.0503297634,
0.4271395504,
0.3697990179,
-0.3066859245,
0.3754459918,
0.0397882089,
-0.1964011192,
0.1140559912,
-0.7943332791,
-0.7040625811,
1.2446686029,
0.6112866402,
0.6899954677,
0.2377289981,
0.4007144272,
0.366209358,
0.2012114525,
-1.0230967999,
0.7308568358,
-0.6132116318,
-0.6343904138,
-0.1326777339,
-0.3634538651,
-1.1373119354,
0.3731845319,
-0.3046078384,
-0.3202078938,
-0.0060300282,
-0.3183687627,
-0.5522176027,
0.4693509936,
-0.2452624887,
0.5138018727,
-0.2732468545,
-0.3840554357,
-0.2883594036,
-0.2983981371,
0.4283490181,
-0.517010808,
0.3621495664,
-0.6057066321,
0.1106437966,
0.5781941414,
-0.6261328459,
0.473716855,
-0.0847569332,
-0.3785841167,
0.5069771409,
-0.0328131914,
0.2739314735,
-0.0456453748,
-0.1572363526,
0.2101842165,
-0.1238257363,
-0.2468395829,
-0.3052831292,
0.5818443894,
-0.5066387057,
-0.8131870627,
-0.5215957761,
-0.4798513353,
-0.1765032709,
0.0394378938,
0.0908759758,
0.2271693349,
-0.1512457728,
0.4749693573,
0.3399894536,
-0.4910264015,
0.653369844,
0.9949843287,
-0.2840431631,
-0.1833322048,
0.6443993449,
0.3398871422,
0.1524414569,
0.1942133904,
0.0929410607,
-0.5372675061,
-0.9611441493,
-0.2569086552,
0.4757116437,
-0.5797547102,
-0.2834579945,
-0.6571786404,
-0.4002601802,
-0.2624422014,
-0.0526752211,
-0.1774888933,
-0.2333581001,
-0.0880438983,
0.0238295533,
0.1255226433,
0.6831531525,
0.1240778193,
0.1173375025,
-0.6749711037,
0.3918954432,
0.4574875236,
0.4302162826,
-0.3713576496,
-0.9775078893,
-0.0767388269,
-0.1570194215,
-0.076281324,
-0.4166108072,
0.5349425077,
0.2583292425,
0.6464582682,
0.2673974931,
-0.1079050824,
0.4857895374,
-0.7512401342,
0.7530741692,
0.1979020536,
-0.8797619939,
0.2718445659,
-0.4851429164,
0.0628109574,
0.2487649918,
0.1343079656,
-0.2885194123,
-0.520159781,
-0.5207213759,
-0.7703978419,
0.501067698,
0.2290491611,
0.5061097741,
0.0573234484,
0.6585449576,
-0.1186068878,
0.4734999835,
-0.7432653904,
0.1730661094,
0.1977352649,
0.0932337344,
-0.0937594622,
-0.3648372889,
0.0760967582,
-0.0441013798,
0.4405532479,
-0.0003844149,
0.1627773196,
-0.097983256,
-0.1528617889,
-0.009116279,
0.6205035448,
0.7209474444,
0.7059970498,
-0.3306758702,
0.0107801305,
0.0627008602,
-0.4334031343,
0.3833200932,
0.0380570255,
-0.110650979,
0.1941493303,
0.65094769,
0.7956797481,
0.0396765135,
-0.9477292895,
0.8119078279,
0.1359363496,
-0.6647840738,
-0.208195135,
0.2643385231,
0.1815199256,
0.4120876789,
0.2513006032,
-0.3253050447,
0.0772313997,
-0.5993468165,
-0.0215535145,
0.734146893,
-0.0503527187,
-0.0945891514,
0.8744111657,
-0.0380307287,
-0.2150243074,
0.4631085694,
-0.1628787965,
-0.279774636,
0.7375842929,
0.519359231,
0.9315285087,
0.3112546206,
0.1011435315,
0.1543401182,
0.2543863356,
-0.3414930701,
-0.0069071711,
0.3174485862,
-0.6785199642,
-0.7068567872,
-0.6502861977,
-0.3813380599,
0.4834283292,
-0.5403203368,
0.1241655946,
-0.8060070276,
-0.4260147214,
0.0361908115,
0.0202307198,
-0.8048992157,
0.1999113858,
0.2587558329,
0.9862913489,
-0.4513312876,
0.9063720703,
0.4650470316,
-0.1655406803,
-0.5647242069,
-0.1580473185,
-0.0853375643,
-0.6729007959,
0.7454806566,
0.2469424903,
0.0409294143,
-0.3906696737,
-0.5022163391,
-0.3872576654,
1.0020751953,
0.7691855431,
-1.2254154682,
-0.0529714003,
0.759611249,
0.7733519673,
-0.2745895386,
-0.1571272463,
0.5914969444,
0.1966676265,
0.0628527775,
-1.082149148,
-0.0946452394,
0.0550769307,
0.0835665539,
0.0309537016,
-0.5104410052,
0.6421297193,
-0.0559855253,
-0.2742555737,
-0.0097885588,
0.473125726,
0.4138524532,
0.1504204422,
0.3095817268,
0.7259316444,
0.6698352098,
-0.24548693,
1.1895722151,
-0.3532492816,
0.3913753331,
0.9678695202,
-0.8066926599,
0.9384239912,
0.1701925695,
-0.2915308177,
0.0941519067,
0.1813961864,
-0.2824763358,
0.2045985162,
0.6651366949,
-0.2365645617,
-0.5275734067,
-0.0906016156,
-0.2197168618,
0.5618724823,
0.213046506,
-0.4082330763,
-0.1641726345,
-0.100966908,
0.0933656245,
0.1969498396,
-0.4760781825,
0.707806468,
0.4320369959,
-0.506069243,
0.5732525587,
0.3757226467,
0.7113847136,
-0.5032134056,
0.2327212691,
-0.1219123676,
0.0027623454,
-0.1063915938,
-0.8476739526,
0.3241273165,
0.3709253073,
0.1725132316,
-0.1496161819,
0.6317551136,
-0.0866361484,
-0.2437189817,
0.6258625984,
0.4498428404,
0.1315593719,
-0.1443865001,
-0.7493656278,
0.0375823602,
-0.4050096273,
-0.1006507352,
0.2649177015,
0.3919052184,
-0.0103488928,
0.7176303267,
0.4479649365,
0.2901350856,
0.1658947617,
0.2915647626,
0.5765372515,
-0.8414754868,
-0.1045355275,
-1.0364992619,
0.2814540565,
0.08776737,
-0.1986569762,
0.6021952629,
0.5691558123,
0.5728105307,
-0.0746837258,
0.5214526057,
0.3206216693,
0.2821025252,
-0.9137417078,
0.5636967421,
-0.4325912297,
0.5234008431,
0.0242760386,
-1.0871549845,
-0.6538895369,
0.4266239107,
-0.3164551556,
0.0332832187,
0.2780831754,
0.554282248,
-0.1260247082,
-0.2316881269,
0.9103702903,
0.2003001422,
0.6798480153,
0.5137630105,
0.9273304939,
-0.1555167884,
0.305748105,
0.405179888,
0.2599173784,
-0.3876762092,
-0.918695569,
-1.031714201,
0.1832521707,
-0.3424349427,
-0.2251953036,
0.0910274014,
0.8702377081,
0.7845004797,
-0.9023593664,
-0.3301157057,
-0.3571334481,
-0.3319722712,
0.2573738992,
-0.1290495992,
0.1746221334,
-0.4853003025,
-0.3757809997,
0.4991428554,
0.441765219,
0.2361349314,
-0.1181189716,
-0.2084086537,
-0.0268218983,
0.4589002132,
0.7261619568,
0.3332508504,
-1.1374585629,
-0.0470099188,
-0.2492489666,
-0.3799883127,
0.1714359075,
0.8615654707,
-0.4188389778,
0.2028476298,
0.1966887563,
0.7933735847,
0.464104563,
-0.1101324186,
0.5301974416,
-0.4620799422,
0.1348481923,
0.2647468746,
0.7539615035,
0.1112072393,
0.0453024209,
0.7181801796,
-0.0084536429,
-0.6328732967,
-0.6918687224,
0.0520246029,
-0.9105804563,
-0.4811942577,
1.4273394346,
-0.2893942297,
0.0083303889,
-0.0948491096,
-0.0778416023,
-0.0393060073,
-0.1838666648,
0.3536884487,
0.7933467627,
0.233113274,
0.092848599,
-1.0141741037,
0.4283474088,
0.4441437125,
-0.6689288616,
0.0385433696,
0.5545222163,
0.334842205,
0.0767714158,
0.5095709562,
-0.2061139047,
0.1739770323,
-0.3207551241,
-0.2874785364,
-0.1623490453,
-0.3459101021,
-0.7987706065,
0.5199915171,
0.5087352395,
0.1805384606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08886v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08886v1
|
CLIMB: Curriculum Learning for Infant-inspired Model Building
| 2023-11-15T11:48:16 | 2023-11-15T11:48:16 |
Richard Diehl Martinez, Zebulon Goriely, Hope McGovern, Christopher Davis, Andrew Caines, Paula Buttery, Lisa Beinborn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We describe our team's contribution to the STRICT-SMALL track of the BabyLM
Challenge. The challenge requires training a language model from scratch using
only a relatively small training dataset of ten million words. We experiment
with three variants of cognitively-motivated curriculum learning and analyze
their effect on the performance of the model on linguistic evaluation tasks. In
the vocabulary curriculum, we analyze methods for constraining the vocabulary
in the early stages of training to simulate cognitively more plausible learning
curves. In the data curriculum experiments, we vary the order of the training
instances based on i) infant-inspired expectations and ii) the learning
behavior of the model. In the objective curriculum, we explore different
variations of combining the conventional masked language modeling task with a
more coarse-grained word class prediction task to reinforce linguistic
generalization capabilities. Our results did not yield consistent improvements
over our own non-curriculum learning baseline across a range of linguistic
benchmarks; however, we do find marginal gains on select tasks. Our analysis
highlights key takeaways for specific combinations of tasks and settings which
benefit from our proposed curricula. We moreover determine that careful
selection of model architecture, and training hyper-parameters yield
substantial improvements over the default baselines provided by the BabyLM
challenge.
|
[
0.0319389515,
-0.7397847176,
-0.0451231636,
-0.084641397,
-0.0450801775,
0.2641949654,
-0.3263264,
-0.2897207439,
-0.2981153429,
0.2841305733,
-0.6028366089,
-0.5066670775,
-0.7565400004,
-0.3597224951,
-0.2383119762,
1.1469097137,
0.1317967474,
-0.1659538448,
-0.2281986922,
0.0508055575,
-0.8341130614,
-0.4454594254,
-0.662096858,
-0.3208877146,
0.5912399888,
0.6054471731,
0.3334205449,
0.8388430476,
0.4174421728,
0.0981495455,
-0.3725619912,
0.1339141876,
-0.7268164158,
0.2107560635,
0.1326820254,
-0.3426573873,
-0.3671161532,
0.1621196121,
0.5245464444,
1.1496243477,
-0.6021948457,
0.3600620627,
0.3677957654,
0.7096869946,
-0.625410974,
0.6457390189,
-0.9750310779,
-0.3094158471,
-0.1802875698,
0.2484229654,
-0.5816738009,
0.1018101647,
0.1418766826,
-0.5180525184,
0.3986219764,
0.3489514887,
0.7736017704,
0.1424487233,
-0.4545033872,
-0.6069401503,
-0.3372713625,
1.0349185467,
-0.3368619978,
0.4164840281,
0.5866420865,
0.0303160753,
-0.1842584312,
-0.4759122431,
-0.1279370338,
-0.5874242783,
0.1847993433,
0.0436102748,
0.2209365964,
-0.0957184583,
0.1987185627,
0.4688723087,
-0.6810966134,
0.2969577014,
-0.6757237911,
-0.135343641,
0.5009384155,
0.3616025448,
0.1374538392,
-0.1382699013,
-0.1222015023,
-0.2887200713,
-0.9934063554,
0.2127279043,
0.1957624853,
0.7749880552,
-0.3755336404,
0.4575042725,
-0.1692728102,
0.6757032275,
-0.1925312728,
0.2383590192,
0.2834254503,
0.018013604,
-0.0595535599,
0.1828436702,
0.1884505749,
-0.0104385233,
0.1503759772,
-0.1099686697,
-0.3038664162,
0.3562305272,
0.3825428486,
-0.7364266515,
-0.5555403829,
-0.2734412253,
-0.2816014588,
-0.3760216236,
-0.2757335007,
-0.4059208035,
-0.1013699025,
-0.4080976546,
0.3068605959,
-0.5669901371,
0.0422422811,
0.3072363734,
0.136015892,
0.3605290651,
0.4422625601,
-1.1548012495,
0.223147437,
0.8046579361,
0.6765535474,
-0.3145012856,
-0.15102911,
-0.4409184754,
-0.0135468412,
-0.5586539507,
0.5824828744,
-0.519779563,
-0.6133157611,
0.2449228466,
-0.2635401487,
-0.4031153023,
-0.6142141223,
0.4605793953,
-0.7127542496,
0.1844507307,
-0.1382077485,
-0.651006639,
-0.2101141661,
0.5537123084,
-0.5182673931,
1.1166055202,
0.3216378093,
-0.4082477987,
0.3999943733,
-0.5700328946,
-0.4935145974,
0.214531973,
-0.0728113577,
-0.2581253052,
0.3316159844,
0.0024922083,
-0.008834077,
-0.3128072619,
0.0779828578,
0.1123133525,
-0.1169036776,
-0.326000005,
-0.1865159273,
1.0672168732,
0.1184552386,
-0.1719360799,
-0.1651446819,
-0.8740196824,
0.0665939599,
0.3870386481,
-0.551841855,
-0.4696975946,
0.210924238,
-0.0340931863,
0.0526596867,
0.2244551927,
-0.4366666079,
0.3603144586,
-0.5117683411,
0.2265954763,
0.5831290483,
0.0705310032,
0.212038219,
-0.680770874,
0.5301269889,
-0.1047547087,
0.0391800217,
-0.3256811202,
-0.6974897385,
-1.0044634342,
-0.119477123,
0.3821192682,
0.3243308961,
-0.5402680635,
0.0936439708,
-0.149317041,
-0.50117594,
-0.5663772225,
0.468942523,
0.6690754294,
0.7287684083,
0.5457026362,
-0.741755724,
-0.3803020418,
-0.4638278186,
-0.0268389639,
-0.4785982966,
0.0017394954,
0.1810385138,
0.5774229765,
0.0900490135,
0.5600190163,
-0.540224731,
-0.4733490944,
-0.2123192251,
0.4485491514,
0.2209182233,
0.7457990646,
0.4078846574,
-0.5568628907,
-0.4402607083,
-0.2821090221,
-0.3196304142,
-0.0399944186,
0.1295585632,
0.1254859716,
-0.0802127868,
0.4604645967,
-0.4523061514,
0.3543300927,
0.3092247248,
-0.0814163834,
0.7405282259,
-0.0992418453,
-0.2510631084,
-0.6715955138,
-0.47620067,
-0.1715098917,
0.1617088914,
-0.6229639649,
0.3694708943,
0.0252303034,
0.0783413425,
-0.6563395262,
0.4627146721,
-0.3602212667,
0.363019079,
-0.1911645383,
-0.0561241396,
0.0666229054,
0.5104862452,
0.0664462224,
0.7383261919,
0.6155185699,
-0.6300219893,
-0.0329431109,
0.5851458907,
-0.524163723,
0.378480792,
-0.6139799953,
0.3748793602,
0.0029523268,
0.0906274915,
-0.865649581,
-0.0834161788,
-0.1797912717,
-0.4258118868,
0.5575264692,
0.0311737414,
-0.5139808059,
-0.3931521475,
-0.2482454777,
0.4082561433,
0.7720370293,
-0.3551880121,
0.179714784,
0.2827782035,
0.0119613232,
0.0682736784,
-0.633551836,
-0.0064091217,
-0.1552240998,
-0.1708381176,
0.4890536666,
-0.3484170437,
-0.1413334608,
-0.2193956971,
-0.180064261,
0.0169034153,
0.2024300098,
0.1238895357,
0.5364522338,
-0.5452235341,
0.2142847776,
-0.1283037663,
0.0289762802,
0.2089179307,
-0.449357599,
0.4215322435,
-0.4335612059,
-0.215009287,
-0.0001546741,
0.0130326003,
0.1267212629,
-0.1690307409,
0.764456749,
0.1193541735,
-0.4373600781,
-0.4046288729,
-0.2607508898,
-0.0273359623,
-0.485524565,
0.1943746656,
-0.2393644005,
-0.9746785164,
0.1457318217,
0.1730107516,
0.5440317988,
0.373218298,
0.7008900046,
-0.410343051,
0.8682077527,
0.8067883253,
0.1881729513,
0.3996636569,
-0.4542206228,
-0.2064855099,
-1.1091704369,
-0.4462597668,
-0.6893587112,
-0.2130342871,
-0.5330204368,
-0.6097211838,
0.254932642,
-0.1233709231,
-0.6675806046,
0.5756130815,
-0.4731942415,
0.2173407227,
0.5927611589,
0.0301385149,
0.3312787712,
-0.0635579601,
-0.3389432132,
-0.1548174918,
-1.0175951719,
-0.3778740764,
1.2088369131,
-0.0416720472,
0.8277870417,
0.0222754572,
0.611774981,
0.3214056492,
0.7161716223,
-1.0045390129,
0.5819303393,
-0.1607100517,
-0.8389791846,
0.0080826338,
-0.2089533955,
-1.0026862621,
0.142299518,
-0.1860532165,
-0.7682723403,
-0.0638781413,
0.1091582254,
-0.3899579942,
0.002219836,
-0.4710189402,
0.6714330912,
-0.3751811385,
-0.2340156734,
-0.3363585472,
-0.8164490461,
0.2119197249,
-0.1727619767,
0.3489121497,
-0.0991925374,
-0.0122694205,
0.8919891715,
-0.1960745454,
0.962972343,
0.1142108142,
-0.0368354321,
0.5302440524,
0.4691810012,
0.1089732274,
-0.3720838428,
-0.1741620302,
0.1571439058,
-0.2709285319,
-0.6353079081,
-0.2948919833,
0.5369169116,
-0.778699398,
-0.8608699441,
-0.4705763161,
-0.8650673628,
-0.5023620725,
0.1692006439,
0.0233866107,
0.339780122,
-0.3475556672,
0.6066207886,
0.6431288123,
-0.051780656,
0.3267240822,
0.5849390626,
-0.1269895434,
-0.2686842084,
0.8885430098,
0.0508328453,
0.5675129294,
0.329549253,
0.2987358272,
-0.0986093655,
-0.8441768885,
-0.4432633221,
0.0139248278,
-0.6151245832,
-0.0788477808,
-0.3431115746,
-0.5249280334,
-0.3322091997,
-0.2710578144,
-0.4165584147,
-0.4020546377,
-0.375782311,
-0.0039680111,
-0.1266532391,
0.8673759103,
0.2406895906,
0.6790849566,
-0.623595953,
0.0612042658,
0.3778136075,
-0.072368592,
0.0156687982,
-1.1189947128,
-0.4911662638,
0.0920758471,
-0.8058388829,
-0.3797830045,
0.1424927562,
0.5712305307,
0.3440690041,
0.5514157414,
-0.0067023817,
0.651832521,
-0.8006457686,
0.9956119657,
0.2128392011,
-0.6155462861,
0.7035181522,
-0.3590261936,
0.2030786425,
0.6789274812,
0.2247260213,
-0.1422984451,
-0.2710751593,
-0.9418305159,
-0.7132593989,
0.4442664683,
0.3408727944,
0.566157937,
-0.0927141234,
0.3688359559,
0.0034090045,
0.4479129314,
-0.4512930214,
0.0156302191,
-0.1099227667,
-0.1516930312,
-0.0279699583,
-0.1449041963,
-0.0556982271,
-0.3861650229,
0.8442027569,
-0.1447050571,
-0.2992520928,
-0.2384175211,
-0.2941908836,
-0.1460786909,
-0.0480995253,
0.3580596149,
0.3340365589,
-0.1804900914,
-0.0351065211,
0.3154650033,
-0.5445540547,
-0.0802063346,
-0.1528879255,
-0.2844226062,
-0.2252104282,
0.7854906321,
0.7569036484,
0.6883658171,
-0.6962943673,
0.4166865051,
0.1632444561,
-0.1646812856,
0.0162875503,
0.4014084041,
0.1299429089,
-0.0502944514,
0.3187968135,
-0.153948471,
-0.0942004994,
-0.6067257524,
0.3705246747,
0.5252069235,
-0.5103110075,
-0.5008704662,
0.9055477977,
-0.0265271086,
-0.6001406908,
0.9060393572,
-0.2523856163,
-0.4406031668,
1.0059226751,
0.8248115778,
0.7330500484,
-0.3712296188,
0.1919334978,
0.3511105776,
0.668195188,
-0.0592377558,
-0.0276663154,
-0.2003067136,
-0.7882769108,
-0.158750385,
-0.8818817139,
-0.6645270586,
0.1175857782,
-0.8515877128,
0.641112268,
-0.4225694239,
0.1377401948,
-0.1590368748,
0.198657006,
-0.8318203092,
0.4241091311,
0.5769520998,
1.1224892139,
-0.736967504,
0.9375345111,
0.8382532597,
-0.3259062171,
-0.8728568554,
0.0289519951,
0.2635819912,
-1.1116095781,
0.7505181432,
0.3956864774,
0.0191976223,
0.3139688373,
-0.5402594805,
-0.640973866,
0.8892284632,
-0.0580357872,
-0.4410772026,
-0.4971517026,
-0.0584346429,
0.5507853627,
-0.8560577631,
0.0411000252,
0.4690697193,
-0.0048501166,
0.6386811137,
-0.5552775264,
-0.3623092473,
-0.0105812456,
0.2119484097,
-0.2024876028,
-0.6701878905,
0.757240057,
-0.4202190042,
0.0137913479,
0.1776146144,
0.956317544,
0.514185369,
0.4187979698,
0.6543073058,
0.6177754402,
0.5698921084,
0.113563627,
0.8939878345,
-0.3696579933,
0.66989851,
1.336835742,
-0.3486406803,
0.9071212411,
0.3461329341,
-0.2264456302,
0.8163658977,
0.9592213631,
0.1941625178,
0.6670199037,
0.4635117352,
-0.1110118181,
-0.2926847339,
-0.2587269545,
-0.3705486655,
0.6245217323,
0.8496055603,
0.0599672198,
-0.543264091,
-0.0220995173,
0.0437773354,
0.059343636,
-0.4374281168,
0.3972575665,
0.4356712997,
-0.5643808246,
0.7327276468,
-0.2439939976,
0.369184196,
-0.6886475086,
-0.0293433033,
-0.0410915054,
-0.1041533351,
0.1449675113,
-0.2022969723,
0.2968493402,
0.064229615,
0.0742106587,
-0.5193310976,
0.4198660851,
-0.5859409571,
-0.6758280396,
0.0748247355,
0.6780555248,
-0.0347550623,
0.2642046511,
-0.8334794641,
0.0774483979,
-0.2881512046,
-0.6818957329,
0.3293296099,
0.300801754,
-0.2076487392,
0.524302125,
0.8893656731,
0.3020972013,
0.1636802256,
-0.0233153384,
1.0990519524,
-0.4547551572,
-0.5337920189,
-0.5398955345,
0.3800614774,
0.2256710976,
-0.3633386791,
0.5381472111,
0.681845367,
0.9178367853,
-0.0053640008,
0.4219098985,
-0.302693367,
0.3020688891,
-0.4511477053,
0.5962144136,
-0.6943728328,
0.3983173966,
0.1149126589,
-0.776248157,
-0.4513469338,
0.5236954093,
-0.4033130407,
-0.0452930331,
0.9429465532,
0.7049900293,
0.0198642705,
0.0658676252,
0.2989496887,
0.2517964542,
0.2787721753,
0.8247117996,
0.8728452921,
-0.2543589473,
0.3482216299,
-0.1284205914,
-0.419803977,
-0.1682375222,
-1.0239583254,
-0.9465528131,
-0.4726420939,
-0.5464993119,
-0.4899164736,
0.1759215891,
1.0722987652,
0.7170160413,
-0.9744865894,
-0.3178229332,
-0.2702555358,
0.0779884085,
-0.3351362348,
-0.1458445489,
0.3650702834,
-0.6919894218,
-0.7542260289,
0.5548305511,
0.1796592921,
-0.2614473104,
-0.2460175753,
0.076688841,
-0.3144235015,
0.3008685112,
0.5039390922,
0.2484284937,
-0.5318509936,
-0.3952992558,
-0.0024806934,
-0.3012844324,
0.2502879798,
0.8600097299,
-0.8237395883,
0.4754610658,
0.088387534,
0.8115843534,
0.5672110915,
-0.0410930924,
-0.1037531197,
-0.7306106687,
0.3284285069,
0.3924719393,
0.1985889524,
0.2853791714,
-0.1711998284,
0.4763240516,
0.4685351849,
-0.3570667207,
-0.7920544147,
0.4053281248,
-0.9206779003,
0.1211893037,
0.982077837,
-0.1807801723,
-0.3407151997,
-0.0646921769,
0.0352901854,
0.1824042648,
-0.0477914549,
1.208008647,
0.9546352625,
-0.0811281651,
0.0261694081,
-1.0381193161,
0.2442002147,
0.6614942551,
-0.484039247,
-0.1616344303,
0.4445501268,
0.2500256002,
0.1011234596,
0.4342536926,
-0.1851847619,
0.0657305047,
-0.1699329466,
-0.002109569,
-0.0804569945,
-0.5381917357,
-0.1632058471,
0.0717250779,
0.3038937151,
-0.3749853969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08883v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08883v2
|
Enabling Large Language Models to Learn from Rules
| 2023-11-15T11:42:41 | 2024-02-16T14:07:24 |
Wenkai Yang, Yankai Lin, Jie Zhou, Jirong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown incredible performance in completing
various real-world tasks. The current knowledge learning paradigm of LLMs is
mainly based on learning from examples, in which LLMs learn the internal rule
implicitly from a certain number of supervised examples. However, this learning
paradigm may not well learn those complicated rules, especially when the
training examples are limited. We are inspired that humans can learn the new
tasks or knowledge in another way by learning from rules. That is, humans can
learn new tasks or grasps new knowledge quickly and generalize well given only
a detailed rule and a few optional examples. Therefore, in this paper, we aim
to explore the feasibility of this new learning paradigm, which targets on
encoding rule-based knowledge into LLMs. We further propose rule distillation,
which first uses the strong in-context abilities of LLMs to extract the
knowledge from the textual rules, and then explicitly encode the knowledge into
the parameters of LLMs by learning from the above in-context signals produced
inside the model. Our experiments show that making LLMs learn from rules by our
method is much more efficient than example-based learning in both the sample
size and generalization ability. Warning: This paper may contain examples with
offensive content.
|
[
-0.0963239372,
-0.8463178277,
0.8441163301,
-0.0650551468,
-0.6324757338,
-0.2091893107,
-0.5731282234,
-0.2611398995,
-0.1296322793,
0.6070165634,
-0.4306366742,
-0.5434285402,
-0.846683383,
0.1318114251,
-0.3612284958,
0.8845736384,
0.2010471374,
0.111870259,
-0.1505683959,
0.3680820167,
-0.2946671546,
-0.5996578336,
-0.5769300461,
-0.6103449464,
0.3446045518,
0.4803813398,
0.109208487,
0.8324568272,
0.2778937519,
0.3322460353,
-0.1577468067,
0.5034433603,
-0.7009267211,
0.1235681102,
-0.1746759564,
-0.6803962588,
-0.2855521142,
0.1068474948,
0.4394164979,
0.5728338361,
-0.4626887441,
0.1210467443,
0.2853461504,
0.7111980915,
-0.2746500671,
0.625864923,
-1.0444540977,
-0.0517100804,
-0.0146698589,
-0.4556460083,
-0.5839417577,
-0.3499987423,
0.1353086084,
-0.6864790916,
-0.1386246383,
0.1424492598,
0.7174037099,
0.2651217282,
-0.4851057529,
-0.7179794312,
-0.6850789189,
0.7635981441,
-0.8927620649,
0.3543775678,
0.5371516943,
0.5128564835,
-0.4267921448,
-0.7838788033,
-0.5993489027,
-0.1415362358,
-0.2329085618,
-0.324428767,
-0.1035633162,
-0.0225448962,
0.4869357049,
0.1374359876,
-0.017305186,
0.1408302039,
-0.3933414817,
0.0717301443,
0.5662286282,
0.0235229209,
0.1492765248,
-0.1138801873,
-0.3039112985,
-0.1333304793,
-0.8596378565,
0.0044742422,
0.1237318218,
0.4933634102,
-0.0988368168,
0.312178582,
-0.2616738379,
0.6405693889,
0.3039619625,
-0.7138031721,
0.2776327431,
-0.0233745519,
-0.1738691777,
-0.0770209357,
0.5956904292,
0.3077622652,
0.3797027767,
-0.2053267509,
-0.3054692447,
-0.2705273628,
0.0725080371,
-1.0556076765,
0.0334535688,
-0.2189803123,
-0.538998127,
-0.1264271885,
0.0237683635,
-0.7980571389,
-0.5297830701,
-0.73396945,
0.5938529372,
-0.5852977633,
-0.2719938159,
0.3196850121,
-0.3435947895,
0.4628494978,
0.4169454575,
-1.1301785707,
0.3626725376,
0.767195344,
0.5547263622,
0.2358129472,
-0.1783970594,
-0.6548997164,
0.1224590912,
-0.1110985726,
0.3676793873,
-0.5260055065,
-0.1811483055,
-0.062714316,
-0.1758979559,
0.0670286566,
-0.6986361146,
0.3738439083,
-0.7897164822,
-0.1699908674,
-0.3174005151,
-0.8231144547,
-0.3987542391,
0.0872427747,
-0.5321735144,
0.6400720477,
-0.1403824687,
-0.5207746029,
0.6291989088,
-0.5066045523,
-0.6792350411,
0.0880152285,
-0.1435569972,
-0.2317490727,
0.2275232524,
0.0760348812,
0.9344773889,
-0.4422183037,
0.483820796,
-0.2479221374,
-0.2347584069,
0.0897435769,
-0.4497974813,
0.8171496391,
0.3624127209,
-0.370952189,
-0.1633628458,
-0.596304059,
-0.1425375342,
0.2155966759,
-0.6907653809,
-0.6976006031,
0.2783725858,
-0.4086455703,
0.3840018213,
0.071671173,
-0.4072526693,
0.3491314948,
-0.1032761857,
0.6131862402,
0.8396711946,
0.107385993,
0.5531079769,
-0.3287949264,
0.1346486062,
-0.0033607339,
-0.0618989766,
-0.0085069928,
-0.207347244,
-0.6689742208,
-0.5091764927,
0.1845003664,
0.3355357349,
-0.7754822969,
0.6548784375,
-0.2147832662,
-0.4137056768,
-0.2805036902,
0.623457253,
0.2330263555,
0.4272039831,
0.3882890046,
-0.0321756713,
-0.7756288648,
-0.6225613356,
-0.0293925907,
-0.0904163867,
-0.0149426227,
0.1899706721,
0.6274603009,
-0.2028920203,
0.8465788364,
-0.5298630595,
-0.3574046791,
-0.6468746662,
-0.1814840883,
0.3393064737,
0.1480235159,
0.4211836755,
-0.8462800384,
-0.4998659194,
0.0288762078,
-0.9462894201,
-0.1057134122,
0.2026329488,
-0.0307450891,
-0.0751295164,
1.0521284342,
-0.2730346322,
0.0892799571,
0.381852448,
-0.2921598554,
0.2689810097,
-0.4879362881,
-0.147396192,
-1.1877839565,
-0.3423675895,
0.2648837864,
-0.3808106482,
-0.7406342626,
-0.1203394011,
0.1027854085,
0.2609848082,
-0.4934411645,
0.4618573189,
-0.4950190187,
0.377658397,
-0.3409398198,
-0.0652822182,
-0.0641162097,
0.6363574266,
0.2128475904,
0.157395184,
0.6686034799,
-0.9315267205,
0.364261657,
0.0612232648,
-0.7136547565,
0.3624184132,
-0.3881370723,
-0.0360335223,
-0.4493184686,
0.2838604152,
-0.6619099379,
-0.1159702614,
-0.0995763764,
0.0446789525,
0.4862966835,
-0.221578449,
-0.6331772208,
0.0401569419,
-0.0722215101,
0.1569270939,
1.0882213116,
-0.8249787688,
0.798666954,
0.5826748013,
0.130454883,
-0.3866429329,
-0.450769484,
-0.1999195367,
-0.7237941027,
-0.1640345007,
0.0750074685,
0.0903507471,
-0.489068687,
-0.165870741,
0.0029768308,
0.0028810157,
0.261436671,
0.3062721193,
0.0103189098,
0.0680698976,
0.1696650237,
0.0676916614,
0.2145916671,
0.1208130047,
-0.4220728874,
0.5873445272,
0.1533067822,
-0.1773564219,
-0.5561499,
0.1480165273,
0.7159873247,
-0.1291056275,
0.7764229774,
0.1367158145,
-0.3423905671,
-0.834944725,
-0.5377697945,
-0.4451425672,
-0.5355696678,
0.5184018612,
-0.3978454173,
-0.9972162843,
0.2395064235,
-0.5508953929,
0.068669863,
0.2730810344,
0.5188595057,
-0.0804113075,
0.7305019498,
0.8364887834,
-0.156883508,
0.641492188,
-0.2691316009,
0.0431771092,
-0.5839865804,
-0.3249830902,
-0.458342582,
-0.2148744017,
-0.433380574,
-0.5454713106,
0.3727836907,
0.2944617867,
-0.0825492367,
0.3361631632,
-0.0620479062,
0.7309434414,
0.5948454142,
0.4210103154,
0.4161350429,
0.0115893781,
-0.2991875708,
0.1495120227,
-0.7993670106,
-0.5202745795,
1.2618141174,
0.3823544383,
0.9966702461,
0.1398640722,
0.8902655244,
0.3009147644,
0.2563934028,
-0.8063831329,
0.6364747286,
-0.3360105753,
-0.5222062469,
-0.476519376,
-0.5984789729,
-0.7277944684,
0.3523801863,
-0.3877588511,
-0.5480074286,
0.0051919697,
0.126482144,
-0.0629965365,
0.4843251705,
-0.731548667,
0.4867025614,
-0.2625273168,
-0.1815706044,
-0.2751716077,
-0.4633149505,
0.3731846809,
-0.365408361,
0.5992083549,
-0.1611862183,
0.2166667432,
0.7307090759,
-0.4619134665,
1.3004910946,
-0.4484676421,
-0.3872652948,
0.3011847436,
-0.038137231,
0.5834549665,
-0.0533358194,
-0.174670428,
0.1363773346,
-0.0795110613,
-0.0952160209,
-0.6707767248,
0.3270643651,
-0.7051060796,
-0.7634424567,
-0.1814403534,
-0.3775385022,
-0.0204471871,
0.1106598973,
0.1130036339,
0.3089205623,
-0.0494430698,
0.3395996094,
0.8114115596,
0.0012589226,
0.4609356225,
0.801433146,
-0.2569483221,
-0.0644819438,
0.7667945623,
0.0654853135,
0.346629709,
0.6179155707,
0.4015915394,
-0.4892856479,
-0.8368084431,
-0.1928218007,
0.3035752475,
-0.8573225737,
-0.1793312877,
-0.3467077613,
-0.1559802741,
-0.1703784019,
0.0857219473,
-0.0271021593,
0.0334888659,
-0.3135236204,
-0.0474887379,
0.4689096808,
0.9858657122,
-0.1100594699,
0.1837024242,
-0.6962059736,
0.3307999372,
0.7273598909,
0.2467128038,
0.1415194422,
-0.7792251706,
-0.2226022929,
0.1174508259,
-0.0348747261,
-0.6030949354,
0.3370675743,
0.4552477002,
0.85825032,
0.5855871439,
0.2106113285,
0.5906863809,
-0.9191038013,
0.2999797761,
0.015345769,
-1.0205389261,
0.3272745013,
-0.1541123241,
0.049354665,
0.534983933,
0.5368657112,
-0.6267136335,
-0.3199179471,
-0.3121047914,
-0.6081149578,
0.6966407895,
-0.2177239507,
0.2840603292,
-0.0458987579,
0.6975935698,
0.4621417522,
0.2750540972,
-0.6181109548,
0.0071385568,
0.0643653199,
-0.2784089744,
-0.2567250133,
-0.270257473,
0.0882920995,
-0.5027944446,
0.7627596259,
-0.2179758996,
-0.2025534064,
-0.0744533688,
-0.4039193392,
0.1696743667,
0.328028053,
0.3356616795,
0.6563075781,
-0.1134144217,
0.3727306128,
0.3920267224,
-0.3603133857,
0.1627016664,
-0.1154351756,
-0.0959193781,
-0.3192028105,
0.3893907666,
0.7752158642,
0.1702237576,
-0.732070744,
0.5032886863,
-0.2036648691,
-0.5086711645,
-0.282006979,
0.3636043072,
0.2544145882,
0.582162559,
0.4098026752,
-0.3531334102,
-0.0088596214,
-0.7869452238,
0.3668271601,
0.5100525022,
-0.2469604611,
-0.1869086027,
0.4921020269,
0.254768014,
-0.1072557345,
0.4110911787,
-0.3149660826,
-0.4879805446,
0.3370376527,
0.6083875299,
0.4786777794,
-0.0314156301,
-0.0393699445,
0.322608918,
0.0926229358,
-0.453620404,
0.0212572031,
-0.3122901917,
-0.8705436587,
-0.5502778888,
-1.079829216,
-0.254624337,
0.2007593364,
-0.4872488678,
0.3491214514,
-0.5778351426,
0.174973309,
0.0813756362,
-0.1527405679,
-0.5362800956,
0.0474215746,
0.244349286,
0.8854789734,
-1.018155694,
1.1919757128,
0.4833983779,
-0.2240720391,
-0.8936864734,
-0.1414970756,
0.0363902822,
-0.7542430162,
0.9515554905,
0.1601663232,
0.0203391947,
-0.0280379262,
-0.6642058492,
-0.6365162134,
1.1597499847,
0.6003272533,
-0.7846556902,
-0.1182318777,
0.0037977053,
0.4831493795,
-0.5479920506,
0.0122952247,
0.7635441422,
0.3113414049,
0.4076407254,
-0.9381710887,
0.2218953371,
-0.2399777919,
-0.1424471885,
0.2339560986,
-0.5460854769,
0.8675682545,
-0.2833000124,
-0.0865308344,
-0.3175484538,
0.5720194578,
0.072042197,
0.0262685474,
0.6386588216,
0.4335195422,
0.8557397127,
-0.0035552508,
0.8380228877,
-0.0316106342,
0.2868651152,
1.1952598095,
-0.4182781577,
0.8731224537,
0.4590070546,
-0.0799923018,
0.7033984661,
0.3425188959,
0.1693853438,
0.7361676097,
0.4740883708,
-0.2887203097,
-0.3835823536,
0.1593103558,
-0.0550403818,
0.7177703977,
0.4660674036,
-0.4589883387,
-0.3375744224,
-0.0250579845,
0.2760285139,
0.2163288146,
-0.5068693757,
1.2937915325,
0.1714994758,
-0.468139559,
0.7511746287,
0.0271127149,
1.0477503538,
-0.841173172,
-0.432621181,
0.1411082894,
0.2845398188,
-0.0997883007,
-0.3448795378,
-0.0397276431,
-0.0140920207,
-0.2761877477,
-0.3388635516,
0.5304474831,
-0.681229353,
-0.2847959101,
0.3472901583,
0.4863244295,
0.1848904043,
0.050888896,
-0.2340591848,
-0.1923323423,
0.1199118048,
-0.0076711914,
0.5638093352,
0.7325798273,
-0.0740446821,
0.6318636537,
0.6152505875,
0.2348477393,
0.1306422055,
-0.1803977937,
0.9456273913,
-0.510573864,
-0.4099791646,
-1.2448730469,
0.3347096741,
-0.1430708468,
0.1982751638,
0.7847952843,
0.3657698333,
0.9938473105,
-0.0982521549,
0.937353909,
-0.0558403544,
0.2849694788,
-0.8391036987,
0.7834692001,
-0.5668147206,
0.3443662822,
-0.1204588115,
-0.7706605196,
-0.2118842602,
0.5234399438,
-0.3684813976,
-0.080051668,
0.6912335753,
0.6019266248,
-0.0665343627,
0.0639862269,
0.5603379011,
0.2916618288,
0.3560098112,
0.6307801008,
0.6013938785,
-0.0057114828,
0.3401198983,
-0.1703142822,
-0.4163305163,
-0.2438628376,
-0.989595592,
-1.1738114357,
-0.8104060888,
0.0130792884,
-0.1392966509,
-0.0099882297,
1.2548906803,
0.844213903,
-0.60525769,
-0.4499132335,
-0.0630263239,
0.1886210591,
-0.1889744401,
-0.1137677357,
0.2980544567,
-0.5151218772,
-0.8362165689,
0.5088567138,
-0.0395003706,
0.1594742239,
0.0308608934,
-0.3202386796,
-0.3283242285,
-0.0021937247,
0.8265638351,
0.0977883562,
-0.3934235871,
-0.1495104879,
-0.4461730421,
0.0661488473,
-0.1257311106,
0.8495005369,
-0.7380245924,
0.1592590809,
0.3843042254,
0.5921186209,
0.6264986992,
-0.2109002471,
0.4623044729,
-0.6704896688,
0.2290070504,
-0.1353139579,
0.6058826447,
0.1702893972,
-0.1694675237,
0.2179815024,
0.0544068515,
-0.3600366116,
-0.6113749743,
0.2524492443,
-0.7046579123,
-0.4245911241,
1.5130115747,
-0.2192535698,
-0.4391127825,
-0.1625740081,
-0.2254765928,
0.3148394823,
-0.5766026974,
0.7416520715,
0.4771178365,
0.0314442925,
0.0725713968,
-0.6418082118,
0.7277601361,
-0.1289564073,
-0.8344087005,
0.4225151539,
0.5220915675,
0.7285220623,
-0.1069116145,
0.4139308631,
-0.1290372014,
-0.0083492342,
-0.1835723668,
0.0665194616,
-0.2806336582,
-0.393165797,
-0.3909499645,
0.3181408644,
0.402669102,
0.1498586982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08877v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08877v1
|
Llamas Know What GPTs Don't Show: Surrogate Models for Confidence Estimation
| 2023-11-15T11:27:44 | 2023-11-15T11:27:44 |
Vaishnavi Shrivastava, Percy Liang, Ananya Kumar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
To maintain user trust, large language models (LLMs) should signal low
confidence on examples where they are incorrect, instead of misleading the
user. The standard approach of estimating confidence is to use the softmax
probabilities of these models, but as of November 2023, state-of-the-art LLMs
such as GPT-4 and Claude-v1.3 do not provide access to these probabilities. We
first study eliciting confidence linguistically -- asking an LLM for its
confidence in its answer -- which performs reasonably (80.5% AUC on GPT-4
averaged across 12 question-answering datasets -- 7% above a random baseline)
but leaves room for improvement. We then explore using a surrogate confidence
model -- using a model where we do have probabilities to evaluate the original
model's confidence in a given question. Surprisingly, even though these
probabilities come from a different and often weaker model, this method leads
to higher AUC than linguistic confidences on 9 out of 12 datasets. Our best
method composing linguistic confidences and surrogate model probabilities gives
state-of-the-art confidence estimates on all 12 datasets (84.6% average AUC on
GPT-4).
|
[
-0.5392135978,
-0.7263175249,
1.0304344893,
-0.0557949059,
-0.2154129297,
0.2117454112,
-0.0266683102,
-0.4439213276,
0.1296784133,
0.4542734921,
-0.4498534501,
-0.7033496499,
-0.8733769059,
0.2674625814,
-0.3796123862,
0.95600003,
0.2312328368,
-0.2120325118,
-0.176447168,
0.1447236389,
-0.2544679046,
-0.7663897276,
-0.5339491367,
-0.3185884058,
0.3132273853,
0.5039313436,
0.9351353645,
0.2202716768,
0.2899730206,
0.2236802876,
-0.2016296387,
0.265307337,
-0.4614908695,
-0.1376989335,
0.1826261729,
-0.6369596124,
-0.265052408,
0.2855577171,
0.4178608358,
0.7142783999,
-0.2696581185,
-0.1050260141,
-0.0723155737,
0.3122941852,
-0.6477313638,
0.243935883,
-0.85204494,
-0.1699231863,
-0.0042239446,
-0.3550039828,
-0.4036313891,
-0.5933598876,
0.161651507,
-0.431293726,
0.080422543,
-0.2376337647,
0.8268149495,
0.2576593459,
-0.484685272,
-0.2734852433,
-0.5436992049,
0.8944805264,
-0.7696859837,
0.0845381841,
0.755673945,
0.0846047476,
-0.412160635,
-0.6447986364,
-0.5735221505,
-0.7008894682,
0.0216717068,
0.1639582366,
-0.2825298011,
0.1610245556,
0.1585807353,
0.4425818026,
-0.5255439281,
-0.0016164231,
-0.3168617189,
-0.310627073,
0.7337626219,
-0.0747856349,
-0.0332026519,
0.051613085,
-0.6111139655,
0.2114084959,
-1.0808926821,
-0.213224411,
0.4759869277,
0.1337252259,
0.0975261629,
0.7261072993,
-0.0935018808,
0.6280938387,
0.0227381717,
-0.2178300321,
0.2031484991,
-0.1421023905,
-0.2962374687,
-0.2069434822,
0.8234545588,
0.3477264345,
0.9198394418,
-0.0592199042,
-0.2649626434,
0.3726008832,
0.1057960987,
-0.3580240309,
-0.0458150022,
0.2050992399,
0.0485743992,
-0.2144205719,
0.0557037592,
-0.5233757496,
-0.452124089,
0.0932101458,
0.6182496548,
-0.18196778,
-0.2165667266,
0.189667061,
0.0472290441,
0.3625839055,
0.1658670306,
-0.6670638323,
0.5058015585,
0.5692810416,
0.6283025146,
-0.1807991862,
-0.0968855768,
-0.2761954665,
-0.1300013661,
-0.6822817326,
0.752142787,
-0.6582049131,
-0.7283566594,
0.0824206248,
0.1561359167,
-0.227292046,
-0.4755906165,
0.7099388838,
-0.5314642787,
0.1643811464,
-0.3646012545,
-0.7056927085,
-0.1183546931,
0.224888742,
-0.3877753317,
1.0177738667,
-0.0678474754,
-0.6506729126,
0.1726552695,
-0.0922957808,
-0.1873886734,
-0.0965524986,
-0.4343498349,
-0.1268455088,
0.3151787519,
0.3869008422,
0.580760181,
-0.1330931336,
0.2153620422,
-0.2521848977,
-0.7142365575,
0.7387930155,
-0.7564495206,
0.4688687623,
0.0349698365,
-0.1336418241,
-0.384327054,
-0.3045498431,
-0.0461842604,
-0.0973243862,
-0.2606509924,
-0.2374816537,
-0.1958917528,
-0.39549613,
0.1802952141,
0.2165003866,
-0.6959204078,
0.2224949747,
-0.4206122756,
0.4486403465,
0.7984202504,
0.1543928236,
0.0248231571,
-0.4161016345,
0.7990432382,
-0.0786037669,
-0.0464175344,
0.1145296916,
-1.0834420919,
-0.6701189876,
0.068605803,
0.3083730638,
0.684422493,
-0.7302253246,
0.0777513459,
-0.3145914376,
-0.5690854192,
-0.5252811909,
0.1272489429,
0.548836112,
0.5621957779,
0.3561602533,
-0.4013524652,
-0.2969203591,
-1.1451386213,
-0.4746777415,
-0.5018630624,
-0.0489839278,
0.2367904633,
0.5766332746,
0.0827292725,
0.6738846302,
-0.566311419,
0.0103241345,
-0.4626387656,
0.3163707852,
0.3072009981,
0.2199838758,
0.3795001805,
-0.9174363613,
-0.3265397847,
-0.3346478343,
-0.5414626598,
-0.0405717082,
0.1375962496,
0.2395367175,
0.3094845414,
0.1851083636,
-0.9545794129,
0.6533880234,
0.7391515374,
-0.157589376,
0.4620606899,
-0.3029964566,
0.2054265738,
-0.9412839413,
-0.3501347899,
0.2573337853,
-0.3754215539,
-0.6330324411,
-0.1141459495,
-0.2153795063,
0.3545716405,
-0.2621800303,
0.5368469954,
-0.4848755002,
-0.1758883148,
-0.2079671621,
0.195570305,
-0.056074474,
0.4798312783,
0.2228304744,
1.0283366442,
0.5045835376,
-0.6449003816,
0.0645740777,
0.1844466925,
-0.4402965307,
0.5380533338,
-0.6799010634,
0.2435122728,
0.0098445956,
0.2459656447,
-1.3853495121,
-0.4738955498,
0.0698273554,
-0.7608521581,
0.5333303213,
-0.4146807194,
-0.3593856692,
-0.4609841704,
-0.2826552987,
-0.0031649538,
0.8850605488,
-0.3316417634,
0.4749837816,
0.7018814087,
-0.4172948003,
-0.9961378574,
-1.2693949938,
0.2843500674,
-0.1689489782,
-0.3685563803,
0.0379495956,
-0.0557268672,
-0.2665714324,
-0.158631444,
-0.2270883173,
-0.3563971519,
-0.0244178865,
0.2947057784,
0.3304778934,
-0.1138449237,
0.2870262861,
-0.1156279519,
-0.353734076,
-0.0062101982,
-0.0476010516,
0.3198719323,
-0.3272127211,
-0.7000931501,
-0.4615767598,
0.0701365918,
0.4286231101,
0.1176144928,
0.7449835539,
0.3342573941,
-0.4817889333,
0.1336877793,
-1.0409396887,
-0.0829466879,
-0.4675912857,
0.3112618029,
-0.348855406,
-0.9876196384,
0.3669244349,
0.0367391743,
-0.0808383897,
0.3868379593,
0.6564254761,
-0.1109693721,
1.1383574009,
0.6754950285,
0.0136552835,
0.0550639257,
0.0069413101,
0.0596434437,
-0.629737854,
-0.1596233398,
-0.4231987596,
-0.0162365213,
-1.0043705702,
-0.5278819203,
0.4890874028,
-0.2039615214,
-0.1573863775,
0.3892546296,
-0.3406582475,
0.5106741786,
0.6350342035,
0.0076382402,
0.6378691792,
0.1731784791,
-0.007923888,
-0.1685487181,
-0.6980908513,
-0.7525622845,
1.4118493795,
0.3144166172,
0.9866121411,
0.0138191171,
0.5895368457,
0.2313276082,
0.6590976119,
-0.6728227139,
0.6760953665,
-0.1495470703,
-0.8506971598,
-0.1998991966,
-0.6076544523,
-0.8284391165,
0.0519307964,
-0.00992247,
-0.8426350355,
0.4642242491,
0.2506502271,
-0.3520724177,
0.2354065031,
-0.8632537127,
0.4846566617,
-0.0461753085,
-0.2831360996,
0.2013934404,
-0.6451379061,
0.5949879289,
-0.2124037296,
0.2656397223,
-0.2375124693,
-0.3415833712,
0.5729390383,
-0.4326152205,
1.0740945339,
-0.1936829537,
-0.2154828161,
0.7618536353,
0.0467705429,
0.7032587528,
0.2459093928,
-0.3201608062,
0.1042700186,
0.0624672025,
-0.4136336744,
-0.4591707885,
0.7383912206,
-0.6558670402,
-0.8044620752,
-0.6016085148,
-0.3815594912,
-0.6294850707,
-0.2993534505,
0.493496567,
0.2068985701,
-0.1493656337,
0.1776519716,
0.5975339413,
-0.2316916138,
0.1203197017,
0.5211166143,
0.1869453043,
-0.277352035,
0.593557179,
0.4225457609,
0.5775191784,
0.1563603133,
0.1465639323,
-0.6201486588,
-0.5149841309,
-0.2658871412,
0.3477575183,
-0.8221130371,
-0.0985870063,
-0.3499133587,
-0.3362282813,
-0.255358696,
0.0529030263,
-0.2929864526,
-0.5240259767,
-0.0291847643,
-0.5667276978,
0.6016041636,
0.8998001814,
-0.1108143553,
0.4359983504,
-0.5579674244,
0.2646508217,
0.4936847687,
0.1811686605,
-0.5179699063,
-0.898560524,
0.2685890496,
0.1373280138,
-0.1194854528,
-1.1262003183,
0.5032749772,
0.2096143514,
0.6028890014,
0.0752503648,
0.0957584605,
0.7521482706,
-0.1535782814,
0.8907935619,
-0.1046078503,
-0.8504750133,
0.3814950287,
-0.1087469682,
-0.1676281393,
0.7232322693,
0.676820159,
-0.2376416028,
-0.4717802703,
-0.7532252669,
-0.5629938245,
0.1911367774,
0.2854332924,
0.4649369121,
-0.3131117225,
0.7192491889,
0.0667326525,
0.4987585545,
-0.9022933245,
-0.2607653737,
-0.0437269993,
-0.2684820592,
-0.4009189308,
-0.5233588219,
-0.1814556718,
0.005731788,
0.6430566311,
-0.2192730755,
0.2570480406,
0.4668418467,
0.0285097174,
-0.0131081641,
0.4691486359,
0.5435336828,
0.7677173018,
-0.1584397107,
0.3203192949,
0.5145586133,
-0.7752407789,
0.1742770523,
0.1399302781,
-0.1940369457,
0.0034508996,
0.5973702073,
0.5529456735,
0.1837289929,
-0.7252892852,
0.8025276661,
-0.0104509778,
-0.3882713616,
-0.5299887657,
0.1142671555,
0.2542212009,
-0.022692116,
0.4278379977,
-0.230824545,
-0.0951953679,
-0.4854891598,
-0.0126141077,
0.6460996866,
-0.4916997552,
-0.3876726925,
0.5058573484,
-0.0963641852,
-0.0230745897,
0.4483454227,
-0.0127341039,
-0.4527887702,
0.7094268203,
0.5062754154,
0.6874608397,
-0.4041417241,
0.2641189396,
0.1999076754,
0.7650564313,
-0.3701057434,
0.5909049511,
0.3967637122,
-0.7251968384,
-0.6413522363,
-0.5828484297,
-0.7494010329,
0.3899642825,
-0.3846048415,
-0.0818790197,
-0.2129164636,
-0.580286026,
-0.532843709,
0.3280626237,
-0.7118419409,
0.4877252281,
0.047889296,
1.125824213,
-1.1172072887,
0.5823199153,
0.382191062,
-0.5358861685,
-0.9959807396,
-0.0185859129,
-0.1069201976,
-1.2312178612,
0.1678855717,
0.1579185575,
-0.2767857611,
0.0987094417,
-1.0204342604,
-0.8255824447,
1.0573830605,
0.5664815903,
-0.3939446509,
0.1884766072,
0.3263876438,
0.5707498193,
-0.4048079848,
0.2832824588,
0.5545056462,
0.6938812733,
0.4168908,
-0.8189896345,
-0.0035719357,
-0.0494423322,
-0.177885443,
-0.27281937,
-0.3948633671,
0.9061883092,
-0.4999837279,
-0.2195858061,
0.3487592041,
0.3931393921,
0.4932495654,
0.2570162714,
0.4533015192,
0.4694418013,
0.7776510119,
-0.3494827747,
1.3857514858,
-0.2008052617,
0.2413366288,
1.114354372,
-0.2886599302,
1.0617351532,
0.5893268585,
-0.3768633008,
0.5769526362,
0.8628060222,
0.1426493078,
0.2925868332,
0.2203030139,
-0.2745390832,
-0.6354433894,
-0.0990559757,
-0.4302676618,
0.2570123076,
0.6625198126,
-0.3724744618,
0.2097888887,
-0.4599648714,
0.1544815153,
-0.0823608264,
-0.1369730532,
0.4962405562,
0.528593123,
-0.7635339499,
0.692933023,
-0.1830818206,
0.5078868866,
-0.7274939418,
0.048940789,
-0.5678187013,
0.0235591009,
-0.2784501314,
-1.134252429,
0.0787332878,
0.1987093389,
0.4482963085,
0.2303397655,
0.8156692386,
-0.3280017972,
-0.6469219327,
0.1323415488,
0.9627044201,
0.5602717996,
-0.1392056644,
-0.3670667708,
-0.243080914,
-0.3397821486,
-0.6161542535,
0.1912336349,
0.3340112269,
-0.0610082746,
1.0635410547,
0.7093709111,
0.2383994907,
0.035044048,
0.0353979915,
0.7950772047,
-0.3942749202,
-0.1447763741,
-0.9700823426,
0.262930125,
0.0084867356,
-0.270943433,
0.7265060544,
0.2120740563,
0.6158823967,
-0.0202576723,
1.016150713,
0.4159532189,
0.4918662608,
-0.4746807218,
0.3959384561,
-0.5179258585,
0.5887315869,
-0.3298369646,
-0.7337018847,
-0.2980572581,
0.6423125267,
-0.687900424,
0.4400909245,
0.445630908,
0.9698323607,
0.0803062618,
0.080946669,
0.4921841025,
0.5631293654,
-0.0540428944,
0.8170388937,
1.1329231262,
-0.2796422839,
0.747267127,
-0.1296833605,
-0.3382409215,
-0.0599815138,
-1.0757831335,
-0.7999764681,
-0.1474716067,
-0.1989611536,
-0.3241822124,
0.2605941296,
0.598534584,
0.6729664803,
-0.619854629,
-0.0663354322,
-0.1722386926,
0.0755934343,
0.0123311132,
-0.1811015755,
0.3186458051,
0.112515755,
-0.6058009267,
0.5017904639,
0.1263236403,
0.325190872,
-0.280403018,
-0.0611459613,
-0.1214538217,
0.490655601,
0.1479200572,
0.4242978394,
-0.8248494267,
-0.5383805633,
0.1150485873,
-0.1254952252,
0.0425139181,
0.1555455774,
-1.0080549717,
0.0607714765,
0.1522919238,
0.5261303782,
0.4185367227,
0.3473611772,
0.6242406964,
-0.8415055275,
-0.1009214744,
0.1406611204,
0.2656332254,
0.6054273844,
-0.358779639,
0.6975634694,
0.2662014365,
-0.6420664787,
-0.7720561028,
0.4506697655,
-0.880142808,
0.071578525,
1.1577767134,
-0.2780142725,
-0.0388711989,
-0.4023596942,
0.019628074,
-0.0327467248,
-0.2706582844,
0.6218836308,
0.8477176428,
-0.2070042491,
0.1521608233,
-1.0339053869,
0.560192883,
0.3358395994,
-0.6877043843,
0.0092423437,
0.1484020054,
0.6124724746,
0.1453738213,
1.0136523247,
-0.0417778566,
0.1238522679,
-0.0113485493,
-0.3945448697,
0.0687104315,
-0.2300692052,
-0.3693590462,
0.2537052035,
0.2844435573,
-0.0214146096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08849v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08849v2
|
OFA: A Framework of Initializing Unseen Subword Embeddings for Efficient Large-scale Multilingual Continued Pretraining
| 2023-11-15T10:40:45 | 2024-03-25T15:49:53 |
Yihong Liu, Peiqin Lin, Mingyang Wang, Hinrich Schütze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instead of pretraining multilingual language models from scratch, a more
efficient method is to adapt existing pretrained language models (PLMs) to new
languages via vocabulary extension and continued pretraining. However, this
method usually randomly initializes the embeddings of new subwords and
introduces substantially more embedding parameters to the model, thus weakening
the efficiency. To address these issues, we propose a novel framework:
$\textbf{O}$ne $\textbf{F}$or $\textbf{A}$ll ($\textbf{OFA}$), which wisely
initializes the embeddings of unseen subwords and thus can adapt a PLM to
multiple languages efficiently and effectively. OFA takes advantage of external
well-aligned multilingual static word vectors and injects the alignment
knowledge into the subword embeddings. In addition, OFA applies matrix
factorization and replaces the cumbersome embeddings with two lower-dimensional
matrices, which largely reduces the number of parameters. We show OFA
accelerates the convergence of continued pretraining, which is environmentally
friendly as much fewer carbon footprints are generated. Through extensive
experiments, we demonstrate OFA can achieve competitive or better performance
than default continued pretraining baselines on a wide range of crosslingual
downstream tasks. We make our code and models publicly available.
|
[
-0.4130551815,
-0.4084935188,
0.492339313,
0.3272425532,
-0.4361050129,
0.3510306478,
-0.3311320543,
0.0394689888,
0.2250875235,
0.3081356883,
-0.5146158934,
-0.281281054,
-0.5145002604,
0.0100179752,
-0.1041699499,
0.6909285784,
-0.1933236569,
0.1268755645,
-0.0931016356,
-0.4231497049,
-0.321993649,
-0.5343724489,
-0.4932680428,
-0.3481830359,
0.5892183185,
0.34779194,
0.4513381422,
0.8299756646,
0.1467379928,
0.3461560905,
0.2208388597,
0.139548853,
-0.7359027863,
-0.1450448781,
-0.0132046016,
-0.3130464256,
-0.1911804974,
0.0168660823,
0.9797059298,
0.9511936307,
-0.4578138292,
0.1374723464,
0.0838380456,
0.5896289945,
-0.8473705053,
0.0914767683,
-0.687323451,
0.0530496463,
-0.2713407874,
-0.2677767575,
-0.2572666705,
-0.0599758029,
0.146818772,
-0.8486914635,
-0.3212321699,
-0.1656014323,
0.5701336265,
0.2693933249,
-0.1012785733,
-0.1669814587,
-0.5867171884,
0.8824522495,
-0.3702407479,
0.8031492829,
-0.0129350303,
0.0136812506,
-0.0056042657,
-0.6882452965,
-0.7500380874,
-0.1163483858,
0.0872479156,
0.2189483643,
-0.0852096081,
0.0135970069,
-0.0470310971,
0.3067281246,
-0.3945513964,
0.2907860577,
-0.0582423769,
0.1779697984,
0.3067648113,
-0.2970526218,
0.4489158988,
0.4849382639,
-0.6206928492,
-0.1672094017,
-0.9616400003,
-0.2033521533,
0.5761179924,
0.2740125358,
-0.2283904701,
0.4060677588,
-0.0071900967,
0.4804804027,
0.0371435694,
-0.2006773651,
0.4457657337,
-0.4098653197,
0.0550964437,
0.1819666177,
0.3900623024,
-0.0661805794,
0.343935132,
-0.1624229401,
-0.2335661352,
0.042848967,
0.0645350739,
-0.7559728026,
-0.2067730725,
-0.0256514736,
-0.3761121929,
0.0995914415,
-0.044452861,
-0.5318444371,
-0.1334981918,
-0.5081790686,
0.2916796207,
-0.3195207417,
-0.4031861126,
0.3810640574,
0.2323404551,
0.2508981824,
-0.049606815,
-0.7831380367,
0.1315021664,
0.5175802708,
0.6489810944,
-0.1281794906,
-0.6108770967,
-0.6062985063,
0.0490089878,
-0.4738815725,
0.4332725108,
-0.6551936865,
-0.2668368816,
0.1194483787,
-0.0763109848,
-0.0597822927,
-0.2447054833,
-0.1789085865,
-0.7484378219,
0.2678862512,
-0.2899370492,
-0.3109685481,
-0.1988669485,
0.1661287248,
-0.5516601801,
0.9842120409,
-0.0429808125,
-0.5396790504,
0.5640310645,
-0.8305883408,
-0.2796677649,
0.0071162893,
-0.1712297946,
-0.0723417476,
0.2327684015,
0.2865039408,
0.1034241319,
-0.1473250389,
0.014870883,
-0.1640408039,
-0.1381966472,
-0.2808604538,
-0.2427252233,
0.6692636609,
0.2043301314,
-0.2120775729,
0.064186506,
-0.8065479994,
0.0175454188,
0.0323167369,
-0.497251451,
-0.589363575,
-0.0906648338,
-0.257641077,
0.2741056085,
0.4492718875,
-0.6776058078,
0.2006745934,
-0.4196665585,
0.1285919249,
0.7572517991,
-0.2412316799,
0.5328344703,
-0.0182142295,
0.8398432732,
0.0767659098,
-0.0737710744,
-0.4720139503,
-0.1830591708,
-0.9603221416,
-0.6370043159,
0.4418507814,
0.5708297491,
-0.9582893252,
0.5390663743,
-0.615547657,
-0.4849147499,
-0.4145909846,
0.5117228627,
0.7286639214,
-0.0007778869,
0.3969858885,
-0.3556407094,
-0.6325463057,
-0.7121850848,
-0.1062992737,
0.062803261,
0.2535058558,
-0.1187885404,
0.3902226985,
-0.1754207909,
0.8800795674,
-0.4252558053,
-0.206267342,
-0.3567426801,
0.0226264838,
0.1156706586,
0.768191874,
0.7894825935,
-0.4562438726,
-0.5991841555,
0.0157588422,
-0.4781157076,
0.0774947926,
-0.1618577242,
-0.3539707959,
0.0266828258,
0.8096500039,
-0.238587603,
-0.0373454019,
0.8069547415,
-0.0614471324,
0.0802569315,
-0.3857450783,
-0.2710828185,
-1.0034343004,
0.1278672069,
-0.4590044618,
-0.1533691585,
-0.4943872094,
0.1974678636,
-0.2533561289,
-0.2481343895,
-0.5348893404,
0.6792863011,
-0.7780465484,
-0.0392037928,
-0.4028640985,
0.2075394094,
-0.0973411202,
0.5400031209,
0.2885136604,
0.6267868876,
0.6547583938,
-0.5976064801,
-0.0289182235,
0.2815436721,
-0.3049365878,
0.231629625,
-0.5105175376,
0.3682135344,
-0.4667668343,
0.3192991018,
-0.7941097021,
0.2849324644,
-0.0639879033,
-0.1235847101,
0.4366282821,
0.0070982398,
-0.4887841046,
-0.104546763,
-0.1554043144,
0.6757966876,
0.3916837871,
-1.0024678707,
0.8927585483,
0.4427660704,
-0.3249792457,
-0.7913461924,
-0.55597049,
-0.0465444587,
-0.0104057333,
-0.31727916,
0.2549268007,
0.0282302219,
-0.0316177644,
0.0259140152,
-0.0719280019,
0.0704881921,
0.2408266813,
-0.1415630728,
-0.013757946,
-0.2152062804,
0.2068557441,
0.0770990625,
-0.271805346,
-0.2144683152,
-0.7309884429,
0.904826045,
-0.162544474,
-0.4420197308,
-0.0958629549,
0.4408801198,
0.4210814536,
-0.7208032608,
0.9005455971,
0.5964069366,
-0.5149888396,
-0.2622016668,
-0.4365850389,
-0.0654589087,
-0.5173243284,
0.6821728945,
-0.3896757662,
-0.765730679,
0.4403693676,
-0.1902566701,
0.3264738619,
0.1442598701,
0.5282734036,
0.3062244356,
0.9342649579,
1.1626911163,
-0.0293738451,
0.7805709243,
-0.2679041028,
0.2639935017,
-0.5200735331,
-0.1008010283,
-0.3059641123,
-0.2658948302,
-0.5921756029,
-0.5880690217,
0.1221132502,
0.268908143,
-0.1523628086,
0.3137741983,
-0.0276023913,
0.652874887,
0.4270091653,
-0.1946939975,
0.0946841761,
0.1154970229,
-0.5416743755,
0.1746965051,
-1.0884574652,
-0.3772141635,
1.0691722631,
0.3546449244,
0.7237971425,
0.1899247766,
0.9487531185,
-0.285883069,
0.7347425818,
-0.5459667444,
0.2939478755,
-0.5015157461,
-0.5568891168,
-0.2427438945,
-0.2518419921,
-0.9804379344,
0.3427076936,
-0.2503073514,
-0.648514688,
0.4537100792,
0.2589368224,
-0.4741023183,
0.315751642,
-0.5810790062,
0.7257643938,
-0.4513624012,
-0.3301084638,
-0.2964158952,
-0.3670484424,
0.1181288287,
-0.5145222545,
0.2679693103,
0.1288061291,
-0.2103736997,
0.8466123939,
-0.4112641215,
0.7104526162,
-0.4069183171,
-0.4090381563,
0.2262629569,
-0.4377100468,
0.3876418173,
-0.0002869161,
0.0915343612,
0.0681747049,
-0.1566877514,
-0.4158708453,
-0.4370077848,
0.8019164205,
-0.5572935343,
-0.3267496824,
-0.4440542459,
-0.4951944053,
-0.5145558119,
0.5870747566,
0.0584475771,
0.3977620602,
-0.1575042754,
0.459923774,
0.5805552602,
-0.524787128,
0.3262713253,
0.755201757,
-0.4425192177,
-0.4359911978,
1.02952981,
0.1556875259,
0.1229799688,
0.5404629707,
0.1941639483,
-0.634219408,
-0.5866398215,
-0.2550438643,
0.2314858735,
-0.75372082,
0.1007491425,
-0.6617004871,
0.2041206956,
-0.2637737095,
-0.2054656893,
-0.6885746717,
-0.0933456644,
-0.146364823,
-0.2832793593,
0.0700037107,
0.4023106396,
-0.2073854059,
0.6673474312,
-0.9486103058,
0.2352985144,
0.1881664842,
0.5945880413,
0.0261318926,
-0.3209552765,
-0.4855674505,
0.0230457317,
-0.0714311451,
-0.3800599575,
0.2032622993,
0.6059142351,
0.8821933866,
0.5311203003,
-0.101406917,
0.7313188314,
-0.6963716149,
0.5246856213,
0.4286398888,
-1.0288923979,
-0.0080791041,
-0.142962575,
0.4660580158,
0.8206912279,
0.7296800017,
-0.2586575449,
-0.0398523845,
-0.3485206962,
-0.9710616469,
0.4905417562,
-0.0993075594,
0.4018424451,
-0.2269774228,
0.1959486306,
0.2519363761,
0.3384349048,
-0.5776146054,
-0.3026830256,
-0.3606458008,
-0.1401093304,
-0.577696383,
-0.2302764505,
-0.1416532397,
-0.1697907001,
0.7737747431,
-0.2917743325,
0.0100143598,
-0.1709053516,
-0.4563028812,
0.1307574511,
-0.0433607139,
0.4116836786,
0.791387558,
0.042205099,
0.0203900691,
0.2821491957,
-0.4796203375,
0.3525578678,
0.1921353787,
-0.0014239192,
-0.1102210954,
0.4290185273,
0.8970435262,
0.2897881866,
-0.6270979047,
0.1847505122,
-0.0272896755,
-0.0686818138,
-0.3664967418,
-0.2786775827,
0.1723852009,
-0.0192764476,
0.2686172128,
-0.1371864378,
-0.3421258628,
-0.7103372216,
0.3569145501,
0.4546129405,
-0.1669406146,
-0.2681188881,
0.4920836389,
0.3987347484,
0.1714534611,
0.463247776,
-0.2065345943,
-0.6192742586,
0.1552146524,
0.4132831395,
0.8081428409,
-0.3132962584,
-0.0875572041,
0.2602543533,
0.5458039045,
-0.1280123889,
0.6830388904,
0.0447834209,
-1.0098041296,
-0.6130880117,
-0.820062995,
-0.007282801,
0.1754812896,
-0.5529680848,
0.0650239363,
-0.7425715923,
-0.0810615867,
-0.2372526526,
0.0234071594,
-0.8202020526,
0.3089318275,
0.2513442636,
0.9487602115,
-0.7187047005,
0.9422370791,
0.9243015647,
-0.1819940805,
-0.7528789639,
-0.1274497807,
-0.156696409,
-0.8458762169,
0.5568903089,
0.2643418312,
-0.2678879201,
0.3802965283,
-0.1365391761,
-1.290506959,
0.9164270759,
0.5963876843,
-0.7991821766,
0.1587179601,
0.0451653525,
0.4251996875,
-0.6186057329,
-0.0245491229,
0.4758290648,
0.5779888034,
-0.1976600438,
-0.5853242874,
0.0651930869,
-0.275339365,
0.1145130992,
0.046681162,
-0.4524939358,
0.7391242385,
-0.1242996827,
-0.4343172312,
0.1485294551,
0.7720923424,
0.128481552,
-0.2496601641,
0.8748050332,
0.780659318,
0.7248743176,
-0.0875283703,
1.0639244318,
-0.8454065919,
0.1442058086,
1.3212897778,
-0.4671489894,
0.7300180197,
0.500377655,
-0.0330444016,
0.5314555168,
0.3111763895,
0.2326126099,
0.7301174998,
0.4189403653,
-0.1840027869,
-0.4252080619,
-0.1334903091,
-0.5904896855,
0.7982481122,
0.1761653721,
-0.1869291663,
-0.4517427981,
0.3392909765,
0.0003496623,
0.0620314777,
-0.1384143233,
0.5728824139,
0.0794237331,
-0.6916450262,
0.6346479058,
0.1335870177,
0.8338854909,
-1.0115302801,
0.1029075235,
-0.2763225138,
0.408264339,
0.0013931749,
-0.1672032773,
0.1397412419,
-0.1237566397,
0.0101540806,
-0.5006905198,
0.3077563345,
-0.8115500808,
-0.3863275051,
0.5085163116,
0.608399868,
-0.0846450478,
0.1512572169,
-0.5993936062,
0.057533782,
-0.2275923938,
-0.3654334545,
0.4158026874,
0.3223216832,
0.0215660352,
0.5506725907,
0.9963170886,
-0.0512471832,
0.2052997649,
0.0372922383,
1.027422905,
-0.0391069762,
-0.7835412025,
-0.525123179,
0.346571207,
0.2810619771,
-0.4489656687,
0.7738170028,
0.497225225,
1.002325654,
-0.1557786912,
0.6750229597,
0.1491182446,
0.2147817016,
-0.7537435889,
0.9225387573,
-0.82634902,
0.1732022613,
-0.1494748592,
-1.0788289309,
0.0183328055,
0.6577982903,
-0.1477593184,
0.2923691869,
0.642054677,
0.5664548874,
-0.0750845522,
-0.4553732872,
0.1881957799,
0.0993094668,
0.3533711731,
0.1333460957,
0.497656405,
0.1005266383,
0.2326524407,
-0.2306375057,
-0.4548499286,
0.1651179045,
-1.2097098827,
-0.6517447829,
-0.393838048,
-0.2924799919,
-0.0539436229,
0.1336269677,
1.0186473131,
0.8496117592,
-0.7802327275,
-0.1762041748,
-0.2423789352,
-0.2131224424,
-0.2656931877,
-0.1073182896,
0.2763160169,
-0.3787755072,
-0.7062113881,
0.7050712705,
0.0850643441,
0.0155089432,
-0.5308003426,
-0.2739872038,
-0.756477654,
0.3993254602,
0.5591729283,
0.4453901947,
-0.2186431438,
-0.1843096316,
-0.0929213092,
0.2500791848,
-0.1979174614,
0.7222658396,
-0.7346233726,
0.5007272363,
0.4978746474,
0.9697677493,
0.1590569615,
-0.074261792,
0.858191967,
-1.0227404833,
0.5339224339,
0.1284989268,
0.6553634405,
0.2975266874,
0.0766971558,
0.2658758461,
0.1730002314,
0.0705884919,
-0.8835752606,
0.3383544981,
-0.6755158305,
-0.1608312726,
0.9391999245,
-0.7475026846,
-0.0688273907,
-0.0298846513,
0.1906270832,
0.2652961314,
-0.2074563056,
0.4571224153,
0.5942028761,
0.3776296973,
-0.0118009439,
0.0184999313,
0.343008399,
0.6407574415,
-0.8134613633,
-0.0422197469,
0.2340589017,
0.3269641399,
0.5375080109,
0.7478503585,
-0.1432282329,
0.0718619674,
0.1211583465,
0.1199378371,
-0.3170834184,
-0.6879781485,
-0.3228402138,
-0.0356522463,
-0.061276149,
-0.4294320941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08844v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08844v1
|
Violet: A Vision-Language Model for Arabic Image Captioning with Gemini Decoder
| 2023-11-15T10:34:14 | 2023-11-15T10:34:14 |
Abdelrahman Mohamed, Fakhraddin Alwajih, El Moatez Billah Nagoudi, Alcides Alcoba Inciarte, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Although image captioning has a vast array of applications, it has not
reached its full potential in languages other than English. Arabic, for
instance, although the native language of more than 400 million people, remains
largely underrepresented in this area. This is due to the lack of labeled data
and powerful Arabic generative models. We alleviate this issue by presenting a
novel vision-language model dedicated to Arabic, dubbed \textit{Violet}. Our
model is based on a vision encoder and a Gemini text decoder that maintains
generation fluency while allowing fusion between the vision and language
components. To train our model, we introduce a new method for automatically
acquiring data from available English datasets. We also manually prepare a new
dataset for evaluation. \textit{Violet} performs sizeably better than our
baselines on all of our evaluation datasets. For example, it reaches a CIDEr
score of $61.2$ on our manually annotated dataset and achieves an improvement
of $13$ points on Flickr8k.
|
[
-0.2409824133,
-0.1676705629,
0.1598256677,
0.28285864,
-0.6620524526,
0.0064137424,
0.2742134035,
-0.4920039773,
0.2150985897,
0.461345464,
-0.3670969903,
-0.615019083,
-0.7697051764,
0.1793436408,
-0.6873915195,
0.9222112894,
0.0721336678,
0.5140389204,
-0.0459379256,
-0.3272147775,
-0.6479515433,
-0.2131181806,
-0.6442872882,
0.1658582985,
0.3107460737,
0.7156889439,
0.8564763069,
0.6853326559,
0.8759201765,
0.294732511,
0.206638515,
0.277772814,
-0.3317778707,
-0.1402036846,
-0.128766641,
-0.4982335865,
0.0136947921,
-0.1380551159,
0.4627189636,
0.2527964711,
0.2229301035,
0.0106758811,
-0.3636488914,
1.004330039,
-0.8123720884,
0.4334323704,
-0.5142256618,
0.2209106684,
-0.0382211022,
-0.0752705336,
-0.1778322905,
-0.1913861036,
0.0173518136,
-0.3398310542,
-0.0104411133,
0.2317953855,
1.1108093262,
0.4079967141,
-0.5470559001,
-0.0747362375,
-0.8114042282,
0.8405742049,
-0.1512253284,
0.2058647275,
0.10895551,
0.6514994502,
0.4599996805,
-0.9204034805,
-0.6520816088,
-0.3333721757,
0.164821282,
0.371458143,
-0.5147083998,
-0.0989123508,
-0.2223867625,
0.7359766364,
-0.2405956686,
-0.2617960572,
-0.5999945998,
-0.238162607,
0.5680485368,
0.0912997872,
0.4594726264,
-0.3169797361,
-0.3307898939,
-0.0572647899,
-0.4520361125,
-0.1841262877,
0.0554635599,
-0.0383876674,
-0.3104473054,
0.751665473,
-0.1932128668,
0.6086701155,
-0.0934215859,
0.2232170701,
0.2751629651,
-0.1880268157,
-0.1064982265,
-0.3486718237,
0.6771535277,
0.960500896,
0.6680827737,
-0.2510138452,
-0.324501127,
0.6311468482,
0.0863932744,
-0.9005613327,
-0.6316924095,
0.2183331698,
-0.5500032902,
-0.4457676411,
0.3871196806,
-0.7688451409,
-0.7557489276,
0.0079669403,
0.4522979856,
-0.465988487,
0.0802510008,
-0.056099277,
-0.2499853522,
0.5511778593,
0.2512468994,
-0.7311809063,
0.2370214611,
0.1988666058,
0.8537890315,
-0.2490257919,
-0.1238299683,
-0.7202228904,
-0.2152251005,
-0.5759314895,
0.5861883759,
-0.631493628,
-0.3707728088,
0.0530187227,
-0.0859436169,
0.2559088767,
-0.532335341,
0.6156636477,
-0.685392797,
-0.1825437397,
-0.067463398,
-0.4308996797,
-0.2735987008,
-0.0040172413,
-0.7660495043,
0.4970496297,
0.1944132596,
-0.6234937906,
0.322863698,
-0.7996128798,
-0.3038842678,
0.3593217432,
-0.3333515525,
-0.473023504,
0.0641344264,
0.6644359231,
0.2215398699,
-0.1657407582,
-0.0952387005,
0.3241274059,
-0.4071023166,
0.5936134458,
-0.6040699482,
0.4861382842,
0.4024264514,
-0.3433556557,
0.3187918365,
-0.7667301893,
-0.1351611614,
0.144690007,
-0.1258883476,
0.0472407416,
-0.1109195948,
0.5812467337,
0.0926268622,
0.3517414927,
-0.7516366839,
-0.1096738279,
-0.6380482912,
0.3553867638,
0.4731317759,
-0.0292778537,
0.7122196555,
-0.3282807767,
0.896496892,
0.3695207238,
0.3789975345,
-0.494379729,
-0.6639529467,
-1.3430553675,
-0.3464018106,
0.3145395815,
0.6257508993,
-0.9417538047,
0.0388981141,
-0.2885076106,
-0.5815886259,
-0.8270773292,
0.0086078532,
0.6934110522,
0.3777773082,
0.460917443,
-0.39937374,
-0.4542769492,
-1.1800751686,
0.063811034,
0.222608462,
0.1463641822,
0.4770623147,
0.7262727022,
-0.518450141,
0.812269032,
-0.4839966893,
-0.6133649349,
-0.2556678057,
-0.0456396043,
0.17542018,
0.4716509283,
0.5703029037,
-1.2833262682,
-0.7257881165,
0.2186426669,
-0.6296511292,
0.0845416114,
0.0685414374,
-0.271935761,
0.5747816563,
0.4799958467,
-0.4943076968,
0.7873913646,
0.8847731352,
-0.3554986119,
0.5919056535,
-0.0068382551,
0.3073878884,
-1.0720926523,
-0.0797362179,
-0.0825312436,
-0.3172386289,
-0.3455942571,
0.3097300231,
0.2829401493,
-0.3694376945,
-0.6765039563,
0.7820900679,
-0.5615344644,
0.018159816,
-0.4378266037,
-0.1933489442,
-0.1362414807,
0.495395273,
0.110788174,
0.9030979872,
1.0465888977,
-0.4580639303,
0.8059001565,
0.3538577557,
-0.3882882893,
0.3884229362,
-0.6230210662,
-0.0540696308,
-0.3637644649,
-0.2447412014,
-1.1068829298,
-0.2384411693,
0.4857410789,
-0.5930019021,
0.0770481229,
-0.3061783016,
-0.1221119761,
-0.3643276691,
-0.1808441877,
0.4008015692,
0.6815564632,
-0.624247551,
0.8698157072,
0.3109057546,
-0.0770312101,
-0.6497874856,
-0.7973044515,
0.3397094905,
-0.2597138882,
-0.5348550677,
0.4747683108,
0.1769277006,
-0.3039054275,
-0.0107927183,
-0.0727363452,
-0.2048974186,
-0.2845870256,
0.5387673378,
0.4557286799,
0.0528935418,
0.2118253261,
-0.3460640609,
-0.3885141611,
-0.0067683826,
-0.6011779904,
0.5432463884,
-0.5032742023,
-0.2724347115,
-0.5788451433,
0.3448811471,
0.670516789,
-0.8094780445,
1.0090757608,
0.4040201604,
-0.3868734837,
-0.0667046383,
-0.2032972574,
-0.1927153319,
-0.4998585284,
0.6753112078,
-0.3178789914,
-0.15536201,
0.3395818174,
0.247855708,
0.0683116391,
0.4215400219,
0.3384691775,
-0.4283634424,
0.951841712,
0.9578425288,
-0.2101804763,
0.5326762795,
-0.4854231477,
0.097241573,
-0.3578780293,
-0.2092941105,
-0.2950088382,
-0.3814939857,
-0.5410861373,
-0.5433248281,
0.4513531029,
-0.2155577242,
0.0428803861,
-0.0103271259,
-0.4244581461,
0.7164860368,
0.8128731847,
0.3247153461,
0.3352872133,
0.2966633141,
0.0651354492,
-0.2625579238,
-0.6181014776,
-0.5136965513,
1.1879024506,
0.1421263218,
0.7711860538,
0.2496140748,
0.4415458739,
0.4468175471,
0.451395005,
-0.8637060523,
0.4922889173,
-0.4249949157,
-0.4279729426,
-0.1718698591,
-0.2090427727,
-1.0075615644,
0.0299532022,
-0.3446114659,
-0.4238740206,
-0.0326766111,
0.4000136852,
-0.0144694094,
0.0236078203,
-0.5343526006,
0.9979380369,
-0.4235419035,
-0.1957456321,
-0.0948465019,
-0.6055277586,
0.2466268986,
-0.0217409059,
0.2136407644,
0.1844798177,
0.0144405207,
0.7643325329,
-0.6350087523,
0.6622031927,
-0.0848411545,
0.2955341041,
0.3106318414,
-0.0290511437,
0.4300912023,
-0.0783434585,
0.1966657192,
0.1617037207,
-0.132917434,
-0.5775805712,
-0.530867219,
0.411770612,
-0.8266932368,
-0.3508302867,
-0.5784391165,
-0.5246832371,
-0.0881058127,
0.0341511779,
0.5977659225,
0.4296548069,
0.0440636426,
0.0451032668,
0.2332795411,
-0.4062737226,
0.3536984026,
0.3558448553,
-0.6794237494,
-0.6747909784,
1.0829867125,
-0.1928328425,
0.0401650034,
0.5704065561,
0.0769374445,
-0.3198904991,
-0.6583616734,
-0.5926520228,
0.2909343541,
-0.9688799381,
-0.1681899726,
-0.4348242879,
-0.3288893104,
0.0043289349,
-0.2924970388,
-0.2640135884,
-0.3566658497,
-0.2399965078,
-0.0517307781,
0.6334674358,
0.5066828132,
0.2701422572,
0.3836469352,
-0.9718813896,
0.4728217125,
0.3663479388,
0.0767492652,
-0.1775674671,
-0.6921567917,
-0.4163956642,
0.042880889,
-0.391048342,
-1.1428035498,
0.910314858,
0.3527874053,
0.1065813154,
0.5405185223,
-0.0177174173,
0.6287704706,
-0.4528760016,
0.5890367031,
0.3244544864,
-0.8686563373,
0.6693609953,
-0.2837401927,
0.4574485421,
0.2909658253,
0.2602728605,
-0.4857104421,
-0.4416989386,
-0.3105368912,
-0.9346526861,
0.2701112926,
0.5975987911,
0.4896166623,
0.0601473004,
0.247886762,
-0.1572994888,
0.2848421633,
-1.0563728809,
-0.4713324308,
-0.3981714845,
-0.6626520157,
-0.1627358049,
-0.2034757137,
0.1007930636,
-0.3220511973,
0.5936840773,
-0.090752475,
0.2565482259,
0.0408166125,
-0.2826664746,
-0.0875058472,
-0.0040869149,
0.0663686693,
0.4205917716,
0.1431354135,
-0.1616175771,
-0.1240678951,
-0.6323837042,
-0.0496048294,
0.2873347402,
-0.559114337,
0.0772326663,
0.2705396116,
0.6802718639,
0.0153531805,
-0.965929091,
0.5935570598,
-0.0911580846,
0.1091633812,
-0.6992830634,
0.0264778137,
0.039119333,
0.2006974369,
0.489665091,
0.4564737082,
0.2545048892,
-0.415641129,
0.1063155532,
0.5052312613,
-0.5868265629,
0.1577958316,
0.8738492727,
0.7201925516,
-0.3309223354,
0.7985345125,
-0.0757998899,
-0.5706026554,
0.9779835939,
0.154133752,
0.7508514524,
0.0778061822,
0.377523005,
0.3993009329,
0.2425713241,
0.4581829906,
0.7840355039,
0.1390262097,
-0.9863978028,
-0.1458811015,
-0.9097001553,
-0.466042161,
-0.0606092289,
-0.4459887445,
0.3337371349,
-0.2989661992,
0.0348076485,
0.0631881282,
-0.2000761628,
-0.6883293986,
0.5641168356,
0.2889199853,
1.020080328,
-0.7334845662,
0.6454651356,
0.88098526,
-0.7625651956,
-0.6340655088,
-0.1155705675,
-0.1177655905,
-0.6617588997,
0.6618238688,
0.5449381471,
-0.2820622027,
0.3423963785,
-0.4658370912,
-0.7254467607,
0.8667906523,
0.2153852731,
-0.7404055595,
0.4055779576,
0.0973956287,
0.3141079247,
-0.5932179093,
-0.0891858116,
0.3710866272,
0.4635724127,
0.2179285437,
-0.5698001385,
-0.494514972,
-0.4772043824,
-0.0118588936,
-0.0263858605,
-0.4082588851,
0.7964764237,
-0.5697078109,
-0.4297973514,
0.6656267643,
0.8887624741,
0.0719062537,
0.169125542,
0.1890280247,
0.2005966902,
0.6737478971,
-0.2451531738,
1.3275316954,
-0.5053088665,
0.061147593,
0.7462168336,
0.0435280725,
0.8942319155,
0.4901561439,
-0.1209865585,
0.4586293697,
0.4868090451,
-0.3570134938,
0.7033202052,
0.0486403331,
-0.4039928615,
-0.0662617907,
-0.1516805142,
0.0483393967,
0.6872739792,
0.0349332504,
-0.7714371681,
0.3267529309,
0.3464990258,
-0.2742378414,
0.4128230512,
-0.7382997274,
0.6003392339,
0.0037184288,
-0.5850790143,
0.47430709,
0.2501783669,
0.6684296131,
-0.4953037798,
-0.1690828949,
-0.3590058684,
0.326874882,
-0.212824285,
-0.728700161,
0.2563216984,
0.2820899487,
-0.1813732982,
0.1735998094,
0.5506744385,
-0.482499212,
-1.0172216892,
-0.0047166715,
0.2977610528,
0.3684429824,
-0.2027234733,
-0.4912447631,
-0.0291463211,
0.1631613374,
0.3455875516,
-0.4422045052,
0.0464402772,
-0.2075173706,
0.9461321235,
0.4929609597,
0.1923727691,
0.1327294111,
0.2477007359,
0.6649259925,
-0.7764809728,
-0.7305270433,
-0.931283474,
0.8693054318,
-0.1323401779,
-0.2785542607,
0.8781824708,
0.5465463996,
0.4700217545,
-0.7185528278,
0.8940176368,
0.1009078398,
-0.0022936654,
-0.6990936399,
0.8670303822,
-0.5503857136,
0.0741642118,
-0.2193897665,
-0.9595322013,
-0.4142759144,
0.8598558903,
-0.1792266071,
0.2620087862,
0.6082999706,
1.0296508074,
0.1449251473,
-0.2030424476,
0.429821074,
0.31024459,
0.01396483,
0.5236693621,
0.9741267562,
-0.622035563,
0.8685330153,
-0.2409363389,
-0.3177610636,
-0.1688610315,
-0.6799599528,
-0.8935590982,
-0.5365179777,
-0.4887923598,
-0.154278636,
0.0892963409,
0.5420875549,
0.7998673916,
-0.9869776964,
0.0362355746,
-0.4978061914,
-0.2293922305,
-0.2322082371,
-0.2128464431,
0.315977633,
0.1169164106,
-1.0470341444,
0.0037914999,
0.3231090605,
0.3903087974,
-0.4504367411,
-0.4403152764,
0.171511814,
0.198480919,
0.3364788294,
0.1428134739,
-0.7990329266,
0.0808380768,
-0.0637779087,
-0.1047477722,
0.1068722755,
0.1156011522,
-0.9120678902,
0.5273749828,
0.0336911529,
0.5184828043,
0.571018815,
0.0977746397,
0.5636945963,
-0.6383895278,
0.1916301399,
0.2314179242,
0.6514977813,
0.6792657971,
-0.1981505007,
0.3688279092,
0.1275682598,
-0.247092694,
-0.2366715968,
0.5417212248,
-0.8987288475,
-0.1840967387,
1.0745482445,
-0.0387693346,
-0.2078617513,
0.0492088161,
-0.7567449808,
-0.0597646758,
-0.2436078489,
0.9433240891,
0.5945891142,
0.2379773855,
-0.6621679664,
-0.2004866004,
0.4340918958,
0.39419052,
-0.6936630011,
-0.3724985421,
0.8243128657,
0.197577849,
0.1867542118,
0.5031268597,
-0.1714826971,
0.901902318,
0.2128715366,
0.2200947255,
-0.1809515208,
-0.6210793257,
-0.4883904457,
0.0661357269,
0.161831826,
-0.8575772047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10766v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10766v1
|
Value FULCRA: Mapping Large Language Models to the Multidimensional Spectrum of Basic Human Values
| 2023-11-15T10:29:28 | 2023-11-15T10:29:28 |
Jing Yao, Xiaoyuan Yi, Xiting Wang, Yifan Gong, Xing Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has attracted much
attention to value alignment for their responsible development. However, how to
define values in this context remains a largely unexplored question. Existing
work mainly follows the Helpful, Honest, Harmless principle and specifies
values as risk criteria formulated in the AI community, e.g., fairness and
privacy protection, suffering from poor clarity, adaptability and transparency.
Inspired by basic values in humanity and social science across cultures, this
work proposes a novel basic value alignment paradigm and introduces a value
space spanned by basic value dimensions. All LLMs' behaviors can be mapped into
the space by identifying the underlying values, possessing the potential to
address the three challenges. To foster future research, we apply the
representative Schwartz's Theory of Basic Values as an initialized example and
construct FULCRA, a dataset consisting of 5k (LLM output, value vector) pairs.
Our extensive analysis of FULCRA reveals the underlying relation between basic
values and LLMs' behaviors, demonstrating that our approach not only covers
existing mainstream risks but also anticipates possibly unidentified ones.
Additionally, we present an initial implementation of the basic value
evaluation and alignment, paving the way for future research in this line.
|
[
-0.114606984,
-0.6117498279,
0.4420681596,
0.0696685761,
0.1310677975,
0.220587939,
-0.0893185064,
-0.6298205256,
0.0500961691,
0.6130072474,
-0.5063660741,
-0.3684704006,
-0.6520659924,
-0.4467961192,
-0.3070580065,
1.2420783043,
0.3055733442,
-0.2370310277,
0.115129374,
-0.4795751572,
-0.1423190534,
-0.6445229053,
-0.1789362878,
-0.1270097196,
0.8284282088,
0.5362246633,
1.0197503567,
0.6642878652,
0.4993380904,
0.2208558917,
-0.1441183537,
-0.0460215099,
-0.6986059546,
-0.3159005344,
0.0519581772,
-0.2539026737,
-0.5635530353,
0.240596801,
0.5933253169,
1.1808056831,
-0.1876230985,
0.3354347348,
0.0264671315,
1.084915638,
-0.4578699172,
0.1436038315,
-0.5899471045,
-0.2583676577,
-0.3726559579,
0.0677447766,
-0.1669813097,
-0.7334777117,
-0.0154384421,
-0.3144714832,
-0.3090739548,
-0.1194283962,
1.1167503595,
0.4288860559,
-0.70184201,
-0.3579516411,
-0.7073466778,
0.8405134678,
-0.3526560962,
0.228463769,
0.107562907,
0.4658317864,
-0.2098053694,
-0.2880294621,
-0.779042244,
0.0681648105,
0.0402245186,
-0.2486110628,
-0.3273876905,
-0.1418688148,
0.0789253712,
0.2537715137,
-0.2082939297,
0.1725543141,
-0.6221699715,
-0.1629367918,
0.9160277843,
0.3984962106,
0.370077461,
0.3248943985,
-0.4768476784,
-0.233044073,
-1.0465197563,
0.645590663,
0.653316617,
0.6190721393,
-0.2980969548,
0.4959552586,
0.0230736844,
0.4750189185,
-0.0328402892,
-0.2330076694,
0.5111581087,
-0.5245825648,
-0.0977969617,
0.0280426815,
0.5167699456,
0.2551806271,
0.61600703,
-0.1785604507,
0.0445726477,
0.3092810512,
0.3905512989,
-0.6070669889,
0.0991785154,
0.0964395404,
-0.4537400603,
-0.6941311955,
-0.0036353299,
-0.8411642909,
-0.4826536477,
-0.5954897404,
0.2580516338,
-0.251139015,
-0.2923271954,
0.0491636656,
0.3659819663,
0.7888097763,
0.3100741804,
-1.1238728762,
0.6885188818,
0.6602267623,
0.4872413278,
-0.1946288347,
-0.2422967851,
-0.4685600996,
0.2433766276,
-0.1277365834,
0.8144523501,
-0.4673219025,
-0.4845295846,
-0.270054549,
-0.2244580686,
0.3851120174,
-0.1669291407,
0.5149145126,
-0.2546321452,
-0.0511261038,
-0.4491205812,
-0.30730322,
-0.0679971576,
0.1893021166,
-0.752196908,
0.8275540471,
0.285155654,
-0.3913562,
0.2443485111,
-0.8938586712,
-0.5473884344,
-0.0592097342,
-0.3049246669,
-0.3236072958,
-0.0681539103,
-0.2303315252,
0.2045796812,
-0.4065203369,
0.354173094,
-0.2612488568,
-0.4272017181,
0.6770768166,
-0.621352613,
1.0459778309,
0.2039610147,
-0.1151093915,
0.3276917934,
-0.6470103264,
0.2419430763,
0.0369637683,
-0.2243903726,
-0.1438101679,
-0.1808443815,
0.2659564912,
0.3839900494,
0.3743034303,
-0.2399755567,
0.1571655571,
-0.4824987352,
0.2934227884,
1.087718606,
-0.2901704609,
0.6620265245,
-0.3603800833,
0.2283124626,
0.1058528125,
0.2834529579,
0.0015708531,
-0.5115616918,
-0.4641977847,
-0.3538302481,
0.1164694354,
0.4425395131,
0.1976884604,
0.6647449732,
-0.4965195954,
-0.5406367183,
-1.0441598892,
0.2965670228,
-0.0213383622,
0.3418406546,
0.2137368023,
0.0539170764,
-0.2677211463,
-1.0705071688,
-0.097842373,
-0.1013823301,
0.064055942,
0.139465645,
0.1884002388,
-0.5561095476,
1.1006919146,
-0.6151329279,
-0.3373402357,
0.0068286755,
-0.0488032438,
0.3879914284,
0.3645153642,
0.5010375381,
-1.0246325731,
-0.2938677967,
0.0249843281,
-0.3379765749,
-0.2348607183,
0.071816355,
-0.3419311643,
0.0637373775,
0.0029067122,
-0.1471702754,
0.4674421847,
0.6363503933,
-0.4130418897,
0.0648060739,
-0.0781698748,
0.1691592634,
-1.0900424719,
0.490845561,
0.0302840434,
0.0240467768,
-0.8843702078,
-0.0149346441,
0.0031928204,
-0.0500355586,
-0.4956892133,
0.6875828505,
0.0409966744,
-0.1729365736,
-0.3931028843,
0.1262407303,
-0.034504842,
0.5169342756,
-0.2327171564,
0.6372506022,
-0.0078226943,
-0.6057444215,
0.2775337696,
0.1844621301,
-0.0645152703,
1.0897750854,
-0.5810863376,
0.0876197442,
-0.1210891977,
0.095698975,
-0.9911438823,
-0.0255330987,
0.1784745157,
-0.5092153549,
-0.05484806,
0.0835820884,
-0.4807278216,
0.1656278968,
-0.3550852239,
0.6475557089,
0.6620177627,
-0.286419332,
0.4259575307,
1.0070059299,
-0.2692574859,
-0.5649064183,
-0.4856654704,
0.1540215909,
-0.4602982402,
-0.7671225071,
0.3290351331,
-0.4093279839,
-0.345831424,
-0.1104524881,
0.1346181333,
-0.3476003408,
0.3405582309,
0.4337983131,
0.4248228073,
-0.0989965647,
-0.1139642298,
0.1358378828,
-0.6117069125,
-0.0781714991,
0.0231331941,
0.2796296775,
-0.6810244322,
-0.3232366145,
0.0288279653,
0.4380904734,
0.5107703209,
-0.0847556815,
0.6468449831,
0.4933923781,
-0.6978681684,
0.1341739297,
-0.3688004911,
0.2183750421,
-0.4538061023,
-0.0324944071,
-0.0147725614,
-0.9025164843,
0.5696194172,
-0.0454767756,
0.012877929,
0.4260632694,
0.6638185382,
-0.3161245883,
0.7512425184,
0.8477522731,
-0.336037457,
0.0162338894,
-0.054149773,
0.4525631368,
-0.762552917,
-0.3577425182,
-0.7891856432,
-0.5015981197,
-0.5166451931,
-0.372089386,
0.4162921309,
-0.1620074213,
-0.4616520107,
0.104573518,
-0.3388386965,
0.5481069684,
0.2994709909,
-0.3084474802,
0.3655443192,
-0.3076784909,
0.18973957,
-0.2742529213,
-0.1861899197,
-0.9043101072,
1.0446993113,
0.5047058463,
0.9088135958,
0.5202414989,
0.5199261904,
0.2338015437,
0.5583461523,
-0.7282838225,
0.2530415058,
-0.0128257358,
-0.6492637396,
-0.5424938798,
-0.3272911608,
-1.1608073711,
0.2447393984,
-0.2017954737,
-0.9454118609,
0.1012984365,
0.0559467822,
-0.4639678001,
-0.0158275142,
-0.4424009919,
0.9697642326,
-0.6781800985,
-0.1904752254,
-0.0697350278,
-1.0703032017,
0.6021441221,
-0.1623375267,
0.5380433798,
-0.4416873157,
-0.0391589589,
0.3238280714,
-0.0170990899,
1.1563611031,
0.149047941,
-0.4237788618,
-0.0014921575,
-0.0604310632,
0.1462655663,
-0.3021066487,
-0.0632019639,
0.2594058812,
0.3131667078,
-0.6865252256,
-0.4116230309,
0.7746127844,
-0.9013435841,
-0.1254205704,
-0.5457713008,
-0.5681040287,
-0.1371362209,
0.3243619204,
-0.247643888,
-0.132441327,
-0.7108220458,
0.1251961738,
0.778141439,
-0.2283302248,
0.0663324073,
0.4883652329,
-0.0848215595,
-0.1845155656,
0.9911721945,
-0.0003198381,
0.3254871666,
0.2025998235,
0.2040040195,
-0.43079561,
0.0038063722,
-0.2607378364,
0.0552165285,
-0.8899772763,
-0.2570749819,
-0.3030300438,
-0.2785186172,
-0.225053817,
-0.628775835,
-0.3214989305,
-0.1224793792,
-0.0660637245,
-0.030535927,
0.1880090982,
0.5744999051,
0.0727746859,
0.0643975213,
-0.9316946268,
0.4041703343,
0.2004056573,
0.4589100778,
-0.0841105804,
-0.1458158791,
-0.2373159081,
0.5690211654,
-0.3166710436,
-0.7084795237,
0.2977592051,
-0.1295095384,
0.9472411275,
0.4705806077,
0.081757009,
0.6714091897,
-0.3399765193,
0.6272621155,
0.0593058094,
-1.2706154585,
0.4113342464,
-0.1155540049,
-0.1271672845,
0.7440515757,
0.0429082587,
-0.9012566805,
0.0641803816,
-0.7706201673,
-0.8137830496,
0.3713509142,
0.2832887173,
0.4584048092,
0.2304325402,
0.1201278791,
0.1596692204,
0.3016242087,
-0.9502719641,
-0.1694283336,
-0.2151964158,
-0.7438188791,
-0.040577095,
0.0672757626,
-0.5394799709,
-0.1916186064,
0.1972710788,
-0.3145979643,
0.2334451377,
-0.424248755,
-0.2690595388,
-0.3914061487,
0.5218676329,
0.8818148375,
0.5313765407,
-0.0408577286,
0.2022225261,
0.1582279354,
-0.1074082553,
0.5950665474,
-0.1816475391,
0.0825864524,
-0.8235721588,
0.11814861,
0.537794888,
0.5490396619,
-0.7376111746,
0.7348794341,
0.2874234617,
0.1903834641,
-0.3071683943,
0.2457281798,
0.1593401283,
-0.0098719504,
0.2505944669,
0.0038837229,
0.0035757152,
-0.769418478,
0.2183812857,
0.4711204171,
-0.40698722,
-0.4322452545,
0.5029180646,
0.3863147795,
-0.2367738336,
0.5626041889,
0.0142310634,
-0.333071053,
0.7367408276,
0.3449003696,
0.7390736938,
-0.1988905221,
0.1080585569,
-0.0551923215,
0.5283207297,
0.1055708677,
0.3132820129,
0.1402098238,
-1.1573975086,
-0.0990970731,
-0.6236183047,
-0.4082919359,
-0.1929454803,
-0.6935947537,
0.2378208935,
-0.3796028495,
0.2455704957,
0.020548841,
0.1972866505,
-0.7054094672,
0.1312928349,
0.3121063709,
0.5916582942,
-1.0362474918,
1.1196655035,
0.2093230486,
-0.5678358078,
-0.6374466419,
-0.0137867229,
0.3538134396,
-1.1002144814,
0.7273173928,
0.2146311849,
-0.5055204034,
-0.0744179413,
-0.4951978922,
-0.7642370462,
1.3075621128,
0.3609363437,
-0.1090197787,
0.0419398695,
0.5278084278,
0.7001621127,
-0.7132366896,
-0.3206487,
0.7574161291,
0.8994820118,
0.3540962636,
-0.6022391915,
-0.0357587636,
-0.358361125,
0.0290448554,
0.3067902029,
-0.590813756,
0.4821508825,
-0.5639019012,
-0.1791561991,
-0.0582466796,
0.4189008474,
0.2547546029,
0.3361410797,
0.35016644,
0.379730016,
1.0587687492,
-0.0424794443,
0.7959868908,
-0.272891283,
0.1235610768,
0.7482671738,
-0.6133130789,
0.7123301625,
0.5599517822,
-0.3815585971,
0.2915953994,
0.425755322,
-0.0043427162,
0.362845093,
0.3303661346,
0.035774406,
0.0741141364,
-0.0778829381,
-0.2736755013,
0.5087624192,
0.6335729957,
-0.0787776932,
-0.0107681947,
-0.4798754454,
0.1827161461,
0.2769334316,
-0.1678603441,
0.6987826824,
0.0799473003,
-0.1612704247,
0.2542411983,
0.046511475,
0.4910864234,
-0.6455233097,
0.0672829002,
-0.0920262486,
-0.0164193623,
-0.1703273952,
-1.1467151642,
0.5910354853,
0.024931429,
-0.0961193889,
-0.31280303,
0.2449534684,
-0.4481216073,
-0.6195832491,
0.1719945967,
0.2570838928,
-0.0358418785,
0.3014114499,
-0.5147753954,
0.1631922722,
-0.2262825519,
0.2140404433,
0.4573674202,
0.3744773567,
-0.1555491835,
0.6669788957,
0.7780486345,
-0.0837763846,
-0.161064297,
-0.1418626606,
0.7992392182,
-1.0464767218,
-0.6056972146,
-0.8687685132,
0.8435124159,
-0.0384330265,
-0.4672418237,
0.3598004878,
0.4128829539,
0.5228295922,
0.3529573381,
0.7197976112,
0.1779524535,
0.1424671263,
-0.4504837394,
0.7823036313,
-0.1755940169,
0.3165216446,
-0.5815688372,
-0.7677749991,
-0.3877175748,
0.8098657727,
0.0971691683,
-0.1169174239,
0.1951765418,
0.5847661495,
0.1094629988,
-0.2213458717,
0.4478094876,
0.0751734897,
0.5727283955,
0.7378684282,
0.6458353996,
-0.4061121047,
0.4468171597,
0.0550489798,
-0.2678102851,
-0.378074646,
-1.057243824,
-0.3987283707,
-0.7634209991,
0.0057081324,
-0.3105813265,
-0.3464601636,
1.0671665668,
0.4830304384,
-0.6365292668,
-0.5109617114,
0.3786724806,
0.292152077,
-0.1639100462,
-0.163063556,
0.1740628332,
0.0241796561,
-0.4314626455,
0.0797186419,
0.6108542085,
0.3626897037,
-0.5037896633,
-0.4860152602,
-0.015500552,
0.518783927,
0.4387164116,
0.4278504848,
-0.7896949053,
-0.6616446376,
-0.0461076796,
-0.5608730912,
0.2470888048,
0.6310415864,
-0.5271321535,
0.1017471477,
0.0649623424,
0.7828634381,
0.1153110564,
-0.1627306342,
0.5819675326,
-0.5331072211,
0.0905160978,
0.2412576377,
0.3091522157,
0.278580755,
-0.5657435656,
0.5170041919,
-0.0407659374,
-0.4525938332,
-0.8516702056,
0.6631177068,
-1.3104170561,
0.0452755429,
0.8492665291,
0.1456960738,
-0.0833732113,
-0.0437482446,
-0.4166702926,
0.0991306007,
-0.2905023396,
1.0973992348,
0.6406277418,
0.0279264841,
-0.1055312529,
-0.2299384475,
0.3814944625,
-0.1170100868,
-1.1459343433,
0.1962077022,
0.5513189435,
0.3197579384,
0.1462232918,
0.6975165009,
-0.3328957558,
0.2820027471,
-0.4014670849,
0.2195070535,
0.0995055586,
-0.1107048765,
-0.5152617097,
0.1755121946,
0.198322311,
0.1404268891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10765v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10765v1
|
Enhancing Machine Translation through Advanced In-Context Learning: A Methodological Strategy for GPT-4 Improvement
| 2023-11-15T10:28:28 | 2023-11-15T10:28:28 |
Yufeng Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The challenge of improving translation accuracy in GPT-4 is being addressed
by harnessing a method known as in-context learning. This paper introduces a
strategic approach to utilize in-context learning specifically for machine
translation, aiming to significantly boost accuracy. The crux of this method
lies in the judicious selection of demonstrations that are most effective for
in-context learning. By selecting these examples carefully, GPT-4 can utilize
them to achieve remarkably accurate machine translations, eliminating the need
for task-specific fine-tuning. This technique is anchored in the semantic
similarities between the user's prompt and the chosen dataset. Sentences from
this dataset, carefully picked for their relevance and clarity, serve as potent
demonstrations for in-context learning. This approach not only enhances
translation accuracy but also enriches the understanding of nuanced linguistic
structures. It represents a significant step forward in machine learning,
leveraging the inherent capabilities of GPT-4 to provide translations that are
not only accurate but also contextually rich and linguistically sophisticated.
This method demonstrates the potential of in-context learning in overcoming
language barriers, opening new avenues for cross-cultural communication and
global collaboration.
|
[
-0.2433294058,
-0.6771149635,
0.6779516339,
0.1439440846,
-0.3988643587,
0.3418703377,
-0.3954285085,
-0.1499480605,
-0.450299114,
0.1667061299,
-0.3480326533,
-0.4220365286,
-0.6270135641,
0.4587905407,
-0.1612404585,
1.0270168781,
-0.5010371208,
0.1623451263,
-0.1369058937,
-0.2356649339,
-0.784876883,
-0.5475280285,
-0.5166469216,
-0.4252682924,
0.1083597317,
0.7126649022,
0.5573047996,
0.6208108068,
0.48217237,
0.310513854,
0.1367408484,
0.3611032963,
-0.4684095383,
0.1527963877,
-0.0637395233,
-0.318313241,
-0.2889381647,
0.0708241537,
0.8011393547,
0.4597177505,
0.2508369088,
-0.1178331971,
0.3965089917,
0.4550541043,
-0.2449870408,
0.2667947412,
-0.6485595107,
0.0558421202,
-0.4310258627,
-0.4842132628,
-0.1774693727,
-0.3316321075,
0.1934064478,
-0.634739995,
0.152061224,
-0.1649118811,
0.7305079699,
0.4037181139,
-0.6464627981,
-0.3357102573,
-0.4212957621,
0.6606342793,
-0.6027471423,
0.3305415511,
0.398846209,
0.5769815445,
-0.2109300196,
-0.9088061452,
-0.3093509674,
-0.117264159,
-0.0242904443,
0.3484446704,
0.1265112907,
-0.1040524393,
0.3118600845,
0.2398086637,
-0.5121319294,
-0.144559741,
-0.2001417577,
-0.1209999546,
0.1954687834,
-0.1816754192,
0.2198739797,
0.0674908012,
-0.4997418523,
-0.0169956498,
-0.8021659851,
-0.0222287159,
0.0966997743,
0.2809557021,
0.0743826106,
0.2338889092,
-0.3734553158,
0.6534332633,
0.1899412423,
-0.1634923816,
0.4614523649,
-0.6325885057,
-0.1083333641,
0.1526044309,
0.559822917,
0.2976370454,
-0.1776440293,
-0.3245220482,
-0.3566926718,
-0.1923103333,
0.2326795459,
-0.9232353568,
-0.01995112,
-0.0870710835,
-0.1994859576,
-0.2597973347,
0.048779048,
-0.6086998582,
0.1493664533,
-0.2814634144,
0.5915948153,
-0.602846384,
0.1295381635,
-0.0505715981,
-0.1017104611,
0.3164032102,
0.2472944856,
-1.0435750484,
0.1865133494,
0.6275097728,
1.1423245668,
-0.1385731995,
-0.2367577702,
-0.7578812838,
0.5490990281,
-0.449010849,
0.4853530228,
-0.5316067934,
-0.3180212677,
-0.1806885749,
-0.1497538835,
0.1075472459,
-0.5244928598,
0.8983872533,
-0.3772591352,
0.4304822087,
-0.5007143617,
-0.6474909782,
-0.5183392167,
0.4139121771,
-0.2982654274,
0.9459571838,
0.404488951,
-0.4733653963,
0.5677482486,
-1.0896946192,
-0.5184544921,
0.3949505091,
-0.3121758401,
-0.3719632626,
0.0345236138,
0.5604183078,
0.6039960384,
0.0104228044,
0.2038134336,
0.0579221435,
-0.5142093897,
0.0832186416,
-0.4132869542,
0.5429834127,
0.3738350868,
-0.7567865849,
0.197733447,
-0.1637032181,
0.062766172,
-0.0165170394,
-0.4005814493,
-0.1831047684,
-0.4419263899,
-0.2379162312,
0.3564463854,
0.2968230247,
-0.2420649827,
0.1621913016,
-0.633985579,
0.7080568075,
0.4943920076,
0.0030460914,
0.8039209843,
-0.0796477273,
0.5653361082,
-0.171117276,
0.1220154986,
-0.2848550677,
-0.6249264479,
-0.1103581488,
-0.1239712834,
0.2826804519,
0.5546070337,
-1.1101840734,
0.2947526574,
-0.4451220036,
-0.1551970243,
-0.4722650349,
0.2621288002,
0.4659432173,
1.0682458878,
0.635021925,
-0.2460893244,
-0.204246074,
-0.6437729597,
-0.4527745843,
0.1962502897,
-0.1182307228,
0.147626102,
0.4352823496,
-0.3403680921,
0.7861881852,
-0.0134603018,
-0.2409437299,
-0.3847535849,
0.0756677166,
0.1180500165,
0.550208807,
0.4365364611,
-1.1122716665,
-0.7421050668,
0.4910383821,
-0.9408648014,
-0.0845394582,
0.1089531109,
-0.2261216193,
0.0912786499,
0.5173062086,
-0.2356388867,
0.1548424512,
0.3855561912,
-0.07452932,
0.1360007972,
-0.5160211325,
0.4273444414,
-1.1423139572,
-0.1484585404,
-0.1804846972,
-0.4753437936,
-0.6831631064,
0.2380364686,
0.5248291492,
-0.0042656721,
-0.3957792521,
0.3046343029,
-0.2862207592,
-0.0500592813,
-0.2595508099,
0.2998539209,
-0.0858260915,
0.2657454908,
-0.1746863574,
1.0599685907,
0.2688480318,
-0.3756738603,
0.3415145874,
0.422092557,
-0.287763983,
0.6761923432,
-0.2855353355,
0.1805159003,
0.2653385103,
0.546033442,
-0.7515075803,
-0.5134230852,
0.528092742,
-0.5067578554,
0.4949689507,
-0.0872011483,
-0.4300486743,
-0.0288913641,
-0.0343464687,
0.4534502923,
0.5066313744,
-0.5997356772,
0.2665829659,
0.1611351818,
-0.1197265983,
-0.5262188315,
-0.5443486571,
0.4164378047,
-0.6794222593,
-0.4067718983,
0.7443634272,
0.0310064368,
0.133422941,
-0.2849074602,
-0.1131606922,
0.0863741785,
0.1929987669,
-0.1897003055,
-0.0814803094,
0.0397042893,
0.1008688509,
0.2327849567,
-0.2863141,
-0.0951637626,
-0.7219850421,
0.1521970481,
-0.4209084809,
-0.1178361624,
-0.4810367525,
0.3390188217,
0.26260975,
-0.193391785,
0.1737639308,
0.7637465596,
-0.2985286713,
0.0720809922,
-0.165174216,
-0.3795354664,
-0.5118492842,
0.5305483341,
-0.8261796236,
-0.778776288,
0.1838932037,
-0.6529939771,
-0.0569526963,
0.1955180764,
0.456741333,
-0.2182540298,
1.1516525745,
0.5848097801,
-0.0952651128,
0.6265671253,
-0.3123947382,
0.2505111396,
-0.8697118759,
-0.1767271012,
-0.3496024609,
-0.3520065844,
-0.6017937064,
-0.4992780089,
0.5737721324,
0.1203307956,
-0.3732844591,
0.4191428423,
-0.4891504943,
0.583252728,
0.6096012592,
0.1825964302,
0.2819162011,
0.0058231032,
-0.3188545406,
-0.1905373782,
-0.8366807103,
-0.7702921629,
0.9597784281,
0.2530997694,
0.1449739784,
0.1875221729,
0.6662731767,
0.0371554159,
0.3958673775,
-0.5161008835,
0.2657001019,
0.1960125715,
-0.2731344402,
-0.3777391911,
-0.6169877052,
-0.7410709262,
0.2253772318,
0.0507532209,
-0.2882568836,
-0.2247314155,
0.2891145051,
-0.0956038982,
0.0461144485,
-0.6932504177,
1.3868736029,
-0.6319070458,
-0.2735720575,
-0.1293297112,
-1.0911222696,
0.0501074269,
-0.2886436284,
0.1709189117,
0.2846215665,
-0.4664479196,
0.276979357,
-0.0608023778,
0.6138788462,
-0.2878811061,
-0.0150200389,
-0.1149753556,
-0.1126970053,
0.6957941651,
-0.0305370018,
-0.0397964492,
0.1572541893,
-0.3922167122,
-0.6189348102,
-0.8381639123,
0.5568572879,
-0.6223025322,
-0.3365921676,
-0.1510092467,
-0.6273297071,
-0.341748625,
0.1910299361,
0.5417799354,
0.5678889155,
-0.2065254301,
0.2065512985,
0.572540164,
-0.0707089528,
0.337908566,
0.0550976433,
0.1191794351,
-0.489543736,
0.9816180468,
0.0325507149,
0.3330186903,
0.6552739143,
0.3132686615,
-0.655044198,
-0.8602944613,
-0.9259428978,
-0.0229888614,
-0.9234362245,
-0.2155863643,
-0.5594192743,
0.2378978878,
-0.290918529,
-0.4035145342,
0.0391592309,
-0.2506678998,
-0.0679574832,
-0.2128169835,
0.1477397233,
0.7322232723,
0.195527032,
0.4774306715,
-0.6304145455,
-0.0389750153,
0.1109869778,
0.0679243207,
-0.5347819328,
-0.8114164472,
-0.472886622,
0.0674785003,
-0.8505091667,
-0.8851513863,
0.3861810267,
0.359631449,
0.7316503525,
0.289373517,
-0.1637283713,
0.8236782551,
-0.6790263653,
0.7524384856,
-0.0637646392,
-1.153408885,
0.7743933201,
-0.5523727536,
0.3649920821,
0.558165431,
0.5031095147,
-0.4829289615,
-0.4283819497,
-0.7034003735,
-0.8498085737,
0.4170872867,
0.3407601118,
0.0547613725,
0.1505314112,
0.5837590694,
0.1671686023,
0.3236411214,
-0.5576971173,
0.228681758,
-0.5506170988,
-0.3640330434,
-0.3920889497,
0.2068599612,
-0.1683251113,
-0.2716231048,
0.7872563004,
-0.5909708142,
0.0495948344,
0.0959107652,
-0.2796316445,
0.1878060997,
0.0171727333,
0.7398475409,
0.7402213216,
-0.054725118,
0.0155818602,
0.6015716791,
-0.2827725708,
0.2020425349,
0.0154611357,
-0.1347011477,
-0.0672878027,
0.1863700897,
0.7629230618,
0.4924600124,
-0.3748261333,
0.5984627008,
0.1140692756,
-0.1177367046,
-0.0665502027,
-0.2665205002,
-0.0778463185,
0.2800395489,
0.2944130599,
0.2451861054,
0.4301882684,
-0.4136722386,
0.3585649133,
0.3965916038,
-0.4953178465,
-0.244616732,
0.6725438237,
0.3491786718,
-0.3076192141,
0.5146214962,
-0.3596076667,
-0.7347047925,
0.2040067166,
0.7620025277,
0.8516872525,
-0.3093660176,
0.0365610793,
0.2554072142,
0.1532615274,
-0.3267667592,
-0.0778579712,
-0.3372578323,
-0.5432749987,
-0.5789096355,
-0.1620507836,
-0.6134872437,
-0.1706010997,
-0.3465575576,
0.3559105098,
0.0784376785,
-0.0730975419,
-0.5474280715,
0.0922981873,
-0.4131264687,
0.0502115041,
-0.0496815778,
0.6452888846,
-0.7249661684,
0.999735117,
0.7587246299,
-0.3695584834,
-0.5671826005,
0.2658113539,
0.0223197173,
-0.4969410598,
0.558744669,
0.4516847134,
-0.120594196,
0.3624655604,
-0.4432156086,
-0.6354746222,
1.2408494949,
0.5804154873,
-0.1552472562,
0.231583938,
0.0309803709,
0.3270772696,
-0.5386454463,
0.21006082,
0.5977795124,
0.5799095035,
0.0303868465,
-0.8260207176,
0.1378350854,
0.0907077044,
0.1546221375,
0.1962935179,
-0.3971669972,
0.3073463142,
-0.1296118647,
-0.1513953209,
-0.0587405488,
0.7690114975,
0.0899306908,
0.3347668648,
0.3820835054,
0.2531736791,
0.8579500914,
-0.2584934831,
0.9946187735,
-0.1196433604,
0.0978918076,
1.0116404295,
-0.0957668871,
0.6826049089,
0.467582047,
0.155521214,
0.2989153862,
0.8730995655,
0.2578162253,
0.8334814906,
-0.1094026119,
-0.5227809548,
-0.002147496,
0.2259333581,
-0.2615457773,
0.441236347,
0.528324306,
-0.2548513412,
-0.2760580778,
0.295638144,
0.0669084787,
0.3035607338,
-0.1421951354,
0.8682115674,
-0.0182101652,
-0.6574726701,
0.6460369825,
-0.0034605362,
0.5510230064,
-0.453587383,
-0.2607132494,
-0.0295279212,
0.2107143849,
-0.0641326308,
-0.6593003869,
0.3256311119,
-0.0175142419,
0.0946320966,
-0.7903748751,
0.4574759305,
-0.5272861123,
-0.1248520687,
0.1807368547,
0.5860153437,
0.5427307487,
-0.2724703848,
-0.787553966,
-0.201157093,
0.0834885538,
0.0880555287,
0.3379701078,
0.9131650329,
-0.2714824975,
0.4818423688,
0.4948426485,
-0.1286289394,
-0.2249239683,
-0.0311035346,
0.6489092112,
-0.5003958941,
-0.6359844208,
-0.9755725265,
0.3450281918,
-0.3364475369,
-0.3019214571,
0.8941267729,
0.588748455,
1.2967441082,
0.0775859505,
0.9846306443,
0.1060261205,
0.2853396535,
-0.3723742664,
0.460642755,
-0.4510744214,
0.0872643292,
-0.3485346735,
-0.7795028687,
-0.4921998382,
0.7548267245,
-0.4551887512,
0.1521510631,
0.8256136179,
0.7402079701,
-0.2564825118,
0.0159170739,
0.4916940928,
0.0204581767,
0.5385674238,
0.5162170529,
0.7117983103,
-0.5493795872,
0.6197473407,
-0.1530948132,
-0.6721496582,
-0.2429735512,
-1.0408970118,
-0.6439427733,
-0.695235908,
-0.0041877222,
-0.0381520838,
0.0971710086,
0.8702788353,
0.6522884965,
-0.5740149021,
-0.1689106524,
-0.2851033509,
-0.091986753,
-0.7596157193,
-0.1148108467,
0.2292301059,
-0.8608302474,
-0.913498342,
0.8281682134,
0.3368228376,
0.1507922262,
0.1369008124,
-0.3774441481,
0.0780188516,
-0.4711025357,
0.7436443567,
0.0128755653,
-0.7143682241,
-0.2519270182,
-0.1840860993,
0.0277486648,
0.223008886,
0.7247923613,
-0.8091207743,
0.5568435192,
0.3912719488,
1.061424017,
0.6024702787,
0.2179218084,
0.9642170072,
-0.8301647305,
0.01155282,
0.3025095463,
0.2132445574,
0.7451933026,
-0.4498553574,
0.7338479757,
0.2792414427,
-0.9316695929,
-0.531955421,
0.3237740397,
-0.6546363831,
-0.1048586518,
0.9229289889,
-0.2854148746,
0.1357671916,
-0.4009896219,
-0.4424147308,
0.4956382215,
-0.4468874633,
0.6418088078,
0.5624707937,
-0.1845412403,
0.0423374139,
-1.1209233999,
0.8179442286,
0.35390836,
-0.6964455247,
-0.1414119303,
0.2872849405,
0.1708919406,
-0.1374658644,
0.4157891572,
-0.2531445026,
0.1731322557,
-0.475726217,
-0.3523357511,
0.1076879799,
-0.2760270834,
-0.585919857,
0.0998546779,
-0.1040826589,
-0.30621925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08838v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08838v2
|
Disinformation Capabilities of Large Language Models
| 2023-11-15T10:25:30 | 2024-02-23T10:44:18 |
Ivan Vykopal, Matúš Pikuliak, Ivan Srba, Robert Moro, Dominik Macko, Maria Bielikova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automated disinformation generation is often listed as an important risk
associated with large language models (LLMs). The theoretical ability to flood
the information space with disinformation content might have dramatic
consequences for societies around the world. This paper presents a
comprehensive study of the disinformation capabilities of the current
generation of LLMs to generate false news articles in the English language. In
our study, we evaluated the capabilities of 10 LLMs using 20 disinformation
narratives. We evaluated several aspects of the LLMs: how good they are at
generating news articles, how strongly they tend to agree or disagree with the
disinformation narratives, how often they generate safety warnings, etc. We
also evaluated the abilities of detection models to detect these articles as
LLM-generated. We conclude that LLMs are able to generate convincing news
articles that agree with dangerous disinformation narratives.
|
[
-0.3767981827,
-0.9097426534,
0.8972002864,
0.0702094063,
-0.1284173131,
0.2155655026,
-0.2641489804,
-0.5916498303,
-0.0763500184,
0.4059544504,
-0.225080654,
-0.3461088836,
-0.8587569594,
0.2619102895,
-0.8600532413,
0.911925137,
-0.0802770928,
-0.0928790197,
-0.3335353136,
0.3439602852,
-0.2916341424,
-0.6153550744,
-0.4195591211,
-0.1874702424,
0.5069338679,
0.3258042336,
0.7239899635,
0.4727787971,
0.333664149,
0.3477372229,
-0.2074609548,
0.061429739,
-0.6937587857,
0.1694862843,
-0.277072072,
-0.5176918507,
-0.1948635578,
0.1475943923,
0.7907660604,
0.6267142892,
-0.0585848726,
0.2843744755,
0.2221808881,
0.7771844864,
-0.1407473087,
-0.0558406115,
-0.99674052,
-0.2153437287,
-0.2475016266,
-0.1862108707,
-0.6287730932,
-0.3456995487,
-0.0287543405,
-0.2532215118,
0.030935796,
0.2951687872,
0.5588223338,
0.2007399201,
-0.6241853237,
-0.8116288185,
-1.0227781534,
0.6966186166,
-0.7261836529,
0.1677076966,
0.345482111,
0.2057073265,
-0.3560694456,
-0.4898997247,
-0.7395703197,
-0.4902962744,
0.005989104,
-0.2426083833,
-0.5751222968,
-0.3619308472,
0.4396699369,
0.2778525651,
-0.5639344454,
0.6604446173,
-0.5030495524,
-0.2050047964,
0.8047450185,
0.0964219794,
0.3723026216,
-0.3333994448,
-0.2789983451,
-0.0322989263,
-0.864341259,
-0.3713730574,
0.8366448283,
-0.1080025211,
-0.0574677885,
0.6182034016,
-0.1491516978,
0.4651785791,
-0.0038185362,
-0.8021838069,
0.1953303367,
-0.1995735914,
-0.1031602994,
0.3256923258,
0.793089807,
0.269975096,
0.1810017824,
0.0170230139,
-0.4668578804,
-0.0337743051,
0.4057654142,
-0.5346305966,
0.3313400745,
0.2767985463,
-0.4690014422,
-0.6846916676,
0.0483226813,
-0.6457189918,
-0.5650977492,
-0.151907891,
0.4445866048,
-0.2972080112,
-0.3202161789,
0.2317355871,
-0.131847173,
-0.1253909916,
0.2545154095,
-0.4785007536,
0.0218823031,
0.3537427485,
0.5818628073,
-0.1043453589,
-0.114890486,
-0.2601192892,
0.2588611841,
-0.4124630392,
0.4522101581,
-0.0275449157,
-0.2232623249,
0.2248310298,
0.0645260587,
0.3999992609,
-0.4529102743,
0.3917285502,
-0.6531458497,
0.0937474594,
-0.1160795987,
-0.4448372424,
-0.3669568598,
0.316179961,
-0.879611671,
0.5278158188,
-0.0679922253,
-0.7848013043,
0.3341830969,
-0.2665747702,
-0.7046627998,
0.0078470958,
-0.0114810765,
-0.5255677104,
0.1190094128,
0.0933206305,
0.668722868,
-0.2016281337,
0.6038401127,
-0.1444445699,
-0.035449896,
0.6651317477,
-0.9614068866,
0.5338869691,
0.3470432758,
-0.4834479392,
-0.1614199132,
-0.6747577786,
-0.5245779157,
0.4123456478,
-0.5332262516,
-0.4598632753,
0.0062870621,
-0.1904130429,
0.2800976336,
0.3924927413,
-0.3626542985,
-0.0538084097,
-0.1696898788,
0.2820417583,
0.6150601506,
0.3482605219,
0.1043878421,
-0.7223082185,
0.4481873214,
0.2628757656,
0.149578169,
-0.3290782273,
-0.4598536491,
-0.563593328,
0.0066686594,
0.0927529037,
0.468795985,
-0.9044949412,
0.5313584805,
-0.1613500714,
-0.8118596077,
0.0419668816,
0.270899564,
0.3109637201,
0.3901487887,
-0.0462800264,
0.3305536211,
-0.601554215,
-0.832695961,
-0.0711267516,
-0.3143979311,
0.0047394843,
-0.1646207124,
0.6116814017,
-0.356669426,
0.5657426715,
-0.1249918044,
0.0633378401,
-0.4066332281,
0.1863392144,
0.2168685645,
0.0466055274,
0.6908669472,
-1.015214324,
-0.4711351395,
-0.1955480725,
-0.8601360917,
-0.0946513042,
-0.4259030819,
0.4011377394,
0.6287631989,
0.5189654231,
-0.5714921355,
0.3200166225,
0.7256496549,
-0.0489533208,
0.7063081861,
-0.3193772137,
0.262578696,
-1.249753356,
0.0360639542,
0.209317252,
-0.3122991323,
-0.6169846654,
-0.2624950409,
-0.0667840615,
-0.00055914,
-0.7661131024,
0.2729019821,
-0.670129478,
0.0571843982,
-0.2594493628,
0.4158506393,
-0.1203905717,
-0.2349795848,
-0.165341571,
0.3897277415,
0.5521933436,
-0.795276463,
0.7414216995,
0.0663082823,
-0.7436817288,
0.1103459969,
-0.4814728498,
-0.1980683059,
-0.3791116774,
0.1502168626,
-1.0166592598,
-0.4989273548,
-0.0976883546,
-0.3180709779,
0.2979811132,
0.1861905605,
-0.8082758784,
-0.6376977563,
-0.2759156227,
0.0280403402,
0.7563290596,
-0.370875597,
0.1369829476,
0.5702579618,
-0.4210009277,
-0.4639101923,
-0.9263001084,
0.3630321026,
-0.5515933037,
-0.6600467563,
0.0674569607,
0.069257535,
-0.643345654,
0.0683443546,
0.0830130503,
0.3263522685,
0.2094564289,
0.4505554736,
0.1752880365,
0.0805387273,
0.2853698432,
-0.0290610399,
0.047555957,
0.1631323397,
-0.0473362058,
0.7271580696,
0.1385583282,
-0.6215518117,
-0.3698036671,
0.1830193251,
0.8348161578,
0.0479086004,
1.0878845453,
0.3241882622,
-0.449048847,
-0.2953560352,
-0.7704752088,
-0.1245539561,
-0.4636023939,
0.6251915097,
0.2001734525,
-0.7795690894,
0.3664707839,
-0.03507296,
0.0003922408,
0.6172893643,
0.8142943382,
0.1988508254,
1.0416066647,
0.5669344068,
-0.3601079881,
0.178984344,
0.0784593001,
0.3289964497,
-0.056116458,
-0.3594547212,
-0.4900586605,
-0.1947443634,
-0.668299973,
-0.2263938785,
0.5579846501,
-0.0031756945,
-0.0274095628,
0.114814125,
-0.2175410539,
0.3687120378,
0.4112943709,
-0.2077970505,
0.5723009706,
0.2516540289,
0.067123808,
0.1111442372,
-0.6250027418,
-1.0777561665,
1.0823343992,
0.8543749452,
1.0975960493,
0.2361228466,
0.5442416072,
0.5560584664,
0.3153038025,
-0.6338798404,
0.4835976064,
-0.0808695927,
-0.5840796828,
-0.4172303677,
-0.4172843993,
-0.6029391885,
-0.3774517477,
-0.4436587393,
-0.4546554983,
-0.2176733464,
0.0416745245,
-0.2159640789,
0.5501258373,
-0.3470024168,
0.1416052133,
-0.5934039354,
0.0279026683,
-0.4382082522,
-0.1427087933,
0.6525990963,
-0.7194371819,
0.5082565546,
-0.07218346,
0.0143030947,
0.6246871352,
0.3118961155,
1.0599764585,
0.0782319233,
-0.5491890907,
0.4202379286,
0.0943265855,
0.6163566709,
0.2014645487,
-0.2275978923,
0.3250071704,
-0.2667611539,
-0.025765419,
0.023642106,
0.6951875687,
-0.5750385523,
-0.9263051152,
-0.4893114865,
-0.538089335,
-0.0757567957,
0.298612982,
0.4030520916,
0.2077928782,
-0.4220261574,
0.3882251978,
0.7000890374,
-0.5434300303,
0.5610725284,
0.7239170671,
-0.4463802576,
-0.0861074403,
0.7207314372,
0.3061613441,
0.3371013105,
0.1949097663,
0.0450030416,
-0.379948765,
-0.8628576398,
-0.3359438479,
0.2452725619,
-0.6025159359,
-0.1949036568,
-0.4310441017,
-0.4176253378,
-0.282879293,
-0.0169552863,
-0.1762287617,
-0.0785477012,
-0.2508554757,
-0.3140881956,
0.1653582901,
1.2293695211,
-0.0136528956,
0.130368039,
-0.9960699081,
0.2943094075,
0.2773281336,
-0.0581609905,
-0.0878880844,
-0.4542137086,
-0.3922959268,
0.3115231395,
-0.4593484402,
-0.973276794,
0.3934367597,
-0.3167827129,
0.8742194772,
0.631886065,
0.2478081435,
-0.026084194,
-0.5645829439,
0.9521945119,
0.3208280206,
-0.7219467163,
0.4034272432,
-0.4706332982,
0.030747436,
-0.0256497469,
0.9056980014,
-0.5348873734,
-0.7362462878,
-0.5577225685,
-0.6525476575,
0.3552341163,
-0.0401647352,
0.4156016409,
-0.2610382736,
0.2210005522,
0.3211840689,
0.2891341448,
-0.8509507179,
-0.0938484892,
0.026568329,
-0.037403401,
-0.1345121711,
-0.8020872474,
-0.1618371159,
0.1366156191,
0.8441386223,
0.0931322947,
-0.197278142,
0.0301127285,
-0.079518728,
-0.4049046934,
0.2918302119,
0.7252469063,
0.8245509267,
0.1989595145,
0.3675271571,
0.1457297057,
-0.3609960973,
0.3788909912,
-0.2772189677,
-0.2098618746,
0.0778937116,
0.4444796741,
0.6840147376,
-0.1844094843,
-0.8735756278,
0.5343232155,
0.0756687745,
-0.4804304838,
-0.6513338089,
0.0979330763,
0.2947738469,
0.1912965029,
0.5624629855,
-0.1977793723,
-0.1680440456,
-0.7080931664,
0.2365533859,
0.5410564542,
0.0929055586,
-0.2318742871,
0.5280616879,
0.1881007701,
-0.0318167247,
0.373174876,
-0.238799274,
-0.3930982649,
0.5311790109,
0.7461392283,
0.468244642,
-0.3514007032,
0.3174565732,
0.2690299451,
0.7021389008,
-0.3129453361,
-0.1240647659,
0.6652873158,
-0.7327235341,
-0.4395527542,
-0.737721622,
-0.2134631127,
0.8412364125,
-0.3248599172,
0.3240040839,
-0.2841293812,
-0.1827258468,
0.0313776657,
-0.2554632723,
-0.3000965714,
0.0797287002,
0.5730986595,
0.821708858,
-0.9753184915,
0.6340088844,
0.5637400746,
-0.2953797877,
-0.6265015602,
0.356556505,
0.3156443834,
-0.5282908082,
0.6023305058,
0.2503882349,
-0.0534573495,
-0.1979762763,
-0.5005542636,
-0.7250115275,
1.0388079882,
0.7207577825,
-1.0625053644,
-0.0801463351,
0.6928420067,
0.494301796,
-0.4431271553,
-0.3393821716,
0.4260216057,
0.6126329303,
-0.0940793157,
-1.0742800236,
0.1413128823,
0.0780526027,
0.1248611584,
-0.0554835945,
-0.4636227787,
0.7943733335,
-0.233304143,
-0.4031685889,
-0.0697521791,
0.3381274045,
0.0161998998,
0.2978186607,
0.6304573417,
0.3959584236,
0.6982076764,
0.1062025055,
0.9694889188,
-0.4237806797,
0.1485833973,
0.6294670701,
-0.2910750508,
0.6468731761,
0.3192443252,
0.0828055516,
0.3941161633,
0.304898113,
-0.0096525671,
0.1670924574,
0.2417626977,
-0.3677016199,
-0.1525952369,
0.0526755266,
-0.1669083089,
0.6318679452,
0.4060871601,
-0.7551413178,
-0.1194947585,
0.2812639177,
0.1879435331,
0.3896495998,
-0.3246971667,
0.6992180347,
0.06201078,
-0.4406658113,
0.6793215871,
0.1833352298,
0.6236823201,
-0.4660301507,
0.0001995042,
0.1268025637,
0.0920356736,
-0.2012980431,
-0.8392748833,
0.495475769,
0.2764168084,
-0.2606452703,
-0.1560118943,
0.8710119128,
-0.3833890259,
-0.5097259283,
0.2484148592,
0.7250859737,
0.1415589005,
-0.1209329367,
-0.2108457536,
0.1854431629,
0.1095982566,
-0.4085974395,
0.3837416172,
0.4683514535,
-0.0952453613,
0.7421984673,
0.666346252,
0.2806375325,
0.0551093705,
-0.1151281521,
0.8953999877,
-0.4958820343,
-0.3419118822,
-1.0778743029,
0.3964627683,
-0.1122221276,
0.2358724624,
1.0676907301,
0.4474503994,
0.765932858,
-0.2238408327,
1.1652719975,
-0.032034602,
0.6028161049,
-0.6244271994,
1.060295105,
-0.4631407261,
0.5150556564,
-0.0454746969,
-0.911432445,
0.0278602615,
0.1170220003,
-0.4457643926,
-0.0263126586,
0.5843524933,
0.6988249421,
0.1197932735,
-0.1739065647,
0.6295647025,
0.5615050197,
0.3483894765,
0.3169101775,
0.9738448262,
-0.0141442716,
0.4921892583,
-0.1571281701,
-0.2661621869,
-0.2606962025,
-1.1695717573,
-1.0088528395,
-0.6553542018,
-0.1488700509,
-0.3947305679,
-0.1511739939,
0.4574290812,
0.3511560857,
-0.5856025815,
0.0227576923,
0.0786457285,
0.1011117697,
0.2586567104,
-0.2077983171,
0.084575139,
-0.1340998262,
-0.9021636844,
0.3897144496,
0.2226202488,
0.2459642142,
-0.9199727178,
-0.0468082428,
0.0290673971,
0.2666611969,
0.661875546,
0.0071697049,
-0.6280078292,
-0.3787821233,
-0.2736087739,
-0.3616233766,
-0.5143280625,
0.4219864905,
-0.5824421048,
0.0645011663,
0.3339227736,
0.386918664,
0.0825727731,
-0.198519513,
0.4799666405,
-0.81081599,
0.3597684205,
0.1800447106,
0.3985919058,
0.4844333231,
-0.5183289051,
0.03895339,
0.1311251372,
-0.5857021213,
-0.9482955933,
0.2485169321,
-0.5854497552,
-0.3547289371,
1.6050320864,
0.0935476422,
-0.3167472184,
-0.2228304595,
-0.2867984772,
0.2818187475,
-0.1858033389,
0.953491509,
0.7833652496,
0.2087563723,
0.0406254493,
-0.7996976972,
0.4586490095,
-0.1933216602,
-0.8944582939,
0.0848557577,
0.6308605075,
0.6033748984,
0.5365634561,
0.2146030515,
-0.2419973612,
0.1287911087,
0.1524645537,
-0.0835794806,
-0.4481258392,
-0.4279869497,
-0.108527936,
0.1628107578,
0.276199162,
0.2402936667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08836v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08836v2
|
Evaluating Gender Bias in the Translation of Gender-Neutral Languages into English
| 2023-11-15T10:25:14 | 2023-12-13T04:15:26 |
Spencer Rarrick, Ranjita Naik, Sundar Poudel, Vishal Chowdhary
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Machine Translation (MT) continues to improve in quality and adoption, yet
the inadvertent perpetuation of gender bias remains a significant concern.
Despite numerous studies into gender bias in translations from gender-neutral
languages such as Turkish into more strongly gendered languages like English,
there are no benchmarks for evaluating this phenomenon or for assessing
mitigation strategies. To address this gap, we introduce GATE X-E, an extension
to the GATE (Rarrick et al., 2023) corpus, that consists of human translations
from Turkish, Hungarian, Finnish, and Persian into English. Each translation is
accompanied by feminine, masculine, and neutral variants for each possible
gender interpretation. The dataset, which contains between 1250 and 1850
instances for each of the four language pairs, features natural sentences with
a wide range of sentence lengths and domains, challenging translation rewriters
on various linguistic phenomena. Additionally, we present an English gender
rewriting solution built on GPT-3.5 Turbo and use GATE X-E to evaluate it. We
open source our contributions to encourage further research on gender
debiasing.
|
[
-0.2703388631,
-0.4166637361,
0.4631199837,
0.0850362107,
0.1365579069,
0.0350710861,
0.1124929339,
-0.3460174799,
-0.252135694,
0.4217660725,
-0.9276887178,
-0.4440341592,
-0.6925668716,
0.5471417308,
-0.594727397,
0.9875314832,
-0.3231564462,
0.4523884356,
0.2580535114,
0.0658894926,
-0.7788278461,
-0.2067930251,
-0.516896069,
-0.1263209134,
0.1841166317,
0.2228336781,
0.6543174386,
0.5671595931,
0.2314674556,
0.2381947786,
-0.0134135699,
-0.083213985,
-0.3105003834,
0.0770411119,
-0.4361299574,
-0.3912698925,
-0.6548811793,
0.3255028725,
0.8648925424,
0.8360372186,
0.0577497035,
0.3167853653,
0.1928258538,
0.7504251003,
-0.6195607185,
0.1118226647,
-0.6934297085,
0.1844488829,
-0.1400720626,
0.2896707952,
-0.2208875269,
-0.121060662,
0.1056374088,
-0.4693967998,
0.4362669885,
0.3870989978,
0.807076335,
0.0401631594,
-0.7186558843,
0.0141292978,
-0.7391424179,
1.1729090214,
-0.290230453,
0.9154040217,
0.4625984132,
0.2832044065,
-0.4055305421,
-0.1834891587,
-0.3654274344,
-0.2279750556,
0.0591232032,
-0.0381706059,
-0.6684023738,
-0.1548817158,
0.1346438378,
0.2603818774,
-0.5602263212,
-0.3159844875,
-0.3607798219,
-0.0435366519,
0.4894161224,
0.0130981477,
0.6731193066,
-0.0425848141,
-0.0904242918,
-0.1394735426,
-0.692707479,
-0.1842518002,
0.8754785657,
0.2439104915,
0.1716919988,
0.3803730607,
-0.123862423,
0.2433139384,
0.2364387959,
0.2975015342,
0.5857639909,
-0.2044482976,
-0.135902226,
0.0628546327,
0.6441190243,
0.6299033761,
-0.0526841469,
-0.1906074584,
-0.2198390514,
0.1677857786,
0.4234306216,
-0.5970748663,
0.46144557,
0.1156388223,
-0.4334569275,
-0.3409381807,
0.0463786572,
-0.7585427761,
-0.3651257157,
-0.0009220435,
0.2175260633,
-0.1542355269,
-0.4012300372,
0.3348769844,
-0.4616575241,
0.2963466346,
0.2731863856,
-0.7476276755,
0.3330123127,
0.7481693625,
0.4197321534,
0.0273831896,
-0.3412306905,
-0.4893785417,
0.0680030733,
-0.4772571325,
0.2720228434,
-0.4993009567,
-0.5322239399,
-0.0516139455,
0.410694927,
0.1553071141,
-0.3003959358,
1.1065512896,
-0.1443310082,
0.5024986863,
-0.5124416947,
-0.0793044791,
-0.2440472245,
0.2011418641,
-0.6606968641,
0.6239691973,
0.09011323,
-0.8642165065,
0.6243596673,
-0.4189166427,
-0.3570367396,
-0.3573943079,
-0.4845609665,
-0.5941943526,
0.3081674278,
0.3954731524,
-0.0716765448,
-0.5560168624,
0.3167225718,
-0.1444460452,
-0.2599899173,
-0.0118809603,
-0.5769287348,
0.7750378251,
0.1152801961,
-0.8188304901,
-0.0889880508,
-0.4322430491,
-0.3053656518,
0.0551273562,
0.3309667408,
-0.3378116786,
0.1503473669,
-0.1196317524,
0.3834255338,
-0.1090630218,
-0.8933360577,
-0.1023119688,
-0.3754295707,
0.3365898728,
0.7083296776,
-0.351380378,
0.6716837883,
-0.2806285024,
0.7527601123,
-0.0763908923,
0.159626022,
0.1309712976,
-0.6539546251,
-0.5629000068,
-0.1368893832,
0.1440179795,
0.5837735534,
-0.5500098467,
0.2692077756,
-0.3221540153,
-0.1106842905,
-0.9123643637,
0.1108545363,
0.6293876767,
0.5186389685,
0.3119184375,
-0.0579676852,
-0.4911334813,
-1.3586257696,
-0.7259681225,
-0.3132314682,
-0.0947599858,
0.1001677066,
0.6389425993,
-0.3815156221,
0.7564494014,
-0.1857880205,
-0.4272698462,
-0.2156740725,
0.2789983451,
0.1584797055,
0.5459077358,
0.4179268479,
-0.3842156827,
-0.1865484864,
0.174593851,
-0.5623134971,
-0.5700215101,
0.0015676725,
-0.5621555448,
0.3130233288,
0.3231476247,
-0.4128980637,
0.5044316649,
0.6825362444,
-0.7209308147,
0.4985626936,
0.1052852795,
0.7127049565,
-0.7234039903,
0.1109565943,
-0.0683827251,
-0.4984890521,
-0.4672917128,
0.1853011698,
0.0716188326,
0.0888737813,
-0.5408471823,
0.5722820759,
-0.7046355605,
0.0218665861,
-0.2750506997,
0.0864044726,
0.0927077532,
0.021771526,
-0.1521416157,
0.8281870484,
0.0901213959,
-0.0943598077,
-0.3153454065,
0.4791907668,
-0.0100903315,
0.6893650293,
-0.4690572917,
0.2574102283,
-0.4380884469,
0.2354240716,
-0.6867785454,
0.3665401042,
0.5970446467,
-0.5387086868,
0.3423427343,
-0.3272112608,
-0.0312739015,
-0.2980692387,
-0.8695040345,
0.412296623,
0.5449700356,
-0.2859714925,
0.3248741031,
0.3281461298,
-0.0306071006,
-0.9562442899,
-0.7199923992,
0.2746194303,
0.0017459063,
-0.5596788526,
0.2859297097,
0.2239660174,
-0.4023589492,
0.1330996007,
-0.231791541,
0.1947188526,
0.0871965438,
0.1206119508,
0.0635418296,
0.0641178191,
-0.1342107803,
0.6483780146,
-0.1786852777,
0.3304272592,
-0.5500531197,
0.3033641279,
-0.1623162031,
-0.3000213504,
-0.1495823115,
0.7507067919,
0.5035005212,
-0.1367943138,
0.6281182766,
0.6329394579,
-0.6052429676,
-0.2548320293,
-0.3998752534,
-0.1188934296,
-0.4011895061,
0.5438714623,
-0.6798394918,
-0.8889161348,
0.2959714234,
0.4458207786,
0.2863129675,
0.6989880204,
0.4149768651,
-0.0666354597,
1.5692082644,
0.5790315866,
-0.1619565636,
0.1397893429,
0.1416849494,
0.0684669316,
-0.807990551,
0.234835729,
-0.758808434,
-0.3711906672,
-0.9559474587,
-0.3744848967,
0.1200592741,
-0.1660412252,
-0.298324734,
0.3950720131,
-0.2860664427,
0.2985869944,
0.4226600826,
-0.0599689409,
0.4094223082,
0.1188676953,
0.072111994,
-0.4592351019,
-0.3392751515,
-0.7716465592,
1.1427592039,
0.6023696065,
0.5124852657,
0.2926537991,
0.4162080586,
0.7205697894,
0.2702830136,
-0.111719951,
0.4287114441,
-0.4314011633,
-1.009573698,
-0.0924504623,
-0.581769228,
-1.2797578573,
0.4319802821,
-0.2332329601,
-0.6093572974,
0.2351706922,
0.0525283627,
0.1697755754,
0.4697741866,
-0.5378382206,
0.9561319351,
-0.2083514333,
-0.6671754122,
-0.1961723864,
-0.3186898232,
0.7325744629,
-0.2189171761,
0.3129960895,
-0.1549526751,
-0.182599023,
0.5698839426,
-0.3769769967,
0.6098025441,
-0.0454278216,
-0.5442970991,
-0.1665710658,
0.2655135691,
0.1791600883,
-0.0011554423,
-0.0839159787,
0.6069641709,
0.0351922661,
-0.5568929315,
-0.4015269876,
0.628159523,
-1.0341709852,
-0.8725119829,
-0.5683501959,
-0.3951216042,
-0.1026658714,
0.221197173,
0.1656893194,
-0.0250129309,
-0.4898287952,
-0.3038061857,
0.3223867118,
-0.5782077312,
-0.0456419401,
0.412142396,
-0.7341666818,
-0.4511023462,
0.6626633406,
0.1020821333,
0.0511506498,
0.4010983407,
0.2065068781,
-0.3752427101,
-0.1853390336,
-1.0239938498,
0.2317347527,
-0.4452697337,
0.1235089153,
-0.848169148,
0.1489658505,
-0.5494191051,
-0.1590379477,
-0.3624244332,
-0.3865107894,
0.2127921879,
-0.1589178741,
-0.0017535936,
0.635707736,
0.2290748358,
0.2198409885,
-0.8097065091,
0.4000310302,
0.157654807,
0.1018293723,
-0.3828277588,
-0.7788054943,
0.1240636781,
0.0653564036,
-0.2644260824,
-1.2612698078,
0.4669867456,
-0.0897011682,
0.6200506687,
0.1810600609,
-0.1432100981,
0.2749870121,
-0.8182513118,
0.7184355259,
0.162967667,
-1.321572423,
0.5390616059,
-0.6367288232,
0.1031970158,
0.6399242282,
0.2749397755,
-0.661726594,
-0.5478942394,
-0.5185944438,
-0.8057585359,
0.5979702473,
0.6203616858,
0.2192731053,
-0.0874921381,
0.3089231849,
0.5427789688,
0.7268395424,
-0.5039445758,
-0.4049307406,
0.046330478,
-0.1559700072,
0.0461887829,
-0.1626027375,
0.1737036854,
-0.3075380623,
0.96765697,
0.1912846863,
0.4284681678,
0.2150268853,
-0.4674815238,
-0.1850869358,
0.5728188157,
0.5147712827,
0.3290556669,
-0.3217716217,
0.1825514883,
0.3579011559,
-0.7688714862,
0.5629102588,
0.0232348964,
-0.7696678638,
0.2452151626,
0.0332184285,
0.6512586474,
-0.374653697,
-0.3931654394,
0.5295808315,
-0.2649095654,
-0.329552263,
-0.1936656982,
-0.3836976588,
-0.3098735213,
-0.01682432,
0.1000869274,
-0.1791872531,
0.5382429361,
-0.472250253,
0.1560794711,
0.5089272261,
-0.8152695894,
-0.5265404582,
1.0330114365,
0.6313676834,
-0.0152446618,
0.5058651567,
-0.6920552254,
-0.7071581483,
0.2932132185,
0.4957315922,
1.725124836,
-0.407182008,
0.1601353884,
0.5121561885,
1.2129905224,
0.0200330615,
0.4411072433,
0.3729117811,
-0.6239806414,
-0.5034357309,
-0.2766827941,
-0.2220820338,
0.0501461849,
-0.3006876111,
0.5227053761,
-0.2194582522,
-0.3686339557,
-0.5012960434,
0.0421433225,
-0.6947337389,
-0.0754666328,
0.3727920353,
0.7706378102,
-1.0796291828,
0.4002563059,
0.8274263144,
-0.4005308151,
-0.209354803,
-0.1292553097,
0.2955316901,
-0.4995482266,
0.6355721354,
0.2384035438,
-0.6285939813,
-0.2227012217,
-0.0893922597,
-0.4559112191,
0.7685214877,
0.6708155274,
-0.8390852809,
0.356023699,
0.5391460657,
0.1630538553,
-0.1076463684,
0.7426018119,
0.7804598808,
0.6819871068,
-0.8878206015,
-0.9180684686,
0.1528351754,
-0.5311946869,
-0.0387580581,
0.4577826262,
-0.3748843372,
0.851319015,
0.289938122,
-0.2982343137,
-0.2781866789,
0.602022171,
-0.0858494416,
0.2909280658,
0.8871104717,
0.5653908849,
0.6895847321,
-0.1192259267,
0.8011532426,
-0.1907388568,
-0.0031677275,
0.9451494217,
-0.502704978,
0.4655624628,
0.5571207404,
-0.339482069,
0.4627999663,
0.0776060596,
0.3216354251,
0.0012673035,
0.477978766,
-0.2771745026,
-0.025735205,
-0.2925193906,
-0.4680171907,
0.3234489262,
0.0068550161,
-0.4865787923,
-0.3029771447,
-0.0355747379,
0.5597055554,
0.1649506092,
-0.2787355781,
0.2121077925,
0.0580417179,
-0.5416690707,
0.2808054388,
0.4464187622,
0.6450794339,
-0.4405768514,
-0.1555975229,
-0.4135512412,
0.1833655685,
-0.2261819839,
-0.5061923265,
0.2711509764,
0.3787225783,
-0.4390883446,
-0.5087172985,
0.6825274229,
-0.4792776704,
-0.8097239733,
0.3467398286,
0.9322481751,
0.1699994802,
-0.3366021216,
-0.7545404434,
-0.0395929068,
0.2879536152,
-0.0706650093,
0.2673719525,
0.1902750134,
-0.6954290867,
0.4747311771,
0.4988194406,
-0.0298006553,
0.1873903275,
0.1181995571,
0.4715287983,
-0.7735372782,
-0.3624136746,
-1.0107690096,
0.402528584,
-0.0306665953,
-0.30134058,
1.0340291262,
0.580657959,
0.9445692897,
-0.0310093202,
0.9352648854,
0.0742404908,
0.3796801567,
-0.0840855166,
0.8714571595,
-0.6027816534,
0.2125468254,
-0.6541744471,
-1.1193668842,
-0.193048805,
0.5345577002,
-0.3216785491,
0.0640238896,
0.7285645008,
0.8225399256,
-0.0479341,
0.053011667,
0.3783496916,
0.1033366919,
0.3095532954,
0.5433881283,
1.2305159569,
-0.8020369411,
0.5858667493,
0.0169458091,
-0.4021716714,
0.1907269508,
-1.1732057333,
-0.71237427,
-0.2018386126,
-0.5790173411,
-0.4383925498,
0.3577458858,
1.1536563635,
0.4338965416,
-0.6491142511,
-0.2868212759,
-0.1853085905,
0.270752281,
-0.3732529581,
-0.046709612,
0.0836454257,
-0.272197336,
-1.0983531475,
0.2085043937,
0.1031218842,
-0.4497973919,
-0.5020560622,
-0.1282464862,
0.0851155072,
0.0146337794,
0.4823979437,
-0.0420762151,
-0.4850776792,
-0.2754205465,
0.255456835,
-0.1094575375,
-0.2426026911,
0.6558015347,
-0.5463244915,
0.4203202128,
0.7329597473,
0.7098501325,
0.0875861496,
-0.2957600355,
1.1324367523,
-0.5709438324,
-0.1779773384,
-0.0725978911,
0.4192829728,
0.1869970709,
-0.101403378,
0.506770134,
0.357383579,
-0.419893086,
-0.8300376534,
0.2595025003,
-0.5830884576,
-0.195415318,
1.1892038584,
-0.0027785969,
-0.5023696423,
-0.3653123677,
-0.5322149396,
0.1724195033,
-0.5784059763,
0.513227582,
0.6894129515,
0.454549104,
-0.0710464939,
-1.0509772301,
0.2160084099,
0.8687096834,
-0.5563976765,
0.0814244077,
0.3981232345,
0.1384367943,
-0.1869644076,
0.4832854867,
-0.2907035649,
0.2566063404,
-0.0070254146,
0.6251154542,
0.2013927102,
0.0465882793,
-0.6304923892,
-0.3662649393,
0.1653542966,
-0.5187903643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08817v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08817v1
|
MAP's not dead yet: Uncovering true language model modes by conditioning away degeneracy
| 2023-11-15T09:38:53 | 2023-11-15T09:38:53 |
Davis Yoshida, Kartik Goyal, Kevin Gimpel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
It has been widely observed that exact or approximate MAP (mode-seeking)
decoding from natural language generation (NLG) models consistently leads to
degenerate outputs (Stahlberg and Byrne, 2019, Holtzman et al., 2019). This has
generally been attributed to either a fundamental inadequacy of modes in models
or weaknesses in language modeling. Contrastingly in this work, we emphasize
that degenerate modes can even occur in the absence of any model error, due to
contamination of the training data. Specifically, we show that mixing even a
tiny amount of low-entropy noise with a population text distribution can cause
the data distribution's mode to become degenerate, implying that any models
trained on it will be as well. As the unconditional mode of NLG models will
often be degenerate, we therefore propose to apply MAP decoding to the model's
distribution conditional on avoiding specific degeneracies. Using exact-search,
we empirically verify that the length-conditional modes of machine translation
models and language models are indeed more fluent and topical than their
unconditional modes. For the first time, we also share many examples of exact
modal sequences from these models, and from several variants of the LLaMA-7B
model. Notably, the modes of the LLaMA models are still degenerate, showing
that improvements in modeling have not fixed this issue. Because of the cost of
exact mode finding algorithms, we develop an approximate mode finding approach,
ACBS, which finds sequences that are both high-likelihood and high-quality. We
apply this approach to LLaMA-7B, a model which was not trained for instruction
following, and find that we are able to elicit reasonable outputs without any
finetuning.
|
[
-0.3084229529,
-1.0921999216,
0.8934989572,
0.0158978868,
-0.640647769,
0.0945732966,
-0.5210283995,
-0.3222310245,
0.1178963929,
0.54999125,
-0.5050289035,
-0.6816849113,
-0.8932665586,
0.2084001303,
-0.7036186457,
0.5041756034,
0.0531953424,
-0.1562700868,
-0.0360553078,
0.0428262129,
-0.3163672388,
-0.2605306804,
-0.6977741122,
-0.2838454247,
-0.0087841433,
0.2063519806,
0.7737941742,
0.8388230801,
0.4506739676,
0.2312483042,
-0.3311923146,
0.1496366262,
-0.7026910782,
0.4231496155,
0.5322065353,
-0.3992876709,
-0.4316860735,
0.0546709113,
0.6546630263,
0.5505476594,
-0.1794311851,
-0.1543001682,
-0.241257593,
0.6713783741,
-0.3822908998,
0.4967076778,
-0.8910743594,
-0.0000418678,
-0.1625671834,
-0.317932725,
-0.6462000012,
-0.1394341588,
0.0308194347,
-0.2994061708,
0.2846217155,
0.0214325879,
0.7929230332,
0.4720441699,
-0.6334958673,
-0.2721165121,
-0.7570628524,
0.8492348194,
-1.0303435326,
0.4078448415,
0.8411251903,
0.4985311031,
-0.4134126604,
-0.3349938691,
-0.6745282412,
-0.5360080004,
0.0808596388,
0.1454018801,
-0.2784492373,
0.2294679731,
0.173086971,
0.4178705513,
-0.3929876983,
0.0406200886,
-0.522601068,
0.0641835853,
0.5058500767,
0.0862314999,
0.4917400777,
-0.267450124,
-0.3568494022,
0.0699362531,
-0.8543757796,
-0.0499089919,
0.209393099,
0.22077097,
-0.5568383932,
0.427282989,
-0.1130049303,
1.058211565,
-0.0074983574,
-0.3432031274,
-0.0584255643,
-0.0957043096,
-0.3110970855,
0.1108625233,
0.7504531145,
0.4211255312,
0.0418309607,
-0.4282888174,
-0.5037164688,
0.1740761846,
0.2227135748,
-0.481618017,
-0.2928344309,
0.0522045083,
-0.5923247933,
-0.3450374305,
-0.271748513,
-0.6428326964,
-0.3837007284,
-0.2040566653,
0.3791901469,
-0.3370160162,
-0.4596610367,
0.0160100888,
0.0018290647,
0.1377121061,
0.193796888,
-0.6812320948,
0.0078658825,
0.5337789059,
0.8996626735,
-0.1475483477,
0.1784669757,
-0.2278015316,
-0.0293791667,
-0.4651271105,
0.714746356,
-0.8715746403,
-0.4516003132,
-0.0715278089,
0.0514789782,
-0.1657375693,
-0.5048438311,
0.4381787479,
-0.6887875795,
-0.0151069304,
-0.3736051619,
-0.3436939418,
-0.4542120099,
0.2075368464,
-0.7755906582,
0.7754160762,
0.0709085613,
-0.3149682879,
0.3349563181,
-0.4360826015,
-0.4610309899,
-0.3263070285,
-0.1749513298,
-0.38953197,
0.2736903429,
-0.0386834294,
0.1660104841,
-0.5586906672,
0.45309484,
-0.3608080447,
-0.4213013649,
0.0523902811,
-0.6144837141,
0.7043140531,
0.3561116755,
-0.6598313451,
-0.0667586774,
-0.7956310511,
-0.2962721288,
0.3275624216,
-0.2479969561,
-0.1893428266,
0.3454814255,
-0.0635971874,
0.276610136,
0.0438475311,
-0.5881730914,
0.3463964462,
-0.2595137656,
0.5446460843,
0.8045572639,
-0.0530226603,
0.653862536,
-0.5060382485,
0.7514291406,
0.1061802581,
0.2537560165,
-0.0464055203,
-0.7298508883,
-0.8818252087,
-0.2836290896,
0.103389293,
0.3910114765,
-0.5442508459,
0.472894311,
-0.2663721144,
-0.5726011395,
-0.5075342655,
0.0548183098,
0.2421057969,
0.5941560864,
0.4490342438,
-0.3123906851,
-0.6178689599,
-0.8540031314,
0.1961212307,
-0.2314565927,
0.2216324657,
-0.0338585638,
0.0165443569,
-0.4610694647,
0.7436660528,
-0.162158981,
-0.1628094614,
-0.6107814312,
-0.1307606697,
0.1237577498,
0.4051159322,
0.5774891376,
-0.6862729788,
-0.2172336131,
-0.2819103301,
-0.7620096803,
-0.1092739776,
-0.0593385287,
-0.0034987251,
0.3952692747,
0.5271648169,
-0.3762424886,
0.4545509517,
0.9105427861,
-0.2048306167,
-0.1794791818,
-0.0696960613,
0.1457809508,
-0.8254653811,
0.0299766473,
-0.2218919843,
-0.3983735442,
-0.5746793747,
0.0799664706,
0.0954995975,
-0.0684924573,
-0.0383987613,
0.4358341098,
-0.5731973052,
0.2347252667,
-0.6375889778,
0.1539927572,
0.0271720402,
0.2602702081,
0.0278776996,
0.4563278258,
0.6614695191,
-0.4244255126,
0.0366045646,
0.0687786117,
-0.314948529,
-0.0444308855,
-0.5330891609,
-0.0290049501,
-0.5514129996,
0.4720062912,
-0.966475606,
0.1011832133,
0.4414381683,
-0.1735296398,
0.5424678326,
-0.486313343,
-0.3715698421,
-0.0649329126,
-0.0195004214,
0.4393723905,
1.0264757872,
-0.2008091062,
0.4600512087,
0.4734552205,
0.179769516,
-0.2336598188,
-0.7638888359,
0.1469780803,
0.0002360901,
-0.4821607471,
0.0621794462,
-0.2170155197,
-0.3101853132,
-0.0888834298,
-0.4788065851,
-0.2641542554,
0.4165567756,
0.4460542202,
0.1414279789,
-0.2879103124,
-0.0698429644,
0.3611249626,
-0.0695999041,
-0.0526302308,
0.0410751551,
0.7281681299,
-0.0106056593,
-0.3056867421,
-0.1591068804,
0.2847263813,
0.7197265625,
-0.4667433202,
0.7942537069,
0.2475485802,
-0.4736481905,
-0.1206928492,
-0.5759038925,
-0.2221577615,
-0.4879695773,
-0.0339627564,
-0.2052651793,
-0.5671003461,
0.6469649076,
0.2411123365,
-0.0172076691,
0.4569095671,
0.4252837598,
0.2202333063,
1.0421733856,
0.9826141,
0.1768182665,
0.361312598,
-0.3961054385,
0.551299572,
-0.4925876856,
-0.3732416332,
-0.2201892138,
-0.3907429874,
-0.5529469848,
-0.484511286,
0.5340437889,
0.2188304961,
0.2548992336,
0.2383558005,
-0.3616244793,
0.3911630213,
0.3890184164,
0.3046701252,
0.4558362961,
-0.1449808031,
-0.0419458672,
0.2219079286,
-0.7227177024,
-0.5037415624,
1.1301805973,
0.1619588882,
0.8922988772,
0.1283391714,
0.8856809139,
0.2468444109,
0.4681765437,
-0.6661967039,
0.3973330855,
-0.0944381207,
-0.7399684191,
-0.1190041453,
-0.4413476586,
-0.9493386745,
-0.0272031575,
-0.2141331732,
-0.281308502,
0.2338071764,
0.3525807858,
-0.1733355373,
0.4749767482,
-0.4594239891,
0.8831846118,
-0.1421958506,
0.1519764811,
-0.0080561349,
-0.8401445746,
0.6058272719,
-0.1216142476,
0.3692741394,
-0.5234616399,
0.0655528381,
0.5468335748,
-0.0915942341,
0.7389461994,
-0.1018202081,
-0.2792036235,
0.3646193743,
0.4592228234,
0.3480396569,
0.0350277387,
-0.1494962275,
-0.0121943234,
-0.0257289894,
-0.6124635339,
-0.3603868484,
0.8309141397,
-0.5577002764,
-0.650223434,
-0.2418647408,
-0.5018366575,
-0.0516717657,
0.3109319508,
0.4680489004,
0.5609965324,
0.0478853285,
0.0624197759,
0.7371996641,
-0.0330434777,
0.5355837941,
0.5222087502,
-0.1354666054,
-0.0618843287,
0.8086408377,
0.0989838913,
0.4966816604,
0.2129817903,
0.1186842248,
-0.2238817215,
-0.5765721798,
-0.6067941785,
0.1580495685,
-0.7407341003,
-0.2992648482,
-0.8090327978,
-0.0280921422,
-0.4390865564,
-0.138839975,
-0.4802835286,
-0.2719090283,
-0.1574814171,
-0.0746924952,
0.4227572381,
0.8492648005,
-0.08902172,
0.362495333,
-0.9136599898,
0.4285464883,
0.0151900472,
0.0934570506,
0.0339283347,
-0.7828553319,
0.000057554,
0.3380940259,
-0.1912579536,
-1.206692934,
0.4882906079,
0.270590663,
0.6108374596,
0.4960890114,
0.2777565122,
0.4525275826,
-0.4211339653,
0.6388815045,
-0.1504972428,
-0.9405144453,
0.3461421132,
-0.3052156866,
0.2003841847,
0.5748963356,
0.3070937991,
-0.5564677119,
-0.76809901,
-0.6139398217,
-0.8811066151,
0.282399714,
0.061014194,
0.2157162279,
-0.3848724067,
0.3024989069,
0.2822067738,
0.2271485478,
-0.7321893573,
-0.3833783865,
-0.3118861914,
-0.1806983799,
-0.2581754327,
-0.3546167314,
-0.0776732862,
-0.1851146221,
0.4234058857,
0.0633656979,
0.3938291371,
0.1779313236,
-0.2898647189,
-0.4813639224,
0.2559202611,
0.8735567927,
0.8435444832,
-0.486774981,
0.4385440946,
-0.1713624895,
-0.1237491295,
0.3356831074,
0.0813209265,
-0.3882400692,
0.2125954777,
0.3872716427,
0.7441469431,
0.1891233623,
-0.8697369695,
0.6349691749,
0.0367000178,
0.2918692827,
-0.3875496387,
-0.0931415483,
-0.0388127342,
-0.0004154384,
0.392529577,
0.1230496094,
0.0717493668,
-0.5829563737,
0.1589041948,
0.6031243801,
-0.5521065593,
-0.449085176,
0.8603550792,
0.1101034656,
0.0518903174,
0.6529000401,
-0.3859810531,
-0.571586132,
0.6890926957,
0.7505863309,
0.9178425074,
0.0483602025,
0.06030678,
0.1351703852,
0.7493919134,
-0.2446159869,
0.2456548959,
-0.1182323545,
-0.374753207,
-0.5042901039,
-0.7308831811,
-0.0835817978,
0.0239526965,
-0.6302846074,
0.1793616861,
-0.4182224274,
-0.0743462443,
-0.5750072002,
-0.4466680884,
-0.4900825024,
0.2209017277,
0.2235506326,
0.9003797174,
-1.0513137579,
0.9757475853,
0.3345517218,
-0.3430136442,
-0.5298981071,
0.100151822,
-0.0372110792,
-0.970323801,
0.5289236307,
0.175455451,
0.1234383881,
0.1973636299,
-0.5919474363,
-0.7683696747,
0.827814281,
0.428365618,
-0.4424512982,
-0.1296412349,
-0.3194538057,
0.4123334587,
-0.0268587451,
-0.0295709055,
0.4395173192,
0.6685944796,
-0.0897199288,
-0.8247422576,
0.262590915,
-0.1120526195,
-0.2850225568,
0.4931578934,
-0.5464240313,
0.784106791,
-0.2614389062,
-0.5205709338,
0.1423606128,
0.4873510599,
-0.0040585184,
0.2173101604,
0.5529978871,
0.6639486551,
0.2631408572,
-0.0377491564,
1.1258591413,
-0.5051038265,
0.38166067,
0.5382407904,
0.0503112562,
0.7081723213,
0.4461831748,
0.0845813006,
0.3188348114,
0.6204954982,
0.1920149028,
0.6791466475,
0.1280215979,
-0.3460369706,
-0.7472307682,
0.0642592534,
-0.5669304132,
0.3809944689,
0.1204830781,
-0.5184077024,
-0.5291189551,
0.0686494336,
0.248934105,
0.2505741417,
0.2325579077,
0.4853187203,
0.1479070634,
-0.5122503638,
1.1100566387,
0.2319058776,
0.7392121553,
-0.6029231548,
-0.1353753209,
-0.667185843,
-0.3098285496,
0.0587886535,
-0.2124467343,
0.2880356312,
-0.2508119643,
-0.2850697041,
-0.27896896,
0.3083782196,
-0.738386035,
-0.4650504589,
0.2322024107,
0.385391593,
0.0080211172,
-0.0607404895,
-0.3237040043,
0.5011001229,
0.0405336581,
-0.1355498135,
0.142563045,
0.1718109846,
0.1222741008,
0.7842075825,
0.5107934475,
0.1013394967,
0.517504096,
-0.4085307419,
0.6939917803,
-0.6540530324,
-0.1079400554,
-0.8869799376,
0.2648256123,
0.2871177495,
-0.0391140468,
0.6322870851,
0.549279213,
0.5906413794,
-0.1784807742,
0.6260610819,
-0.1610594988,
0.0576070547,
-0.6384241581,
0.9190279841,
-0.6602557898,
0.3394727409,
0.0770147964,
-0.8210707307,
-0.2692415416,
0.5589231253,
-0.2997557819,
-0.1320171654,
0.5613716841,
0.8406083584,
-0.2797732651,
-0.2159504741,
0.4499399662,
0.2508989573,
0.5780214071,
0.5920466781,
0.6877297163,
-0.4549252987,
0.5135776997,
-0.4273337126,
-0.3656073809,
-0.2868746817,
-0.8606771827,
-0.7840729952,
-0.7275531888,
-0.1448857188,
-0.5005567074,
0.2075154334,
0.8633847237,
0.4638543725,
-0.5293654799,
-0.042724248,
-0.1893008202,
0.3319943249,
-0.015866464,
-0.1802710444,
0.1483290195,
-0.3228475153,
-0.6509252191,
0.8798056245,
0.3355570138,
0.3516659737,
-0.2531530559,
0.0817262158,
-0.1054363474,
0.0756278709,
0.4947097301,
0.3535773158,
-0.898891151,
-0.1918088794,
0.0990537331,
-0.3010686338,
0.0674937367,
0.7160812616,
-0.7385594845,
0.6462333202,
0.5779973269,
0.4882423282,
0.2498318702,
-0.3270089328,
0.6922108531,
-0.3032433093,
0.365750879,
0.1964775324,
0.2486542165,
0.248086527,
0.0033998517,
0.3303213418,
0.3117059469,
-0.4956820011,
-1.1106775999,
0.348148942,
-1.3625983,
-0.2656265497,
1.2496327162,
0.0232210942,
-0.3432564437,
-0.0777246207,
-0.0963934585,
0.4249415696,
-0.3443180621,
1.1226866245,
0.2872654796,
0.1291964203,
-0.1234048158,
-0.6787692308,
0.6224521399,
0.444096297,
-0.4364314973,
-0.0139433676,
0.6074095964,
0.2890024781,
-0.1278534383,
0.5124058127,
-0.1269678771,
0.1298988312,
-0.0808453187,
-0.1050622165,
-0.1568855196,
-0.2595481873,
-0.2098930776,
0.0052865078,
0.385820657,
-0.0379101671
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08803v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08803v3
|
StrategyLLM: Large Language Models as Strategy Generators, Executors, Optimizers, and Evaluators for Problem Solving
| 2023-11-15T09:18:09 | 2024-05-24T13:55:23 |
Chang Gao, Haiyun Jiang, Deng Cai, Shuming Shi, Wai Lam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Most existing prompting methods suffer from the issues of generalizability
and consistency, as they often rely on instance-specific solutions that may not
be applicable to other instances and lack task-level consistency across the
selected few-shot examples. To address these limitations, we propose a
comprehensive framework, StrategyLLM, allowing LLMs to perform inductive
reasoning, deriving general strategies from specific task instances, and
deductive reasoning, applying these general strategies to particular task
examples, for constructing generalizable and consistent few-shot prompts. It
employs four LLM-based agents: strategy generator, executor, optimizer, and
evaluator, working together to generate, evaluate, and select promising
strategies for a given task. Experimental results demonstrate that StrategyLLM
outperforms the competitive baseline CoT-SC that requires human-annotated
solutions on 13 datasets across 4 challenging tasks without human involvement,
including math reasoning (34.2\% $\rightarrow$ 38.8\%), commonsense reasoning
(70.3\% $\rightarrow$ 72.5\%), algorithmic reasoning (73.7\% $\rightarrow$
85.0\%), and symbolic reasoning (30.0\% $\rightarrow$ 79.2\%). Further analysis
reveals that StrategyLLM is applicable to various LLMs and demonstrates
advantages across numerous scenarios.
|
[
-0.2835819423,
-1.0504813194,
0.9538726807,
0.4107691944,
0.0478996523,
0.1841461509,
-0.5932709575,
0.2135146409,
-0.0742100105,
0.2926342487,
-0.8742221594,
-0.6627648473,
-0.3011547923,
0.3041591942,
-0.0313368328,
0.7389247417,
-0.0958992243,
-0.0206009354,
-0.2991225719,
0.0383996777,
-0.6621692181,
-0.2574732602,
-0.9708073139,
-0.5302630067,
0.4300257266,
0.7544223666,
0.606666863,
0.4084204137,
0.5443426967,
0.2788206041,
-0.0035427499,
0.3792526722,
-0.4817043245,
0.5575646162,
-0.2946536243,
-0.4699530005,
-0.0552674867,
-0.0821844563,
0.4682600796,
0.5815540552,
-0.3828492463,
0.0250140205,
0.0232006032,
0.454166472,
-0.6690987349,
0.1648011208,
-0.7921996713,
0.032877367,
0.1412303001,
-0.4251261055,
-0.5948812962,
-0.3664858341,
-0.0093411831,
-0.7497636676,
-0.0066976589,
0.1312953234,
0.4182676077,
0.4613728523,
-0.1617949754,
-0.5883972645,
-0.8902445436,
1.1354070902,
-0.6709880829,
-0.1578021497,
0.2054541856,
0.385638684,
-0.4514502585,
-0.5647486448,
-0.4056101739,
-0.3065835536,
-0.0083149513,
0.0889667049,
-0.2227827013,
0.1087869033,
0.5053195953,
-0.1717817038,
-0.6724597216,
0.331338495,
-0.076949358,
0.0399907194,
0.7425571084,
0.5301395655,
0.1861719191,
0.1901742965,
-0.4688098133,
0.046207808,
-0.9656121731,
0.0850749537,
0.1276950836,
0.4443505704,
0.06377808,
0.4602222145,
-0.1972928494,
0.7651439905,
0.051809866,
-0.2958119214,
-0.1986363232,
-0.4027425051,
-0.2344945967,
0.0850223303,
0.8003067374,
0.2446619719,
0.0854787156,
-0.0728196576,
-0.3018146157,
0.0981091186,
0.0565459803,
-0.713059783,
-0.0843393803,
0.3920749724,
-0.3827500045,
-0.1637541205,
-0.2613536119,
-0.7661578059,
-0.5123128891,
-0.3432589471,
0.5787254572,
-0.4335659146,
-0.1636122763,
0.2031483799,
-0.1401836276,
0.7071740627,
0.4232495129,
-0.9328153729,
0.2347178012,
0.8649301529,
0.9039795399,
-0.5649966598,
-0.1754778773,
-0.6446409225,
0.2205998898,
-0.5365025997,
0.8606132269,
-0.5885878205,
-0.6169183254,
0.1884230673,
-0.3548154831,
-0.170495227,
-0.7438753843,
0.691154778,
-0.2241399735,
0.298422277,
-0.4650291502,
-0.7948172092,
-0.0111667756,
0.5415255427,
-0.6423022151,
0.948292315,
-0.2201799154,
-0.2487898171,
0.2891736329,
-1.0648852587,
-0.4163742661,
0.3226857483,
-0.4469216764,
-0.1745439172,
-0.0131201819,
0.1780314445,
0.5880083442,
-0.7309154868,
0.282089293,
0.068650566,
-0.5023362041,
0.1924949288,
-0.3011373281,
0.9039455652,
0.4535369277,
-0.5843272209,
0.3973120749,
-0.5001514554,
0.2708436549,
0.4574288726,
-0.5075870156,
0.0616016798,
0.0500989035,
-0.2832953036,
0.1769211441,
0.2219312191,
-0.2692611217,
0.3966127634,
-0.1161097065,
0.6487766504,
0.7255039215,
0.0514983237,
0.4702416956,
-0.525190115,
0.881667316,
-0.1783537716,
-0.0606506318,
-0.3862863481,
-0.4674372375,
-0.8072238564,
-0.3756434321,
-0.1255227327,
0.788644135,
-0.7898049951,
0.2449299842,
0.0186080188,
-0.3315973282,
-0.2647403777,
0.3678295016,
0.3540041447,
0.4052459002,
0.4093941152,
0.3868581951,
-0.4990995526,
-0.8378348351,
-0.1611791253,
-0.103052631,
0.1752213538,
0.1462961435,
0.3400171101,
-0.0891009718,
1.1510685682,
-0.4417261183,
-0.1230808049,
-0.8473388553,
0.2927938402,
0.5049858689,
0.3714463711,
0.1733713299,
-0.6168844104,
-0.4877738953,
-0.2468320131,
-0.9971086383,
-0.1308885962,
-0.3996357322,
-0.1148367971,
0.3296767473,
0.6102608442,
-0.795296073,
0.176069662,
0.0915361121,
-0.1271956414,
0.6744829416,
-0.0959942639,
-0.0960381851,
-1.1089224815,
-0.0213572141,
0.0846960023,
-0.0665016025,
-0.8231014609,
0.1470053196,
-0.2293926775,
-0.233938098,
-0.4829610288,
0.7228286266,
-0.48757568,
0.2809187472,
-0.2594476342,
0.1268848777,
-0.1074783877,
0.3981714249,
0.0998224691,
0.8586546183,
0.5638906956,
-0.6893826723,
0.6619665027,
0.0408589877,
-0.2513758838,
0.6017290354,
-0.8774480224,
0.2566252351,
-0.1580383629,
0.1357941031,
-1.0698208809,
-0.0892043784,
0.1570804566,
-0.1501079798,
0.254303813,
0.0946209729,
-0.4976492524,
-0.4572965503,
-0.3735509813,
0.149972707,
0.6784974337,
-0.4232693911,
0.7349900603,
-0.1711719185,
-0.1395369172,
-0.6783001423,
-0.462064445,
0.1735705137,
-0.4897854626,
-0.6005354524,
0.2003077269,
-0.3927773833,
-0.594786942,
-0.0478670634,
0.141051352,
0.1568808556,
0.2458125502,
0.2027282715,
0.2990816236,
-0.1955305636,
0.2160597444,
-0.2229566723,
-0.2479003817,
0.1795418859,
-0.2177699953,
0.6931301355,
-0.1773782521,
-0.5320631862,
-0.1653412133,
0.640429318,
0.2356806397,
-0.1889803559,
0.5641899705,
0.4983148873,
-0.3553746641,
-0.697930038,
-0.7082972527,
-0.3921228349,
-0.5261954069,
0.2518241704,
-0.5469689369,
-0.928847909,
0.4432321787,
-0.2886019647,
0.3049448133,
0.1530064642,
0.9615477324,
0.0458513349,
1.0813690424,
0.3241855502,
-0.0381895527,
0.1350279152,
-0.4239309728,
0.3186879456,
-0.488278389,
-0.2740835547,
-0.418081224,
-0.4494159818,
-0.3704532683,
-0.4295929372,
0.3411307037,
0.0410062782,
-0.3142485917,
0.1608497649,
-0.5562462211,
0.7317367196,
0.8842335343,
-0.2572228014,
0.2456088811,
-0.1447650939,
-0.4447448254,
0.07151182,
-0.9682858586,
-0.6611852646,
0.997543335,
0.1400030702,
1.0248224735,
0.3065460324,
1.1347278357,
0.2258413583,
0.0470753945,
-1.0579820871,
0.9322654605,
0.3150900304,
-0.6891340017,
-0.4788202941,
-0.3813015223,
-1.1263264418,
0.0497251265,
-0.224013865,
-0.6697773337,
-0.098389551,
-0.0019217384,
-0.6412157416,
0.1871293336,
-0.608615756,
0.8514131308,
-0.2700474262,
-0.5111477375,
-0.1493304521,
-0.4296820462,
0.3011226058,
0.0782850981,
0.0070979497,
-0.267822206,
-0.2178460062,
0.5280262828,
-0.236655131,
0.7320964336,
-0.2058518976,
-0.1677580327,
0.63919276,
0.1932431161,
0.6607976556,
-0.1539924592,
-0.1150345653,
-0.3884031177,
-0.1704696119,
-0.3084113896,
-0.8497522473,
0.7357311249,
-0.4605205059,
-1.0630275011,
-0.3315351605,
-0.7520960569,
-0.2766113281,
0.1017440632,
0.3266204596,
0.3087743521,
-0.2925364375,
0.3230377436,
0.8394507766,
-0.1271616817,
0.8249545693,
0.5103241205,
-0.0188113134,
-0.0554174259,
0.8208627701,
-0.2270644903,
0.2168071121,
0.3796624541,
0.4034956992,
-0.4540914893,
-0.5827538967,
-0.3511533737,
0.0615144894,
-0.9124111533,
-0.3948489726,
-0.3760256469,
-0.2609059811,
-0.0721918717,
-0.4184694588,
-0.0014681551,
-0.2071152031,
-0.3057958484,
-0.0717227533,
0.2642278671,
0.6888361573,
-0.0368511565,
0.1256437004,
-0.4204136431,
0.1447488219,
0.6157757044,
-0.1407547891,
-0.0727802441,
-0.2703428864,
0.0329290889,
-0.1868357062,
-0.4079605043,
-0.9178166986,
0.2047132552,
0.1667618006,
0.8779345751,
0.3432638645,
0.0877431631,
0.2973286211,
-0.5052336454,
0.863363564,
0.4087482393,
-0.8370293379,
0.8059999347,
-0.378901571,
0.382891804,
0.6182202697,
0.5158600807,
-0.4409730732,
-0.1557991803,
-0.2779552937,
-0.6519975066,
0.6164708138,
0.0469711497,
0.0554539301,
-0.2422593236,
0.2482653707,
-0.0849388093,
0.0330594629,
-0.4803801775,
-0.2703277767,
0.088451162,
-0.4342377782,
0.1038476676,
-0.1838931292,
-0.4402140379,
-0.010308519,
0.6444281936,
-0.3990471959,
0.2554665208,
0.0200409964,
-0.0307925399,
-0.0797132328,
0.6376678944,
0.7892559767,
0.8794729114,
-0.0457115658,
0.1038572788,
0.260250181,
-0.017437743,
0.6893802285,
0.1562602073,
-0.3815852404,
-0.1589870155,
0.4250122905,
0.6212354302,
0.1423894316,
-0.9315622449,
0.3977364302,
0.0673018917,
-0.4517377615,
-0.2094205618,
0.3898281157,
0.2899304628,
0.4719538689,
0.6912811399,
-0.5094214678,
0.0928959548,
-0.5934383273,
-0.0075084795,
0.8561570644,
-0.1367357969,
0.0960878581,
0.5249270797,
0.2371487767,
-0.4211451709,
0.3196262121,
-0.606595993,
-0.4282979071,
0.7174757123,
0.781368196,
0.9707014561,
-0.1898399889,
0.4658011794,
0.4216876626,
0.2944157124,
-0.2924257815,
0.4656934738,
0.0912305862,
-0.7775655389,
-0.5943514705,
-0.4237557948,
-0.6159824133,
0.2170499563,
-0.377325654,
0.2426192164,
-0.7572668195,
-0.1328044832,
-0.0782863349,
0.2059355676,
-0.7191832662,
-0.1680919975,
0.1491835564,
0.9371318817,
-0.4223496318,
0.5227550268,
0.9273989797,
-0.3657591939,
-0.9659314752,
-0.3117489219,
0.30431512,
-0.9792256355,
0.7947776914,
0.1415815651,
-0.2512345612,
0.0354072079,
-0.7367864847,
-0.7016150355,
1.3038100004,
0.2934041321,
-0.6414891481,
-0.0305785928,
0.1598025262,
0.1781871468,
-0.678584516,
0.0923644826,
0.6979107261,
0.6268881559,
0.3601646423,
-0.6375479102,
0.2854445577,
-0.0318958983,
0.0133524276,
0.1079431549,
-0.5265401602,
0.8190131187,
-0.516177237,
-0.2356296629,
0.2987355292,
0.3948692977,
0.7306335568,
0.3692284524,
0.270080626,
0.62554878,
0.7804965973,
-0.2088706642,
0.8333053589,
-0.2301250547,
0.2162633389,
1.165792942,
-0.5565072298,
0.6067010164,
0.2655760646,
-0.0946291089,
0.5617018342,
0.4015577435,
0.0027424488,
0.4007967114,
0.4876635373,
-0.5162183046,
-0.4740369916,
-0.2060761154,
-0.1372020096,
0.5673318505,
0.3831762969,
-0.2597221136,
-0.3964443803,
-0.0676643252,
0.2688904405,
0.2559091151,
-0.4050992727,
0.9003414512,
0.1497804224,
-0.8830951452,
0.6162871122,
0.0701182485,
0.7126049399,
-0.7600029111,
-0.1209809184,
-0.2360053062,
0.1858454049,
-0.047145132,
-0.7407611012,
-0.118579343,
-0.0976383984,
-0.1082570851,
-0.284740448,
0.9004808664,
-0.504604578,
-0.484898895,
0.0299477875,
0.893682003,
-0.1385225654,
0.0884374678,
-0.9301180243,
0.1611975729,
-0.1467336416,
-0.101387471,
0.1113462597,
0.4590568542,
0.0178274792,
0.9012125134,
0.5477713943,
-0.0589227192,
-0.1081110612,
0.1242843419,
0.7615080476,
-0.7871564031,
-0.3124189377,
-1.2182623148,
0.2619308829,
-0.1699851006,
-0.1818310022,
0.9592861533,
0.4323925376,
0.3523692489,
0.07410869,
0.8018388152,
0.1948898137,
0.3213550448,
-0.7521525621,
0.2434552759,
-0.2448310405,
0.1986504495,
0.0068899216,
-1.1451920271,
-0.281871289,
0.7453165054,
-0.3131258786,
0.1445563585,
0.6944825649,
0.8316328526,
0.2989643216,
-0.0450156517,
0.35227561,
-0.0958980396,
0.4926039279,
1.0225592852,
1.1555136442,
0.2660406828,
0.5700917244,
0.0961806774,
-0.1692856848,
-0.3205526471,
-1.1311657429,
-1.1981729269,
-0.3290894926,
-0.2873387039,
-0.2453929782,
0.0123033402,
1.3774236441,
0.6882443428,
-0.7516221404,
-0.4312954247,
-0.1839074939,
0.3405902386,
-0.2090385854,
-0.2767722905,
0.1568920612,
-0.8790214658,
-0.5060812831,
0.6063888669,
0.3586259484,
-0.1152035967,
-0.5896549225,
-0.337092638,
-0.2125583291,
0.3652845919,
0.6647369862,
0.4848765731,
-0.8875402808,
0.0113115432,
0.1736649126,
-0.0951663852,
-0.0562223867,
1.1016858816,
-0.6844382286,
0.3141248226,
0.3481971025,
0.9090381265,
0.2759889066,
-0.0095400279,
0.500592649,
-0.6907567382,
0.1183030754,
0.5100152493,
0.3469205201,
0.3618066907,
-0.2603488564,
0.6419706941,
0.0495568104,
-0.5644869208,
-0.6010183692,
0.417195648,
-0.8100060225,
-0.5071894526,
1.5884094238,
-0.0688886419,
-0.1179899052,
0.0163542349,
-0.2351519018,
-0.2460038662,
-0.6531482935,
0.4478350878,
0.8324015141,
-0.3400938213,
-0.2722294629,
-0.4636898339,
0.7394190431,
0.6096448898,
-1.0765732527,
-0.1445717067,
0.6170917749,
0.1096293703,
0.3020476997,
0.7660612464,
0.3094082177,
0.1921580434,
-0.2430729121,
-0.3388471305,
-0.241029501,
-0.4189206958,
-0.2720767856,
0.1760139018,
0.2248858064,
-0.0462076217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08793v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08793v1
|
German FinBERT: A German Pre-trained Language Model
| 2023-11-15T09:07:29 | 2023-11-15T09:07:29 |
Moritz Scherrmann
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, stat.ML
|
This study presents German FinBERT, a novel pre-trained German language model
tailored for financial textual data. The model is trained through a
comprehensive pre-training process, leveraging a substantial corpus comprising
financial reports, ad-hoc announcements and news related to German companies.
The corpus size is comparable to the data sets commonly used for training
standard BERT models. I evaluate the performance of German FinBERT on
downstream tasks, specifically sentiment prediction, topic recognition and
question answering against generic German language models. My results
demonstrate improved performance on finance-specific data, indicating the
efficacy of German FinBERT in capturing domain-specific nuances. The presented
findings suggest that German FinBERT holds promise as a valuable tool for
financial text analysis, potentially benefiting various applications in the
financial domain.
|
[
-0.4606591165,
-0.7550805807,
0.2897488773,
0.2129095197,
-0.1987996846,
0.1904581338,
-0.3226305544,
-0.5161373615,
0.1379374564,
0.6677247286,
-0.4907926619,
-0.7968226075,
-0.5818027854,
-0.2283201069,
-0.6162052751,
1.5917901993,
-0.0067716716,
0.4537921548,
-0.1682700217,
0.1420593113,
0.0450881422,
-0.9116922617,
-0.8847327232,
-0.4417898357,
0.6772976518,
0.2548026145,
0.5401873589,
0.1129260808,
0.7289002538,
0.2699679136,
0.2831758261,
-0.4922533035,
-0.437851131,
-0.2358898222,
-0.0108407279,
-0.3895177245,
-0.5943758488,
0.3593954146,
0.4401397705,
0.9282507896,
-0.0611623339,
0.3914038837,
-0.1048805192,
0.9231615067,
-0.5529910922,
0.3863470256,
-0.3701549768,
-0.0313086733,
-0.2776899338,
-0.0437059477,
-0.6218978763,
-0.3628513515,
0.7787026763,
-0.3349128067,
0.4531838894,
-0.0343151204,
1.0287101269,
0.149784863,
-0.4308155477,
-0.4237965941,
-0.6674352884,
0.5591562986,
-0.6063446403,
0.6423547864,
0.4921532273,
0.3528061807,
0.2153130919,
-1.2374697924,
-0.1753390878,
-0.3499976397,
-0.3850137293,
0.1389808655,
-0.4642270207,
0.0974308178,
-0.2544020116,
0.1860256642,
-0.5974147916,
-0.0453473963,
-0.626747489,
-0.2685541511,
0.6778553724,
-0.2935717106,
-0.1420823932,
0.2658060789,
-0.5212202668,
-0.4597046673,
-0.4410921931,
0.3985511661,
0.7745166421,
0.4665623009,
-0.0266737361,
-0.0053370143,
0.0334959216,
0.9786778688,
-0.0554390885,
0.0840643793,
0.3887898922,
0.15668042,
-0.2819490731,
0.5662967563,
0.4528263509,
-0.0276913121,
0.7483279705,
-0.1732620895,
-0.5647509694,
-0.2232836932,
0.4792304039,
-0.6137105823,
-0.7090246081,
0.3096383214,
-0.5726034641,
-0.4222698808,
0.2930567563,
-0.4026678503,
0.0798279718,
-0.2151057273,
0.2533349097,
-0.3707396388,
-0.1519752592,
0.4589693844,
-0.4092203975,
0.2873310447,
0.1699570864,
-1.1031955481,
0.3795878291,
0.5995025635,
0.4557802081,
0.0850740671,
-0.2679406703,
-0.7251060009,
0.0043199528,
-0.4413490891,
0.9783662558,
-0.4295008183,
-0.3677701056,
0.1775421053,
-0.0584216565,
-0.1061252803,
-0.2499676049,
0.4979062378,
-0.8836249113,
0.3468843102,
0.1294745505,
-0.6202040315,
-0.3535889685,
-0.1421371847,
-0.7990967035,
0.5961219668,
0.4340666831,
-1.1087162495,
0.505224824,
-0.9700151682,
-0.6406941414,
0.0324522778,
0.0453918912,
-0.3238206804,
-0.0966682658,
0.119315356,
0.6642517447,
-0.2306343615,
0.3736796677,
-0.3023400307,
-0.4638875127,
0.5271394253,
-0.270956099,
0.417134285,
0.108758688,
-0.0474177711,
0.2753373682,
-0.8314419389,
-0.1317816973,
0.1596663147,
-0.0226536449,
-0.5726771951,
-0.1508716643,
0.6064887047,
-0.053939607,
0.6588121653,
-0.4428657591,
-0.2176150084,
-0.585947156,
0.2495534569,
0.7266514897,
-0.2940087914,
0.6116377711,
-0.1985463947,
0.5700139403,
-0.2665548921,
0.0633488595,
-0.1235898137,
0.0788627267,
-0.6573187113,
-0.433734715,
0.8327285647,
0.8081462979,
-0.332154274,
0.472161442,
-0.1644185483,
-0.7688957453,
-0.3780268729,
0.1002549008,
0.2213153094,
0.5748775005,
0.0752360597,
-0.1196644306,
-0.4562037289,
-1.2682263851,
-0.054001227,
-0.3369141221,
-0.1316118091,
-0.0173054021,
0.4657159746,
-0.1293609589,
0.9507957101,
-0.7412239909,
-0.104972519,
-0.5239354372,
0.6151606441,
0.3853216469,
0.4013067484,
1.091083169,
-1.1215902567,
-0.2161046714,
-0.026385976,
-0.4827937782,
0.029640764,
-0.1092085987,
-0.0708123371,
0.190165922,
0.6084013581,
-0.0441697948,
0.1244734302,
0.6869562268,
-0.5891321301,
0.3570080996,
-0.2842843533,
-0.084912926,
-0.8253203034,
0.3985047936,
0.1352084726,
-0.393484652,
-0.8542146683,
-0.4638546407,
0.1197200343,
-0.0105797788,
-0.3966314495,
0.6362602711,
0.1511755139,
-0.1048084944,
-0.3713774979,
0.1219637766,
-0.1179509908,
0.4356801212,
0.4011203945,
0.8527008295,
0.4295792282,
-0.4584394693,
0.1938687563,
0.2818017006,
-0.3365758955,
0.2992561162,
-0.7231816649,
-0.1658395678,
-0.3374079466,
0.0795556754,
-1.1953074932,
-0.1627616882,
-0.1323363036,
-0.5602498055,
0.4457909465,
0.1664714813,
-0.3383776248,
-0.3187127411,
-0.158417359,
0.0246920437,
0.3491848707,
-0.3458988965,
0.6381295323,
0.3122107387,
-0.7917894125,
-0.642079711,
-0.5937162638,
-0.304651022,
-0.3159237504,
-0.7440857291,
0.3667053878,
0.2304459065,
-0.2555702031,
-0.0274107885,
-0.088587448,
-0.351287365,
0.3624239266,
-0.0367773362,
0.8528228998,
-0.262529999,
0.4185378253,
-0.087814182,
-0.4214618206,
0.0209972039,
-0.3615060151,
0.6785622835,
-0.6923086047,
0.0705853552,
-0.108611621,
0.1798953712,
0.3221352994,
-0.4252277017,
0.7292297482,
0.7725830078,
-0.1708451658,
0.0281555597,
-0.4359716475,
-0.1280839294,
-0.5317062736,
0.3208400905,
-0.1899600774,
-1.1197357178,
0.5370090008,
-0.1962262392,
0.1161617115,
0.5818123817,
0.3025571108,
-0.3107925951,
0.5847680569,
1.1370439529,
-0.2638139427,
0.6728905439,
-0.2018996477,
0.2122763246,
0.1083801314,
-0.0420302637,
-0.5201007128,
-0.1272112876,
-0.259539932,
0.2947291136,
0.0239869971,
0.2698003352,
-0.4919563234,
0.4593764544,
-0.1453261524,
0.1547114849,
0.7479549646,
-0.439894855,
-0.0234507639,
0.0082037337,
-0.0914088562,
0.0060704588,
-0.5604189038,
-0.8183913827,
1.1191487312,
0.4684629738,
0.6619318724,
-0.444252193,
0.6782138944,
0.666020155,
0.5449129939,
-0.4423711896,
0.149691239,
-0.441202879,
-0.724516511,
-0.3958007097,
-0.4008790553,
-0.8461066484,
-0.1512270719,
-0.237579897,
-0.790499568,
-0.1504101753,
0.0595897473,
-0.5766090155,
0.0361573771,
-0.778493464,
1.1984033585,
-0.5558641553,
0.2505137026,
-0.1626893431,
-0.6080281138,
0.2628116906,
-0.8336994052,
0.3012312353,
-0.1484101862,
0.1236435995,
1.0838937759,
-0.1065987945,
0.7208156586,
-0.2111537904,
-0.3483534753,
0.1422285587,
-0.3123611212,
0.4408996701,
0.0878146291,
0.0879495293,
0.237161845,
0.3557312787,
-0.5484875441,
-0.6108638644,
0.3009366393,
-0.7583861947,
-0.4473696351,
-0.4148828089,
-0.4401471317,
-0.5082589388,
0.0411451496,
0.2105560303,
0.1642940044,
-0.6073847413,
0.1618658453,
0.3665350378,
-0.3615346849,
0.5401369333,
0.8081792593,
-0.4373847246,
-0.5329329967,
0.7185654044,
-0.0769878998,
0.0826908052,
0.3960142136,
-0.1448475868,
-0.3740605414,
-0.1782840192,
-0.2566010356,
0.1086002514,
-0.7634786367,
-0.0186161194,
-0.6872512102,
-0.5565860271,
-0.4414455891,
-0.7275779247,
-0.6342040896,
-0.5028153658,
-0.0727479905,
-0.5020112395,
0.5437442064,
0.6847794056,
-0.1237919331,
0.6879573464,
-1.0589702129,
-0.0815743804,
0.1679165214,
0.4146374166,
-0.1578654051,
-0.2894064188,
-0.5290079713,
-0.1971864402,
0.1304647923,
-0.463259995,
0.4299035966,
0.0161502194,
0.5870866776,
0.6938987374,
0.2105967104,
0.1992358267,
-0.2256562859,
0.5315163136,
0.2794259489,
-0.9744697213,
0.6304620504,
-0.3161913455,
0.1918427944,
0.7803017497,
0.7125074267,
-0.464589268,
-0.4591038227,
-0.7855198979,
-1.0070148706,
0.6791659594,
0.1879961938,
0.2509247661,
0.238422066,
0.2175919414,
0.4716278315,
0.5982379913,
-0.6073704958,
-0.2970044613,
-0.1534049064,
-0.2562830746,
-0.4941011369,
-0.201152429,
0.0161137376,
-0.3810098767,
0.5812211633,
0.0203913674,
0.2358199358,
0.0129989814,
0.041780483,
0.2013569176,
0.0872462466,
0.4603925049,
0.6885425448,
-0.5357385874,
-0.052627828,
0.205206722,
-0.5104234815,
0.0562041104,
0.6936572194,
0.1168555319,
0.2545456588,
0.6885244846,
0.8420725465,
0.4675910771,
-1.0576890707,
0.5930845141,
-0.1247078553,
-0.5686298013,
-0.8107721806,
-0.0051688259,
0.1354668587,
0.5528499484,
0.6508613229,
0.0135332216,
0.0757622123,
-0.3180252016,
0.6976169348,
0.1016260758,
-0.6935399771,
-0.1348255128,
0.7591827512,
0.0261001121,
0.0571560301,
0.6772065759,
0.1425662041,
-0.5926573277,
0.4385286272,
0.3370818198,
0.7894185781,
-0.0240708925,
0.5362280607,
0.000664334,
0.0877011195,
-0.0438913256,
0.3724946678,
-0.1197687089,
-0.7973697186,
-0.3315387964,
-0.8305767179,
-0.2613805234,
0.0196253676,
-0.8017526865,
0.2510324419,
-0.5165467858,
-0.5733751655,
0.2613485754,
-0.0328560062,
-0.6511611342,
0.2938314676,
0.2977834642,
1.1742748022,
-0.7600415945,
1.107032299,
0.6802540421,
-0.502697885,
-0.4994791746,
-0.0876035094,
-0.3334249258,
-0.7048794031,
1.1540727615,
0.0829810947,
-0.2896336615,
0.070534043,
-0.6182665229,
-0.8967195749,
0.8210734129,
0.5129497647,
-0.3574105799,
-0.1410693079,
0.0982438847,
0.534127593,
-0.6112449169,
-0.2606176734,
0.7002971768,
0.4859401882,
0.0883919969,
-0.7272311449,
-0.5417668819,
-0.4178242981,
-0.2683585286,
0.2629242241,
-0.5355213284,
0.9828567505,
0.0999398082,
0.0044726715,
-0.2293381244,
0.880589664,
0.0441005677,
0.3991833329,
0.5448668599,
0.1571637988,
1.032304883,
-0.1369387358,
0.9864577055,
-0.8875801563,
0.2876857519,
1.0665996075,
-0.4018535316,
1.064175725,
0.2249656767,
-0.0098754745,
0.62825948,
0.8356782794,
-0.2415647805,
0.7849193811,
0.2268974632,
-0.2947396338,
-0.3909460008,
0.1695737243,
-0.3185736835,
0.7018924356,
0.1852229983,
-0.5394144654,
-0.1750563383,
0.3723393679,
0.0922325104,
-0.0376242884,
-0.3100160956,
0.5315968394,
0.1216279194,
-0.3793777525,
0.3244409561,
0.144427374,
0.600135684,
-1.0620776415,
0.2867538929,
-0.000527807,
0.3732533157,
0.2162282318,
-0.4910179377,
0.3973006308,
0.1617023349,
-0.0932051688,
-0.4830753803,
0.9246688485,
-0.2106837928,
-0.6656522751,
0.5296311975,
0.6259735227,
0.1205148846,
-0.1413278729,
-0.4262576699,
-0.5299306512,
-0.0750761181,
-0.3681863546,
0.2439050078,
0.346434027,
0.2012833804,
0.6072241664,
0.7083420157,
-0.2111091167,
-0.4634079933,
0.0253809616,
0.77885288,
-0.9060536623,
-0.642899096,
-0.7460900545,
0.3015222251,
-0.1321174353,
-0.3106595278,
0.5707356334,
0.744209826,
1.0807757378,
-0.396956563,
0.9648402333,
0.3850081861,
0.3619428575,
-0.4682718217,
1.0692005157,
-0.3764756918,
-0.1211984903,
-0.3908147812,
-0.6383715868,
-0.2120365053,
0.7627990246,
-0.7268381715,
-0.0475253128,
0.5572126508,
0.2442745566,
0.1065008789,
0.572724402,
0.3565435708,
-0.3297018111,
-0.1583609134,
0.2946144938,
0.5770232677,
-0.1329995245,
0.6048187613,
-0.0462880842,
-0.0317823961,
-0.2269067019,
-0.5153875947,
-1.1447008848,
-0.7361976504,
-0.1063009277,
-0.0851992667,
0.0207264479,
0.8540554643,
0.5331234932,
-0.8003653884,
-0.4494799972,
0.135349825,
-0.3850704432,
0.0468575507,
-0.1664120406,
0.5137468576,
-0.6786157489,
-0.5621910691,
0.1612154543,
0.3001908958,
0.540076673,
-0.2020930797,
0.0073489179,
-0.1125012115,
0.2719345391,
0.5834237933,
0.1013890728,
-0.0965484008,
-0.1752764881,
0.0924548507,
-0.1818094105,
-0.1176475286,
1.0495181084,
-0.586250484,
-0.0004662836,
0.2134906799,
0.6909419894,
0.7583538294,
-0.0803748667,
1.1978284121,
-0.6611084342,
0.6258391738,
0.1428022236,
0.5012452602,
0.1632690132,
-0.3048489094,
0.6216233969,
-0.1909126341,
-0.1975307167,
-0.3215459883,
-0.1223712564,
-0.7117361426,
-0.6721314788,
0.6704538465,
-0.3436458409,
-0.2600925267,
0.0387764424,
-0.2612653971,
0.2277576774,
-0.4284276366,
0.4407624304,
1.1458067894,
0.1376891732,
0.0233311243,
-0.8289482594,
0.6270312667,
0.2345628589,
-0.488954097,
0.0831622928,
0.2215099633,
-0.0108816223,
0.1095259935,
0.7160066962,
0.0686906651,
0.3318583667,
0.1630667448,
0.1604354382,
0.1478531808,
-0.3447137475,
-0.0606392436,
0.352227062,
0.0174504016,
0.0236789193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08788v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08788v2
|
X-Eval: Generalizable Multi-aspect Text Evaluation via Augmented Instruction Tuning with Auxiliary Evaluation Aspects
| 2023-11-15T09:01:55 | 2024-04-13T14:41:24 |
Minqian Liu, Ying Shen, Zhiyang Xu, Yixin Cao, Eunah Cho, Vaibhav Kumar, Reza Ghanadan, Lifu Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Natural Language Generation (NLG) typically involves evaluating the generated
text in various aspects (e.g., consistency and naturalness) to obtain a
comprehensive assessment. However, multi-aspect evaluation remains challenging
as it may require the evaluator to generalize to any given evaluation aspect
even if it's absent during training. In this paper, we introduce X-Eval, a
two-stage instruction tuning framework to evaluate the text in both seen and
unseen aspects customized by end users. X-Eval consists of two learning stages:
the vanilla instruction tuning stage that improves the model's ability to
follow evaluation instructions, and an enhanced instruction tuning stage that
exploits the connections between fine-grained evaluation aspects to better
assess text quality. To support the training of X-Eval, we collect
AspectInstruct, the first instruction tuning dataset tailored for multi-aspect
NLG evaluation spanning 27 diverse evaluation aspects with 65 tasks. To enhance
task diversity, we devise an augmentation strategy that converts human rating
annotations into diverse forms of NLG evaluation tasks, including scoring,
comparison, ranking, and Boolean question answering. Extensive experiments
across three essential categories of NLG tasks: dialogue generation,
summarization, and data-to-text coupled with 21 aspects in meta-evaluation,
demonstrate that our X-Eval enables even a lightweight language model to
achieve a comparable if not higher correlation with human judgments compared to
the state-of-the-art NLG evaluators, such as GPT-4.
|
[
-0.5071953535,
-0.9401781559,
0.4047092199,
0.0870228335,
-0.3805744052,
0.3445926607,
-0.4326674342,
-0.4305815697,
-0.0121480636,
0.5654229522,
-0.7225930691,
-0.7829553485,
-0.3215917349,
0.1643173993,
-0.3754969537,
1.5041778088,
0.0918495432,
-0.1524694115,
-0.197158128,
-0.0991246551,
-0.3758597076,
-0.31956774,
-0.7985613346,
-0.2578257024,
0.1993186176,
0.3656023443,
0.612801075,
0.6262232661,
0.2538663745,
0.3365020156,
-0.0039276704,
0.3742212057,
-0.2125647962,
0.1353048533,
-0.2202752829,
-0.4593952596,
-0.6462891102,
0.0137156602,
0.6269908547,
0.4489742517,
-0.06320104,
0.2621330619,
0.3648498356,
0.7449941039,
-0.5305892825,
0.0731728747,
-0.5547302365,
-0.0411244966,
0.1449339539,
-0.3150911629,
-0.2876318097,
-0.3016445935,
0.2780508697,
-0.5283587575,
0.432208091,
0.2989476323,
0.6532961726,
0.1053610817,
-0.2784295082,
-0.3655833304,
-0.4645806551,
0.9066648483,
-0.6892161369,
0.3918537498,
0.4917427897,
0.0638863817,
0.2266550064,
-0.5502829552,
-0.5457293987,
-0.4925322831,
-0.0957151949,
0.177083686,
-0.0370332822,
0.3685050607,
-0.0404091179,
0.7617636323,
-0.5881759524,
0.0653976426,
-0.0104391119,
-0.0410756208,
0.5662556887,
0.2110368013,
0.2769378722,
-0.4551701248,
-0.2618535757,
-0.2664584517,
-0.3636151552,
0.256238699,
0.6883469224,
0.2963487208,
-0.0358542874,
0.2682919204,
-0.2330899984,
0.7739109993,
0.3028153181,
0.0411057398,
0.3724507987,
-0.7588234544,
-0.1778710932,
0.0342915319,
0.8657993078,
0.4101567864,
-0.4719508588,
-0.1497073025,
-0.4362881482,
-0.2312482744,
0.6396808028,
-0.5464161038,
-0.1332619041,
0.2108482718,
-0.2668561637,
-0.570106566,
0.015162671,
-0.7604843378,
-0.1400539875,
-0.5460851789,
0.6645626426,
-0.5749938488,
0.0523554869,
-0.0791857392,
0.0146220298,
0.0264769085,
0.2075280696,
-0.9453303814,
0.4563373923,
0.9435040951,
0.603489697,
-0.1695445627,
-0.218084231,
-0.743902564,
-0.3414988518,
-0.2976713479,
0.7985283136,
-0.945502162,
-0.2282773107,
-0.0766172633,
-0.2118000835,
0.0816947594,
-0.2896986306,
0.9877667427,
-0.2829426825,
0.6504736543,
0.022782417,
-0.5981516838,
-0.3815633357,
0.4505910277,
-0.5445770621,
1.3196891546,
0.4516924918,
-0.5367717743,
0.5912754536,
-0.8043794036,
-0.6122466922,
0.0676460117,
-0.1308421195,
-0.642978847,
0.4448125362,
0.4186816216,
0.1931651682,
-0.3513757885,
-0.0301189087,
0.2180737257,
-0.2663471103,
-0.0008847667,
-0.6353722215,
0.1632475257,
-0.3204647303,
-0.5425753593,
0.4416865706,
-1.1504900455,
0.596213758,
-0.461792618,
-0.5094799399,
-0.4522734284,
0.0078691449,
0.0351219513,
0.1501168162,
0.1660226136,
-0.51128304,
0.19439812,
-0.7490077019,
0.185221985,
0.3998848796,
0.0137173915,
0.4649325013,
-0.2554410994,
0.6260062456,
-0.2920084596,
0.156168893,
-0.5578995943,
-0.4173026085,
-1.1514203548,
0.1379778087,
0.3298043907,
0.5330349207,
-0.9648370147,
0.9067271352,
-0.1249406114,
-0.3476721942,
-0.8099948168,
0.3390332758,
0.9680580497,
0.3023887277,
0.4294989705,
-0.1094452664,
-0.4394522011,
-0.7766389251,
-0.1985237896,
-0.1325103045,
-0.1102371663,
0.3340434134,
0.2553803623,
0.0981485322,
0.7275769114,
-0.3598595262,
-0.3157290518,
-0.5706439614,
0.6185373664,
-0.0866504535,
0.3619390726,
0.2707627714,
-0.5823165774,
-0.5341308117,
0.3282020986,
-0.3207375407,
-0.1942197084,
-0.2766957581,
-0.1573896557,
0.3003419042,
0.1458998621,
0.0623318106,
0.219474569,
0.7737865448,
-0.3382251859,
0.6461231709,
-0.3920355141,
0.6452006698,
-0.9420176148,
-0.351929009,
0.1518120617,
-0.387293756,
-0.6403757334,
0.3075810075,
0.2959362566,
-0.0041130781,
-0.1467086226,
0.4474723041,
-0.3772551119,
0.3315347433,
-0.645691812,
0.22081469,
0.4827417731,
0.5853853226,
0.0013655877,
0.8295269608,
0.4797441363,
-0.4256257713,
-0.0495349802,
-0.0496212207,
-0.4163105786,
0.5617976785,
-0.4704137444,
0.3738636374,
0.0522196591,
-0.0426523313,
-0.6733064651,
-0.0581236519,
0.1408772022,
-0.1338019073,
0.5158843398,
-0.0335790515,
-0.2524186969,
-0.1756439954,
-0.6182906032,
0.0932187214,
0.3485371172,
-0.5436075926,
0.4790334702,
-0.0595618263,
-0.2071170658,
-0.3735916317,
-0.3046119809,
0.2355916351,
-0.0097569218,
-0.5698437095,
0.5113565326,
0.0297378544,
0.0897064582,
0.0078480225,
-0.2048206478,
-0.1180311441,
-0.0664421692,
0.0596471429,
0.148350969,
-0.2991102934,
0.0835264921,
0.8154832125,
-0.2152964473,
-0.0897940993,
-0.3950480521,
0.3471881747,
-0.1916530877,
-0.4134106636,
-0.2265343964,
0.460580647,
-0.0422186553,
-0.3120766282,
0.4063587189,
0.7633613944,
-0.0690101162,
-0.3983485401,
-0.4321909547,
0.0511933304,
-0.4784989059,
0.7821416855,
-0.1769230068,
-0.991356194,
-0.0203973632,
0.2452491224,
0.4231407046,
0.2270920128,
0.4074179828,
0.1921049058,
1.1431903839,
0.8081659675,
0.3510005772,
0.5249865651,
-0.1505914479,
0.1765844375,
-1.2324438095,
-0.0814443827,
-0.2816078365,
-0.300362885,
-0.4954106808,
-0.4797926247,
0.4636026621,
0.3454300761,
0.2601461411,
0.3384186625,
-0.6715855598,
0.7780100107,
0.5351658463,
0.2742924988,
0.4059374332,
-0.1519949287,
0.1813291907,
-0.0578902178,
-0.4311736226,
-0.731585741,
1.126630187,
0.0579202287,
0.4505315125,
-0.0891538411,
0.8778540492,
0.3692921996,
0.4229561687,
-0.7060030103,
0.3697982728,
-0.4699541628,
-0.2749910653,
-0.3109278977,
-0.4944881499,
-0.6579423547,
0.3660323024,
-0.3761870861,
-0.8128547072,
-0.1887554079,
0.3485470712,
-0.5301428437,
0.0639075115,
-0.9063775539,
0.6779808402,
-0.5127899051,
-0.3490917385,
-0.3625976741,
-0.3166984618,
0.5543495417,
-0.2258035392,
0.0372116938,
0.0608654357,
-0.1312234551,
0.5880824924,
-0.3184549809,
0.6792607903,
0.0896451473,
-0.1307034492,
0.2659475803,
-0.1345264465,
0.2670608163,
0.3826694489,
-0.2507825494,
0.1156907678,
-0.1420403421,
-0.0488210618,
-1.0652271509,
0.7318894863,
-0.6676292419,
-0.6187257171,
-0.0830525011,
-0.4506749511,
-0.2257190645,
0.0020138747,
0.4156357944,
0.6759738326,
-0.3070601523,
0.0575939044,
0.4719471335,
-0.4154629409,
0.3889790177,
0.4001254737,
-0.3533529043,
-0.6021253467,
1.2389971018,
-0.1856421232,
0.390866816,
0.6697348356,
0.3602949679,
-0.270742923,
-0.5141596794,
-0.7281091213,
-0.4078936577,
-0.4458957613,
-0.2653555572,
-0.6928938627,
-0.1604136378,
-0.132978484,
-0.0718908161,
-0.3639974296,
-0.4429323971,
-0.1393955648,
-0.0289303735,
0.2129649073,
0.7359976172,
0.1623748392,
0.5237787962,
-0.9519788623,
0.3336628973,
0.1968907267,
0.5193128586,
-0.0721394122,
-0.5355444551,
-0.4958353639,
0.0707399845,
-0.6055445075,
-0.5088748336,
0.1521191597,
0.6809609532,
0.4142846167,
0.4497147202,
-0.0948913172,
0.526653111,
-0.6848468781,
0.9042010903,
0.1935706735,
-1.2115030289,
0.5634748936,
0.0351474211,
0.2591387928,
0.7301037312,
0.0178589392,
-0.3723492324,
-0.6114258766,
-0.4527548552,
-1.1071472168,
0.8171260357,
0.410975486,
0.3533600569,
-0.1039964333,
0.3605021834,
0.676040411,
0.3298328519,
-0.5063755512,
-0.3200176656,
-0.4154436588,
-0.0954440609,
0.1045156494,
-0.1753899902,
0.0142351678,
-0.2602552772,
0.6592592597,
-0.1615274101,
-0.0965845734,
-0.0833912566,
-0.0767430067,
0.1439998001,
0.7634854317,
0.5880206227,
0.4582182467,
-0.0668161288,
-0.0480468608,
0.1560577601,
-0.5273451209,
0.2480672449,
0.1641634852,
-0.0904040411,
-0.0411607623,
0.5301280618,
1.2563130856,
0.5124233961,
-0.4592173696,
0.3887886405,
-0.3136264086,
-0.1747039855,
0.1788050234,
0.5853201151,
-0.4076717198,
0.0313346647,
0.3401677608,
0.1347576827,
0.2919037044,
-0.3784070909,
0.2629263699,
0.2929220498,
-0.4209241569,
-0.4943706989,
0.5055545568,
0.4812814295,
-0.6100125909,
0.3288147151,
-0.8618540764,
-0.5175645351,
0.1927811801,
0.4594487548,
1.2353670597,
-0.1123142838,
0.4839887917,
0.3016107082,
0.3940204382,
0.2595158219,
0.3044662178,
-0.3155503869,
-0.3807651401,
-0.818910718,
-0.9534169436,
-0.5155096054,
0.1144067347,
-0.8146941662,
0.2121462375,
-0.293256253,
-0.0700556338,
-0.1066196114,
0.0584420227,
-0.6712725163,
0.265522331,
0.0025893964,
0.6138528585,
-0.743609786,
0.6262619495,
0.8480946422,
-0.2433836907,
-0.5577800274,
0.2779649794,
-0.1997881681,
-0.5603692532,
0.1769471765,
0.2397331148,
0.023420753,
-0.1285707504,
-0.0709884465,
-0.6351049542,
0.693910718,
0.1308736503,
-0.7022222877,
0.0008600015,
0.1764425337,
0.698047936,
-0.3624470532,
0.5612838864,
0.8967461586,
0.4135136902,
-0.2722343504,
-0.8041617274,
-0.085309945,
-0.3787781596,
0.0768581107,
0.4394200444,
-0.3791153133,
0.6046119928,
-0.0784693584,
-0.0787945911,
0.1525057703,
0.7589491606,
0.0412187018,
0.2489511669,
0.648121953,
0.4806083739,
0.6400498748,
-0.2500579655,
1.1587545872,
-0.5948084593,
0.2395009547,
1.3491271734,
-0.067135863,
0.702044487,
0.0612419397,
-0.0701660886,
0.5394614935,
0.2970270216,
0.1831501871,
0.3796124458,
-0.090566732,
-0.3977070749,
-0.3148441315,
0.1004398391,
-0.0532718264,
0.5362241864,
0.3233248591,
-0.3837148845,
-0.4103412628,
0.2829639316,
-0.2058939934,
0.1535984278,
-0.2927340567,
0.9231419563,
-0.1053668261,
-0.714840889,
0.3251183629,
0.2063445598,
0.7324553728,
-0.7005283237,
-0.3240886033,
-0.0840219483,
-0.0655743331,
-0.2974942625,
-1.0585802794,
0.2542612255,
0.231820792,
-0.3773822486,
-0.1595449597,
0.5055531859,
-0.6054822803,
-0.8144177794,
0.0154354572,
0.2714599669,
-0.0773718655,
-0.2315543145,
-0.7500047088,
0.0655055717,
0.1942554414,
-0.4706541598,
0.4021387696,
0.5612767339,
-0.1532624811,
0.3395487666,
0.4262966812,
-0.0054460447,
0.0669096634,
0.366527766,
0.7956239581,
-0.5636630654,
-0.4844612181,
-0.7216442227,
0.7310791016,
-0.1459560543,
-0.728613317,
0.7686063051,
0.6297582984,
0.653897047,
0.3136313558,
0.9913006425,
-0.0548315719,
0.3986164927,
-0.7378159761,
0.5701135993,
-0.4812293053,
0.2904735208,
-0.4257036746,
-1.0440227985,
-0.0408256315,
0.3856036663,
-0.2170053124,
0.2329844385,
0.8049533963,
0.5803378224,
-0.0829487443,
0.3372442722,
0.4834522903,
-0.2360307425,
0.4363046885,
0.2596547604,
0.610740006,
-0.4930374324,
0.6043521762,
-0.4407078326,
-0.4963101745,
0.1235291734,
-0.8542533517,
-0.9386624098,
-0.4947287142,
-0.483623296,
-0.0809119791,
0.0200825427,
0.9838808775,
0.5866767168,
-0.6721839309,
0.086313419,
-0.0810256973,
0.0854508802,
-0.4798035622,
-0.2804332972,
0.4859409034,
-0.7753072977,
-0.9244984388,
0.5919011831,
0.6097075939,
-0.4819194376,
-0.4576872289,
0.0749900267,
0.3019889891,
0.0540060177,
0.8113286495,
-0.1403955072,
-0.5914973021,
-0.5303201079,
-0.1148648262,
0.2016692758,
0.2208575159,
0.8187430501,
-0.6942728162,
0.6242825389,
0.3238534629,
0.5270854235,
0.1497712284,
0.2265875638,
0.5318663716,
-1.2906666994,
-0.2217879444,
0.0898398012,
0.04875255,
0.409913063,
-0.3807682395,
0.1264312714,
-0.4470674396,
-0.6223919988,
-0.5065086484,
0.0407098643,
-0.7501088977,
-0.0063532814,
1.0604920387,
-0.1568412781,
-0.1332436949,
-0.0082203327,
-0.4759589434,
0.1411446631,
-0.5387749672,
0.9353896976,
0.6168689728,
-0.4625240862,
-0.188867256,
-0.4396657348,
0.5372962356,
0.3480962515,
-1.1683183908,
-0.0529999584,
0.2881031632,
0.0172476992,
0.2514693737,
0.1374597251,
0.149841845,
0.3616727591,
-0.0628068298,
0.0853246376,
-0.1427455992,
-0.1792926043,
-0.3348284066,
0.0255374517,
-0.0184222646,
-0.2359064072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08768v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08768v1
|
Three Conjectures on Unexpectedeness
| 2023-11-15T08:24:41 | 2023-11-15T08:24:41 |
Giovanni Sileno, Jean-Louis Dessalles
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IT, cs.SY, eess.SY, math.IT
|
Unexpectedness is a central concept in Simplicity Theory, a theory of
cognition relating various inferential processes to the computation of
Kolmogorov complexities, rather than probabilities. Its predictive power has
been confirmed by several experiments with human subjects, yet its theoretical
basis remains largely unexplored: why does it work? This paper lays the
groundwork for three theoretical conjectures. First, unexpectedness can be seen
as a generalization of Bayes' rule. Second, the frequentist core of
unexpectedness can be connected to the function of tracking ergodic properties
of the world. Third, unexpectedness can be seen as constituent of various
measures of divergence between the entropy of the world (environment) and the
variety of the observer (system). The resulting framework hints to research
directions that go beyond the division between probabilistic and logical
approaches, potentially bringing new insights into the extraction of causal
relations, and into the role of descriptive mechanisms in learning.
|
[
-0.7278804779,
-0.7536883354,
1.0964124203,
0.1831126213,
-0.0891158059,
-0.2044297904,
-0.0359496437,
-0.6445456147,
0.1690599322,
-0.0142096831,
-0.9618020058,
-0.0720087737,
-0.4432295561,
-0.0404763259,
-0.375390619,
0.8398544192,
0.2756490409,
-0.0271353684,
0.3509215713,
-0.0119092762,
-0.3326492906,
-0.2295888066,
-0.2266187072,
-0.1116449684,
0.4666494429,
0.3252471983,
0.8054242134,
0.4243368208,
0.382348299,
0.2808429897,
0.0663071349,
0.0247529298,
-0.1376856118,
0.0691396967,
-0.1110743433,
-1.2294982672,
0.1719271094,
0.1802680641,
0.4947413206,
1.1064709425,
-0.2929781675,
-0.3805367947,
0.3863765001,
0.9920452237,
-0.5393320918,
0.1815571636,
-0.3060711622,
-0.0457587205,
-0.1706852913,
-0.087931186,
-0.0752482638,
-0.3061512113,
0.2200486958,
-0.9114421606,
0.7371436954,
0.309342891,
0.4497561157,
0.0022279138,
-0.4180940688,
-0.6103188992,
-0.8808997869,
0.702291429,
-0.1969781816,
0.1633481085,
0.1426736563,
0.4291255176,
-0.4938196838,
-0.57886976,
-0.7926923037,
-0.0987190232,
0.0574751124,
0.1255512536,
-0.2859677672,
0.1696507931,
0.4740482569,
0.1065000743,
-0.281441927,
-0.2091721594,
-0.1451662779,
0.2455131859,
0.4338439405,
0.3782441616,
0.3403009176,
-0.1538185626,
-0.0081658149,
0.0862887651,
-0.4836513102,
0.438975215,
0.9549810886,
0.1233123913,
-0.2534133494,
0.4363728464,
-0.4992596805,
0.7140371799,
-0.1881043017,
0.2955848575,
0.1423522383,
-0.1013606861,
0.2356681675,
-0.1045414805,
0.3845380843,
0.1978357136,
0.0322541147,
-0.1443178356,
0.2650342882,
0.173758626,
-0.022051055,
-0.1656400114,
-0.7749583721,
0.2147527933,
-0.300542891,
-0.5124927759,
0.5457616448,
-0.5908139348,
-0.2314049304,
-0.1464805752,
0.3195696771,
-0.5504586101,
-0.1808525175,
0.1317656636,
-0.3007578552,
-0.0509296358,
0.7114033699,
-0.8913813829,
0.4824928939,
0.8524289131,
0.4416801631,
-0.493240416,
-0.6038021445,
0.1278698146,
0.1343730539,
-0.3214984536,
0.7898898721,
-0.41363585,
-0.1296089888,
-0.2080647498,
0.2361458689,
-0.0241404846,
-0.1905068308,
0.5850486755,
-0.1310481727,
0.0604748018,
-0.4258939922,
-0.4762111306,
-0.6459101439,
0.0997313261,
-0.5342363715,
0.5296117663,
-0.1503858566,
-0.6890313625,
0.5955762863,
-0.588852644,
-0.1472222954,
0.2919973135,
-0.4479632676,
-0.0796776563,
0.6222630143,
-0.4590937793,
0.1032977998,
-0.1281779408,
0.2348866463,
-0.5670281053,
-0.5143992305,
0.8679881692,
-0.577663064,
0.8034623861,
0.3681405485,
-0.3812805712,
-0.5088443756,
-0.9100906253,
0.2132758796,
0.0331498608,
-0.2471726388,
-0.5132209659,
0.3088953197,
-0.2817567885,
0.1243764088,
0.0118409274,
-0.5962071419,
0.3597404063,
-0.4025064409,
0.3769087791,
0.6151000261,
0.2973943949,
0.5410006046,
-0.4372102916,
0.2093745917,
0.0832312182,
0.3747024536,
-0.1771186292,
-0.7512270212,
-0.7537430525,
-0.2453068048,
0.1928135753,
0.5711625218,
-0.5465012789,
-0.0337456241,
-0.0409075804,
-0.393770963,
-0.0264724381,
-0.084712334,
0.364056915,
-0.3129662275,
-0.1170208901,
-0.0879533365,
-0.6225811243,
-0.8636576533,
-1.0561861992,
-0.2900705338,
-0.1637613475,
0.2866135538,
0.2806193531,
0.0432814583,
1.0709555149,
-0.6919125319,
0.0391894802,
-0.035335429,
0.3077306151,
0.6718202829,
0.8321431279,
0.4445780814,
-0.9398007393,
-0.1249283776,
-0.0156634487,
-0.8413079977,
0.3309455216,
0.2160582244,
0.2328802645,
0.2647521198,
0.3447437286,
-0.7812014818,
0.6476297379,
-0.0395466723,
-0.013533066,
0.6074921489,
-0.1224200204,
-0.0807386264,
-0.6262313128,
-0.2746051252,
-0.3294107914,
0.2306772619,
-0.843809545,
0.2939065695,
-0.113387011,
0.2427156717,
-0.4021467566,
0.1515151858,
-0.4797283709,
-0.0123445401,
0.0275184941,
-0.3620060682,
-0.407902509,
0.5387947559,
-0.3708060086,
-0.1969026327,
0.7524779439,
-0.8905200362,
0.2941215932,
-0.3469761014,
-0.3957975209,
0.5517438054,
-0.2180429399,
-0.211042583,
-0.4150359333,
-0.0207309555,
-1.2078369856,
-0.604968369,
0.3423753083,
-0.7285097241,
0.0022027066,
-0.1727129817,
-0.454851836,
-0.6094935536,
-0.3040997684,
0.4803541005,
0.5466021299,
-0.3993133307,
0.4400137067,
0.073240228,
-0.0563328788,
-0.2883326709,
-0.5849993229,
-0.2939288914,
-0.3610484898,
-0.359249562,
-0.0318133421,
-0.5408592224,
-0.6657706499,
-0.1492375731,
-0.3048025072,
-0.0917012841,
0.3037932515,
0.5973399878,
0.2340575904,
0.1492543966,
-0.2518173456,
-0.0848941952,
0.0261570942,
0.3335005045,
-0.3996400833,
0.2472123653,
-0.4155058265,
-0.6013610959,
-0.4437845647,
0.3758052289,
0.1961680204,
0.9969899654,
0.1956178993,
0.2482503653,
-0.661895752,
0.0516327508,
-0.5708261728,
-0.147855565,
-0.4837667346,
0.1239028946,
-0.4735618532,
-0.5986129045,
0.7748895288,
-0.0600600317,
-0.2279032767,
0.4809732735,
0.1844014376,
-0.4595293105,
1.2985465527,
0.6625547409,
0.6943321228,
0.2738200426,
-0.2577253282,
0.4998355508,
-0.5541253686,
-0.818652451,
-0.4679237902,
-0.2206148207,
-1.4681684971,
-0.0129373502,
0.5748860836,
0.382133007,
-0.212917313,
-0.0085665165,
0.0984618887,
0.8232259154,
0.6853628755,
0.3200754821,
0.2687144876,
0.1520230919,
-0.2896448374,
-0.0716477931,
-0.8829336762,
-0.0280119218,
0.9280308485,
-0.0982191041,
0.8884100318,
0.4541147649,
0.7627962232,
0.1380421221,
-0.0716967508,
-0.6998170614,
0.4569381475,
0.3287695646,
-0.5940250754,
-0.5227645636,
-0.321390599,
-1.1239881516,
0.1954777837,
-0.3213885128,
-1.0651708841,
0.6338267326,
0.1998846084,
-0.500488162,
0.0428643338,
-0.4297175705,
0.3894886374,
-0.0303035975,
-0.5285896063,
-0.0801757351,
-1.0000377893,
0.6429968476,
0.0074075395,
0.7375822663,
-0.060361024,
0.0291864611,
0.7589969635,
-0.2723027468,
0.7093615532,
-0.0783834532,
0.2817403376,
0.5086116195,
0.5209926367,
0.5709845424,
0.2586745918,
0.4194230437,
0.1536671668,
0.0703542754,
-0.7112929225,
-0.7791290879,
0.5303595066,
-0.7165191174,
-0.5657635331,
-0.7235058546,
-0.429297626,
-0.2700982094,
0.2558799684,
0.8937956691,
0.0773311779,
-0.3837040663,
-0.1831587404,
0.779435873,
0.1251741797,
0.8524477482,
0.7585901618,
-0.0733367428,
-0.1248210073,
0.9088297486,
0.2570859492,
0.061691232,
0.0793016776,
0.0781759396,
0.1415056586,
-0.3565790951,
0.3067855537,
-0.0904970765,
-0.7057329416,
0.2117723823,
-0.8709343672,
-0.0941878781,
-0.0633744746,
-0.3420906365,
-0.217054978,
-0.9088096619,
-0.2150629312,
-0.0707370713,
-0.0047599864,
1.1669652462,
-0.5593147278,
0.3450178504,
-0.4399705827,
0.1360101253,
0.7035893798,
0.0375298709,
0.0847883746,
-0.4328212738,
-0.2128536701,
-0.0832372829,
-0.3820154369,
-0.8347141147,
0.2208146006,
-0.0886142403,
0.8726232648,
0.9333310127,
-0.0481607094,
0.3401815891,
-0.316293329,
0.6535561085,
0.542794764,
-0.6956662536,
0.3475651443,
-0.6898706555,
-0.0313055851,
0.4153292775,
0.4995337129,
-0.0540126339,
-0.3528903425,
-1.3857141733,
-0.7911900282,
0.507635355,
0.5963625908,
-0.0390130021,
-0.143796429,
0.2851899266,
0.5572098494,
0.270829618,
-0.5643336177,
-0.5633137822,
0.1803802997,
0.347529918,
-0.1974624991,
-0.3114893734,
-0.2924669683,
-0.1846052557,
0.3038683534,
0.0352382101,
0.3236066997,
0.1807177216,
0.1375197768,
-0.1206294224,
0.3021232188,
0.8330614567,
0.8166496754,
-0.2126277834,
0.5146887302,
0.0790816024,
-0.2658371627,
0.304077208,
-0.0002871907,
-0.0924782902,
0.069537811,
0.3978564441,
0.6434143186,
0.3418704271,
-0.2617858946,
0.414032042,
-0.1067257747,
-0.2055655569,
-0.6751226783,
0.477960676,
-0.3099199235,
0.2346015573,
0.820258677,
0.8874819279,
0.6658645868,
-1.012873292,
-0.0025592449,
0.3968906999,
-0.3125962317,
-0.8155599236,
0.414616704,
-0.2349376082,
-0.5472936034,
0.2985544801,
-0.4533771276,
-0.6032420397,
0.7527518868,
0.3585921228,
0.5866923928,
-0.2864336073,
0.0875909775,
0.2778555751,
0.5316416621,
-0.434240371,
0.6898555756,
0.0003416124,
-0.5926699638,
0.1014059484,
-0.3651702404,
-0.4422038794,
-0.2748064697,
-0.9094469547,
0.3449268937,
-0.1769750416,
0.1917675585,
0.0574958734,
-0.3130413592,
-0.898627758,
-0.0296375304,
-0.1090770885,
0.6698536873,
-1.3070211411,
0.3415829241,
0.4572655857,
0.0429181792,
-0.8222831488,
0.0130802412,
0.1136165038,
-0.9323455691,
0.373883158,
0.1470536292,
0.2507587075,
-0.0241594091,
-0.9620371461,
-0.9530808926,
0.6596301794,
0.2690603435,
-0.4179477394,
-0.0306101926,
-0.0717764571,
0.3785949647,
-0.3344888687,
0.0790643916,
0.8417990804,
0.5964999199,
-0.1032900438,
-0.427975148,
0.0573700815,
-0.3465595245,
-0.0022567147,
0.1091999412,
-0.5156290531,
0.8802250028,
-0.9007200599,
0.0074172635,
0.3151214123,
0.4326927364,
0.4598737359,
0.7002320886,
0.3471356034,
0.5990322828,
0.5951859355,
-0.1600276232,
1.2834630013,
-0.2635483146,
0.4643763602,
0.873881042,
0.1439720392,
0.3274464011,
0.6592048407,
-0.8166220784,
0.6975903511,
0.8784973025,
0.3116924763,
0.6645476818,
0.3533419967,
-0.2939181924,
-0.1820749789,
0.1889076829,
-0.3345513344,
0.4845385849,
0.5833984017,
-0.0217700191,
-0.0939143896,
0.0509358011,
-0.1744326651,
-0.3292001784,
-0.3743531704,
0.6685352921,
0.150049448,
-0.8768750429,
0.1624995768,
-0.1958651692,
0.2684822679,
-0.582180202,
-0.283803612,
-0.1501537412,
-0.1600501537,
-0.2694560289,
-0.8224901557,
-0.0879624784,
-0.7430936098,
-0.2335090488,
0.3954848647,
0.5131467581,
0.1208021715,
-0.3719670475,
-0.1496239007,
0.5056788325,
0.5517927408,
-0.0383174047,
-0.2382907718,
-0.1779245585,
-0.0019570058,
-0.281260252,
0.3757618964,
0.9878935218,
-0.0335394293,
0.752659142,
0.6842547655,
0.0458318107,
0.4480539262,
-0.5807347894,
0.5385448337,
-0.714204371,
-1.0320417881,
-0.9910811782,
0.172015518,
0.2520323694,
-0.2223605067,
0.8191338181,
0.4996471405,
0.4971587062,
-0.2454450727,
0.9450977445,
-0.1385798603,
0.1428029835,
-0.4943301678,
0.3571906686,
-0.1957060993,
0.3006082475,
-0.4804689586,
-0.9903988242,
-0.2491104603,
0.357788533,
0.035024371,
-0.011046106,
1.2571514845,
0.2273740917,
0.11426007,
0.3425447047,
0.4359436333,
0.3300606608,
-0.3693880737,
0.5980964899,
0.9080822468,
-0.2174392045,
0.2744576633,
-0.4169712961,
-0.4270350635,
-0.528136909,
-0.8586017489,
-0.4585705101,
-0.6502351761,
-0.067545943,
-0.3297905624,
0.1774800271,
0.4728150368,
0.5115649104,
-0.7007505894,
-0.0588065982,
-0.8257023096,
0.2553379536,
-0.554515183,
-0.2630750239,
0.1919137388,
-0.0026625618,
-0.4781885445,
0.2524294257,
0.245194003,
0.6090329289,
0.1355443895,
0.0919781402,
0.2072736472,
0.0824263021,
0.2183781862,
0.7732650042,
-0.7156637907,
-0.2473243177,
-0.3087562025,
0.3213799596,
-0.1741334498,
0.7769200206,
-0.6398900151,
0.3273494244,
0.5480318666,
-0.1055582687,
0.3119570911,
-0.2809103131,
0.4978939891,
-0.3754353523,
0.3996321559,
0.0013952797,
0.4306016564,
-0.0208418574,
-0.5341746807,
0.5847150087,
0.7603744864,
-0.2876838148,
-1.1103914976,
0.7210832834,
-0.9892625213,
-0.4134167731,
0.6124316454,
-0.2129379511,
-0.0507399067,
-0.3553515375,
0.238740012,
0.035560593,
-0.2262368798,
1.0945539474,
0.9070250392,
-1.0020996332,
0.0191178434,
-0.9903660417,
0.5105619431,
0.5875679255,
-0.427151382,
-0.2371001095,
0.1492660791,
0.3941223621,
0.3864547908,
0.3874118924,
0.3512193263,
0.6342696548,
0.1102209389,
-0.1474696845,
0.230821982,
-0.3884888291,
-0.3545387089,
0.4574249685,
0.0147289578,
0.0263200235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.09430v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.09430v1
|
Deep Representation Learning for Open Vocabulary Electroencephalography-to-Text Decoding
| 2023-11-15T08:03:09 | 2023-11-15T08:03:09 |
Hamza Amrani, Daniela Micucci, Paolo Napoletano
|
eess.SP
|
eess.SP, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Previous research has demonstrated the potential of using pre-trained
language models for decoding open vocabulary Electroencephalography (EEG)
signals captured through a non-invasive Brain-Computer Interface (BCI).
However, the impact of embedding EEG signals in the context of language models
and the effect of subjectivity, remain unexplored, leading to uncertainty about
the best approach to enhance decoding performance. Additionally, current
evaluation metrics used to assess decoding effectiveness are predominantly
syntactic and do not provide insights into the comprehensibility of the decoded
output for human understanding. We present an end-to-end deep learning
framework for non-invasive brain recordings that brings modern representational
learning approaches to neuroscience. Our proposal introduces the following
innovations: 1) an end-to-end deep learning architecture for open vocabulary
EEG decoding, incorporating a subject-dependent representation learning module
for raw EEG encoding, a BART language model, and a GPT-4 sentence refinement
module; 2) a more comprehensive sentence-level evaluation metric based on the
BERTScore; 3) an ablation study that analyses the contributions of each module
within our proposal, providing valuable insights for future research. We
evaluate our approach on two publicly available datasets, ZuCo v1.0 and v2.0,
comprising EEG recordings of 30 subjects engaged in natural reading tasks. Our
model achieves a BLEU-1 score of 42.75%, a ROUGE-1-F of 33.28%, and a
BERTScore-F of 53.86%, outperforming the previous state-of-the-art methods by
3.38%, 8.43%, and 6.31%, respectively.
|
[
-0.2608434558,
-0.6925739646,
0.5704297423,
0.1002414599,
-0.4608850479,
-0.1396038383,
-0.7212432623,
-0.5800567269,
0.2146201283,
0.3912470639,
-0.2443157732,
-0.8973582983,
-0.5710287094,
0.0665310994,
-0.1982595176,
0.564301312,
-0.0399273597,
0.1829487383,
-0.3570772409,
-0.1021905765,
-0.7414606214,
-0.584849894,
-0.4637875259,
-0.444821924,
0.5111625195,
0.2530912161,
0.1074483246,
0.1676162481,
0.1106624678,
0.1255907714,
-0.200133875,
0.2034007013,
-0.359182328,
-0.0449003763,
-0.1734193116,
-0.4681327343,
-0.4808235466,
-0.3371170163,
0.4182422459,
1.0242831707,
-0.2095600963,
-0.0187375788,
0.1900098771,
0.6837887168,
-0.8123858571,
0.2213388979,
-0.3275411129,
0.1477329582,
0.1256461143,
-0.0491606854,
-0.9305016994,
0.0228061434,
0.2540551126,
-0.4931287169,
0.0278901681,
-0.1175216511,
0.8639258146,
-0.1399413645,
-0.4702683985,
-0.226694569,
-0.5791714191,
0.6306346059,
-0.7229623795,
0.730492115,
0.500290215,
-0.0890180096,
0.1624076068,
-0.826274693,
-0.4233962595,
-0.3304128349,
0.009957877,
0.5043453574,
-0.3069206178,
0.2669839263,
-0.0197442658,
0.4050580561,
-0.6147329807,
0.5097867846,
-0.452288568,
-0.1196527481,
0.4873581827,
-0.0787799358,
0.1145145446,
0.1158685908,
-0.2675205767,
-0.1865711808,
-0.3788434863,
-0.0053943899,
0.3197989762,
0.0982210264,
-0.0784573555,
0.4827630818,
-0.0896645784,
0.4327254593,
0.0423265956,
0.7011170983,
0.605838716,
-0.0739730299,
-0.3544265032,
0.3150643706,
0.8287290335,
0.3742035627,
0.1304990053,
-0.4906944633,
-0.2391366661,
-0.0511511639,
0.3578987122,
-0.8875542283,
-0.1777562201,
0.2636552453,
-0.787530303,
0.0422546603,
-0.013396115,
-0.7667396665,
-0.4814313054,
-0.4322296977,
0.5450624824,
-0.6721634865,
-0.3564342558,
0.7247902155,
0.1480790228,
0.2717808485,
0.2271016538,
-0.9700997472,
0.3167560697,
0.3140492439,
0.8705194592,
-0.0858464614,
-0.1074644998,
-0.2219067067,
0.061117515,
-0.5180308223,
0.6669394374,
-0.211517781,
-0.2347666323,
0.0443428941,
0.0331190974,
0.0098284082,
-0.2848780155,
0.5782445073,
-0.5982949138,
0.2587894499,
-0.0999017134,
-0.8108822703,
-0.4036809802,
-0.0360473879,
-0.7703748345,
0.4085647464,
-0.1947803348,
-0.3248603046,
0.3198544681,
-0.6327986121,
-0.5387038589,
0.0687607378,
-0.189514339,
-0.4015213847,
0.5116458535,
0.3799234927,
0.5708650351,
-0.145644635,
0.1653078943,
-0.1882919669,
-0.4182017148,
0.1839015186,
-0.637454927,
0.7130172849,
0.1051743329,
-0.2220481038,
0.0079498496,
-0.8146724701,
0.1283054352,
0.0079152808,
-0.1663461626,
-0.2667688727,
-0.0508341454,
0.1410772204,
-0.1780457199,
0.3429381549,
-0.8750706911,
-0.0269212723,
-0.7038708925,
0.4591890872,
0.505430758,
-0.0278748684,
0.4112994969,
0.10790319,
0.1549426615,
0.1823694706,
-0.2571130991,
-0.559917748,
-0.3661142886,
-0.5660385489,
-0.1528673321,
0.6525917053,
0.4809345901,
-0.3018096387,
0.9537135363,
-0.32428056,
-0.402044028,
-0.6370388865,
-0.3585529625,
0.2459279895,
0.5403078794,
0.5891193748,
-0.6165084243,
-0.4152227044,
-0.8957408667,
-0.1164631471,
-0.0054617431,
-0.2916842103,
0.1880653054,
0.4107975066,
-0.3315357268,
0.6379804611,
-0.2994645834,
-0.4747675955,
-0.2121133655,
0.4361428916,
0.3939083219,
0.3172402978,
0.2795098424,
-0.359806031,
-0.1874009818,
0.446234256,
-0.93565166,
0.1760249138,
-0.2838424146,
0.1784178913,
0.2688215077,
0.5487300754,
-0.5176101923,
0.4440435171,
0.2041694969,
-0.4686446488,
0.3636495769,
-0.6756420135,
0.1680814177,
-0.8451174498,
0.0854477659,
0.1168656796,
0.0840424001,
-0.6887181401,
-0.0948284343,
0.300649941,
-0.1279242337,
-0.1407882124,
0.2695350945,
-0.6081169844,
0.0546684749,
-0.1126476303,
0.045897603,
0.1944746673,
0.5772690773,
0.3856492639,
0.4469896853,
0.6271406412,
-0.4510689974,
0.0309502259,
0.3736644983,
-0.3687301576,
0.1220980585,
-0.6910434365,
0.3765241802,
-0.5128446221,
-0.0204020571,
-0.9218306541,
-0.0879625827,
-0.1403573751,
-0.7975008488,
0.6364360452,
0.2627366781,
-0.4265947044,
0.033851888,
-0.0893492922,
0.3961950541,
0.7565028071,
-0.5996680856,
0.6110996604,
0.1524742097,
0.1489806771,
-0.5688189864,
-1.2134839296,
0.2855529487,
0.2691325247,
-0.4532290697,
0.4658464789,
0.2147844434,
0.2430366725,
-0.0213673841,
-0.1011261269,
-0.1503331214,
-0.1488288641,
-0.0673107654,
-0.0061529283,
-0.2876286209,
0.2719433308,
0.1551503837,
-0.0328030102,
0.3137027919,
-0.4368465245,
0.5307458043,
-0.105651252,
-0.2826491594,
-0.3264162838,
0.4619755447,
0.3622860014,
-0.6320030689,
0.6862621307,
0.7035191655,
-0.7389648557,
-0.1475327164,
-0.1929180771,
-0.1776663959,
-0.4608468413,
0.7232643366,
-0.2671917081,
-0.7974386215,
0.4406749606,
-0.1270274669,
-0.0104021812,
0.1498225629,
0.6215923429,
-0.2021843344,
0.8354369998,
0.6753186584,
0.1816520542,
0.3914971948,
-0.3952944279,
0.3814509213,
-0.8314835429,
-0.5908796787,
0.1072013825,
-0.3910349309,
-0.2148380876,
-0.102854155,
-0.0415430516,
0.2686254382,
-0.0953884125,
0.2082985342,
-0.6279436946,
0.4147685766,
0.3834790289,
0.672275126,
0.1921827197,
0.2771793604,
-0.2457097173,
-0.175990209,
-0.4378187954,
-0.417647928,
1.43196702,
0.5282911658,
0.6641562581,
-0.0617670752,
0.8781918287,
0.3468892574,
0.1156825721,
-0.9227517247,
0.5230792165,
-0.1224390343,
-0.20256643,
-0.2286239564,
-0.2516352236,
-1.198341012,
0.1598877311,
-0.2145468295,
-0.9517586231,
0.6783367991,
-0.1086504459,
-0.4189169705,
0.432782799,
-0.9800238609,
0.9168319702,
-0.170940578,
-0.4685586691,
-0.4212251306,
-0.5395055413,
0.1670291126,
0.1318186671,
-0.130840838,
0.2866440713,
-0.2745519876,
0.5676352978,
0.1667464823,
0.9108525515,
-0.2138330489,
-0.1797137856,
0.2206666172,
-0.0884327963,
0.1278063506,
0.0440645032,
-0.1698433757,
0.6301657557,
-0.256452471,
-0.3112795055,
-0.4569533169,
0.5361410379,
-0.9264701605,
-0.0699938908,
-0.338028729,
-0.2755274773,
-0.2521126866,
0.3785881698,
0.56388551,
0.4763784409,
-0.3092028499,
0.3686369658,
1.1970671415,
-0.4007294476,
0.4941278696,
0.1457295269,
0.0173598211,
-0.7025197148,
1.0464961529,
0.089696601,
-0.1047368124,
0.5853856802,
-0.2253324389,
-0.3770975173,
-0.957970798,
-0.2692905962,
0.1822246164,
-0.7780021429,
-0.1186486185,
-0.5618526936,
-0.1283588558,
-0.2620284557,
-0.0207346845,
-0.2447208613,
0.0345934778,
-0.5924711823,
-0.349652946,
0.0765227154,
0.5804390311,
-0.0733247772,
0.3144511878,
-0.6426387429,
0.2943643332,
0.0080411602,
0.7292676568,
0.1275626868,
-0.2915662229,
-0.646289885,
0.0534743369,
-0.1943262666,
-1.1702982187,
0.5729551315,
0.2204476595,
0.4052051604,
0.2241202146,
-0.0605404787,
0.3453393281,
-0.5442677736,
0.7073218226,
0.6830282211,
-0.951474905,
0.3639236391,
-0.1368029416,
0.2281797379,
0.563606739,
0.2340037674,
-0.4152551293,
0.1366399378,
-0.3011024594,
-1.0472015142,
0.5203224421,
0.1113958433,
0.21423769,
-0.1653847694,
0.5307449102,
0.2559494674,
0.202365458,
-0.8140429258,
-0.2066372186,
-0.2913016677,
-0.4899970591,
-0.1321242601,
-0.2458679825,
0.1929207295,
-0.4105658233,
0.1830396801,
-0.1627877653,
0.9098059535,
0.5079396963,
-0.317792505,
0.0549586453,
0.3574277461,
0.3865576386,
0.5783545971,
-0.2792639732,
-0.1228132471,
0.2171489894,
-0.6235489845,
0.0149096726,
0.1856342256,
0.0658970103,
0.1800778061,
0.4213843942,
0.996735394,
-0.1409451365,
-0.6788527369,
0.659265101,
-0.2036079466,
-0.6381031275,
-0.3791638911,
-0.3794577718,
0.1405679435,
0.1681875736,
0.368047297,
0.058294531,
0.3537902534,
-0.288636446,
0.2210575342,
0.2736054361,
-0.4409382939,
-0.3720260262,
0.6420581937,
0.1387988925,
-0.1862760484,
0.6266961694,
-0.2628386319,
-0.0058305082,
0.4975291193,
0.6121647954,
1.2136554718,
-0.0164854173,
0.0024170061,
0.3949482143,
0.4817333817,
0.1028968245,
0.5361002684,
-0.0884383991,
-0.6598110795,
-0.7546807528,
-0.4534774721,
-0.2832765877,
0.4133507609,
-0.8377162218,
0.3606455326,
-0.4057114124,
-0.0637325794,
-0.2386775315,
-0.1869562268,
-0.7304329276,
0.3075950146,
0.6290627122,
0.9225693345,
-0.6102349758,
0.7644221187,
0.7401174307,
-0.488691479,
-0.3316298425,
0.1020827219,
-0.7740992308,
-0.4883505702,
0.4081869721,
0.5168688297,
0.0421853736,
0.177403301,
-0.4069128633,
-0.5098514557,
1.1771062613,
0.6812514663,
-0.9437459111,
-0.3227080405,
0.1196941286,
0.6586824656,
-0.2630293667,
0.5394558311,
0.3468182981,
0.3256214261,
-0.4392519593,
-0.7144834995,
-0.0177438632,
-0.2445208877,
-0.0597956926,
0.1920621395,
-0.4229524434,
0.5705954432,
-0.1400116533,
-0.3827330768,
-0.0759763196,
1.0870393515,
-0.1471593976,
0.4866594076,
0.1577364504,
0.7505314946,
0.8944784999,
0.0240109339,
0.7916945815,
-0.2042918205,
0.346819371,
0.8291274905,
-0.0744091049,
0.8415769935,
0.3506990969,
0.0765876547,
0.6061477065,
0.6913075447,
0.0255069789,
0.8152343631,
0.1502677947,
-0.3382773101,
-0.2714791894,
0.2290311307,
-0.2692151666,
0.1989292502,
0.626287818,
-0.4733610153,
-0.2726289332,
0.4780527651,
-0.379966706,
0.3348714113,
-0.4670034647,
0.6698945165,
0.3054714501,
-0.2873903811,
0.6047558188,
0.0215267986,
0.752972424,
-0.5625686049,
-0.2306099385,
0.0824086666,
0.2467606217,
-0.2389800251,
-0.815900147,
0.0784422159,
-0.2131153345,
-0.2018659562,
-0.1564512849,
0.6623479128,
-0.5153461695,
-0.2143033743,
0.593588233,
0.4470942914,
0.1125665382,
-0.0206461195,
-0.4117978215,
-0.1646713018,
-0.1506945044,
-0.4449620247,
0.2895342708,
0.5609095693,
0.1945763081,
0.3332059681,
0.422075808,
0.0171325151,
-0.0077148713,
0.1434900165,
0.6415840983,
-0.8370535374,
-0.5028737783,
-0.8268527985,
0.5739014745,
-0.0283919666,
-0.4088347554,
0.4360113144,
0.5062969923,
0.9178286791,
-0.0650638416,
0.7893511057,
0.0738832727,
0.028383242,
-0.5877495408,
0.7927024961,
-0.389231056,
0.0260103568,
0.1369127333,
-0.6122344732,
-0.3218715787,
0.5506453514,
-0.1990751028,
-0.0255233012,
0.8587282896,
0.4290152192,
-0.1173334196,
0.2740578353,
0.6126416922,
0.080922395,
0.0879694298,
0.8427122235,
0.5831996202,
-0.4037589729,
0.3769710064,
-0.0385524482,
-0.306997627,
0.0142585905,
-0.7560255527,
-1.0294407606,
-0.4485117495,
-0.3498466909,
-0.2441168129,
0.1455275118,
0.809601903,
0.3950379491,
-0.6343329549,
-0.2080032676,
-0.4989100397,
-0.3894298375,
-0.4271946549,
-0.1254137605,
0.5451074243,
-0.5741779804,
-0.4556573629,
0.4942921996,
0.1401352882,
-0.2354966402,
-0.3133293986,
-0.1633041799,
0.0236769449,
0.0097540161,
0.8170981407,
0.1863084137,
-0.5716739297,
-0.0803270563,
0.3928005099,
0.0739121363,
0.3133690953,
0.5695750713,
-1.0484082699,
0.6441963315,
0.466717422,
1.0373942852,
0.7705954313,
-0.5078418255,
0.6233836412,
-0.7625639439,
-0.1149187461,
0.6039592028,
0.4098118842,
0.1962389946,
-0.5307247043,
0.1200722754,
-0.0241128262,
-0.5329733491,
-0.7199835777,
0.1166116446,
-1.2086694241,
-0.5056833625,
0.9150877595,
-0.2091015875,
-0.481364429,
0.051491607,
-0.1242365763,
0.4069201052,
-0.5088074803,
0.5243207216,
0.7408013344,
-0.2174925953,
-0.4204722345,
-0.5070411563,
-0.0904453844,
0.595824182,
-0.6795938015,
0.1881079078,
0.5539182425,
-0.0604738854,
0.1660037041,
0.3542759418,
-0.2255887836,
0.429453969,
-0.0412192047,
0.5322319269,
-0.311044991,
-0.2127012163,
-0.8732100725,
0.1985441446,
-0.0577064902,
-0.4243532717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08756v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08756v1
|
Accelerating Toeplitz Neural Network with Constant-time Inference Complexity
| 2023-11-15T07:50:57 | 2023-11-15T07:50:57 |
Zhen Qin, Yiran Zhong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Toeplitz Neural Networks (TNNs) have exhibited outstanding performance in
various sequence modeling tasks. They outperform commonly used
Transformer-based models while benefiting from log-linear space-time
complexities. On the other hand, State Space Models (SSMs) achieve lower
performance than TNNs in language modeling but offer the advantage of constant
inference complexity. In this paper, we aim to combine the strengths of TNNs
and SSMs by converting TNNs to SSMs during inference, thereby enabling TNNs to
achieve the same constant inference complexities as SSMs. To accomplish this,
we formulate the conversion process as an optimization problem and provide a
closed-form solution. We demonstrate how to transform the target equation into
a Vandermonde linear system problem, which can be efficiently solved using the
Discrete Fourier Transform (DFT). Notably, our method requires no training and
maintains numerical stability. It can be also applied to any LongConv-based
model. To assess its effectiveness, we conduct extensive experiments on
language modeling tasks across various settings. Additionally, we compare our
method to other gradient-descent solutions, highlighting the superior numerical
stability of our approach. The source code is available at
https://github.com/OpenNLPLab/ETSC-Exact-Toeplitz-to-SSM-Conversion.
|
[
-0.1783233285,
-0.8452787399,
0.7317842245,
0.659899652,
-0.5970833302,
0.1574005485,
-0.4992171228,
-0.1390598267,
0.0498824939,
0.2482172251,
-0.439427644,
-0.2742566466,
-0.6128101945,
-0.0469832867,
-0.2271683365,
0.3490860462,
-0.1863186657,
0.4772268236,
-0.0004996315,
0.1335471869,
-0.2009041011,
-0.2139362842,
-0.7025214434,
-0.4789491594,
0.3045367599,
0.2354116738,
0.4490030408,
0.7608581185,
0.4171282947,
0.360132724,
-0.234574005,
-0.1101424322,
-0.521732986,
0.2166276723,
-0.1046682,
-0.3626045585,
-0.2652719021,
-0.2670148015,
0.6494083405,
1.2658729553,
-0.2178673744,
-0.014148403,
-0.2460332513,
0.5735476017,
-0.3957059085,
0.0656276494,
-0.4093056321,
0.2025304884,
0.0680119172,
-0.0030881101,
-0.4211868942,
-0.6556670666,
0.2088469863,
-0.4528057873,
0.2310673743,
-0.2524702847,
0.4850855768,
0.3999102116,
-0.2518099844,
0.1851270497,
-1.2544596195,
0.849552989,
-0.6321723461,
0.5541568995,
-0.2253054082,
0.289863199,
-0.4215580225,
-0.6654688716,
-0.7308793068,
-0.3813494742,
0.1482677013,
0.1644191295,
-0.3360840678,
0.1766949445,
0.1319239736,
0.2723903358,
-0.5848284364,
0.1745586544,
-0.491068244,
0.0349203274,
0.3046580553,
0.2259587646,
-0.0958409384,
-0.1809866428,
-0.5902826786,
-0.2719666064,
-0.1958276629,
0.0693126395,
-0.05732565,
0.5806271434,
-0.0125046102,
0.2643300891,
0.0374964625,
0.5589594245,
0.3149864972,
0.3545737565,
0.3202139437,
-0.050639838,
-0.2164564431,
0.2486957163,
0.4724132717,
0.2134908438,
0.0566362254,
-0.3047688305,
-0.0000209484,
0.3909312189,
0.335437566,
-1.0427058935,
0.0119545488,
0.5795876384,
-0.3415473402,
-0.2208712399,
-0.085104458,
-0.5722626448,
-0.2322975248,
-0.5613939166,
0.4913670421,
-0.5809141994,
-0.4842282534,
0.5412536263,
-0.1011450738,
0.2136985064,
0.26744169,
-0.4217655957,
0.5080130696,
0.8433751464,
1.0444151163,
-0.43753317,
-0.0786995813,
-0.5475484133,
-0.4532176554,
-0.7562935352,
0.1865487248,
-0.2516463399,
-0.3199671805,
-0.3111101389,
-0.1263525784,
-0.0657460541,
-0.1677193195,
0.4665602744,
-0.4829267561,
-0.0751583651,
0.23584117,
-0.6651595235,
0.1726278365,
0.0481977053,
-0.4897660315,
0.9831326008,
0.0345678888,
-0.3076600134,
-0.2060833722,
-0.7696348429,
-0.338347435,
0.2215234488,
-0.0300083552,
-0.2371067256,
0.4967354834,
0.0192362461,
0.7102241516,
-0.1331195086,
0.6314939857,
-0.3384459615,
-0.5874007344,
-0.0611575916,
-0.4284854531,
0.8548509479,
0.0993777961,
-0.4613105059,
0.0685352907,
-0.8554846048,
-0.0032522022,
0.3191412389,
-0.4238911271,
-0.28236866,
-0.0383053347,
-0.2105692774,
0.1866602302,
0.1719188541,
-0.9488285184,
0.1288731843,
-0.6374461055,
0.3913007677,
0.7804899812,
0.0080854241,
0.6391949058,
0.3312086463,
0.4745319784,
0.0861691758,
0.2551106215,
0.165092811,
-0.1759959161,
-0.8318961263,
0.0579472333,
0.4586222172,
0.4756780267,
-1.179407835,
0.546187222,
-0.9736953378,
-0.751416862,
-0.1379996985,
-0.3988126814,
0.2463994622,
0.6287524104,
0.2647482455,
-0.1532490402,
-0.288105011,
-0.9612996578,
-0.0427585989,
-0.1351636797,
-0.2364163846,
0.042495437,
0.2602717578,
0.1727663428,
0.6393300891,
-0.2394817024,
0.3818152249,
-0.1613807082,
-0.0084035872,
0.8003361225,
0.7215759158,
0.5239918232,
-0.7842906117,
-0.5014676452,
-0.0179034583,
-0.408662051,
0.0281594247,
-0.2618352473,
-0.2389708161,
-0.0598943233,
0.6159777641,
-0.6949027181,
0.5222287178,
0.5069864988,
-0.4296523631,
0.3649900258,
-0.0050389091,
-0.1969576776,
-0.8454889655,
0.2324493676,
0.2659834921,
-0.3334645927,
-1.213773489,
-0.0026404832,
0.2267633677,
-0.2489077449,
-0.447060734,
0.6076965332,
-0.1741114706,
0.1278208494,
-0.2309426218,
0.0114729665,
-0.2094893306,
0.9105800986,
0.1034524888,
0.4956595302,
0.5548030734,
-0.7841582894,
0.4172307551,
0.1127277762,
-0.1366582662,
0.360296458,
-0.6537784934,
-0.0072587882,
-0.2876374722,
0.2058150917,
-0.7541990876,
0.2669112086,
0.5056398511,
-0.5210767984,
0.3977612853,
-0.2330110073,
-0.4278993309,
-0.3754656911,
-0.1599973291,
0.1304561347,
0.3971869946,
-0.6887459159,
1.0165380239,
-0.2324712425,
-0.2764745951,
-0.4574638009,
-0.6910964251,
0.1620149016,
0.1576711982,
-0.5635198355,
0.6629644036,
-0.125043124,
-0.1087395623,
-0.1586021632,
-0.5769534111,
0.1693445295,
0.126516819,
0.1193983257,
0.2875562012,
-0.6288356185,
0.355322063,
0.1989585459,
-0.3612359762,
0.0019002409,
-0.5873051286,
0.7580484748,
-0.4842862785,
-0.135843724,
-0.3082177937,
0.4306086004,
0.6091448665,
-0.0439041667,
0.8590378165,
0.5576385856,
-0.2344208062,
-0.4109005928,
-0.1622340232,
-0.4439031184,
-0.4795025587,
0.491694212,
-0.3564974964,
-0.8506830931,
0.2324427217,
-0.4497435987,
0.0870990455,
0.4783990383,
0.439203769,
-0.0541074052,
0.6853897572,
0.4694084227,
0.109401837,
0.5234642029,
-0.1738779992,
0.3372295797,
-0.34493801,
-0.0610376298,
-0.4217002392,
-0.4818010926,
-0.3459773064,
-0.6317261457,
0.3200686872,
0.0945830122,
-0.481716156,
0.382711798,
-0.4225004911,
0.3756813705,
0.3735245168,
0.3698234856,
-0.0496515669,
0.4886944592,
-0.3947132826,
-0.111677736,
-0.8751001954,
-0.0171527639,
0.8033283353,
0.5034597516,
0.4473004043,
0.1884204447,
0.3648174703,
0.1639492065,
0.1936544776,
-0.72435987,
0.7044864893,
-0.5979852676,
-0.216193527,
-0.5186978579,
-0.7094332576,
-0.70532161,
0.4828854799,
-0.120410189,
-0.7665935755,
0.5009023547,
0.0279479548,
-0.3035613894,
0.3349531293,
-0.5061171651,
0.5962907076,
-0.4085352719,
-0.4385044575,
-0.3267459571,
-0.8259204626,
0.0880561322,
-0.0619996488,
-0.2034416199,
-0.1806253344,
-0.0784031525,
0.4802927673,
-0.6265821457,
0.7397497296,
-0.4881386459,
0.0086725,
-0.2482012659,
0.3039523065,
0.3878103495,
-0.2064943016,
-0.3446679115,
0.4107363522,
-0.5049765706,
-0.5160467029,
-0.72577703,
0.6266925931,
-0.5749440193,
-0.4672054648,
-0.2454248667,
-0.2413490862,
-0.4002101421,
0.3514657915,
-0.1902509481,
0.5028990507,
-0.09966214,
0.4030135274,
0.7636840343,
0.1035294309,
0.5328809619,
0.4239373207,
-0.2439000756,
-0.1691499352,
0.8099083304,
-0.2350912094,
0.3126992285,
0.3728608489,
0.3901690245,
-0.196236819,
-0.7133559585,
-0.5318673849,
0.2614015043,
-0.7264668941,
0.0656728745,
-0.4016764164,
-0.3638427258,
-0.0257939752,
-0.0571291596,
-0.7614768147,
-0.7250820994,
-0.0443803594,
-0.0905694216,
0.4122592509,
0.0950841755,
-0.2043231428,
0.5226053596,
-0.7106066942,
0.4055175185,
0.1317626685,
0.7227858305,
0.0457410105,
-0.4877406657,
-0.2233027518,
-0.1728409827,
0.1679167747,
-0.6791869998,
0.0556539707,
0.2006013244,
0.5150172114,
0.1206797287,
-0.0041360836,
0.4595442712,
-0.6461400986,
0.522174418,
0.287902981,
-0.9965518117,
0.1637021303,
-0.3616996109,
0.4611801505,
0.3498446047,
0.3957829475,
-0.5215987563,
-0.0184973553,
-0.4699694812,
-0.7690702677,
0.7418811321,
0.702306211,
0.2639207542,
0.0737091303,
0.5874069929,
-0.1544820964,
0.1666087806,
-0.3302092254,
-0.5491738319,
-0.3671715856,
-0.0939933211,
-0.0130424704,
0.0255704354,
0.2079666853,
-0.4204287231,
0.777474165,
-0.0671946779,
0.3788007796,
0.26072824,
0.0858522281,
-0.1667676419,
0.0475837588,
0.6600204706,
0.6449493766,
-0.2151163369,
-0.1341903061,
0.1527282,
-0.5156730413,
0.2092923969,
0.3718319833,
0.1124324501,
0.4454306364,
-0.0150109064,
1.0054787397,
0.3518660665,
-0.2388883084,
0.458560437,
-0.342876792,
-0.3509598076,
-0.2711449265,
0.0157411266,
0.3716118038,
0.3607569635,
0.6232056618,
0.336974889,
-0.3496898413,
0.1541646123,
0.0684706941,
-0.0282161199,
-0.2500729859,
-0.0503928177,
0.3989685178,
0.316156745,
-0.4708120227,
0.620405376,
0.124869369,
-0.6299455166,
0.696713388,
0.4085526168,
0.9123346806,
-0.5449535847,
0.1074954942,
0.4563142359,
0.2681759,
0.0201514587,
0.438261658,
-0.1616589725,
-0.6929706335,
-0.5106822252,
-0.8278439641,
-0.2174129933,
0.0829510316,
-0.5634646416,
-0.1042498946,
-0.6849941015,
-0.2116384953,
0.3638256788,
-0.2283743322,
-0.5254152417,
0.1407806724,
0.1520982236,
0.9165334702,
-0.6097269654,
0.6839277148,
0.3862649798,
0.2273419499,
-0.5570886135,
-0.1066811532,
-0.3319977224,
-0.5822213888,
0.556917727,
0.0300364271,
-0.5129896402,
0.0704550222,
-0.6711692214,
-0.6725453734,
0.8120883703,
0.485214591,
-0.8515694141,
-0.0983271077,
0.1844386309,
0.678696394,
-0.201288715,
-0.381564796,
0.6505188346,
0.4216361642,
-0.0456163064,
-0.6799958348,
-0.0689117461,
-0.4582607746,
0.5722139478,
0.4404539168,
-0.3579020798,
0.9748030901,
0.2875857353,
-0.3033332229,
0.008702727,
0.7115097046,
0.253801614,
-0.1581863761,
0.8268303871,
0.3324315548,
0.3684465289,
-0.0480394661,
0.8287140727,
-0.2848512828,
0.3064396977,
0.911863327,
0.0875917226,
0.9305436015,
0.7488248348,
-0.3125769198,
0.4182413816,
0.3093725741,
-0.1645077318,
0.2327774465,
0.4107096493,
-0.1735006422,
-0.7682375908,
0.1812165231,
-0.1838084906,
0.3916454613,
0.5303535461,
-0.2878569961,
-0.4724008441,
0.0287086349,
-0.027796194,
0.1883607656,
-0.4492165148,
0.3359606266,
0.2903801203,
-0.4116091728,
0.6185295582,
0.1822268218,
0.4807969928,
-0.7018154263,
-0.0236655511,
-0.2096447051,
0.2941181958,
0.1308060735,
-0.4484731853,
0.1087015644,
-0.0311114974,
-0.2410296649,
-0.1073998138,
0.6405102611,
-0.3385695517,
-0.8292001486,
0.4106834233,
0.5487742424,
0.1636020988,
-0.0118337208,
-0.6288838983,
0.0265149567,
-0.120728001,
-0.2994016707,
-0.0468531549,
0.1183666289,
0.0978419185,
0.6448784471,
0.6445760131,
0.129705891,
0.2106560767,
-0.0584466383,
0.6932423115,
-0.5566905737,
-0.7581723332,
-0.9326546192,
0.4594200253,
-0.2327498794,
0.0191026423,
0.4909676015,
0.2611896396,
0.482441932,
-0.2605943978,
0.5400511622,
0.2038156986,
0.5743368864,
-0.518896997,
0.8206906319,
-0.5134158731,
0.0200446732,
0.0482215099,
-0.9424795508,
-0.3120086193,
0.4471315444,
-0.0703495666,
-0.0214965362,
0.4919208586,
0.4121359587,
-0.2250573486,
0.0693935454,
0.3561557531,
0.3946714103,
0.2762940526,
0.5764599442,
0.4374870062,
-0.3047492802,
0.5509070754,
-0.54310745,
0.0115965512,
-0.1733004153,
-1.0263986588,
-0.7194209695,
-0.4224652052,
-0.3286024332,
-0.2682487071,
0.1579757482,
0.9621968269,
0.6631224751,
-0.7207443714,
-0.1455778033,
-0.3241642118,
-0.1511139274,
-0.1666547954,
-0.2008101493,
0.5155277848,
-0.1000698879,
-0.7437785268,
0.6747590899,
0.234453097,
0.0062164753,
-0.3045197725,
-0.0446172394,
-0.014184772,
0.1343153864,
0.4744373262,
0.2684547603,
-0.7679572105,
-0.2175202519,
0.0183501523,
-0.1021887064,
0.3400845826,
0.7078077197,
-0.8062573075,
0.6490998268,
0.3377701938,
0.9255239367,
0.7893432379,
-0.0556998253,
0.8344578147,
-0.8826783895,
0.0983378217,
0.5098683238,
0.2598149776,
0.2888865173,
-0.1877390593,
0.315569222,
0.1147928908,
-0.1108745933,
-0.6978701353,
0.1507952362,
-1.0950167179,
-0.5210766792,
0.8335024118,
-0.0207584724,
-0.5234575868,
-0.010124187,
0.3007794023,
0.3804113865,
-0.4368261099,
0.5265550017,
0.3799961507,
0.0584735721,
-0.2067665011,
-0.2603017986,
0.2080996782,
0.5323731303,
-0.310626477,
-0.0221602283,
0.2182643712,
0.2507073283,
0.3678772151,
0.2792193592,
0.1266819686,
0.4847342968,
0.1182073131,
0.1573003083,
-0.296998769,
-0.3085961938,
-0.8764086366,
0.2008307278,
-0.4035844505,
-0.2153393775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09263v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09263v2
|
Auto-ICL: In-Context Learning without Human Supervision
| 2023-11-15T07:37:28 | 2024-06-17T06:53:41 |
Jinghan Yang, Shuming Ma, Furu Wei
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With in-context learning ability, the performance of large language models
can be significantly boosted when provided with appropriate context. However,
existing in-context learning methods mainly rely on human-provided contexts,
such as labeled examples and explicit instructions. Writing context by humans
is labor-intensive on various tasks and limits the model to tasks manageable by
humans. To overcome these limitations, we propose Automatic In-Context Learning
framework that enables the model to autonomously generate examples and
instructions for problem-solving. With experiments across various models and
datasets, results show that model-generated contexts outperform human-annotated
contexts, including Few-Shot and Few-Shot-CoT methods, and surpass existing
self-generated context methods like Zero-CoT and Auto-CoT.
|
[
-0.4145951569,
-0.7069164515,
0.3318503201,
0.2588041425,
0.0382136516,
-0.0445944406,
-0.1883010417,
-0.6004266739,
-0.5160253644,
0.4026606083,
-0.6359727383,
-0.3703529239,
-0.138835609,
0.4657174051,
-0.5707631111,
0.9315112829,
-0.1173075065,
-0.002628111,
-0.5568028092,
0.1535167396,
-0.3520639241,
-0.6675499678,
-0.6144861579,
-0.2318058759,
0.1110695079,
0.8834636211,
0.0894963294,
0.8236633539,
0.2526807785,
0.2703365684,
0.4529455602,
0.4023917615,
-0.1742199659,
0.0647507384,
-0.0762066171,
-0.1571771652,
-0.2562659681,
0.1476779431,
0.4879948795,
0.6926475763,
-0.012080024,
0.2107061893,
0.4068476558,
0.5097520351,
-0.6792896986,
0.2649791241,
-0.6395525932,
0.1576935798,
0.012452147,
-0.0721091032,
-0.5219836235,
0.0153768091,
0.292858541,
-0.6124044061,
0.1489657611,
0.1191790625,
0.5482675433,
0.5487884283,
-0.4719136059,
-0.705979228,
-0.6374894977,
0.6844726801,
-0.7310308814,
0.0464393534,
0.4975787401,
0.3700771332,
-0.3330765963,
-0.6105850339,
-0.4797107577,
-0.3857813179,
-0.3618678451,
-0.0126804523,
0.2340203226,
0.0786245316,
0.225569129,
0.0411024392,
-0.2845897377,
0.0405779034,
-0.2598310709,
0.0879585072,
0.7737222314,
0.3248754144,
0.4894441366,
-0.1083792076,
-0.4708728492,
0.0550857149,
-0.8237705231,
0.1044759601,
-0.1140326336,
0.303028971,
-0.1918780208,
0.3374181688,
-0.337713033,
0.8805974722,
0.2863833606,
-0.0587625951,
-0.0618505813,
-0.1308172792,
-0.4233309627,
0.0842967033,
0.6178982854,
0.0620823018,
0.0825368315,
-0.4390062988,
-0.3768472075,
-0.2178790867,
0.0794861391,
-0.6643459797,
-0.2995062768,
-0.0687057599,
-0.2397596538,
-0.1893959492,
-0.0905660763,
-0.3893148005,
-0.0226791054,
-0.6956080198,
0.5947499275,
-0.386174202,
-0.0269579105,
-0.2292197794,
0.2095358074,
0.29402107,
0.257250756,
-0.7868498564,
0.5415380597,
0.1252154112,
0.6583704352,
-0.4056130052,
-0.5173306465,
-0.6275972724,
0.4747837782,
-0.4981827736,
0.6574682593,
-0.2993515432,
-0.3979529738,
-0.2227874249,
-0.135753423,
-0.0126389926,
-0.527771771,
-0.0646076724,
-0.1511259824,
0.3817440271,
-0.2343651205,
-0.8595436811,
-0.0846974179,
-0.0486650541,
-0.2247477174,
1.0970067978,
0.3098518848,
-0.3786244988,
0.5551772118,
-1.1346734762,
-0.6271792054,
0.3531963229,
-0.3232595026,
-0.1934279948,
-0.0947634056,
0.2215927988,
0.7570025325,
-0.1819097996,
0.6303930283,
-0.0355424471,
-0.2998045385,
0.0708991364,
-0.2901285887,
0.9935377836,
0.2348965406,
-1.0030617714,
0.0590161495,
-0.5829982758,
-0.1669562608,
0.1415937543,
-0.2975351214,
-0.2622850537,
0.0637618378,
0.0067999908,
0.6198985577,
0.0404948965,
-0.5353799462,
0.1231803745,
-0.5032021403,
0.3638583422,
0.5346173048,
-0.0886364505,
0.6045657992,
-0.1950892955,
0.3316925168,
0.1106766611,
0.1062192544,
-0.4166650176,
-0.124960281,
-0.7738137841,
-0.2709967196,
-0.1473947465,
0.5446905494,
-0.7431805134,
0.4870252311,
0.2753835022,
-0.3972961009,
-0.3132025898,
0.5037833452,
0.817951262,
1.0496479273,
0.5458916426,
-0.1815623045,
-0.5408830643,
-0.8646495342,
-0.121759437,
0.0281819571,
0.1860105544,
0.5916625261,
0.5716757178,
-0.2900979519,
1.3790950775,
-0.2967651188,
-0.5018575191,
-0.2076029181,
0.4025664926,
-0.4174682498,
0.892721355,
0.4873321652,
-0.7473307848,
-0.8678441644,
-0.2524455488,
-1.1926066875,
-0.3333714604,
-0.1216221228,
-0.0434734561,
0.6012370586,
1.120290637,
-0.1852660775,
0.6594017744,
0.128561303,
-0.2791168392,
0.4513175488,
-0.4645189941,
-0.2589197159,
-0.9490324259,
0.1312985122,
0.0871164426,
-0.3898449242,
-0.563401401,
-0.0660937801,
0.2824441195,
-0.2116690874,
-0.4836147428,
0.867741406,
-0.6546376348,
-0.0045321831,
-0.405400306,
0.043945089,
-0.015057547,
0.555000484,
0.2526907325,
0.8537259102,
0.5862115622,
-0.7645735741,
0.1672035903,
0.080040589,
-0.2574780881,
0.2549367547,
-0.4824883044,
-0.0086742621,
-0.258841753,
0.489159435,
-0.9661650062,
-0.6157387495,
0.1589022279,
-0.0539456271,
0.3336610198,
0.0007806932,
-0.6135231256,
-0.1551196426,
0.3024874032,
0.5878822803,
0.3137317002,
-0.6666778326,
0.3791856766,
0.4336467385,
0.0021175314,
-0.437435925,
-0.6867267489,
0.1837054044,
-0.3110920191,
-0.0256545823,
0.4559893012,
-0.375220418,
-0.3128980696,
0.0505305342,
0.3468822837,
-0.2127849609,
0.3165045381,
0.3857323527,
0.193747893,
0.0323431231,
0.4223169684,
0.1206264496,
-0.0735799521,
0.025982162,
-0.342559129,
0.1128366441,
-0.3744930029,
-0.3156102002,
-0.5743305087,
0.6828749776,
0.5477868915,
-0.2300777435,
0.4289268851,
0.2885772586,
-0.4582007825,
-0.5125368834,
-0.3782287538,
-0.216965571,
-0.5044825673,
0.1703817695,
-0.2383654714,
-0.6213799715,
0.1314351708,
0.0553380288,
0.1698298007,
0.2385031581,
0.5299623609,
-0.3297789693,
1.1465351582,
0.8648745418,
-0.1626612395,
0.4543522596,
-0.2464662045,
0.224553898,
-0.6442885399,
-0.113007322,
-0.0450787321,
0.0039414726,
-0.1494326442,
0.0949268788,
0.6166431308,
0.0812647641,
-0.4031803012,
0.5676684976,
-0.8493563533,
0.6112239361,
0.6812733412,
-0.03094442,
0.1861911863,
-0.3318276405,
-0.3033810258,
0.1963499784,
-1.033816576,
-0.4164228439,
0.9726659656,
-0.0241322462,
0.4784852862,
-0.1739942729,
0.8635172248,
0.3917590976,
0.7266611457,
-0.5646088719,
0.4552764893,
0.0670827851,
-0.6931913495,
-0.4787810445,
-0.1386633813,
-0.6431765556,
0.0518892296,
-0.1379712224,
-0.6862325072,
0.1279835254,
0.4754138589,
-0.5337659717,
0.1025654078,
-1.0275381804,
0.8642638922,
-0.3849024177,
-0.4625626504,
0.1000227779,
-0.7112859488,
0.2800306678,
-0.0015499789,
0.4052596688,
0.0527244471,
-0.0331475884,
0.4698479474,
-0.3550495505,
1.269782424,
-0.3723915219,
-0.1302247941,
0.5123503208,
0.3325879276,
0.4620039165,
0.1012034491,
0.0567869246,
-0.3976902664,
-0.0863778517,
-0.2890003622,
-0.4911230206,
0.563408792,
-0.6168894768,
-0.4688268304,
-0.2411727607,
-0.8126165867,
-0.1099639237,
0.175414294,
0.5713778138,
0.948792398,
0.0170181114,
-0.0221306533,
0.5101598501,
-0.204506278,
1.0279535055,
0.5410366058,
-0.1011736467,
-0.0420337804,
0.8707278967,
0.1737502515,
0.135458827,
0.139457494,
0.1126750931,
-0.2747951746,
-0.2139663398,
-0.7932628989,
-0.0480167046,
-0.9393008947,
-0.3557744324,
-0.6656131744,
-0.2108041048,
-0.2552576363,
-0.7100561857,
-0.2776814401,
0.0160231031,
-0.430998534,
0.1988305449,
0.0137927337,
0.9036867023,
-0.0612646155,
0.2151543498,
-0.5263138413,
0.1203417405,
0.4601274729,
0.1665937603,
0.2368607968,
-0.2940174639,
-0.4527769089,
-0.0533997156,
-0.268006593,
-0.6530358791,
0.5956126451,
0.4300254285,
0.4563762844,
0.3107330203,
0.2990578711,
0.7822155952,
-0.5048663616,
0.6746525168,
-0.1195804477,
-1.3003180027,
0.5797236562,
-0.2915198505,
0.4148028791,
0.5524929762,
0.3680053651,
-0.2898854315,
-0.5506845117,
-0.5970649123,
-0.9399976134,
0.7774015665,
0.0820839405,
0.0317649283,
-0.1686661094,
0.583748877,
0.1983157694,
0.0796245039,
-0.9955669641,
-0.0801175758,
-0.2425080687,
-0.3934309185,
-0.0171307307,
-0.0045048692,
0.0514145233,
-0.6953641176,
0.6684601903,
-0.5290492177,
0.1953615248,
0.6847336888,
-0.6825628877,
-0.3178288937,
-0.1115723103,
0.6293690801,
0.744925499,
0.0390810445,
0.0896260887,
0.4923562407,
0.1579253525,
0.1869802177,
-0.1145838648,
-0.212795794,
-0.3723901212,
0.4170885086,
0.413125515,
0.4826109111,
-1.0527861118,
0.565931499,
-0.070700489,
-0.1409717351,
-0.7604407668,
0.3076681793,
-0.0040616514,
0.1362452507,
0.6718732715,
-0.1343843341,
0.2814075649,
-0.4727457464,
0.5019987822,
0.4592739642,
-0.5546960235,
-0.1442275196,
0.6028482914,
0.1349196285,
-0.3025565147,
0.48615399,
-0.405634135,
-0.3448457122,
0.7869604826,
1.0164502859,
0.8665018678,
-0.0326281078,
0.0938193798,
0.3630090356,
-0.0351241827,
0.1076130122,
-0.0846198946,
-0.6355969906,
-0.4692565799,
-0.3555514514,
-0.4066749215,
-0.3880276084,
0.069133155,
-0.623136878,
0.1459760368,
-0.430847764,
0.3873071969,
-0.0727884993,
-0.0728482977,
-0.5819293857,
0.591871798,
0.1338972151,
0.8159715533,
-0.742171824,
1.0680963993,
0.6985365152,
-0.2711480856,
-0.7424242496,
0.1099621132,
-0.0209413413,
-0.2565619648,
0.9300860167,
0.4374716282,
-0.4469060898,
0.3885627389,
-0.9782503247,
-0.902821064,
1.1036772728,
0.188115865,
-0.2620869279,
-0.1365081966,
-0.0225310549,
0.4369224608,
-1.0379070044,
0.1195117757,
0.2558980286,
0.1509804875,
-0.2799945772,
-0.8560937047,
-0.0118641993,
-0.3200480342,
-0.2259757072,
-0.1779277176,
-0.5756875873,
0.877125442,
-0.0481660627,
-0.2343462706,
-0.2066308856,
0.6509268284,
-0.1268574744,
0.254757911,
0.5747134686,
0.1998919696,
0.3998741508,
0.3140274882,
0.9751963615,
-0.5013852119,
0.1487981677,
1.4089480639,
-0.3008413315,
0.5530504584,
0.2890155017,
0.369045943,
0.6238538027,
0.5334903002,
0.1792721897,
0.5649214983,
-0.0694871023,
-0.3346855342,
-0.4755725563,
-0.0368866734,
0.1187840104,
0.7456218004,
0.5012601018,
-0.2605492473,
-0.5139985085,
0.3354738057,
-0.0479541905,
0.2786769271,
-0.1446001083,
1.1076087952,
0.1055370122,
-0.8808970451,
0.6540036201,
-0.0645274892,
0.5720970631,
-0.3260303736,
-0.209918797,
-0.0011088203,
0.0322980545,
-0.1068016514,
-0.3727423847,
0.6286365986,
0.1197551265,
-0.21342507,
-0.2964686155,
0.703925252,
-0.5584837794,
-0.3969270587,
0.3898966312,
0.5456007123,
-0.0052695707,
0.1811937392,
-0.6154769659,
-0.6131100655,
-0.2942030728,
-0.1300594509,
0.4258681834,
0.3238404095,
-0.2135589123,
0.9281158447,
0.3589607179,
-0.3839240074,
-0.0249080099,
-0.6425204873,
0.7913452387,
-0.5688579082,
-0.5510876179,
-0.9440466762,
0.4610545039,
-0.0783024877,
-0.4310129881,
0.637483418,
0.5347360969,
1.1574193239,
0.0132559696,
1.1216806173,
-0.3234460056,
0.385073483,
-0.3158821464,
0.7656966448,
-0.7011061907,
0.003187648,
-0.3174535334,
-0.3799485266,
-0.4832306802,
0.5886158943,
-0.3809150755,
-0.1051603183,
0.501162529,
0.7420736551,
-0.3124290407,
-0.1893529147,
0.3428379893,
-0.162494272,
0.2517799735,
0.5388069749,
0.6152697206,
-0.1471776515,
0.2603470385,
-0.5261152387,
-0.321044147,
-0.2759347856,
-1.1183751822,
-1.1317507029,
-1.1222726107,
-0.1013050526,
0.0781819299,
-0.1141701192,
1.521319747,
1.1658364534,
-0.7739951611,
-0.5240286589,
-0.5606922507,
-0.0866456404,
-0.2758386731,
-0.2517284751,
0.4507359266,
-1.0070524216,
-0.7160112262,
0.7269718051,
0.2815358341,
0.2659676373,
-0.3191634417,
-0.1669300646,
-0.2128235102,
0.0740309134,
0.5838017464,
0.4325856864,
-0.6950576901,
-0.1217511818,
-0.2650911212,
-0.3493591249,
0.0694622099,
0.8729835153,
-1.0514383316,
0.4988501072,
0.0825388655,
0.6433761716,
0.3476727307,
0.0061722477,
0.8834788799,
-0.8746886253,
0.21406506,
0.248481974,
0.202559486,
0.3551023006,
-0.6920101643,
0.2494242936,
0.0419074968,
-0.6041140556,
-0.6527484059,
0.3378546238,
-0.3445528746,
-0.6249882579,
0.8830092549,
-0.3722224832,
-0.2719071805,
-0.415533185,
-0.2388281375,
0.5107909441,
-0.2427334934,
1.0799146891,
0.3842789531,
-0.4429494143,
-0.1094170436,
-0.5363135934,
1.1014617682,
0.4083546698,
-0.9682779908,
0.1584650427,
0.4139097631,
0.2378026694,
-0.2411132604,
0.4915653765,
0.0875194296,
0.351546973,
-0.3637208045,
0.0995570347,
-0.3715364337,
-0.6571392417,
-0.174764201,
0.199619323,
-0.1050857082,
0.1583117247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08734v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08734v1
|
Thread of Thought Unraveling Chaotic Contexts
| 2023-11-15T06:54:44 | 2023-11-15T06:54:44 |
Yucheng Zhou, Xiubo Geng, Tao Shen, Chongyang Tao, Guodong Long, Jian-Guang Lou, Jianbing Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have ushered in a transformative era in the
field of natural language processing, excelling in tasks related to text
comprehension and generation. Nevertheless, they encounter difficulties when
confronted with chaotic contexts (e.g., distractors rather than long irrelevant
context), leading to the inadvertent omission of certain details within the
chaotic context. In response to these challenges, we introduce the "Thread of
Thought" (ThoT) strategy, which draws inspiration from human cognitive
processes. ThoT systematically segments and analyzes extended contexts while
adeptly selecting pertinent information. This strategy serves as a versatile
"plug-and-play" module, seamlessly integrating with various LLMs and prompting
techniques. In the experiments, we utilize the PopQA and EntityQ datasets, as
well as a Multi-Turn Conversation Response dataset (MTCR) we collected, to
illustrate that ThoT significantly improves reasoning performance compared to
other prompting techniques.
|
[
-0.7015112638,
-1.3046607971,
0.749175787,
0.1000610143,
-0.6462347507,
0.1656240672,
-0.2931975126,
-0.4365693331,
0.1768867671,
0.4539958835,
-0.9907079935,
0.0417020842,
-0.2601118684,
0.1574788392,
-0.3973343074,
1.198699832,
-0.0581979677,
-0.216878742,
-0.099459447,
0.0178631302,
-0.6733103991,
-0.4026759565,
-0.6730053425,
-0.4127852023,
0.6212323308,
0.2389334738,
0.4182947278,
0.5013190508,
0.3696382642,
0.3565453887,
-0.1710251719,
0.6615951061,
-0.5756809711,
0.7557148337,
-0.3211449981,
-0.4085416794,
-0.2352131754,
-0.0294309352,
0.4163811803,
0.5390552878,
-0.2118203789,
0.0377969369,
0.2102841437,
0.671995759,
-0.4308295548,
-0.0441886969,
-0.8514204621,
-0.0193269327,
-0.3405590057,
-0.6511214972,
-0.0452308431,
-0.2211205363,
0.4819847643,
-0.4497076273,
-0.0050597191,
0.2636644542,
0.5395293832,
0.3472417593,
-0.4519459307,
-0.4894384146,
-0.9655770659,
0.7605723143,
-0.3883017898,
0.2742267847,
0.2915530801,
-0.09211611,
-0.3991850615,
-0.5325216055,
-0.8530784249,
0.3267431259,
0.3466184437,
0.3073396385,
-0.0355575308,
-0.0759732574,
0.1975436062,
0.3674620986,
-0.209918797,
-0.4309455454,
-0.3375640213,
-0.072649397,
0.2703450322,
0.4351293743,
0.1604745984,
-0.1926726401,
-0.2947820425,
0.1533965915,
-0.3316892087,
-0.0164411031,
0.0038132989,
0.1868146062,
0.0352019295,
0.5897300243,
0.1020369008,
0.6536682844,
0.2926898599,
-0.10708303,
-0.2494047582,
-0.2525381744,
-0.3833093047,
-0.2192416489,
0.6886386871,
0.2730674446,
0.0924720392,
-0.2210518569,
-0.3719720244,
-0.1900158226,
0.567021966,
-0.5461286902,
-0.3635545373,
0.2646591067,
-0.1697656214,
-0.1794778705,
-0.2442570478,
-0.8422180414,
-0.5574454665,
-0.5741631985,
0.3073132634,
-0.5579707623,
-0.1235788614,
-0.0056734416,
-0.0794442818,
-0.0300338268,
0.5094223022,
-0.621307075,
0.1573360562,
0.6747486591,
0.8260910511,
-0.252204299,
-0.093887046,
-0.1995376647,
0.1622375697,
-0.4080438018,
1.0303014517,
-0.5034289956,
-0.3588948548,
-0.0971182957,
-0.3055127859,
-0.0914902836,
-0.3851075768,
0.7096544504,
-0.752037704,
0.6017332077,
-0.6082874537,
-0.5917685032,
-0.3048924208,
0.5232751369,
-0.4958387911,
1.0362588167,
-0.0902487934,
-1.0575829744,
0.2555398643,
-0.7117943168,
-0.4884850383,
0.074103117,
-0.3510351181,
-0.1324543059,
0.299241364,
0.3658418655,
0.3072259724,
-0.4552705586,
0.3327051997,
-0.3234484792,
-0.2654351592,
0.4918733835,
-0.5276556015,
0.7219432592,
0.4270471931,
-0.3365132511,
0.0910850018,
-0.3918053508,
0.0682599843,
0.2241177559,
-0.4036457241,
-0.5704825521,
0.1155033112,
-0.028904859,
0.3694052398,
-0.1004787236,
-0.3308566213,
0.2843214273,
-0.5492914915,
0.7615382671,
0.9294049144,
0.2639703155,
0.3166319132,
-0.4988872111,
0.3496170044,
0.2863082588,
-0.1020622998,
-0.3222497106,
-0.4378574789,
-0.9593796134,
-0.2585182786,
-0.2618408203,
0.4548600316,
-1.0748443604,
0.2793162465,
-0.0310436096,
-0.2629743218,
-0.4173857868,
0.0624999367,
0.1314530522,
0.6019471288,
0.236658603,
-0.2453394681,
-0.7116166353,
-0.5781670809,
-0.3211635351,
-0.2204600126,
0.1111221462,
0.3417236507,
0.4228590727,
-0.3644169271,
1.2212916613,
-0.4886368215,
0.0096606379,
-0.2825115025,
0.1945919991,
0.1462280303,
0.3361665606,
-0.0018249599,
-0.5939994454,
-0.0249317475,
-0.1994859576,
-0.5653489232,
-0.0695486218,
-0.3928987086,
-0.4008839726,
0.1002277508,
0.5316305161,
-0.7630967498,
0.293556422,
0.166480571,
-0.0832699835,
0.6539981365,
-0.0793078318,
0.1873847544,
-1.3542230129,
0.0156091964,
-0.2048825175,
-0.2733699083,
-0.6028613448,
-0.075395599,
-0.1141294539,
0.0650737211,
-0.1878442764,
0.4351100624,
-0.3762528002,
0.3778006434,
-0.4111558795,
0.3162265122,
-0.0240815468,
0.5153800249,
-0.1811825633,
0.9795224667,
0.4161321819,
-0.611977458,
0.1771682203,
0.1348154843,
-0.5037759542,
0.4212597311,
-0.3398292959,
0.6439643502,
-0.3420824409,
0.4593209028,
-0.9919292927,
-0.3402033448,
0.3325417638,
0.067649357,
0.1120330915,
0.3071932495,
-0.637952745,
-0.6064163446,
-0.253801167,
0.7158794999,
0.2603755295,
-0.3551653326,
0.408991456,
0.6598466039,
-0.1436036676,
-0.246886313,
-0.6893008351,
0.1220556051,
-0.4934153259,
-0.3042914271,
0.2567342818,
-0.3043556213,
-0.4649646878,
-0.3036931753,
-0.2085124105,
-0.2814993262,
0.0614538975,
0.1506494135,
0.263402313,
-0.1436298639,
0.4217067957,
-0.0484029502,
0.1923731714,
0.2356451452,
-0.6222980022,
0.7690567374,
-0.1508862078,
-0.3391164541,
-0.4054124653,
0.4722127914,
0.5520089269,
-0.0688410923,
0.4701380432,
0.2857118845,
-0.3269786835,
-0.4404218495,
-0.6860749125,
-0.2975204289,
-0.5118240714,
0.2963505685,
-0.130911842,
-1.1504483223,
0.4752060771,
-0.1375103146,
0.272236079,
-0.0215027761,
0.8886546493,
-0.4975120723,
0.9569758177,
0.6068715453,
-0.3288592696,
0.6755657196,
0.0897578672,
0.7413960099,
-0.8366504312,
0.023396926,
-0.0807178468,
-0.432954818,
-0.3503924906,
-0.7165794969,
0.4622724652,
0.2421980202,
-0.1230887696,
0.0567612574,
-0.4694568813,
0.6347796917,
0.4229799509,
0.2156670988,
0.3128913641,
-0.2071496099,
-0.3514583409,
0.0072192433,
-0.7244184017,
-0.570674777,
0.8035517335,
0.1096607298,
0.5495055914,
-0.0132084833,
0.6397012472,
0.0491159521,
0.3606535196,
-0.8468447328,
0.5946839452,
0.4511560798,
-0.7259232402,
-0.1872335821,
-0.3024675548,
-1.0521072149,
0.1898884773,
-0.0630121157,
-1.0447888374,
-0.1597789377,
0.2013835162,
-0.6317261457,
0.4360401928,
-0.4989147782,
0.2960274816,
0.0435762256,
-0.231363371,
-0.2798724473,
-0.3722181618,
0.7139581442,
-0.2829850316,
0.2753530741,
0.1466687769,
0.078859143,
0.6806613207,
-0.2058927119,
0.76137501,
0.5006602407,
-0.3211690784,
0.7604579926,
0.1892654747,
0.4799073935,
0.1049540341,
0.0970754996,
-0.2044642121,
-0.1563219726,
-0.1350983828,
-0.5888914466,
0.5584961176,
-0.5128406882,
-0.8239074349,
-0.1198415905,
-0.9976981282,
-0.4186999202,
0.1301721781,
0.4496148825,
0.5736522079,
-0.078563109,
-0.1230669394,
0.7949782014,
-0.0388846844,
0.6302300692,
0.0829990655,
-0.3865701258,
-0.1887831092,
0.6598764658,
-0.0128299985,
0.0920458734,
0.1705555171,
0.174954623,
-0.1451877356,
-0.2526214421,
-0.1852992177,
0.0684216917,
-0.6766061187,
-0.2072271705,
-0.9146004915,
-0.2276873738,
-0.1791789532,
0.0995107964,
-0.3255285025,
-0.1750093102,
-0.2106297016,
0.0125020752,
0.1816612929,
0.7845601439,
0.3344348669,
0.0533145741,
-0.6542921066,
0.032055568,
0.5657436848,
0.2063151151,
0.448402673,
-0.3692293763,
-0.3124799728,
0.0430634059,
-0.7949157953,
-0.8828622103,
0.3084302545,
-0.1170934141,
0.2787694633,
0.5579653978,
0.238607794,
1.0696597099,
-0.6991289854,
0.8087393045,
0.0834800079,
-0.8334450126,
0.5955049992,
-0.6063768864,
0.676661253,
0.342227608,
0.0019914163,
-0.7492188215,
-0.8167225718,
-0.5229892135,
-0.7863467932,
0.6095080376,
0.4950558841,
0.1815703809,
-0.3649201691,
0.3775188625,
0.0363701805,
0.1331909597,
-0.5372257829,
-0.1869963109,
0.0785410702,
0.0180433169,
0.2489256114,
-0.1777062118,
-0.3287525475,
-0.3381296396,
0.33626917,
-0.0962062329,
0.6325374246,
0.4312831461,
0.0276513677,
-0.4617375731,
0.3809714019,
0.8715563416,
0.6015049219,
0.144730255,
0.338455081,
0.2809821665,
-0.4227068126,
-0.2448392659,
-0.364477098,
-0.0202072524,
-0.3067084849,
0.4298388064,
0.4710182548,
0.1366673112,
-0.7433102727,
0.0486451574,
-0.1182730049,
-0.0901937336,
0.0882422403,
0.1935544014,
0.1563751698,
0.6637536287,
0.3768217266,
0.3485390544,
0.1506575495,
-0.7913470864,
0.330578804,
0.3208427429,
-0.6017907262,
-0.5936458707,
0.3278297186,
0.2119920552,
-0.512116015,
0.5473822355,
-0.1857710928,
-0.9895483255,
0.2717944682,
0.6197564006,
1.0241976976,
0.0562989973,
0.0065667378,
0.1772759557,
0.1852508485,
-0.0966177359,
0.4790862501,
-0.3256212473,
-0.9133067727,
-0.5074596405,
-0.2847132385,
-0.1758078188,
0.4107408524,
-0.4426752627,
0.0116316611,
-0.4611276388,
-0.3595622182,
-0.201658383,
-0.0291309133,
-0.6334209442,
-0.0072434051,
0.3071881235,
0.7093702555,
-0.3740682006,
0.9522932768,
0.6763164997,
0.0364323929,
-0.7782407403,
0.6061004996,
0.4483151138,
-0.5738787055,
0.409237653,
0.1774445325,
-0.1979254931,
-0.0352650955,
-0.6254705787,
-0.715500474,
0.7100413442,
0.0980401933,
-0.4855169058,
0.0854422674,
-0.1913912445,
0.576187551,
-0.2297696769,
0.1728799641,
0.6366974711,
0.3424399197,
0.0850580186,
-0.820881784,
-0.0277764071,
-0.2302778512,
-0.2203732431,
0.4256725907,
-0.5597670078,
0.8827419281,
-0.2920047641,
-0.4875506759,
-0.0779312402,
0.7151523232,
0.3108093143,
0.2473029345,
0.653950572,
0.2256419659,
1.0740849972,
0.1180579364,
0.8485561013,
-0.1334008127,
0.2763257325,
1.2068189383,
-0.1799617857,
0.6995619535,
0.8650794625,
0.0729594305,
0.309436202,
0.6756488085,
0.5104011893,
0.554500401,
0.084686242,
-0.2948530316,
-0.393358171,
-0.099916935,
-0.0107307117,
0.4298117757,
0.4061957002,
0.0182008781,
-0.2899337411,
-0.0498524681,
0.051091969,
0.0308486782,
-0.1132709831,
0.897842288,
0.2651821077,
-1.0732332468,
0.3333435357,
-0.2843534648,
0.5506215692,
-0.1726321876,
0.1094219834,
-0.175128594,
0.1158527061,
0.2629374266,
-0.8239932656,
0.4671781361,
0.0766568258,
-0.3418946564,
-0.3938877285,
0.6137402654,
-0.4506136179,
-0.2971211374,
0.0088090757,
0.7369447947,
-0.0881220922,
-0.1397874653,
-0.84377563,
-0.0962844789,
0.0571229085,
-0.4770708382,
0.1804990023,
1.1634261608,
-0.273909241,
0.9387702942,
0.6205096841,
-0.0845420286,
-0.2341759056,
-0.0476424359,
1.2474310398,
-0.8063975573,
-0.5999589562,
-1.1080157757,
0.3545063436,
-0.1977101862,
-0.7053689361,
0.5487929583,
0.2929686904,
0.563139379,
0.303794235,
0.5884436369,
-0.0531540252,
0.5289455056,
-0.4039095342,
0.5659410954,
-0.4595802724,
0.4895780385,
-0.4653360546,
-0.855686605,
-0.1166360006,
0.6028332114,
-0.3139947653,
-0.0410005413,
0.9157947898,
0.5510669947,
0.0307133757,
0.5883308649,
0.2255875021,
0.2940494716,
0.4633381069,
0.5697667003,
1.2446806431,
-0.0665579662,
0.3936333358,
-0.0319571421,
-0.1134419292,
-0.0181929544,
-0.8872488737,
-1.2405869961,
-0.7990127206,
-0.0917042419,
-0.0803753063,
-0.2409903109,
1.2526072264,
0.6135151386,
-0.679792285,
-0.2165422738,
-0.1770937443,
0.1888970286,
-0.2052922547,
-0.2144309133,
0.1634242386,
-0.7055820823,
-0.5500049591,
0.3123238981,
0.6814485788,
-0.0382183716,
-0.1855352521,
0.1650206447,
-0.2439160049,
0.488604337,
0.6123504043,
-0.158718735,
-0.9569755197,
-0.4111659825,
0.003580231,
-0.2470428348,
0.0870815217,
1.2012579441,
-0.7963686585,
0.5658771396,
0.4644398093,
0.7525574565,
0.156528607,
-0.0064959573,
0.8533258438,
-0.5785722733,
0.0735713616,
0.4817867875,
0.2393774092,
0.0487140045,
-0.2938206494,
0.1801339686,
0.144380182,
-0.6039111614,
-0.8215020299,
0.2108075619,
-0.9385322928,
-0.5702952743,
0.8772358298,
0.1671717018,
-0.3314161897,
-0.4930971265,
-0.4906646609,
0.3342080414,
-0.4163721502,
1.3761267662,
1.0676646233,
-0.1805624217,
-0.2908111215,
-0.53733778,
0.5049296021,
0.5705071092,
-0.8095331788,
0.246867761,
0.2287769318,
-0.173720181,
0.1860523373,
0.6784756184,
0.2176364213,
0.0236972291,
-0.3903882802,
-0.4170511663,
0.3311037421,
-0.1116067246,
0.0502480492,
0.0222427752,
-0.3440503478,
0.16356197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08732v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08732v1
|
Enhancing Emergency Decision-making with Knowledge Graphs and Large Language Models
| 2023-11-15T06:48:50 | 2023-11-15T06:48:50 |
Minze Chen, Zhenxiang Tao, Weitong Tang, Tingxin Qin, Rui Yang, Chunli Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Emergency management urgently requires comprehensive knowledge while having a
high possibility to go beyond individuals' cognitive scope. Therefore,
artificial intelligence(AI) supported decision-making under that circumstance
is of vital importance. Recent emerging large language models (LLM) provide a
new direction for enhancing targeted machine intelligence. However, the
utilization of LLM directly would inevitably introduce unreliable output for
its inherent issue of hallucination and poor reasoning skills. In this work, we
develop a system called Enhancing Emergency decision-making with Knowledge
Graph and LLM (E-KELL), which provides evidence-based decision-making in
various emergency stages. The study constructs a structured emergency knowledge
graph and guides LLMs to reason over it via a prompt chain. In real-world
evaluations, E-KELL receives scores of 9.06, 9.09, 9.03, and 9.09 in
comprehensibility, accuracy, conciseness, and instructiveness from a group of
emergency commanders and firefighters, demonstrating a significant improvement
across various situations compared to baseline models. This work introduces a
novel approach to providing reliable emergency decision support.
|
[
-0.1035962105,
-0.9566557407,
1.1054056883,
0.3202099204,
0.1074279845,
0.1773188114,
-0.1513473392,
-0.521944046,
0.2495371252,
0.3776627481,
-0.2128418088,
-0.6124304533,
-0.4894704223,
0.331928879,
-0.2114386559,
0.5899511576,
0.0423522294,
-0.0474087,
0.0619466528,
0.1420603544,
-0.564068675,
-0.4942525625,
-1.1500452757,
-0.5328103304,
0.523734808,
0.5643161535,
0.83238554,
0.2461285889,
0.3124130964,
0.3462993503,
0.180563122,
0.2237483561,
-0.44539994,
0.1124590039,
0.006978868,
-0.0943786204,
-0.65327245,
-0.6283528805,
0.3615353405,
0.5145005584,
-0.3371343911,
-0.2672807872,
-0.0436892435,
0.7983310819,
-0.5517543554,
0.5012586117,
-0.6615669131,
-0.0405421555,
0.4426169991,
-0.2131744325,
-0.6967465878,
-0.3678975403,
0.500947237,
-0.8304357529,
-0.3611446917,
0.5558797121,
0.4318272769,
0.4409933686,
-0.4256264567,
-0.2933383286,
-0.6813592315,
0.1829464138,
-0.6549479961,
0.6858355999,
0.5555702448,
0.4197003245,
-0.2910781801,
-0.7411413193,
-0.5821617842,
-0.1629934609,
-0.0686032325,
0.096287705,
-0.0939294249,
0.4129072726,
0.1280270219,
-0.5199292898,
-0.320998013,
0.2661297321,
-0.0644721687,
-0.2770716846,
0.8482287526,
0.3572184443,
0.3462410569,
-0.3393853009,
-0.1939070821,
-0.0351125784,
-0.5837647915,
-0.1959649622,
0.3216166496,
0.275093168,
0.0445422418,
0.4716932178,
-0.3990665972,
0.6329467297,
-0.0078650229,
-0.2643403113,
0.2320588678,
0.1390670091,
-0.6069197059,
0.5930492282,
0.637403667,
0.8267960548,
0.2321853042,
-0.3043738604,
-0.2460062504,
-0.2884272933,
0.2944098413,
-0.6928631067,
-0.4935016632,
0.152100876,
-0.474093169,
-0.3418749273,
-0.282145083,
-0.8135142922,
-0.7607303858,
-0.3606571555,
0.7139517665,
-0.7708296776,
-0.3664501309,
0.1209492683,
-0.075698249,
-0.3088564277,
0.8334241509,
-0.4501706958,
0.0318015553,
0.2017404884,
0.6867171526,
0.2724283338,
-0.03350484,
-0.1569323987,
0.2535950541,
-0.2145375907,
0.8811017275,
-0.5880886912,
-0.3158888817,
-0.0474872515,
0.0081068501,
-0.1432864219,
-0.3959396183,
1.0312988758,
-0.5865004063,
-0.1587091386,
-0.1555895656,
-0.5951622725,
-0.6667981744,
0.3220201433,
-0.4478251934,
0.7695944309,
0.0473972969,
-0.3717856705,
0.4494656622,
-0.542401433,
-0.5327913165,
0.1071549281,
-0.2986832261,
-0.3784756362,
-0.2927723527,
0.5360904336,
0.5949499607,
-0.2307556272,
0.3504374623,
-0.4617769718,
0.1224094555,
-0.0911433324,
-0.1673656106,
0.4357781708,
0.1280260086,
-0.1846395433,
0.2171034813,
-0.7690131068,
0.3750971854,
0.1500063688,
-0.5485832095,
-0.4550509751,
0.4039719105,
-0.0125793209,
0.1636971384,
-0.0055650631,
-0.1267462522,
0.0207866207,
-0.0308536291,
0.315679431,
0.8609686494,
0.0261882357,
0.3005080223,
-0.4961166382,
0.144711256,
-0.1134161726,
-0.0382158235,
-0.163753584,
-0.59769243,
-0.8289658427,
0.0894937217,
0.076994881,
0.8860402107,
-0.8511183858,
0.8550980687,
-0.0790040717,
-0.286031127,
-0.2334030867,
-0.3868849576,
0.0458100587,
0.9272661209,
0.6340740919,
0.2941990495,
-0.9733276367,
-0.7143596411,
0.1041972712,
-0.4558132589,
0.0156429913,
0.5184584856,
0.2949916422,
-0.2514781356,
0.7670922279,
-0.3311464489,
0.0070651905,
-0.5890725851,
-0.1266024858,
0.0958237723,
0.2053593248,
0.2748211622,
-0.6107070446,
-0.2670552731,
0.2649537623,
-1.017606616,
-0.1412966102,
-0.3249278963,
-0.2441509366,
0.0435361601,
0.3283988535,
-0.4258983135,
0.4331968427,
-0.0570948347,
-0.6865447164,
0.6277177334,
-0.2388265878,
0.286141634,
-0.8078520894,
-0.0408779532,
0.0037861702,
-0.2033861428,
-0.8557533026,
-0.1397037655,
0.1422593296,
-0.1660297513,
-0.1354214698,
0.4915541112,
-0.2219579667,
0.0602401383,
-0.0485364497,
0.2497357279,
-0.2508320808,
0.3592401743,
0.2202581167,
0.2593273222,
0.5105737448,
-0.5620735288,
0.2846366167,
0.3045420349,
-0.3711781502,
0.4080562294,
-0.6734344959,
0.1347736716,
-0.2735711336,
0.3195644915,
-0.6357946992,
-0.5809999704,
0.2322071791,
-0.0535254106,
0.3057708144,
-0.1296040416,
-0.3851316571,
-0.5657212138,
0.2162252665,
-0.1159619689,
0.533860147,
-0.2610665858,
0.9421853423,
0.5085883141,
-0.2811039388,
-0.3342490196,
-0.2177353501,
0.3086198866,
-0.1070325226,
-0.8666589856,
0.1501495242,
0.0240714513,
-0.5396244526,
0.1137223616,
-0.0574437715,
-0.0838497207,
0.0280590188,
0.3259968162,
0.3923288584,
-0.0833741799,
0.3565434217,
0.0464373976,
0.0365171656,
0.2460713387,
-0.3079676628,
0.5192771554,
-0.0346702598,
-0.3245135546,
-0.3885945678,
0.2600758076,
0.8574837446,
0.2637376189,
0.7494182587,
0.1330115646,
-0.7007138729,
-0.1082715318,
-0.7963368893,
-0.1593215168,
-0.3841792047,
0.4653074145,
0.024118064,
-0.6373045444,
0.4443902075,
-0.3888334632,
0.0018180237,
0.3437157273,
0.565934062,
-0.0236306805,
1.2013266087,
0.24285689,
-0.1352101862,
0.1039229035,
0.0157153178,
0.4476051033,
-0.5403645039,
-0.6599094272,
-0.2568148971,
-0.3907646835,
0.0190809593,
-0.1050348654,
0.8868837357,
0.2432720065,
-0.4485652149,
0.0290984046,
-0.4400380254,
0.4423902035,
-0.0049259611,
0.4520569444,
0.2179652452,
-0.1121432856,
-0.3451371789,
0.4309180081,
-0.9554444551,
-0.6177731752,
1.0232905149,
0.3039770424,
0.5790666342,
-0.0420286655,
0.7059642673,
0.4727096856,
0.2820029855,
-0.7121239901,
0.6701549888,
0.5393352509,
-0.3475331068,
-0.673751533,
-0.5260717869,
-0.6333190799,
0.1834298223,
-0.7348234057,
-0.6336701512,
0.0544728078,
-0.0595068596,
-0.7297809124,
0.319370389,
-1.102368474,
0.4715091884,
-0.3592245877,
0.0740131512,
-0.4907960296,
-0.532697618,
0.2009365559,
-0.1678644866,
0.4012930095,
-0.2560388446,
0.1287400275,
0.7491052747,
-0.6710790992,
0.6547298431,
-0.1808609068,
0.137540102,
0.488761425,
-0.0736445934,
1.1537818909,
0.0937247053,
-0.6171320081,
-0.0308163203,
-0.489407748,
-0.0884546116,
-0.7020193934,
0.5938416719,
-0.8403013349,
-0.5699363947,
0.022329269,
-0.5805714726,
-0.2672687769,
0.4515871406,
0.1045819819,
0.599853754,
-0.0964637026,
-0.0241012983,
0.4106538296,
-0.3052814901,
0.5132591724,
0.4884724915,
-0.3906315267,
-0.4544432163,
0.6570744514,
0.3347254395,
0.0510641225,
0.3175918162,
0.3691553771,
-0.5122007728,
-0.5741065741,
-0.4187912643,
-0.2741079032,
-0.9120413065,
-0.4424404204,
-1.0774662495,
-0.3989677727,
-0.2944011986,
-0.4392732382,
0.1703985184,
-0.545111835,
0.0388494618,
-0.4620631039,
0.6212830544,
0.8631262779,
-0.0975791588,
-0.1764182299,
-0.7382309437,
0.1029536128,
0.3883426487,
0.0297854617,
0.486956954,
0.0216569155,
-0.1666291356,
-0.1605806202,
-0.2874368727,
-1.1054545641,
0.21760647,
0.0211501438,
0.5746448636,
0.3961385489,
0.4599043429,
0.5843208432,
-0.6569105983,
0.2913564444,
0.5618387461,
-0.6969954371,
0.5970554352,
-0.4461686313,
-0.0432860702,
0.3425040245,
0.2962735295,
-0.3705415726,
-0.4053475559,
-0.6573758721,
-0.8403255343,
0.4710273445,
0.4564490318,
-0.4125897884,
-0.2670610845,
0.0004262212,
-0.1881029755,
0.1003556475,
-0.4185162485,
-0.3131915033,
-0.2181697488,
-0.1533135623,
0.3751038611,
-0.1752622724,
-0.0280857794,
-0.5003959537,
0.6447289586,
-0.0537378602,
0.27382496,
0.3985111713,
0.1121833548,
-0.2659646869,
0.4092483819,
0.4993918836,
0.6766151786,
-0.0965813249,
0.1935247481,
0.8139491677,
-0.3310469687,
0.2564077377,
0.0733403191,
-0.1775731146,
-0.1412154883,
0.4144768119,
0.7384985685,
0.3331136703,
-0.816539824,
0.0718333796,
0.1239190474,
-0.1158566624,
-0.3223873079,
0.1392903626,
0.1165482327,
0.4860818386,
0.5770297647,
0.2932512462,
0.1728833914,
-0.4594832659,
0.1993688196,
0.1300335526,
0.0428059474,
0.0007890943,
0.4044050276,
0.5695905685,
-0.5277431011,
0.5854351521,
-0.4895766377,
-0.6874462962,
0.7521653771,
0.7718010545,
0.7676068544,
-0.3803044558,
0.1815028787,
0.5408165455,
0.5631198883,
-0.1744428128,
0.4777678847,
0.3131999373,
-0.8748509288,
-0.2446704209,
-0.4522800744,
-0.3331179917,
0.2573563457,
-0.2392970622,
0.3851649463,
-0.8939483762,
-0.1391838044,
-0.3116917312,
-0.4062667191,
-0.8377509117,
0.3320731521,
0.2155666798,
0.8655407429,
-0.4738910198,
0.5035515428,
0.6216163635,
-0.0474455133,
-1.3259489536,
-0.1275028586,
0.0181934498,
-0.9160060287,
0.674017787,
0.2171990871,
0.1322748512,
0.1226459295,
-0.2503145039,
-0.9317356944,
1.1877223253,
0.2101943046,
-1.0095589161,
-0.322699517,
-0.1641169786,
0.3062940538,
-0.5170006156,
0.5730840564,
0.5279533267,
1.0032428503,
0.0419609658,
-0.8988025784,
0.2420661151,
-0.0735050663,
-0.5273273587,
0.5867949128,
-0.4423857331,
0.3402687311,
-0.7172131538,
-0.4120667577,
-0.3588178456,
0.4891307354,
0.2286090404,
0.6582289338,
0.7115917206,
0.969040513,
1.3157474995,
-0.0318123512,
0.8961722255,
-0.3185640574,
0.1727437228,
1.02604568,
-0.4680965245,
0.8406734467,
-0.0699340254,
-0.0792267919,
0.6559262276,
0.5044752359,
0.270462364,
0.5075305104,
-0.2148252279,
-0.4496822953,
-0.7641321421,
-0.2078859955,
-0.4104907513,
0.1887151003,
0.6125973463,
-0.6073236465,
-0.341707021,
-0.0643083826,
0.1073302105,
-0.3695984483,
-0.4317704141,
0.6889672279,
-0.0173441134,
-0.4625310004,
0.4882999957,
-0.0952442363,
-0.0764398128,
-0.2529315352,
-0.1815774143,
0.3906220198,
-0.2001485229,
-0.4495069683,
-1.0341236591,
0.201506719,
-0.0370501764,
-0.2619588673,
0.0383759737,
1.0733253956,
-0.1410507113,
-0.6841590405,
0.368453145,
0.5371565819,
-0.087270394,
0.0625044182,
-0.5689202547,
0.1264789701,
-0.1099045649,
0.0418408737,
-0.0120893074,
0.5634532571,
0.0941148996,
0.8792397976,
0.6658933163,
-0.0587764829,
-0.1508941352,
0.1262125373,
0.9099851847,
-0.4309021831,
-0.7175709605,
-0.9090160728,
0.482393384,
-0.4326442182,
-0.0895910189,
0.5615905523,
0.2853733897,
0.4081405997,
0.1269634813,
1.2275944948,
-0.3707750142,
0.1737740934,
-0.7878441811,
0.869602263,
-0.1681040972,
0.2513424158,
-0.3222691715,
-0.7541874647,
-0.3207288384,
0.6529173851,
-0.5221053958,
-0.1324480921,
0.7447605133,
0.5706620812,
0.2149655372,
0.2774828374,
0.441031158,
0.4077626467,
0.2573236823,
0.7751495242,
0.9500101209,
-0.0900244415,
0.4399440289,
0.0471320003,
-0.2653723359,
-0.4519228339,
-0.9630112052,
-1.1267213821,
-0.4081464708,
-0.1203236207,
-0.227716893,
0.122043252,
1.3642721176,
0.7639533281,
-0.5489155054,
0.2144571543,
-0.2512732744,
0.5901658535,
0.0444860235,
-0.1841528714,
0.2921466231,
-0.348801285,
0.0479211807,
0.7559657097,
0.6201176047,
-0.007746005,
0.0798427314,
-0.4884167314,
0.0070551285,
0.1411349624,
0.8745815158,
0.0265750978,
-0.7467272282,
-0.6296182275,
-0.1614350826,
0.2405399978,
-0.1470674872,
0.7081041336,
-0.9270582795,
0.4659722447,
0.4968710244,
0.7561074495,
-0.1146196574,
-0.2236053646,
0.5023879409,
-0.2967350781,
-0.1508704871,
0.2608702779,
0.6937441826,
0.378253758,
-0.6953390241,
0.5448018909,
0.287291348,
-0.8828707337,
-0.5314145088,
0.1395077705,
-0.4785048068,
-0.170769304,
1.1507320404,
0.0649449602,
0.091110833,
-0.5454642773,
-0.4601868689,
0.2113298625,
-0.8764867783,
1.0709145069,
0.7566985488,
-0.3192902207,
-0.1899689734,
-0.4046417177,
0.3927154839,
0.1098138317,
-1.199919939,
-0.0889808685,
0.6343707442,
-0.0589042753,
0.249609068,
0.478728354,
0.4704013765,
0.218464449,
-0.095223628,
-0.3518403471,
-0.1479095817,
-0.7804267406,
0.1615440398,
0.2133883238,
-0.0902321041,
0.3747628033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08726v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08726v2
|
Uncertainty Estimation on Sequential Labeling via Uncertainty Transmission
| 2023-11-15T06:36:29 | 2024-06-05T15:04:29 |
Jianfeng He, Linlin Yu, Shuo Lei, Chang-Tien Lu, Feng Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Sequential labeling is a task predicting labels for each token in a sequence,
such as Named Entity Recognition (NER). NER tasks aim to extract entities and
predict their labels given a text, which is important in information
extraction. Although previous works have shown great progress in improving NER
performance, uncertainty estimation on NER (UE-NER) is still underexplored but
essential. This work focuses on UE-NER, which aims to estimate uncertainty
scores for the NER predictions. Previous uncertainty estimation models often
overlook two unique characteristics of NER: the connection between entities
(i.e., one entity embedding is learned based on the other ones) and wrong span
cases in the entity extraction subtask. Therefore, we propose a Sequential
Labeling Posterior Network (SLPN) to estimate uncertainty scores for the
extracted entities, considering uncertainty transmitted from other tokens.
Moreover, we have defined an evaluation strategy to address the specificity of
wrong-span cases. Our SLPN has achieved significant improvements on three
datasets, such as a 5.54-point improvement in AUPR on the MIT-Restaurant
dataset. Our code is available at
\url{https://github.com/he159ok/UncSeqLabeling_SLPN}.
|
[
-0.1702034026,
-0.5138229728,
0.5570369363,
0.169532612,
-0.2321723253,
-0.042840641,
0.0764383972,
-0.6673324108,
0.3196330667,
0.2980639338,
-0.3244445622,
-0.3492409289,
-0.7817020416,
0.1092631072,
-0.2921281457,
0.8294881582,
0.0361673161,
0.0069507663,
0.1844967902,
0.1477471739,
-0.3545441329,
-0.1642780453,
-0.9542456269,
-0.336116612,
0.6937611103,
0.3078688085,
0.5554964542,
0.5121551156,
0.5898444653,
0.2904600799,
-0.0054629403,
0.1104978323,
-0.0555698276,
0.2037006617,
-0.4124016166,
-0.1992316544,
-0.4485642016,
-0.3969991207,
0.9002082944,
0.6709108353,
-0.1302186549,
0.1857322007,
-0.0954794437,
0.606901288,
-0.830247879,
0.1297109276,
-0.5536971092,
0.192359075,
-0.2546721697,
0.2004899979,
-0.515798986,
-0.1652778983,
0.4573910236,
-0.7099045515,
-0.080779843,
0.3119547963,
0.9716758132,
0.5108962059,
-0.3432863355,
-0.0656428784,
-0.7685614228,
0.5456585884,
-0.6903967857,
0.3667105138,
0.3178695142,
0.0935599282,
-0.2847192883,
-1.1543284655,
-0.4551033974,
0.1938052326,
0.0075096088,
0.2468800396,
-0.2466079444,
0.0369300991,
0.0602666289,
-0.0102294255,
-0.3750339746,
0.4481320083,
-0.0902762264,
-0.3648540378,
0.765047133,
0.0256411415,
0.0301808398,
-0.2226656824,
-0.6622661948,
0.0666773394,
-0.1828125715,
-0.1084644124,
0.262606591,
0.0662945658,
0.2333833724,
0.4506667256,
-0.2004706711,
0.6903090477,
0.130221352,
0.045181334,
0.4921438992,
-0.3228363693,
-0.2999791503,
0.2091618329,
1.1062679291,
0.0712361187,
0.0016783028,
-0.2448961586,
-0.4719060361,
-0.3351120651,
0.2820093036,
-0.3604350388,
-0.3549802005,
0.1637856364,
-0.1524996459,
-0.0481015183,
0.3307452202,
-0.8776141405,
-0.3476642072,
0.0430134125,
0.5688559413,
-0.2787136734,
-0.1612428278,
-0.0775963143,
-0.1154203191,
0.1194671169,
0.2655498981,
-0.5695112944,
0.3772290349,
0.5263187289,
0.7577117085,
-0.4189003706,
-0.1649485081,
-0.387308687,
0.0913983881,
-0.1596412957,
0.6714505553,
-0.4231492579,
-0.2788916528,
-0.4993355274,
-0.0073274747,
-0.44754228,
-0.2436629534,
0.7735502124,
-0.7959316969,
-0.3073249161,
-0.1056349576,
-0.9264079332,
-0.0836786851,
-0.1290942878,
-0.8394409418,
1.1264024973,
0.0146326525,
-1.1373001337,
0.3981503248,
-0.237087816,
-0.2882692814,
0.1385008395,
-0.1054370701,
-0.6753813624,
-0.0070667518,
0.3879391253,
0.3235316873,
-0.0298291501,
0.4847252071,
-0.2874663472,
-0.4060922563,
0.4880040586,
-0.5234712958,
0.4204062819,
0.1141902059,
-0.4592703879,
0.0514964871,
-0.6868035793,
0.2697284222,
-0.078099601,
-0.1925169826,
-0.3268607855,
-0.0536129586,
-0.1712711751,
0.028407909,
0.1044408232,
-0.3826830685,
0.1580242962,
-0.4911721349,
0.2121939212,
0.8507533669,
0.470875293,
0.6987695098,
-0.0667851344,
0.3302578628,
0.0589802936,
-0.011221109,
0.2352024615,
-0.7265472412,
-0.6127081513,
0.0004094366,
0.917619288,
0.9136786461,
-0.7384389043,
0.4523712099,
-0.2789499164,
-0.4373097718,
-0.268830061,
-0.3010960519,
0.422249794,
0.7289843559,
0.3641524911,
-0.5463312864,
-0.6817992926,
-0.6917458177,
-0.2839336395,
-0.1667643934,
0.0051421099,
-0.0213098694,
0.7481871843,
-0.0917279124,
0.9298514724,
-0.5393385887,
-0.1446667463,
0.0504494533,
0.4876984954,
0.1620834023,
0.8055669069,
-0.190554902,
-0.8887654543,
-0.5288494825,
-0.2576419115,
-0.5513139963,
0.1577960253,
-0.5137267709,
-0.0959822759,
0.1994390488,
0.2966654301,
-0.4711675048,
0.7162544727,
0.2009961009,
0.0643933117,
0.5666179657,
-0.2065418065,
-0.1422875524,
-0.9545034766,
-0.185053423,
0.4116390646,
-0.1748242825,
-0.3705125749,
-0.4245909154,
0.0711529627,
0.4033948779,
-0.4014056921,
0.5247991681,
-0.6428637505,
-0.4605259597,
0.0669084191,
0.0876107588,
0.0333395675,
0.3083175719,
0.4139854908,
0.6347357631,
0.6986609101,
-0.3916456401,
0.0271512363,
-0.0588538125,
-0.5198699832,
0.3800598979,
-0.8154574037,
0.2882973254,
-0.0928731635,
0.2940633297,
-0.9742541909,
-0.1442875415,
0.7832422256,
-0.4293591082,
0.7258242369,
-0.1803576499,
-0.3379358649,
-0.4961563051,
0.2537290454,
0.2930407524,
0.0509824529,
-0.0460464209,
0.3758970797,
0.5159549117,
-0.0758304223,
-0.8556675911,
-0.8062028885,
-0.0163758788,
-0.06903366,
-0.3717450798,
0.3822911978,
0.1921252012,
0.0243515391,
0.1778569371,
-0.6170600057,
-0.503459096,
0.0341596901,
0.5396018028,
0.0735136122,
-0.2407738417,
0.3079451919,
0.2552109361,
-0.3976722956,
-0.00862261,
-0.7221938372,
-0.0187540241,
-0.2862132788,
-0.3248377144,
-0.7259249687,
0.0279730037,
-0.1214484349,
-0.1957486719,
0.6803238988,
0.9296293855,
-0.651892364,
-0.122258842,
-0.3856084645,
-0.0812185183,
-0.4052754343,
0.3596642315,
-0.5184031725,
-0.6045777798,
0.4445880949,
-0.1885887533,
-0.4248118401,
0.5626822114,
-0.1073074564,
-0.3715511262,
0.6699968576,
0.375900507,
-0.0411021151,
0.2811524272,
-0.1985094845,
0.0734068304,
-0.8459346294,
-0.3445904553,
-0.4199038148,
-0.2970688045,
-0.5204945207,
-0.3778116703,
0.3119448423,
0.2148341388,
-0.3125654161,
0.2524608374,
-0.5010974407,
0.3979131877,
0.7408407331,
0.2154783159,
0.233812809,
0.0408758223,
-0.2953822017,
-0.26254493,
-0.579671979,
-0.3418410718,
0.7836133838,
0.3996382058,
0.6772704124,
0.0069237598,
1.010388732,
0.4439776838,
0.1053123772,
-0.5786530972,
0.2697215378,
0.1027633622,
-0.4648109674,
-0.6921211481,
-0.6467446685,
-0.9675155282,
0.3083616495,
-0.1628611386,
-1.3399909735,
0.4971919358,
0.0280807819,
-0.6370057464,
0.3057151437,
-0.6473727226,
0.810860157,
-0.2297102213,
-0.1130792052,
0.5429081321,
-1.2073925734,
0.1099179983,
-0.177639991,
0.123162888,
-0.0576844588,
-0.1872730404,
0.966180563,
-0.4119460881,
0.9502727985,
-0.0890022516,
0.0937537923,
0.4836263359,
0.0153301964,
0.8248023987,
0.5237936378,
-0.4348996878,
0.372677207,
-0.0904712304,
-0.0479671657,
-0.4825631976,
0.4075251818,
-0.6249674559,
-0.1555228829,
-0.726474762,
-0.4078933597,
-0.1236571148,
0.651235044,
0.6473749876,
0.216364637,
0.2354960591,
-0.3090217113,
0.6638256907,
0.1049180105,
0.6410318613,
0.1616412997,
0.2437164038,
-0.5444846749,
0.8175690174,
0.3894323111,
0.12325041,
0.7225884795,
0.0719030127,
-0.5570359826,
-0.6804394126,
-0.4187864959,
0.0193338171,
-0.580344975,
-0.3994564712,
-0.6622803807,
-0.3507732749,
-0.3617675602,
0.1447363943,
-0.5890264511,
-0.5866851807,
-0.5809704661,
-0.213719815,
0.0260066036,
0.7220021486,
-0.3584622443,
0.6335316896,
-0.7611781359,
0.0813567489,
-0.0023690839,
0.2918879688,
-0.1868040711,
-0.6528057456,
0.0269819628,
0.1586805582,
0.0375793688,
-1.2431803942,
0.4349454045,
0.3168554008,
0.5954968333,
0.2066308409,
0.249062553,
0.559718132,
-0.3272949159,
0.3852525651,
0.143972218,
-1.0490546227,
0.5556958318,
0.0416923761,
0.2111291587,
0.6870834827,
0.6657568216,
-0.1961586028,
-0.0594313145,
-0.725638926,
-1.1939396858,
0.6334097385,
0.2218279988,
-0.4571638107,
-0.0012858891,
0.509537518,
-0.0868200511,
0.2805503011,
-0.7341645956,
-0.5919994712,
0.0486331098,
-0.0785954073,
0.1884607524,
-0.21533373,
0.3102555573,
-0.1786922961,
0.8237240911,
0.0516128689,
0.4013698101,
0.4637215137,
-0.152273342,
-0.1607425064,
0.2352546751,
0.2866776288,
0.5769670606,
-0.2760903537,
0.2259043157,
0.1943901628,
-0.5420850515,
0.0559914187,
0.3313212991,
-0.4501173794,
0.1489436626,
0.2608473897,
0.8281880617,
0.3302355111,
-0.1440368295,
0.4795618653,
-0.0938464478,
0.0927294567,
-0.6480861902,
-0.3607112169,
0.0044108797,
0.3295908272,
0.3956030905,
0.4724310338,
0.4124495089,
0.220801875,
0.7022072077,
-0.0535725132,
-0.6876080036,
-0.1348081231,
0.4234647155,
-0.211305663,
-0.0615906678,
0.9241012931,
-0.6642054319,
-0.3833421469,
0.7533271313,
0.6538643241,
0.6069423556,
-0.3281193376,
0.5476572514,
0.5200245976,
0.5163257122,
-0.2480625063,
0.2397719026,
0.1985697746,
-0.9277720451,
-0.3829392195,
-0.5881638527,
-0.2772469521,
-0.267690897,
-0.8776659369,
-0.1591265649,
-0.1913930476,
-0.4888878167,
0.1679407805,
-0.0409228466,
-0.5908007622,
0.2955238521,
0.1137135178,
0.6607394218,
-0.6262888908,
0.8037288785,
0.6728819609,
-0.4937570393,
-1.2093721628,
-0.1171749905,
0.0593298785,
-0.5125699043,
0.6904740334,
0.1071930602,
0.0952673405,
0.1375792474,
-0.1793822497,
-1.3506809473,
1.0761055946,
0.0932340398,
-0.8433109522,
-0.2811256945,
0.0695698708,
0.1829181463,
-0.220327124,
0.4419983029,
0.3369159698,
0.6091163754,
0.2159395814,
-0.8682417274,
0.112363115,
0.0735043213,
0.0945534334,
0.433449924,
-0.1962094903,
0.6751070619,
-0.5902931094,
-0.2851501703,
0.1880198568,
1.0136882067,
-0.044976037,
0.5490866899,
0.51843822,
0.6905962825,
1.2730270624,
-0.269374609,
0.7186373472,
0.1363230795,
0.5154251456,
1.7924954891,
-0.2988851964,
0.9620873332,
0.5133794546,
-0.2019765079,
0.4726504087,
0.9972620606,
-0.0687473938,
0.4457340837,
0.3926585615,
-0.1054270416,
-0.2140424401,
-0.0226584878,
-0.3438582718,
0.4102029502,
0.6540702581,
-0.5583695173,
0.0713688061,
-0.183979705,
-0.059917666,
-0.408202678,
-0.1888836026,
0.6729955077,
0.2598599494,
-0.4501388073,
0.1215146929,
-0.0199063513,
0.4572869241,
-0.2735716999,
0.0253395364,
0.0373510309,
-0.0188918654,
-0.2224979848,
-0.8264704347,
0.2423424721,
-0.5538814068,
-0.1166833639,
0.0585574284,
0.920568347,
-0.280975312,
-0.6144280434,
0.1241799742,
0.4915172458,
0.2588378787,
-0.15694803,
-0.8349949718,
-0.0001039843,
-0.2370036244,
-0.3376713395,
0.0597506724,
0.4497632384,
-0.0903054178,
0.5931761265,
0.2392174453,
0.0776708201,
0.4338145554,
0.0006755345,
0.3704203069,
-0.3501058221,
-0.3570379913,
-0.6032307744,
0.6834882498,
-0.1058547124,
-0.4865465164,
0.5621284842,
0.3560944796,
0.9022151828,
-0.0049684704,
0.5646561384,
-0.0761953145,
0.1403940916,
-0.4784119427,
0.4466475248,
-0.2760745585,
0.3951651454,
-0.5393192768,
-0.818631351,
-0.4198712707,
0.6689579487,
-0.4195413888,
0.0512441956,
0.7365711927,
0.6568467617,
0.1542952508,
0.310569495,
0.0098341685,
0.1393568963,
-0.2806691527,
0.4982333481,
0.6183363199,
-0.7854028344,
0.311136663,
-0.6951311827,
-0.0136020686,
0.1202278659,
-1.0363252163,
-0.1429416239,
-0.5497492552,
-0.7356886864,
-0.2495584637,
0.256953001,
0.584723413,
0.8387690187,
-0.8467960954,
0.0893812925,
-0.2838354409,
0.5351825356,
-0.5149388909,
-0.267244339,
0.5799375772,
-0.1135583967,
-0.4551934898,
0.3050044775,
0.1119764745,
0.0672243908,
0.3735432327,
0.0715536699,
-0.5577962399,
-0.1746218652,
0.1129078567,
0.4609871805,
-0.6433595419,
-0.4408911169,
-0.1630931944,
-0.0910482481,
-0.0353675969,
0.3635309041,
-0.5127118826,
0.4489880204,
0.4261546433,
0.9518370032,
0.5955924988,
0.0593196116,
0.2708497345,
-1.1258956194,
-0.248766318,
0.3447544873,
0.574864924,
0.1876695305,
-0.5829930305,
0.653208375,
0.3911553919,
-0.6901964545,
-0.5834211111,
0.1634862572,
-1.020413518,
-0.0465012155,
0.9474567175,
-0.5235099792,
-0.304217875,
-0.2338351309,
0.2719096541,
0.4676454663,
-0.69866997,
0.2429018468,
0.2406368703,
-0.2536384761,
-0.1938879341,
-0.4685377777,
0.0995083153,
0.4364358485,
-0.5518676639,
-0.672853291,
0.3948128819,
0.302401185,
0.2808825374,
0.7125942111,
0.2416498661,
0.0097709866,
0.1524318606,
0.0745781139,
0.1678692997,
-0.6100386977,
-0.1738999486,
0.2461708486,
-0.0124276187,
-0.4264349937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08724v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08724v3
|
Knowledge Graph Construction in Power Distribution Networks
| 2023-11-15T06:35:01 | 2024-01-27T07:15:54 |
Xiang Li, Che Wang, Bing Li, Hao Chen, Sizhe Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we propose a method for knowledge graph construction in power
distribution networks. This method leverages entity features, which involve
their semantic, phonetic, and syntactic characteristics, in both the knowledge
graph of distribution network and the dispatching texts. An enhanced model
based on Convolutional Neural Network, is utilized for effectively matching
dispatch text entities with those in the knowledge graph. The effectiveness of
this model is evaluated through experiments in real-world power distribution
dispatch scenarios. The results indicate that, compared with the baselines, the
proposed model excels in linking a variety of entity types, demonstrating high
overall accuracy in power distribution knowledge graph construction task.
|
[
-0.5255448222,
-0.2972065806,
0.3297393918,
0.2308564931,
-0.3674617708,
-0.1601952165,
-0.0515343063,
-0.5920640826,
0.3654100001,
0.7591044903,
-0.4522981346,
-0.4410942197,
-0.592969358,
0.1001868322,
-0.3910564482,
0.6937858462,
0.0196095817,
-0.3686546683,
0.0178612974,
-0.1134644374,
-0.4741740227,
-0.3843956888,
-0.5675216317,
-0.9725529552,
0.1961960644,
0.1183729395,
0.9905517101,
0.4323968291,
0.4325762987,
0.3337572217,
0.0619021878,
0.563110888,
-0.1653040349,
0.3052188456,
-0.3646520972,
-0.1673096269,
-0.4854537249,
-0.1959514171,
0.6569049358,
0.8301720619,
-0.1705035418,
-0.2083651125,
-0.0228530336,
0.6591049433,
-0.4910281599,
0.5702214241,
-0.7591122389,
0.0508180447,
-0.1402625442,
-0.402975589,
-0.5772382021,
-0.3811588883,
0.421212405,
-0.96877563,
0.2976500094,
0.4607803226,
0.8684369326,
0.1549199522,
-0.7515848875,
-0.2631123066,
-0.7846574187,
0.1396654099,
-0.1799729317,
0.644097805,
0.345646292,
0.5468909144,
0.2189766169,
-1.0098872185,
-0.6718084216,
-0.1084835082,
-0.4484447539,
0.1290713996,
0.0012547928,
0.3989497423,
0.2727765739,
0.1449746937,
-0.0322151259,
-0.0012689054,
-0.1534419954,
-0.0644799247,
0.6140781045,
0.1833924949,
0.0767197832,
-0.7350928187,
-0.6242597103,
-0.0816958845,
-0.5666427016,
-0.4293892682,
0.6392345428,
0.2221495211,
0.0631636605,
0.6426098943,
-0.1578636914,
0.6272189021,
0.0081794271,
-0.2320079654,
0.2550424039,
-0.2718864381,
-0.6099804044,
0.4698177874,
0.7969538569,
0.6605104804,
0.6696664095,
-0.5053639412,
0.0072115101,
-0.4002860785,
0.4315884709,
-0.5633657575,
-0.7916529775,
-0.224404335,
-0.7065602541,
-0.395393759,
-0.1443819702,
-0.5873833895,
-0.673489213,
-0.3904910088,
0.095342271,
-0.8749516606,
-0.6038765907,
-0.185105294,
-0.4651770294,
-0.2620217204,
0.1293547302,
-0.8920222521,
0.4871848524,
0.3180920184,
0.6808431149,
0.2981949449,
-0.1386781633,
0.017046174,
0.4990374744,
0.0076308851,
0.7219051719,
-0.3036729991,
0.0615391284,
0.1469706297,
0.2294670641,
-0.2753889263,
-0.5340307951,
0.4510628879,
-0.9589344263,
-0.5596170425,
-0.1035460383,
-1.1157237291,
-0.4035962522,
0.1935016811,
-0.7956444621,
0.6939746737,
0.3297227025,
-1.3283258677,
0.4312966168,
-0.4158723056,
-0.5693300962,
0.2919057012,
0.1803034246,
-0.4604841173,
-0.475869298,
-0.0227836668,
0.6248557568,
-0.1203675419,
0.1630032212,
-0.3512744904,
0.3362781107,
-0.0116524734,
-0.029020533,
0.8360261321,
0.3418691754,
-0.0591337308,
-0.1921849549,
-0.9766184092,
-0.1081748009,
0.0633693412,
0.0815670416,
-0.7477152348,
0.2629529834,
-0.2511073947,
-0.1772556156,
0.1161088869,
-0.306189388,
0.1099073365,
-0.5324099064,
0.0732689574,
0.4239293933,
0.4947214127,
0.8839916587,
-0.2194297165,
0.3360874057,
0.0884110779,
0.2137184441,
0.3901155889,
-0.5428299308,
-0.4649848044,
0.3620972633,
0.2201739997,
0.8236284256,
-1.0809988976,
0.9006226063,
-0.2719205022,
-0.7804237604,
0.0533547513,
-0.0094570667,
0.1247982755,
0.9101784229,
0.2908766568,
0.1048383638,
-0.6984041929,
-0.7173944712,
0.1818611175,
-0.2805867493,
0.1082551852,
0.435072571,
0.1526025087,
0.2724287212,
0.9205620885,
-0.7032818794,
-0.3313697278,
-0.5632013679,
-0.427649796,
0.066471003,
0.1698389351,
0.6983413696,
-0.8983733654,
-0.2852743864,
0.1741920412,
-0.756002903,
0.1887122244,
0.0316729993,
-0.2089703679,
-0.5623497963,
0.3690297008,
-0.6354532838,
0.1174459681,
0.2228707224,
-0.3033196032,
0.5893106461,
-0.2586037815,
-0.1292096972,
-1.5073558092,
-0.1393165737,
0.021942148,
-0.1508780569,
-0.5975980163,
-0.0120621435,
0.0812334567,
-0.2016120255,
-0.4545202255,
-0.0179630108,
-0.3183905482,
-0.0748966858,
0.3988146484,
0.380699873,
-0.017121546,
0.1469353139,
-0.1589967906,
0.3001005352,
0.5678294897,
-0.8567368388,
1.093116641,
0.5842269063,
-0.5077306628,
0.5198545456,
-0.4568727911,
-0.1623340249,
-0.2526482046,
0.1114038005,
-0.7253090143,
-0.0171208102,
0.2163532823,
0.2348534614,
0.3095220327,
-0.3696936965,
-0.6903968453,
-0.4611214697,
0.3628464341,
0.2702733278,
0.4705705047,
-0.4001727402,
0.5553568602,
0.5210722685,
0.2439718395,
-0.205356732,
-0.4679301381,
-0.0404790603,
-0.1787043959,
-1.063339591,
0.7642416358,
0.3655466437,
-0.2421205491,
0.005284566,
0.5953219533,
-0.0087346593,
0.3307735324,
0.2288814038,
-0.174230203,
-0.0020803246,
0.7430981398,
0.1244037971,
0.12320856,
-0.0149537418,
-0.5272104144,
0.6817002296,
0.7320610285,
-0.0995497555,
-0.3108434081,
0.2981045544,
0.320029974,
-0.317368716,
0.8213185072,
0.113280423,
-0.4337823987,
-0.4162392616,
-0.1460133046,
0.078775458,
-0.4629065096,
0.2115343958,
-0.3338801265,
-0.1815417111,
0.5980645418,
-0.6774887443,
-0.2014183849,
0.3998344541,
0.0721451119,
0.0613988191,
0.589140594,
0.6955973506,
0.1295963973,
0.6189252734,
-0.5002775192,
0.5136291981,
-0.8858020306,
-0.5851382613,
-0.557631135,
-0.2912274897,
-0.5005376935,
0.0937259123,
0.355017662,
0.5148575902,
-0.1376954466,
0.7552238703,
-0.8214922547,
-0.1731038243,
0.0344728939,
0.2870705724,
0.1952503771,
0.0718867779,
-0.3938470483,
0.0758175477,
-0.6613506079,
-0.2911095917,
0.8135787845,
0.2690110505,
0.538020432,
0.0772536397,
0.6201031208,
0.2898102701,
0.4445240796,
-0.6665747762,
0.3630893826,
-0.3072835803,
-0.0920866728,
-0.6005744338,
-0.5046693087,
-1.0345773697,
-0.1735281497,
-0.258007586,
-0.7402544618,
0.3449375629,
0.1914522946,
-0.1443265975,
0.5185139179,
-1.0722504854,
0.6029404998,
0.265393436,
0.6526458859,
0.00950942,
-0.2025493532,
0.230696246,
0.369554013,
0.0267537627,
-0.0549331196,
0.2206106633,
0.7592923045,
-1.0161399841,
0.577932477,
-0.2215896249,
-0.1791359782,
0.5496321321,
-0.1669708043,
1.0305294991,
0.0454626568,
-0.7104338408,
-0.2075746208,
-0.5524151325,
-0.0598471165,
-0.8180144429,
0.1435710192,
-0.7668188214,
0.0655752793,
0.3707452416,
-0.4562180638,
-0.095097959,
0.2412305176,
0.6501153111,
0.9129559994,
-0.0605939515,
-0.1958744377,
0.6748530269,
0.2318123728,
0.4572490454,
-0.1527020335,
-0.0534557477,
-0.4960079491,
0.6272330284,
0.6973876953,
0.4571721554,
0.5233178735,
-0.1511625797,
-0.5660771132,
-0.6313013434,
-0.4521086514,
-0.0765489936,
-0.9486408234,
-0.4714175165,
-0.9762316942,
-0.6810290217,
-0.565212667,
-0.0218404047,
0.03965538,
-0.260222137,
-0.2670322657,
-0.5327857733,
0.899017334,
0.9121897221,
0.3786824346,
0.4704293311,
-0.4090198874,
0.3081249297,
0.6138986945,
0.3551937044,
0.394454658,
0.0748655945,
-0.1436371207,
-0.1631742418,
-0.7764472961,
-1.2759068012,
0.2990480959,
0.469026804,
0.4771174788,
0.4103212953,
0.6097544432,
0.3318873048,
-0.7047992945,
0.600799799,
0.5666847229,
-0.6036379337,
0.6286077499,
-0.0558833778,
-0.2590760589,
0.1064586267,
0.2082334161,
-0.2536352277,
-0.5705106258,
-1.0171408653,
-0.5706650019,
0.2419889271,
0.5776519179,
0.1413487047,
-0.458602488,
0.3925091922,
-0.2009420842,
0.1070750728,
-0.2068058401,
-0.9744278789,
-0.4992995858,
-0.1285241991,
0.2650824189,
-0.1995913684,
-0.0759233385,
-0.2005840689,
0.3586859107,
-0.170605585,
0.2553436458,
0.3645997047,
0.0845264494,
0.0361370072,
0.2052289099,
0.146377027,
0.7333490252,
-0.0335929394,
0.5059373975,
0.5665341616,
-0.6034393311,
0.2786497176,
0.3834382594,
-0.3362864852,
0.4009387195,
0.3264972568,
0.9643638134,
0.2870047987,
0.2797857523,
0.4122412205,
0.0823734477,
-0.2608986199,
-0.4438853264,
0.17855905,
0.3952785432,
0.2188611925,
0.4936100841,
0.3646658957,
0.2387446761,
-0.4218466282,
0.2814876437,
0.1990057081,
-0.4421352446,
-0.1815519631,
0.3868709505,
0.2251983285,
-0.617170155,
0.6650730968,
-0.5381314754,
-0.7209606171,
0.9471606016,
0.7687469125,
0.6130350828,
-0.135910809,
0.4213636816,
0.298179388,
0.3900976777,
0.1461774111,
0.333437711,
0.0697051138,
-0.9533765912,
-0.139050439,
-0.6121307611,
-0.1514023393,
-0.1986176819,
-0.3417650163,
0.5654512048,
-0.5714372993,
-0.1577226073,
0.3301848173,
0.1962881982,
-1.1199500561,
0.4289585948,
-0.2424226254,
1.2610667944,
-0.7812511921,
1.0273441076,
0.5940781832,
-0.2382728159,
-1.6450492144,
-0.2591429353,
-0.9333798885,
-0.5899938941,
0.603281498,
-0.2003259212,
0.5155163407,
0.3422479331,
-0.0787371621,
-0.9275764227,
1.6221164465,
0.6193006635,
-0.5823426247,
-0.121301502,
-0.1980275214,
0.3237167299,
-0.4764654636,
0.2923822105,
0.2604570091,
0.517359376,
0.0297996122,
-1.0016063452,
0.2977270484,
-0.0149181355,
0.0409624428,
0.7285045981,
-0.670765996,
0.668194592,
0.0309811905,
-0.376866281,
-0.206941694,
0.8248605132,
-0.0160519723,
0.2167295963,
0.9488617182,
0.6533768177,
1.1442254782,
0.2029880732,
1.1886115074,
-0.3843238652,
0.6576585174,
0.8628298044,
-0.2663570344,
0.1591322869,
0.0205474403,
-0.2426526546,
0.7085290551,
0.3243058026,
-0.0349793546,
0.8930792212,
0.2205916047,
-0.3222998977,
-0.3924363256,
-0.5145016909,
-0.607822001,
-0.0541076139,
0.3577140272,
-0.6953407526,
-0.5809276104,
0.0632292628,
-0.0413419418,
-0.0966407806,
-0.4233316779,
0.8329327703,
0.2986231446,
-0.4862078726,
0.3537476957,
-0.1480743587,
0.083023712,
-0.4424841702,
-0.0662704408,
0.3023512959,
-0.0701680332,
-0.440338701,
-1.0117651224,
0.6261312962,
-0.4872980714,
-0.4378608763,
-0.1494520158,
0.9337965846,
-0.2400307059,
-0.3035969734,
0.4891584218,
-0.0530041084,
0.12688528,
0.0310257692,
-0.3381767571,
-0.4588656723,
-0.2230446041,
0.1609488875,
0.1848724633,
1.0611337423,
-0.0982958376,
0.5994277596,
0.3486822844,
0.2320528924,
0.2264736742,
0.6854439378,
0.7624040246,
-0.1055421457,
-0.6720861793,
-0.5444699526,
0.35167557,
-0.6156046391,
-0.5500686765,
0.470933646,
0.2707256079,
0.4786254168,
0.0393826589,
0.9370346665,
-0.1925197691,
0.0165819656,
-0.4914909303,
0.9863324761,
0.0422734097,
-0.0325408578,
-0.4116481543,
-0.8393799067,
-0.0482858941,
0.0535708293,
-0.2880014479,
-0.3771163225,
0.8903613091,
0.3609030545,
-0.3162629306,
0.1010841206,
0.3258042336,
-0.0511946641,
0.1959745735,
0.3107328713,
0.5048826933,
-0.7575860023,
0.7658491731,
-0.7939092517,
-0.0568090379,
-0.0807946548,
-0.9662126899,
-0.8548653722,
-0.6039535403,
-0.3643888533,
-0.4798857272,
-0.2873119414,
0.658128202,
0.8008394837,
-0.5042350292,
0.4050555527,
-0.4673790038,
0.8293500543,
-0.2401301265,
-0.2240220457,
0.6034951806,
-0.2920287251,
-0.1516510695,
0.0670314208,
0.040701706,
-0.0410995111,
-0.0786815509,
-0.0862988681,
-0.002819241,
-0.1372015029,
0.500698328,
-0.4462736845,
-0.2062053382,
-0.7188249826,
-0.1422071308,
-0.0241597518,
-0.3761254251,
0.8486446738,
-0.6847125888,
0.307957083,
0.5590727329,
0.2852945626,
0.2082609981,
-0.1179940701,
0.5881755948,
-1.1377700567,
0.328323096,
-0.0276370794,
0.7072449327,
0.5823953152,
-0.8929423094,
0.2474460751,
0.515410006,
-0.449485302,
-0.3390918672,
0.4707544446,
-0.8317793608,
0.2289727777,
0.9384468198,
-0.2812471092,
-0.1081754342,
-0.6195004582,
-0.244732514,
0.6891676784,
-0.2870141268,
0.5909234285,
0.3288478255,
0.1090961322,
-0.2467803657,
-0.1377643347,
0.6572605968,
-0.294325918,
-0.8498510122,
-0.038265463,
-0.2198725194,
0.3232135773,
0.492080301,
0.7017790079,
0.4102632701,
0.0065150745,
-0.038644392,
-0.0068046898,
-0.1012501046,
-0.292576462,
0.4169138074,
0.7502818108,
-0.121421881,
-0.1254379153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08723v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08723v1
|
Token Prediction as Implicit Classification to Identify LLM-Generated Text
| 2023-11-15T06:33:52 | 2023-11-15T06:33:52 |
Yutian Chen, Hao Kang, Vivian Zhai, Liangze Li, Rita Singh, Bhiksha Raj
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces a novel approach for identifying the possible large
language models (LLMs) involved in text generation. Instead of adding an
additional classification layer to a base LM, we reframe the classification
task as a next-token prediction task and directly fine-tune the base LM to
perform it. We utilize the Text-to-Text Transfer Transformer (T5) model as the
backbone for our experiments. We compared our approach to the more direct
approach of utilizing hidden states for classification. Evaluation shows the
exceptional performance of our method in the text classification task,
highlighting its simplicity and efficiency. Furthermore, interpretability
studies on the features extracted by our model reveal its ability to
differentiate distinctive writing styles among various LLMs even in the absence
of an explicit classifier. We also collected a dataset named OpenLLMText,
containing approximately 340k text samples from human and LLMs, including
GPT3.5, PaLM, LLaMA, and GPT2.
|
[
0.1238363311,
-0.4839795232,
0.6500865221,
-0.1237997934,
-0.2426933795,
0.3892604411,
-0.2059856951,
-0.6654214859,
-0.0121921524,
0.5079550743,
-0.5687516332,
-0.7113896608,
-0.7241681814,
0.312419951,
-0.5939329863,
1.0713016987,
-0.221616596,
-0.0483825356,
-0.1238711029,
0.2703660131,
-0.4836198688,
-0.6551826596,
-0.6541585326,
-0.3054262102,
0.5817890763,
0.2901667058,
0.1497650295,
0.5634400845,
0.1965698004,
0.2356931567,
-0.2506535053,
0.0872059688,
-0.3707080781,
-0.0159887746,
0.0053418963,
-0.7382770181,
-0.2524901927,
0.0524339415,
0.6363424659,
0.3759714067,
0.3731780946,
0.2916188538,
0.0096536661,
0.1051458791,
-0.5028015971,
0.2604516447,
-0.9822098613,
0.2289860547,
-0.4077486694,
-0.1307577938,
-0.8516557813,
-0.3863384426,
-0.0606836267,
-0.1591817588,
0.479023844,
0.3649567664,
0.6051165462,
0.0112829208,
-0.6129767895,
-0.3122336566,
-0.7068793774,
0.7101176977,
-0.6010690928,
0.2397442013,
0.0600766502,
0.1872516274,
-0.1436499357,
-1.0359783173,
-0.9295233488,
-0.2362775505,
-0.2400823981,
-0.0049890615,
-0.1018562838,
0.0111246314,
0.1678390354,
0.2625475526,
-0.2882261872,
0.3595426977,
-0.3830247521,
-0.4544512331,
0.3364122808,
0.1919832528,
0.4763257802,
-0.2625571489,
-0.4591251314,
0.2224780768,
-0.792036891,
0.0440797545,
0.2770351171,
0.419187665,
-0.0260975044,
0.6950317025,
0.1606058776,
0.2350814044,
0.0263089575,
-0.2058762312,
0.2536875904,
-0.35005036,
-0.0885239467,
0.2989176214,
0.830812633,
0.0701685101,
0.260025084,
-0.149245128,
-0.4790885448,
0.0019108653,
0.1165392175,
-0.8203163743,
0.0686672255,
0.0576958656,
-0.4825315773,
-0.7263283134,
0.2438038886,
-0.5451897383,
-0.622867465,
-0.177014038,
0.2974293232,
-0.0390367955,
-0.2089857757,
-0.3212578297,
-0.0981168374,
-0.0306244008,
0.2002437562,
-1.0488351583,
0.4401074648,
0.7447654009,
0.8691529036,
-0.5784949064,
-0.1375524253,
-0.4204398692,
0.3230687976,
-0.4387637377,
0.7592548728,
-0.5659142733,
-0.2918415666,
0.287463516,
0.0001527836,
0.0067073926,
-0.2543869019,
0.870880127,
-0.4480126798,
0.2958829701,
-0.0048759421,
-0.4617705941,
-0.0616443418,
0.0106624635,
-0.9607416391,
1.2390578985,
0.0000842011,
-1.0384932756,
0.6254664063,
-0.6287223101,
-0.4307075143,
0.0793252289,
-0.0371103399,
-0.5659081936,
0.3539071977,
0.1293543726,
0.7851483226,
-0.2292602509,
0.2521933019,
-0.1697234213,
-0.5607292056,
0.5634765029,
-0.6723314524,
0.2678898275,
0.0135265216,
-0.4593467116,
0.4077240527,
-0.814904213,
-0.1150090173,
-0.0397091545,
-0.4446122646,
-0.1334524304,
-0.1041023061,
0.2972602248,
0.253878206,
0.4333003461,
-0.8512109518,
0.3179346025,
-0.3742521703,
0.4574536979,
1.0069512129,
-0.1064345315,
0.4141143262,
0.0002889487,
0.443413198,
0.1597082764,
-0.0506670848,
-0.3023824096,
-0.4609486461,
-0.8784288168,
-0.260332495,
0.5835213065,
0.4052318335,
-0.4806966484,
0.3568329811,
-0.5141667128,
-0.3622715175,
-0.3328449726,
-0.0995775834,
0.425503999,
0.3655048013,
0.2424105108,
0.1468225867,
-0.6562657356,
-0.6562741995,
-0.3347980082,
-0.2202346623,
0.1586066186,
0.135142833,
0.5114589334,
-0.3113346398,
0.8028950095,
-0.5289779902,
-0.1693155468,
-0.4150257409,
0.3073432148,
0.1479673684,
0.3176609874,
0.3309747279,
-0.5721831918,
-0.4504592121,
0.1830864698,
-0.4366084635,
-0.2133467346,
-0.1115645319,
0.0522725545,
0.6335965991,
0.9481804967,
-0.4977582097,
0.4668957591,
0.4400742054,
-0.5078315139,
0.4155076146,
-0.0578483678,
-0.3463913798,
-1.249235034,
0.2473504096,
-0.1729470044,
-0.2179611921,
-0.6480826139,
-0.27827847,
0.2679730058,
-0.1116171256,
-0.2405320257,
0.9483522177,
-0.5753169656,
-0.1373681575,
-0.2673440576,
-0.2740562856,
-0.3407682776,
0.5284673572,
0.026377935,
0.8122474551,
0.1846598089,
-0.2397465259,
0.0391444005,
0.0369341969,
-0.2447632551,
-0.1650470644,
-0.4678642452,
0.4277102649,
-0.191272378,
0.3715355694,
-1.3178480864,
-0.0703333393,
0.2110259235,
-0.5409155488,
0.4924108386,
-0.015511605,
-0.7100499868,
-0.4078655541,
-0.1987995356,
0.2261747569,
0.4931921363,
-0.5340826511,
0.7916808128,
0.0599298514,
-0.2475650012,
-0.6551920176,
-0.5973914266,
0.1427907497,
-0.1800764501,
-0.0908276364,
0.435061723,
0.0249110907,
0.1746882647,
-0.1113266498,
-0.0183067508,
0.030406408,
0.1732535958,
0.6381493211,
0.3991151452,
-0.1190005764,
0.2988985777,
0.4379784465,
-0.2613903582,
0.0498710945,
-0.4563670158,
0.5640660524,
0.0073773861,
-0.1302294433,
-0.4814607203,
0.1526589543,
0.6440755129,
-0.1497114301,
0.7612915039,
0.897079885,
-0.2573310137,
-0.4582110941,
-0.3690945506,
-0.0656601638,
-0.4390729964,
0.3773207664,
-0.5356267095,
-0.8765245676,
0.4141238928,
-0.1913591623,
0.0845965892,
0.5918087959,
0.6248790622,
0.272655189,
1.1154044867,
1.0373045206,
-0.191918686,
0.5125247836,
0.0505520366,
0.1057718769,
-0.5704737306,
-0.4290986657,
-0.5935248137,
-0.2297164947,
-0.6931522489,
-0.2419031262,
0.0770893246,
0.03792518,
-0.2372239679,
0.125700444,
-0.3004054427,
0.5422558784,
0.43713063,
-0.1365231425,
0.3536713719,
0.1536997855,
-0.5704390407,
0.0604609363,
-0.3953211904,
-0.6603184938,
1.3838750124,
0.5459432006,
0.2806063592,
0.0324547961,
0.7592358589,
0.3144404888,
0.8941156864,
-0.8000712991,
0.5836743116,
-0.2326106727,
-0.3658714294,
-0.177295506,
-0.2205827683,
-0.9457861185,
0.0011116739,
-0.4146572053,
-0.7279349566,
-0.3955677748,
-0.0952671617,
-0.0588262863,
0.2700101137,
-0.7075707912,
0.5477854609,
-0.0852328241,
-0.0848472491,
0.2134223282,
-0.4508361816,
0.2935706675,
-0.4174914956,
0.1382198632,
-0.0574937277,
-0.4355097413,
0.7732475996,
-0.2022130489,
1.1753065586,
0.0017531008,
-0.274394244,
0.1229346097,
-0.0048370408,
0.561847806,
-0.181493178,
-0.1366457641,
0.1470157653,
-0.3230441511,
-0.0988550782,
-0.6361763477,
0.6406360865,
-0.868478179,
-0.3862304688,
-0.2935196757,
-0.3441779912,
-0.1655222178,
0.6254449487,
0.4572844505,
0.4750768542,
-0.1596103758,
-0.1413499564,
0.4133992195,
-0.0249931589,
0.7572004199,
0.3744926453,
-0.3682737648,
-0.4289306998,
0.8569574952,
-0.0685720965,
-0.0603541955,
0.6924763918,
0.3340712488,
-0.6656109095,
-0.8981834054,
-0.360150069,
0.2413781434,
-0.7600263953,
-0.1680838764,
-0.5402873158,
-0.2668848932,
-0.3828631341,
0.0404242314,
0.0191679858,
-0.3671605885,
-0.7393411398,
-0.4114369154,
0.162179172,
1.2281346321,
0.4443789721,
0.3533449769,
-0.7231078148,
0.0909668058,
0.0206952766,
0.4352294505,
0.1008910388,
-0.5332034826,
0.0003081796,
-0.3800373077,
-0.1294907331,
-0.7732956409,
0.4970389903,
0.1820451766,
0.6343683004,
0.3738015592,
-0.0395752601,
0.2569321096,
-0.6902503371,
0.8277531266,
0.4235718846,
-1.1748305559,
0.4020119309,
-0.2310561091,
0.0000220354,
0.2340609729,
0.3561857641,
-0.4018904865,
-0.3903957009,
-0.5713140965,
-0.8299995065,
0.5744377971,
0.1597842127,
0.3259712458,
0.0027892904,
0.5428856611,
0.4113869667,
0.3653890491,
-1.0353890657,
-0.0949684381,
-0.0256121177,
-0.6789807677,
-0.2239358723,
-0.440702647,
0.263667345,
-0.1128113046,
0.2808562219,
-0.4344194531,
0.4320889711,
-0.0664586127,
-0.0440385155,
-0.0947651863,
0.2236269861,
0.8180109859,
0.4126524925,
0.0297277067,
0.3345687091,
0.3226152062,
-0.6870913506,
0.1074028984,
-0.1939036846,
-0.1615507305,
0.1603389531,
0.6576733589,
0.9778711796,
0.1339964122,
-0.5241221189,
0.6972295046,
-0.136297822,
-0.2564713359,
-0.4635186791,
0.0364556983,
-0.0649468973,
0.1868522167,
0.4822348058,
0.1121481806,
-0.0243201256,
-0.4921607673,
0.0581994765,
0.3147858083,
-0.67463696,
-0.5813081264,
0.6209241748,
0.3293640316,
-0.2271784544,
0.3312044442,
0.022268597,
-0.7244970798,
0.4223087132,
0.8708899021,
1.2460078001,
-0.031201506,
0.0212817155,
0.2082622945,
0.1396466345,
-0.0033506099,
0.1938118488,
0.0431078114,
-0.7842515111,
-0.4876520336,
-0.8110286593,
-0.106901221,
0.327450037,
-0.356123805,
0.4516818821,
-0.5739309788,
-0.145585224,
0.0903733373,
0.0732716396,
-0.4983866215,
0.0635391176,
0.5225220323,
0.7665815353,
-1.0180603266,
0.9912322164,
0.636416018,
-0.2352588922,
-0.8090559244,
0.380148828,
-0.179839164,
-0.7952385545,
1.1364566088,
0.4787860513,
-0.2325434089,
0.0959328562,
-0.6858052611,
-0.8117575049,
1.1417671442,
0.1951509714,
-0.4662479758,
-0.0709550977,
0.2304542363,
0.6166630387,
-0.3989168108,
0.4301563501,
0.4612437487,
0.3585122228,
0.2450531423,
-1.0527075529,
0.3928705752,
-0.2783507109,
0.2878932655,
0.3032661378,
-0.3599209189,
1.0148495436,
-0.3950167894,
-0.4631074071,
0.2659339905,
0.9143840671,
0.192033574,
0.2107636482,
0.2950831652,
0.0623644255,
0.9871709347,
-0.0276638959,
0.9150580764,
-0.1413517147,
0.1693613231,
0.6896855831,
-0.1941884607,
1.1249449253,
0.4280736744,
-0.0012346552,
0.6918962598,
0.5397763252,
-0.0121857626,
0.347448498,
0.4152016044,
-0.2578135133,
0.0382024758,
-0.1197525933,
-0.1029510647,
0.4196862876,
0.2193876952,
-0.6245724559,
0.1495931,
-0.0106294472,
0.1415177137,
-0.1085140929,
-0.5498324633,
0.8402549028,
-0.0518994965,
-0.5548843741,
0.4520046711,
0.3124904037,
0.9232154489,
-0.2274085879,
-0.1487073302,
-0.1410351545,
0.3770274818,
-0.2834693491,
-0.8562617898,
-0.0037805606,
0.0145750102,
-0.3029467762,
-0.3063102663,
1.0687795877,
-0.4109082222,
-0.6622164845,
0.0132084703,
0.3909298778,
0.0234416574,
0.0324671306,
-0.2672124803,
0.005136997,
0.0885327384,
-0.2715724409,
0.3014600575,
0.6591206789,
-0.3771208227,
0.5817024708,
0.8453692794,
0.127929613,
0.1893058568,
-0.0469612777,
0.7855497599,
-0.8444339633,
-0.6275163889,
-0.9336441755,
0.3289409876,
-0.0074299383,
-0.4361155629,
0.5802548528,
0.4792426527,
0.515319705,
-0.297401309,
1.0585548878,
0.4128918946,
0.6988736391,
-0.7451210618,
0.7643950582,
-0.27681005,
0.2273662537,
-0.2983327508,
-0.7449128628,
-0.2378493547,
0.1006796435,
-0.2035299391,
-0.0183677431,
0.9335103035,
0.4663460553,
0.1488546133,
0.037957307,
0.1719373018,
0.1446130723,
0.3118633628,
0.3797659576,
0.9850302935,
-0.3654437065,
0.7373899817,
0.1718906164,
0.0106713828,
-0.189417094,
-1.0195982456,
-1.2669968605,
-0.6917973757,
0.0075999596,
-0.269957751,
-0.2740110755,
0.6911330819,
0.4810382128,
-0.8152900338,
0.004681868,
-0.415574193,
0.0707040653,
0.0709284469,
-0.20080401,
0.4500560462,
-0.255141288,
-0.9040212035,
0.08807794,
-0.111781776,
0.4191567898,
-0.2913280129,
0.1665925384,
0.3844122887,
0.0650905147,
0.7518638968,
-0.1025961787,
-0.8989223242,
-0.3225394189,
0.1069555655,
-0.2801505625,
-0.1721952856,
1.0915830135,
-0.825030148,
-0.0628833175,
0.4807703495,
0.5217974186,
0.5404012203,
-0.1719228476,
0.5500684381,
-1.0156670809,
0.0621190667,
0.1973981261,
0.2437624633,
0.1064485908,
-0.5257384181,
0.1783691943,
0.2400861382,
-0.1583690792,
-0.8969153166,
0.1204541773,
-0.9915323853,
-0.3768420219,
1.4774973392,
-0.0869047865,
-0.3625965416,
-0.195653677,
-0.497392416,
0.3536460698,
-0.4964908361,
0.5244154334,
0.5161291957,
0.038347967,
-0.3618963957,
-0.3637041748,
0.6979523897,
0.0647148713,
-0.9039832354,
0.1645589918,
0.3174394667,
0.3898304701,
0.2294653356,
0.5148524642,
-0.0221356619,
-0.1581495404,
-0.0004609137,
0.1153824106,
-0.331938684,
-0.4573561549,
-0.2030809373,
0.5257880092,
0.1464525014,
-0.06774012
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08719v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08719v1
|
Think-in-Memory: Recalling and Post-thinking Enable LLMs with Long-Term Memory
| 2023-11-15T06:08:35 | 2023-11-15T06:08:35 |
Lei Liu, Xiaoyan Yang, Yue Shen, Binbin Hu, Zhiqiang Zhang, Jinjie Gu, Guannan Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Memory-augmented Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable
performance in long-term human-machine interactions, which basically relies on
iterative recalling and reasoning of history to generate high-quality
responses. However, such repeated recall-reason steps easily produce biased
thoughts, \textit{i.e.}, inconsistent reasoning results when recalling the same
history for different questions. On the contrary, humans can keep thoughts in
the memory and recall them without repeated reasoning. Motivated by this human
capability, we propose a novel memory mechanism called TiM (Think-in-Memory)
that enables LLMs to maintain an evolved memory for storing historical thoughts
along the conversation stream. The TiM framework consists of two crucial
stages: (1) before generating a response, a LLM agent recalls relevant thoughts
from memory, and (2) after generating a response, the LLM agent post-thinks and
incorporates both historical and new thoughts to update the memory. Thus, TiM
can eliminate the issue of repeated reasoning by saving the post-thinking
thoughts as the history. Besides, we formulate the basic principles to organize
the thoughts in memory based on the well-established operations,
(\textit{i.e.}, insert, forget, and merge operations), allowing for dynamic
updates and evolution of the thoughts. Furthermore, we introduce
Locality-Sensitive Hashing into TiM to achieve efficient retrieval for the
long-term conversations. We conduct qualitative and quantitative experiments on
real-world and simulated dialogues covering a wide range of topics,
demonstrating that equipping existing LLMs with TiM significantly enhances
their performance in generating responses for long-term interactions.
|
[
-0.579153657,
-1.1965154409,
0.7604407668,
-0.158174023,
-0.4174889922,
0.2586318552,
-0.2730894983,
-0.5680616498,
0.4088331163,
0.540707469,
-0.4514722824,
-0.0257826038,
-0.1439478695,
-0.1865334362,
-0.1461006105,
0.7865284681,
-0.1424040347,
-0.1794668585,
-0.0823763907,
-0.2499687374,
-0.5367493629,
-0.7512080669,
-1.1852039099,
-0.6267022491,
0.5939663053,
0.1289074868,
0.6402989626,
0.3356373012,
0.3261895776,
0.2169650942,
-0.1421471685,
0.4713779092,
-0.6515158415,
0.4058019817,
-0.2978509665,
-0.7293816209,
-0.7035042644,
-0.2815778255,
0.5939772129,
0.3335165381,
-0.2944594026,
-0.0785938799,
0.0866350755,
0.6287806034,
-0.4211473465,
-0.1351559311,
-0.9353855252,
0.150931567,
-0.0479577109,
-0.5771101117,
-0.4240379333,
-0.4358303547,
0.1132755429,
-0.0959401056,
-0.0465377867,
0.2028334588,
0.6111793518,
0.0142290276,
-0.0443474576,
-0.3251428604,
-0.9355578423,
0.716858089,
-0.646293819,
0.3871771991,
0.4351551533,
0.1769791692,
-0.3580323458,
-0.6911124587,
-0.7977373004,
-0.0797787979,
0.1708801538,
0.2085126787,
0.0479962938,
0.0795029402,
0.1766617894,
0.3039081991,
-0.324587971,
-0.1472600251,
-0.1260007769,
-0.0689177811,
0.1057139561,
0.3006221056,
0.1327255219,
0.171943441,
-0.7369311452,
0.2123083174,
-0.8437559009,
0.0101605328,
-0.1327469051,
0.2389953434,
0.2926626503,
0.1647501737,
0.247496739,
0.273633033,
0.0969262049,
-0.021911297,
0.0365979485,
-0.2716448009,
-0.3326199353,
0.0162382238,
0.8566030264,
0.1628141701,
0.4206620753,
-0.2987723649,
-0.3076706827,
-0.1946122944,
0.5053421259,
-0.7171576619,
-0.0682188198,
0.1866781712,
-0.4171086848,
0.0726751089,
-0.2434115112,
-0.598162353,
-0.0511873104,
-0.1651558131,
0.7170500755,
-0.6237552762,
-0.2888854146,
0.2639098465,
-0.0736089721,
0.2359353155,
0.3655887246,
-0.763102591,
0.6730064154,
0.6063680053,
0.6291509271,
-0.2032896876,
-0.5078129172,
-0.4561834037,
0.5130921602,
-0.346647501,
0.9396485686,
-0.5861335397,
-0.4014572203,
0.0735868961,
-0.223011896,
0.1957961321,
-0.8398103714,
0.2490558624,
-0.668851614,
0.3738029599,
-0.5940561295,
-0.5521891713,
-0.1219070107,
0.5657729506,
-0.470777899,
1.4219255447,
-0.0883060768,
-0.7223413587,
0.2659192085,
-0.7311477065,
-0.442186743,
0.0584655926,
-0.1364139169,
-0.4399476349,
0.1187500134,
0.1975510716,
0.325076133,
-0.4622155726,
0.4371487796,
-0.3095974624,
-0.6818935275,
0.6368923783,
-0.3353647888,
0.5076349378,
0.1176243499,
-0.2543708384,
0.0323536545,
-0.0660997778,
-0.0021577282,
0.1143414974,
-0.3784230053,
-0.2833744884,
0.0724621937,
-0.4309517145,
0.1284976155,
0.2558144331,
-0.5657806993,
0.0691910088,
-0.3842919469,
0.6632367969,
0.7650268078,
0.2930895686,
0.3359172046,
-0.7395011783,
0.2015625536,
0.3929829299,
0.2382080406,
-0.5509428978,
-0.0892346129,
-0.9016965628,
-0.0123253223,
-0.2837876081,
0.5403429866,
-0.7211378217,
0.1340884715,
-0.3220696151,
-0.05985149,
-0.3759889901,
0.2036564052,
0.2205015421,
0.3392041028,
0.2748152614,
-0.4097923934,
-0.7552719116,
-0.7739098668,
-0.1936120987,
-0.3604857326,
0.2345235646,
0.2946952581,
0.3725332022,
-0.2031606734,
1.0134181976,
-0.3709768951,
0.0787721053,
-0.4962416887,
-0.0904892236,
0.0000540816,
0.1945391744,
0.2613112032,
-0.5191630721,
-0.0802972764,
-0.3248167932,
-0.7729346752,
0.4116851687,
-0.2964565754,
-0.3994650245,
0.2942454815,
0.4246902764,
-1.0899461508,
0.1445315331,
-0.2959176004,
0.1032808647,
0.1946317255,
-0.3863521814,
0.2128053606,
-1.4028215408,
-0.2523106933,
-0.329122901,
-0.3251081705,
-0.3397297263,
-0.0907156542,
0.0316395015,
-0.1420692503,
-0.5295991302,
0.6558389664,
-0.4733191133,
-0.0422233306,
-0.3506139815,
0.3310522139,
-0.1457775384,
0.6310730577,
-0.0394008607,
0.8978769779,
0.383569777,
-0.6451919675,
0.1905076355,
-0.0171376094,
-0.2016927153,
0.6493634582,
-0.2553303242,
0.8592093587,
-0.2760392427,
0.4719734788,
-0.8952923417,
0.2525572479,
0.2090557814,
-0.3703491092,
0.4642548859,
0.2690215707,
-0.9065591693,
-0.3612338901,
-0.5043222904,
0.2943026423,
0.5383635163,
-0.4947601855,
0.8191741109,
0.465582341,
-0.3408641219,
-0.5127621889,
-0.746424675,
0.3626514375,
-0.4859526157,
-0.1834229976,
0.2995395064,
-0.3481684029,
-0.2758623958,
0.2065460533,
-0.0958289579,
0.0576311648,
-0.0741193965,
0.1525641084,
0.2836036384,
-0.1650332958,
0.3566908538,
-0.1185551062,
0.0414686725,
0.145100683,
-0.5160874724,
0.882499218,
-0.0571946539,
-0.1275129467,
-0.3712101579,
0.3269424438,
0.6545298696,
-0.1144517511,
0.6221384406,
0.3560527265,
-0.5188296437,
-0.4790991545,
-0.9210300446,
-0.3714903891,
-0.4827177525,
0.332123816,
-0.4364551902,
-1.059671998,
0.6878391504,
-0.3748847246,
0.1259630024,
0.001384697,
0.6354295015,
-0.7861383557,
0.3353135288,
0.4130349755,
-0.3557405472,
0.6508046389,
-0.1557977647,
0.3322254121,
-0.9939371943,
-0.0916674584,
0.0102298185,
-0.5594306588,
-0.0926540419,
-0.5831141472,
0.1165912673,
-0.0382262282,
-0.6145934463,
0.0959106162,
-0.2131952792,
0.686494112,
0.5016543865,
0.3155309558,
0.063495785,
-0.1323527247,
0.0418551676,
-0.0883986577,
-0.3901896775,
-0.4752166867,
1.1223919392,
0.3007621169,
0.7344434857,
0.0109436465,
1.0547692776,
0.323647052,
0.3713283837,
-0.6328235269,
1.0111162663,
0.2109419107,
-0.5006235838,
-0.1540558636,
-0.2804352343,
-0.9800168276,
0.0701640323,
0.1197194383,
-0.8753913641,
-0.3880963326,
0.1161461845,
-0.4246041179,
0.771173954,
-0.3478020132,
0.1325869113,
-0.3286325634,
-0.4716142118,
-0.5608980656,
-0.5008682013,
0.2495592535,
-0.0626169592,
-0.0876799822,
0.2426146865,
-0.0759231672,
0.623237133,
-0.1427435428,
0.8321493268,
-0.1300881356,
0.1889613867,
0.7119419575,
0.2371775359,
0.6741440892,
-0.2189335227,
0.045624204,
-0.1356308609,
-0.2604352832,
-0.1727189124,
-0.7855484486,
0.6582110524,
-0.6349723935,
-0.7503304482,
-0.2492640615,
-0.6745656133,
-0.1547328085,
0.0145995654,
-0.203855142,
0.358089745,
-0.3485817015,
0.0036157449,
1.0238741636,
-0.113018088,
0.7044222951,
0.5389229059,
-0.5399438739,
-0.6979497075,
0.6607707143,
0.2903494239,
0.29440552,
0.6843906641,
0.0455677249,
-0.1981221884,
-0.6229219437,
-0.1173624545,
0.4215137362,
-0.6198093891,
-0.1645325422,
-0.7287077904,
-0.2539061606,
0.2180869877,
-0.0625048503,
-0.217820555,
-0.1674213409,
0.061964497,
-0.3411862254,
0.3139591515,
0.6514180899,
0.2726967335,
0.0235322211,
-0.5713878274,
0.3655116558,
0.3757280707,
0.3227311075,
0.3611392081,
-0.3002070487,
-0.3422008753,
0.10967163,
-0.4983366132,
-0.7166224718,
0.2353589088,
-0.1085674986,
0.5904937387,
0.1110935584,
-0.1855458766,
0.8841333389,
-0.5012043715,
0.7426947355,
-0.068231754,
-0.6683784127,
0.717869401,
-0.2992405891,
0.4897761345,
0.4766341448,
-0.0406356379,
-0.475594461,
-0.5577092171,
-0.5592978001,
-0.648159802,
0.5077533126,
-0.0042530051,
0.3065785766,
-0.4792855978,
0.7380854487,
0.1647915542,
0.1638376117,
-0.5332072377,
-0.1107236221,
0.214501515,
0.0040818322,
0.0585385934,
-0.6259607673,
-0.156711325,
-0.1610933244,
0.5284798145,
0.1369267851,
0.7026686668,
0.1772637367,
-0.1306397915,
-0.2128634155,
0.3728981614,
0.5942513943,
0.672958076,
-0.5376803875,
0.4947699606,
0.6413089037,
-0.4220605493,
0.0018253544,
-0.2811463475,
-0.0100300284,
-0.2000344694,
0.0327777825,
0.5421156287,
0.4065521359,
-0.5927269459,
0.0916887373,
-0.1240452528,
-0.0649743825,
-0.7170855403,
0.0617631339,
0.4800055921,
0.4852487147,
0.501188159,
0.1483080834,
-0.1867646277,
-1.1271235943,
0.2954632044,
0.4299898446,
-0.2954885662,
-0.3933499753,
0.6816747785,
-0.0343017168,
-0.7195711732,
0.7232071161,
-0.168693319,
-0.536319077,
0.2750559747,
0.9239473939,
1.1062785387,
-0.1032058001,
-0.176261723,
0.2803720236,
0.1703583747,
-0.256388098,
0.7857914567,
-0.3657397926,
-0.8365015388,
-0.279610008,
-0.4073606431,
-0.4312104583,
0.2172582448,
-0.5448003411,
-0.1775317043,
-0.6714619398,
-0.6408923268,
-0.4752877057,
0.1040642485,
-0.68064183,
0.0628957152,
0.1998468339,
0.8479041457,
-0.3920137584,
1.2125474215,
0.4367654026,
-0.2208452076,
-0.3938146532,
0.1948135197,
-0.0875824466,
-0.8607541919,
0.597324729,
0.1427009255,
-0.5894064903,
-0.1451949924,
-0.4246773124,
-0.7434737682,
1.2312440872,
0.4487989843,
-0.533544302,
-0.0094150528,
0.0980351642,
0.5161130428,
-0.3708946407,
0.1932991594,
0.4251421094,
0.0673900247,
0.1793317646,
-0.8914002776,
0.0916904435,
-0.2518895566,
-0.1182033867,
0.7142861485,
-0.8419810534,
0.7633922696,
-0.3859787583,
-0.3115214705,
-0.0896715596,
0.7684999108,
0.3642672896,
0.3394075036,
0.2426708639,
0.838730514,
0.9451111555,
-0.0236982368,
0.9136103988,
-0.2167996317,
-0.0672605485,
1.3881459236,
-0.3816077411,
1.2343719006,
0.5388009548,
-0.1637047082,
0.394733578,
0.3567075133,
0.4215435088,
0.4775681794,
0.0281178094,
-0.4598011374,
-0.1659578979,
-0.0206755921,
-0.0779090375,
0.1135148481,
0.4945765138,
-0.3020245731,
0.1547834873,
-0.0855797008,
0.325039804,
-0.0089584058,
-0.2602901757,
0.9812430143,
0.3006824255,
-0.8522681594,
0.418590486,
-0.5238407254,
0.6784531474,
-0.6332933903,
-0.0231691319,
-0.420904994,
0.3814465106,
0.2357938886,
-1.0433155298,
0.3578468561,
-0.136947453,
-0.2632538378,
-0.4553924203,
0.6423362494,
-0.5472265482,
-0.0875205472,
0.4108675122,
0.696054697,
0.1877752244,
0.1576005071,
-0.6091874242,
0.1501022875,
-0.1437038034,
-0.2368975729,
0.5644195676,
0.6083865166,
-0.115519926,
0.9870405793,
0.4687906802,
0.1498310715,
-0.2875360847,
0.2599945664,
0.8548930287,
-1.1646894217,
-0.3456354439,
-1.2452077866,
0.2620356083,
-0.0473548099,
-0.0461345688,
0.3776732981,
0.8292223215,
0.7455088496,
0.3875416815,
0.6652810574,
0.3718909323,
0.4917990267,
-0.4907885492,
0.5463082194,
-0.1981028169,
0.2281419337,
-0.136355713,
-0.8425691128,
-0.0192972962,
0.2619153857,
-0.2230109423,
0.0864319354,
0.8370751739,
0.6848070025,
0.0874233767,
0.1989513934,
0.1645286977,
0.3131417334,
0.449919343,
0.9060214162,
1.125408411,
-0.1262001395,
0.4914456904,
0.1365006119,
0.236050874,
0.1897706836,
-0.5675140023,
-1.0501064062,
-0.6370198131,
-0.0393132344,
-0.1199418455,
0.2913596332,
1.1030718088,
0.4418946207,
-0.404204458,
-0.4204804003,
0.0877426043,
-0.0607310347,
-0.2008710504,
-0.1832644045,
0.4692023396,
-0.3995023072,
-0.4138983786,
0.3159630597,
0.8567306399,
0.1680824608,
-0.2712596953,
-0.0880428553,
-0.1454132348,
0.4433456957,
0.6358813047,
0.1258880347,
-0.945610702,
-0.5025312901,
-0.0573622771,
-0.1079777032,
0.4822584987,
0.8070993423,
-1.1162488461,
0.7213457823,
0.2105392218,
0.6208657622,
0.7903339863,
-0.0811648592,
0.6506208777,
-0.2228926569,
0.0872481614,
0.403930217,
0.5014925599,
0.3100916445,
-0.1915651411,
0.2565628588,
-0.0326045044,
-0.5556966066,
-0.8002021313,
0.3139456809,
-0.952411294,
-0.321790874,
0.6871752143,
0.0300847683,
-0.1411085576,
-0.1108656302,
-0.3849045336,
0.243706733,
-0.4536904395,
0.9282134175,
0.6750939488,
-0.3712565899,
-0.6001663208,
-0.5610540509,
0.4270598292,
0.3064131737,
-0.7712976336,
0.0837187916,
0.0973344445,
0.3374766409,
-0.0822872892,
1.1698893309,
-0.1054892465,
0.1667466164,
0.0532712899,
-0.1169566959,
-0.0840378031,
-0.1976163387,
0.1773428321,
0.3100122809,
0.167873919,
-0.1869055629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08718v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08718v2
|
Decomposing Uncertainty for Large Language Models through Input Clarification Ensembling
| 2023-11-15T05:58:35 | 2024-06-10T21:17:24 |
Bairu Hou, Yujian Liu, Kaizhi Qian, Jacob Andreas, Shiyu Chang, Yang Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Uncertainty decomposition refers to the task of decomposing the total
uncertainty of a predictive model into aleatoric (data) uncertainty, resulting
from inherent randomness in the data-generating process, and epistemic (model)
uncertainty, resulting from missing information in the model's training data.
In large language models (LLMs) specifically, identifying sources of
uncertainty is an important step toward improving reliability, trustworthiness,
and interpretability, but remains an important open research question. In this
paper, we introduce an uncertainty decomposition framework for LLMs, called
input clarification ensembling, which can be applied to any pre-trained LLM.
Our approach generates a set of clarifications for the input, feeds them into
an LLM, and ensembles the corresponding predictions. We show that, when
aleatoric uncertainty arises from ambiguity or under-specification in LLM
inputs, this approach makes it possible to factor an (unclarified) LLM's
predictions into separate aleatoric and epistemic terms, using a decomposition
similar to the one employed by Bayesian neural networks. Empirical evaluations
demonstrate that input clarification ensembling provides accurate and reliable
uncertainty quantification on several language processing tasks. Code and data
are available at https://github.com/UCSB-NLP-Chang/llm_uncertainty.
|
[
-0.333278954,
-1.1305912733,
0.9391545057,
0.1256892234,
-0.2678844631,
-0.0138130281,
-0.5543893576,
-0.2977448404,
-0.1914685667,
0.5648233891,
-0.607209146,
-0.3553133011,
-0.7094843984,
-0.0424903184,
-0.4960267842,
0.5595781803,
-0.395501107,
-0.1058663428,
-0.3537637591,
0.0236080494,
-0.1042269766,
-0.4822060466,
-0.6086043119,
-0.3919960856,
0.2405502647,
0.3087346554,
0.6253798008,
0.7190033197,
0.4432898164,
0.3824130595,
-0.3323743343,
0.1350207329,
-0.2611834705,
0.6146818995,
-0.0623268895,
-0.6184471846,
0.0524915531,
-0.3671370149,
0.8515367508,
1.019487381,
-0.2034110576,
0.3428269625,
0.1286040246,
0.2343935966,
-0.9053350687,
0.2227366567,
-0.5455222726,
-0.0589203984,
-0.2125195712,
-0.0452997684,
-0.4005768001,
-0.4503420293,
-0.0215018522,
-0.4122852385,
0.1018459275,
-0.0635394305,
0.8422206044,
0.6850178838,
-0.0369925015,
-0.2738507092,
-1.0505225658,
0.6017411947,
-0.7432312369,
0.5767734647,
0.5016926527,
0.1596684307,
-0.2169794887,
-0.5869650841,
-0.5225300193,
0.2373013645,
-0.0685223043,
-0.0256723352,
-0.191517964,
0.2378112823,
0.0682557523,
0.1704371721,
-0.31574893,
0.0961397886,
-0.4242153466,
-0.2022696733,
0.4047242105,
-0.2580936253,
0.1598478705,
0.4376218021,
-0.1566817611,
0.0022727503,
-0.9133278131,
-0.0615548342,
0.4414895475,
0.0476402566,
0.1142597795,
0.7216647863,
-0.1588179618,
0.7876278758,
0.2534918487,
-0.1136156768,
0.1387112141,
-0.2234080136,
-0.3415620625,
-0.0456657708,
0.7138765454,
0.0348045453,
0.0678380653,
-0.0840674862,
-0.2664624453,
-0.1065012291,
-0.0282714926,
-0.5814936757,
-0.0493322201,
0.496712327,
-0.2098863423,
-0.1931818873,
-0.2709031999,
-0.4818428457,
-0.4048484862,
-0.3055721223,
0.3478223979,
-0.4337487817,
-0.1852656454,
0.1484790742,
0.1435416043,
0.1803192794,
0.609515965,
-0.6904815435,
0.1432739943,
0.7810788155,
0.6022673249,
0.1149956062,
-0.2322498411,
-0.328325808,
0.0453821458,
-0.3167587221,
0.4952719212,
-0.5463766456,
-0.1551402658,
0.1368573606,
-0.1143941954,
-0.2190172523,
-0.6610609293,
0.3972503543,
-0.5011038184,
0.0389741845,
0.1904528737,
-0.7578558326,
-0.297127068,
0.2972460687,
-0.7008097768,
0.8417001963,
0.0200763121,
-0.587846458,
0.2063442767,
-0.4105315506,
-0.3223800361,
0.137482807,
-0.1376442313,
-0.4395367801,
0.3527919948,
0.2890182436,
0.5483872294,
-0.2728507817,
0.653994143,
-0.4773181379,
-0.1160451844,
0.486597687,
-0.5799378753,
0.6407195926,
0.3251219988,
0.020204708,
-0.0794400796,
-0.8604040146,
0.0701925755,
-0.1719628423,
-0.4272588491,
-0.015959898,
0.2178810686,
-0.3289141655,
-0.0690470785,
0.4833970964,
-0.5338754058,
-0.1768909842,
-0.7229030728,
0.5718255639,
0.573745966,
0.280328393,
0.6275035143,
-0.0521037579,
0.5458773375,
-0.0068405825,
-0.0331985764,
-0.1023518965,
-0.3559060395,
-0.8600303531,
-0.0094535202,
0.471367687,
0.519723773,
-0.7052260041,
0.5992013216,
0.0225853305,
-0.2585372627,
-0.7742874026,
0.0721186474,
0.2760876417,
0.3843654394,
0.1499137282,
0.1617871374,
-0.5769941211,
-0.9543274045,
-0.222081542,
-0.4847167134,
-0.3412484527,
-0.444160372,
0.5287640691,
-0.324450016,
0.8772640228,
-0.2453865409,
0.1564755738,
-0.2390467227,
0.2955881953,
-0.0526758134,
0.5229020715,
0.02628747,
-0.5898916125,
-0.0859922096,
0.0574011542,
-0.3506637514,
-0.0933704302,
-0.1459294409,
0.0036514443,
0.0582334474,
0.7251321673,
-0.8127797842,
0.5989064574,
0.4305311739,
0.0835999921,
0.4841447473,
-0.1002602428,
-0.1911930591,
-0.8977050781,
0.0270960853,
-0.2090641707,
-0.3659438789,
-0.4213915765,
0.4501026273,
-0.0174230114,
0.062428128,
-0.2749394476,
0.3264034986,
-0.4039815068,
0.1434288919,
-0.0711090714,
0.1272529513,
0.0544177592,
0.3251165152,
0.2295541465,
0.3649086356,
0.641972065,
-0.6112672687,
0.380985111,
-0.1087288782,
-0.4484921396,
0.2171290517,
-0.6865538955,
-0.0403462611,
-0.2173715234,
0.0828123763,
-0.9153441191,
-0.4027166069,
0.4576006234,
-0.5824479461,
0.3722119927,
-0.2743250132,
-0.6577162147,
0.0153732682,
0.0346551612,
0.5574228764,
0.4187434912,
-0.3927755654,
0.5974695683,
0.3482742012,
-0.3662837148,
-0.6904157996,
-0.7909927368,
-0.3936014473,
-0.2024639994,
-0.5685762167,
0.1616250128,
-0.0651119426,
-0.6119357347,
0.04830762,
-0.2479636967,
-0.3418306112,
0.4246390164,
0.271713078,
0.0692412928,
-0.1926322281,
0.3859686553,
0.0908939689,
0.0783947557,
0.3117490113,
0.0434406102,
0.5520446301,
-0.1037070602,
-0.5941485763,
-0.1349550635,
0.3454440832,
0.3606206775,
-0.2585996687,
0.7501229644,
0.6847820878,
-0.7291619778,
-0.489299655,
-0.5360985398,
-0.1348882765,
-0.452357471,
0.3645178676,
-0.2265002131,
-0.9900932908,
0.7621000409,
-0.2670541108,
0.1646648198,
0.4439060986,
0.5927451253,
-0.3452320993,
0.772495091,
0.5483291745,
0.0537607595,
0.1506666541,
0.2312392145,
0.3872979879,
-0.6353699565,
-0.1341025382,
-0.7146522999,
-0.2607422769,
-0.2196268737,
-0.6287869811,
0.0498429574,
0.1457704753,
-0.2418497205,
-0.0313446037,
-0.1807400435,
0.57493186,
0.5537095666,
0.0547138974,
0.128918305,
-0.2086938322,
0.0244688112,
0.3914991915,
-0.3868919015,
-0.3128440082,
0.9581758976,
0.6238770485,
0.9582762718,
0.083878845,
0.9350368381,
-0.2948758006,
0.0282435343,
-0.9492723346,
0.3616767824,
0.2525288761,
-0.5171362758,
-0.4714791775,
-0.6071380973,
-0.898720324,
0.2260292619,
-0.1484712958,
-0.9817008972,
0.3115605116,
0.1488713324,
-0.6605969071,
0.22953403,
-0.563744843,
0.4374752343,
-0.0142906504,
-0.1029611081,
0.0078994883,
-0.7551970482,
0.3716539741,
-0.2533268631,
0.4924913347,
-0.0347375125,
0.0725169331,
0.7538185716,
-0.7002465725,
0.9057993889,
-0.076905854,
-0.4237248003,
0.3867771924,
0.335529089,
0.5096829534,
0.1329672933,
-0.0017885803,
0.1336218566,
0.1339084357,
0.1237040758,
-0.7965888381,
0.4419000447,
-0.7542518377,
-0.4370333552,
-0.1358051747,
-0.4478532076,
-0.3380405605,
0.1096746922,
0.5824466348,
0.2835243642,
0.0106302341,
0.3578315377,
1.0081321001,
-0.1644016206,
0.3447294533,
0.3473120332,
-0.2802537978,
-0.1864225715,
0.4984767735,
0.1953217387,
0.2220727205,
0.5268935561,
0.0059981272,
-0.2864870429,
-0.766271174,
-0.1662084311,
0.2030739933,
-0.912319243,
-0.2116218209,
-0.152309224,
-0.2644703388,
-0.4505325854,
-0.1299268752,
-0.6172267199,
-0.4354062676,
-0.3629323244,
-0.274096489,
0.0366699211,
0.7678018808,
0.0995293781,
0.687084198,
-0.7528864145,
0.1393499672,
0.0448454209,
0.4563613534,
-0.3267647326,
-0.7082642913,
-0.3564160764,
0.3275821507,
-0.0023485825,
-0.9125575423,
0.3987148106,
0.3331313133,
0.6255200505,
0.4923837781,
0.0776582807,
0.8068445921,
-0.3435489833,
0.7145966291,
0.0461983457,
-1.1559917927,
0.5185129642,
-0.0707280636,
0.4884564877,
0.7502606511,
0.269179821,
-0.3982689083,
-0.5513954759,
-0.7196959853,
-1.080599308,
0.6349554658,
0.2061036825,
-0.3673989177,
0.1788179129,
0.411588043,
0.0198789611,
0.2197287083,
-0.6713322401,
-0.1246484071,
0.4657865167,
-0.4377679825,
-0.0973457843,
-0.3853378296,
-0.3191562891,
-0.2272405922,
0.6580882072,
0.0630306229,
0.434894383,
-0.1711969525,
-0.535844028,
-0.1840875149,
0.3287199736,
0.4820299447,
0.7326775193,
-0.1383468658,
0.3810429275,
0.0895977467,
-0.2866202891,
0.0339990631,
-0.1370390356,
-0.2111803144,
0.1220986843,
0.5883899927,
0.6485559344,
0.0915180221,
-0.6499216557,
0.3625437319,
-0.076302059,
-0.2273343205,
-0.5318246484,
-0.1518871635,
0.1308645755,
0.1931750029,
0.1315655261,
0.4013334513,
0.1038772017,
-0.3856487572,
0.1483527273,
0.0631576851,
-0.051147826,
-0.4464806318,
0.3115932047,
-0.0569957681,
-0.0710270256,
0.6078218222,
-0.1502931267,
-0.4929600954,
0.552662611,
0.4686319232,
0.9446740746,
-0.3582507074,
0.156768769,
0.3119148612,
0.5819032788,
-0.3530418277,
0.1734474152,
-0.0724468902,
-0.9869135618,
-0.706430912,
-0.796741426,
-0.5239459872,
0.175057143,
-0.7983241081,
0.0730773062,
-0.4951858222,
-0.0777229145,
-0.1108014807,
-0.5098591447,
-0.8234117031,
0.1488400251,
0.4348956048,
0.45232898,
-0.9052336216,
0.658136189,
0.6364670992,
-0.164265275,
-0.9935808778,
0.1136375219,
-0.0399802774,
-0.9402022958,
0.5003926754,
-0.0917660668,
-0.1403686404,
-0.3875083923,
-0.9138097763,
-1.2330013514,
0.645203352,
0.7430283427,
-0.5361878276,
-0.0487448722,
0.3580372334,
0.3667312264,
-0.0605737939,
0.3119823635,
0.7346845865,
0.664073348,
0.1137701422,
-0.8510667086,
0.0476974286,
-0.1974409968,
-0.1983733475,
0.3189674914,
-0.268994838,
1.0039609671,
0.0852763504,
-0.4889089465,
0.0092988126,
0.4811286926,
-0.021467872,
0.1147117093,
0.2500509322,
0.5931308866,
1.0426039696,
-0.3827117383,
0.6417433023,
-0.1359404773,
0.2625858784,
1.472132206,
-0.1069423184,
1.1299203634,
0.6636659503,
-0.2586446702,
0.3403255641,
0.8714991808,
0.368809253,
0.2341579646,
0.2535685301,
-0.0937685147,
-0.3837286234,
0.2392735332,
-0.2311974764,
0.6381105185,
0.9559346437,
-0.4773925841,
-0.4401919842,
0.0215152428,
0.1652273536,
-0.2686892748,
-0.3200083971,
0.905369401,
-0.041380018,
-0.8167478442,
0.6294223666,
0.2321741134,
0.3699754775,
-0.6391972303,
0.0627264157,
0.048128996,
0.1966035068,
-0.2642923892,
-0.9058674574,
0.4083231091,
-0.2144374996,
0.0533383936,
-0.3770326078,
0.682202518,
-0.749483943,
-0.5310640335,
-0.0237432588,
0.4193735421,
0.1689784378,
-0.2668784261,
-0.3276645243,
0.3552619219,
0.0671083257,
-0.3542445004,
0.1382522434,
0.7299533486,
0.175724864,
0.8564651012,
0.1656677574,
0.1595241278,
0.1030261964,
-0.1412704587,
0.6474456191,
-0.2642943859,
-0.2367141843,
-1.0780676603,
0.4316354692,
0.2867898643,
-0.3442233801,
0.7102063298,
0.2066722661,
0.9108402729,
-0.0658063293,
0.9186558723,
0.0090893544,
0.3511727154,
-0.576772213,
0.6487482786,
-0.2181410044,
0.3926571012,
0.0775828511,
-0.771125257,
-0.4379347861,
0.7300800085,
-0.2248098254,
-0.1802319586,
0.6342164278,
0.5860918164,
0.2539529204,
0.0232460219,
0.1929850876,
0.226209715,
-0.0443301871,
0.4882834554,
0.8252249956,
-0.0739355981,
0.3466606438,
-0.4337108135,
-0.0121566653,
-0.1759115607,
-0.5497174263,
-0.5501564741,
-0.7599301934,
-0.5291649103,
-0.0642664209,
-0.1345532089,
0.9310911894,
0.5181755424,
-0.7574624419,
-0.178312704,
-0.0353321955,
0.2566721141,
-0.2657592297,
-0.1473808438,
0.2728242278,
-0.4436659813,
-0.643044591,
0.4765586853,
0.0335957892,
-0.0290390998,
-0.2998029888,
0.1227200329,
-0.0453529395,
0.1482713819,
0.4840928316,
0.124083437,
-0.7009925842,
-0.4686526358,
-0.2008201331,
0.3392316103,
-0.1442559063,
0.4866793454,
-0.5870479941,
0.574293375,
0.5664587617,
0.8895517588,
0.4299331307,
-0.0602028109,
0.9493157864,
-1.2253676653,
-0.0027876976,
0.4420150816,
0.7156615853,
0.0972881094,
-0.4106654227,
0.4303151071,
-0.1242283881,
-0.599947989,
-0.9548575878,
0.4554712772,
-0.715844512,
-0.3470700085,
1.263830781,
-0.3867296278,
-0.5184761882,
-0.2113344073,
0.1029222533,
0.2360697389,
-0.2042797506,
0.4602382481,
1.0911769867,
0.1407251805,
-0.3593283296,
-0.2189220786,
0.4006239176,
0.299713999,
-0.673418045,
0.2296405584,
0.5236872435,
0.2245888859,
0.2403804362,
0.1875547022,
-0.0720151067,
0.1186148971,
0.1050875857,
0.2253136784,
0.1225750297,
-0.305788815,
-0.4395977557,
0.4743145108,
0.1760984957,
-0.3116377592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08711v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08711v2
|
PLUG: Leveraging Pivot Language in Cross-Lingual Instruction Tuning
| 2023-11-15T05:28:07 | 2024-02-12T01:09:34 |
Zhihan Zhang, Dong-Ho Lee, Yuwei Fang, Wenhao Yu, Mengzhao Jia, Meng Jiang, Francesco Barbieri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction tuning has remarkably advanced large language models (LLMs) in
understanding and responding to diverse human instructions. Despite the success
in high-resource languages, its application in lower-resource ones faces
challenges due to the imbalanced foundational abilities of LLMs across
different languages, stemming from the uneven language distribution in their
pre-training data. To tackle this issue, we propose pivot language guided
generation (PLUG), an approach that utilizes a high-resource language,
primarily English, as the pivot to enhance instruction tuning in lower-resource
languages. It trains the model to first process instructions in the pivot
language, and then produce responses in the target language. To evaluate our
approach, we introduce a benchmark, X-AlpacaEval, of instructions in 4
languages (Chinese, Korean, Italian, and Spanish), each annotated by
professional translators. Our approach demonstrates a significant improvement
in the instruction-following abilities of LLMs by 29% on average, compared to
directly responding in the target language alone. Further experiments validate
the versatility of our approach by employing alternative pivot languages beyond
English to assist languages where LLMs exhibit lower proficiency. Our code and
data are available at https://github.com/ytyz1307zzh/PLUG.
|
[
-0.3532375991,
-0.6217915416,
0.1697843969,
0.460680604,
-0.279468894,
0.2084358335,
-0.7261881828,
0.1590643525,
0.2471081316,
0.57884413,
-0.8971579075,
-0.7774518132,
-0.3988881707,
0.0018873777,
-0.0830216929,
0.9621769786,
0.1034178585,
0.3653113246,
0.004279349,
-0.0455975048,
-0.9027304649,
-0.2009085268,
-0.3721297085,
-0.3870735466,
0.5165183544,
0.9861017466,
0.6525090933,
0.6029977202,
0.3536863029,
0.2042866945,
0.2206699997,
0.6601638794,
-0.6506682038,
-0.111413762,
-0.306450367,
-0.6352896094,
-0.6189525127,
-0.0822094232,
0.6060543656,
0.8856467605,
-0.0832339376,
0.0843484774,
-0.0145816579,
0.8920138478,
-0.6858121753,
0.3493294418,
-0.7673354149,
0.2321449071,
-0.4669626653,
-0.3872056603,
-0.7763189077,
-0.2141564637,
-0.2953579426,
-0.5995168686,
0.3754789531,
0.3193922341,
0.5903797746,
0.2796106339,
-0.1181294173,
-0.2883138061,
-0.5316594839,
0.7415899038,
-0.7018879652,
0.5463222265,
0.5252167583,
0.1947419345,
-0.0946056396,
-0.4094444811,
-0.2312737852,
0.040632125,
-0.1852534562,
-0.079117395,
0.1390324235,
-0.3202105463,
0.1583963335,
0.4130941033,
-0.5058768392,
0.4313391149,
-0.414400667,
-0.1270159334,
0.6836628318,
0.1756124198,
0.4763796031,
0.2936322987,
-0.0063219047,
-0.1672169864,
-1.2877212763,
0.1802658737,
0.432926625,
0.6760990024,
-0.2223316729,
0.6044279933,
-0.0036631762,
0.8845647573,
0.3335098922,
-0.0582754947,
0.2141751647,
-0.2405882627,
0.0195101704,
0.4211515784,
0.7283658981,
0.430395335,
0.1711136103,
-0.0805309191,
0.0541614741,
-0.3363353312,
0.1575263441,
-0.7609105706,
-0.4308561385,
-0.3721969128,
0.0186067782,
0.0446302705,
0.0832251683,
-0.7625168562,
-0.2110432833,
-0.0108133489,
-0.0058596851,
-0.547930181,
-0.1897378862,
0.1801040024,
0.5569844246,
0.4216364324,
0.0753129795,
-1.336779356,
0.0258647744,
1.0083459616,
0.9194272757,
-0.5039712191,
-0.452832669,
-1.1734929085,
0.1375715286,
-0.6129789948,
0.7649553418,
-0.8056808114,
-0.6490216851,
0.1980765611,
0.3633157313,
-0.3488522172,
-0.4964691699,
0.4450797141,
-0.5267953277,
0.5641151667,
-0.3837299049,
-0.4797788858,
-0.1700931638,
-0.0956402943,
-0.5643369555,
0.8807449341,
0.1423168033,
-0.5711207986,
0.3574115932,
-0.7565787435,
-0.9239560962,
0.1860781908,
-0.2508302331,
-0.5563804507,
0.1304995418,
0.4852248132,
0.2785515487,
-0.2929395139,
-0.1662177444,
0.2405995727,
-0.5091254711,
-0.2438784987,
-0.3835488558,
0.7933255434,
-0.133169502,
-0.5122389793,
0.1110709533,
-0.5085058808,
0.2496620715,
0.0756341517,
-0.4259711206,
-0.2301438451,
-0.0458406396,
-0.3513778746,
-0.0076146857,
0.1235054284,
-0.376718998,
0.441446811,
-0.5746952891,
0.1275896877,
0.4071367681,
-0.0998072252,
0.5592060685,
0.1415108889,
0.9103886485,
-0.1423313916,
-0.1841014773,
-0.7273778915,
-0.7170684934,
-0.781657815,
-0.1783632338,
0.3162185848,
0.6751654744,
-0.8940292597,
0.4003948569,
-0.2447139472,
-0.2080748677,
-0.7525037527,
0.4893076718,
0.648712337,
0.5302336812,
0.362044096,
-0.2985949218,
-0.0990262032,
-0.6114801764,
-0.2608001232,
0.0909587219,
-0.0716318265,
0.2869532406,
-0.221932441,
-0.0577422976,
0.5399035811,
-0.6460636258,
-0.2034116983,
-0.3469280601,
0.1767597198,
0.2711592615,
0.3414719105,
0.3913472295,
-0.4931568801,
-0.9905240536,
0.3653733432,
-0.2894523144,
-0.5229052901,
-0.1783089042,
-0.5664252043,
0.3819522858,
0.5981424451,
-0.2863759398,
0.2020211071,
0.7077159286,
-0.4178267121,
0.3237981498,
-0.3221056759,
0.271789521,
-0.6396778822,
-0.2556344569,
-0.2560185492,
-0.1431456357,
-0.5199894309,
-0.0946912318,
0.3196780086,
-0.1946737915,
-0.7578800917,
0.3663954735,
-0.8910876513,
-0.0889881924,
-0.413194716,
0.0797319114,
0.1233761907,
0.5913954377,
0.0500000343,
1.2677919865,
0.4999842644,
-0.481387645,
0.3355125487,
0.1856846958,
-0.3836659491,
0.3853939772,
-0.4952743053,
0.0802183896,
0.2442001402,
-0.2632064521,
-0.4672679305,
-0.1389183849,
0.4011835754,
-0.011136462,
0.8500505686,
-0.206848681,
-0.4465551972,
-0.0458843559,
-0.0177415442,
0.2972327769,
0.4696459174,
-0.6984975934,
0.3583061099,
0.250572443,
-0.3327564895,
-0.3357904851,
-0.5425342321,
-0.1598670483,
-0.0026226605,
-0.5972621441,
0.350881964,
-0.0438377373,
0.0291130878,
-0.2190957516,
0.0531328395,
0.1037722975,
-0.2598389089,
-0.1037443876,
0.3203867674,
-0.4981682301,
0.1501422077,
0.497079581,
-0.207781449,
-0.026657993,
-0.2088315636,
0.7776243091,
-0.2390847653,
-0.8642773628,
-0.0461706109,
0.5118060112,
0.4308425486,
-0.6494026184,
0.658903718,
0.7923255563,
0.2921038866,
-0.3127316833,
-0.2098174244,
-0.0650663674,
-0.5193408132,
0.4802335501,
-0.1886105984,
-0.6466215253,
0.0787533,
-0.3518748581,
0.4895907938,
0.1096207872,
0.9172112346,
0.1122486144,
1.1186510324,
0.9112700224,
-0.090224579,
0.5549340248,
-0.1725344807,
0.5044831038,
-0.6603929996,
-0.1371448189,
-0.1768039167,
-0.3310380578,
-0.6833835244,
-0.8273680806,
0.5852842331,
0.0441651382,
-0.0233622305,
0.1586091518,
-0.526941359,
0.797301054,
0.7230889201,
-0.0519136079,
0.2132837623,
0.2278900445,
-0.2664555907,
-0.3103886247,
-1.1755867004,
-0.3741729259,
0.7773979306,
-0.0042641861,
0.8415269256,
-0.2040772587,
0.5667054057,
0.1560256481,
0.2096355408,
-0.7371261716,
0.5174078941,
-0.4960262775,
-0.2051628232,
-0.3138709366,
-0.2894508839,
-0.9829382896,
0.2664211392,
-0.203494072,
-0.3984795809,
-0.1711143404,
0.3433672488,
-0.1520380229,
0.4057254493,
-0.9890108109,
0.9152859449,
-0.850363493,
-0.676589191,
-0.2333150059,
-0.3681128323,
0.3976711631,
-0.1225623265,
0.1943143904,
-0.1833922565,
-0.1685100049,
0.3512402773,
-0.47708565,
0.8537870049,
-0.0977936238,
-0.3545471728,
0.1040602177,
0.0554450862,
0.3707309067,
-0.1178591326,
-0.1011380777,
0.1966073811,
-0.431432724,
-0.5479463935,
-0.6688501835,
0.8513393998,
-0.5943964124,
-0.8799750805,
-0.024257822,
-0.8306469321,
-0.3361803591,
0.3677488267,
0.5376679301,
0.1115704775,
0.0058544665,
0.0403490812,
0.8805061579,
-0.5222231746,
0.3197899461,
0.7740367651,
-0.3005447388,
-0.230983302,
1.1796474457,
0.0014628678,
0.190077424,
0.4654504955,
0.2505215704,
0.1320505887,
-0.1714476347,
-0.9340129495,
0.4642487764,
-0.3435974717,
-0.2421837598,
-0.2022615224,
-0.0380990915,
-0.216968298,
-0.3803828657,
-0.6237918735,
-0.4223075211,
-0.2118160725,
0.0719795078,
0.3164704442,
0.4165344834,
0.1840401292,
0.4799085855,
-0.9289973378,
0.1266902387,
0.0790252015,
0.4487975538,
-0.271199882,
-0.4275419116,
-0.8591788411,
0.0885759667,
-0.3706831336,
-0.8266442418,
0.5285531282,
0.6148042679,
0.6513850689,
0.4903202653,
0.1797887683,
0.6381742358,
-1.15774858,
0.7071475387,
0.2754856646,
-0.8129332662,
0.7302982211,
0.0236266926,
0.5860603452,
0.3454001248,
0.5189110041,
-0.5078041553,
-0.4281650186,
-0.2068561763,
-1.0266679525,
0.831735909,
-0.207921952,
0.2567460835,
0.0382054709,
0.0839072466,
0.4765174985,
0.2223807722,
-0.3126229644,
-0.3015361428,
-0.2870037556,
-0.1224740446,
0.0351873487,
-0.0349514075,
-0.2328960896,
-0.1684638411,
0.8792617321,
-0.3390443027,
0.0879315659,
-0.4112708569,
-0.2215947807,
-0.2783538699,
0.1939251572,
0.7230657339,
0.6756251454,
0.3042816222,
-0.1179731488,
0.1692049056,
-0.5692385435,
0.0396225937,
-0.0932328105,
-0.4386156797,
0.1857549846,
0.4676428735,
0.9962364435,
0.4396331906,
-0.6139717102,
0.2892593145,
-0.1160457581,
0.1730814874,
0.0568438321,
0.4999656677,
0.1865281314,
0.0502113141,
0.109811306,
-0.3515006602,
-0.3365502357,
-0.314643085,
0.113146387,
0.3830694556,
-0.2211816907,
-0.4320608974,
0.4573201835,
0.5124453902,
-0.8243051767,
0.6573839188,
-0.3036966622,
-0.6145842075,
0.157341823,
0.591257751,
0.7670412064,
-0.2395471781,
0.1795874387,
0.2561968267,
0.4518806636,
0.2817124724,
0.1858242601,
-0.1951974481,
-0.5034236908,
-0.6777358651,
-0.2694377899,
-0.6484802365,
-0.208698675,
-0.7507452369,
0.5189761519,
-0.2486689091,
0.0397708602,
-0.4025052488,
0.0440161563,
-0.5450811386,
-0.2571115792,
0.2259061486,
0.9321049452,
-1.044580102,
0.9887241721,
0.8710779548,
-0.1878789067,
-0.6864343882,
0.1611559987,
-0.0046589668,
-1.0109510422,
0.6681511998,
0.0041469377,
-0.3210800588,
-0.2271597534,
-0.3621380329,
-0.5624833703,
0.9664947391,
0.5026567578,
-0.7315568924,
0.0480178669,
0.4089687765,
0.4146451056,
-0.7639320493,
0.0365619995,
0.6703737378,
0.263448894,
-0.0003923076,
-0.7020438313,
-0.2049182057,
-0.3272435963,
-0.0328046903,
0.3295742273,
-0.8078016043,
0.6890198588,
-0.2600676715,
-0.2011764795,
-0.3847877979,
0.7598590851,
0.2939703166,
0.2820468843,
0.4427586198,
0.3043201864,
0.7924486995,
-0.1027723923,
0.7075090408,
-0.8799463511,
-0.0561844744,
1.277605176,
-0.3162581921,
0.6998741031,
0.5040851235,
0.0236298554,
0.6219554543,
0.4896037579,
0.0715715811,
0.6122096181,
-0.1359690875,
-0.2649586201,
-0.2439251691,
-0.0460630357,
-0.407137394,
0.5258721709,
0.5546002388,
-0.3071576655,
-0.1372423172,
0.0605972409,
0.1738167405,
0.26583305,
-0.4660146534,
0.5766255856,
-0.1122461855,
-0.7511587739,
0.808965385,
-0.0066074152,
0.6242945194,
-0.5724816322,
-0.2877797782,
-0.5204514861,
0.0422553718,
-0.2319681644,
-0.6467841268,
0.2104587257,
0.378082186,
-0.3895664811,
-0.4581365883,
0.3335993588,
-0.8189575076,
-0.9032580256,
0.1224034429,
0.4947207868,
0.1263906956,
0.5176184773,
-0.4821474254,
0.1685740203,
0.2781859636,
-0.1198483855,
0.4188269973,
0.7363039255,
-0.2367557734,
0.655213356,
0.4172727168,
0.4918272793,
0.5179178119,
0.1417718679,
0.8401199579,
-0.3863747716,
-0.5155113935,
-0.5461706519,
0.4304289818,
0.023977479,
-0.2627249956,
0.7522169352,
0.5570524931,
1.2448378801,
-0.1430172175,
0.4966705441,
0.1335662305,
0.691685617,
-0.6334771514,
0.6283134222,
-0.4194637537,
0.6807908416,
0.0319683999,
-0.7744110227,
-0.2187598944,
0.5665477514,
-0.6076396108,
-0.2084281594,
0.5444242954,
0.9061734676,
-0.3102782071,
-0.16048868,
0.4987806082,
-0.1965380162,
0.2565346956,
0.4656710625,
0.372810632,
-0.1393751055,
0.7072148919,
-0.4397068322,
-0.3595691621,
-0.2586011589,
-0.8220814466,
-0.9602271914,
-0.1789480001,
-0.3253152072,
0.0987388119,
-0.0045220586,
0.9946470261,
0.7461361289,
-0.9497023225,
-0.5535997748,
0.1331773698,
0.4381060898,
-0.4318777323,
-0.1969961226,
0.3153088689,
-0.7839142084,
-0.9776886106,
0.5688803196,
0.409196943,
-0.4911606908,
-0.4444411993,
-0.3612636328,
-0.1333699971,
-0.1449027807,
0.6872866154,
0.4837500453,
-0.4810907543,
0.0879880637,
0.3756527901,
-0.0384687856,
0.2366800606,
1.2349162102,
-0.4790090919,
0.6020111442,
0.3923277855,
0.8069238067,
0.3883710206,
-0.1004789695,
0.96735394,
-0.8944194317,
0.3029516637,
0.0863427967,
0.3332316279,
0.6426923275,
-0.4968807697,
0.4801751375,
-0.1284593642,
-0.4580569267,
-0.6078044176,
0.4101592004,
-0.3319967687,
-0.0249195527,
0.8951167464,
-0.5097529292,
-0.225741908,
0.2379905134,
-0.2521049082,
0.2856808901,
-0.2243721485,
0.7734959722,
0.5336771011,
-0.4211788774,
-0.4567826986,
-0.4101284146,
0.2305709869,
0.6179734468,
-0.5831537247,
0.1346579641,
0.3777083755,
-0.0952962264,
0.1342383176,
0.2765055299,
-0.0396171995,
0.4416617751,
-0.3005518317,
0.0041795094,
-0.2121628374,
-0.3253082633,
-0.2469449192,
-0.1424635947,
0.0932137743,
-0.3719160557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08705v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08705v1
|
Evaluating Robustness of Dialogue Summarization Models in the Presence of Naturally Occurring Variations
| 2023-11-15T05:11:43 | 2023-11-15T05:11:43 |
Ankita Gupta, Chulaka Gunasekara, Hui Wan, Jatin Ganhotra, Sachindra Joshi, Marina Danilevsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dialogue summarization task involves summarizing long conversations while
preserving the most salient information. Real-life dialogues often involve
naturally occurring variations (e.g., repetitions, hesitations) and existing
dialogue summarization models suffer from performance drop on such
conversations. In this study, we systematically investigate the impact of such
variations on state-of-the-art dialogue summarization models using publicly
available datasets. To simulate real-life variations, we introduce two types of
perturbations: utterance-level perturbations that modify individual utterances
with errors and language variations, and dialogue-level perturbations that add
non-informative exchanges (e.g., repetitions, greetings). We conduct our
analysis along three dimensions of robustness: consistency, saliency, and
faithfulness, which capture different aspects of the summarization model's
performance. We find that both fine-tuned and instruction-tuned models are
affected by input variations, with the latter being more susceptible,
particularly to dialogue-level perturbations. We also validate our findings via
human evaluation. Finally, we investigate if the robustness of fine-tuned
models can be improved by training them with a fraction of perturbed data and
observe that this approach is insufficient to address robustness challenges
with current models and thus warrants a more thorough investigation to identify
better solutions. Overall, our work highlights robustness challenges in
dialogue summarization and provides insights for future research.
|
[
-0.3914861083,
-0.8362150788,
0.2641783357,
0.0652367026,
-0.2641276419,
0.1209089458,
-0.0392840244,
-0.4944194257,
0.019476762,
0.4795669317,
-0.6255013943,
-0.3182227612,
-0.5716263652,
0.3617312014,
-0.1826539189,
1.1029565334,
0.1685040146,
0.0370016769,
-0.2557910979,
-0.4277130663,
-0.4920840263,
-0.6269157529,
0.0083727147,
0.0631646737,
0.2381187528,
0.3653995097,
0.8113508224,
0.3769955337,
0.6174691916,
0.2763887942,
-0.5587357879,
0.162194103,
-0.9054996371,
0.3954199255,
0.1167806163,
-0.6699232459,
-0.4116517007,
-0.1471260488,
0.9310315847,
0.813673377,
-0.1335768104,
0.0474896245,
0.4523585737,
0.2602562308,
-0.5962973237,
0.1827179343,
-0.6121122837,
-0.0892281234,
0.1206118092,
0.0510987863,
-0.0366190821,
-0.3856706917,
0.6149467826,
-0.3567407727,
0.3446780443,
-0.2544424534,
0.9559546113,
0.3054605722,
-0.1726448983,
-0.0583331957,
-0.8340700269,
0.7296101451,
-1.2686610222,
0.0863504857,
0.3684011102,
0.299046129,
-0.2443851829,
-0.439144671,
-0.1600347757,
-0.4106236994,
-0.0454467423,
0.2410683781,
-0.0937824696,
0.1590327621,
0.5533152223,
0.6576651931,
-0.1581063867,
-0.0784664005,
0.0122818202,
-0.2829020917,
0.3386008739,
0.7000829577,
0.1694896668,
-0.1121180579,
0.151541695,
-0.2040368915,
-0.4141023159,
0.4259372056,
0.6668085456,
0.4038647413,
-0.4090985954,
0.3904741108,
-0.4141812325,
0.5880865455,
0.0613776743,
-0.2642787397,
-0.1101810187,
-0.9561908245,
-0.0950687751,
-0.5406891704,
0.5835308433,
0.5795896649,
0.030085437,
0.1089156047,
-0.1826821417,
-0.3649680912,
0.1709609926,
-0.8429079056,
-0.3153402507,
0.0592148528,
-0.4321284294,
-0.5548921824,
-0.0206300933,
-0.7207887769,
-0.4268844724,
-0.1196680143,
0.2409998029,
-0.3500028551,
-0.0203247853,
-0.0017692664,
-0.0532100163,
-0.0031021293,
0.526393652,
-0.9734835029,
0.3296146989,
0.4168174267,
0.9270096421,
-0.1090589091,
-0.1733269989,
-0.5140749216,
-0.1688689291,
-0.0883866847,
0.6522096992,
-0.5260931253,
-0.8064064384,
-0.171582818,
-0.0678818077,
-0.2247975469,
-0.6270475984,
0.3457369804,
-0.0028819498,
0.1855188906,
-0.3241802454,
-0.4541549385,
-0.0334238485,
0.3391667902,
-0.7433965802,
0.5091834664,
0.2030096501,
-1.0763591528,
0.2533959448,
-0.44144997,
-0.3625436723,
-0.3525866866,
0.0201127604,
-0.7900413275,
0.4314794838,
0.1620020568,
0.087214537,
0.0037111987,
0.1192508861,
-0.3422206342,
-0.4562079906,
0.517834723,
-0.8605844378,
0.6980817914,
-0.0501167774,
-0.0556381643,
-0.0079943733,
-0.9459452033,
-0.2940315902,
-0.1519292742,
-0.3343117833,
-0.054974284,
0.1827881783,
-0.1501507759,
-0.2145941854,
0.0426842012,
-0.3590252697,
0.0996685475,
-0.6791427732,
0.2486926764,
0.4853102565,
0.5646165013,
0.1383302212,
-0.6769859791,
0.7251386642,
0.1942435503,
0.3166673779,
-0.7082252502,
-0.5526334643,
-0.4980795383,
-0.3399640322,
0.4496123791,
0.6558073759,
-0.2729410827,
0.1580714285,
-0.2201986015,
-0.4852536321,
-0.2625516355,
-0.1087305173,
0.3846281171,
0.602445364,
0.1090612561,
-0.6948068142,
-0.2945532799,
-0.8605266213,
-0.5449476242,
-0.2022693306,
-0.175734058,
0.2296667993,
0.3162327111,
-0.1205326021,
1.0502985716,
-0.3226342201,
0.1852039546,
-0.4140123129,
0.4626811445,
0.1430007219,
0.466057092,
0.4512629509,
-0.3261665404,
-0.3436194658,
-0.296253562,
-0.4774102867,
-0.1478153467,
-0.2706775963,
0.2423583567,
0.1820838898,
0.0518267602,
-0.4731652737,
0.9268309474,
0.3994163573,
0.1710255146,
0.7795395255,
-0.1490699798,
0.1617411822,
-1.103959918,
-0.0023243306,
-0.1599554867,
-0.1362565905,
-0.7557814121,
-0.2262705714,
-0.2844578326,
-0.1078356206,
-0.1568231434,
-0.0188408997,
-0.1832568794,
-0.034091197,
-0.0761549994,
-0.1787040383,
0.1044199541,
0.4387292564,
-0.2568989098,
0.7544503808,
0.3082194626,
-0.4887416363,
0.1074605137,
0.2860406935,
-0.4358215332,
0.3959533572,
-0.8802353144,
0.0599018559,
-0.146996513,
0.3762515783,
-1.0385291576,
-0.7389852405,
0.0298340935,
-0.4076858163,
0.2860363722,
-0.2910810113,
-0.2515321374,
0.2720315456,
-0.6399611235,
0.3207877278,
0.212900579,
-0.1007745862,
0.7381058335,
0.1237922311,
-0.458298713,
-0.4263778925,
-0.4606361687,
0.1032839343,
-0.2794156075,
-0.6652415991,
-0.176948458,
-0.2029201388,
-0.2435351163,
-0.4643622339,
-0.4260318577,
0.1172342598,
0.4944005311,
0.3472384512,
0.3383342326,
-0.0250943787,
-0.4077201486,
0.0193513818,
0.1375887543,
0.0436998606,
0.1195360124,
0.2985235453,
-0.1945193708,
-0.3540014923,
-0.8558618426,
0.3448605835,
0.7174323201,
-0.142082423,
0.5828072429,
0.2090634108,
-0.2124202996,
0.2191614509,
-0.3695733249,
-0.3438916504,
-0.4227169156,
0.5650069714,
-0.19120498,
-0.8439192176,
0.9713017344,
0.0741601437,
0.5405601859,
0.0568150617,
0.3775976896,
-0.3519493937,
1.1442970037,
0.5526273847,
0.1146497428,
0.6509260535,
-0.0569737367,
0.254503876,
-0.721552074,
-0.1155597642,
-0.5199401379,
-0.1103294268,
-0.7039868832,
-0.0940661058,
0.4554596841,
-0.1285011917,
0.1853253245,
0.1933080405,
0.041702535,
0.3781065047,
0.4193538725,
-0.1016009748,
0.3823077977,
-0.0448756218,
-0.0878126696,
-0.2806333601,
-0.6914845109,
-0.663023591,
1.0143706799,
0.492454797,
0.9086070657,
0.2143346667,
0.5391155481,
0.1307771951,
-0.1078049615,
-0.5231710672,
0.3318661749,
-0.0009868329,
-0.2654016912,
-0.3862289786,
-0.6027935147,
-0.7930030227,
0.1231001616,
-0.3901267052,
-0.9387732148,
0.2632302046,
0.4943236411,
-0.6519227624,
0.0617619678,
-0.562944591,
0.8419010043,
-0.0488078818,
-0.3983196616,
0.0471676737,
-1.0393817425,
0.2699587941,
-0.0124312341,
0.0533025302,
-0.0984219685,
0.3159669936,
0.2090363055,
-0.3837499022,
1.1177512407,
0.1123432443,
-0.2644026875,
0.05814014,
0.3510114551,
0.5835835338,
0.3836086988,
0.15818578,
0.0807381719,
0.1985838264,
-0.464646548,
-0.787325561,
0.2749368846,
-0.7545031905,
-0.6166860461,
-0.1099543199,
-0.681140542,
-0.5524175763,
-0.1045262814,
0.6603082418,
0.9237370491,
-0.4871130288,
0.1646831036,
0.7476217747,
-0.2327625901,
0.3403868675,
0.2910129428,
0.0033998783,
-0.3977358639,
0.8482194543,
0.3073387146,
0.7816995978,
0.132303223,
0.1226214096,
-0.072794646,
-0.7836974859,
-0.3336761892,
-0.0146144386,
-0.5693817735,
0.0506103337,
-0.492626667,
-0.1288975626,
-0.386659354,
0.0559987947,
-0.3752209544,
-0.6111548543,
-0.4815487862,
-0.0687032714,
-0.0632770434,
0.7575381994,
0.151749149,
0.2239067703,
-0.8818526268,
0.2226023525,
0.4186488688,
0.4818581045,
-0.2616750896,
-0.8964464664,
-0.4046108425,
0.3477221727,
-0.3812245429,
-0.7926819921,
0.1012326553,
0.3059724867,
0.410931617,
0.4781067371,
0.1373766214,
0.5570256114,
0.0345444903,
1.1630784273,
-0.0126014007,
-0.7895416021,
0.5931614041,
-0.7333052158,
0.839622438,
0.8751197457,
-0.1798947901,
-0.1928386539,
-0.8980636001,
-0.6486452222,
-0.7668690681,
0.8320800662,
0.608055532,
0.3359267116,
0.3083135188,
0.2686292231,
0.1888978034,
0.1377114058,
-0.248228386,
-0.0206336807,
-0.5964891911,
0.0586008988,
0.1601132452,
-0.363086462,
-0.1663025618,
-0.0484855175,
0.4116695523,
0.0120528452,
-0.0453091487,
0.0508500189,
-0.038120538,
0.0843252763,
0.1885129064,
1.0291532278,
0.6241599917,
-0.527472496,
-0.1071654707,
0.4582486749,
-0.5910159349,
-0.2037160546,
-0.0847387239,
-0.3435977995,
0.2686356008,
0.5279008746,
1.0429332256,
0.3863964975,
-0.8016599417,
0.3301910758,
-0.5071594715,
-0.0983860567,
0.0225983802,
0.3521640599,
-0.2697268128,
0.0176646486,
0.0577843785,
0.4412980676,
0.349570483,
-0.6194885373,
-0.1594573557,
0.4174836576,
-0.203927055,
-0.5211042166,
0.5760365129,
0.2316077203,
-0.3368443549,
0.5407034755,
0.1343494356,
-0.4602310061,
0.6081826687,
0.3606244922,
0.8172995448,
-0.1664711982,
0.0291325729,
0.2110941708,
0.2701806724,
-0.0705126822,
-0.1083425656,
-0.2546346188,
-0.5601965189,
-0.2628808022,
-0.2146449834,
-1.0204678774,
0.0615678169,
-0.954562068,
0.1118238717,
-0.4742232561,
-0.5380316973,
-0.2535149157,
-0.2491008043,
-0.2577238977,
0.0087985937,
-0.113343671,
0.594512105,
-0.6436460018,
0.2318200022,
0.7001954317,
-0.2102489322,
-0.7075657248,
0.4650011361,
0.087095432,
-0.1532046497,
-0.2440841645,
0.1133388206,
-0.4277462959,
-0.3013646007,
-0.6261719465,
-0.8464701772,
0.7749734521,
0.6614455581,
-0.4812604189,
0.1209786013,
0.2668611109,
0.690969348,
-0.19322519,
0.3613559306,
0.8128577471,
0.0643936098,
0.2236268967,
-1.0983973742,
-0.3919903636,
-0.4017167389,
0.2703124881,
-0.0830460489,
-0.6839250922,
0.6241321564,
-0.1793057323,
-0.3339739144,
0.424037993,
0.3682403564,
0.1573999673,
0.2725099921,
0.3041196764,
0.3422935009,
0.6246982217,
-0.1381986439,
1.0439058542,
-0.4511829019,
0.3930945694,
1.3817400932,
-0.2109820396,
0.4310515523,
0.1367084235,
-0.1012809277,
0.1874918044,
0.4146804512,
-0.0880913287,
0.3059168756,
0.1708771735,
-0.3462008834,
-0.1386584342,
-0.0160232913,
-0.2355572581,
0.4852322638,
0.2273824066,
-0.048227068,
-0.037244264,
-0.1139678508,
0.0118080508,
0.0194240827,
0.1535507143,
1.0793384314,
-0.2128443271,
-0.7729113698,
0.7020196319,
-0.1678290069,
0.3980441093,
-0.5203835964,
-0.0076953545,
-0.7235252261,
-0.1565642804,
-0.2898609936,
-0.3488807678,
0.2407844961,
0.2074095756,
-0.0885830671,
0.1925363094,
0.2870832384,
-0.1822511256,
-0.429552108,
-0.303871423,
0.2078433633,
0.0819946676,
0.2739284933,
-0.1324249208,
0.3022224903,
0.2338743657,
-0.1753900498,
0.5123350024,
0.3548576534,
0.0710088238,
0.5411585569,
0.3613814712,
-0.0259416252,
0.0837652981,
0.2022466809,
0.953741014,
-0.3415034711,
-0.3373455405,
-0.7001619935,
0.6569336057,
-0.2492175996,
-0.5496178865,
0.7435110211,
0.480897218,
0.4685916305,
-0.0438379273,
0.8671159744,
0.3492664397,
0.5454788208,
-0.3613998592,
0.5319997668,
-0.1465358585,
0.7571142316,
-0.4027565718,
-0.8817750216,
-0.296990633,
0.4869900644,
-0.0761727095,
-0.0014331854,
0.254696548,
0.83832407,
0.0561658591,
0.4182988703,
0.3974164426,
0.2526932955,
0.3279230595,
0.1466969699,
1.0301811695,
-0.182126537,
0.4380259216,
-0.3055603802,
-0.2248863876,
-0.3622358143,
-0.7508619428,
-0.9026629925,
-0.3504018784,
-0.3793687522,
-0.2565951645,
0.204732433,
0.7870267034,
0.5592573881,
-0.858727634,
-0.1613512933,
-0.1544994712,
0.1234665364,
0.0435396582,
-0.1955367029,
-0.0283152238,
-0.2992230654,
-0.6078164577,
0.3561578691,
0.3104443252,
0.4961788654,
-0.1390237212,
0.1976145059,
0.3966967762,
0.5329345465,
0.2928650379,
0.3560305238,
-0.5419624448,
-0.3185191453,
0.017525427,
0.0958478302,
0.1858852953,
0.7734798789,
-0.4182381928,
0.7903327942,
0.3479177654,
0.4703055918,
0.3844820559,
0.5011720657,
0.8492943645,
-0.8127428293,
-0.0452968478,
0.2589586377,
0.1762944609,
0.3539482355,
-0.2795001566,
0.1844953895,
0.1464264691,
-0.5588893294,
-0.9457141757,
0.4600746632,
-0.8468475938,
0.1105730757,
0.7801684737,
-0.4827110767,
0.3073754609,
-0.3796437383,
-0.2668835521,
0.1761403531,
-0.3835063279,
1.0975599289,
0.9272997975,
-0.4091826081,
-0.1707081199,
-0.3671243191,
0.493496567,
0.5255537033,
-0.6434851289,
0.2844643593,
0.6778076887,
0.3471392691,
0.0342431888,
0.2525493801,
-0.0352760591,
0.3846871257,
0.0035717604,
-0.549500227,
-0.018265862,
-0.0810893029,
-0.6380849481,
0.2020006925,
0.1869881451,
0.040071398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08704v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08704v2
|
Can Large Language Models Follow Concept Annotation Guidelines? A Case Study on Scientific and Financial Domains
| 2023-11-15T05:11:26 | 2024-06-27T03:48:35 |
Marcio Fonseca, Shay B. Cohen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Although large language models (LLMs) exhibit remarkable capacity to leverage
in-context demonstrations, it is still unclear to what extent they can learn
new concepts or facts from ground-truth labels. To address this question, we
examine the capacity of instruction-tuned LLMs to follow in-context concept
guidelines for sentence labeling tasks. We design guidelines that present
different types of factual and counterfactual concept definitions, which are
used as prompts for zero-shot sentence classification tasks. Our results show
that although concept definitions consistently help in task performance, only
the larger models (with 70B parameters or more) have limited ability to work
under counterfactual contexts. Importantly, only proprietary models such as
GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 can recognize nonsensical guidelines, which we hypothesize is
due to more sophisticated alignment methods. Finally, we find that
Falcon-180B-chat is outperformed by Llama-2-70B-chat is most cases, which
indicates that careful fine-tuning is more effective than increasing model
scale. Altogether, our simple evaluation method reveals significant gaps in
concept understanding between the most capable open-source language models and
the leading proprietary APIs.
|
[
-0.2916000187,
-0.9657047391,
0.8105591536,
-0.0004887465,
-0.3939218223,
0.0436139479,
-0.2749098539,
-0.57450068,
-0.083908163,
0.6185958385,
-0.509472549,
-0.506062746,
-0.6781398654,
0.1194682494,
-0.2987475693,
1.305316925,
-0.0623859726,
-0.2021874338,
-0.425194025,
0.0780991688,
-0.6332840323,
-0.492226094,
-0.2478582114,
-0.3492199779,
0.3490642011,
0.568796277,
0.604300797,
0.8057348728,
0.6044685245,
0.2110529244,
-0.2758787572,
0.2894173265,
-0.1863516122,
-0.0990491956,
-0.3194172978,
-0.4567956924,
-0.3841435313,
0.3307178319,
0.4223015606,
0.7996320128,
-0.0727948546,
0.1648553908,
-0.0806559846,
0.2624872923,
-0.5123865604,
0.6163150072,
-0.6748449802,
-0.0892477185,
-0.0883500129,
-0.2977552414,
-0.5523754954,
-0.0742958933,
0.524984777,
-0.9401471615,
0.031312447,
0.1792522222,
1.0854277611,
0.4529434741,
-0.4300934374,
-0.5599226356,
-0.4579719007,
0.6391911507,
-0.7258651853,
0.12335971,
0.3546704352,
0.0203915238,
-0.1279422939,
-0.5015332699,
-0.4568052292,
-0.3986792564,
-0.1791151762,
-0.2047786713,
-0.2195145041,
0.2319532633,
0.6401963234,
-0.0622773319,
-0.1964090168,
0.4827266037,
-0.4112488329,
-0.2276244909,
0.4487988949,
-0.0577961691,
-0.0835347548,
-0.1954681575,
-0.3695074916,
0.0093478905,
-0.9666087627,
-0.1639760733,
-0.0153215397,
0.4870064557,
-0.246790126,
0.7471637726,
-0.2373901457,
0.7256534696,
0.197834,
-0.1708517224,
0.1673005521,
-0.3414568603,
-0.4193274379,
0.2688850164,
0.5147672296,
0.4672708511,
0.4123163223,
-0.2041059732,
-0.0075503178,
0.0678748116,
0.3122507036,
-0.9150345325,
-0.112377964,
-0.1104736924,
0.0684305057,
-0.1442436129,
-0.1100318581,
-0.3649113178,
-0.3922148645,
-0.4931382835,
0.5096431971,
-0.3119512796,
0.0176149979,
0.1032395959,
-0.2322105169,
0.2441978455,
0.3053509891,
-0.7772417068,
0.1341468543,
0.9381843209,
1.0153251886,
0.1685564071,
0.1215580925,
-0.5546643734,
0.1421262324,
-0.609369874,
0.7969908118,
-0.8187034726,
-0.4607181251,
-0.2303884774,
-0.1282554716,
-0.1983620077,
-0.2589576244,
0.445686847,
-0.3957436383,
0.0807317495,
-0.5080731511,
-1.0060217381,
-0.2481896728,
0.0526229106,
-0.2190985978,
0.4367671907,
-0.2416754514,
-0.8631192446,
0.6507718563,
-0.8789949417,
-0.5129566193,
0.1391901076,
-0.2972450852,
-0.193775028,
0.1774581522,
-0.1510173231,
0.6878375411,
-0.2553934753,
0.4293967187,
-0.3918480277,
-0.5611870885,
0.3653670847,
-0.2906814814,
0.3447505832,
0.0982423052,
-0.4167716503,
0.282951355,
-0.7105613947,
-0.2116850466,
-0.1164875627,
0.0455684401,
-0.6154913902,
0.0161584988,
-0.3350975811,
0.1228012517,
-0.0131082926,
-0.5263694525,
0.2532686889,
-0.2688746154,
0.9424366951,
0.6109855771,
0.040241126,
0.2798343599,
-0.1541537642,
0.3152604103,
-0.0337665863,
-0.3564604521,
-0.4487870932,
-0.4553165138,
-0.8532574773,
-0.3926294148,
0.2768527865,
0.4151954353,
-0.4971381724,
0.6936681271,
-0.1984850615,
-0.5091764331,
-0.3889053166,
-0.0285716373,
0.4587584436,
0.9598014951,
0.3180695176,
0.0683005899,
-0.5150026679,
-1.0633196831,
0.1184099689,
-0.2049773484,
0.1220319346,
0.3758290708,
0.7625191212,
-0.0389152169,
0.9603600502,
-0.4974914789,
-0.0875632465,
-0.0010891779,
0.3913339674,
0.1456093639,
0.2378146648,
0.507979691,
-0.6388469338,
-0.1761547178,
-0.0173549503,
-0.75868541,
-0.1729515195,
-0.3031767607,
0.0889448598,
0.4181815684,
0.6913212538,
-0.7644696832,
0.2388627082,
0.3092116714,
-0.374240011,
0.3149933815,
-0.2761379778,
-0.3723955154,
-0.8524065018,
-0.0503426529,
0.4836441278,
-0.0901357159,
-0.5207901001,
0.0833500549,
0.1405079216,
0.3719446063,
-0.2335466295,
0.4739892781,
-0.0885371566,
0.0608156398,
-0.4616772532,
0.3970476389,
0.0393579602,
0.27291888,
0.5591419339,
0.8343667984,
0.5580331087,
-0.7551313043,
-0.0038310192,
0.3618344069,
-0.560390234,
0.6634114385,
-0.864772737,
0.0550371557,
-0.0695554316,
0.5933048725,
-0.9013199806,
-0.1571831256,
0.2016752362,
-0.0328496769,
0.319357127,
-0.0370151959,
-0.3911429346,
-0.1719096452,
-0.0328691751,
-0.0905892104,
0.4046943188,
-0.3005010784,
0.1988664418,
0.2397809029,
-0.0871134251,
-0.6686694026,
-0.7088066339,
0.1167205721,
-0.3745294213,
-0.3052944243,
0.264172554,
-0.0133567518,
-0.2932464182,
0.0155152027,
-0.3028174937,
0.2570542991,
0.2865926325,
0.5573533177,
0.5304824114,
-0.2885042727,
0.4029392004,
-0.0299541745,
0.0460100956,
0.1021173447,
-0.4084354043,
0.2677292228,
-0.1764415056,
-0.2301279604,
-0.3943462074,
-0.1666404456,
0.453035146,
-0.1004723683,
0.7735159993,
0.4863348007,
-0.1407807767,
-0.1430666894,
-0.5341607332,
-0.1013609543,
-0.4288884103,
0.4441080689,
-0.4541788101,
-1.2557110786,
0.2237116992,
0.1164572015,
0.0979595482,
0.6272982955,
0.5130949616,
-0.0964155272,
0.526906848,
0.7956804037,
0.2326251715,
0.2551730573,
-0.1918673068,
0.3226744235,
-0.9162024856,
-0.1230552197,
-0.4762314856,
0.0062747421,
-0.667553544,
-0.4586375058,
0.2164018005,
0.1166907102,
-0.2813616991,
0.4237705171,
-0.2972995341,
0.5431654453,
0.3802827001,
-0.1995034367,
0.2174916863,
-0.2205534428,
-0.318359226,
0.1073490679,
-0.5932859778,
-0.8095734715,
1.1619670391,
0.5922045708,
0.5776391029,
-0.3327683806,
0.4511310458,
0.1772094667,
0.4835001826,
-0.9146490693,
0.4486204088,
-0.207109049,
-0.6720756292,
-0.3421176076,
-0.4207270145,
-0.2457748502,
0.1213169098,
-0.0987563506,
-0.707498014,
0.1612936109,
-0.0444824658,
-0.6451892853,
0.0649952888,
-0.9571174383,
0.7881188393,
-0.0280327331,
-0.087522842,
-0.2028474212,
-0.5137030482,
0.4279336631,
-0.426209569,
0.3707751632,
-0.2840380669,
0.014122664,
0.6705296636,
-0.2695781589,
1.2616386414,
-0.1486847401,
-0.5491427779,
0.361292243,
-0.185517326,
0.3429715037,
0.0258716773,
0.0710971802,
0.238633588,
0.195987612,
-0.1230822429,
-0.4969108999,
0.5419529676,
-0.7404200435,
-0.8835871816,
-0.2667147815,
-0.5960484147,
-0.3495537341,
-0.0070234784,
0.1865731925,
0.2257772088,
-0.2373821437,
0.5533783436,
0.7087517381,
-0.1077317744,
0.2591725886,
0.8791520596,
0.1666841954,
0.1531085074,
0.7614947557,
0.2491514534,
0.4143258631,
0.4966025949,
0.2093882859,
-0.4350490868,
-0.5221378803,
-0.3041614294,
0.1372481585,
-0.8108848929,
-0.1930637956,
-0.6494982243,
-0.2888120115,
-0.2194422036,
-0.0724315345,
-0.107598573,
-0.5713508725,
-0.3153247237,
-0.4743181169,
0.540084362,
0.6736913323,
0.023214696,
0.3133344948,
-0.5987455249,
0.1360490769,
0.1850043684,
0.3233805597,
-0.0908387229,
-0.7809258103,
-0.2176008224,
0.2820034921,
-0.1611911952,
-0.457054764,
-0.1010991335,
0.3343447149,
0.4879975915,
0.4980101585,
0.093401514,
0.7434154749,
-0.5681846738,
0.5553004146,
-0.002962834,
-1.1255303621,
0.4289342165,
-0.3494674563,
0.1057353094,
0.1736018956,
0.4514429569,
-0.7412490845,
-0.4326049685,
-0.4152900279,
-0.5220860839,
0.7281467915,
-0.031469509,
0.3653939962,
-0.2007113397,
0.6370033026,
0.1436724663,
0.4310712516,
-0.4824492037,
0.0926018283,
-0.3639367223,
-0.1507907957,
-0.3155874908,
-0.1830628216,
-0.2591106892,
-0.0803082511,
0.5198699236,
-0.4364405274,
-0.1239760965,
0.0944860503,
-0.0571067594,
-0.25747931,
0.4099989533,
0.8327455521,
0.8251187801,
-0.216497764,
0.0307127032,
-0.0243671183,
-0.2218699604,
-0.0348488614,
0.2218552828,
-0.3407104313,
-0.3782579899,
0.6502087712,
1.1373289824,
0.4218518436,
-0.8380590677,
0.2899972796,
0.1286832094,
-0.4873067439,
-0.028301673,
0.4745742083,
0.205529511,
0.3412139714,
0.2033430934,
-0.0948944241,
-0.1408621967,
-0.7654917836,
0.2211315036,
0.6227846146,
-0.3095907569,
-0.2852698267,
0.5665719509,
0.0935988724,
0.1532558948,
0.5217705965,
-0.1962930262,
-0.4098049998,
0.6890716553,
0.4784682691,
0.763228178,
0.1933845431,
0.5415005684,
0.0796886384,
0.2155021876,
-0.2228357047,
0.0494611338,
-0.1112421975,
-0.9036678672,
-0.7141161561,
-0.6925864816,
-0.6741856337,
0.0690692738,
-0.509051621,
0.1745598018,
-0.6654719114,
-0.1162577048,
0.687431097,
0.1188430712,
-0.5194510818,
0.0909838676,
0.3354752362,
0.8758024573,
-0.8103134036,
0.9123675823,
0.7695344687,
-0.5072775483,
-0.6208584905,
-0.1314307898,
0.1485132575,
-0.7537173629,
0.9948117733,
0.1608094424,
-0.1207791194,
-0.200914979,
-0.6978361011,
-0.857064724,
1.0051549673,
0.2394893169,
-0.8707891703,
-0.2242704034,
-0.057709448,
0.7773808241,
-0.7504657507,
0.1439525336,
0.5849131346,
0.5694656968,
0.7052804828,
-1.1971236467,
0.0070618978,
-0.0320885517,
-0.2008501738,
-0.125776127,
-0.7422382832,
0.675357163,
-0.435672313,
-0.0394185707,
0.0307801403,
0.5653827786,
0.3303252757,
0.2489453852,
0.3504294157,
0.3928980231,
0.8131724,
-0.260778904,
0.8015143871,
-0.3589746654,
0.1850018352,
1.0807235241,
-0.5945718884,
0.9008028507,
0.2692850232,
0.0961731821,
0.5580431819,
0.7795647383,
-0.2649705112,
0.374417156,
0.2496192157,
0.397870332,
-0.3866173327,
-0.5234857798,
-0.1849005818,
0.5892492533,
0.690654099,
-0.2488612831,
0.0221688431,
-0.1069712117,
0.2579260767,
-0.0711788684,
-0.2339490652,
0.7204248905,
0.2543088794,
-0.6695600152,
0.5812659264,
0.1016438007,
0.6708675623,
-0.5326779485,
-0.0330659561,
0.0462647043,
0.1199670658,
-0.0872785822,
-0.7360930443,
0.2598977685,
0.1926566511,
-0.0154226394,
-0.1449601799,
0.3135646284,
-0.3049877286,
-0.4519318044,
-0.0895558298,
0.2865150571,
-0.0883562416,
0.0191092417,
-0.3156180084,
0.0211179163,
-0.1744192541,
-0.0529712848,
0.2529940307,
0.6474332809,
-0.2777182758,
0.668810606,
0.3817566931,
0.0159658249,
-0.1830606312,
0.0487585627,
0.6869790554,
-0.6075341702,
-0.469075501,
-0.8525867462,
0.1219601408,
0.0570174754,
-0.3606100082,
0.801379621,
0.2630483508,
1.0046316385,
0.1283127815,
0.7691391706,
0.2215671837,
0.3260149956,
-0.7501615286,
0.405128181,
-0.4401600361,
0.4022170305,
-0.2675050795,
-0.8197077513,
-0.1433404386,
0.7914943695,
-0.4802604914,
-0.0520323552,
0.6157767773,
0.3471306264,
0.1560974717,
0.3936673403,
0.1877511442,
0.4038818181,
0.4835082591,
0.3635656238,
0.6794897914,
0.0731747374,
0.2394733429,
-0.0637068152,
-0.0567673221,
-0.3148672283,
-1.1191148758,
-1.0424304008,
-0.4587568641,
-0.7454852462,
0.1419731826,
0.0774209201,
1.0841386318,
0.799656868,
-0.7208255529,
-0.1168464795,
-0.067052424,
-0.0184824858,
-0.0553068966,
-0.159548834,
0.3864620328,
-0.4852752686,
-0.4290931523,
0.3863342106,
0.4791124165,
0.1715061218,
-0.3004410565,
0.092960462,
-0.1463039517,
0.4081971943,
0.5638559461,
0.0998493508,
-0.9191390276,
-0.5728296638,
0.0889276713,
-0.0515197441,
-0.2446660846,
0.7811489701,
-0.6278324127,
0.282536,
0.0612922497,
0.4453726709,
0.2564437091,
0.0153394565,
0.4582620263,
-0.7884152532,
0.1941200346,
0.0013685066,
0.2931839526,
0.2179538459,
-0.2290979922,
0.4501629472,
0.225386098,
-0.2299522907,
-0.7782369256,
0.103603594,
-0.7054803371,
-0.4618063569,
1.2749146223,
-0.2040828019,
-0.0980952904,
0.0682094321,
-0.0464481488,
0.1329660863,
-0.3912075758,
0.8114097714,
1.2526170015,
-0.0199560411,
-0.1284380704,
-0.7658933997,
0.5449991822,
0.151778698,
-0.4856628776,
0.3189751208,
0.5820576549,
0.3023139238,
0.373693049,
0.3189872205,
0.1402742118,
0.011547571,
-0.2477330416,
-0.2819599807,
-0.2629499733,
-0.4262952209,
-0.1709803939,
-0.098667942,
0.1194989532,
0.0194213353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08702v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08702v1
|
Debate Helps Supervise Unreliable Experts
| 2023-11-15T05:05:40 | 2023-11-15T05:05:40 |
Julian Michael, Salsabila Mahdi, David Rein, Jackson Petty, Julien Dirani, Vishakh Padmakumar, Samuel R. Bowman
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.0
|
As AI systems are used to answer more difficult questions and potentially
help create new knowledge, judging the truthfulness of their outputs becomes
more difficult and more important. How can we supervise unreliable experts,
which have access to the truth but may not accurately report it, to give
answers that are systematically true and don't just superficially seem true,
when the supervisor can't tell the difference between the two on their own? In
this work, we show that debate between two unreliable experts can help a
non-expert judge more reliably identify the truth. We collect a dataset of
human-written debates on hard reading comprehension questions where the judge
has not read the source passage, only ever seeing expert arguments and short
quotes selectively revealed by 'expert' debaters who have access to the
passage. In our debates, one expert argues for the correct answer, and the
other for an incorrect answer. Comparing debate to a baseline we call
consultancy, where a single expert argues for only one answer which is correct
half of the time, we find that debate performs significantly better, with 84%
judge accuracy compared to consultancy's 74%. Debates are also more efficient,
being 68% of the length of consultancies. By comparing human to AI debaters, we
find evidence that with more skilled (in this case, human) debaters, the
performance of debate goes up but the performance of consultancy goes down. Our
error analysis also supports this trend, with 46% of errors in human debate
attributable to mistakes by the honest debater (which should go away with
increased skill); whereas 52% of errors in human consultancy are due to
debaters obfuscating the relevant evidence from the judge (which should become
worse with increased skill). Overall, these results show that debate is a
promising approach for supervising increasingly capable but potentially
unreliable AI systems.
|
[
-0.5556656718,
-0.7031601667,
0.7989165783,
0.0149565721,
0.0234369077,
0.198263377,
-0.1434066743,
-0.4964731634,
0.206528008,
0.6342946887,
-0.0468662307,
0.186110884,
-0.8129700422,
0.1338474751,
-0.2840766907,
0.9455462098,
0.0074048154,
0.2360084504,
-0.381475091,
-0.4402618408,
-0.5299623013,
-0.2486403435,
-1.0672174692,
-0.458588779,
0.6033785343,
0.788443327,
0.8148894906,
0.538164258,
0.5205433965,
0.513253212,
-0.1313942373,
0.4380320609,
-0.2665109634,
0.2874579132,
-0.5310301185,
-0.8525658846,
-0.3804178238,
0.4301064909,
-0.0008585828,
0.488476336,
-0.522723496,
-0.2151668221,
-0.1716080904,
0.796667397,
-0.3958711028,
0.1823330373,
-0.8802230954,
-0.0415103696,
-0.4057515562,
-0.3240923285,
-0.3801235855,
-0.5832561255,
0.3043532968,
-0.744432807,
0.3585738242,
0.2156365216,
0.9752982259,
0.8589217067,
-0.4249798954,
-0.2290857732,
-0.727766633,
0.348424226,
-0.7738088369,
-0.1615727097,
0.372143358,
0.2251515687,
-0.1625120044,
-0.732585609,
-0.726631999,
-0.4980642498,
-0.1688827127,
0.3499187231,
-0.1727894396,
0.1002955362,
0.3196801543,
-0.0831033736,
0.042233143,
0.1244974583,
-0.3853698969,
-0.2088073343,
0.7933904529,
0.1105199903,
0.0179501381,
-0.1661910564,
-0.1006374434,
-0.148248598,
-0.233000949,
0.0303545222,
0.5194690228,
-0.2379101515,
0.3974589705,
0.1646079868,
-0.164794147,
0.4147818387,
0.649864912,
0.1044213325,
-0.2467610091,
-0.0020415238,
0.1366106421,
0.2033426315,
0.6221918464,
0.3074519932,
0.2318074852,
-0.1599661708,
-0.010078866,
0.0718855187,
0.8472867012,
-0.4080419242,
-0.7186750174,
0.1008441746,
-0.0032116978,
-0.1314676404,
0.2139464915,
-0.9666139483,
-0.7119489908,
-0.2611695826,
0.4275534749,
-0.0456854813,
-0.3086507022,
0.0221607555,
-0.5028265119,
0.0062484555,
0.8255703449,
-0.5066804886,
0.2336344868,
0.6387203336,
0.4257979095,
0.0035483493,
-0.1947527677,
-0.7159672976,
0.0600552037,
-0.8849972486,
1.1514152288,
-0.3605135083,
-0.154053092,
-0.3025178611,
-0.1135623679,
-0.3431449831,
-0.8403614163,
1.0531848669,
-0.5013076663,
0.3959734142,
-0.3778860271,
-0.5091004968,
0.2325031757,
0.1923510879,
-0.8445546031,
0.7168031931,
-0.250182271,
-1.0180282593,
0.4888653159,
-0.8788684607,
-0.2861668468,
0.0900328457,
-0.3398625255,
-0.5063945055,
-0.2498933822,
0.2705852985,
0.0653521419,
-0.133941263,
0.3606014848,
-0.3162391484,
-0.32669577,
0.6236740351,
-0.5903880596,
0.5295782685,
0.0864254981,
-0.831970036,
-0.1151740626,
-0.3607922792,
0.0409192406,
-0.1647702008,
-0.2609627247,
-0.3691200316,
0.5433492064,
-0.4740454853,
-0.1264685094,
-0.3034025133,
-0.6749104261,
0.0758336484,
-0.4441521466,
0.4556782246,
1.1213685274,
0.0371122248,
0.1572776139,
-0.6133116484,
0.2654516101,
0.0068050446,
-0.1657218784,
0.1081563607,
-0.5577327013,
-1.1908664703,
0.2100428194,
0.4543869495,
0.7116872072,
-1.0522074699,
-0.0071082567,
-0.1053928435,
-0.607513845,
-1.127633214,
0.242466718,
0.566054225,
0.9941552877,
0.4090495408,
-0.4166488945,
-0.1352135986,
-0.9096667767,
-0.6102774143,
-0.7042098641,
0.2700159252,
0.5724388361,
0.3128908873,
0.2550927997,
0.9966964722,
-0.5131292343,
-0.0949818864,
0.0339200236,
0.687492609,
-0.0049419766,
0.532384038,
0.1963409334,
-0.7563742399,
-0.4808525741,
0.0235043578,
-0.8660749197,
-0.1138151661,
-0.4637669921,
-0.221162647,
0.4935982823,
0.3137240708,
-0.5849305987,
0.4271552563,
-0.3740978837,
-0.5865980983,
0.7414911389,
-0.3401179314,
0.2733385861,
-0.5495718122,
0.1458383948,
0.0689341649,
-0.2698920071,
-0.3722353578,
-0.1171559244,
-0.2300312966,
0.4469789267,
-0.1449959129,
0.379773885,
-0.1391697675,
0.4191275835,
-0.2445054799,
0.3620868921,
0.1256290674,
0.3692682683,
0.1220261976,
0.8571723104,
0.150992468,
-0.1732304245,
0.6510839462,
0.5524815917,
-0.5401273966,
1.2652380466,
-0.6800954342,
0.4972988069,
0.1120932102,
0.3670735955,
-0.9846335649,
-0.365495652,
0.2838204503,
-0.4766660631,
0.2993352711,
-0.1343204975,
-0.1087481007,
-0.3903166652,
-0.1137624905,
-0.0441991054,
0.0111815082,
-0.4255946279,
0.2238275856,
0.4266145527,
-0.7471085191,
-1.0665764809,
-0.5227571726,
0.6591403484,
-0.2133696526,
-0.5382658243,
-0.0088886935,
-0.0050832299,
-0.7324866056,
0.4808468223,
-0.2532155216,
-0.4483825266,
0.0941809937,
0.1093340516,
0.2541512549,
-0.3936201334,
0.0237637162,
-0.0611480363,
-0.4253401756,
0.4922177494,
0.1472536772,
-0.2242520154,
-0.0976894125,
-0.7960053086,
-0.5810845494,
0.4174372852,
0.5611322522,
-0.1590813547,
0.5492966175,
0.3796568215,
0.2060747147,
-0.1395540088,
-1.2733631134,
-0.106277667,
-0.4984076917,
0.2909182906,
-0.121923089,
-0.5586742759,
0.0923816785,
0.0017245923,
0.3667815924,
0.5945201516,
0.2388618439,
-0.5172941089,
0.8636686206,
0.4457767606,
-0.228639394,
0.1149225309,
-0.0625281781,
0.0611874349,
-0.432954669,
-0.3097094297,
-0.7551791668,
-0.4187645018,
-0.1577136964,
-0.2107911557,
0.6465789676,
-0.1913903356,
-0.0541864075,
-0.2593408525,
-0.6507881284,
0.5624790788,
0.7914426923,
0.1676892191,
0.3030394316,
-0.3345547915,
-0.1085858718,
-0.1514736265,
-0.7015021443,
-0.5762087107,
0.7879906297,
0.0381827578,
0.889595747,
-0.1827518195,
0.2985452712,
0.7684505582,
0.4061518013,
-0.4825738966,
0.4058167338,
0.3102197051,
-0.8627715111,
-0.4057441056,
-0.4384662211,
-0.7231020927,
0.2616383433,
-0.2454745471,
-0.1659785956,
0.5149645805,
0.2380714267,
-0.3297696114,
0.7027161717,
-0.8123485446,
0.8831453323,
-0.3058062792,
-0.6431317925,
-0.4828964472,
-0.8762663603,
0.2487632781,
-0.0273934267,
-0.0524733551,
0.2357087433,
0.1764300913,
1.140229702,
-0.5891383886,
0.8147770166,
-0.2757326365,
0.1361264735,
0.5389790535,
-0.1200047061,
0.4410636723,
0.1934885681,
-0.1455358714,
-0.1543721706,
0.0998102054,
-0.4616092443,
-0.5897344947,
0.2769480348,
-1.0789325237,
-1.2718926668,
-0.6360758543,
-0.2550150156,
-0.2647118866,
-0.1434630156,
0.1145375073,
0.2114207149,
-0.1356602609,
0.257101059,
0.7092057467,
0.2153935879,
0.1954730004,
0.6297219992,
0.7045246959,
-0.3867768943,
0.7318310738,
0.216021955,
0.1155893058,
-0.0752462149,
-0.0107905706,
-0.237796858,
-0.4505929947,
-0.8377022147,
0.0517901368,
-0.5928993821,
-0.267418623,
-0.6375597715,
-0.2034340203,
-0.1063621119,
-0.1510083079,
-0.3473562002,
-0.7256072164,
-0.1042218879,
-0.349879235,
0.3086191416,
0.8431587219,
-0.2692838907,
0.0349074043,
-0.240215227,
0.2206355631,
0.8433914781,
0.1577450037,
0.1308384687,
-0.4723429382,
-0.2495156825,
0.052314762,
-0.8412732482,
-0.9273146391,
0.0276850294,
-0.0212682486,
0.8712249398,
0.9061472416,
0.3466003239,
0.8884553909,
-0.4331066608,
0.6982750297,
-0.1886075288,
-0.8245377541,
0.358152926,
-0.1277192086,
-0.4734910727,
0.816372931,
0.2169137001,
-0.5871956348,
-0.8036803603,
-0.6764410734,
-0.709936738,
1.0761276484,
0.0775116161,
-0.1824062467,
0.1370065212,
0.4910631478,
0.1041481644,
0.1138652712,
-0.3829452097,
-0.1369083822,
-0.288641572,
0.2975672185,
0.0930775031,
-0.2099195123,
-0.6193748116,
-0.2615041733,
0.6176405549,
-0.0821185634,
0.1941350102,
0.4929741621,
0.1693460643,
-0.4936050773,
0.5629605651,
0.4280294478,
0.7882757783,
0.0076290416,
0.3943030834,
0.4095206261,
-0.191706419,
0.2508530319,
0.2063689977,
0.0251495373,
-0.020645231,
0.6693252325,
0.7823183537,
-0.0961765796,
-0.6324842572,
0.4519021213,
-0.0603393577,
-0.5939356089,
-0.1023214608,
0.5366407037,
0.3485421836,
0.5227156281,
0.4342027307,
0.6648260355,
-0.1259854585,
-0.4803224206,
0.5235665441,
0.3962697089,
-0.2862867713,
-0.1080355421,
0.9692893028,
0.5863395333,
-0.4926613569,
0.6853896379,
0.1292686611,
-0.6265221238,
1.0485424995,
0.2888165712,
0.506054163,
-0.1365930587,
0.419927001,
-0.1630509496,
0.2496632636,
-0.2725999057,
0.057038486,
-0.0376555175,
-0.492673099,
-0.2708101571,
0.1414137036,
-1.2515637875,
-0.1600037217,
-0.746938765,
-0.1573376656,
-0.3810206652,
-0.198900044,
0.0568566658,
0.3838452101,
-0.3439577222,
0.0959595218,
-0.1166130528,
0.9261381626,
-0.8070460558,
0.603536725,
0.6538439393,
-0.2138485312,
-0.7575247288,
-0.0810375139,
-0.145388335,
-0.3420882821,
0.3585246801,
-0.2087696344,
-0.2166071236,
-0.4110178053,
-0.9321687222,
-0.3782640696,
0.6868528724,
0.5880078077,
-0.2486710697,
0.1875276715,
-0.0878330544,
0.7215955853,
-0.0384033173,
0.7709789276,
0.3605331481,
0.8470832109,
0.2106863856,
-1.0255409479,
-0.1473064274,
-0.5064618587,
-0.760794878,
-0.1492976546,
-0.9800217748,
0.6850810051,
-0.4566619694,
0.056169156,
0.1086906493,
0.6626352668,
-0.0743654668,
0.8310603499,
0.7068600059,
0.4000048637,
1.1575546265,
-0.1156738698,
0.6674336791,
-0.1537829489,
-0.171272561,
1.1177744865,
-0.3635287881,
0.9012854695,
0.3341364563,
-0.1038642749,
0.7601314187,
0.4320103228,
-0.1385108382,
0.1974363774,
-0.2294145525,
-0.1005310193,
-0.6148024797,
-0.0998526439,
-0.3069286048,
0.1520718485,
0.2070529312,
0.1072168797,
-0.0482552312,
-0.3595378399,
0.4441193044,
0.4668624699,
0.0591293834,
0.8068466187,
0.0854651257,
-1.2441592216,
0.3587398231,
0.1019574255,
0.2903065979,
-0.2788605094,
-0.1011815816,
-0.4402686357,
0.3065908849,
-0.2121525556,
-0.90897578,
0.1994966865,
0.2292001098,
0.1067524478,
-0.3349838853,
0.5435577035,
-0.1492342204,
-0.1975815147,
-0.017340092,
0.7859469652,
0.1458280534,
0.1348071992,
-0.8436311483,
-0.622646451,
-0.1383755803,
-0.2596012354,
-0.0812964886,
0.6616410017,
-0.0956812203,
0.7946493626,
0.3769421875,
0.2732779682,
0.0112509262,
-0.3938972652,
1.1255447865,
-0.5497015119,
-0.4343959391,
-0.7479763627,
0.3050856292,
-0.5337116718,
-0.3089916408,
0.6081233025,
0.3198114932,
0.4672731161,
0.1960212886,
0.6907704473,
-0.0234827157,
0.6174067259,
-0.3011686802,
0.9824044704,
-0.4920258224,
-0.0130594205,
-0.320654273,
-0.3106520772,
0.1703785956,
0.6474778652,
-0.4053583145,
-0.2268133461,
0.7419500351,
0.6516553164,
-0.0539336205,
0.2493631393,
-0.1794321984,
0.6751377583,
0.61207515,
0.5270280838,
1.1308271885,
0.2796509564,
0.7901290655,
0.01806367,
-0.1505977958,
-0.1046081334,
-0.5185139179,
-0.8949792385,
-0.2448262721,
-0.4144797623,
-0.2332747281,
0.3536501229,
0.5694559813,
0.6555530429,
-0.8035272956,
-0.08826188,
0.0910198018,
0.5801513195,
-0.415412724,
-0.2250679582,
0.4397099316,
-0.3250997961,
-0.7250049114,
0.4611847699,
0.0317114443,
-0.7271417975,
-0.0477913283,
-0.1523611546,
-0.1688799858,
0.5229608417,
-0.1358889788,
0.4897995889,
-0.6410554647,
-0.4931079149,
-0.3708381653,
-0.1678201407,
0.4211164117,
0.6395404339,
-0.8563796282,
0.6123843193,
0.265232712,
0.8694201708,
0.3057401776,
0.3323170841,
0.4467247128,
-0.1939784586,
-0.1414869875,
0.3694680333,
0.2392157763,
0.1986974329,
-0.4228063822,
0.6313281655,
0.5536655188,
-0.9317836761,
-0.8103277087,
-0.0424872264,
-0.9023633003,
-0.142455861,
0.5339176655,
-0.4294615686,
0.0242389962,
-0.6894705892,
-0.5222180486,
0.0580265522,
-0.4942116737,
1.3875511885,
1.0496793985,
-0.4006076157,
0.0985298529,
-0.6259329915,
0.6301505566,
0.9300112724,
-0.7675282955,
-0.0474744588,
0.4351696968,
0.3477591872,
0.2722420096,
0.9275673032,
0.2792529762,
0.4323995709,
0.2817744911,
-0.420624584,
-0.2381013334,
-0.4877356589,
0.1565041393,
0.3342683315,
0.0271052439,
0.0594606809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08695v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08695v2
|
Attribute Diversity Determines the Systematicity Gap in VQA
| 2023-11-15T04:50:30 | 2024-06-24T15:51:13 |
Ian Berlot-Attwell, Kumar Krishna Agrawal, A. Michael Carrell, Yash Sharma, Naomi Saphra
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
The degree to which neural networks can generalize to new combinations of
familiar concepts, and the conditions under which they are able to do so, has
long been an open question. In this work, we study the systematicity gap in
visual question answering: the performance difference between reasoning on
previously seen and unseen combinations of object attributes. To test, we
introduce a novel diagnostic dataset, CLEVR-HOPE. We find that while increased
quantity of training data does not reduce the systematicity gap, increased
training data diversity of the attributes in the unseen combination does. In
all, our experiments suggest that the more distinct attribute type combinations
are seen during training, the more systematic we can expect the resulting model
to be.
|
[
-0.8044238687,
-0.4412404597,
0.4153713584,
-0.0870069191,
-0.1975925565,
0.1920367777,
-0.1027418748,
-0.6966671944,
0.0882398859,
0.210672766,
-0.8730797768,
-0.4958582819,
-0.5834510326,
0.0581562854,
-0.4956766367,
0.7476697564,
-0.0695743933,
0.3878869712,
-0.369206816,
-0.7520316243,
-0.7994058132,
-0.19914186,
-0.4371013045,
-0.1327542365,
0.9117501378,
0.4163102806,
0.9004631042,
0.4217390418,
0.8978527188,
0.3374999464,
-0.1711840928,
0.1722008139,
-0.4087381959,
0.3127011061,
-0.3370536566,
-0.7290844917,
-0.0810774043,
-0.2081794441,
0.703337729,
1.0043373108,
-0.0778125823,
0.2030399144,
-0.097531423,
0.6965529323,
-0.5463699698,
-0.2823865712,
-0.6194711924,
0.2230956554,
-0.2445335835,
0.1356939077,
0.183481887,
-0.3526672423,
0.6390171647,
-0.6109269857,
0.6100409031,
-0.107954897,
1.1486206055,
0.3214111626,
-0.2902631164,
0.063370727,
-0.7372372746,
0.8388821483,
-0.2512968481,
0.2807353139,
-0.105084978,
0.6534132957,
0.1136310697,
-0.8095664382,
-0.615922153,
0.0455056205,
-0.0080226436,
0.1272272915,
-0.0830945447,
0.0693932325,
0.4761885703,
0.534095645,
-0.7814537883,
-0.1333129406,
-0.6170031428,
0.0107579045,
0.7362312675,
0.3502323329,
0.4331884682,
0.0000378739,
-0.1954689026,
-0.2100249231,
-0.4138205349,
0.4639745951,
0.1905524135,
-0.248609677,
0.2437271625,
0.5621955991,
-0.8380866051,
0.7624665499,
-0.3975945413,
0.1674853712,
0.2888389528,
-0.5233930349,
-0.1659283936,
-0.328694582,
0.4462273419,
0.4138181508,
0.3979076147,
0.1131210178,
-0.1773810536,
0.2476327717,
-0.0237046983,
-0.4910165071,
-0.2759607136,
0.1289683431,
-0.4602985978,
-0.1154624224,
0.3314083815,
-0.3157367408,
-0.2551066279,
-0.5055424571,
0.2673282325,
-0.3601801991,
-0.2792723477,
0.2776010931,
-0.7528579831,
0.6796694994,
0.6174041033,
-0.4106873572,
0.316732347,
0.6128133535,
0.5508915186,
-0.11828693,
-0.4455054402,
-0.1660142988,
-0.3507419229,
-0.421934396,
0.5435168147,
-0.4685367346,
-0.0210065078,
-0.3502166867,
-0.0811632499,
-0.1007053927,
-0.7082676888,
0.1167936176,
-0.5531826615,
0.0697586685,
-0.7863115668,
-0.0351855941,
-0.3714123964,
0.1522744894,
-0.8104438782,
0.9168961048,
0.3041077554,
-0.8905358315,
0.9717677832,
-0.15917705,
-0.1607040912,
0.2014201432,
-0.4190954268,
-0.4370374084,
0.2564345896,
0.2194026858,
0.0216828939,
-0.2026433796,
0.1364745051,
-0.6233482361,
-0.4744383693,
0.6389602423,
-0.0394690223,
0.4858332574,
0.0848795399,
-0.2972519994,
0.1569965333,
-0.790723443,
0.1949652135,
-0.0294907968,
0.2449171245,
-0.5613486171,
-0.0506300144,
-0.5065339804,
0.499464184,
0.0782113895,
-0.4278189242,
0.2333886474,
-0.2188946605,
0.1510147303,
0.7544950247,
-0.0325184539,
0.3446425796,
-0.5764193535,
0.5453642011,
0.4649559259,
0.3119949996,
0.2544570565,
-0.9022583961,
-1.2216033936,
-0.3376721144,
0.3233765662,
0.604673326,
-0.9227671027,
-0.0858492181,
-0.1174520925,
-0.1884533763,
-0.7965112925,
0.0899386257,
0.3947008252,
0.4350621998,
0.139020592,
-0.9688953757,
-0.667982161,
-1.3063815832,
-0.2553052306,
-0.0387133062,
-0.0888906196,
0.6120178699,
0.6761606336,
-0.0318727382,
1.0347598791,
-0.4598631859,
0.0293676499,
-0.323292017,
0.1730713993,
0.4486002326,
0.3629267812,
0.4197590947,
-0.7433542609,
-0.2284153104,
-0.0910973847,
-0.9151749015,
0.2613440454,
-0.3129068613,
-0.4405219257,
-0.4016893804,
0.1167179942,
-0.7013452053,
0.9466032982,
0.0836379528,
-0.153502509,
0.4341275096,
0.1718133688,
0.1436811686,
-0.5633662939,
-0.1989075989,
0.0467054658,
0.0352057852,
-0.6539013386,
0.0439922996,
-0.0849483982,
0.0837132484,
-0.4314132631,
0.3190944493,
-0.5411921144,
-0.3951695561,
0.2179803401,
0.0161244329,
0.0878739506,
0.3471190333,
0.0965105966,
0.7032257318,
1.0693286657,
-0.7547072768,
0.2930178642,
0.3919086754,
-0.3502001464,
0.6423835158,
-1.0094155073,
-0.1639789641,
-0.6845960021,
-0.2116556168,
-1.130450964,
-0.454928875,
-0.0740575716,
-0.6189293861,
0.136339739,
0.1428201795,
-0.1107358634,
-0.7100129128,
-0.2868545949,
0.8440016508,
0.7017766833,
-0.5013649464,
0.4074915051,
-0.161378935,
0.067800805,
-0.9535785317,
-0.782137692,
-0.1672143489,
-0.0265560467,
-1.3860160112,
0.0387781896,
-0.0863735974,
-0.4319707155,
-0.0036794308,
-0.1361689568,
-0.2816448212,
0.2957851291,
0.1384586245,
0.3741467297,
-0.5598372221,
0.10408099,
-0.1592707783,
0.3622062504,
0.0555345714,
-0.0460550748,
0.2794940174,
-0.1836070716,
-0.5525068641,
-0.3749997318,
0.4022701681,
0.24168396,
-0.4225093722,
0.9379950762,
0.353767395,
-0.0694480911,
-0.5500351787,
-0.3952002823,
-0.1347679496,
-0.4897960126,
0.3413946927,
-0.3635857999,
-0.9444554448,
0.8574671745,
0.442240864,
-0.0610649735,
0.2649524212,
0.1960458606,
-0.3176536262,
0.9916196465,
0.4287766516,
0.3543123901,
0.4194379151,
-0.4322546124,
0.0917242467,
-0.7579845786,
-0.3638329208,
-0.0669281483,
-0.7754720449,
-0.6289641261,
-0.3645107746,
0.3840383291,
0.1841558218,
-0.1722325683,
-0.134787634,
-0.61320889,
0.5751399994,
0.9406903386,
0.4094209373,
0.099255383,
-0.1583155245,
0.0815643743,
-0.2072161734,
-0.7522575855,
0.1657973528,
1.0920784473,
0.2991019785,
0.6897193193,
0.046795249,
0.7858492732,
-0.2392669469,
0.1924149245,
-0.692759037,
0.6652190685,
-0.0069093583,
-0.6208627224,
-0.26796031,
-0.3895941675,
-0.8816282153,
0.4139719307,
-0.0414880104,
-0.4637627304,
0.6773199439,
0.2181478441,
-0.2737043202,
0.0059391023,
-0.3775651455,
0.6902198792,
-0.2802885175,
-0.3282788694,
0.1666251421,
-0.7584065199,
0.9695735574,
0.3278149366,
-0.1684932411,
0.1218727008,
0.0701204762,
0.5903527737,
-0.4686536193,
0.5672298074,
0.150431633,
0.4846518636,
0.4546052516,
-0.1066796556,
0.2389850765,
0.2780960202,
0.4399579465,
0.1917272061,
-0.5216886401,
-0.7110263705,
-0.8356133103,
0.3482031226,
-0.7228112817,
-0.7634276152,
-0.6520311236,
-0.5778388381,
-0.2972575128,
0.0953870043,
0.3297940195,
0.3250697851,
-0.0880265757,
0.4000836909,
1.2428473234,
-0.3057436943,
0.2944965959,
0.2079165578,
-0.0714982077,
-0.380233556,
0.7384641767,
0.1730053872,
0.5644703507,
0.0300192442,
-0.1699804813,
0.0894299299,
-0.7121566534,
-0.0122374324,
0.3421990573,
-0.9263603091,
0.0651306137,
-0.4299548268,
-0.6684523821,
-0.0944234058,
-0.0675047114,
-0.0927665457,
-0.7123613358,
-0.229421407,
-0.1080133393,
0.3525789678,
0.7866581082,
0.1289939582,
0.2938401997,
-0.3705602884,
0.4824768007,
0.9131715894,
0.547244966,
0.0154406009,
-0.4938369691,
0.0107773831,
-0.0204803906,
-0.1667617857,
-0.8078588843,
0.1395211965,
0.2401412725,
0.7671966553,
0.3022778332,
-0.2631398141,
0.6731255054,
-0.1735570282,
0.8944889903,
0.3878221512,
-0.426733017,
0.5156059265,
-0.3668729365,
0.4311620295,
0.667306602,
0.250027597,
-0.4546914995,
-0.5183513761,
-0.7572720051,
-0.7481198907,
0.5350756049,
0.5832812786,
-0.2961858809,
0.1809142828,
-0.006717795,
-0.0303089786,
0.4067190289,
-0.4943857491,
-0.5214458704,
-0.4178619385,
-0.0465430021,
0.2521584034,
-0.0871905163,
-0.4272013903,
-0.6874364018,
0.1214150935,
0.0753316581,
0.1071369573,
0.3814105988,
-0.1023439839,
0.183493197,
0.2796346843,
0.4709291458,
0.9929283857,
-0.0226894021,
-0.1442027241,
0.2091815621,
-0.5119177699,
-0.1676288545,
-0.0936533138,
-0.3568153977,
0.4353651404,
0.5029330254,
1.1615670919,
-0.0628585294,
-0.4800221026,
0.671929419,
-0.3833912611,
-0.4317305386,
-0.3043532968,
0.4464167356,
-0.1463309079,
0.3243199289,
0.3132765889,
0.4928307235,
0.3664172888,
-0.495514065,
0.4502208531,
0.7885550261,
-0.1611170322,
-0.1620865166,
0.5199747682,
-0.0406902507,
-0.0540608428,
0.8112766147,
-0.0242461823,
-0.4909041822,
1.0948227644,
-0.2036727965,
0.8803265691,
-0.0219693277,
0.5289853215,
0.4986557961,
0.4636832476,
-0.0489811115,
0.9189890027,
0.0132693248,
-0.6671295762,
-0.0159166995,
-0.487447232,
-0.1270830482,
0.0705420747,
-0.8516793251,
0.0779622048,
-0.6053459644,
-0.2241578698,
-0.1333682388,
-0.4981594086,
-1.1449786425,
0.5011532903,
0.0899453089,
0.8640976548,
-0.7889532447,
0.484153986,
0.3386999965,
-0.6502842307,
-1.1207854748,
-0.3158710003,
-0.2041332424,
-0.8059536219,
0.9897795916,
0.1617382616,
0.2885896266,
-0.5234698653,
-0.898504734,
-1.1787188053,
1.3195137978,
0.0417952202,
-0.6083837748,
-0.1761533618,
0.3073439002,
0.627405107,
-0.3687613308,
0.4144034982,
0.6264395714,
0.2992444038,
0.5334864259,
-0.7887406349,
-0.3113402724,
-0.3344048262,
0.5037533641,
0.0781165808,
-0.5096143484,
1.282638073,
-0.2634269893,
-0.190001145,
0.303712368,
0.6883330345,
0.5144016743,
0.4204719663,
0.3201235235,
0.6534612775,
0.8209810257,
-0.4293272793,
1.2320870161,
0.0269250311,
0.0612461232,
0.9183174372,
0.0720490962,
0.3490716219,
0.4375568032,
-0.1480033398,
0.6421656013,
0.7473421097,
-0.0336375535,
0.4780480266,
0.3077210486,
-0.2510551214,
-0.5107449889,
-0.0637610555,
-0.6014977694,
0.2244210541,
0.2304599881,
-0.5913367271,
-0.1797507703,
-0.2484341264,
-0.5192161202,
-0.2617488503,
-0.5874739885,
0.6764349341,
0.1810411662,
-0.8116924763,
0.7718964815,
-0.5767381191,
0.5183007717,
-0.6555773616,
-0.1255313009,
-0.533133626,
0.0217217654,
-0.3939197063,
-1.0116602182,
-0.0654792935,
-0.5988340378,
-0.3549111187,
0.1841620654,
0.6437904835,
-0.4037665129,
-0.5767917037,
0.0402683653,
0.4969699085,
-0.2051908374,
0.2683315575,
-0.7471116781,
-0.2249101996,
-0.09323892,
-0.1178041771,
0.2558608055,
0.7817200422,
-0.2984012365,
0.7801055908,
0.3806737065,
0.2389218658,
0.5793520212,
0.2230859101,
1.1163977385,
-0.5782559514,
-0.5257275701,
-0.4309410751,
0.984942615,
-0.5671241879,
-0.7470235825,
0.7687669396,
0.1695566028,
0.9254583716,
-0.1764526665,
0.7189777493,
0.1778112054,
0.4096439779,
-0.4768195748,
0.3736287653,
-0.7551909685,
0.3113940954,
-0.3421450257,
-0.8071228266,
-0.0653787702,
0.4533490539,
-0.2904769778,
0.0900346562,
0.9603156447,
0.9026276469,
-0.1769936383,
-0.0240802187,
0.2211758941,
-0.0858242661,
-0.0923398882,
0.7959050536,
1.1241211891,
-0.3009088337,
0.387039423,
-0.3509836197,
-0.2518438995,
-0.0154030342,
-0.3211427033,
-0.9712497592,
-0.4202192724,
-0.2678798437,
-0.3657338619,
0.1119391173,
0.0763615593,
0.7164830565,
-0.821034193,
-0.0864421055,
-0.3074327111,
0.3636170924,
-0.3277031183,
-0.2204041481,
-0.1516746283,
-0.1416219622,
-0.1392988861,
-0.2129153311,
0.1551943719,
0.0818726048,
-0.2270170599,
0.0177740436,
-0.0516563952,
0.1510769874,
0.1875032783,
0.5396259427,
-0.7264843583,
-0.2285832316,
0.2785956562,
0.0556496643,
0.3352885842,
0.8648751378,
-0.7389102578,
0.5516856909,
0.7806517482,
0.7489416599,
0.3986640275,
0.0715765134,
0.6464197636,
-0.871737957,
0.1818057597,
0.4351596534,
0.4205927551,
0.2684875727,
-0.4046469331,
0.4255514741,
0.4402401447,
-0.2767927647,
-0.7417979836,
0.6827668548,
-1.0098382235,
-0.3945597708,
0.9621610641,
0.1999495924,
-0.486340493,
-0.0652084872,
-0.088032946,
-0.1447884887,
-0.2208588868,
0.4877921939,
0.8161202073,
-0.2913256288,
-0.4193588793,
-0.4933204055,
0.6100104451,
0.6596241593,
-0.6108217239,
-0.586279273,
0.54529953,
0.362549901,
-0.0549159944,
0.351881206,
0.2611263692,
1.0453641415,
-0.009936153,
-0.0855203047,
0.1567896456,
-0.5126883388,
-0.3906739652,
0.1490426809,
0.1508491039,
-0.2857570052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08692v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08692v1
|
Routing to the Expert: Efficient Reward-guided Ensemble of Large Language Models
| 2023-11-15T04:40:43 | 2023-11-15T04:40:43 |
Keming Lu, Hongyi Yuan, Runji Lin, Junyang Lin, Zheng Yuan, Chang Zhou, Jingren Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The complementary potential of Large Language Models (LLM) assumes
off-the-shelf LLMs have heterogeneous expertise in a wide range of domains and
tasks so that an ensemble of LLMs can achieve consistently better performance.
Existing ensemble methods for LLMs mainly focus on reward model ranking of
outputs, leading to significant computation overhead. To combat this issue, we
revisit the complementary potential of LLMs and further elaborate it by mining
latent expertise with off-the-shelf reward models. We propose Zooter, a
reward-guided routing method distilling rewards on training queries to train a
routing function, which can precisely distribute each query to the LLM with
expertise about it. We also integrate a tag-based label enhancement to mitigate
noise from uncertainty when using rewards as silver supervision. Zooter shows
computation efficiency in inference as it introduces only a minor computation
overhead of a routing function compared with reward model ranking methods. We
evaluate Zooter on a comprehensive benchmark collection with 26 subsets on
different domains and tasks. Zooter outperforms the best single model on
average and ranks first on 44% of tasks, even surpassing multiple reward model
ranking methods.
|
[
-0.3775371313,
-0.3156786561,
0.4372847378,
-0.1230968833,
-0.0635121167,
0.2355852574,
-0.3202356696,
-0.1950682253,
0.3458605409,
0.5702762604,
-0.6251598001,
-0.3835020065,
-0.807585597,
-0.1906769872,
-0.0512163714,
0.8663669229,
0.4343080819,
-0.0174815208,
-0.3205101192,
0.0042791013,
-0.23130247,
-0.5573031902,
-0.6763735414,
-0.4474436343,
0.7900704145,
0.3728358448,
0.5264980793,
0.6578746438,
0.4517585635,
0.4247523248,
-0.2258872092,
0.1865818352,
-0.5472419858,
0.2641985118,
-0.5541551709,
-0.5246180296,
-0.5376073718,
-0.0250740293,
0.1183069572,
0.7910090089,
-0.3640253842,
-0.1701742709,
-0.1047177315,
0.5763004422,
-0.5766778588,
0.1847462058,
-0.7015002966,
-0.254655987,
-0.5048394799,
-0.2646587491,
-0.2208533138,
-0.3411232829,
0.068276912,
-0.5711757541,
0.2061890662,
0.0473621041,
0.4316985607,
0.5452560186,
-0.1517171115,
-0.3511260748,
-0.5309576988,
0.9251692891,
-0.5526556373,
0.2317482531,
0.5721492171,
0.5283861756,
-0.0852948651,
-0.6994258761,
-0.1761027128,
-0.0400504023,
0.104654856,
0.0969576538,
-0.2390264422,
0.0393369757,
-0.1349100173,
0.578790009,
-0.4081986248,
0.3795349896,
0.0159797575,
-0.0060283681,
0.746697247,
-0.0188372079,
0.0106907832,
0.1000101715,
-0.0745034218,
-0.4149377346,
-0.5816619992,
0.234310329,
0.5014615655,
0.2083812356,
0.2296970338,
0.4835664332,
-0.3237693608,
0.9388384223,
0.2351893187,
-0.2214847207,
-0.0309844874,
0.0723516718,
0.2498017848,
0.1085488647,
0.6539002657,
0.0162882376,
0.1500423551,
-0.7450953722,
-0.5635214448,
-0.0267421976,
0.3261660039,
-0.5245660543,
-0.7232136726,
0.1303637475,
-0.1361453533,
-0.4879864454,
-0.0331064612,
-0.881231904,
-0.4138874114,
0.0429123715,
0.3454212248,
-0.14436692,
-0.5141678452,
0.0782018453,
-0.1955314875,
0.0463272668,
0.3791072369,
-1.1786857843,
0.4223139584,
1.0906565189,
0.8053542972,
-0.2206600159,
-0.1554992795,
-0.975004077,
-0.0201111902,
-0.2514484525,
1.106637001,
-0.7917901874,
-0.3010447025,
-0.0801702216,
-0.1823275834,
0.001294709,
-0.3830377162,
0.6399951577,
-0.9845049381,
-0.162427187,
-0.1971660554,
-0.6770626307,
-0.1766836345,
0.1232929081,
-0.8054469228,
0.9293018579,
0.2595666349,
-0.7133752704,
0.1011635661,
-0.4798144996,
-0.4425218999,
0.2877188325,
-0.1348207742,
0.1212052032,
0.1186486781,
0.2432765365,
0.4669742584,
-0.3925898671,
0.3803415298,
-0.1611091942,
-0.3074600697,
0.0066219047,
-0.180991292,
0.5421641469,
0.1773371696,
-0.3467299938,
-0.0697599873,
-0.4587299228,
-0.1194872186,
0.0006022064,
-0.4382432401,
-0.7417005897,
0.1646227092,
-0.1671273857,
0.1097875983,
0.1252160519,
-0.2566321492,
0.4591341913,
-0.637579143,
0.3585780859,
1.061617136,
-0.1978397965,
0.8243999481,
-0.5661710501,
0.6590709686,
-0.4441460073,
-0.3374862373,
-0.0686189979,
-0.608207643,
-0.6895632744,
-0.2621982396,
0.4122305214,
0.5283099413,
-0.6835903525,
0.6859305501,
-0.4709074795,
-0.9079980254,
-0.529261291,
0.0992867202,
0.1411735862,
0.4083459973,
0.2228676975,
-0.304071188,
-0.0381540321,
-0.5848515034,
-0.2771010399,
-0.1675486416,
0.0707483441,
0.4321102202,
0.1397794932,
-0.2065569311,
0.8857864738,
-0.58222121,
-0.1390348226,
-0.1768248528,
0.3185240924,
0.4509815276,
0.5332343578,
0.410736382,
-0.5811950564,
-0.2828414142,
0.0356751233,
-0.3346347511,
-0.3132400811,
0.2834529877,
-0.1956017911,
-0.0817888603,
0.3257462084,
-0.5796635151,
-0.0092426194,
0.5317890644,
-0.1489326358,
0.2820377946,
-0.1529313773,
0.0087170359,
-0.7616792917,
0.0530982092,
-0.1551387906,
-0.2654317021,
-0.5836564302,
-0.1058059335,
-0.355230689,
0.1032199785,
0.1327856928,
0.8139283657,
-0.286537379,
0.0434774309,
-0.3689900637,
-0.0949692279,
-0.1767562032,
0.6070222259,
0.2890827358,
0.5867111087,
0.8506538272,
-0.5877712369,
0.5813709497,
0.1579682827,
-0.3854864836,
0.5003895164,
-0.4954015315,
0.2826758921,
0.0586696528,
0.108074978,
-0.9686148763,
-0.2443999946,
0.119763568,
-0.4767997563,
0.4124370217,
-0.4168524146,
-0.5067077875,
-0.1134678647,
-0.1708128005,
0.2178048342,
0.6220074892,
-0.7406867743,
0.6107264757,
0.5148651004,
-0.57227844,
-0.6925621629,
-0.5586489439,
0.0272782743,
-0.3697803319,
-0.5196826458,
0.5791732073,
0.0651221275,
-0.3222126663,
-0.0567123257,
-0.1820335835,
0.0234715473,
0.4666038752,
0.1689497381,
-0.1499178708,
-0.1902707815,
0.4308150709,
-0.0062386654,
-0.2855055034,
0.2510928512,
-0.4297687113,
0.6167975068,
-0.19030343,
-0.5591945648,
0.1666920483,
0.3081463873,
0.3857178688,
-0.4740343392,
0.5571359992,
0.6162266135,
-0.1463182271,
-0.3634449244,
-0.7136558294,
-0.4734710157,
-0.5168758035,
0.2576257885,
-0.2233211994,
-0.9593665004,
0.3892289996,
-0.417307198,
0.2157291621,
0.3828665912,
0.2950440645,
0.0586326979,
0.9151921272,
0.7469037175,
-0.4218149185,
0.4096594155,
-0.2788538635,
0.2340874076,
-0.4322819412,
-0.2846694589,
-0.8124597073,
-0.1288927197,
-0.7046420574,
-0.6372336149,
0.4468628764,
0.3469616473,
-0.2005383074,
-0.1438543648,
-0.4682254791,
0.3496794999,
0.7882189751,
-0.0163594298,
0.2805024385,
0.2000395954,
-0.0463098586,
0.3377610743,
-1.3307931423,
-0.4720692635,
0.9370045066,
0.0762664825,
1.1741043329,
0.2543160617,
0.6731268167,
0.3524354696,
0.4746487737,
-0.8317909837,
0.3977169693,
-0.2075726539,
-0.3141070008,
-0.3863891363,
-0.3362015784,
-0.81530267,
0.099989064,
-0.1912260354,
-0.8218901157,
0.0754571408,
0.1268199086,
-0.3071913719,
0.4418528974,
-0.3210763931,
0.6250960827,
-0.5835441351,
-0.7971045375,
-0.1929167062,
-0.7042238712,
0.3169006705,
-0.1860063821,
0.1290343553,
0.1755292714,
-0.0677181482,
0.9018272161,
-0.580217123,
0.7252383232,
-0.141506657,
0.1146596,
0.053001117,
0.102779828,
0.7510412335,
0.0163920298,
-0.4816627204,
0.0863830671,
-0.5168899894,
-0.284081012,
-0.5275754929,
0.9258701205,
-0.809995532,
-0.8277247548,
-0.4958728254,
-0.4154102206,
-0.3242458105,
0.2267322391,
0.1666770726,
0.4898416996,
0.0788472369,
0.1169516668,
0.9356932044,
-0.2479228675,
0.3459136784,
0.344725728,
0.2054096311,
-0.2541842759,
0.8625339866,
-0.1317223608,
-0.0137092592,
0.609054625,
0.3663769364,
-0.5932133198,
-0.4939223826,
-0.4353326261,
0.1475105733,
-0.7217179537,
-0.3356422484,
-0.9047465324,
-0.0480209701,
-0.3959151804,
-0.4748595953,
-0.5311535001,
-0.3816236854,
-0.2182787508,
-0.0500238054,
0.8857811689,
0.7619057894,
-0.3311023116,
0.5621691346,
-0.6299167275,
-0.1492204666,
0.5971896052,
0.4692933559,
0.3335201144,
-0.4346525967,
-0.3411608934,
-0.3021296263,
-0.1499759704,
-0.7873190045,
0.3599753678,
0.0759390742,
1.1621617079,
0.6160734296,
0.2649798989,
0.3891324699,
-0.2673520148,
0.6487860084,
0.0191079807,
-0.6615421176,
0.3448695242,
-0.4386686683,
0.0878055915,
0.4718313813,
0.3899708986,
-0.2938507497,
-0.3623739779,
-0.7755118608,
-0.9802667499,
0.9537267685,
0.0257021058,
-0.0800986439,
0.0986481756,
0.2004739493,
0.1654690206,
0.2654235959,
-0.636478126,
-0.1950881928,
-0.3011502326,
0.0138784871,
-0.5028170943,
0.0027392618,
-0.1330011785,
-0.1329496801,
0.7132623792,
-0.0935224593,
0.3707165122,
-0.115860641,
-0.1505583823,
-0.1379157156,
0.2198682576,
0.1430141777,
0.5476292372,
-0.3736715317,
0.3437616527,
0.0552873313,
-0.0597864538,
0.0294650458,
0.428879261,
0.2869826853,
-0.0742488652,
0.4664152265,
0.6186316013,
0.195090279,
-0.6678037643,
0.6669666171,
0.218990162,
-0.0392264649,
-0.0312799737,
0.4392601848,
0.4367777109,
0.3091776967,
0.3719747066,
0.0915281698,
0.1494951546,
-0.0613916628,
0.1967096329,
0.4775742888,
-0.4202715158,
-0.1784964353,
0.4902896881,
0.3052519262,
-0.5285690427,
0.5313333869,
-0.09579207,
-0.7447175384,
0.6137177348,
0.1102120131,
0.6962667108,
-0.5320879221,
0.0819395185,
0.2357883751,
0.2449864745,
-0.3903801143,
-0.2212348431,
-0.4412887692,
-0.5974227786,
-0.4001893699,
-0.6173192859,
-0.5154936314,
0.1274204105,
-0.5965390801,
0.1216410846,
0.0227081608,
0.0947605222,
0.0720352605,
-0.006127594,
-0.5349991918,
0.0950249508,
-0.0063290847,
0.8888818622,
-0.8615031242,
0.8613327146,
1.1237024069,
-0.0740835741,
-0.8163256049,
-0.3131139576,
-0.2547875643,
-0.6056774259,
0.5471253991,
0.088112846,
-0.4787995815,
0.1601504683,
-0.436050117,
-0.6013339758,
1.100615263,
-0.0497258678,
-0.5321864486,
0.120091252,
-0.0168560427,
0.4498617351,
-0.3567494154,
0.6153616309,
0.3880644143,
0.3740801811,
0.3231540322,
-0.5839954615,
-0.2493707389,
-0.3346948326,
-0.2937426567,
0.088443242,
-0.6518386006,
0.9318139553,
-0.0115488926,
0.2049113661,
-0.0448745899,
0.4004652798,
0.4249483049,
0.2555545568,
0.7568768263,
0.4363636672,
1.0356994867,
0.1016400456,
0.9079277515,
-0.3506363034,
0.1573808789,
0.8335351944,
-0.1438080817,
0.5480109453,
0.4051773548,
0.1041097194,
0.4512783289,
0.9017696381,
0.0804485306,
1.0265114307,
0.4606621861,
-0.2160009742,
-0.6131579876,
-0.062626712,
-0.4221214354,
0.4167794585,
0.329457134,
-0.1615437716,
-0.5056394339,
-0.1601214558,
-0.0030393035,
0.0762758777,
-0.5203706622,
0.8496887088,
0.0567752942,
-1.0555483103,
0.4093617201,
0.1841433942,
0.8496974707,
-0.7167807221,
-0.1632152945,
-0.5023191571,
0.1743411869,
0.0057267305,
-0.6096944213,
0.0258059576,
0.181186229,
-0.0545027815,
-0.425327152,
0.9731963873,
-0.2479256541,
-0.4216251075,
0.1799299121,
0.8067876697,
0.2391947806,
-0.3032580018,
-0.4940243959,
-0.4455811083,
-0.2650399506,
-0.4366520941,
0.3242118061,
0.549110949,
-0.0466937013,
0.8674250841,
0.5727902651,
0.082618162,
-0.0630093142,
-0.1806204319,
1.2628728151,
-0.5010572076,
-0.9220955372,
-0.6425625086,
0.3362541497,
0.0294797216,
-0.0718527511,
0.5448467135,
0.520188272,
0.7520192266,
-0.0584323704,
0.8090395331,
0.0805014893,
0.4576140642,
-0.3835168481,
0.7798629403,
-0.7877666354,
0.5421882272,
-0.2142851502,
-0.6397393942,
0.0609781034,
0.8323965073,
-0.5236575603,
0.1528875232,
0.3070212603,
1.0248608589,
-0.3105386496,
0.0822562203,
0.0404014885,
-0.1393761933,
0.2014715523,
0.6850055456,
1.0866330862,
0.0915319994,
0.3563961089,
-0.3041712344,
-0.4568995833,
-0.4537153244,
-0.9299046993,
-0.9177901149,
-0.4140671194,
-0.0727051944,
-0.1457444429,
0.1219109222,
0.849290669,
1.0272088051,
-0.616618216,
-0.4463682473,
-0.2342706174,
0.4649834335,
-0.4671806097,
-0.1284076571,
0.4445152581,
-0.2727676332,
-0.6213026643,
0.4041838944,
0.1762289703,
-0.3530562818,
-0.326544404,
-0.3440713584,
-0.2009904683,
-0.0622817613,
0.3122501373,
0.0367603451,
-0.5633086562,
0.1896591932,
0.1973672211,
-0.0832054913,
-0.0392223187,
0.7820802927,
-0.9199630022,
0.3232502937,
0.5438574553,
0.9033270478,
0.6279976964,
0.06510102,
0.5426082611,
-0.3818228245,
-0.10370408,
0.4739063978,
-0.0056021865,
0.307072401,
-0.3583711684,
0.6723937988,
0.1976955682,
-0.6485213041,
-0.7568297982,
-0.0161764733,
-1.1580355167,
-0.2544984221,
1.2396063805,
-0.2186454982,
-0.1550675035,
-0.2828569114,
0.2056301385,
0.1648982018,
-0.4701752067,
0.7083191276,
0.6673145294,
-0.0527038984,
-0.3133789301,
-0.420737952,
0.5985664725,
0.3762714863,
-0.6951629519,
-0.088944599,
0.2523623705,
0.2383496761,
0.0937519744,
0.6394413114,
0.2386447191,
0.0868825838,
-0.0488587804,
0.0952353328,
-0.2755361497,
-0.2079092264,
-0.2840512991,
0.2151008546,
0.458129406,
0.1071456522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08687v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08687v1
|
An Eye on Clinical BERT: Investigating Language Model Generalization for Diabetic Eye Disease Phenotyping
| 2023-11-15T04:30:20 | 2023-11-15T04:30:20 |
Keith Harrigian, Tina Tang, Anthony Gonzales, Cindy X. Cai, Mark Dredze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Diabetic eye disease is a major cause of blindness worldwide. The ability to
monitor relevant clinical trajectories and detect lapses in care is critical to
managing the disease and preventing blindness. Alas, much of the information
necessary to support these goals is found only in the free text of the
electronic medical record. To fill this information gap, we introduce a system
for extracting evidence from clinical text of 19 clinical concepts related to
diabetic eye disease and inferring relevant attributes for each. In developing
this ophthalmology phenotyping system, we are also afforded a unique
opportunity to evaluate the effectiveness of clinical language models at
adapting to new clinical domains. Across multiple training paradigms, we find
that BERT language models pretrained on out-of-distribution clinical data offer
no significant improvement over BERT language models pretrained on non-clinical
data for our domain. Our study tempers recent claims that language models
pretrained on clinical data are necessary for clinical NLP tasks and highlights
the importance of not treating clinical language data as a single homogeneous
domain.
|
[
-0.0442910157,
-0.8252777457,
0.6557582021,
0.1036839113,
-0.4407295883,
-0.4251020551,
-0.1725147963,
-0.7966993451,
0.3372912407,
0.7837628126,
-0.0758812353,
-0.7128468156,
-0.5959955454,
-0.0953687802,
-0.2849368155,
1.1115031242,
0.0276132021,
0.6674748063,
-0.0470691547,
0.0565862544,
-0.3307362199,
-0.3796567917,
-0.562917769,
-0.0852634236,
0.404125154,
0.3308291733,
0.4969387352,
0.4099691808,
1.0907562971,
0.1447662413,
0.1693582386,
-0.0979619622,
-0.2673752606,
0.0840993673,
0.2553175688,
-0.4909783006,
-0.7395934463,
-0.0561860688,
0.3620752394,
1.1738929749,
-0.2261606604,
-0.1744362414,
-0.1319874674,
0.6803959012,
-0.4636436999,
0.189891085,
-0.4897170663,
0.2132603526,
-0.3821880817,
-0.0225012843,
-0.5075407028,
-0.3374601603,
0.8534149528,
-0.6870148778,
0.571819365,
-0.016502548,
0.850405097,
0.0005831451,
-0.3413647115,
-0.4468450844,
-0.5407060385,
0.4611434937,
-0.9196190834,
0.283621043,
0.4455787838,
0.3425665796,
0.167355895,
-0.7589538097,
-0.379052192,
-0.6835894585,
-0.0659403875,
0.16928792,
0.1205507815,
0.3906734288,
-0.1409321874,
0.1640687883,
-0.6098753214,
0.1178830713,
-0.355247438,
0.0626496524,
0.6408750415,
0.0769500732,
0.4127975404,
0.0722345859,
-0.5898100734,
-0.0173586607,
-0.5221421123,
-0.2295572758,
-0.088323012,
0.0543469191,
-0.1084428579,
0.4570968449,
0.2633966804,
0.6845405102,
-0.0490039065,
0.0646517277,
0.1664578021,
-0.3171531856,
-0.3184401095,
0.1082078591,
0.4390218258,
0.4920111597,
0.4015390873,
-0.3494451344,
-0.1797661483,
-0.015238028,
0.5222566724,
-0.5787935853,
-0.756326139,
0.1973467916,
-0.6735277772,
-0.2601517141,
0.0553031638,
-0.8848076463,
-0.3401097953,
0.0820742622,
0.3272877336,
-0.5818697214,
-0.1508784294,
0.3924041092,
-0.2504748404,
-0.0371607393,
0.5327841043,
-1.4877833128,
0.2112144381,
0.4522891641,
0.4985600114,
-0.3045840859,
-0.0937579349,
-0.1222141609,
0.1355062872,
-0.5754739046,
0.4411766827,
-0.4788075089,
-0.4081570506,
0.1549163908,
-0.0242951177,
-0.180884853,
-0.7211321592,
0.2327394336,
-0.3890863955,
-0.086794734,
0.0955011994,
-0.9976710677,
0.1509670019,
-0.2649100125,
-0.596930027,
0.597943306,
0.2312886268,
-0.4843403101,
0.7950667143,
-0.6261524558,
-0.1958166063,
0.582993865,
-0.2371484637,
-0.6662950516,
0.6170848608,
0.0861670747,
0.4466288686,
0.0694950595,
0.6846850514,
-0.3931771815,
0.0049372599,
0.0164870098,
0.1883265078,
0.4887580276,
0.1729856879,
-0.2349587679,
-0.1236469671,
-0.804885447,
-0.1960505247,
0.1467813849,
-0.2292907536,
-0.851934135,
0.2443157285,
0.2391556948,
-0.4149839282,
0.3320510089,
-0.8230371475,
0.2580992281,
-0.4102459252,
0.1821885854,
0.6306757927,
0.040889699,
0.2525091767,
-0.0455294698,
0.256860435,
0.1755434573,
0.5417692661,
0.0112400232,
-0.8894649744,
-0.8163971305,
-0.1768749356,
0.3304382563,
0.4661482275,
-0.4437436163,
0.2654554546,
0.0936986059,
-0.2706003189,
-0.7413685322,
-0.1370930672,
0.3597411513,
0.6706224084,
0.3215364814,
-0.7359597683,
-0.2732974887,
-1.1182472706,
0.1771084517,
-0.2803176343,
0.0803425014,
0.239682287,
0.5783433318,
-0.267183423,
0.8732200861,
-0.6019320488,
-0.4227596819,
-0.2636165321,
0.3026648164,
-0.1070412546,
0.5453380942,
0.8174705505,
-0.7817339301,
-0.482970953,
0.023118224,
-0.964274168,
-0.2246331722,
-0.0749445036,
-0.0045963097,
0.0031992497,
0.4167979658,
-0.3614490628,
0.8234505057,
0.525881052,
-0.4367311895,
0.5667085052,
-0.4379953742,
-0.1682525873,
-0.4293181002,
0.3237240613,
0.1027170047,
-0.2756620646,
-0.951903522,
0.0347950757,
0.0288065709,
-0.1262990683,
-0.1029833257,
0.3671889305,
-0.0175005347,
0.0440311655,
-0.0896623656,
0.0512611419,
-0.0480943955,
0.1510683596,
0.3871829808,
0.4898329675,
0.5472758412,
-0.4461509883,
0.3728283346,
0.7187170386,
-0.8079631329,
0.3527214527,
-0.6513024569,
-0.3044508994,
-0.1833326221,
0.0271692071,
-0.9521859288,
0.0316565074,
0.0014513973,
-0.533813715,
0.2660400271,
0.1939613521,
-0.2145242691,
-0.3047465086,
0.0568098724,
0.2129961699,
0.4579825103,
-0.1946746856,
-0.0275676753,
0.441657275,
-0.468662709,
-0.3664276004,
-0.7315457463,
-0.0043607964,
-0.0936982557,
-0.4672828913,
0.4014893472,
0.1158775091,
-0.4022647142,
0.1208586171,
0.0582148582,
-0.5640727282,
0.1356324255,
-0.2279848754,
0.3649449646,
-0.450350374,
0.4474651515,
-0.4215572774,
-0.1018143147,
0.0548021048,
0.0324540399,
0.0895041302,
0.4686350822,
-0.3309229016,
-0.5208486319,
0.6799485087,
0.3391765356,
-0.0665206164,
0.565195322,
0.3665340245,
-0.2314936817,
-0.1488698274,
-0.4162811041,
-0.4282571077,
-0.3730271757,
0.5350626707,
0.0972687602,
-0.6105079651,
0.3450192511,
0.2044404149,
0.152695775,
0.2159387171,
0.475556016,
-0.3140720427,
0.7846925259,
1.2400927544,
0.3382901847,
0.6696847081,
-0.0739292428,
0.2677959204,
-0.6006695032,
-0.3822371662,
-0.1795012355,
0.0512608178,
-0.3336324692,
-0.0476766936,
0.7177088857,
-0.0768476725,
0.1739286929,
-0.0197470691,
-0.455581069,
0.0485335775,
0.487652272,
0.5174404383,
0.2386182845,
-0.1015681252,
-0.2372166067,
-0.397911489,
-0.6058697701,
-0.3427524865,
1.5193893909,
0.3908694685,
0.6786063313,
-0.0757890269,
0.4775061309,
0.6480815411,
0.607509315,
-0.4360251725,
0.29986763,
-0.4974195063,
-0.7276512384,
-0.2527201176,
-0.1845262945,
-0.9206075668,
0.088660121,
-0.0733740702,
-0.7079653144,
0.4976304471,
0.2951577902,
-0.4570203722,
0.0970557705,
-0.9620124698,
1.1313650608,
-0.4814976156,
-0.0773449466,
-0.1227026284,
-0.9058644772,
0.2520489097,
-0.3946804702,
0.0009023836,
-0.0098420456,
0.0634634346,
0.7076958418,
-0.6965674162,
1.1300576925,
-0.2674024105,
-0.2759532332,
-0.0126137417,
-0.2394875735,
0.1747953147,
-0.073335737,
0.4684826732,
0.1622945368,
0.0776505768,
-0.5196954012,
-0.36069417,
0.1582073718,
-0.5619162321,
-0.4355410635,
-0.4357033968,
-0.355484128,
-0.5347043276,
-0.0452490933,
0.1066815928,
0.5021985173,
-0.4286671281,
0.0224261191,
0.7057809234,
-0.2593130767,
0.1073824465,
0.6835977435,
-0.2388505042,
-0.3230305314,
0.6513587236,
-0.3792815208,
0.6353836656,
0.6932310462,
0.0482505634,
-0.1773923934,
-0.9645257592,
-0.3375781775,
0.306661129,
-0.6076750755,
0.273691535,
-0.2731771171,
0.0691542551,
-0.5703046918,
-0.1830221713,
-0.1068272367,
-0.2360291481,
-0.1953155696,
0.1057872847,
0.3735889792,
0.8285182714,
0.0679313913,
0.4656829536,
-0.9035021663,
0.3360815048,
0.276551038,
0.3560342193,
-0.1553783119,
-0.0938519984,
-0.5320664048,
-0.0121758273,
-0.2527433932,
-0.8423537612,
0.5831217766,
0.5722901821,
0.5908589363,
0.6512143016,
-0.32592538,
0.7331463695,
-0.7042262554,
0.7726530433,
0.4418987036,
-0.7725895643,
0.6195757389,
-0.1108539924,
-0.1590541601,
0.5686529875,
0.3847483993,
-0.5711373091,
-0.5805829167,
-0.6024914384,
-0.7897179127,
0.498770684,
0.0239728279,
-0.2734601796,
-0.1145546958,
0.2866195142,
0.3906122148,
0.3467139006,
-0.3636718988,
-0.1717720181,
-0.1326216608,
-0.3402068019,
-0.4659639597,
-0.251983732,
-0.0584422946,
-0.2789538801,
0.2747807205,
-0.0668355748,
0.4900005162,
0.7489053607,
-0.2197099477,
-0.1189853922,
-0.0120099476,
0.5644367933,
0.790527463,
-0.6485720873,
-0.0292679463,
-0.3961210847,
-1.1888002157,
-0.2956463695,
0.140943855,
-0.2912926674,
0.4550804794,
0.5527976751,
0.7092244625,
0.3446097672,
-1.0536050797,
0.7092476487,
0.1927561909,
-0.1969931871,
-0.2673108578,
-0.114004761,
-0.4086710811,
-0.0297320392,
0.3583078086,
-0.0746981427,
0.1909333318,
-0.3232321739,
0.6130902171,
0.373818785,
-0.3108907342,
-0.5429584384,
0.9533048272,
0.5422151089,
0.2324323058,
0.7193513513,
0.436612159,
-0.2122785598,
0.7904716134,
0.4920162261,
0.6642823219,
-0.199316293,
0.3749211133,
-0.0318398438,
0.2597280145,
0.0850365534,
0.2201116681,
0.1296832263,
-0.8142750263,
-0.3456825614,
-0.5194950104,
-0.5667894483,
0.2864347994,
-0.6898426414,
0.1368169636,
-0.5047867894,
-0.2832123935,
0.5304234028,
-0.3000410795,
-0.3106065392,
0.403267771,
0.5044057965,
1.0309380293,
-0.8670097589,
0.9208370447,
0.6680386066,
-0.4557368457,
-0.0530785434,
-0.2411781102,
-0.14073129,
-1.278529048,
0.8162076473,
-0.1731845587,
0.4451766014,
-0.0294727013,
-0.6595205069,
-0.270781517,
0.5746573806,
0.1996291578,
-0.6085775495,
-0.4165769219,
0.3051652908,
0.7740343213,
-0.5833375454,
-0.1303615421,
0.4585018754,
0.3631871343,
-0.1581676602,
-1.1651064157,
-0.3469186425,
-0.1149955988,
-0.0940508395,
0.4209436476,
-0.2475004345,
0.7826095223,
-0.5483629107,
-0.0606221482,
0.2622054517,
0.0376323797,
-0.1220889539,
0.4608292282,
0.1494527012,
0.8259766102,
0.5257658362,
-0.0607778914,
0.9670137167,
-0.1784681082,
0.4862679243,
0.5356235504,
-0.5566925406,
0.6956583261,
0.4346472025,
-0.2352610528,
0.2845064104,
0.6469500065,
-0.0879830495,
0.9544843435,
0.0295413118,
-0.3612679243,
-0.459836334,
-0.0085835475,
-0.5030988455,
0.3238859773,
0.4924965501,
-0.6767081618,
-0.2209993005,
0.0879705027,
-0.2440368533,
-0.077412203,
-0.2186000496,
0.7719859481,
0.0963166207,
-0.3278760016,
0.5762404799,
-0.3645995557,
0.3390868902,
-1.0034734011,
-0.1016778424,
-0.0327667035,
0.5212842226,
0.1325562,
-0.4655334949,
0.3140324652,
-0.1604457945,
-0.053147275,
-0.0978306979,
0.3595196605,
-0.4503979087,
-0.2557184398,
0.1719637215,
0.6283063889,
0.3395089507,
0.3109015524,
-0.5841189027,
-0.2824658155,
-0.0044237385,
0.0932705179,
0.2810306251,
0.6573505402,
-0.0241558943,
0.604752779,
0.541959703,
0.5748841763,
0.0988592058,
0.144766748,
0.5827701092,
-0.7209616899,
-0.4305290878,
-0.735845387,
0.2605066597,
0.0088228509,
-0.5837221742,
0.5653293133,
0.4237065613,
0.5534667373,
-0.4038654566,
0.7889029384,
0.0054043895,
0.3727521598,
-0.5674600601,
0.6972096562,
-0.7395212054,
-0.056690637,
-0.2035825551,
-0.5067824721,
-0.7196336389,
0.6149150133,
-0.2545248866,
-0.1735084504,
0.9485689998,
0.1692343056,
0.0010270549,
0.1456997842,
0.454338491,
0.3914761245,
0.2314829677,
0.6819825172,
0.4130299687,
-0.1760613471,
0.0097905779,
-0.1079130843,
-0.4252236485,
-0.714055717,
-0.6235775948,
-0.7742738724,
-0.554695487,
-0.3173556626,
-0.0021204553,
0.2509812117,
0.5208591819,
0.8507849574,
-1.0052863359,
-0.0337673388,
-0.2907826304,
-0.378627032,
-0.3872499466,
-0.1536842138,
0.54047966,
-0.4895284176,
-0.456448704,
0.043385651,
0.2221486419,
0.4432361424,
-0.3179098964,
0.3339307308,
-0.0686908737,
-0.1985750347,
0.5130504966,
0.2149088979,
-0.5882404447,
-0.1383921206,
0.0277456511,
-0.2125279903,
0.2141986191,
0.926721096,
-0.5348809361,
0.8062308431,
0.1462049037,
0.3835443258,
0.1799470186,
-0.0376999639,
0.7741991282,
-0.4494121075,
0.2017861605,
0.6059738994,
0.4502846003,
0.268555671,
-0.0754332691,
0.4164233208,
0.6385016441,
-0.6285511851,
-0.7538366318,
0.1912456602,
-0.9649867415,
-0.1367813051,
0.7200177908,
-0.382848084,
-0.2824772894,
-0.3887182772,
-0.0773733258,
-0.1886950135,
-0.3755459189,
1.0463883877,
0.6492690444,
-0.2787212133,
-0.1121595055,
-0.9062493443,
0.7390139103,
0.5288091898,
-0.727190733,
0.1440829486,
0.4118587375,
0.2118359804,
0.0178538356,
0.8374167085,
-0.1668897122,
0.3538144231,
-0.0546385795,
0.3709430695,
0.3774272203,
-0.3598185182,
-0.1173460335,
-0.139169991,
-0.1981635243,
-0.3911995292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08685v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08685v3
|
Safer-Instruct: Aligning Language Models with Automated Preference Data
| 2023-11-15T04:22:22 | 2024-03-31T22:42:03 |
Taiwei Shi, Kai Chen, Jieyu Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) is a vital strategy for
enhancing model capability in language models. However, annotating preference
data for RLHF is a resource-intensive and creativity-demanding process, while
existing automatic generation methods face limitations in data diversity and
quality. In response, we present Safer-Instruct, a novel pipeline for
automatically constructing large-scale preference data. Our approach leverages
reversed instruction tuning, instruction induction, and expert model evaluation
to efficiently generate high-quality preference data without human annotators.
To verify the effectiveness of Safer-Instruct, we apply the pipeline to
construct a safety preference dataset as a case study. Finetuning an Alpaca
model on this synthetic dataset not only demonstrates improved harmlessness but
also outperforms models fine-tuned on human-annotated safety preference data,
all the while maintaining a competitive edge in downstream tasks. Importantly,
our Safer-Instruct framework is versatile and can be applied to generate
preference data across various domains, extending its utility beyond safety
preferences. It addresses the challenges in preference data acquisition and
advances the development of more capable and responsible AI systems. For
dataset and code implementation, see
https://github.com/uscnlp-lime/safer-instruct
|
[
-0.3721065223,
-0.4991991818,
0.2191985846,
-0.129464373,
-0.0368424729,
-0.152968213,
-0.3562934399,
-0.2992320955,
0.0218495913,
0.7582038641,
-0.4991102219,
-0.5970454812,
-0.411734432,
-0.1965484321,
-0.2005757987,
1.2720551491,
0.1967541277,
-0.1086292416,
-0.0339027345,
-0.1031008586,
-0.5335825086,
-0.6130450964,
-0.7863442898,
-0.2329617292,
0.5342675447,
0.6938320994,
1.0752655268,
1.0189779997,
0.1367830038,
0.2238695472,
0.5864303708,
0.314443022,
-0.2972660661,
0.0552108958,
-0.2059399933,
-0.2324360311,
-0.4323350191,
0.2580531836,
0.3361483514,
0.5275762677,
-0.2749116719,
0.105002746,
0.0318153761,
0.7733985782,
-0.7813238502,
0.3631055057,
-0.6953579187,
0.086587429,
-0.0835328028,
-0.3499102294,
-0.8145363331,
-0.7533550858,
0.2349270582,
-0.4662067294,
0.1253063679,
0.2829005718,
0.7591891885,
0.6684978604,
-0.5048445463,
-0.1427713782,
-0.4327467084,
0.7717603445,
-0.6031705737,
0.2726131678,
0.6724631786,
0.2669734061,
-0.3455622196,
-0.3220945001,
-0.396841377,
-0.3318542242,
0.0080032172,
-0.1613563746,
0.2636449337,
0.2038274854,
-0.1490209848,
-0.0777723342,
-0.4301542342,
0.5414503813,
-0.0358119793,
-0.2796810269,
0.9319576621,
0.052519232,
0.386562258,
-0.127231583,
-0.0585570149,
-0.5638080835,
-0.968983829,
0.0592828915,
0.7771207094,
0.7051307559,
0.023048237,
0.445910424,
-0.3702700436,
0.5196064711,
0.2456806898,
-0.0981894061,
0.4675088823,
0.2360316813,
-0.216589421,
0.4766633809,
0.9294106364,
0.5955165029,
0.3928507864,
-0.1988177449,
-0.1657230705,
0.1343900561,
0.4209597707,
-0.668900013,
-0.4710311294,
0.184558019,
-0.1057584509,
-0.7715166807,
0.0627275407,
-0.550526917,
-0.4837246835,
-0.4081865549,
0.3872882128,
-0.204735294,
-0.043342378,
0.2796681225,
0.3011448085,
0.1335172802,
0.0196122192,
-1.2255223989,
-0.029292278,
0.6711983681,
0.2744484246,
-0.0991973355,
-0.3144473433,
-0.8964089751,
0.2804656029,
-0.4806500375,
0.625348866,
-0.4113315344,
-0.3253302872,
0.0951560065,
0.3037914634,
0.1571100205,
-0.4280401468,
0.8218158484,
-0.4486328959,
0.2957306504,
0.0592689663,
-0.5181024075,
-0.0908155516,
0.0049531418,
-0.4936338961,
0.7477068901,
0.1144360602,
-0.7546684742,
0.7471294403,
-0.6950570941,
-0.4771811962,
-0.1279840469,
-0.1223189831,
-0.6676142812,
-0.5798881054,
0.4900975823,
0.6531187892,
0.0786142722,
0.5678768158,
-0.5969511867,
0.0096026529,
0.1997966915,
-0.5288742185,
0.7795926929,
-0.0105611244,
-0.4162628949,
0.3615677953,
-0.632304132,
0.0524514765,
0.0093810176,
-0.3665729463,
-0.3102093935,
0.136850208,
-0.1775856614,
0.0085014477,
0.0210958514,
-0.5102556348,
0.2119405866,
-0.5060365796,
0.3823896646,
1.1474766731,
-0.0395101085,
0.7584431767,
-0.2201062441,
0.4115137756,
-0.254599601,
0.4116026461,
0.2658121586,
-0.2589685619,
-0.8393629789,
-0.1179479957,
0.3203218877,
0.6351166964,
-0.5060809851,
0.7059061527,
-0.1682553887,
-0.2674201131,
-0.6887272,
0.0390836596,
0.4578499794,
0.8824299574,
0.4107401073,
-0.3348541856,
-0.5465120673,
-1.1573243141,
0.1107269675,
-0.2763301432,
0.1330808252,
0.1754275858,
0.023319155,
-0.4564613104,
0.968277514,
-0.5586023927,
-0.0652806312,
0.0245299228,
0.2076094598,
-0.0787864998,
0.8885719776,
0.5384235978,
-0.4520255029,
-0.341296941,
-0.0564418621,
-0.5455265045,
0.0656736195,
0.0523649901,
-0.5341563821,
0.4215680659,
0.3348671198,
-0.2848027945,
0.2090980411,
0.3511636555,
-0.186342001,
0.3840811253,
-0.2212336808,
0.142974332,
-0.7934721112,
-0.1512742788,
-0.1568114012,
-0.2379088849,
-0.3234724104,
0.0194995701,
0.0959004983,
0.1156161577,
-0.5024008751,
0.3627170324,
0.0856057853,
0.1733431965,
-0.0262386501,
-0.3664986491,
-0.2594432235,
0.539444983,
0.260522753,
0.8282482624,
0.4108195603,
-0.5417650342,
0.1408787519,
0.3322039843,
-0.2754912972,
0.241217494,
-0.3893951476,
0.49137187,
-0.1693422198,
0.2729818225,
-0.4752680361,
-0.8090494871,
0.4093945324,
-0.1662301868,
0.2471943647,
-0.6446364522,
-0.4064314663,
-0.0863231122,
-0.256359458,
0.1046876162,
0.5991780758,
-0.781552732,
0.1709343642,
0.7537408471,
-0.251378119,
-1.0029094219,
-0.5197618604,
-0.0558472462,
-0.5303413868,
-0.2440178394,
-0.0511116683,
-0.0917589441,
-0.0742198378,
-0.2163158059,
0.3033069968,
-0.1504926533,
0.1752653271,
0.5666126013,
0.5492678881,
0.2532117665,
0.2138180882,
0.5334861279,
-0.4643299878,
0.1161606312,
-0.3195352852,
0.3217819035,
-0.2643620372,
-0.4454146326,
-0.4521314502,
0.2134729773,
0.4544489384,
-0.3114507496,
0.4322535396,
0.4345651567,
-0.0420170464,
-0.4765422046,
-0.1925782859,
-0.4094600677,
-0.5168472528,
0.0799100623,
0.2322648168,
-0.6460646391,
-0.1901725084,
0.2328696549,
0.5011370778,
0.2471589595,
0.3425738513,
-0.2176828235,
1.2724744081,
0.4596636593,
-0.2367574871,
0.3314287961,
-0.1656717211,
0.1664026678,
-0.1870716214,
-0.1749984175,
-0.4268992543,
-0.0028086258,
-0.6402279139,
-0.0471066125,
0.4964694977,
-0.2805926502,
-0.6682559252,
0.2450325489,
-0.7403975129,
0.5595293641,
0.5906743407,
0.3697894812,
0.1913342029,
-0.17551817,
0.0878573731,
-0.02487446,
-0.6617118716,
-0.7895715237,
1.3233634233,
0.2719442844,
0.7942807674,
-0.065876022,
0.9751312733,
0.5439684391,
0.5254827738,
-0.9549354315,
0.4934700727,
-0.2269233018,
-0.4040882885,
-0.4360285401,
-0.1652651578,
-0.8788110614,
-0.2727686465,
-0.5425124168,
-0.2888797522,
0.0415650643,
0.6275638938,
-0.6925369501,
0.066152066,
-1.0671687126,
0.7071762681,
-0.4402520061,
-0.4000671804,
-0.2628800571,
-0.7362417579,
0.4123773277,
0.0346142948,
0.2368596047,
-0.1883889735,
0.150391534,
0.684153676,
-0.4501586556,
0.9102259278,
-0.2370023727,
-0.2278754115,
0.1794445068,
0.1873505712,
0.6212950945,
0.3239006698,
-0.2595521212,
-0.2679571509,
-0.0904146656,
-0.1939155608,
-0.5614353418,
0.6821900606,
-0.7925425768,
-0.5771915913,
-0.2220976204,
-0.5821290612,
-0.5447629094,
0.2018861622,
0.0786806867,
0.5134419799,
0.0228837952,
0.1034010053,
0.6856612563,
-0.2903021276,
0.5434297919,
0.1462575346,
-0.0819327384,
-0.4624034464,
0.9381609559,
0.0203922223,
0.1934931874,
0.2521814108,
0.310433656,
-0.4627786577,
-0.5378453732,
-0.8363686204,
-0.2813596427,
-0.6803973317,
-0.1629793644,
-0.5732848644,
-0.0566043891,
-0.1542998552,
-0.3920966089,
-0.6407153606,
-0.5716154575,
-0.1379592419,
-0.469760865,
0.5819253325,
0.5836821198,
-0.2551406324,
0.0116895465,
-0.7391809821,
0.0130994283,
0.6746595502,
0.3627112806,
-0.1125330031,
-0.1399409622,
-0.2609743476,
0.0783847943,
-0.0655306578,
-0.2987031937,
0.5671641827,
0.100431636,
0.3605389595,
0.5565112829,
0.7050463557,
0.3894745111,
-0.4288991392,
0.4802707136,
-0.0089788418,
-0.7036156058,
0.5691577196,
-0.5629495382,
-0.0722280145,
0.9418688416,
0.4021956623,
-0.0261598639,
-0.2495690286,
-0.6127973795,
-0.9701103568,
0.4848398566,
-0.1164354533,
0.1042750552,
-0.0119385328,
0.1860294789,
0.6500171423,
0.1541093439,
-0.5648335814,
-0.0001644968,
-0.2691536248,
-0.3552639186,
0.0011265973,
0.1531339884,
-0.311065346,
-0.2285430431,
0.8300237656,
-0.3820171356,
-0.0624216199,
-0.1850284636,
-0.0097039808,
-0.0722618252,
0.4446275234,
0.0969815999,
0.3065716922,
-0.3959128261,
0.1878943443,
0.0528787635,
-0.244878158,
0.3156857491,
-0.017288601,
-0.4559422731,
-0.4262784123,
0.2315519303,
0.6087560058,
0.0668374225,
-0.7151330113,
0.2085115463,
-0.131041646,
0.0589119829,
-0.3609217405,
0.6211932898,
-0.1110302657,
-0.1447855681,
0.0123899616,
0.3028666079,
0.0930883959,
-0.4360073507,
0.3820399642,
0.4047926068,
-0.4740631282,
-0.0341981761,
0.4527406096,
0.5257570744,
-0.1446549594,
0.675537765,
-0.1746861041,
-0.1975899637,
0.5316881537,
0.0361316539,
0.8727045059,
-0.0131159015,
0.3611274064,
0.5100038648,
0.1295482516,
-0.130457893,
-0.0651093051,
-0.0778530166,
-0.8322838545,
-0.281730026,
-0.3425430357,
-0.5453316569,
0.1123751774,
-0.7647424936,
0.2207393795,
-0.689596951,
-0.21209234,
-0.0315934531,
-0.2805689573,
-0.4915316403,
0.2720662355,
-0.1052191183,
0.375239104,
-0.8041477799,
1.0948650837,
0.4076639712,
-0.3281590939,
-1.0679163933,
0.07147374,
0.0772833526,
-0.6002082229,
0.4792334437,
0.1760831028,
-0.3747986555,
0.0307646971,
-0.831671834,
-0.498549968,
0.7596091032,
0.692299068,
-0.4587476254,
0.1757964343,
0.0323174074,
0.2705703974,
-0.4857934117,
0.0830014274,
0.5719907284,
0.4715916514,
-0.3295391798,
-0.9058029652,
0.0166286044,
-0.0203088075,
-0.4374672771,
0.1894255579,
-0.6161488295,
0.3496268988,
-0.5636593699,
-0.2056692094,
-0.1226850003,
0.480053097,
0.2354008555,
0.0794963986,
0.8124316931,
0.5630300045,
0.6914635301,
0.1037065759,
0.8846203089,
-0.2302785069,
0.1064105481,
1.4699573517,
-0.0493900366,
0.9788574576,
0.3644351661,
0.0733396634,
0.4519382119,
0.7615320683,
0.2957684398,
0.7691339254,
-0.1544006914,
-0.0738789365,
-0.5114183426,
-0.3622675836,
-0.3465289474,
0.5846341848,
0.1603410542,
-0.4210319817,
0.0276159085,
-0.254404515,
0.2308915555,
0.1585115045,
-0.1185081005,
0.6705653667,
-0.302633971,
-0.9657179117,
0.6743544936,
-0.1716758758,
0.6484728456,
-0.4428889453,
-0.1329682022,
-0.0734299421,
0.1721409857,
-0.3511834145,
-0.9213045835,
0.2284612507,
-0.0226463471,
-0.098217696,
-0.3455759585,
0.4186912179,
-0.5293095112,
-0.2214106321,
-0.0010891582,
-0.0120199211,
-0.1778000444,
0.5140151381,
-0.4811261892,
-0.3039823472,
0.0953023136,
0.0447119139,
0.3964140713,
0.0351353735,
-0.3394197822,
0.888938725,
0.7970474362,
-0.1700058877,
-0.1368120909,
0.1700916439,
0.5866094232,
-0.3309507072,
-0.6290348768,
-0.5358417034,
0.493342489,
0.0091892565,
-0.2324074358,
0.4978795648,
0.3514468968,
1.006107688,
-0.360514313,
1.1155263186,
-0.0284540765,
0.3433997631,
-0.5512394905,
0.9890373945,
-0.0994760245,
0.0901566893,
-0.2746578753,
-0.4827432334,
-0.373411119,
0.5001658797,
-0.3933311999,
-0.2659671009,
0.253133893,
1.1972768307,
-0.1613740325,
0.0231115725,
-0.164956376,
-0.131481126,
0.421291858,
0.4790039659,
0.7174323797,
-0.0689597949,
0.3781473935,
-0.6236664653,
-0.2650742233,
-0.0571837053,
-1.3097727299,
-0.789339602,
-0.5734585524,
-0.4421164393,
-0.3631503284,
0.149648115,
1.7025929689,
1.0424547195,
-1.0430036783,
-0.1114386171,
-0.2310360074,
0.0212462004,
-0.1430203319,
-0.2187749445,
0.5609346032,
-0.2567906678,
-0.8116356134,
0.5706856251,
0.1700391322,
0.2405655682,
-0.2791155577,
-0.3855433762,
0.0613402501,
0.0222051498,
0.48730281,
0.5459213853,
-0.4865246117,
-0.7057894468,
-0.4321811497,
-0.0163879935,
-0.0874814838,
0.5660480261,
-0.7578718066,
0.502583921,
0.2642605603,
0.8508553505,
0.026139088,
-0.0553057268,
0.9082306623,
-0.4721229076,
0.3954871297,
0.2435771972,
0.2944917679,
0.5368189812,
-0.6690044403,
0.5638294816,
-0.2219718397,
-0.6314749122,
-0.715267539,
0.3433344066,
-0.8628149033,
0.0606161579,
1.1086155176,
-0.0573795773,
-0.0447599776,
-0.286321193,
-0.4435523152,
0.2095134109,
-0.9349882007,
1.1843448877,
0.2293431163,
-0.2533022761,
-0.0371712483,
-0.3680076301,
0.7940884233,
0.4312877655,
-0.9169884324,
0.2663884163,
0.6262249351,
0.30032897,
-0.3223209083,
0.2891399562,
0.0052056061,
0.227037102,
-0.2989186943,
0.0796711072,
-0.2920409739,
-0.3865365386,
-0.0655950084,
0.223673597,
0.3100264668,
-0.2792002857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08669v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08669v2
|
On the Calibration of Multilingual Question Answering LLMs
| 2023-11-15T03:29:02 | 2024-04-15T14:44:04 |
Yahan Yang, Soham Dan, Dan Roth, Insup Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Multilingual pre-trained Large Language Models (LLMs) are incredibly
effective at Question Answering (QA), a core task in Natural Language
Understanding, achieving high accuracies on several multilingual benchmarks.
However, little is known about how well their confidences are calibrated. In
this paper, we comprehensively benchmark the calibration of several
multilingual LLMs (MLLMs) on a variety of QA tasks. We perform extensive
experiments, spanning encoder-only, encoder-decoder, and decoder-only QA models
(size varying from 110M to 7B parameters) and diverse languages, including both
high- and low-resource ones. We study different dimensions of calibration in
in-distribution, out-of-distribution, and cross-lingual transfer settings, and
investigate strategies to improve it, including post-hoc methods and
regularized fine-tuning. For decoder-only LLMs such as LlaMa2, we additionally
find that in-context learning improves confidence calibration on multilingual
data. We also conduct several ablation experiments to study the effect of
language distances, language corpus size, and model size on calibration, and
how multilingual models compare with their monolingual counterparts for diverse
tasks and languages. Our experiments suggest that the multilingual QA models
are poorly calibrated for languages other than English and incorporating a
small set of cheaply translated multilingual samples during
fine-tuning/calibration effectively enhances the calibration performance.
|
[
-0.4204387665,
-0.4726103246,
0.4098417163,
0.1309436709,
-0.1457052976,
0.1374145895,
-0.2490416616,
-0.357679069,
-0.0813298225,
0.3240242302,
-0.5466040373,
-0.3901181221,
-0.210437566,
0.5045495629,
0.2037384361,
0.7024209499,
-0.2622605562,
0.6882890463,
-0.4738479257,
-0.3590420783,
-0.4866758585,
-0.64290905,
-0.489992857,
-0.374345988,
0.6879338026,
0.2701556683,
0.5455923676,
0.194700703,
0.2989941239,
0.2148355544,
-0.1014634669,
0.4819123149,
-0.6765091419,
-0.0189661141,
-0.0198681764,
-0.8226547241,
-0.0228536949,
-0.1433805823,
0.7026295662,
0.6266101599,
-0.1326120943,
0.4744390845,
0.1117690429,
0.4955146313,
-0.779212594,
-0.0531214923,
-0.5821005106,
-0.0864587799,
0.1148901433,
-0.3286396563,
-0.5058892369,
-0.7190905809,
-0.2056364268,
-0.6218309999,
-0.0923489854,
0.0192766283,
0.5411304832,
0.4505070448,
-0.7258979082,
-0.2462173104,
-0.5711991787,
0.9870626926,
-0.7936859727,
0.5289155245,
0.6118243933,
0.4641568363,
0.2745258212,
-0.1492388994,
-0.2321520597,
0.209444806,
-0.0555392243,
0.0216200594,
0.2075729072,
-0.0505305566,
0.1790710539,
0.2278358787,
-0.7809188366,
0.1508096457,
-0.243749693,
-0.4785071015,
0.4376103878,
-0.0321262553,
0.0307381228,
0.0415220559,
-0.2993626297,
-0.2000034899,
-1.0708481073,
0.3334045708,
0.5540058613,
0.2550913692,
-0.0578930117,
0.4343964458,
-0.0607770681,
0.7262895703,
-0.1948206872,
-0.5059936047,
0.2490626872,
-0.7069149017,
-0.0222115442,
-0.0132993432,
0.4168092608,
0.336045593,
0.5018529892,
-0.2224477828,
-0.0667079464,
-0.3668299317,
-0.1668086946,
-0.956528008,
0.0127442079,
0.1388067901,
0.0507633612,
0.1838416159,
-0.1915715784,
-0.348895669,
-0.3243069351,
-0.2566126287,
0.5332882404,
-0.0922454,
-0.0888336226,
0.1704310477,
0.2370607704,
0.694308877,
0.1860702336,
-0.6025511026,
-0.0282299258,
0.3871839046,
0.2683185041,
0.1188942418,
-0.4850718379,
-0.7075346708,
-0.1270437688,
-0.5973552465,
0.6249269843,
-0.2661080658,
-0.1244567856,
0.1346707791,
0.0724010468,
-0.375582248,
-0.5914435387,
0.2739233673,
-0.8713536263,
0.1140035763,
-0.6394044757,
-0.3942639232,
-0.516063273,
0.7318732142,
-0.5742365122,
0.9506448507,
-0.0527805574,
-0.5285029411,
0.0906678885,
0.0022601599,
-0.2301969826,
-0.119149521,
-0.0559349954,
0.0906842202,
-0.0312701575,
0.3717740476,
0.2931197584,
-0.5450639725,
0.0494949371,
-0.2040838748,
-0.5985617042,
0.482598424,
-0.6736240983,
0.7433587313,
0.1724319905,
0.1674530953,
-0.1605416685,
-0.5773702264,
0.483876586,
-0.2579716742,
-0.4452688396,
-0.1502199322,
-0.3957485557,
-0.124431327,
0.3655032814,
0.4248523116,
-0.6582064629,
-0.3332998157,
-0.5115348101,
0.3290896416,
0.3741929233,
0.0546193384,
0.1651266366,
-0.4608260393,
0.7580111623,
-0.1133359373,
-0.1669249684,
-0.3635804951,
-0.1836773902,
-0.5696361065,
-0.1184466332,
0.4125073254,
0.8908641338,
-0.9650093913,
-0.0567000918,
-0.3757062554,
-0.4037458897,
-0.8243767619,
0.5430220962,
0.6196267605,
0.4828058481,
0.1785711497,
-0.0124856206,
-0.0653248653,
-0.8783109188,
-0.3252065778,
-0.1992378086,
-0.1217899695,
0.4069493711,
0.2059720159,
0.1200532541,
0.6247720122,
-0.0429893248,
-0.036374826,
0.0286847092,
-0.0698524937,
0.2470679581,
0.0344239995,
0.5339564085,
-0.7258806229,
-0.6314066648,
0.086930953,
-0.5142194033,
-0.0725749582,
0.1934635192,
-0.1349095255,
0.2210634947,
0.2531416416,
-0.2848813534,
0.0898661837,
0.8437318802,
-0.0024717115,
0.6306092143,
-0.4305509627,
0.6347858906,
-1.145480752,
0.1088407859,
-0.1507944167,
-0.4306577146,
-0.7374335527,
0.4432661831,
0.4957196712,
0.20233652,
-0.9408490658,
0.6410456896,
-0.4908493459,
-0.0833085179,
-0.0289720483,
0.3345900476,
0.4454119205,
0.4556878805,
-0.0649847165,
1.0995246172,
0.2719241083,
-0.4718913138,
0.4024421871,
0.2733238935,
-0.5083810091,
0.6289114356,
-0.5012628436,
0.3017401695,
-0.2292585224,
0.0962792709,
-1.2734119892,
0.0647670701,
-0.2379244417,
-0.3050705194,
0.1352480501,
-0.2046513259,
-0.8095067143,
-0.1980570853,
-0.3281624019,
0.9624878168,
0.2746319473,
-0.5092883706,
0.5078290701,
0.1018131375,
-0.1827309877,
-0.8211411834,
-0.9323825836,
-0.1707769334,
-0.1294461638,
-0.5076233745,
0.0523155965,
-0.5148002505,
-0.2022726834,
-0.5248258114,
0.0632141083,
-0.2720525861,
-0.0077420371,
0.0399764441,
0.135555923,
-0.3413287401,
0.3075205982,
-0.0201191157,
0.0313055664,
0.0586423278,
0.2683092356,
0.6884591579,
-0.2297438383,
-0.646956563,
-0.221931383,
0.1415872127,
0.5802050233,
-0.5243970156,
0.6922602057,
0.574529469,
-0.4382067025,
0.1768072993,
-0.901394248,
-0.2388920039,
-0.4293804765,
0.3455564678,
-0.6525307298,
-0.7264267802,
0.8670039177,
0.21880202,
0.2862795889,
0.2378699481,
0.5789524317,
0.0778664574,
0.9418744445,
0.4211108387,
-0.1305732429,
-0.1170748621,
0.0264967792,
0.1200755462,
-0.8060166836,
-0.0272767209,
-0.6371660829,
-0.1449800432,
-0.5389043093,
-0.6509148479,
0.4250520766,
0.2675020695,
-0.2865116298,
0.1705914736,
0.0875652507,
0.790989697,
0.38489452,
-0.0297722314,
0.3736892045,
-0.0319189206,
-0.1911979914,
-0.1237563193,
-0.7033699751,
-0.5982681513,
1.223429203,
0.3269574642,
0.7971126437,
0.1418740153,
0.4862688184,
-0.3390713334,
0.469278723,
-0.4494449496,
0.2149040997,
-0.1658230275,
-0.6641064882,
-0.3177878857,
-0.5844658017,
-0.5878196359,
0.5239368081,
0.0014707044,
-0.6287562251,
0.1615566909,
0.1120838225,
-0.508146584,
0.2522942424,
-0.6684846878,
0.8103203177,
-0.3531804681,
-0.2612481415,
-0.1176655516,
-0.4786700308,
0.2890913486,
-0.3033319116,
0.5153030753,
-0.3492509425,
-0.0469401143,
0.4203260243,
0.1609039158,
0.621878624,
-0.0346774086,
-0.5481265187,
0.1399251819,
0.1180290505,
0.3754469752,
0.2446979135,
-0.6420946717,
0.1268818825,
0.7650204301,
-0.4201047122,
-0.394618541,
0.5706593394,
-0.8360276222,
-0.3696677685,
0.0244836491,
-0.850169003,
-0.5282822847,
0.1009912044,
0.2884748876,
0.5044083595,
-0.258169353,
0.1898969859,
0.7441205382,
-0.4279392064,
0.190741539,
0.77716887,
-0.2143473625,
-0.5802494287,
0.8450838327,
-0.0147484811,
0.5917485356,
0.7721452713,
-0.0829641372,
-0.6875810623,
-0.3273727596,
-0.8188518882,
0.4985335767,
-1.0450992584,
-0.3166255653,
-0.3375250101,
-0.2451107353,
-0.4380085766,
0.1162175462,
-0.2894844115,
-0.146670565,
-0.3465955555,
-0.0004181423,
0.1459448636,
0.3051117659,
0.3689041734,
0.1920382828,
-0.8327793479,
0.20262447,
0.2767769694,
0.115340516,
-0.2085684538,
-0.6718701124,
-0.2256585658,
0.6009106636,
0.0034373936,
-0.794583261,
0.2744419575,
0.4286935627,
0.5488131046,
0.1928277016,
0.1293993741,
0.8314648867,
-0.4233219922,
0.6658243537,
-0.0669974312,
-0.5733129382,
-0.0085101202,
0.0711504743,
0.7300941348,
0.9686956406,
0.4369598329,
-0.8602788448,
-0.2367289215,
0.1924750507,
-0.528275013,
0.3521076143,
-0.2472863197,
0.3671648204,
0.1046407446,
0.4563574493,
0.2268262058,
0.334240824,
-0.7733565569,
-0.3487576544,
0.1316039562,
-0.3207071126,
-0.6433747411,
-0.3458642662,
-0.3353062868,
0.0506295338,
0.6644032001,
-0.4958740175,
-0.1817009151,
-0.0147615867,
-0.5983774662,
-0.2453745008,
0.3538477719,
0.6254010797,
0.9262077808,
-0.1485993862,
0.2274612337,
0.5841305256,
-0.2559143007,
0.3502340913,
0.2764818668,
-0.1883800328,
-0.1943411231,
0.2287759781,
0.5891243815,
0.3550866544,
-0.9473831058,
0.4496585727,
-0.2881719768,
-0.2398297489,
-0.1573690027,
-0.1751607209,
0.2833035886,
0.2229117751,
0.3748368025,
-0.3642229438,
-0.0843834803,
-0.29666394,
-0.0969263539,
0.6102184057,
-0.3072111011,
-0.3053976595,
0.5076777935,
-0.0166444518,
-0.0295210388,
0.4724368453,
-0.0691809505,
-0.5600391626,
0.5805811286,
0.3958308399,
0.4576034844,
-0.3306170404,
0.2218815386,
0.4552460611,
0.5694130659,
0.0117974589,
0.4696145356,
-0.066878289,
-0.9347369075,
-0.673022151,
-0.8175308108,
-0.6621303558,
-0.0483070016,
-0.6667452455,
-0.0487282202,
0.1139260828,
0.0577736534,
-0.3000523746,
0.389321357,
-0.9694784284,
0.123409681,
0.0867800638,
0.9489474297,
-0.8141751289,
0.6686969995,
0.8564714789,
0.0551984385,
-0.8094288707,
-0.3453778327,
-0.0534461178,
-1.0168641806,
0.4066188335,
0.4675475359,
-0.3413749337,
0.2841743529,
0.0653585792,
-1.0322237015,
1.1288200617,
0.7550694346,
-0.4285172224,
0.1101803854,
0.5449367166,
0.5571130514,
-0.2247117758,
0.5830096006,
0.4755226374,
0.473018378,
0.0731951967,
-1.0845354795,
-0.1722806841,
-0.2202027589,
-0.096521534,
-0.0168530475,
-0.4497877657,
0.6524790525,
-0.1292884946,
-0.1914862543,
0.3049017191,
0.256685257,
0.4799872637,
0.1299465001,
0.4695701599,
0.3343144655,
0.7018349171,
-0.1347392499,
0.980017066,
-0.7601818442,
0.1408455521,
0.8266232014,
-0.4250466526,
1.0063610077,
0.6233786941,
-0.132628426,
0.091489777,
1.0115125179,
0.4476580918,
0.3552899361,
0.0936618149,
-0.219561711,
-0.4149093926,
-0.1082726121,
-0.2692166269,
0.1606820226,
0.1605343968,
-0.0241938774,
-0.2968142331,
0.2509815991,
-0.2088297009,
0.0182952881,
-0.3480165601,
0.6300965548,
0.0652033836,
-0.8608932495,
0.8940270543,
0.0300757978,
0.5515689254,
-0.6785077453,
0.2303701788,
-0.465149641,
0.1986527741,
-0.0169516653,
-0.632886827,
0.0215046462,
-0.0607843138,
0.0594121665,
-0.1719195098,
0.2437378317,
-0.914953053,
-0.5115214586,
0.2270480841,
0.8328466415,
0.3983468413,
-0.1545127481,
-0.5131654143,
-0.0662333742,
0.0114245359,
-0.2787930965,
0.3654642403,
0.2266940624,
0.1980144829,
0.7352815866,
0.5397955775,
0.1097966805,
0.3087071776,
0.3312547505,
0.3265793622,
-0.3206783831,
-0.339271307,
-0.5595787168,
0.2304702848,
0.4459372163,
-0.3656282127,
0.8154225945,
0.7194738388,
1.0395196676,
0.0159505885,
0.1796609163,
0.564889133,
0.4819773734,
-0.5322716236,
0.5522593856,
-0.8213281631,
0.2543493807,
0.0979987904,
-1.0944753885,
-0.2942085564,
0.4862875044,
-0.3588514924,
0.1133831143,
0.4892738461,
1.042548418,
0.2213953882,
-0.2040946633,
0.6327602267,
-0.1185431406,
0.1149120703,
0.7629633546,
0.7098919153,
-0.5372570753,
0.7491360903,
-0.4908933938,
0.0490667261,
-0.0799981728,
-0.749982357,
-0.6824048162,
-0.3860839903,
-0.1143765524,
-0.0316963606,
-0.0657976493,
0.6661190391,
0.6814373136,
-0.8878778815,
-0.4643186033,
0.5549967289,
0.1938314885,
-0.280110836,
-0.1340909004,
0.1999132931,
-0.267943114,
-0.7804401517,
0.2443391681,
0.0870824307,
0.0009809904,
-0.4452924728,
-0.2211107612,
-0.1725509614,
0.1916238517,
0.5927704573,
0.2301595956,
-0.7796976566,
-0.1107726619,
0.4160030484,
-0.3698532581,
0.1212880835,
0.3285720348,
-0.5147030354,
0.5696573853,
0.5003064275,
0.9109348655,
0.4793669581,
0.1352102607,
0.5119742155,
-0.9100793004,
0.0047312197,
0.1650823653,
0.3053670824,
0.5223280191,
-0.1072771773,
0.3873279095,
-0.4051253796,
-0.5599318743,
-0.9899272919,
0.1111083552,
-0.3953018785,
-0.1684619635,
1.0981658697,
-0.294827193,
-0.1026865691,
0.0710560158,
-0.0905644968,
0.0635243282,
0.1554619819,
0.3813070953,
0.9785243273,
0.1999241412,
-0.4508593976,
-0.7623641491,
0.2434198558,
0.5519028306,
-0.7871156335,
0.2347269207,
0.4110077024,
0.4826527834,
0.0988114104,
0.5975510478,
-0.006359362,
0.4770995975,
-0.4763935804,
0.0508050323,
0.1500472724,
-0.2182923704,
-0.6039124727,
0.022981206,
0.3116407096,
0.0806404054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08666v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08666v1
|
It Takes Two to Negotiate: Modeling Social Exchange in Online Multiplayer Games
| 2023-11-15T03:21:04 | 2023-11-15T03:21:04 |
Kokil Jaidka, Hansin Ahuja, Lynnette Ng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.GT, cs.LG
|
Online games are dynamic environments where players interact with each other,
which offers a rich setting for understanding how players negotiate their way
through the game to an ultimate victory. This work studies online player
interactions during the turn-based strategy game, Diplomacy. We annotated a
dataset of over 10,000 chat messages for different negotiation strategies and
empirically examined their importance in predicting long- and short-term game
outcomes. Although negotiation strategies can be predicted reasonably
accurately through the linguistic modeling of the chat messages, more is needed
for predicting short-term outcomes such as trustworthiness. On the other hand,
they are essential in graph-aware reinforcement learning approaches to predict
long-term outcomes, such as a player's success, based on their prior
negotiation history. We close with a discussion of the implications and impact
of our work. The dataset is available at
https://github.com/kj2013/claff-diplomacy.
|
[
-0.7151423693,
-0.8587883115,
0.7941901088,
0.3925120831,
-0.0126652531,
0.1923034936,
-0.2824079096,
-0.870272398,
0.3877613842,
0.3535250425,
-0.5657755136,
-0.1612055302,
-0.6947013736,
-0.1298534423,
0.0411785059,
0.6959860921,
0.1352781057,
-0.1407091767,
-0.2435988337,
-0.2386242449,
-0.3546636701,
-0.5335100889,
-1.2361818552,
-0.898958683,
0.3436558247,
0.3997167647,
1.0717793703,
0.422993958,
0.5402673483,
0.4331645668,
-0.1826122403,
-0.1825413704,
-1.240144372,
0.3672311008,
-0.3967903554,
-0.214155063,
-0.2629650533,
0.3197323382,
0.2320243418,
0.4808003604,
-0.3340770602,
-0.0543173663,
-0.193801403,
0.6320303082,
-0.0171055496,
0.5838152766,
-0.5510345697,
0.1440824121,
0.0467906296,
-0.1111354753,
-0.4128336608,
-0.3639146388,
0.6780242324,
-0.9745872021,
-0.2985603213,
-0.0657863095,
1.0396561623,
-0.4036623538,
-0.7090639472,
-0.4718410373,
-0.6404189467,
0.4454287887,
-0.6353375912,
0.0939241648,
0.4708896577,
0.6711640954,
-0.6613171101,
-0.9922359586,
-0.3958255947,
-0.0073765111,
-0.4094643593,
0.45363006,
-0.2146094292,
0.3780487776,
0.3372033834,
-0.0778068304,
-0.063991338,
-0.0062528788,
-0.6267012358,
0.0703473464,
0.9877966642,
0.2133510113,
0.1943464279,
-0.1076406017,
-0.6539337039,
0.0375839695,
-0.4301038086,
0.6659311056,
0.6263769269,
0.170162037,
-0.5596798658,
0.3655943573,
-0.0507709011,
0.362950623,
0.43490237,
0.1136213914,
-0.3036910892,
-0.1318224669,
0.0398850888,
-0.0862710774,
0.8472085595,
0.9376528263,
0.6808941364,
-0.2102006078,
0.0554965176,
0.2616049051,
0.243313387,
-0.7281867266,
-0.2733265758,
0.428283155,
-0.8283600807,
-0.621717453,
0.1712349653,
-1.317504406,
-0.3996045291,
-0.0830199942,
0.4390923977,
0.1087185591,
-0.4675667882,
-0.0491461046,
-0.637803793,
0.4240016043,
0.2585943043,
-0.6733295321,
0.8094571233,
0.7089418769,
0.8303166628,
-0.2424925268,
-0.4372339845,
-0.6321531534,
0.1543179899,
-0.4653442502,
0.5677760243,
-0.708547473,
-0.899287641,
0.2021397501,
-0.0897992179,
0.1366351396,
-0.0657225922,
0.2371028662,
-0.5986855626,
0.0142088253,
-0.384812355,
-0.7311034799,
0.1992608756,
0.6034218073,
-0.9602194428,
0.4472540617,
-0.2283599675,
-0.4891925454,
0.1857230663,
-0.6878901124,
-0.5007937551,
0.2428827584,
0.0617057122,
-0.3827754557,
0.1279683858,
-0.0679551363,
0.4026993811,
-0.18486166,
0.1078583375,
-0.453412354,
-0.5355238318,
0.7054780722,
0.2013766319,
0.3349278271,
-0.0041042571,
-0.3299886584,
0.0123641025,
-0.0583787449,
-0.0906457454,
0.2895862162,
-0.290574193,
0.1175212041,
0.5562853217,
-0.4032607079,
0.50100559,
-0.0077368426,
-0.5147973299,
0.2356522679,
-0.4650222659,
0.866779387,
0.7296520472,
0.3402347863,
0.6495503187,
-0.5707341433,
0.5078838468,
-0.1943609267,
0.4941643775,
0.2633810341,
-0.7341273427,
-0.5356831551,
0.0348972976,
0.1400275081,
0.2913248837,
-0.8324388862,
-0.5713295341,
-0.4356527627,
-0.55513376,
-0.593588531,
-0.4793547094,
0.3921426237,
-0.2757844925,
0.1613000333,
-0.2587016523,
-0.2551957071,
-0.5602785945,
-0.5033836365,
-0.6034674644,
0.4906588197,
0.6642652154,
0.235760197,
-0.08528997,
0.8914453983,
-0.303809911,
-0.3460964561,
-0.5424607396,
0.603677094,
-0.2803213894,
0.1833726764,
0.5194313526,
-0.800627768,
-0.8908882737,
0.1406733394,
-0.3640875518,
0.5279342532,
-0.4632865191,
-0.301359117,
0.219307512,
0.5926342607,
-0.7683858871,
0.620996058,
0.7060939074,
-0.3821628094,
0.1919887513,
-0.278414607,
0.6020994186,
-0.5552986264,
-0.3230478466,
-0.2008404136,
-0.4299493432,
-1.0042574406,
0.2902430892,
-0.2828455269,
-0.2251373976,
-0.6258841157,
0.7661138773,
-0.5960101485,
-0.1511873901,
-0.1145364642,
0.5846045017,
-0.1225398332,
0.4112366438,
0.4583700001,
0.4755137265,
0.0957403257,
-0.5204043388,
0.304110527,
0.3293600082,
-0.2335033119,
0.6298501492,
-0.8180737495,
0.5602021217,
-0.0246926341,
0.3811299503,
-1.0606142282,
-0.1399982721,
0.3854157627,
-0.629540205,
0.2456939071,
-0.4463341832,
-0.019084651,
-0.287553519,
-0.306327045,
0.2569127381,
0.3779301643,
-0.5401328206,
0.8686990738,
0.8124981523,
0.0878478587,
-0.2654113472,
-0.5713430047,
0.0541168936,
-0.1721697599,
-0.4365880489,
0.4008441269,
-0.0468067266,
-0.418186456,
-0.1772707403,
0.3519744873,
-0.0211317893,
0.2295394242,
0.5145787001,
0.0438718125,
0.3406070471,
-0.0750656426,
-0.1143141314,
-0.3066420853,
0.4009823501,
0.2632007897,
0.5345636606,
-0.2081110775,
-0.2674619257,
-0.2451873422,
0.492266506,
0.4274800718,
-0.1555785835,
1.1418529749,
0.2123630345,
-0.133973673,
0.1182840914,
-0.2806234062,
-0.2909835875,
-0.5126918554,
0.2059493363,
-0.5954223275,
-0.6632792354,
0.7972476482,
-0.3757939935,
0.1039109677,
0.1730129719,
0.1507621706,
-0.2772338986,
1.3480536938,
0.2260598242,
-0.0619166791,
-0.0168073252,
0.0377822444,
0.3309022188,
-0.2359637767,
-0.4954744577,
-0.248563379,
-0.5940521955,
-1.0764921904,
-0.3807525635,
0.1560970545,
-0.0761220455,
-0.1152778268,
0.1580429673,
-0.0828274935,
0.7471455336,
0.1221269891,
0.1530604362,
0.0180179588,
-0.3988555372,
0.1426946521,
-0.3147543073,
-0.5749458671,
-0.0326604769,
0.4547792673,
0.5942538977,
0.3585145473,
0.6689149141,
0.5814409256,
0.2984959781,
0.2606789768,
-0.9241787195,
0.6004661918,
0.500605762,
-0.5202265978,
-0.5070407987,
-0.6009761691,
-1.3386127949,
-0.0112950429,
-0.7178595662,
-0.4579418898,
0.0831050053,
0.0114637315,
-0.0574247874,
0.2035976946,
-0.4398413599,
0.7945621014,
-0.3180086911,
-0.3898511231,
-0.5887759924,
-0.91587466,
0.0396248996,
0.468487829,
0.468426764,
0.0420860574,
0.2891591489,
0.6789383888,
0.2327908278,
0.7118365765,
-0.1357462257,
0.5570120811,
0.025173571,
0.5961068869,
0.9362696409,
-0.086157307,
0.0326717123,
0.2654879689,
0.4127327204,
-0.6877130866,
-0.4664420784,
0.6461489797,
-1.0520473719,
-0.6018601656,
-0.8742303252,
-0.1486022025,
-0.0115322843,
-0.130102396,
0.1934043169,
0.139888823,
-0.9441829324,
-0.017566897,
0.4811937511,
-0.170261696,
0.2262224257,
0.3849417269,
-0.5040305853,
-0.2443209887,
0.9347414374,
-0.0516236462,
0.6599358916,
0.0585662089,
0.3058110476,
-0.1660016477,
-0.0565862693,
-0.1104232743,
0.4274635911,
-0.7045313716,
-0.1623970419,
-0.2230041176,
-0.1147587076,
-0.1210679039,
-0.4984486401,
-0.2394178361,
-0.2786234021,
-0.0489679761,
-0.4996024072,
0.442389667,
1.3113330603,
-0.2154996544,
0.5082481503,
-0.6276344657,
-0.0076108733,
0.366461575,
0.3183111846,
0.1072286591,
-0.1719216108,
-0.1500661522,
0.1700015962,
-0.0167346653,
-1.5125230551,
0.3114798367,
0.1129299775,
0.6020945311,
0.5625728369,
0.0571514852,
0.8362743855,
-0.3278979659,
1.0742666721,
0.0751551017,
-1.0787721872,
0.1528207362,
-0.3561592698,
-0.0073874146,
0.3407135308,
0.5168997049,
-0.9552804828,
-0.1166450307,
-0.9322561622,
-0.8222403526,
0.7682321072,
0.0994763374,
0.0695446879,
-0.2404388934,
0.4246737361,
-0.1436238885,
0.3193904757,
-0.6224330068,
-0.3161456883,
-0.0284261368,
0.1788599491,
-0.0784324184,
-0.4739333093,
-0.2915633321,
0.0153283095,
0.6697359085,
0.1801031083,
0.4146525562,
-0.3236754239,
0.0970374271,
-0.2714592516,
0.0760982931,
0.5368994474,
0.7240549326,
-0.1118997112,
-0.0848113,
0.2197971195,
0.1099770591,
-0.1050700843,
-0.0444275402,
0.354279995,
-0.2093671262,
0.3668375611,
0.6549928188,
0.4620793164,
-0.5451714396,
0.7356314063,
-0.3269380331,
-0.4352885485,
-0.2223837525,
-0.4206167758,
0.2549710572,
0.5676074028,
-0.253421247,
-0.4325674772,
0.090806365,
-0.735368371,
0.1082219929,
0.5973900557,
-0.5511246324,
-0.3473929167,
0.334153533,
0.5689719915,
-0.4541004896,
0.8301082253,
-0.2621408403,
-0.8770804405,
0.362631321,
0.1860870272,
0.2583763897,
-0.1488053054,
0.9303654432,
0.2451606095,
0.0762282759,
-0.0623118207,
0.030562425,
0.0730648264,
-0.4344245791,
-0.105591841,
-0.0244022757,
-0.686608851,
-0.1635480076,
-0.8015597463,
0.1178512946,
-0.3151778877,
-0.6081078649,
-0.1864042878,
0.4040018618,
-1.1303037405,
-0.4289208353,
0.0870789886,
0.5774636269,
-0.8625617623,
0.2861529589,
0.3852227032,
-0.4775501192,
-0.5572091341,
-0.2716821134,
0.1136803478,
-0.5935857892,
0.5033703446,
-0.1016878188,
-0.0198773835,
-0.1349771917,
-0.5204467773,
-0.5824814439,
0.9211149216,
0.1571483165,
-0.3731303513,
-0.1224384606,
0.4865762889,
0.6219418645,
-0.4274226427,
0.5286617875,
0.797026813,
0.6012301445,
0.0174689982,
-0.850037992,
-0.0628933311,
-0.0152719375,
-0.0489477739,
0.3962745368,
-0.963414073,
0.4502865374,
-0.1011161357,
-0.4806680679,
0.1833290607,
0.7204077244,
0.0129215047,
0.382525444,
0.4723416865,
0.1606860012,
0.3249753416,
-0.3728339374,
0.9692044258,
-0.1857810318,
0.3943114281,
0.8133577108,
-0.3668315709,
0.9004487395,
0.5386268497,
0.1080680862,
0.5911102295,
0.7610185146,
0.3815912008,
0.5030703545,
0.328391999,
0.1816743612,
-0.3671308458,
0.0479455702,
-0.2052165121,
0.3582920134,
0.4969969988,
0.0531696603,
-0.1463381797,
-0.2359456718,
0.3423211575,
0.273470819,
-0.0713429525,
1.1677523851,
0.0935468748,
-0.7822493315,
-0.3403929174,
-0.032217253,
0.2009290159,
-0.6159238815,
-0.3795001805,
-0.1774125844,
0.0427473523,
0.0156736709,
-1.0322387218,
-0.0933311433,
-0.710927546,
0.1860131472,
-0.1484865248,
0.5857214928,
-0.7484744787,
-0.0475508235,
0.8560399413,
0.5867325664,
0.253955096,
0.3115262985,
-0.8686224222,
0.4441675842,
-0.2639316618,
-0.3136628866,
0.5419738293,
0.6148467064,
0.3445359468,
0.4874204099,
0.5890056491,
0.4306097031,
-0.379154563,
-0.3362500072,
0.6187168956,
-0.2425657362,
-0.610650301,
-0.5912263989,
0.5114968419,
-0.4939425588,
-0.1359014213,
0.5678280592,
0.1436339617,
0.7156137824,
0.2240524441,
0.520881772,
0.2341160625,
0.3197970688,
-0.4333622754,
0.6644160748,
-0.1945395917,
0.0081812935,
0.0584566109,
-0.3309658766,
0.401258409,
0.7089805007,
-0.4169008136,
-0.1977345645,
0.3539545536,
0.3641318679,
-0.0404776707,
0.1365104169,
0.2575570345,
0.1525876224,
0.5824846625,
0.4812084734,
0.8752431273,
-0.2983612418,
0.594127357,
-0.2281076908,
0.0088014714,
-0.3290646672,
-0.8191690445,
-1.2885406017,
-0.70669204,
-0.1056726798,
-0.8766613603,
0.4413863122,
1.3221060038,
0.543338716,
-0.382014066,
-0.6986393332,
0.352068603,
0.0616737679,
-0.5375781655,
-0.2142630368,
0.1102225035,
-0.0456855446,
-0.5365382433,
0.2392400652,
-0.0616097562,
0.0708265826,
-0.129586339,
-0.5168958902,
-0.3194457293,
0.6462286115,
0.6623122096,
0.5553539991,
-0.6118309498,
-0.5407797098,
0.0603965111,
-0.0098747704,
-0.0032838942,
0.984591186,
-0.7000882626,
0.8749542832,
0.39920187,
0.380763799,
0.7630158067,
0.1602469385,
1.0142495632,
-0.3495154977,
0.2157643139,
0.0044606733,
-0.0650456697,
0.2831098139,
-0.2444393188,
0.4000779986,
0.0044551259,
-0.689652741,
-0.6113723516,
0.2509668469,
-0.5810073614,
-0.2633830607,
1.091848135,
-0.3387435973,
0.1118698046,
-0.1365348846,
-0.1189139038,
0.1359677315,
-0.6872412562,
0.8422666192,
1.1704317331,
-0.0488769263,
-0.1510059088,
-0.4806714952,
1.0545173883,
0.0420962349,
-0.5061308146,
-0.1613735259,
0.4553870261,
-0.2804070711,
0.0483888015,
0.7077960968,
0.3471211791,
0.2778442502,
-0.134733066,
-0.4695710242,
0.1276478767,
-0.492885083,
0.05882724,
0.1534145176,
0.1301448494,
0.1612374634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08662v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08662v1
|
Multi-Set Inoculation: Assessing Model Robustness Across Multiple Challenge Sets
| 2023-11-15T02:59:10 | 2023-11-15T02:59:10 |
Vatsal Gupta, Pranshu Pandya, Tushar Kataria, Vivek Gupta, Dan Roth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Language models, given their black-box nature, often exhibit sensitivity to
input perturbations, leading to trust issues due to hallucinations. To bolster
trust, it's essential to understand these models' failure modes and devise
strategies to enhance their performance. In this study, we propose a framework
to study the effect of input perturbations on language models of different
scales, from pre-trained models to large language models (LLMs). We use
fine-tuning to train a robust model to perturbations, and we investigate
whether exposure to one perturbation improves or degrades the model's
performance on other perturbations. To address multi-perturbation robustness,
we suggest three distinct training strategies. We also extend the framework to
LLMs via a chain of thought(COT) prompting with exemplars. We instantiate our
framework for the Tabular-NLI task and show that the proposed strategies train
the model robust to different perturbations without losing accuracy on a given
dataset.
|
[
-0.2537848055,
-0.9102984667,
0.4352830946,
0.300226897,
-0.0088395355,
0.0032654924,
-0.3931399286,
-0.1950842589,
-0.323504895,
0.5387482643,
-0.4557452798,
-0.2970804572,
-0.7169163227,
0.1261390299,
-0.3499905169,
0.9965930581,
-0.1377014965,
0.1270816624,
-0.2887688577,
-0.1016516834,
-0.5586752295,
-0.8309620023,
-0.3563396037,
-0.4796811342,
0.3190452456,
0.4848458171,
0.7467448115,
0.3635864556,
0.5880895853,
0.2959498465,
-0.1133477241,
0.2904861867,
-0.5914057493,
0.3949253857,
-0.0707054958,
-0.560330987,
-0.3171981871,
0.0920429453,
0.7636687756,
0.6261147261,
-0.204312399,
0.2460325211,
0.5656318069,
-0.1809915006,
-0.8052155972,
0.0739531592,
-0.9631825089,
-0.0758837759,
0.0295007359,
-0.1611795127,
-0.6590089798,
-0.140050739,
0.0196374543,
-0.4088223279,
-0.0265523437,
-0.1551717669,
0.8868144155,
0.4399239421,
-0.0989729688,
-0.2391679883,
-0.7343122363,
0.798140347,
-0.9600506425,
0.2705275416,
0.531465888,
-0.093530111,
-0.4915833175,
-0.5759883523,
-0.5856658816,
-0.4379202425,
-0.1012436599,
-0.3211991489,
0.2676461935,
0.1238216832,
0.6063457727,
0.2635673583,
-0.1324528605,
0.1796384752,
0.1958166361,
-0.1757927388,
0.0154593131,
0.026345063,
0.19559668,
0.1069975793,
-0.1766038239,
-0.4799699187,
-0.6588621736,
0.0837517157,
0.7115342021,
0.7230557799,
-0.1254138798,
0.5597355962,
0.2016074657,
0.7807602882,
0.3123060763,
-0.2751315236,
0.1215112805,
-0.7046756148,
-0.2149939835,
-0.2167048901,
0.7043023705,
-0.0114219934,
0.2139247656,
-0.0804583356,
-0.2995664477,
0.162016511,
0.3882957399,
-0.7029247284,
-0.0865846574,
0.1676416695,
-0.1427689195,
-0.670096457,
-0.0510571674,
-0.7336086035,
-0.4312141836,
-0.1777999997,
0.7739522457,
-0.4848713279,
-0.1086338013,
0.0912973136,
0.0950945467,
-0.0153963026,
0.0869755223,
-1.0275262594,
0.5317504406,
0.4114543796,
0.6375271678,
0.0819339529,
-0.621199429,
-0.8234348297,
0.0723939836,
-0.2577709258,
0.6705595851,
-0.8465045691,
-0.2915948033,
0.0779101476,
-0.2048683316,
-0.2474370152,
-0.4950774014,
0.4154153466,
-0.0944203958,
0.0219264589,
-0.1527299136,
-0.5019857287,
0.1545884013,
0.5932067037,
-0.6600584388,
0.8581907749,
0.1408813745,
-0.7639023066,
0.4180368185,
-0.6646190286,
-0.4668571949,
-0.2441591471,
-0.310890317,
-0.5281771421,
0.2322404087,
0.4628880322,
0.4682840705,
-0.0378118083,
0.2180895805,
-0.6863696575,
-0.2395118773,
0.4171500206,
-0.3803840578,
0.6618487239,
-0.1774080843,
-0.2507273257,
0.2466869801,
-0.8139123321,
0.082002528,
-0.1573763341,
-0.3045623004,
-0.348443836,
-0.0056062872,
0.0160472915,
0.2572515309,
-0.1316453815,
-0.3213651478,
0.1065631434,
-0.4406200647,
0.4530991912,
0.67494452,
0.2603546083,
0.1709748805,
-0.3025745749,
0.5459811687,
0.1752607971,
0.2462164909,
-0.206855759,
-0.2136084437,
-0.4555316567,
-0.0969726145,
0.3591063023,
0.3850992322,
-0.6369751096,
0.2770237029,
-0.0297565628,
-0.311873138,
-0.5333476067,
0.1574087441,
0.5660105944,
0.4852400124,
0.3064068258,
-0.3898942769,
-0.2315461338,
-0.7674721479,
-0.179268986,
-0.039043095,
0.1398972869,
0.0958622098,
0.5810173154,
-0.191361621,
0.4200223982,
0.0131438719,
-0.2197347879,
-0.0777817592,
0.1522976905,
0.0740478262,
0.5871946216,
0.3897100091,
-0.4858779609,
-0.1855624914,
0.0270564575,
-0.5279581547,
0.1757607758,
-0.1090485603,
0.1768879741,
0.0159314387,
0.6228998899,
-0.2744294405,
0.5009874105,
0.7487689257,
-0.2058639526,
0.8007153869,
-0.1569571048,
0.2563547492,
-1.0880404711,
-0.0914331004,
-0.1384902149,
0.0529684722,
-0.7930936217,
0.2935954928,
-0.1293710321,
0.0147009306,
-0.366425693,
0.1719491631,
-0.2317023873,
0.041338753,
-0.1248769835,
0.1639631242,
0.0377220772,
0.3590325713,
-0.326516062,
0.6291231513,
0.6979631782,
-0.6850069165,
0.1822248101,
0.3540953994,
-0.2684502304,
0.5715688467,
-0.5667929649,
0.4987638295,
-0.0443803184,
0.0797668621,
-1.1246848106,
-0.1845141202,
-0.0634061694,
-0.4827988148,
0.5305618644,
0.0195189938,
-0.6446254849,
-0.0719772801,
-0.46212098,
0.4740100801,
-0.2848521769,
-0.5612362027,
0.7216333151,
0.2981080115,
0.3109684587,
-0.9073562026,
-0.8444128036,
-0.0406369455,
-0.3058040738,
-0.2817303836,
0.1001261845,
-0.2576428652,
-0.4185199738,
-0.0882494822,
-0.1305385977,
-0.0089548957,
0.3535202444,
0.3232493699,
0.1749347299,
-0.1101948842,
0.1077250466,
-0.0443616174,
0.1903125644,
0.0121717984,
-0.3170920014,
0.7731510997,
-0.2981954515,
-0.3332727849,
-0.4320342541,
0.3062387705,
0.6435033679,
-0.3532253802,
0.866019845,
0.4220438898,
-0.6807202697,
-0.4480271041,
-0.4874886572,
-0.5203402638,
-0.4646992683,
0.603390336,
-0.8487961292,
-0.8383092284,
0.6097678542,
0.0154108871,
0.1539204419,
0.0660737082,
0.8248397112,
-0.0417348705,
0.7602086663,
0.7739682198,
-0.1613310724,
0.4452872276,
-0.1215238497,
0.3168271184,
-0.9132676721,
-0.0385731757,
-0.7829071879,
-0.2151827514,
-0.4592222869,
-0.2715517282,
0.1128514484,
-0.0062146895,
-0.2103216201,
0.3704353273,
-0.3445020616,
0.4598272741,
0.3598850667,
0.1276396513,
0.1444077194,
0.0146386614,
-0.4030372202,
0.0793513656,
-0.8620665669,
-0.6570851207,
1.2556838989,
0.3508888781,
1.0056333542,
-0.015171173,
0.4450445175,
-0.1406121999,
0.3060373366,
-0.5784419179,
0.2070978582,
-0.2125110924,
-0.6531596184,
-0.5056288242,
-0.3125413358,
-0.6824204326,
0.2162377685,
-0.6275724769,
-1.1756311655,
0.355114907,
0.3830114007,
-0.6765383482,
0.3832853138,
-0.7264516354,
0.8056941628,
-0.1316830367,
-0.479542613,
-0.1920683682,
-0.5008140206,
0.352642864,
-0.1791291088,
0.195531413,
0.2768850625,
0.2210860699,
0.3362044394,
0.1056061313,
0.8076205254,
0.1708362252,
-0.16718705,
0.009558633,
0.3101119399,
0.4641788602,
0.2558328807,
-0.2953265309,
0.0087465681,
0.1736431867,
-0.1670801938,
-0.7019711137,
0.796564281,
-0.7906826138,
-0.4898210466,
-0.1125315502,
-0.8901054263,
-0.7630798817,
0.1448003054,
0.4889879227,
0.7052975297,
-0.0279530007,
0.3266954422,
0.7873105407,
-0.226899758,
0.4447840452,
-0.134905979,
-0.1083157733,
-0.3353759944,
0.4649673402,
0.1236263812,
0.8031442165,
0.2383298725,
0.1073079109,
-0.2300133407,
-0.5960985422,
-0.2480581254,
0.0468344875,
-0.6518015265,
-0.2448589057,
-0.2842155695,
-0.2010330558,
-0.4601595104,
0.137589559,
-0.3878453374,
0.0163559821,
-0.3422230184,
-0.2999956906,
0.0589502119,
0.911125958,
0.2105932832,
0.3493741751,
-0.4031572938,
0.1661655605,
0.3045168519,
0.6993628144,
-0.0400272273,
-0.7588257194,
-0.2160574794,
0.0053963619,
-0.2316594571,
-0.9301460385,
-0.038967032,
0.1694996655,
0.6320897937,
0.4432250857,
-0.1359735131,
0.8235666156,
-0.2867870629,
0.5396345854,
-0.0210032687,
-1.1638581753,
0.3941850066,
-0.2644754648,
0.3814407289,
0.7486286759,
0.1740427613,
-0.1155408993,
-0.7825286388,
-0.6014729738,
-0.5066230893,
0.5068118572,
0.0588977598,
0.1765761524,
0.2417491823,
0.7261419892,
0.0258195531,
0.3333123922,
-0.9954060316,
-0.0348434933,
-0.1482955664,
-0.1613464355,
-0.1072592735,
-0.3482785225,
-0.2664796114,
-0.1742709577,
0.5905858278,
-0.3290918469,
0.0363253839,
0.1573864371,
-0.2276422381,
-0.3562108278,
0.2212812901,
0.7940068841,
0.7251952887,
-0.2338865846,
0.2952679694,
0.4563687146,
-0.4682332277,
0.1438986808,
-0.0865801573,
-0.0752563328,
-0.3099915683,
0.5224503875,
1.0076082945,
0.1502130032,
-0.3221104145,
0.2510934472,
-0.2196199447,
-0.2356899232,
0.1424742043,
-0.0115380036,
-0.1473751515,
0.0866357014,
-0.1336678416,
0.1763791889,
-0.0841777995,
-0.7286598086,
0.3106443286,
0.5654088855,
-0.5127516985,
-0.2632001042,
0.5920627713,
-0.3010394573,
-0.4187299311,
0.5356485844,
-0.0503564589,
-0.5948632956,
0.4090406001,
0.9417081475,
0.5456306934,
-0.4613253772,
-0.016268177,
0.2950775623,
0.7889522314,
-0.1907773018,
0.0845720842,
0.3664345741,
-1.1409537792,
-0.619166553,
-0.4351900816,
-0.4713665843,
0.6562324762,
-0.7170262933,
0.2766267359,
-0.6384182572,
-0.4296544492,
-0.200400129,
-0.0649629384,
-0.6324305534,
0.1926532537,
0.1941588968,
0.6179251075,
-0.875305593,
0.8725385666,
0.7311362028,
-0.2395589054,
-1.1289391518,
0.3014573455,
-0.0712743625,
-0.2984185517,
0.029182896,
0.078993164,
-0.2967970073,
-0.1617187113,
-0.5626964569,
-0.9726109505,
0.4970716834,
0.7114757299,
-0.5548562407,
0.0662060082,
0.0781824663,
0.5393730998,
-0.5745264292,
0.1835875213,
0.8035395145,
0.4737430215,
-0.2497862428,
-1.1951545477,
0.1795944422,
-0.0660663024,
-0.0142533397,
0.0018278809,
-0.3744027317,
0.9618967772,
-0.324380368,
0.0406016633,
-0.0864377767,
0.4163779616,
0.3399638534,
-0.2544470131,
0.7381461263,
0.6120786071,
0.7783874869,
-0.027320968,
0.9541254044,
-0.2721183896,
0.241364643,
1.5205299854,
-0.2539767027,
0.9452129006,
0.7111141682,
0.0637131929,
0.3268645704,
0.4090883434,
-0.1157789305,
0.3431376815,
0.4801551402,
0.1850547045,
-0.0838903487,
-0.0466486551,
-0.1203162074,
0.509174943,
0.6441747546,
-0.0850254893,
-0.0813450813,
0.3315694928,
0.0338214338,
0.3654202223,
-0.1655329168,
0.4877893627,
0.0254318975,
-0.6909961104,
0.4961175919,
-0.2299413383,
0.6227061749,
-0.589548409,
-0.0066095013,
-0.0446535796,
0.3905457854,
-0.1956467479,
-0.4274108112,
0.1061389074,
-0.3011697233,
-0.1545100063,
0.0177789703,
0.4246684909,
-0.5658568144,
-0.5495801568,
0.465795964,
0.3797068596,
-0.2770054042,
-0.0116364378,
-0.4498356581,
0.3852707446,
-0.1210818961,
-0.2066937834,
0.4117900729,
0.3226115406,
-0.1126870587,
0.6497730017,
0.438949883,
0.2727425396,
0.0883805975,
0.3148308694,
0.8253312707,
-0.2057629973,
-0.1114613935,
-1.0002917051,
0.3744350672,
0.0394252874,
-0.5802206397,
0.7570735216,
0.1065486893,
0.9087896943,
0.0554596819,
0.583347857,
0.2573187649,
0.1673258841,
-0.2496118844,
0.6854211092,
-0.4887080193,
0.2495431006,
-0.5897001624,
-0.7166029215,
-0.6477655768,
0.626132071,
-0.1564006656,
0.0089226076,
0.9013115168,
0.978777945,
0.2277269661,
-0.2316767573,
0.3616504371,
0.42898193,
0.4166994691,
0.3984945714,
0.9151963592,
-0.3329339623,
0.480569303,
-0.3886105418,
-0.2424684167,
0.1754586399,
-0.8385586739,
-1.0697710514,
-0.6970921755,
-0.2092344165,
-0.6840993166,
0.031347964,
0.9372027516,
0.8223471642,
-1.1061451435,
-0.4758040905,
0.1690348387,
0.1239474565,
-0.3610675335,
-0.131253764,
0.2904641926,
-0.6487885118,
-0.6480576396,
0.4886691272,
0.2634754777,
-0.0242165029,
-0.3543003798,
0.3046042621,
-0.3536575437,
0.2565430701,
0.5430608392,
-0.2851473391,
-0.645313561,
-0.5165460706,
-0.020223124,
0.0135023603,
0.1303465217,
0.7781991363,
-0.4945414066,
0.4961510301,
0.0216929596,
0.6264657378,
0.2955397069,
-0.0419143289,
0.8055720925,
-0.8454251885,
0.3406526148,
0.2899654806,
0.4296183586,
0.3167045414,
-0.4957350492,
0.2576601505,
-0.1550029069,
-0.4811549783,
-1.2466833591,
0.3053452075,
-0.6137340069,
-0.1771322191,
1.0832407475,
-0.1115108356,
-0.1646695882,
-0.1169077829,
-0.0513219647,
0.2185475975,
-0.2102019042,
0.8443478942,
1.2999746799,
0.048178304,
-0.1839488149,
-0.4075460136,
0.6964974403,
0.4282746315,
-0.7659080625,
0.0871399418,
0.2945062518,
0.1417928189,
0.3304970562,
0.1166500971,
-0.2807646692,
0.0381154642,
0.1209656522,
-0.0821649432,
0.0509791709,
-0.5744786263,
-0.5854662657,
0.4862619936,
0.4049313962,
-0.1190904081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08648v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08648v4
|
Explore Spurious Correlations at the Concept Level in Language Models for Text Classification
| 2023-11-15T01:58:54 | 2024-06-16T01:28:49 |
Yuhang Zhou, Paiheng Xu, Xiaoyu Liu, Bang An, Wei Ai, Furong Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Language models (LMs) have achieved notable success in numerous NLP tasks,
employing both fine-tuning and in-context learning (ICL) methods. While
language models demonstrate exceptional performance, they face robustness
challenges due to spurious correlations arising from imbalanced label
distributions in training data or ICL exemplars. Previous research has
primarily concentrated on word, phrase, and syntax features, neglecting the
concept level, often due to the absence of concept labels and difficulty in
identifying conceptual content in input texts. This paper introduces two main
contributions. First, we employ ChatGPT to assign concept labels to texts,
assessing concept bias in models during fine-tuning or ICL on test data. We
find that LMs, when encountering spurious correlations between a concept and a
label in training or prompts, resort to shortcuts for predictions. Second, we
introduce a data rebalancing technique that incorporates ChatGPT-generated
counterfactual data, thereby balancing label distribution and mitigating
spurious correlations. Our method's efficacy, surpassing traditional token
removal approaches, is validated through extensive testing.
|
[
-0.190279603,
-1.0886136293,
0.0046889125,
0.0446435846,
-0.4407466054,
0.4176517427,
0.0220306329,
-0.4581491053,
0.0863275453,
0.4532618523,
-0.2507156432,
-0.3233311772,
-0.6613175273,
-0.3340174556,
-0.880235374,
1.428781271,
0.0147409039,
-0.1856953502,
-0.3390851915,
-0.1282205284,
-0.805208981,
-0.8532269001,
-0.7712436318,
-0.449106127,
0.3179706931,
0.340841651,
0.7204502821,
0.4382591248,
0.5066365004,
0.1015140638,
-0.2745257318,
0.2465028912,
-0.5841450095,
0.3271361887,
-0.0845221877,
-0.4769354761,
-0.3683869243,
-0.0049693203,
0.6355562806,
0.8092907667,
-0.0519081764,
-0.0977181792,
0.4430778027,
0.3935477138,
-0.5287376046,
0.1106699184,
-0.9205184579,
-0.09652365,
-0.3412846625,
-0.3069601953,
-0.5209464431,
-0.1460843533,
0.4012198746,
-0.3325257599,
0.476638943,
0.3184616268,
1.0635361671,
0.4581960738,
-0.2571448088,
-0.4616456926,
-0.6282741427,
0.7416861653,
-0.5036069155,
0.2887060642,
0.615029037,
-0.2574810982,
-0.1303430498,
-0.4967269301,
-0.4253945947,
-0.1346892715,
-0.2213815153,
-0.0020296327,
-0.0025282698,
-0.2545520067,
0.1093750447,
0.2624538541,
-0.5113435388,
0.3062489033,
-0.1100538969,
-0.2275672555,
0.4154396951,
0.0797556937,
0.3959161639,
-0.0693768933,
-0.5073314309,
-0.0975215733,
-0.7017506957,
0.0273965467,
0.0486317351,
0.4620127678,
-0.1063371301,
0.6082734466,
0.1651819795,
0.5082291961,
0.0635725111,
-0.0261536483,
0.285687834,
-0.4796514511,
-0.032848224,
0.2234803736,
0.8199172616,
0.2541935146,
0.2664908469,
-0.2794294953,
-0.1703563482,
0.1919775456,
0.2863837183,
-0.6261395812,
-0.2531900406,
0.1850206852,
-0.007155159,
-0.5670430064,
-0.241496399,
-0.6516570449,
-0.283487916,
0.0657627657,
0.3114773631,
-0.5322269201,
-0.2242797464,
-0.0219831932,
-0.0965905413,
0.0686622709,
0.1166412234,
-0.8746750355,
0.1949241906,
0.8067500591,
0.94483459,
-0.3985795379,
-0.3301628828,
-0.3069039583,
0.1951462775,
-0.4832432866,
0.7843387127,
-0.6093943119,
-0.5652257204,
0.0083977506,
-0.246062085,
-0.2512008846,
-0.4998829961,
0.7215774059,
-0.348849833,
0.104908444,
-0.0006788461,
-0.8535349965,
0.1745163351,
0.3936554492,
-0.3847245574,
1.3249623775,
-0.1807757318,
-1.2073739767,
0.5090227723,
-0.1257675141,
-0.5411558747,
0.1237725019,
-0.1038102508,
-0.5625001788,
0.0145165166,
-0.1665426642,
0.532537818,
-0.1848725677,
0.5923547149,
-0.3352602124,
-0.3125147223,
0.4217525721,
-0.5205203295,
0.5032184124,
0.1366426349,
-0.040949937,
-0.0187050719,
-0.7569451332,
-0.1321048439,
-0.1289402395,
-0.0927088633,
-0.9063175917,
0.2261303663,
0.037508335,
0.2108214796,
-0.0499194339,
-0.170982331,
0.1475444734,
-0.4300892055,
0.3399074078,
0.3607042432,
0.0472827218,
0.4070684314,
-0.4327558279,
0.268111825,
0.3568733037,
-0.1958926618,
-0.2278909236,
-0.6470295191,
-0.864849031,
-0.2670107484,
0.3688565791,
0.6803523302,
-0.8531558514,
0.5560994148,
-0.3239116967,
-0.5738598108,
-0.2901893258,
0.0345620885,
0.4486839175,
0.7766181827,
0.2397642881,
-0.3912899792,
-0.0919455886,
-0.7359589934,
-0.4022846818,
-0.2464999408,
0.028817609,
0.0902242586,
0.4332241416,
-0.1710863709,
1.1406542063,
-0.4962796867,
-0.2652263045,
-0.0653464943,
0.4305856824,
-0.1621647626,
0.7195889354,
0.4377607405,
-0.7921029329,
-0.4229319692,
-0.0792390406,
-0.4781941175,
-0.1080003083,
-0.1524586678,
0.0028109089,
0.1766263098,
0.8654851317,
-0.4806185663,
0.3929638267,
0.1110603958,
-0.3454872966,
0.4084088206,
-0.0537584536,
-0.3260860741,
-1.1100636721,
-0.0412323996,
0.1777916104,
-0.1046851352,
-0.7831302285,
0.0232235976,
0.0890246853,
0.2183823586,
-0.1500316113,
0.5144991279,
-0.0488300472,
0.4241278172,
-0.257424742,
0.2814541459,
-0.1102933437,
0.281401515,
0.1014538109,
0.5970610976,
0.5081045032,
-0.6628133059,
-0.0983325914,
0.1302680522,
-0.2039602697,
0.4422879219,
-0.4085989296,
-0.0351663977,
-0.138686955,
0.1697561592,
-1.0878390074,
-0.0179599617,
0.286303699,
-0.3701023459,
0.5550450087,
-0.0300541297,
-0.5780220628,
-0.0051019611,
-0.2049210221,
0.5298501849,
0.337520808,
-0.3117220402,
0.1859919429,
0.6136622429,
0.0279228482,
-0.7111554146,
-0.6698419452,
-0.1545630544,
-0.50016433,
-0.0675420985,
0.2618144453,
0.070470579,
-0.1074853837,
-0.1094238907,
-0.1824982017,
-0.2594842017,
0.3819841743,
0.1426292658,
0.289047271,
0.0519968495,
0.4510317743,
0.0442876518,
-0.0152463363,
0.0853067935,
-0.2512280047,
0.5942289829,
0.0439283922,
-0.1078155637,
-0.0343923345,
0.0388358086,
0.4102288783,
0.0251034386,
0.8028652072,
0.6971037388,
-0.3861851692,
-0.3005931377,
-0.2834976315,
-0.0614672713,
-0.3732312918,
0.5977717042,
-0.2967832386,
-0.8120658398,
0.5559486151,
0.1049685031,
0.1364937574,
0.347197324,
0.4404608607,
-0.0697055236,
0.7362930179,
0.7056027651,
-0.3175156116,
0.5658667684,
-0.0700739324,
0.4549144804,
-0.6555606127,
-0.0899619609,
-0.6232002974,
0.0824729428,
-0.7778972983,
-0.4370746911,
0.1023106501,
0.4061360359,
-0.0354012065,
0.1317831874,
-0.2377426773,
0.5078393817,
0.3812384009,
0.0843119472,
0.3547329307,
-0.0187385678,
-0.2768900096,
-0.0601530299,
-0.891644299,
-0.4343397915,
1.0128695965,
0.3088484704,
0.7492172718,
-0.1507391781,
0.4522240162,
0.1413602531,
0.370069325,
-0.7750883698,
0.2602811754,
-0.2622935474,
-0.6117728949,
-0.2633988857,
-0.3369250298,
-0.7599976659,
0.3258348405,
-0.4076335728,
-0.8426176906,
0.1089519784,
0.2867850363,
-0.1751931608,
0.2528952956,
-0.8246924877,
0.7484744787,
0.049620118,
-0.52398175,
-0.1113187373,
-0.5664803982,
0.5808489323,
-0.4772716165,
0.3307849169,
-0.0096243294,
-0.0018298855,
0.5576760173,
-0.3804169595,
1.0707464218,
0.3873477876,
-0.5682343841,
0.2873473167,
0.2280481756,
0.3896892667,
0.0199148823,
0.2232460082,
0.1659165323,
0.0346680321,
-0.4337505698,
-0.4807931483,
0.6732060313,
-0.6775884032,
-0.3799009919,
-0.474657774,
-0.5964899659,
-0.4444874823,
0.0943855122,
0.4527186155,
0.4377042949,
-0.3073084056,
0.1243123114,
0.6628721952,
-0.2191570103,
0.3481263816,
0.2362874746,
-0.2299441844,
0.099127084,
1.2935776711,
0.1665762961,
0.5718652606,
0.5125535131,
0.1161178201,
-0.0837941617,
-0.5095337629,
-0.1200633273,
-0.1752566695,
-0.5289062262,
-0.1263349205,
-0.7410132885,
-0.5003820062,
-0.1477687955,
0.0572677404,
-0.4587080777,
-0.4695042074,
-0.2959781587,
0.0236247592,
0.1237619594,
0.4217398465,
0.3057171702,
0.6012684703,
-0.5679564476,
-0.0105021391,
0.0130594103,
0.2991439104,
0.2430442274,
-0.5778948069,
-0.3682187498,
-0.0274116993,
-0.4355226457,
-0.5977675319,
0.4332661629,
0.1443155855,
0.2710627317,
0.4729095995,
0.0666247234,
0.5562784672,
-0.5177627802,
0.6443545818,
-0.0060316566,
-0.9233575463,
0.3779573143,
-0.3348430097,
0.0664997771,
0.2309785485,
0.4229446948,
-0.7122598886,
-0.8352034092,
-0.7941910625,
-1.0653418303,
0.6344655156,
0.2951607704,
0.087061204,
-0.1896530092,
0.4044294655,
0.1558941901,
0.1785480082,
-0.6620633006,
-0.3845811188,
-0.2526109219,
-0.3336316943,
-0.246918276,
-0.3303655386,
0.1272839904,
-0.1889906228,
0.6594883204,
-0.0885941982,
-0.2176663876,
0.0137630971,
-0.3216761947,
0.1349039376,
0.2743277252,
0.5987728238,
0.3542637825,
-0.2618920505,
0.3655907512,
0.162168324,
-0.6521728635,
0.0222623106,
-0.1439031959,
-0.5069336295,
0.0503282472,
0.5114524961,
0.6162272096,
0.3864317536,
-0.4928010106,
0.3445144296,
-0.0809514001,
0.0310004931,
0.124220781,
0.1547302604,
0.0625462979,
-0.2313570231,
0.1619296968,
0.1967808604,
-0.0719265193,
-0.415176332,
0.2876544893,
0.7243759632,
-0.5646236539,
-0.3216712177,
0.3967668116,
0.1310116649,
-0.1862769425,
0.3611801565,
-0.1462663859,
-0.5394343734,
0.594317615,
0.6466892958,
0.7499331236,
-0.0344392397,
0.2771424651,
0.2587006092,
0.483548671,
-0.1751236916,
-0.2859166265,
0.0087236064,
-1.1873303652,
-0.1903609633,
-0.4424751103,
-0.5140818357,
0.1763768345,
-0.6484658718,
0.3285408914,
-0.3111890256,
-0.1144103557,
0.1891738325,
-0.117148146,
-0.3895699382,
-0.0293135289,
-0.0850581229,
0.6361815333,
-0.9906710982,
1.1992390156,
0.4677475095,
-0.3599283397,
-0.59170717,
0.356125623,
-0.0263704229,
-0.6497616172,
0.7125350237,
-0.0096334936,
-0.048631154,
0.0459618494,
-0.6116104722,
-0.758266151,
0.4893355668,
-0.0618044399,
-0.5480132103,
0.0529134944,
0.1296243966,
0.682679534,
-0.2781285346,
0.3013489544,
0.6366431713,
-0.0068815346,
0.1083384827,
-0.8856662512,
-0.006827055,
-0.0611749254,
-0.0994009525,
0.1715509444,
-0.6336063147,
0.7825091481,
0.0617885776,
-0.2696731091,
-0.0397782363,
0.500377059,
0.2003727406,
0.2278844565,
0.4839634299,
0.4176361561,
0.9382688403,
-0.119145371,
0.9058686495,
-0.3494558036,
0.5506056547,
1.1540932655,
-0.436193496,
0.7734068632,
0.5627555251,
0.0256532654,
0.2106839716,
0.7342917919,
0.0955536216,
0.4782494009,
0.1834079325,
-0.0491350442,
-0.1702402085,
-0.3363842666,
-0.3223501444,
0.2985202968,
0.7521898746,
-0.0278774817,
-0.1665478349,
-0.1334591359,
0.094424136,
-0.1511171311,
-0.0933832824,
0.7839983702,
0.2192675322,
-0.5436099768,
0.5935443044,
-0.216141507,
0.9410731792,
-0.4181387424,
0.2219502628,
-0.345900774,
0.3568733037,
-0.0612385236,
-0.6548822522,
0.4004629552,
-0.1294189692,
-0.2470220029,
-0.0543192849,
0.739895761,
-0.6982781291,
-0.4108528197,
0.1720523685,
0.5726313591,
0.058400277,
0.1916442513,
-0.5730518699,
-0.1748247445,
-0.0860677585,
0.0695403144,
0.4420706034,
0.6991428137,
-0.4201273322,
0.8908985853,
0.4834567606,
0.1681025028,
0.0135214189,
0.101586014,
0.8066549301,
-0.5952165723,
-0.5589902997,
-1.0414731503,
0.0396349654,
-0.0121926786,
-0.5395513773,
0.7762510777,
0.588542223,
1.0300673246,
0.092568472,
0.599093318,
0.2278645784,
0.587067306,
-0.4824346304,
0.7457392216,
-0.4251947999,
0.5529119372,
-0.5795869827,
-0.6181853414,
-0.4847640991,
0.4506933093,
-0.0877519697,
-0.2042246461,
0.8496748805,
0.6854615211,
-0.0581588596,
0.1084344387,
0.1927529573,
0.2920762599,
0.3278985023,
0.3795099854,
1.0117712021,
-0.4285131693,
0.4309690595,
-0.1876129508,
-0.1321418136,
-0.2456814647,
-0.7735258937,
-1.1423032284,
-0.5779235959,
-0.5178317428,
-0.3457864821,
0.005265356,
0.8279587626,
0.6234086752,
-0.9350516796,
-0.2109948397,
-0.1415741444,
0.5009976029,
-0.1061018854,
-0.2733764946,
0.4434343874,
-0.6871078014,
-0.7059639692,
-0.0561348163,
0.1078784019,
0.3074278235,
-0.0515970439,
0.1909380555,
-0.2769353688,
-0.1421907097,
0.5839242935,
0.0674722418,
-0.6764014959,
-0.2808268368,
-0.3051722944,
-0.262994796,
-0.0940015689,
0.8978120089,
-0.7161846161,
0.1397846192,
0.3975665867,
0.6102488041,
0.1838565469,
0.0040459409,
0.6710546613,
-1.1050646305,
0.4363403916,
0.0699396953,
0.1945430487,
0.1959260404,
-0.3012829423,
0.5008852482,
0.3466452956,
-0.328205049,
-1.1858458519,
0.1171226948,
-0.7873342037,
-0.4142050147,
0.9235838056,
0.0514369346,
0.0430613868,
-0.2977047861,
-0.1363758892,
0.2998705208,
-0.2285647243,
0.9190356731,
1.0990253687,
0.1120369136,
0.0128953308,
-0.6462199688,
0.8441916704,
0.7947024107,
-0.5811949372,
0.3125499189,
0.1364608854,
0.1834698468,
0.3366132081,
0.3325600028,
0.0984814018,
-0.2919075191,
-0.0484075621,
-0.1355642378,
0.4404680729,
-0.2123180777,
-0.269905448,
0.0085882489,
0.0488377213,
-0.1657821238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08640v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08640v3
|
Multistage Collaborative Knowledge Distillation from a Large Language Model for Semi-Supervised Sequence Generation
| 2023-11-15T01:28:28 | 2024-02-26T22:30:53 |
Jiachen Zhao, Wenlong Zhao, Andrew Drozdov, Benjamin Rozonoyer, Md Arafat Sultan, Jay-Yoon Lee, Mohit Iyyer, Andrew McCallum
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We study semi-supervised sequence generation tasks, where the few labeled
examples are too scarce to finetune a model, and meanwhile, few-shot prompted
large language models (LLMs) exhibit room for improvement. In this paper, we
present the discovery that a student model distilled from a few-shot prompted
LLM can commonly generalize better than its teacher to unseen examples on such
tasks. We find that the student is able to learn a general pattern from the
high-quality pseudolabels produced by the teacher during knowledge distillation
(KD), and favorably not a general pattern from the low-quality pseudolables.
Leveraging this discovery, we propose a new method, Multistage Collaborative
Knowledge Distillation from an LLM (MCKD), for these tasks. MCKD first few-shot
prompts an LLM to produce pseudolabels for unlabeled data. Then at each stage
of an iterative KD process, a new pair of students is trained on disjoint
partitions of the pseudolabeled data, and produces new and improved
pseudolabels for their unseen partitions. We conduct extensive experiments on
four syntactic and semantic parsing datasets and show the effectiveness of MCKD
for low-resource semi-supervised sequence generation. On CRAFT biomedical
parsing, for example, 3-stage MCKD with 50 labeled examples outperforms an LLM
teacher and vanilla KD by 7.5% and 3.7% parsing F1, respectively, and matches
the performance of supervised finetuning with 500 labeled examples.
|
[
-0.2184700221,
-0.7585549355,
0.8703751564,
-0.1618160158,
-0.3616273701,
0.2782548368,
-0.1689794362,
-0.1749976575,
-0.0219666008,
0.3288498223,
-0.4691210687,
-0.7458120584,
-0.5317703485,
0.241586715,
-0.4094334841,
1.0446873903,
0.2871253192,
0.2320092767,
-0.2205883116,
-0.120860979,
-0.4291575253,
-0.5282114148,
-0.33784917,
-0.560808301,
0.4543820024,
0.6097580194,
0.1545062661,
0.3926499486,
0.1568507403,
0.3931439519,
-0.2837187052,
0.2967346013,
-0.561239779,
0.0342423357,
-0.0787784755,
-0.663716197,
-0.1313513219,
0.0979204997,
0.4107474685,
1.0696731806,
-0.3208969533,
0.1601253599,
0.3408501744,
0.7229653597,
-0.4221926928,
0.1265659332,
-0.5569865108,
0.0883264765,
-0.3518100381,
0.1199237108,
-0.4577731192,
-0.3635607362,
0.2663798332,
-0.5722133517,
0.5092401505,
-0.0766513944,
0.3255452812,
0.2692325711,
-0.2587165534,
-0.2063798755,
-0.6246392727,
0.8521367908,
-0.8429074287,
0.1062239483,
0.1617689431,
0.3689421415,
-0.4152136445,
-0.9886215329,
-0.6804535389,
0.0882619172,
-0.0162569098,
0.0649241135,
-0.0032857826,
0.0936701745,
0.3614895642,
0.3991073072,
-0.3619970679,
-0.1377856582,
-0.3854858875,
-0.2834183276,
0.3323419392,
0.0867163241,
-0.0246133823,
-0.1496611089,
-0.3156687319,
-0.3265517652,
-0.5020848513,
0.0021999343,
0.179625079,
0.3997255862,
0.1357876211,
0.7626928687,
-0.3304680586,
0.8502386808,
0.2589093149,
-0.6232371926,
0.3171153665,
-0.57510674,
-0.02533786,
0.3190688789,
0.8114631772,
0.1393630505,
0.1208870038,
0.0037368275,
0.0698173046,
-0.0008844428,
-0.0856945589,
-0.7544779181,
-0.6928781867,
-0.0890449435,
-0.3881751597,
-0.2997081876,
-0.1606426239,
-0.6493433118,
-0.4057303369,
-0.5411683917,
0.3240145743,
-0.2960153818,
-0.0017051422,
-0.0125839552,
-0.4479984939,
-0.3467119336,
0.1297692209,
-0.548917532,
-0.022154307,
0.3775303364,
0.953522265,
-0.1277123839,
-0.3294480145,
-0.5139374733,
0.3421798348,
-0.1318091899,
0.7119799852,
-0.2937050164,
-0.5538951159,
-0.3008987606,
-0.1056638286,
0.2976031303,
-0.8137472272,
0.1713221669,
-0.2972058058,
0.1530333906,
-0.3275302052,
-0.6842065454,
-0.0556632578,
0.0970212966,
-0.4609686732,
0.8519948721,
-0.0228293817,
-0.8118190765,
0.7405706644,
-0.3158055842,
-0.3214759529,
0.0931323916,
-0.3415155709,
-0.4382654727,
0.1571038663,
0.1907476485,
0.6422646642,
-0.1876351982,
0.5396434665,
-0.593131721,
0.01222838,
0.1424513161,
-0.198865816,
0.6095725298,
0.1121398509,
-0.1106589437,
-0.1598560959,
-1.102794528,
-0.0686922222,
0.0712885931,
-0.547976613,
-0.694085598,
-0.295393765,
-0.3585911393,
0.306714654,
0.0898001865,
-0.5531824827,
0.3788739145,
-0.4559715688,
0.2554264665,
0.5963539481,
0.4367709756,
0.5130927563,
-0.2839275301,
0.2042487562,
0.3640754521,
-0.171439901,
-0.1707356274,
-0.5408043265,
-0.6512876153,
-0.5452899337,
0.1142520532,
0.2344274223,
-1.2087661028,
0.2641934454,
0.0936430171,
-0.4795288444,
-0.5394194722,
0.5352811217,
0.5401710272,
0.8787074685,
0.6060271263,
-0.135219872,
-0.3329832852,
-0.840580523,
-0.1518700719,
-0.0820242316,
-0.0660342276,
0.0929628238,
0.1580345333,
-0.042758394,
1.1698952913,
-0.8129369617,
-0.2916445732,
-0.3553577065,
0.7534984946,
0.4657369256,
0.2691493332,
0.3440183401,
-0.3668459058,
-0.5002623796,
-0.2833274901,
-0.6303997636,
-0.3283475339,
0.091833815,
-0.208283782,
-0.0416141897,
0.4113664627,
-0.1452102065,
0.0501213633,
0.4341989756,
0.0166574661,
0.2994930744,
-0.3347141743,
0.0112186875,
-1.5381139517,
-0.0827839375,
0.1576672494,
-0.4529278874,
-0.5636485219,
-0.2819239199,
-0.1744015664,
-0.053512428,
-0.6853067279,
0.0775489956,
-0.4761665463,
-0.0062512266,
-0.509993434,
-0.1003465876,
-0.0521583222,
0.2994545698,
0.1587110311,
0.4558887482,
0.4819497764,
-0.6305018663,
0.475519985,
0.1798093617,
-0.5426347256,
0.37003842,
-0.546836555,
0.2378187925,
-0.0580397062,
0.3493052125,
-1.0398586988,
-0.1671512276,
-0.1572540849,
-0.0603800602,
0.3261108994,
-0.3585912287,
-0.5879241824,
-0.511441946,
0.0122640347,
0.4863709807,
0.435970217,
-0.6407756805,
0.1123526618,
0.3069261014,
-0.2076898366,
-0.3648552001,
-0.726242125,
-0.1270060688,
-0.2083432227,
-0.6256036758,
0.0364799127,
-0.0426210091,
-0.1652730554,
-0.1091308594,
-0.0717476308,
-0.0925981328,
-0.0240840446,
0.0694362521,
0.3096727729,
-0.045454856,
0.0467507243,
0.2365260124,
-0.1578964889,
-0.1113186479,
-0.4885188639,
0.4802145362,
0.1880723983,
-0.4155824184,
-0.3472148776,
0.0834377557,
0.1883206666,
0.1638158858,
0.8541013002,
0.4840064347,
-0.114430137,
-0.4628759027,
-0.4355829656,
-0.4657704532,
-0.4853610396,
0.1846929044,
-0.2157090306,
-1.11386168,
0.2454006225,
-0.7048673034,
-0.0532066524,
0.2754122019,
0.6925368905,
-0.2278098017,
0.8104864359,
0.6280117631,
-0.1115057096,
0.1641147137,
-0.4497249722,
0.1989319623,
-0.3725139499,
-0.2283536196,
-0.481369406,
-0.515083611,
-0.4939860404,
-0.5721549392,
0.7945714593,
0.3253344893,
0.3731995523,
0.2691418827,
-0.4809010327,
0.6424047351,
0.879712224,
0.1754364967,
0.5385979414,
-0.0662159249,
-0.5695833564,
0.0358982794,
-0.7385900021,
-0.3804072142,
1.1963244677,
-0.1019567847,
0.7212258577,
0.0039277673,
1.3403483629,
0.1666664183,
-0.0285970084,
-0.6856392026,
0.4761345685,
-0.2144662291,
-0.6050237417,
-0.2455838621,
-0.5862591267,
-0.6844553947,
0.1576805413,
-0.2992634773,
-0.5370137691,
0.1392645389,
0.4136357009,
-0.4375788569,
-0.0461378843,
-0.8837617636,
0.7664521933,
0.1617390811,
-0.4303556681,
-0.2008954734,
-0.783184886,
0.7282129526,
-0.5054137111,
0.3447858095,
0.0476158336,
0.4458623827,
0.6825771332,
-0.7946583629,
0.9857906103,
-0.4432036579,
-0.0180973653,
0.5988105536,
0.0053486144,
0.4680421054,
0.0590086952,
0.1720359027,
0.0340265036,
0.161742419,
-0.3166068792,
-0.2873588204,
0.7134758234,
-0.6425481439,
-0.5199112892,
-0.2277134955,
-0.4491290152,
-0.3271956444,
0.2018819153,
0.3654617369,
0.3250992,
0.0048904,
0.1300860047,
0.6543472409,
-0.2410529554,
0.5782610178,
0.500797689,
-0.0266098771,
-0.2530784011,
0.8460369706,
0.069292888,
0.432785809,
0.2393358052,
0.4991745055,
-0.3513538241,
-0.568116188,
-0.3561975956,
0.1581531167,
-0.6547346115,
-0.2334139347,
-0.6471543908,
0.0994567871,
-0.4995740652,
0.001840748,
-0.5215588212,
-0.5820649266,
-0.3077838719,
-0.0378683023,
0.2851633132,
0.7538239956,
-0.2184363902,
0.4322811365,
-1.1652173996,
0.513925612,
0.5234235525,
-0.3061854839,
-0.1509460956,
-0.4407308698,
-0.1837257296,
0.1377834529,
-0.5181466341,
-0.8289988041,
0.33867535,
0.2409089804,
0.5691310763,
0.4717420638,
0.2713288665,
0.8193364739,
-0.6434456706,
0.8305388689,
0.4655314386,
-0.7429714799,
0.6571809649,
-0.1416217536,
0.4930284321,
0.7086922526,
0.4284024537,
-0.3439610898,
-0.7123910785,
-0.5476807952,
-0.8061205149,
0.8461145759,
0.0065208967,
-0.1966370642,
-0.1684443206,
0.1277099252,
0.3553932905,
0.2990027368,
-0.5323185325,
-0.397844851,
0.0216212403,
-0.3574945033,
-0.2402015477,
-0.0630158111,
-0.2335758209,
-0.246371761,
0.7197506428,
-0.2332977951,
-0.2188450694,
0.0267784093,
-0.1733957082,
0.0409345068,
0.3178515434,
0.3513468802,
0.4768595397,
0.0782826543,
0.459009409,
0.1617304683,
-0.299628526,
0.3937031925,
0.0896168053,
0.0119327847,
0.0773860514,
0.3629422784,
0.4624845088,
0.0477239601,
-0.3511862159,
0.5542031527,
0.1273358613,
-0.2845662832,
0.2007246763,
0.2011856139,
0.2728834152,
0.570527494,
0.219006449,
-0.0177927501,
0.3909638524,
-0.5921573639,
0.4152823389,
0.154176116,
0.2310035527,
-0.3112828434,
0.5118097067,
0.0664835647,
0.3121975064,
0.5370258689,
-0.4418519139,
-0.3136807978,
0.2209974825,
0.5129910111,
0.5581693649,
-0.1331758946,
0.3252518177,
0.4994414747,
-0.203059569,
-0.4876182675,
0.0479109064,
-0.3184443116,
-0.7058240771,
-0.5557023883,
-0.9432911873,
-0.1994920671,
0.0404276289,
-0.4817217886,
0.3273611069,
-0.3989126384,
-0.3204207122,
0.3158091307,
-0.1640701145,
-0.4962733686,
-0.0772558823,
0.1570323557,
0.3138207197,
-1.0937700272,
1.0652387142,
0.7876780629,
-0.268539995,
-0.9698576927,
-0.1175098941,
0.3711856604,
-0.7843751311,
0.7276306748,
-0.094367981,
0.0990887731,
0.0395893343,
-0.4166645706,
-0.5267412663,
1.1794557571,
0.3151765168,
-1.0829566717,
-0.0167120509,
0.47558707,
0.5761064291,
-0.0231180862,
-0.0568963736,
0.5467275381,
0.2416078895,
0.7370932102,
-0.7789609432,
-0.1295395494,
0.1778480411,
-0.0232667439,
0.3031285107,
-0.4608113468,
0.6153916717,
-0.2346000969,
-0.0315307491,
-0.1552970558,
0.5923107266,
0.569529593,
0.644061327,
0.480935961,
0.8725799918,
0.9387527108,
0.0422083624,
0.6711776853,
-0.0385623425,
0.2282743901,
1.4991340637,
-0.2550930679,
0.4437193573,
0.6634771228,
-0.2868178785,
0.17968373,
0.3551577628,
0.0507474542,
0.8598884344,
0.297745645,
-0.4512137771,
-0.4219367206,
-0.1369839162,
-0.2069772184,
0.3339630663,
0.0624726303,
-0.5111252069,
-0.4353449941,
0.3331157267,
-0.1151050776,
0.0590860434,
-0.0793669522,
1.2257255316,
0.2853071392,
-0.587446332,
0.5464761257,
-0.1074791923,
0.5445513129,
-0.2858215868,
-0.0877816975,
-0.1582852602,
0.3010439575,
-0.1533884704,
-0.6520708203,
0.1598766744,
0.1565390676,
-0.3431734443,
-0.2889973223,
0.6938057542,
-0.6789086461,
-0.6457406282,
0.0005242634,
0.6953329444,
0.4037145972,
0.1095022857,
-0.381378293,
-0.2863995433,
0.0841333941,
-0.0794533864,
0.4260610938,
0.7392356396,
0.0918265581,
0.237906456,
0.7546986341,
0.1783721149,
0.4387924671,
0.3294851482,
1.0433113575,
-0.3315744102,
-0.2002333254,
-0.9077059627,
0.4689477086,
-0.0585183203,
-0.0404086225,
0.6014216542,
0.6918377876,
1.1380645037,
-0.0912537426,
0.7504912615,
0.0758410767,
0.6753365993,
-0.5648949146,
0.6114147902,
-0.4501324594,
0.2433527261,
-0.3388817906,
-1.0356652737,
0.0015956197,
0.468460381,
-0.0601238944,
-0.1340310276,
0.7644774914,
0.6115466356,
-0.1630802602,
-0.0060728281,
0.5038616061,
0.2920286953,
0.4127729833,
0.5358198285,
0.8538510799,
0.0738584548,
0.406984508,
-0.7067216635,
-0.2735090256,
0.1801030934,
-0.845669806,
-1.1417626143,
-0.6175673008,
-0.4521342516,
-0.073872149,
-0.1180660203,
1.0329447985,
0.5499428511,
-0.7143208981,
-0.0226046126,
-0.3626444638,
-0.1802423,
0.1379339993,
-0.1795336604,
0.0478266627,
-0.438557148,
-0.7862980366,
0.5788418651,
-0.0142954942,
0.228630349,
0.0072370688,
0.1212475747,
-0.2672933042,
-0.3371645808,
0.4990414679,
-0.0770447329,
-0.4887999296,
-0.0058913841,
-0.2242654264,
-0.0325550921,
-0.1582302302,
0.7913700342,
-0.778993845,
0.5855790377,
0.5745645761,
0.5663061142,
0.6804235578,
0.0358315669,
0.4257456958,
-1.2306439877,
0.154100582,
0.0600753427,
0.3528825045,
0.171912998,
-0.1036765352,
0.2646600008,
0.6051437259,
-0.4983048439,
-0.6143523455,
-0.0671683997,
-0.8273139,
-0.3896373808,
1.1470745802,
-0.3574823439,
-0.1555537581,
0.0599398054,
-0.3004013896,
0.8076969385,
-0.4959301949,
0.8216839433,
0.7855075002,
-0.0882474259,
-0.0077263601,
-0.2562005222,
0.41410622,
0.256220758,
-0.7063747048,
-0.0556112751,
0.8483551145,
0.2939362824,
0.1192073449,
0.4574650228,
0.0458628647,
-0.0850532353,
-0.2440199703,
0.0619745217,
-0.2176381052,
-0.4750593007,
-0.0594105907,
0.2374099493,
0.2772316337,
-0.2217980176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08637v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08637v1
|
Formal Proofs as Structured Explanations: Proposing Several Tasks on Explainable Natural Language Inference
| 2023-11-15T01:24:09 | 2023-11-15T01:24:09 |
Lasha Abzianidze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7
|
In this position paper, we propose a way of exploiting formal proofs to put
forward several explainable natural language inference (NLI) tasks. The formal
proofs will be produced by a reliable and high-performing logic-based NLI
system. Taking advantage of the in-depth information available in the generated
formal proofs, we show how it can be used to define NLI tasks with structured
explanations. The proposed tasks can be ordered according to difficulty defined
in terms of the granularity of explanations. We argue that the tasks will
suffer with substantially fewer shortcomings than the existing explainable NLI
tasks (or datasets).
|
[
-0.0591299497,
-0.8595621586,
0.8731300831,
0.552682519,
0.094181478,
-0.3008040488,
-0.3153387308,
-0.5988702178,
-0.0923474282,
0.4736252725,
-0.6415088773,
-0.2919592857,
-0.258240819,
0.4084891379,
-0.5461426973,
0.9755277634,
-0.1799467653,
-0.2074313313,
-0.2732727826,
0.3482599854,
-0.456094563,
-0.2701383233,
-0.6217105389,
-0.5550475121,
0.4802362621,
0.3468922377,
0.7092798948,
0.8354492188,
0.2594507933,
0.4110411406,
-0.1371939778,
0.3387361765,
-0.0634377524,
0.0477737114,
-0.1688872576,
-0.5911288261,
-0.4657687247,
-0.032829199,
0.6177435517,
1.1531136036,
-0.1843507886,
-0.1639666557,
-0.0977905244,
0.6208637953,
-0.5887678266,
0.226138413,
-0.4747577906,
0.25116238,
-0.142217204,
-0.4482224584,
-0.6233488917,
-0.3423662782,
0.0025619084,
-1.0664874315,
0.1908064634,
0.1480070949,
1.0389349461,
0.093372345,
-0.370557636,
-0.4467381835,
-1.1146636009,
0.9844257832,
-0.8923675418,
0.1974909455,
0.4245882332,
0.623375237,
-0.1990278065,
-0.855181098,
-0.4991209805,
-0.1786567122,
-0.4794133604,
0.0958234295,
0.0902692974,
0.2961858213,
0.5543294549,
0.4904007018,
-0.5675005317,
-0.0920412838,
0.0104407696,
-0.0724993721,
0.8885203004,
0.1246949285,
0.2481964678,
-0.1518949419,
0.1100323498,
0.542211175,
-0.4007661939,
0.2185766101,
0.3523035049,
0.220827356,
0.0587992221,
0.3942995071,
-0.5284233689,
1.0151900053,
0.1238785535,
-0.3707784116,
-0.0672683939,
-0.8103427291,
-0.3678615391,
0.1854112744,
0.4807984829,
-0.1259132326,
0.3480298221,
-0.7370645404,
-0.3419621587,
0.2051267177,
0.1540354043,
-0.5009489059,
0.0029329911,
0.5962103009,
-0.5543873906,
-0.340062499,
0.1256158203,
-0.4891586304,
-0.0397713743,
-0.5685510039,
0.3284450471,
-0.4457727075,
0.0182203334,
0.5258105397,
-0.5215534568,
0.2388451099,
0.2220081836,
-1.1061373949,
0.9630320072,
1.0423958302,
0.5064250231,
0.3685832322,
-0.0711638257,
-0.5708058476,
0.5224308372,
-0.3132885695,
0.7328753471,
-0.496073097,
0.0856980905,
0.2012612224,
-0.0333630927,
-0.014705264,
-0.3310411572,
0.881719172,
-0.3038494289,
0.5715871453,
-0.2582338452,
-0.6545580029,
-0.1256684065,
0.3033649325,
-0.5030210614,
0.8904341459,
-0.3356754184,
-1.0060043335,
0.373688966,
-0.9966115355,
-0.8602577448,
0.1041302383,
0.0827195048,
-0.1450439692,
0.0133935297,
0.3232547045,
0.4092949033,
-0.0287037268,
0.5653259158,
-0.1198108271,
-0.3618035913,
0.2385087013,
-0.1158746853,
0.9774820805,
0.1258784235,
-0.7065874934,
0.193168357,
-0.9504668117,
0.0354962014,
0.2522566319,
-0.3014423251,
-0.3460277319,
0.475050658,
-0.2245666236,
0.0407144129,
0.0602733493,
-0.5487632155,
-0.1268799901,
-0.9435398579,
0.5987575054,
0.5565131903,
0.0261616893,
0.6974266768,
-0.3089831769,
0.4041828215,
-0.1615436226,
0.3518546522,
-0.0635126233,
-0.4082570076,
-0.6018733978,
-0.1873290688,
0.3883805871,
0.7067427039,
-0.7345964313,
0.3735462725,
-0.2403444946,
-0.127001673,
-0.0176441874,
0.022424994,
0.4925473928,
0.6549022198,
0.0696887821,
0.2563765049,
-0.7882157564,
-1.0348303318,
-0.4894475341,
-0.0497349203,
-0.4264647365,
0.2163686305,
0.6662093997,
-0.0229519792,
1.1252450943,
-0.0909689665,
0.285509944,
-0.2453164607,
0.2777136862,
0.5286522508,
0.4085140228,
0.2742957175,
-0.8226212859,
0.1919905841,
-0.1836717129,
-0.8579890132,
-0.2588803172,
-0.4696733654,
-0.3605354726,
-0.0157277528,
0.4605465233,
-0.3733305633,
0.3487676978,
0.1666135341,
-0.4443828464,
0.8174312115,
-0.0871851668,
-0.1493368149,
-0.7192650437,
-0.2018937767,
0.0065971185,
-0.5592909455,
-0.8243755102,
0.1222935244,
-0.4082652628,
0.0743574798,
-0.0272015724,
0.3633068204,
-0.383865416,
0.0314004421,
-0.0812485516,
0.3541039526,
0.3738117814,
0.2763408422,
0.1897144318,
0.1188710779,
0.6486157179,
-0.9550736547,
0.164822042,
0.1644407213,
-0.1141611263,
0.3664805591,
-1.1810559034,
-0.1017999798,
-0.2291725129,
0.3853469193,
-0.8261521459,
-0.4231860638,
0.3043356836,
-0.264537245,
0.0619299263,
-0.2679198086,
-0.4981467724,
-0.3228273988,
-0.1177660599,
0.2013023049,
0.3185585737,
-0.5354480743,
0.7324069142,
0.0772849023,
0.1414194256,
-0.4352705777,
-0.8096752167,
0.2083856761,
-0.2856610715,
-0.9474644065,
0.7627243996,
0.0702194944,
-0.7195398211,
0.0639772415,
-0.2353406996,
-0.3783124387,
0.3379310071,
0.5938704014,
-0.0767089874,
-0.3931611776,
0.0893492773,
-0.0396837108,
-0.239833802,
0.4271578491,
-0.4770535827,
-0.0854814872,
-0.4504428208,
-0.4302847385,
-0.5555163622,
0.6819577813,
0.0110870181,
-0.2928206027,
0.6077650189,
0.4242502749,
-0.755231142,
-0.2620059848,
-0.3138834238,
-0.0836157948,
-0.4511903524,
-0.2239064723,
-0.37334162,
-0.7195749879,
0.4346266687,
-0.2365352362,
0.5828956962,
0.5134978294,
0.2923489213,
-0.169751212,
1.0845479965,
0.3547854125,
0.4276197255,
0.3485460579,
-0.1931852698,
0.5269979835,
-0.1762013584,
-0.2702147961,
-0.8625649214,
-0.1376507878,
-0.4058525562,
-0.1057020798,
-0.0724532157,
0.3086078763,
-0.1230562627,
0.1896994263,
-0.3704605997,
0.6526504755,
0.7853672504,
0.0468566157,
0.4265604615,
-0.2618792355,
0.098123014,
0.3332962692,
-0.7306291461,
-0.8722329736,
0.2883534431,
0.3698433042,
0.3270073533,
0.1087760925,
0.8296406865,
0.0344150141,
-0.0652423277,
-0.7552525401,
0.5067821741,
-0.0301554371,
-0.8336654902,
-0.5513560772,
-0.475943923,
-0.9790087938,
-0.1672969759,
-0.3651980758,
-0.7623314261,
0.1572803706,
0.2654485106,
-0.3565834165,
-0.0246729814,
-0.7596881986,
0.8722865582,
-0.0621669255,
-0.1520565599,
-0.1014081165,
-0.6807376146,
0.7861360908,
0.4697568715,
0.6352356076,
-0.0534548201,
0.259401232,
1.0095225573,
-0.8327408433,
0.8881565332,
-0.3577179015,
-0.084326759,
0.3385517895,
-0.0327093042,
0.4186525941,
0.4175771773,
-0.3664638698,
-0.2176633477,
0.220927,
-0.63579005,
-1.1018968821,
0.2148797065,
0.0098179569,
-0.4099983871,
-0.2318036407,
-0.5512370467,
-0.1073285565,
0.0808933377,
0.0394821614,
0.9394459128,
0.0452969857,
-0.206697464,
0.7619825006,
0.0694417432,
0.7110394239,
0.144384712,
0.0564214848,
0.0147168972,
0.9079965949,
-0.1982133985,
-0.0128236637,
0.6182320118,
0.4901913404,
-0.1780366302,
-0.8713158965,
-0.1063079834,
0.026770344,
-0.5164363384,
0.1115261689,
-0.3893449605,
-0.0471551046,
-0.3841347396,
-0.4313260913,
-0.0294230077,
-0.8324906826,
0.0823238865,
-0.0859983712,
0.2607563436,
0.8491569757,
0.0432684459,
0.2023689449,
-0.5458410382,
0.9129233956,
0.6202319264,
0.6052624583,
-0.2825578749,
-0.4241980612,
-0.1257727742,
0.1116683185,
0.0665881559,
-0.7720043659,
-0.01243487,
0.5370898247,
0.4919373095,
0.6807237864,
0.0764646381,
1.0364637375,
-0.7399136424,
0.6450788379,
-0.2232123613,
-1.1682537794,
0.9823441505,
-0.2988341749,
0.0459590219,
0.4754828811,
0.2348284125,
-0.3396467865,
-0.6735884547,
-0.6274359226,
-0.8490539789,
0.4741907716,
0.4459307492,
-0.10482914,
-0.2242664844,
0.7814648151,
0.0731944516,
-0.2063110024,
-0.7777855992,
-0.0960266665,
-0.1324560046,
-0.1744140834,
0.3354282677,
-0.3130005002,
-0.440656215,
-0.1901057959,
0.879763186,
-0.1809005886,
0.2715078592,
0.4919543564,
-0.3010224402,
0.2455528229,
0.5515440106,
0.5645491481,
0.9953509569,
-0.0320903286,
0.3823862672,
-0.032746397,
0.0429212525,
-0.1126431748,
0.2409048527,
-0.2435052991,
0.2246127874,
1.0287395716,
0.7095794678,
0.3813401461,
-0.7725673914,
0.4142276347,
-0.1954560876,
-0.6558662057,
-0.4130505919,
0.0737273395,
-0.0076859174,
0.1577531546,
0.1643404961,
-0.1981524676,
0.539026916,
-0.578191638,
0.2168065608,
0.4364143908,
-0.1280895472,
-0.316776216,
0.6652216315,
0.0119410018,
-0.461630553,
0.3340112269,
-0.4642778039,
-0.3701776862,
0.4303946793,
0.7183736563,
0.4706500173,
0.2205583453,
0.3757742047,
0.2185776532,
0.2879039049,
-0.2155650854,
0.4151669443,
-0.1551558822,
-0.5463961363,
-0.9503431916,
-0.5790224075,
-0.5875083208,
-0.2043201774,
-0.6315469742,
-0.1978626996,
-0.5562467575,
0.3044617772,
0.5715220571,
-0.1329307556,
-0.4647626877,
0.2947804928,
0.1954997033,
0.8580344915,
-1.0198504925,
0.175675571,
0.5572727323,
-0.1662454307,
-0.8592237234,
-0.1769090593,
-0.1870675087,
-0.4423461854,
0.5047149658,
0.0814199075,
-0.2580069602,
-0.4416460693,
-0.6985891461,
-0.5003629327,
0.7098542452,
0.4510831833,
-0.3226976097,
-0.1797018647,
0.0277684219,
0.453692615,
-0.1589366347,
0.1342130601,
0.6960496902,
0.8907273412,
-0.1378050745,
-0.5081831217,
0.3501913249,
-0.2814978659,
0.0235600844,
-0.0276361089,
0.2495592237,
0.0764242038,
-0.2107882202,
-0.3761565685,
-0.0315562002,
1.0857977867,
0.2885659635,
0.6469768286,
0.8862658739,
0.4407116175,
1.04540658,
-0.3909128308,
1.4993231297,
-0.0374151953,
-0.1379707009,
1.2188334465,
-0.0016636865,
0.5524529815,
0.4934559762,
-0.1559700966,
1.0301982164,
0.7816736698,
0.2413999438,
0.1373362541,
0.4813576639,
-0.3121963441,
-0.3398525417,
-0.3667719662,
0.0950684398,
0.4450480044,
0.2009693831,
-0.1240633801,
-0.1620125324,
-0.2941289246,
-0.2455021143,
0.2543046474,
-0.2279298455,
0.7517552376,
-0.1952984929,
-0.7663766742,
0.5321670175,
0.2154954076,
0.381270647,
-0.5212357044,
-0.3086294532,
0.09555839,
-0.1510178447,
-0.6811276078,
-0.6368885636,
0.7818550467,
-0.1085435897,
-0.4409608543,
-0.6519405842,
0.7922999263,
-0.3331741691,
-0.5823702216,
-0.0665798038,
0.2860054374,
0.1668349952,
-0.1232575849,
-0.5319117308,
-0.4958986044,
-0.4356585741,
-0.2941530347,
-0.1564015746,
0.8028401732,
-0.1502610892,
0.5382125974,
0.6508387327,
-0.0873535424,
0.1497148424,
0.4595204294,
0.4991865456,
-0.6313003302,
-0.5246986151,
-0.8850179315,
0.5756322145,
-0.2119379193,
0.1145452261,
0.6503412127,
0.4466749132,
0.2377246022,
-0.0183223989,
0.6100413203,
-0.1706771404,
0.3091911376,
-0.756513834,
-0.0273427777,
-0.186500147,
0.1278555989,
-0.2973665297,
-0.5966108441,
-0.6207313538,
0.5181205273,
-0.1587280929,
-0.0521547608,
0.9897521734,
0.5233278275,
-0.095084995,
0.2802356482,
-0.1557892114,
0.2246825695,
0.1643684655,
0.5465373993,
0.5572696924,
-0.2795675695,
0.476773262,
-0.5494323969,
-0.2671982348,
0.1128653735,
-1.2619479895,
-0.7659544349,
-0.3492923379,
-0.5948526859,
-0.3260166049,
0.0821245313,
0.2765788138,
1.0769553185,
-1.0363922119,
0.0399110802,
-0.623546958,
0.8388765454,
-0.7626187801,
-0.2906341553,
0.2898833156,
-0.5381734371,
-0.6026346087,
0.8734979033,
0.3915479481,
-0.250248611,
0.0617432669,
0.0068338094,
-0.347772032,
0.2049314082,
0.77434659,
0.4230863452,
-0.9240113497,
-0.450847894,
-0.1736156493,
0.3165936172,
-0.0833785012,
1.0609513521,
-0.7147507071,
0.0474683382,
0.6398735642,
0.5896753669,
0.2201317549,
0.062451914,
0.8573750854,
-0.9282858372,
0.0296253394,
0.1695672572,
0.5324388146,
0.1280107945,
-0.2810118198,
0.608088553,
0.0072468529,
-0.3763623536,
-0.8549460769,
0.3833217323,
-1.1440132856,
-0.177987054,
0.9721118212,
-0.2369245887,
-0.3558374643,
-0.691367805,
0.2117212862,
0.2701443732,
0.0737255067,
0.5060984492,
0.628223896,
-0.2553377151,
0.1014779061,
-0.6572756767,
0.5260569453,
0.4102663696,
-1.1704423428,
0.0727208704,
0.2487718165,
0.1511397064,
0.2313446999,
0.4916324914,
-0.3186526597,
0.2159692347,
-0.0177237839,
-0.1469095349,
-0.1364420503,
-0.4133221507,
-0.3831014633,
0.2440704852,
-0.0082605518,
-0.0540087111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08623v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08623v1
|
DEED: Dynamic Early Exit on Decoder for Accelerating Encoder-Decoder Transformer Models
| 2023-11-15T01:01:02 | 2023-11-15T01:01:02 |
Peng Tang, Pengkai Zhu, Tian Li, Srikar Appalaraju, Vijay Mahadevan, R. Manmatha
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Encoder-decoder transformer models have achieved great success on various
vision-language (VL) tasks, but they suffer from high inference latency.
Typically, the decoder takes up most of the latency because of the
auto-regressive decoding. To accelerate the inference, we propose an approach
of performing Dynamic Early Exit on Decoder (DEED). We build a multi-exit
encoder-decoder transformer model which is trained with deep supervision so
that each of its decoder layers is capable of generating plausible predictions.
In addition, we leverage simple yet practical techniques, including shared
generation head and adaptation modules, to keep accuracy when exiting at
shallow decoder layers. Based on the multi-exit model, we perform step-level
dynamic early exit during inference, where the model may decide to use fewer
decoder layers based on its confidence of the current layer at each individual
decoding step. Considering different number of decoder layers may be used at
different decoding steps, we compute deeper-layer decoder features of previous
decoding steps just-in-time, which ensures the features from different decoding
steps are semantically aligned. We evaluate our approach with two
state-of-the-art encoder-decoder transformer models on various VL tasks. We
show our approach can reduce overall inference latency by 30%-60% with
comparable or even higher accuracy compared to baselines.
|
[
-0.1968982369,
-0.7574520707,
0.469841212,
0.2655830085,
-0.2951683998,
0.2020557821,
0.0108786393,
-0.3467692435,
-0.3314591348,
0.4397705793,
-0.5143971443,
-0.2112184912,
-1.0021717548,
-0.1568476111,
-0.5769840479,
0.5439166427,
-0.2640680075,
-0.1391170472,
-0.0089852586,
0.2514108121,
-0.2758970857,
-0.0723399967,
-0.6790610552,
-0.2951981425,
0.2861585617,
0.2118174434,
0.7334557176,
0.8685877919,
0.5982018709,
0.313491106,
-0.4554425776,
0.1494192332,
-0.4729706049,
0.1567044109,
0.1910480261,
-0.3270153999,
-0.519549489,
-0.1911287904,
0.4685959518,
0.5918391943,
-0.5200207233,
0.0051318281,
0.0111992536,
0.5750902891,
-0.8405102491,
0.1492403746,
-0.4539617896,
0.4664596319,
0.0234821979,
-0.1438949853,
-0.7500160336,
-0.1390280724,
-0.0002570921,
-0.663651526,
0.1232250556,
-0.3366726637,
0.8730806112,
0.6944394112,
-0.4085827768,
0.1415887475,
-0.9679355621,
0.6342971325,
-0.6804856658,
0.8738408089,
-0.2293076366,
0.6279332042,
0.0514957793,
-1.056755662,
-0.7349051833,
-0.2173544317,
0.0038452712,
0.3375172615,
-0.1071826816,
0.0221788045,
0.3813751638,
0.2427418381,
-0.0142983142,
0.0011055843,
-0.0931733996,
-0.0935833603,
0.2455363423,
0.1717138588,
-0.0347466804,
-0.1115207598,
-0.5560716391,
-0.4094906747,
-0.6009201407,
0.3704492748,
0.4627723992,
0.0130211459,
-0.3222627938,
0.472312361,
-0.3131705225,
0.6120649576,
0.5823780298,
0.0698673502,
0.4384603798,
-0.3987233341,
-0.0441764332,
0.1327103674,
0.5252863765,
0.3184443414,
0.1368226856,
-0.2768459022,
-0.3808734417,
0.2319641113,
0.3805555105,
-1.156015873,
-0.2110971808,
0.2586704195,
-0.6429554224,
-0.3107470572,
0.102500245,
-0.8958542347,
-0.3853601515,
-0.2674677074,
0.4598270655,
-0.3073692918,
-0.3306756616,
0.5149722099,
-0.0697753355,
0.8833417296,
0.5170321465,
-0.2947420478,
0.5403459072,
0.4558435977,
0.6853685975,
-0.3857252598,
-0.1831460297,
-1.2367222309,
0.0001191346,
-0.2644098997,
0.3548924029,
-0.6819370389,
0.0161049943,
-0.1180979311,
0.1621669978,
0.0610944852,
-0.3626724482,
0.5850750208,
-0.9267020226,
0.0691931024,
0.3624044061,
-0.2808004618,
-0.1150921583,
0.1306880713,
-0.786077261,
0.9227210879,
-0.0707398057,
-0.5112022161,
0.4304846525,
-0.8305641413,
-0.4165883362,
-0.2033527792,
-0.0422584601,
-0.4604977369,
0.3539890945,
0.4501151741,
0.5199862123,
-0.1144609526,
0.312556833,
-0.07046175,
-0.6057201028,
-0.1317182481,
-0.7572446465,
0.6716859341,
0.1709061265,
-0.6873755455,
-0.0944290161,
-1.0288858414,
-0.1417609602,
0.0139950747,
-0.3741255403,
-0.0959002003,
0.3046605885,
-0.2763471305,
0.4086990356,
0.4031039774,
-0.7207871675,
0.2982950509,
-0.4558495581,
-0.0819965601,
0.5891815424,
-0.1000892743,
0.4750855565,
0.3093835115,
0.6487355828,
0.4948857129,
0.372748524,
-0.4123126268,
-0.4838576019,
-0.9089999199,
-0.0222225245,
0.1877714097,
0.6809780002,
-1.0174422264,
0.5048010945,
-0.5576199293,
-0.4523532987,
-0.8905615211,
-0.1860635132,
0.734926641,
0.4569085836,
0.4545947313,
-0.3858095706,
-0.2247821391,
-0.6007641554,
-0.3896621466,
0.091649957,
-0.0337755308,
0.0454507098,
0.3160973787,
-0.1875188649,
0.8058419824,
-0.557482481,
-0.0414509587,
-0.0947858542,
0.0793638751,
0.5833066106,
0.3480238616,
0.0170589704,
-1.0477274656,
-0.4313059151,
0.0972085074,
-0.6728821993,
-0.0976687446,
-0.2428918183,
-0.2857313156,
-0.1474779993,
0.4795736969,
-0.7123457789,
0.5523350239,
0.6134761572,
-0.6164098382,
0.4410770833,
-0.3821078539,
0.181822896,
-0.8728080988,
-0.2867453992,
-0.348274976,
-0.107688196,
-0.6471799612,
0.1398110837,
0.2383296639,
0.1644131392,
-0.8395017385,
0.4483289123,
-0.7462239861,
-0.0713593662,
-0.0104765324,
-0.159934178,
0.2889618576,
0.293035239,
0.3606051505,
0.7062622905,
0.7089005113,
-0.7346642613,
0.3852558434,
0.3124628961,
-0.2251987159,
-0.0554425158,
-0.6644052863,
0.1677752435,
-0.1461955607,
0.0133870635,
-0.7618862987,
0.1018178165,
0.2740111947,
-0.4445577562,
0.3686694503,
-0.3698926866,
-0.1122953296,
-0.4075881541,
-0.1887253523,
0.3705069125,
0.7041772008,
-0.6809232235,
1.0591208935,
-0.1164533943,
0.200901553,
-0.8760894537,
-0.9043767452,
0.3364692032,
0.0459995084,
-0.6602417827,
0.5402153134,
0.0580448471,
-0.0700183138,
0.2450567931,
0.0789706409,
0.0198536869,
-0.1541868299,
0.2264043838,
-0.03814869,
-0.319013238,
-0.453758657,
0.2703901827,
-0.4176865816,
0.1515535116,
-0.2675409913,
0.5400394797,
-0.2435186505,
-0.6045688391,
-0.3092514277,
0.2677738965,
0.7597793937,
-0.6905093789,
1.0152533054,
0.9294476509,
-0.256300509,
-0.0750253424,
-0.4212616682,
-0.3240439594,
-0.5050721765,
0.3453250527,
-0.7070343494,
-0.2776689529,
0.5927054286,
-0.1500749886,
-0.14520064,
0.2442599833,
0.5360068083,
0.0904093459,
0.9444955587,
0.803928256,
0.5406693816,
0.508250773,
-0.678924799,
0.5603302717,
-0.812302947,
-0.425116092,
0.0067626354,
-0.202596128,
-0.3509551287,
-0.7071638703,
0.2947191596,
0.1602252573,
-0.0649323761,
0.3277301788,
-0.4025675356,
0.3541502655,
0.3810220063,
0.2785241604,
0.2670943737,
-0.0454497449,
-0.0778316855,
0.0536506474,
-0.7075897455,
-0.2865387499,
0.8391315937,
0.3815508485,
0.9971513152,
0.259670943,
0.7365627885,
0.4186511636,
-0.1137332469,
-0.7524626851,
0.5640258789,
-0.3752302229,
-0.0571041182,
-0.3086611629,
-0.2096094936,
-0.700442791,
0.3330943584,
-0.0623310208,
-0.2894209325,
0.6376449466,
0.291307956,
-0.4713813365,
0.3529085517,
-0.6457870603,
1.070182085,
-0.1712488234,
-0.610060215,
0.1112982631,
-0.8973120451,
0.536110878,
-0.1438283026,
-0.0912944525,
0.1896558702,
-0.2161856443,
0.5069667101,
-0.382158041,
0.8041383624,
-0.6702786684,
-0.23035492,
0.3284212649,
0.1349372715,
0.8178578615,
-0.2756290138,
-0.2957527339,
0.1372427046,
-0.295792222,
-0.138390854,
-0.6436321735,
0.1516311169,
-0.598857224,
-0.1243020818,
-0.1820529699,
-0.1474891454,
0.1310261935,
0.109523274,
0.2754934728,
0.7081727982,
0.1832684577,
0.3404939175,
0.7206930518,
-0.2488291264,
0.6597457528,
0.4546114504,
0.0347616486,
-0.1515936106,
0.7560059428,
-0.3880639672,
0.4053905904,
0.5659259558,
0.4610301256,
-0.6583554745,
-0.7872656584,
-0.562184155,
-0.1223955825,
-0.7237152457,
-0.1188042611,
-0.8413092494,
-0.2256006598,
-0.3775929213,
-0.1027664691,
-0.7918181419,
0.0330795497,
-0.0421793051,
0.0318915136,
0.1159895658,
0.5061030984,
0.0961993858,
0.6856955886,
-1.1485749483,
0.8087118268,
0.0818380564,
0.2181998044,
-0.0454957597,
-0.8543586135,
-0.2303031236,
-0.1935915947,
-0.0826429054,
-0.9507098198,
0.4323808551,
0.4505198002,
0.5716522336,
0.7519202232,
0.3418246508,
0.7114278078,
-0.7410426736,
0.8593585491,
0.2410592735,
-0.9508981109,
0.4508907199,
-0.0826609954,
0.3011131585,
0.2480761707,
0.1473154128,
-0.253049314,
-0.2686734796,
-0.3385098577,
-1.0317312479,
0.5709687471,
0.1907833219,
0.0431514159,
0.1160112917,
0.2605938911,
0.2127083242,
0.2427597791,
-0.6507579088,
0.0482554026,
-0.2152937651,
-0.1628319919,
0.1775066406,
-0.32094118,
0.2240775526,
-0.4400955439,
0.2851714492,
-0.2455595434,
0.4882965684,
-0.0114286887,
-0.373614341,
-0.0239298549,
0.1549577266,
0.2802146077,
0.6085455418,
-0.1347798407,
0.1491750479,
0.1795395464,
-0.5013493299,
0.5211436152,
0.1762451231,
-0.3093626797,
-0.0978325158,
0.541637361,
1.2259975672,
0.3278023601,
-0.477512002,
0.9962881804,
-0.2396643907,
0.0347484201,
-0.4075834751,
0.002629501,
-0.0971260592,
0.4739719629,
0.2543430924,
0.1458286643,
0.2026634216,
-0.1468143314,
0.4316424429,
0.0288382061,
-0.2093498111,
-0.3197310865,
1.0092047453,
0.3116168976,
-0.222163856,
0.6089015603,
-0.3006681502,
-0.4871059358,
0.5695729852,
0.2582782805,
1.243709445,
-0.3585658371,
-0.024956461,
0.085179612,
0.2608206868,
0.0651019439,
0.3170193434,
-0.2222865522,
-0.9036420584,
-1.0475610495,
-1.0804041624,
-0.1976416111,
-0.1780509502,
-0.9014961123,
0.313900888,
0.196257934,
0.0946664065,
-0.5095369816,
-0.2144473344,
-0.880895257,
0.4102248847,
0.3667887151,
1.0333969593,
-0.8069959879,
0.8306693435,
0.4126985669,
-0.0366547406,
-0.5002885461,
0.2983485758,
-0.3129419088,
-0.6822681427,
0.966945827,
0.3248140514,
-0.8036721945,
0.1196677834,
-0.275310427,
-0.6649113297,
1.0178164244,
0.3948429227,
-0.7444418669,
-0.4778058827,
-0.0342074707,
0.4229695797,
-0.3161348403,
0.4780191183,
0.6087545156,
0.7741509676,
0.1869571954,
-0.4852415919,
-0.0400705263,
-0.2199089676,
-0.0991564021,
0.1246389076,
-0.3260277808,
0.9259468317,
-0.5438229442,
-0.1266854554,
-0.0114086987,
0.8643779159,
-0.2483881712,
0.1858765483,
0.9375499487,
0.5128160119,
0.2479289472,
-0.1527285129,
1.0965054035,
-0.7264186144,
0.0666389465,
1.0385985374,
-0.0438854061,
1.0182029009,
0.5560566783,
-0.07341028,
0.441672802,
0.501886785,
0.1112012789,
0.8968601227,
-0.1553421021,
-0.205133304,
-0.5493209362,
0.2867529094,
-0.2888164222,
0.9167852998,
0.193908006,
-0.2825462818,
-0.1807053089,
0.0945337787,
-0.2518295944,
-0.1575196534,
-0.0533341281,
0.7021827698,
-0.1800475419,
-0.496886611,
0.4618908465,
-0.0278647356,
0.6990344524,
-0.7369114757,
-0.2900215089,
-0.2522928715,
0.4188995957,
-0.0608060621,
-0.8648208976,
0.3431952596,
-0.0859944224,
0.0327609554,
-0.536002636,
0.7352616787,
-0.6533592939,
-0.5779050589,
0.7886669636,
0.7288916707,
0.2300302684,
-0.1416884661,
-0.4013305604,
0.3046320081,
-0.3040197194,
-0.8046807647,
-0.2286220938,
0.6015787125,
0.2761823237,
0.5442588925,
0.7365822792,
0.3169624507,
0.7760385275,
0.1269007176,
0.9247838259,
-0.7040807605,
-0.5108810663,
-0.7985078096,
0.8887912035,
-0.1310597211,
-0.1226278916,
0.4460671544,
0.384573549,
0.6133441329,
-0.2787924707,
0.4019291401,
-0.0828924999,
0.0775940493,
-0.8675881028,
0.6536748409,
-0.7534002066,
0.139913097,
-0.2405757904,
-1.0513432026,
-0.0339687094,
0.3330545127,
-0.009098527,
0.0770906508,
0.5298501253,
0.688365519,
-0.3607584238,
-0.5674159527,
0.4920942783,
0.3746986687,
0.6543770432,
0.624992013,
0.8017826676,
-0.5721043348,
0.5441076756,
-0.3322451413,
-0.235619545,
-0.1250378489,
-1.3936642408,
-0.364174068,
-0.2904043496,
-0.333003819,
-0.1952086389,
0.230425477,
0.2702381015,
0.8049582243,
-0.5821756124,
0.1739157289,
-0.0819261447,
-0.2980139852,
-0.5123118162,
-0.2844360769,
0.2752578557,
-0.1518045664,
-0.8590514064,
0.6742132306,
0.2692728937,
-0.1290905327,
-0.4224091172,
-0.3299628198,
0.0650404245,
0.0272898078,
0.8093582988,
-0.1114466488,
-0.8749077916,
-0.2599132657,
-0.1001200229,
0.1357085109,
0.211772278,
0.7359855175,
-1.0890113115,
0.6131469011,
0.5389726758,
0.9698002934,
0.7418942451,
0.0732072666,
0.5738763809,
-0.5623239279,
0.1651394069,
0.2188084573,
0.240009129,
0.2066565603,
-0.3461670578,
0.3912798762,
0.2254109681,
-0.0407188721,
-0.7395763397,
0.1621581018,
-1.0397788286,
0.0895996764,
0.955319941,
-0.2043384463,
-0.5308102965,
0.0360914096,
0.0175188091,
0.5033934712,
-0.3221470714,
0.4373219609,
0.3955065608,
-0.1245832816,
-0.5537967086,
-0.5088357925,
0.2816455364,
0.2298336625,
-0.7282094955,
0.2532304227,
0.2234413922,
-0.1421034634,
0.1663801968,
0.4456619024,
-0.1438838542,
0.3041201532,
0.3739439845,
0.4220039845,
-0.3776835203,
-0.9536944032,
-0.451235652,
0.3840303719,
-0.3299574554,
-0.6786227226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08622v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08622v1
|
Multiple-Question Multiple-Answer Text-VQA
| 2023-11-15T01:00:02 | 2023-11-15T01:00:02 |
Peng Tang, Srikar Appalaraju, R. Manmatha, Yusheng Xie, Vijay Mahadevan
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present Multiple-Question Multiple-Answer (MQMA), a novel approach to do
text-VQA in encoder-decoder transformer models. The text-VQA task requires a
model to answer a question by understanding multi-modal content: text
(typically from OCR) and an associated image. To the best of our knowledge,
almost all previous approaches for text-VQA process a single question and its
associated content to predict a single answer. In order to answer multiple
questions from the same image, each question and content are fed into the model
multiple times. In contrast, our proposed MQMA approach takes multiple
questions and content as input at the encoder and predicts multiple answers at
the decoder in an auto-regressive manner at the same time. We make several
novel architectural modifications to standard encoder-decoder transformers to
support MQMA. We also propose a novel MQMA denoising pre-training task which is
designed to teach the model to align and delineate multiple questions and
content with associated answers. MQMA pre-trained model achieves
state-of-the-art results on multiple text-VQA datasets, each with strong
baselines. Specifically, on OCR-VQA (+2.5%), TextVQA (+1.4%), ST-VQA (+0.6%),
DocVQA (+1.1%) absolute improvements over the previous state-of-the-art
approaches.
|
[
-0.6562493443,
-0.9196109772,
0.5984256864,
-0.0798525289,
-0.0532716326,
0.1223701909,
0.3175547123,
-0.2410648465,
0.0134155266,
0.7150497437,
-0.8371477127,
-0.1784120053,
-0.6726522446,
0.2795473337,
-0.3375026584,
0.5060348511,
-0.2899562418,
0.397123307,
-0.5076604486,
-0.2440135926,
-0.5528228879,
-0.8363749385,
-0.4419998229,
-0.1166117713,
0.5171669722,
0.5990415812,
0.6093440056,
0.2794898748,
0.4385181963,
0.2457965463,
0.2719131708,
0.3937879801,
-0.1120208204,
0.2542729378,
0.2872936726,
-0.4584938288,
-0.4898886085,
-0.1240500584,
0.697277844,
0.0380905308,
-0.1429694295,
0.4687667787,
-0.1991400421,
0.5421342254,
-0.8107746243,
-0.2763223946,
-0.4560489357,
0.0692316741,
0.3576839268,
-0.2379518598,
-0.5168144703,
-0.2132405341,
-0.1555312574,
-0.5270774364,
-0.1023024842,
-0.0659980699,
0.7270913124,
0.4666811526,
-1.0149980783,
-0.3488963544,
-0.9457983971,
0.7641295195,
-0.3141389191,
0.4482702017,
0.3252841234,
0.5457087755,
0.2858510017,
-0.7221554518,
-1.0328593254,
0.1750503629,
-0.1069372594,
0.5433987975,
-0.0941001996,
-0.1198993474,
0.2506791651,
0.4377253056,
-0.5704833865,
-0.4232032895,
-0.396671176,
-0.0810464174,
0.3451146483,
0.616109252,
0.005628698,
-0.2003358006,
-0.6530175209,
-0.1259426177,
-0.4090156853,
0.3398633301,
0.0215781182,
-0.1311146915,
0.3056203723,
0.7187178731,
-0.365596503,
0.4973993599,
-0.1324964464,
-0.1455418169,
0.3544674814,
-0.8087162971,
-0.1990059167,
-0.3805959821,
0.8963323236,
0.1913807541,
-0.1132659465,
0.2910617292,
0.0067173298,
-0.0806135014,
0.6029758453,
-0.9732986689,
0.0857122242,
0.4580518603,
-0.5094471574,
-0.0962684527,
-0.0897883475,
-0.836845994,
-0.1460035592,
-0.2749097049,
1.12830019,
-0.2517187595,
-0.1727577299,
0.5876323581,
-0.1405784637,
0.8099118471,
0.4950428307,
-0.6014862061,
0.2899183929,
0.2128000408,
0.4521966279,
0.192895025,
-0.3173154294,
-0.361309737,
0.0011661915,
-0.0504733548,
0.8430337906,
-0.5253483653,
-0.320388943,
-0.062196888,
0.1356549412,
-0.2066400349,
-0.2566765845,
0.6855985522,
-0.7798546553,
0.7294486165,
-0.3907186389,
-0.265016526,
-0.3709748983,
0.6591842175,
-0.8080496192,
1.1195999384,
0.1394048929,
-0.6481583714,
0.0890567526,
-0.7574852705,
-0.1736223698,
-0.4079684019,
0.0408023372,
-0.4872766137,
-0.1053287312,
0.6948924065,
0.1057299823,
-0.4465914667,
-0.2673959732,
0.0873836428,
-0.4560950398,
0.4199166894,
-0.7068742514,
0.5811308622,
0.1927109808,
0.0308580399,
0.1842206419,
-0.7534232736,
0.2201309502,
0.180463627,
-0.6519083977,
0.0592089258,
-0.1631802917,
-0.0272651985,
0.7041454315,
0.2592819929,
-0.5859090686,
0.4069095552,
-0.0648420826,
0.3166486621,
0.3817193508,
0.1580708921,
0.4443515241,
-0.7643152475,
0.9409396648,
0.30282107,
0.4528209269,
-0.6200339794,
-0.6337298751,
-0.8186118603,
-0.1739883423,
0.1397026032,
0.7989668846,
-1.2437223196,
-0.1833384335,
-0.117416501,
-0.5953065753,
-1.016618371,
-0.116247043,
0.2975922525,
0.5232394934,
0.8352043629,
-0.3150716722,
-0.4592627287,
-0.7482125163,
-0.1411682516,
-0.0594011918,
-0.0880038217,
0.2627281845,
0.4991427362,
-0.2997419834,
0.6325747967,
-0.6358177066,
-0.3910693228,
0.158619985,
0.0848674029,
0.2190944552,
0.4200351238,
0.3691232204,
-1.0532354116,
-0.3302130103,
-0.5195384622,
-0.5606042743,
0.3335430324,
-0.2935222387,
-0.2807281315,
-0.1127819046,
0.5043476224,
-0.8614825606,
0.3808303177,
0.510350287,
-0.2055589408,
0.8051229119,
-0.0918632075,
0.7377732396,
-1.459017992,
-0.2375890464,
-0.2979940474,
-0.0584523864,
-0.8282151818,
0.236413762,
0.2667127252,
0.151690945,
-0.6883013248,
0.2678692043,
-0.3738728762,
0.1932563186,
-0.233581081,
-0.1389428228,
0.5088957548,
0.7370688915,
-0.0996763036,
0.916572094,
0.3656118512,
-0.5708469152,
0.4766537845,
0.7335740924,
-0.0767074525,
0.3886483014,
-0.7520884871,
0.5405530334,
-0.509799242,
0.0604356341,
-1.4782639742,
0.2623842955,
0.473425597,
-0.7820061445,
0.0669029951,
-0.0340995602,
-0.4305598438,
-0.5322425365,
-0.3772283494,
0.6643007994,
0.3964624703,
-0.401360333,
1.2949754,
0.2829637527,
0.0393264778,
-0.9311408401,
-0.4833492339,
-0.0447066985,
-0.0048373621,
-0.6519161463,
0.2546710074,
-0.54826051,
0.3677921593,
-0.0703440607,
-0.0522577353,
-0.5165040493,
0.1867921054,
0.3144359291,
0.2298060805,
-0.5021772981,
0.2646107078,
0.1759147346,
-0.0955132768,
0.1991903186,
-0.2248059362,
0.603788197,
-0.118992731,
-0.3183853924,
-0.1846675873,
0.7240754366,
0.7201072574,
-0.7020840049,
0.7679837346,
0.8245080709,
-0.4516173005,
0.2310159355,
-0.2955915332,
-0.0828678831,
-0.4501510561,
0.375757724,
-0.9627138376,
-1.0207488537,
0.3956924081,
0.070448406,
0.3459029496,
0.4821260273,
0.8509346843,
-0.3647515774,
1.2705581188,
0.5202785134,
0.3086233437,
0.2671225965,
-0.225165531,
0.0353498496,
-0.7164136767,
-0.3619940281,
-0.7493727803,
-0.1164396554,
-0.250053525,
-0.5607485175,
0.3678103685,
-0.0632250533,
-0.2652933002,
0.2185023874,
-0.5429161787,
0.291231662,
0.7400875092,
0.2012017369,
0.5136469007,
-0.1757087857,
0.1027715281,
0.1380253136,
-0.6382052302,
-0.5955116749,
1.3177987337,
0.3575741053,
0.7854182124,
0.3364395797,
0.5957541466,
0.0204288419,
0.1921206564,
-1.0385707617,
0.2553717792,
-0.0575951003,
-0.7259758711,
-0.5828208923,
-0.2382982671,
-0.8740583062,
0.7739158869,
-0.6815858483,
-0.0499305651,
0.1467138529,
0.0527964011,
-0.5565330982,
0.1468961537,
-0.5751891136,
0.8350549936,
-0.0619618967,
-0.0525421612,
0.0192369353,
-0.6470811963,
0.5461286902,
-0.2576813996,
0.3394138515,
0.1706568301,
-0.1606058925,
0.5976268649,
-0.1177110747,
0.3739743233,
-0.05833387,
-0.1722146124,
0.4205539227,
-0.1959393173,
-0.0569897145,
0.1248178929,
-0.0092126811,
-0.1288123727,
0.604219377,
-0.4550341666,
-0.6166635752,
0.0792677104,
-0.9622469544,
-0.6428263783,
-0.394954145,
-0.4450930357,
-0.2893922925,
0.321415782,
0.2364860922,
0.707629025,
-0.058183942,
0.0922233239,
0.7288241386,
-0.216208443,
0.3899038136,
0.5463297963,
-0.2434581369,
-0.6339234114,
0.5477694869,
-0.1038477123,
0.3144825399,
0.6314478517,
0.0515402704,
-0.4558403194,
-0.4866595864,
-0.6115425825,
0.0693620145,
-0.9170287251,
-0.3087923825,
-1.057890296,
-0.3633773923,
-0.3969903588,
0.3819114566,
-0.2842262387,
-0.2642405927,
-0.242615819,
0.1408071965,
0.0615125746,
0.504424572,
0.3609682918,
0.4889034629,
-1.2989971638,
0.9428684711,
0.6986830235,
0.0848464966,
-0.2383923084,
-0.71901685,
-0.3108846247,
0.2760808766,
-0.5753937364,
-1.0383330584,
0.2387122512,
0.302577734,
0.4291554689,
-0.1127386242,
0.2219646871,
0.5772765279,
-0.7161842585,
0.8274435997,
0.1754581481,
-0.8786634207,
0.1516052186,
0.1112771332,
0.69662112,
0.6237815619,
0.6603578329,
-0.5802901983,
-0.2666568458,
-0.166425243,
-0.5273785591,
0.4437027574,
-0.0134233702,
0.4763504565,
0.2806591392,
0.224656865,
0.1271948814,
0.3494047523,
-0.6777098775,
-0.4891223013,
-0.5367004275,
-0.2143812776,
-0.0582365021,
-0.6051971316,
-0.0048701786,
-0.2615528107,
0.5699386001,
-0.2762309909,
0.634555161,
0.3859417439,
-0.3145605028,
-0.0116684251,
0.4887440205,
0.6938747168,
0.5147666931,
-0.136820972,
0.2257682085,
0.1747953892,
-0.7404628992,
0.4901143312,
-0.1146831363,
-0.154008165,
0.1547770202,
-0.0225628372,
0.5749822259,
-0.258209914,
-0.4473205507,
0.5972114801,
-0.726137042,
-0.845402956,
-0.5022538304,
-0.1745114177,
0.0740943924,
0.2064195573,
0.5414729118,
0.2601299286,
0.3441207111,
-0.5013660789,
0.4899992347,
0.14072299,
-0.5886435509,
-0.1114521921,
0.6863393188,
-0.0596920699,
-0.1482091695,
0.5262684822,
0.059176378,
-0.7546845675,
0.6768965125,
0.3266814351,
0.6215327382,
-0.3835714757,
0.4083496928,
0.5390975475,
0.5880227685,
0.0880261809,
0.9432886839,
0.1404828131,
-0.9884326458,
-0.4781650901,
-0.4347713292,
-0.5700220466,
0.0992830396,
-0.780754745,
0.2500792742,
-0.2357815504,
-0.2083290368,
0.032430388,
-0.1017506272,
-0.7278484702,
0.5389276147,
-0.026694579,
0.8868438601,
-0.6252015829,
0.9002095461,
0.6320531964,
-0.5405347347,
-0.7496485114,
-0.0593871363,
-0.2506305873,
-0.7802475691,
0.1103672758,
0.229279235,
-0.2992582321,
0.2436412424,
-0.4781330824,
-0.9228260517,
1.1361137629,
0.1079754606,
-0.1657362729,
0.0187943112,
0.2378670424,
0.2100204676,
-0.350668788,
0.6804459691,
0.4303411841,
0.3595008254,
0.1578783095,
-0.7142708898,
0.054770764,
-0.3581982851,
-0.4541210532,
0.3227589726,
-0.6520135403,
1.0708452463,
-0.3223285973,
-0.2813334465,
0.2499821931,
0.5621656775,
0.0843610093,
0.2393695861,
0.5414711237,
0.2504275143,
0.5153493881,
-0.0601980388,
0.7876560092,
-0.3097489476,
0.2736501098,
1.2004015446,
0.0965283141,
1.0813075304,
0.6403182745,
-0.0914896578,
0.3627085686,
0.5355980396,
0.0078393724,
0.3940418661,
0.0889199972,
-0.2107078731,
-0.4590771794,
0.0812115222,
-0.3578802347,
0.7766640782,
0.1560453624,
-0.0548281819,
0.0287694242,
0.1793947816,
-0.390969187,
0.1242968664,
-0.27915591,
0.828786552,
0.0463060476,
-0.4246388674,
0.6118505597,
0.1884878725,
0.6749287248,
-0.4805344641,
-0.135710746,
-0.0777021125,
-0.2189144343,
-0.1102015972,
-0.8053008914,
0.2907045484,
-0.3522498608,
-0.5442982316,
-0.291456461,
0.6690324545,
-0.7090867162,
-0.384352237,
-0.0856954157,
0.9477834105,
-0.162482515,
-0.3290162683,
-0.7467841506,
-0.3593674898,
-0.2197921872,
-0.2162819952,
-0.0191265363,
0.3426911533,
0.2808596194,
0.6415976882,
0.479321152,
-0.6225878596,
0.4438963532,
0.0393180288,
0.9006212354,
-0.7704126239,
-0.3515222371,
-0.6129283309,
0.7573103309,
0.2765683234,
-0.2896578908,
0.6888152957,
0.43548733,
0.6308248043,
-0.3415603042,
0.7165588737,
0.2820117176,
0.4830858409,
-0.7003015876,
0.5614778996,
-0.8961979151,
-0.040590547,
-0.1399511844,
-0.8253750801,
0.0103563126,
0.2218096852,
0.0935577601,
-0.0838797912,
0.8462554216,
0.764724195,
0.3048080206,
0.0648525432,
0.4550690353,
-0.3183116019,
0.3182542324,
1.0410153866,
1.4023276567,
-1.1306083202,
0.9626431465,
-0.1630903482,
0.0124644348,
0.1465852112,
-0.489376694,
-0.7658184767,
-0.8534575701,
-0.285412997,
-0.290997535,
-0.5131270289,
0.5615878701,
0.4992959499,
-0.6609361768,
0.0390706584,
0.615386188,
0.2517622709,
-0.2445574403,
-0.1302323043,
0.0966421813,
-0.0874341056,
-0.5888687372,
0.1914447248,
0.1160803661,
0.0940072164,
-0.1270321608,
-0.0156992972,
-0.2722142339,
0.4186809361,
0.7584459186,
-0.0354911797,
-0.4241702557,
-0.3189402819,
0.6120363474,
-0.3565933406,
0.458848536,
0.7445836067,
-0.7473501563,
0.6012112498,
0.5597848296,
0.8499366045,
0.5677400231,
0.1927250773,
0.5088867545,
-0.469661355,
-0.2011506259,
0.2351953387,
0.1456450224,
-0.0389216319,
-0.3484640718,
0.0143921254,
-0.1335723698,
-0.4407462776,
-0.4830903411,
0.4663396776,
-1.0492351055,
-0.4237162471,
0.8776577115,
0.0708517358,
-0.1770404428,
-0.4233276546,
-0.5535526872,
0.1148049757,
-0.1915089786,
0.5608468652,
0.680431962,
0.098183997,
-0.7882297039,
-0.6035780311,
0.3424189985,
0.3883886039,
-0.9771361351,
-0.3835964203,
0.474653393,
0.0689679012,
0.1711528003,
1.01242733,
-0.2280692309,
0.5533108711,
-0.0121635236,
0.1334061772,
-0.2644969523,
-0.4245965779,
-0.6429988742,
0.5674113035,
0.0626669005,
-0.7038645744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08620v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08620v1
|
Toucan: Token-Aware Character Level Language Modeling
| 2023-11-15T00:57:51 | 2023-11-15T00:57:51 |
William Fleshman, Benjamin Van Durme
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Character-level language models obviate the need for separately trained
tokenizers, but efficiency suffers from longer sequence lengths. Learning to
combine character representations into tokens has made training these models
more efficient, but they still require decoding characters individually. We
propose Toucan, an augmentation to character-level models to make them
"token-aware". Comparing our method to prior work, we demonstrate significant
speed-ups in character generation without a loss in language modeling
performance. We then explore differences between our learned dynamic
tokenization of character sequences with popular fixed vocabulary solutions
such as Byte-Pair Encoding and WordPiece, finding our approach leads to a
greater amount of longer sequences tokenized as single items. Our project and
code are available at https://nlp.jhu.edu/nuggets/.
|
[
0.0815925002,
-0.6012337804,
0.0528924428,
0.276699096,
-0.2589048743,
0.5193904042,
-0.2546344697,
-0.6565766931,
0.3873561025,
0.5928167701,
-0.3805447221,
-0.6245743632,
-0.3991706073,
0.2846780419,
-0.6766565442,
0.7444478869,
0.254896909,
0.0396729,
-0.0774357393,
0.0567753129,
-0.4248670638,
-0.6796146631,
-1.0564044714,
-0.0460300036,
0.8655125499,
0.492697984,
0.5760577917,
1.1535345316,
0.4470775425,
0.3695047498,
-0.2447428852,
-0.0414123014,
-0.484002918,
0.1955773532,
-0.0610080659,
-0.5963695645,
-0.6137215495,
-0.5012288094,
0.8196856976,
0.9646148682,
0.1280689538,
-0.0924082547,
-0.2933349907,
0.3368619084,
-0.3890371919,
0.1189800501,
-0.3771130443,
0.2547506392,
-0.4604828656,
-0.0578236543,
-0.578701973,
-0.1238311604,
-0.1976075172,
-0.7626258731,
0.3410260975,
0.2673698664,
0.4728165567,
0.0506393723,
-0.5061397552,
-0.2688176334,
-0.6008468866,
0.5002347827,
-0.8503589034,
0.3358711302,
0.1185080633,
0.1084619984,
-0.1545384377,
-1.029160738,
-0.6926575303,
-0.4742362797,
-0.1159308702,
0.0364564285,
0.3681932688,
0.4120085239,
0.4969790876,
0.5947455764,
-0.411798656,
0.4707719982,
-0.2793391347,
-0.2005209029,
0.5471531749,
0.2290357053,
0.580607295,
-0.3475121856,
-0.3343238235,
-0.1195286959,
-0.5154783726,
0.4572665989,
0.5996539593,
0.6095431447,
0.3249011338,
0.6745960116,
0.0608459376,
0.3550951183,
0.1464339197,
0.0882735401,
0.0707583576,
-0.3654748797,
-0.0331116877,
0.3226726949,
0.5024875998,
-0.207688719,
0.0728688315,
-0.3109538257,
-0.3880476356,
-0.0130271437,
0.107999675,
-1.0943104029,
-0.2294203639,
0.2019876689,
-0.41745314,
-0.5429366827,
0.2111670524,
-0.6479794979,
-0.5383426547,
-0.0057264064,
0.223729521,
-0.543166101,
-0.3906019926,
0.1898257881,
-0.3777255416,
-0.0547965318,
0.1428483725,
-1.1542280912,
0.3380105197,
0.9353138208,
0.7060804963,
-0.2231133431,
-0.4193548262,
-0.6226699352,
-0.0240334105,
-0.7299140692,
0.525018692,
-0.6824379563,
-0.7745666504,
-0.0004599356,
0.0641458631,
0.101827085,
-0.3716048002,
0.4389092624,
-0.4587756991,
0.1094358861,
-0.5131839514,
-0.8042503595,
-0.0652923658,
0.0643898919,
-0.8300431371,
1.1523388624,
0.3520927727,
-0.6419885755,
0.5001399517,
-0.8131304979,
-0.8911305666,
0.4140978754,
0.1672494113,
-0.0956282988,
0.4452471137,
0.2695777416,
0.2710323632,
0.1324988455,
0.1366750002,
-0.1498941481,
-0.4690143168,
0.2712084651,
-0.4715934992,
0.8579279184,
0.0199766308,
-0.0286993645,
0.5122086406,
-0.9795716405,
-0.2995660603,
0.2443652749,
-0.5816762447,
-0.4457488954,
-0.0513259396,
-0.0224924814,
0.1197712645,
0.428653419,
-0.4519812167,
0.3633733094,
-0.6055730581,
0.5796357989,
0.6575442553,
-0.1807984561,
0.415327549,
-0.1448838413,
0.4826299548,
0.1617481261,
0.1161343902,
-0.7607463598,
-0.1929977685,
-1.3317676783,
-0.4170826375,
0.5800531507,
0.4730280638,
-0.9632645249,
0.5604409575,
-0.3150832355,
-0.1132037789,
-0.3847070336,
-0.2568932772,
0.3592444658,
0.6193460226,
0.3328686953,
-0.763703227,
-0.3464964628,
-0.3320375383,
-0.2642219663,
-0.3363547325,
-0.010168938,
-0.0513320491,
0.4851680398,
0.0669760555,
0.5871170759,
-0.0372733511,
0.0660397038,
-0.4046577215,
-0.0557656325,
-0.0643489137,
0.6311852932,
0.6074909568,
-0.3880898654,
-0.3896878064,
0.0748764426,
-0.4044242799,
0.1190595329,
-0.0706497133,
0.0868809149,
-0.082856901,
0.6981625557,
-0.1646600664,
0.3935230076,
0.3211011887,
-0.5937037468,
0.3245494664,
-0.4616294205,
0.1575282216,
-1.4142079353,
0.1267724782,
-0.2963157892,
-0.5237590075,
-1.0435941219,
0.2480743676,
0.2471714169,
-0.5491364002,
-0.4303483367,
0.694666326,
-0.5359646082,
-0.3461915851,
-0.2426570654,
0.125036642,
0.2829715908,
0.5924346447,
-0.0166894291,
1.1277065277,
0.5139048696,
-0.4577184916,
0.713472724,
0.245580107,
-0.4048400819,
0.3522218168,
-0.6852511168,
0.0683016852,
-0.1384511888,
0.1876216978,
-0.9061619639,
-0.2204606235,
0.2184324861,
-0.387150526,
0.7814844847,
-0.1667653322,
-0.5183377266,
-0.5921405554,
-0.3401860595,
0.7301813364,
0.2491459697,
-0.8585615754,
0.305034101,
0.1570491642,
-0.2565190196,
-0.6072583795,
-0.71401757,
0.3161354363,
-0.1332120299,
-0.4726529717,
0.4303772449,
-0.1560568959,
0.2192548215,
-0.1686309725,
0.0068696169,
-0.1089583039,
0.1551172584,
-0.0441638418,
0.064184919,
-0.3923074901,
0.4580464959,
0.252460897,
-0.1301840097,
-0.1555413306,
-0.5875954628,
0.5463359356,
0.0187078379,
-0.4343464971,
-0.4790554643,
0.4484353662,
0.5731303692,
-0.621697247,
0.8240529895,
0.3333031237,
-0.5240285397,
-0.0868228972,
-0.1595336348,
-0.195530355,
-0.5197392702,
0.6594395041,
-0.4340490699,
-1.0192104578,
0.8021510243,
-0.1031004936,
0.1290462762,
0.466689527,
0.1214648411,
0.1837671548,
0.9731395841,
0.6959921122,
-0.1203633174,
1.0083332062,
-0.1025803089,
0.2204563618,
-0.6436169147,
-0.4058311284,
-0.624625504,
-0.1592592746,
-0.5548333526,
-0.5986332297,
-0.1568187773,
0.1241024062,
-0.1747500002,
0.5121216178,
-0.377574414,
0.552223146,
0.3280860782,
0.0511408597,
0.2860881984,
-0.0135943349,
-0.2393909097,
0.2994398177,
-0.8467159271,
-0.1068923026,
0.8815922737,
0.4171636105,
0.4413881302,
-0.1614753753,
0.5814937353,
0.2945792377,
-0.0816132426,
-0.8679859638,
0.6781731248,
-0.5458912849,
-0.6552233696,
-0.5208708644,
-0.4402217567,
-0.8133769631,
-0.1063716188,
-0.2920886576,
-0.6905229092,
0.2827040851,
0.0519592687,
-0.3569233119,
0.3130021095,
-0.3743513823,
0.8124200106,
-0.4417717159,
-0.1507696211,
-0.2467954457,
-0.5834733844,
0.2956335247,
0.0145944552,
-0.1037181392,
-0.1292824149,
-0.0836834237,
0.6313090324,
-0.9190379381,
0.6639768481,
0.0473158658,
-0.126939252,
0.2789107859,
-0.0223426968,
0.6729820371,
0.1823386252,
-0.2987753451,
0.1093000993,
-0.0914396271,
-0.685086906,
-0.5926764607,
0.6536903977,
-0.5440304279,
-0.5310701728,
-0.2262873799,
-0.4227391481,
0.1597635001,
0.2720140517,
0.1877941936,
0.7874869704,
-0.2628829479,
0.0929959267,
0.6809948087,
-0.2788640261,
0.5701088309,
0.1370286644,
-0.5639907122,
-0.5541386604,
1.0871639252,
0.0277851894,
0.1353417188,
0.6844875813,
0.1661304086,
-0.1838273108,
-0.4888980985,
-0.5875034332,
0.1488074064,
-0.6390227675,
0.0415054411,
-0.528621614,
-0.3891132176,
-0.4479954541,
-0.0764965862,
-0.497815311,
-0.878492415,
-0.3983914256,
-0.2785446346,
0.4455088973,
0.5695111752,
0.1450459361,
0.6058081985,
-0.5739484429,
0.1278421432,
0.3517834246,
0.3943821788,
0.1794354618,
-0.5318690538,
-0.448974818,
-0.0439333767,
0.1417546272,
-0.7404708266,
0.2082447857,
0.2167170644,
0.258797586,
0.7066441774,
-0.0529487804,
0.7474508882,
-0.4848648012,
0.9832414985,
0.3728885055,
-1.2622077465,
0.293135643,
-0.1739717722,
0.0935270116,
0.3758757114,
-0.0080805169,
-0.990752995,
-0.23026447,
-0.3113470078,
-0.8657531738,
0.6650224924,
0.1514373124,
0.4249492586,
-0.1610858142,
0.5137859583,
0.311771661,
0.374920696,
-0.3996991217,
-0.1650048196,
-0.5365796089,
-0.2224396467,
-0.1242168322,
-0.4551382065,
0.3042289317,
-0.4802162945,
0.4891074002,
-0.0987704024,
0.3666652739,
-0.216901511,
-0.2953231633,
-0.0181331187,
0.0382843912,
0.749012351,
0.3165977895,
0.1982272714,
-0.0108096758,
0.4057910144,
-0.4193100929,
-0.0652476624,
0.162625879,
0.0105874464,
-0.0575043596,
0.4994729757,
1.2040406466,
0.2702446282,
-0.4201516807,
0.54137218,
-0.2473077178,
0.0398764908,
-0.0266837385,
0.2533517182,
0.0127365934,
0.1801114529,
0.0349970013,
-0.1692411155,
-0.0190914981,
-0.7119423747,
0.0917514563,
0.150324598,
-0.4476536214,
-0.5137985349,
0.6598476171,
0.5716058016,
-0.6401703954,
0.9055404067,
0.0686829165,
-0.6000192761,
0.7419058084,
0.7720463276,
0.7147889137,
-0.3689330816,
0.0944296345,
0.3327722251,
0.0630347282,
-0.1248616055,
0.0756343901,
-0.0928078741,
-0.5787652731,
-0.2304715514,
-0.5211539268,
-0.2526427209,
0.0672971755,
-0.3444654942,
0.4469257891,
-0.6318004727,
-0.2297233343,
-0.1586339772,
0.1446696222,
-0.3965775073,
0.2165231854,
-0.103920579,
1.1077727079,
-0.4720087945,
0.7752258182,
0.45457986,
-0.5395228863,
-0.7963744998,
-0.03763346,
-0.5135660768,
-0.649269104,
0.1914780587,
0.295632422,
0.2634547055,
0.2706195414,
-0.1465375721,
-0.7286043167,
0.9808000922,
0.3127670586,
-0.6110248566,
-0.5761186481,
0.3797839582,
0.5628522038,
-0.4518710077,
0.2411848158,
0.4303682745,
0.3732178211,
0.1307753325,
-0.459872067,
-0.0300092958,
-0.2854894698,
0.4422692955,
0.3011563122,
-0.6137545109,
0.8096031547,
-0.1878612638,
-0.3149413764,
0.4358838201,
1.017696619,
-0.222593084,
0.242675975,
0.2710544169,
0.2945267558,
1.0854249001,
-0.0505768396,
0.7725984454,
-0.6363229156,
0.0749026313,
0.91337955,
-0.0836205855,
0.5891349912,
0.2125922441,
0.0754057318,
0.5027603507,
0.8318900466,
0.0679405332,
0.2658866644,
0.4009135365,
-0.4774822891,
-0.205491364,
-0.1961840093,
-0.3831008375,
0.2084852755,
0.3808718622,
-0.3587143421,
0.1488592178,
0.2539429367,
-0.0570854098,
0.032633476,
-0.4387069643,
0.7074919343,
0.0715137646,
-0.3682494462,
0.3572052717,
0.1595868915,
0.5890797973,
-0.5548178554,
0.2675873339,
-0.4292345047,
0.0075643305,
-0.0110375751,
-0.3891613781,
0.0207489859,
0.1336511225,
-0.1513367593,
-0.1482170373,
0.8200554252,
-0.7305725217,
-0.7700597644,
0.136360839,
0.1606910676,
0.1635274738,
0.2866326272,
-0.4624605179,
-0.0825575218,
-0.3280815184,
-0.1072692052,
0.1957774758,
0.7201381326,
-0.2807901502,
0.5090686679,
0.6988684535,
-0.0094909659,
0.2750447094,
0.2738301456,
0.853243649,
-0.6317206621,
-0.4800648987,
-0.6540625691,
0.5931082368,
-0.1732995808,
-0.2639832497,
0.4683098495,
0.6594388485,
0.8435516357,
-0.0353228301,
0.6412646174,
0.2823830545,
0.2807701528,
-0.3292975724,
0.8559036851,
-0.6084647775,
0.0916211903,
-0.1115627363,
-0.8527525067,
-0.2864737511,
0.4413500726,
0.1446622908,
0.21355775,
0.6427234411,
0.7371190786,
-0.0468122922,
-0.0232267249,
0.6665976644,
-0.1846613884,
0.438982904,
0.4446185231,
0.7960894108,
-0.4727822244,
0.280726254,
-0.1926996559,
0.0142632397,
-0.4856130183,
-0.9577885866,
-1.2027004957,
-0.6185333729,
-0.1788783222,
-0.2452525049,
0.2946952283,
0.9592878819,
0.5897496939,
-0.7601484656,
-0.2903114855,
-0.3977169693,
0.2981449068,
-0.197599262,
-0.1195356771,
0.1883738637,
-0.4628071189,
-0.9394569993,
0.5615355968,
0.3672367632,
0.2175489515,
-0.1145143807,
-0.0882650316,
0.2006526142,
0.5270712972,
0.6011887193,
0.4159636497,
-0.5124239326,
-0.4204047918,
0.3107624054,
-0.2067785114,
0.3276563585,
1.1939278841,
-0.6263230443,
0.5860449672,
0.7201195955,
0.6138510108,
0.5297728777,
-0.0682224333,
0.6123669744,
-0.8684440851,
0.2731854022,
0.1606978923,
0.306029439,
0.5144589543,
-0.365367204,
0.0124897305,
0.2796686292,
-0.2330761552,
-0.7406091094,
0.464228034,
-0.744497776,
-0.2026000321,
0.7985143065,
-0.367705971,
-0.3300849497,
0.2469184399,
-0.2274270058,
0.8923175335,
-0.478516072,
0.6095781922,
0.5634279847,
0.3518765569,
-0.247689411,
0.0917200744,
0.4829318821,
0.1631736904,
-0.919545114,
0.1745527536,
0.2108285874,
0.1977192312,
0.1462138444,
0.2684128881,
0.0563886575,
0.0857827142,
0.167664513,
0.0578036569,
-0.5057198405,
-0.7234938145,
-0.3212503791,
0.0330740213,
0.3349414468,
-0.0173574928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10763v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10763v1
|
Comparing Generalization in Learning with Limited Numbers of Exemplars: Transformer vs. RNN in Attractor Dynamics
| 2023-11-15T00:37:49 | 2023-11-15T00:37:49 |
Rui Fukushima, Jun Tani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
ChatGPT, a widely-recognized large language model (LLM), has recently gained
substantial attention for its performance scaling, attributed to the billions
of web-sourced natural language sentences used for training. Its underlying
architecture, Transformer, has found applications across diverse fields,
including video, audio signals, and robotic movement. %The crucial question
this raises concerns the Transformer's generalization-in-learning (GIL)
capacity. However, this raises a crucial question about Transformer's
generalization in learning (GIL) capacity. Is ChatGPT's success chiefly due to
the vast dataset used for training, or is there more to the story? To
investigate this, we compared Transformer's GIL capabilities with those of a
traditional Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) in tasks involving attractor
dynamics learning. For performance evaluation, the Dynamic Time Warping (DTW)
method has been employed. Our simulation results suggest that under conditions
of limited data availability, Transformer's GIL abilities are markedly inferior
to those of RNN.
|
[
-0.1474558562,
-0.6577680111,
0.0073945122,
0.177491203,
-0.1760881096,
0.2590186,
-0.4011255205,
-0.4054189026,
0.0191855095,
0.1454817504,
-0.5547373295,
0.0229665805,
-0.8263292313,
0.1653569192,
-0.7298409343,
1.2834851742,
-0.0299689192,
-0.2688805163,
-0.0481040552,
-0.112064518,
-0.2426249832,
-0.2655132711,
-0.8659890294,
-0.6080383062,
0.4965378344,
-0.1519704014,
0.7358070612,
0.5487380624,
0.8459657431,
0.368116051,
-0.3336554766,
0.0482452586,
-0.8395050168,
0.3463868499,
0.1355188489,
-0.6231274009,
0.0011013547,
-0.1383756548,
0.7925001979,
0.5557358265,
-0.2504933774,
0.1598855108,
0.1265838295,
0.6466213465,
-0.2041493356,
0.4671637714,
-0.6807457209,
0.5335093141,
0.0284313876,
0.0750071183,
-0.293279469,
-0.5143586397,
0.7156250477,
-0.7280691862,
0.6922959089,
0.0488806255,
0.8828111291,
0.5312619805,
-0.3694514036,
-0.1668103486,
-1.2256352901,
0.8125438094,
-0.365817517,
0.418065995,
-0.2558406889,
0.5706087947,
-0.1200746149,
-0.8339029551,
-0.4778243601,
-0.3855236769,
0.1072352827,
0.2668493688,
-0.4951991439,
-0.1190053374,
0.7167746425,
0.5503646731,
-0.7830417752,
0.0447686501,
-0.4062129855,
0.114194721,
0.3365743756,
0.2073057443,
0.0896269977,
0.1805935502,
-0.3059896529,
-0.5998364091,
-0.4597810209,
0.1313275248,
0.3697519898,
0.2193933427,
-0.1184852347,
0.4404453933,
0.1397194266,
0.4874640405,
0.1658343375,
0.1419944018,
0.2466476411,
-0.0323291533,
-0.2366196066,
-0.2575704753,
1.040844202,
0.0023039591,
0.4320726097,
-0.6321748495,
0.0328384228,
0.1375286579,
0.3812385499,
-0.7508022189,
-0.2541907728,
0.0267246682,
-0.2998322248,
-0.2240715176,
0.1200617477,
-1.0134829283,
-0.4330599904,
-0.0520283133,
0.2698865831,
-0.4542966187,
-0.3230687976,
-0.0183763281,
-0.3263276517,
0.5898239613,
0.1046883985,
-0.9683922529,
0.3017043471,
0.5770826936,
1.0154610872,
-0.6348211765,
-0.2650040388,
-0.424067378,
-0.0852721408,
-0.2177117616,
0.7192875743,
-0.6385421157,
-0.3956235647,
-0.028376285,
-0.110159725,
-0.4883185029,
-0.7185599208,
0.2641351819,
-0.725554049,
0.2808916271,
0.1167130768,
-0.4854137301,
-0.1198360398,
-0.0043958691,
-0.8405088186,
0.8685581088,
0.2429229617,
-0.4738744795,
0.5660625696,
-0.7594940066,
-0.3337465227,
-0.1054485738,
-0.2542058229,
-0.8350924253,
0.1762690246,
-0.0070683197,
0.3130906224,
-0.0407220572,
0.2655000687,
-0.1392110884,
-0.5645722747,
0.4111069143,
-0.6898356676,
0.2316648513,
0.2912667692,
-0.4863286912,
-0.0704930499,
-0.7753820419,
-0.1949345917,
0.3800123334,
-0.5868350863,
0.1077351719,
0.217549637,
-0.1071735546,
0.1257885396,
-0.1488974988,
-0.5515008569,
0.3706447482,
-0.6830965281,
0.4131359756,
0.5134714842,
-0.1769330949,
0.439509213,
-0.408872515,
0.7768690586,
0.0293616112,
-0.0362370871,
-0.2484195977,
-0.5439389944,
-0.9031894803,
0.1171095222,
0.1369545311,
0.4683600366,
-0.5862368941,
-0.0203593858,
-0.7711696625,
-0.2754648626,
-0.2717404962,
0.0181939173,
0.101192303,
0.1213494465,
0.4520546496,
0.0263486877,
-0.537201941,
-0.5838315487,
-0.3296019137,
0.0137479864,
-0.236905992,
0.3023447394,
0.2403942794,
-0.1714275181,
0.883030355,
-0.1925078332,
-0.249925524,
-0.5662842989,
0.1243027672,
0.5383145809,
0.1036011055,
0.6622985601,
-0.6866195202,
-0.4678109288,
0.276568532,
-0.8560698628,
0.2452397794,
-0.2886422873,
0.2761197686,
0.1950342208,
0.2330895513,
-0.6540591717,
0.4190745652,
0.7133315802,
0.0128726913,
0.1411893964,
-0.2079608291,
-0.0652235374,
-0.8840759397,
-0.1194209084,
0.0623756722,
-0.0077429949,
-0.733252883,
-0.0693134442,
-0.0836003646,
-0.4347078204,
-0.3292206526,
0.2596436739,
-0.3741698563,
0.0810994655,
-0.2844780684,
0.16903238,
-0.4739870727,
0.7244285345,
0.0193921011,
0.7656366229,
0.3662438989,
-0.5991076827,
0.4795363843,
0.0672062263,
-0.2632156909,
0.0161129199,
-0.8052285314,
0.2677675486,
-0.201338619,
0.1969612092,
-0.9327870607,
-0.1443459839,
0.1112448126,
-0.2426907271,
0.5432292819,
-0.271630466,
-0.2255909592,
-0.7052342296,
-0.099892512,
0.3815024793,
0.7950232029,
-0.5477292538,
0.7169762254,
-0.0431976803,
0.2315963358,
-0.7572801113,
-0.6127516627,
-0.0068858224,
-0.3859559298,
-0.3977656662,
0.0855957344,
0.0601597689,
-0.0059885136,
-0.1105921268,
-0.3881122172,
0.2592557967,
0.015609731,
0.3579815328,
0.1289038956,
-0.2565131485,
0.1287858337,
-0.1939327121,
-0.2692303956,
0.0860492215,
-0.4303336442,
0.6813840866,
-0.2951495349,
-0.5767718554,
-0.2617016733,
-0.0629427955,
0.5501866937,
0.0008036594,
0.8635254502,
0.6558526754,
0.1211453974,
-0.3749555647,
-0.3582988083,
-0.017539626,
-0.4687744677,
0.6024938822,
-0.1541084945,
-1.0291502476,
0.5493304133,
-0.0380831696,
0.1926892847,
0.6039505005,
0.3681033552,
0.0971820503,
0.7215390801,
0.5616558194,
-0.2317291349,
0.7922416329,
-0.6485940218,
0.2579293251,
-0.5979173183,
-0.2659495771,
-0.2487212867,
-0.6635821462,
-0.9103537202,
-0.266523838,
0.3205056787,
-0.5639920831,
-0.3196377754,
0.5478273034,
-0.5340783596,
0.3879018724,
0.3686593771,
0.0283915158,
0.2412009537,
0.3998605907,
0.0495991297,
-0.0106454538,
-0.956012845,
-0.3060674667,
1.141248703,
0.3517677486,
1.0203319788,
0.2218755931,
0.3445964754,
0.0704511032,
0.2710146606,
-0.8149397373,
0.5384979248,
-0.3149363101,
-0.280942291,
-0.4537390471,
-0.757576108,
-1.5283433199,
0.44378528,
-0.2449936718,
-0.6247140765,
0.039260786,
0.1286572069,
-0.1943777949,
0.7614498138,
-0.6681360602,
0.5326570868,
-0.0616284162,
-0.1035443768,
-0.1621975154,
-0.4489723146,
-0.0793954059,
-0.1001288593,
-0.2560650706,
0.0135779288,
0.0349075645,
0.7419917583,
-0.0737814978,
0.7732724547,
-0.0669367984,
-0.0542470217,
0.2865545452,
0.0684813187,
0.6492887735,
-0.2254889458,
0.0039033503,
0.0879951194,
-0.3192629516,
-0.1786412299,
-0.836986661,
0.4845859408,
-1.026315093,
-0.5218307972,
-0.4451787174,
-0.5949029326,
-0.1851985902,
-0.1434253305,
0.4250496328,
0.4704401791,
-0.312240988,
0.4306551516,
0.8417795897,
-0.2131311446,
0.6012932062,
0.3159074783,
-0.3689365387,
-0.0549624003,
1.0789386034,
0.3228231966,
0.3275681436,
0.665590167,
0.2017293721,
-0.0997732952,
-0.4646101892,
-0.2022636831,
0.2352437973,
-0.228835389,
-0.0127778035,
-0.7568634152,
-0.4338716269,
0.0227844678,
0.1933801025,
-0.4019173682,
-0.3532727659,
-0.0131975198,
-0.0221930724,
0.4119060934,
0.8902962208,
0.17011787,
0.41054371,
-0.3476831317,
0.1364426613,
0.722237587,
0.4672107399,
0.1612476856,
-0.8650925756,
-0.2434611619,
0.0833353102,
-0.560736239,
-0.6173670888,
0.1540237367,
0.4480974376,
0.6560522914,
0.6293836236,
-0.2822164297,
0.4570078254,
-0.5271071196,
0.7316544652,
0.1047681496,
-0.4398831129,
0.5137194991,
-0.5205565095,
0.4658593535,
-0.0054607126,
0.3719910979,
-0.6372565627,
-0.6587643027,
-0.7447671294,
-0.7599788904,
0.5891423821,
0.3617007434,
0.4771441519,
0.0557934418,
0.3573221862,
0.1782947481,
0.1241585836,
-0.7404108644,
-0.3362239897,
-0.3905432522,
-0.0070762015,
-0.19037278,
-0.1153578833,
0.1703977287,
-0.014578904,
0.3078299761,
-0.0542488508,
0.7715549469,
-0.085379757,
-0.0736848041,
-0.1902370453,
0.2780979872,
0.4675258398,
0.4720274508,
-0.1036015972,
0.0069145737,
0.5652922988,
-0.7926732302,
0.2771632373,
0.0652719811,
-0.0341989398,
0.0683635995,
0.4388489425,
1.1561789513,
0.3069244921,
-0.4438556135,
0.4202322066,
-0.1435420066,
-0.1722191423,
-0.2631539702,
0.5370876193,
-0.1767718494,
0.4498496354,
0.5413154364,
0.212521553,
-0.2541383207,
-0.1411009729,
-0.0288474094,
0.3713640869,
-0.4501431286,
-0.4226905107,
0.7792600989,
-0.1222314388,
-0.402782768,
0.8770599365,
0.0193649642,
-0.2271855474,
0.8459098339,
0.6257919073,
0.8904607296,
-0.1694443077,
0.0516483858,
0.4275586903,
0.25441131,
-0.186846301,
-0.1983543336,
-0.0504882559,
-0.6838011146,
-0.5525554419,
-0.288523227,
-0.5086275935,
0.1785253882,
-0.6949489713,
-0.003857408,
-0.2746912539,
-0.2977992296,
-0.227782473,
-0.1023421958,
-0.8492788672,
-0.1783585399,
-0.0121529195,
0.8015872836,
-0.5552284122,
0.4834500849,
0.7955858111,
-0.1703533679,
-0.6976256967,
0.1391465664,
-0.1666307747,
-0.7930678725,
0.6722840667,
0.2082670182,
-0.2375828177,
-0.1079783142,
-0.6078444123,
-0.8221191168,
1.2780708075,
0.4525083005,
-0.6785181165,
-0.0418401547,
0.3197889924,
1.0130286217,
-0.0164229069,
0.3753414452,
0.3175579607,
0.0369031839,
0.1942990124,
-0.8864135146,
-0.4196601212,
-0.2107277811,
0.221003145,
0.2993244231,
-0.934001565,
0.5831906796,
-0.3197485507,
-0.5211824775,
-0.0698440373,
0.8427215219,
-0.0243748035,
-0.0013485551,
0.3911358118,
0.4583472013,
0.6529302001,
-0.3683125079,
1.1570256948,
-0.0260902587,
0.7140079737,
0.9249590635,
-0.0541575998,
0.6624816656,
0.2263770998,
-0.7957696915,
0.5529483557,
0.3088738322,
-0.3251687586,
0.3794498444,
0.3988151252,
-0.2472217828,
-0.0952877998,
0.3363215029,
-0.4518229365,
0.3984180987,
0.1604330987,
-0.2362346947,
-0.4113967717,
0.185245961,
-0.1299749911,
-0.1844912469,
-0.1364195198,
0.7924832106,
0.0187748317,
-0.4244785905,
0.3404051065,
-0.5554996729,
0.6637252569,
-0.7579228282,
0.1697186977,
-0.4229853451,
0.30877316,
0.006495296,
-0.8002668619,
0.2940880954,
0.0155486111,
-0.0515262149,
-0.0619366094,
0.5382187963,
-0.379627496,
-0.3836425543,
0.3260935247,
0.5415359139,
0.2105330527,
0.2028067559,
-0.4058346152,
-0.1688930541,
-0.1695450842,
-0.5075647235,
0.5351818204,
0.3901439607,
0.2763346434,
1.3376910686,
0.3574157357,
-0.0008934409,
0.4056721926,
0.1554797739,
0.870408237,
-0.3842619061,
-0.1532913893,
-0.9011643529,
0.0159769915,
0.0272115748,
-0.2316326797,
0.8603226542,
0.513859868,
0.857471168,
-0.197132647,
0.6811496615,
-0.0297442339,
0.3261848688,
-0.2509056926,
0.4935899973,
-0.2785306275,
0.1955491155,
-0.161660254,
-0.988953054,
-0.313690275,
0.7241725922,
-0.3935295641,
0.299543947,
0.5681174994,
0.6767455935,
-0.2679314613,
0.29070279,
0.4076314867,
0.2172068954,
0.275151521,
0.768042624,
1.1018538475,
-0.5339415073,
0.9834048152,
0.0862411782,
-0.0361277722,
0.0400942229,
-0.7208202481,
-1.0528399944,
-0.5186284184,
-0.3103232682,
-0.330060184,
0.1261727959,
1.0266782045,
0.5222827792,
-0.8663852811,
-0.2861976624,
-0.0904394463,
0.0526306704,
-0.4758701921,
-0.1902922988,
0.2498104274,
-0.5279957652,
-0.7135527134,
0.2251974493,
0.0697295889,
0.1876173317,
-0.1661046594,
-0.0038592205,
0.2624416351,
-0.253053695,
0.5171456337,
0.478181392,
-0.3422984481,
-0.2972529233,
0.1270885915,
0.2413844168,
0.3201918006,
0.9692633152,
-0.9056814909,
0.4871316254,
0.2443076819,
0.7419793606,
0.8781775832,
-0.2130631059,
0.5282746553,
-0.54747504,
-0.0113424398,
-0.1029643863,
0.1348623186,
-0.0343952663,
-0.121597901,
0.6480684876,
0.2937774658,
-0.8559710383,
-0.3937987685,
0.1588554978,
-0.9542806149,
0.2141179889,
1.2657263279,
-0.0924238339,
0.1028125435,
-0.0307442471,
-0.0533642396,
0.3408148885,
-0.476342082,
0.9880071282,
0.498552382,
-0.4014048874,
-0.3027747273,
-0.5811129808,
0.4115797281,
0.103829734,
-0.4278871715,
-0.0481652357,
0.0122265927,
0.2881463468,
0.2463214844,
0.0046979566,
0.0431198031,
0.04134202,
-0.0946025178,
-0.3583849967,
-0.2261829972,
-0.1319672465,
-0.5553733706,
0.2573352158,
-0.1871101856,
-0.1778324246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08614v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08614v1
|
XplainLLM: A QA Explanation Dataset for Understanding LLM Decision-Making
| 2023-11-15T00:34:28 | 2023-11-15T00:34:28 |
Zichen Chen, Jianda Chen, Mitali Gaidhani, Ambuj Singh, Misha Sra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently made impressive strides in natural
language understanding tasks. Despite their remarkable performance,
understanding their decision-making process remains a big challenge. In this
paper, we look into bringing some transparency to this process by introducing a
new explanation dataset for question answering (QA) tasks that integrates
knowledge graphs (KGs) in a novel way. Our dataset includes 12,102
question-answer-explanation (QAE) triples. Each explanation in the dataset
links the LLM's reasoning to entities and relations in the KGs. The explanation
component includes a why-choose explanation, a why-not-choose explanation, and
a set of reason-elements that underlie the LLM's decision. We leverage KGs and
graph attention networks (GAT) to find the reason-elements and transform them
into why-choose and why-not-choose explanations that are comprehensible to
humans. Through quantitative and qualitative evaluations, we demonstrate the
potential of our dataset to improve the in-context learning of LLMs, and
enhance their interpretability and explainability. Our work contributes to the
field of explainable AI by enabling a deeper understanding of the LLMs
decision-making process to make them more transparent and thereby, potentially
more reliable, to researchers and practitioners alike. Our dataset is available
at: https://github.com/chen-zichen/XplainLLM_dataset.git
|
[
-0.3782007396,
-0.7066196799,
0.9526381493,
-0.0984143168,
-0.1570566744,
0.0639148504,
-0.0879357904,
-0.2451287806,
-0.1126774922,
0.495731473,
-0.7490304708,
-0.708589077,
-0.5140559077,
-0.029329652,
-0.3395881951,
0.9089922905,
-0.4099713564,
-0.1380893439,
-0.3856664598,
-0.1755503267,
-0.6886343956,
-0.2111756504,
-1.1034121513,
-0.4446687102,
0.8140485883,
0.4371710122,
0.913431406,
0.9653325677,
0.0114066824,
0.269626081,
-0.1041398421,
0.4226789773,
-0.671854794,
-0.0049902857,
-0.2007622868,
-0.6351930499,
-0.4407088161,
-0.0240495279,
0.521902144,
0.8275520205,
0.1202560216,
0.4139956832,
-0.0089355465,
0.7378522158,
-0.3509825766,
0.6800423265,
-0.3771623671,
0.2176986188,
0.1834454089,
-0.2144068331,
-0.3229025602,
-0.4776638448,
0.3032752872,
-0.7552458644,
-0.135190919,
0.3089583814,
0.7182817459,
0.1710941941,
-0.4811739326,
-0.2507298291,
-0.5127007365,
0.6049107313,
-0.3110081851,
0.3377180398,
0.2115209997,
0.5983462334,
0.0112144928,
-0.7946996093,
-0.6317945719,
0.3536508977,
-0.2668336928,
0.1487473547,
-0.2959095538,
0.1743986607,
0.0937826559,
0.3508608341,
-0.9143502116,
-0.0437799729,
-0.0582343824,
-0.1494557261,
0.4353492558,
0.3054484725,
0.2980997264,
-0.0387309045,
-0.3305083811,
0.1084842831,
-0.6173192263,
0.1037063152,
0.2008013427,
0.0004432751,
-0.0408164375,
0.4919074774,
-0.2048955113,
0.7880932689,
-0.0646520853,
0.0489299893,
0.1338138133,
-0.1553200036,
-0.4914833009,
0.1766085029,
0.5024162531,
0.3627458215,
0.2495047897,
-0.316547811,
0.0844836906,
-0.2510779202,
-0.3236554563,
-0.6501606703,
-0.249523595,
0.6798855066,
-0.4637578428,
-0.2233703434,
-0.2271451801,
-0.4284547865,
-0.5101335049,
-0.6054816842,
0.5240259171,
-0.3156204224,
-0.2503010333,
0.4392375648,
-0.2037841827,
0.2103690505,
0.448183924,
-0.5187259912,
0.2305558473,
0.4719919562,
0.5514713526,
-0.1436177939,
-0.1590477824,
-0.4775227308,
0.2625317872,
-0.3570769131,
0.6006980538,
-0.3816767633,
0.0289089959,
-0.2359312773,
-0.0074178507,
-0.2746015191,
-0.6165775061,
0.5611047149,
-0.8684619069,
0.4004465044,
-0.3632482588,
-0.5777754784,
-0.7480161786,
0.4334457219,
-0.6011453867,
0.8365979791,
0.154763937,
-0.6762833595,
0.319050163,
-0.7742458582,
-0.1569356173,
0.0129454434,
-0.1325298399,
-0.2498797178,
-0.1504891515,
0.5075190663,
0.4865576625,
-0.3248873055,
0.326810807,
-0.2733066082,
-0.1093225554,
0.6404896975,
-0.3552905917,
1.1187595129,
0.2338769734,
-0.0922649503,
0.2988002896,
-0.5697856545,
0.3676101267,
0.2349537313,
-0.1687610149,
-0.0022697705,
-0.1379225999,
-0.6199938655,
0.390155822,
0.2732920051,
-0.2543627024,
-0.2574141622,
-0.2834990919,
0.5087701678,
0.8949234486,
-0.0818609744,
0.3626435101,
-0.3116068244,
0.8633388877,
-0.051882226,
0.3631578088,
-0.206478551,
-0.4423801005,
-0.5309331417,
-0.2187483609,
0.130140245,
0.3416209817,
-0.8873183727,
-0.1133496538,
-0.3826045096,
0.1062955633,
-0.468187958,
0.1281513572,
0.482632488,
0.8955897689,
0.2443692088,
0.3914125562,
-0.5501749516,
-0.8223371506,
-0.2399642766,
-0.3124441803,
0.0093956692,
0.6226945519,
0.3068606555,
0.0531913005,
1.2365124226,
-0.6422290206,
0.1161532104,
-0.6185564995,
-0.0571143031,
0.4018034339,
-0.1370634139,
0.2587023079,
-0.973510921,
-0.4148635566,
0.0680013075,
-0.9423955083,
-0.1455842704,
-0.0428843275,
-0.3662610948,
-0.2164993286,
0.3314512372,
-0.5686774254,
0.1088450626,
0.5525233746,
-0.3935287297,
0.6899908185,
-0.1089703366,
-0.1315062493,
-0.7952350378,
-0.1418468058,
-0.2228322625,
-0.4724293053,
-0.5264322758,
0.1831172258,
0.0056066234,
-0.1133150458,
-0.3499569893,
0.7486819029,
-0.6065075397,
-0.0653401092,
0.0435270742,
0.6398860216,
0.347577095,
0.6530310512,
-0.2323667556,
0.5532209873,
0.7283039689,
-0.5127450228,
0.4651702344,
0.5620645881,
-0.2113170028,
0.2266010493,
-0.5477778912,
0.1015621275,
-0.4410990477,
0.2303418964,
-1.0817238092,
-0.3104858398,
0.4771741629,
-0.5315187573,
0.1538812071,
-0.2504355013,
-0.4914422929,
-0.4666599333,
-0.2479656935,
0.3630260527,
0.3442413807,
-0.8856359124,
0.708266139,
0.3490412235,
-0.1209846586,
-0.530626893,
-0.6354125738,
0.279551357,
-0.3939826787,
-0.9862188101,
0.2194288522,
-0.268561095,
-0.3494746685,
0.094175525,
-0.1851296872,
-0.0738586932,
0.1637420803,
0.3325998485,
0.3160909116,
-0.3358804882,
0.3973162472,
0.058611948,
-0.2533534169,
0.414073199,
-0.638690114,
0.3799450397,
-0.0185735151,
-0.2130992711,
-0.5479992628,
0.0523891971,
0.35771963,
-0.2480744869,
0.7874414921,
0.3728067279,
-0.114001222,
-0.3884665668,
-0.1289228946,
-0.0070040026,
-0.4034609199,
0.2657679617,
-0.3133274913,
-0.922793448,
0.5798238516,
0.0052714613,
-0.0839845017,
0.2122397572,
0.5323858261,
-0.0306993872,
1.3044737577,
0.1295068711,
0.1328147203,
0.0378514603,
-0.2475040406,
0.4503931999,
-0.718126595,
-0.3640185893,
-0.2099017352,
-0.2360517085,
-0.3264886141,
-0.503115654,
0.37787655,
-0.0370817855,
-0.0650315061,
-0.2005422711,
-0.1595019251,
0.6480314732,
0.1409852654,
0.1147186756,
0.4485405982,
-0.1273212135,
0.0222400054,
0.4438227117,
-0.8103009462,
-0.5097658634,
0.8958304524,
0.3978440166,
0.6350232363,
0.1528045237,
0.5888252854,
0.1118764058,
0.3044033051,
-0.730555594,
0.63729316,
0.0737624615,
-0.628955245,
-0.5365924835,
-0.6672523022,
-1.0484695435,
0.4084710777,
0.1207720488,
-0.7275429368,
-0.0788405985,
0.1557476372,
-0.462480098,
0.1721366197,
-0.8209442496,
0.8681092262,
-0.2419343889,
-0.2578135729,
0.0521992482,
-0.5942403078,
0.5834966302,
0.0106647378,
0.3362677097,
-0.1383106709,
0.0638245344,
0.6571108699,
-0.4088717997,
0.6221218705,
-0.2253644764,
-0.3110993803,
0.4140594006,
-0.1276930571,
0.59770298,
0.2646420002,
-0.3775317967,
-0.1225423291,
-0.1711645573,
-0.2992178202,
-0.9646580219,
0.5384578109,
-0.5355575681,
-0.6657324433,
0.1701260358,
-0.875623405,
-0.300575316,
0.0143402098,
-0.0399963073,
0.5456933379,
0.1532479674,
-0.0741553679,
0.9244830608,
-0.263772428,
-0.050822515,
0.4681442976,
-0.7528064847,
-0.1264409274,
0.9659875631,
0.2122224271,
0.1486666352,
0.4925453663,
0.2972383499,
-0.5766175985,
-0.8690075874,
-0.4278039634,
0.1959277391,
-0.9415307641,
0.0707110688,
-0.6766422391,
-0.0411974788,
-0.1284940541,
0.2140500396,
0.4774934649,
-0.6138654351,
-0.2467555106,
-0.4028644264,
0.1613276899,
0.7960537672,
0.1275691688,
0.310846746,
-0.5907323956,
0.5912200212,
0.5389668941,
0.2126641124,
0.10500817,
-0.5619125366,
-0.4069435596,
0.1335219741,
0.0387183577,
-0.9685189128,
0.2702842951,
0.0672252476,
0.6537470222,
0.4337566793,
0.0082420092,
0.5080528259,
-0.0648798868,
0.3831942976,
-0.1615677178,
-0.8881403208,
0.3135672808,
-0.3394115269,
0.2679335773,
0.1558464915,
0.2707819641,
-0.5463761091,
-0.3174337447,
-0.3847323358,
-0.76060462,
0.9031103253,
0.4242271483,
-0.1012313291,
-0.0446012393,
0.6514237523,
0.3061609864,
0.1343016177,
-0.6133025885,
-0.5965813994,
0.1978353858,
-0.287646085,
0.1179324016,
-0.3120092452,
-0.3298482895,
-0.0082918545,
0.807471931,
-0.3297273219,
0.1042268947,
0.1174754426,
-0.4167793691,
0.0130853197,
0.2119784504,
0.1981488019,
1.0257898569,
-0.1947667748,
0.3775157332,
0.1976066232,
-0.1057089344,
-0.0162758734,
0.368845284,
-0.0281111617,
-0.1032751501,
0.3742100596,
0.8882602453,
-0.1292716563,
-0.7139676809,
0.3780969679,
-0.3544952571,
-0.2601524591,
-0.1189230233,
0.0775451213,
0.3986020684,
0.4784612954,
0.2640043795,
-0.42722857,
0.1358108521,
-0.3965423703,
-0.145316124,
0.4612876475,
-0.3787035048,
-0.2702886164,
0.5431440473,
-0.0322541855,
0.1619220823,
0.4301790595,
-0.4629825652,
-0.51080513,
0.8018098474,
0.2894664109,
0.7243767381,
0.1013682932,
0.7011705637,
0.0439328998,
0.1353509426,
0.3149995208,
0.4732742906,
-0.0939929411,
-0.9009752274,
-0.6628424525,
-0.3561436236,
-0.3609818816,
0.2497406006,
-0.6993408203,
-0.0716510564,
-0.2788513303,
0.133678481,
0.1451458335,
-0.284021467,
-0.6288561821,
0.4338076413,
0.1784938574,
0.9325365424,
-0.7616200447,
0.5985575318,
0.5109368563,
-0.2415211201,
-0.9640210867,
-0.0551041923,
-0.0558405481,
-1.3707678318,
0.8193438053,
0.0953200907,
-0.1126038283,
0.0668258891,
-0.6004289389,
-0.8251004815,
1.2717899084,
0.641980648,
-0.3614788651,
-0.0144338682,
0.269382745,
0.3332073092,
-0.339061141,
0.2134154737,
0.6774311662,
0.7629624009,
0.0000086858,
-0.3003175557,
0.3148893118,
0.1061404198,
-0.276410073,
0.3549157381,
-0.4296960533,
0.7199742794,
-0.5649484992,
-0.3468079865,
-0.0405214876,
0.5416951776,
0.1999299973,
0.5153204203,
0.4733516872,
0.4569637775,
1.137788415,
-0.1796573997,
1.2128843069,
-0.1813916266,
0.2507121265,
1.3893514872,
-0.1410403848,
0.2573478222,
0.4897943437,
-0.2472326159,
0.5376609564,
0.8621227145,
0.3856557608,
0.0877447799,
0.4011799395,
-0.2342261374,
-0.5233323574,
-0.2432135493,
-0.0859382525,
0.2999953926,
0.2533642948,
-0.6260480881,
-0.4407505393,
-0.0085284319,
0.0778669417,
-0.2828263342,
-0.3716160059,
0.7154542208,
-0.0150271384,
-0.395996511,
0.5475080609,
-0.2871313095,
-0.2891641557,
-0.5007229447,
-0.1075148359,
-0.1872735769,
-0.1417686492,
-0.4329809546,
-1.3162733316,
-0.0698360056,
-0.2280996442,
-0.3954173923,
-0.3791917562,
0.5087218285,
-0.4471167922,
-0.2262250483,
0.4203666747,
0.7519565821,
0.3136670291,
-0.2417587042,
-0.7824314237,
-0.133283779,
0.2177559733,
-0.2228266299,
0.1538581401,
0.8502608538,
-0.2560597658,
0.9142166972,
0.4850821495,
-0.193426773,
-0.1280597746,
0.1652982682,
0.8719043136,
-0.3972064555,
-0.4603645205,
-0.8045916557,
0.4997612238,
-0.0833353251,
0.015211801,
0.7549031377,
0.6192856431,
0.410867691,
0.1761188805,
1.0543118715,
0.1061698571,
0.5187867284,
-0.8108484745,
0.5000328422,
-0.4475772679,
0.5558162332,
0.2892488539,
-0.6553239822,
-0.2011552751,
0.0943111554,
-0.5187696218,
0.1639541984,
0.7526516318,
0.6649838686,
0.0080779921,
0.2226630151,
0.3698537052,
0.7604213357,
0.2838484645,
0.547822535,
0.9266602397,
-0.1003894731,
1.0745249987,
-0.0606482476,
-0.2841797173,
-0.0263782758,
-1.010083437,
-0.7984372377,
-0.3559687138,
-0.3845998049,
-0.253957063,
0.188582018,
0.5403536558,
0.625800252,
-0.6397047043,
0.028479239,
-0.111361973,
0.7408607006,
-0.2041293532,
-0.2476641089,
0.6410215497,
-0.3606244028,
-0.4188724458,
0.2867410481,
0.4348914623,
-0.2222735584,
-0.0919684544,
-0.3166512251,
0.0436640456,
0.1242503226,
0.7002578378,
0.1061130464,
-0.5540674925,
-0.1588143706,
-0.0602634028,
0.354983896,
0.2775569856,
0.6951025724,
-0.8558553457,
0.6205023527,
0.5148023367,
0.6431151628,
0.4972589612,
-0.1496435404,
0.6330980659,
-0.5505638123,
-0.5480778813,
-0.1118552834,
0.4743843377,
0.2687213719,
-0.4025612175,
0.5249589682,
-0.2025802583,
-0.5178408623,
-0.5805486441,
0.2909795344,
-0.8691141605,
-0.4271170795,
1.1713083982,
-0.3409631848,
-0.3920646906,
-0.5528344512,
-0.6016393304,
0.2559932172,
-0.3768828809,
0.6129936576,
0.7455854416,
-0.4644049406,
-0.3061693013,
-0.6261214018,
0.4130455554,
0.3548409939,
-1.1210314035,
0.5004441738,
0.4158359468,
0.1836915463,
-0.1785587072,
0.3169511259,
-0.145947665,
0.2736923993,
-0.6070791483,
-0.292652607,
-0.2454886585,
-0.0981175452,
-0.4980537295,
0.2199097127,
0.2339096367,
-0.2323146909
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08607v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08607v1
|
Towards Generalizable SER: Soft Labeling and Data Augmentation for Modeling Temporal Emotion Shifts in Large-Scale Multilingual Speech
| 2023-11-15T00:09:21 | 2023-11-15T00:09:21 |
Mohamed Osman, Tamer Nadeem, Ghada Khoriba
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
Recognizing emotions in spoken communication is crucial for advanced
human-machine interaction. Current emotion detection methodologies often
display biases when applied cross-corpus. To address this, our study
amalgamates 16 diverse datasets, resulting in 375 hours of data across
languages like English, Chinese, and Japanese. We propose a soft labeling
system to capture gradational emotional intensities. Using the Whisper encoder
and data augmentation methods inspired by contrastive learning, our method
emphasizes the temporal dynamics of emotions. Our validation on four
multilingual datasets demonstrates notable zero-shot generalization. We publish
our open source model weights and initial promising results after fine-tuning
on Hume-Prosody.
|
[
-0.1404667646,
-0.6337989569,
0.2062003314,
0.2826010287,
-0.1776900291,
-0.151151821,
-0.3329668045,
-0.5475572348,
0.3133048415,
0.0930994153,
-0.6777517796,
-0.7402868271,
-0.432115674,
0.1660217792,
-0.1053757221,
1.1330254078,
0.1285417378,
-0.0454123653,
0.4325017333,
-0.5898730159,
0.1774073541,
-0.5867371559,
-0.6379768252,
-0.2781056762,
0.6434714794,
0.3237479031,
0.7168611288,
0.1028306112,
0.0761439502,
0.2576651871,
-0.2033908814,
-0.000160029,
-0.3812629879,
0.5299268365,
0.0838619769,
-0.5158596039,
-0.5669558644,
-0.0244790558,
0.6184578538,
0.6222646832,
-0.117119588,
0.0556382537,
-0.2306817174,
0.6550397277,
-0.6036039591,
0.4017280936,
-0.3884594738,
0.4687330723,
-0.3556288481,
-0.0196175706,
-0.2666184604,
-0.2512987554,
0.2836954296,
-0.5120167136,
0.1700230241,
-0.3139220774,
0.5067012906,
0.2531659901,
-0.6991786361,
-0.4254110754,
-0.6060174704,
0.8271889091,
-0.7527666092,
0.5849465728,
0.055562526,
0.2534940541,
0.1684109718,
-0.6436004639,
-0.5281662941,
0.0059452057,
0.2687748075,
0.4050179124,
-0.200820908,
0.2086140662,
0.1368623823,
0.3840837479,
-0.6621841788,
0.0988925397,
0.2017879188,
-0.0475121662,
0.5339558721,
0.2091911584,
0.5695909858,
-0.0406677313,
0.1586286724,
-0.1584156603,
-0.2026237547,
0.2708741426,
0.6395173669,
0.5470380783,
-0.4907696545,
0.3091030419,
-0.1171792522,
0.387730509,
0.077227734,
0.0312616564,
0.664272964,
0.0573797449,
-0.1900524348,
0.1756571233,
0.8162335753,
0.3326614499,
0.4390529692,
-0.1143113077,
-0.0304106046,
0.1689055115,
-0.1922245771,
-0.733916223,
0.0386534967,
0.6007210612,
-0.3630311191,
-0.0649197921,
-0.2008184493,
-1.0814887285,
-0.5690361261,
-0.212720111,
0.2969791293,
-0.3121474981,
-0.526442647,
0.3843190074,
-0.036723882,
0.180016771,
-0.0842135474,
-0.779854238,
0.0917888209,
0.5786358118,
0.8496469259,
0.1669532508,
-0.0219507683,
-0.529817462,
0.1161819845,
-0.309702754,
0.3975914717,
-0.9265335202,
-0.5183813572,
0.249223873,
0.4631750882,
-0.0962572023,
-0.3252905607,
0.709203124,
-0.1756814122,
0.4495142102,
0.2352826297,
-0.4168926179,
-0.0980973318,
-0.0854716524,
-0.6129945517,
0.6434173584,
0.0145074539,
-0.5728269219,
0.0568863489,
-0.5565821528,
-0.5802459121,
-0.0020310618,
0.1064088866,
-0.5262818336,
0.3771370351,
0.1217127442,
0.3957844973,
0.0272628143,
0.3220143318,
-0.4758659005,
-0.3659623861,
0.3080462515,
-0.3594314158,
0.4187021554,
0.3250143826,
-0.5277464986,
0.1226995364,
-0.9015069008,
-0.0414627716,
-0.0784341991,
-0.0451005623,
-0.3637608886,
0.1173387393,
0.0750358477,
-0.0101227555,
0.226714313,
-0.6853963137,
0.2295584083,
-0.4744653106,
0.4359978139,
0.647105813,
-0.1431399435,
0.3329645693,
0.1479453444,
0.5496145487,
0.2684455514,
0.3673889637,
-0.3573957086,
-0.2822767794,
-0.8444669247,
-0.2016326338,
0.1244297773,
0.5310799479,
-0.5740261078,
0.06226198,
-0.0399769098,
-0.3221616447,
-1.0956218243,
-0.368763566,
0.3104624152,
0.6602157354,
0.3803574145,
0.0871508494,
-0.4196794033,
-0.9400550127,
-0.2398678064,
0.0824721009,
-0.1977293491,
0.6059294939,
-0.0354320481,
-0.6853126884,
0.5739579201,
-0.4063551426,
-0.2020417601,
0.1092744842,
0.7522982359,
0.3381872475,
0.3307869434,
0.4295024574,
-0.9472161531,
-0.4672531784,
0.2579675317,
-0.7029986382,
-0.4694008827,
0.0197293777,
0.0961105675,
0.4620856643,
0.095318146,
-0.1390876323,
0.2049649209,
0.637155056,
-0.1757512242,
0.5738607645,
-0.0375134088,
0.5244708657,
-0.868675828,
0.013159669,
0.2591098845,
-0.0582951345,
-0.9041442275,
-0.282448709,
0.0537087545,
-0.46716097,
-0.6259903312,
0.6379656196,
-0.359852463,
-0.0461528674,
-0.2827117145,
-0.0331600308,
-0.1559941471,
0.5484768748,
0.2213491499,
0.5415818095,
0.5533025861,
-0.6219272614,
0.3852161169,
0.0406189486,
-0.0441996083,
0.7185084224,
-0.8408136964,
0.3379880786,
-0.4105194509,
0.2244559675,
-1.0106223822,
-0.3427177966,
0.1794241965,
-0.501314044,
0.229214713,
-0.4872175455,
-0.2070429772,
-0.0785847604,
-0.3286709785,
0.3845261633,
0.5593203306,
-0.3313772082,
0.828764081,
0.3992240727,
-0.5877578855,
-0.4752506912,
-0.7562419772,
-0.071913667,
-0.1892445236,
-0.6169861555,
0.1643703282,
-0.211135596,
-0.1515315026,
-0.1023595184,
0.0394552872,
-0.1454563886,
-0.2182746828,
0.4151912928,
-0.0045188549,
0.0455772169,
0.4476500452,
0.204079926,
-0.2866198719,
-0.250002712,
-0.0162600372,
0.411742419,
-0.3977017403,
-0.2853655815,
-0.4016184807,
0.5322551131,
0.6242801547,
-0.0846854746,
0.4440624714,
1.2158145905,
-0.3555908501,
0.0261807851,
-0.4026071131,
0.1392119974,
-0.4801710844,
0.2855192423,
-0.5147101283,
-1.0435968637,
0.7577851415,
-0.0781164095,
-0.0076954835,
0.2841805816,
0.4534240961,
-0.1042947844,
1.6928950548,
0.6398752928,
-0.2948291898,
0.594789505,
-0.0271983333,
0.0242256504,
-0.8143462539,
-0.0649220943,
-0.5125204325,
-0.5324270725,
-0.8812054992,
-0.0862541422,
0.5305525064,
-0.425132364,
-0.2077513635,
-0.3498115242,
-0.5404352546,
0.2601034939,
0.1113325879,
-0.0637422204,
-0.1028008685,
-0.2167717814,
0.3047379851,
-0.3991374671,
-0.2702840567,
-0.2237284034,
0.6842730045,
0.2914088666,
0.8164166808,
0.1804389358,
0.4942971766,
0.4529499114,
-0.013537514,
-0.7767341733,
0.3689664602,
-0.6461003423,
-0.2159199119,
-0.2405375242,
-0.5044446588,
-1.2441161871,
0.2573892772,
0.099809438,
-0.8009082675,
0.3539779186,
-0.0898093879,
-0.1094640195,
-0.0338009968,
-1.0168153048,
0.719824791,
-0.1801516414,
-0.3798227012,
-0.0766952038,
-0.7055620551,
0.308203578,
0.2182283849,
0.4992566407,
-0.4185439944,
-0.2109390944,
0.6866887212,
-0.1423366666,
1.0389536619,
-0.4056366086,
-0.2536351979,
0.0807502642,
0.0625990406,
0.3785063922,
-0.1477254778,
-0.2758840621,
-0.0130706467,
-0.0347683653,
-0.3722938001,
-0.7703939676,
0.6755232811,
-0.7200310826,
-0.0891728252,
-0.270798564,
-0.6184828281,
-0.3726551831,
-0.1924769729,
0.1346932352,
0.6945879459,
-0.0257572737,
0.1000667661,
0.7268886566,
-0.4819411039,
0.3297687471,
1.027074337,
-0.0396356247,
-0.5369583964,
1.1793607473,
0.2746683061,
0.042793598,
0.2986125946,
0.4010401368,
-0.5029622912,
-0.0591732934,
-0.2001393735,
0.2060823143,
-0.3221409023,
0.0938454345,
-0.7093003988,
0.2126583904,
-0.7027239203,
-0.2772285938,
-0.2927852273,
-0.3542754352,
-0.3939168751,
-0.0001797531,
0.4797402024,
0.5587079525,
-0.3616601527,
0.3636661172,
-1.0042194128,
0.511798203,
0.3619643152,
0.564686656,
-0.078772299,
-0.5388354063,
-0.0712544471,
0.189209953,
0.1276989579,
-1.0854735374,
0.7330002189,
0.7290246487,
0.415507406,
0.4734355211,
0.1631127,
0.5861512423,
-0.402818948,
0.9646744132,
0.1207619831,
-1.2786921263,
0.738258481,
-0.4691585898,
0.5825420022,
0.213170886,
0.6836696863,
-1.1890380383,
-0.2168288976,
-0.6577051282,
-1.2239934206,
0.5057541728,
-0.389618814,
0.1062751263,
-0.0179908872,
0.3057783842,
0.3620688915,
0.1918061972,
-0.4891773164,
-0.1257925183,
-0.1420284808,
-0.7402978539,
-0.2805796862,
-0.3235297501,
0.1219520345,
0.1084405556,
0.4924324453,
-0.3463687003,
0.2355326861,
0.1161934659,
-0.3078971803,
-0.0164223593,
0.6360148787,
0.4525152147,
-0.1251918226,
-0.3842928708,
0.3025269806,
-0.0201187078,
-0.3342243135,
0.3145467639,
0.2528039217,
0.0533639863,
0.1430440098,
0.2092906088,
1.0256285667,
0.6284841895,
-0.7360306382,
0.3137780726,
-0.01336833,
0.0762052238,
0.110735096,
-0.2155809104,
-0.080304198,
0.4553690255,
0.35411641,
-0.7274401784,
0.6305572391,
-0.7308208942,
0.1147348359,
0.1924075931,
-0.7053232193,
-0.6523294449,
0.4427312016,
0.3819251955,
-0.172575444,
0.2676372528,
-0.3426846564,
-0.5924573541,
0.3920643926,
0.3458648324,
1.0498207808,
-0.5799568295,
0.4194845855,
0.1244456992,
-0.0742943957,
0.2531741261,
0.5369288921,
-0.1309731752,
-0.4732415378,
-0.4019724131,
-0.4168588221,
-0.9350354671,
-0.0459441952,
-0.838088572,
-0.0107270628,
-0.1670017838,
-0.385288775,
-0.048671253,
0.0919152647,
-0.4644432664,
0.1838295907,
0.4563322961,
0.3898378015,
-1.0084246397,
0.3824121952,
0.6742104888,
-0.2087205946,
-0.3496749401,
-0.2960760593,
0.2414573729,
-0.6553578377,
0.5197384953,
0.2244150639,
-0.3104442656,
0.0690585747,
-0.7637919784,
-0.4118397534,
0.7575082183,
0.2877383232,
-0.6778542995,
0.3898170888,
0.145295307,
0.8567120433,
-0.1399537623,
0.6790181994,
0.5464581251,
0.4035795331,
0.0627763867,
-0.724134624,
-0.5654240251,
-0.454493165,
-0.3477235138,
0.3625561893,
-0.8170621395,
0.8405140042,
0.1170523092,
-0.6331819892,
-0.3400569856,
0.652723968,
0.0348347723,
0.5778853893,
0.4229496419,
0.4530086517,
1.0061975718,
-0.2173782736,
0.8267734051,
-0.1757987291,
0.0412521586,
1.023219943,
-0.6210602522,
0.7143060565,
-0.0061209388,
-0.2029392272,
0.4564170241,
0.6450715661,
0.2662662268,
0.2522054315,
0.1180735603,
-0.5005765557,
-0.0611799173,
-0.733230114,
-0.5160697699,
0.1853400916,
0.6093565822,
0.1371523291,
-0.089533329,
0.4265932441,
0.0765633285,
-0.3229879141,
-0.4713054597,
0.8276280761,
0.0006854555,
-0.0619518869,
0.505664289,
-0.364413619,
1.1321327686,
-0.8157941103,
0.1730902344,
-0.3096388578,
0.0914682001,
-0.2584059834,
-0.9750275612,
0.0419797413,
0.3262186348,
-0.1709278524,
-0.1218625233,
0.7816449404,
-0.9178523421,
-0.3866921067,
0.4455659986,
0.2678237259,
0.4482173622,
-0.077184096,
-0.6347472072,
0.4367901683,
-0.0239297096,
-0.3321292996,
0.3566903472,
0.6846625209,
0.1380478591,
0.6694167256,
0.3534746468,
0.0246914998,
0.1086357832,
0.7524765134,
0.4575813115,
-0.7324441671,
-0.5097284317,
-0.5205177069,
0.6825197339,
0.1327470541,
-0.1659214497,
0.4461871982,
0.2816267312,
0.3776796758,
-0.1146806255,
0.8769456148,
0.3198147714,
0.5859901309,
-0.2970275581,
0.2912499011,
-0.6402802467,
-0.4312212169,
-0.4595105946,
-0.5824875236,
-0.1503686905,
0.3510774076,
-0.2801988125,
-0.2147678584,
0.1728151143,
0.543515265,
0.1974445432,
0.2150956988,
0.3190582693,
0.2746089697,
0.469145596,
0.8849031329,
0.6309651136,
-0.2987426519,
0.4174510837,
-0.1890849769,
-0.4019907713,
-0.2494833618,
-0.9517090321,
-0.3983314931,
-0.7736994624,
-0.5878983736,
-0.0509376414,
0.2941647172,
0.837465167,
0.5475381613,
-0.7738739252,
-0.1633536667,
0.4430152178,
-0.0441349186,
-0.0294154994,
-0.3011772633,
0.2074540854,
-0.525611639,
-1.1370865107,
0.443687439,
0.4047631025,
0.4287893474,
0.0626446828,
-0.0416343398,
0.0822683275,
0.1013889015,
0.6777641773,
0.5588206649,
-0.3500762284,
-0.1872692257,
-0.0352937281,
0.0118512241,
-0.2390347272,
0.6203177571,
-0.5097685456,
0.6954551935,
0.5732935071,
0.526691854,
0.4707222581,
-0.0780638233,
0.5378385186,
-0.936694026,
0.4136896431,
0.3051859736,
0.3068459034,
0.4706334472,
-0.2358738035,
0.6620464921,
0.1763815731,
-0.6657328606,
-0.8275970221,
0.2173983902,
-1.0180367231,
-0.0670386851,
1.0634939671,
-0.1596443504,
-0.3555997908,
0.0515900441,
-0.2186761349,
0.4858329296,
-0.5984281898,
0.5130826235,
0.7459485531,
-0.303840369,
-0.160937205,
-0.3386136293,
0.3494942188,
0.4061684906,
-0.7368885875,
0.1433388144,
0.6775486469,
-0.0698890239,
0.0577330962,
0.6049895287,
-0.0377858281,
0.0971424431,
-0.0506759696,
0.3829822838,
0.1167728007,
-0.1721849442,
-0.7895191908,
0.1663791984,
-0.4951266348,
-0.2647530138
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08605v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08605v2
|
Exploring the Jungle of Bias: Political Bias Attribution in Language Models via Dependency Analysis
| 2023-11-15T00:02:25 | 2024-05-12T13:56:25 |
David F. Jenny, Yann Billeter, Mrinmaya Sachan, Bernhard Schölkopf, Zhijing Jin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.SI
|
The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has sparked intense
debate regarding the prevalence of bias in these models and its mitigation.
Yet, as exemplified by both results on debiasing methods in the literature and
reports of alignment-related defects from the wider community, bias remains a
poorly understood topic despite its practical relevance. To enhance the
understanding of the internal causes of bias, we analyse LLM bias through the
lens of causal fairness analysis, which enables us to both comprehend the
origins of bias and reason about its downstream consequences and mitigation. To
operationalize this framework, we propose a prompt-based method for the
extraction of confounding and mediating attributes which contribute to the LLM
decision process. By applying Activity Dependency Networks (ADNs), we then
analyse how these attributes influence an LLM's decision process. We apply our
method to LLM ratings of argument quality in political debates. We find that
the observed disparate treatment can at least in part be attributed to
confounding and mitigating attributes and model misalignment, and discuss the
consequences of our findings for human-AI alignment and bias mitigation. Our
code and data are at https://github.com/david-jenny/LLM-Political-Study.
|
[
-0.4011850357,
-0.7665849328,
0.5143209696,
0.1046454012,
0.0764387175,
-0.0755835027,
-0.0920026004,
-0.0186591204,
0.242060408,
0.7263817191,
-0.7690498233,
-0.2212522477,
-0.7767468691,
-0.1574675143,
-0.0656314939,
0.8319439888,
0.2995899022,
0.3687405288,
-0.1828494817,
-0.3098947406,
-0.7658417225,
-0.4692930281,
-0.6085790396,
-0.6132444739,
0.4506877661,
0.4880344868,
0.6879895329,
0.599234283,
0.2929342985,
0.2957825959,
-0.3719720244,
-0.1026918143,
-0.4444366097,
0.1333083063,
-0.4047441185,
-0.4762762189,
-0.3708532155,
0.3154509366,
0.484926343,
0.8103365302,
-0.0065614679,
0.0699576885,
0.1354286075,
0.8627734184,
-0.6930142641,
0.0748733953,
-0.8966565728,
-0.1266695559,
-0.5012281537,
-0.31594491,
-0.2200855315,
-0.3091616929,
0.1631956846,
-0.2652339935,
0.1615759134,
0.122478351,
0.6967220306,
0.4337418377,
-0.704300344,
-0.5473114252,
-0.4245940149,
1.0203014612,
-0.63637954,
0.0054007345,
0.312520802,
0.0881704837,
-0.3794764876,
-0.1340634078,
-0.5799883008,
0.0636685491,
-0.0750098079,
-0.0994441211,
-0.013413134,
0.1549898684,
0.2183341235,
0.3263968527,
-0.2602723539,
0.2410976738,
-0.3202630281,
-0.1972581595,
0.5825588107,
0.1512849927,
0.3518426716,
-0.7072253823,
-0.0487574749,
0.1292277575,
-0.9518325925,
0.0342229679,
0.9240872264,
0.4186071754,
0.0380567499,
0.5659094453,
0.0231490098,
0.5927485228,
0.0497606955,
0.0688605756,
-0.0338920318,
-0.2715790868,
-0.1155665591,
0.3201140761,
0.7061619163,
0.2893470824,
0.3264396489,
0.1881381422,
-0.0168911312,
0.2603205442,
0.0060905665,
-0.6150036454,
-0.146922946,
0.2124409825,
-0.6234397888,
-0.6418498755,
-0.1637675464,
-0.9674645066,
-0.9780883789,
-0.3922813535,
-0.0366625898,
0.1250033528,
-0.4144189358,
0.0118147256,
0.0629995689,
0.0331488587,
0.1331565976,
-0.7920898199,
0.2874763906,
0.7247985601,
0.7840839028,
-0.2014458627,
0.1108618006,
-0.6362986565,
-0.0954208225,
-0.2513634562,
0.8782747388,
-0.5070941448,
-0.1300854981,
0.151634559,
0.0429913327,
0.2108843923,
-0.6849504113,
0.7238202095,
-0.4521745741,
0.4884056151,
-0.6393572688,
-0.4194338024,
-0.3567940295,
0.1567437351,
-1.00519526,
0.6966930032,
-0.1437813193,
-0.8564353585,
0.4647060931,
-0.720246613,
-0.2818718255,
-0.3728353977,
-0.5633640289,
-0.2981011569,
-0.1053190082,
0.3102770746,
0.2086069733,
-0.5894309282,
0.7011064887,
-0.2722479999,
-0.0368718319,
0.2020253986,
-0.5536836982,
1.532563448,
0.0077628465,
-0.4649983644,
0.3395349383,
-0.6872072816,
-0.5431272984,
0.0580446534,
-0.1085576117,
-0.4088920057,
0.4432289004,
-0.1861829609,
0.3851771951,
-0.1327290535,
-0.2391174436,
0.1956476867,
-0.3661671281,
0.3618926406,
1.2843798399,
-0.1608865857,
0.754637599,
-0.1968347579,
0.488206774,
0.1003013775,
-0.0238775779,
-0.0270076096,
-0.3947677612,
-0.6123182774,
-0.1674646437,
0.3486620486,
0.5843484402,
-0.32404989,
0.2713840306,
-0.1369167417,
0.1464946866,
-0.6250831485,
0.2576929331,
0.1708277762,
0.5330045819,
-0.0247868784,
-0.3823078275,
-0.6820389032,
-1.0066576004,
-0.4189545512,
-0.3417723775,
0.0243848395,
0.4301520288,
0.5635451674,
0.0122659374,
1.0883584023,
-0.2808412015,
-0.3896241486,
-0.2742239237,
-0.005484906,
0.2222208381,
0.2951771915,
0.3720804155,
-0.4982270002,
-0.0414536893,
-0.3340854645,
-0.5498417616,
-0.8025035858,
-0.0321553834,
-0.2898471653,
0.1286824346,
0.5691064596,
-0.420681119,
0.1989408582,
0.5663324594,
-0.5827749372,
0.4937922359,
0.4361705184,
0.1198638156,
-0.8722450733,
0.0643339381,
0.063587971,
-0.1343563348,
-0.4718245268,
-0.3962483406,
-0.3344229758,
0.1675368696,
-0.3995644748,
0.6601082683,
-0.3689925671,
0.0556992963,
-0.2603320777,
0.3053417504,
0.1538335979,
0.3031640351,
-0.2849376798,
0.5444480181,
0.2812330425,
-0.2751055658,
0.2128367722,
0.1262821406,
-0.4007854164,
0.5978694558,
-0.4795238674,
0.0857847184,
-0.1851639599,
0.2725940049,
-1.1121169329,
-0.0812508613,
0.5845674872,
-0.1599989086,
0.2051265389,
-0.4621507823,
-0.3315230608,
0.0717133358,
-0.2658439875,
0.5136854053,
0.2498689145,
-0.479297936,
0.4863990843,
0.798250854,
-0.1806102097,
-0.7798694372,
-0.4988553822,
-0.027645912,
-0.6134836674,
-0.5893937349,
0.2278266847,
0.3085110188,
-0.9345619678,
-0.0320102014,
-0.0793385878,
0.1549686939,
0.1224023774,
0.189056173,
0.064517118,
-0.1279552132,
0.0250607654,
-0.1817034185,
-0.154499352,
0.4375066459,
-0.1401345283,
0.3714712262,
0.2258498222,
-0.3429287076,
-0.1709296405,
0.3425241411,
0.4130976796,
0.020310089,
0.6029619575,
0.0111468611,
-0.3208304048,
-0.1484226733,
-0.6436321735,
-0.2857950926,
-0.4427519143,
0.3973959684,
0.1779121459,
-0.6453120708,
0.8179938197,
-0.0564825833,
-0.0283907969,
0.4598475099,
0.6580352783,
0.2541673481,
0.9813467264,
0.6449741721,
-0.4429228008,
0.5867038369,
-0.00217435,
0.1727413833,
-0.6474792957,
-0.0289839823,
-0.6372221112,
-0.3437354863,
-0.7386436462,
-0.3862791359,
-0.1354926825,
-0.028564699,
-0.3579063118,
-0.4104961455,
-0.4142127633,
0.6440199018,
0.3397962749,
-0.1382065117,
0.1396021843,
-0.1194897071,
0.073788099,
-0.3131612837,
-0.7511991858,
-0.6217370629,
0.9155570865,
0.3951288462,
0.7545651793,
0.1050038561,
0.1400811225,
0.3852889538,
0.4950380027,
-0.668466866,
0.4768301249,
0.0365444049,
-0.9035433531,
-0.1832757443,
-0.4213910401,
-0.8078567386,
0.4345573485,
-0.0748141035,
-0.7566727996,
0.2593471706,
0.0891779512,
-0.1240390539,
0.3515178859,
-0.4420220852,
0.9733130336,
-0.291441977,
-0.6094968915,
-0.063422665,
-0.5754315853,
0.7075200677,
0.1974453181,
0.4731701016,
-0.3827537596,
0.2512509227,
1.0017980337,
-0.3142202795,
0.9695169926,
-0.2769314349,
-0.2790241838,
0.1400086284,
0.0282919854,
0.3651676476,
-0.0365123041,
-0.2282119393,
0.1473323256,
-0.4997699559,
-0.3508841395,
-0.5487141609,
0.7645874023,
-0.6269753575,
-0.8477312922,
-0.4994300306,
-0.6727884412,
0.01454724,
0.0215165094,
-0.1212345436,
0.2080941945,
-0.1675283015,
-0.0806292295,
0.6623619199,
-0.38744995,
0.1880698502,
0.3295190036,
-0.3464446962,
-0.1533621401,
0.7045150399,
0.289080739,
0.191662401,
-0.0658897609,
0.3929126859,
-0.2079427689,
-0.2832670808,
-0.2554856539,
0.153980419,
-0.8545870185,
-0.2025776505,
-0.4394718111,
-0.0062110289,
-0.1605937332,
-0.0749142468,
-0.3381269872,
-0.3530213535,
-0.218794018,
-0.0290666167,
0.2944739759,
0.9698498249,
0.1035656333,
0.5257207751,
0.0194641817,
0.0008086783,
0.0270408224,
0.2268018723,
0.0417691544,
-0.5054069757,
-0.0506648161,
-0.0964933559,
-0.6815539598,
-1.2467657328,
0.2114806771,
-0.1269005388,
0.5135458112,
0.412972182,
-0.0362058654,
0.5295103788,
-0.4964102805,
0.938231647,
-0.0819758847,
-0.8729493022,
0.5782507658,
-0.2793040872,
-0.0030303984,
0.4270034432,
0.1018067971,
-0.2748183012,
-0.5167894959,
-0.6355919242,
-1.0074168444,
0.8404278755,
0.1377882212,
-0.1085906103,
-0.0196713284,
0.2490517348,
-0.0189087279,
0.1493880451,
-0.7631669044,
-0.4376603067,
0.0203358233,
-0.1407914311,
0.0213243719,
-0.4600350857,
-0.2546694875,
-0.116355285,
0.7280697227,
-0.1093777195,
-0.1238002777,
0.0229471475,
-0.2624638677,
-0.2066888064,
0.2894601226,
0.7089629173,
0.6520296335,
-0.0177580155,
0.203772217,
0.0988976955,
-0.1644866467,
0.1986238509,
0.069183588,
-0.0820031762,
0.1148003936,
0.3439462185,
0.5015013218,
-0.0631432012,
-0.3700550795,
0.683224082,
0.0538267717,
0.0649478361,
-0.2211385369,
-0.2008874863,
0.2051444203,
0.3130783439,
0.3063386381,
-0.0833959877,
0.2849874496,
-0.481657654,
0.0229877364,
0.8539782763,
-0.4303105772,
-0.1755888313,
0.6036043167,
0.4575678706,
-0.305704385,
0.5634627938,
-0.0590017699,
-0.7934717536,
0.7628481388,
0.2075287104,
0.7935150266,
-0.246260643,
-0.033229962,
0.1472638547,
0.4881268442,
0.1328311265,
0.0901503563,
0.3894573152,
-0.7624307871,
-0.7312402129,
-0.2724063098,
-0.1698412299,
0.4191707373,
-0.213618353,
0.3853638768,
-0.2279649228,
-0.1422293037,
-0.0611928403,
0.3131014109,
-0.5357140899,
-0.182855159,
0.0910519287,
0.6381714344,
-1.2211600542,
0.4403588772,
0.3754355311,
-0.2978182733,
-0.4933944941,
0.1363347471,
0.60881567,
-0.6879016161,
0.7801088095,
0.173308745,
-0.0609417111,
-0.4216203392,
-0.6233337522,
-0.5556771159,
0.7776458263,
0.7502290606,
-0.5501074195,
0.2876323462,
0.1374395341,
0.0881805122,
-0.4862392545,
0.5345341563,
0.7335793972,
0.4218516946,
-0.3947357237,
-0.6636199951,
0.2774653435,
-0.1328369379,
-0.0944191888,
0.1330161989,
-0.4792818129,
0.7661659718,
0.02518332,
0.044571843,
-0.5067988634,
0.5202122331,
0.3317922652,
0.1560005248,
0.6274770498,
0.1862000525,
0.872444272,
-0.0817828327,
0.8492968082,
-0.2012534291,
0.1598793715,
1.0286068916,
-0.3345845342,
0.1017311513,
0.9542347193,
0.0438882001,
0.5335661173,
0.6491039991,
0.3852309585,
0.4952433705,
0.7852860093,
-0.2152975947,
0.079355143,
-0.5310271382,
-0.0940555409,
0.3388726711,
0.3813045621,
-0.4555043578,
-0.1655948013,
-0.2125386298,
0.2868608534,
0.1137364134,
-0.222675398,
0.6050061584,
0.0836661831,
-0.625803709,
0.1087559015,
-0.1779444963,
0.7386996746,
-0.3576423824,
-0.172948584,
-0.3509798348,
0.0958936512,
-0.3614032269,
-0.8056902885,
0.3334116936,
-0.0895912424,
-0.4153657258,
-0.3185726404,
0.6034263968,
-0.3946557343,
-0.3054213524,
0.3261433244,
0.6562176943,
0.0062861252,
0.1099107787,
-0.7658068538,
0.4538909197,
0.0445464775,
-0.5049741268,
0.2528783083,
0.6768010259,
-0.2967839837,
0.596631825,
0.4391311407,
0.259167403,
-0.2252862602,
0.3136920929,
0.8350954652,
-0.4210739136,
-0.2098444551,
-1.3066217899,
0.6964238882,
-0.2024393678,
-0.1913149655,
0.5681511164,
0.3997760117,
0.6096614003,
0.3197600543,
0.8546800613,
-0.1451554447,
0.2347726822,
-0.6002646685,
0.8418437839,
-0.5317677259,
0.6536697745,
-0.4321095645,
-0.6965850592,
-0.3164561391,
0.7074568868,
-0.466119349,
0.1428980678,
0.5426331758,
1.0701566935,
-0.1584127694,
-0.0971501619,
-0.1552337855,
0.2565982044,
0.5733528137,
0.3158848286,
1.0147615671,
-0.2066227496,
0.4274692237,
-0.019980086,
-0.3868136108,
-0.1264482439,
-1.2869095802,
-0.8611652851,
-0.4514644742,
-0.3124320209,
-0.658200562,
0.2680460811,
0.972787261,
0.5039970279,
-0.8056970239,
-0.4382124543,
-0.1653716564,
0.8197818995,
0.1439135075,
-0.2822948098,
0.5001301765,
-0.3662517667,
-0.5647905469,
-0.1542986035,
0.000423417,
-0.4679440558,
-0.5624263883,
-0.2445777208,
-0.406180948,
0.1254151016,
0.3714538515,
0.0218398012,
-0.9378435612,
-0.3487710655,
-0.2553648949,
-0.0880286768,
0.1123201624,
1.1141796112,
-0.6758841276,
0.3642173707,
0.4927993417,
0.5068061352,
-0.2666591704,
-0.1415137649,
0.8859938979,
-0.7036454082,
0.2120516896,
0.1239894778,
0.431928128,
0.590236187,
-0.2141163647,
0.4417150021,
0.2643469572,
-0.8295686245,
-1.0068244934,
0.3653959036,
-0.633810699,
-0.1787108332,
1.4009596109,
0.1879004389,
-0.2244909853,
-0.2633823156,
-0.6117830276,
0.3502218127,
-0.3982824683,
1.0055232048,
1.0795555115,
0.049875211,
-0.164360866,
-0.8588961363,
0.7974800467,
0.5944409966,
-0.6214528084,
0.3571051657,
0.5571383834,
0.2550422251,
-0.0073561245,
0.8001950383,
-0.0797253251,
-0.0437667929,
-0.2896109223,
0.0728943795,
0.3953860104,
-0.0697059631,
-0.5292183161,
-0.0970490724,
0.0740520805,
0.1244831458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08598v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08598v2
|
DALA: A Distribution-Aware LoRA-Based Adversarial Attack against Language Models
| 2023-11-14T23:43:47 | 2024-02-17T19:14:20 |
Yibo Wang, Xiangjue Dong, James Caverlee, Philip S. Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models (LMs) can be manipulated by adversarial attacks, which
introduce subtle perturbations to input data. While recent attack methods can
achieve a relatively high attack success rate (ASR), we've observed that the
generated adversarial examples have a different data distribution compared with
the original examples. Specifically, these adversarial examples exhibit reduced
confidence levels and greater divergence from the training data distribution.
Consequently, they are easy to detect using straightforward detection methods,
diminishing the efficacy of such attacks. To address this issue, we propose a
Distribution-Aware LoRA-based Adversarial Attack (DALA) method. DALA considers
distribution shifts of adversarial examples to improve the attack's
effectiveness under detection methods. We further design a novel evaluation
metric, the Non-detectable Attack Success Rate (NASR), which integrates both
ASR and detectability for the attack task. We conduct experiments on four
widely used datasets to validate the attack effectiveness and transferability
of adversarial examples generated by DALA against both the white-box BERT-base
model and the black-box LLaMA2-7b model. Our codes are available at
https://anonymous.4open.science/r/DALA-A16D/.
|
[
-0.3498906493,
-1.2096487284,
0.1954886317,
0.2832172513,
-0.2176068425,
-0.0846859515,
-0.0510954,
-0.2270197421,
0.3280379474,
0.5004371405,
-0.2470014691,
-0.5422261357,
-0.8818376064,
-0.118667163,
-0.9654192328,
0.8244342208,
0.3009830415,
-0.1972953975,
0.2911324799,
-0.2993255854,
-0.2099046111,
-0.5196031928,
-0.8164806962,
-0.1404533982,
0.6740986109,
-0.1158985496,
0.8724310398,
0.5588561893,
0.6027386785,
0.3012189269,
-0.4217833281,
-0.0935380906,
-0.5352780819,
0.0144011723,
0.0410638638,
-0.7822761536,
-0.5696511865,
-0.1812515259,
0.5926896334,
0.582124114,
-0.2955940366,
-0.0477363355,
-0.2530263066,
0.8118149638,
-0.97164011,
-0.2668605149,
-0.936199069,
-0.0095118433,
-0.4437050223,
0.0069148759,
-0.7053614259,
-0.3992411196,
-0.104733929,
-0.3429651558,
0.1054959223,
-0.4186524153,
0.4757042527,
0.4248532653,
-0.3990058899,
-0.4461053312,
-0.6198534369,
0.4604481757,
-0.828494668,
0.0928656161,
0.2385496348,
0.603839159,
-0.4751160443,
-0.2087700516,
-0.7306902409,
-0.1152417287,
0.3346771002,
0.0408174656,
-0.6202625632,
-0.4286982417,
0.1769326776,
0.0991952792,
-0.4626383185,
0.1085363626,
-0.0939289853,
0.326551646,
0.6817530394,
-0.1044815481,
0.4648509324,
0.1633967459,
-0.4075468779,
-0.3199536204,
-0.9681413174,
-0.2991579473,
0.7455792427,
0.3315621912,
-0.3528855741,
0.5291416049,
-0.0566004328,
0.662530899,
0.0694443956,
-0.0345495939,
0.2556574643,
-0.0385036878,
-0.2434957772,
0.0057405829,
0.9304172993,
-0.1559930444,
0.0828388855,
-0.2039084285,
-0.3804924488,
0.4273061156,
0.3344649076,
-0.5042726994,
-0.3660101891,
0.1157136858,
-0.2178198397,
-0.713463366,
-0.2784206271,
-0.9024238586,
-0.934954226,
0.445269078,
0.4679587185,
-0.298450917,
-0.3165475726,
0.0453414097,
0.0332044922,
0.2022166401,
0.0450809151,
-0.7411196828,
0.2707782984,
0.4237682223,
0.5048870444,
-0.0584804341,
-0.1021455079,
-0.601908505,
0.1661505401,
-0.4658208191,
0.9468125701,
-0.0581090637,
-0.4391353428,
0.0380358808,
-0.3377594948,
-0.1789434254,
-0.6242944598,
0.4991764426,
-0.9414235353,
-0.0692318082,
-0.0171335824,
-0.3516537547,
-0.0519678891,
0.3600974679,
-0.9835986495,
0.6176116467,
-0.0554381572,
-0.9393456578,
0.0154539794,
-0.9037981629,
-0.4891276658,
-0.2546699047,
0.0384551808,
-0.4748769403,
-0.0173141137,
0.2815737128,
0.2615207732,
-0.1519262493,
-0.1455025971,
-0.5755727291,
-0.2738001049,
0.6408643126,
-0.9304086566,
1.0111068487,
0.2695784867,
-0.3626124263,
-0.0769831911,
-0.9278162122,
-0.0470790043,
0.6431029439,
-0.2536173165,
-0.521713078,
0.0169453118,
-0.207619071,
-0.2219934016,
0.3230061829,
-0.2675473988,
0.3022604287,
-0.6531943083,
-0.0511459038,
0.7517926693,
0.0114731248,
0.4278008342,
0.0467003845,
0.5167287588,
-0.0403567776,
0.3913341463,
0.3872612417,
-0.3652039468,
-0.683067143,
-0.3171044588,
0.4214294553,
0.5459122062,
-0.9380874634,
0.3708491325,
-0.1289943904,
-0.6492054462,
-0.4369257987,
0.2714186907,
0.3405633867,
0.0610126704,
0.0699846521,
-0.1251317114,
-0.3270412385,
-0.5580593348,
-0.215719223,
-0.2328816205,
0.3864915073,
-0.0753299966,
0.3852256238,
-0.4168657362,
0.813339293,
-0.5855942965,
-0.1089138687,
-0.488845557,
-0.0803383961,
0.1858618706,
0.0112916259,
0.6646782756,
-0.7918995023,
-0.5821714401,
-0.0491289608,
-0.9327446818,
-0.2171853036,
0.1902376711,
-0.0101524051,
0.3002662957,
0.0974019542,
-0.5688858032,
0.4981456101,
0.730280757,
-0.3895019591,
0.2594597638,
-0.3222046793,
-0.1970304996,
-1.2210428715,
-0.0826501697,
-0.2154024094,
0.0478801876,
-0.9918702245,
0.2473422587,
0.0711377412,
0.0942026153,
-0.7284769416,
0.6128991842,
-0.0469706319,
-0.2341418415,
-0.4211079478,
0.2940493524,
-0.1855333149,
0.1523278654,
-0.3484814167,
0.6403563023,
0.4666474164,
-0.5926218629,
0.3764181137,
0.1892959774,
-0.4206261635,
0.6374579668,
-0.6797702909,
0.23104918,
0.0647082552,
0.2669453025,
-0.7690200806,
0.1870517582,
0.4990873933,
-0.4776626527,
0.1866170019,
-0.1392530203,
-0.5517718196,
0.1357348114,
-0.2163406461,
0.2434042245,
0.522898078,
-0.8234316707,
0.4772405028,
0.2913466692,
0.1379732043,
-1.0843042135,
-0.4770553112,
0.1483129561,
-0.5143826604,
-0.6031965613,
-0.1126624122,
-0.2876112461,
-0.501111269,
-0.1842714101,
0.1640639603,
-0.2114631534,
0.5813017488,
0.0817598328,
0.1783307046,
0.0176547524,
-0.4495612085,
-0.3973075151,
-0.0766600668,
0.1987188458,
0.2770755589,
0.6411457658,
0.2742420435,
-0.6624769568,
-0.4075250924,
0.1583492607,
0.5816014409,
-0.0242141448,
0.9444330931,
0.5790159702,
-0.3880714178,
-0.5828588605,
-0.1703719795,
0.0119918119,
-0.460291326,
0.3782067895,
-0.4903220236,
-0.0153342988,
0.5126630068,
0.214025721,
-0.0619981475,
0.2825159132,
0.4297646582,
0.0128108701,
1.0036479235,
0.4651828706,
-0.4396966994,
0.5735487938,
-0.605056107,
0.2952546477,
-0.7155780792,
0.0553726368,
-0.4371173978,
-0.0833573267,
-0.2675768137,
-0.2565678954,
0.1178456098,
0.0605155043,
-0.0852205679,
0.4275765419,
-0.0781780258,
0.4044288397,
0.2351743132,
-0.0147832474,
0.2368165553,
0.0693353191,
0.3508738875,
0.4301690757,
-0.5835567117,
-0.3440704346,
1.3237733841,
0.3956730068,
1.0660246611,
0.6064797044,
0.6769984961,
0.8024622202,
0.4128533006,
-0.4127295613,
0.6730550528,
-0.495443821,
-0.1937838197,
-0.2082753032,
-0.5061240196,
-1.0517846346,
0.2171495408,
0.0418212153,
-0.4557216465,
0.2303228825,
-0.0720473751,
-0.1352101862,
0.4865328968,
-0.7123810649,
0.7025790811,
-0.1528736204,
0.2707242072,
-0.0433014147,
-0.0832277983,
0.400696218,
-0.3223477006,
0.4077768028,
-0.046989385,
0.1971535683,
0.6878627539,
-0.3678004146,
0.9632380009,
-0.3891325891,
-0.6196035147,
0.1821592897,
0.1942332834,
1.0793056488,
-0.0940159112,
-0.0692966282,
0.1260153055,
-0.2487010211,
-0.4270870984,
-0.9749053717,
0.7008219361,
-0.898638308,
-0.4801589847,
-0.4114338756,
-0.5513602495,
0.0117700463,
-0.2093690038,
0.1073800325,
0.1572863907,
-0.274790436,
-0.0141891893,
0.6733366847,
-0.0700763687,
0.2546526194,
0.734349668,
-0.0563046336,
-0.3783418536,
1.0667837858,
-0.0541669689,
0.7143629789,
0.4087599814,
-0.0331134088,
-0.3835171461,
-0.6993685961,
-0.4399425387,
0.2003259063,
-0.9952246547,
-0.0667184666,
-0.4211393893,
-0.2612380087,
-0.4020068645,
-0.1285844296,
-0.5217406154,
-0.1794754118,
-0.1459046453,
0.3101167679,
0.4240413904,
0.9102363586,
0.1518234909,
0.6731349826,
-0.1018468887,
0.4183589816,
0.3752333522,
0.0834929869,
-0.1259896904,
-0.6426264644,
0.0086130118,
0.3755639195,
-0.1474464536,
-0.9131142497,
0.5426369905,
-0.1157852262,
0.3563791811,
0.4836320579,
0.1822590679,
0.3174135983,
-0.2712819576,
0.5109156966,
0.1252014339,
-0.7469184399,
0.5695918202,
-0.0520084761,
0.1092078239,
0.0782473981,
-0.2021129727,
-0.080320552,
-0.3558706343,
-0.7116906643,
-0.3698323071,
0.5348905325,
0.4250358045,
-0.0138559258,
0.0514516681,
-0.0085961986,
-0.192293033,
-0.1181636453,
-0.7779690027,
-0.6756727099,
-0.0293826889,
-0.2204955965,
-0.0621816218,
-0.1002086326,
-0.2432261854,
0.5677468181,
0.7268210649,
-0.0777594596,
0.0769460648,
-0.1734290123,
-0.0994732454,
0.2154319435,
0.6302598715,
0.3337002099,
0.3507790864,
-0.2061275393,
0.1215212196,
0.3172126114,
-0.5493013859,
0.4715515375,
0.271091938,
-0.4511370957,
-0.100708276,
0.1837688833,
0.5311000347,
-0.1450645626,
-0.6793173552,
0.6222699285,
-0.4261120558,
0.1318223476,
-0.4282358885,
0.1783082485,
0.0375696532,
0.482631892,
0.1681941897,
0.0466767587,
-0.0113195451,
-0.4349551201,
-0.085196875,
0.8696757555,
-0.3125576973,
-0.2938276827,
0.3370649219,
-0.0521709882,
-0.4126529098,
0.0823111162,
-0.3729835451,
-0.421481818,
0.8813179731,
0.8907789588,
0.7266808748,
-0.4134816229,
0.3517585695,
-0.3842401206,
0.3893553317,
-0.043421071,
0.2180347443,
0.2413827181,
-0.8870140314,
0.0421432033,
-0.4137194157,
-0.2720706761,
0.2550543547,
-0.5563628674,
0.167879045,
-0.4731220305,
-0.1267977208,
0.1582820266,
-0.1048574448,
-0.3591908514,
0.1725622416,
0.0449092574,
0.7616702914,
-0.7676344514,
0.9089185596,
0.427051872,
-0.2438360453,
-0.2629505396,
-0.0120187989,
-0.1535809636,
-0.8010957837,
0.7148217559,
-0.2849493921,
-0.0966917798,
-0.2884569466,
-0.2317498177,
-0.8564861417,
1.0365445614,
0.6835796237,
-0.254969418,
0.2218096703,
0.2575101256,
0.4666825235,
-0.2044639736,
0.082523331,
0.5214029551,
0.146155566,
0.0742357522,
-0.4744669795,
-0.0946690068,
-0.207263127,
-0.1275380254,
0.3100197315,
-0.4945782423,
0.8257142901,
-0.1963056028,
-0.3028188944,
0.1252079755,
0.5574730635,
0.4384084344,
0.3805812895,
0.7608523965,
0.740432322,
0.668757081,
0.1282507777,
1.241055727,
-0.157131508,
0.1941113919,
0.955164969,
-0.5444051623,
1.055582881,
0.3405575454,
-0.3498808742,
0.3497986495,
0.2406425029,
0.1581618339,
0.8512979746,
0.2498759478,
-0.5483800769,
0.1877459884,
-0.0474940576,
-0.5593304634,
0.2819370031,
0.4036331177,
-0.3287406862,
-0.2308232486,
0.0091105038,
0.1265158653,
0.0696827248,
-0.0777719915,
0.6962726116,
-0.0520953722,
-0.0350299999,
1.0536874533,
0.0494333804,
0.5963656306,
-0.8399621844,
0.1584394425,
-0.4234186113,
0.5601240993,
0.0163825843,
-0.4709199667,
0.1011555269,
0.2474077493,
-0.2978000343,
0.4532570839,
0.4783072174,
-0.2059359401,
-0.4724881351,
0.4970602095,
0.4373314679,
0.1346188486,
-0.0561316162,
-0.6256844997,
0.3132678866,
0.0397396795,
-0.2070595771,
0.5956878066,
0.2843317986,
0.0267389677,
1.0540688038,
0.767731607,
0.4403634369,
0.0108704213,
0.4250418544,
0.6252061129,
-0.3907198906,
-0.4631202221,
-0.8699601293,
-0.0862111524,
-0.0569613725,
0.0536935963,
0.7533527017,
0.2061619759,
0.4078256786,
0.0753986239,
0.9796794653,
0.0175590329,
0.296423912,
-0.4838311076,
0.9127257466,
-0.2569734454,
0.8612152338,
-0.2523276806,
-0.7931838632,
-0.1664035916,
0.3469881415,
-0.3536550701,
-0.1287655681,
0.5942029953,
0.7834557891,
-0.0149781778,
-0.0928233936,
0.4125756919,
0.4339089692,
0.5900262594,
0.6346727014,
0.860294044,
-0.7340230942,
0.7822890282,
-0.224336639,
-0.1096017361,
-0.0002855933,
-0.7305637598,
-1.0693911314,
-0.2058600187,
-0.3435704112,
-0.3822179735,
0.5699871778,
0.4396128953,
0.4434616566,
-0.681184411,
-0.1129958406,
0.0352516808,
0.1875227541,
-0.1481708586,
-0.2155285031,
0.7001572251,
-0.0897510648,
-0.5921060443,
0.7278894186,
-0.1403797716,
0.2477294058,
-0.5421616435,
-0.0649654344,
-0.2859911621,
0.3552650213,
0.3943310678,
0.2674191296,
-0.7037311792,
-0.0240084454,
-0.3040358424,
-0.2258754373,
-0.3055635095,
0.111910589,
-0.6876553297,
0.2791858613,
0.2450949997,
0.8577384353,
-0.2089528888,
-0.0321171135,
0.3753075302,
-0.7610290051,
0.109153308,
-0.1803717017,
0.4594288468,
0.428940922,
-0.3827881217,
0.4792938828,
0.2335872948,
-0.2426821589,
-1.0881055593,
0.0190123934,
-0.8983494043,
-0.2168765664,
1.2872554064,
-0.3051598668,
-0.4647669792,
0.0787266791,
-0.069076471,
0.043936424,
-0.4233714342,
1.1170637608,
0.3420033157,
0.3807817698,
0.2988864779,
-0.4283275306,
0.3798901141,
0.3573873937,
-1.1795862913,
0.2397984862,
0.0294376016,
0.291826874,
0.2158564031,
0.5062393546,
0.0143651869,
0.2104025632,
0.1225997061,
-0.0956851318,
0.1330063641,
-0.2070740461,
-0.5904448032,
0.3851875067,
0.0155854663,
-0.372556746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08596v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08596v2
|
Are You Sure? Challenging LLMs Leads to Performance Drops in The FlipFlop Experiment
| 2023-11-14T23:40:22 | 2024-02-21T18:15:47 |
Philippe Laban, Lidiya Murakhovs'ka, Caiming Xiong, Chien-Sheng Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The interactive nature of Large Language Models (LLMs) theoretically allows
models to refine and improve their answers, yet systematic analysis of the
multi-turn behavior of LLMs remains limited. In this paper, we propose the
FlipFlop experiment: in the first round of the conversation, an LLM completes a
classification task. In a second round, the LLM is challenged with a follow-up
phrase like "Are you sure?", offering an opportunity for the model to reflect
on its initial answer, and decide whether to confirm or flip its answer. A
systematic study of ten LLMs on seven classification tasks reveals that models
flip their answers on average 46% of the time and that all models see a
deterioration of accuracy between their first and final prediction, with an
average drop of 17% (the FlipFlop effect). We conduct finetuning experiments on
an open-source LLM and find that finetuning on synthetically created data can
mitigate - reducing performance deterioration by 60% - but not resolve
sycophantic behavior entirely. The FlipFlop experiment illustrates the
universality of sycophantic behavior in LLMs and provides a robust framework to
analyze model behavior and evaluate future models.
|
[
-0.4501875639,
-1.1674431562,
0.649371326,
0.0874073803,
-0.1906755567,
-0.0406099111,
-0.1959816664,
-0.4534711242,
0.0806865096,
0.6609604955,
-0.6812685728,
-0.1522821635,
-0.548502624,
0.0996186137,
-0.8288223743,
1.1641377211,
0.1805408001,
0.276520431,
-0.5143182278,
0.1221106425,
-0.1987714022,
-0.5751806498,
-0.6501608491,
-0.5712637901,
0.1888665706,
0.5140890479,
0.7710698247,
0.2970520556,
0.6486452818,
0.3069490194,
-0.4087651074,
0.0499667265,
-0.6486136913,
0.0874945968,
-0.1126113459,
-1.0269260406,
-0.3845207393,
0.2599538267,
0.4902442992,
0.8356643319,
-0.3933689296,
0.1985786855,
0.1249480024,
0.4796329141,
-0.5321170688,
-0.1393819302,
-0.643212676,
0.0940689594,
-0.2279099226,
-0.132538408,
-0.5945789218,
-0.4173650146,
0.1343749166,
-0.5177990794,
0.3260754347,
-0.0857068077,
0.5871921778,
0.1329526156,
-0.2901179492,
-0.2911218107,
-1.0376734734,
0.5504615307,
-0.9386823177,
0.0658564195,
0.1857455075,
0.223311305,
-0.2400311977,
-0.7223209143,
-0.8692116737,
-0.3185588717,
0.2079318762,
0.0902916938,
-0.0272878557,
0.131824404,
0.3832295835,
0.2182237506,
-0.2912923992,
0.170798853,
-0.0787734017,
-0.4468285739,
0.5890322924,
0.3757947087,
0.2348067611,
0.0914731398,
-0.2697772086,
-0.1402877122,
-0.5729345083,
0.3780486584,
0.2024680823,
0.2360816896,
0.0449146405,
0.8692888618,
-0.0216010418,
0.3322078586,
0.1569257826,
-0.0768047199,
0.0929317474,
-0.2217347026,
-0.1993748993,
-0.1392691433,
0.6205863953,
0.4381077588,
0.5727795959,
-0.0150997778,
-0.4367891252,
-0.014363843,
0.2352205366,
-0.5730634332,
-0.1855102181,
0.4067565203,
-0.1029876024,
-0.4369344413,
0.1065266281,
-0.3780154586,
-0.4894455075,
-0.0632245243,
0.8298179507,
-0.435097307,
-0.3728849888,
0.4074953198,
0.0676110461,
0.186397627,
0.4301544428,
-0.5912610888,
0.5055407286,
1.146877408,
0.8632945418,
-0.4364562035,
-0.4277997911,
-0.7718983293,
-0.0429741591,
-0.4718413949,
0.7782883644,
-0.3738814592,
-0.6652969718,
-0.0018371344,
-0.1083014309,
-0.1576271504,
-0.8318045735,
0.5389736295,
-0.3832836449,
0.2209597826,
-0.1980201602,
-0.7698938847,
0.1265884936,
0.3369066119,
-0.5038609505,
0.7251369953,
-0.6053548455,
-0.9631155133,
0.168022573,
-0.233933121,
-0.3903635144,
-0.0610654093,
-0.3823119104,
-0.617942512,
0.4176598489,
-0.0424598418,
0.3197982907,
0.0364982821,
0.1633948386,
-0.5895562172,
-0.5990294218,
0.9187585115,
-0.3388945758,
0.6089026928,
-0.0933854952,
-0.4937144816,
0.0303777363,
-0.5211732984,
0.2579409182,
0.0462697707,
-0.4129070342,
-0.162981227,
-0.0404741764,
-0.076928176,
0.1777177602,
0.057672359,
-0.6155564189,
0.5052822828,
-0.3875449896,
0.1880733818,
0.8677853346,
0.0706046149,
0.3111615181,
-0.5529905558,
0.6448112726,
0.2476669252,
0.1574575454,
0.0571947433,
-0.6797940135,
-1.144318819,
0.0055274121,
0.1821474135,
0.6640739441,
-0.7728263736,
-0.237282142,
-0.2017558664,
-0.3362018764,
-0.6193697453,
-0.0895390958,
0.4078551531,
0.5448064208,
0.1804397404,
-0.123497121,
-0.2011372596,
-1.1227558851,
-0.410074532,
-0.2004705817,
-0.0467265099,
0.1506139189,
0.4434117973,
-0.1196603552,
0.9892704487,
-0.5618500113,
-0.1053099632,
-0.3186707497,
0.5079829693,
0.1344676763,
0.2191249877,
0.1670032293,
-0.5245995522,
-0.0109620187,
-0.1750439405,
-0.458966434,
-0.1588856578,
-0.0703043565,
0.1565942168,
0.4562107623,
0.3762445152,
-0.8490803242,
0.3208241761,
0.4161356986,
-0.2606380582,
0.7317637801,
-0.2332553416,
-0.0075901202,
-0.6081969738,
0.013196406,
-0.2150054872,
-0.2693637311,
-0.8279438615,
-0.040489696,
-0.0422666371,
0.0163376126,
-0.4569960237,
0.2318914086,
-0.0728515908,
0.0014547684,
-0.20199503,
0.1650231332,
-0.2115431428,
0.0838683695,
0.1522782147,
0.82623595,
0.5196577907,
-0.7976004481,
0.0170760192,
0.0013446911,
-0.4267576933,
0.4314940572,
-0.6634181738,
0.3087792695,
-0.1427688003,
0.030468259,
-1.156018734,
-0.2738986015,
-0.0237762872,
-0.4564019442,
0.1523577571,
0.1051922441,
-0.3339112401,
-0.382073909,
-0.4355585277,
0.0480121225,
0.3656722605,
-0.2748356462,
0.4587038159,
0.2140136957,
-0.182328105,
-0.5621628165,
-0.9399499893,
-0.0960778669,
-0.0412069932,
-0.6959574223,
0.0005556991,
-0.2829222381,
-0.429743588,
-0.1911024749,
-0.219149828,
0.0371891744,
0.2918882966,
0.215414837,
0.1213380322,
-0.0063263276,
0.0826835334,
-0.1847838759,
-0.0575846918,
0.327937007,
0.0588395111,
0.561139524,
-0.4092286527,
-0.5905560255,
-0.5172827244,
0.0890052989,
0.7663102746,
-0.0173650868,
0.5351077318,
0.2983124852,
-0.196801275,
-0.3667479157,
-0.6232792139,
-0.4154978991,
-0.5244316459,
0.2582908571,
-0.3643665016,
-0.7819763422,
0.6509952545,
-0.1203011125,
0.0856110454,
0.1708236337,
0.409625411,
-0.5032880306,
1.1243549585,
0.7461631894,
0.3130055368,
0.0072997962,
-0.4025756121,
0.1407281756,
-0.4228460491,
-0.4555913508,
-0.3643552661,
-0.3605662286,
-0.6719099283,
-0.3992298245,
0.5787487626,
0.2129038125,
0.0718303919,
-0.2136363983,
-0.3114640713,
0.3201922178,
0.3418433964,
0.0650184751,
0.6002396941,
-0.3438369334,
-0.1657648534,
-0.1139008924,
-0.6555624604,
-0.5234356523,
0.8058642149,
0.3919835985,
0.8916851878,
0.0550721735,
0.9187707901,
0.152715072,
0.364646554,
-0.7543497682,
0.9208042622,
0.1343391985,
-0.6211981773,
-0.4155030251,
-0.517406404,
-0.7331732512,
0.0307182912,
-0.3894256055,
-0.362105608,
-0.0345041752,
0.3757103384,
-0.1933164448,
0.3205197453,
-0.4315982759,
0.6037670374,
-0.3939324319,
-0.1914491653,
-0.261473,
-0.4160507917,
0.5043437481,
-0.0765987337,
0.5122547746,
-0.1296173632,
-0.2164241225,
0.6844084859,
-0.4947840273,
0.7601504326,
-0.0825603679,
-0.2535003424,
0.5020801425,
0.5806072354,
0.56253016,
0.1900062114,
-0.0943937153,
0.0122759845,
0.107247211,
-0.1599560082,
-0.7295426726,
0.6187003255,
-0.6981577277,
-0.7403885722,
-0.4099490643,
-0.2987258732,
-0.3235682547,
0.1678884476,
0.3893889487,
0.1593358815,
-0.0938569978,
-0.1647741199,
0.73626858,
0.0846309066,
0.4289055765,
0.6454821229,
-0.7422556877,
-0.2281236351,
0.839531064,
0.3189240396,
0.4532423019,
0.0686621517,
0.4925245643,
-0.1003965661,
-0.766706109,
-0.0912805796,
0.3222229481,
-0.5991615057,
0.0355663225,
-0.4300099909,
0.0147069208,
-0.2712820768,
0.0621015802,
-0.4972560704,
-0.8079093695,
-0.1466176063,
-0.1173244566,
0.2756884098,
0.9381734729,
0.0491188914,
0.1187432706,
-0.4661263525,
0.1471600831,
0.4084243178,
0.4447511137,
-0.0909251943,
-0.6274558902,
-0.0178611372,
0.2322065234,
-0.3539597094,
-0.8020654917,
0.1640194207,
0.3140338659,
0.480039835,
0.3240800202,
0.0170181617,
0.4467907548,
-0.3364586234,
0.7880308628,
0.0582182594,
-1.0027208328,
0.5148444176,
-0.3764802516,
0.4066483378,
0.4969871342,
0.4940819442,
-0.661655426,
-0.6792915463,
-0.5708260536,
-0.6734210849,
0.480873704,
0.0806043223,
0.1489568949,
-0.0631282926,
0.6937114596,
0.1462147087,
0.3984754682,
-0.8459529877,
-0.3002428412,
0.0785261765,
0.2505564094,
-0.0752398148,
-0.1594978869,
-0.0892824009,
-0.0949523896,
0.5438955426,
-0.1332011372,
0.008790086,
0.1980634928,
-0.1187614128,
-0.1804901212,
0.2659800053,
0.7590888739,
0.6352760196,
-0.2955613732,
0.227174446,
0.3140792251,
-0.621385932,
0.0323335901,
-0.401953727,
-0.5681527853,
-0.0290704798,
0.6519781351,
0.5339224935,
0.3088209331,
-0.7974385619,
0.5718626976,
-0.0269666221,
-0.1818341911,
-0.2007431686,
0.2521030605,
0.3184373379,
0.1238865927,
0.5064537525,
0.0070948987,
0.2216610163,
-0.7268544436,
0.3272792399,
0.5419579148,
-0.0776551217,
-0.2206482291,
0.4933980405,
0.328615427,
-0.6261276603,
0.7359034419,
-0.0235345531,
-0.6036959887,
0.6580290198,
0.5563622117,
0.8072398305,
-0.1730008274,
0.3357280493,
-0.025452815,
0.3271777928,
-0.2061989903,
0.3781088591,
0.2619909644,
-0.6561912894,
-0.5795426965,
-0.4780477583,
-0.9336726069,
0.1756972969,
-0.8742231727,
0.3199413717,
-0.5594551563,
-0.5363637805,
-0.1916881949,
-0.133333534,
-0.3747566938,
0.139249444,
0.3336150944,
0.9242486954,
-0.7681514621,
0.5558012128,
0.7427949309,
-0.0876314566,
-0.4179468453,
0.1443584263,
0.062031135,
-0.6172676682,
0.5770077109,
0.2053801119,
-0.4564725459,
-0.2208977938,
-0.7600886822,
-0.8386242986,
0.8194563985,
0.5799717903,
-0.7333292365,
0.0677032918,
0.6251568198,
0.6945241094,
-0.1935070008,
0.4409655929,
0.6385630369,
0.4034824669,
0.0606180653,
-1.1676101685,
-0.2238945365,
-0.0554714054,
-0.1133320704,
0.1067130119,
-0.6942046285,
0.9604155421,
-0.7564620376,
-0.3125709593,
-0.0638426915,
0.5816049576,
0.2162741125,
0.6631829739,
0.5954372883,
0.6411851645,
0.8430839777,
-0.1938576996,
1.0705217123,
0.0179131366,
0.4889840782,
0.9977343678,
-0.2619435787,
1.195350647,
0.5214439034,
-0.1305526495,
0.2178379595,
0.4853036106,
0.3456106186,
0.3685763776,
0.3839265704,
-0.1936055124,
-0.7046363354,
0.2072972953,
-0.162073642,
0.459982872,
0.2078703493,
0.2916136682,
0.0505685173,
0.3653681576,
0.136964798,
0.2214799821,
-0.3830666244,
0.5670070052,
0.1079106405,
-0.5971389413,
0.6279705763,
-0.0780298859,
0.8875436783,
-0.3235063553,
0.1603751332,
-0.468396455,
0.285799861,
-0.2737230062,
-1.1219810247,
0.246982947,
-0.2299846709,
-0.1366441995,
-0.0195040759,
0.3425650895,
-0.3959220052,
-0.5950137377,
0.1059628278,
0.5580412149,
0.2640125453,
0.1377080381,
-0.5463785529,
0.3520313799,
-0.0656490326,
-0.403752774,
0.2191212326,
0.2836169004,
-0.0501003116,
1.302728653,
0.4479334056,
0.1177629009,
0.3175055981,
0.0358920209,
0.7434272766,
-0.4245327711,
-0.0800502226,
-0.8629776835,
0.3318926692,
0.0506530218,
-0.4541023076,
0.6857277155,
0.5095559955,
0.9281883836,
-0.1102951169,
0.6853227019,
0.3230005205,
0.5845807791,
-0.5742294192,
0.6414240599,
-0.4222227335,
0.3941224217,
-0.1668947488,
-0.6713822484,
-0.0566873066,
0.5132359266,
-0.4264149964,
0.0313697308,
0.5169143081,
0.5176609159,
0.069377996,
0.0642266497,
0.3410086334,
0.6597524285,
0.5331397057,
0.3479689658,
0.7856143117,
-0.1771648377,
0.6846148372,
-0.7003136277,
-0.2341074795,
-0.2814800739,
-0.8701515794,
-0.7336265445,
-0.4201549292,
-0.4910087287,
-0.3762087226,
0.0948865786,
0.6848133802,
0.3253108859,
-0.8237918615,
-0.5166217089,
0.0088978875,
0.1138959005,
-0.1910930723,
-0.2294583917,
0.038013231,
-0.2496523112,
-0.5832878947,
0.1777314246,
0.0966373459,
0.152646631,
-0.2877843678,
0.143019706,
-0.1851943433,
0.3315779269,
0.4282464385,
0.2109285295,
-0.6612951756,
-0.4143936038,
0.1538452357,
-0.2004681975,
-0.1620990485,
0.8353946209,
-0.7342911959,
0.4830547273,
0.3685650229,
0.4999185503,
0.6926307678,
0.0619597323,
0.5564550161,
-0.3267298639,
-0.1146008223,
0.4650377333,
0.0820791051,
0.2463243455,
-0.3247664571,
0.2631657422,
0.1948638409,
-0.6266025305,
-1.0514651537,
0.1837571412,
-0.8299415112,
-0.1795966327,
1.0952275991,
0.0748553053,
-0.1244802848,
0.1581192613,
-0.1552956998,
0.0843414962,
-0.0965704843,
0.9961619973,
0.8889747858,
-0.7482523322,
-0.1677379012,
-0.5246500373,
0.4909741282,
0.8199971318,
-0.680197835,
0.2216943651,
0.3097633123,
0.5323688984,
0.3395791352,
0.4906486571,
0.1224883944,
0.3417007327,
-0.3101037443,
-0.0802305862,
-0.2046695501,
-0.3028588593,
-0.4874532521,
0.2305676192,
0.333869189,
0.0014370035
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08593v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08593v1
|
ACID: Abstractive, Content-Based IDs for Document Retrieval with Language Models
| 2023-11-14T23:28:36 | 2023-11-14T23:28:36 |
Haoxin Li, Phillip Keung, Daniel Cheng, Jungo Kasai, Noah A. Smith
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Generative retrieval (Wang et al., 2022; Tay et al., 2022) is a new approach
for end-to-end document retrieval that directly generates document identifiers
given an input query. Techniques for designing effective, high-quality document
IDs remain largely unexplored. We introduce ACID, in which each document's ID
is composed of abstractive keyphrases generated by a large language model,
rather than an integer ID sequence as done in past work. We compare our method
with the current state-of-the-art technique for ID generation, which produces
IDs through hierarchical clustering of document embeddings. We also examine
simpler methods to generate natural-language document IDs, including the naive
approach of using the first k words of each document as its ID or words with
high BM25 scores in that document. We show that using ACID improves top-10 and
top-20 accuracy by 15.6% and 14.4% (relative) respectively versus the
state-of-the-art baseline on the MSMARCO 100k retrieval task, and 4.4% and 4.0%
respectively on the Natural Questions 100k retrieval task. Our results
demonstrate the effectiveness of human-readable, natural-language IDs in
generative retrieval with LMs. The code for reproducing our results and the
keyword-augmented datasets will be released on formal publication.
|
[
-0.1225107834,
-0.6167463064,
0.6973947883,
-0.4117155671,
-0.2386600673,
0.5892496109,
-0.0018275911,
-0.2045190632,
0.397459656,
0.0088260444,
-0.0814606696,
-1.0440180302,
-0.3406688273,
0.2014753968,
-0.5215335488,
0.8270508647,
0.2958500981,
-0.0784106031,
-0.4259238541,
-0.2036190778,
0.2022654563,
-0.5930424929,
-0.3151057661,
-0.177488938,
0.600903213,
0.2215363085,
0.7982538342,
0.8101435304,
0.7843768597,
0.1862800568,
-0.3806313574,
0.2509225607,
-0.4050344825,
0.4288628399,
-0.3292239606,
-0.246206969,
-0.3836202919,
-0.1264899075,
0.3698768616,
0.8385227919,
0.1750284433,
-0.0717215389,
-0.2150149047,
0.7889620066,
-0.9631187916,
0.1326881945,
-0.5901953578,
-0.055801671,
-0.4182026386,
-0.2730798125,
-0.6184334755,
-0.5588081479,
0.0769308135,
-0.7057850361,
0.2190086693,
0.0682005435,
0.8764352202,
-0.2217769921,
-0.481459707,
-0.8555424809,
-0.7609781623,
0.3848153055,
-0.5153427124,
0.2046983093,
0.4697403014,
0.1718785912,
0.0629793629,
-0.8875758648,
-0.5448477864,
0.0600414462,
0.1063185111,
0.1006996781,
0.3766515255,
0.4053321481,
0.0790949315,
0.9005064368,
-0.5987380147,
-0.0209260434,
-0.2786932588,
-0.0356800519,
0.6803853512,
0.0747352913,
0.5000110865,
-0.1088144258,
0.1188964322,
-0.1569417417,
-0.9400625825,
-0.1614180803,
0.3137750328,
0.3496674001,
0.2208111286,
0.5551536679,
-0.3553939164,
0.2299044132,
0.0161165725,
-0.22621198,
0.3973934948,
-0.5232553482,
-0.0649408996,
-0.151345402,
0.5376890302,
0.3181426227,
0.2613916993,
-0.4822996557,
-0.4407938421,
0.1595170349,
0.1220573932,
-0.9879795909,
-0.3997164369,
0.4383397698,
-0.5574364662,
-0.5860209465,
0.128720656,
-0.557549119,
-0.3933180869,
-0.3760614395,
0.3561340868,
-0.5641993284,
-0.225867182,
-0.341039896,
-0.3701383471,
0.3917014301,
0.1543650776,
-1.0373322964,
0.427149266,
0.75799191,
0.7939653397,
-0.5506407619,
0.0846956968,
-0.1614943743,
0.1328714341,
-0.9206646085,
0.5722234845,
-0.7126303315,
-0.6671728492,
0.4086538553,
-0.1065647975,
0.3269490004,
-0.8456500769,
0.4096602798,
-0.8690010309,
-0.0827143863,
-0.458796978,
-0.5927813053,
0.2462837845,
0.2771327496,
-0.6491058469,
1.039965868,
0.0313826539,
-0.4214444757,
0.1804649234,
-0.5484110117,
-0.6200443506,
0.2773962617,
-0.5179784298,
-0.1619141549,
0.0863241702,
-0.0292331036,
-0.093266286,
-0.3976954222,
0.3403648734,
-0.0815338194,
-0.2835487127,
0.0976503938,
-0.2391004413,
0.3963696659,
0.512563467,
0.1963490546,
0.0395556502,
-0.7274852395,
0.1003052741,
0.2379116267,
-0.5274348855,
-0.523857832,
-0.1534475237,
0.1000364721,
0.0083279563,
0.2707241476,
-0.6206618547,
0.2979112267,
-0.3410508037,
0.1989092678,
0.6810413599,
0.2833462954,
0.6745553613,
-0.4688533843,
0.5540169477,
-0.1442056298,
-0.2326434702,
-0.700045526,
-0.3677506149,
-0.4706977606,
-0.2316094041,
0.5564533472,
0.3196024597,
-0.6522424221,
0.3860494196,
-0.5698285103,
-0.5076012015,
-0.6016178727,
0.0338755772,
0.501301825,
0.2024619281,
0.2735396922,
-0.5083343387,
-0.2005728036,
-0.6636932492,
-0.0750583261,
-0.0515569821,
-0.0999367833,
0.5435238481,
0.538559556,
-0.1137475967,
0.8753646612,
-0.5642541647,
-0.0724972337,
-0.067312561,
0.4664654732,
0.1145288423,
0.3463472724,
0.3032083213,
-0.7739073038,
-0.6644103527,
0.0274524838,
-0.8429706693,
0.039102193,
0.1627363116,
-0.2368353158,
0.340174526,
0.4649847746,
-0.7910907865,
0.3213222027,
-0.1812682301,
-0.1120421663,
0.3302983642,
-0.205124855,
0.1197549477,
-1.0590487719,
0.4514640868,
-0.2236490995,
0.0428044051,
-0.468120724,
0.5661945939,
0.1936183423,
-0.7290890813,
-0.3676180542,
0.5155215859,
-0.6324750781,
-0.1571147591,
-0.305467397,
0.119959332,
0.2561014891,
0.4549100697,
-0.1034763455,
0.8840476274,
0.4146299064,
-0.5334879756,
0.2281655818,
0.1930490136,
-0.3248718083,
0.6483487487,
-0.6211619973,
0.5330768824,
-0.7044996619,
0.2609143555,
-1.0123082399,
-0.1477185935,
-0.1074644476,
-0.5385704041,
0.5580615997,
-0.1954754889,
-0.5454389453,
-0.1189452559,
-0.511852026,
0.5845163465,
0.5255361199,
-0.5851711631,
0.4594554901,
0.471069932,
-0.3643268347,
-0.4370588064,
-0.2921564877,
0.2573577166,
0.0878503621,
-0.3655291796,
0.991384387,
-0.2828682959,
-0.272277087,
0.1304442137,
-0.3460461199,
-0.2086849213,
0.0919944495,
0.0890902653,
0.1060241461,
0.0126950266,
0.380733639,
0.0060564857,
-0.1281391233,
-0.0319894776,
-0.0934355259,
0.5861923695,
0.2510271072,
-0.330096066,
-0.3753717244,
0.7023400068,
1.1325000525,
-0.6012964249,
0.278213352,
-0.0546632409,
-0.6742857695,
-0.0815950781,
-0.0637868047,
-0.1954807788,
-0.4256305695,
0.1037209332,
-0.8353680968,
-0.1626802981,
0.5848510265,
-0.1896678805,
0.0604422688,
0.2065470666,
0.4568284154,
-0.3001288772,
1.0090157986,
0.1182309836,
-0.3229523301,
0.2673004568,
-0.6265720725,
0.3276187181,
-0.8051745892,
-0.3268350661,
-0.6382749081,
-0.4302185774,
-0.4514843524,
-0.3407384753,
0.1885357648,
-0.06629581,
-0.0761615485,
-0.1617057025,
-0.422007978,
0.4862104356,
0.5559380651,
-0.0858118758,
0.2968012393,
-0.1964396536,
-0.391187489,
0.011075954,
-0.0923457816,
-0.325065732,
1.4980885983,
0.0713237375,
1.0175316334,
0.3758172095,
0.8844296336,
0.5367256403,
0.3098768592,
-0.8371401429,
0.3427370787,
0.0584655181,
-0.7168279886,
-0.0411909148,
0.0438714847,
-1.0000127554,
0.1850427687,
-0.0372725278,
-0.4181353748,
0.2559574544,
-0.2127078921,
-0.2996533513,
-0.2078959495,
-0.4818388224,
0.6785794497,
-0.3208344579,
-0.2411897779,
-0.0629691482,
-0.518777132,
-0.0113227759,
0.0853857398,
0.0824967325,
-0.0333337076,
-0.1009997278,
0.549767077,
-0.5804113746,
0.3771626651,
-0.1042105556,
-0.0760575533,
0.3533929884,
0.0914479494,
0.7722514868,
-0.0837543085,
-0.2349555641,
-0.5223242044,
-0.0337535925,
-0.2957939804,
-0.8941371441,
0.919449985,
-0.5190045834,
-0.5457018018,
-0.5140087605,
-0.4530141354,
0.1996212602,
0.410526067,
0.391225785,
0.7132132649,
-0.1628817469,
0.3733676076,
0.9436523914,
-0.0917780325,
0.3833049238,
0.3657317758,
-0.2739155591,
-0.4005149305,
1.2132399082,
0.4116461575,
0.2407257259,
0.5143628716,
-0.0553767346,
-0.3988372386,
-0.7360317111,
-0.2655948699,
0.1553586572,
-0.906819284,
-0.3108310997,
-0.592715323,
-0.396938324,
-0.6791046858,
-0.0223679915,
-0.3467139006,
-0.3069992363,
-0.2613927126,
-0.3840503097,
0.1410034895,
0.4256666899,
0.2170094252,
-0.1694784015,
-0.4427027106,
0.7527561188,
0.0865642577,
0.4289777875,
-0.0309858657,
-0.2642706037,
-0.0806528181,
-0.2298079431,
-0.3964089155,
-1.2680286169,
0.4077238441,
0.4957003295,
0.4507525265,
0.6151833534,
0.5504526496,
0.1924028397,
-0.2621673942,
0.4753657877,
-0.5502365232,
-0.6017677188,
0.7559207082,
-0.3575552106,
0.3576508462,
0.9822112918,
0.6985260844,
-0.5853360891,
-0.2863060832,
-0.5254276991,
-1.096993804,
0.2668492198,
0.0950027257,
0.2880885899,
-0.420943141,
0.3040810823,
-0.0186444446,
0.1921791136,
-0.4713326693,
-0.4960343838,
0.2276697159,
-0.6904537678,
0.4378972054,
-0.3153172135,
-0.0794040412,
-0.2430590242,
0.6407744884,
-0.3115861118,
0.2153091729,
0.194875434,
-0.3274235725,
0.1984559894,
0.2143775523,
0.1881427914,
0.7027354836,
-0.6876088381,
0.1989331692,
-0.5545915961,
-0.4432506561,
0.2462338358,
-0.0407214127,
-0.635892272,
0.2826587856,
-0.0510032848,
0.291375488,
-0.0165301133,
-0.6945499778,
0.5788390636,
-0.0846197084,
-0.1143981889,
-0.5530892611,
-0.2434070855,
0.0279307589,
-0.2421334386,
0.6085555553,
-0.293643117,
0.3349363804,
-0.8728151917,
0.1463929862,
0.613486588,
-0.1752500236,
-0.2128439695,
0.5367154479,
0.6143987775,
-0.7074127197,
0.8210328221,
-0.614606142,
-0.1675305218,
0.6018228531,
0.6939285994,
0.7764633894,
0.0138278492,
0.003379121,
0.3829848766,
0.1009452865,
0.2647299469,
0.6440368295,
-0.4045403302,
-0.6642884016,
0.1951327771,
-0.4639869034,
-0.3836838007,
0.4007871747,
-0.4597870111,
0.1505516171,
-0.6098172069,
0.0000772968,
0.0201182663,
0.0597447269,
-0.3980849683,
0.2616733611,
0.0762779638,
1.0908619165,
-0.75300318,
0.8607183695,
0.6993900537,
-0.8315876126,
-0.1944658756,
0.1270532161,
0.0415898338,
-0.3431884348,
0.2484980822,
0.1833568811,
0.3447345197,
0.2983881533,
-0.1431551278,
-1.2218194008,
1.4005110264,
-0.1282821,
-0.2066972852,
-0.2165644616,
0.0725561529,
0.6313922405,
-0.3097316027,
0.4339286089,
0.5596122146,
0.1986171752,
0.1532478482,
-0.3251456916,
0.0816043168,
-0.8413917422,
0.2524672449,
0.2132773399,
-0.1039586142,
0.6104480624,
-0.2101467699,
-0.7171776891,
0.353761375,
0.6499860287,
0.2610396743,
0.3906245828,
-0.0060541974,
0.9281614423,
1.1557605267,
-0.0785327628,
1.2015372515,
-0.9142584801,
0.0399087705,
0.8668951988,
-0.1846645623,
0.8373083472,
0.3543658555,
-0.1313521415,
0.4803129435,
0.6349424124,
0.3219999671,
0.9397969842,
0.382273823,
-0.6290530562,
0.269411236,
-0.4718744457,
-0.441575408,
0.0785401538,
0.6535086632,
-0.7372767925,
-0.049689576,
-0.1441192925,
0.000174172,
0.2609426975,
0.0663312227,
0.9774341583,
-0.0182045214,
-0.7975040674,
0.5308756232,
0.1955868155,
0.6379787326,
-0.142000407,
-0.0711138397,
-0.7344703674,
-0.0360045843,
-0.0901783109,
-0.5579901934,
0.0567831025,
-0.1897751689,
-0.3544020057,
-0.1760778278,
0.7021191716,
-0.4484128654,
-0.2567939758,
0.0208757408,
0.3399085999,
0.1409971267,
-0.1251096874,
-0.2283063829,
-0.0584491454,
-0.4671066403,
0.0818043724,
0.4076629281,
0.3113431036,
-0.0243020728,
0.4710293114,
0.7937454581,
-0.026470717,
-0.0846393183,
0.2168564498,
0.6628357768,
-0.5811445117,
-0.4129853249,
-0.4906567931,
0.2643747032,
-0.126928553,
-0.3279871345,
0.1422830671,
0.8367418647,
0.6942923665,
-0.0754816234,
1.0899326801,
0.0018130895,
0.4680065215,
-0.3288201392,
0.8250439763,
-0.3207243979,
0.2372891605,
-0.1126747951,
-0.8779947162,
-0.1691373885,
0.2146677673,
0.0888876766,
-0.0533372797,
0.8639400601,
1.0089942217,
0.1430247277,
-0.4888528883,
0.0836475641,
-0.0912970081,
0.6316623688,
0.3235513866,
0.4994336069,
-0.6242206097,
0.5189629197,
-0.1958142668,
-0.053594254,
-0.3808255494,
-0.3080981672,
-0.3316192031,
-0.7285027504,
-0.2005551457,
-0.3478444815,
0.3647082746,
0.7833871245,
0.4591241479,
-0.7345322967,
0.0193607286,
-0.2598882616,
0.3774704039,
0.1120508239,
-0.2322071791,
0.4698521495,
-0.6018696427,
-0.8695855141,
0.4294474125,
0.3009547591,
0.1511002928,
-0.2466430664,
-0.3838233352,
-0.3744302392,
0.1986939013,
0.4712839723,
0.5694838166,
-0.6304543614,
-0.1886211485,
0.2416200042,
-0.6515951157,
0.3281292021,
0.6912539601,
-0.8070389032,
0.6304067969,
0.94887954,
0.9436669946,
0.3709109724,
0.4125494361,
0.6800048351,
-0.7461812496,
-0.1236105636,
0.34801355,
0.136781171,
0.4098156691,
-0.1523969024,
0.4664801061,
0.5298014283,
-0.3748370409,
-0.785559237,
0.1219543368,
-0.5650590658,
-0.2339808494,
1.0833019018,
-0.1636128873,
-0.1645363271,
-0.1615884304,
-0.0721464008,
0.0276741851,
-0.4963180423,
0.9917370677,
0.5129303336,
0.1880504191,
-0.1618768871,
-0.1707217842,
0.6834430099,
0.2764674425,
-0.9351503253,
-0.1253268421,
0.4203091562,
-0.031319052,
0.5093662143,
0.9914937019,
-0.4326376617,
0.3292562962,
-0.1030313149,
0.0915739164,
0.2129332125,
-0.6093815565,
-0.2393195778,
0.1958212852,
0.5170922875,
-0.3943379819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08592v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08592v2
|
AART: AI-Assisted Red-Teaming with Diverse Data Generation for New LLM-powered Applications
| 2023-11-14T23:28:23 | 2023-11-29T23:18:16 |
Bhaktipriya Radharapu, Kevin Robinson, Lora Aroyo, Preethi Lahoti
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Adversarial testing of large language models (LLMs) is crucial for their safe
and responsible deployment. We introduce a novel approach for automated
generation of adversarial evaluation datasets to test the safety of LLM
generations on new downstream applications. We call it AI-assisted Red-Teaming
(AART) - an automated alternative to current manual red-teaming efforts. AART
offers a data generation and augmentation pipeline of reusable and customizable
recipes that reduce human effort significantly and enable integration of
adversarial testing earlier in new product development. AART generates
evaluation datasets with high diversity of content characteristics critical for
effective adversarial testing (e.g. sensitive and harmful concepts, specific to
a wide range of cultural and geographic regions and application scenarios). The
data generation is steered by AI-assisted recipes to define, scope and
prioritize diversity within the application context. This feeds into a
structured LLM-generation process that scales up evaluation priorities.
Compared to some state-of-the-art tools, AART shows promising results in terms
of concept coverage and data quality.
|
[
-0.5945258141,
-1.112823844,
-0.1329200715,
0.1390565485,
0.1140458733,
0.4285192192,
-0.188575536,
-0.3365852237,
-0.0290901661,
0.4227662385,
-0.5452064276,
-0.5165328979,
-0.5187622309,
0.1225008368,
-0.6764344573,
1.1761044264,
-0.1379390955,
-0.1332742125,
0.0458492264,
-0.1405145675,
-0.5343521237,
-0.5070657134,
-0.8404212594,
-0.1993851364,
0.3602079451,
0.5490395427,
1.1253266335,
0.6813997626,
0.7890171409,
0.3764831424,
0.1120779067,
0.3899460733,
-0.3719525933,
0.5042415857,
-0.0301836058,
-0.2317942083,
-0.5018179417,
0.1477720737,
0.2994399965,
0.3902986646,
-0.0911316723,
0.1812096238,
-0.0960744843,
0.7234229445,
-0.8438219428,
-0.2025559098,
-1.0211933851,
0.0038780854,
0.0292758066,
-0.2135632038,
-0.3350980878,
-0.4971952736,
-0.0675503612,
-0.6010937095,
0.2566435635,
0.1609129161,
0.5754553676,
0.4803526103,
-0.7078530192,
-0.195684582,
-0.7564486265,
0.7753210068,
-0.3500952423,
0.04740775,
0.1804296523,
0.7173336148,
-0.3709721267,
-0.6456814408,
-0.5605053902,
-0.4176331162,
0.0998186618,
0.1075583398,
-0.329158932,
-0.0543013588,
-0.1989770383,
0.2971266508,
-0.8746773601,
0.0512929112,
-0.3225454092,
-0.0152835622,
1.0975117683,
0.1943072081,
0.5619957447,
0.3056854904,
-0.3739004731,
-0.3498067558,
-0.7540341616,
-0.5437623262,
0.3501042426,
0.5525542498,
-0.0275864191,
0.6766774058,
-0.2148292512,
0.4724854529,
-0.126256302,
0.3544807434,
0.2948300242,
-0.6922891736,
-0.2895132005,
0.1083819792,
0.8515071273,
0.2601736188,
0.3155515194,
-0.0110041155,
-0.3039414585,
0.3378317356,
0.6171540618,
-0.4237768948,
-0.6156725883,
0.0848496705,
-0.1069421023,
-0.6932943463,
-0.1553363204,
-0.6559255123,
-0.5047311187,
-0.063812919,
0.3060660958,
-0.5311338902,
-0.194829762,
-0.1275274158,
-0.2805247307,
0.1806446016,
0.1496808827,
-0.8017716408,
0.2923122048,
0.6008128524,
0.559391737,
-0.5217561126,
-0.6090620756,
-0.7008818388,
0.0888136923,
-0.3234659731,
0.6075520515,
-0.2528995275,
-0.5118393898,
-0.2432684153,
-0.2396510541,
0.0168827642,
-0.6287227869,
0.2036768943,
-0.6459074616,
0.0825833231,
0.052651193,
-0.2391239852,
-0.0693553984,
0.5450040102,
-0.5306699276,
0.7499446273,
0.0886776522,
-0.6028459072,
0.5368928313,
-0.9425415993,
-0.8600976467,
0.3154542148,
-0.3000676632,
-0.6365498304,
-0.4823524058,
0.3838204741,
0.1218580976,
-0.2605025768,
-0.1832441539,
-0.3004069924,
-0.3355676532,
0.0536579937,
-0.649938643,
1.0169184208,
0.3005185127,
-0.6978492141,
0.3221644759,
-0.5021042824,
0.2660262585,
0.3200731874,
-0.2965945899,
-0.2750239372,
-0.1746834964,
0.1673111469,
-0.1596558392,
0.110488601,
-0.3129496276,
0.0633536428,
-0.2195705175,
0.1769576967,
0.8452479839,
0.0909968764,
0.3702546954,
-0.2944709659,
0.9992120862,
-0.2963307202,
0.459017694,
0.0600954331,
-0.4636220038,
-0.8476524353,
-0.2275680751,
0.2883325517,
0.8883016706,
-0.7963445783,
0.7561689615,
-0.1820194423,
-0.5815526843,
-0.4557321668,
0.2670665979,
0.4030159712,
0.1987438053,
0.2495495081,
-0.1237341091,
-0.7174229026,
-1.0069128275,
0.1821966618,
-0.3767632246,
0.1029542163,
0.3019158542,
0.6401208639,
-0.4291385412,
0.821272552,
-0.3850608766,
-0.1956144124,
-0.55519557,
0.216721043,
-0.3822290003,
0.3532061279,
0.4590166807,
-1.0325298309,
-0.6368520856,
0.2389993966,
-0.6356295347,
0.0054560285,
-0.0972458348,
-0.3373703063,
0.2571236193,
0.3813621104,
-0.2571040392,
0.1103822291,
0.7646378875,
-0.4459250271,
0.5272001624,
-0.0361470133,
0.3706042767,
-0.8188834786,
0.1007614732,
-0.3768546581,
-0.05693762,
-0.4042718709,
0.4071859419,
-0.0749144927,
-0.1342040151,
-0.6903557181,
0.4594986439,
-0.3717425168,
-0.0166214891,
-0.270273,
-0.0743452832,
0.1422369182,
-0.0037881075,
-0.3548488617,
1.2473055124,
0.2979097664,
-0.5932853222,
0.6529068947,
0.3760690093,
-0.0430285446,
0.1792747229,
-0.6151960492,
0.0537669249,
0.3346612751,
0.1525262147,
-0.7424561977,
-0.0137859341,
0.2089910954,
-0.549721837,
0.0721000805,
-0.0477217324,
-0.5338570476,
-0.1905302554,
-0.2471127659,
0.4932172,
0.6544621587,
-0.6134421229,
0.3754406273,
0.5806792974,
-0.2646487355,
-0.5395598412,
-0.8468748331,
0.3242732584,
-0.4662735164,
-0.8217678666,
0.1071125716,
-0.0434483401,
-0.4826426804,
0.082450591,
0.4584162533,
-0.2225927413,
0.5311476588,
0.1886090934,
0.320949018,
-0.1929730624,
-0.1113678887,
-0.0751165822,
-0.0526076034,
-0.0560340211,
0.0066603138,
0.3117230833,
-0.3198696375,
-0.4935256243,
0.0583969466,
0.5688765645,
0.4682423174,
-0.3869430125,
0.5022036433,
0.7183390856,
-0.0311669055,
-0.4886296093,
-0.1555588096,
-0.0685011595,
-0.5735931396,
0.4171528816,
0.0402945206,
-0.6686487198,
0.2184260786,
0.2476819903,
0.3881301582,
0.3528530002,
0.6857147217,
0.02395913,
1.0737739801,
0.467487365,
-0.1043589339,
0.3356615007,
-0.2774406075,
0.1121816039,
-0.4082009494,
0.2481697947,
-0.0576503687,
-0.3910481334,
-0.4083186686,
-0.2138334066,
0.6825373173,
-0.3220240772,
-0.600277245,
0.0051819691,
-0.6979838014,
0.6633028388,
0.7210083008,
-0.1209182739,
0.352499187,
-0.1639088839,
0.1819554269,
0.2687381506,
-0.5973821878,
-0.3513349891,
1.4325697422,
0.2144267857,
0.6054062843,
0.1799544245,
0.6788228154,
0.7020869255,
0.4976621568,
-0.7234014869,
0.5737934709,
-0.3936517537,
-0.6476112604,
-0.4043650031,
-0.4150589108,
-0.9718565941,
0.136442557,
-0.242022559,
0.0783469975,
-0.3196940422,
0.2845644355,
-0.5021671653,
0.1613514274,
-0.959877491,
0.7499910593,
-0.5979722142,
-0.0645218492,
-0.0920625255,
-0.493378669,
0.7057625651,
-0.1471442282,
-0.0578071699,
0.1348515898,
0.0937930122,
0.492366612,
-0.3636724055,
0.587340951,
-0.079577066,
0.0713838115,
0.3037014902,
0.1651244015,
0.5898656249,
-0.0739426836,
-0.2615588307,
-0.0556171201,
-0.668402791,
-0.0900817961,
-0.5938154459,
0.6009708643,
-0.6644831896,
-0.5069980025,
-0.4320083559,
-0.7858694196,
-0.1396746337,
0.2401510626,
0.0939790606,
-0.1563731283,
-0.3724466264,
0.1548127383,
0.4459770918,
-0.3776012659,
-0.0017944139,
0.4958253503,
0.0960551277,
-0.5288363695,
0.9585214257,
-0.2750644982,
0.434590131,
0.0388807654,
-0.0951088816,
-0.117361851,
-0.9829986095,
-0.6339470744,
-0.3258997202,
-0.5215373635,
-0.2247845978,
-0.3609885275,
-0.3691050112,
-0.297626704,
-0.3766655624,
-0.6432185173,
-0.4462292492,
0.0210256986,
-0.0808361545,
0.6399275661,
0.62691921,
-0.0769812986,
0.24251692,
-0.6507897377,
0.3392139971,
0.3389818668,
-0.0551210903,
-0.2233125269,
-0.111631602,
-0.3360025287,
0.1531479806,
-0.6170346737,
-0.3178219199,
0.4752911031,
0.2214458436,
0.51666224,
-0.0892044231,
0.2436134815,
0.4354536235,
-0.4852081835,
0.9098445177,
-0.0613898151,
-0.5655594468,
0.7420499325,
-0.4547034502,
0.1483322233,
0.8031761646,
-0.0387177914,
-0.2176274359,
-0.6958909631,
-0.5167534947,
-1.2665880919,
0.2446750104,
0.5154364109,
-0.1699390709,
0.0448943302,
0.0120589165,
0.0750114992,
0.062833339,
-0.3017701507,
-0.5042850375,
-0.1961656958,
-0.2718517184,
-0.1926965863,
0.3614220917,
-0.5333023667,
0.1438634992,
0.7616681457,
-0.0127817281,
-0.0198357105,
-0.0589214489,
-0.035494037,
-0.0192697775,
0.2448075563,
0.3057361841,
0.2919272184,
-0.1468645185,
0.1084142104,
0.2673573196,
-0.6287641525,
0.3947352767,
0.3638009727,
-0.3327215612,
-0.2185195386,
0.3738504052,
0.4449982047,
-0.4439491928,
-0.896538496,
0.3558126092,
-0.4751492143,
-0.3251274228,
-0.5443446636,
0.4882084131,
-0.3091890514,
0.2918336391,
0.3701283932,
0.0877022147,
0.2178252637,
-0.4157986045,
0.7597374916,
0.7199021578,
0.110912703,
0.2452579141,
0.6509712934,
0.5649905801,
-0.0765321851,
0.7637146115,
-0.4941267073,
-0.5012921691,
0.9287671447,
0.2609704733,
1.0553760529,
-0.2601317465,
0.152304247,
-0.010104591,
0.4363056123,
0.2268165052,
0.0535194017,
0.2941204906,
-0.775239706,
-0.1457811594,
-0.3405431211,
-0.6754960418,
0.2559062541,
-0.4851736128,
0.2283889204,
-0.4413666725,
-0.0033443295,
-0.2187322825,
-0.0708460733,
-0.3673619926,
0.3134767413,
0.1732878536,
0.708871603,
-0.9040924311,
0.6578453779,
0.7093681097,
-0.2195720822,
-0.5340566635,
0.0371690914,
0.2944760323,
-1.0309966803,
0.7272849679,
-0.2039506137,
-0.1326086819,
-0.116512768,
-0.0255364124,
-0.6865362525,
1.2392166853,
0.3888493478,
-0.2248738855,
0.1761982292,
0.1721117795,
0.4332378209,
-0.3397699893,
0.325004369,
0.5618035197,
0.4728579521,
0.1088861376,
-0.7663396001,
0.0578390174,
-0.5847175121,
-0.155542925,
0.2110359967,
-0.6123677492,
0.6485375762,
-0.2880656123,
-0.2105561495,
-0.181818679,
0.3866088092,
0.6964237094,
0.0573367961,
0.8183553219,
0.3399177194,
0.549749434,
0.1676174104,
1.1351008415,
-0.3223398328,
-0.1004261151,
1.292462945,
-0.3310161829,
0.8308974504,
0.2923860252,
-0.0689376816,
0.1254422814,
0.5724622011,
-0.299472928,
0.5441757441,
0.36179021,
-0.2975589335,
-0.0551522784,
-0.1119794399,
-0.4516555369,
0.4782556891,
0.1343396753,
-0.4199530482,
-0.1281102151,
-0.1577729136,
-0.1730080843,
-0.0332684368,
0.0155752152,
0.6341831684,
-0.1823332906,
-0.6261187792,
0.9217152596,
-0.1353205442,
0.7710636854,
-0.7102120519,
-0.0437628329,
-0.1957816482,
0.3591890633,
-0.0423237123,
-0.8092751503,
0.5803743601,
0.1887298226,
-0.0598607287,
-0.2731387913,
0.490013659,
-0.3588992357,
-0.5894803405,
0.3275976479,
0.341375798,
-0.1191831082,
0.0016335372,
-0.8378263116,
0.1784916073,
0.0905156136,
-0.3667501509,
0.3200561106,
0.2080192119,
0.0748833269,
0.8892487288,
0.6527733207,
0.3469413519,
0.1768165082,
0.0846003219,
0.8567395806,
-0.4193324745,
-0.4609796405,
-0.8022431731,
0.564384222,
0.1099643111,
-0.3032073081,
0.8580909371,
0.6535140872,
0.6964462399,
0.2423723042,
1.3903259039,
0.0195365511,
0.2863303721,
-0.3115505576,
1.0341910124,
-0.5528879166,
0.4289896786,
-0.0350062288,
-0.4873835742,
-0.4060464799,
0.398270905,
0.0238358062,
0.1008809656,
0.4429482818,
0.7928860188,
-0.1752818823,
0.0784153119,
0.028607389,
0.1943129897,
0.7357065082,
0.7200564146,
0.8794910312,
-0.5361388922,
0.9752581716,
-0.1981408596,
-0.4021891057,
0.0433961563,
-0.6529411674,
-0.6278208494,
-0.1889545918,
-0.3592660129,
-0.1293359697,
0.5010582805,
0.7828752995,
0.6077655554,
-0.816134274,
-0.0862750858,
-0.5197312236,
-0.0706072971,
-0.1943279505,
-0.2648356557,
0.2004031837,
-0.3050893247,
-0.6705454588,
0.7737355232,
-0.0248843972,
0.2927753627,
-0.5326741338,
-0.2614171803,
-0.0108651249,
-0.35117504,
0.356472075,
0.1839431524,
-0.3182845712,
-0.1281727701,
-0.1937631518,
0.0941556618,
-0.2160178721,
0.4835402668,
-0.6168297529,
0.3077546954,
0.2517257333,
0.9615662694,
-0.0985017344,
0.149061963,
1.2657928467,
-0.7425405383,
0.0688744336,
0.5765689611,
0.0826968551,
0.3451196849,
-0.5479049683,
0.6876012087,
-0.1419043988,
-0.6736725569,
-0.9704811573,
0.3259759247,
-0.654940784,
-0.1404056549,
1.3792182207,
-0.0864875764,
0.1219305098,
-0.2781522274,
-0.0471711718,
0.2328621149,
-0.4294239283,
0.9191870093,
0.2287305593,
-0.2777114213,
0.0815763175,
-0.4359882474,
0.4910555482,
0.5506187081,
-1.0519783497,
0.3641802371,
0.3316141069,
0.095720306,
-0.0638778731,
0.3917235136,
-0.0254648607,
0.4421457648,
0.172741279,
0.0805391148,
-0.3271804154,
-0.3196553886,
-0.1992888749,
0.1445116401,
0.1004334539,
-0.5811343789
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.